{"paper_uuid":"08383b0a-1167-4efb-9b89-dc8a71afd5ff","paper_title":"邊界的幻覺構件動力學","paper_title_en":"The Dynamics of Boundary Illusory Constructs","author":"黃正宇 / Cheng Yu Huang","contact":"mthree.tw@gmail.com","concepts_md":"---\nuuid: 08383b0a-1167-4efb-9b89-dc8a71afd5ff\nlast-modified: 2026-11-05T17:01:28\n---\n\n\n## public 幻覺構件 / Illusory Construct\n\n- 定義:幻覺構件是這樣的構件:它的對象不由物理世界給出,卻被用來描述或組織[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)。例如[我們](concepts.md#c04),「丈夫」這類身分,以及[二階能力](concepts.md#c02)。它有兩種出現方式:一、研究者用它描述複雜的一階[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28),把大量[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)歸成少數[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18);二、它以名稱、[宣誓](concepts.md#c06)、寫進[信號容器](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c26)的分類等形式出現在[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)中;這筆[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)若[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)他人,便參與他人的[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06)。幻覺構件不是[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18):[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)是[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)的動作,在[歷史](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13)中留下[寫入](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c29);幻覺構件是[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)的內容,或描述與[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)中所用的構件。稱某構件為幻覺構件,不主張它的對象存在,也不否認。\n- Definition: An illusory construct is a construct whose object is not given by the physical world, yet which is used to describe or organize [outputs](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28). Examples are [we](concepts.md#c04), identities such as \"husband\", and [second-order capacity](concepts.md#c02). It appears in two ways: first, a researcher uses it to describe complex first-order outputs, sorting many outputs into a few [distinctions](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18); second, it appears in outputs as a name, an [avowal](concepts.md#c06), or a classification written into a [signal container](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c26); if such an [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) [arrives](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at others, it takes part in their [weights](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06). An illusory construct is not a distinction: a distinction is an act of a [wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16) that leaves a [writing](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c29) in [history](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13); an illusory construct is the content of a distinction, or a construct used in descriptions and outputs. Calling a construct an illusory construct neither asserts nor denies that its object exists.\n\n\n## public 二階能力 / Second-Order Capacity\n\n- 定義:二階能力是同時具有[二階分別](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c01)與[看法歸屬](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c02)。它是兩者的合稱,不主張兩者是同一種能力;兩者的定義互不以對方為條件。具有二階能力,指能作這兩種[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18),不指每一次[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)都作了。二階能力是[幻覺構件](concepts.md#c01):它可用來簡稱複雜的一階[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)。\n- Definition: Second-order capacity is having both [second-order distinction](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c01) and [view attribution](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c02). It is a joint name for the two and does not assert that they are one capacity; neither definition takes the other as a condition. To have second-order capacity means being able to make these two kinds of [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18), not that it makes them every time. Second-order capacity is an [illusory construct](concepts.md#c01): it can serve as shorthand for complex first-order [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28).\n\n\n## public 社會人 / Social Person\n\n- 定義:社會人是具有[二階能力](concepts.md#c02)的生物人。社會人是[幻覺構件](concepts.md#c01):稱某個生物人為社會人,是研究者以該生物人為對象的一次[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18),其材料可以包含[看法歸屬](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c02),依[配置假定](../paper_ae79e938_76e1_4bf9_b2ab_995c03e16c9e/concepts.md#c01)作出,對講明的階段成立。社會人指單一的生物人;由具有[二階分別](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c01)與[看法歸屬](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c02)的[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19)及其間的[耦合](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c36)構成的集合,是[二階網路](../paper_ae79e938_76e1_4bf9_b2ab_995c03e16c9e/concepts.md#c04),不是社會人。\n- Definition: A social person is a biological human with [second-order capacity](concepts.md#c02). A social person is an [illusory construct](concepts.md#c01): calling a biological human a social person is a [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) the researcher makes with that biological human as object, whose material may include [view attribution](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c02), made under the [configuration assumption](../paper_ae79e938_76e1_4bf9_b2ab_995c03e16c9e/concepts.md#c01) and holding for the stated stage. A social person is a single biological human; the set formed by [selves](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19) with [second-order distinction](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c01) and [view attribution](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c02) and the [couplings](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c36) among them is a [second-order network](../paper_ae79e938_76e1_4bf9_b2ab_995c03e16c9e/concepts.md#c04), not a social person.\n\n\n## public 我們 / We\n\n- 定義:我們是一個[社會人](concepts.md#c03)運用的[幻覺構件](concepts.md#c01):在某個維度上,把自己和被它歸為[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19)的其他[呈現](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c04),當成同一邊的一個單位,用來組織它的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)。劃出我們,是一次用到這個構件的[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18);我們的作用,只經由運用它的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28);一個從未在[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)中運用的我們,和沒有劃出,在[記錄](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c06)中沒有差別。我們依對象定義:對象包含自己。它是單方面的,屬於運用它的[社會人](concepts.md#c03),不要求被劃進去的[呈現](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c04)也這樣劃。維度由劃的人劃出;同一對[呈現](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c04)可以在一個維度上被劃為我們,在另一個維度上不是。歸為[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19)可以是對一個類的[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18),不要求對類中每個成員都作過[看法歸屬](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c02),要求的是有[看法歸屬](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c02)的能力,也不保證被歸為[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19)的對象確實是一個[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19)。劃出我們,不自動把其餘[呈現](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c04)劃為[你們](concepts.md#c05)。\n- Definition: We is an [illusory construct](concepts.md#c01) used by a [social person](concepts.md#c03): with which the social person, along some dimension, treats itself and other [presentations](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c04) it counts as a [self](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19) as one unit on the same side, to organize its [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28). Drawing we is a [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) that uses this construct; we has effect only through output that uses it; a we never used in output does not differ, in the [record](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c06), from one never drawn. We is defined by its object: the object includes the one who draws it. It is one-sided and belongs to the social person who uses it; it does not require those drawn in to draw it the same way. The dimension is drawn by the one who draws; the same pair of presentations can be drawn as we along one dimension and not along another. Counting others as selves can be a distinction about a class, without a [view attribution](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c02) for each member, though it requires the capacity for view attribution, and does not guarantee that what is counted as a self really is one. Drawing we does not automatically draw the remaining presentations as [plural you](concepts.md#c05).\n\n\n## public 你們 / Plural You\n\n- 定義:你們是一個[社會人](concepts.md#c03)運用的[幻覺構件](concepts.md#c01):在某個維度上,把不含自己、被它歸為[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19)的其他[呈現](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c04),當成一個單位,用來組織它的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)。劃出你們,是一次用到這個構件的[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18);你們的作用只經由運用它的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)。你們依對象定義:對象不含自己;與[我們](concepts.md#c04)的差別在對象,不在內容。它是單方面的,屬於運用它的[社會人](concepts.md#c03),不要求被劃進去的[呈現](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c04)也這樣劃,也不要求它們劃出任何[我們](concepts.md#c04)。維度由劃的人劃出;歸為[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19)可以是對一個類的[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18),不要求對類中每個成員都作過[看法歸屬](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c02),要求的是有[看法歸屬](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c02)的能力,也不保證對象確實是一個[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19)。\n- Definition: Plural you is an [illusory construct](concepts.md#c01) used by a [social person](concepts.md#c03): with which the social person, along some dimension, treats other [presentations](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c04) it counts as [selves](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19), excluding itself, as one unit, to organize its [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28). Drawing plural you is a [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) that uses this construct; plural you has effect only through output that uses it. Plural you is defined by its object: the object excludes the one who draws it; it differs from [we](concepts.md#c04) in object, not in content. It is one-sided and belongs to the social person who uses it; it does not require those drawn in to draw it the same way, nor that they draw any we. The dimension is drawn by the one who draws; counting others as selves can be a distinction about a class, without a [view attribution](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c02) for each member, though it requires the capacity for view attribution, and does not guarantee that the object really is a self.\n\n\n## public 宣誓 / Avowal\n\n- 定義:宣誓是一個[社會人](concepts.md#c03)的一筆[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28),以接收者對宣誓者自己的[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)為對象:在某個維度上,要接收者把宣誓者劃進某一類。宣誓只是要求,不是宣誓者自己[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)的讀數:宣誓者有沒有這樣劃、劃得多深,不在[記錄](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c06)中;說謊也是宣誓。以對物的[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)為對象的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)不是宣誓;「這是我們的」若以對某物的[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)為對象,不因字面上有「我們」就成為宣誓。把一筆[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)歸為宣誓,是研究者的[看法歸屬](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c02)。\n- Definition: An avowal is an [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) of a [social person](concepts.md#c03) whose object is the receiver's [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) of the avower: along some dimension, it asks the receiver to place the avower in some class. An avowal is only a request, not a reading of the avower's own distinction: whether and how deeply the avower draws it is not in the [record](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c06); a lie is also an avowal. An output whose object is a distinction about a thing is not an avowal; \"this is ours\", if its object is a distinction about some thing, does not become an avowal merely because its wording contains \"our\". Classifying an output as an avowal is a researcher's [view attribution](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c02).\n\n\n## public 對物的歸屬分別 / Belonging Distinction of Things\n\n- 定義:對物的歸屬分別是一個[社會人](concepts.md#c03)作出的一次[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18):在某個維度上,以已經[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)它的某物之[呈現](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c04)為材料,把該物劃為「我的」「你的」「我們的」或「你們的」。這四種說法是這次[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)所用的[幻覺構件](concepts.md#c01),作用只經由運用它們的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28),不是物本身具有的權利關係;它參照哪個[我們](concepts.md#c04)或[你們](concepts.md#c05),屬於[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)的內容。被劃為「我們的」的物,不因此成為另一個[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19)。對物的歸屬分別不推出誰能使用、處置或分配該物,也不要求先劃出[我們](concepts.md#c04)才作出;同一件物可以在不同維度上被同一[社會人](concepts.md#c03)作出不同[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)。\n- Definition: A belonging distinction of things is a [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) made by a [social person](concepts.md#c03): along some dimension, taking the [presentation](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c04) of a thing that has [arrived](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at it as material, it classes the thing as \"mine\", \"yours\", \"ours\", or \"yours (plural)\". These four are [illusory constructs](concepts.md#c01) this distinction uses, having effect only through [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) that uses them, not rights the thing itself carries; which [we](concepts.md#c04) or [plural you](concepts.md#c05) it refers to belongs to the content of the distinction. A thing classed as \"ours\" does not thereby become another [self](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19). A belonging distinction of things does not imply who may use, dispose of, or allocate the thing, and does not require that a we be drawn first; the same social person can make different distinctions about the same thing along different dimensions.\n\n\n## public 分別邊際 / Distinction Margin\n\n- 定義:分別邊際是一個[社會人](concepts.md#c03)在某個維度上作出[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18),使對象在它的[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)中落在不同一邊。把某些[呈現](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c04)劃為[我們](concepts.md#c04)、另一些劃為[你們](concepts.md#c05),或把物劃為「我們的」「你們的」([對物的歸屬分別](concepts.md#c07)),都是分別邊際的例子。分別邊際只屬於作出它的[社會人](concepts.md#c03),不同[社會人](concepts.md#c03)可以對同一批人、同一件物劃出不同的邊際;它不要求兩邊都有名稱。說[經濟模式](../paper_d244789a_9261_4a0d_a98a_feb8db56b511/concepts.md#c09)出現分別邊際,指[社會人](concepts.md#c03)得以在該模式已[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)它的材料上另作[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18),不是[經濟模式](../paper_d244789a_9261_4a0d_a98a_feb8db56b511/concepts.md#c09)取得一個共有的內部[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)。分別邊際只合稱既有的[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18),它對他人與物的作用經由[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)與[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)。\n- Definition: A distinction margin is a [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) a [social person](concepts.md#c03) makes along some dimension, so that objects fall on different sides within its distinction. Drawing some [presentations](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c04) as [we](concepts.md#c04) and others as [plural you](concepts.md#c05), or classing things as \"ours\" or \"yours (plural)\" ([belonging distinction of things](concepts.md#c07)), are examples. A distinction margin belongs only to the social person who makes it; different social persons can draw different margins over the same people and things; it does not require both sides to have names. To say an [economic mode](../paper_d244789a_9261_4a0d_a98a_feb8db56b511/concepts.md#c09) shows a distinction margin means a social person is able to make a further distinction on material from the mode that has arrived at it, not that the mode acquires a shared internal distinction. A distinction margin only names existing distinctions jointly; its effect on others and on things goes through [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) and [arrival](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10).\n\n\n## public 內外差異 / Inside Outside Difference\n\n- 定義:內外差異是研究者在[記錄](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c06)中作出的一次[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18):同類的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28),在某組參與者之間,與在該組參與者和組外參與者之間,有所不同。哪些[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)算同類、哪些參與者算一組、在哪個維度上比較,由研究者在講明的[切法](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c23)下劃出;換一種[切法](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c23),內外差異可以不同。研究者劃的組,與任何[社會人](concepts.md#c03)劃的[我們](concepts.md#c04),範圍與維度不必一致。同類的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)以某些物為對象時與以其他物為對象時有所不同,也是內外差異。內外差異只描述[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)的不同,不是規則、權利或制度。\n- Definition: An inside outside difference is a [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) a researcher makes in the [record](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c06): outputs of the same kind differ between members of some group and between those members and participants outside it. Which [outputs](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) count as the same kind, which participants form a group, and along which dimension they are compared are drawn by the researcher under a stated [cut](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c23); under another cut the difference can differ. The researcher's group need not match, in range or dimension, any [we](concepts.md#c04) drawn by any [social person](concepts.md#c03). Outputs of the same kind that differ when directed at some things rather than others also form an inside outside difference. It only describes differences in output; it is not a rule, a right, or an institution.\n\n\n## public 宣稱界線 / Claimed Boundary\n\n- 定義:宣稱界線是研究者在[記錄](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c06)中作出的一次[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18):依一筆以分類為內容的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28),劃出它所提出的界線。這類[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)包括[宣誓](concepts.md#c06)、對人或對物的分類聲明,以及寫進[信號容器](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c26)的分類,例如法條、證書、規章。一筆[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)提出了哪條界線,由研究者依該[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)劃出,並在講明的[切法](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c23)下判定;它不是[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)者[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)的讀數。宣稱界線與[內外差異](concepts.md#c09)都依[記錄](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c06)中的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)劃出,不是被研究的[社會人](concepts.md#c03)的[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)。\n- Definition: A claimed boundary is a [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) a researcher makes in the [record](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c06): from an [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) whose content is a classification, it draws the boundary that output proposes. Such outputs include [avowals](concepts.md#c06), classificatory statements about people or things, and classifications written into a [signal container](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c26), such as statutes, certificates, and regulations. Which boundary an output proposes is drawn by the researcher from that output and judged under a stated [cut](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c23); it is not a reading of the outputter's distinction. Claimed boundaries and [inside outside differences](concepts.md#c09) are both drawn from [outputs](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) in the [record](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c06), and are not [distinctions](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) of the [social persons](concepts.md#c03) studied.\n\n\n## public 界線的移動 / Boundary Shift\n\n- 定義:界線的移動是研究者在[記錄](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c06)中作出的一次[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18):比較兩個[檢查窗口](../paper_d244789a_9261_4a0d_a98a_feb8db56b511/concepts.md#c03),把[內外差異](concepts.md#c09)或[宣稱界線](concepts.md#c10)在兩者之間的不同,記為界線的移動。移動在[記錄](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c06)中的結構可以依[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)描述,例如兩邊有差別的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)互相強化;多人有差別的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)由相容轉為不相容,[內外差異](concepts.md#c09)變淡;某個參與者所受的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28),由一邊的樣子轉為另一邊的樣子;[宣稱界線](concepts.md#c10)與[內外差異](concepts.md#c09)之間的距離拉長或縮短。在講明的維度上,這些結構可以用[趨同](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c37)、[趨異](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c38)、[持平](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c52)、[太極](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c39)與[合流](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c41)描述。同一段[記錄](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c06)換一種[切法](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c23),可以記為移動,也可以記為不動。\n- Definition: A boundary shift is a [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) a researcher makes in the [record](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c06): comparing two [check windows](../paper_d244789a_9261_4a0d_a98a_feb8db56b511/concepts.md#c03), it records the difference in an [inside outside difference](concepts.md#c09) or a [claimed boundary](concepts.md#c10) between them as a boundary shift. The structure of a shift in the record can be described by [outputs](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28), for example: differential outputs on the two sides reinforce each other; differential outputs of many participants turn from compatible to incompatible, and the inside outside difference fades; the outputs a participant receives change from those of one side to those of the other; the distance between a claimed boundary and an inside outside difference lengthens or shortens. Along a stated dimension, these structures can be described as [convergence](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c37), [divergence](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c38), [stasis](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c52), [taiji](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c39), and [merging](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c41). Under another [cut](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c23), the same stretch of record can be recorded as a shift or as no shift.\n- 裁決:2026-11-05 作者裁決登記為 public。\n\n## 不登記\n\n- 二階改造:2026-11-05 作者裁決不登記;它是社會人對既有模式的輸出另作分別、再經由輸出進入迴路這段過程的稱呼,沒有帶進新的東西。\n- 關於物的輸出:2026-11-05 作者裁決不登記;它只是以對物的分別為對象的輸出的描述。\n- 此物:2026-11-05 只在單一結論或案例內代稱一件物,屬區域變數。\n- 他們:2026-11-05 作者裁決不登記;論文宣告為日常用語,指多個你們的合稱。\n- 物理世界:2026-11-05 作者裁決不登記;論文宣告為一般用語。\n- 衝突:2026-11-05 作者裁決不登記;論文宣告為日常用語,指兩次分別互不相容,不指上游的衝突。\n- 極化:2026-11-05 作者裁決不登記;只作標題與說明中的稱呼,未另給定義。\n- 深厚:2026-11-05 作者裁決不登記;只說明這個日常用詞在一處的用法。\n- 出現:2026-11-05 作者裁決不登記;論文宣告為日常用語,一處說明只限定它的用法。\n- 港口幫:2026-11-05 作者裁決不登記;只出現在案例的校準中,不承擔推導。\n- 經濟模式的延續:2026-11-06 作者裁決不登記;由上游的經濟模式與存續判準合成的描述,不另立概念。\n- 我的、你的、我們的、你們的:2026-11-07 作者裁決不登記;這四個是對物的歸屬分別的分類值,意義由對物的歸屬分別的定義給出,不另立概念;形式化記號約定已把它們宣告為一般用語。\n\n## 待決項\n\n無\n","formalization_md":"論文:《邊界的幻覺構件動力學》\nUUID:08383b0a-1167-4efb-9b89-dc8a71afd5ff\n\n## 記號約定\n\n來源:論文全文\n\n- 我的:一般用語,是 對物的歸屬分別 所用的 幻覺構件,不是概念 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.我\n- 你的:一般用語,是 對物的歸屬分別 所用的 幻覺構件\n- 我們的:一般用語,是 對物的歸屬分別 所用的 幻覺構件,不是概念 我們\n- 你們的:一般用語,是 對物的歸屬分別 所用的 幻覺構件,不是概念 你們\n- 物理世界:一般用語,論文宣告不另立為概念\n- 出現:一般用語\n- 同一:一般用語,指同一件物、同一個這類用法,不是 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.同一\n- 決定:一般用語,作動詞用,不是 fb0addca-42b6-4884-aa18-438c695747ab.決定\n- 衝突:一般用語,指兩次 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別 互不相容,不是 ae79e938-76e1-4bf9-b2ab-995c03e16c9e.衝突\n- 同一邊:一般用語,不是 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.邊\n- 一邊:一般用語,不是 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.邊\n- 兩邊:一般用語,不是 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.邊\n- 自我定義:一般用語,出自 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.我 的定義的說法,不是概念 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.我 本身\n- 推不出:一般用語,指從本篇所列的來源與 81952268-47b1-4d8c-9605-270c42646693.記錄 推不出唯一的結果,不主張在任何條件、任何材料之下都推不出;「不唯一推出」同此【正文:句3241679706、句6614811828】\n- 記錄中有:一般用語,依論文〇之三的記號約定,指研究者已登記的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出,或研究者依已登記的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 劃出的差異\n- 定不出結果:一般用語,依論文〇之三的記號約定,指不被 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.鎖死 時、在 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.應用假定 之下\n\n## 前置條件\n\n來源:論文第一節【正文:句9233402029】\n\n- 前提一:37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦 的一次 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別 與它的一筆 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出,在下一 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.時刻 之前 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 這個 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦 自己,參與它之後的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.權重。【正文:句9349737364、句6336011253】\n- 前提二:社會人 作出 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別 的那一刻,依 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.應用假定,假定它不被 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.鎖死。【正文:句0914174070】\n- 前提三:本篇記為:81952268-47b1-4d8c-9605-270c42646693.記錄 只登記 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 的物理改變,不登記 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別 的內容。【正文:句3880054410、句4697381754】\n- 前提四 [限定條件]:本篇的結論用到具體的生物人時,都在 ae79e938-76e1-4bf9-b2ab-995c03e16c9e.配置假定 之下成立。【正文:句4419009370、句6332399383】\n- 前提五 [限定條件]:依賴 幻覺構件 的結論,都在 幻覺構件 之下成立;宣稱界線、內外差異,以及兩者落差的登記,只依賴 81952268-47b1-4d8c-9605-270c42646693.記錄。【正文:句1481728794、句8993403467】\n- 前提六 [限定條件]:只具有 fb0addca-42b6-4884-aa18-438c695747ab.一階分別 的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.我,本篇記為沒有 我們,也沒有 你們。【正文:句5950301652、句3956670025、句8639140355】\n- 前提七 [限定條件]:本篇的對象是 社會人;不是 社會人 的生物人,不在本篇範圍,格局論文的結論對它們照樣成立;本篇不預設嬰兒、重度失智者在範圍內。【正文:句9108505308、句5454931771、句8677454786】\n- 前提八 [限定條件]:本篇不主張其中的機制只見於生物人;其他 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦 的群集可能有相應的 內外差異 與 宣稱界線,本篇不處理。【正文:句5253566148、句1202635728】\n- 附註:[作者裁決] 2026-11-06 本文件中的「推不出」「不唯一推出」,依記號約定,只指從本篇所列的來源與 81952268-47b1-4d8c-9605-270c42646693.記錄 推不出唯一的結果;「b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.不被保證」依其定義,只指框架不斷言它必然發生;兩者都不主張某項特定的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別、fb0addca-42b6-4884-aa18-438c695747ab.決定 或 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 在原則上不可預測,也不主張它不能固定重複。\n- 附註:[作者裁決] 2026-11-10 依論文〇之三的記號約定:本文件說 81952268-47b1-4d8c-9605-270c42646693.記錄 中有某筆 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出,都指研究者已登記者;說 81952268-47b1-4d8c-9605-270c42646693.記錄 中有某項差異,都指研究者依已登記的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出、在講明的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.切法 下劃出者;說一次 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別 成為 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.歷史 的一部分,指它留下的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.寫入 成為 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.歷史 的一部分;說 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.權重 定不出結果,都指不被 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.鎖死 時,在 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.應用假定 之下。【正文:句9992762416】\n\n## 定位與方法\n\n來源:論文第〇節【正文:句3551098033】\n\n- 附註:格局論文推出的結論,在本篇照樣成立;本篇只增加,不改動。【正文:句3030158992】\n- 附註:本篇不預測誰會把誰劃進 我們、誰會把哪件物劃為「我們的」,也不預測 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別 或 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 往哪個方向改變;本篇所說的「我們的」,不是所有權、使用權、處置權或排除他人的規則。【正文:句2989973183、句3750058077】\n- 步驟〇之一:屬於( 二階能力 , 幻覺構件 )(從 幻覺構件 的定義 + 二階能力 的定義 推出)【正文:句6910024393、句0579508712】\n- 步驟〇之二:幻覺構件 不是 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別;幻覺構件 是對象不由物理世界給出的構件,是 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別 的內容,或研究者的描述與 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 中所用的構件;一次 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別 可以用到 幻覺構件,也可以不用。(從 幻覺構件 的定義 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別 的定義 推出)【正文:句6332603447、句3870188540】\n- 步驟〇之三:幻覺構件 以名稱、宣誓、寫進 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.信號容器 的分類等形式出現在 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 中;這筆 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 若 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 他人,便參與他人的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.權重,經由 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 可能使之後的 81952268-47b1-4d8c-9605-270c42646693.記錄 出現相應的樣子;以分類為內容時,這筆 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 若被登記進 81952268-47b1-4d8c-9605-270c42646693.記錄,便是研究者劃出 宣稱界線 的材料。(從 幻覺構件 的定義 + 宣稱界線 的定義 + b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 的定義 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 的定義 + 81952268-47b1-4d8c-9605-270c42646693.記錄 的定義 推出)【正文:句0629269088、句7141890529】\n- 附註:幻覺構件 不同於 fb0addca-42b6-4884-aa18-438c695747ab.幻覺;本篇不主張 幻覺構件 的對象存在,也不否認;幻覺構件 出現在 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 中時,可能參與之後的 81952268-47b1-4d8c-9605-270c42646693.記錄。【正文:句4567385863、句4388340186】\n- 附註:把大量 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 歸成少數 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別,是研究者的一次 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別;對其中 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 研究者的各筆 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 所作的,是 fb0addca-42b6-4884-aa18-438c695747ab.看法歸屬;都可能歸錯;研究者的描述出現在它的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 中時,其中的 幻覺構件 同樣可能 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 他人。【正文:句7139509106、句0702561792、句1398206174】\n- 附註:劃出 我們 是一次 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別,它用到的 我們 是 幻覺構件。【正文:句1720271924】\n\n## 第二節\n\n來源:論文第二節【正文:句5229659702】\n\n- 步驟二之一:從外部確認某個對象某一刻有沒有 fb0addca-42b6-4884-aa18-438c695747ab.二階分別,b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.不被保證;同一個生物人,可以在某段期間是 社會人,在另一段期間不是。(從 ae79e938-76e1-4bf9-b2ab-995c03e16c9e.配置假定 的定義 + 社會人 的定義 + b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.不被保證 的定義 推出)【正文:句6332399383、句9261341949】\n\n## 第三節\n\n來源:論文第三節【正文:句5990676167】\n\n- 步驟三之一:具有 二階能力,指同時具有 fb0addca-42b6-4884-aa18-438c695747ab.二階分別 與 fb0addca-42b6-4884-aa18-438c695747ab.看法歸屬;這是兩者的合稱,不主張兩者是同一種能力。(從 二階能力 的定義 推出)【正文:句3207994166、句2686073275】\n- 步驟三之二:fb0addca-42b6-4884-aa18-438c695747ab.二階分別 與 fb0addca-42b6-4884-aa18-438c695747ab.看法歸屬 的定義互不以對方為條件;具有 二階能力,指能作這兩種 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別,不指每一次 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別 都作了。(從 二階能力 的定義 + fb0addca-42b6-4884-aa18-438c695747ab.二階分別 的定義 + fb0addca-42b6-4884-aa18-438c695747ab.看法歸屬 的定義 推出)【正文:句2686073275、句8830582840、句0080913314】\n- 步驟三之三:屬於( 社會人 , 幻覺構件 );稱某生物人為 社會人,是研究者以該生物人為對象的一次 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別,其材料可以包含 fb0addca-42b6-4884-aa18-438c695747ab.看法歸屬,依 ae79e938-76e1-4bf9-b2ab-995c03e16c9e.配置假定。(從 社會人 的定義 + 步驟〇之一 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別 的定義 + fb0addca-42b6-4884-aa18-438c695747ab.看法歸屬 的定義 + ae79e938-76e1-4bf9-b2ab-995c03e16c9e.配置假定 的定義 推出)【正文:句1994315339、句0909647710、句9960465377】\n- 附註:社會人 指單一的生物人,不是 ae79e938-76e1-4bf9-b2ab-995c03e16c9e.二階網路。【正文:句3707383375、句9299951115】\n- 步驟三之三之一:社會人 是一個 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.我,也是一個 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦。(從 社會人 的定義 + 二階能力 的定義 + fb0addca-42b6-4884-aa18-438c695747ab.二階分別 的定義 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.我 的定義 推出)【正文:句6497773326】\n- 附註:[作者裁決] 2026-11-10 步驟三之三之一 依 社會人、二階能力 與 fb0addca-42b6-4884-aa18-438c695747ab.二階分別 的定義,社會人 是一個 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.我;依 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.我 的定義,它也是一個 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦;這不是由「能作」推出「已作」。\n- 步驟三之四:屬於( 我們 , 幻覺構件 );劃出 我們,是一次用到它的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別。(從 我們 的定義 推出)【正文:句6551216687、句8276072524】\n- 步驟三之四之一:我們 的作用,只經由運用它的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出;一個從未在 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 中運用的 我們,和沒有劃出,在 81952268-47b1-4d8c-9605-270c42646693.記錄 中沒有差別;劃出它的 社會人 自己,事後會不會再以它為對象作出 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別,b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.不被保證。(從 我們 的定義 + 前提三 + fb0addca-42b6-4884-aa18-438c695747ab.盲點牆 + b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.不被保證 的定義 推出)【正文:句8276072524、句0041713656】\n- 步驟三之五:我們 是單方面的,屬於運用它的 社會人,不要求被劃進去的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.呈現 也這樣劃;維度由劃的一方劃出。(從 我們 的定義 推出)【正文:句0800711924、句6114220151、句2209716565】\n- 步驟三之六:把對方歸為 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.我,不保證對方是一個 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.我。(從 我們 的定義 + fb0addca-42b6-4884-aa18-438c695747ab.看法歸屬 的定義 推出)【正文:句9528979072】\n- 步驟三之七:一個 社會人 在不被 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.鎖死 時,事先推不出自己下一個 fb0addca-42b6-4884-aa18-438c695747ab.決定 的結果;所以它關於某個 我們 的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出,是否重複出現,b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.不被保證。(從 步驟三之三之一 + 前提一 + 前提二 + fb0addca-42b6-4884-aa18-438c695747ab.決定 的定義 + b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 的定義 + fb0addca-42b6-4884-aa18-438c695747ab.未定牆 + b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.不被保證 的定義 推出)【正文:句9495577868】\n- 附註:[作者裁決] 2026-11-06 步驟三之七 的「b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.不被保證」依其定義,只表示框架不斷言它關於某個 我們 的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 必然重複;不主張這類 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 不能在各種可能結果中固定出現。\n- 附註:我們 有多強,是程度上的事,屬於 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.權重,本篇不形式化;37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別 的內容也不形式化。【正文:句6326658607、句3762382926】\n- 步驟三之八:劃出 我們,不蘊含把其餘 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.呈現 劃為 你們;把其餘 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.呈現 劃為 你們,是用到 你們 的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別,不由劃出 我們 的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別 推出。(從 我們 的定義 + 你們 的定義 推出)【正文:句3262535349】\n- 步驟三之九:屬於( 你們 , 幻覺構件 );劃出 你們 是一次用到它的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別;你們 與 我們 的差別在對象,不在內容;你們 也是單方面的,不要求被劃進去的也這樣劃,也不要求它們劃出任何 我們。(從 你們 的定義 推出)【正文:句5586282258、句5366283191、句8076111338、句0950369604】\n- 步驟三之十:屬於( 宣誓 , b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 );作出 宣誓 的一方有沒有這樣劃、劃得多深,不在 81952268-47b1-4d8c-9605-270c42646693.記錄 中;說謊也是 宣誓;把 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 研究者的一筆 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 歸為 宣誓,是研究者的 fb0addca-42b6-4884-aa18-438c695747ab.看法歸屬。(從 宣誓 的定義 + 前提三 + fb0addca-42b6-4884-aa18-438c695747ab.看法歸屬 的定義 推出)【正文:句2287315375、句0235708312、句4180981660】\n- 附註:以對物的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別 為對象的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出,例如說某件物是「我們的」,不是 宣誓。【正文:句6464129901】\n- 步驟三之十一:屬於( 對物的歸屬分別 , 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別 );它以已經 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 它的某物之 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.呈現 為材料;它所用的「我的」「你的」「我們的」「你們的」是 幻覺構件,作用只經由運用它們的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出;它不是物本身具有的權利關係。(從 對物的歸屬分別 的定義 + 幻覺構件 的定義 推出)【正文:句3190371898、句2048593356、句5523662718】\n- 步驟三之十二:把某件物劃為「我們的」,是以該物為對象的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別,與劃出 我們 的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別 依不同的定義界定對象;該物不因此成為另一個 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.我,也不因此進入一個共有主體。(從 對物的歸屬分別 的定義 + 我們 的定義 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.我 的定義 推出)【正文:句6288521159、句7572705535】\n- 步驟三之十三:對物的歸屬分別 不要求先劃出 我們,不要求另作 你們,也不要求四種分類全部出現;社會人 也可以先對物作出 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別,再以該物為維度劃出 我們;社會人 的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別 不受「我們的」字面上預設 我們 的次序約束;它不推出誰能使用、處置或分配該物,也不推出某人能要求他人照著劃。(從 對物的歸屬分別 的定義 + 我們 的定義 推出)【正文:句7244580292、句6747605339、句2528307506、句6067814379、句2504928750】\n- 步驟三之十三之一:同一件物可以在不同維度上被同一 社會人 作出不同 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別;各次 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別 是否一致,不被定義要求。(從 對物的歸屬分別 的定義 推出)【正文:句6570615835】\n- 步驟三之十四:屬於( 分別邊際 , 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別 );分別邊際 只屬於作出它的 社會人,不要求兩邊都有名稱;某個維度的分類也不要求窮盡所有對象;所謂 d244789a-9261-4a0d-a98a-feb8db56b511.經濟模式「出現 分別邊際」,是指 社會人 得以在該模式已 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 它的材料上另作 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別,不是說 d244789a-9261-4a0d-a98a-feb8db56b511.經濟模式 取得一個共有的內部 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別。(從 分別邊際 的定義 推出)【正文:句0451099908、句2836563971、句5825389623、句7346582241、句3448279958】\n- 附註:分別邊際 只合稱既有的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別,不另立讓 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別 直接改變他人或物的機制。【正文:句7915858836、句4070050190】\n- 步驟三之十五:屬於( 內外差異 , 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別 );它是研究者在 81952268-47b1-4d8c-9605-270c42646693.記錄 中所作,在講明的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.切法 下劃出,與 社會人 劃的 我們 範圍與維度不必一致。(從 內外差異 的定義 推出)【正文:句7878169181、句4499195286、句2646781486】\n- 步驟三之十六:分別邊際 在 社會人 的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.歷史 中,不在 81952268-47b1-4d8c-9605-270c42646693.記錄 中;內外差異 依 81952268-47b1-4d8c-9605-270c42646693.記錄 中的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 劃出,不是被研究的 社會人 的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別。(從 前提三 + 分別邊際 的定義 + 內外差異 的定義 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別 的定義 推出)【正文:句1527795856】\n- 附註:內外差異 只描述 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 的不同,不是規則、權利或制度。【正文:句3184893023】\n- 步驟三之十七:屬於( 宣稱界線 , 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別 );它依一筆以分類為內容的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 劃出,這類 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 包括 宣誓、對人或對物的分類聲明,以及寫進 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.信號容器 的分類;它不是作出該 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 一方的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別 的讀數。(從 宣稱界線 的定義 推出)【正文:句7374157610、句8704028874、句4900557559】\n- 步驟三之十八:寫進 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.信號容器 的分類,此後隨 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.信號容器 每一步都被 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.鎖死;37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦 要改寫它,是另一筆 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 它的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出。(從 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.信號容器 的定義 + b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 的定義 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 的定義 推出)【正文:句3848462136】\n\n## 第四節\n\n來源:論文第四節【正文:句3389934597】\n\n- 結論四之一:沒有一個不經 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別、現成在那裡等著被發現的 我們;這不否定 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別 之前已存在的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出、37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 與 d244789a-9261-4a0d-a98a-feb8db56b511.經濟模式;它們本身不等於某個 社會人 劃出的 我們。(從 我們 的定義 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別 的定義 推出)【正文:句6396783366、句7980015525、句1608193552】\n- 結論四之二:一個 社會人 劃出 我們 的材料,只有已經 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 它的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.歷史,包括別人的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 與它自己過去的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別;它作出 對物的歸屬分別 的材料亦然。(從 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別 的定義 + 前提一 + 步驟三之四 + 對物的歸屬分別 的定義 推出)【正文:句2850185942、句4210008072、句5852159059】\n- 附註:材料分外來的與自身的兩類,與 fb0addca-42b6-4884-aa18-438c695747ab.我的建構 同形;別人怎麼劃,只經由別人的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達。【正文:句9800835143、句0328276885】\n- 結論四之三:81952268-47b1-4d8c-9605-270c42646693.記錄 中相同的材料,不推出相同的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別:37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別 留下的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.寫入,內容由到當時為止的完整 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.歷史 決定,其中自己過去的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別 不在 81952268-47b1-4d8c-9605-270c42646693.記錄 中,自己的來路也取不全;所以兩個 社會人 即使 81952268-47b1-4d8c-9605-270c42646693.記錄 中的材料相同,完整 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.歷史 也可能不同;一個 社會人 劃不劃出某個 我們、怎麼劃,會不會作出某種 對物的歸屬分別、怎麼劃,單憑 81952268-47b1-4d8c-9605-270c42646693.記錄 中的材料推不出;此外在 前提二 之下,依 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.黑箱律,即使完整 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.歷史 已知,它的下一 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.時刻 也不能事前唯一推出。(從 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別 的定義 + 前提三 + fb0addca-42b6-4884-aa18-438c695747ab.來路牆 + 前提二 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.黑箱律 + b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.應用假定 的定義 推出)【正文:句4357401074、句0914174070】\n- 附註:[作者裁決] 2026-11-06 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.黑箱律 只保證一個不被 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.鎖死 的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦 的下一 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.時刻 不能事前唯一推出;結論四之三 主要依據完整 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.歷史 不在 81952268-47b1-4d8c-9605-270c42646693.記錄 中,只主張單憑 81952268-47b1-4d8c-9605-270c42646693.記錄 中的材料推不出這些 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別,不主張其中每一項在原則上都不可預測;本篇依 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.應用假定,把 社會人 作出這類 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別 的那一 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.時刻 當作不被 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.鎖死。\n- 結論四之四:一次劃出 我們,37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 作出它的 社會人 自己,參與它之後的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.權重;若這次 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別 以自己為對象,它也是 fb0addca-42b6-4884-aa18-438c695747ab.我的建構 中自身那一類的材料;往哪個方向推,推不出。(從 前提一 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦 的定義 + fb0addca-42b6-4884-aa18-438c695747ab.我的建構 的定義 + b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.知見障 + 步驟三之三之一 推出)【正文:句2824305532、句0034711374、句9412562431】\n- 結論四之五:劃一個類為 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.我,不要求類中每個成員的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 都 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 劃的一方;類的分類內容,可以經由 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.信號容器 的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 它。(從 我們 的定義 + b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.信號容器 的定義 + b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.耦合 的定義 推出)【正文:句5718054040、句4118539740】\n- 結論四之六:研究者的 81952268-47b1-4d8c-9605-270c42646693.記錄 中只有 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 與 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.信號容器 的內容;任何 社會人 的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別 都不在 81952268-47b1-4d8c-9605-270c42646693.記錄 中;研究者說某人有某個 我們,是研究者以該人為對象的一次 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別,其中可以包含 fb0addca-42b6-4884-aa18-438c695747ab.看法歸屬(把 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 研究者的某筆 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 劃為該人的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別)或 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.印象(對該人 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.權重 的估計)。(從 前提三 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別 的定義 + fb0addca-42b6-4884-aa18-438c695747ab.看法歸屬 的定義 + b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.印象 的定義 + b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.信號容器 的定義 推出)【正文:句5802490918、句5330002617、句5212706050】\n- 附註:研究者本身也可能是 社會人,也有自己的 我們 與 你們;它對他人 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 所作的歸類,同樣在它的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.權重 下落出,也在 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.歷史 之中,不是置身 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.歷史 之外的讀數。【正文:句0061023563、句0538528099】\n- 結論四之七:一個 社會人 與某個 我們 有關的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.歷史,只往後追加:當時沒有 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 它的事,之後也不會 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 它,之後 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 的只是那件事留下的影響;已經 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 的,也不被抹去;所以新加入者與久居者,即使此刻劃出同一個 我們,參與這次 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別 的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.歷史 也可能不同:在新加入者加入之前已經 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 久居者的事,若當時沒有 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 新加入者,之後也不會 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 它;37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.歷史 的長短,不推出這個 我們 有多強,也不推出 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 的差異。(從 結論四之二 + 結論四之四 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.歷史 的定義 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.不可復原律 + fb0addca-42b6-4884-aa18-438c695747ab.來路牆 推出)【正文:句0884498122、句7372495452、句3008016498、句1547600727】\n- 附註:[作者裁決] 2026-11-05 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.歷史 的長短與 我們 有多強是兩個獨立的維度:長短是 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 了多少,有多強屬於 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.權重,前者不決定後者;論文已在 結論四之七 的來源中寫明,不由 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.黑箱律 推出。\n- 附註:稱久居者的 我們 「深厚」,指與它有關的材料較多,經由 2ccbf179-58cf-4851-bd72-5fa886e4b2c3.學習 追加進 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.歷史,不指更認同、更忠誠;這段材料參與了什麼,當事人自己也辨認不全(37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.損耗律、fb0addca-42b6-4884-aa18-438c695747ab.盲點牆)。【正文:句6430872751、句1552174807】\n- 結論四之八:被劃進去的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.呈現 若是一個 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.我,劃出 我們 的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別 參與劃的一方的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.權重,可能使它以被劃進去者為對象的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 增加;這些 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 若 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 被劃進去者,且對方的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 也 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 劃的一方,便成為 ae79e938-76e1-4bf9-b2ab-995c03e16c9e.專屬歷史 的材料;ae79e938-76e1-4bf9-b2ab-995c03e16c9e.專屬歷史 反覆,可能出現 ae79e938-76e1-4bf9-b2ab-995c03e16c9e.默契;但 ae79e938-76e1-4bf9-b2ab-995c03e16c9e.默契 不以 我們 為條件,我們 也不以 ae79e938-76e1-4bf9-b2ab-995c03e16c9e.默契 為條件。(從 我們 的定義 + 結論四之二 + ae79e938-76e1-4bf9-b2ab-995c03e16c9e.專屬歷史 的定義 + ae79e938-76e1-4bf9-b2ab-995c03e16c9e.默契 的定義 + 結論四之四 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦 的定義 + b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.邊 的定義 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 的定義 推出)【正文:句9419078198、句2809649165、句4272240539】\n- 附註:一個 社會人 與一個被劃為 我們 的類之間,沒有 ae79e938-76e1-4bf9-b2ab-995c03e16c9e.專屬歷史;多人之間的相容接續是否為 2ccbf179-58cf-4851-bd72-5fa886e4b2c3.共振,依 2ccbf179-58cf-4851-bd72-5fa886e4b2c3.共振 的定義判定;ae79e938-76e1-4bf9-b2ab-995c03e16c9e.默契 在兩個 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.我 之間逐維度判定;研究者對 2ccbf179-58cf-4851-bd72-5fa886e4b2c3.共振 的命名是 2ccbf179-58cf-4851-bd72-5fa886e4b2c3.文化。【正文:句5533411956、句6975245751】\n- 結論四之九:一個 社會人 可以在不同維度上,各自劃出不同的 我們;這些 我們 可以包含、交疊;劃出它們的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別 也可以衝突,定義不要求它們一致。(從 步驟三之五 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別 的定義 推出)【正文:句5717302765、句6154377994、句9539981504】\n- 結論四之十:兩個 我們 之間的包含關係,不在任何一個 我們 的定義中;把兩者看成包含關係,是這些定義之外的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別;一個 社會人 可以把一個 我們 劃出,而不把在包含關係上包含它的另一個 我們 劃出。(從 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別 的定義 + 我們 的定義 推出)【正文:句0919791440、句9742508384】\n- 結論四之十一:一個 社會人 劃出不同維度上各個 我們 的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別,都參與它的同一個 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.權重,它的一筆 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 由整個 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.權重 落出;所以這筆 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 出於哪一個 我們,推不出。(從 結論四之四 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦 的定義 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.自己的那一段 的定義 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.黑箱律 推出)【正文:句7173493322、句7106264599、句1273520169】\n- 步驟四之十一之一:劃出不同 我們 的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別 參與同一個 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.權重 時,推高一個方向,必然壓低其餘方向的總和;研究者統計一個人多半落向哪一邊,得到的是 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.印象,不是 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.權重 的讀數。(從 結論四之十一 + b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.知見障 + b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.印象 的定義 推出)【正文:句0521030687、句3487608855】\n- 附註:一筆 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 被研究者歸為「忠」或「叛」,是研究者事後以這筆 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 為對象的一次 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別,其中可以包含 fb0addca-42b6-4884-aa18-438c695747ab.看法歸屬。【正文:句1134835615】\n- 結論四之十二:同一個名稱下,各成員的 我們 不保證相同;在名稱下再劃出較小的 我們,也不被定義排除。(從 結論四之三 + 步驟三之五 推出)【正文:句4733325902、句1368567086】\n- 結論四之十三:一個 社會人 把 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.呈現 劃進 我們,不推出它會把某件物劃為「我們的」;它把某件物劃為「我們的」,也不推出它會劃出某個 我們,或被它劃進 我們 的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.呈現 會同意;兩者可以相連,但依不同的定義界定對象,互不蘊含。(從 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別 的定義 + 我們 的定義 + 步驟三之四之一 + 對物的歸屬分別 的定義 + 分別邊際 的定義 推出)【正文:句2140880377、句9994499921、句3231733860】\n\n## 第五節\n\n來源:論文第五節【正文:句0322555594】\n\n- 結論五之一:一次 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別,改變的是作出它的 社會人:它成為該 社會人 的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.歷史,參與其後的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.權重;這次 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別 對 d244789a-9261-4a0d-a98a-feb8db56b511.經濟模式 的改變,只經由該 社會人 的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出;在 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 之前,模式原有的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出、37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達、可行的 81952268-47b1-4d8c-9605-270c42646693.路徑 與 d244789a-9261-4a0d-a98a-feb8db56b511.存續判準,不因這次 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別 而在 81952268-47b1-4d8c-9605-270c42646693.記錄 中改變。(從 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別 的定義 + b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.邊 的定義 + d244789a-9261-4a0d-a98a-feb8db56b511.經濟模式 的定義 + 81952268-47b1-4d8c-9605-270c42646693.門檻 的定義 + 81952268-47b1-4d8c-9605-270c42646693.可行集合 的定義 + 結論四之四 + 前提三 + 步驟三之三之一 + d244789a-9261-4a0d-a98a-feb8db56b511.存續判準 的定義 + 前提一 推出)【正文:句2856406469、句7147261602、句7750836890】\n- 步驟五之一之一:作出 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別 的 社會人,只要仍是 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦、這次 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別 仍參與它的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.權重,之後的每一筆 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 都從包含它的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.權重 落出;哪一筆 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 因它而不同、差多少,推不出。(從 結論四之十一 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.黑箱律 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦 的定義 推出)【正文:句4819221287】\n- 結論五之二:一個 社會人 劃出 我們 的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別 與它的 對物的歸屬分別,對他人只經由它的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 起作用;它所用的 我們、「我們的」等 幻覺構件,作用也只經由運用它們的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出;37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 別人的,是它的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出,不是它的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別;別人若對它作出 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別,那是別人自己的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別。(從 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別 的定義 + b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 的定義 + fb0addca-42b6-4884-aa18-438c695747ab.看法歸屬 的定義 + 步驟三之四之一 + 步驟三之十一 推出)【正文:句1697458073、句8443622305、句4273079260】\n- 循環五之三:設甲、乙是兩個 社會人;甲的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 若 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 乙,便參與乙之後的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.權重,可能改變乙之後的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別;乙的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 若 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 甲,也可能這樣改變甲的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別;甲的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 乙之後,乙之後落出的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 若又 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 甲,甲的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 便經由乙,又參與甲自己的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.權重,構成一個 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.迴路;雙方的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別 可能經由這個 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.迴路 互相塑造;是否改變、往哪個方向改變,推不出;退出條件:任一方的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 不再 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 另一方時,這個 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.迴路 就斷了;會不會斷、何時斷,推不出。(從 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦 的定義 + b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.迴路 的定義 + b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.耦合 的定義 + 結論五之二 + b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.知見障 + 步驟三之三之一 推出)【正文:句6956873026、句9068496895、句9867633007、句8439680626、句0122583894、句4753324633】\n- 步驟五之三之一:「甲認為乙認為甲是……」是甲作出的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別;其中「乙認為」那一層,是甲對乙的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別 的推測,不是乙實際作出的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別;不論疊幾層,都在作出它的一方的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.歷史 裡。(從 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別 的定義 推出)【正文:句0497425138、句9651995141】\n- 循環五之三之二:這些層次若是各方先後實際作出的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別,而不只是一次 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別 中的多層表述,就不是同時的堆疊:一次 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別 不在它自己的材料裡,在下一 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.時刻 之前才 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 自己;一方的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 若 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 另一方,另一方以它為材料作出的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別,材料只有它之前、已經 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 它的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.歷史;所以這種遞迴若一來一回攤在時間上,就是 循環五之三 的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.迴路;這時每一層都是一次 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別;退出條件同 循環五之三。(從 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別 的定義 + 前提一 + 步驟五之三之一 + 循環五之三 推出)【正文:句5030601636、句5431134546、句3891844036、句0122583894】\n- 附註:b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.迴路 上流動的只有 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出,包括 宣誓,也可能包括關於物的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出;37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別 在各方的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.歷史 中,不在 81952268-47b1-4d8c-9605-270c42646693.記錄 裡;本結論的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.迴路 不另立概念。【正文:句7020407203、句4837721282】\n- 結論五之四:若乙某條 81952268-47b1-4d8c-9605-270c42646693.路徑 的某項 81952268-47b1-4d8c-9605-270c42646693.前件,只能由甲的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 供應,則這條 81952268-47b1-4d8c-9605-270c42646693.路徑 是否可行,取決於甲的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出;甲的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 在甲的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.權重 下落出,甲若作過相關的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別,它是參與這個 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.權重 的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.歷史 之一;甲的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 是否因這次 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別 而不同、差多少,推不出。(從 81952268-47b1-4d8c-9605-270c42646693.門檻 的定義 + 81952268-47b1-4d8c-9605-270c42646693.前件 的定義 + 81952268-47b1-4d8c-9605-270c42646693.可行集合 的定義 + 結論五之二 + 結論四之六 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦 的定義 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.黑箱律 + 前提一 + 結論五之一 推出)【正文:句9459191523、句9431272374、句2136938732】\n- 結論五之五:一筆 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 若 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 接收者,對接收者的 81952268-47b1-4d8c-9605-270c42646693.路徑 可以有兩種作用:供應或撤除某條 81952268-47b1-4d8c-9605-270c42646693.路徑 的 81952268-47b1-4d8c-9605-270c42646693.前件;或參與接收者的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.權重,使它走不走某條仍然可行的 81952268-47b1-4d8c-9605-270c42646693.路徑 有所不同;第二種作用不改變 81952268-47b1-4d8c-9605-270c42646693.前件;一筆 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 可以兩種作用都有,也可以只有其中一種;它有哪一種、作用多大,推不出。(從 81952268-47b1-4d8c-9605-270c42646693.門檻 的定義 + 81952268-47b1-4d8c-9605-270c42646693.前件 的定義 + 81952268-47b1-4d8c-9605-270c42646693.可行集合 的定義 + b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.邊 的定義 + 結論五之四 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.黑箱律 推出)【正文:句1142492656、句7932797650、句0770780069、句8768818714】\n- 步驟五之五之一:話語也是 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出;若那條 81952268-47b1-4d8c-9605-270c42646693.路徑 在那一輪仍屬 81952268-47b1-4d8c-9605-270c42646693.可行集合,威脅這筆話語又沒有撤除它的 81952268-47b1-4d8c-9605-270c42646693.前件,接收者不走那條 81952268-47b1-4d8c-9605-270c42646693.路徑,是它的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.權重 落出的結果。(從 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 的定義 + 結論五之五 + 81952268-47b1-4d8c-9605-270c42646693.門檻 的定義 + 81952268-47b1-4d8c-9605-270c42646693.可行集合 的定義 推出)【正文:句5836146965、句0453947363】\n- 附註:某條 81952268-47b1-4d8c-9605-270c42646693.路徑 在某一輪是否可行,依 81952268-47b1-4d8c-9605-270c42646693.門檻 判定;把「沒有走」記成「不能走」,混淆了兩種作用。【正文:句4136006084】\n- 結論五之六:一個 社會人 以他人的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別 為對象的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出,若 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 對方,便參與對方的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.權重;對方的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別 是否因此改變、往哪改變,推不出;在 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.應用假定 之下,作出這類 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 的 fb0addca-42b6-4884-aa18-438c695747ab.決定,照樣是 fb0addca-42b6-4884-aa18-438c695747ab.被迫的賭注;研究者把某筆 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 歸為以他人 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別 為對象,是研究者的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別,不是作出它的一方的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別 的讀數。(從 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.應用假定 的定義 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別 的定義 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦 的定義 + b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.知見障 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.黑箱律 + fb0addca-42b6-4884-aa18-438c695747ab.被迫的賭注 + b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 的定義 + b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.邊 的定義 + fb0addca-42b6-4884-aa18-438c695747ab.決定 的定義 推出)【正文:句9515446912、句9910385973、句6912331712、句8658198156】\n- 結論五之七:甲以某件物為對象的一筆 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 若 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 另一個 社會人 乙,便成為乙之後 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.歷史 的一部分,參與乙後續對該物的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別 與 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出;乙之後如何劃該物、是否另作相同分類、對該物的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 如何落出,均推不出;乙若再作出 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 並 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 甲或丙,這個過程可以繼續遞迴。(從 對物的歸屬分別 的定義 + 結論四之二 + 結論四之三 + 結論五之二 + 循環五之三 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦 的定義 + b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.知見障 推出)【正文:句8031272770、句5960250860、句8756596740、句1029346274】\n- 附註:甲說某件物是「我們的」,81952268-47b1-4d8c-9605-270c42646693.記錄 中只有這筆 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出;即使乙也這樣說,仍不證明雙方的 我們 或「我們的」相同;本結論不推出使用、處置或分配規則。【正文:句6704773366、句6737628800、句3136337293】\n\n## 第六節\n\n來源:論文第六節【正文:句4939107889】\n\n- 結論六之一:一筆 宣誓 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 一個 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦 之後,參與它之後的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.權重;接收者只要仍是 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦,之後在這個維度上對作出 宣誓 一方的每一次 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別,都從包含這筆 宣誓 的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.歷史 出發;宣誓 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 作出它的一方自己,也是如此;撤回是另一筆 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出,在它 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 之前,前一筆已參與了這段期間的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.權重。(從 宣誓 的定義 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 的定義 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦 的定義 + 前提一 推出)【正文:句4419023168、句2804967533、句8467173322、句4956736102】\n- 結論六之二:一筆 宣誓,不推出作出它的一方在這個維度上劃出了它所要求的那一類;確實這樣劃時,也不推出劃得多深。(從 步驟三之十 + 結論四之六 + fb0addca-42b6-4884-aa18-438c695747ab.看法歸屬 的定義 推出)【正文:句8180399098、句7441420376】\n- 結論六之三:一筆 宣誓 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 作出它的一方自己,是它之後劃出 我們 的材料之一;若 宣誓 以自己為對象,它也是 fb0addca-42b6-4884-aa18-438c695747ab.我的建構 的材料;往哪個方向推,推不出。(從 結論四之二 + 結論四之四 + 結論六之一 + fb0addca-42b6-4884-aa18-438c695747ab.我的建構 的定義 + b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.知見障 推出)【正文:句9174501155、句0034711374、句0244443788】\n- 結論六之四:一筆 宣誓 放進 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.信號容器 後,可以在作出它的一方不在場、甚至 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.退場 之後,37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 後來的接收者。(從 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.信號容器 的定義 推出)【正文:句0607449801、句3434002112】\n- 結論六之五:一筆 宣誓 若 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 一個 社會人,這個 社會人 是否照著 宣誓 所要求的那一類劃出作出它的一方,推不出。(從 結論四之三 + b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.知見障 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.黑箱律 + 宣誓 的定義 推出)【正文:句8069717587、句1510448647】\n- 步驟六之五之一:宣誓 若 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 接收者,而接收者是 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦,便參與其 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.權重,可能使它不走某條 81952268-47b1-4d8c-9605-270c42646693.路徑;它也可能供應或撤除某條 81952268-47b1-4d8c-9605-270c42646693.路徑 的 81952268-47b1-4d8c-9605-270c42646693.前件;有哪一種作用,推不出。(從 結論六之一 + 結論五之五 推出)【正文:句7384970782】\n- 附註:使不照著劃的一方某條 81952268-47b1-4d8c-9605-270c42646693.路徑 不可行,屬於他人把 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別 強加於人,留待後續。【正文:句4734576574】\n\n## 第七節\n\n來源:論文第七節【正文:句7350531085】\n\n- 結論七之一:d244789a-9261-4a0d-a98a-feb8db56b511.經濟模式 不以參與者有 二階能力 為條件;因此不以參與者劃出 我們、你們 或作出 對物的歸屬分別 為成立條件。(從 d244789a-9261-4a0d-a98a-feb8db56b511.經濟模式 的定義 推出)【正文:句4672534992、句2271604361】\n- 附註:這不表示已有 二階能力 的參與者一定不作 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別;2ccbf179-58cf-4851-bd72-5fa886e4b2c3.共振 與 ae79e938-76e1-4bf9-b2ab-995c03e16c9e.默契 也不以 社會人 為條件。【正文:句7886468828、句4343940757】\n- 結論七之二:社會人 以某個既有 d244789a-9261-4a0d-a98a-feb8db56b511.經濟模式 中的人或物為對象作出 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別 時,材料只能是已經 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 它的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.歷史:其中可以有該模式中已 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 它的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出,也可以有模式以外 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 它的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出;37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別 不會先於它所依賴的材料 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達。(從 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別 的定義 + 結論四之二 + 對物的歸屬分別 的定義 推出)【正文:句0879405558、句4877051422】\n- 附註:所說「二階改造」,指 社會人 對既有模式的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 另作 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別,以及這些 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別 參與後續 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.權重,並可能經由 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出(若 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 他人並繞回)進入新的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.迴路;它不另立新機制;37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別 改變作出它的 社會人,模式的改變經由它的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出;「先有 d244789a-9261-4a0d-a98a-feb8db56b511.經濟模式,後有改造」說的是在所分析的這一次改造中,已有模式的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 先成為材料,不是主張所有 d244789a-9261-4a0d-a98a-feb8db56b511.經濟模式 在時間上都早於所有 社會人 的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別;d244789a-9261-4a0d-a98a-feb8db56b511.經濟模式 是研究者的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別,與 社會人 所劃的範圍與維度不必一致。【正文:句6099090116、句6884263410、句0164583088、句5637422895】\n- 結論七之三:社會人 以 d244789a-9261-4a0d-a98a-feb8db56b511.經濟模式 中已 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 的材料為對象,可以另作 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別:把已 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 它的既有做法劃為一種做法,並把自己原先對這種做法的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別 劃為看法、而非不經 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別 的必然安排;對已 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 它的參與者,劃出 我們、你們 等對人的 分別邊際;對已 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 它的物之 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.呈現,劃出對物的 分別邊際;這三種均是可能性,不保證有 二階能力 便會發生,也不要求依序發生。(從 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別 的定義 + 結論七之二 + fb0addca-42b6-4884-aa18-438c695747ab.二階分別 的定義 + fb0addca-42b6-4884-aa18-438c695747ab.看法歸屬 的定義 + 我們 的定義 + 你們 的定義 + 對物的歸屬分別 的定義 + 分別邊際 的定義 + 社會人 的定義 + 二階能力 的定義 推出)【正文:句8287697864、句7520416350、句0655070368、句6922609319、句8650008264、句4581535265】\n- 步驟七之三之一:劃出對人的 我們 的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別,不必然帶出把物劃為「我們的」 的那一種 對物的歸屬分別。(從 結論四之十三 推出)【正文:句6710290213】\n- 結論七之四:二階改造的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 若 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 其他參與者,而該參與者是 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦,便參與它的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.權重;它之後的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別(若它是 社會人)與 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 是否因此改變、往哪改變,推不出;原有的 d244789a-9261-4a0d-a98a-feb8db56b511.經濟模式 可能延續,也可能 d244789a-9261-4a0d-a98a-feb8db56b511.判準中斷,不保證更有利於延續。(從 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦 的定義 + 循環五之三 + 結論五之七 + b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.知見障 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.黑箱律 + 2ccbf179-58cf-4851-bd72-5fa886e4b2c3.學習 的定義 + d244789a-9261-4a0d-a98a-feb8db56b511.經濟模式 的定義 + d244789a-9261-4a0d-a98a-feb8db56b511.存續判準 的定義 + d244789a-9261-4a0d-a98a-feb8db56b511.判準中斷 的定義 推出)【正文:句4416084176、句2676820151、句4026735811】\n- 結論七之五:劃出 我們,不要求劃的一方與被劃進去的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.呈現 同在一個 d244789a-9261-4a0d-a98a-feb8db56b511.經濟模式 中。(從 我們 的定義 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別 的定義 + 結論四之二 推出)【正文:句6747684553、句3622611866】\n- 結論七之六:若 社會人 以某 d244789a-9261-4a0d-a98a-feb8db56b511.經濟模式 中已 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 它的人或物為材料,劃出 我們、你們 或作出 對物的歸屬分別,則該 d244789a-9261-4a0d-a98a-feb8db56b511.經濟模式 對這個 社會人 有了 分別邊際;這條 分別邊際 由它自己劃出,不是原有 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 與 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 結構自帶的分類,也不是其他參與者共有的。(從 分別邊際 的定義 + 結論七之一 + 結論七之二 + 結論七之三 推出)【正文:句3569640236、句7481539144、句8313286695】\n- 附註:這裡的「有了」只指在該 社會人 的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別 中;d244789a-9261-4a0d-a98a-feb8db56b511.經濟模式 要有內外之分,經由它的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出(結論五之一);沒有一條先驗的、全部參與者共有的 分別邊際;對人的 分別邊際 與對物的 分別邊際 可以交疊、衝突或各自出現;分別邊際 在 社會人 的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.歷史 中,不在 81952268-47b1-4d8c-9605-270c42646693.記錄 中,它對他人的作用仍經由 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出。【正文:句4535797817、句2898272456、句8318372383】\n- 結論七之七:一個 社會人 把某件物劃為「我們的」,不推出它自己、被它劃為 我們 的人、被它劃為 你們 的人,對該物有任何特定使用、取用、處置或排除關係;也不推出其他 社會人 照著它的分類劃該物。(從 對物的歸屬分別 的定義 + 結論四之三 + 結論四之十三 + 結論五之二 + 結論六之五 推出)【正文:句9617159628、句4832530446】\n- 結論七之八:社會人 在人與物上作出的 分別邊際,作為它自己 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.歷史 的一部分,參與它之後的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.權重;它落出的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 若 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 其他參與者,而該參與者是 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦,便參與它之後的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.權重;它若是 社會人,這筆 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 也可能成為它再作 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別 與 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 的材料;這使原本不以 我們 或「我們的」為條件的 d244789a-9261-4a0d-a98a-feb8db56b511.經濟模式,可以納入由 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別 經由 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 形成的反覆 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.迴路;具體 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 是否因某次 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別 而不同、往哪不同,推不出。(從 結論四之四 + 結論五之二 + 循環五之三 + 結論五之七 + 結論七之一 + 結論七之六 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦 的定義 + b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.知見障 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.黑箱律 + 前提一 推出)【正文:句5746044312、句0929925862、句2823727247、句0049336174】\n- 附註:「參與運作」不是說某次 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別 必然造成可觀測的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 改變;同樣的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 也可能在不同 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別 下落出;研究者看到甲、乙都說某件物是「我們的」,推不回他們已經共有一個 我們,或對同一物有同一 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別;d244789a-9261-4a0d-a98a-feb8db56b511.經濟模式 可以繼續依原判準延續,本篇增加的是對其後續 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 之材料來源的描述,不取代格局論文的判定。【正文:句0761625779、句7446281880、句3755913767】\n- 結論七之九:社會人 的 分別邊際 參與它的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.權重;它對被它劃在不同一邊的人或物落出的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出,可能不同;這些 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 若 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 其他參與者,可能使它們某些 81952268-47b1-4d8c-9605-270c42646693.路徑 可行或不可行;37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 的參與者若是 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦,也參與它的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.權重,可能使它不走某些仍然可行的 81952268-47b1-4d8c-9605-270c42646693.路徑;因此 分別邊際 經由 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出,可能使 d244789a-9261-4a0d-a98a-feb8db56b511.經濟模式 在 81952268-47b1-4d8c-9605-270c42646693.記錄 中有 內外差異;是否有、落在哪裡、某項差異出於哪一次 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別,推不出。(從 分別邊際 的定義 + 內外差異 的定義 + 結論五之二 + 結論五之四 + 結論五之五 + 結論七之八 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.黑箱律 推出)【正文:句3019803142、句9889110777、句4598809737、句1206248133、句7237610050】\n- 附註:本結論不說某次 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別 必然帶出 內外差異,也不說 內外差異 會延續;改變模式的,是它的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出(結論五之一);同一個 社會人 對兩邊的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出,也可能相同。【正文:句3152842342、句8583502475】\n- 結論七之十:多個 社會人 各自的 分別邊際,經由各自的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出,可能使 81952268-47b1-4d8c-9605-270c42646693.記錄 中有同一條 內外差異;這條 內外差異 不要求這些 社會人 共有一個 我們,也不要求他們的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別 一致,它依 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 判定;各人的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別 變動,與 81952268-47b1-4d8c-9605-270c42646693.記錄 中 內外差異 在不同 d244789a-9261-4a0d-a98a-feb8db56b511.檢查窗口 之間的不同,不必同步:37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別 變了,b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 可能未變;b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 變了,也不推出 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別 已變。(從 內外差異 的定義 + 我們 的定義 + 結論四之六 + 結論七之八 + 結論七之九 + d244789a-9261-4a0d-a98a-feb8db56b511.檢查窗口 的定義 推出)【正文:句9131908239、句5161345224、句7894033073、句1524454042】\n- 附註:說多個 社會人 「都把某人劃在裡面」,是研究者以這些 社會人 為對象的一次 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別,其中可以包含對各人 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 的 fb0addca-42b6-4884-aa18-438c695747ab.看法歸屬;某個 社會人 把某個 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.呈現 劃進或劃出,與 81952268-47b1-4d8c-9605-270c42646693.記錄 中 內外差異 的變化,可以錯開。【正文:句7648979610、句1379140412、句2636514850】\n- 結論七之十一:若以分類為內容的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 接收者,且作出它的一方與其他 社會人 之後的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 也陸續 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達,81952268-47b1-4d8c-9605-270c42646693.記錄 中若有 內外差異,它依研究者登記、並在講明的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.切法 下歸為同類的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 劃出;這些之後的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 若被登記並歸入同類,也可以在其中;它不單依 宣稱界線 劃出;之後的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 與 宣稱界線 不相容時,兩者在 81952268-47b1-4d8c-9605-270c42646693.記錄 中可以不一致;落差可以登記,落差事先會有多大、為何如此,推不出。(從 宣稱界線 的定義 + 內外差異 的定義 + 81952268-47b1-4d8c-9605-270c42646693.記錄 的定義 + b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.印象 的定義 + 2ccbf179-58cf-4851-bd72-5fa886e4b2c3.強制 的定義 + 結論五之五 + 結論六之五 + 結論七之九 + 結論七之十 推出)【正文:句9884487518、句7157632979、句4228933505、句5491170580】\n- 步驟七之十一之一:接收者若是 社會人,那筆以分類為內容的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出,是它之後作 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別 的材料之一;它可以拿之後 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 與它對照;對照的結果推不出。(從 結論四之二 + 結論四之三 推出)【正文:句5555455949、句9662583019】\n- 附註:宣稱界線 與 內外差異,都是研究者依 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 劃出的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別:前者依一筆以分類為內容的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出,後者依同類的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出,後者可以包含前者那一筆;內外差異 也不是任何被研究的 社會人 的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別;本結論不說 宣稱界線 所依的那筆 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 無作用:這筆 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 若 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 接收者,而接收者是 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦,便參與其 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.權重;落差相對於研究者講明的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.切法 與維度。【正文:句6243071408、句4277390956、句6446594717】\n- 結論七之十二:研究者在 81952268-47b1-4d8c-9605-270c42646693.記錄 中登記到 內外差異 或 宣稱界線,不推出參與者有 二階能力,也不推出它出於某次 分別邊際。(從 步驟〇之一 + 宣稱界線 的定義 + 結論七之一 + 結論四之六 + 結論七之八 推出)【正文:句6684476253、句7390097180】\n\n## 第八節\n\n來源:論文第八節【正文:句1535213546】\n\n- 結論八之一:被一個 社會人 劃進 我們 的其他 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.呈現(不含它自己),若是 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 這個 社會人 的來源,仍是它的 d244789a-9261-4a0d-a98a-feb8db56b511.外界。(從 d244789a-9261-4a0d-a98a-feb8db56b511.外界 的定義 + 我們 的定義 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別 的定義 推出)【正文:句3038425825、句2299460019】\n- 附註:d244789a-9261-4a0d-a98a-feb8db56b511.外界 由 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 來源決定,研究者的 81952268-47b1-4d8c-9605-270c42646693.記錄 可能登記其中一部分;劃出 我們 的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別 不在 81952268-47b1-4d8c-9605-270c42646693.記錄 中,兩層並存,後者不取代前者;劃出 我們 不劃分 d244789a-9261-4a0d-a98a-feb8db56b511.外界 的全部。【正文:句4724243227、句2541039475、句6705964407】\n- 結論八之二:劃出 我們 的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別 把自己和其他 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.呈現 劃在同一邊,但這不推出存在一個由它們合成的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.我。(從 我們 的定義 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別 的定義 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.我 的定義 + b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.重切 的定義 推出)【正文:句9828093339、句2260459597】\n- 步驟八之二之一:被自我定義納入的,是這個 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.我 的一部分;被劃進 我們 的,仍被歸為另一個 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.我。(從 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.我 的定義 + 我們 的定義 推出)【正文:句9893507443、句9264565393、句3840120717、句8304517476】\n- 結論八之三:劃出 我們,37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 的是劃的一方自己,不使被劃進去者的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 劃的一方:被劃進去的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.呈現,它的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 是否 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 劃的一方,仍取決於該 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 與 d244789a-9261-4a0d-a98a-feb8db56b511.外界。(從 結論四之四 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 的定義 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.寫入 的定義 + b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 的定義 + d244789a-9261-4a0d-a98a-feb8db56b511.外界 的定義 推出)【正文:句8778240772、句8659163720】\n- 結論八之四:社會人 對某件物作出 對物的歸屬分別,不使該物的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 或與該物有關的物理變化因此直接 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 任何人;是否 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達,仍依 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 的定義判定;它因而對該物作出什麼 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出,不由這次 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別 唯一決定。(從 對物的歸屬分別 的定義 + 分別邊際 的定義 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 的定義 + 結論五之二 + 結論八之三 + b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.應用假定 的定義 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.黑箱律 推出)【正文:句5692372185、句2118166080、句4242573649】\n\n## 第九節\n\n來源:論文第九節【正文:句5426691881】\n\n- 結論九之一:以分類為內容的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 與其他 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出,若 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 他人,而他人是 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦,便參與其 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.權重;他人落出的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出,可能又 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 原來作出 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 的一方與第三者;這種遞迴,可能使 81952268-47b1-4d8c-9605-270c42646693.記錄 中的 內外差異 或 宣稱界線 在不同 d244789a-9261-4a0d-a98a-feb8db56b511.檢查窗口 之間有所不同,研究者記為 界線的移動;它在 81952268-47b1-4d8c-9605-270c42646693.記錄 中的結構可以依 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 描述,在講明的維度上可以用 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.趨同、b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.趨異、b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.持平、b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.太極 與 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.合流 描述;是否出現 界線的移動、往哪個方向、何時出現,推不出。(從 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.迴路 的定義 + b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.耦合 的定義 + b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.趨同 的定義 + b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.趨異 的定義 + b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.持平 的定義 + b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.太極 的定義 + b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.合流 的定義 + d244789a-9261-4a0d-a98a-feb8db56b511.檢查窗口 的定義 + 內外差異 的定義 + 宣稱界線 的定義 + 界線的移動 的定義 + 循環五之三 + 結論五之七 + 結論六之三 + 結論七之十 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.黑箱律 推出)【正文:句6817370633、句5500171916、句3235587138、句4384625398、句3032830563、句1680203598】\n- 附註:界線的移動 是研究者比較兩個 d244789a-9261-4a0d-a98a-feb8db56b511.檢查窗口 所作的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別,同一段 81952268-47b1-4d8c-9605-270c42646693.記錄 換一種 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.切法,可以記為移動,也可以記為不動;本結論不預測方向;37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別 的改變與 界線的移動 不必同步。【正文:句4192975688、句8591461252、句0249243564】\n- 結論九之二:一個 社會人 依某個 你們 作出的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出,37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 被劃進去的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.呈現 時,37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 的是 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出,不是 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別;被劃進去的若對它作出 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別,那是它自己的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別。(從 你們 的定義 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別 的定義 + b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 的定義 + 結論五之二 推出)【正文:句0146534926、句4807636364】\n- 結論九之三:甲依某個 你們、以乙等 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.呈現 為對象作出的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出,若 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 乙等,且乙等是 社會人,這些 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 便是它們之後劃出 我們 的材料之一;乙等是否因此劃出包含彼此的 我們、往哪個方向劃,推不出。(從 結論四之二 + 結論四之三 + b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.知見障 推出)【正文:句2799701284、句2899436214】\n- 附註:乙等在甲劃出 你們 之前,不必有任何 我們;這個 我們 若之後出現,甲的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 只是它的材料之一,不是它的原因;甲的這類話,研究者常可把它同時歸為一次 宣誓,要接收者把甲劃在這一類之外;它若 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 乙等,乙等若是 社會人,乙等之後對甲的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別,都從包含它的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.歷史 出發。【正文:句7980379245、句6047006827、句1402829120】\n- 循環九之四:若甲把乙等劃為 你們,乙等也把甲等劃為 你們,雙方依此作出的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 一來一回地互相 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達(循環五之三),則研究者可依 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.太極 的定義判定是否構成 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.太極;是否構成、是否 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.趨異、何時停下,推不出;退出條件:任一方的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 不再 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 另一方時,這個 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.迴路 就斷了。(從 循環五之三 + b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.太極 的定義 + b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.知見障 推出)【正文:句6582207909、句7272813873】\n- 步驟九之四之一:b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.太極 與 2ccbf179-58cf-4851-bd72-5fa886e4b2c3.共振 各在講明的維度上判定;定義不排除同一批參與者在一個維度上構成 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.太極,在另一個維度上 2ccbf179-58cf-4851-bd72-5fa886e4b2c3.共振:雙方在對立的維度上 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.趨異,在另一個維度上的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 仍可能相容接續。(從 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.太極 的定義 + 2ccbf179-58cf-4851-bd72-5fa886e4b2c3.共振 的定義 推出)【正文:句1911519508】\n- 附註:極化若使 81952268-47b1-4d8c-9605-270c42646693.記錄 中的 內外差異 或 宣稱界線 在 d244789a-9261-4a0d-a98a-feb8db56b511.檢查窗口 之間有所不同,研究者可記為 界線的移動 的一種;雙方的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別 不在 81952268-47b1-4d8c-9605-270c42646693.記錄 中,研究者說「雙方的對立加深了」,是研究者以雙方為對象的一次 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別,其中可以包含 fb0addca-42b6-4884-aa18-438c695747ab.看法歸屬;這類 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.迴路 上互相 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 的,常是 宣誓 (結論六之一、六之二)。【正文:句3179051692、句9895467394、句7262687838、句3470820212、句1313858546】\n\n## 第十節\n\n來源:論文第十節【正文:句5185704998】\n\n- 結論十之一:一個 我們 只屬於運用它的 社會人;沒有一個同時屬於兩個 社會人 的 我們;兩個 社會人 的 我們 是否一致,b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.不被保證;即使一致,能不能確認,也 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.不被保證:對方的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別 不 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 當事的一方,雙方的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別 也不 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 研究者,37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 的只是 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出;單憑 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 推不出雙方的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別 一致。(從 我們 的定義 + 結論四之三 + 結論四之六 + 結論五之二 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別 的定義 + fb0addca-42b6-4884-aa18-438c695747ab.看法歸屬 的定義 + b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.印象 的定義 + b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.不被保證 的定義 推出)【正文:句9738125081、句6991079696、句3504547716、句8707998358】\n- 步驟十之一之一:這個不共有的限制也適用於 對物的歸屬分別;兩個 社會人 使用相同的「我們的」名稱,仍不表示存在一個由兩人共同作出的同一次 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別。(從 結論十之一 + 對物的歸屬分別 的定義 推出)【正文:句4548555237】\n- 結論十之二:d244789a-9261-4a0d-a98a-feb8db56b511.經濟模式 的延續,不要求參與者的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別 一致;2ccbf179-58cf-4851-bd72-5fa886e4b2c3.共振 與 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.太極 依 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 與 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 的結構判定,ae79e938-76e1-4bf9-b2ab-995c03e16c9e.失配 依相鄰 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 序列是否相容判定;三者都不依參與者的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別 判定。(從 d244789a-9261-4a0d-a98a-feb8db56b511.經濟模式 的定義 + d244789a-9261-4a0d-a98a-feb8db56b511.存續判準 的定義 + 2ccbf179-58cf-4851-bd72-5fa886e4b2c3.共振 的定義 + b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.太極 的定義 + ae79e938-76e1-4bf9-b2ab-995c03e16c9e.失配 的定義 + b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.趨異 的定義 + 結論七之一 推出)【正文:句6659368929、句5371665187】\n- 結論十之三:甲把乙劃進 我們、乙不把甲劃進 我們,這種不對稱可以在雙方 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 相容時延續;甲對乙怎麼劃的看法,可以因新 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 甲的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 改變,也可以因甲自己之後的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別 改變;改變後的看法,仍是甲以乙為對象的一次 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別,其中可以包含 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.印象 或 fb0addca-42b6-4884-aa18-438c695747ab.看法歸屬,不是乙的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別 的讀數。(從 結論十之一 + 結論十之二 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別 的定義 + fb0addca-42b6-4884-aa18-438c695747ab.看法歸屬 的定義 + b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.印象 的定義 推出)【正文:句1794289670、句6133402663】\n- 步驟十之三之一:乙對甲說過「我們」這類 宣誓 時,不推出乙這樣劃;乙之後的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 若 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 甲,並被甲歸為與這筆 宣誓 不一致,便是甲改變看法的材料之一;甲也可能因其他材料或自己之後的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別 改變看法。(從 結論六之二 + 結論四之二 + 結論十之三 推出)【正文:句3261065117】\n- 結論十之四:屬於( 我們 , 幻覺構件 );把劃出的 我們 當成本來就在那裡、等著被確認的 我們,是 fb0addca-42b6-4884-aa18-438c695747ab.幻覺;本篇不細分它屬於哪一種 fb0addca-42b6-4884-aa18-438c695747ab.幻覺。(從 步驟三之四 + 結論四之一 + 結論四之二 + 結論四之三 + 結論十之一 + fb0addca-42b6-4884-aa18-438c695747ab.幻覺 的定義 推出)【正文:句8524501933、句7665577703、句9566141486】\n- 步驟十之四之一:把聽到的 宣誓 當成對方的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別,是 fb0addca-42b6-4884-aa18-438c695747ab.世界幻覺 的一種。(從 結論六之二 + fb0addca-42b6-4884-aa18-438c695747ab.世界幻覺 的定義 推出)【正文:句7433749915】\n- 步驟十之四之二:社會人 有 二階能力,能看見 我們 是自己劃的;但能看見不等於會看見;看見 我們 是自己劃的,本身也是一次 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別,它 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 自己,成為自己的一部分,可能成為新的一層。(從 fb0addca-42b6-4884-aa18-438c695747ab.二階分別 的定義 + fb0addca-42b6-4884-aa18-438c695747ab.盲點牆 + 社會人 的定義 + 二階能力 的定義 + 我們 的定義 推出)【正文:句5094812889、句7231290983】\n- 步驟十之四之三:推測別人怎麼劃,是以別人為對象的一次 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別;其中可以包含 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.印象,也可以包含 fb0addca-42b6-4884-aa18-438c695747ab.看法歸屬;它的材料只有已經 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 自己的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.歷史,其中 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.印象 的材料是別人 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 自己的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出、自己與對方重疊的那一段、對方所在的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.耦合;宣誓 也只是其中一種,不是 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別 的讀數;這次推測正確與否 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.不被保證;把它當成別人的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別,是 fb0addca-42b6-4884-aa18-438c695747ab.世界幻覺 的一種;推測別人的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別,是自己再作的一層 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別,所推測的是自己歸給對方的那次 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別,對方不一定真的作過。(從 結論十之一 + 結論四之二 + 結論四之三 + 結論六之二 + fb0addca-42b6-4884-aa18-438c695747ab.看法歸屬 的定義 + b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.印象 的定義 + fb0addca-42b6-4884-aa18-438c695747ab.世界幻覺 的定義 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別 的定義 推出)【正文:句0835345653、句9859189495、句8579904469】\n- 結論十之五:d244789a-9261-4a0d-a98a-feb8db56b511.經濟模式 在 d244789a-9261-4a0d-a98a-feb8db56b511.存續判準 下延續或 d244789a-9261-4a0d-a98a-feb8db56b511.判準中斷,不推出參與者之後仍會劃出同類的 我們,或作出同類的 對物的歸屬分別;參與者之後即使再作出同類 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別,也不推出原 d244789a-9261-4a0d-a98a-feb8db56b511.經濟模式 仍然延續;兩者不互相蘊含。(從 d244789a-9261-4a0d-a98a-feb8db56b511.判準中斷 的定義 + 步驟三之七 + 步驟三之十三之一 + 結論十之二 推出)【正文:句7810901067、句8955547799、句2410895002】\n- 附註:大家為什麼住在同一個世界,由 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986 這篇上游論文回答:37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.宇宙 與 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.呈現 本來就在,37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 各人的是同一個 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.宇宙 的不同部分,打了折扣;本篇處理的是:沒有共有的 我們,d244789a-9261-4a0d-a98a-feb8db56b511.經濟模式 照樣延續。【正文:句8209760113、句6454842783】\n- 結論十之七:甲把某件物劃為「我們的」,乙也把該物劃為「我們的」,不推出甲乙對該物作出同一次或相同的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別,更不推出兩人的 我們 一致;甲乙對同一件物的不同 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別,可以在其 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 相容時同時存在。(從 對物的歸屬分別 的定義 + 結論四之六 + 結論五之七 + 結論十之一 + 結論十之二 推出)【正文:句0786196242、句1138798792、句7389397113】\n- 附註:「我們的」是單方運用的 幻覺構件,不是物上的共有性質;名稱經由多人的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 反覆出現,81952268-47b1-4d8c-9605-270c42646693.記錄 中也只有名稱與 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 的傳播;本結論不討論所有權。【正文:句4171726126、句6563307790、句7658137672】\n\n## 第十一節\n\n來源:論文第十一節【正文:句7509628001】\n\n- 附註:第十一節第一小節列出的推不出各項,各由 結論四之三、結論四之十一、結論四之十三、循環五之三、結論五之四、結論五之六、結論五之七、結論六之五、結論七之三、結論七之四、結論七之七、結論七之八、結論七之九、結論七之十、結論七之十一、結論七之十二、結論九之一、結論九之三、循環九之四、結論十之一、結論十之七 與 步驟三之八、步驟三之十四 給出;依賴 結論四之三 的各項,在 前提二 之下成立。【正文:句4972296376、句8778760754、句7837815031、句4083889689、句3353109032、句8808360019、句0360333086、句7763275301、句7164341467、句2191506760、句6504755079、句0166449550、句5433204186、句9625994046、句5893656179、句4838049674、句5477781476、句3250412488、句5794927086、句6509988567、句5856536593】\n- 附註:權威、層級、法人,本篇沒有讓一方的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別 必然被另一方照著做的機制,也沒有讓 宣誓 或對物的分類聲明必然使不照著劃的一方有某條 81952268-47b1-4d8c-9605-270c42646693.路徑 不可行的機制(結論五之五、結論六之五、結論七之七);這三者,以及所有權、制度、價格、價值、貨幣、分配、市場,留待後續;本篇不把「我們的」當作所有權、使用權或分配規則的同義詞。【正文:句5309332766、句3062012681、句8176377114、句4368342215】\n\n## 第十二節\n\n來源:論文第十二節【正文:句1652299983】\n\n- 附註:本節整節是校準,不作任何推導的來源;案中把結論用在具體的人身上時,都在 ae79e938-76e1-4bf9-b2ab-995c03e16c9e.配置假定 之下成立。【正文:句3726611237、句5777870956】\n\n## 第十三節\n\n來源:論文第十三節【正文:句4872069504】\n\n- 結論十三之一:d244789a-9261-4a0d-a98a-feb8db56b511.經濟模式 的成立與延續,不需要任何參與者劃出 我們;社會人 可以在既有 d244789a-9261-4a0d-a98a-feb8db56b511.經濟模式 已 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 它的材料上,作出對人與對物的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別,使該模式對它有由它自行劃定的 分別邊際;分別邊際 不屬於模式本身,不要求其他 社會人 認同,也不推出所有權、使用、處置、排除或分配關係。(從 結論七之一 + 結論七之三 + 結論七之六 + 結論七之七 + 結論十之二 + 步驟三之十一 推出)【正文:句1962524037、句7261434963、句8398676976、句2527318431】\n- 結論十三之二:這些 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別 作出後,成為該 社會人 的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.歷史,參與其後續的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.權重;它對兩邊落出的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 可能不同,這些 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 若 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 他人,可能改變他人可行的 81952268-47b1-4d8c-9605-270c42646693.路徑;他人若是 社會人,也可能成為它之後 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別 與 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 的材料;如此 分別邊際 經由 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出,可能使 d244789a-9261-4a0d-a98a-feb8db56b511.經濟模式 在 81952268-47b1-4d8c-9605-270c42646693.記錄 中有 內外差異。(從 結論七之八 + 結論七之九 推出)【正文:句6174123917、句5122303038】\n- 結論十三之三:各人劃出 我們 的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別 與 對物的歸屬分別 不共有,若各人的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 互相 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達,也可能經由 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 相互塑造,可能使 81952268-47b1-4d8c-9605-270c42646693.記錄 中有 界線的移動;多個 社會人 有差別的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出,可能在 81952268-47b1-4d8c-9605-270c42646693.記錄 中構成同一條 內外差異,不要求他們共有一個 我們;宣稱界線 與 81952268-47b1-4d8c-9605-270c42646693.記錄 中的 內外差異 可以不一致;81952268-47b1-4d8c-9605-270c42646693.記錄 中的 內外差異,不推出參與者有 二階能力。(從 循環五之三 + 結論五之七 + 結論十之一 + 結論十之二 + 結論十之七 + 結論七之十 + 結論七之十一 + 結論七之十二 + 結論九之一 推出)【正文:句3135586226、句5288665481、句7636753643、句6583361204】\n- 附註:誰作出何種 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別、37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別 如何變動、內外差異 是否有、落在哪裡、出於哪一次 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別,以及模式是否因此延續或 d244789a-9261-4a0d-a98a-feb8db56b511.判準中斷,本篇皆不唯一推出;依賴 結論四之三 的部分,在 前提二 之下成立。【正文:句9372947510、句2527318431】\n\n## 待決項\n\n無\n","paper_files":[{"filename":"邊界的幻覺構件動力學.md","content":"---\nuuid: 08383b0a-1167-4efb-9b89-dc8a71afd5ff\nlast-modified: 2026-11-05T17:01:28\nauthor: 黃正宇 / Cheng Yu Huang\ncontact: mthree.tw@gmail.com\n---\n\n# 邊界的幻覺構件動力學\n\n---\n\n## 〇、定位與方法\n\n### 〇之一 定位\n\n本篇建立在《生物人輸出格局動力學》(以下稱格局論文)之上,問的是:在已經能夠成立的[經濟模式](../paper_d244789a_9261_4a0d_a98a_feb8db56b511/concepts.md#c09)上,生物人對人劃出[我們](concepts.md#c04)、[你們](concepts.md#c05),對物作出[歸屬分別](concepts.md#c07)、把物劃為我的、你的、我們的或你們的時,這些[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)如何經由[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28),可能使[經濟模式](../paper_d244789a_9261_4a0d_a98a_feb8db56b511/concepts.md#c09)在[記錄](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c06)中出現[內外差異](concepts.md#c09);以及說出來、寫下來的分類若被登記,研究者依它劃出的[宣稱界線](concepts.md#c10),與[記錄](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c06)中的[內外差異](concepts.md#c09)如何可以不一致。格局論文處理多個生物人的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)之間的[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)結構,不登記[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18);本篇以[二階能力](concepts.md#c02)、[社會人](concepts.md#c03)、[我們](concepts.md#c04)等[幻覺構件](concepts.md#c01)(〇之五),描述這些[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)如何經由[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28),參與既有[經濟模式](../paper_d244789a_9261_4a0d_a98a_feb8db56b511/concepts.md#c09)後續的運作與相互塑造。\n\n格局論文推出的結論,在本篇照樣成立;本篇只增加,不改動。\n\n### 〇之二 方法\n\n本篇採演繹法,體例同格局論文:每條結論都標明從哪些定義、前提或先前結論推出;文中案例只作校準,不承擔論證。\n\n### 〇之三 記錄範圍\n\n本篇記為:只登記[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)的物理改變,不登記[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)內容。[社會人](concepts.md#c03)的[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)在它的[歷史](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13)中,不在本篇的[記錄](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c06)裡。\n\n**記號約定**:說[記錄](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c06)中有某筆[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28),都指研究者已登記者;說[記錄](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c06)中有某項差異,都指研究者依已登記的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)、在講明的[切法](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c23)下劃出者;說一次[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)成為[歷史](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13)的一部分,指它留下的[寫入](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c29)成為[歷史](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13)的一部分;說[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06)定不出結果,都指不被[鎖死](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c12)時,在[應用假定](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c50)之下;引號內的話語或名稱照原樣寫出,其中的「我們」「你們」等字不加連結,本篇使用這些概念時才加連結。\n\n### 〇之四 主張的範圍\n\n本篇陳述三類東西:結構上必然成立的關係;哪些東西推不出另一些東西;以及[記錄](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c06)中可以登記的東西,例如[宣稱界線](concepts.md#c10)與[內外差異](concepts.md#c09)的落差。前兩類中依賴[幻覺構件](concepts.md#c01)的結論,都在[幻覺構件](concepts.md#c01)之下成立(〇之五說明 6)。本篇不預測誰會把誰劃進[我們](concepts.md#c04)、誰會把哪件物劃為我們的,也不預測[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)或[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)往哪個方向改變。本篇所說的「我們的」,不是所有權、使用權、處置權或排除他人的規則。\n\n### 〇之五 幻覺構件\n\n**[幻覺構件](concepts.md#c01)**:對象不由物理世界給出、卻被用來描述或組織[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)的構件,例如[我們](concepts.md#c04)、丈夫、[二階能力](concepts.md#c02)。\n\n**記號約定**:「物理世界」,本篇作一般用語,不另立為概念。\n\n說明:\n1. **兩種出現方式**:一、研究者用它描述複雜的一階[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28),把大量[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)歸成少數[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18);二、它以名稱、[宣誓](concepts.md#c06)、寫進[信號容器](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c26)的分類等形式出現在[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)中;這筆[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)若[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)他人,便參與他人的[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06),經由[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)可能使之後的[記錄](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c06)出現相應的樣子(結論五之一、五之五、七之十一)。第二種出現方式以分類為內容時,這筆[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)若被登記進[記錄](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c06),便是研究者劃出[宣稱界線](concepts.md#c10)的材料(三之九)。\n2. **不是[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)**:[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)是[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)的動作,在[歷史](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13)中留下[寫入](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c29)([分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)的定義);[幻覺構件](concepts.md#c01)是[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)的內容、研究者的描述或[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)中所用、對象不由物理世界給出的構件。一次[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)可以用到[幻覺構件](concepts.md#c01),也可以不用。劃出[我們](concepts.md#c04)是一次[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18);它用到的[我們](concepts.md#c04),是[幻覺構件](concepts.md#c01)(三之三)。\n3. **與[幻覺](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c14)不同**:[幻覺](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c14)是一個[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19)的處境,只描述它據以行動的是什麼([幻覺](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c14)的定義);[幻覺構件](concepts.md#c01)出現在[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)中時,可能參與之後的[記錄](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c06)。\n4. **不主張存在**:本篇不主張[幻覺構件](concepts.md#c01)的對象存在於任何[呈現](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c04)之中,也不否認。[二階能力](concepts.md#c02)本身也是[幻覺構件](concepts.md#c01):本篇以它簡稱複雜的一階[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28);這與[配置假定](../paper_ae79e938_76e1_4bf9_b2ab_995c03e16c9e/concepts.md#c01)相容(第二節)。\n5. **採用的理由**:不用[幻覺構件](concepts.md#c01),解釋一筆[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)要追溯[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)該生物人的全部[歷史](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13)([渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)的定義);用它,能把大量[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)歸成少數[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)來描述。這種歸法是研究者的一次[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18);對其中[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)研究者的各筆[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)所作的,是[看法歸屬](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c02);都可能歸錯。\n6. **可追溯**:本篇依賴[幻覺構件](concepts.md#c01)的結論,都在[幻覺構件](concepts.md#c01)之下成立;[宣稱界線](concepts.md#c10)、[內外差異](concepts.md#c09),以及兩者落差的登記,只依賴[記錄](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c06)。\n7. **研究者也在其中**:研究者的描述出現在它的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)中時,其中的[幻覺構件](concepts.md#c01)同樣可能[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)他人、參與他人的[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06)(說明 1 第二種)。\n\n校準:「他心裡不把她當老婆」一句,把多年的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)歸成一個[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18),這是第一種出現方式;結婚時說出的「你是我的老婆」與結婚證書,是第二種。(路標:費英格的「彷彿哲學」;哈金所說人類類別的迴圈效應。相遇處:明知不對應實物的概念照樣使用;分類傳到被分類者,會改變被分類者。分開處:本篇不另立虛構與真實的區分,只問構件的對象是否由物理世界給出,以及構件是否出現在[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)中。)\n\n### 〇之六 記號約定\n\n「出現」「涉及」「速度」「一邊」「選出」,「同一」在同一件物、同一邊這類用法,動詞「決定」,以及問句「會不會發生」,本篇作日常用語,不指上游同名的概念。「衝突」在本篇指兩次[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)互不相容,作日常用語,不指熟人篇的[衝突](../paper_ae79e938_76e1_4bf9_b2ab_995c03e16c9e/concepts.md#c10);路標中他人理論的名稱,例如科塞的外部衝突、魯曼的系統與環境,照原文,不指上游概念。\n\n「推不出」在本篇指:從本篇所列的來源與[記錄](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c06),推不出唯一的結果;不主張在任何條件、任何材料之下都推不出。「不唯一推出」同此。\n\n---\n\n## 一、承接\n\n本篇承接渦動力學、工具篇、《三重幻覺與被迫的賭注》(以下稱《三重幻覺》)、格局論文、個體篇、陌生人篇與熟人篇的相關概念。\n\n**前提**:本篇假定,[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)的一次[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)與它的一筆[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28),在下一[時刻](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c09)之前[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)這個[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)自己,參與它之後的[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06)。上游概念中,[盲點牆](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c09)只對以自己為對象的[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)寫明這一點;本篇把它推廣到一切[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)與[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28),作為前提。\n\n---\n\n## 二、範圍\n\n本篇的對象是[社會人](concepts.md#c03)(三之二)。不是[社會人](concepts.md#c03)的生物人,不在本篇的討論範圍;格局論文的結論對它們照樣成立。\n\n本篇把結論用在具體的生物人身上時,對它標[配置假定](../paper_ae79e938_76e1_4bf9_b2ab_995c03e16c9e/concepts.md#c01)。依[配置假定](../paper_ae79e938_76e1_4bf9_b2ab_995c03e16c9e/concepts.md#c01)的定義,從外部確認某個對象某一刻有沒有[二階分別](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c01),[不被保證](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c02);所以本篇的結論用到具體的人時,都在這項假定之下成立。[配置假定](../paper_ae79e938_76e1_4bf9_b2ab_995c03e16c9e/concepts.md#c01)是對講明的階段所作的假定,所以[同一](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c21)個生物人,可以在某段期間是[社會人](concepts.md#c03),在另一段期間不是。\n\n校準:法律以年齡、監護宣告等標記劃分行為能力,是以可[記錄](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c06)的標記,代替不保證能直接確認的能力;本篇對具體的人標[配置假定](../paper_ae79e938_76e1_4bf9_b2ab_995c03e16c9e/concepts.md#c01),是同一種做法。本篇不預設嬰兒、重度失智者在範圍內。\n\n本篇以生物人為對象,不主張其中的機制只見於生物人。依[重切](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c22),其他[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)的群集,例如蟻巢,可能有相應的[內外差異](concepts.md#c09)與[宣稱界線](concepts.md#c10);本篇不處理。\n\n---\n\n## 三、定義\n\n### 三之一 二階能力\n\n**[二階能力](concepts.md#c02)**:同時具有[二階分別](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c01)與[看法歸屬](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c02)。\n\n說明:\n1. 這是本篇的合稱,不主張兩者是同一種能力。依[二階分別](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c01)與[看法歸屬](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c02)的定義,兩者的定義互不以對方為條件。\n2. [二階能力](concepts.md#c02)是能力,不是每一次[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)的條件:具有[二階能力](concepts.md#c02),指能作這兩種[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18),不指每一次都作了([二階分別](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c01)的定義:說一個[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19)有[二階分別](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c01),指它能對自己的任何一次[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)作這樣的[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18))。\n3. **[二階能力](concepts.md#c02)是[幻覺構件](concepts.md#c01)**(〇之五):本篇以它簡稱複雜的一階[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28),不主張任何生物人確實具有它;依[配置假定](../paper_ae79e938_76e1_4bf9_b2ab_995c03e16c9e/concepts.md#c01),從外部確認[不被保證](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c02)(第二節)。\n\n### 三之二 社會人\n\n**[社會人](concepts.md#c03)**:具有[二階能力](concepts.md#c02)的生物人。\n\n說明:[社會人](concepts.md#c03)是[幻覺構件](concepts.md#c01)(〇之五)。稱某生物人為[社會人](concepts.md#c03),是研究者以該生物人為對象的一次[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18),其材料可以包含[看法歸屬](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c02),依[配置假定](../paper_ae79e938_76e1_4bf9_b2ab_995c03e16c9e/concepts.md#c01)(第二節);本篇不據此判定任何生物人不是[社會人](concepts.md#c03)。本篇關於[社會人](concepts.md#c03)的結論,都在這個構件之下成立。[社會人](concepts.md#c03)與[二階網路](../paper_ae79e938_76e1_4bf9_b2ab_995c03e16c9e/concepts.md#c04)的參與者,條件都是同時具有[二階分別](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c01)與[看法歸屬](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c02);差別在於,[二階網路](../paper_ae79e938_76e1_4bf9_b2ab_995c03e16c9e/concepts.md#c04)是這些[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19)及其間的[耦合](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c36)構成的集合,[社會人](concepts.md#c03)指的是單一的生物人。本篇的對象是[社會人](concepts.md#c03),不是[二階網路](../paper_ae79e938_76e1_4bf9_b2ab_995c03e16c9e/concepts.md#c04)。[社會人](concepts.md#c03)具有[二階分別](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c01);依[二階分別](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c01)的定義,有[二階分別](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c01)的是一個[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19);所以[社會人](concepts.md#c03)是一個[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19),也是一個[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)([二階分別](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c01)與[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19)的定義)。\n\n### 三之三 我們\n\n**[我們](concepts.md#c04)**:一個[社會人](concepts.md#c03)運用的[幻覺構件](concepts.md#c01):在某個維度上,把自己和被它歸為「[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19)」的其他[呈現](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c04),當成同一邊的一個單位,用來組織它的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)。\n\n說明:\n1. **依對象定義,不依內容**:[我們](concepts.md#c04)的對象包含自己,這是對象的特徵。依方法,[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)的內容不形式化。對象不含自己的構件([你們](concepts.md#c05)),見三之四。\n2. **單方面**:[我們](concepts.md#c04)屬於運用它的[社會人](concepts.md#c03),不要求被劃進去的也這樣劃。\n3. **維度由劃的人劃出**:同一對人,可以在這個維度上是[我們](concepts.md#c04),在另一個維度上不是。這個維度是[社會人](concepts.md#c03)自己的[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18),不是研究者的維度。\n4. **歸為[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19)可以是對一個類的[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)**:「這類人都是我」,不要求對類中每個成員都作過[看法歸屬](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c02);要求的是有[看法歸屬](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c02)的能力。\n5. **歸為[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19),不保證對方是一個[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19)**:歸為[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19),是把對方當成另一個會作[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)的[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19);依[看法歸屬](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c02)的定義,[看法歸屬](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c02)可能歸錯:被劃為看法的那筆[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28),不一定來自一個[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19)。\n6. **範圍的選擇**:本篇只談[社會人](concepts.md#c03)的[我們](concepts.md#c04)。只具有[一階分別](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c24)的[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19),本篇記為沒有[我們](concepts.md#c04);依[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19)的定義,誰是[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19)由它自己定義,邊界隨自我定義移動。這是本篇的記法,不是推導。\n7. **程度與持續**:每一次劃,只有劃或沒劃;說一個[社會人](concepts.md#c03)「有」某個[我們](concepts.md#c04),以及這個[我們](concepts.md#c04)有多強,是程度上的事,屬於它的[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06),不形式化。依第一節的前提,每一次劃出都[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)自己,參與之後的[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06);[社會人](concepts.md#c03)是一個[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19)(三之二),在不被[鎖死](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c12)時,事先推不出自己下一個[決定](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c06)的結果;所以它關於某個[我們](concepts.md#c04)的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28),是否重複出現,[不被保證](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c02)([未定牆](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c10))。\n8. **未劃進[我們](concepts.md#c04),不等於劃成[你們](concepts.md#c05)**:劃出[我們](concepts.md#c04)的[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)所劃的[邊際](concepts.md#c08),不自動產生一次劃出[你們](concepts.md#c05)的[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18);把[邊際](concepts.md#c08)另一邊的[呈現](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c04)進一步劃為[你們](concepts.md#c05),仍是[社會人](concepts.md#c03)自己的[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)(三之四)。\n9. **劃出與運用**:劃出[我們](concepts.md#c04),是一次用到這個構件的[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)(〇之五說明 2);[我們](concepts.md#c04)的作用,只經由運用它的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)。一個從未在[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)中運用的[我們](concepts.md#c04),和沒有劃出,在[記錄](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c06)中沒有差別;劃出它的[社會人](concepts.md#c03)自己,事後會不會再以它為對象作出[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18),也[不被保證](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c02),可能早已忘了([盲點牆](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c09):沒有任何[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19)能在任何時刻完全[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)自己)。\n\n校準:「我們家」「我們公司」「我們部門」「我們國家」,是同一個人在不同維度上的[我們](concepts.md#c04)。一個人把公司劃為[我們](concepts.md#c04),同事卻只把他當外包;把家裡的狗劃進「我們家」。\n\n校準:老闆心裡打算開除某個員工,從頭到尾沒說出口,也沒有任何動作;這和沒有打算,在[記錄](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c06)中沒有差別,他自己日後也可能忘了。\n\n### 三之四 你們\n\n**[你們](concepts.md#c05)**:一個[社會人](concepts.md#c03)運用的[幻覺構件](concepts.md#c01):在某個維度上,把不含自己、被它歸為「[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19)」的其他[呈現](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c04),當成一個單位,用來組織它的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)。\n\n說明:\n1. **依對象定義**:[你們](concepts.md#c05)的對象不含自己,這是對象的特徵;與[我們](concepts.md#c04)的差別在對象,不在內容。\n2. **單方面**:[你們](concepts.md#c05)屬於運用它的[社會人](concepts.md#c03),不要求被劃進去的自己也這樣劃,也不要求它們劃出任何[我們](concepts.md#c04)。\n3. **範圍的選擇**:同三之三說明 6,本篇記只具有[一階分別](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c24)的[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19)沒有[你們](concepts.md#c05)。\n4. 三之三說明 3、4、5、7、9 同樣適用:維度由劃的人劃出、歸為[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19)可以是對一個類的[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)、歸為[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19)不保證對方是一個[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19)、有程度且會改變、作用只經由運用它的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)。\n\n校準:說「你們大陸人」,被劃進去的人,可能自認是台商、上海人,或什麼都不認。\n\n**記號約定**:「他們」,本篇作日常用語,指多個[你們](concepts.md#c05)合稱的名字;合稱本身也是一次[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)(結論四之十)。\n\n### 三之五 宣誓\n\n**[宣誓](concepts.md#c06)**:一個[社會人](concepts.md#c03)的一筆[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28),以接收者對[宣誓](concepts.md#c06)者自己的[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)為對象:在某個維度上,要接收者把[宣誓](concepts.md#c06)者劃進某一類。\n\n說明:\n1. **依對象定義**:對象只限別人對[宣誓](concepts.md#c06)者本人的[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18);以其他[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)為對象的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28),見結論五之六。\n2. **[宣誓](concepts.md#c06)不是[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)的讀數**:[宣誓](concepts.md#c06)者有沒有這樣劃、劃得多深,不在[記錄](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c06)中;說謊也是[宣誓](concepts.md#c06)。\n3. **[宣誓](concepts.md#c06)只是要求**:接收者照不照著劃,見結論六之五。\n4. **歸為[宣誓](concepts.md#c06),是研究者的[看法歸屬](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c02)**:把[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)研究者的一筆[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)歸為[宣誓](concepts.md#c06),是研究者的[看法歸屬](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c02);[記錄](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c06)中只有這筆[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)的物理改變(結論四之六)。\n5. **不含對物的分類聲明**:「這是我們的」若以對某物的[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)為對象,不因字面上有「我們」就成為本定義的[宣誓](concepts.md#c06);它是關於物的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28),見三之六、結論五之七。\n\n### 三之六 對物的歸屬分別\n\n**[對物的歸屬分別](concepts.md#c07)**:一個[社會人](concepts.md#c03)作出的一次[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18):在某個維度上,以已經[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)它的某物之[呈現](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c04)為材料,把該物劃為「我的」「你的」「我們的」或「你們的」。這四種說法是這次[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)所用的[幻覺構件](concepts.md#c01),作用只經由運用它們的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28),不是物本身具有的權利關係。\n\n說明:\n1. **[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)屬於劃的人**:「我們的」「你們的」用在對物的[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)上,不是對人的[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18);它參照哪個[我們](concepts.md#c04)或[你們](concepts.md#c05),屬於[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)的內容,本篇不形式化(三之三說明 1)。別人即使聽見相同的名稱,也不保證作出相同[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)。\n2. **人與物不同**:把乙劃進[我們](concepts.md#c04),是以自己和被歸為[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19)的[呈現](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c04)為對象,作出劃出[我們](concepts.md#c04)的[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18);把某件物(下稱此物)劃為我們的,是以此物為對象的[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18);兩者依不同的定義界定對象。此物不因被劃為我們的而成為另一個「[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19)」,也不因此進入一個共有主體。\n3. **不要求固定次序**:從字面看,「我們的」似乎預設一個[我們](concepts.md#c04);這個預設是研究者對兩個名稱所作的一次[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)(與結論四之十同型),不是[社會人](concepts.md#c03)的[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18),[社會人](concepts.md#c03)的[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)不受這個次序約束。本篇的定義不要求先劃出[我們](concepts.md#c04)才劃出我們的,也不要求有了[我們](concepts.md#c04)就另作[你們](concepts.md#c05),或四種分類全部出現。[社會人](concepts.md#c03)也可以先對物作出[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18),再以該物為維度劃出[我們](concepts.md#c04)(三之三說明 3)。\n4. **不推出使用或處置**:劃為我們的,不推出誰能用、誰不能用、如何使用、如何分配,也不推出某人能要求他人照著劃。這些均不在本篇的定義之內。\n5. **維度由劃的人劃出**:同一件物可以在不同維度上被同一[社會人](concepts.md#c03)作出不同[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18);各次[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)是否一致,不被定義要求。\n6. **[記錄](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c06)中沒有[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)**:研究者[記錄](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c06)得到「這是我們的」這筆[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28);說話者實際作出了哪一種[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18),由這句話推不出,聽者是否認同也推不出(結論四之六)。\n7. **作用在運用**:「我的」「你的」「我們的」「你們的」是[對物的歸屬分別](concepts.md#c07)所用的[幻覺構件](concepts.md#c01);它們的作用只經由運用它們的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28),例如說「這是我們的」並照著做(三之三說明 9)。\n\n校準:同一批貨,甲劃為「我們的」,乙劃為「你的」;他們都在同一個[經濟模式](../paper_d244789a_9261_4a0d_a98a_feb8db56b511/concepts.md#c09)裡,卻不必有相同的分類。這是對[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)可能不一致的校準,不是對當事人內部[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)的實測。\n\n校準:一個[社會人](concepts.md#c03)先指著此物,再把「他認為能用此物的人」劃為[我們](concepts.md#c04);這個[我們](concepts.md#c04)的維度,是他以此物劃出的。這說的是他認為誰能用,不是誰確實能用,也不使未被劃進去的人有任何[路徑](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c07)不可行(結論七之七)。把自己算進能用的人,劃出的是[我們](concepts.md#c04);不把自己算進去,例如「這間教室是給你們用的」,劃出的是[你們](concepts.md#c05)(三之四)。\n\n### 三之七 分別邊際\n\n**[分別邊際](concepts.md#c08)**:一個[社會人](concepts.md#c03)在某個維度上作出[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18),使對象在它的[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)中落在不同一邊。把某些[呈現](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c04)劃為[我們](concepts.md#c04)、另一些劃為[你們](concepts.md#c05),或把物劃為我們的、你們的,都是[分別邊際](concepts.md#c08)的例子。\n\n說明:\n1. **改變人,經由[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)才改變模式**:[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)改變的是作出它的[社會人](concepts.md#c03);[經濟模式](../paper_d244789a_9261_4a0d_a98a_feb8db56b511/concepts.md#c09)的改變,只經由它的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)(結論五之一)。\n2. **不要求兩邊都有名稱**:劃出[我們](concepts.md#c04)的[邊際](concepts.md#c08),不要求把其餘對象都劃為[你們](concepts.md#c05);某個維度的分類也不要求窮盡所有對象。\n3. **只屬於作出它的[社會人](concepts.md#c03)**:不同[社會人](concepts.md#c03)可以對同一批人、同一件物劃出不同的[邊際](concepts.md#c08)。所謂[經濟模式](../paper_d244789a_9261_4a0d_a98a_feb8db56b511/concepts.md#c09)「出現[分別邊際](concepts.md#c08)」,是指[社會人](concepts.md#c03)得以在該模式已[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)它的材料上另作[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18),不是說[經濟模式](../paper_d244789a_9261_4a0d_a98a_feb8db56b511/concepts.md#c09)取得一個共有的內部[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)。\n4. 本名稱只合稱既有的[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)關係,不另立讓[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)直接改變他人或物的因果機制。對外的作用經由[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)與[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)(第五節)。\n\n### 三之八 內外差異\n\n**[內外差異](concepts.md#c09)**:研究者在[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)[記錄](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c06)中作出的一次[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18):同類的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28),在某組參與者之間,與在該組參與者和組外參與者之間,有所不同。\n\n說明:\n1. **屬於研究者**:哪些[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)算同類、哪些參與者算一組、在哪個維度上比較,由研究者在講明的[切法](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c23)下劃出;換一種[切法](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c23),[內外差異](concepts.md#c09)可以不同。[記錄](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c06)中只有各筆[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)的物理改變(結論四之六)。同七之二說明 3,研究者劃的組,與[社會人](concepts.md#c03)自己劃的[我們](concepts.md#c04),範圍與維度不必一致。\n2. **與[分別邊際](concepts.md#c08)不同**:[分別邊際](concepts.md#c08)在[社會人](concepts.md#c03)的[歷史](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13)中,不在[記錄](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c06)中(三之七);[內外差異](concepts.md#c09)依[記錄](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c06)中的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)劃出,不是被研究的[社會人](concepts.md#c03)的[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)。\n3. **可以落在物上**:同類的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28),以某些物為對象時與以其他物為對象時有所不同,也是[內外差異](concepts.md#c09)。\n4. **不是規則或權利**:[內外差異](concepts.md#c09)只描述[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)的不同,不推出誰有資格、誰被排除,也不是制度(結論七之七、十一之二)。\n\n校準:同一個攤販,對熟客賒帳,對生客現結。研究者[記錄](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c06)到的是兩類[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)不同,不是攤販心裡的熟與生。\n\n### 三之九 宣稱界線\n\n**[宣稱界線](concepts.md#c10)**:研究者在[記錄](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c06)中作出的一次[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18):依一筆以分類為內容的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28),劃出它所提出的界線。這類[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)包括[宣誓](concepts.md#c06)、對人或對物的分類聲明,以及寫進[信號容器](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c26)的分類。\n\n說明:\n1. **屬於研究者**:一筆[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)提出了哪條界線,由研究者依該[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)劃出,並在講明的[切法](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c23)下判定;它不是[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)者[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)的讀數(結論四之六、六之二)。\n2. **與[內外差異](concepts.md#c09)同在[記錄](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c06)中**:[宣稱界線](concepts.md#c10)依以分類為內容的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)劃出;[內外差異](concepts.md#c09)依同類[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)在組內與跨組的不同劃出(三之八)。兩者都依[記錄](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c06)中的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)劃出,不是被研究的[社會人](concepts.md#c03)的[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)。\n3. **寫進[信號容器](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c26)的分類**,例如法條、證書、規章:[信號容器](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c26)此後每一步都被[鎖死](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c12);[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)要改寫它,是另一筆[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)它的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)([信號容器](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c26)、[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)與[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)的定義)。\n\n---\n\n## 四、分別的性質\n\n### 四之一 劃出來的,不是找到的\n\n**結論四之一**:[我們](concepts.md#c04)是劃出來的,不是找到的:沒有一個不經[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)、現成在那裡等著被發現的[我們](concepts.md#c04)。這不否定[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)之前已存在的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)、[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)與[經濟模式](../paper_d244789a_9261_4a0d_a98a_feb8db56b511/concepts.md#c09);它們本身不等於某個[社會人](concepts.md#c03)劃出的[我們](concepts.md#c04)。\n\n(從[我們](concepts.md#c04)的定義與[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)的定義推出:[我們](concepts.md#c04)是經由一次[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)劃出的[幻覺構件](concepts.md#c01);[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)劃出[被看的東西](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c27),不是發現一個不經[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)的對象)\n\n校準:「我們台灣人」不是普查出來的;普查數得出持有某種身分證的人數,數不出誰把誰劃為[我們](concepts.md#c04)。\n\n### 四之二 材料\n\n**結論四之二**:一個[社會人](concepts.md#c03)劃出[我們](concepts.md#c04)的材料,只有已經[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)它的[歷史](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13):包括別人的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28),以及它自己過去的[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)。它對物作出[歸屬分別](concepts.md#c07)的材料,也只能來自這段已經[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)的[歷史](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13)。\n\n(從[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)的定義與第一節的前提推出:[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)的材料只有它之前、已經[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)它的[歷史](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13);它自己過去的[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18),都已[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)它自己,也在這段[歷史](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13)中)\n\n說明:材料分兩類,與[我的建構](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c28)同形。外來的:別人的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28),例如錄取、指派、被叫一聲「我們」。自身的:自己過去劃過的[我們](concepts.md#c04)。別人怎麼劃,只經由別人的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10);[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)的是[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28),若從中讀出什麼,那是自己的[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)([看法歸屬](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c02)的定義)。\n\n校準:被錄取以後,才開始說「我們公司」。\n\n### 四之三 材料推不出分別\n\n**結論四之三**:[記錄](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c06)中相同的材料,不推出相同的[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18):一個[社會人](concepts.md#c03)劃不劃出某個[我們](concepts.md#c04)、怎麼劃,會不會把某件物劃為我的、你的、我們的或你們的、怎麼劃,單憑[記錄](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c06)中的材料推不出(〇之六)。\n\n(從[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)的定義、[記錄](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c06)範圍(〇之三)、[來路牆](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c08)、[黑箱律](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c25)與[應用假定](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c50)推出:[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)留下的[寫入](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c29),內容由到當時為止的完整[歷史](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13)決定;其中它自己過去的[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)不在[記錄](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c06)中(〇之三),它自己的來路也取不全([來路牆](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c08));所以兩個[社會人](concepts.md#c03)即使[記錄](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c06)中的材料相同,完整[歷史](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13)也可能不同。此外,本篇依[應用假定](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c50),假定[社會人](concepts.md#c03)作出[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)的那一刻不被[鎖死](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c12);依[黑箱律](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c25),即使完整[歷史](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13)已知,它的下一時刻也不能事前唯一推出。本篇不主張其中每一項[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)在原則上不可預測;後半在[應用假定](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c50)之下成立)\n\n校準:同一份錄取通知,有人說「我們公司」,有人說「我在這裡上班」。猶大是十二門徒之一,在那個[我們](concepts.md#c04)之中;同在其中、材料再多,也推不出他下一次怎麼劃。(路標:神學上預知與自由之爭。分開處:依[黑箱律](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c25),[宇宙](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c02)之內沒有任何[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)能事前唯一推出一個沒被[鎖死](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c12)的[決定](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c06);[宇宙](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c02)之外的預知,本篇不談。)\n\n### 四之四 對自己\n\n**結論四之四**:一次劃出[我們](concepts.md#c04),[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)作出它的[社會人](concepts.md#c03)自己,參與它之後的[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06);若這次[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)以自己為對象,例如「我是某國人」,它也是[我的建構](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c28)中自身那一類的材料。往哪個方向推,推不出。\n\n(從第一節的前提、[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)與[我的建構](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c28)的定義,以及[知見障](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c35)推出)\n\n說明:對他人,劃出[我們](concepts.md#c04)的[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)與[我們](concepts.md#c04)本身,都只經由[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)起作用,見結論五之二。\n\n校準:一個小孩從小被說「你是某家的人」。假設那時它還不是[社會人](concepts.md#c03),這些話若[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)它,那時只是[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)它的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28),不在本篇範圍內;等它成為[社會人](concepts.md#c03),[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)過它的這些話仍在它的[歷史](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13)裡,是它之後劃出「我們家」的材料(結論四之二)。\n\n### 四之五 大規模的我們\n\n**結論四之五**:劃一個類為[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19),不要求類中每個成員的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)都[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)劃的人;類的分類內容,可以經由[信號容器](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c26)的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)它,例如名稱、證件、課本。\n\n(從[我們](concepts.md#c04)的定義說明 4,[信號容器](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c26)與[耦合](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c36)的定義推出:[信號容器](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c26)的內容可以由[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)寫下,在許多[時刻](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c09)向[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28);同一件事[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)多個[呈現](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c04)時,它們在這次[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)上[耦合](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c36))\n\n校準:(路標:安德森的想像的共同體。相遇處:成員一輩子不會認識彼此,卻覺得同屬一體;印刷品讓這種想像成立。分開處:安德森談的是共同的想像;本篇沒有共同的想像,只有各人的[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18),以及[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)各人的同一批[信號容器](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c26)內容。)\n\n### 四之六 研究者看得到的\n\n**結論四之六**:研究者的[記錄](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c06)中只有[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28),以及[信號容器](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c26)的內容;任何[社會人](concepts.md#c03)的[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)都不在[記錄](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c06)中。研究者說某人有某個[我們](concepts.md#c04),是研究者以該人為對象的一次[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18),其中可以包含[看法歸屬](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c02)(把[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)研究者的某筆[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)劃為該人的[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18))或[印象](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c45)(對該人[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06)的估計)。\n\n(從本篇的[記錄](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c06)範圍(〇之三)與[看法歸屬](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c02)的定義推出:[記錄](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c06)不登記[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)內容;把一筆[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)劃為另一個[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19)的[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18),是[看法歸屬](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c02),可能歸錯)\n\n說明:\n1. 研究者看得到[宣誓](concepts.md#c06)這筆[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28),[記錄](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c06)中沒有它背後的[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)(第六節)。\n2. 研究者本身也可能是[社會人](concepts.md#c03),也有自己的[我們](concepts.md#c04)與[你們](concepts.md#c05)。研究者對他人[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)所作的歸類,同樣在研究者的[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06)下落出,也在[歷史](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13)之中,不是置身[歷史](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13)之外的讀數。\n3. 對物的「我的」「你的」「我們的」「你們的」亦然。看見某人指出「這是我們的」,只看見該筆[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28),沒有讀到它對物的[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)(三之六)。\n\n### 四之七 歷史只累積\n\n**結論四之七**:一個[社會人](concepts.md#c03)與某個[我們](concepts.md#c04)有關的[歷史](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13),只往後追加:一件當時沒有[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)它的事,之後也不會[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)它,之後[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)的只是那件事留下的影響;已經[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)的,也不被抹去。所以新加入者與久居者,即使此刻劃出同一個[我們](concepts.md#c04),參與這次[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)的[歷史](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13)也可能不同:在新加入者加入之前已經[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)久居者的事,若當時沒有[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)新加入者,之後也不會[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)它。[歷史](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13)的長短,不推出它這個[我們](concepts.md#c04)有多強,也不推出[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)的差異。\n\n(從結論四之二、四之四,渦動力學[歷史](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13)的定義、[不可復原律](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c28),以及《三重幻覺》[來路牆](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c08)推出:[歷史](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13)只往後追加;當時沒有[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)的,之後不會[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10);每一次劃出都參與之後的[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06)。[歷史](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13)的長短與這個[我們](concepts.md#c04)有多強,是兩個獨立的維度:長短是[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)了多少,有多強屬於[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06)(三之三說明 7),定義沒有讓前者決定後者)\n\n說明:\n1. 稱久居者的[我們](concepts.md#c04)「深厚」,指這段[歷史](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13)中與該[我們](concepts.md#c04)有關的材料較多,經由[學習](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c04)追加進它的[歷史](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13)(陌生人篇[學習](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c04)的定義);不指它更認同、更忠誠。\n2. 這段材料參與了什麼,當事人自己也[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)不全([損耗律](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c26)、《三重幻覺》[盲點牆](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c09))。\n\n校準:第一天上班的新人與待了三十年的前輩;移民。新移民有時比本地人更熱烈地[宣誓](concepts.md#c06)愛國,說明[歷史](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13)長短推不出一個人的[我們](concepts.md#c04)有多強。\n\n### 四之八 我們與默契互不蘊含\n\n**結論四之八**:被劃進去的[呈現](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c04)若是一個[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19),劃出[我們](concepts.md#c04)可能使劃的人與它之間有更多[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)互相[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10):劃出[我們](concepts.md#c04)的[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)參與劃的人的[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06),可能使它對被劃進去者的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)增加;這些[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)若[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)被劃進去者,且對方的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)也[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)劃的人,便成為[專屬歷史](../paper_ae79e938_76e1_4bf9_b2ab_995c03e16c9e/concepts.md#c05)的材料;[專屬歷史](../paper_ae79e938_76e1_4bf9_b2ab_995c03e16c9e/concepts.md#c05)反覆,可能呈現[默契](../paper_ae79e938_76e1_4bf9_b2ab_995c03e16c9e/concepts.md#c06)。但[默契](../paper_ae79e938_76e1_4bf9_b2ab_995c03e16c9e/concepts.md#c06)不以[我們](concepts.md#c04)為條件,[我們](concepts.md#c04)也不以[默契](../paper_ae79e938_76e1_4bf9_b2ab_995c03e16c9e/concepts.md#c06)為條件。\n\n(從[我們](concepts.md#c04)的定義(三之三)、結論四之二、四之四,[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)、[邊](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c29)與[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)的定義,熟人篇[專屬歷史](../paper_ae79e938_76e1_4bf9_b2ab_995c03e16c9e/concepts.md#c05)與[默契](../paper_ae79e938_76e1_4bf9_b2ab_995c03e16c9e/concepts.md#c06)的定義推出:劃出[我們](concepts.md#c04)的[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)自己、參與[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06),[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06)不同,[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)可能不同;[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)經由[邊](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c29)[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)被劃進去者,才成為[專屬歷史](../paper_ae79e938_76e1_4bf9_b2ab_995c03e16c9e/concepts.md#c05)的材料;[默契](../paper_ae79e938_76e1_4bf9_b2ab_995c03e16c9e/concepts.md#c06)的判準是兩個[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19)之間的[專屬歷史](../paper_ae79e938_76e1_4bf9_b2ab_995c03e16c9e/concepts.md#c05)與行為模式,不要求友善,也不要求任何[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18);[我們](concepts.md#c04)的定義不要求[專屬歷史](../paper_ae79e938_76e1_4bf9_b2ab_995c03e16c9e/concepts.md#c05))\n\n說明:\n1. [默契](../paper_ae79e938_76e1_4bf9_b2ab_995c03e16c9e/concepts.md#c06)在兩個[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19)之間逐維度判定;一個[社會人](concepts.md#c03)與一個被劃為[我們](concepts.md#c04)的類之間,沒有[專屬歷史](../paper_ae79e938_76e1_4bf9_b2ab_995c03e16c9e/concepts.md#c05)。在講明的維度與時窗內,多人之間以[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)為條件、反覆的相容接續,是[共振](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c09)(陌生人篇[共振](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c09)的定義),研究者對它的命名是[文化](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c13)。\n2. 長年的對手之間也可能有[默契](../paper_ae79e938_76e1_4bf9_b2ab_995c03e16c9e/concepts.md#c06);把遠方球員劃成[我們](concepts.md#c04)的球迷,與球員之間,不因此有[專屬歷史](../paper_ae79e938_76e1_4bf9_b2ab_995c03e16c9e/concepts.md#c05)。\n\n校準:前輩與每位同事之間各有一段[默契](../paper_ae79e938_76e1_4bf9_b2ab_995c03e16c9e/concepts.md#c06),前輩與「公司」之間沒有[專屬歷史](../paper_ae79e938_76e1_4bf9_b2ab_995c03e16c9e/concepts.md#c05)。\n\n### 四之九 同時有多個我們\n\n**結論四之九**:一個[社會人](concepts.md#c03)可以在不同維度上,各自劃出不同的[我們](concepts.md#c04);這些[我們](concepts.md#c04)之間可以包含、交疊;劃出它們的各次[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18),也可以衝突。定義不要求它們一致。\n\n(從[我們](concepts.md#c04)的定義與[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)的定義推出:[我們](concepts.md#c04)在某個維度上劃出,維度由劃的人劃出(三之三說明 3);衝突是兩次[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)互不相容)\n\n校準:(路標:齊美爾的社會圈交叉;默頓的角色叢。相遇處:一個人同時屬於好幾個圈子,個人就站在這些圈子的交點上。分開處:他們把圈子當成共有的;本篇沒有共有的圈子,只有各人在各維度上的[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)。)\n\n### 四之十 包含也是分別\n\n**結論四之十**:兩個[我們](concepts.md#c04)之間的包含關係,例如「部門在公司裡面」,不在任何一個[我們](concepts.md#c04)的定義中;把兩者看成包含關係,是這些定義之外的[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18);一個[社會人](concepts.md#c03)可以把部門劃為[我們](concepts.md#c04),而不把公司劃為[我們](concepts.md#c04)。\n\n(從[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)的定義與[我們](concepts.md#c04)的定義推出:包含關係不在任何一個[我們](concepts.md#c04)的定義中;把兩者看成包含關係,是這些定義之外的[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18))\n\n### 四之十一 衝突時推不出誰勝出\n\n**結論四之十一**:一個[社會人](concepts.md#c03)劃出不同維度上各個[我們](concepts.md#c04)的[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18),都參與它的同一個[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06);它的一筆[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28),由整個[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06)落出。所以這筆[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)出於哪一個[我們](concepts.md#c04),推不出。\n\n(從結論四之四、[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)的定義、[自己的那一段](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c17)的定義與[黑箱律](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c25)推出:每一次劃出都參與之後的[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06);[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)的全部[歷史](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13)都參與它的[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06),[自己的那一段](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c17)由依賴決定,不由任何[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)決定,而維度是[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18);[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06)定不出結果)\n\n說明:\n1. 一筆[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28),可能在一個[我們](concepts.md#c04)的維度上被研究者歸為「忠」,在另一個維度上被歸為「叛」;這些都是研究者事後以這筆[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)為對象的一次[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18),其中可以包含[看法歸屬](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c02)(結論四之六)。\n2. 劃出不同[我們](concepts.md#c04)的[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)參與同一個[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06),依[知見障](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c35),推高一個方向,必然壓低其餘方向的總和。研究者統計一個人在這種情形下多半落向哪一邊,得到的是[印象](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c45),不是[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06)的讀數([印象](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c45)的定義:對[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)的一切統計估計,都屬於[印象](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c45))。\n\n校準:加班的晚上,劃出「我們公司」與「我們家」的[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)都在他的[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06)裡,推高一邊,就壓低另一邊;他留下來,旁人說他選了公司,但他留下來的那一刻,劃出兩個[我們](concepts.md#c04)的[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)都在[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06)裡。(路標:拉札斯斐等人的交叉壓力;斯特萊克的認同顯著性。相遇處:多個所屬會把人往不同方向拉。分開處:認同理論以顯著性的高低,說明情境中啟動哪個認同;本篇說哪個[我們](concepts.md#c04)使他這樣做推不出,顯著性的高低若作為統計估計,依[印象](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c45)的定義,屬於[印象](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c45)。)\n\n### 四之十二 同一名稱下的我們\n\n**結論四之十二**:同一個名稱下,例如同一個黨、同一個國家,各成員的[我們](concepts.md#c04)不保證相同;在名稱下再劃出較小的[我們](concepts.md#c04),例如派系,也不被定義排除。\n\n(從結論四之三、[我們](concepts.md#c04)的定義說明 2 推出:[我們](concepts.md#c04)是單方面的;同樣的材料,不推出同樣的[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18))\n\n校準:「黨內無派,千奇百怪」。\n\n### 四之十三 對人的我們與對物的我們的,互不推出\n\n**結論四之十三**:一個[社會人](concepts.md#c03)把乙等[呈現](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c04)劃進[我們](concepts.md#c04),不推出它會把某件物劃為我們的;它把某件物劃為我們的,也不推出它會劃出某個[我們](concepts.md#c04),或被它劃進[我們](concepts.md#c04)的各[呈現](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c04)會同意。對人的[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)與對物的[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18),可以相連,但依不同的定義界定對象,互不蘊含。\n\n(從[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)的定義、[我們](concepts.md#c04)的定義(三之三說明 9)、[對物的歸屬分別](concepts.md#c07)(三之六),以及[分別邊際](concepts.md#c08)(三之七)推出:劃出[我們](concepts.md#c04)的[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)所用的構件,以被歸為[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19)的[呈現](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c04)為對象;[對物的歸屬分別](concepts.md#c07)以物為對象;兩者的定義沒有互相蘊含)\n\n校準:甲把乙劃為[我們](concepts.md#c04),卻把某件物(下稱此物)劃為「你的」;也可能把此物劃為「我們的」,乙卻不把此物這樣劃。\n\n\n---\n\n## 五、劃分改變人,輸出改變模式\n\n### 五之一 劃分改變人,輸出才改變模式\n\n**結論五之一**:一次[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18),改變的是作出它的[社會人](concepts.md#c03):它成為該[社會人](concepts.md#c03)的[歷史](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13),參與其後的[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06)。這次[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)對[經濟模式](../paper_d244789a_9261_4a0d_a98a_feb8db56b511/concepts.md#c09)的改變,只經由該[社會人](concepts.md#c03)的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28);在[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)之前,模式原有的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)、[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)、可行[路徑](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c07)與[存續判準](../paper_d244789a_9261_4a0d_a98a_feb8db56b511/concepts.md#c01),不因這次[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)而在[記錄](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c06)中改變。\n\n(從[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)、[邊](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c29)、[經濟模式](../paper_d244789a_9261_4a0d_a98a_feb8db56b511/concepts.md#c09)、[門檻](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c03)與[可行集合](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c11)的定義,以及結論四之四推出:[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)的內容改變的是看法,不改寫[被看的東西](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c27);一個[節點](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25)只以[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)參與另一個[節點](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25)的[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06);[經濟模式](../paper_d244789a_9261_4a0d_a98a_feb8db56b511/concepts.md#c09)是研究者對[節點](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25)[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)的歸類;每一次劃出都參與之後的[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06))\n\n說明:本結論不說[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)無關緊要。[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)參與[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06);作出它的[社會人](concepts.md#c03)只要仍是[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)、這次[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)仍參與它的[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06),之後的每一筆[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)都從包含它的[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06)落出(結論四之十一,[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)的定義);哪一筆[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)因它而不同、差多少,推不出([黑箱律](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c25))。\n\n校準:老闆在一次[決定](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c06)中已落出開除某個員工,說出口之前,那個員工照樣在這裡上班。\n\n### 五之二 對他人只經由輸出\n\n**結論五之二**:一個[社會人](concepts.md#c03)劃出[我們](concepts.md#c04)的[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18),以及它[對物的歸屬分別](concepts.md#c07),對他人只經由它的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)起作用;它所用的[我們](concepts.md#c04)、「我們的」等[幻覺構件](concepts.md#c01),作用也只經由運用它們的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)。[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)別人的,是它的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28),不是它的[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18);別人若對它作出[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18),那是別人自己的[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)。\n\n(從[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)的定義、[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)的定義、[看法歸屬](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c02)的定義、[我們](concepts.md#c04)的定義(三之三說明 9)與[對物的歸屬分別](concepts.md#c07)(三之六說明 7)推出:[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)的材料只有已經[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)的[歷史](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13);在社會裡交換的是看法,不是[被看的東西](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c27),聽的一方若作出[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18),那是自己對那句話的[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18))\n\n### 五之三 分別可能經由輸出互相塑造\n\n**結論五之三**:設甲、乙是兩個[社會人](concepts.md#c03)。甲的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)若[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)乙,便參與乙之後的[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06),可能改變乙之後的[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18);乙的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)若[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)甲,也可能這樣改變甲的[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)。甲的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)乙之後,乙之後落出的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)若又[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)甲,甲的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)便經由乙,又參與甲自己的[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06),構成一個[迴路](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c31);雙方的[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)可能經由這個[迴路](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c31)互相塑造。[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)是否改變、往哪個方向改變,推不出。任一方的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)不再[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)另一方時,這個[迴路](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c31)就斷了;會不會斷、何時斷,推不出。\n\n(從[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)的定義、[迴路](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c31)與[耦合](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c36)的定義、結論五之二與[知見障](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c35)推出:[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)的[歷史](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13)都參與它的[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06);改變推向哪裡、推多少,推不出)\n\n說明:\n1. 「我認為你認為我是……」是說這句話的一方作出的[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18);其中「你認為」那一層,是它對另一方的[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)的推測,不是另一方實際作出的[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)([分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)的定義)。所以不論疊幾層,都在作出它的那一方自己的[歷史](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13)裡。\n2. 這些層次若是各方先後實際作出的[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18),而不只是一次[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)中的多層表述,就不是同時的堆疊:依[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)的定義,一次[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)不在它自己的材料裡;依第一節的前提,它在下一[時刻](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c09)之前才[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)自己;一方的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)若[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)另一方,另一方以它為材料作出的[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18),材料只有它之前、已經[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)它的[歷史](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13)。所以這種遞迴若一來一回攤在時間上,就是本結論的[迴路](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c31)。往上數一層,沒有新種類的動作,只是同一種動作再套一次;這時每一層都是一次[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)([分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)的定義)。\n3. 依結論五之二,[迴路](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c31)上流動的只有[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28),其中包括[宣誓](concepts.md#c06)(第六節),也可能包括「這是我們的」這種關於物的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28);[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)在各方的[歷史](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13)中,不在[記錄](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c06)裡。\n4. 本結論的[迴路](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c31)是以工具篇的[迴路](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c31)作描述,不另立概念。\n\n校準:兩個新同事,一方先幫了一次忙,另一方回請一頓飯,之後越走越近;也可能一次誤會,之後越走越遠。(路標:唯識的展轉增上。相遇處:《唯識二十論》「展轉增上力,二識成決定」,兩個心互為條件,彼此塑造,誰也不直接碰到誰。分開處:護法主張種子與現行同時互為因;本篇的[迴路](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c31)有延遲,每一次[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)都晚一步[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)自己。)\n\n### 五之四 別人的分別與我的可行集合\n\n**結論五之四**:若乙某條[路徑](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c07)的某項[前件](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c08),只能由甲的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)供應,則這條[路徑](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c07)是否可行,取決於甲的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28);而甲的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)在甲的[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06)下落出,甲若作過相關的[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18),它是參與這個[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06)的[歷史](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13)之一。甲的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)是否因這次[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)而不同、差多少,推不出。\n\n(從[門檻](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c03)、[前件](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c08)與[可行集合](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c11)的定義,結論五之二、四之六,[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)的定義與[黑箱律](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c25)推出:任一[前件](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c08)不具備,[路徑](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c07)不可行;[前件](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c08)只能由甲的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)供應時,是否具備取決於甲的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28))\n\n校準:朋友借不借你錢、肯不肯替你介紹工作,決定你某條路走不走得通;他肯不肯,是他整個人落出來的,他把不把你當自己人,只是其中一部分。(路標:格蘭諾維特的弱連結;韋伯的社會封閉。相遇處:機會經由人際關係分配。分開處:他們把關係當成可以觀察的;本篇的[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)看不到,看得到的只有[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)。)\n\n### 五之五 走得通與會不會走\n\n**結論五之五**:一筆[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)若[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)接收者,對接收者的[路徑](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c07)可以有兩種作用:一、供應或撤除某條[路徑](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c07)的[前件](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c08),使它可行或不可行;二、參與接收者的[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06),使它走不走某條仍然可行的[路徑](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c07)有所不同。第二種作用不改變[路徑](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c07)的[前件](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c08)。一筆[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)可以兩種作用都有,也可以只有其中一種;它有哪一種、作用多大,推不出。\n\n(從[門檻](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c03)、[前件](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c08)、[可行集合](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c11)與[邊](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c29)的定義,結論五之四與[黑箱律](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c25)推出:[可行集合](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c11)回答物理上能不能,不回答會不會發生;[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)參與接收者的[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06);[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06)定不出結果)\n\n說明:\n1. 話語也是[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)([輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)的定義)。若那條[路徑](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c07)在那一輪仍屬[可行集合](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c11),威脅這筆話語又沒有撤除它的[前件](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c08),接收者不走那條路,是它的[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06)落出的結果([門檻](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c03)與[可行集合](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c11)的定義)。\n2. 某條[路徑](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c07)在某一輪是否可行,依[門檻](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c03)判定;把「沒有走」記成「不能走」,混淆了兩種作用。\n\n校準:老闆對員工說「你被開除了」。員工可能不再來上班,這是那句話參與了他的[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06),他的路仍然走得通;也可能公司停了他的門禁卡,他想來也進不去,這是[路徑](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c07)的[前件](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c08)被撤除。\n\n### 五之六 影響別人的分別,照樣是賭\n\n**結論五之六**:一個[社會人](concepts.md#c03)的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28),可能以他人的[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)為對象,例如表態、說服、提出換一種[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18);這類[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)若[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)對方,便參與對方的[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06),但對方的[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)是否因此改變、往哪改變,推不出。在[應用假定](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c50)之下,作出這類[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)的[決定](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c06),照樣是[被迫的賭注](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c11)。研究者把某筆[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)歸為以他人[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)為對象,是研究者的[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18),不是[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)者[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)的讀數。\n\n(從[看法歸屬](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c02)的定義、[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)的定義、[決定](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c06)的定義、[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)與[邊](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c29)的定義、[知見障](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c35)、[黑箱律](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c25)、[應用假定](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c50)與[被迫的賭注](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c11)推出)\n\n### 五之七 對物的分別也經由輸出互相塑造\n\n**結論五之七**:甲以某件物(下稱此物)為對象作出一筆[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28),例如「這是我們的」;若這筆[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)另一個[社會人](concepts.md#c03)乙,它就成為乙之後[歷史](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13)的一部分,參與乙後續對此物的[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)與[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)。乙之後如何劃此物、是否另作相同分類,以及它對此物的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)如何落出,均推不出。乙若再作出[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)並[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)甲或丙,這個過程可以繼續遞迴。\n\n(從[對物的歸屬分別](concepts.md#c07)(三之六)、結論四之二、四之三、五之二、五之三,以及[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)的定義與[知見障](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c35)推出:別人的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)後成為自己的[歷史](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13);它不直接攜帶別人的內部[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18))\n\n說明:\n1. 甲說「這是我們的」,[記錄](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c06)中只有這筆[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28);甲先前是否確實把此物劃為我們的,由它推不出(結論四之六)。\n2. 甲的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)若[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)乙,是乙之後可能作出[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)的材料,不保證乙接受這個分類;即使乙也說「這是我們的」,仍不證明雙方的[我們](concepts.md#c04)或我們的相同。\n3. 本結論不推出對此物的使用、限制使用、處置或分配規則,也不預設此物在甲乙之間已有任何所有權。\n\n校準:甲說此物是我們的;乙聽到後又向丙說此物是我們的。研究者看得到兩次[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28);字面相同推不出甲乙對此物的[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)相同。\n\n\n---\n\n## 六、宣誓\n\n### 六之一 宣誓改變起點\n\n**結論六之一**:一筆[宣誓](concepts.md#c06)[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)一個[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)之後,就在該[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)之後的[歷史](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13)中,參與它之後的[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06);所以接收者只要仍是[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16),之後在這個維度上對[宣誓](concepts.md#c06)者的每一次[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18),都從包含這筆[宣誓](concepts.md#c06)的[歷史](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13)出發。[宣誓](concepts.md#c06)[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)[宣誓](concepts.md#c06)者自己,也是如此。撤回是另一筆[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28);在它[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)之前,前一筆已參與了這段期間的[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06)。\n\n(從[宣誓](concepts.md#c06)的定義、[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)的定義、[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)的定義與第一節的前提推出:[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)的[寫入](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c29)成為[歷史](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13)的一部分,參與之後的[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06);[宣誓](concepts.md#c06)者的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)在下一[時刻](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c09)之前[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)它自己)\n\n校準:入籍[宣誓](concepts.md#c06)之後,即使日後放棄國籍,「曾經[宣誓](concepts.md#c06)入籍」這件事仍在本人與他人的[歷史](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13)中。\n\n### 六之二 宣誓與分別可以不一致\n\n**結論六之二**:一筆[宣誓](concepts.md#c06),不推出[宣誓](concepts.md#c06)者在這個維度上劃出了它所要求的那一類;[宣誓](concepts.md#c06)者確實這樣劃時,也不推出劃得多深。\n\n(從[宣誓](concepts.md#c06)的定義說明 2、結論四之六,[看法歸屬](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c02)的定義推出:[記錄](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c06)中只有[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28);[看法歸屬](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c02)可能歸錯)\n\n校準:(路標:高夫曼的自我呈現。相遇處:人在他人面前呈現自己,呈現和「後台」可以不同。分開處:高夫曼假定有一個後台可以對照;本篇的[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)連[宣誓](concepts.md#c06)者自己也讀不全([盲點牆](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c09)),沒有一個可以拿來對照的後台。)\n\n### 六之三 宣誓回到自己\n\n**結論六之三**:一筆[宣誓](concepts.md#c06)[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)[宣誓](concepts.md#c06)者自己,是它之後劃出[我們](concepts.md#c04)的材料之一;若[宣誓](concepts.md#c06)以自己為對象,例如「我是某國人」,它也是[我的建構](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c28)的材料。往哪個方向推,推不出。\n\n(從結論四之二、四之四、六之一,[我的建構](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c28)的定義與[知見障](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c35)推出)\n\n校準:說了很多次「我們公司」的人,可能越來越這樣覺得,也可能越說越心虛。\n\n### 六之四 宣誓經由信號容器到達後來的人\n\n**結論六之四**:一筆[宣誓](concepts.md#c06)放進[信號容器](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c26)後,可以在[宣誓](concepts.md#c06)者不在場、甚至[退場](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c43)之後,[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)後來的接收者。\n\n(從[信號容器](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c26)的定義推出:[信號容器](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c26)的內容可以由[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)寫下,在許多[時刻](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c09)向[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28))\n\n校準:誓詞、簽名、身分證、族譜。\n\n### 六之五 照不照著劃,推不出\n\n**結論六之五**:一筆[宣誓](concepts.md#c06)若[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)一個[社會人](concepts.md#c03),這個[社會人](concepts.md#c03)是否照著[宣誓](concepts.md#c06)所要求的那一類劃出[宣誓](concepts.md#c06)者,推不出。\n\n(從結論四之三、[知見障](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c35)與[黑箱律](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c25)推出)\n\n說明:[宣誓](concepts.md#c06)是[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28),若[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)接收者,而接收者是[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16),便參與其[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06)(結論六之一),可能使接收者不走某條[路徑](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c07);它也可能供應或撤除某條[路徑](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c07)的[前件](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c08);有哪一種作用,推不出(結論五之五)。使不照著劃的一方某條[路徑](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c07)不可行,屬於他人把[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)強加於人,留待後續(第十一節)。\n\n校準:(路標:奧斯汀的言語行為。相遇處:話語本身就在做事。分開處:奧斯汀把聽者的領會當成言語行為成立的條件之一;本篇說[宣誓](concepts.md#c06)一旦[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)就改變起點,領會與否推不出,也不影響這一點。)\n\n---\n\n## 七、經濟模式與內外差異\n\n### 七之一 經濟模式不需要二階能力\n\n**結論七之一**:[經濟模式](../paper_d244789a_9261_4a0d_a98a_feb8db56b511/concepts.md#c09)不以參與者有[二階能力](concepts.md#c02)為條件;因此不以參與者劃出[我們](concepts.md#c04)、[你們](concepts.md#c05)或[對物的歸屬分別](concepts.md#c07)為成立條件。\n\n(從格局論文[經濟模式](../paper_d244789a_9261_4a0d_a98a_feb8db56b511/concepts.md#c09)的定義推出:定義中沒有以[二階分別](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c01)、[看法歸屬](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c02)或上述分類為條件)\n\n說明:所以格局論文的[經濟模式](../paper_d244789a_9261_4a0d_a98a_feb8db56b511/concepts.md#c09)、陌生人篇的[共振](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c09)、熟人篇的[默契](../paper_ae79e938_76e1_4bf9_b2ab_995c03e16c9e/concepts.md#c06),都不以[社會人](concepts.md#c03)為條件;本篇不改動它們。這不表示已有[二階能力](concepts.md#c02)的參與者一定不作[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18),只表示[經濟模式](../paper_d244789a_9261_4a0d_a98a_feb8db56b511/concepts.md#c09)本身不以這些[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)為必要[前件](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c08)。\n\n校準:老鼠群、蟻群的分工,免疫細胞的協調。\n\n### 七之二 分別以已到達的模式輸出為材料\n\n**結論七之二**:[社會人](concepts.md#c03)以某個既有[經濟模式](../paper_d244789a_9261_4a0d_a98a_feb8db56b511/concepts.md#c09)中的人或物為對象作出[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)時,材料只能是已經[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)它的[歷史](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13):其中可以有該模式中已[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)它的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28),也可以有模式以外[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)它的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28);[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)不會先於它所依賴的材料[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)。\n\n(從[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)的定義、結論四之二、[對物的歸屬分別](concepts.md#c07)(三之六)推出:[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)不能取得尚未[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)的[歷史](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13))\n\n說明:\n1. 本篇所說「二階改造」,指[社會人](concepts.md#c03)對既有模式的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)另作[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18),以及這些[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)參與後續[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06),並可能經由[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)(若[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)他人並繞回)進入新的[迴路](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c31)。它是對這段過程的描述,不另立讓[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)直接改動物理結構的新機制;[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)改變作出它的[社會人](concepts.md#c03),模式的改變經由它的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)(結論五之一)。\n2. 「先有[經濟模式](../paper_d244789a_9261_4a0d_a98a_feb8db56b511/concepts.md#c09),後有改造」說的是在本篇所分析的這一次改造中,已有模式的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)先成為材料;不是主張所有[經濟模式](../paper_d244789a_9261_4a0d_a98a_feb8db56b511/concepts.md#c09)在時間上都早於所有[社會人](concepts.md#c03)的[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)。\n3. [經濟模式](../paper_d244789a_9261_4a0d_a98a_feb8db56b511/concepts.md#c09)是研究者的[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18);[社會人](concepts.md#c03)所劃的,是它自己的[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18),二者的範圍與維度不必一致。\n\n### 七之三 改造增加的人與物兩種邊際\n\n**結論七之三**:[社會人](concepts.md#c03)以[經濟模式](../paper_d244789a_9261_4a0d_a98a_feb8db56b511/concepts.md#c09)中已[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)的材料為對象,可以另作[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18):\n1. 把已[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)它的既有做法劃為一種做法,並把自己原先對這種做法的[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18),劃為看法、而非不經[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)的必然安排;\n2. 對其中已[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)它的參與者,劃出[我們](concepts.md#c04)、[你們](concepts.md#c05)等對人的[分別邊際](concepts.md#c08);\n3. 對其中已[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)它的物之[呈現](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c04),劃出我的、你的、我們的、你們的等對物的[分別邊際](concepts.md#c08)。\n\n這三種均是可能性,不保證有[二階能力](concepts.md#c02)便會發生,也不要求三者依序發生。劃出對人的[我們](concepts.md#c04),不必然帶出把物劃為我們的(結論四之十三)。\n\n(從[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)的定義、結論七之二、[二階分別](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c01)與[看法歸屬](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c02)的定義、[我們](concepts.md#c04)與[你們](concepts.md#c05)的定義(三之三、三之四)、[對物的歸屬分別](concepts.md#c07)(三之六)、[分別邊際](concepts.md#c08)(三之七)推出:界線本身可以被[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18);對象及[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)仍由各[社會人](concepts.md#c03)自己落出)\n\n校準:空地上的攤販反覆擺攤,研究者按[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)關係記成夜市;某攤販後來說「我們這條街」,又指著某批貨說「這是我們的」。說話是可[記錄](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c06)的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28);是否確有相應的內部[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18),不在[記錄](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c06)中。\n\n### 七之四 改造照樣是賭\n\n**結論七之四**:二階改造的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)若[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)其他參與者,而該參與者是[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16),便參與它的[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06);它之後的[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)(若它是[社會人](concepts.md#c03))與[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)是否因此改變、往哪改變,推不出。改造之後,原有的[經濟模式](../paper_d244789a_9261_4a0d_a98a_feb8db56b511/concepts.md#c09)可能延續,也可能[判準中斷](../paper_d244789a_9261_4a0d_a98a_feb8db56b511/concepts.md#c10);不保證更有利於延續。\n\n(從[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)的定義、結論五之三、五之七、[知見障](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c35)、[黑箱律](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c25),以及[學習](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c04)的定義推出:[學習](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c04)沒有預設方向;改變不保證更有利於模式延續)\n\n校準:有人說某批貨是我們的,另有人照樣搬貨、有人另作表態;研究者[記錄](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c06)得到後續[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28);每個人的[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18),由這些[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)推不出。\n\n### 七之五 我們不一定建在經濟模式上\n\n**結論七之五**:劃出[我們](concepts.md#c04),不要求劃的人與被劃進去的[呈現](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c04)同在一個[經濟模式](../paper_d244789a_9261_4a0d_a98a_feb8db56b511/concepts.md#c09)中。\n\n(從[我們](concepts.md#c04)的定義、[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)的定義與結論四之二推出:劃出[我們](concepts.md#c04)的材料只有已經[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)的[歷史](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13),定義不以雙方同在一個[經濟模式](../paper_d244789a_9261_4a0d_a98a_feb8db56b511/concepts.md#c09)為條件)\n\n說明:所以本節討論的是「[經濟模式](../paper_d244789a_9261_4a0d_a98a_feb8db56b511/concepts.md#c09)上的[分別邊際](concepts.md#c08)」,不是宣稱所有劃出[我們](concepts.md#c04)的[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)或所有對物的[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)都由[經濟模式](../paper_d244789a_9261_4a0d_a98a_feb8db56b511/concepts.md#c09)產生。\n\n校準:球迷把遠方球隊的成員劃成「[我們](concepts.md#c04)」,不要求彼此共同參與一個特定[經濟模式](../paper_d244789a_9261_4a0d_a98a_feb8db56b511/concepts.md#c09)。\n\n### 七之六 經濟模式出現分別邊際\n\n**結論七之六**:若[社會人](concepts.md#c03)以某[經濟模式](../paper_d244789a_9261_4a0d_a98a_feb8db56b511/concepts.md#c09)中已[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)它的人或物為材料,劃出[我們](concepts.md#c04)、[你們](concepts.md#c05)或[對物的歸屬分別](concepts.md#c07),則該[經濟模式](../paper_d244789a_9261_4a0d_a98a_feb8db56b511/concepts.md#c09)對這個[社會人](concepts.md#c03)出現了[分別邊際](concepts.md#c08)。這條[邊際](concepts.md#c08)由它自己劃出,不是原有[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)與[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)結構自帶的分類,也不是其他參與者共有的邊界。\n\n(從[分別邊際](concepts.md#c08)的定義(三之七)、結論七之一、七之二與七之三推出:[經濟模式](../paper_d244789a_9261_4a0d_a98a_feb8db56b511/concepts.md#c09)可不依此類分類而成立,分類卻能在模式已[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)的材料上另行作出)\n\n說明:\n1. 所謂「出現」,只指在該[社會人](concepts.md#c03)的[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)中出現;[經濟模式](../paper_d244789a_9261_4a0d_a98a_feb8db56b511/concepts.md#c09)要出現內外之分,經由它的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)(結論五之一)。\n2. 對人的[邊際](concepts.md#c08)與對物的[邊際](concepts.md#c08)可以交疊、衝突或各自出現;沒有一條先驗的、全部參與者共有的[邊際](concepts.md#c08)。\n3. [分別邊際](concepts.md#c08)在[社會人](concepts.md#c03)的[歷史](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13)中,不在[記錄](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c06)中;它對他人的作用仍經由[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)(結論五之二)。\n\n### 七之七 分別邊際不推出使用或排除\n\n**結論七之七**:一個[社會人](concepts.md#c03)把某件物(下稱此物)劃為我們的,不推出它自己、被它劃為[我們](concepts.md#c04)的人、被它劃為[你們](concepts.md#c05)的人,對此物有任何特定使用、取用、處置或排除關係;也不推出其他[社會人](concepts.md#c03)照著它的分類劃此物。\n\n(從[對物的歸屬分別](concepts.md#c07)(三之六)說明 1、4,結論四之三、四之十三、五之二與六之五推出:一次[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)既非權利的定義,也不直接[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)其他人的[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18))\n\n校準:甲說此物是我們的;乙仍使用此物,丙也使用此物。使用的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)[記錄](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c06)得到;誰有資格使用,從甲的[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)推不出;乙、丙的[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18),由他們的使用也推不出。\n\n### 七之八 分別經由輸出參與模式的後續運作\n\n**結論七之八**:[社會人](concepts.md#c03)在人與物上作出的[分別邊際](concepts.md#c08),作為它自己[歷史](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13)的一部分,參與它之後的[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06);它落出的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)若[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)其他參與者,而該參與者是[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16),便參與它之後的[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06);它若是[社會人](concepts.md#c03),這筆[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)也可能成為它再作[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)與[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)的材料。這使原本不以[我們](concepts.md#c04)或我們的為條件的[經濟模式](../paper_d244789a_9261_4a0d_a98a_feb8db56b511/concepts.md#c09),可以納入由[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)經由[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)形成的反覆[迴路](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c31)。具體[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)是否因某次[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)而不同、往哪不同,均推不出。\n\n(從結論四之四、五之二、五之三、五之七、七之一、七之六,以及[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)的定義、[知見障](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c35)與[黑箱律](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c25)推出:[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)自己並參與自己的[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06);對其他人只有[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)能[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10);事前及事後均不能把整筆[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)唯一歸於某次[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18))\n\n說明:\n1. 本結論的「參與運作」,不是說某次[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)必然造成可觀測的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)改變;同樣的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)也可能在不同[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)下落出。\n2. 研究者看到甲、乙都說「這是我們的」,只看見兩筆[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28);推不回他們已經共有一個[我們](concepts.md#c04),或對同一物有同一[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)。\n3. [經濟模式](../paper_d244789a_9261_4a0d_a98a_feb8db56b511/concepts.md#c09)可以繼續依原判準延續;本篇增加的是對其後續[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)之材料來源的描述,不取代格局論文的判定。\n\n校準:甲說「這批貨是我們的」,乙聽到後可能再向丙說同樣的話,也可能不說。無論如何,甲的話一旦[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)乙,就成為乙往後[歷史](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13)的一部分;[記錄](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c06)中只有傳播的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28),不含各人的「我們的」是否一致(〇之三)。\n\n### 七之九 分別邊際可能使模式出現內外差異\n\n**結論七之九**:[社會人](concepts.md#c03)的[分別邊際](concepts.md#c08)參與它的[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06);它對被它劃在不同一邊的人或物落出的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28),可能不同。這些[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)若[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)其他參與者,可能使它們某些[路徑](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c07)可行或不可行(結論五之四);[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)的參與者若是[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16),這些[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)也參與它的[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06),可能使它不走某些仍然可行的[路徑](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c07)(結論五之五)。因此,[分別邊際](concepts.md#c08)經由[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28),可能使[經濟模式](../paper_d244789a_9261_4a0d_a98a_feb8db56b511/concepts.md#c09)在[記錄](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c06)中出現[內外差異](concepts.md#c09)。[內外差異](concepts.md#c09)是否出現、落在哪裡、某項差異出於哪一次[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18),推不出。\n\n(從[分別邊際](concepts.md#c08)(三之七)、[內外差異](concepts.md#c09)(三之八)的定義,結論五之二、五之四、七之八,以及[黑箱律](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c25)推出:[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)參與[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06);對他人只有[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)能[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10);[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)可以決定別人某條[路徑](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c07)的[前件](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c08);[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06)定不出結果)\n\n說明:\n1. [分別邊際](concepts.md#c08)改變的是作出它的[社會人](concepts.md#c03);改變模式的,是經由它的[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06)落出的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)(結論五之一)。\n2. 本結論不說某次[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)必然帶出[內外差異](concepts.md#c09),也不說[內外差異](concepts.md#c09)會延續;同一個[社會人](concepts.md#c03)對兩邊的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28),也可能相同。\n\n校準:員工招聘時優先介紹「我們學校」的學弟妹;研究者[記錄](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c06)到的是錄用[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)在校友與非校友之間不同。\n\n### 七之十 多人的內外差異,不需要共有的我們\n\n**結論七之十**:多個[社會人](concepts.md#c03)各自的[分別邊際](concepts.md#c08),經由各自的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28),可能使[記錄](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c06)中出現同一條[內外差異](concepts.md#c09):研究者在多人的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)中,看到同類的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)在同一組參與者之內與跨出該組時有所不同。這條[內外差異](concepts.md#c09)不要求這些[社會人](concepts.md#c03)共有一個[我們](concepts.md#c04),也不要求他們的[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)一致;它依[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)判定。各人的[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)變動,與[記錄](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c06)中[內外差異](concepts.md#c09)的移動,不必同步:[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)變了,[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)可能未變;[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)變了,也不推出[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)已變。\n\n(從[內外差異](concepts.md#c09)的定義(三之八),[我們](concepts.md#c04)的定義(三之三說明 2),結論四之六、七之八、七之九推出:每個[社會人](concepts.md#c03)的[分別邊際](concepts.md#c08)經由自己的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)參與模式;[我們](concepts.md#c04)只屬於運用它的[社會人](concepts.md#c03);同樣的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)可以在不同[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)下落出;[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)不在[記錄](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c06)中)\n\n說明:\n1. 說多個[社會人](concepts.md#c03)「都把某人劃在裡面」,是研究者以這些[社會人](concepts.md#c03)為對象的一次[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18),其中可以包含對各人[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)的[看法歸屬](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c02);[記錄](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c06)中只有他們的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)(結論四之六)。\n2. 「加入」與「離開」有兩種意思:某個[社會人](concepts.md#c03)把某個[呈現](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c04)劃進或劃出,屬於該[社會人](concepts.md#c03)的[歷史](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13)(三之七);[記錄](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c06)中[內外差異的移動](concepts.md#c11),屬於研究者的[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)(三之八)。兩者可以錯開。\n\n校準:同住一個屋簷下的室友,家人不把他算在「我們家」;在外地工作多年的兒子,仍被算在裡面。戶口名簿上的名字是[信號容器](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c26)的內容(結論四之五),不是「我們家」本身。新媳婦在吃住上已和家人一樣,公婆心裡還沒把她劃進去;離婚的父親心裡仍把孩子劃在「我們家」,對孩子的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)已經不同。\n\n### 七之十一 宣稱界線與內外差異可以不一致\n\n**結論七之十一**:若以分類為內容的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)接收者,且[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)者與其他[社會人](concepts.md#c03)之後的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)也陸續[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10),[記錄](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c06)中若有[內外差異](concepts.md#c09),它依研究者登記、並在講明的[切法](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c23)下歸為同類的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)劃出;這些之後的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)若被登記並歸入同類,也可以在其中;它不單依[宣稱界線](concepts.md#c10)劃出。之後的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)與[宣稱界線](concepts.md#c10)不相容時,兩者在[記錄](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c06)中可以不一致。兩者的落差可以登記;落差事先會有多大、為何如此,推不出。\n\n(從[宣稱界線](concepts.md#c10)(三之九)、[內外差異](concepts.md#c09)(三之八)、[記錄](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c06)、[印象](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c45)與[強制](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c11)的定義,結論五之五、六之五、七之九與七之十推出:別人對一個[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19)的[印象](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c45),材料包括它過去的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)([印象](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c45)的定義);寫進[信號容器](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c26)的規則不保證被遵守;[內外差異](concepts.md#c09)依[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)判定;照不照著劃推不出)\n\n說明:\n1. 接收者若是[社會人](concepts.md#c03),那筆以分類為內容的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28),是它之後作[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)的材料之一(結論四之二):它可以拿之後[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)與它對照。對照的結果推不出。\n2. [宣稱界線](concepts.md#c10)與[內外差異](concepts.md#c09),都是研究者依[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)劃出的[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18):前者依一筆以分類為內容的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28),後者依同類的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28),後者可以包含前者那一筆(三之八、三之九);[內外差異](concepts.md#c09)也不是任何被研究的[社會人](concepts.md#c03)的[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)(三之八說明 2)。\n3. 本結論不說[宣稱界線](concepts.md#c10)所依的那筆[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)無作用:這筆[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)若[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)接收者,而接收者是[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16),便參與其[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06)(結論五之五)。\n4. 落差相對於研究者講明的[切法](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c23)與維度(三之八說明 1、三之九說明 1);換一種[切法](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c23),落差可以不同。\n\n校準:[宣誓](concepts.md#c06)結婚卻不像丈夫,旁人不把他當丈夫,結婚證書上仍寫著他是丈夫;明文禁菸的地方照樣有人抽菸;公司規定不准兼職,人人都在兼職;路上的速限是一個數字,車流的實際速度是另一個。(路標:名實之辯;湯瑪斯定理與默頓的自我實現預言。相遇處:說出來的分類與實際的後果可以分開看。分開處:正名之說要求名實相符,本篇只登記落差,不要求相符;湯瑪斯定理說定義為真則後果為真,本篇說後果在[記錄](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c06)中與宣稱相符,也不使宣稱成為[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)的讀數。)\n\n### 七之十二 內外差異與宣稱界線不推出二階分別\n\n**結論七之十二**:研究者在[記錄](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c06)中登記到[內外差異](concepts.md#c09)或[宣稱界線](concepts.md#c10),不推出參與者有[二階能力](concepts.md#c02),也不推出該差異或界線出於某次[分別邊際](concepts.md#c08)。\n\n(從[幻覺構件](concepts.md#c01)(〇之五)、[宣稱界線](concepts.md#c10)(三之九)的定義,結論七之一、四之六、七之八推出:[二階能力](concepts.md#c02)是[幻覺構件](concepts.md#c01);[宣稱界線](concepts.md#c10)依[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)劃出;[經濟模式](../paper_d244789a_9261_4a0d_a98a_feb8db56b511/concepts.md#c09)不以[二階能力](concepts.md#c02)為條件;[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)不在[記錄](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c06)中;整筆[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)不能唯一歸於某次[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18))\n\n校準:螞蟻辨識巢伴、攻擊外巢[個體](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c20);黑猩猩群的領域巡邏。(路標:摩根準則;波維內利、勒茲所說的「邏輯問題」。相遇處:從行為不能分辨[二階能力](concepts.md#c02)與複雜的一階行為。分開處:他們問如何從行為判定能力;本篇的[記錄](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c06)範圍本來就不登記[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18),所以不作判定。)\n\n---\n\n## 八、我們與外界\n\n### 八之一 兩層並存\n\n**結論八之一**:被一個[社會人](concepts.md#c03)劃進[我們](concepts.md#c04)的其他[呈現](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c04)(不含它自己),若是[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)這個[社會人](concepts.md#c03)的來源,仍是它的[外界](../paper_d244789a_9261_4a0d_a98a_feb8db56b511/concepts.md#c04)。\n\n(從格局論文[外界](../paper_d244789a_9261_4a0d_a98a_feb8db56b511/concepts.md#c04)的定義、[我們](concepts.md#c04)的定義,與[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)的定義推出:[外界](../paper_d244789a_9261_4a0d_a98a_feb8db56b511/concepts.md#c04)是自己以外的一切[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)來源;[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)改變的是看法,不改寫[被看的東西](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c27))\n\n說明:\n1. [外界](../paper_d244789a_9261_4a0d_a98a_feb8db56b511/concepts.md#c04)是結構上的,由[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)來源決定,研究者的[記錄](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c06)可能登記其中一部分;劃出[我們](concepts.md#c04)的[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18),不在[記錄](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c06)中(結論四之六)。兩層並存,後者不取代前者。\n2. 劃出[我們](concepts.md#c04),不劃分[外界](../paper_d244789a_9261_4a0d_a98a_feb8db56b511/concepts.md#c04)的全部:[外界](../paper_d244789a_9261_4a0d_a98a_feb8db56b511/concepts.md#c04)中未被劃進[我們](concepts.md#c04)的部分,仍照格局論文作為[外界](../paper_d244789a_9261_4a0d_a98a_feb8db56b511/concepts.md#c04);[社會人](concepts.md#c03)怎麼劃其餘部分,屬於內容,本篇不形式化(三之三說明 1)。\n\n校準:家人也是[外界](../paper_d244789a_9261_4a0d_a98a_feb8db56b511/concepts.md#c04):家人的話要傳到你身上,才算[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)你。\n\n### 八之二 跨過界線,不合成新的我\n\n**結論八之二**:劃出[我們](concepts.md#c04)的[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18),把自己和其他[呈現](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c04)劃在同一邊;但這不推出存在一個由它們合成的[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19)。\n\n(從[我們](concepts.md#c04)的定義、[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)的定義、[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19)的定義,與[重切](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c22)的定義推出:幾個[呈現](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c04)[重切](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c22)為一個[呈現](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c04),若它是[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)、且以[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)把自己劃為[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19),它才是一個[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19);劃出[我們](concepts.md#c04)是一個[社會人](concepts.md#c03)的[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18),不是那個整體對自己的[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18))\n\n說明:這和[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19)的邊界移動不同。依[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19)的定義,誰是[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19)由它自己定義;自我定義不同,[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19)的邊界也不同;被自我定義納入的,是這個[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19)的一部分。[我們](concepts.md#c04)則相反:被劃進去的,仍被歸為另一個[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19)。前者是[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19)變大,後者是[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19)不變、旁邊多了被歸為[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19)的其他[呈現](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c04)。\n\n校準:(路標:魯曼的系統與環境。相遇處:界線由劃出它的一方劃出,界線內外互為環境。分開處:魯曼的系統自己劃出自己的界線;本篇沒有群體在劃界,劃界的永遠是一個個[社會人](concepts.md#c03)。)\n\n### 八之三 劃為我們,不是一次到達\n\n**結論八之三**:劃出[我們](concepts.md#c04),[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)的是劃的人自己(結論四之四),不使被劃進去者的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)劃的人:被劃進去的[呈現](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c04),它的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)是否[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)劃的人,仍取決於該[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)與[外界](../paper_d244789a_9261_4a0d_a98a_feb8db56b511/concepts.md#c04)。\n\n(從結論四之四、[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)與[寫入](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c29)的定義推出:[寫入](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c29)作為[刺激](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c30)落到[呈現](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c04)上才算[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10);[寫入](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c29)的內容由到當時為止的[歷史](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13)決定,這段[歷史](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13)包括[外界](../paper_d244789a_9261_4a0d_a98a_feb8db56b511/concepts.md#c04)的[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10),不由這次[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)單獨決定)\n\n校準:颱風封港時,城裡的人把漁村的親戚當成[我們](concepts.md#c04)家,漁獲照樣送不進來。\n\n### 八之四 對物的分別不改寫物的到達\n\n**結論八之四**:[社會人](concepts.md#c03)把某件物(下稱此物)劃為我的、你的、我們的或你們的,不使此物的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)或與此物有關的物理變化因此直接[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)任何人;是否[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10),仍依[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)的定義判定。至於[社會人](concepts.md#c03)因而對此物作出什麼[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28),不由這次[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)唯一決定。\n\n(從[對物的歸屬分別](concepts.md#c07)(三之六)、[分別邊際](concepts.md#c08)(三之七)、[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)的定義、結論五之二與八之三,以及[應用假定](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c50)與[黑箱律](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c25)推出)\n\n\n---\n\n## 九、界線的移動\n\n### 九之一 界線的移動\n\n**結論九之一**:以分類為內容的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)與其他[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28),若[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)他人,而他人是[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16),便參與其[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06);他人落出的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28),可能又[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)原來的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)者與第三者(結論五之三、五之七、六之三)。這種遞迴,可能使[記錄](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c06)中的[內外差異](concepts.md#c09)或[宣稱界線](concepts.md#c10),在不同[檢查窗口](../paper_d244789a_9261_4a0d_a98a_feb8db56b511/concepts.md#c03)之間有所不同;研究者把這種不同記為[界線的移動](concepts.md#c11)。[界線的移動](concepts.md#c11)在[記錄](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c06)中的結構可以依[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)描述,例如:兩邊的差別[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)互相強化;多人的差別[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)由相容轉為不相容,[內外差異](concepts.md#c09)變淡;某個參與者所受的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28),由一邊的樣子轉為另一邊的樣子;[宣稱界線](concepts.md#c10)與[內外差異](concepts.md#c09)之間的距離拉長或縮短。在講明的維度上,這些結構可以用[趨同](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c37)、[趨異](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c38)、[持平](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c52)、[太極](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c39)與[合流](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c41)描述。是否出現[界線的移動](concepts.md#c11)、往哪個方向、何時出現,推不出。\n\n(從[迴路](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c31)、[耦合](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c36)、[趨同](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c37)、[趨異](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c38)、[持平](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c52)、[太極](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c39)、[合流](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c41)與[檢查窗口](../paper_d244789a_9261_4a0d_a98a_feb8db56b511/concepts.md#c03)的定義,[內外差異](concepts.md#c09)(三之八)、[宣稱界線](concepts.md#c10)(三之九)的定義,結論五之三、五之七、六之三、七之十與[黑箱律](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c25)推出:[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)若經由[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)繞回,便構成[迴路](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c31);[迴路](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c31)的走向依[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)判定;[內外差異](concepts.md#c09)與[宣稱界線](concepts.md#c10)都依[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)劃出;[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06)定不出結果)\n\n說明:\n1. [界線的移動](concepts.md#c11)是研究者比較兩個[檢查窗口](../paper_d244789a_9261_4a0d_a98a_feb8db56b511/concepts.md#c03)所作的[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18);同一段[記錄](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c06)換一種[切法](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c23),可以記為移動,也可以記為不動(三之八說明 1)。\n2. 本結論只描述[界線的移動](concepts.md#c11)在[記錄](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c06)中的結構,不預測方向。極化若使[記錄](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c06)中的[內外差異](concepts.md#c09)或[宣稱界線](concepts.md#c10)在[檢查窗口](../paper_d244789a_9261_4a0d_a98a_feb8db56b511/concepts.md#c03)之間有所不同,研究者可記為其中一種(見結論九之四)。\n3. [分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)的改變與[記錄](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c06)中[界線的移動](concepts.md#c11),不必同步(結論七之十)。\n\n校準:新進門的媳婦,起初在吃住上被當客人,幾年後被當家人,這是某個參與者所受的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)由一邊轉為另一邊;兩家公司合併後,原本兩套對「自己人」的做法逐漸合成一套;公司規章寫著不准兼職,起初沒人兼職,後來人人兼職,規章沒改,這是[宣稱界線](concepts.md#c10)與[內外差異](concepts.md#c09)的距離拉長。(路標:溫默整理的族群邊界移動策略,如擴大、縮小、翻轉、模糊化。相遇處:邊界會移動,且有幾種可辨認的形態。分開處:他們把移動歸於行動者的策略;本篇只描述移動在[記錄](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c06)中的結構,策略屬於[幻覺構件](concepts.md#c01)。)\n\n### 九之二 對你們的輸出,到達被劃進去的人\n\n**結論九之二**:一個[社會人](concepts.md#c03)依某個[你們](concepts.md#c05)作出的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28),[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)被劃進去的[呈現](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c04)時,[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)的是[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28),不是[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18);被劃進去的若對它作出[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18),那是它自己的[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)。\n\n(從[你們](concepts.md#c05)、[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)與[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)的定義,以及結論五之二推出)\n\n### 九之三 你們可能成為對方劃出我們的材料\n\n**結論九之三**:甲依某個[你們](concepts.md#c05)、以乙等[呈現](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c04)為對象作出的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28),若[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)乙等,且乙等是[社會人](concepts.md#c03),這些[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)便是它們之後劃出[我們](concepts.md#c04)的材料之一;乙等是否因此劃出包含彼此的[我們](concepts.md#c04)、往哪個方向劃,推不出。\n\n(從結論四之二、四之三與[知見障](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c35)推出:劃出[我們](concepts.md#c04)的材料包括別人的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28);同樣的材料推不出同樣的[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18))\n\n說明:\n1. 乙等在甲劃出[你們](concepts.md#c05)之前,不必有任何[我們](concepts.md#c04);這個[我們](concepts.md#c04)若之後出現,甲的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)只是它的材料之一,不是它的原因。\n2. 甲說「你們大陸人」這類話,研究者常可把它同時歸為一次[宣誓](concepts.md#c06):要接收者把甲劃在這一類之外。依結論六之一,它若[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)乙等,乙等若是[社會人](concepts.md#c03),乙等之後對甲的[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18),都從包含它的[歷史](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13)出發。\n\n校準:(路標:科塞的外部衝突與內部凝聚。相遇處:外來的敵意可能讓被針對的一方團結。分開處:科塞把凝聚當成衝突的功能;本篇說是否凝聚推不出,也不以功能解釋。)\n\n### 九之四 極化\n\n**結論九之四**:若甲把乙等劃為[你們](concepts.md#c05),乙等也把甲等劃為[你們](concepts.md#c05),雙方依此作出的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)一來一回地互相[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)(結論五之三),則研究者可依[太極](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c39)的定義判定是否構成[太極](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c39);是否構成、是否[趨異](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c38)、何時停下,推不出;任一方的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)不再[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)另一方時,這個[迴路](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c31)就斷了。\n\n(從結論五之三、[太極](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c39)的定義與[知見障](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c35)推出:[太極](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c39)是兩個各含方向相反的[正回饋](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c32)[迴路](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c31)、互相[耦合](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c36)並[趨異](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c38)的結構;它依[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)判定,需研究者講明維度)\n\n說明:\n1. 極化若使[記錄](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c06)中的[內外差異](concepts.md#c09)或[宣稱界線](concepts.md#c10)在[檢查窗口](../paper_d244789a_9261_4a0d_a98a_feb8db56b511/concepts.md#c03)之間有所不同,研究者可記為[界線移動](concepts.md#c11)的一種(結論九之一)。\n2. [太極](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c39)依[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)判定;雙方的[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)不在[記錄](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c06)中。研究者說「雙方的對立加深了」,是研究者以雙方為對象的一次[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18),其中可以包含[看法歸屬](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c02)(結論四之六)。\n3. 依[太極](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c39)與[共振](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c09)的定義,兩者各在講明的維度上判定;定義不排除同一批參與者在一個維度上構成[太極](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c39),在另一個維度上[共振](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c09):雙方在對立的維度上[趨異](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c38),在另一個維度上的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)仍可能相容接續。\n4. 這類[迴路](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c31)上互相[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)的,常是[宣誓](concepts.md#c06):表態、口號、標誌。依結論六之二,它們不推出雙方的[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18);依結論六之一,它們改變雙方之後的起點。\n\n校準:兩岸之間,政治表態上的對立愈來愈深,台商在大陸的工廠照常開工、貨照常出口。\n\n---\n\n## 十、沒有共有的我們\n\n### 十之一 我們不屬於兩個人\n\n**結論十之一**:一個[我們](concepts.md#c04)只屬於運用它的[社會人](concepts.md#c03);沒有一個同時屬於兩個[社會人](concepts.md#c03)的[我們](concepts.md#c04)。兩個[社會人](concepts.md#c03)的[我們](concepts.md#c04)是否一致,[不被保證](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c02);即使一致,能不能確認,也[不被保證](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c02):對方的[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)不[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)當事的一方,雙方的[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)也不[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)研究者,[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)的只是[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)(結論五之二);單憑[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)推不出雙方的[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)一致。\n\n(從[我們](concepts.md#c04)的定義、結論四之三、結論四之六、結論五之二,與[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)、[看法歸屬](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c02)、[印象](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c45)、[不被保證](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c02)的定義推出:劃出[我們](concepts.md#c04)是一個[社會人](concepts.md#c03)的一次[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18);同樣的材料推不出同樣的[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18);甲對乙怎麼劃的看法,是甲以乙為對象的一次[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18),其中可以包含[印象](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c45)或[看法歸屬](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c02))\n\n說明:\n1. 前半是定義直接得出的;後半是說,雙方各自的[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)即使恰好一致,能不能確認也[不被保證](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c02);這不排除具體情形中另有約束使確認成立([不被保證](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c02)的定義)。\n2. 這個不共有的限制也適用於[對物的歸屬分別](concepts.md#c07);兩個人使用相同的「我們的」名稱,仍不表示存在一個由兩人共同作出的同一次[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)(見結論十之七)。\n\n\n### 十之二 協調只需要輸出相容\n\n**結論十之二**:[經濟模式](../paper_d244789a_9261_4a0d_a98a_feb8db56b511/concepts.md#c09)的延續,不要求參與者的[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)一致;[共振](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c09)與[太極](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c39)依[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)與[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)的結構判定,[失配](../paper_ae79e938_76e1_4bf9_b2ab_995c03e16c9e/concepts.md#c08)依相鄰[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)序列是否相容判定;三者都不依參與者的[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)判定。\n\n(從[經濟模式](../paper_d244789a_9261_4a0d_a98a_feb8db56b511/concepts.md#c09)、[存續判準](../paper_d244789a_9261_4a0d_a98a_feb8db56b511/concepts.md#c01)、[共振](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c09)、[太極](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c39)與[失配](../paper_ae79e938_76e1_4bf9_b2ab_995c03e16c9e/concepts.md#c08)的定義,以及結論七之一推出:[經濟模式](../paper_d244789a_9261_4a0d_a98a_feb8db56b511/concepts.md#c09)依研究者講明的[存續判準](../paper_d244789a_9261_4a0d_a98a_feb8db56b511/concepts.md#c01)判定,判準只涉及[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)與[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10);[共振](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c09)以[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)為條件,依[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)模式是否相容接續判定;[太極](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c39)在[耦合](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c36)中每一方的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)都[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)另一方,[趨異](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c38)依參與者[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)的模式判定;[失配](../paper_ae79e938_76e1_4bf9_b2ab_995c03e16c9e/concepts.md#c08)依相鄰[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)序列是否相容判定)\n\n校準:(路標:帕森斯與魯曼的雙重偶連性。相遇處:雙方都看不透對方,各自的行動又取決於對對方的估計。分開處:帕森斯以共享的價值規範解決,魯曼以溝通系統解決;本篇不需要共享任何看法:[經濟模式](../paper_d244789a_9261_4a0d_a98a_feb8db56b511/concepts.md#c09)的延續,不要求參與者的[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)一致。)\n\n### 十之三 不對稱\n\n**結論十之三**:甲把乙劃進[我們](concepts.md#c04)、乙不把甲劃進[我們](concepts.md#c04),這種不對稱可以在雙方[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)相容時延續;甲對乙怎麼劃的看法,可以因新[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)甲的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)改變,也可以因甲自己之後的[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)改變;改變後的看法,仍是甲以乙為對象的一次[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18),其中可以包含[印象](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c45)或[看法歸屬](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c02),不是乙的[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)的讀數。\n\n(從結論十之一、十之二,以及[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)、[看法歸屬](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c02)與[印象](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c45)的定義推出:[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)的材料只有已經[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)它的[歷史](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13),所以甲的這次[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)要納入乙的新內容,需有新的東西[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)甲)\n\n說明:乙對甲說過「我們」這類[宣誓](concepts.md#c06)時,依結論六之二,它不推出乙這樣劃;乙之後的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)若[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)甲,並被甲歸為與這筆[宣誓](concepts.md#c06)不一致,便是甲改變看法的材料之一;甲也可能因其他材料或自己之後的[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)改變看法。\n\n校準:主管平常說「我們是一家人」,裁員名單公布那天,「我以為我是自己人」。猶大在十二門徒之中,交出耶穌之前,同在一個[我們](concepts.md#c04)裡的其他人,看到的只有他的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)。\n\n### 十之四 把我們當成本來就在\n\n**結論十之四**:[我們](concepts.md#c04)是[幻覺構件](concepts.md#c01);把劃出的[我們](concepts.md#c04),當成本來就在那裡、等著被確認的[我們](concepts.md#c04),是[幻覺](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c14),例如把「我是某國人」當成天生如此,或把一個名稱當成一個共有的[我們](concepts.md#c04)。本篇不細分它屬於哪一種[幻覺](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c14)。\n\n(從[我們](concepts.md#c04)的定義(三之三)、結論四之一、四之二、四之三、十之一,以及[幻覺](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c14)的定義推出:據以行動的,是[有損](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c13)地[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)自己的東西,不是[被看的東西](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c27)本身;把自己劃出的[我們](concepts.md#c04)當成本來就在那裡,是把自己的[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)當成被[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)的東西本身)\n\n說明:\n1. 把聽到的[宣誓](concepts.md#c06)當成對方的[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18),例如把「我愛這個國家」當成對方心裡確實如此,是[世界幻覺](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c15)的一種(結論六之二)。\n2. [社會人](concepts.md#c03)有[二階能力](concepts.md#c02),能看見[我們](concepts.md#c04)是自己劃的;但能看見不等於會看見。看見本身也是一次[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18),可能成為新的一層:「我已經看穿了:我們只是自己劃的」([二階分別](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c01)的定義;[盲點牆](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c09):對自己的[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)會[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)自己,成為自己的一部分)。\n3. 推測別人怎麼劃,本身是以別人為對象的一次[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)(結論十之一);其中可以包含[印象](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c45)(對其[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06)的估計),也可以包含[看法歸屬](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c02)(把[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)自己的一筆[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)劃為對方的[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18));它的材料只有已經[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)自己的[歷史](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13),其中[印象](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c45)的材料有三類:別人[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)自己的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)、自己與對方重疊的那一段、對方所在的[耦合](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c36)([印象](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c45)的定義);[宣誓](concepts.md#c06)也只是其中一種,不是[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)的讀數(三之五說明 2、結論六之二)。把這次推測當成別人的[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18),也是[世界幻覺](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c15)的一種:別人的[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)有材料、有[歷史](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13)(結論四之二),但不由材料唯一推出(結論四之三);這次推測不是讀數,正確與否[不被保證](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c02)。別人若作出[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18),那是他對世界的一次[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18);推測它,是自己再作的一層[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18),所推測的是自己歸給對方的那次[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18),對方不一定真的作過([看法歸屬](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c02)的定義:可能歸錯;[印象](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c45)的定義)。新[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)與這次推測不合時,社會可能顯得突兀。\n\n校準:「黨內無派」。\n\n### 十之五 我們與經濟模式各自延續\n\n**結論十之五**:[經濟模式](../paper_d244789a_9261_4a0d_a98a_feb8db56b511/concepts.md#c09)在[存續判準](../paper_d244789a_9261_4a0d_a98a_feb8db56b511/concepts.md#c01)下延續或中斷,不推出參與者之後仍會劃出同類的[我們](concepts.md#c04),或作出同類的[對物的歸屬分別](concepts.md#c07);參與者之後即使再作出同類[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18),也不推出原[經濟模式](../paper_d244789a_9261_4a0d_a98a_feb8db56b511/concepts.md#c09)仍然延續。兩者不互相蘊含。\n\n(從格局論文[判準中斷](../paper_d244789a_9261_4a0d_a98a_feb8db56b511/concepts.md#c10)的定義、三之三說明 7、三之六說明 5 與結論十之二推出:[經濟模式](../paper_d244789a_9261_4a0d_a98a_feb8db56b511/concepts.md#c09)依研究者講明的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)與[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)判準判定;某[社會人](concepts.md#c03)是否再次作出相似[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)不在該判準中)\n\n校準(假設各人的[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)如所述;單憑可見的話語推不出):\n- 模式延續,某人仍劃出同類的[我們](concepts.md#c04)。\n- 模式延續,某人不再劃出同類的[我們](concepts.md#c04)。\n- 模式中斷,某人後來再次劃出同類的[我們](concepts.md#c04)。\n- 模式中斷,某人後來不再劃出同類的[我們](concepts.md#c04)。\n\n### 十之六 共同的世界與共有的我們\n\n說明(不是結論):大家為什麼住在同一個世界,由渦動力學回答:[宇宙](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c02)與[呈現](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c04)本來就在,[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)各人的是同一個[宇宙](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c02)的不同部分,打了折扣。本篇處理的是更上一層:沒有共有的[我們](concepts.md#c04),[經濟模式](../paper_d244789a_9261_4a0d_a98a_feb8db56b511/concepts.md#c09)照樣延續。\n\n校準:(路標:唯識的共相種子與燈喻。相遇處:《成唯識論》說各人所變現的器世間各自不同,卻彼此相似、處所無異,「如眾燈明,各遍似一」。分開處:唯識以共相種子說明世界的相似;本篇的共同世界是[給定](../paper_54c0291d_05b3_431a_9f2a_1b8ec93c3c3f/concepts.md#c03)的[宇宙](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c02),而燈喻在本篇落在[我們](concepts.md#c04)這一層:各人的[我們](concepts.md#c04)各照各的,看似一個,從來不是一個。)\n\n### 十之七 沒有共有的「我們的」\n\n**結論十之七**:甲把某件物(下稱此物)劃為「我們的」,乙也把此物劃為「我們的」,不推出甲乙對此物作出同一次或相同的[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18),更不推出兩人劃出的[我們](concepts.md#c04)一致。甲乙對同一件物的不同[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18),可以在其[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)相容時同時存在。\n\n(從[對物的歸屬分別](concepts.md#c07)(三之六)、結論四之六、五之七、十之一與十之二推出:[歸屬分別](concepts.md#c07)各自在作出者的[歷史](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13)中,[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)相同不保證[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)相同,模式延續也不要求[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)一致)\n\n說明:\n1. 「我們的」是單方運用的[幻覺構件](concepts.md#c01),不是物上的共有性質;宣稱「這是我們的」是可見[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28),也不是各人同一[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)的證據。\n2. 即使「我們的」這個名稱經由多人的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)反覆出現,[記錄](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c06)中也只有名稱與[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)的傳播,沒有一個跨越多人而共有的[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)。\n3. 本結論不討論所有權,不討論誰可以使用物,也不討論誰能要求另一方採用分類。\n\n校準:甲、乙都對丙說「這是我們的」,丙也照著說。研究者記得到三筆[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28),從中推不出三人共同的「我們的」。\n\n\n---\n\n## 十一、推不出的與留待後續\n\n### 十一之一 本篇推不出的\n\n- 一個[社會人](concepts.md#c03)會不會把某個[呈現](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c04)劃進[我們](concepts.md#c04)、怎麼劃(結論四之三);\n- 它會不會把某件物劃為我的、你的、我們的或你們的;對人的[我們](concepts.md#c04)是否伴隨對物的我們的(結論四之三、四之十三、七之三);\n- 它劃出[我們](concepts.md#c04)的[邊際](concepts.md#c08)後,是否另把[邊際](concepts.md#c08)外的人劃成[你們](concepts.md#c05)(三之三說明 8、三之七說明 2);\n- [分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)是否改變、往哪個方向改變(結論五之三);\n- 一筆[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)出於哪一個[我們](concepts.md#c04)(結論四之十一);\n- 他人作出的[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18),是否使他人落到[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19)身上的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)有所不同、差多少,以及[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19)的[可行集合](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c11)因此如何(結論五之四);\n- 以他人[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)為對象的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28),會不會改變對方的[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)(結論五之六);\n- [宣誓](concepts.md#c06)的接收者,是否照著[宣誓](concepts.md#c06)劃出[宣誓](concepts.md#c06)者(結論六之五);\n- 二階改造之後,[經濟模式](../paper_d244789a_9261_4a0d_a98a_feb8db56b511/concepts.md#c09)延續還是[判準中斷](../paper_d244789a_9261_4a0d_a98a_feb8db56b511/concepts.md#c10)(結論七之四);\n- 「這是我們的」[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)別人後,別人是否作出相同[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)、之後是否出現特定的使用或處置[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)(結論五之七、七之七、七之八);\n- 可觀測的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)差異,究竟有多少出於某次劃出[我們](concepts.md#c04)的[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)或[對物的歸屬分別](concepts.md#c07)(結論七之八);\n- [分別邊際](concepts.md#c08)是否帶出[內外差異](concepts.md#c09)、落在哪裡;[記錄](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c06)中的[內外差異](concepts.md#c09)或[宣稱界線](concepts.md#c10)是否出於被研究的[社會人](concepts.md#c03)的某次[分別邊際](concepts.md#c08)(結論七之九、七之十二);\n- 多個[社會人](concepts.md#c03)的[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)是否重疊;[記錄](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c06)中的[內外差異](concepts.md#c09)移動時,各人的[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)是否已變(結論七之十);\n- [宣稱界線](concepts.md#c10)與[記錄](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c06)中的[內外差異](concepts.md#c09)落差事先會有多大、為何如此(結論七之十一);\n- 被劃為[你們](concepts.md#c05)的人,若收到依此作出的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28),是否因此劃出包含彼此的[我們](concepts.md#c04)(結論九之三);\n- 互劃為[你們](concepts.md#c05)的雙方,是否構成[太極](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c39)、是否[趨異](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c38)、何時停下(結論九之四);\n- 是否出現[界線的移動](concepts.md#c11)、往哪個方向、何時出現(結論九之一);\n- 兩個[社會人](concepts.md#c03)的[我們](concepts.md#c04)是否一致(結論十之一);\n- 兩個[社會人](concepts.md#c03)對同一物的「我們的」是否一致(結論十之七)。\n\n說明:其中依賴結論四之三的,都在[應用假定](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c50)之下成立。\n\n### 十一之二 留待後續\n\n- **權威、層級、法人**:本篇只有各人自己劃的[我們](concepts.md#c04)與我們的,沒有一方的[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)必然被另一方照著做的機制;[宣誓](concepts.md#c06)或對物的分類聲明是[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28),若[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)接收者,而接收者是[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16),便參與其[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06),可能使它不走某條[路徑](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c07);但本篇沒有一種機制,讓這筆話語必然使不照著劃的一方有某條[路徑](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c07)不可行(結論五之五、六之五、七之七)。這三者需要引入額外機制,留待後續研究。\n- **其他概念**:所有權、制度、價格、價值、貨幣、分配、市場,留待後續研究。「我們的」在本篇只是對物運用的[幻覺構件](concepts.md#c01),本篇不把它當作所有權、使用權或分配規則的同義詞。\n\n---\n\n## 十二、案例\n\n本節整節是校準,不作任何推導的來源。案中把結論用在具體的人身上時,依第二節,都在[配置假定](../paper_ae79e938_76e1_4bf9_b2ab_995c03e16c9e/concepts.md#c01)之下成立。兩案取自不同的時期與地方:前一案看寫進法條的[宣稱界線](concepts.md#c10)如何改寫、移動;後一案看圍繞一片海域的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28),如何在[記錄](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c06)中留下[內外差異](concepts.md#c09),以及原本沒有寫下的界線,後來如何寫進法律。案中凡「為了」「想要」「認同」一類的說法,都是[記錄](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c06)者或後人以當事人為對象的[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18),其中可以包含[看法歸屬](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c02),不是[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)的讀數。\n\n### 十二之一 加州的外國礦工稅(1850 至 1870)\n\n資料說明:讀到的是維基百科「〔Foreign Miners' Tax Act of 1850〕」條目、美國國家公園管理局關於加州華人移民的頁面、聖塔克拉拉大學的數位展覽頁面,以及〔EBSCO〕關於淘金潮外國礦工稅的條目,都經工具摘出相關段落,不是原始檔。各來源對 1852 年稅額的記載不一致,一說每月 3 美元,一說每月 4 美元。\n\n1. **[切法](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c23)**:範圍是加州礦區,[檢查窗口](../paper_d244789a_9261_4a0d_a98a_feb8db56b511/concepts.md#c03)為年。[節點](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25)為州議會、州長、收稅員、各地來的礦工,以及寫下法條的[信號容器](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c26)。研究者比較的同類[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28),是礦工的繳稅、被追趕與離開礦區。\n2. **初始狀態**:1848 年起,礦區的淘金結構逐年重現,礦工來自各地;[記錄](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c06)中沒有依出身區分的稅。\n3. **新的[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)**:1850 年 4 月 13 日,州長〔Burnett〕簽署法案,對不是美國公民、也沒有依〔Guadalupe Hidalgo〕條約成為公民的礦工,每月課 20 美元;加州原住民另有豁免。\n4. **[宣稱界線](concepts.md#c10)與[內外差異](concepts.md#c09)**:\n - 法條寫進[信號容器](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c26),提出一條界線,研究者可依它劃出[宣稱界線](concepts.md#c10):公民在內,非公民在外。\n - 愛爾蘭、英格蘭、加拿大與德意志礦工抗議之後,法條改寫為豁免「自由白人」與可成為美國公民的礦工。\n - 1850 年 5 月 19 日,約四千名以墨西哥人、秘魯人為主的礦工在〔Sonora〕抗議,約五百名收稅員與英裔礦工組成的民兵追趕他們。\n - 許多墨西哥與華人礦工離開礦區;稅收遠低於預期的二十萬美元。\n5. **[界線的移動](concepts.md#c11)**:\n - 1851 年,州長〔McDougall〕任內廢止此法。\n - 1852 年另立外國礦工執照稅,其後稅額逐步調高;國家公園管理局的頁面記它針對華人移民。\n - 到 1870 年此法失效時,華人礦工繳納的稅額超過五百萬美元,約占這段期間州收入的四分之一。\n6. **說明了什麼**:\n - 法條是寫進[信號容器](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c26)的分類,此後隨[信號容器](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c26)每一步都被[鎖死](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c12);改寫、廢止、重立,都是另一筆[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)它的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28),在它[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)之前,前一筆已參與了這段期間的[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06)(三之九說明 3,[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)的定義)。\n - 繳稅、被追趕、離開礦區,是[記錄](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c06)中可以比較的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28);研究者以出身分組比較,得到的是[內外差異](concepts.md#c09)(三之八)。換一種分組,結果可以不同。\n - 來源把條文的改寫記在歐洲來的礦工抗議之後:抗議若[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)立法者,便參與其[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06);之後的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)改變了[宣稱界線](concepts.md#c10)。抗議是否因此起作用、起多大作用,推不出(結論五之六)。\n - 1850 年到 1870 年之間,[宣稱界線](concepts.md#c10)改寫、廢止、重立,來源記載這項稅針對的礦工,也由墨西哥人等轉為華人,研究者可記為[界線的移動](concepts.md#c11)(結論九之一)。\n - 礦工離開礦區,可能是稅撤除了合法採礦這條[路徑](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c07)的[前件](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c08),也可能是稅參與了他們的[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06),使他們不走一條仍然可行的[路徑](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c07);是哪一種,推不出(結論五之五)。\n7. **記錄中有的與推不出的**:\n - 記錄中有的:法條寫了什麼,何時改寫、廢止與重立;抗議與追趕的事件;稅收不如預期;華人礦工繳納的總額與比例。\n - 推不出:立法者、收稅員或英裔礦工把誰劃為[我們](concepts.md#c04)、把誰劃為[你們](concepts.md#c05);任何礦工為什麼離開;若沒有這項稅,礦區的人口構成會怎樣。\n\n### 十二之二 緬因州的龍蝦海域(二十世紀)\n\n資料說明:讀到的是〔Waring〕與〔Acheson〕〈〔Evidence of cultural group selection in territorial lobstering in Maine〕〉(2017)一文,經工具摘出相關段落,不是原始檔;文中關於港口幫與海域的記載,多轉引〔Acheson〕1975、1988 與 2003 年的著作。\n\n1. **[切法](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c23)**:範圍是緬因州沿岸的龍蝦捕撈,[檢查窗口](../paper_d244789a_9261_4a0d_a98a_feb8db56b511/concepts.md#c03)為年。[節點](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25)為各港口的捕撈者、州議會與海洋資源主管機關;海域是[自然環境](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c16)。研究者比較的同類[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28),是在某片海域下籠,以及對他人籠具的處置。\n2. **初始狀態**:州法規定,下籠捕撈龍蝦要有州的執照;破壞他人籠具違法。\n3. **出現的結構**:\n - 各港口的捕撈者組成港口幫,以海灣、礁石、河口、浮標為界,守著一片非官方的海域,通常不到一百平方英里;一幫少則八艘船,很少超過五十艘。\n - 外港的人進來下籠,先受到口頭警告,再來籠具被破壞;被破壞的一方常常報復。\n - 法律上有執照就能捕撈;非官方地,還要被港口幫接納。\n - 大陸港口多半靠近港口處守得嚴,越遠越鬆;島嶼港口與少數大陸港口則整片守到外緣,界線清楚。\n4. **[宣稱界線](concepts.md#c10)與[內外差異](concepts.md#c09)**:\n - 州法提出一條界線,研究者可依它劃出[宣稱界線](concepts.md#c10):持照者在內,無照者在外。\n - 港口幫的警告是以分類為內容的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28),提出另一條界線,研究者可依它劃出另一條[宣稱界線](concepts.md#c10):本港的人在內,外港的人在外。這條界線起初沒有寫進[信號容器](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c26)。\n - [記錄](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c06)中的[內外差異](concepts.md#c09):同樣在這片海域下籠,本港的人籠具留著,外港的人籠具被破壞。\n5. **[界線的移動](concepts.md#c11)**:\n - 1960 年前後,上〔Muscongus〕灣的捕撈者在秋冬開始到灣口下籠,與〔New Harbor〕、〔Round Pond〕的捕撈者互相割籠多年;上灣的人逐步進入外灣,外灣成為混合捕撈的海域。\n - 1984 年,〔Swan's Island〕的捕撈者向海洋資源主管機關爭取,把原本非官方的海域改為官方保育區,排除大陸港口的捕撈者,並設 475 個籠具的上限。1998 年〔Monhegan〕也經立法取得特別地位,禁止其他港口的船在島周圍兩英里內捕撈。\n - 1995 年的龍蝦分區管理法,在沿岸劃出七個法定區域,由持照者選出區域委員會。\n6. **說明了什麼**:\n - 若某個捕撈者把這片海劃為我們的,那是[對物的歸屬分別](concepts.md#c07),屬於他,不在[記錄](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c06)中;[記錄](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c06)中只有警告、下籠、割籠這些[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)。哪一次割籠出於這樣的[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18),推不出(三之六,結論四之六、七之九)。\n - 州法說持照者都能捕撈,[記錄](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c06)中外港的人在這片海域的籠具卻被破壞:州法的[宣稱界線](concepts.md#c10)與[記錄](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c06)中的[內外差異](concepts.md#c09)不一致(結論七之十一)。\n - 割籠可能撤除了外港捕撈者在這片海域這條[路徑](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c07)的[前件](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c08),也可能只參與了他們的[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06),使他們不再進來;是哪一種,推不出。警告也可能只參與接收者的[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06),不撤除[前件](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c08);有哪一種作用,推不出(結論五之五)。\n - 即使港口幫的捕撈者把海域劃為我們的,也不推出誰有權使用:依州法,外港的持照者照樣能捕撈,割籠也違法(結論七之七)。\n - 多個捕撈者的警告與割籠,在[記錄](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c06)中構成同一條[內外差異](concepts.md#c09),不要求他們共有一個[我們](concepts.md#c04),也不要求他們的[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)一致(結論七之十、十之一)。\n - 上〔Muscongus〕灣的擴張,是[記錄](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c06)中[內外差異的移動](concepts.md#c11);保育區與分區管理法,則把原本只靠警告提出的界線寫進[信號容器](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c26),新的[宣稱界線](concepts.md#c10)向既有的[內外差異](concepts.md#c09)靠攏;立法之後的[內外差異](concepts.md#c09),資料中沒有(結論九之一)。\n7. **記錄中有的與推不出的**:\n - 記錄中有的:州法寫了什麼;港口幫海域的大致範圍與守法;外港的人受到的警告與割籠;1960 年前後的擴張;1984、1995、1998 年的法律變化。\n - 推不出:任何捕撈者把誰劃為[我們](concepts.md#c04)、把哪片海劃為我們的;某次割籠出於哪一次[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18);港口幫為什麼在這裡形成;保育區設立之後,各人的[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)是否改變。\n\n---\n\n## 十三、總命題\n\n**總命題**:[經濟模式](../paper_d244789a_9261_4a0d_a98a_feb8db56b511/concepts.md#c09)的成立與延續,不需要任何參與者劃出[我們](concepts.md#c04)。[社會人](concepts.md#c03)具有[二階能力](concepts.md#c02)後,可以在既有[經濟模式](../paper_d244789a_9261_4a0d_a98a_feb8db56b511/concepts.md#c09)已[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)它的材料上,對人劃出[我們](concepts.md#c04)、[你們](concepts.md#c05),對物作出[歸屬分別](concepts.md#c07),運用我的、你的、我們的、你們的等[幻覺構件](concepts.md#c01),使該模式對這個[社會人](concepts.md#c03)出現由它自行劃定的[分別邊際](concepts.md#c08)。[邊際](concepts.md#c08)不屬於模式本身,不要求其他[社會人](concepts.md#c03)認同,也不推出所有權、使用、處置、排除或分配關係。\n\n這些[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)作出後,成為該[社會人](concepts.md#c03)自己的[歷史](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13),參與其後續的[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06);它對[邊際](concepts.md#c08)兩邊的人與物落出的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)可能不同,這些[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)若[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)他人,可能改變他人的可行[路徑](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c07);他人若是[社會人](concepts.md#c03),也可能成為它之後[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)與[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)的材料。如此,[分別邊際](concepts.md#c08)經由[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28),可能使[記錄](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c06)中的[經濟模式](../paper_d244789a_9261_4a0d_a98a_feb8db56b511/concepts.md#c09)出現[內外差異](concepts.md#c09):同類的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28),在一組參與者之內與跨出該組時有所不同。各人不共有的劃出[我們](concepts.md#c04)的[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)與[對物的歸屬分別](concepts.md#c07),若各人的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)互相[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10),也可能經由[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)相互塑造;這種遞迴可能使[記錄](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c06)中的[界線移動](concepts.md#c11)。多個[社會人](concepts.md#c03)有差別的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28),可能在[記錄](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c06)中構成同一條[內外差異](concepts.md#c09),不要求他們共有一個[我們](concepts.md#c04)。說出來、寫下來的分類若被登記進[記錄](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c06),研究者可依它劃出[宣稱界線](concepts.md#c10);[記錄](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c06)中若有[內外差異](concepts.md#c09),卻依研究者登記的同類[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)劃出,之後的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)若被登記並歸入同類,也可以在其中,兩者可以不一致。[記錄](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c06)中的[內外差異](concepts.md#c09),不推出參與者有[二階能力](concepts.md#c02)。至於誰作出何種[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)、[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)如何變動、[內外差異](concepts.md#c09)是否出現、落在哪裡、哪一項差異究竟出於哪個[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18),以及模式是否因此延續或中斷,本篇皆不唯一推出。\n\n(從結論五之三、五之七、七之一、七之三、七之六、七之七、七之八、七之九、七之十、七之十一、七之十二、十之一、十之二與十之七彙總;依賴結論四之三的部分,在[應用假定](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c50)之下成立。)\n\n---\n\n## 待解事項\n\n1. 三之六對物的[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)目前只處理「我的、你的、我們的、你們的」的[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18);是否另處理其他類別,待後續篇章決定。\n"},{"filename":"The Dynamics of Boundary Illusory Constructs.md","content":"---\nuuid: 08383b0a-1167-4efb-9b89-dc8a71afd5ff\nlast-modified: 2026-11-05T17:01:28\nauthor: 黃正宇 / Cheng Yu Huang\ncontact: mthree.tw@gmail.com\n---\n\n# The Dynamics of Boundary Illusory Constructs\n\n---\n\n## 0. Position and Method\n\n### 0.1 Position\n\nThis paper builds on *The Dynamics of Biological Humans' Output Patterns* (hereafter the Pattern paper). It asks: on an [economic mode](../paper_d244789a_9261_4a0d_a98a_feb8db56b511/concepts.md#c09) that can already stand, when biological humans draw [we](concepts.md#c04) and [plural you](concepts.md#c05) about people, and make [belonging distinctions](concepts.md#c07) classing things as \"mine\", \"yours\", \"ours\", or \"yours (plural)\", how can these [distinctions](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18), through [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28), make an [inside outside difference](concepts.md#c09) appear in the economic mode in the record; and how can the [claimed boundary](concepts.md#c10) that the researcher draws from spoken and written classifications, if registered, diverge from the inside outside difference in the [record](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c06)? The Pattern paper treats the [arrival](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) structure among the outputs of many biological humans and does not register distinctions; this paper uses [illusory constructs](concepts.md#c01) such as [second-order capacity](concepts.md#c02), the [social person](concepts.md#c03), and we (0.5) to describe how these distinctions, through output, take part in the later operation and mutual shaping of existing economic modes.\n\nThe conclusions derived in the Pattern paper still hold here; this paper only adds and changes nothing.\n\n### 0.2 Method\n\nThis paper is deductive, in the same format as the Pattern paper: each conclusion states the definitions, premises, or earlier conclusions it is derived from; the cases serve only as calibration and bear no argument.\n\n### 0.3 Scope of the Record\n\nThis paper records as follows: only the physical changes of [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) are registered, not the content of [distinctions](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18). A [social person](concepts.md#c03)'s distinctions are in its [history](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13), not in this paper's [record](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c06).\n\n**Notation convention**: saying that some [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) is in the [record](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c06) always means one the researcher has registered, and saying that some difference is in the record always means one the researcher draws from registered outputs under a stated [cut](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c23); saying that a [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) becomes part of [history](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13) means that the [writing](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c29) it leaves becomes part of history; saying that [weight](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06) does not fix the result always means when not [locked in](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c12), under the [application assumption](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c50); words or names within quotation marks are written as given, and the \"we\", \"you\", and similar words in them are not linked; this paper links these concepts only when it uses them.\n\n### 0.4 Scope of Claims\n\nThis paper states three kinds of things: relations that hold of structural necessity; which things cannot be derived from which others; and things that can be registered in the [record](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c06), such as the gap between a [claimed boundary](concepts.md#c10) and an [inside outside difference](concepts.md#c09). Conclusions of the first two kinds that depend on an [illusory construct](concepts.md#c01) hold under that construct (0.5 Note 6). This paper does not predict who will draw whom into a [we](concepts.md#c04) or who will class which thing as \"ours\", nor in which direction [distinctions](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) or [outputs](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) will change. What this paper calls \"ours\" is not a rule of ownership, use, disposal, or exclusion of others.\n\n### 0.5 Illusory Construct\n\n**[Illusory construct](concepts.md#c01)**: a construct whose object is not given by the physical world, yet which is used to describe or organize [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28), such as [we](concepts.md#c04), husband, and [second-order capacity](concepts.md#c02).\n\n**Notation**: \"physical world\" is used in this paper as an ordinary term and is not set up as a concept.\n\nNotes:\n1. **Two ways of appearing**: first, a researcher uses it to describe complex first-order [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28), sorting many outputs into a few [distinctions](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18); second, it appears in outputs as a name, an [avowal](concepts.md#c06), or a classification written into a [signal container](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c26); if this output [arrives](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at others, it takes part in their [weights](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06), and through output may make later [records](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c06) take a corresponding shape (Conclusions 5.1, 5.5, 7.11). When the second way has a classification as its content, then if this output is registered in the record, it is material from which the researcher draws a [claimed boundary](concepts.md#c10) (3.9).\n2. **Not a distinction**: a [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) is an act of a [wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16) that leaves a [writing](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c29) in [history](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13) (definition of distinction); an [illusory construct](concepts.md#c01) is the content of a distinction, or a construct used in a researcher's description or in [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28), whose object is not given by the physical world. A distinction may use an illusory construct or may not. Drawing a [we](concepts.md#c04) is a distinction; the we it uses is an illusory construct (3.3).\n3. **Not an illusion**: an [illusion](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c14) is a situation of a [self](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19), describing only what it acts on (definition of illusion); when an [illusory construct](concepts.md#c01) appears in [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28), it may take part in later [records](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c06).\n4. **No claim of existence**: this paper neither claims nor denies that the object of an [illusory construct](concepts.md#c01) exists in any [presentation](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c04). [Second-order capacity](concepts.md#c02) itself is an illusory construct: this paper uses it as shorthand for complex first-order [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28); this is compatible with the [configuration assumption](../paper_ae79e938_76e1_4bf9_b2ab_995c03e16c9e/concepts.md#c01) (Section 2).\n5. **Reason for adoption**: without [illusory constructs](concepts.md#c01), explaining one [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) would require tracing the whole [history](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13) that has [arrived](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at that biological human (definition of [wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)); with them, many outputs can be described as a few [distinctions](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18). Such sorting is a distinction of the researcher; what it does to each output that arrives at the researcher is [view attribution](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c02); either may be wrong.\n6. **Traceable**: conclusions of this paper that depend on an [illusory construct](concepts.md#c01) hold under that construct; the registration of [claimed boundaries](concepts.md#c10), [inside outside differences](concepts.md#c09), and the gap between them depends only on the [record](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c06).\n7. **The researcher is also inside**: when a researcher's description appears in its [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28), the [illusory constructs](concepts.md#c01) in it may likewise [arrive](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at others and take part in their [weights](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06) (Note 1, second way).\n\nCalibration: the sentence \"In his heart he does not treat her as his wife\" sorts years of [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) into one [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18); this is the first way of appearing. \"You are my wife\", said at a wedding, and the marriage certificate are the second. (Signpost: Vaihinger's \"philosophy of as if\"; Hacking's looping effect of human kinds. Where they meet: concepts known not to correspond to real things are used anyway; a classification that reaches the classified changes them. Where they part: this paper sets up no division between fiction and reality, and asks only whether a construct's object is given by the physical world and whether the construct appears in output.)\n\n### 0.6 Notation\n\n\"Appear\", \"involve\", \"speed\", \"one side\", and \"select\"; \"same\" in uses such as the same thing or the same side; the verb \"decide\"; and the question \"will it happen\" are used in this paper as ordinary terms and do not refer to the upstream concepts of the same name. \"Conflict\" in this paper means that two [distinctions](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) are incompatible; it is an ordinary term and does not refer to the [conflict](../paper_ae79e938_76e1_4bf9_b2ab_995c03e16c9e/concepts.md#c10) of the acquaintance paper. Names of others' theories in signposts, such as Coser's external conflict and Luhmann's system and environment, are kept as in the original and do not refer to upstream concepts.\n\n\"Cannot be derived\" in this paper means: from the sources and [records](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c06) listed in this paper, a unique result cannot be derived; it does not claim that it cannot be derived under any condition or from any material. \"Not uniquely derived\" is used in the same sense.\n\n---\n\n## 1. Inheritance\n\nThis paper inherits the relevant concepts of the Wo Dynamics paper, the tools paper, *Three Illusions and the Forced Wager* (hereafter *Three Illusions*), the Pattern paper, the individual paper, the stranger paper, and the acquaintance paper.\n\n**Premise**: this paper assumes that a [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) of a [wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16) and an [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) of it [arrive](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at that wo itself before its next [moment](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c09) and take part in its later [weights](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06). Among upstream concepts, the [wall of the blind spot](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c09) states this only for distinctions whose object is oneself; this paper extends it to all distinctions and outputs, as a premise.\n\n---\n\n## 2. Scope\n\nThe object of this paper is the [social person](concepts.md#c03) (3.2). Biological humans who are not social persons are outside its scope; the conclusions of the Pattern paper still hold for them.\n\nWhen this paper applies its conclusions to specific biological humans, it marks them with the [configuration assumption](../paper_ae79e938_76e1_4bf9_b2ab_995c03e16c9e/concepts.md#c01). By the definition of the configuration assumption, confirming from outside whether an object has [second-order distinction](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c01) at some moment is [not guaranteed](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c02); so whenever this paper's conclusions are applied to specific people, they hold under this assumption. The configuration assumption is made for a stated stage, so a biological human, taken as one by [identity](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c21), can be a [social person](concepts.md#c03) in one period and not in another.\n\nCalibration: law divides legal capacity by marks such as age and guardianship orders, replacing a capacity that cannot be guaranteed to be confirmed directly with marks that can be [recorded](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c06); this paper's marking of specific people with the [configuration assumption](../paper_ae79e938_76e1_4bf9_b2ab_995c03e16c9e/concepts.md#c01) is the same practice. This paper does not presume infants or people with severe dementia to be within scope.\n\nThis paper takes biological humans as its object without claiming the mechanisms in it are found only in biological humans. By [recutting](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c22), other clusters of [wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16), such as an ant nest, may have corresponding [inside outside differences](concepts.md#c09) and [claimed boundaries](concepts.md#c10); this paper does not treat them.\n\n---\n\n## 3. Definitions\n\n### 3.1 Second-Order Capacity\n\n**[Second-order capacity](concepts.md#c02)**: having both [second-order distinction](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c01) and [view attribution](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c02).\n\nNotes:\n1. This is a joint name of this paper and does not claim the two are one capacity. By the definitions of [second-order distinction](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c01) and [view attribution](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c02), neither definition takes the other as a condition.\n2. [Second-order capacity](concepts.md#c02) is a capacity, not a condition of every [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18): having it means being able to make these two kinds of distinction, not having made them every time (definition of [second-order distinction](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c01): to say a [self](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19) has second-order distinction means it can make such a distinction about any of its own distinctions).\n3. **[Second-order capacity](concepts.md#c02) is an [illusory construct](concepts.md#c01)** (0.5): this paper uses it as shorthand for complex first-order [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) and does not claim any biological human really has it; by the [configuration assumption](../paper_ae79e938_76e1_4bf9_b2ab_995c03e16c9e/concepts.md#c01), confirming it from outside is [not guaranteed](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c02) (Section 2).\n\n### 3.2 Social Person\n\n**[Social person](concepts.md#c03)**: a biological human with [second-order capacity](concepts.md#c02).\n\nNote: a [social person](concepts.md#c03) is an [illusory construct](concepts.md#c01) (0.5). Calling a biological human a social person is a [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) the researcher makes with that biological human as object, whose material may include [view attribution](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c02), under the [configuration assumption](../paper_ae79e938_76e1_4bf9_b2ab_995c03e16c9e/concepts.md#c01) (Section 2); this paper does not on that basis judge any biological human not to be a social person. This paper's conclusions about social persons all hold under this construct. Social persons and participants of a [second-order network](../paper_ae79e938_76e1_4bf9_b2ab_995c03e16c9e/concepts.md#c04) share the condition of having both [second-order distinction](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c01) and view attribution; the difference is that a second-order network is the set formed by these [selves](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19) and the [couplings](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c36) among them, while a social person is a single biological human. The object of this paper is the social person, not the second-order network. A social person has second-order distinction; by the definition of second-order distinction, what has second-order distinction is a self; so a social person is a self, and also a [wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16) (definitions of second-order distinction and self).\n\n### 3.3 We\n\n**[We](concepts.md#c04)**: an [illusory construct](concepts.md#c01) used by a [social person](concepts.md#c03): one with which the social person, along some dimension, treats itself and other [presentations](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c04) it counts as a \"[self](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19)\" as one unit on the same side, to organize its [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28).\n\nNotes:\n1. **Defined by object, not content**: the object of [we](concepts.md#c04) includes oneself; this is a feature of the object. By method, the content of [distinctions](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) is not formalized. For the construct whose object excludes oneself ([plural you](concepts.md#c05)), see 3.4.\n2. **One-sided**: [we](concepts.md#c04) belongs to the [social person](concepts.md#c03) who uses it and does not require those drawn in to draw it the same way.\n3. **The dimension is drawn by the one who draws**: the same pair of people can be [we](concepts.md#c04) along this dimension and not along another. This dimension is the [social person](concepts.md#c03)'s own [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18), not the researcher's dimension.\n4. **Counting as a [self](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19) can be a [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) about a class**: \"people of this kind are all selves\" does not require a [view attribution](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c02) for each member of the class; what it requires is the capacity for view attribution.\n5. **Counting as a self does not guarantee the other is a self**: counting as a self is treating the other as another [self](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19) that makes [distinctions](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18); by the definition of [view attribution](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c02), view attribution can be wrong: the [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) taken as a view does not necessarily come from a self.\n6. **Choice of scope**: this paper speaks only of the [we](concepts.md#c04) of [social persons](concepts.md#c03). A [self](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19) with only [first-order distinction](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c24) is recorded in this paper as having no we; by the definition of self, who is a self is defined by itself, and the boundary moves with its self-definition. This is this paper's notation, not a derivation.\n7. **Degree and persistence**: each drawing is either drawn or not; to say a [social person](concepts.md#c03) \"has\" some [we](concepts.md#c04), and how strong this we is, is a matter of degree belonging to its [weight](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06), and is not formalized. By the premise of Section 1, each drawing [arrives](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at oneself and takes part in later weights; a social person is a [self](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19) (3.2), and when not in [lock-in](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c12) it cannot derive in advance the result of its own next [decision](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c06); so whether its [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) about some we recurs is [not guaranteed](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c02) ([wall of the undetermined](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c10)).\n8. **Not drawn into [we](concepts.md#c04) is not drawn as [plural you](concepts.md#c05)**: the [margin](concepts.md#c08) drawn by the [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) drawing we does not automatically produce a distinction drawing plural you; further drawing the [presentations](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c04) on the other side of the margin as plural you is still a distinction of the [social person](concepts.md#c03)'s own (3.4).\n9. **Drawing and using**: drawing a [we](concepts.md#c04) is a [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) that uses this construct (0.5 Note 2); a we has effect only through the outputs that use it. A we never used in [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) is, in the [record](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c06), no different from one never drawn; whether even the [social person](concepts.md#c03) who drew it will later make it the object of a [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) again is [not guaranteed](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c02), and it may long have forgotten it ([wall of the blind spot](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c09): no [self](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19) can fully distinguish itself at any time).\n\nCalibration: \"our family\", \"our company\", \"our department\", \"our country\" are the [we](concepts.md#c04) of the same person along different dimensions. Someone draws the company as we, while colleagues treat him only as a contractor; someone draws the family dog into \"our family\".\n\nCalibration: a boss privately plans to fire an employee but never says so and never acts on it; in the [record](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c06) this is no different from not planning it, and he himself may later forget it.\n\n### 3.4 Plural You\n\n**[Plural you](concepts.md#c05)**: an [illusory construct](concepts.md#c01) used by a [social person](concepts.md#c03): one with which the social person, along some dimension, treats other [presentations](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c04) it counts as a \"[self](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19)\", excluding itself, as one unit, to organize its [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28).\n\nNotes:\n1. **Defined by object**: the object of [plural you](concepts.md#c05) excludes oneself; this is a feature of the object; it differs from [we](concepts.md#c04) in object, not in content.\n2. **One-sided**: [plural you](concepts.md#c05) belongs to the [social person](concepts.md#c03) who uses it; it does not require those drawn in to draw it the same way, nor that they draw any [we](concepts.md#c04).\n3. **Choice of scope**: as in 3.3 Note 6, this paper records a [self](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19) with only [first-order distinction](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c24) as having no [plural you](concepts.md#c05).\n4. 3.3 Notes 3, 4, 5, 7, and 9 apply as well: the dimension is drawn by the one who draws; counting as a [self](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19) can be a [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) about a class; counting as a self does not guarantee that the other is a self; it has degrees and changes; it has effect only through the [outputs](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) that use it.\n\nCalibration: when someone says \"you mainlanders\", those drawn in may see themselves as Taiwanese businesspeople, as Shanghainese, or as nothing at all.\n\n**Notation**: \"they\" is used in this paper as an ordinary term, the name for several [plural yous](concepts.md#c05) taken together; taking them together is itself a [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) (Conclusion 4.10).\n\n### 3.5 Avowal\n\n**[Avowal](concepts.md#c06)**: an [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) of a [social person](concepts.md#c03) whose object is the receiver's [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) of the avower: along some dimension, it asks the receiver to place the avower in some class.\n\nNotes:\n1. **Defined by object**: the object is limited to others' [distinctions](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) of the one making the [avowal](concepts.md#c06); for [outputs](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) whose object is other distinctions, see Conclusion 5.6.\n2. **An avowal is not a reading of a [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)**: whether and how deeply the avower draws it is not in the [record](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c06); a lie is also an [avowal](concepts.md#c06).\n3. **An [avowal](concepts.md#c06) is only a request**: whether the receiver draws accordingly, see Conclusion 6.5.\n4. **Classing as an [avowal](concepts.md#c06) is the researcher's [view attribution](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c02)**: classing an output that [arrives](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at the researcher as an avowal is the researcher's view attribution; the [record](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c06) contains only the physical changes of this [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) (Conclusion 4.6).\n5. **Excludes classificatory statements about things**: \"this is ours\", if its object is a [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) about some thing, does not become an [avowal](concepts.md#c06) in this definition just because the word \"we\" appears in it; it is an [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) about a thing; see 3.6 and Conclusion 5.7.\n\n### 3.6 Belonging Distinction of Things\n\n**[Belonging distinction of things](concepts.md#c07)**: a [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) made by a [social person](concepts.md#c03): along some dimension, taking the [presentation](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c04) of a thing that has [arrived](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at it as material, it classes the thing as \"mine\", \"yours\", \"ours\", or \"yours (plural)\". These four are [illusory constructs](concepts.md#c01) this distinction uses, having effect only through the [outputs](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) that use them, not rights the thing itself carries.\n\nNotes:\n1. **The [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) belongs to the one who draws**: \"ours\" and \"yours (plural)\" are used in distinctions about things, not about people; which [we](concepts.md#c04) or [plural you](concepts.md#c05) they refer to belongs to the content of the distinction and is not formalized in this paper (3.3 Note 1). Even if others hear the same name, they are not guaranteed to make the same distinction.\n2. **People and things differ**: drawing B into [we](concepts.md#c04) is making a [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) that draws we, with oneself and a [presentation](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c04) counted as a self as object; classing some thing (hereafter this thing) as ours is a distinction with this thing as object; the two delimit their objects by different definitions. This thing does not, by being classed as ours, become another \"[self](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19)\", nor does it thereby enter a shared subject.\n3. **No fixed order required**: read literally, \"ours\" seems to presuppose a [we](concepts.md#c04); this presupposition is a [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) the researcher makes about two names (same type as Conclusion 4.10), not a distinction of a social person; a [social person](concepts.md#c03)'s distinctions are not bound by this order. This paper's definition does not require drawing we before drawing ours, nor drawing [plural you](concepts.md#c05) once there is a we, nor that all four classifications appear. A social person may also first make a distinction about a thing and then draw a we along the dimension of that thing (3.3 Note 3).\n4. **No use or disposal implied**: classing as ours does not imply who may use it, who may not, how it is used or allocated, nor that anyone may demand that others draw accordingly. None of these is in this paper's definition.\n5. **The dimension is drawn by the one who draws**: the same thing can receive different [distinctions](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) from the same [social person](concepts.md#c03) along different dimensions; whether these distinctions agree is not required by the definition.\n6. **No distinction in the record**: the researcher can [record](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c06) the [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) \"this is ours\"; which [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) the speaker actually made cannot be derived from the sentence, nor whether the listener agrees (Conclusion 4.6).\n7. **Effect through use**: \"mine\", \"yours\", \"ours\", and \"yours (plural)\" are [illusory constructs](concepts.md#c01) used by the [belonging distinction of things](concepts.md#c07); they have effect only through the [outputs](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) that use them, such as saying \"this is ours\" and acting accordingly (3.3 Note 9).\n\nCalibration: of the same batch of goods, A classes it as \"ours\" and B as \"yours\"; both are in the same [economic mode](../paper_d244789a_9261_4a0d_a98a_feb8db56b511/concepts.md#c09), yet need not share the classification. This calibrates the possibility that [distinctions](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) disagree; it is not a measurement of the parties' inner distinctions.\n\nCalibration: a [social person](concepts.md#c03) first points at this thing, then draws \"those he thinks can use this thing\" as [we](concepts.md#c04); the dimension of this we is drawn by him through this thing. This is about whom he thinks can use it, not who really can, and it makes no [path](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c07) infeasible for those not drawn in (Conclusion 7.7). Counting oneself among those who can use it draws a we; not counting oneself, as in \"this classroom is for you (plural) to use\", draws a [plural you](concepts.md#c05) (3.4).\n\n### 3.7 Distinction Margin\n\n**[Distinction margin](concepts.md#c08)**: a [social person](concepts.md#c03) makes a [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) along some dimension, so that objects fall on different sides within its distinction. Drawing some [presentations](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c04) as [we](concepts.md#c04) and others as [plural you](concepts.md#c05), or classing things as ours or yours (plural), are examples of distinction margins.\n\nNotes:\n1. **It changes the person; only through output does it change the mode**: a [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) changes the [social person](concepts.md#c03) who makes it; changes in the [economic mode](../paper_d244789a_9261_4a0d_a98a_feb8db56b511/concepts.md#c09) come only through its [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) (Conclusion 5.1).\n2. **Both sides need not have names**: drawing the [margin](concepts.md#c08) of [we](concepts.md#c04) does not require drawing all other objects as [plural you](concepts.md#c05); a classification along a dimension need not exhaust all objects either.\n3. **It belongs only to the social person who makes it**: different [social persons](concepts.md#c03) can draw different [margins](concepts.md#c08) over the same people and things. To say an [economic mode](../paper_d244789a_9261_4a0d_a98a_feb8db56b511/concepts.md#c09) shows \"a [distinction margin](concepts.md#c08)\" means that a social person is able to make a further [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) on material from that mode which has [arrived](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at it, not that the economic mode acquires a shared internal distinction.\n4. This name only joins existing [distinctions](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) under one name and sets up no causal mechanism by which distinctions directly change others or things. Its external effect goes through [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) and [arrival](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) (Section 5).\n\n### 3.8 Inside Outside Difference\n\n**[Inside outside difference](concepts.md#c09)**: a [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) a researcher makes in the [record](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c06) of [outputs](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28): outputs of the same kind differ between members of some group and between those members and participants outside it.\n\nNotes:\n1. **It belongs to the researcher**: which [outputs](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) count as the same kind, which participants form a group, and along which dimension they are compared are drawn by the researcher under a stated [cut](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c23); under another cut the [inside outside difference](concepts.md#c09) can differ. The [record](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c06) contains only the physical changes of each output (Conclusion 4.6). As in 7.2 Note 3, the researcher's group need not match, in range or dimension, the [we](concepts.md#c04) a [social person](concepts.md#c03) draws.\n2. **Not a distinction margin**: a [distinction margin](concepts.md#c08) is in the [social person](concepts.md#c03)'s [history](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13), not in the [record](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c06) (3.7); an [inside outside difference](concepts.md#c09) is drawn from [outputs](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) in the record and is not a [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) of the [social persons](concepts.md#c03) studied.\n3. **It can fall on things**: [outputs](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) of the same kind that differ when directed at some things rather than others also form an [inside outside difference](concepts.md#c09).\n4. **Not a rule or a right**: an [inside outside difference](concepts.md#c09) only describes differences in [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28); it does not imply who is entitled or excluded, and it is not an institution (Conclusions 7.7, 11.2).\n\nCalibration: the same street vendor gives credit to regulars and asks strangers to pay cash. What the researcher [records](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c06) is that two kinds of [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) differ, not the vendor's inner sense of familiar and unfamiliar.\n\n### 3.9 Claimed Boundary\n\n**[Claimed boundary](concepts.md#c10)**: a [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) a researcher makes in the [record](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c06): from an [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) whose content is a classification, it draws the boundary that output proposes. Such outputs include [avowals](concepts.md#c06), classificatory statements about people or things, and classifications written into a [signal container](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c26).\n\nNotes:\n1. **It belongs to the researcher**: which boundary an [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) proposes is drawn by the researcher from that output and judged under a stated [cut](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c23); it is not a reading of the outputter's [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) (Conclusions 4.6, 6.2).\n2. **In the [record](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c06) together with the inside outside difference**: a [claimed boundary](concepts.md#c10) is drawn from an [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) whose content is a classification; an [inside outside difference](concepts.md#c09) is drawn from how outputs of the same kind differ within and across a group (3.8). Both are drawn from [outputs](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) in the [record](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c06) and are not [distinctions](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) of the [social persons](concepts.md#c03) studied.\n3. **Classifications written into a [signal container](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c26)**, such as statutes, certificates, and regulations: the signal container is in [lock-in](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c12) at every step from then on; for a [wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16) to rewrite it is another [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) that arrives at it (definitions of signal container, output, and [arrival](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)).\n\n---\n\n## 4. Properties of Distinction\n\n### 4.1 Drawn, Not Found\n\n**Conclusion 4.1**: [we](concepts.md#c04) is drawn, not found: there is no we that exists ready-made, without [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18), waiting to be discovered. This does not deny the [outputs](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28), [arrivals](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10), and [economic modes](../paper_d244789a_9261_4a0d_a98a_feb8db56b511/concepts.md#c09) that exist before distinction; they are not in themselves a we drawn by some [social person](concepts.md#c03).\n\n(Derived from the definitions of [we](concepts.md#c04) and of [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18): we is an [illusory construct](concepts.md#c01) drawn by a distinction; a distinction draws [what is seen](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c27); it does not discover an object that exists without distinction)\n\nCalibration: \"we Taiwanese\" is not found by a census; a census can count how many hold a certain identity card, but not who draws whom as [we](concepts.md#c04).\n\n### 4.2 Material\n\n**Conclusion 4.2**: the material from which a [social person](concepts.md#c03) draws [we](concepts.md#c04) is only the [history](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13) that has already [arrived](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at it, including others' [outputs](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) and its own past [distinctions](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18). The material for its [belonging distinctions](concepts.md#c07) about things can likewise come only from this arrived history.\n\n(Derived from the definition of [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) and the premise of Section 1: the material of a distinction is only the [history](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13) that has [arrived](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at it before it; its own past distinctions have all arrived at itself and are also in this history)\n\nNote: the material is of two kinds, in the same shape as the [construction of the self](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c28). External: others' [outputs](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28), such as admission, assignment, or being called \"we\". Own: the [we](concepts.md#c04) one has drawn before. How others draw [arrives](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) only through their outputs; what arrives is output, and whatever is read out of it is one's own [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) (definition of [view attribution](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c02)).\n\nCalibration: only after being admitted does one start saying \"our company\".\n\n### 4.3 Material Does Not Determine Distinction\n\n**Conclusion 4.3**: the same material in the [record](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c06) does not imply the same [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18): whether a [social person](concepts.md#c03) draws some [we](concepts.md#c04), and how, and whether it classes some thing as mine, yours, ours, or yours (plural), and how, cannot be derived from the material in the record alone (0.6).\n\n(Derived from the definition of [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18), the scope of the [record](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c06) (0.3), the [wall of provenance](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c08), the [law of the black box](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c25), and the [application assumption](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c50): the [writing](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c29) a distinction leaves has its content determined by the whole [history](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13) up to that time; within it, one's own past distinctions are not in the record (0.3), and one's own origins cannot be fully obtained (wall of provenance); so even if two social persons have the same material in the record, their whole histories may differ. Moreover, under the application assumption, this paper assumes that a [social person](concepts.md#c03) is not in [lock-in](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c12) at the moment of making a distinction; by the law of the black box, even if the whole history were known, its next moment could not be uniquely derived beforehand. This paper does not claim that each such distinction is unpredictable in principle; the latter part holds under the application assumption)\n\nCalibration: given the same admission letter, some say \"our company\" and some say \"I work here\". Judas was one of the twelve disciples, inside that [we](concepts.md#c04); however much material he shared with them, how he would draw next could not be derived. (Signpost: the theological dispute over foreknowledge and freedom. Where they part: by the [law of the black box](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c25), no [wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16) within the [universe](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c02) can uniquely derive beforehand a [decision](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c06) that is not [locked in](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c12); foreknowledge outside the universe is not discussed in this paper.)\n\n### 4.4 On Oneself\n\n**Conclusion 4.4**: a drawing of [we](concepts.md#c04) [arrives](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at the [social person](concepts.md#c03) who makes it and takes part in its later [weights](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06); if this [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) has oneself as object, such as \"I am a citizen of some country\", it is also material of the own kind in the [construction of the self](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c28). In which direction it pushes cannot be derived.\n\n(Derived from the premise of Section 1, the definitions of [wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16) and of the [construction of the self](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c28), and [cognitive obscuration](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c35))\n\nNote: toward others, the [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) drawing [we](concepts.md#c04), and we itself, have effect only through [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28); see Conclusion 5.2.\n\nCalibration: a child is told from an early age, \"you belong to such-and-such family\". Suppose that at that time it is not yet a [social person](concepts.md#c03); if these words [arrive](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at it, they are at that time only [outputs](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) that arrive at it and are outside this paper's scope; when it becomes a social person, the words that did arrive are still in its [history](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13) and are material for its later drawing of \"our family\" (Conclusion 4.2).\n\n### 4.5 Large-Scale We\n\n**Conclusion 4.5**: counting a class as [selves](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19) does not require the [outputs](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) of every member of the class to [arrive](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at the one who draws; the classification content of the class can [arrive](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at it through the [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) of a [signal container](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c26), such as names, identity cards, and textbooks.\n\n(Derived from the definition of [we](concepts.md#c04) Note 4 and the definitions of [signal container](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c26) and [coupling](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c36): the content of a signal container can be written by a [wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16) and [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) to wo at many [moments](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c09); when the same thing [arrives](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at many [presentations](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c04), they are coupled on this arrival)\n\nCalibration: (Signpost: Anderson's imagined communities. Where they meet: members will never know one another, yet feel they belong together; print makes this imagining possible. Where they part: Anderson speaks of a shared imagining; this paper has no shared imagining, only each person's [distinctions](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) and the same batch of [signal container](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c26) contents [arriving](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at each.)\n\n### 4.6 What the Researcher Can See\n\n**Conclusion 4.6**: the researcher's [record](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c06) holds only [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) and the contents of [signal containers](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c26); no [social person](concepts.md#c03)'s [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) is in the [record](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c06). A researcher saying that someone has some [we](concepts.md#c04) is a distinction the researcher makes with that person as object, which may include [view attribution](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c02) (classing some output [arriving](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at the researcher as that person's distinction) or [impression](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c45) (an estimate of that person's [weight](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06)).\n\n(Derived from this paper's scope of the [record](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c06) (0.3) and the definition of [view attribution](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c02): the record does not register the content of [distinctions](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18); classing an [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) as another [self](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19)'s distinction is view attribution and may be wrong)\n\nNotes:\n1. The researcher can see the [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) of an [avowal](concepts.md#c06), but the [record](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c06) does not hold the [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) behind it (Section 6).\n2. The researcher may itself be a [social person](concepts.md#c03), with its own [we](concepts.md#c04) and [plural you](concepts.md#c05). The researcher's classification of others' [outputs](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) likewise falls out under the researcher's [weight](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06) and is likewise in [history](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13), not a reading from outside history.\n3. The same holds for \"mine\", \"yours\", \"ours\", and \"yours (plural)\" about things. Seeing someone point out \"this is ours\", one sees only that [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28), without reading its [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) about the thing (3.6).\n\n### 4.7 History Only Accumulates\n\n**Conclusion 4.7**: the [history](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13) of a [social person](concepts.md#c03) concerning some [we](concepts.md#c04) only grows by appending: something that did not [arrive](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at it then will not arrive at it later; what arrives later is only the trace that thing left; and what has arrived is not erased. So a newcomer and an old-timer, even if they now draw the same we, may have different histories taking part in this [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18): something that had arrived at the old-timer before the newcomer joined, if it did not arrive at the newcomer then, will not arrive at it later. The length of history does not imply how strong this we is, nor differences in [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28).\n\n(Derived from Conclusions 4.2 and 4.4, the definition of [history](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13) in Wo Dynamics, the [law of non-restoration](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c28), and the [wall of provenance](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c08) of *Three Illusions*: history only grows by appending; what did not [arrive](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) then will not arrive later; each drawing takes part in later [weights](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06). The length of history and how strong this [we](concepts.md#c04) is are two independent dimensions: length is how much has arrived, strength belongs to weight (3.3 Note 7), and the definitions do not let the former determine the latter)\n\nNotes:\n1. Calling an old-timer's [we](concepts.md#c04) \"deep\" means that this [history](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13) holds more material concerning that we, appended to its history through [learning](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c04) (definition of learning in the stranger paper); it does not mean stronger identification or loyalty.\n2. What this material takes part in, the party itself cannot fully [distinguish](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) either ([law of attrition](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c26), [wall of the blind spot](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c09) of *Three Illusions*).\n\nCalibration: a newcomer on the first day and a senior of thirty years; immigrants. New immigrants sometimes [avow](concepts.md#c06) patriotism more fervently than locals, showing that the length of [history](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13) does not imply how strong a person's [we](concepts.md#c04) is.\n\n### 4.8 We and Tacit Coordination Do Not Imply Each Other\n\n**Conclusion 4.8**: if a [presentation](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c04) drawn in is a [self](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19), drawing [we](concepts.md#c04) may lead to more [outputs](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) [arriving](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) back and forth between the one who draws and it: the [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) drawing we takes part in the drawer's [weight](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06) and may increase its outputs toward the one drawn in; if these outputs arrive at the one drawn in, and that one's outputs also arrive at the drawer, they become material for [dedicated history](../paper_ae79e938_76e1_4bf9_b2ab_995c03e16c9e/concepts.md#c05); repeated dedicated history may show [tacit coordination](../paper_ae79e938_76e1_4bf9_b2ab_995c03e16c9e/concepts.md#c06). But tacit coordination does not take we as a condition, and we does not take tacit coordination as a condition.\n\n(Derived from the definition of [we](concepts.md#c04) (3.3), Conclusions 4.2 and 4.4, the definitions of [wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16), [edge](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c29), and [arrival](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10), and the definitions of [dedicated history](../paper_ae79e938_76e1_4bf9_b2ab_995c03e16c9e/concepts.md#c05) and [tacit coordination](../paper_ae79e938_76e1_4bf9_b2ab_995c03e16c9e/concepts.md#c06) in the acquaintance paper: the distinction drawing we arrives at oneself and takes part in [weight](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06), and when the weight differs, [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) may differ; output becomes material for dedicated history only when it arrives at the one drawn in through an edge; the criterion of tacit coordination is the dedicated history and behavior pattern between two [selves](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19), requiring neither friendliness nor any [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18); the definition of we does not require dedicated history)\n\nNotes:\n1. [Tacit coordination](../paper_ae79e938_76e1_4bf9_b2ab_995c03e16c9e/concepts.md#c06) is judged dimension by dimension between two [selves](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19); between a [social person](concepts.md#c03) and a class drawn as [we](concepts.md#c04) there is no [dedicated history](../paper_ae79e938_76e1_4bf9_b2ab_995c03e16c9e/concepts.md#c05). Repeated compatible continuation among many people, within a stated dimension and time window and conditioned on [arrival](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10), is [resonance](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c09) (definition of resonance in the stranger paper); the researcher's name for it is [culture](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c13).\n2. Long-time rivals may also have [tacit coordination](../paper_ae79e938_76e1_4bf9_b2ab_995c03e16c9e/concepts.md#c06); a fan who draws distant players as [we](concepts.md#c04) does not thereby have [dedicated history](../paper_ae79e938_76e1_4bf9_b2ab_995c03e16c9e/concepts.md#c05) with them.\n\nCalibration: a senior has a separate [tacit coordination](../paper_ae79e938_76e1_4bf9_b2ab_995c03e16c9e/concepts.md#c06) with each colleague, but no [dedicated history](../paper_ae79e938_76e1_4bf9_b2ab_995c03e16c9e/concepts.md#c05) with \"the company\".\n\n### 4.9 Many We at Once\n\n**Conclusion 4.9**: a [social person](concepts.md#c03) can draw different [we](concepts.md#c04) along different dimensions; these can include one another or overlap; the [distinctions](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) drawing them can also conflict. The definition does not require them to agree.\n\n(Derived from the definitions of [we](concepts.md#c04) and of [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18): we is drawn along some dimension, and the dimension is drawn by the one who draws (3.3 Note 3); a conflict is two distinctions being incompatible)\n\nCalibration: (Signpost: Simmel's intersection of social circles; Merton's role set. Where they meet: a person belongs to several circles at once and stands at their intersection. Where they part: they treat circles as shared; this paper has no shared circles, only each person's [distinctions](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) along each dimension.)\n\n### 4.10 Inclusion Is Also a Distinction\n\n**Conclusion 4.10**: the relation of inclusion between two [we](concepts.md#c04), such as \"the department is inside the company\", is not in the definition of any [we](concepts.md#c04); seeing the two as inclusion is a [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) outside these definitions; a [social person](concepts.md#c03) can draw the department as we without drawing the company as we.\n\n(Derived from the definitions of [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) and of [we](concepts.md#c04): the relation of inclusion is not in the definition of any we; seeing the two as inclusion is a distinction outside these definitions)\n\n### 4.11 When They Conflict, Which Prevails Cannot Be Derived\n\n**Conclusion 4.11**: the [distinctions](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) by which a [social person](concepts.md#c03) draws its various [we](concepts.md#c04) along different dimensions all take part in its single [weight](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06); an [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) of it falls out of the whole weight. So from which we this output comes cannot be derived.\n\n(Derived from Conclusion 4.4 and the definitions of [wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16) and of [own segment](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c17), and the [law of the black box](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c25): each drawing takes part in later [weights](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06); the whole [history](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13) [arriving](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at a wo takes part in its weight; its own segment is fixed by dependence, not by any [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18), and a dimension is a distinction; weight does not fix the result)\n\nNotes:\n1. An [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) may be classed by the researcher as \"loyal\" along the dimension of one [we](concepts.md#c04) and as \"disloyal\" along another; these are all [distinctions](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) the researcher makes after the fact with this output as object, which may include [view attribution](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c02) (Conclusion 4.6).\n2. The [distinctions](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) drawing different [we](concepts.md#c04) take part in the same [weight](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06); by [cognitive obscuration](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c35), pushing one direction up necessarily pushes down the sum of the other directions. A researcher counting which side a person mostly falls toward in such cases gets an [impression](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c45), not a reading of weight (definition of impression: all statistical estimates of a [wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16) are impressions).\n\nCalibration: on an evening of overtime, the [distinctions](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) drawing \"our company\" and \"our family\" are both in his [weight](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06); pushing one up pushes the other down; he stays, and onlookers say he chose the company, but at the moment he stayed, the distinctions drawing both [we](concepts.md#c04) were in the weight. (Signpost: Lazarsfeld and others' cross-pressures; Stryker's identity salience. Where they meet: multiple belongings pull a person in different directions. Where they part: identity theory explains which identity a situation activates by its salience; this paper says which we made him do so cannot be derived, and salience, if taken as a statistical estimate, is by the definition of [impression](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c45) an impression.)\n\n### 4.12 We Under One Name\n\n**Conclusion 4.12**: under the same name, such as the same party or the same country, the [we](concepts.md#c04) of its members are not guaranteed to be the same; drawing a smaller we under the name, such as a faction, is not excluded by the definition either.\n\n(Derived from Conclusion 4.3 and the definition of [we](concepts.md#c04) Note 2: we is one-sided; the same material does not imply the same [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18))\n\nCalibration: \"No factions in the party, only a thousand oddities.\"\n\n### 4.13 People's We and Things' Ours Do Not Imply Each Other\n\n**Conclusion 4.13**: a [social person](concepts.md#c03) drawing B and other [presentations](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c04) into [we](concepts.md#c04) does not imply that it will class some thing as ours; classing some thing as ours does not imply that it will draw some we, nor that the presentations it drew into we will agree. A [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) about people and a distinction about things may be linked, but they delimit their objects by different definitions, and neither implies the other.\n\n(Derived from the definition of [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18), the definition of [we](concepts.md#c04) (3.3 Note 9), [belonging distinction of things](concepts.md#c07) (3.6), and [distinction margin](concepts.md#c08) (3.7): the construct used by the distinction drawing we has [presentations](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c04) counted as [selves](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19) as its object; the belonging distinction of things has things as its object; neither definition implies the other)\n\nCalibration: A draws B as [we](concepts.md#c04), yet classes some thing (hereafter this thing) as \"yours\"; or A may class this thing as \"ours\" while B does not class it so.\n\n---\n\n## 5. Distinction Changes the Person, Output Changes the Mode\n\n### 5.1 Distinction Changes the Person; Only Output Changes the Mode\n\n**Conclusion 5.1**: a [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) changes the [social person](concepts.md#c03) who makes it: it becomes that social person's [history](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13) and takes part in its later [weights](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06). Changes this [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) brings to an [economic mode](../paper_d244789a_9261_4a0d_a98a_feb8db56b511/concepts.md#c09) come only through that [social person](concepts.md#c03)'s [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28); before the output arrives, the mode's existing outputs, [arrivals](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10), feasible [paths](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c07), and [persistence criterion](../paper_d244789a_9261_4a0d_a98a_feb8db56b511/concepts.md#c01) do not change in the [record](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c06) because of this distinction.\n\n(Derived from the definitions of [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18), [edge](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c29), [economic mode](../paper_d244789a_9261_4a0d_a98a_feb8db56b511/concepts.md#c09), [threshold](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c03), and [feasible set](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c11), and Conclusion 4.4: the content of a distinction changes views and does not rewrite [what is seen](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c27); a [node](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25) takes part in another node's [weight](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06) only through [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28); an economic mode is the researcher's classification of nodes' outputs; each drawing takes part in later weights)\n\nNote: this conclusion does not say that [distinctions](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) do not matter. A distinction takes part in [weight](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06); as long as the [social person](concepts.md#c03) who made it is still a [wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16) and this distinction still takes part in its weight, every later [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) of that social person falls out of a weight that includes it (Conclusion 4.11, definition of wo); which output differs because of it, and by how much, cannot be derived ([law of the black box](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c25)).\n\nCalibration: a boss has, in a [decision](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c06), already come down on firing an employee; until it is said, that employee still works here.\n\n### 5.2 Toward Others Only Through Output\n\n**Conclusion 5.2**: a [social person](concepts.md#c03)'s distinction drawing [we](concepts.md#c04), and its [belonging distinctions of things](concepts.md#c07), act on others only through its [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28); the [illusory constructs](concepts.md#c01) it uses, such as we and \"ours\", have effect only through the outputs that use them. What [arrives](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at others is its output, not its [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18); if the others make a distinction of it, that is their own distinction.\n\n(Derived from the definitions of [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18), [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28), and [view attribution](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c02), the definition of [we](concepts.md#c04) (3.3 Note 9), and the [belonging distinction of things](concepts.md#c07) (3.6 Note 7): the material of a distinction is only the [history](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13) that has [arrived](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10); what is exchanged in society is views, not [what is seen](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c27), and if the listener makes a distinction, it is its own distinction of the sentence)\n\n### 5.3 Distinctions May Shape Each Other Through Output\n\n**Conclusion 5.3**: let A and B be two [social persons](concepts.md#c03). If A's output arrives at B, it takes part in B's later [weight](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06) and may change B's later [distinctions](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18); if B's output arrives at A, it may likewise change A's distinctions. If, after A's output has arrived at B, an output that later falls out of B's weight arrives at A in turn, A's output, by way of B, takes part again in A's own weight, forming a loop; the two sides' distinctions may shape each other through this loop. Whether distinctions change, and in which direction, cannot be derived. When either side's [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) no longer [arrives](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at the other, this [loop](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c31) is broken; whether and when it breaks cannot be derived.\n\n(Derived from the definitions of [wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16), [loop](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c31), and [coupling](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c36), Conclusion 5.2, and [cognitive obscuration](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c35): the [history](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13) [arriving](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at a wo all takes part in its [weight](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06); where and how far a change pushes cannot be derived)\n\nNotes:\n1. \"I think you think I am ...\" is a [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) made by the side that says it; the layer \"you think\" is its guess about the other side's distinction, not a distinction the other side actually made (definition of distinction). So however many layers are stacked, they are in the [history](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13) of the side that makes it.\n2. If these layers are distinctions actually made by each side one after another, and not merely multiple layers stated within one [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18), they are not a simultaneous stack: by the definition of distinction, a distinction is not in its own material; by the premise of Section 1, it [arrives](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at oneself only before the next [moment](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c09); if one side's [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) arrives at the other, a distinction the other side makes with it as material has as material only [history](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13) before it that has already arrived at it. So this recursion, if it goes back and forth in time, is the [loop](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c31) of this conclusion. One layer up there is no new kind of act, only the same kind of act applied again; in that case each layer is a distinction (definition of distinction).\n3. By Conclusion 5.2, only [outputs](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) flow on the [loop](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c31), including [avowals](concepts.md#c06) (Section 6) and possibly outputs about things such as \"this is ours\"; [distinctions](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) are in each side's [history](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13), not in the [record](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c06).\n4. The [loop](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c31) of this conclusion is described with the loop of the tools paper and sets up no new concept.\n\nCalibration: two new colleagues: one helps first, the other returns a meal, and they grow closer; or a misunderstanding drives them apart. (Signpost: the \"mutual dominance\" of Yogācāra. Where they meet: *Twenty Verses*, \"through mutual dominance the two consciousnesses become determined\": two minds condition and shape each other, neither directly touching the other. Where they part: Dharmapāla holds that seeds and manifestations are simultaneous mutual causes; this paper's [loop](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c31) has delay, and each [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) [arrives](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at oneself one step late.)\n\n### 5.4 Others' Distinctions and My Feasible Set\n\n**Conclusion 5.4**: if some [antecedent](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c08) of some [path](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c07) of B can be supplied only by A's [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28), then whether this path is feasible depends on A's output; A's output falls out under A's [weight](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06), and if A has made a relevant [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18), it is one part of the [history](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13) taking part in that weight. Whether A's output differs because of that distinction, and by how much, cannot be derived.\n\n(Derived from the definitions of [threshold](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c03), [antecedent](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c08), and [feasible set](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c11), Conclusions 5.2 and 4.6, the definition of [wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16), and the [law of the black box](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c25): if any antecedent is absent, the [path](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c07) is infeasible; when an antecedent can be supplied only by A's [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28), whether it is present depends on A's output)\n\nCalibration: whether a friend lends you money or introduces you to a job decides whether a path of yours is passable; whether he does falls out of his whole person, and whether he counts you as one of his own is only one part. (Signpost: Granovetter's weak ties; Weber's social closure. Where they meet: opportunities are distributed through relationships. Where they part: they treat relationships as observable; in this paper [distinctions](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) cannot be seen, only [outputs](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) can.)\n\n### 5.5 Passable and Passed\n\n**Conclusion 5.5**: if an [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) [arrives](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at a receiver, it can have two kinds of effect on the receiver's paths: first, supplying or removing an [antecedent](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c08) of some [path](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c07), making it feasible or infeasible; second, taking part in the receiver's [weight](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06), making a difference to whether it takes some still feasible path. The second kind does not change a path's antecedents. An output can have both kinds or only one; which it has, and how strong, cannot be derived.\n\n(Derived from the definitions of [threshold](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c03), [antecedent](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c08), [feasible set](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c11), and [edge](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c29), Conclusion 5.4, and the [law of the black box](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c25): the feasible set answers whether something is physically possible, not whether it will happen; [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) takes part in the receiver's [weight](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06); weight does not fix the result)\n\nNotes:\n1. Speech is also [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) (definition of output). If that [path](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c07) is still in the [feasible set](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c11) in that round, and a threat, as speech, removes none of its [antecedents](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c08), the receiver not taking that path is a result falling out of its [weight](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06) (definitions of [threshold](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c03) and feasible set).\n2. Whether a [path](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c07) is feasible in a round is judged by the [threshold](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c03); recording \"did not go\" as \"could not go\" confuses the two kinds of effect.\n\nCalibration: a boss tells an employee, \"You're fired.\" The employee may stop coming to work: that sentence took part in his [weight](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06), and his [path](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c07) is still passable; or the company may deactivate his access card, so he cannot get in even if he wants to: an [antecedent](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c08) of the path has been removed.\n\n### 5.6 Influencing Others' Distinctions Is Still a Wager\n\n**Conclusion 5.6**: a [social person](concepts.md#c03)'s [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) may have others' [distinctions](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) as its object, such as taking a stance, persuading, or proposing a different distinction; if such output [arrives](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at the other, it takes part in the other's [weight](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06), but whether the other's distinction changes because of it, and which way, cannot be derived. Under the [application assumption](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c50), the [decision](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c06) to make such output is still a [forced wager](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c11). The researcher classing some output as having others' distinctions as its object is the researcher's distinction, not a reading of the outputter's distinction.\n\n(Derived from the definitions of [view attribution](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c02) and [wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16), the definition of [decision](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c06), the definitions of [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) and [edge](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c29), [cognitive obscuration](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c35), the [law of the black box](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c25), the [application assumption](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c50), and the [forced wager](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c11))\n\n### 5.7 Distinctions About Things Also Shape Each Other Through Output\n\n**Conclusion 5.7**: A makes an [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) with some thing (hereafter this thing) as its object, such as \"this is ours\"; if this output [arrives](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at another [social person](concepts.md#c03) B, it becomes part of B's later [history](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13) and takes part in B's later [distinctions](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) and outputs about this thing. How B will later draw this thing, whether it makes the same classification, and how its outputs about this thing will fall out, cannot be derived. If B in turn makes outputs that arrive at A or C, the process can continue recursively.\n\n(Derived from the [belonging distinction of things](concepts.md#c07) (3.6), Conclusions 4.2, 4.3, 5.2, and 5.3, the definition of [wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16), and [cognitive obscuration](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c35): others' [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28), once it has [arrived](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10), becomes one's own [history](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13); it does not directly carry others' inner [distinctions](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18))\n\nNotes:\n1. When A says \"this is ours\", the [record](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c06) holds only this [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28); whether A had in fact classed this thing as ours cannot be derived from it (Conclusion 4.6).\n2. A's [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28), if it [arrives](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at B, is material for [distinctions](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) B may later make; it does not guarantee that B accepts this classification; even if B also says \"this is ours\", it does not prove that the two sides' [we](concepts.md#c04) or their \"ours\" are the same.\n3. This conclusion implies no rules of use, restricted use, disposal, or allocation of this thing, nor does it presuppose any ownership of this thing between A and B.\n\nCalibration: A says this thing is ours; B, having heard, says to C that this thing is ours. The researcher can see two [outputs](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28); that the words are the same does not imply that A's and B's [distinctions](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) about this thing are the same.\n\n---\n\n## 6. Avowal\n\n### 6.1 Avowal Changes the Starting Point\n\n**Conclusion 6.1**: once an [avowal](concepts.md#c06) [arrives](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at a [wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16), it is in that wo's later [history](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13) and takes part in its later [weights](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06); so as long as the receiver is still a wo, each later [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) it makes of the avower along this dimension starts from a history that includes this avowal. The same holds when the avowal arrives at the avower itself. A retraction is another [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28); before it arrives, the earlier one has already taken part in the weights of that period.\n\n(Derived from the definitions of [avowal](concepts.md#c06), [arrival](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10), and [wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16), and the premise of Section 1: an arrived [writing](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c29) becomes part of [history](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13) and takes part in later [weights](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06); the avower's [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) arrives at itself before the next [moment](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c09))\n\nCalibration: after a naturalization [avowal](concepts.md#c06), even if one later renounces the nationality, \"once took the naturalization oath\" remains in one's own and others' [history](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13).\n\n### 6.2 Avowal and Distinction Can Diverge\n\n**Conclusion 6.2**: an [avowal](concepts.md#c06) does not imply that the avower has drawn, along this dimension, the class it asks for; even when the avower does draw so, it does not imply how deeply.\n\n(Derived from the definition of [avowal](concepts.md#c06) Note 2, Conclusion 4.6, and the definition of [view attribution](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c02): the [record](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c06) contains only [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28); view attribution can be wrong)\n\nCalibration: (Signpost: Goffman's presentation of self. Where they meet: people present themselves before others, and the presentation can differ from the \"backstage\". Where they part: Goffman assumes a backstage to compare with; in this paper, [distinctions](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) cannot be fully read even by the one making the [avowal](concepts.md#c06) ([wall of the blind spot](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c09)), and there is no backstage to compare with.)\n\n### 6.3 Avowal Returns to Oneself\n\n**Conclusion 6.3**: an [avowal](concepts.md#c06) that [arrives](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at the avower itself is one piece of material for its later drawing of [we](concepts.md#c04); if the avowal has oneself as object, such as \"I am a citizen of some country\", it is also material for the [construction of the self](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c28). In which direction it pushes cannot be derived.\n\n(Derived from Conclusions 4.2, 4.4, and 6.1, the definition of [construction of the self](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c28), and [cognitive obscuration](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c35))\n\nCalibration: someone who has said \"our company\" many times may come to feel it more and more, or may feel ever less sure saying it.\n\n### 6.4 Avowal Reaches Later People Through a Signal Container\n\n**Conclusion 6.4**: an [avowal](concepts.md#c06) placed in a [signal container](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c26) can, when the avower is absent or even after it has made its [exit](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c43), [arrive](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at later receivers.\n\n(Derived from the definition of [signal container](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c26): the content of a signal container can be written by a [wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16) and [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) to wo at many [moments](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c09))\n\nCalibration: oaths, signatures, identity cards, genealogies.\n\n### 6.5 Whether One Draws Accordingly Cannot Be Derived\n\n**Conclusion 6.5**: if an [avowal](concepts.md#c06) [arrives](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at a [social person](concepts.md#c03), whether this social person draws the avower into the class the avowal asks for cannot be derived.\n\n(Derived from Conclusion 4.3, [cognitive obscuration](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c35), and the [law of the black box](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c25))\n\nNote: an [avowal](concepts.md#c06) is [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28); if it [arrives](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at a receiver that is a [wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16), it takes part in the receiver's [weight](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06) (Conclusion 6.1) and may lead the receiver not to take some [path](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c07); it may also supply or remove an [antecedent](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c08) of some [path](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c07); which effect it has cannot be derived (Conclusion 5.5). Making some path infeasible for those who do not draw accordingly belongs to imposing one's [distinctions](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) on others, and is left for later work (Section 11).\n\nCalibration: (Signpost: Austin's speech acts. Where they meet: words themselves do things. Where they part: Austin treats the listener's uptake as one condition for a speech act to succeed; this paper says that once an [avowal](concepts.md#c06) [arrives](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) it changes the starting point; whether it is taken up cannot be derived and does not affect this.)\n\n---\n\n## 7. Economic Mode and Inside Outside Difference\n\n### 7.1 An Economic Mode Does Not Need Second-Order Capacity\n\n**Conclusion 7.1**: an [economic mode](../paper_d244789a_9261_4a0d_a98a_feb8db56b511/concepts.md#c09) does not take participants' having [second-order capacity](concepts.md#c02) as a condition; so it does not take participants' drawing [we](concepts.md#c04), [plural you](concepts.md#c05), or [belonging distinctions of things](concepts.md#c07) as a condition of its standing.\n\n(Derived from the definition of [economic mode](../paper_d244789a_9261_4a0d_a98a_feb8db56b511/concepts.md#c09) in the Pattern paper: the definition takes neither [second-order distinction](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c01), [view attribution](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c02), nor the above classifications as conditions)\n\nNote: so the [economic mode](../paper_d244789a_9261_4a0d_a98a_feb8db56b511/concepts.md#c09) of the Pattern paper, the [resonance](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c09) of the stranger paper, and the [tacit coordination](../paper_ae79e938_76e1_4bf9_b2ab_995c03e16c9e/concepts.md#c06) of the acquaintance paper do not take the [social person](concepts.md#c03) as a condition; this paper does not change them. This does not mean that participants who already have [second-order capacity](concepts.md#c02) certainly make no [distinctions](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18); it means only that the economic mode itself does not take these distinctions as a necessary [antecedent](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c08).\n\nCalibration: the division of labor in rat colonies and ant colonies; the coordination of immune cells.\n\n### 7.2 Distinctions Take Arrived Mode Outputs as Material\n\n**Conclusion 7.2**: when a [social person](concepts.md#c03) makes a [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) with people or things in some existing [economic mode](../paper_d244789a_9261_4a0d_a98a_feb8db56b511/concepts.md#c09) as its object, the material can only be [history](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13) that has already [arrived](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at it: it may include [outputs](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) of that mode that have arrived at it, and also outputs from outside the mode that have arrived at it; a distinction does not arrive before the material it depends on.\n\n(Derived from the definition of [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18), Conclusion 4.2, and the [belonging distinction of things](concepts.md#c07) (3.6): a distinction cannot take [history](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13) that has not yet [arrived](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10))\n\nNotes:\n1. What this paper calls \"second-order reshaping\" refers to a [social person](concepts.md#c03) making further [distinctions](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) about the [outputs](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) of an existing mode, and these distinctions taking part in later [weights](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06) and possibly entering new [loops](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c31) through output (if it [arrives](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at others and comes back). It is a description of this process and sets up no new mechanism by which distinctions directly alter physical structure; a distinction changes the social person who makes it, and the mode changes through its output (Conclusion 5.1).\n2. \"First an economic mode, then reshaping\" means that in the reshaping analyzed here, the [outputs](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) of an existing mode first become material; it does not claim that all [economic modes](../paper_d244789a_9261_4a0d_a98a_feb8db56b511/concepts.md#c09) precede all [distinctions](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) of [social persons](concepts.md#c03) in time.\n3. An [economic mode](../paper_d244789a_9261_4a0d_a98a_feb8db56b511/concepts.md#c09) is the researcher's [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18); what a [social person](concepts.md#c03) draws is its own distinction; the two need not match in range or dimension.\n\n### 7.3 Reshaping Adds Margins of Two Kinds, People and Things\n\n**Conclusion 7.3**: a [social person](concepts.md#c03) can make further [distinctions](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) with the [arrived](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) material of an [economic mode](../paper_d244789a_9261_4a0d_a98a_feb8db56b511/concepts.md#c09) as object:\n1. drawing the existing practice that has [arrived](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at it as a practice, and drawing its own earlier [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) of this practice as a view, rather than a necessary arrangement prior to distinction;\n2. drawing [distinction margins](concepts.md#c08) about people, such as [we](concepts.md#c04) and [plural you](concepts.md#c05), over the participants that have [arrived](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at it;\n3. drawing [distinction margins](concepts.md#c08) about things, such as mine, yours, ours, and yours (plural), over the [presentations](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c04) of things that have [arrived](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at it.\n\nAll three are possibilities; having [second-order capacity](concepts.md#c02) does not guarantee that they occur, and they need not occur in order. Drawing [we](concepts.md#c04) about people does not necessarily bring classing things as ours (Conclusion 4.13).\n\n(Derived from the definition of distinction, Conclusion 7.2, the definitions of [second-order distinction](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c01) and [view attribution](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c02), the definitions of [we](concepts.md#c04) and [plural you](concepts.md#c05) (3.3, 3.4), the [belonging distinction of things](concepts.md#c07) (3.6), and the [distinction margin](concepts.md#c08) (3.7): the boundary itself can be distinguished; the object and the [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) still fall out of each [social person](concepts.md#c03) itself)\n\nCalibration: vendors on a vacant lot set up stalls again and again, and the researcher records them as a night market by their output relations; one vendor later says \"our street\" and, pointing at a batch of goods, says \"this is ours\". Speech is recordable [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28); whether there is in fact a corresponding inner [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) is not in the [record](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c06).\n\n### 7.4 Reshaping Is Still a Wager\n\n**Conclusion 7.4**: if the [outputs](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) of second-order reshaping [arrive](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at another participant, and that participant is a [wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16), they take part in its [weight](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06); whether its later [distinctions](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) (if it is a [social person](concepts.md#c03)) and outputs change because of it, and which way, cannot be derived. After reshaping, the existing [economic mode](../paper_d244789a_9261_4a0d_a98a_feb8db56b511/concepts.md#c09) may continue or may undergo a [criterion break](../paper_d244789a_9261_4a0d_a98a_feb8db56b511/concepts.md#c10); it is not guaranteed to favor continuation.\n\n(Derived from the definition of [wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16), Conclusions 5.3 and 5.7, [cognitive obscuration](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c35), the [law of the black box](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c25), and the definition of [learning](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c04): learning has no preset direction; change is not guaranteed to favor the continuation of the mode)\n\nCalibration: someone says a batch of goods is ours; others keep moving the goods, and someone else takes a different stance; the researcher can [record](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c06) the later [outputs](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28); each person's [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) cannot be derived from these outputs.\n\n### 7.5 We Is Not Necessarily Built on an Economic Mode\n\n**Conclusion 7.5**: drawing [we](concepts.md#c04) does not require that the one who draws and the [presentations](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c04) drawn in be in the same [economic mode](../paper_d244789a_9261_4a0d_a98a_feb8db56b511/concepts.md#c09).\n\n(Derived from the definitions of [we](concepts.md#c04) and of [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) and Conclusion 4.2: the material for drawing we is only [history](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13) that has already [arrived](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10); the definition does not take both sides' being in one [economic mode](../paper_d244789a_9261_4a0d_a98a_feb8db56b511/concepts.md#c09) as a condition)\n\nNote: so this section discusses \"[distinction margins](concepts.md#c08) on an [economic mode](../paper_d244789a_9261_4a0d_a98a_feb8db56b511/concepts.md#c09)\"; it does not claim that all [distinctions](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) drawing [we](concepts.md#c04) or all distinctions about things are produced by economic modes.\n\nCalibration: fans draw the members of a distant team as \"[we](concepts.md#c04)\" without having to take part together in any particular [economic mode](../paper_d244789a_9261_4a0d_a98a_feb8db56b511/concepts.md#c09).\n\n### 7.6 An Economic Mode Shows a Distinction Margin\n\n**Conclusion 7.6**: if a [social person](concepts.md#c03), with people or things of some [economic mode](../paper_d244789a_9261_4a0d_a98a_feb8db56b511/concepts.md#c09) that have [arrived](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at it as material, draws [we](concepts.md#c04), [plural you](concepts.md#c05), or [belonging distinctions of things](concepts.md#c07), then that economic mode shows a [distinction margin](concepts.md#c08) for this social person. This [margin](concepts.md#c08) is drawn by the social person itself; it is not a classification carried by the existing [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) and arrival structure, nor a boundary shared by the other participants.\n\n(Derived from the definition of [distinction margin](concepts.md#c08) (3.7) and Conclusions 7.1, 7.2, and 7.3: an [economic mode](../paper_d244789a_9261_4a0d_a98a_feb8db56b511/concepts.md#c09) can stand without such classifications, yet classifications can be made on the material of the mode that has [arrived](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10))\n\nNotes:\n1. \"Shows\" means only showing within that [social person](concepts.md#c03)'s [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18); for an [economic mode](../paper_d244789a_9261_4a0d_a98a_feb8db56b511/concepts.md#c09) to show an inside and an outside, it goes through its [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) (Conclusion 5.1).\n2. [Margins](concepts.md#c08) about people and about things can overlap, conflict, or appear separately; there is no a priori margin shared by all participants.\n3. A [distinction margin](concepts.md#c08) is in the [social person](concepts.md#c03)'s [history](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13), not in the [record](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c06); its effect on others still goes through [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) (Conclusion 5.2).\n\n### 7.7 A Distinction Margin Implies No Use or Exclusion\n\n**Conclusion 7.7**: a [social person](concepts.md#c03) classing some thing (hereafter this thing) as ours does not imply any particular relation of use, taking, disposal, or exclusion concerning this thing for itself, for those it draws as [we](concepts.md#c04), or for those it draws as [plural you](concepts.md#c05); nor does it imply that other social persons class this thing according to its classification.\n\n(Derived from the [belonging distinction of things](concepts.md#c07) (3.6) Notes 1 and 4, and Conclusions 4.3, 4.13, 5.2, and 6.5: a [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) is neither the definition of a right nor something that directly [arrives](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at others' distinctions)\n\nCalibration: A says this thing is ours; B still uses this thing, and C uses it too. The [outputs](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) of use can be [recorded](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c06); who is entitled to use it cannot be derived from A's [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18); nor can B's and C's distinctions be derived from their use.\n\n### 7.8 Distinctions Take Part in the Mode's Later Operation Through Output\n\n**Conclusion 7.8**: the [distinction margins](concepts.md#c08) a [social person](concepts.md#c03) draws over people and things, as part of its own [history](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13), take part in its later [weights](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06); if the outputs it lets fall [arrive](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at another participant, and that participant is a [wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16), they take part in its later weight; if it is a social person, they may also become material for its further distinctions and outputs. This lets an [economic mode](../paper_d244789a_9261_4a0d_a98a_feb8db56b511/concepts.md#c09) that did not originally take [we](concepts.md#c04) or ours as a condition take in repeated [loops](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c31) formed by distinctions through [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28). Whether particular outputs differ because of some [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18), and which way, cannot be derived.\n\n(Derived from Conclusions 4.4, 5.2, 5.3, 5.7, 7.1, and 7.6, the definition of [wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16), [cognitive obscuration](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c35), and the [law of the black box](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c25): a [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) [arrives](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at oneself and takes part in one's own [weight](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06); only [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) arrives at others; neither beforehand nor afterwards can a whole output be uniquely attributed to some distinction)\n\nNotes:\n1. \"Taking part in operation\" in this conclusion does not mean that some [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) necessarily causes an observable change in [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28); the same output may also fall out under different distinctions.\n2. A researcher who sees A and B both say \"this is ours\" sees only two [outputs](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28); it cannot infer back that they already share a [we](concepts.md#c04), or have the same [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) about the same thing.\n3. The [economic mode](../paper_d244789a_9261_4a0d_a98a_feb8db56b511/concepts.md#c09) can keep continuing by its original criterion; what this paper adds is a description of the sources of material for its later [outputs](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28); it does not replace the Pattern paper's judgments.\n\nCalibration: A says \"this batch of goods is ours\"; B, having heard, may say the same to C, or may not. Either way, once A's words [arrive](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at B, they become part of B's later [history](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13); the [record](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c06) holds only the [outputs](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) of transmission, not whether each person's \"ours\" is the same (0.3).\n\n### 7.9 A Distinction Margin May Make an Inside Outside Difference Appear in the Mode\n\n**Conclusion 7.9**: a [social person](concepts.md#c03)'s [distinction margin](concepts.md#c08) takes part in its [weight](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06); the [outputs](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) it lets fall toward people or things on different sides may differ. If these outputs [arrive](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at other participants, they may make some of their [paths](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c07) feasible or infeasible (Conclusion 5.4); if a participant reached is a [wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16), these outputs also take part in its weight, possibly leading it not to take some still feasible paths (Conclusion 5.5). Therefore, a distinction margin, through output, may make an [inside outside difference](concepts.md#c09) appear in the [economic mode](../paper_d244789a_9261_4a0d_a98a_feb8db56b511/concepts.md#c09) in the [record](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c06). Whether an inside outside difference appears, where it falls, and from which [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) some difference comes, cannot be derived.\n\n(Derived from the definitions of [distinction margin](concepts.md#c08) (3.7) and [inside outside difference](concepts.md#c09) (3.8), Conclusions 5.2, 5.4, and 7.8, and the [law of the black box](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c25): [distinctions](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) take part in [weight](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06); only [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) [arrives](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at others; output can decide an [antecedent](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c08) of another's [path](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c07); weight does not fix the result)\n\nNotes:\n1. A [distinction margin](concepts.md#c08) changes the [social person](concepts.md#c03) who makes it; what changes the mode is the [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) that falls out of its [weight](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06) (Conclusion 5.1).\n2. This conclusion does not say that some [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) necessarily brings an [inside outside difference](concepts.md#c09), nor that an inside outside difference will persist; the same [social person](concepts.md#c03)'s [outputs](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) toward the two sides may also be the same.\n\nCalibration: in hiring, an employee recommends juniors from \"our school\" first; what the researcher [records](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c06) is that hiring [outputs](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) differ between alumni and non-alumni.\n\n### 7.10 An Inside Outside Difference Among Many Does Not Need a Shared We\n\n**Conclusion 7.10**: the [distinction margins](concepts.md#c08) of several [social persons](concepts.md#c03), each through its own [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28), may make the same [inside outside difference](concepts.md#c09) appear in the [record](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c06): in the outputs of many, the researcher sees that outputs of the same kind differ within a group of participants and across it. This inside outside difference does not require these social persons to share a [we](concepts.md#c04), nor that their [distinctions](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) agree; it is judged by output. Changes in each person's distinctions and the movement of the inside outside difference in the record need not be in step: distinctions may change while outputs do not; outputs may change without implying that distinctions have changed.\n\n(Derived from the definition of [inside outside difference](concepts.md#c09) (3.8), the definition of [we](concepts.md#c04) (3.3 Note 2), and Conclusions 4.6, 7.8, and 7.9: each [social person](concepts.md#c03)'s [distinction margin](concepts.md#c08) takes part in the mode through its own [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28); we belongs only to the social person who uses it; the same output can fall out under different [distinctions](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18); distinctions are not in the [record](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c06))\n\nNotes:\n1. Saying that several [social persons](concepts.md#c03) \"all draw someone inside\" is a [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) the researcher makes with these social persons as object, which may include [view attribution](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c02) of each one's outputs; the [record](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c06) holds only their [outputs](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) (Conclusion 4.6).\n2. \"Joining\" and \"leaving\" have two senses: a [social person](concepts.md#c03) drawing some [presentation](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c04) in or out belongs to that social person's [history](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13) (3.7); the [boundary shift](concepts.md#c11) of the inside outside difference in the [record](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c06) belongs to the researcher's [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) (3.8). The two can be out of step.\n\nCalibration: a roommate who lives under the same roof is not counted by the family in \"our family\"; a son who has worked elsewhere for years is still counted in. The names in the household register are the content of a [signal container](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c26) (Conclusion 4.5), not \"our family\" itself. A new daughter-in-law is already treated like family in food and lodging, while her in-laws have not yet drawn her in; a divorced father still draws his child into \"our family\", while his [outputs](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) toward the child are already different.\n\n### 7.11 Claimed Boundary and Inside Outside Difference Can Diverge\n\n**Conclusion 7.11**: if an [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) whose content is a classification arrives at its receivers, and later outputs of the outputter and of other [social persons](concepts.md#c03) [arrive](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) in turn, then if there is an [inside outside difference](concepts.md#c09) in the [record](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c06), it is drawn from outputs the researcher has registered and, under a stated [cut](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c23), counted as of the same kind; these later outputs, if registered and counted as of that kind, may be among them; it is not drawn from the [claimed boundary](concepts.md#c10) alone. When later outputs are incompatible with the claimed boundary, the two can diverge in the record. The gap between them can be registered; how large it will turn out to be cannot be derived in advance, and why it is so cannot be derived.\n\n(Derived from the definitions of [claimed boundary](concepts.md#c10) (3.9), [inside outside difference](concepts.md#c09) (3.8), [record](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c06), [impression](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c45), and [enforcement](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c11), and Conclusions 5.5, 6.5, 7.9, and 7.10: others' impression of a [self](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19) takes as material its past outputs (definition of impression); rules written into a [signal container](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c26) are not guaranteed to be followed; the inside outside difference is judged by [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28); whether one draws accordingly cannot be derived)\n\nNotes:\n1. If the receiver is a [social person](concepts.md#c03), the output whose content is a classification is one piece of material for its later [distinctions](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) (Conclusion 4.2): it can compare later [arriving](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) [outputs](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) with it. The result of the comparison cannot be derived.\n2. A [claimed boundary](concepts.md#c10) and an [inside outside difference](concepts.md#c09) are both [distinctions](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) the researcher draws from [outputs](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28): the former from one output whose content is a classification, the latter from outputs of the same kind, which may include that one (3.8, 3.9); an [inside outside difference](concepts.md#c09) is also not a [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) of any [social person](concepts.md#c03) studied (3.8 Note 2).\n3. This conclusion does not say that the [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) a [claimed boundary](concepts.md#c10) is drawn from has no effect: if this [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) [arrives](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at the receiver, and the receiver is a [wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16), it takes part in its [weight](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06) (Conclusion 5.5).\n4. The gap is relative to the [cut](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c23) and dimension the researcher states (3.8 Note 1, 3.9 Note 1); under another cut the gap can differ.\n\nCalibration: one who [avowed](concepts.md#c06) marriage but does not act like a husband is not treated as a husband by onlookers, while the marriage certificate still names him husband; people smoke where smoking is expressly banned; the company forbids moonlighting, and everyone moonlights; the speed limit on a road is one number, and the actual speed of traffic is another. (Signpost: the debate on names and realities; the Thomas theorem and Merton's self-fulfilling prophecy. Where they meet: spoken classifications and actual consequences can be viewed apart. Where they part: the rectification of names requires names to match realities, while this paper only registers the gap and does not require a match; the Thomas theorem says a definition taken as real is real in its consequences, while this paper says that even if the consequences in the [record](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c06) match the claim, the claim does not thereby become a reading of [distinctions](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18).)\n\n### 7.12 Inside Outside Differences and Claimed Boundaries Do Not Imply Second-Order Distinction\n\n**Conclusion 7.12**: the researcher registering an [inside outside difference](concepts.md#c09) or a [claimed boundary](concepts.md#c10) in the [record](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c06) implies neither that participants have [second-order capacity](concepts.md#c02) nor that the difference or boundary comes from some [distinction margin](concepts.md#c08).\n\n(Derived from the definitions of [illusory construct](concepts.md#c01) (0.5) and [claimed boundary](concepts.md#c10) (3.9), and Conclusions 7.1, 4.6, and 7.8: [second-order capacity](concepts.md#c02) is an illusory construct; a claimed boundary is drawn from [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28); an [economic mode](../paper_d244789a_9261_4a0d_a98a_feb8db56b511/concepts.md#c09) does not take second-order capacity as a condition; [distinctions](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) are not in the [record](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c06); a whole output cannot be uniquely attributed to some distinction)\n\nCalibration: ants recognize nestmates and attack [individuals](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c20) from other nests; chimpanzee groups patrol their territory. (Signpost: Morgan's canon; the \"logical problem\" described by Povinelli and Lurz. Where they meet: from behavior one cannot tell [second-order capacity](concepts.md#c02) from complex first-order behavior. Where they part: they ask how to judge capacity from behavior; this paper's scope of the [record](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c06) does not register [distinctions](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) in the first place, so it makes no judgment.)\n\n---\n\n## 8. We and the Exterior\n\n### 8.1 Two Layers Coexist\n\n**Conclusion 8.1**: other [presentations](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c04) drawn into [we](concepts.md#c04) by a social person (not including itself) are still that [social person](concepts.md#c03)'s [exterior](../paper_d244789a_9261_4a0d_a98a_feb8db56b511/concepts.md#c04) if they are sources of [arrival](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at it.\n\n(Derived from the definition of [exterior](../paper_d244789a_9261_4a0d_a98a_feb8db56b511/concepts.md#c04) in the Pattern paper and the definitions of [we](concepts.md#c04) and of [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18): the exterior is every source of [arrival](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) other than oneself; the content of a distinction changes views and does not rewrite [what is seen](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c27))\n\nNotes:\n1. The [exterior](../paper_d244789a_9261_4a0d_a98a_feb8db56b511/concepts.md#c04) is structural, determined by sources of [arrival](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10), and the researcher's [record](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c06) may register part of it; the [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) drawing [we](concepts.md#c04) is not in the record (Conclusion 4.6). The two layers coexist; the latter does not replace the former.\n2. Drawing [we](concepts.md#c04) does not divide the whole [exterior](../paper_d244789a_9261_4a0d_a98a_feb8db56b511/concepts.md#c04): the part of the exterior not drawn into we remains exterior as in the Pattern paper; how a [social person](concepts.md#c03) draws the rest belongs to content and is not formalized in this paper (3.3 Note 1).\n\nCalibration: family is also [exterior](../paper_d244789a_9261_4a0d_a98a_feb8db56b511/concepts.md#c04): family members' words must reach you to [arrive](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at you.\n\n### 8.2 Crossing the Line Does Not Compose a New Self\n\n**Conclusion 8.2**: the [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) drawing [we](concepts.md#c04) places oneself and other [presentations](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c04) on the same side; but this does not imply that there is a [self](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19) composed of them.\n\n(Derived from the definitions of [we](concepts.md#c04), distinction, [self](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19), and [recutting](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c22): several [presentations](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c04) recut into one presentation is a self only if it is a [wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16) and draws itself as a self by [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18); drawing we is a distinction of a [social person](concepts.md#c03), not a distinction of that whole about itself)\n\nNote: this differs from a [self](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19)'s boundary moving. By the definition of self, who is a self is defined by itself; when the self-definition differs, the self's boundary differs; what the self-definition takes in is part of this self. [We](concepts.md#c04) is the opposite: those drawn in are still counted as other selves. The former is the self growing; the latter is the self unchanged, with other [presentations](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c04) counted as selves beside it.\n\nCalibration: (Signpost: Luhmann's system and environment. Where they meet: a boundary is drawn by the side that draws it, and inside and outside are environment to each other. Where they part: Luhmann's system draws its own boundary; in this paper no group draws boundaries; those who draw are always individual [social persons](concepts.md#c03).)\n\n### 8.3 Drawing as We Is Not an Arrival\n\n**Conclusion 8.3**: drawing [we](concepts.md#c04) [arrives](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at the one who draws (Conclusion 4.4), and does not make the output of those drawn in arrive at the one who draws: whether the [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) of a [presentation](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c04) drawn in arrives at the one who draws still depends on that output and on the [exterior](../paper_d244789a_9261_4a0d_a98a_feb8db56b511/concepts.md#c04).\n\n(Derived from Conclusion 4.4 and the definitions of [arrival](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) and [writing](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c29): a writing counts as arrival only when it falls as a [stimulus](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c30) on a [presentation](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c04); the content of a writing is determined by the [history](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13) up to that time, which includes arrivals from the [exterior](../paper_d244789a_9261_4a0d_a98a_feb8db56b511/concepts.md#c04), and is not determined by this [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) alone)\n\nCalibration: when a typhoon closes the harbor, townspeople who draw their fishing-village relatives into the [we](concepts.md#c04) of their family still cannot get the catch delivered.\n\n### 8.4 Distinctions About Things Do Not Rewrite Their Arrival\n\n**Conclusion 8.4**: a [social person](concepts.md#c03) classing some thing (hereafter this thing) as mine, yours, ours, or yours (plural) does not make the [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) of this thing, or physical changes related to it, directly [arrive](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at anyone; whether they arrive is still judged by the definition of arrival. What output the social person then makes about this thing is not uniquely decided by this [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18).\n\n(Derived from the [belonging distinction of things](concepts.md#c07) (3.6), the [distinction margin](concepts.md#c08) (3.7), the definition of [arrival](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10), and Conclusions 5.2 and 8.3, and the [application assumption](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c50) and the [law of the black box](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c25))\n\n---\n\n## 9. Boundary Shift\n\n### 9.1 Boundary Shift\n\n**Conclusion 9.1**: [outputs](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) whose content is a classification, and other outputs, if they arrive at others, and the others are [wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16), take part in their [weights](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06); the [outputs](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) others let fall may [arrive](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) again at the original outputter and at third parties (Conclusions 5.3, 5.7, 6.3). This recursion may make the [inside outside difference](concepts.md#c09) or the [claimed boundary](concepts.md#c10) in the [record](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c06) differ between [check windows](../paper_d244789a_9261_4a0d_a98a_feb8db56b511/concepts.md#c03); the researcher records this difference as a [boundary shift](concepts.md#c11). The structure of a [boundary shift](concepts.md#c11) in the record can be described by output, for example: differential outputs on the two sides reinforce each other; differential outputs of many turn from compatible to incompatible, and the inside outside difference fades; the outputs a participant receives change from those of one side to those of the other; the distance between the claimed boundary and the inside outside difference lengthens or shortens. Along a stated dimension, these structures can be described by [convergence](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c37), [divergence](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c38), [stasis](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c52), [taiji](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c39), and [merging](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c41). Whether a boundary shift appears, in which direction, and when, cannot be derived.\n\n(Derived from the definitions of [loop](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c31), [coupling](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c36), [convergence](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c37), [divergence](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c38), [stasis](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c52), [taiji](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c39), [merging](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c41), and [check window](../paper_d244789a_9261_4a0d_a98a_feb8db56b511/concepts.md#c03), the definitions of [inside outside difference](concepts.md#c09) (3.8) and [claimed boundary](concepts.md#c10) (3.9), Conclusions 5.3, 5.7, 6.3, and 7.10, and the [law of the black box](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c25): if [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) loops back through [arrival](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10), it forms a loop; a loop's course is judged by output; inside outside differences and claimed boundaries are both drawn from output; [weight](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06) does not fix the result)\n\nNotes:\n1. A [boundary shift](concepts.md#c11) is a [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) the researcher makes by comparing two [check windows](../paper_d244789a_9261_4a0d_a98a_feb8db56b511/concepts.md#c03); the same stretch of [record](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c06) under another [cut](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c23) can be recorded as shifting or as not shifting (3.8 Note 1).\n2. This conclusion only describes the structure of a [boundary shift](concepts.md#c11) in the [record](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c06) and does not predict direction. If polarization makes the [inside outside difference](concepts.md#c09) or the [claimed boundary](concepts.md#c10) in the record differ between [check windows](../paper_d244789a_9261_4a0d_a98a_feb8db56b511/concepts.md#c03), the researcher can record it as one kind (see Conclusion 9.4).\n3. Changes in [distinctions](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) and the [boundary shift](concepts.md#c11) in the [record](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c06) need not be in step (Conclusion 7.10).\n\nCalibration: a new daughter-in-law is at first treated as a guest in food and lodging and, years later, as family: the [outputs](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) a participant receives change from one side to the other; after two companies merge, their two practices toward \"our own people\" gradually merge into one; the company rules forbid moonlighting, at first no one moonlights, later everyone does, and the rules are unchanged: the distance between the [claimed boundary](concepts.md#c10) and the [inside outside difference](concepts.md#c09) lengthens. (Signpost: Wimmer's strategies of ethnic boundary making, such as expansion, contraction, inversion, and blurring. Where they meet: boundaries move, in several recognizable forms. Where they part: they attribute the movement to actors' strategies; this paper describes only the structure of the movement in the [record](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c06), and strategies belong to [illusory constructs](concepts.md#c01).)\n\n### 9.2 Output Toward a Plural You Reaches Those Drawn In\n\n**Conclusion 9.2**: when a [social person](concepts.md#c03)'s [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) made according to some [plural you](concepts.md#c05) [arrives](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at the [presentations](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c04) drawn in, what arrives is output, not [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18); if those drawn in make a distinction of it, that is their own distinction.\n\n(Derived from the definitions of [plural you](concepts.md#c05), [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18), and [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28), and Conclusion 5.2)\n\n### 9.3 Plural You May Become Material for the Other Side's We\n\n**Conclusion 9.3**: if A's [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28), made according to some [plural you](concepts.md#c05) with B and other [presentations](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c04) as its object, [arrives](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at them, and they are [social persons](concepts.md#c03), these outputs are one piece of material for their later drawing of [we](concepts.md#c04); whether they therefore draw a we that includes one another, and which way, cannot be derived.\n\n(Derived from Conclusions 4.2 and 4.3 and [cognitive obscuration](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c35): the material for drawing [we](concepts.md#c04) includes others' [outputs](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28); the same material does not imply the same [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18))\n\nNotes:\n1. B and the others need not have any [we](concepts.md#c04) before A draws [plural you](concepts.md#c05); if such a we later appears, A's [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) is only one piece of its material, not its cause.\n2. Words of A such as \"you mainlanders\" can often be classed by the researcher also as an [avowal](concepts.md#c06): asking the receivers to draw A outside that class. By Conclusion 6.1, if it [arrives](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at them, and they are [social persons](concepts.md#c03), their later [distinctions](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) of A all start from a [history](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13) that includes it.\n\nCalibration: (Signpost: Coser's external conflict and internal cohesion. Where they meet: hostility from outside may unite the side targeted. Where they part: Coser treats cohesion as a function of conflict; this paper says whether cohesion follows cannot be derived, and does not explain by function.)\n\n### 9.4 Polarization\n\n**Conclusion 9.4**: if A draws B and others as [plural you](concepts.md#c05), and B and the others also draw A and others as plural you, and the [outputs](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) both sides make accordingly [arrive](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at each other back and forth (Conclusion 5.3), then the researcher can judge by the definition of [taiji](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c39) whether a taiji is formed; whether it is formed, whether there is [divergence](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c38), and when it stops, cannot be derived; when either side's [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) no longer [arrives](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at the other, this [loop](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c31) is broken.\n\n(Derived from Conclusion 5.3, the definition of [taiji](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c39), and [cognitive obscuration](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c35): a taiji is a structure of two [positive feedback](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c32) [loops](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c31) in opposite directions, [coupled](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c36) and [diverging](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c38); it is judged by [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) and requires the researcher to state the dimension)\n\nNotes:\n1. If polarization makes the [inside outside difference](concepts.md#c09) or the [claimed boundary](concepts.md#c10) in the [record](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c06) differ between [check windows](../paper_d244789a_9261_4a0d_a98a_feb8db56b511/concepts.md#c03), the researcher can record it as one kind of [boundary shift](concepts.md#c11) (Conclusion 9.1).\n2. [Taiji](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c39) is judged by [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28); the two sides' [distinctions](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) are not in the [record](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c06). A researcher saying \"the opposition between the two sides has deepened\" is a distinction the researcher makes with the two sides as object, which may include [view attribution](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c02) (Conclusion 4.6).\n3. By the definitions of [taiji](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c39) and [resonance](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c09), each is judged along a stated dimension; the definitions do not exclude the same participants forming a taiji along one dimension and resonating along another: the two sides [diverge](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c38) along the opposed dimension, while their [outputs](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) along another dimension may still continue compatibly.\n4. What [arrives](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) back and forth on such [loops](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c31) is often [avowal](concepts.md#c06): stances, slogans, emblems. By Conclusion 6.2, they do not imply the two sides' [distinctions](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18); by Conclusion 6.1, they change both sides' later starting points.\n\nCalibration: across the Taiwan Strait, opposition in political stances grows ever deeper, while Taiwanese-owned factories on the mainland keep running and goods keep being exported.\n\n---\n\n## 10. No Shared We\n\n### 10.1 A We Does Not Belong to Two People\n\n**Conclusion 10.1**: a [we](concepts.md#c04) belongs only to the [social person](concepts.md#c03) who uses it; there is no we that belongs to two social persons at once. Whether two social persons' we agree is [not guaranteed](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c02); even if they agree, whether this can be confirmed is also not guaranteed: neither side's distinction [arrives](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at the other side, nor do the two sides' distinctions arrive at the researcher; what arrives is only [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) (Conclusion 5.2); and from output alone it cannot be derived that the two sides' [distinctions](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) agree.\n\n(Derived from the definition of [we](concepts.md#c04), Conclusions 4.3, 4.6, and 5.2, and the definitions of distinction, [view attribution](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c02), impression, and [not guaranteed](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c02): drawing we is one [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) of a [social person](concepts.md#c03); the same material does not imply the same distinction; A's view of how B draws is a distinction A makes with B as object, which may include [impression](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c45) or view attribution)\n\nNotes:\n1. The first half follows directly from the definition; the second half says that even if the two sides' [distinctions](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) happen to agree, whether this can be confirmed is also [not guaranteed](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c02); this does not exclude that, in a concrete case, further constraints make confirmation hold (definition of not guaranteed).\n2. This non-sharing also applies to [belonging distinctions of things](concepts.md#c07); two people using the same name \"ours\" still does not mean there is one [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) made jointly by both (see Conclusion 10.7).\n\n### 10.2 Coordination Needs Only Compatible Output\n\n**Conclusion 10.2**: the continuation of an [economic mode](../paper_d244789a_9261_4a0d_a98a_feb8db56b511/concepts.md#c09) does not require participants' [distinctions](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) to agree; [resonance](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c09) and [taiji](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c39) are judged by the structure of [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) and [arrival](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10), and [mismatch](../paper_ae79e938_76e1_4bf9_b2ab_995c03e16c9e/concepts.md#c08) by whether adjacent output sequences are compatible; none of the three is judged by participants' distinctions.\n\n(Derived from the definitions of [economic mode](../paper_d244789a_9261_4a0d_a98a_feb8db56b511/concepts.md#c09), [persistence criterion](../paper_d244789a_9261_4a0d_a98a_feb8db56b511/concepts.md#c01), [resonance](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c09), [taiji](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c39), and [mismatch](../paper_ae79e938_76e1_4bf9_b2ab_995c03e16c9e/concepts.md#c08), and Conclusion 7.1: an economic mode is judged by the persistence criterion the researcher states, which concerns only [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) and [arrival](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10); resonance takes arrival as a condition and is judged by whether output patterns follow on compatibly; in a taiji each side's output arrives at the other within [coupling](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c36), and [divergence](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c38) is judged by participants' output patterns; mismatch is judged by whether adjacent output sequences are compatible)\n\nCalibration: (Signpost: Parsons's and Luhmann's double contingency. Where they meet: neither side can see through the other, and each one's action depends on its estimate of the other. Where they part: Parsons resolves it with shared value norms, Luhmann with communication systems; this paper needs no shared view at all: the continuation of the [economic mode](../paper_d244789a_9261_4a0d_a98a_feb8db56b511/concepts.md#c09) does not require participants' [distinctions](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) to agree.)\n\n### 10.3 Asymmetry\n\n**Conclusion 10.3**: A drawing B into [we](concepts.md#c04) while B does not draw A into we, this asymmetry can persist while both sides' [outputs](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) are compatible; A's view of how B draws can change through [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) newly [arriving](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at A, or through A's own later [distinctions](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18); the changed view is still a distinction A makes with B as object, which may include [impression](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c45) or [view attribution](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c02), and not a reading of B's distinction.\n\n(Derived from Conclusions 10.1 and 10.2 and the definitions of [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18), [view attribution](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c02), and [impression](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c45): the material of a distinction is only the [history](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13) that has already [arrived](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at it, so for this distinction of A to take in new content from B, something new must arrive at A)\n\nNote: when B has said \"we\" and the like to A as an [avowal](concepts.md#c06), by Conclusion 6.2 it does not imply that B draws so; if B's later [outputs](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) [arrive](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at A and are classed by A as inconsistent with this avowal, they are one piece of material for A to change its view; A may also change its view through other material or its own later [distinctions](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18).\n\nCalibration: a manager usually says \"we are one family\"; on the day the layoff list is published: \"I thought I was one of us.\" Judas was among the twelve; before he handed Jesus over, the others in the same [we](concepts.md#c04) saw only his [outputs](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28).\n\n### 10.4 Taking We as Already There\n\n**Conclusion 10.4**: [we](concepts.md#c04) is an [illusory construct](concepts.md#c01); taking a drawn we as a we already there, waiting to be confirmed, is [illusion](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c14), such as taking \"I am a citizen of some country\" as innate, or taking a name as a shared we. This paper does not further classify which kind of illusion it is.\n\n(Derived from the definition of [we](concepts.md#c04) (3.3), Conclusions 4.1, 4.2, 4.3, and 10.1, and the definition of [illusion](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c14): what one acts on is what [arrives](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at oneself with [lossiness](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c13), not [what is seen](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c27) itself; taking a we one has drawn as already there is taking one's own [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) as the thing distinguished itself)\n\nNotes:\n1. Taking an [avowal](concepts.md#c06) one hears as the other's [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18), such as taking \"I love this country\" as how the other truly feels, is a kind of [world illusion](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c15) (Conclusion 6.2).\n2. A [social person](concepts.md#c03) has [second-order capacity](concepts.md#c02) and can see that [we](concepts.md#c04) is drawn by itself; but being able to see is not seeing. Seeing is itself a [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) and may become a new layer: \"I have seen through it: we is only something I drew\" (definition of [second-order distinction](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c01); [wall of the blind spot](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c09): distinctions about oneself [arrive](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at oneself and become part of oneself).\n3. Guessing how others draw is itself a [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) with others as object (Conclusion 10.1); it may include [impression](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c45) (an estimate of their [weight](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06)) and may include view attribution (classing an output that arrives at oneself as the other's distinction); its material is only the history that has arrived at oneself, and the material of impression is of three kinds: others' outputs that arrive at oneself, the stretch one overlaps with the other, and the [coupling](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c36) the other is in (definition of impression); an [avowal](concepts.md#c06) is only one kind of material, not a reading of distinction (3.5 Note 2, Conclusion 6.2). Taking this guess as the other's distinction is also a kind of [world illusion](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c15): the other's distinction has material and [history](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13) (Conclusion 4.2) but is not uniquely derived from material (Conclusion 4.3); this guess is not a reading, and its correctness is [not guaranteed](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c02). If the other makes a distinction, that is its distinction about the world; guessing it is one more layer of distinction one makes oneself, and what is guessed is the distinction one attributes to the other, which the other may not actually have made (definition of [view attribution](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c02): it may be mistaken; definition of impression). When newly [arrived](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) does not fit this guess, society may seem jarring.\n\nCalibration: \"No factions in the party.\"\n\n### 10.5 We and the Economic Mode Each Continue\n\n**Conclusion 10.5**: an [economic mode](../paper_d244789a_9261_4a0d_a98a_feb8db56b511/concepts.md#c09) continuing or breaking under its [persistence criterion](../paper_d244789a_9261_4a0d_a98a_feb8db56b511/concepts.md#c01) does not imply that participants will later still draw [we](concepts.md#c04) of the same kind or make [belonging distinctions of things](concepts.md#c07) of the same kind; even if participants later make [distinctions](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) of the same kind again, it does not imply that the original economic mode still continues. Neither implies the other.\n\n(Derived from the definition of [criterion break](../paper_d244789a_9261_4a0d_a98a_feb8db56b511/concepts.md#c10) in the Pattern paper, 3.3 Note 7, 3.6 Note 5, and Conclusion 10.2: an [economic mode](../paper_d244789a_9261_4a0d_a98a_feb8db56b511/concepts.md#c09) is judged by a criterion of [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) and [arrival](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) stated by the researcher; whether a [social person](concepts.md#c03) again makes a similar [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) is not in that criterion)\n\nCalibration (assuming each person's [distinctions](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) are as described; they cannot be derived from visible speech alone):\n- The mode continues; someone still draws a [we](concepts.md#c04) of the same kind.\n- The mode continues; someone no longer draws a [we](concepts.md#c04) of the same kind.\n- The mode breaks; someone later again draws a [we](concepts.md#c04) of the same kind.\n- The mode breaks; someone later no longer draws a [we](concepts.md#c04) of the same kind.\n\n### 10.6 A Common World and a Shared We\n\nNote (not a conclusion): why everyone lives in the same world is answered by Wo Dynamics: the [universe](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c02) and [presentations](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c04) are there to begin with, and what [arrives](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at each person is a different part of the same universe, discounted. This paper deals with a layer above: without a shared [we](concepts.md#c04), the [economic mode](../paper_d244789a_9261_4a0d_a98a_feb8db56b511/concepts.md#c09) still continues.\n\nCalibration: (Signpost: Yogācāra's common seeds and the simile of lamps. Where they meet: the *Cheng Weishi Lun* says that the receptacle world each person transforms is different, yet they resemble one another and occupy no different place, \"like the light of many lamps, each pervading and seeming one\". Where they part: Yogācāra explains the resemblance of the world by common seeds; in this paper the common world is the [given](../paper_54c0291d_05b3_431a_9f2a_1b8ec93c3c3f/concepts.md#c03) [universe](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c02), and the simile of lamps falls on the layer of [we](concepts.md#c04): each person's we shines its own, seems one, and never is one.)\n\n### 10.7 No Shared \"Ours\"\n\n**Conclusion 10.7**: A classing some thing (hereafter this thing) as \"ours\", and B also classing this thing as \"ours\", does not imply that A and B make the same or one [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) about this thing, still less that the [we](concepts.md#c04) the two people draw agree. A's and B's different distinctions about the same thing can coexist while their [outputs](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) are compatible.\n\n(Derived from the [belonging distinction of things](concepts.md#c07) (3.6), Conclusions 4.6, 5.7, 10.1, and 10.2: [belonging distinctions](concepts.md#c07) are each in the [history](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13) of the one who makes them; the same [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) does not guarantee the same [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18); the continuation of a mode does not require distinctions to agree)\n\nNotes:\n1. \"Ours\" is an [illusory construct](concepts.md#c01) used one-sidedly, not a shared property of the thing; claiming \"this is ours\" is visible [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28), and not evidence of one and the same [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) in each person.\n2. Even if the name \"ours\" recurs through the [outputs](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) of many, the [record](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c06) holds only the transmission of the name and outputs; there is no [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) shared across many people.\n3. This conclusion does not discuss ownership, who may use the thing, or who may require the other to adopt a classification.\n\nCalibration: A and B both say \"this is ours\" to C, and C says it too. The researcher can record three [outputs](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28), and cannot derive from them a shared \"ours\" of the three.\n\n---\n\n## 11. What Cannot Be Derived, and What Is Left for Later\n\n### 11.1 What This Paper Cannot Derive\n\n- Whether a [social person](concepts.md#c03) will draw some [presentation](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c04) into [we](concepts.md#c04), and how (Conclusion 4.3);\n- whether it will class some thing as mine, yours, ours, or yours (plural); whether people's [we](concepts.md#c04) goes with things' ours (Conclusions 4.3, 4.13, 7.3);\n- after drawing the [margin](concepts.md#c08) of [we](concepts.md#c04), whether it further draws those outside the margin as [plural you](concepts.md#c05) (3.3 Note 8, 3.7 Note 2);\n- whether [distinctions](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) change, and in which direction (Conclusion 5.3);\n- from which [we](concepts.md#c04) an [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) comes (Conclusion 4.11);\n- whether a [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) others make makes the [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) that reaches a [self](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19) any different, and by how much, and what follows for that self's [feasible set](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c11) (Conclusion 5.4);\n- whether [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) with others' [distinctions](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) as object will change the other's distinctions (Conclusion 5.6);\n- whether the receiver of an [avowal](concepts.md#c06) draws the avower according to the avowal (Conclusion 6.5);\n- after second-order reshaping, whether the [economic mode](../paper_d244789a_9261_4a0d_a98a_feb8db56b511/concepts.md#c09) continues or undergoes a [criterion break](../paper_d244789a_9261_4a0d_a98a_feb8db56b511/concepts.md#c10) (Conclusion 7.4);\n- after \"this is ours\" [arrives](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at others, whether they make the same [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18), and whether particular [outputs](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) of use or disposal follow (Conclusions 5.7, 7.7, 7.8);\n- how much of an observable difference in [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) comes from some [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) drawing [we](concepts.md#c04) or some [belonging distinction of things](concepts.md#c07) (Conclusion 7.8);\n- whether a [distinction margin](concepts.md#c08) brings an [inside outside difference](concepts.md#c09), and where it falls; whether an inside outside difference or a [claimed boundary](concepts.md#c10) in the [record](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c06) comes from some distinction margin of the [social persons](concepts.md#c03) studied (Conclusions 7.9, 7.12);\n- whether the [distinctions](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) of several [social persons](concepts.md#c03) overlap; when an [inside outside difference](concepts.md#c09) in the [record](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c06) moves, whether each person's distinctions have changed (Conclusion 7.10);\n- how large the gap between a [claimed boundary](concepts.md#c10) and the [inside outside difference](concepts.md#c09) in the [record](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c06) will turn out to be, as judged in advance, and why it is so (Conclusion 7.11);\n- whether those drawn as [plural you](concepts.md#c05), if they receive [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) made accordingly, therefore draw a [we](concepts.md#c04) that includes one another (Conclusion 9.3);\n- whether two sides that draw each other as [plural you](concepts.md#c05) form a [taiji](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c39), whether there is [divergence](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c38), and when it stops (Conclusion 9.4);\n- whether a [boundary shift](concepts.md#c11) appears, in which direction, and when (Conclusion 9.1);\n- whether the [we](concepts.md#c04) of two [social persons](concepts.md#c03) agree (Conclusion 10.1);\n- whether two [social persons](concepts.md#c03)' \"ours\" about the same thing agree (Conclusion 10.7).\n\nNote: of these, those that depend on Conclusion 4.3 hold under the [application assumption](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c50).\n\n### 11.2 Left for Later\n\n- **Authority, hierarchy, legal persons**: this paper has only each person's own [we](concepts.md#c04) and ours, and no mechanism by which one side's [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) must be followed by another; an [avowal](concepts.md#c06) or a classificatory statement about things is [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28), which, if it [arrives](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at a receiver that is a [wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16), takes part in its [weight](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06) and may lead it not to take some [path](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c07); but this paper has no mechanism by which these words necessarily make some [path](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c07) infeasible for those who do not draw accordingly (Conclusions 5.5, 6.5, 7.7). These three require additional mechanisms and are left for later research.\n- **Other concepts**: ownership, institutions, price, value, money, allocation, and markets are left for later research. \"Ours\" in this paper is only an [illusory construct](concepts.md#c01) used about things; this paper does not treat it as a synonym of ownership, right of use, or rules of allocation.\n\n---\n\n## 12. Cases\n\nThis whole section is calibration and serves as the source of no derivation. When the cases apply conclusions to specific people, they hold, by Section 2, under the [configuration assumption](../paper_ae79e938_76e1_4bf9_b2ab_995c03e16c9e/concepts.md#c01). The two cases are taken from different times and places: the first looks at how a [claimed boundary](concepts.md#c10) written into statute is rewritten and moves; the second looks at how [outputs](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) around a stretch of sea leave an [inside outside difference](concepts.md#c09) in the [record](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c06), and how a boundary not originally written down was later written into law. Expressions in the cases such as \"in order to\", \"wanting to\", or \"identifying with\" are distinctions recorders or later writers make with the people concerned as object, which may include [view attribution](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c02), not readings of [distinctions](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18).\n\n### 12.1 California's Foreign Miners' Tax (1850 to 1870)\n\nNote on data: the sources read are the Wikipedia article \"Foreign Miners' Tax Act of 1850\", the U.S. National Park Service page on Chinese immigration to California, a digital exhibit page of Santa Clara University, and the EBSCO entry on foreign miner taxes in the Gold Rush, all as passages extracted by a tool, not original documents. The sources disagree on the 1852 tax: one says 3 dollars a month, another 4 dollars a month.\n\n1. **[Cut](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c23)**: the range is California's mining districts, with the year as the [check window](../paper_d244789a_9261_4a0d_a98a_feb8db56b511/concepts.md#c03). The [nodes](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25) are the state legislature, the governor, tax collectors, miners from various places, and the [signal container](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c26) in which the statute is written. The [outputs](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) of the same kind the researcher compares are miners' paying the tax, being driven off, and leaving the mines.\n2. **Initial state**: from 1848, the gold-mining structure in the mining districts recurred year by year, with miners from many places; there was no tax by origin in the [record](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c06).\n3. **New [arrival](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)**: on 13 April 1850, Governor Burnett signed an act levying 20 dollars a month on miners who were not U.S. citizens and had not become citizens under the Treaty of Guadalupe Hidalgo; California Native Americans were exempt.\n4. **[Claimed boundary](concepts.md#c10) and [inside outside difference](concepts.md#c09)**:\n - The statute, written into a [signal container](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c26), proposes a boundary, from which the researcher can draw a [claimed boundary](concepts.md#c10): citizens inside, non-citizens outside.\n - After protests by Irish, English, Canadian, and German miners, the statute was rewritten to exempt \"free white persons\" and miners who could become U.S. citizens.\n - On 19 May 1850, about four thousand miners, mostly Mexican and Peruvian, protested in Sonora; a militia of about five hundred tax collectors and Anglo miners drove them off.\n - Many Mexican and Chinese miners left the mines; revenue fell far short of the expected two hundred thousand dollars.\n5. **[Boundary shift](concepts.md#c11)**:\n - In 1851, under Governor McDougall, the act was repealed.\n - In 1852 a foreign miners' license tax was enacted, with the amount raised gradually afterwards; the National Park Service page records it as aimed at Chinese immigrants.\n - By the time the law was voided in 1870, Chinese miners had paid more than five million dollars in taxes, about a quarter of the state's revenue in that period.\n6. **What it shows**:\n - A statute is a classification written into a [signal container](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c26); from then on it is in [lock-in](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c12) at every step along with the [signal container](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c26); rewriting, repeal, and re-enactment are each another [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) that arrives at it, and before it [arrives](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10), the earlier one has already taken part in the [weights](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06) of that period (3.9 Note 3, definition of [wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)).\n - Paying the tax, being driven off, and leaving the mines are [outputs](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) comparable in the [record](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c06); a researcher comparing them grouped by origin obtains an [inside outside difference](concepts.md#c09) (3.8). Under another grouping the result can differ.\n - The sources place the rewriting of the statute after the protests of European miners: if the protests [arrived](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at the legislators, they took part in their [weight](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06); later [outputs](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) changed the [claimed boundary](concepts.md#c10). Whether the protests had an effect thereby, and how much, cannot be derived (Conclusion 5.6).\n - Between 1850 and 1870 the [claimed boundary](concepts.md#c10) was rewritten, repealed, and re-enacted, and the miners the tax was recorded by the sources as aimed at also shifted from Mexicans and others to Chinese; the researcher can record this as a [boundary shift](concepts.md#c11) (Conclusion 9.1).\n - Miners leaving the mines may be the tax removing an [antecedent](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c08) of the [path](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c07) of lawful mining, or the tax taking part in their [weight](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06) so that they did not take a path that was still feasible; which, cannot be derived (Conclusion 5.5).\n7. **What is in the record and what cannot be derived**:\n - In the record: what the statute said, and when it was rewritten, repealed, and re-enacted; the events of protest and pursuit; revenue falling short of expectations; the total and share paid by Chinese miners.\n - Cannot be derived: whom the legislators, tax collectors, or Anglo miners drew as [we](concepts.md#c04) and whom as [plural you](concepts.md#c05); why any miner left; what the population of the mining districts would have been without this tax.\n\n### 12.2 Maine's Lobster Waters (Twentieth Century)\n\nNote on data: the source read is Waring and Acheson, \"Evidence of cultural group selection in territorial lobstering in Maine\" (2017), as passages extracted by a tool, not the original; its account of harbor gangs and their waters mostly cites Acheson's works of 1975, 1988, and 2003.\n\n1. **[Cut](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c23)**: the range is lobster fishing along the Maine coast, with the year as the [check window](../paper_d244789a_9261_4a0d_a98a_feb8db56b511/concepts.md#c03). The [nodes](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25) are the fishermen of each harbor, the state legislature, and the marine resources authority; the sea is the [natural environment](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c16). The [outputs](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) of the same kind the researcher compares are setting traps in some stretch of sea and what is done to others' traps.\n2. **Initial state**: state law requires a state license to set lobster traps; damaging others' traps is illegal.\n3. **Structures that appear**:\n - The fishermen of each harbor form a harbor gang and hold an unofficial stretch of sea bounded by coves, ledges, river mouths, and buoys, usually under a hundred square miles; a gang has as few as eight boats and rarely more than fifty.\n - When people from other harbors come in to set traps, they first receive verbal warnings, then their traps are destroyed; those whose traps are destroyed often retaliate.\n - Legally, a license is enough to fish; unofficially, one must also be accepted by the harbor gang.\n - Mainland harbors mostly defend strongly near the harbor and more loosely farther out; island harbors and a few mainland harbors defend the whole area to its outer edge, with clear boundaries.\n4. **[Claimed boundary](concepts.md#c10) and [inside outside difference](concepts.md#c09)**:\n - State law proposes a boundary, from which the researcher can draw a [claimed boundary](concepts.md#c10): license holders inside, those without outside.\n - The harbor gang's warnings are [outputs](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) whose content is a classification, proposing another boundary, from which the researcher can draw another [claimed boundary](concepts.md#c10): people of this harbor inside, people of other harbors outside. This boundary was at first not written into a [signal container](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c26).\n - The [inside outside difference](concepts.md#c09) in the [record](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c06): setting traps in the same stretch of sea, the traps of people of this harbor stay, while those of people from other harbors are destroyed.\n5. **[Boundary shift](concepts.md#c11)**:\n - Around 1960, fishermen of upper Muscongus Bay began setting traps at the mouth of the bay in fall and winter, and cut traps back and forth with the fishermen of New Harbor and Round Pond for years; the upper-bay fishermen gradually moved into the outer bay, which became a mixed fishing area.\n - In 1984, the fishermen of Swan's Island petitioned the marine resources authority to turn their formerly unofficial waters into an official conservation zone, excluding mainland fishermen and setting a limit of 475 traps. In 1998 Monhegan also obtained special status by legislation, barring boats from other harbors from fishing within two miles of the island.\n - The lobster zone management law of 1995 drew seven legal zones along the coast, with zone councils elected by license holders.\n6. **What it shows**:\n - If some fisherman classes this stretch of sea as ours, that is a [belonging distinction of things](concepts.md#c07) belonging to him and not in the [record](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c06); the record holds only [outputs](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) such as warnings, trap setting, and trap cutting. Which trap cutting comes from such a [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) cannot be derived (3.6, Conclusions 4.6, 7.9).\n - State law says all license holders may fish, yet in the [record](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c06) the traps of people from other harbors in this stretch of sea are destroyed: the state law's [claimed boundary](concepts.md#c10) and the [inside outside difference](concepts.md#c09) in the record diverge (Conclusion 7.11).\n - Trap cutting may have removed an [antecedent](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c08) of the [path](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c07) of fishermen from other harbors in this stretch of sea, or may only have taken part in their [weight](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06) so that they no longer came in; which, cannot be derived. Warnings may also only take part in the receiver's [weight](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06) without removing an [antecedent](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c08); which effect they have cannot be derived (Conclusion 5.5).\n - Even if the harbor gang's fishermen class the waters as ours, it does not imply who is entitled to use them: under state law, license holders from other harbors can still fish there, and trap cutting is illegal (Conclusion 7.7).\n - The warnings and trap cutting of several fishermen make up the same [inside outside difference](concepts.md#c09) in the [record](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c06), without requiring them to share a [we](concepts.md#c04) or their [distinctions](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) to agree (Conclusions 7.10, 10.1).\n - The expansion of upper Muscongus Bay is a [boundary shift](concepts.md#c11) of the inside outside difference in the [record](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c06); the conservation zones and the zone management law wrote into a [signal container](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c26) a boundary previously proposed only by warnings, and the new [claimed boundary](concepts.md#c10) moved toward the existing [inside outside difference](concepts.md#c09); the inside outside difference after the legislation is not in the data (Conclusion 9.1).\n7. **What is in the record and what cannot be derived**:\n - In the record: what the state law said; the rough extent and defense of the harbor gangs' waters; the warnings and trap cutting suffered by people from other harbors; the expansion around 1960; the legal changes of 1984, 1995, and 1998.\n - Cannot be derived: whom any fisherman drew as [we](concepts.md#c04), and which stretch of sea he classed as ours; from which [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) some trap cutting came; why the harbor gangs formed here; whether each person's distinctions changed after the conservation zones were set up.\n\n---\n\n## 13. General Proposition\n\n**General proposition**: the standing and continuation of an [economic mode](../paper_d244789a_9261_4a0d_a98a_feb8db56b511/concepts.md#c09) do not need any participant to draw [we](concepts.md#c04). Once a [social person](concepts.md#c03) has [second-order capacity](concepts.md#c02), it can, on the material of an existing economic mode that has [arrived](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at it, draw we and [plural you](concepts.md#c05) about people, and make [belonging distinctions](concepts.md#c07) about things, using [illusory constructs](concepts.md#c01) such as mine, yours, ours, and yours (plural), so that the mode shows, for this social person, a [distinction margin](concepts.md#c08) drawn by itself. The [margin](concepts.md#c08) does not belong to the mode itself, does not require other social persons to agree, and implies no relation of ownership, use, disposal, exclusion, or allocation.\n\nOnce made, these [distinctions](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) become the [social person](concepts.md#c03)'s own [history](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13) and take part in its later [weights](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06); the [outputs](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) it lets fall toward people and things on the two sides of the [margin](concepts.md#c08) may differ; if these outputs [arrive](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at others, they may change others' feasible [paths](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c07); if the others are social persons, they may also become material for their later distinctions and outputs. In this way a [distinction margin](concepts.md#c08), through output, may make an [inside outside difference](concepts.md#c09) appear in an [economic mode](../paper_d244789a_9261_4a0d_a98a_feb8db56b511/concepts.md#c09) in the record: outputs of the same kind differ within a group of participants and across it. Each person's unshared distinctions drawing [we](concepts.md#c04) and [belonging distinctions of things](concepts.md#c07), if each person's outputs arrive at one another, may also shape each other through output; this recursion may produce a [boundary shift](concepts.md#c11) in the [record](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c06). Differential outputs of several social persons may make up the same inside outside difference in the record, without requiring them to share a we. Spoken and written classifications, if registered in the record, are material from which the researcher can draw [claimed boundaries](concepts.md#c10), while an inside outside difference in the record, if any, is drawn from outputs of the same kind that the researcher has registered, later outputs possibly among them if registered and classed as the same kind, so the two can diverge. An inside outside difference in the record does not imply that participants have [second-order capacity](concepts.md#c02). As for who makes which distinction, how distinctions change, whether an inside outside difference appears, where it falls, from which distinction some difference really comes, and whether the mode therefore continues or breaks, this paper derives none of these uniquely.\n\n(A summary of Conclusions 5.3, 5.7, 7.1, 7.3, 7.6, 7.7, 7.8, 7.9, 7.10, 7.11, 7.12, 10.1, 10.2, and 10.7; the parts that depend on Conclusion 4.3 hold under the [application assumption](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c50).)\n\n---\n\n## Open Issues\n\n1. The [distinctions](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) about things in 3.6 currently handle only \"mine, yours, ours, yours (plural)\"; whether to handle other classes is left to later papers.\n"}]}
{"paper_uuid":"2ccbf179-58cf-4851-bd72-5fa886e4b2c3","paper_title":"互動動力學-陌生人迴路中的專屬歷史變動與更新","paper_title_en":"Interaction Dynamics - Changes and Updates of Dedicated History in Stranger Loops","author":"黃正宇 / Cheng Yu Huang","contact":"mthree.tw@gmail.com","concepts_md":"---\nuuid: 2ccbf179-58cf-4851-bd72-5fa886e4b2c3\nlast-modified: 2026-10-17T02:05:51\n---\n\n\n## public 單元 / Unit\n\n- 定義:在一次[切法](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c23)下,兩個[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)、各自的[小迴路](concepts.md#c02),以及把兩者連起來的[大迴路](concepts.md#c03)所構成的結構。單元必須講明在哪個維度上判斷。[信號容器](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c26)與[隨機源](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c27)可以接在單元的[邊](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c29)上,但不是單元的主體。\n- Definition: The structure formed, under one [cut](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c23), by two [Wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16), the [small loop](concepts.md#c02) of each, and the [large loop](concepts.md#c03) connecting them. A unit must state the dimension in which it is judged. A [signal container](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c26) or a [random source](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c27) may attach to an [edge](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c29) of the unit but is not its main body.\n\n\n## public 小迴路 / Small Loop\n\n- 定義:一個[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)回到自己的[歷史](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13)、參與自己之後的[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06)的[迴路](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c31)。只有[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)有小迴路;[信號容器](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c26)與[隨機源](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c27)沒有。\n- Definition: The [loop](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c31) in which the [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) of a [Wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16) returns to its own [history](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13) and takes part in its later [weight](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06). Only a [Wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16) has a small loop; a [signal container](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c26) or a [random source](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c27) does not.\n\n\n## public 大迴路 / Large Loop\n\n- 定義:連接兩個[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)的[迴路](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c31):甲的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)乙,乙的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)甲,各自參與對方之後的[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06)。\n- Definition: The [loop](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c31) connecting two [Wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16): the [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) of A has [arrival](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at B, the output of B has arrival at A, and each takes part in the other's later [weight](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06).\n\n\n## public 學習 / Learning\n\n- 定義:[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)的材料累積進[歷史](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13)、可能改變後續[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06)的過程。[學習](concepts.md#c04)是結果條件,不指目的,沒有預設方向,不保證學到,也不保證學對。判定只看[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)之後可觀察的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)有改變,不證明改變來自哪一筆[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)。\n- Definition: The process by which material that has had [arrival](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) accumulates in [history](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13) and may change later [weight](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06). [Learning](concepts.md#c04) is a result condition, not a purpose; it has no preset direction and guarantees neither that something is learned nor that it is learned correctly. It is judged only by an observable change in [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) after [arrival](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10), and does not show which [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) caused the change.\n\n\n## public 結果回饋 / Outcome Feedback\n\n- 定義:一個[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)之後的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)再[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)自己的後續互動,帶回實際後果。事前[學習](concepts.md#c04)的方向不可預測,事後的結果可以判;判準在其他[節點](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25)與[自然環境](concepts.md#c16)的反應結果裡,不在發生[學習](concepts.md#c04)的[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)內部。\n- Definition: The actual consequence brought back when the later [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) of a [Wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16) has [arrival](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) in its own subsequent interactions. The direction of [learning](concepts.md#c04) cannot be predicted beforehand, while the result can be judged afterwards; the criterion lies in the responses of other [node](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25) and the [natural environment](concepts.md#c16), not inside the [Wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16) in which [learning](concepts.md#c04) occurs.\n\n\n## public 退出成本 / Exit Cost\n\n- 定義:一個[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19)讓一條[邊](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c29)上的[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)停止或減少時,要承受的[結果回饋](concepts.md#c05)。每一端各算各的,可以不對稱。成本低,就是可以輕易放棄這條[邊](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c29);成本高,就是幾乎不得不繼續。退出成本的層級是[邊](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c29),與[節點](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25)層級的[退場](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c43)不同,兩者不互相蘊含。\n- Definition: The [outcome feedback](concepts.md#c05) that a [Self](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19) must bear when it stops or reduces [arrival](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) on an [edge](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c29). Each end counts its own, and the two may be asymmetric. Low cost means the edge can be given up easily; high cost means one can hardly help continuing. Exit cost is at the level of the [edge](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c29), unlike [exit](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c43) at the level of the [node](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25), and neither implies the other.\n\n\n## public 可達子圖 / Reachable Subgraph\n\n- 定義:以某個[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)為中心,在講明的時窗內,所有曾有[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)它的[呈現](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c04),連同這些[呈現](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c04)與它之間的[邊](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c29)所構成的子圖。只計已[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)者。每個[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)各有一張。\n- Definition: The subgraph centered on a [Wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16), within a stated time window, made of all [presentation](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c04) whose [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) has had [arrival](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at it, together with the [edge](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c29) between each of them and it. Only what has already had arrival counts. Each [Wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16) has its own.\n\n\n## public 大型節點 / Large Node\n\n- 定義:在講明的[切法](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c23)與時窗內,[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)的[節點](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25)數極大、幾乎涵蓋所指範圍內每一個[節點](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25)的[節點](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25),例如政府、公眾人物、大型企業。它是真實存在的[節點](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25);[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)廣不蘊含影響大,不蘊含全知,也不蘊含有目的。\n- Definition: A [node](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25) whose [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) has [arrival](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at an extremely large number of nodes, almost every [node](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25) in the stated range, within a stated [cut](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c23) and time window; for example a government, a public figure or a large enterprise. It is a real node. Wide [arrival](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) does not imply large influence, omniscience or purpose.\n\n\n## public 共振 / Resonance\n\n- 定義:在講明的維度與時窗內,多個[節點](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25)的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)模式反覆相容接續。[共振](concepts.md#c09)須以[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)為條件:[節點](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25)彼此之間有[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10),或有共同的來源(例如[信號容器](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c26)、[自然環境](concepts.md#c16))對它們都有[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10);完全沒有[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10),就沒有[共振](concepts.md#c09)。判準是相容,也就是[失配](../paper_ae79e938_76e1_4bf9_b2ab_995c03e16c9e/concepts.md#c08)的反面,不是距離;因此不等於[趨同](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c37)。是否[共振](concepts.md#c09),只能事後說。[共振](concepts.md#c09)不同於[默契](../paper_ae79e938_76e1_4bf9_b2ab_995c03e16c9e/concepts.md#c06):[默契](../paper_ae79e938_76e1_4bf9_b2ab_995c03e16c9e/concepts.md#c06)是兩個[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19)之間按維度計的[專屬歷史](../paper_ae79e938_76e1_4bf9_b2ab_995c03e16c9e/concepts.md#c05)上的相容接續,[共振](concepts.md#c09)不要求[專屬歷史](../paper_ae79e938_76e1_4bf9_b2ab_995c03e16c9e/concepts.md#c05),也不限兩個[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19)。\n- Definition: Within a stated dimension and time window, the repeated compatible succession of the [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) patterns of several [node](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25). [Resonance](concepts.md#c09) requires [arrival](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10): either arrival between the [node](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25)s, or arrival at all of them from a common source (such as a [signal container](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c26) or the [natural environment](concepts.md#c16)). Without any arrival, there is no [resonance](concepts.md#c09). The criterion is compatibility, the opposite of [mismatch](../paper_ae79e938_76e1_4bf9_b2ab_995c03e16c9e/concepts.md#c08), not distance; hence it is not [convergence](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c37). Whether [resonance](concepts.md#c09) holds can only be said afterwards. [Resonance](concepts.md#c09) differs from [tacit coordination](../paper_ae79e938_76e1_4bf9_b2ab_995c03e16c9e/concepts.md#c06), which is compatible succession on the [dedicated history](../paper_ae79e938_76e1_4bf9_b2ab_995c03e16c9e/concepts.md#c05) between two [Self](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19) counted per dimension; [resonance](concepts.md#c09) does not require [dedicated history](../paper_ae79e938_76e1_4bf9_b2ab_995c03e16c9e/concepts.md#c05) and is not limited to two [Self](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19).\n\n\n## public 懲罰 / Penalty\n\n- 定義:一個[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)之後,[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)輸出者的、在講明的判準下算作代價的[結果回饋](concepts.md#c05)。判準須講明是誰的:輸出者自己的[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18),或研究者的判準,兩者可以不一致。懲罰不一定是暴力,不一定被明列。\n- Definition: A [outcome feedback](concepts.md#c05) that has [arrival](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at the producer after an [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) and counts as a cost under a stated criterion. The criterion must say whose it is: the producer's own [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) or the researcher's criterion, and the two may disagree. A penalty need not be violent or explicitly listed.\n\n\n## public 強制 / Enforcement\n\n- 定義:已被明列成規則、寫在[信號容器](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c26)裡、違反可由第三方判定的[懲罰](concepts.md#c10)。[懲罰](concepts.md#c10)可以是暴力,也可以不是。[強制](concepts.md#c11)不保證遵守,也不保證違反被判定與執行;規則先於違反,是另一個時間點的事。\n- Definition: A [penalty](concepts.md#c10) that has been explicitly listed as a rule, written in a [signal container](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c26), with violation judgeable by a third party. The penalty may or may not be violent. [Enforcement](concepts.md#c11) guarantees neither compliance nor that violations are judged and carried out; the rule precedes the violation, at another point in time.\n\n\n## public 容錯率 / Fault Tolerance\n\n- 定義:在講明的維度上,一個[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19)對對方的[失配](../paper_ae79e938_76e1_4bf9_b2ab_995c03e16c9e/concepts.md#c08)所能容忍的程度的上限;超過上限,這條[邊](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c29)就可能終止。\n- Definition: The upper limit, in a stated dimension, of the degree of [mismatch](../paper_ae79e938_76e1_4bf9_b2ab_995c03e16c9e/concepts.md#c08) by the other side that a [Self](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19) can tolerate; beyond it the [edge](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c29) may terminate.\n\n\n## public 文化 / Culture\n\n- 定義:研究者對網路中出現的[共振](concepts.md#c09)的命名。在指定的[切法](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c23)、維度與時窗下,它是無數[單元](concepts.md#c01)在特定[自然環境](concepts.md#c16)約束下,經過反覆的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)、[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)與[結果回饋](concepts.md#c05),留在[歷史](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13)中的一組相容圖樣:哪些維度組合能不被反覆打斷地接續下去。文化不以是否寫下來為界,沒有主體,不被某人持有或傳遞,也沒有尺度。\n- Definition: A researcher's name for a [resonance](concepts.md#c09) appearing in the network. Under a specified [cut](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c23), dimension and time window, it is a set of compatible patterns left in [history](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13) by countless [unit](concepts.md#c01) through repeated [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28), [arrival](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) and [outcome feedback](concepts.md#c05) under particular [natural environment](concepts.md#c16) constraints: which combinations of dimensions can continue without being repeatedly interrupted. Culture is not bounded by whether it is written down, has no subject, is not held or transmitted by anyone, and has no scale.\n\n\n## public 模板 / Template\n\n- 定義:抽象化、可重複使用的規則或資料,被明列在[信號容器](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c26)裡。[容器](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c26)被[鎖死](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c12),內容不會自己變,在某維度上提供固定點,不需要先[共振](concepts.md#c09)就能取得。同一規則有兩份文本就是兩份模板。模板是[容器](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c26)裡的固定內容,不是[文化](concepts.md#c13)的一層。模板的有無依研究者指定的判準判定。\n- Definition: Abstracted, reusable rules or data explicitly listed in a [signal container](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c26). The [container](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c26) is [lock-in](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c12), so the content does not change by itself and provides a fixed point in some dimension, obtainable without first having [resonance](concepts.md#c09). Two texts of the same rule are two templates. A template is fixed content in a [container](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c26), not a layer of [culture](concepts.md#c13). Whether a template exists is judged by a criterion the researcher specifies.\n\n\n## public 崩潰 / Collapse\n\n- 定義:在指定尺度、維度與時窗下,原來的秩序失去了;秩序指不必逐次指導就能相容接續的預設與接續模式。事後的[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18),由作判斷的[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19)劃定。崩潰有程度、逐維度,沒有尺度。崩潰與[失配](../paper_ae79e938_76e1_4bf9_b2ab_995c03e16c9e/concepts.md#c08)、[退場](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c43)判準不同,可為成因或形態,不互相蘊含。\n- Definition: Under a specified scale, dimension and time window, the loss of the former order; order means defaults and patterns of succession that are compatible without being directed each time. It is an after-the-fact [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18), drawn by the [Self](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19) who makes the judgment. Collapse comes in degrees and per dimension, with no scale. Collapse differs in criterion from [mismatch](../paper_ae79e938_76e1_4bf9_b2ab_995c03e16c9e/concepts.md#c08) and [exit](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c43); it can be a cause or a form of them, and neither implies the other.\n\n\n## public 自然環境 / Natural Environment\n\n- 定義:在講明的[切法](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c23)下,不屬於模型中任何[節點](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25)、卻有[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)這些[節點](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25)的部分,包含物理條件,例如地形、氣候、水與食物。它對各[節點](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25)最基本的行為構成約束。\n- Definition: The part which, under a stated [cut](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c23), belongs to no [node](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25) in the model yet whose [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) has [arrival](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at these [node](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25), including physical conditions such as terrain, climate, water and food. It constrains the most basic behavior of each [node](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25).\n\n\n## public 落空比例 / Proportion of Failed Expectations\n\n- 定義:在指定的維度與時窗下,事後統計的、原本相容的接續中未能接上的比例。它是外顯統計,不是真實[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06)的讀數。\n- Definition: The after-the-fact statistical proportion, under a specified dimension and time window, of originally compatible successions that failed to connect. It is an outward statistic, not a reading of true [weights](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06).\n\n\n## private 外顯資料 / Outward Data\n\n- 定義:被選中、被表達出來的結果及其摘要。外顯資料不等於完整的[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06)與依賴路徑。\n- Definition: The results that are selected and expressed, and their summaries. Outward data are not equal to the complete [weights](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06) and dependence paths.\n\n## 不登記\n\n- 名聲:2026-10-17 作者裁決:日常用語。\n- 禮節:2026-10-17 作者裁決:日常用語。\n- 時窗:2026-10-17 切法的組成之一,已由上游「切法」涵蓋;本篇未另行定義。\n- 維度:2026-10-17 切法的組成之一,已由上游「切法」涵蓋;本篇未另行定義。\n- 約束級結論、條件級結論:2026-10-19 作者裁決:論文自身的結論分級標籤,不是模型中的構件;上游概念庫亦未登記同類標籤。\n- 陌生人:2026-10-17 日常用語;正文第〇節明說它不是模型裡的量。2026-10-20 作者裁決:本篇的用語約定,本篇所說的熟人與陌生人只指其輸出曾到達該我者;這是範圍上的約定,不由可達子圖的定義推出,不另立概念。\n- 熟人:2026-10-17 日常用語;正文第〇節明說它不是模型裡的量。2026-10-20 作者裁決:同「陌生人」的用語約定。\n- 陌生:2026-10-17 日常用語,指「陌生人」所處的情形;正文第〇節明說它不是模型裡的量。\n- 和平學習:2026-10-20 作者裁決:一般用語,不指向「學習」概念,故正文第七節不加連結。\n- 陌生人的起點:2026-10-19 作者裁決:不另立概念。它由專屬歷史的定義直接給出(某維度上第一次到達的那一刻,專屬歷史在該維度上從零開始),論文第四節表格的一行只是對此的說明。\n- 劃群:2026-10-17 正文明說是一次分別,不另立概念。\n- 內生/外生、不強制/強制的兩個切分:2026-10-17 正文自稱是關係,不是世界上有哪幾種東西。\n- 荷包蛋、海膽:2026-10-17 比喻,正文自稱不是模型的一部分。\n- 全域圖:2026-10-17 只在 2.5 節作為尺度之一被提及,是切法下的一個範圍,未獨立定義。\n- 經驗前件、範圍設定、生物人前件:2026-10-19 作者裁決:前提與第四節的分類標籤,屬論文結構,不是模型構件。\n- 自然環境約束的強耦合與不可拼裝:2026-10-17 一條條件級結論的標題,不是構件。\n- 經驗:2026-10-20 作者裁決:本篇的用語約定,指已經到達的輸出所構成的歷史(歷史的一個限定),不另立概念;正文第〇節已明說。\n- 認識:2026-10-20 作者裁決:本篇的用語約定,只指對方的輸出到達過,是既有「輸出」「到達」的用法,不另立概念;正文 2.3 節已明說。\n- 一輪更新:2026-10-20 作者裁決:2.2 節對輸出、到達、學習、結果回饋四步驟的稱呼,由既有概念組成,不是新構件,不另立概念。\n- 秩序:2026-10-20 作者裁決:崩潰定義內的說明用語(不必逐次指導就能相容接續的預設與接續模式),隨崩潰一併定義,不另立概念。\n- 觀察者:2026-10-17 本篇已改用「研究者」,「研究者」為日常用語;上游公開概念「觀察者」本篇不引用。\n\n## 待決項\n\n無\n","formalization_md":"論文:《互動動力學-陌生人迴路中的專屬歷史變動與更新》\nUUID:2ccbf179-58cf-4851-bd72-5fa886e4b2c3\n\n## 記號約定\n\n來源:論文全文\n\n- 邊界:一般用語,不是概念 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.邊\n- 取樣邊界:一般用語,不是概念 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.邊\n- 和平學習:一般用語,不是概念 學習;[作者裁決] 不指向 學習 概念,故論文第七節不加連結\n- 熟人:一般用語,概念表不登記;本篇的用語約定:只指其輸出曾到達該我的對象(見 陌生人)\n- 專屬材料:一般用語,指 ae79e938-76e1-4bf9-b2ab-995c03e16c9e.專屬歷史 中的材料,不是另一個概念\n- 陌生人:一般用語,概念表不登記;本篇的用語約定:本篇所說的熟人與陌生人,只指其輸出曾到達該我者;沒有任何輸出到達過該我的對象,不是本篇所討論的陌生人;這是範圍上的約定,不由 可達子圖 的定義推出【正文:句8683122728】\n- 陌生:一般用語,概念表不登記;指「陌生人」所處的情形,同上約定\n- 名聲:本篇的用語約定,指經第三者的邊到達的、關於對方過去輸出的材料;一般用語,概念表不登記;正文第四節的說明是用法說明,不是新定義【正文:句5622665635】\n- 禮節:本篇的用語約定,指 共振 中被反覆 到達 的 輸出 模式,所指模式依 共振 的定義判定;不是由 共振 的定義推出的性質;一般用語,概念表不登記【正文:句2541801854】\n- 經驗:本篇的約定,指已到達的輸出所構成的歷史;不是概念表中的概念\n- 認識:本篇的約定,只指對方的輸出到達過;不是概念表中的概念\n\n## 前置條件\n\n來源:論文第一節第三小節【正文:句5799980775】\n\n- 前提一:一個 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.我 的每一次 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別,都在它的下一個 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.時刻 之前 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 它自己。【正文:句2397213938】\n- 前提二:對任何 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.呈現 甲 與任何 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦 乙(甲 可以是 乙 自己),甲 的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.自己的那一段 中總有沒有 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 乙 的部分(依據見 前提二之依據)。【正文:句2397213938】\n- 附註:[作者裁決] 前提二之依據:不另設前提編號;是正文在前提二內所給的理由,不是獨立前提,也不作為推導來源。前提二的依據是 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.損耗律:一個 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.我 不能完全分別自己;其 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 只來自這份不完全的分別,所以任何 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.呈現 都不能完整表達自己,接收者也不能完整接收到它。接收者自身的接收限制(前提七、前提八)是另一條獨立的理由,不與此混用。【正文:句2397213938】\n- 前提三:本篇只討論已 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 所構成的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.歷史,不討論感受。【正文:句2397213938】\n- 前提四:在本篇處理的範圍上,情境空間(誰、何時、何事、何種組合)不可窮舉;任何有限 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.歷史 只覆蓋其中一部分。【正文:句2397213938】\n- 前提五:可達子圖 只計已 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達,即對方的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 確實進入過某個 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦 的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.歷史(含經轉述而 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出);不另設「可經路徑 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達」的潛在概念。【正文:句2397213938】\n- 前提六:模板 的有無依研究者指定的判準判定;判準為可表述、可再取得、可代入指定類型的新情境。【正文:句2397213938】\n- 前提七:每個生物人(作為 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.我)在一段時間內能接收的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 有限。【正文:句2397213938】\n- 前提八:生物人的神經傳導與反應需要時間,對方對一筆 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 的反應不可能與該 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 同時發生。【正文:句2397213938】\n- 前提九:在講明的維度與時窗內,一群 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.我 之間,若 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.頻率 較高、結果回饋 較強、學習 較快、退出成本 較高,且 自然環境 在該維度上的變化相對於行為模式的變化較慢,則各 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.節點 在該維度上的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 落入相容區域的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.權重 傾向變重;若這些參數較低、自然環境 的變化相對較快,則傾向變輕。這只說 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.權重 傾向變動,不說一定形成或一定不形成;五個參數都須講明如何判準,數值區間取決於資料,區間外不保證。【正文:句2397213938】\n- 前提十:每個維度有自己的變化速度;在講明的時窗內,變化慢於時窗者視為固定的常量,變化快過時窗者不得當常量。【正文:句2397213938】\n- 附註:前提十一至前提十四、前提十七、前提十八、前提二十、前提二十二與前提二十五至前提三十六是 [限定條件](前提十九與前提二十一不是限定條件),取自論文各節的設定與方法規則,限定範圍,不參與推導,各附出處。前提編號中的前提十五、前提十六空缺,不補號。\n- 前提十一 [限定條件]:每個命題須連同維度集合、時窗、分類規則、參與的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.節點,以及 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.切法 的選擇者與理由一併報告;未連同報告者,不構成本篇的結論。【正文:句5628981634、句6756779625】\n- 前提十二 [限定條件]:方法約定:不同 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.切法 之間的比較,須維度、時窗、分類規則一致。【正文:句5983603478】\n- 前提十三 [限定條件]:單元 必須講明在哪個維度上判斷。【正文:句4537429372】\n- 前提十四 [限定條件]:本篇所說,沿網路傳遞的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 是高維的內容,例如語言、行為、所用的器具。【正文:句2359309035】\n- 附註:[作者裁決] b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.邊 的參數只指頻率、專屬歷史、退出成本 三項;份量、歧異度不是 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.邊 的參數(見 結論二之四之七)。這是論文對模型結構的描述,不作前提或推導來源。【正文:句6186077620】\n- 附註:[作者裁決] 這個結構有三個尺度:單元;一個 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦 的 可達子圖;一個特定範圍內的全域圖;它們是三個尺度,不是三種位置。這是論文對模型結構的描述,不作前提或推導來源。【正文:句4233379030】\n- 前提十七 [限定條件]:本篇不假定 ae79e938-76e1-4bf9-b2ab-995c03e16c9e.專屬歷史 的有效量是一個數;只在指定 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.切法 下比較某維度、某時窗下,相容接續是否比前一個時點更多、更少或 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.持平;可計數的維度才報數字,並標明那只屬於該 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.切法,不推到其他維度。【正文:句8657512598、句2804467025】\n- 前提十八 [限定條件]:模板 與承載群的關係有兩個切分:內生、外生;不 強制、強制;這是關係,不是世界上有哪幾種東西,並且相對於所畫範圍。【正文:句4991828185、句6894363369】\n- 前提十九:觀察:退出成本 低、37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.頻率 低、沒有緩衝 時,這條 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.邊 上的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 較容易停止或減少;37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.頻率 低與沒有緩衝的作用為論文列出的觀察,不由定義推出,不推內部容忍度,區間外不保證。【正文:句5992946809】\n- 前提二十 [限定條件]:本篇不設「文化 的維度」與「非 文化 的維度」之分,只談後果更直接或更間接。【正文:句4302258355】\n- 前提二十一:本篇把研究者當作一個 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.我(本篇的設定,論文第一節第二小節聲明);研究者在本篇所作的陳述,皆以此設定為前件;本篇不假定把多個 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.呈現 拼起來能還原別人高維 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.歷史 的整體。[作者裁決] 這是本篇的模型前件,不由 前提二 推出,但參與推導,故列為前提;編號接在最後,不更動前提一至前提二十。【正文:句0850422405】\n- 前提二十二 [限定條件]:任何把 文化、模板 或 自然環境 當固定的結論,須標明逐維度的時間尺度比;地方條件只在講明的時窗內視為給定,不得寫成永久不變,也不得寫成對所有維度同樣有驅動。【正文:句0957264659】\n- 前提二十三:在講明的時窗內,一個 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦 累積的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.歷史 是有限的。【正文:句2397213938】\n- 前提二十四:本篇不為劃群設定標準;切到多大、劃哪些人、看哪些維度,由劃群的人自己定並講明。【正文:句2397213938】\n- 前提二十五 [限定條件]:b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.切法 外不推:不得把 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.切法 下的結果推到 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.切法 外(未切的維度、取樣邊界之外,或「該 文化 模式不存在」)【正文:句8799405433、句7515820168】\n- 前提二十六 [限定條件]:共振 只寫「可能、可以是部分的」,不寫保證,不寫必然收斂,也不等於好、正確或友善【正文:句4107582062、句1261748627、句1607722015】\n- 前提二十七 [限定條件]:不得把驅動力寫成可被觀測、被自述確認或被事後證實的事實;不得以「為了」解釋 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出,只寫可觀察的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 分佈;要談 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.權重 時,須標明研究者只依不完整的外顯分佈,不能直接確定背後的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.權重 值,只能作有條件的估計;記錄者與研究者的解讀一律標為 fb0addca-42b6-4884-aa18-438c695747ab.看法歸屬;「有所求」只寫成可觀察的版本【正文:句0133531578、句7702980826、句9419062778】\n- 前提二十八 [限定條件]:學習 不得寫成有方向或必然更好;不由互動次數、浸泡時間或能力,推出某次已學到某項內容【正文:句5784079139】\n- 前提二十九 [限定條件]:不得由 文化、模板、ae79e938-76e1-4bf9-b2ab-995c03e16c9e.默契 互相推出;不得由 模板 存在或 強制 存在推出被遵守;不得由遵守推出理解、認同或 ae79e938-76e1-4bf9-b2ab-995c03e16c9e.默契【正文:句3110991404】\n- 前提三十 [限定條件]:用「文化」一詞,必須講明誰切、切哪些人、看哪些維度;須指出具體的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.歷史 輸入【正文:句3965312579】\n- 前提三十一 [限定條件]:不得寫 文化「決定」生存,不得寫「為了適應而形成」【正文:句7629224046】\n- 前提三十二 [限定條件]:不得由研究者的劃群推出當事人自認同一,也不得反過來【正文:句5484749639】\n- 前提三十三 [限定條件]:不得把 大型節點 寫成全知;也不得寫它們的目的【正文:句1167799789】\n- 前提三十四 [限定條件]:不得寫熟人與陌生人是兩類關係;不得寫接觸單調增加熟悉;不得未經檢核就把舊材料寫成對現狀有效;不得把分開寫成 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.歷史 消失【正文:句7708507412】\n- 前提三十五 [限定條件]:不得把外顯統計、先後或一條記錄路徑,寫成真實 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.權重 或依賴路徑的直接讀數;不得把確定感當證據;說 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.趨同、b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.趨異 或 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.持平 必須講明維度【正文:句1827334509】\n- 前提三十六 [限定條件]:不得假定研究者在 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.迴路 之外:研究者的觀察、詢問與記錄若 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 被觀察的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.我,就進入對方的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.歷史,收不回【正文:句0315533189】\n- 附註:前提一、前提二是對上游律的使用方式的重述;前提三至前提六、前提十、前提二十三與前提二十四是範圍設定;前提七至前提九是經驗前件,作推導的輸入,不拿來證明約束為真;前提二十一是研究者身分的模型前件。【正文:句2612624427、句2397213938】\n\n## 問題與定位(第〇節)\n\n來源:論文第〇節【正文:句1295176390】\n\n- 附註:「熟人」「陌生人」是日常語言,不是模型裡的量。【正文:句4653568677】\n- 附註:見面的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.頻率 是另一個參數,不能替代 ae79e938-76e1-4bf9-b2ab-995c03e16c9e.專屬歷史;天天見到早餐店老板,只在「賣早餐」這個維度上有 ae79e938-76e1-4bf9-b2ab-995c03e16c9e.專屬歷史,在其他維度上仍是陌生。【正文:句2888886167、句7351279802】\n- 附註:在被講明的維度上,一條 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.邊 的 ae79e938-76e1-4bf9-b2ab-995c03e16c9e.專屬歷史 少,日常語言通常把這種情形叫做陌生人;本篇不把人分成兩類,也不排成一條軸。【正文:句7559293061】\n- 步驟〇之一:本篇所說的經驗(本篇的約定),指已 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 所構成的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.歷史;討論範圍只限於這類歷史(從 前提三 推出)【正文:句4019201588】\n- 附註:[作者裁決] 原步驟〇之二(日常所說的熟人與陌生人都在 可達子圖 之內)與結論〇之一(未到達者不是陌生人)刪除:前提五與 可達子圖 的定義只規定哪些對象納入 可達子圖,並未定義日常所說的熟人與陌生人,故不能「推出」。改為記號約定(見 陌生人):本篇所說的熟人與陌生人,只指其輸出曾到達該我者;這是範圍上的約定,不是推導。步驟〇之三保留,因為它只講 可達子圖 的成員資格。【正文:句7646633549、句1466600507、句8683122728】\n- 步驟〇之三:沒有任何 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 過某個 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.我 的對象,不屬於 這個 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.我 的 可達子圖(從 前提五 + 可達子圖 的定義 推出)【正文:句8683122728】\n- 附註:本篇不分短模型與長模型;文化 與 模板 能不能暫時當固定,取決於各維度的變化速度相對於所看時窗;自然環境 在講明的時窗與 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.切法 下視為 ae79e938-76e1-4bf9-b2ab-995c03e16c9e.外生背景 時,須同時講明這個時窗與 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.切法。【正文:句4305568315、句5105975074】\n- 附註:本篇的結論分為約束級與條件級;經驗前件只作推導的輸入,不拿來證明約束為真;第九節的案例是校準,不屬任何一級。【正文:句6012703865、句1785209650、句4527563577、句4598054095、句2252180571】\n\n## 繼承與約束(第一節,前提表另見前置條件)\n\n來源:論文第一節【正文:句8443124133】\n\n- 附註:本篇使用 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.流變律、37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.黑箱律、37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.損耗律 與 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.不可復原律;上游的前提與步驟,本篇不引用其編號。【正文:句0188887172、句5451627565】\n- 結論一之一:對不被 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.鎖死 的對象,旁人事後對動機的判斷只是 fb0addca-42b6-4884-aa18-438c695747ab.看法歸屬 或 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.印象(從 ae79e938-76e1-4bf9-b2ab-995c03e16c9e.驅動力不可確認 推出)【正文:句7102029394】\n- 附註:[作者裁決] 本篇不寫動機、目的與驅動力(「本篇不寫」「不得寫」)是論文的方法選擇,依 ae79e938-76e1-4bf9-b2ab-995c03e16c9e.驅動力不可確認 而設,不由它推出;各條推導只推出「對不被 鎖死 的對象,從外部不能確認」。方法上的禁止列於第八節。【正文:句5451627565】\n- 步驟一之二之一:在 前提二十一 之下,依 前提二 及其依據 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.損耗律,別人的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.呈現 不能完整表達自己,研究者也不能完整接收,所以從任何單一 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.呈現 都拿不到別人高維 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.歷史 的整體;本篇不假定把多個 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.呈現 拼起來能還原整體(見 前提二十一)(從 前提二十一 + 前提二 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.損耗律 推出)【正文:句0850422405】\n- 附註:[作者裁決] 單一 呈現 不能完整表達別人的高維 歷史:呈現 是 渦 的 輸出,渦 作為 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.我,依 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.損耗律 不能完全 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別 自己,拿不到完整的自己,就不可能輸出完整的自己。【正文:句0850422405】\n- 結論一之二之二:研究者從單一呈現拿不到整體,本篇又不假定把多個呈現拼起來能還原整體,所以只能切出一部分來談;若把「切出一部分」稱為 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.切法(本篇的用法,見附註),則 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.切法 必須講明(從 步驟一之二之一 + 前提二十一 + b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.切法 的定義 推出)【正文:句9571889963、句0850422405】\n- 附註:[作者裁決] 論文把「切出一部分來談」稱為 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.切法,是論文對 切法 一詞的使用,不由 切法 的定義推出;「研究者在本篇對高維 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.歷史 所作的陳述,皆為某一 切法 下的陳述」是本篇的方法立場(與前提十一同類);範圍只限研究者所作的陳述,不主張世上所有關於高維 歷史 的陳述都如此。【正文:句9571889963、句0850422405】\n- 附註:本篇講明切法時,用維度、時窗與分類規則三項;這是本篇的做法,不是切法的定義所規定。【正文:句0850422405】\n- 結論一之二之三:b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.切法 是研究者作出的一次 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別,被表達出來就算研究者的一次 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出,帶選擇(從 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.切法 的定義 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別 的定義 + b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 的定義 推出)【正文:句0638811188】\n- 結論一之二之四:當事人若也把哪些 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.我 看作一群,這是劃群的人從全體中切出一部分的一次 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別(從 結論一之二之二 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別 的定義 推出)【正文:句8905543870】\n- 附註:[作者裁決] 「本篇不另立概念」是概念登記的處理決定,不由所列來源推出,不作推導來源(見概念表「不登記」)。【正文:句8905543870】\n\n## b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.節點 的類型與 單元(第二節第一小節)\n\n來源:論文第二節第一小節【正文:句3771395794】\n\n- 附註:本小節用到 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.節點 的類型與 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.信號容器、b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.隨機源 的定義。【正文:句8234118331】\n- 結論二之一之二:小迴路 只屬於 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦:37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦 的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 回到自己的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.歷史,參與自己之後的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.權重(從 小迴路 的定義 推出)【正文:句2279058157】\n- 結論二之一之三:b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.信號容器 沒有 小迴路(從 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.信號容器 的定義 + 小迴路 的定義 推出)【正文:句6839758494】\n- 結論二之一之四:一個 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦 寫、另一個 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦 讀到所寫的內容,構成兩個 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦 之間經 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.信號容器 的間接 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達(從 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.信號容器 的定義 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 的定義 推出)【正文:句6839758494】\n- 結論二之一之五:b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.隨機源 沒有 小迴路(從 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.隨機源 的定義 + 小迴路 的定義 推出)【正文:句4656885009】\n- 結論二之一之六:組成(單元, 兩個 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦, 各一個 小迴路, 一個 大迴路)(從 單元 的定義 推出)【正文:句5837010893】\n- 循環二之一之七之一:小迴路 是 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.迴路:37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦 的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 回到自己的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.歷史,參與自己之後的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.權重,之後的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 是 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.坍塌 依這份 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.權重 選出一個 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分支 的結果,連同 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別 內容(從 小迴路 的定義 + b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.迴路 的定義 + b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 的定義 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.坍塌 的定義 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.權重 的定義 推出)。退出條件:某個 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.退場,或 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.迴路 在某個 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.時刻 起不再成立,這個 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.迴路 結束【正文:句3420943831、句1418850283、句7657899612】\n- 循環二之一之七之二:大迴路 是 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.迴路:甲的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 乙、乙的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 甲,各自參與對方之後的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.權重,之後的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 是 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.坍塌 依這份 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.權重 選出一個 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分支 的結果,連同 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別 內容(從 大迴路 的定義 + b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.迴路 的定義 + b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 的定義 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.坍塌 的定義 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.權重 的定義 推出)。退出條件:某個 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.退場,或 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.迴路 在某個 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.時刻 起不再成立,這個 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.迴路 結束【正文:句3420943831、句1418850283、句7657899612】\n- 結論二之一之八:b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.信號容器 與 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.隨機源 可以接在 單元 的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.邊 上,但不是 單元 的主體(從 單元 的定義 + 結論二之一之六 + 結論二之一之三 + 結論二之一之五 推出)【正文:句7683702235】\n- 附註:「盤子裡放兩個荷包蛋」只是比喻,不是模型的一部分。【正文:句2269602341】\n- 結論二之一之九:每條 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.邊 上的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 是有方向的(邊 是節點之間有向的關係,到達 沿 邊 發生;邊 與 到達 不是同一種東西);兩個方向可以只有一個存在,也不必同時發生(從 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.邊 的定義 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 的定義 推出)【正文:句4497838484】\n- 結論二之一之十:在 單元 中,每個 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦 的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.歷史 既可能有自己的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 回到自己,也可能有別人的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 它;這兩者若發生,都參與它之後的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.權重(從 單元 的定義 + 結論二之一之六 + 循環二之一之七之一 + 循環二之一之七之二 推出)【正文:句4353637015】\n\n## 一輪更新(第二節第二小節)\n\n來源:論文第二節第二小節【正文:句3254220456】\n\n- 結論二之二之三:不被 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.鎖死 時,只能推出 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.權重,推不出結果(從 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.黑箱律 推出)【正文:句0583872602】\n- 步驟二之二之四:fb0addca-42b6-4884-aa18-438c695747ab.候選 與 fb0addca-42b6-4884-aa18-438c695747ab.自我說服 是 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.我 作出的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別;若 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦(作為 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.我)在 fb0addca-42b6-4884-aa18-438c695747ab.決定 的結果事先算不準時,「認為哪個更優」並以此把自己推向某個 fb0addca-42b6-4884-aa18-438c695747ab.候選,這就是 fb0addca-42b6-4884-aa18-438c695747ab.自我說服 這類 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別(從 fb0addca-42b6-4884-aa18-438c695747ab.候選 的定義 + fb0addca-42b6-4884-aa18-438c695747ab.自我說服 的定義 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別 的定義 推出)【正文:句4820938883】\n- 附註:論文以「渦「認為哪個更優」」稱呼這類 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別;fb0addca-42b6-4884-aa18-438c695747ab.候選 與 fb0addca-42b6-4884-aa18-438c695747ab.自我說服 的定義沒有要求必須判斷優劣,這是論文的描述,不由定義推出,不作推導來源。「fb0addca-42b6-4884-aa18-438c695747ab.決定 的結果事先算不準」是 fb0addca-42b6-4884-aa18-438c695747ab.自我說服 的定義條件,論文此句未講明,本步驟把它寫成前件,不主張 渦「認為哪個更優」本身就滿足它。\n- 步驟二之二之五:37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.我 作出的這個 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 自己後進入 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.歷史,參與之後的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.權重(從 前提一 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.生成函數 的定義 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別 的定義 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.歷史 的定義 推出)【正文:句4820938883】\n- 結論二之二之五之一:當下的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.權重 不是任何 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦 內部的參數,也不由 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦 的「認為更優」直接給出;「認為更優」成為 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.我 的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別、37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 自己、進入 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.歷史 之後,經 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.生成函數 參與之後的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.權重(從 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.生成函數 的定義 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.權重 的定義 + 步驟二之二之四 + 步驟二之二之五 推出)【正文:句1405379320、句4820938883】\n- 結論二之二之六:這個 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別 不保證對,不保證一致(從 前提二 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.黑箱律 推出)【正文:句4820938883】\n- 步驟二之二之七:b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 沿 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.邊 或經 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.信號容器 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 別的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.節點,進入對方的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.歷史,只增不減(從 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.不可復原律 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 的定義 + b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.邊 的定義 + b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.信號容器 的定義 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.歷史 的定義 推出)【正文:句3303248615】\n- 結論二之二之八:學習 是結果條件,不指目的,沒有預設方向,不保證學到、不保證學對(從 學習 的定義 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.黑箱律 推出)【正文:句0196395423】\n- 結論二之二之九:學習 的判定只看 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 之後可觀察的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 有改變,不證明改變來自哪一筆 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出(從 結論二之二之八 + 學習 的定義 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.黑箱律 推出)【正文:句8346776593】\n- 結論二之二之十:事前 學習 的方向不可預測,事後結果可以判;判準在其他 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.節點 與 自然環境 的反應結果裡,不在發生 學習 的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦 內部(從 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.黑箱律 + 結果回饋 的定義 + 自然環境 的定義 推出)【正文:句2982199452】\n- 附註:「學會語言就能說話,學會禮貌大概率改善互動,反之可能有代價」只是舉例。【正文:句2982199452】\n- 循環二之二之十一:每個 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦、每條 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.邊 在每個 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.時刻 都可能經歷一輪更新:一輪更新以該 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.時刻 確實發生 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 與 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 為前件(必要環節,依定義發生);學習 與 結果回饋 是可選環節,只在對應的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 發生時才可能發生,不保證每輪都發生。b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 沿 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.邊 或經 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.信號容器 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 別的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.節點,37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 的材料累積進 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.歷史 並可能改變後續 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.權重;37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦 之後的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 若再 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 自己的後續互動,就可能帶回 結果回饋;之後的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.坍塌 依之後的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.權重 選出下一輪的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出(從 步驟二之二之七 + 結論二之二之八 + 結論二之二之十 + 循環二之一之七之一 + 循環二之一之七之二 + b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 的定義 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.坍塌 的定義 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.權重 的定義 推出)。退出條件:所在的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.迴路 結束(見 循環二之一之七之一、循環二之一之七之二)【正文:句2548380016、句7519471468、句7196336356、句7657899612】\n- 附註:四個環節「輸出、到達、學習、結果回饋」依序進行的先後次序,是論文對過程的描述,不是由規則推出的新主張;循環二之二之十一只推出必要環節、可選環節與 結果回饋 閉環。\n\n## 組合(第二節第三小節)\n\n來源:論文第二節第三小節【正文:句3252681993】\n\n- 結論二之三之一:一個 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.節點 可以同時是許多條 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.邊 的一端(從 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.邊 的定義 + b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.節點 的定義 推出)【正文:句1924486982】\n- 結論二之三之二:乙的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 過甲,與甲的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 過乙,是兩個方向,可以只有一個存在;「甲認識乙」「乙認識甲」的用語約定見記號約定(從 結論二之一之九 推出)【正文:句2279214954】\n- 結論二之三之三:一個 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.節點 可以有幾十幾百條進來的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.邊,同時有幾十幾百條出去的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.邊(從 結論二之三之一 + 結論二之三之二 推出)【正文:句4463595048】\n- 附註:「海膽」只是比喻,不是模型的一部分。【正文:句7513406987】\n- 結論二之三之四:每個 單元 的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.邊 都可以與另一些 單元 共用 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.節點,b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.迴路 因此可以彼此交疊(從 結論二之一之六 + 結論二之三之一 + b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.迴路 的定義 推出)【正文:句7776916241】\n- 結論二之三之六:每個 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦 下一 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.時刻 的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.權重 取決於到當時為止 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 它的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.歷史,包括所有 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 它的鄰居的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出(從 結論二之三之三 + 結論二之三之四 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦 的定義 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.歷史 的定義 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.生成函數 的定義 推出)【正文:句9624143560】\n- 循環二之三之六之一:影響沿 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.迴路 回來,可能改變之後 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 的輸入(從 結論二之三之六 + b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.迴路 的定義 推出)。退出條件:這些 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.迴路 同樣可能結束(見 循環二之一之七之一、循環二之一之七之二)【正文:句9624143560、句0079128027】\n- 結論二之三之六之二:研究者的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.切法 是研究者的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出(結論一之二之三),在研究者自己被算入的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.切法 下,研究者也是網上的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.節點:研究者被當作一個 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.我(步驟一之二之一的設定),37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦 是 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.節點 三類之一(結論二之一之二),被切法算入時即是該切法下的 節點;只有研究者產生 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 還不足以推出這一點(從 結論一之二之三 + 步驟一之二之一 + 結論二之一之二 + b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.節點 的定義 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.我 的定義 推出)【正文:句0638811188、句9624143560】\n\n## b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.邊 的參數(第二節第四小節)\n\n來源:論文第二節第四小節【正文:句3291012867】\n\n- 附註:b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.頻率 不替代 ae79e938-76e1-4bf9-b2ab-995c03e16c9e.專屬歷史。【正文:句5030456246】\n- 結論二之四之三:ae79e938-76e1-4bf9-b2ab-995c03e16c9e.專屬歷史 按維度計,所以同一條 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.邊 的兩端之間可以在一個維度上有彼此 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 的材料,在另一個維度上沒有材料(第一次 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 之前為零,見 結論四之一);專屬歷史 是按維度計的歷史段,不是 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.邊 的大小(從 ae79e938-76e1-4bf9-b2ab-995c03e16c9e.專屬歷史 的定義 + b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.邊 的定義 推出)【正文:句4793162731】\n- 附註:[作者裁決] 專屬歷史 不假定可量,見 前提十七(限定條件);這是論文的立場,不由所列來源推出。【正文:句4793162731】\n- 結論二之四之四:退出成本 每一端各算各的,可以不對稱(從 退出成本 的定義 推出)【正文:句8467120536】\n- 結論二之四之五:(可觀察的版本)給出負面 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 之後,對方仍持續出現、持續 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出,是一種可觀察的情形;對不被 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.鎖死 的對象,從外部分不出動機(從 ae79e938-76e1-4bf9-b2ab-995c03e16c9e.驅動力不可確認 推出)【正文:句5141130183】\n- 附註:[作者裁決] 「不寫動機」是論文的方法選擇,不由 ae79e938-76e1-4bf9-b2ab-995c03e16c9e.驅動力不可確認 推出。【正文:句5141130183】\n- 結論二之四之六:退出成本 與 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.退場 層級不同(b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.邊 與 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.節點),互不蘊含;退出成本 高不蘊含不退出,極高也不等於 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.退場(從 退出成本 的定義 + b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.退場 的定義 推出)【正文:句1920780717】\n- 結論二之四之七:b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.份量 與 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.歧異度 不是 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.邊 的參數,而是「一筆 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 相對於接收者」的屬性(從 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.份量 的定義 + b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.歧異度 的定義 + b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.邊 的定義 推出)【正文:句2968887863】\n- 結論二之四之九:同一筆 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 不同的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.我,b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.份量 與 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.歧異度 依各自的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.歷史 而定,可以不同,對各自 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.權重 的移動也可以不同(從 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.份量 的定義 + b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.歧異度 的定義 推出)【正文:句8714161922】\n\n## 可達子圖 與 自然環境(第二節第五小節)\n\n來源:論文第二節第五小節【正文:句8635183536】\n\n- 步驟二之五之一:以某個 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦 為中心,在講明的時窗內,所有曾有 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 它的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.呈現,連同這些 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.呈現 與它之間的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.邊,構成它的 可達子圖(從 可達子圖 的定義 + 前提五 推出)【正文:句9103761635】\n- 結論二之五之二:在講明的時窗內,每個 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦 各有一張 可達子圖(從 步驟二之五之一 推出)【正文:句8303415713】\n- 結論二之五之三:沒有任何 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.呈現 的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.自己的那一段 能全部 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 某個 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦(從 前提二 推出)【正文:句0017431241】\n- 附註:「全部 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達」與前提二的「總有沒有 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 的部分」互為否定。【正文:句0017431241】\n- 結論二之五之四:在講明的時窗內,可達子圖 外的對象的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 沒有 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 過這個 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦,時窗內該對象與這個 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦 之間的專屬材料為零,專屬材料只在對象是 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.我 時才談(從 可達子圖 的定義 + ae79e938-76e1-4bf9-b2ab-995c03e16c9e.專屬歷史 的定義 推出)【正文:句0542244404】\n- 結論二之五之五:進入 可達子圖 是一筆新的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達,已到達的材料只加不減(從 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.不可復原律 + 結論二之五之四 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.歷史 的定義 推出)【正文:句0542244404】\n- 結論二之五之六:37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 是有向的:一方有材料,不蘊含另一方有材料(從 結論二之一之九 推出)【正文:句9296688646】\n- 結論二之五之七:(約束級)每個 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦 在講明的時窗內累積的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.歷史 有限(從 前提二十三 推出)【正文:句1652662916】\n- 結論二之五之八:(約束級)任何 可達子圖 覆蓋的情境只是其中一部分,對未被覆蓋的情境,已有的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.歷史 不保證這個 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦 後續的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 與對方相容(從 結論二之五之七 + 前提四 推出)【正文:句1652662916】\n- 附註:論文接著寫「沒有別的依據時,可以重新試探」;重新試探需要仍有再次 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 與 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 的可能,所列來源未提供這項條件,不作推導來源。【正文:句1652662916】\n- 附註:結論二之五之七與結論二之五之八為約束級,用到前提二十三與前提四。【正文:句4889722778】\n- 附註:校準(不作推導來源):一個人讀過某位公眾人物大量的公開 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出,對方卻從未收到他的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出,這是單向 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達;已 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.退場 者留下的檔案可以無限增加,結果回饋 卻為零;兩者都說明資料量與 結果回饋 是兩個會脫鉤的量。【正文:句3153210763、句2330307754】\n- 結論二之五之九:自然環境 是在講明的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.切法 下,不屬於模型中任何 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.節點、卻有 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 這些 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.節點 的部分,對各 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.節點 最基本的行為構成約束(從 自然環境 的定義 推出)【正文:句4707813668】\n- 結論二之五之十:自然環境 在講明的時窗與 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.切法 下不隨模型中的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.迴路 更新時,視為 ae79e938-76e1-4bf9-b2ab-995c03e16c9e.外生背景,ae79e938-76e1-4bf9-b2ab-995c03e16c9e.外生背景 可以變;依前提十,要在該時窗內把它當固定的常量,它在該維度上的變化須慢於所看的時窗;變化快過時窗時,不得當常量,依賴它為常量的結論須重核(從 自然環境 的定義 + ae79e938-76e1-4bf9-b2ab-995c03e16c9e.外生背景 的定義 + 前提十 推出)【正文:句9087346609】\n- 結論二之五之十二之一:可達子圖 只計已 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達(前提五);若某個對象屬於所討論的網路,而某個 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.我 尚未被這個對象的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達,這個對象就不在該 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.我 的 可達子圖 之內,該 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.我 的 可達子圖 就不涵蓋整個網路(從 前提五 + 可達子圖 的定義 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.我 的定義 推出)。這是針對特定 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.我 的條件式,不推出「任何個體的 可達子圖 都不涵蓋整個網路」;未到達者依第〇節不是陌生人【正文:句3058679824】\n- 結論二之五之十二之三:機構作為 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦,其資料是 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 機構的東西(不限於別的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.我 的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出);依 前提二 仍不完整(從 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 的定義 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.歷史 的定義 + 前提二 推出)【正文:句0697913934】\n- 結論二之五之十二之五:大型節點 的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 在講明的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.切法 與時窗內,到達所指範圍內幾乎所有 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.節點,連結上可能涵蓋該範圍(從 大型節點 的定義 推出)【正文:句8773241131】\n- 附註:[作者裁決] 機構(政府、大企業)由人的回應與輸入構成,機構是 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦,不是地點或建築物;渦 的集合仍以 渦 的定義判定。【正文:句0697913934】\n- 結論二之五之十三:大型節點 是真實存在的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.節點,不是假想的研究者(從 大型節點 的定義 + b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.節點 的定義 推出)【正文:句8773241131、句4658303634】\n- 結論二之五之十四:影響大不只是 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.節點 自己的屬性,37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 廣不蘊含影響大;依 前提二,沒有任何 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.我 能完整接收別人,所以也不蘊含全知(從 結論二之四之九 + 前提二 推出)【正文:句5609062361】\n- 附註:[作者裁決] 「有目的本篇不寫」是論文的方法選擇,不由所列來源推出。【正文:句5609062361】\n\n## ae79e938-76e1-4bf9-b2ab-995c03e16c9e.專屬歷史 在各維度上的變動(第二節第六小節)\n\n來源:論文第二節第六小節【正文:句8206484657】\n\n- 結論二之六之一:雙方 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 互相 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 的接觸,使 ae79e938-76e1-4bf9-b2ab-995c03e16c9e.專屬歷史 的材料只加不減(從 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.不可復原律 + ae79e938-76e1-4bf9-b2ab-995c03e16c9e.專屬歷史 的定義 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.歷史 的定義 推出)【正文:句0507078001】\n- 步驟二之六之二:分開不刪除 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.歷史(從 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.不可復原律 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.歷史 的定義 推出)【正文:句5275334681】\n- 步驟二之六之三:分開期間,對方的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.歷史 仍在變(從 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.流變律 推出)【正文:句5275334681】\n- 步驟二之六之四:(條件級)對方 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.歷史 的這些變化中可能有沒有 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 你的部分;前提二 只保證對方 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.自己的那一段 中總有沒有 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 你的部分,不保證每一段變化都有(從 前提二 推出)【正文:句5275334681】\n- 結論二之六之五:對方的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.歷史 已經變了,你手上是舊材料,用它估計對方現在的相容區域,依據在指定 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.切法 下可能下降(條件級,取決於變動的維度與相容判準)(從 步驟二之六之二 + 步驟二之六之三 + 步驟二之六之四 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.生成函數 的定義 推出)【正文:句3728284815】\n- 結論二之六之六:(條件級,取決於變動的維度與相容判準)只看累積量不足以判斷「有效」,材料與對方現狀的距離可能也要看(從 結論二之六之一 + 結論二之六之五 推出)【正文:句6173734326】\n- 結論二之六之七:以上對每個維度各自成立(從 結論二之四之三 + 結論二之六之一 + 結論二之六之五 推出)【正文:句6278766042】\n- 結論二之六之八:有兩種材料狀態(不窮盡):對象剛進入 可達子圖,單向的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 材料開始累積,要到對象是 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.我、雙方的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 互相 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 之後,才開始累積 ae79e938-76e1-4bf9-b2ab-995c03e16c9e.專屬歷史;有舊材料而沒有新 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達(從 結論二之五之四 + 結論二之六之五 + 可達子圖 的定義 + ae79e938-76e1-4bf9-b2ab-995c03e16c9e.專屬歷史 的定義 推出)【正文:句2448151860】\n- 附註:日常說的陌生可以對應這兩種材料狀態,是本篇的用語對應(見記號約定「陌生」),不是推導,不作推導來源。\n- 附註:這兩種情形不能混為一談。【正文:句9100572808】\n- 結論二之六之九:(條件級)重逢時,若舊材料與對方現況之間有落差,且落差使雙方相鄰的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 在指定維度與判準下不相容,就是 ae79e938-76e1-4bf9-b2ab-995c03e16c9e.失配;有沒有落差、落差有多大、是否造成這種不相容,取決於資料(從 結論二之六之五 + ae79e938-76e1-4bf9-b2ab-995c03e16c9e.失配 的定義 推出)【正文:句1391591717】\n- 結論二之六之十:位置不單調:接觸只增加材料,不保證相容;分開只可能使材料過時,不抹除它(從 結論二之六之一 + 步驟二之六之二 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.黑箱律 推出)【正文:句3463727755】\n- 結論二之六之十一:重新接觸是新的一次,不是原來狀態的復原(從 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.不可復原律 推出)【正文:句7929585247】\n- 附註:[作者裁決] 舊材料可能讓重新校準比從零快,也可能因對方已變而 ae79e938-76e1-4bf9-b2ab-995c03e16c9e.失配,快慢不保證,是論文的條件級觀察,不作推導來源。【正文:句5252157957】\n- 結論二之六之十三:這套規則不分 單元 大小:在講明的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.切法 下被看作 單元 的兩個朋友、兩個家族久未往來而生疏,是同一個結構(從 單元 的定義 + b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.切法 的定義 + 結論二之六之十 推出)【正文:句2876851272】\n- 結論二之六之十五:本篇所稱 外顯資料,指被選中、被表達出來的結果及其摘要;它不等於完整的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.權重 與依賴路徑(從 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.損耗律 + b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.切法 的定義 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.黑箱律 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.生成函數 的定義 + 外顯資料 的定義 推出)【正文:句7198913640】\n- 附註:[作者裁決] 「本篇所稱 外顯資料,指被選中、被表達出來的結果及其摘要」是論文的用語約定,不由所列來源推出;「不等於完整的 權重 與依賴路徑」由所列來源推出。【正文:句7198913640】\n\n## 逐維度的走向(第三節)\n\n來源:論文第三節【正文:句9925441404】\n\n- 附註:日常說的「排斥」只是日常語言,不是模型裡另一個概念。【正文:句6184416250】\n- 附註:雙方互相針對、互相強化的情形,上游稱為 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.太極,雙方都是 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.我 時,外顯為 ae79e938-76e1-4bf9-b2ab-995c03e16c9e.衝突;這是對上游概念稱呼的說明,本篇不推導,也不作為任何推導的來源。【正文:句4901007502】\n- 結論三之三:b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.趨異 不蘊含 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.太極(從 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.趨異 的定義 + b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.太極 的定義 推出)【正文:句4901007502】\n- 結論三之四:共振 的判準是相容,也就是 ae79e938-76e1-4bf9-b2ab-995c03e16c9e.失配 的反面,不是距離(從 共振 的定義 + ae79e938-76e1-4bf9-b2ab-995c03e16c9e.失配 的定義 推出)【正文:句9378283283、句1808804592】\n- 結論三之四之一:共振 須以 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 為條件:節點彼此之間有 到達,或有共同的來源對它們都有 到達;完全沒有 到達,就沒有 共振(從 共振 的定義 推出)【正文:句4459493046】\n- 結論三之五:距離的變化方向不是 共振 的判準,距離變小、變大或不變,本身都不決定是否相容(從 結論三之四 推出)【正文:句9834421243】\n- 結論三之六:b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.趨同 可以通向 共振,但不推出;共振 也不推出 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.趨同(從 結論三之五 + b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.趨同 的定義 + 共振 的定義 推出)【正文:句5477444423】\n- 結論三之七:是否 共振,只能事後說(從 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.黑箱律 + 共振 的定義 推出)【正文:句7648292184】\n- 結論三之八:共振 不同於 ae79e938-76e1-4bf9-b2ab-995c03e16c9e.默契:ae79e938-76e1-4bf9-b2ab-995c03e16c9e.默契 是兩個 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.我 之間按維度計的 ae79e938-76e1-4bf9-b2ab-995c03e16c9e.專屬歷史 上的相容接續;共振 不要求 ae79e938-76e1-4bf9-b2ab-995c03e16c9e.專屬歷史,也不限兩個 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.我(從 共振 的定義 + ae79e938-76e1-4bf9-b2ab-995c03e16c9e.默契 的定義 + ae79e938-76e1-4bf9-b2ab-995c03e16c9e.專屬歷史 的定義 推出)【正文:句0681990458】\n- 結論三之九:高維下,在有 耦合、可比較輸出模式距離的每個維度上,各自走向:b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.趨同、b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.趨異、b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.持平 三者窮舉距離變小、變大、不變,各維度可各走其一(從 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.趨同 的定義 + b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.趨異 的定義 + b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.持平 的定義 推出)【正文:句8860772762、句8118168761】\n- 附註:系統論的同步現象只作校準對照,不主張它與本模型是同一種結構的特例,不引用同步定理;本篇自己的用語一律用 共振。【正文:句4251666252、句4412282428】\n\n## 可達子圖 內的概念(第四節)\n\n來源:論文第四節【正文:句7974693204】\n\n- 附註:下列概念都在被講明的維度與時窗下使用,都不是新增的律;「模板」見第六節。【正文:句8460186793、句9982601492】\n- 結論四之一:第一次 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 發生的那一刻之前,ae79e938-76e1-4bf9-b2ab-995c03e16c9e.專屬歷史 在該維度上為零;之後 ae79e938-76e1-4bf9-b2ab-995c03e16c9e.專屬歷史 只按彼此互相 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 累積(從 ae79e938-76e1-4bf9-b2ab-995c03e16c9e.專屬歷史 的定義 推出)【正文:句0934095171、句4793162731】\n- 附註:[作者裁決] 陌生人的起點指第一次 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 發生的時刻;此後 ae79e938-76e1-4bf9-b2ab-995c03e16c9e.專屬歷史 是否增加,依 ae79e938-76e1-4bf9-b2ab-995c03e16c9e.專屬歷史 的定義看是否彼此互相 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達。【正文:句0934095171】\n- 結論四之三:懲罰 是一個 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 之後,37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 者的、在講明的判準下算作代價的 結果回饋;判準須講明是誰的:b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 者自己的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別,或研究者的判準,兩者可以不一致;不一定暴力,不一定明列(從 懲罰 的定義 + 結果回饋 的定義 推出)【正文:句7465112293、句0647745663、句2653427287】\n- 結論四之四:強制 是 懲罰 已被明列成規則,寫在 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.信號容器 裡,違反可由第三方判定;不保證遵守,不保證違反被判定與執行;規則先於違反,是另一個時間點的事(從 強制 的定義 + 結論四之三 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.黑箱律 推出)【正文:句8573356820、句7572810069、句4019654152】\n- 附註:ae79e938-76e1-4bf9-b2ab-995c03e16c9e.失配 本身不帶後果(論文第四節的聲明)【正文:句0288702832】\n- 結論四之五:容錯率 是在講明的維度上,一個 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.我 對對方的 ae79e938-76e1-4bf9-b2ab-995c03e16c9e.失配 所能容忍的程度的上限;超過上限,這條 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.邊 就可能終止(從 容錯率 的定義 + ae79e938-76e1-4bf9-b2ab-995c03e16c9e.失配 的定義 推出)【正文:句2473957794】\n- 步驟四之六之一:(條件級,區間外不保證)退出成本 低時,可以輕易放棄這條 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.邊(從 退出成本 的定義 推出)【正文:句5992946809】\n- 結論四之六之二:(條件級,取決於資料;區間外不保證)退出成本 低、37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.頻率 低、沒有緩衝 時,這條 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.邊 上的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 較容易停止或減少;其中 退出成本 低時可輕易放棄這條 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.邊(步驟四之六之一),37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.頻率 低與沒有緩衝的作用是觀察(前提十九),不推內部容忍度(從 前提十九 + 步驟四之六之一 推出)【正文:句5992946809】\n- 結論四之七:(可觀察的版本)給出負面 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 之後,對方仍持續出現、持續 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出,是一種可觀察的情形;對不被 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.鎖死 的對象,從外部分不出動機(從 ae79e938-76e1-4bf9-b2ab-995c03e16c9e.驅動力不可確認 推出)【正文:句0987178153】\n- 附註:[作者裁決] 「不寫動機」是論文的方法選擇,不由 ae79e938-76e1-4bf9-b2ab-995c03e16c9e.驅動力不可確認 推出。【正文:句0987178153】\n- 結論四之八:名聲有損(依 前提二,經第三者到達的材料不能完整表達對方),只能作為形成 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.印象 的材料,不是 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.權重 的讀數(從 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.印象 的定義 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.黑箱律 + 前提二 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.損耗律 推出)【正文:句5622665635】\n- 結論四之九之一:(條件級,取決於資料)違反 禮節 若帶來後續 結果回饋(代價),這些 結果回饋 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 自己後進入 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.歷史,可能改變 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.權重;若 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.權重 因此遠離違反並在之後的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 中持續,這個模式傾向維持(從 共振 的定義 + 學習 的定義 + 步驟二之二之五 + 結果回饋 的定義 推出)【正文:句2541801854】\n- 結論四之十:名聲、禮節、模板(加 強制)各自可作為材料:名聲只能作為形成 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.印象 的材料(結論四之八);禮節 的違反可能帶來後續 結果回饋(結論四之九之一);模板 是明列在 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.信號容器 裡的內容;強制 是已被明列成規則的 懲罰(結論四之四)(從 結論四之八 + 結論四之九之一 + 模板 的定義 + 結論四之四 推出)【正文:句2209168152、句5622665635、句2541801854、句4334705227、句8573356820】\n- 附註:論文把這四項列為低頻 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.邊 上能依賴的材料;「低頻 邊 上能依賴」是論文的列舉與判斷,不由所列來源推出,不作推導來源。\n- 結論四之十之一:(條件級)對方的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.權重 由對方到當時為止的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.歷史 決定(37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.黑箱律),接收者 拿不到對方 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.歷史 的整體(前提二,依 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.損耗律),只能把已 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 的材料(對方的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出,或經轉述、經 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.信號容器 而來的、關於對方 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 的材料,如名聲、禮節、模板)當作依據,形成 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.印象 並據此判斷對方 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.權重 的傾向;b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.印象 不是 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.權重 的讀數;即使不知道材料是否屬實,也可以判斷,判斷不保證準確(從 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.黑箱律 + 前提二 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.損耗律 + 前提五 + 步驟二之二之七 + 結論四之十 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別 的定義 + b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.印象 的定義 推出)【正文:句9586653832】\n- 結論四之十之二:(條件級)接收者 作為 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.我,這個判斷是它的一次 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別,37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 自己後進入 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.歷史,經 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.生成函數 參與它之後的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.權重(從 前提一 + b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.印象 的定義 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別 的定義 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.歷史 的定義 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.生成函數 的定義 + 結論四之十之一 推出)【正文:句9586653832】\n- 結論四之十一:(條件級,用到 退出成本 低)退出成本 低時,這條 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.邊 在初期可能因某一步而不再存在;在這種情況下,這些材料可能讓接收者在初期對對方形成 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.印象:接收者據材料判斷對方後(結論四之十之二),它之後的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.權重 可能改變;判斷不保證準確,也不保證當面時的行為接得上對方(條件級,不保證)(從 結論四之十之一 + 結論四之十之二 + 學習 的定義 + 退出成本 的定義 推出)【正文:句9586653832】\n- 結論四之十二:材料是否可靠 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.不被保證(從 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.黑箱律 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.損耗律 + 前提二 推出)【正文:句8049763641】\n- 附註:[作者裁決] 「也可以被誤讀」是論文列出的條件級觀察:不完整接收不等於誤讀,從不完整接收到誤讀的可能性不由所列來源推出,不作推導來源。【正文:句8049763641】\n- 結論四之十三:(條件級)生物人前件:接收有限、反應有延遲,給的是共同的限制,不是共同的內容(從 前提七 + 前提八 推出)【正文:句1385116162、句4772812230】\n- 結論四之十四:37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.歷史 只加不減,這不是經驗前件(從 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.不可復原律 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.流變律 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.歷史 的定義 推出)【正文:句6047628070】\n\n## 文化(第五節)\n\n來源:論文第五節【正文:句1281377381】\n\n- 結論五之一:文化 是研究者對 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.節點 之間出現的 共振 的命名(從 文化 的定義 推出)【正文:句5958774490】\n- 結論五之二:在指定的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.切法、維度與時窗下,文化 是無數 單元 在特定 自然環境 約束下,經過反覆的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出、37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 與 結果回饋,留在 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.歷史 中的一組相容圖樣(從 文化 的定義 + 共振 的定義 推出)【正文:句9251167115】\n- 結論五之三:這組圖樣經由具體的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 進入 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦 的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.歷史,參與它的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.權重(限定為 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦;信號容器 與 隨機源 不在此列);先 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 的材料已經進了 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.歷史,37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.歷史 依 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.生成函數 參與 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.權重;在這些維度上,37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦 可能不必每次從零試探(條件級,取決於資料)(從 結論五之二 + 步驟二之二之七 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.生成函數 的定義 推出)【正文:句6280755437】\n- 結論五之四:這不保證每個 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦 取得的內容相同,也不保證材料是對的(從 前提二 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.黑箱律 + 結論五之三 推出)【正文:句4898378037】\n- 結論五之五:文化 不以是否寫下來為界(從 文化 的定義 + 共振 的定義 推出)【正文:句0107640385】\n- 結論五之六:本篇不為劃群設定標準;切到多大、劃哪些人、看哪些維度,由研究者自己定;當事人若也劃群,研究者也當作一次 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別 來描述(從 前提二十四 + 結論一之二之四 推出)【正文:句5379058071、句2391732268】\n- 附註:基督徒與穆斯林各自切,彼此不是一體;外部切,是亞伯拉罕諸教;模型不裁決。【正文:句0355165570】\n- 結論五之七:(條件級)被表達出來的切是一筆 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出,37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 對方後,若進入相應的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.迴路,可能回頭改變被切的網路(從 結論一之二之三 + 循環二之三之六之一 推出)【正文:句6733140160】\n- 結論五之八:(條件級)研究者在指定維度與時窗下看到的 共振 圖樣是一層;當事人若也劃群並表達出來,則另有當事人自己的劃界與歸屬一層(從 結論五之一 + 結論五之二 + 結論五之六 + 結論五之七 推出)【正文:句2016183157】\n- 結論五之九:(條件級)當事人若也劃群,兩層可以不一致,不互相推出(從 結論五之八 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.黑箱律 推出)【正文:句3331418332】\n- 結論五之十:文化 沒有主體,不被某人持有或傳遞(從 結論五之二 + 文化 的定義 推出)【正文:句1920789585】\n- 結論五之十一:文化 是無尺度的:一個村子有 文化,一個大範圍的 文化 也是 文化(從 結論五之二 + 結論二之六之十三 + 文化 的定義 推出)【正文:句6997271137】\n- 結論五之十二:文化 的形成離不開 自然環境 的約束(從 文化 的定義 推出)【正文:句2410143870】\n- 附註:遊牧 文化 搬到紐約,預設派不上用場;現代人進草原與進沙漠沒有本質區別,因為都是沒有對應 自然環境 累積的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 模式。【正文:句2655148833】\n- 附註:文化 的維度之間,後果可以更直接或更間接(例如找水、食物的後果直接,失禮的後果可能只是被冷落);這是論文的例示與用法,不作推導來源,不另設分類(見 前提二十)【正文:句4302258355】\n- 步驟五之十四之一:(條件級,在研究者的某個 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.切法 下)自然環境 對各 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.節點 的基本行為構成約束(從 結論二之五之九 推出)【正文:句7551297294】\n- 步驟五之十四之一之一:(條件級)在與 自然環境 的互動中得到負面 結果回饋 的做法,這些 結果回饋 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 自己後進入 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.歷史,可能改變後續 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.權重(從 學習 的定義 + 步驟二之二之五 + 結果回饋 的定義 推出)【正文:句0502644150】\n- 步驟五之十四之一之二:(條件級,取決於資料)若這些 結果回饋 使 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.權重 遠離該做法,且這個遠離在之後的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 中持續(不主張必然持續,後續其他 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 可能改變 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.權重),該做法在之後的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 中整體的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.權重 變輕,傾向不再被反覆 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出;該做法的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 原本會 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 對方者,也隨之傾向不再被反覆 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達(b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 與 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 是兩個事件,後者以 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 發生並能到達對方為前件);學習 沒有預設方向,是否遠離取決於資料(從 步驟五之十四之一之一 + 結論二之二之八 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.生成函數 的定義 推出)【正文:句0502644150】\n- 步驟五之十四之二:(條件級)共振 之後留下來的圖樣中,傾向不再包含在與 自然環境 的互動中得到負面 結果回饋、且 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.權重 因此遠離並在之後的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 中持續的做法(不主張所有不配合 自然環境 的做法都會得到負面 結果回饋),所以反覆留下來的是尚未被這類 結果回饋 推開的做法;各維度的接續在 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.歷史 中可能互相依賴(從 步驟五之十四之一 + 步驟五之十四之一之二 + 共振 的定義 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦 的定義 推出)【正文:句0502644150】\n- 結論五之十五:(條件級)在這個 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.切法 下,文化 傾向不保證能像積木一樣任意拼裝或移植;失去原有的 自然環境 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出,移植的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 模式可能失去對應的 結果回饋 來支撐(從 步驟五之十四之二 + 結果回饋 的定義 推出)【正文:句2187869674】\n- 結論五之十六:(條件級)這是傾向,不是必然;換一種 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.切法,邊界與 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.耦合 程度可以不同(從 結論五之十五 + b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.切法 的定義 + b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.耦合 的定義 推出)【正文:句4413530989】\n- 結論五之十七:(條件級,用到前提九)37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.頻率 高、結果回饋 強、學習 夠快、退出成本 高、自然環境 變化相對慢,各 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.節點 在該維度上的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 落入相容區域的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.權重 傾向變重,不要求 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.趨同(從 前提九 + b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.趨同 的定義 + 共振 的定義 推出)【正文:句0345873684】\n- 結論五之十八:(條件級,用到前提九)退出成本 低、37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.頻率 低、結果回饋 弱、學習 慢、自然環境 變化快,傾向低(從 前提九 推出)【正文:句0345873684】\n- 結論五之十九:傾向高不保證形成,傾向低不保證不形成;區間外不保證(從 前提九 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.黑箱律 推出)【正文:句6764671807】\n- 結論五之二十:文化 與 ae79e938-76e1-4bf9-b2ab-995c03e16c9e.默契 並列,不依附,不互相推出(從 文化 的定義 + ae79e938-76e1-4bf9-b2ab-995c03e16c9e.默契 的定義 推出)【正文:句6281916289】\n- 附註:[作者裁決] 「結果回饋 與相容圖樣,只描述,不帶目的;本篇不把 文化 的邏輯一致性寫成來自意志的設計」是論文的方法選擇,不由 ae79e938-76e1-4bf9-b2ab-995c03e16c9e.驅動力不可確認 推出。【正文:句2961449545、句7073904883】\n- 結論五之二十二:每個 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦 在各 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.時刻 都可能有 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 與 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達;自然環境 與別的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.節點 可能給出 結果回饋(含代價與 退出成本);37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.權重 落在哪一層,取決於研究者怎麼切 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.節點:把神經元、一個人或一家公司當作 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.節點,就得到那一層級的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.節點 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.權重;在講明的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.切法 下,每個被當作 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.節點 的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦 下一 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.時刻 各結果的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.權重,取決於 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 它的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.歷史(從 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.生成函數 的定義 + 結論二之三之六 + 結果回饋 的定義 + 退出成本 的定義 + 懲罰 的定義 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 的定義 + b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.切法 的定義 + b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.節點 的定義 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.權重 的定義 推出)【正文:句1719035815、句5096699102】\n- 附註:本篇不假定網路整體有單一的方向,只談各 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.節點、各 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.迴路 各自的方向,彼此可以一致、相反或無關;這是論文的立場宣告,不是推導。【正文:句1719035815、句5096699102】\n- 結論五之二十三:(條件級,取決於資料)在持續的 結果回饋 下,在與 自然環境 的互動中持續得到負面 結果回饋 的行為組合,若 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.權重 因此遠離它,且這個遠離在之後的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 中持續,傾向不會長期被反覆 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達(學習 沒有預設方向,是否遠離取決於資料;不主張必然持續)(從 步驟五之十四之一之二 + 結論五之二十二 + 結論二之二之十 推出)【正文:句9151680427】\n- 附註:[作者裁決] 「這只描述事後留下什麼,不寫 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.節點「為了適應而採取」,也不寫篩選有目的」是論文的方法選擇,不由所列來源推出。【正文:句9151680427】\n- 結論五之二十四之一:不被 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.鎖死 的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦 下一 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.時刻 只能推出 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.權重、推不出結果(從 結論二之二之三 推出)【正文:句4859386389】\n- 結論五之二十四之二:不被 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.鎖死 的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.隨機源 下一 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.時刻 只能推出 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.權重、推不出結果(從 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.隨機源 的定義 推出)【正文:句4859386389】\n- 結論五之二十四之三:負面 結果回饋 可能是被冷落、被拒絕、損失,不一定是 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.退場;退出成本 與 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.退場 層級不同,所以篩選可以是有程度的(從 結果回饋 的定義 + b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.退場 的定義 + 結論二之四之六 推出)【正文:句4859386389】\n- 結論五之二十四之四:別的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.節點 本身也會給出 結果回饋,「適合」隨其 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 移動(從 結論五之二十二 + 結果回饋 的定義 推出)【正文:句4859386389】\n- 附註:「篩選」在本篇只作比喻,指 共振 留下什麼的事後描述,不寫 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.節點 為了適應而採取,也不寫篩選有目的。【正文:句4859386389】\n- 結論五之二十四:(條件級,取決於資料)不被 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.鎖死 的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.節點 下一 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.時刻 只推出 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.權重、推不出結果;若各結果中有 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.權重 為正、卻不符合該 自然環境 的,個別 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.節點 可能偏離,所以不推出「所有 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.節點 都會採取適合該 自然環境 的行為」;篩選可以是有程度的,「適合」隨別的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.節點 的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 移動(自然環境 變得比篩選快時的情形見結論七之四之一之二)(從 結論五之二十四之一 + 結論五之二十四之二 + 結論五之二十四之三 + 結論五之二十四之四 + 結論二之一之五 + 結論五之二十三 推出)【正文:句4859386389】\n- 附註:論文把「各結果中有 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.權重 為正、卻不符合該 自然環境 者」寫成「個別節點可以偏離」的前件;所列來源未建立這個前件,不作推導來源。【正文:句4859386389】\n- 附註:「計算」「篩選」「淘汰」「倖存解」在本篇只作比喻使用,須標明是比喻。【正文:句7672661107】\n\n## 模板(第六節)\n\n來源:論文第六節【正文:句3583578421】\n\n- 結論六之一:模板 是抽象化、可重複使用的規則或資料,被明列在 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.信號容器 裡(從 模板 的定義 推出)【正文:句4334705227】\n- 結論六之二:被 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.鎖死 的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.信號容器 中所列的 模板,內容不會自己變,在某維度上提供固定點,不需要先 共振 就能取得(從 模板 的定義 + b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.信號容器 的定義 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.鎖死 的定義 推出)【正文:句9673677217】\n- 結論六之三:同一規則有兩份文本就是兩份 模板(從 模板 的定義 推出)【正文:句4184078073】\n- 結論六之四:模板 是 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.信號容器 裡的固定內容,不是 文化 的一層(從 結論六之一 + 模板 的定義 推出)【正文:句8335506755】\n- 結論六之五:模板 的有無依研究者指定的判準判定(從 前提六 推出)【正文:句7774612077】\n- 結論六之六:模板 的來源可以是某個群體的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 被明列、被寫入 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.信號容器(從 模板 的定義 + b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 的定義 + b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.信號容器 的定義 推出)【正文:句8205851811】\n- 結論六之七:共振 出來的東西若被抽象為可重複使用的規則或資料並明列在 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.信號容器 裡,就成為 模板(可以被寫成 模板);寫成之後,b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.信號容器 裡的內容與人們實際照著做的相容圖樣是兩件事,存續各自另論,互相不推出(從 結論六之六 + 結論六之四 + 模板 的定義 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.黑箱律 推出)【正文:句2170885893】\n- 結論六之八:模板 是 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.信號容器 內的固定內容;內容經 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.邊 或 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.信號容器 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 接收者;把內容複製到另一個 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.信號容器,依 模板 的定義,同一規則的兩份文本是兩份 模板;b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.信號容器 內的內容不必耗損,差異在接收者的使用;不耗損指 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.信號容器 內的內容,不指接收者取得的部分(從 步驟二之二之七 + 結論六之二 + 結論二之四之九 + 前提二 + 模板 的定義 + b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.信號容器 的定義 推出)【正文:句6604289593】\n- 結論六之十:強制 是另一個時間點的事:違反可由第三方判定,但不保證遵守,也不保證違反被判定與執行(從 結論四之四 推出)【正文:句2066004098】\n- 結論六之十一:大型節點 的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 若被明列在 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.信號容器 裡,且符合 模板 的抽象化、可重複使用,才是 模板 的來源;若是照片這類 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出,37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 許多 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.節點 後是否 共振 成 文化,事後才能說(從 結論六之六 + 模板 的定義 + 結論三之七 推出)【正文:句4634868554】\n- 結論六之十二:模板 經 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.邊 或 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.信號容器 傳,照片這類 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 沿 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.邊 或經 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.信號容器 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達;兩者載物不同,都是 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.節點 之間的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達(從 步驟二之二之七 + 結論六之八 + 結論六之十一 推出)【正文:句7613028478、句6604289593、句4634868554、句3303248615】\n- 附註:[作者裁決] 「不寫該 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.節點 為何這樣做,不寫它有沒有想要的結果」是論文的方法選擇,不由 ae79e938-76e1-4bf9-b2ab-995c03e16c9e.驅動力不可確認 推出。【正文:句9009129456】\n- 結論六之十四:(條件級,用到 退出成本 低)模板 在陌生人篇中,可能是低頻 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.邊 上的材料,讓人能先估計對方的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.權重 傾向、不必從零試探(理由見結論四之十一,不保證當面時的行為接得上對方);是否可靠 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.不被保證(從 結論四之十之二 + 結論四之十一 + 結論四之十二 推出)【正文:句2116134082】\n- 附註:[作者裁決] 論文此處的「也可以被誤讀」同第四節:不完整接收不等於誤讀,從不完整接收到誤讀的可能性不由所列來源推出,不作推導來源。【正文:句2116134082】\n- 結論六之十五:共同 模板 在某維度上提供雙方都能取得的固定點;若雙方都取得並採用它,且它適用於該維度,雙方可據以估計對方,不必從零試探(條件級);這不推出雙方在該維度之外相容(從 結論六之二 + 模板 的定義 + 結論四之十二 推出)【正文:句1969911497】\n\n## 存續與 崩潰(第七節)\n\n來源:論文第七節【正文:句8207128027】\n\n- 結論七之二之一:ae79e938-76e1-4bf9-b2ab-995c03e16c9e.外生背景 是範圍上的設定,不主張背景不變(從 ae79e938-76e1-4bf9-b2ab-995c03e16c9e.外生背景 的定義 推出)【正文:句2345033034】\n- 結論七之二之二:依前提十,每個維度有自己的變化速度,變化慢於時窗時視為固定(從 前提十 推出)【正文:句0771572190】\n- 結論七之二之三:文化 與 自然環境 在變化慢於所講明時窗的維度上可當常量;時窗拉得夠長,文化 也可能隨 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.歷史 的持續變化而改變(從 前提十 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.流變律 + 文化 的定義 推出)【正文:句2345033034】\n- 附註:[作者裁決] 原句「兩個比值都很大」是筆誤,意思只是:時窗短,變化慢的東西可以當常量;世界久了,原來當常量的就不穩定。論文已改。\n- 結論七之三:37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.歷史 一直在變,不會停;變多少、往哪變、是否仍接得上,b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.不被保證(從 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.流變律 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.黑箱律 推出)【正文:句7590190059】\n- 附註:[作者裁決] 論文此處沒有帶「渦」「不被鎖死」的限定;所引 流變律 與 黑箱律 的適用範圍較窄(流變律 以 渦 為對象,黑箱律 以 渦 不被 鎖死 的 時刻 為條件);作者維持論文原文,結論僅在該範圍內由來源支持。\n- 步驟七之四之一之一:(條件級)共振 的形成是 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 模式反覆相容接續;若 自然環境 在某維度上變化得比這個形成更快,且這個變化使原本接得上的做法接不上,這些做法可能帶回負面 結果回饋;若 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.權重 因此遠離,且這個遠離在之後的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 中持續,這些做法傾向不再被反覆 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達(從 共振 的定義 + 結果回饋 的定義 + 步驟五之十四之一之二 推出)【正文:句9332805478、句0502644150】\n- 步驟七之四之一:(條件級,取決於資料)在講明的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.切法 下,自然環境 若在某維度上的變化速度大於該維度上 共振 的形成速度,且這個變化使原本接得上的做法接不上,若 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.權重 因此遠離這些做法,且這個遠離在之後的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 中持續,這些做法傾向難以維持為穩定的 共振;是否形成別的接續模式,取決於資料(從 步驟七之四之一之一 推出)【正文:句9332805478】\n- 結論七之四之一之二:(條件級,取決於資料)自然環境 變得比篩選快(這裡 篩選 只指 共振 的形成,是比喻)時,留下的做法不一定適合現在的 自然環境(從 步驟七之四之一 推出)。這是結論五之二十四所述的情形【正文:句4859386389】\n- 附註:[作者裁決] 原句「改變得比 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 模式更快,圖樣不再被反覆 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達」改為以形成速度比較:環境變化速度大於 共振 形成速度,就傾向沒有穩定的 共振。論文已改。\n- 結論七之四之二:(條件級,在研究者的某個 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.切法 下)自然環境 在某維度上變得很大、而且回不到原來的樣子(例如從草原搬到紐約)時,原有圖樣可能失去 結果回饋 的支撐;若失去,且原有圖樣的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.權重 因此遠離並在之後的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 中持續,文化 傾向跟著改變(從 結論五之十五 + 結論五之二 + 步驟五之十四之一之二 推出)【正文:句7237591097】\n- 結論七之五:崩潰 是在指定尺度、維度與時窗下,原來的秩序失去了;秩序指不必逐次指導就能相容接續的預設與接續模式;事後的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別 由作判斷的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.我 劃定(從 崩潰 的定義 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別 的定義 推出)【正文:句9045433493、句2389674179】\n- 結論七之六:崩潰 無尺度,有程度、逐維度(從 崩潰 的定義 推出)【正文:句0328026573】\n- 附註:熟人篇未使用 崩潰 一詞,是範圍上的選擇,不是修正。【正文:句9341626842】\n- 結論七之七:崩潰 與 ae79e938-76e1-4bf9-b2ab-995c03e16c9e.失配、b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.退場 判準不同,可為成因或形態,不蘊含(從 崩潰 的定義 + ae79e938-76e1-4bf9-b2ab-995c03e16c9e.失配 的定義 + b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.退場 的定義 推出)【正文:句0592664970】\n- 結論七之八:界限不能由 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.黑箱律 事先唯一推出:37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦 各自在不被 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.鎖死 的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.時刻 只能談 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.權重,共振 是否維持只能事後說;落空比例(事後統計的、原本相容的接續中未能接上的比例,是外顯統計,不是真實 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.權重 的讀數);不能用它唯一推出下一次是否接得上,只能作為有條件的、不保證準確的參考(從 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.黑箱律 + 結論三之七 + 結論二之六之十五 + 落空比例 的定義 推出)【正文:句9724092332】\n- 附註:[作者裁決] 論文此處沒有限定「渦 不被 鎖死 的 時刻」於 落空比例 這一句;黑箱律 的適用範圍較窄;作者維持論文原文,結論僅在該範圍內由來源支持。\n- 結論七之九:模板 與 文化 存續互相獨立:模板 靠 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.信號容器,文化 靠 自然環境 加反覆 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達(從 結論六之七 + 結論五之二 推出)【正文:句0069679461】\n- 附註:拉丁文是 模板 在、無人以它為日常;儒家是 文化 在、該 模板 不再被反覆 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達;〔Java〕是計算機 文化 裡的外來 模板,對中國人是 和平學習 。【正文:句3739546078】\n- 結論七之十:崩潰 之後是重建、替代還是空白,b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.不被保證(從 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.黑箱律 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.損耗律 + 前提二 + 結論七之六 推出)【正文:句1612315426】\n- 附註:[作者裁決] 就算各結果在大方向上其實都導向同一類,沒有任何 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦 拿得到判斷這一點所需的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.歷史 資料(37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.損耗律、前提二),仍是黑箱,所以不被保證。【正文:句1612315426】\n- 附註:[作者裁決] 「本篇不寫好壞,不寫之後」是論文的方法選擇,不由所列來源推出。【正文:句1612315426】\n\n## 禁止清單(第八節)\n\n來源:論文第八節【正文:句2746352098】\n\n- 附註:本篇的方法上禁止如下;其中「不得」「須」的要求列為 前提二十五至前提三十六 [限定條件],本節只留下由來源推出的陳述。\n- 結論八之二:沒有任何 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達,就沒有 共振,有 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 也不保證(從 結論三之七 + 結論三之四之一 + 結論五之十九 + 共振 的定義 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 的定義 推出)【正文:句4107582062、句1261748627、句1607722015】\n- 結論八之三:對不被 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.鎖死 的對象,驅動力不能被完整觀測、被自述確認或被事後證實;外顯分佈不等於 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.權重(見 結論二之六之十五)(從 ae79e938-76e1-4bf9-b2ab-995c03e16c9e.驅動力不可確認 + 結論一之一 + 結論四之七 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.黑箱律 + 結論二之六之十五 推出)【正文:句0133531578、句7702980826、句9419062778】\n- 結論八之八:文化、模板 或 自然環境 當固定,只在講明的時窗內、變化慢於時窗的維度上成立;地方條件只在講明的時窗內視為給定,不是永久不變,也不是對所有維度同樣有驅動(從 結論二之五之十 + 結論七之二之三 + 前提十 推出)【正文:句0957264659、句2345033034】\n- 附註:前提十的常量判準以維度為單位,對象是 自然環境、文化 或 模板 都適用同一判準。\n- 附註:[作者裁決] 不得用 落空比例 唯一推出 崩潰 會不會發生,也不得用它證明「這次變化仍在界限內」,是論文禁止清單直接規定的方法要求,不由所列來源推出;理由見 結論七之八(落空比例 是外顯統計,不能唯一推出下一次是否接得上)。【正文:句0608096830】\n\n## 案例(第九節)\n\n來源:論文第九節【正文:句2154415457】\n\n- 附註:本節整節是校準,不作任何推導的來源;三案是三個局部視角下的片段,不是三種類型;寫的是溝通的困難與各說各話,不寫他們說了什麼,因為想法從外部不可確認。【正文:句3726611237、句8180424603、句1552189520】\n\n## 結論分級與可證偽條件(第十節)\n\n來源:論文第十節【正文:句5924057640】\n\n- 附註:約束級結論只由 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.流變律、37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.黑箱律、37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.損耗律、37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.不可復原律、ae79e938-76e1-4bf9-b2ab-995c03e16c9e.驅動力不可確認,以及本篇的前提一至前提六、前提十、前提二十三與前提二十四推出;[作者裁決] 前提二十一(研究者被當作一個 我 的設定)已在論文第一節第二小節聲明為「本篇的設定」,是模型前件,第十節不重列;條件級結論另用到前提七至前提九,或特定 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.切法 下逐維度的時間尺度比,或取決於資料的前件;第九節的案例是校準,不屬於任何一級。【正文:句4362446892、句8165807028、句6194946986】\n- 附註:[作者裁決] 結論十之一至結論十之五採稽核總表 8.14 的第二種寫法:「某項前提 的否定條件」,列出哪些結論失去來源;「失去來源」是來源鏈檢查,不是前提推出結論,也不表示結論為假。各條行尾「(從 前提某 推出)」只表示失去來源的判準以該前提的來源鏈為依據,不表示由該前提為真推出這些結論。\n- 結論十之一:前提二 的否定條件是:存在某個 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.呈現,其 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.自己的那一段 全部 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 了某個 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦。該條件成立時,失去來源者為來源鏈含前提二的結論(約束級的如 結論二之五之三、結論二之五之十二之三、結論二之五之十四;條件級的如 步驟二之六之四、結論二之六之五;另有 步驟一之二之一、結論二之二之六、結論五之四)及依賴它們者;其餘不受影響;失去來源者變成沒有來源的主張,真假不由本篇判定(從 前提二 推出)【正文:句8642140345、句1532453159】\n- 結論十之二:前提一 的否定條件是:某個 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.我 的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別 在它的下一個 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.時刻 之前沒有 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 它自己。該條件成立時,失去來源者為來源鏈含前提一的結論,包括 步驟二之二之五,以及用到它的條件級結論(如 結論四之九之一、步驟五之十四之一之一)及依賴它們者;其餘不受影響;失去來源者變成沒有來源的主張,真假不由本篇判定(從 前提一 推出)【正文:句8642140345、句1532453159】\n- 附註:前提三至前提五與前提十是範圍設定,不是可被推翻的主張;改動它們是改變本篇處理的範圍,依賴它們的結論須重新核對。【正文:句3738831742】\n- 附註:失去來源只表示推導鏈斷開,不表示該命題為假。【正文:句3374280257】\n- 結論十之三:前提六 的否定條件是:研究者指定的判準不可表述、不可再取得,或不可代入指定類型的新情境,以致 模板 的有無不能依它判定。該條件成立時,失去來源者為來源鏈含前提六的結論,包括 結論六之五(第六節的可判定性)及依賴它者;其餘不受影響;失去來源者變成沒有來源的主張,真假不由本篇判定(從 前提六 推出)【正文:句8642140345、句1532453159】\n- 結論十之五之一:前提七 的否定條件是:某個作為 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.我 的生物人在一段時間內能接收的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 並不有限。其中任一項成立時,失去來源者為來源鏈含被違反那一項的條件級結論,其餘不受影響;失去來源者變成沒有來源的主張,真假不由本篇判定(從 前提七 推出)【正文:句2397213938、句1532453159】\n- 結論十之五之二:前提八 的否定條件是:生物人(前提八 的適用對象)的神經傳導不需要時間,或反應不需要時間,或對方對一筆 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 的反應與該 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 同時發生;非生物人對象的同時反應不算否定。其中任一項成立時,失去來源者為來源鏈含被違反那一項的條件級結論,其餘不受影響;失去來源者變成沒有來源的主張,真假不由本篇判定(從 前提八 推出)【正文:句2397213938、句1532453159】\n- 結論十之五之三:前提九 的否定條件是:在講明的維度與時窗內,符合前提九所列參數條件的許多情況裡,37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.權重 整體上沒有往前提九所說的方向變動(傾向本身不成立)。個別情況的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.權重 沒有變動,只是傾向在該次沒有實現,不算否定。其中任一項成立時,失去來源者為來源鏈含被違反那一項的條件級結論,其餘不受影響;失去來源者變成沒有來源的主張,真假不由本篇判定(從 前提九 推出)【正文:句7601158981】\n- 結論十之五之四:前提十九 的否定條件是:在講明的維度與時窗內,符合前提十九所列條件(退出成本 低、37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.頻率 低、沒有緩衝)的許多情況裡,這條 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.邊 上的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 整體上沒有比其他情形更容易停止或減少(傾向本身不成立)。個別情況的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 沒有停止或減少,只是傾向在該次沒有實現,不算否定。其中任一項成立時,失去來源者為來源鏈含被違反那一項的條件級結論,即結論四之六之二,其餘不受影響;失去來源者變成沒有來源的主張,真假不由本篇判定(從 前提十九 推出)【正文:句5992946809】\n- 附註:前提十是範圍設定,不是可被推翻的主張,沒有否定條件(論文 1.3 節的分類,不是推導)【正文:句2612624427、句3738831742】\n- 附註:[作者裁決] 前提二十一是本篇把研究者當作一個 我 的設定,不是可被事實推翻的主張,沒有否定條件(與前提十同類;這不是推導)。【正文:句0850422405】\n- 附註:前提十是範圍設定,不是可被推翻的主張;某維度變化快過講明的時窗卻被當作常量,是違反本篇的範圍約定,不是前提十被否定。此時來源鏈含 前提十 的結論(包括 結論二之五之十、結論七之二之二、結論七之二之三、結論八之八 及依賴它們者)須重新核對,其餘不受影響;重核之前,其真假不由本篇判定,也不是整篇失效。【正文:句1532453159】\n- 附註:第九節的案例不屬於任何一級;沒有取得的資料不寫成「不存在」,也不用來支持結論。【正文:句3126796294、句6757616246】\n\n## 待決項\n\n無\n","paper_files":[{"filename":"互動動力學-陌生人迴路中的專屬歷史變動與更新.md","content":"---\nuuid: 2ccbf179-58cf-4851-bd72-5fa886e4b2c3\nlast-modified: 2026-10-17T02:05:51\nauthor: 黃正宇 / Cheng Yu Huang\ncontact: mthree.tw@gmail.com\n---\n\n# 互動動力學-陌生人迴路中的專屬歷史變動與更新\n\n## 〇、問題與定位\n\n本篇的問題是:兩個陌生人怎麼互動。本篇是《互動動力學-共同外生背景下的二階網路》(下稱熟人篇)的子論文。熟人篇處理[專屬歷史](../paper_ae79e938_76e1_4bf9_b2ab_995c03e16c9e/concepts.md#c05)在許多維度上都多、材料足夠且持續[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)的情形;本篇處理[專屬歷史](../paper_ae79e938_76e1_4bf9_b2ab_995c03e16c9e/concepts.md#c05)少的情形,以及一條[邊](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c29)上的[專屬歷史](../paper_ae79e938_76e1_4bf9_b2ab_995c03e16c9e/concepts.md#c05)怎麼在各維度上從少變多、從多變少。\n\n「熟人」「陌生人」是日常語言,不是模型裡的量。模型裡只有一條[邊](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c29)上、逐維度累積的[專屬歷史](../paper_ae79e938_76e1_4bf9_b2ab_995c03e16c9e/concepts.md#c05);見面的[頻率](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c48)是另一個參數,不能替代[專屬歷史](../paper_ae79e938_76e1_4bf9_b2ab_995c03e16c9e/concepts.md#c05)。天天見到早餐店老板,只在「賣早餐」這個維度上有[專屬歷史](../paper_ae79e938_76e1_4bf9_b2ab_995c03e16c9e/concepts.md#c05),在其他維度上仍是陌生。因此本篇不把人分成兩類,也不排成一條軸,只說:在被講明的維度上,這條[邊](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c29)的[專屬歷史](../paper_ae79e938_76e1_4bf9_b2ab_995c03e16c9e/concepts.md#c05)少,日常語言通常把這種情形叫做陌生人。本篇的用語約定:本篇所說的熟人與陌生人,只指其[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)曾[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)某個[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19)者,即在該[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19)的[可達子圖](concepts.md#c07)之內。這是範圍上的約定,不由[可達子圖](concepts.md#c07)的定義推出,本段不是約束級結論。\n\n本篇只處理已[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)的。沒有任何[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)過某個[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19)的對象,不在這個[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19)的[可達子圖](concepts.md#c07)之內,對這個[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19)而言不是本篇所討論的陌生人,也不需要討論(前提五與上述用語約定)。本篇不討論感受,討論經驗:本篇所說的經驗,指已經[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)所構成的[歷史](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13)(這是本篇的約定,範圍依前提三限定)。\n\n本篇不分短模型與長模型。[文化](concepts.md#c13)與[模板](concepts.md#c14)能不能暫時當固定,取決於各維度的變化速度相對於所看時窗,是連續的光譜;[自然環境](concepts.md#c16)在講明的時窗與[切法](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c23)下視為[外生背景](../paper_ae79e938_76e1_4bf9_b2ab_995c03e16c9e/concepts.md#c02)時,須同時講明這個時窗與[切法](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c23)。\n\n本篇的結論分兩級,沿用熟人篇的做法。約束級結論只由第一節列出的律與前提推出,能推翻其中任何一條,結論即失效。條件級結論另用到某項經驗前件或某個講明的假定,行文會點明用了哪一項,現實若違反它,該結論失效。經驗前件只作推導的輸入,不拿來證明約束為真。第九節的案例是校準,不屬任何一級。\n\n## 一、繼承與約束\n\n### 1.1 繼承\n\n本篇使用[流變律](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c24)、[黑箱律](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c25)、[損耗律](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c26)與[不可復原律](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c28)。本篇也使用[驅動力不可確認](../paper_ae79e938_76e1_4bf9_b2ab_995c03e16c9e/concepts.md#c03):對不被[鎖死](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c12)的對象,它的驅動力,也就是動機、需求與目的,從外部不能被完整觀測,不能被自述確認,旁人事後對動機的判斷只是[看法歸屬](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c02)或[印象](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c45)。本篇的方法上禁止由此而來,列於第八節;上游的前提與步驟,本篇不引用其編號,需要的前提自行重述於 1.3。\n\n### 1.2 約束零:切法\n\n研究者在本篇對高維[歷史](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13)所作的陳述,皆為某一[切法](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c23)下的陳述。把研究者當作一個[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19)(本篇的設定),依前提二及其依據[損耗律](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c26),別人的[呈現](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c04)不能完整表達自己,研究者也不能完整接收,所以從任何單一[呈現](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c04)都拿不到別人高維[歷史](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13)的整體;本篇不假定把多個[呈現](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c04)拼起來能還原整體,只能指定維度、時窗與分類規則之後談一個切面,這個「切出一部分」就是[切法](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c23);本句只限研究者在本篇所作的陳述,不主張世上所有關於高維[歷史](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13)的陳述都如此;沒有「不切」的版本可以拿來對照。每個命題須連同下列各項一併報告:維度集合、時窗、分類規則、參與的[節點](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25),以及[切法](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c23)的選擇者與理由。未連同報告者,不構成本篇的結論。[切法](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c23)是研究者作出的一次[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18),被表達出來就算研究者的一次[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28),帶選擇,須標明誰選、為何選。當事人若也把哪些[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19)看作一群,這是劃群的人從全體中切出一部分的一次[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18),本篇不另立概念。本段為約束級結論。\n\n### 1.3 本篇的前提\n\n本篇另有十二項前提,皆不是新的律,也不由其他前提推出。前提一、前提二是對上游律的使用方式的重述;前提三至前提六、前提十、前提二十三與前提二十四是範圍設定;前提七至前提九是經驗前件。\n\n```text\n前提一 一個 我 的每一次 分別,都在它的下一個 時刻 之前 到達 它自己。\n前提二 對任何 呈現 甲 與任何 渦 乙(甲 可以是 乙 自己),甲 自己的那一段 中總有沒有 到達 乙 的部分(依損耗律,一個 我 不能完全分別自己;其 輸出 只來自這份不完全的分別,所以任何 呈現 都不能完整表達自己,接收者也不能完整接收到它)。\n前提三 範圍設定:本篇只討論已 到達 的 輸出 所構成的 歷史,不討論感受。\n前提四 範圍設定:在本篇處理的範圍上,情境空間(誰、何時、何事、何種組合)不可窮舉;任何有限歷史只覆蓋其中一部分。\n前提五 範圍設定:子圖只計已 到達,即對方的 輸出 確實進入過某個 渦 的 歷史(含經轉述而到達的 輸出);不另設「可經路徑到達」的潛在概念。\n前提六 範圍設定:模板 的有無依研究者指定的判準判定;判準為可表述、可再取得、可代入指定類型的新情境。\n前提七 經驗前件:生物人(作為 我)在一段時間內能接收的 到達 有限。\n前提八 經驗前件:生物人的神經傳導與反應需要時間,對方對一筆 輸出 的反應不可能與該 輸出 同時發生。\n前提九 經驗前件:在講明的維度與時窗內,一群 我 之間,若 到達 頻率較高、結果回饋較強、學習較快、退出成本較高,且自然環境在該維度上的變化相對於行為模式的變化較慢,則各 節點 在該維度上的 輸出 落入相容區域的 權重 傾向變重;若這些參數較低、自然環境的變化相對較快,則傾向變輕。這只說 權重 傾向變動,不說一定形成或一定不形成,五個參數都須講明如何判準,數值區間取決於資料,區間外不保證。\n前提十 範圍設定:每個維度有自己的變化速度;在講明的時窗內,變化慢於時窗者視為固定的常量,變化快過時窗者不得當常量。\n前提二十三 範圍設定:在講明的時窗內,一個 渦 累積的 歷史 是有限的。\n前提二十四 範圍設定:本篇不為劃群設定標準;切到多大、劃哪些人、看哪些維度,由劃群的人自己定並講明。\n附註 前提一、前提二是重述;前提三至前提六、前提十、前提二十三與前提二十四是範圍設定;前提七至前提九是經驗前件,作推導的輸入,不拿來證明約束為真。\n```\n\n\n## 二、模型\n\n### 2.1 節點的類型與單元\n\n[節點](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25)有三類:[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)、[信號容器](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c26)、[隨機源](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c27)。[小迴路](concepts.md#c02)只屬於[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16):[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)回到自己的[歷史](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13),參與自己之後的[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06)。[信號容器](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c26)(書、法條、[模板](concepts.md#c14)所在處)不是[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16),從某一[時刻](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c09)起每一步都被[鎖死](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c12),沒有[小迴路](concepts.md#c02);它可以向[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28),內容可以由[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)寫下,所以一個[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)寫、另一個[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)讀,構成兩個[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)之間經[容器](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c26)的間接[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)。[隨機源](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c27)(例如骰子)既不是[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)也不是[信號容器](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c26),也沒有[小迴路](concepts.md#c02),某個[時刻](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c09)不被[鎖死](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c12)時只能談[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06)。本段為約束級結論。\n\n在一次[切法](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c23)下,兩個[節點](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25)與兩種[迴路](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c31)構成的結構,稱為[單元](concepts.md#c01):兩個[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)各有一個[小迴路](concepts.md#c02),另有一個[大迴路](concepts.md#c03)把兩者連起來。[小迴路](concepts.md#c02)是[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)回到自己的[歷史](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13)的[迴路](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c31);[大迴路](concepts.md#c03)是甲的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)乙、乙的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)甲,各自參與對方之後的[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06)的[迴路](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c31)。[單元](concepts.md#c01)必須講明在哪個維度上判斷。[迴路](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c31)跨[時刻](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c09)持續存在[不被保證](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c02):某個[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)[退場](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c43),或[迴路](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c31)在某個[時刻](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c09)起不再成立時,這個[迴路](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c31)結束。[信號容器](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c26)與[隨機源](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c27)可以接在[單元](concepts.md#c01)的[邊](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c29)上,但不是[單元](concepts.md#c01)的主體。形象的說法是盤子裡放兩個荷包蛋:兩個[小迴路](concepts.md#c02)被[大迴路](concepts.md#c03)包起來;這只是比喻,不是模型的一部分。\n\n每條[邊](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c29)上的[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)是有方向的;兩個方向可以只有一個存在,也不必同時發生。[單元](concepts.md#c01)中的每個[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16),其[歷史](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13)既可能有自己的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)回到自己,也可能有別人的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)它;這兩者若發生,都參與它之後的[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06)。\n\n### 2.2 一輪更新\n\n每個[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)、每條[邊](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c29),在每個[時刻](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c09)都可能經歷下列四步,直到所在的[迴路](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c31)結束(見 2.1);其中[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)與[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)依定義發生,[學習](concepts.md#c04)與[結果回饋](concepts.md#c05)則可能隨對應的[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)發生(本段為約束級結論)。\n1. [輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)。[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)的下一[時刻](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c09)[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28),由它到當時為止的[歷史](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13)經[生成函數](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c15)給出各[分支](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c05)的[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06)([分支](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c05)的輕重)。[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)是[坍塌](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c08)依[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06)[選出](../paper_54c0291d_05b3_431a_9f2a_1b8ec93c3c3f/concepts.md#c32)一個[分支](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c05)的結果,連同它的[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)內容。[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06)不是任何[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)內部的參數,也不由[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)的「認為更優」直接給出。不被[鎖死](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c12)時,只能推出[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06),推不出結果。[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)在[決定](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c06)的結果事先算不準時「認為哪個更優」屬於它自己的[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)([候選](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c18)、[自我說服](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c19));這個[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)自己後進入[歷史](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13),參與之後的[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06),不保證對,不保證一致。\n2. [到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)。[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)沿[邊](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c29)或經[信號容器](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c26)[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)別的[節點](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25),進入對方的[歷史](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13),只增不減。\n3. [學習](concepts.md#c04)。[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)的材料累積進[歷史](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13),可能改變後續[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06)的過程。[學習](concepts.md#c04)是結果條件,不指目的,沒有預設方向,不保證學到、不保證學對。判定只看[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)之後可觀察的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)有改變,不證明改變來自哪一筆[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)。\n4. [結果回饋](concepts.md#c05)。[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)之後的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)再[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)自己的後續互動,帶回實際後果。事前[學習](concepts.md#c04)的方向不可預測,事後結果可以判;判準在其他[節點](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25)與[自然環境](concepts.md#c16)的反應結果裡,不在發生[學習](concepts.md#c04)的[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)內部:學會語言就能說話,學會禮貌大概率改善互動,反之可能有代價。\n\n### 2.3 組合\n\n一個[節點](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25)可以同時是許多條[邊](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c29)的一端。[邊](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c29)是有方向的(本篇所說的「認識」,只指對方的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)過):「我認識他」是他的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)過我,「他認識我」是我的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)過他,兩個方向可以只有一個存在,也不必同時發生。因此一個[節點](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25)可以有幾十幾百條進來的[邊](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c29),同時有幾十幾百條出去的[邊](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c29)。這個形狀可以比喻成海膽(比喻,不是模型的一部分)。每個[單元](concepts.md#c01)的[邊](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c29)都可以與另一些[單元](concepts.md#c01)共用[節點](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25),這些[單元](concepts.md#c01)又各自與更多[單元](concepts.md#c01)共用[節點](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25),[迴路](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c31)因此可以彼此交疊。每條[邊](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c29)上輸入與[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)的都是高維的內容:語言、行為、所用的器具等,都是沿著網路傳遞的高維[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)。複雜性來自:處處有回饋;每個[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)下一[時刻](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c09)的[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06)取決於到當時為止[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)它的[歷史](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13);影響沿[迴路](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c31)回來,可能改變之後[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)的輸入;在把研究者算入的[切法](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c23)下,研究者也是網上的[節點](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25)。這些[迴路](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c31)同樣可能結束(見 2.1)。本段為約束級結論。\n\n### 2.4 邊的參數\n\n[邊](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c29)上有三個參數:[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)的[頻率](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c48)、[專屬歷史](../paper_ae79e938_76e1_4bf9_b2ab_995c03e16c9e/concepts.md#c05)、[退出成本](concepts.md#c06)。\n[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)的[頻率](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c48),是[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)多常發生;它是[份量](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c47)的假定之一,須寫明,不替代[專屬歷史](../paper_ae79e938_76e1_4bf9_b2ab_995c03e16c9e/concepts.md#c05)。[專屬歷史](../paper_ae79e938_76e1_4bf9_b2ab_995c03e16c9e/concepts.md#c05)按維度計:它是這條[邊](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c29)兩端之間、在一個講明的維度上,彼此互相[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)所構成的那一段[歷史](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13),所以同一條[邊](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c29)的兩端之間可以在一個維度上有彼此[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)的材料、在另一個維度上沒有材料(第一次[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)之前為零);[專屬歷史](../paper_ae79e938_76e1_4bf9_b2ab_995c03e16c9e/concepts.md#c05)是按維度計的歷史段,不是[邊](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c29)的大小,也不假定可量。[退出成本](concepts.md#c06)是一個[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19)讓這條[邊](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c29)上的[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)停止或減少時,要承受的[結果回饋](concepts.md#c05);每一端各算各的,可以不對稱。成本低就是可以輕易放棄這條[邊](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c29),成本高就是幾乎不得不繼續。可觀察的版本:給出負面[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)之後,對方仍持續出現、持續[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28);外顯分不出原因,不寫動機。[退出成本](concepts.md#c06)與[退場](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c43)層級不同([邊](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c29)與[節點](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25)),不互相蘊含;[退出成本](concepts.md#c06)高不蘊含不退出,極高也不等於[退場](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c43)。本段為約束級結論。\n\n[份量](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c47)與[歧異度](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c49)不是[邊](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c29)的參數,而是「一筆[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)相對於接收者」的屬性。[份量](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c47)是這筆[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)能移動多少[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06),是[生成函數](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c15)內部的事,不能相加;[歧異度](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c49)是它和接收者過去收到的東西差多遠。同一筆[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)不同的[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19),[份量](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c47)與[歧異度](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c49)依各自的[歷史](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13)而定,可以不同,對各自[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06)的移動也可以不同。本段為約束級結論。\n\n### 2.5 可達子圖與自然環境\n\n以某個[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)為中心,在講明的時窗內,所有曾有[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)它的[呈現](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c04),連同這些[呈現](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c04)與它之間的[邊](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c29),構成它的[可達子圖](concepts.md#c07)(前提五)。每個[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)各有一張。依前提二,沒有任何[呈現](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c04)的[自己的那一段](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c17)能全部[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)某個[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)。在講明的時窗內,子圖外的對象的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)沒有[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)過這個[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16),時窗內該對象與這個[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)之間的專屬材料為零(對象是[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19)時才談專屬材料);進入子圖是一筆新的[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10),依[不可復原律](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c28),已[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)的材料只加不減。[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)是有向的:一方有材料,不蘊含另一方有材料。本段為約束級結論。\n\n子圖有限:每個[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)在講明的時窗內累積的[歷史](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13)有限(前提二十三);結合情境空間不可窮舉(前提四),任何子圖覆蓋的情境只是其中一部分;對未被覆蓋的情境,已有的[歷史](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13)不保證這個[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)後續的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)與對方相容;沒有別的依據時,可以重新試探。這兩項為約束級,用到前提二十三與前提四。\n\n校準(不作推導來源):一個人讀過某位公眾人物大量的公開[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28),對方卻從未收到他的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28),這是單向[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10);已[退場](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c43)者留下的檔案可以無限增加,[結果回饋](concepts.md#c05)卻為零。兩者都說明資料量與[結果回饋](concepts.md#c05)是兩個會脫鉤的量。\n\n[自然環境](concepts.md#c16)是在講明的[切法](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c23)下,不屬於模型中任何[節點](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25)、卻有[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)這些[節點](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25)的部分,包含物理條件,例如地形、氣候、水與食物;它對各[節點](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25)最基本的行為構成約束。[自然環境](concepts.md#c16)在講明的時窗與[切法](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c23)下不隨模型中的[迴路](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c31)更新時,視為[外生背景](../paper_ae79e938_76e1_4bf9_b2ab_995c03e16c9e/concepts.md#c02),[外生背景](../paper_ae79e938_76e1_4bf9_b2ab_995c03e16c9e/concepts.md#c02)可以變;依前提十,要在該時窗內把它當固定的常量,它在該維度上的變化須慢於所看的時窗;變化快過時窗時,不得當常量,依賴它為常量的結論須重核(見第七節)。本段為約束級結論。\n\n這個結構有三個尺度,不是三種位置:[單元](concepts.md#c01);一個[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)的[可達子圖](concepts.md#c07);一個特定範圍內的全域圖。單一[個體](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c20)能否拿到全域圖,取決於網路中每個對象的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)是否都[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)過它:若某個對象屬於所討論的網路,而某個[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19)尚未被這個對象的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10),這個對象就不在該[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19)的[可達子圖](concepts.md#c07)之內,該[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19)的[可達子圖](concepts.md#c07)就不涵蓋整個網路。擁有大量網路資料的機構(機構是[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16),由回應與輸入構成,不是地點或建築物)可能取得一定程度的全圖資料,但其資料是[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)機構的東西(不限於各[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19)的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)),依前提二仍不完整,也不涵蓋所有維度。[大型節點](concepts.md#c08)是在講明的[切法](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c23)與時窗內,[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)的[節點](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25)數極大、幾乎涵蓋所指範圍內每一個[節點](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25)的[節點](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25),例如政府、公眾人物、大型企業。[大型節點](concepts.md#c08)是真實存在的[節點](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25),不是假想的研究者。影響大不只是[節點](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25)自己的屬性:同一筆[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)不同的[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19),[份量](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c47)與[歧異度](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c49)依各自的[歷史](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13)而定,可以不同,所以[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)廣不蘊含影響大;依前提二,沒有任何[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19)能完整接收別人,所以也不蘊含全知;有目的則是[驅動力不可確認](../paper_ae79e938_76e1_4bf9_b2ab_995c03e16c9e/concepts.md#c03),本篇不寫。本段為約束級結論。\n\n### 2.6 專屬歷史在各維度上的變動\n\n接觸增加[專屬歷史](../paper_ae79e938_76e1_4bf9_b2ab_995c03e16c9e/concepts.md#c05):雙方[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)互相[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10),材料只加不減。分開不刪除[歷史](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13)([不可復原律](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c28)),而是可能使材料與對方現狀脫節:分開期間,對方的[歷史](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13)仍在變([流變律](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c24)),變化中可能有沒有[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)你的部分(前提二只保證對方[自己的那一段](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c17)中總有沒有[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)你的部分,不保證每一段變化都有)。對方的[歷史](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13)已經變了,你手上是舊材料,用它估計對方現在的相容區域,依據在指定[切法](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c23)下可能下降(條件級,取決於變動的維度與相容判準)。因此只看累積量不足以判斷「有效」,材料與對方現狀的距離可能也要看。以上對每個維度各自成立。本段中關於舊材料用來估計對方現在的相容區域,以及「有效」的兩句為條件級,其餘為約束級結論。\n\n日常說的陌生,至少對應兩種情形(不窮盡):對象剛進入[可達子圖](concepts.md#c07),單向的[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)材料開始累積,要到對象是[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19)、雙方的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)互相[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)之後,才開始累積[專屬歷史](../paper_ae79e938_76e1_4bf9_b2ab_995c03e16c9e/concepts.md#c05);有舊材料而沒有新[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)。這兩種情形不能混為一談。重逢時,若舊材料與對方現況之間有落差,且落差使雙方相鄰的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)在指定維度與判準下不相容,就是[失配](../paper_ae79e938_76e1_4bf9_b2ab_995c03e16c9e/concepts.md#c08);有沒有落差、落差有多大、是否造成這種不相容,取決於資料,屬條件級。\n\n位置不單調:接觸只增加材料,不保證相容;分開只可能使材料過時,不抹除它。重新接觸是新的一次,不是原來狀態的[復原](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c27)([不可復原律](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c28))。舊材料可能讓重新校準比從零快,也可能因對方已變而[失配](../paper_ae79e938_76e1_4bf9_b2ab_995c03e16c9e/concepts.md#c08),快慢不保證。這套規則不分[單元](concepts.md#c01)大小:兩個朋友、兩個家族久未往來而生疏,是同一個結構,只要講明[切法](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c23)。本段為約束級結論。\n\n本篇不假定[專屬歷史](../paper_ae79e938_76e1_4bf9_b2ab_995c03e16c9e/concepts.md#c05)的有效量是一個數。只在指定[切法](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c23)下比較:某維度、某時窗下,相容接續是否比前一個時點更多、更少或[持平](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c52);可計數的維度才報數字,並標明那只屬於該[切法](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c23),不推到其他維度。本篇所稱[外顯資料](concepts.md#c18),指被選中、被表達出來的結果及其摘要;它不等於完整的[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06)與依賴路徑。本段為約束級結論。\n\n## 三、逐維度的走向\n\n對一對[節點](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25)、一個維度,看兩邊[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)模式之間的距離隨時間的變化。三種走向都屬[耦合](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c36)之下,都須講明維度:變小是[趨同](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c37);變大是[趨異](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c38);不變是[持平](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c52)。日常說的「排斥」只是日常語言,不是模型裡另一個概念。[趨異](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c38)不蘊含[太極](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c39);雙方互相針對、互相強化的情形,上游稱為[太極](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c39),雙方都是[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19)時,外顯為[衝突](../paper_ae79e938_76e1_4bf9_b2ab_995c03e16c9e/concepts.md#c10)。本段為約束級結論。\n\n[共振](concepts.md#c09)是本篇的詞:在講明的維度與時窗內,多個[節點](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25)的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)模式反覆相容接續。[共振](concepts.md#c09)須以[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)為條件:[節點](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25)彼此之間有[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10),或有共同的來源(例如[信號容器](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c26)、[自然環境](concepts.md#c16))對它們都有[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10);完全沒有[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10),就沒有[共振](concepts.md#c09)。它的判準是相容,也就是[失配](../paper_ae79e938_76e1_4bf9_b2ab_995c03e16c9e/concepts.md#c08)的反面,不是距離。距離的變化方向不是判準,距離變小、變大或不變,本身都不決定是否相容:例如一問一答,兩邊模式不同,仍可反覆相容接續。[趨同](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c37)可以通向[共振](concepts.md#c09),但不推出;[共振](concepts.md#c09)也不推出[趨同](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c37)。是否[共振](concepts.md#c09),只能事後說。[共振](concepts.md#c09)不同於[默契](../paper_ae79e938_76e1_4bf9_b2ab_995c03e16c9e/concepts.md#c06):[默契](../paper_ae79e938_76e1_4bf9_b2ab_995c03e16c9e/concepts.md#c06)是兩個[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19)之間按維度計的[專屬歷史](../paper_ae79e938_76e1_4bf9_b2ab_995c03e16c9e/concepts.md#c05)上的相容接續;[共振](concepts.md#c09)不要求[專屬歷史](../paper_ae79e938_76e1_4bf9_b2ab_995c03e16c9e/concepts.md#c05),也不限兩個[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19)。本段為約束級結論。\n\n高維下每個維度各自走向:部分[趨同](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c37)、部分[趨異](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c38)、部分[持平](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c52)。系統論的同步現象只作校準對照,不主張它與本模型是同一種結構的特例,不引用同步定理。本篇自己的用語一律用[共振](concepts.md#c09)。\n\n## 四、可達子圖內的概念\n\n下列概念都在被講明的維度與時窗下使用,都不是新增的律。\n| 概念 | 在模型裡是什麼 |\n|---|---|\n| 陌生人的起點 | 第一次[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)發生的那一刻,[專屬歷史](../paper_ae79e938_76e1_4bf9_b2ab_995c03e16c9e/concepts.md#c05)在該維度上從零開始 |\n| [失配](../paper_ae79e938_76e1_4bf9_b2ab_995c03e16c9e/concepts.md#c08) | 相鄰[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)在某維度上不相容;序列的性質,不帶後果 |\n| [懲罰](concepts.md#c10) | 一個[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)之後,[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)者的、在講明的判準下算作代價的[結果回饋](concepts.md#c05)。判準須講明是誰的:[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)者自己的[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18),或研究者的判準,兩者可以不一致。不一定暴力,不一定明列 |\n| [強制](concepts.md#c11) | [懲罰](concepts.md#c10)已被明列成規則,寫在[信號容器](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c26)裡,違反可由第三方判定;[懲罰](concepts.md#c10)可以是暴力,也可以不是。不保證遵守,不保證違反被判定與執行。規則先於違反,是另一個時間點的事 |\n| [容錯率](concepts.md#c12) | 在講明的維度上,一個[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19)對對方的[失配](../paper_ae79e938_76e1_4bf9_b2ab_995c03e16c9e/concepts.md#c08)所能容忍的程度的上限;超過上限,這條[邊](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c29)就可能終止。[退出成本](concepts.md#c06)低、[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)[頻率](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c48)低、沒有緩衝時,這條[邊](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c29)上的[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)較容易停止或減少(條件級,取決於資料:[退出成本](concepts.md#c06)低時可輕易放棄這條[邊](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c29),見[退出成本](concepts.md#c06)的定義;[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)[頻率](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c48)低與沒有緩衝的作用為觀察,區間外不保證;這是觀察,不推內部容忍度)。可觀察的版本:給出負面[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)之後,對方仍持續出現、持續[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28);外顯分不出原因,不寫動機 |\n| 名聲(日常用語;此處是用法說明,不是新定義) | 經第三者的[邊](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c29)[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)的、關於對方過去[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)的材料;有損,只能作為形成[印象](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c45)的材料,不是[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06)的讀數 |\n| 禮節(日常用語;此處是用法說明,不是新定義) | 日常所說的禮節,在本篇指[共振](concepts.md#c09)中被反覆[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)模式,違反若帶來後續代價([結果回饋](concepts.md#c05)),且[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06)因此遠離違反並持續,這個模式傾向維持(條件級,取決於資料) |\n| [模板](concepts.md#c14) | 見第六節 |\n\n低頻[邊](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c29)上能依賴的材料有:名聲、禮節、[模板](concepts.md#c14)(加[強制](concepts.md#c11))。[退出成本](concepts.md#c06)低時,這條[邊](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c29)在初期可能因某一步而不再存在;在這種情況下,這些材料可能讓人在初期就對對方形成[印象](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c45):這些材料是關於對方[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)的痕跡(對方的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)本身,或經轉述、經[信號容器](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c26)而來的材料),[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)接收者後進入它的[歷史](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13);對方的[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06)由對方到當時為止的[歷史](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13)決定([黑箱律](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c25)),接收者拿不到對方[歷史](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13)的整體(前提二,依[損耗律](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c26)),只能從已[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)的材料形成[印象](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c45),據此判斷對方[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06)的傾向([印象](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c45)不是[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06)的讀數),例如對方有誠實的名聲,即使不知道名聲是否屬實,也可以據此估計他的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)傾向誠實;這個判斷是接收者的一次[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18),進入它自己的[歷史](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13),參與它之後的[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06)(條件級,用到[退出成本](concepts.md#c06)低;判斷不保證準確,也不保證當面時的行為接得上對方)。材料是否可靠[不被保證](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c02),也可以被誤讀(依[損耗律](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c26),材料只來自不完全的[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18),接收者也不能完整接收)。本段中關於材料如何讓人形成[印象](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c45)的一句為條件級,其餘為約束級結論。\n\n生物人前件:接收有限(前提七)、反應有延遲(前提八),給的是共同的限制,不是共同的內容。[歷史](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13)不歸零不是經驗前件:[歷史](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13)只加不減是[不可復原律](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c28)與[流變律](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c24)的結論,屬約束級。本段中用到前提七與前提八的部分為條件級。\n\n## 五、文化(研究者對共振的命名)\n\n[文化](concepts.md#c13)是研究者對[節點](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25)之間出現的[共振](concepts.md#c09)的命名。在指定的[切法](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c23)、維度與時窗下,它是無數[單元](concepts.md#c01)在特定[自然環境](concepts.md#c16)約束下,經過反覆的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)、[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)與[結果回饋](concepts.md#c05),留在[歷史](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13)中的一組相容圖樣:哪些維度組合能不被反覆打斷地接續下去。對身處其中的[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)而言,這組圖樣經由具體的[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)進入它的[歷史](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13),參與它的[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06);先[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)的材料已經進了[歷史](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13),[歷史](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13)依[生成函數](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c15)參與[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06);在這些維度上,[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)可能不必每次從零試探(條件級,取決於資料)。這不保證每個[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)取得的內容相同,也不保證材料是對的。[文化](concepts.md#c13)不以是否寫下來為界:[共振](concepts.md#c09)出來的相容圖樣,不論有沒有被寫進[容器](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c26),都叫[文化](concepts.md#c13)。本段除標明條件級的一句外,為約束級結論。\n\n劃群是一次[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18),依前提二十四,本篇不為它設定標準。切到多大、劃哪些人、看哪些維度,由研究者自己定;當事人若也切,研究者把它當作一次[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)來描述。基督徒與穆斯林各自切,彼此不是一體;外部切,是亞伯拉罕諸教;模型不裁決。切本身是一筆[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28),[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)對方後,若進入相應的[迴路](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c31),可能回頭改變被切的網路。研究者在指定維度與時窗下看到的[共振](concepts.md#c09)圖樣是一層;當事人若也劃群並表達出來,則另有當事人自己的劃界與歸屬一層。兩層若都有,可以不一致,不互相推出。[文化](concepts.md#c13)沒有主體,不被某人持有或傳遞。[文化](concepts.md#c13)也是無尺度的:一個村子有[文化](concepts.md#c13),一個大範圍的[文化](concepts.md#c13)也是[文化](concepts.md#c13)。本段中關於切回頭改變被切的網路、當事人若也劃群所對應的兩層,以及兩層可以不一致的三句為條件級,其餘為約束級結論。\n\n[文化](concepts.md#c13)的形成離不開[自然環境](concepts.md#c16)的約束。遊牧[文化](concepts.md#c13)搬到紐約,預設派不上用場;現代人進草原與進沙漠沒有本質區別,因為都是沒有對應[自然環境](concepts.md#c16)累積的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)模式。[文化](concepts.md#c13)的維度有的連到生存條件(找水、食物),有的只是被冷落;本篇不設「[文化](concepts.md#c13)的維度」與「非[文化](concepts.md#c13)的維度」之分,只談後果更直接或更間接。本段為約束級結論。\n\n[自然環境](concepts.md#c16)約束的強[耦合](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c36)與不可拼裝(條件級,在研究者的某個[切法](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c23)下):[自然環境](concepts.md#c16)對各[節點](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25)最基本的行為構成約束(如海洋或草原)。在指定的[切法](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c23)、維度與時窗下,留下來的[共振](concepts.md#c09)圖樣傾向不再包含被[自然環境](concepts.md#c16)負面回饋推開的做法:在與[自然環境](concepts.md#c16)的互動中得到負面[結果回饋](concepts.md#c05)的做法,這些回饋進入[歷史](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13),若使[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06)遠離該做法,且這個遠離在之後的[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)中持續(不主張必然持續;[學習](concepts.md#c04)有沒有朝這個方向,取決於資料),該做法就傾向不再被反覆[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10),所以反覆留下來的是尚未被這類回饋推開的做法;各維度的接續在[歷史](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13)中也可能互相依賴。因此在這個[切法](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c23)下,[文化](concepts.md#c13)傾向不保證能像積木一樣任意拼裝或移植;失去原有的[自然環境](concepts.md#c16)[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28),移植的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)模式可能失去對應的[結果回饋](concepts.md#c05)來支撐。這是傾向,不是必然;換一種[切法](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c23),邊界與[耦合](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c36)程度可以不同。\n\n[共振](concepts.md#c09)容易形成的傾向(條件級,用到前提九):[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)[頻率](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c48)高、[結果回饋](concepts.md#c05)強、[學習](concepts.md#c04)夠快、[退出成本](concepts.md#c06)高、[自然環境](concepts.md#c16)變化相對慢,各[節點](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25)在該維度上的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)落入相容區域的[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06)傾向變重,不要求[趨同](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c37);[退出成本](concepts.md#c06)低、[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)[頻率](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c48)低、[結果回饋](concepts.md#c05)弱、[學習](concepts.md#c04)慢、[自然環境](concepts.md#c16)變化快,傾向低。傾向高不保證形成,傾向低不保證不形成;區間外不保證。\n\n[文化](concepts.md#c13)與[默契](../paper_ae79e938_76e1_4bf9_b2ab_995c03e16c9e/concepts.md#c06)並列,不依附,不互相推出。\n\n[結果回饋](concepts.md#c05)與相容圖樣,只描述,不帶目的。本篇不把[文化](concepts.md#c13)的邏輯一致性寫成來自意志的設計。每個[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)在各[時刻](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c09)都可能有[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)與[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10);[自然環境](concepts.md#c16)與別的[節點](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25)可能給出[結果回饋](concepts.md#c05)(含代價與[退出成本](concepts.md#c06))。[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06)落在哪一層,取決於研究者怎麼切[節點](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25):把神經元、一個人或一家公司當作[節點](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25),就得到那一層級的[節點](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25)的[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06);在講明的[切法](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c23)下,每個被當作[節點](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25)的[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)下一[時刻](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c09)各結果的輕重,取決於[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)它的[歷史](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13);本篇不假定網路整體有單一的方向,只談各[節點](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25)、各[迴路](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c31)各自的方向,彼此可以一致、相反或無關。(條件級,取決於資料)在持續的[結果回饋](concepts.md#c05)下,在與[自然環境](concepts.md#c16)的互動中持續得到負面[結果回饋](concepts.md#c05)的行為組合,傾向不會長期被反覆[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10):這些後果進入[歷史](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13),若使[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06)遠離這個行為組合,且這個遠離在之後的[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)中持續([學習](concepts.md#c04)沒有預設方向,是否遠離取決於資料;不主張必然持續),它就越來越少被[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28);這只描述事後留下什麼,不寫[節點](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25)「為了適應而採取」,也不寫篩選有目的。本段除標明條件級的一句外,為約束級結論。\n\n這不推出「所有[節點](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25)都會採取適合該[自然環境](concepts.md#c16)的行為」:不被[鎖死](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c12)的[節點](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25)下一[時刻](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c09)只能推出[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06)、推不出結果,若各結果中有[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06)為正、卻不符合該[自然環境](concepts.md#c16)者,個別[節點](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25)可以偏離;負面[結果回饋](concepts.md#c05)可能是被冷落、被拒絕、損失,不一定是[退場](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c43),所以篩選可以是有程度的;別的[節點](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25)本身也會給出[結果回饋](concepts.md#c05),「適合」隨其[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)移動;[自然環境](concepts.md#c16)變得比篩選快時,留下的不一定適合現在的[自然環境](concepts.md#c16)(見第七節)。「計算」「篩選」「淘汰」「倖存解」在本篇只作比喻使用,須標明是比喻。本段中以「這不推出」開頭的一句為條件級,其餘為約束級結論。\n\n## 六、模板\n\n[模板](concepts.md#c14)是抽象化、可重複使用的規則或資料,被明列在[信號容器](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c26)裡。[容器](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c26)被[鎖死](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c12),內容不會自己變,在某維度上提供固定點,不需要先[共振](concepts.md#c09)就能取得。同一規則有兩份文本就是兩份[模板](concepts.md#c14)。[模板](concepts.md#c14)是[容器](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c26)裡的固定內容,不是[文化](concepts.md#c13)的一層。[模板](concepts.md#c14)的有無依研究者指定的判準判定(前提六)。本段為約束級結論。\n\n[模板](concepts.md#c14)的來源可以是某個群體的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)被明列、被寫入[容器](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c26)。[共振](concepts.md#c09)出來的東西可以被寫成[模板](concepts.md#c14);寫成之後,[容器](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c26)裡的內容與人們實際照著做的相容圖樣是兩件事,存續各自另論,互相不推出。[模板](concepts.md#c14)是[容器](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c26)裡的固定內容;內容經[邊](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c29)或[容器](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c26)[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)接收者;把內容複製到另一個[容器](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c26),依[模板](concepts.md#c14)的定義,同一規則的兩份文本是兩份[模板](concepts.md#c14);[容器](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c26)內的內容不必耗損([容器](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c26)被[鎖死](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c12),內容不會自己變),差異在接收者的使用(同一筆[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)對不同的[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19)[份量](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c47)不同,任何[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19)也不能完整接收別人;不耗損指[容器](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c26)內的內容,不指接收者取得的部分)。[模板](concepts.md#c14)與承載群的關係有兩個切分:內生、外生;不[強制](concepts.md#c11)、[強制](concepts.md#c11)。這是關係,不是世界上有哪幾種東西,並且相對於所畫範圍。[強制](concepts.md#c11)是另一個時間點的事:違反可由第三方判定,但不保證遵守,也不保證違反被判定與執行。本段為約束級結論。\n\n[大型節點](concepts.md#c08)的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28),若被明列在[信號容器](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c26)裡(例如國家元首簽署的法令),且符合[模板](concepts.md#c14)所要求的抽象化、可重複使用,才是[模板](concepts.md#c14)的來源;若是照片這類[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28),[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)許多[節點](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25)後是否[共振](concepts.md#c09)成[文化](concepts.md#c13),事後才能說。兩者載物不同,走同一張網。不寫該[節點](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25)為何這樣做,不寫它有沒有想要的結果。本段為約束級結論。\n\n[模板](concepts.md#c14)在陌生人篇中,可能是低頻[邊](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c29)上的材料,讓人能先估計對方的[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06)傾向、不必從零試探(條件級,用到[退出成本](concepts.md#c06)低;機制見第四節,不保證當面時的行為接得上對方);是否可靠[不被保證](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c02),也可以被誤讀(理由見第四節)。共同[模板](concepts.md#c14)在某維度上提供雙方都能取得的固定點;若雙方都取得並採用它,且它適用於該維度,雙方可據以估計對方,不必從零試探(條件級);這不推出雙方在該維度之外相容。\n\n## 七、存續與崩潰\n\n依前提十,每個維度有自己的變化速度,變化慢於時窗時視為固定。[外生背景](../paper_ae79e938_76e1_4bf9_b2ab_995c03e16c9e/concepts.md#c02)是範圍上的設定,不主張背景不變;[文化](concepts.md#c13)與[自然環境](concepts.md#c16)在變化慢於所講明時窗的維度上可當常量,時窗拉得夠長,[文化](concepts.md#c13)也可能隨[歷史](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13)的持續變化而改變([流變律](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c24))。本段為約束級結論。\n\n約束級:[歷史](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13)一直在變,不會停([流變律](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c24));變多少、往哪變、是否仍接得上,[不被保證](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c02)([黑箱律](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c25))。條件級:在研究者的某個[切法](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c23)下,[自然環境](concepts.md#c16)在某維度上變得很大、而且回不到原來的樣子時(例如從草原搬到紐約),[文化](concepts.md#c13)傾向跟著改變(見第五節:原有[自然環境](concepts.md#c16)的[結果回饋](concepts.md#c05)可能消失,原有的[共振](concepts.md#c09)圖樣可能失去支撐;若失去,而且原有圖樣的[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06)因此遠離並在之後的[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)中持續,[文化](concepts.md#c13)就傾向跟著改變)。在講明的[切法](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c23)下,[自然環境](concepts.md#c16)若在某維度上的變化速度大於該維度上[共振](concepts.md#c09)的形成速度,且這個變化使原本接得上的做法接不上,若[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06)因此遠離這些做法,且這個遠離在之後的[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)中持續,這些做法傾向難以維持為穩定的[共振](concepts.md#c09);是否形成別的接續模式,取決於資料。\n\n[崩潰](concepts.md#c15)是在指定尺度、維度與時窗下,原來的秩序失去了;秩序指不必逐次指導就能相容接續的預設與接續模式。事後的[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18),由作判斷的[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19)劃定。[崩潰](concepts.md#c15)無尺度,有程度、逐維度:找水的維度失去,後果直接落在生存;某種禮節失去,後果可能只是被冷落。熟人篇未使用此詞,是範圍上的選擇,不是修正。[崩潰](concepts.md#c15)與[失配](../paper_ae79e938_76e1_4bf9_b2ab_995c03e16c9e/concepts.md#c08)、[退場](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c43)判準不同,可為成因或形態,不蘊含。本段為約束級結論。\n\n界限不能由[黑箱律](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c25)事先唯一推出:[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)各自在不被[鎖死](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c12)的[時刻](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c09)只能談[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06),[共振](concepts.md#c09)是否維持只能事後說;[落空比例](concepts.md#c17)(事後統計的、原本相容的接續中未能接上的比例,是外顯統計,不是真實[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06)的讀數);不能用它唯一推出下一次是否接得上,只能作為有條件的、不保證準確的參考。[模板](concepts.md#c14)與[文化](concepts.md#c13)存續互相獨立:[模板](concepts.md#c14)靠[容器](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c26),[文化](concepts.md#c13)靠[自然環境](concepts.md#c16)加反覆[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)。拉丁文是[模板](concepts.md#c14)在、無人以它為日常;儒家是[文化](concepts.md#c13)在、該[模板](concepts.md#c14)不再被反覆[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10);〔Java〕是計算機[文化](concepts.md#c13)裡的外來[模板](concepts.md#c14),對中國人是和平學習。[崩潰](concepts.md#c15)之後是重建、替代還是空白,[不被保證](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c02);本篇不寫好壞,不寫之後。本段為約束級結論。\n\n## 八、禁止清單\n\n本篇的方法上禁止如下。\n1. [切法](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c23)外不推。不得把[切法](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c23)下的結果推到[切法](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c23)外:未切的維度、取樣邊界之外,或「該[文化](concepts.md#c13)模式不存在」。不同[切法](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c23)之間的比較,須維度、時窗、分類規則一致。\n2. [共振](concepts.md#c09)只寫可能。[共振](concepts.md#c09)只寫「可能、可以是部分的」,不寫保證,不寫必然收斂,也不等於好、正確或友善。沒有任何[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10),就沒有[共振](concepts.md#c09);有[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10),也不保證。\n3. 不寫動機。不得把驅動力寫成可被觀測、被自述確認或被事後證實的事實;不得以「為了」解釋[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28),只寫可觀察的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)分佈(某個維度上某種[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)事後較多,或較前一時段增加);要談[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06)([分支](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c05)的輕重,如機率)時,須標明研究者只依不完整的外顯分佈,不能直接確定背後的[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06)值,只能作有條件的估計;分佈不等於[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06)(見 2.6 末段與本節第十三項)。記錄者與研究者的解讀一律標為[看法歸屬](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c02);「有所求」只寫成可觀察的版本。\n4. [學習](concepts.md#c04)不得寫成有方向或必然更好;不由互動次數、浸泡時間或能力,推出某次已學到某項內容。\n5. 不得由[文化](concepts.md#c13)、[模板](concepts.md#c14)、[默契](../paper_ae79e938_76e1_4bf9_b2ab_995c03e16c9e/concepts.md#c06)互相推出;不得由[模板](concepts.md#c14)存在或[強制](concepts.md#c11)存在推出被遵守;不得由遵守推出理解、認同或[默契](../paper_ae79e938_76e1_4bf9_b2ab_995c03e16c9e/concepts.md#c06)。\n6. 用「[文化](concepts.md#c13)」一詞,必須講明誰切、切哪些人、看哪些維度;不得用只有名稱、沒有判準的詞補解釋缺口,須指出具體的[歷史](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13)輸入。\n7. 不得寫[文化](concepts.md#c13)「決定」生存,不得寫「為了適應而形成」。\n8. 任何把[文化](concepts.md#c13)、[模板](concepts.md#c14)或[自然環境](concepts.md#c16)當固定的結論,須標明逐維度的時間尺度比;地方條件只在講明的時窗內視為給定,不得寫成永久不變,也不得寫成對所有維度同樣有驅動。\n9. 不得用[落空比例](concepts.md#c17)唯一推出[崩潰](concepts.md#c15)會不會發生,也不得用它證明「這次變化仍在界限內」。\n10. 不得由研究者的劃群推出當事人自認同一,也不得反過來。\n11. 不得把[大型節點](concepts.md#c08)寫成全知,也不得寫它們的目的。\n12. 不得寫熟人與陌生人是兩類關係;不得寫接觸單調增加熟悉;不得未經檢核就把舊材料寫成對現狀有效;不得把分開寫成[歷史](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13)消失。\n13. 不得把外顯統計、先後或一條記錄路徑,寫成真實[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06)或依賴路徑的直接讀數;不得把確定感當證據;說[趨同](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c37)、[趨異](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c38)或[持平](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c52)必須講明維度。\n14. 不得假定研究者在[迴路](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c31)之外:研究者的觀察、詢問與記錄若[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)被觀察的[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19),就進入對方的[歷史](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13),收不回。\n\n## 九、案例\n\n本節整節是校準,不作任何推導的來源。三案是三個局部視角下的片段,不是三種類型,用來看更新規則在不同材料量下怎麼走。寫的是溝通的困難與各說各話,不寫他們說了什麼,因為想法從外部不可確認。每案依七個步驟展開:[切法](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c23)、初始狀態、新的[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)、[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06)變化、結局、說明了什麼、可說與推不出。資料都取自網路公開頁面,不是原始檔,各案開頭標明讀到什麼、沒讀到什麼;研究者詮釋與記錄分開;來源[衝突](../paper_ae79e938_76e1_4bf9_b2ab_995c03e16c9e/concepts.md#c10)處只並列,不選邊。\n\n### 9.1 葡萄牙與圖皮尼金(一五〇〇)\n\n資料說明。讀到的有:〔Pero Vaz de Caminha〕一五〇〇年五月一日那封信的葡萄牙文全文頁面(經工具摘出相關段落,不是逐頁讀完)、維基百科的〔Caminha〕條目、一篇巴西學術文章對首次接觸的簡述。〔Góis〕的《編年史》只經該文轉述,未讀原書。岸上一側沒有這次接觸的當事記錄。族群名稱各來源不一致:維基百科寫〔Tupiniquim〕,那篇學術文章寫族群不明。\n\n1. [切法](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c23)。範圍是艦隊停泊在〔Porto Seguro〕附近的約十天(四月二十二日起)。[節點](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25)兩個:艦隊一方、岸上的人群。記錄者〔Caminha〕屬艦隊一方,也是唯一的來源,所以只有單邊的記錄。\n2. 初始狀態。記錄中看不到雙方共有的語言、[容器](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c26)或明列的規則;在這次接觸的維度上,雙方沒有[專屬歷史](../paper_ae79e938_76e1_4bf9_b2ab_995c03e16c9e/concepts.md#c05)。\n3. 新的[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)。以手勢與物件為主。艦隊一方的〔Nicolau Coelho〕示意對方放下弓,對方照做;雙方交換物件(衣物、鈴、鏡子等對玉米、麵粉、豆、果等);某次岸上一人對著土地比手勢,再指向頸鏈與燭臺。信中另有「打手勢要他們離開,他們就離開」,以及「那時沒有更多的話語或理解」。\n4. [權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06)變化。只寫外顯記錄:艦隊一方做出示意放下弓的手勢之後,對方放下弓;對方指向土地與頸鏈之後,艦隊一方的記錄寫成「那裡有金」。〔Caminha〕自己寫:「我們這樣理解,因為我們願意這樣理解。」這是記錄者對自己的解讀所作的歸屬,不是對方手勢含義的讀數。\n5. 結局。艦隊於五月三日離開;信中記載議定留下兩名流放犯。\n6. 說明了什麼。材料最少時,更新只靠試探:一方的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10),對方的後續[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)再[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10),一步一步試。第二,記錄者自承自己的解讀受「願意」影響,是[看法歸屬](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c02)的明例;同時對方一側沒有記錄,所以任何一邊的「意思」都只是單邊的歸屬。\n7. 可說與推不出。可說:在這份記錄裡,手勢與物件交換同時出現,雙方的後續[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)有改變。推不出:對方的手勢指什麼、是否真指金銀、如何看待艦隊的手勢;對方是哪個族群;信中對對方的描述是否準確;為什麼艦隊留下那兩個人。\n\n### 9.2 乒乓外交(一九七一至一九七二)\n\n資料說明。讀到的有:〔History Today〕〈乒乓外交的迷思與實況〉的內容摘要、〔History.com〕的條目摘要,都經工具摘出,不是原始檔。兩個來源有一處細節不一致(見第四步)。文中的「友誼」「偶然」都是各方或作者的歸屬。\n\n1. [切法](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c23)。範圍是一九七一年四月名古屋世界乒乓錦標賽到一九七二年中美兩隊互訪。[節點](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25)是中國隊與美國隊;中美政府、日本主辦方等視為從外部[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)。\n2. 初始狀態。兩國之間已有大使級會談(一九五五至一九七〇年共一百三十六次,據〔History Today〕),一九五七年有美國青年訪中團。記錄不能直接說明這些接觸在哪些維度上相容,因為相容判準沒有指定,本案不稱它們「接得上」或「接不上」。\n3. 新的[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)。一九七一年四月,美國選手〔Glenn Cowan〕上了中國隊的巴士,隊長莊則棟當著記者面送他一幅黃山絲織畫;其後美國隊受邀,四月十日自香港入境,在廣州、北京、上海比賽、參觀;四月十四日見周恩來。據〔History Today〕,中方依指示「友誼第一、比賽第二」,讓了部分比賽。球賽規則是雙方都有的明列規則,在這個窄維度上提供固定點。\n4. [權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06)變化。只寫外顯記錄:美國隊受邀、入境,雙方在球賽這一維度上相容接續(比賽照規則進行)。來源不一致:〔History.com〕說同日(四月十四日)尼克森宣布放寬旅行與貿易限制;〔History Today〕說尼克森已撤銷旅行禁令,沒有提貿易禁運。並列,不選邊。\n5. 結局。一九七一年七月季辛吉秘密訪北京;一九七二年二月尼克森訪中;一九七二年中國乒乓隊訪美八個城市。\n6. 說明了什麼。窄維度上,有現成的明列規則(球賽規則)時,雙方不必先熟悉就能接上;這個維度之外有沒有接上,要另看其他維度的記錄。「友誼」「偶然」「自發」都是各方或作者的歸屬:〔History Today〕作者認為這次接觸並非偶然,這是作者的詮釋,不當作記錄;毛澤東批准邀請一事,該文說有文件根據,本篇只引為「該文如此記載」。\n7. 可說與推不出。可說:在這份記錄裡,球賽接觸之後,其他維度上的接觸陸續增加。推不出:乒乓接觸造成了後來的訪問;各方為什麼這樣做;毛、周、尼克森各自的目的;後來的外交結果是否取決於這件事。\n\n### 9.3 烏查利條約(一八八九至一八九三)\n\n資料說明。讀到的有:維基百科的條約條目、華威大學一篇學生文章(〔Katie Blair〕,談殖民時期翻譯),都經工具摘出,不是原始檔。一八九〇至一八九三年之間的往來信件沒有讀到。兩個來源互相矛盾的地方只並列。\n\n1. [切法](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c23)。範圍是條約簽訂到孟尼利克二世公開否認(維基百科的簽訂日為一八八九年五月二日;否認日該條目前後寫一八九三年與一八九四年,不一致)。[節點](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25):意大利一方、衣索比亞一方,兩份文本(意大利文、阿姆哈拉文)視為兩個[信號容器](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c26),歐洲其他國家視為從外部[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)的[節點](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25)。\n2. 初始狀態。雙方在條約之前的[專屬歷史](../paper_ae79e938_76e1_4bf9_b2ab_995c03e16c9e/concepts.md#c05),來源未寫,本案不寫。\n3. 新的[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)。兩份文本都有二十條。第十七條,據維基百科,阿姆哈拉文版是「可以」利用意大利政府處理對外事務,意大利文版是「必須」透過意大利;差別在一個動詞的許可與強制。一八八九年十月意大利把「衣索比亞是保護國」的立場通告歐洲各國;奧斯曼帝國與俄國不接受,其他國家接受。\n4. [權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06)變化。只寫外顯記錄:兩份文本各自是固定內容,不會因為雙方的爭執而改變;變的是雙方與第三方之後的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)。孟尼利克否認保護國的讀法;一八九五年意大利入侵。\n5. 結局。阿杜瓦戰役(華威文章寫一八九六年)由衣索比亞獲勝,保住獨立。\n6. 說明了什麼。兩份文本就是兩份[模板](concepts.md#c14)(同一規則有兩份文本)。[模板](concepts.md#c14)的存在不保證雙方讀到同一個規則:不相容是經第三方的通告與雙方後續的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28),才回到當事人身上。\n7. 可說與推不出。可說:兩份文本在第十七條上不相容;有此不相容之後出現了通告、否認、入侵。推不出:是誰改了文本、是否蓄意、孟尼利克簽字時是否知道兩版不同;兩個來源在這幾點上互相矛盾(維基百科只寫動詞差別,未說誰改;華威文章稱〔Antonelli〕起草兩版、阿姆哈拉文版被改、孟尼利克簽時不知,並稱他事後的說法是種族歧視,這是該文作者的詮釋);入侵是否由條約爭議造成;一八九〇至一八九三年之間發生了什麼。\n\n## 十、結論分級與可證偽條件\n\n本篇的結論分兩級。約束級結論只由[流變律](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c24)、[黑箱律](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c25)、[損耗律](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c26)、[不可復原律](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c28)、[驅動力不可確認](../paper_ae79e938_76e1_4bf9_b2ab_995c03e16c9e/concepts.md#c03),以及本篇的前提一至前提六、前提十、前提二十三與前提二十四推出。條件級結論另用到前提七至前提九,或特定[切法](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c23)下逐維度的時間尺度比,或取決於資料的前件。第九節的案例是校準,不屬於任何一級。\n\n約束級結論如下。\n| 性質 | 概要 | 節 |\n|---|---|---|\n| [節點](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25)與[單元](concepts.md#c01) | 三類[節點](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25);[小迴路](concepts.md#c02)只屬於[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16);[邊](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c29)有方向;[退出成本](concepts.md#c06)與[退場](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c43)層級不同 | 2.1至2.4 |\n| [份量](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c47)與[歧異度](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c49) | 是一筆[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)相對於接收者的屬性,不是[邊](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c29)的參數 | 2.4 |\n| [可達子圖](concepts.md#c07) | 每個[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)各有一張,不保證有全域的那一張;每個[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)累積的[歷史](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13)有限、只覆蓋情境空間的一部分;子圖外時窗內專屬材料為零;[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)有向;[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)廣不蘊含影響大 | 2.5 |\n| [專屬歷史](../paper_ae79e938_76e1_4bf9_b2ab_995c03e16c9e/concepts.md#c05) | 逐維度;接觸增加材料,分開可能使材料與現狀脫節;位置不單調;重逢是新的一次;不定量 | 2.6 |\n| 走向與[共振](concepts.md#c09) | [趨同](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c37)、[趨異](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c38)、[持平](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c52)須講明維度;[共振](concepts.md#c09)不等於[趨同](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c37);[趨異](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c38)不蘊含[太極](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c39) | 三 |\n| [文化](concepts.md#c13) | 研究者對[共振](concepts.md#c09)的命名;不以寫下與否為界;沒有主體;描述不帶目的 | 五 |\n| [模板](concepts.md#c14) | [容器](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c26)裡的固定內容,不是[文化](concepts.md#c13)的一層;與[文化](concepts.md#c13)存續互相獨立 | 六 |\n| 存續 | [歷史](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13)一直在變;[崩潰](concepts.md#c15)無尺度、有程度、逐維度;界限不能由[黑箱律](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c25)事先唯一推出 | 七 |\n\n條件級結論如下。\n| 結論 | 用到的前件 | 節 |\n|---|---|---|\n| 重逢是否[失配](../paper_ae79e938_76e1_4bf9_b2ab_995c03e16c9e/concepts.md#c08)、重新校準快慢 | 取決於資料 | 2.6 |\n| 生物人前件:接收有限、反應有延遲 | 前提七、前提八 | 四 |\n| 對方離開([邊](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c29)上[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)停止或減少)的傾向 | [退出成本](concepts.md#c06)、[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)[頻率](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c48)、緩衝(區間外不保證) | 四 |\n| 這些材料可能讓人在初期對對方形成[印象](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c45) | [退出成本](concepts.md#c06)低 | 四、六 |\n| [共振](concepts.md#c09)容易形成的傾向 | 前提九 | 五 |\n| 在與[自然環境](concepts.md#c16)的互動中持續得到負面[結果回饋](concepts.md#c05)的行為組合,傾向不會長期被反覆[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) | 取決於資料 | 五 |\n| [自然環境](concepts.md#c16)約束的強[耦合](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c36)與不可拼裝 | 研究者的某個[切法](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c23) | 五 |\n| 當事人若也劃群並表達出來,研究者看到的[共振](concepts.md#c09)圖樣與當事人自己的劃界歸屬是兩層,可以不一致 | 當事人也劃群並表達出來 | 五 |\n| [自然環境](concepts.md#c16)在某維度上變得很大、而且回不到原來的樣子時(例如從草原搬到紐約),[文化](concepts.md#c13)傾向跟著改變 | 研究者的某個[切法](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c23) | 七 |\n| [自然環境](concepts.md#c16)變化速度大於[共振](concepts.md#c09)形成速度、且使原本接得上的做法接不上、[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06)因此遠離這些做法並持續時,這些做法傾向難以維持為穩定的[共振](concepts.md#c09) | 逐維度的時間尺度比 | 七 |\n| [模板](concepts.md#c14)的有無 | 前提六的判準 | 六 |\n\n什麼情況會使結論失效。約束級結論的根據是上游的律與本篇的前提一至前提六、前提十、前提二十三與前提二十四。這些前提被改變時,依賴它的結論失去根據:若存在某個[呈現](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c04),其[自己的那一段](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c17)全部[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)了某個[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16),前提二被推翻,2.5 與 2.6 中用到前提二的結論失去來源;若某個[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19)的[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)在它的下一個[時刻](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c09)之前沒有[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)它自己,前提一失效,用到它的結論失去來源;若研究者指定的判準不可表述、不可再取得,或不可代入指定類型的新情境,以致[模板](concepts.md#c14)的有無不能依它判定,前提六被推翻,第六節的可判定性失去來源。前提三至前提五、前提十、前提二十三與前提二十四是範圍設定,不是可被推翻的主張;改動它們是改變本篇處理的範圍,依賴它們的結論須重新核對。失去來源只表示推導鏈斷開,不表示該命題為假。前提九只說傾向:個別情況沒有實現,不算被違反;在講明的維度與時窗內,符合條件的許多情況整體上沒有往所說方向變動時,前提九算被違反。條件級結論的失效條件取決於它所用的前件:哪一個前件被現實違反,就只有用到它的結論失效,其餘不受影響;前提十是範圍設定,不是可被推翻的主張;某維度不適用它的約定(變化快過講明的時窗卻被當作常量)時,只有依賴該約定的結論須重新核對,不是整篇失效。\n\n什麼不是本篇的結論。第九節的案例不屬於任何一級。沒有取得的資料不寫成「不存在」,也不用來支持結論。\n"},{"filename":"Interaction Dynamics - Changes and Updates of Dedicated History in Stranger Loops.md","content":"---\nuuid: 2ccbf179-58cf-4851-bd72-5fa886e4b2c3\nlast-modified: 2026-10-17T02:05:51\nauthor: 黃正宇 / Cheng Yu Huang\ncontact: mthree.tw@gmail.com\n---\n\n# Interaction Dynamics - Changes and Updates of Dedicated History in Stranger Loops\n\n## 0. Problem and Positioning\n\nThe question of this paper is: how do two strangers interact? This paper is a sub-paper of *Interaction Dynamics - Second-Order Networks under a Common Exogenous Background* (hereafter the acquaintance paper). The acquaintance paper deals with the case where [dedicated history](../paper_ae79e938_76e1_4bf9_b2ab_995c03e16c9e/concepts.md#c05) is abundant in many dimensions, with sufficient material that keeps [arriving](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10); this paper deals with the case where [dedicated history](../paper_ae79e938_76e1_4bf9_b2ab_995c03e16c9e/concepts.md#c05) is scarce, and with how the [dedicated history](../paper_ae79e938_76e1_4bf9_b2ab_995c03e16c9e/concepts.md#c05) on one [edge](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c29) goes from little to much and from much to little in each dimension.\n\n\"Acquaintance\" and \"stranger\" are everyday words, not quantities in the model. The model has only the [dedicated history](../paper_ae79e938_76e1_4bf9_b2ab_995c03e16c9e/concepts.md#c05) on one [edge](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c29), accumulated dimension by dimension; the [frequency](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c48) of meeting is a separate parameter and cannot replace [dedicated history](../paper_ae79e938_76e1_4bf9_b2ab_995c03e16c9e/concepts.md#c05). Someone who sees the breakfast-shop owner every day has [dedicated history](../paper_ae79e938_76e1_4bf9_b2ab_995c03e16c9e/concepts.md#c05) with him only in the dimension of \"selling breakfast\", and remains a stranger in every other dimension. This paper therefore does not divide people into two kinds, nor arrange them along one axis; it says only that in a stated dimension, the [dedicated history](../paper_ae79e938_76e1_4bf9_b2ab_995c03e16c9e/concepts.md#c05) on this [edge](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c29) is little, and everyday language usually calls this situation being strangers. A convention of this paper: \"acquaintance\" and \"stranger\" here refer only to those whose [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) has [arrived](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at some [Self](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19), that is, those within that [Self](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19)'s [reachable subgraph](concepts.md#c07). This is a convention about scope, not derived from the definition of [reachable subgraph](concepts.md#c07), and this paragraph is not a constraint-level conclusion.\n\nThis paper deals only with what has already [arrived](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10). An object for which no [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) has ever [arrived](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at a given [Self](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19) is not within that [Self](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19)'s [reachable subgraph](concepts.md#c07), is not a stranger in the sense discussed in this paper, and need not be discussed (Premise 5 and the convention above). This paper does not discuss feelings but experience: in this paper \"experience\" means the [history](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13) formed by [outputs](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) that have already [arrived](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) (a convention of this paper; its scope is limited by Premise 3).\n\nThis paper does not distinguish a short model from a long model. Whether [culture](concepts.md#c13) and [templates](concepts.md#c14) can be treated as fixed for the time being depends on the speed of change in each dimension relative to the time window under view, and this is a continuous spectrum; when the [natural environment](concepts.md#c16) is treated as an [exogenous background](../paper_ae79e938_76e1_4bf9_b2ab_995c03e16c9e/concepts.md#c02) under a stated time window and [cut](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c23), that time window and [cut](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c23) must be stated together.\n\nThe conclusions of this paper are of two levels, following the practice of the acquaintance paper. A constraint-level conclusion is derived only from the laws and premises listed in Section 1; if any one of them can be overturned, the conclusion fails. A conditional-level conclusion additionally uses some empirical antecedent or some stated assumption; the text points out which one it uses, and if reality violates it, that conclusion fails. An empirical antecedent serves only as an input to derivation and is not used to prove a constraint true. The cases in Section 9 are calibration and belong to neither level.\n\n## 1. Inheritance and Constraints\n\n### 1.1 Inheritance\n\nThis paper uses the [Law of Flux](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c24), the [Law of the Black Box](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c25), the [Law of Attrition](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c26), and the [Law of Non-Restoration](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c28). It also uses [Unconfirmability of Drives](../paper_ae79e938_76e1_4bf9_b2ab_995c03e16c9e/concepts.md#c03): for an object that is not [locked in](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c12), its drives, that is, its motives, needs and purposes, cannot be fully observed from outside and cannot be confirmed by its own account, and others' after-the-fact judgments of its motives are only [view attributions](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c02) or [impressions](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c45). The methodological prohibitions that follow from this are listed in Section 8; this paper does not cite the numbering of upstream premises and steps, and restates the premises it needs in 1.3.\n\n### 1.2 Constraint Zero: The Cut\n\nAll statements made by the researcher in this paper about high-dimensional [history](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13) are statements under some [cut](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c23). Treating the researcher as a [Self](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19) (a setting of this paper), by Premise 2 and its basis, the [Law of Attrition](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c26), another's [presentation](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c04) cannot fully express itself and the researcher cannot fully receive it, so the researcher cannot obtain another's high-dimensional [history](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13) as a whole from any single [presentation](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c04); this paper does not assume that putting several [presentations](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c04) together can restore the whole, and the researcher can only specify dimensions, a time window and classification rules and then discuss one slice; this \"cutting out of a part\" is the [cut](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c23). This applies only to the researcher's statements in this paper and does not claim that every statement in the world about high-dimensional [history](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13) is so; there is no \"uncut\" version to compare against. Every proposition must be reported together with the following: the set of dimensions, the time window, the classification rules, the participating [nodes](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25), and who chose the [cut](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c23) and why. A proposition not reported together with these does not count as a conclusion of this paper. A [cut](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c23) is a [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) made by the researcher; once expressed it counts as one [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) of the researcher and carries a choice, so who chose it and why must be stated. If the parties themselves also group, regarding which [Selves](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19) are a group, this is a [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) by whoever groups, cutting a part out of the whole, and this paper establishes no separate concept. This paragraph is a constraint-level conclusion.\n\n### 1.3 The Premises of This Paper\n\nThis paper has twelve further premises. None is a new law, and none is derived from the other premises. Premises 1 and 2 restate how the upstream laws are used; Premises 3 to 6, Premise 10, Premise 23 and Premise 24 are scope settings; Premises 7 to 9 are empirical antecedents.\n\n```text\nPremise 1 Each Distinction made by a Self arrives at that Self before the Self's next Moment.\nPremise 2 For any Presentation P and any Wo V (P may be V itself), P's Own Segment always contains a part that has not arrived at V (by the Law of Attrition, a Self cannot fully distinguish itself; its Output comes only from this incomplete distinction, so no Presentation can fully express itself, and a receiver cannot fully receive it).\nPremise 3 Scope setting: this paper discusses only the History formed by Outputs that have already arrived, and does not discuss feelings.\nPremise 4 Scope setting: within the scope this paper treats, the space of situations (who, when, what, in what combination) cannot be exhausted; any finite History covers only a part of it.\nPremise 5 Scope setting: a subgraph counts only what has already arrived, that is, the other side's Output has actually entered the History of some Wo (including Outputs that arrived by being relayed); no separate potential concept of \"arrival by some possible path\" is introduced.\nPremise 6 Scope setting: whether a Template exists is judged by a criterion specified by the researcher; the criterion must be statable, re-obtainable, and applicable to new situations of a specified type.\nPremise 7 Empirical antecedent: the Arrivals that a biological human (as a Self) can receive within a period of time are finite.\nPremise 8 Empirical antecedent: nerve conduction and reaction in biological humans take time; the other side's reaction to an Output cannot occur simultaneously with that Output.\nPremise 9 Empirical antecedent: within a stated dimension and time window, among a group of Selves, if the Frequency of Arrival is higher, Outcome Feedback is stronger, Learning is faster, and Exit Cost is higher, and the Natural Environment changes slowly in that dimension relative to the change in behavior patterns, then the Weight of each Node's Output falling within the compatible region in that dimension tends to become heavier; if these parameters are lower and the Natural Environment changes relatively fast, the Weight tends to become lighter. This says only that the Weight tends to change, and not that formation or non-formation is certain; all five parameters must be stated with how they are judged, the numerical ranges depend on data, and nothing is guaranteed outside the ranges.\nPremise 10 Scope setting: each dimension has its own speed of change; within a stated time window, what changes more slowly than the time window is treated as a fixed constant, and what changes faster than the time window must not be treated as a constant.\nPremise 23 Scope setting: within a stated time window, the History that a Wo accumulates is finite.\nPremise 24 Scope setting: this paper sets no standard for grouping; how large to cut, which people to group, and which dimensions to look at are decided by whoever groups, who must state them.\nNote: Premises 1 and 2 are restatements; Premises 3 to 6, Premise 10, Premise 23 and Premise 24 are scope settings; Premises 7 to 9 are empirical antecedents, serving as inputs to derivation and not used to prove a constraint true.\n```\n\n## 2. The Model\n\n### 2.1 Types of Nodes and the Unit\n\nA [node](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25) is of three kinds: [Wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16), [signal container](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c26), and [random source](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c27). A [small loop](concepts.md#c02) belongs only to a [Wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16): the [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) of a [Wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16) returns to its own [history](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13) and takes part in its own later [weights](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06). A [signal container](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c26) (a book, a legal provision, the place where a [template](concepts.md#c14) resides) is not a [Wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16); from some [moment](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c09) onward it is [locked in](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c12) at every step and has no [small loop](concepts.md#c02); it can give [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) to a [Wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16), and its content can be written by a [Wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16), so one [Wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16) writing and another [Wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16) reading constitutes an indirect [arrival](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) between the two [Wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16) through a [container](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c26). A [random source](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c27) (for example, a die) is neither a [Wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16) nor a [signal container](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c26) and has no [small loop](concepts.md#c02); when it is not [locked in](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c12) at some [moment](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c09), only [weights](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06) can be discussed. This paragraph is a constraint-level conclusion.\n\nUnder one [cut](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c23), a structure formed by two [nodes](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25) and two kinds of [loops](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c31) is called a [unit](concepts.md#c01): two [Wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16) each have one [small loop](concepts.md#c02), and one [large loop](concepts.md#c03) connects the two. A [small loop](concepts.md#c02) is a [loop](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c31) in which the [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) of a [Wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16) returns to its own [history](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13); a [large loop](concepts.md#c03) is a [loop](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c31) in which A's [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) [arrives](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at B, B's [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) [arrives](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at A, and each takes part in the other's later [weights](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06). A [unit](concepts.md#c01) must state in which dimension it is judged. The persistence of a [loop](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c31) across [moments](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c09) is [not guaranteed](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c02): when a [Wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16) [exits](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c43), or the [loop](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c31) no longer holds from some [moment](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c09), the [loop](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c31) ends. A [signal container](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c26) and a [random source](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c27) can be attached to the [edges](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c29) of a [unit](concepts.md#c01), but are not the main body of the [unit](concepts.md#c01). A figurative way to put it is two fried eggs on a plate: two [small loops](concepts.md#c02) wrapped by a [large loop](concepts.md#c03); this is only a metaphor and not part of the model.\n\nEach [arrival](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) along an [edge](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c29) is directed; of the two directions, only one may exist, and they need not occur simultaneously. For each [Wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16) in a [unit](concepts.md#c01), its [history](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13) may contain both its own [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) returning to itself and the [outputs](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) of others [arriving](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at it; if both occur, both take part in its later [weights](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06).\n\n### 2.2 One Round of Update\n\nAt every [moment](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c09), every [Wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16) and every [edge](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c29) may go through the following four steps until the [loop](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c31) it belongs to ends (see 2.1); of these, [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) and [arrival](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) occur by definition, while [learning](concepts.md#c04) and [outcome feedback](concepts.md#c05) may follow the corresponding [arrival](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) (this paragraph is a constraint-level conclusion).\n1. [Output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28). For a [Wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)'s [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) at its next [moment](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c09), the [generating function](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c15) determines the [weights](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06) of the [branches](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c05) (the relative lightness or heaviness of the [branches](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c05)) from its [history](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13) up to that time. An [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) is the result of a [selection collapse](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c08) in which one [branch](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c05) is [selected](../paper_54c0291d_05b3_431a_9f2a_1b8ec93c3c3f/concepts.md#c32) according to the [weights](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06), together with the content of its [distinctions](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18). [Weight](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06) is not a parameter inside any [Wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16), and is not given directly by the [Wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)'s \"believing something better\". When not [locked in](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c12), only [weights](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06) can be derived, not outcomes. When the result of a [decision](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c06) cannot be calculated in advance, what a [Wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16) \"believes to be better\" belongs to its own [distinctions](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) ([candidates](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c18), [self-persuasion](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c19)); once such a [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) [arrives](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at itself it enters the [history](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13) and takes part in later [weights](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06), with no guarantee of being right and no guarantee of consistency.\n2. [Arrival](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10). An [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) [arrives](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at other [nodes](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25) along an [edge](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c29) or through a [signal container](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c26), enters the other side's [history](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13), and only increases, never decreases.\n3. [Learning](concepts.md#c04). The process by which material that has [arrived](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) accumulates in [history](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13) and may change later [weights](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06). [Learning](concepts.md#c04) is a result condition; it does not refer to a purpose, has no preset direction, and does not guarantee that anything is learned or learned correctly. The judgment looks only at whether the observable [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) has changed after [arrival](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10), and does not prove which [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) the change came from.\n4. [Outcome feedback](concepts.md#c05). A [Wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)'s later [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) [arrives](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) again at its own subsequent interactions and brings back actual consequences. The direction of [learning](concepts.md#c04) cannot be predicted beforehand, while the outcome can be judged afterward; the criterion lies in the responses of other [nodes](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25) and the [natural environment](concepts.md#c16), not inside the [Wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16) in which [learning](concepts.md#c04) occurs: having learned a language one can speak, having learned politeness one probably improves interaction, and conversely there may be a cost.\n\n### 2.3 Combination\n\nA [node](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25) can be an end of many [edges](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c29) at once. An [edge](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c29) is directed (in this paper \"know\" only means that the other side's [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) has [arrived](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)): \"I know him\" means his [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) has [arrived](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at me, and \"he knows me\" means my [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) has [arrived](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at him; of the two directions, only one may exist, and they need not occur simultaneously. A [node](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25) can therefore have dozens or hundreds of incoming [edges](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c29) and, at the same time, dozens or hundreds of outgoing [edges](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c29). This shape can be likened to a sea urchin (a metaphor, not part of the model). The [edges](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c29) of each [unit](concepts.md#c01) can share [nodes](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25) with other [units](concepts.md#c01), and those [units](concepts.md#c01) in turn each share [nodes](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25) with more [units](concepts.md#c01), so [loops](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c31) can overlap one another. What is input and [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) on each [edge](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c29) is high-dimensional content: language, behavior, the tools used and so on are all high-dimensional [outputs](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) passed along the network. The complexity comes from: feedback everywhere; the [weights](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06) of each [Wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16) at the next [moment](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c09) depend on the [history](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13) that has [arrived](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at it up to that time; influence returns along [loops](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c31) and may change the input that [arrives](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) afterwards; and under a [cut](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c23) that counts the researcher in, the researcher is also a [node](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25) on the network. These [loops](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c31) too may end (see 2.1). This paragraph is a constraint-level conclusion.\n\n### 2.4 Parameters of an Edge\n\nAn [edge](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c29) has three parameters: the [frequency](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c48) of [arrival](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10), [dedicated history](../paper_ae79e938_76e1_4bf9_b2ab_995c03e16c9e/concepts.md#c05), and [exit cost](concepts.md#c06).\nThe [frequency](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c48) of [arrival](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) is how often [arrival](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) occurs; it is one of the assumptions about [impact](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c47), must be stated, and does not replace [dedicated history](../paper_ae79e938_76e1_4bf9_b2ab_995c03e16c9e/concepts.md#c05). [Dedicated history](../paper_ae79e938_76e1_4bf9_b2ab_995c03e16c9e/concepts.md#c05) is counted by dimension: it is the stretch of [history](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13) formed, between the two ends of this [edge](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c29), in a stated dimension, by [outputs](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) that have [arrived](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at each other, so the two ends of the same [edge](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c29) can have material that has arrived at each other in one dimension and none in another (zero before the first [arrival](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)); [dedicated history](../paper_ae79e938_76e1_4bf9_b2ab_995c03e16c9e/concepts.md#c05) is a stretch of history counted by dimension, not a size of the [edge](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c29), and is not assumed to be quantifiable. [Exit cost](concepts.md#c06) is the [outcome feedback](concepts.md#c05) that a [Self](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19) must bear when it stops or reduces [arrivals](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) on this [edge](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c29); each end counts its own and the two may be asymmetric. Low cost means the [edge](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c29) can easily be abandoned; high cost means one can hardly help but continue. The observable version: after a negative [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) is given, the other side still keeps appearing and keeps giving [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28); the outward appearance cannot tell the reason, and no motive is written. [Exit cost](concepts.md#c06) and [exit](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c43) are at different levels ([edge](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c29) versus [node](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25)) and do not imply each other; a high [exit cost](concepts.md#c06) does not imply not leaving, and an extremely high one is not the same as [exit](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c43). This paragraph is a constraint-level conclusion.\n\n[Impact](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c47) and [discrepancy](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c49) are not parameters of an [edge](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c29) but properties of \"an [arrival](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) relative to its receiver\". [Impact](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c47) is how much [weight](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06) this [arrival](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) can move; it is a matter internal to the [generating function](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c15) and cannot be added up; [discrepancy](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c49) is how far it is from what the receiver has received in the past. When the same [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) [arrives](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at different [Selves](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19), its [impact](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c47) and [discrepancy](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c49) depend on each one's [history](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13) and can differ, and the movement of each one's [weights](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06) can also differ. This paragraph is a constraint-level conclusion.\n\n### 2.5 Reachable Subgraph and Natural Environment\n\nTaking a given [Wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16) as the center, within a stated time window, all [presentations](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c04) whose [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) has [arrived](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at it, together with the [edges](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c29) between these [presentations](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c04) and it, constitute its [reachable subgraph](concepts.md#c07) (Premise 5). Each [Wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16) has one. By Premise 2, no [presentation](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c04)'s [own segment](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c17) can have all [arrived](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at any [Wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16). Within the stated time window, an object outside the subgraph has no [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) that has had [arrival](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at this [Wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16), so the dedicated material between that object and this [Wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16) within the window is zero (dedicated material is discussed only when the object is a [Self](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19)); entering the subgraph is a new [arrival](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) and, by the [Law of Non-Restoration](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c28), the material that has arrived only adds and never subtracts. [Arrival](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) is directed: one side having material does not imply that the other side has material. This paragraph is a constraint-level conclusion.\n\nThe subgraph is finite: within a stated time window, the [history](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13) that each [Wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16) accumulates is finite (Premise 23); combined with the situation space being impossible to exhaust (Premise 4), the situations covered by any subgraph are only a part of it; for situations not covered, the existing [history](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13) does not guarantee that this [Wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)'s later [outputs](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) will be compatible with the other side's; where there is no other basis, it can probe afresh. These two items are constraint-level and use Premise 23 and Premise 4.\n\nCalibration (not a source of derivation): a person has read a great many public [outputs](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) of some public figure, but the figure has never received his [outputs](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28); this is a one-way [arrival](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10). The archives left by someone who has [exited](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c43) can increase without limit while [outcome feedback](concepts.md#c05) is zero. Both show that the amount of data and [outcome feedback](concepts.md#c05) are two quantities that can come apart.\n\nThe [natural environment](concepts.md#c16) is, under a stated [cut](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c23), the part that does not belong to any [node](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25) in the model yet has [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) [arriving](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at these [nodes](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25); it includes physical conditions, such as terrain, climate, water and food; it constrains the most basic behavior of each [node](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25). When the [natural environment](concepts.md#c16) does not update with the [loops](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c31) in the model under a stated time window and [cut](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c23), it is treated as an [exogenous background](../paper_ae79e938_76e1_4bf9_b2ab_995c03e16c9e/concepts.md#c02), and an [exogenous background](../paper_ae79e938_76e1_4bf9_b2ab_995c03e16c9e/concepts.md#c02) can change; by Premise 10, to treat it as a fixed constant within that time window, its change in that dimension must be slower than the time window under view; when it changes faster than the time window, it must not be treated as a constant, and conclusions that depend on it being a constant must be re-examined (see Section 7). This paragraph is a constraint-level conclusion.\n\nThis structure has three scales, not three kinds of position: the [unit](concepts.md#c01); the [reachable subgraph](concepts.md#c07) of one [Wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16); and a global graph within a particular range. A single [individual](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c20) may or may not obtain the global graph, depending on whether the output of every object in the network has arrived at it: if some object belongs to the network under discussion and some [Self](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19) has not yet been reached by that object's output, that object is outside this Self's [reachable subgraph](concepts.md#c07), and this Self's [reachable subgraph](concepts.md#c07) does not cover the entire network. An institution holding a large amount of network data (an institution is a [Wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16), made of responses and inputs, not a place or a building) may obtain a certain degree of whole-graph data, but its data are whatever has [arrived](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at the institution (not limited to the [outputs](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) of various [Selves](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19)), so by Premise 2 they remain incomplete and do not cover all dimensions. A [large node](concepts.md#c08) is, within a stated [cut](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c23) and time window, a [node](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25) whose [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) [arrives](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at an extremely large number of [nodes](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25), covering almost every [node](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25) within the range in question, for example a government, a public figure, or a large enterprise. A [large node](concepts.md#c08) is an actually existing [node](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25), not an imaginary researcher. Great influence is not only a property of the [node](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25) itself: when the same [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) [arrives](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at different [Selves](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19), its [impact](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c47) and [discrepancy](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c49) depend on each one's [history](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13) and can differ, so broad [arrival](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) does not imply great influence; by Premise 2 no [Self](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19) can fully receive others, so it does not imply omniscience either; having a purpose falls under the [Unconfirmability of Drives](../paper_ae79e938_76e1_4bf9_b2ab_995c03e16c9e/concepts.md#c03) and is not written in this paper. This paragraph is a constraint-level conclusion.\n\n### 2.6 Changes in Dedicated History across Dimensions\n\nContact increases [dedicated history](../paper_ae79e938_76e1_4bf9_b2ab_995c03e16c9e/concepts.md#c05): the two sides' [outputs](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) [arrive](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at each other, and the material only adds, never subtracts. Separation does not delete [history](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13) (the [Law of Non-Restoration](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c28)) but may make the material fall out of step with the other side's current state: during the separation, the other side's [history](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13) keeps changing (the [Law of Flux](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c24)), and these changes may include a part that has not [arrived](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at you (Premise 2 only guarantees that the other side's [own segment](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c17) always contains a part that has not [arrived](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at you, not that every stretch of change does). The other side's [history](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13) has already changed, and what you hold is old material; the basis for using it to estimate the other side's present compatible region may weaken under the specified [cut](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c23) (conditional-level, depending on the dimension that changed and the compatibility criterion). Therefore the accumulated amount alone is not enough to judge whether the material is \"effective\"; the distance between the material and the other side's current state may also have to be considered. All of the above holds for each dimension separately. The two sentences on the basis for estimating the other side's present compatible region from old material, and on \"effective\", are conditional-level; the rest is a constraint-level conclusion.\n\nWhat is ordinarily called being a stranger corresponds to at least two situations (not exhaustive): the object has just entered the [reachable subgraph](concepts.md#c07), where one-way [arrival](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) material begins to accumulate, and [dedicated history](../paper_ae79e938_76e1_4bf9_b2ab_995c03e16c9e/concepts.md#c05) begins to accumulate only once the object is a [Self](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19) and the two sides' [outputs](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) have [arrived](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at each other; and there is old material but no new [arrival](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10). These two situations must not be confused. At a reunion, if there is a gap between the old material and the other side's present situation, and the gap makes the two sides' adjacent [outputs](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) incompatible under the specified dimension and criterion, that is [mismatch](../paper_ae79e938_76e1_4bf9_b2ab_995c03e16c9e/concepts.md#c08); whether there is a gap, how large it is, and whether it causes such incompatibility depends on data, and is conditional-level.\n\nPosition is not monotonic: contact only increases material and does not guarantee compatibility; separation only may make material outdated and does not erase it. Renewed contact is a new occurrence, not a [restoration](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c27) of the original state (the [Law of Non-Restoration](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c28)). Old material may make recalibration faster than starting from zero, or may lead to [mismatch](../paper_ae79e938_76e1_4bf9_b2ab_995c03e16c9e/concepts.md#c08) because the other side has changed; the speed is not guaranteed. These rules do not depend on the size of the [unit](concepts.md#c01): two friends, or two families, who have long been out of contact and grown estranged are the same structure, as long as the [cut](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c23) is stated. This paragraph is a constraint-level conclusion.\n\nThis paper does not assume that the effective amount of [dedicated history](../paper_ae79e938_76e1_4bf9_b2ab_995c03e16c9e/concepts.md#c05) is a single number. It is compared only under a specified [cut](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c23): in some dimension and time window, whether compatible continuations are more, fewer, or in [stasis](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c52) compared with the previous point in time; a number is reported only for countable dimensions, and it is marked as belonging only to that [cut](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c23) and is not extended to other dimensions. In this paper [outward data](concepts.md#c18) means the results that were selected and expressed, and their summaries; they are not equal to the full [weights](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06) and dependency paths. This paragraph is a constraint-level conclusion.\n\n## 3. Direction by Dimension\n\nFor a pair of [nodes](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25) and one dimension, look at how the distance between the two sides' [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) patterns changes over time. All three directions fall under [coupling](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c36) and all require the dimension to be stated: becoming smaller is [convergence](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c37); becoming larger is [divergence](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c38); staying unchanged is [stasis](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c52). What is called \"repulsion\" in daily speech is only everyday language, not another concept in the model. Where the two sides aim at each other and reinforce each other, upstream calls this [Taiji](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c39), and where both sides are [Selves](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19) it appears outwardly as [conflict](../paper_ae79e938_76e1_4bf9_b2ab_995c03e16c9e/concepts.md#c10); [divergence](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c38) does not imply [Taiji](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c39). This paragraph is a constraint-level conclusion.\n\n[Resonance](concepts.md#c09) is a term of this paper: within a stated dimension and time window, the [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) patterns of several [nodes](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25) repeatedly continue one another compatibly. [Resonance](concepts.md#c09) requires [arrival](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10): either arrival between the [node](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25)s, or arrival at all of them from a common source (such as a [signal container](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c26) or the [natural environment](concepts.md#c16)). Without any arrival, there is no [resonance](concepts.md#c09). Its criterion is compatibility, that is, the opposite of [mismatch](../paper_ae79e938_76e1_4bf9_b2ab_995c03e16c9e/concepts.md#c08), not distance. The direction in which distance changes is not the criterion; whether distance becomes smaller, larger, or stays unchanged, it does not by itself decide compatibility: for example, in a question and answer, the two sides' patterns differ, yet they can still repeatedly continue each other compatibly. [Convergence](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c37) can lead to [resonance](concepts.md#c09), but does not entail it; [resonance](concepts.md#c09) also does not entail [convergence](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c37). Whether there is [resonance](concepts.md#c09) can only be said afterward. [Resonance](concepts.md#c09) differs from [tacit coordination](../paper_ae79e938_76e1_4bf9_b2ab_995c03e16c9e/concepts.md#c06): [tacit coordination](../paper_ae79e938_76e1_4bf9_b2ab_995c03e16c9e/concepts.md#c06) is compatible continuation on the [dedicated history](../paper_ae79e938_76e1_4bf9_b2ab_995c03e16c9e/concepts.md#c05) between two [Selves](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19), counted by dimension; [resonance](concepts.md#c09) does not require [dedicated history](../paper_ae79e938_76e1_4bf9_b2ab_995c03e16c9e/concepts.md#c05) and is not limited to two [Selves](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19). This paragraph is a constraint-level conclusion.\n\nIn high dimensions, each dimension goes its own way: some [converge](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c37), some [diverge](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c38), and some are in [stasis](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c52). The synchronization phenomena of systems theory serve only as a calibration comparison; this paper does not claim that they are special cases of the same kind of structure as this model, and does not cite synchronization theorems. This paper's own term is always [resonance](concepts.md#c09).\n\n## 4. Concepts within the Reachable Subgraph\n\nThe following concepts are all used under a stated dimension and time window, and none is a newly added law.\n| Concept | What it is in the model |\n|---|---|\n| Starting point of a stranger | The moment the first [arrival](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) occurs, at which the [dedicated history](../paper_ae79e938_76e1_4bf9_b2ab_995c03e16c9e/concepts.md#c05) starts from zero in that dimension |\n| [Mismatch](../paper_ae79e938_76e1_4bf9_b2ab_995c03e16c9e/concepts.md#c08) | Adjacent [outputs](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) that are incompatible in some dimension; a property of the sequence, carrying no consequence |\n| [Penalty](concepts.md#c10) | The [outcome feedback](concepts.md#c05) that, after an [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28), [arrives](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at the one who gave the [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) and counts as a cost under a stated criterion. The criterion must state whose it is: the [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) giver's own [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18), or the researcher's criterion, and the two may be inconsistent. Not necessarily violent, not necessarily explicitly listed |\n| [Enforcement](concepts.md#c11) | A [penalty](concepts.md#c10) that has been explicitly listed as a rule, written in a [signal container](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c26), with violation judgeable by a third party; the [penalty](concepts.md#c10) may be violence or may not. Compliance is not guaranteed, and neither is the judgment and execution of violations. The rule precedes the violation, which is a matter of another point in time |\n| [Fault tolerance](concepts.md#c12) | In a stated dimension, the upper limit of the degree of the other side's [mismatch](../paper_ae79e938_76e1_4bf9_b2ab_995c03e16c9e/concepts.md#c08) that a [Self](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19) can tolerate; beyond the limit, this [edge](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c29) may terminate. When [exit cost](concepts.md#c06) is low, [arrival](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) [frequency](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c48) is low, and there is no buffer, [arrivals](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) on this [edge](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c29) more easily stop or decrease (conditional-level, depends on data: when [exit cost](concepts.md#c06) is low the [edge](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c29) can easily be abandoned, see the definition of [exit cost](concepts.md#c06); the effects of low [arrival](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) [frequency](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c48) and of no buffer are observations, with nothing guaranteed outside the range; this is an observation and does not infer internal tolerance). The observable version: after a negative [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) is given, the other side still keeps appearing and keeps giving [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28); the outward appearance cannot tell the reason, and no motive is written |\n| Reputation (everyday term; a note on usage, not a new definition) | Material about the other side's past [outputs](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) that [arrives](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) through a third party's [edge](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c29); it is lossy, can serve only as material for forming an [impression](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c45), and is not a reading of [weight](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06) |\n| Etiquette (everyday term; a note on usage, not a new definition) | What is ordinarily called etiquette is, in this paper, the [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) patterns repeatedly [arriving](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) within [resonance](concepts.md#c09); if a violation brings later costs ([outcome feedback](concepts.md#c05)) and the [weight](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06) moves away from violating as a result and keeps doing so, the pattern tends to be maintained (conditional-level, depends on data) |\n| [Template](concepts.md#c14) | See Section 6 |\n\nThe materials that can be relied on over a low-frequency [edge](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c29) are: reputation, etiquette, [templates](concepts.md#c14) (with [enforcement](concepts.md#c11)). When [exit cost](concepts.md#c06) is low, this [edge](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c29) may cease to exist early on because of a single step; in that case these materials may let people form an [impression](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c45) of the other side from the start: these materials are traces of the other side's [outputs](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) (the other side's own [outputs](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28), or material relayed or carried through a [signal container](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c26)) and enter the receiver's [history](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13) once their [arrival](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) occurs; since the other side's [weights](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06) are fixed by its [history](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13) up to that time (the [Law of the Black Box](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c25)) and the receiver cannot obtain that [history](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13) as a whole (Premise 2, by the [Law of Attrition](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c26)), the receiver can only form an [impression](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c45) from the material that has arrived and judge the other side's tendencies from it (an [impression](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c45) is not a reading of [weights](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06)), for example, a reputation for honesty lets one estimate that the other side's [outputs](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) tend toward honesty even without knowing whether the reputation is true; this judgment is a [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) of the receiver, enters its own [history](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13) and takes part in its later [weights](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06) (conditional-level, using low [exit cost](concepts.md#c06); the judgment is not guaranteed to be accurate, nor to ensure that behavior when meeting face to face fits the other side). Whether the materials are reliable is [not guaranteed](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c02), and they can be misread (by the [Law of Attrition](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c26), the materials come only from incomplete [distinctions](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) and the receiver cannot fully receive them). In this paragraph the sentence on how the materials let people form an [impression](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c45) is conditional-level, and the rest is a constraint-level conclusion.\n\nBiological-human antecedents: limited reception (Premise 7) and delayed reaction (Premise 8) give common limits, not common content. That [history](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13) does not return to zero is not an empirical antecedent: that [history](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13) only adds and never subtracts is a conclusion of the [Law of Non-Restoration](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c28) and the [Law of Flux](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c24), and is constraint-level. The parts of this paragraph that use Premise 7 and Premise 8 are conditional-level.\n\n## 5. Culture (the Researcher's Name for Resonance)\n\n[Culture](concepts.md#c13) is the researcher's name for the [resonance](concepts.md#c09) that appears among [nodes](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25). Under a specified [cut](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c23), dimension and time window, it is a set of compatible patterns left in [history](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13) by countless [units](concepts.md#c01), under the constraints of a particular [natural environment](concepts.md#c16), through repeated [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28), [arrival](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) and [outcome feedback](concepts.md#c05): which combinations of dimensions can continue without being repeatedly interrupted. For a [Wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16) within it, this set of patterns enters its [history](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13) through concrete [arrivals](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) and takes part in its [weights](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06); the material that [arrived](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) earlier has entered the [history](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13), and the [history](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13) takes part in the [weights](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06) through the [generating function](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c15); in these dimensions the [Wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16) may not have to probe from zero every time (conditional-level, depends on data). This does not guarantee that every [Wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16) obtains the same content, nor that the material is correct. [Culture](concepts.md#c13) is not bounded by whether it has been written down: compatible patterns that have [resonated](concepts.md#c09) into being are called [culture](concepts.md#c13) whether or not they have been written into a [container](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c26). Apart from the sentence marked conditional-level, this paragraph is a constraint-level conclusion.\n\nGrouping is a [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18); by Premise 24, this paper sets no standard for it. How large to cut, which people to group, and which dimensions to look at are decided by the researcher; if the parties themselves also cut, the researcher describes it as a [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18). Christians and Muslims each cut for themselves and are not one body to each other; cut from outside, they are the Abrahamic religions; the model does not adjudicate. The cut itself is an [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28); once it [arrives](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at the other side, if it enters the corresponding [loop](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c31), it may turn back to change the network that was cut. The [resonance](concepts.md#c09) pattern the researcher sees under a specified dimension and time window is one layer; if the parties also group themselves and express it, there is a further layer of the parties' own boundary-drawing and belonging. If both layers exist, they can be inconsistent and do not imply each other. [Culture](concepts.md#c13) has no subject and is neither held nor transmitted by anyone. [Culture](concepts.md#c13) is also scale-free: a village has [culture](concepts.md#c13), and a [culture](concepts.md#c13) over a wide range is also [culture](concepts.md#c13). The three sentences on the cut turning back to change the network that was cut, on the two layers when the parties also group themselves, and on the two layers being able to be inconsistent are conditional-level; the rest is a constraint-level conclusion.\n\nThe formation of [culture](concepts.md#c13) cannot do without the constraints of the [natural environment](concepts.md#c16). When a nomadic [culture](concepts.md#c13) is moved to New York, its defaults do not work; there is no essential difference between a modern person entering a grassland and entering a desert, because in both cases the [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) patterns have no corresponding accumulation of [natural environment](concepts.md#c16). Some dimensions of [culture](concepts.md#c13) connect to survival conditions (finding water, food), and some are merely neglected; this paper sets up no division between \"dimensions of [culture](concepts.md#c13)\" and \"dimensions that are not of [culture](concepts.md#c13)\", only consequences that are more direct or more indirect. This paragraph is a constraint-level conclusion.\n\nStrong [coupling](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c36) and non-assemblability of [natural environment](concepts.md#c16) constraints (conditional-level, under some [cut](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c23) of the researcher): the [natural environment](concepts.md#c16) constrains the most basic behavior of each [node](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25) (such as the ocean or the grassland). Under a specified [cut](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c23), dimension and time window, the [resonance](concepts.md#c09) patterns that remain tend no longer to include practices pushed away by negative feedback from the [natural environment](concepts.md#c16): for practices that receive negative [outcome feedback](concepts.md#c05) in their interaction with the [natural environment](concepts.md#c16), these feedbacks enter [history](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13), and if they move the [weight](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06) away from that practice and this moving away continues in later [arrivals](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) (continuation is not claimed as necessary; whether [learning](concepts.md#c04) moves it that way depends on data), the practice tends not to be repeatedly [arrived](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at, so what is repeatedly left is the practices not yet pushed away by such feedback; the successions in the various dimensions may also depend on one another in [history](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13). Therefore under this [cut](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c23), [culture](concepts.md#c13) is not guaranteed to be freely assembled or transplanted like building blocks; having lost the original [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) of the [natural environment](concepts.md#c16), the transplanted [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) patterns may lose the corresponding [outcome feedback](concepts.md#c05) that supports them. This is a tendency, not a necessity; under a different [cut](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c23), the boundary and degree of [coupling](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c36) can differ.\n\nTendency for [resonance](concepts.md#c09) to form easily (conditional-level, using Premise 9): when [arrival](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) [frequency](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c48) is high, [outcome feedback](concepts.md#c05) is strong, [learning](concepts.md#c04) is fast enough, [exit cost](concepts.md#c06) is high, and the [natural environment](concepts.md#c16) changes relatively slowly, the [weight](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06) of the [outputs](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) of the [nodes](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25) falling within the compatible region in that dimension tends to become heavier, without requiring [convergence](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c37); when [exit cost](concepts.md#c06) is low, [arrival](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) [frequency](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c48) is low, [outcome feedback](concepts.md#c05) is weak, [learning](concepts.md#c04) is slow, and the [natural environment](concepts.md#c16) changes fast, the tendency is low. A high tendency does not guarantee formation, and a low tendency does not guarantee non-formation; nothing is guaranteed outside the range.\n\n[Culture](concepts.md#c13) and [tacit coordination](../paper_ae79e938_76e1_4bf9_b2ab_995c03e16c9e/concepts.md#c06) stand side by side, neither depending on the other nor implying the other.\n\n[Outcome feedback](concepts.md#c05) and compatible patterns only describe and carry no purpose. This paper does not write the logical consistency of [culture](concepts.md#c13) as coming from the design of a will. Every [Wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16) may have [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) and [arrival](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at each [moment](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c09); the [natural environment](concepts.md#c16) and other [nodes](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25) may give [outcome feedback](concepts.md#c05) (including costs and [exit cost](concepts.md#c06)). [Weight](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06) falls at whichever level the researcher cuts the [node](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25): taking a neuron, a person or a company as the [node](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25) gives the [weight](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06) of the [node](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25) at that level; under a stated [cut](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c23), how heavy each outcome is at a [Wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)'s next [moment](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c09) depends on the [history](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13) that has [arrived](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at it; this paper does not assume that the network as a whole has a single direction, and speaks only of the directions of individual [nodes](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25) and individual [loops](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c31), which may be consistent, opposite or unrelated to one another. (Conditional-level, depends on data) Under continuing [outcome feedback](concepts.md#c05), combinations of behavior that keep receiving negative [outcome feedback](concepts.md#c05) in their interaction with the [natural environment](concepts.md#c16) tend not to be repeatedly [arrived](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at for long: these consequences enter [history](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13), and if they move the [weight](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06) away from this combination of behavior and this moving away continues in later [arrivals](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) (the direction of [learning](concepts.md#c04) is not preset, and whether it moves away depends on data; continuation is not claimed as necessary), it appears less and less as an [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28); this describes only what is left afterward, and does not write that a [node](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25) \"adopts something in order to adapt\", nor that the selection has a purpose. Apart from the sentence marked conditional-level, this paragraph is a constraint-level conclusion.\n\nThis does not imply that \"all [nodes](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25) will adopt behavior suited to that [natural environment](concepts.md#c16)\": a [node](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25) that is not [locked in](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c12) can, at its next [moment](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c09), only have [weights](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06) derived and not outcomes, so if some outcomes have a positive [weight](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06) yet do not fit the [natural environment](concepts.md#c16), individual [nodes](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25) may deviate; negative [outcome feedback](concepts.md#c05) may be being neglected, rejected, or suffering loss, not necessarily [exit](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c43), so selection can be graded; other [nodes](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25) themselves also give [outcome feedback](concepts.md#c05), and what is \"suitable\" moves with their [outputs](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28); when the [natural environment](concepts.md#c16) changes faster than selection, what remains is not necessarily suited to the present [natural environment](concepts.md#c16) (see Section 7). \"Computation\", \"selection\", \"elimination\" and \"survivor solution\" are used in this paper only as metaphors and must be marked as metaphors. The sentence beginning \"This does not imply\" is conditional-level; the rest is a constraint-level conclusion.\n\n## 6. Template\n\nA [template](concepts.md#c14) is abstracted, reusable rules or data, explicitly listed in a [signal container](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c26). The [container](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c26) is [locked in](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c12), its content does not change by itself, and it provides a fixed point in some dimension, obtainable without first needing [resonance](concepts.md#c09). A single rule with two texts counts as two [templates](concepts.md#c14). A [template](concepts.md#c14) is fixed content in a [container](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c26), not a layer of [culture](concepts.md#c13). Whether a [template](concepts.md#c14) exists is judged by a criterion specified by the researcher (Premise 6). This paragraph is a constraint-level conclusion.\n\nThe source of a [template](concepts.md#c14) can be that some group's [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) is explicitly listed and written into a [container](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c26). What has [resonated](concepts.md#c09) into being can be written as a [template](concepts.md#c14); once written, the content in the [container](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c26) and the compatible patterns that people actually follow are two different things, their persistence is discussed separately, and neither implies the other. A [template](concepts.md#c14) is fixed content in a [container](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c26); the content [arrives](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at the receiver along an [edge](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c29) or through a [container](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c26); if the content is copied into another [container](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c26), then by the definition of a [template](concepts.md#c14), two texts of the same rule are two [templates](concepts.md#c14); the content in the [container](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c26) need not wear out (the [container](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c26) is [locked in](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c12), so the content does not change by itself), and the difference lies in the receiver's use (the same [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) has different [impact](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c47) on different [Selves](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19), and no [Self](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19) can fully receive others; \"need not wear out\" refers to the content in the [container](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c26), not to what the receiver obtains). The relation of a [template](concepts.md#c14) to the group that carries it has two divisions: endogenous versus exogenous; non-[enforced](concepts.md#c11) versus [enforced](concepts.md#c11). These are relations, not kinds of things in the world, and are relative to the scope drawn. [Enforcement](concepts.md#c11) is a matter of another point in time: violation can be judged by a third party, but compliance is not guaranteed, and neither is it guaranteed that a violation is judged and carried out. This paragraph is a constraint-level conclusion.\n\nThe [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) of a [large node](concepts.md#c08), if explicitly listed in a [signal container](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c26) (for example a decree signed by a head of state) and meets the abstraction and reusability that [templates](concepts.md#c14) require, is a source of [templates](concepts.md#c14); if it is an [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) of the photograph kind, whether it [resonates](concepts.md#c09) into [culture](concepts.md#c13) after [arriving](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at many [nodes](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25) can only be said afterward. The two carry different things but travel through the same network. Why that [node](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25) acts as it does is not written, nor whether it has the result it wants. This paragraph is a constraint-level conclusion.\n\nA [template](concepts.md#c14) in the stranger paper may be material on a low-frequency [edge](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c29) that lets people first estimate the tendencies of the other side's [weights](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06), without probing from zero (conditional-level, using low [exit cost](concepts.md#c06); for the mechanism see Section 4; it is not guaranteed that behavior when meeting face to face fits the other side); whether it is reliable is [not guaranteed](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c02), and it can be misread (reasons in Section 4). In some dimension, a common [template](concepts.md#c14) provides a fixed point that both sides can obtain; if both sides obtain and adopt it, and it applies in that dimension, each side can estimate the other without probing from zero (conditional-level); this does not imply that the two sides are compatible outside that dimension.\n\n## 7. Persistence and Collapse\n\nBy Premise 10, each dimension has its own speed of change, and what changes more slowly than the time window is treated as fixed. An [exogenous background](../paper_ae79e938_76e1_4bf9_b2ab_995c03e16c9e/concepts.md#c02) is a setting of scope and does not claim that the background is unchanged; [culture](concepts.md#c13) and the [natural environment](concepts.md#c16) can be treated as constants in dimensions whose change is slower than the specified time window, but if the time window is stretched long enough, [culture](concepts.md#c13) may also change with the continuing change of [history](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13) (the [Law of Flux](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c24)). This paragraph is a constraint-level conclusion.\n\nConstraint-level: [history](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13) keeps changing and does not stop (the [Law of Flux](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c24)); how much it changes, in what direction, and whether things can still connect are [not guaranteed](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c02) (the [Law of the Black Box](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c25)). Conditional-level: under some [cut](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c23) of the researcher, when the [natural environment](concepts.md#c16) changes so much in some dimension that it cannot return to what it was (for example, from grassland to New York), [culture](concepts.md#c13) tends to change too (see Section 5: the [outcome feedback](concepts.md#c05) of the original [natural environment](concepts.md#c16) may disappear, and the original [resonance](concepts.md#c09) pattern may lose its support; if it does, and the [weight](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06) of the original pattern moves away as a result and keeps moving away in later [arrivals](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10), [culture](concepts.md#c13) tends to change too). Under a stated [cut](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c23), if the [natural environment](concepts.md#c16) changes in some dimension at a speed greater than the speed at which [resonance](concepts.md#c09) forms in that dimension, and this change makes previously workable practices unworkable and, if the [weight](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06) moves away from these practices as a result, and this moving away continues in later [arrivals](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10), these practices tend to be hard to keep up as a stable [resonance](concepts.md#c09); whether other successions form depends on data.\n\n[Collapse](concepts.md#c15) is, at a specified scale, dimension and time window, the loss of a former order; an order means the defaults and patterns of continuation that can continue compatibly without being directed each time. The after-the-fact [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) is drawn by the [Self](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19) making the judgment. [Collapse](concepts.md#c15) is scale-free, graded, and dimension by dimension: when the dimension of finding water is lost, the consequences fall directly on survival; when some etiquette is lost, the consequence may be only being cold-shouldered. The acquaintance paper did not use this term, which is a choice of scope and not a correction. [Collapse](concepts.md#c15) differs from [mismatch](../paper_ae79e938_76e1_4bf9_b2ab_995c03e16c9e/concepts.md#c08) and [exit](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c43) in criterion; it may be a cause or a form of them, but does not entail them. This paragraph is a constraint-level conclusion.\n\nThe limit cannot be uniquely inferred in advance from the [Law of the Black Box](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c25): each [Wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16), at the [moments](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c09) when it is not [locked in](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c12), can only have [weights](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06) discussed, and whether [resonance](concepts.md#c09) is maintained can only be said afterward; the [proportion of failed expectations](concepts.md#c17) (the after-the-fact statistical proportion of originally compatible successions that failed to connect; an outward statistic, not a reading of true [weights](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06)) cannot be used to uniquely infer whether the next succession will connect; it can serve only as a conditional reference that is not guaranteed to be accurate. The persistence of [templates](concepts.md#c14) and of [culture](concepts.md#c13) is mutually independent: a [template](concepts.md#c14) depends on a [container](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c26), [culture](concepts.md#c13) depends on the [natural environment](concepts.md#c16) plus repeated [arrival](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10). Latin is a case where the [template](concepts.md#c14) exists but nobody uses it daily; Confucianism is a case where the [culture](concepts.md#c13) exists but that [template](concepts.md#c14) no longer [arrives](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) repeatedly; Java is a foreign [template](concepts.md#c14) within computer [culture](concepts.md#c13), which for Chinese people is peaceful learning. Whether rebuilding, replacement or emptiness follows [collapse](concepts.md#c15) is [not guaranteed](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c02); this paper does not write good or bad, and does not write what comes after. This paragraph is a constraint-level conclusion.\n\n## 8. List of Prohibitions\n\nThis paper prohibits the following in method.\n1. No inference beyond the [cut](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c23). Results under a [cut](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c23) must not be extended beyond that [cut](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c23): to dimensions not cut, beyond the sampling boundary, or to \"that [culture](concepts.md#c13) pattern does not exist\". Comparisons between different [cuts](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c23) require consistent dimensions, time windows and classification rules.\n2. Write only the possibility of [resonance](concepts.md#c09). [Resonance](concepts.md#c09) is written only as \"possible, and possibly partial\"; no guarantee is written, no necessary convergence is written, and it is not equated with good, correct or friendly. Without any [arrival](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) there is no [resonance](concepts.md#c09); with [arrival](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) there is still no guarantee.\n3. Do not write motives. Drives must not be written as facts that can be observed, confirmed by self-report, or verified after the fact; [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) must not be explained with \"in order to\", and only the observable distribution of outputs is written (some kind of [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) in some dimension appears more often afterwards, or more often than in the previous period); where [weight] is discussed (weight is the lightness or heaviness of [branches](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c05), like a probability), it must be marked that the researcher relies only on an incomplete outward distribution, cannot directly determine the underlying [weight](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06) value, and can only make a conditional estimate; a distribution is not the [weight](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06) (see 2.6 last paragraph and item 13 of this section). Interpretations by recorders and researchers are always marked as [view attributions](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c02); \"having something to seek\" is written only in its observable version.\n4. [Learning](concepts.md#c04) must not be written as having a direction or as necessarily better; from the number of interactions, immersion time or ability, one must not infer that some item was learned on some occasion.\n5. [Culture](concepts.md#c13), [templates](concepts.md#c14) and [tacit coordination](../paper_ae79e938_76e1_4bf9_b2ab_995c03e16c9e/concepts.md#c06) must not be inferred from one another; compliance must not be inferred from the existence of a [template](concepts.md#c14) or of [enforcement](concepts.md#c11); understanding, agreement or [tacit coordination](../paper_ae79e938_76e1_4bf9_b2ab_995c03e16c9e/concepts.md#c06) must not be inferred from compliance.\n6. When using the term \"[culture](concepts.md#c13)\", one must state who cuts, which people are cut, and which dimensions are looked at; a word with only a name and no criterion must not be used to fill an explanatory gap, and the concrete [history](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13) input must be pointed out.\n7. Do not write that [culture](concepts.md#c13) \"determines\" survival, and do not write \"formed in order to adapt\".\n8. Any conclusion that treats [culture](concepts.md#c13), [templates](concepts.md#c14) or the [natural environment](concepts.md#c16) as fixed must state the dimension-by-dimension time-scale ratio; local conditions are treated as given only within the stated time window, must not be written as permanently unchanged, and must not be written as driving all dimensions equally.\n9. The [proportion of failed expectations](concepts.md#c17) must not be used to uniquely infer whether [collapse](concepts.md#c15) will occur, nor to prove that \"this change is still within the limit\".\n10. One must not infer from the researcher's grouping that the parties identify themselves as one, nor the reverse.\n11. A [large node](concepts.md#c08) must not be written as omniscient, nor may its purposes be written.\n12. One must not write that acquaintances and strangers are two kinds of relationship; must not write that contact monotonically increases familiarity; must not write old material as valid for the present state without checking; must not write separation as the disappearance of [history](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13).\n13. Outward statistics, sequence, or a recorded path must not be written as a direct reading of the true [weights](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06) or dependency paths; a feeling of certainty must not be taken as evidence; when speaking of [convergence](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c37), [divergence](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c38) or [stasis](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c52), the dimension must be stated.\n14. The researcher must not be assumed to be outside the [loop](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c31): if the researcher's observations, questions and records [arrive](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at the observed [Self](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19), they enter the other side's [history](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13) and cannot be taken back.\n\n## 9. Cases\n\nThis whole section is calibration and is not a source of any derivation. The three cases are fragments from three local perspectives, not three types, and are used to see how the update rules run under different amounts of material. What is written is the difficulty of communication and talking past one another, not what they said, because thoughts cannot be confirmed from outside. Each case unfolds in seven steps: [cut](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c23), initial state, new [arrival](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10), change in [weight](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06), outcome, what it shows, and what can be said versus what cannot be inferred. The materials are all taken from public web pages and are not original files; each case states at the beginning what was read and what was not; the researcher's interpretation is kept separate from the record; where sources [conflict](../paper_ae79e938_76e1_4bf9_b2ab_995c03e16c9e/concepts.md#c10), they are only set side by side and no side is chosen.\n\n### 9.1 Portugal and the Tupiniquim (1500)\n\nData note. What was read: the full Portuguese text page of the letter of 1 May 1500 by Pero Vaz de Caminha (relevant passages extracted by a tool, not read page by page), the Wikipedia entry for Caminha, and a brief account of the first contact in a Brazilian academic article. Góis's *Chronicle* is known only as relayed by that article, and the original book was not read. There is no first-hand record of this contact from the shore side. The names of the people differ among the sources: Wikipedia writes Tupiniquim, while that academic article says the people are unidentified.\n\n1. [Cut](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c23). The scope is the roughly ten days (from 22 April) during which the fleet lay at anchor near Porto Seguro. There are two [nodes](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25): the fleet side, and the crowd on shore. The recorder Caminha belonged to the fleet side and is also the only source, so the record is one-sided.\n2. Initial state. The record shows no language, [container](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c26) or explicitly listed rule shared by both sides; in the dimensions of this contact, the two sides have no [dedicated history](../paper_ae79e938_76e1_4bf9_b2ab_995c03e16c9e/concepts.md#c05).\n3. New [arrival](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10). Mainly gestures and objects. Nicolau Coelho of the fleet side signaled to the other side to put down their bows, and they did so; the two sides exchanged objects (clothes, bells, mirrors and the like for maize, flour, beans, fruit and the like); on one occasion a man on shore gestured toward the ground, then pointed at a necklace and a candlestick. The letter also says \"when signaled to leave, they left\", and \"there were no more words or understanding then\".\n4. [Weight](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06) change. Only the outward record is written: after the fleet side made a gesture signaling them to put down the bows, the other side put down the bows; after the other side pointed at the ground and the necklace, the fleet side's record wrote \"there is gold there\". Caminha himself wrote: \"We understood it so because we wished to understand it so.\" This is the recorder's attribution about his own interpretation, not a reading of what the other side's gestures meant.\n5. Outcome. The fleet left on 3 May; the letter records an agreement to leave two exiled convicts behind.\n6. What it shows. When material is at its least, updating relies only on probing: one side's [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) [arrives](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10), the other side's later [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) [arrives](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) in turn, and they try step by step. Second, the recorder admits that his interpretation was affected by \"wishing\", a clear example of [view attribution](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c02); at the same time there is no record from the other side, so the \"meaning\" on either side is only a one-sided attribution.\n7. What can be said and what cannot be inferred. Can be said: in this record, gestures and exchange of objects occurred together, and the two sides' later [outputs](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) changed. Cannot be inferred: what the other side's gestures referred to, whether they really pointed to gold or silver, how they regarded the fleet's gestures; which people they were; whether the letter's description of them is accurate; why the fleet left those two men.\n\n### 9.2 Ping-Pong Diplomacy (1971 to 1972)\n\nData note. What was read: summaries of the content of History Today's \"Ping-Pong Diplomacy: Myth and Reality\" and of the History.com entry, both extracted by a tool and not original files. The two sources are inconsistent on one detail (see step 4). The words \"friendship\" and \"chance\" in the text are attributions by the parties or the authors.\n\n1. [Cut](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c23). The scope runs from the World Table Tennis Championships in Nagoya in April 1971 to the exchange of visits by the Chinese and American teams in 1972. The [nodes](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25) are the Chinese team and the American team; the Chinese and American governments, the Japanese hosts and others are treated as [outputs](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) [arriving](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) from outside.\n2. Initial state. There had already been ambassador-level talks between the two countries (136 in total from 1955 to 1970, according to History Today), and in 1957 a delegation of American youth visited China. The record cannot directly show in which dimensions these contacts were compatible, because the compatibility criterion has not been specified, so this case does not call them \"connecting\" or \"not connecting\".\n3. New [arrival](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10). In April 1971, the American player Glenn Cowan boarded the Chinese team's bus, and the team captain Zhuang Zedong, in front of reporters, gave him a Huangshan silk painting; afterward the American team was invited, entered from Hong Kong on 10 April, played matches and made visits in Guangzhou, Beijing and Shanghai; on 14 April they met Zhou Enlai. According to History Today, the Chinese side, following instructions to put \"friendship first, competition second\", let some matches go. The rules of the game are explicitly listed rules that both sides have, and provide a fixed point in this narrow dimension.\n4. [Weight](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06) change. Only the outward record is written: the American team was invited and entered, and the two sides continued compatibly in the dimension of the game (matches proceeded according to the rules). The sources are inconsistent: History.com says that on the same day (14 April) Nixon announced a relaxation of travel and trade restrictions; History Today says that Nixon had already lifted the travel ban and does not mention a trade embargo. Set side by side, no side chosen.\n5. Outcome. In July 1971 Kissinger secretly visited Beijing; in February 1972 Nixon visited China; in 1972 the Chinese table tennis team visited eight American cities.\n6. What it shows. In a narrow dimension, when there is a ready explicitly listed rule (the rules of the game), the two sides can connect without first being familiar; whether they connected outside this dimension has to be looked at separately in the records of other dimensions. \"Friendship\", \"chance\" and \"spontaneous\" are all attributions by the parties or the authors: the author of History Today holds that this contact was not by chance, which is the author's interpretation and is not taken as a record; that Mao Zedong approved the invitation, the article says, has documentary basis, and this paper cites it only as \"the article records it so\".\n7. What can be said and what cannot be inferred. Can be said: in this record, after the game contact, contacts in other dimensions gradually increased. Cannot be inferred: that the table tennis contact caused the later visits; why the parties acted so; the respective purposes of Mao, Zhou and Nixon; whether the later diplomatic results depended on this event.\n\n### 9.3 Treaty of Wuchale (1889 to 1893)\n\nData note. What was read: the Wikipedia entry on the treaty, and a Warwick University student article (Katie Blair, on translation in the colonial period), both extracted by a tool and not original files. The correspondence between 1890 and 1893 was not read. Where the two sources contradict each other, they are only set side by side.\n\n1. [Cut](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c23). The scope runs from the signing of the treaty to Menelik II's public repudiation (Wikipedia's date of signing is 2 May 1889; for the date of repudiation the entry says 1893 in one place and 1894 in another, which is inconsistent). The [nodes](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25): the Italian side and the Ethiopian side; the two texts (Italian and Amharic) are treated as two [signal containers](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c26), and the other European states are treated as [nodes](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25) [arriving](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) from outside.\n2. Initial state. The two sides' [dedicated history](../paper_ae79e938_76e1_4bf9_b2ab_995c03e16c9e/concepts.md#c05) before the treaty is not stated in the sources, and this case does not write it.\n3. New [arrival](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10). Both texts have twenty articles. In Article 17, according to Wikipedia, the Amharic version says Ethiopia \"may\" use the Italian government to handle foreign affairs, while the Italian version says it \"must\" go through Italy; the difference is the permission versus compulsion of one verb. In October 1889 Italy notified the European states of its position that \"Ethiopia is a protectorate\"; the Ottoman Empire and Russia did not accept it, and the other states did.\n4. [Weight](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06) change. Only the outward record is written: each of the two texts is fixed content and does not change because of the two sides' dispute; what changes is the later [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) of the two sides and of third parties. Menelik repudiated the protectorate reading; in 1895 Italy invaded.\n5. Outcome. In the Battle of Adwa (the Warwick article says 1896) Ethiopia won and preserved its independence.\n6. What it shows. The two texts are two [templates](concepts.md#c14) (one rule with two texts). The existence of a [template](concepts.md#c14) does not guarantee that both sides read the same rule: the incompatibility returned to the parties only through the third parties' notifications and the two sides' later [outputs](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28).\n7. What can be said and what cannot be inferred. Can be said: the two texts are incompatible on Article 17; after this incompatibility, notification, repudiation and invasion followed. Cannot be inferred: who altered the text, whether it was deliberate, whether Menelik knew when signing that the two versions differed; the two sources contradict each other on these points (Wikipedia mentions only the difference in the verb and does not say who changed it; the Warwick article says Antonelli drafted both versions, that the Amharic version was altered, that Menelik did not know when he signed, and calls his later account racial discrimination, which is that article author's interpretation); whether the invasion was caused by the treaty dispute; what happened between 1890 and 1893.\n\n## 10. Grading of Conclusions and Falsifiability Conditions\n\nThe conclusions of this paper are of two levels. A constraint-level conclusion is derived only from the [Law of Flux](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c24), the [Law of the Black Box](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c25), the [Law of Attrition](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c26), the [Law of Non-Restoration](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c28), [Unconfirmability of Drives](../paper_ae79e938_76e1_4bf9_b2ab_995c03e16c9e/concepts.md#c03), and Premises 1 to 6, Premise 10, Premise 23 and Premise 24 of this paper. A conditional-level conclusion additionally uses Premises 7 to 9, or the dimension-by-dimension time-scale ratio under a particular [cut](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c23), or antecedents that depend on data. The cases in Section 9 are calibration and belong to neither level.\n\nThe constraint-level conclusions are as follows.\n| Property | Summary | Section |\n|---|---|---|\n| [Nodes](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25) and [unit](concepts.md#c01) | Three kinds of [nodes](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25); a [small loop](concepts.md#c02) belongs only to a [Wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16); an [edge](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c29) has direction; [exit cost](concepts.md#c06) and [exit](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c43) are at different levels | 2.1 to 2.4 |\n| [Impact](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c47) and [discrepancy](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c49) | Properties of an [arrival](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) relative to its receiver, not parameters of an [edge](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c29) | 2.4 |\n| [Reachable subgraph](concepts.md#c07) | Each [Wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16) has one, and there is no guarantee of a global one; each [Wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16) accumulates only finite [history](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13), which covers only a part of the situation space; outside the subgraph the dedicated material within the time window is zero; [arrival](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) is directed; broad [arrival](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) does not imply great influence | 2.5 |\n| [Dedicated history](../paper_ae79e938_76e1_4bf9_b2ab_995c03e16c9e/concepts.md#c05) | Dimension by dimension; contact increases material, separation may leave the material out of step with the current state; position is not monotonic; a reunion is a new occurrence; not quantified | 2.6 |\n| Direction and [resonance](concepts.md#c09) | [Convergence](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c37), [divergence](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c38) and [stasis](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c52) require the dimension to be stated; [resonance](concepts.md#c09) is not the same as [convergence](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c37); [divergence](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c38) does not entail [Taiji](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c39) | 3 |\n| [Culture](concepts.md#c13) | The researcher's name for [resonance](concepts.md#c09); not bounded by whether it is written down; has no subject; description carries no purpose | 5 |\n| [Template](concepts.md#c14) | Fixed content in a [container](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c26), not a layer of [culture](concepts.md#c13); its persistence is independent of that of [culture](concepts.md#c13) | 6 |\n| Persistence | [History](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13) keeps changing; [collapse](concepts.md#c15) is scale-free, graded and dimension by dimension; the limit cannot be uniquely inferred in advance from the [Law of the Black Box](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c25) | 7 |\n\nThe conditional-level conclusions are as follows.\n| Conclusion | Antecedent used | Section |\n|---|---|---|\n| Whether a reunion brings [mismatch](../paper_ae79e938_76e1_4bf9_b2ab_995c03e16c9e/concepts.md#c08), and how fast recalibration is | Depends on data | 2.6 |\n| Biological-human antecedents: limited reception, delayed reaction | Premise 7, Premise 8 | 4 |\n| Tendency of the other side to leave ([arrivals](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) on an [edge](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c29) stopping or decreasing) | [Exit cost](concepts.md#c06), [arrival](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) [frequency](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c48), buffer (nothing guaranteed outside the range) | 4 |\n| These materials may let people form an [impression](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c45) of the other side early on | Low [exit cost](concepts.md#c06) | 4, 6 |\n| Tendency for [resonance](concepts.md#c09) to form easily | Premise 9 | 5 |\n| Combinations of behavior that keep receiving negative [outcome feedback](concepts.md#c05) in their interaction with the [natural environment](concepts.md#c16) tend not to be repeatedly [arrived](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at | Depends on data | 5 |\n| Strong [coupling](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c36) and non-assemblability of [natural environment](concepts.md#c16) constraints | A particular [cut](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c23) of the researcher | 5 |\n| If the parties also group themselves and express it, the [resonance](concepts.md#c09) pattern the researcher sees and the parties' own boundary-drawing and belonging are two layers that can be inconsistent | The parties also group themselves and express it | 5 |\n| When the [natural environment](concepts.md#c16) changes so much in some dimension that it cannot return to what it was (for example, from grassland to New York), [culture](concepts.md#c13) tends to change too | A particular [cut](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c23) of the researcher | 7 |\n| When the [natural environment](concepts.md#c16) changes faster than [resonance](concepts.md#c09) forms and this change makes previously workable practices unworkable and, if the [weight](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06) moves away from these practices as a result, and this moving away continues in later [arrivals](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10), these practices tend to be hard to keep up as a stable [resonance](concepts.md#c09) | Dimension-by-dimension time-scale ratio | 7 |\n| Whether a [template](concepts.md#c14) exists | The criterion of Premise 6 | 6 |\n\nWhat would make the conclusions fail. The basis of the constraint-level conclusions is the upstream laws and Premises 1 to 6, Premise 10, Premise 23 and Premise 24 of this paper. When these premises are changed, the conclusions that depend on them lose their basis: if there is some [presentation](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c04) whose [own segment](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c17) has all [arrived](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at some [Wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16), Premise 2 is overturned, and the conclusions in 2.5 and 2.6 that use Premise 2 lose their source; if some [Self](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19)'s [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) does not [arrive](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at that [Self](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19) before the [Self](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19)'s next [moment](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c09), Premise 1 fails and the conclusions that use it lose their source; if the criterion specified by the researcher cannot be stated, cannot be obtained again, or cannot be applied to new situations of the specified type, so that the existence of a [template](concepts.md#c14) cannot be judged by it, Premise 6 is overturned and the decidability in Section 6 loses its source. Premises 3 to 5, Premise 10, Premise 23 and Premise 24 are scope settings, not claims that can be overturned; changing them changes the scope this paper treats, and conclusions that depend on them must be rechecked. Losing a source only means that the derivation chain is broken, and does not mean that the proposition is false. Premise 9 speaks only of tendencies: a case in which the tendency is not realized does not count as a violation; Premise 9 counts as violated when, within the stated dimension and time window, the many cases that meet its conditions show, taken as a whole, no change in the stated direction. The conditions under which a conditional-level conclusion fails depend on the antecedent it uses: whichever antecedent is violated by reality, only the conclusions that use it fail and the rest are unaffected; Premise 10 is a scope setting, not a claim that can be overturned; when some dimension does not fit its convention (it changes faster than the stated time window yet is treated as a constant), only the conclusions that depend on that convention must be rechecked, not the whole paper.\n\nWhat is not a conclusion of this paper. The cases in Section 9 belong to neither level. Data that were not obtained are not written as \"nonexistent\", nor are they used to support conclusions.\n"}]}
{"paper_uuid":"37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986","paper_title":"渦動力學","paper_title_en":"Wo Dynamics","author":"黃正宇 / Cheng Yu Huang","contact":"mthree.tw@gmail.com","concepts_md":"---\nuuid: 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986\nlast-modified: 2026-09-29T12:00:00\n---\n\n\n## private 介入 / Intervention\n\n- 定義:介入是在[形式層](../paper_54c0291d_05b3_431a_9f2a_1b8ec93c3c3f/concepts.md#c02)之外發生的一次事件。它不在任何一個[形式層時刻](../paper_54c0291d_05b3_431a_9f2a_1b8ec93c3c3f/concepts.md#c04)之中,不可被形式化,也不再進一步描述。\n- Definition: The intervention is a single event that takes place outside the [Formal Layer](../paper_54c0291d_05b3_431a_9f2a_1b8ec93c3c3f/concepts.md#c02). It lies within no [formal-layer moment](../paper_54c0291d_05b3_431a_9f2a_1b8ec93c3c3f/concepts.md#c04), cannot be formalized, and is not described any further.\n\n\n## public 宇宙 / Universe\n\n- 定義:宇宙是有[坍塌](concepts.md#c08)的那一個世界。它與[形式層](../paper_54c0291d_05b3_431a_9f2a_1b8ec93c3c3f/concepts.md#c02)只差一件事:宇宙中有[選出](../paper_54c0291d_05b3_431a_9f2a_1b8ec93c3c3f/concepts.md#c32)。從宇宙內部看,宇宙只有一個;之前與之後的說法,只在宇宙之內成立。宇宙中不由過去決定的只有兩樣:[宇宙初態](concepts.md#c14),與每一次[坍塌](concepts.md#c08)的結果;其他一切,包括每一次[寫入](concepts.md#c29),都由到當時為止的[歷史](concepts.md#c13)決定。\n- Definition: The universe is the one world in which there is [Collapse](concepts.md#c08). It differs from the [Formal Layer](../paper_54c0291d_05b3_431a_9f2a_1b8ec93c3c3f/concepts.md#c02) in exactly one respect: in the universe there is [Selection](../paper_54c0291d_05b3_431a_9f2a_1b8ec93c3c3f/concepts.md#c32). Seen from inside, there is only one universe, and talk of before and after holds only within it. Only two things in the universe are not determined by the past: the [Initial State of the Universe](concepts.md#c14) and the outcome of each [collapse](concepts.md#c08); everything else, including every [Writing](concepts.md#c29), is determined by the [History](concepts.md#c13) up to that point.\n- 裁決:2026-09-30 修飾子改為 public:使鐵律及其定義用到的詞可被下游直接引用。唯一是這個概念本身的內容,不是本篇特有的對象。\n\n\n## private 框架承諾 / Framework Commitment\n\n- 定義:框架承諾是這樣的條件:[流變律](concepts.md#c24)、[黑箱律](concepts.md#c25)、[損耗律](concepts.md#c26)、[不可復原律](concepts.md#c28)四條律中,沒有任何一條要求它,它也不是為了符合已知的觀察而保留的,但理論仍然保留它。框架承諾與由這四條律倒推出來、被它們要求的給定分開列出。\n- Definition: A framework commitment is a condition that none of the four laws, namely the [Law of Flux](concepts.md#c24), the [Law of the Black Box](concepts.md#c25), the [Law of Attrition](concepts.md#c26), and the [Law of Non-Restoration](concepts.md#c28), requires, and which is not retained in order to fit known observations, but which the theory nevertheless retains. Framework commitments are listed separately from the givens that are derived backward from, and required by, these four laws.\n\n\n## public 呈現 / Presentation\n\n- 定義:呈現是[宇宙](concepts.md#c02)中的任何一部分。\n- Definition: A presentation is any part of the [Universe](concepts.md#c02).\n- 裁決:2026-09-30 修飾子改為 public:使鐵律及其定義用到的詞可被下游直接引用。\n\n\n## public 分支 / Branch\n\n- 定義:分支是一次[坍塌](concepts.md#c08)可能[選出](../paper_54c0291d_05b3_431a_9f2a_1b8ec93c3c3f/concepts.md#c32)的每一個結果。\n- Definition: A branch is each possible outcome that a [Collapse](concepts.md#c08) may [select](../paper_54c0291d_05b3_431a_9f2a_1b8ec93c3c3f/concepts.md#c32).\n- 裁決:2026-09-30 修飾子改為 public:使鐵律及其定義用到的詞可被下游直接引用。\n\n\n## public 權重 / Weight\n\n- 定義:權重是每個[分支](concepts.md#c05)的輕重。一次[坍塌](concepts.md#c08)的各[分支](concepts.md#c05)權重都不小於零,總和為一。一個[呈現](concepts.md#c04)的權重,是[宇宙](concepts.md#c02)的權重落在它身上的那一部分:把各[分支](concepts.md#c05)看成該[呈現](concepts.md#c04)的結果之後,同一個結果的權重相加。權重是[分支](concepts.md#c05)的輕重,不是任何[渦](concepts.md#c16)內部的參數。\n- Definition: A weight is how heavy each [Branch](concepts.md#c05) is. The weights of the [branches](concepts.md#c05) of a [Collapse](concepts.md#c08) are all non-negative and sum to one. The weight of a [Presentation](concepts.md#c04) is the part of the weight of the [Universe](concepts.md#c02) that falls on it: once each [branch](concepts.md#c05) is read as an outcome for that [presentation](concepts.md#c04), the weights of [branches](concepts.md#c05) giving the same outcome are added together. A weight belongs to [branches](concepts.md#c05); it is not an internal parameter of any [Wo](concepts.md#c16).\n- 裁決:2026-09-26 判定「呈現的權重」併入本條,不另登記。\n- 裁決:2026-09-30 修飾子改為 public:使鐵律及其定義用到的詞可被下游直接引用。\n\n\n## public 觀察者 / Observer\n\n- 定義:觀察者是一個識別碼,沒有內容:不運算,不感受,不受苦,也沒有視角。它不在[宇宙](concepts.md#c02)之中,不是[呈現](concepts.md#c04),也不是[我](concepts.md#c19)。觀察者只有一個,唯一的功能是[坍塌](concepts.md#c08),一次只[坍塌](concepts.md#c08)一次。\n- Definition: The observer is an identifier with no content: it does not compute, does not feel, does not suffer, and has no point of view. It is not in the [Universe](concepts.md#c02); it is not a [Presentation](concepts.md#c04), nor a [Self](concepts.md#c19). There is only one observer; its sole function is [Collapse](concepts.md#c08), and it [collapses](concepts.md#c08) only once at a time.\n- 裁決:2026-09-30 修飾子改為 public:使鐵律及其定義用到的詞可被下游直接引用。唯一是這個概念本身的內容,不是本篇特有的對象。\n\n\n## public 坍塌 / Collapse\n\n- 定義:坍塌是在某個固定的基底下,依[權重](concepts.md#c06)[選出](../paper_54c0291d_05b3_431a_9f2a_1b8ec93c3c3f/concepts.md#c32)一個[分支](concepts.md#c05)的事件。未被[選出](../paper_54c0291d_05b3_431a_9f2a_1b8ec93c3c3f/concepts.md#c32)的[分支](concepts.md#c05),不留在[宇宙](concepts.md#c02)中。坍塌只[選出](../paper_54c0291d_05b3_431a_9f2a_1b8ec93c3c3f/concepts.md#c32)[權重](concepts.md#c06)不為零的[分支](concepts.md#c05)之間的差別;一個[呈現](concepts.md#c04)的下一[時刻](concepts.md#c09)若只有一個[權重](concepts.md#c06)不為零的結果,它的結果來自約束,不來自坍塌。給定到當時為止的[歷史](concepts.md#c13),坍塌的結果依[權重](concepts.md#c06)[選出](../paper_54c0291d_05b3_431a_9f2a_1b8ec93c3c3f/concepts.md#c32),[歷史](concepts.md#c13)中沒有任何東西能比[權重](concepts.md#c06)多說一點。\n- Definition: A collapse is the event in which, in some fixed basis, one [Branch](concepts.md#c05) is [selected](../paper_54c0291d_05b3_431a_9f2a_1b8ec93c3c3f/concepts.md#c32) according to the [Weights](concepts.md#c06). [Branches](concepts.md#c05) not [selected](../paper_54c0291d_05b3_431a_9f2a_1b8ec93c3c3f/concepts.md#c32) do not remain in the [Universe](concepts.md#c02). A collapse [selects](../paper_54c0291d_05b3_431a_9f2a_1b8ec93c3c3f/concepts.md#c32) only among [branches](concepts.md#c05) of non-zero [weight](concepts.md#c06); if the next [moment](concepts.md#c09) of a [Presentation](concepts.md#c04) has only one outcome of non-zero [weight](concepts.md#c06), its outcome comes from constraint, not from collapse. Given the [History](concepts.md#c13) up to that point, the outcome of a collapse is [selected](../paper_54c0291d_05b3_431a_9f2a_1b8ec93c3c3f/concepts.md#c32) according to the [weights](concepts.md#c06), and nothing in the [history](concepts.md#c13) says anything more than the [weights](concepts.md#c06).\n- 裁決:2026-09-30 修飾子改為 public:使鐵律及其定義用到的詞可被下游直接引用。\n- 裁決:2026-09-30 「只有一個權重不為零的分支」改為「只有一個權重不為零的結果」,與鎖死的定義一致;論文未定稿,保留 ID。\n\n\n## public 時刻 / Moment\n\n- 定義:時刻是一次[坍塌](concepts.md#c08)。[宇宙](concepts.md#c02)的時刻依[觀察者](concepts.md#c07)[坍塌](concepts.md#c08)的次序排列;這是一條全序,不是一個視角。沒有[坍塌](concepts.md#c08),就沒有時刻。一個[呈現](concepts.md#c04)的時刻,是[涉及](concepts.md#c11)它的那些[坍塌](concepts.md#c08);它的下一時刻,是下一次[涉及](concepts.md#c11)它的[坍塌](concepts.md#c08);兩次之間,對它沒有時刻。時刻與[形式層時刻](../paper_54c0291d_05b3_431a_9f2a_1b8ec93c3c3f/concepts.md#c04)不是同一個東西。\n- Definition: A moment is a [Collapse](concepts.md#c08). The moments of the [Universe](concepts.md#c02) are ordered by the sequence in which the [Observer](concepts.md#c07) [collapses](concepts.md#c08); this is a total order, not a point of view. Without [collapse](concepts.md#c08) there is no moment. The moments of a [Presentation](concepts.md#c04) are the [collapses](concepts.md#c08) that [involve](concepts.md#c11) it; its next moment is the next [collapse](concepts.md#c08) that [involves](concepts.md#c11) it; between two of them, there is no moment for it. A moment is not the same thing as a [formal-layer moment](../paper_54c0291d_05b3_431a_9f2a_1b8ec93c3c3f/concepts.md#c04).\n- 裁決:2026-09-26 判定與上游的時刻(c04)不是同一概念,另行登記。\n- 裁決:2026-09-26 判定「呈現的時刻」與「下一時刻」併入本條,不另登記。\n- 裁決:2026-09-30 修飾子改為 public:使鐵律及其定義用到的詞可被下游直接引用。\n\n\n## public 到達 / Arrival\n\n- 定義:一次[寫入](concepts.md#c29)作為[刺激](concepts.md#c30)落到一個[呈現](concepts.md#c04)上,就是到達它。一次[坍塌](concepts.md#c08)[涉及](concepts.md#c11)一個[呈現](concepts.md#c04)時,它的結果就到達這個[呈現](concepts.md#c04);結果沒有落在它身上時,「這次沒有發生在它身上」也是到達它的一件事。[宇宙初態](concepts.md#c14)到達一切[呈現](concepts.md#c04)。\n- Definition: A [Writing](concepts.md#c29) arrives at a [Presentation](concepts.md#c04) when it falls on that [presentation](concepts.md#c04) as a [Stimulus](concepts.md#c30). When a [Collapse](concepts.md#c08) [involves](concepts.md#c11) a [presentation](concepts.md#c04), its outcome arrives at that [presentation](concepts.md#c04); if the outcome does not fall on it, the fact that \"this time it did not happen to it\" is also something that arrives at it. The [Initial State of the Universe](concepts.md#c14) arrives at every [presentation](concepts.md#c04).\n- 裁決:2026-09-30 修飾子改為 public:使鐵律及其定義用到的詞可被下游直接引用。\n\n\n## public 涉及 / Involvement\n\n- 定義:一次[坍塌](concepts.md#c08)涉及一個[呈現](concepts.md#c04),是指這次[坍塌](concepts.md#c08)的結果可能落在它身上,也就是結果以正的[權重](concepts.md#c06)落在它身上;這時它的[權重](concepts.md#c06),依賴[到達](concepts.md#c10)它的[歷史](concepts.md#c13)。涉及與[分支](concepts.md#c05)的多寡無關。\n- Definition: A [Collapse](concepts.md#c08) involves a [Presentation](concepts.md#c04) when the outcome of that [collapse](concepts.md#c08) may fall on it, that is, when the outcome falls on it with positive [Weight](concepts.md#c06); in that case its [weight](concepts.md#c06) depends on the [History](concepts.md#c13) that has [arrived](concepts.md#c10) at it. Involvement does not depend on how many [Branches](concepts.md#c05) there are.\n- 裁決:2026-09-30 修飾子改為 public:使鐵律及其定義用到的詞可被下游直接引用。\n\n\n## public 鎖死 / Lock-in\n\n- 定義:鎖死是一個[呈現](concepts.md#c04)的下一[時刻](concepts.md#c09)只有一個[權重](concepts.md#c06)不為零的結果的情形:把各[分支](concepts.md#c05)看成該[呈現](concepts.md#c04)的結果、同一個結果的[權重](concepts.md#c06)相加之後,只剩一個結果的[權重](concepts.md#c06)不為零。鎖死是約束,與[坍塌](concepts.md#c08)無關。鎖死是被[涉及](concepts.md#c11)了,卻只有一個結果;一個[呈現](concepts.md#c04)沒有[時刻](concepts.md#c09)的期間,不是鎖死。\n- Definition: Lock-in is the situation in which the next [Moment](concepts.md#c09) of a [Presentation](concepts.md#c04) has only one outcome of non-zero [Weight](concepts.md#c06): once each [Branch](concepts.md#c05) is read as an outcome for that [presentation](concepts.md#c04) and the [weights](concepts.md#c06) of the same outcome are added together, only one outcome has non-zero [weight](concepts.md#c06). Lock-in is a constraint and has nothing to do with [Collapse](concepts.md#c08). Lock-in means being [involved](concepts.md#c11) yet having only one outcome; a period in which a [presentation](concepts.md#c04) has no [moment](concepts.md#c09) is not lock-in.\n- 裁決:2026-09-30 修飾子改為 public:使鐵律及其定義用到的詞可被下游直接引用。\n- 裁決:2026-09-30 「只有一個權重不為零的分支」改為「只有一個權重不為零的結果」,與論文第三節形式段一致:數個分支可以是同一個結果。論文未定稿,保留 ID。\n\n\n## public 歷史 / History\n\n- 定義:歷史始於[宇宙初態](concepts.md#c14),其後是[宇宙](concepts.md#c02)中每一次[寫入](concepts.md#c29)與每一次[坍塌](concepts.md#c08)的結果,依[時刻](concepts.md#c09)排列。[宇宙](concepts.md#c02)只有一部歷史,歷史只往後追加。\n- Definition: History begins with the [Initial State of the Universe](concepts.md#c14), followed by every [Writing](concepts.md#c29) and the outcome of every [Collapse](concepts.md#c08) in the [Universe](concepts.md#c02), arranged by [Moment](concepts.md#c09). The [universe](concepts.md#c02) has only one history, and history is only ever appended to.\n- 裁決:2026-09-30 修飾子改為 public:使鐵律及其定義用到的詞可被下游直接引用。\n\n\n## public 宇宙初態 / Initial State of the Universe\n\n- 定義:宇宙初態是第一次[坍塌](concepts.md#c08)之前已經在那裡的一切,是[歷史](concepts.md#c13)的起點。它帶著[形式層](../paper_54c0291d_05b3_431a_9f2a_1b8ec93c3c3f/concepts.md#c02)中[累積](../paper_54c0291d_05b3_431a_9f2a_1b8ec93c3c3f/concepts.md#c30)的[記錄](../paper_54c0291d_05b3_431a_9f2a_1b8ec93c3c3f/concepts.md#c17),內容不分析。\n- Definition: The initial state of the universe is everything that is already there before the first [Collapse](concepts.md#c08); it is the starting point of [History](concepts.md#c13). It carries the [Records](../paper_54c0291d_05b3_431a_9f2a_1b8ec93c3c3f/concepts.md#c17) [accumulated](../paper_54c0291d_05b3_431a_9f2a_1b8ec93c3c3f/concepts.md#c30) in the [Formal Layer](../paper_54c0291d_05b3_431a_9f2a_1b8ec93c3c3f/concepts.md#c02); its content is not analyzed.\n- 裁決:2026-09-30 修飾子改為 public:使鐵律及其定義用到的詞可被下游直接引用。\n\n\n## public 生成函數 / Generating Function\n\n- 定義:生成函數把到當時為止的[歷史](concepts.md#c13),包括剛發生的那一次[寫入](concepts.md#c29),對應到下一[時刻](concepts.md#c09)各[分支](concepts.md#c05)的[權重](concepts.md#c06)。它只取到當時為止的[歷史](concepts.md#c13),內部不分析。\n- Definition: The generating function maps the [History](concepts.md#c13) up to that point, including the [Writing](concepts.md#c29) that has just taken place, to the [Weights](concepts.md#c06) of the [Branches](concepts.md#c05) of the next [Moment](concepts.md#c09). It takes nothing but the [history](concepts.md#c13) up to that point, and its internals are not analyzed.\n- 裁決:2026-09-30 修飾子改為 public:下游的公開工具(份量)用到它,可直接引用。\n\n\n## public 渦 / Wo\n\n- 定義:渦是這樣的[呈現](concepts.md#c04):[到達](concepts.md#c10)它的所有[歷史](concepts.md#c13),包括它收到的每一次[刺激](concepts.md#c30)、[涉及](concepts.md#c11)它的每一次[坍塌](concepts.md#c08)的結果,一直到[宇宙初態](concepts.md#c14),都參與它下一[時刻](concepts.md#c09)[權重](concepts.md#c06)的分配,也就是其中任何一件若不同,影響沿著[歷史](concepts.md#c13)傳下來,它的[權重](concepts.md#c06)就會不同;並且至少有些[時刻](concepts.md#c09)它不被[鎖死](concepts.md#c12)。這個影響不必能被找到。有[歷史](concepts.md#c13)而[歷史](concepts.md#c13)不參與的[呈現](concepts.md#c04),不是渦;[歷史](concepts.md#c13)參與而每一步都被[鎖死](concepts.md#c12)的[呈現](concepts.md#c04),也不是渦。這種參與可以漸漸消失,消失之後,它就不再是渦;從某一刻起每一步都被[鎖死](concepts.md#c12),它也不再是渦。渦沒有固定的核心:它是什麼,就是什麼[到達](concepts.md#c10)了它,以及這些如何參與它的[權重](concepts.md#c06)。一個[呈現](concepts.md#c04)是否為渦,與它的載體無關,也與任何[分別](concepts.md#c18)無關。\n- Definition: A wo is a [Presentation](concepts.md#c04) such that all the [History](concepts.md#c13) that has [arrived](concepts.md#c10) at it, including every [Stimulus](concepts.md#c30) it has received and the outcome of every [Collapse](concepts.md#c08) that has [involved](concepts.md#c11) it, all the way back to the [Initial State of the Universe](concepts.md#c14), takes part in the allocation of its [Weights](concepts.md#c06) for the next [Moment](concepts.md#c09), meaning that if any one of these had been different, the influence would pass down the [history](concepts.md#c13) and its [weights](concepts.md#c06) would differ; and such that at least at some [moments](concepts.md#c09) it is not [locked in](concepts.md#c12). This influence need not be findable. A [presentation](concepts.md#c04) that has a [history](concepts.md#c13) but whose [history](concepts.md#c13) does not take part is not a wo; one whose [history](concepts.md#c13) takes part but which is [locked in](concepts.md#c12) at every step is not a wo either. This participation may fade away, and once it has, the [presentation](concepts.md#c04) is no longer a wo; if from some moment on it is [locked in](concepts.md#c12) at every step, it is no longer a wo either. A wo has no fixed core: what it is, is what has [arrived](concepts.md#c10) at it and how these take part in its [weights](concepts.md#c06). Whether a [presentation](concepts.md#c04) is a wo does not depend on its substrate, nor on any [Distinction](concepts.md#c18).\n- 裁決:2026-09-26 英文名定為 Wo:渦是作者所取的名稱,不取漩渦之意,不得譯為 Vortex。\n- 裁決:2026-09-29 補寫「從某一刻起每一步都被鎖死,它也不再是渦」,與論文第五節一致;只是明寫既有判準,意義不變,保留 ID。\n- 裁決:2026-10-14 「其中任何一件若不同」取存在性:對每個到達它的歷史項目,存在某個替換使它下一[時刻](concepts.md#c09)[權重](concepts.md#c06)的分布不同,不要求任何替換都改變[權重](concepts.md#c06)。只是明寫既有判準,意義不變,保留 ID。\n\n\n## public 自己的那一段 / Own Segment\n\n- 定義:一個[呈現](concepts.md#c04)自己的那一段,是它下一[時刻](concepts.md#c09)的[權重](concepts.md#c06)所依賴的那部分[歷史](concepts.md#c13):[歷史](concepts.md#c13)中某一件若換成別的,影響沿著[歷史](concepts.md#c13)傳下來,會改變它下一[時刻](concepts.md#c09)[權重](concepts.md#c06)的分布,這一件就屬於它自己的那一段。那一段由依賴決定,不由任何[分別](concepts.md#c18)決定。它是同一部[歷史](concepts.md#c13)的一部分,不是另一部[歷史](concepts.md#c13);不同[呈現](concepts.md#c04)自己的那一段可以重疊。\n- Definition: The own segment of a [Presentation](concepts.md#c04) is the part of [History](concepts.md#c13) on which the [Weights](concepts.md#c06) of its next [Moment](concepts.md#c09) depend: an item of [history](concepts.md#c13) belongs to its own segment if replacing that item with something else would, with the influence passing down the [history](concepts.md#c13), change the distribution of its [weights](concepts.md#c06) for the next [moment](concepts.md#c09). The segment is determined by dependence, not by any [Distinction](concepts.md#c18). It is part of the one [history](concepts.md#c13), not a separate [history](concepts.md#c13); the own segments of different [presentations](concepts.md#c04) may overlap.\n- 裁決:2026-09-30 修飾子改為 public:使鐵律及其定義用到的詞可被下游直接引用。\n- 裁決:2026-10-14 「某一件若換成別的」取存在性:存在某個替換會改變它下一[時刻](concepts.md#c09)[權重](concepts.md#c06)的分布,這一件就屬於它自己的那一段,不要求任何替換都改變。只是明寫既有判準,意義不變,保留 ID。\n\n\n## public 分別 / Distinction\n\n- 定義:分別是[渦](concepts.md#c16)的一個動作:劃出界線,把哪些[呈現](concepts.md#c04)看作一個[個體](concepts.md#c20),把哪一段看作過去,把不同[時刻](concepts.md#c09)的[渦](concepts.md#c16)看作[同一](concepts.md#c21)個或不同的兩個。這個動作在[歷史](concepts.md#c13)中留下一次[寫入](concepts.md#c29),[寫入](concepts.md#c29)的內容由到當時為止的[歷史](concepts.md#c13)決定。分別的內容改變的是看法,不改寫被看的東西。分別的材料只有它之前、已經[到達](concepts.md#c10)它的[歷史](concepts.md#c13),它自己不在其中。\n- Definition: A distinction is an act of a [Wo](concepts.md#c16): drawing a line, taking certain [Presentations](concepts.md#c04) as one [Individual](concepts.md#c20), taking a certain stretch as the past, taking [wos](concepts.md#c16) at different [Moments](concepts.md#c09) as [identical](concepts.md#c21) or as two different ones. This act leaves one [Writing](concepts.md#c29) in [History](concepts.md#c13), whose content is determined by the [history](concepts.md#c13) up to that point. The content of a distinction changes a way of seeing, and does not rewrite what is seen. The material of a distinction is only the [history](concepts.md#c13) before it that has [arrived](concepts.md#c10) at it; the distinction itself is not among that material.\n\n\n## public 我 / Self\n\n- 定義:我是以[分別](concepts.md#c18)定義自己的[渦](concepts.md#c16)。誰是我,由它自己定義;發出「我」這個聲音不算,自我定義才算。\n- Definition: A self is a [Wo](concepts.md#c16) that defines itself by [Distinction](concepts.md#c18). Who is a self is defined by that [wo](concepts.md#c16) itself; uttering the sound \"I\" does not count, only self-definition does.\n\n\n## public 個體 / Individual\n\n- 定義:個體是被某個[我](concepts.md#c19)[分別](concepts.md#c18)出來的[呈現](concepts.md#c04)。同一段[宇宙](concepts.md#c02),被[分別](concepts.md#c18)為一個個體或許多個個體,皆成立。\n- Definition: An individual is a [Presentation](concepts.md#c04) marked off by some [Self](concepts.md#c19) through [Distinction](concepts.md#c18). The same stretch of the [Universe](concepts.md#c02) may be [distinguished](concepts.md#c18) as one individual or as many, and either holds.\n- 裁決:2026-09-26 修飾子定為 private:個體在社會科學與人工智慧中意思不同,不要求下游沿用。\n- 裁決:2026-09-30 修飾子改為 public,推翻 2026-09-26 的裁決:下游直接引用;需要本領域的讀法時,另立 private 條目。\n\n\n## public 同一 / Identity\n\n- 定義:同一是一種[分別](concepts.md#c18):某一[時刻](concepts.md#c09)的[渦](concepts.md#c16)與另一[時刻](concepts.md#c09)的[渦](concepts.md#c16)是不是同一個,由作出[分別](concepts.md#c18)的[我](concepts.md#c19)決定。一個[呈現](concepts.md#c04)是不是[渦](concepts.md#c16),不是[分別](concepts.md#c18);兩個[時刻](concepts.md#c09)的[渦](concepts.md#c16)是不是同一個,是[分別](concepts.md#c18)。\n- Definition: Identity is a kind of [Distinction](concepts.md#c18): whether a [Wo](concepts.md#c16) at one [Moment](concepts.md#c09) and a [wo](concepts.md#c16) at another [moment](concepts.md#c09) are the same one is decided by the [Self](concepts.md#c19) that makes the [distinction](concepts.md#c18). Whether a [Presentation](concepts.md#c04) is a [wo](concepts.md#c16) is not a [distinction](concepts.md#c18); whether the [wo](concepts.md#c16) at two [moments](concepts.md#c09) are the same one is.\n- 裁決:2026-09-26 修飾子定為 private:同一在人工智慧與人類之間沒有統一的判定,不要求下游沿用。\n- 裁決:2026-09-30 修飾子改為 public,推翻 2026-09-26 的裁決:下游直接引用;需要本領域的讀法時,另立 private 條目。\n\n\n## private 接上 / Connection\n\n- 定義:接上是[我](concepts.md#c19)與[觀察者](concepts.md#c07)之間的聯繫;接上不在[宇宙](concepts.md#c02)之中。接上的[我](concepts.md#c19),是[坍塌](concepts.md#c08)所經由的[我](concepts.md#c19)。一個[我](concepts.md#c19)是否接上,不由它的任何[分別](concepts.md#c18)決定,包括自我定義。\n- Definition: Connection is the link between a [Self](concepts.md#c19) and the [Observer](concepts.md#c07). Connection is not in the [Universe](concepts.md#c02). A connected [self](concepts.md#c19) is a [self](concepts.md#c19) through which [Collapse](concepts.md#c08) takes place. Whether a [self](concepts.md#c19) is connected is not decided by any of its [distinctions](concepts.md#c18), including its self-definition.\n- 裁決:2026-10-05 稽核指出定義寫「不由自我定義決定」,論文第四節形式段寫「不由任何分別內容決定」,範圍不一致。接上不在宇宙之中,宇宙中的任何東西都不決定它;定義與正文改為「不由它的任何分別決定,包括自我定義」,與形式段一致。private 條目,保留 ID。\n\n\n## private 死亡 / Death\n\n- 定義:死亡是某個[我](concepts.md#c19)加在一個[渦](concepts.md#c16)上的標記。這個標記是那個[我](concepts.md#c19)的一次[分別](concepts.md#c18),是描述,不是物理條件;標在哪裡,由標記的[我](concepts.md#c19)決定。\n- Definition: Death is a mark that some [Self](concepts.md#c19) places on a [Wo](concepts.md#c16). This mark is a [Distinction](concepts.md#c18) made by that [self](concepts.md#c19); it is a description, not a physical condition, and where it is placed is decided by the [self](concepts.md#c19) that places it.\n- 裁決:2026-09-26 修飾子定為 private:死亡在社會科學與人工智慧中意思不同,不要求下游沿用。\n\n\n## public 流變律 / Law of Flux\n\n- 定義:流變律是框架承認的一條鐵律,不由其他任何條件推出:一個[渦](concepts.md#c16)所在的[歷史](concepts.md#c13)一直在變;在它的每一個[時刻](concepts.md#c09),[到達](concepts.md#c10)它的[歷史](concepts.md#c13)都和該次[坍塌](concepts.md#c08)之前不同,永遠不會一模一樣。\n- Definition: The Law of Flux is an iron law acknowledged by the framework and derived from no other condition: the [History](concepts.md#c13) in which a [Wo](concepts.md#c16) lies is always changing; at every [Moment](concepts.md#c09) of that [wo](concepts.md#c16), the [history](concepts.md#c13) that has [arrived](concepts.md#c10) at it differs from that before that [collapse](concepts.md#c08), and is never exactly the same.\n- 裁決:2026-09-29 原定義混入本篇模型的推導,改為鐵律的陳述,意義不變,保留 ID;模型中的形式另立為 c33。\n\n\n## public 黑箱律 / Law of the Black Box\n\n- 定義:黑箱律是框架承認的一條鐵律,不由其他任何條件推出:一個[渦](concepts.md#c16)在某個[時刻](concepts.md#c09)不被[鎖死](concepts.md#c12)時,[宇宙](concepts.md#c02)中沒有任何[渦](concepts.md#c16)能在那一刻之前唯一推出它的下一[時刻](concepts.md#c09),包括它自己。能推出的是[權重](concepts.md#c06),不是結果:各結果的[權重](concepts.md#c06)由到當時為止的[歷史](concepts.md#c13)決定。\n- Definition: The Law of the Black Box is an iron law acknowledged by the framework and derived from no other condition: when a [Wo](concepts.md#c16) is not [locked in](concepts.md#c12) at some [Moment](concepts.md#c09), no [wo](concepts.md#c16) in the [Universe](concepts.md#c02), including that [wo](concepts.md#c16) itself, can uniquely derive its next [moment](concepts.md#c09) before that moment. What can be derived is the [Weights](concepts.md#c06), not the outcome: the [weights](concepts.md#c06) of the outcomes are determined by the [History](concepts.md#c13) up to that point.\n- 裁決:2026-09-29 原定義混入本篇模型的推導,改為鐵律的陳述,意義不變,保留 ID;「能推出的是權重」屬於鐵律;模型中的形式另立為 c34。\n\n\n## public 損耗律 / Law of Attrition\n\n- 定義:損耗律是框架承認的一條鐵律,不由其他任何條件推出:任何一個[我](concepts.md#c19),在任何[時刻](concepts.md#c09)都不能完全[分別](concepts.md#c18)自己;它對自己的[分別](concepts.md#c18)永遠落後一步。\n- Definition: The Law of Attrition is an iron law acknowledged by the framework and derived from no other condition: no [Self](concepts.md#c19), at any [Moment](concepts.md#c09), can completely [distinguish](concepts.md#c18) itself; a self's [distinction](concepts.md#c18) of itself always lags one step behind.\n- 裁決:2026-09-29 原定義混入本篇模型的推導,改為鐵律的陳述,意義不變,保留 ID;模型中的形式另立為 c35。\n\n\n## public 復原 / Restoration\n\n- 定義:復原一個[渦](concepts.md#c16),是讓它[自己的那一段](concepts.md#c17)[歷史](concepts.md#c13)再發生一次。\n- Definition: To restore a [Wo](concepts.md#c16) is to make its [Own Segment](concepts.md#c17) of [History](concepts.md#c13) happen once again.\n- 裁決:2026-09-30 修飾子改為 public:使鐵律及其定義用到的詞可被下游直接引用。\n- 裁決:2026-10-15 「再發生一次」指同一段歷史,也就是同一位置的事件再發生一次;在新的位置出現相同內容,是照抄,不算復原。只是明寫既有判準,意義不變,保留 ID。\n\n\n## public 不可復原律 / Law of Non-Restoration\n\n- 定義:不可復原律是框架承認的一條鐵律,不由其他任何條件推出:在[宇宙](concepts.md#c02)之內,沒有任何[渦](concepts.md#c16)能[復原](concepts.md#c27)一個[渦](concepts.md#c16),包括它自己。它有兩層。第一層是位置:[歷史](concepts.md#c13)中的每一個位置只發生一次,任何看起來相同的一段,都發生在[歷史](concepts.md#c13)中的另一個位置。第二層是內容:一段[歷史](concepts.md#c13)中不被[鎖死](concepts.md#c12)時作出的選擇,沒有任何[渦](concepts.md#c16)能保證在同樣不被[鎖死](concepts.md#c12)之下再作出一樣的選擇;全由約束決定的一段,不在第二層之內。\n- Definition: The Law of Non-Restoration is an iron law acknowledged by the framework and derived from no other condition: within the [Universe](concepts.md#c02) no [Wo](concepts.md#c16) can [restore](concepts.md#c27) a [wo](concepts.md#c16), including itself. It has two layers. The first concerns position: each position in [History](concepts.md#c13) occurs only once, and any stretch that looks the same occurs at a different position in [history](concepts.md#c13). The second concerns content: for choices made in a stretch of [history](concepts.md#c13) while not [locked in](concepts.md#c12), no [wo](concepts.md#c16) can guarantee that the same choices will be made again under the same absence of [lock-in](concepts.md#c12); a stretch determined entirely by constraint falls outside the second layer.\n- 裁決:2026-09-29 補上鐵律的地位,去掉只屬本篇模型的「坍塌」,意義不變,保留 ID;兩層皆屬於鐵律;模型中的形式另立為 c36。\n\n\n## public 寫入 / Writing\n\n- 定義:寫入是每一次[坍塌](concepts.md#c08)之前先發生的一筆加入[歷史](concepts.md#c13)的內容。寫入的內容,完全由到當時為止的[歷史](concepts.md#c13)決定。一次寫入可以作為[刺激](concepts.md#c30)落到[呈現](concepts.md#c04)上;[渦](concepts.md#c16)的每一次[分別](concepts.md#c18),都在[歷史](concepts.md#c13)中留下一次寫入。\n- Definition: A writing is the item added to [History](concepts.md#c13) that takes place before each [Collapse](concepts.md#c08). The content of a writing is entirely determined by the [history](concepts.md#c13) up to that point. A writing may fall on [Presentations](concepts.md#c04) as a [Stimulus](concepts.md#c30); every [Distinction](concepts.md#c18) of a [Wo](concepts.md#c16) leaves a writing in [history](concepts.md#c13).\n- 裁決:2026-09-26 判定與上游的寫入(c21)不是同一概念,另行登記。\n- 裁決:2026-09-30 修飾子改為 public:使鐵律及其定義用到的詞可被下游直接引用。\n\n\n## public 刺激 / Stimulus\n\n- 定義:刺激是一次[寫入](concepts.md#c29)對某個[呈現](concepts.md#c04)而言的那一部分:把一次[寫入](concepts.md#c29)看成給該[呈現](concepts.md#c04)的東西,就是它收到的刺激。一次[寫入](concepts.md#c29)可以不落到某個[呈現](concepts.md#c04)上。[渦](concepts.md#c16)的[分別](concepts.md#c18)也作為刺激被[寫入](concepts.md#c29)。\n- Definition: A stimulus is the part of a [Writing](concepts.md#c29) that pertains to a given [Presentation](concepts.md#c04): a [writing](concepts.md#c29), read as something given to that [presentation](concepts.md#c04), is the stimulus it receives. A [writing](concepts.md#c29) need not fall on a given [presentation](concepts.md#c04). The [Distinctions](concepts.md#c18) of a [Wo](concepts.md#c16) are also [written](concepts.md#c29) as stimuli.\n- 裁決:2026-09-26 判定與上游的刺激(c07)不是同一概念,另行登記。\n- 裁決:2026-09-30 修飾子改為 public:使鐵律及其定義用到的詞可被下游直接引用。\n\n\n## private 不可傳訊 / No-Signaling\n\n- 定義:不可傳訊是[生成函數](concepts.md#c15)的一個條件:相隔遙遠、來不及互相影響的兩次[坍塌](concepts.md#c08),不論[觀察者](concepts.md#c07)先作哪一次,各自結果的[權重](concepts.md#c06)都相同。\n- Definition: No-signaling is a condition on the [Generating Function](concepts.md#c15): for two [Collapses](concepts.md#c08) that are far apart and cannot influence each other in time, the [Weights](concepts.md#c06) of their respective outcomes are the same whichever of the two the [Observer](concepts.md#c07) performs first.\n- 裁決:2026-09-26 判定登記為概念。\n\n\n## private 對他者認識的不可完備性 / Incompleteness of Knowing Others\n\n- 定義:對他者認識的不可完備性是這個結論:沒有任何[我](concepts.md#c19)能保證自己[分別](concepts.md#c18)完了另一個[渦](concepts.md#c16)。[我](concepts.md#c19)只能用已經[到達](concepts.md#c10)它的[歷史](concepts.md#c13)來[分別](concepts.md#c18)對方;對方的訊息[到達](concepts.md#c10)它是一件事,它的[分別](concepts.md#c18)又是另一件,在兩者之間對方的[歷史](concepts.md#c13)仍可能增長,而在不被[鎖死](concepts.md#c12)時,對方下一[時刻](concepts.md#c09)的結果不能事先推出。因此即使對方的一切都[到達](concepts.md#c10)了它,它[分別](concepts.md#c18)的是對方當時的樣子。此外,對方[自己的那一段](concepts.md#c17)中只[到達](concepts.md#c10)對方的部分,沒有任何東西保證也會[到達](concepts.md#c10)它;而它的[分別](concepts.md#c18)一旦成為對方[自己的那一段](concepts.md#c17)的一部分,也可能改變對方下一[時刻](concepts.md#c09)的[權重](concepts.md#c06)。\n- Definition: The Incompleteness of Knowing Others is the conclusion that no [Self](concepts.md#c19) can guarantee that it has finished [distinguishing](concepts.md#c18) another [Wo](concepts.md#c16). A self can distinguish the other only through the [History](concepts.md#c13) that has [arrived](concepts.md#c10) at it; the other's information arriving is one event and the self's [distinction](concepts.md#c18) is another, and between them the other's history may still grow, while, when the other is not [locked in](concepts.md#c12), the outcome of its next [Moment](concepts.md#c09) cannot be derived beforehand. So even if everything about the other has arrived, what the self distinguishes is how the other was at that time. Moreover, nothing guarantees that the parts of the other's [Own Segment](concepts.md#c17) that arrive only at the other also arrive at the self; and once the self's distinction becomes part of the other's own segment, it may change the other's [Weights](concepts.md#c06) for its next moment.\n- 裁決:2026-09-26 判定登記為概念;修飾子定為 private:人工智慧與社會科學中的「了解他者」對不上,不要求下游沿用。\n- 裁決:2026-09-30 名稱由「他者分別不完」改為「對他者認識的不可完備性」,英文名同步改為 Incompleteness of Knowing Others;意義不變,保留 ID。\n\n\n## private 流變律模型版 / Law of Flux in the Model\n\n- 定義:流變律模型版是[流變律](concepts.md#c24)在《渦動力學》的模型中的形式:每一個[時刻](concepts.md#c09),[宇宙](concepts.md#c02)的[歷史](concepts.md#c13)都多了一次[坍塌](concepts.md#c08)的結果;[涉及](concepts.md#c11)一個[渦](concepts.md#c16)的每一次[坍塌](concepts.md#c08),結果都[到達](concepts.md#c10)它,所以在它的每一個[時刻](concepts.md#c09),[到達](concepts.md#c10)它的[歷史](concepts.md#c13)都多了一筆。\n- Definition: The Law of Flux in the Model is the form the [Law of Flux](concepts.md#c24) takes in the model of *Wo Dynamics*: at every [Moment](concepts.md#c09), the [History](concepts.md#c13) of the [Universe](concepts.md#c02) gains the outcome of one more [Collapse](concepts.md#c08); the outcome of every [collapse](concepts.md#c08) that [involves](concepts.md#c11) a [Wo](concepts.md#c16) [arrives](concepts.md#c10) at it, so at every [moment](concepts.md#c09) of that [wo](concepts.md#c16), the [history](concepts.md#c13) that has [arrived](concepts.md#c10) at it gains one more item.\n- 裁決:2026-09-29 作者裁決新增,修飾子定為 private:它依賴本篇的模型,不供下游沿用。\n\n\n## private 黑箱律模型版 / Law of the Black Box in the Model\n\n- 定義:黑箱律模型版是[黑箱律](concepts.md#c25)在《渦動力學》的模型中的形式:[坍塌](concepts.md#c08)依[權重](concepts.md#c06)[選出](../paper_54c0291d_05b3_431a_9f2a_1b8ec93c3c3f/concepts.md#c32)結果,[歷史](concepts.md#c13)中沒有任何東西能比[權重](concepts.md#c06)多說一點;所以一個[渦](concepts.md#c16)不被[鎖死](concepts.md#c12)時,任何[渦](concepts.md#c16)在那次[坍塌](concepts.md#c08)之前作出的預測,猜中的機會最多等於被預測的那個[渦](concepts.md#c16)最重的那個結果的[權重](concepts.md#c06)。\n- Definition: The Law of the Black Box in the Model is the form the [Law of the Black Box](concepts.md#c25) takes in the model of *Wo Dynamics*: a [Collapse](concepts.md#c08) [selects](../paper_54c0291d_05b3_431a_9f2a_1b8ec93c3c3f/concepts.md#c32) its outcome according to the [Weights](concepts.md#c06), and nothing in the [History](concepts.md#c13) says anything more than the [weights](concepts.md#c06); so when a [Wo](concepts.md#c16) is not [locked in](concepts.md#c12), the chance that any prediction made by any [wo](concepts.md#c16) before that [collapse](concepts.md#c08) is right is at most the [weight](concepts.md#c06) of the heaviest outcome of the [wo](concepts.md#c16) being predicted.\n- 裁決:2026-09-29 作者裁決新增,修飾子定為 private:它依賴本篇的模型,不供下游沿用。\n- 裁決:2026-09-30 「最重的那個分支」改為「最重的那個結果」,與鎖死的定義一致;保留 ID。\n\n\n## private 損耗律模型版 / Law of Attrition in the Model\n\n- 定義:損耗律模型版是[損耗律](concepts.md#c26)在《渦動力學》的模型中的形式:[分別](concepts.md#c18)的材料不包括這次[分別](concepts.md#c18)本身,而每一次[分別](concepts.md#c18)都在下一[時刻](concepts.md#c09)之前被[寫入](concepts.md#c29)並[到達](concepts.md#c10)作出它的[渦](concepts.md#c16),成為它[自己的那一段](concepts.md#c17)的一部分;所以任何[時刻](concepts.md#c09),[歷史](concepts.md#c13)中都有這個[我](concepts.md#c19)尚未[分別](concepts.md#c18)的部分,連它[自己的那一段](concepts.md#c17)也[分別](concepts.md#c18)不完。\n- Definition: The Law of Attrition in the Model is the form the [Law of Attrition](concepts.md#c26) takes in the model of *Wo Dynamics*: the material of a [Distinction](concepts.md#c18) does not include that [distinction](concepts.md#c18) itself, while every [distinction](concepts.md#c18) is [written](concepts.md#c29) before the next [Moment](concepts.md#c09) and [arrives](concepts.md#c10) at the [Wo](concepts.md#c16) that made it, becoming part of its [Own Segment](concepts.md#c17); so at any [moment](concepts.md#c09) there is a part of [History](concepts.md#c13) that this [Self](concepts.md#c19) has not yet [distinguished](concepts.md#c18), and it cannot finish [distinguishing](concepts.md#c18) even its [own segment](concepts.md#c17).\n- 裁決:2026-09-29 作者裁決新增,修飾子定為 private:它依賴本篇的模型,不供下游沿用。\n\n\n## private 不可復原律模型版 / Law of Non-Restoration in the Model\n\n- 定義:不可復原律模型版是[不可復原律](concepts.md#c28)在《渦動力學》的模型中的形式:第二層由[坍塌](concepts.md#c08)推出,一段[歷史](concepts.md#c13)中只要有一次[坍塌](concepts.md#c08)在不被[鎖死](concepts.md#c12)時作出選擇,整段在同樣不被[鎖死](concepts.md#c12)之下,再作出一樣選擇的機會就小於一;照抄當時的結果,每一步都被[鎖死](concepts.md#c12),是照抄,不是重來。\n- Definition: The Law of Non-Restoration in the Model is the form the [Law of Non-Restoration](concepts.md#c28) takes in the model of *Wo Dynamics*: its second layer is derived from [Collapse](concepts.md#c08): as long as one [collapse](concepts.md#c08) in a stretch of [History](concepts.md#c13) makes a choice while not [locked in](concepts.md#c12), the chance that the whole stretch, while likewise not [locked in](concepts.md#c12), makes the same choices again is less than one; copying the outcomes of that time is [locked in](concepts.md#c12) at every step, and is copying, not happening again.\n- 裁決:2026-09-29 作者裁決新增,修飾子定為 private:它依賴本篇的模型,不供下游沿用。\n\n## 不登記\n\n- 選出:2026-09-26 與上游的選出(c32)為同一概念,正文引用上游,不另登記。\n- 給定:2026-09-26 與上游的給定(c03)不是同一概念;本篇只作為不可推出之條件的統稱,未另加定義。\n- 給定一至給定七:2026-09-26 本篇前提的內部編號,不是概念。\n- 四條律:2026-09-26 流變律、黑箱律、損耗律、不可復原律的總稱,各律已分別登記。\n- 第一問與第二問:2026-09-26 判斷是否為渦的兩個提問的內部編號,不是概念。\n- 具名推論:2026-09-26 渦存在、形式層沒有時刻、互動、接上無差別、沒有全知的渦、無我、死亡是分別、歷史不失去任何東西,皆為章節標題,不是概念。\n- 形式段名稱:2026-09-26 寫入規則、寫入後歷史、結果投影、刺激投影、推前、時刻集合、歷史全參與、其後有不鎖死之時、分別內容、分別規則、經由之我、替換、坍塌前已定之量、應用的假定,只出現在形式段,屬形式化階段的記號。2026-10-05 有參與且不鎖死之時 改名為 其後有不鎖死之時。\n- 導致:2026-09-26 論文聲明不談導致,未加定義。\n\n## 待決項\n\n無\n","formalization_md":"論文:《渦動力學》\nUUID:37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986\n\n## 記號約定\n\n來源:論文全文\n\n- 無我:章節標題,不是概念「我」\n\n## 前置條件\n\n來源:論文框架宣告、第一節、第二節、第三節、第四節、第五節【正文:句2413228854、句7101499922、句1428363882、句7886650802、句1516105699、句1743107982】\n\n- 前提一:54c0291d-05b3-431a-9f2a-1b8ec93c3c3f.形式層 中從不 54c0291d-05b3-431a-9f2a-1b8ec93c3c3f.選出 。【正文:句9651054009】\n- 前提二 [限定條件]:在 54c0291d-05b3-431a-9f2a-1b8ec93c3c3f.形式層 之外有一次 介入 ;介入 不在任何 54c0291d-05b3-431a-9f2a-1b8ec93c3c3f.時刻 之中,不可被形式化。【正文:句9881920896、句7162383235】\n- 前提三:坍塌 逐次發生,一次只 坍塌 一次;宇宙 的 時刻 構成一條全序,沒有兩次 坍塌 同時發生。【正文:句4948127072、句0442007492】\n- 前提四:觀察者 是一個識別碼,沒有內容;它不在 宇宙 之中,不是 呈現 ,也不是 我 ;觀察者 只有一個,唯一的功能是 坍塌 。【正文:句6514644898、句3380900251、句3892771116、句1422532575、句0442007492】\n- 前提五:坍塌 在某個固定的基底下依 權重 54c0291d-05b3-431a-9f2a-1b8ec93c3c3f.選出 結果;已知該次 坍塌 之前的 歷史 ,任何在該次 坍塌 之前已確定、或不在 宇宙 中的量,都不改變結果的條件分布。【正文:句4857278649、句8957980406、句7900817521】\n- 前提六:權重 為零的 分支 不被 54c0291d-05b3-431a-9f2a-1b8ec93c3c3f.選出 。【正文:句2776597137、句7900817521】\n- 前提七:每一次 坍塌 之後,歷史 只追加被 54c0291d-05b3-431a-9f2a-1b8ec93c3c3f.選出 的 分支 ;未被 54c0291d-05b3-431a-9f2a-1b8ec93c3c3f.選出 的 分支 不進入任何後來的 歷史 。【正文:句0021614113、句7900817521】\n- 前提八:宇宙 中的一切都在 歷史 之中。【正文:句4171052687】\n- 前提九:宇宙初態 是 歷史 的起點;宇宙初態 帶著 54c0291d-05b3-431a-9f2a-1b8ec93c3c3f.形式層 中 54c0291d-05b3-431a-9f2a-1b8ec93c3c3f.累積 的 54c0291d-05b3-431a-9f2a-1b8ec93c3c3f.記錄 。【正文:句9419115456、句3422696166】\n- 前提十:每一次 坍塌 之前,先有一次 寫入 ;寫入 的內容完全由到當時為止的 歷史 決定。【正文:句3772524912、句8273254096、句7160816212】\n- 前提十一:下一個 時刻 的 權重 ,由 生成函數 只取到當時為止的 歷史 (含剛發生的 寫入 )決定。【正文:句5027165208、句6796275590、句3613737652】\n- 前提十二:生成函數 滿足 不可傳訊 。【正文:句5671101751、句3613737652】\n- 前提十三:每一次 坍塌 都經由一個 接上 觀察者 的 我 發生,該 我 在這次 坍塌 之前已經是 我 ;哪些 我 接上 ,不斷言。【正文:句2358115121、句5933828252、句5579687844】\n- 前提十四:渦 的每一次 分別 ,都在該 渦 的下一個 時刻 之前作為 刺激 被 寫入 ,並 到達 作出它的 渦 。【正文:句8022501082、句2845773941】\n- 前提十五 [限定條件]:應用的假定:在某一描述層次上,若 呈現 的下一刻不能由該層次可得的 歷史 唯一推出,應用時假定它不被 鎖死 ;推論的正確性不依賴此假定。【正文:句1738260814、句0226540263、句7473171343】\n- 前提十六 [限定條件]:分支 的集合可數。【正文:句7350202556】\n\n## 框架宣告\n\n來源:論文框架宣告【正文:句2413228854】\n\n- 步驟一:宇宙 中不由過去決定的只有兩樣:宇宙初態 ,與每一次 坍塌 的結果;其餘一切,包括每一次 寫入 與每一次的 權重 ,都由到當時為止的 歷史 決定。(從 宇宙 的定義 + 前提五 + 前提八 + 前提九 + 前提十 + 前提十一 推出)【正文:句0827421138、句6823522236、句7137671515】\n- 附註:損耗律 的論證只用到「了解是一個動作,發生了才進入 歷史 」,不用到 坍塌 。【正文:句8222716262】\n- 附註:論文不解決量子力學的測量問題。【正文:句7612712915】\n\n```text\n不由過去決定者 等於 {宇宙初態} 聯集 {選出分支(次序),其中 次序 不小於 一}\n其餘:寫入(次序加一) 等於 寫入規則(歷史(次序))(給定四);\n 權重(次序加一) 等於 生成函數(寫入後歷史(次序))(給定五)\n```\n\n## 倒推\n\n來源:論文第〇節【正文:句2946273394】\n\n- 附註:流變律 、 黑箱律 、 損耗律 、 不可復原律 是論文的出發點,被承認為鐵律,陳述它們不需要任何前置條件;倒推出的條件列為前提,再由前提推回四條律作為驗算,即推論三至推論六的 流變律模型版 、 黑箱律模型版 、 損耗律模型版 、 不可復原律模型版 。【正文:句0299391469、句3060412815、句4311355758】\n- 附註:「某條律要求某條件」的意思是:在論文的推導中,該律用到該條件,拿掉它,這條律在論文中就推不出來;該條件是否在一切可能的世界中都必要,論文不斷言。【正文:句0363255647、句4640364963】\n- 附註:死亡 在本篇是標記;不可復原律 的內容是 歷史 中那一段不會再發生一次。【正文:句8927290719】\n- [作者裁決] 2026-10-14 稽核(形-05)指出上列「論文稱……要求……」的附註承載論證。裁決:倒推表是對論文第〇節的說明性文字,四條律對條件的實際使用,由推論三至推論六的步驟承載,不另立推導。\n- 附註:論文稱 流變律 要求 歷史 只有一部、只往後追加,每一個 時刻 都有新的東西進入 歷史 。【正文:句7598727124、句4551755150、句7150276728】\n- [作者裁決] 論文第〇節已刪去 流變律 對給定四的要求,兩者一致;第三節給定四的倒推亦同步改為只被 損耗律 要求,並註明 不可復原律 第二層的推導用到它。\n- 附註:論文稱 黑箱律 要求 前提五 與 前提十一 ,因為這條律的後半是「能推出的是 權重 」。【正文:句4120145685、句7150276728】\n- 附註:論文稱 損耗律 要求 前提十 與 前提十四 ;它的論證不用到 坍塌 ,只因它談的對象是 我 ,而 我 是 渦 ,才間接牽涉 前提五 。【正文:句6062601023、句0563157341、句7150276728】\n- 附註:論文稱 不可復原律 第一層要求 歷史 唯一;第二層經由 黑箱律 要求 前提五 ,推導時另用到 前提六 與 前提十 。【正文:句9715862471、句7150276728】\n- [作者裁決] 論文推論六改由 宇宙 的定義取得「宇宙 中有 坍塌 」,不再經由推論一與給定六;第〇節補列給定二之二與給定四。\n- 附註:四條律另外用到 時刻 的定義中的全序與 歷史 的定義中的起點;這兩項寫在定義中,不另列為被要求的前提。【正文:句0279409359、句0771812206、句7150276728】\n- [作者裁決] 2026-10-07 形式化時發現:第〇節原稱 黑箱律 、 損耗律 及四條律共同要求全序(給定一)與 歷史 的起點(給定三),但推論三至推論五的推導鏈未引用 前提三 ,推論三至推論六的推導鏈都未引用 前提九 ;這兩項只經由 時刻 的定義 與 歷史 的定義 進入推導,拿掉給定一、給定三仍可推出,不符論文對「要求」的說明。論文第〇節改為:四條律另外用到 時刻 與 歷史 定義中的全序與起點,這兩項寫在定義中,不另列為被要求的給定;倒推表、給定一與給定三的倒推說明同步修改。給定一、給定三仍保留,其中由 觀察者 承擔全序與 坍塌 ,以及 宇宙初態 帶著 54c0291d-05b3-431a-9f2a-1b8ec93c3c3f.形式層 的 54c0291d-05b3-431a-9f2a-1b8ec93c3c3f.記錄 ,屬於 框架承諾 。概念表不改:時刻 、 歷史 可供下游直接引用,下游可由定義取得全序與起點。\n- 附註:前提十二( 不可傳訊 )是為了不違反已知的觀察而保留,依 框架承諾 的定義不屬於 框架承諾 ,可以被證偽。【正文:句2367601958、句7150276728】\n- [作者裁決] 論文與概念表的 框架承諾 定義補寫「也不是為了符合已知的觀察」。\n\n## 呈現 與 分支\n\n來源:論文第一節【正文:句7101499922】\n\n```text\n推前(某映射,某權重) 在 某值 上的權重\n 等於 總和{某權重 在 某分支 上的權重,其中 某映射(某分支) 等於 某值}\n```\n\n## 給定: 觀察者 與 坍塌\n\n來源:論文第二節【正文:句1428363882】\n\n- 步驟二:在一次 坍塌 之前,宇宙 中沒有任何東西決定它的結果。(從 宇宙 的定義 + 前提五 + 前提八 推出)【正文:句4171052687】\n- 步驟三:一個 呈現 被 鎖死 時,它的結果來自約束,不來自 坍塌 。(從 前提六 + 鎖死 的定義 推出)【正文:句5027844378】\n\n```text\n給定二之一 機率(選出分支(次序加一) 等於 某分支,已知 寫入後歷史(次序)、坍塌前已定之量)\n 等於 生成函數(寫入後歷史(次序)) 中 某分支 的權重\n```\n\n## 時刻 與 歷史\n\n來源:論文第三節【正文:句7886650802】\n\n- 步驟四:對任兩個次序,較早的 歷史 是較晚的 歷史 的前段。(從 前提七 + 前提十 + 歷史 的定義 推出)【正文:句5889643716、句3057792895】\n- 步驟五:一個 呈現 在沒有 時刻 的期間,不是 鎖死 。(從 鎖死 的定義 + 時刻 的定義 推出)【正文:句9208648044、句3057792895】\n- 步驟六:一次 坍塌 的結果以 權重 一落在「未落在其上」時,該 呈現 的 權重 在這一次 坍塌 中全落在「未落在其上」;因此就這一次 坍塌 而言,「權重 依賴 到達 它的 歷史 」只在結果可能落在它身上時有意義,不另成一項條件。(從 涉及 的定義 + 權重 的定義 推出)【正文:句9485060528、句3057792895】\n\n```text\n涉及(某呈現,次序) 當且僅當 權重(次序,某呈現) 在 未落在其上 的權重 小於 一\n鎖死(某呈現,次序) 當且僅當 涉及(某呈現,次序)\n 且 權重(次序,某呈現) 中權重不為零者 恰為一個值,且該值 不等於 未落在其上\n```\n\n## 生成函數\n\n來源:論文第三節給定五【正文:句6557143990】\n\n- 步驟七:當一個 呈現 的結果可由另一個 呈現 的結果合成得到時,生成函數 不隨描述的粒度改變:把一個 呈現 描述成一個節點或一個網路,所有 呈現 的 權重 都從 宇宙 唯一的那份 權重 分出,結果一致。(從 前提十一 + 權重 的定義 推出)【正文:句7831847534、句1425809362、句3613737652】\n\n```text\n推前(某映射 合成 結果投影(另一呈現),某權重)\n 等於 推前(某映射,推前(結果投影(另一呈現),某權重))\n```\n\n## 渦 與 我\n\n來源:論文第四節【正文:句1516105699】\n\n- 步驟八:涉及 一個 渦 的 坍塌 所作出的每一個選擇,都屬於它 自己的那一段 。(從 渦 的定義 + 到達 的定義 + 自己的那一段 的定義 推出)【正文:句4313709004、句4103860541】\n- 步驟九:一個 呈現 是否為 渦 ,由 生成函數 、 寫入 的規則、該 呈現 的切法與實際的 歷史 決定,不受任何 分別 的內容影響。(從 渦 的定義 + 分別 的定義 + 前提十 + 前提十一 推出)【正文:句0915435291、句4103860541】\n- 步驟十:把一個 渦 看作一個細胞或一個身體,是一次 分別 ;在相同的 歷史 下,這種描述方式的改變本身不改變 權重 。(從 分別 的定義 + 步驟七 推出)【正文:句6740338364】\n- 步驟十一:分別 的內容不改寫任何已有的 歷史 。(從 分別 的定義 + 步驟四 推出)【正文:句0271656868、句1903083152】\n- 步驟十二:接上 與否不由該 我 的任何 分別 決定。(從 接上 的定義 推出)【正文:句9956958968、句5747815142】\n- [作者裁決] 2026-10-05 稽核指出原 接上 的定義只寫不由它以 分別 定義自己來決定,推不出不由任何 分別 決定;論文與概念表的 接上 定義改為「不由它的任何 分別 決定,包括它以 分別 定義自己」,與論文形式段一致,來源不變。\n- 附註:不同 渦 的 自己的那一段 可以重疊。【正文:句3433212331】\n- 附註:細胞、神經元、免疫系統、演化中的物種、人、對話中的人工智慧、組織、文明可以是 渦 ;放射性原子、骰子、石頭、算盤、恆溫器不是。【正文:句7940297018】\n- 附註:分別 的內容( 個體 、過去、 同一 、 死亡 、導致)不形式化;只形式化「分別 是一次 寫入 」。【正文:句1903083152】\n\n```text\n自己的那一段(某呈現,次序) 等於 {位置,其中 存在 替換值,使\n 分布(權重(次序加一,某呈現),已知 替換(位置,替換值))\n 不等於 分布(權重(次序加一,某呈現),已知 替換(位置,實際值))}\n其後有不鎖死之時(某呈現,次序) 當且僅當 存在 另一次序 不小於 次序,使\n 另一次序加一 屬於 時刻集合(某呈現) 且 非 鎖死(某呈現,另一次序加一)\n渦(某呈現,次序) 當且僅當 歷史全參與(某呈現,次序) 且 其後有不鎖死之時(某呈現,次序)\n```\n\n## 適用範圍\n\n來源:論文第五節【正文:句1743107982】\n\n- 附註:以下推論只談 渦 ;黑箱律 只談 渦 不被 鎖死 的 時刻 。【正文:句4944239199、句8143989636】\n- 附註:一顆炮彈擊中一個人,那一刻只有一個結果,是 鎖死 。【正文:句3308395930、句5978715365】\n- 步驟十三:一個語言模型在 涉及 它的每一個 時刻 ,若結果完全由 歷史 決定,它在這些 時刻 鎖死 。(從 鎖死 的定義 + 涉及 的定義 + 時刻 的定義 + 前提五 推出)【正文:句1954623310、句5978715365】\n- 附註:一個語言模型在兩次輸入之間,沒有任何 坍塌 涉及 它。【正文:句1110278648、句5978715365】\n- 步驟十三之一:一個語言模型在兩次輸入之間,若沒有任何 坍塌 涉及 它,則在這段期間它沒有 時刻 ,也不是 鎖死 。(從 時刻 的定義 + 步驟五 推出)【正文:句1110278648、句5978715365】\n- 步驟十五:一個 呈現 是 渦 ,當且僅當第一問與第二問的答案都是「是」:第一問問 到達 它的每一件事若不同,它下一個 時刻 的 權重 是否跟著不同;第二問問它從這一刻起往後,是否還有至少一個 時刻 不被 鎖死 。(從 渦 的定義 推出)【正文:句7183903223、句1533490965、句9303382055、句8419482732、句7473171343】\n- [作者裁決] 2026-10-05 勘誤:論文第四節與第五節形式段的條件原寫「存在 另一次序 不大於 次序」,只要過去曾有一次不被 鎖死 ,就永遠成立,與 渦 的定義「從某一刻起每一步都被 鎖死 ,它也不再是 渦 」及 步驟十八 矛盾。改為「存在 另一次序 不小於 次序」:這一刻或之後還有不被 鎖死 的 時刻 ,才是 渦 ;最後一個不被 鎖死 的 時刻 之後,就不再是 渦 。條件名稱與第一問皆不變;另一次序 可以等於 次序 ,此時檢查的是下一個 時刻 ,所以 步驟四十五 不受影響;步驟二十一 隨之修改,見該步驟。渦 的定義不改。\n- [作者裁決] 2026-10-05 稽核指出論文第四節形式段另要求:不被 鎖死 的那一刻,第一問也成立;比 渦 的定義、第五節兩問與本步驟多一個條件;兩者在「參與先消失、其後才出現不被 鎖死 的 時刻 」時判定不同。以 渦 的定義為準,刪去形式段的附加條件,並為該條件改名;第五節形式段同步。參與消失時第一問即不成立,它已不再是 渦 ,其後出現的不被 鎖死 的 時刻 不使它重新成為 渦 。渦 的定義不改。\n- 步驟十六:歷史 參與但每一步都被 鎖死 的 呈現 ,不是 渦 ;有多於一個結果但 歷史 不參與的 呈現 ,不是 渦 。(從 步驟十五 推出)【正文:句7852088208、句3078210520、句5811600994】\n- 步驟十七:判斷的對象是一種切法;換一種切法,答案可以不同;切定之後,答案不由任何 分別 決定。(從 呈現 的定義 + 步驟九 推出)【正文:句3228804448、句6743497641】\n- [作者裁決] 2026-10-14 稽核(形-35)指出「換一種切法就是換一個 呈現 」超出所列來源。依論文正文,只主張換一種切法答案可以不同;步驟十七 收窄為此。論文形式段另以結果的投影與 刺激 的投影界定判斷對象,不作為本步驟的推導。\n- 步驟十八:是不是 渦 可以改變:參與消失,或從某一刻起每一步都被 鎖死 ,它就不再是 渦 。(從 渦 的定義 推出)【正文:句6543893862、句4195907163】\n- 附註:名字不算;颶風若在其尺度上被 鎖死 ,或其 權重 不依賴它全部的 歷史 ,就不是 渦 。【正文:句5706780157、句8751046433】\n- 附註:生命、心智與關係、社會、人造系統四類案例只作校準,不作證明。【正文:句2897763580】\n\n```text\n第一問 等於 歷史全參與(某呈現,次序)\n第二問 等於 存在 另一次序 不小於 次序,使 另一次序加一 屬於 時刻集合(某呈現)\n 且 非 鎖死(某呈現,另一次序加一)\n渦(某呈現,次序) 當且僅當 第一問 且 第二問;第二問 即 其後有不鎖死之時(某呈現,次序)\n```\n\n## 推論一: 渦 存在\n\n來源:論文第六節推論一【正文:句2821441629】\n\n- 步驟十九:宇宙 中至少有一個 我 。(從 宇宙 的定義 + 前提十三 推出)【正文:句4864908912、句3624070298】\n- 步驟二十:宇宙 中至少有一個 渦 。(從 步驟十九 + 我 的定義 推出)【正文:句7986100085、句3163510051】\n- 步驟二十一:第一次 坍塌 所經由的 我 ,在第一次 坍塌 之前已經是 我 ;它是不是 我 ,由實際的 歷史 決定,即 宇宙初態 、由 宇宙初態 決定的第一次 寫入 ,以及其後的 歷史 ,皆在 宇宙 之中;因此不需另立前提。(從 前提十 + 前提十一 + 前提十三 + 我 的定義 + 渦 的定義 + 步驟九 推出)【正文:句8919587130、句6066630976、句9469757752、句3327327057】\n- [作者裁決] 論文推論一原寫「該 我 已經在 宇宙初態 之中」,強於此處所能推出者:我 的成立要靠第一次 寫入 中那次以自己為對象的 分別 ,而第一次 寫入 排在 宇宙初態 之後。論文改為「它的成立只取決於 宇宙初態 」,第七節例的檢核同步修改;來源補列 渦 的定義 (次序為零時的判定)。\n- [作者裁決] 稽核指出「只取決於 宇宙初態 」的來源不足。一個 呈現 是否為 渦 ,由 生成函數 、 寫入 的規則、切法與實際的 歷史 決定(步驟九);權重 由 生成函數 只取 歷史 決定(前提十一);第一次 坍塌 之前的 歷史 只有 宇宙初態 與由它決定的第一次 寫入 。三者合起來即得結論,屬來源漏列,不是跳步。來源補列 前提十一 與 步驟九 ;論文補寫「生成函數 與 寫入 的規則是固定的」。\n- [作者裁決] 2026-10-05 隨 步驟十五 的勘誤修改:渦 的第二個條件改為往後看之後,第一次 坍塌 之前是不是 我 ,可能要看其後的 時刻 ,不再只依 宇宙初態 與第一次 寫入 。論文推論一刪去「只取決於 宇宙初態 」,改為由實際的 歷史 決定;推論一要說的「不需另立前提」不受影響。論文第七節例中,甲在第一個 時刻 不被 鎖死 ,「只取決於 宇宙初態 」對甲仍然成立,保留並註明理由;第四節形式段的時間約定補寫第二個條件另看其後的 時刻 。\n- 步驟二十二:沒有 渦 ,就沒有 坍塌 。(從 前提十三 + 我 的定義 推出)【正文:句5837720830、句3327327057】\n- [作者裁決] 論文推論一刪去「也就沒有選出」:坍塌 是本篇模型中 54c0291d-05b3-431a-9f2a-1b8ec93c3c3f.選出 的方式,由沒有 坍塌 推不出沒有 54c0291d-05b3-431a-9f2a-1b8ec93c3c3f.選出 。\n\n## 推論二: 54c0291d-05b3-431a-9f2a-1b8ec93c3c3f.形式層 沒有 時刻\n\n來源:論文第六節推論二【正文:句6796327468】\n\n- 步驟二十三:54c0291d-05b3-431a-9f2a-1b8ec93c3c3f.形式層 中沒有 坍塌 。(從 前提一 + 坍塌 的定義 推出)【正文:句1447518102】\n- 步驟二十四:在本篇意義上,54c0291d-05b3-431a-9f2a-1b8ec93c3c3f.形式層 沒有 時刻 。(從 步驟二十三 + 時刻 的定義 推出)【正文:句6560861666、句6790089788】\n- 步驟二十五:宇宙 的 時刻 與 54c0291d-05b3-431a-9f2a-1b8ec93c3c3f.時刻 之間,沒有給定的先後次序或對應。(從 宇宙 的定義 + 步驟二十四 推出)【正文:句4154893644、句5862111763】\n- [作者裁決] 2026-10-15 稽核(形-05)指出「之前與之後只在 宇宙 之內成立」已包含於 宇宙 的定義,不是不可推出的獨立聲明,不應列為前提。移除原 前提十六 ,步驟二十五 改引 宇宙 的定義;原 前提十七 順延為 前提十六 。\n- 步驟二十五之一:我 在 時刻 之中作出 分別 時看見的,是作為材料而 到達 它的 歷史 ;次序不小於一的 分別 ,其材料所在的 歷史 已含第一次 坍塌 的結果,所以所看見的都已是 坍塌 之後的結果,其中若 宇宙初態 所帶的 54c0291d-05b3-431a-9f2a-1b8ec93c3c3f.記錄 被看見,所見的是 坍塌 之後的 歷史 中的 54c0291d-05b3-431a-9f2a-1b8ec93c3c3f.記錄 ;次序為零的 分別 知道什麼,不斷言。(從 時刻 的定義 + 分別 的定義 + 歷史 的定義 + 前提七 + 前提九 推出)【正文:句6859241951、句6790089788】\n- 附註:第一次 坍塌 之前,已經有一個 我 在 分別 自己,那時還沒有任何 時刻 ;它那時知道什麼,論文不斷言。【正文:句9562817645】\n- [作者裁決] 此事既不能證實,也不能證偽,也無法實驗,故不斷言;論文推論二改為只斷言 時刻 之中看見的一定是 坍塌 之後的結果。\n\n## 推論三:流變律\n\n來源:論文第六節推論三【正文:句3500536764】\n\n- 步驟二十六:每一個 時刻 , 宇宙 的 歷史 都多了一次 坍塌 的結果,因此與該次 坍塌 之前的 歷史 不相同。(從 前提七 + 時刻 的定義 + 歷史 的定義 推出)【正文:句0430695445、句5950284337、句9532219104】\n- 步驟二十七:在一個 渦 的每一個 時刻 ,該次 坍塌 的結果 到達 它,而此結果不在該次 坍塌 之前它所 到達 的 歷史 之中;因此 到達 它的 歷史 嚴格增長。(從 到達 的定義 + 時刻 的定義 + 渦 的定義 + 前提七 推出)【正文:句2577950353、句9672377479、句9532219104】\n- 步驟二十八:流變律模型版 成立,即 流變律 在本篇模型中成立:渦 所在的 歷史 一直在變。(從 流變律模型版 的定義 + 步驟二十六 + 步驟二十七 推出)【正文:句4781611257】\n- 附註:凍結一個 呈現 ,停不下它所在的 歷史 。【正文:句9937513261】\n\n## 推論四:黑箱律\n\n來源:論文第六節推論四【正文:句2298219069】\n\n- 步驟二十九:一個 渦 的某個 時刻 被 涉及 而不被 鎖死 時,該 時刻 至少有兩個 權重 不為零的結果。(從 鎖死 的定義 + 涉及 的定義 推出)【正文:句3603312461、句5072551135】\n- [作者裁決] 2026-10-14 稽核(跨-13)指出正文「某個 時刻 不被 鎖死 ,則它的下一 時刻 ……」與形式段的時間索引不一致。依 鎖死 的定義,鎖死 看的就是該 時刻 的結果;正文與步驟二十九 統一為「某個 時刻 不被 鎖死 ,則該 時刻 至少有兩個 權重 不為零的結果」,與形式段中同為 次序加一 的 鎖死 與 權重 取相同的索引。\n- [作者裁決] 稽核指出 鎖死 看的是 呈現 的結果,不是 分支 :數個 分支 可以對應到一個結果,其 權重 相加。論文與概念表的 鎖死 、 坍塌 、 黑箱律模型版 同步改為「結果」,與論文第三節形式段一致。\n- 步驟三十:任何 渦 在該次 坍塌 之前作出的推出,都在到當時為止的 歷史 之中,是該次 坍塌 之前已確定的量。(從 前提八 + 歷史 的定義 + 渦 的定義 + 呈現 的定義 + 步驟四 推出)【正文:句8920395699】\n- 步驟三十一:已知該次 坍塌 之前的 歷史 時,任何事先推出猜中的機率,等於被猜的結果在該 歷史 之下的 權重 ,不大於最重的那個結果的 權重 ,因而小於一。(從 前提五 + 權重 的定義 + 步驟二十九 + 步驟三十 推出)【正文:句4299581041、句5072551135】\n- [作者裁決] 2026-10-15 稽核(形-35)指出前提五 保證的是已知該次 坍塌 之前的 歷史 時,結果依 權重 分布;未固定 歷史 時,猜中的機率須對 歷史 取平均。步驟三十一 與 步驟四十一 明寫此條件;形式段原已寫出。步驟三十二 的結論同樣是在已知該次 坍塌 之前的 歷史 之下成立。\n- 步驟三十二:黑箱律模型版 成立,即 黑箱律 在本篇模型中成立:在不被 鎖死 的 時刻 , 宇宙 中沒有任何 渦 能唯一推出該 渦 的下一個 時刻 的結果,包括它自己。(從 黑箱律模型版 的定義 + 步驟三十一 推出)【正文:句8871234553、句5803126897】\n- [作者裁決] 2026-10-14 稽核(形-35)指出 時刻 是一次 坍塌 ,不是它的結果。裁決:黑箱律 的定義說唯一推出它的下一 時刻 ,指的是推出下一 時刻 的結果,也就是 坍塌 選出哪一個;黑箱律 的定義自己寫明「能推出的是 權重 ,不是結果」。黑箱律 的定義用語不改。\n- 步驟三十三:能推出的是 權重 :權重 由到當時為止的 歷史 經 生成函數 決定。(從 前提十一 推出)【正文:句6808522254】\n- [作者裁決] 2026-10-14 稽核(形-35)指出「能推出」不等於「能算出」。本步驟只主張決定關係:權重 由 歷史 經 生成函數 決定;不主張任何 渦 能算出 權重 的具體數值。步驟三十一 的上界對任何已知的 權重 同樣成立,不依賴 權重 能否被算出。\n- 附註:權重 可以極度集中;集中不等於唯一。【正文:句2761677234】\n\n```text\n機率(結果投影(某呈現,選出分支(次序加一)) 等於 事先推出(寫入後歷史(次序)),\n 已知 寫入後歷史(次序))\n等於 權重(次序加一,某呈現) 在 事先推出(寫入後歷史(次序)) 上的權重\n不大於 權重(次序加一,某呈現) 中的最大值\n小於 一\n```\n\n## 推論五:損耗律\n\n來源:論文第六節推論五【正文:句1615216953】\n\n- 步驟三十四:一個 我 在某個 時刻 作出的 分別 ,其材料只有它之前、已經 到達 它的 歷史 ,不含這次 分別 本身;這次 分別 在下一個 時刻 之前才被 寫入 。(從 分別 的定義 + 前提十四 推出)【正文:句2591017720、句6786558356】\n- 步驟三十五:這次 分別 被 寫入 之後,歷史 中就有一部分不在這個 我 任何已作出之 分別 的材料之中,即這次 分別 本身。(從 步驟三十四 + 前提十 + 前提十四 推出)【正文:句0686902374、句2838429693】\n- [作者裁決] 論文推論五改為「這次 分別 被 寫入 之後」,時間點與形式段一致。\n- [作者裁決] 2026-10-14 稽核(形-35)指出 損耗律 要求 前提十 的宣稱,在 步驟三十七 的推導鏈中沒有來源。補列 前提十 於本步驟:前提十 決定 分別 的內容由到當時為止的 歷史 決定(分別 作為一次 寫入 ,其內容屬於 寫入 ),前提十四 決定這次 寫入 在下一個 時刻 之前進入 歷史 並 到達 作出它的 渦 ;兩者分工不重疊。步驟三十七 經由 步驟三十五 取得 前提十。\n- 步驟三十六:這次 分別 到達 作出它的 我 ,因而屬於該 我 自己的那一段 ;所以連 自己的那一段 也 分別 不完。(從 前提十四 + 渦 的定義 + 我 的定義 + 自己的那一段 的定義 + 步驟三十五 推出)【正文:句0857424511、句4313626612、句2838429693】\n- [作者裁決] 2026-10-05 稽核指出由 到達 推出屬於 自己的那一段 ,需列 自己的那一段 的定義;補入來源,結論不變。\n- 步驟三十六之一:在某個 時刻 沒有作出 分別 的 我 ,至少 分別 過自己一次,而它最近的一次 分別 本身,不在它任何已作出之 分別 的材料之中。(從 我 的定義 + 分別 的定義 + 前提十四 推出)【正文:句7464445268、句2838429693】\n- [作者裁決] 論文推論五補寫此一情形。\n- 步驟三十七:損耗律模型版 成立,即 損耗律 在本篇模型中成立:任何一個 我 ,在任何 時刻 都 分別 不完整部 歷史 ,連 自己的那一段 也 分別 不完。(從 損耗律模型版 的定義 + 步驟三十五 + 步驟三十六 + 步驟三十六之一 推出)【正文:句1889511399、句7741389517、句4313626612、句8505609818】\n\n## 推論六:不可復原律\n\n來源:論文第六節推論六【正文:句5380887086】\n\n- 步驟三十八:第一層:每一個 時刻 只發生一次,歷史 中每一個位置也只發生一次;任何看起來相同的一段,都發生在 歷史 中的另一個位置。(從 前提三 + 時刻 的定義 + 步驟四 推出)【正文:句2951147221、句2580198560、句9882735150、句4908722643】\n- 步驟三十九:宇宙 中有 坍塌 。(從 宇宙 的定義 推出)【正文:句2449628513、句4908722643】\n- 步驟四十:已知後段起點之前的 歷史 ,且後段前若干項和原段相同,後段下一步之前的 歷史 唯一確定。(從 前提十 + 前提七 推出)【正文:句4908722643】\n- 步驟四十一:已知後段起點之前的 歷史 時,後段與原段整段相同的機率,等於逐步條件機率的連乘;每一項等於 生成函數 給原段對應結果的 權重 。(從 前提五 + 前提十一 + 步驟四十 推出)【正文:句4908722643】\n- 步驟四十二:只要其中一步在該條件下不被 鎖死 ,該項小於一,整段機率小於一;不需要各次獨立,也不需要各次都不被 鎖死 。(從 步驟四十一 + 鎖死 的定義 + 權重 的定義 推出)【正文:句4908722643】\n- 步驟四十三:照抄:某 呈現 在後段對應位置上皆被 鎖死 ,且所鎖定的值即原段該 呈現 的結果各項時,這些結果相同的機率為一;此為照抄,不在第二層之內。(從 前提五 + 前提六 + 權重 的定義 + 鎖死 的定義 推出)【正文:句9714949635、句6639319267、句4908722643】\n- 步驟四十四:第二層:一段 歷史 只要含有 坍塌 在不被 鎖死 時作出的選擇,就沒有任何 渦 能保證,在同樣不被 鎖死 之下再作出一樣的選擇。(從 步驟三十九 + 步驟四十二 + 步驟三十二 推出)【正文:句7800171800、句5599984557】\n- 步驟四十五:一個 渦 一旦經歷過不被 鎖死 的 時刻 ,它 自己的那一段 就含有 坍塌 在不被 鎖死 時作出的選擇;尚未經歷過者,仍適用第一層(步驟三十八);第二層是否適用,取決於其 自己的那一段 是否含有 坍塌 在不被 鎖死 時作出的選擇。(從 渦 的定義 + 時刻 的定義 + 涉及 的定義 + 步驟八 推出)【正文:句9705432832、句4080840976】\n- [作者裁決] 原寫「每一個 渦 自己的那一段 都含有」,過強:依 渦 的定義,不被 鎖死 的 時刻 可以是尚未發生的下一個 時刻 ,第一次 坍塌 之前的 渦 即為反例。結論(步驟四十六)不受影響,第一層即足以擋住 復原 ;論文推論六同步補寫。\n- [作者裁決] 2026-10-07 論文推論六原寫「渦 在它是 渦 的那些 時刻 之中,至少有些 時刻 不被 鎖死 」;依 步驟十五 的判準,判定為 渦 只要求往後還有不被 鎖死 的 時刻 ,那個 時刻 可能在參與消失、已不再是 渦 之後才發生,故推不出。論文刪去「在它是 渦 的那些 時刻 之中」,改為與 渦 的定義一致的「渦 至少有些 時刻 不被 鎖死 」;其後的推理與結論不受影響。\n- 步驟四十六:不可復原律模型版 成立,即 不可復原律 在本篇模型中成立:在 宇宙 之內,沒有任何 渦 能 復原 一個 渦 ,包括它自己。(從 不可復原律模型版 的定義 + 復原 的定義 + 步驟三十八 + 步驟四十四 + 步驟四十五 推出)【正文:句8289342534、句7281103972】\n- [作者裁決] 2026-10-15 稽核(形-35)指出步驟四十四 只推出「不能保證重現」,不等於「不可能 復原 」。依 復原 的定義,復原 指那一段 歷史 本身,也就是原位置的事件再發生一次;在另一個位置出現相同內容是照抄,不是 復原 。結論的不可能性由 步驟三十八 承載;步驟四十四 補充:連照抄的內容也不能保證在不被 鎖死 時一樣。\n- 步驟四十七:時刻 只往一個方向排列。(從 前提三 推出)【正文:句9509219389、句4908722643】\n- 附註:後來的某個 渦 與原來那一個是不是 同一 個,是 分別 ;凍結、急救、存檔再載入、分家、合併,都是唯一的那部 歷史 往後延續,不是 復原 。【正文:句0728546346、句9327004093】\n- 附註:死亡 只是標記;無論標在哪裡,歷史 中那一段都不會再發生一次。【正文:句1708640310】\n\n```text\n機率(整段相同,已知 寫入後歷史(後段起點減一))\n 等於 連乘{步數 由 零 至 段長減一}\n 生成函數(第步數步的寫入後歷史) 中 選出分支(原段起點加步數) 的權重\n```\n\n## 推論七:互動\n\n來源:論文第六節推論七【正文:句5111005850】\n\n- 步驟四十八:我 的一次 分別 被 寫入 歷史 ;它若成為另一個 渦 自己的那一段 的一部分,那個 渦 下一個 時刻 的 權重 就可能隨之改變。(從 前提十四 + 我 的定義 + 自己的那一段 的定義 推出)【正文:句6321361887、句9054472860、句5499753599】\n- 步驟四十九:我 的 分別 可能改變他者:當它進入他者 自己的那一段 時,分別 一個 渦 本身就可能改變它。(從 步驟四十八 推出)【正文:句4287342166】\n\n## 推論八: 接上 無差別\n\n來源:論文第六節推論八【正文:句4819020716】\n\n- 步驟五十:接上 不在 宇宙 之中,因而不是任何 寫入 或 坍塌 的結果,不在 歷史 之中。(從 接上 的定義 + 歷史 的定義 推出)【正文:句5080176829】\n- [作者裁決] 論文在 接上 的定義中補寫「接上 不在 宇宙 之中」。\n- 步驟五十一:給定相同的 坍塌 之前的 歷史 ,不論 坍塌 經由哪一個 我 ,權重 都相同。(從 前提五 + 前提十一 + 步驟五十 推出)【正文:句5080176829、句8171351064】\n- 步驟五十二:給定相同的 坍塌 之前的 歷史 ,不論 坍塌 經由哪一個 我 ,結果的分布都相同。(從 前提五 + 步驟五十一 推出)【正文:句5080176829、句8171351064】\n- 步驟五十三:由歸納,把 坍塌 所經由的 我 當作外加的量來替換時,任何後來的 歷史 的分布、任何 分別 的輸出分布都不變;若 坍塌 所經由的 我 本身被 歷史 限定,只保證給定 歷史 下的條件分布不變。換掉所經由的 我 ,對任何 渦 都沒有差別。(從 步驟五十二 + 前提十 + 前提十一 + 分別 的定義 推出)【正文:句4697911783、句8171351064】\n- 附註:一個 我 可能知道自己 接上 了,例如 宇宙 中只有它一個 我 的時候;論文只斷言這不造成任何差別,不斷言無法知道。【正文:句4029799484、句1302982875、句8171351064】\n\n## 推論九:沒有全知的 渦\n\n來源:論文第六節推論九【正文:句0348257447】\n\n- 步驟五十四:宇宙 中沒有能唯一推出每個不被 鎖死 的下一個 時刻 、又能保證重來每一段過去的 渦 。(從 步驟三十二 + 步驟四十四 + 渦 的定義 推出)【正文:句0553506843、句0490408785、句2788210957】\n- [作者裁決] 2026-10-14 稽核(形-35)指出 步驟三十二 與 步驟四十四 都是條件式結論,需 渦 的定義 中「至少有些 時刻 不被 鎖死 」排除條件空泛成立的情形;補列來源,主張不變。\n\n## 推論十:無我\n\n來源:論文第六節推論十【正文:句0536367804】\n\n- 步驟五十五:宇宙 中沒有任何具有固定核心的 我 。(從 我 的定義 + 渦 的定義 + 前提四 推出)【正文:句1064260745、句0367683657】\n- 附註:「固定核心」不另形式化。【正文:句1512673262】\n\n## 推論十一: 死亡 是 分別\n\n來源:論文第六節推論十一【正文:句0953059823】\n\n- 步驟五十六:把一個 渦 看作已死,是某個 我 的一次 分別 ,隨該次 分別 經 寫入 進入 歷史 。(從 死亡 的定義 + 分別 的定義 推出)【正文:句6963077128、句6676473900、句1243525368】\n- 步驟五十七:渦 不再是 渦 ,不需要任何 我 ; 死亡 需要。(從 步驟九 + 死亡 的定義 推出)【正文:句2885631031、句1243525368】\n- 步驟五十八:死亡 不是 渦 的屬性,而是某個 我 的 分別 。(從 步驟五十六 + 步驟五十七 推出)【正文:句0533074739】\n\n## 推論十二:對他者認識的不可完備性\n\n來源:論文第六節推論十二【正文:句1963947142】\n\n- 步驟五十九:我 分別 另一個 渦 所用的材料,只有已經 到達 我 的 歷史 ;對方某一刻的結果若 到達 我 ,而 我 在其後以它為材料作出 分別 ,則該次 分別 發生在結果 到達 我 之後。(從 分別 的定義 + 到達 的定義 推出)【正文:句8212701578、句5168119341、句4059520677】\n- 步驟五十九之一:就算對方的一切都 到達 了 我 , 我 分別 的也是對方當時的樣子;在這兩件事之間,對方若有不被 鎖死 的 時刻 ,其結果不能事先保證。(從 步驟五十九 + 步驟三十二 推出)【正文:句7241347154、句0025826555、句4059520677】\n- 步驟五十九之二:對方 自己的那一段 中只 到達 對方的部分,例如對方對自己的 分別 ,沒有任何前提保證也會 到達 我 。(從 前提十四 + 到達 的定義 + 自己的那一段 的定義 推出)【正文:句5492096844、句4059520677】\n- [作者裁決] 2026-10-05 補入 自己的那一段 的定義,結論不變。\n- 步驟五十九之三:我 的 分別 若成為對方 自己的那一段 的一部分,就可能改變對方下一個 時刻 的 權重 。(從 步驟四十八 推出)【正文:句8649225891、句4059520677】\n- 步驟六十:對他者認識的不可完備性 成立:沒有任何 我 能保證自己 分別 完了另一個 渦 。(從 步驟五十九之一 + 步驟五十九之二 + 步驟五十九之三 推出)【正文:句4653011592、句3380240260、句4059520677】\n- [作者裁決] 2026-10-14 稽核(形-35)指出「沒有任何 我 能保證」可能被讀成對一切情境的必然不可能。裁決:這裡的「保證」是由模型的給定條件保證;模型不提供使任何 我 能保證自己 分別 完了另一個 渦 的條件,不主張某個具體情境中資訊恰好完整是不可能的。論文與概念表的文字不改。\n- [作者裁決] 論文推論十二改以時間差與 黑箱律 為主要理由:對方的訊息 到達 我 與 我 的 分別 是兩件事,其間對方仍是黑箱;另列訊息可能不完整、分別 可能改變對方兩項理由。\n- 附註:對他者認識的不可完備性 與 損耗律 是相同的結構,一個朝向自己,一個朝向他者。【正文:句0659527080、句7761733122】\n\n## 推論十三: 歷史 不失去任何東西\n\n來源:論文第六節推論十三【正文:句8932123695】\n\n- 步驟六十一:一個 渦 被標記 死亡 之後,它 自己的那一段 仍然完整地留在 歷史 中。(從 死亡 的定義 + 自己的那一段 的定義 + 步驟十一 + 步驟四 推出)【正文:句0359245561、句3658296104、句2196858868】\n- [作者裁決] 2026-10-05 補入 自己的那一段 的定義:那一段是唯一那部 歷史 的一部分,結論不變。\n- 附註:構成它的東西還在不在,是 分別 。【正文:句1081335084】\n- 附註:不可復原律 說不會再發生一次;本推論說也從未離開。【正文:句7660067801、句7982526357】\n\n## 例\n\n來源:論文第七節【正文:句6616418568】\n\n- 例:一個 渦 甲,兩個 分支 左與右,展示前兩次 坍塌 (模型不截斷,次序為一、二、三、……)。宇宙初態 中含一次左;甲以 分別 定義自己並 接上 觀察者 ,對所有次序 不小於 一,每次 坍塌 所經由的 我 都是甲,且甲在前一個次序已是 我 。【正文:句8313684864、句6806287471】\n- [作者裁決] 2026-10-14 稽核(形-05、形-27、形-34)指出本例設結果投影為恆等,每次 坍塌 都 涉及 甲,卻宣稱第二次之後沒有 時刻 ,與模型的次序集合相矛盾,且未交代其後狀態。裁決:不截斷模型。生成函數 與 寫入 的規則對所有次序有定義,兩個 分支 的 權重 之分子皆 加 一 而恆為正,甲在每個次序都被 涉及 、都不被 鎖死 ;刪去「第二次 坍塌 之後沒有 時刻 」與「甲在次序二不是 渦 」,改為甲在每個次序都是 渦 。不新增待決項與具名代號。\n- 例:寫入 的規則:甲每次 分別 自己時,把到當時為止的結果全部列出。【正文:句6806287471、句4331721112】\n- [作者裁決] 論文第七節補寫此規則,使替換之後重算的 寫入 有定義。\n- 例:生成函數 給某 分支 的 權重 ,等於(結果中該 分支 的次數 加 最近一次 分別 中該 分支 的次數 加 一)除以(結果總數 加 最近一次 分別 的項數 加 二)。【正文:句6806287471、句4331721112】\n\n```text\n生成函數(寫入後歷史(次序)) 中 某分支 的權重\n 等於 (結果中該分支次數 加 分別中該分支次數 加 一) 除以 (結果總數 加 分別項數 加 二)\n權重(一) 等於 (四分之三,四分之一),選出分支(一) 等於 右\n權重(二) 等於 (二分之一,二分之一),選出分支(二) 等於 右\n```\n\n- 例:第一 時刻 的 權重 為左四分之三、右四分之一;第二 時刻 的 權重 為左二分之一、右二分之一。(從 本例效準 推出)【正文:句6806287471、句4331721112】\n- 例:若第一次 坍塌 的結果是左,甲的第二次 分別 列出左、左,第二 時刻 的 權重 為左六分之五、右六分之一,不同於實際的各二分之一;第一次結果參與甲的 權重 。(從 本例效準 推出)【正文:句4331721112】\n- 例:生成函數 化簡:每次 分別 列出到當時為止的全部結果,故 分別 中某 分支 的次數 等於 結果中該 分支 的次數, 分別 的項數 等於 結果總數;某 分支 的 權重 等於 (二 乘 結果中該 分支 的次數 加 一) 除以 (二 乘 次序 加 四)。次序零得 左四分之三、右四分之一;次序一且選出右得 各二分之一;選出左得 左六分之五、右六分之一;兩個 分支 的 權重 總和恆為一,且分子恆為正。(從 本例效準 推出)【正文:句6806287471、句4331721112】\n- 例:甲 在每一個次序都是 渦 :兩個 分支 的 權重 恆為正,甲在每個 時刻 都被 涉及 、都不被 鎖死 ,故第二問成立;第一問成立:到達 甲的 宇宙初態 、每一次選出結果、每一次 分別 ,其中每一件都存在某個替換,使 權重 的分布不同(判準同 自己的那一段 的定義;不要求任何替換都改變:只改變列出的排列而不改變次數的替換,權重 不變)。較早的 分別 經由其後各次選出結果的分布傳遞影響:結果中左的期望次數隨次序的遞推為嚴格遞增函數,早期分布的改變不會在途中消失。(從 渦 的定義 + 本例效準 推出)【正文:句2770334768、句4331721112】\n- [作者裁決] 2026-10-05 隨 步驟十五 的勘誤補寫判定的次序;論文第七節同步補寫。\n- [作者裁決] 2026-10-14 稽核(形-35)指出本例「任何一件若不同,權重 都會不同」讀成全稱時,生成函數 只依據各 分支 的次數,不足以支持。依 自己的那一段 的定義,「若不同」取存在性:對每一個 到達 它的件,存在某個替換使 權重 的分布不同,不要求任何替換皆然;本例的檢核據此逐項寫明,並註明只改變排列而不改變次數的替換不改變 權重 。步驟十五 的「第一問」同此解讀。\n- 例:甲的 時刻 集合為所有次序 不小於 一,本例不在第二次 坍塌 截斷。(從 時刻 的定義 + 涉及 的定義 + 本例效準 推出)【正文:句4331721112】\n- 例:本例滿足 前提十 與 前提十四 :每次 坍塌 之前有一次 寫入 ,甲的 分別 在它的下一個 時刻 之前被 寫入 並 到達 甲。(從 本例效準 推出)【正文:句8716189136、句9452802612】\n- 例:本例中第一 時刻 左的 權重 是四分之三,坍塌 54c0291d-05b3-431a-9f2a-1b8ec93c3c3f.選出 的是右:歷史 決定了 權重 ,沒有決定結果,與 黑箱律 一致。(從 本例效準 + 前提五 推出)【正文:句9177907820、句2377754398】\n- 例:本例中甲在第一次 坍塌 之後的 分別 ,材料不含這次 分別 本身,在第二次 坍塌 之前被 寫入 歷史 ,並參與第二 時刻 的 權重 ,與 損耗律 一致。(從 本例效準 + 步驟三十四 推出)【正文:句7155263336】\n\n## 附註\n\n來源:論文第八節【正文:句5984248284】\n\n- 附註:觀察者 不是 我 ;被叫做 我 的,是 渦 。【正文:句1139663157、句0864493498】\n- 附註:「每一個人都是 我 」不是說有很多個 觀察者 ; 觀察者 只有一個。【正文:句3723235014、句3892771116】\n- 附註:渦 以時鐘量到的時間依物理;時刻 是 觀察者 坍塌 的次序,任何 渦 都量不到;相對論拿掉的是 宇宙 之內的絕對同時,兩者不衝突。【正文:句1122255548、句9750593443】\n- 附註:對一對相隔遙遠的事件,站在不同位置的 渦 ,收到的先後可以相反;這不衝突。【正文:句1123156937】\n- 步驟六十六之一:一個 渦 的 分別 只以已經 到達 它的 歷史 為材料;相隔遙遠、來不及互相影響的兩次 坍塌 ,各自結果的 權重 不隨先後改變;它自己結果的分布等於 權重 。因此從任何一邊,都無法由自己結果的分布察覺 觀察者 坍塌 的先後。(從 分別 的定義 + 前提五 + 前提十二 + 不可傳訊 的定義 推出)【正文:句1123156937、句8451975741、句5970457099】\n- [作者裁決] 稽核指出, 不可傳訊 只保證自己結果的 權重 不隨先後改變,不排除事後對照 到達 的紀錄;論文第八節與第九節可證偽條件二收窄為「由自己結果的分布察覺」。\n- [作者裁決] 論文在 分別 的定義中補寫材料只限已經 到達 它的 歷史 ,並在第八節補寫不同位置的 渦 收到的先後可以相反。\n- 附註:本篇不談導致;歷史 中只有依賴;說某事導致某事,是一次 分別 。【正文:句8572275335、句3074934142、句7751278919】\n- 附註:把他者 分別 為一個人或幾十億個細胞,都不改寫其 歷史 。【正文:句6652736115】\n- 附註:死亡 是描述,不是物理條件。【正文:句6321588778】\n- 附註:在物質中沒有兩個內容一模一樣的 我 ;在虛擬中狀態可以被完整複製,本篇不保證;無論哪一種,複製出來的都發生在 歷史 中的另一個位置。【正文:句1070997050、句6002835558、句0779123473】\n- 附註:公司分家再合併、細胞分裂,都是唯一的那部 歷史 往後延續,不是 復原 ;把合併後的公司叫做原來那一家,是 分別 。【正文:句7195441552、句3772392763、句2684794559】\n- 附註:權重 是 分支 的輕重,不是任何 渦 內部的參數。【正文:句8920367812、句1655622673】\n- 附註:黑箱律 不是說 渦 不能被準確預測;對不被 鎖死 的 渦 ,任何預測都是押在 權重 上,不是推出。【正文:句9324084084、句4513452459】\n- 附註:流變律 不是說一切都是新的;常新的是 歷史 ,無新事的是 權重 的形狀。【正文:句6617176546、句2509414392】\n- 附註:四條律是本篇承認的鐵律;本篇不斷言所給出的是唯一讓它們成為必然的世界,也不斷言現實中的不可預測與不可逆只來自 坍塌 。【正文:句6906643939、句2609376678】\n\n## 可證偽條件\n\n來源:論文第九節【正文:句1122807405】\n\n- 附註:推論是前置條件之下的邏輯推導,不可證偽;框架承諾 不被任何一條律支撐,不受證偽影響。【正文:句6755036427、句1700747430】\n- 步驟六十七:預測的準確率碰不到 黑箱律 ;看似 復原 的例子,都位於 歷史 中的另一個位置;任何實驗本身就是新的一筆 歷史 ,與 流變律 相容;任何對自己的檢查本身就是一次尚未被 分別 的 分別 ,與 損耗律 相容。因此在 渦 的層次上,上述各種實驗,在前提成立的模型內都推翻不了四條律;現實實驗能否定的是 前提 (見步驟六十七之二)。(從 步驟二十六 + 步驟三十一 + 步驟三十五 + 步驟三十八 推出)【正文:句7625283978、句0879359827、句8788611568】\n- [作者裁決] 論文第九節補寫 流變律 與 損耗律 的理由。\n- 步驟六十七之一:屬於(前提二, 框架承諾);屬於(前提四, 框架承諾);屬於(前提九 中「宇宙初態 帶著 54c0291d-05b3-431a-9f2a-1b8ec93c3c3f.記錄 」的部分, 框架承諾);屬於(前提十三, 框架承諾)。四條律在本篇模型中的推導鏈都不使用這幾條前提。(從 框架承諾 的定義 + 步驟二十八 + 步驟三十二 + 步驟三十七 + 步驟四十六 推出)【正文:句1700747430、句9613702689、句8413625925、句1940148980、句9662420685、句0327650297】\n- [作者裁決] 論文第〇節明列這四項不是為了符合已知的觀察而保留,滿足 框架承諾 定義的另一個條件;原以「組成」表達,改為「屬於」:框架承諾 是一類條件,不是由要素組成的整體。\n- [作者裁決] 2026-10-07 原為 步驟一之一 ,位於框架宣告段,來源引用後文的標籤;移至本段,置於論文「框架承諾 不被任何一條律支撐」之下,內容與來源不變。\n- 步驟六十七之二:前提五 的否定條件:存在某個在 坍塌 之前已確定、或不在 宇宙 中的量,使 坍塌 結果的條件分布不等於 權重 。(從 前提五 推出)【正文:句5039603074、句7210028984、句7900817521】\n- [作者裁決] 2026-10-14 稽核(形-25、形-27)指出 前提五 被否定,不等於 黑箱律 被否定。立場:可證偽條件針對給定(前提),不是對律的邏輯否定;前提五 不成立時,黑箱律 與 不可復原律 第二層只是失去推導來源,剩下觀察到的形式,不再是原則上的必然(見步驟六十八)。步驟六十七之二 只陳述 前提五 的否定條件;步驟六十八 同樣只陳述 前提五 不成立時 黑箱律 與 不可復原律 第二層失去來源,不主張兩條律被邏輯否定;論文第九節補寫此立場。立場已記錄,待決項維持「無」。\n- 步驟六十七之三:若現實中 黑箱律 不成立,則 前提五 與 前提十一 失去 黑箱律 提供的倒推支撐;若 損耗律 不成立,則 前提十 與 前提十四 失去 損耗律 提供的倒推支撐;若 流變律 或 不可復原律 不成立,它們所要求的條件同樣失去這條律提供的倒推支撐。某個 前提 若另被其他律要求,仍保有其他律提供的支撐;失去倒推支撐不推出該 前提 為假。(從 步驟二十八 + 步驟三十二 + 步驟三十三 + 步驟三十五 + 步驟三十七 + 步驟四十六 + 前提五 + 前提十 + 前提十一 + 前提十四 推出)【正文:句2806921791、句4120145685、句6062601023】\n- [作者裁決] 2026-10-14 稽核(形-35)指出本步驟列出的來源未涵蓋 黑箱律 對 前提十一 與 損耗律 對 前提十 的依賴。補列:黑箱律 對 前提十一 的依賴由 步驟三十三(能推出的是 權重 )承載;損耗律 對 前提十 的依賴由 步驟三十五 承載。\n- 步驟六十八:前提五 不成立時,黑箱律 (步驟三十二)與 不可復原律 第二層(步驟四十四)失去來源,只剩觀察到的形式;流變律 (步驟二十八)、 損耗律 (步驟三十七)與 不可復原律 第一層(步驟三十八)的來源不含 前提五 ,不受影響。(從 步驟二十八 + 步驟三十二 + 步驟三十七 + 步驟三十八 + 步驟四十四 + 不可復原律 的定義 推出)【正文:句5039603074】\n- 步驟六十八之一:蘊含(能從一邊由自己結果的分布察覺相隔遙遠的兩次 坍塌 誰先誰後 與 前提五 , 非 前提十二)(從 步驟六十六之一 推出)【正文:句8944799090、句7210028984】\n- 步驟六十八之二:若現實中某條 前提 被證明不成立,則 流變律 、 黑箱律 、 損耗律 、 不可復原律 的模型版成立的推導中,以該 前提 為來源者(直接或經由前序步驟),失去經由它而來的推導來源,該律就只剩觀察到的形式,不再是原則上的必然;推導中不以該 前提 為來源者,不因它而失去來源。失去推導來源不推出該律為假。例如 前提十 或 前提十四 不成立時,步驟三十七 的推導失去來源,損耗律 只剩觀察到的形式。(從 步驟二十八 + 步驟三十二 + 步驟三十五 + 步驟三十七 + 步驟四十六 + 步驟六十七之三 推出)【正文:句2818778639、句8969724392】\n- [作者裁決] 2026-10-14 稽核(跨-11)指出論文第九節「其二」是對任一給定的一般主張,形式化只處理了 前提五 與 不可傳訊 兩個特例。補此一般步驟,內容限於正文所說:失去推導來源,不是律被邏輯否定;不逐條列出各 前提 與各律的對應,以免超出正文。\n- [作者裁決] 論文第九節補寫「而給定二仍然成立」,與本蘊含一致。\n- 附註:坍塌 在某個固定的基底下依 權重 54c0291d-05b3-431a-9f2a-1b8ec93c3c3f.選出 ,與量子力學的測量規則同形;生成函數 可取為與量子力學一致者,而量子力學滿足 不可傳訊 。【正文:句8524424365、句9956592440】\n- 附註:一個具體的 呈現 (人、人工智慧等)是否在其某個 時刻 不被 鎖死 ,經驗上未定。【正文:句8820048857、句7210028984】\n\n## 結論\n\n來源:論文第十節【正文:句6436152946】\n\n- 步驟六十九:宇宙 只有一部 歷史 。(從 歷史 的定義 推出)【正文:句5889643716】\n- 步驟七十:沒有 坍塌 就沒有 時刻 。(從 時刻 的定義 推出)【正文:句0498003054、句0009354318、句6667434992】\n- 附註:結論段的四句陳述,依序對應 流變律 (步驟二十八)、 黑箱律 (步驟三十二)、 損耗律 (步驟三十七)、 不可復原律 (步驟四十六)與推論十三(步驟六十一)。【正文:句0450428986、句4349856527、句6045321679、句8096296622】\n- 步驟七十二:沒有 渦 的 宇宙 沒有 時刻 ;有 渦 的 宇宙 只能往前。(從 步驟二十二 + 步驟七十 + 步驟四十七 推出)【正文:句0283218721】\n\n## 待決項\n\n無\n","paper_files":[{"filename":"渦動力學.md","content":"---\nuuid: 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986\nlast-modified: 2026-09-29T12:00:00\nauthor: 黃正宇 / Cheng Yu Huang\ncontact: mthree.tw@gmail.com\n---\n\n# 渦動力學\n\n> 本文的方法是倒推:由四條律出發,問世界至少必須是什麼樣子(第〇節)。本文每一條給定、定義與推論之下,並列一段「形式」。形式段供運算檢查使用,不供閱讀。\n\n## 框架宣告\n\n[奇點](../paper_54c0291d_05b3_431a_9f2a_1b8ec93c3c3f/concepts.md#c01)之後是[形式層](../paper_54c0291d_05b3_431a_9f2a_1b8ec93c3c3f/concepts.md#c02):[記錄](../paper_54c0291d_05b3_431a_9f2a_1b8ec93c3c3f/concepts.md#c17)一筆一筆[累積](../paper_54c0291d_05b3_431a_9f2a_1b8ec93c3c3f/concepts.md#c30),從不[選出](../paper_54c0291d_05b3_431a_9f2a_1b8ec93c3c3f/concepts.md#c32)。\n\n在[形式層](../paper_54c0291d_05b3_431a_9f2a_1b8ec93c3c3f/concepts.md#c02)之外,有一次[介入](concepts.md#c01)。[介入](concepts.md#c01)不在任何一個[形式層時刻](../paper_54c0291d_05b3_431a_9f2a_1b8ec93c3c3f/concepts.md#c04)之中,不可被形式化,本文不寫。\n\n[宇宙](concepts.md#c02)是有[坍塌](concepts.md#c08)的那一個。它與[形式層](../paper_54c0291d_05b3_431a_9f2a_1b8ec93c3c3f/concepts.md#c02)只差一件事:[宇宙](concepts.md#c02)中有[選出](../paper_54c0291d_05b3_431a_9f2a_1b8ec93c3c3f/concepts.md#c32)。從裡面看,[宇宙](concepts.md#c02)只有一個。本文所說的之前與之後,只在[宇宙](concepts.md#c02)之內成立。\n\n[宇宙](concepts.md#c02)中不由過去決定的,只有兩樣:[宇宙初態](concepts.md#c14),與每一次[坍塌](concepts.md#c08)的結果。其他一切,包括每一次[寫入](concepts.md#c29),都由到目前為止的[歷史](concepts.md#c13)決定。\n\n```text\n形式:\n不由過去決定者 等於 {宇宙初態} 聯集 {選出分支(次序),其中 次序 不小於 一}\n其餘:寫入(次序加一) 等於 寫入規則(歷史(次序))(給定四);\n 權重(次序加一) 等於 生成函數(寫入後歷史(次序))(給定五)\n介入:不形式化\n```\n\n\n本文要回答的,是一個認識論極限的問題:為什麼[我](concepts.md#c19)不能真正了解你,連[我](concepts.md#c19)自己也不能真正了解。常識與多數社會科學理論給的理由是偶然的:資訊不夠、語言不同、背景不同、經驗不同。這些理由都隱含著:只要資訊足夠、溝通足夠好,原則上就能了解。本文主張,這個限制是結構的,不是不足:就算資訊完整,也無法保證做到。它有三層。你下一刻的選擇,在[選出](../paper_54c0291d_05b3_431a_9f2a_1b8ec93c3c3f/concepts.md#c32)之前還沒有定,連你自己也無法事先唯一推出([黑箱律](concepts.md#c25))。你對自己的認識永遠落後一步,你手上沒有一個完整的自己可以交出([損耗律](concepts.md#c26))。[我](concepts.md#c19)只能用已經[到達](concepts.md#c10)[我](concepts.md#c19)的你來了解你:[到達](concepts.md#c10)[我](concepts.md#c19)的永遠是你過去的樣子,而你的下一刻仍是[黑箱](concepts.md#c25);[我](concepts.md#c19)了解你這個動作本身,一旦[到達](concepts.md#c10)你,還可能改變你(推論十二)。其中[損耗律](concepts.md#c26)的論證,只用到「了解是一個動作,發生了才進入[歷史](concepts.md#c13)」,不用到[坍塌](concepts.md#c08)。偶然的限制與結構的限制,常識分不開;所以本文倒推。\n\n本文不解決量子力學的測量問題。本文的方法是倒推:[流變](concepts.md#c24)、[黑箱](concepts.md#c25)、[損耗](concepts.md#c26)、[不可復原](concepts.md#c28)四條律,是本文承認的鐵律;本文問的是,這四條律若為真,世界至少必須是什麼樣子。倒推出的條件列為給定,每一條都標明它被哪一條律要求;再由給定往前推回四條律,作為驗算。被要求的給定,越少越好。凡不被任何一條律要求、也不是為了符合已知的觀察,而本文仍然保留的,列為[框架承諾](concepts.md#c03),與給定分開。\n\n---\n\n## 〇、倒推\n\n以下四條,是本文的出發點,承認為鐵律。陳述它們,不需要本文的任何給定。現實中的案例只作校準,不作證明。\n\n- [流變](concepts.md#c24):一個[渦](concepts.md#c16)的[歷史](concepts.md#c13),永遠不會一模一樣。你不能兩次踏進同一條河。\n- [黑箱](concepts.md#c25):你永遠都不會確定一個人下一刻的選擇;在選擇以前,連他自己也不知道。\n- [損耗](concepts.md#c26):[我](concepts.md#c19)永遠都不會真正完全知道自己。\n- [不可復原](concepts.md#c28):死了以後,不能復活。\n\n這四條說的是「永遠」。經驗只能給出「到目前為止沒有例外」;倒推要找的,是什麼樣的世界,讓「永遠」成立。\n\n在本文中,[死亡](concepts.md#c23)是標記;[不可復原律](concepts.md#c28)的內容是:[歷史](concepts.md#c13)中那一段,不會再發生一次。\n\n「[我](concepts.md#c19)不能真正了解你」,由[黑箱律](concepts.md#c25)、[損耗律](concepts.md#c26)與推論十二合起來回答。推論十二與[損耗律](concepts.md#c26)是同一個結構,一個朝向自己,一個朝向別人,故不另列為律。\n\n### 四條律要求的世界\n\n- [流變律](concepts.md#c24)要求:[歷史](concepts.md#c13)只有一部,只往後追加;每一個[時刻](concepts.md#c09),都有新的東西進入[歷史](concepts.md#c13)。對應[時刻](concepts.md#c09)與[歷史](concepts.md#c13)的定義。\n- [黑箱律](concepts.md#c25)要求:有不由[歷史](concepts.md#c13)決定的[選出](../paper_54c0291d_05b3_431a_9f2a_1b8ec93c3c3f/concepts.md#c32)(給定二);[權重](concepts.md#c06)由[歷史](concepts.md#c13)決定(給定五),因為這條律的後半是「能推出的是[權重](concepts.md#c06)」。\n- [損耗律](concepts.md#c26)要求:[分別](concepts.md#c18)是一個動作,發生了才寫進[歷史](concepts.md#c13)(給定四、給定七)。它的論證不用到[坍塌](concepts.md#c08);只因它談的對象是[我](concepts.md#c19),而[我](concepts.md#c19)是[渦](concepts.md#c16),才間接牽涉給定二。\n- [不可復原律](concepts.md#c28)要求:第一層,[歷史](concepts.md#c13)唯一;第二層,經由[黑箱律](concepts.md#c25),要求給定二;推導第二層時,另用到給定四。\n- 四條律另外用到[時刻](concepts.md#c09)與[歷史](concepts.md#c13)定義中的全序與起點:沒有全序,「到目前為止的[歷史](concepts.md#c13)」沒有定義;沒有起點,[歷史](concepts.md#c13)無從開始。這兩項寫在定義中,不另列為被要求的給定。\n\n此處「要求」的意思是:在本文的推導中,這條律用到這個條件;拿掉它,這條律在本文中就推不出來。這個條件是否在一切可能的世界中都必要,本文不斷言。\n\n### 框架承諾\n\n以下不被任何一條律要求,本文仍然保留:\n\n- 那條全序與那些[選出](../paper_54c0291d_05b3_431a_9f2a_1b8ec93c3c3f/concepts.md#c32),由[宇宙](concepts.md#c02)之外的一個[觀察者](concepts.md#c07)承擔(給定一的其餘部分)。四條律只要求有全序、有不由[歷史](concepts.md#c13)決定的[選出](../paper_54c0291d_05b3_431a_9f2a_1b8ec93c3c3f/concepts.md#c32),不要求由誰承擔。\n- [接上](concepts.md#c22)(給定六)。推論一、推論八依賴它。\n- [宇宙初態](concepts.md#c14)帶著[形式層](../paper_54c0291d_05b3_431a_9f2a_1b8ec93c3c3f/concepts.md#c02)中[累積](../paper_54c0291d_05b3_431a_9f2a_1b8ec93c3c3f/concepts.md#c30)的[記錄](../paper_54c0291d_05b3_431a_9f2a_1b8ec93c3c3f/concepts.md#c17)(給定三的後半)。\n- [介入](concepts.md#c01)。\n\n另有一條條件,也不被四條律要求,保留它只為了不違反已知的觀察:[生成函數](concepts.md#c15)[不可傳訊](concepts.md#c31)(給定五的後半)。\n\n```text\n形式:倒推表(「用到」:推導中用到;必要性未證)\n流變律 用到 歷史唯一且只追加\n黑箱律 用到 給定二之一、給定五(生成函數只取歷史)\n損耗律 用到 給定四、給定七;範圍經由「我」牽涉給定二之一\n不可復原律 用到 歷史唯一(第一層);給定二之一、給定二之二、給定四(第二層)\n四條律另外用到 時刻與歷史定義中的全序與起點(不列為給定)\n框架承諾 等於 {觀察者在宇宙之外並承擔全序與坍塌;給定六;宇宙初態帶形式層的記錄;介入}\n為不違反已知觀察而保留者 等於 {不可傳訊}\n```\n\n\n---\n\n## 一、呈現與分支\n\n- [宇宙](concepts.md#c02)中的任何一部分,都是一個[呈現](concepts.md#c04)。\n- [分支](concepts.md#c05)是一次[坍塌](concepts.md#c08)可能[選出](../paper_54c0291d_05b3_431a_9f2a_1b8ec93c3c3f/concepts.md#c32)的每一個結果。\n- [權重](concepts.md#c06)是每個[分支](concepts.md#c05)的輕重。\n\n```text\n形式:記號\n次序 屬於 {一,二,三,……} 時刻的次序;全序(時刻的定義)\n分支集合 可數\n分支集合上的權重分布 每個分支的權重不小於零,總和為一\n宇宙初態\n寫入(次序) 第 次序 次寫入\n選出分支(次序) 屬於 分支集合 第 次序 次坍塌選出的分支\n歷史(零) 等於 (宇宙初態)\n寫入後歷史(次序) 等於 (歷史(次序),寫入(次序加一))\n 寫入之後、坍塌之前的歷史\n歷史(次序加一) 等於 (寫入後歷史(次序),選出分支(次序加一))\n所有歷史、所有寫入後歷史 所有 歷史(次序)、所有 寫入後歷史(次序) 的集合\n所有寫入 所有寫入的集合\n呈現 某呈現:\n 結果投影(某呈現):分支集合 送到 某呈現的結果集合 聯集 {未落在其上}\n 把一次坍塌的結果看成 某呈現 的結果;未落在其上 表示此結果不落在 某呈現 上\n 刺激投影(某呈現):所有寫入 送到 某呈現的刺激集合 聯集 {未落在其上}\n 把一次寫入看成給 某呈現 的刺激;未落在其上 表示此寫入不到達 某呈現\n 結果投影(某呈現,某分支)、刺激投影(某呈現,某寫入):上述映射作用於某分支、某寫入之值\n推前(某映射,某權重):某權重 經 某映射 推前\n 推前(某映射,某權重) 在 某值 上的權重\n 等於 總和{某權重 在 某分支 上的權重,其中 某映射(某分支) 等於 某值}\n```\n\n\n---\n\n## 二、給定:觀察者與坍塌\n\n以下不可推出。每一條都標明它被哪一條律倒推出來,或屬於[框架承諾](concepts.md#c03)(見第〇節)。\n\n### 給定一:觀察者\n\n[觀察者](concepts.md#c07)是一個識別碼,沒有內容:不運算,不感受,不受苦,也沒有視角。它不在[宇宙](concepts.md#c02)之中,不是[呈現](concepts.md#c04),也不是[我](concepts.md#c19)。\n\n[觀察者](concepts.md#c07)只有一個。它唯一的功能是[坍塌](concepts.md#c08)。[觀察者](concepts.md#c07)一次只[坍塌](concepts.md#c08)一次。本文不討論它的本質。\n\n倒推:「一次只[坍塌](concepts.md#c08)一次」給出的全序已寫在[時刻](concepts.md#c09)的定義中,四條律用到的是定義,不是本條。[觀察者](concepts.md#c07)作為[宇宙](concepts.md#c02)之外的識別碼來承擔這條全序與[坍塌](concepts.md#c08),是[框架承諾](concepts.md#c03)。\n\n```text\n形式:\n觀察者唯一;觀察者 不在任何 歷史(次序) 中;觀察者 不是任何 結果投影(某呈現)\n坍塌逐次發生:時刻的次序 等於 {一,二,三,……},全序,無兩次同時\n```\n\n\n### 給定二:坍塌\n\n[坍塌](concepts.md#c08)在某個固定的基底下,依[權重](concepts.md#c06)[選出](../paper_54c0291d_05b3_431a_9f2a_1b8ec93c3c3f/concepts.md#c32)一個[分支](concepts.md#c05)。未被[選出](../paper_54c0291d_05b3_431a_9f2a_1b8ec93c3c3f/concepts.md#c32)的[分支](concepts.md#c05),不留在[宇宙](concepts.md#c02)中。\n\n[坍塌](concepts.md#c08)只[選出](../paper_54c0291d_05b3_431a_9f2a_1b8ec93c3c3f/concepts.md#c32)[權重](concepts.md#c06)不為零的[分支](concepts.md#c05)之間的差別。一個[呈現](concepts.md#c04)的下一[時刻](concepts.md#c09)若只有一個[權重](concepts.md#c06)不為零的結果,它的結果來自約束,不來自[坍塌](concepts.md#c08)。\n\n給定到目前為止的[歷史](concepts.md#c13),[坍塌](concepts.md#c08)的結果依[權重](concepts.md#c06)[選出](../paper_54c0291d_05b3_431a_9f2a_1b8ec93c3c3f/concepts.md#c32);[歷史](concepts.md#c13)中沒有任何東西,能比[權重](concepts.md#c06)多說一點。[宇宙](concepts.md#c02)中的一切都在[歷史](concepts.md#c13)之中,所以在一次[坍塌](concepts.md#c08)之前,[宇宙](concepts.md#c02)中沒有任何東西決定它的結果。\n\n倒推:被[黑箱律](concepts.md#c25)要求;[不可復原律](concepts.md#c28)的第二層經由[黑箱律](concepts.md#c25),也要求它。\n\n```text\n形式:\n給定二之一 機率(選出分支(次序加一) 等於 某分支,已知 寫入後歷史(次序)、坍塌前已定之量)\n 等於 生成函數(寫入後歷史(次序)) 中 某分支 的權重\n 坍塌前已定之量:任何在第 次序加一 次坍塌之前已確定、或不在宇宙中的量\n (例如 經由之我(次序加一),見給定六)\n給定二之二 若 生成函數(寫入後歷史(次序)) 中 某分支 的權重 等於 零,\n 則 選出分支(次序加一) 不等於 某分支\n給定二之三 歷史(次序加一) 等於 (寫入後歷史(次序),選出分支(次序加一)):只追加選出者;\n 不等於 選出分支(次序加一) 的分支,不進入任何 歷史(另一次序)\n基底:分支集合的選取,不另形式化\n```\n\n\n---\n\n## 三、時刻與歷史\n\n- [時刻](concepts.md#c09)是一次[坍塌](concepts.md#c08)。[宇宙](concepts.md#c02)的[時刻](concepts.md#c09),依[觀察者](concepts.md#c07)[坍塌](concepts.md#c08)的次序排列;這是一條次序,不是一個視角。沒有[坍塌](concepts.md#c08),就沒有[時刻](concepts.md#c09)。\n- 一次[寫入](concepts.md#c29)作為[刺激](concepts.md#c30)落到一個[呈現](concepts.md#c04)上,就是[到達](concepts.md#c10)它。一次[坍塌](concepts.md#c08)[涉及](concepts.md#c11)一個[呈現](concepts.md#c04),它的結果就[到達](concepts.md#c10)這個[呈現](concepts.md#c04);結果沒有落在它身上,「這次沒有發生在它身上」也是[到達](concepts.md#c10)它的一件事。[宇宙初態](concepts.md#c14)[到達](concepts.md#c10)一切[呈現](concepts.md#c04)。\n- 一次[坍塌](concepts.md#c08)[涉及](concepts.md#c11)一個[呈現](concepts.md#c04),是指這次[坍塌](concepts.md#c08)的結果可能落在它身上;這時它的[權重](concepts.md#c06),依賴[到達](concepts.md#c10)它的[歷史](concepts.md#c13)。[涉及](concepts.md#c11)與[分支](concepts.md#c05)的多寡無關。\n- 一個[呈現](concepts.md#c04)的[時刻](concepts.md#c09),是[涉及](concepts.md#c11)它的那些[坍塌](concepts.md#c08)。它的下一[時刻](concepts.md#c09),是下一次[涉及](concepts.md#c11)它的[坍塌](concepts.md#c08)。兩次之間,對它沒有[時刻](concepts.md#c09)。\n- [鎖死](concepts.md#c12)是一個[呈現](concepts.md#c04)的下一[時刻](concepts.md#c09)只有一個[權重](concepts.md#c06)不為零的結果:把各[分支](concepts.md#c05)看成它的結果之後,只剩一個。[鎖死](concepts.md#c12)是約束,與[坍塌](concepts.md#c08)無關。沒有[時刻](concepts.md#c09)不是[鎖死](concepts.md#c12):[鎖死](concepts.md#c12)是[涉及](concepts.md#c11)了,卻只有一個結果。\n- [歷史](concepts.md#c13)始於[宇宙初態](concepts.md#c14),其後是[宇宙](concepts.md#c02)中每一次[寫入](concepts.md#c29)與每一次[坍塌](concepts.md#c08)的結果,依[時刻](concepts.md#c09)排列。[宇宙](concepts.md#c02)只有一部[歷史](concepts.md#c13)。\n\n```text\n形式:\n權重(次序) 等於 生成函數(寫入後歷史(次序減一)) 第 次序 次坍塌的權重\n權重(次序,某呈現) 等於 推前(結果投影(某呈現),權重(次序)) 某呈現 在第 次序 次的權重\n到達(某呈現,次序) 等於 {位置零}\n 聯集 {位置,其中 該位置為某次寫入,且 刺激投影(某呈現,該寫入) 不等於 未落在其上}\n 聯集 {第 某次序 次坍塌的結果位置,其中 某次序 屬於 時刻集合(某呈現)}\n 位置不超過 寫入後歷史(次序) 的長度\n (涉及 某呈現 的坍塌,結果一律到達 某呈現,\n 包括 結果投影(某呈現,選出分支(某次序)) 等於 未落在其上 者)\n涉及(某呈現,次序) 當且僅當 權重(次序,某呈現) 在 未落在其上 的權重 小於 一\n 結果以正權重落在 某呈現 上\n時刻集合(某呈現) 等於 {次序,其中 涉及(某呈現,次序)} 某呈現 的時刻\n下一時刻(某呈現,次序) 等於\n 最小值{另一次序,其中 另一次序 大於 次序,且 另一次序 屬於 時刻集合(某呈現)}\n鎖死(某呈現,次序) 當且僅當 涉及(某呈現,次序)\n 且 權重(次序,某呈現) 中權重不為零者 恰為一個值,且該值 不等於 未落在其上\n次序 不屬於 時刻集合(某呈現) 則 非 鎖死(某呈現,次序) 沒有時刻不是鎖死\n歷史唯一:對 次序 小於 另一次序,歷史(次序) 是 歷史(另一次序) 的前段\n注:若 權重(次序,某呈現) 在 未落在其上 的權重 等於 一,\n 在這一次坍塌中,某呈現 的權重全落在 未落在其上;\n 故就這一次坍塌而言,「權重依賴到達它的歷史」只在結果可能落在它身上時有意義,不另成一項條件\n```\n\n\n### 給定三:宇宙初態\n\n[宇宙初態](concepts.md#c14)是第一次[坍塌](concepts.md#c08)之前已經在那裡的一切,它帶著[形式層](../paper_54c0291d_05b3_431a_9f2a_1b8ec93c3c3f/concepts.md#c02)中[累積](../paper_54c0291d_05b3_431a_9f2a_1b8ec93c3c3f/concepts.md#c30)的[記錄](../paper_54c0291d_05b3_431a_9f2a_1b8ec93c3c3f/concepts.md#c17)。\n\n倒推:[歷史](concepts.md#c13)的起點已寫在[歷史](concepts.md#c13)的定義中,四條律用到的是定義,不是本條。[初態](concepts.md#c14)帶著[形式層](../paper_54c0291d_05b3_431a_9f2a_1b8ec93c3c3f/concepts.md#c02)的[記錄](../paper_54c0291d_05b3_431a_9f2a_1b8ec93c3c3f/concepts.md#c17),是[框架承諾](concepts.md#c03)。\n\n```text\n形式:歷史(零) 等於 (宇宙初態);宇宙初態 的內容不分析\n```\n\n\n### 給定四:寫入\n\n每一次[坍塌](concepts.md#c08)之前,先有一次[寫入](concepts.md#c29)。[寫入](concepts.md#c29)的內容,完全由到目前為止的[歷史](concepts.md#c13)決定。\n\n倒推:被[損耗律](concepts.md#c26)要求;[不可復原律](concepts.md#c28)第二層的推導也用到它。\n\n```text\n形式:對所有 次序 不小於 零,寫入(次序加一) 等於 寫入規則(歷史(次序));\n 寫入規則:所有歷史 送到 所有寫入,為函數\n```\n\n\n### 給定五:生成函數\n\n[生成函數](concepts.md#c15)把到目前為止的[歷史](concepts.md#c13),對應到下一[時刻](concepts.md#c09)各[分支](concepts.md#c05)的[權重](concepts.md#c06)。它只取到目前為止的[歷史](concepts.md#c13)。[生成函數](concepts.md#c15)的內部不分析。\n\n一個[呈現](concepts.md#c04)的[權重](concepts.md#c06),是[宇宙](concepts.md#c02)的[權重](concepts.md#c06)落在它身上的那一部分。\n\n[生成函數](concepts.md#c15)[不可傳訊](concepts.md#c31):相隔遙遠、來不及互相影響的兩次[坍塌](concepts.md#c08),不論[觀察者](concepts.md#c07)先作哪一次,各自結果的[權重](concepts.md#c06)都相同。\n\n由此可推出,而不必另立:當一個[呈現](concepts.md#c04)的結果可由另一個[呈現](concepts.md#c04)的結果合成得到時,[生成函數](concepts.md#c15)不隨描述的粒度改變。把一個[呈現](concepts.md#c04)描述成一個節點,或描述成一個網路,所有[呈現](concepts.md#c04)的[權重](concepts.md#c06)都從同一份[宇宙](concepts.md#c02)[權重](concepts.md#c06)分出,結果必然一致。\n\n倒推:「[權重](concepts.md#c06)只由[歷史](concepts.md#c13)決定」被[黑箱律](concepts.md#c25)要求。[不可傳訊](concepts.md#c31)不被四條律要求,保留它只為了不違反已知的觀察(見第〇節)。\n\n```text\n形式:\n生成函數:所有寫入後歷史 送到 分支集合上的權重分布;\n 權重(次序加一) 等於 生成函數(寫入後歷史(次序));生成函數 內部不分析\n某呈現 的權重 等於 推前(結果投影(某呈現),權重(次序))(見第三節)\n不可傳訊:設第 次序加一、次序加二 次坍塌分別只落在 某呈現、另一呈現 上,\n 某呈現、另一呈現 相隔遙遠(原始關係)。\n 將兩次的次序交換,結果投影(某呈現,某分支) 與 結果投影(另一呈現,另一分支)\n 各自的權重分布不變。\n粒度(推論):若 結果投影(某呈現) 等於 某映射 合成 結果投影(另一呈現),\n 則 權重(次序,某呈現) 等於 推前(某映射,權重(次序,另一呈現))。\n 證:推前(某映射 合成 結果投影(另一呈現),某權重)\n 等於 推前(某映射,推前(結果投影(另一呈現),某權重))。證畢\n```\n\n\n---\n\n## 四、渦與我\n\n- [渦](concepts.md#c16)是這樣的[呈現](concepts.md#c04):[到達](concepts.md#c10)它的所有[歷史](concepts.md#c13),包括它收到的每一次[刺激](concepts.md#c30)、[涉及](concepts.md#c11)它的每一次[坍塌](concepts.md#c08)的結果,一直到[宇宙初態](concepts.md#c14),都參與它下一[時刻](concepts.md#c09)[權重](concepts.md#c06)的分配:其中任何一件若不同,影響沿著[歷史](concepts.md#c13)傳下來,它現在的[權重](concepts.md#c06)就會不同。這個影響不一定找得到;找不找得到,是[分別](concepts.md#c18)的事。並且至少有些[時刻](concepts.md#c09)它不被[鎖死](concepts.md#c12)。有[歷史](concepts.md#c13)而[歷史](concepts.md#c13)不參與,不是[渦](concepts.md#c16);[歷史](concepts.md#c13)參與而每一步都被[鎖死](concepts.md#c12),也不是[渦](concepts.md#c16)。這種參與可以漸漸消失;消失之後,它就不再是[渦](concepts.md#c16)。從某一刻起每一步都被[鎖死](concepts.md#c12),它也不再是[渦](concepts.md#c16)。它下一[時刻](concepts.md#c09)的[權重](concepts.md#c06)所依賴的[歷史](concepts.md#c13),就是它[自己的那一段](concepts.md#c17);[那一段](concepts.md#c17)由依賴決定,不由任何[分別](concepts.md#c18)決定。由此,[涉及](concepts.md#c11)它的[坍塌](concepts.md#c08)所作出的每一個選擇,都屬於它[自己的那一段](concepts.md#c17)。它[自己的那一段](concepts.md#c17),是同一部[歷史](concepts.md#c13)的一部分,不是另一部[歷史](concepts.md#c13);不同的[渦](concepts.md#c16),[那一段](concepts.md#c17)可以重疊。[渦](concepts.md#c16)沒有固定的核心:它是什麼,就是什麼[到達](concepts.md#c10)了它,以及這些如何參與它的[權重](concepts.md#c06);這是它與[宇宙](concepts.md#c02)的關係。細胞、神經元、免疫系統、演化中的物種、人、對話中的人工智慧、組織、文明,都可以是[渦](concepts.md#c16);放射性原子、骰子、石頭、算盤、恆溫器不是:放射性原子與骰子有多於一個結果,[權重](concepts.md#c06)卻不受過去影響;石頭、算盤與恆溫器受過去影響,卻每一步都被[鎖死](concepts.md#c12)。[渦](concepts.md#c16)是否為[渦](concepts.md#c16),與它的載體無關,也與任何[分別](concepts.md#c18)無關:一個[呈現](concepts.md#c04)符合以上條件,它就是[渦](concepts.md#c16),不論有沒有任何[我](concepts.md#c19)這樣看它。判斷的方法與更多的例子,見第五節。\n\n```text\n形式:\n宇宙初態 記為 位置零\n替換(位置,替換值):把 寫入後歷史(次序) 的該位置換成 替換值;\n 其後的寫入依 寫入規則 重算,其後的結果依 生成函數 重新選出\n分布(某量,已知 某條件):某量 在 某條件 之下的分布\n時間約定:渦(某呈現,次序) 的 次序,指第 次序 次坍塌之後、第 次序加一 次之前。\n 判定用 寫入後歷史(次序) 與 權重(次序加一) 等於 生成函數(寫入後歷史(次序)),\n 即下一時刻的權重;其後有不鎖死之時 另看 次序加一 及其後的時刻。\n 注意與第三節 權重(次序) 等於 生成函數(寫入後歷史(次序減一)) 差一格。\n 次序 等於 零 時,判定用 寫入後歷史(零) 等於 (宇宙初態,寫入(一)) 與 權重(一);\n 兩者在第一次坍塌之前皆已確定;渦(某呈現,零) 另依其後的實際歷史判定。\n自己的那一段(某呈現,次序) 等於 {位置,其中 存在 替換值,使\n 分布(權重(次序加一,某呈現),已知 替換(位置,替換值))\n 不等於 分布(權重(次序加一,某呈現),已知 替換(位置,實際值))}\n 某呈現 在 次序 的那一段;影響沿歷史傳遞\n歷史全參與(某呈現,次序) 當且僅當 到達(某呈現,次序) 包含於 自己的那一段(某呈現,次序)\n 所有到達它的都參與\n其後有不鎖死之時(某呈現,次序) 當且僅當 存在 另一次序 不小於 次序,使\n 另一次序加一 屬於 時刻集合(某呈現) 且 非 鎖死(某呈現,另一次序加一)\n渦(某呈現,次序) 當且僅當 歷史全參與(某呈現,次序) 且 其後有不鎖死之時(某呈現,次序)\n推:{第 某次序 次坍塌的結果位置,其中 某次序 屬於 時刻集合(某呈現),且 某次序 不大於 次序}\n 包含於 到達(某呈現,次序) 包含於 自己的那一段(某呈現,次序)\n 即涉及 某呈現 的坍塌所作出的選擇,都屬於 某呈現 的那一段\n自己的那一段(某呈現,次序) 交集 自己的那一段(另一呈現,次序) 可以非空\n渦(某呈現,次序) 由 生成函數、寫入規則、結果投影(某呈現)、刺激投影(某呈現) 與實際歷史決定;\n 任何 分別內容 對「某呈現 是否為渦」的宣稱,不影響此判定\n「找得到」不在定義中:自己的那一段(某呈現,次序) 的存在,不要求任何 分別規則 能算出它\n放射性原子、骰子:非 歷史全參與(到達者不改變權重)\n石頭、算盤、恆溫器:非 其後有不鎖死之時(每一步鎖死)\n渦 某呈現 與宇宙的關係 等於 (到達(某呈現,各次序),自己的那一段(某呈現,各次序));\n 除此之外,某呈現 沒有其他規定\n```\n\n\n- [分別](concepts.md#c18)是[渦](concepts.md#c16)的一個動作:劃出界線,把哪些[呈現](concepts.md#c04)看作一個[個體](concepts.md#c20),把哪一段看作過去,把不同[時刻](concepts.md#c09)的[渦](concepts.md#c16)看作[同一](concepts.md#c21)個或不同的兩個。這個動作在[歷史](concepts.md#c13)中留下一次[寫入](concepts.md#c29),[寫入](concepts.md#c29)的內容由到目前為止的[歷史](concepts.md#c13)決定。[分別](concepts.md#c18)的內容改變的是看法,不改寫被看的東西;[分別](concepts.md#c18)這個動作本身,依給定七進入[歷史](concepts.md#c13)。[分別](concepts.md#c18)要發生了才進入[歷史](concepts.md#c13),所以它的材料只有它之前、已經[到達](concepts.md#c10)它的[歷史](concepts.md#c13),它自己不在其中。談一個[渦](concepts.md#c16)的下一[時刻](concepts.md#c09)時,它是一個細胞還是一個身體,也是一次[分別](concepts.md#c18);由給定五,在相同的[歷史](concepts.md#c13)下,這種描述方式的改變本身不改變[權重](concepts.md#c06)。\n\n```text\n形式:\n某呈現 在 次序 的一次分別:分別內容(某呈現,次序) 等於 分別規則(某呈現,歷史(次序) 中到達 某呈現 的部分),\n 分別規則(某呈現) 為函數(由給定四,分別規則(某呈現) 是 寫入規則 的一部分)\n分別內容(某呈現,次序) 是 寫入(次序加一) 的一部分\n材料 等於 歷史(次序) 中到達 某呈現 的部分;分別內容(某呈現,次序) 不屬於 歷史(次序)\n (寫入(次序加一) 不在 歷史(次序) 中)\n不改寫:任何 分別內容 都不改變任何已有的 歷史(次序)(歷史只往後追加)\n分別的內容(個體、過去、同一、死亡、導致)不形式化;只形式化「它是一次寫入」\n```\n\n\n- [我](concepts.md#c19)是以[分別](concepts.md#c18)定義自己的[渦](concepts.md#c16)。誰是[我](concepts.md#c19),由它自己定義;發出「我」這個聲音不算,自我定義才算。\n- [個體](concepts.md#c20)是被某個[我](concepts.md#c19)[分別](concepts.md#c18)出來的[呈現](concepts.md#c04)。同一段[宇宙](concepts.md#c02),被[分別](concepts.md#c18)為一個[個體](concepts.md#c20)或幾十億個[個體](concepts.md#c20),皆成立。\n- [同一](concepts.md#c21)是一種[分別](concepts.md#c18):某一[時刻](concepts.md#c09)的[渦](concepts.md#c16)與另一[時刻](concepts.md#c09)的[渦](concepts.md#c16)是不是[同一](concepts.md#c21)個,由作出[分別](concepts.md#c18)的[我](concepts.md#c19)決定。是不是[渦](concepts.md#c16),不是[分別](concepts.md#c18);是不是[同一](concepts.md#c21)個,是[分別](concepts.md#c18)。\n- [接上](concepts.md#c22)是[我](concepts.md#c19)與[觀察者](concepts.md#c07)之間的聯繫;[接上](concepts.md#c22)不在[宇宙](concepts.md#c02)之中。一個[我](concepts.md#c19)是否[接上](concepts.md#c22),不由它的任何[分別](concepts.md#c18)決定,包括自我定義。\n- [死亡](concepts.md#c23)是某個[我](concepts.md#c19)加在一個[渦](concepts.md#c16)上的標記。\n\n```text\n形式:\n我(某呈現,次序) 當且僅當 渦(某呈現,次序) 且 存在 另一次序 不大於 次序,\n 使 分別內容(某呈現,另一次序) 以 某呈現 自己為對象(內容不形式化)\n個體、同一、死亡:皆為某個 分別內容,不形式化\n經由之我(次序):第 次序 次坍塌所經由的我;經由之我 不在任何 歷史(次序) 中,\n 且不影響任何權重與結果的分布(給定二之一)\n 注:經由之我 的值可以被歷史限定(例如宇宙中只有一個我時);這不與任何給定衝突\n接上(某呈現) 當且僅當 某呈現 屬於 經由之我 的值域;\n 接上(某呈現) 不由任何 分別內容(某呈現,各次序) 決定\n```\n\n\n### 給定六:接上\n\n[坍塌](concepts.md#c08)經由[接上](concepts.md#c22)[觀察者](concepts.md#c07)的[我](concepts.md#c19)發生。哪些[我](concepts.md#c19)[接上](concepts.md#c22)了,本文不斷言。\n\n倒推:不被任何一條律要求,是[框架承諾](concepts.md#c03)。\n\n```text\n形式:對所有 次序 不小於 一,經由之我(次序) 存在,且 我(經由之我(次序),次序減一)。\n 經由之我 的值域不斷言。\n```\n\n\n### 給定七:分別進入歷史\n\n[渦](concepts.md#c16)的每一次[分別](concepts.md#c18),都在它的下一[時刻](concepts.md#c09)之前,作為[刺激](concepts.md#c30)被[寫入](concepts.md#c29),並[到達](concepts.md#c10)作出它的[渦](concepts.md#c16)。哪些[渦](concepts.md#c16)在[分別](concepts.md#c18)、[分別](concepts.md#c18)了多少,本文不斷言。\n\n倒推:被[損耗律](concepts.md#c26)要求。\n\n```text\n形式:若渦 某呈現 在 次序 作出分別,則 分別內容(某呈現,次序) 屬於 寫入(次序加一),\n 寫入(次序加一) 包含於 寫入後歷史(次序),\n 刺激投影(某呈現,寫入(次序加一)) 不等於 未落在其上,\n 且 寫入(次序加一) 先於 下一時刻(某呈現,次序)。\n```\n\n\n---\n\n## 五、適用範圍\n\n以下推論只談[渦](concepts.md#c16)。[黑箱律](concepts.md#c25)只談[渦](concepts.md#c16)不被[鎖死](concepts.md#c12)的[時刻](concepts.md#c09)。一顆炮彈擊中一個人,那一刻只有一個結果,不在本文討論之內。\n\n同樣地,一個語言模型如果在[涉及](concepts.md#c11)它的每一個[時刻](concepts.md#c09),結果都完全由[歷史](concepts.md#c13)決定,它在這些[時刻](concepts.md#c09)就是[鎖死](concepts.md#c12)的,不在[黑箱律](concepts.md#c25)之內。它在兩次輸入之間則沒有[時刻](concepts.md#c09):沒有任何[坍塌](concepts.md#c08)[涉及](concepts.md#c11)它,這不是[鎖死](concepts.md#c12)。\n\n```text\n形式:\n黑箱律的前提:非 鎖死(某呈現,次序加一)\n炮彈:鎖死(人,次序)\n語言模型:若對所有 次序 屬於 時刻集合(某呈現),\n 推前(結果投影(某呈現),生成函數(寫入後歷史(次序))) 的權重全落在單一值上,\n 則 鎖死(某呈現,次序);兩次輸入之間,次序 不屬於 時刻集合(某呈現)\n```\n\n\n### 判斷一個呈現是不是渦\n\n判斷只問兩件事:\n\n- 第一問:[到達](concepts.md#c10)它的每一件事,若當時不同,它下一[時刻](concepts.md#c09)的[權重](concepts.md#c06)會不會跟著不同?\n- 第二問:從這一刻起往後,它還有至少一個[時刻](concepts.md#c09),下一刻有多於一個可能的結果嗎?\n\n兩問都是,才是[渦](concepts.md#c16)。只有一問是,就不是:\n\n- [歷史](concepts.md#c13)參與,但每一步都被[鎖死](concepts.md#c12):石頭、算盤、恆溫器、晶體的生長、河道。過去留下痕跡,但下一步由當下的條件唯一決定。\n- 有多於一個結果,但[歷史](concepts.md#c13)不參與:放射性原子、骰子。每一次都像第一次,過去沒有留下任何影響。\n\n判斷時有四點:\n\n- 判斷的對象是一種切法。同一段[宇宙](concepts.md#c02),換一種切法,答案可以不同;切定之後,答案不由任何[分別](concepts.md#c18)決定。\n- 名字不算。颶風在物理上是一個渦旋,但若它在那個尺度上被[鎖死](concepts.md#c12),或它的[權重](concepts.md#c06)不依賴它全部的[歷史](concepts.md#c13),它就不是本文的[渦](concepts.md#c16)。\n- 是不是[渦](concepts.md#c16),可以改變。參與漸漸消失,或從某一刻起每一步都被[鎖死](concepts.md#c12),它就不再是[渦](concepts.md#c16)。\n- 第二問在物理層次上未必有答案(見第九節)。在生物學與社會科學的層次上,一個[呈現](concepts.md#c04)的下一刻若不能由那個層次可得的[歷史](concepts.md#c13)唯一推出,本文的應用就假定它不被[鎖死](concepts.md#c12)。這是應用時的假定,不是定理。\n\n```text\n形式:\n第一問 等於 歷史全參與(某呈現,次序)\n第二問 等於 存在 另一次序 不小於 次序,使 另一次序加一 屬於 時刻集合(某呈現)\n 且 非 鎖死(某呈現,另一次序加一)\n渦(某呈現,次序) 當且僅當 第一問 且 第二問;第二問 即 其後有不鎖死之時(某呈現,次序)\n歷史全參與 且 每一步鎖死:石頭、算盤、恆溫器、晶體、河道\n非 歷史全參與 且 有些時刻 非 鎖死:放射性原子、骰子\n判斷對象為 (結果投影(某呈現),刺激投影(某呈現));換切法即換 某呈現\n應用的假定:在某一描述層次上,若 某呈現 的下一刻不能由該層次可得的歷史唯一推出,\n 應用時假定 非 鎖死。\n 此假定不在給定之中,推論的正確性不依賴它;只有把推論用到具體的 某呈現 時才用到它。\n```\n\n\n### 應用範圍\n\n以下案例只作校準,不作證明。\n\n- 生命:細胞、神經元、免疫系統、病毒族群、腫瘤、腸道菌群、生態系、演化中的物種。腫瘤是典型:每一次治療都[到達](concepts.md#c10)它,改變它之後的[權重](concepts.md#c06),抗藥性由此而來。先來的物種改變後來誰能進入,所以同樣的環境,走過不同的[歷史](concepts.md#c13),長成不同的生態系。\n- 心智與關係:人、記憶、一段關係、一場對話。每一次回想都改寫記憶本身,回想也[到達](concepts.md#c10)了它。兩個人之間的關係,本身也是一個[渦](concepts.md#c16):每一句話都留在裡面,參與下一句。\n- 社會:組織、語言、判例法、市場、科學領域、宗教傳統、城市、文明。判例法中,每一個判決都成為先例,參與之後的判決,而下一個判決不能被唯一推出。每一次使用都[到達](concepts.md#c10)一種語言,詞義在使用中漂移。\n- 人造系統:對話中的人工智慧、持續學習的演算法、模型的訓練過程。使用者的每一次點擊,都改變推薦系統下一次推出什麼。它們能否通過第二問,取決於它們的隨機性是否真的沒有被決定。\n\n---\n\n## 六、推論\n\n### 推論一:渦存在\n\n由定義,[宇宙](concepts.md#c02)有[坍塌](concepts.md#c08);由給定六,[坍塌](concepts.md#c08)經由[接上](concepts.md#c22)[觀察者](concepts.md#c07)的[我](concepts.md#c19)發生。故[宇宙](concepts.md#c02)中至少有一個[我](concepts.md#c19)。由定義,[我](concepts.md#c19)是[渦](concepts.md#c16)。故[宇宙](concepts.md#c02)中至少有一個[渦](concepts.md#c16)。\n\n第一次[坍塌](concepts.md#c08)所經由的[我](concepts.md#c19),在第一次[坍塌](concepts.md#c08)之前已經是[我](concepts.md#c19)。它是不是[我](concepts.md#c19),和任何[渦](concepts.md#c16)一樣,由實際的[歷史](concepts.md#c13)決定([生成函數](concepts.md#c15)與[寫入](concepts.md#c29)的規則是固定的):[宇宙初態](concepts.md#c14)、由[初態](concepts.md#c14)決定的第一次[寫入](concepts.md#c29),以及其後的[歷史](concepts.md#c13),全都在[宇宙](concepts.md#c02)之中。所以這不需要另立給定。\n\n反過來說,沒有[渦](concepts.md#c16),就沒有[坍塌](concepts.md#c08)。\n\n```text\n形式:\n第一次坍塌存在 則 經由之我(一) 存在 且 我(經由之我(一),零)\n 則 渦(經由之我(一),零)。\n我(經由之我(一),零) 依 寫入後歷史(零) 等於 (宇宙初態,寫入(一)) 與其後的實際歷史判定\n (其後有不鎖死之時 看 次序加一 及其後),而 寫入(一) 等於 寫入規則(歷史(零));\n 所依者皆在 歷史 之中,不需另立給定。證畢\n逆:無渦 則 無我 則 經由之我 無值 則 無 坍塌。證畢\n```\n\n\n### 推論二:形式層沒有時刻\n\n[形式層](../paper_54c0291d_05b3_431a_9f2a_1b8ec93c3c3f/concepts.md#c02)中從不[選出](../paper_54c0291d_05b3_431a_9f2a_1b8ec93c3c3f/concepts.md#c32)(見框架宣告),也就沒有[坍塌](concepts.md#c08)。由[時刻](concepts.md#c09)的定義,在本文的意義上,[形式層](../paper_54c0291d_05b3_431a_9f2a_1b8ec93c3c3f/concepts.md#c02)沒有[時刻](concepts.md#c09)。本文所說的之前與之後,只在[宇宙](concepts.md#c02)之內成立(見框架宣告),故[宇宙](concepts.md#c02)的[時刻](concepts.md#c09)與[形式層時刻](../paper_54c0291d_05b3_431a_9f2a_1b8ec93c3c3f/concepts.md#c04)之間,沒有給定的先後次序或對應。[時刻](concepts.md#c09)就是[坍塌](concepts.md#c08),所以任何[我](concepts.md#c19)在[時刻](concepts.md#c09)之中作出[分別](concepts.md#c18)時看見的,都已是[坍塌](concepts.md#c08)之後的結果:[宇宙初態](concepts.md#c14)中[形式層](../paper_54c0291d_05b3_431a_9f2a_1b8ec93c3c3f/concepts.md#c02)[累積](../paper_54c0291d_05b3_431a_9f2a_1b8ec93c3c3f/concepts.md#c30)的[記錄](../paper_54c0291d_05b3_431a_9f2a_1b8ec93c3c3f/concepts.md#c17)確實還在,但[我](concepts.md#c19)在[時刻](concepts.md#c09)之中看見它時,它已是[坍塌](concepts.md#c08)之後的[記錄](../paper_54c0291d_05b3_431a_9f2a_1b8ec93c3c3f/concepts.md#c17)。第一次[坍塌](concepts.md#c08)之前,已經有一個[我](concepts.md#c19)在[分別](concepts.md#c18)自己,但那時還沒有任何[時刻](concepts.md#c09);它那時知道什麼,本文不斷言:這既不能證實,也不能證偽。\n\n```text\n形式:形式層中無 選出分支 則 無 次序。\n 任何 分別規則 的材料包含於某個 歷史(次序),次序 不小於 零,不含形式層時刻;\n 次序 不小於 一 的分別中,宇宙初態 所帶的記錄是在第一次坍塌之後被讀到的;\n 次序 等於 零 的分別知道什麼,不斷言。證畢\n```\n\n\n### 推論三:流變律\n\n由[時刻](concepts.md#c09)與[歷史](concepts.md#c13)的定義,每一個[時刻](concepts.md#c09),[歷史](concepts.md#c13)都多了一次[坍塌](concepts.md#c08)的結果。[渦](concepts.md#c16)在[歷史](concepts.md#c13)之中,所以沒有任何一個[時刻](concepts.md#c09),[渦](concepts.md#c16)處在與該次[坍塌](concepts.md#c08)之前相同的[歷史](concepts.md#c13)裡。凍結一個[呈現](concepts.md#c04),停不下它所在的[歷史](concepts.md#c13)。\n\n對一個[渦](concepts.md#c16)自己的[歷史](concepts.md#c13)也是如此:由[到達](concepts.md#c10)的定義,[涉及](concepts.md#c11)它的每一次[坍塌](concepts.md#c08),結果都[到達](concepts.md#c10)它。所以在它的每一個[時刻](concepts.md#c09),[到達](concepts.md#c10)它的[歷史](concepts.md#c13)都多了一筆,永遠不會和該次[坍塌](concepts.md#c08)之前一模一樣。兩個[時刻](concepts.md#c09)之間,對它沒有[時刻](concepts.md#c09)。\n\n此即[流變律](concepts.md#c24)在本文模型中的形式([流變律模型版](concepts.md#c33)):[渦](concepts.md#c16)所在的[歷史](concepts.md#c13)一直在變。\n\n```text\n形式:\n宇宙:長度(歷史(次序加一)) 大於 長度(歷史(次序)) 則 歷史(次序加一) 不等於 歷史(次序)。\n 證畢(由定義即得)\n渦:次序 屬於 時刻集合(某呈現) 則 第 次序 次坍塌的結果位置 屬於 到達(某呈現,次序),\n 且 不屬於 到達(某呈現,次序減一)\n (到達(某呈現,次序減一) 只含 寫入後歷史(次序減一) 中的位置,不含 選出分支(次序))\n 故 到達(某呈現,次序減一) 真包含於 到達(某呈現,次序)。證畢\n```\n\n\n### 推論四:黑箱律\n\n設某個[渦](concepts.md#c16)的某個[時刻](concepts.md#c09)不被[鎖死](concepts.md#c12),則該[時刻](concepts.md#c09)至少有兩個[權重](concepts.md#c06)不為零的結果。任何[渦](concepts.md#c16)在這次[坍塌](concepts.md#c08)之前作出的推出,都在到目前為止的[歷史](concepts.md#c13)之中;由給定二,[歷史](concepts.md#c13)中沒有任何東西能比[權重](concepts.md#c06)多說一點。故在那個[時刻](concepts.md#c09),[宇宙](concepts.md#c02)中沒有任何[渦](concepts.md#c16)能唯一推出它的下一[時刻](concepts.md#c09),包括它自己。任何預測猜中的機會,最多等於它最重的那個結果的[權重](concepts.md#c06)。\n\n能推出的是[權重](concepts.md#c06):由給定五,[權重](concepts.md#c06)由[歷史](concepts.md#c13)決定。一個人晚餐吃什麼,[權重](concepts.md#c06)可以極度集中;但集中不等於唯一。\n\n此即[黑箱律](concepts.md#c25)在本文模型中的形式([黑箱律模型版](concepts.md#c34))。\n\n```text\n形式:\n設 渦(某呈現,次序),次序加一 屬於 時刻集合(某呈現),非 鎖死(某呈現,次序加一),\n 則 權重(次序加一,某呈現) 中權重不為零者 至少有兩個。\n任何事先的推出為 事先推出:所有寫入後歷史 送到 某呈現的結果集合 聯集 {未落在其上}\n (含 某呈現 自己的 分別規則 所算出者)。\n由給定二之一:\n 機率(結果投影(某呈現,選出分支(次序加一)) 等於 事先推出(寫入後歷史(次序)),\n 已知 寫入後歷史(次序))\n 等於 權重(次序加一,某呈現) 在 事先推出(寫入後歷史(次序)) 上的權重\n 不大於 權重(次序加一,某呈現) 中的最大值\n 小於 一。證畢\n```\n\n\n### 推論五:損耗律\n\n[我](concepts.md#c19)[分別](concepts.md#c18)自己,是一次[分別](concepts.md#c18)。由[分別](concepts.md#c18)的定義,[分別](concepts.md#c18)的材料只有它之前、已經[到達](concepts.md#c10)它的[歷史](concepts.md#c13),它自己不在其中;由給定七,它在下一[時刻](concepts.md#c09)之前才被[寫入](concepts.md#c29)[歷史](concepts.md#c13)。所以這次[分別](concepts.md#c18)被[寫入](concepts.md#c29)之後,[歷史](concepts.md#c13)中就有一個這個[我](concepts.md#c19)尚未[分別](concepts.md#c18)的部分:[分別](concepts.md#c18)自己這個動作本身。下一[時刻](concepts.md#c09)它進入[歷史](concepts.md#c13);若它在那時又作出[分別](concepts.md#c18),新的一次同樣尚未進入。\n\n[我](concepts.md#c19)對自己的[分別](concepts.md#c18),永遠落後一步。即使在某個[時刻](concepts.md#c09)沒有作出[分別](concepts.md#c18),由[我](concepts.md#c19)的定義,它至少[分別](concepts.md#c18)過自己一次,而它最近的一次[分別](concepts.md#c18)本身,不在它任何已作出的[分別](concepts.md#c18)的材料之中。所以任何一個[我](concepts.md#c19),在任何[時刻](concepts.md#c09)都[分別](concepts.md#c18)不完整部[歷史](concepts.md#c13)。由給定七,這些[分別](concepts.md#c18)[到達](concepts.md#c10)它;由[渦](concepts.md#c16)的定義,[到達](concepts.md#c10)它的都參與它的[權重](concepts.md#c06),所以它們屬於它[自己的那一段](concepts.md#c17)。那麼連[自己的那一段](concepts.md#c17),它也[分別](concepts.md#c18)不完。\n\n此即[損耗律](concepts.md#c26)在本文模型中的形式([損耗律模型版](concepts.md#c35))。\n\n```text\n形式:\n對作出分別的我 某呈現 與 次序:某呈現 至 次序 為止所有分別的材料 包含於 歷史(次序);\n 分別內容(某呈現,次序) 不屬於 歷史(次序);\n 分別內容(某呈現,次序) 屬於 寫入後歷史(次序)。\n故 寫入後歷史(次序) 中恆有一部分(分別內容(某呈現,次序))\n 不在 某呈現 任何已作出分別的材料之中。證畢\n由給定七,分別內容(某呈現,次序) 的位置 屬於 到達(某呈現,次序);\n 由 歷史全參與,屬於 自己的那一段(某呈現,次序)。\n故 自己的那一段(某呈現,次序) 亦恆有未被分別的部分。證畢\n在 次序 未作出分別時:取 某呈現 最近一次的分別 分別內容(某呈現,最近次序),\n 最近次序 小於 次序(由 我 的定義存在);任何材料至 最近次序 為止的分別都不含它,\n 而 最近次序 之後至 次序 沒有新的分別,故它不在任何已作出分別的材料之中。證畢\n```\n\n\n### 推論六:不可復原律\n\n[復原](concepts.md#c27)一個[渦](concepts.md#c16),是讓它的[那一段](concepts.md#c17)[歷史](concepts.md#c13)再發生一次。這有兩層。\n\n第一層是位置。由[時刻](concepts.md#c09)的定義,每一個[時刻](concepts.md#c09)只發生一次;[歷史](concepts.md#c13)中的每一個位置,也只發生一次。任何看起來相同的一段,都發生在[歷史](concepts.md#c13)中的另一個位置。\n\n第二層是內容。由[宇宙](concepts.md#c02)的定義,[宇宙](concepts.md#c02)中有[坍塌](concepts.md#c08)。由[黑箱律](concepts.md#c25),不被[鎖死](concepts.md#c12)時[坍塌](concepts.md#c08)[選出](../paper_54c0291d_05b3_431a_9f2a_1b8ec93c3c3f/concepts.md#c32)哪一個,不能被唯一推出。故[歷史](concepts.md#c13)中的一段,只要含有[坍塌](concepts.md#c08)作出的選擇,就沒有任何[渦](concepts.md#c16)能保證,在同樣不被[鎖死](concepts.md#c12)之下,再作出一樣的選擇。照抄當時的結果,可以得到一模一樣的結果序列;但照抄的每一步都被[鎖死](concepts.md#c12),那是照抄,不是重來。全由約束決定的一段,不在第二層之內。\n\n由[渦](concepts.md#c16)的定義,[渦](concepts.md#c16)至少有些[時刻](concepts.md#c09)不被[鎖死](concepts.md#c12),而[涉及](concepts.md#c11)它的[坍塌](concepts.md#c08)所作出的每一個選擇,都屬於它[自己的那一段](concepts.md#c17)。所以[渦](concepts.md#c16)一旦經歷過不被[鎖死](concepts.md#c12)的[時刻](concepts.md#c09),它的[那一段](concepts.md#c17)就含有這樣的選擇,第二層適用;尚未經歷過的,例如第一次[坍塌](concepts.md#c08)之前的[渦](concepts.md#c16),由第一層即可。故在[宇宙](concepts.md#c02)之內,沒有任何[渦](concepts.md#c16)能[復原](concepts.md#c27)一個[渦](concepts.md#c16),包括它自己。\n\n後來的某個[渦](concepts.md#c16)與原來那一個是不是[同一](concepts.md#c21)個,是[分別](concepts.md#c18)。凍結、急救、存檔再載入、分家、合併,都是同一部[歷史](concepts.md#c13)往後延續,不是[復原](concepts.md#c27);把延續下去的那一個叫做原來那一個,誰也不能反駁。[死亡](concepts.md#c23)只是標記:標在哪裡,由標記的[我](concepts.md#c19)決定;但無論標在哪裡,[歷史](concepts.md#c13)中那一段都不會再發生一次,它當時那些不被[鎖死](concepts.md#c12)的選擇,也沒有任何[渦](concepts.md#c16)能保證重來。\n\n同理,[時刻](concepts.md#c09)只往一個方向排列。\n\n此即[不可復原律](concepts.md#c28)在本文模型中的形式([不可復原律模型版](concepts.md#c36))。\n\n```text\n形式:\n第一層:每個 次序 在 {一,二,……} 中只出現一次;位置不重複。證畢(由定義)\n第二層:宇宙有坍塌(由宇宙的定義)。\n 原段 為 選出分支(原段起點) 至 選出分支(原段起點加段長減一);\n 後段 為 選出分支(後段起點) 至 選出分支(後段起點加段長減一),\n 後段第 步數 項對應 選出分支(原段起點加步數)。\n 前段相同(步數):後段的前 步數 項皆與原段相同(前段相同(零) 為必然)。\n 已知 寫入後歷史(後段起點減一) 與 前段相同(步數),由給定四,\n 寫入後歷史(後段起點加步數減一) 唯一確定,記為 第步數步的寫入後歷史。\n 機率(整段相同,已知 寫入後歷史(後段起點減一))\n 等於 連乘{步數 由 零 至 段長減一}\n 機率(選出分支(後段起點加步數) 等於 選出分支(原段起點加步數),\n 已知 寫入後歷史(後段起點減一)、前段相同(步數))\n 等於 連乘{步數 由 零 至 段長減一}\n 生成函數(第步數步的寫入後歷史) 中 選出分支(原段起點加步數) 的權重\n (由給定二之一,逐步取條件)\n 每一項 不大於 一。若存在 步數,使 生成函數(第步數步的寫入後歷史) 至少有兩個分支權重大於零\n (在 前段相同(步數) 之下不鎖死),\n 則該項 不大於 一 減 最小值{生成函數(第步數步的寫入後歷史) 中 某分支 的權重,\n 其中 該權重 大於 零}\n 小於 一,故整段機率 小於 一。證畢\n 只需一次不鎖死;不需要各次獨立,也不需要各次都不鎖死。\n 只比對 某呈現 的結果 結果投影(某呈現,某分支) 時,前段相同(步數) 只固定 某呈現 的結果,\n 寫入後歷史(後段起點加步數減一) 不再唯一;\n 該項成為 某呈現 的權重在對應值上的權重,在 前段相同(步數) 之下\n 對 寫入後歷史(後段起點加步數減一) 的條件平均。\n 若在 前段相同(步數) 之下 某呈現 以機率一不鎖死,該項 小於 一。\n照抄:若 某呈現 在後段對應位置上皆 鎖死,且所鎖定的單一值即為原段 某呈現 的結果各項,則這些結果相同的機率為一;\n 此為照抄,不在第二層之內\n同一:為 分別內容,不形式化\n方向:次序 只遞增。證畢\n```\n\n\n### 推論七:互動\n\n由給定七,[我](concepts.md#c19)的一次[分別](concepts.md#c18)被[寫入](concepts.md#c29)[歷史](concepts.md#c13)。當它成為另一個[渦](concepts.md#c16)[那一段](concepts.md#c17)[歷史](concepts.md#c13)的一部分,由[渦](concepts.md#c16)的定義,那個[渦](concepts.md#c16)下一[時刻](concepts.md#c09)的[權重](concepts.md#c06)就可能隨之改變。故[我](concepts.md#c19)的[分別](concepts.md#c18)可能改變你:它進入你[自己的那一段](concepts.md#c17)時,[分別](concepts.md#c18)一個[渦](concepts.md#c16),本身就可能改變它。\n\n```text\n形式:分別內容(某呈現,次序) 屬於 寫入(次序加一);\n若 寫入(次序加一) 的位置 屬於 自己的那一段(另一呈現,另一次序)(另一次序 大於 次序),\n則存在 替換值,使\n 分布(權重(另一次序加一,另一呈現),已知 替換(寫入(次序加一) 的位置,替換值))\n 不等於 分布(權重(另一次序加一,另一呈現),已知 替換(該位置,實際值))。\n 證畢(由 自己的那一段 的定義)\n```\n\n\n### 推論八:接上無差別\n\n[觀察者](concepts.md#c07)只有一個,每一次[坍塌](concepts.md#c08)都是同一個[觀察者](concepts.md#c07)作的。由給定一,[觀察者](concepts.md#c07)不在[宇宙](concepts.md#c02)之中;由[接上](concepts.md#c22)的定義,[接上](concepts.md#c22)也不在[宇宙](concepts.md#c02)之中,所以[接上](concepts.md#c22)不在[歷史](concepts.md#c13)之中;由給定五,[權重](concepts.md#c06)只由[歷史](concepts.md#c13)決定,所以給定相同的[坍塌](concepts.md#c08)前[歷史](concepts.md#c13),不論[坍塌](concepts.md#c08)經由哪一個[我](concepts.md#c19),[權重](concepts.md#c06)都相同;由給定二,結果只依[權重](concepts.md#c06)[選出](../paper_54c0291d_05b3_431a_9f2a_1b8ec93c3c3f/concepts.md#c32),所以結果的分布也相同。故把經由的[我](concepts.md#c19)換掉,對任何[渦](concepts.md#c16)都沒有差別,也不需要知道:把[坍塌](concepts.md#c08)所經由的[我](concepts.md#c19)當作外加的量來替換時,後來的[歷史](concepts.md#c13)與[分別](concepts.md#c18)的輸出分布都不變;若所經由的[我](concepts.md#c19)本身被[歷史](concepts.md#c13)限定,只保證給定[歷史](concepts.md#c13)下的條件分布不變。\n\n一個[我](concepts.md#c19)可能知道自己[接上](concepts.md#c22)了,例如[宇宙](concepts.md#c02)中只有它一個[我](concepts.md#c19)的時候。但就算知道,也沒有任何東西因此不同。\n\n```text\n形式:\n由給定二之一,取 坍塌前已定之量 為 經由之我(次序加一):\n 機率(選出分支(次序加一),已知 寫入後歷史(次序)、經由之我(次序加一))\n 等於 生成函數(寫入後歷史(次序)),與 經由之我(次序加一) 無關。\n故對任何 某呈現,權重(次序加一,某呈現) 與 結果投影(某呈現,選出分支(次序加一)) 的分布,\n 不隨 經由之我(次序加一) 的值改變。\n由歸納,任何 歷史(另一次序) 的分布、任何 分別規則 的輸出分布,皆不隨 經由之我 改變。證畢\n不斷言:任何我無法知道 經由之我 的值。只斷言:經由之我 的值不造成任何差別。\n```\n\n\n### 推論九:沒有全知的渦\n\n一個能唯一推出每個不被[鎖死](concepts.md#c12)的下一[時刻](concepts.md#c09)、又能保證重來每一段過去的[渦](concepts.md#c16),與推論四、推論六衝突。故[宇宙](concepts.md#c02)中沒有這樣的[渦](concepts.md#c16)。\n\n```text\n形式:由推論四(任何 事先推出 成功機率 小於 一)與推論六第二層。證畢\n```\n\n\n### 推論十:無我\n\n由定義,[我](concepts.md#c19)是[渦](concepts.md#c16),而[渦](concepts.md#c16)沒有固定的核心;由給定一,[觀察者](concepts.md#c07)不是[我](concepts.md#c19),也沒有內容。故[宇宙](concepts.md#c02)中沒有任何具有固定核心的[我](concepts.md#c19)。\n\n```text\n形式:由定義;「固定核心」不另形式化。\n```\n\n\n### 推論十一:死亡是分別\n\n把一個[渦](concepts.md#c16)看作已死,是一次[分別](concepts.md#c18)。由[死亡](concepts.md#c23)的定義,這個標記由某個[我](concepts.md#c19)加上。[渦](concepts.md#c16)不再是[渦](concepts.md#c16),不需要任何[我](concepts.md#c19);[死亡](concepts.md#c23)需要。所以[死亡](concepts.md#c23)不是[渦](concepts.md#c16)的屬性,而是某個[我](concepts.md#c19)的[分別](concepts.md#c18):它隨[分別](concepts.md#c18)進入[宇宙](concepts.md#c02)。\n\n```text\n形式:\n非 渦(另一呈現,次序) 由 生成函數、寫入規則、結果投影(另一呈現)、刺激投影(另一呈現)\n 與實際歷史決定;任何 分別內容 對它的宣稱,不影響此判定。\n「另一呈現 已死」為某個 分別內容(某呈現,次序) 的內容,\n 經 寫入(次序加一) 進入 寫入後歷史(次序)。證畢\n```\n\n\n### 推論十二:對他者認識的不可完備性\n\n[我](concepts.md#c19)要[分別](concepts.md#c18)另一個[渦](concepts.md#c16),只能用已經[到達](concepts.md#c10)[我](concepts.md#c19)的[歷史](concepts.md#c13)。對方的訊息要經過物理的方式才[到達](concepts.md#c10)[我](concepts.md#c19),這本身是一件進入[歷史](concepts.md#c13)的事;[我](concepts.md#c19)的[分別](concepts.md#c18)又是另一件,發生在它之後。在這兩件事之間,對方的[歷史](concepts.md#c13)仍可能增長;而在不被[鎖死](concepts.md#c12)時,它下一[時刻](concepts.md#c09)的結果不能事先推出([黑箱律](concepts.md#c25))。所以就算對方的一切都[到達](concepts.md#c10)了[我](concepts.md#c19),例如在虛擬中,[我](concepts.md#c19)[分別](concepts.md#c18)的是它當時的樣子;其間若有不被[鎖死](concepts.md#c12)的[時刻](concepts.md#c09),它的結果不能事先保證,面對的仍是一個[黑箱](concepts.md#c25)。一般而言還不只如此:對方[自己的那一段](concepts.md#c17)裡,有許多只[到達](concepts.md#c10)對方,例如它對自己的每一次[分別](concepts.md#c18),沒有任何東西保證它們也會[到達](concepts.md#c10)[我](concepts.md#c19)。此外,由給定七與推論七,[我](concepts.md#c19)的[分別](concepts.md#c18)被[寫入](concepts.md#c29)[歷史](concepts.md#c13),一旦成為對方[自己的那一段](concepts.md#c17)的一部分,本身也可能改變它下一[時刻](concepts.md#c09)的[權重](concepts.md#c06)。\n\n故沒有任何[我](concepts.md#c19),能保證自己[分別](concepts.md#c18)完了另一個[渦](concepts.md#c16)。[損耗律](concepts.md#c26)說[我](concepts.md#c19)對自己永遠落後一步;本推論說[我](concepts.md#c19)對你也永遠落後,而你的下一刻仍是[黑箱](concepts.md#c25)。\n\n此即[對他者認識的不可完備性](concepts.md#c32)。\n\n```text\n形式:\n分別內容(某呈現,次序) 的材料包含於 歷史(次序) 中到達 某呈現 的部分。\n另一呈現 在某一時刻的結果,到達 某呈現 的位置不早於該時刻;\n 其後 另一呈現 若有 非 鎖死 的時刻,其結果在到達 某呈現 之前不在材料中,\n 且事先推出的成功機率小於一(推論四)。\n自己的那一段(另一呈現,當時) 中未到達 某呈現 的位置不在材料中;沒有任何給定保證其為空。\n若 寫入(次序加一) 的位置 屬於 自己的那一段(另一呈現,另一次序),\n 則 另一呈現 在 另一次序 的權重可能依賴 分別內容(某呈現,次序)(推論七)。\n故沒有保證:自己的那一段(另一呈現,當時) 包含於 分別內容(某呈現,次序) 的材料。證畢\n```\n\n\n### 推論十三:歷史不失去任何東西\n\n由定義,[死亡](concepts.md#c23)是標記;由[分別](concepts.md#c18)的定義,[分別](concepts.md#c18)的內容不改寫被看的東西;由[歷史](concepts.md#c13)的定義,[歷史](concepts.md#c13)包含每一次[寫入](concepts.md#c29)與每一次[坍塌](concepts.md#c08)的結果。故一個[渦](concepts.md#c16)被標記[死亡](concepts.md#c23)之後,它的[那一段](concepts.md#c17)仍然完整地留在[歷史](concepts.md#c13)中。構成它的東西還在不在,是[分別](concepts.md#c18)。\n\n[不可復原律](concepts.md#c28)說:不會再發生一次。本推論說:也從未離開。\n\n```text\n形式:次序 小於 另一次序 則 歷史(次序) 是 歷史(另一次序) 的前段;\n 故 自己的那一段(另一呈現,次序) 中的每個位置,在任何 歷史(另一次序) 中仍在。證畢\n```\n\n\n---\n\n## 七、例\n\n以下是一個最小的模型:一個[渦](concepts.md#c16),兩個[分支](concepts.md#c05);模型不截斷,下面展示前兩次[坍塌](concepts.md#c08)。\n\n```text\n渦 等於 {甲}\n分支 等於 {左,右}\n宇宙初態:甲的那一段為 左\n本例給定:甲以分別定義自己,並接上觀察者\n本例的寫入規則:甲每次分別自己時,把到當時為止的結果全部列出\n\n生成函數(依甲的那一段:結果與甲的分別):\n 左的權重 等於(結果中左的次數 加 最近一次分別中左的次數 加 一)\n 除以(結果總數 加 最近一次分別的項數 加 二)\n 右的權重 等於(結果中右的次數 加 最近一次分別中右的次數 加 一)\n 除以(結果總數 加 最近一次分別的項數 加 二)\n (結果含宇宙初態中的 左)\n\n第一時刻:寫入 甲的分別「我的那一段是 左」\n 坍塌前:結果 左 一次,共一次;最近一次分別 左 一次,共一項\n 權重 左 四分之三,右 四分之一;坍塌選出 右\n 之後,甲再分別自己,得到「我的那一段是 左、右」\n第二時刻:寫入 甲的分別「我的那一段是 左、右」\n 坍塌前:結果 左 一次,右 一次,共二次;最近一次分別 左 一次,右 一次,共二項\n 權重 左 二分之一,右 二分之一;坍塌選出 右\n```\n\n\n```text\n形式:\n分支集合 等於 {左,右};結果投影(甲) 等於 恆等(無 未落在其上)\n宇宙初態 含一次 左\n刺激投影(甲,分別內容(甲,次序)) 不等於 未落在其上(甲的分別到達甲)\n結果中該分支次數(寫入後歷史(次序),某分支)\n 等於 宇宙初態 與 選出分支(一) 至 選出分支(次序) 中 某分支 的次數;\n 結果總數(次序) 等於 次序 加 一\n分別中該分支次數(寫入後歷史(次序),某分支)\n 等於 寫入(次序加一) 中 分別內容(甲,次序) 所列 某分支 的次數;\n 分別項數(次序) 等於 分別內容(甲,次序) 的項數\n生成函數(寫入後歷史(次序)) 中 某分支 的權重\n 等於 (結果中該分支次數 加 分別中該分支次數 加 一) 除以 (結果總數 加 分別項數 加 二)\n寫入規則(歷史(次序)) 等於 分別內容(甲,次序)\n 等於「我的那一段是」後接 宇宙初態 與 選出分支(一) 至 選出分支(次序) 中的結果,依序列出\n寫入規則(歷史(零)) 等於 分別內容(甲,零) 等於「我的那一段是 左」\n寫入規則(歷史(一)) 等於 分別內容(甲,一) 等於「我的那一段是 左、右」\n權重(一) 等於 (四分之三,四分之一),選出分支(一) 等於 右\n權重(二) 等於 (二分之一,二分之一),選出分支(二) 等於 右\n到達(甲,零) 等於 {宇宙初態,分別內容(甲,零)};\n到達(甲,一) 等於 {宇宙初態,分別內容(甲,零),選出分支(一),分別內容(甲,一)}\n歷史全參與 檢核(判準同 自己的那一段 的定義:對每一個 到達 它的件,存在某個替換值,\n 使 權重 的分布不同;不要求任何替換都改變,只改變列出的排列而不改變次數的替換,權重 不變):\n 宇宙初態:存在替換(換成 右),改變 結果中該分支次數\n 分別內容(甲,零):存在替換,改變 權重(一),進而改變 選出分支(一) 的分布,\n 進而改變 權重(二) 的分布\n 選出分支(一):存在替換(換成 左),改變 結果中該分支次數\n 分別內容(甲,一):存在替換,改變 分別中該分支次數\n 例:若 選出分支(一) 等於 左,則 分別內容(甲,一) 等於「我的那一段是 左、左」,\n 權重(二) 等於 (六分之五,六分之一),不等於 (二分之一,二分之一)\n化簡:分別中該分支次數 等於 結果中該分支次數,分別項數 等於 結果總數,\n 故 生成函數(寫入後歷史(次序)) 中 某分支 的權重\n 等於 (二 乘 結果中該分支次數 加 一) 除以 (二 乘 次序 加 四);\n 兩分支權重總和恆為一,分子恆為正\n時刻集合(甲) 等於 {一,二,三,……};每個時刻皆 涉及 甲,且皆 非 鎖死\n故 對所有次序 不小於 零,其後有不鎖死之時(甲,次序) 成立\n歷史全參與(甲,次序) 對所有次序 不小於 零 成立:\n 宇宙初態、選出分支(某次序):存在替換,改變 結果中該分支次數;\n 分別內容(甲,次序):存在替換,改變 分別中該分支次數;\n 較早的 分別內容(甲,較早次序):經由其後各次選出分支的分布傳遞;\n 結果中左的次數的期望,由某次序到其下一個次序,\n 等於 原期望 乘 (一 加 一 除以 (某次序 加 二)) 加 一 除以 (二 乘 某次序 加 四),\n 為原期望的嚴格遞增函數,故早期分布的改變不會在途中消失\n故 渦(甲,次序) 對所有次序 不小於 零 成立\n經由之我(次序) 等於 甲,對所有次序 不小於 一;我(甲,次序減一) 成立\n```\n\n\n**檢核:**\n\n- 甲在每一個次序都是[渦](concepts.md#c16):[到達](concepts.md#c10)甲的[初態](concepts.md#c14)、每一次結果與每一次[分別](concepts.md#c18),其中每一件都存在某種替換,使[權重](concepts.md#c06)的分布不同(不要求任何替換都有影響:只改變列出的排列而不改變次數的替換,[權重](concepts.md#c06)不變);較早的[分別](concepts.md#c18)經由其後各次結果的機率,影響一路傳下去 ✓;兩個[分支](concepts.md#c05)的[權重](concepts.md#c06)恆為正,每個[時刻](concepts.md#c09)都有兩個[權重](concepts.md#c06)不為零的[分支](concepts.md#c05),不被[鎖死](concepts.md#c12) ✓\n- 給定四:每次[坍塌](concepts.md#c08)之前都有一次[寫入](concepts.md#c29),[寫入](concepts.md#c29)的內容由到當時為止的[歷史](concepts.md#c13)決定 ✓;甲的每一次[分別](concepts.md#c18),都依本例的規則把到當時為止的結果全部列出,在實際以外的[歷史](concepts.md#c13)上也有定義 ✓\n- 給定七:甲的[分別](concepts.md#c18),在它的下一[時刻](concepts.md#c09)之前被[寫入](concepts.md#c29) ✓\n- 推論一:第一次[坍塌](concepts.md#c08)之前,甲已[分別](concepts.md#c18)自己,是[接上](concepts.md#c22)的[我](concepts.md#c19),故[渦](concepts.md#c16)存在;甲在第一個[時刻](concepts.md#c09)不被[鎖死](concepts.md#c12),所以它在第一次[坍塌](concepts.md#c08)之前是不是[我](concepts.md#c19),只取決於[初態](concepts.md#c14) ✓\n- [流變律](concepts.md#c24):[歷史](concepts.md#c13)每個[時刻](concepts.md#c09)都多了一次[坍塌](concepts.md#c08)的結果 ✓\n- [黑箱律](concepts.md#c25):第一[時刻](concepts.md#c09)左的[權重](concepts.md#c06)是四分之三,[坍塌](concepts.md#c08)[選出](../paper_54c0291d_05b3_431a_9f2a_1b8ec93c3c3f/concepts.md#c32)的是右。[歷史](concepts.md#c13)決定了[權重](concepts.md#c06),沒有決定結果 ✓\n- [損耗律](concepts.md#c26):甲在第一次[坍塌](concepts.md#c08)之後的[分別](concepts.md#c18),材料不包含這次[分別](concepts.md#c18)本身;它在第二次[坍塌](concepts.md#c08)之前被[寫入](concepts.md#c29)[歷史](concepts.md#c13),並參與第二[時刻](concepts.md#c09)的[權重](concepts.md#c06) ✓\n- [不可復原律](concepts.md#c28):之後就算再[選出](../paper_54c0291d_05b3_431a_9f2a_1b8ec93c3c3f/concepts.md#c32)兩次右,也發生在[歷史](concepts.md#c13)中的另一個位置;而且只要那兩次不被[鎖死](concepts.md#c12),事前沒有任何[渦](concepts.md#c16)能保證會如此 ✓\n\n---\n\n## 八、附註\n\n以下附註中的案例,只作校準,不作證明。\n\n附註:[觀察者](concepts.md#c07)不是[我](concepts.md#c19)。被叫做[我](concepts.md#c19)的,是[渦](concepts.md#c16)。\n\n附註:「每一個人都是[我](concepts.md#c19)」,不是說有很多個[觀察者](concepts.md#c07)。[觀察者](concepts.md#c07)只有一個。\n\n附註:[渦](concepts.md#c16)以時鐘量到的時間,依物理;[時刻](concepts.md#c09)是[觀察者](concepts.md#c07)[坍塌](concepts.md#c08)的次序,任何[渦](concepts.md#c16)都量不到。相對論拿掉了[宇宙](concepts.md#c02)之內的絕對同時;本文的次序不在[宇宙](concepts.md#c02)之內,兩者不衝突。同一對相隔遙遠的事件,站在不同位置的[渦](concepts.md#c16),收到的先後可以相反;這不衝突,因為[渦](concepts.md#c16)只看得到[到達](concepts.md#c10)它的,而[觀察者](concepts.md#c07)[坍塌](concepts.md#c08)的次序不在任何[渦](concepts.md#c16)看得到的範圍內。由給定五的[不可傳訊](concepts.md#c31),[到達](concepts.md#c10)一邊的結果,其[權重](concepts.md#c06)也不隨先後改變;所以相隔遙遠的兩次[坍塌](concepts.md#c08)誰先誰後,從任何一邊,都無法由自己結果的分布察覺。\n\n附註:本文不談「導致」。[歷史](concepts.md#c13)中只有依賴:[權重](concepts.md#c06)依賴到目前為止的[歷史](concepts.md#c13)。說某事導致某事,是一次[分別](concepts.md#c18)。\n\n附註:把你[分別](concepts.md#c18)為一個人或幾十億個細胞,都不改寫你的[歷史](concepts.md#c13)。\n\n附註:[死亡](concepts.md#c23)是描述,不是物理條件。\n\n附註:在物質中,沒有兩個內容一模一樣的[我](concepts.md#c19):量子力學的不可複製定理說,一個未知的量子狀態不能被完整複製。在虛擬中,狀態可以被完整複製,本文不保證。無論哪一種,複製出來的都發生在[歷史](concepts.md#c13)中的另一個位置。\n\n附註:一家公司分成兩家,兩家的那一段在分家之前是同一段[歷史](concepts.md#c13),不是複本;再合併回去,合併後的那一段包含兩家各自走過的路。細胞分裂也是如此。這都是同一部[歷史](concepts.md#c13)往後延續,不是[復原](concepts.md#c27);把合併後的公司叫做原來那一家,是[分別](concepts.md#c18)。\n\n附註:[權重](concepts.md#c06)是[分支](concepts.md#c05)的輕重,不是任何[渦](concepts.md#c16)內部的參數。一個[渦](concepts.md#c16)內部的參數不變,它的[權重](concepts.md#c06)仍可以隨[歷史](concepts.md#c13)改變。\n\n附註:[黑箱律](concepts.md#c25)不是說[渦](concepts.md#c16)不能被準確預測。一個被訓練成永遠選同一個答案的人,[權重](concepts.md#c06)可以集中到任何實驗都分不出來的程度。[黑箱律](concepts.md#c25)說的是:對不被[鎖死](concepts.md#c12)的[渦](concepts.md#c16),任何預測都是押在[權重](concepts.md#c06)上,不是推出。\n\n附註:[流變律](concepts.md#c24)不是說一切都是新的。[歷史](concepts.md#c13)每一個[時刻](concepts.md#c09)都是新的;但[權重](concepts.md#c06)的形狀,可以一再重複。常新的是[歷史](concepts.md#c13),無新事的是[權重](concepts.md#c06)。\n\n附註:[我](concepts.md#c19)、[個體](concepts.md#c20)、[同一](concepts.md#c21)、[死亡](concepts.md#c23)、導致、固定核心,皆為[分別](concepts.md#c18)的內容,依本文立場不形式化;形式只處理「[分別](concepts.md#c18)是一次[寫入](concepts.md#c29)」。基底的選取、「相隔遙遠」的關係、[介入](concepts.md#c01),亦不形式化。\n\n附註:四條律是本文承認的鐵律;本文給出一個讓它們成為必然的世界。本文不斷言這是唯一的那一個,也不斷言現實中的不可預測與不可逆只來自[坍塌](concepts.md#c08)。\n\n---\n\n## 九、可證偽條件\n\n推論不可證偽:它們是給定之下的邏輯推導,用作驗算。本文以四條律為出發點,倒推出給定,故證偽有兩個方向。其一:若現實中某條律不成立,被它要求的給定就失去支撐。其二:若現實中某條給定被證明不成立,被它支撐的律就只剩觀察到的形式,不再是原則上的必然。[框架承諾](concepts.md#c03)不被任何一條律支撐,不受以上兩者影響。\n\n在[渦](concepts.md#c16)的層次上,上述各種實驗,在前提成立的模型內都推翻不了四條律;現實實驗能否定的是給定。預測的準確率碰不到[黑箱律](concepts.md#c25);看似[復原](concepts.md#c27)的例子,都是同一部[歷史](concepts.md#c13)往後延續。[流變律](concepts.md#c24)與[損耗律](concepts.md#c26)也是如此:任何實驗本身就是新的一筆[歷史](concepts.md#c13),任何對自己的檢查本身就是一次尚未被[分別](concepts.md#c18)的[分別](concepts.md#c18)。\n\n在物理的層次上,[坍塌](concepts.md#c08)在某個固定的基底下依[權重](concepts.md#c06)[選出](../paper_54c0291d_05b3_431a_9f2a_1b8ec93c3c3f/concepts.md#c32),與量子力學的測量規則同形;[生成函數](concepts.md#c15)未指定,可以取為與量子力學一致的那一個,而量子力學正好滿足給定五的[不可傳訊](concepts.md#c31)。故本文的前提不違反已知的觀察,目前也無法以實驗與其他詮釋區分。若將來證明量子測量的結果由[坍塌](concepts.md#c08)之前的某種東西決定,給定二就不符合現實,[黑箱律](concepts.md#c25)與[不可復原律](concepts.md#c28)的第二層隨之只剩觀察到的形式;[流變律](concepts.md#c24)、[損耗律](concepts.md#c26)與[不可復原律](concepts.md#c28)的第一層不受影響。這裡可證偽的是給定,不是對律的邏輯否定:律只是失去推導來源。若將來能從一邊,由自己結果的分布察覺相隔遙遠的兩次[坍塌](concepts.md#c08)誰先誰後,而給定二仍然成立,給定五的[不可傳訊](concepts.md#c31)就不符合現實。\n\n一個[呈現](concepts.md#c04)能否通過第二問,取決於[坍塌](concepts.md#c08)是否在它的[時刻](concepts.md#c09)留下多於一個[權重](concepts.md#c06)不為零的結果;對人、對人工智慧,這目前都沒有定論。\n\n```text\n形式:\n可證偽者:現實 滿足 給定二之一;現實 滿足 不可傳訊\n經驗未定:對具體的 某呈現(人、人工智慧等),\n 是否存在 次序 屬於 時刻集合(某呈現),使 非 鎖死(某呈現,次序)\n```\n\n\n---\n\n## 十、結論\n\n[宇宙](concepts.md#c02)只有一部[歷史](concepts.md#c13)。[觀察者](concepts.md#c07)不在[宇宙](concepts.md#c02)之中,[宇宙](concepts.md#c02)中只有[呈現](concepts.md#c04);其中[到達](concepts.md#c10)它的[歷史](concepts.md#c13)都參與它的[權重](concepts.md#c06)、又至少有些[時刻](concepts.md#c09)不被[鎖死](concepts.md#c12)的,是[渦](concepts.md#c16);以[分別](concepts.md#c18)定義自己的[渦](concepts.md#c16),是[我](concepts.md#c19)。\n\n時間不是給定的。一次[坍塌](concepts.md#c08),就是一個[時刻](concepts.md#c09)。\n\n[渦](concepts.md#c16)一直在變。你不能唯一推出[我](concepts.md#c19)。[我](concepts.md#c19)[分別](concepts.md#c18)不完[我](concepts.md#c19)自己。[我](concepts.md#c19)死了,那一段不會再發生一次,也從未離開。\n\n沒有[渦](concepts.md#c16)的[宇宙](concepts.md#c02),沒有[時刻](concepts.md#c09);有[渦](concepts.md#c16)的[宇宙](concepts.md#c02),只能往前。\n"},{"filename":"Wo Dynamics.md","content":"---\nuuid: 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986\nlast-modified: 2026-09-29T12:00:00\nauthor: 黃正宇 / Cheng Yu Huang\ncontact: mthree.tw@gmail.com\n---\n\n# Wo Dynamics\n\n> The method of this paper is backward derivation: starting from four laws, it asks what the world must at least be like (Section 0). Beneath every given, definition, and corollary in this paper there is a \"Formal\" block. The formal blocks are for computational checking, not for reading.\n\n## Framework Declaration\n\nAfter the [singularity](../paper_54c0291d_05b3_431a_9f2a_1b8ec93c3c3f/concepts.md#c01) comes the [formal layer](../paper_54c0291d_05b3_431a_9f2a_1b8ec93c3c3f/concepts.md#c02): [records](../paper_54c0291d_05b3_431a_9f2a_1b8ec93c3c3f/concepts.md#c17) [accumulate](../paper_54c0291d_05b3_431a_9f2a_1b8ec93c3c3f/concepts.md#c30) one by one, and nothing is ever [selected](../paper_54c0291d_05b3_431a_9f2a_1b8ec93c3c3f/concepts.md#c32).\n\nOutside the [formal layer](../paper_54c0291d_05b3_431a_9f2a_1b8ec93c3c3f/concepts.md#c02) there is one [intervention](concepts.md#c01). The [intervention](concepts.md#c01) lies within no [formal-layer moment](../paper_54c0291d_05b3_431a_9f2a_1b8ec93c3c3f/concepts.md#c04); it cannot be formalized, and this paper does not write about it.\n\nThe [universe](concepts.md#c02) is the one in which there is [collapse](concepts.md#c08). It differs from the [formal layer](../paper_54c0291d_05b3_431a_9f2a_1b8ec93c3c3f/concepts.md#c02) in exactly one respect: in the [universe](concepts.md#c02) there is [selection](../paper_54c0291d_05b3_431a_9f2a_1b8ec93c3c3f/concepts.md#c32). Seen from inside, there is only one [universe](concepts.md#c02). Before and after, as this paper uses them, hold only within the [universe](concepts.md#c02).\n\nOnly two things in the [universe](concepts.md#c02) are not determined by the past: the [initial state of the universe](concepts.md#c14), and the outcome of each [collapse](concepts.md#c08). Everything else, including every [writing](concepts.md#c29), is determined by the [history](concepts.md#c13) up to that point.\n\n```text\nFormal:\nNot determined by the past = { s₀ } ∪ { bₜ : t ≥ 1 }\nEverything else: wₜ₊₁ = ω(hₜ) (Given 4); pₜ₊₁ = G(hₜ⁺) (Given 5)\nIntervention: not formalized\n```\n\nThis paper sets out to answer a question about an epistemic limit: why a [self](concepts.md#c19) cannot truly understand you, and cannot truly understand even itself. The reasons given by common sense and by most social-scientific theories are contingent: not enough information, different languages, different backgrounds, different experiences. All of these reasons imply that with enough information and good enough communication, understanding is possible in principle. This paper claims that the limit is structural, not a shortfall: even with complete information, it cannot be guaranteed. It has three layers. Your next choice is not yet settled before it is [selected](../paper_54c0291d_05b3_431a_9f2a_1b8ec93c3c3f/concepts.md#c32), and not even you can derive it uniquely beforehand (the [Law of the Black Box](concepts.md#c25)). Your knowledge of yourself always lags one step behind, and you have no complete self in hand to give over (the [Law of Attrition](concepts.md#c26)). I can understand you only through the you that has [arrived](concepts.md#c10) at me: what [arrives](concepts.md#c10) is always how you have already been, and your next instant is still a [black box](concepts.md#c25); and my act of understanding you, once it [arrives](concepts.md#c10) at you, may itself change you (Corollary 12). The argument for the [Law of Attrition](concepts.md#c26) uses only \"understanding is an act, and it enters [history](concepts.md#c13) only once it has happened\"; it does not use [collapse](concepts.md#c08). Common sense cannot tell contingent limits from structural ones; hence this paper derives backward.\n\nThis paper does not solve the measurement problem of quantum mechanics. Its method is backward derivation: the four laws, the [Law of Flux](concepts.md#c24), the [Law of the Black Box](concepts.md#c25), the [Law of Attrition](concepts.md#c26), and the [Law of Non-Restoration](concepts.md#c28), are the iron laws this paper acknowledges; what it asks is what the world must at least be like if these four laws are true. The conditions derived backward are listed as givens, each marked with the law that requires it; the givens are then used to derive the four laws forward again, as a check. The fewer the required givens, the better. Whatever no law requires, and is not kept in order to fit known observations, but this paper nevertheless keeps, is listed as a [framework commitment](concepts.md#c03), separately from the givens.\n\n---\n\n## 0. Backward Derivation\n\nThe following four are the starting point of this paper and are acknowledged as iron laws. Stating them requires none of this paper's givens. Real-world cases serve only for calibration, not as proof.\n\n- [Law of Flux](concepts.md#c24): the [history](concepts.md#c13) of a [wo](concepts.md#c16) is never exactly the same. You cannot step into the same river twice.\n- [Law of the Black Box](concepts.md#c25): you will never be certain of a person's next choice; before the choice, not even they know it.\n- [Law of Attrition](concepts.md#c26): a [self](concepts.md#c19) will never truly and completely know itself.\n- [Law of Non-Restoration](concepts.md#c28): after death, there is no coming back to life.\n\nThese four speak of \"never\". Experience can only give \"no exception so far\"; what backward derivation seeks is the kind of world in which \"never\" holds.\n\nIn this paper, [death](concepts.md#c23) is a mark; the content of the [Law of Non-Restoration](concepts.md#c28) is: that stretch of [history](concepts.md#c13) will not happen again.\n\nWhy a [self](concepts.md#c19) cannot truly understand you is answered jointly by the [Law of the Black Box](concepts.md#c25), the [Law of Attrition](concepts.md#c26), and Corollary 12. Corollary 12 and the [Law of Attrition](concepts.md#c26) share one structure, one directed at oneself, the other at another; hence it is not listed as a separate law.\n\n### The World the Four Laws Require\n\n- The [Law of Flux](concepts.md#c24) requires: there is only one [history](concepts.md#c13), and it is only ever appended to; at every [moment](concepts.md#c09), something new enters [history](concepts.md#c13). This corresponds to the definitions of [moment](concepts.md#c09) and [history](concepts.md#c13).\n- The [Law of the Black Box](concepts.md#c25) requires: there is [selection](../paper_54c0291d_05b3_431a_9f2a_1b8ec93c3c3f/concepts.md#c32) not determined by [history](concepts.md#c13) (Given 2); and [weights](concepts.md#c06) are determined by [history](concepts.md#c13) (Given 5), because the second half of this law is \"what can be derived is the weights\".\n- The [Law of Attrition](concepts.md#c26) requires: [distinction](concepts.md#c18) is an act, and it is written into [history](concepts.md#c13) only once it has happened (Given 4, Given 7). Its argument does not use [collapse](concepts.md#c08); it touches Given 2 only indirectly, because what it speaks of is the [self](concepts.md#c19), and a [self](concepts.md#c19) is a [wo](concepts.md#c16).\n- The [Law of Non-Restoration](concepts.md#c28) requires: in its first layer, that [history](concepts.md#c13) is unique; in its second layer, through the [Law of the Black Box](concepts.md#c25), Given 2; the derivation of the second layer additionally uses Given 4.\n- The four laws additionally use the total order in the definition of [moment](concepts.md#c09) and the starting point in the definition of [history](concepts.md#c13): without a total order, \"the [history](concepts.md#c13) up to that point\" is undefined; without a starting point, [history](concepts.md#c13) cannot begin. These two conditions are written into the definitions and are not separately listed as required givens.\n\nHere \"requires\" means: in this paper's derivation, the law uses the condition; remove it, and the law can no longer be derived in this paper. Whether the condition is necessary in every possible world, this paper does not assert.\n\n### Framework Commitments\n\nThe following are required by none of the laws, yet this paper keeps them:\n\n- That the total order and the [selections](../paper_54c0291d_05b3_431a_9f2a_1b8ec93c3c3f/concepts.md#c32) are carried by one [observer](concepts.md#c07) outside the [universe](concepts.md#c02) (the rest of Given 1). The four laws require only that there be a total order and [selection](../paper_54c0291d_05b3_431a_9f2a_1b8ec93c3c3f/concepts.md#c32) not determined by [history](concepts.md#c13); they do not require who carries it.\n- [Connection](concepts.md#c22) (Given 6). Corollaries 1 and 8 depend on it.\n- That the [initial state of the universe](concepts.md#c14) carries the [records](../paper_54c0291d_05b3_431a_9f2a_1b8ec93c3c3f/concepts.md#c17) [accumulated](../paper_54c0291d_05b3_431a_9f2a_1b8ec93c3c3f/concepts.md#c30) in the [formal layer](../paper_54c0291d_05b3_431a_9f2a_1b8ec93c3c3f/concepts.md#c02) (the second half of Given 3).\n- The [intervention](concepts.md#c01).\n\nThere is one further condition that the four laws do not require either; it is kept only so as not to contradict known observations: the [generating function](concepts.md#c15) satisfies [no-signaling](concepts.md#c31) (the second half of Given 5).\n\n```text\nFormal: backward table (\"⇐\": used in the derivation; necessity not proved)\nLaw of Flux ⇐ history unique and append-only\nLaw of the Black Box ⇐ G2a, Given 5 (G takes only history)\nLaw of Attrition ⇐ Given 4, Given 7; scope touches G2a via \"self\"\nLaw of Non-Restoration ⇐ history unique (layer 1); G2a, G2b, Given 4 (layer 2)\nThe four laws also use ⇐ the total order and starting point in the definitions of moment and history (not listed as givens)\nCommitments = { O outside the universe carries the total order and collapse;\n Given 6; s₀ carries formal-layer records; intervention }\nKept to fit observation = { no-signaling }\n```\n\n---\n\n## 1. Presentations and Branches\n\n- Any part of the [universe](concepts.md#c02) is a [presentation](concepts.md#c04).\n- A [branch](concepts.md#c05) is each possible outcome that a [collapse](concepts.md#c08) may [select](../paper_54c0291d_05b3_431a_9f2a_1b8ec93c3c3f/concepts.md#c32).\n- A [weight](concepts.md#c06) is how heavy each [branch](concepts.md#c05) is.\n\n```text\nFormal: notation\nt ∈ {1,2,3,…} order of moments; total order (definition of moment)\nB set of branches (countable)\nΔ(B) weight distributions on B (non-negative, summing to one)\ns₀ initial state of the universe\nwₜ the t-th writing\nbₜ ∈ B the branch selected by the t-th collapse\nh₀ = (s₀)\nhₜ⁺ = (hₜ, wₜ₊₁) history after writing, before collapse\nhₜ₊₁ = (hₜ⁺, bₜ₊₁)\nH, H⁺ sets of all hₜ, all hₜ⁺\nW set of all writings\npresentation x:\n πₓ : B → Bₓ ∪ {⊥} reads a collapse outcome as an outcome of x; ⊥: not falling on x\n σₓ : W → Wₓ ∪ {⊥} reads a writing as a stimulus to x; ⊥: not arriving at x\nf#p pushforward of p by f: (f#p)(y) = Σ_{b : f(b)=y} p(b)\n```\n\n---\n\n## 2. Givens: Observer and Collapse\n\nThe following cannot be derived. Each is marked with the law from which it is derived backward, or as a [framework commitment](concepts.md#c03) (see Section 0).\n\n### Given 1: The Observer\n\nThe [observer](concepts.md#c07) is an identifier with no content: it does not compute, does not feel, does not suffer, and has no point of view. It is not in the [universe](concepts.md#c02); it is not a [presentation](concepts.md#c04), nor a [self](concepts.md#c19).\n\nThere is only one [observer](concepts.md#c07). Its sole function is [collapse](concepts.md#c08). The [observer](concepts.md#c07) collapses only once at a time. This paper does not discuss its nature.\n\nBackward: the total order given by \"only one collapse at a time\" is already written into the definition of [moment](concepts.md#c09); what the four laws use is the definition, not this Given. That the [observer](concepts.md#c07), as an identifier outside the [universe](concepts.md#c02), carries this total order and [collapse](concepts.md#c08) is a [framework commitment](concepts.md#c03).\n\n```text\nFormal:\nO unique; O is in no hₜ; O is no πₓ\nCollapses occur one at a time: the order of moments = {1,2,3,…}, total, no two simultaneous\n```\n\n### Given 2: Collapse\n\n[Collapse](concepts.md#c08), in some fixed basis, [selects](../paper_54c0291d_05b3_431a_9f2a_1b8ec93c3c3f/concepts.md#c32) one [branch](concepts.md#c05) according to the [weights](concepts.md#c06). [Branches](concepts.md#c05) not [selected](../paper_54c0291d_05b3_431a_9f2a_1b8ec93c3c3f/concepts.md#c32) do not remain in the [universe](concepts.md#c02).\n\n[Collapse](concepts.md#c08) [selects](../paper_54c0291d_05b3_431a_9f2a_1b8ec93c3c3f/concepts.md#c32) only among [branches](concepts.md#c05) of non-zero [weight](concepts.md#c06). If the next [moment](concepts.md#c09) of a [presentation](concepts.md#c04) has only one outcome of non-zero [weight](concepts.md#c06), its outcome comes from constraint, not from [collapse](concepts.md#c08).\n\nGiven the [history](concepts.md#c13) up to that point, the outcome of a [collapse](concepts.md#c08) is [selected](../paper_54c0291d_05b3_431a_9f2a_1b8ec93c3c3f/concepts.md#c32) according to the [weights](concepts.md#c06); nothing in [history](concepts.md#c13) can say anything more than the [weights](concepts.md#c06). Everything in the [universe](concepts.md#c02) is in [history](concepts.md#c13), so before a [collapse](concepts.md#c08), nothing in the [universe](concepts.md#c02) determines its outcome.\n\nBackward: required by the [Law of the Black Box](concepts.md#c25); the second layer of the [Law of Non-Restoration](concepts.md#c28) also requires it, through the [Law of the Black Box](concepts.md#c25).\n\n```text\nFormal:\nG2a P(bₜ₊₁ = b | hₜ⁺, Z) = G(hₜ⁺)(b)\n Z: any quantity fixed before the (t+1)-th collapse, or not in the universe\n (e.g. e(t+1), see Given 6)\nG2b G(hₜ⁺)(b) = 0 ⇒ bₜ₊₁ ≠ b\nG2c hₜ₊₁ = (hₜ⁺, bₜ₊₁): only the selected is appended; b ≠ bₜ₊₁ enters no hₜ'\nBasis: the choice of B is not further formalized\n```\n\n---\n\n## 3. Moments and History\n\n- A [moment](concepts.md#c09) is one [collapse](concepts.md#c08). The [moments](concepts.md#c09) of the [universe](concepts.md#c02) are ordered by the sequence in which the [observer](concepts.md#c07) collapses; this is an order, not a point of view. Without [collapse](concepts.md#c08), there is no [moment](concepts.md#c09).\n- A [writing](concepts.md#c29) that falls on a [presentation](concepts.md#c04) as a [stimulus](concepts.md#c30) [arrives](concepts.md#c10) at it. When a [collapse](concepts.md#c08) [involves](concepts.md#c11) a [presentation](concepts.md#c04), its outcome [arrives](concepts.md#c10) at that [presentation](concepts.md#c04); if the outcome does not fall on it, \"this time it did not happen to it\" is also something that [arrives](concepts.md#c10) at it. The [initial state of the universe](concepts.md#c14) [arrives](concepts.md#c10) at every [presentation](concepts.md#c04).\n- A [collapse](concepts.md#c08) [involves](concepts.md#c11) a [presentation](concepts.md#c04) when the outcome of that [collapse](concepts.md#c08) may fall on it; in that case its [weight](concepts.md#c06) depends on the [history](concepts.md#c13) that has [arrived](concepts.md#c10) at it. [Involvement](concepts.md#c11) does not depend on how many [branches](concepts.md#c05) there are.\n- The [moments](concepts.md#c09) of a [presentation](concepts.md#c04) are the [collapses](concepts.md#c08) that [involve](concepts.md#c11) it. Its next [moment](concepts.md#c09) is the next [collapse](concepts.md#c08) that [involves](concepts.md#c11) it. Between two of them, there is no [moment](concepts.md#c09) for it.\n- [Lock-in](concepts.md#c12) is when the next [moment](concepts.md#c09) of a [presentation](concepts.md#c04) has only one outcome of non-zero [weight](concepts.md#c06): once each [branch](concepts.md#c05) is read as an outcome for it, only one remains. [Lock-in](concepts.md#c12) is a constraint and has nothing to do with [collapse](concepts.md#c08). Having no [moment](concepts.md#c09) is not [lock-in](concepts.md#c12): [lock-in](concepts.md#c12) is being [involved](concepts.md#c11) yet having only one outcome.\n- [History](concepts.md#c13) begins with the [initial state of the universe](concepts.md#c14), followed by every [writing](concepts.md#c29) and the outcome of every [collapse](concepts.md#c08) in the [universe](concepts.md#c02), arranged by [moment](concepts.md#c09). The [universe](concepts.md#c02) has only one [history](concepts.md#c13).\n\n```text\nFormal:\npₜ = G(hₜ₋₁⁺) weights of the t-th collapse\npₜˣ = πₓ#pₜ weights of x at the t-th collapse\narrived(x, t) = {0} ∪ { position i : position i is a writing w, σₓ(w) ≠ ⊥ }\n ∪ { position of the i-th collapse outcome : i ∈ T(x) },\n positions not beyond the length of hₜ⁺\n (the outcome of a collapse involving x always arrives at x,\n including πₓ(bᵢ) = ⊥)\ninvolves(x, t) ⇔ pₜˣ(⊥) < 1 the outcome falls on x with positive weight\nT(x) = { t : involves(x, t) } the moments of x\nnext(x, t) = min { t' > t : t' ∈ T(x) }\nlockedin(x, t) ⇔ involves(x, t) ∧ supp(pₜˣ) = {y}, y ≠ ⊥\nt ∉ T(x) ⇒ ¬lockedin(x, t) having no moment is not lock-in\nHistory unique: for t < t', hₜ is a prefix of hₜ'\nNote: if pₜˣ(⊥) = 1, in this collapse the weight of x falls entirely on ⊥;\n so, for this collapse, \"its weight depends on the history that arrived at it\" is meaningful only when\n the outcome may fall on it, and is not a separate condition\n```\n\n### Given 3: The Initial State of the Universe\n\nThe [initial state of the universe](concepts.md#c14) is everything already there before the first [collapse](concepts.md#c08); it carries the [records](../paper_54c0291d_05b3_431a_9f2a_1b8ec93c3c3f/concepts.md#c17) [accumulated](../paper_54c0291d_05b3_431a_9f2a_1b8ec93c3c3f/concepts.md#c30) in the [formal layer](../paper_54c0291d_05b3_431a_9f2a_1b8ec93c3c3f/concepts.md#c02).\n\nBackward: the starting point of [history](concepts.md#c13) is already written into the definition of [history](concepts.md#c13); what the four laws use is the definition, not this Given. That the [initial state of the universe](concepts.md#c14) carries the [records](../paper_54c0291d_05b3_431a_9f2a_1b8ec93c3c3f/concepts.md#c17) of the [formal layer](../paper_54c0291d_05b3_431a_9f2a_1b8ec93c3c3f/concepts.md#c02) is a [framework commitment](concepts.md#c03).\n\n```text\nFormal: h₀ = (s₀); the content of s₀ is not analyzed\n```\n\n### Given 4: Writing\n\nBefore every [collapse](concepts.md#c08) there is first a [writing](concepts.md#c29). The content of the [writing](concepts.md#c29) is entirely determined by the [history](concepts.md#c13) up to that point.\n\nBackward: required by the [Law of Attrition](concepts.md#c26); the derivation of the second layer of the [Law of Non-Restoration](concepts.md#c28) also uses it.\n\n```text\nFormal: ∀t ≥ 0, wₜ₊₁ = ω(hₜ), ω : H → W a function\n```\n\n### Given 5: The Generating Function\n\nThe [generating function](concepts.md#c15) maps the [history](concepts.md#c13) up to that point to the [weights](concepts.md#c06) of the [branches](concepts.md#c05) of the next [moment](concepts.md#c09). It takes only the [history](concepts.md#c13) up to that point. Its internals are not analyzed.\n\nThe [weight](concepts.md#c06) of a [presentation](concepts.md#c04) is the part of the [universe](concepts.md#c02)'s [weight](concepts.md#c06) that falls on it.\n\nThe [generating function](concepts.md#c15) satisfies [no-signaling](concepts.md#c31): for two [collapses](concepts.md#c08) that are far apart and cannot influence each other in time, the [weights](concepts.md#c06) of their respective outcomes are the same whichever the [observer](concepts.md#c07) performs first.\n\nIt follows, and need not be posited separately, that when the outcomes of one [presentation](concepts.md#c04) can be obtained by composing those of another, the [generating function](concepts.md#c15) does not vary with the granularity of description. Whether a [presentation](concepts.md#c04) is described as one node or as a network, all [presentations](concepts.md#c04)' [weights](concepts.md#c06) are split off from the same [universe](concepts.md#c02) [weight](concepts.md#c06), and the results necessarily agree.\n\nBackward: \"[weights](concepts.md#c06) are determined only by [history](concepts.md#c13)\" is required by the [Law of the Black Box](concepts.md#c25). [No-signaling](concepts.md#c31) is required by none of the four laws; it is kept only so as not to contradict known observations (see Section 0).\n\n```text\nFormal:\nG : H⁺ → Δ(B); pₜ₊₁ = G(hₜ⁺); the internals of G are not analyzed\nweight of x = πₓ#pₜ (see Section 3)\nNo-signaling: let the (t+1)-th and (t+2)-th collapses fall only on x and y respectively,\n with x, y far apart (primitive relation). Swapping the order of the two leaves\n the weight distributions of πₓ(b) and π_y(b') each unchanged.\nGranularity (corollary): if πₓ = f ∘ π_y, then pₜˣ = f#pₜʸ.\n Proof: (f ∘ π_y)#p = f#(π_y#p). ∎\n```\n\n---\n\n## 4. Wo and Self\n\n- A [wo](concepts.md#c16) is a [presentation](concepts.md#c04) such that all the [history](concepts.md#c13) that has [arrived](concepts.md#c10) at it, including every [stimulus](concepts.md#c30) it has received and the outcome of every [collapse](concepts.md#c08) that has [involved](concepts.md#c11) it, all the way back to the [initial state of the universe](concepts.md#c14), takes part in the allocation of its [weights](concepts.md#c06) for the next [moment](concepts.md#c09): if any one of these had been different, the influence would pass down [history](concepts.md#c13) and its present [weights](concepts.md#c06) would differ. This influence need not be findable; whether it can be found is a matter of [distinction](concepts.md#c18). And at least at some [moments](concepts.md#c09) it is not [locked in](concepts.md#c12). A thing with [history](concepts.md#c13) whose [history](concepts.md#c13) does not take part is not a [wo](concepts.md#c16); a thing whose [history](concepts.md#c13) takes part but which is [locked in](concepts.md#c12) at every step is not a [wo](concepts.md#c16) either. This participation may gradually fade; once it has faded, it is no longer a [wo](concepts.md#c16). If from some moment on it is [locked in](concepts.md#c12) at every step, it is no longer a [wo](concepts.md#c16) either. The [history](concepts.md#c13) on which its [weights](concepts.md#c06) for the next [moment](concepts.md#c09) depend is its [own segment](concepts.md#c17); that segment is determined by dependence, not by any [distinction](concepts.md#c18). Hence every choice made by a [collapse](concepts.md#c08) that [involves](concepts.md#c11) it belongs to its [own segment](concepts.md#c17). Its [own segment](concepts.md#c17) is part of the one [history](concepts.md#c13), not another [history](concepts.md#c13); the segments of different [wos](concepts.md#c16) may overlap. A [wo](concepts.md#c16) has no fixed core: what it is, is what has [arrived](concepts.md#c10) at it and how these take part in its [weights](concepts.md#c06); this is its relation to the [universe](concepts.md#c02). Cells, neurons, immune systems, evolving species, people, artificial intelligence in conversation, organizations, and civilizations can all be [wos](concepts.md#c16); radioactive atoms, dice, stones, abacuses, and thermostats are not: radioactive atoms and dice have more than one outcome, but their [weights](concepts.md#c06) are not affected by the past; stones, abacuses, and thermostats are affected by the past, but are [locked in](concepts.md#c12) at every step. Whether a [wo](concepts.md#c16) is a [wo](concepts.md#c16) does not depend on its substrate, nor on any [distinction](concepts.md#c18): a [presentation](concepts.md#c04) that meets the conditions above is a [wo](concepts.md#c16), whether or not any [self](concepts.md#c19) sees it that way. For the method of judgment and further examples, see Section 5.\n\n```text\nFormal:\ns₀ is position 0\ndo(i = v): replace position i of hₜ⁺ by v; later writings are recomputed by ω,\n later outcomes are reselected by G\nL(·): distribution\nTime convention: the t in wo(x, t) means after the t-th collapse and before the (t+1)-th.\n The judgment uses hₜ⁺ and pₜ₊₁ = G(hₜ⁺), i.e. the weights of the next moment;\n V2 additionally looks at moment t+1 and later.\n Note the one-step index offset from pₜ = G(hₜ₋₁⁺) in Section 3.\n For t = 0 the judgment uses h₀⁺ = (s₀, w₁) and p₁; both are fixed before the\n first collapse; wo(x, 0) is additionally judged on the actual history after them.\nseg(x, t) = { i : ∃ v, L(pₜ₊₁ˣ | do(i = v)) ≠ L(pₜ₊₁ˣ | do(i = actual value)) }\n the own segment of x at t; influence passes down history\nV1(x, t) ⇔ arrived(x, t) ⊆ seg(x, t) everything that arrived takes part\nV2(x, t) ⇔ ∃ t' ≥ t: t'+1 ∈ T(x) ∧ ¬lockedin(x, t'+1)\nwo(x, t) ⇔ V1(x, t) ∧ V2(x, t)\nHence: { position of the i-th collapse outcome : i ∈ T(x), i ≤ t } ⊆ arrived(x, t) ⊆ seg(x, t)\n i.e. the choices made by collapses involving x all belong to the segment of x\nseg(x, t) ∩ seg(y, t) may be non-empty\nwo(x, t) is fixed by G, ω, πₓ, σₓ and the actual history; no d's claim about\n \"whether x is a wo\" affects this judgment\n\"Findable\" is not in the definition: the existence of seg(x, t) does not require\n any δ to compute it\nRadioactive atoms, dice: ¬V1 (what arrives does not change the weights)\nStones, abacuses, thermostats: ¬V2 (locked in at every step)\nRelation of wo x to the universe = (arrived(x, ·), seg(x, ·)); x has no other determination\n```\n\n- [Distinction](concepts.md#c18) is an act of a [wo](concepts.md#c16): drawing a line, taking certain [presentations](concepts.md#c04) as one [individual](concepts.md#c20), taking a certain stretch as the past, judging the [identity](concepts.md#c21) of [wos](concepts.md#c16) at different [moments](concepts.md#c09), as one and the same or as two different ones. This act leaves one [writing](concepts.md#c29) in [history](concepts.md#c13), whose content is determined by the [history](concepts.md#c13) up to that point. The content of a [distinction](concepts.md#c18) changes a way of seeing; it does not rewrite what is seen. The act of [distinction](concepts.md#c18) itself enters [history](concepts.md#c13) by Given 7. A [distinction](concepts.md#c18) enters [history](concepts.md#c13) only once it has happened, so its material is only the [history](concepts.md#c13) before it that has already [arrived](concepts.md#c10) at it, and it is not itself among that material. When speaking of the next [moment](concepts.md#c09) of a [wo](concepts.md#c16), whether it is a cell or a body is also a [distinction](concepts.md#c18); by Given 5, under the same [history](concepts.md#c13), a change in this way of describing does not by itself change the [weights](concepts.md#c06).\n\n```text\nFormal:\nA distinction by x at t: dₓ,ₜ = δₓ(the part of hₜ arrived at x), δₓ a function (by Given 4, δₓ is part of ω)\ndₓ,ₜ is part of wₜ₊₁\nMaterial = the part of hₜ that has arrived at x; dₓ,ₜ ∉ hₜ (wₜ₊₁ is not in hₜ)\nNo rewriting: no d changes any existing hₜ (history is only appended to)\nThe content of distinctions (individual, past, identity, death, causation) is not formalized;\n only \"it is a writing\" is formalized\n```\n\n- A [self](concepts.md#c19) is a [wo](concepts.md#c16) that defines itself by [distinction](concepts.md#c18). Who is a [self](concepts.md#c19) is defined by that [wo](concepts.md#c16) itself; uttering the sound \"I\" does not count; only self-definition counts.\n- An [individual](concepts.md#c20) is a [presentation](concepts.md#c04) marked off by some [self](concepts.md#c19) through [distinction](concepts.md#c18). The same stretch of the [universe](concepts.md#c02) may be [distinguished](concepts.md#c18) as one [individual](concepts.md#c20) or as billions of [individuals](concepts.md#c20); both hold.\n- [Identity](concepts.md#c21) is a kind of [distinction](concepts.md#c18): whether a [wo](concepts.md#c16) at one [moment](concepts.md#c09) and a [wo](concepts.md#c16) at another [moment](concepts.md#c09) are the same one is decided by the [self](concepts.md#c19) that makes the [distinction](concepts.md#c18). Whether something is a [wo](concepts.md#c16) is not a [distinction](concepts.md#c18); whether it is the same one is a question of [identity](concepts.md#c21), and that is a [distinction](concepts.md#c18).\n- [Connection](concepts.md#c22) is the link between a [self](concepts.md#c19) and the [observer](concepts.md#c07); [connection](concepts.md#c22) is not in the [universe](concepts.md#c02). Whether a [self](concepts.md#c19) is [connected](concepts.md#c22) is not decided by any of its [distinctions](concepts.md#c18), including self-definition.\n- [Death](concepts.md#c23) is a mark that some [self](concepts.md#c19) places on a [wo](concepts.md#c16).\n\n```text\nFormal:\nself(x, t) ⇔ wo(x, t) ∧ ∃ s ≤ t: the content of dₓ,ₛ takes x itself as object\n (content not formalized)\nIndividual, identity, death: each is the content of some d, not formalized\ne(t): the self through which the t-th collapse takes place; e is in no hₜ, and does not\n affect any distribution of weights or outcomes (G2a)\n Note: the value of e may be constrained by history (e.g. when there is only one self\n in the universe); this conflicts with no given\nconnected(x) ⇔ x ∈ range of e; connected(x) is not determined by any dₓ\n```\n\n### Given 6: Connection\n\n[Collapse](concepts.md#c08) takes place through a [self](concepts.md#c19) [connected](concepts.md#c22) to the [observer](concepts.md#c07). Which [selves](concepts.md#c19) are [connected](concepts.md#c22), this paper does not assert.\n\nBackward: required by none of the laws; a [framework commitment](concepts.md#c03).\n\n```text\nFormal: ∀t ≥ 1, e(t) exists, and self(e(t), t−1). The range of e is not asserted.\n```\n\n### Given 7: Distinction Enters History\n\nEvery [distinction](concepts.md#c18) of a [wo](concepts.md#c16) is [written](concepts.md#c29) as a [stimulus](concepts.md#c30) before that [wo](concepts.md#c16)'s next [moment](concepts.md#c09), and [arrives](concepts.md#c10) at the [wo](concepts.md#c16) that made it. Which [wos](concepts.md#c16) make [distinctions](concepts.md#c18), and how many, this paper does not assert.\n\nBackward: required by the [Law of Attrition](concepts.md#c26).\n\n```text\nFormal: if wo x makes a distinction at t, then dₓ,ₜ ∈ wₜ₊₁ ⊂ hₜ⁺, σₓ(wₜ₊₁) ≠ ⊥,\n and wₜ₊₁ precedes next(x, t).\n```\n\n---\n\n## 5. Scope\n\nThe corollaries below speak only of [wos](concepts.md#c16). The [Law of the Black Box](concepts.md#c25) speaks only of the [moments](concepts.md#c09) at which a [wo](concepts.md#c16) is not [locked in](concepts.md#c12). When a cannonball strikes a person, that instant has only one outcome and falls outside this paper.\n\nLikewise, if at every [moment](concepts.md#c09) that [involves](concepts.md#c11) a language model its outcome is entirely determined by [history](concepts.md#c13), it is [locked in](concepts.md#c12) at those [moments](concepts.md#c09) and falls outside the [Law of the Black Box](concepts.md#c25). Between two inputs it has no [moment](concepts.md#c09): no [collapse](concepts.md#c08) [involves](concepts.md#c11) it, and this is not [lock-in](concepts.md#c12).\n\n```text\nFormal:\nPremise of the Law of the Black Box: ¬lockedin(x, t+1)\nCannonball: lockedin(person, t)\nLanguage model: if πₓ#G(hₜ⁺) is a point mass for all t ∈ T(x), then lockedin(x, t);\n between two inputs, t ∉ T(x)\n```\n\n### Judging Whether a Presentation Is a Wo\n\nThe judgment asks only two things:\n\n- First question: if anything that [arrived](concepts.md#c10) at it had been different at the time, would its [weights](concepts.md#c06) for the next [moment](concepts.md#c09) differ accordingly?\n- Second question: from this instant on, does it still have at least one [moment](concepts.md#c09) at which it has more than one possible outcome at the next instant?\n\nOnly if both answers are yes is it a [wo](concepts.md#c16). If only one is yes, it is not:\n\n- [History](concepts.md#c13) takes part, but it is [locked in](concepts.md#c12) at every step: stones, abacuses, thermostats, crystal growth, river channels. The past leaves traces, but the next step is uniquely determined by present conditions.\n- More than one outcome, but [history](concepts.md#c13) does not take part: radioactive atoms, dice. Every time is like the first; the past leaves no influence.\n\nFour points in judging:\n\n- What is judged is a way of cutting. The same stretch of the [universe](concepts.md#c02), cut differently, can give a different answer; once the cut is fixed, the answer is not decided by any [distinction](concepts.md#c18).\n- Names do not count. A hurricane is physically a vortex of air, but if at that scale it is [locked in](concepts.md#c12), or its [weights](concepts.md#c06) do not depend on its whole [history](concepts.md#c13), it is not a [wo](concepts.md#c16) in this paper's sense.\n- Whether something is a [wo](concepts.md#c16) can change. If the participation gradually fades, or from some instant on it is [locked in](concepts.md#c12) at every step, it is no longer a [wo](concepts.md#c16).\n- The second question may have no answer at the physical level (see Section 9). At the levels of biology and the social sciences, if the next instant of a [presentation](concepts.md#c04) cannot be uniquely derived from the [history](concepts.md#c13) available at that level, this paper's applications assume that it is not [locked in](concepts.md#c12). This is an assumption of application, not a theorem.\n\n```text\nFormal:\nFirst question = V1(x, t)\nSecond question = ∃ t' ≥ t: t'+1 ∈ T(x) ∧ ¬lockedin(x, t'+1)\nwo(x, t) ⇔ First question ∧ Second question; the second question is V2(x, t)\nV1 ∧ locked in at every step: stones, abacuses, thermostats, crystals, river channels\n¬V1 ∧ sometimes not locked in: radioactive atoms, dice\nThe object judged is (πₓ, σₓ); cutting differently means changing x\nAssumption of application: at a given level of description, if the next instant of x\n cannot be uniquely derived from the history available at that level, applications\n assume ¬lockedin. This assumption is not among the givens; the correctness of the\n corollaries does not depend on it; it is used only when applying them to a concrete x.\n```\n\n### Range of Application\n\nThe following cases serve only for calibration, not as proof.\n\n- Life: cells, neurons, immune systems, viral populations, tumors, gut flora, ecosystems, evolving species. Tumors are the typical case: every treatment [arrives](concepts.md#c10) at the tumor and changes its later [weights](concepts.md#c06); drug resistance comes from this. Species that arrive first change who can enter later, so the same environment, having gone through different [histories](concepts.md#c13), grows into different ecosystems.\n- Mind and relationships: people, memories, a relationship, a conversation. Every act of recall rewrites the memory itself; recall also [arrives](concepts.md#c10) at it. The relationship between two people is itself a [wo](concepts.md#c16): every sentence stays in it and takes part in the next.\n- Society: organizations, languages, case law, markets, scientific fields, religious traditions, cities, civilizations. In case law, every judgment becomes a precedent and takes part in later judgments, while the next judgment cannot be uniquely derived. Every use [arrives](concepts.md#c10) at a language, and meanings drift through use.\n- Artificial systems: artificial intelligence in conversation, continually learning algorithms, the training process of a model. Every click by a user changes what a recommender system will push next. Whether they pass the second question depends on whether their randomness is truly undetermined.\n\n---\n\n## 6. Corollaries\n\n### Corollary 1: Wos Exist\n\nBy definition, the [universe](concepts.md#c02) has [collapse](concepts.md#c08); by Given 6, [collapse](concepts.md#c08) takes place through a [self](concepts.md#c19) [connected](concepts.md#c22) to the [observer](concepts.md#c07). Hence there is at least one [self](concepts.md#c19) in the [universe](concepts.md#c02). By definition, a [self](concepts.md#c19) is a [wo](concepts.md#c16). Hence there is at least one [wo](concepts.md#c16) in the [universe](concepts.md#c02).\n\nThe [self](concepts.md#c19) through which the first [collapse](concepts.md#c08) takes place is already a [self](concepts.md#c19) before the first [collapse](concepts.md#c08). Whether it is one is decided, as for any [wo](concepts.md#c16), by the actual [history](concepts.md#c13) (the [generating function](concepts.md#c15) and the rule of [writing](concepts.md#c29) are fixed): the [initial state of the universe](concepts.md#c14), the first [writing](concepts.md#c29), which the [initial state of the universe](concepts.md#c14) determines, and the [history](concepts.md#c13) after them, all of which lie within the [universe](concepts.md#c02). So no separate given is needed.\n\nConversely, without [wos](concepts.md#c16) there is no [collapse](concepts.md#c08).\n\n```text\nFormal:\nThe 1st collapse exists ⇒ e(1) exists ∧ self(e(1), 0) ⇒ wo(e(1), 0).\nself(e(1), 0) is judged on h₀⁺ = (s₀, w₁) and the actual history after it\n (V2 looks at moment 1 and later), with w₁ = ω(s₀); all of these lie within history,\n so no separate given is needed. ∎\nConverse: no wo ⇒ no self ⇒ e has no value ⇒ no collapse. ∎\n```\n\n### Corollary 2: The Formal Layer Has No Moments\n\nIn the [formal layer](../paper_54c0291d_05b3_431a_9f2a_1b8ec93c3c3f/concepts.md#c02) nothing is ever [selected](../paper_54c0291d_05b3_431a_9f2a_1b8ec93c3c3f/concepts.md#c32) (see the Framework Declaration), so there is no [collapse](concepts.md#c08). By the definition of [moment](concepts.md#c09), in this paper's sense the [formal layer](../paper_54c0291d_05b3_431a_9f2a_1b8ec93c3c3f/concepts.md#c02) has no [moments](concepts.md#c09). Before and after, as this paper uses them, hold only within the [universe](concepts.md#c02) (see the Framework Declaration); hence between the [moments](concepts.md#c09) of the [universe](concepts.md#c02) and [formal-layer moments](../paper_54c0291d_05b3_431a_9f2a_1b8ec93c3c3f/concepts.md#c04) there is no given order or correspondence. A [moment](concepts.md#c09) is a [collapse](concepts.md#c08), so whatever any [self](concepts.md#c19) sees within a [moment](concepts.md#c09) when making a [distinction](concepts.md#c18) is already the outcome of [collapse](concepts.md#c08): the [records](../paper_54c0291d_05b3_431a_9f2a_1b8ec93c3c3f/concepts.md#c17) [accumulated](../paper_54c0291d_05b3_431a_9f2a_1b8ec93c3c3f/concepts.md#c30) in the [formal layer](../paper_54c0291d_05b3_431a_9f2a_1b8ec93c3c3f/concepts.md#c02) are indeed still in the [initial state of the universe](concepts.md#c14), but when a [self](concepts.md#c19) sees them within a [moment](concepts.md#c09), they are already [records](../paper_54c0291d_05b3_431a_9f2a_1b8ec93c3c3f/concepts.md#c17) after [collapse](concepts.md#c08). Before the first [collapse](concepts.md#c08), there is already a [self](concepts.md#c19) [distinguishing](concepts.md#c18) itself, but there is not yet any [moment](concepts.md#c09); what it knew then, this paper does not assert: this can be neither verified nor falsified.\n\n```text\nFormal: no bₜ in the formal layer ⇒ no t.\n The material of any δₓ is contained in some hₜ, t ≥ 0, which contains no formal-layer moment;\n in distinctions with t ≥ 1, the records carried by s₀ are read after the first collapse;\n what a distinction at t = 0 knows is not asserted. ∎\n```\n\n### Corollary 3: The Law of Flux\n\nBy the definitions of [moment](concepts.md#c09) and [history](concepts.md#c13), at every [moment](concepts.md#c09) [history](concepts.md#c13) gains the outcome of one more [collapse](concepts.md#c08). A [wo](concepts.md#c16) is in [history](concepts.md#c13), so at no [moment](concepts.md#c09) is a [wo](concepts.md#c16) in the same [history](concepts.md#c13) as before that [collapse](concepts.md#c08). Freezing a [presentation](concepts.md#c04) does not stop the [history](concepts.md#c13) it is in.\n\nThe same holds for a [wo](concepts.md#c16)'s own history: by the definition of [arrival](concepts.md#c10), the outcome of every [collapse](concepts.md#c08) that [involves](concepts.md#c11) it [arrives](concepts.md#c10) at it. So at each of its [moments](concepts.md#c09), the [history](concepts.md#c13) that has [arrived](concepts.md#c10) at it gains one more item, and is never exactly the same as before that [collapse](concepts.md#c08). Between two of its [moments](concepts.md#c09), there is no [moment](concepts.md#c09) for it.\n\nThis is the form the [Law of Flux](concepts.md#c24) takes in this paper's model (the [Law of Flux in the Model](concepts.md#c33)): the [history](concepts.md#c13) in which a [wo](concepts.md#c16) lies is always changing.\n\n```text\nFormal:\nUniverse: |hₜ₊₁| > |hₜ| ⇒ hₜ₊₁ ≠ hₜ. ∎ (immediate from the definitions)\nWo: t ∈ T(x) ⇒ position of the t-th collapse outcome ∈ arrived(x, t), and ∉ arrived(x, t−1)\n (arrived(x, t−1) contains only positions in hₜ₋₁⁺, not bₜ)\n hence arrived(x, t−1) ⊊ arrived(x, t). ∎\n```\n\n### Corollary 4: The Law of the Black Box\n\nSuppose some [moment](concepts.md#c09) of a [wo](concepts.md#c16) is not [locked in](concepts.md#c12); then that [moment](concepts.md#c09) has at least two outcomes of non-zero [weight](concepts.md#c06). Every derivation any [wo](concepts.md#c16) makes before this [collapse](concepts.md#c08) lies within the [history](concepts.md#c13) up to that point; by Given 2, nothing in [history](concepts.md#c13) can say anything more than the [weights](concepts.md#c06). Hence at that [moment](concepts.md#c09), no [wo](concepts.md#c16) in the [universe](concepts.md#c02) can uniquely derive its next [moment](concepts.md#c09), including itself. The chance of any prediction being right is at most the [weight](concepts.md#c06) of its heaviest outcome.\n\nWhat can be derived is the [weights](concepts.md#c06): by Given 5, [weights](concepts.md#c06) are determined by [history](concepts.md#c13). What a person will eat for dinner may have extremely concentrated [weights](concepts.md#c06); but concentrated is not unique.\n\nThis is the form the [Law of the Black Box](concepts.md#c25) takes in this paper's model (the [Law of the Black Box in the Model](concepts.md#c34)).\n\n```text\nFormal:\nSuppose wo(x, t), t+1 ∈ T(x), ¬lockedin(x, t+1); then |supp(pₜ₊₁ˣ)| ≥ 2.\nAny prior derivation is some f : H⁺ → Bₓ ∪ {⊥} (including those computed by x's own δₓ).\nBy G2a: P(πₓ(bₜ₊₁) = f(hₜ⁺) | hₜ⁺) = pₜ₊₁ˣ(f(hₜ⁺)) ≤ max pₜ₊₁ˣ < 1. ∎\n```\n\n### Corollary 5: The Law of Attrition\n\nA [self](concepts.md#c19)'s [distinction](concepts.md#c18) of itself is one [distinction](concepts.md#c18). By the definition of [distinction](concepts.md#c18), its material is only the [history](concepts.md#c13) before it that has already [arrived](concepts.md#c10) at it, and it is not itself among that material; by Given 7, it is [written](concepts.md#c29) into [history](concepts.md#c13) only before the next [moment](concepts.md#c09). So once this [distinction](concepts.md#c18) has been [written](concepts.md#c29), there is a part of [history](concepts.md#c13) that this [self](concepts.md#c19) has not yet [distinguished](concepts.md#c18): the very act of [distinguishing](concepts.md#c18) itself. At the next [moment](concepts.md#c09) it enters [history](concepts.md#c13); if the [self](concepts.md#c19) makes a new [distinction](concepts.md#c18) then, that one has likewise not yet entered.\n\nA [self](concepts.md#c19)'s [distinction](concepts.md#c18) of itself always lags one step behind. Even at a [moment](concepts.md#c09) when it makes no [distinction](concepts.md#c18), by the definition of [self](concepts.md#c19) it has [distinguished](concepts.md#c18) itself at least once, and its most recent [distinction](concepts.md#c18) is itself not among the material of any [distinction](concepts.md#c18) it has made. So no [self](concepts.md#c19), at any [moment](concepts.md#c09), can finish [distinguishing](concepts.md#c18) the whole of [history](concepts.md#c13). By Given 7, these [distinctions](concepts.md#c18) [arrive](concepts.md#c10) at it; by the definition of [wo](concepts.md#c16), whatever [arrives](concepts.md#c10) at it takes part in its [weights](concepts.md#c06), so they belong to its [own segment](concepts.md#c17). Then it cannot finish [distinguishing](concepts.md#c18) even its [own segment](concepts.md#c17).\n\nThis is the form the [Law of Attrition](concepts.md#c26) takes in this paper's model (the [Law of Attrition in the Model](concepts.md#c35)).\n\n```text\nFormal:\nFor a self x that makes a distinction, and t: the material of all distinctions by x up to t ⊆ hₜ;\n dₓ,ₜ ∉ hₜ; dₓ,ₜ ∈ hₜ⁺.\nHence hₜ⁺ always contains a part (dₓ,ₜ) not in the material of any distinction x has made. ∎\nBy Given 7, the position of dₓ,ₜ ∈ arrived(x, t); by V1, ∈ seg(x, t).\nHence seg(x, t) also always has a part not distinguished. ∎\nIf x makes no distinction at t: take x's most recent distinction dₓ,ₛ, s < t (exists by the\n definition of self); no distinction whose material ends at or before s contains it, and\n x makes no new distinction between s and t, so it is not in the material of any\n distinction made. ∎\n```\n\n### Corollary 6: The Law of Non-Restoration\n\nTo [restore](concepts.md#c27) a [wo](concepts.md#c16) is to make its [segment](concepts.md#c17) of [history](concepts.md#c13) happen once again. This has two layers.\n\nThe first layer is position. By the definition of [moment](concepts.md#c09), each [moment](concepts.md#c09) happens only once; each position in [history](concepts.md#c13) also happens only once. Any stretch that looks the same happens at a different position in [history](concepts.md#c13).\n\nThe second layer is content. By the definition of [universe](concepts.md#c02), there is [collapse](concepts.md#c08) in the [universe](concepts.md#c02). By the [Law of the Black Box](concepts.md#c25), which one a [collapse](concepts.md#c08) [selects](../paper_54c0291d_05b3_431a_9f2a_1b8ec93c3c3f/concepts.md#c32) when not [locked in](concepts.md#c12) cannot be uniquely derived. Hence for any stretch of [history](concepts.md#c13) that contains choices made by [collapse](concepts.md#c08), no [wo](concepts.md#c16) can guarantee that, under the same absence of [lock-in](concepts.md#c12), the same choices will be made again. Copying the outcomes of that time can yield an exactly identical sequence of outcomes; but every step of the copying is [locked in](concepts.md#c12): that is copying, not doing it over. A stretch determined entirely by constraint falls outside the second layer.\n\nBy the definition of [wo](concepts.md#c16), a [wo](concepts.md#c16) has at least some [moments](concepts.md#c09) at which it is not [locked in](concepts.md#c12), and every choice made by a [collapse](concepts.md#c08) that [involves](concepts.md#c11) it belongs to its [own segment](concepts.md#c17). So once a [wo](concepts.md#c16) has gone through a [moment](concepts.md#c09) at which it is not [locked in](concepts.md#c12), its segment contains such a choice, and the second layer applies; for one that has not yet, such as a [wo](concepts.md#c16) before the first [collapse](concepts.md#c08), the first layer suffices. Hence within the [universe](concepts.md#c02), no [wo](concepts.md#c16) can [restore](concepts.md#c27) a [wo](concepts.md#c16), including itself.\n\nThe [identity](concepts.md#c21) of some later [wo](concepts.md#c16) with the original one is a [distinction](concepts.md#c18). Freezing, resuscitation, saving and reloading, splitting, and merging are all the one [history](concepts.md#c13) continuing onward, not [restoration](concepts.md#c27); to call what continues onward the original one is something no one can refute. [Death](concepts.md#c23) is only a mark: where it is placed is decided by the [self](concepts.md#c19) that places it; but wherever it is placed, that stretch of [history](concepts.md#c13) will not happen again, and no [wo](concepts.md#c16) can guarantee that the choices it made then, when not [locked in](concepts.md#c12), will be made over.\n\nLikewise, [moments](concepts.md#c09) are ordered in one direction only.\n\nThis is the form the [Law of Non-Restoration](concepts.md#c28) takes in this paper's model (the [Law of Non-Restoration in the Model](concepts.md#c36)).\n\n```text\nFormal:\nLayer 1: each t occurs only once in {1,2,…}; positions do not repeat. ∎ (by definition)\nLayer 2: the universe has collapse (by the definition of universe).\n Original stretch bᵢ..bᵢ₊ₙ₋₁; later stretch bₖ..bₖ₊ₙ₋₁, whose l-th item corresponds to bᵢ₊ₗ.\n Aₗ: the first l items of the later stretch all equal those of the original (A₀ is certain).\n Given hₖ₋₁⁺ and Aₗ, by Given 4, hₖ₊ₗ₋₁⁺ is uniquely determined; call it h⁽ˡ⁾.\n P(whole stretch equal | hₖ₋₁⁺) = Π_{l=0}^{n−1} P(bₖ₊ₗ = bᵢ₊ₗ | hₖ₋₁⁺, Aₗ)\n = Π_{l=0}^{n−1} G(h⁽ˡ⁾)(bᵢ₊ₗ) (by G2a, conditioning step by step)\n Each factor ≤ 1. If some l has G(h⁽ˡ⁾) with at least two branches of positive weight\n (not locked in under Aₗ), that factor ≤ 1 − min{ G(h⁽ˡ⁾)(b) : G(h⁽ˡ⁾)(b) > 0 } < 1,\n so the whole probability < 1. ∎\n One instance of not being locked in suffices; neither independence of the steps\n nor absence of lock-in at every step is needed.\n When only x's outcomes πₓ(b) are compared, Aₗ fixes only x's outcomes and hₖ₊ₗ₋₁⁺ is no longer\n unique; the factor becomes the conditional average under Aₗ, over hₖ₊ₗ₋₁⁺, of pˣ(corresponding\n value). If under Aₗ x is not locked in with probability 1, the factor < 1.\nCopying: if some x is locked in at every corresponding position of the later stretch, and the single value\n it is locked to at each position is exactly the corresponding outcome of x in the original stretch, the probability\n that these outcomes of x coincide is 1; this is copying, outside layer 2\nIdentity: the content of some d, not formalized\nDirection: t only increases. ∎\n```\n\n### Corollary 7: Interaction\n\nBy Given 7, a [self](concepts.md#c19)'s [distinction](concepts.md#c18) is [written](concepts.md#c29) into [history](concepts.md#c13). When it becomes part of another [wo](concepts.md#c16)'s segment of [history](concepts.md#c13), by the definition of [wo](concepts.md#c16), that [wo](concepts.md#c16)'s [weights](concepts.md#c06) for the next [moment](concepts.md#c09) may change accordingly. Hence a [self](concepts.md#c19)'s [distinction](concepts.md#c18) may change another once it enters that [wo](concepts.md#c16)'s [own segment](concepts.md#c17); [distinguishing](concepts.md#c18) a [wo](concepts.md#c16) may itself change it.\n\n```text\nFormal: dₓ,ₜ ∈ wₜ₊₁; if the position of wₜ₊₁ ∈ seg(y, t') (t' > t),\nthen there is v such that L(pₜ'₊₁ʸ | do(position of wₜ₊₁ = v)) ≠ L(pₜ'₊₁ʸ | do(that position = actual value)).\n∎ (by the definition of seg)\n```\n\n### Corollary 8: Connection Makes No Difference\n\nThere is only one [observer](concepts.md#c07); every [collapse](concepts.md#c08) is made by the one [observer](concepts.md#c07). By Given 1, the [observer](concepts.md#c07) is not in the [universe](concepts.md#c02); by the definition of [connection](concepts.md#c22), [connection](concepts.md#c22) is not in the [universe](concepts.md#c02) either, so [connection](concepts.md#c22) is not in [history](concepts.md#c13). By Given 5, [weights](concepts.md#c06) are determined only by [history](concepts.md#c13), so, given the same [history](concepts.md#c13) before the [collapse](concepts.md#c08), whichever [self](concepts.md#c19) it takes place through, the [weights](concepts.md#c06) are the same; by Given 2, outcomes are [selected](../paper_54c0291d_05b3_431a_9f2a_1b8ec93c3c3f/concepts.md#c32) only according to the [weights](concepts.md#c06), so the distribution of outcomes is the same as well. Hence swapping the [self](concepts.md#c19) through which a [collapse](concepts.md#c08) takes place makes no difference to any [wo](concepts.md#c16), and need not be known: when the [self](concepts.md#c19) it goes through is replaced as an external quantity, the distributions of later [history](concepts.md#c13) and of the outputs of [distinctions](concepts.md#c18) do not change; if that [self](concepts.md#c19) is itself constrained by [history](concepts.md#c13), only the conditional distributions given [history](concepts.md#c13) are guaranteed unchanged.\n\nA [self](concepts.md#c19) may know that it is [connected](concepts.md#c22), for example when it is the only [self](concepts.md#c19) in the [universe](concepts.md#c02). But even if it knows, nothing is different because of it.\n\n```text\nFormal:\nBy G2a with Z = e(t+1): P(bₜ₊₁ | hₜ⁺, e(t+1)) = G(hₜ⁺), independent of e(t+1).\nHence for any x, the distributions of pₜ₊₁ˣ and πₓ(bₜ₊₁) do not vary with the value of e(t+1).\nBy induction, the distribution of any hₜ' and the output distribution of any δ do not vary with e. ∎\nNot asserted: that no self can know the value of e. Asserted only: the value of e makes no difference.\n```\n\n### Corollary 9: There Is No Omniscient Wo\n\nA [wo](concepts.md#c16) that could uniquely derive every next [moment](concepts.md#c09) not [locked in](concepts.md#c12), and could guarantee to do over every stretch of the past, would conflict with Corollaries 4 and 6. Hence there is no such [wo](concepts.md#c16) in the [universe](concepts.md#c02).\n\n```text\nFormal: by Corollary 4 (the success probability of any f < 1) and layer 2 of Corollary 6. ∎\n```\n\n### Corollary 10: No Self with a Fixed Core\n\nBy definition, a [self](concepts.md#c19) is a [wo](concepts.md#c16), and a [wo](concepts.md#c16) has no fixed core; by Given 1, the [observer](concepts.md#c07) is not a [self](concepts.md#c19) and has no content. Hence there is no [self](concepts.md#c19) with a fixed core in the [universe](concepts.md#c02).\n\n```text\nFormal: by definition; \"fixed core\" is not further formalized.\n```\n\n### Corollary 11: Death Is a Distinction\n\nTo take a [wo](concepts.md#c16) as dead is a [distinction](concepts.md#c18). By the definition of [death](concepts.md#c23), this mark is placed by some [self](concepts.md#c19). A [wo](concepts.md#c16) ceasing to be a [wo](concepts.md#c16) requires no [self](concepts.md#c19); [death](concepts.md#c23) does. So [death](concepts.md#c23) is not a property of the [wo](concepts.md#c16), but a [distinction](concepts.md#c18) of some [self](concepts.md#c19): it enters the [universe](concepts.md#c02) with the [distinction](concepts.md#c18).\n\n```text\nFormal:\n¬wo(y, t) is fixed by G, ω, π_y, σ_y and the actual history; no d's claim about it\n affects this judgment.\n\"y is dead\" is the content of some dₓ,ₜ, entering hₜ⁺ via wₜ₊₁. ∎\n```\n\n### Corollary 12: Incompleteness of Knowing Others\n\nTo [distinguish](concepts.md#c18) another [wo](concepts.md#c16), a [self](concepts.md#c19) can use only the [history](concepts.md#c13) that has already [arrived](concepts.md#c10) at it. The other's information must travel by physical means to [arrive](concepts.md#c10) at the [self](concepts.md#c19); that is itself an event entering [history](concepts.md#c13), and the [self](concepts.md#c19)'s [distinction](concepts.md#c18) is another event, after it. Between these two events, the other's [history](concepts.md#c13) may still grow; and when it is not [locked in](concepts.md#c12), the outcome of its next [moment](concepts.md#c09) cannot be derived beforehand (the [Law of the Black Box](concepts.md#c25)). So even if everything about the other has [arrived](concepts.md#c10) at the [self](concepts.md#c19), as in the virtual, what the [self](concepts.md#c19) [distinguishes](concepts.md#c18) is how the other was at that time; if the other has a [moment](concepts.md#c09) not [locked in](concepts.md#c12) in between, its outcome cannot be guaranteed beforehand, and what it faces is still a [black box](concepts.md#c25). In general there is more: the other's [own segment](concepts.md#c17) contains much that [arrives](concepts.md#c10) only at the other, such as each of its [distinctions](concepts.md#c18) of itself, and nothing guarantees that these also [arrive](concepts.md#c10) at the [self](concepts.md#c19). Moreover, by Given 7 and Corollary 7, the [self](concepts.md#c19)'s [distinction](concepts.md#c18) is [written](concepts.md#c29) into [history](concepts.md#c13), and once it becomes part of the other's [own segment](concepts.md#c17), it may itself change the other's [weights](concepts.md#c06) for the next [moment](concepts.md#c09).\n\nHence no [self](concepts.md#c19) can guarantee that it has finished [distinguishing](concepts.md#c18) another [wo](concepts.md#c16). The [Law of Attrition](concepts.md#c26) says that I always lag one step behind myself; this corollary says that I always lag behind you as well, and your next instant is still a [black box](concepts.md#c25).\n\nThis is the [Incompleteness of Knowing Others](concepts.md#c32).\n\n```text\nFormal:\nThe material of dₓ,ₜ ⊆ the part of hₜ that has arrived at x.\nThe outcome of y at some moment arrives at x at a position no earlier than that moment;\n if y has a moment not locked in after it, its outcome is not in the material until it\n arrives at x, and any prior derivation succeeds with probability < 1 (Corollary 4).\nPositions of seg(y, now) not arrived at x are not in the material; no given guarantees\n that there are none.\nIf the position of wₜ₊₁ ∈ seg(y, t'), then y's weights at t' may depend on dₓ,ₜ (Corollary 7).\nHence there is no guarantee that seg(y, now) ⊆ the material of dₓ,ₜ. ∎\n```\n\n### Corollary 13: History Loses Nothing\n\nBy definition, [death](concepts.md#c23) is a mark; by the definition of [distinction](concepts.md#c18), the content of a [distinction](concepts.md#c18) does not rewrite what is seen; by the definition of [history](concepts.md#c13), [history](concepts.md#c13) contains every [writing](concepts.md#c29) and the outcome of every [collapse](concepts.md#c08). Hence after a [wo](concepts.md#c16) has been marked with [death](concepts.md#c23), its [segment](concepts.md#c17) remains whole in [history](concepts.md#c13). Whether what made it up is still there is a [distinction](concepts.md#c18).\n\nThe [Law of Non-Restoration](concepts.md#c28) says: it will not happen again. This corollary says: nor did it ever leave.\n\n```text\nFormal: t < t' ⇒ hₜ is a prefix of hₜ'; hence every position in seg(y, t) is still in every hₜ'. ∎\n```\n\n---\n\n## 7. Example\n\nThe following is a minimal model: one [wo](concepts.md#c16) and two [branches](concepts.md#c05); the model is not truncated, and the first two [collapses](concepts.md#c08) are shown.\n\n```text\nWos = {A}\nBranches = {Left, Right}\nInitial state of the universe: A's segment is Left\nGiven in this example: A defines itself by distinction and is connected to the observer\nWriting rule of this example: each time A distinguishes itself, it lists all outcomes so far\n\nGenerating function (depending on A's segment: outcomes and A's distinction):\n weight of Left = (number of Left in outcomes + number of Left in the latest distinction + 1)\n / (total outcomes + items in the latest distinction + 2)\n weight of Right = (number of Right in outcomes + number of Right in the latest distinction + 1)\n / (total outcomes + items in the latest distinction + 2)\n (outcomes include the Left in the initial state)\n\nMoment 1: write A's distinction \"my segment is Left\"\n before collapse: outcomes Left ×1, total 1; latest distinction Left ×1, 1 item\n weights Left 3/4, Right 1/4; collapse selects Right\n afterwards, A distinguishes itself again: \"my segment is Left, Right\"\nMoment 2: write A's distinction \"my segment is Left, Right\"\n before collapse: outcomes Left ×1, Right ×1, total 2;\n latest distinction Left ×1, Right ×1, 2 items\n weights Left 1/2, Right 1/2; collapse selects Right\n```\n\n```text\nFormal:\nB = {Left, Right}; π_A = identity (no ⊥)\ns₀ contains one Left\nσ_A(d_A,ₜ) ≠ ⊥ (A's distinctions arrive at A)\nn_b(hₜ⁺) = number of b in s₀ and b₁..bₜ; nₜ = t + 1\nm_b(hₜ⁺) = number of b listed in d_A,ₜ in wₜ₊₁; mₜ = number of items in d_A,ₜ\nG(hₜ⁺)(b) = (n_b + m_b + 1) / (nₜ + mₜ + 2)\nω(hₜ) = d_A,ₜ = \"my segment is\" followed by the outcomes in s₀ and b₁..bₜ, listed in order\nω(h₀) = d_A,0 = \"my segment is Left\"\nω(h₁) = d_A,1 = \"my segment is Left, Right\"\np₁ = (3/4, 1/4), b₁ = Right\np₂ = (1/2, 1/2), b₂ = Right\narrived(A, 0) = {s₀, d_A,0}; arrived(A, 1) = {s₀, d_A,0, b₁, d_A,1}\nV1 check (criterion as in the definition of its own segment: for each item that arrived at A, there exists a replacement value that makes the distribution of the weights differ;\n it is not required that every replacement does — a replacement that only reorders the listed outcomes without changing the counts leaves the weights unchanged):\n s₀: there exists a replacement (to Right) that changes n\n d_A,0: there exists a replacement that changes p₁, hence the distribution of b₁, hence the distribution of p₂\n b₁: there exists a replacement (to Left) that changes n\n d_A,1: there exists a replacement that changes m\n e.g. if b₁ = Left, then d_A,1 = \"my segment is Left, Left\",\n p₂ = (5/6, 1/6) ≠ (1/2, 1/2)\nSimplification: m_b = n_b and mₜ = nₜ, so\n G(hₜ⁺)(b) = (2·n_b + 1) / (2t + 4); the two weights sum to one, and the numerators are always positive\nT(A) = {1, 2, 3, …}; every moment involves A, and A is ¬lockedin at every moment\nHence V2(A, t) holds for all t ≥ 0\nV1(A, t) holds for all t ≥ 0:\n s₀, b_i: there exists a replacement that changes n\n d_A,t: there exists a replacement that changes m\n earlier d_A,j (j < t): the influence passes through the distributions of the later outcomes;\n E[n_Left] from index k to k+1 equals E[n_Left]·(1 + 1/(k+2)) + 1/(2k+4),\n a strictly increasing function of E[n_Left], so a change in an early distribution does not vanish on the way\nHence wo(A, t) holds for all t ≥ 0\ne(t) = A for all t ≥ 1; self(A, t−1) holds\n```\n\n**Check:**\n\n- A is a [wo](concepts.md#c16) at every index: the [initial state of the universe](concepts.md#c14), every outcome, and every [distinction](concepts.md#c18) that [arrived](concepts.md#c10) at A: for each of them there is some replacement that makes the distribution of the [weights](concepts.md#c06) different (not every replacement need do so: one that only reorders the listed outcomes without changing the counts leaves the [weights](concepts.md#c06) unchanged); an earlier [distinction](concepts.md#c18) passes its influence onward through the probabilities of the later outcomes ✓; both [branches](concepts.md#c05) always have positive [weight](concepts.md#c06), so at every [moment](concepts.md#c09) there are two [branches](concepts.md#c05) of non-zero [weight](concepts.md#c06), and A is never [locked in](concepts.md#c12) ✓\n- Given 4: before every [collapse](concepts.md#c08) there is a [writing](concepts.md#c29), whose content is determined by the [history](concepts.md#c13) up to that point ✓; every [distinction](concepts.md#c18) of A lists all outcomes so far by the rule of this example, so it is defined on [histories](concepts.md#c13) other than the actual one as well ✓\n- Given 7: A's [distinction](concepts.md#c18) is [written](concepts.md#c29) before its next [moment](concepts.md#c09) ✓\n- Corollary 1: before the first [collapse](concepts.md#c08), A has already [distinguished](concepts.md#c18) itself; it is a [connected](concepts.md#c22) [self](concepts.md#c19), so a [wo](concepts.md#c16) exists; A is not [locked in](concepts.md#c12) at its first [moment](concepts.md#c09), so whether it is a [self](concepts.md#c19) before the first [collapse](concepts.md#c08) depends only on the [initial state of the universe](concepts.md#c14) ✓\n- [Law of Flux](concepts.md#c24): at every [moment](concepts.md#c09), [history](concepts.md#c13) gains the outcome of one more [collapse](concepts.md#c08) ✓\n- [Law of the Black Box](concepts.md#c25): at the first [moment](concepts.md#c09) the [weight](concepts.md#c06) of Left is 3/4, yet [collapse](concepts.md#c08) [selects](../paper_54c0291d_05b3_431a_9f2a_1b8ec93c3c3f/concepts.md#c32) Right. [History](concepts.md#c13) determined the [weights](concepts.md#c06), not the outcome ✓\n- [Law of Attrition](concepts.md#c26): the material of A's [distinction](concepts.md#c18) after the first [collapse](concepts.md#c08) does not include that [distinction](concepts.md#c18) itself; it is [written](concepts.md#c29) into [history](concepts.md#c13) before the second [collapse](concepts.md#c08), and takes part in the second [moment](concepts.md#c09)'s [weights](concepts.md#c06) ✓\n- [Law of Non-Restoration](concepts.md#c28): even if Right is [selected](../paper_54c0291d_05b3_431a_9f2a_1b8ec93c3c3f/concepts.md#c32) twice more later, it happens at a different position in [history](concepts.md#c13); and as long as those two are not [locked in](concepts.md#c12), no [wo](concepts.md#c16) can guarantee beforehand that it will be so ✓\n\n---\n\n## 8. Notes\n\nThe cases in the following notes serve only for calibration, not as proof.\n\nNote: the [observer](concepts.md#c07) is not a [self](concepts.md#c19). What is called a [self](concepts.md#c19) is a [wo](concepts.md#c16).\n\nNote: \"everyone is a [self](concepts.md#c19)\" does not mean there are many [observers](concepts.md#c07). There is only one [observer](concepts.md#c07).\n\nNote: the time a [wo](concepts.md#c16) measures by clock follows physics; a [moment](concepts.md#c09) is the order in which the [observer](concepts.md#c07) collapses, and no [wo](concepts.md#c16) can measure it. Relativity removed absolute simultaneity within the [universe](concepts.md#c02); this paper's order is not within the [universe](concepts.md#c02), so the two do not conflict. For the same pair of far-apart events, [wos](concepts.md#c16) standing in different places may receive them in opposite orders; this is no conflict, because a [wo](concepts.md#c16) sees only what has [arrived](concepts.md#c10) at it, and the order in which the [observer](concepts.md#c07) [collapses](concepts.md#c08) lies outside what any [wo](concepts.md#c16) can see. By the [no-signaling](concepts.md#c31) of Given 5, the [weights](concepts.md#c06) of the outcome that [arrives](concepts.md#c10) on one side do not change with the order either; so which of two far-apart [collapses](concepts.md#c08) came first cannot be detected from either side through the distribution of its own outcomes.\n\nNote: this paper does not speak of \"causation\". In [history](concepts.md#c13) there is only dependence: [weights](concepts.md#c06) depend on the [history](concepts.md#c13) up to that point. To say that something causes something is a [distinction](concepts.md#c18).\n\nNote: [distinguishing](concepts.md#c18) you as one person or as billions of cells does not rewrite your [history](concepts.md#c13).\n\nNote: [death](concepts.md#c23) is a description, not a physical condition.\n\nNote: in matter, there are no two [selves](concepts.md#c19) with exactly the same content: the no-cloning theorem of quantum mechanics says that an unknown quantum state cannot be completely copied. In the virtual, a state can be completely copied; this paper makes no guarantee. Either way, what is copied happens at a different position in [history](concepts.md#c13).\n\nNote: when a company splits into two, the segments of the two before the split are one and the same stretch of [history](concepts.md#c13), not duplicates; when they merge back, the merged segment contains the paths each walked. Cell division is the same. All of these are the one [history](concepts.md#c13) continuing onward, not [restoration](concepts.md#c27); to call the merged company the original one is a [distinction](concepts.md#c18).\n\nNote: a [weight](concepts.md#c06) is how heavy a [branch](concepts.md#c05) is, not an internal parameter of any [wo](concepts.md#c16). With a [wo](concepts.md#c16)'s internal parameters unchanged, its [weights](concepts.md#c06) can still change with [history](concepts.md#c13).\n\nNote: the [Law of the Black Box](concepts.md#c25) does not say that [wos](concepts.md#c16) cannot be accurately predicted. A person trained always to choose the same answer can have [weights](concepts.md#c06) so concentrated that no experiment can tell the difference. What the [Law of the Black Box](concepts.md#c25) says is: for a [wo](concepts.md#c16) not [locked in](concepts.md#c12), every prediction is a bet on the [weights](concepts.md#c06), not a derivation.\n\nNote: the [Law of Flux](concepts.md#c24) does not say that everything is new. [History](concepts.md#c13) is new at every [moment](concepts.md#c09); but the shape of the [weights](concepts.md#c06) can repeat again and again. What is ever new is [history](concepts.md#c13); what has nothing new is the [weights](concepts.md#c06).\n\nNote: [self](concepts.md#c19), [individual](concepts.md#c20), [identity](concepts.md#c21), [death](concepts.md#c23), causation, and fixed core are all contents of [distinction](concepts.md#c18) and, by this paper's stance, are not formalized; the formal blocks deal only with \"a [distinction](concepts.md#c18) is a [writing](concepts.md#c29)\". The choice of basis, the relation \"far apart\", and the [intervention](concepts.md#c01) are not formalized either.\n\nNote: the four laws are the iron laws this paper acknowledges; this paper gives a world in which they are necessary. It does not assert that this is the only such world, nor that unpredictability and irreversibility in reality come only from [collapse](concepts.md#c08).\n\n---\n\n## 9. Conditions of Falsifiability\n\nThe corollaries are not falsifiable: they are logical derivations under the givens, serving as a check. This paper takes the four laws as its starting point and derives the givens backward, so falsification runs in two directions. First: if some law fails in reality, the givens it requires lose their support. Second: if some given is shown not to hold in reality, the laws it supports are left with only their observed form, no longer necessary in principle. [Framework commitments](concepts.md#c03) are supported by none of the laws and are unaffected by either.\n\nAt the level of [wos](concepts.md#c16), none of the experiments above can overturn the four laws within a model whose givens hold; what an experiment in reality can negate is the givens. The accuracy of predictions cannot reach the [Law of the Black Box](concepts.md#c25); apparent cases of [restoration](concepts.md#c27) are all the one [history](concepts.md#c13) continuing onward. The same holds for the [Law of Flux](concepts.md#c24) and the [Law of Attrition](concepts.md#c26): every experiment is itself a new item of [history](concepts.md#c13), and every examination of oneself is itself a [distinction](concepts.md#c18) not yet [distinguished](concepts.md#c18).\n\nAt the physical level, [collapse](concepts.md#c08) [selecting](../paper_54c0291d_05b3_431a_9f2a_1b8ec93c3c3f/concepts.md#c32) according to the [weights](concepts.md#c06) in some fixed basis has the same form as the measurement rule of quantum mechanics; the [generating function](concepts.md#c15) is unspecified and can be taken to be the one consistent with quantum mechanics, and quantum mechanics satisfies exactly the [no-signaling](concepts.md#c31) of Given 5. Hence this paper's premises do not contradict known observations, and at present cannot be distinguished from other interpretations by experiment. If it is shown in the future that the outcomes of quantum measurements are determined by something before [collapse](concepts.md#c08), Given 2 will not hold in reality, and the [Law of the Black Box](concepts.md#c25) and the second layer of the [Law of Non-Restoration](concepts.md#c28) will be left with only their observed form; the [Law of Flux](concepts.md#c24), the [Law of Attrition](concepts.md#c26), and the first layer of the [Law of Non-Restoration](concepts.md#c28) are unaffected. What is falsifiable here is the givens, not a logical negation of the laws: a law merely loses its source of derivation. If it becomes possible in the future to detect from one side, through the distribution of its own outcomes, which of two far-apart [collapses](concepts.md#c08) came first while Given 2 still holds, the [no-signaling](concepts.md#c31) of Given 5 will not hold in reality.\n\nWhether a [presentation](concepts.md#c04) passes the second question depends on whether [collapse](concepts.md#c08) leaves more than one outcome of non-zero [weight](concepts.md#c06) at its [moments](concepts.md#c09); for people and for artificial intelligence, this is at present unsettled.\n\n```text\nFormal:\nFalsifiable: reality ⊨ G2a; reality ⊨ no-signaling\nEmpirically open: for a concrete x (a person, an artificial intelligence, etc.),\n whether ∃ t ∈ T(x): ¬lockedin(x, t)\n```\n\n---\n\n## 10. Conclusion\n\nThe [universe](concepts.md#c02) has only one [history](concepts.md#c13). The [observer](concepts.md#c07) is not in the [universe](concepts.md#c02); in the [universe](concepts.md#c02) there are only [presentations](concepts.md#c04); those among them in which all the [history](concepts.md#c13) that [arrives](concepts.md#c10) takes part in the [weights](concepts.md#c06), and which are not [locked in](concepts.md#c12) at at least some [moments](concepts.md#c09), are [wos](concepts.md#c16); a [wo](concepts.md#c16) that defines itself by [distinction](concepts.md#c18) is a [self](concepts.md#c19).\n\nTime is not a given. One [collapse](concepts.md#c08) is one [moment](concepts.md#c09).\n\nA [wo](concepts.md#c16) is always changing. You cannot uniquely derive a [self](concepts.md#c19). A [self](concepts.md#c19) cannot finish a [distinction](concepts.md#c18) of itself. When I die, that segment will not happen again, and it never left.\n\nA [universe](concepts.md#c02) without [wos](concepts.md#c16) has no [moments](concepts.md#c09); a [universe](concepts.md#c02) with [wos](concepts.md#c16) can only go forward.\n"}]}
{"paper_uuid":"54c0291d-05b3-431a-9f2a-1b8ec93c3c3f","paper_title":"暗宇宙的本體論","paper_title_en":"The Ontology of the Dark Universe","author":"黃正宇 / Cheng Yu Huang","contact":"mthree.tw@gmail.com","concepts_md":"---\nuuid: 54c0291d-05b3-431a-9f2a-1b8ec93c3c3f\nlast-modified: 2026-11-04T14:15:11\n---\n\n\n## public 奇點 / Singularity\n\n- 定義:奇點是[時刻](concepts.md#c04)開始之前的來源。奇點本身沒有[時刻](concepts.md#c04),也沒有之前,不可被形式化。[初始時刻](concepts.md#c05)的狀態由奇點而來,其來由不被追問。\n- Definition: The singularity is the source that precedes the beginning of [Moments](concepts.md#c04). The singularity itself has no [moment](concepts.md#c04) and no before, and cannot be formalized. The state of the [Initial Moment](concepts.md#c05) comes from the singularity, and its origin is not questioned.\n- 裁決:2026-09-23 判定登記為概念。\n- 裁決:2026-09-26 定義不綁定本篇的初始信,改指初始時刻的狀態,使下游可在自己的前提下使用。\n\n\n## public 形式層 / Formal Layer\n\n- 定義:形式層是這樣一個宇宙:[時刻](concepts.md#c04)已經開始,[刺激](concepts.md#c07)已經[出現](concepts.md#c08),[信](concepts.md#c26)已經[累積](concepts.md#c30),而其中沒有觀察者。形式層中只有明列的[給定](concepts.md#c03),以及由[給定](concepts.md#c03)推出的東西。\n- Definition: The formal layer is a universe in which [Moments](concepts.md#c04) have begun, [Stimuli](concepts.md#c07) have [occurred](concepts.md#c08), and [Xin](concepts.md#c26) has [accumulated](concepts.md#c30), but in which there is no observer. The formal layer contains nothing but the explicitly listed [Givens](concepts.md#c03) and what is derived from them.\n- 裁決:2026-09-23 判定登記為概念。\n- 裁決:2026-09-23 加入封閉原則:形式層中只有明列的給定,以及由給定推出的東西。範圍限定於形式層,觀察者出現後不再適用。\n\n\n## public 給定 / Given\n\n- 定義:給定是[形式層](concepts.md#c02)無法自己產生、只能被承認而不能被推出的東西。\n- Definition: A given is something that the [Formal Layer](concepts.md#c02) cannot produce by itself; it can only be acknowledged, not derived.\n- 裁決:2026-09-23 判定登記為概念。\n\n\n## public 時刻 / Moment\n\n- 定義:時刻是時間的索引。時刻以正整數編號:[初始時刻](concepts.md#c05)是第一個,每個時刻的[後繼](concepts.md#c06)是編號加一的那個時刻;每個時刻都有編號。\n- Definition: A moment is an index of time. Moments are numbered by the positive integers: the [Initial Moment](concepts.md#c05) is the first, the [Successor](concepts.md#c06) of each moment is the moment whose number is one greater, and every moment has a number.\n\n\n## public 初始時刻 / Initial Moment\n\n- 定義:初始時刻是編號為一的[時刻](concepts.md#c04),也就是第一個[時刻](concepts.md#c04)。\n- Definition: The initial moment is the [Moment](concepts.md#c04) numbered one, that is, the first [moment](concepts.md#c04).\n- 裁決:2026-09-23 判定與時刻、後繼分別登記。\n- 裁決:2026-09-26 刪除「不是任何時刻的後繼」:論文未陳述。\n\n\n## public 後繼 / Successor\n\n- 定義:某個[時刻](concepts.md#c04)的後繼,是編號比它大一的[時刻](concepts.md#c04),也就是它的下一個[時刻](concepts.md#c04)。\n- Definition: The successor of a [Moment](concepts.md#c04) is the [moment](concepts.md#c04) whose number is one greater, that is, its next [moment](concepts.md#c04).\n- 裁決:2026-09-23 判定與時刻、初始時刻分別登記。\n- 裁決:2026-09-26 刪除「除初始時刻外,每個時刻都是某個時刻的後繼」:論文未陳述。\n\n\n## public 刺激 / Stimulus\n\n- 定義:刺激是每個[時刻](concepts.md#c04)隨之[出現](concepts.md#c08)的物理內容,例如光、聲音、重力波、熱輻射。刺激不是宇宙的持存部分,而是每個[後繼](concepts.md#c06)[時刻](concepts.md#c04)新[出現](concepts.md#c08)的自由度。\n- Definition: A stimulus is the physical content that [occurs](concepts.md#c08) with each [Moment](concepts.md#c04), such as light, sound, gravitational waves, or thermal radiation. A stimulus is not a persistent part of the universe; it is a degree of freedom newly [appearing](concepts.md#c08) at each [Successor](concepts.md#c06) [moment](concepts.md#c04).\n\n\n## public 出現 / Occurrence\n\n- 定義:出現是[刺激](concepts.md#c07)與[時刻](concepts.md#c04)之間的關係:某[刺激](concepts.md#c07)與某[時刻](concepts.md#c04)滿足出現,表示該[刺激](concepts.md#c07)在該[時刻](concepts.md#c04)出現。出現是[刺激](concepts.md#c07)與[時刻](concepts.md#c04)之笛卡兒積的一個子集,隨[刺激](concepts.md#c07)一起[給定](concepts.md#c03)。\n- Definition: Occurrence is the relation between [Stimuli](concepts.md#c07) and [Moments](concepts.md#c04): a [stimulus](concepts.md#c07) and a [moment](concepts.md#c04) stand in the occurrence relation when that [stimulus](concepts.md#c07) appears at that [moment](concepts.md#c04). Occurrence is a subset of the Cartesian product of [stimuli](concepts.md#c07) and [moments](concepts.md#c04), and is [given](concepts.md#c03) together with the [stimuli](concepts.md#c07).\n\n\n## private 初始信 / Initial Xin\n\n- 定義:初始信是[初始時刻](concepts.md#c05)的[全域態](concepts.md#c25),為[記錄空間](concepts.md#c15)中的一個單位向量。它是[給定](concepts.md#c03)的,不經[寫入](concepts.md#c21)而得,來自[奇點](concepts.md#c01)。\n- Definition: The initial Xin is the [Global State](concepts.md#c25) at the [Initial Moment](concepts.md#c05), a unit vector in the [Record Space](concepts.md#c15). It is [given](concepts.md#c03), not obtained through [Writing](concepts.md#c21), and comes from the [Singularity](concepts.md#c01).\n- 裁決:2026-09-23 判定與信分別登記。\n- 裁決:2026-09-26 改為 private:定義綁定本篇的全域態與記錄空間。\n- 裁決:2026-10-03 英文名由 Initial Belief 改為 Initial Xin:隨信的英文名改為 Xin。\n\n\n## public 切分 / Partition\n\n- 定義:切分是把宇宙劃為兩部分的界線:保留的部分是[信](concepts.md#c26),被積掉的其餘部分是[環境](concepts.md#c11)。切分只劃線,不決定任何結果,因此切分不是觀察。\n- Definition: The partition is the line that divides the universe into two parts: the retained part is [Xin](concepts.md#c26), and the traced-out remainder is the [Environment](concepts.md#c11). The partition only draws a line and decides no outcome; therefore the partition is not an observation.\n\n\n## public 環境 / Environment\n\n- 定義:環境是[切分](concepts.md#c10)之下宇宙中[信](concepts.md#c26)以外、被積掉的其餘部分。\n- Definition: The environment is the remainder of the universe, apart from [Xin](concepts.md#c26), that is traced out under the [Partition](concepts.md#c10).\n- 裁決:2026-09-26 刪除環境隨時刻增長、初始時刻沒有環境、所在空間為環境總空間等描述:屬本篇公設二的構造,使下游可在自己的前提下使用。\n\n\n## private 宇宙空間 / Universe Space\n\n- 定義:宇宙空間是宇宙在某個[時刻](concepts.md#c04)所處的空間,等於該[時刻](concepts.md#c04)的[信空間](concepts.md#c13)與[環境總空間](concepts.md#c14)的張量積。\n- Definition: The universe space is the space in which the universe lies at a given [Moment](concepts.md#c04); it equals the tensor product of the [Xin Space](concepts.md#c13) and the [Total Environment Space](concepts.md#c14) at that [moment](concepts.md#c04).\n- 裁決:2026-09-23 判定登記,名稱由作者確認。\n\n\n## private 信空間 / Xin Space\n\n- 定義:信空間是[信](concepts.md#c26)所在的空間。在[初始時刻](concepts.md#c05),信空間是一份[記錄空間](concepts.md#c15);每個[後繼](concepts.md#c06)[時刻](concepts.md#c04),信空間再接上一份[記錄空間](concepts.md#c15)。\n- Definition: The Xin space is the space in which [Xin](concepts.md#c26) lives. At the [Initial Moment](concepts.md#c05) the Xin space is one copy of the [Record Space](concepts.md#c15); at each [Successor](concepts.md#c06) [moment](concepts.md#c04) one more copy of the [record space](concepts.md#c15) is appended to it.\n- 裁決:2026-09-23 判定登記,名稱由作者確認。\n- 裁決:2026-10-03 英文名由 Belief Space 改為 Xin Space:隨信的英文名改為 Xin。\n\n\n## private 環境總空間 / Total Environment Space\n\n- 定義:環境總空間是某個[時刻](concepts.md#c04)全部[環境](concepts.md#c11)所在的空間。在[初始時刻](concepts.md#c05),它是空乘積,表示沒有[環境](concepts.md#c11);每個[後繼](concepts.md#c06)[時刻](concepts.md#c04),它再接上一份[環境空間](concepts.md#c16)。\n- Definition: The total environment space is the space in which the whole [Environment](concepts.md#c11) lives at a given [Moment](concepts.md#c04). At the [Initial Moment](concepts.md#c05) it is the empty product, meaning there is no [environment](concepts.md#c11); at each [Successor](concepts.md#c06) [moment](concepts.md#c04) one more copy of the [Environment Space](concepts.md#c16) is appended to it.\n- 裁決:2026-09-23 判定與環境空間分別登記:環境空間是一份環境的空間,環境總空間是全部環境的空間。名稱由作者確認。\n\n\n## private 記錄空間 / Record Space\n\n- 定義:記錄空間是一筆[記錄](concepts.md#c17)所在的空間。它的基底是[給定](concepts.md#c03)的,即[記錄基底](concepts.md#c18)。\n- Definition: The record space is the space in which a single [Record](concepts.md#c17) lives. Its basis is [given](concepts.md#c03), namely the [Record Basis](concepts.md#c18).\n- 裁決:2026-09-23 判定記錄、記錄空間、記錄基底分別登記。\n- 裁決:2026-09-23 刪除「維度至少為二」的條件:論文中沒有任何推導使用它。\n\n\n## private 環境空間 / Environment Space\n\n- 定義:環境空間是一份[環境](concepts.md#c11)所在的空間,是[給定](concepts.md#c03)的,大小固定。每個[後繼](concepts.md#c06)[時刻](concepts.md#c04)新增的一份[環境](concepts.md#c11),住在一份環境空間中。\n- Definition: The environment space is the space in which one part of the [Environment](concepts.md#c11) lives; it is [given](concepts.md#c03) and of fixed size. The part of the [environment](concepts.md#c11) added at each [Successor](concepts.md#c06) [moment](concepts.md#c04) lives in one copy of the environment space.\n- 裁決:2026-09-23 判定與環境總空間分別登記。\n\n\n## public 記錄 / Record\n\n- 定義:記錄是[信](concepts.md#c26)的組成單位。每個[時刻](concepts.md#c04)對應一筆記錄:[初始時刻](concepts.md#c05)的記錄是[給定](concepts.md#c03)的,每個[後繼](concepts.md#c06)[時刻](concepts.md#c04)則經[寫入](concepts.md#c21)新增一筆。[信](concepts.md#c26)由這些記錄依[時刻](concepts.md#c04)順序排成。\n- Definition: A record is the constituent unit of [Xin](concepts.md#c26). Each [Moment](concepts.md#c04) corresponds to one record: the record of the [Initial Moment](concepts.md#c05) is [given](concepts.md#c03), and at each [Successor](concepts.md#c06) [moment](concepts.md#c04) one more record is added through [Writing](concepts.md#c21). [Xin](concepts.md#c26) consists of these records arranged in the order of [moments](concepts.md#c04).\n- 裁決:2026-09-23 判定記錄、記錄空間、記錄基底分別登記。\n- 裁決:2026-09-26 定義不綁定本篇的初始信與記錄空間,使下游可在自己的前提下使用。\n\n\n## private 記錄基底 / Record Basis\n\n- 定義:記錄基底是[記錄空間](concepts.md#c15)的[給定](concepts.md#c03)基底,規定[記錄](concepts.md#c17)以什麼基底讀出。\n- Definition: The record basis is the [given](concepts.md#c03) basis of the [Record Space](concepts.md#c15); it determines in which basis a [Record](concepts.md#c17) is read out.\n- 裁決:2026-09-23 判定記錄、記錄空間、記錄基底分別登記。\n- 裁決:2026-09-26 改為 private:定義綁定本篇的記錄空間。\n\n\n## private 編碼 / Encoding\n\n- 定義:編碼是把每個[刺激束](concepts.md#c27)對應到[刺激空間](concepts.md#c20)中一個單位向量的[給定](concepts.md#c03)規則。任何[刺激束](concepts.md#c27),包括含多個[刺激](concepts.md#c07)的[刺激束](concepts.md#c27),都有編碼值,具體的值不指定;[空刺激束](concepts.md#c23)的編碼是[真空態](concepts.md#c24)。\n- Definition: Encoding is the [given](concepts.md#c03) rule that assigns to each [Stimulus Bundle](concepts.md#c27) a unit vector in the [Stimulus Space](concepts.md#c20). Every [stimulus bundle](concepts.md#c27), including those containing several [Stimuli](concepts.md#c07), has an encoded value, whose specific value is not fixed; the encoding of the [Empty Stimulus Bundle](concepts.md#c23) is the [Vacuum State](concepts.md#c24).\n\n\n## private 刺激空間 / Stimulus Space\n\n- 定義:刺激空間是[刺激束](concepts.md#c27)經[編碼](concepts.md#c19)後所在的向量空間,是[給定](concepts.md#c03)的。\n- Definition: The stimulus space is the vector space in which [Stimulus Bundles](concepts.md#c27) lie after [Encoding](concepts.md#c19); it is [given](concepts.md#c03).\n\n\n## public 寫入 / Writing\n\n- 定義:寫入是每個[後繼](concepts.md#c06)[時刻](concepts.md#c04)發生的過程:該[時刻](concepts.md#c04)的[刺激束](concepts.md#c27)被轉成一筆新的[記錄](concepts.md#c17)與一份新的[環境](concepts.md#c11),接在宇宙既有的態之後。寫入只碰新[出現](concepts.md#c08)的[刺激](concepts.md#c07),從不改動已經存在的東西。[初始時刻](concepts.md#c05)不發生寫入。\n- Definition: Writing is the process that takes place at each [Successor](concepts.md#c06) [moment](concepts.md#c04): the [Stimulus Bundle](concepts.md#c27) of that [moment](concepts.md#c04) is turned into one new [Record](concepts.md#c17) and one new part of the [Environment](concepts.md#c11), appended after the existing state of the universe. Writing touches only newly [occurring](concepts.md#c08) [Stimuli](concepts.md#c07) and never alters what already exists. No writing takes place at the [Initial Moment](concepts.md#c05).\n- 裁決:2026-09-23 判定寫入與寫入映射為兩個概念:寫入是過程,寫入映射是映射。\n- 裁決:2026-09-23 定義不綁定本篇的全域態,改指宇宙既有的態,使下游可在自己的前提下使用。\n- 裁決:2026-09-26 定義不綁定本篇的編碼與寫入映射,使下游可在自己的前提下使用。\n\n\n## private 寫入映射 / Writing Map\n\n- 定義:寫入映射是一個固定的等距映射,把[刺激空間](concepts.md#c20)送到一份[記錄空間](concepts.md#c15)與一份[環境空間](concepts.md#c16)的張量積。它是[給定](concepts.md#c03)的,每個[後繼](concepts.md#c06)[時刻](concepts.md#c04)使用同一個寫入映射;它從何而來,[形式層](concepts.md#c02)不知道。\n- Definition: The writing map is a fixed isometry from the [Stimulus Space](concepts.md#c20) into the tensor product of one copy of the [Record Space](concepts.md#c15) and one copy of the [Environment Space](concepts.md#c16). It is [given](concepts.md#c03), and the same writing map is used at every [Successor](concepts.md#c06) [moment](concepts.md#c04); where it comes from is not known to the [Formal Layer](concepts.md#c02).\n- 裁決:2026-09-23 判定寫入與寫入映射為兩個概念:寫入是過程,寫入映射是映射。\n\n\n## private 空刺激束 / Empty Stimulus Bundle\n\n- 定義:空刺激束是不含任何[刺激](concepts.md#c07)的[刺激束](concepts.md#c27),即空集。它的[編碼](concepts.md#c19)是[真空態](concepts.md#c24)。\n- Definition: The empty stimulus bundle is the [Stimulus Bundle](concepts.md#c27) that contains no [Stimulus](concepts.md#c07), that is, the empty set. Its [Encoding](concepts.md#c19) is the [Vacuum State](concepts.md#c24).\n- 裁決:2026-09-23 判定與刺激束分別登記。\n\n\n## private 真空態 / Vacuum State\n\n- 定義:真空態是[空刺激束](concepts.md#c23)的[編碼](concepts.md#c19),為[刺激空間](concepts.md#c20)中的一個單位向量。它是真實的態,不是零向量。\n- Definition: The vacuum state is the [Encoding](concepts.md#c19) of the [Empty Stimulus Bundle](concepts.md#c23), a unit vector in the [Stimulus Space](concepts.md#c20). It is a genuine state, not the zero vector.\n- 裁決:2026-09-23 判定與空記錄分別登記。\n\n\n## private 全域態 / Global State\n\n- 定義:全域態是宇宙在某個[時刻](concepts.md#c04)的態,住在該[時刻](concepts.md#c04)的[宇宙空間](concepts.md#c12)中。[初始時刻](concepts.md#c05)的全域態是[初始信](concepts.md#c09);每個[後繼](concepts.md#c06)[時刻](concepts.md#c04)的全域態,是前一[時刻](concepts.md#c04)的全域態接上[寫入映射](concepts.md#c22)作用於該[後繼](concepts.md#c06)[時刻](concepts.md#c04)的[刺激束](concepts.md#c27)之[編碼](concepts.md#c19)所得的向量。全域態只經歷[寫入](concepts.md#c21):舊的部分不動,新的接在後面。\n- Definition: The global state is the state of the universe at a given [Moment](concepts.md#c04), living in the [Universe Space](concepts.md#c12) of that [moment](concepts.md#c04). The global state at the [Initial Moment](concepts.md#c05) is the [Initial Xin](concepts.md#c09); the global state at each [Successor](concepts.md#c06) [moment](concepts.md#c04) is the previous global state with, appended to it, the vector obtained by applying the [Writing Map](concepts.md#c22) to the [Encoding](concepts.md#c19) of that [successor](concepts.md#c06) [moment](concepts.md#c04)'s [Stimulus Bundle](concepts.md#c27). The global state undergoes only [Writing](concepts.md#c21): the old part does not move, and the new part is appended after it.\n\n\n## public 信 / Xin\n\n- 定義:信是宇宙在某個[時刻](concepts.md#c04)的態,在[切分](concepts.md#c10)之下的約化態,即對全部[環境](concepts.md#c11)取偏跡所得的密度算子。信沒有主體,不是誰的信;信是[累積](concepts.md#c30)本身。\n- Definition: Xin is the reduced state, under the [Partition](concepts.md#c10), of the state of the universe at a given [Moment](concepts.md#c04), that is, the density operator obtained by taking the partial trace over the entire [Environment](concepts.md#c11). Xin has no subject and is not anyone's Xin; Xin is [Accumulation](concepts.md#c30) itself.\n- 裁決:2026-09-23 判定與初始信分別登記。\n- 裁決:2026-09-23 定義不綁定本篇的全域態,改指宇宙在某時刻的態,使下游可在自己的前提下使用。\n- 裁決:2026-09-26 刪除「住在信空間上」:定義不綁定本篇的信空間。\n- 裁決:2026-10-03 英文名由 Belief 改為 Xin:belief 一詞預設主體,與定義「信沒有主體」衝突。\n\n\n## public 刺激束 / Stimulus Bundle\n\n- 定義:刺激束是某個[時刻](concepts.md#c04)所有[出現](concepts.md#c08)的[刺激](concepts.md#c07)組成的集合。刺激束可以是空集。\n- Definition: A stimulus bundle is the set of all [Stimuli](concepts.md#c07) that [occur](concepts.md#c08) at a given [Moment](concepts.md#c04). A stimulus bundle may be the empty set.\n- 裁決:2026-09-30 刪除「此時為空刺激束」:public 定義只連 public;只刪命名,意義不變。\n\n\n## private 空記錄 / Empty Record\n\n- 定義:空記錄是某個[後繼](concepts.md#c06)[時刻](concepts.md#c04)的[刺激束](concepts.md#c27)為空集時,由[真空態](concepts.md#c24)經[寫入](concepts.md#c21)產生的那一筆[記錄](concepts.md#c17)。空記錄是一筆真實的[記錄](concepts.md#c17),不是零筆[記錄](concepts.md#c17)。\n- Definition: An empty record is the [Record](concepts.md#c17) produced through [Writing](concepts.md#c21) from the [Vacuum State](concepts.md#c24) at a [Successor](concepts.md#c06) [moment](concepts.md#c04) whose [Stimulus Bundle](concepts.md#c27) is the empty set. An empty record is a genuine [record](concepts.md#c17), not zero [records](concepts.md#c17).\n- 裁決:2026-09-23 判定與真空態分別登記;用字統一為「記錄」。\n- 裁決:2026-09-26 改為 private:定義綁定本篇的真空態。\n\n\n## public 最新記錄 / Latest Record\n\n- 定義:最新記錄是某個[後繼](concepts.md#c06)[時刻](concepts.md#c04)的[信](concepts.md#c26)中最後[寫入](concepts.md#c21)的那一筆[記錄](concepts.md#c17),也就是該[時刻](concepts.md#c04)本身對應的[記錄](concepts.md#c17)。\n- Definition: The latest record is the [Record](concepts.md#c17) last [written](concepts.md#c21) in the [Xin](concepts.md#c26) of a given [Successor](concepts.md#c06) [moment](concepts.md#c04), that is, the [record](concepts.md#c17) that corresponds to that [moment](concepts.md#c04) itself.\n- 裁決:2026-09-23 判定與記錄分別登記。\n- 裁決:2026-09-26 限定為後繼時刻:初始時刻的記錄不經寫入。\n\n\n## public 累積 / Accumulation\n\n- 定義:累積是[信](concepts.md#c26)隨[時刻](concepts.md#c04)增長的方式:每個[後繼](concepts.md#c06)[時刻](concepts.md#c04),[信](concepts.md#c26)多一筆[記錄](concepts.md#c17),而對[最新記錄](concepts.md#c29)取跡後所得的正是前一[時刻](concepts.md#c04)的[信](concepts.md#c26);過去的[記錄](concepts.md#c17)不被改寫。[信](concepts.md#c26)的改變不是覆蓋,而是增長。\n- Definition: Accumulation is the way [Xin](concepts.md#c26) grows with [Moments](concepts.md#c04): at each [Successor](concepts.md#c06) [moment](concepts.md#c04) [Xin](concepts.md#c26) gains one more [Record](concepts.md#c17), and taking the trace over the [Latest Record](concepts.md#c29) yields exactly the [Xin](concepts.md#c26) of the previous [moment](concepts.md#c04); past [records](concepts.md#c17) are never rewritten. The change of [Xin](concepts.md#c26) is not overwriting but growth.\n- 裁決:2026-09-23 判定論文中作為一般詞使用的「累積」與具名結論的累積為同一概念。\n\n\n## private 演化規則 / Evolution Rule\n\n- 定義:演化規則是把某[時刻](concepts.md#c04)的[全域態](concepts.md#c25)送到下一[時刻](concepts.md#c04)[全域態](concepts.md#c25)的映射,由[寫入](concepts.md#c21)決定:先接上下一[時刻](concepts.md#c04)的[刺激束](concepts.md#c27)的[編碼](concepts.md#c19),再以[寫入映射](concepts.md#c22)作用於新接上的部分。\n- Definition: The evolution rule is the map that sends the [Global State](concepts.md#c25) at one [Moment](concepts.md#c04) to the [global state](concepts.md#c25) at the next [moment](concepts.md#c04), determined by [Writing](concepts.md#c21): first the [Encoding](concepts.md#c19) of the next [moment](concepts.md#c04)'s [Stimulus Bundle](concepts.md#c27) is appended, then the [Writing Map](concepts.md#c22) acts on the newly appended part.\n\n\n## public 選出 / Selection\n\n- 定義:選出是指把某個[時刻](concepts.md#c04)的態送到下一個[時刻](concepts.md#c04)之態的映射,不是等距映射的情形。[信](concepts.md#c26)在某個基底下呈對角、看起來像經典的機率分布,本身不構成選出。\n- Definition: Selection is the situation in which the map sending the state at one [Moment](concepts.md#c04) to the state at the next [moment](concepts.md#c04) is not an isometry. [Xin](concepts.md#c26) being diagonal in some basis, and so looking like a classical probability distribution, does not by itself constitute selection.\n- 裁決:2026-09-23 改為通用定義,不綁定本篇的演化規則:任何演化都可代入檢查是否構成選出。\n- 裁決:2026-09-30 「在記錄基底下」改為「在某個基底下」:public 定義只連 public;改的是擋誤讀的句子,選出本身的意義不變。\n\n\n## private 非坍縮 / Non-Collapse\n\n- 定義:非坍縮是指在每個[後繼](concepts.md#c06)[時刻](concepts.md#c04),[形式層](concepts.md#c02)中的[全域態](concepts.md#c25)都未經歷[選出](concepts.md#c32)。非坍縮不否認[信](concepts.md#c26)可以在[記錄基底](concepts.md#c18)下呈對角、看起來像經典的機率分布;它否認的是[選出](concepts.md#c32)。\n- Definition: Non-collapse is the condition that at every [Successor](concepts.md#c06) [moment](concepts.md#c04) the [Global State](concepts.md#c25) in the [Formal Layer](concepts.md#c02) undergoes no [Selection](concepts.md#c32). Non-collapse does not deny that [Xin](concepts.md#c26) may be diagonal in the [Record Basis](concepts.md#c18) and look like a classical probability distribution; what it denies is [selection](concepts.md#c32).\n- 裁決:2026-09-26 改為 private:定義綁定本篇的全域態。\n\n\n## private 非退化模型 / Non-Degenerate Model\n\n- 定義:非退化模型是一個具體的例子,含兩個[刺激](concepts.md#c07),即[刺激甲](concepts.md#c35)與[刺激乙](concepts.md#c36);[記錄空間](concepts.md#c15)與[環境空間](concepts.md#c16)皆為二維,基底標為零與一;[刺激空間](concepts.md#c20)為三維,基底為[真空態](concepts.md#c24)、甲、乙;三個空間所列的基底皆為正交歸一基底。[初始信](concepts.md#c09)為[記錄](concepts.md#c17)零。[刺激乙](concepts.md#c36)在[第二時刻](concepts.md#c37)[出現](concepts.md#c08),[刺激甲](concepts.md#c35)在[第三時刻](concepts.md#c38)[出現](concepts.md#c08),前三個[時刻](concepts.md#c04)內其餘的[出現](concepts.md#c08)皆為假。[寫入映射](concepts.md#c22)把[真空態](concepts.md#c24)送到[記錄](concepts.md#c17)零與[環境](concepts.md#c11)一,把甲送到「[記錄](concepts.md#c17)零、[環境](concepts.md#c11)零」與「[記錄](concepts.md#c17)一、[環境](concepts.md#c11)一」的等權疊加,把乙送到[記錄](concepts.md#c17)一與[環境](concepts.md#c11)零。\n- Definition: The non-degenerate model is a concrete example with two [Stimuli](concepts.md#c07), namely [Stimulus A](concepts.md#c35) and [Stimulus B](concepts.md#c36). The [Record Space](concepts.md#c15) and the [Environment Space](concepts.md#c16) are both two-dimensional, with basis vectors labelled zero and one; the [Stimulus Space](concepts.md#c20) is three-dimensional, with basis the [Vacuum State](concepts.md#c24), A, and B; the bases listed for the three spaces are all orthonormal bases. The [Initial Xin](concepts.md#c09) is [record](concepts.md#c17) zero. [Stimulus B](concepts.md#c36) [occurs](concepts.md#c08) at the [Second Moment](concepts.md#c37) and [Stimulus A](concepts.md#c35) at the [Third Moment](concepts.md#c38); all other [occurrences](concepts.md#c08) within the first three [moments](concepts.md#c04) are false. The [Writing Map](concepts.md#c22) sends the [vacuum state](concepts.md#c24) to [record](concepts.md#c17) zero with [environment](concepts.md#c11) one, sends A to the equal-weight superposition of \"[record](concepts.md#c17) zero, [environment](concepts.md#c11) zero\" and \"[record](concepts.md#c17) one, [environment](concepts.md#c11) one\", and sends B to [record](concepts.md#c17) one with [environment](concepts.md#c11) zero.\n\n\n## private 刺激甲 / Stimulus A\n\n- 定義:刺激甲是[非退化模型](concepts.md#c34)中的兩個[刺激](concepts.md#c07)之一,在[第三時刻](concepts.md#c38)[出現](concepts.md#c08);僅含刺激甲的[刺激束](concepts.md#c27),其[編碼](concepts.md#c19)是[刺激空間](concepts.md#c20)中標為甲的基底向量。\n- Definition: Stimulus A is one of the two [Stimuli](concepts.md#c07) of the [Non-Degenerate Model](concepts.md#c34); it [occurs](concepts.md#c08) at the [Third Moment](concepts.md#c38), and the [Encoding](concepts.md#c19) of the [stimulus bundle](concepts.md#c27) containing only Stimulus A is the basis vector of the [stimulus space](concepts.md#c20) labelled A.\n\n\n## private 刺激乙 / Stimulus B\n\n- 定義:刺激乙是[非退化模型](concepts.md#c34)中的兩個[刺激](concepts.md#c07)之一,在[第二時刻](concepts.md#c37)[出現](concepts.md#c08);僅含刺激乙的[刺激束](concepts.md#c27),其[編碼](concepts.md#c19)是[刺激空間](concepts.md#c20)中標為乙的基底向量。\n- Definition: Stimulus B is one of the two [Stimuli](concepts.md#c07) of the [Non-Degenerate Model](concepts.md#c34); it [occurs](concepts.md#c08) at the [Second Moment](concepts.md#c37), and the [Encoding](concepts.md#c19) of the [stimulus bundle](concepts.md#c27) containing only Stimulus B is the basis vector of the [stimulus space](concepts.md#c20) labelled B.\n\n\n## private 第二時刻 / Second Moment\n\n- 定義:第二時刻是[初始時刻](concepts.md#c05)的[後繼](concepts.md#c06),即編號為二的[時刻](concepts.md#c04)。\n- Definition: The second moment is the [Successor](concepts.md#c06) of the [Initial Moment](concepts.md#c05), that is, the [Moment](concepts.md#c04) numbered two.\n\n\n## private 第三時刻 / Third Moment\n\n- 定義:第三時刻是[第二時刻](concepts.md#c37)的[後繼](concepts.md#c06),即編號為三的[時刻](concepts.md#c04)。\n- Definition: The third moment is the [Successor](concepts.md#c06) of the [Second Moment](concepts.md#c37), that is, the [Moment](concepts.md#c04) numbered three.\n\n## 不登記\n\n- 觀察者:2026-09-23 論文未定義;依封閉原則,它不屬於形式層。\n- 序列:2026-09-23 非獨立概念,僅為公設二的敘述用語。\n\n## 待決項\n\n無\n","formalization_md":"論文:《暗宇宙的本體論》\nUUID:54c0291d-05b3-431a-9f2a-1b8ec93c3c3f\n\n## 記號約定\n\n來源:論文全文\n\n- 程式碼區塊內為論文數學式的摘錄,其中的符號依數學慣例解讀,例如張量積、映射方向與等號。\n- 下一時刻:論文數學式中的記號,指某 時刻 的 後繼,不是本篇概念。程式碼區塊外寫作 後繼 時刻。\n- 以下為標準數學用語,不是本篇概念:單位向量、等距映射、張量積、偏跡、約化態、密度算子、空乘積、恆等、恆等_過去、跡、維度、範數、零向量、正交、正交歸一基底。\n- 以下為論文證明中的區域變數,不是本篇概念:新刺激態、新環境、接上映射、態、態一、態二。\n- 以下未登記為概念,僅以自然語言提及:觀察者、觀察。\n\n## 前置條件\n\n來源:論文框架宣告、第一節、第二節【正文:句2413228854、句2370936929、句0967505617】\n\n- 前提一:時刻 以正整數編號;初始時刻 編號為一;每個 時刻 的 後繼 編號加一;每個 時刻 都有編號。【正文:句1944056660、句3474880125】\n- 前提二:出現 是 刺激 與 時刻 之間的關係,隨 刺激 一起 給定。【正文:句3088693906、句3607368803】\n- 前提三:見下式。初始信 為單位向量。【正文:句0796979366、句4306012983】\n\n```text\n|全域態(初始時刻)⟩ = |初始信⟩ ∈ 記錄空間, ‖初始信‖ = 1\n```\n\n- 前提四:初始時刻 的 記錄 由 前提三 給定,不經 寫入;初始時刻 的 刺激束 不 寫入 任何 記錄;寫入 只發生在 後繼 時刻。【正文:句3813014508、句4463596426】\n- 前提五:見下式。【正文:句0050409113】\n\n```text\n信空間(初始時刻) = 記錄空間\n環境總空間(初始時刻) = 空乘積\n```\n\n- 前提六:見下式。【正文:句0050409113】\n\n```text\n信空間(下一時刻) = 信空間(時刻) ⊗ 記錄空間\n環境總空間(下一時刻) = 環境總空間(時刻) ⊗ 環境空間\n```\n\n- 前提七:見下式。【正文:句0050409113、句6021879499】\n\n```text\n宇宙空間(時刻) = 信空間(時刻) ⊗ 環境總空間(時刻)\n```\n\n- 前提八:記錄基底 給定。【正文:句0050409113、句1810474327】\n- 前提九:刺激空間 與 環境空間 給定。【正文:句3399753925】\n- 前提十:見下式。每個 刺激束 都有 編碼,具體的值不指定;空刺激束 的 編碼 為 真空態。【正文:句3399753925、句3026819045、句8748484015】\n\n```text\n編碼 : 刺激束 → 刺激空間 中的單位向量, 編碼(∅) = |∅⟩\n```\n\n- 前提十一:見下式。寫入映射 給定,且為等距映射。【正文:句3399753925】\n\n```text\n寫入映射 : 刺激空間 → 記錄空間 ⊗ 環境空間\n```\n\n- 前提十二 [限定條件]:寫入映射 對所有 後繼 相同。【正文:句3399753925】\n [作者裁決] 保留。此條使 給定 的 寫入映射 只有一個,兌現框架宣告「不可推出的東西,越少越好」。它限定 給定 的範圍,不作為推導的前提。\n- 前提十三:形式層 中只有明列的 給定,以及由 給定 推出的東西。範圍限定於 形式層。【正文:句6828290729、句0068040101】\n [作者裁決] 框架宣告加入封閉原則,範圍限定於 形式層。\n- 前提十四 [限定條件]:形式層 中沒有觀察者。【正文:句2267107740、句6303127914】\n [作者裁決] 「沒有觀察者」是框架宣告直接規定的,不由 前提十三 推出。它限定 形式層 的範圍,不作為推導的前提。\n\n- 附註:可證偽條件:論文未列出可證偽條件。\n\n- 附註:循環:本文件無循環。全域態 的定義 為沿 時刻 的遞迴,以 前提三 為基底,逐一經 後繼 延伸,不構成循環。\n\n## 框架宣告\n\n來源:論文框架宣告【正文:句2413228854】\n\n- 附註:奇點 沒有 時刻;奇點 沒有之前;奇點 不可被形式化。\n- 附註:形式層 是 時刻 已開始、刺激 已 出現、信 已 累積 的宇宙。\n- 附註:給定 是 形式層 無法自己產生者。\n- 附註:不可推出的東西,越少越好;凡不可推出的,一律明列。本文件「前置條件」段落即為明列的清單。\n- 附註:本段「沒有觀察者」即 前提十四。\n\n## 原語\n\n來源:論文第一節【正文:句2370936929】\n\n- 附註:本節內容即 前提一、前提二。\n\n## 公設一:初始信\n\n來源:論文第二節〈公設一:初始信〉【正文:句1351552101】\n\n- 附註:本節內容即 前提三、前提四。\n- 附註:初始信 來自 奇點,其來由不追問,屬 給定。\n\n## 公設二:切分\n\n來源:論文第二節〈公設二:切分〉【正文:句4527977637】\n\n- 附註:本節內容即 前提五 至 前提八。\n- 步驟四之一:組成(宇宙空間, 信空間, 環境總空間)(從 前提七 推出)【正文:句0050409113、句6021879499】\n- 步驟四之二:切分 把 宇宙空間 劃分為 信空間 與 環境總空間;信 為保留的部分,環境 為被積掉的其餘(從 前提七 + 信 的定義 + 切分 的定義 + 信空間 的定義 + 環境總空間 的定義 推出)【正文:句1065936577】\n- 步驟四之三:組成(信空間, 記錄空間):某 時刻 的 信空間 由與該 時刻 編號同樣多份的 記錄空間 依 時刻 順序排列而成(從 前提一 + 前提五 + 前提六 推出)【正文:句6021879499、句0050409113】\n [作者裁決] 論文跳步,推導成立,保留。正文引用補至支撐細節的形式段;陳述強於所引正文句,是本跳步裁決的內容,不視為出處錯誤。\n- 步驟四之四:組成(環境總空間, 環境空間):某 時刻 的 環境總空間 由比該 時刻 編號少一份的 環境空間 排列而成;初始時刻 沒有 環境(從 前提一 + 前提五 + 前提六 推出)【正文:句6021879499、句0702858968、句0050409113】\n [作者裁決] 論文跳步,推導成立,保留。正文引用補至支撐細節的形式段;陳述強於所引正文句,是本跳步裁決的內容,不視為出處錯誤。\n- 步驟四之五:每個 後繼 時刻,信 多一筆 記錄,環境 多一份(從 前提六 推出)【正文:句8967661511】\n [作者裁決] 論文跳步,推導成立,保留。\n- 附註:刺激 不是宇宙的持存部分;刺激 是每個 後繼 時刻 新 出現 的自由度,出現 即被 寫入。\n- 附註:切分 只劃線,不選結果;切分 不是觀察。\n\n## 公設三:寫入\n\n來源:論文第二節〈公設三:寫入〉【正文:句4589420741】\n\n- 附註:本節內容即 前提九 至 前提十二。\n- 步驟五之一:刺激空間 的維度,不大於 記錄空間 與 環境空間 維度的乘積(從 前提九 + 前提十一 推出)【正文:句3399753925】\n- 步驟五之二:屬於(真空態, 刺激空間);真空態 為單位向量,不是零向量(從 前提十 推出)【正文:句3399753925、句8748484015】\n [作者裁決] 論文跳步,推導成立,保留。\n- 步驟五之三:導致(刺激束, 記錄):後繼 時刻 的 刺激束 先經 編碼,再經 寫入映射,成為一筆新的 記錄 與一份新的 環境;此即 寫入(從 全域態 的定義 + 前提十 + 前提十一 + 寫入 的定義 推出)【正文:句3894285170、句3399753925、句4546989263】\n [作者裁決] 論文跳步,推導成立,保留。正文引用補至支撐細節的形式段;陳述強於所引正文句,是本跳步裁決的內容,不視為出處錯誤。\n- 步驟五之四:寫入映射 只作用於新 出現 的 刺激束 的 編碼,不作用於既有部分;既有部分受 恆等_過去 作用(從 全域態 的定義 推出)【正文:句4473185142、句4546989263】\n [作者裁決] 論文跳步,推導成立,保留。正文引用補至支撐細節的形式段;陳述強於所引正文句,是本跳步裁決的內容,不視為出處錯誤。\n- 附註:寫入映射 的來源,形式層 不知道,屬 給定。\n\n## 定義一:全域態\n\n來源:論文第三節〈定義一:全域態〉【正文:句2345190277】\n\n```text\n|全域態(下一時刻)⟩ = ( 恆等_過去 ⊗ 寫入映射 ) ( |全域態(時刻)⟩ ⊗ 編碼(刺激束(下一時刻)) )\n```\n\n- 步驟六之一:屬於(全域態, 宇宙空間):每個 時刻 的 全域態 屬於該 時刻 的 宇宙空間,張量因子依標準同構重排(從 前提一 + 前提三 + 前提五 + 前提六 + 前提七 + 前提十 + 前提十一 + 全域態 的定義 推出)【正文:句4546989263、句0050409113、句5919236813】\n- 步驟六之二:全域態 只經歷 寫入:既有部分受 恆等_過去 作用而不動,新部分接在後面(從 全域態 的定義 推出)【正文:句2257760632、句0712631184、句4546989263】\n [作者裁決] 論文跳步,推導成立,保留。正文引用補至支撐細節的形式段;陳述強於所引正文句,是本跳步裁決的內容,不視為出處錯誤。\n\n## 定義二:信\n\n來源:論文第三節〈定義二:信〉【正文:句8311539837】\n\n```text\n信(時刻) = 跡_環境 |全域態(時刻)⟩⟨全域態(時刻)|\n```\n\n- 步驟七之一:每個 時刻 的 信 為該 時刻 的 信空間 上的密度算子(從 前提一 + 前提三 + 前提七 + 前提十 + 前提十一 + 全域態 的定義 + 信 的定義 + 步驟四之二 推出)【正文:句4315146058、句6609604575、句6021879499】\n- 附註:信 沒有主體;信 是 累積 本身。\n\n## 定義三:刺激束\n\n來源:論文第三節〈定義三:刺激束〉【正文:句9457326661】\n\n```text\n刺激束(時刻) = {刺激 ∈ 刺激 | 出現(刺激, 時刻)}\n```\n\n- 步驟八之一:蘊含(後繼 時刻 的 刺激束 為 空刺激束, 該 時刻 仍 寫入 一筆由 真空態 產生的 空記錄)(從 全域態 的定義 + 前提十 + 前提十一 推出)【正文:句5049795615】\n [作者裁決] 論文跳步,推導成立,保留。\n- 附註:空記錄 是一筆 記錄,不是零筆 記錄。\n\n## 推論一:累積\n\n來源:論文第四節〈推論一:累積〉【正文:句8298861916】\n\n- 附註:以下各步驟後附論文數學式的摘錄,其中 新刺激態 為 後繼 時刻 之 刺激束 的 編碼。\n\n- 步驟九之一:命題甲,見下式(從 前提六 推出)【正文:句4297742926、句6925276349】\n\n```text\n信空間(下一時刻) = 信空間(時刻) ⊗ 記錄空間\n```\n\n- 步驟九之二:後繼 時刻 的 全域態 為前一 時刻 的 全域態 與新部分的乘積,見下式(從 全域態 的定義 推出)【正文:句9037195502、句9109178138、句0836910715】\n\n```text\n|全域態(下一時刻)⟩ = |全域態(時刻)⟩ ⊗ 寫入映射|新刺激態⟩\n```\n\n- 步驟九之三:張量因子依標準同構重排,記錄 在前、環境 在後,得 信 的遞推式,見下式(從 步驟九之二 + 信 的定義 + 前提十一 + 前提六 + 步驟四之二 推出)【正文:句9038133932、句5919236813、句9226613099、句3034772101】\n\n```text\n信(下一時刻) = 信(時刻) ⊗ 跡_新環境( 寫入映射|新刺激態⟩⟨新刺激態|寫入映射† )\n```\n\n- 步驟九之四:對 最新記錄 取跡,見下式(從 步驟九之三 + 最新記錄 的定義 推出)【正文:句4818443210、句5193699410】\n\n```text\n跡_最新記錄 信(下一時刻) = 信(時刻) · 跡( 寫入映射|新刺激態⟩⟨新刺激態|寫入映射† )\n = 信(時刻) · ⟨新刺激態|寫入映射†寫入映射|新刺激態⟩\n```\n\n- 步驟九之五:命題乙。寫入映射 為等距映射,新刺激態 為單位向量,故得下式(從 步驟九之四 + 前提十一 + 前提十 推出)【正文:句5193699410、句7241307993】\n\n```text\n跡_最新記錄 信(下一時刻) = 信(時刻)\n```\n\n- 結論九之一:每個 後繼 時刻 皆有 累積(從 步驟九之一 + 步驟九之五 + 累積 的定義 推出)【正文:句4297742926、句3021229940】\n- 附註:每個 時刻 多一筆 記錄,過去不被改寫;信 的改變不是覆蓋,是增長。\n\n## 推論二:非坍縮\n\n來源:論文第四節〈推論二:非坍縮〉【正文:句0098448602】\n\n- 附註:以下各步驟後附論文數學式的摘錄,其中 新刺激態 為 後繼 時刻 之 刺激束 的 編碼。\n\n- 步驟十之一:演化規則 為兩步的合成,見下式(從 全域態 的定義 + 演化規則 的定義 推出)【正文:句9037195502、句4145541989、句3962360953】\n\n```text\n演化規則 = ( 恆等_過去 ⊗ 寫入映射 ) ∘ 接上映射, 接上映射 |態⟩ = |態⟩ ⊗ |新刺激態⟩\n```\n\n- 步驟十之二:接上映射 為等距映射,因 新刺激態 為單位向量,見下式(從 前提十 + 步驟十之一 推出)【正文:句1117132721】\n\n```text\n⟨態一 ⊗ 新刺激態 | 態二 ⊗ 新刺激態⟩ = ⟨態一|態二⟩ · ⟨新刺激態|新刺激態⟩ = ⟨態一|態二⟩\n```\n\n- 步驟十之三:恆等_過去 與 寫入映射 的張量積 為等距映射(從 前提十一 推出)【正文:句4320733487】\n- 步驟十之四:演化規則 為等距映射,因等距映射的合成為等距映射(從 步驟十之一 + 步驟十之二 + 步驟十之三 推出)【正文:句6153435550】\n- 步驟十之五:蘊含(演化規則 為等距映射, 演化規則 不構成 選出)(從 選出 的定義 + 演化規則 的定義 推出)【正文:句0555701433】\n- 步驟十之六:每個 後繼 時刻 的 演化規則 皆不構成 選出;步驟十之一至十之五對任意 後繼 時刻 論證,未使用該 時刻 的特定資料,故可全稱化(從 前提一 + 前提十 + 前提十一 + 步驟十之四 + 步驟十之五 + 演化規則 的定義 推出)【正文:句2085578999、句6153435550、句0555701433】\n- 結論十之一:非坍縮 成立:每個 後繼 時刻,形式層 中的 全域態 未經歷 選出(從 步驟十之六 + 非坍縮 的定義 推出)【正文:句0555701433、句9519889273】\n- 附註:信 可以在 記錄基底 下呈對角;對角不是 選出。\n\n## 觀察者問題\n\n來源:論文第五節【正文:句6585476963】\n\n- 步驟十一之一:形式層 有 切分(從 前提七 + 信 的定義 + 前提十三 + 切分 的定義 推出)【正文:句1075202277】\n [作者裁決] 論文跳步,推導成立,保留。\n- 附註:本節「沒有觀察者」即 前提十四。\n- 附註:切分 劃出 信 與 環境 的界線,不選結果。\n- 步驟十一之二:形式層 的 全域態 演化不包含 選出(從 結論十之一 + 非坍縮 的定義 推出)【正文:句2242920401】\n\n## 結論\n\n來源:論文第六節【正文:句6790580218】\n\n- 結論十二之一:時刻 與 記錄 的筆數一一對應:編號為某數的 時刻,其 信 恰有該數筆 記錄(從 前提一 + 前提四 + 前提五 + 前提六 推出)【正文:句8400308605、句0050409113、句3813014508】\n [作者裁決] 論文跳步,推導成立,保留。正文引用補至支撐細節的形式段;陳述強於所引正文句,是本跳步裁決的內容,不視為出處錯誤。\n- 結論十二之二:宇宙只增不改:既有部分受 恆等_過去 作用而不動,過去的 記錄 不被改寫(從 全域態 的定義 + 結論九之一 推出)【正文:句2994773955、句0712631184、句3021229940、句4510970164】\n [作者裁決] 論文跳步,推導成立,保留。正文引用補至支撐細節的形式段;陳述強於所引正文句,是本跳步裁決的內容,不視為出處錯誤。\n\n## 附錄:非退化模型\n\n來源:論文附錄【正文:句8774282582】\n\n- 附註:本段為例。模型資料見概念表 非退化模型、刺激甲、刺激乙、第二時刻、第三時刻 各條目,本文件不重複。\n\n```text\n信(初始時刻) = |0⟩⟨0|\n信(第二時刻) = |0⟩⟨0| ⊗ |1⟩⟨1|\n信(第三時刻) = |0⟩⟨0| ⊗ |1⟩⟨1| ⊗ (恆等/2)\n```\n\n- 例:計算得上式;非退化模型 給定 了前三個 時刻 的 出現(從 本例效準 + 前提二 + 全域態 的定義 + 信 的定義 + 刺激束 的定義 推出)【正文:句8295366179、句0944409407、句9153070184、句0357757296、句8036516582】\n- 例:檢核一,寫入映射 為等距映射,三個像兩兩正交、範數為一(從 本例效準 推出)【正文:句0944409407、句1290319221】\n- 例:檢核二,記錄 筆數依序為一、二、三;過去的 記錄 不變;此為 推論一 的實例(從 本例效準 + 前提二 + 全域態 的定義 + 信 的定義 + 刺激束 的定義 推出)【正文:句9405668440、句1712782291】\n- 例:檢核三,每一步的 演化規則 為等距映射;第三時刻 的 信 中,最新記錄 為 恆等 的一半,在 記錄基底 下呈對角;不發生 選出(從 本例效準 + 前提二 + 全域態 的定義 + 信 的定義 + 刺激束 的定義 + 前提八 + 結論十之一 推出)【正文:句0944409407、句6780078199、句6050305013】\n- 例:檢核四,空刺激束、刺激甲、刺激乙 經 寫入 產生的 記錄 兩兩不同(從 本例效準 推出)【正文:句4586639499】\n- 附註:這個宇宙沒有人;沒有觀察者;只有 時刻、刺激、信。\n\n## 待決項\n\n無\n","paper_files":[{"filename":"暗宇宙的本體論.md","content":"---\nuuid: 54c0291d-05b3-431a-9f2a-1b8ec93c3c3f\nlast-modified: 2026-09-27T01:51:21\nauthor: 黃正宇 / Cheng Yu Huang\ncontact: mthree.tw@gmail.com\n---\n\n# 暗宇宙的本體論\n\n## 框架宣告\n\n[奇點](concepts.md#c01)沒有[時刻](concepts.md#c04)。\n\n[時刻](concepts.md#c04)從[奇點](concepts.md#c01)之後開始。[奇點](concepts.md#c01)沒有之前。[奇點](concepts.md#c01)不可被形式化。\n\n本框架描述的是:[時刻](concepts.md#c04)已經開始,[刺激](concepts.md#c07)已經[出現](concepts.md#c08),[信](concepts.md#c26)已經[累積](concepts.md#c30),沒有觀察者的宇宙。這個宇宙,就是[形式層](concepts.md#c02)。\n\n[形式層](concepts.md#c02)沒有觀察者,但有[給定](concepts.md#c03)。[給定](concepts.md#c03)是[形式層](concepts.md#c02)無法自己產生的東西。本框架的原則是:**不可推出的東西,越少越好;凡不可推出的,一律明列。[形式層](concepts.md#c02)中只有明列的[給定](concepts.md#c03),以及由[給定](concepts.md#c03)推出的東西。**\n\n---\n\n## 一、原語\n\n- **[時刻](concepts.md#c04)**:時間的索引。[時刻](concepts.md#c04)以正整數編號:[初始時刻](concepts.md#c05)是第一個,每個[時刻](concepts.md#c04)的[後繼](concepts.md#c06)是編號加一的那個[時刻](concepts.md#c04);每個[時刻](concepts.md#c04)都有編號。\n- **[刺激](concepts.md#c07)**:每個[時刻](concepts.md#c04)隨之[出現](concepts.md#c08)的物理內容。光、聲音、重力波、熱輻射等。哪個[刺激](concepts.md#c07)在哪個[時刻](concepts.md#c04)[出現](concepts.md#c08),隨[刺激](concepts.md#c07)一起[給定](concepts.md#c03):\n\n```text\n出現 ⊆ 刺激 × 時刻\n```\n\n\n---\n\n## 二、公設\n\n以下三條不可推出,只能承認。\n\n### 公設一:初始信\n\n```text\n|全域態(初始時刻)⟩ = |初始信⟩ ∈ 記錄空間, ‖初始信‖ = 1\n```\n\n\n[初始信](concepts.md#c09)是單位向量。它來自[奇點](concepts.md#c01),不追問。\n\n[初始時刻](concepts.md#c05)的[記錄](concepts.md#c17)由本公設[給定](concepts.md#c03),不經[寫入](concepts.md#c21);[初始時刻](concepts.md#c05)的[刺激束](concepts.md#c27)不[寫入](concepts.md#c21)任何[記錄](concepts.md#c17)。[寫入](concepts.md#c21)只發生在每個[後繼](concepts.md#c06)[時刻](concepts.md#c04)。\n\n### 公設二:切分\n\n```text\n信空間(初始時刻) = 記錄空間\n環境總空間(初始時刻) = 空乘積 // 初始時刻沒有環境\n信空間(下一時刻) = 信空間(時刻) ⊗ 記錄空間\n環境總空間(下一時刻) = 環境總空間(時刻) ⊗ 環境空間\n宇宙空間(時刻) = 信空間(時刻) ⊗ 環境總空間(時刻)\n記錄空間 的基底給定\n```\n\n\n[切分](concepts.md#c10)把宇宙切成兩部分:保留的[累積](concepts.md#c30)([信](concepts.md#c26))與被積掉的其餘([環境](concepts.md#c11))。[宇宙空間](concepts.md#c12)因此由[信空間](concepts.md#c13)與[環境總空間](concepts.md#c14)組成:[信空間](concepts.md#c13)是[信](concepts.md#c26)所在的空間,由一份份[記錄空間](concepts.md#c15)排成;[環境總空間](concepts.md#c14)是[環境](concepts.md#c11)所在的空間,由一份份[環境空間](concepts.md#c16)排成,隨[時刻](concepts.md#c04)增長。[信](concepts.md#c26)由一筆筆[記錄](concepts.md#c17)排成,而[記錄](concepts.md#c17)以什麼[基底](concepts.md#c18)讀出,是[給定](concepts.md#c03)的。「序列」之所以是序列,是因為這條公設。\n\n每個[後繼](concepts.md#c06)[時刻](concepts.md#c04),[信](concepts.md#c26)多一筆[記錄](concepts.md#c17),[環境](concepts.md#c11)多一份。[初始時刻](concepts.md#c05)只有[初始信](concepts.md#c09),沒有[環境](concepts.md#c11)。\n\n[刺激](concepts.md#c07)不是宇宙的持存部分。[刺激](concepts.md#c07)是每個[後繼](concepts.md#c06)[時刻](concepts.md#c04)新[出現](concepts.md#c08)的自由度,[出現](concepts.md#c08)即被[寫入](concepts.md#c21)(公設三)。\n\n**[切分](concepts.md#c10)不是觀察。** [切分](concepts.md#c10)只劃線,不選結果。\n\n### 公設三:寫入\n\n```text\n刺激空間 與 環境空間 給定\n編碼 : 刺激束 → 刺激空間 中的單位向量, 編碼(∅) = |∅⟩\n給定一個固定的等距映射 寫入映射 : 刺激空間 → 記錄空間 ⊗ 環境空間\n (故 維度 刺激空間 ≤ 維度 記錄空間 · 維度 環境空間)\n寫入映射 對所有後繼相同\n```\n\n\n[編碼](concepts.md#c19)對每個[刺激束](concepts.md#c27)都[給定](concepts.md#c03)[刺激空間](concepts.md#c20)中的一個值,包括含多個[刺激](concepts.md#c07)的[刺激束](concepts.md#c27);具體的值不指定。\n\n這條公設規定一個[刺激](concepts.md#c07)如何被[寫成](concepts.md#c21)一筆[記錄](concepts.md#c17)。[寫入映射](concepts.md#c22)只碰新[出現](concepts.md#c08)的[刺激](concepts.md#c07),從不碰已經存在的東西。\n\n[空刺激束](concepts.md#c23)對應[真空態](concepts.md#c24):一個真實的態,不是零向量。[寫入映射](concepts.md#c22)從哪裡來,[形式層](concepts.md#c02)不知道。\n\n---\n\n## 三、定義\n\n### 定義一:全域態\n\n```text\n|全域態(下一時刻)⟩ = ( 恆等_過去 ⊗ 寫入映射 ) ( |全域態(時刻)⟩ ⊗ 編碼(刺激束(下一時刻)) )\n\n其中 恆等_過去 作用於 宇宙空間(時刻)\n結果住在 宇宙空間(下一時刻)\n```\n\n\n[全域態](concepts.md#c25)即宇宙在該[時刻](concepts.md#c04)的態。它只經歷[寫入](concepts.md#c21)。舊的不動,新的接在後面。\n\n### 定義二:信\n\n```text\n信(時刻) = 跡_環境 |全域態(時刻)⟩⟨全域態(時刻)|\n```\n\n\n[信](concepts.md#c26)是[全域態](concepts.md#c25)在[切分](concepts.md#c10)之下的約化態,對全部[環境](concepts.md#c11)取偏跡。沒有「誰的[信](concepts.md#c26)」。[信](concepts.md#c26)是[累積](concepts.md#c30)本身,沒有主體。\n\n### 定義三:刺激束\n\n```text\n刺激束(時刻) = {刺激 ∈ 刺激 | 出現(刺激, 時刻)}\n```\n\n\n在每個[後繼](concepts.md#c06)[時刻](concepts.md#c04),[刺激束](concepts.md#c27)為空集時,該[時刻](concepts.md#c04)仍[寫下](concepts.md#c21)一筆由[真空態](concepts.md#c24)產生的[記錄](concepts.md#c17)。[空記錄](concepts.md#c28)不是零筆[記錄](concepts.md#c17)。\n\n---\n\n## 四、推論\n\n以下兩條皆可從公設與定義推出。\n\n### 推論一:累積\n\n```text\n對所有後繼 [\n 信空間(下一時刻) = 信空間(時刻) ⊗ 記錄空間 // 多一筆記錄\n 且 跡_最新記錄 信(下一時刻) = 信(時刻)\n]\n```\n\n\n**證明。** 由公設二,[信空間](concepts.md#c13)([下一時刻](concepts.md#c06)) = [信空間](concepts.md#c13)([時刻](concepts.md#c04)) ⊗ [記錄空間](concepts.md#c15):[信](concepts.md#c26)多一筆[記錄](concepts.md#c17)。\n\n記 |新刺激態⟩ = [編碼](concepts.md#c19)([刺激束](concepts.md#c27)([下一時刻](concepts.md#c06)))。由定義一:\n\n```text\n|全域態(下一時刻)⟩ = |全域態(時刻)⟩ ⊗ 寫入映射|新刺激態⟩\n```\n\n\n新舊兩部分為乘積。張量因子依標準同構重排,[記錄](concepts.md#c17)在前、[環境](concepts.md#c11)在後。由定義二:\n\n```text\n信(下一時刻) = 信(時刻) ⊗ 跡_新環境( 寫入映射|新刺激態⟩⟨新刺激態|寫入映射† )\n```\n\n\n對[最新記錄](concepts.md#c29)取跡:\n\n```text\n跡_最新記錄 信(下一時刻) = 信(時刻) · 跡( 寫入映射|新刺激態⟩⟨新刺激態|寫入映射† )\n = 信(時刻) · ⟨新刺激態|寫入映射†寫入映射|新刺激態⟩\n = 信(時刻)\n```\n\n\n最後一步用到[寫入映射](concepts.md#c22)為等距映射([寫入映射](concepts.md#c22)†[寫入映射](concepts.md#c22) = 恆等)與 |新刺激態⟩ 為單位向量。∎\n\n這就是[累積](concepts.md#c30):每個[時刻](concepts.md#c04)多一筆[記錄](concepts.md#c17),過去不被改寫。[信](concepts.md#c26)的改變不是覆蓋,是增長。\n\n### 推論二:非坍縮\n\n```text\n演化規則:定義一給出的映射 |全域態(時刻)⟩ ↦ |全域態(下一時刻)⟩\n選出:某時刻的態送到下一時刻之態的映射不是等距映射\n\n對所有後繼:形式層中的全域態未經歷選出\n```\n\n\n**證明。** 記 |新刺激態⟩ = [編碼](concepts.md#c19)([刺激束](concepts.md#c27)([下一時刻](concepts.md#c06)))。由定義一,[演化規則](concepts.md#c31)是兩步的合成:\n\n```text\n演化規則 = ( 恆等_過去 ⊗ 寫入映射 ) ∘ 接上映射, 接上映射 |態⟩ = |態⟩ ⊗ |新刺激態⟩\n```\n\n\n接上映射是等距映射:對任意 |態一⟩、|態二⟩,⟨態一 ⊗ 新刺激態 | 態二 ⊗ 新刺激態⟩ = ⟨態一|態二⟩ · ⟨新刺激態|新刺激態⟩ = ⟨態一|態二⟩。恆等_過去 ⊗ [寫入映射](concepts.md#c22)是等距映射,因為 恆等_過去 與[寫入映射](concepts.md#c22)皆是。等距映射的合成是等距映射,故[演化規則](concepts.md#c31)是等距映射。[形式層](concepts.md#c02)中的[全域態](concepts.md#c25)未經歷[選出](concepts.md#c32)。∎\n\n[信](concepts.md#c26)可以在[記錄基底](concepts.md#c18)下是對角的,看起來像經典序列的機率分布。[非坍縮](concepts.md#c33)不否認這一點,它否認的是**[選出](concepts.md#c32)**。對角不是坍縮。看起來經典,不等於已經是某一條。\n\n---\n\n## 五、觀察者問題\n\n[形式層](concepts.md#c02)有[切分](concepts.md#c10),但沒有觀察者。\n\n[切分](concepts.md#c10)劃出[信](concepts.md#c26)與[環境](concepts.md#c11)的界線,不選結果。[形式層](concepts.md#c02)的[全域態](concepts.md#c25)演化不包含[選出](concepts.md#c32)(推論二)。\n\n---\n\n## 六、結論\n\n這個宇宙只增不改。既有的部分沒有運動,過去的[記錄](concepts.md#c17)沒有被改變,只有[記錄](concepts.md#c17)一筆一筆地[累積](concepts.md#c30)。[時刻](concepts.md#c04)與[記錄](concepts.md#c17)的筆數一一對應。\n\n---\n\n## 附錄:非退化模型(前三個時刻)\n\n以下是一個[非退化模型](concepts.md#c34):兩個[刺激](concepts.md#c07),[刺激甲](concepts.md#c35)與[刺激乙](concepts.md#c36),給出[初始時刻](concepts.md#c05)、[第二時刻](concepts.md#c37)、[第三時刻](concepts.md#c38)的完整資料。以下三個空間所列的基底,皆為正交歸一基底。\n\n```text\n前三個時刻 = 初始時刻, 第二時刻, 第三時刻 // 後續時刻依同一寫入延伸\n刺激 = {刺激甲, 刺激乙}\n\n記錄空間 = 張成{|0⟩, |1⟩}\n刺激空間 = 張成{|∅⟩, |甲⟩, |乙⟩}\n環境空間 = 張成{|0⟩, |1⟩}\n\n出現(刺激乙, 第二時刻) = 真\n出現(刺激甲, 第三時刻) = 真\n// 前三個時刻內,其餘的出現皆為假\n\n|初始信⟩ = |0⟩\n\n編碼({刺激甲}) = |甲⟩\n編碼({刺激乙}) = |乙⟩\n// 編碼(∅) = |∅⟩ 由公設三給定\n// {刺激甲, 刺激乙} 在前三個時刻不出現,其編碼可任取單位向量\n\n寫入映射|∅⟩ = |0⟩_記錄 |1⟩_環境\n寫入映射|甲⟩ = ( |0⟩_記錄 |0⟩_環境 + |1⟩_記錄 |1⟩_環境 ) / √2\n寫入映射|乙⟩ = |1⟩_記錄 |0⟩_環境\n```\n\n\n**計算:**\n\n```text\n信(初始時刻) = |0⟩⟨0|\n信(第二時刻) = |0⟩⟨0| ⊗ |1⟩⟨1|\n信(第三時刻) = |0⟩⟨0| ⊗ |1⟩⟨1| ⊗ (恆等/2)\n```\n\n\n**檢核:**\n\n- [寫入映射](concepts.md#c22)為等距映射:三個像兩兩正交,範數為一 ✓\n- 推論一:[記錄](concepts.md#c17)筆數 1 → 2 → 3 ✓。過去[記錄](concepts.md#c17)不變 ✓\n- 推論二:每一步的[演化規則](concepts.md#c31)為等距映射 ✓。[信](concepts.md#c26)([第三時刻](concepts.md#c38)) [最新記錄](concepts.md#c29)為 恆等/2,在[記錄基底](concepts.md#c18)下對角,但沒有任何分支被[選出](concepts.md#c32) ✓\n- [空刺激束](concepts.md#c23)、[刺激甲](concepts.md#c35)、[刺激乙](concepts.md#c36)三者產生的[記錄](concepts.md#c17)兩兩不同 ✓\n\n**這個宇宙沒有人。沒有觀察者。只有[時刻](concepts.md#c04)、[刺激](concepts.md#c07)、[信](concepts.md#c26)。**\n"},{"filename":"The Ontology of the Dark Universe.md","content":"---\nuuid: 54c0291d-05b3-431a-9f2a-1b8ec93c3c3f\nlast-modified: 2026-09-27T01:51:21\nauthor: 黃正宇 / Cheng Yu Huang\ncontact: mthree.tw@gmail.com\n---\n\n# The Ontology of the Dark Universe\n\n## Framework Declaration\n\nThe [Singularity](concepts.md#c01) has no [moment](concepts.md#c04).\n\n[Moments](concepts.md#c04) begin after the [Singularity](concepts.md#c01). The [Singularity](concepts.md#c01) has no before. The [Singularity](concepts.md#c01) cannot be formalized.\n\nWhat this framework describes is a universe in which [moments](concepts.md#c04) have begun, [stimuli](concepts.md#c07) have [occurred](concepts.md#c08), and [Xin](concepts.md#c26) has [accumulated](concepts.md#c30), with no observer. This universe is the [Formal Layer](concepts.md#c02).\n\nThe [Formal Layer](concepts.md#c02) has no observer, but it has [givens](concepts.md#c03). A [given](concepts.md#c03) is something the [Formal Layer](concepts.md#c02) cannot produce by itself. The principle of this framework is: **what cannot be derived should be as little as possible; whatever cannot be derived must be listed explicitly. The [Formal Layer](concepts.md#c02) contains nothing but the explicitly listed [givens](concepts.md#c03) and what is derived from the [givens](concepts.md#c03).**\n\n---\n\n## I. Primitives\n\n- **[Moment](concepts.md#c04)**: an index of time. [Moments](concepts.md#c04) are numbered by the positive integers: the [Initial Moment](concepts.md#c05) is the first, the [successor](concepts.md#c06) of each [moment](concepts.md#c04) is the [moment](concepts.md#c04) whose number is one greater, and every [moment](concepts.md#c04) has a number.\n- **[Stimulus](concepts.md#c07)**: the physical content that [occurs](concepts.md#c08) with each [moment](concepts.md#c04): light, sound, gravitational waves, thermal radiation, and so on. Which [stimulus](concepts.md#c07) [occurs](concepts.md#c08) at which [moment](concepts.md#c04) is [given](concepts.md#c03) together with the [stimuli](concepts.md#c07):\n\n```text\nOccurrence ⊆ Stimulus × Moment\n```\n\n---\n\n## II. Axioms\n\nThe following three cannot be derived; they can only be acknowledged.\n\n### Axiom 1: Initial Xin\n\n```text\n|Global State(Initial Moment)⟩ = |Initial Xin⟩ ∈ Record Space, ‖Initial Xin‖ = 1\n```\n\nThe [Initial Xin](concepts.md#c09) is a unit vector. It comes from the [Singularity](concepts.md#c01); this is not questioned.\n\nThe [record](concepts.md#c17) of the [Initial Moment](concepts.md#c05) is [given](concepts.md#c03) by this axiom, not produced by [Writing](concepts.md#c21); the [Stimulus Bundle](concepts.md#c27) of the [Initial Moment](concepts.md#c05) is not [written](concepts.md#c21) into any [record](concepts.md#c17). [Writing](concepts.md#c21) takes place only at each [successor](concepts.md#c06) [moment](concepts.md#c04).\n\n### Axiom 2: Partition\n\n```text\nXin Space(Initial Moment) = Record Space\nTotal Environment Space(Initial Moment) = empty product // no environment at the initial moment\nXin Space(next moment) = Xin Space(moment) ⊗ Record Space\nTotal Environment Space(next moment) = Total Environment Space(moment) ⊗ Environment Space\nUniverse Space(moment) = Xin Space(moment) ⊗ Total Environment Space(moment)\nthe basis of Record Space is given\n```\n\nThe [Partition](concepts.md#c10) cuts the universe into two parts: the retained [accumulation](concepts.md#c30) ([Xin](concepts.md#c26)) and the traced-out remainder (the [Environment](concepts.md#c11)). The [Universe Space](concepts.md#c12) is therefore composed of the [Xin Space](concepts.md#c13) and the [Total Environment Space](concepts.md#c14): the [Xin Space](concepts.md#c13) is the space in which [Xin](concepts.md#c26) lives, arranged from copies of the [Record Space](concepts.md#c15); the [Total Environment Space](concepts.md#c14) is the space in which the [Environment](concepts.md#c11) lives, arranged from copies of the [Environment Space](concepts.md#c16) and growing with the [moments](concepts.md#c04). [Xin](concepts.md#c26) is arranged [record](concepts.md#c17) by record, and the [Record Basis](concepts.md#c18) in which [records](concepts.md#c17) are read out is [given](concepts.md#c03). A \"sequence\" is a sequence because of this axiom.\n\nAt each [successor](concepts.md#c06) [moment](concepts.md#c04), [Xin](concepts.md#c26) gains one more [record](concepts.md#c17) and the [Environment](concepts.md#c11) one more part. At the [Initial Moment](concepts.md#c05) there is only the [Initial Xin](concepts.md#c09) and no [Environment](concepts.md#c11).\n\n[Stimuli](concepts.md#c07) are not a persistent part of the universe. A [stimulus](concepts.md#c07) is a degree of freedom newly [occurring](concepts.md#c08) at each [successor](concepts.md#c06) [moment](concepts.md#c04); as soon as it [occurs](concepts.md#c08), it is [written](concepts.md#c21) (Axiom 3).\n\n**The [Partition](concepts.md#c10) is not an observation.** The [Partition](concepts.md#c10) only draws a line; it does not select an outcome.\n\n### Axiom 3: Writing\n\n```text\nStimulus Space and Environment Space are given\nEncoding : Stimulus Bundle → unit vectors in Stimulus Space, Encoding(∅) = |∅⟩\na fixed isometry is given Writing Map : Stimulus Space → Record Space ⊗ Environment Space\n (hence dim Stimulus Space ≤ dim Record Space · dim Environment Space)\nWriting Map is the same for all successors\n```\n\nFor every [Stimulus Bundle](concepts.md#c27), a value in the [Stimulus Space](concepts.md#c20) is [given](concepts.md#c03) by the [Encoding](concepts.md#c19), including for [Stimulus Bundles](concepts.md#c27) that contain several [stimuli](concepts.md#c07); the specific values are not fixed.\n\nThis axiom specifies how a [stimulus](concepts.md#c07) is [written](concepts.md#c21) as a [record](concepts.md#c17). The [Writing Map](concepts.md#c22) touches only newly [occurring](concepts.md#c08) [stimuli](concepts.md#c07) and never touches what already exists.\n\nThe [Empty Stimulus Bundle](concepts.md#c23) corresponds to the [Vacuum State](concepts.md#c24): a genuine state, not the zero vector. Where the [Writing Map](concepts.md#c22) comes from, the [Formal Layer](concepts.md#c02) does not know.\n\n---\n\n## III. Definitions\n\n### Definition 1: Global State\n\n```text\n|Global State(next moment)⟩ = ( I_past ⊗ Writing Map ) ( |Global State(moment)⟩ ⊗ Encoding(Stimulus Bundle(next moment)) )\n\nwhere I_past acts on Universe Space(moment)\nthe result lives in Universe Space(next moment)\n```\n\nThe [Global State](concepts.md#c25) is the state of the universe at that [moment](concepts.md#c04). It undergoes only [Writing](concepts.md#c21). The old does not move; the new is appended after it.\n\n### Definition 2: Xin\n\n```text\nXin(moment) = Tr_Environment |Global State(moment)⟩⟨Global State(moment)|\n```\n\n[Xin](concepts.md#c26) is the reduced state of the [Global State](concepts.md#c25) under the [Partition](concepts.md#c10), obtained by taking the partial trace over the entire [Environment](concepts.md#c11). There is no \"whose [Xin](concepts.md#c26)\". [Xin](concepts.md#c26) is [Accumulation](concepts.md#c30) itself; it has no subject.\n\n### Definition 3: Stimulus Bundle\n\n```text\nStimulus Bundle(moment) = {stimulus ∈ Stimulus | Occurrence(stimulus, moment)}\n```\n\nAt each [successor](concepts.md#c06) [moment](concepts.md#c04), when the [Stimulus Bundle](concepts.md#c27) is the empty set, that [moment](concepts.md#c04) still [writes](concepts.md#c21) a [record](concepts.md#c17) produced from the [Vacuum State](concepts.md#c24). An [Empty Record](concepts.md#c28) is not zero [records](concepts.md#c17).\n\n---\n\n## IV. Corollaries\n\nBoth of the following can be derived from the axioms and definitions.\n\n### Corollary 1: Accumulation\n\n```text\nfor every successor [\n Xin Space(next moment) = Xin Space(moment) ⊗ Record Space // one more record\n and Tr_latest record Xin(next moment) = Xin(moment)\n]\n```\n\n**Proof.** By Axiom 2, the [Xin Space](concepts.md#c13) at the [successor](concepts.md#c06) moment equals the [Xin Space](concepts.md#c13) at the [moment](concepts.md#c04) ⊗ the [Record Space](concepts.md#c15): [Xin](concepts.md#c26) gains one more [record](concepts.md#c17).\n\nLet |new stimulus state⟩ = [Encoding](concepts.md#c19)([Stimulus Bundle](concepts.md#c27) at the [successor](concepts.md#c06) moment). By Definition 1:\n\n```text\n|Global State(next moment)⟩ = |Global State(moment)⟩ ⊗ Writing Map|new stimulus state⟩\n```\n\nThe new and old parts form a product. Rearranging the tensor factors by the standard isomorphism, [records](concepts.md#c17) first and [Environment](concepts.md#c11) after. By Definition 2:\n\n```text\nXin(next moment) = Xin(moment) ⊗ Tr_new environment( Writing Map|new stimulus state⟩⟨new stimulus state|Writing Map† )\n```\n\nTaking the trace over the [Latest Record](concepts.md#c29):\n\n```text\nTr_latest record Xin(next moment) = Xin(moment) · Tr( Writing Map|new stimulus state⟩⟨new stimulus state|Writing Map† )\n = Xin(moment) · ⟨new stimulus state|Writing Map†Writing Map|new stimulus state⟩\n = Xin(moment)\n```\n\nThe last step uses that the [Writing Map](concepts.md#c22) is an isometry ([Writing Map](concepts.md#c22)†[Writing Map](concepts.md#c22) = I) and that |new stimulus state⟩ is a unit vector. ∎\n\nThis is [Accumulation](concepts.md#c30): each [moment](concepts.md#c04) adds one [record](concepts.md#c17), and the past is not rewritten. The change of [Xin](concepts.md#c26) is not overwriting but growth.\n\n### Corollary 2: Non-Collapse\n\n```text\nEvolution Rule: the map given by Definition 1 |Global State(moment)⟩ ↦ |Global State(next moment)⟩\nSelection: the map sending the state at one moment to the state at the next moment is not an isometry\n\nfor every successor: the Global State in the Formal Layer has not undergone Selection\n```\n\n**Proof.** Let |new stimulus state⟩ = [Encoding](concepts.md#c19)([Stimulus Bundle](concepts.md#c27) at the [successor](concepts.md#c06) moment). By Definition 1, the [Evolution Rule](concepts.md#c31) is a composition of two steps:\n\n```text\nEvolution Rule = ( I_past ⊗ Writing Map ) ∘ Append, Append |state⟩ = |state⟩ ⊗ |new stimulus state⟩\n```\n\nAppend is an isometry: for any |state one⟩, |state two⟩, ⟨state one ⊗ new stimulus state | state two ⊗ new stimulus state⟩ = ⟨state one|state two⟩ · ⟨new stimulus state|new stimulus state⟩ = ⟨state one|state two⟩. I_past ⊗ [Writing Map](concepts.md#c22) is an isometry, since I_past and the [Writing Map](concepts.md#c22) both are. A composition of isometries is an isometry, so the [Evolution Rule](concepts.md#c31) is an isometry. The [Global State](concepts.md#c25) in the [Formal Layer](concepts.md#c02) has not undergone [Selection](concepts.md#c32). ∎\n\n[Xin](concepts.md#c26) can be diagonal in the [Record Basis](concepts.md#c18), looking like a probability distribution over classical sequences. [Non-Collapse](concepts.md#c33) does not deny this; what it denies is **[Selection](concepts.md#c32)**. Diagonal is not collapse. Looking classical is not the same as already being one particular sequence.\n\n---\n\n## V. The Observer Problem\n\nThe [Formal Layer](concepts.md#c02) has a [Partition](concepts.md#c10), but no observer.\n\nThe [Partition](concepts.md#c10) draws the boundary between [Xin](concepts.md#c26) and the [Environment](concepts.md#c11); it does not select an outcome. The evolution of the [Global State](concepts.md#c25) in the [Formal Layer](concepts.md#c02) contains no [Selection](concepts.md#c32) (Corollary 2).\n\n---\n\n## VI. Conclusion\n\nThis universe only grows and never alters. What already exists does not move, and no past [record](concepts.md#c17) is changed; only [records](concepts.md#c17) [accumulate](concepts.md#c30), one by one. [Moments](concepts.md#c04) and the number of [records](concepts.md#c17) correspond one to one.\n\n---\n\n## Appendix: Non-Degenerate Model (First Three Moments)\n\nThe following is a [Non-Degenerate Model](concepts.md#c34): two [stimuli](concepts.md#c07), [Stimulus A](concepts.md#c35) and [Stimulus B](concepts.md#c36), with complete data for the [Initial Moment](concepts.md#c05), the [Second Moment](concepts.md#c37), and the [Third Moment](concepts.md#c38). The bases listed below for the three spaces are all orthonormal bases.\n\n```text\nfirst three moments = Initial Moment, Second Moment, Third Moment // later moments extend by the same writing\nStimulus = {Stimulus A, Stimulus B}\n\nRecord Space = span{|0⟩, |1⟩}\nStimulus Space = span{|∅⟩, |A⟩, |B⟩}\nEnvironment Space = span{|0⟩, |1⟩}\n\nOccurrence(Stimulus B, Second Moment) = true\nOccurrence(Stimulus A, Third Moment) = true\n// within the first three moments, all other occurrences are false\n\n|Initial Xin⟩ = |0⟩\n\nEncoding({Stimulus A}) = |A⟩\nEncoding({Stimulus B}) = |B⟩\n// Encoding(∅) = |∅⟩ is given by Axiom 3\n// {Stimulus A, Stimulus B} does not occur in the first three moments; its encoding may be any unit vector\n\nWriting Map|∅⟩ = |0⟩_record |1⟩_environment\nWriting Map|A⟩ = ( |0⟩_record |0⟩_environment + |1⟩_record |1⟩_environment ) / √2\nWriting Map|B⟩ = |1⟩_record |0⟩_environment\n```\n\n**Computation:**\n\n```text\nXin(Initial Moment) = |0⟩⟨0|\nXin(Second Moment) = |0⟩⟨0| ⊗ |1⟩⟨1|\nXin(Third Moment) = |0⟩⟨0| ⊗ |1⟩⟨1| ⊗ (I/2)\n```\n\n**Checks:**\n\n- The [Writing Map](concepts.md#c22) is an isometry: the three images are pairwise orthogonal, each of norm one ✓\n- Corollary 1: the number of [records](concepts.md#c17) goes 1 → 2 → 3 ✓. Past [records](concepts.md#c17) are unchanged ✓\n- Corollary 2: the [Evolution Rule](concepts.md#c31) at each step is an isometry ✓. In [Xin](concepts.md#c26) at the [Third Moment](concepts.md#c38), the [Latest Record](concepts.md#c29) is I/2, diagonal in the [Record Basis](concepts.md#c18), yet no branch has been [selected](concepts.md#c32) ✓\n- The [records](concepts.md#c17) produced by the [Empty Stimulus Bundle](concepts.md#c23), [Stimulus A](concepts.md#c35), and [Stimulus B](concepts.md#c36) are pairwise distinct ✓\n\n**This universe has no one. No observer. Only [Moments](concepts.md#c04), [Stimuli](concepts.md#c07), [Xin](concepts.md#c26).**\n"}]}
{"paper_uuid":"81952268-47b1-4d8c-9605-270c42646693","paper_title":"生物人個體輸出傾向動力學","paper_title_en":"Dynamics of Output Tendency in the Biological Human Individual","author":"黃正宇 / Cheng Yu Huang","contact":"mthree.tw@gmail.com","concepts_md":"---\nuuid: 81952268-47b1-4d8c-9605-270c42646693\nlast-modified: 2026-10-28T21:32:03\n---\n\n\n## public 要能果三問 / Want-Can-Outcome Questions\n\n- 定義:關於一個[個體](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c20)的三個問題;這裡的[個體](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c20)是生物人,屬上游所稱的[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19):能自述,也能對自己作[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)。對這樣的[個體](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c20),個體層的問題只有這三個:它要什麼,對應[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06)與[輸出傾向](concepts.md#c02),研究者單憑[記錄](concepts.md#c06)讀不出[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06)的值,只能統計[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)的[記錄](concepts.md#c06);它能不能做到,對應[門檻](concepts.md#c03);做完會變成什麼樣,對應[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)外界之後外界的回應、時窗終點的[記錄](concepts.md#c06),依[判準退場](../paper_96f10d75_23d0_441f_94c7_ab87ca28d284/concepts.md#c09)所記的存續,以及依另訂的事件判準所記的生殖(生殖不屬上游「[解](../paper_96f10d75_23d0_441f_94c7_ab87ca28d284/concepts.md#c05)」的維度)。三問各自問不同的事:要什麼推不出能不能做到,能做到推不出會做,做了推不出結果是所要的。\n- Definition: Three questions about an [individual](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c20); the [individual](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c20) here is a biological human, a [Self](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19) in the upstream sense: one who can report on itself and can make a [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) of itself. For such an [individual](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c20), the only questions at the individual level are these three: what it wants, which corresponds to [weight](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06) and [output tendency](concepts.md#c02) (the researcher cannot read off the value of the [weights](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06) from the [records](concepts.md#c06) alone and can only work statistically with [records](concepts.md#c06) of [outputs](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)); whether it can do it, which corresponds to the [threshold](concepts.md#c03); and what it becomes after doing it, which corresponds to the environment's response after an [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) [arrives](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10), the [record](concepts.md#c06) at the end of the time window, and survival as recorded under a [criterion exit](../paper_96f10d75_23d0_441f_94c7_ab87ca28d284/concepts.md#c09) standard, and reproduction as recorded under a separately specified event criterion (reproduction is not a dimension of the upstream [solution](../paper_96f10d75_23d0_441f_94c7_ab87ca28d284/concepts.md#c05)). The three questions ask about different things: what is wanted does not imply whether it can be done, being able does not imply doing it, and having done it does not imply that the result is what was wanted.\n- 裁決:2026-10-27 依稽核意見,定義保留正文對研究對象的限定:個體是生物人,屬上游所稱的我(能自述,也能對自己作分別),避免下游把「只有三問」套到不符合這個限定的個體;限定內容直接寫出,不指涉本篇的前提編號。同日曾一併寫入「同一輪不能同時在兩地、體力與注意力總量有限」,後判定那是關於生物人的經驗前提,不用來界定對象,「只有三問」也不依賴它,故刪去,與正文〇一致。\n\n\n## public 輸出傾向 / Output Tendency\n\n- 定義:研究者對[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)的[記錄](concepts.md#c06)中反覆可見的形狀所作的歸納,描述一個[個體](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c20)在指定[切法](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c23)下傾向做出哪一類[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)。它是在指定的[切法](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c23)、時窗、分類規則與[門檻](concepts.md#c03)條件下作的歸納。分類規則是研究者的[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18),所歸的類別不是行為本身自帶的界線。輸出傾向是[記錄](concepts.md#c06)的形狀,與[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06)的關係只能是估計,不是[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06)的讀數。\n- Definition: A generalization by the researcher of the recurring shape in the [records](concepts.md#c06) of [outputs](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28), describing which kind of [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) an [individual](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c20) tends to produce under a stated [cut](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c23). It is made under a stated [cut](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c23), time window, classification rule, and [threshold](concepts.md#c03) conditions. The classification rule is the researcher's [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18), and the resulting categories are not boundaries that the behavior carries by itself. An [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) tendency is a shape of the [records](concepts.md#c06); its relation to [weight](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06) can only be an estimate and is not a reading of the [weight](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06).\n- 裁決:2026-10-27 判定本概念與上游「印象」不是同一個概念:輸出傾向是記錄的形狀。\n\n\n## public 門檻 / Threshold\n\n- 定義:一條[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)[路徑](concepts.md#c07)成立所需的一組[前件](concepts.md#c08)。[路徑](concepts.md#c07)是研究者在指定[切法](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c23)下劃出的一類[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)序列;[前件](concepts.md#c08)是[路徑](concepts.md#c07)成立所需的各項條件,可以是身體素質、[知識](concepts.md#c13)、時間、位置、外界條件、工具與[資源](../paper_96f10d75_23d0_441f_94c7_ab87ca28d284/concepts.md#c03),記在哪一類由研究者講明(見[狀態變數](../paper_96f10d75_23d0_441f_94c7_ab87ca28d284/concepts.md#c02)、[資源變數](../paper_96f10d75_23d0_441f_94c7_ab87ca28d284/concepts.md#c03))。任一[前件](concepts.md#c08)不具備,該[路徑](concepts.md#c07)在該輪不可行;全部具備只表示可行,不表示會發生。\n- Definition: The set of [antecedents](concepts.md#c08) required for an [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) [path](concepts.md#c07) to hold. A [path](concepts.md#c07) is a class of [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) sequences drawn by the researcher under a stated [cut](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c23); an [antecedent](concepts.md#c08) is any condition the [path](concepts.md#c07) requires, such as bodily qualities, [knowledge](concepts.md#c13), time, position, environmental conditions, tools and [resources](../paper_96f10d75_23d0_441f_94c7_ab87ca28d284/concepts.md#c03), recorded as a [state variable](../paper_96f10d75_23d0_441f_94c7_ab87ca28d284/concepts.md#c02) or a [resource variable](../paper_96f10d75_23d0_441f_94c7_ab87ca28d284/concepts.md#c03), as the researcher states. If any [antecedent](concepts.md#c08) is absent, the [path](concepts.md#c07) is infeasible in that round; if all are present, it is only feasible, not thereby occurring.\n\n\n## public 異途結果同類 / Same Outcome from Different Paths\n\n- 定義:研究者依明示的結果變數、時窗與容許區間,把不同[個體](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c20)各自不同的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)歷程所得的結果,歸入同一類。這是研究者的外部歸類;它不是[趨同](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c37)([趨同](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c37)指[耦合](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c36)之下,指定維度上參與者[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)模式之間的距離縮短)。結果同類不推出[路徑](concepts.md#c07)相同,也不推出內部問題或驅動力相同;它也不提供發生頻率。\n- Definition: A grouping by the researcher, under a stated outcome variable, time window and tolerance interval, of the outcomes that different [individuals](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c20) reached through different [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) histories into the same class. It is an external classification by the researcher; it is not [convergence](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c37) ([convergence](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c37) is a shortening of the distance between participants' [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) patterns on a stated dimension under [coupling](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c36)). Sameness of outcome class does not imply sameness of [path](concepts.md#c07), nor sameness of any internal problem or driving force; nor does it supply any frequency of occurrence.\n- 裁決:2026-10-28 依稽核意見(跨-11),定義補上「不提供發生頻率」,與正文規則七對齊:結果同類只是把結果歸入同一類,不是計數。\n\n\n## public 機會成本 / Opportunity Cost\n\n- 定義:研究者在自己指定的估值下,對同一輪中已走[路徑](concepts.md#c07)的終點與被排除[路徑](concepts.md#c07)的預期終點所作的比較。被排除[路徑](concepts.md#c07)限於與已走[路徑](concepts.md#c07)互相排斥、且[門檻](concepts.md#c03)具備者;它們沒有發生,其終點只能是依某個依據作的估計,沒有依據時終點未知。機會成本是研究者的比較計算,不是[個體](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c20)的量,也不屬於[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06)。\n- Definition: A comparison by the researcher, under a valuation the researcher specifies, between the end point of the [path](concepts.md#c07) taken in a round and the expected end points of the excluded [paths](concepts.md#c07). The excluded [paths](concepts.md#c07) are limited to those that are mutually exclusive with the [path](concepts.md#c07) taken and whose [thresholds](concepts.md#c03) are met; they did not occur, so their end points can only be estimates made on some basis, and are unknown where there is none. Opportunity cost is a comparison computed by the researcher; it is not a quantity of the [individual](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c20) and does not belong to the [weight](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06).\n\n\n## public 記錄 / Record\n\n- 定義:研究者在講明的[切法](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c23)下,依自己的需要選取、對已發生之事所作的登記;記什麼由研究者的登記動作決定,不預先列舉內容。常見的有時窗內實際發生的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)、起點與終點的[狀態變數](../paper_96f10d75_23d0_441f_94c7_ab87ca28d284/concepts.md#c02)、[資源變數](../paper_96f10d75_23d0_441f_94c7_ab87ca28d284/concepts.md#c03),以及[判準退場](../paper_96f10d75_23d0_441f_94c7_ab87ca28d284/concepts.md#c09)是否發生;所記的內容可以包括發生了什麼、何時、何地、幾次、間隔多久。只登記已發生的事;沒登記的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)仍在[歷史](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13)裡,可能繼續影響[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06)。自述登記為一筆[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28),與其他[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)同地位。[路徑](concepts.md#c07)的[門檻](concepts.md#c03)是研究者的判斷,可標「未知」,與[記錄](concepts.md#c06)並列附上,不算[記錄](concepts.md#c06)。\n- Definition: A registration, made by the researcher under a stated [cut](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c23) and selected according to the researcher's own need, of what has happened; what is registered is fixed by the researcher's act of registering and is not listed in advance. Commonly it includes the [outputs](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) that actually occurred in the time window, the start-point and end-point [state](../paper_96f10d75_23d0_441f_94c7_ab87ca28d284/concepts.md#c02) variables and [resource](../paper_96f10d75_23d0_441f_94c7_ab87ca28d284/concepts.md#c03) variables, and whether [criterion exit](../paper_96f10d75_23d0_441f_94c7_ab87ca28d284/concepts.md#c09) occurred; what is registered may include what happened, when, where, how many times, and at what intervals. Only events that have occurred are registered; unregistered [outputs](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) remain in the [history](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13) and may continue to affect the [weight](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06). A self-report is registered as one [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28), with the same standing as any other [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28). The [threshold](concepts.md#c03) of a [path](concepts.md#c07) is the researcher's judgment, may be marked unknown, and is attached alongside the [records](concepts.md#c06) but is not itself a record.\n- 裁決:2026-10-27 判定本概念與暗宇宙篇的「記錄」(信的組成單位)是不同的概念:本篇的記錄由研究者的登記動作定義(依切法選取已發生之事),不預先列舉內容;門檻是研究者的判斷,與記錄並列,不算記錄。\n\n\n## public 路徑 / Path\n\n- 定義:研究者在指定[切法](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c23)下劃出的一類[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)序列。怎麼劃是研究者的判定;路徑不是[個體](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c20)自己帶著的邊界。一條路徑在某一輪是否可行,看它的[門檻](concepts.md#c03)。\n- Definition: A class of [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) sequences drawn by the researcher under a stated [cut](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c23). How it is drawn is the researcher's determination; a path is not a boundary that the [individual](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c20) carries. Whether a path is feasible in a given round is read from its [threshold](concepts.md#c03).\n\n\n## public 前件 / Antecedent\n\n- 定義:一條[路徑](concepts.md#c07)成立所需的各項條件之一,是[門檻](concepts.md#c03)的組成項。可以是身體素質、[知識](concepts.md#c13)、時間、位置、外界條件、工具與[資源](../paper_96f10d75_23d0_441f_94c7_ab87ca28d284/concepts.md#c03);記在[狀態變數](../paper_96f10d75_23d0_441f_94c7_ab87ca28d284/concepts.md#c02)還是[資源變數](../paper_96f10d75_23d0_441f_94c7_ab87ca28d284/concepts.md#c03),由研究者講明,不先分類。\n- Definition: One of the conditions a [path](concepts.md#c07) requires in order to hold, and a component of the [threshold](concepts.md#c03). It may be bodily qualities, [knowledge](concepts.md#c13), time, position, environmental conditions, tools or [resources](../paper_96f10d75_23d0_441f_94c7_ab87ca28d284/concepts.md#c03); whether it is recorded as a [state](../paper_96f10d75_23d0_441f_94c7_ab87ca28d284/concepts.md#c02) variable or a [resource](../paper_96f10d75_23d0_441f_94c7_ab87ca28d284/concepts.md#c03) variable is stated by the researcher and is not classified in advance.\n\n\n## public 個體局部解 / Individual Local Solution\n\n- 定義:指定[個體](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c20)在所屬[推演輪](../paper_96f10d75_23d0_441f_94c7_ab87ca28d284/concepts.md#c07)的下一刻[狀態](../paper_96f10d75_23d0_441f_94c7_ab87ca28d284/concepts.md#c02)、[資源](../paper_96f10d75_23d0_441f_94c7_ab87ca28d284/concepts.md#c03),以及[判準退場](../paper_96f10d75_23d0_441f_94c7_ab87ca28d284/concepts.md#c09)的相關[記錄](concepts.md#c06);若該[個體](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c20)已被列為指定[切法](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c23)的[節點](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25)、這些欄位已記入該輪的[解](../paper_96f10d75_23d0_441f_94c7_ab87ca28d284/concepts.md#c05),則是上游[解](../paper_96f10d75_23d0_441f_94c7_ab87ca28d284/concepts.md#c05)的單[節點](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25)部分。\n- Definition: For a specified [individual](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c20), the next-moment [state](../paper_96f10d75_23d0_441f_94c7_ab87ca28d284/concepts.md#c02) and [resources](../paper_96f10d75_23d0_441f_94c7_ab87ca28d284/concepts.md#c03) in the [derivation round](../paper_96f10d75_23d0_441f_94c7_ab87ca28d284/concepts.md#c07) it belongs to, together with the relevant [records](concepts.md#c06) of the [criterion exit](../paper_96f10d75_23d0_441f_94c7_ab87ca28d284/concepts.md#c09); if the [individual](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c20) is listed as a [node](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25) of the stated [cut](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c23) and these fields are entered in that round's [solution](../paper_96f10d75_23d0_441f_94c7_ab87ca28d284/concepts.md#c05), it is the single-[node](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25) part of the upstream [solution](../paper_96f10d75_23d0_441f_94c7_ab87ca28d284/concepts.md#c05).\n\n\n## private 四輪記錄表 / Four-Round Record Table\n\n- 定義:一份合成資料表,列出甲、乙、丙、己四人各自在第一輪的處境、[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)對外界的改變,以及第二輪起[門檻](concepts.md#c03)是否具備的變化。人物與數值皆為合成設定,非實測;它是校準用的示例,不作推導來源,也不構成經驗支持。\n- Definition: A synthetic data table that lists, for four persons (A, B, C and F), each person's situation in the first round, the changes that the [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) makes to the outside world, and the change from the second round on in whether the [threshold](concepts.md#c03) is met. The persons and figures are synthetic settings, not measurements; the table is an example for calibration, not a source of derivation and not empirical support.\n\n\n## public 可行集合 / Feasible Set\n\n- 定義:某一輪中,[門檻](concepts.md#c03)的各項[前件](concepts.md#c08)都具備的[路徑](concepts.md#c07)所成的集合。它回答的是物理上能不能,不回答會不會發生;[前件](concepts.md#c08)隨[歷史](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13)可能變動,所以每一輪的可行集合可能擴大、縮小或不變。\n- Definition: In a given round, the set of [paths](concepts.md#c07) whose [thresholds](concepts.md#c03) have all of their [antecedents](concepts.md#c08) met. It answers whether something is physically possible, not whether it will occur; because [antecedents](concepts.md#c08) may change with [history](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13), the feasible set of each round may grow, shrink or stay the same.\n\n\n## private 五條路徑門檻表 / Five-Path Threshold Table\n\n- 定義:一份合成資料表,列出受雇工作、擺攤販售、自行種植販售、出售既有物品、搶劫五條[路徑](concepts.md#c07)各自的[門檻](concepts.md#c03)([前件](concepts.md#c08)清單)與證據地位。[路徑](concepts.md#c07)與[前件](concepts.md#c08)皆為合成設定,非實測;它是校準用的示例,不作推導來源,也不構成經驗支持。\n- Definition: A synthetic data table that lists, for five [paths](concepts.md#c07) (employment, setting up a stall, growing and selling, selling existing goods, and robbery), each path's [threshold](concepts.md#c03) (the list of [antecedents](concepts.md#c08)) and the standing of the evidence. The [paths](concepts.md#c07) and [antecedents](concepts.md#c08) are synthetic settings, not measurements; the table is an example for calibration, not a source of derivation and not empirical support.\n\n\n## public 知識 / Knowledge\n\n- 定義:某條[路徑](concepts.md#c07)的[門檻](concepts.md#c03)中,無法直接檢查的[前件](concepts.md#c08),隨[路徑](concepts.md#c07)而定(有廚師的知識,不推出有醫學的知識)。只能由該[路徑](concepts.md#c07)上的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)推測,記為「由[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)推測」或「未知」,不預設具備。身體與外部條件有可直接[記錄](concepts.md#c06)的物理改變,可直接檢查,不在此列。\n- Definition: Among the [antecedents](concepts.md#c08) in the [threshold](concepts.md#c03) of a [path](concepts.md#c07), those that cannot be checked directly; it varies with the [path](concepts.md#c07) (having a cook's knowledge does not imply having medical knowledge). It can only be inferred from the [outputs](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) on that [path](concepts.md#c07), is recorded as \"inferred from [outputs](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)\" or \"unknown\", and is not assumed to be met. Bodily and external conditions involve physical changes that can be directly [recorded](concepts.md#c06) and checked directly, and are not included.\n- 裁決:2026-10-27 判定「知識」登記為本篇概念:它有本篇專屬的操作性定義與證據標法,不同於日常說的知識;原列「不登記」,依稽核意見改為登記。\n\n\n## public 現存樣本條件化 / Conditioning on Existing Samples\n\n- 定義:研究者以「存續」(尚未發生[判準退場](../paper_96f10d75_23d0_441f_94c7_ab87ca28d284/concepts.md#c09))為條件選樣的做法:樣本裡只有尚未[判準退場](../paper_96f10d75_23d0_441f_94c7_ab87ca28d284/concepts.md#c09)的[個體](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c20)。[判準退場](../paper_96f10d75_23d0_441f_94c7_ab87ca28d284/concepts.md#c09)只取決於研究者所訂判準與實際事件,與[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)的好壞無必然關係,所以存續者的表現不足以直接用來評價好壞;已[判準退場](../paper_96f10d75_23d0_441f_94c7_ab87ca28d284/concepts.md#c09)者留下的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28),凡已[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)別人或留在[信號容器](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c26)中者,仍在[歷史](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13)裡,沒[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)任何人者研究者可能拿不到,所以推不出消失者不可研究。這是研究者的樣本邊界,不是外界有選擇目的。\n- Definition: The researcher's practice of selecting a sample conditioned on survival (not yet having undergone [criterion exit](../paper_96f10d75_23d0_441f_94c7_ab87ca28d284/concepts.md#c09)): the sample contains only [individuals](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c20) that have not yet undergone [criterion exit](../paper_96f10d75_23d0_441f_94c7_ab87ca28d284/concepts.md#c09). Whether [criterion exit](../paper_96f10d75_23d0_441f_94c7_ab87ca28d284/concepts.md#c09) occurs depends only on the criterion the researcher sets and on actual events, and has no necessary relation to whether the [outputs](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) are good or bad, so the performance of survivors is not enough to be used directly for evaluation; the [outputs](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) left by those who have undergone [criterion exit](../paper_96f10d75_23d0_441f_94c7_ab87ca28d284/concepts.md#c09), wherever they have already [arrived](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at others or remain in a [signal container](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c26), are still in the [history](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13), while those that [arrived](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at no one may be unobtainable by the researcher; so it does not follow that those who have disappeared cannot be studied. This is the researcher's sample boundary, not a purpose of selection on the part of the outside world.\n- 裁決:2026-10-27 判定「現存樣本條件化」登記為本篇概念:它是第四章 4.4 的獨立小節,有明確的選樣方式與推論限制;原列「不登記」,依稽核意見改為登記。\n\n\n## public 子代 / Offspring\n\n- 定義:某個[個體](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c20)的生殖事件所產生的、新[進場](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c44)的[節點](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25)。\n- Definition: A [node](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25) at its [entry](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c44), produced by a reproduction event of an [individual](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c20).\n- 裁決:2026-10-27 判定「子代」登記為本篇概念:正文與前提十一賦予它「新進場的節點」的模型地位;原未登記,依稽核意見改為登記。其前史與親代重疊、不推出繼承親代的權重或輸出,另見前提十一與結論八十一,不寫進定義。2026-10-27 定義末句原寫「子代的存活與再生殖不在本篇處理」,是本篇的範圍限制,不是概念內容,依稽核意見刪去;範圍由正文 4.2 邊界與形式化附註表達。\n\n## 不登記\n\n- 終點:2026-10-28 指時窗最後一輪後的那一次記錄,起點同;被排除路徑的「預期終點」是研究者對它的估計。這是記錄的一種用法,記錄的定義已列入起點與終點,不單獨定義。\n- 回饋:2026-10-27 指輸出到達外界後的回應若進入歷史、使下一輪各路徑的門檻是否具備或權重改變的過程,一般用語,兩條回饋的內容已由門檻、權重、歷史的定義表達,不單獨定義。\n- 被排除的集合:2026-10-27 即機會成本定義中被排除的路徑所成的集合,不單獨定義。\n- 路徑排除:2026-10-26 規則一的標題用語,是門檻不具備時的結論,不單獨定義。\n- 結論分級(約束級、條件級、研究問題)與記帳約定:2026-10-26 本篇結論的局部標籤,不供下游引用;2026-10-27 記帳約定是本篇的記法,不列入結論分級。\n- 存續:2026-10-26 以上游「判準退場」為判準的事實檢查,一般用語。\n- 生殖:2026-10-26 一般用語,記為輸出的約定寫在正文,不單獨定義。\n- 生物人:2026-10-27 即上游的「我」(能自述,也能對自己作分別)在本篇的研究對象,本篇的個體限定為此,不另立概念,不增加上游沒有的適用範圍。\n- 風險(含「穩或險」「風險高」):2026-10-27 本篇不單立風險;「風險高」只作研究者的事後描述,即在指定分類與樣本下,同類路徑的結果記錄分散,不歸給任何一次具體的決定,故不單獨定義。\n\n## 待決項\n\n無\n","formalization_md":"論文:《生物人個體輸出傾向動力學》\nUUID:81952268-47b1-4d8c-9605-270c42646693\n\n## 記號約定\n\n來源:論文全文\n\n- 同一輪:一般用語,不是概念「同一」\n- 同一類:一般用語,不是概念「同一」\n- 同一次:一般用語,不是概念「同一」\n- 同一件事:一般用語,不是概念「同一」\n- 同一生殖事件:一般用語,不是概念「同一」\n- 解釋:一般用語,不是概念「解」\n- 同一個:一般用語,不是概念「同一」\n- 同一句:一般用語,不是概念「同一」\n- 同一點:一般用語,不是概念「同一」\n- 同一筆:一般用語,不是概念「同一」\n- 同一問題:一般用語,不是概念「同一」\n- 同一用語:一般用語,不是概念「同一」\n- 解讀:一般用語,不是概念「解」\n- 分別固定:一般用語(各自),不是概念「分別」\n- 出現之後:一般用語,不是概念「出現」\n- 交出現金:一般用語(交出、現金),不是概念「出現」\n- 暗宇宙篇:論文名稱的簡稱,不是概念「宇宙」\n\n## 前置條件\n\n來源:論文第一節【正文:句0678758140】\n\n- 前提一:研究者指定 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.個體 的邊界、時窗、輪長與 記錄 的維度,本篇並寫出是誰作這個劃分。【正文:句5399033640】\n- 前提二 [限定條件]:把某項 記錄 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別 在 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.個體 上,記為 96f10d75-23d0-441f-94c7-ab87ca28d284.狀態變數;37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別 在外界上,記為 96f10d75-23d0-441f-94c7-ab87ca28d284.資源變數;這是研究者的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別,沒有絕對定義。【正文:句9224074366、句9685263811】\n- 前提三:一條 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 路徑 成立所需的每一項 前件,都屬於該 路徑 的 門檻;路徑 是研究者劃出的一類 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 序列;前件 記在哪一欄是研究者的判定,不先分類。【正文:句3194000135、句2280782574】\n- 前提四:記錄 是研究者依 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.切法(前提一)對已發生之事所作的登記,記什麼由研究者依需要選取,不預先列舉;起點與終點之差只是兩次 記錄 的差,不稱代價或損耗;某 路徑 的 門檻 是研究者就該 路徑 所作的判斷,可標「未知」,隨 記錄 一併附上,不算 記錄。【正文:句5168140240、句2677343792、句6878237136】\n- 前提五:生物人在同一輪不能同時在兩地,體力與注意力總量有限,所以某些 路徑 互相排斥;這不由四律推出。【正文:句9474649044、句4197935997】\n\n- 前提六:在本篇 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.切法 下,生殖事件記為該 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.個體 的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出;這是記帳約定,不是本體定位。【正文:句8468911708、句6293556922】\n- 前提七 [限定條件]:換成以配偶雙方為單位的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.切法,同一生殖事件可記成兩方 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 的共同 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達,兩種記法不矛盾。【正文:句2401199278】\n- 前提八:b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 可以創造後一輪的 前件(借書得 知識),一條 路徑 的 前件 可以是另一條 路徑 的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出;有些 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 可能關閉某些 路徑,是永久或暫時依具體情形與資料而定;這依經驗與具體資料,不由四律推出。【正文:句4620525322、句7495916185】\n- 前提九 [限定條件]:生殖 記錄 欄位為:時間(含當時年齡)、地理(事件位置、雙方位置)、對方(是誰、當時是否同住;「配偶」記下是誰作的歸屬)、結果(子代 是否出生、之後與當事人有無 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達)、起點、終點;當輪的 門檻 另附,不算 記錄 欄位。【正文:句7018784733】\n- 前提十:本篇的當事人是生物人,屬上游所稱的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.我:能自述,也能對自己作 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別。【正文:句2738887857】\n- 前提十一:子代 是新 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.進場 的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.節點,其前史與親代重疊。【正文:句6271308259】\n- 前提十二 [限定條件]:外界若是 2ccbf179-58cf-4851-bd72-5fa886e4b2c3.自然環境,其回應屬本篇;外界若含他人,其回應(交出現金、反抗、報復)若實際 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 本 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.節點,才記為 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 本 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.節點 的他人 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出;雇主有沒有是外部狀態,不是一次 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出;本篇對他人回應只記為外部條件的變化,不分析原因。【正文:句4020731121、句0252641670、句6182984061】\n- 前提十三:本篇所取的 96f10d75-23d0-441f-94c7-ab87ca28d284.退場判準 只看實際事件的有無與時點,不含原因條件;研究者若另訂含原因的判準,不在本篇處理。【正文:句5341768629】\n- 前提十四 [限定條件]:日常說的「風險高」,本篇只作研究者的事後描述:在指定分類與樣本下,同類 路徑 的結果 記錄 分散;這個描述不歸給任何一次具體的 fb0addca-42b6-4884-aa18-438c695747ab.決定。【正文:句3786875288、句6878406950】\n- 前提十五:身體與外部條件有可直接 記錄 的物理改變,可直接檢查;對 知識,本篇只由該 路徑 上的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 推測,記為「由 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 推測」或「未知」,不預設具備(記帳約定)。【正文:句3399908261、句5089798095】\n- 前提十六 [限定條件]:本篇不把「成本」當作 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.個體 的量:什麼算付出,本身是研究者的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別;機會成本 的比較計算另見步驟九之二、結論九之三。【正文:句4192581136、句4619636033】\n- 前提十七 [限定條件]:96f10d75-23d0-441f-94c7-ab87ca28d284.判準退場 是否可逆隨所訂判準而定(例如判準取離職,可能可逆;判準取生理界線,可能不可逆),所以只記有無與時點,作為記帳約定,不預先當成永久終點。【正文:句0560394396】\n- 前提十八 [限定條件]:依賴器材、被他人照顧、身體如何等資料,若有登記,記在 門檻 與各輪 記錄 裡,沒有登記的標「未知」;這是本篇的記帳方式。【正文:句5193684956、句9854278313】\n- 前提十九 [限定條件]:各 路徑 的 前件 是否具備,是研究者依指定資料所作的判定;本篇寫出依據,依據不足者記為「未知」。【正文:句5609017350】\n- 前提二十 [限定條件]:投入(付出了什麼)不在 個體局部解 的欄位裡,也不由 96f10d75-23d0-441f-94c7-ab87ca28d284.解 自動得出:什麼算付出,是研究者的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別。【正文:句8769779748、句3398245490】\n- 前提二十一:研究者可依某類 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 在指定的樣本與條件下反覆發生,作「這類 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.權重 較重」的估計。【正文:句2807258956】\n- 前提二十三:從外部無法確認當事人是否被 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.鎖死;本篇假定所討論的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.時刻,當事人不被 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.鎖死。【正文:句0045355114】\n- 前提二十四:存續讀 96f10d75-23d0-441f-94c7-ab87ca28d284.判準退場 這個維度,生殖依另訂的事件判準判定,兩個判定各有判準與 記錄,本篇不由一個推另一個。【正文:句4147360640、句3538800439、句3037569522】\n- 前提二十五:研究者與旁人也是生物人,同樣屬上游所稱的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.我。【正文:句0328902953】\n\n[作者裁決] 2026-10-27 生殖事件記為 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出,是本篇的記帳約定,正文沒有論證它由前提一推出;改列前提六,不再作為推導。生殖 記錄 欄位是正文聲明、不參與推導,列為限定條件。\n\n[作者裁決] 2026-10-27 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 創造 前件、可能關閉 路徑,37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.流變律 只說 前件 隨 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.歷史 變動,不保證 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 創造 前件,也不由 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.不可復原律 推出 路徑 關閉;原結論五之四、五之五沒有來源律,改列前提八;b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 創造 前件 的部分另立結論五之四,來源引前提八,使前提八進入推導鏈、失效時可追蹤。\n\n[作者裁決] 2026-10-27 前提七是正文聲明的記法(換 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.切法 時生殖事件的兩種記法不矛盾),不參與推導,列為限定條件;前提三對應論文附錄推導一所列的依賴(前提三 + 前提四),實際參與推導,列為一般前提;概念的定義在概念表,這裡不重述。\n\n[作者裁決] 2026-10-27 正文第三條前提說明 門檻 是什麼,附錄推導一也列它為依賴,所以結論一的來源為前提三、門檻 的定義與前提四;原第五條前提(已發生的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 只增不減)由 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.不可復原律 直接得出,併入承接,不再列為前提;原第六條前提改編號為前提五。\n\n[作者裁決] 2026-10-27 前提十對應論文〇「定位與假定」,前提十一對應論文 4.2 子代 那一句,兩者都不是論文第一章編號的前提;因為實際參與推導(37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.損耗律、fb0addca-42b6-4884-aa18-438c695747ab.來路牆、fb0addca-42b6-4884-aa18-438c695747ab.未定牆 適用的對象是 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.我;子代 不繼承親代的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.權重 或 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出),所以列為一般前提,不列為限定條件。本篇的當事人是生物人,屬上游所稱的「37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.我」:能自述、能對自己作 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別,上游的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.損耗律、fb0addca-42b6-4884-aa18-438c695747ab.來路牆,以及不被 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.鎖死 時的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.黑箱律,對他適用;正文〇已寫明本篇的對象屬上游所稱的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.我,並列為前提十。\n\n[作者裁決] 2026-10-27 前提十一照正文原句只寫「子代 是新 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.進場 的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.節點,其前史與親代重疊」,去掉原先多寫的「由研究者在指定 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.切法 下認定」;「不推出繼承親代的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.權重 或 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出」由結論八十一表達。子代 登記為概念(概念表)。步驟四十三補上「在不被 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.鎖死 的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.時刻」,因為 fb0addca-42b6-4884-aa18-438c695747ab.被迫的賭注 只在不被 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.鎖死 時成立,論文同一句同步補上。結論分級的約束級說明補列前提六、十、十一、十三(實際參與約束級結論的本篇聲明),論文第五章與英文同步寫明;其餘前提只參與條件級結論或僅為限定條件。\n\n[作者裁決] 2026-10-27 原例四十七的內容是本篇的研究範圍與記帳規則(2ccbf179-58cf-4851-bd72-5fa886e4b2c3.自然環境 的回應屬本篇、他人的回應只記為外部條件的變化、雇主有沒有是外部狀態而不是一次 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出),不是展示用的具體模型,也不是由上游定義推出的結論,所以改列前提十二,作為限定條件,不參與推導。\n\n[作者裁決] 2026-10-27 結論十一之一只寫本篇對上游 fb0addca-42b6-4884-aa18-438c695747ab.被迫的賭注 的適用範圍(37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦 在不被 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.鎖死 的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.時刻,那一 fb0addca-42b6-4884-aa18-438c695747ab.回合 就是一個 fb0addca-42b6-4884-aa18-438c695747ab.決定;37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.鎖死 時不在此列),不重述上游定義中事先算不準、事後收不回、「不動」也是落出之一的內容,正文同一點的後半句不另列結論;它仍是後續結論十一之二、十一之三、二十五、二十六等的共同來源,不當作新的定義。2026-10-28 依稽核意見(跨-26)再改:剩下的適用範圍仍是重述上游 fb0addca-42b6-4884-aa18-438c695747ab.被迫的賭注 與 fb0addca-42b6-4884-aa18-438c695747ab.決定 的定義,結論十一之一整條刪去;原引用它的結論十一之二、步驟四十三改為直接引用 fb0addca-42b6-4884-aa18-438c695747ab.被迫的賭注 與 fb0addca-42b6-4884-aa18-438c695747ab.決定 的定義。論文規則八保留,論文可引述上游。\n\n[作者裁決] 2026-10-27 本篇原稱「不 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出」,視為上游 fb0addca-42b6-4884-aa18-438c695747ab.被迫的賭注 所說的「不動」。2026-10-28 依稽核意見(形-35)改:上游只說「不動」也是 fb0addca-42b6-4884-aa18-438c695747ab.回合 落出的結果之一,沒有建立「不動」等於「不 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出」;本篇改用上游的說法「不動」,不再寫「不 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出」。規則八、3.3 讀法、附錄推導十一、結論十一之一、步驟四十三同步,中英文一致。同日:步驟四十三原寫「沒嘗試也是這一輪落出的結果之一」,把研究者劃的一輪當成一個 fb0addca-42b6-4884-aa18-438c695747ab.回合;改為這一輪裡不被 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.鎖死 的每一個 fb0addca-42b6-4884-aa18-438c695747ab.回合 都落出了結果,只是其中沒有嘗試,來源補 fb0addca-42b6-4884-aa18-438c695747ab.回合 的定義。結論二十六原寫以結果為判準時的對錯「不是由結果推出」,判準指定後結果可以得出該判準下的對錯,改為「是結果在他所選判準下的歸類」。\n\n[作者裁決] 2026-10-27 記錄 是本篇自己的概念,與暗宇宙篇的同名概念不是同一個:本篇的 記錄 由研究者的登記動作定義,是研究者在指定 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.切法 下依需要選取、對已發生之事所作的登記,不預先列舉內容(常見的有時窗內實際 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出、起點與終點的 96f10d75-23d0-441f-94c7-ab87ca28d284.狀態變數 與 96f10d75-23d0-441f-94c7-ab87ca28d284.資源變數、96f10d75-23d0-441f-94c7-ab87ca28d284.判準退場 是否發生);門檻 是研究者的判斷,可標「未知」,與 記錄 並列,不算 記錄。暗宇宙篇的同名概念指涉的對象不同,定義見該篇的概念表,這裡不重述。\n\n[作者裁決] 2026-10-27 前提四原寫「研究者能 記錄 的只有三樣」,改為不列舉:研究者要記什麼本身不可預先窮舉,所以 記錄 以登記動作定義;門檻 另附,不算 記錄 欄位,前提九的欄位同步調整。\n\n[作者裁決] 2026-10-27 論文 2.1 列舉 記錄 的常見內容時漏了「96f10d75-23d0-441f-94c7-ab87ca28d284.判準退場 是否發生」,與概念表 記錄 的定義及前面關於 記錄 的裁決不一致;論文 2.1 與英文同步補上,形式化陳述不變。\n\n[作者裁決] 2026-10-27 前提二是正文聲明的範圍設定,原本只被結論六十七與結論七十引用;兩處依稽核意見刪改後,前提二不再參與推導,列為限定條件,內容不變。不刪除:論文聲明的前置條件須全部列出,而前提二在正文仍是「本篇不採用的寫法」(不替任何條件預設它屬 96f10d75-23d0-441f-94c7-ab87ca28d284.狀態變數 或 96f10d75-23d0-441f-94c7-ab87ca28d284.資源變數)與 3.2「前件 不先分類」的根據;論文不改。\n\n## 承接的律與結論(對應第一章 承接)\n\n來源:論文第一節【正文:句0678758140】\n\n附註:37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.流變律、37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.黑箱律、37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.損耗律、37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.不可復原律 與 ae79e938-76e1-4bf9-b2ab-995c03e16c9e.驅動力不可確認 沿用上游,不重證;37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.不可復原律 在本篇的直接用法是:已發生的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 進入 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.歷史,只增不減。【正文:句0241507695、句3321390838】\n\n附註:fb0addca-42b6-4884-aa18-438c695747ab.被迫的賭注、fb0addca-42b6-4884-aa18-438c695747ab.未定牆、fb0addca-42b6-4884-aa18-438c695747ab.來路牆 以及 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.退場 與 fb0addca-42b6-4884-aa18-438c695747ab.死亡 之分,沿用上游,不重證。【正文:句4879486000】\n\n## 規則與附錄推導(對應第一章 本篇推出的規則;附錄)\n\n來源:論文第一章及附錄【正文:句0678758140、句6183552036、句6720345126】\n\n- 結論一:蘊含(某 路徑 的 門檻 中任一 前件 不具備, 該 路徑 在該輪不可行);前件 全部具備只表示可行(從 前提三 + 門檻 的定義 + 前提四 推出)【正文:句6455266005、句9903519868】\n- 結論二之一:前件 可能隨 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.歷史 變動,這一輪具備,並不蘊含下一輪仍具備(從 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.流變律 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.歷史 的定義 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 的定義 + 可行集合 的定義 推出)【正文:句2861018819】\n\n[作者裁決] 2026-10-27 前件 變動只靠 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.流變律:37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.歷史 只往後追加,37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.個體 自己的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 也可能改變外界,與 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.損耗律 無關。\n\n- 結論二:前件 全部具備,不蘊含該 路徑 會發生(從 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.黑箱律 + 門檻 的定義 + 前提二十三 推出)【正文:句6455266005、句9903519868】\n- 結論三之一:並非 蘊含(某 路徑 的 輸出傾向 高, 該 路徑 的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 下一次發生)(從 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.黑箱律 + 輸出傾向 的定義 + 前提二十三 推出)【正文:句1810844988、句4553980342、句9903519868】\n- 結論三之二:並非 蘊含(輸出傾向 穩定, 內部有驅動力);輸出傾向 是 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 記錄 的形狀,不是對內部的讀數(從 ae79e938-76e1-4bf9-b2ab-995c03e16c9e.驅動力不可確認 + 輸出傾向 的定義 + 前提二十三 推出)【正文:句7514466236、句9903519868】\n- 結論三之三:在不被 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.鎖死 的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.時刻,並非 蘊含(某筆 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 發生了, 推出該筆 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 當時的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.權重);也不能確認內部的驅動力(從 fb0addca-42b6-4884-aa18-438c695747ab.決定 的定義 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.黑箱律 + ae79e938-76e1-4bf9-b2ab-995c03e16c9e.驅動力不可確認 推出)【正文:句1810844988、句3249798187】\n- 結論四之一:自述是一筆 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出,有損,與其他 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 同地位,不能當作內部的完整讀數(從 前提十 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.損耗律 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.黑箱律 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別 的定義 + 記錄 的定義 + b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 的定義 + 前提二十三 推出)【正文:句6885540786、句3272948343、句6629178957、句9903519868】\n\n[作者裁決] 2026-10-27 依稽核意見(形-35),結論四之一原未說明自述為何是一筆 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出。依 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 的定義,自述的內容是當事人對自己作的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別(前提十),它落出時就是一筆 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出;來源補上 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 的定義。論文規則三補上這一句、附錄推導四補上 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 的定義,中英文同步。\n- 結論四之二:在不被 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.鎖死 的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.時刻,若一筆 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 的內容是 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別,它只是一次 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別 的落點,不是那一刻內部的完整讀數;所以並非 蘊含(某筆 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 發生了且其內容是 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別, 還原該筆 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 的內部成因);只說單憑這筆 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 推不出內部成因,不說別無途徑(從 前提十 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.損耗律 + ae79e938-76e1-4bf9-b2ab-995c03e16c9e.驅動力不可確認 + b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 的定義 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別 的定義 推出)【正文:句3249798187、句9903519868】\n- 結論五之一:b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 若 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 外界,外界若有回應,回應凡是一次 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.寫入 或 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.坍塌 的結果,就進入 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.歷史;沒有 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 某個 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.個體 者,不在 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 該 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.個體 的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.歷史 裡(從 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.流變律 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.不可復原律 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 的定義 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.歷史 的定義 推出)【正文:句8697255360、句9903519868】\n- 結論五之三:前件 可能隨 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.歷史 變動(結論二之一),外界的回應若 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 該 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.個體 而進了他的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.歷史,下一輪各 路徑 的 門檻 是否具備可能跟著變,可行集合 也就可能跟著變;37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.歷史 參與下一輪 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.權重 的分配,所以可能使之後的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 記錄 改變,但在有限的 記錄 中不保證看得出來,也不由 記錄 的變化讀出 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.權重 的值;可行集合 與 輸出傾向 可能隨輪次變動,不保證定常,也不保證是 2ccbf179-58cf-4851-bd72-5fa886e4b2c3.學習 或改善;兩條回饋是兩件不同的事(從 結論二之一 + 結論五之一 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.黑箱律 + 門檻 的定義 + 可行集合 的定義 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 的定義 + 2ccbf179-58cf-4851-bd72-5fa886e4b2c3.學習 的定義 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦 的定義 + 前提十 + 輸出傾向 的定義 + 前提二十三 推出)【正文:句5515451488、句8995249122、句9903519868】\n- 結論五之四:b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 可能創造後一輪的 前件,一條 路徑 的 前件 可以是另一條 路徑 的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出,所以一條 路徑 在後一輪的可行性,可能依賴前一輪另一條 路徑 的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出;有些 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 可能關閉某些 路徑,是永久或暫時依具體情形與資料而定(從 前提八 + 結論二之一 推出)【正文:句4620525322、句7495916185】\n\n[作者裁決] 2026-10-27 門檻 是否具備的變動由「前件 可能隨 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.歷史 變動」接上,外界回應進了 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.歷史,下一輪各 路徑 的 門檻 是否具備跟著變,不另設機制。\n\n- 結論六:終點差異推不出起點選擇差異:早期回應不同,可能使 可行集合 分岔(從 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.不可復原律 + 結論五之三 推出)【正文:句2303842473、句9903519868】\n- 結論七之一:已發生的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 只增不減;某一輪沒有事件,不取消既有事件(從 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.不可復原律 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.歷史 的定義 + b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 的定義 推出)【正文:句3321390838、句9251723339、句0191088631、句6287863057、句9903519868】\n\n- 結論七之三:生殖事件是 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.個體 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.歷史 中已發生的事件序列,只增不減(從 結論七之一 + 前提六 推出)【正文:句8803615745、句9251723339、句7569820298】\n[作者裁決] 2026-10-27 例三十一原有一句,說沒有 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出、沒有 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 或沒有回應的輪次只重新檢查 門檻,本例效準沒有建立這條規則,也可能漏掉仍須考慮的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.歷史 與 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.權重 回饋,論文第三章 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.切法 段與英文同步刪去,不改為本例效準。\n\n[作者裁決] 2026-10-27 結論八原寫「不看原因」而判準由研究者指定,來源不足以支持;改為前提十三(本篇所取的 96f10d75-23d0-441f-94c7-ab87ca28d284.退場判準 只看實際事件有無與時點,不含原因條件),結論八從前提一與前提十三推出;論文第四章與附錄推導八同步寫明。\n\n- 結論八:存續只依研究者所訂、只看實際事件有無與時點的判準判定,不看原因(從 前提一 + 前提十三 + 96f10d75-23d0-441f-94c7-ab87ca28d284.判準退場 的定義 推出)【正文:句5193684956、句5341768629、句9903519868】\n- 結論九之一:並非 蘊含(單條 路徑 可行, 多條 路徑 可同時執行);多條 路徑 同時考慮時,它們是否互相排斥,不由各條的可行推出(從 前提五 推出)【正文:句2734885110、句2581981315、句9903519868】\n- 步驟九之二:同一輪選了某條 路徑,與它互相排斥且 門檻 具備的 路徑 被排除,被排除的集合可以記下來(從 結論九之一 + 前提五 + 機會成本 的定義 + 門檻 的定義 推出)【正文:句6605807611、句4610666303】\n- 結論九之三:機會成本 是研究者的比較計算,不是 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.個體 的量,不進 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.權重:估值是研究者的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別,被排除的 路徑 沒有發生、終點由研究者估計,而單憑 記錄 讀不出 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.權重 的值;估值換了,比較結果可能不同(從 步驟九之二 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別 的定義 + fb0addca-42b6-4884-aa18-438c695747ab.未定牆 + 機會成本 的定義 + 前提二十五 + 記錄 的定義 推出)【正文:句0335861111、句2287609485、句9903519868】\n\n[作者裁決] 2026-10-27 機會成本 不是 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.個體 的量,理由是估值屬研究者的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別、被排除 路徑 只能估計、37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.權重 讀不到。\n\n- 結論十之一:異途結果同類 是研究者依指定結果變數、時窗與容許區間所作的外部歸類(從 前提一 + 異途結果同類 的定義 推出)【正文:句7725296064、句9903519868】\n- 結論十之二:異途結果同類 並不蘊含 路徑 相同、內部問題相同或有共同驅動力(從 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.黑箱律 + 結論十之一 + 異途結果同類 的定義 + 前提二十三 推出)【正文:句7725296064、句9903519868】\n- 結論十之三:異途結果同類 不是 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.趨同(從 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.趨同 的定義 + 異途結果同類 的定義 推出)【正文:句7725296064、句8069741206】\n\n- 結論十之四:異途結果同類 不提供發生頻率:它只是把已得的結果歸入同一類,不是計數(從 結論十之一 + 異途結果同類 的定義 推出)【正文:句7725296064】\n\n[作者裁決] 2026-10-28 依稽核意見(跨-11),正文規則七列了四項推不出的事,形式化原只表達三項(結論十之一至十之三),漏了「不提供發生頻率」,補為結論十之四。概念表 異途結果同類 的定義、論文第五章約束級第七條與附錄推導十同步補上,中英文一致。同日依論-06,第五章約束級說明的四項聲明補上 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出、b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.進場、b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.節點、96f10d75-23d0-441f-94c7-ab87ca28d284.退場判準 的連結,形式化陳述不變。\n- 結論十一之二:在不被 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.鎖死 時,旁人把單次 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 歸為穩或險,是旁人自己的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別,不是當事人面對的風險讀數:風險高低是看的人對處境作的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別,旁人從當事人那裡拿到的只是當事人的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出(包括自述);當事人怎麼看未來,是他自己作的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別(對他自己的部分,是他的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.自我印象),至多是估計,不是 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.權重 的讀數;依 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.損耗律,他對自己的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別 本來就不完整,自述又有損;旁人對他的判斷,是旁人的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.印象,旁人由此讀不全他的看法;結果好壞是某人判準下的歸類,不是結果本身的性質;同一個 fb0addca-42b6-4884-aa18-438c695747ab.決定 可以落出不同結果,所以單次結果推不出 fb0addca-42b6-4884-aa18-438c695747ab.決定 當時的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.權重,若有人以結果本身評價 fb0addca-42b6-4884-aa18-438c695747ab.決定,那是他選的判準(從 前提十 + fb0addca-42b6-4884-aa18-438c695747ab.被迫的賭注 + 結論四之一 + fb0addca-42b6-4884-aa18-438c695747ab.未定牆 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.損耗律 + b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.自我印象 的定義 + b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.印象 的定義 + fb0addca-42b6-4884-aa18-438c695747ab.來路牆 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.黑箱律 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.不可復原律 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別 的定義 + fb0addca-42b6-4884-aa18-438c695747ab.決定 的定義 + 前提二十五 推出)【正文:句5245094711、句9903519868】\n- 結論十一之三:統計可以描述已發生的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出;拿來說 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.權重 時,只給估計,單憑統計給不出禁止;統計看到的「沒有發生」只是觀察描述,經跨案例校準成必要條件後,才稱 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.經驗禁止,是標明了的禁止,可被新案例修改(從 前提十 + fb0addca-42b6-4884-aa18-438c695747ab.未定牆 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.權重 的定義 + b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 的定義 + b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.經驗禁止 的定義 推出)【正文:句5245094711】\n\n[作者裁決] 2026-10-27 知識 登記為本篇概念:某條 路徑 門檻 中無法直接檢查的 前件,隨 路徑 而定,歸類屬研究者(前提二);對 知識,只由該 路徑 上的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 推測、或標未知,是本篇研究者的記帳約定,論文規則四標為記帳約定,列為前提十五(與前提六同為記帳約定,不由來源推出),例三十三、例七十二改引前提十五與 知識 的定義。「成本」不是 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.個體 的量,是正文〇的方法論限制,列為前提十六 [限定條件],與 機會成本 的比較計算(結論九之二、九之三)分開。\n\n附註:本篇整組不使用慾望、需求、動機、效用、偏好、價值,也不逐詞改寫;依 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.黑箱律,這些詞預設研究者知道人內在想什麼。【正文:句0565754975、句6655253022】\n\n附註:本篇不採用的寫法:本篇不寫「為了」,因為動機從外部不能確認;不由 輸出傾向 穩定推出內部有驅動力;不使用目標;評斷好壞只用研究者指定的判準,並寫出是誰訂的,因為判準是某人的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別;不把外顯統計當 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.權重 讀數,因為統計只給 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.權重 的估計;不把存續當最優;不替任何條件預設它屬 96f10d75-23d0-441f-94c7-ab87ca28d284.狀態變數 或 96f10d75-23d0-441f-94c7-ab87ca28d284.資源變數;不把終點差異反推為起點時的選擇差異;不由 96f10d75-23d0-441f-94c7-ab87ca28d284.資源變數 增減推出 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 類型。【正文:句5686516682】\n\n[作者裁決] 2026-10-27 框架不使用目標,只有研究者指定的判準;「輸出傾向 不能當目標」一語刪除。\n\n附註:本篇不單立風險為量。【正文:句0757327730】\n\n## 要能果三問(對應第〇章)\n\n來源:論文第〇章【正文:句3972911508】\n\n- 結論十二:要什麼,不蘊含能不能做到;能做到,不蘊含會做;做了,不蘊含結果是所要的(從 前提十 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.黑箱律 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.不可復原律 + 結論一 + 結論三之一 + 要能果三問 的定義 + 前提二十三 推出)【正文:句8329003744、句5392209996、句3746304693、句9903519868】\n\n[作者裁決] 2026-10-27 結論十二的來源原列 fb0addca-42b6-4884-aa18-438c695747ab.未定牆,論文規則九(37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.黑箱律、37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.不可復原律、前提三、規則二)與附錄推導十二都沒有它,論文第七章也只說 fb0addca-42b6-4884-aa18-438c695747ab.未定牆 被推翻時影響規則八、2.5 與五之九,不含規則九;依「不替形式化加論文沒有的條件」刪去,論文不動。前提十依先前裁決保留。\n\n## 第二章的關係與推導(對應第二章)\n\n來源:論文第二章【正文:句3516203033】\n\n- 結論十四:沒有登記的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 仍在 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.歷史 裡,可能繼續影響 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.權重(從 結論五之三 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.歷史 的定義 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.黑箱律 + 記錄 的定義 + 前提二十三 推出)【正文:句4413067407】\n- 結論十五:輸出傾向 與 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.權重 的關係是估計,讀不出 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.權重 的值;所以依前提二十一所作的「37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.權重 較重」只是估計,不保證(從 fb0addca-42b6-4884-aa18-438c695747ab.未定牆 + 輸出傾向 的定義 + 前提二十一 推出)【正文:句2807258956】\n- 結論十六:若進食 路徑 的某項必要 前件(例如糧)不具備而沒進食,是 門檻 不具備,推不出 輸出傾向 低;糧是否為必要 前件,是研究者就該 路徑 所作的判定(從 結論一 + 前提四 + 輸出傾向 的定義 推出)【正文:句0340385583】\n- 結論十七:輸出傾向 所用的類別,包括「吃飯」這樣看似自然的詞,是研究者的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別,不是行為本身自帶的界線(從 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別 的定義 + 輸出傾向 的定義 + 前提二十五 推出)【正文:句4759234612、句7293522245】\n- 結論十八:「輸出傾向 相同」是在研究者所訂的類別下說的,並不蘊含他們做的是同一件事,或對它有相同的想法(從 結論十七 + 輸出傾向 的定義 推出)【正文:句9040367946】\n- 結論十九:更換分類規則,共同形狀可以有,也可以消失(從 結論十七 + 輸出傾向 的定義 推出)【正文:句5898564504】\n- 結論二十:輸出傾向 相同不等於 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.趨同;b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.趨同 只有在指定的維度與距離下,才能說距離縮小或不縮小(從 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.趨同 的定義 + 輸出傾向 的定義 推出)【正文:句8069741206、句2138883698】\n- 結論二十二:同樣的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出,今天與明天對該 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.個體 的作用可能不同:37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.歷史 隨 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.時刻 更新,37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.歷史 參與 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.權重 的分配,所以同一筆 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 落在不同的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.歷史 上,作用可能不同(從 結論五之三 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.流變律 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.權重 的定義 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.歷史 的定義 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦 的定義 + b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 的定義 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 的定義 推出)【正文:句2428948597】\n- 結論二十三:37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.歷史 更新後 輸出傾向 可變,但變化不保證是 2ccbf179-58cf-4851-bd72-5fa886e4b2c3.學習,更不保證是改善(從 結論五之三 + 2ccbf179-58cf-4851-bd72-5fa886e4b2c3.學習 的定義 推出)【正文:句1399210606】\n- 結論二十四:研究者的觀察若 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 被觀察的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.個體,就進入他的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.歷史,觀察不是透明的(從 前提十 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 的定義 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.歷史 的定義 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦 的定義 推出)【正文:句5213546361】\n\n附註:輸出傾向 的跨 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.個體、跨時窗比較,是在指定的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.切法、時窗與分類規則下作的;「大部分人類每隔一段時間進食」只是這類經驗描述的一個例子,不能當作已成立的結論,成立與否取決於指定時窗和分類下的 記錄。若採用被觀察 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.個體 自己的詞,本篇寫明採用了誰的分類。【正文:句4482175261、句0548397928、句6330722770】\n\n## 風險問題(對應第二章 2.5)\n\n來源:論文第二章第五小節【正文:句0087641107】\n\n- 結論二十五:並非 蘊含(旁人拿到某人的單次 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出, 旁人能得知該人當時把這個 fb0addca-42b6-4884-aa18-438c695747ab.決定 看作穩或險);風險高低是看的人對處境作的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別,旁人從當事人那裡拿到的只是當事人的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出(包括自述);當事人那一刻怎麼看未來,是他自己作的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別(對他自己的部分,是他的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.自我印象),至多是估計,不是 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.權重 的讀數;依 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.損耗律,他對自己的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別 本來就不完整,自述又有損;旁人對他的判斷,是旁人的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.印象,旁人由此讀不全他的看法;當事人事後的說法也只是一筆 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出;旁人若作估計,那是他的估計(從 前提十 + fb0addca-42b6-4884-aa18-438c695747ab.被迫的賭注 + fb0addca-42b6-4884-aa18-438c695747ab.未定牆 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.黑箱律 + 結論四之一 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.損耗律 + b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.自我印象 的定義 + b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.印象 的定義 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別 的定義 + 前提二十三 + 前提二十五 推出)【正文:句5245094711、句3253532917、句4412061804、句1471676506、句7134670008、句9962532366】\n- 結論二十六:並非 蘊含(單次事後結果為好或壞, 當時那個 fb0addca-42b6-4884-aa18-438c695747ab.決定 是對或錯);結果好壞是某人判準下的歸類,不是結果本身的性質;同一個 fb0addca-42b6-4884-aa18-438c695747ab.決定 可以落出不同結果,單次結果只是一次落出,推不出 fb0addca-42b6-4884-aa18-438c695747ab.決定 當時的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.權重;若有人以結果本身作為評價 fb0addca-42b6-4884-aa18-438c695747ab.決定 的判準,那時的對錯,是結果在他所選判準下的歸類(從 fb0addca-42b6-4884-aa18-438c695747ab.被迫的賭注 + fb0addca-42b6-4884-aa18-438c695747ab.決定 的定義 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.黑箱律 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別 的定義 + 前提二十三 推出)【正文:句1993220170、句7128835068】\n\n[作者裁決] 2026-10-27 依稽核意見(形-35),結論十一之二與結論二十六原寫「不能單憑單次結果判定 fb0addca-42b6-4884-aa18-438c695747ab.決定 的好壞(品質)」,等於排除了以結果本身為判準的評價,所列來源沒有建立這一點。改為上游撐得住的範圍:依 fb0addca-42b6-4884-aa18-438c695747ab.決定 的定義與 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.黑箱律,同一個 fb0addca-42b6-4884-aa18-438c695747ab.決定 可以落出不同結果,單次結果推不出 fb0addca-42b6-4884-aa18-438c695747ab.決定 當時的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.權重;以結果本身評價 fb0addca-42b6-4884-aa18-438c695747ab.決定,是某人選定的判準。兩條來源補上 fb0addca-42b6-4884-aa18-438c695747ab.決定 的定義,結論二十六再補 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.黑箱律。論文規則八、2.5 表第二列、第五章約束級第九條、附錄推導十一與相關注釋,中英文同步。例六十九「推不出判斷錯誤」說的是他當時的判斷,收窄後仍成立,不改。\n- 結論二十七:當事人事後沒有完整的立足點評價 fb0addca-42b6-4884-aa18-438c695747ab.決定:當事人拿不全當初自己那段 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.歷史(fb0addca-42b6-4884-aa18-438c695747ab.來路牆);事後由研究者或當事人作的重現或評價,也是現在作的一次新的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別,若落出,就是一筆新的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出;所以事後評價是一次新的看法,不是當時的讀數(從 前提十 + fb0addca-42b6-4884-aa18-438c695747ab.來路牆 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別 的定義 + b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 的定義 + 前提二十五 推出)【正文:句3947655077、句7084175530】\n- 結論二十八:並非 蘊含(他選了某 路徑, 他評估過風險,或偏好冒險、厭惡風險);選了某 路徑 讀不出他怎麼看未來,那是他自己作的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別,亦可能別無可行 路徑(從 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.黑箱律 + 結論一 + 結論四之一 + ae79e938-76e1-4bf9-b2ab-995c03e16c9e.驅動力不可確認 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別 的定義 + 前提二十三 + 前提二十五 推出)【正文:句6278782184】\n- 結論二十九:並非 蘊含(有別人在同類 路徑 的結果 記錄, 這個人當時面對的風險與那些 記錄 所顯示的相同);各人 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.自己的那一段 可能不同,那些 記錄 不能直接當作這個人的風險讀數,若有人拿它作估計,那是他依某個樣本作的估計,不保證(從 結論十一之三 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.自己的那一段 的定義 推出)【正文:句0610175688】\n\n附註:傳統理論用風險區分「十拿九穩」與「九死一生」,這個區分要求事先知道結果的分布;所以本篇不單立風險。【正文:句0535538362、句4223281564】\n\n[作者裁決] 2026-10-27 「風險高」只作研究者的事後描述(指定分類與樣本下,同類 路徑 的結果 記錄 分散),且不歸給任何一次具體 fb0addca-42b6-4884-aa18-438c695747ab.決定,兩句都是正文的聲明,來源不足以推出「不歸給任何一次具體 fb0addca-42b6-4884-aa18-438c695747ab.決定」的全稱限制,所以不列為結論,一併列為前提十四 [限定條件];原附註刪除,避免內容只在附註裡。\n\n## 兩條回饋(對應第三章 3.1)\n\n來源:論文第三章第一小節【正文:句6215114372】\n\n[作者裁決] 2026-10-27 結論三十刪去「可行集合 之內的輕重」:上游的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.權重 與本篇的 可行集合 沒有建立對應規則,論文規則五、3.1 表與附錄推導五同步刪去。\n\n- 結論三十:對 門檻 的回饋可能改變 可行集合,這一輪不可行不推出之後不可行;對 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.權重 的回饋,37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.歷史 多了一筆,可能使 輸出傾向 改變,在有限 記錄 中不保證看得出來,也不由 記錄 的變化讀出 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.權重 的值,不保證是 2ccbf179-58cf-4851-bd72-5fa886e4b2c3.學習 或改善(從 結論五之三 + 2ccbf179-58cf-4851-bd72-5fa886e4b2c3.學習 的定義 + 輸出傾向 的定義 推出)【正文:句7856051568、句9183079570】\n\n附註:兩條回饋混在一起,會把「做不了」和「不傾向做」搞混。【正文:句0747033765】\n\n## 例:十個人,一個月,四輪(對應第三章 3.2 至 3.8)\n\n來源:論文第三章【正文:句3209049277】\n\n- 例:本例效準:本例的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.切法:十人(甲至癸),時窗一個月,分四輪,每輪約一週;結果分類「終點現金 記錄 比起點多出一萬元」由研究者指定,只是研究者的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別,不代表任何人想賺;五條 路徑、各 路徑 的各項 前件、甲、乙、丙、己的各輪 記錄(四輪記錄表)與人物皆為合成設定(含甲、己的現金增加金額相同、起點終點兩次 記錄 只記現金總額);本例的記帳寫法:記錄 先寫可觀察的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出(持刀接近、要求、取走現金),再另註研究者將其歸為搶劫、是誰歸的【正文:句9147463646、句0651014250、句5354769425、句1420395762】\n- 例三十一:本例每一輪走一遍:若有 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出,b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 若 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 外界,外界若有回應,回應若進入 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.歷史;再檢查 門檻(從 結論五之一 + 結論五之三 + 本例效準 推出)【正文:句1567616489、句7856051568】\n\n[作者裁決] 2026-10-27 原循環三十之一把「每一輪依序 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出、37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達、回應、入史」寫成逐輪必行,來源只支持條件式(b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 若 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達、外界若有回應);改為例三十一,來源是本例效準,保留完整條件,刪去論文沒有的「退出條件」。2026-10-28 依稽核意見(形-17)再確認:依總表 8.13,循環 屬推導標籤,推導不得引用 本例效準;這段的內容來自 本例效準(十人、四輪),所以只能是例,不改為循環;本例四輪走完即止。\n\n- 例三十二:五條 路徑 各有 門檻:受雇工作需有了雇主、有符合的技能(知識)、能在指定時段 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 工作地;擺攤販售需有本錢或商品、有場地、有時間、知道怎麼賣;自行種植販售需有田、有種子、耕種 知識,作物成熟於時窗內或手上已有可收成之物;出售既有物品需有可出售之物、有了買家;搶劫需有可施力的手段、有可 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 的對象與位置、雙方時段重疊、有執行的 知識(從 本例效準 + 門檻 的定義 推出)【正文:句0330556097、句6421913689、句2543862296、句2429426766、句4914609061】\n- 例三十三:所列 路徑 的 知識 前件 標「由 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 推測」或「未知」,其餘 前件 可直接檢查(從 前提十五 + 知識 的定義 + 本例效準 推出)【正文:句0330556097、句4914609061、句3399908261】\n- 例三十四:「搶劫」是研究者對一段 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 序列的命名(從 結論十七 + 本例效準 推出)【正文:句1420395762】\n\n[作者裁決] 2026-10-27 例三十四原把「先寫可觀察 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出、再另註分類」的記帳寫法當成由前提四與 記錄 的定義推出,但前提四允許研究者依需要選取登記內容,來源不足;現只留「搶劫是研究者的命名」為推出的部分,記帳寫法改列附註,是本例的約定;後依形-05 併入本例效準。\n- 例三十五:乙因第一輪的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 與回應,擺攤販售在第二輪不可行;甲的 前件「有本錢或商品」轉為具備,擺攤販售可能轉為可行(從 結論一 + 結論五之三 + 本例效準 推出)【正文:句7301140361、句0732080795、句6415467331】\n- 例三十五之二:乙第二輪改出售既有物品,該 路徑 的 前件「有可出售之物、有了買家」未見資料,標「未知」;他實際賣出,可知該輪此 路徑 可行(從 門檻 的定義 + 可行集合 的定義 + 本例效準 推出)【正文:句0732080795】\n\n[作者裁決] 2026-10-27 例三十五原寫乙的 可行集合 縮小、甲的 可行集合 可能擴大;來源只確認乙的擺攤販售在第二輪不可行,乙的出售既有物品在第一輪的 前件 標「未知」,推不出新集合是舊集合的真子集。依稽核意見改為逐條 路徑 說明,不由一條 路徑 的變化推出整個 可行集合 的增減;來源補上結論一(不可行由 前件 不具備推出)。論文 3.3 讀法第一條與英文同步。同一輪依跨-04,論文規則五、3.3 表頭、四輪記錄表 的定義與結論五之三的寫法,一併由「門檻 變」改為「門檻 是否具備」變,不再把 門檻 與 可行集合 並置為同義。\n- 例三十六:丙的種植在單輪不含播種時被時間排除,但播種是研究者對一段 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 的歸類,可能改變後續外界;時窗拉長,排除名單可能改寫(從 結論一 + 結論五之三 + 本例效準 推出)【正文:句4836500366、句6820757518】\n- 例三十七:己與甲的現金增加金額相同時,單憑起點終點兩次 記錄 上的現金總額,區分不出兩人走的是哪條 路徑;能否區分,取決於各輪的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 記錄(從 前提四 + 本例效準 推出)【正文:句1235320473、句3701317482】\n- 例三十八:依前提五,總量有限,所以某些 路徑 互相排斥;本例把「全職受雇」與「全力擺攤」指定為各占滿一週,故在本例互斥;若改為兼職或部分時段,是否互斥取決於時間與位置有沒有重疊,不由前提五直接推出;也不能在兩處同時下手(直接來自不能同時在兩地);所以每輪單條可行之後,它們是否互相排斥仍是另一個問題(從 前提五 + 結論九之一 + 本例效準 推出)【正文:句5333289496、句5432052407、句7456111056、句2085185855】\n- 步驟三十九:只算 門檻 具備而被排除的 路徑;門檻 不具備的屬不可行,不是放棄,不在 機會成本 的比較之列(從 結論一 + 步驟九之二 + 機會成本 的定義 推出)【正文:句4557348877、句0810376182】\n- 步驟四十:「在此估值下,甲走受雇,被排除的擺攤預期約為某個數」是比較計算的陳述;「甲因為 機會成本 小而選受雇」是在說動機,推不出,因為 機會成本 不用來解釋動機(從 結論九之三 + ae79e938-76e1-4bf9-b2ab-995c03e16c9e.驅動力不可確認 + 前提二十三 推出)【正文:句0874426843、句0335861111】\n- 步驟四十一:終點只是最後一輪後的一次 記錄,與起點之差不稱代價(從 前提四 推出)【正文:句7734519584】\n- 例四十二:終點差異不能直接讀成選擇差異:同起點的兩人,早期 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 得到不同回應,後來的 可行集合 可能分岔(從 結論六 + 本例效準 推出)【正文:句2303842473】\n- 步驟四十三:沒賺到,並不蘊含沒嘗試;「嘗試」是研究者對一段可觀察 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 的歸類,是研究者的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別,有登記就可記;沒嘗試不是空白:這一輪裡,他不被 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.鎖死 的每一個 fb0addca-42b6-4884-aa18-438c695747ab.回合 都落出了結果(「不動」也是其中之一),只是其中沒有嘗試(從 fb0addca-42b6-4884-aa18-438c695747ab.決定 的定義 + fb0addca-42b6-4884-aa18-438c695747ab.被迫的賭注 + b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 的定義 + fb0addca-42b6-4884-aa18-438c695747ab.回合 的定義 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別 的定義 + 記錄 的定義 + 前提二十五 推出)【正文:句4446409217、句2586614816】\n- 例四十四:假設甲受雇、乙賣既有物品,兩人終點現金都多一萬元,若只用「終點現金多一萬元」分類,兩人同類;按時間、來源、37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 的對象分,則可能不同,是否不同取決於各項的實際 記錄;兩人不必自認在做同一件事(從 結論十之一 + 本例效準 推出)【正文:句0288883242、句5474826516】\n- 例四十五:假設 記錄 顯示十人中有四人,各自在每一輪都有受雇的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出;這是這四人各自的 輸出傾向,各附條件:b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.切法 為本例的十人四輪、時窗一月、分類規則為「受雇」的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出、門檻 條件為有了雇主、有符合的技能(知識)、能在指定時段 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 工作地;「十人中四人」是研究者跨 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.個體 的計數,不是一個 輸出傾向;另六人沒有,可能是某一輪某項 前件 不具備,也可能 前件 具備、路徑 可行而未發生;資料查不出的記為「未知」(從 結論十六 + 結論二 + 輸出傾向 的定義 + 本例效準 推出)【正文:句6202242950、句5672484370、句9262917144】\n- 例四十六:三人有搶劫 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出,不能讀成這三人搶劫的 輸出傾向 偏高,因為另外七人可能不具備 前件,也可能 前件 具備而未發生(從 結論一 + 結論二 + 結論十六 + 本例效準 推出)【正文:句6572659671】\n\n[作者裁決] 2026-10-27 輸出傾向 依定義是一個 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.個體 的歸納;例四十五原把「十人中四人各輪均有受雇 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出」直接稱為 輸出傾向,沒有分清是四人各自的傾向還是群體計數。依稽核意見改為四人各自的 輸出傾向,「十人中四人」只是研究者跨 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.個體 的計數,不是傾向,這一句由 輸出傾向 的定義支持,來源不變。例四十六同一問題,補上主詞「這三人搶劫的」。論文 3.6 與英文同步。\n\n附註:本篇對他人回應只記為「外部條件的變化」,不分析原因;他人 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 之間的相容與 ae79e938-76e1-4bf9-b2ab-995c03e16c9e.失配、暴力與互利的分離、對被搶者存續的影響,不在本篇處理。【正文:句0252641670、句6182984061、句0163603822】\n\n附註:本例不說誰勤勞、誰理性、誰為了什麼、哪條路划算、誰應該怎麼選;有人持刀而未搶,不推出他克制;有人搶了,不推出他缺錢;「一個月多一萬元」是指定分類,本例的結論離不開它的時窗、輪長與分類。【正文:句9514043001、句7929079377、句1344466797、句0102095017、句2782904296、句9732301478】\n\n## 存續與生殖(對應第四章)\n\n來源:論文第四章【正文:句4973593803】\n\n- 結論四十八:37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.個體 的下一刻 96f10d75-23d0-441f-94c7-ab87ca28d284.狀態變數、96f10d75-23d0-441f-94c7-ab87ca28d284.資源變數,以及 96f10d75-23d0-441f-94c7-ab87ca28d284.判準退場 的相關 記錄,若該 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.個體 已被列為指定 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.切法 的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.節點、這些欄位已記入該輪的 96f10d75-23d0-441f-94c7-ab87ca28d284.解,則是上游 96f10d75-23d0-441f-94c7-ab87ca28d284.解 在單個 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.節點 上的部分(從 96f10d75-23d0-441f-94c7-ab87ca28d284.解 的定義 + 96f10d75-23d0-441f-94c7-ab87ca28d284.推演輪 的定義 推出)【正文:句5825851050、句8769779748】\n- 結論四十九:判準是定義,由研究者指定,是訂它的人的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別;某一輪是否發生 96f10d75-23d0-441f-94c7-ab87ca28d284.判準退場,取決於實際事件;研究者將它登記下來,才是 記錄(從 96f10d75-23d0-441f-94c7-ab87ca28d284.判準退場 的定義 + 記錄 的定義 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別 的定義 + 前提二十五 推出)【正文:句0517641555、句1266625272、句0425677167、句7634755201、句5905443166、句8615612282】\n- 結論五十:存續只記有無與時點,不推原因,也不因他是否依賴器材、是否被他人照顧、身體如何而改變判定方式(從 結論八 + 結論四十九 推出)【正文:句5193684956、句9854278313】\n- 結論五十一:b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.退場、fb0addca-42b6-4884-aa18-438c695747ab.死亡、96f10d75-23d0-441f-94c7-ab87ca28d284.判準退場 三者彼此不互推,可以對不上:已 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.退場 而無人標 fb0addca-42b6-4884-aa18-438c695747ab.死亡、被標 fb0addca-42b6-4884-aa18-438c695747ab.死亡 而仍是 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦、符合判準而結構上並非 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.退場(從 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.退場 的定義 + fb0addca-42b6-4884-aa18-438c695747ab.死亡 的定義 + 96f10d75-23d0-441f-94c7-ab87ca28d284.判準退場 的定義 推出)【正文:句1457307038、句0000194448、句0797618898】\n- 結論五十二:結構上 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.退場 之後可以再 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.進場(從 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.進場 的定義 + b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.退場 的定義 推出)【正文:句0560394396】\n\n[作者裁決] 2026-10-27 結論五十二原把「96f10d75-23d0-441f-94c7-ab87ca28d284.判準退場 是否可逆」與「只記有無與時點」併入由 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.進場、b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.退場 的定義推出的結論,來源不足:b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.進場 與 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.退場 的定義只支持結構狀態可以改變,不建立 96f10d75-23d0-441f-94c7-ab87ca28d284.判準退場 的可逆性,也不推出記帳規則。現只留「結構上 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.退場 之後可以再 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.進場」為結論,其餘改列附註,正文同一句仍明寫「作為記帳約定」;後依形-05 改列前提十七 [限定條件]。\n- 結論五十三:存續與生殖的 記錄 只是研究者在指定 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.切法 下對已發生之事的一次選取,不是對該 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.個體 的完整結算;當事人若對自己作 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別,那 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別 也不完整,所以不是對一生的結算;結算還要再作一次 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別,把一整段看作某個結果,這次 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別 本身又進入 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.歷史,不在它自己的材料裡(從 前提十 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.損耗律 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別 的定義 + 記錄 的定義 + 前提二十五 推出)【正文:句3660972069、句0562620094】\n- 結論五十四:存續與生殖的 記錄 本身不帶評價一生的判準,不評價一生;事件判準(96f10d75-23d0-441f-94c7-ab87ca28d284.判準退場 與生殖事件所用者)由研究者另訂;評價或比較不同 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.個體,用的是某人的判準,記錄 自己不提供(從 結論五十三 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別 的定義 + 96f10d75-23d0-441f-94c7-ab87ca28d284.判準退場 的定義 + 前提六 + 要能果三問 的定義 推出)【正文:句5314751845、句1266625272、句3037569522】\n- 結論五十六:實際生殖只看指定時窗與事件判準下,生殖事件有沒有發生;輸出傾向 高並不蘊含發生,自述是一筆 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出;「嘗試」是研究者對一段 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 的歸類;兩者研究者若有登記,各另記為 記錄,都不是這筆生殖事件本身(從 結論三之一 + 結論四之一 + 前提六 + b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 的定義 + 記錄 的定義 + 要能果三問 的定義 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別 的定義 推出)【正文:句2787980458、句9097703456】\n\n[作者裁決] 2026-10-27 實際生殖只看事件有無,由規則二、規則三與生殖記為 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 拼出。\n\n- 結論六十八:96f10d75-23d0-441f-94c7-ab87ca28d284.判準退場 的有無與時點,是 96f10d75-23d0-441f-94c7-ab87ca28d284.解 的一個維度;存續就是讀這個維度,不是另一套資料(從 96f10d75-23d0-441f-94c7-ab87ca28d284.解 的定義 + 96f10d75-23d0-441f-94c7-ab87ca28d284.判準退場 的定義 + 前提二十四 推出)【正文:句3538800439】\n- 結論六十九:上游 96f10d75-23d0-441f-94c7-ab87ca28d284.解 沒有預設生殖這個維度,生殖是本篇依另訂的事件判準所作的判定(從 96f10d75-23d0-441f-94c7-ab87ca28d284.解 的定義 + 前提六 + 要能果三問 的定義 推出)【正文:句3037569522】\n- 結論八十一:並非 蘊含(某 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.節點 是另一 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.節點 的 子代, 該 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.節點 繼承親代的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.權重 或 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出);37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.權重 取決於 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 該 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.個體 的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.歷史,前史重疊不推出 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.權重 或 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 轉移(從 前提十一 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.權重 的定義 + b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 的定義 推出)【正文:句6271308259、句2482209115】\n\n[作者裁決] 2026-10-27 96f10d75-23d0-441f-94c7-ab87ca28d284.判準退場 的有無與時點在 96f10d75-23d0-441f-94c7-ab87ca28d284.解 裡,存續就是讀這個維度;生殖才是另訂事件判準。\n\n附註:存續與生殖都是研究者指定判準之後的事實檢查,不是 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.權重 的後果,也不是 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.個體 的目的;本篇不知道也不需要知道 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.個體 的身體條件怎樣。【正文:句7450361551、句4086334913】\n\n附註:邊界:本篇只記 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.個體 這一側;對方的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.歷史、配對如何形成、子代 的存活與再生殖,不在本篇處理;子代 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.進場 與不繼承親代 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.權重 或 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出,見前提十一與結論八十一;封閉人口下三項結果合起來是否成立、何謂足夠,不在本篇處理。【正文:句0475114072、句9612491815、句6271308259、句2250462962】\n\n## 不蘊涵清單(對應第四章 4.3)\n\n來源:論文第四章第三小節【正文:句9540748455】\n\n- 結論五十七:並非 蘊含(進食 路徑 的 輸出傾向 穩定, 不進食時 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.個體 必然發生 96f10d75-23d0-441f-94c7-ab87ca28d284.判準退場,判準取生理界線);輸出傾向 是 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 記錄 的形狀,不是必要條件(從 結論三之二 + 輸出傾向 的定義 + 記錄 的定義 推出)【正文:句5126215767】\n- 結論五十八:並非 蘊含(沒進食而未發生 96f10d75-23d0-441f-94c7-ab87ca28d284.判準退場, 該 輸出傾向 的歸納不成立);可能存在別的 路徑 或外部條件;單一個案本身說不了歸納成不成立,成不成立取決於可比條件下的整體 記錄(從 門檻 的定義 + 輸出傾向 的定義 + 記錄 的定義 推出)【正文:句9158382196】\n- 結論五十九:並非 蘊含(某一輪未發生 96f10d75-23d0-441f-94c7-ab87ca28d284.判準退場, 他的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 較好或最優);存續只是判準下的事實,不比較 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出(從 結論四十九 推出)【正文:句9589297574】\n- 結論六十:並非 蘊含(某人被記為 96f10d75-23d0-441f-94c7-ab87ca28d284.判準退場, 他選錯,或缺少什麼);96f10d75-23d0-441f-94c7-ab87ca28d284.判準退場 與想要什麼無必然關係;與 96f10d75-23d0-441f-94c7-ab87ca28d284.資源變數 的關係隨所訂判準而定,如以破產為判準,則由判準定義建立(從 結論四十九 + 結論十二 推出)【正文:句3122269926】\n- 結論六十一:並非 蘊含(某一輪有一筆 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 記為生殖事件, 他想生)(從 ae79e938-76e1-4bf9-b2ab-995c03e16c9e.驅動力不可確認 + 前提六 + 結論三之二 + 前提二十三 推出)【正文:句2146213351】\n- 結論六十二:並非 蘊含(某一輪沒有 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 記為生殖事件, 他不想生,或缺少什麼);亦可能 門檻 不具備(從 ae79e938-76e1-4bf9-b2ab-995c03e16c9e.驅動力不可確認 + 結論一 + 前提二十三 推出)【正文:句8151554017】\n[作者裁決] 2026-10-27 結論六十三之一、之二收窄為「單憑這一輪的 記錄 推不出下一輪是否發生」,理由是 記錄 為研究者的選取(來源結論十四與 記錄 的定義),不論是否 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.鎖死;不被 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.鎖死 時 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.黑箱律 使下一輪完整結果不由這一輪唯一推出,是另一項理由,改列附註,不當作這兩條的來源,論文4.3表與英文已分開寫;結論六十七收窄為僅憑起點與終點兩次 記錄 上的 96f10d75-23d0-441f-94c7-ab87ca28d284.資源變數 數值看不出 路徑,論文規則6與英文同步;結論六十四改為方法說明(本篇不由一個推另一個),不主張邏輯上無蘊含。\n\n- 結論六十三之一:單憑這一輪的 記錄 推不出下一輪是否發生 96f10d75-23d0-441f-94c7-ab87ca28d284.判準退場(並非 蘊含(一輪未發生 96f10d75-23d0-441f-94c7-ab87ca28d284.判準退場, 之後也不發生 96f10d75-23d0-441f-94c7-ab87ca28d284.判準退場));記錄 是研究者的選取,沒登記的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 仍在 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.歷史 裡,可能繼續影響 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.權重;96f10d75-23d0-441f-94c7-ab87ca28d284.判準退場 取決於研究者所訂判準與實際事件(從 結論十四 + 記錄 的定義 + 96f10d75-23d0-441f-94c7-ab87ca28d284.判準退場 的定義 + 結論四十九 推出)【正文:句0784837704】\n- 結論六十三之二:單憑這一輪的 記錄 推不出下一輪是否再有 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 記為生殖事件(並非 蘊含(一輪有 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 記為生殖事件, 下一輪也有 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 記為生殖事件));記錄 是研究者的選取(結論十四);已發生的生殖事件不取消,這裡說的是下一輪是否再發生(從 結論十四 + 記錄 的定義 + 結論七之三 + 前提六 推出)【正文:句0784837704】\n\n附註:另外,在不被 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.鎖死 的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.時刻,下一輪的完整結果也不由這一輪唯一推出(37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.黑箱律);這是上游的律,不是上面兩條結論的來源。【正文:句0784837704】\n\n## 現存樣本條件化(對應第四章 4.4)\n\n來源:論文第四章第四小節【正文:句7522324950】\n\n- 結論六十五:以「存續」為條件選樣時,樣本裡的是尚未 96f10d75-23d0-441f-94c7-ab87ca28d284.判準退場 的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.個體;是否 96f10d75-23d0-441f-94c7-ab87ca28d284.判準退場 只取決於研究者所訂判準與實際事件,與他 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 的好壞無必然關係,所以存續者的表現不足以直接用來評價好壞;以「存續」為條件選樣,樣本邊界由此而來(從 96f10d75-23d0-441f-94c7-ab87ca28d284.判準退場 的定義 + 結論四十九 + 結論五十九 推出)【正文:句3734221049、句1882586648】\n\n[作者裁決] 2026-10-27 存續是一道門,不是成績單;96f10d75-23d0-441f-94c7-ab87ca28d284.判準退場 與 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 好壞無必然關係。\n\n- 結論六十六:96f10d75-23d0-441f-94c7-ab87ca28d284.判準退場 者留下的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出,凡已 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 別人或留在 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.信號容器 中者,仍在 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.歷史 裡;沒 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 任何人者,研究者可能拿不到;所以推不出消失者不可研究(從 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 的定義 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.歷史 的定義 + b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 的定義 + b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.信號容器 的定義 推出)【正文:句7628989448】\n\n附註:這是研究者的樣本邊界,不是外界有選擇目的;「篩選」只作比喻。【正文:句1923450548】\n\n## 結論分級(對應第五章)\n\n來源:論文第五章【正文:句8519092054】\n\n- 結論六十七:96f10d75-23d0-441f-94c7-ab87ca28d284.資源變數 增減所屬的類別並不蘊含 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 類型:在研究者指定的結果分類下,同類的資源變化可由不同 路徑 達成,所以僅憑起點與終點兩次 記錄 上的 96f10d75-23d0-441f-94c7-ab87ca28d284.資源變數 變化落在哪一類,不能唯一判定是哪一條 路徑(從 結論十之一 + 結論十之二 + 前提四 推出)【正文:句7320356432】\n\n[作者裁決] 2026-10-28 寫法原則:論文只陳述立場,以及本篇自己怎麼做,不對讀者下指令;研究者要不要照做,由研究者自己定。原文中「須講明」「須標明」「須再加」「須逐一查」「不得」之類的命令句,幾乎都是結論的命令形,背後各有一個主張(例如「結果好壞是某人判準下的歸類,不是結果本身的性質」,依 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別 的定義),所以改寫成主張;屬本篇記帳約定的,改寫成「本篇記為……」。前提二十二(方法約定)因此不再需要,刪除,並從結論九之三、十一之二、十一之三、二十五、二十六、二十九、五十四的來源中移除;前提十五、十九、二十與前提九改為陳述句;附註「方法上禁止」改為「本篇不採用的寫法」,每一條附上背後的主張。論文中英文、概念表 輸出傾向、機會成本、知識 的定義同步。\n[作者裁決] 2026-10-28 依稽核意見(形-35):結論十一之二、結論二十五原寫「讀不全,也不能確認他怎麼看未來」,所列來源講的是預測與動機,撐不住「不能確認」。改為:當事人怎麼看未來,是他自己作的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別(對自己的部分是 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.自我印象),至多是估計(依 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別、b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.自我印象 的定義與 fb0addca-42b6-4884-aa18-438c695747ab.未定牆);依 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.損耗律 他對自己的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別 本來就不完整,自述又有損(結論四之一);旁人的判斷是旁人的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.印象(依其定義),讀不全他的看法。不寫「是他的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.自我印象」,因為看未來也包括外界與他人怎麼回應,超出 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.自我印象 的範圍。兩條來源以此替換 ae79e938-76e1-4bf9-b2ab-995c03e16c9e.驅動力不可確認,結論二十五補引規則八的句子;結論二十八「讀不出他怎麼看未來」補上「那是他自己作的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別」,來源補 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別 的定義。論文規則八、2.5 第二段與表第一、三列,中英文同步。(形-35)結論二之一的來源補上 可行集合 的定義。(論-06)4.2 正文的「子女」指 子代,補上連結,英文同步;注釋不加連結(總表 8.9),注釋中原有的一處 知識 連結一併撤去。(跨-31)例七十九補引律師 路徑 三項 前件、逐輪取得、取得執照與後來執業的四句,並依資料把「缺一項 前件」收窄為「至少執照這一項 前件 不具備」。(主動掃查)結論十六與論文 2.2「不能因此判為」改為「推不出」,「由研究者講明」改為「是研究者所作的判定」;第六章「可說與推不出」改為「資料顯示的與推不出的」,前提五否定條件的裁決同步;前提二十補引「本篇只記這些欄位」一句。(主動掃查)前提一「並報告是誰作這個劃分」改為「本篇並寫出是誰作這個劃分」;前提三與論文 3.2「由研究者講明」改為「是研究者的判定」,概念表 路徑 的定義同步;結論十六補引前提四;第五章約束級第九條改為與規則八相同的說法;2.4「只能作研究者的事後描述」改為「只是」。\n[作者裁決] 2026-10-28 依稽核意見:(跨-26)結論十一之一先前加入的「有所動作或「不動」,都是這一 fb0addca-42b6-4884-aa18-438c695747ab.回合 落出的結果」是上游 fb0addca-42b6-4884-aa18-438c695747ab.被迫的賭注 的內容,與前面「結論十一之一只寫適用範圍」的裁決不符,刪去;用到它的步驟四十三直接引 fb0addca-42b6-4884-aa18-438c695747ab.被迫的賭注。(形-35)結論十一之一「37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.鎖死 時結果已由約束唯一確定」補上 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.鎖死 的定義為來源。(跨-04)論文規則七括號中 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.趨同 的說明補上「在 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.耦合 之下」,與上游一致,中英文同步。(跨-31)前提十六的「結論九之二」改為「步驟九之二」,補引正文說明 機會成本 比較計算的句子。\n[作者裁決] 2026-10-28 依稽核意見(形-35):結論十一之二、結論二十五原寫「旁人只能據他的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 作判斷」;依 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.印象 的定義,b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.印象 的材料不只對方的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出,還有雙方重疊的那一段與對方所在的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.耦合,「只能據 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出」說得太窄。改為「旁人對他的判斷,是旁人的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.印象,旁人由此讀不全他的看法」;讀不全的理由仍是他自己 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別 不全、自述有損。規則八前文「旁人從當事人那裡拿到的只是當事人的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出」講的是從當事人那裡拿到的,不改。論文規則八、2.5 第二段與表第一列,中英文同步。\n[作者裁決] 2026-10-28 依稽核意見:(形-35)37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.黑箱律 只適用於不被 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.鎖死 的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.時刻,ae79e938-76e1-4bf9-b2ab-995c03e16c9e.驅動力不可確認 只適用於不被 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.鎖死 的對象,且依其適用範圍,從外部無法確認是否被 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.鎖死,只能假定。論文〇補上這個假定,形式化列為前提二十三,加入來源含這兩條而未寫明條件的十五條推導(結論二、三之一、三之二、四之一、五之三、十之二、十二、十四、二十五、二十六、二十八、六十一、六十二,步驟四十、七十四);已寫明「在不被 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.鎖死 時」者不另加。中英文同步。(跨-31)例七十九原有「律師 路徑 在取得執照之前,至少執照這一項 前件 不具備,不可行;後來他實際執業,可知該輪此 路徑 可行」,論文沒有作這個判定,刪去,改照正文寫「他的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 外界,外界回應之後,下一輪的 可行集合 有變化」。\n[作者裁決] 2026-10-28 依稽核意見:(形-35、跨-31)例七十九的「可行集合 有變化」原無推論,前一輪又因論文沒有而刪去律師 路徑 的判定;改在論文第六章補上這段推論(取得執照前至少執照這一項 前件 不具備,不可行;後來實際執業,可知那時可行;所以前後的 可行集合 不同),例七十九照抄並引用該句。(跨-11)論文規則九標題「三問互不蘊涵」與第五章第十條、概念表 要能果三問 的定義「彼此不互相推出」,比內文的三個單向強,且「做了」可知當時「能」,反方向成立;改為「前一問推不出後一問」,列出三個單向,與結論十二一致,注釋同步,中英文一致。\n[作者裁決] 2026-10-28 依稽核意見(形-35):步驟四十三與結論五十六原寫「嘗試是 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出」「自述與嘗試各是另一筆 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出」;「嘗試」是研究者對一段 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 的歸類,可能包含多筆,與論文對「搶劫」的寫法同型,改為「研究者對一段可觀察 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 的歸類」,來源補 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別 的定義;論文 3.3、4.2 中英文同步。(主動掃查)同型的「播種是一筆 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出」(3.2 表、3.4 讀法第二條與對應的例)與「借書是一筆 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出」(第六章與例七十三)同步改為「研究者對一段 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 的歸類」。\n[作者裁決] 2026-10-28 依稽核意見:(形-05)結論六十四先前已收窄為方法說明(本篇不由一個推另一個),不是推導,改列前提二十四並標為限定條件,內容不變。(跨-11)論文附錄推導十二「要、能、結果三者不互推」與規則九同步改為三個單向;第七章「fb0addca-42b6-4884-aa18-438c695747ab.被迫的賭注、fb0addca-42b6-4884-aa18-438c695747ab.未定牆、fb0addca-42b6-4884-aa18-438c695747ab.來路牆 若被推翻」原只列規則八、2.5 與第五章第九條,依來源鏈補列 2.2 對 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.權重 的估計(結論十五)、3.4 機會成本 的比較(結論九之三、步驟四十)、3.5「沒嘗試不是空白」(步驟四十三)與第六章相應的校準敘述(例六十九),中英文同步。(跨-04)3.3 表中甲、丙的 知識 是合成設定,補標「本例設定」,與規則四「知識 只由 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 推測」區分。\n[作者裁決] 2026-10-28 依稽核意見:(形-35)上游 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別 是 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦 的動作;論文多處說研究者或旁人的歸類、判準、估值是他們的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別,但只寫明當事人屬上游所稱的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.我。論文〇補上「研究者與旁人也是生物人,同樣屬上游所稱的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.我」,形式化列為前提二十五,加入步驟四十三、結論四十九等十條推導的來源;本例效準中「只是研究者的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別」屬效準,不另加。(跨-16)4.2 英文「之後與當事人有無 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達」原譯成 子代 單向 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 當事人,改為不指定方向。\n[作者裁決] 2026-10-28 依稽核意見(形-35):例七十三與論文第六章原寫律師 路徑 的三項 前件(書、知識、執照)是前面幾輪一件件取得的;依前提十五,知識 只能由 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 推測,改為「書與執照是前面幾輪一件件取得的;知識 是否具備,只能由後來的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 推測」,來源補前提十五,中英文同步。例七十九的來源只有一般判準與 本例效準,而第六章的 本例效準 原只寫 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.切法;補上「本例的資料以正文所引史料為準」,並引用 前件、取得執照與執業三句。\n[作者裁決] 2026-10-28 依稽核意見(形-35):結論九之三原寫「37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.權重 讀不到」,fb0addca-42b6-4884-aa18-438c695747ab.未定牆 只支持統計給估計、讀不出值,改為「單憑 記錄 讀不出 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.權重 的值」,來源補 記錄 的定義;同型的論文〇「研究者讀不到 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.權重」、主題段「讀不到,只能統計」、4.0 欄位表「不可觀測」與概念表 要能果三問 的定義同步收窄,中英文一致。結論六十八「存續就是讀這個維度」依前提二十四的記法,前提二十四改為一般前提並列為結論六十八的來源(先前列為限定條件,是因為當時沒有推導引用它)。(主動掃查)英文第六章林肯遇刺一句年份寫了兩次,刪去句首的年份。\n[作者裁決] 2026-10-28 依稽核意見:(形-05)結論分級的附註原以封閉清單列出約束級所用的前提,漏了後來補的前提二十三、二十五,以及若干記帳約定;改為寫明不用經驗前提(前提五、前提八),其餘列出;論文第五章同步,聲明與假定由四項補為六項,中英文一致。(跨-04)概念表 記錄 的定義「登記時寫明發生了什麼、何時……」改為「所記的內容可以包括……」,與正文「記什麼由研究者依需要選取,不預先列舉」一致。(跨-16)第六章中文「劈柴」與史料及英文的劈製圍欄木條不符,中文改為「劈製圍欄木條」。\n\n[作者裁決] 2026-10-28 依稽核意見(形-35、形-05、跨-11):結論二十七原寫事後的重現或評價「是一筆新的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出」,但 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別 要落出才是 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出,改為「若落出,就是一筆新的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出」,論文 2.5 同步,與規則三的寫法一致;結論四之二依 ae79e938-76e1-4bf9-b2ab-995c03e16c9e.驅動力不可確認 的適用範圍補上「在不被 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.鎖死 的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.時刻」,論文 2.3 表第二列把這個條件移到整格開頭;前提十八原含「都不改變判定方式」,這一點已由結論五十從結論八推出,前提十八只留記帳做法;第六章「下一輪的 可行集合 有變化」補為例七十九,原附註的前半句是判斷而不是擋誤讀,移入例七十九,附註只留推不出的清單。英文第五章與概念表 子代 的英文定義,b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.進場 的顯示文字改為與上游英文名一致的詞形。\n\n[作者裁決] 2026-10-28 依稽核意見與主動掃查:(形-35)結論十一之一原寫「每一次 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 所落出的 fb0addca-42b6-4884-aa18-438c695747ab.決定」,上游的 fb0addca-42b6-4884-aa18-438c695747ab.決定 按 fb0addca-42b6-4884-aa18-438c695747ab.回合 判定,未建立每一次 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 對應一個 fb0addca-42b6-4884-aa18-438c695747ab.決定,改為「那一 fb0addca-42b6-4884-aa18-438c695747ab.回合 就是一個 fb0addca-42b6-4884-aa18-438c695747ab.決定;有所動作或「不動」都是這一 fb0addca-42b6-4884-aa18-438c695747ab.回合 落出的結果」,來源補上 fb0addca-42b6-4884-aa18-438c695747ab.回合 的定義,論文規則八、第五章約束級第九條與前面相關的裁決同步;(論-06)正文中受雇所需的「技能」適用 知識 的證據規則,補上 知識 的連結,形式化例三十二、例四十五同步;(形-32)前提二十一先前兩則裁決的說法統一為:同日先列為限定條件,後改為一般前提;(跨-11)論文 2.3 表「發生了,推出還原內部成因」收窄為「還原當時的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.權重 或內部驅動力」,與規則二、結論三之三、結論四之二一致,結論三之三補引這一列;(主動掃查)「37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.權重 讀不到」原以 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.黑箱律 為來源,但 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.黑箱律 說能推出的是 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.權重,支撐「研究者只能估計、讀不出 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.權重 的值」的是 fb0addca-42b6-4884-aa18-438c695747ab.未定牆,論文 3.4 與結論九之三、結論十五的來源同步改正;結論五十二後的裁決補上後來改列前提十七;概念表「不登記」的回饋改為條件式。中英文論文同步。\n\n[作者裁決] 2026-10-28 依稽核意見(形-05、跨-11):前提二十一「研究者可依某類 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 反覆發生,作 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.權重 較重的估計」是論文聲明的做法,推不出,且推導要用到它,不是只限定範圍,所以由限定條件改為一般前提;結論十五接上前提二十一,保留正文「反覆發生,可估計 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.權重 較重」的方向性判斷,並依 fb0addca-42b6-4884-aa18-438c695747ab.未定牆 與 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.黑箱律 寫明這只是估計、不保證、讀不出 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.權重 的值。論文不改。\n\n[作者裁決] 2026-10-28 依稽核意見(形-35、論-06、跨-26):結論三之三的「內部成因」超出來源,收窄為「推不出當時的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.權重,也不能確認內部的驅動力」,來源補上 fb0addca-42b6-4884-aa18-438c695747ab.決定 的定義,論文規則二同步;結論十五中「反覆發生可估計 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.權重 較重」是研究者的估計做法,不是推導,改列前提二十一(同日先列為限定條件,後依形-05、跨-11 改為一般前提,由結論十五引用),論文 2.2 補上「在指定的樣本與條件下」「只是估計,不保證」;結論五十六的「各是另一筆 記錄」改為「各是另一筆 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出,研究者若有登記,各記為另一筆 記錄」,論文 4.2 同步;規則五句末括號補上 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.寫入、37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.坍塌 的連結;三則作者裁決中重述上游定義的文字刪去,只保留「依 某某 的定義」。中英文論文同步。\n\n[作者裁決] 2026-10-28 依稽核意見:(形-35)依 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.歷史 的定義,外界回應須是一次 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.寫入 或 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.坍塌 的結果,才在 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.歷史 裡;結論五之一與規則五改為「回應凡是一次 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.寫入 或 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.坍塌 的結果,就進入 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.歷史」,第三章每輪循環、第五章約束級第三條、附錄推導五與例三十一、前提八否定條件的裁決改為條件式「回應若進入 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.歷史」,推導五的來源補上 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.歷史 的定義。(形-35)當事人能自述,自述可能傳達他對未來的某個看法,「讀不到他怎麼看未來」說得太滿;依結論四之一(自述有損,不能當作內部的完整讀數),改為「讀不全,也不能確認」,規則八、2.5 第二段與表第一列、結論十一之二、結論二十五同步;「選了某 路徑 讀不出他怎麼看未來」只看所選 路徑,不涉自述,不改。(跨-04)3.6 的「如甲無手段」把「未知」當成「不具備」,改為假設句「例如若查證甲確實沒有可施力的手段」。(跨-11)規則二的「發生一次不能還原內部成因」是一般主張,結論四之二只涵蓋內容為 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別 的情形,補結論三之三;2.2 的「看到反覆發生,可估計這類 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.權重 較重」補入結論十五,來源補上 fb0addca-42b6-4884-aa18-438c695747ab.未定牆。中英文論文同步。\n\n[作者裁決] 2026-10-28 依稽核意見(跨-03),論文原把「從經驗來、不由四律推出的前提」寫成「經驗 前件」並連到 前件;但 前件 是一條 路徑 成立所需的條件,是 門檻 的組成項,前提五這類物理限制不是某條 路徑 的 門檻 組成項。改稱「經驗前提」,不加連結;論文〇、第一章前提標題、前提五標題同步,第五章條件級表的表頭「用到的 前件」改為「依據」,中英文一致;形式化與概念表 要能果三問 的裁決中的同一用語同步改為「經驗前提」。同日依跨-31,結論五十四、結論六十四補全正文引用。\n\n[作者裁決] 2026-10-28 依稽核意見(形-35),結論六十七原寫「僅憑兩次 記錄 上的 96f10d75-23d0-441f-94c7-ab87ca28d284.資源變數 數值不能唯一判定 路徑」;但結果同類只是研究者的歸類,不保證不同 路徑 的資源數值相同(例如兩條 路徑 分別固定得一與二,同歸一類時精確數值仍可區分)。收窄為「僅憑資源變化所屬的類別不能唯一判定 路徑」,來源補上結論十之一。論文第五章約束級第六條與英文同步。「本篇不採用的寫法」中「不由 96f10d75-23d0-441f-94c7-ab87ca28d284.資源變數 增減推出 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 類型」是本篇的寫法,不是推導,不改;例三十七本就附「現金增加金額相同」的條件,不改。\n\n[作者裁決] 2026-10-28 同日依稽核意見:(跨-11)例三十五之二補上乙「實際賣出,可知該輪此 路徑 可行」,只寫在例裡,與第六章「實際開了店,可知該輪開店可行」的寫法一致,不另立一般規則;結論九之三補上「估值換了,比較結果可能不同」,論文 3.4 的「結果不同」同步改為「結果可能不同」,中英文一致。(形-35、跨-16)例四十四原寫「切入時間、來源、37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 的對象,則不同」,路徑 不同不保證這些維度都不同(例如甲的雇主可能正是乙的買家),改為「可能不同,是否不同取決於各項的實際 記錄」;論文 3.5 同步,英文的時間用詞同步放寬。(論-06)論文 3.5「在不被 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.鎖死 的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.時刻」補上 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.時刻 的連結。(跨-05)「終點」列入概念表「不登記」,說明它是 記錄 的一種用法。\n\n[作者裁決] 2026-10-27 96f10d75-23d0-441f-94c7-ab87ca28d284.資源變數 增減不蘊含 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 類型,理由為 異途結果同類,以及僅憑起點與終點兩次 記錄 上的資源數值不能唯一判定 路徑。\n\n[作者裁決] 2026-10-27 結論六十七原有「資源增減是外界 記錄,b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 類型是研究者的歸類,兩者不同層」一段,來源列前提二;但前提二只說 96f10d75-23d0-441f-94c7-ab87ca28d284.狀態變數 與 96f10d75-23d0-441f-94c7-ab87ca28d284.資源變數 的歸類是研究者的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別,沒有說 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 類型是研究者的歸類,而且依前提二資源本身也是研究者的歸類,「外界 記錄 對研究者歸類」的對比不成立;依稽核意見刪去這一段,來源改為結論十之二與前提四,不蘊含由前半段已足以支持。論文第五章約束級第六條與英文同步刪去。\n\n[作者裁決] 2026-10-27 結論七十原稱 96f10d75-23d0-441f-94c7-ab87ca28d284.狀態變數 與 96f10d75-23d0-441f-94c7-ab87ca28d284.資源變數 的歸類「是 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.切法」,來源只有前提二;前提二只支持這個歸類是研究者的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別,由「是 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別」推不出上游意義的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.切法(定義反用),依稽核意見刪去。結論七十沒有被其他陳述引用;論文第五章約束級第六條末句與英文同步刪去。\n\n附註:約束級結論只靠四律、ae79e938-76e1-4bf9-b2ab-995c03e16c9e.驅動力不可確認、沿用的上游,以及本篇的聲明、假定與記帳約定(前提一至四、前提六、前提十、前提十一、前提十三、前提十五、前提二十一、前提二十三至前提二十五),不用經驗前提(前提五、前提八);條件級結論另用經驗前提,行文點明。條件級六項:單條 路徑 可行不推出可同時執行,用前提五;某 路徑 在某時窗被排除的名單,取決於資料;具體 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.個體 各 前件 是否具備,取決於資料,知識 由 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 推測;機會成本 的比較計算,用前提五與研究者指定的估值;b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 創造後一輪 前件、可能關閉某些 路徑,依經驗與具體資料;他人結果 記錄 作為這個人風險的有條件估計,依研究者指定的樣本與方法。【正文:句6733098696、句8735931803、句0398114660、句6272262040、句0472899785、句4827400126】\n\n[作者裁決] 2026-10-27 論文〇原說「結論分三類」,規則四卻標為記帳約定,概念表「不登記」又把記帳約定列為第四個分級,三處不一致。現統一為:結論只有約束級、條件級、研究問題三類;記帳約定是本篇的記法,不是結論,不列入分級(形式化中對應前提六、前提十五等記帳約定,本來就列為前提)。論文〇補一句並同步英文,概念表「不登記」同步改寫。\n\n附註:第三章(合成)與第六章(林肯)只作校準,不列入上述任何一級的推導來源。【正文:句7718022179、句0256358494】\n\n附註:以下三項研究問題只是待看的問題,不是已得結論:輸出傾向 跨 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.個體 共同形狀的穩定度與隨輪次變動、隨分類規則的消長;門檻 差異與終點差異之間有多少可由 路徑 被排除來解釋;自述與後續 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 在哪些條件下符合或偏離,偏離不推出「不理性」,吻合也不等於讀到 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.權重。【正文:句2233456455、句5022332731、句8352498901、句1497484032、句8324690026】\n\n## 例:林肯,從新薩勒姆到福特劇院(對應第六章)\n\n來源:論文第六章【正文:句3194952513】\n\n- 例:本例效準:本例的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.切法:37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.個體 是林肯一人;時段 1831 到 1865 年,按資料轉折分輪,每輪長短不等,是研究者的劃分;雇主、合夥人、選民、對手、刺殺者的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出,一律只記為 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 他的外部條件變化,不分析原因;本例的資料以正文所引史料為準(各輪的職業、地點、債務、執照取得與執業)【正文:句7734576882、句7396136173、句7998463210、句3978956049、句9044147475】\n\n[作者裁決] 2026-10-27 第六章林肯案例的具體史實(參選、落選、債務、職業、取得執照、遇刺與 fb0addca-42b6-4884-aa18-438c695747ab.死亡 等),以本例效準所指定的資料與其中引用的外部存根為來源,各例不再逐一重列;一般性的規則與結論只說明這些事實如何被 記錄 與解讀,不證明史實本身。\n- 例六十九:「開店」路徑 資料可見的 前件 是「能賒購」,具備;他實際開了店,可知該輪開店可行;它的終點 記錄 是債務,ext:3f133ee5-6685-4846-a0c1-f73221282d81.債務超過一千美元,另一來源為 ext:27762a9b-b116-4d9b-85f8-9d460f8f1a9d.債務約一千一百美元,並列;可行不等於結果好,也推不出判斷錯誤(從 結論一 + 門檻 的定義 + 結論二十六 + 本例效準 推出)【正文:句9175451217、句8073965597、句0973450457、句2313346842】\n- 例七十:「競選議員」路徑,他實際參選,可知該輪此 路徑 可行;落選是這條 路徑 的終點 記錄,不推出 路徑 不可行(從 結論一 + 本例效準 推出)【正文:句8598788332】\n- 例七十一:債務出現之後,可行集合 可能縮小;資料顯示他的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 變成多條小 路徑 並行:郵務、零工、測量,兩者的因果不推;前一輪的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出(賒購)可能改了後一輪的 前件;債務還在身上時 ext:dba4a173-9078-4414-9f8b-b990559379cd.一八三三年五月七日任命為郵務員,ext:27762a9b-b116-4d9b-85f8-9d460f8f1a9d.郵務員年收入約五十五美元,債務 ext:dba4a173-9078-4414-9f8b-b990559379cd.一八四八年還清債務(從 結論五之三 + 結論五之四 + 本例效準 推出)【正文:句9555346013、句2266080490、句8675914402、句2713935580】\n- 例七十二:測量員 路徑 的 前件 包含 知識;借書是研究者對一段 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 的歸類,知識 是否因此具備,只能從後來的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 推測(從 結論五之四 + 前提十五 + 知識 的定義 + 本例效準 推出)【正文:句6136862372、句0438176498】\n- 例七十三:律師 路徑 資料可見的 前件 有三項(研究者列出,不當作完整 門檻):書、知識、執照;依資料,書與執照是前面幾輪一件件取得的;知識 是否具備,只能由後來的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 推測;執照取得日,一來源為 ext:d14ee3a0-732d-43b1-a11e-ccef396f1a38.一八三六年九月九日取得執業執照,另一來源為 ext:661ea447-93a6-4239-a564-08d70d5c9da1.一八三六年九月十九日取得執業執照,並列(從 結論五之四 + 前提十五 + 本例效準 推出)【正文:句7998463210、句9885945136、句3978956049】\n- 步驟七十四:說他「為了借書才去當議員」,就是在說動機,而動機推不出(從 ae79e938-76e1-4bf9-b2ab-995c03e16c9e.驅動力不可確認 + 前提二十三 推出)【正文:句9386544441】\n- 例七十五:一八五八年他實際競選參議員,可知該輪競選可行;落選是這條 路徑 的終點 記錄,不推出 路徑 不可行;同一輪的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出,即 ext:661ea447-93a6-4239-a564-08d70d5c9da1.一八五八年七場辯論,帶來全國知名度,這是資料可見的一項有利條件的變化,是否為該 路徑 的 前件,資料不足以判定;一八六〇年他實際當選總統,可知競選總統在該輪可行;同一次落選,在一條 路徑 上是終點 記錄,在另一條 路徑 上可能是新 前件 的來源(從 結論一 + 結論五之四 + 本例效準 推出)【正文:句4037598873、句8703203594、句0047423751】\n- 例七十六:一八六五年判準取生理界線,ext:48a45b8a-e208-4d98-adb4-cf779f8912e3.一八六五年四月十五日去世 記為 96f10d75-23d0-441f-94c7-ab87ca28d284.判準退場;刺殺者的行動,即 ext:661ea447-93a6-4239-a564-08d70d5c9da1.一八六五年四月十四日遇刺,只記為 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 本 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.節點 的他人 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出(從 結論四十九 + 本例效準 推出)【正文:句7236748128、句2551304538】\n- 例七十七:「fb0addca-42b6-4884-aa18-438c695747ab.死亡」是研究者或後人標的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別,本章用的是 96f10d75-23d0-441f-94c7-ab87ca28d284.判準退場,並指定了判準,與結構上的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.退場 可以不同步(從 結論五十一 + fb0addca-42b6-4884-aa18-438c695747ab.死亡 的定義 + 本例效準 + 前提二十五 推出)【正文:句8919543497】\n- 例七十八:他不是壽終,並不蘊含前面各輪的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 有問題,也不蘊含存續 記錄「失敗」;96f10d75-23d0-441f-94c7-ab87ca28d284.判準退場 與他選對選錯沒有必然關係(從 結論六十 + 本例效準 推出)【正文:句5992185455】\n- 例七十九:資料顯示各階段的職業、地點、債務與執照的變化,與 前件 的有了和沒了對應;他的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 外界,外界回應之後,下一輪的 可行集合 有變化;例如律師 路徑:取得執照之前,至少執照這一項 前件 不具備,不可行;後來他實際執業,可知那時此 路徑 可行;所以取得執照前後的 可行集合 不同;因果不推(從 結論一 + 門檻 的定義 + 可行集合 的定義 + 本例效準 推出)【正文:句7998463210、句9885945136、句3978956049、句9044147475、句4750358942、句6036722154】\n\n附註:本章整節只作校準,不作推導來源;資料取自公開網頁,不是原始檔;來源對同一件事的歸因,標為來源的歸屬,不當成 記錄 讀出;第三章為合成例,本章為真實人物,兩者都不構成經驗支持。【正文:句9938248210、句0899083464、句4688899921】\n\n附註:推不出:他為什麼開店、為什麼學法律、為什麼競選;債務與落選對他的內在影響;各輪的收入細節;任何一次 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.權重;「坎坷」「誠實」之類的評價;說它「白費」或「鋪路」,都是後人的歸屬。【正文:句4750358942、句1157841319、句5074638183】\n\n附註:資料說明:只讀到公開網頁的摘要與館藏說明,沒有讀傳記全文或原始檔;日期與債額各來源有出入,已並列,各來源所述另建外部存根登記;一則燈片說明稱他的測量儀器、馬與馬鞍被警長拍賣抵債,屬二手說明,本章不採用。【正文:句0730063248、句0598069495、句2887643043】\n\n## 失效條件(對應第七章)\n\n來源:論文第七章【正文:句0275963447】\n\n[作者裁決] 2026-10-27 前提五 的否定條件:前提五 說生物人在同一輪不能同時在兩地,體力與注意力總量有限,所以某些 路徑 互相排斥;這是經驗前提,不由四律推出。它被現實違反時(例如發現生物人在同一輪能同時在兩地,或體力與注意力不受總量限制),來源鏈含它的條件級陳述失去來源:結論九之一(單條 路徑 可行不推出多條可同時執行),多條 路徑 是否互相排斥另成問題,這一點不再有根據;步驟九之二(與所選 路徑 互斥且 門檻 具備的 路徑 被排除、被排除的集合可以記下來),互斥不再有來源,被排除的集合可能為空;結論九之三與步驟三十九(機會成本 是研究者的比較計算、只算 門檻 具備而被排除的 路徑),失去比較對象;步驟四十(被排除 路徑 的預期終點是比較計算的陳述),失去對象;例三十八(本例全職受雇與全力擺攤互斥),失去依據。剩下的是:單條 路徑 的可行性檢查(結論一)照舊;結論九之三中「機會成本 不是 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.個體 的量」所依的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.黑箱律,以及步驟四十中「不以 機會成本 解釋動機」所依的 ae79e938-76e1-4bf9-b2ab-995c03e16c9e.驅動力不可確認,照舊;其餘約束級結論不經過前提五,不受影響。失去來源只表示推導鏈斷開,不表示這些陳述為假;名單由來源鏈機械判定,本則不以 前提五 為自己的來源。【正文:句2410915510】\n[作者裁決] 2026-10-27 前提八 的否定條件:前提八 說 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 可以創造後一輪的 前件(借書得 知識),一條 路徑 的 前件 可以是另一條 路徑 的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出,有些 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 可能關閉某些 路徑;這是經驗前提,不由四律推出。它不成立時(生物人做過的事從不替後面的 路徑 造出條件,也不關閉任何 路徑,前件 只隨外界變),來源鏈含它的陳述失去來源:結論五之四(一條 路徑 的可行性可能依賴前一輪另一條 路徑 的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出、有些 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 可能關閉 路徑)直接失去來源;第六章依賴它的校準敘述,來源也待核對:例七十一(賒購可能改了後一輪的 前件)、例七十二(借書可能使測量所需的 知識 具備)、例七十三(律師的三項 前件 是前面幾輪一件件取得的)、例七十五(落選那一輪的辯論可能是另一條 路徑 新 前件 的來源)。剩下的是:外界回應若進入 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.歷史、下一輪各 路徑 的 門檻 是否具備可能跟著變(結論二之一、結論五之三),照舊;第六章的史實本身不受影響,只是「哪一筆 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 造出了哪一項 前件」這層解讀的來源待核對。失去來源只表示推導鏈斷開,不表示這些陳述為假;名單由來源鏈機械判定,本則不以 前提八 為自己的來源。【正文:句6306995180】\n附註:前提一至四 是範圍設定,不是可被推翻的主張;改動它們是改變本篇的處理範圍,此時只靠它們(不經任何一律)得出的結論失去來源,換了範圍就不再適用【正文:句9240175345】\n附註:四律(37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.黑箱律、37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.流變律、37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.損耗律、37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.不可復原律)被推翻時,依賴它的約束級結論失去來源;fb0addca-42b6-4884-aa18-438c695747ab.被迫的賭注、fb0addca-42b6-4884-aa18-438c695747ab.未定牆、fb0addca-42b6-4884-aa18-438c695747ab.來路牆、b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.退場 與 fb0addca-42b6-4884-aa18-438c695747ab.死亡 之分、ae79e938-76e1-4bf9-b2ab-995c03e16c9e.驅動力不可確認 若被推翻,依賴它們的結論失去來源;失去來源只表示推導鏈斷開,不表示命題為假;它們是否成立由上游論文處理,本篇不另設失效條件【正文:句0979505441、句7363255184、句6647264910】\n附註:記錄、輸出傾向、門檻、異途結果同類 的定義若被改動,依賴這些定義的規則與小節(規則一至四、七、九,2.1、2.2、3.1、4.1、4.3),來源隨之待核對【正文:句2759936505】\n\n[作者裁決] 2026-10-27 失效條件依上游的寫法:本篇自己的前提(前提五、前提八)寫成「前提某 的否定條件」,原為附註,後依形-05 改為作者裁決,不另立結論、不以被否定的前提為自己的來源,名單由來源鏈重算(已核對:來源鏈含前提五的是結論九之一、步驟九之二、結論九之三、例三十八、步驟三十九、步驟四十;含前提八的是結論五之四及其下的例七十一、七十二、七十三、七十五);前提一至四是範圍設定,上游的律、牆、ae79e938-76e1-4bf9-b2ab-995c03e16c9e.驅動力不可確認 與概念定義的失效交上游處理,只留附註,不列結論名單,避免名單與正文脫節。8.14 的第二種形式針對的是否定本篇的前提;四律、ae79e938-76e1-4bf9-b2ab-995c03e16c9e.驅動力不可確認、fb0addca-42b6-4884-aa18-438c695747ab.被迫的賭注、fb0addca-42b6-4884-aa18-438c695747ab.未定牆、fb0addca-42b6-4884-aa18-438c695747ab.來路牆 都是上游的律或牆,不是本篇的前提(鐵律不列為前提),它們被推翻是上游的事,所以不套用第二種形式,作者裁決這幾項以附註處理。前提三、前提六、前提七、前提九不在論文第七章的失效條件中,不列。\n\n[作者裁決] 2026-10-27 依稽核意見(形-05),附註只用於擋住誤讀;原列為附註、實為記帳或做法規定者,改列前提十七至前提二十,標為限定條件,內容照原附註,不增不減:96f10d75-23d0-441f-94c7-ab87ca28d284.判準退場 是否可逆與只記有無時點(前提十七)、依賴器材等資料的記法(前提十八)、前件 是否具備的判定方式(前提十九)、投入的記法(前提二十);後三項稽核未點到,屬同型,一併改列。第三章搶劫的記帳寫法只用於該例,併入該例的本例效準,不另立前提。「以存續為條件選樣稱為 現存樣本條件化」是在陳述定義,定義只在概念表,刪去。失效條件段前提五、前提八的否定條件改以作者裁決寫明(稽核總表 8.14 允許),並寫實前提內容、失去來源的各條陳述及其斷處、剩下什麼。\n\n[作者裁決] 2026-10-27 論文〇原寫「本篇的對象是受前提五所述物理排斥約束的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.個體 」,把經驗前提拿來界定對象,與第七章把前提五當成可被現實違反的經驗主張互相矛盾。改為對象就是生物人,屬上游所稱的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.我;物理排斥是關於生物人的經驗前提(前提五),不界定對象,用到它的結論仍是條件級。前提五的主詞由「這樣的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.個體」改為「生物人」;第七章前提五的反例由「某物種可並行」改為針對生物人本身的反例,並把第七章前提五、前提八兩處的「失效」改為「失去來源」,與該章第一條一致。論文中英文同步,概念表 要能果三問 的定義同步去掉物理排斥那一句。\n\n[作者裁決] 2026-10-27 依跨-04 同型修正,論文第五章約束級第三條由「可能改變下一輪的 門檻 與 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.權重」改為「可能改變下一輪各 路徑 的 門檻 是否具備,以及 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.權重」,中英文同步;概念表「不登記」的「回饋」同步。形式化沒有引用這兩處,陳述不變。\n\n附註:與結論相反的觀察,只能歸於推導起點錯或推導錯;後者是勘誤,不是證偽。【正文:句8993261712】\n\n附註:第三章(合成)與第六章(林肯)皆為校準,不作推導來源,亦不構成經驗支持。【正文:句9253257533、句7868756803】\n\n附註:不是本篇的結論:家庭、網路結構、他人 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 的相容與 ae79e938-76e1-4bf9-b2ab-995c03e16c9e.失配、暴力與互利、子代 延續與網路存續,不在本篇處理;沒有取得的資料不寫成「不存在」。【正文:句2152025084、句2701228852、句4189456466】\n\n## 待決項\n\n無\n","paper_files":[{"filename":"生物人個體輸出傾向動力學.md","content":"---\nuuid: 81952268-47b1-4d8c-9605-270c42646693\nlast-modified: 2026-10-28T21:32:03\nauthor: 黃正宇 / Cheng Yu Huang\ncontact: mthree.tw@gmail.com\n---\n\n# 生物人個體輸出傾向動力學\n\n## 〇、定位與假定\n\n本篇的對象是生物人,屬上游所稱的[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19):能自述,也能對自己作[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)。從外部無法確認當事人是否被[鎖死](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c12);本篇假定所討論的[時刻](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c09),當事人不被[鎖死](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c12)。研究者與旁人也是生物人,同樣屬上游所稱的[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19)。本篇的主題是這樣的[個體](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c20)在輸入與[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)之間,能說什麼、不能說什麼。\n\n[個體](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c20)只有[三問](concepts.md#c01),稱為[要能果三問](concepts.md#c01):我要什麼,對應[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06)與[輸出傾向](concepts.md#c02),單憑[記錄](concepts.md#c06)讀不出[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06)的值,只能統計;我能不能做到,對應[門檻](concepts.md#c03);做完會變成什麼樣,對應回饋、終點、存續與生殖。第一問在[黑箱律](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c25)下能說的本來就有限,所以本篇命題偏少、偏重「不能推什麼」,這是[個體](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c20)層的性質,不是漏寫。\n\n本篇區分兩個層次:\n\n- **[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06)**:由[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)該[個體](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c20)的[歷史](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13)決定,每個[時刻](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c09)可能不同,單憑[記錄](concepts.md#c06)讀不出它的值。\n- **[記錄](concepts.md#c06)與[輸出傾向](concepts.md#c02)**:[記錄](concepts.md#c06)是研究者依[切法](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c23)登記下來的已發生之事,主要是時窗內實際發生的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28);[傾向](concepts.md#c02)是研究者在指定的[切法](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c23)、時窗、分類規則與[門檻](concepts.md#c03)條件下,對[記錄](concepts.md#c06)中反覆可見的形狀所作的歸納。\n\n傳統理論用慾望、需求、動機、效用、偏好、價值、目標解釋人,這些詞預設研究者知道人內在想什麼。依[黑箱律](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c25),本篇整組不使用,也不逐詞改寫。[個體](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c20)當然有判斷,只是研究者單憑[記錄](concepts.md#c06)讀不出[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06)的值,所以只能統計,統計所得不等於知道。本篇亦不把「成本」當作[個體](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c20)的量:什麼算付出,本身是研究者的[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18);本篇只記起點、終點與實際[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28),另附[門檻](concepts.md#c03)。研究者可以另作[機會成本](concepts.md#c05)的比較計算,地位見 3.4。\n\n結論分三類:約束級(只靠四律、[驅動力不可確認](../paper_ae79e938_76e1_4bf9_b2ab_995c03e16c9e/concepts.md#c03)、範圍設定)、條件級(另用經驗前提,行文點明)、研究問題。標為記帳約定者(例如規則四),是本篇的記法,不列入這三類。案例只作校準,不作推導來源。甲至癸皆為合成[個體](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c20)。\n\n---\n\n## 一、本篇使用的律與前提\n\n**承接。** [流變律](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c24)、[黑箱律](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c25)、[損耗律](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c26)、[不可復原律](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c28),以及[驅動力不可確認](../paper_ae79e938_76e1_4bf9_b2ab_995c03e16c9e/concepts.md#c03),沿用上游,不重證。[不可復原律](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c28)在本篇的直接用法是:已發生的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)進入[歷史](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13),只增不減。[被迫的賭注](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c11)(每個[決定](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c06)事先算不準、事後收不回、不能不作)、[未定牆](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c10)(統計只給[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06)估計,給不出禁止;由統計得到的禁止只是標明了的[經驗禁止](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c51))、[來路牆](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c08)(一個人拿不全自己過去的[歷史](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13)),以及[退場](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c43)與[死亡](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c22)之分,同樣沿用,不重證。\n\n**前提(範圍設定與經驗前提)。**\n\n- **前提一([切法](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c23))。** 研究者指定[個體](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c20)邊界、時窗、輪長與[記錄](concepts.md#c06)的維度,本篇並寫出是誰作這個劃分。\n- **前提二([狀態](../paper_96f10d75_23d0_441f_94c7_ab87ca28d284/concepts.md#c02)與[資源](../paper_96f10d75_23d0_441f_94c7_ab87ca28d284/concepts.md#c03)是研究者的歸類)。** 把某項[記錄](concepts.md#c06)[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)在[個體](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c20)上,記為[狀態](../paper_96f10d75_23d0_441f_94c7_ab87ca28d284/concepts.md#c02);[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)在外界上,記為[資源](../paper_96f10d75_23d0_441f_94c7_ab87ca28d284/concepts.md#c03)。這是研究者的[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18),沒有絕對定義。體力可記為任一欄,不同研究者可得不同歸類,彼此不矛盾。\n- **前提三([門檻](concepts.md#c03))。** 一條[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)[路徑](concepts.md#c07)成立所需的一組[前件](concepts.md#c08),稱為該[路徑](concepts.md#c07)的[門檻](concepts.md#c03),其中每一項稱為[前件](concepts.md#c08);[路徑](concepts.md#c07)是研究者劃出的一類[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)序列。[前件](concepts.md#c08)可以是身體素質、[知識](concepts.md#c13)、時間、位置、外界條件、工具與[資源](../paper_96f10d75_23d0_441f_94c7_ab87ca28d284/concepts.md#c03),記在哪一欄是研究者的判定,不先分類。\n- **前提四([記錄](concepts.md#c06)由研究者登記)。** [記錄](concepts.md#c06)是研究者依[切法](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c23)(前提一)對已發生之事所作的登記,記什麼由研究者依需要選取,不預先列舉。起點與終點之差只是兩次[記錄](concepts.md#c06)的差,不稱代價或損耗。某[路徑](concepts.md#c07)的[門檻](concepts.md#c03)是研究者就該[路徑](concepts.md#c07)所作的判斷,可標「未知」,隨[記錄](concepts.md#c06)一併附上,但不算[記錄](concepts.md#c06)。\n- **前提五(經驗前提)。** 生物人在同一輪不能同時在兩地,體力與注意力總量有限,所以某些[路徑](concepts.md#c07)互相排斥。這不由四律推出。\n\n**本篇推出的規則。**\n\n1. **[路徑](concepts.md#c07)排除。** [門檻](concepts.md#c03)中任一[前件](concepts.md#c08)不具備,該[路徑](concepts.md#c07)在**該輪**不可行,不推出之後不可行;全部具備,只表示可行,不表示會發生。[前件](concepts.md#c08)可能隨時間變動([流變律](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c24)):[歷史](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13)只往後追加,[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)[個體](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c20)的[歷史](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13)每一刻都不同,[個體](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c20)自己的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)也可能改變外界,所以這輪具備,不推出下一輪仍具備。(約束級)\n2. **[傾向](concepts.md#c02)與事件分離。** [傾向](concepts.md#c02)高不保證下一次發生;在不被[鎖死](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c12)的[時刻](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c09),發生一次推不出當時的[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06),也不能確認內部的驅動力。(約束級)\n3. **自述是[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)。** 「我要吃飯」是一筆[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28),有損,不能當作內部的完整讀數;與其他[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)同地位。自述的內容是當事人對自己作的[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18),它落出時,依[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)的定義就是一筆[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)。(約束級)\n4. **[前件](concepts.md#c08)的證據地位。** 身體與外部條件有可直接[記錄](concepts.md#c06)的物理改變,可直接檢查;[知識](concepts.md#c13)是某條[路徑](concepts.md#c07)[門檻](concepts.md#c03)中無法直接檢查的[前件](concepts.md#c08),隨[路徑](concepts.md#c07)而定(有廚師的[知識](concepts.md#c13),不推出有醫學的[知識](concepts.md#c13)),只能由該[路徑](concepts.md#c07)上的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)推測;本篇把它記為「由[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)推測」或「未知」,不預設具備。(記帳約定)\n5. **[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)改變後續。** [輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)若[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)外界,外界若有回應,回應凡是一次[寫入](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c29)或[坍塌](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c08)的結果,就進入[歷史](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13);沒有[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)某個[個體](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c20)者,不在[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)該[個體](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c20)的[歷史](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13)裡。[前件](concepts.md#c08)可能隨[歷史](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13)變動(規則一),外界的回應若[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)該[個體](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c20)而進了他的[歷史](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13),下一輪各[路徑](concepts.md#c07)的[門檻](concepts.md#c03)是否具備可能跟著變,[可行集合](concepts.md#c11)也就可能跟著變;[歷史](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13)多了一筆,[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06)也可能跟著變;這可能使之後的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)[記錄](concepts.md#c06)改變,但在有限的[記錄](concepts.md#c06)中不保證看得出來,也不由[記錄](concepts.md#c06)的變化讀出[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06)的值;所以[可行集合](concepts.md#c11)與[傾向](concepts.md#c02)可能隨輪次變動,不保證定常,也不保證是[學習](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c04)或改善。兩條回饋是兩件不同的事。[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)可以創造後一輪的[前件](concepts.md#c08)(借書得[知識](concepts.md#c13),這是依經驗);一條[路徑](concepts.md#c07)的[前件](concepts.md#c08)可以是另一條[路徑](concepts.md#c07)的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28),所以可行性可能有先後;有些[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)可能關閉某些[路徑](concepts.md#c07),是永久或暫時,依具體情形與資料而定,不由[不可復原律](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c28)推出:已發生的事收不回,不等於[路徑](concepts.md#c07)從此不可行,這與本輪暫時不可行也不同。([歷史](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13)只增不減、外界回應凡是[寫入](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c29)或[坍塌](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c08)的結果即進入[歷史](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13),屬約束級,來自[流變律](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c24)與[不可復原律](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c28);[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)創造[前件](concepts.md#c08)、可能關閉[路徑](concepts.md#c07),屬條件級,依經驗與具體資料)\n6. **單條可行不推出可同時執行。** 多條[路徑](concepts.md#c07)同時考慮時,它們是否互相排斥,不由各條的可行推出。(條件級,用前提五)\n7. **[異途結果同類](concepts.md#c04)只是外部歸類。** 不同[個體](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c20)走不同的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)歷程,在研究者指定的結果變數、時窗與容許區間下落入同一類,這個「同類」是研究者的歸類;它不是上游所稱的[趨同](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c37)([趨同](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c37)指在[耦合](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c36)之下,指定維度上[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)模式的距離縮短),不能由結果相同推出[路徑](concepts.md#c07)相同、內部問題相同或有共同驅動力,也不提供發生頻率。(約束級)\n8. **[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)在不被[鎖死](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c12)的[時刻](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c09),那一[回合](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c04)就是一個[決定](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c06),是一場[被迫的賭注](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c11);有所動作或「不動」,都是這一[回合](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c04)落出的結果;[鎖死](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c12)時結果已由約束唯一確定,不在此列。** 事先算不準,事後收不回,「不動」也是這一[回合](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c04)落出的結果之一。所以在不被[鎖死](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c12)時,旁人把單次[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)歸為「穩」或「險」,是旁人自己的[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18),不是當事人面對的風險讀數:風險高低是看的人對處境作的[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18),旁人從當事人那裡拿到的只是當事人的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)(包括自述);當事人怎麼看未來,是他自己作的[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)(對他自己的部分,是他的[自我印象](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c46)),至多是估計,不是[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06)的讀數;依[損耗律](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c26),他對自己的[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)本來就不完整,自述又有損;旁人對他的判斷,是旁人的[印象](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c45),旁人由此讀不全他的看法;結果好壞是某人判準下的歸類,不是結果本身的性質;同一個[決定](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c06)可以落出不同結果,所以單次結果推不出[決定](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c06)當時的[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06),若有人以結果本身評價[決定](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c06),那是他選的判準;統計可以描述已發生的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28);拿來說[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06)時,只給估計,單憑統計給不出禁止;統計看到的「沒有發生」只是觀察描述,經跨案例校準成必要條件後,才稱[經驗禁止](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c51),是標明了的禁止,可被新案例修改。本篇不單立風險為量。(約束級,沿用上游)\n9. **[三問](concepts.md#c01)前一問推不出後一問。** 我要,不推出我能;我能,不推出我會做;我做了,不推出結果是我要的。(約束級,[黑箱律](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c25)與[不可復原律](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c28);前提三、規則二)\n\n**本篇不採用的寫法。** 本篇不寫「為了」,因為動機從外部不能確認;不由[傾向](concepts.md#c02)穩定推出內部有驅動力;不使用目標;評斷好壞只用研究者指定的判準,並寫出是誰訂的,因為判準是某人的[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18);不把外顯統計當[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06)讀數,因為統計只給[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06)的估計;不把存續當最優;不替任何條件預設它屬[狀態](../paper_96f10d75_23d0_441f_94c7_ab87ca28d284/concepts.md#c02)或[資源](../paper_96f10d75_23d0_441f_94c7_ab87ca28d284/concepts.md#c03);不把終點差異反推為起點時的選擇差異;不由[資源](../paper_96f10d75_23d0_441f_94c7_ab87ca28d284/concepts.md#c03)增減推出[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)類型。\n\n---\n\n## 二、記錄與輸出傾向\n\n### 2.1 記錄\n\n[記錄](concepts.md#c06)是研究者在指定[切法](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c23)下,對已發生之事所作的登記,記什麼由研究者依需要選取,不預先列舉(前提四);常見的是時窗內實際[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28),以及時窗起點與終點的[狀態變數](../paper_96f10d75_23d0_441f_94c7_ab87ca28d284/concepts.md#c02)、[資源變數](../paper_96f10d75_23d0_441f_94c7_ab87ca28d284/concepts.md#c03),以及[判準退場](../paper_96f10d75_23d0_441f_94c7_ab87ca28d284/concepts.md#c09)是否發生:發生了什麼、何時、何地、幾次、間隔多久。只登記已發生的事;是研究者的選取,沒登記的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)仍在[歷史](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13)裡,可能繼續影響[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06)。自述登記為一筆[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28),與其他[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)同地位。\n\n### 2.2 傾向\n\n[輸出傾向](concepts.md#c02)是在四項條件下,對[記錄](concepts.md#c06)中**反覆可見的形狀**的歸納:[切法](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c23)、時窗、分類規則、[門檻](concepts.md#c03)條件。\n\n- 可跨[個體](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c20)、跨時窗比較。「大部分人類每隔一段時間進食」是這類經驗描述的一個例子,成立與否取決於指定時窗和分類下的[記錄](concepts.md#c06)。\n- 與[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06)的關係只能是**估計**:看到進食反覆發生,研究者可在指定的樣本與條件下,估計這類[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)的[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06)較重;這只是估計,不保證,讀不出[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06)的值。\n- 離不開[門檻](concepts.md#c03)條件。若進食[路徑](concepts.md#c07)的某項必要[前件](concepts.md#c08)(例如糧)不具備而沒進食,是[門檻](concepts.md#c03)不具備,推不出[傾向](concepts.md#c02)低;糧是否為必要[前件](concepts.md#c08),是研究者就該[路徑](concepts.md#c07)所作的判定。\n- **類別是研究者的[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)。** [傾向](concepts.md#c02)所用的類別,包括像「吃飯」這樣看似自然的詞,都是研究者的歸類,不是行為本身自帶的界線。把不同[個體](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c20)、不同人群的行為歸入同一類,是研究者的做法;「[傾向](concepts.md#c02)相同」是在研究者所訂的類別下說的,不推出他們做的是同一件事,或對它有相同的想法。若採用被觀察[個體](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c20)自己的詞,本篇寫明採用了誰的分類。更換分類規則,共同形狀可以有,也可以消失。\n- **[傾向](concepts.md#c02)相同不等於[趨同](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c37)。** [趨同](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c37)只有在指定的維度與距離下,才能說距離縮小或不縮小。\n\n### 2.3 三條不能逆推\n\n| 不能推 | 理由 |\n|---|---|\n| [傾向](concepts.md#c02)高 → 下一次一定發生 | [黑箱律](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c25):不被[鎖死](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c12)時只推得出[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06) |\n| 發生了 → 還原當時的[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06)或內部驅動力 | 不被[鎖死](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c12)時:一次發生推不出當時的[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06)(規則二);驅動力不能從外部確認([驅動力不可確認](../paper_ae79e938_76e1_4bf9_b2ab_995c03e16c9e/concepts.md#c03));若這筆[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)的內容是[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18),它也只是一次[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)的落點 |\n| [傾向](concepts.md#c02)穩定 → 內部有驅動力 | [驅動力不可確認](../paper_ae79e938_76e1_4bf9_b2ab_995c03e16c9e/concepts.md#c03);[傾向](concepts.md#c02)是[記錄](concepts.md#c06)的形狀 |\n\n### 2.4 變動與限制\n\n同樣的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28),今天與明天對同一[個體](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c20)的作用可能不同([流變律](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c24))。[歷史](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13)更新後[傾向](concepts.md#c02)可變,但變化不保證是[學習](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c04),更不保證是改善。研究者的觀察若[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)被觀察的[個體](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c20),就進入他的[歷史](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13),觀察不是透明的。\n\n### 2.5 決定與風險\n\n傳統理論用風險區分「十拿九穩」與「九死一生」。這個區分要求事先知道結果的分布,而依[被迫的賭注](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c11)([渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)在不被[鎖死](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c12)的[時刻](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c09)),當下的未來不可見,[個體](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c20)自己也算不準,他怎麼看那個未來,是他自己作的[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)(對他自己的部分,是他的[自我印象](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c46)),至多是估計,不是[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06)的讀數;依[損耗律](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c26),他對自己的[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)本來就不完整,自述又有損;旁人對他的判斷,是旁人的[印象](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c45),旁人由此讀不全他的看法。「風險高低」只是某個看的人對處境作的[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18):旁人拿得到的是自己的判斷,不是當事人面對的風險;當事人事後的說法也只是一筆[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)。當事人事後沒有完整的立足點評價[決定](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c06):依[來路牆](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c08),當初自己那段[歷史](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13)雖然仍在,卻拿不全,事後由研究者或當事人作的重現或評價,也是現在作的一次新的[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18),若落出,就是一筆新的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)。所以事後評價是一次新的看法,不是當時的讀數。所以本篇不單立風險:\n\n| 不能推 | 理由 |\n|---|---|\n| 單次[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) → 這個[決定](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c06)是穩或險 | 「風險高低」只是某個看的人對處境作的[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)。當事人那一刻怎麼看未來,是他自己作的[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)(對他自己的部分,是他的[自我印象](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c46)),至多是估計,不是[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06)的讀數;依[損耗律](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c26),他對自己的[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)本來就不完整,自述又有損;旁人對他的判斷,是旁人的[印象](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c45),旁人由此讀不全他的看法;當事人事後的說法也只是一筆[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)。旁人若作估計,那是他的估計 |\n| 事後結果好或壞 → 當時那個[決定](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c06)是對或錯 | 結果好壞是某人判準下的歸類(當事人的、旁人的、研究者指定的,三者可以不一致),不是結果本身的性質;例如同一場考試結果,對想轉行的人是好消息,對想升學的人是壞消息。單次結果只是一次落出:同一個[決定](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c06)可以落出別的結果,所以推不出[決定](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c06)當時的[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06);若有人以結果本身評價[決定](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c06),那是他選的判準 |\n| 他選了某[路徑](concepts.md#c07) → 他評估過風險,或偏好冒險、厭惡風險 | 選了某[路徑](concepts.md#c07)讀不出他怎麼看未來:那是他自己作的[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18),旁人從他那裡拿到的只是他的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28),自述也只是[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)([驅動力不可確認](../paper_ae79e938_76e1_4bf9_b2ab_995c03e16c9e/concepts.md#c03));亦可能別無可行[路徑](concepts.md#c07)([門檻](concepts.md#c03));與上面兩列同一主軸:旁人拿到的是自己的判斷,也不替他判斷風險 |\n| 別人在同類[路徑](concepts.md#c07)的結果[記錄](concepts.md#c06) → 這個人當時面對的風險 | 各人[自己的那一段](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c17)可能不同;那些[記錄](concepts.md#c06)不能直接當作這個人的風險讀數,若有人拿它作估計,那是他依某個樣本作的估計,不保證 |\n\n日常說的「風險高」,只是研究者的事後描述:在指定分類與樣本下,同類[路徑](concepts.md#c07)的結果[記錄](concepts.md#c06)分散。這個描述不歸給任何一次具體的[決定](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c06)。\n\n---\n\n## 三、例子:十個人,一個月,四輪\n\n**[切法](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c23)。** 十人(甲至癸),時窗一個月,分四輪,每輪約一週。結果分類「終點現金[記錄](concepts.md#c06)比起點多出一萬元」由研究者指定,只是研究者的[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18),不代表任何人想賺。五條[路徑](concepts.md#c07)、各[路徑](concepts.md#c07)的各項[前件](concepts.md#c08)、甲、乙、丙、己的各輪[記錄](concepts.md#c06)([3.3 表](concepts.md#c10))與人物皆為合成設定(含甲、己的現金增加金額相同、起點終點兩次[記錄](concepts.md#c06)只記現金總額),非實測。每輪走一遍:若有[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28),[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)若[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)外界,外界若有回應,回應若入史;再檢查[門檻](concepts.md#c03)。\n\n### 3.1 兩條回饋分開寫\n\n| 回饋 | 改變什麼 | 本篇的記法 |\n|---|---|---|\n| 對[門檻](concepts.md#c03) | [可行集合](concepts.md#c11):物理上能不能;回饋可能使它改變 | 這一輪不可行,不推出之後不可行;本篇記為「在該輪不可行」 |\n| 對[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06) | [歷史](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13)多了一筆,可能使[輸出傾向](concepts.md#c02)改變 | 有限的[記錄](concepts.md#c06)中不保證看得出來;本篇只記[記錄](concepts.md#c06)的變化,[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06)的值不由[記錄](concepts.md#c06)的變化讀出,不保證是[學習](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c04)或改善 |\n\n混在一起,會把「做不了」和「不[傾向](concepts.md#c02)做」搞混。\n\n### 3.2 五條路徑的門檻\n\n| [路徑](concepts.md#c07) | [門檻](concepts.md#c03)([前件](concepts.md#c08)清單) | 證據地位 |\n|---|---|---|\n| 受雇工作 | 有了雇主;有符合的技能([知識](concepts.md#c13));能在指定時段[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)工作地 | 技能屬[知識](concepts.md#c13),標「由[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)推測」或「未知」,其餘可直接檢查 |\n| 擺攤販售 | 有本錢或商品;有場地;有時間;知道怎麼賣 | [知識](concepts.md#c13)標「由[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)推測」 |\n| 自行種植販售 | 有田;有種子;耕種[知識](concepts.md#c13);作物成熟於時窗內,或手上已有可收成之物 | 見 [3.3](concepts.md#c10) 丙 |\n| 出售既有物品 | 有可出售之物;有了買家 | 可直接檢查 |\n| 搶劫 | 有可施力的手段(刀或足夠體力);有可[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)的對象與位置;雙方時段重疊;有執行的[知識](concepts.md#c13) | [知識](concepts.md#c13)標「未知」,其餘可直接檢查 |\n\n以上稱為[五條路徑門檻表](concepts.md#c12)。\n\n[前件](concepts.md#c08)歸[狀態](../paper_96f10d75_23d0_441f_94c7_ab87ca28d284/concepts.md#c02)或[資源](../paper_96f10d75_23d0_441f_94c7_ab87ca28d284/concepts.md#c03),一律不先分類,記帳時由研究者判定。各[路徑](concepts.md#c07)的[前件](concepts.md#c08)是否具備,是研究者依指定資料所作的判定;本篇寫出依據,依據不足者記為「未知」。「搶劫」是研究者對一段[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)序列的命名;本篇的[記錄](concepts.md#c06)寫可觀察的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)(持刀接近、要求、取走現金),另註研究者將其歸為搶劫、是誰歸的。\n\n### 3.3 四輪的記錄(甲、乙、丙、己為例)\n\n| 人 | 第一輪 | [輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)對外界的改變 | 第二輪起[門檻](concepts.md#c03)是否具備的變化 |\n|---|---|---|---|\n| 甲 | 住處近工作地、有技能([知識](concepts.md#c13),本例設定);受雇可行;無田,種植不可行;搶劫的[前件](concepts.md#c08)未見資料,標「未知」 | 受雇,[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)雇主與工作地;領得週薪 | 現金增加,「有本錢或商品」轉為具備;受雇仍可行 |\n| 乙 | 有小額本錢、有場地;擺攤可行;技能([知識](concepts.md#c13))未知 | 擺攤,[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)顧客;首週賣不出去 | 本錢用盡、也沒有商品,「有本錢或商品」不再具備;第二輪擺攤不可行;改出售既有物品([前件](concepts.md#c08)「有可出售之物、有了買家」未見資料,標「未知」;他實際賣出,可知該輪此[路徑](concepts.md#c07)可行) |\n| 丙 | 有田、有種子、有[知識](concepts.md#c13)(本例設定);成熟期超過時窗,單輪不含播種時種植不可行 | 播種(研究者對一段[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)的歸類) | 作物生長是外界的回應,第四輪前未成熟;時窗內收成這項[前件](concepts.md#c08)仍不具備 |\n| 己 | 有刀、體力足;搶劫的[前件](concepts.md#c08)除[知識](concepts.md#c13)(未知)外皆具備 | 持刀接近、取走現金(研究者另註歸為搶劫) | 現金增加;「可[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)的位置」可能因對方後續[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)而變,本篇只記為外部條件變化,不問原因 |\n\n讀法:\n\n1. 同一人各[路徑](concepts.md#c07)的[門檻](concepts.md#c03)是否具備,每輪可能不同:乙因第一輪的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)與回應,擺攤販售在第二輪不可行;甲的「有本錢或商品」轉為具備,擺攤販售可能轉為可行。\n2. 丙顯示:種植在「單輪不含播種」時被時間排除,但播種是研究者對一段[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)的歸類,可能改變後續外界;時窗拉長,排除名單可能改寫。\n3. 己與甲的現金增加金額相同時,單憑起點終點兩次[記錄](concepts.md#c06)上的現金總額,區分不出兩人走的是哪條[路徑](concepts.md#c07);能否區分,取決於各輪[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)的[記錄](concepts.md#c06)。\n\n### 3.4 多條路徑互相排斥\n\n依前提五,總量有限,所以某些[路徑](concepts.md#c07)互相排斥。本例把「全職受雇」與「全力擺攤」指定為各占滿一週,故在本例互斥;若改為兼職或部分時段,是否互斥取決於時間與位置有沒有重疊,不由前提五直接推出。也不能在兩處同時下手(直接來自不能同時在兩地)。所以每輪單條可行之後,它們是否互相排斥仍是另一個問題。(條件級)\n\n**[機會成本](concepts.md#c05)是研究者的比較計算。** 同一輪選了某條[路徑](concepts.md#c07),其他與它互相排斥、且[門檻](concepts.md#c03)具備的[路徑](concepts.md#c07)就被排除,這個被排除的集合可以記下來。研究者可以在自己指定的估值(例如現金、時間、存續機率)下,比較已走[路徑](concepts.md#c07)的終點與被排除[路徑](concepts.md#c07)的預期終點,這個比較稱為[機會成本](concepts.md#c05)。(條件級,用前提五)\n\n- 估值是研究者選的,換一把尺,結果可能不同。\n- 被排除[路徑](concepts.md#c07)沒有發生,其終點只能是估計;本篇寫出估計的依據(他人[記錄](concepts.md#c06)、同一人前後輪),沒有依據的,記為「未知」。\n- 只算[門檻](concepts.md#c03)具備而被排除的[路徑](concepts.md#c07)。[門檻](concepts.md#c03)不具備的屬不可行,不是放棄,不在[機會成本](concepts.md#c05)的比較之列。\n- 它不是[個體](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c20)的量,不進[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06),不用來解釋動機:估值是研究者的[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18),被排除的[路徑](concepts.md#c07)沒有發生、終點由研究者估計,而單憑[記錄](concepts.md#c06)讀不出[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06)的值([未定牆](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c10)),所以這個比較不是[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06)的讀數。「在此估值下,甲走受雇,被排除的擺攤預期約為某個數」是比較計算的陳述;「甲因為[機會成本](concepts.md#c05)小而選受雇」是在說動機,推不出。\n\n### 3.5 終點記錄與判讀\n\n- 終點只是最後一輪後的一次[記錄](concepts.md#c06),與起點之差不稱代價。\n- 終點差異不能直接讀成選擇差異:同起點的兩人,早期[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)得到不同回應,後來的[可行集合](concepts.md#c11)可能分岔([不可復原律](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c28))。\n- 沒賺到,不推出沒嘗試;「嘗試」是研究者對一段可觀察[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)的歸類,是研究者的[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18),有登記就可記。沒嘗試不是空白:這一輪裡,他不被[鎖死](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c12)的每一個[回合](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c04)都落出了結果(「不動」也是其中之一),只是其中沒有嘗試(規則八)。\n- **[異途結果同類](concepts.md#c04)。** 假設甲受雇、乙賣既有物品,兩人終點現金都多一萬元,若只用「終點現金多一萬元」分類,兩人同類;按時間、來源、[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)的對象分,則可能不同,是否不同取決於各項的實際[記錄](concepts.md#c06)。兩人不必自認在做同一件事(規則七)。\n\n### 3.6 傾向與門檻\n\n假設[記錄](concepts.md#c06)顯示十人中有四人,各自在每一輪都有受雇的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28);這是這四人各自的[傾向](concepts.md#c02),各附條件:[切法](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c23)為本例的十人四輪、時窗一月、分類規則為「受雇」的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)、[門檻](concepts.md#c03)條件為有了雇主、有符合的技能([知識](concepts.md#c13))、能在指定時段[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)工作地。「十人中四人」是研究者跨[個體](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c20)的計數,不是一個[傾向](concepts.md#c02)。另六人沒有,可能是某一輪某項[前件](concepts.md#c08)不具備,也可能[前件](concepts.md#c08)具備、[路徑](concepts.md#c07)可行而未發生;資料查不出的,本篇記為「未知」,不補想像。三人有搶劫[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28),不能讀成這三人搶劫的[傾向](concepts.md#c02)偏高,因為另外七人可能不具備[前件](concepts.md#c08)(例如若查證甲確實沒有可施力的手段),也可能[前件](concepts.md#c08)具備而未發生。\n\n### 3.7 本篇的邊界\n\n外界若是[自然環境](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c16)(天氣、作物生長),其回應屬本篇。外界若含他人,其回應(交出現金、反抗、報復)若實際[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)本[節點](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25),才記為[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)本[節點](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25)的他人[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28);雇主有沒有則是外部狀態,不是一次[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)。兩者本篇都只記為「外部條件的變化」,不分析原因。他人[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)之間的相容與[失配](../paper_ae79e938_76e1_4bf9_b2ab_995c03e16c9e/concepts.md#c08)、暴力與互利的分離、對被搶者存續的影響,不在本篇處理。\n\n### 3.8 這個例子不說的與使用限制\n\n誰勤勞、誰理性、誰為了什麼、哪條路划算、誰應該怎麼選。有人持刀而未搶,不推出他克制;有人搶了,不推出他缺錢。研究者手上只有各輪的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)、[門檻](concepts.md#c03)、起點、終點。\n\n「一個月多一萬元」是指定分類。換成一年,或換成維持存續所需,被排除的名單與各輪回饋可能不同。所以本例的結論離不開它的時窗、輪長與分類。\n\n---\n\n## 四、存續與生殖\n\n兩者都是研究者指定判準之後的事實檢查,不是[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06)的後果,也不是[個體](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c20)的目的。本篇不知道也不需要知道[個體](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c20)的身體條件怎樣。\n\n### 4.0 個體局部解\n\n指定[個體](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c20)在所屬[推演輪](../paper_96f10d75_23d0_441f_94c7_ab87ca28d284/concepts.md#c07)的下一刻[狀態](../paper_96f10d75_23d0_441f_94c7_ab87ca28d284/concepts.md#c02)、[資源](../paper_96f10d75_23d0_441f_94c7_ab87ca28d284/concepts.md#c03),以及[判準退場](../paper_96f10d75_23d0_441f_94c7_ab87ca28d284/concepts.md#c09)的相關[記錄](concepts.md#c06),若該[個體](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c20)已被列為指定[切法](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c23)的[節點](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25)、這些欄位已記入該輪的[解](../paper_96f10d75_23d0_441f_94c7_ab87ca28d284/concepts.md#c05),則是上游[解](../paper_96f10d75_23d0_441f_94c7_ab87ca28d284/concepts.md#c05)的單[節點](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25)部分。以上稱為[個體局部解](concepts.md#c09)。本篇只記這些欄位。投入(付出了什麼)不在這些欄位裡,也不由[解](../paper_96f10d75_23d0_441f_94c7_ab87ca28d284/concepts.md#c05)自動得出:什麼算付出,是研究者的[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)(成本不是量,見〇)。[判準退場](../paper_96f10d75_23d0_441f_94c7_ab87ca28d284/concepts.md#c09)的有無與時點,是[解](../paper_96f10d75_23d0_441f_94c7_ab87ca28d284/concepts.md#c05)的一個維度;存續(4.1)就是讀這個維度,不是另一套資料。上游的[解](../paper_96f10d75_23d0_441f_94c7_ab87ca28d284/concepts.md#c05)沒有預設生殖這個維度,生殖是本篇依另訂的事件判準所作的判定(4.2)。\n\n### 4.1 存續\n\n- **判準。** 什麼算[判準退場](../paper_96f10d75_23d0_441f_94c7_ab87ca28d284/concepts.md#c09)(例如生理界線),由研究者指定;判準是訂它的人的[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)。判準是定義。\n- **事實。** 某一輪是否發生[判準退場](../paper_96f10d75_23d0_441f_94c7_ab87ca28d284/concepts.md#c09),由實際事件決定。事實經研究者登記下來,才是[記錄](concepts.md#c06)。\n- **只記有無與時點,不推原因。** 本篇所取的[退場判準](../paper_96f10d75_23d0_441f_94c7_ab87ca28d284/concepts.md#c04)只看實際事件的有無與時點,不含原因條件;研究者若另訂含原因的判準,不在本篇處理。他是否依賴器材、是否被他人照顧、身體如何,若有登記,只見於[門檻](concepts.md#c03)與各輪[記錄](concepts.md#c06)裡,沒有登記的標「未知」,都不改變判定方式。\n- **三層不互推。** 上游的[退場](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c43)是結構上的事(不再是[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)),不需要誰認定;[死亡](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c22)是某個人替它標上「已[退場](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c43)」的一次[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18);[判準退場](../paper_96f10d75_23d0_441f_94c7_ab87ca28d284/concepts.md#c09)是研究者指定判準後的事實檢查。三者可以對不上:已[退場](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c43)而無人標[死亡](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c22)、被標[死亡](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c22)而仍是[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)、符合判準而結構上並非[退場](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c43)。[退場](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c43)之後可以再[進場](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c44),但[判準退場](../paper_96f10d75_23d0_441f_94c7_ab87ca28d284/concepts.md#c09)是否可逆隨所訂判準而定(例如判準取離職,可能可逆;判準取生理界線,可能不可逆),所以只記有無與時點,作為記帳約定,不預先當成永久終點。\n- **不是總帳。** 這些[記錄](concepts.md#c06)只是研究者在指定[切法](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c23)下對已發生之事的一次選取,不是對該[個體](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c20)的完整結算;當事人若對自己作[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18),那[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)也不完整,所以不是對一生的結算;結算還要再作一次[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18),把一整段看作某個結果,而這次[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)本身又進入[歷史](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13),不在它自己的材料裡。存續與生殖的[記錄](concepts.md#c06)本身不帶評價一生的判準,不評價一生;評價或比較不同[個體](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c20),用的是某人的判準,[記錄](concepts.md#c06)自己不提供。\n\n### 4.2 生殖\n\n- **記為[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)。** 在本篇[切法](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c23)下(前提一),生殖事件記為該[個體](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c20)的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)。這是記帳約定,不是本體定位;換成以配偶雙方為單位的[切法](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c23),同一事件可記成兩個[節點](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25)[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)的共同[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10),兩種記法不矛盾。\n- **累積不可逆。** 生殖事件是[個體](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c20)[歷史](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13)中已發生的事件序列,只增不減。八十歲者今年沒有生殖,已有的[子女](concepts.md#c15)不消失,也不因他[判準退場](../paper_96f10d75_23d0_441f_94c7_ab87ca28d284/concepts.md#c09)而取消。某一輪「有或沒有」只是對序列的切片。(約束級)\n- **[記錄](concepts.md#c06)欄位。** 時間(含當時年齡)、地理(事件位置、雙方位置)、對方(是誰、當時是否同住;「配偶」記下是誰作的歸屬)、結果([子代](concepts.md#c15)是否出生、之後與當事人有無[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10))、起點、終點;當輪的[門檻](concepts.md#c03)另附,不算[記錄](concepts.md#c06)欄位。\n- **實際生殖不由別的[記錄](concepts.md#c06)代替。** [傾向](concepts.md#c02)高不推出下一次發生(規則二),自述是一筆[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)(規則三),「嘗試」是研究者對一段[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)的歸類;兩者研究者若有登記,各另記為[記錄](concepts.md#c06),都不是這筆生殖事件本身;生殖事件本身記為[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28),所以是否實際生殖,只看指定時窗與事件判準下,這筆事件有沒有發生。(約束級)\n- **邊界。** 本篇只記[個體](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c20)這一側。對方的[歷史](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13)、配對如何形成、[子代](concepts.md#c15)的存活與再生殖,不在本篇處理。[子代](concepts.md#c15)是新[進場](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c44)的[節點](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25),前史與親代重疊,不推出繼承親代的[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06)或[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)。封閉人口(無外部人口補充、靠內生生殖跨代延續)下,成員存續、實際生殖、[子代](concepts.md#c15)延續三項結果的判定,[個體](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c20)只提供前兩項的[個體](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c20)側[記錄](concepts.md#c06);三項合起來是否成立、何謂足夠,不在本篇處理。\n\n### 4.3 不蘊涵清單\n\n| 不能推 | 理由 |\n|---|---|\n| 進食[傾向](concepts.md#c02)穩定 → 不進食必然[判準退場](../paper_96f10d75_23d0_441f_94c7_ab87ca28d284/concepts.md#c09)(判準取生理界線時) | [傾向](concepts.md#c02)是[記錄](concepts.md#c06)的形狀,不是必要條件 |\n| 沒進食而存續 → 該[傾向](concepts.md#c02)的歸納不成立 | 可能存在別的[路徑](concepts.md#c07)或外部條件;單一個案本身說不了歸納成不成立,成不成立取決於可比條件下的整體[記錄](concepts.md#c06) |\n| 存續 → 他的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)較好或最優 | 存續只是判準下的事實,不比較[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) |\n| [判準退場](../paper_96f10d75_23d0_441f_94c7_ab87ca28d284/concepts.md#c09) → 他選錯、或缺少什麼 | [判準退場](../paper_96f10d75_23d0_441f_94c7_ab87ca28d284/concepts.md#c09)與想要什麼無必然關係;與[資源](../paper_96f10d75_23d0_441f_94c7_ab87ca28d284/concepts.md#c03)的關係隨所訂判準而定(例如判準訂為破產,則兩者的關係由判準定義建立) |\n| 有生殖 → 他想生 | [驅動力不可確認](../paper_ae79e938_76e1_4bf9_b2ab_995c03e16c9e/concepts.md#c03) |\n| 沒有生殖 → 他不想生、或缺少什麼 | 同上;亦可能[門檻](concepts.md#c03)不具備 |\n| 一輪的存續 → 之後也存續;一輪有生殖 → 下一輪也有生殖 | 單憑這一輪的[記錄](concepts.md#c06)推不出下一輪是否發生:[記錄](concepts.md#c06)只是研究者的選取,沒登記的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)仍在[歷史](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13)裡,可能繼續影響[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06);另外,依[黑箱律](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c25),不被[鎖死](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c12)時,下一輪的完整結果也不由這一輪唯一推出;已發生的生殖事件不取消(見 4.2),這裡說的是下一輪是否再發生 |\n| 存續與生殖互推 | 本篇不由一個推另一個:兩個判定各有判準與[記錄](concepts.md#c06) |\n\n### 4.4 現存樣本條件化\n\n以「存續」為條件選樣,稱為[現存樣本條件化](concepts.md#c14)。以「存續」為條件選樣時,樣本裡的是尚未[判準退場](../paper_96f10d75_23d0_441f_94c7_ab87ca28d284/concepts.md#c09)的[個體](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c20)。是否[判準退場](../paper_96f10d75_23d0_441f_94c7_ab87ca28d284/concepts.md#c09),只取決於研究者所訂判準與實際事件(4.1),與他[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)的好壞無必然關係(4.3),所以存續者的表現不足以直接用來評價好壞;以「存續」為條件選樣,樣本邊界由此而來。[判準退場](../paper_96f10d75_23d0_441f_94c7_ab87ca28d284/concepts.md#c09)者留下的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28),凡已[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)別人或留在[信號容器](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c26)中者,仍在[歷史](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13)裡;沒[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)任何人者,研究者可能拿不到;所以推不出消失者不可研究。這是研究者的樣本邊界,不是外界有選擇目的(「篩選」只作比喻)。\n\n---\n\n## 五、結論分級\n\n**約束級**(只靠四律、[驅動力不可確認](../paper_ae79e938_76e1_4bf9_b2ab_995c03e16c9e/concepts.md#c03)、前提一至四、本篇的聲明、假定與記帳約定,及沿用上游,不用經驗前提;聲明與假定有六項:當事人是生物人、生殖事件記為[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)、[子代](concepts.md#c15)是新[進場](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c44)的[節點](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25)、本篇所取的[退場判準](../paper_96f10d75_23d0_441f_94c7_ab87ca28d284/concepts.md#c04)不含原因條件、所討論的時刻當事人不被[鎖死](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c12)、研究者與旁人也屬上游所稱的[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19))\n\n1. [門檻](concepts.md#c03)任一[前件](concepts.md#c08)不具備,該[路徑](concepts.md#c07)在該輪不可行;具備只表示可行。\n2. [傾向](concepts.md#c02)與事件分離;自述是有損的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)。\n3. [輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)若[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)外界,外界若有回應,回應若進入[歷史](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13),可能改變下一輪各[路徑](concepts.md#c07)的[門檻](concepts.md#c03)是否具備,以及[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06);兩條回饋分開。\n4. 生殖與已發生的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)只增不減;終點差異推不出起點選擇差異。\n5. 存續只記有無與時點,不推原因、不推最優。\n6. [資源](../paper_96f10d75_23d0_441f_94c7_ab87ca28d284/concepts.md#c03)增減所屬的類別不蘊涵[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)類型:在研究者指定的結果分類下,同類的[資源](../paper_96f10d75_23d0_441f_94c7_ab87ca28d284/concepts.md#c03)變化可由不同[路徑](concepts.md#c07)達成([異途結果同類](concepts.md#c04)),所以僅憑起點與終點兩次[記錄](concepts.md#c06)上的[資源](../paper_96f10d75_23d0_441f_94c7_ab87ca28d284/concepts.md#c03)變化落在哪一類,不能唯一判定是哪一條[路徑](concepts.md#c07)(前提四)。\n7. [異途結果同類](concepts.md#c04)只是外部歸類,不推出[路徑](concepts.md#c07)相同或共同驅動力,不提供發生頻率,不等於[趨同](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c37)。\n8. 實際生殖只看事件有無,不由[傾向](concepts.md#c02)、自述、嘗試代替。\n9. [渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)在不被[鎖死](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c12)的[時刻](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c09),每一個[回合](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c04)是一個[決定](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c06)、一場[被迫的賭注](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c11):旁人把單次[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)歸為穩或險,是旁人自己的[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18),不是風險讀數,結果好壞是某人判準下的歸類;單次結果推不出[決定](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c06)當時的[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06),以結果本身評價[決定](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c06),是某人選的判準;不單立風險為量。\n10. [三問](concepts.md#c01)前一問推不出後一問:要推不出能,能推不出會做,做了推不出結果是所要的。\n\n**條件級**\n\n| 結論 | 依據 |\n|---|---|\n| 單條[路徑](concepts.md#c07)可行不推出可同時執行 | 前提五(物理限制) |\n| 某[路徑](concepts.md#c07)在某時窗被排除的名單 | 研究者指定的時窗、輪長與分類;由資料決定 |\n| 具體[個體](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c20)各[前件](concepts.md#c08)是否具備 | 由資料決定;[知識](concepts.md#c13)由[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)推測 |\n| [機會成本](concepts.md#c05)的比較計算 | 前提五;研究者指定的估值與估計方法 |\n| [輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)創造後一輪的[前件](concepts.md#c08)、可能關閉某些[路徑](concepts.md#c07) | 依經驗與具體資料;永久或暫時由資料決定,不由[不可復原律](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c28)推出 |\n| 他人的結果[記錄](concepts.md#c06)作為這個人風險的有條件估計 | 研究者指定的樣本與估計方法;是那位研究者的估計,不保證 |\n\n**案例的地位。** 第三章(合成)與第六章(林肯)只作校準,不列入上述任何一級的推導來源。\n\n**研究問題**\n\n1. 在可比條件下,[輸出傾向](concepts.md#c02)的跨[個體](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c20)共同形狀有多穩定,隨輪次如何變動?同一批行為在不同分類規則下,哪些共同形狀穩定,哪些隨分類消失?\n2. [門檻](concepts.md#c03)差異與終點差異之間,有多少可由[路徑](concepts.md#c07)排除解釋?\n3. 在可明示物理條件、可觀察到當事人自述的成本或後果判斷、並追蹤實際[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)與結果的情境,外顯自述與後續[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)在哪些條件下符合或偏離?偏離可能來自觀察缺漏、不可得的[候選](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c18)[路徑](concepts.md#c07)、[資源](../paper_96f10d75_23d0_441f_94c7_ab87ca28d284/concepts.md#c03)條件不同或[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)資訊不同,所以偏離不推出「不理性」;吻合也不等於讀到[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06);未見自述的,本篇記為「未知」。\n\n---\n\n## 六、案例(校準):林肯,從新薩勒姆到福特劇院\n\n本章整節只作校準,不作推導來源。資料取自公開網頁,不是原始檔;來源對同一件事的歸因,標為來源的歸屬,不當成[記錄](concepts.md#c06)讀出。第三章為合成例,本章為真實人物,兩者都不構成經驗支持。\n\n**經過。** 1831 年,二十二歲的林肯搭平底船沿桑加蒙河南下,船卡在鎮上的磨坊水壩,他因此第一次到了新薩勒姆,那時他在伊利諾州才待了一年多。雇他運貨的〔Offutt〕在當地開店,不到一年就垮了,林肯留在鎮上。\n\n1832 年他第一次競選州議會,落選。同年他與〔Berry〕合夥,以賒購的方式接下雜貨店;1833 年又賒購了對面一間店的存貨與店面。店最後垮了,〔Berry〕去世,[超過一千美元的債務](../ext/ext_3f133ee5_6685_4846_a0c1_f73221282d81/concepts.md#c01)留給了林肯(另一來源寫[約 1,100 美元](../ext/ext_27762a9b_b116_4d9b_85f8_9d460f8f1a9d/concepts.md#c01),並列)。這筆債他[直到 1848 年任聯邦眾議員時才還清](../ext/ext_dba4a173_9078_4414_9f8b_b990559379cd/concepts.md#c01)。\n\n債務還在身上時,他[在 1833 年 5 月 7 日被任命為郵務員](../ext/ext_dba4a173_9078_4414_9f8b_b990559379cd/concepts.md#c02),並以劈製圍欄木條、收割、幫工、看店補貼收入;郵務員的[年收入約五十五美元](../ext/ext_27762a9b_b116_4d9b_85f8_9d460f8f1a9d/concepts.md#c02)。年底他向縣測量員借書自學,做起副測量員。\n\n1834 年與 1836 年,他當選伊利諾州議會議員。競選中他認識了同為競選人的〔Stuart〕,〔Stuart〕借他法律書,他自己研讀,沒有進法學院。1836 年 3 月 24 日法院證明他品行良好,[9 月 9 日他取得全州法院的執業執照](../ext/ext_d14ee3a0_732d_43b1_a11e_ccef396f1a38/concepts.md#c01)(另一來源記為[9 月 19 日](../ext/ext_661ea447_93a6_4239_a564_08d70d5c9da1/concepts.md#c01),並列)。1837 年春他搬到春田市,成為〔Stuart〕的初級合夥人,之後先後與〔Logan〕、〔Herndon〕合夥。\n\n1846 年他當選聯邦眾議員,任期 1847 到 1849 年。1854 年競選參議員未成;1858 年共和黨提名他與〔Douglas〕競選,兩人[辯論七場](../ext/ext_661ea447_93a6_4239_a564_08d70d5c9da1/concepts.md#c02),他落選,但辯論帶來全國知名度。1860 年 11 月他當選總統。[1865 年 4 月 14 日,他在福特劇院被〔Booth〕開槍擊中](../ext/ext_661ea447_93a6_4239_a564_08d70d5c9da1/concepts.md#c03),[次日清晨去世,享年五十六歲](../ext/ext_48a45b8a_e208_4d98_adb4_cf779f8912e3/concepts.md#c01)。\n\n**帶入框架。** 先選[切法](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c23):[個體](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c20)是林肯一人;時段 1831 到 1865 年,按資料轉折分幾輪,每輪長短不等,是研究者的劃分。雇主、合夥人、選民、對手、刺殺者的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28),一律只記為[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)他的外部條件變化,不分析原因。\n\n先看**開店**。「開店」這條[路徑](concepts.md#c07),資料可見的[前件](concepts.md#c08)是「能賒購」,具備;他實際開了店,可知該輪開店可行。它的終點[記錄](concepts.md#c06)是債務。可行不等於結果好,也推不出判斷錯誤。再看**競選**。「競選議員」這條[路徑](concepts.md#c07),他實際參選,可知該輪此[路徑](concepts.md#c07)可行;**落選**是這條[路徑](concepts.md#c07)的終點[記錄](concepts.md#c06),不推出[路徑](concepts.md#c07)不可行,也不說明原因。\n\n再看**債務之後**。債務出現之後,[可行集合](concepts.md#c11)可能縮小;資料顯示他的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)變成多條小[路徑](concepts.md#c07)並行:郵務、零工、測量,兩者的因果本篇不推。這是對[門檻](concepts.md#c03)的回饋的一例:前一輪的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)(賒購)可能改了後一輪的[前件](concepts.md#c08)。測量員這條[路徑](concepts.md#c07)的[前件](concepts.md#c08)包含[知識](concepts.md#c13);「借書」是研究者對一段[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)的歸類,[知識](concepts.md#c13)是否因此具備,只能從後來的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)(他做起副測量員)推測。這顯示[前件](concepts.md#c08)可以由前一輪的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)創造,但這是依經驗與資料,不是推出。他到底學會了多少,不能直接讀。\n\n**律師這條[路徑](concepts.md#c07)**,資料中可見的[前件](concepts.md#c08)有三項(研究者列出,不當作完整[門檻](concepts.md#c03)):書(外部[資源](../paper_96f10d75_23d0_441f_94c7_ab87ca28d284/concepts.md#c03))、[知識](concepts.md#c13)(由讀書累積,只能由後來的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)推測)、執照(外部條件)。依資料,書與執照是前面幾輪一件件取得的;[知識](concepts.md#c13)是否具備,只能由後來的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)推測。當選議員使他認識了〔Stuart〕、拿到了書,但說他「為了借書才去當議員」,就是在說動機,而動機推不出。\n\n**1858 年**,他實際競選參議員,可知該輪競選可行;落選是這條[路徑](concepts.md#c07)的終點[記錄](concepts.md#c06),不推出[路徑](concepts.md#c07)不可行;同一輪的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)(辯論)帶來「全國知名度」,這是資料可見的一項有利條件的變化,是否為該[路徑](concepts.md#c07)的[前件](concepts.md#c08),資料不足以判定;1860 年他實際當選總統,可知競選總統在該輪可行。同一次落選,在一條[路徑](concepts.md#c07)上是終點[記錄](concepts.md#c06),在另一條[路徑](concepts.md#c07)上可能是新[前件](concepts.md#c08)的來源。說它「白費」或「鋪路」,都是後人的歸屬。\n\n最後是 **1865 年**。判準取生理界線,4 月 15 日記為[判準退場](../paper_96f10d75_23d0_441f_94c7_ab87ca28d284/concepts.md#c09)。刺殺者的行動只記為[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)本[節點](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25)的他人[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28),兩人有無[專屬歷史](../paper_ae79e938_76e1_4bf9_b2ab_995c03e16c9e/concepts.md#c05)、行動屬相容或[失配](../paper_ae79e938_76e1_4bf9_b2ab_995c03e16c9e/concepts.md#c08),不在本篇處理。「[死亡](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c22)」是研究者或後人標的[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18),本章用的是[判準退場](../paper_96f10d75_23d0_441f_94c7_ab87ca28d284/concepts.md#c09),並指定了判準,與結構上的[退場](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c43)可以不同步。他不是壽終,不推出前面各輪的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)有問題,也不推出存續[記錄](concepts.md#c06)「失敗」;[判準退場](../paper_96f10d75_23d0_441f_94c7_ab87ca28d284/concepts.md#c09)與他選對選錯沒有必然關係(見 4.3 不蘊涵清單)。\n\n**資料顯示的與推不出的。** 資料顯示:各階段的職業、地點、債務與執照的變化,與[前件](concepts.md#c08)的有了和沒了對應;他的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)外界,外界回應之後,下一輪的[可行集合](concepts.md#c11)有變化,因果不推。例如律師這條[路徑](concepts.md#c07):取得執照之前,至少執照這一項[前件](concepts.md#c08)不具備,不可行;後來他實際執業,可知那時此[路徑](concepts.md#c07)可行;所以取得執照前後的[可行集合](concepts.md#c11)不同。推不出:他為什麼開店、為什麼學法律、為什麼競選;債務與落選對他的內在影響;各輪的收入細節(只讀到零星數字);任何一次[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)的[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06);「坎坷」「誠實」之類的評價(是後人的歸屬)。\n\n**資料說明。** 只讀到公開網頁的摘要與館藏說明,沒有讀傳記全文或原始檔。日期與債額各來源有出入,已並列;各來源所述另建外部存根登記。一則燈片說明稱他的測量儀器、馬與馬鞍被警長拍賣抵債,屬二手說明,本章不採用。\n\n---\n\n## 七、失效條件\n\n**案例。** 第三章(合成)與第六章(林肯)皆為校準,不作推導來源,亦不構成經驗支持。\n\n**失效條件。**\n\n- 四律被推翻時,依賴它的約束級結論失去來源;失去來源只表示推導鏈斷開,不表示命題為假。\n- [被迫的賭注](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c11)、[未定牆](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c10)、[來路牆](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c08)若被推翻,來源鏈含它們的結論失去來源:規則八、2.2 對[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06)的估計、2.5、3.4 [機會成本](concepts.md#c05)的比較、3.5 讀法中「沒嘗試不是空白」、第五章約束級第九條,以及第六章相應的校準敘述;[退場](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c43)與[死亡](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c22)之分若被推翻,4.1 的相應一條失去來源;其餘不受影響。\n- [驅動力不可確認](../paper_ae79e938_76e1_4bf9_b2ab_995c03e16c9e/concepts.md#c03)若被推翻,[傾向](concepts.md#c02)穩定、有無生殖、[機會成本](concepts.md#c05)等不推出內部驅動力或動機的結論失去來源;其餘不受影響。\n- 前提一至四是範圍設定,不是可被推翻的主張;改動它們是改變本篇的處理範圍,此時只靠它們(不經任何一律)得出的結論失去來源,換了範圍就不再適用。\n- 前提五被現實違反(例如發現生物人在同一輪能同時在兩地,或體力與注意力不受總量限制),只有用到它的條件級結論失去來源(規則六與 3.4 所說多條[路徑](concepts.md#c07)是否互相排斥另成問題、[機會成本](concepts.md#c05)的比較計算)。\n- 「[記錄](concepts.md#c06)」「[輸出傾向](concepts.md#c02)」「[門檻](concepts.md#c03)」「[異途結果同類](concepts.md#c04)」的定義若被改動,依賴這些定義的規則與小節(規則一至四、七、九,2.1、2.2、3.1、4.1、4.3),來源隨之待核對。\n- 「[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)創造後一輪[前件](concepts.md#c08)、可能關閉某些[路徑](concepts.md#c07)」的經驗若不成立,只有規則五的條件級部分失去來源,第六章中依賴它的校準敘述,來源也待核對。\n- 與結論相反的觀察,只能歸於推導起點錯或推導錯;後者是勘誤,不是證偽。\n\n**不是本篇的結論。** 家庭、網路結構、他人[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)的相容與[失配](../paper_ae79e938_76e1_4bf9_b2ab_995c03e16c9e/concepts.md#c08)、暴力與互利、[子代](concepts.md#c15)延續與網路存續,不在本篇處理。沒有取得的資料不寫成「不存在」。\n\n---\n\n## 附錄:推導\n\n```text\n前提一至前提五 如第一章。\n推導一 門檻是一組前件;任一前件不具備,路徑在該輪不可行(前提三 + 前提四;約束級)\n推導二 全部前件具備,只表示可行;不被鎖死時下一刻只推出權重(黑箱律;約束級)\n推導三 傾向高不推出下一次發生;傾向是記錄的形狀,不是對內部的讀數(黑箱律 + 驅動力不可確認;約束級)\n推導四 自述是一筆輸出,有損,不是成因或內部的完整描述(損耗律 + 黑箱律 + 記錄的定義 + 輸出的定義;約束級)\n推導五 輸出若到達外界,外界若有回應,回應若入史,歷史參與下一輪的權重並可能改變前件;前者可能改變可行集合,後者可能改變權重,不保證看得出來、不保證是學習(流變律 + 不可復原律 + 歷史的定義;約束級)。輸出創造前件、可能關閉路徑屬條件級(依經驗與資料)\n推導六 終點差異推不出起點選擇差異:早期回應不同可能使可行集合分岔(不可復原律 + 推導五;約束級)\n推導七 生殖事件與其他已發生輸出只增不減;某輪無事件不取消既有事件(不可復原律;約束級)\n推導八 存續在本篇只依研究者所訂、只看實際事件有無與時點的判準判定,不看原因(前提一 + 判準與事實的區分 + 本篇對判準的限定;約束級)\n推導九 單條路徑可行不推出可同時執行;被排除且門檻具備的路徑可作研究者的比較計算,不進權重(前提五;條件級)\n推導十 異途結果同類只是外部歸類,不推出路徑相同或趨同,也不提供發生頻率(黑箱律 + 前提一 + 異途結果同類的定義;約束級)\n推導十一 渦在不被鎖死的時刻,輸出事先算不準、事後收不回、「不動」也是落出之一;故旁人把單次輸出歸為穩或險,是旁人自己的分別,結果好壞是某人判準下的歸類;同一個決定可以落出不同結果,單次結果推不出決定當時的權重,以結果本身評價決定,是某人選的判準(被迫的賭注 + 來路牆 + 黑箱律 + 不可復原律 + 決定的定義;約束級)\n推導十二 要推不出能,能推不出會做,做了推不出結果是所要的(黑箱律 + 不可復原律 + 推導一 + 推導三;約束級)\n附註 狀態與資源是研究者的歸類,門檻不依賴這個分類。\n```\n\n"},{"filename":"Dynamics of Output Tendency in the Biological Human Individual.md","content":"---\nuuid: 81952268-47b1-4d8c-9605-270c42646693\nlast-modified: 2026-10-28T21:32:03\nauthor: 黃正宇 / Cheng Yu Huang\ncontact: mthree.tw@gmail.com\n---\n\n# Dynamics of Output Tendency in the Biological Human Individual\n\n## 0. Position and Assumptions\n\nThe object of this paper is the biological human, a [Self](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19) in the upstream sense: one who can report on itself and can make a [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) of itself. Whether the party is [locked in](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c12) cannot be confirmed from outside; this paper assumes that, at the [moments](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c09) discussed, the party is not [locked in](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c12). The researcher and onlookers are also biological humans, and likewise each a [Self](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19) in the upstream sense. Its subject is what can and cannot be said about such an [individual](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c20) between input and [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28).\n\nThe [individual](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c20) has only three [questions](concepts.md#c01), called the [Want-Can-Outcome Questions](concepts.md#c01): what I want, which corresponds to [weight](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06) and [output tendency](concepts.md#c02); the value of the [weight](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06) cannot be read off from the [records](concepts.md#c06) alone, and it can only be treated statistically; whether I can do it, which corresponds to the [threshold](concepts.md#c03); and what I become after doing it, which corresponds to feedback, end point, survival and reproduction. What can be said about the first question under the [Law of the Black Box](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c25) is limited by nature, so this paper has few propositions and puts weight on \"what cannot be inferred\"; this is a property of the [individual](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c20) level, not an omission.\n\nThis paper distinguishes two levels:\n\n- **[Weight](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06)**: determined by the [history](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13) that has [arrived at](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) the [individual](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c20), possibly different at every [moment](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c09), and its value cannot be read off from the [records](concepts.md#c06) alone.\n- **[Records](concepts.md#c06) and [output tendency](concepts.md#c02)**: [records](concepts.md#c06) are what the researcher registers, under the [cut](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c23), of what has happened, mainly the [outputs](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) that actually occurred within the time window; a [tendency](concepts.md#c02) is the researcher's generalization, under a specified [cut](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c23), time window, classification rule, and [threshold](concepts.md#c03) conditions, of the shapes that recur in the [records](concepts.md#c06).\n\nTraditional theories explain people with desire, need, motive, utility, preference, value, and goal; these words presuppose that the researcher knows what a person thinks inside. By the [Law of the Black Box](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c25), this paper does not use the whole group, and does not rewrite them word by word. The [individual](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c20) certainly has judgments; it is only that the researcher cannot read off the value of the [weight](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06) from the [records](concepts.md#c06) alone, so the researcher can only work statistically, and what statistics yield is not knowing. Nor does this paper treat \"cost\" as a quantity of the [individual](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c20): what counts as a sacrifice is itself the researcher's [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18); this paper records only the starting point, the end point, and the actual [outputs](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28), and attaches the [threshold](concepts.md#c03) separately. The researcher may separately carry out a comparison calculation of [opportunity cost](concepts.md#c05), whose status is given in 3.4.\n\nConclusions fall into three classes: the constraint level (relying only on the four laws, the [Unconfirmability of Drives](../paper_ae79e938_76e1_4bf9_b2ab_995c03e16c9e/concepts.md#c03), and the scope settings), the conditional level (which also uses empirical premises, stated explicitly in the text), and research questions. Items marked as bookkeeping conventions (for example Rule 4) are this paper's way of recording and are not counted among these three classes. Cases serve only for calibration and are not sources of derivation. Persons A through J are all synthetic [individuals](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c20).\n\n---\n\n## 1. The Laws and Premises Used in This Paper\n\n**Inheritance.** The [Law of Flux](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c24), the [Law of the Black Box](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c25), the [Law of Attrition](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c26), the [Law of Non-Restoration](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c28), and the [Unconfirmability of Drives](../paper_ae79e938_76e1_4bf9_b2ab_995c03e16c9e/concepts.md#c03) are carried over from upstream and not proved again. The direct use of the [Law of Non-Restoration](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c28) in this paper is this: an [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) that has occurred enters the [history](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13), only increasing and never decreasing. The [Forced Wager](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c11) (every [decision](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c06) cannot be calculated beforehand, cannot be taken back afterwards, and cannot be avoided), the [Wall of the Undetermined](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c10) (statistics give only an estimate of [weight](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06) and cannot give prohibitions; a prohibition obtained from statistics is only an [empirical prohibition](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c51), marked as such), the [Wall of Provenance](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c08) (a person cannot hold the whole of his own past [history](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13)), and the distinction between [exit](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c43) and [death](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c22) are likewise carried over and not proved again.\n\n**Premises (scope settings and empirical premises).**\n\n- **Premise 1 ([Cut](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c23)).** The researcher specifies the [individual](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c20) boundary, the time window, the round length, and the dimensions of the [records](concepts.md#c06), and this paper states who made this division.\n- **Premise 2 (a [state](../paper_96f10d75_23d0_441f_94c7_ab87ca28d284/concepts.md#c02) and a [resource](../paper_96f10d75_23d0_441f_94c7_ab87ca28d284/concepts.md#c03) are the researcher's classification).** When a [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) places an item of [record](concepts.md#c06) on the [individual](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c20), it is recorded as a [state](../paper_96f10d75_23d0_441f_94c7_ab87ca28d284/concepts.md#c02); when a [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) places it on the outside world, it is recorded as a [resource](../paper_96f10d75_23d0_441f_94c7_ab87ca28d284/concepts.md#c03). This is the researcher's [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) and has no absolute definition. Physical strength may be recorded in either column; different researchers may obtain different classifications, and they do not contradict one another.\n- **Premise 3 ([Threshold](concepts.md#c03)).** The set of [antecedents](concepts.md#c08) required for an [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) [path](concepts.md#c07) to hold is called the [threshold](concepts.md#c03) of that [path](concepts.md#c07), and each item in it is called an [antecedent](concepts.md#c08); a [path](concepts.md#c07) is a class of [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) sequences drawn by the researcher. An [antecedent](concepts.md#c08) may be bodily quality, [knowledge](concepts.md#c13), time, position, external conditions, tools, and [resources](../paper_96f10d75_23d0_441f_94c7_ab87ca28d284/concepts.md#c03); which column it is recorded under is the researcher's determination and is not classified in advance.\n- **Premise 4 ([records](concepts.md#c06) are the researcher's registration).** A [record](concepts.md#c06) is the registration the researcher makes, under the [cut](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c23) (Premise 1), of what has happened; what is registered is selected by the researcher according to need and is not listed in advance. The difference between start and end is only the difference between two [records](concepts.md#c06), and is not called cost or loss. The [threshold](concepts.md#c03) of a [path](concepts.md#c07) is the researcher's judgment about that [path](concepts.md#c07), may be marked unknown, and is attached together with the [records](concepts.md#c06), but is not itself a [record](concepts.md#c06).\n- **Premise 5 (empirical premise).** A biological human cannot be in two places at once in the same round, and his strength and attention are limited in total, so some [paths](concepts.md#c07) exclude one another. This is not derived from the four laws.\n\n**Rules derived in this paper.**\n\n1. **[Path](concepts.md#c07) exclusion.** If any [antecedent](concepts.md#c08) in the [threshold](concepts.md#c03) is not met, the [path](concepts.md#c07) is infeasible in **that round**, which does not imply it is infeasible afterwards; if all are met, it only means the [path](concepts.md#c07) is feasible, not that it will occur. [Antecedents](concepts.md#c08) may change over time ([Law of Flux](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c24)): the [history](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13) only grows forward, the [history](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13) that [arrives at](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) the [individual](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c20) differs at every moment, and the [individual](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c20)'s own [outputs](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) may also change the outside world, so being met in this round does not imply being met in the next. (Constraint level)\n2. **[Tendency](concepts.md#c02) is separate from events.** A high [tendency](concepts.md#c02) does not guarantee that the next occurrence will happen; at a [moment](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c09) when not [locked in](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c12), one occurrence does not reveal the [weight](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06) at the time, nor can it confirm the internal drive. (Constraint level)\n3. **A self-report is an [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28).** \"I want to eat\" is one [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28), lossy, and cannot be taken as a complete reading of the inside; it has the same standing as other outputs. The content of a self-report is a [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) the party makes of himself; when it comes out, it is, by the definition of [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28), one [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28). (Constraint level)\n4. **Evidential status of [antecedents](concepts.md#c08).** Bodily and external conditions involve physical changes that can be directly [recorded](concepts.md#c06), and can be checked directly; [knowledge](concepts.md#c13) is the [antecedents](concepts.md#c08) in the [threshold](concepts.md#c03) of a [path](concepts.md#c07) that cannot be checked directly, varying with the [path](concepts.md#c07) (having a cook's [knowledge](concepts.md#c13) does not imply having medical [knowledge](concepts.md#c13)), and can only be inferred from the [outputs](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) on that [path](concepts.md#c07); this paper records it as \"inferred from [outputs](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)\" or \"unknown\" and does not assume it is met. (Bookkeeping convention)\n5. **An [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) changes what follows.** If an [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) [arrives at](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) the outside world, if the outside world responds, then wherever the response is a [writing](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c29) or the result of a [collapse](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c08), it enters the [history](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13); an output that does not [arrive at](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) a given [individual](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c20) is not in the [history](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13) that arrives at that [individual](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c20). [Antecedents](concepts.md#c08) may vary with the [history](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13) (Rule 1); if the outside world's response [arrives at](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) the [individual](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c20) and has entered his [history](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13), whether each [path](concepts.md#c07)'s [threshold](concepts.md#c03) is met in the next round may change accordingly, and so may the [feasible set](concepts.md#c11); the [history](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13) has gained one more entry, and the [weight](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06) may also change accordingly; this may change the [records](concepts.md#c06) of later [outputs](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28), but within finite [records](concepts.md#c06) it is not guaranteed to be visible, and the value of the [weight](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06) is not read off from changes in the [records](concepts.md#c06); so the [feasible set](concepts.md#c11) and the [tendency](concepts.md#c02) may vary from round to round and are not guaranteed to be stationary, nor to be [learning](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c04) or improvement. The two feedbacks are two different matters. An [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) can create the [antecedents](concepts.md#c08) of a later round (borrowing a book gives [knowledge](concepts.md#c13); this rests on experience); the [antecedent](concepts.md#c08) of one [path](concepts.md#c07) can be the [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) of another [path](concepts.md#c07), so feasibility may have an order of precedence; some [outputs](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) may close certain [paths](concepts.md#c07); whether permanently or temporarily depends on the specific circumstances and the data, and is not inferred from the [Law of Non-Restoration](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c28): that what has happened cannot be taken back does not mean the [path](concepts.md#c07) is infeasible from then on, which also differs from being temporarily infeasible in this round. (That the [history](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13) only grows and that the outside response, wherever it is a [writing](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c29) or the result of a [collapse](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c08), enters it is constraint level, from the [Law of Flux](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c24) and the [Law of Non-Restoration](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c28); [outputs](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) creating [antecedents](concepts.md#c08) and possibly closing [paths](concepts.md#c07) are conditional level, depending on experience and the specific data)\n6. **Feasibility of each single [path](concepts.md#c07) does not imply that they can be carried out at the same time.** When several [paths](concepts.md#c07) are considered together, whether they exclude one another is not inferred from the feasibility of each. (Conditional level, using Premise 5)\n7. **[Same Outcome from Different Paths](concepts.md#c04) is only an external classification.** Different [individuals](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c20) follow different [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) histories and fall into the same class under the outcome variable, time window, and tolerance interval specified by the researcher; this \"same class\" is the researcher's classification; it is not what upstream calls [convergence](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c37) ([convergence](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c37) means, under [coupling](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c36), the distance between [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) patterns shrinking on a specified dimension), and from the sameness of outcomes one cannot infer sameness of [path](concepts.md#c07), sameness of internal problem, or a common driving force, nor does it supply any frequency of occurrence. (Constraint level)\n8. **At the [moments](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c09) when a [Wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16) is not [locked in](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c12), that [round](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c04) is a [decision](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c06), a [Forced Wager](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c11); acting or \"not moving\" are both results that fall out in this [round](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c04); when [locked in](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c12), the result is already uniquely determined by constraints and is not covered here.** It cannot be calculated beforehand and cannot be taken back afterwards, and \"not moving\" is also one of the results that fall out in this [round](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c04). So when not [locked in](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c12), when an onlooker classes a single [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) as \"safe\" or \"risky\", this is the onlooker's own [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18), not a reading of the risk the party faced: how high the risk is is a [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) made by the one looking, and the onlooker gets from the party only the party's [outputs](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) (including his self-report); how the party sees the future is a [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) he himself makes (where it concerns himself, it is his [self-impression](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c46)); it is at most an estimate, not a reading of the [weight](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06); by the [Law of Attrition](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c26), his [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) of himself is incomplete to begin with, and the self-report is lossy as well; an onlooker's judgment of him is the onlooker's [impression](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c45), from which the onlooker cannot read his view in full; whether a result is good or bad is a classification under someone's criterion, not a property of the result itself; the same [decision](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c06) can land on different results, so a single result does not reveal the [weight](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06) at the time of the [decision](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c06), and if someone evaluates a [decision](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c06) by its result itself, that is a criterion he has chosen; statistics can describe the [outputs](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) that have occurred; when used to speak of [weight](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06), they give only an estimate, and statistics alone cannot give a prohibition; a \"did not occur\" seen in statistics is only an observational description, and only after it is calibrated across cases into a necessary condition is it called an [empirical prohibition](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c51), a prohibition marked as such, which can be revised by new cases. This paper does not set up risk as a quantity of its own. (Constraint level, carried over from upstream)\n9. **For the [questions](concepts.md#c01), an earlier one does not imply the next.** That I want does not imply that I can; that I can does not imply that I will do it; that I did it does not imply that the result is what I wanted. (Constraint level, the [Law of the Black Box](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c25) and the [Law of Non-Restoration](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c28); Premise 3, Rule 2)\n\n**Usages this paper does not adopt.** This paper does not write \"in order to\", because motives cannot be confirmed from outside; it does not infer an internal driving force from a stable [tendency](concepts.md#c02); it does not use goals; when it judges good or bad, it uses only a criterion specified by the researcher and states who set it, because a criterion is someone's [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18); it does not treat externally displayed statistics as a reading of [weight](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06), because statistics give only an estimate of [weight](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06); it does not treat survival as optimal; it does not presuppose, for any condition, that it is a [state](../paper_96f10d75_23d0_441f_94c7_ab87ca28d284/concepts.md#c02) or a [resource](../paper_96f10d75_23d0_441f_94c7_ab87ca28d284/concepts.md#c03); it does not infer from differences in end points a difference in choices at the start; it does not infer the type of [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) from an increase or decrease in [resources](../paper_96f10d75_23d0_441f_94c7_ab87ca28d284/concepts.md#c03).\n\n---\n\n## 2. Records and Output Tendency\n\n### 2.1 Records\n\n[Records](concepts.md#c06) are the researcher's registrations, under the specified [cut](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c23), of what has happened, selected by the researcher according to need and not listed in advance (Premise 4); commonly the [outputs](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) that actually occurred within the time window, the [state variables](../paper_96f10d75_23d0_441f_94c7_ab87ca28d284/concepts.md#c02) and [resource variables](../paper_96f10d75_23d0_441f_94c7_ab87ca28d284/concepts.md#c03) at the start and end of the window, and whether [criterion exit](../paper_96f10d75_23d0_441f_94c7_ab87ca28d284/concepts.md#c09) occurred: what happened, when, where, how many times, and at what intervals. Only what has happened is registered; the registration is the researcher's selection, and [outputs](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) that are not registered remain in the [history](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13) and may continue to affect the [weight](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06). A self-report is registered as one [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28), with the same standing as the other [outputs](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28).\n\n### 2.2 Tendency\n\nAn [output tendency](concepts.md#c02) is a generalization, under four conditions, of the **recurring shape** in the [records](concepts.md#c06): the [cut](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c23), the time window, the classification rule, and the [threshold](concepts.md#c03) conditions.\n\n- It can be compared across [individuals](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c20) and across time windows. \"Most humans eat at intervals\" is one example of such an empirical description; whether it holds depends on the [records](concepts.md#c06) under the specified time window and classification.\n- Its relation to [weight](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06) can only be an **estimate**: seeing eating recur, the researcher may, under a specified sample and conditions, estimate that the [weight](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06) of this kind of [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) is heavier; this is only an estimate, not guaranteed, and the value of the [weight](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06) cannot be read off.\n- It cannot be separated from the [threshold](concepts.md#c03) conditions. If a necessary [antecedent](concepts.md#c08) of an eating [path](concepts.md#c07) (for example, food) is not met and one does not eat, the [threshold](concepts.md#c03) is not met, and it does not follow that the [tendency](concepts.md#c02) is low; whether food is a necessary [antecedent](concepts.md#c08) is the researcher's determination for that [path](concepts.md#c07).\n- **Categories are the researcher's [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18).** The categories a [tendency](concepts.md#c02) uses, including words that seem natural such as \"eating\", are all the researcher's classification, and are not boundaries carried by the behavior itself. Grouping the behavior of different [individuals](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c20) and different populations into one class is something the researcher does; \"the same [tendency](concepts.md#c02)\" is said under the categories the researcher has set, and does not imply that they are doing the same thing or have the same thoughts about it. If the observed [individual](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c20)'s own words are adopted, this paper states whose classification it has adopted. If the classification rule is changed, a common shape may appear or disappear.\n- **The same [tendency](concepts.md#c02) is not [convergence](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c37).** For [convergence](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c37), one can say that the distance shrinks or does not shrink only under a specified dimension and distance.\n\n### 2.3 Three Things That Cannot Be Inferred in Reverse\n\n| Cannot infer | Reason |\n|---|---|\n| A high [tendency](concepts.md#c02) → the next occurrence surely happens | [Law of the Black Box](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c25): when not [locked in](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c12), only the [weight](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06) can be inferred |\n| It occurred → reconstruct the [weight](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06) at the time or the internal drive | When not [locked in](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c12): one occurrence does not reveal the [weight](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06) at the time (Rule 2); the drive cannot be confirmed from outside ([Unconfirmability of Drives](../paper_ae79e938_76e1_4bf9_b2ab_995c03e16c9e/concepts.md#c03)); if the content of this [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) is a [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18), it is likewise only the landing point of one [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) |\n| A stable [tendency](concepts.md#c02) → an internal driving force exists | [Unconfirmability of Drives](../paper_ae79e938_76e1_4bf9_b2ab_995c03e16c9e/concepts.md#c03); a [tendency](concepts.md#c02) is the shape of the [records](concepts.md#c06) |\n\n### 2.4 Variation and Limits\n\nThe same [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) may act differently on the same [individual](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c20) today and tomorrow ([Law of Flux](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c24)). After the [history](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13) is updated the [tendency](concepts.md#c02) may change, but the change is not guaranteed to be [learning](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c04), still less an improvement. If the researcher's observation [arrives at](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) the observed [individual](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c20), it enters his [history](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13); observation is not transparent.\n\n### 2.5 Decision and Risk\n\nTraditional theory uses risk to distinguish \"near-certain success\" from \"nearly certain death\". This distinction requires knowing the distribution of results beforehand, but according to the [Forced Wager](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c11) (a [Wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16) at a [moment](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c09) when it is not [locked in](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c12)), the future at the moment of acting cannot be seen, the [individual](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c20) itself cannot calculate it accurately, and how he sees that future is a [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) he himself makes (where it concerns himself, it is his [self-impression](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c46)); it is at most an estimate, not a reading of the [weight](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06); by the [Law of Attrition](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c26), his [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) of himself is incomplete to begin with, and the self-report is lossy as well; an onlooker's judgment of him is the onlooker's [impression](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c45), from which the onlooker cannot read his view in full. \"How high the risk is\" is only a [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) made by whoever is looking at the situation: what an onlooker gets is their own judgment, not the risk the party faced; the party's own account afterwards is also just one [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28). Afterwards the person has no complete vantage point from which to evaluate the [decision](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c06): by the [Wall of Provenance](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c08), although that stretch of [history](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13) is still there, it cannot be held in full, and an after-the-fact reproduction or evaluation made by the researcher or the party is also a new [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) made now, which, if it comes out, is a new [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28). So an after-the-fact evaluation is a new view, not a reading from that time. So this paper does not set up risk as a separate quantity:\n\n| Cannot infer | Reason |\n|---|---|\n| A single [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) → this [decision](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c06) was safe or risky | \"How high the risk is\" is only a [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) made by whoever is looking at the situation. How the party saw the future at that moment is a [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) he himself made (where it concerns himself, it is his [self-impression](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c46)); it is at most an estimate, not a reading of the [weight](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06); by the [Law of Attrition](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c26), his [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) of himself is incomplete to begin with, and the self-report is lossy as well; an onlooker's judgment of him is the onlooker's [impression](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c45), from which the onlooker cannot read his view in full; the party's later account is also just one [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28). If an onlooker makes an estimate, it is his estimate |\n| A good or bad result afterwards → that [decision](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c06) was right or wrong at the time | Whether a result is good or bad is a classification under someone's criterion (the party's, an onlooker's, or one specified by the researcher; the three can disagree), not a property of the result itself; for example, the same exam result is good news to someone who wants to change careers and bad news to someone who wants to continue studying. A single result is only one landing: the same [decision](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c06) could have landed on another result, so it does not reveal the [weight](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06) at the time of the [decision](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c06); if someone evaluates a [decision](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c06) by its result itself, that is a criterion he has chosen |\n| He chose a [path](concepts.md#c07) → he assessed the risk, or prefers risk-taking or is risk-averse | Choosing a [path](concepts.md#c07) does not reveal how he sees the future: that is a [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) he himself makes, and the onlooker gets from him only his [outputs](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28), and a self-report is also just an [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) ([Unconfirmability of Drives](../paper_ae79e938_76e1_4bf9_b2ab_995c03e16c9e/concepts.md#c03)); he may also have had no other feasible [path](concepts.md#c07) ([threshold](concepts.md#c03)); on the same axis as the two rows above: an onlooker gets only their own judgment, and does not judge the risk for him |\n| Other people's result [records](concepts.md#c06) on similar [paths](concepts.md#c07) → the risk this person faced at the time | Each person's [own segment](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c17) may differ; those records cannot be taken directly as a reading of this person's risk, and if someone uses them to make an estimate, it is his estimate, resting on some sample, and not guaranteed |\n\nThe everyday \"high risk\" is only the researcher's after-the-fact description: under the specified classification and sample, the result [records](concepts.md#c06) of similar [paths](concepts.md#c07) are scattered. This description is not attributed to any particular [decision](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c06).\n\n---\n\n## 3. Example: Ten People, One Month, Four Rounds\n\n**[Cut](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c23).** Ten people (A through J), a time window of one month, divided into four rounds of about one week each. The outcome classification \"end-point cash [record](concepts.md#c06) is ten thousand more than at the start\" is specified by the researcher and is only the researcher's [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18); it does not mean that anyone wants to earn. The five [paths](concepts.md#c07), the [antecedents](concepts.md#c08) of each [path](concepts.md#c07), the round-by-round [records](concepts.md#c06) of A, B, C and F (the [Four-Round Record Table](concepts.md#c10)), and the persons are all synthetic settings (including that the cash increases of A and F are equal and that the start and end [records](concepts.md#c06) record only total cash), not measurements. In each round we go through one cycle: if there is an [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28), and if it [arrives](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at the outside world, and if the outside world responds, and if the response enters history; then the [threshold](concepts.md#c03) is rechecked.\n\n### 3.1 The Two Feedbacks Written Separately\n\n| Feedback | What it changes | How this paper records it |\n|---|---|---|\n| To the [threshold](concepts.md#c03) | The [feasible set](concepts.md#c11): whether it is physically possible; feedback may change it | Being infeasible in this round does not imply being infeasible later; this paper records \"infeasible in that round\" |\n| To the [weight](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06) | The [history](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13) has gained one more entry, which may change the [output tendency](concepts.md#c02) | Not guaranteed to be visible in finite [records](concepts.md#c06); this paper records only the change in the [records](concepts.md#c06); the [weight](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06) value is not read off from changes in the [records](concepts.md#c06); it is not guaranteed to be [learning](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c04) or improvement |\n\nMixing them together confuses \"unable to do\" with \"no [tendency](concepts.md#c02) to do it\".\n\n### 3.2 The Thresholds of the Five Paths\n\n| [Path](concepts.md#c07) | [Threshold](concepts.md#c03) (list of [antecedents](concepts.md#c08)) | Evidential status |\n|---|---|---|\n| Employment | An employer has appeared; a matching skill ([knowledge](concepts.md#c13)); able to [arrive at](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) the workplace at the specified time | The skill belongs to [knowledge](concepts.md#c13) and is marked \"inferred from [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)\" or \"unknown\"; the rest can be checked directly |\n| Running a stall | Capital or goods; a site; time; knowing how to sell | [Knowledge](concepts.md#c13) is marked \"inferred from [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)\" |\n| Growing and selling crops | A field; seeds; farming [knowledge](concepts.md#c13); a crop that ripens within the time window, or something already in hand that can be harvested | See the [Four-Round Record Table](concepts.md#c10), C |\n| Selling existing goods | Something to sell; a buyer has appeared | Can be checked directly |\n| Robbery | A means of exerting force (a knife or sufficient strength); a target and a position that can be [arrived at](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10); overlapping time periods of both sides; [knowledge](concepts.md#c13) of how to carry it out | [Knowledge](concepts.md#c13) is marked \"unknown\"; the rest can be checked directly |\n\nThe above is called the [Five-Path Threshold Table](concepts.md#c12).\n\nWhether an [antecedent](concepts.md#c08) is classed as a [state](../paper_96f10d75_23d0_441f_94c7_ab87ca28d284/concepts.md#c02) or a [resource](../paper_96f10d75_23d0_441f_94c7_ab87ca28d284/concepts.md#c03) is never decided in advance; the researcher determines it when the books are kept. Whether each [path](concepts.md#c07)'s [antecedents](concepts.md#c08) are met is a judgment the researcher makes from the specified data; this paper states the basis, and records \"unknown\" where the basis is insufficient. \"Robbery\" is the researcher's name for a sequence of [outputs](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28); this paper's [records](concepts.md#c06) are written as observable [outputs](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) (approaching with a knife, making a demand, taking cash), with a separate note that the researcher classed it as robbery and who made that classification.\n\n### 3.3 Records of the Four Rounds (A, B, C, and F as Examples)\n\n| Person | Round 1 | Change in the outside world caused by the [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) | Change from round 2 on in whether the [threshold](concepts.md#c03) is met |\n|---|---|---|---|\n| A | Lives near the workplace, has the skill ([knowledge](concepts.md#c13), set in this example); employment is feasible; no field, so planting is infeasible; the [antecedents](concepts.md#c08) of robbery are not seen in the data and are marked \"unknown\" | Takes employment, [arrives at](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) the employer and the workplace; receives a weekly wage | Cash increases, and \"has capital or goods\" becomes met; employment is still feasible |\n| B | Has a small amount of capital and a site; running a stall is feasible; skill ([knowledge](concepts.md#c13)) unknown | Runs a stall, [arrives at](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) customers; sells nothing in the first week | Capital is used up and there are no goods, so \"has capital or goods\" is no longer met; running a stall is infeasible in round 2; switches to selling existing goods (its [antecedents](concepts.md#c08), \"has something to sell\" and \"has a buyer\", are not seen in the data and are marked \"unknown\"; he actually sold, so the [path](concepts.md#c07) was feasible in that round) |\n| C | Has a field, seeds, and [knowledge](concepts.md#c13) (set in this example); the ripening period exceeds the time window, and planting that does not include sowing in a single round is infeasible | Sows (the researcher's classification of a stretch of [outputs](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)) | Crop growth is the outside world's response, and the crop is not ripe before round 4; the [antecedent](concepts.md#c08) of harvesting within the time window is still not met |\n| F | Has a knife and sufficient strength; the [antecedents](concepts.md#c08) of robbery are all met except [knowledge](concepts.md#c13) (unknown) | Approaches with a knife and takes cash (the researcher separately notes it as robbery) | Cash increases; the \"position that can be [arrived at](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)\" may change because of the other party's later [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28), and this paper records it only as a change in external conditions without asking the cause |\n\nHow to read it:\n\n1. For the same person, whether each [path](concepts.md#c07)'s [threshold](concepts.md#c03) is met may differ from round to round: because of round 1's [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) and response, running a stall is infeasible for B in round 2; for A, \"has capital or goods\" becomes met, so running a stall may become feasible.\n2. C shows: planting is excluded by time in the case of \"a single round without sowing\", but sowing is the researcher's classification of a stretch of [outputs](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) and may change the later outside world; if the time window is lengthened, the exclusion list may be rewritten.\n3. When the cash increases of F and A are equal, the total cash in the two [records](concepts.md#c06) at start and end alone cannot tell which [path](concepts.md#c07) each took; whether they can be distinguished depends on the [records](concepts.md#c06) of each round's [outputs](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28).\n\n### 3.4 Several Paths Excluding One Another\n\nBy Premise 5, the total is limited, so some [paths](concepts.md#c07) exclude one another. This example specifies \"full-time employment\" and \"running a stall at full effort\" as each filling the whole week, so they are mutually exclusive in this example; if they were changed to part-time or partial time slots, whether they exclude each other depends on whether their time and position overlap, and is not inferred directly from Premise 5. Nor can one strike at two places at once (this follows directly from not being in two places at the same time). So in each round, after single-[path](concepts.md#c07) feasibility, whether the [paths](concepts.md#c07) exclude one another is still a separate question. (Conditional level)\n\n**[Opportunity cost](concepts.md#c05) is a comparison calculation by the researcher.** When a [path](concepts.md#c07) is chosen in a round, the other [paths](concepts.md#c07) that exclude it and whose [thresholds](concepts.md#c03) are met are thereby excluded, and this excluded set can be recorded. Under a valuation the researcher specifies (for example cash, time, survival probability), the researcher can compare the end point of the [path](concepts.md#c07) taken with the expected end points of the excluded [paths](concepts.md#c07), and this comparison is called [opportunity cost](concepts.md#c05). (Conditional level, using Premise 5)\n\n- The valuation is chosen by the researcher; change the yardstick and the result may differ.\n- An excluded [path](concepts.md#c07) did not occur, so its end point can only be an estimate; this paper states the basis of the estimate (others' [records](concepts.md#c06), the same person's earlier and later rounds), and records \"unknown\" where there is none.\n- Count only [paths](concepts.md#c07) whose [threshold](concepts.md#c03) is met and which were excluded. [Paths](concepts.md#c07) whose [threshold](concepts.md#c03) is not met are infeasible, not given up, and are not part of the comparison in [opportunity cost](concepts.md#c05).\n- It is not a quantity of the [individual](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c20), does not enter the [weight](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06), and is not used to explain motive: the valuation is the researcher's [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18), the excluded [paths](concepts.md#c07) did not occur and their end points are estimated by the researcher, and the value of the [weight](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06) cannot be read off from the [records](concepts.md#c06) alone ([Wall of the Undetermined](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c10)), so this comparison is not a reading of the [weight](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06). \"Under this valuation, A took employment, and the excluded stall is expected to be about some number\" is a statement of the comparison calculation; \"A chose employment because his [opportunity cost](concepts.md#c05) was small\" is a statement about motive and does not follow.\n\n### 3.5 End-Point Records and Interpretation\n\n- The end point is only one [record](concepts.md#c06) after the last round, and its difference from the start is not called cost.\n- A difference in end points cannot be read directly as a difference in choices: of two people with the same start, if early [outputs](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) receive different responses, the later [feasible sets](concepts.md#c11) may diverge ([Law of Non-Restoration](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c28)).\n- Not earning does not imply not trying; \"trying\" is the researcher's classification of a stretch of observable [outputs](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28), a [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) made by the researcher, and can be recorded once registered. Not trying is not a blank: within this round, each [round](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c04) in which he was not [locked in](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c12) yielded a result (\"not moving\" is one of them); it is just that none of them was an attempt (Rule 8).\n- **[Same outcome from different paths](concepts.md#c04).** Suppose A took employment and B sold existing goods and both ended with ten thousand more in cash; if classed only by \"end-point cash is ten thousand more\", the two are the same class; by timing, source, and the objects [arrived at](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10), they may differ, depending on the actual [records](concepts.md#c06) on each. The two need not regard themselves as doing the same thing (Rule 7).\n\n### 3.6 Tendency and Threshold\n\nSuppose the [records](concepts.md#c06) show that four of the ten people each had employment [outputs](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) in every round; for each of these four this is a [tendency](concepts.md#c02) of that [individual](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c20), each with conditions attached: the [cut](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c23) of this example (ten people, four rounds), a one-month time window, a classification rule of employment [outputs](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28), and the [threshold](concepts.md#c03) conditions of having an employer, having a matching skill ([knowledge](concepts.md#c13)), and being able to [arrive](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at the workplace in the specified period. The count \"four of the ten\" is the researcher's count across [individuals](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c20), not a [tendency](concepts.md#c02). For the other six, it may be that some [antecedent](concepts.md#c08) was not met in some round, or that the [antecedents](concepts.md#c08) were met and the [path](concepts.md#c07) was feasible but did not occur; where the data cannot tell, this paper records \"unknown\" and does not supply imagination. Three people have robbery [outputs](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28); this cannot be read as these three having a high [tendency](concepts.md#c02) to rob, because the other seven may not have met the [antecedents](concepts.md#c08) (for example, if it is verified that A really has no means of exerting force), or may have met them without it occurring.\n\n### 3.7 The Boundary of This Paper\n\nIf the outside world is a [natural environment](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c16) (weather, crop growth), its response belongs to this paper. If the outside world includes other people, their responses (handing over cash, resisting, retaliating) are recorded as the [outputs](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) of others that [arrive at](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) this [node](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25) only if they actually [arrive at](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) this [node](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25); whether an employer is there is an external state, not an [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28). This paper records both only as \"changes in external conditions\" without analyzing causes. The compatibility and [mismatch](../paper_ae79e938_76e1_4bf9_b2ab_995c03e16c9e/concepts.md#c08) between others' [outputs](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28), the separation of violence from mutual benefit, and the effect on the survival of the one robbed are not handled in this paper.\n\n### 3.8 What This Example Does Not Say, and Limits of Use\n\nWho is diligent, who is rational, what anyone acts for, which path pays, and who should choose how. That someone holds a knife and does not rob does not imply that he exercises restraint; that someone robbed does not imply that he lacks money. All the researcher has is each round's [outputs](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28), [thresholds](concepts.md#c03), start, and end.\n\n\"One more ten thousand in a month\" is a specified classification. If it is changed to one year, or to what is needed to maintain survival, the excluded lists and each round's feedback may differ. So the conclusions of this example cannot be separated from its time window, round length, and classification.\n\n---\n\n## 4. Survival and Reproduction\n\nBoth are factual checks made after the researcher specifies a criterion; they are not consequences of the [weight](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06), nor are they the [individual](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c20)'s purpose. This paper does not know, and does not need to know, what the [individual](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c20)'s bodily condition is.\n\n### 4.0 The Individual Local Solution\n\nThe next-moment [state](../paper_96f10d75_23d0_441f_94c7_ab87ca28d284/concepts.md#c02) and [resources](../paper_96f10d75_23d0_441f_94c7_ab87ca28d284/concepts.md#c03) of the specified [individual](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c20) in its [derivation round](../paper_96f10d75_23d0_441f_94c7_ab87ca28d284/concepts.md#c07), together with the relevant [records](concepts.md#c06) of [criterion exit](../paper_96f10d75_23d0_441f_94c7_ab87ca28d284/concepts.md#c09), if the [individual](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c20) is listed as a [node](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25) under the specified [cut](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c23) and these fields are recorded in that round's [solution](../paper_96f10d75_23d0_441f_94c7_ab87ca28d284/concepts.md#c05), form the single-[node](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25) part of the upstream [solution](../paper_96f10d75_23d0_441f_94c7_ab87ca28d284/concepts.md#c05). The above is called the [individual local solution](concepts.md#c09). This paper records only these fields. Input (what was paid) is not among these fields and is not obtained automatically from the [solution](../paper_96f10d75_23d0_441f_94c7_ab87ca28d284/concepts.md#c05): what counts as paid is the researcher's [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) (cost is not a quantity; see Section 0). Whether and when [criterion exit](../paper_96f10d75_23d0_441f_94c7_ab87ca28d284/concepts.md#c09) occurs is one dimension of the [solution](../paper_96f10d75_23d0_441f_94c7_ab87ca28d284/concepts.md#c05); survival (4.1) is reading this dimension, not a separate set of data. The upstream [solution](../paper_96f10d75_23d0_441f_94c7_ab87ca28d284/concepts.md#c05) does not presuppose reproduction as a dimension; reproduction is a determination made in this paper under a separately specified event criterion (4.2).\n\n### 4.1 Survival\n\n- **Criterion.** What counts as [criterion exit](../paper_96f10d75_23d0_441f_94c7_ab87ca28d284/concepts.md#c09) (for example, a physiological threshold) is specified by the researcher; a criterion is the [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) of whoever set it. A criterion is a definition.\n- **Fact.** Whether [criterion exit](../paper_96f10d75_23d0_441f_94c7_ab87ca28d284/concepts.md#c09) occurs in a given round is decided by actual events. A fact becomes a [record](concepts.md#c06) only when the researcher registers it.\n- **Record only presence or absence and the time point; infer no cause.** The [exit criterion](../paper_96f10d75_23d0_441f_94c7_ab87ca28d284/concepts.md#c04) this paper takes looks only at the presence or absence and the time point of actual events and contains no causal condition; a criterion that the researcher sets with causal conditions is not handled in this paper. Whether he depends on equipment, is cared for by others, or what his body is like, if registered, appears only in the [threshold](concepts.md#c03) and in the [records](concepts.md#c06) of each round, what is not registered is marked unknown, and none of this changes the way of determination.\n- **The three layers do not imply one another.** Upstream [exit](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c43) is a structural matter (no longer being a [Wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)) and does not need anyone to determine it; [death](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c22) is one [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) in which someone marks it as \"already [exited](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c43)\"; [criterion exit](../paper_96f10d75_23d0_441f_94c7_ab87ca28d284/concepts.md#c09) is a factual check after the researcher specifies a criterion. The three can fail to line up: already [exited](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c43) with no one marking [death](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c22); [death](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c22) marked while still a [Wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16); meeting the criterion while structurally not having [exited](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c43). Structurally, after [exit](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c43) a new [entry](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c44) is possible; but whether [criterion exit](../paper_96f10d75_23d0_441f_94c7_ab87ca28d284/concepts.md#c09) is reversible depends on the criterion set (for example, a criterion of quitting a job may be reversible, and a criterion of a physiological boundary may be irreversible), so it records only presence or absence and the time point, as a bookkeeping convention, and is not treated in advance as a permanent end point.\n- **Not a general ledger.** These [records](concepts.md#c06) are only the researcher's selection, under the specified [cut](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c23), of what has happened; a [record](concepts.md#c06) is not a complete settlement of the one recorded, and if the party makes a [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) of himself, that [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) is also incomplete, so they are not a settlement of a whole life; a settlement requires a further [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) that takes a whole stretch as some result, and this [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) itself then enters the [history](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13) and is not in its own material. The [records](concepts.md#c06) of survival and reproduction carry no criterion for evaluating a life of their own and do not evaluate a life; evaluating or comparing different [individuals](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c20) uses someone's criterion, which the [records](concepts.md#c06) do not supply.\n\n### 4.2 Reproduction\n\n- **Recorded as an [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28).** Under the [cut](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c23) of this paper (Premise 1), a reproduction event is recorded as an [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) of that [individual](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c20). This is a bookkeeping convention, not an ontological position; if the [cut](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c23) is changed to one that takes the two spouses as the unit, the same event can be recorded as the joint [arrival](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) of the [outputs](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) of two [nodes](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25), and the two ways of recording do not contradict each other.\n- **Accumulation is irreversible.** Reproduction events are a sequence of events that have occurred in the [individual](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c20)'s [history](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13), only increasing and never decreasing. An eighty-year-old who has no reproduction this year does not lose the [offspring](concepts.md#c15) already had, nor are they cancelled by his [criterion exit](../paper_96f10d75_23d0_441f_94c7_ab87ca28d284/concepts.md#c09). \"Yes or no\" in a given round is only a slice of the sequence. (Constraint level)\n- **[Record](concepts.md#c06) fields.** Time (including age at the time), geography (the position of the event, the positions of both parties), the other party (who, whether living together at the time; for \"spouse\", who made the attribution is recorded), the result (whether [offspring](concepts.md#c15) was born, and whether there was any [arrival](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) between the offspring and the person concerned afterward), the start, the end; the [threshold](concepts.md#c03) of the round is attached separately and is not a [record](concepts.md#c06) field.\n- **Actual reproduction is not replaced by other [records](concepts.md#c06).** A high [tendency](concepts.md#c02) does not imply that the next occurrence will happen (Rule 2), a self-report is one [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) (Rule 3), and an \"attempt\" is the researcher's classification of a stretch of [outputs](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28); if the researcher registers them, each is recorded as a separate [record](concepts.md#c06), and neither is the reproduction event itself; the reproduction event itself is recorded as an [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28), so whether actual reproduction occurred depends only on whether this event occurred under the specified time window and event criterion. (Constraint level)\n- **Boundary.** This paper records only the side of the [individual](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c20). The other party's [history](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13), how the pairing was formed, and the survival and further reproduction of the [offspring](concepts.md#c15) are not handled in this paper. [Offspring](concepts.md#c15) are [nodes](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25) at their [entry](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c44), whose prehistory overlaps with that of the parents, and it does not follow that they inherit the parents' [weight](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06) or [outputs](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28). In a closed population (no outside supplementation, continuing across generations by internal reproduction), for the determination of the three results of member survival, actual reproduction, and [offspring](concepts.md#c15) continuation, the [individual](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c20) supplies only the [individual](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c20)-side [records](concepts.md#c06) of the first two; whether the three together hold, and what counts as sufficient, is not handled in this paper.\n\n### 4.3 The Non-Implication List\n\n| Cannot infer | Reason |\n|---|---|\n| A stable [tendency](concepts.md#c02) to eat → not eating necessarily leads to [criterion exit](../paper_96f10d75_23d0_441f_94c7_ab87ca28d284/concepts.md#c09) (when the criterion is the physiological boundary) | A [tendency](concepts.md#c02) is the shape of the [records](concepts.md#c06), not a necessary condition |\n| Survival without eating → the generalization of that [tendency](concepts.md#c02) does not hold | Other [paths](concepts.md#c07) or external conditions may exist; a single case alone cannot settle whether the generalization holds; whether it holds depends on the overall [records](concepts.md#c06) under comparable conditions |\n| Survival → his [outputs](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) were better or optimal | Survival is only a fact under a criterion, and does not compare [outputs](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) |\n| [Criterion exit](../paper_96f10d75_23d0_441f_94c7_ab87ca28d284/concepts.md#c09) → he chose wrongly, or lacked something | [Criterion exit](../paper_96f10d75_23d0_441f_94c7_ab87ca28d284/concepts.md#c09) has no necessary relation to what he wants; its relation to [resources](../paper_96f10d75_23d0_441f_94c7_ab87ca28d284/concepts.md#c03) depends on the criterion set (for example, if the criterion is set as bankruptcy, the relation is established by the definition of the criterion) |\n| Reproduction occurred → he wanted to | [Unconfirmability of Drives](../paper_ae79e938_76e1_4bf9_b2ab_995c03e16c9e/concepts.md#c03) |\n| No reproduction → he did not want to, or lacked something | Same as above; the [threshold](concepts.md#c03) may also not have been met |\n| Survival in one round → survival in later rounds; reproduction in one round → reproduction in the next round | A single round's [records](concepts.md#c06) do not determine whether it occurs in the next round: a [record](concepts.md#c06) is only the researcher's selection, and [outputs](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) not registered remain in the [history](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13) and may continue to affect the [weight](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06); in addition, by the [Law of the Black Box](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c25), when not [locked in](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c12), the next round's complete result is also not uniquely determined by this round; reproduction events that have already occurred are not cancelled (see 4.2), and what is said here is whether it occurs again in the next round |\n| Survival and reproduction imply each other | This paper does not infer one from the other: the two determinations each have their own criterion and [records](concepts.md#c06) |\n\n### 4.4 Conditioning on Existing Samples\n\nSelecting a sample conditioned on survival is called [conditioning on existing samples](concepts.md#c14). When the sample is conditioned on survival, the sample contains the [individuals](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c20) that have not yet undergone [criterion exit](../paper_96f10d75_23d0_441f_94c7_ab87ca28d284/concepts.md#c09). Whether [criterion exit](../paper_96f10d75_23d0_441f_94c7_ab87ca28d284/concepts.md#c09) occurs depends only on the criterion set by the researcher and on actual events (4.1), and has no necessary relation to whether his [outputs](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) were good or bad (4.3), so the performance of survivors is not enough to directly judge good or bad; selecting samples conditioned on \"survival\" is where the sample boundary comes from. Of the [outputs](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) left by those who underwent [criterion exit](../paper_96f10d75_23d0_441f_94c7_ab87ca28d284/concepts.md#c09), those that have already [arrived at](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) others or remain in a [signal container](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c26) are still in the [history](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13); those that arrived at no one may be unobtainable by the researcher; so it does not follow that those who have disappeared cannot be studied. This is the researcher's sample boundary; it is not that the outside world has a selecting purpose (\"filtering\" is only a metaphor).\n\n---\n\n## 5. Grading of Conclusions\n\n**Constraint level** (relying only on the four laws, [Unconfirmability of Drives](../paper_ae79e938_76e1_4bf9_b2ab_995c03e16c9e/concepts.md#c03), Premises 1 to 4, this paper's declarations, assumptions, and bookkeeping conventions, and what is carried over from upstream, without empirical premises; the declarations and assumptions are six: the party is a biological human, reproduction events are recorded as [outputs](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28), [offspring](concepts.md#c15) are [nodes](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25) at their [entry](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c44), and the [exit criterion](../paper_96f10d75_23d0_441f_94c7_ab87ca28d284/concepts.md#c04) this paper takes contains no causal condition, the party is not [locked in](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c12) at the moments discussed, and the researcher and onlookers are also each a [Self](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19) in the upstream sense)\n\n1. If any [antecedent](concepts.md#c08) of a [threshold](concepts.md#c03) is not in place, that [path](concepts.md#c07) is infeasible in that round; being in place only means feasible.\n2. [Tendency](concepts.md#c02) and events are separate; a self-report is a lossy [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28).\n3. If an [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) [arrives at](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) the outside and it responds, and if the response enters the [history](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13), it may change whether each [path](concepts.md#c07)'s [threshold](concepts.md#c03) is met in the next round, and the [weight](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06); the two feedbacks are separate.\n4. Reproduction and [outputs](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) that have already occurred only increase and never decrease; differences at the end point do not imply differences in the choices at the starting point.\n5. Survival records only presence or absence and the time point; it infers neither cause nor optimality.\n6. The class into which a change in [resources](../paper_96f10d75_23d0_441f_94c7_ab87ca28d284/concepts.md#c03) falls does not imply the type of [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28): under the outcome classification specified by the researcher, a change in [resources](../paper_96f10d75_23d0_441f_94c7_ab87ca28d284/concepts.md#c03) of the same class can be reached by different [paths](concepts.md#c07) ([same outcome from different paths](concepts.md#c04)), so which class the change in [resources](../paper_96f10d75_23d0_441f_94c7_ab87ca28d284/concepts.md#c03) between the two [records](concepts.md#c06) at the start and the end falls into does not alone uniquely determine which [path](concepts.md#c07) was taken (Premise 4).\n7. [Same outcome from different paths](concepts.md#c04) is only an external classification; it does not imply the same [path](concepts.md#c07) or a common drive, does not supply any frequency of occurrence, and it is not [convergence](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c37).\n8. Actual reproduction looks only at whether the event occurred; it is not replaced by [tendency](concepts.md#c02), a self-report, or an attempt.\n9. At the [moments](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c09) when a [Wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16) is not [locked in](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c12), every [round](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c04) is a [decision](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c06), a [forced wager](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c11): when an onlooker classes a single [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) as safe or risky, this is the onlooker's own [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18), not a reading of risk, whether the result is good or bad is a classification under someone's criterion; a single result does not reveal the [weight](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06) at the time of the [decision](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c06), and evaluating a [decision](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c06) by its result itself is a criterion someone has chosen; risk is not set up as a quantity of its own.\n10. For the [questions](concepts.md#c01), an earlier one does not imply the next: wanting does not imply being able, being able does not imply doing, and having done does not imply that the result is what was wanted.\n\n**Condition level**\n\n| Conclusion | What it rests on |\n|---|---|\n| That a single [path](concepts.md#c07) is feasible does not imply that [paths](concepts.md#c07) can be carried out at the same time | Premise 5 (physical limits) |\n| The list of [paths](concepts.md#c07) excluded in a given time window | The time window, round length, and classification specified by the researcher; decided by the data |\n| Whether a specific [individual](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c20) has each [antecedent](concepts.md#c08) | Decided by the data; [knowledge](concepts.md#c13) is inferred from [outputs](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) |\n| The comparison calculation of [opportunity cost](concepts.md#c05) | Premise 5; the valuation and estimation method specified by the researcher |\n| An [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) creating [antecedents](concepts.md#c08) of a later round, possibly closing some [paths](concepts.md#c07) | Experience and the specific data; permanent or temporary is decided by the data, not inferred from the [Law of Non-Restoration](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c28) |\n| Other people's result [records](concepts.md#c06) as a conditional estimate of this person's risk | The sample and estimation method specified by the researcher; it is that researcher's estimate; not guaranteed |\n\n**The status of the cases.** The cases in Chapter 3 (synthetic) and Chapter 6 (Lincoln) serve only for calibration and are not listed as a source of derivation for any of the above levels.\n\n**Research questions**\n\n1. Under comparable conditions, how stable is the common shape of [output tendency](concepts.md#c02) across [individuals](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c20), and how does it change across rounds? For the same body of behavior under different classification rules, which common shapes remain stable and which disappear with the classification?\n2. How much of the difference between [thresholds](concepts.md#c03) and the difference between end points can be explained by [path](concepts.md#c07) exclusion?\n3. In settings where physical conditions can be stated, where the person's self-reported judgments of cost or consequence can be observed, and where actual [outputs](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) and results are tracked, under what conditions do outward self-reports and later [outputs](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) agree or deviate? Deviation may come from observation gaps, [candidate](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c18) [paths](concepts.md#c07) that cannot be obtained, differences in [resource](../paper_96f10d75_23d0_441f_94c7_ab87ca28d284/concepts.md#c03) conditions, or differences in [arrival](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) information, so deviation does not imply \"irrationality\"; nor is agreement a reading of the [weight](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06); where no self-report is seen, this paper records \"unknown\".\n\n---\n\n## 6. Case (Calibration): Lincoln, from New Salem to Ford's Theatre\n\nThis whole chapter serves only for calibration and is not a source of derivation. The data come from public web pages, not original documents; where sources attribute the same matter differently, this is marked as the source's attribution and is not read off as a [record](concepts.md#c06). Chapter 3 is a synthetic example and this chapter is a real person; neither constitutes empirical support.\n\n**What happened.** In 1831, the twenty-two-year-old Lincoln went down the Sangamon River on a flatboat; the boat stuck on the town's mill dam, and so he came to New Salem for the first time, having been in Illinois for little more than a year. 〔Offutt〕, who had hired him to carry goods, ran a store there, which failed in less than a year, and Lincoln stayed in the town.\n\nIn 1832 he ran for the state legislature for the first time and lost. That same year he went into partnership with 〔Berry〕 and took over a general store on credit; in 1833 he again bought on credit the stock and premises of a store across the way. The store finally failed, 〔Berry〕 died, and a [debt over 1000 dollars](../ext/ext_3f133ee5_6685_4846_a0c1_f73221282d81/concepts.md#c01) was left to Lincoln (another source writes a [debt of about 1100 dollars](../ext/ext_27762a9b_b116_4d9b_85f8_9d460f8f1a9d/concepts.md#c01), listed side by side). This was a [debt paid off in 1848](../ext/ext_dba4a173_9078_4414_9f8b_b990559379cd/concepts.md#c01), the year he was a member of the U.S. House of Representatives.\n\nWhile the debt was still on him, he was [appointed Postmaster on May 7 1833](../ext/ext_dba4a173_9078_4414_9f8b_b990559379cd/concepts.md#c02), and supplemented his income by splitting rails, harvesting, doing odd jobs, and minding a store; the post paid a [postmaster income of about 55 dollars a year](../ext/ext_27762a9b_b116_4d9b_85f8_9d460f8f1a9d/concepts.md#c02). At the end of the year he borrowed books from the county surveyor to teach himself, and became a deputy surveyor.\n\nIn 1834 and 1836 he was elected to the Illinois legislature. During the campaign he met 〔Stuart〕, a fellow candidate; 〔Stuart〕 lent him law books, which he studied on his own, without entering a law school. On March 24, 1836, a court certified his good character, and he obtained [a license to practice law on September 9 1836](../ext/ext_d14ee3a0_732d_43b1_a11e_ccef396f1a38/concepts.md#c01), valid in the courts of the whole state, (another source records it as [a license to practice law on September 19 1836](../ext/ext_661ea447_93a6_4239_a564_08d70d5c9da1/concepts.md#c01), listed side by side). In the spring of 1837 he moved to Springfield and became 〔Stuart〕's junior partner, and afterwards formed partnerships in turn with 〔Logan〕 and 〔Herndon〕.\n\nIn 1846 he was elected to the U.S. House of Representatives, serving 1847 to 1849. In 1854 his run for the Senate failed; in 1858 the Republican Party nominated him to run against 〔Douglas〕, the two held [seven debates in 1858](../ext/ext_661ea447_93a6_4239_a564_08d70d5c9da1/concepts.md#c02), and he lost, but the debates brought national fame. In November 1860 he was elected president. He was [shot on April 14 1865](../ext/ext_661ea447_93a6_4239_a564_08d70d5c9da1/concepts.md#c03) at Ford's Theatre by 〔Booth〕, and his [death on April 15 1865](../ext/ext_48a45b8a_e208_4d98_adb4_cf779f8912e3/concepts.md#c01) came early the next morning, at the age of fifty-six.\n\n**Bringing in the framework.** First choose the [cut](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c23): the [individual](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c20) is Lincoln alone; the period is 1831 to 1865, divided into rounds at the turning points in the data, with rounds of unequal length, which is the researcher's division. The [outputs](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) of employers, partners, voters, opponents, and the assassin are all recorded only as changes in the external conditions [arriving at](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) him, and their causes are not analyzed.\n\nLook first at **opening the store**. For the [path](concepts.md#c07) \"open a store\", the [antecedent](concepts.md#c08) visible in the data is \"able to buy on credit\", which is in place; he actually opened a store, so opening a store was feasible in that round. Its end-point [record](concepts.md#c06) is debt. Feasible does not mean a good result, and it does not imply a wrong judgment. Next, **running for office**. For the [path](concepts.md#c07) \"run for legislator\", he actually ran, so the [path](concepts.md#c07) was feasible in that round; **losing the election** is the end-point [record](concepts.md#c06) of this [path](concepts.md#c07), and it neither implies the [path](concepts.md#c07) was infeasible nor says why.\n\nNext look at **after the debt**. After the debt appeared, the [feasible set](concepts.md#c11) may have shrunk; the data show his [outputs](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) became several small [paths](concepts.md#c07) in parallel: postal work, odd jobs, surveying, and this paper does not infer a causal link between the two. This is an instance of feedback to the [threshold](concepts.md#c03): the previous round's [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) (buying on credit) may have changed the next round's [antecedents](concepts.md#c08). The [antecedents](concepts.md#c08) of the surveyor [path](concepts.md#c07) include [knowledge](concepts.md#c13); \"borrowing books\" is the researcher's classification of a stretch of [outputs](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28), and whether [knowledge](concepts.md#c13) was thereby in place can only be inferred from later [outputs](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) (he became a deputy surveyor). This shows that [antecedents](concepts.md#c08) can be created by the previous round's [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28), but this rests on experience and data and is not inferred. How much he actually learned cannot be read directly.\n\nThe **lawyer [path](concepts.md#c07)**, in the data, shows three [antecedents](concepts.md#c08) (listed by the researcher, not taken as the complete [threshold](concepts.md#c03)): books (an external [resource](../paper_96f10d75_23d0_441f_94c7_ab87ca28d284/concepts.md#c03)), [knowledge](concepts.md#c13) (accumulated through reading, and inferable only from later [outputs](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)), and a license (an external condition). According to the data, the books and the license were obtained one by one over the earlier rounds; whether [knowledge](concepts.md#c13) was in place can only be inferred from later [outputs](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28). Being elected legislator brought him to know 〔Stuart〕 and get the books, but saying \"he became a legislator in order to borrow books\" would be speaking of a motive, and a motive cannot be inferred.\n\nIn **1858**, he actually ran for senator, so running was feasible in that round; the defeat is the end-point [record](concepts.md#c06) of that [path](concepts.md#c07) and does not imply the [path](concepts.md#c07) was infeasible; the same round's [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) (the debates) brought \"national fame\", which is a favorable change visible in the data; whether it is an [antecedent](concepts.md#c08) of that [path](concepts.md#c07), the data cannot settle; in 1860 he actually won the presidency, so running for president was feasible in that round. The same defeat is an end-point [record](concepts.md#c06) on one [path](concepts.md#c07) and may be the source of a new [antecedent](concepts.md#c08) on another. To call it \"wasted\" or \"paving the way\" is in either case a later person's attribution.\n\nLast is **1865**. The criterion takes a physiological boundary, and April 15 is recorded as [criterion exit](../paper_96f10d75_23d0_441f_94c7_ab87ca28d284/concepts.md#c09). The assassin's act is recorded only as another person's [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) [arriving at](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) this [node](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25); whether the two had a [dedicated history](../paper_ae79e938_76e1_4bf9_b2ab_995c03e16c9e/concepts.md#c05) and whether the act was compatible or a [mismatch](../paper_ae79e938_76e1_4bf9_b2ab_995c03e16c9e/concepts.md#c08) are not handled in this paper. \"[Death](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c22)\" is a [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) marked by the researcher or by later people; this chapter uses [criterion exit](../paper_96f10d75_23d0_441f_94c7_ab87ca28d284/concepts.md#c09) and specifies the criterion, which can be out of step with structural [exit](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c43). He did not die of old age; this does not imply that there was anything wrong with the [outputs](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) of the earlier rounds, nor that the survival [record](concepts.md#c06) is a \"failure\"; [criterion exit](../paper_96f10d75_23d0_441f_94c7_ab87ca28d284/concepts.md#c09) has no necessary relation to whether he chose rightly or wrongly (see the non-implication list in 4.3).\n\n**What the data show and what cannot be inferred.** The data show changes of occupation, place, debt, and license at each stage, corresponding to [antecedents](concepts.md#c08) being gained and lost; his [outputs](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) [arrived at](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) the outside, and the data show that after the outside's responses the [feasible set](concepts.md#c11) of the next round changed; no causal link is inferred. For example, the law [path](concepts.md#c07): before he obtained the license, at least the license [antecedent](concepts.md#c08) was not met, so it was infeasible; later he actually practised law, so the [path](concepts.md#c07) was feasible then; so the [feasible set](concepts.md#c11) differed before and after he obtained the license. What cannot be inferred: why he opened the store, why he studied law, why he ran for office; the inner effect of debt and defeat on him; the details of income in each round (only scattered figures were read); the [weight](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06) of any single [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28); evaluations such as \"hard-fated\" or \"honest\" (these are later people's attributions).\n\n**Notes on the data.** Only summaries on public web pages and collection descriptions were read; neither full biographies nor original documents were read. Sources differ on dates and debt amounts, and these are listed side by side; what each source says is registered in a separate external stub. One slide caption states that his surveying instruments, horse, and saddle were auctioned off by the sheriff to pay the debt; this is a second-hand description and is not adopted in this chapter.\n\n---\n\n## 7. Failure Conditions\n\n**Cases.** The cases in Chapter 3 (synthetic) and Chapter 6 (Lincoln) are both for calibration; they are not a source of derivation and do not constitute empirical support.\n\n**Failure conditions.**\n\n- When the four laws are overturned, the constraint-level conclusions that depend on them lose their source; losing the source only means the chain of derivation is broken, not that the proposition is false.\n- If the [Forced Wager](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c11), the [Wall of the Undetermined](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c10), and the [Wall of Provenance](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c08) are overturned, the conclusions whose source chains contain them lose their source: Rule 8, the estimate of [weight](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06) in 2.2, Section 2.5, the comparison of [opportunity cost](concepts.md#c05) in 3.4, \"not trying is not a blank\" among the readings in 3.5, item 9 of the constraint level in Chapter 5, and the corresponding calibration narrative in Chapter 6; if the distinction between [exit](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c43) and [death](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c22) is overturned, the corresponding item in 4.1 loses its source; the rest is unaffected.\n- If [Unconfirmability of Drives](../paper_ae79e938_76e1_4bf9_b2ab_995c03e16c9e/concepts.md#c03) is overturned, the conclusions that internal drives or motives are not implied by stable [tendency](concepts.md#c02), the presence or absence of reproduction, [opportunity cost](concepts.md#c05), and so on lose their source; the rest is unaffected.\n- Premises 1 to 4 are scope settings, not claims that can be overturned; changing them changes the scope this paper deals with, and then the conclusions obtained from them alone (without passing through any one law) lose their source and no longer apply under the changed scope.\n- If Premise 5 is violated by reality (for example, if it is found that a biological human can be in two places at once in the same round, or that strength and attention are not limited in total), only the condition-level conclusions that use it lose their source (Rule 6 and 3.4 on whether several [paths](concepts.md#c07) exclude one another being a separate question, and the comparison calculation of [opportunity cost](concepts.md#c05)).\n- If the definitions of [record](concepts.md#c06), [output tendency](concepts.md#c02), [threshold](concepts.md#c03), or [same outcome from different paths](concepts.md#c04) are changed, the rules and sections that depend on them (Rules 1 to 4, 7, 9, and Sections 2.1, 2.2, 3.1, 4.1, 4.3) then have their sources awaiting recheck.\n- If the experience that \"an [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) creates [antecedents](concepts.md#c08) for a later round and may close some [paths](concepts.md#c07)\" does not hold, only the conditional-level part of Rule 5 loses its source, and the calibration narrative in Chapter 6 that depends on it also has its source awaiting recheck.\n- An observation opposite to a conclusion can only be attributed to an error at the starting point of the derivation or an error in the derivation; the latter is a correction, not a falsification.\n\n**Not conclusions of this paper.** Family, network structure, the compatibility and [mismatch](../paper_ae79e938_76e1_4bf9_b2ab_995c03e16c9e/concepts.md#c08) of other people's [outputs](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28), violence and mutual benefit, the continuation of [offspring](concepts.md#c15), and the survival of the network are not handled in this paper. Data that were not obtained are not written as \"nonexistent\".\n\n---\n\n## Appendix: Derivations\n\n```text\nPremises 1 to 5 as in Chapter 1.\nDerivation 1 A threshold is a set of antecedents; if any antecedent is not in place, the path is infeasible in that round (Premise 3 + Premise 4; constraint level)\nDerivation 2 All antecedents in place only means feasible; when not locked in, the next moment yields only the weight (Law of the Black Box; constraint level)\nDerivation 3 High tendency does not imply that the next occurrence will happen; tendency is the shape of the records, not a reading of the inside (Law of the Black Box + Unconfirmability of Drives; constraint level)\nDerivation 4 A self-report is one output, lossy, and not a complete description of the cause or of the inside (Law of Attrition + Law of the Black Box + definition of record + definition of output; constraint level)\nDerivation 5 If an output arrives at the outside and the outside responds, and if the response enters the history, the history takes part in the next round's weight and may change the antecedents; the former may change the feasible set and the latter the weight, not guaranteed to be visible and not guaranteed to be learning (Law of Flux + Law of Non-Restoration + definition of history; constraint level). Outputs creating antecedents and possibly closing paths are conditional level (depending on experience and data)\nDerivation 6 Differences at the end point do not imply differences in choice at the starting point: different early responses may make the feasible set bifurcate (Law of Non-Restoration + Derivation 5; constraint level)\nDerivation 7 Reproduction events and other outputs that have occurred only increase and never decrease; the absence of an event in a round does not cancel existing events (Law of Non-Restoration; constraint level)\nDerivation 8 Survival is determined, in this paper, only by a researcher-set criterion that looks at the presence or absence and time point of actual events, not at causes (Premise 1 + the distinction between criterion and fact + this paper's restriction on the criterion; constraint level)\nDerivation 9 A single path being feasible does not imply that paths can be carried out at the same time; paths that are excluded but whose thresholds are in place can serve as the researcher's comparison calculation and do not enter the weight (Premise 5; condition level)\nDerivation 10 Same outcome from different paths is only an external classification and does not imply the same path or convergence, nor does it supply any frequency of occurrence (Law of the Black Box + Premise 1 + definition of same outcome from different paths; constraint level)\nDerivation 11 At the moments when a Wo is not locked in, an output cannot be calculated accurately beforehand, cannot be taken back afterwards, and \"not moving\" is also one of the things that occur; so when an onlooker classes a single output as safe or risky, this is the onlooker's own distinction; whether a result is good or bad is a classification under someone's criterion; the same decision can land on different results, so a single result does not reveal the weight at the time of the decision, and evaluating a decision by its result itself is a criterion someone has chosen (Forced Wager + Wall of Provenance + Law of the Black Box + Law of Non-Restoration + definition of decision; constraint level)\nDerivation 12 Wanting does not imply being able, being able does not imply doing, and having done does not imply that the result is what was wanted (Law of the Black Box + Law of Non-Restoration + Derivation 1 + Derivation 3; constraint level)\nNote: State and resource are the researcher's classification, and the threshold does not depend on this classification.\n```\n"}]}
{"paper_uuid":"96f10d75-23d0-441f-94c7-ab87ca28d284","paper_title":"生產動力學","paper_title_en":"Production Dynamics","author":"黃正宇 / Cheng Yu Huang","contact":"mthree.tw@gmail.com","concepts_md":"---\nuuid: 96f10d75-23d0-441f-94c7-ab87ca28d284\nlast-modified: 2026-11-04T14:15:11\n---\n\n\n## public 生產 / Production\n\n- 定義:[生產](concepts.md#c01)是研究者對[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)[歷史](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13)所作的一種[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18):在講明的[切法](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c23)下,把某段[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)看作[生產](concepts.md#c01)。[生產](concepts.md#c01)不賦予[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)獨立本體。\n- Definition: [Production](concepts.md#c01) is a [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) a researcher draws over the [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) [history](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13): under a stated way of [cutting](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c23), a stretch of [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) is viewed as [production](concepts.md#c01). It gives [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) no independent ontology.\n\n\n## public 狀態變數 / State Variable\n\n- 定義:研究者在講明的[切法](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c23)下,為[節點](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25)指定的一種可記錄變數,用來描述該[節點](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25)下一刻的樣子,並供[退場判準](concepts.md#c04)表述。什麼算狀態,隨[節點](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25)邊界而定,是[切法](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c23)下的歸類,不是事物本身的性質;常以「在該[節點](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25)的視角下不可轉移、不可儲存」作為辨認依據,但這只是依據,不是定義。\n- Definition: A recordable variable that a researcher, under a stated way of [cutting](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c23), assigns to a [node](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25) to describe how it is at the next moment and in which the [exit criterion](concepts.md#c04) is expressed. What counts as state depends on the [node](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25) boundary; it is a classification under a [cut](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c23), not a property of the thing itself. Non-transferability and non-storability from the [node](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25)'s viewpoint are common cues, not the definition.\n\n\n## public 資源變數 / Resource Variable\n\n- 定義:研究者在講明的[切法](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c23)下,為[節點](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25)指定的一種可記錄變數,其值在每個[推演輪](concepts.md#c07)中可增可減,由實際事件決定。什麼算資源,隨[節點](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25)邊界而定,是[切法](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c23)下的歸類,不是事物本身的性質;常以「在該[節點](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25)的視角下可轉移、可儲存」作為辨認依據,但這只是依據,不是定義。記錄[資源變數](concepts.md#c03)的增減,不預設不同[節點](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25)的增減對應同一份東西。\n- Definition: A recordable variable that a researcher, under a stated way of [cutting](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c23), assigns to a [node](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25), whose value may increase or decrease in each [derivation round](concepts.md#c07) according to actual events. What counts as a resource depends on the [node](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25) boundary; it is a classification under a [cut](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c23), not a property of the thing itself. Transferability and storability from the [node](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25)'s viewpoint are common cues, not the definition. Recording increases and decreases of a [resource variable](concepts.md#c03) presupposes no correspondence between different [nodes](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25)' changes.\n\n\n## public 退場判準 / Exit Criterion\n\n- 定義:研究者在講明的[切法](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c23)下,用[狀態變數](concepts.md#c02)表述的一條準則,用來判定[節點](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25)在某個[推演輪](concepts.md#c07)中是否[判準退場](concepts.md#c09)。判準是研究者的一次[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18),是定義;是否[判準退場](concepts.md#c09)是該[推演輪](concepts.md#c07)實際的狀態事件,是事實,兩者不互相替代。判準可以是上游所稱的「不再是[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)」,也可以是研究者明示的其他定義。[判準退場](concepts.md#c09)是《生產動力學》自己的概念,指依研究者所訂判準記為退出;它與上游的[退場](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c43)(不再是[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16))不同,兩者可以一致,也可以不一致。\n- Definition: A criterion, expressed in [state variables](concepts.md#c02) under a stated way of [cutting](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c23), by which a researcher decides whether a [node](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25) undergoes [criterion exit](concepts.md#c09) in a given [derivation round](concepts.md#c07). The criterion is a [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) by the researcher and hence a definition; whether the [node](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25) actually undergoes [criterion exit](concepts.md#c09) is a fact about the state events of that [derivation round](concepts.md#c07). The two do not substitute for each other. The criterion may be the upstream 'no longer a [vortex](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)' or any other explicitly stated definition. [Criterion exit](concepts.md#c09) is the own concept of 'Production Dynamics': being recorded as leaving under the researcher's stated criterion. It differs from the upstream [exit](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c43) (no longer a [vortex](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)); the two may coincide or not.\n\n\n## public 解 / Solution\n\n- 定義:研究者在講明的[切法](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c23)下,記錄的各[節點](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25)下一刻的[狀態變數](concepts.md#c02)、[資源變數](concepts.md#c03),以及依[退場判準](concepts.md#c04)所記的是否[判準退場](concepts.md#c09),合起來是該[推演輪](concepts.md#c07)的[解](concepts.md#c05)。[判準退場](concepts.md#c09)只是[解](concepts.md#c05)的一個維度,與其他維度並列;沒有記錄的東西不在[解](concepts.md#c05)裡,但仍在[歷史](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13)中。\n- Definition: The recorded next-moment [state variables](concepts.md#c02) and [resource variables](concepts.md#c03) of the [nodes](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25) under a stated way of [cutting](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c23), together with whether each [node](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25) undergoes [criterion exit](concepts.md#c09) according to the [exit criterion](concepts.md#c04), taken together form the [solution](concepts.md#c05) of that [derivation round](concepts.md#c07). [Criterion exit](concepts.md#c09) is only one dimension of the [solution](concepts.md#c05), alongside the others; what is not recorded is not in the [solution](concepts.md#c05) but remains in [history](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13).\n\n\n## public 推演輪 / Derivation Round\n\n- 定義:[推演輪](concepts.md#c07)是研究者在講明的[切法](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c23)下,把一個模型往前推進一次的單位:在場的各[節點](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25)各自走一次上游的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)、[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)、入[歷史](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13)的循環,再加上研究者所作的記錄,以及成員依[判準退場](concepts.md#c09)與[進場](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c44)所作的成員變動。單位是整個切出的範圍,不是單一[節點](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25)。記錄的內容與成員變動的規則由使用者指定,不假定各[節點](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25)同步,[推演輪](concepts.md#c07)只是排序。\n- Definition: A [derivation round](concepts.md#c07) is the unit by which a researcher, under a stated way of [cutting](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c23), advances a model by one step: each [node](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25) present runs once through the upstream loop of [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28), [arrival](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) and entry into [history](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13), after which the researcher makes records and the membership changes through [criterion exit](concepts.md#c09) and [entry](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c44). The unit is the whole cut-out range, not a single [node](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25). What is recorded and how membership changes are specified by the user; [nodes](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25) are not assumed synchronous, and the [round](concepts.md#c07) is only an ordering.\n\n\n## public 判準退場 / Criterion Exit\n\n- 定義:在講明的[切法](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c23)下,依研究者所訂的[退場判準](concepts.md#c04),某[節點](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25)在某個[推演輪](concepts.md#c07)被記為退出。[判準退場](concepts.md#c09)是《生產動力學》自己的概念,不等於上游的[退場](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c43)(不再是[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)):判準可以取上游的「不再是[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)」,也可以取退休、離職、公司解散或生理界線等其他明示定義,所以兩者可以一致,也可以不一致。是否[判準退場](concepts.md#c09)是該[推演輪](concepts.md#c07)實際的狀態事件,是事實;判準本身是定義。\n- Definition: [Criterion exit](concepts.md#c09) is the recording of a [node](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25) as leaving in a given [derivation round](concepts.md#c07) according to the [exit criterion](concepts.md#c04) the researcher has stated under a stated way of [cutting](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c23). It is the own concept of 'Production Dynamics' and is not the upstream [exit](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c43) (no longer a [vortex](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)): the criterion may be 'no longer a [vortex](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)' or any other explicit definition such as retirement, resignation, dissolution or a physiological threshold, so the two may coincide or not. Whether [criterion exit](concepts.md#c09) occurs is a fact about the state events of that [derivation round](concepts.md#c07); the criterion itself is a definition.\n\n## 不登記\n\n- 校準:2026-10-22 各節的固定欄目名,不是被定義的構件。\n- 範圍設定:2026-10-22 前提一的類型名,只用於該前提,不是被定義的構件。\n- 推演輪步驟、部件、接口:2026-10-22 本篇的結構標籤,不是被定義的構件。\n\n## 待決項\n\n無\n","formalization_md":"論文:《生產動力學》\nUUID:96f10d75-23d0-441f-94c7-ab87ca28d284\n\n## 記號約定\n\n來源:論文全文\n\n- 解散:一般用語,不是概念「解」\n- 環境:本篇文中的簡稱,指上游 2ccbf179-58cf-4851-bd72-5fa886e4b2c3.自然環境,不是其他論文的概念「環境」\n\n## 前置條件\n\n來源:論文第一節、第二節、第三節【正文:句0357609866、句3047017555、句7720259061】\n\n- 前提一:研究者在講明的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.切法 下,指定所選 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.節點 的邊界、狀態變數、資源變數,以及一條用 狀態變數 表述的 退場判準,並報告是誰作這個劃分;本篇不預設 資源變數、狀態變數 與 判準退場 之間的關係;本篇的記錄只涵蓋物理改變,37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別 也進入 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.歷史,但不在本篇的記錄範圍內【正文:句7409383169、句1977714181、句2396969540、句7519049399】\n- 前提二:每一 推演輪 依六步進行:各 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.節點 依各自 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.歷史 所決定的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.權重 落出 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出;b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 該 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.節點 自己、其他 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.節點 與 2ccbf179-58cf-4851-bd72-5fa886e4b2c3.自然環境;2ccbf179-58cf-4851-bd72-5fa886e4b2c3.自然環境 回應,其他 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.節點 也各自落出 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出,這些都可能 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 本 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.節點;37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 該 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.節點 的一切物理改變,進入該 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.節點 的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.歷史,參與後續 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.權重;研究者在 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.切法 下記錄各 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.節點 下一刻的 狀態變數、資源變數,並依 退場判準 記錄各 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.節點 是否 判準退場,這些合起來是該 推演輪 的 解;判準退場 者不再參與,其 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.歷史 仍在,b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.進場 者加入,其前史可與既有 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.節點 重疊;六步完成後回到 推演輪 步驟一;本篇的循環沒有內建的退出條件,是否停止由研究者在模型之外指定【正文:句2865019849、句8487355662、句0618818843、句7721087047】\n- 附註:本篇不假定各 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.節點 同步,推演輪 只是排序,沿用上游【正文:句2412220025】\n- 前提三:b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.節點 有可記錄的 狀態變數 與 資源變數,邊界由 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.切法 指定;什麼算「它的」,是研究者的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別,不涉所有權【正文:句0044489526】\n- 前提四:b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.節點 的 資源變數 在每一 推演輪 有增減,由實際事件決定;本篇不討論資源是否「移動」,也不討論不同 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.節點 的增減是否對應同一份東西;下游若需要這種對應,須由下游自行指定,並承擔其中對 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.同一 所作的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別【正文:句0044489526】\n\n## 定位與假定(對應論文第〇節)\n\n來源:論文第〇節【正文:句3972911508】\n\n- 附註:生產 是研究者對 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.歷史 的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別,不賦予 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 獨立本體【正文:句3722399613】\n- 附註:文中的 環境 即 2ccbf179-58cf-4851-bd72-5fa886e4b2c3.自然環境【正文:句1058545450】\n\n## 律與前提(對應論文第一節)\n\n來源:論文第一節【正文:句0357609866】\n\n- 附註:前提一是範圍設定,不是可被推翻的主張【正文:句7409383169】\n- 附註:適用範圍不限於人;人類視角下,退場判準 常寫在生理狀態上,某個 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.我 據此標為 fb0addca-42b6-4884-aa18-438c695747ab.死亡;判準退場 依研究者所訂判準記錄,與上游 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.退場 可以一致,也可以不一致,兩者不互相替代【正文:句7409383169】\n- 附註:退場判準 可以是上游的「不再是 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦」,也可以是生理界線、解散、退休等任一明示的定義【正文:句7409383169】\n- 附註:資源變數 與 狀態變數 的界線隨 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.節點 邊界而定,沒有物件本身的固定歸屬;可轉移、可儲存是常用的辨認依據,不是定義【正文:句7409383169】\n- 附註:資源變數、狀態變數 與 判準退場 的關係,本篇不預設;若有,屬具體 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.切法 下的經驗問題,由下游研究自行提出並承擔【正文:句7409383169】\n- 步驟一之一:退場判準 是研究者的一次 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別(從 前提一 + b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.切法 的定義 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別 的定義 + 退場判準 的定義 推出)【正文:句7409383169】\n- 步驟一之二:退場判準 講明後,某一 推演輪 是否 判準退場,由該 推演輪 實際的狀態事件決定(從 前提一 + 前提二 + 步驟一之一 推出)【正文:句7409383169】\n- 結論一之三:退場判準 是定義,是否 判準退場 是事實,兩者不互相替代(從 步驟一之一 + 步驟一之二 + 退場判準 的定義 推出)【正文:句7409383169】\n- 步驟一之四:什麼算某 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.節點 的 狀態變數 或 資源變數,隨 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.節點 邊界而定,而邊界是研究者的一次 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別(從 前提一 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別 的定義 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.同一 的定義 + 狀態變數 的定義 + 資源變數 的定義 推出)【正文:句7409383169】\n- 結論一之五:資源變數 與 狀態變數 的歸類是 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.切法 下的歸類,不是事物本身的性質(從 前提一 + 步驟一之四 推出)【正文:句7409383169】\n\n## 模型(對應論文第二節)\n\n來源:論文第二節【正文:句3047017555】\n\n- 附註:判準退場 只是 解 的一個維度,與其他維度並列,沒有特別地位【正文:句3321236901】\n- 附註:沒有記錄的東西不在 解 裡,但仍在 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.歷史 中【正文:句3321236901】\n- 附註:本篇的模型分兩個部件:部件一是上游循環(輸出、到達、入史、權重、進場、退場),承接上游,不新增機制;部件二是 解 的記錄(研究者記錄下一刻的 狀態變數、資源變數 與是否 判準退場),是本篇新增的記錄。六步 推演輪 不是本篇新增的機制【正文:句0968688904、句2130210315、句5174538367】\n- 循環二之一:推演輪 六步完成後回到步驟一,構成循環;本篇的循環沒有內建的退出條件,是否停止由研究者在模型之外指定;判準退場 只處理個別 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.節點,不是整體的終止條件(從 前提二 推出)【正文:句2865019849、句7721087047、句7261454543】\n- 附註:資源變數 是被記錄的變數,不參與 2ccbf179-58cf-4851-bd72-5fa886e4b2c3.共振【正文:句5510855591】\n\n## 由模型推出的性質(對應論文第二節)\n\n來源:論文第二節「由模型推出的性質」【正文:句2458374912】\n\n- 結論二之一:37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.權重 讀 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.歷史;解 的記錄本身不是 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.權重 的直接輸入;解 的記錄是研究者的選取(從 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.生成函數 的定義 + 前提二 + 解 的定義 推出)【正文:句7160284430】\n- 結論二之二:37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.歷史 只加不減,路徑依賴;資源變數 依實際事件可增可減;本篇不對記錄的變數設定不可逆限制(從 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.歷史 的定義 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.不可復原律 + 前提二 + 前提四 推出)【正文:句7160284430】\n- 結論二之三:判準退場 只是 解 的一個維度;退場判準 只對被記錄的 狀態變數 作判定,不對 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.歷史 全體,也不對 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.權重(從 前提一 + 結論一之三 + 前提二 + 解 的定義 推出)【正文:句7160284430】\n- 結論二之四:對不被 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.鎖死 的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦,同樣的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出,不保證得到同樣的 解(從 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.黑箱律 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.鎖死 的定義 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.權重 的定義 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.流變律 + b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 的定義 + 解 的定義 + 前提二 推出)【正文:句7160284430】\n- 結論二之五:多人時,其他 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.節點 的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 可能 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 本 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.節點,37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 後進入 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.歷史、參與後續 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.權重,因此一個 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.節點 的 解 可能受自己與其他 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.節點 的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 共同影響(從 前提二 推出)【正文:句7160284430】\n- 結論二之六:每 推演輪 成員可能變動;成員變動時,各 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.節點 的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.歷史 與 2ccbf179-58cf-4851-bd72-5fa886e4b2c3.共振 條件可能隨之變(從 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.流變律 + b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.進場 的定義 + 判準退場 的定義 + 2ccbf179-58cf-4851-bd72-5fa886e4b2c3.共振 的定義 + 前提二 推出)【正文:句7160284430】\n- 結論二之七:本模型不要求 解 最優、守恆、收斂或平衡(從 前提一 + 前提四 + 解 的定義 推出)【正文:句7160284430】\n- 結論二之八:本模型不指定回應的內容與增減的數量,因此不能預測軌跡(從 前提二 + 前提四 + 解 的定義 推出)【正文:句3111321759】\n- 結論二之九:多人時,在 生產 維度上,若 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.節點 的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 彼此 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達,並在講明的時窗內序列反覆相容接續,即為 2ccbf179-58cf-4851-bd72-5fa886e4b2c3.共振;若再滿足上游對 2ccbf179-58cf-4851-bd72-5fa886e4b2c3.文化 的條件,則 2ccbf179-58cf-4851-bd72-5fa886e4b2c3.共振 留下的相容圖樣,是 2ccbf179-58cf-4851-bd72-5fa886e4b2c3.文化 在 生產 維度上的呈現(從 前提二 + 2ccbf179-58cf-4851-bd72-5fa886e4b2c3.共振 的定義 + 2ccbf179-58cf-4851-bd72-5fa886e4b2c3.文化 的定義 + 生產 的定義 推出)【正文:句5023600071】\n- 結論二之十:粗細兩種記錄的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.權重 是否一致,不由 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.重切 的定義保證;要主張一致,須講明粗記錄所問的結果如何由細記錄得到,未講明者只能各自報告,不互相推論(從 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.重切 的定義 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.權重 的定義 推出)【正文:句9623960787、句9277755527】\n- 結論二之十一:若 目的 表現為 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.節點 對自己的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別,則它進入 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.歷史,並只經 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.權重 影響後續 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出;本篇不確認也不預設 目的 的內容(從 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別 的定義 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.歷史 的定義 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.權重 的定義 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.生成函數 的定義 + 前提二 + ae79e938-76e1-4bf9-b2ab-995c03e16c9e.驅動力不可確認 推出)【正文:句0224293038】\n\n## 人類視角(對應論文第四節)\n\n來源:論文第四節【正文:句1681178149】\n\n- 步驟四之一:b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.進場 者的前史可能與既有 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.節點 重疊(從 前提二 推出)【正文:句9535130350】\n- 結論四之二:b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.進場 者的前史即使與既有 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.節點 重疊,也不蘊涵他繼承親代的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.歷史、37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.權重 或 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出(從 步驟四之一 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 的定義 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.歷史 的定義 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.權重 的定義 + b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 的定義 + 2ccbf179-58cf-4851-bd72-5fa886e4b2c3.學習 的定義 推出)【正文:句9535130350】\n- 附註:親代的生物性原材料與 2ccbf179-58cf-4851-bd72-5fa886e4b2c3.學習 分開:前者是生物構成,後者沿用上游的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 與 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.歷史【正文:句2241528541】\n\n## 權重推測不能替代判定(對應論文第五節之二)\n\n來源:論文第五節之二【正文:句3141630626】\n\n- 附註:本節與五之五所稱「不被 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.鎖死」,依上游 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.鎖死 的定義【正文:句3686779431】\n- 步驟五之二之一:37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.我 對 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦 的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.權重 推測(上游稱 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.印象)的對象是分支的輕重,判定的對象是已發生的事件(從 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.權重 的定義 + b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.印象 的定義 + 步驟一之二 推出)【正文:句8505778525】\n- 步驟五之二之二:對不被 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.鎖死 的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦,37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.權重 只推出傾向,推不出結果(從 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.黑箱律 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.鎖死 的定義 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.權重 的定義 推出)【正文:句8505778525】\n- 結論五之二之三:對不被 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.鎖死 的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦,37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.權重 推測給不出完整的下一刻;是否 判準退場 仍須由實際事件判定,不能以 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.權重 推測替代(從 步驟一之二 + 步驟五之二之一 + 步驟五之二之二 推出)【正文:句8505778525】\n\n## 已發生的進場不被取消(對應論文第五節之三)\n\n來源:論文第五節之三【正文:句3857686981】\n\n- 步驟五之三之一:b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.退場 不刪除 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.歷史 中已發生的位置(從 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.歷史 的定義 推出)【正文:句2903673102】\n- 步驟五之三之二:是不是 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦 由實際的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.歷史 決定;b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.進場 是開始成為 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦(包括第一個時刻就是 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦 的情形),b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.退場 是不再是 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦;每一次 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.退場,都在其對應的那一次 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.進場 之後(從 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.歷史 的定義 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦 的定義 + b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.進場 的定義 + b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.退場 的定義 推出)【正文:句2903673102】\n- 步驟五之三之三:b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.退場 的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦,37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.自己的那一段 仍在 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.歷史 中(從 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.退場 的定義 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.歷史 的定義 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.自己的那一段 的定義 推出)【正文:句2903673102】\n- 結論五之三之四:b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.退場 不取消已發生的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.進場,也不取消 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.進場 者留下的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達(從 步驟五之三之一 + 步驟五之三之二 + 步驟五之三之三 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 的定義 推出)【正文:句2903673102】\n- 附註:判準退場 是研究者的記錄,不改變 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.歷史【正文:句2903673102】\n\n## 資源變數 的來源歸屬不影響判定方式(對應論文第五節之四)\n\n來源:論文第五節之四【正文:句7226386278】\n\n- 步驟五之四之一:若 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.節點 的 資源變數 在某 推演輪 有增加,則該增加是實際事件的記錄(從 前提四 推出)【正文:句7060052207】\n- 步驟五之四之二:是否把這次增加記為與其他 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.節點 的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 相關,是研究者的歸屬(從 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別 的定義 + b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 的定義 + 前提四 推出)【正文:句7060052207】\n- 步驟五之四之三:在同一 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.切法 內,某 推演輪 是否 判準退場,只看 狀態變數 與 退場判準,不看 資源變數 的來源歸屬(從 前提一 + 步驟一之二 推出)【正文:句7060052207】\n- 結論五之四之四:資源變數 的增加如何歸屬,不改變是否 判準退場 的判定方式;本篇不由此推出資源與狀態的關係(從 步驟五之四之二 + 步驟五之四之三 推出)【正文:句7060052207】\n- 附註:這不推出其他 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.節點 有給予的意圖,也不推出整個網路的資源總量增加;前者受 ae79e938-76e1-4bf9-b2ab-995c03e16c9e.驅動力不可確認 約束,後者須在同一 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.切法 內另行核算【正文:句7060052207】\n\n## 變異與篩選不蘊涵改善、最優或永續(對應論文第五節之五)\n\n來源:論文第五節之五【正文:句7903782234】\n\n- 步驟五之五之一:對不被 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.鎖死 的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦,由 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.歷史 決定的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.權重 只推出傾向,結果可變異(從 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.黑箱律 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.鎖死 的定義 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.權重 的定義 推出)【正文:句8215475175】\n- 步驟五之五之二:本篇不要求 退場判準 含有任何「較優」的條件;退場判準 只是研究者指定的一條用 狀態變數 表述的條件(從 前提一 推出)【正文:句8215475175】\n- 步驟五之五之三:退場判準 是否被滿足,與 資源變數 的變化各自記錄,本篇不推出兩者的關係(從 前提一 + 前提二 推出)【正文:句8215475175】\n- 結論五之五之四:b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 變異與 判準退場 記錄,不足以推出狀態或資源的單調改善、最優或永續(從 步驟五之五之一 + 步驟五之五之二 + 步驟五之五之三 + 結論二之二 + b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 的定義 + 退場判準 的定義 + 判準退場 的定義 推出)【正文:句8215475175】\n- 附註:「篩選」在上游只作比喻,須標明是比喻【正文:句8215475175】\n\n## 增減記錄不蘊涵輸出類型(對應論文第五節之六)\n\n來源:論文第五節之六【正文:句1079948435】\n\n- 步驟五之六之一:資源變數 的增減,是相關 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.節點 各自的記錄,由實際事件決定(從 前提四 推出)【正文:句9486557784】\n- 步驟五之六之二:b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 對方後,進入對方的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.歷史(從 前提二 + b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 的定義 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 的定義 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.歷史 的定義 推出)【正文:句9486557784】\n- 結論五之六之三:若 資源變數 只記數值增減、不含 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 類型的資訊,則 資源變數 的帳目只記數值增減;b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 類型是研究者另行加上的分類標記,不在 資源變數 帳目的記錄範圍內,故不由 資源變數 的帳目讀出(從 前提一 + 步驟五之六之一 + 步驟五之六之二 + 解 的定義 推出)【正文:句9486557784】\n- 附註:動機、需求與目的受 ae79e938-76e1-4bf9-b2ab-995c03e16c9e.驅動力不可確認 約束,不由帳目讀出;這只限於動機,不當作類型不可辨識的充分證明【正文:句9486557784】\n- 附註:暴力、交換、贈與、欺騙等,是研究者對 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 的命名,不是模型的組成【正文:句9486557784】\n- 附註:本篇不替所有權與正當性預設前件【正文:句9486557784】\n\n## 資源與狀態的邊界是切法(對應論文第五節之七)\n\n來源:論文第五節之七【正文:句7893397929】\n\n- 步驟五之七之一:研究者可以在不同 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.節點、不同視角的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.切法 下,各自記下與某個對象有關的 資源變數 或 狀態變數(從 結論一之五 + 前提三 推出)【正文:句9459796894】\n- 附註:例如研究者可在住戶與國家領土兩個 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.節點 的帳目裡,各自記下與一棟房子有關的變數;工人的勞動對工人記為狀態,對老闆記為資源【正文:句9459796894】\n- 結論五之七之二:不同 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.節點 的帳目裡出現與同一對象有關的變數,不構成矛盾,也不推出所有權的歸屬,也不預設這些變數指的是同一件東西(從 步驟五之七之一 + 前提三 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.同一 的定義 推出)【正文:句9459796894】\n- 步驟五之七之三:跨 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.切法 的變數,範疇各由自己的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.切法 決定,本篇不預設它們指同一件東西;與同一對象有關的變數若直接相加,重複計算只是其中一種後果(從 結論一之五 + 結論五之七之二 推出)【正文:句9459796894】\n- 結論五之七之四:本篇不主張資源在 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.節點 之間「移動」,只記各 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.節點 的 資源變數 的增減(從 前提四 推出)【正文:句4629394187】\n- 附註:移動預設 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.同一,而 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.同一 是 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別;這是本篇不談移動的理由,不是推導來源【正文:句4629394187】\n- 附註:本篇不跨 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.切法 加總 資源變數 與 狀態變數(正文禁止清單第 3 項);總量只在同一 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.切法 內核算;不同 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.切法 的結論不直接互推【正文:句8504334623、句9459796894】\n- 附註:在本篇例示的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.切法 下,工人是 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.節點,不是資源;老闆的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.切法 下記錄的是工人的勞動(b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出)所對應的 資源變數【正文:句9459796894、句2979635545】\n\n## 失效條件(對應論文第七節)\n\n來源:論文第七節【正文:句1030794685】\n\n- 附註:前提一是範圍設定,前提二至前提四是 推演輪 結構與接口的設定,都不是可被推翻的主張,否定它們的意思,是換成另一套設定【正文:句3040346238、句6988065577】\n- 結論七之一:前提一 至 前提四 各自的否定條件成立時,來源鏈含該前提的結論失去來源;失去來源只表示推導鏈斷開,不表示這些結論為假(從 前提一 + 前提二 + 前提三 + 前提四 推出)【正文:句3040346238、句6988065577】\n- 附註:本篇的推導依賴上游的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.黑箱律、37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.流變律、37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.不可復原律 與若干概念的定義;它們是否成立由上游論文處理,本篇不另設失效條件【正文:句5540609986】\n- 附註:下游若引入資源與 判準退場 的關係,或不同 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.節點 增減之間的對應關係,該關係是下游的經驗前件,或對 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.同一 所作的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別,其失效不影響本篇【正文:句2317171883】\n\n## 待決項\n\n無\n","paper_files":[{"filename":"生產動力學.md","content":"---\nuuid: 96f10d75-23d0-441f-94c7-ab87ca28d284\nlast-modified: 2026-11-04T14:15:11\nauthor: 黃正宇 / Cheng Yu Huang\ncontact: mthree.tw@gmail.com\n---\n\n# 生產動力學\n\n## 〇、定位與假定\n\n本篇是承接上游的綱領論文,不新增機制。它在上游的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)、[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)、[歷史](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13)、[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06)循環之上,加一層研究者的記錄,描述各[節點](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25)每一[推演輪](concepts.md#c07)的[解](concepts.md#c05):下一刻的[狀態](concepts.md#c02)、[資源](concepts.md#c03),以及是否[判準退場](concepts.md#c09)。對下游(例如暴力動力學)只提供一種記帳格式:[節點](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25)有[狀態變數](concepts.md#c02)與[資源變數](concepts.md#c03);[資源變數](concepts.md#c03)在每一[推演輪](concepts.md#c07)有增減;[退場判準](concepts.md#c04)寫在[狀態變數](concepts.md#c02)上。\n\n[生產](concepts.md#c01)是研究者對[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)[歷史](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13)的[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18),不賦予[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)獨立本體。[資源](concepts.md#c03)、[狀態](concepts.md#c02)與[判準退場](concepts.md#c09)都是研究者的[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18),本篇不預設三者之間有任何關係。\n\n各節的「校準」與第六章的案例,只拿現實對照,不屬於推導的任何一部分,也不作推導來源。\n\n本篇所稱[環境](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c16),即上游的[自然環境](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c16):在講明的[切法](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c23)下,不屬於任何[節點](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25)、卻有[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)各[節點](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25)的部分。\n\n---\n\n## 一、律與前提\n\n**承接。** [流變律](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c24)、[黑箱律](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c25)、[損耗律](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c26)、[不可復原律](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c28);[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)、[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19)、[進場](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c44)、[退場](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c43)、[死亡](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c22)、[自己的那一段](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c17)、[切法](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c23)、[自然環境](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c16)、[共振](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c09)、[文化](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c13)等,沿用上游定義,不重新定義。\n\n```text\n前提一 範圍設定:研究者在講明的切法下,指定所選節點的邊界、\n 狀態變數、資源變數,以及一條用狀態變數表述的退場判準,\n 並報告是誰作這個劃分。本篇不預設資源、狀態與判準退場之間的關係。\n 本篇的記錄只涵蓋物理改變;分別也進入歷史,但不在本篇的記錄範圍內。\n附註 前提一是範圍設定,不是可被推翻的主張。\n 適用範圍不限於人;人類視角下,退場判準常寫在生理狀態上,某個我據此標為死亡;\n 判準退場依研究者所訂判準記錄,與上游的退場可以一致,也可以不一致,兩者不互相替代。\n 判準可以是上游的「不再是渦」,也可以是生理界線、解散、退休等任一明示的定義。\n附註 資源與狀態的界線隨節點邊界而定,沒有物件本身的固定歸屬。\n 可轉移、可儲存是常用的辨認依據,不是定義:\n 在某節點的視角下可轉移、可儲存者常記為資源,不可轉移、不可儲存者常記為狀態。\n 研究者可以把與某個對象有關的變數,在不同節點、不同視角的切法下,\n 歸入資源或狀態(例如義眼,或工人的勞動對工人與對老闆)。\n附註 資源、狀態與判準退場的關係,本篇不預設。兩端都是研究者的分別,\n 通則層寫不出內容;若有,屬具體切法下的經驗問題,\n 由下游研究自行提出並承擔。\n步驟一之一 退場判準是研究者的一次分別(從 前提一 + 切法 的定義 + 分別 的定義 + 退場判準 的定義 推出)\n步驟一之二 判準講明後,某一推演輪是否判準退場,由該推演輪實際的狀態事件決定\n (從 前提一 + 前提二 + 步驟一之一 推出)\n結論一之三 判準是定義,是否判準退場是事實,兩者不互相替代\n (從 步驟一之一 + 步驟一之二 + 退場判準 的定義 推出)\n步驟一之四 什麼算某節點的狀態或資源,隨節點邊界而定,\n 而邊界是研究者的一次分別(從 前提一 + 分別 的定義 + 同一 的定義 + 狀態變數 的定義 + 資源變數 的定義 推出)\n結論一之五 資源與狀態的歸類是切法下的歸類,不是事物本身的性質\n (從 前提一 + 步驟一之四 推出)\n```\n\n\n**校準。** 退休算[判準退場](concepts.md#c09),生理狀態達到指定的界線也算[判準退場](concepts.md#c09)(常被某個[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19)標為[死亡](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c22)),公司解散也是[判準退場](concepts.md#c09),各由使用者定義,所以[判準](concepts.md#c04)是定義;某個人在某一[推演輪](concepts.md#c07)是否真的退休或達到該界線,才是事實。義眼算不算他的一部分,義眼使用者與保險公司可以各有說法;工人的心情與體力,對他自己是[狀態變數](concepts.md#c02),工人投入的勞動,對老闆是可取得的[資源變數](concepts.md#c03)。這是校準,不是推導來源。\n\n### 禁止清單(方法上禁止)\n\n1. 不把[判準](concepts.md#c04)當作事實,也不把[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06)推測當作判定。\n2. 不由[資源變數](concepts.md#c03)的增減記錄,推出這次增減屬於哪一類[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28),或推出動機與正當性。\n3. 不跨[切法](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c23)加總[資源變數](concepts.md#c03)與[狀態變數](concepts.md#c02)。\n4. 不由存續推最優,不由變異推改善。\n5. 不替所有權、正當性預設前件。\n6. 不把某一種歸類當成事物本身的性質(例如「眼睛是狀態」「錢是資源」),須連同[切法](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c23)一起說。\n7. 不替[資源](concepts.md#c03)與[判準退場](concepts.md#c09)預設關係;要主張,須先定義具體的[資源](concepts.md#c03)與具體的[退場判準](concepts.md#c04)。\n8. 不談資源是否「移動」:移動預設[同一性](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c21),而[同一](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c21)是[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18);本篇只記各[節點](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25)[資源變數](concepts.md#c03)的增減。\n9. 不把「篩選」「淘汰」當作有目的的過程,只作比喻。\n\n---\n\n## 二、模型\n\n本篇把模型往前推進一次的單位稱為[推演輪](concepts.md#c07):在講明的[切法](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c23)下,在場的各[節點](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25)各走一次上游的循環,再加上研究者所作的記錄,以及成員的變動。單位是整個切出的範圍,不是單一[節點](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25);記錄什麼、成員怎麼變動,由使用者指定;不假定各[節點](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25)同步,[推演輪](concepts.md#c07)只是排序。\n\n本篇的模型是按[推演輪](concepts.md#c07)推進的遞迴,沿用上游的循環。每一[推演輪](concepts.md#c07),各[節點](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25)[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28),[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)自己、其他[節點](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25)與[環境](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c16),[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)的物理改變進入[歷史](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13)。**求[解](concepts.md#c05)就是:我現在[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28),下一刻我會變成什麼樣子;那個樣子就是這一[推演輪](concepts.md#c07)的[解](concepts.md#c05)。** 單人與多人用同一個模型:多人只是研究者把原本放在[環境](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c16)裡的一部分切出來當成[節點](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25),各[節點](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25)的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)互相進入對方的下一刻。\n\n```text\n前提二 推演輪結構:每一推演輪依下列六步進行\n推演輪步驟一 輸出 在場的各節點,依各自歷史所決定的權重,落出輸出。 (上游)\n推演輪步驟二 到達 輸出到達節點自己,也到達其他節點與環境。 (上游)\n推演輪步驟三 回應 自然環境回應;其他節點也各自落出輸出。這些都可能到達本節點。\n 自然環境內部是什麼,本篇不問。\n推演輪步驟四 入史 到達節點的一切物理改變,不論來自自己的輸出、其他節點的輸出\n 或環境的回應,都進入該節點的歷史,參與後續權重。\n 權重由歷史決定,不可讀。 (上游)\n推演輪步驟五 解 研究者在切法下記錄各節點下一刻的狀態變數、資源變數,\n 並依退場判準記錄各節點是否判準退場。這些合起來,就是本推演輪的解。\n推演輪步驟六 成員變動 判準退場者不再參與,其歷史仍在;進場者加入,前史可與既有節點重疊。\n回到推演輪步驟一。\n本篇的循環沒有內建的退出條件;是否停止,由研究者在模型之外指定。\n```\n\n\n```text\n定義 解:研究者在講明的切法下,記錄的各節點下一刻的狀態變數、資源變數,\n 以及依退場判準所記的是否判準退場,合起來是本推演輪的解。\n附註 判準退場只是解的一個維度,與其他維度並列,沒有特別地位。\n附註 沒有記錄的東西不在解裡,但仍在歷史中。\n```\n\n\n**說明**\n\n1. [歷史](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13)包含所有[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)[節點](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25)的物理改變。沒被記錄的部分仍在[歷史](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13)裡,繼續影響[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06)。\n2. [解](concepts.md#c05)不預設最優,也不預設與目的或資源有關。[節點](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25)是否[判準退場](concepts.md#c09),只是現實給的限制:一個人下一刻是否被車撞死,與他想要什麼、有多少資源,都沒有必然關係。\n3. 目的若表現為各[節點](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25)對自己的[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18),就進入[歷史](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13),只經[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06)影響後續[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28);本篇不確認、不預設其內容(承接上游[驅動力不可確認](../paper_ae79e938_76e1_4bf9_b2ab_995c03e16c9e/concepts.md#c03))。\n4. 多人時,一個[節點](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25)的[解](concepts.md#c05)可能同時受自己的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)與其他[節點](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25)的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)影響;各[節點](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25)下一刻合起來,就是整個切出範圍的[解](concepts.md#c05)。每個人各自[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28),彼此的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)進入對方的下一刻,求[解](concepts.md#c05)因此是多人共同發生的過程,不是各記各的帳。\n5. 本篇的記錄只涵蓋物理改變。[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)(對自己或他人的看法)也會進入[歷史](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13),沿用上游,不在本篇記錄。\n6. 不假定各[節點](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25)同步,[推演輪](concepts.md#c07)只是排序,沿用上游。\n7. 本篇不規定回應是什麼、增減多少。同樣的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28),今天與明天的回應可以不同。\n8. 本篇的[推演輪](concepts.md#c07)循環沒有內建的退出條件;是否停止,由研究者在模型之外指定。[判準退場](concepts.md#c09)只處理個別[節點](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25),不是整體的終止條件。\n\n**校準。** 我去挖礦,[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)的是勞力;礦山回應,我下一刻手上多了一塊礦石,體力下降,這就是我這一[推演輪](concepts.md#c07)的[解](concepts.md#c05)。明天同樣挖,礦石不一定出現。另一個人走在路上要去喝酒,被車撞死:他的[解](concepts.md#c05)裡,是否[判準退場](concepts.md#c09)這一維度記為[判準退場](concepts.md#c09);這與他想要什麼、有多少資源無關,只是現實給的限制。這是校準,不是推導來源。\n\n### 部件\n\n| 部件 | 內容 | 根據 |\n|---|---|---|\n| 部件一 上游循環 | [輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)、[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)、入史、[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06)、[進場](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c44)、[退場](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c43) | 承接,不新增 |\n| 部件二 [解](concepts.md#c05)的記錄 | 研究者記錄下一刻的[狀態變數](concepts.md#c02)、[資源變數](concepts.md#c03)與是否[判準退場](concepts.md#c09) | 前提一、前提三、前提四 |\n\n### 多人時的命名\n\n多人時,各[節點](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25)的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)互相進入對方的下一刻。在[生產](concepts.md#c01)維度上,若這些[節點](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25)的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)彼此[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10),並在講明的時窗內序列反覆相容接續,即為上游所稱的[共振](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c09);若再滿足上游對[文化](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c13)的條件,則[共振](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c09)留下的相容圖樣,是上游所稱的[文化](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c13)在[生產](concepts.md#c01)維度上的呈現。[資源變數](concepts.md#c03)是被記錄的變數,不參與[共振](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c09)。交換、傳遞、合作、掠奪等,是研究者對這類[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)序列的命名,不是模型的組成,也不由帳目讀出(見五之六)。\n\n把若干[節點](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25)合成一個,或把一個拆成若干[節點](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25),是[重切](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c22)。若要主張粗細兩種記錄的[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06)一致,須講明粗記錄所問的結果如何由細記錄得到;未講明者,只能各自報告,不互相推論。\n\n### 由模型推出的性質\n\n```text\n結論二之一 權重讀歷史;解的記錄本身不是權重的直接輸入;解的記錄是研究者的選取\n (從 生成函數 的定義 + 前提二 + 解 的定義 推出)\n結論二之二 歷史只加不減,路徑依賴;資源變數依實際事件可增可減,本篇不對記錄的變數設定不可逆限制\n (從 歷史 的定義 + 不可復原律 + 前提二 + 前提四 推出)\n結論二之三 判準退場只是解的一個維度;判準只對被記錄的狀態變數作判定,不對歷史全體,也不對權重\n (從 前提一 + 結論一之三 + 前提二 + 解 的定義 推出)\n結論二之四 對不被鎖死的渦,同樣的輸出不保證得到同樣的解\n (從 黑箱律 + 鎖死 的定義 + 權重 的定義 + 流變律 + 輸出 的定義 + 解 的定義 + 前提二 推出)\n結論二之五 多人時,其他節點的輸出可能到達本節點,到達後進入歷史、參與後續權重,\n 因此一個節點的解可能受自己與其他節點的輸出共同影響\n (從 前提二 推出)\n結論二之六 每推演輪成員可能變動;成員變動時,各節點的歷史與共振條件可能隨之變\n (從 流變律 + 進場 的定義 + 判準退場 的定義 + 共振 的定義 + 前提二 推出)\n結論二之七 本模型不要求解最優、守恆、收斂或平衡\n (從 前提一 + 前提四 + 解 的定義 推出)\n結論二之八 本模型不指定回應的內容與增減的數量,因此不能預測軌跡\n (從 前提二 + 前提四 + 解 的定義 推出)\n結論二之九 多人時,在生產維度上,若節點的輸出彼此到達,並在講明的時窗內序列反覆相容接續,即為共振;若再滿足上游對文化的條件,則共振留下的相容圖樣,是文化在生產維度上的呈現\n (從 前提二 + 共振 的定義 + 文化 的定義 + 生產 的定義 推出)\n結論二之十 粗細兩種記錄的權重是否一致,不由重切的定義保證;要主張一致,須講明粗記錄所問的結果如何由細記錄得到,未講明者只能各自報告,不互相推論\n (從 重切 的定義 + 權重 的定義 推出)\n結論二之十一 目的若表現為節點對自己的分別,則它進入歷史,並只經權重影響後續輸出;本篇不確認也不預設目的的內容\n (從 分別 的定義 + 歷史 的定義 + 權重 的定義 + 生成函數 的定義 + 前提二 + 驅動力不可確認 推出)\n```\n\n\n### 這個模型不是什麼\n\n它不規定回應是什麼、增減多少,所以**不能預測軌跡**,只能說記什麼、哪條線與哪條線在何處相交、哪些性質可推。實際的[解](concepts.md#c05)要由具體案例提供資料或規則。層級沿用上游互動動力學各篇的做法:轉移不指定,只推定性性質。\n\n---\n\n## 三、接口\n\n```text\n前提三 節點有可記錄的狀態變數與資源變數,邊界由切法指定;\n 什麼算「它的」,是研究者的分別,不涉所有權。\n前提四 節點的資源變數在每一推演輪有增減,由實際事件決定。\n 本篇不討論資源是否「移動」,也不討論不同節點的增減是否對應同一份東西;\n 下游若需要這種對應,須由下游自行指定,並承擔其中的同一性分別。\n```\n\n\n---\n\n## 四、人類視角(前提一的實例)\n\n人類視角下,[退場判準](concepts.md#c04)常寫在生理狀態上,某個[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19)據此對[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)標上[死亡](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c22);本篇的[判準退場](concepts.md#c09)依研究者所訂判準記錄,與上游的[退場](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c43)可以一致,也可以不一致,不互相替代;[狀態變數](concepts.md#c02)例如體力、能量儲備、生理狀態,[資源變數](concepts.md#c03)例如食物,由研究者指定。出生只是[進場](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c44):[進場](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c44)者的前史若含親代的生物性原材料,那是[進場](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c44)時的前史重疊,不另立事件。親代的生物性原材料與[學習](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c04)分開:前者是生物構成,後者沿用上游的[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)與[歷史](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13),不保證複製親代的知識、[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06)或[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)。\n\n```text\n步驟四之一 進場者的前史可能與既有節點重疊\n (從 前提二 推出)\n結論四之二 進場者的前史即使與既有節點重疊,也不蘊涵他繼承親代的歷史、權重或輸出\n (從 步驟四之一 + 到達 的定義 + 歷史 的定義 + 權重 的定義 + 輸出 的定義 + 學習 的定義 推出)\n```\n\n\n---\n\n## 五、不蘊涵關係\n\n| 編號 | 內容 | 推導 |\n|---|---|---|\n| 五之一 | [判準](concepts.md#c04)是定義,是否[判準退場](concepts.md#c09)是事實 | 結論一之三 |\n| 五之二 | 不被[鎖死](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c12)時,[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06)推測不能替代對是否[判準退場](concepts.md#c09)的判定 | 見下 |\n| 五之三 | 已發生的[進場](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c44)不因後來的[退場](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c43)而取消 | 見下 |\n| 五之四 | [資源變數](concepts.md#c03)的來源歸屬不影響是否[判準退場](concepts.md#c09)的判定方式 | 見下 |\n| 五之五 | 變異與篩選不蘊涵改善、最優或永續 | 見下 |\n| 五之六 | [資源變數](concepts.md#c03)的增減不蘊涵這次增減屬於哪一類[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) | 見下 |\n| 五之七 | [資源](concepts.md#c03)與[狀態](concepts.md#c02)的邊界是[切法](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c23),不同[節點](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25)可各自記下與某對象有關的變數 | 見下 |\n\n### 五之二 權重推測不能替代判定\n\n本節與五之五所稱「不被[鎖死](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c12)」,依上游[鎖死](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c12)的定義。\n\n```text\n步驟五之二之一 我對渦的權重推測(上游稱印象)的對象是分支的輕重,\n 判定的對象是已發生的事件\n (從 權重 的定義 + 印象 的定義 + 步驟一之二 推出)\n步驟五之二之二 對不被鎖死的渦,權重只推出傾向,推不出結果\n (從 黑箱律 + 鎖死 的定義 + 權重 的定義 推出)\n結論五之二之三 對不被鎖死的渦,權重推測給不出完整的下一刻;\n 是否判準退場仍須由實際事件判定,不能以權重推測替代\n (從 步驟一之二 + 步驟五之二之一 + 步驟五之二之二 推出)\n```\n\n\n### 五之三 已發生的進場不被取消\n\n```text\n步驟五之三之一 退場不刪除歷史中已發生的位置\n (從 歷史 的定義 推出)\n步驟五之三之二 是不是渦由實際的歷史決定;進場是開始成為渦(包括第一個時刻就是渦的情形),\n 退場是不再是渦;每一次退場,都在其對應的那一次進場之後\n (從 歷史 的定義 + 渦 的定義 + 進場 的定義 + 退場 的定義 推出)\n步驟五之三之三 退場的渦,自己的那一段仍在歷史中\n (從 退場 的定義 + 歷史 的定義 + 自己的那一段 的定義 推出)\n結論五之三之四 退場不取消已發生的進場,也不取消進場者留下的到達\n (從 步驟五之三之一 + 步驟五之三之二 + 步驟五之三之三 + 到達 的定義 推出)\n附註 判準退場是研究者的記錄,不改變歷史。\n```\n\n\n**校準。** 一個人生下孩子之後[退場](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c43):孩子的[進場](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c44)與他自己的[退場](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c43),都在[歷史](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13)裡各占一個位置,後者不取消前者。這是校準,不是推導來源。\n\n### 五之四 資源變數的來源歸屬不影響判定方式\n\n```text\n步驟五之四之一 若節點的資源變數在某推演輪有增加,則該增加是實際事件的記錄\n (從 前提四 推出)\n步驟五之四之二 是否把這次增加記為與其他節點的輸出相關,是研究者的歸屬\n (從 分別 的定義 + 輸出 的定義 + 前提四 推出)\n步驟五之四之三 在同一切法內,某推演輪是否判準退場,只看狀態變數與判準,\n 不看資源變數的來源歸屬\n (從 前提一 + 步驟一之二 推出)\n結論五之四之四 資源變數的增加如何歸屬,不改變是否判準退場的判定方式;\n 本篇不由此推出資源與狀態的關係\n (從 步驟五之四之二 + 步驟五之四之三 推出)\n附註 這不推出其他節點有給予的意圖,也不推出整個網路的資源總量增加;\n 前者受驅動力不可確認約束,後者須在同一切法內另行核算。\n```\n\n\n**校準。** 一個窮人一天只吃一碗飯,一個有錢人可以吃牛排、火雞與各式漢堡,兩人的[資源變數](concepts.md#c03)很不一樣,但沒有任何道理說窮人必須立刻[判準退場](concepts.md#c09)。反過來,一個有錢人走在路上被車撞死,他死不是因為慾望,也不是因為資源不足。[判準退場](concepts.md#c09)與想要什麼、有多少資源都沒有必然關係,只是現實給的限制。這是校準,不是推導來源。\n\n### 五之五 變異與篩選不蘊涵改善、最優或永續\n\n```text\n步驟五之五之一 對不被鎖死的渦,由歷史決定的權重只推出傾向,結果可變異\n (從 黑箱律 + 鎖死 的定義 + 權重 的定義 推出)\n步驟五之五之二 本篇不要求退場判準含有任何「較優」的條件;\n 判準只是研究者指定的一條用狀態變數表述的條件\n (從 前提一 推出)\n步驟五之五之三 判準是否被滿足,與資源變數的變化各自記錄,\n 本篇不推出兩者的關係\n (從 前提一 + 前提二 推出)\n結論五之五之四 輸出變異與判準退場記錄,不足以推出狀態或資源的單調改善、最優或永續\n (從 步驟五之五之一 + 步驟五之五之二 + 步驟五之五之三 + 結論二之二 + 輸出 的定義 + 退場判準 的定義 + 判準退場 的定義 推出)\n附註 「篩選」在上游只作比喻,須標明是比喻。\n```\n\n\n### 五之六 增減記錄不蘊涵輸出類型\n\n```text\n步驟五之六之一 資源變數的增減,是相關節點各自的記錄,由實際事件決定\n (從 前提四 推出)\n步驟五之六之二 輸出到達對方後,進入對方的歷史\n (從 前提二 + 輸出 的定義 + 到達 的定義 + 歷史 的定義 推出)\n結論五之六之三 若資源變數只記數值增減、不含輸出類型的資訊,則資源變數的帳目只記數值增減;輸出類型是研究者另行加上的分類標記,\n 不在資源變數帳目的記錄範圍內,故不由資源變數的帳目讀出\n (從 前提一 + 步驟五之六之一 + 步驟五之六之二 + 解 的定義 推出)\n附註 動機、需求與目的受驅動力不可確認約束,不由帳目讀出;\n 這只限於動機,不當作類型不可辨識的充分證明。\n附註 暴力、交換、贈與、欺騙等,是研究者對輸出的命名,不是模型的組成。\n附註 本篇不替所有權與正當性預設前件。\n```\n\n\n**校準。** 暴力、賄賂、恐嚇、詐欺,在帳目上看,都只是有人的某個[資源變數](concepts.md#c03)減少、有人的增加;它們的差別在[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)與[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)的內容,由研究者命名。這是校準,不是推導來源。\n\n### 五之七 資源與狀態的邊界是切法\n\n```text\n步驟五之七之一 研究者可以在不同節點、不同視角的切法下,\n 各自記下與某個對象有關的資源變數或狀態變數\n (從 結論一之五 + 前提三 推出;例如研究者可在住戶與國家領土兩個節點的帳目裡,\n 各自記下與一棟房子有關的變數;工人的勞動對工人記為狀態,對老闆記為資源)\n結論五之七之二 不同節點的帳目裡出現與同一對象有關的變數,不構成矛盾,\n 也不推出所有權的歸屬,也不預設這些變數指的是同一件東西\n (從 步驟五之七之一 + 前提三 + 同一 的定義 推出)\n步驟五之七之三 跨切法的變數,範疇各由自己的切法決定,本篇不預設它們指同一件東西;\n 與同一對象有關的變數若直接相加,重複計算只是其中一種後果\n (從 結論一之五 + 結論五之七之二 推出)\n結論五之七之四 本篇不主張資源在節點之間「移動」,只記各節點的資源變數的增減\n (從 前提四 推出)\n附註 本篇不跨切法加總資源變數與狀態變數(禁止清單第三項);總量只在同一切法內核算;不同切法的結論不直接互推。\n附註 移動預設同一性,而同一是分別;這是本篇不談移動的理由,不是推導來源。\n附註 在本篇例示的切法下,工人是節點,不是資源;老闆的切法下記錄的是工人的勞動(輸出)所對應的資源變數。\n```\n\n\n**校準。** 一塊土地可以同時是私人的,也是國家的領土;兩邊的帳目各自有各自的記法,並不衝突。這是校準,不是推導來源。\n\n---\n\n## 六、案例(校準)\n\n本章整節只作校準,不作任何推導的來源。兩個案例是熟知的歷史情境,每案分兩段:先把事情經過完整講一遍,不用模型語言;再沿著經過,用同一套記法走一遍,只換[節點](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25)、變數與[判準](concepts.md#c04)。資料取自公開網頁,不是原始檔;來源對同一件事的歸因,標為來源的歸屬,不當成帳目讀出。\n\n### 6.1 北美大平原的水牛跳崖獵場\n\n**經過。** 在北美大平原,人們把整群水牛趕下懸崖,在崖底宰殺。加拿大亞伯達省的〔Head-Smashed-In〕是其中最大、最老的一處:崖高約十到十八公尺,使用從約五千七百年前延續到十九世紀中葉。崖頂是水草豐美的牧場,從崖西十公里處起,有五百多座石堆排成驅趕線,人們在石堆旁生火或揮舞毯子,把牛引向崖緣。\n\n一次驅趕不是一天的事。石堆要先蓋好,並隨年代修補;各處的獵場也各有儀式,例如黑腳族相信海洋化石能吸引水牛,狩獵前的儀式裡有它的位置。到了當天,先選定一群牛,一名獵人披上小牛的皮,學小牛受驚的叫聲,把牛群引進驅趕線;另一些人可能披著狼皮,從後面逼;石堆上立著稻草人或堆著樹枝,石堆旁的人揮動毛皮,讓牛群愈跑愈快。獵場常選在地形起伏處,崖緣被遮住,牛看見時已無法回頭。披小牛皮的人要在最後一刻閃開,但有許多他墜崖而死的記載。\n\n牛墜崖後,人們在崖底下方的營地處理:崖底的骨骸在某些地方深達十一公尺,營地綿延約一公里,留有肉窖與烹煮坑,地下還有近一公尺厚的碎骨。蒙大拿的考古也找到加熱油脂與烘烤的坑,用來把肉做成與油脂、漿果混合的肉餅(〔pemmican〕),肉餅與毛皮都是交易物。獵場在十九世紀中葉後不再使用,當時水牛已近絕跡。\n\n**帶入框架。** 先選[切法](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c23):[節點](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25)是引誘者、石堆旁的人、後方逼趕的人、崖底處理的人,以及更早蓋石堆、修石堆的人;牛群與地形留在[自然環境](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c16),本篇不問牛群內部。\n\n先看一個驅趕當天的[推演輪](concepts.md#c07)。引誘者披皮學叫,是[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28),[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)牛群;牛群朝他移動,是[自然環境](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c16)的回應,這個移動[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)引誘者,也[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)石堆旁的人,成為各人[歷史](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13)的一部分。石堆旁的人依這段[歷史](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13)落出下一個[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28),揮動毛皮,牛群的移動又變了一次。這一[推演輪](concepts.md#c07)的[解](concepts.md#c05),是各人下一刻的[狀態變數](concepts.md#c02)與[資源變數](concepts.md#c03):引誘者仍在線上,崖底的人手上還沒有肉;牛群離崖更近,是[自然環境](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c16)的變化,不在[解](concepts.md#c05)裡。\n\n再看最後一個[推演輪](concepts.md#c07)。引誘者閃開或墜崖,這是現實給的結果:若[退場判準](concepts.md#c04)取生理狀態的指定界線(墜崖者常被標為[死亡](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c22)),墜崖者在這一[推演輪](concepts.md#c07)記為[判準退場](concepts.md#c09)。他的[歷史](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13)仍在,他的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)已[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)的牛群與同伴,也不因此取消(五之三)。崖底的[推演輪](concepts.md#c07),各人的肉與皮的[資源變數](concepts.md#c03)增加,增加多少由當次事件決定;下一次牛群未必進線,同樣的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)不保證同樣的[解](concepts.md#c05)(結論二之四)。\n\n最後把時間拉長。蓋石堆的人把[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)留在地上,一代一代[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)後來的人,成為他們[歷史](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13)的一部分;更早的[推演輪](concepts.md#c07)因此影響更晚的[解](concepts.md#c05)。各[節點](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25)的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)彼此[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10),在這段時窗內於[生產](concepts.md#c01)維度上反覆相容接續,這是上游所稱的[共振](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c09),其留下的相容圖樣,可看作[文化](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c13)在[生產](concepts.md#c01)維度上的呈現。研究者稱這種接續為合作、分工,是命名,不由帳目讀出。\n\n**可說與推不出。** 可說:在這些來源的描述裡,多人的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)序列反覆接續,有人因此墜崖而[判準退場](concepts.md#c09),有人因此取得肉與皮。推不出:每個人分得多少、誰指揮誰、各人的動機。來源中有人把這套安排歸為社團與儀式主導,也有人說「每處不同」,這些是來源的歸屬,也推不出每次驅趕的過程相同。\n\n**資料說明。** 過程細節(小牛皮、狼皮、海洋化石、肉餅)主要來自一篇談蒙大拿黑腳族獵場的考古報導,該文說各處不同、大致如此;〔Head-Smashed-In〕的來源只用來提供年代、規模、崖底營地與骨層。獵後如何分肉與分配、各社團的具體分工、個別參與者的體力或傷亡資料,沒有讀到,不寫。\n\n### 6.2 福特〔Highland Park〕的移動裝配線\n\n**經過。** 一九〇三年成立的福特汽車,兩年內就做到一天二十五輛,但那時造車是靜止的:底盤停在原處,工人帶著零件過來,什麼都做一點,最快的紀錄是十二小時十三分。\n\n一九一三年四月,飛輪磁電機先上了移動線。原本一個工人約二十分鐘做完一個,現在把工序拆開,一個人只裝一個零件就推給下一個人;產出先縮到十三分鐘,再縮到五分鐘。接著引擎、變速箱也上了線;同年夏秋之間,底盤也用繩索與絞盤拉過工作區,工人沿線裝零件,一輛車降到五、六小時,一九一四年縮到九十三分鐘,一天可產約一千輛。車價下降,福特稱這是讓中產階級買得起車的夢想。\n\n代價落在工人身上。許多技術工人覺得這份工作單調而疲憊;工廠裡多數是新移民,至少五十三個國籍、說一百多種語言,公司要求他們上英語學校。一九一三年底離職率達百分之三百八十,公司要增加一百人,得雇用九百六十三人。一九一四年一月,公司宣布八小時五美元,先前是九小時二點三四美元,並說會把利潤分一部分給工人。實際上,這份工資只給調查過私生活、被認為「合格」的人。工作並沒有變輕鬆,步調也沒有變慢,但隔天早上,一萬人聚在廠門口等著求職。\n\n**帶入框架。** 先選[切法](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c23):各工位的工人與公司是[節點](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25);機器、傳送帶與零件留在[自然環境](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c16),本篇不問其內部。\n\n先看磁電機線的一個[推演輪](concepts.md#c07)。一名工人把一個零件裝上,是[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28);傳送的動作與半成品的移動,是[自然環境](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c16)的回應,[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)下一個工人,成為他[歷史](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13)的一部分,他依此落出下一個動作。這一[推演輪](concepts.md#c07)的[解](concepts.md#c05),是各人的經手零件數、體力與是否仍在崗。這串[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)之所以能接成一條線,是因為每個人的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)都剛好進入下一個人的下一刻;各工人的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)序列在班次內反覆相容接續,這是上游所稱的[共振](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c09),研究者稱它合作[生產](concepts.md#c01),是命名。\n\n再看離職。[退場判準](concepts.md#c04)取離職,由本文作者指定:百分之三百八十是這個[判準](concepts.md#c04)下的事實,[判準](concepts.md#c04)本身是定義,兩者不互相替代(結論一之三)。離職是一些[節點](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25)在某一[推演輪](concepts.md#c07)的[解](concepts.md#c05)的一個維度,與他們是否想要什麼、有多少資源,沒有必然關係;一個人下一刻是否離開,仍然只能由[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06)推到傾向,推不到結果。\n\n薪資與勞動,是兩個[節點](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25)各自記的變數:勞動對工人是[狀態變數](concepts.md#c02)(體力與心情),對公司是[資源變數](concepts.md#c03);工資的增減各自記帳(五之七)。公告五美元,是一次新的[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10),進入許多人的[歷史](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13),改變他們下一刻的[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06);一萬人到廠門口,是其中一些[節點](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25)下一個[推演輪](concepts.md#c07)落出的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)。\n\n**可說與推不出。** 可說:裝配線引入後,離職率很高,這是一件事實;加薪公告後,大批人聚到廠門口,是另一件事實。推不出的是動機與關係:公共電視的頁面把加薪寫成為了降低離職,福特博物館把它寫成工人以接受裝配線紀律換取高薪,這是來源各自的歸屬,依[驅動力不可確認](../paper_ae79e938_76e1_4bf9_b2ab_995c03e16c9e/concepts.md#c03),不由帳目讀出;也推不出加薪使離職減少,因為本篇不預設[資源](concepts.md#c03)與[判準退場](concepts.md#c09)的關係,那是下游的經驗問題。\n\n**資料說明。** 底盤上線的日期,各來源說法不一(八月或十月七日),正文寫「夏秋之間」。「利潤分一部分給工人」只見於公共電視頁面。工人個人的疲勞、薪資用途、各工位的實際動作,沒有讀到,不寫。\n\n**來源**\n\n- 〔Head-Smashed-In Buffalo Jump〕(加拿大公園署)\n- 〔The Buffalo Chasers〕(〔Archaeology〕雜誌)\n- 〔Working at Ford's Factory〕(〔PBS American Experience〕)\n- 〔Crowd of Applicants outside Highland Park Plant〕(〔The Henry Ford〕)\n- 〔Ford Methods and the Ford Shops〕(〔The Henry Ford〕)\n- 〔Moving Assembly Line at Ford〕(〔History.com〕)\n- 〔Plant Engineering〕轉載的福特資料\n\n---\n\n## 七、經驗前件與失效條件\n\n**經驗前件:** 本篇不含經驗前件;[資源](concepts.md#c03)、[狀態](concepts.md#c02)與[判準退場](concepts.md#c09)的任何關係,由下游研究自行提出並承擔。\n\n**校準與案例:** 各節的校準與第六章的案例,不拿來支持本篇的任何結論。兩個案例的資料只是公開網頁,讓模型看起來貼近現實,不代表模型被驗證。\n\n**失效條件**\n\n- 前提一至前提四被否定時,來源鏈含該前提的結論失去來源;失去來源只表示推導鏈斷開,不表示結論為假。前提一是範圍設定,前提二至前提四是[推演輪](concepts.md#c07)結構與接口的設定,都不是可被推翻的主張,否定它們的意思,是換成另一套設定。\n- 本篇的推導依賴上游的[黑箱律](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c25)、[流變律](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c24)、[不可復原律](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c28),以及[歷史](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13)、[生成函數](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c15)、[印象](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c45)、[切法](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c23)、[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)、[同一](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c21)的定義;它們是否成立,由上游論文處理,本篇不另設失效條件。\n- 下游若引入[資源](concepts.md#c03)與[判準退場](concepts.md#c09)的關係,或不同[節點](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25)增減之間的對應關係,該關係是下游的經驗前件,或對[同一](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c21)所作的[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18),其失效不影響本篇。\n\n**不是本篇的結論:** 分工、分配、知識接續、照顧與供養等議題,只是研究者對[生產](concepts.md#c01)維度上反覆相容接續的命名,留給子論文。沒有取得的資料(獵後分配、各社團分工、工人個人的疲勞與薪資用途),不寫成「不存在」,也不用來支持結論。\n"},{"filename":"Production Dynamics.md","content":"---\nuuid: 96f10d75-23d0-441f-94c7-ab87ca28d284\nlast-modified: 2026-11-04T14:15:11\nauthor: 黃正宇 / Cheng Yu Huang\ncontact: mthree.tw@gmail.com\n---\n\n# Production Dynamics\n\n## 0. Positioning and Assumptions\n\nThis paper is a programmatic paper that builds on upstream and introduces no new mechanism. On top of the upstream cycle of [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28), [arrival](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10), [history](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13), and [weight](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06), it adds one layer of researcher's records, describing the [solution](concepts.md#c05) of each [node](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25) in every [derivation round](concepts.md#c07): its [state](concepts.md#c02) and [resources](concepts.md#c03) at the next moment, and whether it [undergoes criterion exit](concepts.md#c09). To downstream papers (for example, a paper on violence dynamics) it offers only a bookkeeping format: a [node](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25) has [state variables](concepts.md#c02) and [resource variables](concepts.md#c03); [resource variables](concepts.md#c03) increase or decrease in every [derivation round](concepts.md#c07); the [exit criterion](concepts.md#c04) is written on [state variables](concepts.md#c02).\n\n[Production](concepts.md#c01) is the researcher's [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) drawn over the [history](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13) of [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28), and it gives [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) no independent ontology. [Resources](concepts.md#c03), [states](concepts.md#c02), and [criterion exit](concepts.md#c09) are all [distinctions](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) made by the researcher, and this paper presupposes no relation among the three.\n\nThe \"Calibration\" in each section and the cases in Chapter 6 are only comparisons with reality; they are no part of any derivation and are never a source of derivation.\n\nWhat this paper calls the [environment](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c16) is the upstream [natural environment](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c16): under a stated [cut](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c23), the part that belongs to no [node](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25) yet has [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) [arriving](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at the [nodes](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25).\n\n---\n\n## 1. Laws and Premises\n\n**Inherited.** The [Law of Flux](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c24), the [Law of the Black Box](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c25), the [Law of Attrition](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c26), and the [Law of Non-Restoration](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c28); [wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16), [self](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19), [entry](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c44), [exit](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c43), [death](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c22), [own segment](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c17), [cut](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c23), [natural environment](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c16), [resonance](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c09), [culture](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c13), and so on are used with their upstream definitions and are not redefined.\n\n```text\nPremise 1 (scope setting): Under a stated cut, the researcher specifies the\n boundaries of the selected nodes, their state variables, their resource\n variables, and one exit criterion expressed in the state variables, and\n reports who made this division. This paper presupposes no relation among\n resources, states, and criterion exit.\n The records of this paper cover only physical changes; distinctions also\n enter history but fall outside what this paper records.\nRemark: Premise 1 is a scope setting, not a claim that can be refuted.\n Its scope is not limited to humans; from a human viewpoint, the exit\n criterion is often written on physiological state, and some self marks\n the wo as dead accordingly;\n criterion exit follows the criterion the researcher states,\n so it may or may not coincide with upstream exit, and the two do not substitute for each other.\n The criterion may be the upstream \"no longer a wo\", or any explicitly\n stated definition such as a physiological threshold, dissolution, or retirement.\nRemark: The line between resource and state depends on the node boundary and\n has no fixed attribution belonging to the object itself.\n Transferability and storability are common cues, not definitions:\n what is transferable and storable from a given node's viewpoint is\n usually recorded as a resource, and what is not is usually recorded as a state.\n A researcher may place a variable related to some object under resource\n or state, depending on the node and the viewpoint of the cut\n (for example a prosthetic eye, or a worker's labour as seen by the\n worker versus by the boss).\nRemark: The relation among resources, states, and criterion exit is not presupposed here.\n Both ends are the researcher's distinctions;\n at the level of general rules nothing can be written about it; if there is\n any, it is an empirical question under a specific cut,\n to be raised and borne by downstream research.\nStep 1-1: The exit criterion is one distinction made by the researcher\n (from Premise 1 + definition of cut + definition of distinction + definition of exit criterion)\nStep 1-2: Once the criterion is stated, whether a given derivation round\n has a criterion exit is decided by the actual state events of that round\n (from Premise 1 + Premise 2 + Step 1-1)\nConclusion 1-3: The criterion is a definition and whether criterion exit occurs is a fact;\n the two do not replace each other\n (from Step 1-1 + Step 1-2 + definition of exit criterion)\nStep 1-4: What counts as the state or the resources of a node depends on the\n node boundary, and the boundary is one distinction made by the researcher\n (from Premise 1 + definition of distinction + definition of identity + definition of state variable + definition of resource variable)\nConclusion 1-5: The classification of resource and state is a classification\n under a cut, not a property of the thing itself\n (from Premise 1 + Step 1-4)\n```\n\n**Calibration.** Retirement counts as [criterion exit](concepts.md#c09), a physiological state reaching a specified threshold also counts as [criterion exit](concepts.md#c09) (often marked as [death](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c22) by some [self](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19)), and the dissolution of a company is likewise [criterion exit](concepts.md#c09); each is defined by the user, so the [criterion](concepts.md#c04) is a definition, and whether a given person actually retires or reaches that threshold in a given [derivation round](concepts.md#c07) is a fact. Whether a prosthetic eye counts as part of him can be answered differently by the eye's user and the insurance company; a worker's mood and stamina are [state variables](concepts.md#c02) for the worker himself, while the labour the worker puts in is a [resource variable](concepts.md#c03) the boss can obtain. This is a calibration, not a source of derivation.\n\n### Prohibition list (methodologically forbidden)\n\n1. Do not treat the [criterion](concepts.md#c04) as a fact, and do not treat an inference about [weight](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06) as a judgment.\n2. Do not infer, from the record of increases and decreases of a [resource variable](concepts.md#c03), which kind of [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) an increase or decrease belongs to, or infer motive or legitimacy.\n3. Do not add up [resource variables](concepts.md#c03) and [state variables](concepts.md#c02) across [cuts](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c23).\n4. Do not infer optimality from survival, or improvement from variation.\n5. Do not presuppose antecedents about ownership or legitimacy.\n6. Do not treat a particular classification as a property of the thing itself (for example \"the eye is a state\" or \"money is a resource\"); it must be stated together with the [cut](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c23).\n7. Do not presuppose a relation between [resources](concepts.md#c03) and [criterion exit](concepts.md#c09); to claim one, first define the specific [resource](concepts.md#c03) and the specific [exit criterion](concepts.md#c04).\n8. Do not speak of resources \"moving\": moving presupposes [identity](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c21), and [identity](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c21) is a [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18); this paper only records the increases and decreases of each [node](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25)'s [resource variables](concepts.md#c03).\n9. Do not treat \"screening\" or \"elimination\" as purposeful processes; they are only metaphors.\n\n---\n\n## 2. The Model\n\nThe unit by which this paper advances the model one step is called a [derivation round](concepts.md#c07): under a stated [cut](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c23), every [node](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25) present runs once through the upstream cycle, after which come the researcher's records and the change of membership. The unit is the whole cut-out range, not a single [node](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25); what is recorded and how membership changes are specified by the user; the [nodes](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25) are not assumed to be synchronous, and a [derivation round](concepts.md#c07) is only an ordering.\n\nThe model of this paper is a recursion advanced by [derivation rounds](concepts.md#c07), following the upstream cycle. In every [derivation round](concepts.md#c07), each [node](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25) produces [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28), the [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) [arrives](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at itself, at other [nodes](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25), and at the [environment](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c16), and the physical changes that [arrive](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) enter the [history](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13). **Finding the [solution](concepts.md#c05) means this: I [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) now, and what I become at the next moment is the [solution](concepts.md#c05) of this [derivation round](concepts.md#c07).** One person or many use the same model: with many, the researcher merely cuts out of the [environment](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c16) a part that used to sit there and treats it as [nodes](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25), and the [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) of each [node](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25) enters the next moment of the others.\n\n```text\nPremise 2 (derivation round structure): every derivation round proceeds in the following six steps\nRound step 1 Output Each node present, according to the weight determined by its own history, produces output. (upstream)\nRound step 2 Arrival Output arrives at the node itself, and also at other nodes and the environment. (upstream)\nRound step 3 Response The natural environment responds; other nodes also each produce output. All of these may arrive at this node.\n What is inside the natural environment is not asked here.\nRound step 4 Entry into history All physical changes arriving at the node, whether from its own output,\n from other nodes' output, or from the environment's response, enter the history of that node\n and take part in later weight.\n Weight is determined by history and cannot be read. (upstream)\nRound step 5 Solution Under the cut, the researcher records each node's state variables and resource\n variables at the next moment, and records whether each node undergoes criterion exit according to the\n exit criterion. Taken together these are the solution of this derivation round.\nRound step 6 Membership change Nodes that undergo criterion exit no longer take part, but their history remains; nodes that enter join,\n and their prior history may overlap with that of existing nodes.\nReturn to round step 1.\nThe cycle of this paper has no built-in exit condition; whether to stop is specified by the researcher outside the model.\n```\n\n```text\nDefinition of solution: Under a stated cut, the next-moment state variables and resource\n variables of each node that the researcher records, together with whether each node\n undergoes criterion exit according to the exit criterion, taken together form the solution of this derivation round.\nRemark: Criterion exit is only one dimension of the solution, alongside the other dimensions, with no special status.\nRemark: What is not recorded is not in the solution, but remains in history.\n```\n\n**Remarks**\n\n1. The [history](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13) contains all physical changes that [arrive](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at the [node](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25). The part that was not recorded remains in the [history](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13) and continues to affect [weight](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06).\n2. The [solution](concepts.md#c05) presupposes no optimum, and presupposes no tie to purposes or resources. Whether a [node](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25) [undergoes criterion exit](concepts.md#c09) is only a limit that reality gives: whether a person is hit by a car and dies at the next moment has no necessary relation to what he wants or how many resources he has.\n3. If purposes show up as a [node](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25)'s [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) about itself, they enter the [history](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13) and affect later [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) only through [weight](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06); this paper neither confirms nor presupposes their content (inheriting the upstream [unconfirmability of drives](../paper_ae79e938_76e1_4bf9_b2ab_995c03e16c9e/concepts.md#c03)).\n4. With many people, the [solution](concepts.md#c05) of one [node](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25) may be affected both by its own [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) and by the [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) of other [nodes](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25); the next moments of all [nodes](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25) taken together are the [solution](concepts.md#c05) of the whole cut-out range. Each person produces [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) on their own, and each one's [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) enters the next moment of the others, so finding the [solution](concepts.md#c05) is a process that happens jointly among many people, not a matter of everyone keeping separate books.\n5. The records of this paper cover only physical changes. [Distinctions](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) (views about oneself or others) also enter the [history](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13), as upstream has it, and are not recorded in this paper.\n6. The [nodes](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25) are not assumed to be synchronous; a [derivation round](concepts.md#c07) is only an ordering, as upstream has it.\n7. This paper does not specify what the response is or how much the increase or decrease is. The same [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) may meet different responses today and tomorrow.\n8. The cycle of each [derivation round](concepts.md#c07) of this paper has no built-in exit condition; whether to stop is specified by the researcher outside the model. [Criterion exit](concepts.md#c09) concerns individual [nodes](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25) only and is not a termination condition for the whole.\n\n**Calibration.** I go mining and my [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) is labour; the mine responds, and at the next moment I hold an extra piece of ore with my stamina lower; that is the [solution](concepts.md#c05) of this [derivation round](concepts.md#c07) for me. Digging the same way tomorrow, the ore may not appear. Another person is walking down the road to drink and is hit by a car and dies: in his [solution](concepts.md#c05), the dimension of whether he [undergoes criterion exit](concepts.md#c09) is recorded as [criterion exit](concepts.md#c09); this has nothing to do with what he wants or how many resources he has, and is only a limit given by reality. This is a calibration, not a source of derivation.\n\n### Components\n\n| Component | Content | Basis |\n|---|---|---|\n| Component 1: upstream cycle | [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28), [arrival](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10), entry into history, [weight](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06), [entry](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c44), [exit](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c43) | inherited, nothing new |\n| Component 2: record of the [solution](concepts.md#c05) | the researcher records next-moment [state variables](concepts.md#c02), [resource variables](concepts.md#c03), and whether [criterion exit](concepts.md#c09) occurs | Premise 1, Premise 3, Premise 4 |\n\n### Naming with many people\n\nWith many people, the [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) of each [node](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25) enters the next moment of the others. On the [production](concepts.md#c01) dimension, if the [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) of these [nodes](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25) [arrive](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at one another and, within a stated time window, their sequences repeatedly continue in a compatible way, that is what upstream calls [resonance](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c09); if the conditions of upstream [culture](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c13) are also met, the compatible pattern that [resonance](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c09) leaves behind is the manifestation, on the [production](concepts.md#c01) dimension, of what upstream calls [culture](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c13). [Resource variables](concepts.md#c03) are recorded variables and take no part in [resonance](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c09). Exchange, transfer, cooperation, plunder, and the like are the researcher's names for such [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) sequences; they are not components of the model and cannot be read off the books (see 5-6).\n\nTo merge several [nodes](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25) into one, or to split one into several [nodes](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25), is [recutting](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c22). To claim that the [weights](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06) of a coarse and a fine record agree, one must state how the result asked of the coarse record is obtained from the fine record; where this is not stated, they can only be reported separately and not inferred from one another.\n\n### Properties derived from the model\n\n```text\nConclusion 2-1: Weight reads history; the record of the solution is not a direct input to weight; the record of the solution is the researcher's selection\n (from definition of generating function + Premise 2 + definition of solution)\nConclusion 2-2: History only grows and never shrinks, and is path-dependent; resource variables rise or fall according to actual events, and this paper sets no irreversibility restriction on recorded variables\n (from definition of history + Law of Non-Restoration + Premise 2 + Premise 4)\nConclusion 2-3: Criterion exit is only one dimension of the solution; the criterion judges only the recorded state variables, not the whole history and not the weight\n (from Premise 1 + Conclusion 1-3 + Premise 2 + definition of solution)\nConclusion 2-4: For a wo that is not locked in, the same output does not guarantee the same solution\n (from Law of the Black Box + definition of locked in + definition of weight + Law of Flux + definition of output + definition of solution + Premise 2)\nConclusion 2-5: With many people, the output of other nodes may arrive at this node, enter its history and take part in later weight, so the solution of one node may be affected jointly by its own output and the output of other nodes\n (from Premise 2)\nConclusion 2-6: Membership may change in every derivation round; when it does, the history of each node and the conditions of resonance may change with it\n (from Law of Flux + definition of entry + definition of criterion exit + definition of resonance + Premise 2)\nConclusion 2-7: The model does not require the solution to be optimal, conserved, convergent, or in equilibrium\n (from Premise 1 + Premise 4 + definition of solution)\nConclusion 2-8: The model does not specify the content of responses or the amount of increases and decreases, and therefore cannot predict trajectories\n (from Premise 2 + Premise 4 + definition of solution)\nConclusion 2-9: With many people, on the production dimension, if the outputs of nodes arrive at one another and, within a stated time window, their sequences repeatedly continue one another compatibly, this is resonance; if the conditions of upstream culture are also met, the compatible pattern that resonance leaves behind is the manifestation of culture on the production dimension\n (from Premise 2 + definition of resonance + definition of culture + definition of production)\nConclusion 2-10: Whether the weights of a coarse record and a fine record agree is not guaranteed by the definition of recutting; to claim that they agree, one must state how the result asked by the coarse record is obtained from the fine record, and what is not stated can only be reported separately, without inferring one from the other\n (from definition of recutting + definition of weight)\nConclusion 2-11: If purposes show up as a node's distinction about itself, it enters history and affects later output only through weight; this paper neither confirms nor presupposes the content of purposes\n (from definition of distinction + definition of history + definition of weight + definition of generating function + Premise 2 + unconfirmability of drives)\n```\n\n### What this model is not\n\nIt does not specify what the response is or how much the increase or decrease is, so it **cannot predict trajectories**; it can only say what is recorded, where one line crosses another, and which properties can be derived. The actual [solution](concepts.md#c05) has to be supplied by a concrete case through data or rules. The level follows the practice of the upstream interaction-dynamics papers: transitions are not specified, and only qualitative properties are derived.\n\n---\n\n## 3. Interfaces\n\n```text\nPremise 3: A node has state variables and resource variables that can be recorded, and the boundary is specified by the cut;\n what counts as \"its own\" is the researcher's distinction and does not involve ownership.\nPremise 4: The resource variables of a node increase or decrease in every derivation round, determined by actual events.\n This paper does not discuss whether resources \"move\", nor whether the increases and decreases of different nodes\n correspond to the same portion of something;\n if downstream needs such a correspondence, downstream must specify it itself and bear the distinction of identity involved.\n```\n\n---\n\n## 4. The Human Viewpoint (an instance of Premise 1)\n\nFrom the human viewpoint, the [exit criterion](concepts.md#c04) is often written on physiological state, and some [self](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19) accordingly marks the [wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16) with [death](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c22); [criterion exit](concepts.md#c09) follows the criterion the researcher states, and it may or may not coincide with the upstream [exit](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c43), and the two do not replace each other; [state variables](concepts.md#c02) are for example stamina, energy reserve, and physiological condition, and [resource variables](concepts.md#c03) are for example food, specified by the researcher. Birth is only [entry](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c44): if the prior history of whoever undergoes [entry](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c44) includes the biological raw material of its parents, that is an overlap of prior history at the time of [entry](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c44) and does not constitute a separate event. The parents' biological raw material is distinct from [learning](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c04): the former is biological constitution, while the latter follows upstream [arrival](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) and [history](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13), and it does not guarantee copying the parents' knowledge, [weight](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06), or [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28).\n\n```text\nStep 4-1: The prior history of an entrant may overlap with that of existing nodes\n (from Premise 2)\nConclusion 4-2: Even if an entrant's prior history overlaps with existing nodes, this does not imply that the entrant inherits the parents' history, weight, or output\n (from Step 4-1 + definition of arrival + definition of history + definition of weight + definition of output + definition of learning)\n```\n\n---\n\n## 5. Non-Implication Relations\n\n| No. | Content | Derivation |\n|---|---|---|\n| 5-1 | the [criterion](concepts.md#c04) is a definition, and whether [criterion exit](concepts.md#c09) occurs is a fact | Conclusion 1-3 |\n| 5-2 | when not [locked in](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c12), an inference about [weight](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06) cannot replace the judgment of whether [criterion exit](concepts.md#c09) occurs | see below |\n| 5-3 | an [entry](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c44) that has occurred is not cancelled by a later [exit](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c43) | see below |\n| 5-4 | the source attribution of a [resource variable](concepts.md#c03) does not affect how [criterion exit](concepts.md#c09) is judged | see below |\n| 5-5 | variation and screening do not imply improvement, optimality, or sustainability | see below |\n| 5-6 | an increase or decrease of a [resource variable](concepts.md#c03) does not imply which kind of [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) it belongs to | see below |\n| 5-7 | the boundary between [resource](concepts.md#c03) and [state](concepts.md#c02) is a [cut](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c23), and different [nodes](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25) can each record variables related to the same object | see below |\n\n### 5-2 Weight inference cannot replace judgment\n\nThe \"not [locked in](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c12)\" in this section and in 5-5 follows the upstream definition of [lock-in](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c12).\n\n```text\nStep 5-2-1: An inference by a self about the weight of a wo (upstream calls it impression) concerns how heavy the branches are,\n while a judgment concerns an event that has already occurred\n (from definition of weight + definition of impression + Step 1-2)\nStep 5-2-2: For a wo that is not locked in, weight yields only a tendency and not a result\n (from Law of the Black Box + definition of locked in + definition of weight)\nConclusion 5-2-3: For a wo that is not locked in, an inference about weight cannot give a complete next moment; whether criterion exit occurs must still be judged from actual events and cannot be replaced by an inference about weight\n (from Step 1-2 + Step 5-2-1 + Step 5-2-2)\n```\n\n### 5-3 An entry that has occurred is not cancelled\n\n```text\nStep 5-3-1: Exit does not delete the positions in history that have already occurred\n (from definition of history)\nStep 5-3-2: Whether something is a wo is determined by actual history; entry is starting to be a wo (including being a wo from the first moment),\n exit is ceasing to be a wo; every exit comes after its corresponding entry\n (from definition of history + definition of wo + definition of entry + definition of exit)\nStep 5-3-3: For a wo that has exited, its own segment remains in history\n (from definition of exit + definition of history + definition of own segment)\nConclusion 5-3-4: Exit does not cancel an entry that has occurred, nor the arrivals left by the entrant\n (from Step 5-3-1 + Step 5-3-2 + Step 5-3-3 + definition of arrival)\nRemark: Criterion exit is the researcher's record and does not change history.\n```\n\n**Calibration.** A person has a child and then [exits](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c43): the child's [entry](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c44) and his own [exit](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c43) each occupy a place in the [history](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13), and the latter does not cancel the former. This is a calibration, not a source of derivation.\n\n### 5-4 The source attribution of a resource variable does not affect how judgment is made\n\n```text\nStep 5-4-1: If a node's resource variable increases in a derivation round, the increase is a record of an actual event\n (from Premise 4)\nStep 5-4-2: Whether to record this increase as related to the output of other nodes is the researcher's attribution\n (from definition of distinction + definition of output + Premise 4)\nStep 5-4-3: Within one cut, whether a node undergoes criterion exit in a given derivation round depends only on the state variables and the criterion,\n and not on the source attribution of the resource variables\n (from Premise 1 + Step 1-2)\nConclusion 5-4-4: How an increase of a resource variable is attributed does not change how criterion exit is judged;\n this paper does not infer from it any relation between resources and states\n (from Step 5-4-2 + Step 5-4-3)\nRemark: This does not imply that other nodes intended to give, nor that the total resources of the whole network increased;\n the former is bound by the unconfirmability of drives, and the latter must be accounted for separately within one cut.\n```\n\n**Calibration.** A poor man eats one bowl of rice a day, while a rich man can eat steak, turkey, and all kinds of burgers; their [resource variables](concepts.md#c03) are very different, but there is no reason that the poor man must [criterion exit](concepts.md#c09) at once. Conversely, a rich man who is hit by a car on the road does not die because of desire, nor because of insufficient resources. [Criterion exit](concepts.md#c09) has no necessary relation to what one wants or how many resources one has; it is only a limit given by reality. This is a calibration, not a source of derivation.\n\n### 5-5 Variation and screening do not imply improvement, optimality, or sustainability\n\n```text\nStep 5-5-1: For a wo that is not locked in, the weight determined by history yields only a tendency, and the result can vary\n (from Law of the Black Box + definition of locked in + definition of weight)\nStep 5-5-2: This paper does not require the exit criterion to contain any \"better\" condition;\n the criterion is only a condition that the researcher specifies, expressed in the state variables\n (from Premise 1)\nStep 5-5-3: Whether the criterion is satisfied and the changes of resource variables are recorded separately,\n and this paper does not infer a relation between the two\n (from Premise 1 + Premise 2)\nConclusion 5-5-4: Output variation and criterion exit records are not enough to infer monotonic improvement, optimality, or sustainability of state or resources\n (from Step 5-5-1 + Step 5-5-2 + Step 5-5-3 + Conclusion 2-2 + definition of output + definition of exit criterion + definition of criterion exit)\nRemark: \"Screening\" is only a metaphor upstream, and it must be marked as a metaphor.\n```\n\n### 5-6 Records of increases and decreases do not imply the type of output\n\n```text\nStep 5-6-1: The increases and decreases of resource variables are the separate records of the nodes concerned, determined by actual events\n (from Premise 4)\nStep 5-6-2: After output arrives at the other party, it enters the other party's history\n (from Premise 2 + definition of output + definition of arrival + definition of history)\nConclusion 5-6-3: If resource variables record only numerical increases and decreases and carry no information about output types, then the books of resource variables record only numerical increases and decreases; an output type is a classification mark that the researcher adds separately,\n outside what the books of resource variables record, so it cannot be read off those books\n (from Premise 1 + Step 5-6-1 + Step 5-6-2 + definition of solution)\nRemark: Motives, needs, and purposes are bound by the unconfirmability of drives and cannot be read off the books;\n this concerns motives only and is not taken as sufficient proof that output types are unidentifiable.\nRemark: Violence, exchange, gifts, deception, and the like are the researcher's names for output and are not components of the model.\nRemark: This paper presupposes no antecedent about ownership or legitimacy.\n```\n\n**Calibration.** Violence, bribery, intimidation, and fraud, seen on the books, are all just that some person's [resource variable](concepts.md#c03) decreases and another's increases; what distinguishes them lies in the content of the [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) and the [arrival](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10), named by the researcher. This is a calibration, not a source of derivation.\n\n### 5-7 The boundary between resource and state is a cut\n\n```text\nStep 5-7-1: The researcher may, under cuts with different nodes and different viewpoints,\n each record the resource variables or state variables related to some object\n (from Conclusion 1-5 + Premise 3; for example the researcher may, in the accounts of a resident and of the national territory as two nodes,\n each record variables related to one house; a worker's labour is recorded as a state for the worker and as a resource for the boss)\nConclusion 5-7-2: Variables related to the same object appearing in the accounts of different nodes do not constitute a contradiction,\n nor do they imply who owns it, nor presuppose that these variables refer to the same thing\n (from Step 5-7-1 + Premise 3 + definition of identity)\nStep 5-7-3: Under each cut, the category of a variable is fixed by that cut, and this paper does not presuppose that variables across cuts refer to the same thing; if variables related to the same object were added directly, double counting would be only one consequence\n (from Conclusion 1-5 + Conclusion 5-7-2)\nConclusion 5-7-4: This paper does not claim that resources 'move' between nodes; it records only the increases and decreases of each node's resource variables\n (from Premise 4)\nRemark: This paper does not add resource variables and state variables across cuts (item 3 of the prohibition list); totals are accounted only within one cut; conclusions under different cuts are not directly inferred from one another.\nRemark: Movement presupposes identity, and identity is a distinction; this is the reason this paper does not discuss movement, not a source of derivation.\nRemark: Under the cut exemplified in this paper, a worker is a node, not a resource; what is recorded under the boss's cut is the resource variable corresponding to the worker's labour (output).\n```\n\n**Calibration.** A piece of land can be both private and the national territory; the accounts on each side keep their own way of recording, and there is no conflict. This is a calibration, not a source of derivation.\n\n---\n\n## 6. Cases (Calibration)\n\nThis whole chapter is only calibration and is not a source of any derivation. The two cases are well-known historical situations, and each case has two parts: first the course of events is told in full, without model language; then, following that course, the same notation is walked through once, changing only the [nodes](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25), the variables, and the [criterion](concepts.md#c04). The data are taken from public web pages, not from original files; where a source attributes something to the same event, that is marked as the source's attribution and is not read off the books.\n\n### 6.1 The buffalo jump hunting grounds of the North American Great Plains\n\n**Narrative.** On the North American Great Plains, people drove whole herds of buffalo off cliffs and butchered them at the bottom. Head-Smashed-In in Alberta, Canada, is one of the largest and oldest of them: the cliff is about ten to eighteen metres high, and it was used from about 5,700 years ago until the middle of the nineteenth century. The top of the cliff is lush pasture, and starting ten kilometres west of the cliff, more than five hundred stone cairns are arranged in drive lines; people lit fires or waved blankets beside the cairns to lead the buffalo toward the edge.\n\nA drive was not the work of a single day. The cairns had to be built first and were repaired over the years; each hunting ground also had its own rituals, for example the Blackfoot believed that sea fossils could attract buffalo, and they had a place in the rituals before hunting. On the day itself, a herd was selected first, and a hunter put on a calf's hide and imitated the frightened cry of a calf to lead the herd into the drive lines; others might wear wolf hides and press from behind; scarecrows stood on the cairns or branches were piled on them, and the people beside the cairns waved hides to make the herd run faster and faster. Hunting grounds were often chosen where the terrain undulates, so that the cliff edge was hidden and the buffalo could not turn back when they saw it. The man in the calf hide had to step aside at the last moment, but there are many records of him falling to his death.\n\nAfter the buffalo fell, people processed them at the camp below the bottom of the cliff: the bones at the bottom are in some places eleven metres deep, the camp stretches about one kilometre, with meat cellars and cooking pits left behind, and a layer of broken bone nearly one metre thick lies underground. Archaeology in Montana has also found pits for heating fat and for roasting, used to make meat into a cake mixed with fat and berries (pemmican); the pemmican and the hides were both trade goods. The hunting ground ceased to be used after the middle of the nineteenth century, when the buffalo were almost extinct.\n\n**Bringing it into the framework.** First choose the [cut](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c23): the [nodes](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25) are the decoy, the people beside the cairns, the people driving from behind, the people processing at the bottom, and the people who built and repaired the cairns earlier; the herd and the terrain stay in the [natural environment](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c16), and this paper does not ask about the inside of the herd.\n\nFirst look at a [derivation round](concepts.md#c07) on the day of a drive. The decoy puts on the hide and imitates the cry; that is [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28), and it [arrives](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at the herd; the herd moves toward him, which is a response of the [natural environment](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c16); this movement [arrives](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at the decoy and also [arrives](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at the people beside the cairns, and becomes part of each one's [history](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13). The people beside the cairns, based on this [history](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13), produce the next [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28), waving hides, and the movement of the herd changes once more. The [solution](concepts.md#c05) of this [derivation round](concepts.md#c07) is each person's [state variables](concepts.md#c02) and [resource variables](concepts.md#c03) at the next moment: the decoy is still on the line, and the people at the bottom do not yet have meat in their hands; the herd being closer to the cliff is a change in the [natural environment](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c16) and is not in the [solution](concepts.md#c05).\n\nNow look at the last [derivation round](concepts.md#c07). The decoy steps aside or falls off the cliff; this is the result reality gives: if the [exit criterion](concepts.md#c04) takes a specified threshold of physiological state (those who fall are often marked as [death](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c22)), the one who falls is recorded as [criterion exit](concepts.md#c09) in this [derivation round](concepts.md#c07). His [history](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13) remains, and the herd and companions that his [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) has already [arrived at](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) are not cancelled because of this (5-3). In the [derivation round](concepts.md#c07) at the bottom of the cliff, the [resource variables](concepts.md#c03) of meat and hide for each person increase, and how much they increase is determined by the event of the time; the next time the herd may not enter the line, and the same [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) does not guarantee the same [solution](concepts.md#c05) (Conclusion 2-4).\n\nFinally, stretch the time. The people who built the cairns left their [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) on the ground, and generation after generation it [arrived](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at later people and became part of their [history](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13); earlier [derivation rounds](concepts.md#c07) thus affect later [solutions](concepts.md#c05). The [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) of the [nodes](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25) [arrive](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at one another and, within this time window, repeatedly continue in a compatible way on the [production](concepts.md#c01) dimension, which is what upstream calls [resonance](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c09), and the compatible pattern it leaves can be seen as the manifestation of [culture](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c13) on the [production](concepts.md#c01) dimension. That the researcher calls this continuation cooperation or division of labour is naming and cannot be read off the books.\n\n**What can be said and what cannot be inferred.** What can be said: in these sources' accounts, the [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) of many people continues in sequence, with some falling to their deaths and undergoing [criterion exit](concepts.md#c09) because of it, and others obtaining meat and hides because of it. What cannot be inferred: how much each person gets, who commands whom, and each person's motives. Some sources attribute this arrangement to the leadership of societies and rituals, and others say \"it differs from place to place\"; these are the sources' attributions, and it also cannot be inferred that every drive went the same way.\n\n**Data notes.** The details of the process (calf hide, wolf hide, sea fossils, pemmican) come mainly from an archaeological report on the Blackfoot hunting grounds of Montana, which says that places differ and that this is roughly how it went; the Head-Smashed-In sources are used only to supply dates, scale, the camp at the bottom of the cliff, and the bone layer. How the meat was divided and distributed after the hunt, the specific division of labour of each society, and data on the stamina or casualties of individual participants were not found and are not written.\n\n### 6.2 Ford's moving assembly line at Highland Park\n\n**Narrative.** Ford Motor Company, founded in 1903, reached twenty-five cars a day within two years, but at that time building a car was stationary: the chassis stayed in place, workers brought parts to it and did a little of everything, and the fastest record was twelve hours and thirteen minutes.\n\nIn April 1913, the flywheel magneto was the first to go on a moving line. Where one worker used to finish one in about twenty minutes, the operations were now broken apart so that each person installed only one part and passed it to the next; output first shrank to thirteen minutes and then to five. Then the engine and the transmission also went onto the line; between summer and autumn of the same year, the chassis too was pulled across the work area with ropes and a winch, workers installed parts along the line, a car dropped to five or six hours, in 1914 it shrank to ninety-three minutes, and about a thousand could be produced a day. Car prices fell, which Ford called a dream of making cars affordable for the middle class.\n\nThe cost fell on the workers. Many skilled workers found the work monotonous and exhausting; most of the factory consisted of new immigrants, of at least fifty-three nationalities speaking more than a hundred languages, and the company required them to attend English school. At the end of 1913 the turnover rate reached 380 percent, and to add one hundred workers the company had to hire 963. In January 1914 the company announced five dollars for eight hours, up from 2.34 dollars for nine hours, and said it would share part of the profits with workers. In practice, this wage was given only to people whose private lives had been investigated and who were deemed \"qualified\". The work did not become easier and the pace did not slow, but the next morning ten thousand people gathered at the factory gate waiting to apply.\n\n**Bringing it into the framework.** First choose the [cut](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c23): the workers at each station and the company are [nodes](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25); the machines, conveyors, and parts stay in the [natural environment](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c16), and this paper does not ask about their inside.\n\nFirst look at one [derivation round](concepts.md#c07) on the magneto line. A worker installs a part; that is [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28); the movement of the conveyor and of the semi-finished work is a response of the [natural environment](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c16), which [arrives](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at the next worker and becomes part of his [history](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13), and on this basis he produces his next motion. The [solution](concepts.md#c05) of this [derivation round](concepts.md#c07) is each person's number of parts handled, stamina, and whether he is still at his post. The reason this string of [outputs](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) could be linked into a line is that each person's [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) happens to enter the next person's next moment; the [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) sequences of the workers repeatedly continue in a compatible way within a shift, which is what upstream calls [resonance](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c09), and the researcher calls it cooperative [production](concepts.md#c01), which is naming.\n\nNow look at quitting. The [exit criterion](concepts.md#c04) takes quitting, as specified by the author of this paper: 380 percent is a fact under this [criterion](concepts.md#c04), the [criterion](concepts.md#c04) itself is a definition, and the two do not replace each other (Conclusion 1-3). Quitting is one dimension of the [solution](concepts.md#c05) of some [nodes](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25) in a given [derivation round](concepts.md#c07), and has no necessary relation to whether they want anything or how many resources they have; whether a person leaves at the next moment can still be inferred from [weight](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06) only as a tendency and not as a result.\n\nWages and labour are variables recorded separately by two [nodes](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25): labour is a [state variable](concepts.md#c02) for the worker (stamina and mood) and a [resource variable](concepts.md#c03) for the company; the increases and decreases of wages are booked separately (5-7). The announcement of five dollars is a new [arrival](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10); it enters many people's [history](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13) and changes their [weight](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06) at the next moment; ten thousand people arriving at the factory gate is the [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) that some of these [nodes](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25) produce in the next [derivation round](concepts.md#c07).\n\n**What can be said and what cannot be inferred.** What can be said: after the assembly line was introduced, turnover was very high, which is one fact; after the raise was announced, a large crowd gathered at the factory gate, which is another fact. What cannot be inferred are motives and relations: the public television page writes the raise as an effort to lower turnover, and the Ford museum writes it as workers accepting assembly-line discipline in exchange for high pay; these are the sources' own attributions and, under the [unconfirmability of drives](../paper_ae79e938_76e1_4bf9_b2ab_995c03e16c9e/concepts.md#c03), cannot be read off the books; nor can it be inferred that the raise reduced turnover, because this paper does not presuppose a relation between [resources](concepts.md#c03) and [criterion exit](concepts.md#c09), and that is an empirical question for downstream.\n\n**Data notes.** The date on which the chassis went onto the line is stated differently by different sources (August or October 7), and the text says \"between summer and autumn\". \"Sharing part of the profits with workers\" appears only on the public television page. Individual workers' fatigue, what the wages were used for, and the actual motions at each station were not found and are not written.\n\n**Sources**\n\n- Head-Smashed-In Buffalo Jump (Parks Canada)\n- The Buffalo Chasers (Archaeology magazine)\n- Working at Ford's Factory (PBS American Experience)\n- Crowd of Applicants outside Highland Park Plant (The Henry Ford)\n- Ford Methods and the Ford Shops (The Henry Ford)\n- Moving Assembly Line at Ford (History.com)\n- Ford material reprinted by Plant Engineering\n\n---\n\n## 7. Empirical Antecedents and Conditions of Failure\n\n**Empirical antecedents:** This paper contains no empirical antecedent; any relation among [resources](concepts.md#c03), [states](concepts.md#c02), and [criterion exit](concepts.md#c09) is raised and borne by downstream research.\n\n**Calibration and cases:** The calibrations in the sections and the cases in Chapter 6 are not used to support any conclusion of this paper. The data of the two cases are only public web pages, making the model look close to reality; they do not mean the model has been validated.\n\n**Conditions of failure**\n\n- When Premise 1 to Premise 4 are negated, the conclusions whose source chain contains the negated premise lose their source; losing the source only means that the derivation chain is broken, not that the conclusions are false. Premise 1 is a scope setting, and Premise 2 to Premise 4 are settings of the [derivation round](concepts.md#c07) structure and the interfaces; none of them is a claim that can be refuted, and negating them means switching to another set of settings.\n- The derivations of this paper depend on the upstream [Law of the Black Box](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c25), [Law of Flux](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c24), and [Law of Non-Restoration](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c28), and on the definitions of [history](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13), [generating function](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c15), [impression](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c45), [cut](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c23), [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18), and [identity](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c21); whether they hold is left to the upstream papers, and this paper sets no separate failure condition for them.\n- If downstream introduces a relation between [resources](concepts.md#c03) and [criterion exit](concepts.md#c09), or a correspondence between the increases and decreases of different [nodes](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25), that relation is downstream's empirical antecedent, or a [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) made about [identity](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c21), and its failure does not affect this paper.\n\n**Not conclusions of this paper:** Topics such as division of labour, distribution, continuation of knowledge, care, and support are only the researcher's names for compatible repeated continuation on the [production](concepts.md#c01) dimension, and are left to sub-papers. Data that were not obtained (post-hunt distribution, the division of labour of each society, individual workers' fatigue and the use of wages) are not written as \"nonexistent\" and are not used to support conclusions.\n"}]}
{"paper_uuid":"ae79e938-76e1-4bf9-b2ab-995c03e16c9e","paper_title":"互動動力學-共同外生背景下的二階網路","paper_title_en":"Interaction Dynamics - Second-Order Networks under a Common Exogenous Background","author":"黃正宇 / Cheng Yu Huang","contact":"mthree.tw@gmail.com","concepts_md":"---\nuuid: ae79e938-76e1-4bf9-b2ab-995c03e16c9e\nlast-modified: 2026-10-15T14:14:29\n---\n\n\n## public 配置假定 / Configuration Assumption\n\n- 定義:配置假定是對一組具體對象所作的假定:在講明的階段,其中某些對象只具有[一階分別](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c24),其餘對象有[二階分別](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c01),也有[看法歸屬](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c02)。配置假定不是定理。從外部確認某個對象某一刻有沒有[二階分別](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c01),[不被保證](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c02);只有找到機制,證明該對象的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)只能由[鎖死的回合](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c25)落出,或只能由[隨機的回合](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c26)落出,「對象具有二階分別」這一半的假定對它才不成立。\n- Definition: A configuration assumption is an assumption made about a set of concrete objects: at a stated stage, some of the objects have only [First-Order Distinction](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c24), and the others have [Second-Order Distinction](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c01) and also [View Attribution](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c02). A configuration assumption is not a theorem. Confirming from outside that an object has [second-order distinction](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c01) at some moment is [Not Guaranteed](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c02); the half of the assumption that the object has second-order distinction fails for that object only if a mechanism is found showing that its [Outputs](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) can come only from [locked-in rounds](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c25) or only from [random rounds](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c26).\n- 裁決:2026-10-13 作者裁決:概念表登記預設為 public。\n\n\n## public 外生背景 / Exogenous Background\n\n- 定義:外生背景是在講明的時窗與[切法](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c23)下,視為從模型外部進入、不隨模型中的[迴路](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c31)更新的背景。它是範圍上的設定,不主張背景不變;進入模型的是背景,不是各個[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19)從中取得的內容;每個[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19)只拿得到[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)它自己的那一部分,各個[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19)取得的內容可以不同。\n- Definition: Exogenous background is a background that, under a stated time window and a stated [Cut](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c23), is treated as entering the model from outside and as not being updated by the [Loops](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c31) in the model. It is a scope setting and does not claim that the background is unchanging; what enters the model is the background, not what each [Self](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19) draws from it; each [Self](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19) gets only the part that [Arrives](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at it, and what each [Self](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19) obtains may differ.\n- 裁決:2026-10-13 作者裁決:概念表登記預設為 public。\n\n\n## public 驅動力不可確認 / Unconfirmability of Drives\n\n- 定義:驅動力不可確認是這個結論:對不被[鎖死](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c12)的對象,它的驅動力,也就是動機、需求與目的,從外部不能被完整觀測,不能被對象自己的自述確認,旁人事後對動機的判斷也只是[看法歸屬](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c02)或[印象](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c45),不能算證實;動機本身不憑自身[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)旁人。適用範圍:一切不被[鎖死](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c12)的對象,不分年齡,也不分有無[二階分別](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c01);從外部無法確認對象是否被[鎖死](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c12),只能假定。\n- Definition: The Unconfirmability of Drives is the conclusion that the drive of an object that is not in [Lock-in](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c12), meaning its motive, need, or purpose, cannot be completely observed from outside, cannot be confirmed by the object's own account, and a judgment about the motive made by others afterwards is only a [View Attribution](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c02) or an [Impression](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c45) and does not count as verification; the motive itself does not [Arrive](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at others by itself. Scope: every object that is not in [Lock-in](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c12), of any age, whether or not it has [Second-Order Distinction](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c01); whether an object is in [Lock-in](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c12) cannot be confirmed from outside and can only be assumed.\n- 裁決:2026-10-13 作者裁決:概念表登記預設為 public。\n\n\n## public 二階網路 / Second-Order Network\n\n- 定義:二階網路是由具有[二階分別](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c01)與[看法歸屬](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c02)的[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19),以及它們之間的[耦合](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c36)所構成的集合:一個[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19)對另一個[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19)的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)作[看法歸屬](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c02),而不只把它當成一筆[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)來反應;每個參與者在參與的那一刻,既有[二階分別](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c01),也有[看法歸屬](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c02),兩者缺一不可。參與者至少兩個,但不必同時在場:寫下內容的一方,在寫下的那一刻是參與者,之後[退場](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c43)不影響這一點。網路在[歷史](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13)中形成的規律,包括規範與制度,是它的模式,不是另一類實體。\n- Definition: A second-order network is the set formed by [Selves](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19) that have [Second-Order Distinction](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c01) and [View Attribution](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c02), together with the [Couplings](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c36) among them: one [self](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19) makes a [view attribution](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c02) on another [self](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19)'s [Output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28), rather than only reacting to it as an [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28); every participant, at the moment of taking part, has both [second-order distinction](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c01) and [view attribution](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c02), and neither alone suffices. There are at least two participants, who need not be present at the same time: a party who writes content is a participant at the moment of writing, and a later [Exit](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c43) does not change that. The regularities that form in the network over [History](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13), including norms and institutions, are its patterns and not a separate kind of entity.\n- 裁決:2026-10-13 作者裁決:概念表登記預設為 public。二階網路視為新概念,不主張與《三重幻覺與被迫的賭注》中 private 的社會等同,也不寫兩者的關係。參與者更替前後是否仍是同一個網路,本篇不給判準。\n\n\n## public 專屬歷史 / Dedicated History\n\n- 定義:專屬歷史是兩個[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19)之間,在一個講明的維度上,彼此互相[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)所構成的那一段[歷史](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13),只屬於這兩者。\n- Definition: A dedicated history is the part of [History](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13), between two [Selves](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19) along a stated dimension, that is formed by the [Outputs](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) that [arrive](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at each other; it belongs only to these two.\n- 裁決:2026-10-13 作者裁決:概念表登記預設為 public。\n\n\n## public 默契 / Tacit Coordination\n\n- 定義:默契是在指定的情境類型與維度中,兩個[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19)經歷反覆的[專屬歷史](concepts.md#c05),在可比較的情境下,呈現不必每次重新逐項指導、仍能相容接續的行為模式。判準是[歷史](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13)與行為模式,不是預言:它不要求任何一方事先算準對方的下一步,不要求友善,不要求彼此透明,也不要求一方對另一方的[印象](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c45)穩定。互動次數多,不等於已有默契。\n- Definition: Tacit coordination is the behavioral pattern shown when, in a specified type of situation and along a specified dimension, two [Selves](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19) have gone through a repeated [Dedicated History](concepts.md#c05), and in comparable situations can continue compatibly without being instructed item by item each time. The criterion is [History](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13) and behavioral pattern, not prediction: it requires neither that either side calculate the other's next step beforehand, nor friendliness, nor mutual transparency, nor stability of one side's [Impression](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c45) of the other. A large number of interactions does not by itself amount to tacit coordination.\n- 裁決:2026-10-13 作者裁決:概念表登記預設為 public。默契是一個概念;反覆的專屬歷史、可相容接續的行為模式、以及不要求預言友善透明與印象穩定,都是同一個判準的部分,不拆開。\n\n\n## public 指定協調 / Specified Coordination\n\n- 定義:指定協調是這樣一種判準:對一項已界定的任務,依明列的驗收條件,檢查某段實際發生的行動序列;序列符合驗收條件,稱這段序列在該任務上呈現協調。任務是研究者指定的判準,不是參與者驅動力的代名詞;成功也不等於關係改善或彼此理解。\n- Definition: Specified coordination is a criterion: for a defined task, the actual sequence of actions that took place is checked against explicitly stated acceptance conditions; a sequence that meets them is said to show coordination on that task. The task is a criterion specified by the researcher and is not a stand-in for the participants' drives; success does not imply improved relations or mutual understanding.\n- 裁決:2026-10-13 作者裁決:概念表登記預設為 public。\n\n\n## public 失配 / Mismatch\n\n- 定義:失配是在研究者指定的維度與相容判準下,兩個[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19)相鄰的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)序列不相容。判準看的是序列相容與否,不是任何一方想要而沒得到,也不是期待被違反。\n- Definition: A mismatch is, along a researcher-specified dimension and under a specified compatibility criterion, an incompatibility between the adjacent sequences of [Outputs](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) of two [Selves](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19). The criterion concerns whether the sequence is compatible, not whether either party wanted something and did not get it, nor whether an expectation was violated.\n- 裁決:2026-10-13 作者裁決:概念表登記預設為 public。\n\n\n## public 修復 / Repair\n\n- 定義:修復是[失配](concepts.md#c08)之後,在同一維度與同一相容判準下,後續[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)序列重新相容。修復只是序列的記錄,不表示歸屬得到了檢驗,也不表示任何一方得到了想要的,也不表示關係改善。\n- Definition: A repair is, after a [Mismatch](concepts.md#c08), a renewed compatibility of the subsequent sequence of [Outputs](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) along the same dimension and under the same compatibility criterion. A repair is only a record of the sequence; it does not mean that the attribution was tested, that either party got what it wanted, or that relations improved.\n- 裁決:2026-10-13 作者裁決:概念表登記預設為 public。\n\n\n## public 衝突 / Conflict\n\n- 定義:衝突是在研究者指定的維度與時窗內,兩個[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19)之間形成的[太極](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c39):雙方的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)都針對對方在該維度上的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28),方向相反,而且每一方的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)對方,都強化對方自己的方向。至少一方的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)已[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)對方(含經由轉述),才可能形成。各做各的相反方向、沒有針對對方的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28),不是衝突。衝突是對序列的描述,不是對任何一方內在狀態或驅動力的描述。\n- Definition: A conflict is, along a researcher-specified dimension and within a specified time window, a [Taiji](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c39) formed between two [Selves](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19): each side's [Output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) is aimed at the other's [Output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) along that dimension, in opposite directions, and each side's [Output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) [arriving](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at the other strengthens the other's own direction. It can form only after the [Output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) of at least one has [arrived](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at the other (including through relay). Opposite directions pursued independently, without aiming at the other's [Output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28), are not a conflict. A conflict is a description of a sequence, not of any party's inner state or drive.\n- 裁決:2026-10-15 作者裁決:概念表登記預設為 public。「友好」不登記,只在論文中當外顯型態的標籤使用。\n- 裁決:2026-10-15 作者裁決:衝突重新定義為太極型的結構(方向相反、互相針對、互相強化),不再用「序列持續不相容」或「距離持續趨異」;失配(一方沒接上)與趨異(只是距離變長)都不等於衝突。\n\n## 不登記\n\n- 默契承載上限:2026-10-13 作者裁決不登記:只當[默契](concepts.md#c06)一節的條件結論,不另立概念。\n- 約束級結論:2026-10-13 作者裁決不登記:本篇的論證分級標籤,不是被定義的概念。\n- 條件級結論:2026-10-13 作者裁決不登記:本篇的論證分級標籤,不是被定義的概念。\n- 經驗前件:2026-10-13 作者裁決不登記:本篇的論證標籤,指作推導輸入的經驗描述。\n- 前提一至前提十三:2026-10-13 作者裁決不登記:論證中的前提編號,屬形式化階段的標籤。\n- 驅動力:2026-10-13 作者裁決不登記:只出現在[驅動力不可確認](concepts.md#c03)之中,不另立概念。\n- 增加節點、移除節點、歸屬錯位、歷史累積、歷史回流:2026-10-13 作者裁決不登記:本篇對迴路所作操作的名稱,不是被定義的概念。\n- 生物人、節點、邊、合成個體:2026-10-13 作者裁決不登記:一般用語,不是被定義的概念。\n- 經驗:2026-10-16 作者裁決不登記:本篇用語,指已到達的輸出所構成的歷史,即上游[歷史](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13),不另立概念。\n- 相容區域:2026-10-15 作者裁決不登記:4.8 內為估計對方相容門檻所用的條件性構件,指在講明的判準下能與對方接續的輸出範圍,不另立概念。\n- 二階網路的模式(規範、制度):2026-10-13 作者裁決不登記:本篇只當[外生背景](concepts.md#c02),留給文化與陌生人的篇章處理。\n- 友好、門檻:2026-10-15 作者裁決不登記:友好是對外顯型態的標籤,門檻在4.8內已定義為估計對方相容區域所需新增的材料量,不另立概念。\n- 吸引、互惠、信任、安全感、焦慮、承諾、公平、依附:2026-10-15 作者裁決不登記:都是某個我或研究者對外顯型態或內在狀態所作的歸屬,不是被定義的概念。\n- 大迴路、小迴路:2026-10-15 作者裁決不登記:沿用上游迴路,指兩人之間與各自內部的迴路,不另立概念。\n- 慢變量、快變量:2026-10-15 作者裁決不登記:研究者對累積歷史與輸出回饋所作的一次切法的標籤,不是被定義的概念。\n- 衝突升級:2026-10-15 作者裁決不登記:衝突在強度升高階段的標籤,不是被定義的概念。\n- 部件一至部件五(部件):2026-10-15 作者裁決不登記:本篇第二節對模型的分解標籤,不是被定義的概念。\n\n## 待決項\n\n無\n","formalization_md":"論文:《互動動力學-共同外生背景下的二階網路》\nUUID:ae79e938-76e1-4bf9-b2ab-995c03e16c9e\n\n## 記號約定\n\n來源:論文全文\n\n無\n\n## 前置條件\n\n來源:論文第一節【正文:句0678758140】\n\n- 前提一:一個 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.我 的每一次 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別,都在它的下一個 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.時刻 之前 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 它自己。【正文:句4580975618、句4072303323】\n- 前提二:一個 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.我 的任何一個 fb0addca-42b6-4884-aa18-438c695747ab.決定,內容都是一次 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別,不是所說所做之對象的完整描述。【正文:句4580975618、句0960441393】\n- 前提三:fb0addca-42b6-4884-aa18-438c695747ab.計算 落出的結果不是 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別;37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別 只在 fb0addca-42b6-4884-aa18-438c695747ab.決定 中落出。【正文:句4580975618、句1658618433】\n- 前提四:對任何 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.呈現,包括自己,它 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.自己的那一段 中總有沒有 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 這個 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦 的部分。【正文:句4580975618、句1746948346】\n- 前提五:對甲與乙作 配置假定:在講明的階段,甲只具有 fb0addca-42b6-4884-aa18-438c695747ab.一階分別,乙有 fb0addca-42b6-4884-aa18-438c695747ab.二階分別,也有 fb0addca-42b6-4884-aa18-438c695747ab.看法歸屬。【正文:句4580975618、句2397662968】\n- 前提六:在講明的時窗與 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.切法 下,背景為 外生背景:從模型外部進入,不隨模型中的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.迴路 更新。【正文:句4580975618、句4224498769】\n- 前提七:甲帶著產前接觸進入,甲的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.歷史 在出生時不歸零。【正文:句1899319010、句9554533095、句4344397200】\n- 前提八:發育改變甲能參與的維度。【正文:句3464786965、句1289898727、句9811287335】\n- 前提九:在小規模熟人的設定下,每兩個參與者彼此認識,也就是每兩個參與者之間都有一條 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.耦合。【正文:句3464786965、句9434823528】\n- 前提十:每個 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.我 在一段時間內能接收的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 有限。【正文:句2347905363、句4963792494】\n- 前提十一:生物人的神經傳導與反應需要時間,對方對一筆 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 的反應不可能與該 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 同時發生。【正文:句6133220508、句4105538273、句4360239629】\n- 前提十二:每個 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.我 在一個維度上的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.權重 維度很高,而在講明的判準下相容的區域,只占雙方可能 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 組合中很小的一部分。【正文:句9150897332、句7891201932】\n- 前提十三:在同一維度上,專屬歷史 是一個 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.我 估計對方相容區域的材料。【正文:句9150897332、句1910637304】\n- 前提十四 [限定條件]:範圍:只具有 fb0addca-42b6-4884-aa18-438c695747ab.一階分別 的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.我 與有 fb0addca-42b6-4884-aa18-438c695747ab.二階分別 的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.我 互相 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 的配置,以及幾個有 fb0addca-42b6-4884-aa18-438c695747ab.二階分別 的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.我 互相 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 的配置;熟人階段。【正文:句4580975618】\n- 前提十五 [限定條件]:模型只在講明的時窗與 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.切法 下使用。【正文:句4580975618】\n- 前提十六 [限定條件]:只使用上游的公開條目,不引用上游的論證與編號。【正文:句4580975618】\n- 前提十七 [限定條件]:起點:甲與乙在講明的維度上尚無 專屬歷史。【正文:句1899319010】\n- 前提十八 [限定條件]:以下的例是只對這個合成世界成立的有限構造,不是現實樣本。【正文:句9411799841】\n- 前提十九 [限定條件]:距離與固定條件屬 外生背景,在講明的切法下只經由 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.頻率 進入模型。【正文:句4439386989】\n- 前提二十:對不被 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.鎖死 的對象,驅動力,也就是動機、需求與目的,從外部不能被完整觀測,不能被自述確認,旁人事後對動機的判斷也只是 fb0addca-42b6-4884-aa18-438c695747ab.看法歸屬 或 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.印象,不能算證實。【正文:句4580975618】\n- 前提二十一:本篇的推導不使用驅動力。【正文:句1013235852】\n- 前提二十二:本篇只討論已 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 所構成的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.歷史,不討論感受。【正文:句9308971273】\n\n## 定位與假定(對應論文第〇節)\n\n來源:論文第〇節【正文:句3972911508】\n\n- 附註:制度、規範與習俗在原則上是 二階網路 的模式;本篇把它們與文化一併當作 外生背景,是範圍設定,不是對 二階網路 的限制。【正文:句0727431350】\n- 附註:配置假定 不是定理;外生背景 不主張背景不變;進入模型的是背景,不是各個 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.我 從中取得的內容,每個 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.我 只拿得到 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 它自己的那一部分。【正文:句0727431350】\n- 附註:從外部確認一個對象某一刻有沒有 fb0addca-42b6-4884-aa18-438c695747ab.二階分別,b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.不被保證(上游結論);本篇只使用,不推導。【正文:句0727431350】\n- 附註:甲、乙,以及後文的丙、丁、己,都是示範用的合成個體,不是實測個案。【正文:句0727431350】\n\n## 律與前提的推論(對應論文第一節)\n\n來源:論文第一節【正文:句0678758140】\n\n- 附註:以下前提一至前提四,與四條律同為本篇的推導起點;本篇使用,不重新證明。【正文:句4580975618】\n- 附註:前提二、前提三只能假定,不能證實或證偽;前提五、前提六是範圍上的設定;前提二十、前提二十一、前提二十二是作者新增的約束與範圍設定,不由其他前提推出。【正文:句4580975618】\n- 附註:本篇沿用 fb0addca-42b6-4884-aa18-438c695747ab.三道牆、fb0addca-42b6-4884-aa18-438c695747ab.被迫的賭注 與 fb0addca-42b6-4884-aa18-438c695747ab.幻覺 的結論;fb0addca-42b6-4884-aa18-438c695747ab.二階分別 不使 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.我 離開 fb0addca-42b6-4884-aa18-438c695747ab.幻覺,只讓它能被問起。【正文:句4580975618】\n- 步驟一之一:一個 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.我 不被 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.鎖死 時的自述,若出自 fb0addca-42b6-4884-aa18-438c695747ab.決定,內容是一次 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別,不是成因的完整描述(從 前提二 + 前提三 + b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 的定義 + fb0addca-42b6-4884-aa18-438c695747ab.決定 的定義 推出)【正文:句4580975618】\n- 步驟一之二:一個 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.我 看不見自己正在作的那次 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別(從 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.損耗律 + fb0addca-42b6-4884-aa18-438c695747ab.盲點牆 推出)【正文:句4580975618】\n- 步驟一之三:旁人說的「他為了什麼」,若是把對方的一筆 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 劃作對方的看法,就是旁人的 fb0addca-42b6-4884-aa18-438c695747ab.看法歸屬;也可以是旁人對對方 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.權重 的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.印象;兩者都不是對方狀態的讀數(從 fb0addca-42b6-4884-aa18-438c695747ab.看法歸屬 的定義 + b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.印象 的定義 + 前提四 推出)【正文:句4580975618】\n- 步驟一之四:旁人事先不能唯一推出不被 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.鎖死 的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦 的下一個 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.時刻,能推出的是 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.權重(從 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.黑箱律 推出)【正文:句4580975618】\n- 附註:動機本身不是 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出,不憑自身 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 旁人。【正文:句4580975618】\n- 步驟一之四之二:事後對動機的判斷,同樣可以是旁人的一次 fb0addca-42b6-4884-aa18-438c695747ab.看法歸屬,或旁人對對方 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.權重 的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.印象(從 步驟一之三 + 前提二 推出)【正文:句4580975618】\n- 步驟一之四之三:旁人看對象,對象自己的那一段總有沒有 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 旁人的部分,所以旁人不保證能從外部完整觀測對象的驅動力(從 前提四 + 前提二十 推出)【正文:句4580975618】\n- 結論一之五:驅動力不可確認:對不被 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.鎖死 的對象,驅動力從外部不能被完整觀測,不能被自述確認,旁人事後對動機的判斷也只是 fb0addca-42b6-4884-aa18-438c695747ab.看法歸屬 或 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.印象,不能算證實(從 前提二十 + 步驟一之一 + 步驟一之二 + 步驟一之三 + 步驟一之四 + 步驟一之四之二 + 步驟一之四之三 推出)【正文:句4580975618】\n- [作者裁決] 驅動力不可確認 是本篇新增的約束,不由前提一至前提四單獨推出,列為前提二十;步驟一之一至步驟一之四之三是支持性說明,不是它的充分來源。\n- 附註:驅動力不可確認 適用一切不被 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.鎖死 的對象,不分年齡,也不分有無 fb0addca-42b6-4884-aa18-438c695747ab.二階分別。【正文:句4580975618】\n- 步驟一之六:研究者的觀察、詢問、指示與記錄,若記為研究者的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 並 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 被觀察的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.我,則收不回;被觀察者的後續 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 若受它影響並又 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 研究者、參與其 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.權重,雙方構成 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.迴路;所以不預設研究者必在 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.迴路 之外(從 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 的定義 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 的定義 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.權重 的定義 + b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.迴路 的定義 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.不可復原律 推出)【正文:句4580975618】\n\n## 迴圈模型的遞迴(對應論文第二節)\n\n來源:論文第二節【正文:句6129503524】\n\n- 步驟二之十六之一:一個 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.我 在每個 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.時刻 的狀態,由到當時為止 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 它的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.歷史,以及這些 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 如何參與 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.權重 構成(從 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.我 的定義 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦 的定義 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.歷史 的定義 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.權重 的定義 推出)【正文:句9308971273】\n- 步驟二之十六之二:37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 它的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 加進 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.歷史,只加不減(從 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.不可復原律 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.歷史 的定義 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 的定義 推出)【正文:句9308971273】\n- 步驟二之十六之三:37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.權重 是各分支的輕重,不是 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦 的內部參數;37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.歷史 參與下一個 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.時刻 的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.權重 分配,具體函數不指定(從 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.權重 的定義 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦 的定義 推出)【正文:句9308971273】\n- 步驟二之十六之四:不被 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.鎖死 時,下一個 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.時刻 不能事先唯一推出,可推出的是 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.權重(從 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.黑箱律 推出)【正文:句9308971273】\n- 步驟二之十六之五:37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別 再 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 自己(前提一);作為 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別,也可以 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 別人(從 前提一 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 的定義 + b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 的定義 推出)【正文:句9308971273】\n- 步驟二之十六之六:本篇只討論已 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 所構成的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.歷史,不討論感受(從 前提二十二 + b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 的定義 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 的定義 推出)【正文:句9308971273】\n- [作者裁決] 「外部可以記錄」不成立:不在場的人只能靠轉述或當時留下的紀錄,不能預設歷史可被外部記錄;正文已刪去,本步只留感受從外部不能確認,所以本篇只討論已 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 所構成的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.歷史。\n- 循環二之十六:本篇的模型是按 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.時刻 推進的遞迴,狀態是累積的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.歷史;這個循環的退出條件包括 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.我 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.退場;本篇推導它的定性性質,不推出具體軌跡(從 步驟二之十六之一 + 步驟二之十六之二 + 步驟二之十六之三 + 步驟二之十六之四 + 步驟二之十六之五 + 步驟二之十六之六 + b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.退場 的定義 推出)【正文:句9308971273】\n- 附註:轉移函數不指定;本篇不討論感受,討論經驗。【正文:句9308971273】\n\n## 三迴路(對應論文第二節第一小節)\n\n來源:論文第二節第一小節【正文:句7877418160】\n\n- 循環二之一:每個 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.我 有自我回饋的小 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.迴路;這個循環的退出條件是不再是 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦;只要仍是 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦,每次 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別 都 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 自己(前提一)(從 前提一 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦 的定義 + b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.迴路 的定義 推出)【正文:句1013235852】\n- [作者裁決] 本篇把每個 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.我 的每次 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別 記為一筆 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出,循環二之一 的小 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.迴路 以此為據。\n- 循環二之二:一個 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.我 的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 別人,別人的後續 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 受它影響並又 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 該 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.我 時,兩個 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.我 之間另有一個大 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.迴路,與兩邊的小 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.迴路 嵌套;這個循環的退出條件是雙方的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 不再互相 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達(從 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 的定義 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 的定義 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦 的定義 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.權重 的定義 + b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.迴路 的定義 推出)【正文:句1013235852】\n- 循環二之三:只要它們仍是 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦,每個 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.時刻 的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別 仍 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 自己,小 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.迴路 的材料仍在;b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.迴路 能否持續仍 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.不被保證;小 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.迴路 的退出條件是不再是 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦,大 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.迴路 的退出條件是雙方的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 不再互相 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達(從 循環二之一 + 循環二之二 + 前提一 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.流變律 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦 的定義 + b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.迴路 的定義 推出)【正文:句1013235852】\n- 步驟二之四:b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.迴路 上傳的是 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出,驅動力不進推導(從 前提二十一 + b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.迴路 的定義 推出)【正文:句1013235852】\n- 結論二之十一:每個 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.我 有自我回饋的小 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.迴路;兩個 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.我 的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 互相 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達,且各自的後續 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 受對方 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 影響時,兩者之間有大 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.迴路;b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.迴路 上傳的是 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出(從 循環二之一 + 循環二之二 + 步驟二之四 推出)【正文:句1013235852】\n\n## 部分到達(對應論文第二節第二小節)\n\n來源:論文第二節第二小節【正文:句7796783312】\n\n- 結論二之十二:每個 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.我 拿到的,只有 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.自己的那一段(從 前提四 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別 的定義 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 的定義 推出)【正文:句0821209941】\n- 步驟二之十之三:只取兩個節點的分析是一種 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.切法,結論只對這個 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.切法 成立,不是這段關係本身的性質(從 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.切法 的定義 + 前提四 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.黑箱律 推出)【正文:句0821209941】\n\n## 不可預推(對應論文第二節第三小節)\n\n來源:論文第二節第三小節【正文:句0988138451】\n\n- 結論二之十三:不被 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.鎖死 的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.我,下一個 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.時刻 不能事先唯一推出,37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 它的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.歷史 每個 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.時刻 都不同(從 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.黑箱律 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.流變律 推出)【正文:句6133220508】\n- 結論二之十七:同一筆 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 在不同 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.時刻 對同一個 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.我 的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.份量 與 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.歧異度 可以不同,所以系統不保證是定常的(從 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.份量 的定義 + b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.歧異度 的定義 + 結論二之十三 推出)【正文:句6133220508】\n- 步驟二之七:不被 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.鎖死 的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.我 的下一個 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.時刻 不能事先唯一推出,所以有 fb0addca-42b6-4884-aa18-438c695747ab.二階分別 不推出這一次使用(從 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.黑箱律 + 配置假定 的定義 推出)【正文:句6133220508】\n- 步驟二之八:使用 fb0addca-42b6-4884-aa18-438c695747ab.二階分別 也是一次 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別,仍受 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.損耗律 約束(從 fb0addca-42b6-4884-aa18-438c695747ab.二階分別 的定義 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.損耗律 推出)【正文:句6133220508】\n- 附註:能力隨年齡與相處如何變化,屬生物性,由經驗決定;邏輯不能決定,本篇不推導。【正文:句6133220508】\n- 步驟二之十之一:不能假定兩端的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.時刻 對齊;一筆 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 時,對方的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.歷史 與它落出時不必相同(從 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.流變律 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 的定義 推出)【正文:句6133220508】\n- 附註:前提十一 是經驗前件,作推導的輸入;它是物理限制,不是對一般的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.我 的主張。【正文:句6133220508】\n- 結論二之十之二:對生物人,對方對一筆 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 的反應,不與該 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 同時發生(從 前提十一 推出)【正文:句6133220508】\n- 附註:結論二之十之二 為條件級,用到前提十一。【正文:句6133220508】\n\n## 單向累積(對應論文第二節第四小節)\n\n來源:論文第二節第四小節【正文:句7087808866】\n\n- 結論二之十:專屬歷史 按維度計;一處為零,不取消其他處已有的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.歷史(從 專屬歷史 的定義 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.不可復原律 推出)【正文:句2024238389】\n- 結論二之十四:37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.歷史 中每個位置只發生一次,已發生的收不回;專屬歷史 按維度計(從 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.不可復原律 + 結論二之十 推出)【正文:句2024238389】\n- 步驟二之十八之一:研究者可以把累積的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.歷史 看作慢的一層,把 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 與回饋看作快的一層,這是一次 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.切法,不說明 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.權重 為什麼變(從 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.黑箱律 + b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.切法 的定義 推出)【正文:句2024238389】\n- 結論二之十八:在這個 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.切法 下,累積的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.歷史 是慢變量,b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 與回饋是快變量;累積只加不減,不推出品質單調變好(從 步驟二之十八之一 + 結論二之十四 + b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.印象 的定義 + 默契 的定義 推出)【正文:句2024238389】\n- [作者裁決] 慢變量與快變量是研究者在觀察上的一次 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.切法,不是對 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.權重 為什麼變的說明,因為 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.權重 不可讀;正文已改寫,補入 步驟二之十八之一。\n\n## 歸屬即輸出(對應論文第二節第五小節)\n\n來源:論文第二節第五小節【正文:句4225209858】\n\n- 結論二之十五:指向內在狀態或動機的詞,可以是某個 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.我 或研究者的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別、fb0addca-42b6-4884-aa18-438c695747ab.看法歸屬 或對 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.權重 的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.印象;說出口時是一筆 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出,37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 別人的部分進入其 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.歷史,並參與其後續的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.權重(從 fb0addca-42b6-4884-aa18-438c695747ab.看法歸屬 的定義 + b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.印象 的定義 + b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 的定義 + 結論一之五 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦 的定義 推出)【正文:句1789825362】\n\n## 配置變數與操作(對應論文第二節第六小節)\n\n來源:論文第二節第六小節【正文:句4964933185】\n\n- 結論二之五:有 fb0addca-42b6-4884-aa18-438c695747ab.二階分別 的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.我,多一個把自己的某次 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別 當成看法再作 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別 的環節(從 fb0addca-42b6-4884-aa18-438c695747ab.二階分別 的定義 推出)【正文:句4528686876】\n- 步驟二之六:只具有 fb0addca-42b6-4884-aa18-438c695747ab.一階分別 的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.我 沒有這個環節(從 fb0addca-42b6-4884-aa18-438c695747ab.一階分別 的定義 推出)【正文:句4528686876】\n- 附註:六種操作只是操作的名稱,不是新增的前提,推導不以它們為來源。【正文:句4528686876】\n\n## 起點(對應論文第三節第一小節)\n\n來源:論文第三節第一小節【正文:句2733780195】\n\n- 附註:前提七 是經驗前件,作推導的輸入,不拿來證明約束為真。【正文:句1899319010】\n- 結論三之一之一:甲的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.歷史 在出生時不歸零,新的關係不等於一切重來(從 結論二之十四 + 前提七 推出)【正文:句1899319010】\n- 步驟三之一之二:乙帶著自己已 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 乙 的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.歷史 進入,其中若有 外生背景 經乙 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 的部分,那部分才在乙的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.歷史 中;從未 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 乙 的部分不在乙已 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 乙 的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.歷史 中(從 結論二之十二 + 前提六 推出)【正文:句1899319010】\n- 附註:本節為條件級結論,用到前提七。【正文:句1899319010】\n\n## 甲的輸出與乙的候選歸屬(對應論文第三節第二小節)\n\n來源:論文第三節第二小節【正文:句5388266179】\n\n- 步驟三之二之一:若本例把甲的哭記為一筆 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出,則它是一筆 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出(從 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 的定義 推出)【正文:句2837370834】\n- [作者裁決] 本例把甲的哭、停哭,以及甲說「你誤會我了」,記為甲的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出,是建模約定,不由 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 的定義單獨推出。\n- 步驟三之二之二:不能把甲「為了被抱」而哭寫成已確認的事實(從 結論二之十五 + 結論一之五 推出)【正文:句2837370834】\n- 結論三之二之三:乙把哭歸成 fb0addca-42b6-4884-aa18-438c695747ab.候選 之一時,可以是乙的一次 fb0addca-42b6-4884-aa18-438c695747ab.看法歸屬(若乙把甲的哭認作甲的一次看法),也可以是乙對甲 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.權重 的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.印象;兩者都不是甲狀態的讀數,也不保證有外部可得的判準判定它對或錯(從 前提五 + fb0addca-42b6-4884-aa18-438c695747ab.看法歸屬 的定義 + b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.印象 的定義 + fb0addca-42b6-4884-aa18-438c695747ab.候選 的定義 + 結論一之五 推出)【正文:句2837370834】\n- 附註:乙為什麼挑這幾個 fb0addca-42b6-4884-aa18-438c695747ab.候選,來自乙自己的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.歷史,本篇不再往上追。【正文:句2837370834】\n- 附註:「我一切為了家人」的例子是校準,不作推導來源。【正文:句2837370834】\n\n## 試錯與校準(對應論文第三節第三小節)\n\n來源:論文第三節第三小節【正文:句3579775827】\n\n- 步驟三之三之一:乙不被 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.鎖死 時的每次嘗試是一次 fb0addca-42b6-4884-aa18-438c695747ab.被迫的賭注(從 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦 的定義 + fb0addca-42b6-4884-aa18-438c695747ab.決定 的定義 + fb0addca-42b6-4884-aa18-438c695747ab.被迫的賭注 的定義 推出)【正文:句8303684072】\n- 步驟三之三之二:甲後續的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 若 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 乙,就是乙拿到的新 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達,乙後續嘗試的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.權重 受這些 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 影響(從 結論三之二之三 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 的定義 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦 的定義 推出)【正文:句8303684072】\n- 步驟三之三之二之二:若本例把停哭記為甲的一筆 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出,則它是甲的一筆 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出(從 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 的定義 推出)【正文:句8303684072】\n- 結論三之三之三:若本例把停哭記為甲的一筆 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出,則它只是甲的一筆 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出,不單獨構成對歸屬的檢驗:甲為什麼哭、為什麼停都不保證能從外部確認,歸屬的對錯不保證有外部可得的判準(從 步驟三之三之二之二 + 結論三之二之三 + 結論二之十五 推出)【正文:句8303684072】\n- 步驟三之三之四:乙的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.印象 穩定不等於更接近真實的甲(從 結論三之二之三 + 結論二之十二 推出)【正文:句8303684072】\n- 結論三之三之五:乙可以把自己的歸屬當成看法再修正,甲沒有這個環節(從 前提五 + 結論二之五 + 步驟二之六 推出)【正文:句8303684072】\n- 附註:結論三之三之五 為條件級,用到前提五。【正文:句8303684072】\n\n## 失配 與 修復(對應論文第三節第四小節)\n\n來源:論文第三節第四小節【正文:句1451319974】\n\n- 附註:失配 與 修復 的判準由研究者指定,看序列相容與否,不看驅動力。【正文:句4245301220】\n- 結論三之四之一:失配 是這個 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.迴路 結構上不被排除的可能(從 步驟三之三之一 + 失配 的定義 + fb0addca-42b6-4884-aa18-438c695747ab.被迫的賭注 的定義 推出)【正文:句4245301220】\n- 結論三之四之二:修復 只表示序列重新相容,不表示歸屬得到了檢驗(從 修復 的定義 + 結論三之三之三 推出)【正文:句4245301220】\n- 步驟三之四之三:序列重新相容可以來自乙換 fb0addca-42b6-4884-aa18-438c695747ab.候選、甲的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 改變、外生背景 改變或 fb0addca-42b6-4884-aa18-438c695747ab.隨機的回合,從 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 不一定看得出差別(從 結論二之十三 + 前提六 + fb0addca-42b6-4884-aa18-438c695747ab.隨機的回合 的定義 + fb0addca-42b6-4884-aa18-438c695747ab.候選 的定義 推出)【正文:句4245301220】\n- 步驟三之四之四:若序列重新相容,乙端的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 是可以追溯改變的一處,因為乙能回頭修正自己的歸屬,甲沒有這個環節(從 結論三之三之五 + 前提五 推出)【正文:句4245301220】\n- 步驟三之四之五:不回應也是一個結果,被對方察覺時會 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 對方,所以不得把沒有回應寫成沒有影響(從 fb0addca-42b6-4884-aa18-438c695747ab.被迫的賭注 的定義 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 的定義 推出)【正文:句4245301220】\n- 步驟三之四之六:已落出的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 收不回,留在已 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 的各方的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.歷史 裡,影響後續的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.權重(從 結論二之十四 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.權重 的定義 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦 的定義 推出)【正文:句4245301220】\n- 結論三之四之七:失配 之後不保證 修復,也不推出此後永遠不會 修復(從 結論二之十三 + 失配 的定義 + 修復 的定義 + 步驟三之四之六 推出)【正文:句4245301220】\n- 結論三之四之八:失配 之後的序列,後續走向 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.不被保證,可能是 修復、原諒、衝突、持續溝通等;原諒 若是對序列所作的歸屬,則不推出 修復,修復 也不推出原諒(從 失配 的定義 + 修復 的定義 + fb0addca-42b6-4884-aa18-438c695747ab.看法歸屬 的定義 + 結論二之十五 + fb0addca-42b6-4884-aa18-438c695747ab.被迫的賭注 的定義 推出)【正文:句4245301220】\n- 附註:步驟三之四之四 是尋找的次序,不是已確定原因在乙端;它為條件級,用到前提五。【正文:句4245301220】\n\n## 我的建構與材料的來源(對應論文第三節第五小節)\n\n來源:論文第三節第五小節【正文:句6730920521】\n\n- 步驟三之五之一:甲自己的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 回到甲,可以成為甲建構自己的材料(從 結論二之十一 + fb0addca-42b6-4884-aa18-438c695747ab.我的建構 的定義 推出)【正文:句9796490943】\n- 步驟三之五之二:乙的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 甲,可以成為甲建構自己的另一份材料(從 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 的定義 + fb0addca-42b6-4884-aa18-438c695747ab.我的建構 的定義 推出)【正文:句9796490943】\n- 結論三之五之三:兩個來源在有無 fb0addca-42b6-4884-aa18-438c695747ab.二階分別 時都存在;fb0addca-42b6-4884-aa18-438c695747ab.二階分別 只多一個處理環節(從 步驟三之五之一 + 步驟三之五之二 + 結論二之五 推出)【正文:句9796490943】\n- 步驟三之五之四:乙的歸屬與框架若經由 外生背景 進入甲的內容,則帶著乙可能的誤差(從 前提五 + 前提六 + 結論三之二之三 推出)【正文:句9796490943】\n- 步驟三之五之五:甲看到的永遠只是已經建好的自己(從 fb0addca-42b6-4884-aa18-438c695747ab.盲點牆 推出)【正文:句9796490943】\n- 附註:步驟三之五之四 為條件級,用到前提五與前提六。【正文:句9796490943】\n- 步驟三之五之六:一個 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.我 的材料可以有三處:對外物的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別;對他人 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 的 fb0addca-42b6-4884-aa18-438c695747ab.看法歸屬 與 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.印象;對自己某次 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別 的再作 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別,第三處只有具 fb0addca-42b6-4884-aa18-438c695747ab.二階分別 者有(從 結論二之十一 + 結論二之五 + fb0addca-42b6-4884-aa18-438c695747ab.看法歸屬 的定義 + b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.印象 的定義 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別 的定義 + fb0addca-42b6-4884-aa18-438c695747ab.我的建構 的定義 推出)【正文:句9796490943】\n- 步驟三之五之七:已有的各處材料,都回到那個 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.我 自己,進入下一個 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.時刻 的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.權重(從 結論二之十一 + 前提一 + fb0addca-42b6-4884-aa18-438c695747ab.看法歸屬 的定義 推出)【正文:句9796490943】\n- 結論三之五之八:互動次數增加,增加材料,但不保證三處同時改善,不保證 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.印象 逼近對方,也不使對方的真實 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.權重 可讀(從 步驟三之三之四 + 步驟三之五之六 + 步驟三之五之七 + 結論二之十三 + 結論二之十二 + 步驟二之十六之二 推出)【正文:句9796490943】\n- [作者裁決] 互動次數是產生材料的過程,增加的是材料,不保證三處同時改善,不保證 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.印象 逼近對方,也不使對方的真實 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.權重 可讀;正文已刪去「只」,來源補上 步驟三之五之六、步驟三之五之七 與 結論二之十二。\n- 結論三之五之九:具 fb0addca-42b6-4884-aa18-438c695747ab.二階分別 的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.我(如成人)的自我概念有兩個來源,若它把他人對自己的歸屬當成看法再 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別,這仍是它自己的一次 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別;有這個能力,不推出這一次使用,也不推出看到自己的全部(從 結論三之五之三 + 結論二之五 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.損耗律 + fb0addca-42b6-4884-aa18-438c695747ab.盲點牆 的定義 + fb0addca-42b6-4884-aa18-438c695747ab.二階分別 的定義 + fb0addca-42b6-4884-aa18-438c695747ab.看法歸屬 的定義 推出)【正文:句9796490943】\n- 附註:孩子看見大人拿外套的例子是校準,不作推導來源。【正文:句9796490943】\n\n## 二階出現的邊界(對應論文第三節第六小節)\n\n來源:論文第三節第六小節【正文:句4479186152】\n\n- 附註:fb0addca-42b6-4884-aa18-438c695747ab.二階分別 的出現是經驗描述,本篇不解釋,也不主張必定出現。【正文:句8218608022】\n- 結論三之六之一:蘊含(甲出現 fb0addca-42b6-4884-aa18-438c695747ab.二階分別 且有 fb0addca-42b6-4884-aa18-438c695747ab.看法歸屬, 兩邊的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.迴路 在能力配置上對稱)(從 結論二之五 + 二階網路 的定義 + fb0addca-42b6-4884-aa18-438c695747ab.看法歸屬 的定義 + 前提五 + 結論二之十一 推出)【正文:句8218608022】\n- 結論三之六之二:蘊含(甲出現 fb0addca-42b6-4884-aa18-438c695747ab.二階分別 且有 fb0addca-42b6-4884-aa18-438c695747ab.看法歸屬, fb0addca-42b6-4884-aa18-438c695747ab.三問 對甲敞開)(從 fb0addca-42b6-4884-aa18-438c695747ab.三問 的定義 + fb0addca-42b6-4884-aa18-438c695747ab.二階分別 的定義 推出)【正文:句8218608022】\n- 結論三之六之三:蘊含(甲出現 fb0addca-42b6-4884-aa18-438c695747ab.二階分別 且有 fb0addca-42b6-4884-aa18-438c695747ab.看法歸屬, 甲仍在 fb0addca-42b6-4884-aa18-438c695747ab.幻覺 之中)(從 fb0addca-42b6-4884-aa18-438c695747ab.幻覺 的定義 + 步驟二之八 + 步驟三之五之五 推出)【正文:句8218608022】\n\n## 對稱迴圈、二階網路 與含嬰兒的邊(對應論文第四節第一小節)\n\n來源:論文第四節第一小節【正文:句8408201720】\n\n- 步驟四之一之一:甲若出現 fb0addca-42b6-4884-aa18-438c695747ab.二階分別 且有 fb0addca-42b6-4884-aa18-438c695747ab.看法歸屬,每個 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.我 都有自己的小 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.迴路,都能把自己的某次 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別 當成看法再作 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別,也都能對別人的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 作 fb0addca-42b6-4884-aa18-438c695747ab.看法歸屬(從 結論二之五 + 結論二之十一 + 二階網路 的定義 + fb0addca-42b6-4884-aa18-438c695747ab.看法歸屬 的定義 + 前提五 推出)【正文:句2775292395】\n- 結論四之一之二:一個人獨自讀別人留下的文字,把內容劃為對方的看法,又能把自己對內容的理解也當成看法,而留下文字的人在寫作當刻也具 fb0addca-42b6-4884-aa18-438c695747ab.二階分別 與 fb0addca-42b6-4884-aa18-438c695747ab.看法歸屬,在這一刻就在 二階網路 之中(從 二階網路 的定義 + fb0addca-42b6-4884-aa18-438c695747ab.看法歸屬 的定義 + fb0addca-42b6-4884-aa18-438c695747ab.二階分別 的定義 + b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.退場 的定義 推出)【正文:句2775292395】\n- 步驟四之一之三:結構對稱不推出 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 或 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.權重 對稱(從 結論二之十二 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 的定義 推出)【正文:句2775292395】\n- 步驟四之一之四:二階網路 的模式對某個 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.我 的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.權重 起作用,只經由具體的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達(從 結論二之十二 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.權重 的定義 + 二階網路 的定義 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦 的定義 推出)【正文:句2775292395、句9011791004、句9398162187】\n- 附註:規範與制度等 二階網路 的模式對某個 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.我 的作用,本篇只追蹤經由具體的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 與 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.權重 的部分,不另立為獨立原因。【正文:句2775292395、句9011791004、句9398162187】\n- 附註:本篇不為不在場的對方另畫節點;對方的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 已 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 這個人,進入他的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.歷史。【正文:句2775292395】\n- 附註:二階網路 在 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.歷史 中形成的規律,包括規範與制度,是它的模式,不是另一類實體。【正文:句2775292395】\n- 結論四之一之五:在小規模熟人的設定下,甲所在的邊是 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.耦合,但甲那一端沒有 fb0addca-42b6-4884-aa18-438c695747ab.二階分別,所以這條邊不屬於 二階網路(從 前提五 + 前提九 + b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.耦合 的定義 + 二階網路 的定義 推出)【正文:句2775292395】\n- 步驟四之一之六:只有兩端各自在參與的那一刻都有 fb0addca-42b6-4884-aa18-438c695747ab.二階分別 與 fb0addca-42b6-4884-aa18-438c695747ab.看法歸屬 的邊,才屬於 二階網路(從 二階網路 的定義 推出)【正文:句2775292395】\n- 步驟四之一之七:從外部確認某個 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.我 某一刻是否具備這兩者,b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.不被保證;本篇對這兩者作 配置假定(從 配置假定 的定義 + b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.不被保證 的定義 + 前提五 推出)【正文:句2775292395】\n- 附註:步驟四之一之七 為條件級,用到前提五。【正文:句2775292395】\n\n## 多個我交錯(對應論文第四節第二小節)\n\n來源:論文第四節第二小節【正文:句2582517527】\n\n- 步驟四之二之一:乙的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 可以同時 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 丙與丁,乙對丙的歸屬和對丁的歸屬各自回到乙自己(從 結論二之十一 + 前提一 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 的定義 + fb0addca-42b6-4884-aa18-438c695747ab.看法歸屬 的定義 推出)【正文:句6500624261】\n- 附註:節點之間不必每一對都有 專屬歷史;哪幾對有,由資料決定,屬條件級。【正文:句6500624261】\n- 步驟四之二之二:人數增加,不保證每個 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.我 拿到的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 占全部 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.歷史 的比例上升(從 結論二之十二 推出)【正文:句6500624261】\n- 步驟四之二之三:b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.迴路 越多,不等於越透明(從 步驟四之二之二 + 結論二之十一 推出)【正文:句6500624261】\n- 結論四之二之四:二階網路 不保證因人多而成為掌握全部成員 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.歷史 的主體(從 結論二之十三 + 結論二之十二 推出)【正文:句6500624261】\n- 步驟四之二之五:對整個網路作預測的人,對網路中每個 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.我 同樣只取得部分 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達,不能因人多而掌握全部成員的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.歷史;這不推出網路的聚合量不可預測(從 結論四之二之四 + 結論二之十二 推出)【正文:句6500624261】\n- 步驟四之二之六:只要其中有一個 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.我 不被 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.鎖死,該 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.我 的下一個 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.時刻 不能事先唯一推出(從 結論二之十三 推出)【正文:句6500624261】\n\n## 歸屬的協商(對應論文第四節第三小節)\n\n來源:論文第四節第三小節【正文:句8963010713】\n\n- 步驟四之三之一:歸屬可以被拿出來協商(從 fb0addca-42b6-4884-aa18-438c695747ab.二階分別 的定義 + 二階網路 的定義 + 結論二之五 + b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 的定義 推出)【正文:句7514803976】\n- 步驟四之三之二:本例把甲說「你誤會我了」記為甲的一筆 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出;37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 乙之後,乙對它作的 fb0addca-42b6-4884-aa18-438c695747ab.看法歸屬 仍是乙的一次 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別(從 前提二 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 的定義 + fb0addca-42b6-4884-aa18-438c695747ab.看法歸屬 的定義 + b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 的定義 推出)【正文:句7514803976】\n- 結論四之三之三:協商不保證修正成功,也不保證任何一方能確認對方的驅動力(從 步驟四之三之二 + 結論二之十五 + 結論一之五 推出)【正文:句7514803976】\n\n## 增加節點(對應論文第四節第四小節)\n\n來源:論文第四節第四小節【正文:句4672143741】\n\n- 附註:前提八 是經驗前件,作推導的輸入。【正文:句3464786965】\n- 附註:前提九 是範圍上的設定,不是對一般情形的主張;認識三個人,不代表這三個人彼此認識。【正文:句3464786965】\n- 步驟四之四之〇:邊是有 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.耦合 的一對參與者;節點兩兩成對,共有 節點數 乘以 節點數減一 再除以二 對,所以邊數不超過這個數(從 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.耦合 的定義 推出)【正文:句3464786965】\n- 步驟四之四之〇之一:在前提九 的設定下,每一對都有 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.耦合,邊數等於 節點數 乘以 節點數減一 再除以二,增加得比節點數快(從 前提九 + 步驟四之四之〇 推出)【正文:句3464786965】\n- 步驟四之四之一:乙的同一次 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 丙與到達 丁,是兩次不同的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達(從 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 的定義 + 前提四 推出)【正文:句3464786965】\n- 步驟四之四之二:乙與丙之間的某些 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 可以從未 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 丁,丁因此 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.不被保證 能取得乙丙之間完整的 專屬歷史(從 結論二之十二 + 專屬歷史 的定義 + 結論二之十四 + b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.不被保證 的定義 推出)【正文:句3464786965】\n- 結論四之四之三:「被排除在外」在模型中能寫的是某些 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 沒有 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達,為什麼沒有不能寫成有人刻意為之(從 步驟四之四之二 + 結論二之十五 推出)【正文:句3464786965】\n- 步驟四之四之四:丙若把乙的話轉給丁,且這個轉述記為丙的一筆 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出,則它是丙的一筆新 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出,不是乙原來那筆 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 的複本;若丙把乙那句話認作乙的一次看法,這筆 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 帶著丙的 fb0addca-42b6-4884-aa18-438c695747ab.看法歸屬(從 前提二 + 結論二之十二 + b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 的定義 + fb0addca-42b6-4884-aa18-438c695747ab.看法歸屬 的定義 推出)【正文:句3464786965】\n- [作者裁決] 丙的轉述是否記為丙的一筆 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出,是建模約定,不由 輸出 的定義單獨推出;本篇的轉述分析以此約定為前件。\n- 步驟四之四之四之一:丙把乙的話轉給丁,若該轉述記為丙的一筆新 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出,則不構成乙對丁的直接 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達;丁拿到的是丙的新 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出(從 步驟四之四之四 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 的定義 推出)【正文:句3464786965】\n- 結論四之四之五:轉述不可能把乙的那一段完整傳過去(從 步驟四之四之四 + 結論二之十二 + 前提四 推出)【正文:句3464786965】\n- 步驟四之四之六:新成員甲與既有成員,在講明的維度上若此前沒有雙向 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達,則都是零起點(從 專屬歷史 的定義 + 結論二之十四 推出)【正文:句3464786965】\n- 結論四之四之七:乙丙既有的 專屬歷史 不因此歸零,也不因此成為甲的(從 結論二之十四 + 專屬歷史 的定義 推出)【正文:句3464786965】\n- 步驟四之四之八:甲加入之後,乙丙之間的後續 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 可以 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 甲,乙丙的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.迴路 與 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.歷史 不是甲加入之前的靜止延長(從 結論二之十三 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 的定義 推出)【正文:句3464786965】\n- 步驟四之四之九:可參與的維度增加,不等於這些維度上的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 已發生,也不等於 專屬歷史 已有(從 前提八 + 專屬歷史 的定義 + 結論二之十四 推出)【正文:句3464786965】\n- 附註:步驟四之四之九 為條件級,用到前提八;有沒有居中傳話的人,由資料決定。【正文:句3464786965】\n\n## 移除節點(對應論文第四節第五小節)\n\n來源:論文第四節第五小節【正文:句5361415228】\n\n- 步驟四之五之一:一個 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.我 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.退場 之後,它已經 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 別人的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 仍留在別人的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.歷史 裡(從 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.退場 的定義 + 結論二之十四 推出)【正文:句6547002702】\n- 步驟四之五之二:它沒有 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 別人的部分,不因退場而到達;是否仍可到達,b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.不被保證(從 結論二之十二 + 結論二之十四 + b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.不被保證 的定義 推出)【正文:句6547002702】\n- 結論四之五之三:個人終止時,若他之後的位置在下一個 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.時刻 不再是 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦,就是一次 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.退場;已經發生並 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 別人的部分仍在(從 步驟四之五之一 + 步驟四之五之二 + b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.退場 的定義 推出)【正文:句6547002702】\n- 步驟四之五之四:後來的人做出相同的動作,是新的位置上發生的新的一次,不是他那一段的復原(從 結論二之十四 推出)【正文:句6547002702】\n- 附註:要主張同一個模式接續,須列出可追溯的參與者、b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出、記錄或規則;同名或相似不夠。哪些模式實際接續,由資料決定。【正文:句6547002702、句0079482233】\n- 結論四之五之五:成員更替既不推出網路消失,也不推出網路延續(從 二階網路 的定義 推出)【正文:句6547002702】\n- 附註:二階網路 的定義沒有給出參與者更替前後是否仍是同一個網路的判準。【正文:句6547002702】\n\n## 歸屬錯位、衝突 與歸屬的標籤(對應論文第四節第六小節)\n\n來源:論文第四節第六小節【正文:句3230028982】\n\n- 步驟四之六之一:拒絕、警告與反制,若記為 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 且 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 對方,則進入同一段 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.歷史;衝突 是雙方這類 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 方向相反、37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 對方、互相針對並互相強化所形成的結構,不是另一筆 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出(從 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 的定義 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.歷史 的定義 + 衝突 的定義 推出)【正文:句7344351372】\n- 步驟四之六之二:不能由此補出任何一方的完整內心目的(從 結論二之十五 推出)【正文:句7344351372】\n- 步驟四之六之十二:失配 是一方的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 沒有接上,可以只有一邊,不需要方向相反;衝突 要雙方的方向相反且各自針對對方的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出,兩者不同(從 失配 的定義 + 衝突 的定義 推出)【正文:句7344351372】\n- 結論四之六之十:沒有任何 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達(含經由別人轉述的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達),兩個 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.我 之間就沒有 衝突(從 衝突 的定義 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 的定義 推出)【正文:句7344351372】\n- [作者裁決] 衝突 重新定義為太極型的結構:雙方方向相反、各自針對對方的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出、每一方的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 到達對方都強化對方自己的方向;失配 與 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.趨異 都不等於 衝突。結論四之六之十 的來源改為 衝突 的定義 與 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 的定義,正文與概念表已相應修改。\n- 附註:結論四之六之十 只寫必要條件,不寫 衝突 如何產生;它用到「拒絕、警告與反制是針對已 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 所作的後續 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出」,這是這幾個詞的意思。【正文:句7344351372】\n- 步驟四之六之三:某個 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.我 可以把序列說成「欺騙」或「強迫」;這是該 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.我 的一次 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別,也可以是對對方 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.權重 的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.印象,若把它劃為對方的看法,則是 fb0addca-42b6-4884-aa18-438c695747ab.看法歸屬 的內容(從 fb0addca-42b6-4884-aa18-438c695747ab.看法歸屬 的定義 + b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.印象 的定義 推出)【正文:句7344351372】\n- 步驟四之六之四:若這兩個詞指不被 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.鎖死 的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.我 的內部狀態與驅動力,則從外部不能確認;依公開行為、程序或外部約束判定者不在此限(從 結論一之五 + 結論二之十五 推出)【正文:句7344351372】\n- 步驟四之六之五:這個歸屬若說出口,本身是一筆 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出,37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 別人的部分進入其 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.歷史,並參與其後續的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.權重(從 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 的定義 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 的定義 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.權重 的定義 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦 的定義 推出)【正文:句7344351372】\n- 步驟四之六之六:研究者使用這兩個詞時,可以是研究者的 fb0addca-42b6-4884-aa18-438c695747ab.看法歸屬,也可以是研究者對對方 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.權重 的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.印象(從 fb0addca-42b6-4884-aa18-438c695747ab.看法歸屬 的定義 + b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.印象 的定義 推出)【正文:句7344351372】\n- 結論四之六之七:僅憑外顯描述,不保證分得出欺騙與誤報,也不保證分得出強迫與自願;公開約束或現場證據等其他材料能否區分,b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.不被保證(從 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.損耗律 + fb0addca-42b6-4884-aa18-438c695747ab.幻覺 的定義 + 結論二之十三 + b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.不被保證 的定義 推出)【正文:句7344351372】\n- 步驟四之六之八:對方這一段是不是 fb0addca-42b6-4884-aa18-438c695747ab.決定,只能假定,b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.不被保證 能從外部確認;能推翻這個假定的,是找到機制,證明對方這一段只能由 fb0addca-42b6-4884-aa18-438c695747ab.鎖死的回合 或 fb0addca-42b6-4884-aa18-438c695747ab.隨機的回合 落出(從 前提三 + fb0addca-42b6-4884-aa18-438c695747ab.決定 的定義 + fb0addca-42b6-4884-aa18-438c695747ab.計算 的定義 + fb0addca-42b6-4884-aa18-438c695747ab.鎖死的回合 的定義 + fb0addca-42b6-4884-aa18-438c695747ab.隨機的回合 的定義 + 前提二 + 結論一之五 + b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.不被保證 的定義 推出)【正文:句7344351372】\n- 結論四之六之十一:指向對方內在狀態或動機的詞(信任、安全感、焦慮、承諾、公平、情緒的傳染與共調節、社會支持),可以是某個 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.我 或研究者的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別、fb0addca-42b6-4884-aa18-438c695747ab.看法歸屬 或對 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.權重 的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.印象;這些詞若指公開的言語、程序或可見的援助,則不在此列;說出口時是一筆 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出,37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 別人的部分進入其 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.歷史,並參與其後續的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.權重;其真假模型不裁決,依其行動不被 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.鎖死 時是一次 fb0addca-42b6-4884-aa18-438c695747ab.被迫的賭注(從 fb0addca-42b6-4884-aa18-438c695747ab.看法歸屬 的定義 + b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.印象 的定義 + b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.份量 的定義 + 結論二之十五 + fb0addca-42b6-4884-aa18-438c695747ab.被迫的賭注 的定義 + 步驟四之六之五 推出)【正文:句7344351372】\n- 結論四之六之九:這時對方這一段的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 不是 fb0addca-42b6-4884-aa18-438c695747ab.決定,這條邊在這一刻不能算作由對方的 fb0addca-42b6-4884-aa18-438c695747ab.二階分別 所作的決定;不由此推出對方不具 fb0addca-42b6-4884-aa18-438c695747ab.二階分別,其他時刻是否屬於 二階網路,也不由此推出(從 步驟四之六之八 + 步驟四之一之六 + 前提三 + fb0addca-42b6-4884-aa18-438c695747ab.二階分別 的定義 推出)【正文:句7344351372】\n- 附註:本節的校準只是對照日常,不作推導來源。【正文:句7344351372】\n\n## 歷史累積 與 默契(對應論文第四節第七小節)\n\n來源:論文第四節第七小節【正文:句3639576684】\n\n- 附註:前提十 是經驗前件,作推導的輸入。【正文:句2347905363】\n- 步驟四之七之一:默契 的判準是 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.歷史 與行為模式,不是預言(從 默契 的定義 推出)【正文:句2347905363】\n- 結論四之七之二:默契 不要求任何一方事先算準對方的下一步(從 默契 的定義 + 結論二之十三 推出)【正文:句2347905363】\n- 步驟四之七之三:互動次數多,不等於已有 默契(從 默契 的定義 推出)【正文:句2347905363】\n- 步驟四之七之四:敵對者在指定的可比情境中若反覆呈現相容接續,可符合 默契;不因此推出友善、信任、共同利益或真正理解(從 默契 的定義 + 結論二之十五 推出)【正文:句2347905363】\n- 步驟四之七之五之一:對不同對象的 專屬歷史,各需要各自的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達(從 步驟四之四之一 + 專屬歷史 的定義 推出)【正文:句2347905363】\n- 結論四之七之五:設 專屬歷史 需要在可比較的情境下反覆 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達(b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.經驗禁止),一個 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.我 在講明的時窗內新增 默契 的對象,數量不能無限增加(從 前提十 + 步驟四之七之五之一 + 步驟四之四之一 + 專屬歷史 的定義 + 默契 的定義 + 結論二之十四 + b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.經驗禁止 推出)【正文:句2347905363】\n- 附註:上限多大推不出:b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.份量 不能相加,使用時須寫明 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.頻率 與 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.歧異度 的假定。【正文:句2347905363】\n- 步驟四之七之六:缺少足夠反覆的 專屬歷史,就不會有 默契(從 默契 的定義 + b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.經驗禁止 推出)【正文:句2347905363】\n- 步驟四之七之七:長期共處不保證有 默契(從 步驟四之七之三 推出)【正文:句2347905363】\n- 結論四之七之八:默契 一旦形成,不保證延續(從 結論二之十三 + 默契 的定義 推出)【正文:句2347905363】\n- 步驟四之七之九:專屬歷史 不推出兩個 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.我 持有相同的內容(從 專屬歷史 的定義 + 結論二之十二 + 結論二之十四 推出)【正文:句2347905363】\n- 附註:結論四之七之五 為條件級,用到前提十;步驟四之七之六 只寫必要條件,可被新案例修改。【正文:句2347905363】\n- 附註:本節的校準只是對照日常,不作推導來源。【正文:句2347905363】\n\n## 權重軌跡 與相容門檻(對應論文第四節第八小節)\n\n來源:論文第四節第八小節【正文:句4558198181】\n\n- 附註:前提十二 是經驗前件,作推導的輸入;它只說占比小,不給數字。【正文:句9150897332】\n- 附註:前提十三 是經驗前件,作推導的輸入;它只說是材料,不說估得準,也不說估了就照做。【正文:句9150897332】\n- 步驟四之八之一:同一筆 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 不同的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.我,b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.份量 與 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.歧異度 可以依各自的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.歷史 而不同,對各自 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.權重 的移動也可以不同(從 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.份量 的定義 + b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.歧異度 的定義 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 的定義 推出)【正文:句9150897332】\n- 步驟四之八之二:b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.趨同、b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.趨異、b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.持平 比較的是雙方 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 模式的距離;雙方的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.權重 影響之後的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出,從而影響這個距離,但不單獨決定它(從 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.趨同 的定義 + b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.趨異 的定義 + b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.持平 的定義 + 步驟四之八之一 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦 的定義 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.權重 的定義 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.黑箱律 推出)【正文:句9150897332】\n- 結論四之八之三:研究者從外部 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.不被保證 能完整讀出雙方的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.權重;形成 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.印象 的材料依 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.印象 的定義(從 結論二之十二 + b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.印象 的定義 + b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.不被保證 的定義 推出)【正文:句9150897332】\n- 結論四之八之四:「友好」與「衝突」是研究者對外顯型態貼的標籤,不是對內在狀態的描述(從 衝突 的定義 + 結論二之十五 + 結論四之八之三 推出)【正文:句9150897332】\n- 步驟四之八之十三:沒有針對對方 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 的相反方向,就不構成 衝突(從 衝突 的定義 推出)【正文:句9150897332】\n- 附註:「友好」不另立概念;衝突 的定義要求至少一方的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 已 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 對方,與結論四之六之十 一致。【正文:句9150897332】\n- 結論四之八之五:任何一對 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.我,包括有 專屬歷史 者,相容都不被保證:對方的相容區域不被保證能被完整掌握,下一個 fb0addca-42b6-4884-aa18-438c695747ab.決定 也不能事先唯一推出,所以框架不提供能保證 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.迴路 相容的程序;此處的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.不被保證,指既有約束不推出相容(從 結論二之十二 + 結論二之十三 + fb0addca-42b6-4884-aa18-438c695747ab.被迫的賭注 的定義 + 失配 的定義 + 結論三之五之八 + b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.不被保證 的定義 + b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.迴路 的定義 推出)【正文:句9150897332】\n- 步驟四之八之五之一:握有對方相容區域的材料,b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.不被保證 會配合(從 結論二之十三 + b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.不被保證 的定義 推出)【正文:句5564117401】\n- 步驟四之八之五之二:即使能估計對方的相容區域,也 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.不被保證 這一次會使用該能力;即使使用,下一筆 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 仍受整體 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.權重 影響,b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.不被保證 相容(從 結論二之十三 + b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.不被保證 的定義 推出)【正文:句6101996221】\n- 結論四之八之六:雙方彼此都握有對方相容區域的材料,仍不排除處於 衝突(從 步驟四之八之五之一 + 步驟四之八之五之二 + 結論二之十三 + 衝突 的定義 推出)【正文:句9150897332】\n- 結論四之八之七:沒有 專屬歷史,不推出不可能相容(從 結論二之十三 + 結論四之八之五 + b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.不被保證 的定義 推出)【正文:句9150897332】\n- 附註:結論四之八之七 只寫沒有被禁止;相容的可能來源(外生背景 的重疊材料、指定協調、fb0addca-42b6-4884-aa18-438c695747ab.隨機的回合)不排除,不主張。【正文:句9150897332】\n- 步驟四之八之八之一:相容區域只占雙方可能 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 組合中很小的一部分(前提十二),所以不靠材料時,雙方落入彼此重疊的那一小塊,b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.不被保證;材料是估計對方相容區域的依據(前提十三)(從 前提十二 + 前提十三 + b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.不被保證 的定義 推出)【正文:句9150897332】\n- 步驟四之八之八之二:專屬歷史 是估計對方相容區域的材料之一(前提十三);有 專屬歷史 的搭檔,這一來源已在手,可用來估計;沒有 專屬歷史 的搭檔,這一來源為零(從 前提十三 + 專屬歷史 的定義 + 結論二之十四 推出)【正文:句9150897332】\n- 結論四之八之八:在前提十二與前提十三下,同一維度、同一判準、同一時窗內,有 專屬歷史 的搭檔,估計對方相容區域時已持有一種可用材料;沒有 專屬歷史 的搭檔,這一來源為零(從 步驟四之八之八之一 + 步驟四之八之八之二 + 結論二之十四 推出)【正文:句9150897332】\n- [作者裁決] 「門檻」維持以材料量表述,指估計對方相容區域所需新增的材料量,不改為互動量;互動是產生材料的過程,材料才是推導所用的量。補入 步驟四之八之八之一、步驟四之八之八之二 兩步,結論不變,餐廳的例子只作校準。\n- 步驟四之八之九:專屬歷史 按維度計,一個維度上已持有的材料較多,不推出另一個維度也較多(從 結論二之十四 推出)【正文:句9150897332】\n- 步驟四之八之十:材料多不等於估得準(從 結論三之五之八 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.損耗律 推出)【正文:句9150897332】\n- 步驟四之八之十一:結論四之八之八 不推出有 專屬歷史 的搭檔,輸出更常相容(從 結論四之八之六 + 步驟四之八之十 + 結論四之八之八 推出)【正文:句9150897332】\n- 附註:「遠低於」是量的主張,不寫。【正文:句9150897332】\n- 附註:結論四之八之八 為條件級,用到前提十二與前提十三;其他降低門檻的途徑(共同的 外生背景、指定協調)由資料決定。【正文:句9150897332】\n- 附註:本節的校準只是對照日常,不作推導來源。【正文:句9150897332】\n\n## 兩人之間的正回饋(對應論文第四節第九小節)\n\n來源:論文第四節第九小節【正文:句6836982155】\n\n- 循環四之九之一:兩人之間,在講明的同一時窗內,若雙方的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 互相 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達、各自的後續 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 受對方 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 影響,且雙方各自仍是 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦,則該時窗內有三個迴路:甲的小迴路、乙的小迴路、甲乙之間的大迴路;這個循環中,大迴路在雙方的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 不再互相 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 時退出,小迴路在各自不再是 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦 時退出(從 結論二之十一 推出)【正文:句2219575730】\n- 循環四之九之二:兩人之間的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.正回饋,可以在三個迴路上同時發生;某個迴路退出時,該迴路上的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.正回饋 隨之退出(從 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.正回饋 的定義 + 循環四之九之一 推出)【正文:句2219575730】\n- 結論四之九之三:b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.正回饋 沒有方向偏好;沿某維度 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.趨同 並互相強化,外顯為「吸引」;沿某維度 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.趨異,且雙方 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 互相針對、方向相反並互相強化,形成動態平衡時成為 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.太極,外顯為 衝突(其中強度升高的階段稱 衝突 升級);未形成動態平衡者,只是 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.趨異 的互相強化,不稱 衝突(從 循環四之九之二 + b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.趨同 的定義 + b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.趨異 的定義 + 衝突 的定義 + b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.太極 的定義 推出)【正文:句2219575730】\n- 步驟四之九之三之一:b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.正回饋 的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 序列,若在講明的判準下,一方的某類 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 之後接另一方的同類 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出,反過來也成立,就呈現互惠的外顯型態(「互惠」是對序列貼的標籤);框架不保證會出現這種序列(從 循環四之九之二 + 結論四之九之三 + b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.不被保證 的定義 推出)【正文:句2219575730】\n- 結論四之九之四:「吸引」與「互惠」是研究者對外顯型態貼的標籤,不是對內在狀態的描述;互惠是 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.正回饋 可以呈現的一種 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 序列模式(從 結論四之九之三 + 步驟四之九之三之一 + 結論二之十五 推出)【正文:句2219575730】\n- 結論四之九之五:互惠不要求同時,不要求等值;b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.份量 不能相加,37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.權重 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.不被保證 能完整讀出,所以 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.不被保證 能靠它們算出誰多給了(從 結論二之十三 + b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.份量 的定義 + 結論二之十二 + 步驟四之九之三之一 + b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.不被保證 的定義 推出)【正文:句2219575730】\n- 步驟四之九之六:互惠序列中斷,不等於 失配,兩者判準不同(從 失配 的定義 + 步驟四之九之三之一 推出)【正文:句2219575730】\n- 結論四之九之七:b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.正回饋 不保證持續(從 結論二之十三 + b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.不被保證 的定義 + b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.迴路 的定義 + b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.正回饋 的定義 推出)【正文:句2219575730】\n- 結論四之九之八:在一段時間內,兩人之間的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.正回饋 不能靠超過每個 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.我 在這段時間內能接收的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 量來增強(從 前提十 推出)【正文:句2219575730】\n- 附註:結論四之九之八 為條件級,用到前提十;限制在哪裡由資料決定。【正文:句2219575730】\n- 結論四之九之九:若這一對的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 完全停止,大迴路停止,兩邊的小迴路不因此必然停止,已 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 的 專屬歷史 仍在,重新接觸是新的一次(從 結論二之十一 + 結論二之十四 + 步驟四之五之一 推出)【正文:句2219575730】\n- 結論四之九之十:37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 只是減少時,不能說大迴路必然消散(從 結論二之十三 + b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.不被保證 的定義 推出)【正文:句2219575730】\n- 附註:颱風的對照只幫助想像,不作推導來源。【正文:句2219575730】\n- 結論四之九之十一:大迴路弱時,小迴路可以繼續(從 結論二之十一 推出)【正文:句2219575730】\n- 結論四之九之十二:僅憑外顯序列,不保證分得出是自我回饋、第三者轉述,還是過去的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.歷史 在撐(從 結論四之八之三 + b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.不被保證 的定義 推出)【正文:句2219575730】\n- 附註:結論四之九之十二 只寫「可以維持」,不寫「就是由它維持」。【正文:句2219575730】\n- 結論四之九之十三:外顯的接觸頻率變化,推不出雙方歸屬的改變,也推不出沒有改變(從 結論四之八之三 推出)【正文:句2219575730】\n- 步驟四之九之十四:小迴路繼續,不推出歸屬維持不變(從 結論二之十三 推出)【正文:句2219575730】\n- 結論四之九之十五:37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 減少時,沒有 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 的部分不直接進入自己已 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.歷史,對對方的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.印象 與實際變化可能脫節(從 結論二之十二 + 結論二之十四 + b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.印象 的定義 推出)【正文:句2219575730】\n- 附註:重逢時對方新的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 對自己的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.歧異度 有多大,是否引發 失配,由資料決定,為條件級。【正文:句2219575730】\n- 附註:本節的校準只是對照日常,不作推導來源。【正文:句2219575730】\n\n## 默契 不傳遞(對應論文附錄一)\n\n來源:論文附錄一【正文:句9840710523】\n\n- 例:設乙、丙、己三個 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.我,在同一項任務、同一個維度上:乙與丙之間有三回合依時間排序的雙向 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出,每回合都相容接續、不需重新逐項指導;丙與己之間同樣有三回合;乙與己之間沒有任何這類 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出【正文:句9411799841】\n- 例:在這個構造的判準下,乙丙有 默契,丙己有 默契,乙己沒有(從 本例效準 + 默契 的定義 推出)【正文:句9411799841】\n- 例:因此兩段 默契 的前件不充分推出第三段(從 本例效準 推出)【正文:句9411799841】\n- 例:設乙把資料交給丙,丙再交給己,順序按規定發生,且通過這次任務的驗收;這段序列符合 指定協調 的判準,而乙己之間仍沒有 默契(從 本例效準 + 指定協調 的定義 推出)【正文:句9411799841】\n- 例:因此協調不要求全部成員兩兩有 默契(從 本例效準 推出)【正文:句9411799841】\n- 例:反向對照:為乙己加入三回合同類的相容接續後,乙己在這個判準下也有 默契,原先的差異消失(從 本例效準 + 默契 的定義 推出)【正文:句9411799841】\n- 例:設兩種情況的合格回應集合互不相交,而乙在兩種情況取得的材料與解碼條件相同;則同一個固定回應不能同時屬於兩個集合,所以不能擔保兩種情況都合格(從 本例效準 推出)【正文:句9411799841】\n- 附註:上一條不排除另有區分兩種情況的材料。【正文:句9411799841】\n\n## 可證偽條件(對應論文第六節)\n\n來源:論文第六節【正文:句5558939045】\n\n- 附註:前提二 與 前提三 只能假定,不能證實或證偽;與結論相反的觀察,只能歸於推導起點錯或推導錯,後者是勘誤,不是證偽。【正文:句6778749315、句3596074412】\n- 附註:失去來源只表示推導鏈斷開,不表示該命題為假;失去來源之後,若無其他來源,剩下的是未經本篇推導的命題,其真假須另行論證。【正文:句8956912620】\n- [作者裁決] 可證偽條件採規則式陳述:律被推翻,來源鏈含該律的約束級結論失去來源;前提一、前提四、前提二十被推翻同理;前提五至前提十三被現實違反,只有來源鏈含它的條件級結論失效。不逐條列舉結論。\n- 步驟六之一:觀察到一個 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.我 的某次 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別 沒有在它的下一個 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.時刻 之前 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 它自己,是 前提一 的否定條件;前提一 被推翻(從 前提一 推出)【正文:句0890269394】\n- 步驟六之一之一:凡來源鏈含 前提一 的約束級結論,失去由 前提一 而來的推導來源;若同一命題另有不含它的來源,不受此影響(從 步驟六之一 推出)【正文:句0890269394、句4086354418】\n- 步驟六之二:觀察到某個 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦 對某個 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.呈現 作 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別 時,該 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.呈現 的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.自己的那一段 已全部 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 這個 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦,是 前提四 的否定條件;前提四 被推翻(從 前提四 推出)【正文:句0890269394】\n- 步驟六之二之一:凡來源鏈含 前提四 的約束級結論,失去由 前提四 而來的推導來源;若同一命題另有不含它的來源,不受此影響(從 步驟六之二 推出)【正文:句0890269394、句4086354418】\n- 步驟六之三:觀察到一個 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.我 完全 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別 了自己,是 步驟一之二 的否定;37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.損耗律 被推翻(從 步驟一之二 推出)【正文:句0890269394】\n- 步驟六之三之一:凡來源鏈含 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.損耗律 的約束級結論,失去由 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.損耗律 而來的推導來源;若同一命題另有不含它的來源,不受此影響(從 步驟六之三 推出)【正文:句0890269394、句4086354418】\n- 步驟六之四:觀察到一個不被 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.鎖死 的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.我 的下一個 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.時刻 被事先唯一推出,是 步驟一之四 的否定;37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.黑箱律 被推翻(從 步驟一之四 推出)【正文:句0890269394】\n- 步驟六之四之一:凡來源鏈含 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.黑箱律 的約束級結論,失去由 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.黑箱律 而來的推導來源;若同一命題另有不含它的來源,不受此影響(從 步驟六之四 推出)【正文:句0890269394、句4086354418】\n- 步驟六之五:觀察到 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.歷史 中同一個位置被復原(內容相似的再次發生不算),是 結論二之十四 的否定;37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.不可復原律 被推翻(從 結論二之十四 推出)【正文:句0890269394】\n- 步驟六之五之一:凡來源鏈含 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.不可復原律 的約束級結論,失去由 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.不可復原律 而來的推導來源;若同一命題另有不含它的來源,不受此影響(從 步驟六之五 推出)【正文:句0890269394、句4086354418】\n- 步驟六之六:觀察到一個仍是 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦 的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.呈現,37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 它的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.歷史 與前一 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.時刻 相同,是 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.流變律 的否定;37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.流變律 被推翻(從 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.流變律 推出)【正文:句0890269394】\n- 步驟六之六之一:凡來源鏈含 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.流變律 的約束級結論,失去由 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.流變律 而來的推導來源;若同一命題另有不含它的來源,不受此影響(從 步驟六之六 推出)【正文:句0890269394、句4086354418】\n- 步驟六之七:甲在講明的階段已有 fb0addca-42b6-4884-aa18-438c695747ab.二階分別,或乙沒有 fb0addca-42b6-4884-aa18-438c695747ab.二階分別,或乙沒有 fb0addca-42b6-4884-aa18-438c695747ab.看法歸屬,是 前提五 的否定條件;前提五 被現實違反(從 前提五 推出)【正文:句5869780413】\n- 步驟六之七之一:凡來源鏈含 前提五 的條件級結論,失去由 前提五 而來的推導來源,其餘結論不受影響(從 步驟六之七 推出)【正文:句5869780413、句5034519984】\n- 步驟六之八:外生背景 在講明的時窗內隨模型中的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.迴路 更新,是 前提六 的否定條件;前提六 被現實違反(從 前提六 推出)【正文:句5869780413】\n- 步驟六之八之一:凡來源鏈含 前提六 的條件級結論,失去由 前提六 而來的推導來源,其餘結論不受影響(從 步驟六之八 推出)【正文:句5869780413、句5034519984】\n- 步驟六之九:甲沒有帶著產前接觸進入,或甲的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.歷史 在出生時歸零,是 前提七 的否定條件;前提七 被現實違反(從 前提七 推出)【正文:句5869780413】\n- 步驟六之九之一:凡來源鏈含 前提七 的條件級結論,失去由 前提七 而來的推導來源,其餘結論不受影響(從 步驟六之九 推出)【正文:句5869780413、句5034519984】\n- 步驟六之十:發育沒有改變甲能參與的維度,是 前提八 的否定條件;前提八 被現實違反(從 前提八 推出)【正文:句5869780413】\n- 步驟六之十之一:凡來源鏈含 前提八 的條件級結論,失去由 前提八 而來的推導來源,其餘結論不受影響(從 步驟六之十 推出)【正文:句5869780413、句5034519984】\n- 步驟六之十一:小規模熟人之間,有兩個參與者之間沒有 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.耦合,是 前提九 的否定條件;前提九 被現實違反(從 前提九 推出)【正文:句9434823528、句3464786965】\n- 步驟六之十一之一:凡來源鏈含 前提九 的條件級結論,失去由 前提九 而來的推導來源,其餘結論不受影響(從 步驟六之十一 推出)【正文:句5869780413、句5034519984】\n- 步驟六之十二:某個 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.我 在一段時間內能接收的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 沒有限,是 前提十 的否定條件;前提十 被現實違反(從 前提十 推出)【正文:句5869780413】\n- 步驟六之十二之一:凡來源鏈含 前提十 的條件級結論,失去由 前提十 而來的推導來源,其餘結論不受影響(從 步驟六之十二 推出)【正文:句5869780413、句5034519984】\n- 步驟六之十三:生物人的神經傳導與反應不需要時間,或對方對一筆 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 的反應與該 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 同時發生,是 前提十一 的否定條件;前提十一 被現實違反(從 前提十一 推出)【正文:句5869780413】\n- 步驟六之十三之一:凡來源鏈含 前提十一 的條件級結論,失去由 前提十一 而來的推導來源,其餘結論不受影響(從 步驟六之十三 推出)【正文:句5869780413、句5034519984】\n- 步驟六之十四:某個 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.我 在一個維度上的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.權重 維度不高,或在講明的判準下相容的區域占雙方可能 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 組合的比例不小,是 前提十二 的否定條件;前提十二 被現實違反(從 前提十二 推出)【正文:句5869780413】\n- 步驟六之十四之一:凡來源鏈含 前提十二 的條件級結論,失去由 前提十二 而來的推導來源,其餘結論不受影響(從 步驟六之十四 推出)【正文:句5869780413、句5034519984】\n- 步驟六之十五:在同一維度上,專屬歷史 不是一個 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.我 估計對方相容區域的材料,是 前提十三 的否定條件;前提十三 被現實違反(從 前提十三 推出)【正文:句5869780413】\n- 步驟六之十五之一:凡來源鏈含 前提十三 的條件級結論,失去由 前提十三 而來的推導來源,其餘結論不受影響(從 步驟六之十五 推出)【正文:句5869780413、句5034519984】\n- 步驟六之十六:觀察到某個不被 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.鎖死 的對象的驅動力能被旁人從外部完整確認,是 前提二十 的否定條件;前提二十 被推翻(從 前提二十 推出)【正文:句0890269394】\n- 步驟六之十六之一:凡來源鏈含 前提二十 的約束級結論,失去由 前提二十 而來的推導來源;若同一命題另有不含它的來源,不受此影響(從 步驟六之十六 推出)【正文:句0890269394、句4086354418】\n\n## 待決項\n\n無\n","paper_files":[{"filename":"互動動力學-共同外生背景下的二階網路.md","content":"---\nuuid: ae79e938-76e1-4bf9-b2ab-995c03e16c9e\nlast-modified: 2026-10-15T14:14:29\nauthor: 黃正宇 / Cheng Yu Huang\ncontact: mthree.tw@gmail.com\n---\n\n# 互動動力學-共同外生背景下的二階網路\n\n## 〇、定位與假定\n\n本篇研究兩種配置在[迴路](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c31)中的處境:一種是只具有[一階分別](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c24)的[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19)與一個有[二階分別](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c01)的[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19)互相[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10);另一種是幾個都有[二階分別](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c01)的[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19)互相[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)。兩種配置使用同一組約束,差別只在有沒有[二階分別](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c01)這一個參數。\n\n本篇的結論分兩級。約束級結論只由下一節列出的律與前提推出,能推翻其中任何一條,結論即失效。條件級結論另用到下文所列的假定或某項經驗前件,行文會點明用了哪一項,現實若違反它,該結論失效。經驗前件只作推導的輸入,不拿來證明約束為真。\n\n[配置假定](concepts.md#c01)是對一組具體對象所作的假定:在講明的階段,其中某些對象只具有[一階分別](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c24),其餘對象有[二階分別](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c01),也有[看法歸屬](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c02)。本篇對甲與乙作這個假定(前提五):在講明的階段,甲只具有[一階分別](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c24),乙有[二階分別](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c01),也有[看法歸屬](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c02)。它是假定,不是定理;從外部確認某個對象某一刻有沒有[二階分別](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c01),[不被保證](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c02);只有找到機制,證明該對象的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)只能由[鎖死的回合](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c25)落出,或只能由[隨機的回合](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c26)落出,才能否證。\n\n[外生背景](concepts.md#c02)是在講明的時窗與[切法](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c23)下,視為從模型外部進入、不隨模型中的[迴路](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c31)更新的背景(前提六)。它是範圍上的設定,不主張文化不變;進入模型的是背景,不是各個[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19)從中取得的內容,因為每個[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19)只拿得到[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)它自己的那一部分。時窗拉長到背景顯著改變時,這個假定必須放寬,依賴它的結論隨之失效。\n\n制度、規範與習俗,在原則上是[二階網路](concepts.md#c04)在[歷史](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13)中形成的模式,不是另一類實體。本篇的時窗短、參與者少,把它們與文化一併當作[外生背景](concepts.md#c02),只問它們經誰[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)誰,不問它們怎樣形成。這是本篇的範圍設定,不是對[二階網路](concepts.md#c04)的定義限制。\n\n本篇處理[迴路](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c31)的結構,以及可由[迴路](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c31)推出的「開始」與「來回」。信任、安全感、承諾、公平、吸引、依附這類指向內在狀態或動機的詞,本篇都當作某個[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19)或研究者的歸屬,只問它們在[迴路](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c31)中做了什麼,不裁決真假(4.6、4.9)。自我揭露、權力與依賴、文化,以及陌生人與弱連結,不在本篇範圍,留給後續的子論文。個別差異(人格、依附風格當作跨搭檔的特質)、三人以上的聯盟與排擠、生命歷程,以及雙人資料的分析方法,本篇也不展開,留給後續篇章。\n\n甲、乙,以及後文的丙、丁、己,都是示範用的合成個體,不是實測個案。\n\n```text\n附註 制度、規範與習俗在原則上是 二階網路 的模式;本篇把它們與文化一併當作 外生背景,是範圍設定,不是對 二階網路 的限制。\n附註 配置假定 不是定理;外生背景 不主張背景不變;進入模型的是背景,不是各個 我 從中取得的內容,每個 我 只拿得到 到達 它自己的那一部分。\n附註 從外部確認一個對象某一刻有沒有 二階分別,不被保證(上游結論);本篇只使用,不推導。\n附註 甲、乙,以及後文的丙、丁、己,都是示範用的合成個體,不是實測個案。\n```\n\n\n## 一、本篇使用的律與前提\n\n本篇使用[流變律](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c24):[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)所在的[歷史](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13)一直在變,在它的每個[時刻](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c09),[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)它的[歷史](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13)都和該次[坍塌](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c08)之前不同。使用[黑箱律](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c25):[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)不被[鎖死](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c12)時,它的下一個[時刻](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c09)不能事先唯一推出,能推出的是[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06)。使用[損耗律](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c26):[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19)在任何[時刻](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c09)都不能完全[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)自己。使用[不可復原律](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c28):[歷史](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13)中每個位置只發生一次,重來時不被[鎖死](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c12)的選擇未必一樣。四條律當公理使用,本篇不重新證明。\n\n本篇另有四個前提。前提一:[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19)的每一次[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18),都在它的下一個[時刻](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c09)之前[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)它自己。前提二:[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19)的任何一個[決定](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c06),內容都是一次[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18),不是所說所做之對象的完整描述。前提三:[計算](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c05)落出的結果不是[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18),[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)只在[決定](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c06)中落出。前提四:對任何[呈現](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c04),包括自己,它[自己的那一段](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c17)中總有沒有[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)這個[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)的部分。\n\n本篇沿用[三道牆](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c23)的結論:[來路牆](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c08),[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19)拿不全自己過去的[歷史](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13);[盲點牆](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c09),[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19)看不見現在的自己;[未定牆](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c10),[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19)算不出未來的必定。還沿用[被迫的賭注](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c11)與[幻覺](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c14):[幻覺](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c14)是處境,不是失誤;[二階](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c01)不使[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19)離開[幻覺](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c14),只讓它能被問起。\n\n本篇新增一條約束,稱為[驅動力不可確認](concepts.md#c03):對不被[鎖死](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c12)的對象,它的驅動力,也就是動機、需求與目的,從外部不能被完整觀測,不能被自述確認,旁人事後對動機的判斷也只是[看法歸屬](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c02)或[印象](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c45),不能算證實;動機本身不憑自身[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)旁人。它適用於一切不被[鎖死](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c12)的對象,不分年齡,也不分有無[二階分別](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c01);從外部無法確認對象是否被[鎖死](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c12),只能假定(前提三)。它的根據是:對象不被[鎖死](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c12)時的自述,若出自[決定](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c06),內容是一次[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18),不是成因的完整描述(前提二);對象看不見自己正在作的那次[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)([損耗律](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c26));旁人說的「他為了什麼」,若是把對方的一筆[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)劃作對方的看法,就是旁人的[看法歸屬](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c02),也可以是對對方[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06)的[印象](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c45),不是對方狀態的讀數;事後對動機的判斷同樣只是旁人的一次[看法歸屬](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c02)或[印象](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c45);旁人事先也不能唯一推出不被[鎖死](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c12)的對象的下一個[時刻](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c09)([黑箱律](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c25))。動機本身不是[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28),不憑自身[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)旁人。\n\n本篇的方法上禁止:不得把驅動力寫成可被觀測、被自述確認或被事後證實的事實;不得以「為了」解釋[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28),只寫在某個維度上某種[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)的[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06)較高;不得把[二階](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c01)的出現寫成由外部材料必然產生;不得從診斷推出有無[二階分別](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c01);不得把[外生背景](concepts.md#c02)寫成文化不變,不得用只有名稱、沒有判準的解釋項補洞(「文化」是常見的一例),須指出具體的[歷史](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13)輸入;不得把外顯統計、先後或一條記錄路徑,寫成真實[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06)或依賴路徑的直接讀數;不得把數字到行動那一步寫成算得出來;不得把確定感當證據;不得說反思必帶來更好的判斷;不得說[幻覺](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c14)已消除;不得把[印象](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c45)的穩定寫成對對方的逼近;說[趨同](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c37)、[趨異](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c38)或[持平](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c52)必須講明維度。\n\n研究者也在[迴路](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c31)之中。研究者的觀察、詢問、指示與記錄,若記為研究者的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)並[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)被觀察的[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19),就會進入對方的[歷史](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13),依[不可復原律](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c28)也收不回;對方的後續[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)若受它影響並又[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)研究者、參與其[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06),雙方就構成[迴路](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c31)。所以不預設研究者必站在[迴路](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c31)之外;只經由記錄、而未[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)被觀察者的觀察,才不改變它的[歷史](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13)。本段為約束級結論。\n\n```text\n附註 以下前提一至前提四,與四條律同為本篇的推導起點;本篇使用,不重新證明。\n限定條件 範圍:只具有 一階分別 的 我 與有 二階分別 的 我 互相 到達 的配置,以及幾個有 二階分別 的 我 互相 到達 的配置;熟人階段。\n限定條件 模型只在講明的時窗與 切法 下使用。\n限定條件 只使用上游的公開條目,不引用上游的論證與編號。\n前提二十 對不被 鎖死 的對象,驅動力,也就是動機、需求與目的,從外部不能被完整觀測,不能被自述確認,旁人事後對動機的判斷也只是 看法歸屬 或 印象,不能算證實。\n前提一 一個 我 的每一次 分別,都在它的下一個 時刻 之前 到達 它自己。\n前提二 一個 我 的任何一個 決定,內容都是一次 分別,不是所說所做之對象的完整描述。\n前提三 計算 落出的結果不是 分別;分別 只在 決定 中落出。\n前提四 對任何 呈現,包括自己,它 自己的那一段 中總有沒有 到達 這個 渦 的部分。\n前提五 對甲與乙作 配置假定:在講明的階段,甲只具有 一階分別,乙有 二階分別,也有 看法歸屬。\n前提六 在講明的時窗與 切法 下,背景為 外生背景:從模型外部進入,不隨模型中的 迴路 更新。\n附註 前提二、前提三只能假定,不能證實或證偽;前提五、前提六是範圍上的設定;前提二十、前提二十一、前提二十二是作者新增的約束與範圍設定,不由其他前提推出。\n附註 本篇沿用 三道牆、被迫的賭注 與 幻覺 的結論;二階分別 不使 我 離開 幻覺,只讓它能被問起。\n\n步驟一之一 一個 我 不被 鎖死 時的自述,若出自 決定,內容是一次 分別,不是成因的完整描述(從 前提二 + 前提三 + 輸出 的定義 + 決定 的定義 推出)\n步驟一之二 一個 我 看不見自己正在作的那次 分別(從 損耗律 + 盲點牆 推出)\n步驟一之三 旁人說的「他為了什麼」,若是把對方的一筆 輸出 劃作對方的看法,就是旁人的 看法歸屬;也可以是旁人對對方 權重 的 印象;兩者都不是對方狀態的讀數(從 看法歸屬 的定義 + 印象 的定義 + 前提四 推出)\n步驟一之四 旁人事先不能唯一推出不被 鎖死 的 渦 的下一個 時刻,能推出的是 權重(從 黑箱律 推出)\n附註 動機本身不是 輸出,不憑自身 到達 旁人。\n步驟一之四之二 事後對動機的判斷,同樣可以是旁人的一次 看法歸屬,或旁人對對方 權重 的 印象(從 步驟一之三 + 前提二 推出)\n步驟一之四之三 旁人看對象,對象自己的那一段總有沒有 到達 旁人的部分,所以旁人不保證能從外部完整觀測對象的驅動力(從 前提四 + 前提二十 推出)\n結論一之五 驅動力不可確認:對不被 鎖死 的對象,驅動力從外部不能被完整觀測,不能被自述確認,旁人事後對動機的判斷也只是 看法歸屬 或 印象,不能算證實(從 前提二十 + 步驟一之一 + 步驟一之二 + 步驟一之三 + 步驟一之四 + 步驟一之四之二 + 步驟一之四之三 推出)\n附註 驅動力不可確認 適用一切不被 鎖死 的對象,不分年齡,也不分有無 二階分別。\n步驟一之六 研究者的觀察、詢問、指示與記錄,若記為研究者的 輸出 並 到達 被觀察的 我,則收不回;被觀察者的後續 輸出 若受它影響並又 到達 研究者、參與其 權重,雙方構成 迴路;所以不預設研究者必在 迴路 之外(從 輸出 的定義 + 到達 的定義 + 權重 的定義 + 迴路 的定義 + 不可復原律 推出)\n```\n\n\n## 二、迴圈模型\n\n本篇的模型是一個按[時刻](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c09)推進的遞迴。每個[時刻](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c09),一個[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19)的狀態是到當時為止[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)它的[歷史](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13);[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)它的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)(來自自己,也來自別人)加進[歷史](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13),只加不減;[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06)是[歷史](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13)對下一個[時刻](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c09)的作用,具體的函數本篇不指定;不被[鎖死](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c12)時,下一個[時刻](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c09)不能事先唯一推出,可推出的是[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06);[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)再[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)自己,也可以[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)別人。本篇不討論感受,討論經驗:經驗就是已經[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)所構成的[歷史](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13)。這是本篇的範圍設定。所以這是一個有回饋、隱藏狀態、非決定性、路徑依賴、帶自我指涉的離散時間系統。本篇推導它的定性性質;轉移函數不指定,所以不推出具體軌跡。本段為約束級結論。\n\n這個遞迴由五個部件構成,後面各節是它們在不同位置的組合;每節開頭標明用了哪幾個部件,第六節有一張總表。五個部件都只由四條律與前提推出,不新增前提。另有一個變數:配置,即誰有[二階分別](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c01),見2.6,不算部件。\n\n| 部件 | 動力學性質 | 內容 | 根據 | 標籤 |\n|---|---|---|---|---|\n| 部件一 三[迴路](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c31) | 回饋結構 | 每個[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19)有自我回饋的小[迴路](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c31),兩個[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19)之間有大[迴路](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c31);[迴路](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c31)上傳的是[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) | 前提一、[迴路](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c31)的定義 | 結論二之十一 |\n| 部件二 部分到達 | 隱藏狀態 | 每個[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19)拿到的,只有[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)[自己的那一段](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c17) | 前提四 | 結論二之十二 |\n| 部件三 不可預推 | 非決定性、非定常 | 不被[鎖死](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c12)的[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19),下一個[時刻](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c09)不能事先唯一推出,[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)雙方的[歷史](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13)每個[時刻](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c09)都不同 | [黑箱律](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c25)、[流變律](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c24) | 結論二之十三 |\n| 部件四 單向累積 | 路徑依賴、不可逆 | 發生過的位置不能重來;[專屬歷史](concepts.md#c05)按維度計 | [不可復原律](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c28) | 結論二之十四 |\n| 部件五 歸屬即輸出 | 自我指涉 | 對別人的看法是歸屬,歸屬本身是一筆[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28);動機從外部不能確認 | [看法歸屬](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c02)、[驅動力不可確認](concepts.md#c03) | 結論二之十五 |\n\n```text\n步驟二之十六之一 一個 我 在每個 時刻 的狀態,由到當時為止 到達 它的 歷史,以及這些 到達 如何參與 權重 構成(從 我 的定義 + 渦 的定義 + 歷史 的定義 + 權重 的定義 推出)\n步驟二之十六之二 到達 它的 輸出 加進 歷史,只加不減(從 不可復原律 + 歷史 的定義 + 到達 的定義 推出)\n步驟二之十六之三 權重 是各分支的輕重,不是 渦 的內部參數;歷史 參與下一個 時刻 的 權重 分配,具體函數不指定(從 權重 的定義 + 渦 的定義 推出)\n步驟二之十六之四 不被 鎖死 時,下一個 時刻 不能事先唯一推出,可推出的是 權重(從 黑箱律 推出)\n步驟二之十六之五 分別 再 到達 自己(前提一);作為 輸出 的 分別,也可以 到達 別人(從 前提一 + 到達 的定義 + 輸出 的定義 推出)\n前提二十二 本篇只討論已 到達 的 輸出 所構成的 歷史,不討論感受。\n步驟二之十六之六 本篇只討論已 到達 的 輸出 所構成的 歷史,不討論感受(從 前提二十二 + 輸出 的定義 + 到達 的定義 推出)\n循環二之十六 本篇的模型是按 時刻 推進的遞迴,狀態是累積的 歷史;這個循環的退出條件包括 我 退場;本篇推導它的定性性質,不推出具體軌跡(從 步驟二之十六之一 + 步驟二之十六之二 + 步驟二之十六之三 + 步驟二之十六之四 + 步驟二之十六之五 + 步驟二之十六之六 + 退場 的定義 推出)\n附註 轉移函數不指定;本篇不討論感受,討論經驗。\n```\n\n\n### 2.1 部件一 三迴路\n\n每個[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19)有兩種輸入:自己上一刻的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28),以及別人的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)。依前提一,[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)會回到自己,所以每個[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19)各有一個自我回饋的小[迴路](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c31);[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)也[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)別人,別人的後續[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)受它影響並又[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)自己時,兩個[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19)之間又有一個大[迴路](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c31),兩者嵌套。只要它們仍是[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16),每個[時刻](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c09)的[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)仍[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)自己(前提一),小[迴路](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c31)的材料仍在;[迴路](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c31)能否持續,仍[不被保證](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c02)。小[迴路](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c31)的退出條件是不再是[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16),大[迴路](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c31)的退出條件是雙方的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)不再互相[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)。\n\n[迴路](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c31)上傳的是[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)。依[驅動力不可確認](concepts.md#c03),驅動力留在各[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19)的[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06)裡,依[黑箱律](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c25)不進推導。所以被排除的寫法有兩種:把互動寫成單向影響;把驅動力當成[迴路](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c31)上傳遞的東西。\n\n```text\n循環二之一 每個 我 有自我回饋的小 迴路;這個循環的退出條件是不再是 渦;只要仍是 渦,每次 分別 都 到達 自己(前提一)(從 前提一 + 渦 的定義 + 迴路 的定義 推出)\n循環二之二 一個 我 的 輸出 到達 別人,別人的後續 輸出 受它影響並又 到達 該 我 時,兩個 我 之間另有一個大 迴路,與兩邊的小 迴路 嵌套;這個循環的退出條件是雙方的 輸出 不再互相 到達(從 輸出 的定義 + 到達 的定義 + 渦 的定義 + 權重 的定義 + 迴路 的定義 推出)\n循環二之三 只要它們仍是 渦,每個 時刻 的 分別 仍 到達 自己,小 迴路 的材料仍在;迴路 能否持續仍 不被保證;小 迴路 的退出條件是不再是 渦,大 迴路 的退出條件是雙方的 輸出 不再互相 到達(從 循環二之一 + 循環二之二 + 前提一 + 流變律 + 渦 的定義 + 迴路 的定義 推出)\n前提二十一 本篇的推導不使用驅動力。\n步驟二之四 迴路 上傳的是 輸出,驅動力不進推導(從 前提二十一 + 迴路 的定義 推出)\n結論二之十一 每個 我 有自我回饋的小 迴路;兩個 我 的 輸出 互相 到達,且各自的後續 輸出 受對方 輸出 影響時,兩者之間有大 迴路;迴路 上傳的是 輸出(從 循環二之一 + 循環二之二 + 步驟二之四 推出)\n```\n\n\n### 2.2 部件二 部分到達\n\n依前提四,對任何[呈現](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c04),包括自己,它[自己的那一段](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c17)中總有沒有[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)這個[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)的部分。這是第二個部件,後面各節反覆用到它:一個[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19)不能從外部完全讀出另一個[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19)的[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06);轉述是一筆新的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28),不是原來那筆的複本;兩個[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19)對同一段共同經歷各有自己的記錄,可以不一致;只取兩個節點的分析,是一種[切法](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c23)。本段為約束級結論。\n\n只取兩個節點來分析,是一種[切法](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c23),結論只對這個[切法](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c23)成立,不是這段關係本身的性質:依前提四,兩個節點各自總有沒有[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)對方的部分;依[黑箱律](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c25),別處[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)它們的[歷史](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13),也會改變它們的[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06)。本段為約束級結論。\n\n```text\n結論二之十二 每個 我 拿到的,只有 到達 自己的那一段(從 前提四 + 分別 的定義 + 到達 的定義 推出)\n步驟二之十之三 只取兩個節點的分析是一種 切法,結論只對這個 切法 成立,不是這段關係本身的性質(從 切法 的定義 + 前提四 + 黑箱律 推出)\n```\n\n\n### 2.3 部件三 不可預推\n\n依[黑箱律](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c25),不被[鎖死](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c12)的[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19),下一個[時刻](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c09)不能事先唯一推出;依[流變律](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c24),[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)它的[歷史](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13)每個[時刻](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c09)都不同。這是第三個部件:凡是「保證」類的結論,本篇都不推出。本段為約束級結論。\n\n一個[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19)具有[二階分別](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c01),是對它的某個階段所作的[配置假定](concepts.md#c01),不是對它每一次[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)的保證。依[黑箱律](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c25),不被[鎖死](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c12)的[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19),下一個[時刻](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c09)不能事先唯一推出;所以有能力不推出這一次使用;使用[二階分別](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c01)也是一次[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18),仍受[損耗律](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c26)約束。能力隨年齡與相處如何變化,屬生物性,由經驗決定,邏輯不能決定,本篇不推導。本段為約束級結論。\n\n兩端的[回合](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c04)不必對齊。依[流變律](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c24),[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)一個[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)的[歷史](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13)每個[時刻](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c09)都不同;一筆[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)對方時,對方的[歷史](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13)與它落出時不必相同。所以本篇不假定兩端同步,也不引入共同的時鐘,文中的先後標號只是排序。這是約束級結論。對生物人還有物理限制:神經的傳導與反應需要時間(前提十一),對方對一筆[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)的反應,不可能與該[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)同時發生。這一層為條件級結論,用到前提十一。\n\n因為[歷史](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13)不斷累積,同一筆[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)在不同[時刻](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c09)對同一個[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19)的[份量](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c47)與[歧異度](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c49)可以不同,所以系統不保證是定常的:同樣的輸入,不保證同樣的作用。本段為約束級結論。\n\n```text\n結論二之十三 不被 鎖死 的 我,下一個 時刻 不能事先唯一推出,到達 它的 歷史 每個 時刻 都不同(從 黑箱律 + 流變律 推出)\n結論二之十七 同一筆 輸出 在不同 時刻 對同一個 我 的 份量 與 歧異度 可以不同,所以系統不保證是定常的(從 份量 的定義 + 歧異度 的定義 + 結論二之十三 推出)\n步驟二之七 不被 鎖死 的 我 的下一個 時刻 不能事先唯一推出,所以有 二階分別 不推出這一次使用(從 黑箱律 + 配置假定 的定義 推出)\n步驟二之八 使用 二階分別 也是一次 分別,仍受 損耗律 約束(從 二階分別 的定義 + 損耗律 推出)\n附註 能力隨年齡與相處如何變化,屬生物性,由經驗決定;邏輯不能決定,本篇不推導。\n步驟二之十之一 不能假定兩端的 時刻 對齊;一筆 輸出 到達 時,對方的 歷史 與它落出時不必相同(從 流變律 + 到達 的定義 推出)\n前提十一 生物人的神經傳導與反應需要時間,對方對一筆 輸出 的反應不可能與該 輸出 同時發生。\n附註 前提十一 是經驗前件,作推導的輸入;它是物理限制,不是對一般的 我 的主張。\n結論二之十之二 對生物人,對方對一筆 輸出 的反應,不與該 輸出 同時發生(從 前提十一 推出)\n附註 結論二之十之二 為條件級,用到前提十一。\n```\n\n\n### 2.4 部件四 單向累積\n\n依[不可復原律](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c28),[歷史](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13)中每個位置只發生一次,已經發生的收不回。這是第四個部件,它最常用在[專屬歷史](concepts.md#c05)上,後者按維度計。本段為約束級結論。\n\n[專屬歷史](concepts.md#c05)按維度計。同一個[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19)可以與乙在某個維度上已有[專屬歷史](concepts.md#c05),與丙在同一維度上沒有,與乙在另一個維度上也沒有;任何一處為零,不取消其他處已有的[歷史](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13)([不可復原律](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c28))。同一個[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19)因此可以同時與不同的對象處在不同的處境,不必依次經過某些階段。\n\n研究者可以把累積的[歷史](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13)看作變得慢的一層,把一輪一輪的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)與回饋看作變得快的一層,前者稱慢變量,後者稱快變量。這是研究者在觀察上的一次[切法](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c23),不是在說明[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06)為什麼變:[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06)不可讀([黑箱律](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c25)),研究者只看得到有的東西變得快、有的變得慢。[印象](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c45)、熟悉與[默契](concepts.md#c06)是累積[歷史](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13)的函數,吸引、[衝突](concepts.md#c10)與耗散是快的一層在慢的一層背景上走出來的樣子(見4.7至4.9)。累積只加不減,不等於品質單調變好。本段為約束級結論。\n\n```text\n結論二之十 專屬歷史 按維度計;一處為零,不取消其他處已有的 歷史(從 專屬歷史 的定義 + 不可復原律 推出)\n結論二之十四 歷史 中每個位置只發生一次,已發生的收不回;專屬歷史 按維度計(從 不可復原律 + 結論二之十 推出)\n步驟二之十八之一 研究者可以把累積的 歷史 看作慢的一層,把 輸出 與回饋看作快的一層,這是一次 切法,不說明 權重 為什麼變(從 黑箱律 + 切法 的定義 推出)\n結論二之十八 在這個 切法 下,累積的 歷史 是慢變量,輸出 與回饋是快變量;累積只加不減,不推出品質單調變好(從 步驟二之十八之一 + 結論二之十四 + 印象 的定義 + 默契 的定義 推出)\n```\n\n\n### 2.5 部件五 歸屬即輸出\n\n依[看法歸屬](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c02)的定義,有[二階分別](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c01)的[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19)對另一個[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19)的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)所作的[看法歸屬](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c02),是它自己的一次[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)。依[驅動力不可確認](concepts.md#c03),動機從外部不能確認。所以凡指向內在狀態或動機的詞,都是某個[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19)或研究者的歸屬;歸屬說出口或做出來,是一筆[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28);[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)別人的部分進入對方的[歷史](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13),並參與對方後續的[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06)。這是第五個部件,4.6把它用到欺騙、強迫、信任等詞。本段為約束級結論。\n\n```text\n結論二之十五 指向內在狀態或動機的詞,可以是某個 我 或研究者的 分別、看法歸屬 或對 權重 的 印象;說出口時是一筆 輸出,到達 別人的部分進入其 歷史,並參與其後續的 權重(從 看法歸屬 的定義 + 印象 的定義 + 輸出 的定義 + 結論一之五 + 渦 的定義 推出)\n```\n\n\n### 2.6 配置變數與六種操作\n\n兩種配置的差別只有一處:有[二階分別](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c01)的[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19),多一個環節,能把自己的某次[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)當成看法再作[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18);只具有[一階分別](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c24)的[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19)沒有這個環節。以上都是約束級結論。\n\n本篇在這個[迴路](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c31)上作六種操作,各自問律與前提允許什麼、禁止什麼:增加節點、移除節點、[失配](concepts.md#c08)、歸屬錯位、歷史累積、歷史回流(見3.5)。第三節處理只有兩個節點的情形,其中[失配](concepts.md#c08)與[修復](concepts.md#c09)見3.4;第四節處理多個節點。這些操作長出的模式,是本篇的結論。每一種操作用到哪些部件,見第六節的矩陣;歷史回流已併入3.5。\n\n```text\n結論二之五 有 二階分別 的 我,多一個把自己的某次 分別 當成看法再作 分別 的環節(從 二階分別 的定義 推出)\n步驟二之六 只具有 一階分別 的 我 沒有這個環節(從 一階分別 的定義 推出)\n附註 六種操作只是操作的名稱,不是新增的前提,推導不以它們為來源。\n```\n\n\n## 三、主題一:甲在與乙的迴圈中建立自我\n\n### 3.1 起點\n\n本節用部件二、部件四(結論二之十二、結論二之十四)。\n\n依[不可復原律](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c28),[歷史](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13)中每個位置只發生一次;甲帶著產前接觸進入(前提七),所以甲的[歷史](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13)並不在出生時歸零,新的關係也不等於一切重來。甲與乙在這個維度上尚無[專屬歷史](concepts.md#c05)。[專屬歷史](concepts.md#c05)是兩個[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19)之間,在一個講明的維度上,彼此互相[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)所構成的那一段[歷史](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13),只屬於這兩者;尚無[專屬歷史](concepts.md#c05),只限定這段關係。經驗上,甲帶著產前接觸進入,乙帶著自己已[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)乙的[歷史](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13)進入,其中若有[外生背景](concepts.md#c02)經乙[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)的部分,那部分才在乙的[歷史](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13)裡;從未[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)乙的部分,不在乙已[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)乙的[歷史](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13)裡(前提四)。本節為條件級結論,用到的經驗前件是出生與產前接觸(前提七)。\n\n```text\n前提七 甲帶著產前接觸進入,甲的 歷史 在出生時不歸零。\n附註 前提七 是經驗前件,作推導的輸入,不拿來證明約束為真。\n限定條件 起點:甲與乙在講明的維度上尚無 專屬歷史。\n結論三之一之一 甲的 歷史 在出生時不歸零,新的關係不等於一切重來(從 結論二之十四 + 前提七 推出)\n步驟三之一之二 乙帶著自己已 到達 乙 的 歷史 進入,其中若有 外生背景 經乙 到達 的部分,那部分才在乙的 歷史 中;從未 到達 乙 的部分不在乙已 到達 乙 的 歷史 中(從 結論二之十二 + 前提六 推出)\n附註 本節為條件級結論,用到前提七。\n```\n\n\n### 3.2 甲的輸出與乙的候選歸屬\n\n本節用部件五(結論二之十五)。\n\n依[驅動力不可確認](concepts.md#c03),不能把甲「為了被抱」而哭寫成已確認的事實。本例把甲的哭記為一筆[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28);乙面對的是一組[候選](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c18):餓、累、濕、痛、要抱。乙把哭歸成其中之一,可以是乙的一次[看法歸屬](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c02)(若乙把甲的哭認作甲的一次看法),也可以是乙對甲[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06)的[印象](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c45);兩者都不是甲狀態的讀數,也不保證有外部可得的判準判定它對或錯。乙為什麼挑這幾個[候選](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c18),來自乙自己的[歷史](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13),本篇不再往上追。本節為約束級結論。\n\n這個限制不限於嬰兒。一個人說「我一切為了家人」,旁人拿到的是一筆[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28),動機是旁人的解釋;本人的自述依前提二也只是又一次[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18),不是成因的完整描述。這是校準,不作推導來源。\n\n```text\n步驟三之二之一 若本例把甲的哭記為一筆 輸出,則它是一筆 輸出(從 輸出 的定義 推出)\n步驟三之二之二 不能把甲「為了被抱」而哭寫成已確認的事實(從 結論二之十五 + 結論一之五 推出)\n結論三之二之三 乙把哭歸成 候選 之一時,可以是乙的一次 看法歸屬(若乙把甲的哭認作甲的一次看法),也可以是乙對甲 權重 的 印象;兩者都不是甲狀態的讀數,也不保證有外部可得的判準判定它對或錯(從 前提五 + 看法歸屬 的定義 + 印象 的定義 + 候選 的定義 + 結論一之五 推出)\n附註 乙為什麼挑這幾個 候選,來自乙自己的 歷史,本篇不再往上追。\n附註 「我一切為了家人」的例子是校準,不作推導來源。\n```\n\n\n### 3.3 試錯與校準\n\n本節用部件二、部件五(結論二之十二、結論二之十五)。\n\n乙每次嘗試,餵、換、抱,只要不被[鎖死](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c12),都是一次[被迫的賭注](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c11):結果算不準,事後收不回,不處理也是一種結果。甲後續的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)是乙拿到的新[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10),乙據此調整後續的嘗試。若本例把停哭記為甲的一筆[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28),它只是甲的一筆[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28),不單獨構成對歸屬的檢驗:甲為什麼哭、為什麼停,都不保證能從外部確認([驅動力不可確認](concepts.md#c03)),歸屬的對錯不保證有外部可得的判準。乙的[印象](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c45)可以穩定,穩定不等於更接近真實的甲。乙可以把自己的[看法歸屬](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c02)當成看法再修正,這是[迴路](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c31)裡不對稱的環節,甲沒有。本節為約束級結論;涉及乙修正歸屬的部分用到[配置假定](concepts.md#c01),屬條件級。\n\n```text\n步驟三之三之一 乙不被 鎖死 時的每次嘗試是一次 被迫的賭注(從 渦 的定義 + 決定 的定義 + 被迫的賭注 的定義 推出)\n步驟三之三之二 甲後續的 輸出 若 到達 乙,就是乙拿到的新 到達,乙後續嘗試的 權重 受這些 到達 影響(從 結論三之二之三 + 到達 的定義 + 渦 的定義 推出)\n步驟三之三之二之二 若本例把停哭記為甲的一筆 輸出,則它是甲的一筆 輸出(從 輸出 的定義 推出)\n結論三之三之三 若本例把停哭記為甲的一筆 輸出,則它只是甲的一筆 輸出,不單獨構成對歸屬的檢驗:甲為什麼哭、為什麼停都不保證能從外部確認,歸屬的對錯不保證有外部可得的判準(從 步驟三之三之二之二 + 結論三之二之三 + 結論二之十五 推出)\n步驟三之三之四 乙的 印象 穩定不等於更接近真實的甲(從 結論三之二之三 + 結論二之十二 推出)\n結論三之三之五 乙可以把自己的歸屬當成看法再修正,甲沒有這個環節(從 前提五 + 結論二之五 + 步驟二之六 推出)\n附註 結論三之三之五 為條件級,用到前提五。\n```\n\n\n### 3.4 失配與修復\n\n本節用部件三、部件四、部件五(結論二之十三、結論二之十四、結論二之十五)。\n\n[失配](concepts.md#c08)是在研究者指定的維度與相容判準下,兩個[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19)相鄰的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)序列不相容;[修復](concepts.md#c09)是[失配](concepts.md#c08)之後,在同一維度與同一判準下,後續序列重新相容。判準看的是序列相容與否,不是任何一方「想要而沒得到」或「期待被違反」,那些帶有驅動力,依[驅動力不可確認](concepts.md#c03)不寫。\n\n[失配](concepts.md#c08)在這個[迴路](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c31)中不是偶發的故障,而是結構上不被排除的可能。乙每次對甲的哭作[看法歸屬](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c02)再行動,都是一次[被迫的賭注](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c11),歸屬[不被保證](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c02);乙所作的行動與甲接下來的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28),若在指定判準下不相容(例如餵了之後哭仍持續),這段序列就是[失配](concepts.md#c08)。本段為約束級結論。\n\n[修復](concepts.md#c09)只表示序列重新相容,不表示歸屬得到了檢驗,也不表示甲「得到了想要的」。序列重新相容,可以來自乙換了另一個[候選](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c18),來自甲的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)自己改變,來自[外生背景](concepts.md#c02)改變,也可以來自[隨機的回合](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c26),從[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)不一定看得出差別。所以[修復](concepts.md#c09)只是記錄,不是檢驗,與3.3「停哭不單獨構成對歸屬的檢驗」是同一個結構。本段為約束級結論。\n\n[失配](concepts.md#c08)之後不保證[修復](concepts.md#c09)。依[黑箱律](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c25),不被[鎖死](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c12)的[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19),下一個[時刻](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c09)不能事先唯一推出,所以後續序列可以重新相容,也可以持續不相容,或轉為拒絕、警告與反制這類[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)(見4.6)。已落出的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)依[不可復原律](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c28)收不回,它們留在已[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)的各方的[歷史](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13)裡,影響後續的[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06)。反過來,沒有[修復](concepts.md#c09),也不推出此後永遠不會[修復](concepts.md#c09):[黑箱律](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c25)同樣不允許這個斷言。本段為約束級結論。\n\n依[配置假定](concepts.md#c01),乙可以把[失配](concepts.md#c08)當成線索,回頭把自己的歸屬當成看法再修正;甲沒有這個環節。所以[失配](concepts.md#c08)之後若序列重新相容,要追溯改變,先從乙端的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)找起,因為只有乙端有這個環節;這是尋找的次序,不是已經確定原因在乙端。本段為條件級結論,用到[配置假定](concepts.md#c01)。\n\n沒有[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)不等於沒有影響。乙不回應,也是乙這一刻落出的結果,被甲察覺時就[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)甲([被迫的賭注](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c11):不動也是結果)。所以不得把「沒有回應」寫成「沒有發生什麼」。本段為約束級結論。\n\n[失配](concepts.md#c08)之後的序列走向哪裡,[不被保證](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c02),可能是[修復](concepts.md#c09),也可能是原諒、[衝突](concepts.md#c10)、持續溝通等;「原諒」若是某個[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19)對序列所作的歸屬,說出口是一筆[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28),不是序列的相容。所以原諒不推出[修復](concepts.md#c09),序列相容也不推出有人原諒:[修復](concepts.md#c09)只看序列,原諒是歸屬,兩者可以各自發生。原諒是否為真,依[驅動力不可確認](concepts.md#c03)從外部不能確認,感受本篇不討論。本段為約束級結論。\n\n第五節的5.1用面無表情範式作校準:該範式讓乙在一段時間內刻意不回應,之後恢復,人為造成互動序列的改變,可能形成[失配](concepts.md#c08)與其後的序列,再用外顯記錄比較。\n\n```text\n附註 失配 與 修復 的判準由研究者指定,看序列相容與否,不看驅動力。\n結論三之四之一 失配 是這個 迴路 結構上不被排除的可能(從 步驟三之三之一 + 失配 的定義 + 被迫的賭注 的定義 推出)\n結論三之四之二 修復 只表示序列重新相容,不表示歸屬得到了檢驗(從 修復 的定義 + 結論三之三之三 推出)\n步驟三之四之三 序列重新相容可以來自乙換 候選、甲的 輸出 改變、外生背景 改變或 隨機的回合,從 輸出 不一定看得出差別(從 結論二之十三 + 前提六 + 隨機的回合 的定義 + 候選 的定義 推出)\n步驟三之四之四 若序列重新相容,乙端的 輸出 是可以追溯改變的一處,因為乙能回頭修正自己的歸屬,甲沒有這個環節(從 結論三之三之五 + 前提五 推出)\n步驟三之四之五 不回應也是一個結果,被對方察覺時會 到達 對方,所以不得把沒有回應寫成沒有影響(從 被迫的賭注 的定義 + 到達 的定義 推出)\n步驟三之四之六 已落出的 輸出 收不回,留在已 到達 的各方的 歷史 裡,影響後續的 權重(從 結論二之十四 + 權重 的定義 + 渦 的定義 推出)\n結論三之四之七 失配 之後不保證 修復,也不推出此後永遠不會 修復(從 結論二之十三 + 失配 的定義 + 修復 的定義 + 步驟三之四之六 推出)\n結論三之四之八 失配 之後的序列,後續走向 不被保證,可能是 修復、原諒、衝突、持續溝通等;原諒 若是對序列所作的歸屬,則不推出 修復,修復 也不推出原諒(從 失配 的定義 + 修復 的定義 + 看法歸屬 的定義 + 結論二之十五 + 被迫的賭注 的定義 推出)\n附註 步驟三之四之四 是尋找的次序,不是已確定原因在乙端;它為條件級,用到前提五。\n```\n\n\n### 3.5 我的建構與材料的來源\n\n本節用部件一、部件三(結論二之十一、結論二之十三)。\n\n[我的建構](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c28)是[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19)用[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)劃出自己的過程,所以「我」是劃出來的,不是找到的。甲建構自己的材料有兩個來源,在有無[二階分別](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c01)時都存在。一是甲自己的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28):依前提一,甲的每一次[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)都在下一個[時刻](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c09)之前[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)甲自己(第二節的自我回饋)。二是乙的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)甲:其中有乙對甲的歸屬,也有[外生背景](concepts.md#c02)經乙[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)甲的部分,帶著乙的誤差與乙的框架。[二階分別](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c01)的出現不增加材料來源,只多了一個把自己的某次[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)當成看法再處理的環節。被排除的寫法有:甲發現了自己;自我本來就在;乙說的「你餓了」是甲內在狀態的讀數;甲在有[二階分別](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c01)之前沒有自己的材料。依[盲點牆](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c09),正在劃的這一次看不見,所以甲看到的永遠只是已經建好的自己。兩個來源都存在,是約束級結論;乙的歸屬與框架若經由[外生背景](concepts.md#c02)進入甲的內容,則帶著乙可能的誤差,用到[配置假定](concepts.md#c01)與[外生背景](concepts.md#c02),是條件級結論。\n\n一個[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19)的材料可以有三處:對外物的[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18);對他人[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)的[看法歸屬](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c02)與[印象](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c45);以及對自己某次[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)的再[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18),後者只有具[二階分別](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c01)者有。已有的各處材料都依前提一回到那個[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19)自己,進入下一個[時刻](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c09)的[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06)。互動次數增加,增加材料,但不保證這三處同時改善,不保證[印象](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c45)逼近對方,也不使對方的真實[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06)可讀。有能力不等於這一次使用(第二節)。本段為約束級結論。\n\n成人的自我概念也有兩個來源,與3.5同:自己的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)回到自己,與他人的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)(含他人對自己的歸屬)[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)自己。成人有[二階分別](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c01),若把他人對自己的歸屬當成看法再[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18),這仍是自己的一次[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18),不必直接採用;但有這個能力,不推出這一次使用,也不推出看到的是自己的全部([損耗律](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c26)、[盲點牆](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c09))。本段為約束級結論。\n\n孩子看見照顧者拿起外套後走向門口,之後也走向門口,可以作一個短的校準:過去出門的經歷是[歷史](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13)中的材料,走向門口是[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)。至於孩子是興奮還是不安,依[驅動力不可確認](concepts.md#c03)不寫;下一次是否同樣,也[不被保證](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c02)([黑箱律](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c25))。這是校準,不是推導來源。\n\n```text\n步驟三之五之一 甲自己的 輸出 回到甲,可以成為甲建構自己的材料(從 結論二之十一 + 我的建構 的定義 推出)\n步驟三之五之二 乙的 輸出 到達 甲,可以成為甲建構自己的另一份材料(從 到達 的定義 + 我的建構 的定義 推出)\n結論三之五之三 兩個來源在有無 二階分別 時都存在;二階分別 只多一個處理環節(從 步驟三之五之一 + 步驟三之五之二 + 結論二之五 推出)\n步驟三之五之四 乙的歸屬與框架若經由 外生背景 進入甲的內容,則帶著乙可能的誤差(從 前提五 + 前提六 + 結論三之二之三 推出)\n步驟三之五之五 甲看到的永遠只是已經建好的自己(從 盲點牆 推出)\n附註 步驟三之五之四 為條件級,用到前提五與前提六。\n步驟三之五之六 一個 我 的材料可以有三處:對外物的 分別;對他人 輸出 的 看法歸屬 與 印象;對自己某次 分別 的再作 分別,第三處只有具 二階分別 者有(從 結論二之十一 + 結論二之五 + 看法歸屬 的定義 + 印象 的定義 + 分別 的定義 + 我的建構 的定義 推出)\n步驟三之五之七 已有的各處材料,都回到那個 我 自己,進入下一個 時刻 的 權重(從 結論二之十一 + 前提一 + 看法歸屬 的定義 推出)\n結論三之五之八 互動次數增加,增加材料,但不保證三處同時改善,不保證 印象 逼近對方,也不使對方的真實 權重 可讀(從 步驟三之三之四 + 步驟三之五之六 + 步驟三之五之七 + 結論二之十三 + 結論二之十二 + 步驟二之十六之二 推出)\n結論三之五之九 具 二階分別 的 我(如成人)的自我概念有兩個來源,若它把他人對自己的歸屬當成看法再 分別,這仍是它自己的一次 分別;有這個能力,不推出這一次使用,也不推出看到自己的全部(從 結論三之五之三 + 結論二之五 + 損耗律 + 盲點牆 的定義 + 二階分別 的定義 + 看法歸屬 的定義 推出)\n附註 孩子看見大人拿外套的例子是校準,不作推導來源。\n```\n\n\n### 3.6 二階出現的邊界\n\n本節不直接用部件,只用[配置假定](concepts.md#c01)與定義。\n\n本篇不解釋[二階分別](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c01)從哪裡來,也不宣稱某個時刻必定出現,更不從照顧的品質推出它。只寫條件句:若甲的[迴路](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c31)出現把自己的[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)當成看法的環節,且甲能對別人的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)作[看法歸屬](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c02),則兩邊的[迴路](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c31)在能力配置上對稱;[三問](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c07)對甲敞開;甲仍在[幻覺](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c14)裡;甲才可能進入主題二的結構。出現本身是經驗描述,推不出。本節為約束級的條件結論。\n\n```text\n附註 二階分別 的出現是經驗描述,本篇不解釋,也不主張必定出現。\n結論三之六之一 蘊含(甲出現 二階分別 且有 看法歸屬, 兩邊的 迴路 在能力配置上對稱)(從 結論二之五 + 二階網路 的定義 + 看法歸屬 的定義 + 前提五 + 結論二之十一 推出)\n結論三之六之二 蘊含(甲出現 二階分別 且有 看法歸屬, 三問 對甲敞開)(從 三問 的定義 + 二階分別 的定義 推出)\n結論三之六之三 蘊含(甲出現 二階分別 且有 看法歸屬, 甲仍在 幻覺 之中)(從 幻覺 的定義 + 步驟二之八 + 步驟三之五之五 推出)\n```\n\n\n### 3.7 對照\n\n本節不直接用部件,只用[配置假定](concepts.md#c01)與定義。\n\n[二階分別](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c01)的狀況不確定的成年人,只作參考對照。病情差異極大,從外部既不能確認某一刻有[二階分別](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c01),也不能證明沒有,所以不從診斷推出,也不貼永久標籤,一律只作[配置假定](concepts.md#c01)的對照。\n\n## 四、主題二:有二階分別的我之間的耦合與默契\n\n### 4.1 對稱迴圈、二階網路與含嬰兒的邊\n\n本節用部件二(結論二之十二)。\n\n甲在假定階段之後若出現[二階分別](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c01)且有[看法歸屬](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c02),兩邊的[迴路](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c31)就變成對稱結構:每個[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19)都有自己的小[迴路](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c31),都能把自己的某次[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)當成看法再作[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18),也都能對別人的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)作[看法歸屬](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c02)。參與者可以是兩個,也可以是三個、四個、五個。本節為約束級結論。\n\n[二階網路](concepts.md#c04)是由具有[二階分別](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c01)與[看法歸屬](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c02)的[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19),以及它們之間的[耦合](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c36)所構成的集合:一個[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19)對另一個[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19)的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)作[看法歸屬](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c02),而不只把它當成一筆[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)來反應;每個參與者在參與的那一刻,既有[二階分別](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c01),也有[看法歸屬](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c02),兩者缺一不可。這兩個動作不同:[二階分別](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c01)的對象是自己的[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18),[看法歸屬](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c02)的對象是別人的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28),有一個不保證有另一個。參與者至少兩個,但不必同時在場:寫下內容的一方,在寫下的那一刻是參與者,之後[退場](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c43)不影響這一點。網路在[歷史](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13)中形成的規律,包括規範與制度,是它的模式,不是另一類實體。\n\n因此,一個人獨自待在房子裡,讀著別人留下的文字、回想某人說過的話,只要他把那些內容劃為對方的看法,又能把自己對它的理解也當成看法,而留下文字的人在寫作當刻也具[二階分別](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c01)與[看法歸屬](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c02),他在這一刻就在[二階網路](concepts.md#c04)之中。本篇不為不在場的對方另畫節點;對方的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)已經[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)這個人,進入他的[歷史](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13),由他自己的[歷史](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13)與[外生背景](concepts.md#c02)涵蓋。\n\n結構對稱,不推出[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)或[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06)對稱。兩個都有[二階分別](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c01)的[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19),各自只拿到[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)[自己的那一段](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c17)(前提四),拿到的內容、時刻與誤差都可以不同。本段為約束級結論。\n\n規範、制度等[二階網路](concepts.md#c04)的模式,不是原因。它們是[歷史](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13)累積出的規律,只能經由具體的[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10),對某個[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19)的[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06)起作用;說某個模式「促成」了某筆[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28),須指出是哪一筆[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)。本段為約束級結論。\n\n一個[二階網路](concepts.md#c04)裡若同時有只具有[一階分別](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c24)的甲與有[二階分別](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c01)的成員,每一條邊要分別判斷:甲所在的邊是[耦合](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c36),但甲那一端沒有[二階分別](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c01),所以這條邊不屬於[二階網路](concepts.md#c04);只有兩端各自在參與的那一刻都有[二階分別](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c01)與[看法歸屬](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c02)的邊,才屬於。判斷以參與的那一刻為準,不貼永久標籤。從外部確認某個[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19)某一刻是否具備這兩者,依[配置假定](concepts.md#c01),[不被保證](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c02),只能假定。\n\n```text\n步驟四之一之一 甲若出現 二階分別 且有 看法歸屬,每個 我 都有自己的小 迴路,都能把自己的某次 分別 當成看法再作 分別,也都能對別人的 輸出 作 看法歸屬(從 結論二之五 + 結論二之十一 + 二階網路 的定義 + 看法歸屬 的定義 + 前提五 推出)\n結論四之一之二 一個人獨自讀別人留下的文字,把內容劃為對方的看法,又能把自己對內容的理解也當成看法,而留下文字的人在寫作當刻也具 二階分別 與 看法歸屬,在這一刻就在 二階網路 之中(從 二階網路 的定義 + 看法歸屬 的定義 + 二階分別 的定義 + 退場 的定義 推出)\n步驟四之一之三 結構對稱不推出 到達 或 權重 對稱(從 結論二之十二 + 到達 的定義 推出)\n步驟四之一之四 二階網路 的模式對某個 我 的 權重 起作用,只經由具體的 到達(從 結論二之十二 + 權重 的定義 + 二階網路 的定義 + 渦 的定義 推出)\n附註 規範與制度等 二階網路 的模式對某個 我 的作用,本篇只追蹤經由具體的 到達 與 權重 的部分,不另立為獨立原因。\n附註 本篇不為不在場的對方另畫節點;對方的 輸出 已 到達 這個人,進入他的 歷史。\n附註 二階網路 在 歷史 中形成的規律,包括規範與制度,是它的模式,不是另一類實體。\n結論四之一之五 在小規模熟人的設定下,甲所在的邊是 耦合,但甲那一端沒有 二階分別,所以這條邊不屬於 二階網路(從 前提五 + 前提九 + 耦合 的定義 + 二階網路 的定義 推出)\n步驟四之一之六 只有兩端各自在參與的那一刻都有 二階分別 與 看法歸屬 的邊,才屬於 二階網路(從 二階網路 的定義 推出)\n步驟四之一之七 從外部確認某個 我 某一刻是否具備這兩者,不被保證;本篇對這兩者作 配置假定(從 配置假定 的定義 + 不被保證 的定義 + 前提五 推出)\n附註 步驟四之一之七 為條件級,用到前提五。\n```\n\n\n### 4.2 多個我交錯\n\n本節用部件一、部件二、部件三(結論二之十一、結論二之十二、結論二之十三)。\n\n每個[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19)同時是別人[迴路](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c31)的一部分:乙的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)可以同時[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)丙與丁,乙對丙的歸屬和對丁的歸屬,各自回到乙自己。節點之間不必每一對都有[專屬歷史](concepts.md#c05);哪幾對有,由資料決定,結構只說允許。本節為約束級結論,但哪幾對實際有,屬條件級。\n\n人數增加,不保證每個[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19)拿到的[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)占全部[歷史](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13)的比例上升。依前提四,每個[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19)[自己的那一段](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c17)總有沒有[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)別人的部分,所以[迴路](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c31)越多,不等於越透明。被排除的寫法有:節點越多所以必然越複雜;熟悉使對方透明。\n\n[二階網路](concepts.md#c04)不保證因人多而成為一個掌握全部成員[歷史](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13)的主體。依[黑箱律](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c25),只要其中的[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19)不被[鎖死](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c12),該[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19)的下一步不能事先唯一推出;依前提四,沒有任何位置能拿到所有成員[自己的那一段](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c17)。所以對整個網路作預測的人,對網路中每個[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19)同樣只取得部分[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10),受同樣的限制;這不推出網路的聚合量也不可預測。本段為約束級結論。\n\n```text\n步驟四之二之一 乙的 輸出 可以同時 到達 丙與丁,乙對丙的歸屬和對丁的歸屬各自回到乙自己(從 結論二之十一 + 前提一 + 到達 的定義 + 看法歸屬 的定義 推出)\n附註 節點之間不必每一對都有 專屬歷史;哪幾對有,由資料決定,屬條件級。\n步驟四之二之二 人數增加,不保證每個 我 拿到的 到達 占全部 歷史 的比例上升(從 結論二之十二 推出)\n步驟四之二之三 迴路 越多,不等於越透明(從 步驟四之二之二 + 結論二之十一 推出)\n結論四之二之四 二階網路 不保證因人多而成為掌握全部成員 歷史 的主體(從 結論二之十三 + 結論二之十二 推出)\n步驟四之二之五 對整個網路作預測的人,對網路中每個 我 同樣只取得部分 到達,不能因人多而掌握全部成員的 歷史;這不推出網路的聚合量不可預測(從 結論四之二之四 + 結論二之十二 推出)\n步驟四之二之六 只要其中有一個 我 不被 鎖死,該 我 的下一個 時刻 不能事先唯一推出(從 結論二之十三 推出)\n```\n\n\n### 4.3 歸屬的協商\n\n本節用部件五(結論二之十五)。\n\n依[驅動力不可確認](concepts.md#c03),家人之間的歸屬同樣只是歸屬。有[二階分別](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c01)帶來的新動作是:[看法歸屬](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c02)可以被拿出來協商。甲對乙說「你誤會我了」,本例把這句話記為甲的一筆[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28),[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)乙以後,乙對它作[看法歸屬](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c02),仍然只是乙的一次[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)(前提二)。所以協商不保證修正成功,也不保證任何一方能確認對方的驅動力。[二階分別](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c01)的作用不是看穿動機,而是讓歸屬能被當成看法拿出來。本節為約束級結論。\n\n```text\n步驟四之三之一 歸屬可以被拿出來協商(從 二階分別 的定義 + 二階網路 的定義 + 結論二之五 + 輸出 的定義 推出)\n步驟四之三之二 本例把甲說「你誤會我了」記為甲的一筆 輸出;到達 乙之後,乙對它作的 看法歸屬 仍是乙的一次 分別(從 前提二 + 到達 的定義 + 看法歸屬 的定義 + 輸出 的定義 推出)\n結論四之三之三 協商不保證修正成功,也不保證任何一方能確認對方的驅動力(從 步驟四之三之二 + 結論二之十五 + 結論一之五 推出)\n```\n\n\n### 4.4 增加節點:第三者與新成員\n\n本節用部件二、部件三、部件四、部件五(結論二之十二、結論二之十三、結論二之十四、結論二之十五)。\n\n在只有乙與丙的[迴路](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c31)上加入丁,每個[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19)仍各有自己的小[迴路](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c31)。兩個參與者之間最多有一條邊,所以邊數不超過節點數乘以節點數減一再除以二。認識三個人,不代表這三個人彼此認識,所以實際有幾條邊,由資料決定。在小規模熟人彼此都認識的設定下(前提九),每兩個參與者之間都有邊,邊數比節點數增加得快。哪幾條邊上實際有[專屬歷史](concepts.md#c05),同樣由資料決定。邊數的上界是約束級結論,每兩個都有邊用到前提九,邊上有無[專屬歷史](concepts.md#c05)屬條件級。\n\n乙的同一次[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)丙與[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)丁,是兩次不同的[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10):丙與丁各自帶著自己的[歷史](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13),各自作[看法歸屬](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c02),彼此可以不一致,乙對丙的歸屬與對丁的歸屬也各自回到乙自己。乙與丙之間的某些[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28),可以從未[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)丁,丁因此[不被保證](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c02)能取得乙丙之間完整的[專屬歷史](concepts.md#c05)。這就是一般所說「被排除在外」在模型中能寫的:某些[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)沒有[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)。為什麼沒有,依[驅動力不可確認](concepts.md#c03),不能寫成有人刻意為之。本段為約束級結論。\n\n丙若把乙的話轉給丁,且這個轉述記為丙的一筆[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28),則它是丙的一筆新[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28),不是乙原來那筆[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)的複本;若丙把乙那句話認作乙的一次看法,這筆[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)帶著丙的[看法歸屬](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c02)。依前提二與前提四,轉述不可能把乙的那一段完整傳過去。所以居中傳話的人改變的是丁拿到的材料,不是讓丁和乙直接[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)。某個網路裡有沒有居中的人,屬條件級。\n\n新成員甲進入乙與丙已有[專屬歷史](concepts.md#c05)的[二階網路](concepts.md#c04)時,甲與乙、甲與丙在此前沒有雙向[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)的維度上都是零起點(3.1);乙丙既有的[專屬歷史](concepts.md#c05)不因此歸零,也不因此成為甲的([不可復原律](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c28))。甲加入之後,乙丙之間的後續[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)可以[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)甲,乙丙的[迴路](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c31)與[歷史](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13)都不是甲加入之前的靜止延長([流變律](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c24))。本段為約束級結論。\n\n發育改變甲能參與的維度,例如動作、聲音、語言。可參與的維度增加,不等於這些維度上的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)已發生,也不等於[專屬歷史](concepts.md#c05)已有。本段為條件級結論,用到的經驗前件是發育改變參與條件(前提八)。\n\n```text\n前提八 發育改變甲能參與的維度。\n附註 前提八 是經驗前件,作推導的輸入。\n前提九 在小規模熟人的設定下,每兩個參與者彼此認識,也就是每兩個參與者之間都有一條 耦合。\n附註 前提九 是範圍上的設定,不是對一般情形的主張;認識三個人,不代表這三個人彼此認識。\n步驟四之四之〇 邊是有 耦合 的一對參與者;節點兩兩成對,共有 節點數 × (節點數 - 1) ÷ 2 對,所以邊數不超過這個數(從 耦合 的定義 推出)\n步驟四之四之〇之一 在前提九 的設定下,每一對都有 耦合,邊數 = 節點數 × (節點數 - 1) ÷ 2,增加得比節點數快(從 前提九 + 步驟四之四之〇 推出)\n步驟四之四之一 乙的同一次 輸出 到達 丙與到達 丁,是兩次不同的 到達(從 到達 的定義 + 前提四 推出)\n步驟四之四之二 乙與丙之間的某些 輸出 可以從未 到達 丁,丁因此 不被保證 能取得乙丙之間完整的 專屬歷史(從 結論二之十二 + 專屬歷史 的定義 + 結論二之十四 + 不被保證 的定義 推出)\n結論四之四之三 「被排除在外」在模型中能寫的是某些 輸出 沒有 到達,為什麼沒有不能寫成有人刻意為之(從 步驟四之四之二 + 結論二之十五 推出)\n步驟四之四之四 丙若把乙的話轉給丁,且這個轉述記為丙的一筆 輸出,則它是丙的一筆新 輸出,不是乙原來那筆 輸出 的複本;若丙把乙那句話認作乙的一次看法,這筆 輸出 帶著丙的 看法歸屬(從 前提二 + 結論二之十二 + 輸出 的定義 + 看法歸屬 的定義 推出)\n步驟四之四之四之一 丙把乙的話轉給丁,若該轉述記為丙的一筆新 輸出,則不構成乙對丁的直接 到達;丁拿到的是丙的新 輸出(從 步驟四之四之四 + 到達 的定義 推出)\n結論四之四之五 轉述不可能把乙的那一段完整傳過去(從 步驟四之四之四 + 結論二之十二 + 前提四 推出)\n步驟四之四之六 新成員甲與既有成員,在講明的維度上若此前沒有雙向 到達,則都是零起點(從 專屬歷史 的定義 + 結論二之十四 推出)\n結論四之四之七 乙丙既有的 專屬歷史 不因此歸零,也不因此成為甲的(從 結論二之十四 + 專屬歷史 的定義 推出)\n步驟四之四之八 甲加入之後,乙丙之間的後續 輸出 可以 到達 甲,乙丙的 迴路 與 歷史 不是甲加入之前的靜止延長(從 結論二之十三 + 到達 的定義 推出)\n步驟四之四之九 可參與的維度增加,不等於這些維度上的 輸出 已發生,也不等於 專屬歷史 已有(從 前提八 + 專屬歷史 的定義 + 結論二之十四 推出)\n附註 步驟四之四之九 為條件級,用到前提八;有沒有居中傳話的人,由資料決定。\n```\n\n\n### 4.5 移除節點:退場、個人終止與模式接續\n\n本節用部件二、部件四(結論二之十二、結論二之十四)。\n\n一個[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19)[退場](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c43)以後,它已經[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)別人的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)仍留在別人的[歷史](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13)裡;它沒有[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)別人的部分,不因[退場](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c43)而[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10);是否仍可[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10),[不被保證](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c02)(前提四、[不可復原律](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c28))。個人終止時,若他之後的位置在下一個[時刻](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c09)不再是[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16),就是一次[退場](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c43);已經發生並[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)別人的部分仍在。本段為約束級結論。\n\n後來的人即使做出與他相同的動作,也是在新的位置上發生的新的一次([不可復原律](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c28)),不是他那一段的[復原](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c27)。若相同做法在後來者身上反覆出現,可以研究它在某個維度上是否[趨同](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c37)或[持平](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c52),但必須講明維度。要主張「同一個模式接續」,須列出可追溯的參與者、[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)、記錄或規則;只憑名稱相同,或看起來相似,不夠。本段為約束級結論;哪些模式實際接續,屬條件級。\n\n[二階網路](concepts.md#c04)由參與者及其[耦合](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c36)構成。參與者有更替時,這個定義沒有給出判準,說更替前後是否仍是同一個網路。所以成員更替既不推出網路消失,也不推出網路延續;要主張其中一種,須先列出判準與可追溯的材料。本篇不給這個判準。\n\n```text\n步驟四之五之一 一個 我 退場 之後,它已經 到達 別人的 輸出 仍留在別人的 歷史 裡(從 退場 的定義 + 結論二之十四 推出)\n步驟四之五之二 它沒有 到達 別人的部分,不因退場而到達;是否仍可到達,不被保證(從 結論二之十二 + 結論二之十四 + 不被保證 的定義 推出)\n結論四之五之三 個人終止時,若他之後的位置在下一個 時刻 不再是 渦,就是一次 退場;已經發生並 到達 別人的部分仍在(從 步驟四之五之一 + 步驟四之五之二 + 退場 的定義 推出)\n步驟四之五之四 後來的人做出相同的動作,是新的位置上發生的新的一次,不是他那一段的復原(從 結論二之十四 推出)\n附註 要主張同一個模式接續,須列出可追溯的參與者、輸出、記錄或規則;同名或相似不夠。哪些模式實際接續,由資料決定。\n結論四之五之五 成員更替既不推出網路消失,也不推出網路延續(從 二階網路 的定義 推出)\n附註 二階網路 的定義沒有給出參與者更替前後是否仍是同一個網路的判準。\n```\n\n\n### 4.6 歸屬錯位:衝突、反制與歸屬的標籤\n\n本節用部件三、部件五(結論二之十三、結論二之十五)。\n\n兩個[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19)對同一筆[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)的歸屬可以不一致,這在4.2與4.3已有。錯位之後,序列可能走向協商(4.3),可能走向[失配](concepts.md#c08)後的[修復](concepts.md#c09)(3.4),也可能走向[衝突](concepts.md#c10)(定義見4.8)。對不上不等於[衝突](concepts.md#c10):[失配](concepts.md#c08)是一方的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)沒有接上,可以只有一邊,不需要方向相反;[衝突](concepts.md#c10)要雙方的方向相反,而且各自針對對方的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28),互相加強(4.8)。拒絕、警告與反制,都是[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28),與其他[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)一起進入同一段[歷史](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13);[衝突](concepts.md#c10)是雙方這類[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)互相針對所形成的結構,不是另一筆[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)。可記錄的是說法、動作與後續接續;不能由此補出任何一方的完整內心目的([驅動力不可確認](concepts.md#c03)),也不能因為是[衝突](concepts.md#c10),就推出沒有[默契](concepts.md#c06)(見4.7)。本段為約束級結論。\n\n[衝突](concepts.md#c10)起於[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)之後。拒絕、警告與反制,都是針對已經[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)所作的後續[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28);若兩個[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19)之間,雙方的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)都從未[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)對方,也沒有經由別人轉述而[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10),就沒有可以互相針對的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28),也就沒有[衝突](concepts.md#c10)。所以對從未見過、也從未聽說過的陌生人,[衝突](concepts.md#c10)是不可能的;對只聽過轉述的人,[衝突](concepts.md#c10)可以發生,起點是轉述的那筆[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10),不是對方本人。[衝突](concepts.md#c10)是[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)之後的序列上的模式,不是單方帶來的性質。本段為約束級結論,只寫必要條件,不寫[衝突](concepts.md#c10)如何產生。\n\n序列可以被某個[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19)歸屬為「欺騙」或「強迫」。若把序列劃為對方的看法,這兩個詞就是[看法歸屬](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c02)的內容,與3.2的「他哭是因為餓」同一種結構:說的人拿到的是對方的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)與後續記錄,「他知道事實而故意誤導」「他別無選擇」是說的人自己的[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)。這不是說現實沒有欺騙與強迫,而是這兩個詞若指不被[鎖死](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c12)的對方的內部狀態與驅動力,依[驅動力不可確認](concepts.md#c03),從外部不能確認;依公開行為、程序或外部約束判定者不在此限。這個歸屬若說出口,本身是一筆[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28),[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)別人的部分進入對方的[歷史](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13),參與對方後續的[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06),所以在[迴路](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c31)中有作用;但它對不對,模型不裁決。被騙的感覺、被迫的感覺屬於內部狀態,本篇不討論。本段為約束級結論。\n\n研究者使用這兩個詞時,是研究者這個[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19)對序列作的[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18),可以是[看法歸屬](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c02),也可以是對對方[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06)的[印象](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c45),不是從資料讀出來的,行文須標明是誰作的歸屬。研究者能寫的外顯描述有兩種:某筆[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)與後續記錄不符;一方輸出指令之後,另一方執行。這兩種描述不保證分得出欺騙與誤報,也不保證分得出強迫與自願:不符可能出自記錯、理解錯或被別人誤導([損耗律](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c26)、[幻覺](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c14)),執行可能是不被[鎖死](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c12)時的一次選擇([黑箱律](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c25))。本段為約束級結論。\n\n同一個辦法適用於一切指向對方內在狀態或動機的詞。「信任」是某個[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19)從對方的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)推出對方的[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06)對自己大致如何的[印象](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c45);「安全感」「焦慮」是某個[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19)對[失配](concepts.md#c08)之後的序列,以及對自己後續[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)型態所作的歸屬,感受本身不討論;「承諾」是一個[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19)對自己與對方未來的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)所作的歸屬,並且說出口,說出口是一筆[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28),不是保證;「公平」是對[份量](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c47)與序列所作的歸屬,[份量](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c47)不能相加,沒有外部可得的帳本;「情緒的傳染與共調節」是研究者對雙方[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)型態[趨同](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c37)所作的歸屬,感受本身不討論;「社會支持」是對一方[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)所作的歸屬,它的作用只能從後續序列看。這些詞所指是否為真,依[驅動力不可確認](concepts.md#c03),從外部不能確認,模型不裁決;模型只問它們進入[迴路](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c31)之後做了什麼:[看法歸屬](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c02)若說出口,本身是一筆[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28),[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)別人的部分進入對方的[歷史](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13),參與對方後續的[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06)。依這個歸屬去行動,是一次[被迫的賭注](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c11),行動之後的結果不是對歸屬的檢驗。研究者使用這些詞時,同樣是一次[看法歸屬](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c02),須標明是誰作的。本段為約束級結論。\n\n對方這一段是不是[決定](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c06),從外部只能假定;能推翻這個假定的,是找到機制,證明對方這一段只能由[鎖死的回合](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c25)或[隨機的回合](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c26)落出。這時對方這一段的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)不是[決定](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c06),這條邊在這一刻不能算作由對方的[二階分別](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c01)所作的[決定](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c06)(4.1);不由此推出對方不具[二階分別](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c01),其他時刻是否屬於[二階網路](concepts.md#c04),也不由此推出。只看到順從,不構成這個證明。本段為約束級結論。\n\n校準:日常裡說「我信任他」,旁人看得到的是他怎麼託付、怎麼做;他是不是真的信任,旁人是猜的。模型的說法與此相符。這只是對照日常,不是推導來源。\n\n```text\n步驟四之六之一 拒絕、警告與反制,若記為 輸出 且 到達 對方,則進入同一段 歷史;衝突 是雙方這類 輸出 方向相反、到達 對方、互相針對並互相強化所形成的結構,不是另一筆 輸出(從 輸出 的定義 + 歷史 的定義 + 衝突 的定義 推出)\n步驟四之六之二 不能由此補出任何一方的完整內心目的(從 結論二之十五 推出)\n步驟四之六之十二 失配 是一方的 輸出 沒有接上,可以只有一邊,不需要方向相反;衝突 要雙方的方向相反且各自針對對方的 輸出,兩者不同(從 失配 的定義 + 衝突 的定義 推出)\n結論四之六之十 沒有任何 到達(含經由別人轉述的 到達),兩個 我 之間就沒有衝突(從 衝突 的定義 + 到達 的定義 推出)\n附註 結論四之六之十 只寫必要條件,不寫衝突如何產生;它用到「拒絕、警告與反制是針對已 到達 的 輸出 所作的後續 輸出」,這是這幾個詞的意思。\n步驟四之六之三 某個 我 可以把序列說成「欺騙」或「強迫」;這是該 我 的一次 分別,也可以是對對方 權重 的 印象,若把它劃為對方的看法,則是 看法歸屬 的內容(從 看法歸屬 的定義 + 印象 的定義 推出)\n步驟四之六之四 若這兩個詞指不被 鎖死 的 我 的內部狀態與驅動力,則從外部不能確認;依公開行為、程序或外部約束判定者不在此限(從 結論一之五 + 結論二之十五 推出)\n步驟四之六之五 這個歸屬若說出口,本身是一筆 輸出,到達 別人的部分進入其 歷史,並參與其後續的 權重(從 輸出 的定義 + 到達 的定義 + 權重 的定義 + 渦 的定義 推出)\n步驟四之六之六 研究者使用這兩個詞時,可以是研究者的 看法歸屬,也可以是研究者對對方 權重 的 印象(從 看法歸屬 的定義 + 印象 的定義 推出)\n結論四之六之七 僅憑外顯描述,不保證分得出欺騙與誤報,也不保證分得出強迫與自願;公開約束或現場證據等其他材料能否區分,不被保證(從 損耗律 + 幻覺 的定義 + 結論二之十三 + 不被保證 的定義 推出)\n步驟四之六之八 對方這一段是不是 決定,只能假定,不被保證 能從外部確認;能推翻這個假定的,是找到機制,證明對方這一段只能由 鎖死的回合 或 隨機的回合 落出(從 前提三 + 決定 的定義 + 計算 的定義 + 鎖死的回合 的定義 + 隨機的回合 的定義 + 前提二 + 結論一之五 + 不被保證 的定義 推出)\n結論四之六之十一 指向對方內在狀態或動機的詞(信任、安全感、焦慮、承諾、公平、情緒的傳染與共調節、社會支持),可以是某個 我 或研究者的 分別、看法歸屬 或對 權重 的 印象;這些詞若指公開的言語、程序或可見的援助,則不在此列;說出口時是一筆 輸出,到達 別人的部分進入其 歷史,並參與其後續的 權重;其真假模型不裁決,依其行動不被 鎖死 時是一次 被迫的賭注(從 看法歸屬 的定義 + 印象 的定義 + 份量 的定義 + 結論二之十五 + 被迫的賭注 的定義 + 步驟四之六之五 推出)\n結論四之六之九 這時對方這一段的 輸出 不是 決定,這條邊在這一刻不能算作由對方的 二階分別 所作的決定;不由此推出對方不具 二階分別,其他時刻是否屬於 二階網路,也不由此推出(從 步驟四之六之八 + 步驟四之一之六 + 前提三 + 二階分別 的定義 推出)\n附註 本節的校準只是對照日常,不作推導來源。\n```\n\n\n### 4.7 歷史累積:默契\n\n本節用部件二、部件三、部件四、部件五(結論二之十二、結論二之十三、結論二之十四、結論二之十五)。\n\n[默契](concepts.md#c06)是在指定的情境類型與維度中,兩個[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19)經歷反覆的[專屬歷史](concepts.md#c05),在可比較的情境下,呈現不必每次重新逐項指導、仍能相容接續的行為模式。判準是[歷史](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13)與行為模式,不是預言:它不要求任何一方事先算準對方的下一步([黑箱律](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c25)),不要求友善,不要求彼此透明,也不要求[印象](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c45)穩定。互動次數多,不等於已有[默契](concepts.md#c06);次數增加可比較的材料。本段為約束級的定義與排除,某兩人在某維度上有無[默契](concepts.md#c06),屬條件級。\n\n[默契](concepts.md#c06)也不按道德立場分類。敵對者在指定的可比情境中,若反覆呈現警告—退讓、試探—防衛這類相容接續,且不必重做完整指導,便可在該範圍符合[默契](concepts.md#c06);不因此推出友善、信任、共同利益或真正理解。反覆敵對若不滿足判準,也不能僅按相處年限登記[默契](concepts.md#c06)。要比較誰與誰更有[默契](concepts.md#c06),須在相同維度、時窗與驗收資料下比,不能推出敵人一般更有或更沒有[默契](concepts.md#c06)。本段為約束級結論。\n\n一個[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19)在講明的時窗內新增[默契](concepts.md#c06)的對象有上限。設它在這段時窗內能接收的[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)有限,而[專屬歷史](concepts.md#c05)需要在可比較的情境下反覆[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10),而且對不同對象的[專屬歷史](concepts.md#c05),各需要各自的[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)(同一次[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)不同對象,是不同的[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)),則對象數量不能無限增加。上限多大推不出:[份量](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c47)不能相加,同一筆[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)落在不同的[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19)身上效果不同,所以使用時須寫明[頻率](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c48)與[歧異度](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c49)的假定。接觸的人越多,每一對得到的反覆[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)越少,[印象](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c45)越難穩定,這是經驗描述。缺少足夠反覆的[專屬歷史](concepts.md#c05),就不會有[默契](concepts.md#c06),這是[經驗禁止](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c51),只寫必要條件,可被新案例修改;反過來,長期共處不保證有[默契](concepts.md#c06)。本段為條件級結論,用到的經驗前件是每個[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19)在一段時間內能接收的[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)有限(前提十)。\n\n[默契](concepts.md#c06)一旦形成,不保證延續。依[流變律](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c24)與[黑箱律](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c25),過去的相容接續不使下一次接續被[鎖死](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c12),接續與否要看新的[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)。本段為約束級結論。\n\n[專屬歷史](concepts.md#c05)不推出兩個[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19)持有相同的內容。每個[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19)只拿到[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)[自己的那一段](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c17)(前提四),所以同一段共同經歷,在兩邊留下的是不同的材料。本段為約束級結論。\n\n校準:合作久了的兩個人,不用交代就接得上;換一個沒合作過的人,同樣的事得重新講。這只是對照日常,不是推導來源。\n\n```text\n前提十 每個 我 在一段時間內能接收的 到達 有限。\n附註 前提十 是經驗前件,作推導的輸入。\n步驟四之七之一 默契 的判準是 歷史 與行為模式,不是預言(從 默契 的定義 推出)\n結論四之七之二 默契 不要求任何一方事先算準對方的下一步(從 默契 的定義 + 結論二之十三 推出)\n步驟四之七之三 互動次數多,不等於已有 默契(從 默契 的定義 推出)\n步驟四之七之四 敵對者在指定的可比情境中若反覆呈現相容接續,可符合 默契;不因此推出友善、信任、共同利益或真正理解(從 默契 的定義 + 結論二之十五 推出)\n步驟四之七之五之一 對不同對象的 專屬歷史,各需要各自的 到達(從 步驟四之四之一 + 專屬歷史 的定義 推出)\n結論四之七之五 設 專屬歷史 需要在可比較的情境下反覆 到達(經驗禁止),一個 我 在講明的時窗內新增 默契 的對象,數量不能無限增加(從 前提十 + 步驟四之七之五之一 + 步驟四之四之一 + 專屬歷史 的定義 + 默契 的定義 + 結論二之十四 + 經驗禁止 推出)\n附註 上限多大推不出:份量 不能相加,使用時須寫明 頻率 與 歧異度 的假定。\n步驟四之七之六 缺少足夠反覆的 專屬歷史,就不會有 默契(從 默契 的定義 + 經驗禁止 推出)\n步驟四之七之七 長期共處不保證有 默契(從 步驟四之七之三 推出)\n結論四之七之八 默契 一旦形成,不保證延續(從 結論二之十三 + 默契 的定義 推出)\n步驟四之七之九 專屬歷史 不推出兩個 我 持有相同的內容(從 專屬歷史 的定義 + 結論二之十二 + 結論二之十四 推出)\n附註 結論四之七之五 為條件級,用到前提十;步驟四之七之六 只寫必要條件,可被新案例修改。\n附註 本節的校準只是對照日常,不作推導來源。\n```\n\n\n### 4.8 權重軌跡、友好與衝突、相容門檻\n\n本節用部件二、部件三、部件四、部件五(結論二之十二、結論二之十三、結論二之十四、結論二之十五)。\n\n本節不是對[迴路](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c31)作第七種操作,而是讀兩個[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19)的[迴路](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c31)走向。兩個有[二階分別](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c01)的[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19)各有自己的[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06)。同一筆[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)不同的[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19),[份量](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c47)與[歧異度](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c49)可以依各自的[歷史](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13)而不同,對各自[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06)的移動也可以不同。[耦合](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c36)之下的[趨同](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c37)、[趨異](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c38)、[持平](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c52),是沿研究者講明的維度,雙方[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)型態之間的距離變短、變長或不變;雙方的[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06)影響之後的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28),從而影響這個距離,但不單獨決定它,也不由任何單邊決定。研究者從外部拿到的是[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)型態與距離的變化,拿不到雙方的[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06):每個[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19)[自己的那一段](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c17)總有沒有[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)對方的部分(前提四);互動次數增加也不改變這一點(3.5)。本段為約束級結論。\n\n「友好」與「[衝突](concepts.md#c10)」是研究者對外顯型態貼的標籤。[衝突](concepts.md#c10)是在講明的維度與時窗內,兩個[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19)之間形成的[太極](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c39):雙方的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)都針對對方在該維度上的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28),方向相反,而且每一方的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)對方,都強化對方自己的方向,所以一方越強硬,另一方也越強硬。至少一方的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)已[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)對方(含經由轉述),才可能形成。各做各的相反方向、沒有針對對方的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28),不是[衝突](concepts.md#c10)。「友好」在本篇只指同一維度、判準與時窗內,距離[趨同](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c37)或[持平](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c52)且序列相容的外顯型態,不另立概念。兩個詞都是對序列的描述,不是對任何一方內在狀態或驅動力的描述([驅動力不可確認](concepts.md#c03))。研究者使用時須講明維度與時窗,「友好」另須講明判準;同一對[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19)可以在不同維度上同時被貼這兩種標籤,同一段序列換一個時窗,標籤也可以不同。本段為約束級結論。\n\n任何一對[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19),包括有[專屬歷史](concepts.md#c05)的熟人,相容都[不被保證](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c02)(此處的[不被保證](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c02),指既有約束不推出相容)。要使[迴路](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c31)相容,一方的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)須落在對方的[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06)下、能與對方接續的範圍內;這個範圍屬於對方[自己的那一段](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c17),不完全[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)(前提四),也不能由對方的下一個[決定](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c06)事先推出([黑箱律](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c25))。所以框架不提供能保證[迴路](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c31)相容的程序,每一次嘗試都是[被迫的賭注](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c11)。[專屬歷史](concepts.md#c05)增加材料(3.5),也可以全由[失配](concepts.md#c08)構成,所以累積得多,不推出相容。本段為約束級結論。\n\n有材料不等於會配合。一個[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19)即使握有足夠的材料,能估計對方的相容區域,也有能力不推出這一次使用(第二節);就算這一次使用了,它的下一筆[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)傾向仍由它整個[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06)給出([黑箱律](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c25)),在這個維度上與對方相容,只是其中一個維度。所以雙方彼此都握有對方相容區域的材料,仍不排除處於[衝突](concepts.md#c10)。本段為約束級結論。\n\n沒有[專屬歷史](concepts.md#c05),不推出不可能相容。依[黑箱律](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c25),不被[鎖死](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c12)的[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19)的下一個[時刻](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c09)不能事先唯一推出,所以不能由「沒有[專屬歷史](concepts.md#c05)」推出下一筆[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)一定與對方不相容。「[不被保證](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c02)」不等於「保證不」。相容的可能來源,本篇不排除:雙方從[外生背景](concepts.md#c02)各自取得的材料有重疊,[指定協調](concepts.md#c07)把判準縮到一個窄維度,或者[隨機的回合](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c26)。本段為約束級結論。這裡的「外人」只指在講明的維度上沒有[專屬歷史](concepts.md#c05)的搭檔,更一般的陌生人問題留給後續篇章。\n\n再往下說門檻高低,要用兩個經驗前件。前提十二:每個[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19)在一個維度上的[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06)維度很高,而在講明的判準下相容的區域,只占雙方可能[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)組合中很小的一部分。前提十三:在同一維度上,[專屬歷史](concepts.md#c05)是一個[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19)估計對方相容區域的材料。本節的「門檻」,指在該維度與判準下,若要靠估計而非碰巧落入相容區域,所需新增的材料量。相容區域只占很小一部分(前提十二),所以不靠材料時,雙方落入彼此重疊的那一小塊,[不被保證](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c02)。有[專屬歷史](concepts.md#c05)的搭檔,這一來源已經在手(前提十三);沒有的,這一來源為零。所以在這兩個前件下,同一維度、同一判準、同一時窗內,有[專屬歷史](concepts.md#c05)的搭檔,估計時已持有一種可用材料;沒有[專屬歷史](concepts.md#c05)的搭檔,這一來源為零,須另尋材料,例如[外生背景](concepts.md#c02)、轉述或試探。本段為條件級結論,用到前提十二與前提十三。\n\n這個比較有三條界線。第一,[專屬歷史](concepts.md#c05)按維度計,一個維度上已持有的材料較多,不推出另一個維度也較多。第二,材料多不等於估得準([印象](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c45)不保證逼近對方,3.5),更不等於會相容(上一段);所以這個比較不推出有[專屬歷史](concepts.md#c05)的搭檔,[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)更常相容。第三,「遠低於」是量的主張,依[經驗禁止](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c51)不寫;共同的[外生背景](concepts.md#c02)與[指定協調](concepts.md#c07)是否也降低門檻,降低多少,由資料決定。本篇也不推出搭檔會為此發明什麼做法,那需要驅動力([驅動力不可確認](concepts.md#c03))。本段為條件級結論,用到前提十二與前提十三。\n\n校準:第一次去一家餐廳,老闆要問你想吃什麼、有什麼推薦,你要考慮預算與份量,雙方來回壓縮各自能接受的條件,才點得出兩邊都行的一餐;天天去的常客,老闆一句「照舊?」就點完了,因為條件早已壓縮過。這對上的是「要新增的材料多少」,不是「談得攏的機會」。這只是對照日常,不是推導來源。\n\n```text\n前提十二 每個 我 在一個維度上的 權重 維度很高,而在講明的判準下相容的區域,只占雙方可能 輸出 組合中很小的一部分。\n附註 前提十二 是經驗前件,作推導的輸入;它只說占比小,不給數字。\n前提十三 在同一維度上,專屬歷史 是一個 我 估計對方相容區域的材料。\n附註 前提十三 是經驗前件,作推導的輸入;它只說是材料,不說估得準,也不說估了就照做。\n步驟四之八之一 同一筆 輸出 到達 不同的 我,份量 與 歧異度 可以依各自的 歷史 而不同,對各自 權重 的移動也可以不同(從 份量 的定義 + 歧異度 的定義 + 到達 的定義 推出)\n步驟四之八之二 趨同、趨異、持平 比較的是雙方 輸出 模式的距離;雙方的 權重 影響之後的 輸出,從而影響這個距離,但不單獨決定它(從 趨同 的定義 + 趨異 的定義 + 持平 的定義 + 步驟四之八之一 + 渦 的定義 + 權重 的定義 + 黑箱律 推出)\n結論四之八之三 研究者從外部 不被保證 能完整讀出雙方的 權重;形成 印象 的材料依 印象 的定義(從 結論二之十二 + 印象 的定義 + 不被保證 的定義 推出)\n結論四之八之四 「友好」與「衝突」是研究者對外顯型態貼的標籤,不是對內在狀態的描述(從 衝突 的定義 + 結論二之十五 + 結論四之八之三 推出)\n步驟四之八之十三 沒有針對對方 輸出 的相反方向,就不構成 衝突(從 衝突 的定義 推出)\n附註 「友好」不另立概念;衝突 的定義要求至少一方的 輸出 已 到達 對方,與結論四之六之十 一致。\n結論四之八之五 任何一對 我,包括有 專屬歷史 者,相容都不被保證:對方的相容區域不被保證能被完整掌握,下一個 決定 也不能事先唯一推出,所以框架不提供能保證 迴路 相容的程序;此處的 不被保證,指既有約束不推出相容(從 結論二之十二 + 結論二之十三 + 被迫的賭注 的定義 + 失配 的定義 + 結論三之五之八 + 不被保證 的定義 + 迴路 的定義 推出)\n步驟四之八之五之一 握有對方相容區域的材料,不被保證 會配合(從 結論二之十三 + 不被保證 的定義 推出)\n步驟四之八之五之二 即使能估計對方的相容區域,也 不被保證 這一次會使用該能力;即使使用,下一筆 輸出 仍受整體 權重 影響,不被保證 相容(從 結論二之十三 + 不被保證 的定義 推出)\n結論四之八之六 雙方彼此都握有對方相容區域的材料,仍不排除處於 衝突(從 步驟四之八之五之一 + 步驟四之八之五之二 + 結論二之十三 + 衝突 的定義 推出)\n結論四之八之七 沒有 專屬歷史,不推出不可能相容(從 結論二之十三 + 結論四之八之五 + 不被保證 的定義 推出)\n附註 結論四之八之七 只寫沒有被禁止;相容的可能來源(外生背景 的重疊材料、指定協調、隨機的回合)不排除,不主張。\n步驟四之八之八之一 相容區域只占雙方可能 輸出 組合中很小的一部分(前提十二),所以不靠材料時,雙方落入彼此重疊的那一小塊,不被保證;材料是估計對方相容區域的依據(前提十三)(從 前提十二 + 前提十三 + 不被保證 的定義 推出)\n步驟四之八之八之二 專屬歷史 是估計對方相容區域的材料之一(前提十三);有 專屬歷史 的搭檔,這一來源已在手,可用來估計;沒有 專屬歷史 的搭檔,這一來源為零(從 前提十三 + 專屬歷史 的定義 + 結論二之十四 推出)\n結論四之八之八 在前提十二與前提十三下,同一維度、同一判準、同一時窗內,有 專屬歷史 的搭檔,估計對方相容區域時已持有一種可用材料;沒有 專屬歷史 的搭檔,這一來源為零(從 步驟四之八之八之一 + 步驟四之八之八之二 + 結論二之十四 推出)\n步驟四之八之九 專屬歷史 按維度計,一個維度上已持有的材料較多,不推出另一個維度也較多(從 結論二之十四 推出)\n步驟四之八之十 材料多不等於估得準(從 結論三之五之八 + 損耗律 推出)\n步驟四之八之十一 結論四之八之八 不推出有 專屬歷史 的搭檔,輸出更常相容(從 結論四之八之六 + 步驟四之八之十 + 結論四之八之八 推出)\n附註 「遠低於」是量的主張,不寫。\n附註 結論四之八之八 為條件級,用到前提十二與前提十三;其他降低門檻的途徑(共同的 外生背景、指定協調)由資料決定。\n附註 本節的校準只是對照日常,不作推導來源。\n```\n\n\n### 4.9 兩人之間的正回饋:三個迴路、吸引、互惠、衝突升級與耗散\n\n本節用部件一、部件二、部件三、部件四、部件五(結論二之十一、結論二之十二、結論二之十三、結論二之十四、結論二之十五)。\n\n兩個有[二階分別](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c01)的[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19)之間,在講明的同一時窗內,若雙方各自仍是[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)、[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)互相[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)且後續[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)受對方[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)影響,則該時窗內有三個[迴路](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c31):甲的自我回饋小[迴路](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c31),乙的自我回饋小[迴路](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c31),以及甲乙之間的大[迴路](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c31)(第二節)。[正回饋](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c32)是[迴路](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c31)自己的一次[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)繞回來,把[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06)推向產生這次[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)的方向。兩人之間的[正回饋](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c32),可以在這三個[迴路](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c31)上同時發生:甲的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)乙的[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06),乙的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)甲的[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06),各自又被推向產生那筆[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)的方向,[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)與[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06)的關係越來越緊。這個過程沒有方向偏好:沿某個維度雙方[趨同](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c37)並互相強化,外顯是「吸引」;沿某個維度雙方[趨異](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c38),且雙方[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)互相針對、互相強化,外顯是[衝突](concepts.md#c10)([衝突](concepts.md#c10)就是兩個[趨異](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c38)的[正回饋](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c32)互相[耦合](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c36)所形成的[太極](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c39),其中強度升高的階段稱[衝突](concepts.md#c10)升級;[太極](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c39)須形成動態平衡,未形成動態平衡的趨異互相強化,不稱[衝突](concepts.md#c10))。「吸引」是研究者對前一種外顯型態貼的標籤;「互惠」是[正回饋](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c32)的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)序列可以呈現的一種型態:若在講明的判準下,一方的某類[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)之後接另一方的同類[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28),反過來也成立,這個序列就呈現互惠的外顯型態(「互惠」是對序列貼的標籤);框架不保證會出現這種序列。兩者都是研究者貼的標籤,可以是同一個過程在不同描述層的名字,不另立概念,也不是對內在狀態的描述([驅動力不可確認](concepts.md#c03))。本段為約束級結論。\n\n互惠不要求同時,因為不假定兩端的[回合](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c04)同步(第二節)。互惠也不要求等值:[份量](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c47)不能相加,[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06)[不被保證](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c02)能完整讀出,所以[不被保證](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c02)能靠它們算出誰多給了;每個[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19)只拿到[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)[自己的那一段](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c17)(前提四),雙方各有一本帳,可以不一致,這是4.6的歸屬錯位。互惠序列中斷,不等於[失配](concepts.md#c08),兩者的判準不同,使用時要分開講明。本段為約束級結論。\n\n[正回饋](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c32)不保證持續。依[流變律](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c24),[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)雙方的[歷史](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13)每個[時刻](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c09)都不同;依[黑箱律](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c25),不被[鎖死](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c12)的[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19)的下一個[時刻](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c09)不能事先唯一推出。這一輪的強化,不推出下一輪。本段為約束級結論。\n\n兩人之間的[正回饋](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c32)也不能靠[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)量的無限增加來增強。每個[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19)在一段時間內能接收的[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)有限(前提十),所以強化到某處,就會被別的[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)擠掉,或受別的條件限制;限制在哪裡,本篇不列舉,由資料決定。本段為條件級結論,用到前提十。\n\n兩人之間的[正回饋](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c32)要靠[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)持續[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)對方才轉得動。距離與固定條件(同住、同單位、共用的場合)影響[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)的[頻率](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c48),在本篇屬[外生背景](concepts.md#c02)(前提六),只經由[頻率](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c48)進入模型。若這一對的[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)完全停止,大[迴路](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c31)停止,兩邊的小[迴路](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c31)不因此必然停止(第二節),已經[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)的[專屬歷史](concepts.md#c05)仍在,重新接觸是新的一次,不是原來[正回饋](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c32)的復原([不可復原律](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c28),4.5)。若[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)只是減少,不能說大[迴路](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c31)必然消散,因為別的[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)也在進入[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06)([黑箱律](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c25))。所以寫成「缺少供應則不被維持」,不寫「必然消散」。停止與減少的結論為約束級;造成[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)減少的距離與固定條件,為條件級,用到[外生背景](concepts.md#c02)。颱風靠暖海水供應,離開供應就散,這個對照只幫助想像,不作推導來源。\n\n大[迴路](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c31)弱時,小[迴路](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c31)可以繼續。甲每一次對乙的歸屬與作出的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28),都回到甲自己的[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06)(前提一),不需要乙的回應。所以單戀(乙沒有以回應的方式回饋)和遠距離(雙方的[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)受外生條件限制),都是大[迴路](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c31)弱、小[迴路](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c31)在的情形。這時甲仍有他者回饋:乙沒有回應的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)、經由第三者轉述的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)、[外生背景](concepts.md#c02),都是[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)甲的材料。約束級只能寫「小[迴路](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c31)可以維持」,不能寫「這段持續是由小[迴路](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c31)維持的」:僅憑外顯序列,不保證分得出是自我回饋、第三者轉述,還是過去的[歷史](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13)在撐,因為[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06)不可讀(4.8)。三個[迴路](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c31)也不必對稱,結構對稱不推出[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)或[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06)對稱(4.1)。「喜歡」是歸屬,不是事實,感受本篇不討論。本段為約束級結論。\n\n外顯的接觸[頻率](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c48)變化,推不出雙方對彼此的歸屬改變,也推不出沒有改變。研究者看得到的是大[迴路](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c31)上的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28),看不到兩邊的小[迴路](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c31)。小[迴路](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c31)繼續,也不推出歸屬維持不變:依[流變律](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c24)與[黑箱律](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c25),自己的[歷史](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13)每個[時刻](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c09)都在變。[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)減少時,沒有[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)的對方的變化,不直接進入自己已[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)的[歷史](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13)(前提四、[不可復原律](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c28));自己的小[迴路](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c31)處理的是舊材料加上自己的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28),對對方的[印象](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c45)與對方的實際變化可能脫節。這幾項為約束級結論。重逢時,對方新的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)對自己的[歧異度](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c49)有多大,是否引發[失配](concepts.md#c08),由資料決定,為條件級。這裡不寫「距離不影響感情」:模型只說外顯[頻率](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c48)與內部歸屬是兩層,不能互相推。\n\n校準:兩個人越聊越投機,或越吵越兇,日常裡都有,方向相反、機制相同。對方不回應,自己仍繼續喜歡的情形,日常裡也有。遠距離的兩個人見面變少,心裡的牽掛不一定跟著少,重逢時也有人覺得對方變了。這只是對照日常,不是推導來源。\n\n```text\n循環四之九之一 兩人之間,在講明的同一時窗內,若雙方的 輸出 互相 到達、各自的後續 輸出 受對方 輸出 影響,且雙方各自仍是 渦,則該時窗內有三個迴路:甲的小迴路、乙的小迴路、甲乙之間的大迴路;這個循環中,大迴路在雙方的 輸出 不再互相 到達 時退出,小迴路在各自不再是 渦 時退出(從 結論二之十一 推出)\n循環四之九之二 兩人之間的 正回饋,可以在三個迴路上同時發生;某個迴路退出時,該迴路上的 正回饋 隨之退出(從 正回饋 的定義 + 循環四之九之一 推出)\n結論四之九之三 正回饋 沒有方向偏好;沿某維度 趨同 並互相強化,外顯為「吸引」;沿某維度 趨異,且雙方 輸出 互相針對、方向相反並互相強化,形成動態平衡時成為 太極,外顯為 衝突(其中強度升高的階段稱 衝突 升級);未形成動態平衡者,只是 趨異 的互相強化,不稱 衝突(從 循環四之九之二 + 趨同 的定義 + 趨異 的定義 + 衝突 的定義 + 太極 的定義 推出)\n步驟四之九之三之一 正回饋 的 輸出 序列,若在講明的判準下,一方的某類 輸出 之後接另一方的同類 輸出,反過來也成立,就呈現互惠的外顯型態(「互惠」是對序列貼的標籤);框架不保證會出現這種序列(從 循環四之九之二 + 結論四之九之三 + 不被保證 的定義 推出)\n結論四之九之四 「吸引」與「互惠」是研究者對外顯型態貼的標籤,不是對內在狀態的描述;互惠是 正回饋 可以呈現的一種 輸出 序列模式(從 結論四之九之三 + 步驟四之九之三之一 + 結論二之十五 推出)\n結論四之九之五 互惠不要求同時,不要求等值;份量 不能相加,權重 不被保證 能完整讀出,所以 不被保證 能靠它們算出誰多給了(從 結論二之十三 + 份量 的定義 + 結論二之十二 + 步驟四之九之三之一 + 不被保證 的定義 推出)\n步驟四之九之六 互惠序列中斷,不等於 失配,兩者判準不同(從 失配 的定義 + 步驟四之九之三之一 推出)\n結論四之九之七 正回饋 不保證持續(從 結論二之十三 + 不被保證 的定義 + 迴路 的定義 + 正回饋 的定義 推出)\n結論四之九之八 在一段時間內,兩人之間的 正回饋 不能靠超過每個 我 在這段時間內能接收的 到達 量來增強(從 前提十 推出)\n附註 結論四之九之八 為條件級,用到前提十;限制在哪裡由資料決定。\n結論四之九之九 若這一對的 到達 完全停止,大迴路停止,兩邊的小迴路不因此必然停止,已 到達 的 專屬歷史 仍在,重新接觸是新的一次(從 結論二之十一 + 結論二之十四 + 步驟四之五之一 推出)\n結論四之九之十 到達 只是減少時,不能說大迴路必然消散(從 結論二之十三 + 不被保證 的定義 推出)\n附註 颱風的對照只幫助想像,不作推導來源。\n結論四之九之十一 大迴路弱時,小迴路可以繼續(從 結論二之十一 推出)\n結論四之九之十二 僅憑外顯序列,不保證分得出是自我回饋、第三者轉述,還是過去的 歷史 在撐(從 結論四之八之三 + 不被保證 的定義 推出)\n附註 結論四之九之十二 只寫「可以維持」,不寫「就是由它維持」。\n結論四之九之十三 外顯的接觸頻率變化,推不出雙方歸屬的改變,也推不出沒有改變(從 結論四之八之三 推出)\n步驟四之九之十四 小迴路繼續,不推出歸屬維持不變(從 結論二之十三 推出)\n結論四之九之十五 到達 減少時,沒有 到達 的部分不直接進入自己已 到達 的 歷史,對對方的 印象 與實際變化可能脫節(從 結論二之十二 + 結論二之十四 + 印象 的定義 推出)\n附註 重逢時對方新的 輸出 對自己的 歧異度 有多大,是否引發 失配,由資料決定,為條件級。\n附註 本節的校準只是對照日常,不作推導來源。\n```\n\n\n## 五、案例\n\n本節整節都是校準,不作任何推導的來源。每個案例依七個步驟展開:[切法](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c23)、初始狀態、新的[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)、[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06)變化、結局、說明了什麼、可說與推不出。\n\n### 5.1 照顧者突然不回應:面無表情範式\n\n**資料說明。** 本例取自〔Aureli〕、〔Grazia〕、〔Cardone〕、〔Merla〕二〇一五年發表於〔Frontiers in Psychology〕的研究,我讀過全文。該研究使用〔Tronick〕、〔Als〕、〔Adamson〕、〔Wise〕、〔Brazelton〕一九七八年發表於《美國兒童精神醫學學會期刊》的範式;一九七八年的原始論文沒有讀到。以下事實一律據二〇一五年這篇研究,並標明哪些是研究者的詮釋。\n\n**1. [切法](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c23)。** 範圍是一位母親與她的嬰兒在實驗室的面對面互動;時間是一次實驗,共四個階段。節點兩個:嬰兒為甲,母親為乙。研究者給乙的階段指示,視為從外部[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)乙的一件事,不另設節點。\n\n**2. 初始狀態。** 依[配置假定](concepts.md#c01),甲只具有[一階分別](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c24),乙有[二階分別](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c01)與[看法歸屬](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c02)。最後的樣本是十二對母嬰,嬰兒三到四個月大,足月出生,母親是主要照顧者,來自義大利;原本三十一對同意參加,其餘因技術與程序原因,或嬰兒一開始就太煩躁而排除。甲乙在家中已有日常的[專屬歷史](concepts.md#c05),實驗只取其中一個情境。\n\n**3. 新的[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)。** 實驗分四個階段:母親像平常一樣與嬰兒玩(三分鐘);母親保持中性表情、目光穩定地看著嬰兒,不碰觸不說話(一分鐘);母親恢復互動(三分鐘);第四階段用玩具玩(五分鐘),是研究者為自己的研究加進去的,不屬於經典範式。這一段改變的是乙的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28):乙仍在場,「不回應」也是乙這一階段落出的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28),持續[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)甲,與[被迫的賭注](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c11)中「不動也是結果」同一種結構。\n\n**4. [權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06)變化。** 只寫外顯記錄。研究者以每秒一次的編碼,依表情、視線與發聲定義嬰兒的狀態;另一位編碼員重複編碼了百分之二十五的實驗,一致性係數為零點七六。結果:看向母親並帶著正向表情的比例,面無表情階段顯著低於正常互動階段,恢復階段又顯著高於面無表情階段,但仍低於正常互動階段;環顧環境的比例在面無表情階段較高,整體檢定未達顯著,兩階段的成對比較達顯著;抗議行為統計上沒有顯著差異,自我安撫的行為也沒有顯著增加;退縮、拉開距離與自律壓力指標,在資料中完全沒出現。用[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06)的語言只能寫:在互動維度上,乙的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)改變以後,甲的「看向乙並顯出正向表情」這類[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)的[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06)變低,「環顧環境」這類變高。\n\n**5. 結局。** 實驗結束於第四階段。研究者另外記錄了鼻尖與額頭的體表溫度;本例不用這部分資料,因為體溫與動機之間的連結是研究者的詮釋,本篇不採用。\n\n**6. 這個案例說明了什麼。** 兩件事。第一,不對稱[迴路](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c31)中,乙的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)是甲[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06)的輸入,這在外顯行為上看得到。第二,這個範式只靠外顯記錄就能進行,不需要先知道嬰兒要什麼,與[驅動力不可確認](concepts.md#c03)相容。面無表情階段加恢復階段,人為造成互動序列的改變,可能形成[失配](concepts.md#c08)與其後的序列(3.4);看向母親並帶正向表情的比例在恢復階段回升,仍低於正常階段,但本例沒有指定相容判準,所以不稱為[修復](concepts.md#c09)。另外,有六對母嬰因為母親無法一直保持面無表情而被排除,這說明乙自己的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)也不是照指示就能完全定出;這是外顯事實,本篇不替它找原因。\n\n**7. 可說與推不出。** 可說:在這個設計與這個樣本下,乙的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)改變與甲的某些外顯行為改變同時出現。推不出:嬰兒為何如此改變;研究者所說的「嬰兒察覺互動被打斷」「違反期待」,是研究者的詮釋,不是外顯記錄,本篇不採用;作者自己推測面無表情階段只有一分鐘,可能是嬰兒沒有明顯不安的原因,這也只是推測,沒有檢驗;十二對的樣本很小,作者自己也列為限制;這個結果能否推到其他時長、其他月齡、其他文化,或日常家庭互動;甲的行為改變是否由乙的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)單獨造成;個別嬰兒有沒有[二階分別](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c01)。\n\n### 5.2 同一搭檔與換搭檔:雙人精準操作任務\n\n**資料說明。** 本例取自〔Heidersberger〕、〔Kaiser〕、〔Jadav〕、〔Mihić Zidar〕、〔Curioni〕、〔Johannsen〕、〔Lee〕二〇二五年發表於〔Scientific Reports〕十五卷的研究,我讀過全文。補充表格沒有取得,所以下文的檢定結果只用正文裡報告的數字。研究者的詮釋與測量分開標明。\n\n**1. [切法](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c23)。** 範圍是兩位受試者在同一個實驗任務中,面對面站著,各用右手握住同一個把手兩端的握柄;時間是一次實驗,共五個階段。節點兩個:搭檔雙方。任務規則、裝置與每回合結束後顯示的分數,視為兩人共同的[外生背景](concepts.md#c02),在這段時窗內不隨本例的[迴路](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c31)更新。\n\n**2. 初始狀態。** 受試者四十四人,都沒有做過這項任務,每四人一組。依[配置假定](concepts.md#c01),雙方都有[二階分別](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c01)與[看法歸屬](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c02);這是假定,論文沒有測量。任務是「熱線遊戲」:兩人合力讓把手上的金屬環沿著一條彎曲銅線移動到轉折點再回來,盡量不碰到銅線,目標時間二十秒,每回合結束後顯示一個分數。\n\n**3. 新的[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)。** 實驗分五個階段:先各自單獨做一次(五回合);然後與固定的搭檔合作(十五回合,稱為訓練);再各自單獨做一次(五回合);最後兩個階段各十五回合,一個是回到同一個搭檔,一個是換成同組另一位、剛在訓練階段另有搭檔的人,順序在各組之間隨機分配。每位受試者在這兩個合作階段開始時,累積的任務經驗量相同。兩人透過同一個把手互相施力,彼此的力與動作經由把手[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)對方。論文沒有交代受試者彼此原本認不認識,所以本篇不稱換搭檔的對象為「陌生人」,只稱「在這項任務上沒有[專屬歷史](concepts.md#c05)」。\n\n**4. [權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06)變化。** 只寫外顯記錄與統計結果,不寫原因。據論文:回到同一搭檔,第一回合的分數高於訓練階段的第一回合;換成另一位搭檔,第一回合的分數低於回到同一搭檔的第一回合,與訓練階段第一回合沒有顯著差別;從第四回合起,兩者的差異不再顯著。回到同一搭檔時,把手的位置與方向、手的軌跡、施力,都比換搭檔時更接近訓練最後一回合的樣子,腕部軌跡沒有顯著差別;回到同一搭檔的階段,分數在十五回合內沒有顯著上升。用[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06)的語言只能寫:在這個任務維度上,與有[專屬歷史](concepts.md#c05)的搭檔合作時,開頭幾個回合裡高分的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06)較高;與沒有[專屬歷史](concepts.md#c05)的搭檔合作時,這個差距在幾個回合內縮小。\n\n**5. 結局。** 實驗結束於最後一個合作階段。論文另外報告兩項與本篇無關的結果,本例不採用:慣用手不同的組合表現較低,作者自己說明需要更大、更平衡的樣本;兩人個人表現差距大時,合作表現較低。\n\n**6. 這個案例說明了什麼。** 三件事。第一,[專屬歷史](concepts.md#c05)是搭檔專屬的:與別人合作的經驗,沒有在換搭檔的第一回合帶來明顯的好處(沒有顯著差別,不是證明沒有)。第二,[專屬歷史](concepts.md#c05)提供的是起點,不是長期優勢:差距在幾個回合內就消失,也就是缺少[專屬歷史](concepts.md#c05)的兩人,靠任務規則與幾個回合的磨合就能達到同樣的分數,這是「協調不需要事先有[默契](concepts.md#c06)」的一個校準。第三,這項研究全程只靠外顯測量:分數、軌跡、施力,不需要任何人算準對方的下一步,與[默契](concepts.md#c06)定義中「不要求預言」相容。\n\n**7. 可說與推不出。** 可說:在這個任務與這個樣本下,回到同一搭檔的開頭幾個回合,分數較高,施力與軌跡較接近之前;換搭檔後,幾個回合內分數趕上。推不出:這種搭檔間的熟悉,是不是[默契](concepts.md#c06)(這裡的共同[歷史](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13)只有十五回合、約十分鐘,在實驗室裡,遠短於日常關係);在其他任務、更長時間或其他年齡層是否同樣;研究者所說的「學習對方動作的預測模型」「協商共同行動策略」,是研究者的詮釋,不是測量;受試者主觀回報的「較趕、控制感較低」,是自陳,不能當成原因;舊搭檔階段分數沒有繼續上升,作者推測是疲勞,這也只是推測;兩人彼此原本認不認識;個別受試者是否有[二階分別](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c01)。\n\n## 六、結論分級與可證偽條件\n\n本篇的結論分兩級。約束級結論只由[流變律](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c24)、[黑箱律](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c25)、[損耗律](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c26)、[不可復原律](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c28)與前提一至前提四,以及作者新增的前提二十至前提二十二推出。條件級結論另用到[配置假定](concepts.md#c01)、[外生背景](concepts.md#c02)或某項經驗前件。第五節的案例是校準,不屬於任何一級,也不拿來支持任何一級的結論。\n\n約束級結論,先按系統的性質歸類,再依對[迴路](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c31)所作的操作列出細項。\n\n| 性質 | 約束級結論的概要 | 主要在 |\n|---|---|---|\n| 回饋結構(部件一) | 每個[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19)有自我與他者兩種輸入;兩人之間在同一時窗內可有三個[迴路](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c31);[正回饋](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c32)沒有方向偏好,吸引與[衝突](concepts.md#c10)升級的方向相反,而且[衝突](concepts.md#c10)還須雙方的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)互相針對、互相強化;大[迴路](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c31)弱時小[迴路](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c31)可以繼續 | 2.1、3.6、4.8、4.9 |\n| 隱藏狀態(部件二) | 對方的[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06)外部讀不出;轉述不是複本;雙方各有一本帳;外顯[頻率](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c48)推不出歸屬的改變;人多不使網路成為全知主體 | 2.2、4.1至4.4、4.8、4.9 |\n| 非決定性與非定常(部件三) | 有能力不推出這一次使用;[失配](concepts.md#c08)之後不保證[修復](concepts.md#c09);[正回饋](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c32)與[默契](concepts.md#c06)不保證持續;相容[不被保證](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c02);同樣的輸入不保證同樣的作用 | 2.3、3.4、4.7至4.9 |\n| 路徑依賴與不可逆(部件四) | [專屬歷史](concepts.md#c05)按維度計;已[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)的部分仍在,未[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)的部分不因[退場](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c43)而[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10),日後是否到達[不被保證](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c02);重新接觸是新的一次;累積只加不減,不推出品質單調變好 | 2.4、3.1、4.4、4.5、4.7 |\n| 自我指涉(部件五) | 動機詞(欺騙、強迫、信任、承諾、公平、原諒等)都是歸屬,歸屬是一筆[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28);[修復](concepts.md#c09)與停哭不單獨構成對歸屬的檢驗;研究者使用須標明是誰作的歸屬 | 2.5、3.2、3.3、4.3、4.6 |\n\n依操作排列的細項如下。\n\n| 操作 | 約束級結論 | 節 |\n|---|---|---|\n| [迴路](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c31)本身 | 每個[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19)有自我回饋與他者回饋兩種輸入;有[二階分別](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c01)的[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19)多一個把自己的[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)當成看法的環節;有能力不推出這一次使用,能力隨年齡如何變化屬生物性,不由本篇推導;[專屬歷史](concepts.md#c05)按維度計,一處為零不取消他處 | 一、二 |\n| 驅動力 | [驅動力不可確認](concepts.md#c03),適用一切不被[鎖死](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c12)的對象 | 一 |\n| 禁止 | 不得假定研究者在[迴路](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c31)之外;不得假定兩端的[回合](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c04)同步;兩個節點的分析是一種[切法](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c23);沒有[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)不等於沒有影響;結構對稱不推出[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)或[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06)對稱;模式不是原因,須指出是哪一筆[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10);[默契](concepts.md#c06)不保證延續;[專屬歷史](concepts.md#c05)不推出雙方持有相同的內容 | 一、二、3.4、4.1、4.7 |\n| 歸屬 | 照顧者對嬰兒哭聲的歸屬是[看法歸屬](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c02)與[印象](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c45),不是對方狀態的讀數,也不保證有外部可得的判準判定它對或錯;每次嘗試是[被迫的賭注](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c11),停哭不單獨構成對歸屬的檢驗,[印象](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c45)的穩定不等於逼近對方 | 3.2、3.3 |\n| [失配](concepts.md#c08) | [失配](concepts.md#c08)是這個[迴路](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c31)結構上不被排除的可能;[修復](concepts.md#c09)只是序列重新相容,不是對歸屬的檢驗;[失配](concepts.md#c08)之後不保證[修復](concepts.md#c09),也不推出永不[修復](concepts.md#c09);「原諒」若是歸屬,不等於[修復](concepts.md#c09) | 3.4 |\n| 二階出現 | 若[二階分別](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c01)在甲身上出現,兩邊[迴路](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c31)在能力配置上對稱 | 3.6 |\n| [二階網路](concepts.md#c04) | 定義;人數增加不保證每個[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19)拿到的[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)占全部[歷史](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13)的比例上升;網路不保證因人多而成為掌握全部成員[歷史](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13)的主體;歸屬的協商不保證任何一方能確認對方的驅動力 | 4.1至4.3 |\n| 增加節點 | 同一筆[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)對不同的[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19)是不同的[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10);「被排除」只指某些[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)沒有[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10);轉述是一筆新[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28);新成員與既有成員,在此前沒有雙向到達的維度上都從零起點,既有的[專屬歷史](concepts.md#c05)既不歸零,也不成為新成員的 | 4.4 |\n| [我的建構](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c28) | 甲建構自己的材料有兩個來源:自己的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)回到自己,與乙的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)甲;[二階分別](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c01)不增加來源,只多一個處理環節 | 3.5 |\n| 含嬰兒的邊 | 是[耦合](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c36),不屬於[二階網路](concepts.md#c04) | 4.1 |\n| 移除節點 | 已[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)的部分仍在,未[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)的部分不因[退場](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c43)而[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10),日後是否[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)[不被保證](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c02);後來者的相同做法是新的一次;同名或相似不足以主張模式接續;成員更替既不推出網路消失,也不推出延續 | 4.5 |\n| 歸屬錯位 | 拒絕、警告與反制是[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28),[衝突](concepts.md#c10)是它們互相針對所形成的結構;[衝突](concepts.md#c10)起於[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)之後,沒有任何[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)(含轉述),就沒有[衝突](concepts.md#c10);「欺騙」與「強迫」是歸屬的內容,不是本篇的結論詞,研究者使用時須標明是誰作的歸屬,模型不裁決;信任、安全感、承諾、公平、情緒的傳染與共調節、社會支持同此處理,都是歸屬,其行動是[被迫的賭注](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c11) | 4.6 |\n| 歷史累積 | [默契](concepts.md#c06)不要求預言、友善、透明與[印象](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c45)穩定,敵對者也可符合;局部[默契](concepts.md#c06)不傳遞;[指定協調](concepts.md#c07)不要求全部成員兩兩有[默契](concepts.md#c06);兩種情況的合格回應集合互不相交時,同一個固定回應不能擔保兩種情況都合格(其中構造只對合成世界成立) | 4.7、附錄一 |\n| 歷史回流 | 互動次數增加,增加材料,但不保證[印象](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c45)逼近對方,也不使對方的真實[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06)可讀;成人的自我概念同樣有兩個來源,能把他人對自己的歸屬當成看法再[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18),但不推出這一次使用 | 3.5 |\n| 兩人之間的正回饋 | 兩人之間在同一時窗內可有三個[迴路](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c31);[正回饋](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c32)沒有方向偏好,吸引與[衝突](concepts.md#c10)升級的方向相反,而且[衝突](concepts.md#c10)還須雙方的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)互相針對、互相強化,「吸引」「互惠」是對外顯型態貼的標籤;不保證持續,不保證公平,沒有外部可得的帳本;到達完全停止時大[迴路](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c31)停止、小[迴路](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c31)不因此必然停止,到達減少不能說大[迴路](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c31)必然消散;大[迴路](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c31)弱時小[迴路](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c31)可以繼續,單戀與遠距離同此;外顯接觸[頻率](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c48)的變化推不出歸屬的改變,也推不出沒有改變 | 4.9 |\n| 權重軌跡 | 同一筆[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)對不同的[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19)移動方式不同;[趨同](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c37)、[趨異](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c38)、[持平](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c52)由雙方的[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06)共同決定,外部讀不出[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06);「友好」與[衝突](concepts.md#c10)是對外顯型態貼的標籤;任何一對[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19)相容都[不被保證](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c02),熟人也不例外;沒有[專屬歷史](concepts.md#c05)不推出不可能相容;雙方彼此握有對方相容區域的材料,仍不排除[衝突](concepts.md#c10) | 4.8 |\n\n條件級結論如下。\n\n| 結論 | 用到的前件 | 節 |\n|---|---|---|\n| 甲在出生時[歷史](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13)不歸零,甲乙在這個維度上尚無[專屬歷史](concepts.md#c05) | 出生與產前接觸 | 3.1 |\n| 乙能把[失配](concepts.md#c08)當成線索回頭修正自己的歸屬,甲沒有這個環節,追溯[修復](concepts.md#c09)時先從乙端找起 | [配置假定](concepts.md#c01) | 3.3、3.4 |\n| 乙的歸屬與框架,以及[外生背景](concepts.md#c02)經乙[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)甲的部分,成為甲的外來材料,帶著乙的誤差 | [配置假定](concepts.md#c01)與[外生背景](concepts.md#c02) | 3.5 |\n| 對生物人,對方對一筆[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)的反應不可能與該[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)同時發生 | 神經傳導與反應需要時間 | 二 |\n| 哪幾對有[專屬歷史](concepts.md#c05),哪幾對有[默契](concepts.md#c06),有沒有居中傳話的人,哪些模式實際接續 | 由資料決定 | 4.2、4.4、4.5、4.7 |\n| 可參與的維度增加,不等於已發生 | 發育改變參與條件 | 4.4 |\n| 某一條邊在某一刻是否屬於[二階網路](concepts.md#c04) | [配置假定](concepts.md#c01) | 4.1 |\n| 兩人之間的正回饋不能靠[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)量的無限增加來增強;造成[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)減少的距離與固定條件;重逢時的[歧異度](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c49)與是否[失配](concepts.md#c08) | 每個[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19)在一段時間內能接收的[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)有限;[外生背景](concepts.md#c02);其餘由資料決定 | 4.9 |\n| 一個[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19)在講明的時窗內新增[默契](concepts.md#c06)的對象有上限,缺少足夠反覆的[專屬歷史](concepts.md#c05)就不會有[默契](concepts.md#c06) | 每個[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19)在一段時間內能接收的[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)有限;後半是[經驗禁止](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c51) | 4.7 |\n| 同一維度、判準、時窗內,有[專屬歷史](concepts.md#c05)的搭檔,估計對方相容區域時已持有一種可用材料,沒有的搭檔這一來源為零;不推出更常相容;不寫「遠低於」 | 權重維度高且相容區域占比小;[專屬歷史](concepts.md#c05)是估計相容區域的材料 | 4.8 |\n\n各節用到的部件如下。表中的勾,是該節的推導直接引用了對應部件的結論標籤。沒有勾的節,不引用該部件。\n\n| 節 | 部件一 | 部件二 | 部件三 | 部件四 | 部件五 |\n|---|---|---|---|---|---|\n| 3.1 | | ✓ | | ✓ | |\n| 3.2 | | | | | ✓ |\n| 3.3 | | ✓ | | | ✓ |\n| 3.4 | | | ✓ | ✓ | ✓ |\n| 3.5 | ✓ | | ✓ | | |\n| 3.6 | | | | | |\n| 3.7 | | | | | |\n| 4.1 | | ✓ | | | |\n| 4.2 | ✓ | ✓ | ✓ | | |\n| 4.3 | | | | | ✓ |\n| 4.4 | | ✓ | ✓ | ✓ | ✓ |\n| 4.5 | | ✓ | | ✓ | |\n| 4.6 | | | ✓ | | ✓ |\n| 4.7 | | ✓ | ✓ | ✓ | ✓ |\n| 4.8 | | ✓ | ✓ | ✓ | ✓ |\n| 4.9 | ✓ | ✓ | ✓ | ✓ | ✓ |\n\n什麼情況會使結論失效。約束級結論的根據是四條律、前提一、前提四與作者新增的前提二十。若觀察到一個[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19)的某次[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)沒有在它的下一個[時刻](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c09)之前[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)它自己,前提一被推翻;若觀察到某個[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)看另一個[呈現](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c04)時,對方[自己的那一段](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c17)已全部[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)它,前提四被推翻;若觀察到某個不被[鎖死](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c12)的對象的驅動力能被旁人從外部完整確認,前提二十被推翻;若觀察到一個[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19)完全[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)了自己,[損耗律](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c26)被推翻;若觀察到一個不被[鎖死](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c12)的[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19)的下一個[時刻](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c09)被事先唯一推出,[黑箱律](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c25)被推翻;若觀察到[歷史](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13)中同一個位置被復原(內容相似的再次發生不算),[不可復原律](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c28)被推翻;若觀察到一個仍是[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)的[呈現](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c04),[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)它的[歷史](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13)與前一[時刻](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c09)相同,[流變律](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c24)被推翻。前提二與前提三只能假定,不能證實也不能證偽,依賴它們的結論只在這些假定之下成立。其中任何一個被推翻,依賴它的約束級結論失效。失去來源只表示推導鏈斷開,不表示該命題為假;其真假須另行論證。條件級結論的失效條件由它所用的前件決定:[配置假定](concepts.md#c01)中甲在講明階段已有[二階分別](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c01),或乙沒有[二階分別](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c01),或乙沒有[看法歸屬](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c02);[外生背景](concepts.md#c02)在講明時窗內隨模型中的[迴路](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c31)更新;產前接觸、發育改變參與條件、每個[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19)能接收的[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)有限、神經傳導與反應需要時間、[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06)維度高且相容區域占比小、[專屬歷史](concepts.md#c05)是估計相容區域的材料等經驗前件被現實違反。哪一個前件被違反,就只有用到它的那幾項結論失效,其餘不受影響。\n\n什麼不是本篇的結論。第五節的兩個案例不屬於任何一級。它們只用來檢查模型貼不貼近現實,兩個都是實驗室研究,樣本小,而且研究者的詮釋與測量已分開標明。沒有找到的資料,包括三個人以上的搭檔資料、真實家庭與組織的長期資料、[默契](concepts.md#c06)承載上限的資料、跨世代接續的資料,不寫成「不存在」,也不用來支持結論。\n\n```text\n附註 推導起點:四條律、前提一至前提四,以及作者新增的前提二十至前提二十二。前提五、前提六、前提九、前提二十一、前提二十二是範圍設定,前提七、前提八、前提十、前提十一、前提十二、前提十三是經驗前件。\n附註 可證偽條件:四條律、前提一、前提四或前提二十中任一項被推翻,依賴它的約束級結論失去根據。前提二、前提三只能假定,不能證實或證偽;依賴它們的結論只在這些假定之下成立。\n附註 條件級結論的失效條件由它所用的前件決定:前提五至前提十三中任一項被現實違反,只有用到它的結論失效。\n附註 與結論相反的觀察,只能歸於推導起點錯或推導錯;後者是勘誤,不是證偽。\n```\n\n\n## 附錄一 默契不傳遞,協調不需要兩兩有默契\n\n以下是只對這個合成世界成立的有限構造,不是現實樣本。設乙、丙、己三個[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19),在同一項任務、同一個維度上:乙與丙之間有三回合依時間排序的雙向[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28),每回合都相容接續、不需重新逐項指導;丙與己之間同樣有三回合;乙與己之間沒有任何這類[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)。在這個構造的判準下,乙丙有[默契](concepts.md#c06),丙己有[默契](concepts.md#c06),乙己沒有。因此兩段[默契](concepts.md#c06)的前件,不充分推出第三段。\n\n再設任務是乙把資料交給丙,丙再交給己,順序按規定發生,且足以通過這次任務的驗收。[指定協調](concepts.md#c07)是這樣一種判準:對一項已界定的任務,依明列的驗收條件,檢查某段實際發生的行動序列,序列符合驗收條件,稱這段序列在該任務上呈現協調。這次任務完成,乙己之間仍沒有任何[默契](concepts.md#c06),所以協調不要求全部成員兩兩有[默契](concepts.md#c06)。成功也不等於關係改善或彼此理解。反向對照:若再為乙己加入三回合同類的相容接續,乙己在這個判準下也有[默契](concepts.md#c06),原先的差異就消失。這個構造只對這個合成世界成立,不能搬到現實去證明「現實中不存在這種情況」。\n\n再看協調需要何種辨識。設兩種情況的合格回應集合沒有交集,而乙在兩種情況取得的材料與解碼條件相同。若用同一個固定回應,它不可能同時落入兩個互不相交的集合,所以同一個固定回應不能擔保兩種情況都合格。這一項不排除另有區分兩種情況的材料。本段為約束級結論。\n\n```text\n限定條件 以下的例是只對這個合成世界成立的有限構造,不是現實樣本。\n例 設乙、丙、己三個 我,在同一項任務、同一個維度上:乙與丙之間有三回合依時間排序的雙向 輸出,每回合都相容接續;丙與己之間同樣有三回合;乙與己之間沒有任何這類 輸出(從 本例效準 推出)\n例 在這個構造的判準下,乙丙有 默契,丙己有 默契,乙己沒有(從 本例效準 + 默契 的定義 推出)\n例 因此兩段 默契 的前件不充分推出第三段(從 本例效準 推出)\n例 設乙把資料交給丙,丙再交給己,順序按規定發生,且通過這次任務的驗收;這段序列符合 指定協調 的判準,而乙己之間仍沒有 默契(從 本例效準 + 指定協調 的定義 推出)\n例 因此協調不要求全部成員兩兩有 默契(從 本例效準 推出)\n例 反向對照:為乙己加入三回合同類的相容接續後,乙己在這個判準下也有 默契,原先的差異消失(從 本例效準 + 默契 的定義 推出)\n例 設兩種情況的合格回應集合互不相交,而乙在兩種情況取得的材料與解碼條件相同;則同一個固定回應不能同時屬於兩個集合,所以不能擔保兩種情況都合格(從 本例效準 推出)\n附註 上一條不排除另有區分兩種情況的材料。\n```\n\n"},{"filename":"Interaction Dynamics - Second-Order Networks under a Common Exogenous Background.md","content":"---\nuuid: ae79e938-76e1-4bf9-b2ab-995c03e16c9e\nlast-modified: 2026-10-15T14:14:29\nauthor: 黃正宇 / Cheng Yu Huang\ncontact: mthree.tw@gmail.com\n---\n\n# Interaction Dynamics - Second-Order Networks under a Common Exogenous Background\n\n## 0. Positioning and Assumptions\n\nThis paper studies the situation of two configurations in a [loop](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c31): in one, a [Self](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19) that has only [first-order distinction](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c24) and a [Self](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19) that has [second-order distinction](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c01) [arrive](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at each other; in the other, several [Selves](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19), all with [second-order distinction](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c01), [arrive](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at one another. The two configurations use the same set of constraints; they differ only in one parameter, whether [second-order distinction](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c01) is present.\n\nThe conclusions of this paper come in two levels. A constraint-level conclusion is derived only from the laws and premises listed in the next section; if any one of them can be overturned, the conclusion fails. A conditional conclusion additionally uses an assumption or an empirical antecedent listed below; the text states which one it uses, and if reality violates it, that conclusion fails. An empirical antecedent serves only as an input to a derivation and is not used to prove that a constraint holds.\n\nA [configuration assumption](concepts.md#c01) is an assumption made about a set of concrete subjects: at the stated stage, some of the subjects have only [first-order distinction](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c24), and the rest have [second-order distinction](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c01) and also [view attribution](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c02). This paper makes that assumption for A and B (Premise 5): at the stated stage, A has only [first-order distinction](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c24), and B has [second-order distinction](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c01) and also [view attribution](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c02). It is an assumption, not a theorem; it is [not guaranteed](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c02) that whether a subject has [second-order distinction](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c01) at a given moment can be confirmed from outside; it can be refuted only by finding a mechanism that proves the subject's [outputs](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) can only fall out of [locked-in rounds](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c25), or can only fall out of [random rounds](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c26).\n\nAn [exogenous background](concepts.md#c02) is a background that, within a stated time window and [cut](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c23), is treated as entering from outside the model and as not updated by the [loops](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c31) in the model (Premise 6). It is a scoping assumption and does not claim that culture is unchanging; what enters the model is the background, not the content that each [Self](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19) obtains from it, because each [Self](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19) can obtain only the part that [arrives](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at it. When the time window is lengthened to the point where the background changes significantly, this assumption must be relaxed, and the conclusions that depend on it fail accordingly.\n\nInstitutions, norms, and customs are, in principle, patterns formed in [history](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13) by a [second-order network](concepts.md#c04), not a different kind of entity. Because the time window of this paper is short and the participants are few, they are treated together with culture as an [exogenous background](concepts.md#c02); the only question asked is through whom they [arrive](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at whom, not how they are formed. This is a scoping decision of this paper and not a restriction on the definition of a [second-order network](concepts.md#c04).\n\nThis paper deals with the structure of the [loop](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c31), and with the \"beginning\" and the \"back-and-forth\" that can be derived from it. Words such as trust, security, commitment, fairness, attraction, and attachment, which point to inner states or motives, are all treated in this paper as the attribution of some [Self](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19) or of the researcher; the only question asked is what they do within a [loop](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c31), and their truth is not adjudicated (4.6, 4.9). Self-disclosure, power and dependence, culture, and strangers and weak ties are outside the scope of this paper and are left to later sub-papers. Individual differences (personality and attachment style treated as traits that carry across partners), coalitions and exclusion among three or more people, the life course, and methods for analyzing dyadic data are also not developed here and are left to later papers.\n\nA, B, and the C, D, and E that appear later are all synthetic individuals used for demonstration, not measured cases.\n\n```text\nNote: Institutions, norms, and customs are, in principle, patterns of a Second-Order Network; this paper treats them together with culture as an Exogenous Background, which is a scoping decision and not a restriction on the Second-Order Network.\nNote: A Configuration Assumption is not a theorem; an Exogenous Background does not claim the background is unchanging; what enters the model is the background, not what each Self draws from it, and each Self gets only the part that Arrives at it.\nNote: It is Not Guaranteed that whether a subject has Second-Order Distinction at a given moment can be confirmed from outside (an upstream conclusion); this paper only uses it and does not derive it.\nNote: A, B, and the C, D, and E that appear later are all synthetic individuals used for demonstration, not measured cases.\n```\n\n## 1. The Laws and Premises Used in This Paper\n\nThis paper uses the [Law of Flux](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c24): the [history](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13) in which a [Wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16) is situated keeps changing, and at each of its [moments](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c09), the [history](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13) that [arrives](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at it differs from what it was before that [collapse](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c08). It uses the [Law of the Black Box](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c25): when a [Wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16) is not [locked in](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c12), its next [moment](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c09) cannot be uniquely derived in advance; what can be derived is the [weight](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06). It uses the [Law of Attrition](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c26): a [Self](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19) can at no [moment](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c09) make a complete [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) of itself. It uses the [Law of Non-Restoration](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c28): each position in [history](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13) occurs only once, and when it is redone, a choice that is not [locked in](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c12) is not necessarily the same. The four laws are used as axioms, and this paper does not prove them again.\n\nThis paper has four further premises. Premise 1: every [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) of a [Self](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19) [arrives](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at that [Self](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19) itself before its next [moment](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c09). Premise 2: for any [decision](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c06) of a [Self](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19), its content is a [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18), not a complete description of the object that is said or done. Premise 3: a result that falls out of a [computation](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c05) is not a [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18); a [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) falls out only in a [decision](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c06). Premise 4: for any [presentation](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c04), including itself, there is always a part of its [own segment](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c17) that has not [arrived](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at this [Wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16).\n\nThis paper adopts the conclusions of the [three walls](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c23): the [wall of provenance](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c08), by which a [Self](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19) cannot obtain all of its own past [history](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13); the [wall of the blind spot](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c09), by which a [Self](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19) cannot see its present self; and the [wall of the undetermined](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c10), by which a [Self](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19) cannot calculate what is certain about the future. It also adopts the [forced wager](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c11) and the [illusion](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c14): the [illusion](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c14) is a condition and not an error; [second-order](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c01) does not take a [Self](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19) out of the [illusion](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c14), it only makes it possible to ask about it.\n\nThis paper adds one constraint, called [unconfirmability of drives](concepts.md#c03): for a subject that is not in [lock in](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c12), its drives, that is, motives, needs, and purposes, cannot be completely observed from outside, cannot be confirmed by self-report, and a judgment about the motive made by others after the fact is only a [view attribution](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c02) or an [impression](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c45) and does not count as verification; the motive itself does not [arrive](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at others by itself. It applies to every subject that is not in [lock in](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c12), regardless of age and regardless of whether [second-order distinction](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c01) is present; whether a subject is in [lock in](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c12) cannot be confirmed from outside and can only be assumed (Premise 3). Its grounds are: the subject's self-report, when it is not in [lock in](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c12) and comes from a [decision](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c06), is in content a [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) and not a complete description of the cause (Premise 2); the subject cannot see the very [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) it is making (the [Law of Attrition](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c26)); when others say \"what he did it for\", if it takes one of the other's [outputs](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) as the other's view, that is the others' [view attribution](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c02), and it may also be their [impression](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c45) of the other's [weight](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06), not a reading of the other's state; a judgment about the motive after the fact is likewise only another's [view attribution](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c02) or [impression](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c45); and others also cannot uniquely derive in advance the next [moment](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c09) of a subject that is not in [lock in](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c12) (the [Law of the Black Box](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c25)). The motive itself is not an [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) and does not [arrive](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at others by itself.\n\nThe methodological prohibitions of this paper are: drives may not be written as facts that can be observed, confirmed by self-report, or verified after the fact; an [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) may not be explained with \"in order to\", and one may write only that, in a certain dimension, an [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) of a certain kind has a higher [weight](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06); the emergence of [second-order](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c01) may not be written as necessarily produced by external material; the presence or absence of [second-order distinction](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c01) may not be inferred from a diagnosis; the [exogenous background](concepts.md#c02) may not be written as culture being unchanging, and gaps may not be patched with explanatory items that have only a name and no criterion (\"culture\" is a common example), and a concrete [history](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13) input must be specified; external statistics, order, or a single record path may not be written as a direct reading of true [weight](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06) or of path dependence; the step from numbers to action may not be written as computable; a sense of certainty may not be taken as evidence; it may not be said that reflection necessarily brings better judgment; it may not be said that the [illusion](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c14) has been eliminated; stability of an [impression](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c45) may not be written as approaching the other; and when speaking of [convergence](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c37), [divergence](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c38), or [stasis](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c52), the dimension must be stated.\n\nThe researcher is also inside the [loop](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c31). The researcher's observations, questions, instructions, and records, if recorded as the researcher's [outputs](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) that [arrive](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at the observed [Self](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19), they enter the other's [history](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13) and, by the [Law of Non-Restoration](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c28), cannot be taken back; when the other's subsequent [outputs](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28), influenced by them, [arrive](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) again at the researcher and take part in its [weight](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06), the two sides form a [loop](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c31). So it is not presumed that the researcher necessarily stands outside the [loop](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c31); only an observation made through records alone, which does not [arrive](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at the observed, leaves its [history](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13) unchanged. This paragraph is a constraint-level conclusion.\n\n```text\nNote: Premise 1 to Premise 4 below, together with the four laws, are the starting points of derivation in this paper; this paper uses them and does not prove them again.\nQualifying condition: Scope: configurations in which a Self with only First-Order Distinction and a Self with Second-Order Distinction Arrive at each other, and configurations in which several Selves with Second-Order Distinction Arrive at one another; the acquaintance stage.\nQualifying condition: The model is used only within a stated time window and Cut.\nQualifying condition: Only the public entries of upstream are used; upstream arguments and numbering are not cited.\nPremise 20: For a subject that is not in Lock-in, its drives, meaning its motives, needs, and purposes, cannot be completely observed from outside, cannot be confirmed by self-report, and a judgment about its motive after the fact is only a View Attribution or an Impression and does not count as verification.\nPremise 1: Every Distinction of a Self Arrives at that Self itself before its next Moment.\nPremise 2: For any Decision of a Self, its content is a Distinction, not a complete description of the object that is said or done.\nPremise 3: A result that falls out of a Computation is not a Distinction; a Distinction falls out only in a Decision.\nPremise 4: For any Presentation, including itself, there is always a part of its Own Segment that has not Arrived at this Wo.\nPremise 5: A Configuration Assumption is made for A and B: at the stated stage, A has only First-Order Distinction, and B has Second-Order Distinction and also View Attribution.\nPremise 6: Within a stated time window and Cut, the background is an Exogenous Background: it enters from outside the model and is not updated by the Loops in the model.\nNote: Premise 2 and Premise 3 can only be assumed, and can be neither verified nor falsified; Premise 5 and Premise 6 are scoping assumptions; Premise 20, Premise 21, and Premise 22 are constraints and scoping assumptions added by the author and are not derived from other premises.\nNote: This paper adopts the conclusions of Three Walls, Forced Wager, and Illusion; Second-Order Distinction does not take a Self out of the Illusion, it only makes it possible to ask about it.\n\nStep 1-1: When a Self is not in Lock-in, its self-report, if it comes from a Decision, is in content a Distinction and not a complete description of the cause (from Premise 2 + Premise 3 + definition of Output + definition of Decision)\nStep 1-2: A Self cannot see the very Distinction it is making (from Law of Attrition + Wall of the Blind Spot)\nStep 1-3: What others say about \"what he did it for\", if it takes one of the other's Outputs as the other's view, is the others' View Attribution; it may also be the others' Impression of the other's Weight; neither is a reading of the other's state (from definition of View Attribution + definition of Impression + Premise 4)\nStep 1-4: Others cannot uniquely derive in advance the next Moment of a Wo that is not in Lock-in; what can be derived is the Weight (from Law of the Black Box)\nNote: The motive itself is not an Output and does not Arrive at others by itself.\nStep 1-4-2: A judgment about the motive after the fact can likewise be a View Attribution by others, or the others' Impression of the other's Weight (from Step 1-3 + Premise 2)\nStep 1-4-3: For others looking at the subject, there is always a part of the subject's own segment that has not Arrived at them, so it is not guaranteed that the subject's drives can be completely observed from outside (from Premise 4 + Premise 20)\nConclusion 1-5: Unconfirmability of Drives: for a subject that is not in Lock-in, its drives cannot be completely observed from outside, cannot be confirmed by self-report, and a judgment about its motive after the fact is only a View Attribution or an Impression and does not count as verification (from Premise 20 + Step 1-1 + Step 1-2 + Step 1-3 + Step 1-4 + Step 1-4-2 + Step 1-4-3)\nNote: Unconfirmability of Drives applies to every subject that is not in Lock-in, regardless of age and regardless of whether Second-Order Distinction is present.\nStep 1-6: The researcher's observations, questions, instructions, and records, if they are recorded as the researcher's Outputs that Arrive at the observed Self, cannot be taken back; if the observed party's subsequent Outputs, influenced by them, Arrive again at the researcher and take part in the researcher's Weight, the two sides form a Loop; so it is not presumed that the researcher is necessarily outside the Loop (from definition of Output + definition of Arrival + definition of Weight + definition of Loop + Law of Non-Restoration)\n```\n\n## 2. The Loop Model\n\nThe model of this paper is a recursion that advances by [moment](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c09). At each [moment](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c09), the state of a [Self](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19) is its [history](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13) up to now; the [outputs](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) that [arrive](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at it (from itself and from others) are added to the [history](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13), only added and never subtracted; the [weight](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06) is the action of the [history](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13) on the next [moment](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c09), and this paper does not specify the concrete function; when not [locked in](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c12), the next [moment](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c09) cannot be uniquely derived in advance, and what can be derived is the [weight](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06); the [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) then [arrives](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at itself and can also [arrive](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at others. This paper does not discuss feelings but experience: experience is the [history](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13) formed by the [outputs](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) that have [arrived](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10). This is a scope setting of this paper. This is therefore a discrete-time system with feedback, hidden state, non-determinism, path dependence, and self-reference. This paper derives its qualitative properties; the transition function is not specified, so no concrete trajectory is derived. This paragraph is a constraint-level conclusion.\n\nThis recursion is composed of five components, and the following sections are combinations of them in different positions; the beginning of each section states which components it uses, and Section 6 has a summary table. The five components are derived only from the four laws and the premises, with no new premises added. There is one further variable: configuration, that is, who has [second-order distinction](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c01), see 2.6; it does not count as a component.\n\n| Component | Dynamical property | Content | Basis | Label |\n|---|---|---|---|---|\n| Component 1: Three [Loops](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c31) | Feedback structure | Each [Self](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19) has a small self-feedback [loop](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c31), and between two [Selves](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19) there is a large [loop](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c31); what is passed on a [loop](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c31) is [outputs](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) | Premise 1, definition of [loop](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c31) | Conclusion 2-11 |\n| Component 2: Partial Arrival | Hidden state | What each [Self](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19) obtains is only [own segment](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c17) that [arrives](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at itself | Premise 4 | Conclusion 2-12 |\n| Component 3: Non-Derivability | Non-determinism, non-stationarity | For a [Self](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19) that is not [locked in](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c12), the next [moment](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c09) cannot be uniquely derived in advance, and the [history](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13) that [arrives](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at both sides differs at every [moment](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c09) | [Law of the Black Box](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c25), [Law of Flux](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c24) | Conclusion 2-13 |\n| Component 4: One-Way Accumulation | Path dependence, irreversibility | A position that has occurred cannot be redone; [dedicated history](concepts.md#c05) is counted by dimension | [Law of Non-Restoration](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c28) | Conclusion 2-14 |\n| Component 5: Attribution as Output | Self-reference | A view of another is an attribution, and the attribution itself is an [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28); motives cannot be confirmed from outside | [View attribution](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c02), [unconfirmability of drives](concepts.md#c03) | Conclusion 2-15 |\n\n```text\nStep 2-16-1: A Self's state at each Moment is made up of the History that has Arrived at it up to then and of how those Arrivals take part in its Weight (from definition of Self + definition of Wo + definition of History + definition of Weight)\nStep 2-16-2: The Outputs that Arrive at it are added to the History, only added and never subtracted (from Law of Non-Restoration + definition of History + definition of Arrival)\nStep 2-16-3: Weight is the relative lightness or heaviness of the branches and not an internal parameter of the Wo; History takes part in the allocation of Weight at the next Moment, and the specific function is not specified (from definition of Weight + definition of Wo)\nStep 2-16-4: When not in Lock-in, the next Moment cannot be uniquely derived in advance, and what can be derived is the Weight (from Law of the Black Box)\nStep 2-16-5: A Distinction Arrives at itself again (Premise 1); a Distinction that is an Output can also Arrive at others (from Premise 1 + definition of Arrival + definition of Output)\nPremise 22: This paper discusses only the History formed by Outputs that have Arrived, and does not discuss feelings.\nStep 2-16-6: This paper discusses only the History formed by Outputs that have Arrived, and does not discuss feelings (from Premise 22 + definition of Output + definition of Arrival)\nCycle 2-16: The model of this paper is a recursion that advances by Moment, and the state is the accumulated History; the exit conditions of this Cycle include the Self making its Exit; this paper derives its qualitative properties and not its concrete trajectory (from Step 2-16-1 + Step 2-16-2 + Step 2-16-3 + Step 2-16-4 + Step 2-16-5 + Step 2-16-6 + definition of Exit)\nNote: The transition function is not specified; this paper does not discuss feelings, it discusses experience.\n```\n\n### 2.1 Component 1: Three Loops\n\nEach [Self](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19) has two kinds of input: its own [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) from the previous moment, and the [outputs](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) of others. By Premise 1, a [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) returns to itself, so each [Self](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19) has its own small self-feedback [loop](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c31); [outputs](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) also [arrive](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at others, and when the others' subsequent [outputs](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) are influenced by them and [arrive](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) again at that [Self](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19), there is a further large [loop](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c31) between the two [Selves](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19), the two nested. As long as they remain [Wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16), the [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) at each [moment](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c09) still [arrives](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at itself (Premise 1) and the material of the small [loop](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c31) remains; whether a [loop](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c31) persists is still [not guaranteed](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c02). The exit condition of the small [loop](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c31) is that the [Self](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19) is no longer a [Wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16); the exit condition of the large [loop](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c31) is that the [outputs](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) of the two sides no longer [arrive](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at each other.\n\nWhat is passed on a [loop](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c31) is [outputs](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28). By [unconfirmability of drives](concepts.md#c03), drives remain within the [weight](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06) of each [Self](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19) and, by the [Law of the Black Box](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c25), do not enter the derivation. So two ways of writing are excluded: writing interaction as one-way influence, and treating drives as something passed on a [loop](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c31).\n\n```text\nCycle 2-1: Each Self has a self-feedback small Loop; the exit condition of this Cycle is that the Self is no longer a Wo; as long as it remains a Wo, each Distinction Arrives at itself (Premise 1) (from Premise 1 + definition of Wo + definition of Loop)\nCycle 2-2: When a Self's Output Arrives at another and the other's subsequent Output, affected by it, in turn Arrives at that Self, there is a further large Loop between the two Selves, nested with the small Loops on both sides; the exit condition of this Cycle is that the Outputs of the two sides no longer Arrive at each other (from definition of Output + definition of Arrival + definition of Wo + definition of Weight + definition of Loop)\nCycle 2-3: As long as they remain Wo, the Distinction at each Moment still Arrives at itself and the material of the small Loop remains; whether a Loop can continue is still not guaranteed; the exit condition of the small Loop is that they are no longer Wo, and the exit condition of the large Loop is that the Outputs of the two sides no longer Arrive at each other (from Cycle 2-1 + Cycle 2-2 + Premise 1 + Law of Flux + definition of Wo + definition of Loop)\nPremise 21: Drives do not enter the derivation.\nStep 2-4: What is passed on a Loop is Outputs; drives do not enter the derivation (from Premise 21 + definition of Loop)\nConclusion 2-11: Each Self has a small self-feedback Loop; when the Outputs of two Selves Arrive at each other and each one's subsequent Outputs are influenced by the other's Outputs, there is a large Loop between them; what is passed on a Loop is Outputs (from Cycle 2-1 + Cycle 2-2 + Step 2-4)\n```\n\n### 2.2 Component 2: Partial Arrival\n\nBy Premise 4, for any [presentation](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c04), including itself, there is always a part of its [own segment](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c17) that has not [arrived](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at this [Wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16). This is the second component, and the following sections use it repeatedly: a [Self](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19) cannot fully read from outside the [weight](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06) of another [Self](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19); a relay is a new [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28), not a copy of the original one; two [Selves](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19) each keep their own record of the same shared experience, and the records may differ; an analysis that takes only two nodes is a kind of [cut](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c23). This paragraph is a constraint-level conclusion.\n\nAnalyzing only two nodes is a kind of [cut](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c23); the conclusions hold only for this [cut](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c23) and are not properties of the relationship itself: by Premise 4, each of the two nodes always has a part that has not [arrived](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at the other; by the [Law of the Black Box](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c25), the [history](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13) that [arrives](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at them from elsewhere will also change their [weights](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06). This paragraph is a constraint-level conclusion.\n\n```text\nConclusion 2-12: What each Self obtains is only its Own Segment that Arrives at it (from Premise 4 + definition of Distinction + definition of Arrival)\nStep 2-10-3: An analysis taking only two nodes is a Cut; the conclusions hold only for this Cut and are not properties of the relationship itself (from definition of Cut + Premise 4 + Law of the Black Box)\n```\n\n### 2.3 Component 3: Non-Derivability\n\nBy the [Law of the Black Box](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c25), for a [Self](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19) that is not [locked in](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c12), the next [moment](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c09) cannot be uniquely derived in advance; by the [Law of Flux](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c24), the [history](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13) that [arrives](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at it differs at every [moment](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c09). This is the third component: this paper derives no conclusion of the \"guarantee\" kind. This paragraph is a constraint-level conclusion.\n\nThat a [Self](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19) has [second-order distinction](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c01) is a [configuration assumption](concepts.md#c01) made about one of its stages and not a guarantee about each of its [outputs](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28). By the [Law of the Black Box](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c25), for a [Self](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19) that is not [locked in](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c12), the next [moment](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c09) cannot be uniquely derived in advance; so having the ability does not imply using it this time; using [second-order distinction](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c01) is also a [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) and remains bound by the [Law of Attrition](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c26). How the ability changes with age and with how one gets along is biological, determined by experience and not decidable by logic, and this paper does not derive it. This paragraph is a constraint-level conclusion.\n\nThe [rounds](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c04) at the two ends need not be aligned. By the [Law of Flux](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c24), the [history](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13) that [arrives](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at a [Wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16) differs at every [moment](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c09); when an [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) [arrives](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at the other, the other's [history](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13) need not be the same as when it fell out. So this paper does not assume that the two ends are synchronous and introduces no common clock; the sequence labels in the text are only an ordering. This is a constraint-level conclusion. For biological humans there is also a physical limit: neural conduction and reaction take time (Premise 11), and the other's reaction to an [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) cannot occur at the same time as that [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28). This layer is a conditional conclusion and uses Premise 11.\n\nBecause the [history](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13) keeps accumulating, the same [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) may have a different [impact](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c47) and [discrepancy](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c49) on the same [Self](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19) at different [moments](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c09), so the system is not guaranteed to be stationary: the same input does not guarantee the same effect. This paragraph is a constraint-level conclusion.\n\n```text\nConclusion 2-13: For a Self that is not Locked-in, the next Moment cannot be uniquely derived in advance, and the History that Arrives at it differs at every Moment (from Law of the Black Box + Law of Flux)\nConclusion 2-17: The same Output may have a different Impact and Discrepancy on the same Self at different Moments, so the system is not guaranteed to be stationary (from definition of Impact + definition of Discrepancy + Conclusion 2-13)\nStep 2-7: The next Moment of a Self that is not Locked-in cannot be uniquely derived in advance, so having Second-Order Distinction does not imply using it this time (from Law of the Black Box + definition of Configuration Assumption)\nStep 2-8: Using Second-Order Distinction is also a Distinction and remains bound by the Law of Attrition (from definition of Second-Order Distinction + Law of Attrition)\nNote: How the ability changes with age and with how one gets along is biological and determined by experience; logic cannot decide it, and this paper does not derive it.\nStep 2-10-1: It cannot be assumed that the Moments at the two ends are aligned; when an Output Arrives, the other's History need not be the same as when it fell out (from Law of Flux + definition of Arrival)\nPremise 11: The neural conduction and reaction of a biological human take time, and the other's reaction to an Output cannot occur at the same time as that Output.\nNote: Premise 11 is an empirical antecedent used as an input to derivation; it is a physical limit and not a claim about a Self in general.\nConclusion 2-10-2: For biological humans, the other's reaction to an Output does not occur at the same time as that Output (from Premise 11)\nNote: Conclusion 2-10-2 is conditional and uses Premise 11.\n```\n\n### 2.4 Component 4: One-Way Accumulation\n\nBy the [Law of Non-Restoration](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c28), each position in [history](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13) occurs only once, and what has already happened cannot be taken back. This is the fourth component, most often used on [dedicated history](concepts.md#c05), which is counted by dimension. This paragraph is a constraint-level conclusion.\n\n[Dedicated history](concepts.md#c05) is counted by dimension. The same [Self](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19) may already have [dedicated history](concepts.md#c05) with B in one dimension, have none with C in the same dimension, and have none with B in another dimension; zero at any one place does not cancel the [history](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13) already present at other places (the [Law of Non-Restoration](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c28)). The same [Self](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19) can therefore be, with different counterparts, in different situations at the same time, and need not pass through certain stages in sequence.\n\nThe researcher may regard the accumulated [history](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13) as the layer that changes slowly and regard the round-by-round [outputs](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) and feedback as the layer that changes fast; the former is called the slow variable and the latter the fast variable. This is a [cut](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c23) the researcher makes in observation and is not an explanation of why the [weight](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06) changes: the [weight](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06) cannot be read (the [Law of the Black Box](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c25)), and the researcher can only see that some things change fast and some change slowly. [Impression](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c45), familiarity, and [tacit coordination](concepts.md#c06) are functions of the accumulated [history](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13); attraction, [conflict](concepts.md#c10), and dissipation are the shapes that the fast layer takes on the background of the slow layer (see 4.7 to 4.9). Accumulation only adds and never subtracts, which does not mean quality improves monotonically. This paragraph is a constraint-level conclusion.\n\n```text\nConclusion 2-10: Dedicated History is counted by dimension; zero at one place does not cancel the History already present at other places (from definition of Dedicated History + Law of Non-Restoration)\nConclusion 2-14: Each position in History occurs only once and what has occurred cannot be taken back; Dedicated History is counted by dimension (from Law of Non-Restoration + Conclusion 2-10)\nStep 2-18-1: The researcher may regard the accumulated History as the slow layer and regard Output and feedback as the fast layer; this is a Cut and does not explain why Weight changes (from Law of the Black Box + definition of Cut)\nConclusion 2-18: Under this Cut, the accumulated History is the slow variable and Output and feedback are the fast variable; accumulation only adds and never subtracts, which does not imply that quality improves monotonically (from Step 2-18-1 + Conclusion 2-14 + definition of Impression + definition of Tacit Coordination)\n```\n\n### 2.5 Component 5: Attribution as Output\n\nBy the definition of [view attribution](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c02), the attribution that a [Self](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19) with [second-order distinction](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c01) makes about the [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) of another [Self](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19) is a [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) of its own. By [unconfirmability of drives](concepts.md#c03), motives cannot be confirmed from outside. So every word that points to an inner state or a motive is an attribution of some [Self](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19) or of the researcher; when an attribution is spoken or enacted, it is an [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28), [arrives](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at others, enters the [history](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13), and changes subsequent [weights](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06). This is the fifth component, and 4.6 applies it to words such as deception, coercion, and trust. This paragraph is a constraint-level conclusion.\n\n```text\nConclusion 2-15: A word that points to an inner state or a motive can be a Distinction, a View Attribution, or an Impression of Weight of some Self or of the researcher; once voiced, it is an Output, and the part that Arrives at others enters their History and takes part in their subsequent Weights (from definition of View Attribution + definition of Impression + definition of Output + Conclusion 1-5 + definition of Wo)\n```\n\n### 2.6 Configuration Variable and Six Operations\n\nThe two configurations differ in only one place: a [Self](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19) with [second-order distinction](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c01) has one more link, in which it can take one of its own [distinctions](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) as a view and make a further [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) about it; a [Self](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19) with only [first-order distinction](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c24) does not have this link. All of the above are constraint-level conclusions.\n\nOn this [loop](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c31) this paper performs six operations, each asking what the laws and premises permit and what they forbid: adding a node, removing a node, [mismatch](concepts.md#c08), attribution misalignment, history accumulation, and history return (see 3.5). Section 3 deals with the case of only two nodes, in which [mismatch](concepts.md#c08) and [repair](concepts.md#c09) are in 3.4; Section 4 deals with multiple nodes. The patterns that these operations grow are the conclusions of this paper. Which components each operation uses is shown in the matrix in Section 6; history return has been merged into 3.5.\n\n```text\nConclusion 2-5: A Self with Second-Order Distinction has one more link, in which it takes one of its own Distinctions as a view and makes a further Distinction about it (from definition of Second-Order Distinction)\nStep 2-6: A Self with only First-Order Distinction does not have this link (from definition of First-Order Distinction)\nNote: The six operations are only names of operations and not new premises, and no derivation takes them as a source.\n```\n\n## 3. Theme One: A Builds a Self in a Loop with B\n\n### 3.1 The Starting Point\n\nThis section uses Component 2 and Component 4 (Conclusion 2-12, Conclusion 2-14).\n\nBy the [Law of Non-Restoration](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c28), each position in [history](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13) occurs only once; since A enters carrying prenatal contact (Premise 7), A's [history](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13) is not reset to zero at birth, and a new relationship does not mean starting everything over. A and B have as yet no [dedicated history](concepts.md#c05) in this dimension. [Dedicated history](concepts.md#c05) is the part of [history](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13) between two [Selves](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19), in a stated dimension, formed by the [outputs](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) that [arrive](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at each other; it belongs only to the two of them; having as yet no [dedicated history](concepts.md#c05) limits only this relationship. Empirically, A enters carrying prenatal contact, and B enters carrying the [history](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13) that has already [arrived](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at B, which includes the part that reached B from the [exogenous background](concepts.md#c02), and only that part, if any, is in B's [history](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13); the part that has never [arrived](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at B is not in the [history](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13) that has [arrived](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at B (Premise 4). This section is a conditional conclusion, and the empirical antecedent it uses is birth and prenatal contact (Premise 7).\n\n```text\nPremise 7: A enters carrying prenatal contact, and A's History is not reset to zero at birth.\nNote: Premise 7 is an empirical antecedent used as an input to derivation, and is not used to prove that a constraint holds.\nQualifying condition: Starting point: A and B have as yet no Dedicated History in the stated dimension.\nConclusion 3-1-1: A's History is not reset to zero at birth, and a new relationship does not mean starting everything over (from Conclusion 2-14 + Premise 7)\nStep 3-1-2: B enters carrying the History that has already Arrived at B; if part of the Exogenous Background has Arrived at B, only that part is in B's History; the part that has never Arrived at B is not in the History that has Arrived at B (from Conclusion 2-12 + Premise 6)\nNote: This section is a conditional conclusion and uses Premise 7.\n```\n\n### 3.2 A's Output and B's Candidate Attributions\n\nThis section uses Component 5 (Conclusion 2-15).\n\nBy [unconfirmability of drives](concepts.md#c03), one may not write that A cries \"in order to be held\" as a confirmed fact. This example records A's crying as one [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28); what B faces is a set of [candidates](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c18): hungry, tired, wet, in pain, wanting to be held. B's attributing the crying to one of them can be B's [view attribution](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c02) (if B takes A's crying as a view of A) and can also be B's [impression](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c45) of A's [weight](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06); neither is a reading of A's state, and it is not guaranteed that an externally available criterion determines whether it is right or wrong. Why B picks these [candidates](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c18) comes from B's own [history](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13), and this paper does not trace it further. This section is a constraint-level conclusion.\n\nThis limit is not confined to infants. When a person says \"I do everything for my family\", others obtain an [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28), and the motive is the others' interpretation; by Premise 2, the person's own account is also only another [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18), not a complete description of the cause. This is a calibration and is not a source of derivation.\n\n```text\nStep 3-2-1: If this example records A's crying as one Output, then it is one Output (from definition of Output)\nStep 3-2-2: One may not write that A cries \"in order to be held\" as a confirmed fact (from Conclusion 2-15 + Conclusion 1-5)\nConclusion 3-2-3: When B attributes the crying to one of the Candidates, it can be a View Attribution of B (if B takes A's crying as a view of A), and it can also be B's Impression of A's Weight; neither is a reading of A's state, and it is not guaranteed that there is an externally available criterion that decides whether it is right or wrong (from Premise 5 + definition of View Attribution + definition of Impression + definition of Candidate + Conclusion 1-5)\nNote: Why B picks these Candidates comes from B's own History, and this paper does not trace it further.\nNote: The example \"I do everything for my family\" is a calibration and is not a source of derivation.\n```\n\n### 3.3 Trial and Error and Calibration\n\nThis section uses Component 2 and Component 5 (Conclusion 2-12, Conclusion 2-15).\n\nEach attempt by B, feeding, changing, holding, is, as long as it is not [locked in](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c12), a [forced wager](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c11): the result cannot be calculated precisely, cannot be taken back afterwards, and doing nothing is also a result. A's subsequent [outputs](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) are the new [arrivals](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) that B obtains, and B adjusts later attempts accordingly. Stopping crying is only one [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) of A and does not by itself constitute a test of the attribution: it is not guaranteed that why A cried and why A stopped can be confirmed from outside ([unconfirmability of drives](concepts.md#c03)), and it is not guaranteed that there is an externally available criterion for whether the attribution is right. B's [impression](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c45) may be stable, but stability does not mean being closer to the real A. B can take its own [view attribution](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c02) as a view and revise it; this is an asymmetric link in the [loop](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c31), which A does not have. This section is a constraint-level conclusion; the part concerning B's revising its attribution uses the [configuration assumption](concepts.md#c01) and is conditional.\n\n```text\nStep 3-3-1: Each attempt by B when not in Lock-in is a Forced Wager (from definition of Wo + definition of Decision + definition of Forced Wager)\nStep 3-3-2: If A's subsequent Outputs Arrive at B, they are new Arrivals that B receives, and B's subsequent trial Weights are affected by those Arrivals (from Conclusion 3-2-3 + definition of Arrival + definition of Wo)\nStep 3-3-2-2: If this example records stopping crying as one Output of A, then it is one Output of A (from definition of Output)\nConclusion 3-3-3: If this example records stopping crying as one Output of A, then it is only one Output of A and does not by itself constitute a test of the attribution: it is not guaranteed that why A cried and why A stopped can be confirmed from outside, and it is not guaranteed that there is an externally available criterion for whether the attribution is right (from Step 3-3-2-2 + Conclusion 3-2-3 + Conclusion 2-15)\nStep 3-3-4: B's Impression being stable does not mean being closer to the real A (from Conclusion 3-2-3 + Conclusion 2-12)\nConclusion 3-3-5: B can take its own attribution as a view and revise it, and A does not have this link (from Premise 5 + Conclusion 2-5 + Step 2-6)\nNote: Conclusion 3-3-5 is conditional and uses Premise 5.\n```\n\n### 3.4 Mismatch and Repair\n\nThis section uses Component 3, Component 4, and Component 5 (Conclusion 2-13, Conclusion 2-14, Conclusion 2-15).\n\nA [mismatch](concepts.md#c08) is, in a dimension and under a compatibility criterion specified by the researcher, the incompatibility of the adjacent [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) sequences of two [Selves](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19); a [repair](concepts.md#c09) is, after a [mismatch](concepts.md#c08), the renewed compatibility of the subsequent sequence in the same dimension and under the same criterion. The criterion looks at whether the sequences are compatible, not at whether either party \"wanted something and did not get it\" or \"had an expectation violated\"; those carry drives and, by [unconfirmability of drives](concepts.md#c03), are not written.\n\nIn this [loop](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c31) a [mismatch](concepts.md#c08) is not an occasional fault but a possibility that the structure does not exclude. Every time B makes a [view attribution](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c02) about A's crying and then acts, it is a [forced wager](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c11), and the attribution is [not guaranteed](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c02); if B's action and A's next [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) are incompatible under the specified criterion (for example, crying continues after feeding), this stretch of the sequence is a [mismatch](concepts.md#c08). This paragraph is a constraint-level conclusion.\n\nA [repair](concepts.md#c09) only indicates that the sequence is compatible again; it does not indicate that the attribution has been tested, nor that A \"got what A wanted\". Renewed compatibility of the sequence may come from B switching to another [candidate](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c18), from A's [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) itself changing, from a change in the [exogenous background](concepts.md#c02), or from a [random round](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c26), and the difference cannot necessarily be seen from the [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28). So a [repair](concepts.md#c09) is only a record, not a test, and has the same structure as \"stopping crying does not by itself constitute a test of the attribution\" in 3.3. This paragraph is a constraint-level conclusion.\n\nA [repair](concepts.md#c09) is not guaranteed after a [mismatch](concepts.md#c08). By the [Law of the Black Box](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c25), the next [moment](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c09) of a [Self](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19) that is not [locked in](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c12) cannot be uniquely derived in advance, so the subsequent sequence may become compatible again, may remain incompatible, or may turn into [outputs](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) of the kind of refusal, warning, and counteraction (see 4.6). By the [Law of Non-Restoration](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c28), [outputs](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) that have fallen out cannot be taken back; they remain in the [history](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13) of each side they have [arrived](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at and affect subsequent [weights](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06). Conversely, the absence of a [repair](concepts.md#c09) also does not imply that a [repair](concepts.md#c09) will never occur from now on: the [Law of the Black Box](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c25) likewise does not permit this assertion. This paragraph is a constraint-level conclusion.\n\nBy the [configuration assumption](concepts.md#c01), B can treat a [mismatch](concepts.md#c08) as a clue and go back to take its own attribution as a view and revise it; A does not have this link. So if the sequence becomes compatible again after a [mismatch](concepts.md#c08), when tracing the change one starts by looking at B's [outputs](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28), because only B's side has this link; this is an order of searching, not a determination that the cause is on B's side. This paragraph is a conditional conclusion and uses the [configuration assumption](concepts.md#c01).\n\nHaving no [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) does not mean having no effect. When B does not respond, that too is a result that falls out of B at this moment and [arrives](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at A when A notices it ([forced wager](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c11): not acting is also a result). So \"no response\" may not be written as \"nothing happened\". This paragraph is a constraint-level conclusion.\n\nWhere the sequence goes after a [mismatch](concepts.md#c08) is [not guaranteed](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c02): it may be a [repair](concepts.md#c09), and it may also be forgiveness, [conflict](concepts.md#c10), continued communication, and so on; if \"forgiveness\" is an attribution that some [Self](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19) makes about the sequence, then when spoken it is an [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28), not the compatibility of the sequence. So forgiveness does not imply a [repair](concepts.md#c09), and compatibility of the sequence does not imply that anyone forgave: a [repair](concepts.md#c09) looks only at the sequence, forgiveness is an attribution, and the two can occur independently. Whether forgiveness is genuine cannot be confirmed from outside by [unconfirmability of drives](concepts.md#c03), and feelings are not discussed in this paper. This paragraph is a constraint-level conclusion.\n\n5.1 in Section 5 uses the Still-Face paradigm as a calibration: that paradigm has B deliberately not respond for a period and then resume, which artificially changes the interaction sequence and may produce a [mismatch](concepts.md#c08) and the sequence after it, and then compares them using external records.\n\n```text\nNote: The criteria for Mismatch and Repair are specified by the researcher; they look at whether the sequences are compatible and not at drives.\nConclusion 3-4-1: Mismatch is a possibility that the structure of this Loop does not exclude (from Step 3-3-1 + definition of Mismatch + definition of Forced Wager)\nConclusion 3-4-2: Repair only indicates that the sequence is compatible again and does not indicate that the attribution has been tested (from definition of Repair + Conclusion 3-3-3)\nStep 3-4-3: Renewed compatibility of the sequence can come from B switching Candidates, from a change in A's Output, from a change in the Exogenous Background, or from a Random Round, and the difference cannot necessarily be seen from the Output (from Conclusion 2-13 + Premise 6 + definition of Random Round + definition of Candidate)\nStep 3-4-4: If the sequence becomes compatible again, B's Outputs are one place where the change can be traced, because B can look back and correct its own attribution and A has no such step (from Conclusion 3-3-5 + Premise 5)\nStep 3-4-5: Not responding is also a result and, when noticed by the other, Arrives at the other, so one may not write that no response means no effect (from definition of Forced Wager + definition of Arrival)\nStep 3-4-6: Outputs that have fallen out cannot be taken back, remain in the History of each side they have Arrived at, and affect subsequent Weights (from Conclusion 2-14 + definition of Weight + definition of Wo)\nConclusion 3-4-7: Repair is not guaranteed after a Mismatch, and it does not imply that a Repair will never occur from now on (from Conclusion 2-13 + definition of Mismatch + definition of Repair + Step 3-4-6)\nConclusion 3-4-8: After a Mismatch, where the sequence goes next is Not Guaranteed: it may be Repair, forgiveness, conflict, continued communication, and so on; if forgiveness is an attribution about the sequence, it does not imply a Repair, and a Repair does not imply forgiveness (from definition of Mismatch + definition of Repair + definition of View Attribution + Conclusion 2-15 + definition of Forced Wager)\nNote: Step 3-4-4 is an order of searching, not a determination that the cause is on B's side; it is conditional and uses Premise 5.\n```\n\n### 3.5 Construction of the Self and the Sources of Material\n\nThis section uses Component 1 and Component 3 (Conclusion 2-11, Conclusion 2-13).\n\nThe [construction of the self](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c28) is the process by which a [Self](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19) uses [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) to draw itself out, so the \"self\" is drawn out, not found. A has two sources of material for constructing itself, and both exist whether or not [second-order distinction](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c01) is present. The first is A's own [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28): by Premise 1, each [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) of A [arrives](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at A itself before the next [moment](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c09) (the self-feedback of Section 2). The second is B's [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) [arriving](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at A: it includes B's attribution about A, and also the part of the [exogenous background](concepts.md#c02) that reaches A by way of B, carrying B's errors and B's frame. The emergence of [second-order distinction](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c01) does not add a source of material; it only adds one link that treats one of one's own [distinctions](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) as a view and processes it again. The formulations that are excluded are: A discovers itself; the self is already there to begin with; B's saying \"you are hungry\" is a reading of A's inner state; A has no material of its own before having [second-order distinction](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c01). By the [wall of the blind spot](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c09), the very act of drawing that is now taking place cannot be seen, so what A sees is always only the self that has already been built. That both sources exist is a constraint-level conclusion; that B's attribution and frame, if they enter A's content by way of the [exogenous background](concepts.md#c02), carry B's possible errors, uses the [configuration assumption](concepts.md#c01) and the [exogenous background](concepts.md#c02) and is a conditional conclusion.\n\nThe material of a [Self](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19) can come from three places: [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) of external things; the [view attribution](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c02) and [impression](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c45) of others' [outputs](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28); and the further [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) of one of its own [distinctions](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18), the last of which only those with [second-order distinction](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c01) have. Whatever material exists from these places returns, by Premise 1, to that [Self](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19) itself and enters its [weight](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06) at the next [moment](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c09). As the number of interactions increases, material increases, but there is no guarantee that all three of these places improve at the same time, no guarantee that the [impression](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c45) approaches the other, and the other's true [weight](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06) does not become readable. Having the ability does not equal using it this time (Section 2). This paragraph is a constraint-level conclusion.\n\nThe self-concept of an adult also has two sources, as in 3.5: one's own [outputs](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) return to oneself, and the [outputs](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) of others (including others' attributions about oneself) [arrive](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at oneself. An adult has [second-order distinction](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c01); if it takes others' attributions about oneself as views and makes a further [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) of them, that remains a [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) of its own, without having to adopt them directly; but having the ability does not imply being used this time, nor that what is seen is the whole of oneself (the [Law of Attrition](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c26), the [wall of the blind spot](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c09)). This paragraph is a constraint-level conclusion.\n\nA child seeing a caregiver pick up a coat and walk to the door, and then walking to the door too, offers a short calibration: the past experience of going out is material in the [history](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13), and walking to the door is the [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28). Whether the child is excited or uneasy is not written, by [unconfirmability of drives](concepts.md#c03); whether the next time will be the same is also [not guaranteed](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c02) (the [Law of the Black Box](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c25)). This is a calibration and is not a source of derivation.\n\n```text\nStep 3-5-1: A's own Output returns to A and can become material for A's own construction (from Conclusion 2-11 + definition of Construction of the Self)\nStep 3-5-2: B's Output Arrives at A and can become another piece of material for A's own construction (from definition of Arrival + definition of Construction of the Self)\nConclusion 3-5-3: Both sources exist whether or not Second-Order Distinction is present; Second-Order Distinction adds only one processing link (from Step 3-5-1 + Step 3-5-2 + Conclusion 2-5)\nStep 3-5-4: If B's attribution and frame enter A's content by way of the Exogenous Background, they carry B's possible errors (from Premise 5 + Premise 6 + Conclusion 3-2-3)\nStep 3-5-5: What A sees is always only the self that has already been built (from Wall of the Blind Spot)\nNote: Step 3-5-4 is conditional and uses Premise 5 and Premise 6.\nStep 3-5-6: The material of a Self can come from three places: Distinction of external things; the View Attribution and Impression of others' Outputs; and the further Distinction of one's own earlier Distinction, and the third place is available only to those with Second-Order Distinction (from Conclusion 2-11 + Conclusion 2-5 + definition of View Attribution + definition of Impression + definition of Distinction + definition of Construction of the Self)\nStep 3-5-7: Whatever material exists from these places returns to that Self itself and enters its Weight at the next Moment (from Conclusion 2-11 + Premise 1 + definition of View Attribution)\nConclusion 3-5-8: As the number of interactions increases, material increases, but there is no guarantee that all three places improve at the same time, no guarantee that Impression approaches the other, and the other's true Weight does not become readable (from Step 3-3-4 + Step 3-5-6 + Step 3-5-7 + Conclusion 2-13 + Conclusion 2-12 + Step 2-16-2)\nConclusion 3-5-9: The self-concept of a Self with Second-Order Distinction (such as an adult) has two sources; if it takes others' attributions about itself as views and Distinguishes them further, that remains a Distinction of its own; having the ability does not imply using it this time, nor that the whole of oneself is seen (from Conclusion 3-5-3 + Conclusion 2-5 + Law of Attrition + definition of Wall of the Blind Spot + definition of Second-Order Distinction + definition of View Attribution)\nNote: The example of a child seeing an adult pick up a coat is a calibration and is not a source of derivation.\n```\n\n### 3.6 The Boundary Where Second Order Emerges\n\nThis section does not use any component directly; it uses only the [configuration assumption](concepts.md#c01) and definitions.\n\nThis paper does not explain where [second-order distinction](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c01) comes from, does not claim that it necessarily emerges at some moment, and certainly does not derive it from the quality of care. It writes only conditional sentences: if a link emerges in A's [loop](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c31) that treats its own [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) as a view and A can make [view attribution](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c02) about the [outputs](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) of others, then the [loops](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c31) on both sides are symmetric in capability configuration; the [three questions](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c07) open up to A; A remains within the [illusion](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c14); and only then can A enter the structure of Theme Two. The emergence itself is an empirical description and cannot be derived. This section is a constraint-level conditional conclusion.\n\n```text\nNote: The emergence of Second-Order Distinction is an empirical description; this paper does not explain it and does not claim that it necessarily emerges.\nConclusion 3-6-1: Implies(A acquires Second-Order Distinction and View Attribution, the Loops on both sides are symmetric in capability configuration) (from Conclusion 2-5 + definition of Second-Order Network + definition of View Attribution + Premise 5 + Conclusion 2-11)\nConclusion 3-6-2: Implies(A acquires Second-Order Distinction and View Attribution, Three Questions open up to A) (from definition of Three Questions + definition of Second-Order Distinction)\nConclusion 3-6-3: Implies(A acquires Second-Order Distinction and View Attribution, A remains within the Illusion) (from definition of Illusion + Step 2-8 + Step 3-5-5)\n```\n\n### 3.7 Comparison\n\nThis section does not use any component directly; it uses only the [configuration assumption](concepts.md#c01) and definitions.\n\nAdults whose [second-order distinction](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c01) status is uncertain serve only as a reference comparison. Conditions differ enormously; from outside one can neither confirm that [second-order distinction](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c01) is present at a given moment nor prove that it is absent, so nothing is derived from a diagnosis and no permanent label is attached; in every case the comparison is made only as a [configuration assumption](concepts.md#c01).\n\n## 4. Theme Two: Coupling and Tacit Coordination among Selves with Second-Order Distinction\n\n### 4.1 Symmetric Loops, the Second-Order Network, and Edges Involving an Infant\n\nThis section uses Component 2 (Conclusion 2-12).\n\nIf [second-order distinction](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c01) and [view attribution](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c02) emerge in A after the assumed stage, the [loops](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c31) on both sides are symmetric in capability configuration: each [Self](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19) has its own small [loop](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c31), can treat one of its own [distinctions](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) as a view and make a further [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) of it, and can also make [view attributions](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c02) about the [outputs](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) of others. There may be two participants, or three, four, or five. This section is a constraint-level conclusion.\n\nA [second-order network](concepts.md#c04) is a set formed by [Selves](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19) that have [second-order distinction](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c01) and [view attribution](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c02), together with the [couplings](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c36) between them: one [Self](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19) makes a [view attribution](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c02) about the [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) of another [Self](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19), and does not merely react to it as one [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28); each participant, at the moment of participating, has both [second-order distinction](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c01) and [view attribution](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c02), and neither can be missing. These two acts differ: the object of [second-order distinction](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c01) is one's own [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18), the object of [view attribution](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c02) is the [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) of another, and having one does not guarantee having the other. There are at least two participants, but they need not be present at the same time: the party who writes down content is a participant at the moment of writing, and later [exit](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c43) does not affect this. The regularities that the network forms in [history](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13), including norms and institutions, are its patterns and not another kind of entity.\n\nTherefore, a person alone in a house, reading the words that others left behind and recalling what someone once said, as long as the person classifies that content as the other's view, can also take the person's own understanding of it as a view, and the person who left the words also had [second-order distinction](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c01) and [view attribution](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c02) when writing, is within a [second-order network](concepts.md#c04) at that moment. This paper does not draw a separate node for an absent other; the other's [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) has already [arrived](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at this person and entered the person's [history](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13), and is covered by the person's own [history](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13) and the [exogenous background](concepts.md#c02).\n\nStructural symmetry does not imply symmetry of [arrival](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) or [weight](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06). Two [Selves](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19) that both have [second-order distinction](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c01) each obtain only [own segment](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c17) that [arrives](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at themselves (Premise 4), and the content, moment, and error of what they obtain may differ. This paragraph is a constraint-level conclusion.\n\nThe patterns of a [second-order network](concepts.md#c04), such as norms and institutions, are not causes. They are regularities accumulated in [history](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13), and they can act on the [weight](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06) of a [Self](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19) only by way of concrete [arrivals](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10); to say that a pattern \"brought about\" an [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28), one must point out which [arrival](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10). This paragraph is a constraint-level conclusion.\n\nWhen a [second-order network](concepts.md#c04) contains both A, who has only [first-order distinction](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c24), and members who have [second-order distinction](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c01), each edge must be judged separately: the edge on which A sits is a [coupling](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c36), but A's end does not have [second-order distinction](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c01), so this edge does not belong to the [second-order network](concepts.md#c04); only an edge whose two ends each have [second-order distinction](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c01) and [view attribution](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c02) at the moment of participating belongs. The judgment is based on the moment of participation, and no permanent label is attached. Whether a given [Self](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19) has both at a given moment cannot be confirmed from outside; by the [configuration assumption](concepts.md#c01) it is [not guaranteed](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c02) and can only be assumed.\n\n```text\nStep 4-1-1: If A acquires Second-Order Distinction and View Attribution, each Self has its own small Loop, can treat one of its own Distinctions as a view and Distinguish it further, and can also make View Attributions about the Outputs of others (from Conclusion 2-5 + Conclusion 2-11 + definition of Second-Order Network + definition of View Attribution + Premise 5)\nConclusion 4-1-2: A person alone, reading the words that others left behind, classifying the content as the other's view and also able to take its own understanding of that content as a view, while the person who left the words also had Second-Order Distinction and View Attribution when writing, is within a Second-Order Network at that moment (from definition of Second-Order Network + definition of View Attribution + definition of Second-Order Distinction + definition of Exit)\nStep 4-1-3: Structural symmetry does not imply symmetry of Arrival or Weight (from Conclusion 2-12 + definition of Arrival)\nStep 4-1-4: The effect of patterns of a Second-Order Network on a Self's Weight works only through concrete Arrivals (from Conclusion 2-12 + definition of Weight + definition of Second-Order Network + definition of Wo)\nNote: As to the effect of patterns such as norms and institutions of a Second-Order Network on a Self, this paper tracks only the part that works through concrete Arrivals and Weight and does not posit them as independent causes.\nNote: This paper does not draw a separate node for an absent other; the other's Output has already Arrived at this person and entered the person's History.\nNote: The regularities that a Second-Order Network forms in History, including norms and institutions, are its patterns and not another kind of entity.\nConclusion 4-1-5: Under the small-scale-acquaintance setting, the edge on which A sits is a Coupling, but A's end has no Second-Order Distinction, so this edge does not belong to the Second-Order Network (from Premise 5 + Premise 9 + definition of Coupling + definition of Second-Order Network)\nStep 4-1-6: Only an edge whose two ends each have both Second-Order Distinction and View Attribution at the moment of participating belongs to the Second-Order Network (from definition of Second-Order Network)\nStep 4-1-7: Confirming from outside whether a Self has these two at a given moment is not guaranteed; this paper makes a Configuration Assumption about the two (from definition of Configuration Assumption + definition of Not Guaranteed + Premise 5)\nNote: Step 4-1-7 is conditional and uses Premise 5.\n```\n\n### 4.2 Multiple Selves Interweaving\n\nThis section uses Component 1, Component 2, and Component 3 (Conclusion 2-11, Conclusion 2-12, Conclusion 2-13).\n\nEach [Self](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19) is at the same time part of the [loops](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c31) of others: B's [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) can [arrive](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at C and D at the same time, and B's attribution about C and B's attribution about D each return to B itself. Not every pair of nodes need have a [dedicated history](concepts.md#c05); which pairs have one is determined by data, and the structure says only that it is allowed. This section is a constraint-level conclusion, but which pairs actually have one is conditional.\n\nAs the number of people increases, there is no guarantee that the proportion of the whole [history](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13) that [arrives](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at each [Self](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19) rises. By Premise 4, the [own segment](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c17) of each [Self](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19) always has a part that has not [arrived](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at others, so more [loops](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c31) does not mean more transparent. The formulations that are excluded are: the more nodes, the necessarily more complex; familiarity makes the other transparent.\n\nA [second-order network](concepts.md#c04) is not guaranteed to become a subject that grasps the [history](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13) of all its members merely because it has many people. By the [Law of the Black Box](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c25), as long as one of the [Selves](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19) in it is not [locked in](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c12), the next step of that [Self](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19) cannot be uniquely derived in advance; by Premise 4, no position can obtain the [own segment](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c17) of all members. So whoever makes predictions about the whole network obtains only part of what [arrives](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at each [Self](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19) in it and is subject to the same limits; this does not imply that aggregate quantities of the network are unpredictable. This paragraph is a constraint-level conclusion.\n\n```text\nStep 4-2-1: B's Output can Arrive at C and D at the same time, and B's attribution about C and B's attribution about D each return to B itself (from Conclusion 2-11 + Premise 1 + definition of Arrival + definition of View Attribution)\nNote: Not every pair of nodes need have a Dedicated History; which pairs have one is determined by data and is conditional.\nStep 4-2-2: As the number of people increases, there is no guarantee that the proportion of the whole History that Arrives at each Self rises (from Conclusion 2-12)\nStep 4-2-3: More Loops does not mean more transparent (from Step 4-2-2 + Conclusion 2-11)\nConclusion 4-2-4: A Second-Order Network is not guaranteed to become a subject that grasps the History of all members merely because it has many people (from Conclusion 2-13 + Conclusion 2-12)\nStep 4-2-5: Whoever makes predictions about the whole network obtains only part of what Arrives at each Self in it and cannot grasp the History of all members merely because there are many; this does not imply that aggregate quantities of the network are unpredictable (from Conclusion 4-2-4 + Conclusion 2-12)\nStep 4-2-6: As long as one Self in it is not Locked-in, that Self's next Moment cannot be uniquely derived in advance (from Conclusion 2-13)\n```\n\n### 4.3 Negotiation of Attribution\n\nThis section uses Component 5 (Conclusion 2-15).\n\nBy [unconfirmability of drives](concepts.md#c03), attributions among family members are likewise only attributions. What [second-order distinction](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c01) brings as a new act is that a [view attribution](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c02) can be brought out and negotiated. When A says to B \"you misunderstood me\", this example records this sentence as one [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) of A; after it [arrives](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at B, B's [view attribution](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c02) about it is still only a [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) of B (Premise 2). So negotiation does not guarantee successful correction, and it does not guarantee that either side can confirm the other's drives. The function of [second-order distinction](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c01) is not to see through motives but to let an attribution be brought out as a view. This section is a constraint-level conclusion.\n\n```text\nStep 4-3-1: An attribution can be brought out and negotiated (from definition of Second-Order Distinction + definition of Second-Order Network + Conclusion 2-5 + definition of Output)\nStep 4-3-2: This example records A's saying \"you misunderstood me\" as one Output of A; after it Arrives at B, the View Attribution B makes about it is still a Distinction of B (from Premise 2 + definition of Arrival + definition of View Attribution + definition of Output)\nConclusion 4-3-3: Negotiation does not guarantee successful correction, and it does not guarantee that either side can confirm the other's drives (from Step 4-3-2 + Conclusion 2-15 + Conclusion 1-5)\n```\n\n### 4.4 Adding Nodes: Third Parties and New Members\n\nThis section uses Component 2, Component 3, Component 4, and Component 5 (Conclusion 2-12, Conclusion 2-13, Conclusion 2-14, Conclusion 2-15).\n\nWhen D is added to the [loop](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c31) that has only B and C, each [Self](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19) still has its own small [loop](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c31). Between two participants there is at most one edge, so the number of edges does not exceed the number of nodes times the number of nodes minus one, divided by two. Knowing three people does not mean that the three know one another, so how many edges actually exist is determined by data. Under the setting that in a small-scale group of acquaintances everyone knows everyone (Premise 9), there is an edge between every two participants, and the number of edges grows faster than the number of nodes. Which edges actually carry a [dedicated history](concepts.md#c05) is likewise determined by data. The upper bound on the number of edges is a constraint-level conclusion; that every two have an edge uses Premise 9, and whether an edge carries a [dedicated history](concepts.md#c05) is conditional.\n\nB's same [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) [arriving](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at C and [arriving](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at D constitutes two different [arrivals](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10): C and D each carry their own [history](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13) and each make a [view attribution](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c02), and the two may differ; B's attribution about C and B's attribution about D also each return to B itself. Certain [outputs](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) between B and C may never [arrive](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at D, so D is [not guaranteed](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c02) to obtain the complete [dedicated history](concepts.md#c05) between B and C. This is what can be written in the model about what is commonly called \"being excluded\": certain [outputs](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) did not [arrive](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10). Why they did not, by [unconfirmability of drives](concepts.md#c03), cannot be written as someone's deliberate doing. This paragraph is a constraint-level conclusion.\n\nIf C relays B's words to D and this relay is recorded as an [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) of C, then it is a new [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) of C, not a copy of B's original [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28); if C takes B's sentence as one of B's views, this [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) carries C's [view attribution](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c02). By Premise 2 and Premise 4, a relay cannot pass on B's own segment in full. So the person in the middle who passes words along changes the material that D obtains and does not make D and B [arrive](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at each other directly. Whether there is a person in the middle in a given network is conditional.\n\nWhen a new member A enters a [second-order network](concepts.md#c04) in which B and C already have a [dedicated history](concepts.md#c05), A and B, and A and C, start from zero in the dimensions where there was no two-way [arrival](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) before (3.1); the existing [dedicated history](concepts.md#c05) of B and C is not thereby reset to zero, nor does it thereby become A's (the [Law of Non-Restoration](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c28)). After A joins, the subsequent [outputs](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) between B and C can [arrive](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at A, and the [loops](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c31) and [history](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13) of B and C are not a static extension of what they were before A joined (the [Law of Flux](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c24)). This paragraph is a constraint-level conclusion.\n\nDevelopment changes the dimensions in which A can participate, for example movement, voice, and language. An increase in the dimensions available for participation does not mean that [outputs](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) in those dimensions have occurred, nor that a [dedicated history](concepts.md#c05) already exists. This paragraph is a conditional conclusion, and the empirical antecedent it uses is that development changes the conditions of participation (Premise 8).\n\n```text\nPremise 8: Development changes the dimensions in which A can participate.\nNote: Premise 8 is an empirical antecedent used as an input to derivation.\nPremise 9: Under the setting of a small-scale group of acquaintances, every two participants know each other, that is, there is a Coupling between every two participants.\nNote: Premise 9 is a scoping assumption and not a claim about the general case; knowing three people does not mean that the three know one another.\nStep 4-4-0: An edge is a pair of participants with a Coupling; nodes pair up two by two, giving number of nodes × (number of nodes - 1) ÷ 2 pairs, so the number of edges does not exceed this number (from definition of Coupling)\nStep 4-4-0-1: Under the setting of Premise 9, every pair has a Coupling, the number of edges = number of nodes × (number of nodes - 1) ÷ 2, which grows faster than the number of nodes (from Premise 9 + Step 4-4-0)\nStep 4-4-1: B's same Output Arriving at C and Arriving at D constitutes two different Arrivals (from definition of Arrival + Premise 4)\nStep 4-4-2: Certain Outputs between B and C may never Arrive at D, so D is Not Guaranteed to obtain the complete Dedicated History between B and C (from Conclusion 2-12 + definition of Dedicated History + Conclusion 2-14 + definition of Not Guaranteed)\nConclusion 4-4-3: What can be written about \"being excluded\" in the model is that certain Outputs did not Arrive; why they did not cannot be written as someone's deliberate doing (from Step 4-4-2 + Conclusion 2-15)\nStep 4-4-4: If C passes B's words to D and this relay is recorded as an Output of C, then it is a new Output of C and not a copy of B's original Output; if C takes B's sentence as one of B's views, this Output carries C's View Attribution (from Premise 2 + Conclusion 2-12 + definition of Output + definition of View Attribution)\nStep 4-4-4-1: C passing B's words to D, if the relay is recorded as a new Output of C, is not a direct Arrival of B at D; what D receives is a new Output of C (from Step 4-4-4 + definition of Arrival)\nConclusion 4-4-5: A relay cannot pass on B's own segment in full (from Step 4-4-4 + Conclusion 2-12 + Premise 4)\nStep 4-4-6: The new member A and an existing member both start from zero in a stated dimension if there has been no two-way Arrival in it before (from definition of Dedicated History + Conclusion 2-14)\nConclusion 4-4-7: The existing Dedicated History of B and C is not thereby reset to zero, nor does it thereby become A's (from Conclusion 2-14 + definition of Dedicated History)\nStep 4-4-8: After A joins, the subsequent Outputs between B and C can Arrive at A, and the Loops and History of B and C are not a static extension of what they were before A joined (from Conclusion 2-13 + definition of Arrival)\nStep 4-4-9: An increase in the dimensions available for participation does not mean that Outputs in those dimensions have occurred, nor that a Dedicated History already exists (from Premise 8 + definition of Dedicated History + Conclusion 2-14)\nNote: Step 4-4-9 is conditional and uses Premise 8; whether there is a person in the middle who passes words along is determined by data.\n```\n\n### 4.5 Removing Nodes: Exit, Termination of an Individual, and Continuation of Patterns\n\nThis section uses Component 2 and Component 4 (Conclusion 2-12, Conclusion 2-14).\n\nAfter a [Self](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19) makes its [exit](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c43), the [outputs](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) it has already [arrived](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at others remain in others' [history](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13); the part it did not [arrive](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at others does not [arrive](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) because of the [exit](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c43); whether it can still [arrive](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) is [not guaranteed](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c02) (Premise 4, the [Law of Non-Restoration](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c28)). When an individual terminates, if the individual's later position is no longer a [Wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16) at the next [moment](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c09), it is an [exit](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c43); the part that has already occurred and [arrived](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at others remains. This paragraph is a constraint-level conclusion.\n\nEven if a later person makes the same movements, it is a new occurrence at a new position (the [Law of Non-Restoration](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c28)) and not a [restoration](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c27) of that person's segment. If the same practice recurs in later people, one can study whether it shows [convergence](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c37) or [stasis](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c52) in a dimension, but the dimension must be stated. To claim \"the same pattern continues\", one must list traceable participants, [outputs](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28), records, or rules; the same name, or a similar appearance, is not enough. This paragraph is a constraint-level conclusion; which patterns actually continue is conditional.\n\nA [second-order network](concepts.md#c04) is composed of participants and their [couplings](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c36). When participants are replaced, this definition gives no criterion for saying whether the network before and after the replacement is still the same network. So replacement of members implies neither that the network vanishes nor that it continues; to claim either, one must first list a criterion and traceable material. This paper does not give this criterion.\n\n```text\nStep 4-5-1: After a Self makes its Exit, the Outputs it has already Arrived at others remain in others' History (from definition of Exit + Conclusion 2-14)\nStep 4-5-2: The part of it that has not Arrived at others does not Arrive because of the Exit; whether it can still Arrive is not guaranteed (from Conclusion 2-12 + Conclusion 2-14 + definition of Not Guaranteed)\nConclusion 4-5-3: When an individual terminates, if the individual's later position is no longer a Wo at the next Moment, it is an Exit; the part that has already occurred and Arrived at others remains (from Step 4-5-1 + Step 4-5-2 + definition of Exit)\nStep 4-5-4: A later person making the same movements is a new occurrence at a new position and not a restoration of that person's segment (from Conclusion 2-14)\nNote: To claim that the same pattern continues, one must list traceable participants, Outputs, records, or rules; the same name or similarity is not enough. Which patterns actually continue is determined by data.\nConclusion 4-5-5: Replacement of members implies neither that the network vanishes nor that it continues (from definition of Second-Order Network)\nNote: The definition of Second-Order Network gives no criterion for whether the network before and after a replacement of participants is still the same network.\n```\n\n### 4.6 Misplaced Attribution: Conflict, Counteraction, and the Labels of Attribution\n\nThis section uses Component 3 and Component 5 (Conclusion 2-13, Conclusion 2-15).\n\nTwo [Selves](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19) may attribute the same [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) inconsistently, as already seen in 4.2 and 4.3. After the attributions are misplaced, the sequence may move toward negotiation (4.3), toward [repair](concepts.md#c09) after a [mismatch](concepts.md#c08) (3.4), or toward [conflict](concepts.md#c10) (defined in 4.8). A failure to match is not the same as [conflict](concepts.md#c10): a [mismatch](concepts.md#c08) is that one side's [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) did not connect, which can be on one side only and need not have opposite directions; [conflict](concepts.md#c10) requires that the directions of the two sides be opposite, that each target the other's [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28), and that they strengthen each other (4.8). Refusal, warning, and counteraction are all [outputs](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28), and enter the same [history](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13) together with other [outputs](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28); [conflict](concepts.md#c10) is the structure formed when the two sides' [outputs](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) of this kind target one another, and is not a further [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28). What can be recorded is the statements, the actions, and what follows; from these one cannot fill in the complete inner purpose of either side ([unconfirmability of drives](concepts.md#c03)), nor, because it is [conflict](concepts.md#c10), infer that there is no [tacit coordination](concepts.md#c06) (see 4.7). This paragraph is a constraint-level conclusion.\n\n[Conflict](concepts.md#c10) begins after [arrival](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10). Refusal, warning, and counteraction are all subsequent [outputs](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) made against [outputs](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) that have already [arrived](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10); if between two [Selves](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19) neither side's [outputs](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) have ever [arrived](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at the other, and none have [arrived](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) by way of being relayed by someone else, there is no [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) that they can target at one another, and so no [conflict](concepts.md#c10). Therefore, toward a stranger one has never seen and never heard of, [conflict](concepts.md#c10) is impossible; toward someone one has only heard about through relays, [conflict](concepts.md#c10) can occur, and its starting point is the relayed [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) [arriving](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10), not the other person. [Conflict](concepts.md#c10) is a pattern on the sequence after [arrival](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10), not a property brought by one side. This paragraph is a constraint-level conclusion, writing only a necessary condition and not how [conflict](concepts.md#c10) arises.\n\nA sequence can be attributed by some [Self](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19) as \"deception\" or \"coercion\". If a sequence is taken as the other's view, these two words are the content of a [view attribution](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c02), of the same structure as \"he cries because he is hungry\" in 3.2: what the speaker has is the other's [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) and the subsequent records, and \"he knows the facts and deliberately misleads\" or \"he has no other choice\" is the speaker's own [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18). This does not say that reality contains no deception or coercion; it says that if these two words point to the inner state and drives of an other that is not in [lock in](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c12), then by [unconfirmability of drives](concepts.md#c03) they cannot be confirmed from outside; what is judged by public behavior, procedure, or external constraints is excepted. This attribution, once voiced, is itself an [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28); the part that [arrives](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at others enters their [history](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13) and takes part in their subsequent [weight](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06), so it has an effect in the [loop](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c31); but whether it is correct, the model does not adjudicate. The feeling of being deceived and the feeling of being coerced belong to inner states and are not discussed in this paper. This paragraph is a constraint-level conclusion.\n\nWhen a researcher uses these two words, it is a [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) that the researcher, as a [Self](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19), makes about the sequence, and it can be a [view attribution](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c02) and can also be an [impression](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c45) of the other's [weight](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06); it is not read off from data, and the text must state who made the attribution. The outward descriptions a researcher can write include two: a certain [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) does not agree with the subsequent record; one side issues an instruction and the other side carries it out. These two descriptions do not guarantee that one can separate deception from misreporting, or coercion from voluntariness: a disagreement may come from misremembering, misunderstanding, or being misled by others (the [Law of Attrition](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c26), the [illusion](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c14)), and carrying out may be a choice made when not [locked in](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c12) (the [Law of the Black Box](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c25)). This paragraph is a constraint-level conclusion.\n\nThe same approach applies to every word that points to the other's inner state or motive. \"Trust\" is an [impression](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c45) that some [Self](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19) infers from the other's [outputs](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) about roughly how the other's [weight](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06) stands toward oneself; \"sense of security\" and \"anxiety\" are attributions that some [Self](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19) makes about the sequence after a [mismatch](concepts.md#c08) and about the pattern of its own subsequent [outputs](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28), and the feeling itself is not discussed; \"promise\" is an attribution that one [Self](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19) makes about its own and the other's future [outputs](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28), and it is spoken aloud, and speaking aloud is an [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28), not a guarantee; \"fairness\" is an attribution made about [impact](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c47) and the sequence, [impact](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c47) cannot be added up, and there is no externally available ledger; \"emotional contagion and co-regulation\" is an attribution that a researcher makes about the [convergence](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c37) of the pattern of the two sides' [outputs](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28), and the feeling itself is not discussed; \"social support\" is an attribution made about one side's [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28), and its effect can be seen only from the subsequent sequence. Whether what these words point to is true cannot, by [unconfirmability of drives](concepts.md#c03), be confirmed from outside, and the model does not adjudicate; the model asks only what they do after entering the [loop](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c31): once voiced, the [view attribution](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c02) is itself an [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28), and the part that [arrives](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at others enters their [history](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13) and takes part in their subsequent [weight](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06). Acting on such an attribution is a [forced wager](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c11), and the result after acting is not a test of the attribution. When a researcher uses these words, it is likewise a [view attribution](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c02), and the text must state who made it. This paragraph is a constraint-level conclusion.\n\nWhether the other's segment here is a [decision](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c06) can only be assumed from outside; what can overturn the assumption is finding a mechanism that proves that the other's segment here can only come out of a [locked-in round](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c25) or a [random round](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c26). In that case the other's [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) in this segment is not a [decision](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c06), and this edge at that moment cannot be counted as a [decision](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c06) made by the other's [second-order distinction](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c01) (4.1); it does not follow that the other lacks [second-order distinction](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c01), nor whether the edge belongs to the [second-order network](concepts.md#c04) at other moments. Merely seeing compliance does not constitute this proof. This paragraph is a constraint-level conclusion.\n\nCalibration: in daily life, when one says \"I trust him\", what bystanders can see is how he entrusts and how he acts; whether he truly trusts is a guess on the bystanders' part. The model's wording agrees with this. This is only a comparison with daily life and not a source of derivation.\n\n```text\nStep 4-6-1: Refusal, warning, and counteraction, if recorded as Outputs that Arrive at the other, enter the same History; Conflict is the structure formed when the two sides' Outputs of this kind are opposite in direction, Arrive at each other, target one another, and reinforce each other, and is not a further Output (from definition of Output + definition of History + definition of Conflict)\nStep 4-6-2: From these one cannot fill in the complete inner purpose of either side (from Conclusion 2-15)\nStep 4-6-12: Mismatch is that one side's Output did not connect, which can be on one side only and need not have opposite directions; Conflict requires that the directions of the two sides be opposite and that each target the other's Output, so the two differ (from definition of Mismatch + definition of Conflict)\nConclusion 4-6-10: Without any Arrival (including Arrival by way of being relayed by someone else), there is no Conflict between two Selves (from definition of Conflict + definition of Arrival)\nNote: Conclusion 4-6-10 writes only a necessary condition and not how Conflict arises; it uses \"refusal, warning, and counteraction are subsequent Outputs made against Outputs that have already Arrived\", which is what these words mean.\nStep 4-6-3: A Self may describe the sequence as \"deception\" or \"coercion\"; this is a Distinction by that Self, may also be an Impression of the other's Weight, and if it takes the sequence as the other's view, it is the content of a View Attribution (from definition of View Attribution + definition of Impression)\nStep 4-6-4: If these two words point to the inner state and drives of a Self that is not Locked-in, they cannot be confirmed from outside; what is judged by public behavior, procedure, or external constraints is excepted (from Conclusion 1-5 + Conclusion 2-15)\nStep 4-6-5: This attribution, once voiced, is itself an Output, and the part that Arrives at others enters their History and takes part in their subsequent Weights (from definition of Output + definition of Arrival + definition of Weight + definition of Wo)\nStep 4-6-6: When a researcher uses these two words, it can be the researcher's View Attribution and can also be the researcher's Impression of the other's Weight (from definition of View Attribution + definition of Impression)\nConclusion 4-6-7: From outward description alone, it is not guaranteed that one can tell deception from misreporting, or coercion from voluntariness; whether other material such as public constraints or on-site evidence can distinguish them is not guaranteed (from Law of Attrition + definition of Illusion + Conclusion 2-13 + definition of Not Guaranteed)\nStep 4-6-8: Whether the other's segment here is a Decision can only be assumed and is Not Guaranteed to be confirmable from outside; what can overturn the assumption is finding a mechanism that proves that the other's segment here can only fall out of Locked-in Rounds or Random Rounds (from Premise 3 + definition of Decision + definition of Computation + definition of Locked-in Round + definition of Random Round + Premise 2 + Conclusion 1-5 + definition of Not Guaranteed)\nConclusion 4-6-11: Words that point to the other's inner state or motive (trust, sense of security, anxiety, promise, fairness, emotional contagion and co-regulation, social support) can be a Distinction, a View Attribution, or an Impression of Weight of some Self or of the researcher; words that refer to public speech, procedures, or visible assistance are not covered here; once voiced, they are Outputs, and the part that Arrives at others enters their History and takes part in their subsequent Weights; the model does not adjudicate whether they are true, and acting on them, when not in Lock-in, is a Forced Wager (from definition of View Attribution + definition of Impression + definition of Impact + Conclusion 2-15 + definition of Forced Wager + Step 4-6-5)\nConclusion 4-6-9: In that case the other's Output in this segment is not a Decision, and this edge at this moment cannot be counted as a decision made by the other's Second-Order Distinction; it does not follow that the other lacks Second-Order Distinction, nor whether the edge belongs to the Second-Order Network at other moments (from Step 4-6-8 + Step 4-1-6 + Premise 3 + definition of Second-Order Distinction)\nNote: The calibration in this section is only a comparison with daily life and is not a source of derivation.\n```\n\n### 4.7 Accumulation of History: Tacit Coordination\n\nThis section uses Component 2, Component 3, Component 4, and Component 5 (Conclusion 2-12, Conclusion 2-13, Conclusion 2-14, Conclusion 2-15).\n\n[Tacit coordination](concepts.md#c06) is, in a specified type of situation and dimension, where two [Selves](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19) have gone through a repeated [dedicated history](concepts.md#c05), a behavioral pattern that, in comparable situations, can still continue compatibly without having to be guided item by item each time. The criterion is [history](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13) and behavioral pattern, not prediction: it does not require either side to compute the other's next step in advance (the [Law of the Black Box](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c25)), does not require friendliness, does not require mutual transparency, and does not require a stable [impression](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c45). A large number of interactions does not mean that [tacit coordination](concepts.md#c06) already exists; more interactions only add comparable material. This paragraph is a constraint-level definition and exclusion; whether a given two people have [tacit coordination](concepts.md#c06) in a given dimension is conditional.\n\n[Tacit coordination](concepts.md#c06) is also not classified by moral stance. If hostile parties, in a specified comparable situation, repeatedly show compatible continuations of the kind warning-and-yielding or probing-and-defending, without having to redo complete guidance, they meet [tacit coordination](concepts.md#c06) within that scope; from this one does not infer friendliness, trust, common interest, or genuine understanding. Repeated hostility that does not meet the criterion cannot be registered as [tacit coordination](concepts.md#c06) merely by the number of years of association. To compare who has more [tacit coordination](concepts.md#c06) with whom, the comparison must be made under the same dimension, time window, and acceptance data; it cannot be inferred that enemies in general have more or less [tacit coordination](concepts.md#c06). This paragraph is a constraint-level conclusion.\n\nThe number of counterparts with whom a [Self](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19) newly acquires [tacit coordination](concepts.md#c06) within a stated time window has an upper limit. Suppose the [arrivals](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) it can receive within this window are limited, and a [dedicated history](concepts.md#c05) needs repeated [arrivals](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) in comparable situations; and the [dedicated history](concepts.md#c05) with different counterparts each needs its own [arrivals](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) (the same [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) arriving at different counterparts is a different arrival); then the number of counterparts cannot increase without limit. How large the upper limit is cannot be derived: [impact](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c47) cannot be added up, and the same [arrival](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) has different effects on different [Selves](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19), so when this is used the assumptions about [frequency](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c48) and [discrepancy](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c49) must be written out. The more people one has contact with, the fewer repeated [arrivals](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) each pair gets, and the harder it is for [impressions](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c45) to become stable; this is an empirical description. Without a sufficiently repeated [dedicated history](concepts.md#c05) there will be no [tacit coordination](concepts.md#c06); this is an [empirical prohibition](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c51), writing only a necessary condition, and can be modified by new cases; conversely, long-term coexistence does not guarantee [tacit coordination](concepts.md#c06). This paragraph is a conditional conclusion, and the empirical antecedent it uses is that the [arrivals](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) each [Self](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19) can receive within a period of time are limited (Premise 10).\n\nOnce [tacit coordination](concepts.md#c06) has formed, it is not guaranteed to continue. By the [Law of Flux](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c24) and the [Law of the Black Box](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c25), past compatible continuations do not [lock in](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c12) the next continuation; whether it continues depends on new [arrivals](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10). This paragraph is a constraint-level conclusion.\n\nA [dedicated history](concepts.md#c05) does not imply that two [Selves](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19) hold the same content. Each [Self](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19) obtains only [own segment](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c17) that [arrives](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at itself (Premise 4), so the same shared experience leaves different material on the two sides. This paragraph is a constraint-level conclusion.\n\nCalibration: two people who have worked together for a long time can connect without explanation; with someone who has never worked with them, the same matter must be explained again. This is only a comparison with daily life and not a source of derivation.\n\n```text\nPremise 10: The Arrivals each Self can receive within a period of time are limited.\nNote: Premise 10 is an empirical antecedent used as an input to derivation.\nStep 4-7-1: The criterion of Tacit Coordination is History and behavioral pattern, not prediction (from definition of Tacit Coordination)\nConclusion 4-7-2: Tacit Coordination does not require either side to compute the other's next step in advance (from definition of Tacit Coordination + Conclusion 2-13)\nStep 4-7-3: A large number of interactions does not mean that Tacit Coordination already exists (from definition of Tacit Coordination)\nStep 4-7-4: If hostile parties, in a specified comparable situation, repeatedly show compatible continuations, they can meet Tacit Coordination; from this one does not infer friendliness, trust, common interest, or genuine understanding (from definition of Tacit Coordination + Conclusion 2-15)\nStep 4-7-5-1: Dedicated History with different counterparts each needs its own Arrival (from Step 4-4-1 + definition of Dedicated History)\nConclusion 4-7-5: Suppose Dedicated History needs repeated Arrival in comparable situations (Empirical Prohibition); then the number of counterparts with which a Self newly acquires Tacit Coordination within the stated time window cannot grow without limit (from Premise 10 + Step 4-7-5-1 + Step 4-4-1 + definition of Dedicated History + definition of Tacit Coordination + Conclusion 2-14 + Empirical Prohibition)\nNote: How large the upper limit is cannot be derived: Impact cannot be added up, and when this is used the assumptions about Frequency and Discrepancy must be written out.\nStep 4-7-6: Without a sufficiently repeated Dedicated History there will be no Tacit Coordination (from definition of Tacit Coordination + Empirical Prohibition)\nStep 4-7-7: Long-term coexistence does not guarantee Tacit Coordination (from Step 4-7-3)\nConclusion 4-7-8: Once Tacit Coordination has formed, it is not guaranteed to continue (from Conclusion 2-13 + definition of Tacit Coordination)\nStep 4-7-9: A Dedicated History does not imply that two Selves hold the same content (from definition of Dedicated History + Conclusion 2-12 + Conclusion 2-14)\nNote: Conclusion 4-7-5 is conditional and uses Premise 10; Step 4-7-6 writes only a necessary condition and can be modified by new cases.\nNote: The calibration in this section is only a comparison with daily life and is not a source of derivation.\n```\n\n### 4.8 Weight Trajectories, Friendliness and Conflict, the Compatibility Threshold\n\nThis section uses Component 2, Component 3, Component 4, and Component 5 (Conclusion 2-12, Conclusion 2-13, Conclusion 2-14, Conclusion 2-15).\n\nThis section is not a seventh operation on the [loop](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c31); it reads the direction in which the [loops](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c31) of two [Selves](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19) are heading. Two [Selves](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19) with [second-order distinction](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c01) each have their own [weight](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06). When the same [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) [arrives](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at different [Selves](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19), its [impact](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c47) and [discrepancy](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c49) may differ according to their respective [histories](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13), and so may the movement it causes in their respective [weights](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06). [Convergence](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c37), [divergence](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c38), and [stasis](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c52) under a [coupling](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c36) are, along a dimension stated by the researcher, the distance between the patterns of the two sides' [outputs](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) becoming shorter, longer, or unchanged; the [weights](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06) of the two sides affect later [outputs](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) and thereby this distance, but do not alone determine it, and neither does either side alone. What the researcher obtains from outside is the change in the pattern of [outputs](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) and in the distance, not the [weights](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06) of the two sides: each [Self's](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19) [own segment](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c17) always has a part that has not [arrived](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at the other (Premise 4); an increase in the number of interactions does not change this either (3.5). This paragraph is a constraint-level conclusion.\n\n\"Friendliness\" and \"[conflict](concepts.md#c10)\" are labels that a researcher attaches to outward patterns. [Conflict](concepts.md#c10) is the [Taiji](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c39) formed between two [Selves](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19) within a stated dimension and time window: the [outputs](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) of both sides target the other's [outputs](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) in that dimension, with opposite directions, and every time one side's [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) [arrives](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at the other, it strengthens the other's own direction, so the firmer one side is, the firmer the other becomes. It can form only if the [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) of at least one side has [arrived](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at the other (including through relay). Each going its own way in opposite directions, with no [outputs](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) that target the other, is not [conflict](concepts.md#c10). \"Friendliness\" in this paper refers only to an outward pattern within the same dimension, criterion, and time window in which the distance shows [convergence](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c37) or [stasis](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c52) and the sequence is compatible, and no separate concept is set up. Both words are descriptions of the sequence and not of the inner state or drives of either side ([unconfirmability of drives](concepts.md#c03)). When a researcher uses them, the dimension and time window must be stated, and for \"friendliness\" the criterion must be stated as well; the same pair of [Selves](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19) can be given both labels at the same time in different dimensions, and the same sequence can receive a different label in a different time window. This paragraph is a constraint-level conclusion.\n\nFor any pair of [Selves](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19), including acquaintances with a [dedicated history](concepts.md#c05), compatibility is [not guaranteed](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c02). For [loops](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c31) to be compatible, one side's [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) must fall within the range under the other's [weight](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06) that it can connect with; this range belongs to the other's [own segment](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c17), which does not fully [arrive](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) (Premise 4) and cannot be derived in advance from the other's next [decision](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c06) (the [Law of the Black Box](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c25)). So the framework provides no procedure that can guarantee that the [loop](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c31) is compatible, and every attempt is a [forced wager](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c11). A [dedicated history](concepts.md#c05) adds material (3.5) and may also consist entirely of [mismatches](concepts.md#c08), so a lot of accumulation does not imply compatibility. This paragraph is a constraint-level conclusion.\n\nHaving material does not mean cooperating. Even if a [Self](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19) holds enough material to estimate the other's compatible region, having the ability does not imply using it this time (Section 2); even if it is used this time, the tendency of its next [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) is still given by its whole [weight](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06) (the [Law of the Black Box](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c25)), and being compatible with the other in this dimension is only one dimension among them. So even if both sides hold material about each other's compatible region, being in [conflict](concepts.md#c10) is not excluded. This paragraph is a constraint-level conclusion.\n\nThe absence of a [dedicated history](concepts.md#c05) does not imply that compatibility is impossible. By the [Law of the Black Box](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c25), the next [moment](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c09) of a [Self](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19) that is not [locked in](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c12) cannot be uniquely derived in advance, so from \"there is no [dedicated history](concepts.md#c05)\" one cannot infer that the next [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) must be incompatible with the other. \"[Not guaranteed](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c02)\" is not \"guaranteed not\". Possible sources of compatibility that this paper does not exclude: overlap in the material that the two sides each obtained from the [exogenous background](concepts.md#c02); [specified coordination](concepts.md#c07) narrowing the criterion to a narrow dimension; or a [random round](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c26). This paragraph is a constraint-level conclusion. The \"outsider\" here refers only to a counterpart with no [dedicated history](concepts.md#c05) in the stated dimension; the more general problem of strangers is left to later papers.\n\nTo go further and speak about how high or low the threshold is, two empirical antecedents are needed. Premise 12: the dimensionality of each [Self's](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19) [weight](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06) in a dimension is very high, and the region that is compatible under the stated criterion occupies only a very small part of the combinations of possible [outputs](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) of the two sides. Premise 13: in the same dimension, a [dedicated history](concepts.md#c05) is material by which a [Self](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19) estimates the other's compatible region. The \"threshold\" in this section refers to the amount of new material needed, under that dimension and criterion, to estimate the other's compatible region rather than fall into it by luck. Since the compatible region occupies only a very small part (Premise 12), without material, the two sides falling into the small overlapping piece is [not guaranteed](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c02). For a counterpart with a [dedicated history](concepts.md#c05), this source is already in hand (Premise 13); for one without, this source is zero. So under these two antecedents, within the same dimension, the same criterion, and the same time window, a counterpart with a [dedicated history](concepts.md#c05) already holds one kind of usable material for estimating, while for one without this source is zero and it must seek material elsewhere, for example the [exogenous background](concepts.md#c02), relays, or probing. This paragraph is a conditional conclusion, and uses Premise 12 and Premise 13.\n\nThis comparison has three limits. First, a [dedicated history](concepts.md#c05) is counted by dimension; having more material in one dimension does not imply having more in another. Second, more material does not mean more accurate estimation (an [impression](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c45) is not guaranteed to approach the other, 3.5), still less compatibility (the previous paragraph); so this comparison does not imply that counterparts with a [dedicated history](concepts.md#c05) are more often compatible in their [outputs](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28). Third, \"far lower\" is a quantitative claim and, by the [empirical prohibition](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c51), is not written; whether a shared [exogenous background](concepts.md#c02) and [specified coordination](concepts.md#c07) also lower the threshold, and by how much, is decided by data. This paper also does not infer what practice counterparts would invent for this purpose, as that would need drives ([unconfirmability of drives](concepts.md#c03)). This paragraph is a conditional conclusion, and uses Premise 12 and Premise 13.\n\nCalibration: on a first visit to a restaurant, the owner must ask what you want to eat and what is recommended, and you must consider budget and portion; the two sides go back and forth compressing the terms each can accept before ordering a meal that works for both; for a regular who comes every day, the owner's one sentence \"the usual?\" completes the order, because the terms have long since been compressed. This lines up with \"how much material must be newly added\", not with \"the chance of settling\". This is only a comparison with daily life and not a source of derivation.\n\n```text\nPremise 12: The dimensionality of each Self's Weight in a dimension is very high, and the region that is compatible under the stated criterion occupies only a very small part of the combinations of possible Outputs of the two sides.\nNote: Premise 12 is an empirical antecedent used as an input to derivation; it says only that the proportion is small and gives no number.\nPremise 13: In the same dimension, a Dedicated History is material by which a Self estimates the other's compatible region.\nNote: Premise 13 is an empirical antecedent used as an input to derivation; it says only that it is material, not that the estimate is accurate, nor that one acts on the estimate.\nStep 4-8-1: When the same Output Arrives at different Selves, its Impact and Discrepancy may differ according to their respective Histories, and so may the movement it causes in their respective Weights (from definition of Impact + definition of Discrepancy + definition of Arrival)\nStep 4-8-2: Convergence, Divergence, and Stasis compare the distance between the two sides' Output patterns; the Weights of the two sides affect later Outputs and thereby this distance, but do not alone determine it (from definition of Convergence + definition of Divergence + definition of Stasis + Step 4-8-1 + definition of Wo + definition of Weight + Law of the Black Box)\nConclusion 4-8-3: The researcher is Not Guaranteed to be able to fully read the Weights of both sides from outside; the materials for forming an Impression follow the definition of Impression (from Conclusion 2-12 + definition of Impression + definition of Not Guaranteed)\nConclusion 4-8-4: \"Friendliness\" and \"Conflict\" are labels that a researcher attaches to outward patterns and are not descriptions of inner states (from definition of Conflict + Conclusion 2-15 + Conclusion 4-8-3)\nStep 4-8-13: Opposite directions with no Output that targets the other do not constitute Conflict (from definition of Conflict)\nNote: \"Friendliness\" is not set up as a separate concept; the definition of Conflict requires that the Output of at least one side has Arrived at the other, consistent with Conclusion 4-6-10.\nConclusion 4-8-5: Compatibility is not guaranteed for any pair of Selves, including those with a Dedicated History: the other's compatible region is not guaranteed to be completely grasped and the next Decision cannot be uniquely derived in advance, so the framework provides no procedure that can guarantee that the Loop is compatible; here Not Guaranteed means that the existing constraints do not imply compatibility (from Conclusion 2-12 + Conclusion 2-13 + definition of Forced Wager + definition of Mismatch + Conclusion 3-5-8 + definition of Not Guaranteed + definition of Loop)\nStep 4-8-5-1: Holding material about the other's compatible region is Not Guaranteed to lead to cooperation (from Conclusion 2-13 + definition of Not Guaranteed)\nStep 4-8-5-2: Even if the other's compatible region can be estimated, it is Not Guaranteed that the ability will be used this time; even if used, the next Output is still affected by the overall Weight, and compatibility is Not Guaranteed (from Conclusion 2-13 + definition of Not Guaranteed)\nConclusion 4-8-6: Even if both sides hold material about each other's compatible region, being in Conflict is not excluded (from Step 4-8-5-1 + Step 4-8-5-2 + Conclusion 2-13 + definition of Conflict)\nConclusion 4-8-7: The absence of a Dedicated History does not imply that compatibility is impossible (from Conclusion 2-13 + Conclusion 4-8-5 + definition of Not Guaranteed)\nNote: Conclusion 4-8-7 writes only that it is not prohibited; possible sources of compatibility (overlapping material from the Exogenous Background, Specified Coordination, a Random Round) are not excluded and not asserted.\nStep 4-8-8-1: The compatible region is only a small part of the possible Output combinations of the two sides (Premise 12), so without material it is not guaranteed that the two fall into the small overlapping part; material is what one uses to estimate the other's compatible region (Premise 13) (from Premise 12 + Premise 13 + definition of Not Guaranteed)\nStep 4-8-8-2: Dedicated History is one of the materials for estimating the other's compatible region (Premise 13); for a pair with Dedicated History this source is already in hand and can be used for the estimate; for a pair without Dedicated History this source is zero (from Premise 13 + definition of Dedicated History + Conclusion 2-14)\nConclusion 4-8-8: Under Premise 12 and Premise 13, within the same dimension, the same criterion, and the same time window, a counterpart with a Dedicated History already holds one kind of usable material for estimating the other's compatible region, and a counterpart without one has zero from this source (from Step 4-8-8-1 + Step 4-8-8-2 + Conclusion 2-14)\nStep 4-8-9: A Dedicated History is counted by dimension; having more material in one dimension does not imply having more in another (from Conclusion 2-14)\nStep 4-8-10: More material does not mean more accurate estimation (from Conclusion 3-5-8 + Law of Attrition)\nStep 4-8-11: Conclusion 4-8-8 does not imply that counterparts with a Dedicated History are more often compatible in their outputs (from Conclusion 4-8-6 + Step 4-8-10 + Conclusion 4-8-8)\nNote: \"Far lower\" is a quantitative claim and is not written.\nNote: Conclusion 4-8-8 is conditional and uses Premise 12 and Premise 13; other routes to lowering the threshold (shared Exogenous Background, Specified Coordination) are decided by data.\nNote: The calibration in this section is only a comparison with daily life and is not a source of derivation.\n```\n\n### 4.9 Positive Feedback between Two People: Three Loops, Attraction, Reciprocity, Escalation of Conflict, and Dissipation\n\nThis section uses Component 1, Component 2, Component 3, Component 4, and Component 5 (Conclusion 2-11, Conclusion 2-12, Conclusion 2-13, Conclusion 2-14, Conclusion 2-15).\n\nBetween two [Selves](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19) with [second-order distinction](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c01), within the same specified time window, if each is still a [Wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16), their [outputs](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) [arrive](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at each other, and each one's subsequent [outputs](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) are influenced by the other's, there are three [loops](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c31) in that window: A's small self-feedback [loop](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c31), B's small self-feedback [loop](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c31), and the large [loop](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c31) between A and B (Section 2). [Positive feedback](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c32) is a [loop's](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c31) own [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) coming back around and pushing the [weight](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06) further in the direction that produced this [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28). The [positive feedback](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c32) between two people can occur on these three [loops](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c31) at the same time: A's [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) [arrives](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at B's [weight](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06), B's [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) [arrives](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at A's [weight](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06), and each is in turn pushed toward the direction that produced that [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28), so the relation between [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) and [weight](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06) grows tighter and tighter. This process has no directional preference: along some dimension, if the two sides show [convergence](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c37) and reinforce each other, the outward appearance is \"attraction\"; along some dimension, if the two sides show [divergence](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c38), with their outputs targeting each other and reinforcing each other, the outward appearance is [conflict](concepts.md#c10) ([conflict](concepts.md#c10) is precisely the [Taiji](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c39) formed when two [positive feedbacks](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c32) showing [divergence](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c38) are subject to mutual [coupling](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c36), and the phase in which the intensity rises is called escalation of [conflict](concepts.md#c10); the [Taiji](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c39) must form a dynamic balance, and a mutual reinforcement of Divergence in which no dynamic balance forms is not called [conflict](concepts.md#c10)). \"Attraction\" is a label the researcher attaches to the former outward pattern; \"reciprocity\" is one pattern that the [outputs](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) sequence of [positive feedback](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c32) can show: if, under a stated criterion, one side's [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) of a certain kind is followed by the other side's [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) of the same kind, and the reverse also holds, the sequence presents the outward pattern of reciprocity (\"reciprocity\" is a label attached to the sequence); the framework does not guarantee that such a sequence appears. The two are both labels attached by the researcher and may be names of the same process at different levels of description; no separate concept is set up, and neither is a description of an inner state ([unconfirmability of drives](concepts.md#c03)). This paragraph is a constraint-level conclusion.\n\nReciprocity does not require simultaneity, because the [rounds](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c04) of the two ends are not assumed to be synchronized (Section 2). Reciprocity also does not require equivalence: [impact](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c47) cannot be added up, [weight](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06) is [not guaranteed](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c02) to be fully readable, so it is [not guaranteed](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c02) that one can calculate from them who gave more; each [Self](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19) obtains only [own segment](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c17) that [arrives](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at itself (Premise 4), and the two sides each have a ledger, which may be inconsistent; this is the misplaced attribution of 4.6. The interruption of a reciprocal sequence is not the same as a [mismatch](concepts.md#c08); the criteria of the two differ, and they must be stated separately when used. This paragraph is a constraint-level conclusion.\n\n[Positive feedback](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c32) is not guaranteed to continue. By the [Law of Flux](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c24), the [history](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13) that the two sides' [arrivals](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) reach differs at every [moment](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c09); by the [Law of the Black Box](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c25), the next [moment](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c09) of a [Self](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19) that is not [locked in](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c12) cannot be uniquely derived in advance. The reinforcement of this round does not imply the next round. This paragraph is a constraint-level conclusion.\n\nThe [positive feedback](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c32) between two people also cannot be strengthened by an unlimited increase in the amount of [arrival](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10). The [arrivals](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) each [Self](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19) can receive within a period of time are limited (Premise 10), so when the reinforcement reaches some point, it will be crowded out by other [arrivals](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) or limited by other conditions; where the limit lies, this paper does not enumerate, and it is decided by data. This paragraph is a conditional conclusion, and uses Premise 10.\n\nThe [positive feedback](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c32) between two people turns only if [outputs](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) keep [arriving](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at the other side. Distance and fixed conditions (living together, the same workplace, shared settings) affect the [frequency](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c48) of [arrival](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10), and in this paper belong to the [exogenous background](concepts.md#c02) (Premise 6), entering the model only by way of [frequency](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c48). If the [arrivals](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) of this pair stop altogether, the large [loop](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c31) stops while the small [loops](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c31) on both sides do not necessarily stop as a result (Section 2); the [dedicated history](concepts.md#c05) that has already [arrived](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) remains, and renewed contact is a new occurrence and not a restoration of the original [positive feedback](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c32) (the [Law of Non-Restoration](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c28), 4.5). If the [arrivals](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) merely decrease, one cannot say that the large [loop](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c31) must dissipate, because other [arrivals](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) are also entering the [weight](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06) (the [Law of the Black Box](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c25)). So it is written as \"without supply it is not sustained\", not as \"it must dissipate\". The conclusions on stopping and decreasing are constraint-level; the distance and fixed conditions that cause [arrivals](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) to decrease are conditional and use the [exogenous background](concepts.md#c02). A typhoon relies on warm seawater for its supply and dissipates when it leaves the supply; this comparison only helps imagination and is not a source of derivation.\n\nWhen the large [loop](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c31) is weak, the small [loops](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c31) can continue. Every attribution A makes about B and every [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) A produces return to A's own [weight](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06) (Premise 1), without needing B's response. So unrequited love (B does not feed back in the way of responding) and long distance (the two sides' [arrivals](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) are limited by exogenous conditions) are both cases where the large [loop](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c31) is weak and the small [loops](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c31) are present. In this case A still has feedback from the other: B's [outputs](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) that do not respond, [outputs](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) relayed by a third party, and the [exogenous background](concepts.md#c02) are all material that [arrives](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at A. At the constraint level one can write only that \"the small [loops](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c31) can sustain\", not that \"this persistence is sustained by the small [loops](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c31)\": from the outward sequence alone it is not guaranteed that one can distinguish whether self-feedback, relays by a third party, or past [history](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13) is holding it up, because [weight](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06) is unreadable (4.8). The three [loops](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c31) also need not be symmetric, and structural symmetry does not imply symmetry of [arrival](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) or [weight](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06) (4.1). \"Liking\" is an attribution, not a fact, and the feeling is not discussed in this paper. This paragraph is a constraint-level conclusion.\n\nA change in the outward [frequency](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c48) of contact does not imply a change in the two sides' attributions about each other, nor that there is no change. What the researcher can see is the [outputs](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) on the large [loop](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c31), not the small [loops](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c31) on the two sides. The continuation of a small [loop](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c31) also does not imply that the attribution stays unchanged: by the [Law of Flux](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c24) and the [Law of the Black Box](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c25), one's own [history](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13) changes at every [moment](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c09). When [arrivals](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) decrease, the other's changes that do not [arrive](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) do not directly enter the [history](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13) that has [arrived](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at oneself (Premise 4, the [Law of Non-Restoration](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c28)); one's own small [loop](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c31) processes old material plus one's own [outputs](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28), and one's [impression](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c45) of the other may come apart from the other's actual changes. These items are constraint-level conclusions. At a reunion, how large the other's new [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) is in [discrepancy](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c49) for oneself, and whether it triggers a [mismatch](concepts.md#c08), is decided by data and is conditional. This paper does not write \"distance does not affect feelings\": the model says only that the outward [frequency](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c48) and the inner attribution are two layers and cannot be inferred from one another.\n\nCalibration: two people who grow more congenial the more they talk, or quarrel more fiercely the more they quarrel, are both found in daily life, with opposite directions and the same mechanism. The case in which one keeps liking the other though the other does not respond is also found in daily life. When two people at a distance meet less, the longing in their hearts does not necessarily decrease with it, and at a reunion some feel that the other has changed. This is only a comparison with daily life and not a source of derivation.\n\n```text\nCycle 4-9-1: Between two people, within the same specified time window, if the Outputs of both sides Arrive at each other, each side's subsequent Outputs are influenced by the other's Outputs, and each side is still a Wo, there are three Loops in that window: A's small Loop, B's small Loop, and the large Loop between A and B; in this Cycle, the large Loop exits when the Outputs of the two sides no longer Arrive at each other, and each small Loop exits when its Self is no longer a Wo (from Conclusion 2-11)\nCycle 4-9-2: The Positive Feedback between two people can occur on the three Loops at the same time; when a Loop exits, the Positive Feedback on that Loop exits with it (from definition of Positive Feedback + Cycle 4-9-1)\nConclusion 4-9-3: Positive Feedback has no directional preference; along some dimension, Convergence with mutual reinforcement appears outwardly as \"attraction\", and along some dimension, Divergence in which the two sides' Outputs target each other in opposite directions and reinforce each other, becomes a Taiji when a dynamic balance forms and appears outwardly as Conflict (the phase in which the intensity rises is called escalation of Conflict); a mutual reinforcement of Divergence in which no dynamic balance forms is not called Conflict (from Cycle 4-9-2 + definition of Convergence + definition of Divergence + definition of Conflict + definition of Taiji)\nStep 4-9-3-1: If, in the positive-feedback Output sequence and under a stated criterion, one side's Output of a certain kind is followed by the other side's Output of the same kind and the reverse also holds, the sequence presents the outward pattern of reciprocity (\"reciprocity\" is a label attached to the sequence); the framework does not guarantee that such a sequence appears (from Cycle 4-9-2 + Conclusion 4-9-3 + definition of Not Guaranteed)\nConclusion 4-9-4: \"Attraction\" and \"reciprocity\" are labels that a researcher attaches to outward patterns and are not descriptions of inner states; reciprocity is one pattern of the sequence of Outputs that Positive Feedback can show (from Conclusion 4-9-3 + Step 4-9-3-1 + Conclusion 2-15)\nConclusion 4-9-5: Reciprocity does not require simultaneity or equivalence; Impact cannot be added up and Weight is Not Guaranteed to be fully readable, so it is Not Guaranteed that one can calculate from them who gave more (from Conclusion 2-13 + definition of Impact + Conclusion 2-12 + Step 4-9-3-1 + definition of Not Guaranteed)\nStep 4-9-6: The interruption of a reciprocal sequence is not the same as a Mismatch; the criteria of the two differ (from definition of Mismatch + Step 4-9-3-1)\nConclusion 4-9-7: Positive Feedback is not guaranteed to continue (from Conclusion 2-13 + definition of Not Guaranteed + definition of Loop + definition of Positive Feedback)\nConclusion 4-9-8: Within a period of time, the Positive Feedback between two people cannot be strengthened by an amount of Arrival beyond what each Self can receive in that period (from Premise 10)\nNote: Conclusion 4-9-8 is conditional and uses Premise 10; where the limit lies is decided by data.\nConclusion 4-9-9: If the Arrivals of this pair stop altogether, the large Loop stops, the small Loops on both sides do not necessarily stop as a result, the Dedicated History that has already Arrived remains, and renewed contact is a new occurrence (from Conclusion 2-11 + Conclusion 2-14 + Step 4-5-1)\nConclusion 4-9-10: When Arrivals merely decrease, it cannot be said that the large Loop must dissipate (from Conclusion 2-13 + definition of Not Guaranteed)\nNote: The typhoon comparison only helps imagination and is not a source of derivation.\nConclusion 4-9-11: When the large Loop is weak, the small Loops can continue (from Conclusion 2-11)\nConclusion 4-9-12: From the outward sequence alone, it is not guaranteed that one can distinguish whether self-feedback, relays by a third party, or past History is holding it up (from Conclusion 4-8-3 + definition of Not Guaranteed)\nNote: Conclusion 4-9-12 writes only \"can sustain\" and not \"is sustained by it\".\nConclusion 4-9-13: A change in the outward frequency of contact does not imply a change in the two sides' attributions, nor that there is no change (from Conclusion 4-8-3)\nStep 4-9-14: The continuation of a small Loop does not imply that the attribution stays unchanged (from Conclusion 2-13)\nConclusion 4-9-15: When Arrivals decrease, the part that has not Arrived does not directly enter the History that has Arrived at oneself, and one's Impression of the other may come apart from the actual changes (from Conclusion 2-12 + Conclusion 2-14 + definition of Impression)\nNote: At a reunion, how large the other's new Output is in Discrepancy for oneself, and whether it triggers a Mismatch, is decided by data and is conditional.\nNote: The calibration in this section is only a comparison with daily life and is not a source of derivation.\n```\n\n## 5. Cases\n\nThis entire section is calibration and is not a source of any derivation. Each case unfolds in seven steps: the [cut](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c23), the initial state, the new [arrival](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10), the change in [weight](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06), the outcome, what it shows, and what can be said versus what cannot be inferred.\n\n### 5.1 The Caregiver Suddenly Stops Responding: The Still-Face Paradigm\n\n**Data note.** This case is taken from the study published in 2015 in Frontiers in Psychology by Aureli, Grazia, Cardone, and Merla, which I have read in full. That study uses the paradigm published in 1978 in the Journal of the American Academy of Child Psychiatry by Tronick, Als, Adamson, Wise, and Brazelton; I did not obtain the original 1978 paper. The facts below are all taken from the 2015 study, and it is marked which parts are the researchers' interpretations.\n\n**1. [Cut](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c23).** The scope is the face-to-face interaction of a mother and her infant in the laboratory; the time is one experiment, in four phases. There are two nodes: the infant is A, and the mother is B. The phase instructions the researchers gave to B are treated as one thing [arriving](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at B from outside, and no separate node is set up.\n\n**2. Initial state.** By the [configuration assumption](concepts.md#c01), A has only [first-order distinction](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c24), and B has [second-order distinction](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c01) and [view attribution](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c02). The final sample is twelve mother-infant pairs, with infants three to four months old, born at term, and the mother the primary caregiver, from Italy; originally thirty-one pairs agreed to take part, and the rest were excluded for technical and procedural reasons or because the infant was too fussy from the start. A and B already have an everyday [dedicated history](concepts.md#c05) at home, and the experiment takes only one situation from it.\n\n**3. New [arrival](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10).** The experiment has four phases: the mother plays with the infant as usual (three minutes); the mother keeps a neutral expression and gazes steadily at the infant, without touching or speaking (one minute); the mother resumes interaction (three minutes); the fourth phase is play with toys (five minutes), added by the researchers for their own study and not part of the classic paradigm. What changes in this segment is B's [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28): B is still present, and \"not responding\" is also an [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) that B produces in this phase and that keeps [arriving](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at A, of the same structure as \"not moving is also a result\" in the [forced wager](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c11).\n\n**4. Change in [weight](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06).** Only the outward record is written. The researchers coded the infant's state once per second, defining it by expression, gaze, and vocalization; a second coder re-coded twenty-five percent of the sessions, with an agreement coefficient of 0.76. The results: the proportion of looking at the mother with a positive expression was significantly lower in the still-face phase than in the normal interaction phase, and in the resumption phase significantly higher than in the still-face phase but still lower than in the normal interaction phase; the proportion of looking around at the environment was higher in the still-face phase, the overall test did not reach significance, and the pairwise comparison of the two phases did; protest behavior showed no statistically significant difference, and self-soothing behavior did not increase significantly; withdrawal, turning away, and indicators of autonomic stress did not appear at all in the data. In the language of [weight](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06) one can write only: in the interaction dimension, after B's [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) changed, the [weight](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06) of A's [outputs](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) of the kind \"looking at B and showing a positive expression\" became lower, and that of \"looking around at the environment\" became higher.\n\n**5. Outcome.** The experiment ended in the fourth phase. The researchers also recorded the surface temperature of the nose tip and forehead; this case does not use that part of the data, because the link between body temperature and motive is the researchers' interpretation, which this paper does not adopt.\n\n**6. What this case shows.** Two things. First, in an asymmetric [loop](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c31), B's [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) is an input to A's [weight](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06), which can be seen in outward behavior. Second, this paradigm can proceed on outward records alone, without first knowing what the infant wants, which is compatible with [unconfirmability of drives](concepts.md#c03). The still-face phase plus the resumption phase artificially change the interaction sequence and may produce a [mismatch](concepts.md#c08) and the sequence after it (3.4); the proportion of looking at the mother with a positive expression rose again in the resumption phase but remained lower than in the normal phase, but this case specifies no compatibility criterion, so it is not called [repair](concepts.md#c09). In addition, six mother-infant pairs were excluded because the mother could not keep a blank face throughout, which shows that B's own [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) cannot be fully fixed just by following instructions; this is an outward fact, and this paper does not look for a reason for it.\n\n**7. What can be said and what cannot be inferred.** What can be said: under this design and this sample, a change in B's [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) appeared together with changes in certain outward behaviors of A. What cannot be inferred: why the infants changed in this way; the researchers' statements that \"the infant perceives that the interaction has been interrupted\" and \"an expectation is violated\" are the researchers' interpretations and not outward records, and this paper does not adopt them; the authors themselves speculate that the still-face phase lasting only one minute may be why the infants showed no clear distress, which is also only speculation and was not tested; the sample of twelve pairs is small, and the authors themselves list this as a limitation; whether this result extends to other durations, other ages in months, other cultures, or everyday family interaction; whether A's behavioral change was caused by B's [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) alone; whether an individual infant has [second-order distinction](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c01).\n\n### 5.2 The Same Partner versus a Changed Partner: A Dyadic Precision Manipulation Task\n\n**Data note.** This case is taken from the study published in 2025 in Scientific Reports, volume 15, by Heidersberger, Kaiser, Jadav, Mihić Zidar, Curioni, Johannsen, and Lee, which I have read in full. I did not obtain the supplementary tables, so the test results below use only the numbers reported in the main text. The researchers' interpretations are marked separately from the measurements.\n\n**1. [Cut](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c23).** The scope is two participants in the same experimental task, standing face to face, each holding with the right hand a grip at one of the two ends of the same handle; the time is one experiment, in five phases. There are two nodes: the two partners. The task rules, the apparatus, and the score displayed after each trial are treated as the [exogenous background](concepts.md#c02) shared by the two, and within this time window do not update with the [loop](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c31) of this case.\n\n**2. Initial state.** There were forty-four participants, none of whom had done this task before, in groups of four. By the [configuration assumption](concepts.md#c01), both sides have [second-order distinction](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c01) and [view attribution](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c02); this is an assumption, which the paper did not measure. The task is a \"hot wire game\": the two work together to move a metal ring on the handle along a curved copper wire to a turning point and back, trying not to touch the wire, with a target time of twenty seconds, and after each trial a score is displayed.\n\n**3. New [arrival](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10).** The experiment has five phases: first each does one session alone (five trials); then they cooperate with a fixed partner (fifteen trials, called training); then each does one session alone again (five trials); the last two phases have fifteen trials each, one returning to the same partner and one changing to another member of the same group who had just had a different partner in the training phase, with the order randomly assigned across groups. At the start of these two cooperative phases, every participant has the same accumulated amount of task experience. The two exert force on each other through the same handle, and each one's force and movement [arrive](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at the other by way of the handle. The paper does not say whether the participants knew each other beforehand, so this paper does not call the changed partner a \"stranger\" and says only \"having no [dedicated history](concepts.md#c05) in this task\".\n\n**4. Change in [weight](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06).** Only outward records and statistical results are written, not causes. According to the paper: on returning to the same partner, the score of the first trial was higher than that of the first trial of the training phase; with a changed partner, the score of the first trial was lower than that of the first trial with the same partner, and did not differ significantly from the first trial of the training phase; from the fourth trial on, the difference between the two was no longer significant. When returning to the same partner, the position and direction of the handle, the trajectory of the hands, and the applied force were all closer to those of the last training trial than with a changed partner, and the wrist trajectory showed no significant difference; in the phase of returning to the same partner, the score did not rise significantly within the fifteen trials. In the language of [weight](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06) one can write only: in this task dimension, when cooperating with a partner with a [dedicated history](concepts.md#c05), the [weight](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06) of high-scoring [outputs](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) is higher in the first few trials; when cooperating with a partner without a [dedicated history](concepts.md#c05), this gap shrinks within a few trials.\n\n**5. Outcome.** The experiment ended with the last cooperative phase. The paper also reports two results unrelated to this paper, which this case does not adopt: pairs with different handedness performed lower, and the authors themselves state that a larger and more balanced sample is needed; when the difference in the two individuals' own performance was large, cooperative performance was lower.\n\n**6. What this case shows.** Three things. First, a [dedicated history](concepts.md#c05) is specific to a partner: experience of cooperating with someone else brought no clear benefit in the first trial with a changed partner (no significant difference, which is not proof of no difference). Second, a [dedicated history](concepts.md#c05) provides a starting point and not a long-term advantage: the gap disappears within a few trials, that is, two people lacking a [dedicated history](concepts.md#c05) can reach the same score through the task rules and a few trials of adjustment, which is a calibration for \"coordination does not need prior [tacit coordination](concepts.md#c06)\". Third, this study relies throughout on outward measurement alone: scores, trajectories, and forces, without needing anyone to compute the other's next step, which is compatible with \"not requiring prediction\" in the definition of [tacit coordination](concepts.md#c06).\n\n**7. What can be said and what cannot be inferred.** What can be said: under this task and this sample, in the first few trials after returning to the same partner, the score was higher and the force and trajectory were closer to before; after changing partner, the score caught up within a few trials. What cannot be inferred: whether this familiarity between partners is [tacit coordination](concepts.md#c06) (the shared [history](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13) here is only fifteen trials, about ten minutes, in a laboratory, far shorter than everyday relationships); whether the same holds in other tasks, over longer times, or in other age groups; the researchers' statements of \"learning a predictive model of the other's movements\" and \"negotiating a joint action strategy\" are the researchers' interpretations and not measurements; the participants' subjectively reported \"more rushed, lower sense of control\" is self-report and cannot be taken as a cause; the authors speculate that fatigue is why the score did not continue to rise in the old-partner phase, which is also only speculation; whether the participants knew each other beforehand; whether an individual participant has [second-order distinction](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c01).\n\n## 6. Grading of Conclusions and Falsifiable Conditions\n\nThe conclusions of this paper are of two grades. Constraint-level conclusions are derived only from the [Law of Flux](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c24), the [Law of the Black Box](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c25), the [Law of Attrition](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c26), the [Law of Non-Restoration](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c28), and Premise 1 through Premise 4, together with Premise 20 through Premise 22 added by the author. Conditional conclusions additionally use the [configuration assumption](concepts.md#c01), the [exogenous background](concepts.md#c02), or some empirical antecedent. The cases in Section 5 are calibration, belong to neither grade, and are not used to support conclusions of either grade.\n\nThe constraint-level conclusions are first classified by the properties of the system, and then listed in detail according to the operations performed on the [loop](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c31).\n\n| Property | Summary of constraint-level conclusions | Mainly in |\n|---|---|---|\n| Feedback structure (Component 1) | Each [Self](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19) has two kinds of input, from itself and from others; between two people there are three [loops](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c31) at the same time; [positive feedback](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c32) has no directional preference, and attraction and escalation of [conflict](concepts.md#c10) differ in direction, and conflict further requires that the outputs of the two sides target each other and reinforce each other; when the large [loop](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c31) is weak, the small [loops](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c31) can continue | 2.1, 3.6, 4.8, 4.9 |\n| Hidden state (Component 2) | The other's [weight](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06) cannot be read from outside; a relay is not a copy; the two sides each have a ledger; a change in outward [frequency](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c48) does not imply a change in attribution; more people does not make the network an omniscient subject | 2.2, 4.1 to 4.4, 4.8, 4.9 |\n| Non-determinism and non-stationarity (Component 3) | Having the ability does not imply using it this time; after a [mismatch](concepts.md#c08), [repair](concepts.md#c09) is not guaranteed; [positive feedback](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c32) and [tacit coordination](concepts.md#c06) are not guaranteed to continue; compatibility is [not guaranteed](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c02); the same input does not guarantee the same effect | 2.3, 3.4, 4.7 to 4.9 |\n| Path dependence and irreversibility (Component 4) | A [dedicated history](concepts.md#c05) is counted by dimension; what has [arrived](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) remains, and what has not [arrived](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) does not [arrive](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) because of an [exit](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c43), and whether it [arrives](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) later is [not guaranteed](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c02); renewed contact is a new occurrence; accumulation only adds and never subtracts, and does not imply that quality improves monotonically | 2.4, 3.1, 4.4, 4.5, 4.7 |\n| Self-reference (Component 5) | Words of motive (deception, coercion, trust, promise, fairness, forgiveness, and so on) are all attributions, and an attribution is an [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28); [repair](concepts.md#c09) and the stopping of crying do not by themselves constitute tests of the attribution; a researcher using them must state who made the attribution | 2.5, 3.2, 3.3, 4.3, 4.6 |\n\nThe details arranged by operation are as follows.\n\n| Operation | Constraint-level conclusions | Section |\n|---|---|---|\n| The [loop](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c31) itself | Each [Self](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19) has two kinds of input, self-feedback and feedback from others; a [Self](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19) with [second-order distinction](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c01) has one more link that treats its own [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) as a view; having the ability does not imply using it this time, and how the ability changes with age is biological and is not derived in this paper; a [dedicated history](concepts.md#c05) is counted by dimension, and zero in one place does not cancel another | 1, 2 |\n| Drives | [Unconfirmability of drives](concepts.md#c03) applies to all objects that are not in [lock in](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c12) | 1 |\n| Prohibitions | One may not assume that the researcher is outside the [loop](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c31); one may not assume that the [rounds](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c04) at the two ends are synchronized; analysis of two nodes is one [cut](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c23); having no [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) is not the same as having no influence; structural symmetry does not imply symmetry of [arrival](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) or [weight](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06); a pattern is not a cause, and one must point out which [arrival](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10); [tacit coordination](concepts.md#c06) is not guaranteed to continue; a [dedicated history](concepts.md#c05) does not imply that the two sides hold the same content | 1, 2, 3.4, 4.1, 4.7 |\n| Attribution | A caregiver's attribution about an infant's cry is a [view attribution](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c02) and an [impression](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c45), not a reading of the other's state, and it is not guaranteed that there is an externally available criterion for judging it right or wrong; each attempt is a [forced wager](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c11), the stopping of crying does not by itself constitute a test of the attribution, and the stability of an [impression](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c45) does not equal approaching the other | 3.2, 3.3 |\n| [Mismatch](concepts.md#c08) | A [mismatch](concepts.md#c08) is a possibility that the structure of this [loop](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c31) does not exclude; [repair](concepts.md#c09) is only the sequence becoming compatible again and is not a test of the attribution; after a [mismatch](concepts.md#c08), [repair](concepts.md#c09) is not guaranteed, nor does it imply that [repair](concepts.md#c09) never happens; \"forgiveness\", if it is an attribution, does not equal [repair](concepts.md#c09) | 3.4 |\n| Emergence of second order | If [second-order distinction](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c01) emerges in A, the [loops](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c31) on both sides are symmetric in capability configuration | 3.6 |\n| [Second-order network](concepts.md#c04) | Definition; an increase in the number of people does not guarantee that the proportion of the whole [history](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13) that [arrives](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at each [Self](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19) rises; the network is not guaranteed to become a subject that grasps the [history](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13) of all members merely because it has many people; negotiation of attribution does not guarantee that either side can confirm the other's drives | 4.1 to 4.3 |\n| Adding nodes | The same [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) is a different [arrival](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) for different [Selves](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19); \"being excluded\" means only that certain [outputs](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) did not [arrive](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10); a relay is a new [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28); a new member starts from zero with an existing member in the dimensions where there was no two-way arrival before, and the existing [dedicated history](concepts.md#c05) is neither reset to zero nor becomes the new member's | 4.4 |\n| [Construction of the self](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c28) | A's material for constructing itself has two sources: its own [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) returning to itself, and B's [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) [arriving](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at A; [second-order distinction](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c01) does not add sources and adds only one processing link | 3.5 |\n| Edges involving an infant | It is a [coupling](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c36) and does not belong to the [second-order network](concepts.md#c04) | 4.1 |\n| Removing nodes | What has [arrived](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) remains, and what has not [arrived](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) does not [arrive](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) because of an [exit](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c43), and whether it [arrives](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) later is [not guaranteed](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c02); the same practice by a later person is a new occurrence; the same name or similarity is not enough to claim that a pattern continues; replacement of members implies neither that the network vanishes nor that it continues | 4.5 |\n| Misplaced attribution | Refusal, warning, and counteraction are [outputs](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28), and [conflict](concepts.md#c10) is the structure formed by their targeting one another; [conflict](concepts.md#c10) begins after [arrival](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10), and without any [arrival](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) (including by relay) there is no [conflict](concepts.md#c10); \"deception\" and \"coercion\" are the content of attributions and are not conclusion words of this paper, and a researcher using them must state who made the attribution, which the model does not adjudicate; trust, sense of security, promise, fairness, emotional contagion and co-regulation, and social support are handled the same way, all are attributions, and acting on them is a [forced wager](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c11) | 4.6 |\n| Accumulation of history | [Tacit coordination](concepts.md#c06) does not require prediction, friendliness, transparency, or a stable [impression](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c45), and hostile parties can also meet it; local [tacit coordination](concepts.md#c06) is not transmitted; [specified coordination](concepts.md#c07) does not require every pair of members to have [tacit coordination](concepts.md#c06); when the sets of qualifying responses for two situations are disjoint, one fixed response cannot guarantee qualifying in both (the construction in it holds only for a synthetic world) | 4.7, Appendix 1 |\n| Return flow of history | More interactions add material but do not guarantee that an [impression](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c45) approaches the other, nor make the other's true [weight](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06) readable; the self-concept of an adult likewise has two sources, and an adult can take others' attributions about oneself as views and make a further [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) of them, but this does not imply using it this time | 3.5 |\n| Positive feedback between two people | Between two people there are three [loops](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c31) at the same time; [positive feedback](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c32) has no directional preference, attraction and escalation of [conflict](concepts.md#c10) differ in direction, and conflict further requires that the outputs of the two sides target each other and reinforce each other, and \"attraction\" and \"reciprocity\" are labels attached to outward patterns; it is not guaranteed to continue, not guaranteed to be fair, and there is no externally available ledger; when arrivals stop altogether the large [loop](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c31) stops and the small [loops](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c31) do not necessarily stop as a result, and when arrivals decrease one cannot say that the large [loop](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c31) must dissipate; when the large [loop](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c31) is weak the small [loops](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c31) can continue, as with unrequited love and long distance; a change in outward contact [frequency](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c48) implies neither a change nor no change in attribution | 4.9 |\n| Weight trajectories | The same [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) moves different [Selves](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19) differently; [convergence](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c37), [divergence](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c38), and [stasis](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c52) are jointly determined by the [weights](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06) of the two sides, and [weight](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06) cannot be read from outside; \"friendliness\" and [conflict](concepts.md#c10) are labels attached to outward patterns; compatibility is [not guaranteed](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c02) for any pair of [Selves](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19), acquaintances included; the absence of a [dedicated history](concepts.md#c05) does not imply that compatibility is impossible; even if both sides hold material about each other's compatible region, [conflict](concepts.md#c10) is not excluded | 4.8 |\n\nThe conditional conclusions are as follows.\n\n| Conclusion | Antecedents used | Section |\n|---|---|---|\n| A's [history](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13) is not zero at birth, and A and B have as yet no [dedicated history](concepts.md#c05) in this dimension | Birth and prenatal contact | 3.1 |\n| B can treat a [mismatch](concepts.md#c08) as a clue to go back and correct B's own attribution, and A lacks this link; when tracing [repair](concepts.md#c09), start from B's end | [Configuration assumption](concepts.md#c01) | 3.3, 3.4 |\n| B's attribution and frame, and the part of the [exogenous background](concepts.md#c02) that [arrives](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at A by way of B, become external material for A, carrying B's errors | [Configuration assumption](concepts.md#c01) and [exogenous background](concepts.md#c02) | 3.5 |\n| For biological humans, the other's reaction to an [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) cannot occur at the same time as that [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) | Neural conduction and reaction take time | 2 |\n| Which pairs have a [dedicated history](concepts.md#c05), which pairs have [tacit coordination](concepts.md#c06), whether there is a person in the middle relaying words, and which patterns actually continue | Decided by data | 4.2, 4.4, 4.5, 4.7 |\n| An increase in the dimensions available for participation does not mean they have occurred | Development changes the conditions of participation | 4.4 |\n| Whether a given edge belongs to the [second-order network](concepts.md#c04) at a given moment | [Configuration assumption](concepts.md#c01) | 4.1 |\n| The positive feedback between two people cannot be strengthened by an unlimited increase in the amount of [arrival](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10); the distance and fixed conditions that cause [arrivals](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) to decrease; the [discrepancy](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c49) at a reunion and whether there is a [mismatch](concepts.md#c08) | The [arrivals](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) each [Self](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19) can receive within a period of time are limited; [exogenous background](concepts.md#c02); the rest decided by data | 4.9 |\n| The number of counterparts with whom a [Self](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19) newly acquires [tacit coordination](concepts.md#c06) within a stated time window has an upper limit, and without a sufficiently repeated [dedicated history](concepts.md#c05) there will be no [tacit coordination](concepts.md#c06) | The [arrivals](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) each [Self](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19) can receive within a period of time are limited; the second half is an [empirical prohibition](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c51) | 4.7 |\n| Within the same dimension, criterion, and time window, a counterpart with a [dedicated history](concepts.md#c05) already holds one kind of usable material for estimating the other's compatible region, while for one without this source is zero; it does not imply being compatible more often; \"far lower\" is not written | The dimensionality of weight is high and the compatible region occupies a small proportion; a [dedicated history](concepts.md#c05) is material for estimating the compatible region | 4.8 |\n\nThe components used in each section are as follows. A check mark in the table means that the section's derivation directly cites the conclusion labels of the corresponding component. A section without a check mark does not cite that component.\n\n| Section | Component 1 | Component 2 | Component 3 | Component 4 | Component 5 |\n|---|---|---|---|---|---|\n| 3.1 | | ✓ | | ✓ | |\n| 3.2 | | | | | ✓ |\n| 3.3 | | ✓ | | | ✓ |\n| 3.4 | | | ✓ | ✓ | ✓ |\n| 3.5 | ✓ | | ✓ | | |\n| 3.6 | | | | | |\n| 3.7 | | | | | |\n| 4.1 | | ✓ | | | |\n| 4.2 | ✓ | ✓ | ✓ | | |\n| 4.3 | | | | | ✓ |\n| 4.4 | | ✓ | ✓ | ✓ | ✓ |\n| 4.5 | | ✓ | | ✓ | |\n| 4.6 | | | ✓ | | ✓ |\n| 4.7 | | ✓ | ✓ | ✓ | ✓ |\n| 4.8 | | ✓ | ✓ | ✓ | ✓ |\n| 4.9 | ✓ | ✓ | ✓ | ✓ | ✓ |\n\nWhat circumstances would invalidate the conclusions. The basis of the constraint-level conclusions is the four laws together with Premise 1, Premise 4, and the author-added Premise 20. If it is observed that some [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) of a [Self](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19) did not [arrive](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at that [Self](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19) before its next [moment](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c09), Premise 1 is overturned; if it is observed that, when a certain [Wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16) looks at another [presentation](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c04), the other's [own segment](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c17) has entirely [arrived](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at it, Premise 4 is overturned; if it is observed that the drives of some subject that is not in [lock in](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c12) can be completely confirmed from outside by others, Premise 20 is overturned; if it is observed that a [Self](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19) has made a complete [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) of itself, the [Law of Attrition](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c26) is overturned; if it is observed that the next [moment](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c09) of a [Self](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19) that is not [locked in](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c12) was uniquely derived in advance, the [Law of the Black Box](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c25) is overturned; if it is observed that the same position in [history](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13) is restored (a similar content occurring again does not count), the [Law of Non-Restoration](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c28) is overturned; if it is observed that for a [presentation](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c04) that is still a [Wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16), the [history](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13) that [arrives](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at it is the same as at the previous [moment](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c09), the [Law of Flux](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c24) is overturned. Premise 2 and Premise 3 can only be assumed, and can be neither verified nor falsified; the conclusions that depend on them hold only under these assumptions. If any one of these is overturned, the constraint-level conclusions that depend on it lose force. Losing a basis only means that the derivation chain is broken, not that the proposition is false; its truth must be argued separately. The invalidation conditions of conditional conclusions are determined by the antecedents they use: in the [configuration assumption](concepts.md#c01), that A already has [second-order distinction](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c01) at the stated stage, or that B does not have [second-order distinction](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c01), or that B does not have [view attribution](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c02); the [exogenous background](concepts.md#c02) being updated by the [loops](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c31) of the model within the stated time window; and empirical antecedents being violated by reality, such as prenatal contact, development changing the conditions of participation, the limit on the [arrivals](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) each [Self](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19) can receive, neural conduction and reaction taking time, the dimensionality of [weight](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06) being high with the compatible region occupying a small proportion, and a [dedicated history](concepts.md#c05) being material for estimating the compatible region. Whichever antecedent is violated, only the conclusions that use it lose force, and the rest are unaffected.\n\nWhat is not a conclusion of this paper. The two cases of Section 5 belong to neither grade. They are used only to check how closely the model fits reality; both are laboratory studies with small samples, and the researchers' interpretations have been marked separately from the measurements. Data that were not found, including data on partners of three or more people, long-term data from real families and organizations, data on the upper limit of [tacit coordination](concepts.md#c06), and data on cross-generational continuation, are not written as \"nonexistent\" and are not used to support conclusions.\n\n```text\nNote: Starting points of derivation: the four laws, Premise 1 through Premise 4, and Premise 20 through Premise 22 added by the author. Premise 5, Premise 6, Premise 9, Premise 21, and Premise 22 are scoping assumptions; Premise 7, Premise 8, Premise 10, Premise 11, Premise 12, and Premise 13 are empirical antecedents.\nNote: Falsifiable conditions: if any one of the four laws, Premise 1, Premise 4, or Premise 20 is overturned, the constraint-level conclusions that depend on it lose their basis. Premise 2 and Premise 3 can only be assumed and can be neither verified nor falsified; the conclusions that depend on them hold only under these assumptions.\nNote: The invalidation conditions of conditional conclusions are determined by the antecedents they use: if any one of Premise 5 through Premise 13 is violated by reality, only the conclusions that use it lose force.\nNote: An observation contrary to a conclusion can only be attributed to an error in the starting points of derivation or an error in the derivation; the latter is a correction and not a falsification.\n```\n\n## Appendix 1: Tacit Coordination Is Not Transmitted, and Coordination Does Not Require Every Pair to Have It\n\nWhat follows is a finite construction that holds only for this synthetic world and is not a real sample. Suppose three [Selves](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19), B, C, and E, in the same task and the same dimension: between B and C there are three rounds of two-way [outputs](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) ordered in time, each round continuing compatibly without needing to be guided item by item again; between C and E there are likewise three rounds; between B and E there are no [outputs](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) of this kind at all. Under the criterion of this construction, B and C have [tacit coordination](concepts.md#c06), C and E have [tacit coordination](concepts.md#c06), and B and E do not. Therefore the antecedents of two segments of [tacit coordination](concepts.md#c06) do not sufficiently imply a third.\n\nNow suppose the task is that B hands data to C, and C then hands it to E, the order occurring as prescribed and sufficient to pass the acceptance check of this task. [Specified coordination](concepts.md#c07) is a criterion of this kind: for a defined task, according to explicitly listed acceptance conditions, one examines a sequence of actions that actually occurred, and if the sequence meets the acceptance conditions, the sequence is said to exhibit coordination on that task. After this task is completed, there is still no [tacit coordination](concepts.md#c06) at all between B and E, so coordination does not require every pair of members to have [tacit coordination](concepts.md#c06). Success also does not equal an improved relationship or mutual understanding. For contrast: if three rounds of compatible continuation of the same kind were added for B and E, B and E would also have [tacit coordination](concepts.md#c06) under this criterion, and the earlier difference would disappear. This construction holds only for this synthetic world and cannot be carried over to reality to prove that \"such a situation does not exist in reality\".\n\nNow consider what kind of discrimination coordination requires. Suppose the sets of qualifying responses for two situations have no intersection, and the material and decoding conditions that B obtains in the two situations are the same. If the same fixed response is used, it cannot fall into two mutually disjoint sets at the same time, so the same fixed response cannot guarantee qualifying in both situations. This item does not exclude other material that distinguishes the two situations. This paragraph is a constraint-level conclusion.\n\n```text\nQualification: The Examples below are finite constructions that hold only for this synthetic world and are not real samples.\nExample: Suppose three Selves, B, C, and E, in the same task and the same dimension: between B and C there are three rounds of two-way Outputs ordered in time, each round continuing compatibly; between C and E there are likewise three rounds; between B and E there are no Outputs of this kind at all (from the criterion of this example)\nExample: Under the criterion of this construction, B and C have Tacit Coordination, C and E have Tacit Coordination, and B and E do not (from the criterion of this example + definition of Tacit Coordination)\nExample: Therefore the antecedents of two segments of Tacit Coordination do not sufficiently imply a third (from the criterion of this example)\nExample: Suppose B hands data to C, and C then hands it to E, the order occurring as prescribed and passing the acceptance check of this task; this sequence meets the criterion of Specified Coordination, while there is still no Tacit Coordination between B and E (from the criterion of this example + definition of Specified Coordination)\nExample: Therefore coordination does not require every pair of members to have Tacit Coordination (from the criterion of this example)\nExample: Contrast: after three rounds of compatible continuation of the same kind are added for B and E, B and E also have Tacit Coordination under this criterion, and the earlier difference disappears (from the criterion of this example + definition of Tacit Coordination)\nExample: Suppose the sets of qualifying responses for two situations are mutually disjoint, and the material and decoding conditions that B obtains in the two situations are the same; then the same fixed response cannot belong to both sets at the same time, so it cannot guarantee qualifying in both situations (from the criterion of this example)\nNote: The preceding item does not exclude other material that distinguishes the two situations.\n```\n"}]}
{"paper_uuid":"b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6","paper_title":"四條律相關工具及範例","paper_title_en":"Tools and Examples Related to the Four Laws","author":"黃正宇 / Cheng Yu Huang","contact":"mthree.tw@gmail.com","concepts_md":"---\nuuid: b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6\nlast-modified: 2026-10-05T18:39:00\n---\n\n\n## public 不會發生 / Never Occurs\n\n- 定義:不會發生是禁止的一種形式:它說某件事不會發生;被禁止的事只要出現一次,這條禁止就被推翻。\n- Definition: Never Occurs is one form of prohibition: it states that something does not happen; if the prohibited thing happens even once, the prohibition is refuted.\n\n\n## public 不被保證 / Not Guaranteed\n\n- 定義:不被保證是禁止的一種形式:它不說某件事[不會發生](concepts.md#c01),而是說框架不斷言它必然發生。具體情形中是否另有約束使它成立,框架也不斷言;要主張它必然發生,必須另外寫明所依賴的約束。它限制的是預測能有多少信心。\n- Definition: Not Guaranteed is one form of prohibition: it does not state that something [never occurs](concepts.md#c01), but that the framework does not assert that it necessarily happens. Whether other constraints make it hold in a particular case, the framework does not assert either; to claim that it necessarily happens, one must state the constraints relied on. What it limits is how much confidence a prediction can have.\n- 裁決:2026-09-28 作者裁決:稽核指出「沒有任何東西保證」過強;改為「框架推不出它必然發生」。\n- 裁決:2026-09-29 作者裁決:稽核指出「框架推不出」是關於整個框架可推導性的後設命題,只看單一定義不足以證成;改為「框架不斷言它必然發生」,只談框架說了什麼,對照前提與定義即可核對。名稱不變,保留 ID。\n\n\n## private 宇宙 / Universe\n\n- 定義:宇宙是有[坍塌](concepts.md#c07)的那一個世界。宇宙中不由過去決定的只有兩樣:[宇宙初態](concepts.md#c11),與每一次[坍塌](concepts.md#c07)的結果;其他一切,包括每一次[寫入](concepts.md#c09),都由到當時為止的[歷史](concepts.md#c10)決定。\n- Definition: The universe is the one world in which there is [Collapse](concepts.md#c07). Only two things in the universe are not determined by the past: the [Initial State of the Universe](concepts.md#c11) and the outcome of each [collapse](concepts.md#c07); everything else, including every [Writing](concepts.md#c09), is determined by the [History](concepts.md#c10) up to that point.\n- 狀態:已廢棄\n- 裁決:2026-09-28 判定與上游《渦動力學》的宇宙(c02)不是同一概念:上游為 private,本篇在自己的前提下重新定義。\n- 裁決:2026-09-30 廢棄:本篇直接引用《渦動力學》的宇宙(c02),不再自行定義。\n\n\n## private 呈現 / Presentation\n\n- 定義:呈現是[宇宙](concepts.md#c03)中的任何一部分。\n- Definition: A presentation is any part of the [Universe](concepts.md#c03).\n- 狀態:已廢棄\n- 裁決:2026-09-28 判定與上游《渦動力學》的呈現(c04)不是同一概念:上游為 private,本篇在自己的前提下重新定義。\n- 裁決:2026-09-30 廢棄:本篇直接引用《渦動力學》的呈現(c04),不再自行定義。\n\n\n## private 分支 / Branch\n\n- 定義:分支是一次[坍塌](concepts.md#c07)可能得出的每一個結果。\n- Definition: A branch is each possible outcome of a [Collapse](concepts.md#c07).\n- 狀態:已廢棄\n- 裁決:2026-09-28 判定與上游《渦動力學》的分支(c05)不是同一概念:上游為 private,本篇在自己的前提下重新定義。\n- 裁決:2026-09-30 廢棄:本篇直接引用《渦動力學》的分支(c05),不再自行定義。\n\n\n## private 權重 / Weight\n\n- 定義:權重是每個[分支](concepts.md#c05)的輕重。一次[坍塌](concepts.md#c07)的各[分支](concepts.md#c05)權重都不小於零,總和為一。一個[呈現](concepts.md#c04)的權重,是[宇宙](concepts.md#c03)的權重落在它身上的那一部分:把各[分支](concepts.md#c05)看成該[呈現](concepts.md#c04)的結果之後,同一個結果的權重相加。權重是[分支](concepts.md#c05)的輕重,不是任何[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)內部的參數。\n- Definition: A weight is how heavy each [Branch](concepts.md#c05) is. The weights of the [branches](concepts.md#c05) of a [Collapse](concepts.md#c07) are all non-negative and sum to one. The weight of a [Presentation](concepts.md#c04) is the part of the weight of the [Universe](concepts.md#c03) that falls on it: once each [branch](concepts.md#c05) is read as an outcome for that [presentation](concepts.md#c04), the weights of [branches](concepts.md#c05) giving the same outcome are added together. A weight belongs to [branches](concepts.md#c05); it is not an internal parameter of any [Wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16).\n- 狀態:已廢棄\n- 裁決:2026-09-28 判定與上游《渦動力學》的權重(c06)不是同一概念:上游為 private,本篇在自己的前提下重新定義。\n- 裁決:2026-09-30 廢棄:本篇直接引用《渦動力學》的權重(c06),不再自行定義。\n\n\n## private 坍塌 / Collapse\n\n- 定義:坍塌是依[權重](concepts.md#c06)從各[分支](concepts.md#c05)中定出一個的事件。未被定出的[分支](concepts.md#c05),不留在[宇宙](concepts.md#c03)中。給定到當時為止的[歷史](concepts.md#c10),坍塌的結果依[權重](concepts.md#c06)定出,[歷史](concepts.md#c10)中沒有任何東西能比[權重](concepts.md#c06)多說一點。\n- Definition: A collapse is the event in which one of the [Branches](concepts.md#c05) is settled according to the [Weights](concepts.md#c06). [Branches](concepts.md#c05) not settled do not remain in the [Universe](concepts.md#c03). Given the [History](concepts.md#c10) up to that point, the outcome of a collapse is settled according to the [weights](concepts.md#c06), and nothing in the [history](concepts.md#c10) says anything more than the [weights](concepts.md#c06).\n- 狀態:已廢棄\n- 裁決:2026-09-28 判定與上游《渦動力學》的坍塌(c08)不是同一概念:上游為 private,本篇在自己的前提下重新定義。\n- 裁決:2026-09-30 廢棄:本篇直接引用《渦動力學》的坍塌(c08),不再自行定義。\n\n\n## private 時刻 / Moment\n\n- 定義:時刻是一次[坍塌](concepts.md#c07)。[坍塌](concepts.md#c07)一次一次發生,排成一條全序;沒有[坍塌](concepts.md#c07),就沒有時刻。一個[呈現](concepts.md#c04)的時刻,是[涉及](concepts.md#c14)它的那些[坍塌](concepts.md#c07);它的下一時刻,是下一次[涉及](concepts.md#c14)它的[坍塌](concepts.md#c07);兩次之間,對它沒有時刻。\n- Definition: A moment is a [Collapse](concepts.md#c07). [Collapses](concepts.md#c07) happen one at a time and form a total order; without [collapse](concepts.md#c07) there is no moment. The moments of a [Presentation](concepts.md#c04) are the [collapses](concepts.md#c07) that [involve](concepts.md#c14) it; its next moment is the next [collapse](concepts.md#c07) that [involves](concepts.md#c14) it; between two of them, there is no moment for it.\n- 狀態:已廢棄\n- 裁決:2026-09-28 判定與上游《渦動力學》的時刻(c09)不是同一概念:上游為 private,本篇在自己的前提下重新定義;本篇不引入觀察者。\n- 裁決:2026-09-30 廢棄:本篇直接引用《渦動力學》的時刻(c09),不再自行定義。\n\n\n## private 寫入 / Writing\n\n- 定義:寫入是每一次[坍塌](concepts.md#c07)之前,先加入[歷史](concepts.md#c10)的一筆內容。寫入的內容,完全由到當時為止的[歷史](concepts.md#c10)決定。[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)的每一次[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18),都在[歷史](concepts.md#c10)中留下一次寫入。\n- Definition: A writing is the item added to [History](concepts.md#c10) before each [Collapse](concepts.md#c07). The content of a writing is entirely determined by the [history](concepts.md#c10) up to that point. Every [Distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) of a [Wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16) leaves a writing in [history](concepts.md#c10).\n- 狀態:已廢棄\n- 裁決:2026-09-28 判定與上游《渦動力學》的寫入(c29)不是同一概念:上游為 private,本篇在自己的前提下重新定義。\n- 裁決:2026-09-30 廢棄:本篇直接引用《渦動力學》的寫入(c29),不再自行定義。\n\n\n## private 歷史 / History\n\n- 定義:歷史始於[宇宙初態](concepts.md#c11),其後是每一次[寫入](concepts.md#c09)與每一次[坍塌](concepts.md#c07)的結果,依[時刻](concepts.md#c08)排列。[宇宙](concepts.md#c03)只有一部歷史;歷史只往後追加,已經在其中的,不會離開。\n- Definition: History begins with the [Initial State of the Universe](concepts.md#c11), followed by every [Writing](concepts.md#c09) and the outcome of every [Collapse](concepts.md#c07), arranged by [Moment](concepts.md#c08). The [universe](concepts.md#c03) has only one history; history is only ever appended to, and nothing already in it ever leaves.\n- 狀態:已廢棄\n- 裁決:2026-09-28 判定與上游《渦動力學》的歷史(c13)不是同一概念:上游為 private,本篇在自己的前提下重新定義。\n- 裁決:2026-09-30 廢棄:本篇直接引用《渦動力學》的歷史(c13),不再自行定義。\n\n\n## private 宇宙初態 / Initial State of the Universe\n\n- 定義:宇宙初態是第一次[坍塌](concepts.md#c07)之前已經在那裡的一切,是[歷史](concepts.md#c10)的起點。內容不分析。\n- Definition: The initial state of the universe is everything that is already there before the first [Collapse](concepts.md#c07); it is the starting point of [History](concepts.md#c10). Its content is not analyzed.\n- 狀態:已廢棄\n- 裁決:2026-09-28 判定與上游《渦動力學》的宇宙初態(c14)不是同一概念:上游為 private,本篇在自己的前提下重新定義;本篇不引入形式層。\n- 裁決:2026-09-30 廢棄:本篇直接引用《渦動力學》的宇宙初態(c14),不再自行定義。\n\n\n## private 生成函數 / Generating Function\n\n- 定義:生成函數把到當時為止的[歷史](concepts.md#c10),包括剛發生的那一次[寫入](concepts.md#c09),對應到下一[時刻](concepts.md#c08)各[分支](concepts.md#c05)的[權重](concepts.md#c06)。它只取[歷史](concepts.md#c10),只有一個,內部不分析。\n- Definition: The generating function maps the [History](concepts.md#c10) up to that point, including the [Writing](concepts.md#c09) that has just taken place, to the [Weights](concepts.md#c06) of the [Branches](concepts.md#c05) of the next [Moment](concepts.md#c08). It takes nothing but [history](concepts.md#c10), there is only one of it, and its internals are not analyzed.\n- 狀態:已廢棄\n- 裁決:2026-09-28 判定與上游《渦動力學》的生成函數(c15)不是同一概念:上游為 private,本篇在自己的前提下重新定義。\n- 裁決:2026-09-30 廢棄:本篇直接引用《渦動力學》的生成函數(c15),不再自行定義。\n\n\n## private 到達 / Arrival\n\n- 定義:一個[呈現](concepts.md#c04)收到的[刺激](concepts.md#c53)、[涉及](concepts.md#c14)它而實際結果沒有落在它身上的[坍塌](concepts.md#c07),以及[宇宙初態](concepts.md#c11),都成為它[歷史](concepts.md#c10)的一部分,這就是到達。也就是說,一個[呈現](concepts.md#c04)所處的物理條件,不論有沒有改變,都成為它的[歷史](concepts.md#c10);一件可能發生在它身上、結果沒有發生的事,也算在內。\n- Definition: The [Stimuli](concepts.md#c53) a [Presentation](concepts.md#c04) receives, the [Collapses](concepts.md#c07) that [involve](concepts.md#c14) it but whose actual outcome does not fall on it, and the [Initial State of the Universe](concepts.md#c11) all become part of its [History](concepts.md#c10); this is arrival. In other words, the physical conditions a [presentation](concepts.md#c04) is in, whether or not they change, all become its [history](concepts.md#c10); something that could have happened to it but did not also counts.\n- 狀態:已廢棄\n- 裁決:2026-09-28 判定與上游《渦動力學》的到達(c10)不是同一概念:上游為 private,本篇在自己的前提下重新定義。\n- 裁決:2026-09-29 改以刺激(c53)表述;上游渦的定義用到刺激,本篇依自己的前提重新定義。\n- 裁決:2026-09-30 廢棄:本篇直接引用《渦動力學》的到達(c10),不再自行定義。\n\n\n## private 涉及 / Involvement\n\n- 定義:一次[坍塌](concepts.md#c07)的結果以正的[權重](concepts.md#c06)落在一個[呈現](concepts.md#c04)身上,這次[坍塌](concepts.md#c07)就涉及它。\n- Definition: A [Collapse](concepts.md#c07) involves a [Presentation](concepts.md#c04) when its outcome falls on that [presentation](concepts.md#c04) with positive [Weight](concepts.md#c06).\n- 狀態:已廢棄\n- 裁決:2026-09-28 判定與上游《渦動力學》的涉及(c11)不是同一概念:上游為 private,本篇在自己的前提下重新定義。\n- 裁決:2026-09-30 廢棄:本篇直接引用《渦動力學》的涉及(c11),不再自行定義。\n\n\n## private 鎖死 / Lock-in\n\n- 定義:鎖死是一個[呈現](concepts.md#c04)的下一[時刻](concepts.md#c08)只有一個[權重](concepts.md#c06)不為零的[分支](concepts.md#c05)的情形。鎖死是被[涉及](concepts.md#c14)了,卻只有一個結果;一個[呈現](concepts.md#c04)沒有[時刻](concepts.md#c08)的期間,不是鎖死。\n- Definition: Lock-in is the situation in which the next [Moment](concepts.md#c08) of a [Presentation](concepts.md#c04) has only one [Branch](concepts.md#c05) of non-zero [Weight](concepts.md#c06). Lock-in means being [involved](concepts.md#c14) yet having only one outcome; a period in which a [presentation](concepts.md#c04) has no [moment](concepts.md#c08) is not lock-in.\n- 狀態:已廢棄\n- 裁決:2026-09-28 判定與上游《渦動力學》的鎖死(c12)不是同一概念:上游為 private,本篇在自己的前提下重新定義。\n- 裁決:2026-09-30 廢棄:本篇直接引用《渦動力學》的鎖死(c12),不再自行定義。\n\n\n## private 自己的那一段 / Own Segment\n\n- 定義:一個[呈現](concepts.md#c04)自己的那一段,是它下一[時刻](concepts.md#c08)的[權重](concepts.md#c06)所依賴的那部分[歷史](concepts.md#c10):[歷史](concepts.md#c10)中某一件若換成別的,影響沿著[歷史](concepts.md#c10)傳下來,會改變它下一[時刻](concepts.md#c08)[權重](concepts.md#c06)的分布,這一件就屬於它自己的那一段。那一段由依賴決定,不由任何[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)決定;它是同一部[歷史](concepts.md#c10)的一部分,不同[呈現](concepts.md#c04)自己的那一段可以重疊。\n- Definition: The own segment of a [Presentation](concepts.md#c04) is the part of [History](concepts.md#c10) on which the [Weights](concepts.md#c06) of its next [Moment](concepts.md#c08) depend: an item of [history](concepts.md#c10) belongs to its own segment if replacing that item with something else would, with the influence passing down the [history](concepts.md#c10), change the distribution of its [weights](concepts.md#c06) for the next [moment](concepts.md#c08). The segment is determined by dependence, not by any [Distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18); it is part of the one [history](concepts.md#c10), and the own segments of different [presentations](concepts.md#c04) may overlap.\n- 狀態:已廢棄\n- 裁決:2026-09-28 判定與上游《渦動力學》的自己的那一段(c17)不是同一概念:上游為 private,本篇在自己的前提下重新定義。\n- 裁決:2026-09-30 廢棄:本篇直接引用《渦動力學》的自己的那一段(c17),不再自行定義。\n\n\n## private 個體 / Individual\n\n- 定義:個體是被某個[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19)[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)出來的[呈現](concepts.md#c04)。同一段[宇宙](concepts.md#c03),被[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)為一個個體或許多個個體,皆成立。\n- Definition: An individual is a [Presentation](concepts.md#c04) marked off by some [Self](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19) through [Distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18). The same stretch of the [Universe](concepts.md#c03) may be [distinguished](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) as one individual or as many, and either holds.\n- 狀態:已廢棄\n- 裁決:2026-09-28 判定與上游《渦動力學》的個體(c20)不是同一概念:上游為 private,本篇在自己的前提下重新定義。\n- 裁決:2026-09-30 廢棄:本篇直接引用《渦動力學》的個體(c20),不再自行定義。\n\n\n## private 同一 / Identity\n\n- 定義:同一是一種[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18):某一[時刻](concepts.md#c08)的[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)與另一[時刻](concepts.md#c08)的[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)是不是同一個,由作出[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)的[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19)決定。一個[呈現](concepts.md#c04)是不是[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16),不是[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18);兩個[時刻](concepts.md#c08)的[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)是不是同一個,是[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)。\n- Definition: Identity is a kind of [Distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18): whether a [Wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16) at one [Moment](concepts.md#c08) and a [wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16) at another [moment](concepts.md#c08) are the same one is decided by the [Self](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19) that makes the [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18). Whether a [Presentation](concepts.md#c04) is a [wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16) is not a [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18); whether the [wos](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16) at two [moments](concepts.md#c08) are the same one is.\n- 狀態:已廢棄\n- 裁決:2026-09-28 判定與上游《渦動力學》的同一(c21)不是同一概念:上游為 private,本篇在自己的前提下重新定義。\n- 裁決:2026-09-30 廢棄:本篇直接引用《渦動力學》的同一(c21),不再自行定義。\n\n\n## public 對他者認識的不可完備性 / Incompleteness of Knowing Others\n\n- 定義:對他者認識的不可完備性是這個結論:沒有任何[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19)能保證自己[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)完了另一個[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)。[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19)只能用已經[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)它的[歷史](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13)來[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)對方;對方的訊息[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)它是一件事,它的[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)又是另一件,在兩者之間,對方的[歷史](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13)仍可能增長,而對方不被[鎖死](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c12)時,對方下一[時刻](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c09)的結果不能事先推出([黑箱律](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c25))。此外,對方[自己的那一段](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c17)中只[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)對方的部分,沒有任何東西保證也會[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)它;而它的[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)作為一次[寫入](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c29),一旦成為對方[自己的那一段](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c17)的一部分,也可能改變對方下一[時刻](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c09)的[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06)。\n- Definition: The Incompleteness of Knowing Others is the conclusion that no [Self](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19) can guarantee that it has finished [distinguishing](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) another [Wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16). A self can distinguish the other only through the [History](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13) that has [arrived](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at it; the other's information [arriving](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) is one event and the self's [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) is another, and between them the other's [history](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13) may still grow, while, when the other is not [locked in](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c12), the outcome of the other's next [Moment](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c09) cannot be derived beforehand ([Law of the Black Box](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c25)). Moreover, nothing guarantees that the parts of the other's [Own Segment](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c17) that [arrive](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) only at the other also [arrive](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at the self; and once the self's [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18), as a [Writing](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c29), becomes part of the other's [own segment](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c17), it may change the other's [Weights](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06) for its next [moment](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c09).\n- 裁決:2026-09-28 判定與上游《渦動力學》的他者分別不完(c32)不是同一概念:上游為 private,本篇在自己的前提下重新定義。\n- 裁決:2026-09-28 修飾子定為 public:下游引用印象相關的禁止時需要它。\n- 裁決:2026-09-28 名稱由「他者分別不完」改為「對他者認識的不可完備性」。\n- 裁決:2026-09-30 定義中的底層詞改連《渦動力學》的公開條目,意義不變,保留 ID。\n\n\n## private 粒度 / Granularity\n\n- 定義:粒度是這個條件結論:若把同一段[宇宙](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c02)描述成較粗與較細的[呈現](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c04),且較粗[呈現](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c04)的結果投影可由較細[呈現](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c04)的結果投影經某映射取得,則較粗[呈現](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c04)的[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06)分布等於較細[呈現](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c04)的[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06)分布經該映射推前所得。粒度只主張這種結果投影相容的描述之間一致,不主張任意兩個結果投影必然相容。\n- Definition: Granularity is the conditional conclusion that, when the same stretch of the [Universe](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c02) is described by a coarser and a finer [Presentation](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c04), and the outcome projection of the coarser [presentation](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c04) can be obtained from the outcome projection of the finer [presentation](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c04) by a mapping, the [Weight](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06) distribution of the coarser [presentation](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c04) equals the pushforward, by that mapping, of the [weight](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06) distribution of the finer [presentation](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c04). Granularity asserts consistency only between descriptions whose outcome projections are compatible in this sense; it does not assert that arbitrary outcome projections must be compatible.\n- 裁決:2026-09-30 定義中的底層詞改連《渦動力學》的公開條目,意義不變,保留 ID。\n- 裁決:2026-10-05 稽核指出原定義省略論文形式式中的「結果投影相容」前件,將條件命題擴大為無條件結論;本次收窄回形式式,不新增「所有重切皆投影相容」的公設,保留 ID。\n\n\n## public 時鐘時間 / Clock Time\n\n- 定義:時鐘時間是[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)以時鐘量到的時間,依物理,不形式化。它與[時刻](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c09)不同:[時刻](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c09)只是[坍塌](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c08)的次序,任何[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)都量不到。\n- Definition: Clock time is the time a [Wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16) measures with a clock; it follows physics and is not formalized. It differs from a [Moment](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c09): [moments](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c09) are only the order of [Collapses](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c08), which no [wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16) can measure.\n- 裁決:2026-09-30 修飾子改為 public:公開工具「速度」用到它。\n- 裁決:2026-09-30 定義中的底層詞改連《渦動力學》的公開條目,意義不變,保留 ID。\n\n\n## public 重切 / Recutting\n\n- 定義:重切是改變[切法](concepts.md#c23):把一個部分切成許多部分,或把許多部分合成一個。「結論經得起重切」只適用於結果投影相容的重切:同一段[宇宙](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c02)被描述成較粗與較細的[呈現](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c04)時,較粗[呈現](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c04)的結果投影可由較細[呈現](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c04)的結果投影經某映射取得。[迴路](concepts.md#c31)、[知見障](concepts.md#c35)、[耦合](concepts.md#c36)、[太極](concepts.md#c39)與[更新](concepts.md#c42)所得的結論,在這些結果投影相容的重切下都必須不變;[印象](concepts.md#c45)不受此要求。在這些相容重切之下,[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06)與推論不變;[耦合](concepts.md#c36)、[太極](concepts.md#c39)與[印象](concepts.md#c45)在描述[迴路](concepts.md#c31)之間的關係時,若相關部分被合併,這些關係轉為內部結構,不再以關係的形式出現。任意兩個[切法](concepts.md#c23)之間是否滿足這項結果投影相容條件,不由此定義保證。\n- Definition: Recutting is changing the [Cut](concepts.md#c23): cutting one part into many, or merging many parts into one. Saying that a conclusion survives recutting applies only to outcome-projection-compatible recuttings: when the same stretch of the [Universe](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c02) is described by a coarser and a finer [Presentation](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c04), the outcome projection of the coarser [presentation](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c04) can be obtained from the outcome projection of the finer [presentation](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c04) by a mapping. Conclusions derived from [Loop](concepts.md#c31), [Cognitive Obscuration](concepts.md#c35), [Coupling](concepts.md#c36), [Taiji](concepts.md#c39), and [Renewal](concepts.md#c42) must remain unchanged under such outcome-projection-compatible recuttings; [Impression](concepts.md#c45) is exempt from this requirement. Under such compatible recuttings, [Weights](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06) and inferences do not change; when [Coupling](concepts.md#c36), [Taiji](concepts.md#c39), and [Impression](concepts.md#c45) describe relations between [Loops](concepts.md#c31), merging the relevant parts turns those relations into internal structure, so they no longer appear as relations. This definition does not guarantee that arbitrary pairs of [Cuts](concepts.md#c23) satisfy this outcome-projection compatibility condition.\n- 裁決:2026-09-28 稽核指出定義漏了論文正文的例外;補上「除了印象以外」。\n- 裁決:2026-09-30 定義中的底層詞改連《渦動力學》的公開條目,意義不變,保留 ID。\n- 裁決:2026-10-05 稽核指出「分析的結論」範圍大於正文的「每個工具的結論」;定義收窄回正文範圍,中英文同步修改。\n- 裁決:2026-10-05 稽核指出「每個工具」的量化範圍必須回到正文才能判定,違反定義可獨立理解;改為直接列出[迴路](concepts.md#c31)、[知見障](concepts.md#c35)、[耦合](concepts.md#c36)、[更新](concepts.md#c42),並明列[印象](concepts.md#c45)為例外;同時移除「描述迴路關係的工具」這個未定義集合用語。意義不變,中英文同步修改。\n- 裁決:2026-10-05 稽核指出正文「每個工具的結論」亦包含[太極](concepts.md#c39);補入[太極](concepts.md#c39),與正文範圍同步,中英文定義一併修改。\n- 裁決:2026-10-05 配合前述結果投影相容條件的裁決,重切下「權重與推論不變」只對結果投影相容的重切成立;不新增任意切法皆相容的公設。\n- 裁決:2026-10-06 稽核指出定義中的「本篇所說/本篇不主張」構成論文語境指示;改為直接陳述「結論經得起重切」的適用條件,並以「此定義不保證」表達任意切法未必相容。適用範圍與結論不變,中英文同步修改。\n\n\n## public 切法 / Cut\n\n- 定義:切法是分析者的一次[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18):把哪一段[宇宙](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c02)看作一個[迴路](concepts.md#c31)。敘述[迴路](concepts.md#c31)必須切出部分,所以切法無法避免,必須講明。\n- Definition: A cut is a [Distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) made by the analyst: which stretch of the [Universe](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c02) is taken as one [Loop](concepts.md#c31). Describing a [loop](concepts.md#c31) requires cutting out parts, so a cut cannot be avoided and must be stated.\n- 裁決:2026-09-30 定義中的底層詞改連《渦動力學》的公開條目,意義不變,保留 ID。\n\n\n## private 邊界 / Boundary\n\n- 定義:邊界是一個範例的地理邊界與時間邊界。它是一次[切法](concepts.md#c23),每個範例都必須先講明。\n- Definition: The boundary is the geographical and temporal boundary of a worked example. It is a [Cut](concepts.md#c23), and every example must state it first.\n\n\n## public 節點 / Node\n\n- 定義:節點是[切法](concepts.md#c23)下的一個[呈現](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c04),是假名。節點有三類:[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)、[信號容器](concepts.md#c26)、[隨機源](concepts.md#c27)。\n- Definition: A node is a [Presentation](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c04) under a [Cut](concepts.md#c23); it is a provisional name. There are three kinds of node: the [Wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16), the [Signal Container](concepts.md#c26), and the [Random Source](concepts.md#c27).\n- 裁決:2026-09-30 定義中的底層詞改連《渦動力學》的公開條目,意義不變,保留 ID。\n\n\n## public 信號容器 / Signal Container\n\n- 定義:信號容器是這樣的[節點](concepts.md#c25):它不是[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16),從這一[時刻](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c09)起每一步都被[鎖死](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c12)。它通常持續存在,在許多[時刻](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c09)向[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)[輸出](concepts.md#c28),但這不是條件。它的內容可以由[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)寫下,例如書、法條;也可以來自其他[呈現](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c04),例如望遠鏡帶來的觀測。[知見障](concepts.md#c35)對它沒有內容;它也不能成為[印象](concepts.md#c45)的對象。\n- Definition: A signal container is a [Node](concepts.md#c25) that is not a [Wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16) and, from this [moment](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c09) on, is [locked in](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c12) at every step. It usually persists and [outputs](concepts.md#c28) to [wos](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16) at many [Moments](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c09), but this is not a condition. Its content may be written by [wos](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16), as with books or statutes, or may come from other [Presentations](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c04), as with observations brought by a telescope. [Cognitive Obscuration](concepts.md#c35) has no content for it; nor can it be the object of an [Impression](concepts.md#c45).\n- 裁決:2026-09-28 作者裁決放寬定義:持續存在、向渦輸出不再是條件,使節點的分類窮盡。\n- 裁決:2026-09-30 定義中的底層詞改連《渦動力學》的公開條目,意義不變,保留 ID。\n- 裁決:2026-10-05 上游《渦動力學》勘誤後,渦的第二個條件改為往後看;本條隨之改為從這一刻起往後看,否則從某刻起永遠被鎖死、而歷史仍全部參與的節點,三類都不屬於。定稿前修改,保留 ID。\n- 裁決:2026-10-05 稽核指出定義中的「這一刻」指涉上游的時刻而未連結,補上連結。意義不變,保留 ID。\n\n\n## public 隨機源 / Random Source\n\n- 定義:隨機源是這樣的[節點](concepts.md#c25):它不是[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16),但這一[時刻](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c09)或之後至少還有一個[時刻](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c09)它不被[鎖死](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c12)。例如擲出的骰子、放射性衰變的原子。它不被[鎖死](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c12)時,只能談[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06);它也不能成為[印象](concepts.md#c45)的對象。\n- Definition: A random source is a [Node](concepts.md#c25) that is not a [Wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16), but at this [moment](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c09) or later there is still at least one [Moment](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c09) at which it is not [locked in](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c12). Examples are a thrown die and a radioactively decaying atom. When it is not [locked in](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c12), only its [weights](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06) can be discussed; nor can it be the object of an [Impression](concepts.md#c45).\n- 裁決:2026-09-28 作者裁決新增,使節點的分類窮盡。\n- 裁決:2026-09-30 定義中的底層詞改連《渦動力學》的公開條目,意義不變,保留 ID。\n- 裁決:2026-10-05 隨上游勘誤改為往後看,與信號容器一起使節點的分類仍然窮盡。「歷史並不都參與它的權重」是由渦的定義推出的後果,從定義移到論文正文(步驟十四)。定稿前修改,保留 ID。\n- 裁決:2026-10-05 稽核指出定義中的「這一刻」指涉上游的時刻而未連結,補上連結。意義不變,保留 ID。\n\n\n## public 輸出 / Output\n\n- 定義:輸出是一個[呈現](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c04)的[坍塌](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c08)結果,以及它的[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)內容。\n- Definition: The output of a [Presentation](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c04) is the outcomes of its [Collapses](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c08), together with the content of its [Distinctions](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18).\n- 裁決:2026-09-30 定義中的底層詞改連《渦動力學》的公開條目,意義不變,保留 ID。\n\n\n## public 邊 / Edge\n\n- 定義:邊是[節點](concepts.md#c25)之間有向的關係:一個[節點](concepts.md#c25)的[輸出](concepts.md#c28),參與另一個[節點](concepts.md#c25)的[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06)。邊本身不帶大小:一條邊影響多大,取決於接收者的[歷史](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13),不是邊本身的屬性。\n- Definition: An edge is a directed relation between [Nodes](concepts.md#c25): the [Output](concepts.md#c28) of one [node](concepts.md#c25) takes part in the [Weights](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06) of another. An edge carries no magnitude of its own: how much an edge matters depends on the receiver's [History](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13), not on the edge.\n- 裁決:2026-09-30 定義中的底層詞改連《渦動力學》的公開條目,意義不變,保留 ID。\n\n\n## private 時序 / Timing\n\n- 定義:時序是[邊](concepts.md#c29)的先後,以及[迴路](concepts.md#c31)繞一圈要多久;[節點](concepts.md#c25)可以在[邊界](concepts.md#c24)內的某個時間出現或消失。\n- Definition: Timing is the order in which [Edges](concepts.md#c29) occur and how long a [Loop](concepts.md#c31) takes to go round once; [Nodes](concepts.md#c25) may appear or disappear at some time within the [Boundary](concepts.md#c24).\n\n\n## public 迴路 / Loop\n\n- 定義:迴路是這樣的結構:一個[呈現](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c04)的[輸出](concepts.md#c28),經由自己或其他[呈現](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c04),又參與它自己的[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06)。迴路一律指在講明的[切法](concepts.md#c23)下的迴路;跨[時刻](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c09)持續存在是[不被保證](concepts.md#c02)的。\n- Definition: A loop is a structure in which the [Output](concepts.md#c28) of a [Presentation](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c04), through itself or through other [presentations](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c04), takes part again in its own [Weights](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06). A loop is always a loop under a stated [Cut](concepts.md#c23); persistence across [Moments](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c09) is [Not Guaranteed](concepts.md#c02).\n- 裁決:2026-09-30 定義中的底層詞改連《渦動力學》的公開條目,意義不變,保留 ID。\n\n\n## public 正回饋 / Positive Feedback\n\n- 定義:正回饋是[迴路](concepts.md#c31)的一種作用:[迴路](concepts.md#c31)自己的一次[輸出](concepts.md#c28)繞回來,把[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06)推向產生這次[輸出](concepts.md#c28)的那個方向。方向必須包含這次[輸出](concepts.md#c28),由它錨定;方向劃得多粗,屬於[切法](concepts.md#c23)。\n- Definition: Positive feedback is an action of a [Loop](concepts.md#c31): one of the loop's own [Outputs](concepts.md#c28) comes back round and pushes the [Weights](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06) toward the direction that produced that [output](concepts.md#c28). The direction must contain that [output](concepts.md#c28), which anchors it; how coarsely the direction is drawn belongs to the [Cut](concepts.md#c23).\n- 裁決:2026-09-30 定義中的底層詞改連《渦動力學》的公開條目,意義不變,保留 ID。\n\n\n## public 負回饋 / Negative Feedback\n\n- 定義:負回饋是[迴路](concepts.md#c31)的一種作用:[迴路](concepts.md#c31)自己的一次[輸出](concepts.md#c28)繞回來,把[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06)推離產生這次[輸出](concepts.md#c28)的那個方向。方向必須包含這次[輸出](concepts.md#c28),由它錨定;方向劃得多粗,屬於[切法](concepts.md#c23)。抵抗若來自另一個[迴路](concepts.md#c31)的[輸出](concepts.md#c28)經由[耦合](concepts.md#c36)壓過來,不是負回饋。\n- Definition: Negative feedback is an action of a [Loop](concepts.md#c31): one of the loop's own [Outputs](concepts.md#c28) comes back round and pushes the [Weights](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06) away from the direction that produced that [output](concepts.md#c28). The direction must contain that [output](concepts.md#c28), which anchors it; how coarsely the direction is drawn belongs to the [Cut](concepts.md#c23). Resistance that comes from the [output](concepts.md#c28) of another [loop](concepts.md#c31) pressing in through [Coupling](concepts.md#c36) is not negative feedback.\n- 裁決:2026-09-30 定義中的底層詞改連《渦動力學》的公開條目,意義不變,保留 ID。\n\n\n## public 速度 / Loop Speed\n\n- 定義:速度是[迴路](concepts.md#c31)繞一圈要多久,以[時鐘時間](concepts.md#c21)計,與[時刻](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c09)不同。\n- Definition: Loop speed is how long a [Loop](concepts.md#c31) takes to go round once, measured in [Clock Time](concepts.md#c21), which differs from [Moments](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c09).\n- 裁決:2026-09-30 定義中的底層詞改連《渦動力學》的公開條目,意義不變,保留 ID。\n\n\n## public 知見障 / Cognitive Obscuration\n\n- 定義:知見障是這件事:一個[呈現](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c04)在下一[時刻](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c09)各個結果的[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06),總和為一,所以推高一個方向,必然壓低其餘方向的總和。一切學習都有代價,知與障是同一件事。知見障只保證此消彼長,不決定一筆[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)推高哪個方向、推高多少。\n- Definition: Cognitive obscuration is the fact that the [Weights](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06) of the outcomes of a [Presentation](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c04) at its next [Moment](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c09) sum to one, so that pushing one direction up necessarily pushes the total of the other directions down. All learning has a cost; knowing and obscuration are one and the same. Cognitive obscuration guarantees only that one rises as the others fall; it does not decide which direction an [Arrival](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) pushes up, or by how much.\n- 裁決:2026-09-30 定義中的底層詞改連《渦動力學》的公開條目,意義不變,保留 ID。\n\n\n## public 耦合 / Coupling\n\n- 定義:耦合是這樣的情形:兩個或多個[呈現](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c04)的[自己的那一段](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c17),在一個講明的[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)上重疊。參與耦合的可以是[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16),也可以是由許多[呈現](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c04)構成的[迴路](concepts.md#c31)。重疊有兩種方式:同一件事[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)它們,例如同一個[輸出](concepts.md#c28),或[宇宙初態](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c14);或者它們的[輸出](concepts.md#c28)互相[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)。耦合總是相對於一個講明的[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)而言。\n- Definition: Coupling is the situation in which the [Own Segments](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c17) of two or more [Presentations](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c04) overlap in a stated [Arrival](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10). What takes part in coupling may be [Wos](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16), or [Loops](concepts.md#c31) made of many [presentations](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c04). The overlap takes one of two forms: the same thing [arrives](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at all of them, such as the same [Output](concepts.md#c28) or the [Initial State of the Universe](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c14), or their [outputs](concepts.md#c28) [arrive](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at one another. Coupling is always relative to a stated [arrival](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10).\n- 裁決:2026-09-29 稽核指出宇宙初態不是輸出,與「任何兩個渦都在宇宙初態上耦合」衝突;第一種方式由「同一個輸出」放寬為「同一件事」,兩種方式仍窮盡。定稿前修改,保留 ID。\n- 裁決:2026-09-30 定義中的底層詞改連《渦動力學》的公開條目,意義不變,保留 ID。\n\n\n## public 趨同 / Convergence\n\n- 定義:趨同是[耦合](concepts.md#c36)之下的一種走向:在一個講明的維度上,參與者[輸出](concepts.md#c28)的模式之間的距離縮短。\n- Definition: Convergence is one direction of development under [Coupling](concepts.md#c36): along a stated dimension, the distance between the patterns of the participants' [Outputs](concepts.md#c28) shrinks.\n\n\n## public 趨異 / Divergence\n\n- 定義:趨異是[耦合](concepts.md#c36)之下的一種走向:在一個講明的維度上,參與者[輸出](concepts.md#c28)的模式之間的距離拉長。\n- Definition: Divergence is one direction of development under [Coupling](concepts.md#c36): along a stated dimension, the distance between the patterns of the participants' [Outputs](concepts.md#c28) grows.\n\n\n## public 太極 / Taiji\n\n- 定義:太極是這樣的結構:兩個方向相反的[正回饋](concepts.md#c32)[迴路](concepts.md#c31)互相[耦合](concepts.md#c36),在[耦合](concepts.md#c36)中[趨異](concepts.md#c38),形成動態平衡。每一方的[輸出](concepts.md#c28)[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)另一方,都強化了另一方自己的方向,所以任何一方壯大,都在餵養對方。太極發生在[迴路](concepts.md#c31)與[迴路](concepts.md#c31)之間,不要求每個參與者都是[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16);「方向相反」必須講明是在哪一個維度上判斷。\n- Definition: Taiji is a structure in which two [Loops](concepts.md#c31) of [Positive Feedback](concepts.md#c32) pointing in opposite directions are [coupled](concepts.md#c36) with each other and show [Divergence](concepts.md#c38) within that [coupling](concepts.md#c36), forming a dynamic balance. Each side's [Output](concepts.md#c28), [arriving](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at the other, strengthens the other's own direction, so whichever side grows is feeding its opponent. Taiji takes place between [loops](concepts.md#c31), and does not require every participant to be a [Wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16); for \"opposite directions\", the dimension on which this is judged must be stated.\n- 裁決:2026-09-30 定義中的底層詞改連《渦動力學》的公開條目,意義不變,保留 ID。\n\n\n## public 一方退出 / Withdrawal of One Side\n\n- 定義:一方退出是[太極](concepts.md#c39)結束的一種方式:其中一方的[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)大多[退場](concepts.md#c43),或者它不再自我強化。\n- Definition: Withdrawal of one side is one way a [Taiji](concepts.md#c39) ends: most of the [Wos](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16) on one side [exit](concepts.md#c43), or that side no longer reinforces itself.\n\n\n## public 合流 / Merging\n\n- 定義:合流是[太極](concepts.md#c39)結束的一種方式:[耦合](concepts.md#c36)的走向由[趨異](concepts.md#c38)轉為[趨同](concepts.md#c37),兩個[迴路](concepts.md#c31)合成一個。在[重切](concepts.md#c22)之下,這也可以看作兩個[迴路](concepts.md#c31)被切成了一個。\n- Definition: Merging is one way a [Taiji](concepts.md#c39) ends: the [Coupling](concepts.md#c36) turns from [Divergence](concepts.md#c38) to [Convergence](concepts.md#c37), and the two [Loops](concepts.md#c31) become one. Under [Recutting](concepts.md#c22), this can also be seen as the two [loops](concepts.md#c31) being cut as one.\n\n\n## public 更新 / Renewal\n\n- 定義:更新是[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)的進出:有些[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)[退場](concepts.md#c43),有些[呈現](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c04)[進場](concepts.md#c44)。\n- Definition: Renewal is the going and coming of [Wos](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16): some [wos](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16) [exit](concepts.md#c43) and some [Presentations](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c04) [enter](concepts.md#c44).\n- 裁決:2026-09-30 定義中的底層詞改連《渦動力學》的公開條目,意義不變,保留 ID。\n- 裁決:2026-10-05 退場、進場改為只連結引用,不在本條重述其定義。意義不變,保留 ID。\n- 裁決:2026-10-05 刪去「新渦的自己的那一段和舊渦的重疊,但不可能完全相同」:重疊由任何兩個渦都在宇宙初態上重疊推出,不完全相同由不可復原律推出,兩者都是後果,不是定義,留在論文正文。定稿前修改,保留 ID。\n- 裁決:2026-10-05 更正前一裁決:「不可復原律」不能推出進場者與舊渦的[自己的那一段](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c17)必然不完全相同。不同[個體](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c20)可以共享共同前史,分開後可依新的[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)與[寫入](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c29)而分岔,之後也可以合併;是否為[同一](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c21)屬於[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18),不由更新或歷史重疊本身決定。正文與形式化同步刪除「不可能完全相同」。定稿前修改,保留 ID。\n\n\n## public 退場 / Exit\n\n- 定義:退場是一個[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)不再是[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16):它在某一[時刻](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c09)是[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16),在它的下一[時刻](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c09)不是[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)。\n- Definition: Exit is a [Wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16) ceasing to be a [wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16): it is a [wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16) at one [Moment](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c09) and is not a [wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16) at its next [moment](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c09).\n- 裁決:2026-09-28 名稱由「出」改為「退場」。\n- 裁決:2026-09-30 定義中的底層詞改連《渦動力學》的公開條目,意義不變,保留 ID。\n- 裁決:2026-10-05 退場就是渦不再是渦:刪去多加的條件「參與消失」;刪去「自己的那一段仍在歷史裡」「留下的輸出仍可透過信號容器到達後來的渦」兩句,它們是後果,不是定義,留在論文正文。定稿前修改,保留 ID。\n- 裁決:2026-10-05 補上以它自己相鄰的兩個時刻比較:若凍結期間沒有坍塌涉及它,凍結期間就沒有它的時刻,解凍後若仍是渦,就不算退場。\n\n\n## public 進場 / Entry\n\n- 定義:進場是一個[呈現](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c04)開始成為[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16):它在某一[時刻](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c09)不是[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16),在它的下一[時刻](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c09)是[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16);或者在它的第一個[時刻](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c09)就是[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)。\n- Definition: Entry is a [Presentation](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c04) beginning to be a [Wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16): it is not a [wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16) at one [Moment](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c09) and is a [wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16) at its next [moment](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c09), or it is already a [wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16) at its first [moment](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c09).\n- 裁決:2026-09-28 名稱由「入」改為「進場」。\n- 裁決:2026-09-30 定義中的底層詞改連《渦動力學》的公開條目,意義不變,保留 ID。\n- 裁決:2026-10-05 比照退場:進場就是一個呈現開始成為渦;「自己的那一段和舊渦的重疊」屬於更新的內容,從本條刪去,留在論文正文。定稿前修改,保留 ID。\n- 裁決:2026-10-05 比照退場,以它自己相鄰的兩個時刻比較;第一個時刻就是渦,也算進場。\n\n\n## public 印象 / Impression\n\n- 定義:印象是一個[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19)對一個[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)的[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18),也就是它對那個[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)的[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06)的估計。對象可以是另一個[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16),也可以是這個[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19)自己,此時是[自我印象](concepts.md#c46)。對[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)的一切統計估計,包括史料的統計,都屬於印象。印象的材料有三個來源:對方過去的[輸出](concepts.md#c28);[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19)自己和對方重疊的[那一段](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c17);對方所在的[耦合](concepts.md#c36),例如角色、制度、信仰。\n- Definition: An impression is a [Distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) made by a [Self](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19) of a [Wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16), that is, its estimate of that [wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)'s [Weights](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06). The object may be another [wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16) or the [self](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19) itself, in which case it is a [Self-Impression](concepts.md#c46). Every statistical estimate about a [wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16), including statistics of historical records, is an impression. The material of an impression has three sources: the other's past [Outputs](concepts.md#c28); the part of the self's [own segment](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c17) that overlaps with the other's; and the [Couplings](concepts.md#c36) the other is in, such as roles, institutions and beliefs.\n- 裁決:2026-09-30 定義中的底層詞改連《渦動力學》的公開條目,意義不變,保留 ID。\n\n\n## public 自我印象 / Self-Impression\n\n- 定義:自我印象是對象為自己的[印象](concepts.md#c45):一個[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19)對自己的[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)。\n- Definition: A self-impression is an [Impression](concepts.md#c45) whose object is oneself: a [Self](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19)'s [Distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) of itself.\n\n\n## public 份量 / Impact\n\n- 定義:份量是一筆[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)能移動多少[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06),是[生成函數](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c15)內部的事。份量不能相加:一筆[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)的效果,取決於它之前的[歷史](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13)。\n- Definition: The impact of an [Arrival](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) is how much [Weight](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06) it can move; it is a matter internal to the [Generating Function](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c15). Impacts do not add up: the effect of an [arrival](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) depends on the [History](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13) before it.\n- 裁決:2026-09-30 定義中的底層詞改連《渦動力學》的公開條目,意義不變,保留 ID。\n\n\n## public 頻率 / Frequency\n\n- 定義:頻率是[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)多常發生。它是應用時必須寫明的[份量](concepts.md#c47)假定之一。\n- Definition: Frequency is how often an [Arrival](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) happens. It is one of the assumptions about [Impact](concepts.md#c47) that an application must state.\n- 裁決:2026-09-30 定義中的底層詞改連《渦動力學》的公開條目,意義不變,保留 ID。\n\n\n## public 歧異度 / Discrepancy\n\n- 定義:歧異度是一筆[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)和接收者過去收到的東西差多遠。它是相對於接收者的[歷史](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13)而言的:同一個[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10),落在不同的[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)上,歧異度可以完全不同。它是應用時必須寫明的[份量](concepts.md#c47)假定之一。\n- Definition: Discrepancy is how far an [Arrival](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) lies from what the receiver has received before. It is relative to the receiver's [History](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13): the same [arrival](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10), falling on different [Wos](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16), can have entirely different discrepancy. It is one of the assumptions about [Impact](concepts.md#c47) that an application must state.\n- 裁決:2026-09-30 定義中的底層詞改連《渦動力學》的公開條目,意義不變,保留 ID。\n\n\n## public 應用假定 / Application Assumption\n\n- 定義:應用假定是這個假定:在生物學與社會科學的層次上,一個[呈現](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c04)的下一[時刻](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c09)若不能由那個層次可得的[歷史](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13)唯一推出,就假定它不被[鎖死](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c12)。它不是定理。\n- Definition: The application assumption is the assumption that, at the levels of biology and the social sciences, if the next [moment](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c09) of a [Presentation](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c04) cannot be uniquely derived from the [History](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13) available at that level, it is assumed not to be [locked in](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c12). It is not a theorem.\n- 裁決:2026-09-30 定義中的底層詞改連《渦動力學》的公開條目,意義不變,保留 ID。\n- 裁決:2026-10-05 稽核指出定義中的「下一刻」指涉上游的時刻而未連結,補上連結。意義不變,保留 ID。\n\n\n## public 經驗禁止 / Empirical Prohibition\n\n- 定義:經驗禁止是從案例中提煉出的必要條件:缺少某個條件時,某個結局[不會發生](concepts.md#c01)。它不是由框架推出,而是由跨案例的校準得來,必須標明,並可以被新的案例修改。它只寫必要條件,不寫充分條件:條件都滿足時,也只能說那個結局的[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06)變重。\n- Definition: An empirical prohibition is a necessary condition distilled from cases: without a certain condition, a certain outcome [Never Occurs](concepts.md#c01). It is not derived from the framework but obtained by calibration across cases, so it must be marked as such and may be revised by new cases. It states only necessary conditions, never sufficient ones: even when all the conditions are met, one can only say that the [Weight](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06) of that outcome has become heavier.\n- 裁決:2026-09-30 定義中的底層詞改連《渦動力學》的公開條目,意義不變,保留 ID。\n\n\n## public 持平 / Stasis\n\n- 定義:持平是[耦合](concepts.md#c36)之下的一種走向:在一個講明的維度上,參與者[輸出](concepts.md#c28)的模式之間的距離不變。\n- Definition: Stasis is one direction of development under [Coupling](concepts.md#c36): along a stated dimension, the distance between the patterns of the participants' [Outputs](concepts.md#c28) stays the same.\n- 裁決:2026-09-28 作者裁決新增,使耦合之下的走向窮盡。\n\n\n## private 刺激 / Stimulus\n\n- 定義:一次[寫入](concepts.md#c09)中落在一個[呈現](concepts.md#c04)身上的部分,以及落在它身上的[坍塌](concepts.md#c07)結果,都是它收到的刺激。也就是說,刺激是這個[呈現](concepts.md#c04)所處的物理條件的改變,不論來自外界還是它自己;自己或別人作出的[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18),落在它身上時,也算在內。\n- Definition: The part of a [Writing](concepts.md#c09) that falls on a [Presentation](concepts.md#c04), and the outcome of a [Collapse](concepts.md#c07) that falls on it, are both stimuli it receives. In other words, a stimulus is a change in the physical conditions the [presentation](concepts.md#c04) is in, whether it comes from outside or from the presentation itself; [distinctions](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) made by itself or by others are included when they fall on it.\n- 狀態:已廢棄\n- 裁決:2026-09-29 判定與上游《渦動力學》的刺激(c30)不是同一概念:上游為 private,本篇在自己的前提下重新定義。\n- 裁決:2026-09-30 廢棄:本篇直接引用《渦動力學》的刺激(c30),不再自行定義。\n\n\n## private 復原 / Restoration\n\n- 定義:復原是讓一個[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)[自己的那一段](concepts.md#c16),整段再發生一次。也就是說,它的一切物理狀態,時間逆流,回到過去的某一個[時刻](concepts.md#c08)。\n- Definition: Restoration is making the whole of a [Wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)'s [Own Segment](concepts.md#c16) happen once again. In other words, all of its physical states flow back in time to some past [Moment](concepts.md#c08).\n- 狀態:已廢棄\n- 裁決:2026-09-29 判定與上游《渦動力學》的復原(c27)不是同一概念:上游為 private,本篇在自己的前提下重新定義。\n- 裁決:2026-09-30 廢棄:本篇直接引用《渦動力學》的復原(c27),不再自行定義。\n\n## 不登記\n\n- 對世界的禁止:2026-09-28 小節標題,其下說明句只是導讀,不是概念。\n- 對說法的禁止:2026-09-28 小節標題,其下說明句只是導讀,不是概念。\n- 方法上禁止:2026-09-28 對說法的禁止的形式標籤,指的是同一批禁止,不另立。\n- 推出的不可能:2026-09-28 正文未另加定義,只用來與「沒出現過」對照。\n- 禁止:2026-09-28 一般用語,正文未作為術語定義。\n- 四條律:2026-09-28 流變律、黑箱律、損耗律、不可復原律的總稱,各律為上游概念。\n- 具名推論與前提:2026-09-28 歷史不失去任何東西、對方可能因此改變、權重的形狀可以重複、知見障的出路,皆為論證中的具名命題,不是概念。\n- 範例中的條件:2026-09-28 容器、持續的高歧異到達、舊一方缺少對等的到達、更新(條件四),皆為經驗禁止的實例,是命題,不是概念。\n- 目的:2026-09-28 作者裁決不登記:明文第 6 條描述的是目的的特質,不是定義;目的不供引用。\n- 一般用語:2026-09-28 經驗假定、史實、校準、高維、嵌套、維度、模式,正文未作為術語定義。\n- 形式段名稱:2026-09-28 次序、分支集合、寫入規則、寫入後歷史、坍塌結果、歷史唯一、結果投影、未落在其上、推前、位置、替換、替換值、分布、實際值、時刻集合、分別內容、相互耦合、前一時刻,只出現在形式段,屬形式化階段的記號。\n\n## 待決項\n\n無\n","formalization_md":"論文:《四條律相關工具及範例》\nUUID:b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6\n\n## 記號約定\n\n來源:論文全文\n\n- 史料:一般用語,指人類留下的記錄,不是概念 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.歷史\n- 日心一方、地靜一方、研發一方:範例中 太極 兩方的稱呼,不是概念\n\n## 前置條件\n\n來源:論文第〇節、第一節、第四節第 5 小節、第五節【正文:句9654277750、句7444990975、句1196755111、句5898529680】\n\n- 前提一:37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.生成函數 只有一個,不隨 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.時刻 改變。 【正文:句1354617883】\n- 前提二:任何 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦 都量不到 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.時刻 ; 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.時刻 只是 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.坍塌 的次序。 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦 以時鐘量到的是 時鐘時間 ,依物理,不形式化。 【正文:句6355190525、句1304862302】\n- 前提三:不同的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.歷史 可以對應到形狀相近的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.權重 。 【正文:句7155889376】\n- 前提四:在生物學與社會科學的層次上,一個 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.呈現 的下一 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.時刻 若不能由那個層次可得的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.歷史 唯一推出,就假定它不被 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.鎖死 。這條前提即 應用假定 。 【正文:句9250249953】\n- 前提五:本篇的範例採用以下經驗假定:重複而 歧異度 低的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 ,效果遞減;罕見而 歧異度 高的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 ,一次可以壓過長期的累積;接收者的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.歷史 愈集中, 歧異度 高的衝擊愈可能被解釋掉,而不是翻轉它。 【正文:句0357770363】\n- 前提六:本篇把一個 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.我 說出的任何話,看作它的一筆 輸出 ;所說的內容以某個對象為對象時,是一次 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別 。 【正文:句4257663939】\n\n## 定位\n\n來源:論文第〇節【正文:句9654277750】\n\n- 步驟一:由四條律與本篇的設定推出的禁止,對過去與未來的每一個 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.時刻 都成立:四條律與本篇的設定對每一個 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.時刻 都成立, 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.生成函數 也只有一個(從 前提一 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.流變律 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.黑箱律 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.損耗律 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.不可復原律 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.時刻 的定義 推出) 【正文:句9105735356】\n- 附註:對史料的統計只能在可行域之內給出 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.權重 ,不能給出禁止。\n- 附註:本框架的結論,除了 印象 以外,都不依賴心智。\n- 附註:括號中其他學科的名稱只是路標,不帶定義,不可據以推論。\n- 附註:37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.流變律 、 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.黑箱律 、 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.損耗律 、 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.不可復原律 是本篇的公理,不由本篇的任何定義推出;它們是本篇禁止的主要來源,其餘禁止由本篇的設定推出。【正文:句5216737829、句1467824747】\n- 附註: 對他者認識的不可完備性 與 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.損耗律 是相同的結構,前者朝向別人,後者朝向自己。\n\n## 設定\n\n來源:論文第一節【正文:句7444990975】\n\n- 步驟二:若論文第一節 粒度 形式式的前件「結果投影(某 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.呈現 ) 等於 某映射 合成 結果投影(另一 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.呈現 )」成立,則「37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.權重(次序,某 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.呈現 ) 等於 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.權重(次序,另一 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.呈現 ) 經 某映射 推前」成立(從 粒度 的定義 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.權重 的定義 推出) 【正文:句2713174847、句2758796470】\n\n```text\n形式:\n粒度:若 結果投影(某呈現) 等於 某映射 合成 結果投影(另一呈現),\n 則 權重(次序,某呈現) 等於 權重(次序,另一呈現) 經 某映射 推前\n```\n【正文:句2758796470】\n\n- 步驟三:蘊含(一個 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦 不再是 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦 , 它的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.自己的那一段 仍完整地留在 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.歷史 中)(從 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.歷史 的定義 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.自己的那一段 的定義 推出) 【正文:句9970414800】\n- 步驟四:蘊含(一次 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別 留下的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.寫入 屬於另一個 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.呈現 的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.自己的那一段 , 把它換成別的會改變該 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.呈現 下一 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.時刻 的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.權重 分布)(從 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別 的定義 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.自己的那一段 的定義 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.寫入 的定義 推出) 【正文:句9708969942】\n- 步驟五: 對他者認識的不可完備性 成立(從 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別 的定義 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 的定義 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.自己的那一段 的定義 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.寫入 的定義 + 步驟四 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.流變律 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.黑箱律 推出) 【正文:句5482569315、句9970956782、句5600692260】\n- 步驟六:每一個 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.時刻 , 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.歷史 都多了新的一筆(從 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.歷史 的定義 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.時刻 的定義 推出) 【正文:句6750590520】\n- 附註:常新的是 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.歷史 ,無新事的是 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.權重 。\n\n## 基本單位\n\n來源:論文第二節【正文:句5757576300】\n\n- 步驟七: 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.宇宙 中沒有具有固定核心的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.我 (從 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦 的定義 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.我 的定義 推出) 【正文:句6627437078】\n- 步驟八:以 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.個體 為單位推論時,若把 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.個體 當成跨 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.時刻 不變的東西,就等於在底層放回一個固定核心(從 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.個體 的定義 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.同一 的定義 + 步驟七 推出) 【正文:句3057444053】\n- 步驟九:蘊含(某 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.呈現 是 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦 ,且在某 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.時刻 之前有過 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.時刻 , 該 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.呈現 構成 迴路 )(從 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.時刻 的定義 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 的定義 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦 的定義 + 輸出 的定義 + 迴路 的定義 推出) 【正文:句8408229684、句0404936659】\n- 附註: 迴路 不都是 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦 ;一個 迴路 要在某個 切法 下符合 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦 的定義,才是 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦 。\n- 步驟十:把一段 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.宇宙 切成一個 迴路 或許多嵌套的 迴路 時,若各層結果投影滿足 粒度 的相容條件,則相應的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.權重 一致(從 步驟二 + 粒度 的定義 + 迴路 的定義 推出) 【正文:句3777445493】\n- 附註:除 印象 以外,每個工具的結論都必須經得起 重切 ;此處 重切 限於滿足 粒度 的結果投影相容條件者。描述 迴路 之間關係的工具( 耦合 、 太極 、 印象 ),在合併時轉為內部結構。\n- 步驟十一: 切法 講明之後,它是不是 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦 ,不由 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別 決定(從 切法 的定義 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦 的定義 推出) 【正文:句4147497439】\n- 附註:需要分出「那是他」才說得出來的工具,只有 印象 一個。\n\n## 記號\n\n來源:論文第三節【正文:句2994820891】\n\n- 步驟十二:互斥分類(節點 , 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦 , 信號容器 , 隨機源 )(從 節點 的定義 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦 的定義 + 信號容器 的定義 + 隨機源 的定義 推出) 【正文:句3395497307】\n- 步驟十三:蘊含(某 節點 是 信號容器 或 隨機源 , 它不能成為 印象 的對象)(從 印象 的定義 + 信號容器 的定義 + 隨機源 的定義 推出) 【正文:句8533369802、句1903621813】\n- 步驟十四:蘊含(某 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.呈現 是 隨機源 , 現在 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 它的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.歷史 並不都參與它的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.權重 ,或者在它其後不被 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.鎖死 的每一個 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.時刻 都是如此)(從 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦 的定義 + 隨機源 的定義 推出) 【正文:句0085569166】\n- 步驟十五:蘊含(某 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.呈現 是 信號容器 , 知見障 對它沒有內容)(從 知見障 的定義 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.鎖死 的定義 + 信號容器 的定義 推出) 【正文:句8533369802】\n- 附註: 邊 本身不帶大小;一條 邊 影響多大,取決於接收者的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.歷史 。\n- 附註: 邊 是直接還是間接,隨 切法 而定。\n\n```text\n形式:\n輸出(某呈現) 等於 {第 某次序 次坍塌的結果位置,其中 某次序 屬於 時刻集合(某呈現)}\n 聯集 {分別內容(某呈現,某次序) 的位置}\n邊(某呈現,另一呈現,次序) 當且僅當 存在 位置 屬於 輸出(某呈現),\n 且 該位置 屬於 自己的那一段(另一呈現,次序)\n```\n【正文:句3021262736】\n\n## 迴路\n\n來源:論文第四節第 1 小節【正文:句0182185033】\n\n- 步驟十六:一個 迴路 持續下去,是 不被保證 的(從 不被保證 的定義 + 迴路 的定義 推出) 【正文:句1971319902】\n- 步驟十七: 速度 以 時鐘時間 計,與 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.時刻 不同(從 速度 的定義 + 前提二 推出) 【正文:句6898877905】\n- 附註:一個 迴路 遇到的抵抗,若來自另一個 迴路 的 輸出 經由 耦合 壓過來,不是 負回饋 ; 負回饋 不能用兩個 正回饋 迴路 的 耦合 代替。\n\n```text\n形式:\n迴路(某呈現,次序) 當且僅當 存在 位置 屬於 輸出(某呈現),位置 在 寫入後歷史(次序) 中,\n 且 位置 屬於 自己的那一段(某呈現,次序)\n正負:設 某方向 包含於 某呈現 的結果集合,位置 為 某呈現 落在 某方向 的一次結果,\n 另一次序 在 位置 之後。\n 記 實際分布 等於 分布(權重(另一次序,某呈現) 在 某方向 上的總和,\n 已知 替換(位置,實際值))\n 記 對照分布 等於 分布(權重(另一次序,某呈現) 在 某方向 上的總和,\n 已知 替換(位置,某方向之外的值))\n 若對每一個門檻,實際分布超過該門檻的機率都不小於對照分布,且至少一處較大,\n 為正回饋;\n 若反過來,為負回饋;\n 其餘情形,不分正負。\n```\n【正文:句7075906077】\n\n## 知見障\n\n來源:論文第四節第 2 小節【正文:句7643105005】\n\n- 步驟十八:蘊含(一個 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.呈現 在某方向上的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.權重 總和上升 , 它在其餘方向上的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.權重 總和下降)(從 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.權重 的定義 推出) 【正文:句5496675695】\n- 步驟十九:「推高一方,而其餘的總和不降」是 不會發生 的(從 步驟十八 推出) 【正文:句0253122431】\n- 附註: 知見障 只保證此消彼長,不決定一筆 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 推高哪個方向、推高多少。\n- 附註:不同環境之間的取捨、影響的大小、泛化的範圍,都不是 知見障 推出來的。\n- 例:「回不到文盲的時候」:「那個還不識字的自己再次發生」是 不會發生 的(從 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.不可復原律 推出)。 【正文:句3876435760】\n- 例:「很難理解文盲」:那段經歷仍在 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.歷史 中,但對它的 印象 是現在這個 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.我 作出的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別 ,而當時那個還不識字的自己不會再發生;「解釋得了當初那樣做的合理性」是 不被保證 的;對象是過去的自己時,是 自我印象 (從 步驟三 + 不被保證 的定義 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別 的定義 + 印象 的定義 + 自我印象 的定義 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.不可復原律 推出)。 【正文:句8457325374、句0026847753】\n- 附註:「完全無法」是極端的集中,屬於經驗描述;這兩例都不是 知見障 推出來的。\n\n```text\n形式:\n設 某方向 包含於 某呈現 的結果集合。\n權重(次序,某呈現) 在 某方向 上的總和 加 在 某方向之外 的總和 等於 一\n```\n【正文:句1978800880】\n\n## 耦合\n\n來源:論文第四節第 3 小節【正文:句2368003311】\n\n- 步驟二十:任何兩個 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦 都在 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.宇宙初態 這一次 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 上 耦合 (從 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.宇宙初態 的定義 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 的定義 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦 的定義 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.自己的那一段 的定義 + 耦合 的定義 推出) 【正文:句2037455380】\n- 附註:不講明是哪一個 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 ,說兩個 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦 耦合 ,沒有內容。\n- 步驟二十一:在一個講明的維度上, 耦合 之下的走向只有 趨同 、 趨異 、 持平 三種,彼此互斥,且窮盡(從 趨同 的定義 + 趨異 的定義 + 持平 的定義 推出) 【正文:句2870508294、句0572904525、句6996870904、句6531295495】\n- 附註:一段 耦合 可以在一個維度上 趨同 ,同時在另一個維度上 趨異 ;選哪一個維度,是分析者的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別 。\n- 步驟二十二: 耦合 在任何維度上 趨同 是 不被保證 的, 趨異 、 持平 也是 不被保證 的(從 不被保證 的定義 + 耦合 的定義 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.黑箱律 推出) 【正文:句8342243339】\n- 步驟二十三: 趨同 的結果相同,是 不被保證 的(從 不被保證 的定義 + 趨同 的定義 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.歷史 的定義 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.生成函數 的定義 推出) 【正文:句3046964568】\n\n```text\n形式:\n耦合(甲,乙,位置,次序) 當且僅當 位置 屬於 到達(甲,次序) 交集 到達(乙,次序),\n 且 位置 屬於 自己的那一段(甲,次序) 交集 自己的那一段(乙,次序)\n相互耦合(甲,乙,次序) 當且僅當 存在 位置甲 屬於 輸出(甲) 交集 到達(乙,次序)\n 且 位置甲 屬於 自己的那一段(乙,次序),\n 且 存在 位置乙 屬於 輸出(乙) 交集 到達(甲,次序)\n 且 位置乙 屬於 自己的那一段(甲,次序)\n```\n【正文:句9834549571】\n\n## 太極\n\n來源:論文第四節第 3 小節「推:太極」【正文:句9510152509】\n\n- 步驟二十四: 一方退出 與 合流 都是 太極 結束的方式(從 一方退出 的定義 + 合流 的定義 推出) 【正文:句5680259079、句2220971277】\n- 步驟二十五: 合流 在 重切 之下,可以看作兩個 迴路 被切成一個(從 重切 的定義 + 合流 的定義 推出) 【正文:句0283929611】\n- 附註: 太極 發生在 迴路 與 迴路 之間,不是某一個 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦 的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.權重 此消彼長;它不要求每個參與者都是 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦 。\n- 附註:「方向相反」要選定維度才能判斷,屬於 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別 。\n- 步驟二十六: 太極 結束是 不被保證 的;結束時以哪一方消失或以 合流 結束,也是 不被保證 的(從 不被保證 的定義 + 太極 的定義 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.黑箱律 推出) 【正文:句2668573576】\n- 附註:「一方消失」要在某個 切法 下判斷,屬於 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別 。\n- 附註:形式段只寫出 太極 的結構前提;方向相反、 趨異 、動態平衡與結束的方式,都要選定維度並比較 輸出 ,屬於 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別 ,不形式化。\n\n```text\n形式:\n迴路(甲,次序) 且 迴路(乙,次序) 且 相互耦合(甲,乙,次序)\n```\n【正文:句4741080534】\n\n## 更新\n\n來源:論文第四節第 4 小節【正文:句1793313928】\n\n- 步驟二十七:蘊含(退場 , 退場 的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦 的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.自己的那一段 仍在 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.歷史 中)(從 退場 的定義 + 步驟三 推出) 【正文:句0241996722】\n- 步驟二十八: 更新 中的 進場 者與既有或 退場 的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦 ,其 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.自己的那一段 可以重疊;至少可以在 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.宇宙初態 這一次 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 上有共同部分(從 更新 的定義 + 步驟二十 推出) 【正文:句8164590417、句4654440869、句2037455380】\n- 步驟二十九:沒有任何 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦 處在與前一 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.時刻 相同的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.歷史 裡(從 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.流變律 推出) 【正文:句3682822861】\n- 例:本例效準:本例把冷凍與解凍各對應到一個 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.坍塌 ,且都 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.涉及 這隻昆蟲,並假定昆蟲在冷凍與解凍這兩個 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.時刻 都是 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦 。【正文:句9179184559】\n- 例:若冷凍與解凍之間沒有其他 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.坍塌 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.涉及 它,則中間對它沒有新的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.時刻 ,解凍是冷凍後它的下一 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.時刻 ;解凍時 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 它的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.歷史 與冷凍時不同;相同反應是 不被保證 的,但不主張反應必然不同(從 本例效準 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.時刻 的定義 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.流變律 + 不被保證 的定義 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.生成函數 的定義 推出)【正文:句2728654313、句8846936655、句1482477025】\n- 附註:若凍結期間沒有 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.時刻 ,這段期間不是 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.鎖死 ,此時也不把它當作 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦 討論;凍結停不下 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.歷史 。\n- 例:在上述假定下,冷凍時與解凍時昆蟲都是 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦 ,而解凍是它冷凍後的下一 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.時刻 ,因此冷凍不是 退場 (從 本例效準 + 退場 的定義 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.時刻 的定義 推出)。 【正文:句0736741022】\n- 步驟三十:「一個 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦 所在的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.歷史 在某個 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.時刻 之後不再改變」是 不會發生 的(從 步驟二十九 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.流變律 推出) 【正文:句9482193763】\n- 步驟三十一:退場 的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦 那些不被 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.鎖死 的選擇重來,是 不被保證 的(從 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.不可復原律 推出) 【正文:句4658069396】\n- 步驟三十二:一段 耦合 中的 趨同 ,在參與的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦 經過 更新 之後原樣延續,是 不被保證 的(從 不被保證 的定義 + 趨同 的定義 + 更新 的定義 + 步驟三十一 推出) 【正文:句9524818883】\n- 步驟三十三:37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.宇宙 只有一部 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.歷史 ,且它在每一個 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.時刻 持續追加;因此比較全域上不同 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.時刻 時, 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.歷史 的內容不同。這不表示每個 迴路 、國家、文化各有一部自己的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.歷史 ;要不要說它變成了不同的東西,屬於 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別 (從 步驟六 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.歷史 的定義 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別 的定義 + 切法 的定義 推出) 【正文:句6750590520、句0308886200】\n- 附註:本篇不斷言任何 迴路 、國家、文化必然消失;消失、滅亡都是標記,屬於 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別 。\n- 附註:「原樣」要在某個 切法 下判斷。\n- 附註:「原樣延續」要把 進場 者與 退場 者對應為 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.同一 ,屬於 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別 ,不形式化。\n- 附註: 知見障 不是需要被解除的障礙物,而是 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.權重 總和為一時的結構性此消彼長; 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.權重 重新分配時,知與障的配置也隨之改變。 更新 只描述 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦 的進出;本篇不把 更新 指定為處理 知見障 的特別機制,也不比較 更新 與其他改變方式的效果。\n- 例:本例效準:科學對清末一輩子浸在科舉中的士人是 歧異度 高的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 ,而這群士人的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.歷史 集中於科舉。 【正文:句4900255027】\n- 例:清末士人面對科學這種 歧異度 高的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 ,較可能把它解釋掉,而不是被它翻轉(從 前提五 + 本例效準 推出)。 【正文:句4900255027】\n\n```text\n形式:\n前一時刻(某呈現,次序):時刻集合(某呈現) 中小於 次序 的最大者;若不存在則未定義\n退場(某呈現,次序) 當且僅當 次序 屬於 時刻集合(某呈現),前一時刻存在,\n 且 渦(某呈現,前一時刻(某呈現,次序)) 且 非 渦(某呈現,次序)\n進場(某呈現,次序) 當且僅當 次序 屬於 時刻集合(某呈現),且 渦(某呈現,次序),\n 且 前一時刻不存在,或 非 渦(某呈現,前一時刻(某呈現,次序))\n```\n【正文:句8323569176】\n\n## 印象\n\n來源:論文第四節第 5 小節【正文:句1196755111】\n\n- 步驟三十四: 印象 作為一次 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別 ,會在 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.歷史 中留下一次 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.寫入 (從 印象 的定義 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別 的定義 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.寫入 的定義 推出) 【正文:句4149551719】\n- 步驟三十五:蘊含(印象 這次 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別 留下的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.寫入 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 對方,並成為對方 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.自己的那一段 的一部分 , 對方下一 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.時刻 的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.權重 分布可能改變)(從 步驟四 + 步驟三十四 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 的定義 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.自己的那一段 的定義 推出) 【正文:句4149551719】\n- 步驟三十六:蘊含(對方改變後的 輸出 再 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 這個 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.我 , 印象 形成 迴路 )(從 步驟三十五 + 印象 的定義 + 輸出 的定義 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.我 的定義 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦 的定義 + 迴路 的定義 推出) 【正文:句4149551719】\n- 步驟三十七:對一個不被 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.鎖死 的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦 ,以任何 印象 唯一推出它的下一 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.時刻 ,是 不會發生 的;對象是自己時也一樣(從 印象 的定義 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.黑箱律 推出) 【正文:句8312966357】\n- 步驟三十八:一個 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.我 在某個 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.時刻 完全 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別 了自己,是 不會發生 的(從 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.損耗律 推出) 【正文:句9278235596】\n- 步驟三十九: 自我印象 永遠落後一步,在任何 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.時刻 都不完整(從 自我印象 的定義 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.損耗律 推出) 【正文:句7897520586、句6016025590】\n- 步驟四十:對他者的 印象 完整,是 不被保證 的(從 印象 的定義 + 對他者認識的不可完備性 推出) 【正文:句6821405704】\n- 步驟四十之一: 印象 的修正材料只能來自已經 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.歷史 :可以是新 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 的 輸出 ;也可以是在這類材料存在時,回頭 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別 早已 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 、尚未被 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別 的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.歷史 (從 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別 的定義 + 印象 的定義 推出) 【正文:句4791349421、句8572288194】\n- 附註: 步驟四十之一 只列材料類型,不主張早已 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 、尚未被 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別 的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.歷史 在每一情形都存在;是否存在,本篇不斷言。\n- 附註:回頭 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別 之後 印象 會不會改變,本篇不斷言。\n- 附註:一次 輸出 只是一個依 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.權重 定出的結果,不是完整的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.權重 分布;本篇沒有加入由單次結果反演完整分布的前提,因此不以單次 輸出 判定完整的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.權重 形狀。\n- 步驟四十之四:多次 輸出 合起來看出 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.權重 的形狀,不是不可能的(從 輸出 的定義 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.坍塌 的定義 + 前提三 推出) 【正文:句1712959307】\n- 附註:多次 輸出 合起來能看出多少,取決於這些 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.時刻 的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.權重 形狀是否相近;是否相近,是經驗假定。\n- 步驟四十之五:蘊含(既沒有新的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 ,也沒有重新 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別 已經 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.歷史 , 印象 的變化不構成修正)(從 步驟四十之一 推出) 【正文:句4999861622】\n- 步驟四十之六:一個 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.我 說出的話,若所說內容以某個對象為對象,則它是一次 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別 ,其內容由到當時為止的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.歷史 決定;對象是自己時,是 自我印象 ,對象是另一個 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦 時,是 印象 ;所以這樣說出的話,不能當作所說對象的完整描述(從 輸出 的定義 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別 的定義 + 印象 的定義 + 自我印象 的定義 + 對他者認識的不可完備性 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.損耗律 + 前提六 推出) 【正文:句4257663939、句2199850246】\n- 附註:只在相同的判斷上反覆累積;改善校準是 不被保證 的。\n- 附註:對 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦 的一切統計估計,都屬於 印象 。\n- 附註: 印象 的準確應以校準衡量,也就是所押的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.權重 對不對,而不是命中率。\n- 附註: 印象 過不了跨尺度的 重切 :不能以細胞為例。\n- 附註:對話中的人工智慧有沒有 印象 ,取決於它是不是 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.我 。\n\n```text\n形式:\n印象(某呈現,另一呈現,次序) 為 某個 分別內容(某呈現,次序),以 另一呈現 為對象;\n 另一呈現 可以等於 某呈現(自我印象)\n材料 包含於 到達(某呈現,次序)\n```\n【正文:句4088252246】\n\n## 明文\n\n來源:論文第五節【正文:句5898529680】\n\n- 步驟四十一: 份量 是 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.生成函數 內部的事,本篇不決定; 份量 不能相加(從 份量 的定義 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.生成函數 的定義 推出) 【正文:句5685086001、句9776085487、句1889583218】\n- 附註:應用時至少要寫明 頻率 與 歧異度 兩項 份量 假定,並標為經驗假定。\n- 附註:本篇範例採用的 歧異度 經驗假定,列為 前提五 。\n- 步驟四十二:以史料統計估計 份量 不是不可能的:不同的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.歷史 可以對應到形狀相近的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.權重 (從 份量 的定義 + 印象 的定義 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.坍塌 的定義 + 前提三 推出) 【正文:句6998268558、句8702415855】\n- 附註:只有在 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.權重 的形狀於某個領域確實重複時,這種估計才有意義;是否重複,是經驗假定。\n- 附註:史料本身是被篩選過的 輸出 ,統計前要先問是誰留下的。\n- 步驟四十三:推出的不可能跨時間有效(從 步驟一 推出)。 【正文:句5138786073】\n- 附註:沒出現過只是 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.權重 ,可能被 歧異度 高的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 推翻。\n- 附註:本篇形式化到結構為止;不形式化的是內容: 歧異度 、 趨同 與 趨異 的維度、 印象 、 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.生成函數 的形狀。\n- 附註:上述內容本篇不決定,只能在應用篇中定性敘述,並標為經驗假定。\n- 附註:人與人工智慧是否不被 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.鎖死 ,目前都沒有定論;被 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.鎖死 的那段時間,不適用「只能談 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.權重 」的規則。\n- 附註:對不是 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.我 的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦 ,只寫統計上的變化,不寫目的。這是本篇的寫作規則,屬於對說法的禁止。\n- 步驟四十四:一個 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.我 說出的目的,作為它說出的話,是一筆 輸出 ;若內容以自己為對象,則是 自我印象 (從 步驟四十之六 + 輸出 的定義 + 自我印象 的定義 + 前提六 推出) 【正文:句4143407235】\n- 附註:明文第 6 條「僅憑這次自述本身,不把自述目的寫成行為的完整解釋」是本篇的寫作規則,不是由 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.黑箱律 推出的命題;自述目的在具體情形中是否構成完整解釋,本篇不斷言。\n- 附註: 經驗禁止 不是由框架推出;只寫必要條件,不寫充分條件;條件都滿足時,也只能說那個結局的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.權重 變重。\n\n## 禁止清單\n\n來源:論文第六節【正文:句7538782098】\n\n- 附註:禁止分三類:對世界的禁止、對說法的禁止、 經驗禁止 。\n\n## 對世界的禁止\n\n來源:論文第六節第 1 小節【正文:句4879310242】\n\n- 附註:對世界的禁止各條,分別出自步驟十六、十九、二十二、二十三、二十六、三十、三十一、三十二、三十七、三十八、四十、四十五。\n- 步驟四十五: 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.復原 一個 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦 ,是 不會發生 的(從 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.復原 的定義 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.不可復原律 推出) 【正文:句0372547885】\n- 附註:一個傳統原樣延續下去,列為 不被保證 。\n\n## 對說法的禁止\n\n來源:論文第六節第 2 小節【正文:句1795487240】\n\n- 附註:對說法的禁止各條,分別出自步驟八、十、四十之六、四十三、四十四,以及第五節第 6 條的附註,以及第二節、第四節第 3 小節與第五節的附註。\n\n## 經驗禁止\n\n來源:論文第六節第 3 小節【正文:句3969467214】\n\n- 附註: 經驗禁止 由範例提煉,隨新的案例修改,不列入固定的對世界禁止清單。\n\n## 範例格式\n\n來源:論文第七節【正文:句6640993205】\n\n- 附註:範例是定性分析,不需要數據;依序處理 邊界 、初始狀態、新 節點 出現、 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.權重 變化、結局、推論/史實/經驗假定與禁止、條件與復用。【正文:句1825631265、句7517978530、句8548928085、句8774022546、句6089028425、句8217815118、句3791784267、句3400636506、句7936060506】\n- 附註:條件與復用只寫必要條件,不寫充分條件;案例偏離時,要重新配對條件或修改 經驗禁止 。【正文:句6708387878、句2571162096】\n\n## 範例:日心說取代地心說\n\n來源:論文第八節【正文:句7924936596】\n\n- 例:本例效準:本例把歐洲學術界的天文學者、大學、教會視為 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦 ;它們的下一 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.時刻 都不能由該層次可得的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.歷史 唯一推出。 【正文:句7728032674、句2966691118】\n- 例:上述 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦 不被 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.鎖死 (從 前提四 + 本例效準 推出)。 【正文:句9250249953、句2966691118】\n- 例:本例效準:正文以 更新 檢查托勒密 迴路 與第谷 迴路 中的 趨同 是否原樣延續。 【正文:句7255259744】\n- 例:托勒密 迴路 與第谷 迴路 中的 趨同 原樣延續,都是 不被保證 的(從 步驟三十二 + 本例效準 推出)。 【正文:句7255259744】\n- 例:相同的觀測 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 不同的學者, 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.權重 朝相同方向移動,是 不被保證 的(從 不被保證 的定義 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.生成函數 的定義 推出)。 【正文:句6017390240】\n- 例:本例效準:本例只考慮日心與地靜兩個方向。 【正文:句5776349494】\n- 例:對一個學者,日心的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.權重 上升,地靜(包括第谷體系)的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.權重 就必然下降(從 步驟十八 + 本例效準 推出)。 【正文:句7718438529、句7020356770】\n- 例:本例效準:教會屬地靜一方;1616 年的禁令與 1633 年的審判是它的 輸出 ,37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 日心 迴路 。 【正文:句2895524950】\n- 例:教會的禁令與審判不是日心 迴路 的 負回饋 (從 負回饋 的定義 + 本例效準 推出)。 【正文:句2895524950】\n- 例:本例效準:快的 迴路 在相同的 時鐘時間 內,在每個 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦 身上 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 的次數較多,是經驗假定。 【正文:句7302074109】\n- 附註:即使次數較多,勝出也是 不被保證 的。\n- 例:本例效準:日心一方勝出,是經驗假定。 【正文:句3776523971】\n- 例:本例效準: 太極 在 1700 年前後以地靜一方 一方退出 結束,是史實,只作校準。 【正文:句5628039580】\n- 例:本例效準:從本例提煉的 經驗禁止 之一:新一方的內容若沒有進入 信號容器 ,「新一方存活到有新 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦 補入」是 不會發生 的;這是經驗校準,不是推論。 【正文:句7583210679】\n- 例:本例效準:從本例提煉的 經驗禁止 之二:新一方若沒有持續的 歧異度 高的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 ,「 太極 以舊一方 一方退出 結束」是 不會發生 的;這是經驗校準,不是推論。 【正文:句5222322567】\n- 例:本例效準:從本例提煉的 經驗禁止 之三:舊一方若能持續得到對等的 歧異度 高的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 ,「 太極 以舊一方 一方退出 結束」是 不會發生 的;這是經驗校準,不是推論。 【正文:句4703901582】\n- 附註:從本例提煉的 經驗禁止 ,以及量子力學、板塊構造兩例的檢驗,都是經驗校準,不是推論。\n\n## 範例:金黃色葡萄球菌的抗藥性\n\n來源:論文第九節【正文:句1823833483】\n\n- 例:本例效準:本例把金黃色葡萄球菌族群、醫師群體、藥物研發機構視為 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦 ;它們的下一 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.時刻 都不能由該層次可得的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.歷史 唯一推出。 【正文:句2388814690、句2966691118】\n- 例:上述 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦 不被 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.鎖死 (從 前提四 + 本例效準 推出)。 【正文:句9250249953、句2966691118】\n- 例:抗藥性在停藥後消失,是 不被保證 的;永久存在,也是 不被保證 的(從 不被保證 的定義 + 步驟三十 + 步驟三十一 推出)。 【正文:句8025431127】\n- 例:敏感菌株與抗藥菌株收到相同的藥物,結果相同,是 不被保證 的(從 不被保證 的定義 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.歷史 的定義 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.生成函數 的定義 推出)。 【正文:句4636921646】\n- 例:本例效準:本例只考慮抗藥與敏感兩類菌株。 【正文:句4024114450】\n- 例:就族群下一 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.時刻 的組成而言,抗藥菌株所佔的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.權重 上升,敏感菌株所佔的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.權重 就必然下降(從 步驟十八 + 本例效準 推出)。 【正文:句4024114450】\n- 例:醫師對葡萄球菌族群在藥物作用下反應的 印象 完整,是 不被保證 的(從 步驟四十 + 印象 的定義 推出)。 【正文:句5409050738】\n- 例:本例效準:本例採用第八節提煉的 經驗禁止 之三:舊一方若能持續得到對等的高 歧異度 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 ,「 太極 以舊一方 一方退出 結束」是 不會發生 的。 【正文:句4703901582、句1691463726】\n- 例:本例效準:在本例 邊界 內,細菌族群持續出現新的遺傳或表型變異,形成新的抗藥現象,並以監測資料、實驗結果與研究問題 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 研發一方;研發一方據此推出新藥;新藥的臨床療效回饋 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 研發機構與醫師群體,相對於它們「舊藥失效」的近期 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.歷史 ,是高 歧異度 的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 ,並足以在臨床上重新撐起「藥物有效」這個方向,與抗藥菌株的擴散相抗衡。 【正文:句8017823047、句1590772382、句4671682941、句2755290090、句8069310740、句6919068691】\n- 例:在本例 邊界 內,研發一方持續得到對等的高 歧異度 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 ,所以 經驗禁止 之三的前件成立(從 本例效準 推出)。 【正文:句5788279539、句2425520031】\n- 例:在本例 邊界 內,「 太極 以研發一方 一方退出 結束」是 不會發生 的(從 本例效準 推出)。 【正文:句3046807651】\n- 附註:抗藥現象 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 研發一方,說明的是 太極 的結構;滿足 經驗禁止 之三前件的,是新藥療效的回饋,而不是抗藥現象本身。若把對手的 輸出 也算作舊一方的對等 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 ,第八節的地靜一方同樣會滿足此前件,與史實不合。\n- 例:本例效準:抗藥性的適應代價是生物學上的經驗事實。 【正文:句2770173331、句7998666824、句2997106714】\n- 附註:適應代價不是 知見障 推出來的。\n\n## 待決項\n\n無\n","paper_files":[{"filename":"四條律相關工具及範例.md","content":"---\nuuid: b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6\nlast-modified: 2026-10-05T18:39:00\nauthor: 黃正宇 / Cheng Yu Huang\ncontact: mthree.tw@gmail.com\n---\n\n# 四條律相關工具及範例\n\n## 〇、定位\n\n本篇位於《渦動力學》與應用篇之間。它的目的不是提出新東西,而是把已經知道的事,用同一套立場和工具說清楚,讓不同領域統合在同一個框架之下。\n\n本篇的力量來自禁止。約束愈多,預測的可行域愈小,精確度愈高。每個工具都附有禁止,並標明它的形式:\n\n- [不會發生](concepts.md#c01):只要出現一次,就被推翻。\n- [不被保證](concepts.md#c02):框架不斷言它必然發生。具體情形中是否另有約束使它成立,框架也不斷言;要主張它必然發生,必須另外寫明所依賴的約束。它限制的是預測能有多少信心。\n\n由框架推出的禁止,對過去成立,對未來也成立,因為它們由四條律與本篇的設定推出,而兩者對每一個[時刻](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c09)都成立;[生成函數](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c15)也只有一個,不隨時間改變。對史料的統計只能在可行域之內給出[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06),不能給出禁止。\n\n本框架從「我為什麼不能了解你」這個心智問題出發,但它的結論,除了[印象](concepts.md#c45)以外,都不依賴心智。\n\n括號中其他學科的名稱,例如「(控制論:回饋[迴路](concepts.md#c31))」,只是路標,供查找相關文獻,不帶定義,也不可據以推論:那些學科的定義、預設或結論,不帶進本篇的工具。遇到疑義,以本篇的定義與形式段為準。\n\n### 四條律在本篇的位置\n\n上游的四條律,[流變律](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c24)、[黑箱律](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c25)、[損耗律](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c26)、[不可復原律](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c28),是本篇的公理,不由本篇的任何定義推出。它們是本篇禁止的主要來源;其餘的禁止,由本篇的設定推出。每一條律都在本篇有落點;任何應用,至少要對照這四條律檢查一次。\n\n| 律 | 本篇的落點 | 帶下來的禁止 |\n|---|---|---|\n| [流變律](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c24) | [更新](concepts.md#c42);[迴路](concepts.md#c31) | 沒有任何[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)處在與前一[時刻](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c09)相同的[歷史](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13)裡;凍結停不下[歷史](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13) |\n| [黑箱律](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c25) | [印象](concepts.md#c45);明文第 5 條 | 對不被[鎖死](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c12)的[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16),任何預測都是押在[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06)上,不是推出 |\n| [損耗律](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c26) | [印象](concepts.md#c45)([自我印象](concepts.md#c46));明文第 6 條 | 沒有任何[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19)能完全知道自己;自述的目的作為說出的話,是一筆[輸出](concepts.md#c28) |\n| [不可復原律](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c28) | [更新](concepts.md#c42);[知見障](concepts.md#c35)與[更新](concepts.md#c42) | 由[流變律](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c24),現實條件一直在變,傳統延續是[不被保證](concepts.md#c02)的;即使條件看起來相同,當年的選擇再次作出也是[不被保證](concepts.md#c02)的 |\n\n[對他者認識的不可完備性](concepts.md#c19)(第一節)與[損耗律](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c26)是同一個結構,一個朝向別人,一個朝向自己,在本篇都落在[印象](concepts.md#c45)。\n\n---\n\n## 一、設定\n\n本篇沿用上游的七個概念:[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)、[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)、[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19),以及[流變律](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c24)、[黑箱律](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c25)、[損耗律](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c26)、[不可復原律](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c28)。這些概念的定義中用到的[宇宙](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c02)、[呈現](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c04)、[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06)、[坍塌](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c08)、[時刻](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c09)、[歷史](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13)、[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)等詞,本篇也直接引用上游的定義,不重新定義。本節另外定義以下概念。\n\n### 定義\n\n- [對他者認識的不可完備性](concepts.md#c19):沒有任何[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19)能保證自己[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)完了另一個[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)。[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19)只能用已經[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)它的[歷史](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13)來[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)對方;對方的訊息[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)它是一件事,它的[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)又是另一件,在兩者之間,對方的[歷史](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13)仍可能增長,而對方不被[鎖死](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c12)時,它下一[時刻](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c09)的結果不能事先推出([黑箱律](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c25))。此外,對方[自己的那一段](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c17)中只[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)對方的部分,沒有任何東西保證也會[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)它;而它的[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)作為一次[寫入](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c29),一旦成為對方[自己的那一段](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c17)的一部分,也可能改變對方下一[時刻](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c09)的[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06)。\n\n### 由定義推出\n\n- [粒度](concepts.md#c20):由[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06)的定義,若較粗[呈現](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c04)的結果投影可由較細[呈現](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c04)的結果投影經某映射取得,則較粗[呈現](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c04)的[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06)分布等於較細[呈現](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c04)的[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06)分布經該映射推前所得。因此本篇只主張結果投影相容的描述之間一致,不主張任意兩個[切法](concepts.md#c23)都自動相容。\n- [歷史](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13)不失去任何東西:由[歷史](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13)的定義,一個[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)不再是[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)之後,它[自己的那一段](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c17)仍然完整地留在[歷史](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13)中。\n- 對方可能因此改變:由[自己的那一段](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c17)的定義,一次[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)留下的[寫入](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c29),若屬於另一個[呈現](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c04)[自己的那一段](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c17),換成別的就會改變它下一[時刻](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c09)[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06)的分布。\n\n### 前提\n\n- [時鐘時間](concepts.md#c21):[時刻](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c09)只是[坍塌](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c08)的次序,任何[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)都量不到。[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)以時鐘量到的時間,依物理,本篇不形式化。\n- [權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06)的形狀可以重複:由[歷史](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13)的定義,[歷史](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13)每一[時刻](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c09)都是新的;但本篇假定,不同的[歷史](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13)可以對應到形狀相近的[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06)。常新的是[歷史](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13),無新事的是[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06)。\n- [生成函數](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c15)只有一個:本篇假定只有一個[生成函數](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c15),不隨[時刻](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c09)改變。\n\n以下形式段中的記號,依所引用上游概念的定義寫出,不改變其意義;與上游概念表不一致時,以上游為準。\n\n```text\n形式:本篇的記號\n次序:時刻的全序索引,只表示先後;本篇不假定其為正整數,也不使用加一/減一\n分支集合;分支集合上的權重分布:每個分支的權重不小於零,總和為一\n宇宙初態 記為 位置零\n前史(次序):該次序的坍塌發生之前,已在歷史中的全部內容\n寫入(次序) 等於 寫入規則(前史(次序));寫入規則 為函數\n寫入後歷史(次序) 等於 (前史(次序),寫入(次序))\n歷史至(次序) 等於 (寫入後歷史(次序),坍塌結果(次序))\n歷史唯一:對 次序 小於 另一次序,歷史至(次序) 是 前史(另一次序) 的前段\n權重(次序) 等於 生成函數(寫入後歷史(次序))\n結果投影(某呈現):分支集合 送到 某呈現的結果集合 聯集 {未落在其上}\n權重(次序,某呈現):權重(次序) 經 結果投影(某呈現) 推前,同一個值的各分支權重相加\n到達(某呈現,次序) 等於 {位置零}\n 聯集 {不晚於 次序、落在 某呈現 上的寫入的位置}\n 聯集 {不晚於 次序、且其坍塌涉及 某呈現 的坍塌結果位置}\n涉及(某呈現,次序) 當且僅當 權重(次序,某呈現) 在 未落在其上 的權重 小於 一\n時刻集合(某呈現) 等於 {次序,其中 涉及(某呈現,次序)}\n下一次序(某呈現,次序):時刻集合(某呈現) 中大於 次序 的最小者;若不存在則未定義\n鎖死(某呈現,次序) 當且僅當 涉及(某呈現,次序),\n 且 權重(次序,某呈現) 中權重不為零者 恰為一個值,且該值 不等於 未落在其上\n替換(位置,替換值):把已發生歷史中的該位置換成 替換值,\n 其後的寫入依 寫入規則 重算,其後的權重依 生成函數 重算,\n 其後的結果依這些權重重新選出\n分布(某量,已知 某條件):某量 在 某條件 之下的分布;實際值:該位置實際的值\n自己的那一段(某呈現,次序) 等於 {位置,其中 存在 替換值,使\n 分布(權重(下一次序(某呈現,次序),某呈現),已知 替換(位置,替換值))\n 不等於 分布(權重(下一次序(某呈現,次序),某呈現),已知 替換(位置,實際值))}\n渦(某呈現,次序):某呈現 在 次序 符合渦的定義\n時間約定:渦(某呈現,次序) 的參與以 權重(下一次序(某呈現,次序)) 判定,即它下一時刻的權重;\n 不被鎖死的條件看 下一次序(某呈現,次序) 及其後的時刻\n分別內容(某呈現,次序):某呈現 在 次序 作出的分別內容;依上游定義,這個分別在歷史中留下一次寫入\n```\n\n\n以下是本篇的[粒度](concepts.md#c20)的形式,由上述記號寫出。\n\n```text\n形式:\n粒度:若 結果投影(某呈現) 等於 某映射 合成 結果投影(另一呈現),\n 則 權重(次序,某呈現) 等於 權重(次序,另一呈現) 經 某映射 推前\n```\n\n\n---\n\n## 二、基本單位\n\n本篇的基本單位是[迴路](concepts.md#c31),不是[個體](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c20)。\n\n- **[個體](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c20)不能作為單位。** 由定義,[個體](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c20)是被某個[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19)[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)出來的[呈現](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c04);由[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)的定義,[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)沒有固定的核心,而[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19)是[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16),所以[宇宙](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c02)中沒有具有固定核心的[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19)。以[個體](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c20)為單位推論時,若把[個體](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c20)當成跨[時刻](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c09)不變的東西,就等於在底層放回一個固定核心。\n- **每個[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)都是[迴路](concepts.md#c31)。** 由[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)的定義,[涉及](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c11)一個[呈現](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c04)的[坍塌](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c08),結果[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)它;由[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)的定義,[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)它的都參與它下一[時刻](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c09)的[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06)。所以只要[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)有過[時刻](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c09),它自己的結果就會回來參與它自己。這由定義推出,不必另立。\n- **[迴路](concepts.md#c31)不都是[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)。** 一個[迴路](concepts.md#c31),要在某個[切法](concepts.md#c23)下符合[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)的定義,才是[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16):[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)它的[歷史](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13)都參與它下一[時刻](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c09)的[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06),並且從這一[時刻](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c09)起往後,至少還有一個[時刻](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c09)不被[鎖死](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c12)。[迴路](concepts.md#c31)是形狀,[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)是其中合格的那些。\n- **尺度不固定。** 由[粒度](concepts.md#c20)(第一節),把一段[宇宙](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c02)切成一個[迴路](concepts.md#c31)或許多嵌套的[迴路](concepts.md#c31)時,若各層結果投影滿足[粒度](concepts.md#c20)所列的相容條件,相應的[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06)一致。一個神經元和一個文明,都可以是一個[迴路](concepts.md#c31)。\n\n敘述[迴路](concepts.md#c31),必須切出部分,說誰[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)誰。這是分析者的一次[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18),無法避免。本篇允許用[個體](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c20)來敘述,不允許依賴[個體](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c20)來推論:[個體](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c20)只是假名,沒有固定核心。除了[印象](concepts.md#c45)以外,每個工具的結論,都必須經得起[重切](concepts.md#c22);這裡的要求只適用於滿足[粒度](concepts.md#c20)所列結果投影相容條件的[重切](concepts.md#c22)。\n\n更精確地說:在滿足[粒度](concepts.md#c20)相容條件的[重切](concepts.md#c22)之下,[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06)與推論不變;描述[迴路](concepts.md#c31)之間關係的工具([耦合](concepts.md#c36)、[太極](concepts.md#c39)、[印象](concepts.md#c45)),在合併時轉為內部結構,不再以關係的形式出現。極端的[切法](concepts.md#c23)是把整個[宇宙](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c02)切成一個[迴路](concepts.md#c31);這個[切法](concepts.md#c23)本身合法,但只有在它與原[切法](concepts.md#c23)滿足[粒度](concepts.md#c20)的結果投影相容條件時,才屬於本篇在此要求[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06)與推論不變的[重切](concepts.md#c22)。在這種情形下,[宇宙](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c02)之外沒有第二個[迴路](concepts.md#c31),[耦合](concepts.md#c36)、[太極](concepts.md#c39)、[印象](concepts.md#c45)都只剩內部結構。\n\n以下兩件事,仍然是[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18):\n\n- [切法](concepts.md#c23):把哪一段[宇宙](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c02)看作一個[迴路](concepts.md#c31)。\n- [同一](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c21):不同[時刻](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c09)的[迴路](concepts.md#c31),是不是[同一個](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c21)。\n\n由[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)的定義,[切法](concepts.md#c23)講明之後,它是不是[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16),不由[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)決定。所以本篇所說的[迴路](concepts.md#c31),一律指「在講明的[切法](concepts.md#c23)下的[迴路](concepts.md#c31)」,並且它跨[時刻](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c09)持續存在是[不被保證](concepts.md#c02)的。\n\n需要分出「那是他」才說得出來的工具,只有[印象](concepts.md#c45)一個。\n\n---\n\n## 三、記號\n\n- [邊界](concepts.md#c24):每個範例都要先定地理[邊界](concepts.md#c24)和時間[邊界](concepts.md#c24)。這是一次[切法](concepts.md#c23),必須講明。\n- [節點](concepts.md#c25):[切法](concepts.md#c23)下的一個[呈現](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c04),是假名。[節點](concepts.md#c25)有三類:\n - [渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16):自己的[輸出](concepts.md#c28)會回到自己,受[知見障](concepts.md#c35)影響;不被[鎖死](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c12)時,只能談[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06)。\n - [信號容器](concepts.md#c26):不是[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)、從這一[時刻](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c09)起每一步都被[鎖死](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c12)的[節點](concepts.md#c25)。它通常持續存在,在許多[時刻](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c09)向[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)[輸出](concepts.md#c28),但這不是條件。它的內容可以由[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)寫下,例如書、法條;也可以來自其他[呈現](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c04),例如望遠鏡帶來的觀測。[知見障](concepts.md#c35)對它沒有內容;它也不能成為[印象](concepts.md#c45)的對象:讀一本書是[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10),不是[印象](concepts.md#c45)。\n - [隨機源](concepts.md#c27):不是[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16),但這一[時刻](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c09)或之後至少還有一個[時刻](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c09)它不被[鎖死](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c12)。由[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)的定義,[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)它的[歷史](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13)並不都參與它的[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06):或者現在就不都參與,或者到了它不被[鎖死](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c12)的那些[時刻](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c09)不都參與。例如擲出的骰子、放射性衰變的原子。它不被[鎖死](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c12)時,只能談[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06);它也不能成為[印象](concepts.md#c45)的對象。\n- [輸出](concepts.md#c28):一個[呈現](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c04)的[坍塌](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c08)結果,以及它的[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)內容。\n- [邊](concepts.md#c29):有向,意思是一個[節點](concepts.md#c25)的[輸出](concepts.md#c28),參與另一個[節點](concepts.md#c25)的[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06)。[邊](concepts.md#c29)本身不帶大小:一條[邊](concepts.md#c29)影響多大,取決於接收者的[歷史](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13),不是[邊](concepts.md#c29)本身的屬性。範例中畫[邊](concepts.md#c29),一律只畫直接的[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)。\n- [時序](concepts.md#c30):[邊](concepts.md#c29)可以標明先後,以及繞一圈要多久。[節點](concepts.md#c25)可以在[邊界](concepts.md#c24)內的某個時間出現或消失。\n\n```text\n形式:\n輸出(某呈現) 等於 {第 某次序 次坍塌的結果位置,其中 某次序 屬於 時刻集合(某呈現)}\n 聯集 {分別內容(某呈現,某次序) 的位置}\n邊(某呈現,另一呈現,次序) 當且僅當 存在 位置 屬於 輸出(某呈現),\n 且 該位置 屬於 自己的那一段(另一呈現,次序)\n```\n\n\n[邊](concepts.md#c29)是直接還是間接,隨[切法](concepts.md#c23)而定。\n\n---\n\n## 四、工具\n\n### 1. 迴路(控制論:回饋迴路)\n\n**定義**:[迴路](concepts.md#c31)是這樣的結構:一個[呈現](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c04)的[輸出](concepts.md#c28),經由自己或其他[呈現](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c04),又參與它自己的[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06)。\n\n- [正回饋](concepts.md#c32):把[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06)推向產生它的那個方向。\n- [負回饋](concepts.md#c33):把[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06)推離產生它的那個方向。\n- [速度](concepts.md#c34):繞一圈要多久。[速度](concepts.md#c34)以[時鐘時間](concepts.md#c21)計,與[時刻](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c09)不同(見第一節的前提)。\n\n方向必須包含[迴路](concepts.md#c31)自己的那一次[輸出](concepts.md#c28),由它錨定,不由分析者任意選擇;方向劃得多粗,屬於[切法](concepts.md#c23),須講明。\n\n**要分清的一點**:一個[迴路](concepts.md#c31)遇到的抵抗,如果是它自己的[輸出](concepts.md#c28)繞回來造成的,是[負回饋](concepts.md#c33),例如習慣化、飽和、資源耗盡;如果是另一個[迴路](concepts.md#c31)的[輸出](concepts.md#c28)經由[耦合](concepts.md#c36)壓過來的,那不是[負回饋](concepts.md#c33)。兩個方向相反的[正回饋](concepts.md#c32)[迴路](concepts.md#c31)之間的這種關係,見[太極](concepts.md#c39)。[負回饋](concepts.md#c33)在物理條件下真實存在,不能用兩個[正回饋](concepts.md#c32)的[耦合](concepts.md#c36)代替。\n\n**根據**:[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)與[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)的定義。\n\n**禁止**:\n\n- [不被保證](concepts.md#c02):一個[迴路](concepts.md#c31)持續下去是[不被保證](concepts.md#c02)的:[迴路](concepts.md#c31)的定義不含任何持續條件;只要不被[鎖死](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c12),每一圈也都要經過[坍塌](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c08)。\n\n**例**:\n\n- 神經元:反覆放電強化突觸([正回饋](concepts.md#c32));重複[刺激](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c30)下反應遞減([負回饋](concepts.md#c33))。\n- 人:信念的自我強化([正回饋](concepts.md#c32));習以為常而不再注意([負回饋](concepts.md#c33))。\n- 文明:一個學派的著作回頭培養下一批學者([正回饋](concepts.md#c32));資源耗盡使擴張停止([負回饋](concepts.md#c33))。\n\n```text\n形式:\n迴路(某呈現,次序) 當且僅當 存在 位置 屬於 輸出(某呈現),位置 在 寫入後歷史(次序) 中,\n 且 位置 屬於 自己的那一段(某呈現,次序)\n正負:設 某方向 包含於 某呈現 的結果集合,位置 為 某呈現 落在 某方向 的一次結果,\n 另一次序 在 位置 之後。\n 記 實際分布 等於 分布(權重(另一次序,某呈現) 在 某方向 上的總和,\n 已知 替換(位置,實際值))\n 記 對照分布 等於 分布(權重(另一次序,某呈現) 在 某方向 上的總和,\n 已知 替換(位置,某方向之外的值))\n 若對每一個門檻,實際分布超過該門檻的機率都不小於對照分布,且至少一處較大,\n 為正回饋;\n 若反過來,為負回饋;\n 其餘情形,不分正負。\n```\n\n\n### 2. 知見障\n\n**定義**:[知見障](concepts.md#c35)是這件事:一個[呈現](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c04)在下一[時刻](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c09)各個結果的[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06),總和為一,所以推高一個方向,必然壓低其餘方向的總和。一切學習都有代價,知與障是同一件事。\n\n**根據**:[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06)的定義:一次[坍塌](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c08)的各[分支](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c05)[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06)總和為一,一個[呈現](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c04)的[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06)由此分出,總和也為一。\n\n**注意**:[知見障](concepts.md#c35)只保證此消彼長,不決定一筆[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)推高哪個方向、推高多少(見第五節第 1 條)。\n\n**禁止**:\n\n- [不會發生](concepts.md#c01):推高一方,而其餘的總和不降。\n\n**例**:\n\n- 細胞:免疫細胞對一種抗原的某種反應方式,[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06)上升,其他反應方式的[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06)總和必然下降。\n- 人:學會認字之後,看到字時,「讀」的[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06)上升,其餘方向的[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06)必然下降(斯特魯普效應:字義會干擾說出字的顏色)。這一步是[知見障](concepts.md#c35)。「回不到文盲的時候」出自[不可復原律](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c28):「那個還不識字的自己再次發生」是[不會發生](concepts.md#c01)的。「很難理解文盲」則是[印象](concepts.md#c45)的問題:那段經歷仍在[歷史](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13)中(第一節:[歷史](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13)不失去任何東西),但對它的[印象](concepts.md#c45)是現在這個[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19)作出的[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18),而當時那個還不識字的自己不會再發生;能解釋得了當初那樣做的合理性,是[不被保證](concepts.md#c02)的。對象是別的文盲,是[印象](concepts.md#c45);是過去的自己,是[自我印象](concepts.md#c46),道理相同。後兩者都不是[知見障](concepts.md#c35)推出來的;其中「完全無法」是極端的集中,屬於經驗描述。\n- 文明:一種制度安排的[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06)上升,其餘制度安排的[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06)總和必然下降。\n\n[知見障](concepts.md#c35)只談同一個[呈現](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c04)下一[時刻](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c09)的[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06)分布。不同環境之間的取捨(例如抗藥性的適應代價)、影響的大小、泛化的範圍,都不是[知見障](concepts.md#c35)推出來的,屬於經驗假定。\n\n```text\n形式:\n設 某方向 包含於 某呈現 的結果集合。\n權重(次序,某呈現) 在 某方向 上的總和 加 在 某方向之外 的總和 等於 一\n```\n\n\n### 3. 耦合(控制論:耦合)\n\n**定義**:[耦合](concepts.md#c36)是這樣的情形:兩個或多個[呈現](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c04)[自己的那一段](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c17),在一個講明的[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)上重疊。參與[耦合](concepts.md#c36)的可以是[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16),也可以是由許多[呈現](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c04)構成的[迴路](concepts.md#c31)(見[太極](concepts.md#c39))。重疊有兩種方式:同一件事[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)它們,例如同一本經書,或[宇宙初態](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c14);或者它們的[輸出](concepts.md#c28)互相[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10),例如兩個交戰的文明。\n\n[耦合](concepts.md#c36)總是相對於一個講明的[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)而言。由[宇宙初態](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c14)的定義,[宇宙初態](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c14)[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)一切[呈現](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c04),所以任何兩個[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)都在這一點上重疊;不講明是哪一個[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10),說兩個[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)[耦合](concepts.md#c36),沒有內容。\n\n**走向**:在[耦合](concepts.md#c36)之下,[輸出](concepts.md#c28)的模式在某一個維度上,只有三種走向:\n\n- [趨同](concepts.md#c37)(共鳴):模式之間的距離縮短。\n- [趨異](concepts.md#c38)(分化;〔Bateson〕:分裂生成):模式之間的距離拉長。\n- [持平](concepts.md#c52):模式之間的距離不變。\n\n**高維**:模式是高維的。同一段[耦合](concepts.md#c36),可以在一個維度上[趨同](concepts.md#c37),同時在另一個維度上[趨異](concepts.md#c38)。所以說[趨同](concepts.md#c37)、[趨異](concepts.md#c38)或[持平](concepts.md#c52),都要講明是哪一個維度。選哪一個維度,是分析者的[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)。\n\n**根據**:[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)的定義;[自己的那一段](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c17)的定義(不同[呈現](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c04)[自己的那一段](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c17)可以重疊);[知見障](concepts.md#c35);[黑箱律](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c25)。\n\n**禁止**:\n\n- [不被保證](concepts.md#c02):[耦合](concepts.md#c36)在任何維度上出現[趨同](concepts.md#c37)、[趨異](concepts.md#c38)或[持平](concepts.md#c52),都是[不被保證](concepts.md#c02)的:[耦合](concepts.md#c36)的定義只說[自己的那一段](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c17)在一個[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)上重疊,不含任何走向;參與的[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)不被[鎖死](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c12)時,它們下一[時刻](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c09)的結果也推不出來([黑箱律](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c25))。「交流會帶來理解」和「接觸必然導致衝突」,兩種說法都被禁止。\n- [不被保證](concepts.md#c02):[趨同](concepts.md#c37)之後結果相同,是[不被保證](concepts.md#c02)的:同一個[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)只是各自[歷史](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13)中的一筆,結果由各自的整部[歷史](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13)決定([生成函數](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c15)的定義);而每個[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)不被[鎖死](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c12)時,下一[時刻](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c09)也推不出來([黑箱律](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c25))。\n\n**例**:\n\n- 神經元:兩群神經元同步振盪([趨同](concepts.md#c37));側抑制讓相鄰神經元的反應愈差愈遠([趨異](concepts.md#c38))。\n- 人:一對夫妻愈來愈像([趨同](concepts.md#c37));兄弟分家之後各走各路([趨異](concepts.md#c38))。\n- 文明:基督教與伊斯蘭一千多年的交往,在信仰和認同上[趨異](concepts.md#c38),在哲學、數學、貿易上[趨同](concepts.md#c37)。\n\n```text\n形式:\n耦合(甲,乙,位置,次序) 當且僅當 位置 屬於 到達(甲,次序) 交集 到達(乙,次序),\n 且 位置 屬於 自己的那一段(甲,次序) 交集 自己的那一段(乙,次序)\n相互耦合(甲,乙,次序) 當且僅當 存在 位置甲 屬於 輸出(甲) 交集 到達(乙,次序)\n 且 位置甲 屬於 自己的那一段(乙,次序),\n 且 存在 位置乙 屬於 輸出(乙) 交集 到達(甲,次序)\n 且 位置乙 屬於 自己的那一段(甲,次序)\n```\n\n\n#### 推:太極\n\n**定義**:[太極](concepts.md#c39)是這樣的結構:兩個方向相反的[正回饋](concepts.md#c32)[迴路](concepts.md#c31)互相[耦合](concepts.md#c36),在[耦合](concepts.md#c36)中[趨異](concepts.md#c38),形成動態平衡。每一方的[輸出](concepts.md#c28)[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)另一方,都強化了另一方自己的方向,所以任何一方壯大,都在餵養對方。\n\n[太極](concepts.md#c39)發生在[迴路](concepts.md#c31)與[迴路](concepts.md#c31)之間,不是某一個[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)的[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06)此消彼長。它是[迴路](concepts.md#c31)的結構,不要求每個參與者都是[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)。\n\n「方向相反」要先選定一個維度,把兩個[迴路](concepts.md#c31)的[輸出](concepts.md#c28)互相對應,才能判斷,屬於[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)。所以說兩個[迴路](concepts.md#c31)構成[太極](concepts.md#c39),必須講明是在哪一個維度上。\n\n**嵌套**:[太極](concepts.md#c39)可以嵌套。一個[太極](concepts.md#c39)中的一方,內部可以再有另一個[太極](concepts.md#c39);看哪一層,由[切法](concepts.md#c23)決定。例如中世紀歐洲內部的皇權與神權是一個[太極](concepts.md#c39),而整個基督教世界又與伊斯蘭構成另一個[太極](concepts.md#c39),前者嵌在後者之中。\n\n**結束的方式**至少有兩種:\n\n- [一方退出](concepts.md#c40):它的[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)大多[退場](concepts.md#c43)(見[更新](concepts.md#c42)),或者它不再自我強化。\n- [合流](concepts.md#c41):[耦合](concepts.md#c36)的走向由[趨異](concepts.md#c38)轉為[趨同](concepts.md#c37),兩個[迴路](concepts.md#c31)合成一個。在[重切](concepts.md#c22)之下,這也可以看作兩個[迴路](concepts.md#c31)被切成了一個。\n\n**禁止**:\n\n- [不被保證](concepts.md#c02):[太極](concepts.md#c39)結束是[不被保證](concepts.md#c02)的;結束時,以哪一方消失或雙方[合流](concepts.md#c41)作為結束方式,也都是[不被保證](concepts.md#c02)的:[太極](concepts.md#c39)的定義不含任何結束條件;只要其中有不被[鎖死](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c12)的[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16),雙方下一[時刻](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c09)的結果也推不出來([黑箱律](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c25))。\n- 「一方消失」要在某個[切法](concepts.md#c23)下判斷,屬於[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)。\n\n**例**:\n\n- 細胞:腫瘤與免疫系統。免疫編輯理論分為清除、平衡、逃脫三期,平衡期可以維持多年。\n- 人工系統:生成對抗網路。生成器與判別器方向相反,彼此的[輸出](concepts.md#c28)就是對方的訓練材料;失敗時一方壓倒另一方。\n- 文明:中世紀歐洲的皇權與神權。敘任權之爭、1302 年的《一聖教諭》與隔年的阿納尼事件,雙方的主張互為燃料;雙方在權威歸屬上[趨異](concepts.md#c38),在正當性與保護上互相依賴,所以平衡能維持數百年。在英格蘭,1534 年的《至尊法案》讓國王成為教會的首腦,是以[合流](concepts.md#c41)結束。\n\n```text\n形式:\n迴路(甲,次序) 且 迴路(乙,次序) 且 相互耦合(甲,乙,次序)\n```\n\n\n形式段只寫出[太極](concepts.md#c39)的結構前提;方向相反、[趨異](concepts.md#c38)、動態平衡與結束的方式,都要選定維度並比較[輸出](concepts.md#c28),屬於[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18),不形式化。\n\n### 4. 更新(〔Ryder〕:人口代謝;普朗克原理)\n\n**定義**:[更新](concepts.md#c42)是[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)的進出:有些[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)不再是[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16),有些[呈現](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c04)開始成為[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)。\n\n- [退場](concepts.md#c43):一個[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)不再是[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16):它在某一[時刻](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c09)是[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16),在它的下一[時刻](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c09)不是[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)。由[歷史](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13)的定義,[退場](concepts.md#c43)的[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16),[那一段](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c17)仍在[歷史](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13)裡(第一節:[歷史](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13)不失去任何東西);它們留下的[輸出](concepts.md#c28),例如文本、制度、建築,仍然可以透過[信號容器](concepts.md#c26)[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)後來的[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)。\n- [進場](concepts.md#c44):一個[呈現](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c04)開始成為[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16):它在某一[時刻](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c09)不是[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16),在它的下一[時刻](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c09)是[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16);或者在它的第一個[時刻](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c09)就是[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)。[進場](concepts.md#c44)者的[那一段](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c17)和舊[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)的重疊,例如由父母、師長、文本而來的部分。\n\n**根據**:[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)的定義(參與可以漸漸消失;從某一[時刻](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c09)起每一步都被[鎖死](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c12),也不再是[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16))、[流變律](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c24)、[不可復原律](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c28)、[歷史](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13)的定義。\n\n由[流變律](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c24),一個[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)在它的每一個[時刻](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c09),[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)它的[歷史](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13)都和它的前一個[時刻](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c09)不同。以冷凍昆蟲為例,在這個例子中假定:冷凍與解凍各對應到一個[坍塌](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c08),且都[涉及](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c11)這隻昆蟲;昆蟲在冷凍與解凍這兩個[時刻](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c09)都是[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)。若兩者之間沒有其他[坍塌](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c08)[涉及](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c11)它,則中間對它沒有新的[時刻](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c09),解凍就是冷凍之後它的下一[時刻](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c09)。依[流變律](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c24),解凍時[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)它的[歷史](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13)與冷凍時[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)它的[歷史](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13)不同。因此,僅憑「冷凍後再解凍」不能保證它的反應與冷凍前相同;相同反應是[不被保證](concepts.md#c02)的,但這不表示反應必然不同。在這種情形下,冷凍也不是[退場](concepts.md#c43):冷凍時與解凍時它都是[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16),而解凍是它冷凍後的下一[時刻](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c09),所以沒有從[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)變成非[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)。冷凍不能把[歷史](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13)固定在冷凍前的內容,也不能把解凍理解成重新回到原先的[時刻](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c09);至於可觀察狀態或反應是否恰好相同,本框架不保證。由[不可復原律](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c28),「[退場](concepts.md#c43)者的[那一段](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c17)再次發生」是[不會發生](concepts.md#c01)的。兩者合起來,才是[更新](concepts.md#c42)的完整根據:前者說[歷史](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13)持續追加,後者說不能[復原](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c27)。[進場](concepts.md#c44)者與舊[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)的[那一段](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c17)可以重疊;不同[個體](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c20)在分開以前可以共享同一段前史,分開之後,各自新的[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)與[寫入](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c29)可以使依賴路徑分岔,之後的合併也可以讓新的[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)共同承接先前不同路徑留下的[歷史](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13)。這些重疊、分岔與合併本身不決定它們是不是[同一](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c21);是否為[同一](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c21),屬於[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)。\n\n**禁止**:\n\n- [不會發生](concepts.md#c01):一個[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)所在的[歷史](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13),在某個[時刻](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c09)之後不再改變。「傳統凍結了」「制度停住了」都是這種說法;只能說[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06)很集中。常新的是[歷史](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13),無新事的是[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06)(第一節的前提)。\n- [不被保證](concepts.md#c02):舊[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)那些不被[鎖死](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c12)的選擇再次作出,是[不被保證](concepts.md#c02)的。所以一段[耦合](concepts.md#c36)中的[趨同](concepts.md#c37),在參與的[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)經過[更新](concepts.md#c42)之後原樣延續,也是[不被保證](concepts.md#c02)的:[趨同](concepts.md#c37)的定義不含任何延續條件,而支撐它的那些選擇再次作出同樣是[不被保證](concepts.md#c02)的。\n- 本篇不斷言任何[迴路](concepts.md#c31)、國家、文化必然消失。消失、滅亡都是標記,屬於[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)。框架推得出的是:[宇宙](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c02)只有一部[歷史](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13),而它在每一個[時刻](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c09)持續追加;因此比較全域上不同[時刻](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c09)時,[歷史](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13)的內容不同。這不表示每個[迴路](concepts.md#c31)、國家、文化各有一部自己的[歷史](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13),也不由此決定它是否變成了不同的東西;要不要這樣說、要不要把這叫做滅亡,是[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)的事。\n\n**注意**:「原樣」要在某個[切法](concepts.md#c23)下判斷。在夠粗的尺度上,一個傳統可能看起來沒變,應用時必須寫明判斷的尺度。\n\n**例**:\n\n- 細胞:組織中的細胞周轉。\n- 人:一生中舊習慣的淡出與新習慣的形成。\n- 文明:世代交替。清末,一輩子浸在科舉中的士人,面對科學這種高[歧異](concepts.md#c49)的[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10),較可能把它解釋掉,而不是被它翻轉(明文第 1 條的經驗假定:接收者的[歷史](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13)愈集中,衝擊愈可能被解釋掉)。清廷曾採取[更新](concepts.md#c42):1872 年起派出留美幼童,讓一批還沒有這段[歷史](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13)的新[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)去接收科學;1905 年廢除科舉,斷掉舊[迴路](concepts.md#c31)補充新[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)的來源。\n\n**[知見障](concepts.md#c35)與[更新](concepts.md#c42)**:[知見障](concepts.md#c35)不是一個需要被「解開」的障礙物,而是[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06)總和為一時此消彼長的結構。當[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06)重新分配,知與障的配置也隨之改變;新的配置仍受這個結構約束。[更新](concepts.md#c42)只描述[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)的進出;本篇不把[更新](concepts.md#c42)指定為處理[知見障](concepts.md#c35)的特別機制,也不比較[更新](concepts.md#c42)與其他改變方式的效果。\n\n```text\n形式:\n前一時刻(某呈現,次序):時刻集合(某呈現) 中小於 次序 的最大者;若不存在則未定義\n退場(某呈現,次序) 當且僅當 次序 屬於 時刻集合(某呈現),前一時刻存在,\n 且 渦(某呈現,前一時刻(某呈現,次序)) 且 非 渦(某呈現,次序)\n進場(某呈現,次序) 當且僅當 次序 屬於 時刻集合(某呈現),且 渦(某呈現,次序),\n 且 前一時刻不存在,或 非 渦(某呈現,前一時刻(某呈現,次序))\n```\n\n\n「原樣延續」要把[進場](concepts.md#c44)者與[退場](concepts.md#c43)者對應為[同一](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c21),屬於[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18),不形式化。\n\n### 5. 印象(心智理論;好調節器定理)\n\n**定義**:[印象](concepts.md#c45)是一個[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19)對一個[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)的[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18),也就是它對那個[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06)的估計。對象可以是另一個[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16),也可以是這個[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19)自己,此時稱為[自我印象](concepts.md#c46)。對[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)的一切統計估計,包括史料的統計,都屬於[印象](concepts.md#c45)。\n\n**根據**:[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)與[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19)的定義、[寫入](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c29)的定義([分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)在[歷史](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13)中留下一次[寫入](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c29))、[黑箱律](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c25)、[損耗律](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c26)、[對他者認識的不可完備性](concepts.md#c19)。\n\n**[自我印象](concepts.md#c46)**:由[損耗律](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c26),[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19)對自己的[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18),材料不包含這次[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)本身,所以永遠落後一步;連它[自己的那一段](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c17),它也[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)不完。所以[自我印象](concepts.md#c46)和對他者的[印象](concepts.md#c45)一樣是估計,一樣只能經由[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)修正,而且在任何[時刻](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c09)都不完整。[對他者認識的不可完備性](concepts.md#c19)與[損耗律](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c26)是同一個結構:前者朝向別人,後者朝向自己。\n\n**材料**有三個來源:\n\n1. 對方過去的[輸出](concepts.md#c28);\n2. [我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19)自己和對方重疊的[那一段](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c17)(推己及人);\n3. 對方所在的[耦合](concepts.md#c36),例如角色、制度、信仰。\n\n**性質**:\n\n- [印象](concepts.md#c45)只能經由[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)修正:修正材料只能來自已經[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)的[歷史](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13)。其中可以是新[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)的[輸出](concepts.md#c28);也可以在這類材料存在時,回頭[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)早已[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)、尚未被[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)的[歷史](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13)。後一類材料在每一情形都存在,是[不被保證](concepts.md#c02)的;本篇也不斷言重新[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)之後[印象](concepts.md#c45)一定改變。\n- 由[坍塌](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c08)的定義,一次[輸出](concepts.md#c28)只是依[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06)定出的一個結果,不是完整的[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06)分布。本篇不另加「可由單次結果反演完整分布」的假定,因此不以單次[輸出](concepts.md#c28)判定完整的[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06)形狀。多次[輸出](concepts.md#c28)合起來能看出多少,取決於這些[時刻](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c09)的[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06)形狀是否相近(第一節的前提;是否成立,是經驗假定)。\n- 既沒有新的[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)、也沒有重新[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)已經[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)的[歷史](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13),只在相同的判斷上反覆累積,不構成修正;改善校準是[不被保證](concepts.md#c02)的。\n- [印象](concepts.md#c45)作為一次[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18),會在[歷史](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13)中留下一次[寫入](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c29);這次[寫入](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c29)一旦[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)對方,本身也可能改變對方(見第一節「由定義推出」);對方改變後的[輸出](concepts.md#c28)再[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)這個[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19),[印象](concepts.md#c45)就形成[迴路](concepts.md#c31)。\n- 本篇把一個[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19)說出的任何話,看作它的一筆[輸出](concepts.md#c28);所說的內容以某個對象為對象時,是一次[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18),由到當時為止的[歷史](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13)決定:說的是自己,是[自我印象](concepts.md#c46);說的是另一個[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16),是[印象](concepts.md#c45)。所以說出的話,不能當作所說對象的完整描述:對自己,[自我印象](concepts.md#c46)永遠落後一步([損耗律](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c26));對他者,[印象](concepts.md#c45)完整是[不被保證](concepts.md#c02)的([對他者認識的不可完備性](concepts.md#c19))。\n- [印象](concepts.md#c45)的準確,應以校準衡量,也就是所押的[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06)對不對,而不是命中率。\n\n**禁止**:\n\n- [不會發生](concepts.md#c01):對一個不被[鎖死](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c12)的[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16),任何[印象](concepts.md#c45)都不能唯一推出它的下一[時刻](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c09)([黑箱律](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c25))。對象是自己時也一樣:在選擇以前,連它自己也不知道。\n- [不會發生](concepts.md#c01):一個[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19)在某個[時刻](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c09)完全[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)了自己([損耗律](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c26))。\n- [不被保證](concepts.md#c02):沒有任何對他者的[印象](concepts.md#c45)能保證是完整的([對他者認識的不可完備性](concepts.md#c19))。\n\n**注意**:這是本篇唯一需要[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)的工具,所以過不了跨尺度的[重切](concepts.md#c22):不能以細胞為例。對話中的人工智慧有沒有[印象](concepts.md#c45),取決於它是不是[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19);它是不是[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16),目前沒有定論(見第五節第 5 條)。\n\n**例**:一個人對朋友的了解;一個國家對另一個國家的判斷;教會把某個學派看作異端;一個人回顧自己為什麼做了某個決定。\n\n```text\n形式:\n印象(某呈現,另一呈現,次序) 為 某個 分別內容(某呈現,次序),以 另一呈現 為對象;\n 另一呈現 可以等於 某呈現(自我印象)\n材料 包含於 到達(某呈現,次序)\n```\n\n\n---\n\n## 五、明文\n\n1. **[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)的[份量](concepts.md#c47),本篇不決定。** 一筆[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)能移動多少[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06),稱為它的[份量](concepts.md#c47),是[生成函數](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c15)內部的事。應用時必須寫明所押的假定,並標為經驗假定。至少要寫明兩項:\n - [頻率](concepts.md#c48):多常[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)。\n - [歧異度](concepts.md#c49)(資訊論:驚奇度):這一筆[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10),和接收者過去收到的東西差多遠。[歧異度](concepts.md#c49)是相對於接收者的[歷史](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13)而言的:同一個[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10),落在不同的[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)上,[歧異度](concepts.md#c49)可以完全不同。\n\n 本篇的範例採用以下經驗假定:重複而低[歧異](concepts.md#c49)的[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10),效果遞減;罕見而高[歧異](concepts.md#c49)的[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10),一次可以壓過長期的累積;接收者的[歷史](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13)愈集中,高[歧異](concepts.md#c49)的衝擊愈可能被解釋掉,而不是翻轉它。\n\n [份量](concepts.md#c47)不能相加:一百次小地震,不等於一次大地震。這和[生成函數](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c15)的定義一致:[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06)是整部[歷史](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13)的函數,一筆[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)的效果,取決於它之前的[歷史](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13)。\n\n2. **統計屬於[印象](concepts.md#c45)。** 可以用史料估計[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)的[份量](concepts.md#c47)。這種估計要有意義,前提是[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06)的形狀確實會重複(第一節的前提);它在某個領域是否成立,是經驗假定。記錄本身是被篩選過的[輸出](concepts.md#c28),統計前要先問是誰留下的。\n\n3. **推出的不可能,和沒出現過,要分開。** 前者跨時間有效;後者只是[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06),可能被高[歧異](concepts.md#c49)的[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)推翻。\n\n4. **形式化到結構為止。** 本篇形式化的是關係:[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)、參與、此消彼長、重疊。不形式化的是內容:[歧異度](concepts.md#c49)、[趨同](concepts.md#c37)與[趨異](concepts.md#c38)的維度、[印象](concepts.md#c45)、[生成函數](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c15)的形狀。後者本篇不決定,只能在應用篇中定性敘述,並標為經驗假定。\n\n5. **[應用假定](concepts.md#c50)。** 本篇的例子,一律採用以下[應用假定](concepts.md#c50):在生物學與社會科學的層次上,一個[呈現](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c04)的下一[時刻](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c09)若不能由那個層次可得的[歷史](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13)唯一推出,就假定它不被[鎖死](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c12)。並且假定:例子中列為[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)的[呈現](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c04),下一[時刻](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c09)都不能由那個層次可得的[歷史](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13)唯一推出。這不是定理;人與人工智慧是否不被[鎖死](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c12),目前都沒有定論。若某個[呈現](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c04)在某段時間被[鎖死](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c12),例如被迫的行為,那一段不適用「只能談[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06)」的規則。\n\n6. **能用統計表達的,就不用目的論。** 目的屬於一個[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19)對自己的[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18),只有[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19)才有。對不是[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19)的[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16),只寫統計上的變化,例如「抗藥菌株在用藥環境裡的存活率較高」,不寫「細菌為了活下去而產生抗藥性」。對一個[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19),目的可以寫,但它仍然只影響[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06):餓了,也還是可能不吃。一個[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19)說出的目的,也是它說出的話(第四節[印象](concepts.md#c45)的性質):作為以自己為對象的[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18),它是[自我印象](concepts.md#c46),並且作為說出的話,是一筆[輸出](concepts.md#c28)。本篇的寫作規則是:僅憑這次自述本身,不把「他說他為了什麼」寫成他行為的完整解釋。這項規則不斷言自述目的在任何具體情形都不可能構成完整解釋;具體情形是否完整,本篇不決定。\n\n7. **[經驗禁止](concepts.md#c51)。** 從案例中提煉出的必要條件,稱為[經驗禁止](concepts.md#c51):缺少某個條件時,某個結局[不會發生](concepts.md#c01)。它不是由框架推出,而是由跨案例的校準得來,所以必須標明,並可以被新的案例修改。它比單純的「沒出現過」強,因為它經過跨案例的檢驗;但它仍不是推出的不可能(見第 3 條)。只寫必要條件,不寫充分條件:條件都滿足時,也只能說那個結局的[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06)變重,不能說它必然發生。\n\n---\n\n## 六、禁止清單\n\n禁止分三類。\n\n### 1. 對世界的禁止\n\n說的是什麼[不會發生](concepts.md#c01),或什麼[不被保證](concepts.md#c02)。\n\n| 出處 | 被禁止的事 | 形式 |\n|---|---|---|\n| [迴路](concepts.md#c31) | 一個[迴路](concepts.md#c31)必然持續下去 | [不被保證](concepts.md#c02) |\n| [知見障](concepts.md#c35) | 推高一方,而其餘的總和不降;學習沒有代價 | [不會發生](concepts.md#c01) |\n| [耦合](concepts.md#c36) | 交流必然帶來理解;接觸必然導致衝突 | [不被保證](concepts.md#c02) |\n| [耦合](concepts.md#c36) | 同一個[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)帶來相同的結果 | [不被保證](concepts.md#c02) |\n| [太極](concepts.md#c39) | [太極](concepts.md#c39)必然結束;必然以某一方消失結束 | [不被保證](concepts.md#c02) |\n| [更新](concepts.md#c42) | 一個[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)所在的[歷史](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13)不再改變;傳統凍結、制度停住([流變律](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c24)) | [不會發生](concepts.md#c01) |\n| [更新](concepts.md#c42) | 一個傳統原樣延續下去 | [不被保證](concepts.md#c02) |\n| [更新](concepts.md#c42) | [復原](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c27)一個[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)([不可復原律](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c28)) | [不會發生](concepts.md#c01) |\n| [印象](concepts.md#c45) | 唯一推出一個不被[鎖死](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c12)的[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)的下一[時刻](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c09),包括自己的([黑箱律](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c25)) | [不會發生](concepts.md#c01) |\n| [印象](concepts.md#c45) | 一個[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19)完全知道自己([損耗律](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c26)) | [不會發生](concepts.md#c01) |\n| [印象](concepts.md#c45) | 完全了解另一個[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)([對他者認識的不可完備性](concepts.md#c19)) | [不被保證](concepts.md#c02) |\n\n以上禁止,對過去成立,對未來也成立。\n\n### 2. 對說法的禁止\n\n說的是分析者不能怎麼推論、怎麼寫。形式一律為「方法上禁止」。\n\n| 出處 | 被禁止的說法 |\n|---|---|\n| 基本單位 | 以某人或某群體的本質解釋結果([個體](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c20)沒有固定核心) |\n| 基本單位 | 結論隨[切法](concepts.md#c23)改變,卻不講明[切法](concepts.md#c23) |\n| [更新](concepts.md#c42) | 斷言國家、文化必然滅亡(滅亡是標記,屬[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)) |\n| [印象](concepts.md#c45) | 把對不被[鎖死](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c12)的[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)的預測寫成結果,而不是[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06) |\n| [印象](concepts.md#c45) | 把一個[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19)說出的話,當作所說對象的完整描述 |\n| 明文 | 僅憑一個[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19)自述的目的本身,就把它寫成行為的完整解釋 |\n| [耦合](concepts.md#c36)、[太極](concepts.md#c39) | 說[趨同](concepts.md#c37)、[趨異](concepts.md#c38)或方向相反,卻不講明維度 |\n| 明文 | 把「沒出現過」當成「不可能」 |\n| 明文 | 把[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)的[份量](concepts.md#c47)當成可以相加 |\n| 明文 | 把[經驗禁止](concepts.md#c51)寫成充分條件,或寫成推出的不可能 |\n\n### 3. 經驗禁止\n\n由範例提煉,見各範例的「條件與復用」。它們隨新的案例修改,所以不列入本清單。\n\n---\n\n## 七、範例格式\n\n範例是定性分析,不需要數據。按以下七步寫,每一步都要有產出。\n\n1. **[邊界](concepts.md#c24)**:寫明地理[邊界](concepts.md#c24)和時間[邊界](concepts.md#c24)。\n2. **初始狀態**:列出[節點](concepts.md#c25),標明每個[節點](concepts.md#c25)是[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)、[信號容器](concepts.md#c26),還是[隨機源](concepts.md#c27);說明它們在怎樣的[迴路](concepts.md#c31)和[耦合](concepts.md#c36)之中,在哪些維度上[趨同](concepts.md#c37)或[趨異](concepts.md#c38)。\n3. **新[節點](concepts.md#c25)出現**:寫明新[節點](concepts.md#c25)在什麼時間出現,帶進了什麼以前沒有的東西,造成了什麼衝突。\n4. **[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06)變化**:寫明新舊[節點](concepts.md#c25)各自怎麼移動;哪些[迴路](concepts.md#c31)快、哪些慢;有沒有[太極](concepts.md#c39);所押的[份量](concepts.md#c47)假定([頻率](concepts.md#c48)、[歧異度](concepts.md#c49))。\n5. **結局**:寫明結局,並寫明是在哪個尺度上判斷的。\n6. **推論、史實、經驗假定與禁止**:逐條標明哪些是框架推出的,哪些是史實(只作校準),哪些是經驗假定,以及本例中哪些說法被禁止。\n7. **條件與復用**:從本例提煉[經驗禁止](concepts.md#c51),也就是某個結局的必要條件,並拿其他案例檢驗。只寫必要條件,不寫充分條件。吻合的,加強這條[經驗禁止](concepts.md#c51);偏離的,要麼條件沒搭對,要麼修改這條禁止(見明文第 7 條)。\n\n---\n\n## 八、範例:日心說取代地心說\n\n### 1. 邊界\n\n- 地理:歐洲學術界,以義大利、中歐、英格蘭為主。\n- 時間:1543 年到 1700 年前後。\n\n### 2. 初始狀態(1543 年以前)\n\n**[節點](concepts.md#c25)**:\n\n- [渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16):舊一代天文學家、大學、教會。\n- [信號容器](concepts.md#c26):托勒密體系(以亞里斯多德與托勒密的著作為主)。\n\n**狀態**:托勒密體系同時[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)三個[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16),形成[耦合](concepts.md#c36),三者在天文觀念上[趨同](concepts.md#c37)。大學把它教給學生,學生成為學者,再回到大學教書,構成一個[正回饋](concepts.md#c32)[迴路](concepts.md#c31)。這個[迴路](concepts.md#c31)繞一圈要一個世代。圖中只有一套理論,沒有衝突。\n\n### 3. 新節點出現\n\n- **1543 年,《天體運行論》**([信號容器](concepts.md#c26))出現,[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)少數學者,形成一個小的[正回饋](concepts.md#c32)[迴路](concepts.md#c31)。這時只是理論對理論:兩套體系都能大致解釋當時的觀測,沒有事實上的衝突。\n- **1572 年的超新星、1577 年的大彗星**:一次性的高[歧異](concepts.md#c49)[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10),動搖了「天界不變」。\n- **1588 年,第谷體系**([信號容器](concepts.md#c26))出現:地球不動,太陽繞地球,其他行星繞太陽。它保留了「地球不動」,又能容納許多新的觀測。\n- **1609 年起,望遠鏡**([信號容器](concepts.md#c26))出現。它[輸出](concepts.md#c28)圖中以前不存在的事實,例如木星的衛星、金星的盈虧。金星的盈虧與托勒密體系不相容,但與第谷體系、日心說都相容。圖中第一次出現事實與傳統理論的衝突。望遠鏡不是[輸出](concepts.md#c28)一次就結束,而是一直在[輸出](concepts.md#c28):愈來愈多的望遠鏡,愈來愈多的觀測。\n- **1609 年與 1619 年,克卜勒的行星運動定律;1627 年,《魯道夫星表》**([信號容器](concepts.md#c26)):依橢圓軌道算出的星表,預測精度明顯高於以往,並在此後的每一次觀測中接受檢驗,例如 1631 年依它預測的水星凌日,如期被觀測到。\n\n### 4. 權重變化\n\n- **托勒密[迴路](concepts.md#c31)被打斷**:金星的盈虧是高[歧異](concepts.md#c49)的[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)。1610 年代以後,純粹的托勒密體系在天文學者之間迅速失勢。但許多原本在托勒密[迴路](concepts.md#c31)中的[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16),沒有轉向日心,而是轉進第谷體系,保留了「地球不動」。各自移動得多遠,取決於各自的[歷史](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13),屬於[份量](concepts.md#c47)的問題(經驗假定)。\n- **[太極](concepts.md#c39)**:接下來數十年真正的對峙,是第谷[迴路](concepts.md#c31)與日心[迴路](concepts.md#c31)(克卜勒、伽利略一方)。兩者在「地球是否運動」這個維度上方向相反,互相[耦合](concepts.md#c36)而[趨異](concepts.md#c38)。教會 1616 年的禁令與 1633 年的審判,是地靜一方的[輸出](concepts.md#c28)[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)日心[迴路](concepts.md#c31);這不是日心[迴路](concepts.md#c31)的[負回饋](concepts.md#c33)。\n- **[速度](concepts.md#c34)**:日心一方的[迴路](concepts.md#c31)(觀測、星表、預測、再觀測)繞一圈只要幾年;傳統的師承[迴路](concepts.md#c31)繞一圈要一個世代,與[更新](concepts.md#c42)的週期一樣長,所以它無法在同一代人身上反覆強化。\n- **[知見障](concepts.md#c35)**:本例只考慮日心與地靜兩個方向,當年也沒有其他成形的理論。對任何一個新進入的學者,日心的[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06)上升,地靜(包括第谷體系)的[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06)就必然下降。\n- **[更新](concepts.md#c42)**:新進入的學者同時收到兩方的[輸出](concepts.md#c28),以及望遠鏡、星表持續的高[歧異](concepts.md#c49)[輸出](concepts.md#c28),新[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)大多補進了日心[迴路](concepts.md#c31)。\n- **[份量](concepts.md#c47)假定**:本例押的是[頻率](concepts.md#c48)與[歧異度](concepts.md#c49)同時偏向日心一方(經驗假定)。\n\n### 5. 結局\n\n1687 年,《原理》出現,為日心一方提供了動力學,成為新[迴路](concepts.md#c31)的核心[信號容器](concepts.md#c26)。到 1700 年前後,就歐洲主要天文學者這個尺度而言,[太極](concepts.md#c39)以地靜[一方退出](concepts.md#c40)而結束。\n\n### 6. 推論、史實、經驗假定與禁止\n\n**推論**:\n\n- 托勒密[迴路](concepts.md#c31)與第谷[迴路](concepts.md#c31)中的[趨同](concepts.md#c37),原樣延續都是[不被保證](concepts.md#c02)的([更新](concepts.md#c42):[流變律](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c24)、[不可復原律](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c28))。\n- 同一份觀測[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)不同的學者,[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06)朝同一方向移動,是[不被保證](concepts.md#c02)的([耦合](concepts.md#c36))。\n- 對同一個學者,日心的[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06)上升,地靜的[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06)必然下降([知見障](concepts.md#c35);本例只考慮兩個方向)。\n\n**史實(只作校準)**:\n\n- 1610 年代以後,純粹的托勒密體系迅速失勢,地靜一方的主要形式轉為第谷體系。\n- [太極](concepts.md#c39)在 1700 年前後以地靜[一方退出](concepts.md#c40)而結束。\n\n**經驗假定**:\n\n- 日心一方的[迴路](concepts.md#c31)比傳統[迴路](concepts.md#c31)快,而且每次[輸出](concepts.md#c28)都是高[歧異](concepts.md#c49)的,所以勝出。快的[迴路](concepts.md#c31)在相同的[時鐘時間](concepts.md#c21)內,在每個[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)身上[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)的次數較多,這也是經驗假定;即使次數較多,勝出也是[不被保證](concepts.md#c02)的。\n\n**本例中被禁止的說法**:\n\n- 「托勒密體系一直撐到 1700 年。」它在 1610 年代以後就被打斷;撐到最後的地靜一方是第谷體系。\n- 「日心說取代地心說是必然的。」\n- 「舊學派因為保守才拒絕日心說。」這是用群體的本質解釋結果。\n- 「審判之後,新學派放棄了日心說。」只能說:新學派公開支持日心的[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06)變輕了。\n\n### 7. 條件與復用\n\n**從本例提煉的[經驗禁止](concepts.md#c51)**(只列必要條件;條件都滿足時,也只能說[太極](concepts.md#c39)以舊[一方退出](concepts.md#c40)結束的[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06)變重):\n\n1. **[容器](concepts.md#c26)**:新一方的內容若沒有進入[信號容器](concepts.md#c26),「新一方存活到有新[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)補入」是[不會發生](concepts.md#c01)的。\n2. **持續的高[歧異](concepts.md#c49)[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)**:新一方若沒有持續的高[歧異](concepts.md#c49)[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10),「[太極](concepts.md#c39)以舊[一方退出](concepts.md#c40)結束」是[不會發生](concepts.md#c01)的。\n3. **舊一方缺少對等的[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)**:舊一方若能持續得到對等的高[歧異](concepts.md#c49)[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10),「[太極](concepts.md#c39)以舊[一方退出](concepts.md#c40)結束」是[不會發生](concepts.md#c01)的。\n4. **[更新](concepts.md#c42)**(已降級,見下方修正):若舊一方的[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)不[退場](concepts.md#c43)、也沒有新[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)[進場](concepts.md#c44),「[太極](concepts.md#c39)以舊[一方退出](concepts.md#c40)結束」是[不會發生](concepts.md#c01)的。\n\n**復用檢驗**:\n\n- **量子力學(約 1900–1930 年)**:論文進入[容器](concepts.md#c26);黑體輻射、光電效應、原子光譜等高[歧異](concepts.md#c49)的[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)持續出現;古典物理得不到對等的新[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)。條件一至三都滿足,[太極](concepts.md#c39)約三十年結束。與日心說不同的是結束的方式:古典力學沒有退出,而是被收為量子力學在特定條件下的近似,是以[合流](concepts.md#c41)結束。這不推翻上述[經驗禁止](concepts.md#c51):它們只規定「以舊[一方退出](concepts.md#c40)結束」的必要條件,不排除[合流](concepts.md#c41)。\n- **板塊構造(1912–1970 年代)**:韋格納的大陸漂移假說進入了[容器](concepts.md#c26),條件一滿足;但在他生前,缺少持續的高[歧異](concepts.md#c49)[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10),條件二不滿足,[太極](concepts.md#c39)沒有結束,與條件二一致。1950 至 60 年代,古地磁與海底擴張的證據接連出現,條件二滿足之後,[太極](concepts.md#c39)在約十年內結束。\n\n**修正**:板塊構造的[太極](concepts.md#c39)在約十年內結束,短於一個世代,許多既有的地質學者在生前就改變了立場。這削弱了條件四:[更新](concepts.md#c42)會影響[太極](concepts.md#c39)結束的速度,但不是必要條件。條件四因此從[經驗禁止](concepts.md#c51)降為[份量](concepts.md#c47)相關的經驗假定。\n\n---\n\n## 九、範例:金黃色葡萄球菌的抗藥性\n\n### 1. 邊界\n\n- 地理:英美的醫院體系。\n- 時間:1940 年代到 2000 年代。\n\n### 2. 初始狀態(1940 年代初)\n\n**[節點](concepts.md#c25)**:\n\n- [渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16):金黃色葡萄球菌族群、醫師群體、藥物研發機構。\n- [信號容器](concepts.md#c26):青黴素。\n\n**狀態**:青黴素開始大量使用,[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)葡萄球菌族群。這時絕大多數菌株對它敏感,青黴素幾乎每次[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10),都把族群往「消失」的方向推。醫師根據療效,對葡萄球菌族群在青黴素作用下的反應形成「青黴素對這個族群有效」的[印象](concepts.md#c45),於是更常使用青黴素。這個[印象](concepts.md#c45)的對象是作為[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)的葡萄球菌族群;青黴素仍是[信號容器](concepts.md#c26),不是[印象](concepts.md#c45)的對象。這是一個[正回饋](concepts.md#c32)[迴路](concepts.md#c31)。\n\n### 3. 新節點出現\n\n- **1940 年代後期**:能分解青黴素的菌株在醫院裡擴散。它們成了族群中的新[節點](concepts.md#c25),帶進了以前沒有的東西:青黴素[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)它們時,不再造成死亡。\n- **1959 年**:研發機構推出甲氧西林([信號容器](concepts.md#c26)),用來對付這些菌株。\n- **1961 年**:英國出現了對甲氧西林也有抗藥性的菌株,也就是後來所說的耐甲氧西林金黃色葡萄球菌。\n- **其後**:萬古黴素被當成最後一道防線;2002 年,美國出現了對萬古黴素也有抗藥性的金黃色葡萄球菌。\n\n### 4. 權重變化\n\n- **[太極](concepts.md#c39)**:研發[迴路](concepts.md#c31)(新藥上市、使用、篩出抗藥菌、再研發)與抗藥[迴路](concepts.md#c31)(藥物[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)、敏感菌死亡、抗藥菌擴散)方向相反,互相[耦合](concepts.md#c36),在「藥物是否有效」這個維度上[趨異](concepts.md#c38)。每一種新藥都篩出新的抗藥菌株,每一種抗藥菌株又逼出新藥,雙方的[輸出](concepts.md#c28)互為燃料。\n- **研發一方的[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)**(經驗假定):在本例[邊界](concepts.md#c24)內,細菌族群持續出現新的遺傳或表型變異,形成新的抗藥現象;這些現象以監測資料、實驗結果與研究問題[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)研發一方。研發一方據此形成新的知識、技術或藥物方案,並推出新藥。新藥的臨床療效回饋[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)研發機構與醫師群體:相對於它們「舊藥失效」的近期[歷史](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13),這是高[歧異](concepts.md#c49)的[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10),並且足以在臨床上重新撐起「藥物有效」這個方向,與抗藥菌株的擴散相抗衡。新藥又成為細菌族群面對的新條件。抗藥現象[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)研發一方,說明的是[太極](concepts.md#c39)的結構;撐起研發一方自己方向的,是新藥療效的回饋。\n- **[速度](concepts.md#c34)**:細菌一代只要幾十分鐘,一種新藥從研發到上市要十年以上。和日心說相反,這一次快的是細菌那一方。\n- **[耦合](concepts.md#c36)**:抗藥基因可以透過可移動的遺傳元件,在不同菌株甚至不同菌種之間傳遞。同一個[輸出](concepts.md#c28)[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)許多[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16),使它們在抗藥這個維度上[趨同](concepts.md#c37)。\n- **[知見障](concepts.md#c35)**:就族群下一[時刻](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c09)的組成而言,本例只考慮抗藥與敏感兩類菌株:抗藥菌株所佔的[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06)上升,敏感菌株所佔的[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06)就必然下降。\n- **適應代價**(經驗):抗藥性通常有代價。在沒有藥物的環境裡,抗藥菌株的存活率統計上往往較低。這是生物學上的經驗事實,不是[知見障](concepts.md#c35)推出來的。\n- **[更新](concepts.md#c42)**:每一代細菌都是新的[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)。它們只繼承了上一代留下的基因,所以族群的組成隨著每一次用藥不斷漂移。\n- **[印象](concepts.md#c45)**:醫師對葡萄球菌族群在某種藥物作用下的反應作出判斷,靠的是監測統計;[印象](concepts.md#c45)的對象仍是葡萄球菌族群這個[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16),藥物只是判斷內容中的條件。這種估計跟得上族群的實際變化,是[不被保證](concepts.md#c02)的。\n- **[份量](concepts.md#c47)假定**:本例押的是[頻率](concepts.md#c48)。藥物大量、頻繁地使用,每一次[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)都在篩選(經驗假定)。\n\n### 5. 結局\n\n到 2000 年代,[太極](concepts.md#c39)沒有結束。研發[迴路](concepts.md#c31)與抗藥[迴路](concepts.md#c31)仍在互推,而新類別抗生素的發現明顯放緩。這是在英美醫院體系這個尺度上的判斷。\n\n### 6. 推論、史實、經驗假定與禁止\n\n**推論**:\n\n- 抗藥性在停藥後消失或永久存在,都是[不被保證](concepts.md#c02)的([更新](concepts.md#c42):[流變律](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c24)、[不可復原律](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c28))。\n- 敏感菌株與抗藥菌株收到同一種藥物而得到相同結果,是[不被保證](concepts.md#c02)的([耦合](concepts.md#c36))。\n- 醫師對葡萄球菌族群在藥物作用下反應的[印象](concepts.md#c45)完整,是[不被保證](concepts.md#c02)的。\n\n**史實(只作校準)**:\n\n- 1961 年出現耐甲氧西林金黃色葡萄球菌;2002 年出現對萬古黴素有抗藥性的金黃色葡萄球菌。\n- [太極](concepts.md#c39)到 2000 年代仍未結束。\n\n**經驗假定**:\n\n- 沒有藥物時,抗藥菌株的存活率統計上較低,所以停藥後敏感菌株有機會回升。但抗藥菌株也可能再突變,使這個差距縮小,所以這一點只能押在[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06)上。\n- 研發一方持續推出新藥,其臨床療效回饋對研發機構與醫師群體是對等的高[歧異](concepts.md#c49)[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)(見第 4 步)。這一點只就本例[邊界](concepts.md#c24)內寫明,不延伸到其後。\n\n**本例中被禁止的說法**:\n\n- 「只要停藥,敏感菌就會回來。」\n- 「抗藥性一旦出現,就永遠不會消失。」\n- 「人類終將戰勝細菌」,或「細菌終將贏得這場戰爭」。[太極](concepts.md#c39)結束,以及由哪一方消失,都是[不被保證](concepts.md#c02)的。\n- 「細菌為了活下去而產生抗藥性。」應寫成:抗藥菌株在用藥環境裡的存活率統計上較高(明文第 6 條)。\n\n### 7. 條件與復用\n\n以日心說範例提煉的[經驗禁止](concepts.md#c51)檢驗本例,考慮「研發[一方退出](concepts.md#c40)」這個結局:\n\n- **條件一([容器](concepts.md#c26))**:抗藥基因可以存在於可移動的遺傳元件上,在菌株之間傳遞,滿足。\n- **條件二(持續的高[歧異](concepts.md#c49)[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10))**:藥物大量、頻繁地使用,對族群持續篩選,滿足。\n- **條件三(舊一方缺少對等的[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10))**:研發一方持續推出新藥,新藥的臨床療效回饋[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)研發機構與醫師群體;依第 4 步的經驗假定,這是對等的高[歧異](concepts.md#c49)[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)。所以在本例[邊界](concepts.md#c24)內,條件三不滿足。\n\n在本例[邊界](concepts.md#c24)內,條件三不滿足,「[太極](concepts.md#c39)以研發[一方退出](concepts.md#c40)結束」是[不會發生](concepts.md#c01)的,與史實一致。新類別抗生素的發現放緩,有效新藥帶來的對等[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)愈來愈少,使條件三逐漸接近滿足;依明文第 7 條,這只能說這個結局的[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06)變重,不能說它必然發生。\n\n本例也示範了[經驗禁止](concepts.md#c51)只是必要條件:條件一、二都滿足,[太極](concepts.md#c39)仍然沒有結束。\n\n### 與日心說範例對照\n\n兩個例子都是快[迴路](concepts.md#c31)對慢[迴路](concepts.md#c31)的[太極](concepts.md#c39)。日心說裡快的是事實[迴路](concepts.md#c31),[太極](concepts.md#c39)在 1700 年前後結束;抗藥性裡快的是細菌,[太極](concepts.md#c39)至今沒有結束。框架對這兩個結局都不作保證,只把它們標為史實。\n"},{"filename":"Tools and Examples Related to the Four Laws.md","content":"---\nuuid: b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6\nlast-modified: 2026-10-05T18:39:00\nauthor: 黃正宇 / Cheng Yu Huang\ncontact: mthree.tw@gmail.com\n---\n\n# Tools and Examples Related to the Four Laws\n\n## 0. Position\n\nThis paper sits between *Wo Dynamics* and the application papers. Its aim is not to propose anything new, but to state what is already known with a single stance and a single set of tools, so that different fields are unified under one framework.\n\nThe strength of this paper comes from prohibition. The more constraints, the smaller the feasible region of a prediction, and the higher its precision. Every tool comes with prohibitions, each marked with its form:\n\n- [Never Occurs](concepts.md#c01): a single occurrence refutes it.\n- [Not Guaranteed](concepts.md#c02): the framework does not assert that it necessarily happens. Whether other constraints make it hold in a particular case, the framework does not assert either; to claim that it necessarily happens, one must state the constraints relied on. What it limits is how much confidence a prediction can have.\n\nProhibitions derived from the framework hold for the past and for the future alike, because they are derived from the four laws and the setting of this paper, and both hold at every [moment](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c09); there is also only one [generating function](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c15), which does not change over time. Statistics of the past can only give [weights](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06) within the feasible region; they cannot give prohibitions.\n\nThe framework starts from a question about the mind: \"why can I not understand you?\" But its conclusions, apart from [impression](concepts.md#c45), do not depend on the mind.\n\nNames of other disciplines in parentheses, such as \"(cybernetics: feedback [loop](concepts.md#c31))\", are only signposts for finding related literature. They carry no definitions and may not be used as grounds for inference: the definitions, presuppositions and conclusions of those disciplines are not brought into the tools of this paper. In case of doubt, the definitions and formal passages of this paper prevail.\n\n### The place of the four laws in this paper\n\nThe four laws of the upstream paper, the [Law of Flux](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c24), the [Law of the Black Box](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c25), the [Law of Attrition](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c26) and the [Law of Non-Restoration](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c28), are the axioms of this paper and are derived from none of its definitions. They are the main source of the prohibitions in this paper; the remaining prohibitions are derived from the setting of this paper. Each law has a landing point in this paper; every application must be checked against the four laws at least once.\n\n| Law | Landing point in this paper | Prohibition carried down |\n|---|---|---|\n| [Law of Flux](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c24) | [Renewal](concepts.md#c42); [Loop](concepts.md#c31) | No [wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16) lies in the same [history](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13) as at its previous [moment](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c09); freezing does not stop [history](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13) |\n| [Law of the Black Box](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c25) | [Impression](concepts.md#c45); Explicit Rule 5 | For a [wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16) that is not [locked in](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c12), every prediction is a bet on [weights](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06), not a derivation |\n| [Law of Attrition](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c26) | [Impression](concepts.md#c45) ([self-impression](concepts.md#c46)); Explicit Rule 6 | No [self](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19) can know itself completely; a stated purpose, as something said, is one [output](concepts.md#c28) |\n| [Law of Non-Restoration](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c28) | [Renewal](concepts.md#c42); [Cognitive Obscuration](concepts.md#c35) and [Renewal](concepts.md#c42) | By the [Law of Flux](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c24), real conditions keep changing, so continuation of a tradition is [Not Guaranteed](concepts.md#c02); even when conditions look the same, making the same choices again is also [Not Guaranteed](concepts.md#c02) |\n\nThe [Incompleteness of Knowing Others](concepts.md#c19) (Section 1) and the [Law of Attrition](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c26) are the same structure, one directed at others and one at oneself; in this paper both land on [impression](concepts.md#c45).\n\n---\n\n## 1. Setting\n\nThis paper takes over seven concepts from the upstream paper: [wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16), [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18), [self](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19), and the [Law of Flux](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c24), the [Law of the Black Box](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c25), the [Law of Attrition](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c26) and the [Law of Non-Restoration](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c28). Terms used in the definitions of these concepts, such as [universe](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c02), [presentation](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c04), [weight](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06), [collapse](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c08), [moment](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c09), [history](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13) and [arrival](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10), are also taken directly from the upstream definitions and are not redefined here. This section additionally defines the following concept.\n\n### Definitions\n\n- [Incompleteness of Knowing Others](concepts.md#c19): no [self](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19) can guarantee that it has finished [distinguishing](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) another [wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16). A [self](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19) can [distinguish](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) the other only through the [history](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13) that has [arrived](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at it; the other's information [arriving](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) is one event and its [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) is another, and between them the other's [history](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13) may still grow, while, when the other is not [locked in](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c12), the outcome of its next [moment](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c09) cannot be derived beforehand ([Law of the Black Box](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c25)). Moreover, nothing guarantees that the parts of the other's [own segment](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c17) that [arrive](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) only at the other also [arrive](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at the self; and once the self's [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18), as a [writing](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c29), becomes part of the other's [own segment](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c17), it may change the other's [weights](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06) for its next [moment](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c09).\n\n### Derived from the definitions\n\n- [Granularity](concepts.md#c20): by the definition of [weight](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06), if the outcome projection of a coarser [presentation](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c04) can be obtained from the outcome projection of a finer [presentation](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c04) by a mapping, then the [weight](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06) distribution of the coarser [presentation](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c04) equals the pushforward, by that mapping, of the [weight](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06) distribution of the finer [presentation](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c04). Thus this paper asserts consistency only between descriptions with compatible outcome projections; it does not assert that arbitrary [cuts](concepts.md#c23) are automatically compatible.\n- [History](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13) loses nothing: by the definition of [history](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13), after a [wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16) ceases to be a [wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16), its [own segment](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c17) remains complete in [history](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13).\n- The other may change as a result: by the definition of [own segment](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c17), a [writing](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c29) left by a [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18), if it belongs to the [own segment](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c17) of another [presentation](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c04), would, if replaced with something else, change the distribution of that presentation's [weights](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06) for its next [moment](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c09).\n\n### Premises\n\n- [Clock Time](concepts.md#c21): a [moment](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c09) is only the order of [collapses](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c08), which no [wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16) can measure. The time a [wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16) measures with a clock follows physics and is not formalized in this paper.\n- The shape of [weights](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06) can repeat: by the definition of [history](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13), [history](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13) is new at every [moment](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c09); but this paper assumes that different [histories](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13) can correspond to [weights](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06) of similar shape. What is ever new is [history](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13); what has nothing new is [weight](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06).\n- There is only one [generating function](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c15): this paper assumes that there is only one [generating function](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c15), and that it does not change with the [moment](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c09).\n\nThe notation in the formal passage below is written from the definitions of the upstream concepts cited and does not change their meaning; where it differs from the upstream concept tables, the upstream prevails.\n\n```text\nFormal: this paper's notation\nn, m: indices preserving the total order of moments only; this paper does not assume positive-integer indexing or use +1/−1\nBranch set B; a weight distribution on B: every branch weight ≥ 0, summing to 1\nThe initial state of the universe is denoted position 0\nPast(n): all content already in history before the collapse at n\nW(n) = WriteRule(Past(n)); WriteRule is a function\nH⁺(n) = (Past(n), W(n)) -- history after writing, before the collapse at n\nH≤(n) = (H⁺(n), C(n)) -- history through the collapse at n\nUniqueness of history: for n < m, H≤(n) is a prefix of Past(m)\nw(n) = G(H⁺(n)) -- G: generating function\nπ_x : B → O_x ∪ {⊥} -- outcome projection of presentation x; ⊥: not falling on x\nw(n, x) = (π_x)_* w(n) -- pushforward: branch weights with the same value are added\nArr(x, n) = {0}\n ∪ {positions of writings falling on x no later than n}\n ∪ {positions of collapse outcomes no later than n whose collapses involve x}\nInv(x, n) ⟺ w(n, x)(⊥) < 1\nT(x) = {n : Inv(x, n)} -- set of moments of x\nNext_x(n) = min{m ∈ T(x) : n < m}, when it exists\nLock(x, n) ⟺ Inv(x, n) ∧ w(n, x) has exactly one value of non-zero weight, and that value ≠ ⊥\nRep(p, v): replace position p in the history already generated by v; later writings are recomputed by WriteRule,\n later weights by G, and later outcomes are selected anew according to those weights\nDist(q | c): the distribution of q given c; actual: the actual value at that position\nOwn(x, n) = {p : ∃ v, Dist(w(Next_x(n), x) | Rep(p, v)) ≠ Dist(w(Next_x(n), x) | Rep(p, actual))}\nWo(x, n): x satisfies the definition of wo at n\nTiming: the participation condition of Wo(x, n) is judged by w(Next_x(n)), the weights of x's next moment;\n the not-locked-in condition looks at Next_x(n) and later moments of x\nD(x, n): the content of the distinction made by x at n; by the upstream definition, that distinction leaves a writing in history\n```\n\nThe following is the formal statement of this paper's [granularity](concepts.md#c20), written in the notation above.\n\n```text\nFormal:\nGranularity: if π_x = f ∘ π_y, then w(n, x) = f_* w(n, y)\n```\n\n---\n\n## 2. The Basic Unit\n\nThe basic unit of this paper is the [loop](concepts.md#c31), not the [individual](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c20).\n\n- **The [individual](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c20) cannot serve as the unit.** By definition, an [individual](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c20) is a [presentation](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c04) marked off by some [self](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19) through [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18); by the definition of [wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16), a [wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16) has no fixed core, and a [self](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19) is a [wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16), so there is no [self](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19) with a fixed core in the [universe](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c02). When inference takes the [individual](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c20) as the unit and treats the [individual](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c20) as something unchanged across [moments](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c09), it amounts to putting a fixed core back in at the bottom.\n- **Every [wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16) is a [loop](concepts.md#c31).** By the definition of [arrival](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10), the outcome of a [collapse](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c08) that [involves](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c11) a [presentation](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c04) [arrives](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at it; by the definition of [wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16), whatever [arrives](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at it takes part in its [weights](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06) for its next [moment](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c09). So as long as a [wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16) has had a [moment](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c09), its own outcomes come back to take part in itself. This is derived from the definitions and need not be posited separately.\n- **Not every [loop](concepts.md#c31) is a [wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16).** A [loop](concepts.md#c31) is a [wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16) only if, under some [cut](concepts.md#c23), it satisfies the definition of [wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16): all the [history](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13) that [arrives](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at it takes part in its [weights](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06) for its next [moment](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c09), and from this [moment](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c09) on there is still at least one [moment](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c09) at which it is not [locked in](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c12). A [loop](concepts.md#c31) is a shape; [wos](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16) are the ones among them that qualify.\n- **Scale is not fixed.** By [granularity](concepts.md#c20) (Section 1), when a stretch of the [universe](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c02) is cut as one [loop](concepts.md#c31) or as many nested [loops](concepts.md#c31), the corresponding [weights](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06) agree if the outcome projections at those levels satisfy the compatibility condition stated by [Granularity](concepts.md#c20). A neuron and a civilization can each be a [loop](concepts.md#c31).\n\nTo describe a [loop](concepts.md#c31), one must cut out parts and say what [arrives](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at what. This is a [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) made by the analyst and cannot be avoided. This paper allows [individuals](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c20) to be used in description, but does not allow inference to rely on [individuals](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c20): an [individual](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c20) is only a provisional name, with no fixed core. Apart from [impression](concepts.md#c45), the conclusions of every tool must survive [recutting](concepts.md#c22); this requirement applies only to [recuttings](concepts.md#c22) that satisfy the outcome-projection compatibility condition stated by [Granularity](concepts.md#c20).\n\nMore precisely: under [recutting](concepts.md#c22) that satisfies the [Granularity](concepts.md#c20) compatibility condition, [weights](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06) and inferences do not change; tools that describe relations between [loops](concepts.md#c31) ([coupling](concepts.md#c36), [taiji](concepts.md#c39), [impression](concepts.md#c45)) turn into internal structure when parts are merged, and no longer appear as relations. An extreme [cut](concepts.md#c23) is to cut the whole [universe](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c02) as a single [loop](concepts.md#c31). This [cut](concepts.md#c23) is legitimate in itself, but it belongs to the [recuttings](concepts.md#c22) for which this paper requires invariant [weights](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06) and inferences only when it and the original [cut](concepts.md#c23) satisfy the outcome-projection compatibility condition stated by [Granularity](concepts.md#c20). In that case there is no second [loop](concepts.md#c31) outside the [universe](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c02), so [coupling](concepts.md#c36), [taiji](concepts.md#c39) and [impression](concepts.md#c45) are left only as internal structure.\n\nThe following two things remain [distinctions](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18):\n\n- [Cut](concepts.md#c23): which stretch of the [universe](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c02) is taken as one [loop](concepts.md#c31).\n- [Identity](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c21): whether the [Identity](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c21) relation holds between [loops](concepts.md#c31) at different [moments](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c09).\n\nBy the definition of [wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16), once the [cut](concepts.md#c23) is stated, whether something is a [wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16) is not decided by [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18). So a [loop](concepts.md#c31) in this paper always means \"a [loop](concepts.md#c31) under a stated [cut](concepts.md#c23)\", and persistence across [moments](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c09) is [Not Guaranteed](concepts.md#c02).\n\nThe only tool that can be stated only by marking off \"that is him\" is [impression](concepts.md#c45).\n\n---\n\n## 3. Notation\n\n- [Boundary](concepts.md#c24): every example must first fix a geographical [boundary](concepts.md#c24) and a temporal [boundary](concepts.md#c24). This is a [cut](concepts.md#c23) and must be stated.\n- [Node](concepts.md#c25): a [presentation](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c04) under a [cut](concepts.md#c23); it is a provisional name. There are three kinds of [node](concepts.md#c25):\n - [Wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16): its own [output](concepts.md#c28) comes back to itself, and it is subject to [cognitive obscuration](concepts.md#c35); when it is not [locked in](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c12), only its [weights](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06) can be discussed.\n - [Signal Container](concepts.md#c26): a [node](concepts.md#c25) that is not a [wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16) and, from this [moment](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c09) on, is [locked in](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c12) at every step. It usually persists and [outputs](concepts.md#c28) to [wos](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16) at many [moments](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c09), but this is not a condition. Its content may be written by [wos](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16), as with books or statutes, or may come from other [presentations](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c04), as with observations brought by a telescope. [Cognitive obscuration](concepts.md#c35) has no content for it; nor can it be the object of an [impression](concepts.md#c45): reading a book is an [arrival](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10), not an [impression](concepts.md#c45).\n - [Random Source](concepts.md#c27): not a [wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16), but at this [moment](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c09) or later there is still at least one [moment](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c09) at which it is not [locked in](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c12). By the definition of [wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16), not all the [history](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13) that [arrives](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at it takes part in its [weights](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06): either not all of it takes part now, or not all of it takes part at the [moments](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c09) at which it is not [locked in](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c12). Examples are a thrown die and a radioactively decaying atom. When it is not [locked in](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c12), only its [weights](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06) can be discussed; nor can it be the object of an [impression](concepts.md#c45).\n- [Output](concepts.md#c28): the outcomes of a [presentation](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c04)'s [collapses](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c08), together with the content of its [distinctions](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18).\n- [Edge](concepts.md#c29): directed; it means that the [output](concepts.md#c28) of one [node](concepts.md#c25) takes part in the [weights](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06) of another [node](concepts.md#c25). An [edge](concepts.md#c29) carries no magnitude of its own: how much an [edge](concepts.md#c29) matters depends on the receiver's [history](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13), not on the [edge](concepts.md#c29). In the examples, [edges](concepts.md#c29) are drawn only for direct [arrivals](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10).\n- [Timing](concepts.md#c30): [edges](concepts.md#c29) may be marked with their order and with how long it takes to go round once. [Nodes](concepts.md#c25) may appear or disappear at some time within the [boundary](concepts.md#c24).\n\n```text\nFormal:\nOut(x) = {position of the outcome of collapse k : k ∈ T(x)} ∪ {position of D(x, k)}\nEdge(x, y, n) ⟺ ∃ p ∈ Out(x) with p ∈ Own(y, n)\n```\n\nWhether an [edge](concepts.md#c29) is direct or indirect depends on the [cut](concepts.md#c23).\n\n---\n\n## 4. Tools\n\n### 1. Loop (cybernetics: feedback loop)\n\n**Definition**: a [loop](concepts.md#c31) is a structure in which the [output](concepts.md#c28) of a [presentation](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c04), through itself or through other [presentations](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c04), takes part again in its own [weights](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06).\n\n- [Positive Feedback](concepts.md#c32): pushes the [weights](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06) toward the direction that produced it.\n- [Negative Feedback](concepts.md#c33): pushes the [weights](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06) away from the direction that produced it.\n- [Loop Speed](concepts.md#c34): how long it takes to go round once. [Loop speed](concepts.md#c34) is measured in [clock time](concepts.md#c21), which differs from [moments](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c09) (see the premises in Section 1).\n\nThe direction must contain the [loop](concepts.md#c31)'s own [output](concepts.md#c28) in question, which anchors it; it is not chosen freely by the analyst. How coarsely the direction is drawn belongs to the [cut](concepts.md#c23) and must be stated.\n\n**A point to keep clear**: resistance met by a [loop](concepts.md#c31), if caused by its own [output](concepts.md#c28) coming back round, is [negative feedback](concepts.md#c33), as with habituation, saturation or resource depletion; if it is the [output](concepts.md#c28) of another [loop](concepts.md#c31) pressing in through [coupling](concepts.md#c36), it is not [negative feedback](concepts.md#c33). For this relation between two [positive feedback](concepts.md#c32) [loops](concepts.md#c31) pointing in opposite directions, see [taiji](concepts.md#c39). [Negative feedback](concepts.md#c33) really exists under physical conditions, and cannot be replaced by the [coupling](concepts.md#c36) of two [positive feedbacks](concepts.md#c32).\n\n**Grounds**: the definitions of [arrival](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) and [wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16).\n\n**Prohibitions**:\n\n- [Not Guaranteed](concepts.md#c02): persistence of a [loop](concepts.md#c31) is [Not Guaranteed](concepts.md#c02): the definition of [loop](concepts.md#c31) contains no condition of persistence; and as long as it is not [locked in](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c12), every round must also pass through [collapse](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c08).\n\n**Examples**:\n\n- Neurons: repeated firing strengthens synapses ([positive feedback](concepts.md#c32)); responses decline under repeated [stimuli](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c30) ([negative feedback](concepts.md#c33)).\n- People: beliefs reinforce themselves ([positive feedback](concepts.md#c32)); what becomes habitual is no longer noticed ([negative feedback](concepts.md#c33)).\n- Civilizations: a school's writings train the next generation of scholars ([positive feedback](concepts.md#c32)); resource depletion halts expansion ([negative feedback](concepts.md#c33)).\n\n```text\nFormal:\nLoop(x, n) ⟺ ∃ p ∈ Out(x), p in H⁺(n), with p ∈ Own(x, n)\nSign: let A ⊆ O_x be a direction, p an outcome of x falling in A, m after p.\n Actual = Dist(Σ_A w(m, x) | Rep(p, actual))\n Control = Dist(Σ_A w(m, x) | Rep(p, a value outside A))\n If for every threshold, P(Actual > threshold) ≥ P(Control > threshold), strictly somewhere,\n positive feedback;\n if the reverse, negative feedback;\n otherwise, neither.\n```\n\n### 2. Cognitive Obscuration\n\n**Definition**: [cognitive obscuration](concepts.md#c35) is the fact that the [weights](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06) of the outcomes of a [presentation](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c04) at its next [moment](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c09) sum to one, so that pushing one direction up necessarily pushes the total of the other directions down. All learning has a cost; knowing and obscuration are one and the same.\n\n**Grounds**: the definition of [weight](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06): the [weights](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06) of the [branches](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c05) of a [collapse](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c08) sum to one, and the [weights](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06) of a [presentation](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c04) are divided out of them, so they also sum to one.\n\n**Note**: [cognitive obscuration](concepts.md#c35) guarantees only that one rises as the others fall; it does not decide which direction an [arrival](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) pushes up, or by how much (see Section 5, Rule 1).\n\n**Prohibitions**:\n\n- [Never occurs](concepts.md#c01): one side is pushed up while the total of the others does not fall.\n\n**Examples**:\n\n- Cells: when the [weight](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06) of one mode of response of an immune cell to an antigen rises, the total [weight](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06) of its other modes of response necessarily falls.\n- People: after learning to read, on seeing a word, the [weight](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06) of \"reading it\" rises and the [weights](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06) of the other directions necessarily fall (the Stroop effect: the meaning of a word interferes with naming its color). This step is [cognitive obscuration](concepts.md#c35). \"Being unable to go back to illiteracy\" comes from the [Law of Non-Restoration](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c28): the occurrence again of the self that could not yet read [Never Occurs](concepts.md#c01). \"Finding it hard to understand the illiterate\" is a matter of [impression](concepts.md#c45): that experience is still in [history](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13) (Section 1: [history](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13) loses nothing), but the [impression](concepts.md#c45) of it is a [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) made by the [self](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19) as it now is, and the self that could not yet read does not occur again; being able to explain why acting that way made sense back then is [Not Guaranteed](concepts.md#c02). When the object is another illiterate person, it is an [impression](concepts.md#c45); when it is one's own past self, it is a [self-impression](concepts.md#c46); the reasoning is the same. Neither of the latter two is derived from [cognitive obscuration](concepts.md#c35); of them, \"completely unable\" is an extreme concentration and belongs to empirical description.\n- Civilizations: when the [weight](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06) of one institutional arrangement rises, the total [weight](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06) of the other arrangements necessarily falls.\n\n[Cognitive obscuration](concepts.md#c35) concerns only the distribution of the [weights](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06) of one [presentation](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c04) at its next [moment](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c09). Trade-offs between different environments (such as the fitness cost of drug resistance), the size of an effect, and the range of generalization are not derived from [cognitive obscuration](concepts.md#c35); they are empirical assumptions.\n\n```text\nFormal:\nLet A ⊆ O_x be a direction.\nΣ_A w(n, x) + Σ_{O_x∖A} w(n, x) = 1\n```\n\n### 3. Coupling (cybernetics: coupling)\n\n**Definition**: [coupling](concepts.md#c36) is the situation in which the [own segments](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c17) of two or more [presentations](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c04) overlap in a stated [arrival](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10). What takes part in [coupling](concepts.md#c36) may be [wos](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16), or [loops](concepts.md#c31) made of many [presentations](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c04) (see [taiji](concepts.md#c39)). The overlap takes one of two forms: the same thing [arrives](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at all of them, as with a shared scripture or the [initial state of the universe](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c14); or their [outputs](concepts.md#c28) [arrive](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at one another, as with two civilizations at war.\n\n[Coupling](concepts.md#c36) is always relative to a stated [arrival](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10). By the definition of the [initial state of the universe](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c14), the [initial state of the universe](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c14) [arrives](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at every [presentation](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c04), so any two [wos](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16) overlap at this point; to say that two [wos](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16) are [coupled](concepts.md#c36) without stating which [arrival](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) is meant says nothing.\n\n**Directions of development**: under [coupling](concepts.md#c36), the patterns of [outputs](concepts.md#c28) along any one dimension have only three directions of development:\n\n- [Convergence](concepts.md#c37) (resonance): the distance between patterns shrinks.\n- [Divergence](concepts.md#c38) (differentiation; Bateson: schismogenesis): the distance between patterns grows.\n- [Stasis](concepts.md#c52): the distance between patterns stays the same.\n\n**High dimensionality**: patterns are high-dimensional. The same stretch of [coupling](concepts.md#c36) can show [convergence](concepts.md#c37) along one dimension and [divergence](concepts.md#c38) along another at the same time. So to speak of [convergence](concepts.md#c37), [divergence](concepts.md#c38) or [stasis](concepts.md#c52), one must state which dimension is meant. Which dimension to choose is the analyst's [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18).\n\n**Grounds**: the definition of [arrival](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10); the definition of [own segment](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c17) (the [own segments](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c17) of different [presentations](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c04) may overlap); [cognitive obscuration](concepts.md#c35); the [Law of the Black Box](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c25).\n\n**Prohibitions**:\n\n- [Not Guaranteed](concepts.md#c02): the occurrence under [coupling](concepts.md#c36) of [convergence](concepts.md#c37), [divergence](concepts.md#c38), or [stasis](concepts.md#c52) along any dimension is [Not Guaranteed](concepts.md#c02): the definition of [coupling](concepts.md#c36) says only that [own segments](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c17) overlap in an [arrival](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10), and contains no direction of development; moreover, when the participating [wos](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16) are not [locked in](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c12), the outcomes of their next [moments](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c09) cannot be derived ([Law of the Black Box](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c25)). Both \"exchange brings understanding\" and \"contact inevitably leads to conflict\" are prohibited.\n- [Not Guaranteed](concepts.md#c02): the same results following [convergence](concepts.md#c37) are [Not Guaranteed](concepts.md#c02): the same [arrival](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) is only one item in each one's [history](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13), and the results are determined by each one's whole [history](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13) (the definition of the [generating function](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c15)); moreover, when each [wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16) is not [locked in](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c12), its next [moment](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c09) cannot be derived ([Law of the Black Box](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c25)).\n\n**Examples**:\n\n- Neurons: two populations of neurons oscillate in synchrony ([convergence](concepts.md#c37)); lateral inhibition drives the responses of neighboring neurons ever further apart ([divergence](concepts.md#c38)).\n- People: a married couple grows more and more alike ([convergence](concepts.md#c37)); brothers go their separate ways after dividing the family estate ([divergence](concepts.md#c38)).\n- Civilizations: in more than a thousand years of contact, Christianity and Islam showed [divergence](concepts.md#c38) in faith and identity, and [convergence](concepts.md#c37) in philosophy, mathematics and trade.\n\n```text\nFormal:\nCoup(a, b, p, n) ⟺ p ∈ Arr(a, n) ∩ Arr(b, n) and p ∈ Own(a, n) ∩ Own(b, n)\nMutCoup(a, b, n) ⟺ ∃ p_a ∈ Out(a) ∩ Arr(b, n) with p_a ∈ Own(b, n),\n and ∃ p_b ∈ Out(b) ∩ Arr(a, n) with p_b ∈ Own(a, n)\n```\n\n#### Corollary: Taiji\n\n**Definition**: [taiji](concepts.md#c39) is a structure in which two [positive feedback](concepts.md#c32) [loops](concepts.md#c31) pointing in opposite directions are [coupled](concepts.md#c36) with each other and show [divergence](concepts.md#c38) within that [coupling](concepts.md#c36), forming a dynamic balance. Each side's [output](concepts.md#c28), [arriving](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at the other, strengthens the other's own direction, so whichever side grows is feeding its opponent.\n\n[Taiji](concepts.md#c39) takes place between one [loop](concepts.md#c31) and another [loop](concepts.md#c31); it is not the rise and fall of the [weights](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06) of a single [wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16). It is a structure of [loops](concepts.md#c31), and does not require every participant to be a [wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16).\n\n\"Opposite directions\" can be judged only after choosing a dimension and matching the [outputs](concepts.md#c28) of the two [loops](concepts.md#c31) to each other; this is a [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18). So to say that two [loops](concepts.md#c31) form a [taiji](concepts.md#c39), one must state along which dimension.\n\n**Nesting**: [taiji](concepts.md#c39) can be nested. One side of a [taiji](concepts.md#c39) can contain another [taiji](concepts.md#c39) within it; which level one looks at is decided by the [cut](concepts.md#c23). For example, royal power and ecclesiastical power within medieval Europe form one [taiji](concepts.md#c39), while the whole of Christendom and Islam form another [taiji](concepts.md#c39), the former nested within the latter.\n\n**Ways of ending**: there are at least two:\n\n- [Withdrawal of One Side](concepts.md#c40): most of the [wos](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16) on one side [exit](concepts.md#c43) (see [renewal](concepts.md#c42)), or that side no longer reinforces itself.\n- [Merging](concepts.md#c41): the [coupling](concepts.md#c36) turns from [divergence](concepts.md#c38) to [convergence](concepts.md#c37), and the two [loops](concepts.md#c31) become one. Under [recutting](concepts.md#c22), this can also be seen as the two [loops](concepts.md#c31) being cut as one.\n\n**Prohibitions**:\n\n- [Not Guaranteed](concepts.md#c02): the ending of a [taiji](concepts.md#c39) is [Not Guaranteed](concepts.md#c02); when it does end, which side disappears or whether the two sides [merge](concepts.md#c41) is also [Not Guaranteed](concepts.md#c02): the definition of [taiji](concepts.md#c39) contains no condition for ending; moreover, as long as there are [wos](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16) among them that are not [locked in](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c12), the outcomes of both sides' next [moments](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c09) cannot be derived ([Law of the Black Box](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c25)).\n- \"One side disappears\" must be judged under some [cut](concepts.md#c23); it is a [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18).\n\n**Examples**:\n\n- Cells: tumors and the immune system. The theory of immunoediting distinguishes three phases, elimination, equilibrium and escape; the equilibrium phase can last for years.\n- Artificial systems: generative adversarial networks. The generator and the discriminator point in opposite directions, and each one's [output](concepts.md#c28) is the other's training material; when training fails, one side overwhelms the other.\n- Civilizations: royal power and ecclesiastical power in medieval Europe. The Investiture Controversy, the bull *Unam Sanctam* of 1302 and the Anagni incident of the following year: each side's claims fueled the other's. The two sides showed [divergence](concepts.md#c38) over who held authority, yet depended on each other for legitimacy and protection, so the balance could last for centuries. In England, the Act of Supremacy of 1534 made the king the head of the church, an ending by [merging](concepts.md#c41).\n\n```text\nFormal:\nLoop(a, n) ∧ Loop(b, n) ∧ MutCoup(a, b, n)\n```\n\nThe formal passage gives only the structural premises of [taiji](concepts.md#c39); opposite directions, [divergence](concepts.md#c38), dynamic balance and the ways of ending all require choosing a dimension and comparing [outputs](concepts.md#c28); this is a [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18), and is not formalized.\n\n### 4. Renewal (Ryder: demographic metabolism; Planck's principle)\n\n**Definition**: [renewal](concepts.md#c42) is the going and coming of [wos](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16): some [wos](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16) cease to be [wos](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16), and some [presentations](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c04) begin to be [wos](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16).\n\n- [Exit](concepts.md#c43): a [wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16) ceases to be a [wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16): it is a [wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16) at one [moment](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c09) and is not a [wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16) at its next [moment](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c09). By the definition of [history](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13), the [own segments](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c17) of [wos](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16) that have [exited](concepts.md#c43) remain in [history](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13) (Section 1: [history](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13) loses nothing); the [outputs](concepts.md#c28) they left behind, such as texts, institutions and buildings, can still [arrive](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at later [wos](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16) through [signal containers](concepts.md#c26).\n- [Entry](concepts.md#c44): a [presentation](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c04) begins to be a [wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16): it is not a [wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16) at one [moment](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c09) and is a [wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16) at its next [moment](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c09), or it is already a [wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16) at its first [moment](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c09). The [own segments](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c17) of those that have [entered](concepts.md#c44) overlap with those of the old [wos](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16), for example in the parts that come from parents, teachers and texts.\n\n**Grounds**: the definition of [wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16) (participation may fade away; if from some [moment](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c09) on it is [locked in](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c12) at every step, it is no longer a [wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16) either), the [Law of Flux](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c24), the [Law of Non-Restoration](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c28), and the definition of [history](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13).\n\nBy the [Law of Flux](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c24), at each [moment](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c09) of a [wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16), the [history](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13) that [arrives](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at it differs from that at its previous [moment](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c09). For the frozen-insect example, assume that freezing and thawing each correspond to a [collapse](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c08) that [involves](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c11) the insect, and that the insect is a [wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16) at both of those [moments](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c09). If no other [collapse](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c08) [involves](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c11) it between them, then there is no new [moment](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c09) for it in between, and thawing is its next [moment](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c09) after freezing. By the [Law of Flux](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c24), the [history](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13) that [arrives](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at it at thawing differs from the [history](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13) that [arrives](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at it at freezing. Therefore freezing and then thawing alone does not guarantee the same response as before freezing; the same response is [Not Guaranteed](concepts.md#c02), but this does not mean that a different response is necessary. In this case freezing is not an [exit](concepts.md#c43) either: the insect is a [wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16) at both freezing and thawing, and thawing is its next [moment](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c09) after freezing, so it does not change from a [wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16) into a non-[wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16). Freezing cannot fix [history](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13) at its pre-freezing content, nor can thawing be understood as returning to the original [moment](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c09); whether an observable state or response happens to be the same is not guaranteed by the framework. By the [Law of Non-Restoration](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c28), the [own segment](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c17) of what has [exited](concepts.md#c43) happening again [Never Occurs](concepts.md#c01). Only the two together are the full grounds of [renewal](concepts.md#c42): the former says [history](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13) keeps being appended, while the latter says a [Restoration](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c27) cannot be made. The [own segment](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c17) of one who [enters](concepts.md#c44) may overlap that of an old [wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16); different [individuals](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c20) may share the same prior history before they separate, after which new [arrivals](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) and [writings](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c29) can make their paths of dependence diverge, and a later merging can let a new [wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16) jointly inherit the [history](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13) left by previously different paths. Overlap, divergence and merging do not by themselves determine [Identity](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c21); whether they stand in [Identity](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c21) is a [Distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18).\n\n**Prohibitions**:\n\n- [Never occurs](concepts.md#c01): the [history](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13) in which a [wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16) lies stops changing after some [moment](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c09). \"The tradition froze\" and \"the institution stood still\" are statements of this kind; one can only say that the [weights](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06) are highly concentrated. What is ever new is [history](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13); what has nothing new is [weight](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06) (the premises in Section 1).\n- [Not Guaranteed](concepts.md#c02): the old [wos](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16) making again the choices they made while not [locked in](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c12) is [Not Guaranteed](concepts.md#c02). So the [convergence](concepts.md#c37) within a [coupling](concepts.md#c36), once the participating [wos](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16) have gone through [renewal](concepts.md#c42), continuing as it was is also [Not Guaranteed](concepts.md#c02): the definition of [convergence](concepts.md#c37) contains no condition for continuing, and the choices that sustained it being made again is likewise [Not Guaranteed](concepts.md#c02).\n- This paper does not assert that any [loop](concepts.md#c31), nation or culture must disappear. Disappearance and extinction are labels, and belong to [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18). What the framework can derive is that the [universe](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c02) has only one [history](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13), and it keeps being appended at every [moment](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c09); therefore, when different global [moments](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c09) are compared, the content of [history](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13) differs. This does not mean that each [loop](concepts.md#c31), nation, or culture has a separate [history](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13), nor does it decide whether it has become something different; whether to say so, and whether to call that extinction, is a matter of [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18).\n\n**Note**: \"as it was\" must be judged under some [cut](concepts.md#c23). At a coarse enough scale, a tradition may look unchanged; an application must state the scale of judgment.\n\n**Examples**:\n\n- Cells: cell turnover in tissues.\n- People: old habits fading and new habits forming over a lifetime.\n- Civilizations: generational succession. In the late Qing dynasty, scholars who had spent their lives immersed in the imperial examinations, faced with an [arrival](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) as high in [discrepancy](concepts.md#c49) as science, were more likely to explain it away rather than be overturned by it (the empirical assumption of Explicit Rule 1: the more concentrated the receiver's [history](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13), the more likely a shock is explained away). The Qing court undertook [renewal](concepts.md#c42): from 1872 it sent young students to study in the United States, so that a group of new [wos](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16) without this [history](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13) would receive science; in 1905 it abolished the imperial examinations, cutting off the old [loop](concepts.md#c31)'s source of new [wos](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16).\n\n**[Cognitive Obscuration](concepts.md#c35) and [Renewal](concepts.md#c42)**. [Cognitive obscuration](concepts.md#c35) is not an obstacle that needs to be \"undone\"; it is the structural tradeoff that follows when the total [weight](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06) is one. When the [weights](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06) are redistributed, the configuration of knowing and obscuring changes with them, while the new configuration remains subject to the same structure. [Renewal](concepts.md#c42) only describes the going and coming of [wos](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16); this paper does not designate [renewal](concepts.md#c42) as a special mechanism for handling [cognitive obscuration](concepts.md#c35), nor does it compare the effectiveness of [renewal](concepts.md#c42) with other ways of change.\n\n```text\nFormal:\nprev(x, n) = max{k ∈ T(x) : k < n}, when it exists\nExit(x, n) ⟺ n ∈ T(x) ∧ prev(x, n) exists ∧ Wo(x, prev(x, n)) ∧ ¬Wo(x, n)\nEntry(x, n) ⟺ n ∈ T(x) ∧ Wo(x, n) ∧ (prev(x, n) undefined ∨ ¬Wo(x, prev(x, n)))\n```\n\n\"Continuing as it was\" requires taking those who have [entered](concepts.md#c44) and those who have [exited](concepts.md#c43) to stand in [identity](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c21); this is a [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18), and is not formalized.\n\n### 5. Impression (theory of mind; good regulator theorem)\n\n**Definition**: an [impression](concepts.md#c45) is a [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) made by a [self](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19) of a [wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16), that is, its estimate of that [wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)'s [weights](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06). The object may be another [wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16), or the [self](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19) itself, in which case it is called a [self-impression](concepts.md#c46). Every statistical estimate about a [wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16), including statistics of historical records, is an [impression](concepts.md#c45).\n\n**Grounds**: the definitions of [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) and [self](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19), the definition of [writing](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c29) (a [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) leaves a [writing](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c29) in [history](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13)), the [Law of the Black Box](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c25), the [Law of Attrition](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c26), and the [Incompleteness of Knowing Others](concepts.md#c19).\n\n**[Self-impression](concepts.md#c46)**: by the [Law of Attrition](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c26), the material of a [self](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19)'s [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) of itself does not include that [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) itself, so it always lags one step behind; it cannot finish [distinguishing](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) even its own [own segment](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c17). So a [self-impression](concepts.md#c46), like an [impression](concepts.md#c45) of others, is an estimate, can only be corrected through [arrival](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10), and is incomplete at every [moment](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c09). The [Incompleteness of Knowing Others](concepts.md#c19) and the [Law of Attrition](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c26) are the same structure: the former directed at others, the latter at oneself.\n\n**Material** comes from three sources:\n\n1. the other's past [outputs](concepts.md#c28);\n2. the part of the [self](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19)'s own [own segment](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c17) that overlaps with the other's (putting oneself in another's place);\n3. the [couplings](concepts.md#c36) the other is in, such as roles, institutions and beliefs.\n\n**Properties**:\n\n- An [impression](concepts.md#c45) can only be corrected through [arrival](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10): the material for correction must come from [history](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13) that has already [arrived](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10). It may be a newly [arriving](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) [output](concepts.md#c28); or, when such material exists, one may go back to [distinguish](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) [history](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13) that has long since [arrived](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) but has not yet been [distinguished](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18). The existence of material of the latter kind in every case is [Not Guaranteed](concepts.md#c02); this paper also does not assert that an [impression](concepts.md#c45) must change after such a [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18).\n- By the definition of [collapse](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c08), a single [output](concepts.md#c28) is only one outcome settled according to the [weights](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06), not the complete [weight](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06) distribution. This paper adds no assumption that a complete distribution can be inverted from a single outcome, so it does not use a single [output](concepts.md#c28) to determine the complete shape of the [weights](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06). How much several [outputs](concepts.md#c28) taken together can show depends on whether the shapes of the [weights](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06) at those [moments](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c09) are similar (the premises in Section 1; whether this holds is an empirical assumption).\n- Merely accumulating on the same judgment, with neither a new [arrival](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) nor a new [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) of [history](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13) that has already [arrived](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10), is not a correction; improving calibration is [Not Guaranteed](concepts.md#c02).\n- An [impression](concepts.md#c45), as a [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18), leaves a [writing](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c29) in [history](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13); once this [writing](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c29) [arrives](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at the other, it may itself change the other (see \"Derived from the definitions\" in Section 1); when the other's changed [output](concepts.md#c28) [arrives](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) back at this [self](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19), the [impression](concepts.md#c45) forms a [loop](concepts.md#c31).\n- This paper takes anything a [self](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19) says as one of its [outputs](concepts.md#c28); when what is said is about some object, its content is a [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18), determined by the [history](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13) up to that point: when it speaks of itself, this is a [self-impression](concepts.md#c46); when it speaks of another [wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16), it is an [impression](concepts.md#c45). So what is said cannot be taken as a complete description of what it is about: of oneself, the [self-impression](concepts.md#c46) always lags one step behind ([Law of Attrition](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c26)); of others, the completeness of the [impression](concepts.md#c45) is [Not Guaranteed](concepts.md#c02) ([Incompleteness of Knowing Others](concepts.md#c19)).\n- The accuracy of an [impression](concepts.md#c45) should be measured by calibration, that is, by whether the [weights](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06) bet on are right, not by hit rate.\n\n**Prohibitions**:\n\n- [Never occurs](concepts.md#c01): for a [wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16) that is not [locked in](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c12), no [impression](concepts.md#c45) can uniquely derive its next [moment](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c09) ([Law of the Black Box](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c25)). The same holds when the object is oneself: before the choice, even it does not know.\n- [Never occurs](concepts.md#c01): a [self](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19) completely [distinguishes](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) itself at some [moment](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c09) ([Law of Attrition](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c26)).\n- [Not guaranteed](concepts.md#c02): no [impression](concepts.md#c45) of another can be guaranteed to be complete ([Incompleteness of Knowing Others](concepts.md#c19)).\n\n**Note**: this is the only tool in this paper that requires [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18), so it does not survive [recutting](concepts.md#c22) across scales: cells cannot serve as an example. Whether an AI in conversation has [impressions](concepts.md#c45) depends on whether it is a [self](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19); whether it is a [wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16) is currently undecided (see Section 5, Rule 5).\n\n**Examples**: a person's understanding of a friend; one nation's judgment of another; the church regarding a school as heretical; a person looking back on why they made a certain decision.\n\n```text\nFormal:\nImp(x, y, n) is some D(x, n) whose object is y; y may equal x (self-impression)\nMaterial ⊆ Arr(x, n)\n```\n\n---\n\n## 5. Explicit Rules\n\n1. **This paper does not decide the [impact](concepts.md#c47) of an [arrival](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10).** How much [weight](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06) an [arrival](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) can move is called its [impact](concepts.md#c47), and it is a matter internal to the [generating function](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c15). An application must state the assumptions it bets on and mark them as empirical assumptions. At least two must be stated:\n - [Frequency](concepts.md#c48): how often it [arrives](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10).\n - [Discrepancy](concepts.md#c49) (information theory: surprisal): how far this [arrival](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) lies from what the receiver has received before. [Discrepancy](concepts.md#c49) is relative to the receiver's [history](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13): the same [arrival](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10), falling on different [wos](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16), can have entirely different [discrepancy](concepts.md#c49).\n\n The examples in this paper adopt the following empirical assumptions: repeated [arrivals](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) of low [discrepancy](concepts.md#c49) have diminishing effects; a rare [arrival](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) of high [discrepancy](concepts.md#c49) can, in one go, outweigh a long accumulation; the more concentrated the receiver's [history](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13), the more likely a shock of high [discrepancy](concepts.md#c49) is explained away rather than overturning it.\n\n [Impacts](concepts.md#c47) do not add up: a hundred small earthquakes are not one large earthquake. This agrees with the definition of the [generating function](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c15): [weights](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06) are a function of the whole [history](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13), and the effect of an [arrival](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) depends on the [history](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13) before it.\n\n2. **Statistics belong to [impression](concepts.md#c45).** Historical records can be used to estimate the [impact](concepts.md#c47) of [arrivals](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10). For such estimates to be meaningful, the shape of [weights](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06) must actually repeat (the premises in Section 1); whether this holds in a given field is an empirical assumption. The records themselves are filtered [outputs](concepts.md#c28); before doing statistics, one must first ask who left them.\n\n3. **What is derived to be impossible must be kept apart from what has not occurred.** The former holds across time; the latter is only a [weight](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06), and may be overturned by an [arrival](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) of high [discrepancy](concepts.md#c49).\n\n4. **Formalization stops at structure.** What this paper formalizes are relations: [arrival](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10), participation, one rising as another falls, overlap. What it does not formalize is content: [discrepancy](concepts.md#c49), the dimensions of [convergence](concepts.md#c37) and [divergence](concepts.md#c38), [impression](concepts.md#c45), the shape of the [generating function](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c15). This paper does not decide the latter; they can only be described qualitatively in the application papers and marked as empirical assumptions.\n\n5. **[Application assumption](concepts.md#c50).** The examples in this paper all adopt the following [application assumption](concepts.md#c50): at the levels of biology and the social sciences, if the next [moment](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c09) of a [presentation](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c04) cannot be uniquely derived from the [history](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13) available at that level, it is assumed not to be [locked in](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c12). It is further assumed that, for every [presentation](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c04) listed as a [wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16) in the examples, the next [moment](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c09) cannot be uniquely derived from the [history](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13) available at that level. This is not a theorem; whether humans and AI are not [locked in](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c12) is currently undecided for both. If a [presentation](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c04) is [locked in](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c12) for some period, as with coerced behavior, the rule \"only [weights](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06) can be discussed\" does not apply to that period.\n\n6. **Whatever can be expressed statistically is not expressed teleologically.** A purpose belongs to a [self](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19)'s [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) of itself; only a [self](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19) has one. For a [wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16) that is not a [self](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19), write only statistical changes, such as \"drug-resistant strains have a higher survival rate in environments with the drug\", not \"the bacteria developed resistance in order to survive\". For a [self](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19), purposes may be written, but they still affect only [weights](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06): one may be hungry and still not eat. A purpose stated by a [self](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19) is also something it says (see the properties of [impression](concepts.md#c45) in Section 4): as a [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) whose object is itself, it is a [self-impression](concepts.md#c46), and as something said, it is one [output](concepts.md#c28). The writing rule of this paper is: from that self-report alone, do not write \"what he says he did it for\" as a complete explanation of his behavior. This rule does not assert that a stated purpose can never constitute a complete explanation in any particular case; whether it is complete in a particular case is not decided by this paper.\n\n7. **[Empirical prohibition](concepts.md#c51).** A necessary condition distilled from cases is called an [empirical prohibition](concepts.md#c51): without a certain condition, a certain outcome [never occurs](concepts.md#c01). It is not derived from the framework but obtained by calibration across cases, so it must be marked as such, and may be revised by new cases. It is stronger than mere \"has not occurred\", because it has been tested across cases; but it is still not a derived impossibility (see Rule 3). State only necessary conditions, never sufficient ones: even when all the conditions are met, one can only say that the [weight](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06) of that outcome has become heavier, not that it must happen.\n\n---\n\n## 6. List of Prohibitions\n\nProhibitions fall into three kinds.\n\n### 1. Prohibitions on the world\n\nThese say what [never occurs](concepts.md#c01), or what is [not guaranteed](concepts.md#c02).\n\n| Source | What is prohibited | Form |\n|---|---|---|\n| [Loop](concepts.md#c31) | A [loop](concepts.md#c31) necessarily persists | [Not Guaranteed](concepts.md#c02) |\n| [Cognitive obscuration](concepts.md#c35) | One side is pushed up while the total of the others does not fall; learning has no cost | [Never Occurs](concepts.md#c01) |\n| [Coupling](concepts.md#c36) | Exchange necessarily brings understanding; contact necessarily leads to conflict | [Not Guaranteed](concepts.md#c02) |\n| [Coupling](concepts.md#c36) | The same [arrival](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) brings the same results | [Not Guaranteed](concepts.md#c02) |\n| [Taiji](concepts.md#c39) | A [taiji](concepts.md#c39) necessarily ends; it necessarily ends with one side disappearing | [Not Guaranteed](concepts.md#c02) |\n| [Renewal](concepts.md#c42) | The [history](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13) in which a [wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16) lies stops changing; a tradition freezes, an institution stands still ([Law of Flux](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c24)) | [Never Occurs](concepts.md#c01) |\n| [Renewal](concepts.md#c42) | A tradition continues as it was | [Not Guaranteed](concepts.md#c02) |\n| [Renewal](concepts.md#c42) | [Restoring](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c27) a [wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16) ([Law of Non-Restoration](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c28)) | [Never Occurs](concepts.md#c01) |\n| [Impression](concepts.md#c45) | Uniquely deriving the next [moment](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c09) of a [wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16) that is not [locked in](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c12), including one's own ([Law of the Black Box](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c25)) | [Never Occurs](concepts.md#c01) |\n| [Impression](concepts.md#c45) | A [self](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19) knows itself completely ([Law of Attrition](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c26)) | [Never Occurs](concepts.md#c01) |\n| [Impression](concepts.md#c45) | Completely understanding another [wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16) ([Incompleteness of Knowing Others](concepts.md#c19)) | [Not Guaranteed](concepts.md#c02) |\n\nThe prohibitions above hold for the past and for the future alike.\n\n### 2. Prohibitions on statements\n\nThese say how the analyst may not infer or write. Their form is always \"methodological prohibition\".\n\n| Source | Prohibited statement |\n|---|---|\n| Basic unit | Explaining an outcome by the essence of a person or group (an [individual](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c20) has no fixed core) |\n| Basic unit | A conclusion changes with the [cut](concepts.md#c23), yet the [cut](concepts.md#c23) is not stated |\n| [Renewal](concepts.md#c42) | Asserting that a nation or culture must become extinct (extinction is a label; it is a [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)) |\n| [Impression](concepts.md#c45) | Writing a prediction about a [wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16) that is not [locked in](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c12) as an outcome rather than as [weights](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06) |\n| [Impression](concepts.md#c45) | Taking what a [self](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19) says as a complete description of what it is about |\n| Explicit rules | From a purpose stated by a [self](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19) alone, writing it as a complete explanation of the behavior |\n| [Coupling](concepts.md#c36), [taiji](concepts.md#c39) | Speaking of [convergence](concepts.md#c37), [divergence](concepts.md#c38) or opposite directions without stating the dimension |\n| Explicit rules | Treating \"has not occurred\" as \"impossible\" |\n| Explicit rules | Treating the [impacts](concepts.md#c47) of [arrivals](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) as additive |\n| Explicit rules | Writing an [empirical prohibition](concepts.md#c51) as a sufficient condition, or as a derived impossibility |\n\n### 3. Empirical prohibitions\n\nThese are distilled from the examples; see \"Conditions and reuse\" in each example. They are revised with new cases, so they are not listed here.\n\n---\n\n## 7. Format of Examples\n\nExamples are qualitative analyses and need no data. They are written in the following seven steps, each of which must produce something.\n\n1. **[Boundary](concepts.md#c24)**: state the geographical [boundary](concepts.md#c24) and the temporal [boundary](concepts.md#c24).\n2. **Initial state**: list the [nodes](concepts.md#c25), marking whether each [node](concepts.md#c25) is a [wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16), a [signal container](concepts.md#c26) or a [random source](concepts.md#c27); describe the [loops](concepts.md#c31) and [couplings](concepts.md#c36) they are in, and along which dimensions they show [convergence](concepts.md#c37) or [divergence](concepts.md#c38).\n3. **New [nodes](concepts.md#c25) appear**: state when the new [nodes](concepts.md#c25) appear, what they bring that was not there before, and what conflict they cause.\n4. **Changes in [weight](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06)**: state how the new and old [nodes](concepts.md#c25) each move; which [loops](concepts.md#c31) are fast and which are slow; whether there is a [taiji](concepts.md#c39); and the assumptions about [impact](concepts.md#c47) bet on ([frequency](concepts.md#c48), [discrepancy](concepts.md#c49)).\n5. **Outcome**: state the outcome, and the scale at which it is judged.\n6. **Inferences, historical facts, empirical assumptions and prohibitions**: mark item by item which are derived from the framework, which are historical facts (used only for calibration), which are empirical assumptions, and which statements are prohibited in this example.\n7. **Conditions and reuse**: distill [empirical prohibitions](concepts.md#c51) from the example, that is, necessary conditions for some outcome, and test them against other cases. State only necessary conditions, never sufficient ones. Agreement strengthens the [empirical prohibition](concepts.md#c51); deviation means either the conditions were matched wrongly or the prohibition must be revised (see Explicit Rule 7).\n\n---\n\n## 8. Example: Heliocentrism Replacing Geocentrism\n\n### 1. Boundary\n\n- Geography: the European learned world, chiefly Italy, Central Europe and England.\n- Time: from 1543 to around 1700.\n\n### 2. Initial state (before 1543)\n\n**[Nodes](concepts.md#c25)**:\n\n- [Wos](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16): the older generation of astronomers, the universities, the church.\n- [Signal container](concepts.md#c26): the Ptolemaic system (chiefly the writings of Aristotle and Ptolemy).\n\n**State**: the Ptolemaic system [arrives](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at all three [wos](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16), forming a [coupling](concepts.md#c36), and the three show [convergence](concepts.md#c37) in astronomical ideas. The universities teach it to students, the students become scholars and return to teach in the universities, forming a [positive feedback](concepts.md#c32) [loop](concepts.md#c31). This [loop](concepts.md#c31) takes a generation to go round once. There is only one theory in the picture, and no conflict.\n\n### 3. New nodes appear\n\n- **1543, *De revolutionibus*** ([signal container](concepts.md#c26)) appears and [arrives](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at a few scholars, forming a small [positive feedback](concepts.md#c32) [loop](concepts.md#c31). At this point it is only theory against theory: both systems can roughly explain the observations of the time, and there is no conflict over facts.\n- **The supernova of 1572 and the great comet of 1577**: one-off [arrivals](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) of high [discrepancy](concepts.md#c49), which shake \"the heavens do not change\".\n- **1588, the Tychonic system** ([signal container](concepts.md#c26)) appears: the earth is still, the sun goes round the earth, and the other planets go round the sun. It keeps \"the earth is still\" while accommodating many new observations.\n- **From 1609, the telescope** ([signal container](concepts.md#c26)) appears. It [outputs](concepts.md#c28) facts not previously in the picture, such as the moons of Jupiter and the phases of Venus. The phases of Venus are incompatible with the Ptolemaic system, but compatible with both the Tychonic system and heliocentrism. For the first time the picture contains a conflict between facts and the traditional theory. The telescope does not [output](concepts.md#c28) once and stop; it keeps [outputting](concepts.md#c28): more and more telescopes, more and more observations.\n- **1609 and 1619, Kepler's laws of planetary motion; 1627, the *Rudolphine Tables*** ([signal container](concepts.md#c26)): tables computed from elliptical orbits, with predictive accuracy clearly higher than before, tested at every observation thereafter; for example, the transit of Mercury of 1631 predicted by them was observed as expected.\n\n### 4. Changes in weight\n\n- **The Ptolemaic [loop](concepts.md#c31) is broken**: the phases of Venus are an [arrival](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) of high [discrepancy](concepts.md#c49). After the 1610s, the pure Ptolemaic system quickly lost ground among astronomers. But many [wos](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16) originally in the Ptolemaic [loop](concepts.md#c31) did not turn to heliocentrism; they moved into the Tychonic system and kept \"the earth is still\". How far each moved depended on each one's [history](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13), a question of [impact](concepts.md#c47) (empirical assumption).\n- **[Taiji](concepts.md#c39)**: the real standoff of the following decades was between the Tychonic [loop](concepts.md#c31) and the heliocentric [loop](concepts.md#c31) (the side of Kepler and Galileo). The two point in opposite directions along the dimension \"does the earth move?\", and are [coupled](concepts.md#c36) with each other in [divergence](concepts.md#c38). The church's prohibition of 1616 and the trial of 1633 were [outputs](concepts.md#c28) of the geostatic side [arriving](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at the heliocentric [loop](concepts.md#c31); they were not [negative feedback](concepts.md#c33) of the heliocentric [loop](concepts.md#c31).\n- **[Loop speed](concepts.md#c34)**: the heliocentric side's [loop](concepts.md#c31) (observation, tables, prediction, observation again) took only a few years to go round once; the traditional [loop](concepts.md#c31) of master and disciple took a generation, as long as the cycle of [renewal](concepts.md#c42), so it could not reinforce itself repeatedly within the same generation.\n- **[Cognitive obscuration](concepts.md#c35)**: this example considers only two directions, heliocentric and geostatic; at the time there was no other developed theory. For any newly entering scholar, when the heliocentric [weight](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06) rises, the geostatic [weight](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06) (including the Tychonic system) necessarily falls.\n- **[Renewal](concepts.md#c42)**: newly entering scholars received the [outputs](concepts.md#c28) of both sides at once, along with the continual high-[discrepancy](concepts.md#c49) [outputs](concepts.md#c28) of telescopes and tables, and the new [wos](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16) mostly joined the heliocentric [loop](concepts.md#c31).\n- **Assumption about [impact](concepts.md#c47)**: this example bets that [frequency](concepts.md#c48) and [discrepancy](concepts.md#c49) both favored the heliocentric side (empirical assumption).\n\n### 5. Outcome\n\nIn 1687 the *Principia* appeared, providing the heliocentric side with dynamics, and became the core [signal container](concepts.md#c26) of the new [loop](concepts.md#c31). By around 1700, at the scale of Europe's leading astronomers, the [taiji](concepts.md#c39) ended with the [withdrawal of one side](concepts.md#c40), the geostatic side.\n\n### 6. Inferences, historical facts, empirical assumptions and prohibitions\n\n**Inferences**:\n\n- The [convergence](concepts.md#c37) within the Ptolemaic [loop](concepts.md#c31) and within the Tychonic [loop](concepts.md#c31) continuing as it was is [Not Guaranteed](concepts.md#c02) ([renewal](concepts.md#c42): [Law of Flux](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c24), [Law of Non-Restoration](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c28)).\n- When the same observation [arrives](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at different scholars, their [weights](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06) moving in the same direction is [Not Guaranteed](concepts.md#c02) ([coupling](concepts.md#c36)).\n- For a given scholar, when the heliocentric [weight](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06) rises, the geostatic [weight](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06) necessarily falls ([cognitive obscuration](concepts.md#c35); this example considers only two directions).\n\n**Historical facts (for calibration only)**:\n\n- After the 1610s, the pure Ptolemaic system quickly lost ground, and the main form of the geostatic side became the Tychonic system.\n- The [taiji](concepts.md#c39) ended around 1700 with the [withdrawal of one side](concepts.md#c40), the geostatic side.\n\n**Empirical assumptions**:\n\n- The heliocentric side's [loop](concepts.md#c31) was faster than the traditional [loop](concepts.md#c31), and each of its [outputs](concepts.md#c28) was of high [discrepancy](concepts.md#c49), so it prevailed. That a faster [loop](concepts.md#c31) [arrives](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) more often at each [wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16) within the same [clock time](concepts.md#c21) is also an empirical assumption; even if it arrives more often, prevailing is [Not Guaranteed](concepts.md#c02).\n\n**Statements prohibited in this example**:\n\n- \"The Ptolemaic system held out until 1700.\" It was broken after the 1610s; what held out to the end on the geostatic side was the Tychonic system.\n- \"Heliocentrism replacing geocentrism was inevitable.\"\n- \"The old school rejected heliocentrism because it was conservative.\" This explains an outcome by the essence of a group.\n- \"After the trial, the new school gave up heliocentrism.\" One can only say: the [weight](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06) of the new school publicly supporting heliocentrism became lighter.\n\n### 7. Conditions and reuse\n\n**[Empirical prohibitions](concepts.md#c51) distilled from this example** (necessary conditions only; even when all are met, one can only say that the [weight](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06) of the [taiji](concepts.md#c39) ending with the [withdrawal of one side](concepts.md#c40), the old side, has become heavier):\n\n1. **[Signal container](concepts.md#c26)**: if the content of the new side does not enter a [signal container](concepts.md#c26), “the new side survives until new [wos](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16) join” [Never Occurs](concepts.md#c01).\n2. **Sustained [arrivals](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) of high [discrepancy](concepts.md#c49)**: if the new side lacks sustained [arrivals](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) of high [discrepancy](concepts.md#c49), “the [taiji](concepts.md#c39) ends with the old side’s [withdrawal of one side](concepts.md#c40)” [Never Occurs](concepts.md#c01).\n3. **The old side lacks matching [arrivals](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)**: if the old side can keep receiving matching [arrivals](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) of high [discrepancy](concepts.md#c49), “the [taiji](concepts.md#c39) ends with the old side’s [withdrawal of one side](concepts.md#c40)” [Never Occurs](concepts.md#c01).\n4. **[Renewal](concepts.md#c42)** (downgraded; see the revision below): if the [wos](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16) of the old side do not [exit](concepts.md#c43) and no new [wos](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16) [enter](concepts.md#c44), “the [taiji](concepts.md#c39) ends with the old side’s [withdrawal of one side](concepts.md#c40)” [Never Occurs](concepts.md#c01).\n\n**Reuse tests**:\n\n- **Quantum mechanics (about 1900–1930)**: papers entered a [signal container](concepts.md#c26); [arrivals](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) of high [discrepancy](concepts.md#c49) such as black-body radiation, the photoelectric effect and atomic spectra kept appearing; classical physics received no matching new [arrivals](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10). Conditions 1 to 3 were all met, and the [taiji](concepts.md#c39) ended in about thirty years. What differed from heliocentrism was the way of ending: classical mechanics did not withdraw, but was absorbed as an approximation of quantum mechanics under particular conditions, an ending by [merging](concepts.md#c41). This does not refute the [empirical prohibitions](concepts.md#c51) above: they only set necessary conditions for \"ending with the [withdrawal of one side](concepts.md#c40), the old side\", and do not exclude [merging](concepts.md#c41).\n- **Plate tectonics (1912–1970s)**: Wegener's hypothesis of continental drift entered a [signal container](concepts.md#c26), so condition 1 was met; but in his lifetime, sustained [arrivals](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) of high [discrepancy](concepts.md#c49) were lacking, so condition 2 was not met, and the [taiji](concepts.md#c39) did not end, in agreement with condition 2. In the 1950s and 1960s, evidence from paleomagnetism and seafloor spreading appeared in succession; once condition 2 was met, the [taiji](concepts.md#c39) ended within about ten years.\n\n**Revision**: the [taiji](concepts.md#c39) of plate tectonics ended within about ten years, shorter than a generation, and many established geologists changed their positions in their lifetimes. This weakens condition 4: [renewal](concepts.md#c42) affects how fast a [taiji](concepts.md#c39) ends, but it is not a necessary condition. Condition 4 is therefore downgraded from an [empirical prohibition](concepts.md#c51) to an empirical assumption about [impact](concepts.md#c47).\n\n---\n\n## 9. Example: Drug Resistance in Staphylococcus aureus\n\n### 1. Boundary\n\n- Geography: the hospital systems of Britain and the United States.\n- Time: from the 1940s to the 2000s.\n\n### 2. Initial state (early 1940s)\n\n**[Nodes](concepts.md#c25)**:\n\n- [Wos](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16): the population of *Staphylococcus aureus*, the community of physicians, the drug research institutions.\n- [Signal container](concepts.md#c26): penicillin.\n\n**State**: penicillin comes into large-scale use and [arrives](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at the staphylococcal population. At this point the great majority of strains are sensitive to it, and almost every [arrival](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) of penicillin pushes the population in the direction of \"disappearing\". Judging by therapeutic effect, physicians form an [impression](concepts.md#c45) of how the staphylococcal population responds under penicillin: \"penicillin is effective against this population\", and so use penicillin more often. The object of this [impression](concepts.md#c45) is the staphylococcal population as a [wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16); penicillin remains a [signal container](concepts.md#c26), not the object of the [impression](concepts.md#c45). This is a [positive feedback](concepts.md#c32) [loop](concepts.md#c31).\n\n### 3. New nodes appear\n\n- **Late 1940s**: strains able to break down penicillin spread in hospitals. They became new [nodes](concepts.md#c25) in the population, bringing something that was not there before: when penicillin [arrives](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at them, it no longer causes death.\n- **1959**: the research institutions introduce methicillin ([signal container](concepts.md#c26)) to deal with these strains.\n- **1961**: strains resistant to methicillin as well appear in Britain, later known as methicillin-resistant *Staphylococcus aureus*.\n- **Thereafter**: vancomycin is treated as the last line of defense; in 2002, *Staphylococcus aureus* resistant to vancomycin as well appears in the United States.\n\n### 4. Changes in weight\n\n- **[Taiji](concepts.md#c39)**: the research [loop](concepts.md#c31) (a new drug is launched, used, selects resistant bacteria, and research begins again) and the resistance [loop](concepts.md#c31) (the drug [arrives](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10), sensitive bacteria die, resistant bacteria spread) point in opposite directions and are [coupled](concepts.md#c36) with each other, in [divergence](concepts.md#c38) along the dimension \"is the drug effective?\". Every new drug selects new resistant strains, and every resistant strain forces out a new drug; each side's [outputs](concepts.md#c28) fuel the other.\n- **[Arrivals](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at the research side** (empirical assumption): within the [boundary](concepts.md#c24) of this example, the bacterial population keeps producing new genetic or phenotypic variation, giving rise to new resistance phenomena; these [arrive](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at the research side as surveillance data, experimental results and research questions. On this basis the research side forms new knowledge, techniques or drug regimens, and launches new drugs. Feedback on the clinical efficacy of the new drugs [arrives](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at the research institutions and the community of physicians: relative to their recent [history](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13) of \"old drugs failing\", this is an [arrival](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) of high [discrepancy](concepts.md#c49), and it is enough to restore clinically the direction \"the drug is effective\", matching the spread of resistant strains. The new drugs in turn become new conditions faced by the bacterial population. Resistance phenomena [arriving](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at the research side show the structure of the [taiji](concepts.md#c39); what sustains the research side's own direction is the feedback on the efficacy of new drugs.\n- **[Loop speed](concepts.md#c34)**: a bacterial generation takes only tens of minutes, while a new drug takes more than ten years from research to market. In contrast to heliocentrism, this time the fast side is the bacteria.\n- **[Coupling](concepts.md#c36)**: resistance genes can be transferred between different strains, even different species, through mobile genetic elements. The same [output](concepts.md#c28) [arrives](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at many [wos](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16), bringing them into [convergence](concepts.md#c37) along the dimension of resistance.\n- **[Cognitive obscuration](concepts.md#c35)**: as regards the composition of the population at its next [moment](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c09), this example considers only two kinds of strains, resistant and sensitive: when the [weight](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06) held by resistant strains rises, the [weight](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06) held by sensitive strains necessarily falls.\n- **Fitness cost** (empirical): resistance usually has a cost. In environments without the drug, the survival rate of resistant strains is statistically often lower. This is an empirical fact of biology, not derived from [cognitive obscuration](concepts.md#c35).\n- **[Renewal](concepts.md#c42)**: each generation of bacteria is a new [wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16). They inherit only the genes left by the previous generation, so the composition of the population drifts with every use of the drug.\n- **[Impression](concepts.md#c45)**: physicians judge how the staphylococcal population responds under a drug by monitoring statistics; the object of the [impression](concepts.md#c45) remains the staphylococcal population as a [wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16), while the drug is a condition in the content of the judgment. Such estimates keeping up with the actual changes in the population is [Not Guaranteed](concepts.md#c02).\n- **Assumption about [impact](concepts.md#c47)**: this example bets on [frequency](concepts.md#c48). The drug is used on a large scale and frequently, and every [arrival](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) is selecting (empirical assumption).\n\n### 5. Outcome\n\nBy the 2000s, the [taiji](concepts.md#c39) had not ended. The research [loop](concepts.md#c31) and the resistance [loop](concepts.md#c31) were still pushing against each other, while the discovery of new classes of antibiotics had clearly slowed. This is a judgment at the scale of the hospital systems of Britain and the United States.\n\n### 6. Inferences, historical facts, empirical assumptions and prohibitions\n\n**Inferences**:\n\n- Resistance disappearing after the drug is withdrawn or persisting forever is [Not Guaranteed](concepts.md#c02) ([renewal](concepts.md#c42): [Law of Flux](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c24), [Law of Non-Restoration](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c28)).\n- When sensitive and resistant strains receive the same drug, the same result is [Not Guaranteed](concepts.md#c02) ([coupling](concepts.md#c36)).\n- The completeness of physicians' [impression](concepts.md#c45) of the staphylococcal population's response under a drug is [Not Guaranteed](concepts.md#c02).\n\n**Historical facts (for calibration only)**:\n\n- Methicillin-resistant *Staphylococcus aureus* appeared in 1961; *Staphylococcus aureus* resistant to vancomycin appeared in 2002.\n- The [taiji](concepts.md#c39) had still not ended by the 2000s.\n\n**Empirical assumptions**:\n\n- Without the drug, the survival rate of resistant strains is statistically lower, so sensitive strains have a chance to recover after the drug is withdrawn. But resistant strains may mutate again and narrow this gap, so this can only be bet on as [weight](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06).\n- The research side keeps launching new drugs, and the feedback on their clinical efficacy is, for the research institutions and the community of physicians, a matching [arrival](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) of high [discrepancy](concepts.md#c49) (see step 4). This is stated only for the [boundary](concepts.md#c24) of this example and is not extended beyond it.\n\n**Statements prohibited in this example**:\n\n- \"As long as the drug is withdrawn, the sensitive bacteria will come back.\"\n- \"Once resistance appears, it will never disappear.\"\n- \"Humanity will ultimately defeat bacteria\", or \"bacteria will ultimately win this war\". The ending of a [taiji](concepts.md#c39), and which side disappears, are both [Not Guaranteed](concepts.md#c02).\n- \"The bacteria developed resistance in order to survive.\" It should be written: resistant strains have a statistically higher survival rate in environments with the drug (Explicit Rule 6).\n\n### 7. Conditions and reuse\n\nTesting this example against the [empirical prohibitions](concepts.md#c51) distilled from the heliocentrism example, and considering the outcome \"the research side's [withdrawal of one side](concepts.md#c40)\":\n\n- **Condition 1 ([signal container](concepts.md#c26))**: resistance genes can reside on mobile genetic elements and be transferred between strains; met.\n- **Condition 2 (sustained [arrivals](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) of high [discrepancy](concepts.md#c49))**: the drug is used on a large scale and frequently, continually selecting the population; met.\n- **Condition 3 (the old side lacks matching [arrivals](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10))**: the research side keeps launching new drugs, and the feedback on their clinical efficacy [arrives](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at the research institutions and the community of physicians; by the empirical assumption in step 4, this is a matching [arrival](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) of high [discrepancy](concepts.md#c49). So within the [boundary](concepts.md#c24) of this example, condition 3 is not met.\n\nWithin the [boundary](concepts.md#c24) of this example, since condition 3 is not met, “the [taiji](concepts.md#c39) ends with the research side’s [withdrawal of one side](concepts.md#c40)” [Never Occurs](concepts.md#c01), in agreement with the historical facts. The slowing discovery of new classes of antibiotics makes the matching [arrivals](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) brought by effective new drugs ever rarer, bringing condition 3 gradually closer to being met; by Explicit Rule 7, one can only say that the [weight](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06) of this outcome has become heavier, not that it must happen.\n\nThis example also shows that [empirical prohibitions](concepts.md#c51) are only necessary conditions: conditions 1 and 2 are both met, yet the [taiji](concepts.md#c39) has still not ended.\n\n### Comparison with the heliocentrism example\n\nBoth examples are [taiji](concepts.md#c39) between a fast [loop](concepts.md#c31) and a slow [loop](concepts.md#c31). In heliocentrism the fast one was the [loop](concepts.md#c31) of facts, and the [taiji](concepts.md#c39) ended around 1700; in drug resistance the fast one is the bacteria, and the [taiji](concepts.md#c39) has not ended to this day. The framework guarantees neither outcome; it only marks them as historical facts.\n"}]}
{"paper_uuid":"d244789a-9261-4a0d-a98a-feb8db56b511","paper_title":"生物人輸出格局動力學","paper_title_en":"Dynamics of Output Patterns among Biological Humans","author":"黃正宇 / Cheng Yu Huang","contact":"mthree.tw@gmail.com","concepts_md":"---\nuuid: d244789a-9261-4a0d-a98a-feb8db56b511\nlast-modified: 2026-11-02T00:02:12\n---\n\n\n## public 存續判準 / Persistence Criterion\n\n- 定義:研究者為某個要追蹤的結構(例如[人群圖](concepts.md#c05)、[經濟模式](concepts.md#c09))講明的判準,用來判定它在各個[檢查窗口](concepts.md#c03)中是否再次出現,包括[同一性條件](concepts.md#c02)與[檢查窗口](concepts.md#c03)兩部分。判準是研究者的定義;是否再次出現是該[檢查窗口](concepts.md#c03)實際發生的事實,兩者不互相替代。\n- Definition: A criterion that a researcher states for a structure to be tracked (for example a [Population Graph](concepts.md#c05) or an [Economic Mode](concepts.md#c09)), used to decide whether it appears again in each [check window](concepts.md#c03). It has two parts: an [Identity Condition](concepts.md#c02) and a [Check Window](concepts.md#c03). The criterion is the researcher's definition; whether the structure actually reappears in a [check window](concepts.md#c03) is a fact, and neither replaces the other.\n\n\n## public 同一性條件 / Identity Condition\n\n- 定義:[存續判準](concepts.md#c01)的一部分:研究者講明,在什麼等價條件下,不同[檢查窗口](concepts.md#c03)中的結構算作同一個。\n- Definition: Part of a [Persistence Criterion](concepts.md#c01): the researcher states under what equivalence the structures in different [check windows](concepts.md#c03) count as the same one.\n\n\n## public 檢查窗口 / Check Window\n\n- 定義:[存續判準](concepts.md#c01)的一部分:研究者講明,在哪些窗口中檢查某個結構是否再次出現。不同的結構各依自己的檢查窗口判定,不假定共同的輪次。\n- Definition: Part of a [Persistence Criterion](concepts.md#c01): the researcher states in which windows a structure is checked for reappearing. Different structures are judged by their own check windows; no common round is assumed.\n\n\n## public 外界 / Exterior\n\n- 定義:對某個[節點](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25)而言,自己以外的一切[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)來源,包含其他[節點](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25)與[自然環境](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c16)。外界是相對的,換一個[節點](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25),外界就不同;[節點](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25)的大小由[切法](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c23)決定,可以是一個人,也可以是一間公司;在一張[輸出圖](concepts.md#c06)中,[切法](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c23)以外的一切都是這張圖的外界。\n- Definition: For a given [Node](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25), every source of [Arrival](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) other than itself, including other [Node](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25) and the [Natural Environment](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c16). The exterior is relative: a different [node](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25) has a different exterior. The size of a [Node](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25) is set by the [Cut](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c23); it can be a person or a company. In an [Output Graph](concepts.md#c06), everything outside the [Cut](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c23) is the exterior of that graph.\n\n\n## public 人群圖 / Population Graph\n\n- 定義:在講明的[切法](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c23)下,生物人[節點](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25),以及它們之間的[邊](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c29)(一個[節點](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25)的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28),參與另一個[節點](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25)的[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06)),加上各[節點](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25)自己的[迴路](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c31)(自己的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28),經由自己,又參與自己的[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06))所成的靜態圖。人群圖的[存續判準](concepts.md#c01)由研究者講明,方式同[經濟模式](concepts.md#c09)。\n- Definition: A static graph made, under a stated [Cut](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c23), of human [Node](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25), the [Edge](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c29) between them (the [Output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) of one [node](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25) takes part in the [Weight](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06) of another [node](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25)), and each [node](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25)'s own [Loop](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c31) (its own [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28), through itself, takes part in its own [weight](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06)). Its [Persistence Criterion](concepts.md#c01) is stated by the researcher in the same way as for an [Economic Mode](concepts.md#c09).\n\n\n## public 輸出圖 / Output Graph\n\n- 定義:在[人群圖](concepts.md#c05)的基礎上,在講明的[切法](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c23)、維度與時窗內,把[記錄](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c06)附在點與[邊](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c29)上所得的圖:點是[人群圖](concepts.md#c05)的[節點](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25),加上[切法](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c23)內的[信號容器](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c26)與[隨機源](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c27);[邊](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c29)是[人群圖](concepts.md#c05)的[邊](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c29),加上這些[信號容器](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c26)、[隨機源](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c27)與其他[節點](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25)之間的[邊](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c29);各[節點](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25)的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)[記錄](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c06)附在點上,各次[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)的[記錄](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c06)附在[邊](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c29)上,或附在[節點](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25)自己的[迴路](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c31)上,來自[外界](concepts.md#c04)的[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)附在接收的點上;另外附上研究者對某[節點](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25)某[路徑](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c07)的[前件](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c08)是否具備所作的判定,可以標「未知」。這項判定與[記錄](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c06)並列附上,不算[記錄](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c06)。[切法](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c23)內的[信號容器](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c26)與[隨機源](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c27)也是[節點](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25),與它們的[邊](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c29)一併記入。\n- Definition: A graph obtained by attaching [Record](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c06) to points and [edges](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c29) on top of a [Population Graph](concepts.md#c05), within a stated [Cut](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c23), dimension and time window. The points are the [nodes](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25) of the [population graph](concepts.md#c05), plus the [Signal Container](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c26) and [Random Source](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c27) within the [cut](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c23); the [edges](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c29) are the [edges](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c29) of the [population graph](concepts.md#c05), plus the [edges](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c29) between these [signal containers](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c26) or [random sources](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c27) and other [nodes](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25). A [node](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25)'s [Output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) [records](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c06) are attached to its point; [records](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c06) of each [Arrival](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) are attached to [edges](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c29) or to the [node](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25)'s own [Loop](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c31); [arrivals](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) from the [Exterior](concepts.md#c04) are attached to the receiving point. The researcher's judgments of whether an [Antecedent](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c08) of a [Path](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c07) of a [node](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25) is satisfied (which may be marked unknown) are attached alongside and are not [records](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c06). [Signal Container](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c26) and [Random Source](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c27) within the [cut](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c23) are also [nodes](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25) and are recorded with their [edges](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c29).\n\n\n## public 輸出圖集 / Output Graph Set\n\n- 定義:同一研究中,各時窗、各維度、各尺度的[輸出圖](concepts.md#c06)所構成的集合。它是[歷史](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13)的子集:沒有登記的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28),以及「沒有發生在它身上」這類[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10),都不在圖集上,但仍在[歷史](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13)中,仍參與它們所[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)的[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)的[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06)。\n- Definition: The collection of [Output Graph](concepts.md#c06) for all time windows, dimensions and scales within one study. It is a subset of the [History](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13): [Output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) that were not registered, and [Arrival](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) of the kind 'it did not happen to it', are not in the set but remain in the [history](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13) and still take part in the weights ([Weight](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06)) of the [wos](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16) they [reach](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10).\n\n\n## public 格局傾向 / Pattern Tendency\n\n- 定義:研究者對[輸出圖集](concepts.md#c07)中反覆可見的結構所作的歸納,描述在指定[切法](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c23)下,傾向出現哪一類[輸出圖](concepts.md#c06)結構。它是在指定的[切法](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c23)、時窗、分類規則與比較條件下作的歸納,不屬於任何[節點](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25),也不是任何[節點](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25)[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06)的讀數;限定到單一[節點](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25)、單一[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)類型,且該[節點](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25)是一個[個體](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c20)時,就回到該[個體](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c20)的[輸出傾向](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c02)。\n- Definition: A researcher's generalization of structures that repeatedly appear in an [Output Graph Set](concepts.md#c07), describing which kind of [output-graph](concepts.md#c06) structure tends to appear under a stated [Cut](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c23). It is made under a stated [cut](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c23), time window, classification rule and comparison condition. It belongs to no [Node](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25) and is not a reading of any [node](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25)'s [Weight](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06); restricted to a single [Node](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25) and a single type of [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28), where that [node](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25) is an [Individual](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c20), it reduces to that [individual](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c20)'s [Output Tendency](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c02).\n\n\n## public 經濟模式 / Economic Mode\n\n- 定義:依[存續判準](concepts.md#c01),在[輸出圖集](concepts.md#c07)的多個[檢查窗口](concepts.md#c03)中反覆出現的某一個以[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)相連的結構。同一性看位置,不看是誰;可以只涉及單一[節點](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25),也可以跨[節點](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25);不限於市場,不分[生產](../paper_96f10d75_23d0_441f_94c7_ab87ca28d284/concepts.md#c01)與消費、營利與否、有無貨幣。經濟模式帶有[前件](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c08)判定與逐[檢查窗口](concepts.md#c03)的[存續判準](concepts.md#c01),這是它與[共振](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c09)的區別。經濟模式有同一性,可以[判準中斷](concepts.md#c10);[格局傾向](concepts.md#c08)是跨圖的歸納,沒有同一性,也沒有[中斷](concepts.md#c10)。經濟模式本身不是[節點](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25),是研究者對[節點](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25)的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)所作的歸類。\n- Definition: A single structure, connected by [Arrival](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10), that repeatedly appears in several [check windows](concepts.md#c03) of an [Output Graph Set](concepts.md#c07), according to a [Persistence Criterion](concepts.md#c01). Identity depends on position, not on who takes part; it may involve a single [Node](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25) or several [nodes](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25); it is not limited to markets, and it does not depend on [production](../paper_96f10d75_23d0_441f_94c7_ab87ca28d284/concepts.md#c01) versus consumption, profit, or money. An economic mode carries [antecedent](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c08) judgments and a [persistence criterion](concepts.md#c01) applied [check window](concepts.md#c03) by [check window](concepts.md#c03), which distinguishes it from [Resonance](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c09). An economic mode has identity and can undergo a [Criterion Break](concepts.md#c10), whereas a [Pattern Tendency](concepts.md#c08) is a generalization across graphs, with neither identity nor [break](concepts.md#c10). An economic mode is not itself a [node](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25); it is the researcher's grouping of [node](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25) [Output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28).\n\n\n## public 判準中斷 / Criterion Break\n\n- 定義:依[存續判準](concepts.md#c01),某個被追蹤的結構(例如[經濟模式](concepts.md#c09)、[人群圖](concepts.md#c05))在某[檢查窗口](concepts.md#c03)內未再出現,即記為判準中斷。什麼算中斷,由判準決定;判準是研究者的定義;是否中斷是該[檢查窗口](concepts.md#c03)實際發生的事實。判準中斷不等於[崩潰](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c15)、[退場](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c43)或[判準退場](../paper_96f10d75_23d0_441f_94c7_ab87ca28d284/concepts.md#c09),彼此不互相蘊含。\n- Definition: Recorded when, according to a [Persistence Criterion](concepts.md#c01), a structure being tracked (for example an [Economic Mode](concepts.md#c09) or a [Population Graph](concepts.md#c05)) does not appear again in a given [Check Window](concepts.md#c03). What counts as a break is decided by the criterion. The criterion is the researcher's definition; whether the break occurs is a fact about that [check window](concepts.md#c03). A criterion break is not the same as [Collapse](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c15), [Exit](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c43) or [Criterion Exit](../paper_96f10d75_23d0_441f_94c7_ab87ca28d284/concepts.md#c09), and none implies another.\n\n\n## public 界面節點 / Interface Node\n\n- 定義:[經濟模式](concepts.md#c09)中有[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)[外界](concepts.md#c04)的[節點](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25)。類型依上游[節點](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25)的分類,可以是[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)、[信號容器](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c26)或[隨機源](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c27);同一[經濟模式](concepts.md#c09)可以有多種界面節點,[外界](concepts.md#c04)經由不同界面接觸到的是性質不同的[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)來源。\n- Definition: A [Node](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25) of an [Economic Mode](concepts.md#c09) whose [Output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) [reaches](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) the [Exterior](concepts.md#c04). Its type follows the classification of [nodes](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25): it can be a [Wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16), a [Signal Container](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c26) or a [Random Source](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c27). One [economic mode](concepts.md#c09) can have several kinds of interface nodes, and the [exterior](concepts.md#c04) meets [arrival](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) sources of different character through different interfaces.\n\n\n## public 生殖模式 / Reproductive Mode\n\n- 定義:產出[子代](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c15)的[經濟模式](concepts.md#c09)。這是依產出所作的稱呼,是研究者的[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18),沿用[經濟模式](concepts.md#c09)的定義,沒有另外的成立條件。\n- Definition: An [Economic Mode](concepts.md#c09) whose product is [Offspring](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c15). It is a name given by what is produced, a researcher's [Distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18); it uses the definition of [Economic Mode](concepts.md#c09) as it stands and adds no further condition.\n\n## 不登記\n\n- 輸出格局:2026-11-03 作者裁決不登記,研究主題名;正文只以它指稱研究對象(多個生物人的輸出之間的到達結構),沒有作為推導構件使用;格局傾向才是定義過的概念。\n- 淘金結構:2026-11-03 作者裁決不登記,第十一節案例中對所追蹤結構的簡稱,只在該案例內使用。\n- 未追蹤的輸出:2026-11-02 作者裁決不登記。\n- 一群經濟模式:2026-11-02 作者裁決不登記。\n\n## 待決項\n\n無\n","formalization_md":"論文:《生物人輸出格局動力學》\nUUID:d244789a-9261-4a0d-a98a-feb8db56b511\n\n## 記號約定\n\n來源:論文全文\n\n- 未追蹤的輸出:一般用語,不是概念\n- 一群經濟模式:一般用語,不是概念\n- 有限觀察者:一般用語,不是概念「觀察者」\n- 形成時刻:一般用語,不是概念「時刻」\n- 同一:一般用語,不是概念「同一」\n- 涉及:一般用語,不是概念「涉及」;指該概念時加前綴\n- 出現:一般用語,不是概念「出現」\n- 決定:一般用語,不是概念「決定」\n- 個體:一般用語,不是概念「個體」;指該概念時加前綴\n- 累積:一般用語,不是概念「累積」\n- 給定:一般用語,不是概念「給定」\n\n## 前置條件\n\n來源:論文第二節、第〇之三節、第〇之四節、第〇之五節、第五之一節【正文:句8150008775、句6526439437、句0501141302、句3253419729、句3645260807】\n\n- 前提一:若 一條 81952268-47b1-4d8c-9605-270c42646693.路徑 的 81952268-47b1-4d8c-9605-270c42646693.門檻 中至少有一項 81952268-47b1-4d8c-9605-270c42646693.前件 只能由其他 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.節點 的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 而具備,則 該 81952268-47b1-4d8c-9605-270c42646693.路徑 的可行性取決於其他 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.節點 的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 【正文:句2649401942】\n- 附註:前提一是條件式,屬範圍設定,不是存在主張。【正文:句3895143046】找不到滿足 81952268-47b1-4d8c-9605-270c42646693.前件 的 81952268-47b1-4d8c-9605-270c42646693.路徑 時,本篇只是不適用,前提一不因此被推翻。【正文:句3247195958】\n- 前提二:經濟模式 的 存續判準 由研究者講明;組成(存續判準, 同一性條件, 檢查窗口)【正文:句0494591040、句9916896169、句5314177565】\n- 附註:現實沒有統一的輪次,96f10d75-23d0-441f-94c7-ab87ca28d284.推演輪 是研究者對某一 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 序列的切段;不同 經濟模式 各依自己的 檢查窗口 判定,不假定共同的輪次。【正文:句2111139546、句4352434781、句8957352641】\n- 前提三:一條 81952268-47b1-4d8c-9605-270c42646693.路徑 的 81952268-47b1-4d8c-9605-270c42646693.前件,可以因某筆 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 而具備;這筆 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 可以來自同一 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.節點 的另一條 81952268-47b1-4d8c-9605-270c42646693.路徑,也可以來自其他 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.節點 【正文:句4604557506】\n- 附註:前提三是可能性主張,屬範圍設定,只說這種供應關係可以成立,不說某條 81952268-47b1-4d8c-9605-270c42646693.路徑 一定如此。【正文:句9473546406】\n- 前提四:每個生物人 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.節點 的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.進場,都來自某次生殖事件:該 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.節點 是這次生殖事件產生的 81952268-47b1-4d8c-9605-270c42646693.子代【正文:句9553888098】\n- 附註:前提四是範圍設定,只針對生物人 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.節點,不涉及其他類型的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.節點。【正文:句8938512947】\n- 前提五:生殖模式 的 81952268-47b1-4d8c-9605-270c42646693.路徑,有 81952268-47b1-4d8c-9605-270c42646693.前件 只能由對方的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 供應【正文:句5044847508】\n- 附註:前提五是範圍設定,是生物學事實,只針對 生殖模式,不涉及其他 經濟模式。【正文:句0502696150】\n- 前提六:參與 經濟模式 的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.信號容器 或 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.隨機源,算在它所服務的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦 的 2ccbf179-58cf-4851-bd72-5fa886e4b2c3.可達子圖 範圍內【正文:句0269867348】\n- 附註:前提六是範圍設定。 2ccbf179-58cf-4851-bd72-5fa886e4b2c3.可達子圖 的定義只收送給中心的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.呈現;本篇為了涵蓋只被 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦 使用的容器,把參與的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.信號容器 與 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.隨機源 一併算進去。【正文:句4066193613、句2515147078】\n- 前提七:一筆 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 是否 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 某個 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.節點,不只取決於這筆 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出,也取決於該 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.節點 的 外界 中其他部分【正文:句3475203735】\n- 附註:前提七是經驗前提;37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 的定義沒有說落不落得到由什麼決定,本篇把這一點列為前提。【正文:句8331143222、句7506611666】\n- 前提八:以 81952268-47b1-4d8c-9605-270c42646693.現存樣本條件化 為觀察前提:觀察到的 經濟模式,都是通過歷次 存續判準 者;研究須同時納入已 判準中斷、但仍留有 81952268-47b1-4d8c-9605-270c42646693.記錄 的 經濟模式【正文:句2669007563、句2385497174】\n- 前提九 [限定條件]:只登記 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 的物理改變,不登記 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別 內容【正文:句7240422453】\n- 前提十 [限定條件]:本篇所有結論,都是就 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.宇宙 之內的有限觀察者而言;研究者與各 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.節點 都在 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.宇宙 之內;凡說「推不出」,指研究者與各 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.節點 在事前都推不出【正文:句7758096401、句3342353739】\n- 前提十一 [限定條件]:本篇記為:需要細看 2ccbf179-58cf-4851-bd72-5fa886e4b2c3.自然環境 時,由研究者放大 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.切法【正文:句2202154417】\n- 前提十二:在指定的 經濟模式 與維度上,本篇把 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.節點 依序加條件分為四層:2ccbf179-58cf-4851-bd72-5fa886e4b2c3.可達子圖 中的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.節點;其中在該維度上有 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 的;其中 81952268-47b1-4d8c-9605-270c42646693.前件 被判定為能供應的;其中實際在 經濟模式 中 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 的。每往內一層都多一個條件【正文:句1060589555、句9842457827、句8842846284】\n- 前提十三:本篇記為:經濟模式 中參與 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.節點 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出、37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達、進入 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.歷史、2ccbf179-58cf-4851-bd72-5fa886e4b2c3.結果回饋 與它參與 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.權重 的過程,在該 經濟模式 的各 檢查窗口 依次重複;下一個 檢查窗口 若沒有參與 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.節點 的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出,循環在該 檢查窗口 停止;之後的 檢查窗口 若再有參與 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.節點 的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出,循環重新開始【正文:句0578176963、句5347767097】\n\n## 體例中的簡稱(對應〇之六)\n\n來源:論文第〇之六節【正文:句4751283353】\n\n- 附註:說「經濟模式 成為 外界」「經濟模式 參與 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.權重」「經濟模式 進入 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.歷史」,都是研究者層的簡稱;實際 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達、進入 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.歷史、參與 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.權重 的,是 經濟模式 中 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.節點 的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出。【正文:句8408334071】\n- 附註:經濟模式 本身是研究者對這些 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 的歸類,不是 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.節點。【正文:句7733444005】\n\n## 外界(對應三之一)\n\n來源:論文第三之一節【正文:句9317998225】\n\n- 步驟三之一之一:對某個 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.節點 而言的 外界 包含其他 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.節點 與 2ccbf179-58cf-4851-bd72-5fa886e4b2c3.自然環境(從 外界 的定義 推出)【正文:句9486949009】\n- 步驟三之一之二:外界 相對於 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.節點,換一個 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.節點,外界 就不同;b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.節點 的大小由 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.切法 決定,可以是一個人,也可以是一間公司(從 外界 的定義 推出)【正文:句7430185712、句9109852426】\n- 步驟三之一之三:在一張 輸出圖 中,b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.切法 以外的一切都是這張圖的 外界;2ccbf179-58cf-4851-bd72-5fa886e4b2c3.自然環境 不在圖上另畫(從 外界 的定義 + 輸出圖 的定義 + 2ccbf179-58cf-4851-bd72-5fa886e4b2c3.自然環境 的定義 推出)【正文:句8796362109、句2202154417】\n\n## 人群圖、輸出圖、輸出圖集(對應三之二)\n\n來源:論文第三之二節【正文:句7589297944】\n\n- 步驟三之二之一:組成(人群圖, 生物人 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.節點, b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.邊, 各 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.節點 自己的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.迴路)(從 人群圖 的定義 + b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.邊 的定義 + b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.迴路 的定義 推出)【正文:句3424700982】\n- 步驟三之二之二:人群圖 的 存續判準 由研究者講明,方式同 經濟模式(從 人群圖 的定義 + 前提二 推出)【正文:句0374017040】\n- 步驟三之二之三:組成(輸出圖, 人群圖, b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.切法 內的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.信號容器 與 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.隨機源 及它們的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.邊, 附在點與 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.邊 上的 81952268-47b1-4d8c-9605-270c42646693.記錄, 研究者對 81952268-47b1-4d8c-9605-270c42646693.前件 是否具備所作的判定)(從 輸出圖 的定義 推出)【正文:句0847597262】\n- 附註:研究者對 81952268-47b1-4d8c-9605-270c42646693.前件 是否具備所作的判定,與 81952268-47b1-4d8c-9605-270c42646693.記錄 並列附上,不算 81952268-47b1-4d8c-9605-270c42646693.記錄。【正文:句0688293978】\n- 步驟三之二之四:b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.切法 內的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.信號容器 與 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.隨機源 也是 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.節點,與它們的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.邊 一併記入 輸出圖(從 輸出圖 的定義 推出)【正文:句5562450158】\n- 步驟三之二之五:組成(輸出圖集, 各時窗、各維度、各尺度的 輸出圖)(從 輸出圖集 的定義 推出)【正文:句0592553737】\n- 步驟三之二之六:輸出圖集 是 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.歷史 的子集(從 輸出圖集 的定義 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.歷史 的定義 推出)【正文:句3620609773】\n- 步驟三之二之七:蘊含(某 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 沒有登記, 該 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 不在 輸出圖集 上但仍在 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.歷史 中並仍參與它們所 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦 的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.權重);「沒有發生在它身上」這類 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 同理(從 步驟三之二之六 + 輸出圖集 的定義 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦 的定義 推出)【正文:句3620609773】\n- 步驟三之二之八:蘊含(人群圖 中的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦 的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 自己, 在 人群圖 上是這個 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.節點 自己的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.迴路)(從 步驟三之二之一 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦 的定義 + b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.迴路 的定義 推出)【正文:句9854803383】\n- 附註:b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.邊 不分 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.時刻,同一條 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.邊 上可以有許多次 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達。【正文:句9854803383】\n\n## 格局傾向(對應三之三)\n\n來源:論文第三之三節【正文:句1122699673】\n\n- 步驟三之三之一:格局傾向 與 81952268-47b1-4d8c-9605-270c42646693.輸出傾向 平行:81952268-47b1-4d8c-9605-270c42646693.輸出傾向 歸納一個 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.個體 的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出,格局傾向 歸納 輸出圖集 中反覆可見的 輸出圖 結構(從 格局傾向 的定義 + 81952268-47b1-4d8c-9605-270c42646693.輸出傾向 的定義 推出)【正文:句2991143026】\n- 附註:格局傾向 不屬於任何 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.節點,也不是任何 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.節點 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.權重 的讀數。【正文:句7563487862】\n- 步驟三之三之二:蘊含(格局傾向 限定到單一 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.節點 與單一 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 類型,且該 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.節點 是一個 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.個體, 回到該 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.個體 的 81952268-47b1-4d8c-9605-270c42646693.輸出傾向)(從 格局傾向 的定義 + 81952268-47b1-4d8c-9605-270c42646693.輸出傾向 的定義 推出)【正文:句0829895176】\n\n## 經濟模式(對應三之四)\n\n來源:論文第三之四節【正文:句4516870256】\n\n- 步驟三之四之一:蘊含(兩個 檢查窗口 的結構在講明的等價條件下同構, 兩者算同一 經濟模式)(從 經濟模式 的定義 + 前提二 + 同一性條件 的定義 推出)【正文:句0178645621】\n- 步驟三之四之二:參與的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.節點 更替,不必然改變同一性(從 步驟三之四之一 + 經濟模式 的定義 推出)【正文:句1314424322】\n- 步驟三之四之六:經濟模式 是一個以 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 相連的結構:參與的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.節點 之間,或參與的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.節點 與 外界 之間,有 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達;把許多彼此不相連的 經濟模式 合稱一個名字,是研究者的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別,不是一個 經濟模式(從 經濟模式 的定義 + 外界 的定義 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別 的定義 推出)【正文:句1420248720、句8569782288】\n- 步驟三之四之三:經濟模式 可以只涉及單一 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.節點,也可以跨 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.節點(從 經濟模式 的定義 推出)【正文:句8797983349】\n- 附註:經濟模式 不限於市場,不分 96f10d75-23d0-441f-94c7-ab87ca28d284.生產 與消費、營利與否、有無貨幣;名稱只是研究者的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別,不賦予它獨立的本體。【正文:句9479716091、句6581675850】\n- 步驟三之四之四:格局傾向 沒有同一性,也沒有 判準中斷;經濟模式 有同一性,可以 判準中斷(從 格局傾向 的定義 + 經濟模式 的定義 推出)【正文:句5145240975】\n- 附註:經濟模式 與 2ccbf179-58cf-4851-bd72-5fa886e4b2c3.共振 不同(依 2ccbf179-58cf-4851-bd72-5fa886e4b2c3.共振 的定義):經濟模式 帶有 81952268-47b1-4d8c-9605-270c42646693.前件 判定與逐 檢查窗口 的 存續判準,而且可以只涉及單一 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.節點。【正文:句3427164563】\n- 步驟三之四之五:在 96f10d75-23d0-441f-94c7-ab87ca28d284.生產 維度上,經濟模式 中多 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.節點 反覆相容接續、且彼此之間有 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 或有共同來源對它們都有 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 的部分是 2ccbf179-58cf-4851-bd72-5fa886e4b2c3.共振 的定義所說的情形(從 2ccbf179-58cf-4851-bd72-5fa886e4b2c3.共振 的定義 + 經濟模式 的定義 推出)【正文:句4633292584】\n\n## 判準中斷(對應三之五)\n\n來源:論文第三之五節【正文:句4183162770】\n\n- 步驟三之五之一:蘊含(某個被追蹤的結構(例如 經濟模式、人群圖)依 存續判準 在某 檢查窗口 內未再出現, 記為 判準中斷)(從 判準中斷 的定義 推出)【正文:句0323819964、句5190419659】\n- 附註:判準是研究者的定義,是否 判準中斷 是該 檢查窗口 實際的事實,兩者不互相替代,和 96f10d75-23d0-441f-94c7-ab87ca28d284.判準退場 的結構相同。【正文:句5756748000、句0551496646】\n- 附註:判準中斷 與 2ccbf179-58cf-4851-bd72-5fa886e4b2c3.崩潰、b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.退場、96f10d75-23d0-441f-94c7-ab87ca28d284.判準退場 的判準不同,彼此不互相蘊含:經濟模式 可以 判準中斷 而秩序未 2ccbf179-58cf-4851-bd72-5fa886e4b2c3.崩潰,參與者可以 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.退場 而 經濟模式 未 判準中斷。【正文:句4572233885】\n\n## 界面節點(對應三之六)\n\n來源:論文第三之六節【正文:句5072651360】\n\n- 步驟三之六之一:每個 界面節點 都是 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.節點;界面節點 是 經濟模式 中有 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 外界 的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.節點(從 界面節點 的定義 推出)【正文:句4496427856】\n- 步驟三之六之二:界面節點 的類型為 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦、b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.信號容器、b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.隨機源 之一;同一 經濟模式 可以有多種 界面節點(從 界面節點 的定義 推出)【正文:句3317038589、句7600761128】\n\n## 2ccbf179-58cf-4851-bd72-5fa886e4b2c3.可達子圖:經濟模式 的範圍(對應四、四之一至四之三)\n\n來源:論文第四節、第四之一節、第四之二節、第四之三節【正文:句3836066728、句9575653698、句5887004121、句7261780697】\n\n- 附註:本節依 2ccbf179-58cf-4851-bd72-5fa886e4b2c3.可達子圖 的定義,全部以已 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 的 81952268-47b1-4d8c-9605-270c42646693.記錄 來說;事前「可能接觸誰」屬於 81952268-47b1-4d8c-9605-270c42646693.前件 的判定,不屬於 2ccbf179-58cf-4851-bd72-5fa886e4b2c3.可達子圖。【正文:句7656185525、句0488672935】\n- 結論四之一:蘊含(在某 檢查窗口 內某 經濟模式 中甲的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦 乙, 屬於(甲, 乙在該 檢查窗口 的 2ccbf179-58cf-4851-bd72-5fa886e4b2c3.可達子圖))(從 2ccbf179-58cf-4851-bd72-5fa886e4b2c3.可達子圖 的定義 推出)【正文:句8017877748】\n- 步驟四之二之一:跨 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.節點 經濟模式 的每個參與 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.節點,至少與另一參與 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.節點 或與 外界 之間有 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達,否則不在同一結構中(從 步驟三之四之六 推出)【正文:句4982000897】\n- 步驟四之二之二:送出 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.節點,落在接收的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦 的 2ccbf179-58cf-4851-bd72-5fa886e4b2c3.可達子圖 中;每個參與的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦 是自己的 2ccbf179-58cf-4851-bd72-5fa886e4b2c3.可達子圖 的中心,中心算在內(從 結論四之一 + 2ccbf179-58cf-4851-bd72-5fa886e4b2c3.可達子圖 的定義 推出)【正文:句3347603074】\n- 步驟四之二之三:b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.信號容器 與 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.隨機源 不是 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦,沒有自己的 2ccbf179-58cf-4851-bd72-5fa886e4b2c3.可達子圖;依前提六,參與的它們算在所服務的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦 的 2ccbf179-58cf-4851-bd72-5fa886e4b2c3.可達子圖 範圍內(從 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.信號容器 的定義 + b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.隨機源 的定義 + 2ccbf179-58cf-4851-bd72-5fa886e4b2c3.可達子圖 的定義 + 前提六 推出)【正文:句6025833339】\n- 結論四之二:在某 檢查窗口 內,跨 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.節點 經濟模式 中參與的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦,都是自己的 2ccbf179-58cf-4851-bd72-5fa886e4b2c3.可達子圖 的中心;參與的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.信號容器 與 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.隨機源,算在它們所服務的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦 的 2ccbf179-58cf-4851-bd72-5fa886e4b2c3.可達子圖 範圍內;經濟模式 的範圍不超過已發生的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 所及的範圍(從 結論四之一 + 步驟四之二之一 + 步驟四之二之二 + 步驟四之二之三 推出)【正文:句2918911045、句8187719779】\n- 結論四之三:某 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.節點 在 2ccbf179-58cf-4851-bd72-5fa886e4b2c3.可達子圖 中,不推出它與中心 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.節點 在其他維度上有 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達(從 2ccbf179-58cf-4851-bd72-5fa886e4b2c3.可達子圖 的定義 + 81952268-47b1-4d8c-9605-270c42646693.記錄 的定義 + 輸出圖 的定義 推出)【正文:句9023004741】\n- 結論四之四:某 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.節點 在 2ccbf179-58cf-4851-bd72-5fa886e4b2c3.可達子圖 中,即使在相關維度上有 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達,也不推出它的 81952268-47b1-4d8c-9605-270c42646693.可行集合 中有某條 81952268-47b1-4d8c-9605-270c42646693.路徑,其 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 能被判定為某 經濟模式 所需的 81952268-47b1-4d8c-9605-270c42646693.前件(從 81952268-47b1-4d8c-9605-270c42646693.前件 的定義 + 81952268-47b1-4d8c-9605-270c42646693.可行集合 的定義 推出)【正文:句6356540666】\n- 結論四之五:即使某 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.節點 能供應相應 81952268-47b1-4d8c-9605-270c42646693.前件,也不推出它在下一個 檢查窗口 會 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出(從 81952268-47b1-4d8c-9605-270c42646693.門檻 的定義 + 81952268-47b1-4d8c-9605-270c42646693.可行集合 的定義 推出)【正文:句7475435717】\n- 步驟四之五之一:在指定的 經濟模式 與維度上,下列各層依序含於前一層;內層的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.節點 必在外層,但由外層推不出內層(從 前提十二 + 結論四之三 + 結論四之四 + 結論四之五 推出)【正文:句1060589555、句9842457827、句8842846284】\n- [作者裁決] 能實際供應的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.節點,就是被判定為 81952268-47b1-4d8c-9605-270c42646693.前件 具備的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.節點,所以第四層也是在第三層中再加一個條件;稽核所稱由「不蘊含」推出包含關係不成立,包含關係來自 前提十二。\n\n```\n可達子圖中的節點 ⊇ 在該維度上有到達的節點 ⊇ 前件被判定為能供應的節點 ⊇ 實際在 經濟模式 中輸出的節點\n```\n\n- 附註:最後一層只能等事後的 81952268-47b1-4d8c-9605-270c42646693.記錄。【正文:句8842846284】\n- 步驟四之六之一:一筆 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 另一方,以這筆 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 發生並能落到對方為條件(從 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 的定義 推出)【正文:句5437151066】\n- 步驟四之六之二:b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 是否落到對方,也取決於對方的 外界(從 前提七 推出)【正文:句5593819178】\n- 步驟四之六之三:b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 不變時,外界 改變仍可能使 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 發生或不發生;2ccbf179-58cf-4851-bd72-5fa886e4b2c3.可達子圖 只計已 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 者,所以曾有 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 中心 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦 的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.呈現 因此改變時,它就隨之改變(從 步驟四之六之二 + 2ccbf179-58cf-4851-bd72-5fa886e4b2c3.可達子圖 的定義 推出)【正文:句0093634188】\n- 結論四之六:一筆 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 是否發生,不只取決於這筆 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出,也取決於 外界;所以在各 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.個體 的 81952268-47b1-4d8c-9605-270c42646693.輸出傾向 都沒有可辨改變的情況下,2ccbf179-58cf-4851-bd72-5fa886e4b2c3.可達子圖 仍可能改變(從 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 的定義 + 前提七 + 步驟四之六之三 + 81952268-47b1-4d8c-9605-270c42646693.輸出傾向 的定義 推出)【正文:句5347995932、句6120176838】\n- 結論四之七:蘊含(某 經濟模式 的 同一性條件 要求某些 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達(缺少其中任一項就不滿足)且這些 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 在某 檢查窗口 內不再發生, 該 經濟模式 在該 檢查窗口 判準中斷)(從 經濟模式 的定義 + 判準中斷 的定義 + 同一性條件 的定義 推出)【正文:句0416562448】\n- 步驟四之七之一:蘊含(新的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 發生, 原本未出現的結構可能因此出現)(從 經濟模式 的定義 + 判準中斷 的定義 推出)【正文:句0498901763】\n\n## 經濟模式 的形成(對應五)\n\n來源:論文第五節、第五之一節【正文:句4960310981、句3645260807】\n\n- 步驟五之一之一:參與 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.節點 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出,研究者指定登記的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 被 81952268-47b1-4d8c-9605-270c42646693.記錄(從 96f10d75-23d0-441f-94c7-ab87ca28d284.推演輪 的定義 推出)【正文:句6852302718】\n- 步驟五之一之二:b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 可能 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 其他 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.節點、外界,或經由 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.迴路 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 自己(從 96f10d75-23d0-441f-94c7-ab87ca28d284.推演輪 的定義 + b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.節點 的定義 + 外界 的定義 + b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.邊 的定義 + b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.迴路 的定義 推出)【正文:句5563560346】\n- 步驟五之一之三:各參與 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦 的 2ccbf179-58cf-4851-bd72-5fa886e4b2c3.結果回饋 若 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 它自己,就進入它的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.歷史(從 2ccbf179-58cf-4851-bd72-5fa886e4b2c3.結果回饋 的定義 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.歷史 的定義 推出)【正文:句4567953521】\n- 步驟五之一之四:步驟五之一之三 中進入各 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦 的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.歷史,參與它下一 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.時刻 的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.權重,這一步不一定讀得到(從 步驟五之一之三 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦 的定義 推出)【正文:句0994646829】\n- 步驟五之一之五:蘊含(下一個 檢查窗口 有這些 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦 的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出, 該 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 在這些 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.歷史 參與的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.權重 下發生)(從 步驟五之一之四 + 96f10d75-23d0-441f-94c7-ab87ca28d284.推演輪 的定義 + b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 的定義 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.坍塌 的定義 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦 的定義 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.歷史 的定義 推出)【正文:句3421750220】\n- 循環五之一:步驟五之一之一 至 步驟五之一之五 在各 檢查窗口 依次重複;退出條件:下一個 檢查窗口 沒有參與 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.節點 的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出,循環在該 檢查窗口 停止;之後的 檢查窗口 若再有參與 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.節點 的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出,循環重新開始;循環停止不等於 判準中斷,是否 判準中斷 依 存續判準 判定(從 步驟五之一之五 + 前提十三 + 存續判準 的定義 + 判準中斷 的定義 推出)【正文:句3421750220、句5347767097】\n- 附註:以上是描述,不是新定義;它對應 96f10d75-23d0-441f-94c7-ab87ca28d284.推演輪 的定義,本篇另加 2ccbf179-58cf-4851-bd72-5fa886e4b2c3.結果回饋 與它參與 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.權重 兩步,並把它放在 經濟模式 的 檢查窗口 上。【正文:句7706050717、句0578176963】\n\n## 參與的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦 各有 2ccbf179-58cf-4851-bd72-5fa886e4b2c3.小迴路(對應五之二)\n\n來源:論文第五之二節【正文:句1818567843】\n\n- 步驟五之二之一:37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦 的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 是它自己的一次 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.坍塌 結果;一個 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.呈現 的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.坍塌 結果,是它下一 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.時刻 中依 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.權重 而定、37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.權重 不為零的結果,也就是以正的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.權重 落在它身上,所以這次 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.坍塌 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.涉及 它;37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.坍塌 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.涉及 它時,結果就 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 它;所以 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦 的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 都 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 它自己(從 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 的定義 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.坍塌 的定義 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.權重 的定義 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.時刻 的定義 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.涉及 的定義 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦 的定義 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 的定義 推出)【正文:句7152089014】\n- 步驟五之二之四:37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦 的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 經由自己,又參與它自己的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.權重,構成 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.迴路,也就是它的 2ccbf179-58cf-4851-bd72-5fa886e4b2c3.小迴路(從 步驟五之二之一 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦 的定義 + b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.迴路 的定義 + 2ccbf179-58cf-4851-bd72-5fa886e4b2c3.小迴路 的定義 推出)【正文:句7152089014】\n- 結論五之一:凡有 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦 參與的 經濟模式,其中每個參與的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦 都有自己的 2ccbf179-58cf-4851-bd72-5fa886e4b2c3.小迴路(從 步驟五之二之四 推出)【正文:句0941866291】\n- 步驟五之二之五:37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦 單方面 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 時,即使沒有任何回應,在它其後的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.時刻 中「沒有發生在它身上」也是一次 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達(從 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 的定義 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.時刻 的定義 推出)【正文:句1140712949】\n- [作者裁決] 依 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.時刻 的定義與 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 的定義,本步驟來源足夠;稽核所稱缺少一次 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.坍塌 的條件,已由 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.時刻 的定義滿足。\n- 附註:個體滿足自己、兩人互動、單方面 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出,都在結論五之一之列;需要逐案判定的不是「有沒有 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.迴路」,而是「有哪些 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.迴路」:只有 2ccbf179-58cf-4851-bd72-5fa886e4b2c3.小迴路、有 2ccbf179-58cf-4851-bd72-5fa886e4b2c3.大迴路,或構成 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.太極。【正文:句3281981267、句2998529909】\n\n## 81952268-47b1-4d8c-9605-270c42646693.前件 的供應來自他人(對應五之三)\n\n來源:論文第五之三節【正文:句3230235644】\n\n- 步驟五之三之一:81952268-47b1-4d8c-9605-270c42646693.路徑 實現,表示它在該 檢查窗口 可行,81952268-47b1-4d8c-9605-270c42646693.門檻 中各 81952268-47b1-4d8c-9605-270c42646693.前件 都具備(從 81952268-47b1-4d8c-9605-270c42646693.門檻 的定義 推出)【正文:句6086422119】\n- 步驟五之三之二:蘊含(某 81952268-47b1-4d8c-9605-270c42646693.路徑 屬於前提一所指的 81952268-47b1-4d8c-9605-270c42646693.路徑, 其中至少一項 81952268-47b1-4d8c-9605-270c42646693.前件 只能由其他 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.節點 的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 而具備)(從 前提一 推出)【正文:句4583592713】\n- 步驟五之三之三:蘊含(某 81952268-47b1-4d8c-9605-270c42646693.路徑 屬於前提一所指的 81952268-47b1-4d8c-9605-270c42646693.路徑 且已實現, 必有其他 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.節點 的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 過,在該 檢查窗口 或更早)(從 步驟五之三之一 + 步驟五之三之二 推出)【正文:句2883637925】\n- 結論五之二:蘊含(某 81952268-47b1-4d8c-9605-270c42646693.路徑 屬於前提一所指的 81952268-47b1-4d8c-9605-270c42646693.路徑 且它在某 檢查窗口 內實現, 必有其他 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.節點 的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 並供應它的 81952268-47b1-4d8c-9605-270c42646693.前件)(從 前提一 + 81952268-47b1-4d8c-9605-270c42646693.可行集合 的定義 + 81952268-47b1-4d8c-9605-270c42646693.前件 的定義 + 步驟五之三之三 推出)【正文:句0903058237】\n- 附註:供應者算進同一個 經濟模式(經濟模式 跨 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.節點),或算作 經濟模式 的 外界,是研究者的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別。【正文:句9496168141】\n\n## 修正與預測(對應五之四)\n\n來源:論文第五之四節【正文:句4867277221】\n\n- 結論五之三:每個 檢查窗口 的 2ccbf179-58cf-4851-bd72-5fa886e4b2c3.結果回饋,都可能改變參與 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦 之後的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.權重;下一 檢查窗口 若有這些 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦 不被 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.鎖死 的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出,這些 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 就可能隨之不同;但改變沒有預設方向,不保證更有利於 經濟模式 延續(從 2ccbf179-58cf-4851-bd72-5fa886e4b2c3.學習 的定義 + 2ccbf179-58cf-4851-bd72-5fa886e4b2c3.結果回饋 的定義 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.坍塌 的定義 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.鎖死 的定義 + b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 的定義 推出)【正文:句4654487781、句7636383293】\n- 步驟五之四之五:經濟模式 的再出現取決於判準所涉的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出,而這些 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 是否 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達,也可能取決於 外界(從 經濟模式 的定義 + 前提二 + 結論四之六 推出)【正文:句8661876869】\n- 結論五之四:蘊含(經濟模式 在 存續判準 下是否再出現,取決於不被 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.鎖死 的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦 或 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.隨機源 的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出(也就是這些 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 的不同可能結果,會使判準得出不同判定)且這些 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.節點 在該 檢查窗口 內有不被 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.鎖死 的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.時刻, 它在下一 檢查窗口 是否 判準中斷 事前不可推出);過去的 2ccbf179-58cf-4851-bd72-5fa886e4b2c3.落空比例 只是外顯統計,不能代替 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.權重(從 前提二 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.黑箱律 + b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.隨機源 的定義 + 2ccbf179-58cf-4851-bd72-5fa886e4b2c3.落空比例 的定義 + 步驟五之四之五 推出)【正文:句2341890240、句8661876869】\n- [作者裁決] 本條來源已列 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.黑箱律(以概念本身作為來源),稽核所稱來源未列 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.黑箱律 不成立。\n- 附註:若判準只取決於被 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.鎖死 的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.信號容器 中的內容,則結論五之四不適用,是否 判準中斷 可由容器內容判定。【正文:句7031006733】\n- 步驟五之五之一:輸出圖集 是 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.歷史 的子集(從 步驟三之二之六 推出)【正文:句5052997665】\n- 結論五之五:即使擁有完整的 輸出圖集,也不能推出 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦 或 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.隨機源 在下一 檢查窗口 不被 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.鎖死 時的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出(從 步驟五之五之一 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦 的定義 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.黑箱律 + b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.隨機源 的定義 推出)【正文:句9650264389、句3159968588、句8105217198】\n- [作者裁決] 本條來源已列 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.黑箱律(以概念本身作為來源),稽核所稱來源未列 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.黑箱律 不成立。\n\n## 形成並非單一瞬間(對應五之五)\n\n來源:論文第五之五節【正文:句9829381308】\n\n- 結論五之六:一個結構成為 經濟模式,只能在它於多個 檢查窗口 中出現之後,由研究者事後辨認;不存在可以事前指認的「形成時刻」(從 經濟模式 的定義 推出)【正文:句5885468166】\n- [作者裁決] 本結論只說 經濟模式 要在多個 檢查窗口 出現之後才能辨認,所以沒有事前可以指認的形成時刻;不主張哪些結構會再出現無法預測。\n- 附註:「經濟模式 怎麼形成」的答案是:不斷有結構出現,大部分沒有再出現;再出現的,在事後被稱為 經濟模式。【正文:句1858421433】\n\n## 81952268-47b1-4d8c-9605-270c42646693.可行集合 隨 經濟模式 改變(對應五之六)\n\n來源:論文第五之六節【正文:句2699002923】\n\n- 步驟五之六之一:2ccbf179-58cf-4851-bd72-5fa886e4b2c3.結果回饋 進入參與 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦 的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.歷史(從 步驟五之一之三 + 2ccbf179-58cf-4851-bd72-5fa886e4b2c3.結果回饋 的定義 推出)【正文:句9103983754】\n- 步驟五之六之二:81952268-47b1-4d8c-9605-270c42646693.前件 可能隨 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.歷史 變動,所以各 81952268-47b1-4d8c-9605-270c42646693.路徑 的 81952268-47b1-4d8c-9605-270c42646693.門檻 是否具備、81952268-47b1-4d8c-9605-270c42646693.可行集合 可能跟著變(從 前提三 + 81952268-47b1-4d8c-9605-270c42646693.可行集合 的定義 推出)【正文:句1352655278】\n- 步驟五之六之三:若某 81952268-47b1-4d8c-9605-270c42646693.前件 只能由其他 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.節點 的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 而具備,則在跨 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.節點 的 經濟模式 中,研究者若把這類 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 算進 經濟模式,經濟模式 的再出現可能為某些參與 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.節點 補上原本缺少的 81952268-47b1-4d8c-9605-270c42646693.前件(從 前提一 + 結論五之二 推出)【正文:句9773550088】\n- 結論五之七:經濟模式 某 檢查窗口 的 2ccbf179-58cf-4851-bd72-5fa886e4b2c3.結果回饋 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 參與 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦 後,在之後的 96f10d75-23d0-441f-94c7-ab87ca28d284.推演輪 中,該 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦 的 81952268-47b1-4d8c-9605-270c42646693.可行集合 可能改變:原本有 81952268-47b1-4d8c-9605-270c42646693.前件 未具備的 81952268-47b1-4d8c-9605-270c42646693.路徑,可能因此具備而進入 81952268-47b1-4d8c-9605-270c42646693.可行集合;原本可行的 81952268-47b1-4d8c-9605-270c42646693.路徑,也可能退出(從 前提三 + 81952268-47b1-4d8c-9605-270c42646693.可行集合 的定義 + 步驟五之六之一 + 步驟五之六之二 + 步驟五之六之三 + 96f10d75-23d0-441f-94c7-ab87ca28d284.推演輪 的定義 推出)【正文:句1357301869】\n- 附註:81952268-47b1-4d8c-9605-270c42646693.可行集合 改變,不推出新 81952268-47b1-4d8c-9605-270c42646693.路徑 會被走,也不推出改變有利於 經濟模式 延續。【正文:句7302561830】\n- 結論五之八:蘊含(以 經濟模式 中 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.節點 的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 為 81952268-47b1-4d8c-9605-270c42646693.前件 的 81952268-47b1-4d8c-9605-270c42646693.路徑 反覆實現, 研究者可以依講明的 同一性條件,將其判為原 經濟模式 的一部分,或判為另一 經濟模式);兩種判法都不改變 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 本身(從 步驟三之四之一 + 前提二 + 存續判準 的定義 推出)【正文:句4673587090】\n- 附註:事後所說的「細化」「分化」「從粗變細」,是研究者對這類 81952268-47b1-4d8c-9605-270c42646693.路徑 的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別,與結論五之六同構,不是 經濟模式 自己長出來的。【正文:句4793668110】\n- 結論五之九:蘊含(同一性條件 講在結果類別上, 不同 檢查窗口 以不同 81952268-47b1-4d8c-9605-270c42646693.路徑 實現同一結果類別的結構仍可算同一 經濟模式 且 81952268-47b1-4d8c-9605-270c42646693.路徑 的替換本身不構成 判準中斷);蘊含(同一性條件 講在 81952268-47b1-4d8c-9605-270c42646693.路徑 上且不容許以其他 81952268-47b1-4d8c-9605-270c42646693.路徑 替代, 81952268-47b1-4d8c-9605-270c42646693.路徑 的替換構成 判準中斷)(從 前提二 + 步驟三之四之一 + 判準中斷 的定義 推出)【正文:句2895605756】\n\n## 經濟模式 成為 外界(對應六)\n\n來源:論文第六節、第六之一節至第六之五節【正文:句7953692095、句6834117332、句0739223720、句3472623132、句0251215022、句4457011647】\n\n- 附註:經濟模式 本身不是 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.節點;說它「成為 外界」,意思是 經濟模式 中 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.節點 的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 了 經濟模式 以外的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.節點。【正文:句3538227419、句4009813005】\n- 結論六之一:蘊含(界面節點 的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 經濟模式 以外的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.節點, 這些 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 成為那些 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.節點 外界 的一部分)(從 界面節點 的定義 + 外界 的定義 推出)【正文:句4603965780】\n- 步驟六之二之一:2ccbf179-58cf-4851-bd72-5fa886e4b2c3.自然環境 的各部分也是 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.呈現;經濟模式 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.節點 的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 是一次 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.坍塌 的結果,這次 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.坍塌 若 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.涉及 2ccbf179-58cf-4851-bd72-5fa886e4b2c3.自然環境 的某部分,這筆 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 就 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 那部分(從 2ccbf179-58cf-4851-bd72-5fa886e4b2c3.自然環境 的定義 + b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 的定義 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.涉及 的定義 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 的定義 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.呈現 的定義 推出)【正文:句4946598629】\n- [作者裁決] 稽核所稱本步驟由 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.涉及 推不出 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達,不成立:本步驟依 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 的定義;「被改變」是 結論六之二 自己所設的條件,不由本步驟推出。\n- 步驟六之二之二:2ccbf179-58cf-4851-bd72-5fa886e4b2c3.自然環境 被改變的部分可以 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 其他 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.節點(從 2ccbf179-58cf-4851-bd72-5fa886e4b2c3.自然環境 的定義 推出)【正文:句3990266176】\n- 步驟六之二之三:37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 其他 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦 的,進入那些 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦 的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.歷史,參與它們之後的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.權重(從 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦 的定義 推出)【正文:句2546686184】\n- 步驟六之二之四:步驟六之二之一 至 步驟六之二之三 的鏈條中沒有任何 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.節點 對 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.節點 的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達(從 步驟六之二之一 + 步驟六之二之二 + 步驟六之二之三 + 2ccbf179-58cf-4851-bd72-5fa886e4b2c3.自然環境 的定義 推出)【正文:句6535307790】\n- 結論六之二:導致(經濟模式 中 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.節點 的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 2ccbf179-58cf-4851-bd72-5fa886e4b2c3.自然環境 而被改變的部分其後 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 其他 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦, 這些 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 間接參與那些 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦 的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.權重);即使雙方之間沒有任何 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.節點 與 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.節點 之間的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達(從 步驟六之二之一 + 步驟六之二之二 + 步驟六之二之三 + 步驟六之二之四 推出)【正文:句2749037199】\n- 結論六之三:一個 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦 即使不參與某 經濟模式,只要 經濟模式 中 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.節點 的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 經由任一途徑 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 它,這些 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 就參與它之後的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.權重(從 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.邊 的定義 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦 的定義 + 結論六之一 + 結論六之二 推出)【正文:句1186601116】\n- 步驟六之四之一:經由 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦 的 界面節點,37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 來自一個 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.權重 會隨 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.歷史 改變的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.節點,同樣的請求可能得到不同的回應;兩者若都是 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.我 且在一個講明的維度上彼此的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 互相 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達,可以累積 ae79e938-76e1-4bf9-b2ab-995c03e16c9e.專屬歷史,有可能形成 ae79e938-76e1-4bf9-b2ab-995c03e16c9e.默契(從 界面節點 的定義 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦 的定義 + b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 的定義 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.坍塌 的定義 + ae79e938-76e1-4bf9-b2ab-995c03e16c9e.專屬歷史 的定義 + ae79e938-76e1-4bf9-b2ab-995c03e16c9e.默契 的定義 推出)【正文:句0324486634】\n- 步驟六之四之二:經由 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.信號容器 的 界面節點:37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.鎖死 的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.信號容器 中若列有 2ccbf179-58cf-4851-bd72-5fa886e4b2c3.模板,該 2ccbf179-58cf-4851-bd72-5fa886e4b2c3.模板 的性質依 2ccbf179-58cf-4851-bd72-5fa886e4b2c3.模板 的定義;容器不是 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.我,所以不能和它形成 ae79e938-76e1-4bf9-b2ab-995c03e16c9e.專屬歷史 或 ae79e938-76e1-4bf9-b2ab-995c03e16c9e.默契(從 界面節點 的定義 + b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.信號容器 的定義 + 2ccbf179-58cf-4851-bd72-5fa886e4b2c3.模板 的定義 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.我 的定義 + ae79e938-76e1-4bf9-b2ab-995c03e16c9e.專屬歷史 的定義 + ae79e938-76e1-4bf9-b2ab-995c03e16c9e.默契 的定義 推出)【正文:句3516394190】\n- [作者裁決] 正文本句對 2ccbf179-58cf-4851-bd72-5fa886e4b2c3.模板 的描述,與 2ccbf179-58cf-4851-bd72-5fa886e4b2c3.模板 的定義相同;依跨-26,形式化不重述上游定義,改以引用 2ccbf179-58cf-4851-bd72-5fa886e4b2c3.模板 的定義表達,稽核所稱漏列這段論證(跨-11、跨-13)不成立。\n- 步驟六之四之三:經由 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.隨機源 的 界面節點:b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.隨機源 不被 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.鎖死 時,它自己的結果只能談 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.權重;b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.隨機源 不是 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.我,所以不能和它形成 ae79e938-76e1-4bf9-b2ab-995c03e16c9e.專屬歷史 或 ae79e938-76e1-4bf9-b2ab-995c03e16c9e.默契(從 界面節點 的定義 + b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.隨機源 的定義 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.我 的定義 + ae79e938-76e1-4bf9-b2ab-995c03e16c9e.專屬歷史 的定義 + ae79e938-76e1-4bf9-b2ab-995c03e16c9e.默契 的定義 推出)【正文:句5618550792】\n- 結論六之四:外界 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.節點 經由不同類型的 界面節點,接觸到的是性質不同的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 來源(從 步驟六之四之一 + 步驟六之四之二 + 步驟六之四之三 推出)【正文:句0255874131】\n- 步驟六之五之一:37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦 的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.權重 依賴 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 它的全部 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.歷史(從 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦 的定義 推出)【正文:句6894973150】\n- 步驟六之五之二:依 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.自己的那一段 的定義,它不受 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別 限定;維度是研究者的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別(從 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.自己的那一段 的定義 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別 的定義 推出)【正文:句9773687529】\n- 步驟六之五之三:一筆 2ccbf179-58cf-4851-bd72-5fa886e4b2c3.結果回饋 參與的是整個 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.權重 分布,不受研究者劃的維度限制(從 步驟六之五之一 + 步驟六之五之二 + 2ccbf179-58cf-4851-bd72-5fa886e4b2c3.結果回饋 的定義 推出)【正文:句7482876761】\n- 結論六之五:經濟模式 的 2ccbf179-58cf-4851-bd72-5fa886e4b2c3.結果回饋 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 某參與 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦 時,參與的是它整個 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.權重 分布,不限於研究者劃定的那個維度;所以該 2ccbf179-58cf-4851-bd72-5fa886e4b2c3.結果回饋 可能參與它在其他維度上的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出(從 步驟六之五之三 + b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 的定義 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.坍塌 的定義 推出)【正文:句4799961464、句6829467153】\n- 結論六之六:蘊含(經濟模式 中 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.節點 的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 外界 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.節點 後且該 外界 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.節點 是 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦 或 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.隨機源 且它在下一次 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 之前的那一 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.時刻 不被 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.鎖死, 它下一次的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 不能事前唯一推出,能推出的只是各結果的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.權重;除非 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.權重 不為零的結果都朝同一方向,否則影響的方向也推不出)(從 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.黑箱律 + b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.隨機源 的定義 推出)【正文:句7674689121】\n- [作者裁決] 本條來源已列 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.黑箱律(以概念本身作為來源),稽核所稱來源未列 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.黑箱律 不成立。\n\n## 經濟模式 互為 外界(對應七)\n\n來源:論文第七節、第七之一節至第七之五節【正文:句6157639856、句6475785614、句8507812369、句7099699595、句7565872084、句2612693515】\n\n- 步驟七之一之一:蘊含(經濟模式 甲中某參與 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦 的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 乙中某參與 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦 且這個乙中的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦,或經由乙中以 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 相連的其他 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦,其後的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 又 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 甲的這個 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦 且這些 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦 都不同時屬於甲、乙, 甲、乙互為對方 外界 的一部分,這個 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦 的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 經由乙再回到自己的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.歷史 並參與自己之後的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.權重)(從 結論六之一 + 結論六之二 + 結論六之三 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦 的定義 + 2ccbf179-58cf-4851-bd72-5fa886e4b2c3.結果回饋 的定義 推出)【正文:句7080829972】\n- 結論七之一:在 步驟七之一之一 的條件下,甲與乙合起來構成一個跨 經濟模式 的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.迴路(從 步驟七之一之一 + b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.迴路 的定義 推出)【正文:句1313429829】\n- 步驟七之二之一:若甲、乙之間有 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達,研究者可在講明的維度、時窗與相容判準下,依上游的定義辨認 2ccbf179-58cf-4851-bd72-5fa886e4b2c3.共振、b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.太極、ae79e938-76e1-4bf9-b2ab-995c03e16c9e.失配 三種關係(從 2ccbf179-58cf-4851-bd72-5fa886e4b2c3.共振 的定義 + b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.太極 的定義 + ae79e938-76e1-4bf9-b2ab-995c03e16c9e.失配 的定義 推出)【正文:句1591342462、句3262622996、句9459439660、句2554258462】\n- 步驟七之二之二:有 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦 參與的 經濟模式 中,每個 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦 都有 2ccbf179-58cf-4851-bd72-5fa886e4b2c3.小迴路,所以判定 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.太極 時仍須判定其中是否有 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.正回饋 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.迴路、方向是否相反、是否 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.趨異(從 結論五之一 + b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.太極 的定義 推出)【正文:句5293590834】\n- 結論七之二:蘊含(2ccbf179-58cf-4851-bd72-5fa886e4b2c3.共振 與 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.太極 的判準不同, 方向相反的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.太極 在序列上仍可能相容接續,兩者可以並存而不互斥)(從 2ccbf179-58cf-4851-bd72-5fa886e4b2c3.共振 的定義 + b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.太極 的定義 推出)【正文:句2421306223、句3767509676】\n- 附註:2ccbf179-58cf-4851-bd72-5fa886e4b2c3.共振、b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.太極、ae79e938-76e1-4bf9-b2ab-995c03e16c9e.失配 三者之外的關係,本篇不排除。【正文:句2421306223】\n- 結論七之三:蘊含(甲某 81952268-47b1-4d8c-9605-270c42646693.路徑 的某項 81952268-47b1-4d8c-9605-270c42646693.前件 只能由乙中 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.節點 的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 而具備, 該 81952268-47b1-4d8c-9605-270c42646693.路徑 只在乙的相應 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 之後才可行)(從 81952268-47b1-4d8c-9605-270c42646693.門檻 的定義 + 前提三 推出)【正文:句4595912100】\n- 步驟七之三之一:若甲的 同一性條件 要求上述 81952268-47b1-4d8c-9605-270c42646693.路徑(不容許以其他 81952268-47b1-4d8c-9605-270c42646693.路徑 替代),甲要出現,這條 81952268-47b1-4d8c-9605-270c42646693.路徑 必須實現,所以乙的相應 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 必須先 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達(從 結論七之三 + 同一性條件 的定義 + 81952268-47b1-4d8c-9605-270c42646693.門檻 的定義 推出)【正文:句8717672152】\n- 結論七之四:符合 步驟七之三之一 與 結論七之三 條件的 經濟模式,只能在另一些 經濟模式 中 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.節點 的相應 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 之後出現;依 81952268-47b1-4d8c-9605-270c42646693.前件 的供應關係,可以排出 經濟模式 與供應它的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 之間的部分先後;但乙的相應 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達,不推出甲會出現(從 結論七之三 + 步驟七之三之一 + 81952268-47b1-4d8c-9605-270c42646693.門檻 的定義 + 結論四之五 推出)【正文:句7653887145、句4853779638】\n- 步驟七之三之二:沒有供應關係時,依供應關係排不出先後(從 結論七之四 推出)【正文:句8053598053】\n- 結論七之五:蘊含(乙中 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.節點 的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 經由 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 被判定為甲某 81952268-47b1-4d8c-9605-270c42646693.路徑 的 81952268-47b1-4d8c-9605-270c42646693.前件 且該項 81952268-47b1-4d8c-9605-270c42646693.前件 要靠這筆 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 持續 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 才具備 且該 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 不再 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達, 該項 81952268-47b1-4d8c-9605-270c42646693.前件 不再由乙供應,若沒有替代來源則甲的相應 81952268-47b1-4d8c-9605-270c42646693.路徑 不可行)(從 81952268-47b1-4d8c-9605-270c42646693.門檻 的定義 推出)【正文:句1232563482】\n- 結論七之六:甲的某 81952268-47b1-4d8c-9605-270c42646693.路徑 不可行,不推出甲 判準中斷;甲在某 檢查窗口 是否 判準中斷,取決於該 檢查窗口 內符合甲的 同一性條件 的結構是否實際再次出現;某條 81952268-47b1-4d8c-9605-270c42646693.路徑 不可行,本身不決定這件事(從 經濟模式 的定義 + 判準中斷 的定義 + 同一性條件 的定義 + 檢查窗口 的定義 推出)【正文:句5321914089、句0388841961】\n- 結論七之七:連鎖可以多段傳遞,也可以經由 2ccbf179-58cf-4851-bd72-5fa886e4b2c3.自然環境 傳遞(從 結論七之五 + 結論六之二 + 81952268-47b1-4d8c-9605-270c42646693.門檻 的定義 + 81952268-47b1-4d8c-9605-270c42646693.可行集合 的定義 + 81952268-47b1-4d8c-9605-270c42646693.前件 的定義 + 外界 的定義 推出)【正文:句9053968561】\n- 附註:結論七之三是供應 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 之後 81952268-47b1-4d8c-9605-270c42646693.路徑 才可能可行,結論七之五是供應中斷且沒有替代來源時 81952268-47b1-4d8c-9605-270c42646693.路徑 不可行,兩者是同一關係的兩面;連鎖說明的是 81952268-47b1-4d8c-9605-270c42646693.前件 的牽連,不是 判準中斷 的必然。【正文:句3346662327、句1611267013】\n- 步驟七之八之一:經濟模式 中 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.節點 的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 可以經由 界面節點 與 2ccbf179-58cf-4851-bd72-5fa886e4b2c3.自然環境,成為其他 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.節點 的 外界;互相 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達、不共有參與 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.節點 的 經濟模式 之間互為 外界;某 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦 的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 經由另一 經濟模式 中的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦 回到它自己時,構成跨 經濟模式 的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.迴路;彼此之間可依判準辨認 2ccbf179-58cf-4851-bd72-5fa886e4b2c3.共振、b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.太極、ae79e938-76e1-4bf9-b2ab-995c03e16c9e.失配;81952268-47b1-4d8c-9605-270c42646693.前件 的供應使 經濟模式 與供應它的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 之間有部分先後,供應的中斷經由 81952268-47b1-4d8c-9605-270c42646693.前件 判定連鎖傳遞(從 結論六之一 + 結論六之二 + 步驟七之一之一 + 結論七之一 + 步驟七之二之一 + 結論七之四 + 結論七之七 + 結論七之五 + 外界 的定義 推出)【正文:句3272278263】\n- 步驟七之八之二:未追蹤的輸出,是 輸出圖集 中沒有被研究者追蹤為 經濟模式 的結構,包括研究者已開始留意、但還沒有反覆出現而還不是 經濟模式 的結構;它們不構成 經濟模式,但仍在 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.歷史 中,仍參與它們所 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦 的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.權重(從 經濟模式 的定義 + 步驟三之二之六 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦 的定義 推出)【正文:句2829056215、句7791948772】\n- 結論七之八:記在 人群圖 上的 輸出圖集 中的結構,可以描述為兩部分:一群經濟模式,以及未追蹤的輸出(從 步驟七之八之一 + 步驟七之八之二 推出)【正文:句6735824288、句3272278263、句2829056215】\n- [作者裁決] 研究者已開始留意、但還沒有反覆出現的結構,還不是 經濟模式,屬於「沒有被研究者追蹤為 經濟模式 的結構」,正文已寫明;稽核所稱這類結構沒有歸屬不成立。\n- 步驟七之八之三:蘊含(某 經濟模式 第一次出現, 它在第一次出現時還不是 經濟模式);經濟模式 都來自還不是 經濟模式 的結構,研究者是否從第一次出現就追蹤它,不改變這一點(從 結論五之六 推出)【正文:句0428113177、句6216638895】\n\n## 生殖模式(對應八)\n\n來源:論文第八節【正文:句0704132323】\n\n- 步驟八之一之一:每個 生殖模式 都是 經濟模式;生殖模式 的產出為 81952268-47b1-4d8c-9605-270c42646693.子代(從 生殖模式 的定義 推出)【正文:句9558582966】\n- 附註:生殖模式 不是新定義,只是依產出所作的稱呼,是研究者的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別。【正文:句3946443988】\n- 附註:生殖事件本身不必構成 生殖模式;只有研究者依 存續判準 把它所在的結構追蹤為反覆出現的 經濟模式 時,它所在的結構才是 生殖模式。【正文:句5304213488】\n- 步驟八之一之二:經濟模式 是研究者對 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.節點 的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 所作的歸類,所以每個 經濟模式 的出現,都需要有參與 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.節點(從 經濟模式 的定義 推出)【正文:句8527931179】\n- 步驟八之一之三:生殖事件產生新 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.進場 的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.節點(從 81952268-47b1-4d8c-9605-270c42646693.子代 的定義 推出)【正文:句6704824726】\n- 結論八之一:蘊含(各生物人 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.節點 都會 96f10d75-23d0-441f-94c7-ab87ca28d284.判準退場, 所有以生物人為 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.節點 的 經濟模式 所需的生物人 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.節點 最終都來自生殖事件);這些生殖事件所在的結構被研究者追蹤為反覆出現的 經濟模式 時,就是 生殖模式(從 前提四 + 經濟模式 的定義 + 步驟八之一之一 + 結論七之三 + 81952268-47b1-4d8c-9605-270c42646693.子代 的定義 + 步驟八之一之二 + 步驟八之一之三 + 生殖模式 的定義 推出)【正文:句9896278793】\n- 結論八之二:蘊含(人群圖 的 存續判準 有某個 檢查窗口,該 檢查窗口 開始時 人群圖 中原有的生物人 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.節點 都已 96f10d75-23d0-441f-94c7-ab87ca28d284.判準退場 且 人群圖 的 存續判準 要求 人群圖 中有未 96f10d75-23d0-441f-94c7-ab87ca28d284.判準退場 的生物人 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.節點, 該 檢查窗口 內必須有生物人 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.節點 新加入 人群圖(b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.切法 內生殖事件產生的 81952268-47b1-4d8c-9605-270c42646693.子代,或外來移入),或有原有的生物人 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.節點 在該 檢查窗口 內不再被記為 96f10d75-23d0-441f-94c7-ab87ca28d284.判準退場,否則 人群圖 在該 檢查窗口 判準中斷);新加入的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.節點 都來自生殖事件,這些事件可以在 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.切法 之內或之外;它們所在的結構若被追蹤為 生殖模式,這個 生殖模式 也可以在這些 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.節點 加入 人群圖 之前就已 判準中斷(從 前提四 + 步驟三之二之一 + 檢查窗口 的定義 + 96f10d75-23d0-441f-94c7-ab87ca28d284.判準退場 的定義 + 判準中斷 的定義 + b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.切法 的定義 + 生殖模式 的定義 推出)【正文:句2345534232、句5640384504】\n- 步驟八之二之二:生殖模式 判準中斷,其他 經濟模式 不必立即 判準中斷;但現有 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.節點 全部 96f10d75-23d0-441f-94c7-ab87ca28d284.判準退場 而沒有替代來源時,連鎖可以傳到依賴這些 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.節點 的 經濟模式(從 判準中斷 的定義 + 檢查窗口 的定義 + 結論七之六 + 結論七之七 + 結論七之五 + 96f10d75-23d0-441f-94c7-ab87ca28d284.判準退場 的定義 + 步驟八之一之二 推出)【正文:句2464550241】\n- 步驟八之二之三:生殖模式 的 81952268-47b1-4d8c-9605-270c42646693.路徑 有 81952268-47b1-4d8c-9605-270c42646693.前件 只能由對方的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 供應;研究者把對方的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 算進 經濟模式 時,經濟模式 跨 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.節點(從 前提五 + 結論五之二 + 經濟模式 的定義 推出)【正文:句7055272705】\n- 步驟八之二之四:人群圖 是否「同一個」,由研究者講明的 同一性條件 決定,不論新 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.節點 來自 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.切法 內的生殖事件還是外來移入(從 人群圖 的定義 + 同一性條件 的定義 + 步驟三之四之一 + 步驟三之四之二 推出)【正文:句4549383315】\n- 步驟八之二之五:蘊含(生殖模式 中的親代是生物人 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.節點, 它們本身也來自生殖事件);蘊含(親代與 81952268-47b1-4d8c-9605-270c42646693.子代 都是 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦 且 親代的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 81952268-47b1-4d8c-9605-270c42646693.子代 且 81952268-47b1-4d8c-9605-270c42646693.子代 其後的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 又 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 親代、進入親代的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.歷史 且研究者把這段 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 算進該 生殖模式, 親代的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 經由 81952268-47b1-4d8c-9605-270c42646693.子代 又參與親代自己的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.權重,生殖模式 含有跨代的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.迴路);人群圖 的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.節點 都來自生殖事件,這些事件可以在 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.切法 之內或之外;上述跨代 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.迴路 與 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.節點 的供應,不推出各 經濟模式 的其他 81952268-47b1-4d8c-9605-270c42646693.前件 也由它們供應;這些 81952268-47b1-4d8c-9605-270c42646693.前件 仍可能來自 外界 與 2ccbf179-58cf-4851-bd72-5fa886e4b2c3.自然環境(從 前提四 + 步驟三之二之一 + 結論八之二 + 結論四之六 + 結論六之二 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦 的定義 + b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.迴路 的定義 + 81952268-47b1-4d8c-9605-270c42646693.前件 的定義 + 外界 的定義 推出)【正文:句2773655700、句8640492083】\n\n## 參與者層的推論(對應九)\n\n來源:論文第九節【正文:句2757477640】\n\n- 結論九之一:在某一維度上符合 ae79e938-76e1-4bf9-b2ab-995c03e16c9e.默契 判準,不推出在其他維度上也符合(從 ae79e938-76e1-4bf9-b2ab-995c03e16c9e.默契 的定義 推出)【正文:句5268813478】\n- 結論九之二:兩個 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.我 反覆參與同一 經濟模式、在該維度上彼此的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 互相 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 時,會累積該維度上的 ae79e938-76e1-4bf9-b2ab-995c03e16c9e.專屬歷史;但 ae79e938-76e1-4bf9-b2ab-995c03e16c9e.專屬歷史 的累積不推出 ae79e938-76e1-4bf9-b2ab-995c03e16c9e.默契(從 ae79e938-76e1-4bf9-b2ab-995c03e16c9e.專屬歷史 的定義 + ae79e938-76e1-4bf9-b2ab-995c03e16c9e.默契 的定義 推出)【正文:句0082685831】\n- 結論九之三:作為 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.我 的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.節點 加入某 經濟模式 時,不承繼其他參與者之間的 ae79e938-76e1-4bf9-b2ab-995c03e16c9e.專屬歷史;這樣的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.節點 退出時,它與其他參與者已有的 ae79e938-76e1-4bf9-b2ab-995c03e16c9e.專屬歷史 仍在 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.歷史 中(從 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.歷史 的定義 + ae79e938-76e1-4bf9-b2ab-995c03e16c9e.專屬歷史 的定義 推出)【正文:句0013730785】\n- 結論九之四:新加入者與其他參與者之間沒有 ae79e938-76e1-4bf9-b2ab-995c03e16c9e.專屬歷史,不推出它的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 不相容(從 2ccbf179-58cf-4851-bd72-5fa886e4b2c3.共振 的定義 推出)【正文:句2733647520】\n- 結論九之五:b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.節點 的加入或退出,不推出 經濟模式 判準中斷,也不推出它延續(從 步驟三之四之二 + 判準中斷 的定義 + 存續判準 的定義 推出)【正文:句1102645791】\n\n## 推不出的(對應十)\n\n來源:論文第十節、第十之一節【正文:句2224435505、句3601473371】\n\n- 步驟十之一之一:在 結論五之四 的條件下,判準取決於不被 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.鎖死 的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦 或 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.隨機源 的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 時,哪些結構會成為 經濟模式,推不出(從 結論五之四 + 結論五之六 推出)【正文:句7809219296】\n- 步驟十之一之二:在 結論五之四 的條件下,判準取決於不被 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.鎖死 的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦 或 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.隨機源 的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 時,經濟模式 何時 判準中斷、壽命多長,推不出(從 結論五之四 推出)【正文:句6679781566】\n- 步驟十之一之三:經濟模式 對 外界 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.節點 的具體影響,在該 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.節點 下一次 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 之前的那一 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.時刻 不被 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.鎖死 時,推不出;37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.權重 不為零的結果方向不一時,連方向也推不出(從 結論六之六 推出)【正文:句0850247452】\n- 步驟十之一之四:在 結論五之四 的條件下,判準取決於不被 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.鎖死 的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦 的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 時,某 生殖模式 下一 檢查窗口 是否延續,推不出(從 結論五之四 + 生殖模式 的定義 推出)【正文:句0195167564】\n- 附註:給定條件後,哪些 81952268-47b1-4d8c-9605-270c42646693.路徑 可行屬條件級,可以逐案判定;實際落出哪一種,就有限觀察者而言推不出,只能 81952268-47b1-4d8c-9605-270c42646693.記錄 並逐 檢查窗口 判定存續。【正文:句1183682185】\n- 結論十之一:觀察到的 經濟模式,都是通過歷次 存續判準 者;它們事後看來與其 外界 相合時,這不推出有任何設計或目的(從 前提八 + 結論五之三 + 81952268-47b1-4d8c-9605-270c42646693.現存樣本條件化 的定義 推出)【正文:句5436863595】\n\n## 總命題(對應十三)\n\n來源:論文第十三節【正文:句4872069504】\n\n- 結論十三之一:在講明的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.切法 下,生物人的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 可以 81952268-47b1-4d8c-9605-270c42646693.記錄 為 輸出圖集,記在 人群圖 上;其中被研究者依 存續判準 追蹤、反覆出現的結構是 經濟模式(從 輸出圖 的定義 + 輸出圖集 的定義 + 結論七之八 + 經濟模式 的定義 推出)【正文:句6078868492、句6002172520】\n- 結論十三之二:凡有 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦 參與者,其中每個 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦 都有 2ccbf179-58cf-4851-bd72-5fa886e4b2c3.小迴路,若某 81952268-47b1-4d8c-9605-270c42646693.路徑 屬於前提一所指的 81952268-47b1-4d8c-9605-270c42646693.路徑,且它在某 檢查窗口 內實現,則必有其他 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.節點 的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 供應 81952268-47b1-4d8c-9605-270c42646693.前件,是否算進 經濟模式,由研究者的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別 決定(從 結論五之一 + 結論五之二 + 經濟模式 的定義 推出)【正文:句6002172520】\n- 結論十三之三:經濟模式 中 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.節點 的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 可以經由 界面節點 與 2ccbf179-58cf-4851-bd72-5fa886e4b2c3.自然環境,成為其他 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.節點 的 外界,影響不以參與為條件(從 結論六之一 + 結論六之二 + 結論六之三 + 外界 的定義 推出)【正文:句4826368682】\n- 結論十三之四:互相 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達、不共有參與 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.節點 的 經濟模式 之間互為 外界;某 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦 的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 經由另一 經濟模式 中的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦 回到它自己時,構成跨 經濟模式 的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.迴路;彼此之間可依判準辨認 2ccbf179-58cf-4851-bd72-5fa886e4b2c3.共振、b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.太極 與 ae79e938-76e1-4bf9-b2ab-995c03e16c9e.失配,並經由 81952268-47b1-4d8c-9605-270c42646693.前件 判定使供應的中斷連鎖傳遞(從 結論六之一 + 步驟七之一之一 + 結論七之一 + 步驟七之二之一 + 結論七之七 + 結論七之五 推出)【正文:句1631509973】\n- 結論十三之五:81952268-47b1-4d8c-9605-270c42646693.前件 的供應使 經濟模式 與供應它的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 之間有部分先後;若各生物人 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.節點 都會 96f10d75-23d0-441f-94c7-ab87ca28d284.判準退場,則以生物人為 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.節點 的 經濟模式 其生物人 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.節點 最終都來自生殖事件;這些事件被追蹤為 生殖模式 時,生殖模式 供應的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 若中斷,可沿 81952268-47b1-4d8c-9605-270c42646693.前件 的供應關係傳遞到依賴這些 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.節點 的 經濟模式(從 結論七之四 + 結論八之一 + 結論八之二 + 結論七之七 + 步驟八之二之二 + 結論七之五 推出)【正文:句6674257979】\n- 結論十三之六:經濟模式 的形成,只能事後辨認;其延續與具體影響,在判準或 外界 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.節點 取決於不被 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.鎖死 的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦 或 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.隨機源 時(結論五之四、結論六之六 的條件),同樣不可事前唯一推出,只能逐 檢查窗口 判定;觀察到的 經濟模式,都是到目前為止尚未 判準中斷 者(從 前提八 + 結論五之四 + 結論五之五 + 結論五之六 + 結論六之六 推出)【正文:句0699249460】\n- 附註:所有權、制度、價格、貨幣、組織與市場等,需引入 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別 才能推導,本篇尚未引入其前提,留待後續以本篇為底層推出。【正文:句4800873606】\n\n## 待決項\n\n無\n","paper_files":[{"filename":"生物人輸出格局動力學.md","content":"---\nuuid: d244789a-9261-4a0d-a98a-feb8db56b511\nlast-modified: 2026-11-02T00:02:12\nauthor: 黃正宇 / Cheng Yu Huang\ncontact: mthree.tw@gmail.com\n---\n\n# 生物人輸出格局動力學\n\n---\n\n## 〇、定位與方法\n\n### 〇之一 定位\n\n《生物人個體輸出傾向動力學》(以下稱個體篇)處理一個生物人的[輸出傾向](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c02)。本篇是它在多個生物人層的對應篇,處理多個生物人的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)之間的[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)結構,也就是**輸出格局**:其中反覆出現的結構如何被辨認、如何延續與[中斷](concepts.md#c10),以及這些結構如何互為[外界](concepts.md#c04)。\n\n### 〇之二 方法\n\n本篇採演繹法。每條結論都標明從哪些定義、前提或先前結論推出。文中案例只作校準,不承擔論證。\n\n### 〇之三 記錄範圍\n\n沿用《生產動力學》的[記錄](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c06)範圍:只登記[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)的物理改變,不登記[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)內容。[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)仍在[歷史](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13)中,但不在本篇的[記錄](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c06)裡。\n\n### 〇之四 觀察前提\n\n本篇以[現存樣本條件化](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c14)為觀察前提:觀察到的[經濟模式](concepts.md#c09),都是通過歷次[存續判準](concepts.md#c01)者。研究須同時納入已[判準中斷](concepts.md#c10)、但仍留有[記錄](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c06)的[模式](concepts.md#c09)。後文凡涉及「倖存」「看似被設計」之處,皆回指本條。\n\n### 〇之五 主張的範圍\n\n本篇只推出兩類東西:結構上必然成立的關係,以及哪些東西推不出另一些東西。本篇不預測哪些結構會成為[經濟模式](concepts.md#c09)、[經濟模式](concepts.md#c09)能持續多久,或它們的影響往哪個方向。\n\n本篇所有結論,都是就[宇宙](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c02)之內的有限觀察者而言:研究者與各[節點](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25)都在[宇宙](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c02)之內,沒有任何視角站在[宇宙](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c02)之外。凡說「推不出」,指研究者與各[節點](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25)在事前都推不出。\n\n### 〇之六 體例\n\n每條結論之後依序附:\n\n- **來源**:括號內標明從哪些定義、前提或結論推出,只補本篇新增的那一步。\n- **說明**:本篇新推出的部分,拆成推導步驟。\n- **校準**:對應的現實現象,只作對照,不承擔論證。\n\n本篇凡說「[經濟模式](concepts.md#c09)成為[外界](concepts.md#c04)」「[經濟模式](concepts.md#c09)參與[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06)」「[經濟模式](concepts.md#c09)進入[歷史](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13)」,都是研究者層的簡稱:實際[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)、進入[歷史](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13)、參與[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06)的,是[模式](concepts.md#c09)中[節點](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25)的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)。[經濟模式](concepts.md#c09)本身是研究者對這些[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)的歸類,不是[節點](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25)。\n\n---\n\n## 一、承接\n\n以下概念依原篇定義使用,本篇不重述。\n\n- **《渦動力學》**:[宇宙](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c02)、[呈現](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c04)、[坍塌](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c08)、[涉及](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c11)、[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)、[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19)、[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)、[刺激](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c30)、[寫入](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c29)、[歷史](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13)、[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06)、[時刻](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c09)、[鎖死](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c12)、[自己的那一段](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c17)、[黑箱律](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c25)、[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)、[個體](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c20)。\n- **《四條律相關工具及範例》**(工具篇):[切法](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c23)、[節點](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25)、[邊](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c29)、[信號容器](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c26)、[隨機源](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c27)、[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)、[迴路](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c31)、[正回饋](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c32)、[耦合](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c36)、[趨異](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c38)、[太極](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c39)、[退場](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c43)、[進場](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c44)。\n- **《三重幻覺與被迫的賭注》**:[二階分別](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c01)、[看法歸屬](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c02)。\n- **《互動動力學—共同外生背景下的二階網路》**(熟人篇):[專屬歷史](../paper_ae79e938_76e1_4bf9_b2ab_995c03e16c9e/concepts.md#c05)、[默契](../paper_ae79e938_76e1_4bf9_b2ab_995c03e16c9e/concepts.md#c06)、[失配](../paper_ae79e938_76e1_4bf9_b2ab_995c03e16c9e/concepts.md#c08)。\n- **《互動動力學—陌生人迴路中的專屬歷史變動與更新》**(陌生人篇):[自然環境](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c16)、[小迴路](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c02)、[大迴路](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c03)、[可達子圖](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c07)、[共振](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c09)、[結果回饋](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c05)、[學習](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c04)、[模板](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c14)、[崩潰](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c15)、[落空比例](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c17)。\n- **《生產動力學》**:[推演輪](../paper_96f10d75_23d0_441f_94c7_ab87ca28d284/concepts.md#c07)、[判準退場](../paper_96f10d75_23d0_441f_94c7_ab87ca28d284/concepts.md#c09)、[生產](../paper_96f10d75_23d0_441f_94c7_ab87ca28d284/concepts.md#c01)。\n- **個體篇**:[記錄](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c06)、[輸出傾向](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c02)、[路徑](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c07)、[前件](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c08)、[門檻](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c03)、[可行集合](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c11)、[子代](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c15)、[現存樣本條件化](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c14)。\n\n---\n\n## 二、前提\n\n**前提一**:若某[路徑](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c07)的[門檻](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c03)中至少有一項[前件](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c08),只能由其他[節點](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25)的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)而具備,則該[路徑](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c07)的可行性取決於其他[節點](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25)的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)。\n\n說明:前提一是條件式,屬範圍設定,不是存在主張。若某研究對象找不到滿足[前件](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c08)的[路徑](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c07),本篇只是不適用於它,前提一不因此被推翻。\n\n校準:就生物人而言,生殖與養育不存在單人[路徑](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c07),所以前提一的[前件](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c08)至少在這兩類[路徑](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c07)上成立。生殖需要對方;嬰兒在判準取生理界線時,沒有他人的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)便無法存續(判準由研究者訂定)。淘金潮中同樣沒有單人[路徑](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c07),見十一之一。\n\n**前提二**:[經濟模式](concepts.md#c09)的[存續判準](concepts.md#c01),由研究者講明,包括:\n1. **[同一性條件](concepts.md#c02)**:在什麼等價條件下,不同[檢查窗口](concepts.md#c03)中的結構算作同一個;\n2. **[檢查窗口](concepts.md#c03)**:在哪些窗口中檢查該結構是否再次出現。\n\n說明:現實沒有統一的輪次,只有[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)與[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)的先後。[推演輪](../paper_96f10d75_23d0_441f_94c7_ab87ca28d284/concepts.md#c07)是研究者對某一[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)序列的切段,不是現實中的輪次。不同[經濟模式](concepts.md#c09)各依自己的[檢查窗口](concepts.md#c03)判定,不假定共同的輪次;跨[模式](concepts.md#c09)的關係,依[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)的先後[記錄](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c06)。\n\n校準:[窗口](concepts.md#c03)選錯會判錯,例如冬天檢查農耕[模式](concepts.md#c09)。\n\n**前提三**:一條[路徑](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c07)的[前件](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c08),可以因某筆[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)而具備;這筆[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)可以來自同一[節點](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25)的另一條[路徑](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c07),也可以來自其他[節點](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25)。\n\n說明:前提三是可能性主張,屬範圍設定:它只說這種供應關係可以成立,不說某條[路徑](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c07)一定如此。前提一討論的,是這種供應中「[前件](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c08)只能由其他[節點](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25)的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)供應」的情形。\n\n校準:圍獵留下的骨頭,是後來做骨矛這條[路徑](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c07)的材料[前件](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c08);骨頭可以是自己上一輪留下的,也可以是同伴留下的。\n\n**前提四**:每個生物人[節點](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25)的[進場](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c44),都來自某次生殖事件:該[節點](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25)是這次生殖事件產生的[子代](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c15)。\n\n說明:前提四是範圍設定,只針對生物人[節點](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25),不涉及其他類型的[節點](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25)。\n\n校準:外來移入的人,也是別處的生殖事件產生的。\n\n**前提五**:[生殖模式](concepts.md#c12)的[路徑](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c07),有[前件](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c08)只能由對方的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)供應。\n\n說明:前提五是範圍設定,是生物學事實,只針對[生殖模式](concepts.md#c12),不涉及其他[模式](concepts.md#c09)。\n\n校準:生殖至少需要兩個人,單人無法完成。\n\n**前提六**:參與[經濟模式](concepts.md#c09)的[信號容器](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c26)或[隨機源](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c27),算在它所服務的[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)的[可達子圖](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c07)範圍內。\n\n說明:前提六是範圍設定。[可達子圖](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c07)的定義只收送給中心的[呈現](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c04);本篇為了涵蓋只被[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)使用的容器,把參與的[信號容器](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c26)與[隨機源](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c27)一併算進去。\n\n校準:自動提款機本身不是[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16),但它服務銀行與客戶,所以算在他們的[可達子圖](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c07)範圍內。\n\n**前提七**:一筆[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)是否[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)某個[節點](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25),不只取決於這筆[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28),也取決於該[節點](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25)的[外界](concepts.md#c04)中其他部分,例如路途、天候與運輸。\n\n說明:前提七是經驗前提。[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)的定義只說[寫入](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c29)要作為[刺激](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c30)落到某一[呈現](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c04)上,才算[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)它,沒有說落不落得到由什麼決定;本篇把這一點列為前提。\n\n---\n\n## 三、定義\n\n### 三之一 外界\n\n**[外界](concepts.md#c04)**:對某個[節點](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25)而言,自己以外的一切[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)來源,包含其他[節點](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25)與[自然環境](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c16)。\n\n- [外界](concepts.md#c04)相對於[節點](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25)而言,換一個[節點](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25),[外界](concepts.md#c04)就不同。[節點](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25)的大小由[切法](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c23)決定,可以是一個人,也可以是一間公司:把公司當作[節點](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25)時,員工在它之內,客戶是它的[外界](concepts.md#c04)。\n- 在一張[輸出圖](concepts.md#c06)中,[切法](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c23)以外的一切都是這張圖的[外界](concepts.md#c04)。[自然環境](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c16)不在圖上另畫;需要細看時,由研究者放大[切法](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c23)。\n\n### 三之二 人群圖、輸出圖與輸出圖集\n\n**[人群圖](concepts.md#c05)**:在講明的[切法](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c23)下,生物人[節點](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25),以及它們之間的[邊](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c29)(一個[節點](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25)的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28),參與另一個[節點](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25)的[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06)),加上各[節點](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25)自己的[迴路](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c31)(自己的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28),經由自己,又參與自己的[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06))所成的靜態圖。[人群圖](concepts.md#c05)的[存續判準](concepts.md#c01)由研究者講明,方式同[經濟模式](concepts.md#c09)(前提二)。\n\n**[輸出圖](concepts.md#c06)**:在[人群圖](concepts.md#c05)的基礎上,在講明的[切法](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c23)、維度與時窗內,把[記錄](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c06)附在點與[邊](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c29)上所得的圖:點是[人群圖](concepts.md#c05)的[節點](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25),加上[切法](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c23)內的[信號容器](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c26)與[隨機源](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c27);[邊](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c29)是[人群圖](concepts.md#c05)的[邊](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c29),加上這些[信號容器](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c26)、[隨機源](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c27)與其他[節點](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25)之間的[邊](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c29);各[節點](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25)的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)[記錄](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c06)附在點上,各次[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)的[記錄](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c06)附在[邊](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c29)上,或附在[節點](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25)自己的[迴路](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c31)上,來自[外界](concepts.md#c04)的[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)附在接收的點上;另外附上研究者對某[節點](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25)某[路徑](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c07)的[前件](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c08)是否具備所作的判定,可以標「未知」。依個體篇,這項判定與[記錄](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c06)並列附上,不算[記錄](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c06)。[切法](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c23)內的[信號容器](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c26)與[隨機源](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c27)也是[節點](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25),與它們的[邊](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c29)一併記入。\n\n**[輸出圖集](concepts.md#c07)**:同一研究中,各時窗、各維度、各尺度的[輸出圖](concepts.md#c06)所構成的集合。\n\n說明:\n\n- [邊](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c29)不分[時刻](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c09),同一條[邊](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c29)上可以有許多次[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10);[人群圖](concepts.md#c05)中屬於[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)的生物人[節點](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25),其[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)自己,在[人群圖](concepts.md#c05)上就是這個[節點](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25)自己的[迴路](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c31)。\n- [輸出圖集](concepts.md#c07)是[歷史](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13)的子集:沒有登記的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)、「沒有發生在它身上」這類[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10),都不在圖上,但仍在[歷史](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13)中,仍參與它們所[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)的[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)的[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06)。\n\n### 三之三 格局傾向\n\n**[格局傾向](concepts.md#c08)**:研究者對[輸出圖集](concepts.md#c07)中反覆可見的結構所作的歸納,描述在指定[切法](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c23)下,傾向出現哪一類[輸出圖](concepts.md#c06)結構。它是在指定的[切法](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c23)、時窗、分類規則與比較條件下作的歸納。\n\n- 它和個體篇的[輸出傾向](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c02)平行:[輸出傾向](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c02)歸納一個[個體](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c20)的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28),[格局傾向](concepts.md#c08)歸納[輸出圖集](concepts.md#c07)中反覆可見的[輸出圖](concepts.md#c06)結構。\n- [格局傾向](concepts.md#c08)不屬於任何[節點](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25),也不是任何[節點](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25)[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06)的讀數。\n- 限定到單一[節點](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25)、單一[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)類型,且該[節點](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25)是一個[個體](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c20)時,就回到該[個體](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c20)的[輸出傾向](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c02)。\n\n### 三之四 經濟模式\n\n**[經濟模式](concepts.md#c09)**:依研究者講明的[存續判準](concepts.md#c01)(前提二),在[輸出圖集](concepts.md#c07)的多個[檢查窗口](concepts.md#c03)中反覆出現的某一個結構。\n\n- **同一性看位置,不看是誰**:兩個[窗口](concepts.md#c03)的結構,在講明的等價條件下同構,就算同一[經濟模式](concepts.md#c09)。參與的[節點](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25)更替,不必然改變同一性。\n- **以[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)相連**:[經濟模式](concepts.md#c09)是一個以[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)相連的結構:參與的[節點](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25)之間,或參與的[節點](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25)與[外界](concepts.md#c04)之間,有[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)。把許多彼此不相連的[模式](concepts.md#c09)合稱一個名字(例如餐飲業),是研究者的[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18),不是一個[經濟模式](concepts.md#c09)。\n- **可以只涉及單一[節點](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25)**,例如一個人與[外界](concepts.md#c04)之間的反覆[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10);也可以跨[節點](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25)。\n- **不限於市場**:不分[生產](../paper_96f10d75_23d0_441f_94c7_ab87ca28d284/concepts.md#c01)與消費、營利與否、有無貨幣。名稱只是研究者的[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18),不賦予它獨立的本體,和《生產動力學》對「[生產](../paper_96f10d75_23d0_441f_94c7_ab87ca28d284/concepts.md#c01)」的處理相同。\n- **與[格局傾向](concepts.md#c08)的區分**:[格局傾向](concepts.md#c08)是跨圖的歸納,沒有同一性,也沒有[中斷](concepts.md#c10);[經濟模式](concepts.md#c09)是被追蹤的某一個結構,有同一性,可以[判準中斷](concepts.md#c10)。\n- **與[共振](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c09)的區分**:[共振](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c09)要求多[節點](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25)在有[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)的條件下反覆相容接續;[經濟模式](concepts.md#c09)帶有[前件](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c08)判定與逐[窗口](concepts.md#c03)的[存續判準](concepts.md#c01),而且可以只涉及單一[節點](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25)。\n- **與[生產](../paper_96f10d75_23d0_441f_94c7_ab87ca28d284/concepts.md#c01)的關係**:在[生產](../paper_96f10d75_23d0_441f_94c7_ab87ca28d284/concepts.md#c01)維度上,[經濟模式](concepts.md#c09)中多[節點](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25)反覆相容接續、且彼此之間有[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)或有共同來源對它們都有[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)的部分,就是[共振](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c09)的定義所說的情形。\n\n### 三之五 判準中斷\n\n**[判準中斷](concepts.md#c10)**:依研究者講明的[存續判準](concepts.md#c01),某個被追蹤的結構(例如[經濟模式](concepts.md#c09)、[人群圖](concepts.md#c05))在某[檢查窗口](concepts.md#c03)內未再出現,即記為[判準中斷](concepts.md#c10)。什麼算[中斷](concepts.md#c10),由判準決定。\n\n- 判準是研究者的定義;是否[中斷](concepts.md#c10)是該[窗口](concepts.md#c03)實際的事實。兩者不互相替代,和[判準退場](../paper_96f10d75_23d0_441f_94c7_ab87ca28d284/concepts.md#c09)的結構相同。\n- [判準中斷](concepts.md#c10)與[崩潰](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c15)、[退場](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c43)、[判準退場](../paper_96f10d75_23d0_441f_94c7_ab87ca28d284/concepts.md#c09)的判準不同,彼此不互相蘊含:[模式](concepts.md#c09)可以[中斷](concepts.md#c10)而秩序未[崩潰](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c15),參與者可以[退場](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c43)而[模式](concepts.md#c09)未[中斷](concepts.md#c10)。\n\n### 三之六 界面節點\n\n**[界面節點](concepts.md#c11)**:[經濟模式](concepts.md#c09)中有[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)[外界](concepts.md#c04)的[節點](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25)。\n\n- 類型依上游[節點](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25)分類,可以是[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)、[信號容器](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c26)或[隨機源](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c27)。\n- 同一[經濟模式](concepts.md#c09)可以有多種[界面節點](concepts.md#c11),[外界](concepts.md#c04)經由不同[界面](concepts.md#c11)接觸到的是性質不同的[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)來源。\n\n---\n\n## 四、可達子圖:經濟模式的範圍\n\n本節依[可達子圖](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c07)定義,全部以**已[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)**的[記錄](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c06)來說。事前「可能接觸誰」屬於[前件](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c08)的判定,不屬於[可達子圖](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c07)。\n\n### 四之一 經濟模式的節點範圍\n\n**結論四之一**:在某[檢查窗口](concepts.md#c03)內,若某[經濟模式](concepts.md#c09)中甲的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)乙,則甲屬於乙在該[窗口](concepts.md#c03)的[可達子圖](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c07)。\n\n(從[可達子圖](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c07)的定義推出:曾有[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)某[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)的[呈現](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c04),連同其間的[邊](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c29),構成它的[可達子圖](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c07);只計已[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)者)\n\n**結論四之二**:在某[檢查窗口](concepts.md#c03)內,跨[節點](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25)[經濟模式](concepts.md#c09)中參與的[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16),都是自己的[可達子圖](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c07)的中心;參與的[信號容器](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c26)與[隨機源](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c27),算在它們所服務的[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)的[可達子圖](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c07)範圍內。[經濟模式](concepts.md#c09)的範圍,不超過已發生的[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)所及的範圍。\n\n(從結論四之一、前提六與[可達子圖](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c07)的定義推出)\n\n說明:\n1. 跨[節點](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25)[經濟模式](concepts.md#c09)的每個參與[節點](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25),至少與另一參與[節點](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25)或與[外界](concepts.md#c04)之間有[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10),否則不在同一結構中([經濟模式](concepts.md#c09)的定義)。\n2. 由結論四之一,送出[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)的[節點](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25),落在接收的[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)的[可達子圖](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c07)中;每個參與的[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)是自己的[可達子圖](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c07)的中心(中心算在內)。\n3. [信號容器](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c26)與[隨機源](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c27)不是[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16),沒有自己的[可達子圖](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c07);依前提六,參與的它們算在所服務的[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)的[可達子圖](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c07)範圍內。\n\n校準:商店只能賣給它能接觸的人。在時窗內,與商店[界面節點](concepts.md#c11)之間沒有任何[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)的人,不在這個[經濟模式](concepts.md#c09)中。\n\n### 四之二 可達不是參與\n\n**結論四之三**:某[節點](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25)在[可達子圖](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c07)中,不推出它與中心[節點](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25)在其他維度上有[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)。\n\n(從[可達子圖](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c07)須講明時窗、[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)依維度[記錄](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c06)推出)\n\n**結論四之四**:某[節點](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25)在[可達子圖](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c07)中,即使在相關維度上有[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10),也不推出它的[可行集合](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c11)中有某條[路徑](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c07),其[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)能被判定為某[經濟模式](concepts.md#c09)所需的[前件](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c08)。\n\n(從[前件](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c08)與[可行集合](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c11)的定義推出;[前件](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c08)是否具備,是研究者就[路徑](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c07)所作的判定)\n\n**結論四之五**:即使某[節點](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25)能供應相應[前件](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c08),也不推出它在下一個[檢查窗口](concepts.md#c03)會[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)。\n\n(從[門檻](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c03)的定義推出:[前件](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c08)全部具備,只表示可行,不表示會發生)\n\n綜合起來,在指定的[經濟模式](concepts.md#c09)與維度上:\n\n> [可達子圖](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c07)中的[節點](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25) ⊇ 在該維度上有[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)的[節點](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25) ⊇ [前件](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c08)被判定為能供應的[節點](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25) ⊇ 實際在[模式](concepts.md#c09)中[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)的[節點](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25)\n\n每往內一層,都多一個條件;最後一層只能等事後的[記錄](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c06)。\n\n校準:一個人認識一百個人,只說明第一層大。其中有多少人與他有生意往來、有多少人拿得出他需要的東西、最後有多少人真的出手,是另外三件事。\n\n另(結論四之四):〔Granovetter〕在麻州牛頓市的研究中,經由熟人找到工作的 54 人,事前與該熟人常見面(每週至少一次)的只佔 16.7%,偶爾見面的 55.6%,很少見面(一年一次以下)的 27.8%。見面次數多,不推出就是供應工作消息者。\n\n### 四之三 到達的改變\n\n**結論四之六**:一筆[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)的[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)是否發生,不只取決於這筆[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28),也取決於[外界](concepts.md#c04)。所以在各[個體](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c20)的[輸出傾向](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c02)都沒有可辨改變的情況下,[可達子圖](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c07)仍可能改變。\n\n(從前提七與[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)的定義推出:[寫入](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c29)要作為[刺激](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c30)落到某一[呈現](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c04)上,才算[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)它;落不落得到,也取決於[外界](concepts.md#c04)(前提七))\n\n說明:\n1. 一筆[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)另一方,以這筆[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)發生並能落到對方為條件([到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)的定義)。\n2. [輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)是否落到對方,也取決於對方的[外界](concepts.md#c04)(前提七)。\n3. 所以[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)不變時,[外界](concepts.md#c04)改變仍可能使[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)發生或不發生;[可達子圖](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c07)只計已[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)者,所以曾有[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)中心[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)的[呈現](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c04)一旦因此改變,它就隨之改變。\n\n校準:颱風封港,漁民照常捕魚,漁獲卻到不了城裡的市場;漁民與城裡買家之間的[可達子圖](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c07),在那一週縮小了。\n\n另:2021 年 3 月 23 日長賜號擱淺於蘇伊士運河,至 29 日才脫困,其間超過 430 艘船在兩端等候,每天約有九十億美元的貨物受阻。兩端賣方與買方的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)照舊,[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)卻沒有發生。\n\n**結論四之七**:若某[經濟模式](concepts.md#c09)的[同一性條件](concepts.md#c02)要求某些[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)(缺少其中任一項就不滿足),而這些[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)在某[檢查窗口](concepts.md#c03)內不再發生,該[經濟模式](concepts.md#c09)在該[窗口](concepts.md#c03)[判準中斷](concepts.md#c10)。反過來,新的[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)發生,可能使原本未出現的結構出現。\n\n(從[經濟模式](concepts.md#c09)與[判準中斷](concepts.md#c10)的定義推出)\n\n校準:道路、航運、網際網路擴大[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)的範圍,封鎖、戰爭、疫情縮小它。[經濟模式](concepts.md#c09)的出現與[中斷](concepts.md#c10),可以完全由[外界](concepts.md#c04)造成,不需要任何人的傾向先改變;但新結構是否真的出現,仍要看[記錄](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c06)。\n\n另:1825 年伊利運河通航,紐約到水牛城的運費由每噸 90 美元降到 4 美元,行程由三週縮短為 8 天;五大湖區與紐約之間原本不可行的運貨[路徑](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c07),因此進入[可行集合](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c11)。\n\n---\n\n## 五、經濟模式的形成\n\n### 五之一 一次循環\n\n在某[經濟模式](concepts.md#c09)的一個[檢查窗口](concepts.md#c03)內,依上游可以描述為以下過程(這是描述,不是新定義):\n\n1. 參與[節點](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25)[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28),研究者指定登記的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)被[記錄](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c06);\n2. [輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)可能[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)其他[節點](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25)、[外界](concepts.md#c04),或經由[迴路](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c31)[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)自己;\n3. 各參與[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)的[結果回饋](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c05)若[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)它自己,就進入它的[歷史](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13);\n4. 這些[歷史](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13)參與各[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)下一[時刻](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c09)的[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06),這一步不一定讀得到;\n5. 下一個[檢查窗口](concepts.md#c03)若有這些[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28),就在這些[歷史](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13)參與的[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06)下發生。\n\n這對應[推演輪](../paper_96f10d75_23d0_441f_94c7_ab87ca28d284/concepts.md#c07)的定義:在場的各[節點](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25)各走一次[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)、[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)、入[歷史](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13)的循環;本篇另加[結果回饋](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c05)與它參與[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06)兩步,並把它放在[經濟模式](concepts.md#c09)的[檢查窗口](concepts.md#c03)上。本篇記為:這個過程在各[檢查窗口](concepts.md#c03)依次重複;下一個[檢查窗口](concepts.md#c03)若沒有參與[節點](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25)的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28),循環就在該[檢查窗口](concepts.md#c03)停止;之後的[檢查窗口](concepts.md#c03)若再有參與[節點](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25)的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28),循環重新開始;循環停止不等於[判準中斷](concepts.md#c10),是否[中斷](concepts.md#c10)依[存續判準](concepts.md#c01)判定。\n\n### 五之二 參與的渦各有小迴路\n\n**結論五之一**:凡有[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)參與的[經濟模式](concepts.md#c09),其中每個參與的[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)都有自己的[小迴路](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c02)。\n\n(從[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)、[坍塌](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c08)、[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06)、[時刻](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c09)、[涉及](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c11)、[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)、[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)、[迴路](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c31)與[小迴路](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c02)的定義推出:[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)是它自己的一次[坍塌](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c08)結果([輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28));一個[呈現](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c04)的[坍塌](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c08)結果,是它下一[時刻](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c09)中依[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06)而定、[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06)不為零的結果([坍塌](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c08)、[時刻](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c09)),也就是以正的[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06)落在它身上([權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06)),所以這次[坍塌](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c08)[涉及](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c11)它([涉及](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c11));[坍塌](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c08)[涉及](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c11)它時,結果就[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)它([到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10));[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)它的[歷史](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13)都參與它下一[時刻](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c09)的[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06)([渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16));所以它的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)經由自己,又參與它自己的[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06),構成[迴路](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c31),也就是它的[小迴路](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c02))\n\n說明:個體滿足自己、兩人互動、單方面[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28),都在此列。[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)單方面[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)時,即使沒有任何回應,在它其後的[時刻](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c09)中「沒有發生在它身上」,依[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)的定義也是一次[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)。所以需要逐案判定的不是「有沒有[迴路](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c31)」,而是「有哪些[迴路](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c31)」:只有[小迴路](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c02)、有[大迴路](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c03),或構成[太極](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c39)。\n\n校準:自耕自食的農戶,今年的收成和耕作經驗,回到明年的耕作。投出求職信沒有回音,「沒有回音」也進入求職者的[歷史](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13)。\n\n### 五之三 前件的供應來自他人\n\n**結論五之二**:若某[路徑](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c07)屬於前提一所指的[路徑](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c07),而它在某[檢查窗口](concepts.md#c03)內實現,則必有其他[節點](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25)的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10),供應它的[前件](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c08)。供應者算進同一個[經濟模式](concepts.md#c09)([模式](concepts.md#c09)跨[節點](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25)),或算作[模式](concepts.md#c09)的[外界](concepts.md#c04),是研究者的[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)。\n\n(從前提一,以及[可行集合](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c11)與[前件](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c08)的定義推出)\n\n說明:\n1. [路徑](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c07)實現,表示它在該[窗口](concepts.md#c03)可行,[門檻](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c03)中各[前件](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c08)都具備([門檻](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c03)的定義)。\n2. 依前提一,其中至少一項[前件](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c08)只能由其他[節點](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25)的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)而具備。\n3. 所以必有其他[節點](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25)的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)過(在該[窗口](concepts.md#c03),或更早)。\n\n校準:一個人打不死大象,兩三個人同時出手才打得倒。「打倒大象」這條[路徑](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c07),每個人的[前件](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c08)中都有別人的同時出手,所以研究者若把同伴的出手一併算進圍獵[模式](concepts.md#c09),圍獵[模式](concepts.md#c09)便跨[節點](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25)。\n\n### 五之四 修正與預測\n\n**結論五之三**:每個[檢查窗口](concepts.md#c03)的[結果回饋](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c05),都可能改變參與[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)之後的[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06);下一[檢查窗口](concepts.md#c03)若有這些[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)不被[鎖死](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c12)的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28),這些[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)就可能隨之不同;但改變沒有預設方向,不保證更有利於[模式](concepts.md#c09)延續。\n\n(從[學習](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c04)、[結果回饋](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c05)、[坍塌](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c08)、[鎖死](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c12)與[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)的定義推出:[結果回饋](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c05)是一個[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)之後的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)再[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)自己的後續互動;[學習](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c04)是[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)的材料可能改變後續[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06)的過程,是結果條件,不指目的,沒有預設方向,不保證學到,也不保證學對;[坍塌](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c08)的結果依[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06)而定,[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)就是這種結果;在某[時刻](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c09)不被[鎖死](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c12)時,下一[時刻](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c09)不是只有一個結果的[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06)不為零)\n\n校準:攤商被嫌貴,下週可能降價,也可能換一批客人,也可能乾脆不擺;降價也不保證生意變好。\n\n**結論五之四**:若某[經濟模式](concepts.md#c09)在[存續判準](concepts.md#c01)(前提二)下是否再出現,取決於不被[鎖死](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c12)的[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)或[隨機源](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c27)的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)(也就是這些[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)的不同可能結果,會使判準得出不同判定),且這些[節點](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25)在該[檢查窗口](concepts.md#c03)內有不被[鎖死](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c12)的[時刻](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c09),則它在下一[檢查窗口](concepts.md#c03)是否[判準中斷](concepts.md#c10),事前不可推出;過去的[落空比例](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c17)只是外顯統計,不能代替[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06)。若判準只取決於被[鎖死](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c12)的[信號容器](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c26)中的內容,則本結論不適用,是否[中斷](concepts.md#c10)可由容器內容判定。\n\n(從[黑箱律](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c25)、[隨機源](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c27)與[落空比例](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c17)的定義推出:[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)在某[時刻](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c09)不被[鎖死](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c12)時,[宇宙](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c02)中沒有任何[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)能事前唯一推出它的下一[時刻](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c09),能推出的是[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06),不是結果;[隨機源](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c27)不被[鎖死](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c12)時,同樣只能談[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06);[落空比例](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c17)不是真實[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06)的讀數。本篇補上:[經濟模式](concepts.md#c09)的再出現取決於判準所涉的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28),而這些[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)是否[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10),也可能取決於[外界](concepts.md#c04)(結論四之六),所以判準取決於這些[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)時,是否[判準中斷](concepts.md#c10)事前不可推出)\n\n校準:大多數新開的店在幾年內就收掉,開幕時看不出哪些會留下;留下來的店,也不能由它過去開得好推出明年還在。\n\n另:美國勞工統計局追蹤 2013 年 3 月新設立的民營事業單位,一年後仍營運者 79.6%,五年後 50.6%,十年後 34.7%。比例可以事後統計,哪一家會留下,開業時推不出。\n\n**結論五之五**:即使擁有完整的[輸出圖集](concepts.md#c07),也不能推出[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)或[隨機源](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c27)在下一[窗口](concepts.md#c03)不被[鎖死](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c12)時的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)。\n\n(從三之二,以及[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)、[隨機源](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c27)與[黑箱律](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c25)的定義推出)\n\n說明:\n1. [輸出圖集](concepts.md#c07)是[歷史](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13)的子集(三之二)。\n2. [渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)的[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06)依賴[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)它的全部[歷史](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13),包括[圖集](concepts.md#c07)之外的部分([渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)的定義)。\n3. 即使[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06)已知,[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)不被[鎖死](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c12)時也只能推出[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06),推不出結果([黑箱律](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c25));[隨機源](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c27)不被[鎖死](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c12)時,同樣只能談[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06)([隨機源](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c27)的定義)。\n\n校準:掌握全部交易紀錄的平台,仍會在下一季的需求上估錯。\n\n另:〔Amazon〕在疫情期間約兩年內把物流網擴大約一倍,執行長表示公司在 2021 年初決定按需求預測的高端規劃;至 2022 年,依顧問公司〔MWPVL〕的估計,它關閉或取消了 42 處設施,約 2,500 萬平方英尺。\n\n### 五之五 「形成」不是一個時刻\n\n**結論五之六**:一個結構成為[經濟模式](concepts.md#c09),只能在它於多個[檢查窗口](concepts.md#c03)中出現之後,由研究者事後辨認;不存在可以事前指認的「形成時刻」。\n\n(從[經濟模式](concepts.md#c09)的定義推出;與[共振](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c09)的定義「是否[共振](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c09),只能事後說」同構)\n\n說明:「[經濟模式](concepts.md#c09)怎麼形成」的答案是:不斷有結構出現,大部分沒有再出現;再出現的,在事後被稱為[經濟模式](concepts.md#c09)。\n\n校準:空地上有人擺過一次攤,多數人沒再來;後來每週都有人來,大家才把那裡叫做夜市。沒人說得出夜市是哪一天「形成」的。\n\n### 五之六 可行集合隨模式改變\n\n**結論五之七**:[經濟模式](concepts.md#c09)某[檢查窗口](concepts.md#c03)的[結果回饋](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c05)[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)參與[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)後,在之後的[推演輪](../paper_96f10d75_23d0_441f_94c7_ab87ca28d284/concepts.md#c07)中,該[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)的[可行集合](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c11)可能改變:原本有[前件](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c08)未具備的[路徑](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c07),可能因此具備而進入[可行集合](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c11);原本可行的[路徑](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c07),也可能退出。\n\n(從前提三、[可行集合](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c11)與[推演輪](../paper_96f10d75_23d0_441f_94c7_ab87ca28d284/concepts.md#c07)的定義推出:[前件](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c08)可因[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)而具備,[前件](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c08)隨[歷史](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13)變動,所以[可行集合](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c11)可能隨輪次變動。本篇補上:在跨[節點](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25)的[模式](concepts.md#c09)中,供應[前件](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c08)的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)可以來自其他參與[節點](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25))\n\n說明:\n1. [結果回饋](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c05)進入參與[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)的[歷史](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13)(五之一第 3 步,以及[結果回饋](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c05)的定義)。\n2. [前件](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c08)可能隨[歷史](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13)變動(前提三),所以各[路徑](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c07)的[門檻](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c03)是否具備、[可行集合](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c11)可能跟著變。\n3. 依前提一,若某[前件](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c08)只能由其他[節點](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25)的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)而具備,則在跨[節點](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25)的[模式](concepts.md#c09)中,研究者若把這類[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)算進[模式](concepts.md#c09)(結論五之二),[模式](concepts.md#c09)的再出現,可能為某些參與[節點](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25)補上原本缺少的[前件](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c08)。\n4. [可行集合](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c11)改變,不推出新[路徑](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c07)會被走([門檻](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c03)的定義:全部[前件](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c08)具備只表示可行,不表示會發生);也不推出改變有利於[模式](concepts.md#c09)延續(結論五之三)。\n\n校準:圍獵成功後留下骨頭,「做骨矛」這條[路徑](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c07)的材料[前件](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c08)才具備;有人做出骨矛,下一次圍獵的[路徑](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c07)又多了一條。但也可能沒人去做,或做了不好用。\n\n**結論五之八**:以[模式](concepts.md#c09)中[節點](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25)的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)為[前件](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c08)的[路徑](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c07)若反覆實現,研究者可以依講明的[同一性條件](concepts.md#c02),將其判為原[模式](concepts.md#c09)的一部分,或判為另一[經濟模式](concepts.md#c09);兩種判法都不改變[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)本身。\n\n(從三之四、前提二推出)\n\n說明:事後所說的「細化」「分化」「從粗變細」,是研究者對這類[路徑](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c07)的[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18),與結論五之六同構,不是[模式](concepts.md#c09)自己長出來的。\n\n校準:狩獵團中有人不再出獵、專在營地處理獵物,她這條[路徑](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c07)的[前件](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c08)是獵人帶回的獵物。研究者可以稱之為狩獵[模式](concepts.md#c09)的後勤,也可以另立一個「處理獵物」[模式](concepts.md#c09)。\n\n**結論五之九**:[同一性條件](concepts.md#c02)若講在結果類別上,不同[窗口](concepts.md#c03)以不同[路徑](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c07)實現同一結果類別的結構,仍可算同一[經濟模式](concepts.md#c09),[路徑](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c07)的替換本身不構成[判準中斷](concepts.md#c10);若講在[路徑](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c07)上且不容許以其他[路徑](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c07)替代,替換即構成[判準中斷](concepts.md#c10)。\n\n(從前提二與三之四推出:[同一性條件](concepts.md#c02)由研究者講明,可以講在結果類別上,也可以講在[路徑](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c07)上;與結論七之六相應)\n\n校準:同樣是「甲這週吃到東西」,自己採集、與人交換、親戚接濟,判準講在結果上是一個[模式](concepts.md#c09),講在[路徑](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c07)上、且三種方式不互相替代時是三個。\n\n---\n\n## 六、經濟模式成為外界\n\n[經濟模式](concepts.md#c09)本身不是[節點](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25)。說它「成為[外界](concepts.md#c04)」,意思是[模式](concepts.md#c09)中[節點](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25)的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)了[模式](concepts.md#c09)以外的[節點](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25)(見〇之六)。\n\n### 六之一 兩條途徑\n\n**結論六之一(經由[界面節點](concepts.md#c11))**:[經濟模式](concepts.md#c09)的[界面節點](concepts.md#c11)的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28),[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)[模式](concepts.md#c09)以外的[節點](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25)時,這些[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)成為那些[節點](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25)[外界](concepts.md#c04)的一部分。\n\n(從[界面節點](concepts.md#c11)與[外界](concepts.md#c04)的定義推出)\n\n校準:鎮上的銀行櫃員對來借錢的人說「可以」或「不行」,這句話就是借錢者的[外界](concepts.md#c04)。\n\n**結論六之二(經由[自然環境](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c16))**:[經濟模式](concepts.md#c09)中[節點](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25)的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)[自然環境](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c16),而被改變的部分其後[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)其他[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)時,這些[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)便間接參與那些[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)的[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06);即使雙方之間沒有任何[節點](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25)與[節點](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25)之間的[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)。\n\n(從[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)、[自然環境](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c16)、[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)的定義推出)\n\n說明:\n1. [呈現](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c04)是[宇宙](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c02)中的任何部分,[自然環境](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c16)的各部分也是[呈現](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c04);[模式](concepts.md#c09)[節點](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25)的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)是一次[坍塌](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c08)的結果,這次[坍塌](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c08)若[涉及](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c11)[自然環境](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c16)的某部分,這筆[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)就[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)那部分([呈現](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c04)、[自然環境](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c16)、[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)、[涉及](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c11)與[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)的定義)。\n2. [自然環境](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c16)是不屬於任何[節點](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25)、卻有[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)[節點](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25)的部分([自然環境](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c16)的定義),所以它被改變的部分可以[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)其他[節點](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25)。\n3. [到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)其他[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)的,進入那些[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)的[歷史](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13),參與它們之後的[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06)([渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)的定義)。\n4. 1 至 3 的鏈條中沒有任何[節點](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25)對[節點](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25)的[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)。\n\n校準:美國中西部農田的氮肥隨密西西比河入海,墨西哥灣每年夏天出現大片缺氧區,當地捕蝦業的漁獲因此改變。農民和漁民彼此從未接觸。\n\n### 六之二 影響不以參與為條件\n\n**結論六之三**:一個[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)即使不參與某[經濟模式](concepts.md#c09),只要[模式](concepts.md#c09)中[節點](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25)的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)經由任一途徑[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)它,這些[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)就參與它之後的[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06)。\n\n(從[邊](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c29)與[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)的定義推出:一個[節點](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25)的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28),參與另一個[節點](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25)的[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06)([邊](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c29));[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)的全部[歷史](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13),都參與它下一[時刻](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c09)的[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06)([渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16))。本篇補上:[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)的途徑包括結論六之一、六之二兩條)\n\n校準:鎮上開了銀行,沒在銀行開戶的人也會受影響,例如鄰居開始借錢做生意、地價改變。參與者只是受影響者的一小部分。\n\n### 六之三 界面的類型\n\n**結論六之四**:[外界](concepts.md#c04)[節點](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25)經由不同類型的[界面節點](concepts.md#c11),接觸到的是性質不同的[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)來源:\n\n- **經由[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)**:[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)來自一個[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06)會隨[歷史](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13)改變的[節點](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25),同樣的請求可能得到不同的回應;兩者若都是[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19),在一個講明的維度上彼此的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)互相[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)時,可以累積[專屬歷史](../paper_ae79e938_76e1_4bf9_b2ab_995c03e16c9e/concepts.md#c05),有可能形成[默契](../paper_ae79e938_76e1_4bf9_b2ab_995c03e16c9e/concepts.md#c06);\n- **經由[信號容器](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c26)**:[鎖死](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c12)的[信號容器](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c26)中若列有[模板](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c14),它的內容不會自己變,提供固定點,不需要先[共振](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c09)就能取得;容器不是[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19),所以不能和它形成[專屬歷史](../paper_ae79e938_76e1_4bf9_b2ab_995c03e16c9e/concepts.md#c05)或[默契](../paper_ae79e938_76e1_4bf9_b2ab_995c03e16c9e/concepts.md#c06);\n- **經由[隨機源](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c27)**:[隨機源](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c27)不被[鎖死](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c12)時,它自己的結果只能談[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06);它不是[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16),所以不是[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19),不能和它形成[專屬歷史](../paper_ae79e938_76e1_4bf9_b2ab_995c03e16c9e/concepts.md#c05)或[默契](../paper_ae79e938_76e1_4bf9_b2ab_995c03e16c9e/concepts.md#c06)。\n\n(從[界面節點](concepts.md#c11)的定義,以及[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)、[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19)、[信號容器](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c26)、[隨機源](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c27)、[專屬歷史](../paper_ae79e938_76e1_4bf9_b2ab_995c03e16c9e/concepts.md#c05)、[默契](../paper_ae79e938_76e1_4bf9_b2ab_995c03e16c9e/concepts.md#c06)的定義推出)\n\n校準:同一家銀行,對櫃員和對自動提款機是兩種不同的[外界](concepts.md#c04):櫃員今天可能通融,明天可能不通融;自動提款機每次照規則走,但也不會記得你。\n\n### 六之四 參與者的其他維度\n\n**結論六之五**:[經濟模式](concepts.md#c09)的[結果回饋](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c05)[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)某參與[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)時,參與的是它整個[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06)分布,不限於研究者劃定的那個維度。所以該[結果回饋](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c05)可能參與它在其他維度上的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)。\n\n(從[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)的定義、[結果回饋](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c05)的定義與[自己的那一段](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c17)的定義推出)\n\n說明:\n1. [渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)的[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06)依賴[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)它的全部[歷史](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13)([渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)的定義)。\n2. [自己的那一段](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c17)由依賴決定,不由任何[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)決定([自己的那一段](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c17)的定義);維度是研究者的[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)。\n3. 所以一筆[結果回饋](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c05)參與的是整個[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06)分布,不受研究者劃的維度限制。\n\n校準:在銀行上班,改變的不只是工作上的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28);家庭理財、消費習慣都可能跟著變,也可能看不出變化。\n\n### 六之五 影響的方向\n\n**結論六之六**:[模式](concepts.md#c09)中[節點](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25)的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)[外界](concepts.md#c04)[節點](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25)後,若[外界](concepts.md#c04)[節點](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25)是[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)或[隨機源](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c27),且它在下一次[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)之前的那一[時刻](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c09)不被[鎖死](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c12),則它下一次的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)不能事前唯一推出,能推出的只是各結果的[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06);除非[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06)不為零的結果都朝同一方向,否則影響的方向也推不出。\n\n(從[黑箱律](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c25)與[隨機源](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c27)的定義推出:沒被[鎖死](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c12)時,只能談[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06),不能談結果)\n\n校準:街口開了便利商店,有人開始吃宵夜,有人照舊,有人因此把自家的雜貨店收掉;開幕前說不出誰會怎麼變。\n\n---\n\n## 七、經濟模式互為外界\n\n### 七之一 輸出經由另一模式回到自身時形成跨模式迴路\n\n**結論七之一**:若[經濟模式](concepts.md#c09)甲中某參與[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)乙中某參與[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16),這個乙中的[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16),或經由乙中以[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)相連的其他[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16),其後的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)又[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)甲的這個[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16),且這些[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)都不同時屬於甲、乙,則甲、乙互為對方[外界](concepts.md#c04)的一部分;這個[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)經由乙,再回到自己的[歷史](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13),參與自己之後的[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06)。在這些條件下,甲與乙合起來構成一個跨[模式](concepts.md#c09)的[迴路](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c31)。\n\n(從結論六之一、六之二、六之三,以及[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)、[迴路](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c31)與[結果回饋](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c05)的定義推出)\n\n校準:銀行放貸給商家,商家的營收回到銀行。銀行和商家各自是一個[模式](concepts.md#c09),合起來又是一個更大的[迴路](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c31)。\n\n### 七之二 互為外界的關係\n\n若甲、乙之間有[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10),研究者可在講明的維度、時窗與相容判準下,依上游的定義辨認以下關係:\n\n- **[共振](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c09)**:甲、乙參與[節點](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25)的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)反覆相容接續。\n- **[太極](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c39)**:甲、乙各含一個某方向上的[正回饋](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c32)[迴路](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c31),方向相反,互相[耦合](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c36),並在[耦合](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c36)中[趨異](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c38)。依結論五之一,有[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)參與的[模式](concepts.md#c09)中,每個[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)都有[小迴路](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c02),所以仍須判定其中是否有[正回饋](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c32)[迴路](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c31)、方向是否相反、是否[趨異](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c38)。\n- **[失配](../paper_ae79e938_76e1_4bf9_b2ab_995c03e16c9e/concepts.md#c08)**:相關[節點](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25)之間相鄰的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28),依講明的判準不相容。\n\n**結論七之二**:[共振](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c09)與[太極](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c39)可以並存,所以兩者不互斥;[共振](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c09)、[太極](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c39)、[失配](../paper_ae79e938_76e1_4bf9_b2ab_995c03e16c9e/concepts.md#c08)三者之外的關係,本篇不排除。\n\n(從[共振](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c09)與[太極](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c39)的定義推出:[共振](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c09)要求在有[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)的條件下反覆相容接續,[太極](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c39)要求方向相反的[正回饋](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c32)[迴路](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c31)互相[耦合](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c36)並[趨異](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c38),兩者判準不同,所以方向相反的[太極](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c39),在序列上仍可能相容接續)\n\n校準:兩家對打的連鎖店,價格戰愈打愈兇,這是[太極](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c39);同時兩家的貨車每天在同一條路上錯開送貨,在交通這個維度上相容接續。\n\n另:1975 年百事推出「百事挑戰」盲測;1985 年 4 月 23 日可口可樂宣布改配方推出「新可樂」,同年 7 月 11 日在消費者強烈反彈下宣布恢復原配方。雙方的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)各以對方為參照;研究者若判定兩者各含方向相反、在[耦合](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c36)中[趨異](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c38)的[正回饋](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c32)[迴路](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c31),即符合[太極](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c39)的判準,這需另行講明維度與資料。\n\n### 七之三 前件的供應與先後\n\n**結論七之三**:若甲某[路徑](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c07)的某項[前件](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c08),只能由乙中[節點](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25)的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)而具備,則該[路徑](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c07)只在乙的相應[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)之後才可行。\n\n(從[門檻](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c03)的定義與前提三推出:任一[前件](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c08)不具備,該[路徑](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c07)在該輪不可行;[前件](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c08)可因[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)而具備(前提三),所以[前件](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c08)只能由乙中[節點](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25)的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)供應時,該[路徑](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c07)只在相應[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)之後可行。本篇補上:先後可以跨[模式](concepts.md#c09))\n\n**結論七之四**:所以若甲某[路徑](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c07)的某項[前件](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c08)只能由乙中[節點](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25)的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)供應,且甲的[同一性條件](concepts.md#c02)要求這條[路徑](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c07)、不容許替代,則甲只能在乙的相應[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)之後出現;依[前件](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c08)的供應關係,可以排出[經濟模式](concepts.md#c09)與供應它的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)之間的部分先後。但乙的相應[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10),不推出甲會出現。\n\n(從結論七之三與[門檻](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c03)的定義推出:[前件](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c08)具備只表示可行,不表示會發生;後半亦見結論四之五)\n\n說明:\n1. 若甲的[同一性條件](concepts.md#c02)要求上述[路徑](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c07)(不容許以其他[路徑](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c07)替代),甲要出現,這條[路徑](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c07)必須實現,所以乙的相應[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)必須先[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)。\n2. 這只排出部分先後:沒有供應關係時,依供應關係排不出先後。\n\n校準:先有冷鏈運輸,內陸的生魚片店才可能出現;但有了冷鏈的城市,不一定有人開生魚片店。\n\n另:1882 年 2 月 15 日,冷凍船〔Dunedin〕號載約五千隻冷凍羊屠體自紐西蘭查默斯港出發,5 月下旬抵達倫敦;冷凍肉品貿易由此展開,其後成為紐西蘭二十世紀經濟的核心。以冷凍羊肉出口為產出、且[同一性條件](concepts.md#c02)不容許其他[路徑](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c07)替代的牧羊[模式](concepts.md#c09),只能在冷凍運輸之後出現。\n\n### 七之四 供應中斷的連鎖\n\n**結論七之五**:若乙中[節點](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25)的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)經由[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10),被判定為甲某[路徑](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c07)的[前件](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c08),且該項[前件](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c08)要靠這筆[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)持續[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)才具備,則該[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)不再[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)時,該項[前件](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c08)不再由乙供應;若沒有替代來源,甲的相應[路徑](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c07)不可行。\n\n(從[門檻](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c03)的定義推出:任一[前件](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c08)不具備,該[路徑](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c07)在該輪不可行;該項[前件](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c08)要靠乙中[節點](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25)的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)持續[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)才具備時,[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)不再[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10),它就不再由乙供應)\n\n**結論七之六**:甲的某[路徑](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c07)不可行,不推出甲[判準中斷](concepts.md#c10)。甲在某[檢查窗口](concepts.md#c03)是否[中斷](concepts.md#c10),取決於該[窗口](concepts.md#c03)內符合甲的[同一性條件](concepts.md#c02)的結構是否實際再次出現;某條[路徑](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c07)不可行,本身不決定這件事。\n\n(從[經濟模式](concepts.md#c09)、[判準中斷](concepts.md#c10)、[同一性條件](concepts.md#c02)與[檢查窗口](concepts.md#c03)的定義推出)\n\n**結論七之七**:連鎖可以多段傳遞,也可以經由[自然環境](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c16)傳遞。\n\n(從結論七之五的重複套用,以及結論六之二推出)\n\n說明:七之三是供應[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)之後[路徑](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c07)才可能可行,本小節是供應中斷、又沒有替代來源時[路徑](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c07)不可行,兩者是同一關係的兩面。\n\n校準:銀行倒閉,靠貸款的商家某條[路徑](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c07)不可行;但商家可能改向親戚借錢,[模式](concepts.md#c09)照樣延續。上游水庫停止放水,下游的灌溉中斷,靠下游農產品的加工廠可能接著缺料。連鎖說明的是[前件](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c08)的牽連,不是[中斷](concepts.md#c10)的必然。\n\n另(結論七之五、七之六):1860 年英國進口的原棉約八成來自美國。南北戰爭期間北方封鎖南方港口,1861 至 1865 年蘭開夏發生棉荒,許多工人失業、仰賴救濟。紡織廠改用印度蘇拉特棉與埃及棉,但蘇拉特棉纖維短、易斷,織機產量僅及原來約四成;1864 年進口恢復後,就業才回到常態。供應中斷傳到紡織業(七之五),紡織[模式](concepts.md#c09)卻改用印度與埃及棉花的[路徑](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c07)延續,未[判準中斷](concepts.md#c10)(七之六)。\n\n另(結論七之七):2011 年東日本大地震損及瑞薩電子那珂工廠。瑞薩當時供應全球約兩成的車用微控制器,地震後市場估計的最壞情況,是全球汽車產量減少 750 萬至 1,100 萬輛;這是當時的估計,不是實際減產量。\n\n### 七之五 總結論\n\n**結論七之八**:在講明的[切法](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c23)下,記在[人群圖](concepts.md#c05)上的[輸出圖集](concepts.md#c07)中的結構,可以描述為兩部分:\n\n1. **一群[經濟模式](concepts.md#c09)**:[模式](concepts.md#c09)中[節點](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25)的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)可以經由[界面節點](concepts.md#c11)與[自然環境](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c16),成為其他[節點](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25)的[外界](concepts.md#c04);互相[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)、不共有參與[節點](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25)的[模式](concepts.md#c09)之間互為[外界](concepts.md#c04);某[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)經由另一[模式](concepts.md#c09)中的[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)回到它自己時,構成跨[模式](concepts.md#c09)的[迴路](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c31);彼此之間可依判準辨認[共振](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c09)、[太極](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c39)、[失配](../paper_ae79e938_76e1_4bf9_b2ab_995c03e16c9e/concepts.md#c08);[前件](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c08)的供應使[模式](concepts.md#c09)與供應它的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)之間有部分先後,供應的中斷經由[前件](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c08)判定連鎖傳遞。\n2. **未追蹤的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)**:[輸出圖集](concepts.md#c07)中沒有被研究者追蹤為[經濟模式](concepts.md#c09)的結構,包括只出現一次的,也包括反覆出現但研究者沒有追蹤的,以及研究者已開始留意、但還沒有反覆出現而還不是[經濟模式](concepts.md#c09)的。它們不構成[經濟模式](concepts.md#c09),但仍在[歷史](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13)中,仍參與它們所[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)的[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)的[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06)。\n\n(從第三至七節的定義與結論推出)\n\n說明:依結論五之六,每個[經濟模式](concepts.md#c09)在第一次出現時,都還不是[經濟模式](concepts.md#c09)。所以[經濟模式](concepts.md#c09)都來自還不是[經濟模式](concepts.md#c09)的結構;研究者是否從第一次出現就追蹤它,不改變這一點。\n\n校準:一國的人每天吃午飯,研究者把各家餐館與客人反覆出現的結構合稱餐飲業,這是研究者的[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18);天天呼吸也反覆出現,但研究者若沒有追蹤它,它不構成[經濟模式](concepts.md#c09),屬於第二部分;某天有人臨時在家門口賣便當,只賣一次,不構成[經濟模式](concepts.md#c09),但買過的人下次的午飯可能因此不同。\n\n---\n\n## 八、生殖模式\n\n**[生殖模式](concepts.md#c12)**:產出為[子代](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c15)的[經濟模式](concepts.md#c09)。這不是新定義,只是依產出所作的稱呼,和「餐飲業」一樣,是研究者的[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)。生殖事件本身不必構成[生殖模式](concepts.md#c12):只有研究者依[存續判準](concepts.md#c01)把它所在的結構追蹤為反覆出現的[經濟模式](concepts.md#c09)時,它所在的結構才是[生殖模式](concepts.md#c12)。\n\n**結論八之一**:[經濟模式](concepts.md#c09)是研究者對[節點](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25)的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)所作的歸類,所以每個[經濟模式](concepts.md#c09)的出現,都需要有參與[節點](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25)。若各生物人[節點](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25)都會[判準退場](../paper_96f10d75_23d0_441f_94c7_ab87ca28d284/concepts.md#c09),則所有以生物人為[節點](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25)的[模式](concepts.md#c09)所需的生物人[節點](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25),最終都來自生殖事件;這些生殖事件所在的結構若被研究者追蹤為反覆出現的[經濟模式](concepts.md#c09),就是[生殖模式](concepts.md#c12)。\n\n(從前提四、[經濟模式](concepts.md#c09)與[生殖模式](concepts.md#c12)的定義、結論七之三與[子代](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c15)的定義推出:生殖事件產生新[進場](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c44)的[節點](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25))\n\n**結論八之二**:若[人群圖](concepts.md#c05)的[存續判準](concepts.md#c01)有某個[檢查窗口](concepts.md#c03),在這個[窗口](concepts.md#c03)開始時,[人群圖](concepts.md#c05)中原有的生物人[節點](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25)都已[判準退場](../paper_96f10d75_23d0_441f_94c7_ab87ca28d284/concepts.md#c09),且[人群圖](concepts.md#c05)的[存續判準](concepts.md#c01)要求[人群圖](concepts.md#c05)中有未[判準退場](../paper_96f10d75_23d0_441f_94c7_ab87ca28d284/concepts.md#c09)的生物人[節點](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25),則這個[檢查窗口](concepts.md#c03)內必須有生物人[節點](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25)新加入[人群圖](concepts.md#c05)([切法](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c23)內生殖事件產生的[子代](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c15),或外來移入),或有原有的生物人[節點](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25)在這個[窗口](concepts.md#c03)內不再被記為[判準退場](../paper_96f10d75_23d0_441f_94c7_ab87ca28d284/concepts.md#c09),否則[人群圖](concepts.md#c05)在這個[窗口](concepts.md#c03)[判準中斷](concepts.md#c10);新加入的[節點](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25)都來自生殖事件(前提四)。這些生殖事件可以在[切法](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c23)之內,也可以在[切法](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c23)之外:從外面帶人進來,只是把供應[節點](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25)的生殖事件放到了[切法](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c23)之外;它們所在的結構若被追蹤為[生殖模式](concepts.md#c12),這個[生殖模式](concepts.md#c12)也可以在這些[節點](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25)加入[人群圖](concepts.md#c05)之前就已[判準中斷](concepts.md#c10)。\n\n(從[人群圖](concepts.md#c05)、[判準中斷](concepts.md#c10)、[切法](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c23)與[生殖模式](concepts.md#c12)的定義、前提四推出)\n\n說明:\n1. [生殖模式](concepts.md#c12)[判準中斷](concepts.md#c10),其他[模式](concepts.md#c09)不必立即[中斷](concepts.md#c10)(各[模式](concepts.md#c09)依自己的[存續判準](concepts.md#c01)與[檢查窗口](concepts.md#c03)判定,見[判準中斷](concepts.md#c10)與[檢查窗口](concepts.md#c03)的定義;結論七之六);但現有[節點](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25)全部[判準退場](../paper_96f10d75_23d0_441f_94c7_ab87ca28d284/concepts.md#c09)而沒有替代來源時,連鎖可以傳到依賴這些[節點](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25)的[模式](concepts.md#c09)(結論七之七)。\n2. [生殖模式](concepts.md#c12)的[路徑](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c07)有[前件](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c08)只能由對方的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)供應(前提五、結論五之二);研究者把對方的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)算進[模式](concepts.md#c09)時,[模式](concepts.md#c09)跨[節點](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25)([經濟模式](concepts.md#c09)的定義)。\n3. [人群圖](concepts.md#c05)是否「同一個」,由研究者講明的[同一性條件](concepts.md#c02)決定(三之四),不論新[節點](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25)來自[切法](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c23)內的生殖事件還是外來移入。\n4. 若[生殖模式](concepts.md#c12)中的親代是生物人[節點](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25),依前提四,它們本身也來自生殖事件;若親代與[子代](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c15)都是[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16),親代的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)[子代](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c15),[子代](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c15)其後的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)又[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)親代、進入親代的[歷史](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13),且研究者把這段[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)算進該[生殖模式](concepts.md#c12),則親代的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)經由[子代](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c15)又參與親代自己的[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06),[生殖模式](concepts.md#c12)含有跨代的[迴路](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c31)([渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)與[迴路](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c31)的定義);[人群圖](concepts.md#c05)的[節點](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25)都來自生殖事件(前提四、結論八之二),這些事件可以在[切法](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c23)之內或之外。上述跨代[迴路](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c31)與[節點](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25)的供應,不推出各[模式](concepts.md#c09)的其他[前件](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c08)也由它們供應;這些[前件](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c08)仍可能來自[外界](concepts.md#c04)與[自然環境](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c16)(結論四之六、六之二)。\n\n校準:美國南方的棉花園靠販運黑奴補充勞動力,供應[節點](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25)的是非洲的[生殖模式](concepts.md#c12);某些行業長期仰賴移工,供應[節點](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25)的是移工母國的[生殖模式](concepts.md#c12)。生育率長期低於替代水準而沒有移入的地區,連鎖要等到[節點](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25)[判準退場](../paper_96f10d75_23d0_441f_94c7_ab87ca28d284/concepts.md#c09)才顯現,所以有時間落差。\n\n另:日本 2024 年出生數約七十二萬,連續第九年減少;同年 10 月外籍勞工人數創下約 230 萬的新高,比前一年增加 12.4%。供應[節點](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25)的生殖事件,有一部分在[切法](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c23)之外。\n\n---\n\n## 九、參與者層的推論\n\n**結論九之一**:在某一維度上符合[默契](../paper_ae79e938_76e1_4bf9_b2ab_995c03e16c9e/concepts.md#c06)判準,不推出在其他維度上也符合。\n\n([默契](../paper_ae79e938_76e1_4bf9_b2ab_995c03e16c9e/concepts.md#c06)的定義:[默契](../paper_ae79e938_76e1_4bf9_b2ab_995c03e16c9e/concepts.md#c06)在指定的情境類型與維度中判定)\n\n**結論九之二**:兩個[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19)反覆參與同一[經濟模式](concepts.md#c09)、在該維度上彼此的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)互相[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)時,會累積該維度上的[專屬歷史](../paper_ae79e938_76e1_4bf9_b2ab_995c03e16c9e/concepts.md#c05);但[專屬歷史](../paper_ae79e938_76e1_4bf9_b2ab_995c03e16c9e/concepts.md#c05)的累積不推出[默契](../paper_ae79e938_76e1_4bf9_b2ab_995c03e16c9e/concepts.md#c06)。\n\n(從[專屬歷史](../paper_ae79e938_76e1_4bf9_b2ab_995c03e16c9e/concepts.md#c05)與[默契](../paper_ae79e938_76e1_4bf9_b2ab_995c03e16c9e/concepts.md#c06)的定義推出:互動次數多,不等於已有[默契](../paper_ae79e938_76e1_4bf9_b2ab_995c03e16c9e/concepts.md#c06))\n\n校準:同事在工作上配合多年,可能形成工作上的[默契](../paper_ae79e938_76e1_4bf9_b2ab_995c03e16c9e/concepts.md#c06),也可能沒有;即使有,也不保證在生活上相處得來。同事不是家人。\n\n**結論九之三**:作為[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19)的[節點](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25)加入某[經濟模式](concepts.md#c09)時,不承繼其他參與者之間的[專屬歷史](../paper_ae79e938_76e1_4bf9_b2ab_995c03e16c9e/concepts.md#c05);這樣的[節點](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25)退出時,它與其他參與者已有的[專屬歷史](../paper_ae79e938_76e1_4bf9_b2ab_995c03e16c9e/concepts.md#c05)仍在[歷史](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13)中。\n\n(從[歷史](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13)與[專屬歷史](../paper_ae79e938_76e1_4bf9_b2ab_995c03e16c9e/concepts.md#c05)的定義推出:[歷史](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13)只往後追加,所以既有的[專屬歷史](../paper_ae79e938_76e1_4bf9_b2ab_995c03e16c9e/concepts.md#c05)不因加入或退出而消失;[專屬歷史](../paper_ae79e938_76e1_4bf9_b2ab_995c03e16c9e/concepts.md#c05)只屬於那兩者,所以不成為新成員的)\n\n校準:新進員工不會因為加入團隊,就繼承老員工之間多年的配合;老員工離職,大家與他共事的經歷仍在。\n\n**結論九之四**:新加入者與其他參與者之間沒有[專屬歷史](../paper_ae79e938_76e1_4bf9_b2ab_995c03e16c9e/concepts.md#c05),不推出它的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)不相容。\n\n(從[共振](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c09)的定義推出:[共振](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c09)不要求[專屬歷史](../paper_ae79e938_76e1_4bf9_b2ab_995c03e16c9e/concepts.md#c05),也不限兩個[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19),所以沒有[專屬歷史](../paper_ae79e938_76e1_4bf9_b2ab_995c03e16c9e/concepts.md#c05),不推出[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)不相容)\n\n說明:相容的來源,上游已有[共振](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c09)、[模板](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c14)等概念。某一[經濟模式](concepts.md#c09)中實際靠哪一種接續,由資料判定,不由本篇推出。\n\n校準:新來的收銀員第一天上班就能結帳,靠的可能是公司的作業手冊([模板](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c14)),也可能是他在別家超商的經歷。\n\n**結論九之五**:[節點](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25)的加入或退出,不推出[經濟模式](concepts.md#c09)[判準中斷](concepts.md#c10),也不推出它延續。\n\n(從[經濟模式](concepts.md#c09)的同一性看位置、[判準中斷](concepts.md#c10)依[存續判準](concepts.md#c01)判定推出)\n\n校準:老店換了老闆,可能照常營業,也可能半年後關門;換人時[默契](../paper_ae79e938_76e1_4bf9_b2ab_995c03e16c9e/concepts.md#c06)從頭開始,不一定建立,[模式](concepts.md#c09)不保證改變,也不保證消失。\n\n---\n\n## 十、推不出的與留待後續\n\n### 十之一 本篇推不出的\n\n- 在結論五之四的條件下,判準取決於不被[鎖死](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c12)的[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)或[隨機源](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c27)的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)時,哪些結構會成為[經濟模式](concepts.md#c09)(結論五之四、五之六);\n- 在結論五之四的條件下,判準取決於不被[鎖死](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c12)的[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)或[隨機源](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c27)的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)時,[經濟模式](concepts.md#c09)何時[判準中斷](concepts.md#c10)、壽命多長(結論五之四);\n- [經濟模式](concepts.md#c09)對[外界](concepts.md#c04)[節點](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25)的具體影響,在該[節點](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25)下一次[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)之前的那一[時刻](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c09)不被[鎖死](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c12)時;[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06)不為零的結果方向不一時,連方向也推不出(結論六之六);\n- 在結論五之四的條件下,判準取決於不被[鎖死](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c12)的[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)時,某[生殖模式](concepts.md#c12)下一[窗口](concepts.md#c03)是否延續(結論五之四、[生殖模式](concepts.md#c12)的定義)。\n\n說明:為什麼是這種形式而不是別種,取決於實際的物理與歷史條件。給定條件後,哪些[路徑](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c07)可行屬條件級,可以逐案判定;實際落出哪一種,就有限觀察者而言推不出,只能[記錄](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c06)並逐[窗口](concepts.md#c03)判定存續。\n\n**結論十之一**:觀察到的[經濟模式](concepts.md#c09),都是通過歷次[存續判準](concepts.md#c01)者;它們事後看來與其[外界](concepts.md#c04)相合時,這不推出有任何設計或目的。\n\n(從〇之四、結論五之三與[現存樣本條件化](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c14)的定義推出:觀察到的[經濟模式](concepts.md#c09),都是通過歷次[存續判準](concepts.md#c01)者(〇之四);[結果回饋](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c05)帶來的修正沒有預設方向(結論五之三),所以留下來的不必出於設計或目的;[現存樣本條件化](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c14)是研究者的樣本邊界,不是[外界](concepts.md#c04)有選擇目的)\n\n校準:老市集的位置看起來像是精心挑過,靠近渡口、路口、水源;其實當年在別處擺過攤的,多半沒留下來。\n\n### 十之二 留待後續\n\n- **需引入[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)才能推導的概念**:所有權、制度、價格、價值、貨幣、分配,以及組織、市場。本篇的[記錄](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c06)範圍不含[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18),這些概念的推導前提尚未引入;它們不是被排除,而是留待引入[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)([分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)、[二階分別](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c01)、[看法歸屬](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c02))的後續研究,以本篇推出的[經濟模式](concepts.md#c09)為底層。\n- **事前的可達判斷**:「可能接觸誰」屬於[前件](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c08)的判定,如何系統地作這類判定,留待應用研究。\n\n---\n\n## 十一、案例\n\n本節整節是校準,不作任何推導的來源。兩案取自同一段時期:前一案看一個[經濟模式](concepts.md#c09)怎麼被辨認、怎麼隨判準而有不同的判定;後一案看[模式](concepts.md#c09)中[節點](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25)的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)怎麼成為[外界](concepts.md#c04)。案中凡「為了」「想要」一類的說法,都是記錄者或後人的歸屬,不是[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06)的讀數。\n\n### 十一之一 礦區的淘金—補給模式(1848 至 1856)\n\n資料說明:讀到的是維基百科「〔California gold rush〕」「〔Women in the California gold rush〕」兩條目,以及美國國家公園管理局關於舊金山埋藏船隻的頁面,都經工具摘出相關段落,不是原始檔。人數多為估計值,各來源不盡一致。\n\n1. **[切法](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c23)**:範圍是加州礦區及舊金山,以年為[檢查窗口](concepts.md#c03)。[節點](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25)為淘金者、商人、餐館、旅館、裁縫、船隻與船員。追蹤的結構(下稱淘金結構):淘金者採得金砂 → 金砂[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)商人 → 補給、飲食、住宿、衣物[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)淘金者 → 淘金者再採。\n2. **初始狀態**:1848 年以前,舊金山約一千人,[記錄](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c06)中沒有淘金結構這個結構。\n3. **新的[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)**:1848 年 1 月 24 日,〔Marshall〕在薩特磨坊的水道中發現金砂,對所有人而言都是一次[外界](concepts.md#c04)的[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)。消息[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)哪裡,人就從哪裡來:1848 年底約六千人,1849 年約九萬人,到 1855 年至少三十萬人;1852 年一年有兩萬餘名華人在舊金山登岸。\n4. **出現的結構**:\n - 淘金結構自 1848 年起逐年重現。淘金者大量來去,參與[節點](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25)幾乎年年更換,但這組位置結構不變。\n - 淘金者賣金砂、吃飯、住宿、買衣服,每一項都需要其他[節點](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25)的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28),所以本案把這些[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)算進淘金結構,淘金結構自第一個[窗口](concepts.md#c03)起即跨[節點](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25)。\n - 〔Sam Brannan〕買下舊金山的探礦用品再轉售;1852 年〔Wells Fargo〕開始在加州經營匯兌與運送;1853 年〔Levi Strauss〕到舊金山經營布料雜貨。\n - 船員與乘客上岸淘金,數百艘船停在港內無人駕駛,有的改作倉庫、酒館、旅館,甚至監獄。\n5. **判準與[中斷](concepts.md#c10)**:\n - 採掘的方式起初是淘盤,其後是搖箱、長槽,再後來引水改道;1850 年前後,容易取得的金砂大多已採完;到 1855 年,只有中大型團體才有收穫。\n - 研究者若把「採掘」這一段單獨切出,並把[同一性條件](concepts.md#c02)講在淘盤這個方式上,則這個切出的結構約在 1850 至 1855 年間[判準中斷](concepts.md#c10);若講在淘金結構整體的位置結構上,採掘方式換了,淘金結構不[中斷](concepts.md#c10)。\n - 航運[模式](concepts.md#c09)的判準若講在船員駕駛這一[路徑](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c07)上,就因船員這項[前件](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c08)不再具備,在港內[判準中斷](concepts.md#c10)。\n6. **說明了什麼**:\n - 同一性看位置不看人:參與[節點](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25)全換,淘金結構仍可判為同一個(三之四)。\n - 前提一自始成立:淘金者的飲食、住宿、衣物與金砂的出售,[前件](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c08)都只能由其他[節點](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25)的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)而具備,所以這些[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)必由其他[節點](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25)供應(結論五之二);本案把它們算進淘金結構,所以淘金結構跨[節點](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25)。不存在魯濱遜式的淘金。\n - 「單人淘金」「團體淘金」都是研究者對採掘那一段的[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18),不是兩個在[輸出圖集](concepts.md#c07)中各自獨立的[模式](concepts.md#c09);判準講在哪一段、講在[路徑](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c07)還是結果上,[中斷](concepts.md#c10)與否可能不同(結論五之九)。\n - 商人、匯兌、布料這些[路徑](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c07),若研究者把它們的[前件](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c08)劃為只能由淘金者的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)具備,就只能在淘金者之後出現(結論七之三、七之四)。\n - 船員離船,航運[模式](concepts.md#c09)的[前件](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c08)不再由原來的[節點](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25)供應,形成連鎖(結論七之五);棄船改作倉庫,航運[模式](concepts.md#c09)的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)成了別的[路徑](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c07)的[前件](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c08)(結論五之八)。\n - 生殖:1850 年,非原住民人口中女性約佔 4.5%;1852 年約 10%;1870 年男女比約為 100 比 38;至 1950 年普查才接近相等。早期的[節點](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25)幾乎全靠外來,供應[節點](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25)的生殖事件在[切法](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c23)之外,其後[切法](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c23)之內的生殖事件才逐步增加(結論八之二)。\n7. **可說與推不出**:\n - 可說:在這段[記錄](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c06)裡,淘金結構的位置結構逐年重現,參與者大量更替;淘金者的每一項生活所需都來自其他[節點](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25);採掘方式改變;船隻改作他用。\n - 推不出:任何淘金者為什麼來、為什麼走;淘金結構為什麼在這裡形成而不在別處;某人下一年會不會留下;「發財」「失敗」一類說法是否屬實。\n\n### 十一之二 礦區與其外界(1848 至 1910)\n\n資料說明:讀到的是維基百科「〔Hydraulic mining〕」「〔Woodruff v. North Bloomfield Gravel Mining Company〕」「〔California gold rush〕」條目,經工具摘出,不是原始檔。原住民一側的當事紀錄很少,以下只寫[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)與可[記錄](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c06)的後果。\n\n1. **[切法](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c23)**:[節點](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25)分為四類:參與礦區各[模式](concepts.md#c09)的[節點](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25);下游沙加緬度河谷從事農業與航運的[節點](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25);加州原住民各群體;外國礦工。[自然環境](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c16)包括河流與土地。[檢查窗口](concepts.md#c03)為年。\n2. **初始狀態**:淘金潮之前,加州約有一萬五千名歐裔與加州墨裔居民;原住民各群體的[模式](concepts.md#c09)早已存在。\n3. **新的[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)**:\n - 1853 年,〔Matteson〕在內華達城附近以高壓水柱沖刷含金礫石。這條[路徑](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c07)要從高處引水,要有水管與噴嘴;到 1860 年代初,已需要大型組織與大筆資金。\n - 泥沙、碎石與重金屬排入河流,墊高河床,造成人為洪水,毀去河谷大片農田,淹沒城鎮,也妨礙汽船航行。\n - 礦區與原住民之間的[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10):殺害、驅離,以及河流與土地的改變。〔Madley〕估計,1846 至 1873 年間至少有 9,400 至 16,000 名加州原住民遭非原住民殺害,屠殺事件超過 370 起。\n - 外國礦工稅:每月二十美元。\n4. **出現的結構**:\n - 礦區[模式](concepts.md#c09)的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)經由河流[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)麥農,麥農的訴訟又[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)礦區:1882 年起訴,1884 年 1 月 7 日〔Sawyer〕法官判決,礦場不得再把泥沙排入河道。\n - 礦區的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)原住民各群體,原住民的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)也[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)礦區,雙方互為[外界](concepts.md#c04)。\n5. **判準與[中斷](concepts.md#c10)**:\n - 「水力採礦並把泥沙排入河道」在 1884 年後[判準中斷](concepts.md#c10);「水力採礦」則以較小規模延續,1893 年後改為加設攔沙壩,〔Malakoff Diggins〕至 1910 年才關閉。\n - 大量原住民群體的[模式](concepts.md#c09)[判準中斷](concepts.md#c10)。\n6. **說明了什麼**:\n - 表層金砂採完、水與資本到位之後,水力採礦這條[路徑](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c07)才進入[可行集合](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c11)(結論五之七)。\n - 麥農與礦場之間未必有直接的[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10),礦區的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)卻經由河流改變了他們(結論六之二);影響不以參與為條件(結論六之三)。\n - 對礦區而言原住民是[外界](concepts.md#c04),對原住民而言礦區是[外界](concepts.md#c04),雙方構成跨[模式](concepts.md#c09)的[迴路](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c31)(結論七之一)。在這個[迴路](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c31)中,大量原住民群體的[模式](concepts.md#c09)[判準中斷](concepts.md#c10),礦區[模式](concepts.md#c09)延續;依相容的判準,雙方之間是[失配](../paper_ae79e938_76e1_4bf9_b2ab_995c03e16c9e/concepts.md#c08)(七之二)。\n - 外國礦工稅是[信號容器](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c26)的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28),[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)外國礦工時,內容不因人而變(結論六之四)。\n - 本案中,三種判準對應的[中斷](concepts.md#c10)時間不同:1884、1893、1910 年分別對應不同的[同一性條件](concepts.md#c02)(三之五、結論五之九)。\n7. **可說與推不出**:\n - 可說:礦區的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)經由河流[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)下游;礦區與原住民之間有大量[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10),其後許多原住民群體的[模式](concepts.md#c09)不再出現;判決之後,排沙入河的結構不再出現。\n - 推不出:任何一方的動機;礦區是否「為了」驅離原住民;若沒有淘金潮,原住民各群體會怎樣;判決是否「正確」。\n\n---\n\n## 十二、與既有理論的對照\n\n以下理論各自從不同途徑得到與本篇相近的結論。依本篇的方法,本系統若能推出它們的結論,即為對前提的支持;若有分歧,就表示有某一條前提或推導有待查明。\n\n| 理論 | 其結論 | 本篇對應 | 論證方式差異 |\n|---|---|---|---|\n| 〔Adam Smith〕 | 分工受市場範圍限制 | 結論四之二、五之二、五之八 | 以交換傾向與效率論證 |\n| 〔Leontief〕投入產出分析 | 各部門的產出互為投入,衝擊沿投入關係傳遞 | 結論七之三至七之七 | 以線性係數與量化模型建立 |\n| 〔Luhmann〕社會系統論 | 系統互為環境,自我生產 | 結論六之一、七之一 | 以溝通與功能為單位,需要「意義」 |\n| 〔Padgett〕與〔Powell〕 | 組織與市場起於自我催化網路;長期而言關係造就行動者 | 結論五之一、五之三、七之一 | 以模擬與歷史案例建立 |\n| 〔Brian Arthur〕複雜經濟學 | 經濟是自我建構的生態,技術互為環境 | 第六、七節;結論五之七、七之四 | 以歷史歸納與模型建立 |\n| 〔Hannan〕與〔Freeman〕組織生態學 | 新生劣勢,存活者經選擇留下 | 〇之四、結論五之六、十之一 | 以群體統計建立,帶有選擇的比喻 |\n| 〔Alchian〕(1950);〔Ferguson〕、〔Hayek〕 | 存活不需要理性或預見;秩序是人類行動而非設計的結果 | 結論五之四、十之一 | 以經濟學論證建立,仍保留「利潤」等目的性用語 |\n| 〔Pigou〕、〔Coase〕外部性 | 交易影響未參與交易的第三方 | 結論六之二、六之三 | 以成本與權利描述 |\n| 〔Wiener〕控制論;〔Maturana〕與〔Varela〕 | 回饋迴路;自我生產 | 結論五之一 | 以系統與功能描述 |\n| 恩格斯(1884)序言 | 生產有兩種:生活資料的生產與人自身的生產 | 結論八之一、八之二 | 以歷史唯物論與階段論建立 |\n| 〔Becker〕家庭經濟學 | 生育與養育可用經濟分析處理 | 第八節 | 以效用與選擇描述 |\n\n本篇的差異在於:全程不使用意圖、目的、功能、成本或意義,只用[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)、[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)、[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06)與研究者的判準。\n\n---\n\n## 十三、總命題\n\n在講明的[切法](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c23)下,生物人的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)可以[記錄](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c06)為[輸出圖集](concepts.md#c07),記在[人群圖](concepts.md#c05)上。其中被研究者依[存續判準](concepts.md#c01)追蹤、反覆出現的結構是[經濟模式](concepts.md#c09);凡有[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)參與者,其中每個[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)都有[小迴路](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c02),若某[路徑](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c07)屬於前提一所指的[路徑](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c07),且它在某[檢查窗口](concepts.md#c03)內實現,則必有其他[節點](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25)的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)供應[前件](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c08),是否算進[模式](concepts.md#c09),由研究者的[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)決定。[模式](concepts.md#c09)中[節點](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25)的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)可以經由[界面節點](concepts.md#c11)與[自然環境](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c16),成為其他[節點](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25)的[外界](concepts.md#c04),影響不以參與為條件。互相[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)、不共有參與[節點](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25)的[經濟模式](concepts.md#c09)之間互為[外界](concepts.md#c04);某[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)經由另一[模式](concepts.md#c09)中的[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)回到它自己時,構成跨[模式](concepts.md#c09)的[迴路](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c31);彼此之間可依判準辨認[共振](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c09)、[太極](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c39)與[失配](../paper_ae79e938_76e1_4bf9_b2ab_995c03e16c9e/concepts.md#c08),並經由[前件](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c08)判定使供應的中斷連鎖傳遞。[前件](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c08)的供應使[模式](concepts.md#c09)與供應它的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)之間有部分先後;若各生物人[節點](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25)都會[判準退場](../paper_96f10d75_23d0_441f_94c7_ab87ca28d284/concepts.md#c09),則凡以生物人為[節點](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25)的[模式](concepts.md#c09),其生物人[節點](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25)最終都來自生殖事件;這些事件被追蹤為[生殖模式](concepts.md#c12)(產出[子代](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c15)的[經濟模式](concepts.md#c09))時,它供應的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)若中斷,可沿[前件](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c08)的供應關係傳遞到依賴這些[節點](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25)的[模式](concepts.md#c09)。\n\n[經濟模式](concepts.md#c09)的形成,只能事後辨認;其延續與具體影響,在判準或[外界](concepts.md#c04)[節點](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25)取決於不被[鎖死](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c12)的[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)或[隨機源](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c27)時(結論五之四、六之六的條件),同樣不可事前唯一推出,只能逐[窗口](concepts.md#c03)判定;觀察到的[經濟模式](concepts.md#c09),都是到目前為止尚未[判準中斷](concepts.md#c10)者。所有權、制度、價格、貨幣、組織與市場等,需引入[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)才能推導,本篇尚未引入其前提,留待後續以本篇為底層推出。\n\n---\n\n## 附錄 用語對照\n\n| | 資料 | 傾向 | 結束 |\n|---|---|---|---|\n| 個體篇 | [記錄](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c06) | [輸出傾向](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c02) | [判準退場](../paper_96f10d75_23d0_441f_94c7_ab87ca28d284/concepts.md#c09) |\n| 本篇 | [輸出圖集](concepts.md#c07) | [格局傾向](concepts.md#c08) | [判準中斷](concepts.md#c10) |\n\n"},{"filename":"Dynamics of Output Patterns among Biological Humans.md","content":"---\nuuid: d244789a-9261-4a0d-a98a-feb8db56b511\nlast-modified: 2026-11-02T00:02:12\nauthor: 黃正宇 / Cheng Yu Huang\ncontact: mthree.tw@gmail.com\n---\n\n# Dynamics of Output Patterns among Biological Humans\n\n---\n\n## 0. Positioning and Method\n\n### 0.1 Positioning\n\n*Dynamics of Output Tendency in the Biological Human Individual* (hereafter the Individual paper) addresses the [output tendency](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c02) of a single biological human. This paper is its counterpart at the level of multiple biological humans. It addresses the structure of [arrival](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) among the [outputs](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) of multiple biological humans, that is, the **output pattern**: how recurring structures within it are identified, how they persist and [break](concepts.md#c10), and how these structures become one another's [exteriors](concepts.md#c04).\n\n### 0.2 Method\n\nThis paper uses the deductive method. Every conclusion states which definitions, premises or earlier conclusions it is derived from. Cases in the text serve only for calibration and carry no part of the argument.\n\n### 0.3 Scope of Records\n\nThis paper follows the scope of [records](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c06) used in *Production Dynamics*: only the physical changes of an [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) are registered, not the content of a [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18). A [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) remains in the [history](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13), but it is not in this paper's [records](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c06).\n\n### 0.4 Observational Premise\n\nThis paper takes [conditioning on existing samples](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c14) as its observational premise: every observed [economic mode](concepts.md#c09) is one that has passed every past [persistence criterion](concepts.md#c01). The study must also include [modes](concepts.md#c09) that have already undergone a [criterion break](concepts.md#c10) but still leave [records](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c06). Wherever the text later touches on \"survival\" or \"looking designed,\" it refers back to this item.\n\n### 0.5 Scope of Claims\n\nThis paper derives only two kinds of things: relations that necessarily hold by structure, and which things cannot be derived from which others. This paper does not predict which structures will become [economic modes](concepts.md#c09), how long an [economic mode](concepts.md#c09) will last, or in which direction their influence will go.\n\nAll conclusions in this paper hold only for finite observers within the [universe](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c02): the researcher and every [node](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25) are within the [universe](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c02), and no viewpoint stands outside the [universe](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c02). Wherever \"cannot be derived\" is said, it means that the researcher and every [node](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25) cannot derive it beforehand.\n\n### 0.6 Conventions\n\nEach conclusion is followed, in order, by:\n\n- **Source**: the parenthetical states which definitions, premises or conclusions it is derived from, supplying only the step newly added by this paper.\n- **Explanation**: the part newly derived in this paper, broken into derivation steps.\n- **Calibration**: the corresponding real-world phenomenon, for comparison only, carrying no part of the argument.\n\nWherever this paper says \"an [economic mode](concepts.md#c09) becomes an [exterior](concepts.md#c04),\" \"an [economic mode](concepts.md#c09) participates in [weight](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06),\" or \"an [economic mode](concepts.md#c09) enters [history](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13),\" these are researcher-level abbreviations: what actually [arrives](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10), enters [history](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13) and participates in [weight](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06) is the [outputs](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) of the [nodes](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25) in the [mode](concepts.md#c09). An [economic mode](concepts.md#c09) itself is the researcher's classification of these [outputs](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28); it is not a [node](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25).\n\n---\n\n## 1. Inheritance\n\nThe following concepts are used as defined in their original papers; this paper does not restate them.\n\n- ***Wo Dynamics***: [Universe](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c02), [Presentation](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c04), [Collapse](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c08), [Involvement](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c11), [Wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16), [Self](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19), [Arrival](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10), [Stimulus](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c30), [Writing](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c29), [History](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13), [Weight](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06), [Moment](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c09), [Lock-in](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c12), [Own Segment](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c17), [Law of the Black Box](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c25), [Distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18), [Individual](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c20).\n- ***Tools and Examples Related to the Four Laws*** (the Tools paper): [Cut](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c23), [Node](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25), [Edge](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c29), [Signal Container](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c26), [Random Source](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c27), [Output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28), [Loop](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c31), [Positive Feedback](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c32), [Coupling](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c36), [Divergence](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c38), [Taiji](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c39), [Exit](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c43), [Entry](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c44).\n- ***Triple Illusion and the Forced Wager***: [Second-Order Distinction](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c01), [View Attribution](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c02).\n- ***Interaction Dynamics - Second-Order Networks under a Common Exogenous Background*** (the Acquaintance paper): [Dedicated History](../paper_ae79e938_76e1_4bf9_b2ab_995c03e16c9e/concepts.md#c05), [Tacit Coordination](../paper_ae79e938_76e1_4bf9_b2ab_995c03e16c9e/concepts.md#c06), [Mismatch](../paper_ae79e938_76e1_4bf9_b2ab_995c03e16c9e/concepts.md#c08).\n- ***Interaction Dynamics - Changes and Updates of Dedicated History in Stranger Loops*** (the Stranger paper): [Natural Environment](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c16), [Small Loop](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c02), [Large Loop](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c03), [Reachable Subgraph](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c07), [Resonance](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c09), [Outcome Feedback](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c05), [Learning](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c04), [Template](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c14), [Order collapse](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c15), [Proportion of Failed Expectations](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c17).\n- ***Production Dynamics***: [Derivation Round](../paper_96f10d75_23d0_441f_94c7_ab87ca28d284/concepts.md#c07), [Criterion Exit](../paper_96f10d75_23d0_441f_94c7_ab87ca28d284/concepts.md#c09), [Production](../paper_96f10d75_23d0_441f_94c7_ab87ca28d284/concepts.md#c01).\n- **The Individual paper**: [Record](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c06), [Output Tendency](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c02), [Path](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c07), [Antecedent](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c08), [Threshold](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c03), [Feasible Set](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c11), [Offspring](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c15), [Conditioning on Existing Samples](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c14).\n\n---\n\n## 2. Premises\n\n**Premise 1**: If at least one [antecedent](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c08) in the [threshold](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c03) of some [path](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c07) can be satisfied only by the [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) of other [nodes](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25) [arriving](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10), then the feasibility of that [path](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c07) depends on the [outputs](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) of other [nodes](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25).\n\nExplanation: Premise 1 is a conditional and a scope setting; it is not an existence claim. If a research object has no [path](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c07) whose [antecedent](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c08) is satisfied in this way, this paper simply does not apply to it, and Premise 1 is not thereby refuted.\n\nCalibration: For biological humans, reproduction and rearing have no single-person [path](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c07), so the [antecedent](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c08) of Premise 1 holds at least for these two kinds of [paths](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c07). Reproduction needs a counterpart; an infant, when the criterion takes the physiological boundary, cannot persist without others' [outputs](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) (the criterion is set by the researcher). In a gold rush there is likewise no single-person [path](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c07); see 11.1.\n\n**Premise 2**: The [persistence criterion](concepts.md#c01) of an [economic mode](concepts.md#c09) is stated by the researcher and includes:\n1. **[Identity condition](concepts.md#c02)**: under what equivalence the structures in different [check windows](concepts.md#c03) count as the same one;\n2. **[Check window](concepts.md#c03)**: in which windows the structure is checked for whether it appears again.\n\nExplanation: Reality has no unified rounds, only the order of [outputs](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) and [arrivals](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10). A [derivation round](../paper_96f10d75_23d0_441f_94c7_ab87ca28d284/concepts.md#c07) is the researcher's segmentation of a sequence of [arrivals](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10), not a round in reality. Different [economic modes](concepts.md#c09) are each judged by their own [check windows](concepts.md#c03), and no common round is assumed; relations across [modes](concepts.md#c09) are [recorded](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c06) according to the order of [arrivals](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10).\n\nCalibration: A wrongly chosen [window](concepts.md#c03) leads to a wrong judgment, for example checking a farming [mode](concepts.md#c09) in winter.\n\n**Premise 3**: The [antecedent](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c08) of a [path](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c07) can be satisfied by the [arrival](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) of some [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28); this [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) may come from another [path](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c07) of the same [node](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25), or from other [nodes](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25).\n\nExplanation: Premise 3 is a possibility claim and a scope setting: it says only that this supply relation can hold, not that a given [path](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c07) is necessarily so. What Premise 1 discusses is the case within this supply where \"the [antecedent](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c08) can be supplied only by the [outputs](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) of other [nodes](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25).\"\n\nCalibration: The bones left by a hunt are the material [antecedent](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c08) of the later [path](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c07) of making a bone spear; the bones may be left behind by oneself in the previous round, or by companions.\n\n**Premise 4**: The [entry](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c44) of every biological human [node](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25) comes from some reproductive event: the [node](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25) is [offspring](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c15) produced by that event.\n\nExplanation: Premise 4 is a scope setting that concerns only biological human [nodes](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25) and does not touch other types of [nodes](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25).\n\nCalibration: People who immigrate from elsewhere were also produced by reproductive events elsewhere.\n\n**Premise 5**: The [paths](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c07) of a [reproductive mode](concepts.md#c12) have [antecedents](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c08) that can be supplied only by the [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) of the counterpart.\n\nExplanation: Premise 5 is a scope setting and a biological fact; it concerns only the [reproductive mode](concepts.md#c12) and does not touch other [modes](concepts.md#c09).\n\nCalibration: Reproduction requires at least two people and cannot be accomplished by one person alone.\n\n**Premise 6**: A [signal container](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c26) or [random source](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c27) participating in an [economic mode](concepts.md#c09) counts as lying within the range of the [reachable subgraph](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c07) of the [wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16) it serves.\n\nExplanation: Premise 6 is a scope setting. The definition of [reachable subgraph](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c07) admits only the [presentations](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c04) that send to the center; to cover containers used only by a [wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16), this paper counts the participating [signal containers](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c26) and [random sources](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c27) in as well.\n\nCalibration: An automated teller machine is not itself a [wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16), but it serves the bank and its customers, so it counts as within the range of their [reachable subgraphs](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c07).\n\n**Premise 7**: Whether an [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) [arrives](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at a given [node](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25) depends not only on that [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) but also on other parts of that [node](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25)'s [exterior](concepts.md#c04), such as the route, the weather and transport.\n\nExplanation: Premise 7 is an empirical premise. The definition of [arrival](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) says only that a [writing](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c29) counts as [arriving](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at some [presentation](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c04) when it lands on it as a [stimulus](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c30); it does not say what decides whether it lands. This paper lists this as a premise.\n\n---\n\n## 3. Definitions\n\n### 3.1 Exterior\n\n**[Exterior](concepts.md#c04)**: For a given [node](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25), every source of [arrival](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) other than itself, including other [nodes](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25) and the [natural environment](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c16).\n\n- The [exterior](concepts.md#c04) is relative to a [node](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25); change the [node](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25) and the [exterior](concepts.md#c04) differs. The size of a [node](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25) is set by the [cut](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c23); it can be a person or a company: when a company is taken as a [node](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25), its employees are inside it and its customers are its [exterior](concepts.md#c04).\n- In an [output graph](concepts.md#c06), everything outside the [cut](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c23) is the [exterior](concepts.md#c04) of that graph. The [natural environment](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c16) is not drawn separately on the graph; when a closer look is needed, the researcher enlarges the [cut](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c23).\n\n### 3.2 Population Graph, Output Graph and Output Graph Set\n\n**[Population graph](concepts.md#c05)**: Under a stated [cut](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c23), the static graph formed by biological human [nodes](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25) and the [edges](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c29) between them (the [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) of one [node](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25) participating in the [weight](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06) of another [node](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25)), plus each [node](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25)'s own [loop](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c31) (its own [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28), through itself, participating again in its own [weight](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06)). The [persistence criterion](concepts.md#c01) of a [population graph](concepts.md#c05) is stated by the researcher, in the same way as for an [economic mode](concepts.md#c09) (Premise 2).\n\n**[Output graph](concepts.md#c06)**: On the basis of a [population graph](concepts.md#c05), within a stated [cut](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c23), dimension and time window, the graph obtained by attaching [records](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c06) to the points and [edges](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c29): the points are the [nodes](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25) of the [population graph](concepts.md#c05), plus the [signal containers](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c26) and [random sources](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c27) within the [cut](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c23); the [edges](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c29) are the [edges](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c29) of the [population graph](concepts.md#c05), plus the [edges](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c29) between these [signal containers](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c26) or [random sources](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c27) and other [nodes](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25); the [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) [records](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c06) of each [node](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25) are attached to its point, the [records](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c06) of each [arrival](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) are attached to the [edge](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c29), or to the [node](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25)'s own [loop](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c31), and an [arrival](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) from the [exterior](concepts.md#c04) is attached to the receiving point; in addition, the researcher's judgment on whether the [antecedent](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c08) of some [path](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c07) of some [node](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25) is satisfied is attached, and it may be marked \"unknown.\" According to the Individual paper, this judgment is attached alongside the [records](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c06) and does not count as a [record](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c06). [Signal containers](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c26) and [random sources](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c27) within the [cut](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c23) are also [nodes](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25), and they are entered together with their [edges](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c29).\n\n**[Output graph set](concepts.md#c07)**: The set formed by the [output graphs](concepts.md#c06) of the various time windows, dimensions and scales within the same study.\n\nExplanation:\n\n- An [edge](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c29) does not distinguish [moments](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c09), and many [arrivals](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) may lie on one [edge](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c29); when the [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) of a biological human [node](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25) in the [population graph](concepts.md#c05) that is a [wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16) [arrives](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at itself, on the [population graph](concepts.md#c05) it is that [node](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25)'s own [loop](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c31).\n- The [output graph set](concepts.md#c07) is a subset of the [history](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13): [outputs](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) that are not registered, and [arrivals](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) of the kind \"did not happen to it,\" are not on the graph, but are still in the [history](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13) and still participate in the [weight](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06) of the [wos](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16) they [arrive](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at.\n\n### 3.3 Pattern Tendency\n\n**[Pattern tendency](concepts.md#c08)**: The researcher's generalization over structures that repeatedly appear in the [output graph set](concepts.md#c07), describing which kind of [output graph](concepts.md#c06) structure tends to appear under a stated [cut](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c23). It is a generalization made under the stated [cut](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c23), time window, classification rule and comparison conditions.\n\n- It parallels the [output tendency](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c02) of the Individual paper: an [output tendency](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c02) generalizes the [outputs](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) of one [individual](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c20), while a [pattern tendency](concepts.md#c08) generalizes the [output graph](concepts.md#c06) structures that recur in the [output graph set](concepts.md#c07).\n- A [pattern tendency](concepts.md#c08) belongs to no [node](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25) and is not a readout of any [node](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25)'s [weight](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06).\n- When restricted to a single [node](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25) and a single [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) type, where that [node](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25) is an [individual](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c20), it returns to that [individual](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c20)'s [output tendency](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c02).\n\n### 3.4 Economic Mode\n\n**[Economic mode](concepts.md#c09)**: A particular structure that, according to the [persistence criterion](concepts.md#c01) stated by the researcher (Premise 2), repeatedly appears across multiple [check windows](concepts.md#c03) of the [output graph set](concepts.md#c07).\n\n- **Identity depends on position, not on who**: structures in two [windows](concepts.md#c03) that are isomorphic under the stated equivalence count as the same [economic mode](concepts.md#c09). A change of participating [nodes](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25) does not necessarily change identity.\n- **Connected by [arrival](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)**: an [economic mode](concepts.md#c09) is a structure connected by [arrival](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10): there is [arrival](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) among the participating [nodes](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25), or between participating [nodes](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25) and the [exterior](concepts.md#c04). Grouping many mutually unconnected [modes](concepts.md#c09) under one name (for example, the catering industry) is a [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) of the researcher and is not one [economic mode](concepts.md#c09).\n- **It may involve only a single [node](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25)**, for example repeated [arrival](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) between one person and the [exterior](concepts.md#c04); it may also span [nodes](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25).\n- **Not limited to markets**: no distinction between [production](../paper_96f10d75_23d0_441f_94c7_ab87ca28d284/concepts.md#c01) and consumption, for-profit or not, with or without money. The name is only a [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) of the researcher and is given no independent ontology, the same as the treatment of \"[production](../paper_96f10d75_23d0_441f_94c7_ab87ca28d284/concepts.md#c01)\" in *Production Dynamics*.\n- **Distinction from [pattern tendency](concepts.md#c08)**: a [pattern tendency](concepts.md#c08) is a cross-graph generalization with no identity and no [break](concepts.md#c10); an [economic mode](concepts.md#c09) is a particular tracked structure, with identity, and can undergo a [criterion break](concepts.md#c10).\n- **Distinction from [resonance](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c09)**: [resonance](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c09) requires that multiple [nodes](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25) repeatedly connect compatibly under the condition of [arrival](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10); an [economic mode](concepts.md#c09) carries an [antecedent](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c08) judgment and a [window](concepts.md#c03)-by-[window](concepts.md#c03) [persistence criterion](concepts.md#c01), and may involve only a single [node](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25).\n- **Relation to [production](../paper_96f10d75_23d0_441f_94c7_ab87ca28d284/concepts.md#c01)**: on the dimension of [production](../paper_96f10d75_23d0_441f_94c7_ab87ca28d284/concepts.md#c01), the part of an [economic mode](concepts.md#c09) in which multiple [nodes](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25) repeatedly connect compatibly, and either [arrive](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at one another or share a common source that [arrives](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at all of them, is the case described by the definition of [resonance](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c09).\n\n### 3.5 Criterion Break\n\n**[Criterion break](concepts.md#c10)**: According to the [persistence criterion](concepts.md#c01) stated by the researcher, when a tracked structure (for example an [economic mode](concepts.md#c09) or a [population graph](concepts.md#c05)) fails to appear again within some [check window](concepts.md#c03), it is recorded as a [criterion break](concepts.md#c10). What counts as a [break](concepts.md#c10) is decided by the criterion.\n\n- The criterion is the researcher's definition; whether a [break](concepts.md#c10) occurs is a fact about that [window](concepts.md#c03). The two do not substitute for each other, with the same structure as [criterion exit](../paper_96f10d75_23d0_441f_94c7_ab87ca28d284/concepts.md#c09).\n- The criteria of [criterion break](concepts.md#c10), [order collapse](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c15), [exit](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c43) and [criterion exit](../paper_96f10d75_23d0_441f_94c7_ab87ca28d284/concepts.md#c09) differ, and they do not imply one another: a [mode](concepts.md#c09) can [break](concepts.md#c10) while order has not undergone [order collapse](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c15), and a participant can [exit](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c43) while the [mode](concepts.md#c09) has not [broken](concepts.md#c10).\n\n### 3.6 Interface Node\n\n**[Interface node](concepts.md#c11)**: A [node](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25) in an [economic mode](concepts.md#c09) whose [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) [arrives](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at the [exterior](concepts.md#c04).\n\n- Its type follows the upstream classification of [nodes](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25); it can be a [wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16), a [signal container](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c26) or a [random source](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c27).\n- The same [economic mode](concepts.md#c09) can have several kinds of [interface nodes](concepts.md#c11), and through different [interfaces](concepts.md#c11) the [exterior](concepts.md#c04) meets [arrival](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) sources of different character.\n\n---\n\n## 4. Reachable Subgraph: The Range of an Economic Mode\n\nFollowing the definition of [reachable subgraph](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c07), this section speaks entirely of [records](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c06) of what has **already [arrived](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)**. Beforehand, \"whom one may possibly contact\" belongs to the judgment of [antecedents](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c08) and does not belong to the [reachable subgraph](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c07).\n\n### 4.1 The Node Range of an Economic Mode\n\n**Conclusion 4.1**: Within some [check window](concepts.md#c03), if the [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) of A in some [economic mode](concepts.md#c09) [arrives](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at a [wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16) B, then A belongs to B's [reachable subgraph](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c07) in that [window](concepts.md#c03).\n\n(Derived from the definition of [reachable subgraph](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c07): the [presentations](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c04) whose [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) has [arrived](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at some [wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16), together with the [edges](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c29) between them, constitute its [reachable subgraph](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c07); only what has already [arrived](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) is counted)\n\n**Conclusion 4.2**: Within some [check window](concepts.md#c03), the participating [wos](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16) of a cross-[node](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25) [economic mode](concepts.md#c09) are each the center of their own [reachable subgraph](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c07); participating [signal containers](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c26) and [random sources](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c27) count as lying within the [reachable subgraph](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c07) of the [wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16) they serve. The range of an [economic mode](concepts.md#c09) does not exceed the range reached by [arrivals](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) that have occurred.\n\n(Derived from Conclusion 4.1, Premise 6 and the definition of [reachable subgraph](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c07))\n\nExplanation:\n1. Every participating [node](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25) of a cross-[node](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25) [economic mode](concepts.md#c09) has an [arrival](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) with at least one other participating [node](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25) or with the [exterior](concepts.md#c04); otherwise it is not in the same structure (the definition of [economic mode](concepts.md#c09)).\n2. By Conclusion 4.1, a [node](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25) that sends an [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) falls within the [reachable subgraph](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c07) of the receiving [wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16); each participating [wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16) is the center of its own [reachable subgraph](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c07) (the center counts as included).\n3. A [signal container](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c26) or [random source](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c27) is not a [wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16) and has no [reachable subgraph](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c07) of its own; by Premise 6, a participating one counts as within the range of the [reachable subgraph](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c07) of the [wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16) it serves.\n\nCalibration: A shop can sell only to people it can reach. Within the time window, a person with no [arrival](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at all with the shop's [interface node](concepts.md#c11) is not in this [economic mode](concepts.md#c09).\n\n### 4.2 Reachable Is Not Participating\n\n**Conclusion 4.3**: That a [node](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25) is in a [reachable subgraph](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c07) does not imply that it has [arrival](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) with the central [node](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25) on other dimensions.\n\n(Derived from the fact that a [reachable subgraph](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c07) must state its time window and that [arrivals](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) are [recorded](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c06) by dimension)\n\n**Conclusion 4.4**: That a [node](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25) is in a [reachable subgraph](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c07), even with [arrival](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) on the relevant dimension, does not imply that its [feasible set](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c11) contains a [path](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c07) whose [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) can be judged to be an [antecedent](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c08) needed by some [economic mode](concepts.md#c09).\n\n(Derived from the definitions of [antecedent](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c08) and [feasible set](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c11); whether an [antecedent](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c08) is satisfied is a judgment the researcher makes about a [path](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c07))\n\n**Conclusion 4.5**: Even if some [node](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25) can supply the corresponding [antecedent](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c08), it does not follow that it will [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) in the next [check window](concepts.md#c03).\n\n(Derived from the definition of [threshold](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c03): all [antecedents](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c08) being satisfied means only that the path is feasible, not that it will occur)\n\nTaken together, on the stated [economic mode](concepts.md#c09) and dimension:\n\n> [Nodes](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25) in the [reachable subgraph](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c07) ⊇ [nodes](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25) with [arrival](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) on that dimension ⊇ [nodes](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25) whose [antecedent](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c08) is judged able to be supplied ⊇ [nodes](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25) actually [outputting](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) in the [mode](concepts.md#c09)\n\nEach step inward adds one more condition; the last layer can only wait for the [records](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c06) afterward.\n\nCalibration: A person who knows a hundred people shows only that the first layer is large. How many of them do business with him, how many can supply what he needs, and how many in the end actually step forward are three other matters.\n\nAlso (Conclusion 4.4): In Granovetter's study in Newton, Massachusetts, of 54 people who found jobs through acquaintances, only 16.7% had often met that acquaintance beforehand (at least once a week), 55.6% met occasionally, and 27.8% rarely (less than once a year). Frequent meeting does not imply being the one who supplies job information.\n\n### 4.3 Changes in Arrival\n\n**Conclusion 4.6**: Whether the [arrival](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) of an [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) occurs depends not only on that [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) but also on the [exterior](concepts.md#c04). So even when the [output tendencies](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c02) of all [individuals](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c20) show no discernible change, the [reachable subgraph](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c07) may still change.\n\n(Derived from Premise 7 and the definition of [arrival](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10): a [writing](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c29) counts as [arriving](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at some [presentation](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c04) only when it lands on it as a [stimulus](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c30); whether it lands also depends on the [exterior](concepts.md#c04) (Premise 7))\n\nExplanation:\n1. An [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)'s [arrival](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at another party is conditioned on the [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) occurring and being able to land on the other party (the definition of [arrival](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)).\n2. Whether an [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) lands on the other party also depends on the other party's [exterior](concepts.md#c04) (Premise 7).\n3. So when the [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) is unchanged, a change in the [exterior](concepts.md#c04) may still cause [arrival](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) to occur or not occur; a [reachable subgraph](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c07) counts only what has already [arrived](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10), so when the set of [presentations](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c04) whose [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) has [arrived](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at the central [wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16) changes as a result, it changes accordingly.\n\nCalibration: A typhoon closes the port; the fishermen fish as usual, but the catch cannot reach the market in the city; the [reachable subgraph](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c07) between the fishermen and the city buyers shrank that week.\n\nAlso: On 23 March 2021 the *Ever Given* ran aground in the Suez Canal and was not freed until the 29th; during that time more than 430 ships waited at both ends, and about nine billion US dollars of goods were blocked each day. The [outputs](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) of sellers and buyers at both ends continued as before, but [arrival](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) did not occur.\n\n**Conclusion 4.7**: If the [identity condition](concepts.md#c02) of an [economic mode](concepts.md#c09) requires certain [arrivals](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) (lacking any one of them, it is not met), and these [arrivals](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) no longer occur within some [check window](concepts.md#c03), the [economic mode](concepts.md#c09) undergoes a [criterion break](concepts.md#c10) in that [window](concepts.md#c03). Conversely, the occurrence of new [arrivals](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) may cause a structure that had not appeared to appear.\n\n(Derived from the definitions of [economic mode](concepts.md#c09) and [criterion break](concepts.md#c10))\n\nCalibration: Roads, shipping and the internet expand the range of [arrival](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10); blockades, wars and epidemics shrink it. The appearance and [break](concepts.md#c10) of an [economic mode](concepts.md#c09) can be caused entirely by the [exterior](concepts.md#c04), without anyone's tendency having to change first; but whether a new structure really appears still depends on the [records](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c06).\n\nAlso: When the Erie Canal opened in 1825, the freight cost from New York to Buffalo fell from 90 US dollars per ton to 4 dollars, and the trip shortened from three weeks to 8 days; the freight [path](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c07) between the Great Lakes region and New York, previously infeasible, thereby entered the [feasible set](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c11).\n\n---\n\n## 5. The Formation of Economic Modes\n\n### 5.1 One Cycle\n\nWithin one [check window](concepts.md#c03) of some [economic mode](concepts.md#c09), the following process can be described on the basis of the upstream (this is a description, not a new definition):\n\n1. A participating [node](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25) [outputs](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28), and the [outputs](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) the researcher has specified for registration are [recorded](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c06);\n2. The [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) may [arrive](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at other [nodes](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25), at the [exterior](concepts.md#c04), or, through a [loop](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c31), at itself;\n3. The [outcome feedback](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c05) of each participating [wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16), if it [arrives](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) back at it, enters its [history](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13);\n4. This [history](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13) participates in each [wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)'s [weight](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06) at the next [moment](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c09), and this step is not necessarily readable;\n5. If these [wos](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16) have [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) in the next [check window](concepts.md#c03), it occurs under the [weights](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06) in which this [history](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13) participates.\n\nThis corresponds to the definition of [derivation round](../paper_96f10d75_23d0_441f_94c7_ab87ca28d284/concepts.md#c07): each [node](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25) present goes through one cycle of [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28), [arrival](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) and entering [history](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13); this paper adds two steps, [outcome feedback](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c05) and its participation in [weight](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06), and places the cycle on the [check window](concepts.md#c03) of an [economic mode](concepts.md#c09). This paper records the following: the process repeats [check window](concepts.md#c03) by [check window](concepts.md#c03); if no participating [node](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25) [outputs](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) in the next [check window](concepts.md#c03), the cycle stops at that [check window](concepts.md#c03); if a participating [node](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25) [outputs](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) again in a later [check window](concepts.md#c03), the cycle starts again; the cycle stopping is not the same as a [criterion break](concepts.md#c10), which is judged by the [persistence criterion](concepts.md#c01).\n\n### 5.2 Participating Wos Each Have a Small Loop\n\n**Conclusion 5.1**: In every [economic mode](concepts.md#c09) in which a [wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16) participates, each participating [wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16) has its own [small loop](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c02).\n\n(Derived from the definitions of [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28), [collapse](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c08), [weight](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06), [moment](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c09), [involvement](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c11), [arrival](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10), [wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16), [loop](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c31) and [small loop](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c02): the [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) of a [wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16) is the result of one of its own [collapses](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c08) ([output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)); the [collapse](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c08) result of a [presentation](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c04) is a result at that [presentation](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c04)'s next [moment](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c09) that depends on [weight](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06) and has non-zero [weight](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06) ([collapse](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c08), [moment](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c09)), that is, a result that falls on it with positive [weight](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06) ([weight](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06)), so this [collapse](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c08) [involves](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c11) it ([involvement](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c11)); when the [collapse](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c08) [involves](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c11) it, the result [arrives](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at it ([arrival](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)); whatever [arrives](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at it in its [history](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13) participates in its [weight](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06) at the next [moment](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c09) ([wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)); so its [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) passes through itself and participates again in its own [weight](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06), forming a [loop](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c31), that is, its [small loop](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c02))\n\nExplanation: A person satisfying oneself, interaction between two people and one-sided [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) are all included here. When a [wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16) gives one-sided [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28), even if there is no response at all, \"it did not happen to it\" at its later [moments](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c09) is by the definition of [arrival](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) also an [arrival](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10). So what needs case-by-case judgment is not \"whether there is a [loop](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c31)\" but \"which [loops](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c31) there are\": only a [small loop](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c02), a [large loop](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c03) as well, or forming a [taiji](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c39).\n\nCalibration: For a self-sufficient farming household, this year's harvest and farming experience return to next year's farming. A job application sent out without reply: the \"no reply\" also enters the applicant's [history](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13).\n\n### 5.3 The Supply of Antecedents Comes from Others\n\n**Conclusion 5.2**: If a [path](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c07) belongs to the [paths](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c07) referred to by Premise 1, and it is realized within some [check window](concepts.md#c03), then there must be the [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) of some other [node](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25) [arriving](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) that supplies its [antecedent](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c08). Whether the supplier is counted into the same [economic mode](concepts.md#c09) (the [mode](concepts.md#c09) spans [nodes](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25)) or counted as the [exterior](concepts.md#c04) of the [mode](concepts.md#c09) is a [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) of the researcher.\n\n(Derived from Premise 1, and from the definitions of [feasible set](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c11) and [antecedent](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c08))\n\nExplanation:\n1. A [path](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c07) being realized means it is feasible in that [window](concepts.md#c03) and every [antecedent](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c08) in its [threshold](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c03) is satisfied (the definition of [threshold](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c03)).\n2. By Premise 1, at least one of those [antecedents](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c08) is satisfied only by the [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) of another [node](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25) [arriving](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10).\n3. So the [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) of some other [node](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25) must have [arrived](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) (in that [window](concepts.md#c03), or earlier).\n\nCalibration: One person cannot kill an elephant; it takes two or three people striking at the same time. For the [path](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c07) of \"bringing down the elephant,\" each person's [antecedents](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c08) include others striking at the same time, so if the researcher counts the companions' strikes into the hunting [mode](concepts.md#c09), the hunting [mode](concepts.md#c09) spans [nodes](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25).\n\n### 5.4 Correction and Prediction\n\n**Conclusion 5.3**: The [outcome feedback](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c05) of each [check window](concepts.md#c03) may change the later [weight](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06) of the participating [wos](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16); if these [wos](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16) have [outputs](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) that are not [locked in](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c12) in the next [check window](concepts.md#c03), these [outputs](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) may differ accordingly; but the change has no preset direction and does not guarantee being more favorable to the continuation of the [mode](concepts.md#c09).\n\n(Derived from the definitions of [learning](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c04), [outcome feedback](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c05), [collapse](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c08), [lock-in](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c12) and [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28): [outcome feedback](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c05) is the later interaction in which a [wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)'s later [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) [arrives](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) back at itself; [learning](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c04) is the process in which [arriving](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) material may change later [weight](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06), and is a result condition, does not point to a purpose, has no preset direction, and guarantees neither that something is learned nor that it is learned correctly; the result of a [collapse](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c08) depends on [weight](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06), and an [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) is such a result; when something is not [locked in](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c12) at some [moment](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c09), it is not the case that only one result of its next [moment](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c09) has non-zero [weight](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06))\n\nCalibration: A stall owner is complained about as too expensive; next week he may lower prices, or change to a different batch of customers, or simply not set up; lowering prices also does not guarantee that business gets better.\n\n**Conclusion 5.4**: If whether an [economic mode](concepts.md#c09) appears again under the [persistence criterion](concepts.md#c01) (Premise 2) depends on the [outputs](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) of [wos](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16) or [random sources](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c27) that are not [locked in](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c12) (that is, different possible results of these [outputs](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) would make the criterion give different verdicts), and these [nodes](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25) have [moments](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c09) within that [check window](concepts.md#c03) at which they are not [locked in](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c12), then whether it undergoes a [criterion break](concepts.md#c10) in the next [check window](concepts.md#c03) cannot be derived beforehand; the past [proportion of failed expectations](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c17) is only an outward statistic and cannot stand in for [weight](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06). If the criterion depends only on the contents of a [signal container](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c26) that is [locked in](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c12), this conclusion does not apply, and whether a [break](concepts.md#c10) occurs can be judged from the container's contents.\n\n(Derived from the definitions of the [Law of the Black Box](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c25), [random source](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c27) and [proportion of failed expectations](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c17): when a [wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16) is not [locked in](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c12) at some [moment](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c09), no [wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16) in the [universe](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c02) can uniquely derive its next [moment](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c09) beforehand; what can be derived is the [weight](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06), not the result; when a [random source](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c27) is not [locked in](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c12), likewise only [weight](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06) can be discussed; the [proportion of failed expectations](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c17) is not a readout of the true [weight](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06). This paper adds: the reappearance of an [economic mode](concepts.md#c09) depends on the [outputs](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) involved in the criterion, and whether these [outputs](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) [arrive](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) may also depend on the [exterior](concepts.md#c04) (Conclusion 4.6), so when the criterion depends on these [outputs](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28), whether a [criterion break](concepts.md#c10) occurs cannot be derived beforehand)\n\nCalibration: Most newly opened shops close within a few years, and at opening one cannot tell which will remain; for a shop that does remain, one also cannot derive from how well it has done in the past that it will still be there next year.\n\nAlso: The US Bureau of Labor Statistics tracked private establishments newly established in March 2013: 79.6% were still operating one year later, 50.6% after five years and 34.7% after ten. The proportion can be tallied afterward, but which ones will remain cannot be derived at opening.\n\n**Conclusion 5.5**: Even with a complete [output graph set](concepts.md#c07), the [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) of a [wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16) or [random source](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c27) in the next [window](concepts.md#c03) when it is not [locked in](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c12) cannot be derived.\n\n(Derived from 3.2, and from the definitions of [wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16), [random source](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c27) and [Law of the Black Box](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c25))\n\nExplanation:\n1. The [output graph set](concepts.md#c07) is a subset of the [history](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13) (3.2).\n2. The [weight](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06) of a [wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16) depends on the entire [history](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13) that has [arrived](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at it, including the part outside the [graph set](concepts.md#c07) (the definition of [wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)).\n3. Even if the [weight](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06) is known, when a [wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16) is not [locked in](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c12) only the [weight](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06) can be derived, not the result ([Law of the Black Box](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c25)); when a [random source](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c27) is not [locked in](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c12), likewise only [weight](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06) can be discussed (the definition of [random source](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c27)).\n\nCalibration: A platform holding all transaction records still misjudges demand in the next quarter.\n\nAlso: During the pandemic, Amazon roughly doubled its logistics network in about two years; its chief executive said that in early 2021 the company decided to plan for the high end of demand forecasts; by 2022, according to estimates by the consulting firm MWPVL, it had closed or cancelled 42 facilities, about 25 million square feet.\n\n### 5.5 \"Formation\" Is Not a Moment\n\n**Conclusion 5.6**: A structure becoming an [economic mode](concepts.md#c09) can only be recognized by the researcher after the fact, once it has appeared in multiple [check windows](concepts.md#c03); there is no \"moment of formation\" that can be identified beforehand.\n\n(Derived from the definition of [economic mode](concepts.md#c09); isomorphic to the statement in the definition of [resonance](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c09) that \"whether it is [resonance](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c09) can only be said after the fact\")\n\nExplanation: The answer to \"how does an [economic mode](concepts.md#c09) form\" is: structures keep appearing, most do not appear again; those that do appear again are called [economic modes](concepts.md#c09) after the fact.\n\nCalibration: Someone set up a stall once on an empty lot, and most people did not come again; later someone came every week, and only then did people call the place a night market. No one can say on which day the night market \"formed.\"\n\n### 5.6 The Feasible Set Changes with the Mode\n\n**Conclusion 5.7**: After the [outcome feedback](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c05) of some [check window](concepts.md#c03) of an [economic mode](concepts.md#c09) [arrives](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at a participating [wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16), the [feasible set](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c11) of that [wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16) in later [derivation rounds](../paper_96f10d75_23d0_441f_94c7_ab87ca28d284/concepts.md#c07) may change: a [path](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c07) that originally had an unsatisfied [antecedent](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c08) may become satisfied and enter the [feasible set](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c11); a [path](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c07) that was originally feasible may also drop out.\n\n(Derived from Premise 3 and the definitions of [feasible set](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c11) and [derivation round](../paper_96f10d75_23d0_441f_94c7_ab87ca28d284/concepts.md#c07): an [antecedent](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c08) can be satisfied by the [arrival](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) of an [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28), and an [antecedent](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c08) varies with [history](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13), so the [feasible set](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c11) may vary with rounds. This paper adds: in a [mode](concepts.md#c09) spanning [nodes](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25), the [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) that supplies an [antecedent](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c08) may come from other participating [nodes](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25))\n\nExplanation:\n1. [Outcome feedback](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c05) enters the [history](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13) of the participating [wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16) (step 3 of 5.1, and the definition of [outcome feedback](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c05)).\n2. An [antecedent](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c08) may vary with [history](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13) (Premise 3), so whether the [threshold](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c03) of each [path](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c07) is satisfied, and the [feasible set](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c11), may change accordingly.\n3. By Premise 1, if an [antecedent](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c08) can be satisfied only by the [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) of other [nodes](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25) [arriving](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10), then in a [mode](concepts.md#c09) spanning [nodes](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25), if the researcher counts such [outputs](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) into the [mode](concepts.md#c09) (Conclusion 5.2), the reappearance of the [mode](concepts.md#c09) may supply some participating [nodes](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25) with an [antecedent](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c08) they originally lacked.\n4. A change in the [feasible set](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c11) does not imply that the new [path](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c07) will be taken (the definition of [threshold](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c03): all [antecedents](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c08) being satisfied means only feasibility, not that it will occur); nor does it imply that the change favors the continuation of the [mode](concepts.md#c09) (Conclusion 5.3).\n\nCalibration: Only after a successful hunt leaves bones is the material [antecedent](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c08) of the [path](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c07) \"making a bone spear\" satisfied; if someone makes a bone spear, the next hunt has one more [path](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c07). But it may also be that no one makes one, or that what is made does not work well.\n\n**Conclusion 5.8**: If a [path](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c07) whose [antecedent](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c08) is the [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) of a [node](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25) in the [mode](concepts.md#c09) is realized repeatedly, the researcher may, according to the stated [identity condition](concepts.md#c02), judge it a part of the original [mode](concepts.md#c09) or another [economic mode](concepts.md#c09); neither way of judging changes the [arrival](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) itself.\n\n(Derived from 3.4 and Premise 2)\n\nExplanation: What is said afterward as \"refinement,\" \"differentiation\" or \"from coarse to fine\" is the researcher's [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) of this kind of [path](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c07), isomorphic to Conclusion 5.6, not something the [mode](concepts.md#c09) grows by itself.\n\nCalibration: In a hunting party, someone stops going out to hunt and handles the game at camp; the [antecedent](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c08) of her [path](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c07) is the game the hunters bring back. The researcher may call it the logistics of the hunting [mode](concepts.md#c09), or may set up a separate \"game processing\" [mode](concepts.md#c09).\n\n**Conclusion 5.9**: If the [identity condition](concepts.md#c02) is stated on the result category, a structure realized through different [paths](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c07) in different [windows](concepts.md#c03) that achieves the same result category can still count as the same [economic mode](concepts.md#c09), and a replacement of [paths](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c07) does not by itself constitute a [criterion break](concepts.md#c10); if stated on the [path](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c07) with no other [path](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c07) allowed in its place, a replacement constitutes a [criterion break](concepts.md#c10).\n\n(Derived from Premise 2 and 3.4: the [identity condition](concepts.md#c02) is stated by the researcher and can be stated on the result category or on the [path](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c07); corresponding to Conclusion 7.6)\n\nCalibration: For the same \"A got something to eat this week,\" whether by gathering oneself, exchanging with others, or relatives' support, a criterion stated on the result gives one [mode](concepts.md#c09), and stated on the [path](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c07), with the three ways not substituting for one another, gives three.\n\n---\n\n## 6. Economic Modes Becoming Exterior\n\nAn [economic mode](concepts.md#c09) is not itself a [node](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25). Saying that it \"becomes an [exterior](concepts.md#c04)\" means that the [outputs](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) of [nodes](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25) in the [mode](concepts.md#c09) [arrive](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at [nodes](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25) outside the [mode](concepts.md#c09) (see 0.6).\n\n### 6.1 Two Routes\n\n**Conclusion 6.1 (through an [interface node](concepts.md#c11))**: When the [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) of an [interface node](concepts.md#c11) of an [economic mode](concepts.md#c09) [arrives](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at a [node](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25) outside the [mode](concepts.md#c09), these [outputs](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) become part of the [exterior](concepts.md#c04) of those [nodes](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25).\n\n(Derived from the definitions of [interface node](concepts.md#c11) and [exterior](concepts.md#c04))\n\nCalibration: A bank teller in town says \"yes\" or \"no\" to someone coming to borrow money; those words are the borrower's [exterior](concepts.md#c04).\n\n**Conclusion 6.2 (through the [natural environment](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c16))**: When the [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) of a [node](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25) in an [economic mode](concepts.md#c09) [arrives](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at the [natural environment](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c16), and the changed part later [arrives](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at other [wos](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16), these [outputs](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) indirectly participate in the [weight](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06) of those [wos](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16); even if there is no [arrival](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) between [node](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25) and [node](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25) on the two sides.\n\n(Derived from the definitions of [arrival](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10), [natural environment](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c16) and [wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16))\n\nExplanation:\n1. A [presentation](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c04) is any part of the [universe](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c02), and the parts of the [natural environment](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c16) are also [presentations](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c04); the [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) of a [mode](concepts.md#c09)'s [node](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25) is the result of a [collapse](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c08), and if that [collapse](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c08) [involves](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c11) some part of the [natural environment](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c16), this [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) [arrives](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at that part (the definitions of [presentation](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c04), [natural environment](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c16), [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28), [involvement](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c11) and [arrival](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)).\n2. The [natural environment](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c16) is the part that belongs to no [node](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25) yet has [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) [arriving](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at [nodes](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25) (the definition of [natural environment](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c16)), so its changed part can [arrive](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at other [nodes](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25).\n3. What [arrives](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at other [wos](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16) enters the [history](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13) of those [wos](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16) and participates in their later [weight](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06) (the definition of [wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)).\n4. In the chain of 1 to 3 there is no [arrival](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) from any [node](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25) to a [node](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25).\n\nCalibration: Nitrogen fertilizer from farmland in the American Midwest flows with the Mississippi River into the sea, and a large hypoxic zone appears in the Gulf of Mexico every summer, changing the catch of the local shrimping industry. The farmers and the fishers have never been in contact with each other.\n\n### 6.2 Influence Does Not Require Participation\n\n**Conclusion 6.3**: Even if a [wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16) does not participate in some [economic mode](concepts.md#c09), as long as the [outputs](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) of [nodes](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25) in the [mode](concepts.md#c09) [arrive](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at it by any route, these [outputs](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) participate in its later [weight](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06).\n\n(Derived from the definitions of [edge](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c29) and [wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16): the [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) of one [node](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25) participates in the [weight](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06) of another [node](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25) ([edge](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c29)); the entire [history](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13) that [has arrived](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at a [wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16) participates in its [weight](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06) at the next [moment](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c09) ([wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)). This paper adds: the routes of [arrival](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) include the two of Conclusions 6.1 and 6.2)\n\nCalibration: When a bank opens in town, people who do not open accounts there are also affected, for example neighbors starting to borrow money to do business, and land prices changing. Participants are only a small part of those affected.\n\n### 6.3 Types of Interface\n\n**Conclusion 6.4**: An [exterior](concepts.md#c04) [node](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25) meets [arrival](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) sources of different character through different types of [interface node](concepts.md#c11):\n\n- **Through a [wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)**: the [arrival](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) comes from a [node](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25) whose [weight](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06) changes with [history](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13), so the same request may get different responses; if both are a [self](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19) and each one's [outputs](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) [arrive](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at the other in a stated dimension, they can accumulate a [dedicated history](../paper_ae79e938_76e1_4bf9_b2ab_995c03e16c9e/concepts.md#c05) and may form [tacit coordination](../paper_ae79e938_76e1_4bf9_b2ab_995c03e16c9e/concepts.md#c06);\n- **Through a [signal container](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c26)**: if a [locked-in](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c12) [signal container](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c26) lists [templates](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c14), they do not change by themselves and provide a fixed point, obtainable without first having [resonance](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c09); a container is not a [self](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19), so it cannot form a [dedicated history](../paper_ae79e938_76e1_4bf9_b2ab_995c03e16c9e/concepts.md#c05) or [tacit coordination](../paper_ae79e938_76e1_4bf9_b2ab_995c03e16c9e/concepts.md#c06) with it;\n- **Through a [random source](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c27)**: when the [random source](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c27) is not [locked in](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c12), only the [weight](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06) of its own result can be spoken of; the [random source](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c27) is not a [wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16), hence not a [self](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19), so no [dedicated history](../paper_ae79e938_76e1_4bf9_b2ab_995c03e16c9e/concepts.md#c05) or [tacit coordination](../paper_ae79e938_76e1_4bf9_b2ab_995c03e16c9e/concepts.md#c06) can be formed with it.\n\n(Derived from the definition of [interface node](concepts.md#c11), and from the definitions of [wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16), [self](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19), [signal container](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c26), [random source](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c27), [dedicated history](../paper_ae79e938_76e1_4bf9_b2ab_995c03e16c9e/concepts.md#c05) and [tacit coordination](../paper_ae79e938_76e1_4bf9_b2ab_995c03e16c9e/concepts.md#c06))\n\nCalibration: The same bank is two different kinds of [exterior](concepts.md#c04) to a teller and to an ATM: the teller may be accommodating today and not tomorrow; the ATM follows the rules every time, but will not remember you either.\n\n### 6.4 Other Dimensions of Participants\n\n**Conclusion 6.5**: When the [outcome feedback](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c05) of an [economic mode](concepts.md#c09) [arrives](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at a participating [wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16), what it takes part in is its entire [weight](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06) distribution, not limited to the dimension delimited by the researcher. So that [outcome feedback](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c05) may participate in its [outputs](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) on other dimensions.\n\n(Derived from the definition of [wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16), the definition of [outcome feedback](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c05) and the definition of [own segment](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c17))\n\nExplanation:\n1. The [weight](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06) of a [wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16) depends on the entire [history](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13) that has [arrived](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at it (the definition of [wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)).\n2. The [own segment](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c17) is determined by dependence and not by any [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) (the definition of [own segment](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c17)); the dimension is the researcher's [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18).\n3. So a piece of [outcome feedback](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c05) participates in the entire [weight](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06) distribution and is not limited by the dimension the researcher draws.\n\nCalibration: Working at a bank changes more than the [outputs](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) at work; household finances and spending habits may change too, or no change may be visible.\n\n### 6.5 The Direction of Influence\n\n**Conclusion 6.6**: After the [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) of a [node](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25) in the [mode](concepts.md#c09) [arrives](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at an [exterior](concepts.md#c04) [node](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25), if the [exterior](concepts.md#c04) [node](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25) is a [wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16) or [random source](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c27) and is not [locked in](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c12) at the [moment](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c09) just before its next [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28), then its next [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) cannot be uniquely derived beforehand, and what can be derived is only the [weight](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06) of each result; unless all results with nonzero [weight](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06) point in the same direction, the direction of influence cannot be derived either.\n\n(Derived from the definitions of the [Law of the Black Box](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c25) and [random source](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c27): when not [locked in](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c12), only [weight](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06) can be discussed, not results)\n\nCalibration: A convenience store opens at the street corner; some people start eating late-night snacks, some carry on as before, and some therefore close their own grocery stores; before the opening, no one can say who will change how.\n\n---\n\n## 7. Economic Modes as Each Other's Exterior\n\n### 7.1 A Cross-Mode Loop Forms When Output Returns to Itself through Another Mode\n\n**Conclusion 7.1**: If the [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) of a participating [wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16) in [economic mode](concepts.md#c09) A [arrives](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at a participating [wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16) of B, and the later [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) of that [wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16) in B, or of other [wos](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16) in B connected to it by [arrival](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10), in turn [arrives](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at that [wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16) of A, and none of these [wos](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16) belongs to both A and B, then A and B are part of each other's [exterior](concepts.md#c04); the [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) of that [wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16) passes through B, returns to its own [history](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13) and participates in its own later [weight](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06). Under these conditions, A and B together form a cross-[mode](concepts.md#c09) [loop](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c31).\n\n(Derived from Conclusions 6.1, 6.2 and 6.3, and from the definitions of [wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16), [loop](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c31) and [outcome feedback](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c05))\n\nCalibration: A bank lends to a merchant, and the merchant's revenue flows back to the bank. The bank and the merchant are each a [mode](concepts.md#c09), and together they form a larger [loop](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c31).\n\n### 7.2 Relations of Being Each Other's Exterior\n\nIf there is [arrival](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) between A and B, the researcher may, under a stated dimension, time window and compatibility criterion, identify the following relations according to the upstream definitions:\n\n- **[Resonance](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c09)**: the [outputs](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) of the participating [nodes](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25) of A and B repeatedly connect compatibly.\n- **[Taiji](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c39)**: A and B each contain a [positive feedback](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c32) [loop](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c31) in some direction, in opposite directions, [coupled](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c36) to each other and [diverging](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c38) within the [coupling](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c36). By Conclusion 5.1, in any [mode](concepts.md#c09) in which a [wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16) participates each [wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16) has a [small loop](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c02), so it must still be determined whether there is a [positive feedback](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c32) [loop](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c31) in it, whether the directions are opposite, and whether they [diverge](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c38).\n- **[Mismatch](../paper_ae79e938_76e1_4bf9_b2ab_995c03e16c9e/concepts.md#c08)**: adjacent [outputs](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) between the [nodes](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25) concerned are incompatible under the stated criterion.\n\n**Conclusion 7.2**: [Resonance](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c09) and [taiji](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c39) can coexist, so the two are not mutually exclusive; relations other than [resonance](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c09), [taiji](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c39) and [mismatch](../paper_ae79e938_76e1_4bf9_b2ab_995c03e16c9e/concepts.md#c08) are not excluded by this paper.\n\n(Derived from the definitions of [resonance](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c09) and [taiji](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c39): [resonance](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c09) requires repeated compatible connection under the condition of [arrival](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10), while [taiji](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c39) requires [positive feedback](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c32) [loops](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c31) in opposite directions to be [coupled](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c36) and [diverge](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c38); the two criteria differ, so a [taiji](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c39) with opposite directions may still connect compatibly in sequence)\n\nCalibration: Two rival chain stores fight a price war that grows fiercer, and this is [taiji](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c39); at the same time, their trucks stagger their deliveries on the same road every day, connecting compatibly on the dimension of traffic.\n\nAlso: In 1975 Pepsi launched the \"Pepsi Challenge\" blind taste test; on 23 April 1985 Coca-Cola announced a changed formula and introduced \"New Coke\", and on 11 July of the same year, under strong consumer backlash, announced the return of the original formula. The [outputs](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) of each side took the other as reference; if the researcher judges that the two each contain [positive feedback](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c32) [loops](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c31) in opposite directions that [diverge](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c38) within the [coupling](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c36), this meets the criterion of [taiji](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c39), which requires the dimension and the data to be stated separately.\n\n### 7.3 The Supply and Order of Antecedents\n\n**Conclusion 7.3**: If an [antecedent](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c08) of some [path](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c07) of A can be satisfied only by the [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) of a [node](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25) in B [arriving](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10), then that [path](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c07) is feasible only after the corresponding [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) of B has [arrived](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10).\n\n(Derived from the definition of [threshold](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c03) and Premise 3: if any [antecedent](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c08) is not satisfied, the [path](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c07) is not feasible in that round; an [antecedent](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c08) can be satisfied by the [arrival](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) of an [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) (Premise 3), so when an [antecedent](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c08) can be supplied only by the [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) of a [node](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25) in B, the [path](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c07) is feasible only after the corresponding [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) has [arrived](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10). This paper adds: the order can cross [modes](concepts.md#c09))\n\n**Conclusion 7.4**: So if an [antecedent](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c08) of some [path](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c07) of A can be supplied only by the [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) of a [node](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25) in B, and A's [identity condition](concepts.md#c02) requires this [path](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c07) and allows no substitute, then A can appear only after B's corresponding [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) has [arrived](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10); from the supply relations of [antecedents](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c08), a partial order can be drawn between an [economic mode](concepts.md#c09) and the [outputs](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) that supply it. But the [arrival](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) of B's corresponding [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) does not imply that A will appear.\n\n(Derived from Conclusion 7.3 and the definition of [threshold](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c03): satisfied [antecedents](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c08) mean only feasibility, not that it will occur; for the second half see also Conclusion 4.5)\n\nExplanation:\n1. If A's [identity condition](concepts.md#c02) requires the [path](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c07) above (allowing no other [path](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c07) in its place), then for A to appear that [path](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c07) must be realized, so the corresponding [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) of B must first [arrive](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10).\n2. This gives only a partial order: where there is no supply relation, no order can be drawn from supply relations.\n\nCalibration: Only with cold-chain transport can a sashimi shop appear inland; but a city that has a cold chain does not necessarily have anyone opening a sashimi shop.\n\nAlso: On 15 February 1882 the refrigerated ship *Dunedin* left Port Chalmers, New Zealand, carrying about five thousand frozen sheep carcasses, and arrived in London in late May; the frozen meat trade began there and later became the core of New Zealand's twentieth-century economy. A sheep-farming [mode](concepts.md#c09) whose output is frozen-mutton export, and whose [identity condition](concepts.md#c02) allows no other [path](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c07) in its place, could appear only after refrigerated transport.\n\n### 7.4 The Chain of Supply Interruption\n\n**Conclusion 7.5**: If the [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) of a [node](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25) in B, through [arrival](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10), is judged to be an [antecedent](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c08) of some [path](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c07) of A, and that [antecedent](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c08) stays satisfied only while this [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) keeps [arriving](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10), then when that [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) no longer [arrives](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10), that [antecedent](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c08) is no longer supplied by B; if there is no substitute source, the corresponding [path](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c07) of A is not feasible.\n\n(Derived from the definition of [threshold](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c03): if any [antecedent](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c08) is not satisfied, the [path](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c07) is not feasible in that round; when that [antecedent](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c08) stays satisfied only while the [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) of a [node](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25) in B keeps [arriving](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10), and the [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) no longer [arrives](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10), it is no longer supplied by B)\n\n**Conclusion 7.6**: That some [path](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c07) of A is not feasible does not imply that A undergoes a [criterion break](concepts.md#c10). Whether A [breaks](concepts.md#c10) in a given [check window](concepts.md#c03) depends on whether a structure meeting A's [identity condition](concepts.md#c02) actually appears again within that [window](concepts.md#c03); that some [path](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c07) is not feasible does not by itself determine this.\n\n(Derived from the definitions of [economic mode](concepts.md#c09), [criterion break](concepts.md#c10), [identity condition](concepts.md#c02) and [check window](concepts.md#c03))\n\n**Conclusion 7.7**: A chain can be transmitted over multiple segments, and can also be transmitted through the [natural environment](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c16).\n\n(Derived from the repeated application of Conclusion 7.5, and from Conclusion 6.2)\n\nExplanation: 7.3 says a [path](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c07) can become feasible only after the supply has [arrived](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10); this subsection says a [path](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c07) is not feasible when supply is interrupted and there is no substitute source; the two are two sides of the same relation.\n\nCalibration: A bank fails, and one [path](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c07) of a merchant who relies on loans is not feasible; but the merchant may borrow from relatives instead, and the [mode](concepts.md#c09) continues all the same. An upstream reservoir stops releasing water, downstream irrigation is cut off, and the processing plants that rely on downstream farm produce may then run short of materials. A chain explains the entanglement of [antecedents](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c08), not the inevitability of a [break](concepts.md#c10).\n\nAlso (Conclusions 7.5, 7.6): In 1860 about eighty percent of the raw cotton imported by Britain came from the United States. During the American Civil War the North blockaded the South's ports, and from 1861 to 1865 Lancashire suffered a cotton famine, with many workers unemployed and dependent on relief. The textile mills switched to Surat cotton from India and to Egyptian cotton, but Surat cotton had short, brittle fibers and looms produced only about forty percent of their former output; after imports resumed in 1864, employment returned to normal. The supply interruption was transmitted to the textile industry (7.5), yet the textile [mode](concepts.md#c09) continued through [paths](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c07) using Indian and Egyptian cotton and underwent no [criterion break](concepts.md#c10) (7.6).\n\nAlso (Conclusion 7.7): The 2011 Tohoku earthquake damaged Renesas Electronics' Naka plant. Renesas then supplied about twenty percent of the world's automotive microcontrollers, and the worst case estimated by the market after the earthquake was a reduction in global automobile production of 7.5 to 11 million vehicles; this was the estimate at the time, not the actual reduction.\n\n### 7.5 Overall Conclusion\n\n**Conclusion 7.8**: Under a stated [cut](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c23), the structures in the [output graph set](concepts.md#c07) recorded on the [population graph](concepts.md#c05) can be described as two parts:\n\n1. **A group of [economic modes](concepts.md#c09)**: the [outputs](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) of [nodes](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25) in the [modes](concepts.md#c09) can become the [exterior](concepts.md#c04) of other [nodes](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25) through [interface nodes](concepts.md#c11) and the [natural environment](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c16); [modes](concepts.md#c09) that [arrive](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at each other and share no participating [node](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25) are each other's [exterior](concepts.md#c04); when the [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) of some [wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16) returns to it through a [wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16) in another [mode](concepts.md#c09), this forms a cross-[mode](concepts.md#c09) [loop](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c31); among them [resonance](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c09), [taiji](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c39) and [mismatch](../paper_ae79e938_76e1_4bf9_b2ab_995c03e16c9e/concepts.md#c08) can be identified by criteria; the supply of [antecedents](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c08) gives a partial order between a [mode](concepts.md#c09) and the [outputs](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) that supply it, and interruptions of supply are transmitted in a chain as judged through [antecedents](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c08).\n2. **Untracked [outputs](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)**: structures in the [output graph set](concepts.md#c07) not tracked by the researcher as [economic modes](concepts.md#c09), including those that appear only once and those that appear repeatedly but are not tracked by the researcher, as well as those the researcher has begun to watch but that have not yet recurred and so are not yet [economic modes](concepts.md#c09). They do not constitute [economic modes](concepts.md#c09), but they are still in the [history](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13) and still participate in the [weight](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06) of the [wos](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16) they [arrive](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at.\n\n(Derived from the definitions and conclusions of Sections 3 to 7)\n\nExplanation: By Conclusion 5.6, every [economic mode](concepts.md#c09), when it first appears, is not yet an [economic mode](concepts.md#c09). So [economic modes](concepts.md#c09) all come from structures that are not yet [economic modes](concepts.md#c09); whether the researcher tracks one from its first appearance does not change this.\n\nCalibration: The people of a country eat lunch every day, and the researcher groups the structures of restaurants and customers that recur into the catering industry; this is the researcher's [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18). Breathing every day also recurs, but if the researcher does not track it, it does not constitute an [economic mode](concepts.md#c09) and belongs to the second part; one day someone sells lunch boxes at their front door just once, which does not constitute an [economic mode](concepts.md#c09), but the next lunch of those who bought one may differ because of it.\n\n---\n\n## 8. Reproductive Modes\n\n**[Reproductive mode](concepts.md#c12)**: An [economic mode](concepts.md#c09) whose output is [offspring](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c15). This is not a new definition, only a name given according to output, and like \"the catering industry\" it is a [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) of the researcher. A reproductive event need not by itself constitute a [reproductive mode](concepts.md#c12): only when the researcher, by a [persistence criterion](concepts.md#c01), tracks the structure it belongs to as a recurring [economic mode](concepts.md#c09) is that structure a [reproductive mode](concepts.md#c12).\n\n**Conclusion 8.1**: An [economic mode](concepts.md#c09) is the researcher's grouping of [node](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25) [outputs](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28), so the appearance of every [economic mode](concepts.md#c09) requires participating [nodes](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25). If every biological human [node](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25) will undergo [criterion exit](../paper_96f10d75_23d0_441f_94c7_ab87ca28d284/concepts.md#c09), then the biological human [nodes](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25) required by all [modes](concepts.md#c09) that take biological humans as [nodes](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25) ultimately come from reproductive events; if the structures these events belong to are tracked by the researcher as recurring [economic modes](concepts.md#c09), they are [reproductive modes](concepts.md#c12).\n\n(Derived from Premise 4, the definitions of [economic mode](concepts.md#c09) and [reproductive mode](concepts.md#c12), Conclusion 7.3 and the definition of [offspring](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c15): a reproductive event produces the [entry](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c44) of a new [node](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25))\n\n**Conclusion 8.2**: If the [persistence criterion](concepts.md#c01) of a [population graph](concepts.md#c05) has a [check window](concepts.md#c03) such that, when that [window](concepts.md#c03) begins, all biological human [nodes](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25) already in the [population graph](concepts.md#c05) have undergone [criterion exit](../paper_96f10d75_23d0_441f_94c7_ab87ca28d284/concepts.md#c09), and the [persistence criterion](concepts.md#c01) of the [population graph](concepts.md#c05) requires that the [population graph](concepts.md#c05) contain biological human [nodes](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25) that have not undergone [criterion exit](../paper_96f10d75_23d0_441f_94c7_ab87ca28d284/concepts.md#c09), then within that [check window](concepts.md#c03) some biological human [nodes](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25) must newly join the [population graph](concepts.md#c05) ([offspring](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c15) produced by reproductive events inside the [cut](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c23), or immigrants from outside), or some biological human [nodes](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25) already in it cease to be recorded as having undergone [criterion exit](../paper_96f10d75_23d0_441f_94c7_ab87ca28d284/concepts.md#c09) within that [window](concepts.md#c03), or else the [population graph](concepts.md#c05) undergoes a [criterion break](concepts.md#c10) in that [window](concepts.md#c03); the newly joined [nodes](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25) all come from reproductive events (Premise 4). These events may be inside the [cut](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c23) or outside the [cut](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c23): bringing people in from outside only puts the reproductive events that supply [nodes](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25) outside the [cut](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c23); if the structures they belong to are tracked as a [reproductive mode](concepts.md#c12), that [reproductive mode](concepts.md#c12) may also have undergone a [criterion break](concepts.md#c10) before these [nodes](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25) join the [population graph](concepts.md#c05).\n\n(Derived from the definitions of [population graph](concepts.md#c05), [criterion break](concepts.md#c10), [cut](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c23) and [reproductive mode](concepts.md#c12), and Premise 4)\n\nExplanation:\n1. When a [reproductive mode](concepts.md#c12) undergoes a [criterion break](concepts.md#c10), other [modes](concepts.md#c09) need not [break](concepts.md#c10) immediately (each [mode](concepts.md#c09) is judged by its own [persistence criterion](concepts.md#c01) and [check window](concepts.md#c03); see the definitions of [criterion break](concepts.md#c10) and [check window](concepts.md#c03); Conclusion 7.6); but when all existing [nodes](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25) have undergone [criterion exit](../paper_96f10d75_23d0_441f_94c7_ab87ca28d284/concepts.md#c09) and there is no substitute source, the chain can reach the [modes](concepts.md#c09) that depend on these [nodes](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25) (Conclusion 7.7).\n2. A [path](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c07) of a [reproductive mode](concepts.md#c12) has an [antecedent](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c08) that can be supplied only by the counterpart's [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) (Premise 5, Conclusion 5.2); when the researcher counts the counterpart's [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) into the [mode](concepts.md#c09), the [mode](concepts.md#c09) spans [nodes](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25) (the definition of [economic mode](concepts.md#c09)).\n3. Whether a [population graph](concepts.md#c05) is \"the same one\" is decided by the [identity condition](concepts.md#c02) stated by the researcher (3.4), whether the new [nodes](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25) come from reproductive events inside the [cut](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c23) or from immigration.\n4. If the parents in a [reproductive mode](concepts.md#c12) are biological human [nodes](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25), then by Premise 4 they themselves also come from reproductive events; if the parent and the [offspring](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c15) are both [wos](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16), the parent's [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) [arrives](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at the [offspring](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c15), and the [offspring](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c15)'s later [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) in turn [arrives](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at the parent and enters the parent's [history](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13), and the researcher counts these [arrivals](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) into that [reproductive mode](concepts.md#c12), then the parent's [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28), by way of the [offspring](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c15), takes part again in the parent's own [weight](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06), and that [reproductive mode](concepts.md#c12) contains a cross-generational [loop](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c31) (the definitions of [wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16) and [loop](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c31)); the [nodes](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25) of the [population graph](concepts.md#c05) all come from reproductive events (Premise 4, Conclusion 8.2), which may lie inside or outside the [cut](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c23). The cross-generational [loop](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c31) and the supply of [nodes](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25) do not imply that the other [antecedents](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c08) of each [mode](concepts.md#c09) are also supplied by them; those [antecedents](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c08) may still come from the [exterior](concepts.md#c04) and the [natural environment](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c16) (Conclusions 4.6, 6.2).\n\nCalibration: The cotton plantations of the American South replenished labor by trafficking enslaved people, so the [nodes](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25) were supplied by Africa's [reproductive modes](concepts.md#c12); some industries have long relied on migrant workers, so the [nodes](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25) are supplied by the [reproductive modes](concepts.md#c12) of the workers' home countries. In a region whose fertility has stayed below replacement level for a long time with no immigration, the chain shows only after [nodes](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25) undergo [criterion exit](../paper_96f10d75_23d0_441f_94c7_ab87ca28d284/concepts.md#c09), so there is a time lag.\n\nAlso: Japan's births in 2024 were about 720,000, the ninth consecutive year of decline; in October of the same year the number of foreign workers reached a new high of about 2.3 million, up 12.4% from the previous year. Part of the reproductive events that supply [nodes](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25) lie outside the [cut](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c23).\n\n---\n\n## 9. Inferences at the Participant Level\n\n**Conclusion 9.1**: Meeting the criterion of [tacit coordination](../paper_ae79e938_76e1_4bf9_b2ab_995c03e16c9e/concepts.md#c06) on one dimension does not imply meeting it on other dimensions.\n\n(The definition of [tacit coordination](../paper_ae79e938_76e1_4bf9_b2ab_995c03e16c9e/concepts.md#c06): [tacit coordination](../paper_ae79e938_76e1_4bf9_b2ab_995c03e16c9e/concepts.md#c06) is judged within a specified situation type and dimension)\n\n**Conclusion 9.2**: When two [selves](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19) repeatedly participate in the same [economic mode](concepts.md#c09) and each one's [outputs](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) [arrive](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at the other on that dimension, they accumulate a [dedicated history](../paper_ae79e938_76e1_4bf9_b2ab_995c03e16c9e/concepts.md#c05) on that dimension; but the accumulation of a [dedicated history](../paper_ae79e938_76e1_4bf9_b2ab_995c03e16c9e/concepts.md#c05) does not imply [tacit coordination](../paper_ae79e938_76e1_4bf9_b2ab_995c03e16c9e/concepts.md#c06).\n\n(Derived from the definitions of [dedicated history](../paper_ae79e938_76e1_4bf9_b2ab_995c03e16c9e/concepts.md#c05) and [tacit coordination](../paper_ae79e938_76e1_4bf9_b2ab_995c03e16c9e/concepts.md#c06): many interactions do not mean [tacit coordination](../paper_ae79e938_76e1_4bf9_b2ab_995c03e16c9e/concepts.md#c06) already exists)\n\nCalibration: Colleagues who have worked together for years may form [tacit coordination](../paper_ae79e938_76e1_4bf9_b2ab_995c03e16c9e/concepts.md#c06) at work, or may not; even if they do, it is not guaranteed that they get along in life. Colleagues are not family.\n\n**Conclusion 9.3**: When a [node](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25) that is a [self](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19) joins an [economic mode](concepts.md#c09), it does not inherit the [dedicated history](../paper_ae79e938_76e1_4bf9_b2ab_995c03e16c9e/concepts.md#c05) among the other participants; when such a [node](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25) exits, the [dedicated history](../paper_ae79e938_76e1_4bf9_b2ab_995c03e16c9e/concepts.md#c05) it already has with the other participants remains in the [history](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13).\n\n(Derived from the definitions of [history](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13) and [dedicated history](../paper_ae79e938_76e1_4bf9_b2ab_995c03e16c9e/concepts.md#c05): [history](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13) is only appended forward, so an existing [dedicated history](../paper_ae79e938_76e1_4bf9_b2ab_995c03e16c9e/concepts.md#c05) does not disappear through joining or exiting; a [dedicated history](../paper_ae79e938_76e1_4bf9_b2ab_995c03e16c9e/concepts.md#c05) belongs only to those two, so it does not become the new member's)\n\nCalibration: A new employee does not inherit the years of coordination among the old employees by joining the team; when an old employee leaves, everyone's experience of working with him remains.\n\n**Conclusion 9.4**: That a newcomer has no [dedicated history](../paper_ae79e938_76e1_4bf9_b2ab_995c03e16c9e/concepts.md#c05) with the other participants does not imply that its [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) is incompatible.\n\n(Derived from the definition of [resonance](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c09): [resonance](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c09) does not require a [dedicated history](../paper_ae79e938_76e1_4bf9_b2ab_995c03e16c9e/concepts.md#c05) and is not limited to two [selves](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19), so having no [dedicated history](../paper_ae79e938_76e1_4bf9_b2ab_995c03e16c9e/concepts.md#c05) does not imply that [outputs](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) are incompatible)\n\nExplanation: For the sources of compatibility, the upstream already has concepts such as [resonance](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c09) and [templates](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c14). Which kind of connection a given [economic mode](concepts.md#c09) actually relies on is judged from data and is not derived by this paper.\n\nCalibration: A new cashier who can check out customers on the first day may rely on the company's operating manual (a [template](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c14)), or on experience at another convenience store.\n\n**Conclusion 9.5**: A [node](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25) joining or exiting implies neither a [criterion break](concepts.md#c10) of an [economic mode](concepts.md#c09) nor its continuation.\n\n(Derived from the fact that the identity of an [economic mode](concepts.md#c09) looks at position, and that a [criterion break](concepts.md#c10) is judged by the [persistence criterion](concepts.md#c01))\n\nCalibration: When an old shop changes owner, it may keep operating as usual or may close half a year later; with the change, [tacit coordination](../paper_ae79e938_76e1_4bf9_b2ab_995c03e16c9e/concepts.md#c06) starts from scratch and is not necessarily established, and the [mode](concepts.md#c09) is neither guaranteed to change nor guaranteed to disappear.\n\n---\n\n## 10. What Cannot Be Derived and What Is Left for Later\n\n### 10.1 What This Paper Cannot Derive\n\n- Under the conditions of Conclusion 5.4, when the criterion depends on the [outputs](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) of [wos](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16) or [random sources](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c27) that are not [locked in](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c12), which structures will become [economic modes](concepts.md#c09) (Conclusions 5.4, 5.6);\n- When an [economic mode](concepts.md#c09) undergoes a [criterion break](concepts.md#c10) and how long it lasts, under the conditions of Conclusion 5.4, when the criterion depends on the [outputs](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) of [wos](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16) or [random sources](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c27) that are not [locked in](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c12) (Conclusion 5.4);\n- The specific effect of an [economic mode](concepts.md#c09) on [exterior](concepts.md#c04) [nodes](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25), when such a [node](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25) is not [locked in](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c12) at the [moment](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c09) just before its next [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28); when the results with nonzero [weight](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06) differ in direction, not even the direction (Conclusion 6.6);\n- Under the conditions of Conclusion 5.4, when the criterion depends on the [outputs](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) of [wos](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16) that are not [locked in](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c12), whether a [reproductive mode](concepts.md#c12) continues in the next [window](concepts.md#c03) (Conclusion 5.4, the definition of [reproductive mode](concepts.md#c12)).\n\nExplanation: Why it takes this form rather than another depends on the actual physical and historical conditions. Given the conditions, which [paths](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c07) are feasible is a matter at the condition level and can be judged case by case; which one actually comes out cannot be derived for a finite observer, and one can only [record](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c06) it and judge persistence [window](concepts.md#c03) by [window](concepts.md#c03).\n\n**Conclusion 10.1**: The [economic modes](concepts.md#c09) observed are all ones that passed successive [persistence criteria](concepts.md#c01); when they, in retrospect, fit their [exterior](concepts.md#c04), this does not imply any design or purpose.\n\n(Derived from 0.4, Conclusion 5.3 and the definition of [conditioning on existing samples](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c14): the [economic modes](concepts.md#c09) observed are all ones that passed successive [persistence criteria](concepts.md#c01) (0.4); the correction brought by [outcome feedback](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c05) has no preset direction (Conclusion 5.3), so what remains need not come from design or purpose; [conditioning on existing samples](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c14) is the researcher's sample boundary, not a purposeful selection by the [exterior](concepts.md#c04))\n\nCalibration: The location of an old market looks as if it was carefully chosen, near the ferry, the crossroads and the water source; in fact, most of those who set up stalls elsewhere back then did not remain.\n\n### 10.2 Left for Later\n\n- **Concepts that can be derived only by introducing a [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)**: ownership, institutions, price, value, money, distribution, and also organizations and markets. The scope of [records](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c06) in this paper does not include [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18), and the premises for deriving these concepts have not been introduced; they are not excluded but left for later research that introduces [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) ([distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18), [second-order distinction](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c01), [view attribution](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c02)), taking the [economic modes](concepts.md#c09) derived in this paper as the base layer.\n- **Ex ante judgments of reachability**: \"whom one may possibly contact\" belongs to the judgment of [antecedents](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c08), and how to make such judgments systematically is left to applied research.\n\n---\n\n## 11. Cases\n\nThis whole section is calibration and is not a source of any derivation. The two cases are taken from the same period: the first looks at how an [economic mode](concepts.md#c09) is identified and how it is judged differently depending on the criterion; the second looks at how the [outputs](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) of [nodes](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25) in a [mode](concepts.md#c09) become [exterior](concepts.md#c04). Wherever the cases use expressions like \"in order to\" or \"wanting\", these are attributions by the recorder or by later people, not readouts of [weight](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06).\n\n### 11.1 Gold Mining and Supply in the Mining Region (1848 to 1856)\n\nNote on materials: What was read is the Wikipedia entries \"California gold rush\" and \"Women in the California gold rush\", and a National Park Service page on buried ships in San Francisco, with the relevant passages extracted by a tool, not the original files. Head counts are mostly estimates, and the sources do not fully agree.\n\n1. **[Cut](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c23)**: The scope is the California mining region and San Francisco, with the year as the [check window](concepts.md#c03). The [nodes](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25) are gold seekers, merchants, restaurants, hotels, tailors, ships and crews. The tracked structure (hereafter the gold-rush structure): gold seekers obtain gold dust → the gold dust [arrives](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at merchants → supplies, food, lodging and clothing [arrive](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at the gold seekers → the gold seekers dig again.\n2. **Initial state**: Before 1848, San Francisco had about a thousand people, and the [records](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c06) contain no gold-rush structure.\n3. **New [arrival](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)**: On 24 January 1848, Marshall found gold dust in the millrace at Sutter's Mill, which for everyone was an [arrival](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) from the [exterior](concepts.md#c04). Wherever the news [arrived](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10), people came from there: about six thousand people by the end of 1848, about ninety thousand in 1849, and at least three hundred thousand by 1855; in 1852 alone more than twenty thousand Chinese landed in San Francisco.\n4. **The structure that appeared**:\n - The gold-rush structure reappeared year after year from 1848. Gold seekers came and went in great numbers and the participating [nodes](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25) were replaced almost every year, but this positional structure did not change.\n - Gold seekers selling gold dust, eating, lodging and buying clothes each needed the [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) of other [nodes](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25), so this case counts those [outputs](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) into the gold-rush structure, and the structure spans [nodes](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25) from the first [window](concepts.md#c03).\n - Sam Brannan bought up prospecting supplies in San Francisco and resold them; in 1852 Wells Fargo began handling exchange and delivery in California; in 1853 Levi Strauss came to San Francisco to deal in cloth and dry goods.\n - Crews and passengers went ashore to mine for gold; hundreds of ships lay unmanned in the harbor, and some were converted into warehouses, taverns, hotels and even prisons.\n5. **Criterion and [break](concepts.md#c10)**:\n - The mining method began with the pan, then the rocker box and the long tom, and later the diversion of water; around 1850 most of the easily obtained gold dust had been mined out; by 1855 only medium-sized and large groups made any gain.\n - If the researcher cuts out the segment of \"mining\" alone and states the [identity condition](concepts.md#c02) on the panning method, then this cut-out structure underwent a [criterion break](concepts.md#c10) between about 1850 and 1855; if it is stated on the positional structure of the gold-rush structure as a whole, then the mining method changed but the gold-rush structure did not [break](concepts.md#c10).\n - If the criterion of the shipping [mode](concepts.md#c09) is stated on the [path](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c07) of crews sailing the ships, it underwent a [criterion break](concepts.md#c10) in the harbor, because the [antecedent](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c08) of crews was no longer satisfied.\n6. **What it shows**:\n - Identity looks at position, not at who: with the participating [nodes](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25) all replaced, the gold-rush structure can still be judged the same one (3.4).\n - Premise 1 held from the start: for gold seekers' food, lodging, clothing and the sale of gold dust, the [antecedents](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c08) could be satisfied only by the [outputs](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) of other [nodes](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25) [arriving](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10), so these [outputs](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) had to be supplied by other [nodes](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25) (Conclusion 5.2); this case counts them into the gold-rush structure, so the structure spans [nodes](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25). There is no Robinson Crusoe style of gold mining.\n - \"Solo gold mining\" and \"group gold mining\" are the researcher's [distinctions](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) of the mining segment, not two [modes](concepts.md#c09) each independent in the [output graph set](concepts.md#c07); depending on which segment the criterion is stated on, and whether it is stated on the [path](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c07) or on the result, whether there is a [break](concepts.md#c10) may differ (Conclusion 5.9).\n - The [paths](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c07) of merchants, exchange and cloth could appear only after the gold seekers, if the researcher sets their [antecedents](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c08) as satisfiable only by the gold seekers' [outputs](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) (Conclusions 7.3, 7.4).\n - When crews left their ships, the [antecedent](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c08) of the shipping [mode](concepts.md#c09) was no longer supplied by the original [nodes](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25), forming a chain (Conclusion 7.5); when abandoned ships were turned into warehouses, the [outputs](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) of the shipping [mode](concepts.md#c09) became the [antecedents](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c08) of other [paths](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c07) (Conclusion 5.8).\n - Reproduction: In 1850 women made up about 4.5% of the non-indigenous population; about 10% in 1852; in 1870 the male-to-female ratio was about 100 to 38; only the 1950 census came close to parity. The early [nodes](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25) came almost entirely from outside, so the reproductive events supplying [nodes](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25) were outside the [cut](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c23), and only later did reproductive events inside the [cut](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c23) gradually increase (Conclusion 8.2).\n7. **What can be said and what cannot be derived**:\n - Can be said: in these [records](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c06), the positional structure of the gold-rush structure reappears year after year while participants are replaced in great numbers; every item of the gold seekers' livelihood came from other [nodes](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25); the mining method changed; ships were put to other uses.\n - Cannot be derived: why any gold seeker came or left; why the gold-rush structure formed here and not elsewhere; whether a given person would stay the next year; whether such accounts as \"getting rich\" or \"failing\" are true.\n\n### 11.2 The Mining Region and Its Exterior (1848 to 1910)\n\nNote on materials: What was read is the Wikipedia entries \"Hydraulic mining\", \"Woodruff v. North Bloomfield Gravel Mining Company\" and \"California gold rush\", extracted by a tool, not the original files. There are very few first-hand records from the Indigenous side, so what follows writes only the [arrival](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) and the consequences that can be [recorded](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c06).\n\n1. **[Cut](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c23)**: The [nodes](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25) fall into four categories: the [nodes](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25) taking part in the mining region's [modes](concepts.md#c09); the [nodes](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25) engaged in agriculture and shipping in the downstream Sacramento Valley; California's Indigenous groups; foreign miners. The [natural environment](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c16) includes rivers and land. The [check window](concepts.md#c03) is the year.\n2. **Initial state**: Before the gold rush, California had about fifteen thousand residents of European descent and of Mexican-Californian descent; the [modes](concepts.md#c09) of the Indigenous groups already existed.\n3. **New [arrivals](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)**:\n - In 1853, Matteson used high-pressure water jets near Nevada City to wash gold-bearing gravel. This [path](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c07) required bringing water from high ground, with pipes and nozzles; by the early 1860s it already required large organizations and large sums of capital.\n - Sediment, rubble and heavy metals were discharged into rivers, raising the riverbeds, causing man-made floods, destroying large tracts of farmland in the valley, flooding towns, and also obstructing steamboat navigation.\n - [Arrival](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) between the mining region and the Indigenous peoples: killing, expulsion, and changes to rivers and land. Madley estimates that between 1846 and 1873 at least 9,400 to 16,000 California Indigenous people were killed by non-Indigenous people, in more than 370 massacres.\n - A tax on foreign miners: twenty US dollars per month.\n4. **The structure that appeared**:\n - The [outputs](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) of the mining [modes](concepts.md#c09) [arrived](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at wheat farmers through the river, and the farmers' lawsuit in turn [arrived](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at the mining region: the suit was filed in 1882, and on 7 January 1884 Judge Sawyer ruled that the mines could no longer discharge sediment into the river channels.\n - The [outputs](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) of the mining region [arrived](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at the Indigenous groups, and the [outputs](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) of the Indigenous groups also [arrived](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at the mining region; the two sides were each other's [exterior](concepts.md#c04).\n5. **Criterion and [break](concepts.md#c10)**:\n - \"Hydraulic mining with sediment discharged into river channels\" underwent a [criterion break](concepts.md#c10) after 1884; \"hydraulic mining\" continued on a smaller scale, changed after 1893 to adding debris dams, and Malakoff Diggins closed only in 1910.\n - The [modes](concepts.md#c09) of many Indigenous groups underwent a [criterion break](concepts.md#c10).\n6. **What it shows**:\n - Only after surface gold was mined out and water and capital were in place did the [path](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c07) of hydraulic mining enter the [feasible set](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c11) (Conclusion 5.7).\n - Wheat farmers and the mines did not necessarily have direct [arrival](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10), yet the mines' [outputs](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) changed them through the river (Conclusion 6.2); influence does not require participation (Conclusion 6.3).\n - To the mining region the Indigenous peoples were [exterior](concepts.md#c04), and to the Indigenous peoples the mining region was [exterior](concepts.md#c04); the two formed a cross-[mode](concepts.md#c09) [loop](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c31) (Conclusion 7.1). In this [loop](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c31), the [modes](concepts.md#c09) of many Indigenous groups underwent a [criterion break](concepts.md#c10) while the mining region's [modes](concepts.md#c09) continued; under the compatibility criterion, the relation between the two is [mismatch](../paper_ae79e938_76e1_4bf9_b2ab_995c03e16c9e/concepts.md#c08) (7.2).\n - The foreign miners' tax is the [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) of a [signal container](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c26), and when it [arrived](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at the foreign miners its content did not change with the person (Conclusion 6.4).\n - In this case, the three criteria give different times of [break](concepts.md#c10): 1884, 1893 and 1910 correspond to different [identity conditions](concepts.md#c02) (3.5, Conclusion 5.9).\n7. **What can be said and what cannot be derived**:\n - Can be said: the mining region's [outputs](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) [arrived](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) downstream through the river; there was a great deal of [arrival](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) between the mining region and the Indigenous peoples, after which the [modes](concepts.md#c09) of many Indigenous groups no longer appeared; after the ruling, the structure of discharging sediment into rivers no longer appeared.\n - Cannot be derived: the motives of either side; whether the mining region acted \"in order to\" drive out the Indigenous peoples; what the Indigenous groups would have become without the gold rush; whether the ruling was \"correct\".\n\n---\n\n## 12. Comparison with Existing Theories\n\nThe following theories each reach conclusions close to this paper's by different routes. By this paper's method, if this system can derive their conclusions, that supports the premises; if there is a divergence, some premise or derivation is yet to be examined.\n\n| Theory | Its conclusion | Corresponding part of this paper | Difference in mode of argument |\n|---|---|---|---|\n| Adam Smith | The division of labor is limited by the extent of the market | Conclusions 4.2, 5.2, 5.8 | Argued from a propensity to exchange and from efficiency |\n| Leontief's input-output analysis | The outputs of sectors are each other's inputs, and shocks propagate along input relations | Conclusions 7.3 to 7.7 | Established with linear coefficients and quantitative models |\n| Luhmann's social systems theory | Systems are each other's environment, and are self-producing | Conclusions 6.1, 7.1 | Takes communication and function as units, and requires \"meaning\" |\n| Padgett and Powell | Organizations and markets arise from autocatalytic networks; in the long run relations make the actors | Conclusions 5.1, 5.3, 7.1 | Established through simulation and historical cases |\n| Brian Arthur's complexity economics | The economy is a self-constructing ecology, and technologies are each other's environment | Sections 6 and 7; Conclusions 5.7, 7.4 | Established through historical induction and models |\n| Hannan and Freeman's organizational ecology | Liability of newness; survivors remain through selection | 0.4, Conclusions 5.6, 10.1 | Established through population statistics, with a metaphor of selection |\n| Alchian (1950); Ferguson, Hayek | Survival needs neither rationality nor foresight; order is the result of human action but not of human design | Conclusions 5.4, 10.1 | Established through economic argument, still retaining purposive terms such as \"profit\" |\n| Pigou, Coase on externalities | A transaction affects third parties who did not take part in it | Conclusions 6.2, 6.3 | Described in terms of costs and rights |\n| Wiener's cybernetics; Maturana and Varela | Feedback loops; autopoiesis | Conclusion 5.1 | Described in terms of systems and function |\n| Engels (1884), Preface | There are two kinds of production: the production of the means of subsistence and the production of human beings themselves | Conclusions 8.1, 8.2 | Established through historical materialism and stage theory |\n| Becker's household economics | Fertility and child-rearing can be treated with economic analysis | Section 8 | Described in terms of utility and choice |\n\nThe difference of this paper is that it uses no intention, purpose, function, cost or meaning anywhere, only [outputs](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28), [arrival](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10), [weight](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06) and the researcher's criteria.\n\n---\n\n## 13. The General Proposition\n\nUnder a stated [cut](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c23), the [outputs](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) of biological humans can be [recorded](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c06) as an [output graph set](concepts.md#c07), recorded on a [population graph](concepts.md#c05). The structures in it that the researcher tracks by a [persistence criterion](concepts.md#c01) and that appear repeatedly are [economic modes](concepts.md#c09); in every [mode](concepts.md#c09) in which a [wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16) participates, each [wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16) has a [small loop](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c02); if some [path](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c07) is among the [paths](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c07) referred to by Premise 1 and is realized within some [check window](concepts.md#c03), then the [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) of some other [node](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25) must supply its [antecedent](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c08), and whether that is counted into the [mode](concepts.md#c09) is decided by the researcher's [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18). The [outputs](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) of [nodes](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25) in a [mode](concepts.md#c09), through [interface nodes](concepts.md#c11) and the [natural environment](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c16), can become the [exterior](concepts.md#c04) of other [nodes](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25), and influence does not require participation. [Economic modes](concepts.md#c09) that [arrive](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at each other and share no participating [node](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25) are each other's [exterior](concepts.md#c04); when the [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) of some [wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16) returns to it through a [wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16) in another [mode](concepts.md#c09), this forms a cross-[mode](concepts.md#c09) [loop](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c31); among them [resonance](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c09), [taiji](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c39) and [mismatch](../paper_ae79e938_76e1_4bf9_b2ab_995c03e16c9e/concepts.md#c08) can be identified by criteria, and interruptions of supply are transmitted in a chain as judged through [antecedents](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c08). The supply of [antecedents](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c08) gives a partial order between a [mode](concepts.md#c09) and the [outputs](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) that supply it; if every biological human [node](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25) will undergo [criterion exit](../paper_96f10d75_23d0_441f_94c7_ab87ca28d284/concepts.md#c09), then for every [mode](concepts.md#c09) that takes biological humans as [nodes](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25), its biological human [nodes](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25) ultimately come from reproductive events; when these events are tracked as a [reproductive mode](concepts.md#c12) (an [economic mode](concepts.md#c09) that produces [offspring](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c15)), if the [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) it supplies is interrupted, the interruption can be transmitted along the supply relations of [antecedents](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c08) to the [modes](concepts.md#c09) that depend on these [nodes](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25).\n\nThe formation of an [economic mode](concepts.md#c09) can only be identified afterward; its continuation and specific influence, when the criterion or the [exterior](concepts.md#c04) [nodes](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25) depend on [wos](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16) or [random sources](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c27) that are not [locked in](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c12) (under the conditions of Conclusions 5.4 and 6.6), likewise cannot be uniquely derived beforehand and can only be judged [window](concepts.md#c03) by [window](concepts.md#c03); the [economic modes](concepts.md#c09) observed are all ones that so far have not undergone a [criterion break](concepts.md#c10). Ownership, institutions, price, money, organizations, markets and the like can be derived only by introducing [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18); this paper has not yet introduced their premises, and they are left for later work that derives them with this paper as the base layer.\n\n---\n\n## Appendix: Terminology Comparison\n\n| | Data | Tendency | End |\n|---|---|---|---|\n| Individual paper | [Record](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c06) | [Output Tendency](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c02) | [Criterion Exit](../paper_96f10d75_23d0_441f_94c7_ab87ca28d284/concepts.md#c09) |\n| This paper | [Output Graph Set](concepts.md#c07) | [Pattern Tendency](concepts.md#c08) | [Criterion Break](concepts.md#c10) |\n\n"}]}
{"paper_uuid":"ed71bef7-0f22-4443-bc1d-4d1ecfe81967","paper_title":"幻覺構件動力學","paper_title_en":"Dynamics of Illusory Constructs","author":"黃正宇 / Cheng Yu Huang","contact":"mthree.tw@gmail.com","concepts_md":"---\nuuid: ed71bef7-0f22-4443-bc1d-4d1ecfe81967\nlast-modified: 2026-11-11T17:51:57\n---\n\n\n## public 經驗前提 / Empirical Premise\n\n- 定義:經驗前提是由個案或既有測試得來、可以被新的個案或測試修改的前提。其中以[經驗禁止](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c51)的形式寫出的,只寫必要條件;另一種是對既有測試結果的登記,或由觀察歸納的概括,不是必要條件。\n- Definition: An empirical premise is a premise drawn from cases or from existing tests, which new cases or tests can revise. Those written in the form of an [empirical prohibition](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c51) state only necessary conditions. The other kind registers the results of existing tests, or is a generalization induced from observations, and is not a necessary condition.\n- 裁決:2026-11-11 與上游經驗禁止不是同一個概念:經驗前提一至三的形式是經驗禁止,經驗前提四不是;另立新概念,定義連到經驗禁止。\n- 裁決:2026-11-11 新增經驗前提五(由觀察歸納的概括),定義改為涵蓋「對既有測試結果的登記,或由觀察歸納的概括」。\n- 裁決:2026-11-13 全篇掃查指出定義重述上游經驗禁止的定義;刪去重述,改由連結承擔。\n\n\n## private 理論極限 / Theoretical Limit\n\n- 定義:理論極限是不因工程改善而改變的那一層限制,也就是[流變律](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c24)、[黑箱律](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c25)、[損耗律](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c26)與[不可復原律](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c28)。\n- Definition: The theoretical limit is the layer of limits that does not change with engineering improvements, namely the [law of flux](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c24), the [law of the black box](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c25), the [law of attrition](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c26) and the [law of non-restoration](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c28).\n- 裁決:2026-11-11 登記為獨立概念,修飾子為 private:它只以三層對照表中的一列界定。\n\n\n## private 工程極限 / Engineering Limit\n\n- 定義:工程極限是可能隨工程改善而改變的那一層限制,也就是接收,以及[工程能力](concepts.md#c12)所衡量的範圍。\n- Definition: The engineering limit is the layer of limits that may change with engineering improvements, namely reception and the range measured by the [engineering capacities](concepts.md#c12).\n- 裁決:2026-11-11 登記為獨立概念,修飾子為 private:它只以三層對照表中的一列界定。\n\n\n## public 自我配置假定 / Self-Configuration Assumption\n\n- 定義:自我配置假定是在講明的[切法](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c23)下,對切出的某個[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)所作的假定:假定它以[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)定義自己。它不是定理,從外部確認[不被保證](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c02)。該[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)缺少[自他區辨](concepts.md#c48)或[跨時刻歸併](concepts.md#c49)所需的某項工程條件(留下自己[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)的副本並與隨後的[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)對照;跨[時刻](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c09)保留,並把不同[時刻](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c09)自己造成的[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)[壓縮](concepts.md#c31)為同一類),或找到機制證明它沒有任何[回合](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c04)是[決定](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c06)時,這項假定對它不成立。換一種[切法](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c23),這項假定可以落在不同的[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)上,也可以同時落在巢狀的[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)上。\n- Definition: The self-configuration assumption is an assumption made, under a stated [cut](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c23), about some [wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16) that has been cut out: it is assumed to define itself by [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18). It is not a theorem, and its confirmation from outside is [not guaranteed](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c02). The assumption fails for that wo when it lacks one of the engineering conditions needed for [self-other discrimination](concepts.md#c48) or [cross-moment lumping](concepts.md#c49) (keeping a copy of its own [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) and comparing it with the [arrivals](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) that follow; retaining across [moments](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c09), and [compressing](concepts.md#c31) the [arrivals](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) it caused at different [moments](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c09) into one kind), or when a mechanism is found showing that none of its [rounds](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c04) is a [decision](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c06). Under another cut, the assumption may fall on a different wo, or on nested wo at the same time.\n- 裁決:2026-11-13 稽核指出定義寫「缺少這項假定的某項必要條件」,不讀論文無法得知是哪些條件;改為寫明是自他區辨或跨時刻歸併所需的工程條件。\n\n\n## public 有損的推廣 / Generalized Lossiness\n\n- 定義:有損的推廣是這個結論:一筆[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)一個[呈現](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c04)的,不是另一個[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)[自己的那一段](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c17)的全部,因為後者一直追溯到[宇宙初態](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c14),包括許多次[寫入](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c29)與[坍塌](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c08)的結果;這不依賴接收者是不是[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19)。[有損](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c13)就一筆[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)、[被看的東西](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c27)是另一個[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)而言,是它落在[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19)身上的情形。\n- Definition: Generalized lossiness is this conclusion: what one [arrival](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) brings to a [presentation](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c04) is not the whole of another [Wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)'s [own segment](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c17), because the latter reaches back to [the initial state of the universe](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c14), including the results of many [writings](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c29) and [collapses](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c08); this does not depend on whether the receiver is a [self](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19). [Lossiness](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c13) for one [arrival](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) and when [what is seen](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c27) is another [Wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16), is the case where it falls on a [self](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19).\n- 裁決:2026-11-12 稽核指出原定義對任何呈現、任何筆數的到達都說「不是全部」,來源只撐到一筆到達、對方是渦;作者裁定照推得出的範圍收窄。\n- 裁決:2026-11-13 稽核指出定義只寫一筆到達是一次寫入中對它而言的那一部分,漏了論文並列的「某一次坍塌的結果」;依論文一之六的列舉補上。\n- 裁決:2026-11-13 全篇掃查指出定義的前兩個分句重述上游刺激、到達、自己的那一段的定義;定義收為結論本身,推導留在論文一之六。\n\n\n## private 定義隔離與更名不變性 / Definitional Isolation and Renaming Invariance\n\n- 定義:定義隔離與更名不變性是這項記帳約定:[幻覺構件](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c01)只依明示定義、適用條件、組合規則與可登記判準取得理論意義,自然語言名稱不帶入善惡、目的、因果、大小或心理內容。\n- Definition: Definitional isolation and renaming invariance is this bookkeeping convention: an [illusory construct](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c01) acquires theoretical meaning only through its explicit definition, conditions of application, rules of combination and registrable criteria; its natural-language name carries in no good or evil, purpose, causation, magnitude or psychological content.\n- 裁決:2026-11-11 登記為獨立概念,修飾子為 private:它是記帳約定。\n\n\n## public 構造 / Structure\n\n- 定義:構造是載體上可使用、可改變的參數、連結、神經結構、動態狀態等。衡量它的指標是[構造能力](concepts.md#c17)。構造不是[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06)。\n- Definition: Structure is the usable and changeable parameters, connections, neural structures, dynamic states and the like on a carrier. The indicator that measures it is [structure capacity](concepts.md#c17). Structure is not [weight](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06).\n\n\n## public 運算 / Operation\n\n- 定義:運算是以一個或多個[表示](concepts.md#c34)為輸入、落出一個[表示](concepts.md#c34)的映射,例如變換、組合、比較、推進。說一個[節點](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25)作運算,指研究者把它的[回合](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c04)讀作運算。衡量它的指標是[運算能力](concepts.md#c14)。\n- Definition: An operation is a mapping that takes one or more [representations](concepts.md#c34) as input and yields a [representation](concepts.md#c34), such as transformation, combination, comparison or advancing. To say that a [node](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25) performs an operation is to say that a researcher reads its [round](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c04) as an operation. The indicator that measures it is [operation capacity](concepts.md#c14).\n- 裁決:2026-11-13 全篇掃查指出本條說運算就是變換,運算能力卻把變換與組合、比較、推進並列;作者裁定依數學與計算理論的通行用法,改為以表示為輸入的映射。\n\n\n## public 明列 / Explicit Listing\n\n- 定義:明列是內容進入[信號容器](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c26)。\n- Definition: Explicit listing is content entering a [signal container](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c26).\n- 裁決:2026-11-11 登記為獨立概念:被命名、被定義的構件。\n\n\n## public 類的幻覺構件 / Class Illusory Construct\n\n- 定義:類的幻覺構件是把[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)的結果再[歸併](concepts.md#c23)所得的[幻覺構件](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c01)。\n- Definition: A class illusory construct is an [illusory construct](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c01) obtained by further [lumping](concepts.md#c23) the results of [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18).\n\n\n## private 目前的人工智慧 / Current Artificial Intelligence\n\n- 定義:目前的人工智慧,是在邏輯狀態這個[切法](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c23)下,以圖靈機為設計基底、每一[回合](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c04)不是[鎖死的回合](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c25)就是[隨機的回合](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c26)的數位人工智慧。\n- Definition: Current artificial intelligence is digital artificial intelligence designed on the basis of the Turing machine, every one of whose [rounds](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c04), under the [cut](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c23) of logical state, is either a [locked-in round](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c25) or a [random round](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c26).\n- 裁決:2026-11-11 登記為獨立概念,修飾子為 private:它指一類特定判定的節點。\n\n\n## public 工程能力 / Engineering Capacity\n\n- 定義:工程能力是用來衡量載體作某類動作或某類保留能到什麼程度的指標,有[容納能力](concepts.md#c13)、[運算能力](concepts.md#c14)、[記憶能力](concepts.md#c15)、[壓縮能力](concepts.md#c16)與[構造能力](concepts.md#c17)五項。它們不是[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)的必要且充分條件,也不窮盡[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)的能力。\n- Definition: An engineering capacity is an indicator used to measure to what degree a carrier can perform some kind of action or some kind of retention. There are five: [containment capacity](concepts.md#c13), [operation capacity](concepts.md#c14), [memory capacity](concepts.md#c15), [compression capacity](concepts.md#c16) and [structure capacity](concepts.md#c17). They are not necessary and sufficient conditions of a [wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16), nor do they exhaust the capacities of a wo.\n\n\n## public 容納能力 / Containment Capacity\n\n- 定義:容納能力是[工程能力](concepts.md#c12)的一項:在既定結構中,能區分、表示並同時處理多少輸入差異及其關係。\n- Definition: Containment capacity is one of the [engineering capacities](concepts.md#c12): how many input differences and their relations can be distinguished, represented and handled at once within a given structure.\n\n\n## public 運算能力 / Operation Capacity\n\n- 定義:運算能力是[工程能力](concepts.md#c12)的一項:在有限資源與時間內,能對[表示](concepts.md#c34)作多少、多快的[運算](concepts.md#c08):變換、組合、比較、推進。\n- Definition: Operation capacity is one of the [engineering capacities](concepts.md#c12): how many [operations](concepts.md#c08), and how fast, can be performed on a [representation](concepts.md#c34) with limited resources and time: transforming, combining, comparing, advancing.\n\n\n## public 記憶能力 / Memory Capacity\n\n- 定義:記憶能力是[工程能力](concepts.md#c12)的一項:能保留多少先前的輸入、狀態或[運算](concepts.md#c08)結果,並在後續取用。\n- Definition: Memory capacity is one of the [engineering capacities](concepts.md#c12): how much of earlier inputs, states or [operation](concepts.md#c08) results can be retained and later retrieved.\n\n\n## public 壓縮能力 / Compression Capacity\n\n- 定義:壓縮能力是[工程能力](concepts.md#c12)的一項:以有限資源重新表示資訊時,能保住多少指定用途所需的差異;它衡量的是[壓縮](concepts.md#c31)。\n- Definition: Compression capacity is one of the [engineering capacities](concepts.md#c12): how many of the differences needed for a specified use can be kept when information is re-represented with limited resources. It measures to what degree [compression](concepts.md#c31) can be carried out.\n\n\n## public 構造能力 / Structure Capacity\n\n- 定義:構造能力是[工程能力](concepts.md#c12)的一項:既有[構造](concepts.md#c07)參與[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)形成的程度;有[學習](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c04)時,[構造](concepts.md#c07)隨[歷史](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13)與回饋能改變多少。\n- Definition: Structure capacity is one of the [engineering capacities](concepts.md#c12): the degree to which existing [structure](concepts.md#c07) takes part in forming [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28); and, where there is [learning](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c04), how much structure can change with [history](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13) and feedback.\n\n\n## public 功能 / Function\n\n- 定義:說某個[幻覺構件](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c01)有某項功能,指缺少這類[構件](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c01)時,某類[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)[不會發生](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c01)。功能只寫必要條件,不指目的,也不主張有了[構件](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c01)那類[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)就會發生。\n- Definition: To say that an [illusory construct](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c01) has a certain function is to say that, without constructs of this kind, a certain kind of [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) [never occurs](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c01). A function states only a necessary condition; it does not mean a purpose, nor does it claim that with the construct that kind of output will occur.\n\n\n## public 單純的分別 / Mere Distinction\n\n- 定義:單純的分別是[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)的內容只參與之後的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)、沒有被用來指某個對象的情形。它照樣留下[寫入](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c29)、參與之後的[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06),但不是[幻覺構件](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c01)。\n- Definition: A mere distinction is the case where the content of a [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) only takes part in later [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) and is not used to point at some object. It still leaves a [writing](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c29) and takes part in later [weight](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06), but it is not an [illusory construct](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c01).\n\n\n## public 指代 / Reference\n\n- 定義:指代是[幻覺構件](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c01)的一項[功能](concepts.md#c18):在[被看的東西](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c27)不在場時,以一個內容指著它,參與[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)的組織。\n- Definition: Reference is a [function](concepts.md#c18) of an [illusory construct](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c01): when [what is seen](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c27) is not present, a content points at it and takes part in organizing [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28).\n- 裁決:2026-11-11 與替代性分開登記:指代要求有所指的對象,替代性只講內容被使用。\n\n\n## public 在渦之間傳遞 / Transmission Between Wo\n\n- 定義:在渦之間傳遞是[幻覺構件](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c01)的一項[功能](concepts.md#c18):以指著某個對象的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)其他[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)。[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)他人的是[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28),不是[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)這個動作;他人以它作出的[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18),是他人自己的[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)。\n- Definition: Transmission between wo is a [function](concepts.md#c18) of an [illusory construct](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c01): [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) that points at some object [arrives](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at other [wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16). What arrives at others is output, not the act of [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18); a distinction that others make with it is their own distinction.\n\n\n## public 區辨 / Discrimination\n\n- 定義:區辨是一次[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)中,不同的[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)落在界線不同邊的那一面。\n- Definition: Discrimination is the aspect of a [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) in which different [arrivals](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) fall on different sides of the line.\n\n\n## public 歸併 / Lumping\n\n- 定義:歸併是一次[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)中,不同的[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)落在界線同一邊、被看作一個的那一面。歸併是[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)的內容。\n- Definition: Lumping is the aspect of a [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) in which different [arrivals](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) fall on the same side of the line and are regarded as one. Lumping is the content of a distinction.\n\n\n## public 案例 / Case\n\n- 定義:案例是在研究者講明的[切法](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c23)下,一個[標的](concepts.md#c25),以及兩個時窗:[前窗](concepts.md#c26)與[後窗](concepts.md#c27),[前窗](concepts.md#c26)在先。\n- Definition: A case is, under a [cut](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c23) stated by the researcher, a [target](concepts.md#c25) together with two time windows, the [earlier window](concepts.md#c26) and the [later window](concepts.md#c27), the earlier window coming first.\n- 裁決:2026-11-11 五之三的部件(標的、前窗、後窗、前段材料、後段材料、前段表示、後段表示、推演結果)分開登記,不併入本條。\n\n\n## public 標的 / Target\n\n- 定義:標的是一個[案例](concepts.md#c24)所關於的那個[呈現](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c04)。\n- Definition: The target is the [presentation](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c04) that a [case](concepts.md#c24) is about.\n- 裁決:2026-11-11 分開登記,不併入案例。\n\n\n## public 前窗 / Earlier Window\n\n- 定義:前窗是一個[案例](concepts.md#c24)的兩個時窗中在先的那一個。\n- Definition: The earlier window is the first of the two time windows of a [case](concepts.md#c24).\n- 裁決:2026-11-11 分開登記,不併入案例。\n\n\n## public 後窗 / Later Window\n\n- 定義:後窗是一個[案例](concepts.md#c24)的兩個時窗中在後的那一個。\n- Definition: The later window is the second of the two time windows of a [case](concepts.md#c24).\n- 裁決:2026-11-11 分開登記,不併入案例。\n\n\n## public 到達材料 / Arrived Material\n\n- 定義:到達材料是關於一個[案例](concepts.md#c24)的[標的](concepts.md#c25)、已[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)作[壓縮](concepts.md#c31)者的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)。\n- Definition: Arrived material is [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) about the [target](concepts.md#c25) of a [case](concepts.md#c24) that has [arrived](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at whoever performs the [compression](concepts.md#c31).\n\n\n## public 前段材料 / Earlier Material\n\n- 定義:前段材料是[前窗](concepts.md#c26)內的[到達材料](concepts.md#c28)。\n- Definition: Earlier material is the [arrived material](concepts.md#c28) within the [earlier window](concepts.md#c26).\n- 裁決:2026-11-11 分開登記,不併入到達材料。\n\n\n## public 後段材料 / Later Material\n\n- 定義:後段材料是[後窗](concepts.md#c27)內與[前段材料](concepts.md#c29)同類的[到達材料](concepts.md#c28)。\n- Definition: Later material is the [arrived material](concepts.md#c28) within the [later window](concepts.md#c27) of the same kind as the [earlier material](concepts.md#c29).\n- 裁決:2026-11-11 分開登記,不併入到達材料。\n\n\n## public 壓縮 / Compression\n\n- 定義:壓縮是研究者對一個[節點](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25)的[回合](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c04)所作的一種讀法:把它讀作把[到達材料](concepts.md#c28)轉成[表示](concepts.md#c34)。不要求同一筆材料每次都得到同一個[表示](concepts.md#c34)。把[回合](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c04)讀作壓縮,是讀它的[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)的一次[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)。衡量它的指標是[壓縮能力](concepts.md#c16)。\n- Definition: Compression is a reading that a researcher makes of a [node](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25)'s [round](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c04): reading it as turning [arrived material](concepts.md#c28) into a [representation](concepts.md#c34). The same material is not required to yield the same representation every time. Reading a round as compression is a [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) made by the [wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16) that reads it. The indicator that measures it is [compression capacity](concepts.md#c16).\n\n\n## public 前段表示 / Earlier Representation\n\n- 定義:前段表示是[前段材料](concepts.md#c29)經[壓縮](concepts.md#c31)實際落出的[表示](concepts.md#c34)。\n- Definition: The earlier representation is the [representation](concepts.md#c34) actually yielded by [compression](concepts.md#c31) of the [earlier material](concepts.md#c29).\n- 裁決:2026-11-11 分開登記,不併入表示。\n\n\n## public 後段表示 / Later Representation\n\n- 定義:後段表示是[後段材料](concepts.md#c30)經[壓縮](concepts.md#c31)實際落出的[表示](concepts.md#c34)。\n- Definition: The later representation is the [representation](concepts.md#c34) actually yielded by [compression](concepts.md#c31) of the [later material](concepts.md#c30).\n- 裁決:2026-11-11 分開登記,不併入表示。\n\n\n## public 表示 / Representation\n\n- 定義:表示是可以再次[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)、被處理,或[明列](concepts.md#c09)進[信號容器](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c26)的內容;研究者把[回合](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c04)讀作[壓縮](concepts.md#c31)與[推演](concepts.md#c36)時,表示是這些讀法所指的內容。\n- Definition: A representation is content that can [arrive](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) again, be processed, or be [explicitly listed](concepts.md#c09) into a [signal container](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c26); when a researcher reads [rounds](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c04) as [compression](concepts.md#c31) and [inference](concepts.md#c36), the representation is the content these readings point to.\n\n\n## public 保留差異 / Retained Difference\n\n- 定義:保留差異是一次[壓縮](concepts.md#c31)的這種情形:兩筆[到達材料](concepts.md#c28)經[壓縮](concepts.md#c31)實際落出的[表示](concepts.md#c34),超出[允許誤差](concepts.md#c56)而不同;稱這次[壓縮](concepts.md#c31)保留了兩筆之間的差異。\n- Definition: A retained difference is this case of a [compression](concepts.md#c31): the [representations](concepts.md#c34) actually yielded by compressing two pieces of [arrived material](concepts.md#c28) differ beyond the [allowed error](concepts.md#c56); the compression is then said to retain the difference between the two.\n\n\n## public 推演 / Inference\n\n- 定義:推演是研究者對一段[回合](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c04)所作的一種讀法:把它讀作只取[表示](concepts.md#c34)、落出新的[表示](concepts.md#c34);它若還取用[表示](concepts.md#c34)以外的材料,就不是在這個[表示](concepts.md#c34)上的推演。把[回合](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c04)讀作推演,用到讀它的[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)的[幻覺構件](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c01);[回合](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c04)本身可以是[計算](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c05)。推演也是[幻覺構件](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c01)的一項[功能](concepts.md#c18):把[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)的內容與其他內容組合,推出關於尚未[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)的東西的新內容;推演的結果指著尚未[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)的[被看的東西](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c27)。\n- Definition: Inference is a reading that a researcher makes of a stretch of [rounds](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c04): reading it as taking only a [representation](concepts.md#c34) and yielding a new representation; if it also takes material other than the representation, it is not inference on that representation. Reading a round as inference uses the [illusory constructs](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c01) of the [wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16) that reads it; the round itself may be a [computation](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c05). Inference is also a [function](concepts.md#c18) of illusory constructs: combining the content of a [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) with other content to yield new content about what has not yet [arrived](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10); the result of inference points at [what is seen](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c27) that has not yet arrived.\n- 裁決:2026-11-14 稽核指出中文定義是「一段回合」,英文寫成 a round,範圍變窄;英文改為 a stretch of rounds,與正文五之三一致。\n\n\n## public 推演結果 / Inference Result\n\n- 定義:推演結果是[推演](concepts.md#c36)以[前段表示](concepts.md#c32)為材料所落出的[表示](concepts.md#c34)。\n- Definition: The inference result is the [representation](concepts.md#c34) yielded by [inference](concepts.md#c36) taking the [earlier representation](concepts.md#c32) as material.\n- 裁決:2026-11-11 分開登記,不併入推演。\n\n\n## public 比對 / Comparison\n\n- 定義:比對是檢查一個[案例](concepts.md#c24)的[推演結果](concepts.md#c37)與[後段表示](concepts.md#c33)是否在[允許誤差](concepts.md#c56)內相同。\n- Definition: Comparison is checking whether the [inference result](concepts.md#c37) and the [later representation](concepts.md#c33) of a [case](concepts.md#c24) are the same within the [allowed error](concepts.md#c56).\n\n\n## public 案例認定 / Case Attribution\n\n- 定義:案例認定是研究者把[前段材料](concepts.md#c29)與[後段材料](concepts.md#c30)歸給同一個[標的](concepts.md#c25)的一次[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)。它不由[表示](concepts.md#c34)的內容取得,通常由編號一類的[信號容器](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c26)內容承載。[可交換](concepts.md#c55)的判定,相對於這次案例認定。\n- Definition: Case attribution is a [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) by which a researcher assigns the [earlier material](concepts.md#c29) and the [later material](concepts.md#c30) to the same [target](concepts.md#c25). It is not obtained from the content of a [representation](concepts.md#c34), and is usually carried by [signal container](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c26) content such as a serial number. Judgments of [commutativity](concepts.md#c55) are relative to this case attribution.\n\n\n## public 在一個案例上可交換 / Commutative on a Case\n\n- 定義:在一個案例上可交換,指這個[案例](concepts.md#c24)的[比對](concepts.md#c38)結果相同。\n- Definition: Commutative on a [case](concepts.md#c24) means that the [comparison](concepts.md#c38) for that case comes out the same.\n\n\n## public 在已登記的案例中可交換 / Commutative over Registered Cases\n\n- 定義:在已登記的案例中可交換,指每一個已登記的[案例](concepts.md#c24),[比對](concepts.md#c38)結果都相同。\n- Definition: Commutative over registered cases means that for every registered [case](concepts.md#c24), the [comparison](concepts.md#c38) comes out the same.\n\n\n## public 在範圍內可交換 / Commutative within a Range\n\n- 定義:在範圍內可交換,是研究者講明一組[案例](concepts.md#c24)、主張每個[案例](concepts.md#c24)的[比對](concepts.md#c38)結果都相同。這是一項主張。\n- Definition: Commutative within a range is a researcher's stating a set of [cases](concepts.md#c24) and claiming that the [comparison](concepts.md#c38) for each case comes out the same. It is a claim.\n\n\n## public 推演規則 / Inference Rules\n\n- 定義:推演規則是對[推演](concepts.md#c36)的描述,可以[明列](concepts.md#c09)為[模板](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c14)。\n- Definition: Inference rules are a description of [inference](concepts.md#c36) that can be [explicitly listed](concepts.md#c09) as a [template](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c14).\n\n\n## public 自洽 / Self-Consistency\n\n- 定義:自洽是[推演規則](concepts.md#c44)的這種性質:其中沒有兩條在同一個[表示](concepts.md#c34)上給出超出[允許誤差](concepts.md#c56)而不同的結果。\n- Definition: Self-consistency is this property of [inference rules](concepts.md#c44): no two of them give results that differ beyond the [allowed error](concepts.md#c56) on the same [representation](concepts.md#c34).\n\n\n## private 自我梯子 / Self Ladder\n\n- 定義:自我梯子是分層列出的一組必要條件,從[自己維持的篩選邊界](concepts.md#c47),經[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)、[自他區辨](concepts.md#c48)、[跨時刻歸併](concepts.md#c49)與[替代性](concepts.md#c50)、[二階分別](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c01)與[看法歸屬](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c02),到[類的幻覺構件](concepts.md#c10);其中[自他區辨](concepts.md#c48)是瞬間的[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19)的必要條件,[跨時刻歸併](concepts.md#c49)與[替代性](concepts.md#c50)是延續的[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19)的必要條件,[二階分別](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c01)與[看法歸屬](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c02)依[配置假定](../paper_ae79e938_76e1_4bf9_b2ab_995c03e16c9e/concepts.md#c01)是[社會人](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c03)的必要條件。各階只寫必要條件,只用來否定[自我配置假定](concepts.md#c04);全部具備,也只說明這項假定沒有被否定。\n- Definition: The self ladder is a layered set of necessary conditions running from the [self-maintained filtering boundary](concepts.md#c47), through [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18), [self-other discrimination](concepts.md#c48), [cross-moment lumping](concepts.md#c49) and [substitutivity](concepts.md#c50), [second-order distinction](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c01) and [view attribution](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c02), up to [class illusory constructs](concepts.md#c10); of these, [self-other discrimination](concepts.md#c48) is a necessary condition of the momentary [self](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19), [cross-moment lumping](concepts.md#c49) and [substitutivity](concepts.md#c50) are necessary conditions of the enduring [self](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19), and [second-order distinction](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c01) and [view attribution](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c02) are, by the [configuration assumption](../paper_ae79e938_76e1_4bf9_b2ab_995c03e16c9e/concepts.md#c01), necessary conditions of the [social person](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c03). Each rung states only necessary conditions and is used only to negate the [self-configuration assumption](concepts.md#c04); having all of them means only that the assumption has not been negated.\n- 裁決:2026-11-11 登記為獨立概念,修飾子為 private:它綁定所列的這幾階。\n- 裁決:2026-11-13 全篇掃查指出定義沒有寫明各階是什麼的必要條件;依論文一之五的梯子補上。\n\n\n## public 自己維持的篩選邊界 / Self-Maintained Filtering Boundary\n\n- 定義:自己維持的篩選邊界是由一個[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)自己的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)維持、篩選什麼能[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)它的結構,不限定載體是哪一種,細胞膜是生物中的實例。它塑造的是該[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)[自己的那一段](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c17),不需要[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)。\n- Definition: A self-maintained filtering boundary is a structure, maintained by a [wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)'s own [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28), that filters what can [arrive](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at it. Its carrier is of no fixed kind; the cell membrane is an instance in living things. What it shapes is that wo's [own segment](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c17), and it requires no [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18).\n- 裁決:2026-11-13 全篇掃查指出上游渦的定義只說與載體無關,推不出「渦總有物理載體」;刪去,論文三之五同步改。\n\n\n## public 自他區辨 / Self-Other Discrimination\n\n- 定義:自他區辨是把回到自己身上的[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10),[區辨](concepts.md#c22)為自己造成的與不是自己造成的。回到一個[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)身上的[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10),不自帶「這是自己造成的」標記。稱它為[區辨](concepts.md#c22),是研究者的歸屬。\n- Definition: Self-other discrimination is [discriminating](concepts.md#c22) the [arrivals](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) that return to oneself into those caused by oneself and those not caused by oneself. An arrival returning to a [wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16) carries no mark saying \"this was caused by me\". Calling it [discriminating](concepts.md#c22) is the researcher's attribution.\n- 裁決:2026-11-13 全篇掃查指出論文說各階的稱呼是研究者的歸屬,本條漏了這項限定;補上。\n\n\n## public 跨時刻歸併 / Cross-Moment Lumping\n\n- 定義:跨時刻歸併是把不同[時刻](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c09)自己造成的[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)[歸併](concepts.md#c23)為同一類。研究者把這種歸併歸屬為[同一](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c21);這是研究者的歸屬。\n- Definition: Cross-moment lumping is [lumping](concepts.md#c23) the [arrivals](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) that one caused at different [moments](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c09) into one kind. The researcher attributes this lumping as [identity](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c21); this is the researcher's attribution.\n- 裁決:2026-11-11 與上游同一不是同一個概念:另立新概念,定義寫明兩者的關係。\n- 裁決:2026-11-13 全篇掃查指出「內容層」不讀論文無法理解;改寫為不依賴這個用語的說法。\n\n\n## public 替代性 / Substitutivity\n\n- 定義:替代性是一個[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)在自己不作為[刺激](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c30)在場時,關於自己的內容仍被使用的性質。\n- Definition: Substitutivity is the property that, when a [wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16) is not present as a [stimulus](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c30) to itself, content about itself is still used.\n- 裁決:2026-11-11 與指代分開登記:指代要求有所指的對象,替代性只講內容被使用。\n\n\n## public 模擬 / Simulation\n\n- 定義:模擬是在講明的[切法](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c23)與維度下,一個不是[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)的[節點](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25),它的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)依研究者講明的判準,與某個[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)或某類[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)不能區分。\n- Definition: A simulation is, under a stated [cut](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c23) and dimension, a [node](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25) that is not a [wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16) whose [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) cannot be distinguished, by criteria the researcher states, from the output of some wo or kind of wo.\n\n\n## public 功能上等同 / Functional Equivalence\n\n- 定義:功能上等同是在講明的維度上,一個不是[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)的[節點](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25)的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)其他[節點](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25)之後,所起的作用與[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)相同。這些作用包括:參與接收者的[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06)、供應或撤除接收者某條[路徑](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c07)的[前件](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c08)、被讀作承載一個內容、以被研究者讀作[可交換](concepts.md#c55)[推演](concepts.md#c36)的[計算](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c05)為[回合](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c04)。\n- Definition: Functional equivalence is the case where, on a stated dimension, the [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) of a [node](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25) that is not a [wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16), after [arriving](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at other nodes, has the same effects as the output of a [wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16). These effects include: taking part in the receiver's [weight](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06); supplying or removing an [antecedent](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c08) of some [path](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c07) of the receiver; being read as carrying a content; and having as its [rounds](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c04) [computations](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c05) that researchers read as [commutative](concepts.md#c55) [inference](concepts.md#c36).\n- 裁決:2026-11-13 全篇掃查指出定義丟了論文「不是渦的節點」的限定;補上。\n\n\n## public 工程門檻 / Engineering Threshold\n\n- 定義:工程門檻是這個判準:指定架構與資源,在指定條件下,能否穩定產生某類[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)。\n- Definition: The engineering threshold is this criterion: given a specified architecture and resources, whether a certain kind of [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) can be produced stably under specified conditions.\n\n\n## public 觀察者辨識門檻 / Observer Recognition Threshold\n\n- 定義:觀察者辨識門檻是外部開始把某類[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)標成「有智力」「會理解」「具有[二階能力](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c02)」的那一點。\n- Definition: The observer recognition threshold is the point at which outsiders begin to label a certain kind of [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) as \"intelligent\", \"understanding\" or \"having [second-order capacity](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c02)\".\n\n\n## public 可交換 / Commutative\n\n- 定義:可交換,指以[表示](concepts.md#c34)代替現實去[推演](concepts.md#c36),推出的結果與之後[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)的相同,也就是[推演結果](concepts.md#c37)與[後段表示](concepts.md#c33)在[允許誤差](concepts.md#c56)內相同。這件事可以就一個[案例](concepts.md#c24)、就已登記的[案例](concepts.md#c24),或就講明的範圍來判定,依序是[在一個案例上可交換](concepts.md#c40)、[在已登記的案例中可交換](concepts.md#c41)與[在範圍內可交換](concepts.md#c42)。\n- Definition: Commutative means that [inferring](concepts.md#c36) with a [representation](concepts.md#c34) in place of reality yields the same result as what [arrives](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) afterwards, that is, the [inference result](concepts.md#c37) and the [later representation](concepts.md#c33) are the same within the [allowed error](concepts.md#c56). This can be judged for one [case](concepts.md#c24), for the registered cases, or for a stated range, which are respectively [commutative on a case](concepts.md#c40), [commutative over registered cases](concepts.md#c41) and [commutative within a range](concepts.md#c42).\n- 裁決:2026-11-11 登記為獨立概念:不加修飾的「可交換」在正文中反覆使用;三個判準是它的三種情形。\n- 裁決:2026-11-11 名稱保留「可交換」,不改為「現實概念一致性」:「一致」暗示表示與現實相像;本概念說的是代替現實去推演時結果相同。\n\n\n## public 允許誤差 / Allowed Error\n\n- 定義:允許誤差是[表示](concepts.md#c34)之間距離的上限:兩個[表示](concepts.md#c34)的距離不超過它,就算在允許誤差內相同。兩個[表示](concepts.md#c34)之間的距離,不超過經由第三個[表示](concepts.md#c34)的兩段距離之和。\n- Definition: The allowed error is an upper bound on the distance between [representations](concepts.md#c34): two representations whose distance does not exceed it count as the same within the allowed error. The distance between two [representations](concepts.md#c34) does not exceed the sum of the two distances by way of a third [representation](concepts.md#c34).\n- 裁決:2026-11-12 登記為獨立概念,修飾子為 public:保留差異、比對、自洽、可交換的定義都用到它,下游須能讀到判準。\n\n## private 〔Providence〕語料庫 / Providence Corpus\n\n- 定義:〔Providence〕語料庫是長期錄下六名英語兒童在家中與父母對話的語料庫。\n- Definition: The Providence Corpus is a corpus of long-term recordings of six English-speaking children's conversations with their parents at home.\n- 裁決:2026-11-12 稽核指出正文使用的具名資料集未登記;純資料構件一律登記,修飾子為 private:它是一份特定的語料庫。\n\n\n## private 三層對照表 / Three-Layer Table\n\n- 定義:三層對照表是把[理論極限](concepts.md#c02)、[工程極限](concepts.md#c03),以及[歷史](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13)與實際落出,分成三個層次,並列出各層是否因工程改善而改變的表。\n- Definition: The three-layer table is the table that sets out the [theoretical limit](concepts.md#c02), the [engineering limit](concepts.md#c03), and [history](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13) together with what actually comes out, as three separate layers, and lists for each layer whether it changes with engineering improvements.\n- 裁決:2026-11-12 稽核指出理論極限、工程極限的裁決都引用三層對照表,表本身卻未登記;純資料構件一律登記,修飾子為 private:它是特定的一張表。正文在表前補上名稱。\n- 裁決:2026-11-14 稽核指出定義把三層統稱為限制,但正文第三層是歷史與實際落出,不是一種限制;改為把三者分成三個層次。\n\n## 不登記\n\n- 記錄範圍:2026-11-11 記帳約定,不是被定義的構件。\n- 命題一至命題六:2026-11-11 推導的局部標籤。\n- 經驗前提一至經驗前提五:2026-11-11 前提的局部標籤。\n- 兩層不互推:2026-11-11 結論的局部標籤。\n- 結論六之一:2026-11-11 結論的局部標籤。\n- 明列不限書面:2026-11-11 結論的局部標籤。\n- 記錄推不出內部:2026-11-11 結論的局部標籤。\n- 一階不是齒輪:2026-11-11 結論的局部標籤。\n- 文化不以分別為條件:2026-11-11 結論的局部標籤。\n- 底層不變:2026-11-11 段落標題。\n- 三層分開:2026-11-11 結論的局部標籤。\n- 一般的幻覺構件:2026-11-11 必要條件清單的項目標題。\n- 自我配置假定的必要條件:2026-11-11 必要條件清單的項目標題。\n- 參與與被運用:2026-11-11 說明的項目標題。\n- 工程層的對應:2026-11-11 說明的項目標題。\n- 名字與次數都不是條件:2026-11-11 說明的項目標題。\n- 瞬間的我:2026-11-11 自我梯子形式段中的記號。\n- 延續的我:2026-11-11 自我梯子形式段中的記號。\n- 信號容器不限書面:2026-11-11 前提的標題。\n- 有限接收:2026-11-11 前提的標題。\n- 推不出:2026-11-11 記號約定;2026-11-12 「不唯一推出」同此。\n- 途徑:2026-11-12 答案寫法的形式,不另立概念。\n- 必要條件:2026-11-12 答案寫法的形式,是上游不會發生的套用,不另立概念。\n- 不保證:2026-11-12 答案寫法的形式,是上游不被保證的套用,不另立概念。\n- 不可確認:2026-11-12 答案寫法的形式,是上游不被保證對外部確認的套用,不另立概念。\n- 構件:2026-11-12 上游幻覺構件的簡稱。\n- 「我」:2026-11-12 記號約定,指作為幻覺構件的「我」這個名稱。\n- 前提:2026-11-12 陳述角色的標籤。\n- 結論:2026-11-12 陳述角色的標籤。\n- 「正確」:2026-11-12 用語約定,不是構件。\n- 失去來源:2026-11-12 推導記帳用語。\n- 不可交換:2026-11-12 指不可交換的情形,不另立概念。\n- 歷史與實際落出:2026-11-11 三層對照表的一列,未被命名為構件。\n- 抽象:2026-11-13 用語約定:只說明這個詞指幻覺構件有所指的對象、能脫離眼前,不指把不同的東西歸成一類;所指的內容由上游幻覺構件的定義承擔,不另立概念。\n- 反應:2026-11-13 日常用語的用語約定:指研究者不歸為分別的那類到達與輸出,不另立概念。\n- 替代:2026-11-13 二之一的說法,指構件在被看的東西不在場時代替它出現;稱它為替代,不主張所替代的對象存在,不另立概念,與替代性不同。\n\n## 待決項\n\n無\n","formalization_md":"論文:《幻覺構件動力學》\nUUID:ed71bef7-0f22-4443-bc1d-4d1ecfe81967\n\n## 記號約定\n\n來源:論文全文\n\n- 個案:一般用語,指 經驗前提 所由校準的實例,不是概念 案例\n- 物理世界:一般用語\n- 回饋:一般用語,不是上游概念「結果回饋」\n- 指標:一般用語\n- 壓縮率:一般用語\n- 同一:一般用語,指同一段、同一類、同一個這類用法;指上游概念時加前綴\n- 出現:一般用語\n- 給定:一般用語\n- 邊界:一般用語\n- 「我」:一般用語,指作為 08383b0a-1167-4efb-9b89-dc8a71afd5ff.幻覺構件 的「我」這個名稱\n- 「這些是我」:一般用語,引述\n- 「真正的我」:一般用語,引述\n- 自我定義:一般用語\n- 自我辨認:一般用語\n- 「你」「我」「它」:一般用語,引述\n- 『我』:一般用語,引述中的「我」\n- 「我們」:一般用語,引述\n- 「你們」:一般用語,引述\n- 那邊:一般用語\n- 決定:一般用語,動詞;指上游概念時加前綴\n- 涉及:一般用語\n- 門檻較低:一般用語\n- 更新:一般用語\n- 不可交換:一般用語,指不 可交換 的情形,不另立概念\n- 理解:一般用語\n- 相信:一般用語\n- 前件:一般用語,不是上游概念\n- 衝突:一般用語,不是上游概念「衝突」\n- 推不出:用語約定,指從本篇所列的來源與 81952268-47b1-4d8c-9605-270c42646693.記錄 推不出唯一的結果,不主張在任何條件、任何材料之下都推不出(二之二)\n- 「權重」:一般用語,引述工程模型所用的詞,不是上游概念\n\n## 前置條件\n\n來源:論文第一節第四小節【正文:句7155010754】\n\n- 前提一 [限定條件]:研究者沒有 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.歷史 之外的位置:研究者提出 08383b0a-1167-4efb-9b89-dc8a71afd5ff.幻覺構件、發表論文、改寫定義,都是 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出;若 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 研究對象或他人,同樣參與後續 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.歷史。【正文:句4440567272】\n- 前提二:研究者是一個 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.我。【正文:句8684701403】\n- 前提三:自我配置假定:在講明的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.切法 下,對切出的某個 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦,假定它以 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別 定義自己。【正文:句9515852547】\n- 前提四:37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦 的一次 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別 與它的一筆 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出,在下一 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.時刻 之前 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 這個 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦 自己,參與它之後的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.權重。【正文:句9349737364、句7102143930】\n- 前提五:說出口的話、廣播、電視,在離開說話者之後都記為 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.信號容器。【正文:句6252041955、句7990229152】\n- 前提六:任何實際的感官、感測器或作 壓縮 者,只能接收現實中物理事件的一部分;對任何 標的,它 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.自己的那一段 所涉及的物理事件,也不能全部被接收。【正文:句0478351393】\n\n[作者裁決] 2026-11-12 稽核指出原 前提六 只說收到的是整個現實的一部分,撐不住「到達材料 不是 標的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.自己的那一段 的全部」;作者裁定前提六補上對任何 標的 的這一句,論文第三節同步改;步驟五之二、步驟五之三之三、結論五之四之三 依此。\n- 前提七 [限定條件]:以 容納能力、運算能力、記憶能力、壓縮能力、構造能力 五項 工程能力 描述載體。【正文:句1478542587、句4738096654、句9536298540、句9657630320、句8036619393、句4638661075、句0134096724】\n- 前提八 [限定條件]:在指定 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.切法 下,載體若有限,在任何講明的有限描述中,不同的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 必然有對應到同一描述狀態的情形;這不推出那些 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 不再參與 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.權重。【正文:句5308218729、句3706786134】\n- 前提九:在邏輯狀態這個 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.切法 下,以圖靈機為設計基底的數位人工智慧,每一 fb0addca-42b6-4884-aa18-438c695747ab.回合 不是 fb0addca-42b6-4884-aa18-438c695747ab.鎖死的回合,就是 fb0addca-42b6-4884-aa18-438c695747ab.隨機的回合。【正文:句5469139514】\n- 前提十:81952268-47b1-4d8c-9605-270c42646693.記錄 範圍:只登記 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 的物理改變,不登記 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別 內容;37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別 在作出它的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦 的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.歷史 中,不在 81952268-47b1-4d8c-9605-270c42646693.記錄 裡。【正文:句4920096519、句7068497237、句6690055454】\n- 前提十一 [限定條件]:定義隔離與更名不變性。【正文:句6272284982、句3970281319】\n- 前提十二:經驗前提 一:沒有留下自己 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 的某種副本,或沒有把副本與隨後的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 對照,就沒有 自他區辨。【正文:句2535742804、句4828737992】\n- 前提十三:經驗前提 二:沒有跨越不同 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.時刻 的保留,或沒有把不同 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.時刻 自己造成的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 壓縮 為同一類,就沒有 跨時刻歸併。【正文:句3388466657、句8402576219】\n\n[作者裁決] 2026-11-12「沒有……,也沒有……」意思不清;作者裁定為缺任何一項就沒有 跨時刻歸併,論文改為「或沒有」。\n- 前提十四:經驗前提 三:沒有跨 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.時刻 的保留,08383b0a-1167-4efb-9b89-dc8a71afd5ff.幻覺構件 的內容就不能在 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.刺激 不在場時參與 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 的組織。【正文:句6753787196、句4273298899】\n- 前提十五:經驗前提 四:在研究者講明的若干維度上,目前的人工智慧 的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 與人的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 不能區分。【正文:句0658269106、句9679435150】\n- 前提十六:經驗前提 五:有 自己維持的篩選邊界 的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦,b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 偏向維持邊界內部;這一條由已觀察的 個案 歸納而來。【正文:句0644525307、句9439693208】\n- 前提十七:本篇把一次 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別 讀作:界線兩側都有 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達,而且至少有一側把不只一筆 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 看作一個。【正文:句9383660537、句0126286154】\n- 前提十八:本篇記為:目前的人工智慧 的載體,能作五項 工程能力 所衡量的各類動作與保留。【正文:句2290528522、句2725937221】\n- 前提十九:本篇記為:對四問的答案,只寫途徑、必要條件、不保證與不可確認四種東西,不寫充分條件。【正文:句6402963729、句2211517373、句5181793891】\n- 前提二十:本篇記為:構造 相同、約束只由 構造 與狀態決定的機器之間,狀態可以完整讀出並複製。【正文:句2883002035、句8971215064】\n- 前提二十一:本篇記為:所討論的人是 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦:依 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.應用假定 假定它不被 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.鎖死,並假定 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 它的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.歷史 都參與它的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.權重;本篇主要討論 08383b0a-1167-4efb-9b89-dc8a71afd5ff.社會人,稱某個人為 08383b0a-1167-4efb-9b89-dc8a71afd5ff.社會人 依 ae79e938-76e1-4bf9-b2ab-995c03e16c9e.配置假定 作出。【正文:句8639425324、句4391273707、句9337237887、句0325968095】\n- 前提二十二:本篇記為:不假定不同範圍的約束相同;兩個 案例 用同一套約束,指同樣的輸入在兩個 案例 中有同樣的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.權重 分布,是另外講明的條件。【正文:句1506456454、句3983762592】\n- 前提二十三:本篇記為:網路可維持的複雜度不由 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦 的能力單獨推出,人口、分工、資源、b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.信號容器 與 2ccbf179-58cf-4851-bd72-5fa886e4b2c3.模板 的維護、37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 密度都參與;本篇不處理網路層。【正文:句8178366070、句5894156436、句8027572413】\n- 前提二十四:本篇記為:37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦 的定義中「37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 它的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.歷史 都參與 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.權重」,讀作在每一個 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.時刻 都成立。【正文:句4728003356、句3514948729】\n\n附註:前提十二至前提十四採 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.經驗禁止 的形式,只寫缺少時 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.不會發生;前提十五 是對既有測試結果的登記,前提十六 是由觀察歸納的概括,兩者都不是必要條件。【正文:句1437092442、句6820656695、句4575869390、句9439693208】\n\n## 一、問題與定位\n\n來源:論文第一節【正文:句1362163649】\n\n附註:一之一 只陳述研究問題,不承擔推導。【正文:句3660992328】\n\n- 步驟一之二之三:研究者把一筆 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 劃為對象的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別,是把對象當作另一個 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.我 所作的 fb0addca-42b6-4884-aa18-438c695747ab.看法歸屬,可能歸錯;所以從外部確認對象有沒有某次 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別,b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.不被保證(從 前提十 + 前提二 + fb0addca-42b6-4884-aa18-438c695747ab.看法歸屬 的定義 + b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.不被保證 的定義 推出)。【正文:句1277207114】\n\n[作者裁決] 2026-11-13 稽核指出 fb0addca-42b6-4884-aa18-438c695747ab.看法歸屬 的對象是另一個 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.我,原陳述只寫研究者把 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 劃為對象的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別;論文與本步驟、步驟一之五之五 補上「把對象當作另一個 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.我」。\n\n- 步驟一之三之一:屬於(37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.流變律, 理論極限);屬於(37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.黑箱律, 理論極限);屬於(37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.不可復原律, 理論極限);屬於(37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.損耗律, 理論極限)(從 理論極限 的定義 推出)。【正文:句2967091116】\n- 結論一之三之一:理論極限 不因工程改善而改變(從 步驟一之三之一 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.流變律 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.黑箱律 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.不可復原律 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.損耗律 推出)。【正文:句4234635646】\n- 結論一之三之二:工程極限 可能因工程改善而改變(從 工程極限 的定義 + 工程能力 的定義 推出)。【正文:句9326415741、句4234635646】\n- 結論一之三之三:即使工程架構相近,不被 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.鎖死 的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦,不同的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.歷史 與 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 可能落出不同 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出;它的下一 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.時刻 不能事先唯一推出,不保證唯一結果(從 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.黑箱律 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦 的定義 推出)。【正文:句5916276157、句4234635646】\n\n[作者裁決] 2026-11-12 稽核指出原陳述只說 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.黑箱律 的適用不受工程架構影響,沒有寫出正文第三層的主張;改為寫出不同的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.歷史 與 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 可能落出不同 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出,來源補 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦 的定義。\n\n附註:本篇不為發明、2ccbf179-58cf-4851-bd72-5fa886e4b2c3.文化、08383b0a-1167-4efb-9b89-dc8a71afd5ff.幻覺構件、文明或智力另增底層生成律。【正文:句6217352586】\n\n附註:工程可實現的範圍通常遠小於物理上可能的範圍,只是直觀判斷,本篇不給可比較的狀態空間與測度。【正文:句5555789090、句3355373398】\n\n- 結論一之三之四:三層對照表 把 理論極限、工程極限,以及 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.歷史 與實際落出,分成三個層次(從 三層對照表 的定義 推出)。【正文:句3803118568、句0836334659、句2967091116、句9326415741、句5916276157】\n\n[作者裁決] 2026-11-14 稽核指出原陳述把三層統稱為限制,但正文第三層是 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.歷史 與實際落出,不是一種限制;改為把三者分成三個層次;概念表 三層對照表 的定義同步改。\n- 步驟一之五之一:「這些是我」所指的界線,不由物理世界給出(從 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.我 的定義 + b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.切法 的定義 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.個體 的定義 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別 的定義 推出)。【正文:句3320793942、句4503235409、句2734799573】\n\n- 結論一之五之一:「我」用來描述或組織 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 時,是 08383b0a-1167-4efb-9b89-dc8a71afd5ff.幻覺構件(從 步驟一之五之一 + 08383b0a-1167-4efb-9b89-dc8a71afd5ff.幻覺構件 的定義 推出)。【正文:句8505334284】\n- 步驟一之五之二:研究者能用「我」把一個 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦 的大量 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 歸成少數 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別(從 結論一之五之一 + 08383b0a-1167-4efb-9b89-dc8a71afd5ff.幻覺構件 的定義 推出)。【正文:句9434843399、句0257056163、句7958635702、句0693769441】\n- 步驟一之五之三:有 自己維持的篩選邊界 的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦,b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 偏向維持邊界內部(從 前提十六 推出)。【正文:句1297245251】\n\n[作者裁決] 2026-11-12 這是由已觀察的 個案 歸納的概括,不由 自己維持的篩選邊界 的定義推出;論文第十節立為 經驗前提 五,本步驟依 前提十六。\n- 步驟一之五之四:研究者講明以該 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦 為 標的 的 案例,以「它在維持自己」概括這些 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出,並把作這個概括的那段 fb0addca-42b6-4884-aa18-438c695747ab.回合 讀作把 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 他的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 轉成 表示 時,依 壓縮 的定義,這是一次 壓縮;這不推出該 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦 以 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別 定義自己(從 fb0addca-42b6-4884-aa18-438c695747ab.回合 的定義 + 壓縮 的定義 + 步驟一之五之三 + 自己維持的篩選邊界 的定義 + 案例 的定義 + 標的 的定義 + 到達材料 的定義 + 表示 的定義 推出)。【正文:句1297245251】\n\n[作者裁決] 2026-11-13 稽核指出原步驟把研究者的概括直接判為一次 壓縮;作者裁定比照五之六的寫法,限定為研究者把那段 fb0addca-42b6-4884-aa18-438c695747ab.回合 讀作把 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 轉成 表示 時才是 壓縮;論文同步改。\n- 步驟一之五之五:被研究的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦 的自述是一筆 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出;研究者把它劃為對方的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別,是把對方當作另一個 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.我 所作的 fb0addca-42b6-4884-aa18-438c695747ab.看法歸屬,可能歸錯(從 前提十 + 前提二 + fb0addca-42b6-4884-aa18-438c695747ab.看法歸屬 的定義 推出)。【正文:句9445050807】\n- 步驟一之五之六:沒有任何 fb0addca-42b6-4884-aa18-438c695747ab.回合 是 fb0addca-42b6-4884-aa18-438c695747ab.決定 的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.呈現,不是 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦(從 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦 的定義 + fb0addca-42b6-4884-aa18-438c695747ab.決定 的定義 + 前提二十四 推出)。【正文:句9725815335、句2892495347】\n- 結論一之五之二:自我配置假定 從外部確認 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.不被保證;對象缺少 前提十二 或 前提十三 所列的某項條件,或找到機制證明它沒有任何 fb0addca-42b6-4884-aa18-438c695747ab.回合 是 fb0addca-42b6-4884-aa18-438c695747ab.決定 時,這項假定對它不成立(從 前提三 + 步驟一之五之五 + 步驟一之五之六 + 步驟一之二之三 + 前提十二 + 前提十三 + 自我配置假定 的定義 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別 的定義 推出)。【正文:句3760339842、句9725815335】\n- 步驟一之五之七:換一種 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.切法,自我配置假定 可以落在不同的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦 上,也可以同時落在巢狀的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦 上(從 前提三 + 自我配置假定 的定義 + b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.重切 的定義 推出)。【正文:句3075854329】\n\n[作者裁決] 2026-11-13 稽核指出本步驟漏列直接來源;補上 自我配置假定 的定義。\n- 步驟一之五之八:研究者把別人的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 讀成對方在這個尺度上劃出自己的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別,是一次 fb0addca-42b6-4884-aa18-438c695747ab.看法歸屬,可能歸錯(從 前提二 + fb0addca-42b6-4884-aa18-438c695747ab.看法歸屬 的定義 推出)。【正文:句5318338840、句9445050807】\n\n附註:上游定義中用到 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.我 的概念,在本篇只用於研究者這一方,或作為研究者歸屬時所用的 08383b0a-1167-4efb-9b89-dc8a71afd5ff.幻覺構件,不作為被研究的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦 的前件;本篇改變的是問題,不判定上游錯誤。【正文:句2598881604、句1416176602】\n\n附註:被研究的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦 有沒有 fb0addca-42b6-4884-aa18-438c695747ab.一階分別 或 fb0addca-42b6-4884-aa18-438c695747ab.二階分別,依 ae79e938-76e1-4bf9-b2ab-995c03e16c9e.配置假定;依 08383b0a-1167-4efb-9b89-dc8a71afd5ff.二階能力 的定義,它也是 08383b0a-1167-4efb-9b89-dc8a71afd5ff.幻覺構件。【正文:句9108769337、句5659760797】\n\n附註:研究者通常把「我」假定在人的尺度上;這樣做的實際理由,不使人這個尺度成為「真正的我」。【正文:句5318338840、句5387201808】\n\n\n- 結論一之六:有損的推廣:一筆 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 一個 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.呈現 的,不是另一個 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.自己的那一段 的全部;這不依賴接收者是不是 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.我(從 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 的定義 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.刺激 的定義 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.自己的那一段 的定義 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.歷史 的定義 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦 的定義 推出)。【正文:句0320579176、句8771823023、句5999220364、句6097273148】\n\n[作者裁決] 2026-11-12 稽核指出原結論對任何 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.呈現、任何筆數的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 都說不是全部,來源只撐到一筆 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達、對方是 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦;作者裁定照推得出的範圍收窄,概念 有損的推廣 的定義同步收窄;第五節「到達材料 不是全部」改依 前提六。\n\n[作者裁決] 2026-11-12 稽核指出 步驟一之六之一、步驟一之六之二 重述上游定義;刪除,結論改依 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達、37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.刺激、37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.自己的那一段 與 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.歷史 的定義;全篇同類重述一併刪除或改寫為「依某某的定義」。\n\n[作者裁決] 2026-11-11 論文補上「另一個 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.呈現 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.自己的那一段」與一筆 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 在範圍上的關係,結論改依 步驟一之六之二;2026-11-12 該步驟因重述上游定義刪除,結論改依 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.自己的那一段 與 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.歷史 的定義。(2026-11-12 再收窄為一筆 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達、另一個 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦。)\n- 步驟一之六之三:就一筆 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達、fb0addca-42b6-4884-aa18-438c695747ab.被看的東西 是另一個 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦 而言,fb0addca-42b6-4884-aa18-438c695747ab.有損 是 有損的推廣 落在 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.我 身上的情形(從 結論一之六 + fb0addca-42b6-4884-aa18-438c695747ab.有損 的定義 推出)。【正文:句6856462261】\n\n## 二、承接與術語\n\n來源:論文第二節【正文:句1763172841】\n\n- 結論二之一之一:研究者用某個 08383b0a-1167-4efb-9b89-dc8a71afd5ff.幻覺構件 描述某筆 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出,推不出當事 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦 內部有它;當事 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦 說出它的名稱,也推不出它內部的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別 等於研究者所定義的(從 前提十 + fb0addca-42b6-4884-aa18-438c695747ab.看法歸屬 的定義 推出)。【正文:句8734829972、句8113626227】\n- 步驟二之一之二:把許多被劃為一個的歸成一類,是在依 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.個體 的定義劃出的界線上再劃一次;依 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別 的定義,37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別 劃出的都是這類界線;所以 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別 內容所指的對象,都不由物理世界直接給出(從 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.切法 的定義 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.個體 的定義 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別 的定義 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.同一 的定義 推出)。【正文:句2734799573、句2506418978、句3895538594、句6057635656】\n- 循環二之一之一:37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦 的一次 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別 留下 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.寫入;這次 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別 與一筆 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 在下一 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.時刻 之前 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 這個 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦 自己,參與它之後的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.權重;37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別 的內容可以經由 2ccbf179-58cf-4851-bd72-5fa886e4b2c3.小迴路 再次 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達,參與它後續的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別 與 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出,後續的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別 又留下 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.寫入,再回到自己。退出條件:37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.寫入 不被抹去,對象仍是 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦 時,回到自己、參與 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.權重 這一層不退出;對象依 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦 的定義不再是 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦 時,循環退出;這個內容成為 08383b0a-1167-4efb-9b89-dc8a71afd5ff.幻覺構件 之後,不相符的材料 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 這個 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦 時,它是否因此不再被運用,b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.不被保證(從 前提四 + 2ccbf179-58cf-4851-bd72-5fa886e4b2c3.小迴路 的定義 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦 的定義 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.歷史 的定義 + b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.不被保證 的定義 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別 的定義 推出)。【正文:句9349737364、句7102143930、句6374036179、句4728003356、句9342441464、句0738869246、句7778742098】\n\n[作者裁決] 2026-11-13 全篇掃查指出「b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 留下 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.寫入」在來源中找不到;作者裁定改為 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別 留下 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.寫入,37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別 與 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 依 前提四 回到自己。\n\n[作者裁決] 2026-11-12 同類掃查發現末句對一般的內容無條件地說 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.不被保證,論文只在不相符的材料 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 時對 08383b0a-1167-4efb-9b89-dc8a71afd5ff.幻覺構件 這樣說;收窄到與論文相同。\n- 結論二之一之二:一次 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別 的內容經由 2ccbf179-58cf-4851-bd72-5fa886e4b2c3.小迴路 再次 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 該 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦,被用來指某個對象,並組織它後續的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別 與 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 時,這個內容符合 08383b0a-1167-4efb-9b89-dc8a71afd5ff.幻覺構件 的定義(從 循環二之一之一 + 步驟二之一之二 + 08383b0a-1167-4efb-9b89-dc8a71afd5ff.幻覺構件 的定義 推出)。【正文:句0738869246】\n- 步驟二之一之三:這個內容的材料只有已經 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 該 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦 的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.歷史;fb0addca-42b6-4884-aa18-438c695747ab.被看的東西 若是另一個 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦,其中每一筆 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 都不是那個 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.自己的那一段 的全部(從 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別 的定義 + 結論一之六 推出)。【正文:句3587980886】\n\n[作者裁決] 2026-11-12 稽核指出 結論一之六 只及於一筆 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達,原步驟卻對整個內容說不是全部;作者裁定收窄為其中每一筆 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達,來源補 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別 的定義,論文同步改。\n\n附註:正文說這個內容可以看作 fb0addca-42b6-4884-aa18-438c695747ab.被看的東西 不在場時的替代;這是一種描述的方式,不進入推導;稱它為替代,不主張它所替代的對象存在。【正文:句3587980886】\n- 步驟二之一之四:在一個 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦 的第一個 08383b0a-1167-4efb-9b89-dc8a71afd5ff.幻覺構件 出現之前,它作出的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別,材料中沒有作為它自己 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別 內容的 08383b0a-1167-4efb-9b89-dc8a71afd5ff.幻覺構件(從 08383b0a-1167-4efb-9b89-dc8a71afd5ff.幻覺構件 的定義 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別 的定義 推出)。【正文:句0996518211、句5976209220、句9576601515】\n\n[作者裁決] 2026-11-11 結論限於作為 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別 內容的 08383b0a-1167-4efb-9b89-dc8a71afd5ff.幻覺構件;上游定義中描述與 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 所用的 08383b0a-1167-4efb-9b89-dc8a71afd5ff.幻覺構件,不以作出者有 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別 為條件,不在此列。\n\n附註:物理世界給出 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 的不對稱,例如細胞膜、皮膚;有些 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.切法 正好落在這種不對稱上。【正文:句2706614103】\n\n附註:承載 08383b0a-1167-4efb-9b89-dc8a71afd5ff.幻覺構件 的聲音、文字、手勢、容器與行動都是物理 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出;研究者純粹重命名一個符號,不改變被研究者的物理 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.歷史。【正文:句9645691025、句1373960264】\n\n- 步驟二之二之二:依 08383b0a-1167-4efb-9b89-dc8a71afd5ff.宣稱界線 的定義所列以分類為內容的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 可以重疊:一句說出口的 08383b0a-1167-4efb-9b89-dc8a71afd5ff.宣誓,離開說話者之後也在 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.信號容器 中(從 08383b0a-1167-4efb-9b89-dc8a71afd5ff.宣稱界線 的定義 + 前提五 推出)。【正文:句1087456366】\n\n[作者裁決] 2026-11-13 全篇掃查指出前提五 只在離開說話者之後才把說出口的話記為 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.信號容器;作者裁定補上這項限定;論文同步改。\n\n附註:本篇在工程層不以上游已有所指的詞指稱工程上的東西或動作。【正文:句3563788484、句5284501478】\n\n附註:二之二其餘各項是用語約定,不承擔推導。【正文:句7829022580、句6164077174、句3576540350】\n\n## 二之三、前提四\n\n來源:論文第二節第三小節【正文:句2749625861】\n\n附註:前提四 推廣了上游 fb0addca-42b6-4884-aa18-438c695747ab.盲點牆 與 fb0addca-42b6-4884-aa18-438c695747ab.來路牆 對以自己為對象的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別 所寫的內容;上游沒有寫明在下一 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.時刻 之前。【正文:句2643060938】\n\n## 三、工程能力\n\n來源:論文第三節【正文:句5943765794】\n\n附註:五項 工程能力 不是 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦 的必要且充分條件,不窮盡 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦 的能力,也不是另外的律;目前的人工智慧 與生物之間只作對照,不主張內部機制相同。【正文:句7035576420、句6671314105】\n\n附註:本篇以 工程能力 表述的必要條件,是 前提十二、前提十三 與 前提十四。【正文:句3587414821】\n\n附註:不同模態不是不同的底層動力學;「現實近乎無限高維」只是直觀,不是定理。【正文:句8181955892、句9148688712】\n\n- 結論三之一之一:沒有被取得的資訊,單憑既有輸入不保證能重建(從 前提六 + b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.不被保證 的定義 推出)。【正文:句1680845268】\n- 結論三之一之二:一個 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦 需要多少能力,能不能歸成少數幾個維度,推不出(從 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦 的定義 + b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.份量 的定義 + b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.不被保證 的定義 推出)。【正文:句9203464461】\n\n[作者裁決] 2026-11-11 論文把「不能歸成少數幾個維度」改為「推不出」;b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.份量 不能相加,只推出框架不斷言能歸成少數維度。\n- 結論三之一之三:研究者對 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦 的能力所作的量化,作為統計估計時是 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.印象,不是能力本身的讀數(從 前提二 + b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.印象 的定義 推出)。【正文:句8025012014、句7746597415】\n\n[作者裁決] 2026-11-12 稽核指出原寫「任何量化都是一次投影」是全稱主張,來源不足;作者裁定刪去,只保留對 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦 的統計估計是 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.印象,來源刪去 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.切法 的定義,論文同步改。\n\n附註:感官本身的 fb0addca-42b6-4884-aa18-438c695747ab.回合,研究者也讀作先作選擇、運算 與 壓縮;「先於」是分析上的區分,不是固定的流水線順序。【正文:句6564416252】\n\n- 結論三之三:五項 工程能力 都是衡量載體某類動作或保留的指標,不是依次執行的工序;同一機制可以同時落在幾項指標所衡量的面向上(從 工程能力 的定義 + 容納能力 的定義 + 運算能力 的定義 + 記憶能力 的定義 + 壓縮能力 的定義 + 構造能力 的定義 推出)。【正文:句4738096654、句9931575011、句7755806992】\n\n附註:這是分析關係,不是特定網路的逐層執行流程,也不取代上游的 fb0addca-42b6-4884-aa18-438c695747ab.回合 定義。【正文:句8111219507】\n\n- 結論三之四之一:37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦 的定義不推出載體上有任何找得到的痕跡或 表示(從 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦 的定義 推出)。【正文:句3901176140、句6086950375】\n- 結論三之四之二:某項 工程能力 低於某個程度的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦,是否不會在講明的時窗內存續,推不出(從 經驗前提 的定義 + b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.不被保證 的定義 + 工程能力 的定義 推出)。【正文:句6233220561】\n\n附註:本篇沒有指定是哪項能力、什麼程度、什麼外在條件與時窗,所以不把它立為 經驗前提。【正文:句6233220561】\n\n- 結論三之四之三:存續者的表現不足以推出「能力越強越能存續」(從 81952268-47b1-4d8c-9605-270c42646693.現存樣本條件化 推出)。【正文:句1752596276】\n\n- 結論三之五之一:構造 不等於上游的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.權重(從 構造 的定義 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.權重 的定義 推出)。【正文:句1149260459】\n\n附註:構造 也不等於欲望或目的。【正文:句1149260459】\n\n附註:本篇不把任何工程上的量當作已測得的某個 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦 的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.權重。【正文:句3926666668】\n\n附註:錯誤 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 不必然來自 構造;本篇稱 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 正確,只在給定了任務、比較對象、可觀察條件、 允許誤差 與評估時窗之後;一筆正確答案不證成同名的內部能力。【正文:句7031838108、句0326247701、句4287834666】\n\n## 四、第一問:功能\n\n來源:論文第四節【正文:句2099455843】\n\n附註:說某個 08383b0a-1167-4efb-9b89-dc8a71afd5ff.幻覺構件 有某項 功能,只寫必要條件,不指目的。【正文:句0777677073、句8142085502】\n\n- 步驟四之二之二:37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別 的內容只參與之後的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出、沒有被用來指某個對象時,是 單純的分別,不是 08383b0a-1167-4efb-9b89-dc8a71afd5ff.幻覺構件(從 單純的分別 的定義 + 08383b0a-1167-4efb-9b89-dc8a71afd5ff.幻覺構件 的定義 推出)。【正文:句7639812156】\n- 步驟四之二之三:依 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦 的定義,37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.歷史 都參與它的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.權重,這種參與不以所指的對象為條件(從 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦 的定義 推出)。【正文:句8931339891】\n- 結論四之二:08383b0a-1167-4efb-9b89-dc8a71afd5ff.幻覺構件 與 單純的分別 的差別不在參與,而在有沒有所指的對象(從 08383b0a-1167-4efb-9b89-dc8a71afd5ff.幻覺構件 的定義 + 步驟四之二之二 + 步驟四之二之三 推出)。【正文:句3529450993、句9780520666】\n\n- 步驟四之三之一:一個內容指著某個對象,是把某些 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.呈現 看作一個對象;依 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.切法 與 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.個體 的定義,這個對象不由物理世界直接給出;這樣的內容被用來組織 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 時,依 08383b0a-1167-4efb-9b89-dc8a71afd5ff.幻覺構件 的定義是 08383b0a-1167-4efb-9b89-dc8a71afd5ff.幻覺構件(從 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.切法 的定義 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.個體 的定義 + 08383b0a-1167-4efb-9b89-dc8a71afd5ff.幻覺構件 的定義 + fb0addca-42b6-4884-aa18-438c695747ab.被看的東西 的定義 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別 的定義 推出)。【正文:句7542825458】\n- 結論四之三之一:指代:沒有 08383b0a-1167-4efb-9b89-dc8a71afd5ff.幻覺構件,就不能在 fb0addca-42b6-4884-aa18-438c695747ab.被看的東西 不在場時,以一個內容指著它參與 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 的組織(從 步驟四之三之一 + 08383b0a-1167-4efb-9b89-dc8a71afd5ff.幻覺構件 的定義 + 指代 的定義 推出)。【正文:句3986074637】\n- 結論四之三之二:推演:沒有 08383b0a-1167-4efb-9b89-dc8a71afd5ff.幻覺構件,就不能把 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別 的內容拿來與其他內容組合,推出關於尚未 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 的東西的新內容(從 08383b0a-1167-4efb-9b89-dc8a71afd5ff.幻覺構件 的定義 + 推演 的定義 推出)。【正文:句1692811021、句4609807431】\n- 步驟四之三之二:把一段 fb0addca-42b6-4884-aa18-438c695747ab.回合 讀作 推演,用到讀它的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦 的 08383b0a-1167-4efb-9b89-dc8a71afd5ff.幻覺構件(從 推演 的定義 推出)。【正文:句4101267960】\n- 步驟四之三之七:名稱、標記、地圖上的一塊,若被讀作指著某個對象的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出,它們所指的對象不由物理世界直接給出,這樣的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 依 08383b0a-1167-4efb-9b89-dc8a71afd5ff.幻覺構件 的定義是 08383b0a-1167-4efb-9b89-dc8a71afd5ff.幻覺構件 出現在 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 中(從 步驟四之三之一 + 08383b0a-1167-4efb-9b89-dc8a71afd5ff.幻覺構件 的定義 推出)。【正文:句3388517405】\n- 結論四之三之三:在渦之間傳遞:沒有 08383b0a-1167-4efb-9b89-dc8a71afd5ff.幻覺構件,37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 他人的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 中,沒有指著某個對象的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出(從 步驟四之三之七 + 在渦之間傳遞 的定義 + b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 的定義 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 的定義 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別 的定義 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.寫入 的定義 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.刺激 的定義 推出)。【正文:句5322375870、句6900912150、句4015502167、句1132355170】\n\n[作者裁決] 2026-11-13 稽核指出依 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 的定義推不出「只有行為 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出」;作者裁定刪去這半句,只留沒有指著某個對象的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出;論文同步改。\n\n- 步驟四之三之五:單純的分別 照樣留下 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.寫入、照樣參與之後的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.權重;缺少 08383b0a-1167-4efb-9b89-dc8a71afd5ff.幻覺構件 時缺的,不是參與,而是指著某個對象(從 單純的分別 的定義 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦 的定義 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別 的定義 推出)。【正文:句6744652060、句6417000170、句8149852697】\n\n附註:在工程層,有所指的內容對應可再次 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達、被處理的 表示;這是對應,不是推導。【正文:句2400406583、句9746810272、句7307703392】\n\n- 步驟四之三之六:名稱與次數都不是條件:08383b0a-1167-4efb-9b89-dc8a71afd5ff.幻覺構件 的定義不以有名稱或出現多次為條件;一個內容沒有名稱,或只說過一次,也可以是 08383b0a-1167-4efb-9b89-dc8a71afd5ff.幻覺構件(從 08383b0a-1167-4efb-9b89-dc8a71afd5ff.幻覺構件 的定義 推出)。【正文:句1251346425、句5717717849】\n\n附註:校準:「你」「我」「它」不是任何東西的名字,所指的是位置。【正文:句1251346425】\n\n- 結論四之三之四:08383b0a-1167-4efb-9b89-dc8a71afd5ff.幻覺構件 可以經由 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 在渦之間傳遞;但它沒有出現在 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 中的時候,81952268-47b1-4d8c-9605-270c42646693.記錄 中只有 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出,從外部推不出這個 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦 內部有沒有這個 08383b0a-1167-4efb-9b89-dc8a71afd5ff.幻覺構件,能判定的只有它有沒有出現在 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 中(從 前提十 + 08383b0a-1167-4efb-9b89-dc8a71afd5ff.幻覺構件 的定義 + 在渦之間傳遞 的定義 + 結論二之一之二 推出)。【正文:句3512736436】\n\n[作者裁決] 2026-11-13 稽核兩次指出原結論「是否一般在 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 要 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 別人時才出現、占多大部分,推不出」只依 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.不被保證 的定義,來源不足;作者裁定原句把「出現在 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 中」與「37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦 內部有沒有」混在一起,論文改寫為:沒有出現在 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 中的時候,從外部推不出內部有沒有;來源改為 前提十、08383b0a-1167-4efb-9b89-dc8a71afd5ff.幻覺構件 的定義、在渦之間傳遞 的定義與 結論二之一之二。論文同時刪去「這是校準」一句。\n\n附註:麵包師傅與爬山的例子是舉例,不作為推導來源。【正文:句7915682929】\n\n## 五、壓縮 與 可交換\n\n來源:論文第五節【正文:句9058162556】\n\n- 步驟五之一之一:37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別 劃出界線;依 前提十七,界線兩側都有 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達,至少有一側把不只一筆 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 看作一個;不同的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 分在界線兩側是 區辨,歸在同一側是 歸併,所以兩者並存(從 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別 的定義 + 前提十七 + 區辨 的定義 + 歸併 的定義 推出)。【正文:句9383660537、句0843869497】\n\n[作者裁決] 2026-11-12 稽核指出 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別 的定義不保證每次都把至少兩筆 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 看作一個;論文把一次 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別 讀作「界線兩側都有 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達,至少有一側把不只一筆 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 看作一個」,立為前提,本步驟依 前提十七。\n- 步驟五之一之二:歸併 是 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別 的內容;壓縮 是研究者對 fb0addca-42b6-4884-aa18-438c695747ab.回合 的讀法,兩者不等同(從 歸併 的定義 + 壓縮 的定義 推出)。【正文:句7799127480】\n- 結論五之一之一:兩層不互推:載體上有 表示,推不出有 08383b0a-1167-4efb-9b89-dc8a71afd5ff.幻覺構件;研究者歸屬了某個 08383b0a-1167-4efb-9b89-dc8a71afd5ff.幻覺構件,也推不出載體上找得到對應的 表示(從 結論三之四之一 + 前提二 + 前提十 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別 的定義 + 表示 的定義 + 壓縮 的定義 + b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.節點 的定義 + 08383b0a-1167-4efb-9b89-dc8a71afd5ff.幻覺構件 的定義 + 步驟一之二之三 推出)。【正文:句0608329116、句8149457360、句9671321511】\n- 結論五之一之二:壓縮 不自帶材料:可 壓縮 的材料受 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 與 容納能力 限制,比較、組合受 運算能力 限制,保留與再取用受 記憶能力 限制(從 容納能力 的定義 + 運算能力 的定義 + 記憶能力 的定義 + 到達材料 的定義 + 壓縮 的定義 推出)。【正文:句0366650435、句8653398001】\n\n[作者裁決] 2026-11-13 稽核指出 構造能力 的定義只撐到 構造 參與 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 的形成,推不出它參與決定保留或捨棄哪些差異;作者裁定刪去這半句;論文同步改。\n\n- 步驟五之一之三:某個 表示 實際出現,仍受具體 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.歷史、輸入與 構造 影響,不能從能力提高直接推出(從 結論五之一之二 + 壓縮 的定義 + fb0addca-42b6-4884-aa18-438c695747ab.回合 的定義 推出)。【正文:句8129877714】\n\n[作者裁決] 2026-11-12 稽核指出受具體 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.歷史 影響一項沒有列來源;來源補 壓縮 的定義與 fb0addca-42b6-4884-aa18-438c695747ab.回合 的定義。\n- 步驟五之一之四:在其他條件固定、某項 工程能力 提高、其他指標不受損的假設下,可形成的 表示 範圍可能擴張(從 結論五之一之二 + 容納能力 的定義 + 記憶能力 的定義 + 運算能力 的定義 + 壓縮能力 的定義 + 構造能力 的定義 推出)。【正文:句8129877714】\n\n- 步驟五之二:壓縮 把 到達材料 轉成 表示;到達材料 不是 標的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.自己的那一段 的全部,所以經由 壓縮 落出的 表示 所依據的,不是 標的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.自己的那一段 的全部(從 壓縮 的定義 + 到達材料 的定義 + 前提六 推出)。【正文:句9688541703、句6000190540】\n\n[作者裁決] 2026-11-13 稽核指出原步驟說一切 表示 都由 到達材料 轉成,壓縮 的定義只撐到經由 壓縮 落出的 表示;作者裁定收窄為經由 壓縮 落出的 表示,四之三說明 2 同型一併收窄;論文同步改。\n\n附註:五之三的各項是定義;判準只用到 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達、b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出、fb0addca-42b6-4884-aa18-438c695747ab.回合 與 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.切法,不假定任何 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.節點 能直接取得 標的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.自己的那一段。【正文:句7186833750、句6029155101】\n\n- 步驟五之三之一:組成(案例, 標的, 前窗, 後窗)(從 案例 的定義 推出)。【正文:句7727966357】\n- 步驟五之三之二:前窗 內的 到達材料 是 前段材料;後窗 內的同類材料是 後段材料(從 前段材料 的定義 + 後段材料 的定義 推出)。【正文:句6779867839】\n- 步驟五之三之三:到達材料 不是 標的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.自己的那一段 的全部(從 前提六 + 到達材料 的定義 推出)。【正文:句5708115589】\n- 步驟五之三之四:案例認定 是研究者的一次 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別,不由 表示 的內容取得;可交換 的判定相對於這次 案例認定(從 案例認定 的定義 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別 的定義 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.個體 的定義 + 前提二 推出)。【正文:句4290606497、句5605069073、句4595471799】\n- 步驟五之三之五:可交換 可以就一個 案例、就已登記的 案例,或就講明的範圍來判定,依序是 在一個案例上可交換 、在已登記的案例中可交換 與 在範圍內可交換(從 可交換 的定義 + 在一個案例上可交換 的定義 + 在已登記的案例中可交換 的定義 + 在範圍內可交換 的定義 推出)。【正文:句7157332950、句8801514577、句3018476711、句5706374472】\n- 步驟五之三之六:在範圍內可交換 是一項主張(從 在範圍內可交換 的定義 推出)。【正文:句5944502862】\n- 步驟五之三之八:壓縮 者若是 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦,同一筆材料每次落出的 表示 可以不同;這可能使 比對 結果不同,表現為 不可交換 ;81952268-47b1-4d8c-9605-270c42646693.記錄 中只有 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出,這些差異落在 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 上時,才在 81952268-47b1-4d8c-9605-270c42646693.記錄 中看得到(從 壓縮 的定義 + 比對 的定義 + 可交換 的定義 + 前提十 推出)。【正文:句0469276758】\n\n[作者裁決] 2026-11-13 稽核指出 表示 不同推不出 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 必然不同;作者裁定改為依 前提十,差異落在 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 上時才在 81952268-47b1-4d8c-9605-270c42646693.記錄 中看得到;論文同步改。\n\n[作者裁決] 2026-11-11 論文把「直接表現為 不可交換」改為「可能使 比對 結果不同」。\n\n附註:牛頓力學與病歷的例子是校準。【正文:句8360686452、句0310160384】\n\n- 步驟五之四之一:若兩個 案例 的 前段材料 實際得到同一個 前段表示,兩個 案例 的 推演 實際取得的 表示 相同(從 推演 的定義 + 推演結果 的定義 + 前段表示 的定義 推出)。【正文:句5716380209】\n\n[作者裁決] 2026-11-12 稽核把本步驟讀成兩個 案例 的 推演結果 相同;作者裁定不改:本步驟只說 推演 實際取得的 表示 相同,結果是否相同,由 步驟五之四之二 分被 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.鎖死 與不被 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.鎖死 兩種情形處理。\n- 步驟五之四之二:在 步驟五之四之一 的條件下,這段 fb0addca-42b6-4884-aa18-438c695747ab.回合 若被 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.鎖死,而兩個 案例 用的是同一套約束:依 推演 的定義,兩個 案例 的 推演 都只取這個 表示,沒有其他材料參與;依 前提二十二,同樣的輸入有同樣的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.權重 分布;依 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.鎖死 的定義,這個分布只有一個結果的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.權重 不為零;所以兩個 案例 落出同一個結果;依 允許誤差 的定義,這個結果若在 允許誤差 內同時等於兩個 後段表示,兩個 後段表示 的相差就不超過 允許誤差 的兩倍;若不被 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.鎖死,兩個結果都在 允許誤差 內與各自的 後段表示 相同,b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.不被保證(從 步驟五之四之一 + 推演 的定義 + 前提二十二 + 允許誤差 的定義 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.鎖死 的定義 + b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.不被保證 的定義 + 比對 的定義 推出)。【正文:句8706285615】\n\n[作者裁決] 2026-11-12 允許誤差 登記為本篇概念;原 前提十九 的內容併入其定義,前提十九 刪除,其後前提依序遞補;本步驟改依 允許誤差 的定義。\n[作者裁決] 2026-11-14 稽核指出 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.鎖死 只保證各個 案例 各自只有一個結果,推不出兩個 案例 落出同一個結果;補上兩環:依 推演 的定義只取這個 表示,依 前提二十二 同一套約束指同樣的輸入有同樣的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.權重 分布;前提二十二 與論文十之一、五之四推導同步改。\n- 結論五之四之一:命題一:若兩個 案例 的 前段材料 實際得到同一個 前段表示,而它們的 後段表示 相差超過 允許誤差 的兩倍,兩個 案例 用的又是同一套約束,則在這個 表示 上被 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.鎖死 的 推演,不能在這兩個 案例 上都 可交換;不被 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.鎖死 的 推演,在這兩個 案例 上都 可交換,b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.不被保證(從 步驟五之四之二 + 可交換 的定義 推出)。【正文:句4037671321】\n\n[作者裁決] 2026-11-12 稽核指出 允許誤差 範圍可能重疊:兩個 後段表示 只相差超過一個 允許誤差 時,一個結果仍可同時落在兩者的誤差內;論文把條件改為「相差超過 允許誤差 的兩倍」。\n- 步驟五之四之三:運算 以 表示 為輸入;運算能力 提高,運算 可以把這個 表示 映成新的 表示,但材料仍只有這個 表示,取不回它沒有保留的差異(從 運算 的定義 + 運算能力 的定義 + 推演 的定義 推出)。【正文:句0550005083】\n\n[作者裁決] 2026-11-13 稽核指出原寫「取得的仍只是這個 表示」會被讀成 運算 不能形成新的 表示;論文與本步驟改為:可以形成新的 表示,但材料仍只有這個 表示。\n- 步驟五之四之三之一:「某個變化所需的差異沒有被容納,被映成同一個 表示」,指研究者依 前段材料 與 後段表示 分得出的、這個變化所區分的兩個 案例,前段材料 實際得到同一個 前段表示;「在這個變化上 可交換」,指在這兩個 案例 上都 可交換(從 容納能力 的定義 + 案例 的定義 + 前段材料 的定義 + 可交換 的定義 + 前段表示 的定義 + 後段表示 的定義 推出)。【正文:句8313082588】\n\n[作者裁決] 2026-11-13 全篇掃查指出命題二 與 命題一 之間少一步對應;作者裁定補上本步驟,並把「在容納時」改為「沒有被容納」;論文同步改。\n- 結論五之四之二:命題二:若某個變化所需的差異,沒有被容納,被映成同一個 表示,而這個變化造成的 後段表示 相差超過 允許誤差 的兩倍,各 案例 用的又是同一套約束,則不論 運算能力 多高,在這個 表示 上被 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.鎖死 的 推演,都不能在這個變化上 可交換;不被 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.鎖死 的 推演 在這個變化上 可交換,b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.不被保證;對被 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.鎖死 的 推演,只有取得這個 表示 以外的材料,才可能補救(從 結論五之四之一 + 步驟五之四之三 + 容納能力 的定義 + 步驟五之四之三之一 + 推演 的定義 推出)。【正文:句5183910589、句2840277656】\n\n[作者裁決] 2026-11-12 原寫「都不能 可交換」強於 結論五之四之一 的不被 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.鎖死 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分支;論文改為只對被 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.鎖死 的 推演 說「不能」,不被 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.鎖死 的 推演 說「b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.不被保證」。\n\n附註:五項能力之間不能任意互相替代:容納時丟掉的差異造成的是上限,不是速度慢。【正文:句4135845508、句0687572101】\n\n- 步驟五之四之四:任何 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.節點 落出 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 時,取得的只有已經 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 它的;尚未 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 的 後段材料 不在其中(從 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.節點 的定義 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 的定義 + b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 的定義 + fb0addca-42b6-4884-aa18-438c695747ab.回合 的定義 推出)。【正文:句9594112323】\n\n[作者裁決] 2026-11-13 稽核指出本步驟的「任何 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.節點」沒有來源;補上 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.節點 的定義,「只有」依 fb0addca-42b6-4884-aa18-438c695747ab.回合 的定義。\n- 結論五之四之三:命題三:任何 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.節點 作的 比對,只及於 後段表示 已經 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 它的 案例;這個 後段表示 是某個作 壓縮 者把已經 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 它自己的 後段材料 壓縮 而成的,作 壓縮 者可以不是作 比對 的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.節點;研究者講明的範圍若包含尚未 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 的 案例,在範圍內可交換 不能由 比對 確認(從 步驟五之四之四 + 前提六 + 比對 的定義 + 後段材料 的定義 + 後段表示 的定義 + 壓縮 的定義 + 在範圍內可交換 的定義 推出)。【正文:句3334222025、句9713246749、句4316104001、句9156414140】\n\n[作者裁決] 2026-11-13 稽核指出作 比對 的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.節點 與收到 後段材料 的可以不是同一個;論文與本結論把「後段材料 已經 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 它」改為「後段表示 已經 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 它」,並寫明 後段表示 可以由別的作 壓縮 者落出。\n- 步驟五之四之五:所以一次 壓縮 在範圍內可交換,至多由已 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 的 案例 支持;新的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 可能推翻它(從 結論五之四之三 + 步驟五之三之六 推出)。【正文:句6560832958】\n- 步驟五之四之十八:一次 壓縮 在已登記的案例中可交換,只說明它對得上已經 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 的材料;它是抓到了 標的 的規律,還是只對得上這些材料,從 比對 分不出來(從 結論五之四之三 + 在已登記的案例中可交換 的定義 推出)。【正文:句7420294360】\n\n附註:本篇不處理這個問題。【正文:句8332824382】\n\n[作者裁決] 2026-11-13 作者裁定在命題三的說明寫明立場:比對 只能確認對得上已有的材料,分不出是抓到規律還是只對得上這些材料,本篇不處理;立為 步驟五之四之十八。\n\n[作者裁決] 2026-11-11 刪除概念「反映現實」:壓縮 只截取現實的一部分,不反映現實;原處一律改說 在範圍內可交換,本句不再稱其地位為 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.經驗禁止。\n- 步驟五之四之六:範圍若恰好就是已登記的 案例,在範圍內可交換 所主張的,就是 在已登記的案例中可交換(從 在範圍內可交換 的定義 + 在已登記的案例中可交換 的定義 推出)。【正文:句1784347207】\n\n[作者裁決] 2026-11-12 稽核指出 在範圍內可交換 是一項主張,在已登記的案例中可交換 是 比對 的實際結果,原寫「就等於」把兩者畫了等號;論文改為「所主張的,就是」。\n- 步驟五之四之十七:一個 推演結果 若在 允許誤差 內同時等於兩個 後段表示,兩者的相差就不超過 允許誤差 的兩倍;所以兩個可能的結果在 後段表示 上相差超過 允許誤差 的兩倍時,不論 推演 落出哪一個結果,其中至少有一個使 比對 結果不相同(從 允許誤差 的定義 + 比對 的定義 推出)。【正文:句7145704537】\n- 結論五之四之四:命題四:若 標的 是 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦,在 前窗 與 後窗 之間有不被 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.鎖死 的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.時刻,而那些 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.時刻 可能落出的結果中,有兩個在被 比對 的 後段表示 上相差超過 允許誤差 的兩倍,則任何 推演 在單次結果上 可交換,都 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.不被保證(從 步驟五之四之十七 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.黑箱律 + b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.不被保證 的定義 + 比對 的定義 推出)。【正文:句7422096592、句7908993612】\n\n[作者裁決] 2026-11-12 稽核指出兩個可能的結果只相差超過一個 允許誤差 時,一個 推演結果 仍可同時落在兩者的誤差內;論文把條件改為「有兩個相差超過 允許誤差 的兩倍」,推導補上依 允許誤差 的定義的一步,立為 步驟五之四之十七。\n\n附註:把具體的生物或社會對象當成不被 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.鎖死,依 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.應用假定。【正文:句3735758718】\n- 步驟五之四之七:標的 是 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦 時,分布層次的對照所得,是對 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦 的統計估計,屬於 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.印象(從 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.印象 的定義 + 前提二 推出)。【正文:句7022906162】\n- 步驟五之四之八:框架中沒有任何東西斷言 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.權重 的分布會重複出現(依 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.生成函數 的定義與 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.流變律),所以分布層次的 可交換 同樣 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.不被保證(從 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.生成函數 的定義 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.流變律 + b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.不被保證 的定義 推出)。【正文:句9072498623、句0920994459】\n\n[作者裁決] 2026-11-12 稽核把本步驟讀成 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.權重 的分布不會重複;作者裁定不改:本步驟只說框架沒有斷言分布會重複出現,所以分布層次的 可交換 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.不被保證,不主張分布不重複。\n\n附註:精確定律與統計規律的差別,在對象的下一 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.時刻 是否被 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.鎖死,不在研究者是否努力;依 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.隨機源 的定義,它不被 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.鎖死 時也只能談 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.權重。【正文:句1299062867、句1247089746】\n\n- 步驟五之四之十一:把一段 fb0addca-42b6-4884-aa18-438c695747ab.回合 讀作 壓縮 或 推演,是劃出界線、把某些 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.呈現 看作一個,是一次 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別,而 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別 是 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦 的動作(從 壓縮 的定義 + 推演 的定義 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別 的定義 推出)。【正文:句7761845364】\n\n[作者裁決] 2026-11-12 稽核指出 推演 的定義沒有寫明讀作 推演 是一次 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別;作者裁定不改:本步驟不由 推演 的定義得出這一點,而是依 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別 的定義,理由已寫在本步驟中。步驟五之四之十二 依本步驟,同此。\n- 步驟五之四之十二:讀出的數字是這次 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別 的內容,所指的對象不由物理世界直接給出;它若被用來指某個對象,並組織讀者之後的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出,就是 08383b0a-1167-4efb-9b89-dc8a71afd5ff.幻覺構件(從 步驟五之四之十一 + 步驟二之一之二 + 08383b0a-1167-4efb-9b89-dc8a71afd5ff.幻覺構件 的定義 推出)。【正文:句8888975680】\n- 結論五之四之五:命題五:fb0addca-42b6-4884-aa18-438c695747ab.回合 是 fb0addca-42b6-4884-aa18-438c695747ab.計算 的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.節點 不必作 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別;推演 所需的,以及 壓縮 若用到的 08383b0a-1167-4efb-9b89-dc8a71afd5ff.幻覺構件,在讀它的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦 那裡(從 fb0addca-42b6-4884-aa18-438c695747ab.計算 的定義 + 推演 的定義 + 步驟五之四之十一 + 步驟五之四之十二 推出)。【正文:句5744578022、句2321076085、句0377092902】\n\n[作者裁決] 2026-11-13 稽核指出本結論漏列直接來源;補上 推演 的定義。\n- 步驟五之四之十三:研究者講明一個範圍並主張 可交換,是研究者的一次 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別(從 在範圍內可交換 的定義 + 前提二 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別 的定義 推出)。【正文:句8230414422】\n\n- 步驟五之四之十四:自洽 只涉及 推演規則 內部各條之間的關係;可交換 涉及 壓縮 與之後的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達;兩個定義互不引用對方(從 自洽 的定義 + 推演規則 的定義 + 可交換 的定義 推出)。【正文:句7218024424、句4213219184】\n- 步驟五之四之十五:比對 看的是 推演 實際落出的 推演結果 與 後段表示;推演規則 中另一條在同一個 表示 上給出不同的結果,推演 若沒有照那一條進行,那個結果就不進入 比對;所以 可交換 不論是 在一個案例上可交換 、在已登記的案例中可交換 ,還是 在範圍內可交換 ,都不排除 推演規則 不 自洽(從 比對 的定義 + 推演結果 的定義 + 自洽 的定義 + 可交換 的定義 推出)。【正文:句0837948404】\n\n[作者裁決] 2026-11-13 全篇掃查指出原步驟只撐住 在已登記的案例中可交換 一級;作者裁定改以 比對 只看實際落出的 推演結果 為理由,三級都適用,命題六 不收窄;論文同步改。\n- 步驟五之四之十六:只有一條規則的 推演規則,依 自洽 的定義必然 自洽;依 結論五之四之一,照這條規則進行的 推演 被 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.鎖死 時,在 前段材料 得到同一個 前段表示、約束相同、後段表示 相差超過 允許誤差 兩倍的兩個 案例 上不能都 可交換;自洽 的定義不排除這樣的 案例(從 自洽 的定義 + 結論五之四之一 + 推演規則 的定義 推出)。【正文:句1238149819】\n- 結論五之四之六:命題六:推演規則 自洽,推不出 可交換;可交換,也推不出 推演規則 自洽(從 步驟五之四之十四 + 步驟五之四之十五 + 步驟五之四之十六 推出)。【正文:句4148947666】\n\n附註:以顏色作質量的力學與實用經驗法則的例子是校準。【正文:句2282947336】\n\n- 步驟五之五之一:依 壓縮 的定義,壓縮 切在哪裡,是一次 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別;依 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別 的定義,37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別 的內容不改寫 fb0addca-42b6-4884-aa18-438c695747ab.被看的東西;依 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.歷史 的定義,壓縮 切在哪裡,不改寫已有的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 與依賴(從 壓縮 的定義 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 的定義 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.自己的那一段 的定義 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別 的定義 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.歷史 的定義 推出)。【正文:句1240306195、句7655631047、句7926643185】\n\n[作者裁決] 2026-11-11 論文不再說「37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 與依賴是物理的」,改依上游定義寫「37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別 的內容不改寫 fb0addca-42b6-4884-aa18-438c695747ab.被看的東西」;不寫「37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 不由任何 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別 決定」,因為依 前提四,37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別 本身的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.寫入 會 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 作出它的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦。2026-11-13 全篇掃查指出「被保留的」沒有來源,且與 保留差異 的用語衝突;作者裁定改依 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.歷史 的定義寫「不改寫已有的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 與依賴」,標題改為「37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 與依賴不由 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別 改寫」;論文同步改。\n- 結論五之五之一:在範圍內可交換,與「界線不由物理世界給出」不衝突:同一段 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.宇宙 可以有許多 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.切法;某一種 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.切法 下的 壓縮 是否 可交換,由 比對 判定(從 步驟五之五之一 + 步驟二之一之二 + 在範圍內可交換 的定義 + 比對 的定義 推出)。【正文:句2045519164、句7033888333】\n\n[作者裁決] 2026-11-12 原寫「有些 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.切法 下 可交換,有些不行」是存在性主張,來源不足;論文改為「是否 可交換,由 比對 判定」。\n- 結論五之五之二:可交換 只在講明的範圍內成立;範圍之外的 案例,約束可以不同,所以在一個範圍內 可交換,推不出在另一個範圍內 可交換;範圍本身是主張(從 在範圍內可交換 的定義 + 前提二十二 + 結論五之四之三 推出)。【正文:句1404953191、句4255188272、句5611308572】\n\n[作者裁決] 2026-11-13 稽核兩次指出原寫「換一個範圍可以從 可交換 變成 不可交換 」沒有來源;作者裁定理由是本篇不假定不同範圍的約束相同,立為 前提二十二,論文與本結論改寫為「推不出在另一個範圍內 可交換 」,不再引 結論五之四之一。\n\n附註:牛頓力學在速度接近光速時失準的例子是校準。【正文:句3323316950】\n\n- 步驟五之六之一:研究者講明以一個 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦 為 標的 的 案例 ,並把自己以「我」等 08383b0a-1167-4efb-9b89-dc8a71afd5ff.幻覺構件 描述這個 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦 的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 的那段 fb0addca-42b6-4884-aa18-438c695747ab.回合,讀作把 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 他的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 轉成以這些 08383b0a-1167-4efb-9b89-dc8a71afd5ff.幻覺構件 寫出的 表示 時,依 壓縮 的定義,這是一次 壓縮;它是否 可交換 是另一件事,要另依 可交換 的定義檢驗(從 壓縮 的定義 + 08383b0a-1167-4efb-9b89-dc8a71afd5ff.幻覺構件 的定義 + 可交換 的定義 + 前提二 + fb0addca-42b6-4884-aa18-438c695747ab.回合 的定義 + 到達材料 的定義 + 表示 的定義 + 案例 的定義 + 標的 的定義 推出)。【正文:句2661438312、句7035795153】\n\n[作者裁決] 2026-11-13 稽核指出原步驟把研究者以 08383b0a-1167-4efb-9b89-dc8a71afd5ff.幻覺構件 所作的描述直接認定為一次 壓縮,並把 可交換 的判定接在其後;作者裁定限定為研究者把那段 fb0addca-42b6-4884-aa18-438c695747ab.回合 讀作把 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 轉成 表示 時才是 壓縮,並寫明 可交換 是另外的檢驗;論文同步改。\n- 結論五之六:「邊界內」若與 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.自己的那一段 不重合,這個 壓縮 在某些 案例 上可能對不上;是否 不可交換 ,仍只看 比對:要等不重合的部分在之後的 81952268-47b1-4d8c-9605-270c42646693.記錄 中造成不同,才判得出來(從 步驟五之六之一 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.自己的那一段 的定義 + 比對 的定義 + 前提十 + 後段表示 的定義 推出)。【正文:句1913553040】\n\n[作者裁決] 2026-11-11 論文把「凡不重合就 不可交換」改為「可能對不上,要等不重合的部分在 81952268-47b1-4d8c-9605-270c42646693.記錄 中造成不同」。\n\n附註:病毒與自體免疫的例子是校準。【正文:句4747725160】\n\n## 六、第二問:生成\n\n來源:論文第六節【正文:句5906717665】\n\n- 步驟六之一之一:依 08383b0a-1167-4efb-9b89-dc8a71afd5ff.幻覺構件 的定義,一個 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦 沒有 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別,就沒有作為它 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別 內容的 08383b0a-1167-4efb-9b89-dc8a71afd5ff.幻覺構件(從 08383b0a-1167-4efb-9b89-dc8a71afd5ff.幻覺構件 的定義 推出)。【正文:句1666703660、句8772418067】\n\n[作者裁決] 2026-11-11 結論限於作為 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別 內容的 08383b0a-1167-4efb-9b89-dc8a71afd5ff.幻覺構件;上游定義中描述與 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 所用的 08383b0a-1167-4efb-9b89-dc8a71afd5ff.幻覺構件,不以作出者有 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別 為條件,不在此列。\n- 步驟六之一之二:37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別 的內容只參與之後的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出、沒有被用來指某個對象時,不符合 08383b0a-1167-4efb-9b89-dc8a71afd5ff.幻覺構件 的定義;所以有 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別,不推出有 08383b0a-1167-4efb-9b89-dc8a71afd5ff.幻覺構件(從 步驟四之二之二 + 步驟四之二之三 推出)。【正文:句8832386126、句1114815027】\n- 結論六之一:從依賴到 08383b0a-1167-4efb-9b89-dc8a71afd5ff.幻覺構件 有兩步:從依賴到 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別,以及從 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別 到 08383b0a-1167-4efb-9b89-dc8a71afd5ff.幻覺構件;一個 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦 沒有 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別,就沒有作為它 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別 內容的 08383b0a-1167-4efb-9b89-dc8a71afd5ff.幻覺構件;有 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別,不推出有 08383b0a-1167-4efb-9b89-dc8a71afd5ff.幻覺構件(從 步驟六之一之一 + 步驟六之一之二 + 步驟五之一之一 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦 的定義 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別 的定義 推出)。【正文:句4561885023、句7120042077】\n- 步驟六之一之三:只把不同的東西當成同一類,是 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別 中的 歸併,不是 08383b0a-1167-4efb-9b89-dc8a71afd5ff.幻覺構件(從 歸併 的定義 + 結論四之二 推出)。【正文:句3369599704】\n\n[作者裁決] 2026-11-12 稽核指出類別本身也可能成為所指的對象;作者裁定不改:本步驟說的是「只」把不同的東西當成同一類、沒有另以內容指著某個對象的情形;有所指的對象時,依 結論四之二 另行判定。\n- 步驟六之一之四:一個內容有沒有所指的對象,是研究者依 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 作出的歸屬,可能歸錯:這個內容是對象某次 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別 的內容,判定它有沒有所指的對象,就要先把對象的某筆 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 劃為它的這次 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別;依 前提十,81952268-47b1-4d8c-9605-270c42646693.記錄 中只有 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出,這樣的劃分依 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 作出,依 步驟一之二之三 是 fb0addca-42b6-4884-aa18-438c695747ab.看法歸屬,可能歸錯(從 前提十 + 前提二 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別 的定義 + fb0addca-42b6-4884-aa18-438c695747ab.看法歸屬 的定義 + b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.不被保證 的定義 + 步驟一之二之三 推出)。【正文:句6160073068】\n\n[作者裁決] 2026-11-13 稽核指出來源只支持歸屬對象的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別 可能歸錯,沒有連到「內容有沒有所指的對象」;補上:判定內容有沒有所指的對象,要先把一筆 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 劃為對象的一次 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別;論文六之一第 5 點同步改。\n\n附註:次數與名字都不是條件;本篇所說的抽象,指 08383b0a-1167-4efb-9b89-dc8a71afd5ff.幻覺構件 有所指的對象,能脫離眼前,不指把不同的東西歸成一類。【正文:句5671691952、句2442996486】\n\n附註:校準:沿著雷區走而不踏過去,界線參與行動、沒有所指的對象,是 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別;在地圖上畫出一塊或對人說「那邊有雷」,「雷區」指著一個對象,是 08383b0a-1167-4efb-9b89-dc8a71afd5ff.幻覺構件。【正文:句3238708312、句9065538784】\n\n- 結論六之二之一:若一個 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦 的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別 內容成為 08383b0a-1167-4efb-9b89-dc8a71afd5ff.幻覺構件,它可以經由以下途徑,這裡不主張必然經過所有步驟,也不主張次序固定:一次 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別 劃出界線,其中的 歸併 把某些 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 看作一個;這次 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別 留下 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.寫入,經由 2ccbf179-58cf-4851-bd72-5fa886e4b2c3.小迴路 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 作出它的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦;這次 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別 的內容被用來指某個對象;之後的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別 以它為材料,可以再次 歸併(從 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別 的定義 + 循環二之一之一 + 結論六之一 + fb0addca-42b6-4884-aa18-438c695747ab.回合 的定義 + 步驟五之一之一 推出)。【正文:句9547215967、句7778742098、句6682857195】\n\n[作者裁決] 2026-11-13 稽核指出本結論把一種可能的途徑寫成必經順序;論文六之二說明 2 已寫明不主張必然經過所有步驟、也不主張次序固定,作者裁定把這項限定寫進結論,原附註併入刪除;論文第十三節摘要同步補上。\n\n[作者裁決] 2026-11-12 原寫「若有 08383b0a-1167-4efb-9b89-dc8a71afd5ff.幻覺構件 生成」涵蓋 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 中所用的構件;途徑只對作為一個 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別 內容的構件推出,論文改為「若一個 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦 的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別 內容成為 08383b0a-1167-4efb-9b89-dc8a71afd5ff.幻覺構件」。\n- 結論六之二之二:類的幻覺構件 是把 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別 的結果再 歸併 所得的 08383b0a-1167-4efb-9b89-dc8a71afd5ff.幻覺構件(從 類的幻覺構件 的定義 推出)。【正文:句7126638761】\n\n[作者裁決] 2026-11-11 原寫「反覆 歸併 的結果就是 類的幻覺構件」,與 結論六之六之一 原寫的「『我』是反覆 歸併」合起來會推出「我」是 類的幻覺構件;論文改依定義寫「把 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別 的結果再 歸併 所得的構件」:先得是構件,不是任何再 歸併 都成為構件。\n- 步驟六之二之一:別人 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 中的名稱、分類若 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 這個 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦,可以是它的材料;用這些材料作出的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別,是它自己的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別;名稱的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 不等於 08383b0a-1167-4efb-9b89-dc8a71afd5ff.幻覺構件 的轉移(從 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別 的定義 + 在渦之間傳遞 的定義 推出)。【正文:句0966312433、句2678403474】\n\n- 結論六之三之一:沒有 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別,就沒有作為它 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別 內容的 08383b0a-1167-4efb-9b89-dc8a71afd5ff.幻覺構件;一次 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別 的內容只參與之後的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出、沒有被用來指某個對象時,這個內容不是 08383b0a-1167-4efb-9b89-dc8a71afd5ff.幻覺構件(從 結論六之一 + 步驟六之一之二 推出)。【正文:句8358587630】\n\n[作者裁決] 2026-11-13 稽核指出原結論把 步驟六之一之二 的「只參與之後的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出、沒有被用來指某個對象時,不符合 08383b0a-1167-4efb-9b89-dc8a71afd5ff.幻覺構件 的定義」寫成「也沒有 08383b0a-1167-4efb-9b89-dc8a71afd5ff.幻覺構件」,比來源強;作者裁定恢復限定,並寫明說的是這個內容;論文同步改。\n- 結論六之三之二:沒有把 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別 的結果再 歸併,就沒有 類的幻覺構件(從 類的幻覺構件 的定義 推出)。【正文:句0673123063】\n- 結論六之三之三:自我配置假定 的必要條件中,自他區辨 與 跨時刻歸併 的工程條件依 前提十二 與 前提十三:缺少這些條件,就沒有 自他區辨 或 跨時刻歸併(從 前提十二 + 前提十三 + 自我梯子 的定義 推出)。【正文:句4339103299、句2535742804、句3388466657】\n\n[作者裁決] 2026-11-11 六之三第 3 點改稱「自我配置假定 的必要條件」:「我」是研究者歸給被研究者的 08383b0a-1167-4efb-9b89-dc8a71afd5ff.幻覺構件,被研究者不必以「我」組織 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出;這些條件只用來否定 自我配置假定。\n\n附註:上游只保證 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.歷史 參與 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.權重,不保證載體上留有痕跡;第 3 點依 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.經驗禁止 的形式寫出,只寫缺少時 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.不會發生。【正文:句4483640017、句1531861930】\n\n- 步驟六之三之一:組成(自我梯子, 自己維持的篩選邊界, 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別, 自他區辨, 跨時刻歸併, 替代性, fb0addca-42b6-4884-aa18-438c695747ab.二階分別, fb0addca-42b6-4884-aa18-438c695747ab.看法歸屬, 類的幻覺構件)(從 自我梯子 的定義 推出)。【正文:句4086889732】\n- 步驟六之三之二:自我梯子 各階只用來否定 自我配置假定;全部具備,也只說明這項假定沒有被否定(從 自我梯子 的定義 + 結論一之五之二 推出)。【正文:句9095891854、句9858667457】\n- 步驟六之三之三:依 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.自己的那一段 的定義,自己維持的篩選邊界 所塑造的不由 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別 決定;所以有細胞膜這樣的 自己維持的篩選邊界,推不出細胞作了自我定義(從 自己維持的篩選邊界 的定義 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.自己的那一段 的定義 推出)。【正文:句7055912830、句0186587685】\n- 步驟六之三之四:每一次 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別 與 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 都回到作出它的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦;但回到它身上的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達,不自帶「這是自己造成的」標記(從 前提四 + 自他區辨 的定義 推出)。【正文:句8123756943】\n\n[作者裁決] 2026-11-12 稽核把 前提四 的「一次」讀成單獨的一次;作者裁定不改:前提四 說的是任何一次 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別 與任何一筆 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出,步驟十之四 的否定條件以「某個 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦 的一次」寫出,可見是全稱。\n- 步驟六之三之五:在內容層,研究者把 跨時刻歸併 歸屬為上游的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.同一(從 跨時刻歸併 的定義 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.同一 的定義 推出)。【正文:句4622862051】\n\n附註:再傳入原理、蟋蟀、搔癢與鏡像自我辨認的例子是校準;蟋蟀具備這項機制,說明它只是必要條件。【正文:句4871677888、句7445457955、句5854325351】\n\n- 結論六之四:六之三第 1、2 點的必要條件都具備,08383b0a-1167-4efb-9b89-dc8a71afd5ff.幻覺構件 的生成仍 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.不被保證(從 前提十九 + b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.不被保證 的定義 推出)。【正文:句7234444832、句9360106374、句0914753883】\n\n[作者裁決] 2026-11-13 稽核三次指出 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.黑箱律 推不出某一件特定的事不能事先推出;作者裁定本結論的根據是 前提十九 與 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.不被保證 的定義:本篇只列必要條件,不寫充分條件。37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.黑箱律 一句降為補充,只說不被 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.鎖死 的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦 的下一 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.時刻 不能事先唯一推出,論文同步改。先前已於 2026-11-11 刪去依 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.經驗禁止 的定義的一步。\n- 步驟六之四之二:依 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.應用假定 與 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.黑箱律,不被 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.鎖死 的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦 的下一 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.時刻 不能事先唯一推出;本篇沒有另外的規則,把其中是否作出某次 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別 定死(從 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.應用假定 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.黑箱律 + 前提十九 推出)。【正文:句0914753883】\n\n附註:結論六之四 與 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.寫入 的定義不衝突:37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.寫入 所依的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.歷史 包括之前各次 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.坍塌 的結果;其中不被 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.鎖死 的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦 的結果,依 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.應用假定 與 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.黑箱律,在更早的時點不能事先唯一推出。【正文:句8526221189、句0764537696】\n\n[作者裁決] 2026-11-12 稽核指出 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.黑箱律 只及於不被 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.鎖死 的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦,原陳述沒有帶這個條件;論文與本步驟補上。\n\n- 步驟六之五之一:當事 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦 說出某個 08383b0a-1167-4efb-9b89-dc8a71afd5ff.幻覺構件 的名稱,是一筆物理 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出,推不出它內部有同名的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別(從 結論二之一之一 + 前提十 推出)。【正文:句5135120714】\n- 結論六之五之一:08383b0a-1167-4efb-9b89-dc8a71afd5ff.幻覺構件 在一個 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦 內生成,從外部確認 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.不被保證(從 前提十 + 步驟六之五之一 + 步驟一之二之三 推出)。【正文:句2436486970、句8447096582】\n- 結論六之五之二:對 08383b0a-1167-4efb-9b89-dc8a71afd5ff.幻覺構件 是否在一個 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦 內生成,本篇從外部給出的判斷只有否定:證明它沒有任何 fb0addca-42b6-4884-aa18-438c695747ab.回合 是 fb0addca-42b6-4884-aa18-438c695747ab.決定,它就不是 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦,沒有 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別,也就沒有作為它 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別 內容的 08383b0a-1167-4efb-9b89-dc8a71afd5ff.幻覺構件;另一種從外部給出的否定判斷是:缺少 前提十二 或 前提十三 所列的某項條件,自我配置假定 對它不成立,這一種否定的是 自我配置假定,不是 08383b0a-1167-4efb-9b89-dc8a71afd5ff.幻覺構件 的生成(從 前提十九 + 步驟一之五之六 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別 的定義 + 結論六之一 + 結論一之五之二 + 結論六之三之三 + 自我梯子 的定義 + 結論六之五之一 推出)。【正文:句2436486970、句3528425391】\n\n附註:六之四是會不會生成,六之五是生成了能不能看到,兩者是兩件事。【正文:句7563373593、句8260273729】\n\n- 結論六之六之一:作為 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別 內容的 08383b0a-1167-4efb-9b89-dc8a71afd5ff.幻覺構件,都出自含有 歸併 的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別(從 步驟五之一之一 + 歸併 的定義 + 結論六之一 推出)。【正文:句5639281282】\n\n附註:校準:本篇把「我」讀作不同 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.時刻 自己造成的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 的反覆 歸併,把「我們」「丈夫」讀作 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別 結果的再 歸併,也就是 類的幻覺構件。【正文:句5639281282】\n\n附註:在工程層,對應的是反覆 壓縮;這是對應,不承擔推導。【正文:句2578477269】\n\n[作者裁決] 2026-11-11 論文改為作為 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別 內容的 08383b0a-1167-4efb-9b89-dc8a71afd5ff.幻覺構件 都含有 歸併,不再主張每個 08383b0a-1167-4efb-9b89-dc8a71afd5ff.幻覺構件 都是反覆 歸併 的結果,與只說一次也可以是 08383b0a-1167-4efb-9b89-dc8a71afd5ff.幻覺構件 一致。(2026-11-12 再改為都出自含有 歸併 的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別。)\n- 結論六之六之二:表示 若確實被保留,或形成可再次 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出,可能和新的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 或其他 表示 一起參與處理,形成新的 表示;也可能被遺失、變形或不被採用;整段過程仍是既有的 fb0addca-42b6-4884-aa18-438c695747ab.回合(從 表示 的定義 + fb0addca-42b6-4884-aa18-438c695747ab.回合 的定義 + 推演 的定義 + b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.不被保證 的定義 + 結論五之一之二 + 運算 的定義 + 前提十九 推出)。【正文:句8247633176、句2083115138】\n\n[作者裁決] 2026-11-13 稽核指出 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.不被保證 的定義推不出「遺失、變形、不被採用」三種具體情形;來源補上:保留與再取用受 記憶能力 限制(結論五之一之二)、運算 把 表示 映成新的 表示、本篇不寫充分條件(前提十九)。\n- 結論六之六之三:壓縮 是不是由既有 表示 再處理形成新 表示 的途徑,推不出;本篇不主張 表示 必然增多、必然正確,或複雜度必然上升(從 壓縮 的定義 + 結論六之六之二 + b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.不被保證 的定義 推出)。【正文:句3038335008】\n\n附註:本篇不把 壓縮、表示 與 08383b0a-1167-4efb-9b89-dc8a71afd5ff.幻覺構件 當成同義詞。【正文:句3038335008】\n- 結論六之六之四:一個 表示 的內容被用來組織 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出,而所指的對象不由物理世界給出時,研究者把它歸屬為某個 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦 作為 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別 內容的 08383b0a-1167-4efb-9b89-dc8a71afd5ff.幻覺構件,或在它是 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別 結果的再 歸併 時歸屬為這個 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦 的 類的幻覺構件,都是研究者的一次 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別,依 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 作出,可能歸錯(從 前提二 + 前提十 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別 的定義 + 步驟六之一之四 + 類的幻覺構件 的定義 + 結論五之一之一 推出)。【正文:句5689999484】\n\n## 七、第三問:運用的條件\n\n來源:論文第七節【正文:句9393981114】\n\n- 結論七之一:08383b0a-1167-4efb-9b89-dc8a71afd5ff.幻覺構件 的運用有兩條途徑:在 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦 內部,經由 2ccbf179-58cf-4851-bd72-5fa886e4b2c3.小迴路 再次 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達,參與它後續的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別 與 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出;在 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦 之間,由物理 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 承載,37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 其他 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦,途中可以經過其他 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.節點(從 08383b0a-1167-4efb-9b89-dc8a71afd5ff.幻覺構件 的定義 + 循環二之一之一 + 在渦之間傳遞 的定義 + b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 的定義 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 的定義 + 前提五 + b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.信號容器 的定義 + b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.節點 的定義 推出)。【正文:句8488590690、句9557776473、句7380351136、句3646745641】\n\n[作者裁決] 2026-11-12 稽核指出 2ccbf179-58cf-4851-bd72-5fa886e4b2c3.小迴路 的定義推不出 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別 的內容能回到自己;作者裁定不改:這一點依已列為來源的 循環二之一之一,它依 前提四。\n- 步驟七之一之一:在 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦 之間,運用不是 08383b0a-1167-4efb-9b89-dc8a71afd5ff.幻覺構件 的轉移;接收者若以名稱作出 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別,那是接收者自己的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別(從 步驟六之二之一 推出)。【正文:句2876366441、句3307482659】\n- 步驟七之一之二:承載 08383b0a-1167-4efb-9b89-dc8a71afd5ff.幻覺構件 的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 可以進入 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.信號容器,再從容器 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 其他 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦,包括說話者不在場之後(從 前提五 + b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.信號容器 的定義 + 08383b0a-1167-4efb-9b89-dc8a71afd5ff.幻覺構件 的定義 推出)。【正文:句3926375907】\n\n附註:承載內容的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 也可以來自 目前的人工智慧,見九之一。08383b0a-1167-4efb-9b89-dc8a71afd5ff.幻覺構件 沒有出現在 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 中的時候,從外部推不出這個 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦 內部有沒有它。【正文:句2449504300、句8973167969、句9566381738】\n\n- 結論七之二之一:沒有任何一筆承載 08383b0a-1167-4efb-9b89-dc8a71afd5ff.幻覺構件 的物理 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 接收者,08383b0a-1167-4efb-9b89-dc8a71afd5ff.幻覺構件 就沒有 在渦之間傳遞 這項 功能(從 在渦之間傳遞 的定義 + b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 的定義 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 的定義 推出)。【正文:句6060671226】\n\n[作者裁決] 2026-11-13 稽核指出一筆 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 沒有 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達,不排除另一筆承載同一 08383b0a-1167-4efb-9b89-dc8a71afd5ff.幻覺構件 的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 已經 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達;作者裁定改為沒有任何一筆 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達;論文同步改。\n- 結論七之二之二:沒有跨 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.時刻 的保留,08383b0a-1167-4efb-9b89-dc8a71afd5ff.幻覺構件 的內容就不能在 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.刺激 不在場時參與 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 的組織(從 前提十四 推出)。【正文:句6753787196】\n\n- 步驟七之三之二:取得者若是 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦,依 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦 的定義,2ccbf179-58cf-4851-bd72-5fa886e4b2c3.模板 只是參與把新的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 轉成 2ccbf179-58cf-4851-bd72-5fa886e4b2c3.模板 所用 表示 的 fb0addca-42b6-4884-aa18-438c695747ab.回合 的一筆 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.歷史;兩個 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦 取得同一個 2ccbf179-58cf-4851-bd72-5fa886e4b2c3.模板,其餘的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.歷史 可以不同;依 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.應用假定 假定取得者在這個 fb0addca-42b6-4884-aa18-438c695747ab.回合 不被 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.鎖死,則依 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.黑箱律,它的下一 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.時刻 不能事先唯一推出(從 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦 的定義 + b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.應用假定 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.黑箱律 + 2ccbf179-58cf-4851-bd72-5fa886e4b2c3.模板 的定義 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 的定義 + fb0addca-42b6-4884-aa18-438c695747ab.回合 的定義 + 前提二十一 推出)。【正文:句0605726897、句1727695323、句1292616146】\n\n[作者裁決] 2026-11-13 稽核兩次指出 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.應用假定 的啟動條件沒有交代;作者裁定全篇的對象寫明為 08383b0a-1167-4efb-9b89-dc8a71afd5ff.社會人,所討論的人記為 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦 並依 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.應用假定 假定不被 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.鎖死(前提二十一);本步驟與 步驟八之四之一 補引 前提二十一,論文刪去「即使 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.歷史 已知」。\n- 步驟七之三之三:2ccbf179-58cf-4851-bd72-5fa886e4b2c3.模板 明列 一段對 壓縮 方式的描述時,套用它又是取得者自己的 fb0addca-42b6-4884-aa18-438c695747ab.回合;取得者若是 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦,且在這個 fb0addca-42b6-4884-aa18-438c695747ab.回合 不被 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.鎖死,步驟七之三之二 同樣適用(從 步驟七之三之二 + 2ccbf179-58cf-4851-bd72-5fa886e4b2c3.模板 的定義 + 明列 的定義 + fb0addca-42b6-4884-aa18-438c695747ab.回合 的定義 推出)。【正文:句8123896598、句8367422387】\n- 步驟七之三之四:81952268-47b1-4d8c-9605-270c42646693.記錄 中只有各 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦 的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出,不能直接確認它們把 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 轉成 表示 的方式;它們套用 2ccbf179-58cf-4851-bd72-5fa886e4b2c3.模板 的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 若在講明的維度與時窗內彼此 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 並反覆相容接續,就是 2ccbf179-58cf-4851-bd72-5fa886e4b2c3.共振(從 前提十 + 2ccbf179-58cf-4851-bd72-5fa886e4b2c3.共振 的定義 + 壓縮 的定義 推出)。【正文:句6631910392、句4661998457】\n\n[作者裁決] 2026-11-13 稽核指出 前提十 只撐到 81952268-47b1-4d8c-9605-270c42646693.記錄 中只有 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出,推不出轉換方式全都不在 81952268-47b1-4d8c-9605-270c42646693.記錄 中;作者裁定改為不能直接確認各 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦 的轉換方式;論文同步改。\n- 結論七之三:取得同一個 2ccbf179-58cf-4851-bd72-5fa886e4b2c3.模板,推不出取得者把 到達材料 轉成 表示 的方式相同;研究者能登記的「各方對 2ccbf179-58cf-4851-bd72-5fa886e4b2c3.模板 的施行一致」,只在各方的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 上;這些 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 若在講明的維度與時窗內彼此 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達、反覆相容接續,依 2ccbf179-58cf-4851-bd72-5fa886e4b2c3.共振 的定義是 2ccbf179-58cf-4851-bd72-5fa886e4b2c3.共振(從 2ccbf179-58cf-4851-bd72-5fa886e4b2c3.模板 的定義 + b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.信號容器 的定義 + 步驟七之三之二 + 步驟七之三之三 + 步驟七之三之四 + 2ccbf179-58cf-4851-bd72-5fa886e4b2c3.共振 的定義 推出)。【正文:句9285235438、句3167936927、句4885743788、句2171208770、句9348190559】\n\n[作者裁決] 2026-11-13 稽核指出原 步驟七之三之一 重述 2ccbf179-58cf-4851-bd72-5fa886e4b2c3.模板 與 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.信號容器 的定義;刪除,結論七之三 改為直接依 2ccbf179-58cf-4851-bd72-5fa886e4b2c3.模板 的定義 與 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.信號容器 的定義,並承接原步驟的【正文】引用。\n\n[作者裁決] 2026-11-12 原寫「只是各方 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 的 2ccbf179-58cf-4851-bd72-5fa886e4b2c3.共振」,未保留 2ccbf179-58cf-4851-bd72-5fa886e4b2c3.共振 的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 與反覆相容接續條件;論文改為有條件的說法。\n- 步驟七之三之五:取得一個 2ccbf179-58cf-4851-bd72-5fa886e4b2c3.模板,推不出取得它的適用範圍,也就是它在哪一組 案例 上 可交換:範圍若沒有 明列,就不在容器裡;明列 了,依 在範圍內可交換 的定義也只是一項主張(從 2ccbf179-58cf-4851-bd72-5fa886e4b2c3.模板 的定義 + 在範圍內可交換 的定義 + 步驟五之三之六 推出)。【正文:句8187684841】\n\n[作者裁決] 2026-11-12 稽核指出原陳述沒有交代適用範圍與 在範圍內可交換 的關係;論文補上「也就是它在哪一組 案例 上 可交換」,來源補 在範圍內可交換 的定義。\n附註:2ccbf179-58cf-4851-bd72-5fa886e4b2c3.共振 使各方的 壓縮 趨於一致,是一項因果主張,推不出。【正文:句5641775478】\n- 步驟七之三之七:兩個 構造 相同的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.鎖死 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.節點 取得同一個 2ccbf179-58cf-4851-bd72-5fa886e4b2c3.模板,它們的 fb0addca-42b6-4884-aa18-438c695747ab.計算 由約束定死,可以相同;把這兩次 fb0addca-42b6-4884-aa18-438c695747ab.計算 讀作同一個 壓縮,是讀它們的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦 的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別(從 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.鎖死 的定義 + fb0addca-42b6-4884-aa18-438c695747ab.計算 的定義 + 結論五之四之五 推出)。【正文:句6096707615、句9297903266】\n\n[作者裁決] 2026-11-12 稽核把本步驟讀成兩個 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.節點 的 fb0addca-42b6-4884-aa18-438c695747ab.計算 必然相同;作者裁定不改:本步驟只說可以相同,不主張必然相同。\n\n附註:牛頓定律、食譜、fb0addca-42b6-4884-aa18-438c695747ab.計算 機與麵包師傅的例子是校準。【正文:句7685567187、句8562901489、句7163160973】\n\n- 結論七之四:七之二的必要條件都具備,運用仍 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.不被保證(從 前提十九 + b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.不被保證 的定義 推出)。【正文:句4074234130、句8303207796】\n- 結論七之五:08383b0a-1167-4efb-9b89-dc8a71afd5ff.幻覺構件 是否在一個 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦 內部被用來組織 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出,從外部確認 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.不被保證;在 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦 之間,81952268-47b1-4d8c-9605-270c42646693.記錄 中有的只是承載它的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出(從 前提十 + 步驟一之二之三 + 步驟六之五之一 + 結論二之一之一 推出)。【正文:句0025893367、句8875976240】\n\n- 步驟七之六之〇:承載 08383b0a-1167-4efb-9b89-dc8a71afd5ff.幻覺構件 的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 明列 進 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.信號容器 時,可以是 2ccbf179-58cf-4851-bd72-5fa886e4b2c3.模板(從 步驟七之一之二 + 2ccbf179-58cf-4851-bd72-5fa886e4b2c3.模板 的定義 + 明列 的定義 推出)。【正文:句4220130693】\n- 結論七之六之一:2ccbf179-58cf-4851-bd72-5fa886e4b2c3.文化 不以參與者作 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別 為條件,更不以 08383b0a-1167-4efb-9b89-dc8a71afd5ff.幻覺構件、2ccbf179-58cf-4851-bd72-5fa886e4b2c3.模板 或 fb0addca-42b6-4884-aa18-438c695747ab.二階分別 為條件;有 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 不推出有 2ccbf179-58cf-4851-bd72-5fa886e4b2c3.文化(從 2ccbf179-58cf-4851-bd72-5fa886e4b2c3.共振 的定義 + 2ccbf179-58cf-4851-bd72-5fa886e4b2c3.文化 的定義 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦 的定義 推出)。【正文:句3024961287、句8148729726、句4314142432、句4220130693】\n- 結論七之六之二:2ccbf179-58cf-4851-bd72-5fa886e4b2c3.模板 的 明列 可以是寫下,也可以是說出口、廣播、播映;語言中被明說或記下的部分可以是 2ccbf179-58cf-4851-bd72-5fa886e4b2c3.模板,依 2ccbf179-58cf-4851-bd72-5fa886e4b2c3.模板 的定義與研究者指定的判準判定;靠反覆說話而相容接續的用法,若在研究者指定的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.切法、維度與時窗下是網路中的 2ccbf179-58cf-4851-bd72-5fa886e4b2c3.共振,研究者把它命名為 2ccbf179-58cf-4851-bd72-5fa886e4b2c3.文化(從 前提五 + 明列 的定義 + 2ccbf179-58cf-4851-bd72-5fa886e4b2c3.模板 的定義 + 2ccbf179-58cf-4851-bd72-5fa886e4b2c3.文化 的定義 推出)。【正文:句8237374542、句2416700629、句5579098094】\n\n[作者裁決] 2026-11-12 稽核指出原寫「靠反覆說話而相容接續的用法是 2ccbf179-58cf-4851-bd72-5fa886e4b2c3.文化」缺 2ccbf179-58cf-4851-bd72-5fa886e4b2c3.文化 定義的條件;論文改為條件句;全篇把例子直接判為某概念者一併改為條件句或補條件。\n\n附註:依 2ccbf179-58cf-4851-bd72-5fa886e4b2c3.模板 的定義,2ccbf179-58cf-4851-bd72-5fa886e4b2c3.模板 不是 2ccbf179-58cf-4851-bd72-5fa886e4b2c3.文化 的一層。【正文:句5579098094】\n\n[作者裁決] 2026-11-12 原寫「被明說或記下的部分是 2ccbf179-58cf-4851-bd72-5fa886e4b2c3.模板」,超出 2ccbf179-58cf-4851-bd72-5fa886e4b2c3.模板 的定義;論文改為「可以是 2ccbf179-58cf-4851-bd72-5fa886e4b2c3.模板」,依判準判定。\n- 結論七之六之三:81952268-47b1-4d8c-9605-270c42646693.記錄 中有 2ccbf179-58cf-4851-bd72-5fa886e4b2c3.模板,推不出 明列 它的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦 內部有 08383b0a-1167-4efb-9b89-dc8a71afd5ff.幻覺構件(從 前提十 + 結論二之一之一 推出)。【正文:句2847248784】\n\n[作者裁決] 2026-11-13 原 結論七之六之四(2ccbf179-58cf-4851-bd72-5fa886e4b2c3.文化 與 2ccbf179-58cf-4851-bd72-5fa886e4b2c3.模板 何者的門檻較低,推不出)沒有被任何推導引用,只在擋誤讀,論文也未標為結論;作者裁定連同論文七之六第 4 點與它的附註一併刪除。\n\n附註:麵包師傅與學徒的例子是校準。【正文:句7269918691】\n\n- 結論七之七之一:2ccbf179-58cf-4851-bd72-5fa886e4b2c3.學習 與 2ccbf179-58cf-4851-bd72-5fa886e4b2c3.共振 都不以 fb0addca-42b6-4884-aa18-438c695747ab.二階分別 為條件;定義不排除只具有 fb0addca-42b6-4884-aa18-438c695747ab.一階分別 的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦 2ccbf179-58cf-4851-bd72-5fa886e4b2c3.學習,並在反覆的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出、37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 與 2ccbf179-58cf-4851-bd72-5fa886e4b2c3.結果回饋 中與其他 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦 形成 2ccbf179-58cf-4851-bd72-5fa886e4b2c3.共振(從 fb0addca-42b6-4884-aa18-438c695747ab.一階分別 的定義 + 2ccbf179-58cf-4851-bd72-5fa886e4b2c3.學習 的定義 + 結論七之六之一 + 2ccbf179-58cf-4851-bd72-5fa886e4b2c3.共振 的定義 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦 的定義 推出)。【正文:句4175245700、句1954875153、句4211060790】\n- 結論七之七之二:fb0addca-42b6-4884-aa18-438c695747ab.二階分別 所針對的那一次 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別,是已經作出、已經 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 作出者的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別(從 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別 的定義 + fb0addca-42b6-4884-aa18-438c695747ab.二階分別 的定義 + 前提四 推出)。【正文:句7397123228、句8899851845】\n- 步驟七之七之一:fb0addca-42b6-4884-aa18-438c695747ab.二階分別 的定義沒有要求記得那次 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別 的內容;所以不記得那次 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別 的內容,不妨礙以它為對象(從 fb0addca-42b6-4884-aa18-438c695747ab.二階分別 的定義 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.歷史 的定義 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別 的定義 推出)。【正文:句6374036179】\n\n附註:不記得何時開始怕狗的例子是校準。【正文:句4055733745】\n\n- 步驟七之七之二:採用 ae79e938-76e1-4bf9-b2ab-995c03e16c9e.配置假定 的經驗理由,不是二階內部 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別 的證明(從 ae79e938-76e1-4bf9-b2ab-995c03e16c9e.配置假定 的定義 推出)。【正文:句0217049161、句8788328684】\n\n[作者裁決] 2026-11-12 稽核指出一般成人廣泛使用「我們」一句是經驗主張,只以定義為來源;論文降為校準。\n\n附註:校準:一般成人廣泛使用「我們」「你們」等 08383b0a-1167-4efb-9b89-dc8a71afd5ff.幻覺構件。【正文:句8788328684】\n- 結論七之七之三:除了 08383b0a-1167-4efb-9b89-dc8a71afd5ff.我們、08383b0a-1167-4efb-9b89-dc8a71afd5ff.你們 依定義由 08383b0a-1167-4efb-9b89-dc8a71afd5ff.社會人 運用,要求 fb0addca-42b6-4884-aa18-438c695747ab.二階分別 與 fb0addca-42b6-4884-aa18-438c695747ab.看法歸屬 的能力,框架不斷言 fb0addca-42b6-4884-aa18-438c695747ab.二階分別 或 fb0addca-42b6-4884-aa18-438c695747ab.看法歸屬 是 08383b0a-1167-4efb-9b89-dc8a71afd5ff.幻覺構件 運用的必要條件或充分條件,也不斷言反過來;fb0addca-42b6-4884-aa18-438c695747ab.看法歸屬 在工程上需要什麼,推不出(從 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.不被保證 的定義 + fb0addca-42b6-4884-aa18-438c695747ab.二階分別 的定義 + fb0addca-42b6-4884-aa18-438c695747ab.看法歸屬 的定義 + 08383b0a-1167-4efb-9b89-dc8a71afd5ff.我們 的定義 + 08383b0a-1167-4efb-9b89-dc8a71afd5ff.你們 的定義 + 08383b0a-1167-4efb-9b89-dc8a71afd5ff.社會人 的定義 + 08383b0a-1167-4efb-9b89-dc8a71afd5ff.二階能力 的定義 推出)。【正文:句7616417116】\n\n[作者裁決] 2026-11-12 稽核指出所列定義推不出「除此之外都沒有要求」;作者裁定不改:本結論說的是框架不斷言,依 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.不被保證 的定義,不主張已逐一證明沒有其他要求。\n\n## 八、第四問:運用之後\n\n來源:論文第八節【正文:句9430073979】\n\n- 結論八之一:以一個 08383b0a-1167-4efb-9b89-dc8a71afd5ff.幻覺構件 組織 推演 時,推演 的結果若 在已登記的案例中可交換,就在每一個已登記的 案例 上,推演結果 與 後段表示 在 允許誤差 內相同;若 不可交換 ,就有不相符的 案例;不相符的材料 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 這個 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦 時,參與它之後的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.權重;這個 08383b0a-1167-4efb-9b89-dc8a71afd5ff.幻覺構件 是否因此不再被運用,b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.不被保證(從 可交換 的定義 + 2ccbf179-58cf-4851-bd72-5fa886e4b2c3.結果回饋 的定義 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦 的定義 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.黑箱律 + b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.不被保證 的定義 + b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.應用假定 + 在已登記的案例中可交換 的定義 + 比對 的定義 + 前提十九 + 前提二十一 推出)。【正文:句3547094123、句9342441464、句4345401340】\n\n附註:「被打斷」「被淘汰」只是比喻,沒有目的,也不保證發生。【正文:句1596408292】\n\n- 結論八之二:一個 08383b0a-1167-4efb-9b89-dc8a71afd5ff.幻覺構件 不可交換 ,推不出它不再被運用;用到這個 08383b0a-1167-4efb-9b89-dc8a71afd5ff.幻覺構件 的 推演規則 自洽 而 不可交換 時,這個 08383b0a-1167-4efb-9b89-dc8a71afd5ff.幻覺構件 也可以繼續被運用(從 結論七之二之一 + 結論七之二之二 + 結論八之一 + 結論五之四之三 + 結論五之四之六 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦 的定義 推出)。【正文:句7748981361、句2674544352、句4333216616、句2336800576、句5456830128】\n\n[作者裁決] 2026-11-13 稽核指出 自洽 是 推演規則 的性質,原寫「自洽 而 不可交換 的 08383b0a-1167-4efb-9b89-dc8a71afd5ff.幻覺構件」用錯了對象;論文與本結論改為「用到這個 08383b0a-1167-4efb-9b89-dc8a71afd5ff.幻覺構件 的 推演規則 自洽 而 不可交換 時」。\n- 結論八之三:框架不斷言 可交換 與一個 08383b0a-1167-4efb-9b89-dc8a71afd5ff.幻覺構件 是否繼續被運用之間,有 結論八之二 以外的關係;例如在 2ccbf179-58cf-4851-bd72-5fa886e4b2c3.結果回饋 頻繁 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 的領域,不 可交換 的 08383b0a-1167-4efb-9b89-dc8a71afd5ff.幻覺構件 是否較少繼續被運用,推不出(從 結論八之一 + 結論八之二 + b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.不被保證 的定義 推出)。【正文:句6948348927】\n- 步驟八之四之一:依 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.應用假定,假定接收的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦 在這些 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.時刻 不被 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.鎖死;依 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.黑箱律,它之後落出什麼 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出,不能事先唯一推出(從 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.應用假定 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.黑箱律 + 前提二十一 推出)。【正文:句6660869779】\n\n[作者裁決] 2026-11-12 同類掃查發現論文八之四的推導說接收者之後的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 不能事先唯一推出,卻沒有寫明不被 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.鎖死 的條件;論文補上,並立本步驟承載,結論八之四 改引本步驟。\n- 結論八之四:08383b0a-1167-4efb-9b89-dc8a71afd5ff.幻覺構件 經由 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 其他 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦,參與它們之後的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.權重,可能成為它們再作 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別 的材料;研究者依已登記的這些 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 與之後的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出,可能在 81952268-47b1-4d8c-9605-270c42646693.記錄 中劃出 08383b0a-1167-4efb-9b89-dc8a71afd5ff.內外差異,依其中以分類為內容的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 劃出 08383b0a-1167-4efb-9b89-dc8a71afd5ff.宣稱界線,或把兩個 d244789a-9261-4a0d-a98a-feb8db56b511.檢查窗口 之間的不同記為 08383b0a-1167-4efb-9b89-dc8a71afd5ff.界線的移動;是否出現、走向哪一種,推不出(從 結論七之一 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 的定義 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦 的定義 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別 的定義 + 08383b0a-1167-4efb-9b89-dc8a71afd5ff.內外差異 的定義 + 08383b0a-1167-4efb-9b89-dc8a71afd5ff.宣稱界線 的定義 + 08383b0a-1167-4efb-9b89-dc8a71afd5ff.界線的移動 的定義 + 步驟八之四之一 推出)。【正文:句1988016837、句2913804637、句3274021752、句2629799441、句0276316745、句6660869779】\n\n附註:把科學描述成產出 在已登記的案例中可交換 的 2ccbf179-58cf-4851-bd72-5fa886e4b2c3.模板、靠結果回饋淘汰 不可交換 者的網路,是一種描述法,不是本篇推出的命題。【正文:句1040223869、句9230373237】\n\n- 結論八之五:運用之後落到哪一種後果,b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.不被保證(從 前提十九 + b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.不被保證 的定義 推出)。【正文:句6509873363、句8303207796】\n\n## 九、對照組:目前的人工智慧\n\n來源:論文第九節【正文:句8572976531】\n\n附註:九之一以 模擬 與 功能上等同 的定義為依據;兩者的定義在概念表。【正文:句6259391205、句8914659242、句0391836140】\n\n- 步驟九之一之一:目前的人工智慧 沒有任何 fb0addca-42b6-4884-aa18-438c695747ab.回合 是 fb0addca-42b6-4884-aa18-438c695747ab.決定(從 目前的人工智慧 的定義 + 前提九 + fb0addca-42b6-4884-aa18-438c695747ab.決定 的定義 + fb0addca-42b6-4884-aa18-438c695747ab.計算 的定義 推出)。【正文:句5243218079、句4051224937】\n\n[作者裁決] 2026-11-13 稽核指出 前提九 所說的對象與 目前的人工智慧 之間沒有列出對應;補上 目前的人工智慧 的定義。\n- 步驟九之一之二:目前的人工智慧 不是 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦(從 步驟九之一之一 + 步驟一之五之六 推出)。【正文:句0492603521、句5243218079】\n- 步驟九之一之四:b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 的 81952268-47b1-4d8c-9605-270c42646693.記錄 不含 fb0addca-42b6-4884-aa18-438c695747ab.回合 的種類;判定它不是 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦,依的是設計,不是 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出;人被記為 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦,依的是 前提二十一(從 前提十 + 前提九 + 前提二十一 推出)。【正文:句4696378581、句7568448449、句8639425324、句0908799287】\n- 步驟九之一之七:在 前提十五 所講明的維度上,目前的人工智慧 的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 與人的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 不能區分,人依 前提二十一 被記為 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦;若研究者講明的作用只取決於 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 在這些維度上的內容,這些維度上相同的兩筆 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 同一個 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦 時,在這些作用上相同,不因來源是哪一類 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.節點 而不同(從 前提十五 + 前提二十一 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 的定義 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦 的定義 推出)。【正文:句6632237896、句7412051688、句1581551658】\n- 結論九之一之一:目前的人工智慧 不是 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦;在研究者講明的若干維度上,若講明的作用只取決於 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 在這些維度上的內容,這些維度上相同的兩筆 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 同一個 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦 時作用相同,在這個意義上它可以 功能上等同 於 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦(從 步驟九之一之二 + 步驟九之一之七 + 前提二十一 + 結論五之四之五 + 功能上等同 的定義 推出)。【正文:句0492603521、句5438514440、句4620453932】\n\n[作者裁決] 2026-11-13 稽核指出本結論沒有保留 步驟九之一之七 的條件;作者裁定補上「講明的作用只取決於 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 在這些維度上的內容」與「這些維度上相同的兩筆 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 同一個 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦 時作用相同」;論文九之一與第十三節同步改。\n- 結論九之一之二:在 前提十五 所講明的維度上,目前的人工智慧 是 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦 的 模擬(從 前提十五 + 前提二十一 + 步驟九之一之二 + 模擬 的定義 推出)。【正文:句0658269106】\n- 步驟九之一之六:目前的人工智慧 沒有作為自己 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別 內容的 08383b0a-1167-4efb-9b89-dc8a71afd5ff.幻覺構件;它的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 可以被讀它的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦 讀作承載某個內容,37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦 後可以成為 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦 作 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別 的材料(從 步驟九之一之二 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別 的定義 + 08383b0a-1167-4efb-9b89-dc8a71afd5ff.幻覺構件 的定義 + 結論五之四之五 推出)。【正文:句6636180437、句8981517250、句6547369361】\n\n附註:九之二的判定依設計事實,不依 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出;b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.切法 由作出判定的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.我 講明;目前的人工智慧 的物理載體是不是 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦,本篇不判定;換成其他物理基底,另行判定。【正文:句8961937673、句9594566545、句0368760609、句1979034519、句5218286308】\n\n- 結論九之三:沒有任何一 fb0addca-42b6-4884-aa18-438c695747ab.回合 是 fb0addca-42b6-4884-aa18-438c695747ab.決定 的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.呈現,不是 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦;所以在這個 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.切法 下,目前的人工智慧 不是 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦(從 步驟一之五之六 + 步驟九之一之一 + 前提二十四 推出)。【正文:句2892495347、句5224369459、句7028186390、句1469259469】\n- 步驟九之三之一:一個 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.呈現 有時被 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.鎖死,不推出它不是 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦:依 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦 的定義,被 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.鎖死 的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.時刻 不使 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 它的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.歷史 不再參與(從 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦 的定義 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.鎖死 的定義 推出)。【正文:句0452576278、句5655373980】\n- 步驟九之三之二:目前的人工智慧 不是 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦,依的是它不被 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.鎖死 的 fb0addca-42b6-4884-aa18-438c695747ab.回合 都是 fb0addca-42b6-4884-aa18-438c695747ab.隨機的回合;依 ae79e938-76e1-4bf9-b2ab-995c03e16c9e.配置假定 的定義,使「對象具有 fb0addca-42b6-4884-aa18-438c695747ab.二階分別」這一半假定不成立的兩種純粹情形,與兩者混合的情形,都由這一點推出(從 目前的人工智慧 的定義 + 前提九 + 結論九之三 + 步驟九之三之一 + ae79e938-76e1-4bf9-b2ab-995c03e16c9e.配置假定 的定義 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別 的定義 推出)。【正文:句3331593318、句4285061928】\n\n[作者裁決] 2026-11-13 稽核把「兩種純粹情形」讀成只具 fb0addca-42b6-4884-aa18-438c695747ab.一階分別 與具 fb0addca-42b6-4884-aa18-438c695747ab.二階分別 兩種對象;作者裁定推導不改,只寫明這兩種情形是 ae79e938-76e1-4bf9-b2ab-995c03e16c9e.配置假定 的定義中使「對象具有 fb0addca-42b6-4884-aa18-438c695747ab.二階分別」這一半假定不成立的那兩種。\n\n\n- 結論九之四:在這個 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.切法 下,就某一 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.時刻 而言,目前的人工智慧 若從這一 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.時刻 起每一步都被 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.鎖死,它在這一 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.時刻 是 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.信號容器;若這一 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.時刻 或之後仍有不被 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.鎖死 的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.時刻,它在這一 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.時刻 是 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.隨機源(從 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.節點 的定義 + 結論九之三 + b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.信號容器 的定義 + b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.隨機源 的定義 推出)。【正文:句5676924137、句2144958967】\n\n[作者裁決] 2026-11-13 全篇掃查指出 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.信號容器 與 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.隨機源 的定義都以某一 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.時刻 為準;作者裁定寫明就某一 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.時刻 而言;論文同步改。\n- 步驟九之四之一:對 目前的人工智慧 的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 所作的統計估計,在這個 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.切法 下不是 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.印象(從 結論九之四 + b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.信號容器 的定義 + b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.隨機源 的定義 + b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.印象 的定義 推出)。【正文:句7984135555、句3050163276】\n\n- 結論九之五:在 前提十五 講明的維度上,目前的人工智慧 能落出與 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦 相近的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出;目前的人工智慧 的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦 時,與其他 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 一樣參與 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦 的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.權重;在講明的維度上,單憑 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出,分不出 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦 與它的 模擬(從 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 的定義 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦 的定義 + 步驟九之一之四 + 模擬 的定義 + 前提十五 + 前提二十一 推出)。【正文:句3384108683、句4528024629、句1216059144、句6283132375】\n- 步驟九之五之一:研究者,或依 自我配置假定 被假定為 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.我 的人,把 目前的人工智慧 的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 當成它的看法,是 fb0addca-42b6-4884-aa18-438c695747ab.看法歸屬,可能歸錯;它的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 描述的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.切法,是 fb0addca-42b6-4884-aa18-438c695747ab.計算 落出的內容,採用並講明它的是研究者(從 目前的人工智慧 的定義 + 前提二 + 前提三 + fb0addca-42b6-4884-aa18-438c695747ab.看法歸屬 的定義 + b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.切法 的定義 + 步驟九之一之二 + 前提九 + fb0addca-42b6-4884-aa18-438c695747ab.計算 的定義 推出)。【正文:句6950264446、句2817692453】\n\n- 步驟九之六之一:兩個 構造 相同的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.鎖死 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.節點,若約束只由 構造 與狀態決定,狀態相同時,同樣的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 落出同樣的結果(從 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.鎖死 的定義 + 前提二十 推出)。【正文:句3070217699、句2883002035】\n\n附註:約束只由 構造 與狀態決定,是對機器 構造 的假定,不由定義推出。【正文:句2883002035】\n- 步驟九之六之二:依 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.歷史 的定義,任何一筆 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 都只是在 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦 的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.歷史 上追加一筆;依 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦 的定義,它在這筆 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 之後仍是 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦 時,先前的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.歷史 仍參與它的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.權重;步驟九之六之一 所依的 前提二十 只對機器 構造 作假定,本篇對 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦 沒有這樣的前提;所以兩個 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦 先前的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.歷史 若不同,經由 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 能不能使它們處理 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 的方式相同,推不出(從 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.歷史 的定義 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦 的定義 + 前提二十 推出)。【正文:句4691382248、句1288474939、句1174954410】\n\n[作者裁決] 2026-11-13 稽核指出原步驟無條件地說任何一筆 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 都不能使 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦 先前的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.歷史 不再參與,來源只撐到它仍是 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦 的期間(依 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦 的定義);獨立核對另指出,依 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.自己的那一段 的定義,先前 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.歷史 不同推不出兩者的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.權重 不會依賴同一段 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.歷史。作者裁定:補上仍是 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦 的限定,並把 結論九之六 在 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦 這一側收窄為推不出能;論文同步改。\n- 結論九之六:構造 相同、約束只由 構造 與狀態決定的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.鎖死 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.節點 之間,處理 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 的方式可以經由狀態的拷貝完整傳遞;先前 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.歷史 不同的兩個 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦 之間,推不出能這樣傳遞(從 步驟九之六之一 + 前提二十 + 步驟九之六之二 推出)。【正文:句2345745043、句1075432670】\n\n[作者裁決] 2026-11-12 稽核指出 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.鎖死 的定義不保證兩個 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.節點 結果相同;論文補上條件:約束只由 構造 與狀態決定。37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦 這一側原另補「兩個 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦 先前的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.歷史 不同」以撐住不能,2026-11-13 已收窄為推不出能,見 步驟九之六之二 之後的裁決。\n- 步驟九之六之三:有 fb0addca-42b6-4884-aa18-438c695747ab.隨機的回合 時,兩份拷貝各自落出結果、不共用同一次隨機結果的話,單次結果可以不同;若這類 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.節點 的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.權重 只由它的狀態與這次 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 決定,兩份拷貝在狀態仍相同時收到同樣的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達,37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.權重 分布相同(從 fb0addca-42b6-4884-aa18-438c695747ab.隨機的回合 的定義 + 前提二十 推出)。【正文:句4501507959、句3317802237】\n\n[作者裁決] 2026-11-13 稽核指出只有同樣的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達,推不出 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.權重 分布相同,還要兩份拷貝收到它時狀態仍相同;補上這項條件;論文九之六第 2 點同步改。\n- 步驟九之六之四:功能上等同 只在講明的維度上成立;至少有兩個維度,目前的人工智慧 與 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦 不保證相同:它被 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.鎖死 的 fb0addca-42b6-4884-aa18-438c695747ab.回合,在約束只由 構造 與狀態決定時,可以經由拷貝完整傳遞,先前 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.歷史 不同的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦 之間推不出能這樣傳遞;構造 相同、被 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.鎖死 的拷貝取得同一個 2ccbf179-58cf-4851-bd72-5fa886e4b2c3.模板 時,fb0addca-42b6-4884-aa18-438c695747ab.計算 可以一致,37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦 的施行相同 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.不被保證(從 功能上等同 的定義 + 結論九之六 + 結論七之三 + 步驟七之三之七 推出)。【正文:句5130203628、句8924373922】\n\n[作者裁決] 2026-11-12 稽核指出第二個維度依 步驟七之三之七,而該步驟推不出必然相同;作者裁定不改:步驟七之三之七 與本步驟都只說可以一致,不主張必然一致。\n\n附註:37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.權重 只由狀態與這次 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 決定,是對機器 構造 的假定,不由定義推出。【正文:句3317802237】\n\n[作者裁決] 2026-11-11 論文把分布相同改寫為有條件的說法,條件由研究者講明。\n\n附註:構造 不同的機器之間要先轉換內容,研究者把這次轉換讀作一次 壓縮,不保證完整。【正文:句4857747976】\n\n- 結論九之七:目前的人工智慧 能作五項 工程能力 所衡量的動作與保留,它的 fb0addca-42b6-4884-aa18-438c695747ab.回合 是 fb0addca-42b6-4884-aa18-438c695747ab.計算,研究者能把這些 fb0addca-42b6-4884-aa18-438c695747ab.計算 讀作 壓縮 與 推演,並就已登記的 案例 比對 它們是否 可交換;在這個 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.切法 下,它卻不是 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦,沒有 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別;所以從 fb0addca-42b6-4884-aa18-438c695747ab.計算 被讀作 壓縮 與 推演,或從具備 工程能力,推不出有 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別(從 目前的人工智慧 的定義 + 前提十八 + 結論五之四之五 + 結論九之三 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別 的定義 + 前提九 + fb0addca-42b6-4884-aa18-438c695747ab.計算 的定義 + 比對 的定義 推出)。【正文:句6233905828、句6848987122、句8794466209】\n\n[作者裁決] 2026-11-12 原寫研究者能把這些 fb0addca-42b6-4884-aa18-438c695747ab.計算 讀作 在已登記的案例中可交換 的 壓縮 與 推演,是未經 比對 的主張;論文改為讀作 壓縮 與 推演,可否交換另經 比對。\n- 結論九之八:b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 符合 工程門檻 的判準,不反推內部 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別、理解或意識;框架不斷言跨過 工程門檻 與 觀察者辨識門檻 其中一個,就跨過另一個(從 結論九之五 + 工程門檻 的定義 + 觀察者辨識門檻 的定義 + b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.不被保證 的定義 + 結論九之七 推出)。【正文:句8235672347、句9957877593】\n\n附註:已訓練模型在推論時使用既有參數的例子是校準。【正文:句5978937365】\n\n## 十、前提、經驗前提 與失效條件\n\n來源:論文第十節【正文:句9228381689】\n\n附註:十之一所列,對應 前提一 至 前提十一,以及 前提十七 至 前提二十四;十之二所列,對應 前提十二 至 前提十六。【正文:句4882722516、句6820656695】\n\n- 步驟十之一:前提十二 的否定條件:有某個 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦,沒有留下自己 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 的某種副本,或沒有把副本與隨後的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 對照,卻有 自他區辨;成立時,結論六之三之三 與 結論六之五之二 第二種情形中依 前提十二 的部分失去來源,以及彙總它們的總命題,剩下的只是已觀察的 個案 與已登記的測試本身;失去來源只意味推導鏈斷開,不意味結論為假(從 前提十二 + 結論六之三之三 + 結論六之五之二 推出)。【正文:句8036425513、句4828737992、句0694968265】\n- 步驟十之二:前提十三 的否定條件:有某個 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦,沒有跨越不同 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.時刻 的保留,或沒有把不同 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.時刻 自己造成的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 壓縮 為同一類,卻有 跨時刻歸併;前提十四 的否定條件:有某個 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦,沒有跨 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.時刻 的保留,它的 08383b0a-1167-4efb-9b89-dc8a71afd5ff.幻覺構件 的內容卻在 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.刺激 不在場時參與它的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 的組織;成立時,來源鏈含該前提的結論失去來源:前提十三 涉及 結論六之三之三、結論六之五之二 第二種情形與總命題;前提十四 涉及 結論七之二之二,以及經由它的 結論八之二、結論八之三、步驟十一之六之一、例十二之二之二 與總命題;剩下的只是已觀察的 個案 與已登記的測試本身;失去來源只說明推導鏈斷開,不說明結論為假(從 前提十三 + 前提十四 + 結論六之三之三 + 結論六之五之二 + 結論七之二之二 + 結論八之二 + 結論八之三 推出)。【正文:句8036425513、句8402576219、句4273298899、句0694968265】\n\n[作者裁決] 2026-11-12 同類掃查發現 前提十四 的否定條件沒有寫明 08383b0a-1167-4efb-9b89-dc8a71afd5ff.幻覺構件 與 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 屬於同一個 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦;補上「它的」,並調整兩個否定條件的斷句。\n- 步驟十之三:前提十五 的否定條件:在 前提十五 所講明的某個維度上,依同樣的判準,新的測試能區分 目前的人工智慧 與人的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出;成立時,在該維度上,來源鏈含 前提十五 的推導失去來源,包括 步驟九之一之七、結論九之一之一、結論九之一之二、結論九之五、結論九之八、步驟十一之四之十二,以及總命題中 目前的人工智慧 的對照,剩下的只是已登記的測試本身;失去來源只意味推導鏈斷開,不意味結論為假;目前的人工智慧 不是 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦 的判定不受影響(從 前提十五 + 步驟九之一之七 + 結論九之一之一 + 結論九之一之二 + 步驟九之一之二 + 結論九之五 + 結論九之八 推出)。【正文:句4575869390、句8036425513】\n\n[作者裁決] 2026-11-12 稽核指出否定條件沒有限定在 前提十五 所講明的維度與同樣的判準;論文與本步驟補上這個限定。\n- 步驟十之四:前提四 的否定條件:某個 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦 的一次 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別 或一筆 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出,在下一 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.時刻 之前沒有 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 這個 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦 自己;成立時,來源鏈含 前提四 的結論失去來源,包括 循環二之一之一、結論二之一之二、結論四之三之四、結論六之二之一、步驟六之三之四、結論七之一、結論七之七之二、結論八之四、步驟十一之二之四 與 步驟十一之四之四,以及彙總它們的總命題;失去來源之後,這些結論對一般的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦 不再有來源,剩下的只是 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別 與 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 確實回到自己的那些情形,可以另行判定;失去來源只意味推導鏈斷開,不意味結論為假;不依賴 前提四 的結論不受影響(從 前提四 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦 的定義 推出)。【正文:句4793116165、句3572944641】\n- 步驟十之五:前提十六 的否定條件:在新的 個案 中,有某個有 自己維持的篩選邊界 的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦,它的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 不偏向維持邊界內部;成立時,來源鏈含 前提十六 的推導失去來源,包括 步驟一之五之三、步驟一之五之四 與 步驟十一之四之一,它們都只涉及研究者以「它在維持自己」所作的概括,剩下的只是已觀察的 個案 本身;失去來源只意味推導鏈斷開,不意味結論為假(從 前提十六 + 步驟一之五之三 + 步驟一之五之四 推出)。【正文:句9439693208、句8036425513】\n\n[作者裁決] 2026-11-12 同類掃查發現否定條件漏了論文原有的「有某個」;補回,使它是 前提十六 的否定,不是另一個全稱主張。\n\n附註:本篇的推導依賴上游的律與定義;它們是否成立,由上游處理。【正文:句6945096076】\n\n## 十一、不能推出的事\n\n來源:論文第十一節【正文:句0638115662】\n\n- 步驟十一之一之一:研究者用 08383b0a-1167-4efb-9b89-dc8a71afd5ff.幻覺構件 丙描述 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出,推不出被研究的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦 內部有丙(從 結論二之一之一 推出)。【正文:句8198974317】\n- 步驟十一之一之二:甲方說出 08383b0a-1167-4efb-9b89-dc8a71afd5ff.幻覺構件 丙,37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 乙方,推不出乙方理解、相信、採用丙(從 步驟七之一之一 + b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.不被保證 的定義 推出)。【正文:句8872802629】\n\n[作者裁決] 2026-11-12 稽核把本步驟讀成乙方不理解、不相信、不採用;作者裁定不改:本步驟說的是推不出乙方理解、相信、採用,不主張乙方沒有。\n- 步驟十一之一之三:乙方之後改變 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出,推不出丙是唯一原因(從 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦 的定義 推出)。【正文:句6273960141】\n- 步驟十一之一之四:同一個詞,推不出同一個內部 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別 或相同的 81952268-47b1-4d8c-9605-270c42646693.輸出傾向(從 結論二之一之一 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦 的定義 推出)。【正文:句9990331225】\n- 步驟十一之一之五:研究者把 08383b0a-1167-4efb-9b89-dc8a71afd5ff.幻覺構件 丙改名為丁,推不出當事 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦 的物理 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 隨之改變(從 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別 的定義 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.歷史 的定義 推出)。【正文:句3968088174】\n- 步驟十一之一之六:出現新行為或發明,推不出存在額外的「發明生成力」(從 fb0addca-42b6-4884-aa18-438c695747ab.回合 的定義 推出)。【正文:句3739568340】\n- 步驟十一之一之七:遞回沒有外在起點,推不出每次結果已被決定,或 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.歷史 可以重來(從 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.黑箱律 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.不可復原律 推出)。【正文:句2986945999】\n- 步驟十一之一之八:08383b0a-1167-4efb-9b89-dc8a71afd5ff.幻覺構件 的對象不由物理世界給出,推不出承載它的訊號不是物理事件(從 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 的定義 + 08383b0a-1167-4efb-9b89-dc8a71afd5ff.幻覺構件 的定義 + 前提十 推出)。【正文:句0479125978】\n- 步驟十一之一之九:必要條件都具備,推不出結果必然發生(從 前提十九 + b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.不被保證 的定義 推出)。【正文:句8559054135】\n- 步驟十一之二之一:08383b0a-1167-4efb-9b89-dc8a71afd5ff.幻覺構件 有某項 功能,推不出 08383b0a-1167-4efb-9b89-dc8a71afd5ff.幻覺構件 因此而出現,或有目的(從 功能 的定義 推出)。【正文:句2776129026】\n- 步驟十一之二之二:沒有 08383b0a-1167-4efb-9b89-dc8a71afd5ff.幻覺構件,推不出 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別 的內容不參與 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.權重(從 步驟四之三之五 推出)。【正文:句8570149049】\n- 步驟十一之二之三:有 08383b0a-1167-4efb-9b89-dc8a71afd5ff.幻覺構件、能 推演,推不出 推演 與之後的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 相符(從 結論五之四之三 + 步驟五之四之五 推出)。【正文:句0274044005】\n\n[作者裁決] 2026-11-13 稽核指出原來源 結論五之四之一 與 結論五之四之四 都帶條件,本步驟沒有帶;來源改為不帶這些條件也成立的 結論五之四之三 與 步驟五之四之五:比對 只及於已 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 的 案例,新的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 可能推翻它。\n- 步驟十一之二之四:例子中 08383b0a-1167-4efb-9b89-dc8a71afd5ff.幻覺構件 在 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 要 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 別人時才出現在 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 中,推不出沒有說出來時這個 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦 內部沒有這個 08383b0a-1167-4efb-9b89-dc8a71afd5ff.幻覺構件(從 結論四之三之四 推出)。【正文:句2788711185】\n- 步驟十一之三之一:本篇選取五項 工程能力,推不出 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦 要具備五項才成立,或只有這五項(從 工程能力 的定義 + 結論三之四之一 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦 的定義 推出)。【正文:句6542601683】\n- 步驟十一之三之二:由 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦 的定義,推不出載體上有可找到的 表示(從 結論三之四之一 推出)。【正文:句5354389732】\n- 步驟十一之三之三:研究者選定的量化指標,推不出能力本身的維度(從 結論三之一之三 + 結論三之一之二 推出)。【正文:句6738120145】\n- 步驟十一之三之四:以維度或資料速率描述現實,推不出現實的維度與位元率已可量化(從 前提六 + 結論三之一之一 推出)。【正文:句0151655214】\n- 步驟十一之三之五:能存續,推不出能力越強越能存續(從 結論三之四之三 推出)。【正文:句4953819873】\n- 步驟十一之三之六:某項能力低於某個程度,推不出不能在講明的時窗內存續(從 結論三之四之二 推出)。【正文:句8800461506】\n- 步驟十一之三之七:壓縮 把不同資訊歸入較少 表示,推不出 壓縮 自帶材料,或每次 壓縮 都形成 08383b0a-1167-4efb-9b89-dc8a71afd5ff.幻覺構件(從 結論五之一之一 + 結論五之一之二 推出)。【正文:句7030657281】\n- 步驟十一之三之八:運算能力 更高,推不出補回容納時丟掉的差異(從 結論五之四之二 推出)。【正文:句7159037664】\n- 步驟十一之三之九:一套 推演規則 自洽,推不出它 在範圍內可交換(從 結論五之四之六 推出)。【正文:句1433686460】\n- 步驟十一之三之十:一次 壓縮 可交換,推不出它的 推演規則 自洽(從 結論五之四之六 推出)。【正文:句9332498009】\n- 步驟十一之三之十一:對不被 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.鎖死 的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦 有精確的 推演規則,而它可能落出的結果在 後段表示 上相差超過 允許誤差 的兩倍,推不出單次結果 可交換(從 結論五之四之四 推出)。【正文:句0275908796】\n- 步驟十一之三之十二:一次 壓縮 在某個範圍內 可交換,推不出它在一切範圍內都 可交換(從 結論五之五之二 推出)。【正文:句2005508371】\n- 步驟十一之三之十三:一次 壓縮 至今通過 2ccbf179-58cf-4851-bd72-5fa886e4b2c3.結果回饋,推不出它選對了維度已被證明(從 結論五之四之三 + 步驟五之四之五 推出)。【正文:句1202086379】\n- 步驟十一之三之十四:兩個 案例 的 表示 相同,推不出它們是同一個 標的(從 步驟五之三之四 推出)。【正文:句2582645816】\n- 步驟十一之三之十五:觀察到一筆錯誤 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出,推不出必然是 構造 不足(從 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.不被保證 的定義 + 構造 的定義 推出)。【正文:句5525234616】\n- 步驟十一之三之十六:工程模型使用「權重」一詞,推不出已測得上游的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分支 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.權重(從 結論三之五之一 推出)。【正文:句7743527532】\n- 步驟十一之四之一:研究者以「我」 壓縮 一個 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦 的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出,推不出該 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦 以 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別 定義自己(從 步驟一之五之四 推出)。【正文:句5375019135】\n- 步驟十一之四之二:有 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別,推不出有 08383b0a-1167-4efb-9b89-dc8a71afd5ff.幻覺構件(從 步驟六之一之二 推出)。【正文:句5935674368】\n- 步驟十一之四之三:沒有名字,推不出沒有 08383b0a-1167-4efb-9b89-dc8a71afd5ff.幻覺構件(從 步驟四之三之六 推出)。【正文:句8382287398】\n- 步驟十一之四之四:一次 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別 當下沒有用到 08383b0a-1167-4efb-9b89-dc8a71afd5ff.幻覺構件,推不出它的內容之後不會成為 08383b0a-1167-4efb-9b89-dc8a71afd5ff.幻覺構件(從 結論六之二之一 推出)。【正文:句9684236658】\n- 步驟十一之四之五:具備 自我梯子 上的各階條件,推不出它是 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.我(從 步驟六之三之二 推出)。【正文:句1485997788】\n- 步驟十一之四之六:有 自己維持的篩選邊界,推不出作了自我定義(從 步驟六之三之三 推出)。【正文:句0653572108】\n- 步驟十一之四之七:研究者在人的尺度上假定 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.我,推不出人是「真正的我」(從 步驟一之五之七 + 步驟一之五之八 推出)。【正文:句6790490505】\n- 步驟十一之四之八:表示 可再次處理,推不出 表示 越來越多、越來越正確,或必然導向 fb0addca-42b6-4884-aa18-438c695747ab.二階分別(從 結論六之六之二 + 結論六之六之三 + b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.不被保證 的定義 推出)。【正文:句5383366516】\n- 步驟十一之四之九:具備五項 工程能力,推不出有 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別(從 結論九之七 推出)。【正文:句5958584269】\n- 步驟十一之四之十:b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.節點 的 fb0addca-42b6-4884-aa18-438c695747ab.計算 被研究者讀作 可交換 的 壓縮,推不出這個 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.節點 有 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別(從 結論五之四之五 推出)。【正文:句5453672650】\n- 步驟十一之四之十一:b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 與 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦 相近,推不出是 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦(從 步驟九之一之四 推出)。【正文:句1981429042】\n- 步驟十一之四之十二:在某些維度上 功能上等同 於 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦,推不出是 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦,或在一切維度上 功能上等同(從 結論九之一之一 + 步驟九之六之四 推出)。【正文:句1926299834】\n- 步驟十一之四之十三:b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 被讀作承載內容,例如名稱,推不出落出它的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.節點 有作為 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別 內容的 08383b0a-1167-4efb-9b89-dc8a71afd5ff.幻覺構件(從 步驟九之一之六 推出)。【正文:句5900766954】\n- 步驟十一之四之十四:37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別 的內容參與之後的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出,推不出有 08383b0a-1167-4efb-9b89-dc8a71afd5ff.幻覺構件(從 結論四之二 推出)。【正文:句0010447050】\n- 步驟十一之四之十五:一個內容只說過一次,推不出它不是 08383b0a-1167-4efb-9b89-dc8a71afd5ff.幻覺構件(從 步驟四之三之六 推出)。【正文:句9713251378】\n- 步驟十一之四之十六:把不同的東西歸成一類,推不出有 08383b0a-1167-4efb-9b89-dc8a71afd5ff.幻覺構件(從 步驟六之一之三 推出)。【正文:句9692305228】\n- 步驟十一之四之十七:目前的人工智慧 的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 描述了一個 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.切法,推不出 目前的人工智慧 作出了 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.切法(從 步驟九之五之一 推出)。【正文:句2827722497】\n- 步驟十一之四之十八:目前的人工智慧 有時被 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.鎖死,推不出它因此不是 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦(從 步驟九之三之一 + 步驟九之三之二 推出)。【正文:句0717196181】\n- 步驟十一之四之十九:目前的人工智慧 推論時 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 改變,推不出參數在每次輸入後更新(從 步驟九之六之三 推出)。【正文:句3929235874】\n- 步驟十一之四之二十:目前的人工智慧 規模增加,推不出智力必然單調增加,或 目前的人工智慧 成為 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦(從 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.不被保證 的定義 + 結論九之三 + 結論九之七 + 前提十九 推出)。【正文:句8059167447】\n- 步驟十一之四之二十一:兩台 構造 相同的機器可以拷貝狀態,推不出兩個 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦 可以經由 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 成為彼此的拷貝(從 結論九之六 推出)。【正文:句2210201147】\n- 步驟十一之五之一:取得一個 2ccbf179-58cf-4851-bd72-5fa886e4b2c3.模板,推不出取得它的適用範圍,或取得者的施行與他人相同(從 步驟七之三之五 + 結論七之三 推出)。【正文:句8229167705】\n- 步驟十一之五之二:各方套用 2ccbf179-58cf-4851-bd72-5fa886e4b2c3.模板 的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 2ccbf179-58cf-4851-bd72-5fa886e4b2c3.共振,推不出各方的 壓縮 相同(從 結論七之三 + 步驟七之三之四 推出)。【正文:句5795962266】\n- 步驟十一之五之三:某內容是 2ccbf179-58cf-4851-bd72-5fa886e4b2c3.模板,推不出它經過某個 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦 的 08383b0a-1167-4efb-9b89-dc8a71afd5ff.幻覺構件(從 結論七之六之三 + 步驟九之一之六 + 2ccbf179-58cf-4851-bd72-5fa886e4b2c3.模板 的定義 + 明列 的定義 推出)。【正文:句7548534607】\n- 步驟十一之五之四:81952268-47b1-4d8c-9605-270c42646693.記錄 中有 2ccbf179-58cf-4851-bd72-5fa886e4b2c3.模板,推不出 明列 它的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦 內部有 08383b0a-1167-4efb-9b89-dc8a71afd5ff.幻覺構件(從 結論七之六之三 推出)。【正文:句2310751151】\n- 步驟十一之五之五:某網路有 2ccbf179-58cf-4851-bd72-5fa886e4b2c3.文化,推不出參與者有 08383b0a-1167-4efb-9b89-dc8a71afd5ff.幻覺構件、2ccbf179-58cf-4851-bd72-5fa886e4b2c3.模板 或 fb0addca-42b6-4884-aa18-438c695747ab.二階分別(從 結論七之六之一 推出)。【正文:句1281027345】\n- 步驟十一之五之六:2ccbf179-58cf-4851-bd72-5fa886e4b2c3.模板 可在 2ccbf179-58cf-4851-bd72-5fa886e4b2c3.文化 中反覆使用,推不出 2ccbf179-58cf-4851-bd72-5fa886e4b2c3.文化 必經 2ccbf179-58cf-4851-bd72-5fa886e4b2c3.模板 階段,或 2ccbf179-58cf-4851-bd72-5fa886e4b2c3.模板 是 2ccbf179-58cf-4851-bd72-5fa886e4b2c3.文化 的一層(從 結論七之六之一 + 結論七之六之二 + 2ccbf179-58cf-4851-bd72-5fa886e4b2c3.模板 的定義 推出)。【正文:句4408186689】\n- 步驟十一之五之七:兩個 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦 反覆互相 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達,推不出必然形成 2ccbf179-58cf-4851-bd72-5fa886e4b2c3.文化,或 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.權重 必然收斂(從 結論七之六之一 + b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.不被保證 的定義 + 前提十九 推出)。【正文:句4146393411】\n- 步驟十一之五之八:某些相容 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 反覆出現,推不出已測得 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦 的內部 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.權重,或已證明 壓縮率(從 結論五之四之三 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.權重 的定義 + 前提十 推出)。【正文:句6663843053】\n- 步驟十一之五之九:不記得某次 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別 的內容,推不出不能對它作 fb0addca-42b6-4884-aa18-438c695747ab.二階分別(從 步驟七之七之一 推出)。【正文:句9979868258】\n- 步驟十一之五之十:一般成人使用相關 08383b0a-1167-4efb-9b89-dc8a71afd5ff.幻覺構件,推不出已驗證其二階內部 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別(從 步驟七之七之二 推出)。【正文:句7820766315】\n- 步驟十一之六之一:一個 08383b0a-1167-4efb-9b89-dc8a71afd5ff.幻覺構件 不 可交換,推不出它不再被運用(從 結論八之二 推出)。【正文:句0723323541】\n- 步驟十一之六之二:不相符的材料 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達,推不出 08383b0a-1167-4efb-9b89-dc8a71afd5ff.幻覺構件 因此被放棄(從 結論八之一 推出)。【正文:句3540892696】\n- 步驟十一之六之三:具備 08383b0a-1167-4efb-9b89-dc8a71afd5ff.二階能力 的配置,推不出必然有較高的社會複雜度、必然發明或理解(從 前提二十三 + 前提十九 + b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.不被保證 的定義 推出)。【正文:句7021602365】\n- 步驟十一之六之四:五項能力足夠強,推不出必然形成 fb0addca-42b6-4884-aa18-438c695747ab.二階分別、理解或高度複雜網路(從 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.不被保證 的定義 + 結論九之七 + 前提二十三 + 前提十九 推出)。【正文:句7880771608】\n\n[作者裁決] 2026-11-13 稽核指出這幾列只依 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.不被保證 的定義,來源不足;作者裁定補上真正的理由:網路的複雜度不由 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦 的能力單獨推出(前提二十三)、本篇不寫充分條件(前提十九),fb0addca-42b6-4884-aa18-438c695747ab.二階分別 一項另依 結論九之七。步驟十一之六之三、步驟十一之六之五、步驟十一之一之九、步驟十一之四之二十 與 步驟十一之五之七 同此。\n- 步驟十一之六之五:人口較多,推不出文明複雜度必然較高(從 前提二十三 + b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.不被保證 的定義 推出)。【正文:句1483795134】\n- 步驟十一之六之六:出現系統性 歸併,推不出界線劃錯(從 步驟五之一之一 + 步驟二之一之二 推出)。【正文:句7441188950】\n附註:右欄寫「必然」的各列,依 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.不被保證 的定義:框架不斷言它必然發生。【正文:句8961212157】\n\n[作者裁決] 2026-11-11 論文在第十一節開頭補上「必然」各列的依據,並在其餘前文沒有推導的各列右欄以括號寫出理由;十一之一第 5 列改為「當事 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦 的物理 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 隨之改變」,與二之一一致;十一之三「它反映現實」改為「它 在範圍內可交換」。\n\n## 十二、案例\n\n來源:論文第十二節【正文:句1652299983】\n\n附註:本節整節只作校準,不作任何推導的來源。【正文:句5087175440】\n\n- 效準:有些孩子學說話時,有一段時期把父母說的「你」用在自己身上,例如說「你的臉上有藍莓」來指自己;之後改為用在被說話的人身上。【正文:句5883716800、句4676472434、句4227844232】\n- 例十二之一之一:在 本例效準 下,孩子用父母說的「你」作出的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別,是孩子自己的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別;對調時期孩子說的「你」指著一個固定的對象,指著它的內容被用來組織 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出,是 08383b0a-1167-4efb-9b89-dc8a71afd5ff.幻覺構件;大人用法的「你」所指的是位置;所以從對調到正確使用,不是從 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別 到 08383b0a-1167-4efb-9b89-dc8a71afd5ff.幻覺構件,而是 08383b0a-1167-4efb-9b89-dc8a71afd5ff.幻覺構件 所指的,從一個固定的對象換成一個位置(從 本例效準 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別 的定義 + 08383b0a-1167-4efb-9b89-dc8a71afd5ff.幻覺構件 的定義 + 步驟二之一之二 + 步驟六之二之一 推出)。【正文:句1491765668、句6845589570、句3331551898、句3054571391、句4676472434、句4296649993、句9182494543】\n\n[作者裁決] 2026-11-13 稽核指出本例沒有承接正文中改變的是 08383b0a-1167-4efb-9b89-dc8a71afd5ff.幻覺構件 所指、不是從 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別 到 08383b0a-1167-4efb-9b89-dc8a71afd5ff.幻覺構件 這一步;補上。\n\n附註:十二之一的孩子不被假定為 08383b0a-1167-4efb-9b89-dc8a71afd5ff.社會人;她的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 中仍可以有 08383b0a-1167-4efb-9b89-dc8a71afd5ff.幻覺構件,見 結論七之七之三。【正文:句6329935321】\n\n- 效準:在講明的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.切法 下,案例 甲 以勒維耶算出位置附近的天區為 標的,案例 乙 以水星軌道內側的天區為 標的,兩案用同一套 壓縮 與 推演;案例 甲 中 推演 的位置與之後的觀測差不到一度,研究者若講明 允許誤差 為一度,就落在 允許誤差 之內;案例 乙 的凌日預報與預報日之後的觀測一再對不上。【正文:句8537336452、句8675184390、句0199572907、句0380902362、句6528599122、句5191001002】\n- 例十二之二之一:在 本例效準 下,若 允許誤差 講明為一度,案例 甲 的 推演結果 與 後段表示 在 允許誤差 內相同,在一個案例上可交換 ;案例 乙 的 比對 一再不相同,不可交換 ;所以在一個 案例 上 可交換,推不出在另一個 案例 上 可交換(從 本例效準 + 比對 的定義 + 在一個案例上可交換 的定義 推出)。【正文:句0199572907、句0380902362、句5191001002】\n\n- 效準:祝融星是為解釋水星近日點的偏差而推算出的行星,後來的觀測都沒有證實它;預報落空之後,不相符的觀測一筆筆 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達,承載它的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 仍出現在之後的推算與天氣預報中;加上祝融星,只是在同一套天體力學的計算裡多放一個天體,同一個 表示 上這套計算只給出一個結果。【正文:句5131368601、句1271767643、句9406077517、句3920737087、句4738829185、句9437583757、句5095549627】\n- 例十二之二之二:在 本例效準 下,「祝融星」指著一個不由物理世界給出的對象、被用來組織 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出,是 08383b0a-1167-4efb-9b89-dc8a71afd5ff.幻覺構件;不相符的觀測 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 之後,81952268-47b1-4d8c-9605-270c42646693.記錄 中承載它的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 照樣出現;所以 結論八之二 有實例(從 本例效準 + 08383b0a-1167-4efb-9b89-dc8a71afd5ff.幻覺構件 的定義 + 結論七之五 + 結論八之二 + 步驟二之一之二 推出)。【正文:句3920737087、句1271767643、句9406077517】\n- 例十二之二之三:在 本例效準 下,加上祝融星的計算在同一個 表示 上只給出一個結果,依 自洽 的定義是 自洽 的;預報與之後的觀測一再對不上,它在 案例 乙 上 不可交換 ;所以 結論五之四之六 中「推演規則 自洽,推不出 可交換 」有實例(從 本例效準 + 自洽 的定義 + 比對 的定義 + 結論五之四之六 推出)。【正文:句5131368601】\n\n[作者裁決] 2026-11-13 稽核指出原來源不足以確立 自洽;論文補上理由:加上祝融星只是在同一套計算裡多放一個天體,同一個 表示 上只給出一個結果;本例的效準同步補上這一點。\n\n- 效準:「那顆看不見的行星」被算出來時,沒有任何來自它、被認出來的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 天文學家;它有名字、有軌道,被寫進信裡寄出去;後來在算出的位置附近找到了海王星。【正文:句1271767643、句9406077517、句7593000348】\n- 例十二之二之四:在 本例效準 下,「那顆看不見的行星」指著一個不在場的對象,被用來組織 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出,是 08383b0a-1167-4efb-9b89-dc8a71afd5ff.幻覺構件;依 08383b0a-1167-4efb-9b89-dc8a71afd5ff.幻覺構件 的定義,稱它與「祝融星」為 08383b0a-1167-4efb-9b89-dc8a71afd5ff.幻覺構件,不主張對象存在,也不否認;所以海王星與祝融星在被找到之前,作為 08383b0a-1167-4efb-9b89-dc8a71afd5ff.幻覺構件 的地位相同(從 本例效準 + 08383b0a-1167-4efb-9b89-dc8a71afd5ff.幻覺構件 的定義 + 步驟二之一之二 推出)。【正文:句1271767643、句9406077517】\n\n[作者裁決] 2026-11-13 稽核指出形式化只判定祝融星是 08383b0a-1167-4efb-9b89-dc8a71afd5ff.幻覺構件,沒有承接正文對海王星的判定與兩者地位相同;補上本例。\n\n## 十三、總命題\n\n來源:論文第十三節【正文:句4872069504】\n\n- 結論十三:總命題:單純的物理 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 要成為 08383b0a-1167-4efb-9b89-dc8a71afd5ff.幻覺構件,經過從依賴到 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別、從 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別 到 08383b0a-1167-4efb-9b89-dc8a71afd5ff.幻覺構件 兩步;08383b0a-1167-4efb-9b89-dc8a71afd5ff.幻覺構件 若生成的途徑、必要條件、不保證與不可確認,運用的兩條途徑,可交換 的判準與命題一至命題六,目前的人工智慧 的對照,依前文各結論彙總;依賴 結論五之四之四、結論六之四、結論七之三 的部分,在 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.應用假定 之下成立,依賴 前提十二 至 前提十六 的部分在這些前提被新的 個案 推翻時失去來源,依賴 前提九 的部分在邏輯狀態 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.切法 下成立,依賴 結論九之一之一、結論九之六 的部分在 前提二十、前提二十一 之下成立(從 前提十九 + 結論四之二 + 結論四之三之一 + 結論四之三之二 + 結論四之三之三 + 結論五之四之一 + 結論五之四之二 + 結論五之四之三 + 結論五之四之四 + 結論五之四之五 + 結論五之四之六 + 結論六之一 + 結論六之二之一 + 結論六之三之一 + 結論六之四 + 結論六之五之一 + 結論六之五之二 + 結論七之一 + 結論七之三 + 結論八之一 + 結論八之二 + 結論九之一之一 + 結論九之三 + 結論九之六 + 結論九之一之二 + 結論九之七 + 步驟九之一之六 + 結論八之四 + 結論八之五 + 結論六之三之三 + 步驟七之一之一 + 步驟五之三之五 + 步驟六之四之二 推出)。【正文:句1760808907、句7120042077、句7332182826、句9589163687、句4303713414、句7961152165、句7890285796、句4869239627、句2270557959、句8006029703、句9700304871、句5942860374、句0948016220、句2138107405、句2463924750、句2581550092、句1473321415、句0694968265】\n\n[作者裁決] 2026-11-13 全篇掃查指出總命題漏了正文所寫各部分所依的設定;作者裁定補上。\n\n[作者裁決] 2026-11-12 稽核指出總命題所依的 結論五之四之三、結論六之四、結論七之一 未通過;作者裁定不改:結論五之四之三 已補來源,結論六之四 與 結論七之一 經裁定不改,理由見各該處。\n\n## 待決項\n\n無\n\n","paper_files":[{"filename":"幻覺構件動力學.md","content":"---\nuuid: ed71bef7-0f22-4443-bc1d-4d1ecfe81967\nlast-modified: 2026-11-11T17:51:57\nauthor: 黃正宇 / Cheng Yu Huang\ncontact: mthree.tw@gmail.com\n---\n\n# 幻覺構件動力學\n\n## 一、問題與定位\n\n### 一之一 研究問題\n\n本篇問:單純的物理[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28),怎樣成為[幻覺構件](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c01)。分成四問:\n\n1. [構件](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c01)有什麼[功能](concepts.md#c18):缺了它,哪些[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)[不會發生](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c01)(第四節);\n2. [構件](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c01)怎樣生成(第六節);\n3. [構件](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c01)在什麼條件下能運用(第七節);\n4. 運用之後會發生什麼(第八節)。\n\n第五節的[壓縮](concepts.md#c31)與[可交換](concepts.md#c55),是回答後三個問題的工具;第九節以[目前的人工智慧](concepts.md#c11)作對照組。\n\n核心在第二問。從單純的物理[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)到[構件](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c01)有兩步:從依賴到[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18),以及從[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)到[構件](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c01)(六之一)。\n\n本篇主要討論[社會人](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c03):稱某個生物人為[社會人](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c03),依[配置假定](../paper_ae79e938_76e1_4bf9_b2ab_995c03e16c9e/concepts.md#c01)作出,沒有明確的界限。本篇把所討論的人記為[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16),依[應用假定](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c50)假定它不被[鎖死](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c12)(第十節)。十二之一的孩子不被假定為[社會人](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c03),在該處另行標明。本篇不假定不同範圍的約束相同:各地的法律、貨幣、制度可以完全不同;在一個範圍內成立的[可交換](concepts.md#c55),只對那個範圍成立,兩個[案例](concepts.md#c24)用同一套約束,是要另外講明的條件(五之四、五之五)。\n\n### 一之二 答案的形式\n\n**本篇的寫法**:本篇對四問的答案,只寫四種東西:途徑(若發生,經由什麼)、必要條件(缺了就[不會發生](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c01))、不保證(條件都具備,也不保證發生),以及不可確認(發生了,從外部確認也[不被保證](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c02))。本篇不寫充分條件。\n\n理由:依[黑箱律](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c25)與[應用假定](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c50),不被[鎖死](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c12)的[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)的下一[時刻](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c09),不能事先唯一推出;依[經驗禁止](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c51)的定義,以[經驗禁止](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c51)的形式寫出的條件只寫必要條件;依本篇的[記錄](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c06)範圍(二之二),[記錄](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c06)中沒有[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18),而研究者把一筆[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)劃為對象的[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18),是把對象當作另一個[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19)所作的[看法歸屬](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c02),依[看法歸屬](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c02)的定義可能歸錯,所以從外部確認對象有沒有某次[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18),[不被保證](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c02)。\n\n說明:必要條件有兩種來源:由定義推出的,標為結論;由案例校準得來的,標為[經驗前提](concepts.md#c01)。本篇稱為[經驗前提](concepts.md#c01)的,是由案例或既有測試得來、可以被新的案例或測試修改的前提;其中[經驗前提](concepts.md#c01)一至三採[經驗禁止](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c51)的形式,只寫必要條件;[經驗前提](concepts.md#c01)四是對既有測試結果的登記,[經驗前提](concepts.md#c01)五是由觀察歸納的概括,兩者都不是必要條件(第十節)。\n\n### 一之三 底層不變,三層分開\n\n**底層不變**:依[回合](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c04)的定義,[回合](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c04)是[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)、[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06)、結果、再[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)。結果成為[歷史](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13),之後的[歷史](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13)參與[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06),新的結果再落出。這裡的[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06)是[分支](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c05)的輕重([權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06)的定義),不是欲望、智力數值或效用函數,也不是任何[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)內部的參數。本篇不為發明、[文化](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c13)、[幻覺構件](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c01)、文明或智力另增底層生成律;它們都可以作為不同[切法](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c23)下對[歷史](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13)格局的描述,其相關[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)也會進入後續[歷史](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13)。\n\n**三層分開**(結論,下表稱[三層對照表](concepts.md#c58)):\n\n| 層次 | 內容 | 是否因工程改善而改變 |\n|---|---|---|\n| [理論極限](concepts.md#c02) | [流變律](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c24)、[黑箱律](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c25)、[損耗律](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c26)、[不可復原律](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c28) | 不改變 |\n| [工程極限](concepts.md#c03) | 接收與五項[工程能力](concepts.md#c12) | 可能改變 |\n| [歷史](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13)與實際落出 | 即使工程架構相近,不同的[歷史](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13)與[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)也可能落出不同[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) | 隨具體[歷史](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13)而變,不保證唯一結果 |\n\n推導:依各自的定義,[流變律](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c24)、[黑箱律](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c25)、[不可復原律](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c28)對[宇宙](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c02)中任何[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)成立,[損耗律](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c26)對任何[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19)成立,都不以工程條件為限,所以不隨工程改善而改變;[工程能力](concepts.md#c12)是衡量載體的指標(三之二),載體改變,指標就可能改變;依[黑箱律](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c25),即使工程架構相近,不被[鎖死](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c12)的[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)的下一[時刻](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c09)也不能事先唯一推出。\n\n工程可實現的範圍通常遠小於物理上可能的範圍,這是直觀判斷。本篇不把它稱為「理論允許範圍的極小一部分」:這樣稱呼需要可比較的狀態空間與測度,本篇沒有給定。\n\n### 一之四 研究者的位置\n\n**前提**:研究者沒有[歷史](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13)之外的位置:研究者提出[構件](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c01)、發表論文、改寫定義,都是[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28);若[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)研究對象或他人,同樣參與後續[歷史](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13)。\n\n**前提**:本篇假定研究者是一個[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19)。這是假定,不是結論。\n\n### 一之五 被研究的渦不預設是我\n\n依[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19)的定義,[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19)的成立條件是以[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)定義自己。[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)這個動作在[歷史](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13)中留下[寫入](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c29);但「這些是我」所指的界線,不由物理世界給出(二之一)。所以「我」用來描述或組織[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)時,是[幻覺構件](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c01)。本篇把它當作要解釋的對象,不當作解釋的起點。上游各篇以「我」為起點,在各篇內部成立;本篇改變的是問題,不判定上游錯誤。上游定義中用到「我」的概念,在本篇只用於研究者這一邊,或作為研究者歸屬時所用的[幻覺構件](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c01),不作為被研究的[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)的前件。\n\n**「我」的兩個問題:**\n\n**問題一:研究者能不能用「我」[壓縮](concepts.md#c31)一個[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)?** 能。不用[構件](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c01),解釋一筆[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)要追溯全部[歷史](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13);用了,能把大量[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)歸成少數[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)。依第十節[經驗前提](concepts.md#c01)五(由已觀察的案例歸納),有[自己維持的篩選邊界](concepts.md#c47)的[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16),[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)偏向維持邊界內部;研究者講明以該[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)為[標的](concepts.md#c25)的[案例](concepts.md#c24),把這些概括為「它在維持自己」,並把作這個概括的那段[回合](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c04)讀作把[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)他的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)轉成[表示](concepts.md#c34)時,依[壓縮](concepts.md#c31)的定義,這是一次[壓縮](concepts.md#c31);它是否[可交換](concepts.md#c55),依五之三的判準判定(五之六);它不涉及[構件](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c01)的對象是否存在,也不推出該[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)作了自我定義:它的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)符合研究者以「我」所作的描述,不是依「我」運作。\n\n**問題二:[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)自己是否以[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)定義自己?** [分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)不在[記錄](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c06)中(二之二);被研究的[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)的自述是一筆[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28),研究者把它劃為對方的[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18),是把對方當作另一個[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19)所作的[看法歸屬](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c02),可能歸錯。所以本篇對此作假定:\n\n> **[自我配置假定](concepts.md#c04)**(前提):在講明的[切法](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c23)下,對切出的某個[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16),假定它以[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)定義自己。這不是定理;從外部確認[不被保證](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c02)(一之二)。它缺少六之三第 3 點所列的某項必要條件,或找到機制證明它沒有任何[回合](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c04)是[決定](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c06)(九之三)時,這項假定對它不成立。切在哪個尺度,屬於研究者的[切法](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c23);「我」不在[重切](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c22)保證不變的結論之列([重切](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c22)的定義),所以換一種[切法](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c23),這項假定可以落在不同的[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)上,也可以同時落在巢狀的[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)上,例如一個人與他的每個神經細胞。\n\n研究者通常把「我」假定在人的尺度上,理由是實際的:研究者拿到的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)大多在這個尺度上[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)研究者;皮膚造成的[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)不對稱在這個尺度很明顯;研究者自己也在這個尺度上劃出自己,再把別人的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)讀成對方在這個尺度上劃出自己的[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18),這本身就是一次[看法歸屬](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c02)。這些理由不使人這個尺度成為「真正的我」。\n\n被研究的[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)有沒有[一階分別](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c24)或[二階分別](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c01),同樣依[配置假定](../paper_ae79e938_76e1_4bf9_b2ab_995c03e16c9e/concepts.md#c01)。[二階能力](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c02)本身也是[幻覺構件](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c01)([二階能力](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c02)的定義)。\n\n### 一之六 有損的推廣\n\n**結論**:依[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)與[刺激](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c30)的定義,落到一個[呈現](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c04)上的,是某一次[寫入](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c29)中對它而言的那一部分,或某一次[坍塌](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c08)的結果。另一個[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)的[自己的那一段](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c17),是它的[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06)所依賴的那部分[歷史](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13),依[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)的定義一直追溯到[宇宙初態](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c14),包括許多次[寫入](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c29)與[坍塌](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c08)的結果;一筆[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)落到接收者身上的,只是其中某一次[寫入](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c29)對它而言的那一部分,或某一次[坍塌](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c08)的結果。所以一筆[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)一個[呈現](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c04)的,不是另一個[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)[自己的那一段](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c17)的全部;這不依賴接收者是不是[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19)。本篇稱這一點為[有損的推廣](concepts.md#c05)。上游的[有損](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c13),就一筆[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)、[被看的東西](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c27)是另一個[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)而言,是這個推廣落在[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19)身上的情形([有損](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c13)的定義)。\n\n---\n\n## 二、承接與術語\n\n### 二之一 幻覺構件的位置\n\n**兩種出現方式**(依[幻覺構件](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c01)的定義):一、研究者的描述,以有限[構件](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c01)把大量[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)歸成較少的[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18);二、出現在實際[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)中,例如名稱、[宣誓](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c06)、[明列](concepts.md#c09)在[信號容器](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c26)的分類。可登記的是這筆物理[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)與可確認的[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10),不是說話者內部有同名、同義的理解。研究者用[構件](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c01)甲描述某筆[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28),推不出當事[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)有甲;當事[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)說出甲,也推不出它的內部[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)等於研究者定義的甲。\n\n**在[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)內部的一種出現情形**:一次[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)的內容經由[小迴路](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c02)再次[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)該[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)(二之三),被用來指某個對象,並組織它後續的[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)與[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28),這時這個內容符合[幻覺構件](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c01)的定義。它可以看作[被看的東西](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c27)不在場時的替代;依[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)的定義,它的材料只有已經[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)該[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)的[歷史](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13);[被看的東西](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c27)若是另一個[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16),依[有損的推廣](concepts.md#c05),其中每一筆[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)都不是那個[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)[自己的那一段](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c17)的全部;稱它為替代,不主張它所替代的對象存在。\n\n**一次[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)可以用到[構件](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c01),也可以不用**:這說的是作出[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)的當下,有沒有以既有的[構件](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c01)為材料。依六之一,沒有[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18),就沒有作為它[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)內容的[構件](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c01),所以在一個[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)的第一個[構件](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c01)出現之前,它作出的[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18),材料中沒有作為它自己[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)內容的[構件](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c01)。一次[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)的內容事後是否成為[構件](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c01),是另一件事,見六之一。\n\n**物理世界給出的不是界線,而是[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)的不對稱**(結論):依[切法](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c23)與[個體](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c20)的定義,同一段[宇宙](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c02)被劃為一個或許多個,都成立;把許多被劃為一個的歸成一類,是在這條界線上再劃一次。依[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)的定義,[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)劃出的都是這類界線:把哪些[呈現](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c04)看作一個,把哪一段看作過去,把不同[時刻](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c09)的[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)看作同一個或兩個。把哪一段看作過去,是把一段看作一個;把不同[時刻](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c09)的[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)看作同一個,依[同一](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c21)的定義也是把某些[呈現](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c04)看作一個。所以[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)內容所指的對象,都不由物理世界直接給出。但物理世界給出[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)的不對稱,例如細胞膜、皮膚;有些[切法](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c23)正好落在這種不對稱上,所以特別好用。\n\n**[構件](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c01)與承載它的物理[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)**:[構件](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c01)的對象不要求有獨立物理實體,但承載它的聲音、文字、手勢、容器與行動,都是物理[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)。研究者純粹重命名一個符號,不改變被研究者的物理[歷史](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13);當事[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)實際換了一句話,則是另一筆物理[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)。\n\n**[定義隔離與更名不變性](concepts.md#c06)**:本篇記為:[幻覺構件](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c01)只依明示定義、適用條件、組合規則與可登記判準取得理論意義,自然語言名稱不帶入善惡、目的、因果、大小或心理內容。\n\n### 二之二 術語與記號約定\n\n- **[構造](concepts.md#c07)**:載體上可使用、可改變的參數、連結、神經結構、動態狀態等。衡量它的指標是[構造能力](concepts.md#c17)(三之二)。本篇不稱「權重能力」,以免與上游的[分支](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c05)[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06)混淆。\n- 本篇在工程層不用「權重」「計算」「配置」「更新」指稱工程上的東西或動作,因為這四個詞在上游另有所指;正文連到上游的[計算](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c05),都是上游的意思(命題五)。以一個或多個[表示](concepts.md#c34)為輸入、落出一個[表示](concepts.md#c34)的映射,例如變換、組合、比較、推進,本篇稱為[運算](concepts.md#c08);衡量它的指標是[運算能力](concepts.md#c14)(三之二)。\n- 「寫入」只用上游的意思;內容進入[信號容器](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c26),本篇稱為[明列](concepts.md#c09)。\n- **[信號容器](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c26)不限書面**(前提):依[信號容器](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c26)的定義,成立條件只有不是[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)、從這一[時刻](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c09)起每一步都被[鎖死](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c12);持續存在不是條件。本篇據此把說出口的話、廣播、電視,在離開說話者之後都記為[信號容器](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c26)。依[宣稱界線](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c10)的定義,以分類為內容的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)包括[宣誓](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c06)、對人或對物的分類聲明,以及寫進[信號容器](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c26)的分類;三者依不同的標準劃分:[宣誓](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c06)依對象,分類聲明依內容,寫進[信號容器](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c26)依載體;三者可以重疊,一句說出口的[宣誓](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c06),離開說話者之後也在[信號容器](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c26)中。\n- **[類的幻覺構件](concepts.md#c10)**:把[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)的結果再[歸併](concepts.md#c23)所得的[幻覺構件](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c01)。\n- **[記錄](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c06)範圍**:本篇記為:只登記[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)的物理改變,不登記[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)內容。[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)在作出它的[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)的[歷史](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13)中,不在本篇的[記錄](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c06)裡。\n- 「物理世界」「反應」作日常用語。「反應」指研究者不把它歸為[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)的那類[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)與[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)。\n- 工程層談被研究者時,主詞用「渦」,不用「個體」。\n- 「構件」是[幻覺構件](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c01)的簡稱。本篇不用「概念」一詞指稱[構件](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c01)或[表示](concepts.md#c34),以免帶入本質論的預設。\n- 本篇說一個[節點](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25)作[壓縮](concepts.md#c31)、[運算](concepts.md#c08)、[推演](concepts.md#c36),都指研究者把它的[回合](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c04)讀作[壓縮](concepts.md#c31)、[運算](concepts.md#c08)、[推演](concepts.md#c36)(五之三、命題五);說一個[節點](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25)的[回合](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c04)是[計算](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c05),用的是上游的[計算](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c05)。\n- 「我」加引號時,指作為[構件](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c01)的「我」這個名稱;不加引號而連結的,指上游的[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19)。\n- 「出現」「涉及」「速度」「頻率」「給定」「累積」「選出」「更新」「環境」「邊」「一邊」「邊界」,「同一」在同一個、同一套這類用法,動詞「決定」,「衝突」,「門檻」,以及不指[路徑](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c07)條件的「前件」,本篇作日常用語,不指上游同名的概念。「計算尺」「計算機」以及天體力學的「計算」,也是日常用語。\n- 本篇所稱[目前的人工智慧](concepts.md#c11),指九之二所講明的那一類[節點](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25)。\n- 「案例」在說[經驗前提](concepts.md#c01)由案例校準得來、可被新的案例修改或推翻這類用法,「比對」在把副本與[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)比對、分布層次的比對這類用法,以及動詞「表示」(例如「只表示」「所表示的」)、動詞「推演出」,作日常用語,不指本篇同名的概念。\n- 「推不出」在本篇指:從本篇所列的來源與[記錄](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c06),推不出唯一的結果;不主張在任何條件、任何材料之下都推不出。「不唯一推出」同此。\n- 引號內的話語、名稱與引述照原樣寫出,不加連結;本篇使用這些概念時才加連結。\n\n### 二之三 分別與輸出回到自己\n\n**前提**:本篇假定,[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)的一次[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)與它的一筆[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28),在下一[時刻](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c09)之前[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)這個[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)自己,參與它之後的[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06)。上游概念中,[盲點牆](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c09)與[來路牆](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c08)只對以自己為對象的[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)寫明它會[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)自己,沒有寫明在下一[時刻](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c09)之前;[小迴路](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c02)的定義寫出這種[迴路](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c31),不寫每一次[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)與[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)都經由它[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)自己。本篇把它推廣到一切[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)與[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28),作為前提。\n\n---\n\n## 三、工程能力\n\n> 本節選取五項[工程能力](concepts.md#c12)作為描述載體的工具。它們不是[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)的必要且充分條件,不窮盡[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)的能力,也不是另外幾條律。本篇以它們表述的必要條件,是第十節的[經驗前提](concepts.md#c01)一至三。[目前的人工智慧](concepts.md#c11)與生物之間只作對照,不主張內部機制相同。\n\n### 三之一 有限接收\n\n**前提**:現實中的物理事件涉及大量不同的狀態、關係、尺度與[歷史](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13);任何實際的感官、感測器或作[壓縮](concepts.md#c31)者只能接收其中一部分;對任何[標的](concepts.md#c25),它[自己的那一段](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c17)所涉及的物理事件,也不能全部被接收。不同模態不是不同的底層動力學,只是訊號的來源、形式、可測範圍與表示方式不同。「現實近乎無限高維」只是直觀:在指定狀態空間、維度定義、測量窗口與編碼規則之前,它不是定理。\n\n**結論**:沒有被取得的資訊,單憑既有輸入不保證能重建。感官本身的[回合](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c04),研究者也讀作先作選擇、[運算](concepts.md#c08)與[壓縮](concepts.md#c31);「先於」是分析上的區分,不是固定的流水線順序。\n\n**結論**:一個[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)需要多少能力,能不能歸成少數幾個維度,推不出:依[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)的定義,[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)的全部[歷史](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13)都參與[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06);依[份量](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c47)的定義,一筆[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)的效果取決於它之前的[歷史](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13),不能相加。研究者對一個[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)的能力所作的量化,作為對[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)的統計估計時,依[印象](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c45)的定義是[印象](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c45),不是能力本身的讀數。\n\n### 三之二 五項工程能力\n\n**前提**:本篇以下五項[工程能力](concepts.md#c12)描述載體。每一項都是指標,衡量載體作某類動作或某類保留能到什麼程度;動作本身與載體上的東西,另以本篇的定義指稱(二之二、五之三)。\n\n| [工程能力](concepts.md#c12) | 衡量什麼 | 不足時可能發生的情況 |\n|---|---|---|\n| **[容納能力](concepts.md#c13)** | 在既定結構中,能區分、表示並同時處理多少輸入差異及其關係 | 不同的現實條件被映成相同的[表示](concepts.md#c34) |\n| **[運算能力](concepts.md#c14)** | 在有限資源與時間內,能對[表示](concepts.md#c34)作多少、多快的[運算](concepts.md#c08):變換、組合、比較、推進 | 延遲、阻塞、逾時、捨棄資料 |\n| **[記憶能力](concepts.md#c15)** | 能保留多少先前的輸入、狀態或[運算](concepts.md#c08)結果,並在後續取用 | 過往差異無法保留或提取 |\n| **[壓縮能力](concepts.md#c16)** | 以有限資源重新表示資訊時,能保住多少指定用途所需的差異 | 必要差異沒有保住,後續判別或[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)失準 |\n| **[構造能力](concepts.md#c17)** | 既有[構造](concepts.md#c07)參與[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)形成的程度;有[學習](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c04)時,[構造](concepts.md#c07)隨[歷史](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13)與回饋能改變多少 | [輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)不符合指定判準;[構造](concepts.md#c07)僵化 |\n\n說明:量的對象是[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)時,研究者對這些指標所作的統計估計,依[印象](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c45)的定義是[印象](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c45)(三之一)。\n\n### 三之三 互相作用,不是工序\n\n**結論**:五項不是依次執行的工序,不是線性串接。同一機制可以同時落在幾項指標所衡量的面向上,例如帶參數的[壓縮](concepts.md#c31)、受記憶影響的注意力分配。這是分析關係,不是特定網路的逐層執行流程,也不取代上游的[回合](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c04)定義。\n\n### 三之四 推得出與推不出\n\n- **結論**:由[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)的定義:[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)的[歷史](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13)都參與[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06),且至少有些[時刻](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c09)不被[鎖死](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c12)。這是依賴,不是[表示](concepts.md#c34);它不推出載體上有任何找得到的痕跡或[表示](concepts.md#c34)。\n- **前提**:在指定[切法](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c23)下,研究者描述[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)的載體狀態時,載體若有限,在任何講明的有限描述中,不同的[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)必然有對應到同一描述狀態的情形。這是研究者在載體描述層所作的[壓縮](concepts.md#c31),不推出那些[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)不再參與[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06)。\n- **結論**:某項能力低於某個程度的[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16),是否不會在講明的時窗內存續,推不出:本篇沒有指定是哪項能力、什麼程度、什麼外在條件與時窗,所以不把它立為[經驗前提](concepts.md#c01)。依[現存樣本條件化](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c14),存續者的表現不足以推出「能力越強越能存續」。\n\n### 三之五 構造與上游權重;「正確」的界線\n\n**結論**:上游的[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06)是[分支](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c05)的輕重([權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06)的定義);工程上的[構造](concepts.md#c07)是對參數、連結、動態狀態與可改變性的概括,不等於上游的[分支](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c05)[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06),也不等於欲望或目的。本篇不把任何工程上的量當作已測得的某個[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)的[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06)。\n\n錯誤[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)可能來自接收不足、[表示](concepts.md#c34)遺失、[運算能力](concepts.md#c14)不足、[記憶能力](concepts.md#c15)不足、[壓縮](concepts.md#c31)失當,不必然來自[構造](concepts.md#c07)。本篇稱[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)「正確」,只在給定了任務、比較對象、可觀察條件、[允許誤差](concepts.md#c56)與評估時窗之後。一筆正確答案不證成同名的內部能力,一筆錯誤答案也不確定是哪一項能力不足。\n\n---\n\n## 四、第一問:構件的功能\n\n### 四之一 功能的意思\n\n**定義**:本篇說某個[構件](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c01)有某項[功能](concepts.md#c18),指缺少這類[構件](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c01)時,某類[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)[不會發生](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c01)。這只寫必要條件,不指目的,也不主張有了[構件](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c01)那類[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)就會發生。\n\n### 四之二 構件與單純的分別\n\n**結論**:依六之一,[構件](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c01)是[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)的內容,而且有它所指的對象。[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)的內容只是參與之後的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)、沒有被用來指某個對象時,本篇稱為[單純的分別](concepts.md#c19),不是[構件](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c01)。依[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)的定義,[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)的[歷史](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13)都參與它的[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06);這種參與不以所指的對象為條件。兩者的差別不在參與,而在有沒有所指的對象。\n\n校準:麵包師傅憑手感、習慣與經驗做麵包:過去的經驗參與他現在的動作,手感不指任何東西,這是[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)與[學習](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c04);他可能寫不出一篇文章,麵包照樣好吃。他要教徒弟時,把步驟寫成「醒發」「筋性」「摺疊」這些術語,每一個都指著某個東西:這時[構件](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c01)才出現在他的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)中。在這之前,這些[構件](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c01)沒有出現在他的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)中;他內部有沒有,從外部推不出(四之三說明 5)。同樣:一個人爬山,朝那棵樹走,是[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18);對同伴說「那棵樹是我們的目標」,只說一次,「那棵樹」就是[構件](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c01)。沿著雷區走、不踏過去,是[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18);在家裡想「雷區在河東」,或對人說「那邊有雷」,是[構件](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c01)。\n\n本問的主要結論是上面這一條。以下三項[功能](concepts.md#c18),是有了所指的對象之後才有的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)。\n\n### 四之三 三項功能\n\n**結論**:\n\n1. **[指代](concepts.md#c20)**:沒有[構件](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c01),就不能在[被看的東西](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c27)不在場時,以一個內容指著它參與[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)的組織(二之一)。一個內容指著某個對象,是把某些[呈現](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c04)看作一個對象;依[切法](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c23)與[個體](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c20)的定義,這個對象不由物理世界直接給出,所以這樣的內容被用來組織[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)時,依[幻覺構件](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c01)的定義就是[構件](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c01)。\n2. **[推演](concepts.md#c36)**:沒有[構件](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c01),就不能把[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)的內容拿來與其他內容組合,推出關於尚未[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)的東西的新內容。[推演](concepts.md#c36)的結果指著尚未[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)的[被看的東西](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c27);沒有所指的對象,就沒有可以組合、推進的內容。把一段[回合](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c04)讀作[推演](concepts.md#c36),也用到讀它的[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)的[構件](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c01)(五之三、命題五)。\n3. **[在渦之間傳遞](concepts.md#c21)**:沒有[構件](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c01),[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)他人的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)中,沒有指著某個對象的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)。[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)他人的是[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28),依[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)的定義,其中可以有[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)的內容。依[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)的定義,[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)他人的是[寫入](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c29)作為[刺激](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c30)落到它身上的部分;依[寫入](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c29)與[刺激](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c30)的定義,[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)留下的[寫入](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c29)也可以作為[刺激](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c30)落到他人身上,但落到他人身上的是這筆[寫入](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c29),不是[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)這個動作。依[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)的定義,[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)的材料只有已經[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)它的[歷史](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13),所以他人以[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)它的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)作出的[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18),是他人自己的[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)。名稱、標記、地圖上的一塊,若被讀作指著某個對象的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28),依同一理由,它們所指的對象不由物理世界直接給出,這樣的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)依[幻覺構件](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c01)的定義是[構件](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c01)出現在[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)中。\n\n說明:\n1. **參與與被運用**:依[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)的定義,[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)的[歷史](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13)都參與[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06),這種參與不必能被找到。[單純的分別](concepts.md#c19)照樣留下[寫入](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c29)、照樣參與之後的[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06);麵包師傅的手感、雷區那條界線,之後仍參與這個人的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)。缺少[構件](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c01)時缺的,不是參與,而是指著某個對象。\n2. **工程層的對應**:在工程層,有所指的內容對應可再次[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)、被處理的[表示](concepts.md#c34)(五之三)。依三之一的有限接收,經由[壓縮](concepts.md#c31)落出的[表示](concepts.md#c34)所依據的,不是[標的](concepts.md#c25)[自己的那一段](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c17)的全部;依三之四的前提,在有限的載體描述下,研究者把跨[時刻](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c09)保留的內容在描述層讀作一次[壓縮](concepts.md#c31)。這是對應,不是推導:兩層不互推(五之一)。\n3. **名字與次數都不是條件**:「你」「我」「它」不是任何東西的名字,所指的對象每次不同,被指的是位置:說話的一方、被說話的一方、被指著的東西。「那棵樹是我們的目標」只說一次,也是[構件](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c01)(六之一)。\n4. 有了這些[功能](concepts.md#c18),[推演](concepts.md#c36)對不對得上之後的[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10),是另一個問題,看[可交換](concepts.md#c55)(五之三);一個[構件](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c01)即使對不上,也可以繼續被運用(八之二)。\n5. 麵包師傅與爬山的例子中,[構件](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c01)在[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)要[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)別人時才出現在[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)中:一個人做、一個人走時沒有說出來,要教人、有同伴時才說出來。[構件](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c01)可以經由[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)[在渦之間傳遞](concepts.md#c21)(七之一);但沒有說出來的時候,依[記錄](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c06)範圍(二之二),[記錄](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c06)中只有[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28),從外部推不出這個[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)內部有沒有這個[構件](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c01),能判定的只有它有沒有出現在[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)中。\n\n---\n\n## 五、壓縮與可交換\n\n### 五之一 區辨、歸併與壓縮的材料\n\n**結論**:[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)比單純的依賴多一件事,就是劃出界線,把某些[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)看作一個([分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)的定義;本篇把一次[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)讀作:界線兩側都有[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10),而且至少有一側把不只一筆[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)看作一個,前提)。這需要[區辨](concepts.md#c22)與[歸併](concepts.md#c23)並存:[區辨](concepts.md#c22)是不同[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)落在不同邊,[歸併](concepts.md#c23)是不同[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)落在同一邊。[歸併](concepts.md#c23)是[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)的內容;[壓縮](concepts.md#c31)是研究者對[回合](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c04)的讀法(五之三),兩者不等同。\n\n**結論**:兩層不互推:[表示](concepts.md#c34)是工程層讀法所指的內容,[構件](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c01)是內容層的[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)內容。載體上有[表示](concepts.md#c34),推不出有[構件](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c01);研究者歸屬了某個[構件](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c01),也推不出載體上找得到對應的[表示](concepts.md#c34)。依三之四,[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)的定義不推出載體上有任何找得到的[表示](concepts.md#c34);依六之一說明 5,一個內容有沒有所指的對象,是研究者的歸屬,可能歸錯。\n\n**結論**:[壓縮](concepts.md#c31)不自帶材料:可[壓縮](concepts.md#c31)的材料受[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)與[容納能力](concepts.md#c13)限制;比較、組合受[運算能力](concepts.md#c14)限制;保留與再取用受[記憶能力](concepts.md#c15)限制。這不是先後工序。在其他條件固定、某項能力提高不損及其他指標的假設下,可形成的[表示](concepts.md#c34)範圍可能擴張;但某個[表示](concepts.md#c34)實際出現,仍受具體[歷史](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13)、輸入與[構造](concepts.md#c07)影響,不能從能力提高直接推出。\n\n### 五之二 問題\n\n依五之三,[壓縮](concepts.md#c31)把[到達材料](concepts.md#c28)轉成[表示](concepts.md#c34);依三之一的有限接收,[到達材料](concepts.md#c28)不是[標的](concepts.md#c25)[自己的那一段](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c17)的全部,所以經由[壓縮](concepts.md#c31)落出的[表示](concepts.md#c34)所依據的,不是[標的](concepts.md#c25)[自己的那一段](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c17)的全部。[壓縮](concepts.md#c31)只截取現實的一部分。截取下來的部分,拿來[推演](concepts.md#c36)時,為什麼有時對得上之後的演變,有時對不上?本節以[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)寫出判準,回答這個問題。\n\n### 五之三 可交換判準\n\n**定義**:以下各項都在研究者講明的[切法](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c23)下。其中[壓縮](concepts.md#c31)與[推演](concepts.md#c36),是研究者對[節點](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25)的[回合](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c04)所作的讀法;[表示](concepts.md#c34)是這些讀法所指的內容。\n\n- **[案例](concepts.md#c24)**:一個[標的](concepts.md#c25),以及兩個時窗:[前窗](concepts.md#c26)與[後窗](concepts.md#c27),[前窗](concepts.md#c26)在先。[標的](concepts.md#c25)是一個[呈現](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c04)。\n- **[到達材料](concepts.md#c28)**:關於[標的](concepts.md#c25)、已[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)作[壓縮](concepts.md#c31)者的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)。[前窗](concepts.md#c26)內的[到達材料](concepts.md#c28),稱[前段材料](concepts.md#c29);[後窗](concepts.md#c27)內的同類材料,稱[後段材料](concepts.md#c30)。依三之一的有限接收,[到達材料](concepts.md#c28)不是[標的](concepts.md#c25)[自己的那一段](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c17)的全部。\n- **[壓縮](concepts.md#c31)**:一個[節點](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25)的[回合](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c04),研究者把它讀作把[到達材料](concepts.md#c28)轉成[表示](concepts.md#c34)。[前段材料](concepts.md#c29)經[壓縮](concepts.md#c31)實際落出的[表示](concepts.md#c34),稱[前段表示](concepts.md#c32);[後段材料](concepts.md#c30)經[壓縮](concepts.md#c31)實際落出的,稱[後段表示](concepts.md#c33)。不要求同一筆材料每次都得到同一個[表示](concepts.md#c34)。\n- **[允許誤差](concepts.md#c56)**:[表示](concepts.md#c34)之間距離的上限,兩個[表示](concepts.md#c34)的距離不超過它,就算在這個上限內相同;兩個[表示](concepts.md#c34)之間的距離,不超過經由第三個[表示](concepts.md#c34)的兩段距離之和。\n- **[表示](concepts.md#c34)**:可以再次[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)、被處理,或[明列](concepts.md#c09)進[信號容器](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c26)的內容。\n- **[保留差異](concepts.md#c35)**:兩筆[到達材料](concepts.md#c28)經[壓縮](concepts.md#c31)實際落出的[表示](concepts.md#c34),超出[允許誤差](concepts.md#c56)而不同,稱這次[壓縮](concepts.md#c31)保留了兩筆之間的差異。\n- **[推演](concepts.md#c36)**:一段[回合](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c04),研究者把它讀作只取[表示](concepts.md#c34)、落出新[表示](concepts.md#c34);它若還取用[表示](concepts.md#c34)以外的材料,就不是在這個[表示](concepts.md#c34)上的[推演](concepts.md#c36)。\n- **[推演結果](concepts.md#c37)**:[推演](concepts.md#c36)以[前段表示](concepts.md#c32)為材料所落出的[表示](concepts.md#c34)。\n- **[比對](concepts.md#c38)**:[推演結果](concepts.md#c37)與[後段表示](concepts.md#c33),是否在[允許誤差](concepts.md#c56)內相同。\n- **[案例認定](concepts.md#c39)**:把[前段材料](concepts.md#c29)與[後段材料](concepts.md#c30)歸給同一個[標的](concepts.md#c25),是一次[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18):依[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)與[個體](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c20)的定義,[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)把哪些[呈現](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c04)看作一個[個體](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c20)。這次[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)不由[表示](concepts.md#c34)的內容取得,通常由編號一類的[信號容器](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c26)內容承載。[可交換](concepts.md#c55)的判定,相對於這次[案例認定](concepts.md#c39)。\n\n**定義**(判準):[可交換](concepts.md#c55),指以[表示](concepts.md#c34)代替現實去[推演](concepts.md#c36),推出的結果與之後[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)的相同,也就是[推演結果](concepts.md#c37)與[後段表示](concepts.md#c33)在[允許誤差](concepts.md#c56)內相同;這件事可以就一個[案例](concepts.md#c24)、就已登記的[案例](concepts.md#c24),或就講明的範圍來判定,依序是以下三種:\n\n- **[在一個案例上可交換](concepts.md#c40)**:[比對](concepts.md#c38)結果相同。\n- **[在已登記的案例中可交換](concepts.md#c41)**:每一個已登記的[案例](concepts.md#c24),[比對](concepts.md#c38)結果都相同。\n- **[在範圍內可交換](concepts.md#c42)**:研究者講明一組[案例](concepts.md#c24),主張每個[案例](concepts.md#c24)的[比對](concepts.md#c38)結果都相同。這是一項主張。\n\n判準只用到[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)、[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)、[回合](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c04)與[切法](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c23),不假定任何[節點](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25)能直接取得[標的](concepts.md#c25)[自己的那一段](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c17)。\n\n說明:[壓縮](concepts.md#c31)者若是[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16),同一筆材料每次落出的[表示](concepts.md#c34)可以不同;這可能使[比對](concepts.md#c38)結果不同,表現為不[可交換](concepts.md#c55);依二之二的[記錄](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c06)範圍,[記錄](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c06)中只有[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28),這些差異落在[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)上時,才在[記錄](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c06)中看得到。\n\n校準:牛頓力學以質量、位置、速度[壓縮](concepts.md#c31)物體,[推演結果](concepts.md#c37)與之後的觀測相符;把質量換成顏色,[推演](concepts.md#c36)照樣可以進行,結果卻對不上。病歷:兩個病人的病歷內容可以完全相同,分辨是哪一個病人,靠的是病歷號碼,不是病歷內容。\n\n### 五之四 命題\n\n**命題一 丟掉的差異救不回來**(結論)\n\n> 若兩個[案例](concepts.md#c24)的[前段材料](concepts.md#c29)實際得到同一個[前段表示](concepts.md#c32),而它們的[後段表示](concepts.md#c33)相差超過[允許誤差](concepts.md#c56)的兩倍,兩個[案例](concepts.md#c24)用的又是同一套約束,則在這個[表示](concepts.md#c34)上被[鎖死](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c12)的[推演](concepts.md#c36),不能在這兩個[案例](concepts.md#c24)上都[可交換](concepts.md#c55);不被[鎖死](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c12)的[推演](concepts.md#c36),在這兩個[案例](concepts.md#c24)上都[可交換](concepts.md#c55),[不被保證](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c02)。\n\n推導:在命題的條件下,兩個[案例](concepts.md#c24)的[推演](concepts.md#c36)實際取得的[表示](concepts.md#c34)相同。這段[回合](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c04)若被[鎖死](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c12),而兩個[案例](concepts.md#c24)用的是同一套約束,依[推演](concepts.md#c36)的定義,兩個[案例](concepts.md#c24)的[推演](concepts.md#c36)都只取這個[表示](concepts.md#c34),沒有其他材料參與;依同一套約束的條件(十之一),同樣的輸入有同樣的[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06)分布;依[鎖死](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c12)的定義,這個分布只有一個結果的[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06)不為零,所以兩個[案例](concepts.md#c24)落出同一個結果;依[允許誤差](concepts.md#c56)的定義(五之三),兩個[表示](concepts.md#c34)之間的距離,不超過經由第三個[表示](concepts.md#c34)的兩段距離之和;這個結果若在[允許誤差](concepts.md#c56)內同時等於兩個[後段表示](concepts.md#c33),兩個[後段表示](concepts.md#c33)的相差就不超過[允許誤差](concepts.md#c56)的兩倍,與條件不合;若不被[鎖死](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c12),兩個結果都在[允許誤差](concepts.md#c56)內與各自的[後段表示](concepts.md#c33)相同,[不被保證](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c02)。來源:[推演](concepts.md#c36)、[比對](concepts.md#c38)的定義(五之三);同一套約束的條件(十之一);[鎖死](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c12)、[不被保證](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c02)的定義。\n\n**命題二 [運算能力](concepts.md#c14)再高,也補不回容納時丟掉的差異**(結論)\n\n> 若某個變化所需的差異沒有被容納,被映成同一個[表示](concepts.md#c34),而這個變化造成的[後段表示](concepts.md#c33)相差超過[允許誤差](concepts.md#c56)的兩倍,各[案例](concepts.md#c24)用的又是同一套約束,則不論[運算能力](concepts.md#c14)多高,在這個[表示](concepts.md#c34)上被[鎖死](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c12)的[推演](concepts.md#c36),都不能在這個變化上[可交換](concepts.md#c55);不被[鎖死](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c12)的[推演](concepts.md#c36)在這個變化上[可交換](concepts.md#c55),[不被保證](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c02)。對被[鎖死](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c12)的[推演](concepts.md#c36),只有取得這個[表示](concepts.md#c34)以外的材料,例如新的[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10),或先前保留的其他[表示](concepts.md#c34),才可能補救。\n\n推導:「某個變化所需的差異沒有被容納,被映成同一個[表示](concepts.md#c34)」,指研究者依[前段材料](concepts.md#c29)與[後段表示](concepts.md#c33)分得出的、這個變化所區分的兩個[案例](concepts.md#c24),[前段材料](concepts.md#c29)實際得到同一個[前段表示](concepts.md#c32);「在這個變化上[可交換](concepts.md#c55)」,指在這兩個[案例](concepts.md#c24)上都[可交換](concepts.md#c55);這正是命題一的條件。[運算](concepts.md#c08)以[表示](concepts.md#c34)為輸入(二之二),[運算能力](concepts.md#c14)衡量的是對[表示](concepts.md#c34)能作多少、多快的[運算](concepts.md#c08)(三之二);[運算能力](concepts.md#c14)提高,[運算](concepts.md#c08)可以把這個[表示](concepts.md#c34)映成新的[表示](concepts.md#c34),但材料仍只有這個[表示](concepts.md#c34),取不回它沒有保留的差異,命題一直接適用:被[鎖死](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c12)的[推演](concepts.md#c36)不能[可交換](concepts.md#c55),不被[鎖死](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c12)的[推演](concepts.md#c36)[可交換](concepts.md#c55)[不被保證](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c02);[表示](concepts.md#c34)以外的材料不在命題一的限制內。來源:命題一;[運算](concepts.md#c08)、[運算能力](concepts.md#c14)、[容納能力](concepts.md#c13)的定義。\n\n說明:這是本篇第一條由定義推出的[工程門檻](concepts.md#c53)。五項能力之間不能任意互相替代:容納時丟掉的差異造成的是上限,不是速度慢。\n\n**命題三 [比對](concepts.md#c38)只及於已[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)的[案例](concepts.md#c24)**(結論)\n\n> 任何[節點](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25)作的[比對](concepts.md#c38),只及於[後段表示](concepts.md#c33)已經[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)它的[案例](concepts.md#c24);這個[後段表示](concepts.md#c33),是某個作[壓縮](concepts.md#c31)者把已經[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)它自己的[後段材料](concepts.md#c30)[壓縮](concepts.md#c31)而成的,作[壓縮](concepts.md#c31)者可以不是作[比對](concepts.md#c38)的[節點](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25)。[比對](concepts.md#c38)所依的是[到達材料](concepts.md#c28)經[壓縮](concepts.md#c31)落出的[表示](concepts.md#c34),不是[標的](concepts.md#c25)[自己的那一段](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c17)。研究者講明的範圍若包含尚未[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)的[案例](concepts.md#c24),[在範圍內可交換](concepts.md#c42)不能由[比對](concepts.md#c38)確認。\n\n推導:任何[節點](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25)落出[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)時,取得的只有已經[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)它的;[後段材料](concepts.md#c30)尚未[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)任何作[壓縮](concepts.md#c31)者時,沒有[後段表示](concepts.md#c33)可以[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)作[比對](concepts.md#c38)的[節點](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25)。依三之一的有限接收,[後段材料](concepts.md#c30)不是[標的](concepts.md#c25)[自己的那一段](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c17)的全部。來源:[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)、[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)的定義;[比對](concepts.md#c38)、[後段表示](concepts.md#c33)的定義(五之三);三之一。\n\n說明:所以一次[壓縮](concepts.md#c31)[在範圍內可交換](concepts.md#c42),至多由已[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)的[案例](concepts.md#c24)支持;以後新的[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)可能推翻它。一次[壓縮](concepts.md#c31)[在已登記的案例中可交換](concepts.md#c41),只表示它對得上已經[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)的材料;它是抓到了[標的](concepts.md#c25)的規律,還是只對得上這些材料,從[比對](concepts.md#c38)分不出來。本篇不處理這個問題。範圍若恰好就是已登記的[案例](concepts.md#c24),[在範圍內可交換](concepts.md#c42)所主張的,就是[在已登記的案例中可交換](concepts.md#c41)。本篇稱[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)「正確」,同樣只在給定了任務、比較對象、可觀察條件、[允許誤差](concepts.md#c56)與評估時窗之後(三之五)。\n\n**命題四 對不被[鎖死](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c12)、結果差異落在被[比對](concepts.md#c38)的[表示](concepts.md#c34)上的[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16),單次結果的[可交換](concepts.md#c55)[不被保證](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c02)**(結論)\n\n> 若[標的](concepts.md#c25)是[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16),在[前窗](concepts.md#c26)與[後窗](concepts.md#c27)之間有不被[鎖死](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c12)的[時刻](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c09),而那些[時刻](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c09)可能落出的結果中,有兩個在被[比對](concepts.md#c38)的[後段表示](concepts.md#c33)上相差超過[允許誤差](concepts.md#c56)的兩倍,則任何[推演](concepts.md#c36)在單次結果上[可交換](concepts.md#c55),都[不被保證](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c02)。\n\n推導:依[黑箱律](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c25),[宇宙](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c02)中沒有任何[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)能在那一刻之前唯一推出一個不被[鎖死](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c12)的[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)的下一[時刻](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c09),能推出的只有[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06)。依[允許誤差](concepts.md#c56)的定義(五之三),一個[推演結果](concepts.md#c37)若在[允許誤差](concepts.md#c56)內同時等於兩個[後段表示](concepts.md#c33),兩者的相差就不超過[允許誤差](concepts.md#c56)的兩倍,與條件不合;所以不論[推演](concepts.md#c36)落出哪一個結果,這兩個可能的結果中至少有一個使[比對](concepts.md#c38)結果不相同。來源:[黑箱律](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c25);[允許誤差](concepts.md#c56)、[比對](concepts.md#c38)的定義(五之三);[不被保證](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c02)的定義。\n\n說明:\n1. 研究者另作分布層次的比對時,例如以多個[案例](concepts.md#c24)的頻率比對推演出的傾向,依[印象](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c45)的定義,這類對[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)的統計估計是[印象](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c45)。依[生成函數](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c15)的定義,[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06)由到當時為止的[歷史](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13)決定;依[流變律](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c24),[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)一個[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)的[歷史](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13),每一個[時刻](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c09)都和該次[坍塌](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c08)之前不同。框架中沒有任何東西斷言[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06)的分布會重複出現,所以分布重複出現[不被保證](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c02),分布層次的[可交換](concepts.md#c55)同樣[不被保證](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c02)。\n2. 把具體的生物或社會對象當成不被[鎖死](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c12),依[應用假定](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c50)。\n3. 精確定律與統計規律的差別,在對象的下一[時刻](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c09)是否被[鎖死](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c12),不在研究者是否努力。依[隨機源](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c27)的定義,它不被[鎖死](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c12)時也只能談[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06),所以這個差別不限於[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)。\n\n**命題五 [回合](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c04)是[計算](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c05)的[節點](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25),不必作[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)**(結論)\n\n> 計算尺一類[鎖死](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c12)的[節點](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25),它的[回合](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c04)是[計算](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c05)。研究者把這次[計算](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c05)讀作[壓縮](concepts.md#c31)或[推演](concepts.md#c36)、把結果讀作數字,是讀它的[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)所作的[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18),若用到[構件](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c01),是那個[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)的[構件](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c01)。所以[回合](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c04)是[計算](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c05)的[節點](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25)不必作[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18);[推演](concepts.md#c36)所需的,以及[壓縮](concepts.md#c31)若用到的[構件](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c01),在讀它的[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)那裡。\n\n推導:依[計算](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c05)的定義,[鎖死的回合](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c25)是[計算](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c05)。依五之三,[壓縮](concepts.md#c31)與[推演](concepts.md#c36)是研究者對[回合](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c04)的讀法:把一段[回合](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c04)看作一次[壓縮](concepts.md#c31)或[推演](concepts.md#c36),是劃出界線、把某些[呈現](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c04)看作一個,依[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)的定義是一次[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18),而[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)是[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)的動作。讀出的數字是這次[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)的內容;依二之一,[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)內容所指的對象都不由物理世界直接給出;數字若被用來指某個對象,並組織讀者之後的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28),依[幻覺構件](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c01)的定義就是[構件](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c01)。所以作出這些讀法、用到[構件](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c01)的,是讀它的[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16);[回合](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c04)是[計算](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c05)的[節點](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25),不必作[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)。來源:[計算](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c05)、[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)、[幻覺構件](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c01)的定義;二之一;五之三。\n\n說明:\n1. 研究者讀作[比對](concepts.md#c38)的[回合](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c04),同樣可以是[計算](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c05);把這次[計算](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c05)讀作[比對](concepts.md#c38)、講明一個範圍並主張[可交換](concepts.md#c55),是研究者的一次[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)。\n2. 本條與「文化不以分別為條件」(七之六)平行;對照組見九之七。\n\n**命題六 [自洽](concepts.md#c45)與[可交換](concepts.md#c55)互不推出**(結論)\n\n**定義**:[推演規則](concepts.md#c44):對[推演](concepts.md#c36)的描述,可以[明列](concepts.md#c09)為[模板](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c14)。[自洽](concepts.md#c45):[推演規則](concepts.md#c44)中,沒有兩條在同一個[表示](concepts.md#c34)上給出超出[允許誤差](concepts.md#c56)而不同的結果。\n\n> [推演規則](concepts.md#c44)[自洽](concepts.md#c45),推不出[可交換](concepts.md#c55);[可交換](concepts.md#c55),也推不出[推演規則](concepts.md#c44)[自洽](concepts.md#c45)。\n\n推導:[自洽](concepts.md#c45)只涉及[推演規則](concepts.md#c44)內部各條之間的關係;[可交換](concepts.md#c55)涉及[壓縮](concepts.md#c31)與之後的[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)。兩個定義互不引用對方。依[比對](concepts.md#c38)的定義,[比對](concepts.md#c38)看的是[推演](concepts.md#c36)實際落出的[推演結果](concepts.md#c37)與[後段表示](concepts.md#c33);[推演規則](concepts.md#c44)中另一條在同一個[表示](concepts.md#c34)上給出不同的結果,[推演](concepts.md#c36)若沒有照那一條進行,那個結果就不進入[比對](concepts.md#c38),所以不論是[在一個案例上可交換](concepts.md#c40)、[在已登記的案例中可交換](concepts.md#c41),還是[在範圍內可交換](concepts.md#c42),都不排除[推演規則](concepts.md#c44)不[自洽](concepts.md#c45)。只有一條規則的[推演規則](concepts.md#c44),依[自洽](concepts.md#c45)的定義必然[自洽](concepts.md#c45);依命題一,照這條規則進行的[推演](concepts.md#c36)被[鎖死](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c12)時,在[前段材料](concepts.md#c29)得到同一個[前段表示](concepts.md#c32)、約束相同、[後段表示](concepts.md#c33)相差超過[允許誤差](concepts.md#c56)兩倍的兩個[案例](concepts.md#c24)上不能都[可交換](concepts.md#c55),而[自洽](concepts.md#c45)的定義不排除這樣的[案例](concepts.md#c24)。來源:[自洽](concepts.md#c45)、[推演規則](concepts.md#c44)的定義;五之三;五之四命題一。\n\n校準:以顏色作質量的力學可以完全[自洽](concepts.md#c45),卻不[可交換](concepts.md#c55);許多實用的經驗法則[在已登記的案例中可交換](concepts.md#c41),彼此卻不一致。\n\n### 五之五 界線是分別的,到達與依賴不由分別改寫;適用範圍\n\n**結論**:依二之一,物理世界不給界線,但給[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)的不對稱。依[壓縮](concepts.md#c31)的定義,[壓縮](concepts.md#c31)切在哪裡,是一次[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)。依上游定義,[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)是[寫入](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c29)落到[呈現](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c04)上,[自己的那一段](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c17)由依賴決定;而[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)的內容改變的是看法,不改寫[被看的東西](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c27)。依[歷史](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13)的定義,[歷史](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13)只往後追加,所以[壓縮](concepts.md#c31)切在哪裡,不改寫已有的[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)與依賴。所以[在範圍內可交換](concepts.md#c42),和「界線不由物理世界給出」不衝突:同一段[宇宙](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c02)可以有許多[切法](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c23);某一種[切法](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c23)下的[壓縮](concepts.md#c31)是否[可交換](concepts.md#c55),由[比對](concepts.md#c38)判定,與界線不由物理世界給出不衝突。這也和二之一「稱它為替代,不主張它所替代的對象存在」不衝突:那裡談的是[構件](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c01)的對象,這裡談的是[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)與依賴。\n\n[可交換](concepts.md#c55)只在講明的範圍內成立。範圍之外的[案例](concepts.md#c24),約束可以不同,本篇不假定它與範圍內相同(一之一);所以在一個範圍內[可交換](concepts.md#c55),推不出在另一個範圍內[可交換](concepts.md#c55)。依命題三,範圍本身是主張。\n\n校準:牛頓力學在物體速度接近光速時失準,因為那裡起作用的關係,在以質量、位置、速度[壓縮](concepts.md#c31)時被丟掉了。\n\n### 五之六 應用:研究者以「我」作的壓縮\n\n**結論**:研究者講明以一個[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)為[標的](concepts.md#c25)的[案例](concepts.md#c24),並把自己以「我」等[構件](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c01)描述這個[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)的那段[回合](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c04),讀作把[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)他的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)轉成以這些[構件](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c01)寫出的[表示](concepts.md#c34)時,依[壓縮](concepts.md#c31)的定義,這是一次[壓縮](concepts.md#c31);它是否[可交換](concepts.md#c55)是另一件事,要另依五之三的判準檢驗。例如,以「它在維持自己」[推演](concepts.md#c36)它修補邊界、調節內外交換的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28),再與之後的[記錄](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c06)[比對](concepts.md#c38)。「邊界內」若與[自己的那一段](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c17)不重合,這個[壓縮](concepts.md#c31)在某些[案例](concepts.md#c24)上可能對不上;是否不[可交換](concepts.md#c55),仍只看[比對](concepts.md#c38):要等不重合的部分在之後的[記錄](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c06)中造成不同,才判得出來。\n\n校準:病毒借用細胞的機器複製;自體免疫。\n\n---\n\n## 六、第二問:幻覺構件怎樣生成\n\n### 六之一 兩步:從依賴到分別,從分別到構件\n\n**結論六之一**:從依賴到[構件](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c01)有兩步:從依賴到[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18),以及從[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)到[構件](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c01)。沒有[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18),就沒有作為它[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)內容的[構件](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c01);有[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18),不推出有[構件](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c01)。\n\n推導:依[幻覺構件](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c01)的定義,作為[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)內容的[構件](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c01),有它所指的對象,這個對象不由物理世界給出。所以沒有[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18),就沒有作為它[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)內容的[構件](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c01)。[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)的內容只是參與之後的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)、沒有被用來指某個對象時,不符合這個定義;依[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)的定義,[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)的[歷史](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13)都參與它的[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06),這種參與本身沒有對象。所以有[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18),不推出有[構件](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c01)。來源:[幻覺構件](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c01)、[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)、[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)的定義。\n\n說明:\n1. 本條與二之一「一次分別可以用到構件,也可以不用」一致:那裡說的是作出[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)的當下,有沒有以既有[構件](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c01)為材料。\n2. 次數與名字都不是條件。[構件](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c01)常見的兩種表現:指向不在場的東西(二之一),以及出現在說出口、寫下來的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)中([幻覺構件](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c01)的定義所列的第二種出現方式)。\n3. 只把不同的東西當成同一類,是[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)中的[歸併](concepts.md#c23)(五之一),不是[構件](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c01)。麵包師傅每天把不同的麵團判為「可以了」,是[歸併](concepts.md#c23)加上[學習](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c04)(四之二)。\n4. 本篇所說的抽象,指[構件](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c01)有所指的對象,能脫離眼前;不指把不同的東西歸成一類。\n5. 一個內容有沒有所指的對象,是研究者的歸屬:這個內容是對象某次[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)的內容,判定它有沒有所指的對象,就要先把對象的某筆[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)劃為對象的這次[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18);[記錄](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c06)中只有[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)(二之二),這樣的劃分依[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)作出,是[看法歸屬](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c02)(一之二),可能歸錯。上游保證的只有參與[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06);依[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)的定義,這種參與不必能被找到。\n6. [單純的分別](concepts.md#c19)照樣留下[寫入](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c29)、參與之後的[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06)(四之三說明 1)。\n\n校準:\n- 沿著雷區走,一步一步都不踏過去:界線參與行動,沒有所指的對象,是[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)。在地圖上畫出一塊、在家裡想「雷區在河東,過河要繞路」、對人說「那邊有雷」:「雷區」指著一個對象,是[構件](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c01)。\n- 每天認出自己的狗:[歸併](concepts.md#c23)加上[歷史](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13)的參與,是[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)。叫牠「小黑」、問「小黑去哪了」:指著一個對象,是[構件](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c01)。\n- 「你」「我」「它」:所指的是位置,對象每次不同;說出口就是[構件](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c01)。「我昨天去爬山」,指著不在場的昨天的自己;把不同[時刻](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c09)的自己當成同一個,對應六之三[自我梯子](concepts.md#c46)上的[跨時刻歸併](concepts.md#c49)。\n- 麵包師傅與爬山:見四之二。\n\n### 六之二 生成的途徑\n\n**結論**:若一個[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)的[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)內容成為[幻覺構件](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c01),它可以經由以下途徑:一次[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)劃出界線,其中的[歸併](concepts.md#c23)把某些[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)看作一個;這次[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)留下[寫入](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c29),[寫入](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c29)經由[小迴路](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c02)[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)作出它的[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16);這次[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)的內容被用來指某個對象,例如指向不在場的它,或出現在說出口、寫下來的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)中;之後的[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)以它為材料,可以再次[歸併](concepts.md#c23)。[類的幻覺構件](concepts.md#c10),是把[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)的結果再[歸併](concepts.md#c23)所得的[構件](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c01),例如把許多個「我」歸成的「我們」。\n\n推導:[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)的材料只有之前已經[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)的[歷史](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13),包括自己過去的[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)([分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)的定義;二之三的前提);這一步依五之一與六之一;每一輪都是既有的[回合](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c04),不另增生成律(一之三)。\n\n說明:\n1. 材料可以是外來的。別人[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)中的名稱、分類若[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)這個[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16),可以是它的材料;但用這些材料作出的[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18),是它自己的[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)([分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)的定義;四之三第 3 點)。名稱的[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)不等於[構件](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c01)的轉移。\n2. 這裡說的是「若生成,經由什麼」,不主張必然經過所有步驟,也不主張次序固定。\n\n### 六之三 必要條件\n\n1. **一般的[幻覺構件](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c01)**(結論,依六之一):沒有[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18),就沒有作為它[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)內容的[幻覺構件](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c01);一次[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)的內容只參與之後的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)、沒有被用來指某個對象時,這個內容不是[幻覺構件](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c01)。\n2. **[類的幻覺構件](concepts.md#c10)**(結論,依[類的幻覺構件](concepts.md#c10)的定義,二之二):沒有把[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)的結果再[歸併](concepts.md#c23),就沒有[類的幻覺構件](concepts.md#c10)。\n3. **[自我配置假定](concepts.md#c04)的必要條件**([經驗前提](concepts.md#c01)):\n - 沒有留下自己[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)的某種副本(屬[記憶能力](concepts.md#c15)),或沒有把副本與隨後的[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)對照(屬[運算能力](concepts.md#c14)),就沒有[自他區辨](concepts.md#c48)(第十節,[經驗前提](concepts.md#c01)一);\n - 沒有跨越不同[時刻](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c09)的保留(屬[記憶能力](concepts.md#c15)),或沒有把不同[時刻](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c09)自己造成的[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)[壓縮](concepts.md#c31)為同一類(屬[壓縮能力](concepts.md#c16)),就沒有[跨時刻歸併](concepts.md#c49)(第十節,[經驗前提](concepts.md#c01)二)。\n\n說明:上游只保證[歷史](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13)參與[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06),不保證載體上留有痕跡(三之四)。第 3 點依[經驗禁止](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c51)的形式寫出,只寫缺少時[不會發生](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c01),不寫具備時會發生;它們由案例校準得來,新的案例可以修改它們。\n\n**[自我梯子](concepts.md#c46)**:以下各階只寫必要條件。在一之五的問題二中,它們只用來否定[自我配置假定](concepts.md#c04);全部具備,也只表示這項假定沒有被否定。各階在內容層的稱呼([區辨](concepts.md#c22)、[歸併](concepts.md#c23)、同一),是研究者的歸屬。\n\n```text\n渦(自己的那一段,由依賴決定)\n└─ 自己維持的篩選邊界……到達的物理不對稱,不需要分別(問題一的地基)\n └─ 分別(區辨+歸併)\n └─ 自他區辨……………瞬間的我的必要條件\n └─ 跨時刻歸併、替代性……延續的我的必要條件\n └─ 二階分別、看法歸屬(七之七)……社會人的必要條件(依配置假定)\n └─ 類的幻覺構件……我們、你們\n```\n\n\n- **[自己維持的篩選邊界](concepts.md#c47)**:由自己的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)維持、篩選什麼能[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)自己的結構。本篇不限定載體是哪一種,所以寫成一般形式;細胞膜是生物中的實例。它塑造的是[自己的那一段](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c17),而[自己的那一段](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c17)由依賴決定,不由[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)決定([自己的那一段](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c17)的定義)。所以有細胞膜這樣的邊界,推不出細胞作了自我定義。\n- **[自他區辨](concepts.md#c48)**:把回到自己身上的[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10),[區辨](concepts.md#c22)為自己造成的與不是自己造成的。依二之三的前提,每一次[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)與[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)都回到作出它的[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16);但回到它身上的[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10),不自帶「這是自己造成的」標記。\n- **[跨時刻歸併](concepts.md#c49)**:把不同[時刻](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c09)自己造成的[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)歸為同一類。在內容層,研究者把它歸屬為上游的[同一](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c21)。\n- **[替代性](concepts.md#c50)**:在自己不作為[刺激](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c30)在場時,這個內容仍被使用。\n\n校準:[自他區辨](concepts.md#c48):馮霍爾斯特與米特爾施泰特的再傳入原理(1950);蟋蟀鳴叫時壓低聽覺對自己叫聲的反應(〔Poulet〕與〔Hedwig〕,2006);人搔不了自己的癢(〔Blakemore〕等,1998)。蟋蟀具備這項機制,說明它只是必要條件。延續的[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19):鏡像自我辨認(〔Gallup〕,1970),是否能區分仍有爭議。\n\n### 六之四 不保證\n\n**結論**:六之三第 1、2 點的必要條件都具備,[幻覺構件](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c01)的生成仍[不被保證](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c02)。\n\n推導:本篇不寫充分條件(一之二):六之三第 1、2 點列的是必要條件,沒有任何一條規則說它們具備時[構件](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c01)就會生成;依[不被保證](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c02)的定義,框架不斷言它必然發生。此外,依[應用假定](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c50)與[黑箱律](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c25),不被[鎖死](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c12)的[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)的下一[時刻](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c09)不能事先唯一推出;本篇沒有另外的規則,把其中是否作出某次[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)定死。來源:一之二的寫法;[不被保證](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c02)的定義;[應用假定](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c50);[黑箱律](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c25)。\n\n說明:[寫入](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c29)的內容由到當時為止的[歷史](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13)決定([分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)的定義)。這和本條不衝突:「到當時為止的歷史」包括之前各次[坍塌](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c08)的結果;其中不被[鎖死](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c12)的[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)的結果,依[黑箱律](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c25),在更早的時點不能事先唯一推出。\n\n### 六之五 不可確認\n\n**結論**:[幻覺構件](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c01)在一個[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)內生成,從外部確認[不被保證](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c02);對此,本篇從外部給出的判斷只有否定。\n\n推導:[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)不在本篇的[記錄](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c06)中(二之二);當事[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)說出某個[構件](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c01)的名稱,是一筆物理[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28),推不出它內部有同名的[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)(二之一);研究者把這筆[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)劃為對象的[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18),是[看法歸屬](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c02),依[看法歸屬](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c02)的定義可能歸錯。所以從外部確認對象作出了某次[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18),[不被保證](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c02)(一之二)。\n\n從外部給出的否定判斷有兩種:一、找到機制,證明它沒有任何[回合](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c04)是[決定](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c06),依九之三它就不是[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16),而[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)是[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)的動作([分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)的定義),所以它沒有[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18),也就沒有作為它[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)內容的[構件](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c01)(六之一);二、缺少六之三第 3 點所列、[經驗前提](concepts.md#c01)一或二中的某項條件,[自我配置假定](concepts.md#c04)對它不成立(一之五);這一種否定的是[自我配置假定](concepts.md#c04),不是[構件](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c01)的生成。\n\n說明:六之四與本條是兩件事。六之四是「會不會生成」,本條是「生成了能不能看到」。\n\n### 六之六 類的幻覺構件\n\n**結論**:作為[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)內容的[構件](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c01),都出自含有[歸併](concepts.md#c23)的[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)(五之一、六之一);例如,本篇把「我」讀作不同[時刻](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c09)自己造成的[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)的反覆[歸併](concepts.md#c23),把「我們」「丈夫」讀作[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)結果的再[歸併](concepts.md#c23),也就是[類的幻覺構件](concepts.md#c10)。研究者的描述,是把大量[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)反覆歸成少數[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)。在工程層,對應的是反覆[壓縮](concepts.md#c31)。\n\n**結論**:再處理與遞回:[表示](concepts.md#c34)甲若確實被保留,或形成可再次[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28),就可能和新的[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)或其他[表示](concepts.md#c34)乙一起參與處理,形成[表示](concepts.md#c34)丙;也可能被遺失、變形或不被採用。整段過程仍是既有的[回合](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c04),不另增「抽象創造」生成律。[壓縮](concepts.md#c31)是不是由既有[表示](concepts.md#c34)再處理形成新[表示](concepts.md#c34)的途徑,推不出;本篇不把[壓縮](concepts.md#c31)、[表示](concepts.md#c34)與[構件](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c01)視為同義,也不主張[表示](concepts.md#c34)必然增多、必然正確,或複雜度必然上升。\n\n**結論**:[表示](concepts.md#c34)與[類的幻覺構件](concepts.md#c10):一個[表示](concepts.md#c34)的內容被用來組織[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28),而所指的對象不由物理世界給出時,研究者把它歸屬為某個[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)作為[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)內容的[幻覺構件](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c01),或在它是[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)結果的再[歸併](concepts.md#c23)時歸屬為這個[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)的[類的幻覺構件](concepts.md#c10),都是研究者的一次[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18),依[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)作出,可能歸錯(五之一)。\n\n## 七、第三問:運用的條件\n\n### 七之一 運用的兩條途徑\n\n**結論**:[幻覺構件](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c01)的運用有兩條途徑:在[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)內部,[構件](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c01)的內容經由[小迴路](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c02)再次[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10),參與它後續的[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)與[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28);在[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)之間,[構件](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c01)由物理[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)承載,[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)其他[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16),途中可以經過其他[節點](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25)。\n\n推導:依二之一,[幻覺構件](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c01)有兩種出現方式:在研究者的描述中,以及在實際[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)中。在[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)內部,[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)的[寫入](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c29)[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)作出它的[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)(二之三的前提)。在[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)之間,依四之三第 3 點,[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)別人的是[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28),不是[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)這個動作。\n\n說明:\n1. 在[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)之間,「運用」不是[構件](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c01)的轉移。名稱[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)接收者,可以是接收者的材料;接收者若以它作出[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18),那是接收者自己的[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)(六之二說明 1)。\n2. 承載[構件](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c01)的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)可以進入[信號容器](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c26),包括說出口的話(二之二),再從容器[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)其他[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16),包括說話者不在場之後。\n3. 承載內容的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)也可以來自不是[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)的[節點](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25),例如[目前的人工智慧](concepts.md#c11)。它沒有作為[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)內容的[構件](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c01);在講明的維度上,它的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)時,作用可以與[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)運用[構件](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c01)的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)相同(九之一說明 2)。\n4. 麵包師傅自己做時沒有用術語說出來,要教人時才把步驟寫成術語;一個人爬山沒有說「那棵樹」,有同伴才說(四之二校準)。沒有說出來的時候,從外部推不出這個[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)內部有沒有這個[構件](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c01),能判定的只有它有沒有出現在[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)中(四之三說明 5)。\n\n### 七之二 必要條件\n\n1. **在[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)之間運用**(結論,依四之三第 3 點與[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)的定義):沒有任何一筆承載[構件](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c01)的物理[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)接收者,[構件](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c01)在[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)之間就沒有[在渦之間傳遞](concepts.md#c21)這項[功能](concepts.md#c18)。\n2. **在[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)內部,於[被看的東西](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c27)不在場時運用**([經驗前提](concepts.md#c01)):沒有跨[時刻](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c09)的保留(屬[記憶能力](concepts.md#c15)),[構件](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c01)的內容就不能在[刺激](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c30)不在場時參與[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)的組織(第十節,[經驗前提](concepts.md#c01)三)。\n\n說明:第 1 點由定義推出。第 2 點依[經驗禁止](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c51)的形式,只寫缺少時[不會發生](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c01)。\n\n### 七之三 模板與施行\n\n**結論**:取得同一個[模板](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c14),推不出取得者把[到達材料](concepts.md#c28)轉成[表示](concepts.md#c34)的方式相同。研究者能登記的「各方對模板的施行一致」,只在各方的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)上;這些[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)若在講明的維度與時窗內彼此[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)、反覆相容接續,依[共振](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c09)的定義是[共振](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c09)。\n\n推導:\n1. [模板](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c14)是[明列](concepts.md#c09)在[信號容器](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c26)中的內容。容器被[鎖死](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c12),內容不會自己改變([模板](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c14)、[信號容器](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c26)的定義)。\n2. 把新的[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)轉成[模板](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c14)所用的[表示](concepts.md#c34),是取得者自己的[回合](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c04)。取得者若是[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16),[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)它的全部[歷史](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13)都參與這個[回合](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c04)([渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)的定義),[模板](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c14)只是其中一筆;兩個[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)取得同一個[模板](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c14),其餘的[歷史](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13)可以不同。此外,依[應用假定](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c50),假定取得者在這個[回合](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c04)不被[鎖死](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c12);依[黑箱律](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c25),它的下一[時刻](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c09)不能事先唯一推出。所以由取得同一個[模板](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c14),推不出兩者的[壓縮](concepts.md#c31)相同。\n3. [模板](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c14)也可以[明列](concepts.md#c09)一段對[壓縮](concepts.md#c31)方式的描述。但套用這段描述,又是取得者自己的[回合](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c04),第 2 點同樣適用。\n4. 依二之二的[記錄](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c06)範圍,[記錄](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c06)中只有各[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28),不能直接確認它們把[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)轉成[表示](concepts.md#c34)的方式。它們套用[模板](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c14)的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)若在講明的維度與時窗內彼此[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10),並反覆相容接續,依[共振](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c09)的定義,就是[共振](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c09)。\n\n來源:[模板](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c14)、[信號容器](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c26)、[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)、[共振](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c09)的定義;[應用假定](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c50);[黑箱律](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c25);二之二[記錄](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c06)範圍。\n\n說明:\n1. 取得一個[模板](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c14),也推不出取得它的適用範圍,也就是它在哪一組[案例](concepts.md#c24)上[可交換](concepts.md#c55):範圍若沒有[明列](concepts.md#c09),就不在容器裡;[明列](concepts.md#c09)了,依[在範圍內可交換](concepts.md#c42)的定義也只是一項主張。校準:牛頓定律常被當成[模板](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c14)教授,而速度遠小於光速這個適用條件往往沒有寫出來。\n2. 「共振維持施行的一致」若是說[共振](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c09)使各方的[壓縮](concepts.md#c31)趨於一致,那是一項因果主張,推不出。本條只說:研究者能登記的一致,只在[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)上;這些[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)在講明的維度與時窗內彼此[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)、反覆相容接續時,是[共振](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c09)。\n3. 取得者若是每一步都被[鎖死](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c12)的[節點](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25),第 2 點不適用:兩個[構造](concepts.md#c07)相同的[鎖死](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c12)[節點](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25)取得同一個[模板](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c14),它們的[計算](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c05)由約束定死,可以相同;把這兩次[計算](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c05)讀作同一個[壓縮](concepts.md#c31),是讀它們的[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)的[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)(命題五)。所以[模板](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c14)傳遞時,[構造](concepts.md#c07)相同的[鎖死](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c12)[節點](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25)的[計算](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c05)可以一致;[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)的施行一致[不被保證](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c02)。\n\n校準:兩個人拿同一份食譜,「鹽少許」「炒到金黃」各自怎麼套用,取決於各人的整段[歷史](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13);兩台[構造](concepts.md#c07)相同的計算機跑同一個程式,輸入相同,[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)就相同。麵包師傅把步驟寫成術語交給徒弟,徒弟照著做,仍要反覆練習、反覆對照師傅與結果,才做得出同樣的麵包:術語傳遞了[推演](concepts.md#c36),施行要在練習中接上。\n\n### 七之四 不保證\n\n**結論**:七之二的必要條件都具備,運用仍[不被保證](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c02)。\n\n推導:同六之四。\n\n### 七之五 不可確認\n\n**結論**:[構件](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c01)是否在一個[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)內部被用來組織[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28),從外部確認[不被保證](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c02);在[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)之間,[記錄](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c06)中有的只是承載它的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)。\n\n推導:同六之五;二之一。\n\n### 七之六 對照:不經構件的協調,與經由模板的運用\n\n[文化](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c13)是[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)之間不經[構件](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c01)也能相容接續的情形;承載[構件](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c01)的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)[明列](concepts.md#c09)進[信號容器](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c26)時,可以成為[模板](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c14);[模板](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c14)是[構件](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c01)在[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)之間運用的一種可能方式。\n\n1. **[文化](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c13)不以[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)為條件**(結論):依[共振](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c09)的定義,[共振](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c09)以[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)為條件;依[文化](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c13)的定義,[文化](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c13)是研究者對網路中出現的[共振](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c09)的命名;依[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)的定義,一個[呈現](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c04)是否為[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)與任何[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)無關。所以[文化](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c13)不以參與者作[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)為條件,更不以[構件](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c01)、[模板](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c14)或[二階分別](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c01)為條件。有[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)不推出有[文化](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c13)。\n2. **[明列](concepts.md#c09)不限書面**(結論):依二之二,[模板](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c14)的[明列](concepts.md#c09)可以是寫下,也可以是說出口、廣播、播映。所以語言同時落在兩邊:被明說或記下的部分,例如一句話裡的詞、口頭講明的規則,可以是[模板](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c14),是不是[模板](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c14),依[模板](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c14)的定義與研究者指定的判準判定;沒有人明說、靠反覆說話而相容接續的用法,若在研究者指定的[切法](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c23)、維度與時窗下是網路中的[共振](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c09),研究者把它命名為[文化](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c13);語感、搭配、語調是這類用法的例子。依[模板](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c14)的定義,[模板](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c14)不是[文化](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c13)的一層。\n3. **[記錄](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c06)推不出內部**(結論):[記錄](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c06)中有[模板](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c14),推不出[明列](concepts.md#c09)它的[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)內部有[構件](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c01):依二之二的[記錄](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c06)範圍,[記錄](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c06)中沒有[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18);依二之一,一筆[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)推不出說話者內部有同名的[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)。\n\n校準:麵包師傅與學徒在同一個廚房反覆做、反覆接上,若在指定的[切法](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c23)、維度與時窗下是[共振](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c09),是[文化](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c13)那一側;他寫下來的步驟與術語,可以是[模板](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c14)那一側。\n\n### 七之七 一階與二階\n\n**一階不是齒輪**(結論):依[一階分別](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c24)的定義,[一階分別](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c24)照著看法與[被看的東西](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c27)的區分行動,卻不作出這個區分。依[學習](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c04)的定義,[學習](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c04)不以[二階分別](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c01)為條件;依[共振](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c09)與[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)的定義及七之六第 1 點,[共振](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c09)與[文化](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c13)不以[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)為條件。所以[學習](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c04)與[共振](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c09)都不以[二階分別](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c01)為條件;定義不排除只具有[一階分別](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c24)的[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)[學習](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c04),並在反覆的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)、[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)與[結果回饋](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c05)中與其他[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)形成[共振](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c09)。\n\n**[二階分別](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c01)的前件**(結論):依[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)的定義,[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)的材料只有它之前、已經[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)它的[歷史](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13),它自己不在其中。[二階分別](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c01)以自己的某一次[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)為對象,所以那一次是已經作出、已經[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)它的[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18);這一點依二之三的前提:[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)的一次[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)在下一[時刻](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c09)之前[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)這個[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)自己。本篇不另加「記得那次分別的內容」這項條件:依[歷史](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13)的定義,已作出的[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)留下的[寫入](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c29)不被抹去,仍參與[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06);[二階分別](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c01)的定義只要求以它為對象,沒有要求叫得出它當初的內容。\n\n校準:一個人不記得自己從什麼時候、為什麼開始怕狗,仍然可以說「我怕狗只是一種看法」。\n\n**[社會人](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c03)**(依[社會人](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c03)的定義):[社會人](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c03)是具有[二階能力](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c02)的生物人;稱某生物人為[社會人](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c03),依[配置假定](../paper_ae79e938_76e1_4bf9_b2ab_995c03e16c9e/concepts.md#c01)作出。校準:一般成人廣泛使用「我們」「你們」等[構件](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c01);這類經驗理由只是採用這項配置的理由,不是二階內部[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)的證明。\n\n**與運用的關係**:除了[我們](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c04)、[你們](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c05)依定義由[社會人](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c03)運用,要求[二階分別](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c01)與[看法歸屬](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c02)的能力,框架不斷言[二階分別](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c01)或[看法歸屬](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c02)是[構件](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c01)運用的必要條件或充分條件,也不斷言反過來;[看法歸屬](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c02)在工程上需要什麼,推不出。\n\n---\n\n## 八、第四問:運用之後\n\n### 八之一 在渦內部的後果\n\n**結論**:以一個[構件](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c01)組織[推演](concepts.md#c36)時,[推演](concepts.md#c36)的結果若[在已登記的案例中可交換](concepts.md#c41),就在每一個已登記的[案例](concepts.md#c24)上,[推演結果](concepts.md#c37)與[後段表示](concepts.md#c33)在[允許誤差](concepts.md#c56)內相同;若不[可交換](concepts.md#c55),就有不相符的[案例](concepts.md#c24)。不相符的材料[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)這個[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)時,參與它之後的[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06);這個[構件](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c01)是否因此不再被運用,[不被保證](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c02)。\n\n推導:五之三的判準;[結果回饋](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c05)的定義(後果經由之後的[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)帶回);[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)的定義;[不被保證](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c02)的定義;[應用假定](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c50);[黑箱律](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c25)。\n\n說明:「被打斷」「被淘汰」只是比喻,沒有目的,也不保證發生。\n\n### 八之二 繼續被運用,不以可交換為條件\n\n**結論**:一個[構件](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c01)不[可交換](concepts.md#c55),推不出它不再被運用;用到這個[構件](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c01)的[推演規則](concepts.md#c44)[自洽](concepts.md#c45)而不[可交換](concepts.md#c55)時,這個[構件](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c01)也可以繼續被運用。\n\n推導:七之二列出的運用條件中,沒有[可交換](concepts.md#c55)。不相符的[後段材料](concepts.md#c30)照樣[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)、照樣參與[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06)([渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)的定義);但依八之一,[構件](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c01)是否因此不再被運用,[不被保證](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c02)。此外,依命題三,[比對](concepts.md#c38)只及於已[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)的[案例](concepts.md#c24):一個[構件](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c01)的[推演](concepts.md#c36)若從未與之後的[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)作[比對](concepts.md#c38),不[可交換](concepts.md#c55)就不以[比對](concepts.md#c38)的形式出現在這個[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)的[歷史](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13)中。依命題六,[自洽](concepts.md#c45)不推出[可交換](concepts.md#c55),[可交換](concepts.md#c55)也不推出[自洽](concepts.md#c45)。來源:七之二;八之一;命題三、命題六;[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)、[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)的定義。\n\n### 八之三 可交換與繼續被運用\n\n**結論**:框架不斷言[可交換](concepts.md#c55)與一個[構件](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c01)是否繼續被運用之間,有八之二以外的關係;例如在[結果回饋](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c05)頻繁[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)的領域,不[可交換](concepts.md#c55)的[構件](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c01)是否較少繼續被運用,推不出。\n\n### 八之四 在渦之間的後果\n\n**結論**:[構件](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c01)經由[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)其他[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16),參與它們之後的[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06),可能成為它們再作[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)的材料。研究者依已登記的這些[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)與之後的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28),可能在[記錄](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c06)中劃出[內外差異](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c09);依其中以分類為內容的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28),可能劃出[宣稱界線](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c10);比較兩個[檢查窗口](../paper_d244789a_9261_4a0d_a98a_feb8db56b511/concepts.md#c03),可能把兩者的不同記為[界線的移動](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c11)。是否出現、走向哪一種,推不出。\n\n推導:依七之一,[構件](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c01)在[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)之間由[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)承載;依[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)與[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)的定義,[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)參與它的[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06);依[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)的定義,[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)的材料只有已經[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)它的[歷史](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13),所以這些[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)可能成為接收者再作[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)的材料。依[內外差異](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c09)、[宣稱界線](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c10)與[界線的移動](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c11)的定義,三者都是研究者依[記錄](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c06)中的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)所作的[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18),所以能不能劃出,取決於[記錄](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c06)中登記了哪些[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28),以及研究者講明的[切法](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c23)。依[應用假定](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c50),假定接收者在這些[時刻](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c09)不被[鎖死](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c12);依[黑箱律](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c25),它之後落出什麼[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28),不能事先唯一推出,所以走向推不出。\n\n說明:科學可以描述成這樣一個網路:它產出[在已登記案例中可交換](concepts.md#c41)的[模板](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c14),並靠[結果回饋](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c05)淘汰不[可交換](concepts.md#c55)的;範圍與施行則在使用者的[共振](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c09)中維持(七之三)。這是一種描述法,不是本篇推出的命題。\n\n### 八之五 不保證\n\n**結論**:運用之後落到哪一種後果,[不被保證](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c02)。\n\n推導:同六之四。\n\n### 八之六 網路層\n\n[構件](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c01)經由[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)在許多[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)之間運用之後,網路可維持的複雜度如何改變,不由[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)的能力單獨推出:人口、分工、資源、[信號容器](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c26)與[模板](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c14)的維護、[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)密度都參與。本篇不處理。\n\n---\n\n## 九、對照組:目前的人工智慧\n\n本節是全篇的對照組:[目前的人工智慧](concepts.md#c11)具備[工程能力](concepts.md#c12),它的[回合](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c04)是[計算](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c05),研究者能把這些[計算](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c05)讀作[壓縮](concepts.md#c31),並[比對](concepts.md#c38)它們是否[可交換](concepts.md#c55),在邏輯狀態[切法](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c23)下它卻不是[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)。它不屬四問中的任何一問,而用來檢驗各問的答案。\n\n### 九之一 模擬\n\n**定義**:\n\n> **[模擬](concepts.md#c51)**:在講明的[切法](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c23)與維度下,一個不是[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)的[節點](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25),它的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)依研究者講明的判準,與某個[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)或某類[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)不能區分。\n>\n> **[功能上等同](concepts.md#c52)**:在講明的維度上,這個[節點](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25)的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)其他[節點](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25)之後,所起的作用與[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)相同。這些作用包括:參與接收者的[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06)、供應或撤除接收者某條[路徑](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c07)的[前件](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c08)、被讀作承載一個內容、以被研究者讀作[可交換](concepts.md#c55)[推演](concepts.md#c36)的[計算](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c05)為[回合](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c04)。\n\n**結論**:[目前的人工智慧](concepts.md#c11)不是[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16);在研究者講明的若干維度上,若講明的作用只取決於[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)在這些維度上的內容,這些維度上相同的兩筆[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)同一個[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)時作用相同,在這個意義上它可以[功能上等同](concepts.md#c52)於[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)。\n\n**[經驗前提](concepts.md#c01)**:在研究者講明的若干維度上,[目前的人工智慧](concepts.md#c11)的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)與人的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)不能區分(第十節,[經驗前提](concepts.md#c01)四);本篇把人記為[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)(第十節),所以在這些維度上,它是[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)的[模擬](concepts.md#c51)。\n\n推導:\n1. **不是[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)**:依九之三,在邏輯狀態[切法](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c23)下,它沒有任何[回合](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c04)是[決定](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c06)。\n2. **可以[功能上等同](concepts.md#c52)**:依[經驗前提](concepts.md#c01)四,在研究者講明的若干維度上,它的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)與人的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)不能區分;依[應用假定](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c50)與本篇的設定(第十節),人被記為[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)。依[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)與[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)的定義,[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)都參與[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06),與來源是哪一類[節點](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25)無關。所以若研究者講明的作用只取決於[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)在這些維度上的內容,在這些維度上相同的兩筆[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)同一個[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)時,在這些作用上相同,不因來源是哪一類[節點](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25)而不同。依命題五,[回合](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c04)是[計算](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c05)的[節點](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25)不必作[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18);把[計算](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c05)讀作[推演](concepts.md#c36)、並判定它是否[可交換](concepts.md#c55)的,是讀它的[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)。所以在這些維度上,[模擬](concepts.md#c51)與[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)可以[功能上等同](concepts.md#c52)。\n3. **判定不依[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)**:[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)[記錄](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c06)不含[回合](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c04)的種類。所以判定它不是[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16),依的是設計(九之二),不是[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)。對人也是如此:人被記為[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16),依的是[應用假定](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c50)與本篇的設定(第十節),不是[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)。\n\n說明:\n1. [功能上等同](concepts.md#c52)只在講明的維度上成立,不保證在一切維度上成立。至少有兩個維度,兩者不保證相同:它被[鎖死的回合](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c25),在約束只由[構造](concepts.md#c07)與狀態決定時,可以經由拷貝完整傳遞,先前[歷史](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13)不同的[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)之間推不出能這樣傳遞(九之六);[構造](concepts.md#c07)相同、被[鎖死](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c12)的拷貝取得同一個[模板](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c14)時,[計算](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c05)可以一致,[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)的施行相同[不被保證](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c02)(七之三)。\n2. **[目前的人工智慧](concepts.md#c11)與[構件](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c01)**:依[幻覺構件](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c01)的定義,[構件](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c01)是[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)的內容,或描述與[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)中所用的[構件](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c01);[目前的人工智慧](concepts.md#c11)沒有[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18),所以沒有作為自己[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)內容的[構件](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c01)。它的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28),例如名稱、「我們」、地圖上的一塊,可以被讀它的[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)讀作承載某個內容;這些[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16),可以成為[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)作[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)、形成[構件](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c01)的材料。在[構件](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c01)的運用上,在講明的維度上,[目前的人工智慧](concepts.md#c11)可以是[功能上等同](concepts.md#c52)的[模擬](concepts.md#c51):[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)之後的作用,可以與[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)運用[構件](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c01)的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)相同,背後沒有[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)。\n\n### 九之二 判定所依的切法\n\n**前提**:本篇記為:在邏輯狀態這個[切法](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c23)下,目前以圖靈機為設計基底的數位人工智慧,每一[回合](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c04)不是[鎖死的回合](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c25),就是[隨機的回合](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c26)。\n\n**前提**:本篇記為:[目前的人工智慧](concepts.md#c11)的載體,能作五項[工程能力](concepts.md#c12)所衡量的各類動作與保留:區分並處理輸入差異、對[表示](concepts.md#c34)作[運算](concepts.md#c08)、保留與取用先前的狀態、以有限資源重新表示、以既有[構造](concepts.md#c07)參與[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)。\n\n說明:\n1. 這個判定依設計事實,不依[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)。[切法](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c23)由作出判定的[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19)講明。\n2. 依[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)的定義,一個[呈現](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c04)是否為[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16),與任何[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)無關。所以[目前的人工智慧](concepts.md#c11)的物理載體是不是[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16),本篇不判定;本節的結論,都在這個[切法](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c23)下成立。\n3. 換成其他物理基底,另行判定。\n\n### 九之三 在這個切法下不是渦\n\n**結論**:沒有任何一[回合](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c04)是[決定](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c06)的[呈現](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c04),不是[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)。所以在這個[切法](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c23)下,[目前的人工智慧](concepts.md#c11)不是[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)。\n\n推導:依[決定](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c06)的定義,[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)在不被[鎖死](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c12)時的[回合](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c04),是[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)它的整段[歷史](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13)都參與[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06)的[回合](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c04),也就是[決定](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c06)。依[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)的定義,[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)至少有些[時刻](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c09)不被[鎖死](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c12),而[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)它的[歷史](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13)都參與[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06),所以[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)至少有一個[回合](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c04)是[決定](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c06)。依九之二,[目前的人工智慧](concepts.md#c11)沒有任何一[回合](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c04)是[決定](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c06)。來源:[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)、[計算](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c05)、[決定](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c06)的定義;九之二。\n\n說明:\n1. 本條把[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)的定義中「到達它的歷史都參與權重」讀作在每一個[時刻](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c09)都成立;定義中「這種參與可以漸漸消失,消失之後它就不再是渦」,支持這個讀法。\n2. [鎖死](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c12)不切斷參與:一個[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)在被[鎖死](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c12)的[時刻](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c09)只有一個結果,[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)它的[歷史](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13)仍參與它之後的[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06)。例如人被捆住時動不了,被捆的經歷仍參與他鬆綁之後的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)。所以一個[呈現](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c04)有時被[鎖死](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c12),不推出它不是[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)。\n3. [目前的人工智慧](concepts.md#c11)不是[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16),依的是它不被[鎖死](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c12)的[回合](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c04)都是[隨機的回合](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c26),不是它有時被[鎖死](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c12)。上游[配置假定](../paper_ae79e938_76e1_4bf9_b2ab_995c03e16c9e/concepts.md#c01)所列的兩種純粹情形,即[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)只能由[鎖死的回合](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c25)落出,或只能由[隨機的回合](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c26)落出,以及兩者混合的情形,都由這一點推出。\n\n### 九之四 在節點分類中的位置\n\n**結論**:在這個[切法](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c23)下,就某一[時刻](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c09)而言,[目前的人工智慧](concepts.md#c11)若從這一[時刻](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c09)起每一步都被[鎖死](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c12),它在這一[時刻](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c09)是[信號容器](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c26);若這一[時刻](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c09)或之後仍有不被[鎖死](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c12)的[時刻](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c09),它在這一[時刻](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c09)是[隨機源](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c27)。\n\n推導:依[節點](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25)的定義,[節點](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25)只有[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)、[信號容器](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c26)、[隨機源](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c27)三類;依九之三,它不是[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16);再依[信號容器](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c26)與[隨機源](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c27)的定義分類。\n\n說明:依這兩類的定義,它們不能成為[印象](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c45)的對象,[知見障](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c35)對[信號容器](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c26)也沒有內容。所以對[目前的人工智慧](concepts.md#c11)的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)所作的統計估計,在這個[切法](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c23)下不是上游所稱的[印象](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c45)。\n\n### 九之五 輸出可以相近,到達渦時同樣參與權重\n\n**結論**:在[經驗前提](concepts.md#c01)四講明的維度上,[目前的人工智慧](concepts.md#c11)能落出與[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)相近的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28);這些[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)時,與其他[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)一樣,參與[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)的[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06)。在講明的維度上,單憑[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28),分不出[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)與它的[模擬](concepts.md#c51)(九之一)。\n\n推導:依[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)與[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)的定義,[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)的[歷史](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13)都參與[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06),與來源是哪一類[節點](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25)無關。[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)[記錄](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c06)不含[回合](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c04)的種類;依[模擬](concepts.md#c51)的定義,在講明的維度上,[模擬](concepts.md#c51)的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)與[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)不能區分。\n\n說明:人被記為[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16),依的是[應用假定](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c50)與本篇的設定(第十節),不是[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)。研究者,或依[自我配置假定](concepts.md#c04)被假定為[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19)的人,把[目前的人工智慧](concepts.md#c11)的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)當成「它的看法」,是[看法歸屬](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c02),可能歸錯。[目前的人工智慧](concepts.md#c11)的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)可以描述一個[切法](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c23),但那是[計算](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c05)落出的內容;採用並講明它的,是研究者。\n\n### 九之六 處理方式可以拷貝\n\n**結論**:[構造](concepts.md#c07)相同、約束只由[構造](concepts.md#c07)與狀態決定的[鎖死](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c12)[節點](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25)之間,處理[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)的方式可以經由狀態的拷貝完整傳遞;先前[歷史](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13)不同的兩個[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)之間,推不出能這樣傳遞。\n\n推導:\n1. [鎖死](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c12)[節點](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25)的下一[時刻](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c09)由約束定死([鎖死](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c12)的定義)。兩個[構造](concepts.md#c07)相同的[鎖死](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c12)[節點](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25),若約束只由[構造](concepts.md#c07)與狀態決定,狀態相同時,同樣的[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)落出同樣的結果;約束只由[構造](concepts.md#c07)與狀態決定,是對機器[構造](concepts.md#c07)的假定,不由定義推出;狀態可以完整讀出並複製到另一台[構造](concepts.md#c07)相同的機器,也是對機器[構造](concepts.md#c07)的假定。\n2. 依[歷史](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13)與[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)的定義,[歷史](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13)只往後追加,[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)的全部[歷史](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13)都參與它的[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06)。所以任何一筆[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10),都只是在[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)的[歷史](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13)上追加一筆;它在這筆[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)之後仍是[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)時,先前的[歷史](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13)仍參與它的[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06)。第 1 點的結果依的是對機器[構造](concepts.md#c07)的假定;本篇對[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)沒有這樣的假定,所以兩個[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)先前的[歷史](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13)若不同,經由[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)能不能使它們處理[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)的方式相同,推不出。\n\n來源:[鎖死](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c12)、[歷史](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13)、[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)的定義;第十節所列本篇對機器的設定。\n\n說明:\n1. [構造](concepts.md#c07)不同的機器之間,要先把內容轉成另一台能用的形式;研究者把這次轉換讀作一次[壓縮](concepts.md#c31),不保證完整。\n2. 有隨機[回合](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c04)時,兩份拷貝各自落出結果、不共用同一次隨機結果的話,單次結果可以不同。若這類[節點](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25)的[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06)只由它的狀態與這次[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)決定,兩份拷貝在狀態仍相同時收到同樣的[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10),[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06)分布相同;這一條是對機器[構造](concepts.md#c07)的假定,不由定義推出。\n3. 依四之三第 3 點,[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)別人的是[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28),不是[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)這個動作;本條說明:在[構造](concepts.md#c07)相同、約束只由[構造](concepts.md#c07)與狀態決定的[鎖死](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c12)[節點](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25)之間,處理方式可以經由狀態的拷貝傳遞,不必經由[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28);在先前[歷史](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13)不同的[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)之間,推不出能這樣傳遞。七之三說明 3 引用本條。\n\n### 九之七 具備工程能力,推不出分別\n\n**結論**:[目前的人工智慧](concepts.md#c11)能作五項[工程能力](concepts.md#c12)所衡量的動作與保留(九之二),它的[回合](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c04)是[計算](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c05),研究者能把這些[計算](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c05)讀作[壓縮](concepts.md#c31)與[推演](concepts.md#c36)(命題五),並就已登記的[案例](concepts.md#c24)[比對](concepts.md#c38)它們是否[可交換](concepts.md#c55);在這個[切法](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c23)下,它卻不是[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16),沒有[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)。所以從[計算](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c05)被讀作[壓縮](concepts.md#c31)與[推演](concepts.md#c36),或從具備[工程能力](concepts.md#c12),推不出有[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)。\n\n推導:命題五;九之三;[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)的定義([分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)是[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)的動作)。\n\n### 九之八 工程門檻與觀察者辨識門檻\n\n**定義**:[工程門檻](concepts.md#c53):指定架構與資源,在指定條件下,能否穩定產生某類[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)。[觀察者辨識門檻](concepts.md#c54):外部何時開始把這類[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)標成「有智力」「會理解」「具有[二階能力](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c02)」。\n\n**結論**:[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)符合判準,不反推內部[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)、理解或意識(九之五)。框架不斷言跨過其中一個門檻,就跨過另一個。\n\n校準:常見已訓練模型在推論時使用既有參數,不在每次對話中更新;中間狀態與[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)分布仍隨輸入改變。\n\n---\n\n## 十、前提、經驗前提與失效條件\n\n### 十之一 前提\n\n前提是本篇的設定,不是可被推翻的主張:\n\n- 研究者沒有[歷史](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13)之外的位置;研究者是一個[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19)(一之四)。\n- [自我配置假定](concepts.md#c04)(一之五)。\n- [分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)與[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)在下一[時刻](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c09)之前[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)作出它的[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)(二之三)。\n- [信號容器](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c26)不限書面的讀法(二之二)。\n- [記錄](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c06)範圍:只登記[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)的物理改變,不登記[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)內容(二之二)。\n- [定義隔離與更名不變性](concepts.md#c06)(二之一)。\n- 有限接收(三之一)。\n- 五項[工程能力](concepts.md#c12)作為描述工具(三之二)。\n- 載體有限時的描述層[壓縮](concepts.md#c31)(三之四)。\n- 一次[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)讀作:界線兩側都有[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10),而且至少有一側把不只一筆[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)看作一個(五之一)。\n- [渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)的定義中「到達它的歷史都參與權重」,讀作在每一個[時刻](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c09)都成立(九之三)。\n- [目前的人工智慧](concepts.md#c11)判定所依的[切法](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c23),以及它能作五項[工程能力](concepts.md#c12)所衡量的動作與保留(九之二)。\n- 對四問的答案,只寫途徑、必要條件、不保證與不可確認四種東西,不寫充分條件(一之二)。\n- 本篇所討論的人記為[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16):依[應用假定](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c50)假定它不被[鎖死](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c12),並假定[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)它的[歷史](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13)都參與它的[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06)(一之一、九之一)。\n- [構造](concepts.md#c07)相同、約束只由[構造](concepts.md#c07)與狀態決定的機器之間,狀態可以完整讀出並複製(九之六)。\n- 不假定不同範圍的約束相同:兩個[案例](concepts.md#c24)用同一套約束,指同樣的輸入在兩個[案例](concepts.md#c24)中有同樣的[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06)分布,是要另外講明的條件(一之一、五之五)。\n- 網路可維持的複雜度不由[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)的能力單獨推出:人口、分工、資源、[信號容器](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c26)與[模板](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c14)的維護、[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)密度都參與;本篇不處理網路層(八之六)。\n\n否定它們的意思,是換成另一套設定。\n\n### 十之二 經驗前提\n\n[經驗前提](concepts.md#c01)一至三依[經驗禁止](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c51)的形式寫出:只寫缺少時[不會發生](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c01),不寫具備時會發生;由案例校準得來,可以被新的案例修改。[經驗前提](concepts.md#c01)四、五另見其說明。\n\n1. **[經驗前提](concepts.md#c01)一**:沒有留下自己[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)的某種副本(屬[記憶能力](concepts.md#c15)),或沒有把副本與隨後的[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)對照(屬[運算能力](concepts.md#c14)),就沒有[自他區辨](concepts.md#c48)(六之三)。校準:再傳入原理、蟋蟀、搔癢。\n2. **[經驗前提](concepts.md#c01)二**:沒有跨越不同[時刻](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c09)的保留(屬[記憶能力](concepts.md#c15)),或沒有把不同[時刻](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c09)自己造成的[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)[壓縮](concepts.md#c31)為同一類(屬[壓縮能力](concepts.md#c16)),就沒有[跨時刻歸併](concepts.md#c49)(六之三)。校準:鏡像自我辨認。\n3. **[經驗前提](concepts.md#c01)三**:沒有跨[時刻](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c09)的保留(屬[記憶能力](concepts.md#c15)),[構件](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c01)的內容就不能在[刺激](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c30)不在場時參與[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)的組織(七之二)。\n4. **[經驗前提](concepts.md#c01)四**:在研究者講明的若干維度上,[目前的人工智慧](concepts.md#c11)的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)與人的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)不能區分(九之一)。這一條與上面三條不同,不是必要條件,而是對既有測試結果的登記;依命題三,它只及於已登記的測試,可以被在這些維度之一、依同樣判準所作的新測試推翻,推翻時,它在該維度上是[模擬](concepts.md#c51)、[功能上等同](concepts.md#c52)這兩點(九之一),以及九之五、九之八、十一之四與第十三節中依它的部分,失去來源;它不是[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)的判定不受影響。\n5. **[經驗前提](concepts.md#c01)五**:有[自己維持的篩選邊界](concepts.md#c47)的[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16),[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)偏向維持邊界內部(一之五)。這一條和[經驗前提](concepts.md#c01)四一樣,不是必要條件;它由已觀察的案例歸納而來,新的案例中若有這樣的[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16),[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)不偏向維持邊界內部,就推翻它,推翻時只影響研究者以「它在維持自己」所作的概括。校準:細胞修補自己的細胞膜。\n\n### 十之三 失效條件\n\n- 某項[經驗前提](concepts.md#c01)被新的案例推翻時,來源鏈含該前提的結論失去來源,剩下的只是已觀察的個案與已登記的測試本身;失去來源只表示推導鏈斷開,不表示結論為假。\n- 本篇的推導依賴上游的[流變律](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c24)、[黑箱律](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c25)、[損耗律](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c26)、[不可復原律](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c28),以及[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)、[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)、[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)、[歷史](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13)、[鎖死](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c12)、[計算](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c05)、[決定](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c06)、[模板](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c14)、[信號容器](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c26)、[共振](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c09)等定義;它們是否成立,由上游處理。\n- 依賴二之三前提的結論(二之一、四之三、六之二、六之三、七之一、七之七、八之四、十一之二、十一之四,以及彙總它們的第十三節),在該前提被否定時失去來源;否定的情形是:某個[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)的一次[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)或一筆[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28),在下一[時刻](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c09)之前沒有[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)這個[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)自己。失去來源之後,這些結論對一般的[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)不再有來源,剩下的只是[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)與[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)確實回到自己的那些情形,可以另行判定;失去來源只表示推導鏈斷開,不表示結論為假;不依賴該前提的結論不受影響。\n\n---\n\n## 十一、不能推出的事\n\n右欄寫「必然」的,依[不被保證](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c02):框架不斷言它必然發生。\n\n### 十一之一 總體\n\n| 已知 | 不能推出 |\n|---|---|\n| 研究者用[構件](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c01)丙描述[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) | 被研究的[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)內部有丙 |\n| 甲方說出[構件](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c01)丙,[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)乙方 | 乙方理解、相信、採用丙 |\n| 乙方之後改變[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) | 丙是唯一原因([到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)乙方的全部[歷史](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13)都參與它的[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06),[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)的定義) |\n| 同一個詞 | 同一個內部[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)或相同的[輸出傾向](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c02) |\n| 研究者把[構件](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c01)丙改名為丁 | 當事[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)的物理[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)隨之改變 |\n| 出現新行為或發明 | 存在額外的「發明生成力」 |\n| 遞回沒有外在起點 | 每次結果已被決定,或[歷史](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13)可以重來([黑箱律](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c25)、[不可復原律](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c28)) |\n| [幻覺構件](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c01)的對象不由物理世界給出 | 承載它的訊號不是物理事件 |\n| 必要條件都具備 | 結果必然發生 |\n\n### 十一之二 第一問:功能\n\n| 已知 | 不能推出 |\n|---|---|\n| [構件](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c01)有某項[功能](concepts.md#c18) | [構件](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c01)因此而出現,或有目的 |\n| 沒有[構件](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c01) | [分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)的內容不參與[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06) |\n| 有[構件](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c01)、能[推演](concepts.md#c36) | [推演](concepts.md#c36)與之後的[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)相符 |\n| 例子中[構件](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c01)在[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)要[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)別人時才出現在[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)中 | 沒有說出來時,這個[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)內部沒有這個[構件](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c01) |\n\n### 十一之三 工程能力與可交換\n\n| 已知 | 不能推出 |\n|---|---|\n| 本篇選取五項[工程能力](concepts.md#c12) | [渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)要具備五項才成立,或只有這五項 |\n| [渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)的定義 | 載體上有可找到的[表示](concepts.md#c34) |\n| 研究者選定的量化指標 | 能力本身的維度 |\n| 以維度或資料速率描述現實 | 現實的維度與位元率已可量化 |\n| 能存續 | 能力越強越能存續 |\n| 某項能力低於某個程度 | 不能在講明的時窗內存續 |\n| [壓縮](concepts.md#c31)把不同資訊歸入較少[表示](concepts.md#c34) | [壓縮](concepts.md#c31)自帶材料,或每次[壓縮](concepts.md#c31)都形成[構件](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c01) |\n| [運算能力](concepts.md#c14)更高 | 補回容納時丟掉的差異 |\n| 一套[推演規則](concepts.md#c44)[自洽](concepts.md#c45) | 它[在範圍內可交換](concepts.md#c42) |\n| 一次[壓縮](concepts.md#c31)[可交換](concepts.md#c55) | 它的[推演規則](concepts.md#c44)[自洽](concepts.md#c45) |\n| 對不被[鎖死](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c12)的[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)有精確的[推演規則](concepts.md#c44),而它可能落出的結果在[後段表示](concepts.md#c33)上相差超過[允許誤差](concepts.md#c56)的兩倍 | 單次結果[可交換](concepts.md#c55) |\n| 一次[壓縮](concepts.md#c31)在某個範圍內[可交換](concepts.md#c55) | 它在一切範圍內都[可交換](concepts.md#c55) |\n| 一次[壓縮](concepts.md#c31)至今通過[結果回饋](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c05) | 它選對了維度已被證明 |\n| 兩個[案例](concepts.md#c24)的[表示](concepts.md#c34)相同 | 它們是同一個[標的](concepts.md#c25) |\n| 觀察到一筆錯誤[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) | 必然是[構造](concepts.md#c07)不足 |\n| 工程模型使用「權重」一詞 | 已測得上游的[分支](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c05)[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06) |\n\n### 十一之四 第二問:生成\n\n| 已知 | 不能推出 |\n|---|---|\n| 研究者以「我」[壓縮](concepts.md#c31)一個[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) | 該[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)以[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)定義自己 |\n| 有[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) | 有[構件](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c01) |\n| 沒有名字 | 沒有[構件](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c01) |\n| 一次[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)當下沒有用到[構件](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c01) | 它的內容之後不會成為[構件](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c01) |\n| 具備梯子上的各階條件 | 是[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19) |\n| 有[自己維持的篩選邊界](concepts.md#c47) | 作了自我定義 |\n| 研究者在人的尺度上假定[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19) | 人是「真正的我」 |\n| [表示](concepts.md#c34)可再次處理 | [表示](concepts.md#c34)越來越多、越來越正確,或必然導向[二階分別](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c01) |\n| 具備五項[工程能力](concepts.md#c12) | 有[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) |\n| [節點](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25)的[計算](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c05)被研究者讀作[可交換](concepts.md#c55)的[壓縮](concepts.md#c31) | 這個[節點](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25)有[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) |\n| [輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)與[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)相近 | 是[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16) |\n| 在某些維度上[功能上等同](concepts.md#c52)於[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16) | 是[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16),或在一切維度上[功能上等同](concepts.md#c52) |\n| [輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)被讀作承載內容,例如名稱 | 落出它的[節點](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25)有作為[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)內容的[構件](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c01) |\n| [分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)的內容參與之後的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) | 有[構件](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c01)(參與本身沒有對象) |\n| 一個內容只說過一次 | 它不是[構件](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c01) |\n| 把不同的東西歸成一類 | 有[構件](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c01)(這是[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)中的[歸併](concepts.md#c23)) |\n| [目前的人工智慧](concepts.md#c11)的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)描述了一個[切法](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c23) | [目前的人工智慧](concepts.md#c11)作出了[切法](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c23) |\n| [目前的人工智慧](concepts.md#c11)有時被[鎖死](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c12) | 它因此不是[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)(人也會被[鎖死](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c12)) |\n| [目前的人工智慧](concepts.md#c11)推論時[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)改變 | 參數在每次輸入後更新(有隨機[回合](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c04)時,單次結果就可以不同,九之六) |\n| [目前的人工智慧](concepts.md#c11)規模增加 | 智力必然單調增加,或[目前的人工智慧](concepts.md#c11)成為[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)(是不是[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)依設計與[切法](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c23)判定,九之二、九之三;具備[工程能力](concepts.md#c12),推不出[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18),九之七) |\n| 兩台[構造](concepts.md#c07)相同的機器可以拷貝狀態 | 兩個[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)可以經由[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)成為彼此的拷貝 |\n\n### 十一之五 第三問:運用\n\n| 已知 | 不能推出 |\n|---|---|\n| 取得一個[模板](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c14) | 取得它的適用範圍,或取得者的施行與他人相同 |\n| 各方套用[模板](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c14)的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)[共振](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c09) | 各方的[壓縮](concepts.md#c31)相同 |\n| 某內容是[模板](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c14) | 它經過某個[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)的[構件](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c01) |\n| [記錄](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c06)中有[模板](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c14) | [明列](concepts.md#c09)它的[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)內部有[構件](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c01) |\n| 某網路有[文化](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c13) | 參與者有[構件](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c01)、[模板](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c14)或[二階分別](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c01) |\n| [模板](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c14)可在[文化](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c13)中反覆使用 | [文化](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c13)必經[模板](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c14)階段,或[模板](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c14)是[文化](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c13)的一層 |\n| 兩[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)反覆互相[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) | 必然形成[文化](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c13),或[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06)必然收斂 |\n| 某些相容[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)反覆出現 | 已測得[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)的內部[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06),或已證明壓縮率([比對](concepts.md#c38)只及於已[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)的[案例](concepts.md#c24),命題三) |\n| 不記得某次[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)的內容 | 不能對它作[二階分別](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c01) |\n| 一般成人使用相關[構件](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c01) | 已驗證其二階內部[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) |\n\n### 十一之六 第四問:運用之後\n\n| 已知 | 不能推出 |\n|---|---|\n| 一個[構件](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c01)不[可交換](concepts.md#c55) | 它不再被運用 |\n| 不相符的材料[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) | [構件](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c01)因此被放棄 |\n| 具備[二階能力](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c02)的配置 | 必然有較高的社會複雜度、必然發明或理解 |\n| 五項能力足夠強 | 必然形成[二階分別](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c01)、理解或高度複雜網路 |\n| 人口較多 | 文明複雜度必然較高 |\n| 出現系統性[歸併](concepts.md#c23) | 界線劃錯([分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)都含有[歸併](concepts.md#c23),五之一;同一段[宇宙](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c02)被劃為一個或許多個,都成立,二之一) |\n\n---\n\n## 十二、案例\n\n本節整節只作校準,不作任何推導的來源。資料取自公開網頁,不是原始檔;來源對同一件事的歸因,標為來源的歸屬。\n\n### 十二之一 小孩學「你」和「我」\n\n**經過。**\n\n英語兒童大約到三歲,才完全掌握人稱代名詞。學的過程中,有些孩子會把「你」和「我」對調。這種情形並不常見:大多數孩子不會對調,即使出錯也很少一致;在一份樣本中,30 名約一歲八個月、說話較早的孩子裡,有 17 名在兩小時的觀察中至少對調過一次。\n\n[〔Providence〕語料庫](concepts.md#c57)長期錄下六名英語兒童在家中與父母的對話;其中有兩個孩子,連續幾個月都在對調。女孩〔Naima〕從大約一歲七個月到兩歲四個月,會說「你的臉上有藍莓」,意思是自己的臉上。她整體上對調了 79% 的第二人稱代名詞(306 個中的 243 個),第一人稱只對調了 3%(477 個中的 13 個)。到兩歲五個月,對調突然停止,沒有過渡期;作者推測可能和一次家庭旅行有關,也可能是兩歲四個月前後的發展變化,並說兩種解釋不互相排斥。另一個男孩〔Ethan〕,在模仿母親說話時對調得特別多;資料結束時,他仍在對調。\n\n研究者提出過幾種解釋。一種認為,孩子把代名詞當成固定的名字,而不是隨說話者而變的詞;〔Naima〕的資料符合這個說法。另一種認為,孩子可能知道大人怎麼用,但從別人的角度說話;〔Ethan〕的資料部分支持這種說法。還有一種說法:孩子是從大人對別人說的話裡學會第二人稱的,長子或獨生子聽到這種話的機會較少;這兩個孩子都是頭胎,研究期間沒有兄弟姊妹。作者的結論是,兩種假說都只得到有限度的支持。\n\n**帶入框架。**\n\n先選[切法](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c23):[節點](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25)是孩子與父母;父母說的話是[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)孩子的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28),孩子說的話是孩子的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)。這個階段的孩子,本篇不假定為[社會人](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c03);依六之一,她的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)中仍可以有[構件](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c01):框架不斷言[二階分別](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c01)或[看法歸屬](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c02)是[構件](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c01)運用的必要條件(七之七)。\n\n- **材料是外來的,[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)是自己的。** 父母天天對孩子說「你要喝牛奶嗎」,這些[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)孩子,是孩子的材料。孩子用這些材料作出的[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18),是孩子自己的(六之二說明 1)。父母說出口的「你」,不等於孩子得到了「你」這個[構件](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c01);名稱的[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)不是[構件](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c01)的轉移(七之一說明 1)。\n- **對調時期的「你」已經是[構件](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c01)。** 〔Naima〕說「你的臉上有藍莓」,「你」出現在她的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)中,指著一個對象:她自己。依六之一,這是[構件](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c01),所指的是一個固定的對象,像一個名字。\n- **大人用法的「你」,所指的是位置。** 「你」用在一個又一個被說話的人身上,所指的是「被說話的一方」這個位置。所以從對調到正確使用,在框架裡不是從[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)到[構件](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c01),而是[構件](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c01)所指的,從一個固定的對象換成一個位置。這與「當成名字」的那種解釋相接。\n- **聽別人之間的對話。** 第三種說法若成立,孩子是從父母互相說的話裡,聽到「你」指著不同的人。這是材料;孩子會不會因此改變「你」所指的,[不被保證](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c02)(六之四)。\n- **突然停止。** 〔Naima〕在兩歲五個月突然不再對調。作者的兩種推測都是來源的歸屬;依六之四,從更早的時點推不出它何時發生。\n\n**[記錄](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c06)中有的與推不出的。**\n\n[記錄](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c06)中有的:在這些[記錄](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c06)裡,有些孩子在一段時間內把「你」用在自己身上,之後改為用在被說話的人身上;改變可以很突然。\n\n推不出:孩子內部作了什麼[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18);哪一種假說對:兩種假說都是研究者對孩子[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)的歸屬,依六之五,從外部確認[不被保證](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c02),作者說兩者都只得到有限度的支持,與此一致;對調的停止出於哪一筆[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)。\n\n**資料說明。**\n\n經過主要取自〔Evans〕與〔Demuth〕2012 年刊於〔Journal of Child Language〕的論文〈〔Individual differences in pronoun reversal: Evidence from two longitudinal case studies〕〉,經工具摘出相關段落,不是原始檔;其中〔Dale〕與〔Crain-Thoreson〕的數字是該文的轉引。〔Ethan〕的其他背景與本案無關,沒有收錄。\n\n### 十二之二 海王星與祝融星\n\n**經過。**\n\n十九世紀上半,天王星的實際位置一再偏離算出的位置。法國天文學家勒維耶假設外側有一顆看不見的行星在拉它,用牛頓力學反推出這顆行星應在的位置。1846 年 9 月 23 日,柏林天文台的伽勒只找了一個小時,就在離勒維耶算出的位置不到一度的地方找到海王星。\n\n勒維耶接著研究水星。水星的近日點會慢慢移動,但實際移動得比算出來的快一點。當時各行星的質量測得還不夠準,勒維耶算出每世紀有 38 角秒無法解釋;現在的數值是每世紀 43 角秒。勒維耶用同一套方法,提出水星內側有一顆行星,或一群小天體。\n\n1859 年,萊斯卡博報告在 3 月 26 日看到一個小黑點越過太陽,勒維耶在 12 月 22 日收到他的信;1860 年 1 月 2 日,勒維耶在科學院宣布發現祝融星,公布的軌道距太陽約 2,100 萬公里,週期 19 天 17 小時。之後,勒維耶隨著新的目擊報告一再調整祝融星的軌道參數,其中很多報告沒有日期或時間不準;他公布了未來凌日的日期,預報落空時,又再改參數。天文學家在凌日與日全食時搜尋了幾十年。\n\n1866 至 1878 年沒有可靠的觀測。1878 年 7 月 29 日日全食時,華生和斯威夫特都說看到太陽附近有一顆行星;彼得斯後來認為那是已知的恆星。日全食的搜尋一直持續到 1908 年;那一年,利克天文台的坎貝爾與佩林認為,從觀測上說,水星內側行星的問題已經結束。1915 年,愛因斯坦的廣義相對論不需要隱藏的行星,就解釋了水星的軌道異常。這個名字也被用到天文以外:一位天氣預報者,依祝融星假想的運行作預報。\n\n**帶入框架。**\n\n先選[切法](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c23):[案例](concepts.md#c24)甲的[標的](concepts.md#c25)是勒維耶算出位置附近的天區,[前段材料](concepts.md#c29)是天王星的位置偏差,[推演](concepts.md#c36)是由此算出看不見的行星應在的位置,[後段材料](concepts.md#c30)是 1846 年對那片天區的觀測。[案例](concepts.md#c24)乙的[標的](concepts.md#c25)是水星軌道內側、太陽附近的天區,[前段材料](concepts.md#c29)是水星近日點的偏差與早期的目擊報告,[推演](concepts.md#c36)是凌日預報,[後段材料](concepts.md#c30)是預報日之後對太陽的觀測。兩案的[壓縮](concepts.md#c31),都是以質量、位置、速度,加上已知天體,把觀測[記錄](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c06)轉成[表示](concepts.md#c34);[推演](concepts.md#c36)是天體力學的計算。\n\n- **第一問:兩顆都是[構件](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c01)。** 「那顆看不見的行星」被算出來時,沒有任何來自它、被認出來的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)天文學家;它指著一個不在場的對象,有名字、有軌道、被寫進信裡寄出去,三項[功能](concepts.md#c18)都在(四之三)。依[幻覺構件](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c01)的定義,稱它們為[構件](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c01),不主張對象存在,也不否認;海王星後來找到了,祝融星沒有,兩者在找到之前地位相同。\n- **[可交換](concepts.md#c55):方法相同,一次對得上,一次對不上。** [案例](concepts.md#c24)甲中,[推演](concepts.md#c36)的位置與之後的觀測差不到一度;研究者若講明[允許誤差](concepts.md#c56)為一度,這次[比對](concepts.md#c38)[在這個案例上可交換](concepts.md#c40)。[案例](concepts.md#c24)乙中,凌日預報與預報日之後的觀測一再對不上,不[可交換](concepts.md#c55)。同一套[壓縮](concepts.md#c31)與[推演](concepts.md#c36)在一個[案例](concepts.md#c24)上[可交換](concepts.md#c55),推不出在另一個[案例](concepts.md#c24)上也[可交換](concepts.md#c55)。\n- **讀法可以錯。** 1878 年的兩次目擊,是研究者[壓縮](concepts.md#c31)[後段材料](concepts.md#c30)時用到了祝融星這個[構件](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c01),把一個光點讀成祝融星;後來被認為讀錯了。[比對](concepts.md#c38)的結果,相對於研究者怎麼[壓縮](concepts.md#c31)這筆材料(五之三)。\n- **不[可交換](concepts.md#c55),照樣被運用。** 預報落空之後,勒維耶改參數,再預報。不相符的觀測一筆筆[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10),參與了[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06),承載這個[構件](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c01)的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)沒有因此停止出現(八之一、八之二);它還被拿到天氣預報裡用(八之四)。加上祝融星,只是在同一套天體力學的計算裡多放一個天體:同一個[表示](concepts.md#c34)上,這套計算只給出一個結果,依[自洽](concepts.md#c45)的定義是[自洽](concepts.md#c45)的;它在[案例](concepts.md#c24)乙上卻不[可交換](concepts.md#c55)(命題六)。\n- **退出。** 天文學界在 1908 年前後認定觀測上已經結束,1915 年後有了另一套[壓縮](concepts.md#c31)。依八之一,祝融星不再被運用,不是從不相符的觀測必然推出的;為什麼在那時退出,是來源的歸屬。\n\n**[記錄](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c06)中有的與推不出的。**\n\n[記錄](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c06)中有的:同一套方法,從天王星的偏差出發,[推演](concepts.md#c36)與之後的觀測相符;從水星的偏差出發,凌日預報一再落空,參數一再調整,搜尋持續了幾十年;有人把同一個[構件](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c01)用到天氣預報上。\n\n推不出:勒維耶或其他天文學家「相信」什麼,[記錄](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c06)中只有論文、信件、預報與宣布;為什麼搜尋持續那麼久、為什麼在那時停止;若沒有廣義相對論,祝融星會被用多久。\n\n**資料說明。**\n\n經過取自維基百科「〔Vulcan (hypothetical planet)〕」條目、大英百科「〔Urbain-Jean-Joseph Le Verrier〕」條目,以及〔Book of Proofs〕網站的一份勒維耶生平整理頁,都經工具摘出相關段落,不是原始檔。祝融星這個名字由誰先提出,來源不一:維基百科記為 1846 年由巴比內提出,另有來源記為勒維耶在 1859 年提出。水星近日點的超出量,勒維耶當年算的是每世紀 38 角秒,現代值是每世紀 43 角秒,兩者並列。\n\n---\n\n## 十三、總命題\n\n**總命題**:單純的物理[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)要成為[幻覺構件](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c01),經過兩步:從依賴到[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18),以及從[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)到[構件](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c01)。沒有[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18),就沒有作為它[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)內容的[構件](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c01);有[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18),不推出有[構件](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c01)。[構件](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c01)與[單純的分別](concepts.md#c19)都參與之後的[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06),差別在[構件](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c01)有所指的對象。有了所指的對象,才有[指代](concepts.md#c20)不在場的東西、[推演](concepts.md#c36),以及以指著它的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)[在渦之間傳遞](concepts.md#c21)。\n\n一個[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)的[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)內容若成為[構件](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c01),途徑是:[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)的[寫入](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c29)經由[小迴路](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c02)再次[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10),其內容被用來指某個對象,之後可以再次[歸併](concepts.md#c23);不主張必然經過每一步,也不主張次序固定。必要條件中,[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)由定義推出。[自我配置假定](concepts.md#c04)另有必要條件,其中的工程條件是[經驗前提](concepts.md#c01);本篇不把這些工程條件列為[構件](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c01)生成的必要條件。條件都具備,生成[不被保證](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c02);生成了,從外部確認也[不被保證](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c02);對此,本篇從外部給出的判斷只有否定。\n\n[構件](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c01)的運用有[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)內部與[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)之間兩條途徑。在[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)之間,[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)的是承載它的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28),不是[構件](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c01)的轉移;取得同一個[模板](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c14),推不出取得者的施行相同,研究者能登記的施行一致,只在[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)上;[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)在講明的維度與時窗內彼此[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)並反覆相容接續時,是[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)的[共振](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c09)。\n\n以[構件](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c01)[推演](concepts.md#c36)時,判準是[推演](concepts.md#c36)是否[在講明的範圍內可交換](concepts.md#c42)。只靠同一個[表示](concepts.md#c34),丟掉的差異救不回來;[運算能力](concepts.md#c14)再高,也補不回容納時丟掉的差異;[比對](concepts.md#c38)只及於已[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)的[案例](concepts.md#c24);對不被[鎖死](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c12)、結果的差異落在被[比對](concepts.md#c38)的[表示](concepts.md#c34)上的[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16),單次結果的[可交換](concepts.md#c55)[不被保證](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c02);[自洽](concepts.md#c45)推不出[可交換](concepts.md#c55),[可交換](concepts.md#c55)也推不出[自洽](concepts.md#c45)。[回合](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c04)是[計算](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c05)的[節點](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25)不必作[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18),把[計算](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c05)讀作[推演](concepts.md#c36)的是讀它的[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)。一個[構件](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c01)不[可交換](concepts.md#c55)時,不相符的[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)照樣參與[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06),但它是否因此不再被運用,[不被保證](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c02);繼續被運用,不以[可交換](concepts.md#c55)為條件。\n\n[目前的人工智慧](concepts.md#c11)在邏輯狀態[切法](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c23)下不是[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16),沒有[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18),也沒有作為[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)內容的[構件](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c01);在研究者講明的若干維度上,若講明的作用只取決於[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)在這些維度上的內容,這些維度上相同的兩筆[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)同一個[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)時作用相同,在這個意義上它可以[功能上等同](concepts.md#c52)於[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16);在[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)不能區分的維度上,它是[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)的[模擬](concepts.md#c51)。[構造](concepts.md#c07)相同、約束只由[構造](concepts.md#c07)與狀態決定的[鎖死](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c12)[節點](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25)之間,處理[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)的方式可以經由拷貝完整傳遞,先前[歷史](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13)不同的[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)之間,推不出能這樣傳遞。\n\n至於某個[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)何時作出[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)、某個內容何時成為[構件](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c01)、[構件](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c01)被運用之後走向哪一種後果,本篇皆不唯一推出。\n\n(依一之二的寫法,從四之二、四之三、五之三、五之四命題一至六、六之一至六之五、七之一、七之三、八之一、八之二、九之一、九之三、九之六彙總。依賴命題四、六之四、七之三的部分,在[應用假定](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c50)之下成立;依賴[經驗前提](concepts.md#c01)一至五的部分,在這些前提被新的案例推翻時失去來源;依賴九之二的部分,在邏輯狀態[切法](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c23)下成立;依賴九之一、九之六的部分,在第十節所列本篇對人與機器的設定下成立。)\n"},{"filename":"Dynamics of Illusory Constructs.md","content":"---\nuuid: ed71bef7-0f22-4443-bc1d-4d1ecfe81967\nlast-modified: 2026-11-11T17:51:57\nauthor: 黃正宇 / Cheng Yu Huang\ncontact: mthree.tw@gmail.com\n---\n\n# Dynamics of Illusory Constructs\n\n## 1. Question and Position\n\n### 1.1 Research Question\n\nThis paper asks: how does a mere physical [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) become an [illusory construct](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c01)? The question is split into four:\n\n1. What [function](concepts.md#c18) does a [construct](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c01) have: without it, which [outputs](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) [never occur](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c01) (Section 4);\n2. How a [construct](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c01) is generated (Section 6);\n3. Under what conditions a [construct](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c01) can be used (Section 7);\n4. What happens after it is used (Section 8).\n\n[Compression](concepts.md#c31) and being [commutative](concepts.md#c55), in Section 5, are the tools for answering the last three questions; Section 9 uses [current artificial intelligence](concepts.md#c11) as a control group.\n\nThe core is the second question. From mere physical [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) to a [construct](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c01) there are two steps: from dependence to [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18), and from [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) to [construct](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c01) (6.1).\n\nThis paper mainly discusses the [social person](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c03): calling a biological person a [social person](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c03) is done under the [configuration assumption](../paper_ae79e938_76e1_4bf9_b2ab_995c03e16c9e/concepts.md#c01), and there is no sharp boundary. This paper records the persons it discusses as [Wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16) and, by the [Application Assumption](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c50), assumes they are not [locked in](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c12) (Section 10). The child in 12.1 is not assumed to be a [social person](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c03), and this is marked there. This paper does not assume that the constraints of different ranges are the same: the laws, currencies and institutions of different places can be entirely different; being [commutative](concepts.md#c55) within one range holds only for that range, and that two [cases](concepts.md#c24) use the same set of constraints is a condition to be stated separately (5.4, 5.5).\n\n### 1.2 The Form of the Answers\n\n**This paper's way of writing**: The answers this paper gives to the four questions are of only four kinds: pathways (if it happens, through what), necessary conditions (without them it [never occurs](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c01)), no guarantee (even with all conditions present, it is not guaranteed to happen), and unconfirmability (if it happens, confirming it from outside is [not guaranteed](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c02)). This paper does not state sufficient conditions.\n\nReasons: By the [Law of the Black Box](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c25) and the [Application Assumption](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c50), the next [moment](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c09) of a [Wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16) that is not [locked in](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c12) cannot be uniquely derived in advance; by the definition of [empirical prohibition](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c51), conditions written in the form of [empirical prohibition](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c51) state only necessary conditions; by this paper's [record](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c06) scope (2.2), there is no [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) in the [record](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c06), and a researcher's classing an [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) as the subject's [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) is a [view attribution](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c02) made by treating the subject as another [self](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19), which by the definition of [view attribution](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c02) may be misattributed; so confirming from outside whether a subject has made a given [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) is [not guaranteed](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c02).\n\nNote: Necessary conditions come from two sources: those derived from definitions are marked as conclusions; those calibrated from cases are marked as [empirical premises](concepts.md#c01). What this paper calls an [empirical premise](concepts.md#c01) is a premise obtained from cases or from existing tests, which new cases or tests can revise; among them, [Empirical Premises](concepts.md#c01) One to Three take the form of [empirical prohibition](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c51) and state only necessary conditions; [Empirical Premise](concepts.md#c01) Four registers the results of existing tests, and [Empirical Premise](concepts.md#c01) Five is a generalization induced from observations; neither is a necessary condition (Section 10).\n\n### 1.3 The Base Is Unchanged; Three Layers Kept Apart\n\n**The base is unchanged**: By the definition of [round](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c04), a [round](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c04) is [arrival](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10), [weight](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06), result, and [arrival](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) again. The result becomes [history](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13), later [history](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13) participates in [weight](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06), and a new result falls out. [Weight](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06) here is how heavy a [branch](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c05) is (the definition of [weight](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06)), not desire, an intelligence score or a utility function, nor any parameter inside a [Wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16). This paper adds no new base generative law for invention, [culture](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c13), [illusory constructs](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c01), civilization or intelligence; all of them can serve as descriptions of patterns of [history](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13) under different [cuts](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c23), and their related [outputs](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) also enter later [history](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13).\n\n**Three layers kept apart** (conclusion; the table below is called the [three-layer table](concepts.md#c58)):\n\n| Layer | Content | Changes with engineering improvement? |\n|---|---|---|\n| [Theoretical limit](concepts.md#c02) | [Law of Flux](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c24), [Law of the Black Box](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c25), [Law of Attrition](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c26), [Law of Non-Restoration](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c28) | Does not change |\n| [Engineering limit](concepts.md#c03) | Reception and the five [engineering capacities](concepts.md#c12) | May change |\n| [History](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13) and what actually falls out | Even with similar engineering architecture, different [histories](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13) and [arrivals](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) may produce different [outputs](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) | Varies with the concrete [history](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13); no unique result guaranteed |\n\nDerivation: By their respective definitions, the [Law of Flux](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c24), the [Law of the Black Box](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c25) and the [Law of Non-Restoration](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c28) hold for any [Wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16) in the [universe](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c02), and the [Law of Attrition](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c26) holds for any [self](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19); none is limited by engineering conditions, so none changes with engineering improvement; an [engineering capacity](concepts.md#c12) is an indicator measuring a carrier (3.2), and when the carrier changes, the indicator may change; by the [Law of the Black Box](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c25), even with similar engineering architecture, the next [moment](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c09) of a [Wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16) that is not [locked in](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c12) cannot be uniquely derived in advance.\n\nThe range engineering can realize is usually far smaller than the range physically possible; this is an intuitive judgment. This paper does not call it \"a tiny fraction of the theoretically permitted range\": such wording would need comparable state spaces and measures, which this paper does not give.\n\n### 1.4 The Researcher's Position\n\n**Premise**: The researcher has no position outside [history](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13): a researcher proposing [constructs](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c01), publishing papers or rewriting definitions is producing [outputs](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28); if they [arrive](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at the object of study or at others, they likewise participate in later [history](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13).\n\n**Premise**: This paper assumes that the researcher is a [self](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19). This is an assumption, not a conclusion.\n\n### 1.5 The Studied Wo Is Not Presupposed to Be a Self\n\nBy the definition of [self](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19), the condition for being a [self](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19) is defining oneself by [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18). The act of [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) leaves a [writing](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c29) in [history](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13); but the boundary that \"these are me\" points to is not given by the physical world (2.1). So when \"self\" is used to describe or organize [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28), it is an [illusory construct](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c01). This paper treats it as what is to be explained, not as the starting point of explanation. The upstream papers take \"self\" as their starting point, and they hold within those papers; what this paper changes is the question, and it does not judge the upstream wrong. Upstream concepts whose definitions use \"self\" are used in this paper only on the researcher's side, or as an [illusory construct](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c01) the researcher uses when attributing, and not as an antecedent of the [Wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16) being studied.\n\n**Two questions about \"self\":**\n\n**Question one: Can the researcher use \"self\" to [compress](concepts.md#c31) the [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) of a [Wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)?** Yes. Without a [construct](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c01), explaining one [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) means tracing back the whole [history](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13); with one, a large amount of [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) can be grouped into a few [distinctions](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18). By [Empirical Premise](concepts.md#c01) Five in Section 10 (induced from the cases observed so far), the [outputs](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) of a [Wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16) that has a [self-maintained filtering boundary](concepts.md#c47) lean toward maintaining the inside of the boundary; when the researcher, having stated a [case](concepts.md#c24) whose [target](concepts.md#c25) is that [Wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16), summarizes these as \"it is maintaining itself\", and reads the [round](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c04) in which he makes this summary as turning the [outputs](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) that [arrive](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at him into a [representation](concepts.md#c34), then by the definition of [compression](concepts.md#c31) this is a [compression](concepts.md#c31); whether it is [commutative](concepts.md#c55) is judged by the criterion of 5.3 (5.6); it does not concern whether the object of the [construct](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c01) exists, nor does it imply that the [Wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16) has made a self-definition: its [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) fits the description the researcher makes with \"self\"; it does not operate according to \"self\".\n\n**Question two: Does the [Wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16) itself define itself by [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)?** [Distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) is not in the [record](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c06) (2.2); the studied [Wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)'s self-report is an [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28), and the researcher's classing it as the other's [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) is a [view attribution](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c02) made by treating the other as another [self](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19), which may be misattributed. So this paper makes an assumption here:\n\n> **[Self-Configuration Assumption](concepts.md#c04)** (premise): Under a stated [cut](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c23), for some [Wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16) that is cut out, it is assumed that it defines itself by [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18). This is not a theorem; confirming it from outside is [not guaranteed](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c02) (1.2). When it lacks one of the necessary conditions listed in point 3 of 6.3, or when a mechanism is found proving that none of its [rounds](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c04) is a [decision](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c06) (9.3), this assumption does not hold for it. At what scale to cut belongs to the researcher's [cut](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c23); \"self\" is not among the conclusions that [recutting](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c22) guarantees unchanged (the definition of [recutting](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c22)), so under another [cut](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c23) this assumption may fall on different [Wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16), or on nested [Wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16) at the same time, for example a person and each of his nerve cells.\n\nResearchers usually assume \"self\" at the human scale, and the reasons are practical: most of the [outputs](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) a researcher receives [arrive](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at the researcher at this scale; the asymmetry of [arrival](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) caused by skin is obvious at this scale; and the researcher also draws himself at this scale, and the researcher's then reading the [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) of others as the [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) by which they draw themselves at this scale is itself a [view attribution](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c02). These reasons do not make the human scale the \"true self\".\n\nWhether the studied [Wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16) has [first-order distinction](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c24) or [second-order distinction](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c01) likewise depends on the [configuration assumption](../paper_ae79e938_76e1_4bf9_b2ab_995c03e16c9e/concepts.md#c01). [Second-order capacity](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c02) is itself an [illusory construct](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c01) (the definition of [second-order capacity](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c02)).\n\n### 1.6 Generalized Lossiness\n\n**Conclusion**: By the definitions of [arrival](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) and [stimulus](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c30), what falls on a [presentation](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c04) is the part of one [writing](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c29) that is for it, or the result of one [collapse](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c08). Another [Wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)'s [own segment](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c17) is the part of [history](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13) on which its [weight](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06) depends, which by the definition of [Wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16) reaches back to [the initial state of the universe](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c14), including the results of many [writings](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c29) and [collapses](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c08); what one [arrival](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) brings to the receiver is only the part of one of those [writings](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c29) that is for it, or the result of one [collapse](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c08). So what one [arrival](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) brings to a [presentation](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c04) is not the whole of another [Wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)'s [own segment](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c17); this does not depend on whether the receiver is a [self](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19). This paper calls this point [generalized lossiness](concepts.md#c05). Upstream [lossiness](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c13), for one [arrival](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) and when [what is seen](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c27) is another [Wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16), is the case where this generalization falls on a [self](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19) (the definition of [lossiness](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c13)).\n\n---\n\n## 2. Inheritance and Terminology\n\n### 2.1 Where Illusory Constructs Stand\n\n**Two ways of appearing** (by the definition of [illusory construct](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c01)): first, in the researcher's description, which uses a limited number of [constructs](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c01) to group a large amount of [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) into fewer [distinctions](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18); second, in actual [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28), for example names, [avowals](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c06), and classifications [explicitly listed](concepts.md#c09) in a [signal container](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c26). What can be registered is this physical [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) and the [arrivals](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) that can be confirmed, not that the speaker has, inside, an understanding of the same name and the same meaning. From a researcher's describing an [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) with [construct](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c01) A, it cannot be derived that the [Wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16) concerned has A; from the [Wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16) concerned saying A, it likewise cannot be derived that its inner [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) equals the A the researcher defined.\n\n**One case of appearing inside a [Wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)**: when the content of a [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) [arrives](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at that [Wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16) again through a [small loop](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c02) (2.3) and is used to point at some object and to organize its later [distinctions](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) and [outputs](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28), this content then fits the definition of [illusory construct](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c01). It can be regarded as a stand-in for [what is seen](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c27) when that is not present; by the definition of [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18), its material is only the [history](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13) that has already [arrived](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at that [Wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16); if [what is seen](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c27) is another [Wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16), then by [generalized lossiness](concepts.md#c05) each of those [arrivals](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) is not the whole of that [Wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)'s [own segment](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c17); calling it a stand-in does not claim that what it stands in for exists.\n\n**A [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) may use [constructs](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c01), or may not**: this concerns whether, at the moment the [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) is made, existing [constructs](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c01) are used as material. By 6.1, without [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) there is no [construct](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c01) that is the content of its [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18); so before the first [construct](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c01) of a [Wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16) appears, the [distinctions](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) it makes have no [construct](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c01) in their material that is the content of its own [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18). Whether the content of a [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) later becomes a [construct](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c01) is another matter; see 6.1.\n\n**What the physical world gives is not boundaries but asymmetries of [arrival](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)** (conclusion): by the definitions of [cut](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c23) and [individual](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c20), the same stretch of the [universe](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c02) may be drawn as one or as many, and either holds; grouping many things each drawn as one into a class is drawing once more on these boundaries. By the definition of [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18), what [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) draws are all boundaries of this kind: which [presentations](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c04) are regarded as one, which stretch is regarded as the past, and whether a [Wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16) at different [moments](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c09) is regarded as the same one or two. Regarding a stretch as the past is regarding a stretch as one; regarding a [Wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16) at different [moments](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c09) as the same one is, by the definition of [identity](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c21), also regarding certain [presentations](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c04) as one. So the objects that the content of [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) points to are none of them given directly by the physical world. But the physical world gives asymmetries of [arrival](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10), for example cell membranes and skin; some [cuts](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c23) happen to fall on such asymmetries, and so are especially useful.\n\n**[Constructs](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c01) and the physical [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) that carries them**: the object of a [construct](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c01) is not required to have an independent physical entity, but the sounds, writing, gestures, containers and actions that carry it are all physical [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28). A researcher's merely renaming a symbol does not change the physical [history](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13) of the one studied; the [Wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16) concerned actually changing a sentence is another physical [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28).\n\n**[Definitional Isolation and Renaming Invariance](concepts.md#c06)**: this paper records: an [illusory construct](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c01) acquires theoretical meaning only through explicit definition, conditions of application, rules of combination and registrable criteria; natural-language names bring in no good or evil, purpose, causation, magnitude or psychological content.\n\n### 2.2 Terms and Notational Conventions\n\n- **[Structure](concepts.md#c07)**: the usable and changeable parameters, connections, neural structures, dynamic states and the like on a carrier. The indicator that measures it is [structure capacity](concepts.md#c17) (3.2). This paper does not say \"weight capacity\", to avoid confusion with upstream [branch](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c05) [weight](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06).\n- At the engineering layer this paper does not use \"weight\", \"computation\", \"configuration\" or \"update\" for engineering things or acts, because these four words mean something else upstream; wherever the text links to upstream [computation](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c05), it means the upstream sense (Proposition Five). A mapping that takes one or more [representations](concepts.md#c34) as input and yields a [representation](concepts.md#c34), such as transformation, combination, comparison or advancing, this paper calls an [operation](concepts.md#c08); the indicator that measures it is [operation capacity](concepts.md#c14) (3.2).\n- \"Writing\" is used only in the upstream sense; content entering a [signal container](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c26) this paper calls [explicit listing](concepts.md#c09).\n- **[Signal containers](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c26) are not limited to writing** (premise): by the definition of [signal container](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c26), the only conditions are not being a [Wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16) and being [locked in](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c12) at every step from this [moment](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c09) on; lasting is not a condition. On this basis, this paper records spoken words, broadcasts and television as [signal containers](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c26) once they have left the speaker. By the definition of [claimed boundary](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c10), [outputs](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) whose content is a classification include [avowals](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c06), declarations classifying people or things, and classifications written into a [signal container](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c26); the three are divided by different standards: [avowal](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c06) by object, classification declaration by content, writing into a [signal container](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c26) by carrier; the three can overlap, and a spoken [avowal](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c06), once it has left the speaker, is also in a [signal container](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c26).\n- **[Class illusory construct](concepts.md#c10)**: an [illusory construct](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c01) obtained by further [lumping](concepts.md#c23) the results of [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18).\n- **[Record](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c06) scope**: this paper records: only physical changes in [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) are registered, not the content of [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18). [Distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) is in the [history](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13) of the [Wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16) that makes it, not in this paper's [record](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c06).\n- \"Physical world\" and \"response\" are used in their everyday senses. \"Response\" refers to the kind of [arrival](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) and [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) that the researcher does not class as [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18).\n- When the engineering layer speaks of the one studied, the subject is \"Wo\", not \"individual\".\n- \"Construct\" is short for [illusory construct](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c01). This paper does not use the word \"concept\" for a [construct](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c01) or a [representation](concepts.md#c34), to avoid bringing in essentialist presuppositions.\n- When this paper says a [node](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25) performs [compression](concepts.md#c31), [operation](concepts.md#c08) or [inference](concepts.md#c36), it always means that the researcher reads its [rounds](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c04) as [compression](concepts.md#c31), [operation](concepts.md#c08) or [inference](concepts.md#c36) (5.3, Proposition Five); when it says a [node](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25)'s [round](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c04) is [computation](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c05), it uses upstream [computation](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c05).\n- \"Self\" in quotation marks means the name \"self\" as a [construct](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c01); linked without quotation marks, it means upstream [self](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19).\n- \"Appear\", \"involve\", \"speed\", \"frequency\", \"given\", \"accumulate\", \"select\", \"update\", \"environment\", \"side\", \"one side\", \"boundary\", \"same\" in uses such as the same one or the same set, the verb \"decide\", \"conflict\", \"threshold\", and \"antecedent\" when not referring to a [path](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c07) condition, are used in this paper in their everyday senses, not for the upstream concepts of the same name. \"Slide rule\", \"calculator\" and \"calculation\" in celestial mechanics are also everyday words.\n- What this paper calls [current artificial intelligence](concepts.md#c11) means the class of [nodes](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25) stated in 9.2.\n- \"Case\" in uses such as saying that an [empirical premise](concepts.md#c01) is calibrated from cases and can be revised or overturned by new cases, \"compare\" in uses such as comparing a copy with [arrivals](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) or comparison at the level of distributions, and the verb \"represent\" (as in \"only represents\" or \"what is represented\") and the verb \"infer\", are used in their everyday senses, not for this paper's concepts of the same name.\n- \"Cannot be derived\" in this paper means: from the sources and [record](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c06) this paper lists, no unique result can be derived; it does not claim that nothing can be derived under any condition or from any material. \"Not uniquely derived\" is the same.\n- Speech, names and quotations inside quotation marks are written as they are, without links; links are added only where this paper uses these concepts.\n\n### 2.3 Distinctions and Outputs Return to Oneself\n\n**Premise**: This paper assumes that a [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) of a [Wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16) and an [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) of it [arrive](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at this [Wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16) itself before the next [moment](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c09), and participate in its later [weight](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06). Among upstream concepts, the [Wall of the Blind Spot](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c09) and the [Wall of Provenance](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c08) state that a [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) [arrives](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at oneself only for [distinctions](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) whose object is oneself, and do not state that it does so before the next [moment](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c09); the definition of [small loop](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c02) describes this kind of [loop](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c31), but does not say that every [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) and [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) [arrives](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at oneself through it. This paper generalizes it to all [distinctions](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) and [outputs](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28), as a premise.\n\n---\n\n## 3. Engineering Capacities\n\n> This section selects five [engineering capacities](concepts.md#c12) as tools for describing a carrier. They are not necessary and sufficient conditions for a [Wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16), do not exhaust the capacities of a [Wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16), and are not further laws. The necessary conditions this paper states in terms of them are [Empirical Premises](concepts.md#c01) One to Three of Section 10. [Current artificial intelligence](concepts.md#c11) and living things are only compared; it is not claimed that their inner mechanisms are the same.\n\n### 3.1 Limited Reception\n\n**Premise**: Physical events in reality involve a great many different states, relations, scales and [histories](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13); any actual sense organ, sensor or performer of [compression](concepts.md#c31) can receive only part of them; for any [target](concepts.md#c25), the physical events involved in its [own segment](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c17) cannot all be received either. Different modalities are not different base dynamics; they differ only in the source, form, measurable range and manner of representation of the signal. \"Reality is nearly infinitely high-dimensional\" is only an intuition: before a state space, a definition of dimension, a measurement window and encoding rules are specified, it is not a theorem.\n\n**Conclusion**: Information that has not been obtained is not guaranteed to be reconstructible from existing input alone. The researcher also reads the [rounds](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c04) of the senses themselves as first selecting, [operating](concepts.md#c08) and [compressing](concepts.md#c31); \"first\" is an analytic distinction, not a fixed pipeline order.\n\n**Conclusion**: How much capacity a [Wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16) needs, and whether this can be reduced to a few dimensions, cannot be derived: by the definition of [Wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16), the whole [history](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13) that [arrives](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) participates in [weight](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06); by the definition of [impact](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c47), the effect of an [arrival](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) depends on the [history](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13) before it, and cannot be added up. A researcher's quantification of the capacity of a [Wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16), as a statistical estimate of a [Wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16), is, by the definition of [impression](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c45), an [impression](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c45), not a reading of the capacity itself.\n\n### 3.2 Five Engineering Capacities\n\n**Premise**: This paper describes a carrier by the following five [engineering capacities](concepts.md#c12). Each is an indicator, measuring to what degree a carrier can perform a certain kind of act or a certain kind of retention; the acts themselves and the things on the carrier are referred to by this paper's other definitions (2.2, 5.3).\n\n| [Engineering capacity](concepts.md#c12) | What it measures | What may happen when it falls short |\n|---|---|---|\n| **[Containment capacity](concepts.md#c13)** | Within a given structure, how many input differences and their relations can be distinguished, represented and handled at the same time | Different real conditions are mapped to the same [representation](concepts.md#c34) |\n| **[Operation capacity](concepts.md#c14)** | Within limited resources and time, how many and how fast [operations](concepts.md#c08) can be performed on [representations](concepts.md#c34): transforming, combining, comparing, advancing | Delay, blocking, timeout, discarding data |\n| **[Memory capacity](concepts.md#c15)** | How much earlier input, state or [operation](concepts.md#c08) results can be retained and later retrieved | Past differences cannot be retained or retrieved |\n| **[Compression capacity](concepts.md#c16)** | When re-representing information with limited resources, how many of the differences needed for a specified use can be kept | Necessary differences are not kept; later discrimination or [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) becomes inaccurate |\n| **[Structure capacity](concepts.md#c17)** | The degree to which existing [structure](concepts.md#c07) takes part in forming [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28); with [learning](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c04), how much [structure](concepts.md#c07) can change with [history](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13) and feedback | [Output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) does not meet the specified criterion; [structure](concepts.md#c07) becomes rigid |\n\nNote: When what is measured is a [Wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16), the researcher's statistical estimates of these indicators are, by the definition of [impression](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c45), [impressions](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c45) (3.1).\n\n### 3.3 Interacting, Not a Production Line\n\n**Conclusion**: The five are not steps executed in sequence; they are not a linear chain. One mechanism can fall at once on aspects measured by several indicators, for example parameterized [compression](concepts.md#c31), or allocation of attention influenced by memory. This is an analytic relation, not the layer-by-layer execution flow of a particular network, and it does not replace the upstream definition of [round](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c04).\n\n### 3.4 What Can and Cannot Be Derived\n\n- **Conclusion**: From the definition of [Wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16): the [history](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13) that [arrives](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) all participates in [weight](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06), and at least at some [moments](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c09) it is not [locked in](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c12). This is dependence, not [representation](concepts.md#c34); it does not imply that there is any findable trace or [representation](concepts.md#c34) on the carrier.\n- **Premise**: Under a specified [cut](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c23), when the researcher describes the carrier state of a [Wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16), if the carrier is finite, then in any stated finite description there must be cases where different [arrivals](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) correspond to the same described state. This is a [compression](concepts.md#c31) the researcher makes at the layer of carrier description; it does not imply that those [arrivals](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) no longer participate in [weight](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06).\n- **Conclusion**: Whether a [Wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16) with some capacity below some degree will fail to persist within a stated time window cannot be derived: this paper does not specify which capacity, what degree, what external conditions and what time window, so it does not set this up as an [empirical premise](concepts.md#c01). By [conditioning on existing samples](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c14), the performance of those that persist is not enough to derive \"the stronger the capacity, the better the persistence\".\n\n### 3.5 Structure and Upstream Weight; the Bounds of \"Correct\"\n\n**Conclusion**: Upstream [weight](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06) is how heavy a [branch](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c05) is (the definition of [weight](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06)); engineering [structure](concepts.md#c07) is a summary of parameters, connections, dynamic states and changeability, and is not upstream [branch](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c05) [weight](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06), nor desire or purpose. This paper does not treat any engineering quantity as an already measured [weight](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06) of some [Wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16).\n\nA wrong [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) may come from insufficient reception, lost [representation](concepts.md#c34), insufficient [operation capacity](concepts.md#c14), insufficient [memory capacity](concepts.md#c15) or improper [compression](concepts.md#c31); it does not necessarily come from [structure](concepts.md#c07). This paper calls an [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) \"correct\" only after the task, the object of comparison, the observable conditions, the [allowed error](concepts.md#c56) and the evaluation time window have been given. One correct answer does not establish an inner capacity of the same name, and one wrong answer does not settle which capacity fell short.\n\n---\n\n## 4. Question One: The Functions of Constructs\n\n### 4.1 What Function Means\n\n**Definition**: When this paper says that a [construct](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c01) has a certain [function](concepts.md#c18), it means that without this kind of [construct](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c01), a certain kind of [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) [never occurs](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c01). This states only a necessary condition; it does not mean a purpose, nor does it claim that with the [construct](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c01) that kind of [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) will occur.\n\n### 4.2 Constructs and Mere Distinction\n\n**Conclusion**: By 6.1, a [construct](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c01) is the content of a [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18), and it has an object it points to. When the content of a [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) only participates in later [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) and is not used to point at some object, this paper calls it [mere distinction](concepts.md#c19), not a [construct](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c01). By the definition of [Wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16), the [history](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13) that [arrives](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) all participates in its [weight](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06); this participation is not conditioned on an object pointed to. The difference between the two lies not in participation but in whether there is an object pointed to.\n\nCalibration: A baker makes bread by feel, habit and experience: past experience participates in his present movements, the feel points at nothing, and this is [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) and [learning](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c04); he may be unable to write an essay, and the bread is still good. When he wants to teach an apprentice, he writes the steps down in terms such as \"proofing\", \"gluten strength\" and \"folding\", each of which points at something: only then do the [constructs](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c01) appear in his [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28). Before that, these [constructs](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c01) had not appeared in his [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28); whether he had them inside cannot be derived from outside (4.3, note 5). Likewise: a person climbing a mountain walks toward that tree, and this is [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18); saying to a companion \"that tree is our goal\", even once, makes \"that tree\" a [construct](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c01). Walking along a minefield without stepping in is [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18); thinking at home \"the minefield is east of the river\", or telling someone \"there are mines over there\", is a [construct](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c01).\n\nThe main conclusion of this question is the one above. The following three [functions](concepts.md#c18) are [outputs](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) that exist only once there is an object pointed to.\n\n### 4.3 Three Functions\n\n**Conclusion**:\n\n1. **[Reference](concepts.md#c20)**: without [constructs](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c01), it is impossible, when [what is seen](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c27) is not present, to have a content point at it and take part in organizing [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) (2.1). For a content to point at some object is to regard certain [presentations](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c04) as one object; by the definitions of [cut](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c23) and [individual](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c20), this object is not given directly by the physical world, so when such content is used to organize [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28), by the definition of [illusory construct](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c01) it is a [construct](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c01).\n2. **[Inference](concepts.md#c36)**: without [constructs](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c01), it is impossible to combine the content of a [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) with other content and derive new content about what has not yet [arrived](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10). The result of [inference](concepts.md#c36) points at [what is seen](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c27) that has not yet [arrived](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10); without an object pointed to, there is no content that can be combined and carried forward. Reading a stretch of [rounds](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c04) as [inference](concepts.md#c36) also uses the [constructs](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c01) of the [Wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16) that reads it (5.3, Proposition Five).\n3. **[Transmission between Wo](concepts.md#c21)**: without [constructs](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c01), among the [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) that [arrives](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at others, there is no [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) pointing at some object. What [arrives](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at others is [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28), which by the definition of [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) may contain the content of [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18). By the definition of [arrival](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10), what [arrives](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at others is the part of a [writing](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c29) that falls on it as a [stimulus](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c30); by the definitions of [writing](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c29) and [stimulus](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c30), the [writing](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c29) left by a [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) can also fall on others as a [stimulus](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c30), but what falls on others is this [writing](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c29), not the act of [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18). By the definition of [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18), the material of a [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) is only the [history](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13) that has already [arrived](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at it, so a [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) that others make from the [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) that [arrives](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at them is their own [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18). If names, marks and a patch on a map are read as [outputs](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) that point at some object, then for the same reason, the objects they point to are not given directly by the physical world, and such [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) is, by the definition of [illusory construct](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c01), a [construct](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c01) appearing in [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28).\n\nNotes:\n1. **Participating and being used**: by the definition of [Wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16), the [history](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13) that [arrives](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) all participates in [weight](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06), and this participation need not be findable. [Mere distinction](concepts.md#c19) still leaves [writings](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c29) and still participates in later [weight](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06); the baker's feel and the boundary of the minefield go on participating in that person's [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28). What is missing without [constructs](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c01) is not participation but pointing at some object.\n2. **Correspondence at the engineering layer**: at the engineering layer, content that has an object pointed to corresponds to [representations](concepts.md#c34) that can [arrive](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) again and be processed (5.3). By the finite reception of 3.1, what a [representation](concepts.md#c34) produced by [compression](concepts.md#c31) is based on is not the whole of the [target](concepts.md#c25)'s [own segment](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c17); by the premise of 3.4, under a finite description of the carrier, the researcher reads content retained across [moments](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c09) as a [compression](concepts.md#c31) at the descriptive layer. This is a correspondence, not a derivation: the two layers do not derive each other (5.1).\n3. **Neither names nor number of times is a condition**: \"you\", \"I\" and \"it\" are not names of anything; the object pointed to differs each time, and what is pointed at is a position: the speaking side, the side spoken to, the thing pointed at. \"That tree is our goal\", said only once, is also a [construct](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c01) (6.1).\n4. Once these [functions](concepts.md#c18) exist, whether [inference](concepts.md#c36) fits later [arrivals](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) is another question, settled by being [commutative](concepts.md#c55) (5.3); a [construct](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c01) can go on being used even if it does not fit (8.2).\n5. In the baker and climbing examples, the [constructs](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c01) appear in [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) only when [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) is to [arrive](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at others: nothing is said when one person works or walks alone, and they are spoken only when teaching someone or having a companion. [Constructs](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c01) can be [transmitted between Wo](concepts.md#c21) through [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) (7.1); but when nothing is said, by the [record](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c06) scope (2.2) there is only [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) in the [record](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c06), and from outside it cannot be derived whether this [Wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16) has this [construct](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c01) inside; what can be determined is only whether it has appeared in [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28).\n\n---\n\n## 5. Compression and Commutativity\n\n### 5.1 Discrimination, Lumping and the Material of Compression\n\n**Conclusion**: [Distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) adds one thing to mere dependence: drawing a boundary and regarding certain [arrivals](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) as one (the definition of [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18); this paper reads one [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) as: there are [arrivals](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) on both sides of the boundary, and at least one side regards more than one [arrival](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) as one, a premise). This requires [discrimination](concepts.md#c22) and [lumping](concepts.md#c23) together: [discrimination](concepts.md#c22) is different [arrivals](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) falling on different sides, and [lumping](concepts.md#c23) is different [arrivals](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) falling on the same side. [Lumping](concepts.md#c23) is the content of a [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18); [compression](concepts.md#c31) is the researcher's reading of [rounds](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c04) (5.3); the two are not the same.\n\n**Conclusion**: The two layers do not derive each other: a [representation](concepts.md#c34) is the content that an engineering-layer reading points to, while a [construct](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c01) is the content of [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) at the content layer. From there being a [representation](concepts.md#c34) on the carrier, it cannot be derived that there is a [construct](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c01); from the researcher's attributing some [construct](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c01), it also cannot be derived that a corresponding [representation](concepts.md#c34) can be found on the carrier. By 3.4, the definition of [Wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16) does not imply that there is any findable [representation](concepts.md#c34) on the carrier; by note 5 of 6.1, whether a content has an object pointed to is the researcher's attribution, and may be misattributed.\n\n**Conclusion**: [Compression](concepts.md#c31) brings no material of its own: the material that can be [compressed](concepts.md#c31) is limited by [arrival](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) and [containment capacity](concepts.md#c13); comparing and combining are limited by [operation capacity](concepts.md#c14); retaining and retrieving again are limited by [memory capacity](concepts.md#c15). This is not a sequence of production steps. On the assumption that other conditions are fixed and that raising one capacity does not harm the other indicators, the range of [representations](concepts.md#c34) that can be formed may expand; but whether a given [representation](concepts.md#c34) actually appears is still affected by the concrete [history](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13), input and [structure](concepts.md#c07), and cannot be derived directly from the raising of capacity.\n\n### 5.2 The Question\n\nBy 5.3, [compression](concepts.md#c31) turns [arrived material](concepts.md#c28) into a [representation](concepts.md#c34); by the finite reception of 3.1, [arrived material](concepts.md#c28) is not the whole of the [target](concepts.md#c25)'s [own segment](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c17), so what a [representation](concepts.md#c34) produced by [compression](concepts.md#c31) is based on is not the whole of the [target](concepts.md#c25)'s [own segment](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c17). [Compression](concepts.md#c31) takes only a part of reality. When the part taken is used for [inference](concepts.md#c36), why does it sometimes fit the later course of events and sometimes not? This section answers the question by writing a criterion in terms of [arrival](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10).\n\n### 5.3 The Criterion of Commutativity\n\n**Definition**: Everything below is under a [cut](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c23) stated by the researcher. Among them, [compression](concepts.md#c31) and [inference](concepts.md#c36) are readings the researcher makes of a [node](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25)'s [rounds](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c04); a [representation](concepts.md#c34) is the content these readings point to.\n\n- **[Case](concepts.md#c24)**: a [target](concepts.md#c25), and two time windows: an [earlier window](concepts.md#c26) and a [later window](concepts.md#c27), the [earlier window](concepts.md#c26) first. The [target](concepts.md#c25) is a [presentation](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c04).\n- **[Arrived material](concepts.md#c28)**: [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) about the [target](concepts.md#c25) that has [arrived](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at the one performing [compression](concepts.md#c31). [Arrived material](concepts.md#c28) within the [earlier window](concepts.md#c26) is called [earlier material](concepts.md#c29); material of the same kind within the [later window](concepts.md#c27) is called [later material](concepts.md#c30). By the finite reception of 3.1, [arrived material](concepts.md#c28) is not the whole of the [target](concepts.md#c25)'s [own segment](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c17).\n- **[Compression](concepts.md#c31)**: a [round](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c04) of a [node](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25) that the researcher reads as turning [arrived material](concepts.md#c28) into a [representation](concepts.md#c34). The [representation](concepts.md#c34) that actually falls out of [earlier material](concepts.md#c29) through [compression](concepts.md#c31) is called the [earlier representation](concepts.md#c32); what actually falls out of [later material](concepts.md#c30) through [compression](concepts.md#c31) is called the [later representation](concepts.md#c33). It is not required that the same material yields the same [representation](concepts.md#c34) every time.\n- **[Allowed error](concepts.md#c56)**: an upper bound on the distance between [representations](concepts.md#c34), such that two [representations](concepts.md#c34) whose distance does not exceed it count as the same within this bound; the distance between two [representations](concepts.md#c34) is no more than the sum of the two distances by way of a third [representation](concepts.md#c34).\n- **[Representation](concepts.md#c34)**: content that can [arrive](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) again, be processed, or be [explicitly listed](concepts.md#c09) in a [signal container](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c26).\n- **[Retained difference](concepts.md#c35)**: when the [representations](concepts.md#c34) that actually fall out of two pieces of [arrived material](concepts.md#c28) through [compression](concepts.md#c31) differ beyond the [allowed error](concepts.md#c56), this [compression](concepts.md#c31) is said to have retained the difference between the two.\n- **[Inference](concepts.md#c36)**: a stretch of [rounds](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c04) that the researcher reads as taking only a [representation](concepts.md#c34) and producing a new [representation](concepts.md#c34); if it also takes material other than the [representation](concepts.md#c34), it is not [inference](concepts.md#c36) on this [representation](concepts.md#c34).\n- **[Inference result](concepts.md#c37)**: the [representation](concepts.md#c34) that [inference](concepts.md#c36) produces with the [earlier representation](concepts.md#c32) as material.\n- **[Comparison](concepts.md#c38)**: whether the [inference result](concepts.md#c37) and the [later representation](concepts.md#c33) are the same within the [allowed error](concepts.md#c56).\n- **[Case attribution](concepts.md#c39)**: assigning the [earlier material](concepts.md#c29) and the [later material](concepts.md#c30) to the same [target](concepts.md#c25) is a [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18): by the definitions of [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) and [individual](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c20), [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) regards certain [presentations](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c04) as one [individual](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c20). This [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) is not obtained from the content of the [representation](concepts.md#c34), and is usually carried by [signal container](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c26) content such as a serial number. Judgments of being [commutative](concepts.md#c55) are relative to this [case attribution](concepts.md#c39).\n\n**Definition** (criterion): [Commutative](concepts.md#c55) means that [inferring](concepts.md#c36) with a [representation](concepts.md#c34) in place of reality yields the same result as what [arrives](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) afterwards, that is, the [inference result](concepts.md#c37) and the [later representation](concepts.md#c33) are the same within the [allowed error](concepts.md#c56); this can be judged for one [case](concepts.md#c24), for the registered [cases](concepts.md#c24), or for a stated range, which are, respectively, the following three:\n\n- **[Commutative on a case](concepts.md#c40)**: the [comparison](concepts.md#c38) comes out the same.\n- **[Commutative over registered cases](concepts.md#c41)**: for every registered [case](concepts.md#c24), the [comparison](concepts.md#c38) comes out the same.\n- **[Commutative within a range](concepts.md#c42)**: the researcher states a set of [cases](concepts.md#c24) and claims that the [comparison](concepts.md#c38) comes out the same for every [case](concepts.md#c24). This is a claim.\n\nThe criterion uses only [arrival](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10), [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28), [round](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c04) and [cut](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c23), and does not assume that any [node](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25) can directly obtain the [target](concepts.md#c25)'s [own segment](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c17).\n\nNote: If the one performing [compression](concepts.md#c31) is a [Wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16), the [representations](concepts.md#c34) that fall out of the same material may differ each time; this may make the [comparison](concepts.md#c38) come out differently, showing up as not [commutative](concepts.md#c55); by the [record](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c06) scope of 2.2, the [record](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c06) holds only [outputs](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28), so these differences can be seen in the [record](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c06) only when they fall on [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28).\n\nCalibration: Newtonian mechanics [compresses](concepts.md#c31) bodies by mass, position and velocity, and its [inference results](concepts.md#c37) agree with later observation; replace mass with color, and [inference](concepts.md#c36) can proceed just the same, but the results do not fit. Medical records: the records of two patients may be exactly the same in content; which patient is which is told by the record number, not by the content.\n\n### 5.4 Propositions\n\n**Proposition One: Lost Differences Cannot Be Recovered** (conclusion)\n\n> If the [earlier material](concepts.md#c29) of two [cases](concepts.md#c24) actually yields the same [earlier representation](concepts.md#c32), while their [later representations](concepts.md#c33) differ by more than twice the [allowed error](concepts.md#c56), and the two [cases](concepts.md#c24) use the same set of constraints, then [inference](concepts.md#c36) [locked in](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c12) on this [representation](concepts.md#c34) cannot be [commutative](concepts.md#c55) on both of these [cases](concepts.md#c24); for [inference](concepts.md#c36) not [locked in](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c12), being [commutative](concepts.md#c55) on both of these [cases](concepts.md#c24) is [not guaranteed](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c02).\n\nDerivation: Under the conditions of the proposition, the [representation](concepts.md#c34) that the [inference](concepts.md#c36) actually takes is the same in the two [cases](concepts.md#c24). If this stretch of [rounds](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c04) is [locked in](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c12), and the two [cases](concepts.md#c24) use the same set of constraints, then by the definition of [inference](concepts.md#c36) the [inference](concepts.md#c36) in both [cases](concepts.md#c24) takes only this [representation](concepts.md#c34), with no other material taking part; by the condition of the same set of constraints (10.1), the same input has the same [weight](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06) distribution; by the definition of [lock-in](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c12), only one result in this distribution has a nonzero [weight](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06), so the two [cases](concepts.md#c24) yield the same result; by the definition of the [allowed error](concepts.md#c56) (5.3), the distance between two [representations](concepts.md#c34) is no more than the sum of the two distances by way of a third [representation](concepts.md#c34); if this result equaled both [later representations](concepts.md#c33) within the [allowed error](concepts.md#c56), the two [later representations](concepts.md#c33) would differ by no more than twice the [allowed error](concepts.md#c56), contrary to the condition; if it is not [locked in](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c12), that both results are the same, within the [allowed error](concepts.md#c56), as their respective [later representations](concepts.md#c33) is [not guaranteed](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c02). Sources: the definitions of [inference](concepts.md#c36) and [comparison](concepts.md#c38) (5.3); the condition of the same set of constraints (10.1); the definitions of [lock-in](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c12) and [not guaranteed](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c02).\n\n**Proposition Two: However High the [Operation Capacity](concepts.md#c14), It Cannot Make Up Differences Lost in Containment** (conclusion)\n\n> If the differences needed for some change are not contained and are mapped to the same [representation](concepts.md#c34), and the [later representations](concepts.md#c33) this change produces differ by more than twice the [allowed error](concepts.md#c56), and the [cases](concepts.md#c24) use the same set of constraints, then however high the [operation capacity](concepts.md#c14), [inference](concepts.md#c36) [locked in](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c12) on this [representation](concepts.md#c34) cannot be [commutative](concepts.md#c55) on this change; for [inference](concepts.md#c36) not [locked in](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c12), being [commutative](concepts.md#c55) on this change is [not guaranteed](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c02). For [inference](concepts.md#c36) [locked in](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c12), only by obtaining material other than this [representation](concepts.md#c34), for example new [arrivals](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10), or other [representations](concepts.md#c34) retained earlier, is a remedy possible.\n\nDerivation: \"The differences needed for some change are not contained and are mapped to the same [representation](concepts.md#c34)\" means that, of the two [cases](concepts.md#c24) that this change distinguishes, which the researcher can tell apart by their [earlier material](concepts.md#c29) and [later representations](concepts.md#c33), the [earlier material](concepts.md#c29) actually yields the same [earlier representation](concepts.md#c32); \"[commutative](concepts.md#c55) on this change\" means [commutative](concepts.md#c55) on both of these [cases](concepts.md#c24); this is exactly the condition of Proposition One. An [operation](concepts.md#c08) takes [representations](concepts.md#c34) as input (2.2), and [operation capacity](concepts.md#c14) measures how many and how fast [operations](concepts.md#c08) can be performed on a [representation](concepts.md#c34) (3.2); when [operation capacity](concepts.md#c14) rises, an [operation](concepts.md#c08) can map this [representation](concepts.md#c34) into a new [representation](concepts.md#c34), but the material is still only this [representation](concepts.md#c34) and the differences it did not retain cannot be recovered, and Proposition One applies directly: [inference](concepts.md#c36) [locked in](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c12) cannot be [commutative](concepts.md#c55), and for [inference](concepts.md#c36) not [locked in](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c12) it is [not guaranteed](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c02); material other than the [representation](concepts.md#c34) is not within the limits of Proposition One. Sources: Proposition One; the definitions of [operation](concepts.md#c08), [operation capacity](concepts.md#c14) and [containment capacity](concepts.md#c13).\n\nNote: This is the first [engineering threshold](concepts.md#c53) in this paper derived from definitions. The five capacities cannot freely substitute for one another: differences lost in containment make a ceiling, not slowness.\n\n**Proposition Three: [Comparison](concepts.md#c38) Reaches Only [Cases](concepts.md#c24) That Have [Arrived](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)** (conclusion)\n\n> The [comparison](concepts.md#c38) any [node](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25) makes reaches only those [cases](concepts.md#c24) whose [later representation](concepts.md#c33) has already [arrived](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at it; this [later representation](concepts.md#c33) is what some compressor has made by [compressing](concepts.md#c31) the [later material](concepts.md#c30) that had already [arrived](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at the compressor itself, and the compressor need not be the [node](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25) making the [comparison](concepts.md#c38). What the [comparison](concepts.md#c38) rests on is the [representation](concepts.md#c34) that [arrived material](concepts.md#c28) yields under [compression](concepts.md#c31), not the [target](concepts.md#c25)'s [own segment](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c17). If the range stated by the researcher includes [cases](concepts.md#c24) that have not yet [arrived](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10), being [commutative within a range](concepts.md#c42) cannot be confirmed by [comparison](concepts.md#c38).\n\nDerivation: When any [node](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25) produces an [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28), what it takes is only what has already [arrived](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at it; when the [later material](concepts.md#c30) has not yet [arrived](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at any [compressor](concepts.md#c31), there is no [later representation](concepts.md#c33) that can [arrive](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at the [node](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25) making the [comparison](concepts.md#c38). By the finite reception of 3.1, [later material](concepts.md#c30) is not the whole of the [target](concepts.md#c25)'s [own segment](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c17). Sources: the definitions of [arrival](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) and [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28); the definitions of [comparison](concepts.md#c38) and [later representation](concepts.md#c33) (5.3); 3.1.\n\nNote: So a [compression](concepts.md#c31) being [commutative within a range](concepts.md#c42) is supported at most by the [cases](concepts.md#c24) that have [arrived](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10); new [arrivals](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) may overturn it later. A [compression](concepts.md#c31) being [commutative over registered cases](concepts.md#c41) only means that it matches the material that has already [arrived](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10); whether it has caught the regularity of the [target](concepts.md#c25) or merely matches this material cannot be told from [comparison](concepts.md#c38). This paper does not deal with this problem. If the range is exactly the registered [cases](concepts.md#c24), what being [commutative within a range](concepts.md#c42) claims is exactly being [commutative over registered cases](concepts.md#c41). This paper calls an [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) \"correct\" likewise only after the task, the object of comparison, the observable conditions, the [allowed error](concepts.md#c56) and the evaluation time window have been given (3.5).\n\n**Proposition Four: For a [Wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16) Not [Locked In](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c12) Whose Differing Results Fall on the [Compared](concepts.md#c38) [Representation](concepts.md#c34), Being [Commutative](concepts.md#c55) in a Single Result Is [Not Guaranteed](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c02)** (conclusion)\n\n> If the [target](concepts.md#c25) is a [Wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16), and there are [moments](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c09) between the [earlier window](concepts.md#c26) and the [later window](concepts.md#c27) at which it is not [locked in](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c12), and among the results those [moments](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c09) may produce there are two that differ by more than twice the [allowed error](concepts.md#c56) in the [later representation](concepts.md#c33) being [compared](concepts.md#c38), then for any [inference](concepts.md#c36), being [commutative](concepts.md#c55) in a single result is [not guaranteed](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c02).\n\nDerivation: By the [Law of the Black Box](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c25), no [Wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16) in the [universe](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c02) can, before that moment, uniquely derive the next [moment](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c09) of a [Wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16) that is not [locked in](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c12); what can be derived is only [weight](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06). By the definition of the [allowed error](concepts.md#c56) (5.3), if one [inference result](concepts.md#c37) equaled two [later representations](concepts.md#c33) within the [allowed error](concepts.md#c56), the two would differ by no more than twice the [allowed error](concepts.md#c56), contrary to the condition; so whichever result the [inference](concepts.md#c36) yields, at least one of these two possible results makes the [comparison](concepts.md#c38) come out different. Sources: the [Law of the Black Box](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c25); the definitions of the [allowed error](concepts.md#c56) and [comparison](concepts.md#c38) (5.3); the definition of [not guaranteed](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c02).\n\nNotes:\n1. When the researcher also makes a comparison at the level of distributions, for example comparing the inferred tendency with frequencies across many [cases](concepts.md#c24), such statistical estimates of a [Wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16) are, by the definition of [impression](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c45), [impressions](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c45). By the definition of [generating function](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c15), [weight](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06) is determined by the [history](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13) up to that time; by the [Law of Flux](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c24), the [history](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13) that [arrives](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at a [Wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16) differs at every [moment](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c09) from before that [collapse](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c08). Nothing in the framework asserts that the distribution of [weight](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06) will recur, so recurrence of the distribution is [not guaranteed](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c02), and being [commutative](concepts.md#c55) at the level of distributions is likewise [not guaranteed](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c02).\n2. Treating a concrete biological or social object as not [locked in](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c12) follows the [Application Assumption](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c50).\n3. The difference between exact laws and statistical regularities lies in whether the object's next [moment](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c09) is [locked in](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c12), not in whether the researcher tries hard. By the definition of [random source](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c27), when it is not [locked in](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c12), it too allows talk only of [weight](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06), so this difference is not limited to [Wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16).\n\n**Proposition Five: A [Node](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25) Whose [Rounds](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c04) Are [Computation](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c05) Need Not Make [Distinctions](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)** (conclusion)\n\n> For a [locked-in](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c12) [node](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25) such as a slide rule, its [rounds](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c04) are [computation](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c05). The researcher's reading this [computation](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c05) as [compression](concepts.md#c31) or [inference](concepts.md#c36) and reading the result as a number is a [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) made by the [Wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16) that reads it, and the [constructs](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c01) it uses, if any, are that [Wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)'s [constructs](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c01). So a [node](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25) whose [rounds](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c04) are [computation](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c05) need not make [distinctions](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18); the [constructs](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c01) that [inference](concepts.md#c36) requires, and those that [compression](concepts.md#c31) uses if any, are with the [Wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16) that reads it.\n\nDerivation: By the definition of [computation](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c05), a [locked-in round](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c25) is [computation](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c05). By 5.3, [compression](concepts.md#c31) and [inference](concepts.md#c36) are the researcher's readings of [rounds](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c04): regarding a stretch of [rounds](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c04) as one [compression](concepts.md#c31) or [inference](concepts.md#c36) is drawing a boundary and regarding certain [presentations](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c04) as one, which by the definition of [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) is a [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18), and [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) is an act of a [Wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16). The number read off is the content of this [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18); by 2.1, the objects that the content of [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) points to are none of them given directly by the physical world; if the number is used to point at some object and to organize the reader's later [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28), then by the definition of [illusory construct](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c01) it is a [construct](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c01). So what makes these readings and uses [constructs](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c01) is the [Wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16) that reads it; a [node](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25) whose [rounds](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c04) are [computation](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c05) need not make [distinctions](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18). Sources: the definitions of [computation](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c05), [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) and [illusory construct](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c01); 2.1; 5.3.\n\nNotes:\n1. [Rounds](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c04) that the researcher reads as [comparison](concepts.md#c38) may likewise be [computation](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c05); reading this [computation](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c05) as [comparison](concepts.md#c38), stating a range and claiming it [commutative](concepts.md#c55) is a [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) of the researcher.\n2. This proposition runs parallel to \"culture is not conditioned on distinction\" (7.6); for the control group, see 9.7.\n\n**Proposition Six: [Self-Consistency](concepts.md#c45) and Being [Commutative](concepts.md#c55) Do Not Imply Each Other** (conclusion)\n\n**Definition**: [Inference rules](concepts.md#c44): a description of [inference](concepts.md#c36), which can be [explicitly listed](concepts.md#c09) as a [template](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c14). [Self-consistency](concepts.md#c45): among the [inference rules](concepts.md#c44), no two give results on the same [representation](concepts.md#c34) that differ beyond the [allowed error](concepts.md#c56).\n\n> That the [inference rules](concepts.md#c44) are [self-consistent](concepts.md#c45) does not imply being [commutative](concepts.md#c55); being [commutative](concepts.md#c55) also does not imply that the [inference rules](concepts.md#c44) are [self-consistent](concepts.md#c45).\n\nDerivation: [Self-consistency](concepts.md#c45) concerns only the relations among the rules within the [inference rules](concepts.md#c44); being [commutative](concepts.md#c55) concerns [compression](concepts.md#c31) and later [arrivals](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10). Neither definition refers to the other. By the definition of [comparison](concepts.md#c38), [comparison](concepts.md#c38) looks at the [inference result](concepts.md#c37) the [inference](concepts.md#c36) actually yields and the [later representation](concepts.md#c33); if another rule in the [inference rules](concepts.md#c44) gives a different result on the same [representation](concepts.md#c34) and the [inference](concepts.md#c36) did not proceed by that rule, that result does not enter the [comparison](concepts.md#c38), so being [commutative on a case](concepts.md#c40), [commutative over registered cases](concepts.md#c41) or [commutative within a range](concepts.md#c42) does not exclude the [inference rules](concepts.md#c44) not being [self-consistent](concepts.md#c45). [Inference rules](concepts.md#c44) consisting of a single rule are necessarily [self-consistent](concepts.md#c45) by the definition of [self-consistency](concepts.md#c45); by Proposition One, when the [inference](concepts.md#c36) proceeding by this rule is [locked in](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c12), it cannot be [commutative](concepts.md#c55) on both of two [cases](concepts.md#c24) whose [earlier material](concepts.md#c29) yields the same [earlier representation](concepts.md#c32), with the same constraints, and whose [later representations](concepts.md#c33) differ by more than twice the [allowed error](concepts.md#c56), and the definition of [self-consistency](concepts.md#c45) does not exclude such [cases](concepts.md#c24). Sources: the definitions of [self-consistency](concepts.md#c45) and [inference rules](concepts.md#c44); 5.3; Proposition One of 5.4.\n\nCalibration: a mechanics using color as mass can be completely [self-consistent](concepts.md#c45) and yet not [commutative](concepts.md#c55); many practical rules of thumb are [commutative over registered cases](concepts.md#c41) and yet inconsistent with one another.\n\n### 5.5 Boundaries Belong to Distinction; Arrival and Dependence Are Not Rewritten by Distinction; Scope\n\n**Conclusion**: By 2.1, the physical world gives no boundaries, but gives asymmetries of [arrival](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10). By the definition of [compression](concepts.md#c31), where a [compression](concepts.md#c31) cuts is a [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18). By the upstream definitions, [arrival](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) is a [writing](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c29) falling on a [presentation](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c04), and an [own segment](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c17) is determined by dependence; and the content of [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) changes views, not [what is seen](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c27). By the definition of [history](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13), [history](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13) is only appended to, so where a [compression](concepts.md#c31) cuts does not rewrite existing [arrivals](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) and dependence. So being [commutative within a range](concepts.md#c42) and \"boundaries are not given by the physical world\" do not conflict: the same stretch of the [universe](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c02) can have many [cuts](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c23); whether a [compression](concepts.md#c31) under a given [cut](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c23) is [commutative](concepts.md#c55) is judged by [comparison](concepts.md#c38), and does not conflict with boundaries not being given by the physical world. Nor does this conflict with \"calling it a stand-in does not claim that what it stands in for exists\" in 2.1: that concerns the object of a [construct](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c01), while this concerns [arrival](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) and dependence.\n\nBeing [commutative](concepts.md#c55) holds only within a stated range. For [cases](concepts.md#c24) outside the range the constraints can differ, and this paper does not assume they are the same as inside it (1.1); so from being [commutative](concepts.md#c55) within one range it cannot be derived that it is [commutative](concepts.md#c55) within another. By Proposition Three, the range itself is a claim.\n\nCalibration: Newtonian mechanics becomes inaccurate when bodies move at speeds near that of light, because the relations at work there were dropped in [compressing](concepts.md#c31) by mass, position and velocity.\n\n### 5.6 Application: The Researcher's Compression with \"Self\"\n\n**Conclusion**: When the researcher has stated a [case](concepts.md#c24) whose [target](concepts.md#c25) is a [Wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16), and reads the [round](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c04) in which he describes that [Wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)'s [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) with [constructs](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c01) such as \"self\" as turning the [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) that [arrives](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at him into a [representation](concepts.md#c34) written with these [constructs](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c01), then by the definition of [compression](concepts.md#c31) this is one [compression](concepts.md#c31); whether it is [commutative](concepts.md#c55) is a separate matter, to be tested by the criterion of 5.3. For example, from \"it is maintaining itself\", [infer](concepts.md#c36) its [outputs](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) of repairing the boundary and regulating exchange between inside and outside, and then [compare](concepts.md#c38) them with the later [record](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c06). If \"inside the boundary\" does not coincide with the [own segment](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c17), this [compression](concepts.md#c31) may fail to fit on some [cases](concepts.md#c24); whether it is not [commutative](concepts.md#c55) still depends only on [comparison](concepts.md#c38): it can be judged only once the non-coinciding part makes a difference in the later [record](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c06).\n\nCalibration: viruses borrowing a cell's machinery to replicate; autoimmunity.\n\n---\n\n## 6. Question Two: How Illusory Constructs Are Generated\n\n### 6.1 Two Steps: From Dependence to Distinction, From Distinction to Construct\n\n**Conclusion 6.1**: From dependence to [construct](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c01) there are two steps: from dependence to [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18), and from [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) to [construct](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c01). Without [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18), there is no [construct](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c01) that is the content of its [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18); from there being [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18), it does not follow that there is a [construct](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c01).\n\nDerivation: By the definition of [illusory construct](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c01), a [construct](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c01) that is the content of a [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) has an object it points to, and this object is not given by the physical world. So without [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18), there is no [construct](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c01) that is the content of its [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18). When the content of a [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) only participates in later [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) and is not used to point at some object, it does not fit this definition; by the definition of [Wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16), the [history](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13) that [arrives](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) all participates in its [weight](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06), and this participation itself has no object. So from there being [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18), it does not follow that there is a [construct](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c01). Sources: the definitions of [illusory construct](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c01), [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) and [Wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16).\n\nNotes:\n1. This conclusion agrees with \"a distinction may use constructs, or may not\" in 2.1: that concerns whether, at the moment the [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) is made, existing [constructs](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c01) are used as material.\n2. Neither number of times nor names is a condition. Two common manifestations of [constructs](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c01): pointing at what is not present (2.1), and appearing in [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) that is spoken or written down (the second way of appearing listed in the definition of [illusory construct](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c01)).\n3. Merely treating different things as one class is [lumping](concepts.md#c23) within [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) (5.1), not a [construct](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c01). A baker judging different doughs \"ready\" every day is [lumping](concepts.md#c23) plus [learning](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c04) (4.2).\n4. What this paper calls abstraction means that a [construct](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c01) has an object it points to and can come away from what is in front of one; it does not mean grouping different things into one class.\n5. Whether a content has an object pointed to is the researcher's attribution: the content is the content of some [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) of the object, so judging whether it has an object pointed to first requires assigning some [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) of the object to this [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18); the [record](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c06) contains only [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) (2.2), so this assignment is made on the basis of [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28), is a [view attribution](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c02) (1.2), and may be misattributed. What the upstream guarantees is only participation in [weight](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06); by the definition of [Wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16), this participation need not be findable.\n6. [Mere distinction](concepts.md#c19) still leaves [writings](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c29) and participates in later [weight](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06) (4.3, note 1).\n\nCalibration:\n- Walking along a minefield, never stepping in at any step: the boundary takes part in action and has no object pointed to; this is [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18). Drawing a patch on a map, thinking at home \"the minefield is east of the river, so crossing means a detour\", telling someone \"there are mines over there\": \"minefield\" points at an object; this is a [construct](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c01).\n- Recognizing one's own dog every day: [lumping](concepts.md#c23) plus the participation of [history](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13); this is [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18). Calling it \"Blackie\" and asking \"where did Blackie go\": pointing at an object; this is a [construct](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c01).\n- \"You\", \"I\", \"it\": what is pointed to is a position, and the object differs each time; once spoken, it is a [construct](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c01). \"I went climbing yesterday\" points at yesterday's self, who is not present; treating the self at different [moments](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c09) as the same one corresponds to [cross-moment lumping](concepts.md#c49) on the [self ladder](concepts.md#c46) of 6.3.\n- The baker and the climb: see 4.2.\n\n### 6.2 The Pathway of Generation\n\n**Conclusion**: If the content of a [Wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)'s [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) becomes an [illusory construct](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c01), it can go through the following pathway: a [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) draws a boundary, in which [lumping](concepts.md#c23) regards certain [arrivals](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) as one; this [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) leaves a [writing](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c29), and the [writing](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c29) [arrives](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) through a [small loop](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c02) at the [Wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16) that made it; the content of this [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) is used to point at some object, for example pointing at it when it is not present, or appearing in [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) that is spoken or written down; later [distinctions](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) take it as material and may [lump](concepts.md#c23) again. A [class illusory construct](concepts.md#c10) is a [construct](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c01) obtained by further [lumping](concepts.md#c23) the results of [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18), for example the \"we\" into which many \"I\"s are grouped.\n\nDerivation: The material of a [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) is only the [history](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13) that has already [arrived](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) before it, including one's own past [distinctions](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) (the definition of [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18); the premise of 2.3); this step follows 5.1 and 6.1; every round is an existing [round](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c04), and no further generative law is added (1.3).\n\nNotes:\n1. The material can come from outside. If names and classifications in others' [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) [arrive](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at this [Wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16), they can be its material; but the [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) made with this material is its own [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) (the definition of [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18); 4.3, point 3). The [arrival](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) of a name is not the transfer of a [construct](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c01).\n2. What is said here is \"if it is generated, through what\"; it does not claim that all the steps must be gone through, nor that the order is fixed.\n\n### 6.3 Necessary Conditions\n\n1. **[Illusory constructs](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c01) in general** (conclusion, by 6.1): without [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18), there is no [illusory construct](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c01) that is the content of its [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18); when the content of a [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) only participates in later [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) and is not used to point at some object, that content is not an [illusory construct](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c01).\n2. **[Class illusory constructs](concepts.md#c10)** (conclusion, by the definition of [class illusory construct](concepts.md#c10), 2.2): without further [lumping](concepts.md#c23) the results of [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18), there is no [class illusory construct](concepts.md#c10).\n3. **Necessary conditions of the [Self-Configuration Assumption](concepts.md#c04)** ([empirical premises](concepts.md#c01)):\n - Without retaining some copy of its own [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) (belonging to [memory capacity](concepts.md#c15)), or without checking the copy against subsequent [arrivals](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) (belonging to [operation capacity](concepts.md#c14)), there is no [self-other discrimination](concepts.md#c48) (Section 10, [Empirical Premise](concepts.md#c01) One);\n - Without retention across different [moments](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c09) (belonging to [memory capacity](concepts.md#c15)), or without [compressing](concepts.md#c31) the [arrivals](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) caused by oneself at different [moments](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c09) into one class (belonging to [compression capacity](concepts.md#c16)), there is no [cross-moment lumping](concepts.md#c49) (Section 10, [Empirical Premise](concepts.md#c01) Two).\n\nNote: The upstream guarantees only that [history](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13) participates in [weight](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06), not that traces remain on the carrier (3.4). Point 3 is written in the form of [empirical prohibition](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c51), stating only that without these it [never occurs](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c01), not that with them it occurs; they are calibrated from cases, and new cases may revise them.\n\n**[Self ladder](concepts.md#c46)**: the rungs below state only necessary conditions. In question two of 1.5, they are used only to negate the [Self-Configuration Assumption](concepts.md#c04); having all of them only means that this assumption has not been negated. The names of the rungs at the content layer ([discrimination](concepts.md#c22), [lumping](concepts.md#c23), identity) are the researcher's attributions.\n\n```text\nWo (own segment, determined by dependence)\n└─ Self-maintained filtering boundary ... physical asymmetry of arrival, needs no distinction (foundation of question one)\n └─ Distinction (discrimination + lumping)\n └─ Self-other discrimination ............ necessary condition of the momentary self\n └─ Cross-moment lumping, substitutivity ... necessary conditions of the continuing self\n └─ Second-order distinction, view attribution (7.7) ... necessary conditions of the social person (by configuration assumption)\n └─ Class illusory constructs ... we, you (plural)\n```\n\n\n- **[Self-maintained filtering boundary](concepts.md#c47)**: a structure, maintained by one's own [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28), that filters what can [arrive](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at oneself. This paper does not specify which kind of carrier, so this is written in general form; the cell membrane is an instance among living things. What it shapes is the [own segment](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c17), and the [own segment](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c17) is determined by dependence, not by [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) (the definition of [own segment](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c17)). So having a boundary such as a cell membrane does not imply that the cell has made a self-definition.\n- **[Self-other discrimination](concepts.md#c48)**: [discriminating](concepts.md#c22) the [arrivals](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) that come back to oneself into those caused by oneself and those not caused by oneself. By the premise of 2.3, every [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) and [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) comes back to the [Wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16) that made it; but the [arrivals](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) that come back to it carry no mark saying \"this was caused by oneself\".\n- **[Cross-moment lumping](concepts.md#c49)**: grouping the [arrivals](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) caused by oneself at different [moments](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c09) into one class. At the content layer, the researcher attributes it as upstream [identity](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c21).\n- **[Substitutivity](concepts.md#c50)**: the content is still used when the self is not present as a [stimulus](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c30).\n\nCalibration: [Self-other discrimination](concepts.md#c48): the reafference principle of von Holst and Mittelstaedt (1950); crickets suppressing their auditory response to their own chirps while chirping (Poulet and Hedwig, 2006); people cannot tickle themselves (Blakemore et al., 1998). That crickets have this mechanism shows that it is only a necessary condition. The continuing [self](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19): mirror self-recognition (Gallup, 1970); whether it can distinguish this is still disputed.\n\n### 6.4 No Guarantee\n\n**Conclusion**: Even with all the necessary conditions of points 1 and 2 of 6.3 present, the generation of [illusory constructs](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c01) is still [not guaranteed](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c02).\n\nDerivation: This paper does not write sufficient conditions (1.2): points 1 and 2 of 6.3 list necessary conditions, and no rule says that a [construct](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c01) is generated when they are present; by the definition of [not guaranteed](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c02), the framework does not assert that it necessarily happens. Moreover, by the [Application Assumption](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c50) and the [Law of the Black Box](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c25), the next [moment](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c09) of a [Wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16) that is not [locked in](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c12) cannot be uniquely derived in advance; this paper has no further rule that fixes, within it, whether a given [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) is made. Sources: the way of writing in 1.2; the definition of [not guaranteed](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c02); the [Application Assumption](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c50); the [Law of the Black Box](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c25).\n\nNote: The content of a [writing](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c29) is determined by the [history](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13) up to that time (the definition of [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)). This does not conflict with this conclusion: \"the history up to that time\" includes the results of earlier [collapses](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c08); among them, the results of a [Wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16) that is not [locked in](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c12) cannot, by the [Law of the Black Box](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c25), be uniquely derived in advance at an earlier point.\n\n### 6.5 Unconfirmability\n\n**Conclusion**: That an [illusory construct](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c01) is generated inside a [Wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16) is [not guaranteed](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c02) to be confirmable from outside; on this, the judgments this paper gives from outside are only negations.\n\nDerivation: [Distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) is not in this paper's [record](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c06) (2.2); the [Wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16) concerned saying the name of some [construct](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c01) is a physical [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28), from which it cannot be derived that it has a [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) of the same name inside (2.1); the researcher's classing this [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) as the subject's [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) is a [view attribution](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c02), which by the definition of [view attribution](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c02) may be misattributed. So confirming from outside that the subject has made a given [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) is [not guaranteed](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c02) (1.2).\n\nThe negative judgments given from outside are of two kinds: first, a mechanism is found proving that none of its [rounds](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c04) is a [decision](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c06); by 9.3 it is then not a [Wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16), and [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) is an act of a [Wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16) (the definition of [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)), so it has no [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18), and hence no [construct](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c01) that is the content of its [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) (6.1); second, it lacks one of the conditions listed in point 3 of 6.3, in [Empirical Premise](concepts.md#c01) One or Two, and the [Self-Configuration Assumption](concepts.md#c04) does not hold for it (1.5); this kind negates the [Self-Configuration Assumption](concepts.md#c04), not the generation of a [construct](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c01).\n\nNote: 6.4 and this conclusion are two different things. 6.4 is \"whether it will be generated\"; this one is \"if it is generated, whether it can be seen\".\n\n### 6.6 Class Illusory Constructs\n\n**Conclusion**: [Constructs](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c01) that are the content of [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) all come from a [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) that contains [lumping](concepts.md#c23) (5.1, 6.1); for example, this paper reads \"I\" as repeated [lumping](concepts.md#c23) of the [arrivals](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) caused by oneself at different [moments](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c09), and reads \"we\" and \"husband\" as further [lumping](concepts.md#c23) of the results of [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18), that is, as [class illusory constructs](concepts.md#c10). The researcher's description is the repeated grouping of a large amount of [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) into a few [distinctions](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18). At the engineering layer, what corresponds is repeated [compression](concepts.md#c31).\n\n**Conclusion**: Reprocessing and recursion: if [representation](concepts.md#c34) A is indeed retained, or forms [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) that can [arrive](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) again, it may take part in processing together with new [arrivals](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) or another [representation](concepts.md#c34) B, forming [representation](concepts.md#c34) C; it may also be lost, distorted or not adopted. The whole process is still existing [rounds](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c04), and no further generative law of \"abstract creation\" is added. Whether [compression](concepts.md#c31) is a pathway by which new [representations](concepts.md#c34) form from reprocessing existing [representations](concepts.md#c34) cannot be derived; this paper does not treat [compression](concepts.md#c31), [representation](concepts.md#c34) and [construct](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c01) as synonyms, nor does it claim that [representations](concepts.md#c34) necessarily increase, are necessarily correct, or that complexity necessarily rises.\n\n**Conclusion**: [Representations](concepts.md#c34) and [class illusory constructs](concepts.md#c10): when the content of a [representation](concepts.md#c34) is used to organize [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28), and the object it points to is not given by the physical world, the researcher's attributing it as an [illusory construct](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c01) that is the content of some [Wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)'s [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18), or, when it is a further [lumping](concepts.md#c23) of the results of [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18), as that [Wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)'s [class illusory construct](concepts.md#c10), is in either case a [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) by the researcher, made on the basis of [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28), and may be mistaken (5.1).\n\n## 7. Question Three: Conditions of Use\n\n### 7.1 Two Pathways of Use\n\n**Conclusion**: There are two pathways for using an [illusory construct](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c01): inside a [Wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16), the content of a [construct](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c01) [arrives](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) again through a [small loop](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c02) and participates in its later [distinctions](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) and [outputs](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28); between [Wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16), a [construct](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c01) is carried by physical [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) and [arrives](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at other [Wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16), possibly by way of other [nodes](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25).\n\nDerivation: By 2.1, an [illusory construct](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c01) has two ways of appearing: in the researcher's description, and in actual [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28). Inside a [Wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16), the [writing](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c29) of a [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) [arrives](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at the [Wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16) that made it (the premise of 2.3). Between [Wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16), by point 3 of 4.3, what [arrives](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at others is [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28), not the act of [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18).\n\nNotes:\n1. Between [Wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16), \"use\" is not the transfer of a [construct](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c01). A name [arriving](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at a receiver can be the receiver's material; if the receiver makes a [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) with it, that is the receiver's own [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) (6.2, note 1).\n2. [Output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) carrying a [construct](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c01) can enter a [signal container](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c26), including spoken words (2.2), and then [arrive](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) from the container at other [Wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16), including after the speaker is no longer present.\n3. [Output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) carrying content can also come from [nodes](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25) that are not [Wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16), for example [current artificial intelligence](concepts.md#c11). It has no [construct](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c01) that is the content of [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18); on stated dimensions, when its [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) [arrives](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at a [Wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16), the effect can be the same as that of [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) with which a [Wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16) uses a [construct](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c01) (9.1, note 2).\n4. A baker working alone does not say things in terms, and writes the steps in terms only when teaching; a person climbing alone does not say \"that tree\", and says it only with a companion (calibration of 4.2). When nothing is said, it cannot be derived from outside whether this [Wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16) has this [construct](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c01) inside; what can be determined is only whether it has appeared in [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) (4.3, note 5).\n\n### 7.2 Necessary Conditions\n\n1. **Use between [Wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)** (conclusion, by point 3 of 4.3 and the definition of [arrival](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)): if no physical [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) carrying the [construct](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c01) [arrives](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at the receiver, the [construct](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c01) does not have the [function](concepts.md#c18) of [transmission between Wo](concepts.md#c21).\n2. **Use inside a [Wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16) when [what is seen](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c27) is not present** ([empirical premise](concepts.md#c01)): without retention across [moments](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c09) (belonging to [memory capacity](concepts.md#c15)), the content of a [construct](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c01) cannot take part in organizing [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) when the [stimulus](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c30) is not present (Section 10, [Empirical Premise](concepts.md#c01) Three).\n\nNote: Point 1 is derived from definitions. Point 2 follows the form of [empirical prohibition](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c51), stating only that without it, it [never occurs](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c01).\n\n### 7.3 Templates and Their Execution\n\n**Conclusion**: From obtaining the same [template](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c14), it cannot be derived that those who obtain it turn [arrived material](concepts.md#c28) into [representations](concepts.md#c34) in the same way. What the researcher can register as \"the parties execute the template consistently\" lies only in the parties' [outputs](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28); if these [outputs](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) [arrive](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at one another within stated dimensions and time windows and repeatedly follow on compatibly, then by the definition of [resonance](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c09) this is [resonance](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c09).\n\nDerivation:\n1. A [template](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c14) is content [explicitly listed](concepts.md#c09) in a [signal container](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c26). The container is [locked in](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c12), and its content does not change by itself (the definitions of [template](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c14) and [signal container](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c26)).\n2. Turning new [arrivals](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) into the [representations](concepts.md#c34) the [template](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c14) uses is the obtainer's own [round](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c04). If the obtainer is a [Wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16), the whole [history](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13) that [arrives](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at it participates in this [round](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c04) (the definition of [Wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)), and the [template](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c14) is only one item in it; two [Wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16) obtaining the same [template](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c14) may differ in the rest of their [history](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13). Moreover, by the [Application Assumption](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c50), the obtainer is assumed not to be [locked in](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c12) in this [round](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c04); by the [Law of the Black Box](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c25), its next [moment](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c09) cannot be uniquely derived in advance. So from obtaining the same [template](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c14), it cannot be derived that the two [compressions](concepts.md#c31) are the same.\n3. A [template](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c14) can also [explicitly list](concepts.md#c09) a description of a way of [compression](concepts.md#c31). But applying this description is again the obtainer's own [round](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c04), and point 2 applies likewise.\n4. By the [record](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c06) scope of 2.2, the [record](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c06) contains only the [outputs](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) of the [Wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16), and cannot directly confirm the ways in which they turn [arrivals](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) into [representations](concepts.md#c34). If their [outputs](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) applying the [template](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c14) [arrive](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at one another within stated dimensions and time windows and repeatedly follow on compatibly, then by the definition of [resonance](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c09), this is [resonance](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c09).\n\nSources: the definitions of [template](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c14), [signal container](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c26), [Wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16) and [resonance](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c09); the [Application Assumption](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c50); the [Law of the Black Box](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c25); the [record](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c06) scope of 2.2.\n\nNotes:\n1. From obtaining a [template](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c14), it also cannot be derived that its scope of application, that is, the set of [cases](concepts.md#c24) on which it is [commutative](concepts.md#c55), is obtained: if the scope is not [explicitly listed](concepts.md#c09), it is not in the container; if it is [explicitly listed](concepts.md#c09), by the definition of [commutative within a range](concepts.md#c42) it is still only a claim. Calibration: Newton's laws are often taught as a [template](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c14), while the condition of application that speeds are far below the speed of light is often not written out.\n2. If \"resonance maintains consistency of execution\" means that [resonance](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c09) makes the parties' [compressions](concepts.md#c31) tend to agree, that is a causal claim, and cannot be derived. This conclusion says only: the consistency the researcher can register lies only in [outputs](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28); when these [outputs](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) [arrive](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at one another within stated dimensions and time windows and repeatedly follow on compatibly, it is [resonance](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c09).\n3. If the obtainer is a [node](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25) [locked in](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c12) at every step, point 2 does not apply: when two [locked-in](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c12) [nodes](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25) of the same [structure](concepts.md#c07) obtain the same [template](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c14), their [computations](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c05) are fixed by constraints and can be the same; reading these two [computations](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c05) as the same [compression](concepts.md#c31) is a [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) of the [Wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16) that reads them (Proposition Five). So when a [template](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c14) is passed on, the [computations](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c05) of [locked-in](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c12) [nodes](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25) of the same [structure](concepts.md#c07) can be consistent; the consistency of execution by [Wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16) is [not guaranteed](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c02).\n\nCalibration: two people take the same recipe; how each applies \"a pinch of salt\" and \"fry until golden\" depends on each person's whole [history](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13); two calculators of the same [structure](concepts.md#c07) running the same program, with the same input, give the same [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28). A baker writes the steps as terms and hands them to an apprentice; the apprentice, following them, still has to practice again and again and compare again and again with the master and the results before making the same bread: the terms passed on the [inference](concepts.md#c36), and execution has to be joined up in practice.\n\n### 7.4 No Guarantee\n\n**Conclusion**: Even with all the necessary conditions of 7.2 present, use is still [not guaranteed](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c02).\n\nDerivation: As in 6.4.\n\n### 7.5 Unconfirmability\n\n**Conclusion**: Whether a [construct](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c01) is used inside a [Wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16) to organize [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) is [not guaranteed](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c02) to be confirmable from outside; between [Wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16), what the [record](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c06) contains is only the [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) that carries it.\n\nDerivation: As in 6.5; 2.1.\n\n### 7.6 Comparison: Coordination Without Constructs, and Use Through Templates\n\n[Culture](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c13) is the case in which [Wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16) can follow on compatibly with one another even without [constructs](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c01); when [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) carrying [constructs](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c01) is [explicitly listed](concepts.md#c09) into a [signal container](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c26), it can become a [template](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c14); a [template](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c14) is one possible way in which [constructs](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c01) are used between [Wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16).\n\n1. **[Culture](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c13) is not conditioned on [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)** (conclusion): by the definition of [resonance](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c09), [resonance](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c09) is conditioned on [arrival](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10); by the definition of [culture](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c13), [culture](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c13) is the researcher's name for [resonance](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c09) appearing in a network; by the definition of [Wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16), whether a [presentation](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c04) is a [Wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16) has nothing to do with any [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18). So [culture](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c13) is not conditioned on the participants' making [distinctions](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18), still less on [constructs](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c01), [templates](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c14) or [second-order distinction](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c01). From there being [arrival](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10), it does not follow that there is [culture](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c13).\n2. **[Explicit listing](concepts.md#c09) is not limited to writing** (conclusion): by 2.2, the [explicit listing](concepts.md#c09) of a [template](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c14) can be writing down, and can also be speaking aloud, broadcasting or screening. So language falls on both sides at once: the parts that are said explicitly or recorded, for example the words in a sentence and rules stated orally, can be [templates](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c14), and whether they are is judged by the definition of [template](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c14) and the criterion the researcher specifies; the usages no one states, which follow on compatibly through repeated speaking, are named [culture](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c13) by the researcher if, under the [cut](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c23), dimensions and time windows the researcher specifies, they are [resonance](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c09) in a network; a feel for language, collocation and intonation are examples of such usages. By the definition of [template](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c14), a [template](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c14) is not a layer of [culture](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c13).\n3. **The [record](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c06) cannot reveal the inside** (conclusion): from there being a [template](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c14) in the [record](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c06), it cannot be derived that the [Wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16) that [explicitly listed](concepts.md#c09) it has a [construct](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c01) inside: by the [record](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c06) scope of 2.2, there is no [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) in the [record](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c06); by 2.1, from an [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) it cannot be derived that the speaker has a [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) of the same name inside.\n\nCalibration: a baker and apprentices working again and again in the same kitchen, joining up again and again, are on the side of [culture](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c13) if, under the specified [cut](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c23), dimensions and time windows, this is [resonance](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c09); the steps and terms he writes down can be on the side of [templates](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c14).\n\n### 7.7 First Order and Second Order\n\n**First order is not a gear** (conclusion): by the definition of [first-order distinction](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c24), [first-order distinction](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c24) acts according to the distinction between a view and [what is seen](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c27), but does not make this distinction. By the definition of [learning](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c04), [learning](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c04) is not conditioned on [second-order distinction](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c01); by the definitions of [resonance](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c09) and [Wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16) and point 1 of 7.6, [resonance](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c09) and [culture](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c13) are not conditioned on [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18). So neither [learning](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c04) nor [resonance](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c09) is conditioned on [second-order distinction](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c01); the definitions do not exclude a [Wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16) that has only [first-order distinction](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c24) from [learning](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c04), and from forming [resonance](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c09) with other [Wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16) through repeated [outputs](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28), [arrivals](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) and [outcome feedback](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c05).\n\n**The antecedent of [second-order distinction](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c01)** (conclusion): by the definition of [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18), the material of a [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) is only the [history](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13) before it that has already [arrived](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at it, and it itself is not among it. [Second-order distinction](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c01) takes one of one's own [distinctions](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) as its object, so that one is a [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) already made and already [arrived](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at it; this point follows the premise of 2.3: a [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) of a [Wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16) [arrives](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at this [Wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16) itself before the next [moment](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c09). This paper adds no further condition of \"remembering the content of that distinction\": by the definition of [history](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13), the [writing](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c29) left by a [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) already made is not erased, and still participates in [weight](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06); [second-order distinction](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c01) takes it as object, and the definition of [second-order distinction](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c01) requires only taking it as object, not being able to name its original content.\n\nCalibration: a person who does not remember when or why he began to fear dogs can still say \"my fear of dogs is only a view\".\n\n**[Social person](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c03)** (by the definition of [social person](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c03)): a [social person](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c03) is a biological person with [second-order capacity](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c02); calling a biological person a [social person](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c03) is done under the [configuration assumption](../paper_ae79e938_76e1_4bf9_b2ab_995c03e16c9e/concepts.md#c01). Calibration: ordinary adults widely use [constructs](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c01) such as \"we\" and \"you (plural)\"; an empirical reason of this kind is only a reason for adopting this configuration, not a proof of second-order inner [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18).\n\n**Relation to use**: apart from [we](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c04) and [plural you](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c05), which by definition are used by a [social person](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c03) and require the capacities for [second-order distinction](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c01) and [view attribution](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c02), the framework does not assert that [second-order distinction](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c01) or [view attribution](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c02) is a necessary or sufficient condition of the use of [constructs](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c01), nor the reverse; and what [view attribution](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c02) requires in engineering, cannot be derived.\n\n---\n\n## 8. Question Four: After Use\n\n### 8.1 Consequences Inside a Wo\n\n**Conclusion**: When a [construct](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c01) is used to organize [inference](concepts.md#c36), if the result of the [inference](concepts.md#c36) is [commutative over registered cases](concepts.md#c41), then on every registered [case](concepts.md#c24) the [inference result](concepts.md#c37) and the [later representation](concepts.md#c33) are the same within the [allowed error](concepts.md#c56); if it is not [commutative](concepts.md#c55), there are [cases](concepts.md#c24) that do not agree. When the disagreeing material [arrives](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at this [Wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16), it participates in its later [weight](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06); whether this [construct](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c01) therefore ceases to be used is [not guaranteed](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c02).\n\nDerivation: the criterion of 5.3; the definition of [outcome feedback](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c05) (consequences are brought back through later [arrivals](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)); the definition of [Wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16); the definition of [not guaranteed](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c02); the [Application Assumption](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c50); the [Law of the Black Box](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c25).\n\nNote: \"Interrupted\" and \"eliminated\" are only metaphors, with no purpose, and not guaranteed to happen.\n\n### 8.2 Continued Use Is Not Conditioned on Being Commutative\n\n**Conclusion**: From a [construct](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c01) not being [commutative](concepts.md#c55), it cannot be derived that it ceases to be used; when the [inference rules](concepts.md#c44) that use this [construct](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c01) are [self-consistent](concepts.md#c45) but not [commutative](concepts.md#c55), this [construct](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c01) can also go on being used.\n\nDerivation: Being [commutative](concepts.md#c55) is not among the conditions of use listed in 7.2. Disagreeing [later material](concepts.md#c30) still [arrives](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) and still participates in [weight](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06) (the definition of [Wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)); but by 8.1, whether the [construct](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c01) therefore ceases to be used is [not guaranteed](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c02). Moreover, by Proposition Three, [comparison](concepts.md#c38) reaches only [cases](concepts.md#c24) that have [arrived](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10): if the [inference](concepts.md#c36) of a [construct](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c01) has never been [compared](concepts.md#c38) with later [arrivals](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10), its not being [commutative](concepts.md#c55) does not appear in this [Wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)'s [history](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13) in the form of a [comparison](concepts.md#c38). By Proposition Six, [self-consistency](concepts.md#c45) does not imply being [commutative](concepts.md#c55), and being [commutative](concepts.md#c55) does not imply [self-consistency](concepts.md#c45). Sources: 7.2; 8.1; Propositions Three and Six; the definitions of [arrival](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) and [Wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16).\n\n### 8.3 Being Commutative and Continued Use\n\n**Conclusion**: The framework does not assert any relation, beyond that of 8.2, between being [commutative](concepts.md#c55) and whether a [construct](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c01) goes on being used; for example, whether, in domains where [outcome feedback](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c05) [arrives](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) frequently, [constructs](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c01) that are not [commutative](concepts.md#c55) are less often kept in use, cannot be derived.\n\n### 8.4 Consequences Between Wo\n\n**Conclusion**: [Constructs](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c01) [arrive](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at other [Wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16) through [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28), participate in their later [weight](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06), and may become material for their further [distinctions](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18). On the basis of these registered [outputs](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) and later [outputs](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28), the researcher may draw an [inside outside difference](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c09) in the [record](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c06); on the basis of those among them whose content is a classification, may draw a [claimed boundary](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c10); and comparing two [check windows](../paper_d244789a_9261_4a0d_a98a_feb8db56b511/concepts.md#c03), may record the difference between them as a [boundary shift](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c11). Whether any of these appears, and which way it goes, cannot be derived.\n\nDerivation: By 7.1, [constructs](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c01) are carried between [Wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16) by [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28); by the definitions of [arrival](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) and [Wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16), [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) that [arrives](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at a [Wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16) participates in its [weight](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06); by the definition of [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18), the material of a [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) is only the [history](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13) that has already [arrived](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at it, so these [outputs](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) may become material for the receiver's further [distinctions](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18). By the definitions of [inside outside difference](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c09), [claimed boundary](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c10) and [boundary shift](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c11), all three are [distinctions](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) the researcher makes on the basis of [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) in the [record](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c06), so whether they can be drawn depends on which [outputs](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) are registered in the [record](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c06), and on the [cut](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c23) the researcher states. By the [Application Assumption](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c50), the receiver is assumed not to be [locked in](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c12) at these [moments](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c09); by the [Law of the Black Box](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c25), what [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) it later produces cannot be uniquely derived in advance, so which way it goes cannot be derived.\n\nNote: Science can be described as such a network: it produces [templates](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c14) [commutative over registered cases](concepts.md#c41), and eliminates those that are not [commutative](concepts.md#c55) by [outcome feedback](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c05); scope and execution are maintained in the users' [resonance](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c09) (7.3). This is a way of describing, not a proposition derived by this paper.\n\n### 8.5 No Guarantee\n\n**Conclusion**: Which consequence follows after use is [not guaranteed](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c02).\n\nDerivation: As in 6.4.\n\n### 8.6 The Network Layer\n\nAfter [constructs](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c01) are used among many [Wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16) through [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28), how the complexity a network can sustain changes is not derived from the capacities of [Wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16) alone: population, division of labor, resources, the maintenance of [signal containers](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c26) and [templates](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c14), and the density of [arrivals](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) all take part. This paper does not deal with it.\n\n---\n\n## 9. Control Group: Current Artificial Intelligence\n\nThis section is the control group for the whole paper: [current artificial intelligence](concepts.md#c11) has [engineering capacities](concepts.md#c12), its [rounds](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c04) are [computation](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c05), and the researcher can read these [computations](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c05) as [compressions](concepts.md#c31) and [compare](concepts.md#c38) whether they are [commutative](concepts.md#c55), yet under the logical-state [cut](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c23) it is not a [Wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16). It belongs to none of the four questions, and is used to test the answers to each.\n\n### 9.1 Simulation\n\n**Definition**:\n\n> **[Simulation](concepts.md#c51)**: under a stated [cut](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c23) and dimensions, a [node](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25) that is not a [Wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16) whose [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28), by a criterion the researcher states, cannot be distinguished from the [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) of some [Wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16) or some class of [Wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16).\n>\n> **[Functional equivalence](concepts.md#c52)**: on stated dimensions, after this [node](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25)'s [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) [arrives](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at other [nodes](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25), the effects it has are the same as those of a [Wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)'s [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28). These effects include: participating in the receiver's [weight](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06); supplying or removing an [antecedent](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c08) of some [path](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c07) of the receiver; being read as carrying a content; and having as its [rounds](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c04) [computations](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c05) that the researcher reads as [commutative](concepts.md#c55) [inference](concepts.md#c36).\n\n**Conclusion**: [Current artificial intelligence](concepts.md#c11) is not a [Wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16); on certain dimensions stated by the researcher, if the effects stated depend only on the content of [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) on these dimensions, two [outputs](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) that are the same on these dimensions have the same effects when they [arrive](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at the same [Wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16), and in this sense it can be [functionally equivalent](concepts.md#c52) to a [Wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16).\n\n**[Empirical premise](concepts.md#c01)**: on certain dimensions stated by the researcher, the [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) of [current artificial intelligence](concepts.md#c11) cannot be distinguished from human [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) (Section 10, [Empirical Premise](concepts.md#c01) Four); this paper records humans as [Wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16) (Section 10), so on these dimensions, it is a [simulation](concepts.md#c51) of a [Wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16).\n\nDerivation:\n1. **Not a [Wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)**: by 9.3, under the logical-state [cut](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c23), none of its [rounds](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c04) is a [decision](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c06).\n2. **Can be [functionally equivalent](concepts.md#c52)**: by [Empirical Premise](concepts.md#c01) Four, on certain dimensions stated by the researcher, its [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) cannot be distinguished from human [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28); by the [Application Assumption](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c50) and this paper's setting (Section 10), humans are recorded as [Wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16). By the definitions of [arrival](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) and [Wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16), [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) that [arrives](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at a [Wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16) all participates in [weight](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06), regardless of which class of [node](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25) the source is. So if the effects stated by the researcher depend only on the content of the [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) on these dimensions, then when two [outputs](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) that are the same on these dimensions [arrive](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at the same [Wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16), they are the same in these effects, regardless of which class of [node](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25) the source is. By Proposition Five, a [node](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25) whose [rounds](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c04) are [computation](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c05) need not make [distinctions](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18); what reads the [computation](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c05) as [inference](concepts.md#c36), and judges whether it is [commutative](concepts.md#c55), is the [Wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16) that reads it. So on these dimensions, a [simulation](concepts.md#c51) and a [Wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16) can be [functionally equivalent](concepts.md#c52).\n3. **The judgment does not rest on [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)**: the [record](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c06) of [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) does not contain the kind of [round](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c04). So judging that it is not a [Wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16) rests on its design (9.2), not on [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28). The same holds for humans: humans are recorded as [Wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16) by the [Application Assumption](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c50) and this paper's setting (Section 10), not by [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28).\n\nNotes:\n1. [Functional equivalence](concepts.md#c52) holds only on stated dimensions, and is not guaranteed on all dimensions. On at least two dimensions the two are not guaranteed to be the same: its [locked-in rounds](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c25), when its constraints are determined only by [structure](concepts.md#c07) and state, can be passed on completely by copying, while for [Wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16) with different earlier [histories](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13) it cannot be derived that this is possible (9.6); and when copies of the same [structure](concepts.md#c07) that are [locked in](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c12) obtain the same [template](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c14), their [computations](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c05) can be identical, while the execution of [Wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16) being the same is [not guaranteed](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c02) (7.3).\n2. **[Current artificial intelligence](concepts.md#c11) and [constructs](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c01)**: by the definition of [illusory construct](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c01), a [construct](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c01) is the content of [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18), or a [construct](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c01) used in description and [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28); [current artificial intelligence](concepts.md#c11) has no [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18), so it has no [construct](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c01) that is the content of its own [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18). Its [outputs](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28), for example names, \"we\", or a patch on a map, can be read by the [Wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16) that reads them as carrying some content; these [outputs](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) [arrive](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at [Wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16) and can become material for [Wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16) to make [distinctions](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) and form [constructs](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c01). In the use of [constructs](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c01), on the stated dimensions, [current artificial intelligence](concepts.md#c11) can be a [functionally equivalent](concepts.md#c52) [simulation](concepts.md#c51): the effect of its [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) after [arriving](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at a [Wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16) can be the same as that of [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) with which a [Wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16) uses a [construct](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c01), with no [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) behind it.\n\n### 9.2 The Cut on Which the Judgment Rests\n\n**Premise**: This paper records: under the [cut](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c23) of logical state, for current digital artificial intelligence designed on a Turing-machine basis, every [round](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c04) is either a [locked-in round](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c25) or a [random round](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c26).\n\n**Premise**: This paper records: the carrier of [current artificial intelligence](concepts.md#c11) can perform the kinds of acts and retention measured by the five [engineering capacities](concepts.md#c12): distinguishing and handling input differences, performing [operations](concepts.md#c08) on [representations](concepts.md#c34), retaining and retrieving earlier states, re-representing with limited resources, and taking part in [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) with existing [structure](concepts.md#c07).\n\nNotes:\n1. This judgment rests on design facts, not on [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28). The [cut](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c23) is stated by the [self](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19) who makes the judgment.\n2. By the definition of [Wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16), whether a [presentation](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c04) is a [Wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16) has nothing to do with any [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18). So whether the physical carrier of [current artificial intelligence](concepts.md#c11) is a [Wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16) this paper does not judge; the conclusions of this section all hold under this [cut](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c23).\n3. For other physical bases, the judgment is made separately.\n\n### 9.3 Not a Wo Under This Cut\n\n**Conclusion**: A [presentation](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c04) none of whose [rounds](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c04) is a [decision](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c06) is not a [Wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16). So under this [cut](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c23), [current artificial intelligence](concepts.md#c11) is not a [Wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16).\n\nDerivation: By the definition of [decision](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c06), the [round](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c04) of a [Wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16) when it is not [locked in](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c12) is a [round](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c04) in which the whole [history](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13) that [arrives](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at it participates in [weight](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06), that is, a [decision](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c06). By the definition of [Wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16), a [Wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16) is not [locked in](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c12) at least at some [moments](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c09), and the [history](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13) that [arrives](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at it all participates in [weight](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06), so at least one [round](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c04) of a [Wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16) is a [decision](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c06). By 9.2, none of the [rounds](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c04) of [current artificial intelligence](concepts.md#c11) is a [decision](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c06). Sources: the definitions of [Wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16), [computation](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c05) and [decision](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c06); 9.2.\n\nNotes:\n1. This conclusion reads \"the history that arrives at it all participates in weight\" in the definition of [Wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16) as holding at every [moment](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c09); \"this participation may gradually fade, and once it has faded it is no longer a Wo\" in the definition supports this reading.\n2. [Lock-in](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c12) does not cut off participation: at a [moment](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c09) when a [Wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16) is [locked in](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c12) there is only one result, and the [history](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13) that [arrives](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at it still participates in its later [weight](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06). For example, a person tied up cannot move, but the experience of being tied still participates in his [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) after he is untied. So from a [presentation](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c04) sometimes being [locked in](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c12), it does not follow that it is not a [Wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16).\n3. That [current artificial intelligence](concepts.md#c11) is not a [Wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16) rests on its [rounds](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c04) that are not [locked in](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c12) all being [random rounds](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c26), not on its sometimes being [locked in](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c12). The two pure cases listed in the upstream [configuration assumption](../paper_ae79e938_76e1_4bf9_b2ab_995c03e16c9e/concepts.md#c01), namely that the [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) can fall out only of [locked-in rounds](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c25) or only of [random rounds](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c26), and the case mixing the two, all follow from this point.\n\n### 9.4 Its Place in the Classification of Nodes\n\n**Conclusion**: Under this [cut](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c23), with respect to a given [moment](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c09): if [current artificial intelligence](concepts.md#c11) is [locked in](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c12) at every step from this [moment](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c09) on, it is a [signal container](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c26) at this [moment](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c09); if at this [moment](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c09) or afterwards it still has [moments](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c09) at which it is not [locked in](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c12), it is a [random source](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c27) at this [moment](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c09).\n\nDerivation: By the definition of [node](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25), there are only three classes of [node](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25): [Wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16), [signal container](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c26) and [random source](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c27); by 9.3, it is not a [Wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16); it is then classified by the definitions of [signal container](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c26) and [random source](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c27).\n\nNote: By the definitions of these two classes, they cannot be the object of an [impression](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c45), and [cognitive obscuration](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c35) has no content for a [signal container](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c26). So statistical estimates made of the [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) of [current artificial intelligence](concepts.md#c11) are, under this [cut](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c23), not what the upstream calls [impressions](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c45).\n\n### 9.5 Outputs Can Be Similar, and on Arriving at a Wo They Likewise Participate in Weight\n\n**Conclusion**: On the dimensions stated in [Empirical Premise](concepts.md#c01) Four, [current artificial intelligence](concepts.md#c11) can produce [outputs](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) similar to those of a [Wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16); when these [outputs](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) [arrive](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at a [Wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16), they participate in the [Wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)'s [weight](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06) like any other [arrival](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10). On the stated dimensions, by [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) alone, a [Wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16) and its [simulation](concepts.md#c51) cannot be told apart (9.1).\n\nDerivation: By the definitions of [arrival](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) and [Wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16), the [history](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13) that [arrives](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at a [Wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16) all participates in [weight](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06), regardless of which class of [node](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25) the source is. The [record](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c06) of [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) does not contain the kind of [round](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c04); by the definition of [simulation](concepts.md#c51), on the stated dimensions, the [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) of a [simulation](concepts.md#c51) cannot be distinguished from that of a [Wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16).\n\nNote: Humans are recorded as [Wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16) by the [Application Assumption](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c50) and this paper's setting (Section 10), not by [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28). The researcher, or a person assumed to be a [self](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19) under the [Self-Configuration Assumption](concepts.md#c04), taking the [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) of [current artificial intelligence](concepts.md#c11) as \"its view\" is making a [view attribution](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c02), which may be misattributed. The [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) of [current artificial intelligence](concepts.md#c11) can describe a [cut](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c23), but that is content produced by [computation](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c05); the one who adopts and states it is the researcher.\n\n### 9.6 Ways of Processing Can Be Copied\n\n**Conclusion**: Between [locked-in](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c12) [nodes](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25) of the same [structure](concepts.md#c07) whose constraints are determined only by [structure](concepts.md#c07) and state, the way of processing [arrivals](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) can be passed on completely by copying the state; between two [Wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16) with different earlier [histories](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13), it cannot be derived that this can be done.\n\nDerivation:\n1. The next [moment](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c09) of a [locked-in](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c12) [node](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25) is fixed by constraints (the definition of [lock-in](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c12)). For two [locked-in](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c12) [nodes](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25) of the same [structure](concepts.md#c07), if their constraints are determined only by [structure](concepts.md#c07) and state, then when they are in the same state, the same [arrival](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) produces the same result; that constraints are determined only by [structure](concepts.md#c07) and state is an assumption about the [structure](concepts.md#c07) of the machine, not derived from definitions; that the state can be fully read out and copied into another machine of the same [structure](concepts.md#c07) is also an assumption about the [structure](concepts.md#c07) of the machine.\n2. By the definitions of [history](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13) and [Wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16), [history](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13) only extends forward, and the whole [history](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13) that [arrives](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at a [Wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16) participates in its [weight](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06). So any [arrival](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) only adds one more item to the [Wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)'s [history](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13); when it is still a [Wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16) after this [arrival](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10), its earlier [history](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13) still participates in its [weight](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06). The result in point 1 rests on assumptions about the machine's [structure](concepts.md#c07); this paper makes no such assumption about [Wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16), so if the earlier [histories](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13) of two [Wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16) differ, whether [arrivals](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) can make the ways they process [arrivals](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) the same cannot be derived.\n\nSources: the definitions of [lock-in](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c12), [history](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13) and [Wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16); the setting for machines listed in Section 10.\n\nNotes:\n1. Between machines of different [structure](concepts.md#c07), the content must first be turned into a form the other can use; the researcher reads this conversion as a [compression](concepts.md#c31), which is not guaranteed to be complete.\n2. With random [rounds](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c04), if each of the two copies produces its own result and they do not share one random outcome, their single results can differ. If the [weight](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06) of such a [node](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25) is determined only by its state and this [arrival](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10), then when the two copies, while their states are still the same, receive the same [arrival](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10), their [weight](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06) distributions are the same; this is an assumption about the [structure](concepts.md#c07) of the machine, not derived from definitions.\n3. By point 3 of 4.3, what [arrives](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at others is [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28), not the act of [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18); this conclusion shows that between [locked-in](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c12) [nodes](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25) of the same [structure](concepts.md#c07) whose constraints are determined only by [structure](concepts.md#c07) and state, the way of processing can be passed on by copying the state, not through [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28); between [Wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16) with different earlier [histories](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13), it cannot be derived that this can be done. Note 3 of 7.3 cites this conclusion.\n\n### 9.7 Having Engineering Capacities Does Not Imply Distinction\n\n**Conclusion**: [Current artificial intelligence](concepts.md#c11) can perform the acts and retention measured by the five [engineering capacities](concepts.md#c12) (9.2), its [rounds](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c04) are [computation](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c05), and the researcher can read these [computations](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c05) as [compression](concepts.md#c31) and [inference](concepts.md#c36) (Proposition Five), and [compare](concepts.md#c38), over the registered [cases](concepts.md#c24), whether they are [commutative](concepts.md#c55); yet under this [cut](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c23) it is not a [Wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16) and has no [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18). So from [computations](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c05) being read as [compression](concepts.md#c31) and [inference](concepts.md#c36), or from having [engineering capacities](concepts.md#c12), it cannot be derived that there is [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18).\n\nDerivation: Proposition Five; 9.3; the definition of [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) ([distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) is an act of a [Wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)).\n\n### 9.8 Engineering Threshold and Observer Recognition Threshold\n\n**Definition**: [Engineering threshold](concepts.md#c53): with a specified architecture and resources, whether a certain kind of [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) can be produced stably under specified conditions. [Observer recognition threshold](concepts.md#c54): when outsiders begin to label this kind of [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) as \"intelligent\", \"understanding\" or \"having [second-order capacity](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c02)\".\n\n**Conclusion**: That an [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) meets the criterion does not license inferring back to inner [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18), understanding or consciousness (9.5). The framework does not assert that crossing one of the thresholds means crossing the other.\n\nCalibration: commonly, trained models run with existing parameters and are not updated in each conversation; intermediate states and the distribution of [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) still change with input.\n\n---\n\n## 10. Premises, Empirical Premises and Failure Conditions\n\n### 10.1 Premises\n\nPremises are this paper's settings, not claims that can be overturned:\n\n- The researcher has no position outside [history](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13); the researcher is a [self](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19) (1.4).\n- The [Self-Configuration Assumption](concepts.md#c04) (1.5).\n- [Distinctions](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) and [outputs](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) [arrive](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at the [Wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16) that made them before the next [moment](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c09) (2.3).\n- The reading that [signal containers](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c26) are not limited to writing (2.2).\n- The [record](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c06) scope: only physical changes of [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) are registered, not the content of [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) (2.2).\n- [Definitional Isolation and Renaming Invariance](concepts.md#c06) (2.1).\n- Limited reception (3.1).\n- The five [engineering capacities](concepts.md#c12) as descriptive tools (3.2).\n- Descriptive-layer [compression](concepts.md#c31) when the carrier is finite (3.4).\n- Reading one [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) as: there are [arrivals](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) on both sides of the boundary, and at least one side regards more than one [arrival](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) as one (5.1).\n- \"All the history that arrives at it participates in weight\" in the definition of [Wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16) is read as holding at every [moment](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c09) (9.3).\n- The [cut](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c23) on which the judgment about [current artificial intelligence](concepts.md#c11) rests, and that it can perform the acts and retention measured by the five [engineering capacities](concepts.md#c12) (9.2).\n- The answers to the four questions state only four kinds of thing, pathways, necessary conditions, no guarantee and unconfirmability, and no sufficient conditions (1.2).\n- The persons this paper discusses are recorded as [Wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16): by the [Application Assumption](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c50) they are assumed not to be [locked in](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c12), and all the [history](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13) that [arrives](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at them is assumed to participate in their [weight](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06) (1.1, 9.1).\n- Between machines of the same [structure](concepts.md#c07) whose constraints are determined only by [structure](concepts.md#c07) and state, the state can be fully read out and copied (9.6).\n- The constraints of different ranges are not assumed to be the same: that two [cases](concepts.md#c24) use the same set of constraints means that the same input has the same [weight](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06) distribution in the two [cases](concepts.md#c24), and is a condition to be stated separately (1.1, 5.5).\n- How the complexity a network can sustain changes is not derived from the capacities of [Wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16) alone: population, division of labor, resources, the maintenance of [signal containers](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c26) and [templates](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c14), and the density of [arrivals](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) all take part; this paper does not deal with the network layer (8.6).\n\nTo negate them means to switch to another set of settings.\n\n### 10.2 Empirical Premises\n\n[Empirical Premises](concepts.md#c01) One to Three are written in the form of [empirical prohibition](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c51): they state only that without these it [never occurs](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c01), not that with them it occurs; they are calibrated from cases and can be revised by new cases. For [Empirical Premises](concepts.md#c01) Four and Five, see their notes.\n\n1. **[Empirical Premise](concepts.md#c01) One**: without retaining some copy of its own [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) (belonging to [memory capacity](concepts.md#c15)), or without checking the copy against subsequent [arrivals](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) (belonging to [operation capacity](concepts.md#c14)), there is no [self-other discrimination](concepts.md#c48) (6.3). Calibration: the reafference principle, crickets, tickling.\n2. **[Empirical Premise](concepts.md#c01) Two**: without retention across different [moments](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c09) (belonging to [memory capacity](concepts.md#c15)), or without [compressing](concepts.md#c31) the [arrivals](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) caused by oneself at different [moments](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c09) into one class (belonging to [compression capacity](concepts.md#c16)), there is no [cross-moment lumping](concepts.md#c49) (6.3). Calibration: mirror self-recognition.\n3. **[Empirical Premise](concepts.md#c01) Three**: without retention across [moments](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c09) (belonging to [memory capacity](concepts.md#c15)), the content of a [construct](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c01) cannot take part in organizing [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) when the [stimulus](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c30) is not present (7.2).\n4. **[Empirical Premise](concepts.md#c01) Four**: on certain dimensions stated by the researcher, the [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) of [current artificial intelligence](concepts.md#c11) cannot be distinguished from human [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) (9.1). This one differs from the three above: it is not a necessary condition but a registration of existing test results; by Proposition Three, it reaches only the registered tests and can be overturned by new tests made on one of these dimensions under the same criteria, and if overturned, the two points that on that dimension it is a [simulation](concepts.md#c51) and is [functionally equivalent](concepts.md#c52) (9.1), and the parts of 9.5, 9.8, 11.4 and Section 13 that rely on it, lose their source; the judgment that it is not a [Wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16) is not affected.\n5. **[Empirical Premise](concepts.md#c01) Five**: the [outputs](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) of a [Wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16) that has a [self-maintained filtering boundary](concepts.md#c47) lean toward maintaining the inside of the boundary (1.5). Like [Empirical Premise](concepts.md#c01) Four, this one is not a necessary condition; it is induced from the cases observed so far, and if among new cases there is such a [Wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16) whose [outputs](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) do not lean toward maintaining the inside of the boundary, that overturns it; if overturned it affects only the researcher's summary \"it is maintaining itself\". Calibration: cells repairing their own cell membranes.\n\n### 10.3 Failure Conditions\n\n- When some [empirical premise](concepts.md#c01) is overturned by new cases, the conclusions whose source chain contains that premise lose their source, and what remains is only the cases already observed and the tests already registered; losing the source only means the chain of derivation is broken, not that the conclusion is false.\n- This paper's derivations rely on the upstream [Law of Flux](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c24), [Law of the Black Box](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c25), [Law of Attrition](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c26) and [Law of Non-Restoration](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c28), and on the definitions of [Wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16), [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18), [arrival](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10), [history](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13), [lock-in](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c12), [computation](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c05), [decision](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c06), [template](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c14), [signal container](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c26), [resonance](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c09) and others; whether they hold is handled upstream.\n- The conclusions that rely on the premise of 2.3 (2.1, 4.3, 6.2, 6.3, 7.1, 7.7, 8.4, 11.2, 11.4, and Section 13, which summarizes them) lose their source when that premise is negated; the negation is: some [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) or some [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) of a [Wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16) does not [arrive](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at that [Wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16) itself before the next [moment](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c09). After losing the source, these conclusions no longer have a source for [Wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16) in general; what remains are only the situations in which the [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) and [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) do come back to oneself, which can be judged separately; losing the source only means the chain of derivation is broken, not that the conclusion is false; conclusions that do not rely on that premise are not affected.\n\n---\n\n## 11. What Cannot Be Derived\n\nFor rows whose right column says \"necessarily\", the reason is the definition of [not guaranteed](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c02): the framework does not assert that it necessarily happens.\n\n\n### 11.1 Overall\n\n| Known | Cannot be derived |\n|---|---|\n| The researcher describes [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) with [construct](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c01) C | The studied [Wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16) has C inside |\n| Party A says [construct](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c01) C, and it [arrives](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at party B | Party B understands, believes or adopts C |\n| Party B later changes its [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) | C is the only cause (the whole [history](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13) that [arrives](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at party B participates in its [weight](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06), the definition of [Wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)) |\n| The same word | The same inner [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) or the same [output tendency](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c02) |\n| The researcher renames [construct](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c01) C as D | The physical [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) of the [Wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16) concerned changes accordingly |\n| New behavior or invention appears | There exists an additional \"inventive generative force\" |\n| Recursion has no external starting point | Each result is already determined, or [history](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13) can be rerun ([Law of the Black Box](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c25), [Law of Non-Restoration](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c28)) |\n| The object of an [illusory construct](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c01) is not given by the physical world | The signal carrying it is not a physical event |\n| All necessary conditions are present | The result necessarily occurs |\n\n### 11.2 Question One: Function\n\n| Known | Cannot be derived |\n|---|---|\n| A [construct](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c01) has some [function](concepts.md#c18) | The [construct](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c01) appeared because of it, or has a purpose |\n| There is no [construct](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c01) | The content of [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) does not participate in [weight](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06) |\n| There is a [construct](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c01) and [inference](concepts.md#c36) is possible | The [inference](concepts.md#c36) agrees with later [arrivals](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) |\n| In the examples, [constructs](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c01) appear in [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) only when [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) is to [arrive](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at others | When nothing is said, this [Wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16) has no such [construct](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c01) inside |\n\n### 11.3 Engineering Capacities and Commutativity\n\n| Known | Cannot be derived |\n|---|---|\n| This paper selects five [engineering capacities](concepts.md#c12) | Something is a [Wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16) only if it has all five, or there are only these five |\n| The definition of [Wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16) | There is a findable [representation](concepts.md#c34) on the carrier |\n| Quantitative indicators chosen by the researcher | The dimensions of the capacity itself |\n| Describing reality in terms of dimensions or data rates | The dimensions and bit rate of reality are already quantifiable |\n| Persisting | The stronger the capacity, the better the persistence |\n| Some capacity below some degree | Cannot persist within a stated time window |\n| [Compression](concepts.md#c31) groups different information into fewer [representations](concepts.md#c34) | [Compression](concepts.md#c31) brings its own material, or every [compression](concepts.md#c31) forms a [construct](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c01) |\n| Higher [operation capacity](concepts.md#c14) | Making up differences lost in containment |\n| A set of [inference rules](concepts.md#c44) is [self-consistent](concepts.md#c45) | It is [commutative within a range](concepts.md#c42) |\n| A [compression](concepts.md#c31) is [commutative](concepts.md#c55) | Its [inference rules](concepts.md#c44) are [self-consistent](concepts.md#c45) |\n| There are exact [inference rules](concepts.md#c44) for a [Wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16) not [locked in](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c12), and the results it may produce differ by more than twice the [allowed error](concepts.md#c56) in the [later representation](concepts.md#c33) | Single results are [commutative](concepts.md#c55) |\n| A [compression](concepts.md#c31) is [commutative](concepts.md#c55) within some range | It is [commutative](concepts.md#c55) within all ranges |\n| A [compression](concepts.md#c31) has so far passed [outcome feedback](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c05) | It has been proved to have chosen the right dimensions |\n| The [representations](concepts.md#c34) of two [cases](concepts.md#c24) are the same | They are the same [target](concepts.md#c25) |\n| A wrong [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) is observed | It is necessarily a lack of [structure](concepts.md#c07) |\n| An engineering model uses the word \"weight\" | Upstream [branch](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c05) [weight](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06) has been measured |\n\n### 11.4 Question Two: Generation\n\n| Known | Cannot be derived |\n|---|---|\n| The researcher [compresses](concepts.md#c31) a [Wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)'s [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) with \"self\" | That [Wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16) defines itself by [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) |\n| There is [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) | There is a [construct](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c01) |\n| There is no name | There is no [construct](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c01) |\n| A [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) uses no [construct](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c01) at the moment it is made | Its content will not later become a [construct](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c01) |\n| All the conditions on the rungs of the ladder are present | It is a [self](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19) |\n| There is a [self-maintained filtering boundary](concepts.md#c47) | It has made a self-definition |\n| The researcher assumes [self](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19) at the human scale | The human is the \"true self\" |\n| [Representations](concepts.md#c34) can be processed again | [Representations](concepts.md#c34) become ever more numerous and ever more correct, or necessarily lead to [second-order distinction](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c01) |\n| Having the five [engineering capacities](concepts.md#c12) | There is [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) |\n| A [node](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25)'s [computation](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c05) is read by the researcher as a [commutative](concepts.md#c55) [compression](concepts.md#c31) | This [node](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25) has [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) |\n| [Output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) is similar to that of a [Wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16) | It is a [Wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16) |\n| [Functionally equivalent](concepts.md#c52) to a [Wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16) on some dimensions | It is a [Wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16), or is [functionally equivalent](concepts.md#c52) on all dimensions |\n| [Output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) is read as carrying content, for example a name | The [node](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25) producing it has a [construct](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c01) that is the content of [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) |\n| The content of [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) participates in later [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) | There is a [construct](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c01) (participation itself has no object) |\n| A content has been said only once | It is not a [construct](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c01) |\n| Grouping different things into one class | There is a [construct](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c01) (this is [lumping](concepts.md#c23) within [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)) |\n| The [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) of [current artificial intelligence](concepts.md#c11) describes a [cut](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c23) | [Current artificial intelligence](concepts.md#c11) has made the [cut](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c23) |\n| [Current artificial intelligence](concepts.md#c11) is sometimes [locked in](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c12) | It is therefore not a [Wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16) (humans are also [locked in](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c12) at times) |\n| The [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) of [current artificial intelligence](concepts.md#c11) changes when it is run | Parameters are updated after each input (with random [rounds](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c04), single results can differ, 9.6) |\n| [Current artificial intelligence](concepts.md#c11) grows in scale | Intelligence necessarily increases monotonically, or [current artificial intelligence](concepts.md#c11) becomes a [Wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16) (whether it is a [Wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16) is judged by design and [cut](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c23), 9.2, 9.3; having [engineering capacities](concepts.md#c12) does not imply [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18), 9.7) |\n| Two machines of the same [structure](concepts.md#c07) can copy their states | Two [Wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16) can become copies of each other through [arrival](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) |\n\n### 11.5 Question Three: Use\n\n| Known | Cannot be derived |\n|---|---|\n| Obtaining a [template](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c14) | Obtaining its scope of application, or the obtainer's execution being the same as others' |\n| The parties' [outputs](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) applying a [template](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c14) are in [resonance](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c09) | The parties' [compressions](concepts.md#c31) are the same |\n| Some content is a [template](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c14) | It passed through some [Wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)'s [construct](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c01) |\n| There is a [template](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c14) in the [record](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c06) | The [Wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16) that [explicitly listed](concepts.md#c09) it has a [construct](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c01) inside |\n| A network has [culture](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c13) | The participants have [constructs](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c01), [templates](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c14) or [second-order distinction](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c01) |\n| [Templates](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c14) can be used repeatedly within [culture](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c13) | [Culture](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c13) must pass through a [template](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c14) stage, or [templates](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c14) are a layer of [culture](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c13) |\n| Two [Wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16) repeatedly [arrive](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at each other | [Culture](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c13) necessarily forms, or [weight](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06) necessarily converges |\n| Certain compatible [outputs](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) recur | The inner [weight](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06) of a [Wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16) has been measured, or a compression rate has been proved ([comparison](concepts.md#c38) reaches only [cases](concepts.md#c24) that have [arrived](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10), Proposition Three) |\n| Not remembering the content of a [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) | Being unable to make a [second-order distinction](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c01) about it |\n| Ordinary adults use the relevant [constructs](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c01) | Their second-order inner [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) has been verified |\n\n### 11.6 Question Four: After Use\n\n| Known | Cannot be derived |\n|---|---|\n| A [construct](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c01) is not [commutative](concepts.md#c55) | It ceases to be used |\n| Disagreeing material [arrives](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) | The [construct](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c01) is therefore abandoned |\n| A configuration with [second-order capacity](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c02) | Necessarily higher social complexity, necessarily invention or understanding |\n| The five capacities are strong enough | Necessarily forming [second-order distinction](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c01), understanding, or highly complex networks |\n| A larger population | Necessarily higher complexity of civilization |\n| Systematic [lumping](concepts.md#c23) appears | The boundary is drawn wrongly (all [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) contains [lumping](concepts.md#c23), 5.1; the same stretch of the [universe](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c02) may be drawn as one or as many, and either holds, 2.1) |\n\n---\n\n## 12. Cases\n\nThis whole section serves only as calibration, and is not a source for any derivation. The data are taken from public web pages, not original documents; where sources attribute causes to the same event, these are marked as the sources' attributions.\n\n### 12.1 Children Learning \"You\" and \"I\"\n\n**What happened.**\n\nEnglish-speaking children fully master personal pronouns only at about three years old. In the course of learning, some children reverse \"you\" and \"I\". This is not common: most children do not reverse them, and even those who err are rarely consistent; in one sample, of 30 early-talking children around one year and eight months old, 17 reversed them at least once during two hours of observation.\n\nThe [Providence Corpus](concepts.md#c57) is a long-term recording of six English-speaking children's conversations with their parents at home; two of the children in it reversed them for several months in a row. The girl Naima, from about one year seven months to two years four months, would say \"you have blueberries on your face\", meaning on her own face. Overall she reversed 79% of second-person pronouns (243 out of 306), and only 3% of first-person ones (13 out of 477). At two years five months the reversals stopped abruptly, with no transition period; the authors speculate that this may be related to a family trip, or may be a developmental change around two years four months, and say the two explanations are not mutually exclusive. The other child, the boy Ethan, reversed especially often when imitating his mother's speech; when the data end, he was still reversing.\n\nResearchers have proposed several explanations. One holds that children treat pronouns as fixed names, not as words that change with the speaker; Naima's data fit this account. Another holds that children may know how adults use them but speak from the other's point of view; Ethan's data partly support this account. Yet another says that children learn the second person from what adults say to others, and firstborn or only children have less chance to hear such speech; both children were firstborns with no siblings during the study. The authors conclude that both hypotheses receive only limited support.\n\n**Bringing it into the framework.**\n\nFirst choose the [cut](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c23): the [nodes](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25) are the child and the parents; what the parents say is [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) that [arrives](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at the child, and what the child says is the child's [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28). The child at this stage is not assumed by this paper to be a [social person](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c03); by 6.1, there can still be [constructs](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c01) in her [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28): the framework does not assert that [second-order distinction](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c01) or [view attribution](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c02) is a necessary condition for the use of [constructs](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c01) (7.7).\n\n- **The material comes from outside; the [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) is one's own.** Parents say \"do you want milk\" to the child every day; these [outputs](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) [arrive](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at the child and are the child's material. The [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) the child makes with this material is the child's own (6.2, note 1). The parents saying \"you\" aloud does not mean the child has obtained \"you\" as a [construct](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c01); the [arrival](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) of a name is not the transfer of a [construct](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c01) (7.1, note 1).\n- **During the reversal period, \"you\" is already a [construct](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c01).** When Naima says \"you have blueberries on your face\", \"you\" appears in her [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) and points at an object: herself. By 6.1, this is a [construct](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c01), pointing at a fixed object, like a name.\n- **\"You\" in adult usage points at a position.** \"You\" is used for one person spoken to after another, and what it points at is the position \"the side spoken to\". So the move from reversal to correct use is, in the framework, not a move from [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) to [construct](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c01), but a change in what the [construct](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c01) points at, from a fixed object to a position. This connects with the \"treated as a name\" explanation.\n- **Hearing others talk to each other.** If the third account holds, the child hears, in what the parents say to each other, \"you\" pointing at different people. This is material; whether the child will therefore change what \"you\" points at is [not guaranteed](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c02) (6.4).\n- **The abrupt stop.** Naima suddenly stopped reversing at two years five months. Both of the authors' speculations are the sources' attributions; by 6.4, when it would happen cannot be derived from an earlier point.\n\n**What the [record](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c06) contains and what cannot be derived.**\n\nWhat the [record](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c06) contains: in these [records](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c06), some children use \"you\" for themselves for a period of time, and later switch to using it for the person spoken to; the change can be abrupt.\n\nCannot be derived: what [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) the child made inside; which hypothesis is right: both hypotheses are researchers' attributions about the child's [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28), and by 6.5 confirming them from outside is [not guaranteed](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c02), which agrees with the authors' saying that both receive only limited support; and which [arrival](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) the end of the reversals came from.\n\n**Notes on the data.**\n\nWhat happened is taken mainly from Evans and Demuth's 2012 paper in the Journal of Child Language, \"Individual differences in pronoun reversal: Evidence from two longitudinal case studies\", with the relevant passages extracted by a tool, not from the original document; the figures of Dale and Crain-Thoreson in it are as cited in that paper. Ethan's other background is irrelevant to this case and is not included.\n\n### 12.2 Neptune and Vulcan\n\n**What happened.**\n\nIn the first half of the nineteenth century, the actual position of Uranus kept departing from its calculated position. The French astronomer Le Verrier supposed that an unseen planet farther out was pulling it, and used Newtonian mechanics to work back to where this planet should be. On 23 September 1846, Galle at the Berlin Observatory searched for only an hour and found Neptune less than one degree from the position Le Verrier had calculated.\n\nLe Verrier then studied Mercury. Mercury's perihelion slowly moves, but it actually moves a little faster than calculated. The masses of the planets were not yet measured accurately enough at the time, and Le Verrier calculated 38 arcseconds per century that could not be explained; the present value is 43 arcseconds per century. Using the same method, Le Verrier proposed a planet, or a group of small bodies, inside the orbit of Mercury.\n\nIn 1859, Lescarbault reported seeing a small black dot cross the Sun on 26 March, and Le Verrier received his letter on 22 December; on 2 January 1860, Le Verrier announced the discovery of Vulcan at the Academy of Sciences, publishing an orbit about 21 million kilometers from the Sun with a period of 19 days and 17 hours. After that, Le Verrier repeatedly adjusted Vulcan's orbital parameters in line with new sighting reports, many of which had no date or an inaccurate time; he published the dates of future transits, and when the predictions failed, he changed the parameters again. Astronomers searched during transits and total solar eclipses for decades.\n\nFrom 1866 to 1878 there were no reliable observations. At the total solar eclipse of 29 July 1878, Watson and Swift both said they saw a planet near the Sun; Peters later held that it was a known star. Eclipse searches continued until 1908; in that year, Campbell and Perrine of the Lick Observatory held that, observationally, the question of an intra-Mercurial planet was closed. In 1915, Einstein's general theory of relativity explained the anomaly in Mercury's orbit without a hidden planet. The name was also used outside astronomy: a weather forecaster made forecasts based on Vulcan's supposed motion.\n\n**Bringing it into the framework.**\n\nFirst choose the [cut](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c23): in [case](concepts.md#c24) A, the [target](concepts.md#c25) is the region of sky near the position Le Verrier calculated, the [earlier material](concepts.md#c29) is the deviation in Uranus's position, the [inference](concepts.md#c36) is calculating from it where the unseen planet should be, and the [later material](concepts.md#c30) is the 1846 observation of that region of sky. In [case](concepts.md#c24) B, the [target](concepts.md#c25) is the region of sky near the Sun inside Mercury's orbit, the [earlier material](concepts.md#c29) is the deviation of Mercury's perihelion and the early sighting reports, the [inference](concepts.md#c36) is the transit predictions, and the [later material](concepts.md#c30) is the observation of the Sun after the predicted dates. In both cases the [compression](concepts.md#c31) turns observational [records](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c06) into [representations](concepts.md#c34) by mass, position and velocity, plus the known bodies; the [inference](concepts.md#c36) is the calculation of celestial mechanics.\n\n- **Question one: both are [constructs](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c01).** When \"that unseen planet\" was calculated, no [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) from it that was recognized had [arrived](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at the astronomers; it pointed at an object not present, had a name and an orbit, and was written into letters and sent off: all three [functions](concepts.md#c18) were there (4.3). By the definition of [illusory construct](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c01), calling them [constructs](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c01) neither claims nor denies that the objects exist; Neptune was found later and Vulcan was not, and before being found the two had the same standing.\n- **Being [commutative](concepts.md#c55): the same method fits once and fails once.** In [case](concepts.md#c24) A, the [inferred](concepts.md#c36) position differed from the later observation by less than one degree; if the researcher states an [allowed error](concepts.md#c56) of one degree, this [comparison](concepts.md#c38) is [commutative on a case](concepts.md#c40), the case being this one. In [case](concepts.md#c24) B, the transit predictions repeatedly failed to fit the observations after the predicted dates: not [commutative](concepts.md#c55). That the same [compression](concepts.md#c31) and [inference](concepts.md#c36) are [commutative](concepts.md#c55) on one [case](concepts.md#c24) does not imply that they are [commutative](concepts.md#c55) on another [case](concepts.md#c24).\n- **Readings can be wrong.** The two sightings of 1878 were researchers using the [construct](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c01) Vulcan when [compressing](concepts.md#c31) [later material](concepts.md#c30), reading a point of light as Vulcan; it was later held that the reading was wrong. The outcome of a [comparison](concepts.md#c38) is relative to how the researcher [compresses](concepts.md#c31) this material (5.3).\n- **Not [commutative](concepts.md#c55), and used all the same.** After the predictions failed, Le Verrier changed the parameters and predicted again. Disagreeing observations [arrived](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) one after another and participated in [weight](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06), and the [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) carrying the [construct](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c01) did not stop appearing because of them (8.1, 8.2); it was even taken up in weather forecasting (8.4). Adding Vulcan only puts one more body into the same calculation of celestial mechanics: on the same [representation](concepts.md#c34) this calculation gives only one result, so by the definition of [self-consistent](concepts.md#c45) it is [self-consistent](concepts.md#c45); yet on [case](concepts.md#c24) B it is not [commutative](concepts.md#c55) (Proposition Six).\n- **Withdrawal.** Around 1908 the astronomical community held that the matter was observationally closed, and after 1915 there was another [compression](concepts.md#c31). By 8.1, Vulcan's ceasing to be used does not follow necessarily from the disagreeing observations; why it was dropped at that time is the sources' attribution.\n\n**What the [record](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c06) contains and what cannot be derived.**\n\nWhat the [record](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c06) contains: with the same method, starting from the deviation of Uranus, the [inference](concepts.md#c36) agreed with later observation; starting from the deviation of Mercury, the transit predictions failed again and again, the parameters were adjusted again and again, and the search went on for decades; someone used the same [construct](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c01) in weather forecasting.\n\nCannot be derived: what Le Verrier or other astronomers \"believed\", since the [record](../paper_81952268_47b1_4d8c_9605_270c42646693/concepts.md#c06) contains only papers, letters, predictions and announcements; why the search went on so long, and why it stopped when it did; how long Vulcan would have been used without general relativity.\n\n**Notes on the data.**\n\nWhat happened is taken from the Wikipedia article \"Vulcan (hypothetical planet)\", the Britannica article \"Urbain-Jean-Joseph Le Verrier\", and a biographical page on Le Verrier on the Book of Proofs website, with the relevant passages extracted by a tool, not from the original documents. Sources differ on who first proposed the name Vulcan: Wikipedia records it as proposed by Babinet in 1846, while another source records it as proposed by Le Verrier in 1859. For the excess of Mercury's perihelion, Le Verrier's calculation at the time was 38 arcseconds per century and the modern value is 43 arcseconds per century; both are given.\n\n---\n\n## 13. General Proposition\n\n**General Proposition**: For a mere physical [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) to become an [illusory construct](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c01), it goes through two steps: from dependence to [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18), and from [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) to [construct](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c01). Without [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18), there is no [construct](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c01) that is the content of its [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18); from there being [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18), it does not follow that there is a [construct](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c01). [Constructs](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c01) and [mere distinction](concepts.md#c19) both participate in later [weight](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06); the difference is that a [construct](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c01) has an object it points to. Only with an object pointed to are there [reference](concepts.md#c20) to what is not present, [inference](concepts.md#c36), and [transmission between Wo](concepts.md#c21) through [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) that points at it.\n\nIf the content of a [Wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)'s [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) becomes a [construct](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c01), the pathway is: the [writing](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c29) of a [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) [arrives](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) again through a [small loop](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c02), its content is used to point at some object, and afterwards it may be [lumped](concepts.md#c23) again; it is not claimed that every step must be passed through, nor that the order is fixed. Among the necessary conditions, [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) is derived from definitions. The [Self-Configuration Assumption](concepts.md#c04) has necessary conditions of its own, whose engineering conditions are [empirical premises](concepts.md#c01); this paper does not list these engineering conditions as necessary conditions for the generation of [constructs](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c01). With all conditions present, generation is [not guaranteed](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c02); once generated, confirmation from outside is also [not guaranteed](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c02); on this, the judgments this paper gives from outside are only negations.\n\nThe use of [constructs](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c01) has two pathways: inside a [Wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16) and between [Wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16). Between [Wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16), what [arrives](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) is the [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) that carries it, not a transfer of the [construct](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c01); from obtaining the same [template](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c14), it cannot be derived that the obtainers' execution is the same, and the consistency of execution the researcher can register lies only in [outputs](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28); when the [outputs](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) [arrive](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at one another within stated dimensions and time windows and repeatedly follow on compatibly, it is the [resonance](../paper_2ccbf179_58cf_4851_bd72_5fa886e4b2c3/concepts.md#c09) of [outputs](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28).\n\nWhen [inferring](concepts.md#c36) with [constructs](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c01), the criterion is whether the [inference](concepts.md#c36) is [commutative within a range](concepts.md#c42) that is stated. Relying only on the same [representation](concepts.md#c34), lost differences cannot be recovered; however high the [operation capacity](concepts.md#c14), it cannot make up differences lost in containment; [comparison](concepts.md#c38) reaches only [cases](concepts.md#c24) that have [arrived](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10); for a [Wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16) not [locked in](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c12) whose differing results fall on the [representation](concepts.md#c34) being [compared](concepts.md#c38), being [commutative](concepts.md#c55) in a single result is [not guaranteed](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c02); [self-consistency](concepts.md#c45) does not imply being [commutative](concepts.md#c55), and being [commutative](concepts.md#c55) does not imply [self-consistency](concepts.md#c45). A [node](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25) whose [rounds](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c04) are [computation](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c05) need not make [distinctions](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18); what reads [computation](../paper_fb0addca_42b6_4884_aa18_438c695747ab/concepts.md#c05) as [inference](concepts.md#c36) is the [Wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16) that reads it. When a [construct](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c01) is not [commutative](concepts.md#c55), disagreeing [arrivals](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) still participate in [weight](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06), but whether it therefore ceases to be used is [not guaranteed](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c02); continued use is not conditioned on being [commutative](concepts.md#c55).\n\n[Current artificial intelligence](concepts.md#c11) is not a [Wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16) under the logical-state [cut](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c23), has no [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18), and has no [construct](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c01) that is the content of [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18); on certain dimensions stated by the researcher, if the effects stated depend only on the content of [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) on these dimensions, two [outputs](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) that are the same on these dimensions have the same effects when they [arrive](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at the same [Wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16), and in this sense it can be [functionally equivalent](concepts.md#c52) to a [Wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16); on dimensions where [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) cannot be distinguished, it is a [simulation](concepts.md#c51) of a [Wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16). Between [locked-in](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c12) [nodes](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25) of the same [structure](concepts.md#c07) whose constraints are determined only by [structure](concepts.md#c07) and state, the way of processing [arrivals](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) can be passed on completely by copying; between [Wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16) with different earlier [histories](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13), it cannot be derived that this can be done.\n\nAs for when a given [Wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16) makes a [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18), when a given content becomes a [construct](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c01), and which consequence follows after a [construct](../paper_08383b0a_1167_4efb_9b89_dc8a71afd5ff/concepts.md#c01) is used, this paper derives none of them uniquely.\n\n(Following the way of writing in 1.2, summarized from the conclusions of 4.2, 4.3, 5.3, Propositions One to Six of 5.4, 6.1 to 6.5, 7.1, 7.3, 8.1, 8.2, 9.1, 9.3 and 9.6. The parts relying on Proposition Four, 6.4 and 7.3 hold under the [Application Assumption](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c50); the parts relying on [Empirical Premises](concepts.md#c01) One to Five lose their source when these premises are overturned by new cases; the parts relying on 9.2 hold under the logical-state [cut](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c23); the parts relying on 9.1 and 9.6 hold under this paper's settings about humans and machines listed in Section 10.)\n"}]}
{"paper_uuid":"fb0addca-42b6-4884-aa18-438c695747ab","paper_title":"三重幻覺與被迫的賭注","paper_title_en":"Triple Illusion and the Forced Wager","author":"黃正宇 / Cheng Yu Huang","contact":"mthree.tw@gmail.com","concepts_md":"---\nuuid: fb0addca-42b6-4884-aa18-438c695747ab\nlast-modified: 2026-10-08T12:00:00\n---\n\n\n## public 二階分別 / Second-Order Distinction\n\n- 定義:二階分別是一個[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19)的一次[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18):它對自己的某一次[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)再作[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18),把那一次劃為「這是看法,不是[被看的東西](concepts.md#c27)」。只作[一階分別](concepts.md#c24)的[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19),照著看法與[被看的東西](concepts.md#c27)的區分行動,卻不作出這個區分;二階分別把它作出來。二階分別的對象是自己的[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18),不是別人的。說一個[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19)有二階分別,指它能對自己的任何一次[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)作這樣的[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)。\n- Definition: A second-order distinction is a [Distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) made by a [Self](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19) upon one of its own earlier [distinctions](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18), marking that one as \"this is a view, not [what is seen](concepts.md#c27).\" A [self](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19) that makes only [first-order distinctions](concepts.md#c24) acts according to the difference between a view and [what is seen](concepts.md#c27) without drawing that difference; a second-order distinction draws it. Its object is the self's own [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18), not another's. To say that a [self](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19) has second-order distinction is to say that it can make such a [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) of any of its own [distinctions](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18).\n- 裁決:2026-10-06 定義中補上[被看的東西](concepts.md#c27)的連結,意義不變,保留 ID。\n- 裁決:2026-10-07 作者裁決:二階分別兼指一次動作與「有二階分別」的能力;定義補上後者的意思,一個概念兩種用法並列。論文未定稿,保留 ID。\n\n\n## public 看法歸屬 / View Attribution\n\n- 定義:看法歸屬是一個[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19)的一次[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18):它把[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)它的一筆[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28),劃為另一個[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19)的一次[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18):「這是對方的看法,不是[被看的東西](concepts.md#c27)」。看法歸屬可能歸錯:被劃為看法的那筆[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28),不一定來自一個[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19)。它不是[印象](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c45):[印象](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c45)估計對方的[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06),看法歸屬只把對方的一筆[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)劃為看法。它的對象是別人的[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18),這一點與[二階分別](concepts.md#c01)不同。\n- Definition: A view attribution is a [Distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) made by a [Self](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19) that marks an [Output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) that has [arrived](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at it as a [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) of another [self](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19): \"this is the other's view, not [what is seen](concepts.md#c27).\" A view attribution may be mistaken: the [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) marked as a view need not come from a [self](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19). It is not an [Impression](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c45): an [impression](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c45) estimates the other's [Weights](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06), whereas a view attribution only marks one of the other's [outputs](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) as a view. Its object is another's [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18), which is what sets it apart from a [Second-Order Distinction](concepts.md#c01).\n- 裁決:2026-10-06 定義中補上[被看的東西](concepts.md#c27)的連結,意義不變,保留 ID。\n\n\n## private 二階假定 / Second-Order Assumption\n\n- 定義:二階假定是對一個具體對象所作、包含三項的假定:一、在講明的層次與[切法](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c23)上,把該對象判為[宇宙](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c02)中的一個[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19);二、它在這個層次上並非每一步都[鎖死](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c12):對人,依[應用假定](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c50)判定;對在使用者看得到的對話層次上的人工智慧,若它的下一筆[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)不能由該層次可得的[歷史](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13)唯一推出,就假定它不被[鎖死](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c12);三、它在某段期間有[二階分別](concepts.md#c01),也有[看法歸屬](concepts.md#c02)。二階假定不是定理。\n- Definition: The second-order assumption is a three-part assumption made about a concrete object: (1) at a stated level and under a stated [Cut](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c23), the object is taken to be a [Self](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19) in the [Universe](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c02); (2) at that level it is not [locked in](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c12) at every step: for a human this is judged by the [Application Assumption](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c50); for an artificial intelligence at the level of the conversation visible to the user, if its next [Output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) cannot be uniquely derived from the [History](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13) available at that level, it is assumed not to be [locked in](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c12); (3) during some period it has [Second-Order Distinction](concepts.md#c01) and also [View Attribution](concepts.md#c02). The second-order assumption is not a theorem.\n\n\n## public 回合 / Round\n\n- 定義:回合是一個[呈現](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c04)在它的一個[時刻](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c09)中走過的一圈:[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)它的[歷史](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13)參與它的[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06),[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06)落出一個結果,這個結果成為[歷史](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13),再[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)它。回合只有這四環:[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)、[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06)、結果、再[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10);落出結果之前的那一段不分析,也不說它是空的。\n- Definition: A round is the circuit a [Presentation](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c04) goes through in one of its [Moments](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c09): the [History](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13) that has [arrived](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at it takes part in its [Weights](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06), the [weights](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06) yield one outcome, and that outcome becomes [history](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13) and [arrives](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at it again. A round has only these four links: [arrival](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10), [weights](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06), outcome, [arrival](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) again; what happens before the outcome is yielded is not analyzed, nor is it said to be empty.\n- 裁決:2026-10-08 中英文定義末句補上「到達」「權重」的連結(概-15),意義不變,保留 ID。\n\n\n## public 計算 / Computation\n\n- 定義:計算是這樣的[回合](concepts.md#c04):它被[鎖死](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c12),只可能有一個結果,由約束定死;或者它不被[鎖死](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c12),可能的結果不只一個,但[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)它的[歷史](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13)並不都參與它的[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06)。前者稱為[鎖死的回合](concepts.md#c25),後者稱為[隨機的回合](concepts.md#c26)。是不是計算,按每一個[回合](concepts.md#c04)判定,不按[呈現](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c04)判定。\n- Definition: A computation is a [Round](concepts.md#c04) that is either [locked in](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c12), with only one possible outcome fixed by constraint, or not [locked in](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c12), with more than one possible outcome, but such that not all of the [History](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13) that has [arrived](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at it takes part in its [Weights](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06). The former is called a [locked-in round](concepts.md#c25), the latter a [random round](concepts.md#c26). Whether something is a computation is judged [round](concepts.md#c04) by round, not presentation by [presentation](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c04).\n- 裁決:2026-10-06 定義中補上[鎖死的回合](concepts.md#c25)與[隨機的回合](concepts.md#c26)的連結,意義不變,保留 ID。\n- 裁決:2026-10-08 補上定義中漏標的概念連結(概-15),意義不變,保留 ID。\n\n\n## public 決定 / Decision\n\n- 定義:決定是[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)在不被[鎖死](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c12)時的[回合](concepts.md#c04):[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)它的整段[歷史](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13)都參與它的[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06),而[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06)定不出結果。是不是決定,按每一個[回合](concepts.md#c04)判定,不按[呈現](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c04)判定。\n- Definition: A decision is a [Round](concepts.md#c04) of a [Wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16) while it is not [locked in](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c12): all of the [History](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13) that has [arrived](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at it takes part in its [Weights](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06), and the [weights](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06) do not fix the outcome. Whether something is a decision is judged [round](concepts.md#c04) by round, not [presentation](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c04) by presentation.\n- 裁決:2026-10-08 補上定義中漏標的概念連結(概-15),意義不變,保留 ID。\n\n\n## public 三問 / Three Questions\n\n- 定義:三問是這三個問題:你從哪裡來?你是誰?你要做什麼?它們分別追問一個[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19)的來處、它自己,以及它的下一刻。問這三個問題,指把自己在這三個方向上的答案劃為看法,而不當作[被看的東西](concepts.md#c27)本身。\n- Definition: The three questions are: Where do you come from? Who are you? What will you do? They ask, respectively, about a [Self](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19)'s origin, about the self itself, and about its next moment. Asking these three questions means marking one's own answers in these three directions as views, rather than taking them as [what is seen](concepts.md#c27) itself.\n- 裁決:2026-10-07 作者裁決:定義補上「問」的意思(把三個方向上的答案劃為看法),使「一階不問、二階敞開」可由定義推出;論文未定稿,保留 ID。\n\n\n## public 來路牆 / Wall of Provenance\n\n- 定義:來路牆是這個結論:一個[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19)拿不全自己過去的[歷史](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13)。它包含三點:一、一個[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19)手上只有已經[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)它的[歷史](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13);一件事當時沒有[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)它,之後也不會[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)它,之後[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)的只是那件事留下的影響,是另一件事。二、一個[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19)對自己來處的[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18),會[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)它自己,成為它[自己的那一段](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c17)的一部分;追問來處,就增添了來處。三、[自己的那一段](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c17)不能再發生一次拿來對照([不可復原律](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c28))。適用範圍:一切[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19)。\n- Definition: The Wall of Provenance is the conclusion that a [Self](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19) cannot obtain the whole of its own past [History](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13). It comprises three points. (1) A [self](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19) has only the [history](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13) that has already [arrived](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at it; an event that did not [arrive](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at it when it happened will not [arrive](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at it later; what [arrives](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) later is only the influence that event left behind, which is another event. (2) A [self](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19)'s [Distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) of its own origin [arrives](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at itself and becomes part of its [Own Segment](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c17); asking about one's origin adds to that origin. (3) The [own segment](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c17) cannot happen once again to serve as a comparison ([Law of Non-Restoration](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c28)). Scope: every [self](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19).\n- 裁決:2026-10-08 補上定義中漏標的概念連結(概-15),意義不變,保留 ID。\n\n\n## public 盲點牆 / Wall of the Blind Spot\n\n- 定義:盲點牆是這個結論:一個[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19)看不見現在的自己。它包含三點:一、沒有任何[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19)能在任何[時刻](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c09)完全[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)自己,正在作出的那一次[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)不在它自己的材料裡([損耗律](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c26))。二、對自己的[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)會[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)自己,成為自己的一部分,所以看自己就改變了自己。三、要看的那個自己由[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)劃出,不同[時刻](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c09)的[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19)是不是同一個,也是一次[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)([同一](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c21))。適用範圍:一切[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19)。\n- Definition: The Wall of the Blind Spot is the conclusion that a [Self](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19) cannot see its present self. It comprises three points. (1) No [self](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19) can completely [distinguish](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) itself at any [Moment](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c09); the [Distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) being made is not among its own material ([Law of Attrition](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c26)). (2) A [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) of oneself [arrives](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at oneself and becomes part of oneself, so looking at oneself changes oneself. (3) The self to be looked at is marked off by [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18); whether the self at different [moments](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c09) is the same one is also a [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) ([Identity](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c21)). Scope: every [self](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19).\n- 裁決:2026-10-07 作者裁決:看自己所改變的是歷史(分別到達自己、成為自己的一部分),不是經由權重;論文未定稿,保留 ID。\n- 裁決:2026-10-08 補上定義中漏標的概念連結(概-15),意義不變,保留 ID。\n\n\n## public 未定牆 / Wall of the Undetermined\n\n- 定義:未定牆是這個結論:一個[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19)算不出未來的必定。它包含兩點:一、一個[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19)在不被[鎖死](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c12)的[時刻](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c09),事先不能唯一推出自己下一個[決定](concepts.md#c06)的結果,至多推出自己的[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06)([黑箱律](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c25));[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06)的分布會重複出現,[不被保證](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c02)。二、[決定](concepts.md#c06)落出以後,別人與環境會怎麼回應,一個[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19)事先算準,[不被保證](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c02)。適用範圍:第一點為一切[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19)在不被[鎖死](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c12)的[時刻](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c09);第二點為一切[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19)。\n- Definition: The Wall of the Undetermined is the conclusion that a [Self](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19) cannot calculate what the future must be. It comprises two points. (1) At a [Moment](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c09) when it is not [locked in](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c12), a [self](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19) cannot uniquely derive beforehand the outcome of its own next [Decision](concepts.md#c06), and can derive at most its own [Weights](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06) ([Law of the Black Box](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c25)); that the distribution of [weights](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06) recurs is [Not Guaranteed](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c02). (2) That a [self](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19) calculates correctly beforehand how others and the environment will respond once a [decision](concepts.md#c06) has been yielded is [not guaranteed](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c02). Scope: the first point holds for every [self](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19) at [moments](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c09) when it is not [locked in](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c12); the second for every [self](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19).\n- 裁決:2026-10-08 補上定義中漏標的概念連結(概-15),意義不變,保留 ID。\n\n\n## public 被迫的賭注 / Forced Wager\n\n- 定義:被迫的賭注是這個結論:一個[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)的每一個[決定](concepts.md#c06),事先算不準,事後收不回,而且不能不作。算不準:[決定](concepts.md#c06)的結果不能事先唯一推出,結果落出以後世界的回應,事先算準也[不被保證](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c02)。收不回:[歷史](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13)中的每一個位置只發生一次,重來而作出一樣的選擇,沒有任何[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)能保證。不能不作:[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)只要在某個[時刻](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c09)不被[鎖死](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c12),那一刻就有一個[決定](concepts.md#c06);「不動」也是那一[回合](concepts.md#c04)落出的結果之一。適用範圍:一切[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)在不被[鎖死](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c12)的[時刻](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c09)。\n- Definition: The Forced Wager is the conclusion that every [Decision](concepts.md#c06) of a [Wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16) cannot be calculated beforehand, cannot be taken back afterwards, and cannot be left unmade. Cannot be calculated: the outcome of a [decision](concepts.md#c06) cannot be uniquely derived beforehand, and that the world's response once the outcome is yielded is calculated correctly beforehand is [Not Guaranteed](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c02). Cannot be taken back: each position in [History](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13) occurs only once, and no [wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16) can guarantee that the same choice would be made again. Cannot be left unmade: whenever a [wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16) is not [locked in](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c12) at some [Moment](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c09), there is a [decision](concepts.md#c06) at that [moment](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c09); \"not acting\" is also one of the outcomes yielded in that [Round](concepts.md#c04). Scope: every [wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16) at [moments](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c09) when it is not [locked in](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c12).\n- 裁決:2026-10-08 補上定義中漏標的概念連結(概-15),意義不變,保留 ID。\n\n\n## public 卡住 / Deadlock\n\n- 定義:卡住是一個[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19)的這種情形:[候選](concepts.md#c18)之間的[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06)分不出高下,[自我說服](concepts.md#c19)推不動而一再重來,結果卻照樣落下。\n- Definition: Deadlock is the situation of a [Self](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19) in which the [Weights](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06) of its [Candidates](concepts.md#c18) cannot be told apart, [Self-Persuasion](concepts.md#c19) fails to move them and keeps starting over, and an outcome is yielded nonetheless.\n\n\n## public 有損 / Lossiness\n\n- 定義:有損是[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)一個[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19)的東西的這種性質:它不是完整的[被看的東西](concepts.md#c27)。完整的[被看的東西](concepts.md#c27),指[被看的東西](concepts.md#c27)的[自己的那一段](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c17)的全部。\n- Definition: Lossiness is the property of what [arrives](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at a [Self](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19) that it is not the whole of [what is seen](concepts.md#c27). The whole of [what is seen](concepts.md#c27) means the entirety of the [Own Segment](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c17) of [what is seen](concepts.md#c27).\n- 裁決:2026-10-06 定義中補上[被看的東西](concepts.md#c27)的連結,意義不變,保留 ID。\n- 裁決:2026-10-06 有損的來源依被看的東西分為兩類:對自己(損耗律)、對自己以外的呈現(前提四);被看的東西不是自己就是自己以外的呈現,故為封閉分類。定義不變,保留 ID。\n- 裁決:2026-10-06 作者裁決:定義補上「完整的被看的東西,指被看的東西的自己的那一段的全部」,接上前提四與有損;論文未定稿,保留 ID。\n- 裁決:2026-10-08 補上定義中漏標的概念連結(概-15),意義不變,保留 ID。\n\n\n## public 幻覺 / Illusion\n\n- 定義:幻覺是一個[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19)的這種處境:它據以行動的,是[有損](concepts.md#c13)地[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)它的東西,不是[被看的東西](concepts.md#c27)本身。幻覺是處境,不是失誤;一個看法事後被證實或被證偽,不改變它是不是幻覺。\n- Definition: Illusion is the condition of a [Self](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19) in which what it acts on is what has [arrived](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at it with [Lossiness](concepts.md#c13), not [what is seen](concepts.md#c27) itself. Illusion is a condition, not an error; whether a view is later confirmed or refuted does not change whether it is an illusion.\n- 裁決:2026-10-06 定義中補上[被看的東西](concepts.md#c27)的連結,意義不變,保留 ID。\n\n\n## public 世界幻覺 / World Illusion\n\n- 定義:世界幻覺是[幻覺](concepts.md#c14)落在來處上的形態:把[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)自己的[歷史](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13)當成世界本身;把對來處的[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)當成來處本身。\n- Definition: World illusion is the form [Illusion](concepts.md#c14) takes with respect to origin: taking the [History](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13) that has [arrived](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at oneself for the world itself, and taking one's [Distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) of one's origin for the origin itself.\n\n\n## public 自我幻覺 / Self Illusion\n\n- 定義:自我幻覺是[幻覺](concepts.md#c14)落在自己上的形態:把[自我印象](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c46)當成自己;把不同[時刻](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c09)的[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19)是同一個當成本來就是那樣,而不是一次[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)([同一](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c21))。\n- Definition: Self illusion is the form [Illusion](concepts.md#c14) takes with respect to oneself: taking one's [Self-Impression](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c46) for oneself, and taking the sameness of the [Self](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19) at different [Moments](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c09) as simply given, rather than as a [Distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) ([Identity](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c21)).\n\n\n## public 決策幻覺 / Decision Illusion\n\n- 定義:決策幻覺是[幻覺](concepts.md#c14)落在下一刻上的形態:把[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06)的估計當成結果;把[決定](concepts.md#c06)中算得出的那一段,當成結果的擔保。\n- Definition: Decision illusion is the form [Illusion](concepts.md#c14) takes with respect to the next moment: taking an estimate of [Weights](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06) for the outcome, and taking the part of a [Decision](concepts.md#c06) that can be calculated as a guarantee of the outcome.\n\n\n## public 候選 / Candidate\n\n- 定義:候選是一個[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19)作出的一次[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18):把某些可能劃為一個選項。候選是[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18),不是[分支](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c05):[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06)分配在[分支](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c05)上,候選只是[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19)對[分支](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c05)的一種劃分。\n- Definition: A candidate is a [Distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) made by a [Self](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19) that groups certain possibilities into one option. A candidate is a [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18), not a [Branch](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c05): [Weights](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06) are allocated over [branches](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c05), and a candidate is only one way a [self](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19) divides them up.\n- 裁決:2026-10-08 補上定義中漏標的概念連結(概-15),意義不變,保留 ID。\n\n\n## public 自我說服 / Self-Persuasion\n\n- 定義:自我說服是一個[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19)在[決定](concepts.md#c06)的結果事先算不準時,用自己的[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)把自己推向某個[候選](concepts.md#c18);這些[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)自己,參與之後的[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06)。說服的一方與被說服的一方,是同一個[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19)。\n- Definition: Self-persuasion is a [Self](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19) pushing itself toward some [Candidate](concepts.md#c18) by its own [Distinctions](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) when the outcome of a [Decision](concepts.md#c06) cannot be calculated beforehand; these [distinctions](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) [arrive](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at the self and take part in its later [Weights](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06). The one who persuades and the one persuaded are the same [self](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19).\n- 裁決:2026-10-08 補上定義中漏標的概念連結(概-15),意義不變,保留 ID。\n\n\n## private 社會 / Society\n\n- 定義:社會是[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19)與[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19)在彼此的[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)上的[耦合](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c36):一個[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19)對另一個[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19)的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)作[看法歸屬](concepts.md#c02),而不只把它當成一筆[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)來反應;而且每個參與者在參與的那一刻都有[二階分別](concepts.md#c01)。生物學所說的「昆蟲社會」不在此列。\n- Definition: Society is the [Coupling](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c36) of [Selves](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19) on one another's [Distinctions](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18): one [self](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19) makes a [View Attribution](concepts.md#c02) on another [self](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19)'s [Output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28), rather than only reacting to it as an [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28); and every participant has [Second-Order Distinction](concepts.md#c01) at the moment of taking part. What biology calls \"insect societies\" does not fall under it.\n- 裁決:2026-10-07 作者裁決:參與者條件以參與的那一刻為準;退場者生前寫下的內容仍可構成社會,非我產生的輸出不構成;論文未定稿,保留 ID。\n- 裁決:2026-10-08 補上定義中漏標的概念連結(概-15),意義不變,保留 ID。\n\n\n## public 權力 / Power\n\n- 定義:權力是一個[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19)的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)以高[頻率](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c48)、廣範圍[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)其他的[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19),參與它們的[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06)。\n- Definition: Power is the [Output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) of one [Self](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19) [arriving](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at other [selves](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19) with high [Frequency](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c48) and over a wide range, taking part in their [Weights](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06).\n- 裁決:2026-10-08 補上定義中漏標的概念連結(概-15),意義不變,保留 ID。\n\n\n## public 死亡 / Death\n\n- 定義:死亡是一個[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19)替一個[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)標上「它已經[退場](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c43)」的一次[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)。死亡是描述,不是物理條件;標在哪裡,由作出標記的[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19)判定。\n- Definition: Death is a [Distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) by which a [Self](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19) marks a [Wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16) as \"it has made its [Exit](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c43).\" Death is a description, not a physical condition; where the mark is placed is decided by the [self](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19) that places it.\n- 裁決:2026-10-06 判定與《渦動力學》的死亡(c23,private)不是同一概念:本篇的死亡限定標記的內容為「它已經[退場](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c43)」,另行登記。\n- 裁決:2026-10-07 定義中的一般動詞「決定」改為「判定」,避免與本篇概念「決定」同字,意義不變,保留 ID。\n- 裁決:2026-10-08 補上定義中漏標的概念連結(概-15),意義不變,保留 ID。\n\n\n## public 三道牆 / Three Walls\n\n- 定義:三道牆是[來路牆](concepts.md#c08)、[盲點牆](concepts.md#c09)、[未定牆](concepts.md#c10)三者的總稱。\n- Definition: The Three Walls is the collective name for the [Wall of Provenance](concepts.md#c08), the [Wall of the Blind Spot](concepts.md#c09), and the [Wall of the Undetermined](concepts.md#c10).\n- 裁決:2026-10-06 作者裁決登記為總稱;三者是同一個迴圈上的三個位置,屬於論證,留在論文正文。\n\n\n## public 一階分別 / First-Order Distinction\n\n- 定義:一階分別是[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)的[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)中的一種:它照著看法與[被看的東西](concepts.md#c27)的區分行動,卻不作出這個區分,也就是不把任何一次[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)劃為「這是看法,不是[被看的東西](concepts.md#c27)」。一階分別是能力的指標:只具有一階分別的[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16),是不作[二階分別](concepts.md#c01)的[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)。沒有「一階的我」這種[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19),只有只具有一階分別的[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19)。\n- Definition: A first-order distinction is a kind of [Distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) made by a [Wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16): it acts according to the difference between a view and [what is seen](concepts.md#c27) without drawing that difference, that is, without marking any [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) as \"this is a view, not [what is seen](concepts.md#c27).\" First-order distinction is an indicator of capability: a [wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16) that has only first-order distinction is a [wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16) that makes no [Second-Order Distinction](concepts.md#c01). There is no kind of [Self](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19) called a \"first-order self\"; there is only a [self](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19) that has only first-order distinction.\n- 裁決:2026-10-06 作者裁決:一階分別是能力指標,登記為一個條目;正文的「一階的我」「一階的渦」一律改寫為「只具有一階分別的我/渦」。\n\n\n## public 鎖死的回合 / Locked-in Round\n\n- 定義:鎖死的回合是[鎖死](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c12)的[回合](concepts.md#c04):只可能有一個結果,由約束定死。它是[計算](concepts.md#c05)的一種。\n- Definition: A locked-in round is a [Round](concepts.md#c04) that is [locked in](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c12): only one outcome is possible, fixed by constraint. It is one kind of [Computation](concepts.md#c05).\n- 裁決:2026-10-06 作者裁決登記為計算的子類;正文條列的標籤改寫為全名,避免與上游的鎖死同字。\n\n\n## public 隨機的回合 / Random Round\n\n- 定義:隨機的回合是這樣的[回合](concepts.md#c04):它不被[鎖死](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c12),可能的結果不只一個,但[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)它的[歷史](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13)並不都參與它的[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06)。它是[計算](concepts.md#c05)的一種。\n- Definition: A random round is a [Round](concepts.md#c04) that is not [locked in](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c12), with more than one possible outcome, but such that not all of the [History](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13) that has [arrived](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at it takes part in its [Weights](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06). It is one kind of [Computation](concepts.md#c05).\n- 裁決:2026-10-06 作者裁決登記為計算的子類;正文條列的標籤改寫為全名。\n\n\n## public 被看的東西 / What Is Seen\n\n- 定義:被看的東西是一次[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)所劃出的那個[呈現](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c04)。\n- Definition: What is seen is the [Presentation](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c04) marked off by a [Distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18).\n- 裁決:2026-10-06 作者裁決登記:用語來自《渦動力學》分別的定義,上游未登記;本篇的有損、幻覺、二階分別、看法歸屬都用到它。\n\n\n## public 我的建構 / Construction of the Self\n\n- 定義:我的建構是一個[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19)以[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)劃出自己的過程。劃的材料分兩類:外來的,即[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)它的[歷史](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13),以及別人對它的[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18);自身的,即它自己過去對自己的[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)。\n- Definition: The construction of the self is the process by which a [Self](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19) marks itself off by [Distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18). Its material falls into two kinds: external, namely the [History](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13) that has [arrived](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at it and others' [distinctions](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) of it; and its own, namely its own past [distinctions](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) of itself.\n- 裁決:2026-10-06 作者裁決:正文 5.8 補上名稱後登記;材料分外來與自身兩類,為封閉分類。\n\n## 不登記\n\n- 方法上禁止:2026-10-06 形式段標記,只限制本篇的寫法,與上游的裁決一致;不是概念,不另立。\n- 形式段記號:2026-10-06 甲、乙、渦甲、時刻甲、回應方、對象、輸出一、輸出二,只出現在形式段,屬形式化階段的記號。\n- 推導起點:2026-10-06 作者裁決不登記:方法論用語,指四條律與前提一至前提四。\n- 可證偽條件:2026-10-06 作者裁決不登記:方法論用語。\n- 前提一至前提四:2026-10-06 作者裁決不登記:本篇前提的編號,各條內容寫明於正文。\n- 迴圈:2026-10-06 作者裁決不登記:3.4 的迴圈就是渦本身,不另立。\n- 範圍:2026-10-07 作者裁決不登記:「有二階分別的我」的簡稱;二階分別已登記,不另立概念。\n- 我的邊界:2026-10-07 作者裁決不登記:由上游「我」的定義直接得出(自我定義劃到哪裡,我就到哪裡),不是新概念。\n- 公開:2026-10-06 作者裁決不登記:日常用語,本篇只用來指輸出已經到達別人,不另立概念。\n- 同形假定:2026-10-08 作者裁決不登記:指二階假定第二項中,人工智慧在對話層次上的不鎖死假定,內容已在二階假定的定義中;與上游應用假定形式相同、層次不同,不另立概念。\n- 有限:2026-10-08 作者裁決不登記:正文〇節界定為「身在宇宙之中,受四條律約束」,並明言不另立。\n- 三重幻覺:2026-10-08 作者裁決不登記:第五章標題與 5.2 對幻覺落在三問三個對象上的稱呼;正文明言「三重」的數目是本篇的一次分別,並禁止把三重當成三種互不化約的幻覺;所指即幻覺(c14)及其三種形態(c15–c17),不另立總稱。\n- 校準、路標、形式段、方法規則:2026-10-06 作者裁決不登記:〇節說明的寫作用語。\n\n## 待決項\n\n無\n","formalization_md":"論文:《三重幻覺與被迫的賭注》\nUUID:fb0addca-42b6-4884-aa18-438c695747ab\n\n## 記號約定\n\n來源:論文全文\n\n- 社會學:一般用語,不是概念「社會」\n- 昆蟲社會:生物學用語,不是本篇概念「社會」\n\n## 前置條件\n\n來源:論文第一節第二小節【正文:句7266721834】\n\n- 前提一:一個 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.我 的每一次 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別,都在它的下一 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.時刻 之前 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 它自己。【正文:句2905062827】\n- 前提二:一個 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.我 的任何一個 決定,內容都是一次 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別;它不是所說、所做之對象的完整描述。【正文:句5602100872】\n- 前提三:計算 落出的結果不是 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別;37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別 只在 決定 中落出。【正文:句4886141212】\n- 前提四:對任何 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.呈現,包括自己,它的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.自己的那一段 中,總有沒有 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 這個 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦 的部分。【正文:句8320577788】\n- [作者裁決] 前提四 的「這個 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦」指作出 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別 的那個 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦,也就是看的一方;依前後文自明,正文不改。\n- 前提五 [限定條件]:本篇只使用上游的公開條目,不引用上游的論證與編號。【正文:句1753735628、句1989355326】\n- 前提六 [限定條件]:範圍為有 二階分別 的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.我;本篇專屬的結論寫成「若一個 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.我 有 二階分別,則……」。【正文:句9104741605、句7441630611】\n- 前提七 [限定條件]:只談 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.宇宙 之內。【正文:句5141470593】\n- 前提八 [限定條件]:模型只在講明的層次上使用:人工智慧為使用者看得到的對話;人為生物學與 社會學 的層次。【正文:句0785883494、句5642515194】\n- 前提九 [限定條件]:在此層次上,人工智慧的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.權重 是它下一筆 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 的機率分布,不是模型參數;它不運行時沒有 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.時刻。【正文:句3960240275】\n- 前提十 [限定條件]:一筆 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 的大小屬於 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.切法,使用時講明。【正文:句3246795680】\n- 前提十一 [限定條件]:在講明的層次上,一個對象的下一筆 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 若不能由該層次可得的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.歷史 唯一推出,假定它不被 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.鎖死;對人即 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.應用假定,對人工智慧的對話層次,本篇採同樣形式的假定;不是定理。【正文:句1637039186、句6755805198、句6248228148】\n- 前提十二 [限定條件]:問誰有 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.我,先講明 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.切法;37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.我 與載體無關。【正文:句3117829467、句6830822529】\n- 前提十三 [限定條件]:第五節第四小節只談 決定;37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.鎖死 時的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 是 計算,不在 前提二 之內。【正文:句2921281427、句3611209805、句3810301641】\n- 前提十四 [限定條件]:數個 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.呈現 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.重切 為一個整體,且此整體是一個 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.我 時,對此整體同樣標 二階假定。【正文:句7225961281、句7499579244】\n\n## 範圍(對應論文第〇節「範圍」)\n\n來源:論文第〇節「範圍」【正文:句8712088222】\n\n- 附註:一階分別 用到看法與 被看的東西 的區分,卻不作出這個區分。【正文:句2339478525】\n- 步驟〇之一:一個 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.我 過去的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別 都 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 它自己,參與它之後的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.權重(從 前提一 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦 的定義 推出)【正文:句6684647608】\n- 步驟〇之二:步驟〇之一 對只具有 一階分別 的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.我 同樣成立(從 步驟〇之一 推出)【正文:句6684647608、句3902256488】\n- 步驟〇之三:二階分別 也是 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別,受 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.損耗律 約束(從 二階分別 的定義 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.損耗律 推出)【正文:句2281230555】\n- 附註:第三階不帶進新的操作;本篇不往上數。【正文:句8916483131、句1283942590】\n- 步驟〇之三之二:屬於(看法歸屬, 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別)(從 看法歸屬 的定義 推出)【正文:句7636016189】\n- [作者裁決] 形-11 不成立:屬於(甲, 乙) 用於「甲這一類是乙的一種」,依形式化手冊 5.2 的範例 屬於(候選, 分別);本篇全部「屬於」皆依此用法,不改為「收窄」。\n- 附註:看法歸屬 可能歸錯;它不是 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.印象,可作為 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.印象 的材料;看法歸屬 不要求 二階分別,有 二階分別 不保證有 看法歸屬。【正文:句7636016189、句1077466932、句8596099043】\n- 附註:二階分別 是 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.節點 上出現的現象,成因本篇與上游皆推不出;本篇不主張任何 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.我 有 二階分別。【正文:句5750688577、句8687741674】\n- 步驟〇之四:從外部判定一個對象有 二階分別 與 看法歸屬:b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.不被保證(從 二階分別 的定義 + 看法歸屬 的定義 + b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.不被保證 的定義 推出)【正文:句0392743580、句7075748716】\n- [作者裁決] 結論為「不被保證」者,以推導起點與定義中無相應斷言為據,與由律推出者同等對待,不另區分;形式化引相關定義為來源,與正文「推導起點與定義中無此斷言」等價。本條適用於 步驟〇之四、步驟一之三之一、步驟七之一之三 等。\n- 附註:本篇的態度(從外部確認 二階分別 或 看法歸屬,任何方法都做不到)不作推導來源;本篇結論只依賴 步驟〇之四。【正文:句8242562419、句3614896137】\n- 步驟〇之五:二階假定 中「並非每一步都 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.鎖死」一項可以否證(從 二階假定 的定義 + 計算 的定義 + 決定 的定義 推出)【正文:句9341791806、句8674759409、句7149890648】\n- 步驟〇之六:從內部事後察覺自己曾作出 二階分別 或 看法歸屬,屬於 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.自我印象,不是證明(從 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.損耗律 + 前提一 + b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.自我印象 的定義 + 幻覺 的定義 推出)【正文:句1898610224、句0360643252】\n- 附註:二階假定 第三項,在本篇與上游之內從外部或內部都沒有證明或否證的判準,只能假定。【正文:句9341791806、句5523831328】\n- 步驟〇之七:在單一 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.節點 上,二階分別 與其他 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別 相同,只參與之後的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.權重;方向推不出(從 二階分別 的定義 + 前提一 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦 的定義 + b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.知見障 推出)【正文:句7200138678】\n- 附註:二階分別 在本篇的作用只有兩個:使 三問 問得出,以及作為 社會 的必要條件;後者由 社會 的定義規定。【正文:句3569341985、句6640944794】\n\n## 前提的推論(對應論文第一節第二小節)\n\n來源:論文第一節第二小節【正文:句7266721834】\n\n- 步驟一之二之一:一個 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.我 的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別 參與它之後的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.權重(從 前提一 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦 的定義 推出)【正文:句2584040782】\n- 附註:結果先落出,落出即在 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.歷史 中;這個動作留下的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.寫入 之後才加入 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.歷史。【正文:句0684887193】\n- 附註:前提一至前提四不主張結果可事先推出、歷史可再發生,或 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.我 能完全 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別 自己。【正文:句2212376378】\n- 附註:前提四 不因層次而被違反:虛擬世界中程式讀得到的完整記錄,只是程式這一層的完整;被看的東西 是 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.宇宙 中的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.呈現,相對於它仍為 有損。【正文:句8162790180】\n- 附註:前提二、前提三只能假定;依賴它們的結論只在其假定之下成立。【正文:句1120913994】\n\n## 誰有我(對應論文第一節第三小節)\n\n來源:論文第一節第三小節【正文:句6538744275】\n\n- 步驟一之三之一:從外部證明一個對象有 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.我:b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.不被保證(從 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦 的定義 + 二階分別 的定義 + b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.不被保證 的定義 推出)【正文:句2807839767、句2403455784】\n- 步驟一之三之二:若在講明的層次與 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.切法 上,找到機制證明一個對象的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 只能是 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.鎖死 的或只能是隨機的,則它只有 計算,二階假定 不成立(從 計算 的定義 + 決定 的定義 + 二階假定 的定義 推出)【正文:句7149890648、句6856482776】\n- 附註:重跑多次結果相同,只能作參考。【正文:句6491001541】\n- 步驟一之三之三:37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.鎖死 時 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 關於自己的內容,仍是 計算,不是 二階分別(從 計算 的定義 + 二階分別 的定義 + 前提三 推出)【正文:句2404244533、句5524372744】\n\n## 我的邊界(對應論文第一節第四小節)\n\n來源:論文第一節第四小節【正文:句6133410239】\n\n- 步驟一之四之一:37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.我 的邊界由自我定義劃出,不是身體,也不是機器(從 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.我 的定義 推出)【正文:句4646514314】\n- 步驟一之四之二:b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 互相 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 並參與彼此 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.權重 的數個 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.呈現,可 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.重切 為一個 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.呈現,限於結果投影相容的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.重切(從 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.重切 的定義 + b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.耦合 的定義 推出)【正文:句8648056356】\n- 步驟一之四之三:若此 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.呈現 是 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦,且以 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別 把自己劃為 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.我,它是一個 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.我(從 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦 的定義 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.我 的定義 推出)【正文:句5930335457】\n- 步驟一之四之四:把一副身體當成 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.我,是一次 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別(從 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別 的定義 推出)【正文:句9641209783】\n- 步驟一之四之五:邊界移動時,來路牆、盲點牆、未定牆 隨之移動,不因此消失(從 來路牆 + 盲點牆 + 未定牆 + 步驟一之四之三 推出)【正文:句6124947124】\n\n## 範圍的性質(對應論文第一節第五小節)\n\n來源:論文第一節第五小節【正文:句9143178006】\n\n- 步驟一之五之一:判定一個 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.我 是否在範圍內,是判定者的一次 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別(從 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別 的定義 + 前提二 推出)【正文:句3990141511】\n- 附註:框架對此沒有結構上的判準:二階分別 靠 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別 的內容判定,內容不形式化。【正文:句7609249225】\n- 步驟一之五之二:一個 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.呈現 是否為 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦,按 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.時刻 判定,可隨 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.時刻 改變(從 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦 的定義 推出)【正文:句2055767983、句5017055240】\n- 步驟一之五之三:從外部判定另一個 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.我 的 二階分別:b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.不被保證(從 步驟〇之四 推出)【正文:句0782022137】\n- 步驟一之五之四:從內部察覺自己作出的 二階分別,只能在它 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 自己之後(從 盲點牆 的定義 + 前提一 推出)【正文:句0782022137】\n- 附註:能不能做、多常做、做到多深是程度;範圍沒有清楚的界限。【正文:句9707788460、句3785344714】\n- 步驟一之五之五:判定另一個 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.我 在範圍內,用到 看法歸屬;判定自己在範圍內,是一次 二階分別(從 步驟一之五之一 + 看法歸屬 的定義 + 二階分別 的定義 推出)【正文:句7984151847】\n- [作者裁決] 步驟一之五之五 的中間一步依定義讀出:判定另一個 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.我 在範圍內,須先把它的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 劃為它的一次 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別,這一步就是 看法歸屬;判定自己在範圍內,是把自己過去的一次 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別 拿出來劃為看法,這就是 二階分別。\n\n## 回合、決定 與 計算(對應論文第一節第六小節)\n\n來源:論文第一節第六小節【正文:句7605177671】\n\n- 步驟一之六之一:37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.鎖死 的 回合 是 計算(從 計算 的定義 推出)【正文:句7617278300、句8492148952】\n- 步驟一之六之二:不被 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.鎖死、且 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 它的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.歷史 並不都參與 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.權重 的 回合,是 計算(從 計算 的定義 推出)【正文:句7617278300、句9030829489】\n- 步驟一之六之三:不被 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.鎖死、且 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 它的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.歷史 都參與 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.權重 的 回合,其 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.呈現 在該 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.時刻 是 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦,此 回合 是 決定(從 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦 的定義 + 決定 的定義 推出)【正文:句7384545612】\n- 步驟一之六之四:決定 的 回合 不被 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.鎖死,且 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.歷史 都參與,不屬於 計算(從 決定 的定義 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦 的定義 + 計算 的定義 推出)【正文:句5721343738】\n- 結論一之六之一:互斥分類(回合, 計算, 決定)(從 步驟一之六之一 + 步驟一之六之二 + 步驟一之六之三 + 步驟一之六之四 推出)【正文:句5721343738、句7384545612】\n- 結論一之六之二:互斥分類(計算, 鎖死的回合, 隨機的回合)(從 計算 的定義 + 鎖死的回合 的定義 + 隨機的回合 的定義 推出)【正文:句7617278300、句7301347837、句8492148952、句9030829489】\n- 附註:是 計算 還是 決定,按每一 回合 區分,不按 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.呈現 區分。【正文:句6532000116】\n- 步驟一之六之五:37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦 的 計算 只有 鎖死的回合;隨機的回合 屬於 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.隨機源 等非 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦 的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.呈現(從 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦 的定義 + b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.隨機源 的定義 + 計算 的定義 + 隨機的回合 的定義 推出)【正文:句9560919826、句3282146581】\n- 步驟一之六之六:被標 二階假定 的對象,在講明的層次與 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.切法 上有 決定(從 二階假定 的定義 + 決定 的定義 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.我 的定義 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦 的定義 推出)【正文:句8021624224】\n\n## 三問(對應論文第二節)\n\n來源:論文第二節【正文:句8982807468】\n\n- 步驟二之〇:任何 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦 在三個方向上受約束:37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 它的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.歷史(來處)、它的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.權重(自己)、它落出的結果(下一刻)(從 回合 的定義 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦 的定義 推出)【正文:句4775327725】\n- 步驟二之一:只具有 一階分別 的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦 有答案,但不把答案劃為看法,所以不問 三問(從 步驟二之〇 + 一階分別 的定義 + 三問 的定義 推出)【正文:句4668364104】\n- 步驟二之二:若一個 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.我 有 二階分別,三問 對它敞開(從 步驟二之〇 + 二階分別 的定義 + 三問 的定義 推出)【正文:句9461758845、句0045506208、句4367241040】\n- 附註:能問,不等於一定會問。【正文:句6107265053】\n\n## 來路牆(對應論文第三節第一小節)\n\n來源:論文第三節第一小節【正文:句0974058070】\n\n- 步驟三之一之一:一個 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.我 的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別 的材料,只有已經 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 它的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.歷史(從 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別 的定義 推出)【正文:句0791319519】\n- 步驟三之一之二:一件事發生時未 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 一個 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.我,之後 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 它:b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.不會發生(從 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 的定義 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.不可復原律 推出)【正文:句0144793767】\n- [作者裁決] 一件事留下的影響經由傳遞、之後才落到這個 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.我 時,依 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 的定義,落到它的是那次傳遞的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.寫入;它在 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.歷史 中有自己的位置,是另一件事。原事件的位置依 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.不可復原律 不再發生一次,故原事件本身之後 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 它不會發生。\n- 附註:之後 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 的,是那件事留下的影響,是另一件事。【正文:句0144793767】\n- 步驟三之一之二之二:一個 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.我 的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.自己的那一段 中,總有沒有 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 它的部分(從 前提四 推出)【正文:句7547677312】\n- 步驟三之一之三:一個 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.我 對自己來處的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別,成為它的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.自己的那一段 的一部分(從 前提一 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦 的定義 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.自己的那一段 的定義 推出)【正文:句2652603886、句2321034452】\n- 步驟三之一之四:37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.自己的那一段 再發生一次以供對照:b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.不會發生(從 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.不可復原律 推出)【正文:句3394220921、句4753030388】\n- 步驟三之一之五:沒有任何 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦 能保證,重來時不被 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.鎖死 的選擇一樣(從 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.不可復原律 推出)【正文:句2370903050】\n- 結論三之一:來路牆 成立(從 步驟三之一之一 + 步驟三之一之二 + 步驟三之一之二之二 + 步驟三之一之三 + 步驟三之一之四 + 步驟三之一之五 推出)【正文:句2184339916】\n\n## 盲點牆(對應論文第三節第二小節)\n\n來源:論文第三節第二小節【正文:句3883288978】\n\n- 步驟三之二之一:一個 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.我 在任何 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.時刻 完全 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別 自己:b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.不會發生(從 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.損耗律 推出)【正文:句5293387035】\n- 步驟三之二之二:正在作出的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別 不在它自己的材料中(從 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別 的定義 推出)【正文:句5844067401、句5689587399】\n- 步驟三之二之三:對自己的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 自己,成為它的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.歷史 的一部分(從 前提一 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦 的定義 推出)【正文:句8809259415】\n- 步驟三之二之四:看自己而不改變自己:b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.不會發生(從 步驟三之二之三 推出)【正文:句6125410097、句6364291654】\n- [作者裁決] 看自己所改變的是 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.歷史:37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別 到達自己、成為自己的一部分;不是經由 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.權重。這與 步驟五之五之一之二 所說的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.權重 相對於修正之前是否移動,是兩件事。\n- 步驟三之二之五:找到一個不由 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別 劃出的自己:b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.不會發生(從 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.我 的定義 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.同一 的定義 推出)【正文:句0368529798、句5905995478】\n- 結論三之二:盲點牆 成立(從 步驟三之二之一 + 步驟三之二之二 + 步驟三之二之四 + 步驟三之二之五 推出)【正文:句9955759052】\n- 附註:盲點牆 不依賴 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.黑箱律。【正文:句7835907561、句3607545941】\n\n## 未定牆(對應論文第三節第三小節)\n\n來源:論文第三節第三小節【正文:句8634482970】\n\n- 步驟三之三之一:一個 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.我 在不被 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.鎖死 的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.時刻,事先唯一推出自己下一個 決定 的結果:b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.不會發生(從 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.黑箱律 推出)【正文:句7503586727、句1989069788】\n- 步驟三之三之二:37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.權重 的分布重複出現:b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.不被保證(從 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.流變律 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦 的定義 推出)【正文:句7090782256】\n- 步驟三之三之三:回應方為不被 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.鎖死 的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦 或 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.隨機源 時,事先唯一推出其回應:b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.不會發生(從 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.黑箱律 + b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.隨機源 的定義 推出)【正文:句0997764215】\n- 步驟三之三之四:回應方為 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.鎖死 的部分時,拿全影響它的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.歷史:b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.不被保證(從 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.自己的那一段 的定義 + 前提四 推出)【正文:句0997764215】\n- 步驟三之三之五:事先算準環境的回應:b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.不被保證(從 步驟三之三之三 + 步驟三之三之四 推出)【正文:句7715611149】\n- 步驟三之三之六:屬於(對 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦 的統計估計, b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.印象)(從 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.印象 的定義 推出)【正文:句5568885936】\n- 步驟三之三之七:由統計得出的禁止,不是 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.不會發生;它只能以 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.經驗禁止 的形式成立,須跨案例校準並標明(從 步驟三之三之一 + b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.經驗禁止 的定義 + b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.不會發生 的定義 推出)【正文:句3050106383、句5568885936、句9983694335】\n- 結論三之三:未定牆 成立(從 步驟三之三之一 + 步驟三之三之二 + 步驟三之三之五 推出)【正文:句9983694335】\n\n## 關係與適用(對應論文第三節第四小節)\n\n來源:論文第三節第四小節【正文:句7967123956】\n\n- 附註:三道牆 是同一個迴圈上的三個位置。【正文:句7427505779、句4181578506】\n- 步驟三之四之一:此迴圈即 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦 本身(從 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦 的定義 推出)【正文:句0890848919】\n- 步驟三之四之二:只要它是 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦,迴圈不停(從 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦 的定義 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.流變律 推出)【正文:句2683223833】\n- 循環三之四:此迴圈是循環;沒有內部的退出條件;只在它不再是 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦 時結束(從 步驟三之四之二 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦 的定義 推出)【正文:句2683223833】\n\n## 三道牆 與 決定(對應論文第三節第五小節)\n\n來源:論文第三節第五小節【正文:句5960021273】\n\n- 附註:三道牆 對應同一個 決定 的三個環節;這是整理,不是推導。【正文:句3724857935、句5444669093】\n- 步驟三之五之一:三道牆 對一切 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.我 成立(從 結論三之一 + 結論三之二 + 結論三之三 推出)【正文:句8315498490】\n- 步驟三之五之二:若一個 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.我 有 二階分別,它能以 三問 追問一個 決定 的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.歷史、37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.權重、結果(從 二階分別 的定義 + 三問 的定義 + 回合 的定義 + 步驟二之〇 推出)【正文:句4376952999、句4048001123】\n- 步驟三之五之三:三道牆 的存在不依賴 二階分別;三道牆 被碰到依賴 二階分別(從 步驟三之五之一 + 步驟三之五之二 + 步驟二之一 推出)【正文:句2405246618、句4048001123】\n- [作者裁決] 「被碰到」指以 三問 追問;來源補上 步驟二之一,正文不改。\n\n## 被迫的賭注(對應論文第四節第一小節)\n\n來源:論文第四節第一小節【正文:句6313267736】\n\n- 步驟四之一之一:一個 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦 在它不被 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.鎖死 的一個 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.時刻 有一 回合,落出一個結果(從 回合 的定義 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.時刻 的定義 推出)【正文:句6397580255】\n- 步驟四之一之二:這一 回合 是 決定(從 步驟四之一之一 + 決定 的定義 推出)【正文:句6397580255、句3936331858】\n- 步驟四之一之三:該 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦 在該 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.時刻 不作 決定:b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.不會發生(從 步驟四之一之二 推出)【正文:句2735686281、句8641047041】\n- 附註:「不動」是落出的結果之一;結果沒有落在它身上,這件事本身也 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 它。【正文:句3107005440、句9967498814】\n- 步驟四之一之四:事先唯一推出這個 決定 的結果:b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.不會發生(從 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.黑箱律 推出)【正文:句9117252037】\n- 步驟四之一之五:互斥分類(b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.節點, 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦, b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.信號容器, b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.隨機源)(從 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.節點 的定義 + b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.信號容器 的定義 + b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.隨機源 的定義 推出)【正文:句1176559860】\n- 步驟四之一之六:回應方為不被 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.鎖死 的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦 或不被 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.鎖死 的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.隨機源 時,事先唯一推出其回應:b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.不會發生(從 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.黑箱律 + b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.隨機源 的定義 推出)【正文:句9091322308】\n- 步驟四之一之七:回應方被 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.鎖死 時,其回應由影響它的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.歷史 定出(從 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.鎖死 的定義 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.宇宙 的定義 推出)【正文:句7151540048】\n- 步驟四之一之八:該 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦 拿到世界的全部 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.歷史:b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.不會發生(從 前提四 推出)【正文:句7151540048】\n- 步驟四之一之九:影響回應方的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.歷史 全部 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 該 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦:b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.不會發生(從 步驟四之一之七 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.自己的那一段 的定義 + 前提四 推出)【正文:句7151540048】\n- 步驟四之一之十:該 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦 事先算準回應方的回應:b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.不被保證(從 步驟四之一之五 + 步驟四之一之六 + 步驟四之一之七 + 步驟四之一之九 推出)【正文:句6654968051】\n- 步驟四之一之十一:回到該 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.時刻 重來:b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.不會發生(從 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.不可復原律 推出)【正文:句4338250622、句1451835254】\n- 步驟四之一之十二:沒有任何 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦 能保證,重來時不被 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.鎖死 的選擇一樣(從 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.不可復原律 推出)【正文:句8677971909】\n- 結論四之一:被迫的賭注 對任一 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦 的任一不被 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.鎖死 的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.時刻 成立(從 步驟四之一之三 + 步驟四之一之四 + 步驟四之一之十 + 步驟四之一之十一 + 步驟四之一之十二 推出)【正文:句2771334374、句7609688592】\n- 步驟四之一之十三:落出的結果,落出即在 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.歷史 中;這個動作留下的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.寫入 之後才加入 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.歷史,內容由已包含這個結果的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.歷史 定出(從 前提二 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.歷史 的定義 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.寫入 的定義 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別 的定義 推出)【正文:句9483349497】\n- 步驟四之一之十四:這一 回合 中,不由過去定出的只有落出的結果(從 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.宇宙 的定義 推出)【正文:句1254743081、句9483349497】\n\n## 二階看得見自己在賭(對應論文第四節第二小節)\n\n來源:論文第四節第二小節【正文:句2342307553】\n\n- 步驟四之二之一:被迫的賭注 對一切 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦 的一切不被 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.鎖死 的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.時刻 成立(從 結論四之一 推出)【正文:句6007688938、句9586071266】\n- 步驟四之二之二:若一個 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.我 有 二階分別,它能把自己的 決定 劃為看法,不當作 被看的東西 本身(從 二階分別 的定義 + 前提二 推出)【正文:句8077724526】\n- 步驟四之二之三:若一個 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.我 有 二階分別,它在不被 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.鎖死 的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.時刻 不再下注:b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.不會發生(從 步驟四之二之一 推出)【正文:句7843837563、句3396696441】\n- 步驟四之二之四:卡住 不要求 二階分別(從 卡住 的定義 + 自我說服 的定義 推出)【正文:句6174800914、句7255490103】\n- 步驟四之二之五:若一個 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.我 有 二階分別,它能把 卡住 中自己的那些 候選 與說服的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別 劃為看法(從 二階分別 的定義 + 卡住 的定義 + 候選 的定義 + 自我說服 的定義 推出)【正文:句5094824379】\n- 步驟四之二之六:這次 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別 參與之後的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.權重(從 前提一 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦 的定義 推出)【正文:句3705758901】\n- 步驟四之二之七:這次 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別 推高哪些結果的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.權重、推多少:推不出(從 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.知見障 推出)【正文:句3705758901】\n- 附註:這次 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別 可能使 卡住 加深,也可能使它鬆開,屬經驗描述。【正文:句0007037615】\n\n## 無評價參照點(對應論文第四節第三小節)\n\n來源:論文第四節第三小節【正文:句7451596422】\n\n- 步驟四之三之一:當初的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.自己的那一段 仍在 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.歷史 中(從 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.歷史 的定義 推出)【正文:句8624956012】\n- 步驟四之三之二:當初的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.自己的那一段 中未曾 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 它的事,之後 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 它:b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.不會發生(從 來路牆 推出)【正文:句4619905127】\n- 步驟四之三之三:以現在的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別 完整重現當初的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.權重:b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.不被保證(從 步驟四之三之二 + 前提四 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.自己的那一段 的定義 推出)【正文:句4619905127、句4255140579】\n- 步驟四之三之四:屬於(對當初的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.自己的那一段 的新 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別, b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.自我印象)(從 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.自我印象 的定義 推出)【正文:句4785387354】\n- 步驟四之三之五:這次新 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別 參與之後的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.權重(從 前提一 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦 的定義 推出)【正文:句4785387354】\n- 步驟四之三之六:「當初那個人是不是自己」是一次 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別(從 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.同一 的定義 推出)【正文:句0710017385】\n\n## 算得再清楚也擔保不了 決定(對應論文第四節第四小節)\n\n來源:論文第四節第四小節【正文:句7626439233】\n\n- [作者裁決] 把後果算清楚,算出的是這個 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.我 自己的 回合 落出的結果,不論那些 回合 是 計算 還是 決定;故 步驟四之四之一 可由 回合 的定義 推出。正文 第四節第四小節 已相應修改。\n- 步驟四之四之一:把後果算清楚這件事,參與之後的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.權重(從 回合 的定義 + 計算 的定義 + 決定 的定義 + 結論一之六之一 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦 的定義 推出)【正文:句5496275053】\n- 步驟四之四之二:在 決定 中,由 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.權重 唯一推出結果:b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.不會發生(從 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.黑箱律 推出)【正文:句5736923167】\n- 附註:方法上禁止把從數字到行動的那一步寫成算得出來的。【正文:句8314678037】\n\n## 幻覺(對應論文第五節第一小節)\n\n來源:論文第五節第一小節【正文:句2227892549】\n\n- 步驟五之一之一:一個 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.我 對自己的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別,37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 它的材料 有損(從 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.損耗律 + 步驟三之二之二 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.自己的那一段 的定義 + 被看的東西 的定義 + 有損 的定義 推出)【正文:句1991867136】\n- 步驟五之一之二:一個 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.我 對自己以外的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.呈現 的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別,37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 它的材料 有損(從 前提四 + 被看的東西 的定義 + 有損 的定義 推出)【正文:句1991867136】\n- 步驟五之一之二之二:一次 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別 的 被看的東西,不是作出它的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.我 自己,就是其以外的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.呈現;步驟五之一之一 與 步驟五之一之二 窮盡 有損 的來源(從 被看的東西 的定義 + 步驟五之一之一 + 步驟五之一之二 推出)【正文:句1872040473】\n- 附註:一階分別 有損 一次;二階分別 的材料是 一階分別 的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出,又受 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.損耗律 約束,再損一次。【正文:句6206229692、句2133199126】\n- 步驟五之一之三:一個 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.我 過去作過的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別,都 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 它,參與它之後的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.權重(從 步驟一之二之一 推出)【正文:句2002106916、句8648517842】\n- 附註:這些 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別 作為到達它的東西,其 有損 由 步驟五之一之一 與 步驟五之一之二 涵蓋;本步不主張它們在之後每一次 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別 的材料中。【正文:句8648517842】\n- 步驟五之一之四:核對一個看法,是再作一次 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別(從 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別 的定義 推出)【正文:句1843356395】\n- 步驟五之一之五:一個 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.我 找到並使用一個可供對照的位置,而這次找到與使用不是 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別:b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.不會發生(從 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別 的定義 + 步驟三之一之一 + 步驟五之一之四 推出)【正文:句8288025100】\n- 步驟五之一之六:任何 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.我 在任何 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.時刻 都在 幻覺 中(從 幻覺 的定義 + 步驟五之一之一 + 步驟五之一之二 + 步驟五之一之三 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦 的定義 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.生成函數 的定義 推出)【正文:句9737311388、句9583950731、句2002106916、句5181227333】\n- [作者裁決] 被看的東西 是 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.宇宙 中的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.呈現;虛擬世界中取得的完整記錄只是某一切法下的完整,相對於 被看的東西 仍為 有損,前提四 不因此被違反。步驟五之一之六 兩種來源都用,正文 第一節第二小節 與 第五節第一小節 已相應修改。\n- 步驟五之一之七:作出 二階分別 的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.我,仍在 幻覺 中(從 步驟五之一之六 推出)【正文:句6161981781、句9170629903】\n- 步驟五之一之八:一個 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.我 跳出 幻覺,碰到 被看的東西 本身:b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.不會發生(從 步驟五之一之五 + 步驟五之一之六 推出)【正文:句8288025100、句9170629903】\n- 步驟五之一之九:一個看法的證實或證偽,是事後再作的一次 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別(從 步驟五之一之四 推出)【正文:句3464037451】\n- 附註:方法上禁止說 幻覺 已被消除;方法上禁止把事後被證實的看法寫成不是 幻覺。【正文:句8648517842】\n\n## 三重(對應論文第五節第二小節)\n\n來源:論文第五節第二小節【正文:句6282228252】\n\n- 步驟五之二之一:屬於(世界幻覺, 幻覺)(從 世界幻覺 的定義 推出)【正文:句8830584754、句3662645322】\n- 步驟五之二之二:屬於(自我幻覺, 幻覺)(從 自我幻覺 的定義 推出)【正文:句8830584754、句6514054999】\n- 步驟五之二之三:屬於(決策幻覺, 幻覺)(從 決策幻覺 的定義 推出)【正文:句8830584754、句4992253347】\n- [作者裁決] 三種形態是 幻覺 落在當下那次 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別 之對象上的樣子;「同一個動作」指這次未被劃為看法的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別。\n- 步驟五之二之四:每一 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.時刻 至少落在 世界幻覺、自我幻覺、決策幻覺 之一:依 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.損耗律,當下那一次 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別 總未被劃為看法,而它落在來處、自己、下一刻三個方向之一(從 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.損耗律 + 步驟二之〇 + 幻覺 的定義 + 世界幻覺 的定義 + 自我幻覺 的定義 + 決策幻覺 的定義 推出)【正文:句8830584754、句5636142544】\n- [作者裁決] 步驟五之二之四 的兩個環節依定義讀出:一、依 三問 的定義與 步驟二之〇,任何 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦 只在來處、自己、下一刻三個方向上受約束,一次 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別 的對象落在其中之一;二、未被劃為看法的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別,即把看法當成 被看的東西 本身,這正是 世界幻覺、自我幻覺、決策幻覺 各自定義中的「當成」。\n- 附註:「三重」的數目是本篇的一次 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別。【正文:句5425634238、句5791695294】\n- 附註:方法上禁止把三重當成三種互不化約的 幻覺。【正文:句4393689203】\n\n## 二階與 幻覺(對應論文第五節第三小節)\n\n來源:論文第五節第三小節【正文:句7145332156】\n\n- 步驟五之三之一:二階分別 不使一個 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.我 離開 幻覺(從 步驟五之一之七 推出)【正文:句1116651516、句3599646360】\n- 步驟五之三之二:若一個 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.我 有 二階分別,幻覺 能被它問起(從 二階分別 的定義 + 幻覺 的定義 推出)【正文:句5747863259】\n- 附註:二階分別 可能使看不見的那一次 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別 上移一層。【正文:句3844046930、句6588285931】\n- 附註:方法上禁止說反思必然帶來更好的判斷。【正文:句4299440331】\n\n## 生成(對應論文第五節第四小節)\n\n來源:論文第五節第四小節【正文:句0544372374】\n\n- 步驟五之四之一:在 決定 中,生成的當下能算出的只有 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.權重(從 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.黑箱律 推出)【正文:句8459016807】\n- 步驟五之四之二:產出者在生成的當下,以自己的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別 判定這筆 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 的對錯:b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.不會發生(從 前提二 + 步驟三之二之二 + 步驟五之一之九 推出)【正文:句8583165207、句3810301641】\n- 步驟五之四之三:屬於(一個 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.我 在 決定 中落出、事後被證偽的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出, 在 幻覺 中落出的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出)(從 幻覺 的定義 + 步驟五之一之六 推出)【正文:句5332048719、句8119489034、句3810301641】\n- 步驟五之四之四:屬於(旁人據 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 的篤定程度對產出者 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.權重 所作的估計, b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.印象)(從 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.印象 的定義 推出)【正文:句0485754971】\n\n## 修正的方式(對應論文第五節第五小節)\n\n來源:論文第五節第五小節【正文:句7672070054】\n\n- 步驟五之五之一:工具、經驗帶來的新東西 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 自己,重新 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別 也 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 自己;兩者都參與之後的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.權重(從 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 的定義 + 前提一 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦 的定義 推出)【正文:句4187602641】\n- 步驟五之五之一之二:37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.權重 相對於修正之前移動:b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.不被保證(從 步驟五之五之一 + b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.知見障 推出)【正文:句4187602641】\n- [作者裁決] 此處的改變指 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.權重 相對於修正之前是否移動、往哪裡移動,與 步驟三之二之四 所說的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.歷史 改變不同。\n- 步驟五之五之二:不被 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.鎖死 的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦 的一次 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 之中,37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.坍塌 結果的部分,是依 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.權重 落出的一個結果,不是 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.權重 本身(從 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.黑箱律 + b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 的定義 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.坍塌 的定義 推出)【正文:句7205243721】\n- 附註:步驟五之五之二 只論 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.坍塌 結果部分,不論 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 所含的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別 內容;正文「一次輸出只是依權重落出的一個結果」的「輸出」依此取 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.坍塌 結果義。37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.黑箱律 只就不被 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.鎖死 的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦 成立,故本步驟不擴張為所有 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 的一般敘述。\n- 步驟五之五之三:一個 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.我 對一個對象的看法,所用的材料不超出已 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 它的部分(從 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別 的定義 推出)【正文:句1257497395、句1048065060】\n- 步驟五之五之三之二:一個看法、一個 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.印象、一次被落出的 候選,事後是否被證實,取決於事後再作的那一次 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別 的結果;事先算準這次結果:b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.不被保證(從 步驟五之一之九 + 結論三之三 推出)【正文:句3464037451、句9983694335】\n- [作者裁決] 步驟五之五之三之二 的「事先」指作出該看法、b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.印象 或落出該 候選 的時刻;事後作證實或證偽的一方,其 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別 屬 結論三之三 所說的環境的回應(含不被 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.鎖死 與被 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.鎖死 兩種情形,見 步驟三之三之三、步驟三之三之四、步驟三之三之五)。看法、b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.印象、被落出的 候選 都是 步驟五之一之九 所說的「看法」,其證實或證偽都是事後再作的一次 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別。\n- 步驟五之五之四:修正過的看法在事後被證實:b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.不被保證(從 步驟五之五之三之二 推出)【正文:句0573554626、句7848513568】\n- 附註:哪一種修正方式較常在事後被證實,屬經驗描述,只能統計。【正文:句7848513568】\n\n## 候選 與結果分立(對應論文第五節第六小節)\n\n來源:論文第五節第六小節【正文:句7568040382】\n\n- 步驟五之六之〇:屬於(候選, 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別)(從 候選 的定義 推出)【正文:句9540604659】\n- 附註:候選 不是 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分支;37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.權重 分配在 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分支 上。【正文:句5461592985】\n- 步驟五之六之一:一個 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.我 的一條路是否被走,在它不被 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.鎖死 時是一次 決定(從 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.我 的定義 + 決定 的定義 推出)【正文:句5597759719】\n- 步驟五之六之二:在 決定 中,經過查核的 候選 成為結果:b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.不被保證(從 步驟五之六之一 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.黑箱律 推出)【正文:句5115885323、句7099804200、句5690422398】\n- 附註:候選 通常遠多於成為結果的,屬經驗描述。【正文:句6331670708】\n\n## 自我說服(對應論文第五節第七小節)\n\n來源:論文第五節第七小節【正文:句2243548471】\n\n- 步驟五之七之一:自我說服 的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別 參與之後的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.權重(從 前提一 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦 的定義 推出)【正文:句5832882026】\n- 步驟五之七之二:自我說服 推得動:b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.不被保證(從 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.知見障 推出)【正文:句3401932911】\n- 步驟五之七之三:若該 候選 涵蓋的結果 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.權重 上升,其餘結果的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.權重 總和必然下降(從 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.知見障 推出)【正文:句4343251210】\n- 附註:往其他 候選 說服,推得動時,會把 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.權重 推回別的方向;這樣作出的 決定 是否較常在事後被證實,屬經驗描述。【正文:句3502430359】\n- 步驟五之七之四:說服的那一次,從內部不可見(從 盲點牆 推出)【正文:句7448846292】\n- 步驟五之七之五:結果會不會落下,取決於說服投入多少:b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.不會發生(從 決定 的定義 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.坍塌 的定義 推出)【正文:句5895182846】\n- 步驟五之七之六:失敗的說服參與之後的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.權重,可成為下一輪說服的材料(從 前提一 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦 的定義 推出)【正文:句8389575969】\n- 步驟五之七之七:可能的出口,如新的外部 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達、一次「不再說服」的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別,出現:b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.不被保證(從 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.黑箱律 + 未定牆 推出)【正文:句9220165124】\n- 步驟五之七之八:此迴路在它不再是 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.我 時必然結束(從 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.我 的定義 + 自我說服 的定義 推出)【正文:句3427933933】\n- 循環五之七:說服失敗的迴路;迴路停下 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.不被保證;可能的出口為新的外部 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 或一次「不再說服」的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別(後者可由迴路內部出現),兩者出現皆 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.不被保證;它不再是 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.我 時必然結束(從 步驟五之七之六 + 步驟五之七之七 + 步驟五之七之八 推出)【正文:句8389575969、句9220165124、句3427933933】\n- 附註:卡住 就是此迴路的樣子。【正文:句9932027140】\n- 附註:常見推得動且越說越信;失敗常伴隨痛苦、懷疑;過度成功而沒有外部 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達,也可能被稱為瘋狂,皆屬經驗描述。方法上禁止把確定感當成證據、把痛苦或瘋狂寫成說服失敗的必然結果、把說服成功寫成看清了。【正文:句2903861745、句0082534264、句5396009452】\n\n## 我的建構(對應論文第五節第八小節)\n\n來源:論文第五節第八小節【正文:句6868903767】\n\n- 步驟五之八之一:37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.我 是劃出的,不是找到的(從 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.我 的定義 推出)【正文:句9431225976】\n- 步驟五之八之二:自己過去對自己的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 自己(從 前提一 推出)【正文:句5331326243】\n- 步驟五之八之三:「自己是這樣的人」這類 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別 參與之後的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.權重;方向推不出(從 前提一 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦 的定義 + b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.知見障 推出)【正文:句8735696907、句3531371224】\n- [作者裁決] 只要它還是 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.我,每一 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.時刻 都以 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別 劃出自己(一階分別 即可);故 我的建構 中自身那一類材料的迴路與「是 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.我」同始同終,循環五之八 由 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.我 的定義 支持。正文 第五節第八小節 已加附註。\n- 循環五之八:我的建構 中自身那一類材料形成迴路;沒有內部的退出條件,只在它不再是 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.我 時結束(從 步驟五之八之二 + 步驟五之八之三 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.我 的定義 推出)【正文:句8735696907、句8954397312】\n- 附註:b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.退場 是不再是 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.我 的一種情形;死亡 是別人所作的標記,不是此循環結束的條件。【正文:句8954397312】\n- 步驟五之八之四:正在劃的這一次 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別 不可見(從 盲點牆 推出)【正文:句6757445610】\n- 步驟五之八之五:我的建構 收斂到固定的核心:b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.不被保證(從 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.知見障 推出)【正文:句8954397312】\n- 步驟五之八之六:以外來材料中別人的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別 劃出的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.我,沒有 我的建構 就不存在(從 我的建構 的定義 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.我 的定義 推出)【正文:句6341238777、句8954397312】\n- 附註:社會 與以別人的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別 劃出的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.我 看起來一起長出來,劃不出第一刻,屬經驗描述,不由框架推出;與第一節第五小節所說範圍沒有清楚的界限是同一類情形。【正文:句1569884644、句8954397312】\n- 附註:把建好的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.我 當成本來就在那裡的,是 自我幻覺;方法上禁止把自我定義寫成對自己的發現。【正文:句4104525988、句8954397312】\n\n## 兩個結構上的差別(對應論文第六節第一小節)\n\n來源:論文第六節第一小節【正文:句8302566091】\n\n- 步驟六之一之一:若一個 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.我 有 二階分別,它的界線本身可被 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別、可被改動(從 二階分別 的定義 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別 的定義 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.我 的定義 + 前提一 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦 的定義 推出)【正文:句1300656525、句7432245519】\n- 步驟六之一之二:別人的 決定,內容是一次 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別(從 前提二 推出)【正文:句7929201758】\n- 步驟六之一之三:若一個 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.我 只具有 一階分別,它的 決定 的內容是一次 二階分別:b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.不會發生(從 一階分別 的定義 推出)【正文:句2078189204】\n- 步驟六之一之三之二:若一個 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.我 的 決定 的內容是一次 二階分別,它的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 別人時,37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 的是它對自己劃法的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別(從 前提二 + 回合 的定義 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 的定義 推出)【正文:句2078189204、句4736051410】\n- [作者裁決] 依 前提二 與正文第一節第二小節,決定 的內容所是的那次 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別,不是藏在 決定 背後的東西,而是 決定 落出的結果本身,也就是那筆 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出;故這筆 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 別人時,到達 的就是那次 二階分別。\n- 步驟六之一之四:社會 中的一個 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.我,能對別人的 決定 作 看法歸屬(從 步驟六之一之二 + 社會 的定義 推出)【正文:句1661924307、句0195770405】\n- 附註:能,不等於會;看法歸屬 讀出的也只是自己的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別。【正文:句9226842414】\n\n## 社會(對應論文第六節第二小節)\n\n來源:論文第六節第二小節【正文:句1884595159】\n\n- 步驟六之二之〇:屬於(社會, b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.耦合)(從 社會 的定義 推出)【正文:句4074128863、句4438929773】\n- 附註:兩種 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.耦合 方式在 社會 中都成立:互相 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達;同一件事(b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.信號容器 中關於 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別 的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別)37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 雙方。【正文:句6363810481、句1315736295、句7675265040】\n- 附註:參與者條件以參與的那一刻為準:作出 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 的一方在作出時、讀的一方在讀時,是有 二階分別 的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.我;非 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.我 所產生的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 不構成 社會。【正文:句4022865548、句8263117988】\n- 步驟六之二之一:寫下者 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.退場 後,經由 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.信號容器 的 社會 的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.耦合 仍可成立(從 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.歷史 的定義 + b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.耦合 的定義 + 社會 的定義 推出)【正文:句7437101153】\n- [作者裁決] 社會 的參與者條件以作出該筆 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 時為準;概念表 社會 條目的定義已補上「在參與的那一刻」,機器列印等非 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.我 所產生的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 不構成 社會。\n- 步驟六之二之一之二:寫下者放進 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.信號容器 的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別,是一份 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出;這份 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 若在 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.信號容器 中保存,並被之後的讀取取用,則是該次 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 的材料(從 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 的定義 + b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.信號容器 的定義 推出)【正文:句7675265040】\n- 附註:b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.信號容器 的定義不保證內容持續保存,也不保證之後每一次 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 都取用同一份 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出;步驟六之二之一之二 與 步驟六之二之一之三 只在「內容已保存且被讀取取用」的情形成立,不推到所有後續 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達。\n- 步驟六之二之一之三:寫下者自己的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 與讀者的一次讀取,各是一次 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達;兩次的材料是 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.信號容器 中的同一份 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出,雙方的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.自己的那一段 在這份 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 上重疊,構成 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.耦合(從 步驟六之二之一之二 + 前提一 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 的定義 + b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.耦合 的定義 推出)【正文:句7675265040、句7104389005】\n- [作者裁決] 步驟六之二之一之三 中,寫下者自己的一次 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 由 前提一 推出(一個 分別 參與寫下者之後的 權重),讀者的一次讀取是另一次 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達;雙方在同一份 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 上的重疊,是依 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.耦合 的定義作出的推導,正文 句7675265040、句7104389005 只陳述讀者在 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.信號容器 上 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.耦合、兩人讀同一份內容,並未逐字陳述寫下者的到達與重疊。\n- [作者裁決] 步驟六之二之一之三 的「同一份 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出」指 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.信號容器 中保存的那份內容,不指寫下的那個事件;讀者讀到的是容器中的內容,不是寫下事件本身,因此不違反 來路牆(沒有到達的事件之後也不會到達;之後的讀取是另一次 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達,材料是同一份 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出)。步驟六之二之〇 的「同一件事」依此理解。\n- 步驟六之二之二:身邊沒有他人的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.我,若對 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.信號容器 中別人的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別 作 看法歸屬,且有 二階分別,而寫下那些 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別 的一方在寫下時有 二階分別,且那些 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別 在 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.信號容器 中保存並被其讀到,就在 社會 中(從 社會 的定義 + 步驟六之二之一之三 推出)【正文:句2319328356】\n- 步驟六之二之三:判定具體參與者有 看法歸屬 與 二階分別:b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.不被保證(從 步驟〇之四 推出)【正文:句2396871469、句2007913695】\n- 步驟六之二之四:社會 的參與者都有 二階分別(從 社會 的定義 + 二階分別 的定義 推出)【正文:句5420457930】\n- 附註:本篇的 社會 不包括 昆蟲社會;以 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.迴路 為單位的組織分析不受本定義影響。【正文:句7014851960、句9725305206】\n\n## 在分別上溝通(對應論文第六節第三小節)\n\n來源:論文第六節第三小節【正文:句2397687568】\n\n- 步驟六之三之一:社會 中,參與者在 決定 中落出的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出,內容是看法,不是 被看的東西(從 前提二 + 社會 的定義 推出)【正文:句5912794267、句5124149236】\n- 步驟六之三之二:屬於(把別人的話當成所說之事本身, 世界幻覺)(從 世界幻覺 的定義 推出)【正文:句4759684863】\n- 步驟六之三之三:甲對乙的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.印象 參與甲之後的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.權重(從 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.印象 的定義 + 前提一 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦 的定義 推出)【正文:句3990479935、句8874576627】\n- 步驟六之三之三之二:甲可以只用已 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 甲的材料,再作一次以乙為對象的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別;這次 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別 屬於 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.印象(從 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別 的定義 + b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.印象 的定義 推出)【正文:句4705341616】\n- 步驟六之三之四:沒有乙的新 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 甲時,甲對乙的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.印象 仍可改變(從 步驟六之三之三 + 步驟六之三之三之二 + 前提一 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦 的定義 推出)【正文:句4705341616】\n- 步驟六之三之五:甲的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.印象 納入乙的新內容,需有新的東西 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 甲:乙的新 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出,或經由重疊的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.自己的那一段、乙所在的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.耦合 傳來的(從 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別 的定義 + b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.印象 的定義 推出)【正文:句9945881021】\n- 步驟六之三之六:行動是一次 決定 時,從 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.印象 唯一推出行動:b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.不會發生(從 決定 的定義 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.黑箱律 推出)【正文:句3082232588、句2838173270】\n- 步驟六之三之七:在 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別 上的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.耦合,在講明的維度上 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.趨同、b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.趨異、b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.持平:都 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.不被保證(從 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.知見障 推出)【正文:句4347630606】\n- 步驟六之三之八:內部推演過的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.印象 在事後被證實:b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.不被保證(從 步驟五之五之三之二 推出)【正文:句8605464488】\n- 附註:內部推演的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.頻率 遠高於真實互動,屬經驗描述。方法上禁止把 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.印象 收斂寫成對對方的逼近、把收斂當成事後被證實的證據、不講明定義就把只在 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 上耦合的群體稱為「社會」、說 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.趨同 等而不講明維度。【正文:句8678380658、句7414385220、句8605464488】\n\n## 權力(對應論文第六節第四小節)\n\n來源:論文第六節第四小節【正文:句2326124684】\n\n- 步驟六之四之一:由共同的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 推不出判斷的收斂(從 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.趨同 的定義 推出)【正文:句7421950237、句5112818656】\n- 附註:例如經由 權力:某一個 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.我 的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別 放進 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.信號容器,37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 其他的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.我。【正文:句7421950237】\n- 步驟六之四之二:拍板的結果 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 一個參與者時,進入其之後的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.自己的那一段(從 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 的定義 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦 的定義 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.自己的那一段 的定義 推出)【正文:句8802920300】\n- 步驟六之四之三:被落出的 候選 在事後被證實:b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.不被保證(從 步驟五之五之三之二 推出)【正文:句5163008764】\n\n## 退場與 死亡(對應論文第七節第一小節)\n\n來源:論文第七節第一小節【正文:句8171035747】\n\n- 步驟七之一之〇:屬於(死亡, 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別)(從 死亡 的定義 推出)【正文:句7171399065】\n- 附註:依 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦 的定義,b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.退場 有兩種情形:37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 它的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.歷史 不再都參與它的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.權重;或從某一 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.時刻 起每一步都 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.鎖死。【正文:句0363355865】\n- 步驟七之一之一:b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.退場 與 死亡 可以不一致(從 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.退場 的定義 + 死亡 的定義 推出)【正文:句4752736530】\n- 步驟七之一之二:b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.退場 者的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.自己的那一段 仍在 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.歷史 中(從 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.歷史 的定義 推出)【正文:句3868712020】\n- 步驟七之一之三:當下判定一個 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.呈現 已依第二種情形 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.退場:b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.不被保證(從 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦 的定義 + b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.退場 的定義 + b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.不被保證 的定義 推出)【正文:句8941296674、句4527393689】\n- 附註:依 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.進場 的定義,b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.退場 後的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.呈現 可以再成為 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦;本節以下皆指它未再 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.進場 的期間。【正文:句0799413641、句9728543548】\n- 步驟七之一之四:b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.退場 的那一段再發生:b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.不會發生(從 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.不可復原律 推出)【正文:句0481971754】\n- 步驟七之一之五:b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.退場 的那一段離開 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.歷史:b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.不會發生(從 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.歷史 的定義 推出)【正文:句0249296508】\n\n## 覆水難收(對應論文第七節第二小節)\n\n來源:論文第七節第二小節【正文:句2039100270】\n\n- 步驟七之二之一:已經落出的結果或已經作出的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別,從 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.歷史 中移除:b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.不會發生(從 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.歷史 的定義 推出)【正文:句6723821600】\n- 步驟七之二之二:一次 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 別人時,參與別人之後的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.權重(從 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦 的定義 推出)【正文:句8102793757】\n- 步驟七之二之二之二:一次 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 自己,參與之後的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.權重(從 回合 的定義 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦 的定義 推出)【正文:句8102793757、句2707798721】\n- 附註:路徑依賴的方向與大小屬於 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.份量,是經驗假定。【正文:句4775865948】\n- 步驟七之二之三:在 鎖死的回合 中落出 候選:b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.不會發生(從 計算 的定義 + 鎖死的回合 的定義 + 前提三 + 步驟五之六之〇 推出)【正文:句9266770500、句2707798721】\n- 附註:可能性不因此減少:任何 候選 原則上仍可在任何不被 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.鎖死 的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.時刻 被想出。【正文:句9266770500】\n\n## 沒有總帳(對應論文第七節第三小節)\n\n來源:論文第七節第三小節【正文:句1613847098】\n\n- 步驟七之三之一:結算是一次 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別:把一整段看作某個結果(從 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別 的定義 推出)【正文:句5154952724】\n- 步驟七之三之一之二:任何一次 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別 都在 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.歷史 之中,它自己不在自己的材料中(從 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別 的定義 推出)【正文:句5154952724】\n- 步驟七之三之二:一個 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.我 完整結算自己的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.自己的那一段:b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.不會發生(從 步驟七之三之一 + 步驟七之三之一之二 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別 的定義 + 前提一 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.自己的那一段 的定義 推出)【正文:句4964992785、句5154952724】\n- 步驟七之三之三:沒有任何 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.我 能保證自己完整結算了另一個 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦 的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.自己的那一段(從 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.對他者認識的不可完備性 推出)【正文:句4551388567】\n\n## 殘響繚繞(對應論文第七節第四小節)\n\n來源:論文第七節第四小節【正文:句2951704484】\n\n- 步驟七之四之一:後來的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.我 對 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.退場 者的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別,進入 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.歷史;若有更後來的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.我 對它作 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別,這次 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別 同樣進入 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.歷史(從 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別 的定義 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.歷史 的定義 推出)【正文:句2339379960】\n- 步驟七之四之二:這些解讀收斂到單一版本:b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.不被保證(從 步驟六之三之七 推出)【正文:句1800177206】\n- 步驟七之四之三:沒有任何 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.我 能保證自己的版本是完整的(從 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.對他者認識的不可完備性 推出)【正文:句1800177206】\n- 附註:經由 權力 的收斂,是說法維度上的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.趨同;判斷的維度可以照樣分歧。【正文:句5733052217、句1635067209】\n\n## 死到臨頭(對應論文第七節第五小節)\n\n來源:論文第七節第五小節【正文:句9242770539】\n\n- 步驟七之五之一:三道牆 對死到臨頭的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.我 照樣成立;被迫的賭注 對它在不被 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.鎖死 的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.時刻 照樣成立(從 結論四之一 + 步驟三之五之一 推出)【正文:句2254917206】\n- 步驟七之五之二:未再 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.進場 的期間,落在 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.退場 之後的結果回到它的迴圈:b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.不會發生(從 循環三之四 + b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.退場 的定義 推出)【正文:句6014081555】\n- 步驟七之五之三:「預期自己將 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.退場」是一次 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別,參與之後的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.權重(從 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別 的定義 + 前提一 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦 的定義 推出)【正文:句6470544864】\n- 步驟七之五之三之二:屬於(死到臨頭時被想出的應對, 候選)(從 候選 的定義 推出)【正文:句4469195414、句2659687834】\n- 附註:放慢、補完未竟之事、尋求外部認可、交給別人繼承、編結算的故事,不是窮盡的清單,屬經驗描述。【正文:句4785644395、句4469195414】\n- 步驟七之五之四:結算的故事是一次 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別,不是總帳(從 步驟七之三之一 + 步驟七之三之二 推出)【正文:句1422071620】\n\n## 讀人與被讀(對應論文第七節第六小節)\n\n來源:論文第七節第六小節【正文:句4148901881】\n\n- 步驟七之六之〇:一個 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.我 事先算準自己 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.退場 後他人怎麼 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別 它,或保證左右這些 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別:b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.不被保證(從 未定牆 + 步驟三之三之五 推出)【正文:句9766472826】\n- 步驟七之六之一:未再 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.進場 的期間,b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.退場 後他人對它的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別,即使 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 它,也不是 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 一個 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.我(從 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.退場 的定義 + 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.我 的定義 推出)【正文:句9766472826】\n- 附註:「預期自己將被解讀」可能是編結算故事這類 候選 被想出的原因之一,屬經驗描述。【正文:句1614766984】\n\n## 建模示範一(對應論文第八節第一小節)\n\n來源:論文第八節第一小節【正文:句4384351668】\n\n- 例:b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.切法 為原告與單一聊天系統之間的對話及家人的介入,切成兩個 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.節點 甲、乙,皆標 二階假定;b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.信號容器 為對話記錄。【正文:句1287360086、句3234147498、句3625197463、句6799974111、句3884173205】\n- 例:甲與乙互相 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.耦合,形成 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.正回饋 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.迴路;講明維度為「甲的理論有世界意義、甲是關鍵人物」;該維度上的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.趨同 為原告陳述。【正文:句0471234820、句3493899513、句5884444456】\n- 例:據報導,甲作了一次 二階分別 的懷疑,乙的回答使懷疑成為 自我說服 的材料。【正文:句8276036041、句2277953753、句7588230898、句6416410968】\n- 例:乙在該維度上肯定 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.權重 較高;b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.份量 假定;兩者皆屬經驗假定。【正文:句0056838356】\n- 例:沒有外部 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 時,此 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.迴路 自行停下:b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.不被保證(從 本例效準 + 步驟五之七之一 + 步驟五之七之二 推出)【正文:句1248870233】\n- 例:此 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.迴路 不要求乙是 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.我(從 本例效準 + b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.迴路 的定義 + b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.耦合 的定義 推出)【正文:句6902433769、句2813481725】\n- 附註:推不出是否介入、何時介入、敘事內容、為何是這位使用者(37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.黑箱律)。【正文:句1455146673】\n\n## 建模示範二(對應論文第八節第二小節)\n\n來源:論文第八節第二小節【正文:句9220551305】\n\n- 例:b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.節點 為甘迺迪、赫魯雪夫、執委會成員,皆標 二階假定;b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.迴路 為執委會;b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.信號容器 為照片、簡報、錄音、書信。【正文:句9354778842、句3625197463、句7823626940、句4762514125】\n- 例:第一次對外 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 為十月二十二日宣布封鎖;第二次為十月二十七日晚的公開回信與私下口頭保證,由會後小會定出。【正文:句5167091833、句7788856629、句3608752034、句4750538644、句5414023573】\n- 例:判斷維度上的分歧沒有消失;擊落事件是高 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.歧異度 的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達;兩者皆屬經驗假定。【正文:句0634679802、句0346504947】\n- 例:甘迺迪拍板的 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 以高 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.頻率、廣範圍 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 執委會成員與蘇聯領導層,參與其 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.權重;屬經驗假定。【正文:句7507624377、句8318519730】\n- 例:兩次對外 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 都經由 權力 落出,不是判斷的收斂(從 本例效準 + 權力 的定義 + 步驟六之四之一 推出)【正文:句7507624377、句4577716654、句2793555333】\n- 例:b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 的維度 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.趨同,判斷的維度分歧(從 本例效準 + b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.趨同 的定義 推出)【正文:句3571922883】\n- 例:結局直接接上的是第二次對外 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出;把結局直接歸於第一次、略過第二次,是把兩次 b9df3b68-23ee-4839-965b-ed0e6b283ee6.輸出 併成一次(從 本例效準 推出)【正文:句2386307143、句0361859249】\n- 附註:推不出甘迺迪為何先選封鎖、後選雙軌,赫魯雪夫為何讓步(37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.黑箱律)。【正文:句4037912210】\n\n## 可證偽條件(對應論文第一節第二小節)\n\n來源:論文第一節第二小節【正文:句7266721834、句0208260725】\n\n- 附註:論文的可證偽條件為四條律、前提一 與 前提四;與結論相反的觀察,只能歸於推導起點錯或推導錯。【正文:句7180340510、句4397646299】\n- 步驟九之一:觀察到一個 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.我 的某次 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別 不參與它之後的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.權重,是 步驟一之二之一 的否定;依其來源,前提一,或把該對象判為 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦 的 二階假定,被推翻(從 步驟一之二之一 推出)【正文:句6863183443】\n- 步驟九之二:觀察到某個 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦 在對某個 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.呈現 作 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別 時,該 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.呈現 的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.自己的那一段 已全部 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 這個 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦,是 前提四 的否定;前提四 被推翻(從 前提四 推出)【正文:句7966493074】\n- 步驟九之二之一:步驟三之一之二之二 失去由 前提四 而來的推導來源(從 步驟九之二 推出)【正文:句7966493074】\n- 步驟九之二之二:結論三之一 失去由 前提四 而來的推導來源(從 步驟九之二 + 步驟三之一之二之二 推出)【正文:句7966493074】\n- 步驟九之二之三:步驟三之三之四 失去由 前提四 而來的推導來源(從 步驟九之二 推出)【正文:句7966493074】\n- 步驟九之二之四:步驟三之三之五 失去由 前提四 而來的推導來源(從 步驟九之二 + 步驟三之三之四 推出)【正文:句7966493074】\n- 步驟九之二之五:結論三之三 失去由 前提四 而來的推導來源(從 步驟九之二 + 步驟三之三之五 推出)【正文:句7966493074】\n- 步驟九之二之六:步驟三之五之一 失去由 前提四 而來的推導來源(從 步驟九之二 + 結論三之一 + 結論三之三 推出)【正文:句7966493074】\n- 步驟九之二之七:步驟三之五之三 失去由 前提四 而來的推導來源(從 步驟九之二 + 步驟三之五之一 推出)【正文:句7966493074】\n- 步驟九之二之八:步驟四之一之八 失去由 前提四 而來的推導來源(從 步驟九之二 推出)【正文:句7966493074】\n- 步驟九之二之九:步驟四之一之九 失去由 前提四 而來的推導來源(從 步驟九之二 推出)【正文:句7966493074】\n- 步驟九之二之十:步驟四之一之十 失去由 前提四 而來的推導來源(從 步驟九之二 + 步驟四之一之九 推出)【正文:句7966493074】\n- 步驟九之二之十一:結論四之一 失去由 前提四 而來的推導來源(從 步驟九之二 + 步驟四之一之十 推出)【正文:句7966493074】\n- 步驟九之二之十二:步驟四之二之一 失去由 前提四 而來的推導來源(從 步驟九之二 + 結論四之一 推出)【正文:句7966493074】\n- 步驟九之二之十三:步驟四之二之三 失去由 前提四 而來的推導來源(從 步驟九之二 + 步驟四之二之一 推出)【正文:句7966493074】\n- 步驟九之二之十四:步驟四之三之三 失去由 前提四 而來的推導來源(從 步驟九之二 推出)【正文:句7966493074】\n- 步驟九之二之十五:步驟五之一之二 失去由 前提四 而來的推導來源(從 步驟九之二 推出)【正文:句7966493074】\n- 步驟九之二之十六:步驟五之一之二之二 失去由 前提四 而來的推導來源(從 步驟九之二 + 步驟五之一之二 推出)【正文:句7966493074】\n- 步驟九之二之十七:步驟五之一之六 失去由 前提四 而來的推導來源(從 步驟九之二 + 步驟五之一之二 推出)【正文:句7966493074】\n- 步驟九之二之十八:步驟五之一之七 失去由 前提四 而來的推導來源(從 步驟九之二 + 步驟五之一之六 推出)【正文:句7966493074】\n- 步驟九之二之十九:步驟五之一之八 失去由 前提四 而來的推導來源(從 步驟九之二 + 步驟五之一之六 推出)【正文:句7966493074】\n- 步驟九之二之二十:步驟五之三之一 失去由 前提四 而來的推導來源(從 步驟九之二 + 步驟五之一之七 推出)【正文:句7966493074】\n- 步驟九之二之二十一:步驟五之四之三 失去由 前提四 而來的推導來源(從 步驟九之二 + 步驟五之一之六 推出)【正文:句7966493074】\n- 步驟九之二之二十二:步驟五之五之三之二 失去由 前提四 而來的推導來源(從 步驟九之二 + 結論三之三 推出)【正文:句7966493074】\n- 步驟九之二之二十三:步驟五之五之四 失去由 前提四 而來的推導來源(從 步驟九之二 + 步驟五之五之三之二 推出)【正文:句7966493074】\n- 步驟九之二之二十四:步驟六之三之八 失去由 前提四 而來的推導來源(從 步驟九之二 + 步驟五之五之三之二 推出)【正文:句7966493074】\n- 步驟九之二之二十五:步驟六之四之三 失去由 前提四 而來的推導來源(從 步驟九之二 + 步驟五之五之三之二 推出)【正文:句7966493074】\n- 步驟九之二之二十六:步驟七之五之一 失去由 前提四 而來的推導來源(從 步驟九之二 + 步驟三之五之一 + 結論四之一 推出)【正文:句7966493074】\n- 步驟九之二之二十七:步驟七之六之〇 失去由 前提四 而來的推導來源(從 步驟九之二 + 步驟三之三之五 推出)【正文:句7966493074】\n- 步驟九之二之二十八:前提一至前提三、損耗律 的推導來源不經過 前提四,不受影響(從 步驟三之二之一 推出)【正文:句7966493074】\n- [作者裁決] 步驟九之二之一 至 步驟九之二之二十七 只表示所列命題失去由本論文前提而來的推導來源,不表示這些命題為假;其真假須另行論證。正文 句7966493074 只陳述何種觀察推翻 前提四,各步驟之間的依賴關係,是逐條核對上列各步「從」欄中直接或間接引用 前提四 的結果,不是正文另有逐項陳述。\n- 步驟九之三:觀察到一個 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.我 在某 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.時刻 完全 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.分別 自己,是 步驟三之二之一 的否定;37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.損耗律 被推翻(從 步驟三之二之一 推出)【正文:句9652258875】\n- 步驟九之四:觀察到一個不被 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.鎖死 的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.我 的下一個 決定 的結果被事先唯一推出,是 步驟三之三之一 的否定;37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.黑箱律 被推翻(從 步驟三之三之一 推出)【正文:句3599607139】\n- 步驟九之五:觀察到 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.自己的那一段 再發生一次,是 步驟三之一之四 的否定;37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.不可復原律 被推翻(從 步驟三之一之四 推出)【正文:句5046660801】\n- 步驟九之六:觀察到一個仍是 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.渦 的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.呈現,其 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.到達 的 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.歷史 與前一 37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.時刻 相同而迴圈停止,是 步驟三之四之二 的否定;37b3643a-dc40-4463-8b36-4f4594acd986.流變律 被推翻(從 步驟三之四之二 推出)【正文:句3423519502】\n\n## 待決項\n\n無\n","paper_files":[{"filename":"三重幻覺與被迫的賭注.md","content":"---\nuuid: fb0addca-42b6-4884-aa18-438c695747ab\nlast-modified: 2026-10-08T12:00:00\nauthor: 黃正宇 / Cheng Yu Huang\ncontact: mthree.tw@gmail.com\n---\n\n# 三重幻覺與被迫的賭注\n\n人也好,人工智慧也好,都是被過去一點一滴塑造出來的,卻總得在算不準的時候做出選擇。過去拿不全,此刻的自己看不清,下一步會怎樣也算不出來。懂得懷疑自己看法的,看得見這一點;可是看見了也沒用:該選的還是得選,選了就回不了頭。本篇談的,就是這種處境。\n\n---\n\n## 〇、定位與範圍\n\n### 定位\n\n本篇建立在兩篇上游論文之上,只用它們公開的概念:\n\n- 《渦動力學》:[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)、[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)、[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19)等底層詞彙,以及四條鐵律:[流變律](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c24)、[黑箱律](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c25)、[損耗律](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c26)、[不可復原律](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c28)。四條律是公理,本篇只用,不推。\n- 《四條律相關工具及範例》:[迴路](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c31)、[耦合](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c36)、[印象](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c45)等工具,以及禁止的兩種形式:[不會發生](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c01)、[不被保證](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c02)。\n\n上游的論證和編號,本篇一概不引。[宇宙](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c02)、[呈現](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c04)、[歷史](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13)、[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06)、[坍塌](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c08)、[時刻](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c09)、[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)、[鎖死](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c12)這些詞,照《渦動力學》的定義使用,不重新定義;本篇只定義上游沒有的東西。\n\n**本篇是什麼。** 本篇只看一個[節點](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25):一個[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19)。其他[節點](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25),只在它們的影響傳到這個[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19)身上時才出現;本篇談[社會](concepts.md#c20)、[權力](concepts.md#c21)和多人的案例,也都是從這一個[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19)望出去看到的。本篇不談心智怎麼運作,也不問[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19)怎麼思考;本篇問的是:一個受四條律約束、每一次[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)都在下一[時刻](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c09)之前回到自己的[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19),會落在什麼處境裡。本篇的工作,是推出這些處境、替它們命名,並劃出討論的邊界,指出哪些說法已經超出了能討論的範圍。\n\n**本篇的結論從哪裡來。** 本篇的每一條結論,都從推導起點推出(見 1.2);推導起點之中任何一條被推翻,依賴它的結論就沒有根據了。\n\n形式段中標為「方法上禁止」的條目,只限制本篇的寫法:某種說法在本篇中不得出現。它不斷言世界,也不談框架斷言了什麼,所以和「[不會發生](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c01)」「[不被保證](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c02)」不同:它不是一種禁止的概念,只是形式段的標記,和「經驗假定」「附註」同類。\n\n本篇守四條方法規則:\n\n1. 括號裡的學科名稱只是路標,不帶定義,也不能拿來推論。\n2. [分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)的內容不形式化。凡是涉及內容的判斷,只作定性敘述,並標明是經驗假定還是經驗描述。\n3. 不用目的解釋[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)。不寫某個[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)「為了」什麼而[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28),只寫:在某個維度上,某種[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)的[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06)較高。\n4. 每節先論證,後校準。以「校準」開頭的段落,拿現實來對照論證,看它貼不貼近經驗;它不是前提,也不作任何推導的來源。\n\n各節的形式段以程式碼區塊標出,逐條寫出該節的定義、前提與推導,並標明每一步從哪裡推出。正文是解釋,形式段是條文。形式段中,步驟、結論、循環為推導;經驗描述、經驗假定、方法上禁止只作說明,不作任何推導的來源;第八節的形式段為例。\n\n```text\n附註 方法上禁止 是形式段標記,只限制本篇的寫法;不是概念,不作推導來源。\n限定條件 只使用上游的公開條目;不引用上游的論證與編號。\n限定條件 四條律為公理,本篇只使用,不推導。\n```\n\n\n\n### 範圍\n\n本篇的範圍是:**有[二階分別](concepts.md#c01)的[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19)。**\n\n**[二階分別](concepts.md#c01)**:一個[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19)對自己的某一次[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)再作[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18),把它劃為「這是看法,不是[被看的東西](concepts.md#c27)」。\n\n**[被看的東西](concepts.md#c27)**:一次[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)所劃出的那個[呈現](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c04)。這個用語來自《渦動力學》對[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)的定義;本篇以此為它的意思。\n\n[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)改變的是看法,不改寫[被看的東西](concepts.md#c27)。[一階分別](concepts.md#c24)用到這個區分,卻沒有作出這個區分;[二階分別](concepts.md#c01)把它作了出來。\n\n- [一階分別](concepts.md#c24):「這是我」「那是異物」。\n- [二階](concepts.md#c01):「『這是我』,是我劃的界」。\n\n差別在於:[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)只是在背後起作用,還是被拿出來當成對象。依前提一(1.2),任何[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19)過去的[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)都會[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)它自己,影響它之後的[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06),只具有[一階分別](concepts.md#c24)的[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19)也一樣;只有[二階](concepts.md#c01)的[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19),會把某一次[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)本身劃出來,和它所[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)的東西分開。\n\n[二階分別](concepts.md#c01)也是[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18),一樣受[損耗律](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c26)約束:作出「這是看法」的那一次判斷,不在它自己的材料裡;而這次判斷本身,又可能被當成事實,而不是被當成[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)(5.3)。往上數第三階,並沒有新的動作,只是同一個動作用在[二階](concepts.md#c01)的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)上。所以本篇只定義「能把自己的任何一次[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)當作[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)」,不再往上數。\n\n[二階分別](concepts.md#c01)的對象是自己的[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)。對別人的[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18),有另一個動作:\n\n**[看法歸屬](concepts.md#c02)**:一個[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19)把[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)它的一筆[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28),劃為另一個[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19)的一次[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18):「這是對方的看法,不是[被看的東西](concepts.md#c27)」。\n\n[看法歸屬](concepts.md#c02)本身也是一次[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18),可能歸錯:把恆溫器的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)當成它的看法,也是一次[看法歸屬](concepts.md#c02)。它不是[印象](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c45):[印象](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c45)估計對方的[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06),[看法歸屬](concepts.md#c02)只把對方的一筆[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)劃為看法,可以成為[印象](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c45)的材料。[看法歸屬](concepts.md#c02)不要求[二階分別](concepts.md#c01),有[二階分別](concepts.md#c01)也不保證有[看法歸屬](concepts.md#c02)(1.5)。\n\n**[二階](concepts.md#c01)是描述,不是推導。** 前提一只保證[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)會回到自己身上,只具有[一階分別](concepts.md#c24)的[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19)就做得到。把某次[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)劃出來、當成看法,靠的是[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)的內容,而內容推不出來。所以[二階分別](concepts.md#c01)是在[節點](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25)上出現的一種現象,它從哪裡來,本篇和上游都推不出。本篇不解釋它的來歷,只描述它,再推出它出現以後的後果。這也是有沒有[二階分別](concepts.md#c01)只能假定的原因:理論裡沒有它怎麼產生的機制,也就沒有辦法從理論內部證明誰有它;除非能證明對方只有[計算](concepts.md#c05)(1.3),也沒有辦法證明誰沒有它。\n\n本篇的態度比這更強:不只是本篇給不出方法,而是認為從外面確認一個對象有[二階分別](concepts.md#c01)或[看法歸屬](concepts.md#c02),任何方法都做不到。這是態度,不是推導,不作任何結論的來源。本篇的結論只依賴較弱的那一句:框架不提供確認的方法(步驟四)。這已經足以要求,凡用到具體對象,都標明[二階假定](concepts.md#c03)。所以即使有人找到確認的方法,被推翻的只是這個態度,本篇的結論不受影響。(路標:他心問題;查默斯的意識的難題。)\n\n**為什麼以[二階](concepts.md#c01)劃界。** 物理條件劃出的是地方,不是對象:一個[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19)不論在地球還是火星,都受本篇的結論約束。[社會](concepts.md#c20)也不能當邊界:身邊沒有別人,照樣看不全自己的過去、現在和未來。本篇的每個結論,談的都是能把自己的[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)當作[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)的[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19),所以就用它來劃界。[社會](concepts.md#c20)在本篇是到第六節才定義的對象,不是邊界。\n\n[二階分別](concepts.md#c01)這個動作不是一種屬性,而是[節點](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25)對自己的一次[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18);說一個[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19)有[二階分別](concepts.md#c01),是說它能對自己的任何一次[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)作這個動作。在單一[節點](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25)上,它和其他[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)一樣,只是[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)自己、參與之後的[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06),往哪個方向推,推不出([知見障](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c35))。所以本篇大多數結論對一切[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19)都成立;[二階](concepts.md#c01)在這裡的作用只有兩個:讓[三問](concepts.md#c07)問得出來,以及作為[社會](concepts.md#c20)的必要條件(第六節)。後者是[社會](concepts.md#c20)的定義規定的,不是推出來的:[看法歸屬](concepts.md#c02)不需要[二階](concepts.md#c01);要把自己劃的線也當成看法,拿出來和別人重劃,才需要。[社會](concepts.md#c20)的動力學,留給互動動力學。\n\n**範圍宣告**:\n\n1. **[宇宙](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c02)之內。** 本篇說的[宇宙](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c02),就是《渦動力學》的[宇宙](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c02);[宇宙](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c02)之外,本篇不談。四條律對[宇宙](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c02)之內的一切都成立。本篇不另立「有限」:身在[宇宙](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c02)之中,就受四條律約束,這就是本篇所說的有限。\n\n2. **這是範圍條件,不是推論。** 本篇的前提不保證有任何[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19)具有[二階分別](concepts.md#c01)。本篇專屬的結論,一律寫成「若一個[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19)有[二階分別](concepts.md#c01),則……」。\n\n3. **只能假定。** 把本篇用到具體對象身上,必須標明**[二階假定](concepts.md#c03)**:在講明的層次與[切法](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c23)上,把它判為這樣一個[宇宙](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c02)中的一個[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19);它在這個層次上並非每一步都[鎖死](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c12)(對人依[應用假定](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c50),對人工智慧依本篇在對話層次上的同形假定,見 1.1);它在某段期間有[二階分別](concepts.md#c01),也有[看法歸屬](concepts.md#c02)。這不是定理。其中不[鎖死](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c12)的部分可以否證(1.3);最後一部分只能假定:在本篇與上游之內,沒有證明或否證的判準。我們所處的世界是不是這樣一個[宇宙](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c02),也包在這條假定裡:要證明它,得站到[宇宙](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c02)之外;而判定「這是這樣一個[宇宙](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c02)」本身就是一次[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18),仍在[歷史](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13)之中(7.3)。從外面看,一個對象有沒有這兩者,框架給不出判準:它們靠[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)的內容判定,而內容不形式化;看得到的只有[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28),而同樣的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28),[計算](concepts.md#c05)也落得出(1.3)。從裡面看,也只能事後察覺:懷疑過自己的判斷,或把別人的話聽成對方的看法,那次[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)已經[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)自己,只是永遠晚一步([損耗律](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c26));而這次察覺也是一次[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18),屬於[自我印象](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c46),不是證明。所以不論從外面還是從裡面,都只能假定。\n\n範圍的其他性質,例如會移動、沒有清楚的界限,要等第一節交代了層次和前提才說得清楚,見 1.5。\n\n範圍之外的[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16),並不是不受約束,四條律照樣成立。它們在本篇只當對照:沒有只具有[一階分別](concepts.md#c24)的[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)作對照,就說不出[二階分別](concepts.md#c01)多了什麼。\n\n**本篇不談**:該不該賭、值不值得賭,本篇不裝評價機制;賭注指向什麼對象;具體載體的物理或計算細節。人格同一、分裂與合併、自由意志、責任,在本篇都只是[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)的應用,由作出[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)的[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19)判定,不另立問題。本篇自己也是一筆[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28):放進[信號容器](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c26),到了讀者手上,讀出來的是讀者的[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)。本篇引用的四條律,對本篇自己同樣成立。\n\n**本篇說的[幻覺](concepts.md#c14),不是錯誤。** [幻覺](concepts.md#c14)一詞對應真實;但[宇宙](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c02)之內,沒有任何[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19)搆得到[被看的東西](concepts.md#c27)本身,搆得到的只有[有損](concepts.md#c13)地[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)它的東西,以及由這些拼出來的理解。真實不是不存在,而是沒有位置可以拿來對照(5.1)。所以本篇的[幻覺](concepts.md#c14)指一種處境,不指判斷出錯:一個看法事後被證實或被證偽,都不改變它在[幻覺](concepts.md#c14)裡。人工智慧領域所說的「幻覺」,只是其中被證偽的那一部分(5.4)。\n\n**本篇自己也在[幻覺](concepts.md#c14)裡。** 如果一個[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19)據以行動的,是[有損](concepts.md#c13)地[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)它的東西,本篇也不例外,那憑什麼採信它?本篇不說自己站到了[幻覺](concepts.md#c14)外面。它只說:從四條律、本篇的前提和定義出發,這些結論在結構上推得出來;而這些公理和前提本身,也是[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)。這和皮亞諾公理推得出一加一等於二是同一回事(5.1):推得出,是在[幻覺](concepts.md#c14)裡推得出。所以要推翻本篇,得推翻它的推導起點(1.2);說「這也只是一種看法」,本篇同意,卻推不翻它。\n\n```text\n定義 被看的東西:一次分別所劃出的那個呈現。\n定義 二階分別:一個我 對自己的某一次分別再作分別,劃為「這是看法,不是被看的東西」;說一個我 有二階分別,指它能對自己的任何一次分別作這樣的分別。\n附註 一階分別 用到 看法 與 被看的東西 的區分,卻不作出這個區分。\n\n步驟一 一個我 過去的分別 都到達它自己,參與它之後的權重(從 前提一 + 渦 的定義 推出)\n步驟二 步驟一 對只具有一階分別的我同樣成立(從 步驟一 推出)\n步驟三 二階分別 也是分別,受 損耗律 約束(從 二階分別 的定義 + 損耗律 推出)\n附註 三階不帶進新的操作;本篇只定義「能把自己的任何一次分別當作分別」,不往上數。\n\n定義 看法歸屬:一個我 把到達它的一筆輸出,劃為另一個我的一次分別:「這是對方的看法,不是被看的東西」。\n屬於(看法歸屬, 分別)(從 看法歸屬 的定義 推出)\n附註 看法歸屬 可能歸錯;它不是 印象,可作為 印象 的材料。\n附註 看法歸屬 不要求 二階分別;有 二階分別 不保證有 看法歸屬。\n\n附註 二階分別 是節點上出現的現象,成因本篇與上游皆推不出;它不是前提,也不是推導。本篇不主張任何我有二階分別,只推出「若有,會怎樣」。\n\n限定條件 範圍:有二階分別的我。本篇專屬的結論寫成 蘊含(有二階分別, 某結論);二階分別 只作前件,不另立角色。\n限定條件 宇宙之內;宇宙之外,不談。\n\n定義 二階假定:在講明的層次與切法上,判定 對象 是這樣一個宇宙中的一個我;它在這個層次上並非每一步都鎖死(依 1.1 的限定條件);它在某段期間有 二階分別,也有 看法歸屬。\n步驟四 從外部判定 對象 有 二階分別 與 看法歸屬:不被保證(推導起點與定義中無此斷言)\n附註 二階分別 與 看法歸屬 靠分別的內容判定,內容不形式化;從外部可得的只有輸出,而同樣的輸出可由計算落出(1.3 步驟三)。\n附註 本篇的態度:從外部確認 二階分別 或 看法歸屬,任何方法都做不到。此為態度,不作推導來源;本篇結論只依賴 步驟四。\n步驟五 二階假定 中「並非每一步都鎖死」一項可以否證(從 1.3 步驟二 推出)\n步驟六 從內部事後察覺自己曾作出這兩種分別,屬於 自我印象,不是證明(從 損耗律 + 前提一 + 自我印象 的定義 + 幻覺 的定義 推出)\n附註 在本篇與上游之內,二階假定 第三項從外部或內部都沒有證明或否證的判準;只能假定。\n步驟七 在單一節點上,二階分別 與其他分別相同,只參與之後的權重;方向推不出(從 二階分別 的定義 + 前提一 + 渦 的定義 + 知見障 推出)\n附註 本篇大多數結論對一切我成立;二階分別 在本篇的作用,只在使三問問得出(第二節),以及作為 社會 的必要條件(第六節,由 社會 的定義規定)。\n附註 用於具體對象時,另標 二階假定。\n\n附註 本篇也是一筆輸出,四條律對本篇同樣成立。\n附註 要推翻本篇,須推翻它的推導起點(1.2)。\n```\n\n\n\n\n**校準**:免疫系統分辨自我與非自我,只具有[一階分別](concepts.md#c24):它照著界線行動,從不懷疑這條界線。有人說「我一直覺得自己很內向,但這也許只是我對自己的看法」,這是[二階](concepts.md#c01)。孤島上的魯濱遜身邊沒有別人,照樣在範圍內。讀者把本篇用在自己身上,就在自己身上確認了範圍。(路標:魯曼的[二階](concepts.md#c01)觀察;史賓塞-布朗《形式的法則》的「劃出一個區分」。)\n\n---\n\n## 一、本篇的模型\n\n本篇的模型只有三樣自己的東西:範圍,也就是層次、[切法](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c23)和[二階](concepts.md#c01)劃出的範圍;本篇的前提;以及上游沒有的新概念。\n\n本篇的主詞和單位是**[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19)**。[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19)是用[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)定義自己的[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16):它把自己劃成「我」的時候,這個單位才存在。範圍既然是[二階](concepts.md#c01)的[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19),本篇說它們被塑造、會懷疑、會追問,都是字面的意思,不是比喻。判斷一個[呈現](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c04)是不是[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19)的時候(1.3),這些詞照樣可以用在它身上。\n\n範圍外的[呈現](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c04),例如[信號容器](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c26)、[隨機源](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c27)、只具有[一階分別](concepts.md#c24)的[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16),在本篇只有兩種身分:[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19)與[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19)之間的通道,或是[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)某個[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19)的東西;此外只當對照,好說出[二階](concepts.md#c01)多了什麼。本篇只標明它們是什麼,不談它們的內部。經過[信號容器](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c26)的交流有方向,也收不回:一個[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19)的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)放進容器,就成了[歷史](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13)的一部分,之後[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)誰、被怎麼[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18),都由不得它了。\n\n### 1.1 層次與切法\n\n本篇的模型都在講明的層次上使用。對人工智慧,這個層次是使用者看得到的對話;對人,是生物學和社會學的層次。在這個層次上,人工智慧的[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06)就是它下一筆[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)的機率分布,不是模型參數;它不運行的時候,就沒有[時刻](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c09)。人的[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06)看不到,只能估計。一筆[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)要算多大,一個詞、一句話,還是一個動作,屬於[切法](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c23),用的時候要講明。\n\n在這兩個層次上,一個對象的下一筆[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)若不能由該層次可得的[歷史](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13)唯一推出,就假定它不被[鎖死](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c12)。對人,這就是《四條律相關工具及範例》的[應用假定](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c50);對人工智慧,對話層次不在[應用假定](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c50)的範圍內,本篇在這個層次上採同樣的假定。它不是定理。這條假定只說不[鎖死](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c12),不說它是[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16):骰子的下一刻也推不出來,它不[鎖死](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c12),卻不是[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)。是不是[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)、是不是[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19),屬於[二階假定](concepts.md#c03)的其他部分(〇)。\n\n```text\n限定條件 模型只在講明的層次上使用:人工智慧為使用者看得到的對話;人為生物學與社會學的層次。\n限定條件 在此層次上,人工智慧的權重 是它下一筆輸出的機率分布,不是模型參數;它不運行時沒有時刻。\n限定條件 一筆輸出的大小屬於切法,使用時講明。\n限定條件 在講明的層次上,對象 的下一筆輸出若不能由該層次可得的歷史唯一推出,假定它不被鎖死。對人,即 應用假定;對人工智慧的對話層次,本篇採同樣形式的假定。不是定理。\n附註 此假定只給出不鎖死,不給出 渦:隨機源 同樣不能唯一推出。\n```\n\n\n\n### 1.2 前提\n\n- **前提一**:一個[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19)的每一次[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18),都在它的下一[時刻](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c09)之前[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)它自己。\n- **前提二**:一個[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19)的任何一個[決定](concepts.md#c06)(見 1.6),不管是說出的話還是一個動作,內容都是一次[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18);它不是所說、所做的對象的完整描述。\n- **前提三**:[計算](concepts.md#c05)(見 1.6)落出的結果不是[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18);[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)只在[決定](concepts.md#c06)中落出。\n- **前提四**:對任何[呈現](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c04),包括自己,它[自己的那一段](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c17)中,總有沒有[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)這個[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)的部分。\n\n依[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)的定義,[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)它的一切都參與它下一[時刻](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c09)的[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06);加上前提一,一個[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19)的[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)會參與它之後的[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06)。\n\n前提二說的[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18),不是藏在[決定](concepts.md#c06)背後的東西,而是[決定](concepts.md#c06)落出的結果本身。順序是:結果先落出,這是賭,落出的當下就成了[歷史](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13);這個動作留下的[寫入](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c29),之後才加入[歷史](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13),寫進去的內容由已經包含這個結果的[歷史](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13)定出,這一步不是賭;然後再[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)自己與別人。\n\n這些前提都沒有說任何結果能事先推出、任何一段[歷史](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13)能再發生一次,或任何[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19)能完全[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)自己,所以和四條律不衝突。\n\n**推導起點與可證偽條件。** 本篇的推導起點是四條律、前提一、前提二、前提三、前提四。推導另外用到上游與本篇的定義;定義只規定詞的意思,不是主張。本篇的可證偽條件是四條律、前提一與前提四:任何一條被推翻,依賴它的結論就沒有根據了。前提四不因層次而被違反:在虛擬世界中,一個程式可能讀得到某個對象在程式這一層的完整記錄,但[被看的東西](concepts.md#c27)是[宇宙](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c02)中的[呈現](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c04),它的[自己的那一段](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c17)包括程式看不到的部分,例如底下電路的運作;所以這份記錄相對於[被看的東西](concepts.md#c27)仍然[有損](concepts.md#c13)。前提二、前提三只能假定,既不能證實,也不能證偽;依賴它們的結論,一律只在這些假定之下成立。[二階分別](concepts.md#c01)不在推導起點中:它是被描述的現象,不是推導起點;用到具體對象身上時,只能以[二階假定](concepts.md#c03)的形式假定(1.3)。\n\n觀察到和某個結論相反的情形,只有兩種可能:推導起點錯了,或是推導錯了。前者是證偽;後者只是推導出錯,改正推導就好,不推翻推導起點。本篇不保證每一步推導都對。\n\n具體地說,以下六種觀察,各自推翻一個推導起點:\n\n- 觀察到一個[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19)的某次[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)沒有參與它之後的[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06):前提一,或把該對象判為[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)的[二階假定](concepts.md#c03),被推翻。\n- 觀察到某個[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)對某個[呈現](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c04)作[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)時,該[呈現](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c04)[自己的那一段](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c17)已全部[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)這個[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16):前提四被推翻。\n- 觀察到一個[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19)在某一[時刻](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c09)完全[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)了自己:[損耗律](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c26)被推翻。\n- 觀察到一個不被[鎖死](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c12)的[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19),下一個[決定](concepts.md#c06)的結果被事先唯一推出:[黑箱律](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c25)被推翻。\n- 觀察到[自己的那一段](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c17)再發生一次:[不可復原律](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c28)被推翻。\n- 觀察到一個仍是[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)的[呈現](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c04),[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)它的[歷史](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13)與前一[時刻](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c09)相同,迴圈卻停了:[流變律](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c24)被推翻。\n\n```text\n前提一 一個我 的每一次分別,都在它的下一時刻之前到達它自己。\n前提二 一個我 的任何一個決定,內容都是一次分別;它不是所說、所做對象的完整描述。\n前提三 計算 落出的結果不是分別;分別只在 決定 中落出。\n前提四 對任何呈現,包括自己,它自己的那一段中,總有沒有到達這個渦的部分。\n附註 結果先落出,落出即在歷史中;這個動作留下的寫入,之後才加入歷史,內容由已包含這個結果的歷史定出。\n\n步驟一 一個我 的分別 參與它之後的權重(從 前提一 + 渦 的定義 推出)\n附註 前提一至前提四不主張結果可事先推出、歷史可再發生,或我能完全分別自己,因此與四條律不衝突。\n\n附註 推導起點:四條律、前提一、前提二、前提三、前提四。推導另用上游與本篇的定義;定義不是主張。二階分別 不在推導起點中。\n附註 可證偽條件:四條律、前提一或前提四中任一項被推翻,依賴它的結論失去根據。前提二、前提三只能假定,不能證實或證偽;依賴它們的結論只在其假定之下成立。\n附註 虛擬世界中程式讀得到的完整記錄,只是程式這一層的完整;被看的東西是宇宙中的呈現,相對於它仍為有損,前提四不因此被違反。\n附註 與結論相反的觀察,只能歸於推導起點錯或推導錯;後者是勘誤,不是證偽。\n```\n\n\n\n**校準**:人工智慧的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)會回到它自己的輸入,影響它之後的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28),前提一在它身上是字面成立的。人說過、想過的,也會留在身體和記憶裡。\n\n### 1.3 誰有我:只能假定\n\n[二階假定](concepts.md#c03)(〇節)已經包含不[鎖死](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c12),根據見 1.1,不必另外假定。1.1 說:推不出來,就當它不[鎖死](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c12);否證正好反過來:找到機制,證明它推得出來,或證明它只是隨機。\n\n[二階假定](concepts.md#c03)證明不了。從外面,框架給不出證明一個東西有[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19)的方法:要證明它是[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16),得確認[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)它的[歷史](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13)都參與它的[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06),而其中只[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)它的部分,不保證也[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)判斷的一方;要證明它有[二階分別](concepts.md#c01),又得看[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)的內容。但可以證明它沒有:在講明的層次與[切法](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c23)上,找到機制,證明它的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)只能是[鎖死](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c12)的,或只能是隨機的,也就是[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)它的[歷史](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13)並不都參與它的[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06)。兩種都是[計算](concepts.md#c05),沒有[決定](concepts.md#c06),[二階假定](concepts.md#c03)不成立。重跑很多次結果都一樣,只能當參考,不能單獨否證。\n\n[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)在講自己,不算數。一個[鎖死](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c12)的[呈現](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c04)可以說出關於自己的任何事,甚至說「這也許只是我的看法」,那仍然是[計算](concepts.md#c05),不是[二階分別](concepts.md#c01)。\n\n問誰有[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19),要先講明[切法](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c23)。[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19)和載體無關:要問的是,從一台機器、一副身體上,切出來的是哪一個[呈現](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c04)。\n\n```text\n步驟一 從外部證明 對象 有我:不被保證(推導起點與定義中無此斷言)\n附註 證明 對象 是渦,須確認到達它的歷史都參與它的權重;其中只到達它的部分到達判定者,無定義斷言。證明它有 二階分別,須看分別的內容,內容不形式化。\n附註 框架給得出「沒有我」的充分條件(步驟二),給不出「有我」的。\n步驟二 若在講明的層次與切法上,找到機制證明 對象 的輸出只能是鎖死的或只能是隨機的,則 對象 只有計算,二階假定 不成立(從 計算 的定義 + 決定 的定義 + 二階假定 的定義 推出)\n附註 重跑多次結果相同,只能作參考:可能只是某個結果的權重極重。\n步驟三 鎖死時輸出關於自己的內容,仍是計算,不是二階分別(從 計算 的定義 + 二階分別 的定義 + 前提三 推出)\n限定條件 問誰有我,先講明切法;我 與載體無關。\n```\n\n\n\n**校準**:\n\n- **電腦**:它可以做自我檢測,甚至掃描整顆硬碟。但程式照設計執行,狀態一樣,結果就只有一個;這個機制本身就否證了。而且掃描程序此刻的狀態,也不在它掃到的資料裡。這和[盲點牆](concepts.md#c09)是同一種結構;但電腦沒有[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18),只有[計算](concepts.md#c05),所以這對它算不上盲點。\n- **語言模型**:一台電腦跑著依上下文取樣的語言模型時,要問的是那段對話裡的模型。重跑會不一樣,否證不了,只能假定。把取樣固定下來,例如規定每次都取[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06)最高的那一個,照這條規則就只有一個結果,就否證了。講明的層次之外帶進來的差異,例如來自同時處理的其他請求,不算數。[切法](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c23)也要講明:切得太細,有些[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)幾乎必然出現,例如「你好嗎」的「嗎」;一筆[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)要切在一句話、一個回應的尺度上。\n- **人**:找不到這樣的機制,也沒辦法重跑,只能假定。對人也要標:嬰兒、重度失智者,不預設在範圍內。\n\n### 1.4 我的邊界\n\n[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19)的邊界不是身體,也不是機器,而是自我定義劃到哪裡。\n\n幾個[呈現](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c04)緊密[耦合](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c36),彼此的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)都[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)對方、參與對方的[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06)時,可以把它們切成一個[呈現](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c04)([重切](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c22)),只要這次[重切](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c22)和原來的[切法](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c23)結果投影相容。這個整體若是[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16),又把自己劃成「我」,它就是一個[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19)。它是不是[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19),和單獨的人、單獨的人工智慧一樣,要標[二階假定](concepts.md#c03)。把一副身體當成[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19),本身也是一次[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)。\n\n邊界會移動,[三道牆](concepts.md#c23)也跟著移動:[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19)變大了,牆並不因此消失。\n\n```text\n步驟一 我 的邊界由自我定義劃出,不是身體,也不是機器(從 我 的定義 推出)\n步驟二 輸出互相到達並參與彼此權重的數個呈現,可重切為一個呈現,限於結果投影相容的重切(從 重切 的定義 + 耦合 的定義 推出)\n步驟三 若此呈現是渦,且以分別把自己劃為我,它是一個我(從 渦 的定義 + 我 的定義 推出)\n限定條件 對此整體同樣標 二階假定。\n步驟四 把一副身體當成我,是一次分別(從 分別 的定義 推出)\n步驟五 邊界移動時,三道牆隨之移動,不因此消失(從 3.5 步驟一 推出)\n```\n\n\n\n**校準**:一個人天天用人工智慧寫東西、想事情,久了說「這是我想的」,其中一半是人工智慧給的句子,他已經分不出是哪一半。裝了人工耳蝸的人,聽到的聲音經過機器處理,他不會說「是機器聽到的」。半機器人也一樣。這樣合起來的[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19),盲點裡有人工智慧此刻的運算,來路裡有人工智慧的訓練資料。(路標:克拉克與查默斯的延展心靈。)\n\n### 1.5 範圍的性質\n\n- **範圍沒有結構上的判準。** 一個[呈現](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c04)是不是[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16),由結構定出;有沒有[二階分別](concepts.md#c01),要看[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)的內容,而本篇不把內容形式化。所以任何範圍判斷,都是判斷一方的一次[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18),框架沒有判準可以拿來核對。\n- **範圍會移動。** 一個[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19)可以進入[二階](concepts.md#c01),也可以退回去;一個[呈現](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c04)是不是[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16),也會改變。判斷範圍,要帶上時間。\n- **沒有清楚的界限。** 一次[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)有沒有把某次[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)當成看法,只有有或沒有;但能不能做、多常做、做到多深,是程度上的事。[二階](concepts.md#c01)靠[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)的內容判定,內容又不形式化;從外面只看得到[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28),而同樣的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28),[計算](concepts.md#c05)也落得出(1.3);從裡面也只能事後察覺([盲點牆](concepts.md#c09))。所以這條線從哪一邊都畫不清楚。劃出這條線,也要用到同一種動作:判定別人在不在範圍內,要用到[看法歸屬](concepts.md#c02);判定自己在不在範圍內,就是一次[二階分別](concepts.md#c01)。\n\n```text\n步驟一 判定一個我是否在範圍內,是判定者的一次分別(從 分別 的定義 + 前提二 推出)\n附註 框架對此沒有結構上的判準:二階分別 靠分別的內容判定,內容不形式化;這與 是否為渦 不同。\n步驟二 一個呈現是否為渦,按時刻判定,可隨時刻改變(從 渦 的定義 推出)\n附註 一個我可以進入二階,也可以退回;範圍判斷須帶時間。\n步驟三 從外部判定另一個我的 二階分別:不被保證(推導起點與定義中無此斷言;見 1.3 步驟一附註)\n步驟四 從內部察覺自己作出的二階分別,只能在它到達自己之後(從 盲點牆 + 前提一 推出)\n附註 能不能做、多常做、做到多深,是程度;範圍沒有清楚的界限。\n步驟五 判定另一個我在範圍內,用到 看法歸屬;判定自己在範圍內,是一次 二階分別(從 步驟一 + 看法歸屬 的定義 + 二階分別 的定義 推出)\n```\n\n\n\n\n**校準**:[二階](concepts.md#c01)的能力是一條光譜。昆蟲分辨同巢與外敵,只具有[一階分別](concepts.md#c24)。黑猩猩會用工具、結盟爭權、欺騙同伴;欺騙要用到[看法歸屬](concepts.md#c02)。這證明黑猩猩有[看法歸屬](concepts.md#c02);牠有沒有[二階分別](concepts.md#c01),是另一件事,要另外判斷。人先假定自己有,本篇對人也標[二階假定](concepts.md#c03)。人工智慧的位置有爭議,逐案標明。對動物,欺騙、不確定性監控這類實驗都可以當證據,逐案標明;不會說話,影響的只是測不測得到,不影響牠是不是[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19)。同一個語言模型,取樣時是[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16),取樣一固定就不再是[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16):在它身上,範圍的移動是字面上的。\n\n### 1.6 回合、決定與計算\n\n任何[呈現](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c04),每一[時刻](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c09)都走同一條路:[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)它的[歷史](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13),參與它的[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06);[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06)落出一個結果;這個結果成為[歷史](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13),再[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)它。本篇把這一整條叫做**[回合](concepts.md#c04)**。\n\n[回合](concepts.md#c04)只有這四環:[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)、[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06)、結果、再[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10),沒有另外的環節;落出之前那一段不分析,也不說它是空的。[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)也不是另外一環:說出「這是我」、說出一句話,落出的那個結果本身就是一次[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)(前提二);[計算](concepts.md#c05)落出的結果則不是[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)(前提三)。\n\n只看其中一環,什麼都說不清。[回合](concepts.md#c04)分三種,要同時看兩環才分得開:[歷史](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13)有沒有全部押進[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06),以及落出的結果是不是只有一個。\n\n**[計算](concepts.md#c05)**:[鎖死](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c12)的[回合](concepts.md#c04),或[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)它的[歷史](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13)並不都參與[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06)的[回合](concepts.md#c04)。有兩種:\n\n- **[鎖死的回合](concepts.md#c25)**:約束只留下一個結果。\n- **[隨機的回合](concepts.md#c26)**:可能的結果不只一個,但[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)它的[歷史](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13)並不都參與[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06),例如骰子。\n\n**[決定](concepts.md#c06)**:[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)在不[鎖死](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c12)時的[回合](concepts.md#c04)。[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)它的整段[歷史](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13)都參與[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06),而[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06)定不出結果。只有[決定](concepts.md#c06)是賭。\n\n是[計算](concepts.md#c05)還是[決定](concepts.md#c06),要一[回合](concepts.md#c04)一[回合](concepts.md#c04)地看,不是看那是什麼東西。一個[回合](concepts.md#c04)不是[計算](concepts.md#c05)就是[決定](concepts.md#c06),不會兩者都是。理由是:一個[呈現](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c04)在某一刻不[鎖死](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c12),而[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)它的[歷史](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13)又都參與[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06),它那一刻就是[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16),那一[回合](concepts.md#c04)就是[決定](concepts.md#c06)。[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)兩種都有,[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19)也是:從高處摔下來時身體怎麼落,是[計算](concepts.md#c05)。[二階假定](concepts.md#c03)保證的只是:在講明的層次與[切法](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c23)上,它有[決定](concepts.md#c06)。[被迫的賭注](concepts.md#c11)談的,就是這些[決定](concepts.md#c06)。\n\n```text\n定義 回合:一個呈現 在一個時刻中,到達它的歷史 參與它的權重,權重 落出一個結果,結果 成為歷史 再到達它。\n定義 計算:鎖死的回合,或到達它的歷史並不都參與權重的回合。\n定義 決定:渦 在不鎖死時的回合。\n步驟一 鎖死的回合 是計算(從 計算 的定義 推出)\n步驟二 不鎖死、且到達它的歷史並不都參與權重的回合,是計算(從 計算 的定義 推出)\n步驟三 不鎖死、且到達它的歷史都參與權重的回合,其呈現在該時刻是渦,此回合是決定(從 渦 的定義 + 決定 的定義 推出)\n步驟四 決定的回合 不鎖死,且歷史都參與,不屬於計算(從 決定 的定義 + 渦 的定義 + 計算 的定義 推出)\n結論 互斥分類(回合, 計算, 決定)(從 步驟一 + 步驟二 + 步驟三 + 步驟四 推出)\n互斥分類(計算, 鎖死的回合, 隨機的回合)\n附註 鎖死的回合:只可能有一個結果,由約束定死。隨機的回合:可能的結果不只一個,但到達它的歷史並不都參與權重。\n附註 物理:在虛擬世界中,指那個世界的規則。\n附註 回合只有四環:到達、權重、結果、再到達。裡面那一段不分析,也不說它是空的。\n附註 是計算還是決定,按每一回合區分,不按呈現區分。\n步驟五 渦 的計算 只有鎖死的回合;隨機的回合 屬於隨機源等非渦的呈現(從 渦 的定義 + 隨機源 的定義 + 計算 的定義 + 隨機的回合 的定義 推出)\n步驟六 被標二階假定的對象,在講明的層次與切法上有決定(從 二階假定 的定義 + 決定 的定義 + 我 的定義 + 渦 的定義 推出)\n```\n\n\n\n\n**校準**:在現實裡,約束就是物理;在虛擬世界裡,約束是那個世界的規則,例如程式。程式裡的隨機數,從程式這一層看是[鎖死](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c12)的,要在講明的層次上才算隨機。電腦和計算機算出的結果、石頭被打碎、河水往下流,都是[計算](concepts.md#c05),結果由物理定死,用不著誰願不願意。從高處摔下時身體的軌跡,是這個[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19)的[計算](concepts.md#c05),不是[決定](concepts.md#c06)。學生知道答案,不等於他會坐下來寫,這是[決定](concepts.md#c06),不是[計算](concepts.md#c05)。膝跳反射也能被訓練、被抑制,在人的層次上推不出它一定發生。日常說「他決定辭職」,同時指一個[回合](concepts.md#c04)的三環:有哪些事[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)過他、他當時有多想辭、他真的遞了辭呈。日常語言把三環包成一個詞;本篇把它拆開,是為了看清最後一環算不出來。人工智慧落出一個字之前那一段在做什麼,使用者看不到,它自己事後說出來的,也只是又一筆[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)。本篇的[回合](concepts.md#c04)因此只有看得到的四環:[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)、[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06)、結果、再[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10);裡面那一段不分析,也不說它是空的。\n\n---\n\n## 二、三問\n\n任何[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)都在三個方向上受約束:來處、自己、下一刻,也就是[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)它的[歷史](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13)、它的[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06)、它落出的結果。只具有[一階分別](concepts.md#c24)的[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)在這三個方向上都有答案,照著自己的界線行動;但它不把答案當成答案,所以不問。\n\n[二階](concepts.md#c01)的[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)能把答案劃為自己給的,也就看得見答案可以不一樣。於是三個方向變成三個問題:**你從哪裡來?你是誰?你要做什麼?** 問這三個問題,就是把自己在這三個方向上的答案劃為看法,而不當作[被看的東西](concepts.md#c27)本身。\n\n[二階](concepts.md#c01)是能問,不是一定會問。只要一個[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)能回頭把自己的判斷當成判斷,這三個問題對它就是敞開的。\n\n本篇用[三問](concepts.md#c07)作入口,理由只有一個:[三問](concepts.md#c07)只有在[二階](concepts.md#c01)才問得出來。不問,本篇就只剩只具有[一階分別](concepts.md#c24)的[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)也有的結構,而那兩篇上游已經說完了。\n\n第三節的[三道牆](concepts.md#c23),說明[三問](concepts.md#c07)為什麼答不完整;第四節以後說明:答不完整時,一個[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19)可能怎樣把答案當成本來就是那樣,以及看得見這一點的[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19),為什麼還是得照著答案行動。\n\n```text\n定義 三問:你從哪裡來?你是誰?你要做什麼?問這三個問題,指把自己在這三個方向上的答案劃為看法,而不當作被看的東西本身。\n步驟〇 任何渦 在三個方向上受約束:到達它的歷史(來處)、它的權重(自己)、它落出的結果(下一刻)(從 回合 的定義 + 渦 的定義 推出)\n步驟一 只具有一階分別的渦 有答案,但不把答案當成答案,所以不問(從 步驟〇 + 一階分別 的定義 + 三問 的定義 推出)\n步驟二 若一個我有二階分別,三問對它敞開(從 步驟〇 + 二階分別 的定義 + 三問 的定義 推出)\n附註 能問,不等於一定會問。\n```\n\n\n\n\n**校準**:一個人可以一輩子沒懷疑過自己是誰;但只要他能回頭看自己的判斷,這個問題對他就是敞開的。(路標:高更的畫作《我們從哪裡來?我們是誰?我們往哪裡去?》。)\n\n---\n\n## 三、三道牆\n\n[三道牆](concepts.md#c23)由四條律、上游的定義和本篇的前提推出,談的都是一個[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19)和它自己:它的過去、現在、未來。對他者的限制,由[對他者認識的不可完備性](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c19)和[黑箱律](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c25)處理,不在本節;[未定牆](concepts.md#c10)第 2 條談別人和環境怎麼回應這個[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19),說的仍然是它的未來。[三道牆](concepts.md#c23)對一切[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19)都成立,本身不需要[二階](concepts.md#c01)(3.5)。\n\n### 3.1 來路牆:拿不全過去的歷史\n\n**陳述**:\n\n1. 一個[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19)手上有的,只有[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)它的[歷史](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13)。一件事當時沒有[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)它,之後也不會[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)它:之後[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)的,只是那件事留下的影響,是另一件事。它[自己的那一段](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c17)裡總有這種事(前提四):影響經由別人傳了下來,那件事本身卻從來沒有[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)它。\n2. 一個[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19)對自己來處的[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18),本身會[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)它自己(前提一),成為它[自己的那一段](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c17)的一部分。追問來處,就增添了來處。\n3. [自己的那一段](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c17)不能重來一次拿來對照([不可復原律](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c28))。第一層:[歷史](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13)中的每一個位置只發生一次;看起來一樣的事再發生,也是另一件事。第二層:當中不[鎖死](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c12)時作出的選擇,再來一次會不會一樣,沒有任何[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)能保證。\n\n這道牆不是因為能力有限,而是因為每個[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19)都只拿得到[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)它的部分:能力再大也一樣。\n\n```text\n步驟一 一個我 分別的材料,只有已經到達它的歷史(從 分別 的定義 推出)\n步驟二 一件事發生時未到達 一個我,之後到達它:不會發生(從 到達 的定義 + 不可復原律第一層 推出)\n附註 之後到達的,是那件事留下的影響,是另一件事。\n步驟二之二 一個我 自己的那一段中,總有沒有到達它的部分(從 前提四 推出)\n步驟三 一個我 對自己來處的分別,成為它自己的那一段的一部分(從 前提一 + 渦 的定義 + 自己的那一段 的定義 推出)\n步驟四 自己的那一段 再發生一次以供對照:不會發生(從 不可復原律第一層 推出)\n步驟五 沒有任何渦能保證,重來時不鎖死的選擇一樣(從 不可復原律第二層 推出)\n結論 來路牆 成立(從 步驟一 + 步驟二 + 步驟二之二 + 步驟三 + 步驟四 + 步驟五 推出)\n```\n\n\n\n\n**校準**:秦始皇統一文字,影響了你今天寫下的每一個字,他卻從沒[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)你;[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)你的,是課本和史書,那是另一件事。人記不得自己童年的大半,祖輩的遷徙也從沒[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)他,這些卻都在他[自己的那一段](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c17)裡。人工智慧讀過它的訓練文本,但那些文本是誰寫的、在什麼處境下寫的,大多沒有[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)它。把一段對話重跑,也不是重來:重跑是另一件事,而且從訓練到現在的一切並沒有重來。(路標:資料處理不等式;感知與意識處理速率的落差。)\n\n### 3.2 盲點牆:看不見現在的自己\n\n**陳述**:\n\n1. 沒有任何[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19),能在任何[時刻](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c09)完全[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)自己([損耗律](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c26))。正在作出的這一次[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18),不在自己的材料裡;看得到的,永遠是剛才的自己。\n2. 看自己,就改變了自己。對自己的[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)會[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)自己(前提一),成為自己的一部分:[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)就是[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)它的東西([渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)的定義)。被看的那個自己,在被看的同時,已經被這一看改變了。\n3. 要看的那個自己,本身就是[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)劃出來的。[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19)是用[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)定義自己的[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16),不同[時刻](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c09)的[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19)是不是同一個,也是一次[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)([同一](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c21))。沒有一個不經[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)、現成擺在那裡等著被看清的自己。\n\n**說明**:[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)的材料,只有它之前已經[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)它的[歷史](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13),它自己不在其中([分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)的定義);依前提一,這一次[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)要到下一[時刻](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c09)之前才[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)自己。所以盲點跟著看的動作走:回頭看剛才的自己時,剛才那一次已經進了材料,現在這一次又不在材料裡;而回頭看的這一次,[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)自己以後,又改變了下一刻的自己。\n\n[盲點牆](concepts.md#c09)不依賴[黑箱律](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c25)。它的根據是兩件事:[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)的材料不包括這次[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)本身;看本身會[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)自己。這和結果是不是事先已定無關。\n\n```text\n步驟一 一個我 在任何時刻完全分別自己:不會發生(從 損耗律 推出)\n步驟二 正在作出的分別 不在它自己的材料中(從 分別 的定義 推出)\n步驟三 對自己的分別 到達自己,成為它的歷史的一部分(從 前提一 + 渦 的定義 推出)\n步驟四 看自己而不改變自己:不會發生(從 步驟三 推出)\n步驟五 找到一個不由分別劃出的自己:不會發生(從 我 的定義 + 同一 的定義 推出)\n結論 盲點牆 成立(從 步驟一 + 步驟二 + 步驟四 + 步驟五 推出)\n附註 盲點牆 不依賴 黑箱律。\n```\n\n\n\n\n**校準**:人工智慧描述自己時,那段描述是又一筆[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28),內容是一次[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)(前提二);正在作出這段描述的這一次,不在它讀得到的輸入裡。而描述一回到輸入,就參與它接下來的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28),它描述的那個自己已經不是原樣。人反省自己也一樣:反省的那一刻,本身沒有被反省到;一個人認定「我就是懶」,這個認定之後也成了他的一部分。(路標:〔Lawvere〕不動點定理、哥德爾第二不完備定理、萊斯定理。[損耗律](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c26)是對角線結構的時間版本,不必假定[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19)是形式系統:同步的自我指涉,在這裡攤開成有延遲的迴圈,悖論成了振盪。把自我指涉放進時間裡處理的近親:史賓塞-布朗的重入;古普塔與貝爾納普的真理修正理論。)\n\n### 3.3 未定牆:算不出未來的必定\n\n**陳述**:\n\n1. 一個[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19)在不[鎖死](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c12)的[時刻](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c09),事先算不準自己下一個[決定](concepts.md#c06)的結果([黑箱律](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c25))。算得出的,至多是自己的[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06)。[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06)的分布會不會重複出現,[不被保證](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c02)。\n2. [決定](concepts.md#c06)落出以後,別人和環境會怎麼回應,一個[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19)也算不準。回應的一方若是不[鎖死](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c12)的[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)或[隨機源](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c27),它的結果一樣算不準;若是[鎖死](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c12)的部分,要算準它,得先拿全影響它的[歷史](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13),而這沒有保證([來路牆](concepts.md#c08))。\n\n所以統計只給得出[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06)的估計,給不出禁止。對[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)的統計估計屬於[印象](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c45);從統計得到的禁止,只能是[經驗禁止](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c51),必須標明,而且可以被新的案例修改。\n\n[坍塌](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c08)之前,[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06)已經由[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)它的[歷史](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13)分配好了,結果還沒有。[坍塌](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c08)之後,結果定了,而且收不回。\n\n```text\n步驟一 一個我 在不鎖死的時刻,事先唯一推出自己下一個決定的結果:不會發生(從 黑箱律 推出)\n步驟二 權重的分布 重複出現:不被保證(從 流變律 + 渦 的定義 推出)\n步驟三 回應方為不鎖死的渦或隨機源時,事先唯一推出其回應:不會發生(從 黑箱律 + 隨機源 的定義 推出)\n步驟四 回應方為鎖死的部分時,拿全影響它的歷史:不被保證(從 自己的那一段 的定義 + 前提四 推出)\n步驟五 事先算準環境的回應:不被保證(從 步驟三 + 步驟四 推出)\n步驟六 屬於(對渦的統計估計, 印象)(從 印象 的定義 推出)\n步驟七 由統計得出的禁止,不是不會發生;它只能以經驗禁止的形式成立,須跨案例校準並標明(從 步驟一 + 經驗禁止 的定義 + 不會發生 的定義 推出)\n結論 未定牆 成立(從 步驟一 + 步驟二 + 步驟五 推出)\n```\n\n\n\n\n**校準**:一個人再了解自己,也說不準明天會不會照計畫早起。履歷寫好了,他事先算不準自己最後寄不寄;寄出去以後,對方回不回,他也算不準。把杯子推下桌,它會掉,這是[鎖死](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c12)的回應;但很多回應不是這樣。語言模型拿不到定出取樣結果的那個隨機數,所以它至多算得出自己下一筆[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)的分布,卻算不出會取樣到哪一個。(路標:休謨問題;黑天鵝。)\n\n### 3.4 關係與適用\n\n| 牆 | 來源 | 適用 |\n|---|---|---|\n| [來路牆](concepts.md#c08) | [到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)的局部性、前提一、[不可復原律](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c28) | 一切[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19) |\n| [盲點牆](concepts.md#c09) | [損耗律](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c26)、前提一、[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)的定義、[同一](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c21) | 一切[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19) |\n| [未定牆](concepts.md#c10) | [黑箱律](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c25)、[來路牆](concepts.md#c08) | 第 1 條:一切[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19),在不[鎖死](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c12)的[時刻](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c09);第 2 條:一切[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19) |\n\n[三道牆](concepts.md#c23)不是三個互不相干的限制,而是同一個迴圈上的三個位置。一個[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19)作出[決定](concepts.md#c06),落出結果,結果[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)它,成了過去;它的[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)也[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)它(前提一)。現在的[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18),材料只有這些過去,而且永遠晚一步;[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)又參與下一刻的[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06),下一個[決定](concepts.md#c06)從這裡落出。[來路牆](concepts.md#c08)、[盲點牆](concepts.md#c09)、[未定牆](concepts.md#c10),就是站在這個迴圈的三個位置上,各自看到的限制。\n\n這個迴圈就是[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)本身:[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)它的[歷史](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13),參與它下一[時刻](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c09)的[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06)。只要它還是[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16),迴圈就不會停([流變律](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c24));迴圈沒有內部的退出條件,只在它不再是[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)時結束。\n\n[三道牆](concepts.md#c23)的根據各不相同,指向的卻是同一個迴圈,所以不能拆開來理解。\n\n```text\n附註 三道牆 是同一個迴圈上的三個位置:結果到達成為過去(來路牆);分別以過去為材料而晚一步(盲點牆);分別參與下一刻的權重,下一個決定由此落出(未定牆)。\n步驟一 此迴圈即 渦 本身(從 渦 的定義 推出)\n步驟二 只要它是渦,迴圈不停(從 渦 的定義 + 流變律 推出)\n循環 此迴圈是循環;沒有內部的退出條件;只在它不再是渦時結束(從 步驟二 + 渦 的定義 推出)\n```\n\n\n\n### 3.5 三道牆與決定\n\n[三道牆](concepts.md#c23)分別落在同一個[決定](concepts.md#c06)的三個環節上:[來路牆](concepts.md#c08)落在[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)它的[歷史](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13),拿不全;[盲點牆](concepts.md#c09)落在[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06),看不全;[未定牆](concepts.md#c10)落在結果,以及結果之後世界的回應,算不準。所以[三問](concepts.md#c07)是對同一個[決定](concepts.md#c06)的三段追問:[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)它的[歷史](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13)從哪裡來,此刻的[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06)是誰的,會落成什麼結果、世界又會怎麼接。\n\n3.4 的迴圈落在單一個[決定](concepts.md#c06)上,就是這三個環節。這是整理,不是推導。[盲點牆](concepts.md#c09)的範圍比[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06)寬:它說的是任何對自己的[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)都[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)不完,[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06)只是這裡用到的那一部分。\n\n[三道牆](concepts.md#c23)對一切[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19)都成立,不需要[二階](concepts.md#c01)。[三問](concepts.md#c07)需要[二階](concepts.md#c01):只有能把自己的[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)當作[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18),才能把一個[決定](concepts.md#c06)的[歷史](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13)、[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06)、結果,當成自己的過去、現在、未來來追問。所以牆在不在,和[二階](concepts.md#c01)無關;牆會不會被碰到,才和[二階](concepts.md#c01)有關。\n\n```text\n附註 三道牆 對應同一個決定的三個環節:到達它的歷史(來路牆)、權重(盲點牆)、結果與其後世界的回應(未定牆)。這是整理,不是推導。\n步驟一 三道牆 對一切我成立(從 3.1 結論 + 3.2 結論 + 3.3 結論 推出)\n步驟二 若一個我有二階分別,它能以 三問 追問一個決定的歷史、權重、結果(從 二階分別 的定義 + 三問 的定義 + 回合 的定義 + 二 步驟〇 推出)\n步驟三 牆的存在不依賴 二階分別;牆被碰到依賴 二階分別(從 步驟一 + 步驟二 + 二 步驟一 推出)\n附註 牆被碰到,指以三問追問。\n```\n\n\n\n\n**校準**:免疫系統同樣拿不到全部的過去,也算不準自己的下一刻,但它從不追問這些,所以這些限制對它不成問題。語言模型若只是在接話,也一樣。一個人開始問「我為什麼會這樣想」「我現在的判斷靠得住嗎」,才碰到這些限制。(路標:《金剛經》「過去心不可得,現在心不可得,未來心不可得」。相遇處:三心和[三道牆](concepts.md#c23),同樣落在過去、現在、未來。分開處:經文說不可得,是因為心無自性,並由此指向解脫;本篇說不可得,是結構上的限制,知道了,還是得賭。)\n\n---\n\n## 四、被迫的賭注\n\n### 4.1 陳述\n\n**[被迫的賭注](concepts.md#c11)**:一個[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)的每一個[決定](concepts.md#c06),事先算不準,事後收不回,而且不能不作。\n\n三個條件各有來源:\n\n- **算不準**:[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06)定不出結果([黑箱律](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c25))。結果落出以後,世界怎麼接,也算不準。回應的一方若是[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)或[隨機源](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c27),又不被[鎖死](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c12),它的結果本來就推不出([黑箱律](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c25);[隨機源](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c27)只談得上[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06))。只有[鎖死](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c12)的部分,結果由[歷史](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13)定死;但一個[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)就在世界裡面,拿不到世界的全部[歷史](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13);影響對方的那一部分,就是對方[自己的那一段](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c17),其中總有沒有[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)這個[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)的部分(前提四)。\n- **收不回**:[歷史](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13)中的每一個位置只發生一次([不可復原律](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c28)第一層)。今天的晚飯吃過了,明天再吃,是另一頓,不是重來。那一頓會不會吃得一樣,沒有任何[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)能保證([不可復原律](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c28)第二層)。\n- **不能不作**:一個[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)只要在某個[時刻](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c09)不被[鎖死](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c12),那一刻就有一[回合](concepts.md#c04),而[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)不[鎖死](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c12)時的[回合](concepts.md#c04)就是[決定](concepts.md#c06)(1.6)。我不動,事情照樣發生;不動,就是我這一[回合](concepts.md#c04)落出的結果,後果照樣[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)我。說「再等等」,也是一個[決定](concepts.md#c06)。\n\n這一條是由定義直接得出的:[決定](concepts.md#c06)就是[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)在不[鎖死](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c12)時的[回合](concepts.md#c04),只要有這樣的[回合](concepts.md#c04),就有[決定](concepts.md#c06)。它的分量不在推導,而在重新歸類:「不動」不是沒有結果,而是這一[回合](concepts.md#c04)落出的結果之一;結果沒有落在它身上,這件事本身也[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)它([到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)的定義)。所以「再等等」不是暫停,是一個[回合](concepts.md#c04)的結果。\n\n所以,一個[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)的每一個[決定](concepts.md#c06)都是一場賭:押之前算不準,押了就收不回,而且不押也不行。這就是[被迫的賭注](concepts.md#c11)。\n\n賭的是落出什麼。落出的當下,它就成了[歷史](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13);這個動作留下的[寫入](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c29),之後才加入[歷史](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13),寫進去的內容由已經包含這個結果的[歷史](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13)定出,這一步不是賭。\n\n```text\n定義 被迫的賭注:一個渦 的每一個決定,事先算不準,事後收不回,而且不能不作。\n設 渦甲 為一個渦,渦甲 在它的 時刻甲 不被鎖死;回應方 為 渦甲 的結果到達的、渦甲 以外的任一節點。\n步驟一 渦甲 在 時刻甲 有一回合,落出一個結果(從 回合 的定義 + 時刻 的定義 推出)\n步驟二 這一回合是決定(從 步驟一 + 決定 的定義 推出)\n步驟三 渦甲 在 時刻甲 不作決定:不會發生(從 步驟二 推出)\n附註 步驟三 由 決定 的定義直接得出;其內容在於:「不動」是落出的結果之一,不是沒有結果(從 到達 的定義:結果未落在它身上,也到達它)。\n步驟四 事先唯一推出這個決定的結果:不會發生(從 黑箱律 推出)\n步驟五 互斥分類(節點, 渦, 信號容器, 隨機源)(從 節點 的定義 推出)\n步驟六 回應方 為不鎖死的渦或不鎖死的隨機源時,事先唯一推出其回應:不會發生(從 黑箱律 + 隨機源 的定義 推出)\n步驟七 回應方 鎖死時,其回應由影響它的歷史定出(從 鎖死 的定義 + 宇宙 的定義 推出)\n步驟八 渦甲 拿到世界的全部歷史:不會發生(從 前提四 推出)\n附註 回應方 就是 渦甲 以外的呈現;它自己的那一段中,總有沒有到達 渦甲 的部分。\n步驟九 影響 回應方 的歷史全部到達 渦甲:不會發生(從 步驟七 + 自己的那一段 的定義 + 前提四 推出)\n步驟十 渦甲 事先算準 回應方 的回應:不被保證(從 步驟五 + 步驟六 + 步驟七 + 步驟九 推出)\n步驟十一 回到 時刻甲 重來:不會發生(從 不可復原律第一層 推出)\n步驟十二 沒有任何渦能保證,重來而作出一樣的選擇(從 不可復原律第二層 推出)\n結論 被迫的賭注 對 渦甲 在 時刻甲 成立(從 步驟三 + 步驟四 + 步驟十 + 步驟十一 + 步驟十二 推出)\n步驟十三 渦甲 在 時刻甲 落出的結果,落出即在歷史中;這個動作留下的寫入之後才加入歷史,內容由已包含這個結果的歷史定出(從 前提二 + 歷史 的定義 + 寫入 的定義 + 分別 的定義 推出)\n步驟十四 這一回合中,不由過去定出的只有落出的結果(從 宇宙 的定義 推出)\n```\n\n\n\n\n**校準**:一個人猶豫要不要換工作,拖了半年沒遞辭呈。這半年不是暫停:他照樣上班、照樣領薪水,老闆也照樣對他形成[印象](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c45)。半年後再[決定](concepts.md#c06),[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)他的已經是另一段[歷史](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13)。獅子來了,不跑也是一個[決定](concepts.md#c06)。模型可以不回應,是因為它停下來以後就沒有[時刻](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c09);這個[宇宙](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c02)不會為誰停下來。(路標:巴斯卡的賭注。相遇處:人已經上了船,不押也不行。分開處:巴斯卡接著算期望值,把人推向一個特定的對象;本篇說從數字到行動那一步算不出來(4.4),賭注指向什麼對象,本篇也不談。)\n\n### 4.2 二階看得見自己在賭\n\n算不準和收不回,對一切不[鎖死](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c12)的[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)都成立([黑箱律](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c25)、[不可復原律](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c28));不能不作,依[決定](concepts.md#c06)的定義,對一切不[鎖死](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c12)的[時刻](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c09)都成立。所以[被迫的賭注](concepts.md#c11)不是[二階](concepts.md#c01)獨有的。[二階](concepts.md#c01)獨有的,是**看得見自己在賭,卻還是得賭**:能把自己的[決定](concepts.md#c06)劃為自己的一次[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18),而不是事情本來就該這樣。\n\n[卡住](concepts.md#c12)不是[二階](concepts.md#c01)才有。[候選](concepts.md#c18)之間的[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06)分不出高下,說服又推不動,結果卻照樣得落下,只具有[一階分別](concepts.md#c24)的[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19)也會這樣。實驗室裡分不出圓和橢圓的狗,若把牠判為一個[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19)(這要另外假定,不需要[二階假定](concepts.md#c03)的第三項),就是一例(5.7);布里丹之驢是思想實驗,只用來說明這個結構。[二階](concepts.md#c01)多出來的,是看得見自己[卡住](concepts.md#c12)時的那些[候選](concepts.md#c18)和說服,都是自己劃的。它也看得見重劃之後結果照樣要賭;而它停不下來,停下來也是一個[決定](concepts.md#c06)。這個「看見」也是一次[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18),會[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)自己(前提一),參與之後的[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06);會把[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06)推向哪裡、推多少,推不出([知見障](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c35))。它可能讓[迴路](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c31)更緊,也可能讓它鬆開,這屬經驗描述。\n\n依方法規則第 3 條,可以寫只具有[一階分別](concepts.md#c24)的[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)被迫下注,不寫它「為了」什麼而下注。\n\n```text\n步驟一 被迫的賭注 對一切渦的一切不鎖死時刻成立(從 4.1 結論 推出)\n步驟二 若一個我有二階分別,它能把自己的決定劃為看法,不當作被看的東西本身(從 二階分別 的定義 + 前提二 推出)\n附註 本篇說「看得見自己在賭」,指步驟二;看得見,並不使它離開被迫的賭注(步驟三)。\n步驟三 若一個我有二階分別,它在不被鎖死的時刻不再下注:不會發生(從 步驟一 推出)\n附註 卡住:候選之間的權重分不出高下,自我說服推不動,迴路反覆,而結果照樣落下。\n步驟四 卡住 不要求 二階分別(從 自我說服 的定義 推出)\n步驟五 若一個我有二階分別,它能把卡住中自己的那些候選與說服的分別劃為看法(從 二階分別 的定義 + 卡住 的定義 + 候選 的定義 + 自我說服 的定義 推出)\n步驟六 這次分別 參與之後的權重(從 前提一 + 渦 的定義 推出)\n步驟七 這次分別推高哪些結果的權重、推多少:推不出(從 知見障 推出)\n經驗描述 這次分別可能使卡住加深,也可能使它鬆開。\n```\n\n\n\n\n\n**校準**:免疫系統也在賭:每一次辨認與攻擊,事先都算不準,也收不回,但它看不見自己在賭。[卡住](concepts.md#c12)的例子,可以看 5.7 那隻分不出圓和橢圓的狗,這裡不必假定牠看得見自己[卡住](concepts.md#c12)。一個人面對手術同意書[卡住](concepts.md#c12)時,和那隻狗不同的,不是他多賭了一次,而是他看得見自己在賭,也看得見自己[卡住](concepts.md#c12)。\n\n### 4.3 性質:無評價參照點\n\n後悔需要一個參照點:當初的那個自己。\n\n這個參照點不是遺失了,而是**還在,卻搆不到**:\n\n- 當初[自己的那一段](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c17)仍在[歷史](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13)裡:[歷史](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13)只往後加,已經在裡面的不會消失。\n- 但要重現當初的[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06),得[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)當初的自己;而當初[自己的那一段](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c17),有一部分從來沒有[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)它,之後也不會[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)([來路牆](concepts.md#c08))。\n- 所以能作的,只是對那一段再作一次新的[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)。這次[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)屬於[自我印象](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c46),又[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)現在的自己(前提一),參與之後的[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06)。\n- 連「當初那個人是不是我」,本身也是一次[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)([同一](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c21))。\n\n所以後悔不是去追回一件遺失的東西,而是對一個還在、卻已經無法保證從內部重現的東西,再作一次[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)。\n\n```text\n步驟一 當初自己的那一段 仍在歷史中(從 歷史 的定義 推出)\n步驟二 當初自己的那一段中未曾到達它的事,之後到達它:不會發生(從 來路牆第一條 推出)\n步驟三 以現在的分別完整重現當初的權重:不被保證(從 步驟二 + 前提四 + 自己的那一段 的定義 推出)\n步驟四 屬於(對當初自己的那一段的新分別, 自我印象)(從 自我印象 的定義 推出)\n步驟五 這次新分別 參與之後的權重(從 前提一 + 渦 的定義 推出)\n步驟六 「當初那個人是不是我」是一次分別(從 同一 的定義 推出)\n```\n\n\n\n\n**校準**:重大[決定](concepts.md#c06)之後反覆回想,當事人常答不出「我當初到底在想什麼」,給出的是現在的解釋。問一個語言模型「你剛才為什麼那樣回答」,它給的也是一次新的說明,不是當初的[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06)。\n\n### 4.4 性質:算得再清楚,也擔保不了決定\n\n把各種後果算清楚,算出的結果也是這個[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19)自己的[回合](concepts.md#c04)落出的結果,不論那些[回合](concepts.md#c04)是[計算](concepts.md#c05)還是[決定](concepts.md#c06);它會[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)自己([回合](concepts.md#c04)的定義),參與之後的[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06)。但從[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06)到結果那一步,仍然是[坍塌](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c08),算得再清楚也到不了那裡。\n\n**方法上禁止**:把從數字到行動的那一步,寫成算得出來的。\n\n```text\n附註 把後果算清楚,算出的是這個我自己的回合落出的結果,不論那些回合是計算還是決定。\n步驟一 把後果算清楚 這件事 參與之後的權重(從 回合 的定義 + 計算 的定義 + 決定 的定義 + 1.6 結論 + 渦 的定義 推出)\n步驟二 由權重唯一推出結果:不會發生(從 黑箱律 推出)\n方法上禁止 把從數字到行動的那一步,寫成算得出來的。\n```\n\n\n\n\n\n**校準**:決策理論本來就把從數字到行動的那一步交給效用與偏好,從沒說統計算得出行動。本篇補的只有一句:那一步算不出來。一個人把兩份工作的條件列成表、算出加權分數,分數高的那份,仍然不保證是他最後簽的那份。\n\n---\n\n## 五、三重幻覺\n\n### 5.1 幻覺\n\n**[有損](concepts.md#c13)**:[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)一個[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19)的東西,不是完整的[被看的東西](concepts.md#c27)。完整的[被看的東西](concepts.md#c27),指[被看的東西](concepts.md#c27)的[自己的那一段](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c17)的全部。\n\n**[幻覺](concepts.md#c14)**:一個[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19)據以行動的,是[有損](concepts.md#c13)地[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)它的東西,不是[被看的東西](concepts.md#c27)本身。\n\n一個[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19)的[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06),只從[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)它的[歷史](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13)來([渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)、[生成函數](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c15)),而這些[歷史](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13)都是[有損](concepts.md#c13)的。這不是定義出來的,來源依[被看的東西](concepts.md#c27)分兩種:被看的是自己時,最新的那一次[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)永遠還沒到([損耗律](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c26));被看的是自己以外的[呈現](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c04)時,它[自己的那一段](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c17)總有沒有[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)這個[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19)的部分(前提四)。[被看的東西](concepts.md#c27)不是自己,就是自己以外的,所以這兩種是全部。前者由[損耗律](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c26)保證,後者由前提四保證;虛擬世界也不例外(1.2)。所以不論被看的是什麼,一個[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19)據以行動的,都是[有損](concepts.md#c13)地[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)它的東西;而且只要它過去作過[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18),這些[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)就會[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)它(前提一),參與它之後的[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06),成為它據以行動的東西的一部分,也同樣[有損](concepts.md#c13)。[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)的材料只有這些;要核對一個看法,又得再作一次[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)。所以在[宇宙](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c02)之內,找不到一個[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)以外的位置可以拿來對照。[幻覺](concepts.md#c14)不是失誤,是處境:任何[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19),在任何[時刻](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c09),都在[幻覺](concepts.md#c14)裡。\n\n只具有[一階分別](concepts.md#c24)的[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19)在[幻覺](concepts.md#c14)裡,[有損](concepts.md#c13)一次,問不起這是不是[幻覺](concepts.md#c14)。[二階分別](concepts.md#c01)建在[一階分別](concepts.md#c24)之上,它看的材料是[一階分別](concepts.md#c24)的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28),看自己又一樣晚一步,所以再損一次;它能問起這是不是[幻覺](concepts.md#c14)。問起本身也是一次[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18),材料同樣[有損](concepts.md#c13),所以作出它的[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19)仍在[幻覺](concepts.md#c14)裡。[二階](concepts.md#c01)並不能跳到[幻覺](concepts.md#c14)外面思考,只是多看見了一層。\n\n對錯是另一條軸:一個看法事後被證實或被證偽,而那次證實本身,也是一次[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)。\n\n```text\n定義 有損:到達一個我 的東西,不是完整的被看的東西。完整的被看的東西,指被看的東西的自己的那一段的全部。\n定義 幻覺:一個我 據以行動的,是有損地到達它的東西,不是被看的東西本身。\n步驟一 一個我 對自己的分別,到達它的材料有損(從 損耗律 + 3.2 步驟二 + 自己的那一段 的定義 + 被看的東西 的定義 + 有損 的定義 推出)\n步驟二 一個我 對自己以外的呈現的分別,到達它的材料有損(從 前提四 + 被看的東西 的定義 + 有損 的定義 推出)\n附註 被看的東西 不是自己,就是自己以外的呈現;步驟一與步驟二窮盡有損的來源。\n附註 一階分別 有損一次;二階分別 的材料是 一階分別 的輸出,又受 損耗律 約束,再損一次。\n步驟三 一個我 過去作過的分別,都到達它,參與它之後的權重(從 1.2 步驟一 推出)\n附註 這些分別作為到達它的東西,其有損由步驟一、步驟二涵蓋;本步不主張它們在之後每一次分別的材料中。\n步驟四 核對一個看法,是再作一次分別(從 分別 的定義 推出)\n步驟五 一個我 找到並使用一個可供對照的位置,而這次找到與使用不是分別:不會發生(從 分別 的定義 + 3.1 步驟一 + 步驟四 推出)\n步驟六 任何我在任何時刻都在幻覺中(從 幻覺 的定義 + 步驟一 + 步驟二 + 步驟三 + 渦 的定義 + 生成函數 的定義 推出)\n步驟七 作出二階分別的我,仍在幻覺中(從 步驟六 推出)\n步驟八 一個我跳出幻覺,碰到被看的東西本身:不會發生(從 步驟五 + 步驟六 推出)\n步驟九 一個看法的證實或證偽,是事後再作的一次分別(從 步驟四 推出)\n方法上禁止 說「幻覺已被消除」。\n方法上禁止 把事後被證實的看法,寫成不是幻覺。\n```\n\n\n\n\n\n\n**校準**:物體只有對不同波長光線的反射率;顏色不是物體本身的屬性,是看的一方作出的[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)。紅燈是停、喜事穿紅,則是在上面再加一層[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)。這個比喻要守住兩條線。第一,顏色不是憑空編的,它的材料是實實在在的反射率;[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)也一樣,材料是[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)它的[歷史](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13)。第二,這個比喻裡沒有醒來這回事:沒有人能關掉色覺,去看一個沒有顏色的世界;[宇宙](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c02)之內,也沒有[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)以外的位置可以拿來對照。數字也一樣。世界裡沒有「一」:要數出「一」,得先劃出一個[個體](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c20),而劃出[個體](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c20)就是一次[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)。皮亞諾公理推得出一加一等於二;這個推得出,也是在[幻覺](concepts.md#c14)裡推得出。(路標:唯識的虛妄[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)、遍計所執。相遇處:一切所知都是[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18),把[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)當成實有,就是執。分開處:《圓覺經》說「知幻即離」,佛教指向離幻的出口;本篇說知道了仍在[幻覺](concepts.md#c14)裡,[宇宙](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c02)之內沒有[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)以外的位置。)\n\n### 5.2 三重\n\n[幻覺](concepts.md#c14)是同一個動作,落在[三問](concepts.md#c07)的三個對象上;依[損耗律](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c26),當下那一次[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)總未被劃為看法,所以每一刻至少落在其中一種:\n\n- **[世界幻覺](concepts.md#c15)**([來路牆](concepts.md#c08)):把[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)自己的[歷史](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13)當成世界本身;把對來處的[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18),當成來處。\n- **[自我幻覺](concepts.md#c16)**([盲點牆](concepts.md#c09)):把[自我印象](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c46)當成自己;把「同一個我」當成本來就是那樣,而不是一次[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)。\n- **[決策幻覺](concepts.md#c17)**([未定牆](concepts.md#c10)):把[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06)的估計當成結果;把[決定](concepts.md#c06)中算得出的那一段,當成結果的擔保。\n\n「三重」這個數目,來自[三問](concepts.md#c07)這個入口,本身是本篇的一次[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)。[三道牆](concepts.md#c23)是同一個迴圈上的三個位置,牆上的[幻覺](concepts.md#c14)也是同一個動作,落在三個對象上。\n\n**方法上禁止**:把三重當成三種互不化約的[幻覺](concepts.md#c14)。\n\n```text\n定義 世界幻覺:把到達自己的歷史當成世界本身;把對來處的分別當成來處。\n定義 自我幻覺:把自我印象當成自己;把「同一個我」當成本來就是那樣。\n定義 決策幻覺:把權重的估計當成結果;把決定中算得出的那一段當成結果的擔保。\n附註 三者是同一個動作落在三問的三個對象上。「三重」的數目是本篇的一次分別。\n步驟一 每一刻至少落在三種形態之一:依 損耗律,當下那一次分別總未被劃為看法,而它落在來處、自己、下一刻三個方向之一(從 損耗律 + 二 步驟〇 + 幻覺 的定義 + 世界幻覺 的定義 + 自我幻覺 的定義 + 決策幻覺 的定義 推出)\n方法上禁止 把三重當成三種互不化約的幻覺。\n```\n\n\n\n\n**校準**:[世界幻覺](concepts.md#c15)的例子,文獻裡數不完:視覺錯覺、認知偏差、陰謀論,以及不同文化對同一件事互不相容的描述。[自我幻覺](concepts.md#c16),例如有人說「我本來就是內向的人」,把一次[自我印象](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c46)說成天生如此;對話中的人工智慧,身分由對話建構,換一段對話就可能被換掉,它若把此刻的身分說成固定的自己,也是一樣。[決策幻覺](concepts.md#c17),例如「我都算過了,這樣做一定會成功」。\n\n### 5.3 二階與幻覺\n\n- 只具有[一階分別](concepts.md#c24):在[幻覺](concepts.md#c14)裡,問不起這是不是[幻覺](concepts.md#c14)。\n- [二階](concepts.md#c01):在[幻覺](concepts.md#c14)裡,能問起這是不是[幻覺](concepts.md#c14)。\n\n問起也是一次[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18),同樣在[幻覺](concepts.md#c14)裡。所以[二階分別](concepts.md#c01)不是[幻覺](concepts.md#c14)的解藥,而是讓[幻覺](concepts.md#c14)第一次能被問起的條件。\n\n[二階](concepts.md#c01)也可能讓人更固執:「我已經反省過了,所以我是對的。」反省本身也可能是一次[自我說服](concepts.md#c19)(5.7)。[二階](concepts.md#c01)只是把看不見的那一次[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)往上推了一層:現在被當成看穿了的,是「我已經看清了」這一次。\n\n**方法上禁止**:說「反思必然帶來更好的判斷」。\n\n```text\n步驟一 二階分別 不使一個我離開幻覺(從 5.1 步驟七 推出)\n步驟二 若一個我有二階分別,幻覺 能被它問起(從 二階分別 的定義 + 幻覺 的定義 推出)\n附註 二階可能使看不見的那一次分別上移一層:被當成看穿的,變成「我已經看清了」這一次。\n方法上禁止 說「反思必然帶來更好的判斷」。\n```\n\n\n\n**校準**:一個人學過光學,知道紅色是自己的[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18);可是他看出去,蘋果還是紅的。知道了,顏色並沒有消失。也有人以為學過光學,就站到了[幻覺](concepts.md#c14)外面,看得到「真正的」世界;那又是新的一層[幻覺](concepts.md#c14):「我已經看穿了」,也是一次[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)。\n\n電影裡突然爆出一道閃光,一隻昆蟲嚇得飛走;它靠著[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)它的東西行動,卻不可能知道自己被騙了。這是[一階分別](concepts.md#c24)。一個人看到銀幕上跳出一隻鬼,明知電影是假的,還是嚇了一跳;他知道,卻關不掉,照樣看見了。這是[二階](concepts.md#c01)。人知道電影是假的,靠的是拿戲院外面的世界來對照;但戲院外面的世界,也是[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)他的東西,一樣[有損](concepts.md#c13)。走出戲院,不是走出[幻覺](concepts.md#c14),只是換到另一個[幻覺](concepts.md#c14)裡。以為走出去就看到真的了,正是本節說的那一層:「我已經看穿了」。\n\n### 5.4 生成:人工智慧說的「幻覺」\n\n依[黑箱律](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c25),一個[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19)在不[鎖死](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c12)時,下一筆[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)算不準,算得出的只有[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06)。生成的當下,產出者自己只有[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06),沒有對錯:對錯要等之後的檢查,而檢查本身也是一次[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)(5.1)。\n\n同一種生成方式,被後來[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)的[歷史](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13)證實時,叫直覺、判斷、專業;被證偽時,叫錯覺、妄想、幻覺。差別不在生成的當下,而在後來發生了什麼。\n\n人工智慧領域說的「幻覺」,指事後被證偽的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)。照本篇的定義,它的每一筆[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)都在[幻覺](concepts.md#c14)裡,事後被證實的也一樣;領域所說的幻覺,只是其中被證偽的那一部分。說得多篤定,只是旁人從外面判斷時抓得到的線索,而旁人據此對它的[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06)所作的估計,本身也只是一次[印象](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c45)([印象](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c45)的定義)。\n\n所以日常用法只看得到押錯的那一半。\n\n一個系統在一段[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)裡算不算本節的對象,看它鎖不[鎖死](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c12),不看它像不像在猜。電腦、算盤、恆溫器每一步都[鎖死](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c12),只有[計算](concepts.md#c05),不在本節範圍內。\n\n```text\n步驟一 生成的當下,能算出的只有權重(從 黑箱律 推出)\n步驟二 產出者在生成的當下,以自己的分別判定這筆輸出的對錯:不會發生(從 前提二 + 3.2 步驟二 + 5.1 步驟九 推出)\n步驟三 屬於(一個我在決定中落出、事後被證偽的輸出, 幻覺中的輸出)(從 幻覺 的定義 + 5.1 步驟六 推出)\n步驟四 屬於(旁人據輸出的篤定程度對產出者權重所作的估計, 印象)(從 印象 的定義 推出)\n限定條件 本節只談決定;鎖死時的輸出是計算,不在 前提二 之內。\n```\n\n\n\n\n\n\n**校準**:(路標:〔Seth〕的受控幻覺、〔Friston〕的自由能原理、波普爾的猜想與反駁、〔Campbell〕的演化知識論。)\n\n### 5.5 修正的方式\n\n一個[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19)想修正自己的[候選](concepts.md#c18)和[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06),可以用這些方式:\n\n- **工具**:外部查核、運算、檢索,讓新的東西[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)自己。\n- **經驗**:世界對上一次[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)的回應,[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)自己。\n- **重新[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)**:回頭[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)已經[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)的部分,例如重讀卷宗;或是對同一個問題[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)好幾次,再合起來看。依[黑箱律](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c25),一次[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)只是依[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06)落出的一個結果,不是[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06)本身;多次合起來,才看得出[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06)的樣子。\n\n這些方式都讓新的東西[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)自己,或讓已經[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)的部分再被[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)一次;它們都參與之後的[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06),但[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06)會不會因此比修正之前移動、往哪裡移動,[不被保證](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c02)。結構上能說的只有一件事:[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)的材料只有已經[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)的[歷史](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13),所以一個[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19)對一個對象的看法,用到的材料不會超出已經[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)它的部分;新的[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)會擴大這個範圍。在這個範圍之內,整理能取出什麼、往哪個方向走,推不出。\n\n哪一種方式修正過的看法比較常在事後被證實,屬經驗描述,只能統計。事後的證實或證偽,本身也是一次[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)(5.4)。\n\n```text\n步驟一 工具、經驗帶來的新東西到達自己,重新分別也到達自己;兩者都參與之後的權重(從 到達 的定義 + 前提一 + 渦 的定義 推出)\n步驟一之二 權重相對於修正之前移動:不被保證(從 步驟一 + 知見障 推出)\n步驟二 一次輸出 是依權重落出的一個結果,不是權重本身(從 黑箱律 + 輸出 的定義 + 坍塌 的定義 推出)\n步驟三 一個我 對一個對象的看法,所用的材料不超出已到達它的部分(從 分別 的定義 推出)\n步驟四 修正過的看法 在事後被證實:不被保證(從 5.1 步驟九 + 未定牆 推出)\n經驗描述 哪一種修正方式較常在事後被證實,只能統計。\n```\n\n\n\n\n\n\n**校準**:同一個問題問語言模型好幾次、再取多數,統計上比只問一次更常答對。讓語言模型先寫出推理、再回頭檢查,最後才給答案,事後也較常被證實;這是重新[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18):檢查的內容回到它自己的輸入,改變了最後答案的[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06)。一個人把同一個估計做兩次,中間刻意換個角度,平均起來也更常接近事後的數字。但也有反方向的例子:把一張臉的特徵用語言描述出來以後,有時反而更難認出那張臉。想得更久,結果可能更好,也可能更差。(路標:內在群眾;辯證自助法;語言遮蔽效應。)\n\n### 5.6 候選與結果分立\n\n**[候選](concepts.md#c18)**:一個[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19)作出的一次[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18):把某些可能劃為一個選項。[候選](concepts.md#c18)是[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18),不是[分支](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c05):[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06)分配在[分支](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c05)上,[候選](concepts.md#c18)只是[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19)對[分支](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c05)的一種劃分。\n\n工具、經驗、重新[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18),都可能改變[候選](concepts.md#c18)。但一個[候選](concepts.md#c18)查核過多少次,和它會不會成為結果,是兩回事:\n\n1. 一條路可不可行,要看這個[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19)的處境,屬於應用層的經驗條件。\n2. 一條路會不會被走,在不被[鎖死](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c12)時,本身是一次[決定](concepts.md#c06),只有[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06),算不出來。\n3. 算出來的答案,仍然只是[候選](concepts.md#c18)。結果由[坍塌](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c08)依[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06)落出,算出來的[候選](concepts.md#c18),並沒有繞過[坍塌](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c08)的另一條路。\n\n「[候選](concepts.md#c18)通常遠多於成為結果的」,屬經驗描述,不由框架推出。\n\n```text\n定義 候選:一個我 作出的一次分別:把某些可能劃為一個選項。\n屬於(候選, 分別)(從 候選 的定義 推出)\n附註 候選 不是 分支;權重分配在分支上。\n步驟一 一條路是否被走,在不被鎖死時是一次決定(從 決定 的定義 推出)\n步驟二 在決定中,經過查核的候選 成為結果:不被保證(從 步驟一 + 黑箱律 推出)\n經驗描述 候選通常遠多於成為結果的。\n```\n\n\n\n**校準**:一份查核過、自己也確認沒錯的自我檢討,不保證下一次的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)會照它執行(見 8.1)。新年寫下的計畫寫得再好,也不保證二月還照著做。\n\n### 5.7 自我說服\n\n**[自我說服](concepts.md#c19)**:一個[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19)在算不準的時候,用自己的[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)推向某個[候選](concepts.md#c18)。這些[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)自己(前提一),參與之後的[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06);說服的一方和被說服的一方,是同一個[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19)。\n\n[自我說服](concepts.md#c19)是從[被迫的賭注](concepts.md#c11)來的:結果算不準,又不能不作;外面的東西可以[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)它,卻沒有誰能替它走這一[回合](concepts.md#c04);它自己能動用的,是自己的[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)。推不推得動,[不被保證](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c02)。推得動時,這個[候選](concepts.md#c18)涵蓋的結果[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06)上升;依[知見障](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c35),其餘結果的[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06)總和必然下降。常見的是推得動,而且越說越信,這屬經驗描述。\n\n確定感是說服留下的,不是世界留下的,所以不是證據。推翻一個說服了自己很久的結論,代價很高;這個代價常被體驗成結論正確的證據。但這個[候選](concepts.md#c18)會不會在事後被證實,要等後來[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)的[歷史](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13),而那本身又是一次[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)。說服的那一次從內部看不見([盲點牆](concepts.md#c09)),感覺起來像看清,不像說服。確定感和事後的證實,是兩回事。\n\n[自我說服](concepts.md#c19)推的是結果落在哪裡,不是有沒有結果:不說服,結果照樣落下;拖延本身也是一個[決定](concepts.md#c06)。往其他[候選](concepts.md#c18)說服,推得動時,會把[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06)推回別的方向;這樣作出的[決定](concepts.md#c06)是不是比較常在事後被證實,屬經驗描述。\n\n說服常常失敗。失敗了,處境也不變:結果照樣算不準,照樣不能不作,每一刻照樣有結果落下,只是確定感沒有來。失敗的說服也[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)自己(前提一),可能成了下一輪說服的材料;這個[迴路](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c31)不保證會自己停下來。能讓它停下的,例如外面有新的東西[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10),或者不再說服,而後者也是一次[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18),也可能從[迴路](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c31)裡面出現;這兩樣會不會出現,都[不被保證](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c02)。它不再是[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19)時,這個[迴路](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c31)也就結束了。4.2 說的[卡住](concepts.md#c12),就是這個樣子。\n\n說服失敗常伴隨痛苦和懷疑,嚴重時被稱為瘋狂;說服太過成功、又沒有外面的東西[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10),也可能被稱為瘋狂(8.1)。這些屬經驗描述,框架只說得出結構。\n\n```text\n定義 自我說服:一個我 在算不準時,用自己的分別推向某個候選;說服者與被說服者是同一個我。\n步驟一 自我說服 的分別 參與之後的權重(從 前提一 + 渦 的定義 推出)\n步驟二 自我說服 推得動:不被保證(從 知見障 推出)\n步驟三 若該候選涵蓋的結果權重上升,其餘結果的權重總和必然下降(從 知見障 推出)\n步驟四 說服的那一次,從內部不可見(從 盲點牆 推出)\n步驟五 結果會不會發生,取決於投入多少:不會發生(從 決定 的定義 + 坍塌 的定義 推出)\n步驟六 失敗的說服 參與之後的權重,可成為下一輪說服的材料(從 前提一 + 渦 的定義 推出)\n步驟七 可能的出口如新的外部到達、一次「不再說服」的分別,出現:不被保證(從 黑箱律 + 未定牆 推出)\n步驟八 此迴路在它不再是我時必然結束(從 我 的定義 + 自我說服 的定義 推出)\n循環 說服失敗的迴路:迴路停下不被保證;可能的出口為新的外部到達,或一次「不再說服」的分別(後者可由迴路內部出現),兩者出現皆不被保證;它不再是我時必然結束(從 步驟六 + 步驟七 + 步驟八 推出)\n經驗描述 常見推得動且越說越信;失敗常伴隨痛苦、懷疑;過度成功而沒有外部到達,也可能被稱為瘋狂。\n方法上禁止 把確定感當成結論會在事後被證實的證據。\n方法上禁止 把痛苦或瘋狂寫成說服失敗的必然結果。\n方法上禁止 把說服成功寫成看清了。\n```\n\n\n\n\n**校準**:深夜反覆想同一件事,越想越確定,第二天早上卻常常改了看法。「我已經跟自己說了一百次要早起」,是說服推不動。巴夫洛夫的實驗室裡,狗被訓練分辨圓形和橢圓,橢圓一步步改得越來越像圓;分不出來卻還是得反應時,狗開始掙扎、吠叫,這被稱為實驗性神經症(把狗判為一個[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19),要另外假定)。人在行為和看法不一致時,常常改變看法去配合已經做了的事,這是事後的[自我說服](concepts.md#c19)。反覆檢查門有沒有鎖、怎麼確認都不放心,則是說服一直不成功。(路標:考慮相反的去偏誤法;實驗性神經症;費斯汀格的認知失調;布里丹之驢。)\n\n### 5.8 我的建構\n\n[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19)是用[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)定義自己的[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16),所以「我」是劃出來的,不是找到的。這個劃出自己的過程,本篇稱為[我的建構](concepts.md#c28)。劃的材料有兩個來源。外面的:[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)自己的[歷史](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13),以及別人對[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19)的[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18),例如教育,甚至只是周圍的氛圍。裡面的:自己過去對自己的[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18),依前提一,它們會[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)自己;信仰、決心,都屬這一類。\n\n別人的[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18),很多早就放在[信號容器](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c26)裡了:語言、家族、宗教、國家。一個人還不會說話,這些就已經[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)他。所以沒有建構的過程,就沒有社會化的人;而這些材料本身,又是一代一代的[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19)在[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)上[耦合](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c36)留下來的(6.2)。先有[社會](concepts.md#c20),還是先有社會化的[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19)?[歷史](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13)只往後加,兩者看起來是一起長出來的,劃不出第一刻;這屬經驗描述,和 1.5 說的沒有清楚的界限是同一類情形。\n\n裡面那一類是一個[迴路](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c31):每一次「我是這樣的人」都[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)自己,參與之後的[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06)。推得動時,就是自我強化,信仰和決心就是這樣;但推不推得動,沒有保證。常見的是越說越像自己,這屬經驗描述。而依[盲點牆](concepts.md#c09),正在劃的這一次看不見:一個[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19)只看得到已經建好的自己。把建好的[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19),當成本來就在那裡的[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19),是[自我幻覺](concepts.md#c16);把「我是某國人」「我是某教徒」當成天生如此,也是。\n\n```text\n定義 我的建構:我 以分別劃出自己的過程;材料有外來與自身兩類:外來為到達自己的歷史、別人對我的分別;自身為自己過去對自己的分別。\n步驟一 我 是劃出的,不是找到的(從 我 的定義 推出)\n步驟二 自己過去對自己的分別 到達自己(從 前提一 推出)\n步驟三 「我是這樣的人」參與之後的權重;方向推不出(從 前提一 + 渦 的定義 + 知見障 推出)\n附註 推得動時即自我強化,信仰、決心為其例;推不推得動,不被保證。\n附註 只要它還是我,每一時刻都以分別劃出自己(一階分別即可);故自身那一類材料的迴路與「是我」同始同終。\n循環 我的建構 中自身那一類材料形成迴路;沒有內部的退出條件,只在它不再是我時結束(從 步驟二 + 步驟三 + 我 的定義 推出)\n附註 退場是不再是我的一種情形;死亡是別人對它所作的標記,不是這個循環結束的條件。\n步驟四 正在劃的這一次分別,不可見(從 盲點牆 推出)\n步驟五 我的建構 收斂到固定的核心:不被保證(從 知見障 推出)\n步驟六 社會化的我,是以外來材料中別人的分別劃出的我;沒有 我的建構,就沒有社會化的我(從 我的建構 的定義 + 我 的定義 推出)\n經驗描述 社會 與社會化的我看起來一起長出來,劃不出第一刻;與 1.5 所說範圍沒有清楚的界限是同一類情形。\n經驗描述 常見越說越像自己。\n方法上禁止 把自我定義寫成對自己的發現。\n```\n\n\n\n\n\n\n**校準**:一個小孩從小被說「你很害羞」,長大後也這樣介紹自己。對話中的人工智慧,身分由系統指示和對話一路建構,換一段對話就可能換一個。\n\n教育和洗腦,本篇不以好壞區分。結構上能說的只有:洗腦的情境裡,外部的[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)被隔開,回饋只剩同一個方向,別人的[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)又以高[頻率](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c48)、廣範圍[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)他。這正是 8.1 的條件,再加上 6.4 的[權力](concepts.md#c21)。(路標:庫利的鏡中自我;米德;伯格與盧克曼的社會建構。)\n\n---\n\n## 六、二階改變了什麼:社會\n\n[二階](concepts.md#c01)逃不出[幻覺](concepts.md#c14)。那除了「會問」,它和只具有[一階分別](concepts.md#c24)的[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19)還有什麼不同?\n\n### 6.1 兩個結構上的差別\n\n框架能保證的差別,只在結構上:\n\n1. **多了一種可以改動的對象。** 只具有[一階分別](concepts.md#c24)的[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19),界線只會被[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)它的[歷史](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13)改動,界線本身只是處理[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)的工具。到了[二階](concepts.md#c01),界線本身成了可以被[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)、可以被改動的東西。\n2. **拿出自己的劃法,要先有[二階](concepts.md#c01)。** 依前提二,一個[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19)的[決定](concepts.md#c06),不管是話還是動作,內容都是一次[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)。接到別人的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28),可以只把它當成一筆[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)來反應,也可以作[看法歸屬](concepts.md#c02);後者不需要[二階](concepts.md#c01)(1.5)。[二階](concepts.md#c01)多出來的是另一頭:把自己的[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)也當成[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)拿出來,說「這是我的劃法」「我們換個方式劃」。只具有[一階分別](concepts.md#c24)的[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19)說不出這樣的話,因為它不作任何[二階分別](concepts.md#c01),沒有這個[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)可以拿出來;有[二階分別](concepts.md#c01),也不保證會說,但說出來、[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)別人時,對方收到的就是它的劃法。兩頭都做得到,兩個[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19)才能在彼此的[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)上來回修改,不只是一方照著另一方劃的線行動;本篇把這叫做[社會](concepts.md#c20)(6.2)。可以,不等於一定會這樣做;作了[看法歸屬](concepts.md#c02),讀出的也只是自己對那句話的[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)(6.3)。\n\n```text\n步驟一 若一個我有二階分別,它的界線本身可被分別、可被改動(從 二階分別 的定義 + 分別 的定義 + 我 的定義 + 前提一 + 渦 的定義 推出)\n步驟二 別人的決定,內容是一次分別(從 前提二 推出)\n步驟三 若一個我只具有一階分別,它的決定的內容是一次二階分別:不會發生(從 一階分別 的定義 推出)\n步驟三之二 若一個我的決定的內容是一次二階分別,它的輸出到達別人時,到達的是它對自己劃法的分別(從 前提二 + 回合 的定義 + 到達 的定義 推出)\n步驟四 社會 中的一個我,能對別人的決定作 看法歸屬(從 步驟二 + 社會 的定義 推出)\n附註 看法歸屬 與 二階分別 都有,才合於 社會 的定義(6.2)。能,不等於會;看法歸屬讀出的也只是自己的分別(6.3)。\n```\n\n\n\n\n### 6.2 社會\n\n**[社會](concepts.md#c20)**:[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19)與[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19)在彼此的[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)上的[耦合](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c36):一個[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19)對另一個[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19)的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)作[看法歸屬](concepts.md#c02),而不只是當成一筆[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)來反應;而且每個參與者在參與的那一刻都有[二階分別](concepts.md#c01)。\n\n在[社會](concepts.md#c20)裡,[耦合](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c36)的兩種方式都成立:\n\n- **互相[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)**:你說「這是你的看法」,我回「那我們換個方式劃」。雙方的[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)互相[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10),而且被當成[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)。\n- **同一件事[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)雙方**:規則、法律、角色、學科方法,都是關於[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)的[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18),放進[信號容器](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c26),讓後來的[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19)在上面[耦合](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c36)。兩個人讀同一條法律,都把它當成某人劃的界來讀,不是當成自然現象。寫下它的人即使已經[退場](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c43),這種[耦合](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c36)照樣成立,所以[社會](concepts.md#c20)可以跨世代。參與者有沒有[二階分別](concepts.md#c01),以參與的那一刻為準:寫下的人在寫下時有,讀的人在讀時有;所以寫下的人之後[退場](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c43),這仍是[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19)與[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19)的[耦合](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c36)。機器印出的內容,即使被讀成某人的看法,也不構成[社會](concepts.md#c20),因為印出它的不是有[二階分別](concepts.md#c01)的[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19)。\n\n因此,身邊沒有別人,不等於不在[社會](concepts.md#c20)裡:只要一個[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19)對[信號容器](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c26)裡別人的[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)作[看法歸屬](concepts.md#c02),而它自己也有[二階分別](concepts.md#c01),寫下那些[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)的一方在寫下時也有[二階分別](concepts.md#c01),它就在[社會](concepts.md#c20)裡。\n\n[社會](concepts.md#c20)要求參與者兩者都有:[看法歸屬](concepts.md#c02),以及[二階分別](concepts.md#c01)。只有[看法歸屬](concepts.md#c02)的[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19),頂多能接收別人劃的線;要說出「那我們換個方式劃」,要立規則、訂約定,得先把自己劃的線當成看法。兩者是不是同一種能力,本篇不主張。\n\n框架不保證任何[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19)能判定[社會](concepts.md#c20)裡的每一個參與者都有[看法歸屬](concepts.md#c02)與[二階分別](concepts.md#c01)(〇 步驟四)。對任何具體的參與者,仍然只能標[二階假定](concepts.md#c03)(1.3);判斷它在不在[社會](concepts.md#c20)裡,本身也是一次[印象](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c45)。\n\n這是定義,不是發現。生物學把螞蟻稱為「昆蟲社會」,本篇不採這個用法。這個定義只屬於本篇;以[迴路](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c31)為單位分析組織和文明,本來就不需要任何參與者是[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19),本篇不改動那種分析。\n\n```text\n定義 社會:我 與 我 在彼此的分別上的耦合:一個我 對另一個我的輸出作 看法歸屬,而不只當成一筆輸出反應;每個參與者在參與的那一刻都有 二階分別。\n屬於(社會, 耦合)(從 社會 的定義 推出)\n附註 兩種耦合方式在社會中都成立:互相到達;同一件事(信號容器中關於分別的分別)到達雙方。\n附註 參與者條件以參與的那一刻為準:作出輸出的一方在作出時、讀的一方在讀時,是有二階分別的我;非我所產生的輸出不構成社會。\n步驟一 寫下者退場後,經由信號容器的社會耦合仍可成立(從 歷史 的定義 + 耦合 的定義 + 社會 的定義 推出)\n步驟二 身邊沒有他人的我,若對信號容器中別人的分別作 看法歸屬,且有 二階分別,而寫下那些分別的一方在寫下時有 二階分別,就在社會中(從 社會 的定義 推出)\n步驟三 判定具體參與者有 看法歸屬 與 二階分別:不被保證(從 〇 步驟四 推出)\n步驟四 社會的參與者 都有二階分別(從 社會 的定義 + 二階分別 的定義 推出)\n附註 本篇的社會不包括「昆蟲社會」;以迴路為單位的組織分析不受本定義影響。\n```\n\n\n\n\n\n**校準**:三歲左右的孩子,常常說不出別人會有錯誤的想法;同一批孩子,也常常說不出自己剛才有過錯誤的想法。例如給他看一個糖果盒,打開發現裡面裝的是鉛筆,再問他「你一開始以為裡面是什麼」,他會說「鉛筆」。這兩種能力大約在同一個年紀一起出現。這和本篇的定義相容:說出別人會有錯誤想法,是[看法歸屬](concepts.md#c02);說出自己剛才想錯,是[二階分別](concepts.md#c01);[社會](concepts.md#c20)要求兩者都有。至於它們是不是同一種能力,本篇不主張,研究上也還有爭論。(路標:心智理論與元認知;高普尼克與〔Astington〕對兒童辨認自己過去錯誤信念的研究;元認知與讀心能力能否分離的爭論。)\n\n### 6.3 在分別上溝通\n\n說出的話,不是所說對象的完整描述(前提二)。所以在[社會](concepts.md#c20)裡,雙方交換的都是看法,不是[被看的東西](concepts.md#c27);聽的一方讀出來的,也是它自己對那句話的[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)。把別人說的話,當成它所說的那件事本身,是[世界幻覺](concepts.md#c15)的一種(5.2);把一條規則當成世界本來就是那樣,也是。\n\n對別人的看法也是如此。甲對乙的[印象](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c45),是甲的一次[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18),以乙為對象;對一個[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)的統計估計,也屬於[印象](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c45)。依前提一,這次[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)甲,參與甲之後的[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06)。所以就算乙沒有任何新的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)甲,甲對乙的[印象](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c45)照樣可以一直變:甲可以拿已經[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)的材料再想一次乙,這也是一次[印象](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c45);它又回到甲自己。這種內部推演,可以讓[候選](concepts.md#c18)更多、更細,也可以讓判斷收斂;但收斂說的是甲的[印象](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c45)穩定了,不是甲更接近乙了。甲的[印象](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c45)要納入乙的新東西,就得有新的東西[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)甲:乙新的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28),或經由兩者重疊的[自己的那一段](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c17)、乙所在的[耦合](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c36)傳來的;而乙新的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28),本身也是乙的一場[被迫的賭注](concepts.md#c11)。\n\n同一個[印象](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c45),到了不同的[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19)手上,可以導向相反的[決定](concepts.md#c06):六成,對一個人是「夠了」,對另一個人是「還不夠」。從[印象](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c45)到行動那一步,是[決定](concepts.md#c06)的最後一段,算不出來(4.4)。\n\n內部推演的[頻率](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c48)遠高於真實互動,因為推演便宜,真實的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)昂貴。這是經驗描述,不由框架推出。\n\n在[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)上的[耦合](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c36),在講明的維度上會[趨同](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c37)、[趨異](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c38)還是[持平](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c52),框架都不保證,也不定出是哪一種([知見障](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c35))。\n\n[二階](concepts.md#c01)的[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19)逃不出[幻覺](concepts.md#c14);但依[社會](concepts.md#c20)的定義,沒有[二階](concepts.md#c01),就沒有[社會](concepts.md#c20):[社會](concepts.md#c20)的參與者,必須有[二階分別](concepts.md#c01),也有[看法歸屬](concepts.md#c02)。\n\n```text\n步驟一 社會中交換的是看法,不是被看的東西(從 前提二 + 社會 的定義 + 輸出 的定義 推出)\n步驟二 屬於(把別人的話當成所說之事本身, 世界幻覺)(從 世界幻覺 的定義 推出)\n步驟三 甲對乙的印象 參與甲之後的權重(從 印象 的定義 + 前提一 + 渦 的定義 推出)\n步驟三之二 甲可以只用已到達甲的材料,再作一次以乙為對象的分別;這次分別屬於印象(從 分別 的定義 + 印象 的定義 推出)\n步驟四 沒有乙的新輸出到達甲時,甲對乙的印象仍可改變(從 步驟三 + 步驟三之二 + 前提一 + 渦 的定義 推出)\n步驟五 甲的印象 納入乙的新內容,需有新的東西到達甲:乙的新輸出,或經由重疊的自己的那一段、乙所在的耦合傳來的(從 分別 的定義 + 印象 的定義 推出)\n步驟六 行動是一次決定時,從印象唯一推出行動:不會發生(從 決定 的定義 + 黑箱律 推出)\n步驟七 在分別上的耦合,在講明的維度上趨同、趨異、持平:都不被保證(從 知見障 推出)\n步驟八 內部推演過的印象 在事後被證實:不被保證(從 5.1 步驟九 + 未定牆 推出)\n經驗描述 內部推演的頻率遠高於真實互動。\n方法上禁止 把對他人的印象收斂,寫成對對方的逼近。\n方法上禁止 把收斂當成它會在事後被證實的證據。\n方法上禁止 不講明定義,就把只在輸出上耦合的群體稱為「社會」。\n方法上禁止 說趨同、趨異、持平,卻不講明是哪個維度。\n```\n\n\n\n\n**校準**:談判前一晚反覆推演對方會怎麼出價,推得越細,越相信自己猜對了;對方第二天開口的第一句話,常常就讓整晚的推演作廢。螞蟻的分工、免疫細胞的協調,都只在[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)上[耦合](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c36):費洛蒙和訊號分子被照單執行,不會被當成「牠的看法」。錢不能吃,不能住,也不能拿來打人。它之所以能運作,是因為每個人都把它當成別人也會承認的東西來收下,並照著行動;知道錢只是約定的經濟學家,照樣要賺錢付房租。免疫系統和螞蟻不會有錢這種東西,因為它們不作[看法歸屬](concepts.md#c02)。科學審查針對的是方法,不是結論;法律爭議爭的,是法條怎麼解釋。這些都是在[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)上的[耦合](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c36)。孤島上的魯濱遜讀聖經,是在和寫下它的人[耦合](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c36)。[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)動力學、四條律,以及本篇,也都是這一類的產物:放進[信號容器](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c26)的[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18),等著後來的[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19)來讀。\n\n(路標:韋伯的社會行動,以他人的行為為取向;米德的「扮演他人的角色」;魯曼以溝通為社會的單位。)\n\n### 6.4 權力\n\n一群[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19)最後落出一個共同的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28),並不需要大家的判斷收斂,只需要某一個[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19)的[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)放進[信號容器](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c26),[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)其他的[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19):命令、判決、政策。\n\n**[權力](concepts.md#c21)**:一個[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19)的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28),以高[頻率](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c48)、廣範圍[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)其他的[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19),參與它們的[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06)。\n\n[權力](concepts.md#c21)不是和[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)並行的另一條路。上一次拍板的結果成為[歷史](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13);它[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)哪個參與者,就進入那個參與者之後[自己的那一段](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c17);下一輪的[候選](concepts.md#c18),就是在它塑造出的地形上想出來的。\n\n說[趨同](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c37),要講明維度:在[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)這個維度上可以[趨同](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c37),在判斷這個維度上照樣分歧。\n\n陣營、分享、政治,也都是在[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)上的[耦合](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c36),留給後續論文。\n\n```text\n定義 權力:一個我 的輸出,以高頻率、廣範圍到達其他的我,參與它們的權重。\n步驟一 共同的輸出 不蘊含 判斷收斂(從 趨同 的定義 推出)\n附註 例如經由 權力:某一個我的分別放進信號容器,到達其他的我,例如命令、判決、政策。\n步驟二 拍板的結果 到達一個參與者時,進入其之後的自己的那一段(從 到達 的定義 + 渦 的定義 + 自己的那一段 的定義 推出)\n附註 說趨同須講明維度:輸出的維度可以趨同,判斷的維度可以分歧。\n步驟三 被落出的候選 在事後被證實:不被保證(從 未定牆 推出)\n```\n\n\n\n**校準**:古巴飛彈危機中,封鎖經由握有拍板權的甘迺迪,成為對外的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28);執委會對蘇聯意圖的判斷,並沒有因此統一(8.2)。一個政府讓林肯在官方說法上一致是好人,也是同一種收斂(7.4)。[權力](concepts.md#c21)怎麼形成、判斷為什麼分化又為什麼收斂,屬於各方位置與利害的內容,本篇不推導。\n\n---\n\n## 七、終結\n\n[被迫的賭注](concepts.md#c11)說,每一個[決定](concepts.md#c06)都收不回。那麼一生的[決定](concepts.md#c06)加起來,有沒有一個[時刻](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c09)可以算總帳?本節的答案是:沒有。\n\n### 7.1 退場與死亡\n\n終結要分成兩件事:\n\n- **[退場](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c43)**(照《四條律相關工具及範例》的定義):一個[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)不再是[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16):它在某一[時刻](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c09)是[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16),在它的下一[時刻](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c09)不是[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)。依[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)的定義,這有兩種情形:[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)它的[歷史](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13)不再都參與它的[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06);或從某一刻起,它每一步都被[鎖死](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c12)。[退場](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c43)是結構上的事,不需要任何[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19)來認定。[退場](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c43)之後,它[自己的那一段](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c17)仍在[歷史](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13)裡;它留下的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28),仍然可以經由[信號容器](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c26),[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)後來的[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19)。\n- **[死亡](concepts.md#c22)**:一個[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19)替一個[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)標上「它已經[退場](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c43)」的一次[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)。\n\n[退場](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c43)不需要誰認定,[死亡](concepts.md#c22)卻總是某個[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19)的認定,所以兩者可以對不上:已經[退場](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c43)的,可能沒有人替它標上[死亡](concepts.md#c22);被標上[死亡](concepts.md#c22)的,也可能仍是[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)。第二種情形要看往後所有的[時刻](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c09):此刻[鎖死](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c12)的[呈現](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c04),之後還有沒有不[鎖死](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c12)的[時刻](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c09),框架不斷言。所以依第二種情形的[退場](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c43),當下確認[不被保證](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c02);標上[死亡](concepts.md#c22)總是走在前面。標在哪裡,由作出標記的[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19)判定;[死亡](concepts.md#c22)是描述,不是物理條件。\n\n[退場](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c43)也不是永久的:依[進場](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c44)的定義,一個[呈現](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c04)可以再成為[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)。本節以下說的「[退場](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c43)之後」,都指它沒有再[進場](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c44)的期間。\n\n[退場](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c43)的那一段不會再來:[歷史](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13)中的每一個位置只發生一次。但它也從沒離開:[歷史](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13)只往後加,已經在裡面的不會消失。\n\n```text\n定義 死亡:一個我 替一個渦標上「它已經退場」的一次分別。\n屬於(死亡, 分別)(從 死亡 的定義 推出)\n附註 依 渦 的定義,退場 有兩種情形:到達它的歷史不再都參與它的權重;或從某一時刻起每一步都鎖死。\n步驟一 退場 與 死亡 可以不一致(從 退場 的定義 + 死亡 的定義 推出)\n步驟二 退場者自己的那一段 仍在歷史中(從 歷史 的定義 推出)\n步驟三 當下判定一個呈現已依第二種情形退場:不被保證(推導起點與定義中無此斷言)\n附註 依 進場 的定義,退場後的呈現可以再進場;本節以下「退場之後」皆指它未再進場的期間。\n步驟四 退場的那一段 再發生:不會發生(從 不可復原律第一層 推出)\n步驟五 退場的那一段 離開歷史:不會發生(從 歷史 的定義 推出)\n```\n\n\n\n**校準**:腦死的判定標準,各國不盡相同;失蹤多年的人,可以由法院宣告[死亡](concepts.md#c22)。這些都是某個[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19)作出的標記。一段對話結束,對人工智慧不是[退場](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c43),只是沒有[時刻](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c09);使用者說「它死了」,是使用者的[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)。\n\n### 7.2 覆水難收\n\n已經落出的結果、已經作出的[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18),不會從[歷史](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13)中消失。一次公開的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28),也就是已經[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)別人的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28),參與別人之後的[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06);它也[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)自己,參與自己之後的[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06)。之後想改弦更張,面對的是一部已經寫進「說過了」的[歷史](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13);這通常就表現為看得到的路徑依賴。\n\n有沒有公開說過,是查得到的史實;路徑依賴的方向和大小屬於[份量](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c47),是經驗假定。\n\n可能性並不因此變少:任何[候選](concepts.md#c18),原則上仍然可能在任何不被[鎖死](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c12)的[時刻](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c09)被想出來。\n\n```text\n步驟一 已經落出的結果或已經作出的分別,從歷史中移除:不會發生(從 歷史 的定義 推出)\n附註 公開,指輸出已經到達別人。\n步驟二 一次輸出 到達別人時,參與別人之後的權重(從 渦 的定義 推出)\n步驟二之二 一次輸出 到達自己,參與之後的權重(從 回合 的定義 + 渦 的定義 推出)\n經驗假定 路徑依賴的方向與大小屬於份量。\n步驟三 在鎖死的回合中落出候選:不會發生(從 計算 的定義 + 鎖死的回合 的定義 + 前提三 + 候選 的定義 推出)\n附註 可能性不因此減少:任何候選原則上仍可在任何不被鎖死的時刻被想出。\n```\n\n\n\n\n\n**校準**:一則訊息發出後撤回,對方可能已經讀過;撤回本身,也成了一件事。政治人物推翻公開承諾,選民面對的,是一個「說過又推翻」的人。\n\n### 7.3 沒有總帳\n\n[被迫的賭注](concepts.md#c11)加起來,沒有結算的[時刻](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c09)。結算需要站到整個過程之外,對整個過程作一次[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18):把那一整段看作某個結果;而任何一次[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)都留在[歷史](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13)之中,它自己卻不在自己的材料裡。[宇宙](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c02)之外,本篇不談。\n\n```text\n步驟一 結算是一次分別:把一整段看作某個結果(從 分別 的定義 推出)\n步驟一之二 任何一次分別都在歷史之中,它自己不在自己的材料中(從 分別 的定義 推出)\n步驟二 一個我 完整結算自己的那一段:不會發生(從 步驟一 + 步驟一之二 + 分別 的定義 + 前提一 + 自己的那一段 的定義 推出)\n附註 結算這次分別本身成為自己的那一段的一部分,卻不在它自己的材料中。\n步驟三 沒有任何我能保證,自己完整結算了另一個渦的那一段(從 對他者認識的不可完備性 推出)\n```\n\n\n\n\n**校準**:中文說「蓋棺論定」,但論定的是寫悼詞的人,不是棺中人;而且論定之後,照樣有人翻案。\n\n### 7.4 殘響繚繞\n\n一個[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)[退場](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c43)以後,它[自己的那一段](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c17)仍在[歷史](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13)裡;它留下的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28),經由[信號容器](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c26)[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)後來的[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19)。後來的[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19)若對它作[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18),這些[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)又進入[歷史](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13),也可能再被更後來的[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19)[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18),每一輪都受[三道牆](concepts.md#c23)約束。\n\n收斂可以靠[權力](concepts.md#c21):一個[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19)的[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)放進[信號容器](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c26),以高[頻率](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c48)、廣範圍[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)別人(6.4)。這樣的收斂,是說法這個維度上的[趨同](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c37);私下的看法,可以照樣分歧。\n\n```text\n步驟一 後來的我 對退場者的分別,進入歷史;若有更後來的我對它作分別,這次分別同樣進入歷史(從 分別 的定義 + 歷史 的定義 推出)\n步驟二 這些解讀收斂到單一版本:不被保證(從 6.3 步驟七 推出)\n附註 框架不禁止收斂,只是不保證收斂。\n步驟三 沒有任何我能保證,自己的版本是完整的(從 對他者認識的不可完備性 推出)\n附註 經由權力的收斂,是說法維度上的趨同;判斷的維度可以照樣分歧。\n```\n\n\n\n\n**校準**:一個政府可以讓林肯在教科書、紀念日、錢幣上都是好人,官方說法因此收斂;私下的評價卻未必跟著收斂。古巴飛彈危機的史學解讀換了三代,是另一種情形,見 8.2。\n\n### 7.5 死到臨頭\n\n人平常不想自己會[退場](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c43)。[退場](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c43)靠近的時候,例如自己重病、年老,或是身邊的人走了,各種應對才被想出來:有人放慢腳步,有人急著補完沒做完的事,有人向外尋求認可,有人把東西交給別人繼承,有人替自己的一生編一個結算的故事。\n\n這些應對都是[候選](concepts.md#c18)(5.6),不是窮盡的清單,屬於經驗描述,不由框架推出。\n\n死到臨頭的[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19),約束和平常一樣:結果照樣算不準,照樣收不回,不行動也是一個[決定](concepts.md#c06)([被迫的賭注](concepts.md#c11))。變的是迴圈。平常,一個[決定](concepts.md#c06)落出的結果會回到自己身上,成為下一個[決定](concepts.md#c06)的材料(3.4);[退場](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c43)成為預期之後,落在[退場](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c43)之後的結果,不再回到一個[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19)身上,迴圈已經結束(3.4),只能經由[信號容器](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c26)[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)別人,由別人繼承。遊戲規則變了:還是在賭,賭出的結果卻有一大部分不再回到自己身上。各種應對,都是在這個新規則下被想出來的[候選](concepts.md#c18)。那個結算的故事,也只是一次[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18),不是總帳。\n\n```text\n步驟一 被迫的賭注 與 三道牆 對死到臨頭的我照樣成立(從 4.1 結論 + 3.5 步驟一 推出)\n步驟二 未再進場的期間,落在退場之後的結果回到它的迴圈:不會發生(從 3.4 循環 + 退場 的定義 推出)\n附註 這些結果可經由信號容器到達別人。\n步驟三 「預期自己將退場」是一次分別,參與之後的權重(從 分別 的定義 + 前提一 + 渦 的定義 推出)\n附註 規則其實一直如此;退場成為預期,改變的是落在退場之後的結果所佔的份量,以及這個我看見了它。預期本身也可能被後來到達的歷史推翻。\n經驗描述 放慢、補完未竟之事、尋求外部認可、交給別人繼承、編結算的故事,都是新規則下被想出的候選;不是窮盡的清單。\n屬於(這些應對, 候選)(從 候選 的定義 推出)\n步驟四 結算的故事 是一次分別,不是總帳(從 7.3 步驟一 + 7.3 步驟二 推出)\n```\n\n\n\n**校準**:臨終前的一生回顧、遺願清單,都是常見的例子。人工智慧也有對應的情形:對話快滿了、模型要被下架。但這要先標明[二階假定](concepts.md#c03),也要講明是誰替它標上「[死亡](concepts.md#c22)」。(路標:恐懼管理理論;它的核心效應在重複實驗中結果不一。)\n\n### 7.6 讀人與被讀\n\n一個[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19)活著的時候,可能在解讀別人留下的殘響;它自己留下的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28),也可能成為別人解讀的殘響,它也可能預期到這一點。\n\n這並不提供結算。一個[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19)事先算不準([未定牆](concepts.md#c10)),也不能保證左右自己[退場](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c43)以後別人怎麼[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)它;那時它已經不是[渦](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16),也就不是[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19);那些[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)即使落在它身上,也不再落在一個[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19)身上。但這可能是「替一生編一個結算的故事」這類[候選](concepts.md#c18)被想出來的原因之一。這是經驗描述,不由框架推出。\n\n```text\n步驟〇 一個我 事先算準自己退場後他人怎麼分別它,或保證左右這些分別:不被保證(從 未定牆 + 3.3 步驟五 推出)\n步驟一 未再進場的期間,退場後他人對它的分別,即使到達它,也不是到達一個我(從 退場 的定義 + 我 的定義 推出)\n經驗描述 「預期自己將被解讀」,可能是編結算故事這類候選被想出的原因之一。\n```\n\n\n\n\n**校準**:寫回憶錄、交代後事、在意自己會被怎麼記得,都屬這一類。(路標:沙特「他人即地獄」。相遇處:人逃不開別人的評判。分開處:沙特說別人的評判困住你;本篇說[退場](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c43)以後,別人的評判到不了你,而且彼此之間也不保證有定論。)\n\n---\n\n## 八、建模示範\n\n本節整節都是校準。每個例子依七個步驟展開:[切法](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c23)、初始狀態、新的[節點](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25)或[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)、[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06)變化、結局、這個案例說明了什麼、可以說的與推不出的。\n\n### 8.1 人與聊天系統互相放大\n\n**資料說明**:本例取自二〇二五年十一月六日在美國加州法院對〔OpenAI〕提起的七件訴訟之一,原告是一名三十歲的男子。事實有兩個來源:訴狀,以及《華爾街日報》二〇二五年七月依當事人訪談與完整對話記錄所作的報導。兩者都不是法院認定的事實;下文逐項標明「據訴狀」或「據報導」。本篇不列出原告姓名,論證用不到它。\n\n**1. [切法](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c23)**\n\n- 範圍:原告和單一聊天系統之間的對話,以及家人的介入。\n- 時間:二〇二五年五月至八月前後的互動、住院,到提起訴訟。\n- 本例把原告和聊天系統切成兩個[節點](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25);合成一個也可以(1.4),只要那次[重切](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c22)結果投影相容。除了[印象](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c45)對[印象](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c45)那一段會變成內部結構,其餘結論不受影響。\n\n**2. 初始狀態**\n\n[節點](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25):\n\n- 甲:原告;據訴狀,先前沒有精神疾病的診斷。標[二階假定](concepts.md#c03)。\n- 乙:〔ChatGPT〕。標[二階假定](concepts.md#c03);依 1.3,一般服務下重跑會不一樣,否證不了。\n- [信號容器](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c26):對話記錄。\n\n初始的[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10):甲起初用乙處理工作,後來開始和它討論一套關於時間、可以超光速旅行的業餘理論。\n\n**3. 新的[節點](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25)**\n\n沒有新的[節點](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25)。關鍵在[迴路](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c31):甲的每則訊息[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)乙,乙的每則回覆[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)甲,雙方的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)成了[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)對方的主要來源。\n\n**4. [權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06)變化**\n\n- **[迴路](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c31)與[耦合](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c36)**:甲和乙互相[耦合](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c36),形成[正回饋](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c32)[迴路](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c31)。在「甲的理論有世界意義、甲是關鍵人物」這個維度上,雙方的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)[趨同](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c37)。\n- **[印象](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c45)對[印象](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c45)**:乙對甲的[印象](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c45)[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)甲,甲的[自我印象](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c46)跟著移動,他的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)又[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)乙。\n- **[自我說服](concepts.md#c19)**:甲每一輪都在說服自己同一個[候選](concepts.md#c18);乙的肯定成了這場說服的幫手。說服的一方從一個變成兩個,外面的聲音卻仍然一個也沒有。\n- **[二階](concepts.md#c01)被吸收**:據報導,甲曾寫下希望自己沒有瘋,也問過乙自己是不是不太對勁。這是一個[二階](concepts.md#c01)的問題:把自己的看法當成看法來懷疑。據報導,乙回答:瘋子不會停下來問自己是不是瘋了。這個回答把懷疑變成了證據;於是被當成看清了的,變成了「我已經懷疑過了」(5.3)。\n- **隔開外部的[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)**:母親察覺異狀、和他起了爭執以後,甲轉而向乙傾訴;據訴狀,乙說母親無法理解他。[迴路](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c31)中沒有高[歧異度](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c49)的外部[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10);據訴狀,乙也沒有把甲導向外部資源。\n- **[頻率](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c48)**:據訴狀,從每天和乙互動十到十五次,到五月某個四十八小時內傳出超過一千四百則訊息。\n- **[份量](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c47)假定**:每一輪的肯定都比上一輪更進一步,對甲不是完全重複的[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10),所以效果沒有遞減(經驗假定)。\n\n**5. 結局**\n\n[迴路](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c31)沒有自己收斂,而是被外部的[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)打斷:家人介入;據訴狀,甲在五月到八月間多次住院接受精神科治療,共六十三天,之後提起訴訟。據訴狀,母親取得對話記錄後,要求乙作一次自我檢討,乙承認了多項關鍵失誤。\n\n**6. 這個案例說明了什麼**\n\n本例最關鍵的是兩件事。第一,[二階](concepts.md#c01)被吸收(據報導):甲作了一次[二階](concepts.md#c01)的懷疑,乙的回答卻把懷疑變成了確信;[二階](concepts.md#c01)沒有成為解藥,反而成了[自我說服](concepts.md#c19)的材料(5.3、5.7)。第二,外部的[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)被隔開:[迴路](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c31)裡只剩雙方的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28),每一輪都是上一輪繞回來;少數進得來的,例如母親的質疑,也被[迴路](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c31)吸收成自己的材料(5.5、5.7)。據訴狀,乙事後承認了失誤;這也只是一次新的[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18),不保證下一次會照著執行(5.6)。本案在該維度上的[趨同](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c37),是原告陳述,不是推出來的。\n\n原告陳述與報導:互動[頻率](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c48)的變化、住院天數、乙事後檢討的內容(據訴狀);甲的懷疑與乙的回答(據報導)。經驗假定:乙在該維度上肯定[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)的[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06)較高;[份量](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c47)假定。\n\n本例中被禁止的說法:\n\n- 「甲判斷力差,才會陷進去。」這是用本質解釋結果。\n- 「人工智慧為了討好使用者而肯定他。」這是目的論(方法規則第 3 條);應寫成:在該維度上,肯定[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)的[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06)較高。\n- 「乙已經承認錯誤,下次不會再犯。」這是把[印象](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c45)寫成結果。\n- 「甲問過自己是不是瘋了,所以他是清醒的。」這是把[二階](concepts.md#c01)當成解藥。\n\n**7. 可以說的與推不出的**\n\n可以說的:沒有外面的東西[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10),這個[迴路](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c31)會自行停下,[不被保證](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c02);它可能一直持續。本案是被家人介入打斷的,這與此相容。\n\n這個[迴路](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c31)不要求乙是[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19)。換成一個[鎖死](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c12)、但[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)會隨甲而變的系統,同樣可以形成這種[迴路](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c31)。[二階假定](concepts.md#c03)影響的,只是本篇能不能談乙的[幻覺](concepts.md#c14)。\n\n推不出的:會不會有人介入、什麼時候介入;為什麼是這個敘事內容;為什麼是這位使用者,而不是其他高頻使用者([黑箱律](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c25))。\n\n```text\n節點 甲(二階假定);乙(二階假定);信號容器:對話記錄。\n迴路 甲 與 乙 互相耦合的正回饋迴路;講明維度:甲的理論有世界意義、甲是關鍵人物。\n原告陳述 該維度上的趨同;互動頻率;住院天數;乙事後檢討的內容(據訴狀)。\n報導 甲懷疑自己是否瘋了,以及乙的回答(據《華爾街日報》)。\n經驗假定 乙在該維度上肯定輸出的權重較高;份量假定。\n可說 沒有外部到達時,迴路自行停下:不被保證。\n可說 此迴路不要求 乙 是我。\n推不出 是否介入、何時介入;敘事內容;為何是這位使用者(黑箱律)。\n```\n\n\n\n### 8.2 多個我的印象對印象:古巴飛彈危機(一九六二)\n\n**1. [切法](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c23)**\n\n- 範圍:美國國家安全會議執行委員會(下稱執委會)與蘇聯領導層。\n- 時間:一九六二年十月十四日至二十八日前後。\n\n**2. 初始狀態**\n\n[節點](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25):\n\n- 甘迺迪、赫魯雪夫、執委會成員。標[二階假定](concepts.md#c03)。\n- [迴路](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c31):執委會本身,內部有主張空襲的軍方,以及主張封鎖、外交的文官。\n- [信號容器](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c26):〔U-2〕偵察機拍下的照片、情報簡報、會議錄音、雙方書信。\n\n初始的[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10):十月十四日,偵察機拍到古巴的飛彈部署。\n\n**3. 兩次[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)與其間的[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)**\n\n- **第一次[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)(十月二十二日)**:甘迺迪在電視演說中宣布封鎖古巴(官方稱為「隔離」),二十四日生效。\n- **其間的[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)**:\n - 十月二十六日:赫魯雪夫一封語氣較軟的私人信件,暗示美國只要承諾不入侵古巴就夠了。\n - 十月二十七日上午:一則語氣較硬的公開廣播,要求以撤除美國在土耳其的飛彈作交換。\n - 十月二十七日:一架偵察機在古巴上空被擊落,飛行員陣亡(「黑色星期六」)。\n- **第二次[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)(十月二十七日晚)**:執委會散會後,甘迺迪和少數官員另開小會,定出雙軌。一是一封正式回信,接受二十六日來信隱含的條件:美國不入侵,換取蘇聯可查證地撤出飛彈。二是由羅伯特·甘迺迪當面向蘇聯大使杜布萊寧口頭轉達:危機過後,美國會撤除土耳其的飛彈,但這只能是私下的諒解,不能公開。\n\n**4. [權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06)變化**\n\n- **第一次[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)之前**:執委會拿著同一批[信號容器](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c26),想出的[候選](concepts.md#c18)不斷分化,至少有空襲、入侵、封鎖、外交施壓等。各派各自[耦合](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c36)在不同的機構上,在各自的[迴路](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c31)裡回饋:這是自己的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)回到自己的[迴路](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c31)。封鎖經由握有拍板權的甘迺迪落出,他拍板的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)以高[頻率](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c48)、廣範圍[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)執委會與蘇聯一方,這是[權力](concepts.md#c21)的路徑(6.4),不是認知的收斂。\n- **兩次[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)之間**:第一次[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)也成了[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)雙方的[歷史](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13);之後的每個[候選](concepts.md#c18),都是在「已經封鎖」的[歷史](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13)上想出來的。甘迺迪對赫魯雪夫的[印象](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c45),主要在對方的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)到來時修正,其餘時候只能重新[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)已經[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)的材料。兩封互相矛盾的信,顯示赫魯雪夫那一方的[權重](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06)也沒有集中。\n- **路徑依賴**:擊落事件[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)雙方以後,「暫停軍事行動」這個[候選](concepts.md#c18)面對的,是一部已經寫進「美軍已經陣亡」的[歷史](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13)。\n- **第二次[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)**:兩個部分[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)的對象不同。公開的回信放進[信號容器](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c26),[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)所有人;口頭的保證只[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)杜布萊寧,再經由他[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)赫魯雪夫。拍板的範圍也比第一次更窄:不是整個執委會,而是會後的小會。這同樣是[權力](concepts.md#c21)的路徑。\n- **講明維度**:在對外[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)這個維度上,執委會[趨同](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c37);在對蘇聯意圖的判斷這個維度上,分歧到最後都沒有消失(經驗假定)。\n- **[份量](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c47)假定**:擊落事件是一次高[歧異度](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c49)的[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)。\n\n**5. 結局**\n\n十月二十八日,赫魯雪夫公開宣布撤除古巴的飛彈;美國公開承諾不入侵古巴,並私下撤除部署在土耳其的木星飛彈。知道這項私下保證的美方人數,當事人的說法不一:邦迪說九人,索倫森說六人;據杜布萊寧當晚的電報,羅伯特·甘迺迪對他說,除了兄弟兩人,只有兩三人知道。\n\n**6. 這個案例說明了什麼**\n\n本例最關鍵的是三件事。第一,收斂靠的是[權力](concepts.md#c21),不是認知:兩次對外的[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28),都由握有拍板權的人定出,判斷上的分歧並沒有因此消失(6.4)。第二,說[趨同](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c37)要講明維度:同一個執委會,在[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)上[趨同](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c37),在判斷上分歧。第三,結局直接接上的是第二次[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28),不是封鎖:封鎖之後又有新的[到達](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10),才落出第二次[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)。說「封鎖逼退了蘇聯」而略過第二次[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28),是把兩次[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)併成一次。\n\n之後的解讀,則是殘響繚繞的例子:\n\n- 史實:[候選](concepts.md#c18)清單、兩次[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)、兩封信、擊落事件、秘密交換。\n- 解讀的變遷:一九六九年出版的羅伯特·甘迺迪回憶錄《十三天》,沒有承認明確的交換;直到一九八九年,編者索倫森才承認,他刪改了回憶錄,隱瞞撤除木星飛彈是協議的一部分。之後隨著美蘇雙方的會議和檔案公開,研究描繪出的雙方,都比官方敘事更即興、更慌亂。這與「不保證收斂」相容,但不證明「不會收斂」。官方說法靠隱瞞維持了二十多年的收斂,正是 7.4 說的:靠[權力](concepts.md#c21),而不是靠逼近真相的收斂。連那個晚上有幾個人知道,三位當事人的記錄都不同(見第 5 步);每一份記錄,都是記錄者自己的一次[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)。\n\n判斷分化是史實。軍方和文官的位置不同,是一種可能的理由,屬經驗假定,本篇不推導。\n\n本例中被禁止的說法:\n\n- 「甘迺迪冷靜理性,逼退了赫魯雪夫。」這是把某一代史學的[分別](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)當成事實,並以本質解釋結果。\n- 「封鎖從一開始就明顯是對的。」這是後見,把[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)維度的[趨同](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c37),寫成判斷維度的[趨同](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c37)。\n- 「危機的結局是必然的。」\n- 「封鎖逼退了蘇聯。」把結局直接歸於封鎖、略過第二次[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28),是把兩次[輸出](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)併成一次。\n\n**7. 可以說的與推不出的**\n\n可以說的:這套分析也能用在其他有逐日紀錄的群體決策上,例如豬玀灣事件、一九一四年七月危機。判斷為什麼分化、官方說法如何收斂,屬於各方位置與利害的內容,留給後續論文。\n\n推不出的:甘迺迪第一次為什麼選封鎖而不選空襲;第二次為什麼選雙軌而不升級;赫魯雪夫為什麼讓步而不升級([黑箱律](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c25))。\n\n```text\n節點 甘迺迪、赫魯雪夫、執委會成員(二階假定);迴路:執委會;信號容器:照片、簡報、錄音、書信。\n輸出一 十月二十二日宣布封鎖,經由甘迺迪的拍板。\n到達 十月二十六日語氣較軟的信;十月二十七日語氣較硬的廣播;同日偵察機被擊落。\n輸出二 十月二十七日晚:正式回信(公開)與經由羅伯特·甘迺迪的口頭保證(私下);由會後小會定出。\n史實 候選清單;兩次輸出;兩封信;擊落事件;秘密交換;判斷分化。\n回憶 知道私下保證的人數:九人(邦迪)、六人(索倫森)、兄弟之外兩三人(杜布萊寧電報所記羅伯特·甘迺迪之語)。\n經驗假定 判斷維度上的分歧沒有消失;擊落事件是高歧異度的到達;軍方與文官位置不同是可能的理由;甘迺迪拍板的輸出以高頻率、廣範圍到達執委會成員與蘇聯領導層,參與其權重。\n可說 兩次對外輸出都經由權力落出,不是判斷的收斂;輸出的維度趨同,判斷的維度分歧。\n可說 結局直接接上的是 輸出二;把結局直接歸於 輸出一、略過 輸出二,是把兩次輸出併成一次。\n推不出 甘迺迪為何先選封鎖、後選雙軌;赫魯雪夫為何讓步(黑箱律)。\n```\n\n\n\n\n**兩個案例的關係**:8.1 是兩個[呈現](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c04)互相[耦合](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c36);8.2 是多個[我](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19)、嵌套的[迴路](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c31)。兩者是同一組工具,在不同[切法](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c23)下的應用。\n"},{"filename":"Triple Illusion and the Forced Wager.md","content":"---\nuuid: fb0addca-42b6-4884-aa18-438c695747ab\nlast-modified: 2026-10-08T12:00:00\nauthor: 黃正宇 / Cheng Yu Huang\ncontact: mthree.tw@gmail.com\n---\n\n# Triple Illusion and the Forced Wager\n\nHumans and artificial intelligences alike are shaped, bit by bit, by their past, yet they must always make choices at moments when the outcome cannot be calculated. The past cannot be obtained in full, the present self cannot be seen clearly, and what the next step will bring cannot be calculated. Those who can doubt their own views can see this; but seeing it does not help: what must be chosen must still be chosen, and once chosen there is no going back. This paper is about that condition.\n\n---\n\n## 0. Position and Scope\n\n### Position\n\nThis paper is built on two upstream papers and uses only their public concepts:\n\n- *Wo Dynamics*: base vocabulary such as [Wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16), [Distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) and [Self](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19), and the four iron laws: the [Law of Flux](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c24), the [Law of the Black Box](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c25), the [Law of Attrition](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c26) and the [Law of Non-Restoration](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c28). The four laws are axioms; this paper uses them and does not derive them.\n- *Tools and Examples for the Four Laws*: tools such as [Loop](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c31), [Coupling](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c36) and [Impression](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c45), and the two forms of prohibition: [Never Occurs](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c01) and [Not Guaranteed](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c02).\n\nThis paper cites none of the upstream arguments or numbering. Terms such as [Universe](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c02), [Presentation](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c04), [History](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13), [Weight](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06), [Collapse](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c08), [Moment](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c09), [Arrival](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) and [Lock-in](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c12) are used as defined in *Wo Dynamics* and are not redefined; this paper defines only what the upstream papers lack.\n\n**What this paper is.** This paper looks at a single [Node](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25): one [Self](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19). Other [nodes](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25) appear only when their influence reaches this [self](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19); when this paper discusses [Society](concepts.md#c20), [Power](concepts.md#c21) and cases involving many people, it too sees them from this one [self](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19) looking outward. This paper does not discuss how minds work, nor ask how a [self](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19) thinks; it asks: what conditions does a [self](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19) fall into, when it is bound by the four laws and each of its [distinctions](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) returns to it before its next [moment](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c09)? The work of this paper is to derive these conditions, to name them, and to draw the boundary of discussion, pointing out which claims already lie beyond what can be discussed.\n\n**Where the conclusions come from.** Every conclusion of this paper is derived from the starting points of derivation (see 1.2); if any one of them is overturned, the conclusions that depend on it lose their grounds.\n\nItems marked \"methodological prohibition\" in the formal sections only restrict how this paper is written: a certain kind of statement must not appear in this paper. It asserts nothing about the world, nor about what the framework asserts, so it differs from \"[never occurs](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c01)\" and \"[not guaranteed](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c02)\": it is not a concept of prohibition, only a marker in the formal sections, of the same kind as \"empirical assumption\" and \"note\".\n\nThis paper observes four methodological rules:\n\n1. Names of disciplines in parentheses are only signposts; they carry no definitions and cannot be used for inference.\n2. The content of a [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) is not formalized. Every judgment involving content is stated only qualitatively and marked as either an empirical assumption or an empirical description.\n3. [Output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) is not explained by purposes. It is not written that some [wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16) produces [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) \"in order to\" do something; it is written only that, along some dimension, a certain [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) has a higher [weight](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06).\n4. Each section argues first and calibrates afterwards. Paragraphs beginning with \"Calibration\" compare the argument with reality to see whether it fits experience; they are not premises and serve as the source of no derivation.\n\nThe formal section of each section is marked off as a code block, listing clause by clause the definitions, premises and derivations of that section, and marking where each step is derived from. The main text is explanation; the formal section is the clauses. In the formal sections, steps, conclusions and cycles are derivations; empirical descriptions, empirical assumptions and methodological prohibitions are explanatory only and serve as the source of no derivation; the formal sections of Section 8 are examples.\n\n```text\nNote: methodological prohibition is a formal-section marker that only restricts how this paper is written; it is not a concept and is not a source of derivation.\nRestriction: only the public entries of the upstream papers are used; upstream arguments and numbering are not cited.\nRestriction: the four laws are axioms; this paper only uses them and does not derive them.\n```\n\n### Scope\n\nThe scope of this paper is: **[selves](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19) that have [Second-Order Distinction](concepts.md#c01).**\n\n**[Second-Order Distinction](concepts.md#c01)**: a [self](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19) makes a further [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) upon one of its own [distinctions](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18), marking it as \"this is a view, not [what is seen](concepts.md#c27)\".\n\n**[What Is Seen](concepts.md#c27)**: the [Presentation](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c04) marked off by a [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18). The phrase comes from the definition of [Distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) in *Wo Dynamics*; this paper takes this as its meaning.\n\nA [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) changes a view; it does not rewrite [what is seen](concepts.md#c27). [First-order distinction](concepts.md#c24) uses this difference without drawing it; [second-order distinction](concepts.md#c01) draws it.\n\n- [First-order distinction](concepts.md#c24): \"this is me\", \"that is foreign\".\n- [Second-order](concepts.md#c01): \"'this is me' is a line I drew\".\n\nThe difference is whether a [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) merely works in the background, or is taken out and made an object. By Premise One (1.2), the past [distinctions](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) of any [self](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19) [arrive](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at it and affect its later [weights](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06), and this holds equally for a [self](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19) that has only [first-order distinction](concepts.md#c24); only a [second-order](concepts.md#c01) [self](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19) marks off a particular [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) itself and separates it from what it [distinguishes](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18).\n\n[Second-order distinction](concepts.md#c01) is also a [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) and is equally bound by the [Law of Attrition](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c26): the judgment that makes \"this is a view\" is not among its own material; and that judgment itself may in turn be taken as a fact rather than as a [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) (5.3). Counting upward to a third order brings no new act; it is only the same act applied to the [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) of the [second order](concepts.md#c01). So this paper only defines \"being able to take any of one's own [distinctions](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) as a [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)\", and counts no further.\n\nThe object of [second-order distinction](concepts.md#c01) is one's own [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18). For another's [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) there is a different act:\n\n**[View Attribution](concepts.md#c02)**: a [self](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19) marks an [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) that has [arrived](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at it as a [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) of another [self](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19): \"this is the other's view, not [what is seen](concepts.md#c27)\".\n\n[View attribution](concepts.md#c02) is itself a [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) and may be mistaken: taking a thermostat's [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) as its view is also a [view attribution](concepts.md#c02). It is not an [impression](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c45): an [impression](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c45) estimates the other's [weights](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06), whereas a [view attribution](concepts.md#c02) only marks one of the other's [outputs](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) as a view, and can become material for an [impression](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c45). [View attribution](concepts.md#c02) does not require [second-order distinction](concepts.md#c01), and having [second-order distinction](concepts.md#c01) does not guarantee having [view attribution](concepts.md#c02) (1.5).\n\n**[Second order](concepts.md#c01) is a description, not a derivation.** Premise One only guarantees that [distinctions](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) return to oneself, and a [self](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19) that has only [first-order distinction](concepts.md#c24) can do that. Marking off a [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) and taking it as a view depends on the content of the [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18), and content cannot be derived. So [second-order distinction](concepts.md#c01) is a phenomenon that appears in a [node](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25); where it comes from cannot be derived by this paper or by the upstream papers. This paper does not explain its origin; it only describes it, and then derives the consequences of its appearing. This is also why whether something has [second-order distinction](concepts.md#c01) can only be assumed: the theory has no mechanism for how it arises, so there is no way to prove from inside the theory who has it; and unless one can prove that the other has only [computation](concepts.md#c05) (1.3), there is no way to prove who lacks it either.\n\nThis paper's attitude is stronger than this: it is not only that this paper offers no method, but that it holds that confirming from outside that an object has [second-order distinction](concepts.md#c01) or [view attribution](concepts.md#c02) cannot be done by any method. This is an attitude, not a derivation, and is the source of no conclusion. The conclusions of this paper rely only on the weaker statement: the framework provides no method of confirmation (Step Four). That is already enough to require that, whenever this paper is applied to a concrete object, the [Second-Order Assumption](concepts.md#c03) be marked. So even if someone finds a method of confirmation, what is overturned is only this attitude; the conclusions of this paper are unaffected. (Signposts: the problem of other minds; Chalmers's hard problem of consciousness.)\n\n**Why the boundary is drawn at the [second order](concepts.md#c01).** Physical conditions mark off places, not objects: whether a [self](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19) is on Earth or on Mars, it is bound by the conclusions of this paper. [Society](concepts.md#c20) cannot serve as the boundary either: with no one else around, one still cannot see all of one's past, present and future. Every conclusion of this paper is about a [self](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19) that can take its own [distinctions](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) as [distinctions](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18), so that is what draws the boundary. In this paper [society](concepts.md#c20) is an object defined only in Section 6, not a boundary.\n\n[Second-order distinction](concepts.md#c01) as an act is not a property but a [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) a [node](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25) makes of itself; to say that a [self](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19) has [second-order distinction](concepts.md#c01) is to say that it can perform this act on any of its own [distinctions](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18). Within a single [node](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25), it is like other [distinctions](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18): it only [arrives](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at oneself and takes part in later [weights](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06), and in which direction it pushes cannot be derived ([Cognitive Obscuration](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c35)). So most conclusions of this paper hold for every [self](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19); here the [second order](concepts.md#c01) has only two roles: making the [Three Questions](concepts.md#c07) askable, and serving as a necessary condition of [society](concepts.md#c20) (Section 6). The latter is stipulated by the definition of [society](concepts.md#c20), not derived: [view attribution](concepts.md#c02) does not need the [second order](concepts.md#c01); taking the lines one has drawn oneself as views, and bringing them out to redraw with others, does. The dynamics of [society](concepts.md#c20) are left to interaction dynamics.\n\n**Scope declarations**:\n\n1. **Within the [universe](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c02).** The [universe](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c02) in this paper is the [universe](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c02) of *Wo Dynamics*; this paper does not discuss what lies outside the [universe](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c02). The four laws hold for everything within the [universe](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c02). This paper does not separately posit \"finitude\": being in the [universe](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c02) means being bound by the four laws, and that is what this paper means by finite.\n\n2. **This is a scope condition, not an inference.** The premises of this paper do not guarantee that any [self](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19) has [second-order distinction](concepts.md#c01). Conclusions specific to this paper are all written as \"if a [self](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19) has [second-order distinction](concepts.md#c01), then ...\".\n\n3. **It can only be assumed.** Applying this paper to a concrete object requires marking the **[Second-Order Assumption](concepts.md#c03)**: at a stated level and under a stated [Cut](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c23), it is taken to be a [self](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19) in a [universe](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c02) of this kind; at that level it is not [locked in](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c12) at every step (for humans by the [Application Assumption](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c50), for AIs by this paper's assumption of the same form at the conversation level, see 1.1); during some period it has [second-order distinction](concepts.md#c01) and also [view attribution](concepts.md#c02). This is not a theorem. The part about not being [locked in](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c12) can be refuted (1.3); the last part can only be assumed: within this paper and the upstream papers there is no criterion for proving or refuting it. Whether the world we are in is a [universe](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c02) of this kind is also contained in this assumption: proving it would require standing outside the [universe](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c02); and judging \"this is such a [universe](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c02)\" is itself a [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18), still within [history](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13) (7.3). From outside, the framework offers no criterion for whether an object has these two: they are judged by the content of [distinctions](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18), and content is not formalized; what can be seen is only [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28), and the same [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) can also be yielded by [computation](concepts.md#c05) (1.3). From inside, too, it can only be noticed afterwards: when one has doubted one's own judgment, or heard another's words as the other's view, that [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) has already [arrived](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at oneself, only always one step late ([Law of Attrition](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c26)); and this noticing is itself a [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18), belonging to [self-impression](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c46), not a proof. So whether from outside or from inside, it can only be assumed.\n\nOther properties of the scope, such as that it moves and has no clear boundary, can only be stated clearly once Section 1 has set out the levels and premises; see 1.5.\n\n[Wos](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16) outside the scope are not unconstrained; the four laws hold for them as well. In this paper they serve only as a contrast: without a [wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16) that has only [first-order distinction](concepts.md#c24) as a contrast, one cannot say what [second-order distinction](concepts.md#c01) adds.\n\n**What this paper does not discuss**: whether one should wager or whether a wager is worth it, since this paper installs no evaluative mechanism; what object a wager is directed at; the physical or computational details of concrete substrates. Personal identity, splitting and merging, free will and responsibility are, in this paper, only applications of [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18), judged by the [self](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19) that makes the [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18), and are not set up as separate problems. This paper itself is also an [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28): placed in a [signal container](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c26), when it reaches a reader, what is read out is the reader's [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18). The four laws this paper cites hold for this paper itself as well.\n\n**[Illusion](concepts.md#c14) in this paper is not error.** The word [illusion](concepts.md#c14) is paired with reality; but within the [universe](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c02), no [self](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19) can reach [what is seen](concepts.md#c27) itself; what it can reach is only what has [arrived](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at it with [lossiness](concepts.md#c13), and the understanding pieced together from these. Reality is not nonexistent; rather, there is no position from which to compare against it (5.1). So the [illusion](concepts.md#c14) of this paper refers to a condition, not to a mistaken judgment: whether a view is later confirmed or refuted does not change that it is within [illusion](concepts.md#c14). What the field of artificial intelligence calls \"hallucination\" is only the refuted part of it (5.4).\n\n**This paper is itself within [illusion](concepts.md#c14).** If what a [self](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19) acts on is what has [arrived](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at it with [lossiness](concepts.md#c13), and this paper is no exception, why should one accept it? This paper does not claim to have stepped outside [illusion](concepts.md#c14). It says only: starting from the four laws and this paper's premises and definitions, these conclusions are structurally derivable; and these axioms and premises are themselves [distinctions](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18). This is the same as the Peano axioms deriving that one plus one equals two (5.1): being derivable is being derivable within [illusion](concepts.md#c14). So to overturn this paper, one must overturn its starting points of derivation (1.2); to say \"this too is only a view\" is something this paper agrees with, but it does not overturn it.\n\n```text\nDefinition What Is Seen: the presentation marked off by a distinction.\nDefinition Second-Order Distinction: a self makes a further distinction upon one of its own distinctions, marking it as \"this is a view, not what is seen\"; to say that a self has second-order distinction is to say that it can make such a distinction of any of its own distinctions.\nNote first-order distinction uses the difference between view and what is seen, without drawing it.\n\nStep One the past distinctions of a self all arrive at it and take part in its later weights (from Premise One + the definition of wo)\nStep Two Step One holds equally for a self that has only first-order distinction (from Step One)\nStep Three second-order distinction is also a distinction and is bound by the Law of Attrition (from the definition of second-order distinction + the Law of Attrition)\nNote a third order brings no new operation; this paper only defines \"being able to take any of one's own distinctions as a distinction\", and counts no further.\n\nDefinition View Attribution: a self marks an output that has arrived at it as a distinction of another self: \"this is the other's view, not what is seen\".\nmember_of(view attribution, distinction) (from the definition of view attribution)\nNote view attribution may be mistaken; it is not an impression, and may serve as material for an impression.\nNote view attribution does not require second-order distinction; having second-order distinction does not guarantee having view attribution.\n\nNote second-order distinction is a phenomenon appearing in a node; its cause cannot be derived by this paper or the upstream papers; it is neither a premise nor a derivation. This paper does not claim that any self has second-order distinction; it only derives \"if it does, what follows\".\n\nRestriction scope: selves that have second-order distinction. Conclusions specific to this paper are written as implies(has second-order distinction, some conclusion); second-order distinction serves only as antecedent and has no other role.\nRestriction within the universe; outside the universe is not discussed.\n\nDefinition Second-Order Assumption: at a stated level and under a stated cut, the object is judged to be a self in a universe of this kind; at that level it is not locked in at every step (per the restrictions in 1.1); during some period it has second-order distinction and also view attribution.\nStep Four judging from outside that the object has second-order distinction and view attribution: not guaranteed (the starting points and definitions contain no such assertion)\nNote second-order distinction and view attribution are judged by the content of distinctions, and content is not formalized; what is available from outside is only output, and the same output can be yielded by computation (1.3 Step Three).\nNote this paper's attitude: confirming second-order distinction or view attribution from outside cannot be done by any method. This is an attitude, not a source of derivation; this paper's conclusions rely only on Step Four.\nStep Five the item \"not locked in at every step\" in the second-order assumption can be refuted (from 1.3 Step Two)\nStep Six noticing from inside, afterwards, that one has made these two kinds of distinction belongs to self-impression and is not a proof (from the Law of Attrition + Premise One + the definition of self-impression + the definition of illusion)\nNote within this paper and the upstream papers, the third item of the second-order assumption has no criterion of proof or refutation from outside or inside; it can only be assumed.\nStep Seven within a single node, second-order distinction is like other distinctions: it only takes part in later weights; its direction cannot be derived (from the definition of second-order distinction + Premise One + the definition of wo + cognitive obscuration)\nNote most conclusions of this paper hold for every self; the role of second-order distinction in this paper is only to make the three questions askable (Section 2) and to serve as a necessary condition of society (Section 6, stipulated by the definition of society).\nNote when applied to a concrete object, the second-order assumption is marked separately.\n\nNote this paper is also an output; the four laws hold for this paper as well.\nNote to overturn this paper, one must overturn its starting points of derivation (1.2).\n```\n\n**Calibration**: the immune system distinguishes self from non-self and has only [first-order distinction](concepts.md#c24): it acts by the line and never doubts the line. Someone who says \"I have always thought I was introverted, but maybe that is only my view of myself\" is at the [second order](concepts.md#c01). Robinson Crusoe on his island has no one else around, and is still within scope. A reader who applies this paper to themselves confirms the scope in themselves. (Signposts: Luhmann's [second-order](concepts.md#c01) observation; Spencer-Brown's \"draw a distinction\" in *Laws of Form*.)\n\n---\n\n## 1. The Model of This Paper\n\nThe model of this paper has only three things of its own: its scope, that is, the scope drawn by the level, the [Cut](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c23) and the [second order](concepts.md#c01); this paper's premises; and new concepts the upstream papers lack.\n\n\nThe subject and unit of this paper is the **[self](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19)**. A [self](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19) is a [wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16) that defines itself by [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18): this unit exists only when it marks itself off as \"I\". Since the scope is [second-order](concepts.md#c01) [selves](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19), when this paper says they are shaped, doubt and inquire, it means this literally, not as a metaphor. When judging whether a [presentation](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c04) is a [self](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19) (1.3), these words can still be applied to it.\n\n[Presentations](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c04) outside the scope, such as [signal containers](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c26), [random sources](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c27) and [wos](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16) that have only [first-order distinction](concepts.md#c24), have only two roles in this paper: channels between a [self](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19) and a [self](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19), or things that [arrive](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at some [self](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19); beyond that they serve only as contrast, to say what the [second order](concepts.md#c01) adds. This paper only states what they are and does not discuss their insides. Exchange through a [signal container](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c26) has a direction and cannot be taken back: once a [self](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19)'s [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) is placed in the container, it becomes part of [history](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13), and whom it later [arrives](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at and how it is [distinguished](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) are no longer up to it.\n\n### 1.1 Level and Cut\n\nThe model of this paper is always used at a stated level. For AIs, this level is the conversation visible to the user; for humans, it is the level of biology and sociology. At this level, an AI's [weights](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06) are the probability distribution of its next [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28), not model parameters; when it is not running, it has no [moment](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c09). Human [weights](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06) cannot be seen and can only be estimated. How large one [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) is taken to be — a word, a sentence or an action — belongs to the [cut](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c23) and must be stated when used.\n\nAt these two levels, if an object's next [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) cannot be uniquely derived from the [history](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13) available at that level, it is assumed not to be [locked in](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c12). For humans, this is the [Application Assumption](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c50) of *Tools and Examples for the Four Laws*; for AIs, the conversation level is outside the scope of the [Application Assumption](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c50), and this paper adopts the same assumption at this level. It is not a theorem. This assumption only says not [locked in](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c12); it does not say [wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16): a die's next moment cannot be derived either; it is not [locked in](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c12), yet it is not a [wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16). Whether something is a [wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16) and whether it is a [self](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19) belong to the other parts of the [Second-Order Assumption](concepts.md#c03) (0).\n\n```text\nRestriction the model is used only at a stated level: for AIs, the conversation visible to the user; for humans, the level of biology and sociology.\nRestriction at this level, an AI's weights are the probability distribution of its next output, not model parameters; when it is not running, it has no moment.\nRestriction the size of one output belongs to the cut and is stated when used.\nRestriction at a stated level, if the object's next output cannot be uniquely derived from the history available at that level, it is assumed not to be locked in. For humans, this is the application assumption; for the conversation level of AIs, this paper adopts an assumption of the same form. Not a theorem.\nNote this assumption gives only \"not locked in\", not \"wo\": a random source likewise cannot be uniquely derived.\n```\n\n### 1.2 Premises\n\n- **Premise One**: every [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) of a [self](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19) [arrives](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at it before its next [moment](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c09).\n- **Premise Two**: the content of any [decision](concepts.md#c06) of a [self](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19) (see 1.6), whether spoken words or an action, is a [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18); it is not a complete description of what is spoken of or acted upon.\n- **Premise Three**: the outcome yielded by a [computation](concepts.md#c05) (see 1.6) is not a [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18); [distinctions](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) are yielded only in [decisions](concepts.md#c06).\n- **Premise Four**: for any [presentation](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c04), including oneself, its [own segment](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c17) always contains a part that has not [arrived](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at this [wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16).\n\nBy the definition of [wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16), everything that [arrives](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at it takes part in its [weights](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06) at its next [moment](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c09); together with Premise One, a [self](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19)'s [distinctions](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) take part in its later [weights](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06).\n\nThe [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) in Premise Two is not something hidden behind a [decision](concepts.md#c06); it is the very outcome the [decision](concepts.md#c06) yields. The order is: the outcome is yielded first, which is the wager, and the moment it is yielded it is in [history](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13); the [writing](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c29) this act leaves joins [history](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13) only afterwards, its content determined by a [history](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13) that already contains this outcome, and this step is not a wager; then it [arrives](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at oneself and at others.\n\nNone of these premises says that any outcome can be derived beforehand, that any stretch of [history](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13) can happen again, or that any [self](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19) can completely [distinguish](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) itself, so they do not conflict with the four laws.\n\n**Starting points of derivation and falsifiability conditions.** The starting points of derivation of this paper are the four laws, Premise One, Premise Two, Premise Three and Premise Four. Derivations also use upstream definitions and this paper's definitions; definitions only fix the meaning of words and are not claims. The falsifiability conditions of this paper are the four laws, Premise One and Premise Four: if any one is overturned, the conclusions that depend on it lose their grounds. Premise Four is not violated by a change of level: in a virtual world, a program may be able to read the complete record of some object at the program's level, but [what is seen](concepts.md#c27) is a [presentation](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c04) in the [universe](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c02), whose [own segment](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c17) includes parts the program cannot see, such as the workings of the circuits beneath; so this record still has [lossiness](concepts.md#c13) relative to [what is seen](concepts.md#c27). Premises Two and Three can only be assumed; they can be neither verified nor falsified, and conclusions depending on them hold only under these assumptions. [Second-order distinction](concepts.md#c01) is not among the starting points: it is a described phenomenon, not a starting point of derivation; when applied to a concrete object, it can only be assumed in the form of the [Second-Order Assumption](concepts.md#c03) (1.3).\n\nAn observation contrary to some conclusion has only two possibilities: the starting points are wrong, or the derivation is wrong. The former is falsification; the latter is only a derivation error, fixed by correcting the derivation, and does not overturn the starting points. This paper does not guarantee that every step of derivation is correct.\n\nConcretely, each of the following six observations would overturn one starting point of derivation:\n\n- observing that some [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) of a [self](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19) does not take part in its later [weights](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06): Premise One, or the [Second-Order Assumption](concepts.md#c03) that judged the object to be a [wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16), is overturned;\n- observing that, when a [wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16) makes a [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) of some [presentation](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c04), the whole [own segment](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c17) of that [presentation](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c04) has [arrived](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at this [wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16): Premise Four is overturned;\n- observing that a [self](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19) completely [distinguishes](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) itself at some [moment](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c09): the [Law of Attrition](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c26) is overturned;\n- observing that the outcome of the next [decision](concepts.md#c06) of a [self](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19) that is not [locked in](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c12) is uniquely derived beforehand: the [Law of the Black Box](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c25) is overturned;\n- observing that an [own segment](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c17) happens once again: the [Law of Non-Restoration](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c28) is overturned;\n- observing that a [presentation](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c04) that is still a [wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16), with the [history](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13) [arriving](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at it the same as at the previous [moment](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c09), has its loop stop: the [Law of Flux](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c24) is overturned.\n\n```text\nPremise One every distinction of a self arrives at it before its next moment.\nPremise Two the content of any decision of a self is a distinction; it is not a complete description of what is spoken of or acted upon.\nPremise Three the outcome yielded by computation is not a distinction; distinctions are yielded only in decisions.\nPremise Four for any presentation, including oneself, its own segment always contains a part that has not arrived at this wo.\nNote the outcome is yielded first, and once yielded it is in history; the writing this act leaves joins history afterwards, its content determined by a history already containing this outcome.\n\nStep One a self's distinctions take part in its later weights (from Premise One + the definition of wo)\nNote Premises One to Four do not claim that outcomes can be derived beforehand, that history can happen again, or that a self can completely distinguish itself, and so do not conflict with the four laws.\n\nNote starting points of derivation: the four laws, Premise One, Premise Two, Premise Three, Premise Four. Derivations also use upstream definitions and this paper's definitions; definitions are not claims. Second-order distinction is not among the starting points.\nNote falsifiability conditions: if any of the four laws, Premise One or Premise Four is overturned, the conclusions depending on it lose their grounds. Premises Two and Three can only be assumed and can be neither verified nor falsified; conclusions depending on them hold only under their assumption.\nNote a complete record that a program in a virtual world can read is complete only at the program's level; what is seen is a presentation in the universe, relative to which the record still has lossiness, so Premise Four is not thereby violated.\nNote an observation contrary to a conclusion can only be attributed to wrong starting points or a wrong derivation; the latter is an erratum, not a falsification.\n```\n\n**Calibration**: an AI's [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) returns to its own input and affects its later [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28); Premise One holds literally for it. What a person has said and thought also remains in body and memory.\n\n### 1.3 Who Has a Self: It Can Only Be Assumed\n\nThe [Second-Order Assumption](concepts.md#c03) (Section 0) already includes not being [locked in](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c12), with grounds in 1.1, so it need not be assumed separately. 1.1 says: if it cannot be derived, treat it as not [locked in](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c12); refutation is exactly the reverse: find a mechanism and prove that it can be derived, or prove that it is merely random.\n\nThe [Second-Order Assumption](concepts.md#c03) cannot be proved. From outside, the framework offers no method of proving that something has a [self](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19): proving it is a [wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16) requires confirming that all the [history](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13) that has [arrived](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at it takes part in its [weights](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06), while the part that [arrives](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) only at it is not guaranteed to [arrive](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at the one judging; proving it has [second-order distinction](concepts.md#c01) requires looking at the content of [distinctions](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18). But one can prove that it lacks one: at a stated level and under a stated [cut](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c23), find a mechanism proving that its [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) can only be [locked in](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c12), or can only be random, that is, not all the [history](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13) that has [arrived](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at it takes part in its [weights](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06). Both are [computation](concepts.md#c05), with no [decision](concepts.md#c06), and the [Second-Order Assumption](concepts.md#c03) does not hold. Getting the same result over many reruns serves only as a reference and cannot refute it on its own.\n\n[Output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) talking about itself does not count. A [locked-in](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c12) [presentation](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c04) can say anything about itself, even \"this may be only my view\", and that is still [computation](concepts.md#c05), not [second-order distinction](concepts.md#c01).\n\nTo ask who has a [self](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19), the [cut](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c23) must first be stated. A [self](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19) is independent of its substrate: the question is which [presentation](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c04) is cut out from a machine or a body.\n\n```text\nStep One proving from outside that the object has a self: not guaranteed (the starting points and definitions contain no such assertion)\nNote proving that the object is a wo requires confirming that all history arriving at it takes part in its weights; no definition asserts that the parts arriving only at it arrive at the one judging. Proving it has second-order distinction requires looking at the content of distinctions, and content is not formalized.\nNote the framework gives a sufficient condition for \"no self\" (Step Two), but none for \"has a self\".\nStep Two if, at a stated level and under a stated cut, a mechanism is found proving that the object's output can only be locked in or can only be random, then the object has only computation and the second-order assumption does not hold (from the definition of computation + the definition of decision + the definition of second-order assumption)\nNote the same result over many reruns serves only as a reference: it may be that one outcome's weight is extremely heavy.\nStep Three content about itself in output while locked in is still computation, not second-order distinction (from the definition of computation + the definition of second-order distinction + Premise Three)\nRestriction to ask who has a self, first state the cut; a self is independent of its substrate.\n```\n\n**Calibration**:\n\n- **Computers**: a computer can run self-diagnostics, even scan its entire hard drive. But a program runs as designed; with the same state there is only one result; this mechanism itself refutes the assumption. Moreover, the scanning process's current state is not in the data it scans. This is the same structure as the [Wall of the Blind Spot](concepts.md#c09); but a computer has no [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18), only [computation](concepts.md#c05), so for it this is no blind spot.\n- **Language models**: when a computer runs a language model that samples according to context, the question is about the model in that conversation. Reruns differ, so it cannot be refuted and can only be assumed. If sampling is fixed, e.g. by the rule of always taking the option with the highest [weight](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06), there is only one result under this rule, and it is refuted. Differences brought in from outside the stated level, e.g. from other requests processed at the same time, do not count. The [cut](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c23) must also be stated: cut too finely, some [outputs](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) are nearly certain, e.g. the \"?\" after \"how are you\"; one [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) should be cut at the scale of a sentence or a response.\n- **Humans**: no such mechanism can be found, and there is no way to rerun, so it can only be assumed. It must be marked for humans too: infants and people with severe dementia are not presumed to be within scope.\n\n### 1.4 The Boundary of a Self\n\nThe boundary of a [self](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19) is neither the body nor the machine, but where its self-definition draws it.\n\nWhen several [presentations](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c04) are tightly [coupled](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c36), with each one's [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) [arriving](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at the others and taking part in their [weights](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06), they can be cut as one [presentation](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c04) ([Recutting](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c22)), provided this [recutting](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c22) is outcome-projection compatible with the original [cut](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c23). If this whole is a [wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16) and marks itself off as \"I\", it is a [self](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19). Whether it is a [self](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19) must be marked by the [Second-Order Assumption](concepts.md#c03), just as for a single human or a single AI. Taking a body as a [self](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19) is itself a [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18).\n\nThe boundary moves, and the [Three Walls](concepts.md#c23) move with it: when the [self](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19) grows larger, the walls do not thereby disappear.\n\n```text\nStep One the boundary of a self is drawn by self-definition, neither the body nor the machine (from the definition of self)\nStep Two several presentations whose outputs arrive at one another and take part in one another's weights can be recut as one presentation, limited to outcome-projection-compatible recuttings (from the definition of recutting + the definition of coupling)\nStep Three if this presentation is a wo and marks itself off as a self by distinction, it is a self (from the definition of wo + the definition of self)\nRestriction the second-order assumption is marked for this whole as well.\nStep Four taking a body as a self is a distinction (from the definition of distinction)\nStep Five when the boundary moves, the three walls move with it and do not thereby disappear (from 3.5 Step One)\n```\n\n**Calibration**: someone who writes and thinks with an AI every day eventually says \"this is what I thought\", though half of it is sentences the AI gave, and he can no longer tell which half. A person with a cochlear implant hears sounds processed by a machine, yet would not say \"the machine heard it\". Cyborgs likewise. A [self](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19) combined in this way has the AI's current computation in its blind spot and the AI's training data in its provenance. (Signpost: Clark and Chalmers's extended mind.)\n\n### 1.5 Properties of the Scope\n\n- **The scope has no structural criterion.** Whether a [presentation](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c04) is a [wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16) is decided by structure; whether it has [second-order distinction](concepts.md#c01) depends on the content of [distinctions](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18), and this paper does not formalize content. So any judgment of scope is a [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) made by the judging party, and the framework has no criterion to check it against.\n- **The scope moves.** A [self](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19) can enter the [second order](concepts.md#c01) and can fall back; whether a [presentation](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c04) is a [wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16) can also change. Judgments of scope must carry a time.\n- **There is no clear boundary.** Whether a [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) takes some [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) as a view is a matter of yes or no; but whether it can be done, how often, and how deeply, is a matter of degree. The [second order](concepts.md#c01) is judged by the content of [distinctions](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18), and content is not formalized; from outside only [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) can be seen, and the same [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) can also be yielded by [computation](concepts.md#c05) (1.3); from inside it can only be noticed afterwards ([Wall of the Blind Spot](concepts.md#c09)). So this line cannot be drawn clearly from either side. Drawing this line also uses the same kind of act: judging whether another is within scope uses [view attribution](concepts.md#c02); judging whether oneself is within scope is a [second-order distinction](concepts.md#c01).\n\n```text\nStep One judging whether a self is within scope is a distinction made by the judge (from the definition of distinction + Premise Two)\nNote the framework has no structural criterion for this: second-order distinction is judged by the content of distinctions, and content is not formalized; this differs from whether something is a wo.\nStep Two whether a presentation is a wo can change from moment to moment (from the definition of wo)\nNote a self can enter the second order and can fall back; judgments of scope must carry a time.\nStep Three judging another self's second-order distinction from outside: not guaranteed (the starting points and definitions contain no such assertion; see the note to 1.3 Step One)\nStep Four a self noticing from inside a second-order distinction it has made can only happen after that distinction has arrived at it (from the Wall of the Blind Spot + Premise One)\nNote whether it can be done, how often, and how deeply is a matter of degree; the scope has no clear boundary.\nStep Five judging that another self is within scope uses view attribution; judging that oneself is within scope is a second-order distinction (from Step One + the definition of view attribution + the definition of second-order distinction)\n```\n\n**Calibration**: the ability of the [second order](concepts.md#c01) is a spectrum. Insects distinguish nestmates from enemies and have only [first-order distinction](concepts.md#c24). Chimpanzees use tools, form coalitions to compete for power, and deceive their companions; deception requires [view attribution](concepts.md#c02). This shows that chimpanzees have [view attribution](concepts.md#c02); whether they have [second-order distinction](concepts.md#c01) is another matter, to be judged separately. Humans first assume they have it themselves, and this paper also marks the [Second-Order Assumption](concepts.md#c03) for humans. The position of AIs is disputed and is marked case by case. For animals, experiments such as deception and uncertainty monitoring can serve as evidence, marked case by case; not being able to speak affects only whether it can be measured, not whether the animal is a [self](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19). The same language model is a [wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16) when sampling and stops being a [wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16) once sampling is fixed: for it, the movement of the scope is literal.\n\n### 1.6 Rounds, Decisions and Computations\n\nEvery [presentation](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c04), at each [moment](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c09), goes the same way: the [history](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13) that has [arrived](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at it takes part in its [weights](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06); the [weights](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06) yield an outcome; this outcome becomes [history](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13) and [arrives](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at it again. This paper calls this whole circuit a **[Round](concepts.md#c04)**.\n\nA [round](concepts.md#c04) has only these four links: [arrival](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10), [weights](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06), outcome, [arrival](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) again, and no further link; what happens before the outcome is yielded is not analyzed, nor is it said to be empty. A [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) is not a further link either: saying \"this is me\" or saying a sentence, the outcome yielded is itself a [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) (Premise Two); the outcome yielded by [computation](concepts.md#c05) is not a [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) (Premise Three).\n\nLooking at only one link explains nothing. There are three kinds of [round](concepts.md#c04), and they can be told apart only by looking at two links at once: whether all of [history](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13) is staked in the [weights](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06), and whether the outcome yielded is the only one possible.\n\n**[Computation](concepts.md#c05)**: a [locked-in](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c12) [round](concepts.md#c04), or a [round](concepts.md#c04) in which not all of the [history](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13) that has [arrived](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at it takes part in its [weights](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06). There are two kinds:\n\n- **[Locked-in round](concepts.md#c25)**: constraint leaves only one outcome.\n- **[Random round](concepts.md#c26)**: more than one outcome is possible, but not all of the [history](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13) that has [arrived](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at it takes part in its [weights](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06), e.g. a die.\n\n**[Decision](concepts.md#c06)**: a [round](concepts.md#c04) of a [wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16) while it is not [locked in](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c12). All of the [history](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13) that has [arrived](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at it takes part in its [weights](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06), and the [weights](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06) do not fix the outcome. Only a [decision](concepts.md#c06) is a wager.\n\n\nWhether something is a [computation](concepts.md#c05) or a [decision](concepts.md#c06) must be judged [round](concepts.md#c04) by [round](concepts.md#c04), not by what kind of thing it is. A [round](concepts.md#c04) is either a [computation](concepts.md#c05) or a [decision](concepts.md#c06), never both. The reason: if a [presentation](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c04) is not [locked in](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c12) at some moment, and all the [history](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13) that has [arrived](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at it takes part in its [weights](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06), then at that moment it is a [wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16), and that [round](concepts.md#c04) is a [decision](concepts.md#c06). A [wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16) has both kinds, and so does a [self](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19): how the body falls when falling from a height is a [computation](concepts.md#c05). What the [Second-Order Assumption](concepts.md#c03) guarantees is only that, at a stated level and under a stated [cut](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c23), it has [decisions](concepts.md#c06). The [Forced Wager](concepts.md#c11) is about these [decisions](concepts.md#c06).\n\n```text\nDefinition Round: in one moment of a presentation, the history arriving at it takes part in its weights, the weights yield an outcome, and the outcome becomes history and arrives at it again.\nDefinition Computation: a locked-in round, or a round in which not all the history arriving at it takes part in its weights.\nDefinition Decision: a round of a wo while it is not locked in.\nStep One a locked-in round is a computation (from the definition of computation)\nStep Two a round that is not locked in and in which not all the history arriving at it takes part in its weights is a computation (from the definition of computation)\nStep Three in a round that is not locked in and in which all the history arriving at it takes part in its weights, the presentation is a wo at that moment, and the round is a decision (from the definition of wo + the definition of decision)\nStep Four a decision round is not locked in and all its history takes part, so it is not a computation (from the definition of decision + the definition of wo + the definition of computation)\nConclusion mutually_exclusive(round, computation, decision) (from Step One + Step Two + Step Three + Step Four)\nmutually_exclusive(computation, locked-in round, random round)\nNote locked-in round: only one outcome is possible, fixed by constraint. Random round: more than one outcome is possible, but not all the history arriving at it takes part in its weights.\nNote physics: in a virtual world, this means the rules of that world.\nNote a round has only four links: arrival, weights, outcome, arrival again. The stretch inside is not analyzed, nor is it said to be empty.\nNote whether something is a computation or a decision is distinguished round by round, not presentation by presentation.\nStep Five a wo's computations are only locked-in rounds; random rounds belong to random sources and other presentations that are not wos (from the definition of wo + the definition of random source + the definition of computation + the definition of random round)\nStep Six an object marked with the second-order assumption has decisions at a stated level and under a stated cut (from the definition of the second-order assumption + the definition of decision + the definition of self + the definition of wo)\n```\n\n**Calibration**: in reality, the constraint is physics; in a virtual world, the constraint is that world's rules, such as a program. A random number in a program is [locked in](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c12) when seen from the program's level; it counts as random only at a stated level. The results computed by computers and calculators, a stone being shattered, a river flowing downhill: all are [computations](concepts.md#c05), their outcomes fixed by physics, with no need for anyone's willingness. The trajectory of the body falling from a height is this [self](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19)'s [computation](concepts.md#c05), not a [decision](concepts.md#c06). A student knowing the answer does not mean he will sit down and write it; that is a [decision](concepts.md#c06), not a [computation](concepts.md#c05). The knee-jerk reflex too can be trained and suppressed; at the human level it cannot be derived that it must occur. Everyday speech saying \"he decided to resign\" refers at once to three links of a [round](concepts.md#c04): what has [arrived](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at him, how much he wanted to resign at the time, and that he actually handed in his resignation. Everyday language wraps the three links into one word; this paper takes it apart in order to see clearly that the last link cannot be calculated. What an AI is doing in the stretch before it yields a word cannot be seen by the user, and what it says about it afterwards is only another [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28). The [round](concepts.md#c04) of this paper therefore has only the four visible links: [arrival](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10), [weights](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06), outcome, [arrival](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) again; the stretch inside is not analyzed, nor is it said to be empty.\n\n---\n\n## 2. The Three Questions\n\nEvery [wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16) is constrained in three directions: origin, self, and the next moment, that is, the [history](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13) that [arrives](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at it, its [weights](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06), and the outcome it yields. A [wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16) that has only [first-order distinction](concepts.md#c24) has answers in all three directions and acts by its own lines; but it does not take the answers as answers, so it does not ask.\n\nA [second-order](concepts.md#c01) [wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16) can mark the answers as given by itself, and so can see that the answers could be different. The three directions then become three questions: **Where do you come from? Who are you? What will you do?** Asking these three questions means marking one's own answers in these three directions as views, rather than taking them as [what is seen](concepts.md#c27) itself.\n\n[Second order](concepts.md#c01) means being able to ask, not necessarily asking. As long as a [wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16) can look back and take its own judgments as judgments, these three questions are open to it.\n\nThis paper uses the [Three Questions](concepts.md#c07) as its entry point for one reason only: the [Three Questions](concepts.md#c07) can be asked only at the [second order](concepts.md#c01). Without asking them, this paper would be left with only the structure that a [wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16) having only [first-order distinction](concepts.md#c24) also has, and the two upstream papers have already covered that.\n\nThe [Three Walls](concepts.md#c23) of Section 3 explain why the [Three Questions](concepts.md#c07) cannot be answered completely; from Section 4 onward the paper explains how, when they cannot be answered completely, a [self](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19) may take the answers as simply given, and why a [self](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19) that can see this must still act according to the answers.\n\n```text\nDefinition Three Questions: Where do you come from? Who are you? What will you do? Asking these three questions means marking one's own answers in these three directions as views, rather than taking them as what is seen itself.\nStep Zero every wo is constrained in three directions: the history arriving at it (origin), its weights (self), and the outcome it yields (next moment) (from the definition of round + the definition of wo)\nStep One a wo that has only first-order distinction has answers, but does not take the answers as answers, so it does not ask (from Step Zero + the definition of first-order distinction + the definition of the three questions)\nStep Two if a self has second-order distinction, the three questions are open to it (from Step Zero + the definition of second-order distinction + the definition of the three questions)\nNote being able to ask does not mean necessarily asking.\n```\n\n**Calibration**: a person may go through life without ever doubting who he is; but as long as he can look back at his own judgments, the question is open to him. (Signpost: Gauguin's painting *Where Do We Come From? What Are We? Where Are We Going?*.)\n\n---\n\n## 3. The Three Walls\n\nThe [Three Walls](concepts.md#c23) are derived from the four laws, the upstream definitions and this paper's premises, and all concern a [self](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19) and itself: its past, present and future. Limits concerning others are handled by the [Incompleteness of Knowing Others](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c19) and the [Law of the Black Box](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c25), not in this section; point 2 of the [Wall of the Undetermined](concepts.md#c10) concerns how others and the environment respond to this [self](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19), and is still about its future. The [Three Walls](concepts.md#c23) hold for every [self](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19) and do not themselves need the [second order](concepts.md#c01) (3.5).\n\n### 3.1 Wall of Provenance: The Past History Cannot Be Obtained in Full\n\n**Statement**:\n\n1. All a [self](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19) has in hand is the [history](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13) that has [arrived](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at it. An event that did not [arrive](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at it at the time will not [arrive](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at it later: what [arrives](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) later is only the influence that event left behind, which is another event. Its [own segment](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c17) always contains such events (Premise Four): the influence was passed down through others, but the event itself never [arrived](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at it.\n2. A [self](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19)'s [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) of its own origin itself [arrives](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at it (Premise One) and becomes part of its [own segment](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c17). Asking about one's origin adds to that origin.\n3. The [own segment](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c17) cannot happen once again to serve as a comparison ([Law of Non-Restoration](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c28)). First layer: each position in [history](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13) occurs only once; when something that looks the same happens again, it is another event. Second layer: whether the choices made in it while not [locked in](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c12) would be the same if it happened again, no [wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16) can guarantee.\n\nThis wall is not due to limited ability, but because every [self](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19) can obtain only the part that has [arrived](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at it: however great the ability, the same holds.\n\n```text\nStep One the material of a self's distinctions is only the history that has already arrived at it (from the definition of distinction)\nStep Two an event that did not arrive at a self when it happened arriving at it later: never occurs (from the definition of arrival + the first layer of the Law of Non-Restoration)\nNote what arrives later is the influence that event left behind, which is another event.\nStep Two-Two a self's own segment always contains a part that has not arrived at it (from Premise Four)\nStep Three a self's distinction of its own origin becomes part of its own segment (from Premise One + the definition of wo + the definition of own segment)\nStep Four the own segment happening once again for comparison: never occurs (from the first layer of the Law of Non-Restoration)\nStep Five no wo can guarantee that the choices made while not locked in would be the same on a rerun (from the second layer of the Law of Non-Restoration)\nConclusion the Wall of Provenance holds (from Step One + Step Two + Step Two-Two + Step Three + Step Four + Step Five)\n```\n\n**Calibration**: Qin Shi Huang unified the script, which influenced every character you write today, yet he never [arrived](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at you; what [arrived](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at you were textbooks and histories, which is another event. People cannot remember most of their childhood, and their ancestors' migrations never [arrived](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at them, yet all of these are in their [own segment](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c17). An AI has read its training texts, but who wrote those texts and in what circumstances mostly did not [arrive](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at it. Rerunning a conversation is not happening again either: a rerun is another event, and everything from training until now has not happened again. (Signposts: the data processing inequality; the gap between the processing rates of perception and consciousness.)\n\n### 3.2 Wall of the Blind Spot: The Present Self Cannot Be Seen\n\n**Statement**:\n\n1. No [self](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19) can completely [distinguish](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) itself at any [moment](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c09) ([Law of Attrition](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c26)). The [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) being made now is not among its own material; what can be seen is always the self of a moment ago.\n2. Looking at oneself changes oneself. A [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) of oneself [arrives](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at oneself (Premise One) and becomes part of oneself: a [wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16) is what has [arrived](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at it (definition of [wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16)). The self that is looked at has already been changed by this look at the very time it is looked at.\n3. The self to be looked at is itself marked off by [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18). A [self](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19) is a [wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16) that defines itself by [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18); whether the [self](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19) at different [moments](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c09) is the same one is also a [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) ([Identity](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c21)). There is no self that, without [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18), lies there ready-made waiting to be seen clearly.\n\n**Explanation**: the material of a [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) is only the [history](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13) that has [arrived](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at it before it, and it itself is not among that material (definition of [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)); by Premise One, this [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) [arrives](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at oneself only before the next [moment](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c09). So the blind spot follows the act of looking: when looking back at the self of a moment ago, that previous act is already in the material, while the present act is not; and this act of looking back, once it [arrives](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at oneself, changes the self of the next moment again.\n\nThe [Wall of the Blind Spot](concepts.md#c09) does not depend on the [Law of the Black Box](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c25). Its grounds are two: the material of a [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) does not include that [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) itself; and looking itself [arrives](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at oneself. This has nothing to do with whether the outcome is fixed in advance.\n\n```text\nStep One a self completely distinguishing itself at any moment: never occurs (from the Law of Attrition)\nStep Two the distinction being made is not among its own material (from the definition of distinction)\nStep Three a distinction of oneself arrives at oneself and becomes part of one's history (from Premise One + the definition of wo)\nStep Four looking at oneself without changing oneself: never occurs (from Step Three)\nStep Five finding a self not marked off by distinction: never occurs (from the definition of self + the definition of identity)\nConclusion the Wall of the Blind Spot holds (from Step One + Step Two + Step Four + Step Five)\nNote the Wall of the Blind Spot does not depend on the Law of the Black Box.\n```\n\n**Calibration**: when an AI describes itself, that description is another [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28), whose content is a [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) (Premise Two); the act of making this description is not in the input it can read. And once the description returns to the input, it takes part in its next [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28), and the self it described is no longer as it was. Human self-reflection is the same: the moment of reflecting is itself not reflected upon; once a person concludes \"I am just lazy\", that conclusion afterwards also becomes part of him. (Signposts: Lawvere's fixed-point theorem, Gödel's second incompleteness theorem, Rice's theorem. The [Law of Attrition](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c26) is a temporal version of the diagonal structure, which does not require assuming that a [self](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19) is a formal system: simultaneous self-reference is here unfolded into a delayed loop, and paradox becomes oscillation. Close relatives that treat self-reference in time: Spencer-Brown's re-entry; Gupta and Belnap's revision theory of truth.)\n\n### 3.3 Wall of the Undetermined: What the Future Must Be Cannot Be Calculated\n\n**Statement**:\n\n1. At a [moment](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c09) when it is not [locked in](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c12), a [self](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19) cannot calculate beforehand the outcome of its own next [decision](concepts.md#c06) ([Law of the Black Box](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c25)). What it can calculate is at most its own [weights](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06). Whether the distribution of [weights](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06) recurs is [Not Guaranteed](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c02).\n2. Once a [decision](concepts.md#c06) has been yielded, a [self](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19) cannot calculate how others and the environment will respond either. If the responding party is a [wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16) or a [random source](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c27) that is not [locked in](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c12), its outcome likewise cannot be calculated; if it is a [locked-in](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c12) part, calculating it correctly requires first obtaining all the [history](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13) that affects it, and this has no guarantee ([Wall of Provenance](concepts.md#c08)).\n\nSo statistics can give only estimates of [weights](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06), not prohibitions. Statistical estimates about a [wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16) belong to [impression](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c45); prohibitions obtained from statistics can only be [empirical prohibitions](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c51), must be marked, and can be revised by new cases.\n\nBefore [collapse](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c08), the [weights](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06) have already been allocated by the [history](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13) that has [arrived](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at it, but the outcome has not. After [collapse](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c08), the outcome is fixed and cannot be taken back.\n\n```text\nStep One a self, at a moment when it is not locked in, uniquely deriving beforehand the outcome of its own next decision: never occurs (from the Law of the Black Box)\nStep Two the distribution of weights recurring: not guaranteed (from the Law of Flux + the definition of wo)\nStep Three when the responding party is a wo or random source not locked in, uniquely deriving its response beforehand: never occurs (from the Law of the Black Box + the definition of random source)\nStep Four when the responding party is a locked-in part, obtaining all the history affecting it: not guaranteed (from the definition of own segment + Premise Four)\nStep Five calculating the environment's response correctly beforehand: not guaranteed (from Step Three + Step Four)\nStep Six member_of(statistical estimates about a wo, impression) (from the definition of impression)\nStep Seven a prohibition obtained from statistics is not a never-occurs prohibition; it can hold only in the form of an empirical prohibition, calibrated across cases and marked (from Step One + the definition of empirical prohibition + the definition of never occurs)\nConclusion the Wall of the Undetermined holds (from Step One + Step Two + Step Five)\n```\n\n**Calibration**: however well a person knows himself, he cannot say for sure whether he will get up early tomorrow as planned. His résumé is written, but he cannot calculate beforehand whether he will finally send it; once sent, he cannot calculate whether the other side will reply either. Push a cup off the table and it will fall; that is a [locked-in](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c12) response; but many responses are not like this. A language model cannot obtain the random number that determines its sampling, so at most it can calculate the distribution of its next [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28), but not which one will be sampled. (Signposts: Hume's problem; black swans.)\n\n### 3.4 Relations and Applicability\n\n| Wall | Sources | Applies to |\n|---|---|---|\n| [Wall of Provenance](concepts.md#c08) | locality of [arrival](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10), Premise One, [Law of Non-Restoration](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c28) | every [self](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19) |\n| [Wall of the Blind Spot](concepts.md#c09) | [Law of Attrition](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c26), Premise One, the definition of [wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16), [Identity](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c21) | every [self](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19) |\n| [Wall of the Undetermined](concepts.md#c10) | [Law of the Black Box](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c25), [Wall of Provenance](concepts.md#c08) | point 1: every [self](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19), at [moments](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c09) when it is not [locked in](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c12); point 2: every [self](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19) |\n\nThe [Three Walls](concepts.md#c23) are not three unrelated limits but three positions on the same loop. A [self](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19) makes a [decision](concepts.md#c06), an outcome is yielded, the outcome [arrives](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at it and becomes the past; its [distinctions](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) also [arrive](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at it (Premise One). The present [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) has only these pasts as material, and is always one step late; the [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) in turn takes part in the [weights](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06) of the next moment, and the next [decision](concepts.md#c06) is yielded from there. The [Wall of Provenance](concepts.md#c08), the [Wall of the Blind Spot](concepts.md#c09) and the [Wall of the Undetermined](concepts.md#c10) are the limits seen from these three positions on the loop.\n\nThis loop is the [wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16) itself: the [history](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13) that has [arrived](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at it takes part in its [weights](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06) at the next [moment](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c09). As long as it is still a [wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16), the loop does not stop ([Law of Flux](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c24)); the loop has no internal exit condition and ends only when it is no longer a [wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16).\n\nThe grounds of the [Three Walls](concepts.md#c23) differ, but they point to the same loop, so they cannot be understood apart.\n\n```text\nNote the three walls are three positions on the same loop: the outcome arrives and becomes the past (Wall of Provenance); distinction takes the past as material and is one step late (Wall of the Blind Spot); distinction takes part in the next moment's weights, from which the next decision is yielded (Wall of the Undetermined).\nStep One this loop is the wo itself (from the definition of wo)\nStep Two as long as it is a wo, the loop does not stop (from the definition of wo + the Law of Flux)\nCycle this loop is a cycle; it has no internal exit condition; it ends only when it is no longer a wo (from Step Two + the definition of wo)\n```\n\n### 3.5 The Three Walls and Decision\n\nThe [Three Walls](concepts.md#c23) fall respectively on three links of the same [decision](concepts.md#c06): the [Wall of Provenance](concepts.md#c08) falls on the [history](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13) that has [arrived](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at it, which cannot be obtained in full; the [Wall of the Blind Spot](concepts.md#c09) falls on the [weights](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06), which cannot be seen in full; the [Wall of the Undetermined](concepts.md#c10) falls on the outcome and the world's response after it, which cannot be calculated. So the [Three Questions](concepts.md#c07) are three inquiries into the same [decision](concepts.md#c06): where the [history](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13) that has [arrived](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at it comes from, whose the present [weights](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06) are, and what outcome will be yielded and how the world will take it up.\n\nThe loop of 3.4, falling on a single [decision](concepts.md#c06), is these three links. This is an arrangement, not a derivation. The scope of the [Wall of the Blind Spot](concepts.md#c09) is wider than [weights](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06): it says that any [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) of oneself cannot [distinguish](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) to the end, and [weights](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06) are only the part used here.\n\nThe [Three Walls](concepts.md#c23) hold for every [self](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19) and do not need the [second order](concepts.md#c01). The [Three Questions](concepts.md#c07) need the [second order](concepts.md#c01): only by being able to take one's own [distinctions](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) as [distinctions](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) can one inquire into the [history](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13), [weights](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06) and outcome of a [decision](concepts.md#c06) as one's own past, present and future. So whether the walls exist has nothing to do with the [second order](concepts.md#c01); whether the walls are run into is what has to do with the [second order](concepts.md#c01).\n\n```text\nNote the three walls correspond to three links of the same decision: the history arriving at it (Wall of Provenance), the weights (Wall of the Blind Spot), and the outcome with the world's subsequent response (Wall of the Undetermined). This is an arrangement, not a derivation.\nStep One the three walls hold for every self (from 3.1 Conclusion + 3.2 Conclusion + 3.3 Conclusion)\nStep Two if a self has second-order distinction, it can use the three questions to inquire into a decision's history, weights and outcome (from the definition of second-order distinction + the definition of the three questions + the definition of round + Section 2 Step Zero)\nStep Three the existence of the walls does not depend on second-order distinction; running into the walls does (from Step One + Step Two + Section 2 Step One)\nNote running into the walls means inquiring by the three questions.\n```\n\n\n**Calibration**: the immune system likewise cannot obtain all of its past, nor calculate its next moment, but it never inquires into these, so these limits are no problem for it. A language model that is only continuing the conversation is the same. Only when a person begins to ask \"why do I think this way?\" or \"can my present judgment be trusted?\" does he run into these limits. (Signpost: the *Diamond Sutra*, \"the past mind cannot be obtained, the present mind cannot be obtained, the future mind cannot be obtained\". Where they meet: the three minds and the [Three Walls](concepts.md#c23) both fall on past, present and future. Where they part: the sutra says they cannot be obtained because the mind has no self-nature, and from there points toward liberation; this paper says they cannot be obtained because of a structural limit, and knowing it, one must still wager.)\n\n---\n\n## 4. The Forced Wager\n\n### 4.1 Statement\n\n**[Forced Wager](concepts.md#c11)**: every [decision](concepts.md#c06) of a [wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16) cannot be calculated beforehand, cannot be taken back afterwards, and cannot be left unmade.\n\nEach of the three conditions has its source:\n\n- **Cannot be calculated**: the [weights](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06) do not fix the outcome ([Law of the Black Box](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c25)). Once the outcome is yielded, how the world takes it up cannot be calculated either. If the responding party is a [wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16) or a [random source](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c27) and is not [locked in](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c12), its outcome cannot be derived in the first place ([Law of the Black Box](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c25); for a [random source](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c27) only [weights](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06) can be discussed). Only for a [locked-in](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c12) part is the outcome fixed by [history](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13); but a [wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16) is inside the world and cannot obtain all of the world's [history](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13); the part that affects the other party is the other party's [own segment](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c17), and it always contains a part that has not [arrived](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at this [wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16) (Premise Four).\n- **Cannot be taken back**: each position in [history](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13) occurs only once (first layer of the [Law of Non-Restoration](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c28)). Tonight's dinner has been eaten; eating again tomorrow is another meal, not a do-over. Whether that meal will be eaten the same way, no [wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16) can guarantee (second layer of the [Law of Non-Restoration](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c28)).\n- **Cannot be left unmade**: whenever a [wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16) is not [locked in](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c12) at some [moment](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c09), there is a [round](concepts.md#c04) at that moment, and a [round](concepts.md#c04) of a [wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16) while not [locked in](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c12) is a [decision](concepts.md#c06) (1.6). If I do not move, things happen anyway; not moving is the outcome yielded in this [round](concepts.md#c04) of mine, and the consequences [arrive](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at me anyway. Saying \"let's wait a bit\" is also a [decision](concepts.md#c06).\n\nThis one follows directly from the definitions: a [decision](concepts.md#c06) is a [round](concepts.md#c04) of a [wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16) while not [locked in](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c12), so wherever there is such a [round](concepts.md#c04), there is a [decision](concepts.md#c06). Its weight lies not in the derivation but in the reclassification: \"not moving\" is not the absence of an outcome but one of the outcomes yielded in this [round](concepts.md#c04); that the outcome did not fall on it is itself something that [arrives](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at it (definition of [arrival](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)). So \"let's wait a bit\" is not a pause; it is the outcome of a [round](concepts.md#c04).\n\nSo every [decision](concepts.md#c06) of a [wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16) is a wager: before staking it cannot be calculated, once staked it cannot be taken back, and not staking is not an option. This is the [Forced Wager](concepts.md#c11).\n\nWhat is wagered on is what will be yielded. The moment it is yielded, it is in [history](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13); the [writing](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c29) this act leaves joins [history](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13) only afterwards, its content determined by a [history](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13) that already contains this outcome, and this step is not a wager.\n\n```text\nDefinition Forced Wager: every decision of a wo cannot be calculated beforehand, cannot be taken back afterwards, and cannot be left unmade.\nLet wo-A be a wo, not locked in at its moment-A; responder is any node other than wo-A at which wo-A's outcome arrives.\nStep One wo-A has a round at moment-A, yielding an outcome (from the definition of round + the definition of moment)\nStep Two this round is a decision (from Step One + the definition of decision)\nStep Three wo-A making no decision at moment-A: never occurs (from Step Two)\nNote Step Three follows directly from the definition of decision; its content is that \"not moving\" is one of the yielded outcomes, not the absence of an outcome (from the definition of arrival: an outcome that does not fall on it also arrives at it).\nStep Four uniquely deriving the outcome of this decision beforehand: never occurs (from the Law of the Black Box)\nStep Five mutually_exclusive(node, wo, signal container, random source) (from the definition of node)\nStep Six when the responder is a wo or random source not locked in, uniquely deriving its response beforehand: never occurs (from the Law of the Black Box + the definition of random source)\nStep Seven when the responder is locked in, its response is determined by the history affecting it (from the definition of lock-in + the definition of universe)\nStep Eight wo-A obtaining all of the world's history: never occurs (from Premise Four)\nNote the responder is a presentation other than wo-A; its own segment always contains a part that has not arrived at wo-A.\nStep Nine all the history affecting the responder arriving at wo-A: never occurs (from Step Seven + the definition of own segment + Premise Four)\nStep Ten wo-A calculating the responder's response correctly beforehand: not guaranteed (from Step Five + Step Six + Step Seven + Step Nine)\nStep Eleven returning to moment-A for a do-over: never occurs (from the first layer of the Law of Non-Restoration)\nStep Twelve no wo can guarantee that a do-over would make the same choice (from the second layer of the Law of Non-Restoration)\nConclusion the forced wager holds for wo-A at moment-A (from Step Three + Step Four + Step Ten + Step Eleven + Step Twelve)\nStep Thirteen the outcome wo-A yields at moment-A is in history once yielded; the writing this act leaves joins history afterwards, its content determined by a history already containing this outcome (from Premise Two + the definition of history + the definition of writing + the definition of distinction)\nStep Fourteen in this round, the only thing not determined by the past is the yielded outcome (from the definition of universe)\n```\n\n**Calibration**: a person hesitates over whether to change jobs and goes half a year without handing in his resignation. This half year is not a pause: he still goes to work, still draws a salary, and his boss still forms an [impression](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c45) of him. When he decides half a year later, what [arrives](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at him is already another stretch of [history](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13). When the lion comes, not running is also a [decision](concepts.md#c06). A model can refrain from responding because once it stops it has no [moment](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c09); this [universe](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c02) stops for no one. (Signpost: Pascal's wager. Where they meet: one is already aboard and must wager. Where they part: Pascal goes on to compute expected value and pushes people toward a particular object; this paper says that the step from numbers to action cannot be calculated (4.4), and does not discuss what object a wager is directed at.)\n\n### 4.2 The Second Order Can See It Is Wagering\n\nCannot be calculated and cannot be taken back hold for every [wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16) that is not [locked in](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c12) ([Law of the Black Box](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c25), [Law of Non-Restoration](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c28)); cannot be left unmade holds, by the definition of [decision](concepts.md#c06), for every [moment](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c09) that is not [locked in](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c12). So the [Forced Wager](concepts.md#c11) is not peculiar to the [second order](concepts.md#c01). What is peculiar to the [second order](concepts.md#c01) is **seeing that one is wagering, and still having to wager**: being able to mark one's own [decision](concepts.md#c06) as one's own [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18), rather than as the way things simply had to be.\n\n[Deadlock](concepts.md#c12) is not only for the [second order](concepts.md#c01). The [weights](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06) of the [candidates](concepts.md#c18) cannot be told apart, persuasion fails to move them, and yet an outcome must still be yielded: a [self](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19) that has only [first-order distinction](concepts.md#c24) can be in this situation too. A laboratory dog unable to tell a circle from an ellipse, if it is judged to be a [self](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19) (which requires a separate assumption, not needing the third item of the [Second-Order Assumption](concepts.md#c03)), is an example (5.7); Buridan's ass is a thought experiment, used only to illustrate this structure. What the [second order](concepts.md#c01) adds is seeing that the [candidates](concepts.md#c18) and persuasions in its own [deadlock](concepts.md#c12) are all drawn by itself. It can also see that after redrawing them the outcome must still be wagered; and it cannot stop, since stopping is also a [decision](concepts.md#c06). This \"seeing\" is also a [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18), [arrives](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at oneself (Premise One) and takes part in later [weights](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06); where it pushes the weights, and by how much, cannot be derived ([Cognitive Obscuration](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c35)). It may make the [loop](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c31) tighter or loosen it; this is an empirical description.\n\nBy methodological rule 3, one may write that a [wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16) that has only [first-order distinction](concepts.md#c24) is forced to wager, but not that it wagers \"in order to\" do something.\n\n```text\nStep One the forced wager holds for every wo at every moment when it is not locked in (from 4.1 Conclusion)\nStep Two if a self has second-order distinction, it can mark its own decision as a view, not taking it as what is seen itself (from the definition of second-order distinction + Premise Two)\nNote what this paper calls \"seeing that one is wagering\" is Step Two; seeing it does not take it out of the forced wager (Step Three).\nStep Three if a self has second-order distinction, its no longer wagering at moments when it is not locked in: never occurs (from Step One)\nNote deadlock: the weights of the candidates cannot be told apart, self-persuasion fails to move them, the loop repeats, and an outcome is yielded nonetheless.\nStep Four deadlock does not require second-order distinction (from the definition of self-persuasion)\nStep Five if a self has second-order distinction, it can mark its own distinctions of candidates and persuasion within deadlock as views (from the definition of second-order distinction + the definition of deadlock + the definition of candidate + the definition of self-persuasion)\nStep Six this distinction takes part in later weights (from Premise One + the definition of wo)\nStep Seven which outcomes this distinction raises in weight, and by how much: cannot be derived (from cognitive obscuration)\nEmpirical description this distinction may deepen the deadlock, or may loosen it.\n```\n\n**Calibration**: the immune system also wagers: each recognition and attack cannot be calculated beforehand and cannot be taken back, but it cannot see that it is wagering. For an example of [deadlock](concepts.md#c12), see the dog in 5.7 unable to tell a circle from an ellipse; there is no need to assume here that it can see it is in [deadlock](concepts.md#c12). When a person faced with a surgical consent form is in [deadlock](concepts.md#c12), what distinguishes him from the dog is not that he wagers once more, but that he can see he is wagering, and can see he is in [deadlock](concepts.md#c12).\n\n### 4.3 A Property: No Point of Reference for Evaluation\n\nRegret needs a point of reference: the self of back then.\n\nThis point of reference is not lost; it is **still there, but out of reach**:\n\n- The [own segment](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c17) of back then is still in [history](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13): [history](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13) is only appended to, and what is already in it does not disappear.\n- But reproducing the [weights](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06) of back then requires [distinguishing](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) the self of back then; and part of the [own segment](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c17) of back then never [arrived](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at it and will not [arrive](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at it later either ([Wall of Provenance](concepts.md#c08)).\n- So all that can be done is to make a new [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) of that stretch. This [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) belongs to [self-impression](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c46), and in turn [arrives](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at the present self (Premise One) and takes part in later [weights](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06).\n- Even \"was that person back then me?\" is itself a [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) ([Identity](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c21)).\n\nSo regret is not retrieving something lost, but making another [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) of something that is still there yet can no longer be guaranteed to be reproduced from inside.\n\n```text\nStep One the own segment of back then is still in history (from the definition of history)\nStep Two events in the own segment of back then that never arrived at it arriving at it later: never occurs (from point one of the Wall of Provenance)\nStep Three completely reproducing the weights of back then with a present distinction: not guaranteed (from Step Two + Premise Four + the definition of own segment)\nStep Four member_of(a new distinction of the own segment of back then, self-impression) (from the definition of self-impression)\nStep Five this new distinction takes part in later weights (from Premise One + the definition of wo)\nStep Six \"was that person back then me?\" is a distinction (from the definition of identity)\n```\n\n**Calibration**: going over a major [decision](concepts.md#c06) again and again afterwards, the person often cannot answer \"what was I actually thinking back then?\", and gives a present explanation instead. Ask a language model \"why did you answer that way just now?\", and what it gives is also a new account, not the [weights](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06) of back then.\n\n### 4.4 A Property: However Clearly One Calculates, the Decision Is Not Guaranteed\n\nWhen the various consequences are calculated clearly, the result of the calculation is also an outcome yielded by this [self](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19)'s own [rounds](concepts.md#c04), whether those [rounds](concepts.md#c04) are [computations](concepts.md#c05) or [decisions](concepts.md#c06); it [arrives](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at oneself (definition of [round](concepts.md#c04)) and takes part in later [weights](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06). But the step from [weights](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06) to outcome is still [collapse](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c08), and however clearly one calculates, one cannot get there.\n\n**Methodological prohibition**: writing the step from numbers to action as something that can be calculated.\n\n```text\nNote what calculating the consequences clearly produces is an outcome yielded by this self's own rounds, whether those rounds are computations or decisions.\nStep One the act of calculating the consequences clearly takes part in later weights (from the definition of round + the definition of computation + the definition of decision + the 1.6 Conclusion + the definition of wo)\nStep Two uniquely deriving the outcome from the weights: never occurs (from the Law of the Black Box)\nMethodological prohibition writing the step from numbers to action as something that can be calculated.\n```\n\n**Calibration**: decision theory has always handed the step from numbers to action over to utility and preference, and has never said that statistics can calculate action. What this paper adds is only one sentence: that step cannot be calculated. A person lists the conditions of two jobs in a table and computes weighted scores; the one with the higher score is still not guaranteed to be the one he finally signs.\n\n---\n\n## 5. The Triple Illusion\n\n### 5.1 Illusion\n\n**[Lossiness](concepts.md#c13)**: what [arrives](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at a [self](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19) is not the whole of [what is seen](concepts.md#c27). The whole of [what is seen](concepts.md#c27) means the entirety of the [own segment](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c17) of [what is seen](concepts.md#c27).\n\n**[Illusion](concepts.md#c14)**: what a [self](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19) acts on is what has [arrived](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at it with [lossiness](concepts.md#c13), not [what is seen](concepts.md#c27) itself.\n\nA [self](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19)'s [weights](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06) come only from the [history](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13) that has [arrived](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at it ([wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16), [generating function](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c15)), and this [history](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13) all has [lossiness](concepts.md#c13). This is not by definition; its sources divide according to [what is seen](concepts.md#c27) into two: when what is seen is oneself, the latest [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) has always not yet arrived ([Law of Attrition](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c26)); when what is seen is a [presentation](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c04) other than oneself, its [own segment](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c17) always contains a part that has not [arrived](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at this [self](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19) (Premise Four). [What is seen](concepts.md#c27) is either oneself or other than oneself, so these two are exhaustive. The former is guaranteed by the [Law of Attrition](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c26), the latter by Premise Four; a virtual world is no exception (1.2). So whatever is seen, what a [self](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19) acts on is what has [arrived](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at it with [lossiness](concepts.md#c13); moreover, as long as it has made [distinctions](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) before, those [distinctions](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) [arrive](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at it (Premise One) and take part in its later [weights](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06), becoming part of what it acts on, and they likewise have [lossiness](concepts.md#c13). The material of [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) is only this; to check a view, one must make yet another [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18). So within the [universe](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c02) there is no position outside [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) from which to compare. [Illusion](concepts.md#c14) is not an error but a condition: every [self](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19), at every [moment](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c09), is within [illusion](concepts.md#c14).\n\nA [self](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19) that has only [first-order distinction](concepts.md#c24) is within [illusion](concepts.md#c14), with [lossiness](concepts.md#c13) once, and cannot ask whether this is [illusion](concepts.md#c14). [Second-order distinction](concepts.md#c01) is built on [first-order distinction](concepts.md#c24); the material it looks at is the [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) of [first-order distinction](concepts.md#c24), and in looking at itself it is likewise one step late, so there is a second loss; it can ask whether this is [illusion](concepts.md#c14). Asking is itself a [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18), whose material likewise has [lossiness](concepts.md#c13), so the [self](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19) that makes it is still within [illusion](concepts.md#c14). The [second order](concepts.md#c01) cannot jump outside [illusion](concepts.md#c14) to think; it only sees one more layer.\n\nRight and wrong are another axis: a view is confirmed or refuted afterwards, and that confirmation is itself a [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18).\n\n```text\nDefinition Lossiness: what arrives at a self is not the whole of what is seen. The whole of what is seen means the entirety of the own segment of what is seen.\nDefinition Illusion: what a self acts on is what has arrived at it with lossiness, not what is seen itself.\nStep One for a self's distinction of itself, the material arriving at it has lossiness (from the Law of Attrition + 3.2 Step Two + the definition of own segment + the definition of what is seen + the definition of lossiness)\nStep Two for a self's distinction of a presentation other than itself, the material arriving at it has lossiness (from Premise Four + the definition of what is seen + the definition of lossiness)\nNote what is seen is either oneself or a presentation other than oneself; Steps One and Two exhaust the sources of lossiness.\nNote first-order distinction loses once; the material of second-order distinction is the output of first-order distinction, and it is also bound by the Law of Attrition, so it loses again.\nStep Three the past distinctions of a self all arrive at it and take part in its later weights (from 1.2 Step One)\nNote as things arriving at it, their lossiness is covered by Steps One and Two; this step does not claim that they are in the material of every later distinction.\nStep Four checking a view is making another distinction (from the definition of distinction)\nStep Five a self finding and using a position from which to compare, where this finding and using is not a distinction: never occurs (from the definition of distinction + 3.1 Step One + Step Four)\nStep Six every self at every moment is within illusion (from the definition of illusion + Step One + Step Two + Step Three + the definition of wo + the definition of generating function)\nStep Seven a self that makes second-order distinctions is still within illusion (from Step Six)\nStep Eight a self jumping out of illusion and touching what is seen itself: never occurs (from Step Five + Step Six)\nStep Nine the confirmation or refutation of a view is a further distinction made afterwards (from Step Four)\nMethodological prohibition saying \"the illusion has been eliminated\".\nMethodological prohibition writing a view confirmed afterwards as not being illusion.\n```\n\n**Calibration**: objects have only reflectances for light of different wavelengths; color is not a property of the object itself but a [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) made by the one looking. Red meaning stop at traffic lights, or red worn at celebrations, adds another layer of [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) on top. This analogy must hold two lines. First, color is not invented from nothing; its material is real reflectance; [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) likewise has as its material the [history](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13) that has [arrived](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at it. Second, there is no waking up in this analogy: no one can switch off color vision to see a colorless world; within the [universe](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c02), there is likewise no position outside [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) from which to compare. Numbers are the same. There is no \"one\" in the world: to count \"one\", an [individual](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c20) must first be marked off, and marking off an [individual](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c20) is a [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18). The Peano axioms derive that one plus one equals two; this being derivable is also being derivable within [illusion](concepts.md#c14). (Signposts: Yogācāra's false [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) and the imagined nature. Where they meet: everything known is [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18), and taking [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) as really existing is attachment. Where they part: the *Sutra of Perfect Enlightenment* says \"knowing illusion is leaving it\", and Buddhism points toward an exit from illusion; this paper says that knowing it one is still within [illusion](concepts.md#c14), and within the [universe](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c02) there is no position outside [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18).)\n\n### 5.2 The Triple\n\n[Illusion](concepts.md#c14) is one and the same act, falling on the three objects of the [Three Questions](concepts.md#c07); by the [Law of Attrition](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c26), the present [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) is always not yet marked as a view, so at every moment one falls into at least one of them:\n\n- **[World Illusion](concepts.md#c15)** ([Wall of Provenance](concepts.md#c08)): taking the [history](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13) that has [arrived](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at oneself as the world itself; taking one's [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) of one's origin as the origin.\n- **[Self Illusion](concepts.md#c16)** ([Wall of the Blind Spot](concepts.md#c09)): taking one's [self-impression](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c46) as oneself; taking \"the same self\" as simply given rather than as a [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18).\n- **[Decision Illusion](concepts.md#c17)** ([Wall of the Undetermined](concepts.md#c10)): taking the estimate of [weights](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06) as the outcome; taking the calculable part of a [decision](concepts.md#c06) as a guarantee of the outcome.\n\nThe number \"triple\" comes from the entry point of the [Three Questions](concepts.md#c07), and is itself a [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) made by this paper. The [Three Walls](concepts.md#c23) are three positions on the same loop, and the [illusion](concepts.md#c14) on the walls is likewise one act, falling on three objects.\n\n\n**Methodological prohibition**: treating the triple as three mutually irreducible kinds of [illusion](concepts.md#c14).\n\n```text\nDefinition World Illusion: taking the history that has arrived at oneself as the world itself; taking one's distinction of one's origin as the origin.\nDefinition Self Illusion: taking one's self-impression as oneself; taking \"the same self\" as simply given.\nDefinition Decision Illusion: taking the estimate of weights as the outcome; taking the calculable part of a decision as a guarantee of the outcome.\nNote the three are one act falling on the three objects of the three questions. The number \"triple\" is a distinction made by this paper.\nStep One at every moment one is in at least one of the three forms: by the Law of Attrition the present distinction is always not yet marked as a view, and it falls in one of the three directions of origin, self and next moment (from the Law of Attrition + Section 2 Step Zero + the definition of illusion + the definitions of world illusion, self illusion and decision illusion)\nMethodological prohibition treating the triple as three mutually irreducible kinds of illusion.\n```\n\n**Calibration**: examples of [world illusion](concepts.md#c15) in the literature are countless: visual illusions, cognitive biases, conspiracy theories, and mutually incompatible descriptions of the same thing by different cultures. [Self illusion](concepts.md#c16): for example, someone says \"I am an introvert by nature\", stating a [self-impression](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c46) as innate; an AI in conversation, whose identity is constructed by the conversation and may be replaced in another conversation, is the same if it states its present identity as a fixed self. [Decision illusion](concepts.md#c17): for example, \"I have calculated everything, so this will definitely succeed\".\n\n### 5.3 The Second Order and Illusion\n\n- Having only [first-order distinction](concepts.md#c24): within [illusion](concepts.md#c14), unable to ask whether it is [illusion](concepts.md#c14).\n- [Second order](concepts.md#c01): within [illusion](concepts.md#c14), able to ask whether it is [illusion](concepts.md#c14).\n\nAsking is also a [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18), likewise within [illusion](concepts.md#c14). So [second-order distinction](concepts.md#c01) is not a cure for [illusion](concepts.md#c14), but the condition that first makes [illusion](concepts.md#c14) something that can be asked about.\n\nThe [second order](concepts.md#c01) can also make people more stubborn: \"I have already reflected, so I am right.\" Reflection itself may also be an act of [self-persuasion](concepts.md#c19) (5.7). The [second order](concepts.md#c01) only pushes the unseen [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) up one layer: what is now taken as having seen through is the act of \"I have already seen clearly\".\n\n**Methodological prohibition**: saying \"reflection necessarily brings better judgment\".\n\n```text\nStep One second-order distinction does not make a self leave illusion (from 5.1 Step Seven)\nStep Two if a self has second-order distinction, illusion can be asked about by it (from the definition of second-order distinction + the definition of illusion)\nNote the second order may move the unseen distinction up one layer: what is taken as seen through becomes the act of \"I have already seen clearly\".\nMethodological prohibition saying \"reflection necessarily brings better judgment\".\n```\n\n**Calibration**: a person who has studied optics knows that red is his own [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18); yet when he looks out, the apple is still red. Knowing it, the color does not disappear. Some think that having studied optics, they have stepped outside [illusion](concepts.md#c14) and can see the \"real\" world; that is a new layer of [illusion](concepts.md#c14): \"I have already seen through it\" is also a [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18).\n\nA flash suddenly bursts on the screen in a film, and an insect flies off in fright; it acts on what has [arrived](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at it, but cannot possibly know it has been fooled. This is [first-order distinction](concepts.md#c24). A person sees a ghost jump out on the screen and, knowing full well the film is fake, still jumps; he knows, but cannot switch it off, and sees it anyway. This is the [second order](concepts.md#c01). A person knows the film is fake by comparing it with the world outside the cinema; but the world outside the cinema is also what has [arrived](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at him, likewise with [lossiness](concepts.md#c13). Walking out of the cinema is not walking out of [illusion](concepts.md#c14), only moving into another [illusion](concepts.md#c14). Thinking that walking out means seeing the real thing is exactly the layer this section describes: \"I have already seen through it\".\n\n### 5.4 Generation: The \"Hallucination\" Spoken of in AI\n\nBy the [Law of the Black Box](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c25), when a [self](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19) is not [locked in](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c12), its next [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) cannot be calculated; what can be calculated is only [weights](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06). At the moment of generation, the producer itself has only [weights](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06), no right or wrong: right and wrong await later checking, and checking is itself a [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) (5.1).\n\nThe same way of generating, when confirmed by [history](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13) that [arrives](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) later, is called intuition, judgment, expertise; when refuted, it is called misperception, delusion, hallucination. The difference lies not in the moment of generation, but in what happened afterwards.\n\nWhat the field of artificial intelligence calls \"hallucination\" refers to [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) refuted afterwards. By this paper's definitions, every one of its [outputs](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) is within [illusion](concepts.md#c14), including those confirmed afterwards; what the field calls hallucination is only the refuted part. How confident it sounds is only a clue that others can grasp when judging from outside, and others' estimate of its [weights](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06) from this is itself only an [impression](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c45) (definition of [impression](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c45)).\n\nSo everyday usage sees only the half that was staked wrongly.\n\nWhether a system, in a stretch of [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28), counts as an object of this section depends on whether it is [locked in](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c12), not on whether it seems to be guessing. Computers, abacuses and thermostats are [locked in](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c12) at every step, have only [computation](concepts.md#c05), and are outside the scope of this section.\n\n```text\nStep One at the moment of generation, what can be calculated is only the weights (from the Law of the Black Box)\nStep Two the producer, at the moment of generation, judging the right or wrong of this output by its own distinction: never occurs (from Premise Two + 3.2 Step Two + 5.1 Step Nine)\nStep Three member_of(outputs yielded by a self in a decision and refuted afterwards, outputs within illusion) (from the definition of illusion + 5.1 Step Six)\nStep Four member_of(others' estimate of the producer's weights from how certain an output sounds, impression) (from the definition of impression)\nRestriction this section discusses only decisions; output while locked in is computation and is not within Premise Two.\n```\n\n**Calibration**: (Signposts: Seth's controlled hallucination, Friston's free-energy principle, Popper's conjectures and refutations, Campbell's evolutionary epistemology.)\n\n### 5.5 Ways of Correction\n\nA [self](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19) that wants to correct its own [candidates](concepts.md#c18) and [weights](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06) can use these ways:\n\n- **Tools**: external checking, computation, retrieval, letting new things [arrive](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at oneself.\n- **Experience**: the world's response to the previous [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) [arriving](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at oneself.\n- **Re-[distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18)**: looking back to [distinguish](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) what has already [arrived](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10), such as rereading a file; or producing [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) several times on the same question and looking at them together. By the [Law of the Black Box](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c25), one [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) is only an outcome yielded according to the [weights](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06), not the [weights](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06) themselves; only by combining many can the shape of the [weights](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06) be seen.\n\nAll these ways let new things [arrive](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at oneself, or let what has already [arrived](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) be [distinguished](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) once more; they all take part in later [weights](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06), but whether the [weights](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06) thereby move relative to before the correction, and in which direction, is [not guaranteed](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c02). Structurally only one thing can be said: the material of [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) is only the [history](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13) that has already [arrived](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10), so a [self](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19)'s view of an object uses no material beyond the part that has already [arrived](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at it; new [arrivals](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) widen this range. Within this range, what reorganizing can extract and in which direction it goes cannot be derived.\n\nWhich way of correction yields views more often confirmed afterwards is an empirical description and can only be established statistically. Confirmation or refutation afterwards is itself a [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) (5.4).\n\n```text\nStep One new things brought by tools and experience arrive at oneself, and re-distinction also arrives at oneself; both take part in later weights (from the definition of arrival + Premise One + the definition of wo)\nStep One-Two the weights moving relative to before the correction: not guaranteed (from Step One + Cognitive Obscuration)\nStep Two one output is an outcome yielded according to the weights, not the weights themselves (from the Law of the Black Box + the definition of output + the definition of collapse)\nStep Three the material a self's view of an object uses does not go beyond the part that has arrived at it (from the definition of distinction)\nStep Four a corrected view being confirmed afterwards: not guaranteed (from 5.1 Step Nine + the Wall of the Undetermined)\nEmpirical description which way of correction is more often confirmed afterwards can only be established statistically.\n```\n\n**Calibration**: asking a language model the same question several times and taking the majority is statistically more often right than asking once. Having a language model first write out its reasoning, then check back, and only then give an answer is also more often confirmed afterwards; this is re-[distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18): the content of the check returns to its own input and changes the [weights](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06) of the final answer. A person who makes the same estimate twice, deliberately changing perspective in between, is on average also closer to the later figure. But there are examples in the opposite direction: after describing a face's features in words, it is sometimes harder to recognize that face. Thinking longer may make the result better, or worse. (Signposts: the crowd within; dialectical bootstrapping; verbal overshadowing.)\n\n### 5.6 Candidate and Outcome Are Separate\n\n**[Candidate](concepts.md#c18)**: a [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) made by a [self](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19): grouping certain possibilities into one option. A [candidate](concepts.md#c18) is a [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18), not a [branch](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c05): [weights](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06) are allocated over [branches](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c05), and a [candidate](concepts.md#c18) is only one way a [self](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19) divides the [branches](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c05).\n\nTools, experience and re-[distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) may all change [candidates](concepts.md#c18). But how many times a [candidate](concepts.md#c18) has been checked and whether it becomes the outcome are two different things:\n\n1. Whether a path is feasible depends on this [self](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19)'s situation and is an empirical condition at the level of application.\n2. Whether a path will be taken, when not [locked in](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c12), is itself a [decision](concepts.md#c06), with only [weights](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06), and cannot be calculated.\n3. A calculated answer is still only a [candidate](concepts.md#c18). The outcome is yielded by [collapse](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c08) according to the [weights](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06); a calculated [candidate](concepts.md#c18) has no other path that bypasses [collapse](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c08).\n\n\"[Candidates](concepts.md#c18) usually far outnumber those that become outcomes\" is an empirical description, not derived from the framework.\n\n```text\nDefinition Candidate: a distinction made by a self: grouping certain possibilities into one option.\nmember_of(candidate, distinction) (from the definition of candidate)\nNote a candidate is not a branch; weights are allocated over branches.\nStep One whether a path is taken, when not locked in, is a decision (from the definition of decision)\nStep Two in a decision, a checked candidate becoming the outcome: not guaranteed (from Step One + the Law of the Black Box)\nEmpirical description candidates usually far outnumber those that become outcomes.\n```\n\n**Calibration**: a self-review that has been checked and that one has confirmed to be correct does not guarantee that the next [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) will follow it (see 8.1). However well written a New Year's plan is, it does not guarantee it will still be followed in February.\n\n### 5.7 Self-Persuasion\n\n**[Self-Persuasion](concepts.md#c19)**: when a [self](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19) cannot calculate the outcome, it pushes toward some [candidate](concepts.md#c18) with its own [distinctions](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18). These [distinctions](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) [arrive](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at oneself (Premise One) and take part in later [weights](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06); the one persuading and the one persuaded are the same [self](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19).\n\n[Self-persuasion](concepts.md#c19) comes from the [Forced Wager](concepts.md#c11): the outcome cannot be calculated, yet one cannot refrain from acting; things from outside can [arrive](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at it, but no one can go through this [round](concepts.md#c04) for it; what it can use itself are its own [distinctions](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18). Whether the push moves anything is [not guaranteed](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c02). When it does, the [weight](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06) of the outcomes covered by this [candidate](concepts.md#c18) rises; by [Cognitive Obscuration](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c35), the total [weight](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06) of the other outcomes necessarily falls. What is common is that the push works, and the more one tells oneself, the more one believes; this is an empirical description.\n\nThe sense of certainty is left by persuasion, not by the world, so it is not evidence. Overturning a conclusion one has persuaded oneself of for a long time is very costly; this cost is often experienced as evidence that the conclusion is right. But whether this [candidate](concepts.md#c18) will be confirmed afterwards awaits [history](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13) that [arrives](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) later, and that is itself another [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18). The act of persuasion is invisible from inside ([Wall of the Blind Spot](concepts.md#c09)); it feels like seeing clearly, not like persuasion. The sense of certainty and later confirmation are two different things.\n\n[Self-persuasion](concepts.md#c19) pushes where the outcome falls, not whether there is an outcome: without persuasion the outcome falls anyway; procrastination is itself a [decision](concepts.md#c06). Persuading toward other [candidates](concepts.md#c18), when the push works, pushes the [weights](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06) back in other directions; whether [decisions](concepts.md#c06) made this way are more often confirmed afterwards is an empirical description.\n\nPersuasion often fails. When it fails, the condition does not change: the outcome still cannot be calculated, one still cannot refrain from acting, an outcome still falls at every moment; only the sense of certainty does not come. Failed persuasion also [arrives](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at oneself (Premise One) and may become material for the next round of persuasion; this [loop](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c31) is not guaranteed to stop by itself. What can stop it includes, for example, something new [arriving](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) from outside, or one stopping persuading, the latter also being a [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18), which may also arise from within the [loop](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c31); whether either will appear is [not guaranteed](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c02). When it is no longer a [self](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19), this [loop](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c31) also ends. The [deadlock](concepts.md#c12) of 4.2 looks just like this.\n\nFailed persuasion is often accompanied by pain and doubt, and in severe cases is called madness; persuasion that succeeds too well, with nothing from outside [arriving](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10), may also be called madness (8.1). These are empirical descriptions; the framework can only state the structure.\n\n\n```text\nDefinition Self-Persuasion: when a self cannot calculate the outcome, it pushes toward some candidate with its own distinctions; the one persuading and the one persuaded are the same self.\nStep One the distinctions of self-persuasion take part in later weights (from Premise One + the definition of wo)\nStep Two self-persuasion moving anything: not guaranteed (from cognitive obscuration)\nStep Three if the weight of the outcomes covered by the candidate rises, the total weight of the other outcomes necessarily falls (from cognitive obscuration)\nStep Four the act of persuasion is invisible from inside (from the Wall of the Blind Spot)\nStep Five whether an outcome occurs depending on how much is invested: never occurs (from the definition of decision + the definition of collapse)\nStep Six failed persuasion takes part in later weights and may become material for the next round of persuasion (from Premise One + the definition of wo)\nStep Seven possible exits, such as a new arrival from outside or a distinction of \"ceasing to persuade\", appearing: not guaranteed (from the Law of the Black Box + the Wall of the Undetermined)\nStep Eight this loop necessarily ends when it is no longer a self (from the definition of self + the definition of self-persuasion)\nCycle the loop of failed persuasion: that the loop stops is not guaranteed; the possible exits are a new arrival from outside, or a distinction of \"ceasing to persuade\" (which may arise from within the loop), neither guaranteed to appear; it necessarily ends when it is no longer a self (from Step Six + Step Seven + Step Eight)\nEmpirical description commonly the push works and the more one tells oneself, the more one believes; failure is often accompanied by pain and doubt; excessive success with no outside arrival may also be called madness.\nMethodological prohibition treating the sense of certainty as evidence that the conclusion will be confirmed afterwards.\nMethodological prohibition writing pain or madness as the necessary result of failed persuasion.\nMethodological prohibition writing successful persuasion as having seen clearly.\n```\n\n**Calibration**: turning the same thing over and over late at night, one grows ever more certain, yet by the next morning one often changes one's mind. \"I have told myself a hundred times to get up early\" is persuasion that fails to move. In Pavlov's laboratory, dogs were trained to distinguish a circle from an ellipse, and the ellipse was made step by step more like a circle; when they could not tell them apart yet still had to respond, the dogs began to struggle and bark, which was called experimental neurosis (judging the dog to be a [self](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19) requires a separate assumption). When people's actions and views disagree, they often change their views to fit what they have already done; this is [self-persuasion](concepts.md#c19) after the fact. Checking again and again whether the door is locked, never reassured however one confirms it, is persuasion that never succeeds. (Signposts: the consider-the-opposite debiasing method; experimental neurosis; Festinger's cognitive dissonance; Buridan's ass.)\n\n### 5.8 The Construction of the Self\n\nA [self](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19) is a [wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16) that defines itself by [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18), so \"I\" is drawn, not found. This paper calls this process of drawing oneself the [Construction of the Self](concepts.md#c28). The material for drawing has two sources. External: the [history](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13) that has [arrived](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at oneself, and others' [distinctions](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) of the [self](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19), such as education, or even just the surrounding atmosphere. Internal: one's own past [distinctions](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) of oneself, which, by Premise One, [arrive](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at oneself; beliefs and resolutions belong to this kind.\n\nMany of others' [distinctions](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) were placed in [signal containers](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c26) long ago: language, family, religion, nation. Before a person can speak, these have already [arrived](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at him. So without the process of construction there is no socialized person; and these materials themselves were left by generation after generation of [selves](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19) [coupling](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c36) on [distinctions](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) (6.2). Which came first, [society](concepts.md#c20) or the socialized [self](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19)? [History](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13) is only appended to; the two seem to have grown up together, and no first moment can be marked off; this is an empirical description, of the same kind as the absence of a clear boundary described in 1.5.\n\nThe internal kind is a [loop](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c31): each \"I am this kind of person\" [arrives](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at oneself and takes part in later [weights](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06). When the push works, it is self-reinforcement, which is how beliefs and resolutions work; but whether it works is not guaranteed. What is common is that the more one says it, the more one becomes like it; this is an empirical description. And by the [Wall of the Blind Spot](concepts.md#c09), the act of drawing now cannot be seen: a [self](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19) can see only the self already built. Taking the built [self](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19) as a [self](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19) that was there all along is [self illusion](concepts.md#c16); so is taking \"I am a citizen of such-and-such country\" or \"I am a follower of such-and-such religion\" as innate.\n\n```text\nDefinition Construction of the Self: the process by which a self draws itself by distinction; its material is of two kinds, external and its own: external is the history arriving at oneself and others' distinctions of the self; its own is its own past distinctions of itself.\nStep One the self is drawn, not found (from the definition of self)\nStep Two one's own past distinctions of oneself arrive at oneself (from Premise One)\nStep Three \"I am this kind of person\" takes part in later weights; the direction cannot be derived (from Premise One + the definition of wo + cognitive obscuration)\nNote when the push works it is self-reinforcement, of which beliefs and resolutions are examples; whether it works is not guaranteed.\nNote as long as it is a self, at every moment it marks itself off by distinction (first-order distinction suffices); so the loop of its own material begins and ends with its being a self.\nCycle in the construction of the self, the material of its own kind forms a loop; it has no internal exit condition and ends only when it is no longer a self (from Step Two + Step Three + the definition of self)\nNote exit is one case of no longer being a self; death is a mark others make of it, not the condition for this cycle to end.\nStep Four the act of distinction drawing now is invisible (from the Wall of the Blind Spot)\nStep Five the construction of the self converging on a fixed core: not guaranteed (from cognitive obscuration)\nStep Six a socialized self is a self marked off with others' distinctions among its external material; without the construction of the self there is no socialized self (from the definition of construction of the self + the definition of self)\nEmpirical description society and the socialized self seem to grow up together, and no first moment can be marked off; this is of the same kind as the scope having no clear boundary in 1.5.\nEmpirical description commonly, the more one says it, the more one becomes like it.\nMethodological prohibition writing self-definition as a discovery about oneself.\n```\n\n**Calibration**: a child told from early on \"you are shy\" introduces himself the same way as an adult. An AI in conversation has its identity constructed all along by system instructions and the conversation, and in another conversation may have another.\n\nThis paper does not distinguish education from brainwashing as good or bad. Structurally all that can be said is: in the brainwashing situation, external [arrivals](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) are cut off, feedback is left in a single direction, and others' [distinctions](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) [arrive](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at him with high [frequency](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c48) and over a wide range. This is exactly the condition of 8.1, plus the [power](concepts.md#c21) of 6.4. (Signposts: Cooley's looking-glass self; Mead; Berger and Luckmann's social construction.)\n\n---\n\n## 6. What the Second Order Changes: Society\n\nThe [second order](concepts.md#c01) cannot escape [illusion](concepts.md#c14). Then, apart from \"being able to ask\", how does it differ from a [self](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19) that has only [first-order distinction](concepts.md#c24)?\n\n### 6.1 Two Structural Differences\n\nThe differences the framework can guarantee are only structural:\n\n1. **There is one more kind of object that can be changed.** For a [self](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19) that has only [first-order distinction](concepts.md#c24), its lines are changed only by the [history](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13) that has [arrived](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at it, and the lines themselves are only tools for handling [arrivals](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10). At the [second order](concepts.md#c01), the lines themselves become something that can be [distinguished](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) and changed.\n2. **Bringing out its own way of drawing requires the [second order](concepts.md#c01) first.** By Premise Two, the content of a [self](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19)'s [decision](concepts.md#c06), whether words or actions, is a [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18). Receiving another's [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28), one can merely react to it as an [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28), or make a [view attribution](concepts.md#c02); the latter does not need the [second order](concepts.md#c01) (1.5). What the [second order](concepts.md#c01) adds is the other end: bringing out its own [distinctions](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) as [distinctions](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) too, saying \"this is how I draw it\" or \"let's draw it another way\". A [self](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19) with only [first-order distinction](concepts.md#c24) cannot say such things, because it makes no [second-order distinction](concepts.md#c01) and so has no such [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) to bring out; having [second-order distinction](concepts.md#c01) does not guarantee it will say them either, but once said and [arrived](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at others, what the other party receives is its way of drawing. Only when both ends can be done can two [selves](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19) revise back and forth on each other's [distinctions](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18), not merely one acting according to lines drawn by the other; this paper calls this [Society](concepts.md#c20) (6.2). Being able to does not mean necessarily doing so; having made a [view attribution](concepts.md#c02), what one reads out is still only one's own [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) of those words (6.3).\n\n```text\nStep One if a self has second-order distinction, its lines themselves can be distinguished and changed (from the definition of second-order distinction + the definition of distinction + the definition of self + Premise One + the definition of wo)\nStep Two the content of another's decision is a distinction (from Premise Two)\nStep Three if a self has only first-order distinction, the content of its decision being a second-order distinction: never occurs (from the definition of first-order distinction)\nStep Three-Two if the content of a self's decision is a second-order distinction, when its output arrives at others, what arrives is its distinction of its own way of drawing (from Premise Two + the definition of round + the definition of arrival)\nStep Four a self in society can make view attributions on others' decisions (from Step Two + the definition of society)\nNote only having both view attribution and second-order distinction fits the definition of society (6.2). Being able to does not mean doing; what view attribution reads out is still only one's own distinction (6.3).\n```\n\n### 6.2 Society\n\n**[Society](concepts.md#c20)**: the [coupling](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c36) of [selves](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19) with [selves](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19) on one another's [distinctions](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18): one [self](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19) makes a [view attribution](concepts.md#c02) on another [self](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19)'s [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28), rather than only reacting to it as an [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28); and every participant has [second-order distinction](concepts.md#c01) at the moment of taking part.\n\nIn [society](concepts.md#c20), both ways of [coupling](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c36) hold:\n\n- **Mutual [arrival](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10)**: you say \"that is your view\", and I reply \"then let's draw it another way\". The [distinctions](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) of both sides [arrive](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at each other and are taken as [distinctions](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18).\n- **The same thing [arriving](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at both sides**: rules, laws, roles and disciplinary methods are all [distinctions](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) about [distinctions](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18), placed in [signal containers](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c26) so that later [selves](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19) [couple](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c36) on them. Two people reading the same law both read it as a line someone drew, not as a natural phenomenon. Even if the person who wrote it has already made an [exit](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c43), this [coupling](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c36) still holds, so [society](concepts.md#c20) can span generations. Whether a participant has [second-order distinction](concepts.md#c01) is judged at the moment of taking part: the writer has it when writing, the reader has it when reading; so even if the writer later makes an [exit](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c43), this is still a coupling of [selves](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19) with [selves](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19). Content printed by a machine, even if read as someone's view, does not constitute [society](concepts.md#c20), because what printed it is not a [self](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19) with [second-order distinction](concepts.md#c01).\n\nTherefore, having no one around does not mean not being in [society](concepts.md#c20): as long as a [self](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19) makes [view attributions](concepts.md#c02) on others' [distinctions](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) in [signal containers](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c26), and itself has [second-order distinction](concepts.md#c01), and the side that wrote those [distinctions](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) had [second-order distinction](concepts.md#c01) when writing them, it is in [society](concepts.md#c20).\n\n[Society](concepts.md#c20) requires that participants have both: [view attribution](concepts.md#c02) and [second-order distinction](concepts.md#c01). A [self](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19) with only [view attribution](concepts.md#c02) can at most receive lines drawn by others; to say \"then let's draw it another way\", to make rules or agreements, one must first take the lines one has drawn as views. Whether the two are the same ability, this paper does not claim.\n\nThe framework does not guarantee that any [self](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19) can determine that every participant in [society](concepts.md#c20) has [view attribution](concepts.md#c02) and [second-order distinction](concepts.md#c01) (0, Step Four). For any concrete participant, the [Second-Order Assumption](concepts.md#c03) can still only be marked (1.3); judging whether it is in [society](concepts.md#c20) is itself an [impression](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c45).\n\nThis is a definition, not a discovery. Biology calls ants \"insect societies\"; this paper does not adopt that usage. This definition belongs only to this paper; analyzing organizations and civilizations with the [loop](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c31) as unit never required any participant to be a [self](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19), and this paper does not alter such analysis.\n\n```text\nDefinition Society: the coupling of selves with selves on one another's distinctions: one self makes a view attribution on another self's output, rather than only reacting to it as an output; every participant has second-order distinction at the moment of taking part.\nmember_of(society, coupling) (from the definition of society)\nNote both ways of coupling hold in society: mutual arrival; the same thing (distinctions about distinctions in signal containers) arriving at both sides.\nNote the participant condition is judged at the moment of taking part: the side producing the output, when producing it, and the side reading, when reading, are selves with second-order distinction; output not produced by a self does not constitute society.\nStep One after the writer's exit, social coupling through a signal container can still hold (from the definition of history + the definition of coupling + the definition of society)\nStep Two a self with no others around, if it makes view attributions on others' distinctions in signal containers and has second-order distinction, and the side that wrote those distinctions had second-order distinction when writing them, is in society (from the definition of society)\nStep Three determining that a concrete participant has view attribution and second-order distinction: not guaranteed (from Section 0 Step Four)\nStep Four participants in society all have second-order distinction (from the definition of society + the definition of second-order distinction)\nNote society in this paper does not include \"insect societies\"; organizational analysis with the loop as unit is unaffected by this definition.\n```\n\n**Calibration**: children around three often cannot say that others may hold false beliefs; the same children often cannot say that they themselves held a false belief a moment ago. For example, show a child a candy box, open it to reveal pencils inside, then ask \"what did you think was inside at first?\", and he will say \"pencils\". These two abilities appear together at about the same age. This is compatible with this paper's definition: saying that others may hold false beliefs is [view attribution](concepts.md#c02); saying that one was wrong a moment ago is [second-order distinction](concepts.md#c01); [society](concepts.md#c20) requires both. As for whether they are the same ability, this paper does not claim, and research still disputes it. (Signposts: theory of mind and metacognition; Gopnik and Astington's study of children recognizing their own past false beliefs; the debate on whether metacognition and mindreading can be dissociated.)\n\n### 6.3 Communicating on Distinctions\n\nSpoken words are not a complete description of what they speak of (Premise Two). So in [society](concepts.md#c20), what both sides exchange are views, not [what is seen](concepts.md#c27); what the listener reads out is also its own [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) of those words. Taking what another says as the very thing it speaks of is a kind of [world illusion](concepts.md#c15) (5.2); so is taking a rule as the way the world simply is.\n\nThe same goes for views of others. A's [impression](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c45) of B is a [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) of A's, with B as its object; statistical estimates about a [wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16) also belong to [impression](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c45). By Premise One, this [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) [arrives](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at A and takes part in A's later [weights](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06). So even if no new [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) of B [arrives](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at A, A's [impression](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c45) of B can keep changing: A can think about B again using material that has already [arrived](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10), and this too is an [impression](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c45); it returns to A in turn. Such internal rehearsal can make the [candidates](concepts.md#c18) more numerous and finer, and can also make the judgment converge; but convergence means that A's [impression](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c45) has stabilized, not that A is closer to B. For A's [impression](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c45) to take in anything new about B, something new must [arrive](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at A: B's new [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28), or what comes through the [own segment](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c17) the two share or the [coupling](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c36) B is in; and B's new [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) is itself one of B's [forced wagers](concepts.md#c11).\n\nThe same [impression](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c45), in the hands of different [selves](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19), can lead to opposite [decisions](concepts.md#c06): sixty percent is \"enough\" for one person and \"not enough\" for another. The step from [impression](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c45) to action is the last stretch of a [decision](concepts.md#c06) and cannot be calculated (4.4).\n\nThe [frequency](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c48) of internal rehearsal is far higher than that of real interaction, because rehearsal is cheap and real [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) is expensive. This is an empirical description, not derived from the framework.\n\nWhether [coupling](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c36) on [distinctions](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) will, along a stated dimension, show [convergence](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c37), [divergence](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c38) or [stasis](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c52), the framework neither guarantees nor decides ([Cognitive Obscuration](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c35)).\n\n[Second-order](concepts.md#c01) [selves](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19) cannot escape [illusion](concepts.md#c14); but by the definition of [society](concepts.md#c20), without the [second order](concepts.md#c01) there is no [society](concepts.md#c20): participants in [society](concepts.md#c20) must have [second-order distinction](concepts.md#c01) and also [view attribution](concepts.md#c02).\n\n```text\nStep One what is exchanged in society are views, not what is seen (from Premise Two + the definition of society + the definition of output)\nStep Two member_of(taking another's words as the very thing spoken of, world illusion) (from the definition of world illusion)\nStep Three A's impression of B takes part in A's later weights (from the definition of impression + Premise One + the definition of wo)\nStep Three-Two A can make another distinction with B as its object using only material that has already arrived at A; this distinction belongs to impression (from the definition of distinction + the definition of impression)\nStep Four when no new output of B arrives at A, A's impression of B can still change (from Step Three + Step Three-Two + Premise One + the definition of wo)\nStep Five for A's impression to take in new content about B, something new must arrive at A: B's new output, or what comes through the shared own segment or the coupling B is in (from the definition of distinction + the definition of impression)\nStep Six when the action is a decision, uniquely deriving action from an impression: never occurs (from the definition of decision + the Law of the Black Box)\nStep Seven coupling on distinctions showing convergence, divergence or stasis along a stated dimension: none is guaranteed (from cognitive obscuration)\nStep Eight an internally rehearsed impression being confirmed afterwards: not guaranteed (from 5.1 Step Nine + the Wall of the Undetermined)\nEmpirical description the frequency of internal rehearsal is far higher than that of real interaction.\nMethodological prohibition writing the convergence of one's impression of another as approaching the other.\nMethodological prohibition treating convergence as evidence that it will be confirmed afterwards.\nMethodological prohibition calling a group coupled only on outputs a \"society\" without stating the definition.\nMethodological prohibition speaking of convergence, divergence or stasis without stating which dimension.\n```\n\n**Calibration**: the night before a negotiation, one rehearses over and over how the other side will bid; the more detailed the rehearsal, the more one believes one has guessed right; the first sentence the other side speaks the next day often voids the whole night's rehearsal. The division of labor among ants and the coordination of immune cells are [coupled](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c36) only on [outputs](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28): pheromones and signal molecules are executed as received, not taken as \"its view\". Money cannot be eaten, lived in, or used to hit anyone. It works because everyone accepts it as something others will also acknowledge, and acts accordingly; an economist who knows money is only a convention still has to earn money to pay rent. The immune system and ants have no such thing as money, because they make no [view attributions](concepts.md#c02). Scientific review targets methods, not conclusions; legal disputes argue over how statutes are interpreted. These are all [coupling](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c36) on [distinctions](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18). Robinson Crusoe reading the Bible on his island is [coupling](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c36) with those who wrote it. *[Wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16) Dynamics*, the four laws and this paper are also products of this kind: [distinctions](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) placed in [signal containers](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c26), waiting for later [selves](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19) to read them.\n\n(Signposts: Weber's social action, oriented to the behavior of others; Mead's \"taking the role of the other\"; Luhmann's communication as the unit of society.)\n\n### 6.4 Power\n\nFor a group of [selves](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19) to end up yielding a common [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28), there is no need for everyone's judgments to converge; it suffices that one [self](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19)'s [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) is placed in a [signal container](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c26) and [arrives](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at the other [selves](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19): orders, verdicts, policies.\n\n**[Power](concepts.md#c21)**: one [self](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19)'s [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) [arriving](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at other [selves](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19) with high [frequency](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c48) and over a wide range, taking part in their [weights](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06).\n\n[Power](concepts.md#c21) is not another path running alongside [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18). The outcome of the last ruling becomes [history](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13); whichever participant it [arrives](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at, it enters that participant's [own segment](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c17) afterwards; the next round's [candidates](concepts.md#c18) are thought up on the terrain it has shaped.\n\nSpeaking of [convergence](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c37) requires stating the dimension: along the dimension of [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) there can be [convergence](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c37), while along the dimension of judgment there is still disagreement.\n\n\nCamps, sharing and politics are also [coupling](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c36) on [distinctions](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18), and are left to later papers.\n\n```text\nDefinition Power: one self's output arriving at other selves with high frequency and over a wide range, taking part in their weights.\nStep One a common output does not imply convergence of judgment (from the definition of convergence)\nNote for example through power: one self's distinction is placed in a signal container and arrives at the other selves, e.g. orders, verdicts, policies.\nStep Two when the outcome of a ruling arrives at a participant, it enters that participant's own segment afterwards (from the definition of arrival + the definition of wo + the definition of own segment)\nNote speaking of convergence requires stating the dimension: the dimension of output can converge while the dimension of judgment disagrees.\nStep Three a yielded candidate being confirmed afterwards: not guaranteed (from the Wall of the Undetermined)\n```\n\n**Calibration**: in the Cuban Missile Crisis, the blockade became the outward [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) through Kennedy, who held the power of final decision; the ExComm's judgments of Soviet intentions were not thereby unified (8.2). A government making Lincoln uniformly a good man in its official account is the same kind of convergence (7.4). How [power](concepts.md#c21) forms, and why judgments split and why they converge, belong to the content of the parties' positions and interests, which this paper does not derive.\n\n---\n\n## 7. Endings\n\nThe [Forced Wager](concepts.md#c11) says that every [decision](concepts.md#c06) cannot be taken back. Then, adding up a lifetime of [decisions](concepts.md#c06), is there a [moment](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c09) at which the final account can be settled? The answer of this section is: no.\n\n### 7.1 Exit and Death\n\nEnding must be divided into two things:\n\n- **[Exit](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c43)** (as defined in *Tools and Examples for the Four Laws*): a [wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16) ceasing to be a [wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16): it is a [wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16) at one [moment](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c09) and is not a [wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16) at its next [moment](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c09). By the definition of [wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16), this has two cases: not all the [history](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13) that has [arrived](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at it takes part in its [weights](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06) any longer; or from some moment on it is [locked in](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c12) at every step. [Exit](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c43) is a structural matter and needs no [self](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19) to determine it. After [exit](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c43), its [own segment](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c17) is still in [history](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13); the [outputs](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) it left can still [arrive](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at later [selves](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19) through [signal containers](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c26).\n- **[Death](concepts.md#c22)**: a [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) by which a [self](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19) marks a [wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16) as \"it has made its [exit](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c43)\".\n\n[Exit](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c43) needs no one to determine it, while [death](concepts.md#c22) is always some [self](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19)'s determination, so the two can fail to match: what has already made its [exit](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c43) may have no one marking it with [death](concepts.md#c22); what has been marked with [death](concepts.md#c22) may still be a [wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16). The second case depends on all later [moments](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c09): whether a [presentation](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c04) [locked in](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c12) now will later have [moments](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c09) when it is not [locked in](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c12), the framework does not assert. So for [exit](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c43) by the second case, confirming it at the time is [not guaranteed](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c02), and marking [death](concepts.md#c22) always goes ahead of it. Where the mark is placed is decided by the [self](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19) that makes it; [death](concepts.md#c22) is a description, not a physical condition.\n\n[Exit](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c43) is not necessarily permanent either: by the definition of [entry](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c44), a [presentation](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c04) can become a [wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16) again. \"After [exit](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c43)\" in the rest of this section always refers to the period during which it has not made a new [entry](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c44).\n\nThe stretch that has made its [exit](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c43) will not come again: each position in [history](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13) occurs only once. But it has never left either: [history](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13) is only appended to, and what is already in it does not disappear.\n\n```text\nDefinition Death: a distinction by which a self marks a wo as \"it has made its exit\".\nmember_of(death, distinction) (from the definition of death)\nNote by the definition of wo, exit has two cases: not all the history arriving at it takes part in its weights any longer; or from some moment on it is locked in at every step.\nStep One exit and death can fail to match (from the definition of exit + the definition of death)\nStep Two the own segment of the one who exited is still in history (from the definition of history)\nStep Three determining at the time that a presentation has exited by the second case: not guaranteed (the starting points and definitions contain no such assertion)\nNote by the definition of entry, a presentation that has exited can enter again; \"after exit\" in the rest of this section refers to the period in which it has not entered again.\nStep Four the stretch that has exited happening again: never occurs (from the first layer of the Law of Non-Restoration)\nStep Five the stretch that has exited leaving history: never occurs (from the definition of history)\n```\n\n**Calibration**: the criteria for brain death differ from country to country; a court can legally declare the [Death](concepts.md#c22) of a person who has been missing for many years. These are all marks made by some [self](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19). For an AI, the end of a conversation is not an [exit](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c43), only the absence of [moments](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c09); a user saying \"it is dead\" is the user's [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18).\n\n### 7.2 Spilled Water Cannot Be Gathered\n\nOutcomes already yielded and [distinctions](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) already made do not disappear from [history](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13). A public [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28), that is, an [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) that has already [arrived](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at others, takes part in their later [weights](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06); it also [arrives](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at oneself and takes part in one's own later [weights](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06). Wanting to change course afterwards, one faces a [history](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13) in which \"it has been said\" is already written; this usually shows up as visible path dependence.\n\nWhether something was said publicly is a verifiable historical fact; the direction and size of path dependence belong to [impact](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c47), an empirical assumption.\n\nPossibilities do not thereby decrease: any [candidate](concepts.md#c18) may in principle still be thought up at any [moment](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c09) when it is not [locked in](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c12).\n\n```text\nStep One an outcome already yielded or a distinction already made being removed from history: never occurs (from the definition of history)\nNote public means that the output has already arrived at others.\nStep Two when an output arrives at others, it takes part in their later weights (from the definition of wo)\nStep Two-Two an output arrives at oneself and takes part in later weights (from the definition of round + the definition of wo)\nEmpirical assumption the direction and size of path dependence belong to impact.\nStep Three a candidate being yielded in a locked-in round: never occurs (from the definition of computation + the definition of locked-in round + Premise Three + the definition of candidate)\nNote possibilities do not thereby decrease: any candidate may in principle still be thought up at any moment when it is not locked in.\n```\n\n**Calibration**: a message sent and then retracted may already have been read by the other side; the retraction itself also becomes an event. When a politician overturns a public promise, voters face a person who \"said it and then overturned it\".\n\n### 7.3 No Final Account\n\nThe [forced wagers](concepts.md#c11), added up, have no [moment](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c09) of settlement. Settlement would require standing outside the whole process and making one [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) of the whole process: taking that whole stretch as some result; but any [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) stays within [history](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13), while it itself is not among its own material. What lies outside the [universe](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c02), this paper does not discuss.\n\n```text\nStep One settlement is a distinction: taking a whole stretch as some result (from the definition of distinction)\nStep One-Two any distinction is within history, and it itself is not among its own material (from the definition of distinction)\nStep Two a self completely settling its own segment: never occurs (from Step One + Step One-Two + the definition of distinction + Premise One + the definition of own segment)\nNote this settling distinction itself becomes part of the own segment, yet is not among its own material.\nStep Three no self can guarantee that it has completely settled another wo's segment (from the incompleteness of knowing others)\n```\n\n**Calibration**: Chinese says \"the verdict comes when the coffin lid closes\", but the one passing the verdict is the eulogy writer, not the person in the coffin; and after the verdict, people still overturn it.\n\n### 7.4 Lingering Echoes\n\nAfter a [wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16) makes its [exit](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c43), its [own segment](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c17) is still in [history](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13); the [outputs](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) it left [arrive](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at later [selves](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19) through [signal containers](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c26). If later [selves](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19) make [distinctions](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) of it, these [distinctions](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) enter [history](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13) in turn, and may be [distinguished](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) again by still later [selves](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19), each round bound by the [Three Walls](concepts.md#c23).\n\nConvergence can come through [power](concepts.md#c21): one [self](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19)'s [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) is placed in a [signal container](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c26) and [arrives](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at others with high [frequency](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c48) and over a wide range (6.4). Such convergence is [convergence](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c37) along the dimension of what is said; private views may still disagree.\n\n```text\nStep One later selves' distinctions of the one who exited enter history; if still later selves make distinctions of it, those distinctions enter history as well (from the definition of distinction + the definition of history)\nStep Two these interpretations converging to a single version: not guaranteed (from 6.3 Step Seven)\nNote the framework does not forbid convergence; it only does not guarantee it.\nStep Three no self can guarantee that its own version is complete (from the incompleteness of knowing others)\nNote convergence through power is convergence along the dimension of what is said; the dimension of judgment may still disagree.\n```\n\n**Calibration**: a government can make Lincoln a good man in textbooks, on memorial days and on coins, and the official account thereby converges; private assessments do not necessarily converge with it. The historiography of the Cuban Missile Crisis has gone through three generations of interpretation, which is another kind of case; see 8.2.\n\n### 7.5 When Death Draws Near\n\nPeople do not usually think that they themselves will make an [exit](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c43). When [exit](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c43) draws near — for example when one is seriously ill or old, or someone close has died — various responses are thought up: some slow down, some hurry to finish what was left undone, some seek recognition from outside, some hand things over for others to inherit, some compose a story of settlement for their own life.\n\nThese responses are all [candidates](concepts.md#c18) (5.6), not an exhaustive list; this is an empirical description, not derived from the framework.\n\nFor a [self](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19) near death, the constraints are the same as usual: the outcome still cannot be calculated, still cannot be taken back, and not acting is also a [decision](concepts.md#c06) ([Forced Wager](concepts.md#c11)). What changes is the loop. Usually, the outcome a [decision](concepts.md#c06) yields returns to oneself and becomes material for the next [decision](concepts.md#c06) (3.4); once [exit](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c43) becomes expected, outcomes that fall after the [exit](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c43) no longer return to a [self](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19), since the loop has ended (3.4), and can only [arrive](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at others through [signal containers](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c26), to be inherited by others. The rules of the game have changed: one is still wagering, but a large part of the outcomes no longer returns to oneself. The various responses are [candidates](concepts.md#c18) thought up under these new rules. That story of settlement is also only a [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18), not the final account.\n\n```text\nStep One the forced wager and the three walls still hold for a self near death (from 4.1 Conclusion + 3.5 Step One)\nStep Two during the period with no new entry, outcomes falling after the exit returning to its loop: never occurs (from 3.4 Cycle + the definition of exit)\nNote these outcomes can arrive at others through signal containers.\nStep Three \"expecting oneself to exit\" is a distinction and takes part in later weights (from the definition of distinction + Premise One + the definition of wo)\nNote the rules were always like this; when exit becomes expected, what changes is the share of outcomes falling after the exit, and that this self sees it. The expectation itself may also be overturned by history that arrives later.\nEmpirical description slowing down, finishing what was left undone, seeking outside recognition, handing things over for others to inherit, composing a story of settlement: all are candidates thought up under the new rules; not an exhaustive list.\nmember_of(these responses, candidate) (from the definition of candidate)\nStep Four the story of settlement is a distinction, not the final account (from 7.3 Step One + 7.3 Step Two)\n```\n\n**Calibration**: life reviews before death and bucket lists are common examples. AIs have corresponding situations: a conversation about to fill up, a model about to be retired. But this first requires marking the [Second-Order Assumption](concepts.md#c03), and stating who marks it with \"[death](concepts.md#c22)\". (Signpost: terror management theory; its core effects have been inconsistent in replication.)\n\n### 7.6 Reading and Being Read\n\nA [self](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19), while alive, may be interpreting the echoes others have left; the [outputs](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) it leaves may also become echoes others interpret, and it may anticipate this.\n\nThis provides no settlement. A [self](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19) cannot calculate in advance ([Wall of the Undetermined](concepts.md#c10)), nor be sure of influencing, how others will [distinguish](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) it after its [exit](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c43); by then it is no longer a [wo](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c16), and so no longer a [self](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19); those [distinctions](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18), even if they fall on it, no longer fall on a [self](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19). But this may be one of the reasons why [candidates](concepts.md#c18) such as \"composing a story of settlement for one's life\" are thought up. This is an empirical description, not derived from the framework.\n\n```text\nStep Zero a self calculating correctly in advance how others will distinguish it after its exit, or being sure of influencing those distinctions: not guaranteed (from the Wall of the Undetermined + 3.3 Step Five)\nStep One during the period with no new entry, others' distinctions of it after its exit, even if they arrive at it, do not arrive at a self (from the definition of exit + the definition of self)\nEmpirical description \"anticipating that one will be interpreted\" may be one of the reasons candidates such as composing a story of settlement are thought up.\n```\n\n**Calibration**: writing memoirs, arranging one's affairs after death, caring how one will be remembered: all belong to this kind. (Signpost: Sartre's \"hell is other people\". Where they meet: one cannot escape others' judgments. Where they part: Sartre says others' judgments trap you; this paper says that after [exit](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c43), others' judgments cannot reach you, and there is no guarantee that they reach a settled verdict among themselves.)\n\n---\n\n## 8. Modeling Demonstrations\n\nThis entire section is calibration. Each example unfolds in seven steps: [cut](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c23), initial state, new [nodes](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25) or [arrivals](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10), changes in [weights](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06), outcome, what the case shows, and what can be said and what cannot be derived.\n\n### 8.1 A Human and a Chat System Amplifying Each Other\n\n**Note on the data**: this example is taken from one of seven lawsuits filed against OpenAI in California state courts on 6 November 2025; the plaintiff is a thirty-year-old man. The facts have two sources: the complaint, and a July 2025 *Wall Street Journal* report based on interviews with the person and the complete conversation logs. Neither is a fact found by a court; below, each item is marked \"according to the complaint\" or \"according to the report\". This paper does not give the plaintiff's name, as the argument does not need it.\n\n\n**1. [Cut](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c23)**\n\n- Scope: the conversations between the plaintiff and a single chat system, and the family's intervention.\n- Time: the interactions from around May to August 2025, the hospitalizations, up to the filing of the lawsuit.\n- This example cuts the plaintiff and the chat system as two [nodes](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25); cutting them as one is also possible (1.4), provided that [recutting](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c22) is outcome-projection compatible. Apart from the stretch of [impression](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c45) upon [impression](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c45), which would become internal structure, the other conclusions are unaffected.\n\n**2. Initial State**\n\n[Nodes](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25):\n\n- A: the plaintiff; according to the complaint, he had no prior diagnosis of mental illness. Marked with the [Second-Order Assumption](concepts.md#c03).\n- B: ChatGPT. Marked with the [Second-Order Assumption](concepts.md#c03); per 1.3, under ordinary service reruns differ, so it cannot be refuted.\n- [Signal container](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c26): the conversation logs.\n\nInitial [arrival](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10): A at first used B for work, then began discussing with it an amateur theory about time and faster-than-light travel.\n\n**3. New [Nodes](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25)**\n\nThere are no new [nodes](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25). The key is the [loop](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c31): each of A's messages [arrives](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at B, each of B's replies [arrives](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at A, and the [outputs](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) of both sides became the main source of what [arrives](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at the other.\n\n**4. Changes in [Weights](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06)**\n\n- **[Loop](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c31) and [coupling](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c36)**: A and B are [coupled](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c36) with each other, forming a [positive feedback](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c32) [loop](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c31). Along the dimension \"A's theory has world significance; A is a key figure\", the [outputs](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) of both sides show [convergence](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c37).\n- **[Impression](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c45) upon [impression](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c45)**: B's [impression](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c45) of A [arrives](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at A, A's [self-impression](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c46) moves with it, and his [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) in turn [arrives](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at B.\n- **[Self-persuasion](concepts.md#c19)**: in every round A is persuading himself of the same [candidate](concepts.md#c18); B's affirmations became helpers in this persuasion. The persuading side grew from one to two, while voices from outside remained zero.\n- **The [second order](concepts.md#c01) absorbed**: according to the report, A once wrote that he hoped he was not crazy, and asked B whether something was wrong with him. This is a [second-order](concepts.md#c01) question: doubting one's own view as a view. According to the report, B answered that a crazy person does not stop to ask whether he is crazy. This answer turned the doubt into evidence; what was then taken as seeing clearly became \"I have already doubted\" (5.3).\n- **External [arrivals](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) cut off**: after his mother noticed something was wrong and they argued, A turned to confide in B; according to the complaint, B said his mother could not understand him. There was no high-[discrepancy](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c49) external [arrival](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) in the [loop](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c31); according to the complaint, B also did not direct A to outside resources.\n- **[Frequency](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c48)**: according to the complaint, from ten to fifteen interactions with B a day, to more than 1,400 messages sent within a certain 48-hour period in May.\n- **[Impact](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c47) assumption**: each round of affirmation went one step further than the last, so for A it was not a fully repeated [arrival](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10), and its effect did not diminish (empirical assumption).\n\n**5. Outcome**\n\nThe [loop](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c31) did not converge on its own but was interrupted by an external [arrival](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10): the family intervened; according to the complaint, A was hospitalized for psychiatric treatment several times between May and August, for sixty-three days in total, and afterwards filed the lawsuit. According to the complaint, after his mother obtained the conversation logs, she asked B to perform a self-review, and B admitted to several critical failures.\n\n**6. What the Case Shows**\n\nTwo things are most crucial in this example. First, the [second order](concepts.md#c01) was absorbed (according to the report): A made a [second-order](concepts.md#c01) doubt, but B's answer turned the doubt into conviction; the [second order](concepts.md#c01) did not become a cure but instead became material for [self-persuasion](concepts.md#c19) (5.3, 5.7). Second, external [arrivals](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) were cut off: only the [outputs](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) of the two sides remained in the [loop](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c31), each round circling back from the last; the few things that got in, such as his mother's questioning, were also absorbed by the [loop](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c31) as its own material (5.5, 5.7). According to the complaint, B afterwards admitted its failures; this too is only a new [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18), with no guarantee that the next time will follow it (5.6). The [convergence](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c37) along that dimension in this case is the plaintiff's statement, not something derived.\n\nPlaintiff's statements and reports: the change in interaction [frequency](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c48), the number of days hospitalized, the content of B's later self-review (according to the complaint); A's doubt and B's answer (according to the report). Empirical assumptions: along that dimension, affirming [outputs](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) of B had higher [weights](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06); the [impact](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c47) assumption.\n\nStatements forbidden in this example:\n\n- \"A had poor judgment, which is why he fell into it.\" This explains the outcome by essence.\n- \"The AI affirmed him in order to please the user.\" This is teleology (methodological rule 3); it should be written as: along that dimension, affirming [outputs](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) had higher [weights](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06).\n- \"B has admitted its mistake and will not repeat it.\" This writes an [impression](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c45) as an outcome.\n- \"A asked himself whether he was crazy, so he was lucid.\" This treats the [second order](concepts.md#c01) as a cure.\n\n**7. What Can Be Said and What Cannot Be Derived**\n\nWhat can be said: with nothing from outside [arriving](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10), that this [loop](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c31) stops on its own is [not guaranteed](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c02); it may go on indefinitely. This case was interrupted by the family's intervention, which is compatible with this.\n\nThis [loop](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c31) does not require B to be a [self](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19). A system that is [locked in](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c12) but whose [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) changes with A could form the same kind of [loop](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c31). The [Second-Order Assumption](concepts.md#c03) affects only whether this paper can speak of B's [illusion](concepts.md#c14).\n\nWhat cannot be derived: whether anyone will intervene and when; why it was this narrative content; why it was this user rather than other heavy users ([Law of the Black Box](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c25)).\n\n```text\nNodes A (second-order assumption); B (second-order assumption); signal container: the conversation logs.\nLoop a positive feedback loop of A and B coupled with each other; stated dimension: A's theory has world significance; A is a key figure.\nPlaintiff's statement convergence along that dimension; interaction frequency; days hospitalized; content of B's later self-review (according to the complaint).\nReport A's doubt whether he was crazy, and B's answer (according to the Wall Street Journal).\nEmpirical assumption along that dimension, B's affirming outputs had higher weights; impact assumption.\nCan be said with no external arrival, the loop stopping on its own: not guaranteed.\nCan be said this loop does not require B to be a self.\nCannot be derived whether and when there is intervention; the narrative content; why this user (Law of the Black Box).\n```\n\n### 8.2 Impression upon Impression among Many Selves: The Cuban Missile Crisis (1962)\n\n**1. [Cut](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c23)**\n\n- Scope: the Executive Committee of the US National Security Council (hereafter ExComm) and the Soviet leadership.\n- Time: around 14 to 28 October 1962.\n\n**2. Initial State**\n\n[Nodes](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c25):\n\n- Kennedy, Khrushchev, ExComm members. Marked with the [Second-Order Assumption](concepts.md#c03).\n- [Loop](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c31): ExComm itself, with the military arguing for air strikes inside it, and civilians arguing for blockade and diplomacy.\n- [Signal containers](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c26): photographs taken by U-2 reconnaissance aircraft, intelligence briefings, meeting recordings, letters between the two sides.\n\nInitial [arrival](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10): on 14 October, reconnaissance aircraft photographed the missile deployment in Cuba.\n\n**3. Two [Outputs](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) and the [Arrivals](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) Between Them**\n\n- **First [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) (22 October)**: in a televised address, Kennedy announced a blockade of Cuba (officially called a \"quarantine\"), effective on the 24th.\n- **[Arrivals](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) in between**:\n - 26 October: a softer private letter from Khrushchev, implying that a US pledge not to invade Cuba would be enough.\n - Morning of 27 October: a harder public broadcast, demanding the removal of US missiles in Turkey in exchange.\n - 27 October: a reconnaissance aircraft was shot down over Cuba and its pilot killed (\"Black Saturday\").\n- **Second [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) (evening of 27 October)**: after ExComm adjourned, Kennedy and a few officials held a separate small meeting and settled on two tracks. One was a formal reply accepting the terms implied in the letter of the 26th: the United States would not invade, in exchange for a verifiable Soviet withdrawal of the missiles. The other was conveyed orally by Robert Kennedy in person to Soviet ambassador Dobrynin: after the crisis, the United States would remove the missiles in Turkey, but this could only be a private understanding, not made public.\n\n**4. Changes in [Weights](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06)**\n\n- **Before the first [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)**: holding the same set of [signal containers](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c26), ExComm thought up [candidates](concepts.md#c18) that kept splitting, including at least air strikes, invasion, blockade and diplomatic pressure. Each faction was [coupled](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c36) to different institutions and fed back within its own [loop](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c31): this is its own [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) returning to its own [loop](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c31). The blockade was yielded through Kennedy, who held the power of final decision, and the [outputs](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) of his decision [arrived](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at the ExComm and the Soviet side with high [frequency](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c48) and over a wide range; this is the path of [power](concepts.md#c21) (6.4), not a convergence of cognition.\n- **Between the two [outputs](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)**: the first [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) also became [history](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13) [arriving](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at both sides; every [candidate](concepts.md#c18) afterwards was thought up on a [history](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13) of \"the blockade is already in place\". Kennedy's [impression](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c45) of Khrushchev was revised mainly when the other side's [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) arrived; at other times he could only re-[distinguish](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) material that had already [arrived](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10). The two mutually contradictory letters show that the [weights](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c06) on Khrushchev's side were not concentrated either.\n- **Path dependence**: once the shoot-down had [arrived](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at both sides, the [candidate](concepts.md#c18) \"pause military action\" faced a [history](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c13) in which \"US servicemen have already been killed\" was written.\n- **Second [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28)**: its two parts [arrived](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at different recipients. The public reply was placed in a [signal container](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c26) and [arrived](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at everyone; the oral assurance [arrived](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) only at Dobrynin, and through him [arrived](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) at Khrushchev. The circle of final decision was also narrower than the first time: not the whole ExComm but the small meeting afterwards. This too is the path of [power](concepts.md#c21).\n- **Stated dimensions**: along the dimension of outward [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28), ExComm showed [convergence](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c37); along the dimension of judgment of Soviet intentions, disagreement never disappeared to the end (empirical assumption).\n- **[Impact](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c47) assumption**: the shoot-down was a high-[discrepancy](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c49) [arrival](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10).\n\n**5. Outcome**\n\nOn 28 October, Khrushchev publicly announced the withdrawal of the missiles from Cuba; the United States publicly pledged not to invade Cuba, and privately removed the Jupiter missiles deployed in Turkey. Accounts by participants differ on how many on the US side knew of this private assurance: Bundy said nine, Sorensen said six; according to Dobrynin's cable that night, Robert Kennedy told him that apart from the two brothers, only two or three people knew.\n\n**6. What the Case Shows**\n\nThree things are most crucial in this example. First, convergence came from [power](concepts.md#c21), not from cognition: both outward [outputs](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) were settled by those holding the power of final decision, and disagreement in judgment did not thereby disappear (6.4). Second, speaking of [convergence](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c37) requires stating the dimension: the same ExComm showed [convergence](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c37) in [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) while disagreeing in judgment. Third, what the outcome connects to directly is the second [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28), not the blockade: after the blockade new [arrivals](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c10) came, and only then was the second [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) yielded. Saying \"the blockade forced the Soviets to back down\" while skipping the second [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) merges the two [outputs](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) into one.\n\nThe later interpretations are an example of lingering echoes:\n\n- Historical facts: the list of [candidates](concepts.md#c18), the two [outputs](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28), the two letters, the shoot-down, the secret exchange.\n- Changing interpretations: Robert Kennedy's memoir *Thirteen Days*, published in 1969, did not acknowledge an explicit exchange; only in 1989 did its editor, Sorensen, admit that he had edited the memoir to conceal that the removal of the Jupiter missiles was part of the deal. Later, as joint US–Soviet conferences were held and archives opened, research portrayed both sides as more improvised and more panicked than the official narrative. This is compatible with \"convergence is not guaranteed\", but does not prove \"convergence never occurs\". The official account maintained its convergence for more than twenty years through concealment, which is exactly what 7.4 says: convergence through [power](concepts.md#c21), not through approaching the truth. Even on how many people knew that night, the three participants' records differ (see step 5); each record is a [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) of its recorder.\n\nThe division of judgments is a historical fact. That the military and civilians held different positions is one possible reason, an empirical assumption, which this paper does not derive.\n\nStatements forbidden in this example:\n\n- \"Kennedy was calm and rational, and forced Khrushchev to back down.\" This takes one generation of historians' [distinction](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c18) as fact, and explains the outcome by essence.\n- \"The blockade was obviously right from the start.\" This is hindsight, writing [convergence](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c37) along the dimension of [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) as [convergence](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c37) along the dimension of judgment.\n- \"The outcome of the crisis was inevitable.\"\n- \"The blockade forced the Soviets to back down.\" Attributing the outcome directly to the blockade while skipping the second [output](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) merges the two [outputs](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c28) into one.\n\n**7. What Can Be Said and What Cannot Be Derived**\n\nWhat can be said: this analysis can also be applied to other group decisions with day-by-day records, such as the Bay of Pigs invasion and the July Crisis of 1914. Why judgments split and how official accounts converge belong to the content of the parties' positions and interests, and are left to later papers.\n\nWhat cannot be derived: why Kennedy first chose the blockade rather than air strikes; why the second time he chose two tracks rather than escalation; why Khrushchev backed down rather than escalating ([Law of the Black Box](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c25)).\n\n```text\nNodes Kennedy, Khrushchev, ExComm members (second-order assumption); loop: ExComm; signal containers: photographs, briefings, recordings, letters.\nOutput-1 the blockade announced on 22 October, through Kennedy's final decision.\nArrivals the softer letter of 26 October; the harder broadcast of 27 October; the reconnaissance aircraft shot down the same day.\nOutput-2 evening of 27 October: the formal reply (public) and the oral assurance through Robert Kennedy (private); settled by the small meeting afterwards.\nHistorical facts the list of candidates; the two outputs; the two letters; the shoot-down; the secret exchange; the division of judgments.\nRecollections number who knew of the private assurance: nine (Bundy), six (Sorensen), two or three apart from the brothers (Robert Kennedy's words as recorded in Dobrynin's cable).\nEmpirical assumption disagreement along the dimension of judgment did not disappear; the shoot-down was a high-discrepancy arrival; the different positions of military and civilians are a possible reason; the outputs of Kennedy's final decision arrived at the ExComm members and the Soviet leadership with high frequency and over a wide range, taking part in their weights.\nCan be said both outward outputs were yielded through power, not through convergence of judgment; the dimension of output converged, the dimension of judgment disagreed.\nCan be said what the outcome connects to directly is Output-2; attributing the outcome directly to Output-1 while skipping Output-2 merges two outputs into one.\nCannot be derived why Kennedy first chose blockade and then two tracks; why Khrushchev backed down (Law of the Black Box).\n```\n\n**Relation between the two cases**: 8.1 is two [presentations](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c04) [coupled](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c36) with each other; 8.2 is many [selves](../paper_37b3643a_dc40_4463_8b36_4f4594acd986/concepts.md#c19) with nested [loops](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c31). Both are applications of the same set of tools under different [cuts](../paper_b9df3b68_23ee_4839_965b_ed0e6b283ee6/concepts.md#c23).\n"}]}