diff --git "a/data/common-10-1250-test.json" "b/data/common-10-1250-test.json" new file mode 100644--- /dev/null +++ "b/data/common-10-1250-test.json" @@ -0,0 +1,277822 @@ +[ + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148061/0.wav", + "text": "主席好我想請一下陳建仁院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148061/1.wav", + "text": "陳院長請" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148061/2.wav", + "text": "院長好我想先看一段影片" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148061/3.wav", + "text": "先看一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148061/4.wav", + "text": "OK院長這是很多臺灣人現在的一個心理狀態" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148061/5.wav", + "text": "AIT主席羅森伯格這半年3次來臺灣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148061/6.wav", + "text": "坦白說創造過去歷史之最這麼頻繁" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148061/7.wav", + "text": "半年來3次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148061/8.wav", + "text": "那麼他在10月份的時候也特別提到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148061/9.wav", + "text": "美國不支持台獨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148061/10.wav", + "text": "我想請教一下院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148061/11.wav", + "text": "你是否反對臺獨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148061/12.wav", + "text": "請教院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148061/13.wav", + "text": "這問題要問你" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148061/14.wav", + "text": "我想臺灣是一個主權獨立的國家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148061/15.wav", + "text": "這個是一個事實" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148061/16.wav", + "text": "我們大家都很清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148061/17.wav", + "text": "OK這很官方的說法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148061/18.wav", + "text": "啦本席也可以理解" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148061/19.wav", + "text": "其實美國國防部在2023年10月19日" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148061/20.wav", + "text": "特別發布有關中華人民共和國軍事與安全發展報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148061/21.wav", + "text": "直接講到中共對臺採取軍事行動會有6個因素" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148061/22.wav", + "text": "第一個就是臺灣宣布獨立" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148061/23.wav", + "text": "第二個是未下定義的臺獨傾向" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148061/24.wav", + "text": "第三個就是臺灣內部動盪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148061/25.wav", + "text": "第四個是臺灣取得核武" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148061/26.wav", + "text": "第五個是無限期延後兩岸統一對話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148061/27.wav", + "text": "第六個是外國軍隊介入臺灣內部事務" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148061/28.wav", + "text": "這個是美國國防部的一個報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148061/29.wav", + "text": "所以我們幾乎可以做一個小小的結論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148061/30.wav", + "text": "只要臺獨就會引發軍事行動" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148061/31.wav", + "text": "如果兩岸不儘速展開對話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148061/32.wav", + "text": "情勢也會相對危險" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148061/33.wav", + "text": "我想說這是美國國防部的一個報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148061/34.wav", + "text": "我們來看一段小影片" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148061/35.wav", + "text": "這是我們現在的副總統賴清德" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148061/36.wav", + "text": "在2017年當行政院長時" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148061/37.wav", + "text": "在國會裡面直接回應委員的一個答復" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148061/38.wav", + "text": "復他強調他是主張臺灣獨立的政治工作者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148061/39.wav", + "text": "而且強調在任何職務都不會改變" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148061/40.wav", + "text": "這是他親口說的非常地具體" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148061/41.wav", + "text": "在2019年賴清德投入民進黨總統初選時" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148061/42.wav", + "text": "他是個務實的臺獨工作者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148061/43.wav", + "text": "這是從美國的一個國防部報告衍生過來的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148061/44.wav", + "text": "務實的臺獨工作者如果選上總統" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148061/45.wav", + "text": "是不是會給臺灣帶來戰爭" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148061/46.wav", + "text": "這是我們要思考的一個問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148061/47.wav", + "text": "義務役不用上戰場" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148061/48.wav", + "text": "義務役兵員仍以守備部隊為主" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148061/49.wav", + "text": "是否於主戰部隊服役" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148061/50.wav", + "text": "則看個人專業與意願" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148061/51.wav", + "text": "這是你說的嘛對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148061/52.wav", + "text": "可是站在你旁邊的邱國正部長不是這樣講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148061/53.wav", + "text": "他的講法是說面對少子化" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148061/54.wav", + "text": "國軍要想辦法調整義務役或役期較短的官兵" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148061/55.wav", + "text": "有些可以調到戰鬥支援部隊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148061/56.wav", + "text": "部長這也是你講的對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148061/57.wav", + "text": "我要跟委員講一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148061/58.wav", + "text": "一模一樣的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148061/59.wav", + "text": "守備部隊由義務役是主要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148061/60.wav", + "text": "但守備部隊的義務役人員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148061/61.wav", + "text": "有些有意願到主戰部隊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148061/62.wav", + "text": "好有意願" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148061/63.wav", + "text": "第二個不管主戰也好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148061/64.wav", + "text": "守備也好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148061/65.wav", + "text": "裡面有主戰部隊有戰鬥支援部隊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148061/66.wav", + "text": "在這裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148061/67.wav", + "text": "部長這個部分我來跟院長對話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148061/68.wav", + "text": "因為你這個部分基本上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148061/69.wav", + "text": "我看到媒體的訊息也是這樣子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148061/70.wav", + "text": "院長我想說的是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148061/71.wav", + "text": "國防部長的說法跟你其實有一點差異" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148061/72.wav", + "text": "不適合斷章取義" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148061/73.wav", + "text": "你應該看到前後的文章以後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148061/74.wav", + "text": "理解" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148061/75.wav", + "text": "不然斷章取義的話就變成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148061/76.wav", + "text": "理解其實我知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148061/77.wav", + "text": "我問這個問題一定會有很多發言" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148061/78.wav", + "text": "去強調前提等等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148061/79.wav", + "text": "我講一個最簡單的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148061/80.wav", + "text": "院長如果發生戰爭義務役" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148061/81.wav", + "text": "到底會不會上戰場" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148061/82.wav", + "text": "簡單回復好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148061/83.wav", + "text": "一旦發生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148061/84.wav", + "text": "是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148061/85.wav", + "text": "一旦有��樣破壞" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148061/86.wav", + "text": "實際上臺灣這麼小的一塊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148061/87.wav", + "text": "土地並沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148061/88.wav", + "text": "所謂的前線跟" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148061/89.wav", + "text": "後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148061/90.wav", + "text": "所以之前不斷在說義務役不用上戰場" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148061/91.wav", + "text": "這個說法其實是有些問題的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148061/92.wav", + "text": "外交及國防委員會的國防部報告中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148061/93.wav", + "text": "義務役人力分發規劃裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148061/94.wav", + "text": "也明文提到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148061/95.wav", + "text": "義務役役男優先補充" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148061/96.wav", + "text": "守備部隊主戰部隊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148061/97.wav", + "text": "次之次之就表示還是會有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148061/98.wav", + "text": "剛剛院長回答這個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148061/99.wav", + "text": "我覺得我們也聽得進去大部分國人也聽得進去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148061/100.wav", + "text": "因為你說臺灣小真的發生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148061/101.wav", + "text": "戰事的時候大家都跑不掉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148061/102.wav", + "text": "對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148061/103.wav", + "text": "我覺得相對務實" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148061/104.wav", + "text": "再加上美方的壓力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148061/105.wav", + "text": "所以延長了兵役" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148061/106.wav", + "text": "現在又刻意淡化" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148061/107.wav", + "text": "兩岸兵凶戰危的情況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148061/108.wav", + "text": "表示一年期的役男" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148061/109.wav", + "text": "不會分發到主戰部隊也不會上戰場" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148061/110.wav", + "text": "我覺得這樣的說法跟你剛才講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148061/111.wav", + "text": "的有點不太一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148061/112.wav", + "text": "不過你剛才講的方式我可以接受" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148061/113.wav", + "text": "臺灣小真的發生衝突" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148061/114.wav", + "text": "的話大家都跑不掉都會上戰場" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148061/115.wav", + "text": "兩岸兵凶戰危是你講的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148061/116.wav", + "text": "這個其實是美國" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148061/117.wav", + "text": "還有很多國外媒體都這麼講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148061/118.wav", + "text": "不是只有我講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148061/119.wav", + "text": "很多國外的研究者也都是這麼講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148061/120.wav", + "text": "還是說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148061/121.wav", + "text": "院長沒有覺得是這樣的情況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148061/122.wav", + "text": "那是你現在的看法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148061/123.wav", + "text": "但至少在國外他們都覺得臺灣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148061/124.wav", + "text": "是目前國際當中非常具有衝突可能性的地方" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148061/125.wav", + "text": "\n我在想說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148061/126.wav", + "text": "大家可能都跑不掉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148061/127.wav", + "text": "因為臺灣太小了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148061/128.wav", + "text": "我們總要給國軍最好的裝備對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148061/129.wav", + "text": "這個是最基本的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148061/130.wav", + "text": "頭盔跟防彈背心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148061/131.wav", + "text": "這是最基本的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148061/132.wav", + "text": "在所有的戰鬥裝備當中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148061/133.wav", + "text": "我覺得這些是最基本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148061/134.wav", + "text": "那麼在今年3月的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148061/135.wav", + "text": "本席曾經問過頭盔的一個問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148061/136.wav", + "text": "就凹掉了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148061/137.wav", + "text": "那凹掉的角度很大" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148061/138.wav", + "text": "基本上一定會傷到腦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148061/139.wav", + "text": "當時部長有特別提到說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148061/140.wav", + "text": "我們有一定的標準" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148061/141.wav", + "text": "本席也尊重" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148061/142.wav", + "text": "肯定要有一定的標準" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148061/143.wav", + "text": "否則怎麼去採購這些東西呢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148061/144.wav", + "text": "民進黨籍的新北市議員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148061/145.wav", + "text": "他在美國" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148061/146.wav", + "text": "或者是其他的地方" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148061/147.wav", + "text": "我們不曉得到底在哪裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148061/148.wav", + "text": "他就直接" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148061/149.wav", + "text": "發表了這樣的一個FB文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148061/150.wav", + "text": "上面有三個洞" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148061/151.wav", + "text": "小洞" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148061/152.wav", + "text": "這是他的防彈背心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148061/153.wav", + "text": "他的防彈背心直接顯示" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148061/154.wav", + "text": "從防彈背心抽出來的抗彈板" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148061/155.wav", + "text": "它的防護等級是NIJ" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148061/156.wav", + "text": "Ⅲ級國軍用的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148061/157.wav", + "text": "他怎麼樣拿到這個東西" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148061/158.wav", + "text": "拿到國外去測試我們不瞭解" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148061/159.wav", + "text": "我不知道國防部有沒有去追查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148061/160.wav", + "text": "那我要講的狀態是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148061/161.wav", + "text": "這個部分是他背後的狀態" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148061/162.wav", + "text": "這三個洞之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148061/163.wav", + "text": "其實坦白說傷得挺重的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148061/164.wav", + "text": "這個就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148061/165.wav", + "text": "大家都關心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148061/166.wav", + "text": "品質的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148061/167.wav", + "text": "包括在野黨的民意代表" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148061/168.wav", + "text": "也是在關心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148061/169.wav", + "text": "我們也關心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148061/170.wav", + "text": "這個事情發生之後國防部第二天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148061/171.wav", + "text": "馬上就發了一個新聞稿" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148061/172.wav", + "text": "國防部的新聞稿當中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148061/173.wav", + "text": "很清楚地提到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148061/174.wav", + "text": "軍備局205廠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148061/175.wav", + "text": "產製抗彈板" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148061/176.wav", + "text": "曾於民國105年送美國" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148061/177.wav", + "text": "切斯比克實驗室" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148061/178.wav", + "text": "依NIJⅢ級標準" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148061/179.wav", + "text": "測試合格" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148061/180.wav", + "text": "符合國際標準" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148061/181.wav", + "text": "後續批次量產產品" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148061/182.wav", + "text": "由通過全國認證基金會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148061/183.wav", + "text": "與國際實驗室同等級之規格" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148061/184.wav", + "text": "鑑測中心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148061/185.wav", + "text": "執行測試" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148061/186.wav", + "text": "合格後始撥發官兵使用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148061/187.wav", + "text": "所以邱部長是這樣的狀態嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148061/188.wav", + "text": "實際狀態是這樣子嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148061/189.wav", + "text": "可能在民國105年之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148061/190.wav", + "text": "我們所有國軍" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148061/191.wav", + "text": "防彈背心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148061/192.wav", + "text": "基本上都有經過TAF的認證" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148061/193.wav", + "text": "一定會有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148061/194.wav", + "text": "因為當初建案的時候就有規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148061/195.wav", + "text": "這個要經過多大的抗擊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148061/196.wav", + "text": "多少彈藥多少公釐多遠距離" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148061/197.wav", + "text": "我們是按照這一批" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148061/198.wav", + "text": "標準規定在做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148061/199.wav", + "text": "而且經過認證" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148061/200.wav", + "text": "假如說後面有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148061/201.wav", + "text": "就是因為我們關心這些軍品的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148061/202.wav", + "text": "品質問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148061/203.wav", + "text": "也關心國軍的生命安危" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148061/204.wav", + "text": "如果真的不小心發生戰端" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148061/205.wav", + "text": "就像院長講如果不小心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148061/206.wav", + "text": "全臺灣大家都跑不掉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148061/207.wav", + "text": "大家都會上戰場" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148061/208.wav", + "text": "所以我們就索資了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148061/209.wav", + "text": "索資之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148061/210.wav", + "text": "國防部給了我們這個資料" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148061/211.wav", + "text": "他是用密件" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148061/212.wav", + "text": "給我們的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148061/213.wav", + "text": "檢測的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148061/214.wav", + "text": "全部是空白" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148061/215.wav", + "text": "的所有的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148061/216.wav", + "text": "查核項目" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148061/217.wav", + "text": "狀況都是空白的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148061/218.wav", + "text": "他給我的狀態其實都是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148061/219.wav", + "text": "我們採購公開資訊裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148061/220.wav", + "text": "有的東西" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148061/221.wav", + "text": "地址在哪裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148061/222.wav", + "text": "基本上都是公開資料有的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148061/223.wav", + "text": "那我就不太知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148061/224.wav", + "text": "為什麼國防部給了我們一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148061/225.wav", + "text": "查詢資料" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148061/226.wav", + "text": "我們要索資的時候給我們密件" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148061/227.wav", + "text": "是空白的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148061/228.wav", + "text": "那空白需要索資嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148061/229.wav", + "text": "如果給我們的只是公開資料" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148061/230.wav", + "text": "公開資料需要用密件嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148061/231.wav", + "text": "我跟委員報告有時候它空白" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148061/232.wav", + "text": "不是因為他不給" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148061/233.wav", + "text": "而是他口頭跟您做報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148061/234.wav", + "text": "或跟辦公室同仁" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148061/235.wav", + "text": "這裡面為什麼我要用這個機密的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148061/236.wav", + "text": "哪怕是外面公開" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148061/237.wav", + "text": "但我們國防部出手了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148061/238.wav", + "text": "我們不能講這是公開" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148061/239.wav", + "text": "因為這裡為了要嚴謹起見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148061/240.wav", + "text": "每樣資料只要經過國防部出手" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148061/241.wav", + "text": "的我們發給了誰" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148061/242.wav", + "text": "我們都要登記的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148061/243.wav", + "text": "不管公開與否" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148061/244.wav", + "text": "密件給了以後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148061/245.wav", + "text": "我們一定會派人去做說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148061/246.wav", + "text": "一定會用口頭來做一個補" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148061/247.wav", + "text": "那我們就等著你們來做說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148061/248.wav", + "text": "我想問一下院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148061/249.wav", + "text": "蔡英文總統" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148061/250.wav", + "text": "要跟巴拉圭建立一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148061/251.wav", + "text": "中南美洲最好的科技大學" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148061/252.wav", + "text": "我知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148061/253.wav", + "text": "已經有學生在訓練" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148061/254.wav", + "text": "是已經有學生在念了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148061/255.wav", + "text": "臺巴科大到目前其實已經運作五年了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148061/256.wav", + "text": "他們的校舍" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148061/257.wav", + "text": "有沒有開始興建" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148061/258.wav", + "text": "還沒" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148061/259.wav", + "text": "他們已經有學生畢業了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148061/260.wav", + "text": "我知道有學生畢業" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148061/261.wav", + "text": "我們總統還去參加了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148061/262.wav", + "text": "我現在問的是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148061/263.wav", + "text": "有沒有去蓋這個學校" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148061/264.wav", + "text": "這個學校是他們自己要蓋的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148061/265.wav", + "text": "他們現在用臨時的校舍" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148061/266.wav", + "text": "他們現在用臨時校舍" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148061/267.wav", + "text": "在整個教育委員會裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148061/268.wav", + "text": "關心這件事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148061/269.wav", + "text": "為什麼因為本席主張" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148061/270.wav", + "text": "臺灣的教育要走向國際" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148061/271.wav", + "text": "這可以解決臺灣現在教育圈" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148061/272.wav", + "text": "面臨的一個問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148061/273.wav", + "text": "包括少子化包括私校退場等等的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148061/274.wav", + "text": "所以本席是主張" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148061/275.wav", + "text": "臺灣的教育走向國際化" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148061/276.wav", + "text": "可是我們在問這個問題的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148061/277.wav", + "text": "我很詫異的是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148061/278.wav", + "text": "外交部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148061/279.wav", + "text": "竟然用新聞稿" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148061/280.wav", + "text": "我們在打擊友邦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148061/281.wav", + "text": "在污衊外交部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148061/282.wav", + "text": "臺灣教育走向國際的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148061/283.wav", + "text": "外交部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148061/284.wav", + "text": "竟然不讓我們去關心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148061/285.wav", + "text": "我覺得很疑惑" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148061/286.wav", + "text": "院長你知道這個情況嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148061/287.wav", + "text": "我這邊說明一下這是委員在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148061/288.wav", + "text": "10月11日" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148061/289.wav", + "text": "發函到我們外交部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148061/290.wav", + "text": "希望我們外交部派員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148061/291.wav", + "text": "去委員的辦公室" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148061/292.wav", + "text": "去做說明我們已經選派了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148061/293.wav", + "text": "可是在10月11日的晚上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148061/294.wav", + "text": "委員就在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148061/295.wav", + "text": "臉書上面發" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148061/296.wav", + "text": "表一篇文章來攻擊外交部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148061/297.wav", + "text": "部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148061/298.wav", + "text": "我要講的是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148061/299.wav", + "text": "外交部的決算書" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148061/300.wav", + "text": "從2018年到2022年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148061/301.wav", + "text": "已經支付3.36億元" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148061/302.wav", + "text": "作為臺巴科技大學的規劃跟設立的經費" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148061/303.wav", + "text": "可是現在的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148061/304.wav", + "text": "我們去關心這樣的一個預算有錯嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148061/305.wav", + "text": "我在想說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148061/306.wav", + "text": "它花了臺灣納稅人的錢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148061/307.wav", + "text": "我們關心這個錢怎麼去用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148061/308.wav", + "text": "會有錯嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148061/309.wav", + "text": "好謝謝鄭委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148061/310.wav", + "text": "接下來請費委員鴻泰質詢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148060/0.wav", + "text": "謝謝主席" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148060/1.wav", + "text": "本席邀請行政院陳建仁院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148060/2.wav", + "text": "在這裡嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148060/3.wav", + "text": "林委員午安" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148060/4.wav", + "text": "院長好院長午安" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148060/5.wav", + "text": "院長在這個月初" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148060/6.wav", + "text": "本席有看到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148060/7.wav", + "text": "我們國安局" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148060/8.wav", + "text": "局長接受" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148060/9.wav", + "text": "媒體訪問的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148060/10.wav", + "text": "媒體提問" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148060/11.wav", + "text": "中國介入臺灣選舉的可能方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148060/12.wav", + "text": "包括假訊息" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148060/13.wav", + "text": "軍事施壓外交脅迫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148060/14.wav", + "text": "當時蔡局長有提到一點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148060/15.wav", + "text": "是過去從來沒有的新樣態" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148060/16.wav", + "text": "就是所謂的假民調" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148060/17.wav", + "text": "我想瞭解" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148060/18.wav", + "text": "沒有提問" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148060/19.wav", + "text": "局長主動提出有這樣一個樣態" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148060/20.wav", + "text": "也就是所謂的假民調" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148060/21.wav", + "text": "既然局長會主動提出" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148060/22.wav", + "text": "有所謂的假民調" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148060/23.wav", + "text": "是國安單位有注意到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148060/24.wav", + "text": "會跟一些民調公關公司合作" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148060/25.wav", + "text": "在進行假民調" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148060/26.wav", + "text": "請問" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148060/27.wav", + "text": "我們是不是已經有相當的掌握" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148060/28.wav", + "text": "有沒有一些具體事證或者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148060/29.wav", + "text": "有些個案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148060/30.wav", + "text": "是否已經移請相關的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148060/31.wav", + "text": "司法單位調查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148060/32.wav", + "text": "蔡局長有這樣的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148060/33.wav", + "text": "他在提醒我們大家要注意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148060/34.wav", + "text": "有這些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148060/35.wav", + "text": "我們應該要讓" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148060/36.wav", + "text": "全民都能夠提高警覺" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148060/37.wav", + "text": "假消息或假民調" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148060/38.wav", + "text": "的識讀力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148060/39.wav", + "text": "應該要增加" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148060/40.wav", + "text": "其實假民調" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148060/41.wav", + "text": "假訊息的一種" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148060/42.wav", + "text": "所謂境外勢力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148060/43.wav", + "text": "干預我國選舉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148060/44.wav", + "text": "第一是境外資金介入選舉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148060/45.wav", + "text": "第三是散布假訊息" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148060/46.wav", + "text": "我認為假民調就是其中之一" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148060/47.wav", + "text": "但是院長知不知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148060/48.wav", + "text": "其實我國對於假民調是有法律管轄" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148060/49.wav", + "text": "的我們的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148060/50.wav", + "text": "總統副總統選舉罷免法第52條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148060/51.wav", + "text": "以及公職人員選罷法第53條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148060/52.wav", + "text": "自從選舉公告以後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148060/53.wav", + "text": "中選會在這次總統大選" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148060/54.wav", + "text": "的單位都必須要同時公布" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148060/55.wav", + "text": "布是哪個單位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148060/56.wav", + "text": "負責調查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148060/57.wav", + "text": "主持人是誰辦理時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148060/58.wav", + "text": "抽樣方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148060/59.wav", + "text": "母體數目樣本數" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148060/60.wav", + "text": "誤差值以及" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148060/61.wav", + "text": "經費來源" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148060/62.wav", + "text": "如果違反的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148060/63.wav", + "text": "可以罰100萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148060/64.wav", + "text": "有這樣的法律規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148060/65.wav", + "text": "被處罰" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148060/66.wav", + "text": "的有法不執行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148060/67.wav", + "text": "其實我們的法律規範" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148060/68.wav", + "text": "很清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148060/69.wav", + "text": "\n這次總統大選" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148060/70.wav", + "text": "有公布民調的單位我看了好幾十個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148060/71.wav", + "text": "大部分的大型媒體" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148060/72.wav", + "text": "經常性公布民調的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148060/73.wav", + "text": "機構都會公布附上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148060/74.wav", + "text": "前七項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148060/75.wav", + "text": "經費來源我看了幾十份" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148060/76.wav", + "text": "有公布經費來源" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148060/77.wav", + "text": "其他的都沒有公布" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148060/78.wav", + "text": "布為什麼法律要求" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148060/79.wav", + "text": "要公布你的經費來源" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148060/80.wav", + "text": "因為只要你公布經費來源" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148060/81.wav", + "text": "就要負起責任" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148060/82.wav", + "text": "你就不能亂寫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148060/83.wav", + "text": "亂寫就是造假" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148060/84.wav", + "text": "但從來沒有在認真執行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148060/85.wav", + "text": "所以我希望相關單位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148060/86.wav", + "text": "要對於有在發布民調單位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148060/87.wav", + "text": "的既然我們法律規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148060/88.wav", + "text": "公布民調" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148060/89.wav", + "text": "都必須同時要敘" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148060/90.wav", + "text": "寫清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148060/91.wav", + "text": "負責調查的單位主持人辦理時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148060/92.wav", + "text": "抽樣方式母體數樣本數" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148060/93.wav", + "text": "誤差值以及經費來源" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148060/94.wav", + "text": "那麼我們就應該要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148060/95.wav", + "text": "認真執行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148060/96.wav", + "text": "國安單位都已經提出警告了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148060/97.wav", + "text": "我認為我們執法單位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148060/98.wav", + "text": "這裡是不是應該要有所動作" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148060/99.wav", + "text": "來跟有關的這些民調" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148060/100.wav", + "text": "公司來做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148060/101.wav", + "text": "說明跟他們提出這個要求" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148060/102.wav", + "text": "只要有人受處罰" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148060/103.wav", + "text": "其他都會守法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148060/104.wav", + "text": "影響到我們選舉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148060/105.wav", + "text": "的它有講出" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148060/106.wav", + "text": "目前大概有六大樣態" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148060/107.wav", + "text": "第一個就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148060/108.wav", + "text": "中國介選運用臺商的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148060/109.wav", + "text": "政治獻金" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148060/110.wav", + "text": "來支援特定參選" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148060/111.wav", + "text": "人這是法務部公布的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148060/112.wav", + "text": "在法務部的報告裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148060/113.wav", + "text": "的第二個它說中國會運用宮廟的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148060/114.wav", + "text": "慈善活動金援來綁樁" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148060/115.wav", + "text": "委託行銷公司" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148060/116.wav", + "text": "來進行宣傳" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148060/117.wav", + "text": "第四它會衝高頻道的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148060/118.wav", + "text": "點擊量來金援特定的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148060/119.wav", + "text": "候選人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148060/120.wav", + "text": "第五就是地下通匯的方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148060/121.wav", + "text": "來支援" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148060/122.wav", + "text": "特定的參選人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148060/123.wav", + "text": "第六就是用虛擬貨幣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148060/124.wav", + "text": "數位貨幣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148060/125.wav", + "text": "來金援特定參選人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148060/126.wav", + "text": "大概有這六大樣態" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148060/127.wav", + "text": "我想跟院長討論一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148060/128.wav", + "text": "衝高頻道點擊量" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148060/129.wav", + "text": "來金援特定參選" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148060/130.wav", + "text": "其實有很多種" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148060/131.wav", + "text": "有一種就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148060/132.wav", + "text": "一些網紅或者一些所謂的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148060/133.wav", + "text": "尤其像這次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148060/134.wav", + "text": "假網軍" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148060/135.wav", + "text": "他散布假訊息" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148060/136.wav", + "text": "真網軍假訊息" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148060/137.wav", + "text": "這些人的流量非常高" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148060/138.wav", + "text": "流量高當然就代表錢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148060/139.wav", + "text": "院長知道這個事情嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148060/140.wav", + "text": "某個網紅" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148060/141.wav", + "text": "我覺得你節目做得好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148060/142.wav", + "text": "我就捐款給你" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148060/143.wav", + "text": "那他怎麼去捐款" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148060/144.wav", + "text": "相關單位也有提到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148060/145.wav", + "text": "就是金流的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148060/146.wav", + "text": "如果這些錢是來自" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148060/147.wav", + "text": "境外勢力或是來自" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148060/148.wav", + "text": "敵對國家或來自中國" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148060/149.wav", + "text": "那它金援的手段" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148060/150.wav", + "text": "就有很多種" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148060/151.wav", + "text": "如果它是分散式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148060/152.wav", + "text": "就小筆" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148060/153.wav", + "text": "很難去查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148060/154.wav", + "text": "這種狀況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148060/155.wav", + "text": "我不曉得我們相關單位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148060/156.wav", + "text": "有沒有對策或者是有沒有注意到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148060/157.wav", + "text": "一些透過這種方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148060/158.wav", + "text": "來介入臺灣選舉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148060/159.wav", + "text": "目前我舉幾個例子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148060/160.wav", + "text": "\n院長你知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148060/161.wav", + "text": "大概我們臺灣的前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148060/162.wav", + "text": "20個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148060/163.wav", + "text": "網站" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148060/164.wav", + "text": "收到最多捐款的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148060/165.wav", + "text": "前20個裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148060/166.wav", + "text": "大概只有一個綠的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148060/167.wav", + "text": "罵越多的收到的錢越多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148060/168.wav", + "text": "不是說政府不能罵" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148060/169.wav", + "text": "啦你可以批評" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148060/170.wav", + "text": "但是藍綠在臺灣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148060/171.wav", + "text": "臺灣基本上是兩黨政治" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148060/172.wav", + "text": "嘛至少藍綠有一定的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148060/173.wav", + "text": "合理比例才對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148060/174.wav", + "text": "前20名裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148060/175.wav", + "text": "偶爾出現一個綠的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148060/176.wav", + "text": "那是一隻貓就四叉貓" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148060/177.wav", + "text": "啦那也是很出名" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148060/178.wav", + "text": "但是他經常被甩到20名外" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148060/179.wav", + "text": "偶爾才進來20名內" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148060/180.wav", + "text": "其他全部是藍的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148060/181.wav", + "text": "都是罵政府" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148060/182.wav", + "text": "第一名一年收五百零多萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148060/183.wav", + "text": "好幾個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148060/184.wav", + "text": "年收入都兩百萬的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148060/185.wav", + "text": "的這樣子極度地" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148060/186.wav", + "text": "偏向某一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148060/187.wav", + "text": "政黨色彩" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148060/188.wav", + "text": "我認為這不是一個正常民主國家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148060/189.wav", + "text": "正常的存在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148060/190.wav", + "text": "院長你知不知道這種狀況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148060/191.wav", + "text": "你有什麼看法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148060/192.wav", + "text": "我有看過這樣的狀況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148060/193.wav", + "text": "相關的左邊的這個數字我也" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148060/194.wav", + "text": "也有看過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148060/195.wav", + "text": "確實" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148060/196.wav", + "text": "光譜有集中的現象" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148060/197.wav", + "text": "讓我們也需要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148060/198.wav", + "text": "來加強網路的巡邏" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148060/199.wav", + "text": "然後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148060/200.wav", + "text": "更重要的是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148060/201.wav", + "text": "如果有播放了一些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148060/202.wav", + "text": "錯假消息的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148060/203.wav", + "text": "還有一種狀況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148060/204.wav", + "text": "他們會去影響網路的這些創作者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148060/205.wav", + "text": "第一個這些創作者一定希望有很多流量" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148060/206.wav", + "text": "嘛這必然" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148060/207.wav", + "text": "嘛帶來了觀眾因為你有流量" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148060/208.wav", + "text": "就會提高你的收入" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148060/209.wav", + "text": "自然而然" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148060/210.wav", + "text": "中共也不必接觸這些人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148060/211.wav", + "text": "不必接觸這些網紅" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148060/212.wav", + "text": "因為你只要做的節目是罵政府的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148060/213.wav", + "text": "罵民進黨的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148060/214.wav", + "text": "你就會收到很多的捐款" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148060/215.wav", + "text": "嘛自然而然" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148060/216.wav", + "text": "透過這樣的模式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148060/217.wav", + "text": "就會影響你講話的一個方向" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148060/218.wav", + "text": "它就可以影響" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148060/219.wav", + "text": "引導你" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148060/220.wav", + "text": "要怎樣去做節目" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148060/221.wav", + "text": "奇怪你的流量就會高奇怪你就會收到很多錢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148060/222.wav", + "text": "變成認知作戰的一個方法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148060/223.wav", + "text": "這是一個方法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148060/224.wav", + "text": "這些錢怎麼來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148060/225.wav", + "text": "都是正常的嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148060/226.wav", + "text": "為什麼有人可以一年收好幾百萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148060/227.wav", + "text": "為什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148060/228.wav", + "text": "怎麼捐款怎麼do" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148060/229.wav", + "text": "e大概有分三種" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148060/230.wav", + "text": "這三個方式讓你捐款" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148060/231.wav", + "text": "一個是微信" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148060/232.wav", + "text": "第二個是ECPay" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148060/233.wav", + "text": "（綠��支付）這是臺灣的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148060/234.wav", + "text": "第三就是PayPal" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148060/235.wav", + "text": "這是世界性的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148060/236.wav", + "text": "你只要有個姓名有個手機號碼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148060/237.wav", + "text": "你就可以do" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148060/238.wav", + "text": "\n臺灣有發生一個很奇怪的現象" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148060/239.wav", + "text": "不知道院長有沒有注意到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148060/240.wav", + "text": "今年6月" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148060/241.wav", + "text": "我們的司法單位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148060/242.wav", + "text": "現在陸客不能來臺灣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148060/243.wav", + "text": "是不是我們沒有開放" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148060/244.wav", + "text": "今年1月到3月" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148060/245.wav", + "text": "陸客來臺大概" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148060/246.wav", + "text": "不到3萬個人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148060/247.wav", + "text": "就算3萬好了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148060/248.wav", + "text": "超過100萬個門號" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148060/249.wav", + "text": "喔3萬個人需要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148060/250.wav", + "text": "100萬個門號嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148060/251.wav", + "text": "這顯不正常" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148060/252.wav", + "text": "極不可能" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148060/253.wav", + "text": "這是NCC擺爛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148060/254.wav", + "text": "源頭沒有管好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148060/255.wav", + "text": "電信公司亂賣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148060/256.wav", + "text": "我當時查到的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148060/257.wav", + "text": "有跟相關單位提出質詢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148060/258.wav", + "text": "後來我發現" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148060/259.wav", + "text": "不只用在詐騙" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148060/260.wav", + "text": "它也可以介入臺灣的選舉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148060/261.wav", + "text": "你知道這100萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148060/262.wav", + "text": "像政治捐款也可以用這個門號來捐" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148060/263.wav", + "text": "你也查不出來是誰" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148060/264.wav", + "text": "臺灣大概是世界公認" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148060/265.wav", + "text": "受到境外介入選舉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148060/266.wav", + "text": "尤其來自中國介入選舉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148060/267.wav", + "text": "最嚴重的地方" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148060/268.wav", + "text": "有做相關的一個措施" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148060/269.wav", + "text": "政府準備如何應付這樣的一個狀況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148060/270.wav", + "text": "謝謝委員的提醒" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148060/271.wav", + "text": "您今天所講的這些東西" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148060/272.wav", + "text": "都相當重要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148060/273.wav", + "text": "對於臺灣的自由民主" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148060/274.wav", + "text": "是一個很大的傷害" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148060/275.wav", + "text": "而且查辦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148060/276.wav", + "text": "漏洞" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148060/277.wav", + "text": "止境外勢力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148060/278.wav", + "text": "第一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148060/279.wav", + "text": "臺灣是面對中國威脅" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148060/280.wav", + "text": "最嚴重的地方" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148060/281.wav", + "text": "基本上我們應該是一個危機社會才對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148060/282.wav", + "text": "結果臺灣不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148060/283.wav", + "text": "從民間到官方" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148060/284.wav", + "text": "都非常缺乏這樣的危機感" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148060/285.wav", + "text": "對要有危機意識" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148060/286.wav", + "text": "3萬個陸客申請了100萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148060/287.wav", + "text": "5,000個門號" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148060/288.wav", + "text": "這怎麼可能" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148060/289.wav", + "text": "你要知道P2P的第三方支付" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148060/290.wav", + "text": "基本上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148060/291.wav", + "text": "贊助者只要點進去付款" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148060/292.wav", + "text": "流程" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148060/293.wav", + "text": "只要有個手機號碼就可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148060/294.wav", + "text": "目前我們看到的狀況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148060/295.wav", + "text": "是只要是某個色彩的藍色的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148060/296.wav", + "text": "只要是罵政府的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148060/297.wav", + "text": "罵民進黨的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148060/298.wav", + "text": "只要批判政府" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148060/299.wav", + "text": "就可以收到很多捐款" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148060/300.wav", + "text": "我舉的是前20名" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148060/301.wav", + "text": "我再跟院長講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148060/302.wav", + "text": "我後來想一想" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148060/303.wav", + "text": "不然我來看前30名" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148060/304.wav", + "text": "前40名" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148060/305.wav", + "text": "前50名" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148060/306.wav", + "text": "還是都藍" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148060/307.wav", + "text": "政府罵陳建仁就可以收到捐款" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148060/308.wav", + "text": "這怎麼可能" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148060/309.wav", + "text": "臺灣是個民主多元的社會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148060/310.wav", + "text": "怎麼可能只有一言堂" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148060/311.wav", + "text": "這麼多的錢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148060/312.wav", + "text": "如果你把第1名到第50名加起來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148060/313.wav", + "text": "我只加第1名到第7名就100多萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148060/314.wav", + "text": "了一堆都是年收入200萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148060/315.wav", + "text": "的幾百萬的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148060/316.wav", + "text": "所以我當時以為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148060/317.wav", + "text": "這些一百萬個門號的用途" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148060/318.wav", + "text": "有解答了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148060/319.wav", + "text": "它甚至可能" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148060/320.wav", + "text": "用來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148060/321.wav", + "text": "介入臺灣的選舉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148060/322.wav", + "text": "或者說至少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148060/323.wav", + "text": "介入影響臺灣目前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148060/324.wav", + "text": "社群平臺上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148060/325.wav", + "text": "很多輿論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148060/326.wav", + "text": "或者很多人���作節目的方向走向" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148060/327.wav", + "text": "如果是惡意的我認為絕對有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148060/328.wav", + "text": "我們現在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148060/329.wav", + "text": "政府對於這種" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148060/330.wav", + "text": "洗錢防制法大概都不管這種" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148060/331.wav", + "text": "然後金額很小" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148060/332.wav", + "text": "它每一筆都不會捐很多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148060/333.wav", + "text": "為什麼需要那麼多門號" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148060/334.wav", + "text": "donate的金額都很小" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148060/335.wav", + "text": "路透社在今年6月" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148060/336.wav", + "text": "有一份關於臺灣大選" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148060/337.wav", + "text": "假訊息的報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148060/338.wav", + "text": "路透社也引述我們臺灣內部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148060/339.wav", + "text": "鼓勵支持候選人設立微信帳號" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148060/340.wav", + "text": "並透過微信的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148060/341.wav", + "text": "付款模式來提供金援" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148060/342.wav", + "text": "這是另外一種金流" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148060/343.wav", + "text": "嘛可是微信捐的錢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148060/344.wav", + "text": "不能直接轉換為臺幣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148060/345.wav", + "text": "臺灣的銀行不收" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148060/346.wav", + "text": "地下匯兌" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148060/347.wav", + "text": "最近我們抓到的地下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148060/348.wav", + "text": "\n接下來請鄭委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148060/349.wav", + "text": "正鈐質詢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148059/0.wav", + "text": "院長請" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148059/1.wav", + "text": "院長我們要支持國軍" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148059/2.wav", + "text": "要鼓舞軍人的士氣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148059/3.wav", + "text": "所以有幾件事情本席" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148059/4.wav", + "text": "一直在爭取" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148059/5.wav", + "text": "今天是我在任內最後一個會期的質詢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148059/6.wav", + "text": "我要有始有終" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148059/7.wav", + "text": "也要替軍人表達他們的心聲" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148059/8.wav", + "text": "同時也要請教" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148059/9.wav", + "text": "號稱溫暖內閣的陳院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148059/10.wav", + "text": "你是否願意讓人民感到溫暖" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148059/11.wav", + "text": "第一件事情就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148059/12.wav", + "text": "恢復退役上校子女的教育補助" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148059/13.wav", + "text": "主計長其實也不反對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148059/14.wav", + "text": "因為錢也不多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148059/15.wav", + "text": "一年只有1.4億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148059/16.wav", + "text": "我曾經質詢的蘇貞昌院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148059/17.wav", + "text": "說要召集相關部會討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148059/18.wav", + "text": "蔡政府的3位國防部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148059/19.wav", + "text": "他們都贊成恢復" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148059/20.wav", + "text": "但是有一位人事總長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148059/21.wav", + "text": "這麼一個人的反對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148059/22.wav", + "text": "這件事情就卡住了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148059/23.wav", + "text": "換句話說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148059/24.wav", + "text": "3位國防部長的力量" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148059/25.wav", + "text": "竟然不如一位人事總長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148059/26.wav", + "text": "對保家衛國的軍人來說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148059/27.wav", + "text": "真的是情何以堪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148059/28.wav", + "text": "\n馮世寬主委也向總統報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148059/29.wav", + "text": "他說總統都沒有反對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148059/30.wav", + "text": "啊院長你可不可以裁定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148059/31.wav", + "text": "恢復退役上校的子女教育補助" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148059/32.wav", + "text": "其實錢都不多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148059/33.wav", + "text": "但意義卻非常地大" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148059/34.wav", + "text": "升上校本來就是一種榮譽" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148059/35.wav", + "text": "就變成是一種懲罰了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148059/36.wav", + "text": "取消他們的子女教育補助" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148059/37.wav", + "text": "就是不公不義嘛對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148059/38.wav", + "text": "這是不好的作法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148059/39.wav", + "text": "院長認為呢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148059/40.wav", + "text": "我想退役上校子女教育補助費" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148059/41.wav", + "text": "費的部分要分成兩個段落來看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148059/42.wav", + "text": "第一個就是這個上校的退休金是多少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148059/43.wav", + "text": "第二個就是他們現在的子女教育補助費" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148059/44.wav", + "text": "是怎麼發放" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148059/45.wav", + "text": "退伍軍人不管是哪一個階級的子女教育補助費" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148059/46.wav", + "text": "都已經是從優考量" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148059/47.wav", + "text": "我知道他們講的衡平" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148059/48.wav", + "text": "可是真的是一點都不衡平" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148059/49.wav", + "text": "你剛剛講我們公務人員退休是65歲退休" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148059/50.wav", + "text": "他們的子女已經都是大學畢業" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148059/51.wav", + "text": "有的都進入職場了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148059/52.wav", + "text": "可是我們的軍人上校" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148059/53.wav", + "text": "是52歲就必須退休" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148059/54.wav", + "text": "因為有年齡的限制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148059/55.wav", + "text": "嘛他們的子女就是正在求學的階段" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148059/56.wav", + "text": "必須要付學費" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148059/57.wav", + "text": "所以你把他們取消的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148059/58.wav", + "text": "增加他們的負擔" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148059/59.wav", + "text": "這種我們是不是應該要考量一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148059/60.wav", + "text": "啊院長很多中階軍官今天都會看到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148059/61.wav", + "text": "我們在為他們爭取" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148059/62.wav", + "text": "因為他們也是心有戚戚焉他們認為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148059/63.wav", + "text": "這種其實真的不多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148059/64.wav", + "text": "嘛才1.4億一年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148059/65.wav", + "text": "嘛為什麼��砍他們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148059/66.wav", + "text": "我想我也有兩件事" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148059/67.wav", + "text": "剛才我講一半" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148059/68.wav", + "text": "的子女教育補助費已經是從優考量" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148059/69.wav", + "text": "第二個現在我們上校退休的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148059/70.wav", + "text": "退休金還是達到了7.9萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148059/71.wav", + "text": "能夠留才久任" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148059/72.wav", + "text": "如果能夠這樣子做的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148059/73.wav", + "text": "我們是覺得以現在這個制度來進行的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148059/74.wav", + "text": "其實他們很多人都不願意升上校" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148059/75.wav", + "text": "因為他們算一算結果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148059/76.wav", + "text": "不升上校比升上校還好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148059/77.wav", + "text": "因為他們有子女教育的補助" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148059/78.wav", + "text": "升上校卻沒有多領的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148059/79.wav", + "text": "啊可是這樣子的話對他們是一種打擊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148059/80.wav", + "text": "所以很多人都不願意升上校" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148059/81.wav", + "text": "院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148059/82.wav", + "text": "但是我們很珍惜這些人才" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148059/83.wav", + "text": "我們希望這些人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148059/84.wav", + "text": "跟這些退役軍官" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148059/85.wav", + "text": "我覺得我們應該善待他們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148059/86.wav", + "text": "第二個題目" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148059/87.wav", + "text": "我想請教一下院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148059/88.wav", + "text": "在2020年7月份的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148059/89.wav", + "text": "海軍陸戰隊操演的突擊艇翻覆" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148059/90.wav", + "text": "造成三死一傷" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148059/91.wav", + "text": "我發現國軍的團體保險" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148059/92.wav", + "text": "因公死亡理賠只有350萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148059/93.wav", + "text": "當時我就向國防部長質詢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148059/94.wav", + "text": "是不是應該要提高到600萬到700萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148059/95.wav", + "text": "當時的嚴德發部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148059/96.wav", + "text": "也立即答應" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148059/97.wav", + "text": "之後我們邱部長也同意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148059/98.wav", + "text": "我質詢蘇院長的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148059/99.wav", + "text": "他也說盡力的配合" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148059/100.wav", + "text": "可是到現在也還沒有兌現" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148059/101.wav", + "text": "我感到非常地難過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148059/102.wav", + "text": "為什麼要如此對待我們的軍人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148059/103.wav", + "text": "去年公務人員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148059/104.wav", + "text": "因公死亡的慰問金" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148059/105.wav", + "text": "最高從300萬提升到600萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148059/106.wav", + "text": "增加了1倍" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148059/107.wav", + "text": "國軍的團保死亡理賠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148059/108.wav", + "text": "是不是也應該從350萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148059/109.wav", + "text": "增加到700萬才對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148059/110.wav", + "text": "請問院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148059/111.wav", + "text": "國軍團體保險的死亡理賠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148059/112.wav", + "text": "也調高到700萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148059/113.wav", + "text": "我們現在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148059/114.wav", + "text": "是希望我們國防部這邊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148059/115.wav", + "text": "完備相關的法制作業以後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148059/116.wav", + "text": "就趕快函報到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148059/117.wav", + "text": "行政院來審議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148059/118.wav", + "text": "然後我們會由人事總處" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148059/119.wav", + "text": "來做通盤的研議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148059/120.wav", + "text": "不要到時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148059/121.wav", + "text": "結果人事總處又卡住" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148059/122.wav", + "text": "不會啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148059/123.wav", + "text": "這要錄影的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148059/124.wav", + "text": "不會喔" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148059/125.wav", + "text": "會請它來函報這些法制作業" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148059/126.wav", + "text": "當然就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148059/127.wav", + "text": "對啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148059/128.wav", + "text": "公務員的從300萬提升到600萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148059/129.wav", + "text": "軍人這350萬一直卡在那邊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148059/130.wav", + "text": "這個就和旅遊平安保險一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148059/131.wav", + "text": "沒有人要去領這一筆" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148059/132.wav", + "text": "但是真的有發生意外的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148059/133.wav", + "text": "這等於是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148059/134.wav", + "text": "對家屬的一種照顧" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148059/135.wav", + "text": "多一層的保障而已對啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148059/136.wav", + "text": "院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148059/137.wav", + "text": "我們要善待我們的軍人好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148059/138.wav", + "text": "好我們一定會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148059/139.wav", + "text": "我們要重視他們啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148059/140.wav", + "text": "會積極來照顧軍人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148059/141.wav", + "text": "我們讓部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148059/142.wav", + "text": "所以我希望" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148059/143.wav", + "text": "我們今天能確定啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148059/144.wav", + "text": "我跟委員報告一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148059/145.wav", + "text": "事實上這個案子已經在運作當中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148059/146.wav", + "text": "對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148059/147.wav", + "text": "我們也一直在推動" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148059/148.wav", + "text": "這個案子我是從第2會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148059/149.wav", + "text": "我們這個補助" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148059/150.wav", + "text": "有分不同的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148059/151.wav", + "text": "有些專業的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148059/152.wav", + "text": "它本來就很高" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148059/153.wav", + "text": "但是委員好意都加倍" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148059/154.wav", + "text": "原本350萬要變成700萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148059/155.wav", + "text": "所以我們在努力當中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148059/156.wav", + "text": "而且跟各部會達成協議以後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148059/157.wav", + "text": "都說可以啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148059/158.wav", + "text": "預訂在今年年底之前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148059/159.wav", + "text": "可以陳報到行政院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148059/160.wav", + "text": "所以我" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148059/161.wav", + "text": "要替這些軍人謝謝院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148059/162.wav", + "text": "謝謝部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148059/163.wav", + "text": "我們把這個提高" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148059/164.wav", + "text": "讓他們比較安" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148059/165.wav", + "text": "這才是溫暖內閣的作法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148059/166.wav", + "text": "我再請教你" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148059/167.wav", + "text": "你知不知道募兵的待遇如何" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148059/168.wav", + "text": "薪資又是如何" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148059/169.wav", + "text": "我們從明年的1月開始" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148059/170.wav", + "text": "義務役延長1年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148059/171.wav", + "text": "他們的薪水是從6,500提高到2萬6,000" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148059/172.wav", + "text": "你們幫義務役加薪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148059/173.wav", + "text": "但是調薪了以後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148059/174.wav", + "text": "基層軍官卻表示" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148059/175.wav", + "text": "義務役調高到2萬6,000" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148059/176.wav", + "text": "這樣他們就很難再招募到志願役了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148059/177.wav", + "text": "鼓舞他們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148059/178.wav", + "text": "說服他們來參加" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148059/179.wav", + "text": "當志願役" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148059/180.wav", + "text": "院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148059/181.wav", + "text": "你覺得我們的薪資結構" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148059/182.wav", + "text": "有沒有失衡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148059/183.wav", + "text": "去年年底" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148059/184.wav", + "text": "我就有請教過國防部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148059/185.wav", + "text": "月薪調到2萬6,000的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148059/186.wav", + "text": "誰還要去考官校" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148059/187.wav", + "text": "還要去考陸專" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148059/188.wav", + "text": "誰還願意當志願役的士兵" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148059/189.wav", + "text": "去年同樣的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148059/190.wav", + "text": "我今年也要請教院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148059/191.wav", + "text": "你認為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148059/192.wav", + "text": "我們需不需要去調整" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148059/193.wav", + "text": "我想志願役的薪資應該要多少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148059/194.wav", + "text": "是需要通盤來考慮" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148059/195.wav", + "text": "我相信國防部在這一個區塊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148059/196.wav", + "text": "當我們有義務役的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148059/197.wav", + "text": "新兵調進來的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148059/198.wav", + "text": "一定有過很好的研議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148059/199.wav", + "text": "是不是讓部長講一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148059/200.wav", + "text": "我跟委員報告一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148059/201.wav", + "text": "的確我們的志願役" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148059/202.wav", + "text": "役有不同的專業領域" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148059/203.wav", + "text": "有在不同的地區服務" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148059/204.wav", + "text": "高山站臺或者在外離島" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148059/205.wav", + "text": "一般義務役沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148059/206.wav", + "text": "但義務役薪資提高" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148059/207.wav", + "text": "乍聽之下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148059/208.wav", + "text": "事實上當然我們不講滿足" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148059/209.wav", + "text": "但我們這都有一個規劃" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148059/210.wav", + "text": "基本額是1萬沒有錯" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148059/211.wav", + "text": "其他有他的專業" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148059/212.wav", + "text": "屬性不同" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148059/213.wav", + "text": "當然還有他未來的前途" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148059/214.wav", + "text": "不管是參與各個工作的推動" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148059/215.wav", + "text": "或將來的深造" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148059/216.wav", + "text": "是比一般義務要來得優渥" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148059/217.wav", + "text": "我們就不用了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148059/218.wav", + "text": "我們要努力爭取" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148059/219.wav", + "text": "但是不要誤會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148059/220.wav", + "text": "說義務役的薪資提高了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148059/221.wav", + "text": "好像志願役都沒有動因" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148059/222.wav", + "text": "因為志願役原本就有因地" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148059/223.wav", + "text": "因為他的職務" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148059/224.wav", + "text": "這一回我們也會把案子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148059/225.wav", + "text": "重新做整理以後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148059/226.wav", + "text": "講一個合理的數據" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148059/227.wav", + "text": "大家可以做一個研討" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148059/228.wav", + "text": "今天我是要善意的提醒" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148059/229.wav", + "text": "他們的薪資的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148059/230.wav", + "text": "我們目前是很難招募到人才" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148059/231.wav", + "text": "尤其現在兩岸這麼緊張" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148059/232.wav", + "text": "真的是非常困難" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148059/233.wav", + "text": "我是聽到基層的心聲" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148059/234.wav", + "text": "那些去招募的軍官們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148059/235.wav", + "text": "他們說很難招募到人才" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148059/236.wav", + "text": "就是這麼說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148059/237.wav", + "text": "啦\n接下來我想請教一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148059/238.wav", + "text": "義務役要不要上戰場" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148059/239.wav", + "text": "因為募兵狀況不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148059/240.wav", + "text": "我們的兵力不足" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148059/241.wav", + "text": "媒體報導說義務役恐怕要上戰場" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148059/242.wav", + "text": "院長您說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148059/243.wav", + "text": "媒體的報導並非事實" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148059/244.wav", + "text": "義務役是以守備部隊為主" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148059/245.wav", + "text": "我們的總統和副總統" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148059/246.wav", + "text": "也都說了義務役是守備基礎建設" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148059/247.wav", + "text": "不會前往陸海空戰場" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148059/248.wav", + "text": "但是國防部卻表示" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148059/249.wav", + "text": "義務役男要優先分發到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148059/250.wav", + "text": "守備部隊服役" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148059/251.wav", + "text": "但是主戰部隊次之" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148059/252.wav", + "text": "所以國防部的意思是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148059/253.wav", + "text": "義務役也有可能要上戰場" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148059/254.wav", + "text": "所以媒體的報導" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148059/255.wav", + "text": "並非空穴來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148059/256.wav", + "text": "我跟委員報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148059/257.wav", + "text": "這句話當初我有講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148059/258.wav", + "text": "我不是這樣講因為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148059/259.wav", + "text": "我們當初規劃志願役在主戰部隊裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148059/260.wav", + "text": "義務役放守備部隊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148059/261.wav", + "text": "但是有一個但書" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148059/262.wav", + "text": "有一些義務役的小朋友" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148059/263.wav", + "text": "他有意願到主戰部隊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148059/264.wav", + "text": "但我們要經過一個測考" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148059/265.wav", + "text": "都驗證合格以後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148059/266.wav", + "text": "到守備部隊就不打仗不上戰場" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148059/267.wav", + "text": "我曾經很明白地表示過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148059/268.wav", + "text": "一旦臺澎防衛作戰" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148059/269.wav", + "text": "槍砲一響" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148059/270.wav", + "text": "臺灣這個地方沒有前方後方" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148059/271.wav", + "text": "我找不到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148059/272.wav", + "text": "所以我們不希望戰爭發生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148059/273.wav", + "text": "一發生了自然就沒有所謂的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148059/274.wav", + "text": "役男" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148059/275.wav", + "text": "我們都不希望戰爭" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148059/276.wav", + "text": "一旦作戰" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148059/277.wav", + "text": "讓年輕人知道的是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148059/278.wav", + "text": "我們要告訴他們事實的狀況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148059/279.wav", + "text": "譬如講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148059/280.wav", + "text": "守備" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148059/281.wav", + "text": "他們也是在最危險的地方" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148059/282.wav", + "text": "就像" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148059/283.wav", + "text": "烏克蘭的內政部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148059/284.wav", + "text": "在2022年11月說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148059/285.wav", + "text": "的俄軍摧毀的或是破壞的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148059/286.wav", + "text": "總共有七百零多座的重要建築" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148059/287.wav", + "text": "油庫變電站發電廠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148059/288.wav", + "text": "請問這一些不都" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148059/289.wav", + "text": "是重要的基礎建設嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148059/290.wav", + "text": "甚至以色列的國防部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148059/291.wav", + "text": "還說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148059/292.wav", + "text": "開戰以後將分成三個階段" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148059/293.wav", + "text": "作戰第一個階段" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148059/294.wav", + "text": "就是要摧毀哈馬斯的基礎建設" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148059/295.wav", + "text": "所以說來說去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148059/296.wav", + "text": "還是要讓我們的年輕人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148059/297.wav", + "text": "真正地去瞭解我們要做的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148059/298.wav", + "text": "就是這一些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148059/299.wav", + "text": "要給他們心理建設" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148059/300.wav", + "text": "我們不要講都沒事都沒事" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148059/301.wav", + "text": "到時候真的開戰的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148059/302.wav", + "text": "子彈是不分年輕人老人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148059/303.wav", + "text": "不分藍綠都是一樣的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148059/304.wav", + "text": "所以說我們要讓年輕人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148059/305.wav", + "text": "真正的有心理建設心理準備" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148059/306.wav", + "text": "這樣好嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148059/307.wav", + "text": "事實上我跟委員報告我們不斷宣導" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148059/308.wav", + "text": "但有些就會誤" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148059/309.wav", + "text": "因為我們講得很清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148059/310.wav", + "text": "本來講不上戰場" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148059/311.wav", + "text": "現在要上戰場" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148059/312.wav", + "text": "臺灣槍砲一響" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148059/313.wav", + "text": "沒有地方" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148059/314.wav", + "text": "保家衛國是軍人的責任" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148059/315.wav", + "text": "我們就是要讓他們知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148059/316.wav", + "text": "我們要讓年輕人知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148059/317.wav", + "text": "讓他們瞭解而已" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148059/318.wav", + "text": "不是說一定不會上戰場" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148059/319.wav", + "text": "到時候開戰" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148059/320.wav", + "text": "部長你講開戰的話就沒有分哪裡了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148059/321.wav", + "text": "我們不樂見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148059/322.wav", + "text": "啦絕對不樂見作戰" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148059/323.wav", + "text": "最後一個問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148059/324.wav", + "text": "這裡有2張" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148059/325.wav", + "text": "110年的凍結預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148059/326.wav", + "text": "可不可以請問" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148059/327.wav", + "text": "哪一張是愛臺" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148059/328.wav", + "text": "哪一張是賣臺" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148059/329.wav", + "text": "看得出來嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148059/330.wav", + "text": "2張都是凍結預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148059/331.wav", + "text": "可是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148059/332.wav", + "text": "我們的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148059/333.wav", + "text": "副總統" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148059/334.wav", + "text": "他就罵說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148059/335.wav", + "text": "還敢凍結" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148059/336.wav", + "text": "不但沒有刪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148059/337.wav", + "text": "也沒有影響到潛艦的進度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148059/338.wav", + "text": "時間到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148059/339.wav", + "text": "也是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148059/340.wav", + "text": "院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148059/341.wav", + "text": "你要不要說一句" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148059/342.wav", + "text": "公道話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148059/343.wav", + "text": "來謎底揭曉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148059/344.wav", + "text": "這一張是我提案的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148059/345.wav", + "text": "這一張是羅致政提案的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148059/346.wav", + "text": "兩個提案一模一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148059/347.wav", + "text": "可是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148059/348.wav", + "text": "他的就是護臺" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148059/349.wav", + "text": "我們的提案就是賣臺" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148059/350.wav", + "text": "可是提案的道理都一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148059/351.wav", + "text": "啊這個不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148059/352.wav", + "text": "林委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148058/0.wav", + "text": "陳院長請邱部長請" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148058/1.wav", + "text": "陳委員午安" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148058/2.wav", + "text": "等一下部長也針對這個問題先回答" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148058/3.wav", + "text": "今天也再度宣布24小時內有35架次共機擾臺" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148058/4.wav", + "text": "其實目前臺海的局勢是不是相對來講很緊張" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148058/5.wav", + "text": "目前航母上面有14架殲-15戰鬥機" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148058/6.wav", + "text": "目前你們具體掌握的狀況是怎麼樣院長這邊先回答" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148058/7.wav", + "text": "我想我們國軍運用聯合情監偵的手段" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148058/8.wav", + "text": "目前我們整個有掌握很好的這個狀況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148058/9.wav", + "text": "並沒有特別地需要我們大家太緊張或者憂慮的地方" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148058/10.wav", + "text": "好那從海上防禦還有國家安全的角度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148058/11.wav", + "text": "目前臺海之間是不是有一些異常的狀況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148058/12.wav", + "text": "或者平常沒有而突然有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148058/13.wav", + "text": "或者平常不多突然變多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148058/14.wav", + "text": "或者平常有突然變沒有這都叫異常" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148058/15.wav", + "text": "在我們連續看的這個階段" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148058/16.wav", + "text": "它大概每天都有不管是航艦或航空器材" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148058/17.wav", + "text": "在我們周邊不見得繞臺灣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148058/18.wav", + "text": "可能偏南偏北或者是在中線" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148058/19.wav", + "text": "我們研判按照這個週期來講的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148058/20.wav", + "text": "我們已經找出來大概每隔一個階段" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148058/21.wav", + "text": "它會有一點擴大" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148058/22.wav", + "text": "目前就剛好在這個階段時間點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148058/23.wav", + "text": "我們當然並不認為就是如此" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148058/24.wav", + "text": "我們持續密注" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148058/25.wav", + "text": "誠如剛剛院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148058/26.wav", + "text": "每天都要注意到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148058/27.wav", + "text": "不管現在是俄烏戰爭還沒有結束" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148058/28.wav", + "text": "或中東以巴的衝突" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148058/29.wav", + "text": "回到我們臺海之間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148058/30.wav", + "text": "距離2024總統大選" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148058/31.wav", + "text": "目前只剩78天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148058/32.wav", + "text": "其實中共這邊包括經濟方面的動作" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148058/33.wav", + "text": "一定要即時掌握" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148058/34.wav", + "text": "我想這個部分牽一髮而動全身" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148058/35.wav", + "text": "我跟委員報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148058/36.wav", + "text": "這是我們的責任" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148058/37.wav", + "text": "我們每天要監控" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148058/38.wav", + "text": "然後定期或者是臨時有狀況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148058/39.wav", + "text": "第二個訊息" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148058/40.wav", + "text": "先就教院長部長稍等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148058/41.wav", + "text": "中國全國人大常委會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148058/42.wav", + "text": "日前通過所謂的愛國主義教育法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148058/43.wav", + "text": "明年元旦就要生效" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148058/44.wav", + "text": "對象甚至把臺灣納入" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148058/45.wav", + "text": "會不會受到什麼影響" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148058/46.wav", + "text": "我想我們中華民國" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148058/47.wav", + "text": "臺灣人民的權利義務" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148058/48.wav", + "text": "就是由我們立法院按照憲法訂定的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148058/49.wav", + "text": "嘛所以我們這個所謂的以法律訂定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148058/50.wav", + "text": "所謂愛國的這一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148058/51.wav", + "text": "我想這是對岸那邊的論述" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148058/52.wav", + "text": "那是對岸的事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148058/53.wav", + "text": "但是我們這邊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148058/54.wav", + "text": "我們必須" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148058/55.wav", + "text": "我個人是覺得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148058/56.wav", + "text": "一個國家能不能讓人民愛它" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148058/57.wav", + "text": "實在不是靠法律來的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148058/58.wav", + "text": "沒有錯" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148058/59.wav", + "text": "這個是基本認同的層面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148058/60.wav", + "text": "對啊我還是要回到民間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148058/61.wav", + "text": "我們一般" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148058/62.wav", + "text": "國人赴中國大陸" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148058/63.wav", + "text": "當然逐年在遞減" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148058/64.wav", + "text": "臺灣學生也有1.2萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148058/65.wav", + "text": "這些人未來再赴中國大陸" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148058/66.wav", + "text": "會不會因為這個相關的政治宣示" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148058/67.wav", + "text": "甚至是他們這個愛國主義教育法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148058/68.wav", + "text": "或是在入境的時候需要採取一些應對的措施" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148058/69.wav", + "text": "來就教院長後續的應對措施" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148058/70.wav", + "text": "這個愛國教育法通過以後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148058/71.wav", + "text": "到底會有什麼樣的情況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148058/72.wav", + "text": "我們正在密切注意當中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148058/73.wav", + "text": "我想這個部分還是要幫��們保障" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148058/74.wav", + "text": "的這17萬人的相關權益" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148058/75.wav", + "text": "平常不管是在大陸經商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148058/76.wav", + "text": "或者是進行民間交流" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148058/77.wav", + "text": "我想這個部分還是要持續" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148058/78.wav", + "text": "準備相關的應對措施" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148058/79.wav", + "text": "我想政治上可能兩岸會有所分歧" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148058/80.wav", + "text": "但不管說是經濟教育或文化" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148058/81.wav", + "text": "這個基本的正常交流" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148058/82.wav", + "text": "所以陸委會要掌握相關的狀況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148058/83.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148058/84.wav", + "text": "第二個我想就教邱部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148058/85.wav", + "text": "本席最近有接到民眾反映" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148058/86.wav", + "text": "我國現有的5條戰備跑道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148058/87.wav", + "text": "歷年來僅進行過7次起降訓練" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148058/88.wav", + "text": "而且在花蓮和臺東規劃中的戰備跑道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148058/89.wav", + "text": "其實目前也遲遲沒有完成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148058/90.wav", + "text": "甚至當地的民意也反對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148058/91.wav", + "text": "讓外界質疑國防部對於戰備跑道的實戰價值" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148058/92.wav", + "text": "有所存疑" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148058/93.wav", + "text": "所以請問部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148058/94.wav", + "text": "現在各戰備跑道是否還有專門負責的基地" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148058/95.wav", + "text": "尤其針對戰備跑道演練的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148058/96.wav", + "text": "要如何讓它回歸正常化" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148058/97.wav", + "text": "還是目前的頻率你們認為是夠的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148058/98.wav", + "text": "沒有我跟委員報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148058/99.wav", + "text": "我們國軍對於物件或地區的保管是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148058/100.wav", + "text": "有責任劃分的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148058/101.wav", + "text": "每個地段都有作戰區" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148058/102.wav", + "text": "也有交給地區的聯隊來負責" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148058/103.wav", + "text": "負責不只是每天要去掃" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148058/104.wav", + "text": "還要去檢查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148058/105.wav", + "text": "哪裡有損壞他馬上會反應" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148058/106.wav", + "text": "為何我們的漢光很難得做一次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148058/107.wav", + "text": "一方面也就擔憂" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148058/108.wav", + "text": "會在交通方面造成人民不便" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148058/109.wav", + "text": "但平常我們都有在演練" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148058/110.wav", + "text": "雖然沒有到現地去做起降" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148058/111.wav", + "text": "但我們不管是用兵推" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148058/112.wav", + "text": "或者把機場裡面跑道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148058/113.wav", + "text": "當作戰備跑道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148058/114.wav", + "text": "旁邊設置一些狀況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148058/115.wav", + "text": "其效果還是有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148058/116.wav", + "text": "所以我們還是要用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148058/117.wav", + "text": "我想說模擬或是平戰轉換上的一個執行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148058/118.wav", + "text": "但是現在不比過去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148058/119.wav", + "text": "了因為現在兩岸情勢確實比較緊張" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148058/120.wav", + "text": "尤其我們政府現在大推全民國防" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148058/121.wav", + "text": "或國防自主" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148058/122.wav", + "text": "整個兵力結構的調整" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148058/123.wav", + "text": "包含提升國防武力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148058/124.wav", + "text": "尤其你們一直在強調" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148058/125.wav", + "text": "我們民眾黨也認為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148058/126.wav", + "text": "備戰才能避戰" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148058/127.wav", + "text": "以戰止戰" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148058/128.wav", + "text": "我們認為態度上要更積極" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148058/129.wav", + "text": "所以就教下一個問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148058/130.wav", + "text": "目前臺東跟花蓮的戰備跑道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148058/131.wav", + "text": "是不是持續推動" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148058/132.wav", + "text": "因為我們知道臺東的戰備跑道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148058/133.wav", + "text": "本來是預定在110年完成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148058/134.wav", + "text": "那目前的進度如何" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148058/135.wav", + "text": "我們知道地方的居民" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148058/136.wav", + "text": "可能有一些不同的意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148058/137.wav", + "text": "目前溝通的狀況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148058/138.wav", + "text": "是不是說明一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148058/139.wav", + "text": "我跟委員報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148058/140.wav", + "text": "花蓮那邊有一條路" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148058/141.wav", + "text": "它要整建" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148058/142.wav", + "text": "整建以後我們就有一段" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148058/143.wav", + "text": "有沒有辦法加速" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148058/144.wav", + "text": "速度我們要按照正常的運作" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148058/145.wav", + "text": "現在這個工作已經在做了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148058/146.wav", + "text": "但是我們也會擺在表裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148058/147.wav", + "text": "我們不會躁進" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148058/148.wav", + "text": "但也不會把它給延誤" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148058/149.wav", + "text": "這兩天在外交及國防委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148058/150.wav", + "text": "所有跨黨派的國防委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148058/151.wav", + "text": "對於你們整體的國防預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148058/152.wav", + "text": "都是非常支持的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148058/153.wav", + "text": "但是在相關的進度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148058/154.wav", + "text": "上我們認為你們態度上要更積極" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148058/155.wav", + "text": "尤其我接下來要談到的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148058/156.wav", + "text": "國防部在提升國防戰力的各項計畫中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148058/157.wav", + "text": "興安專案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148058/158.wav", + "text": "跟高雄205兵工廠遷建案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148058/159.wav", + "text": "資安園區" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148058/160.wav", + "text": "等等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148058/161.wav", + "text": "其實非常多計畫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148058/162.wav", + "text": "尤其審計部跟立法院預算中心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148058/163.wav", + "text": "跟進度嚴重落後的情況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148058/164.wav", + "text": "雖然國防部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148058/165.wav", + "text": "在跟本席的預算溝通中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148058/166.wav", + "text": "業管單位一再說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148058/167.wav", + "text": "保證明年的進度一定可以趕上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148058/168.wav", + "text": "但去年其實也是這樣講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148058/169.wav", + "text": "本席還是非常擔心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148058/170.wav", + "text": "所以就教邱部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148058/171.wav", + "text": "對於這些重要的軍事建設計畫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148058/172.wav", + "text": "國防部有沒有組成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148058/173.wav", + "text": "營繕專案督導小組協助解決問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148058/174.wav", + "text": "這個部分院長可以補充一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148058/175.wav", + "text": "就是公共工程委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148058/176.wav", + "text": "有沒有專案的小組在協助" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148058/177.wav", + "text": "推動整個招標的作業" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148058/178.wav", + "text": "因為總體的國家工程量" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148058/179.wav", + "text": "是有一定的量能" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148058/180.wav", + "text": "全民防衛意識" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148058/181.wav", + "text": "是我們現在的最高戰略目標" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148058/182.wav", + "text": "這樣應該要有一個優先次序" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148058/183.wav", + "text": "公共工程委員會的量能調動" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148058/184.wav", + "text": "跟國防部現在的溝通如何" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148058/185.wav", + "text": "有沒有專案在督導" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148058/186.wav", + "text": "我剛剛唸的這幾個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148058/187.wav", + "text": "你簡單說明一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148058/188.wav", + "text": "我跟委員報" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148058/189.wav", + "text": "告我也很關切這些專案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148058/190.wav", + "text": "我們每一個專案要建立" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148058/191.wav", + "text": "一定有一個專案小組" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148058/192.wav", + "text": "的的確確有些工程會延宕" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148058/193.wav", + "text": "什麼物價上升" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148058/194.wav", + "text": "人工難找" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148058/195.wav", + "text": "一有問題我們會同步來做調整" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148058/196.wav", + "text": "這調整可能有些人一聽以後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148058/197.wav", + "text": "你們就把數量給減少了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148058/198.wav", + "text": "但是這以後要一步一步" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148058/199.wav", + "text": "持續追加" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148058/200.wav", + "text": "這以後我們一步一步走了再做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148058/201.wav", + "text": "但我們一定要達到目標" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148058/202.wav", + "text": "這是第一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148058/203.wav", + "text": "第二個每個工程" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148058/204.wav", + "text": "包含行政院公共工程委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148058/205.wav", + "text": "它也經常給我們輔導" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148058/206.wav", + "text": "譬如拿興安專案來講好了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148058/207.wav", + "text": "我們都要定期召開的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148058/208.wav", + "text": "多久召開一次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148058/209.wav", + "text": "大概跟行政院幾乎每個月都會召開一次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148058/210.wav", + "text": "有的時候吳澤成政委" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148058/211.wav", + "text": "他會親自到我們國防部來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148058/212.wav", + "text": "不過我想政治的核心在執行力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148058/213.wav", + "text": "我希望你們還是把" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148058/214.wav", + "text": "剛剛我提到幾個專案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148058/215.wav", + "text": "相關的KPI預定的期程" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148058/216.wav", + "text": "把它明列清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148058/217.wav", + "text": "院長是不是請你補充一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148058/218.wav", + "text": "公共工程委員會還有行政院這邊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148058/219.wav", + "text": "可以給予怎麼樣的協助" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148058/220.wav", + "text": "行政院對於各個公共工程" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148058/221.wav", + "text": "都有建立督導的相關專案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148058/222.wav", + "text": "也都在進行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148058/223.wav", + "text": "像剛才我們部長已經講過了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148058/224.wav", + "text": "實際上他們都會針對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148058/225.wav", + "text": "而且國發會也都有例行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148058/226.wav", + "text": "來報告他們執行的進度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148058/227.wav", + "text": "現在公共工程的進度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148058/228.wav", + "text": "實際上執行率都到了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148058/229.wav", + "text": "像今年度的都到了百分之九十六九十七了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148058/230.wav", + "text": "這個不只是撥款進度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148058/231.wav", + "text": "要正式發包甚至是動工" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148058/232.wav", + "text": "我想這個標準你們可能要去明列一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148058/233.wav", + "text": "第二個就是說這麼多工程" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148058/234.wav", + "text": "不管是你們前瞻的地方建設" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148058/235.wav", + "text": "或者是中央基本上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148058/236.wav", + "text": "但是現在國防部這邊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148058/237.wav", + "text": "相關軍備的工程" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148058/238.wav", + "text": "相關全民國防的這些工程" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148058/239.wav", + "text": "應該要有一個輕重緩急" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148058/240.wav", + "text": "甚至你們要稍微去做一個排序" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148058/241.wav", + "text": "因為我想現在目前面臨缺工缺料" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148058/242.wav", + "text": "甚至是工程量能不足" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148058/243.wav", + "text": "因為流標的狀況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148058/244.wav", + "text": "其實不管在哪一個行業" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148058/245.wav", + "text": "都有這樣的狀況發生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148058/246.wav", + "text": "地方政府也有這樣的狀況發生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148058/247.wav", + "text": "這個東西不是流標之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148058/248.wav", + "text": "再把預算提高就會���人來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148058/249.wav", + "text": "不是這樣子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148058/250.wav", + "text": "所以我想你要去做一個總體" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148058/251.wav", + "text": "工程量能的盤點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148058/252.wav", + "text": "跟加強督導" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148058/253.wav", + "text": "沒有錯" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148058/254.wav", + "text": "實際上缺工缺料" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148058/255.wav", + "text": "沒有完成流標的情形" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148058/256.wav", + "text": "在最近已經有比較緩和下來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148058/257.wav", + "text": "我想就教邱國正部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148058/258.wav", + "text": "近日海軍陸戰隊66旅" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148058/259.wav", + "text": "發生盜賣軍品的離譜事件" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148058/260.wav", + "text": "整起事件在檢調調查後才曝光" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148058/261.wav", + "text": "國防部被外界質疑" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148058/262.wav", + "text": "是不是後知後覺" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148058/263.wav", + "text": "請問部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148058/264.wav", + "text": "這個案子你認為國防部的軍品管理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148058/265.wav", + "text": "內控機制失靈的狀況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148058/266.wav", + "text": "怎麼樣強化整個軍紀的要求" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148058/267.wav", + "text": "還有這個案子目前執行的狀況如何" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148058/268.wav", + "text": "是我跟委員報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148058/269.wav", + "text": "第一個最近國軍在內部管理方面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148058/270.wav", + "text": "的確有點缺失" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148058/271.wav", + "text": "我也不斷跟同仁強調" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148058/272.wav", + "text": "從內部管理做起" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148058/273.wav", + "text": "讓每個組織功能要發揮" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148058/274.wav", + "text": "因為部隊裡面都很清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148058/275.wav", + "text": "誰管什麼誰管哪些人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148058/276.wav", + "text": "都很清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148058/277.wav", + "text": "但唯一" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148058/278.wav", + "text": "我們不能講很清楚我們就不管" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148058/279.wav", + "text": "因為假如我們不聞不問" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148058/280.wav", + "text": "委員剛剛所點出的幾個問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148058/281.wav", + "text": "現在我們按照法律程序" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148058/282.wav", + "text": "該查的查該要交給法辦的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148058/283.wav", + "text": "我們都在密切保持聯絡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148058/284.wav", + "text": "所以只要有違法犯紀" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148058/285.wav", + "text": "我想軍紀影響軍心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148058/286.wav", + "text": "軍心影響國人對國軍的信心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148058/287.wav", + "text": "這個是非常重要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148058/288.wav", + "text": "而且現在是全民國防" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148058/289.wav", + "text": "役期也延長到一年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148058/290.wav", + "text": "這一些提升我們國軍的榮譽感" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148058/291.wav", + "text": "跟軍紀的嚴明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148058/292.wav", + "text": "部長要非常重視" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148058/293.wav", + "text": "接著我們邀請吳釗燮吳部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148058/294.wav", + "text": "邱部長您可以請回" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148058/295.wav", + "text": "吳部長時間有限" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148058/296.wav", + "text": "我直接問了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148058/297.wav", + "text": "美國眾議院在25日選出新任的議長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148058/298.wav", + "text": "由共和黨內的強硬保守派" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148058/299.wav", + "text": "Johnson當選" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148058/300.wav", + "text": "他除了是國會臺灣連線的成員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148058/301.wav", + "text": "也曾參與2021臺灣國際團結法案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148058/302.wav", + "text": "我相信對臺美的關係" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148058/303.wav", + "text": "基本上他的立場應該是支持的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148058/304.wav", + "text": "請問部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148058/305.wav", + "text": "你目前跟這位新任的議長熟不熟" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148058/306.wav", + "text": "這位眾議長來臺的交流計畫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148058/307.wav", + "text": "你會不會有這樣一個邀請的計畫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148058/308.wav", + "text": "非常謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148058/309.wav", + "text": "委員我個人跟這位議長並不熟悉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148058/310.wav", + "text": "但是我們駐美代表處國會組的同仁" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148058/311.wav", + "text": "跟國會所有這些議員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148058/312.wav", + "text": "都保持非常密切的聯繫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148058/313.wav", + "text": "目前是沒有邀請議長來臺的計畫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148058/314.wav", + "text": "但是我們會持續跟議長辦公室保持聯繫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148058/315.wav", + "text": "希望他也能夠支持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148058/316.wav", + "text": "涉及到我們臺灣的這些議案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148058/317.wav", + "text": "不管是跨黨派" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148058/318.wav", + "text": "大家對於正向的推動都是支持的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148058/319.wav", + "text": "所以在這個部分請部長幫我們多加費心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148058/320.wav", + "text": "\n另一個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148058/321.wav", + "text": "我們要關心臺美21世紀貿易倡議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148058/322.wav", + "text": "目前談判的進度為何" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148058/323.wav", + "text": "第二個階段什麼時候會展開討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148058/324.wav", + "text": "其實第二階段已經展開討論了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148058/325.wav", + "text": "在8月的時候就已經正式開始了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148058/326.wav", + "text": "目前一切都進行得非常順利" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148058/327.wav", + "text": "我們也希望能夠儘快完成協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148058/328.wav", + "text": "能夠簽訂第二部分的協議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148058/329.wav", + "text": "我想談判本身就是一個溝通的過程" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148058/330.wav", + "text": "除了跟對美方談判之外" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148058/331.wav", + "text": "國內的社會溝通也非常重要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148058/332.wav", + "text": "不管相關可能會影響到的產業" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148058/333.wav", + "text": "民間的團體" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148058/334.wav", + "text": "甚至人民的觀感" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148058/335.wav", + "text": "我想這個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148058/336.wav", + "text": "辦公室跟美方的談判" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148058/337.wav", + "text": "我也建議院長您這邊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148058/338.wav", + "text": "國內的產業溝通跟社會溝通" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148058/339.wav", + "text": "還是要把它做到位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148058/340.wav", + "text": "不要我們跟外面人家談了一談" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148058/341.wav", + "text": "結果到後面我們自己的人沒有共識" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148058/342.wav", + "text": "這個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148058/343.wav", + "text": "我們確實是有跟業界都有很好的溝通" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148058/344.wav", + "text": "謝謝邱委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148058/345.wav", + "text": "\n接下來吳委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148057/0.wav", + "text": "陳院長請" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148057/1.wav", + "text": "林委員午安" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148057/2.wav", + "text": "是院長好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148057/3.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148057/4.wav", + "text": "院長我想先請教" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148057/5.wav", + "text": "一下陸委會在今年8月24號" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148057/6.wav", + "text": "曾經宣布我們要開放陸團" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148057/7.wav", + "text": "也就是大陸人士團客來臺觀光" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148057/8.wav", + "text": "可是設下每天2,000人次的限額" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148057/9.wav", + "text": "又要視大陸的回應" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148057/10.wav", + "text": "再確定實施的日期" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148057/11.wav", + "text": "對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148057/12.wav", + "text": "我想請問的就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148057/13.wav", + "text": "如果大陸不回應" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148057/14.wav", + "text": "我們是不是就永遠不開放" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148057/15.wav", + "text": "院長我相信你一定同意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148057/16.wav", + "text": "觀光就是最好的外交" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148057/17.wav", + "text": "你一定同意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148057/18.wav", + "text": "簡報在國民黨執政的期間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148057/19.wav", + "text": "102年到105年間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148057/20.wav", + "text": "是陸客來臺的最高峰" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148057/21.wav", + "text": "104年全年大陸來臺的觀光人數" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148057/22.wav", + "text": "高達418萬人之多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148057/23.wav", + "text": "109年民進黨政府執政之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148057/24.wav", + "text": "今年疫情結束後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148057/25.wav", + "text": "今年1月到8月大陸觀光來臺人數" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148057/26.wav", + "text": "只有12.6萬人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148057/27.wav", + "text": "當然近年來受到疫情的衝擊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148057/28.wav", + "text": "已經讓業者叫苦連天了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148057/29.wav", + "text": "所以我們政府真的有必要幫業者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148057/30.wav", + "text": "我想這一點院長也一定同意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148057/31.wav", + "text": "我們再看下一張簡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148057/32.wav", + "text": "簡報可以看到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148057/33.wav", + "text": "我們各級觀光旅館的住用率" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148057/34.wav", + "text": "在103年104年達到最���峰" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148057/35.wav", + "text": "平均的住房率都達到七成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148057/36.wav", + "text": "約70%左右" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148057/37.wav", + "text": "雖然說今年1月到8月" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148057/38.wav", + "text": "我們疫後復甦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148057/39.wav", + "text": "但是在疫情期間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148057/40.wav", + "text": "有許多旅館轉型或者倒閉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148057/41.wav", + "text": "所以那個母數就下降很多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148057/42.wav", + "text": "但是我們看到住房率" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148057/43.wav", + "text": "這個住房率平均還是不到60%" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148057/44.wav", + "text": "就大概59.46%" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148057/45.wav", + "text": "所以我們的觀光業者真的叫苦連天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148057/46.wav", + "text": "如果院長跟主委認同我講的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148057/47.wav", + "text": "──觀光就是最好的外交" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148057/48.wav", + "text": "我們中華民國又自詡為自由民主的國家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148057/49.wav", + "text": "那我認為就要開大路走大門" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148057/50.wav", + "text": "我們要有自信" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148057/51.wav", + "text": "難道我們還怕別人來比較嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148057/52.wav", + "text": "所以我的問題就請問院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148057/53.wav", + "text": "如果大陸方面繼續沒有回應" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148057/54.wav", + "text": "請問我們有沒有單方開放的選項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148057/55.wav", + "text": "委員關心我們國際觀光客的這一個事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148057/56.wav", + "text": "實際上我跟委員報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148057/57.wav", + "text": "我們國際觀光客今年的目標" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148057/58.wav", + "text": "包括陸客本來包括陸客是到600萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148057/59.wav", + "text": "可是現在即使沒有陸客的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148057/60.wav", + "text": "我們也相信大概在12月上旬的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148057/61.wav", + "text": "就可以到達600萬的目標" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148057/62.wav", + "text": "了兩岸之間的觀光交流" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148057/63.wav", + "text": "本來就是應該要有對等互惠這樣的立場" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148057/64.wav", + "text": "而且大陸已經開放103十幾個國家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148057/65.wav", + "text": "可是就是沒有臺灣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148057/66.wav", + "text": "我們覺得現在的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148057/67.wav", + "text": "應該是在大陸怎麼樣開放它的心胸" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148057/68.wav", + "text": "然後讓團客能夠來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148057/69.wav", + "text": "就是我們沒有這樣的選項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148057/70.wav", + "text": "我們沒有單方面開放的選項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148057/71.wav", + "text": "就是大陸不回應" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148057/72.wav", + "text": "我們也就一直不會開放大陸團客來臺" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148057/73.wav", + "text": "委員很清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148057/74.wav", + "text": "我想所有的觀光" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148057/75.wav", + "text": "它基本上是對等互惠的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148057/76.wav", + "text": "剛剛你也提到了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148057/77.wav", + "text": "2015年的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148057/78.wav", + "text": "陸客到臺灣來四百十幾萬人次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148057/79.wav", + "text": "但是你知道我們臺灣的旅客到大陸去有多少嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148057/80.wav", + "text": "也是一樣四百多萬人次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148057/81.wav", + "text": "啊所以基本上這是對等互惠的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148057/82.wav", + "text": "那到現在為止" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148057/83.wav", + "text": "連臺灣都沒有列為它國人可以去的地方" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148057/84.wav", + "text": "更不要講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148057/85.wav", + "text": "它還可以調控來影響選舉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148057/86.wav", + "text": "2019年選舉的前一年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148057/87.wav", + "text": "你知道陸客只剩下多少人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148057/88.wav", + "text": "的就是我們應該是要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148057/89.wav", + "text": "共同向大陸方面要求說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148057/90.wav", + "text": "你為什麼不讓陸客來臺灣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148057/91.wav", + "text": "呢你在怕什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148057/92.wav", + "text": "應該是這樣才對啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148057/93.wav", + "text": "因為是它不願意放" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148057/94.wav", + "text": "啊我們已經說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148057/95.wav", + "text": "我們開放的時間點就是你對等開放的時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148057/96.wav", + "text": "主委你講對等開放" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148057/97.wav", + "text": "剛剛你提到我們的人數" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148057/98.wav", + "text": "我們去中國大陸或者中國大陸來臺灣的人數" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148057/99.wav", + "text": "你剛剛也說差不多是一樣的委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148057/100.wav", + "text": "還有一點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148057/101.wav", + "text": "它是會操控人數的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148057/102.wav", + "text": "2019年從原來的400萬人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148057/103.wav", + "text": "降到剩下187萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148057/104.wav", + "text": "人所以表示大陸方面是把陸客當作" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148057/105.wav", + "text": "你沒有釋出善意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148057/106.wav", + "text": "我講我的結論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148057/107.wav", + "text": "──兩岸如果要增進雙方的彼此瞭解" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148057/108.wav", + "text": "我想開放觀光" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148057/109.wav", + "text": "因為剛才院長也同意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148057/110.wav", + "text": "開放觀光絕對是我們最好的一個態度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148057/111.wav", + "text": "所以開放觀光絕對是最好的交流途徑" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148057/112.wav", + "text": "我真的是建議政府要有更開放的胸襟" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148057/113.wav", + "text": "歡迎大陸朋友來臺灣走走看看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148057/114.wav", + "text": "來看看臺灣民主自由的發展" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148057/115.wav", + "text": "所以我希望陸委會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148057/116.wav", + "text": "要以更開放的思維來看待這件事" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148057/117.wav", + "text": "我們已經很開放了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148057/118.wav", + "text": "我也跟委員補充一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148057/119.wav", + "text": "像我們的自由行的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148057/120.wav", + "text": "我們早就開���" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148057/121.wav", + "text": "了但是他們還是沒有來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148057/122.wav", + "text": "所以我覺得我們是有足夠的信心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148057/123.wav", + "text": "我們歡迎陸客來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148057/124.wav", + "text": "現在沒有信心讓我們臺灣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148057/125.wav", + "text": "我們要展現我們善意的一個態度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148057/126.wav", + "text": "院長我問你第二個問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148057/127.wav", + "text": "我想台積電進駐竹科龍潭園區" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148057/128.wav", + "text": "看起來好像是已經破局了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148057/129.wav", + "text": "如果破局我們新竹縣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148057/130.wav", + "text": "有一個竹科三期的計畫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148057/131.wav", + "text": "我們是舉雙手來歡迎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148057/132.wav", + "text": "因為我們新竹縣現在有現成的合適地點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148057/133.wav", + "text": "就是我一直提到的竹科三期" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148057/134.wav", + "text": "我們現在改稱竹東鎮（工" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148057/135.wav", + "text": "院暨附近地區）特定區都市計畫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148057/136.wav", + "text": "院長知道這塊土地" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148057/137.wav", + "text": "在民國70年就被新竹科學園區" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148057/138.wav", + "text": "框定為特定區" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148057/139.wav", + "text": "但是到現在都還沒有開發" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148057/140.wav", + "text": "也沒有解編" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148057/141.wav", + "text": "以及附近的居民可以說叫苦連天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148057/142.wav", + "text": "當初被新竹科學園區匡定為特定區" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148057/143.wav", + "text": "原本就是作為新竹科學園區" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148057/144.wav", + "text": "變更為竹東鎮（工" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148057/145.wav", + "text": "院暨附近地區）特定區都市計畫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148057/146.wav", + "text": "我們每一個會期都在質詢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148057/147.wav", + "text": "到底這個案子還要拖多久" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148057/148.wav", + "text": "因為我們的民眾真的已經快炸鍋了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148057/149.wav", + "text": "快受不了了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148057/150.wav", + "text": "到底行政院支不支持這個案子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148057/151.wav", + "text": "就我的瞭解" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148057/152.wav", + "text": "這個案子新竹縣政府" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148057/153.wav", + "text": "正在加強溝通當中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148057/154.wav", + "text": "監察院也曾經糾正區段徵收的必要性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148057/155.wav", + "text": "合理性跟公益性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148057/156.wav", + "text": "以及客家文化還有歷史文化建築保存的情形" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148057/157.wav", + "text": "當地的民眾也有不同的反對意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148057/158.wav", + "text": "現在整個問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148057/159.wav", + "text": "是縣政府應該針對竹科三期這個計畫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148057/160.wav", + "text": "跟民眾好好的溝通" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148057/161.wav", + "text": "地方政府都沒有能力解決就很困難" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148057/162.wav", + "text": "把責任推給地方政府" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148057/163.wav", + "text": "我告訴你" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148057/164.wav", + "text": "我跟委員報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148057/165.wav", + "text": "全世界都知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148057/166.wav", + "text": "新竹縣市擁有傲視全球的半導體供應鏈" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148057/167.wav", + "text": "台積電也是全球半導體晶圓代工的龍頭" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148057/168.wav", + "text": "我想這個大家都知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148057/169.wav", + "text": "他們需要的供應商都在新竹" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148057/170.wav", + "text": "我們近年來看到台積電又徵收新竹縣寶山" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148057/171.wav", + "text": "作為他們研發三奈米" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148057/172.wav", + "text": "跟研發中心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148057/173.wav", + "text": "三奈米製程的用地" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148057/174.wav", + "text": "都把新竹設為第一首選" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148057/175.wav", + "text": "所以我問院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148057/176.wav", + "text": "請問你是否支持將竹科三期土地" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148057/177.wav", + "text": "作為台積電先進製程的用地" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148057/178.wav", + "text": "如果土地的問題可以解決的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148057/179.wav", + "text": "當然沒有問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148057/180.wav", + "text": "我上個禮拜去的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148057/181.wav", + "text": "他們也跟我提到這個問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148057/182.wav", + "text": "他們對於龍潭沒有辦法爭取到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148057/183.wav", + "text": "也很失望" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148057/184.wav", + "text": "但是我也很誠實地告訴他" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148057/185.wav", + "text": "們地方政府要負起責任" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148057/186.wav", + "text": "現在臺中科學園區" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148057/187.wav", + "text": "橋頭科學園區" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148057/188.wav", + "text": "高雄科學園區都歡迎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148057/189.wav", + "text": "而且土地都已經徵收得差不多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148057/190.wav", + "text": "所以地方政府很重要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148057/191.wav", + "text": "竹科二期也被內政部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148057/192.wav", + "text": "都市審查小組打回票" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148057/193.wav", + "text": "了其實我是要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148057/194.wav", + "text": "部長我現在是要為竹科三期爭取" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148057/195.wav", + "text": "希望行政院及內政部要重視這塊用地" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148057/196.wav", + "text": "明明這塊用地" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148057/197.wav", + "text": "當時因為部分地主反對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148057/198.wav", + "text": "一直延宕到現在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148057/199.wav", + "text": "你認為這四十幾年大家沒有努力嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148057/200.wav", + "text": "大家都在努力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148057/201.wav", + "text": "但是我就覺得很奇怪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148057/202.wav", + "text": "為什麼大家一直努力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148057/203.wav", + "text": "每一個會期新竹縣政府也配合" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148057/204.wav", + "text": "配合審查小組的意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148057/205.wav", + "text": "它退回來我們就重新補做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148057/206.wav", + "text": "依���它的意見整個補正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148057/207.wav", + "text": "但是還是一直被打回票" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148057/208.wav", + "text": "我不曉得行政院或者內政部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148057/209.wav", + "text": "是真心願意支持這個案子嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148057/210.wav", + "text": "尤其台積電現在又這麼委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148057/211.wav", + "text": "我跟你報告一下兩個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148057/212.wav", + "text": "第一個我們的都市計畫是兩級制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148057/213.wav", + "text": "中央政府是一級" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148057/214.wav", + "text": "第二個是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148057/215.wav", + "text": "第一個是都市計畫的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148057/216.wav", + "text": "必須要處理好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148057/217.wav", + "text": "才有辦法走到後面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148057/218.wav", + "text": "因為這個計畫的面積" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148057/219.wav", + "text": "有四百零多公頃" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148057/220.wav", + "text": "然後要區段徵收314公頃" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148057/221.wav", + "text": "這麼多細節" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148057/222.wav", + "text": "我們現在暫時不談" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148057/223.wav", + "text": "你支不支持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148057/224.wav", + "text": "你的政策支不支持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148057/225.wav", + "text": "它土地問題必須先解決" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148057/226.wav", + "text": "嘛委員我跟你報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148057/227.wav", + "text": "我們今年四月份" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148057/228.wav", + "text": "還針對這個案子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148057/229.wav", + "text": "開過一次會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148057/230.wav", + "text": "它必須針對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148057/231.wav", + "text": "所以您的態度是支持的嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148057/232.wav", + "text": "我你到底支不支持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148057/233.wav", + "text": "因為四十幾年都無解" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148057/234.wav", + "text": "到底行政院支不支持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148057/235.wav", + "text": "啦我覺得我這樣問比較清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148057/236.wav", + "text": "就不會來來去去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148057/237.wav", + "text": "所以院長你是支持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148057/238.wav", + "text": "但是縣政府要把該做的事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148057/239.wav", + "text": "所以院長我希望" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148057/240.wav", + "text": "我們在整個都市" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148057/241.wav", + "text": "如果新竹縣政府哪一部分沒有做好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148057/242.wav", + "text": "一次講清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148057/243.wav", + "text": "啦不是這樣來來回回" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148057/244.wav", + "text": "委員委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148057/245.wav", + "text": "我已經講得很清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148057/246.wav", + "text": "現在就是地方政府" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148057/247.wav", + "text": "送來的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148057/248.wav", + "text": "有些時候都沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148057/249.wav", + "text": "按照審查的意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148057/250.wav", + "text": "很用心在做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148057/251.wav", + "text": "推給地方政府" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148057/252.wav", + "text": "還有一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148057/253.wav", + "text": "我再講另外一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148057/254.wav", + "text": "就是竹北的臺灣知識經濟園區" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148057/255.wav", + "text": "也是一樣的情形" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148057/256.wav", + "text": "這個園區被歸類為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148057/257.wav", + "text": "我們國家的重大建設計畫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148057/258.wav", + "text": "也已經延宕了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148057/259.wav", + "text": "二十九年快三十年了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148057/260.wav", + "text": "那院長你支不支持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148057/261.wav", + "text": "臺灣知識經濟園區的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148057/262.wav", + "text": "臺知園區" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148057/263.wav", + "text": "是新竹縣政府" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148057/264.wav", + "text": "在負責的一個工作" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148057/265.wav", + "text": "這整個進度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148057/266.wav", + "text": "我曉得縣政府" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148057/267.wav", + "text": "還是按照審議的意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148057/268.wav", + "text": "我還是希望您從" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148057/269.wav", + "text": "整個國家的一個大方" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148057/270.wav", + "text": "向因為這個叫做國家重大建設" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148057/271.wav", + "text": "院長我只是想請教你" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148057/272.wav", + "text": "您支不支持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148057/273.wav", + "text": "這一個國家重大建設計畫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148057/274.wav", + "text": "政府支持任何一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148057/275.wav", + "text": "可以使臺灣高科技產業" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148057/276.wav", + "text": "所以您願意支持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148057/277.wav", + "text": "所以您願意協助" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148057/278.wav", + "text": "地方政府把整個都市計畫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148057/279.wav", + "text": "你儘速的讓他去完成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148057/280.wav", + "text": "協助他完成都市計畫的審議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148057/281.wav", + "text": "我們是努力在協助" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148057/282.wav", + "text": "是不是應該去協助他" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148057/283.wav", + "text": "所以才會提出" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148057/284.wav", + "text": "我們是努力在協助" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148057/285.wav", + "text": "所以才會提出審議的意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148057/286.wav", + "text": "嘛地方政府應該按照審議的意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148057/287.wav", + "text": "來做更好的規劃" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148057/288.wav", + "text": "政府是一直希望大家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148057/289.wav", + "text": "所以院長您也支持就對了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148057/290.wav", + "text": "這個案子您也我支持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148057/291.wav", + "text": "但是地方政府要努力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148057/292.wav", + "text": "該修改的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148057/293.wav", + "text": "院長我真的是苦口婆心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148057/294.wav", + "text": "啦我一直覺得我們新竹縣市" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148057/295.wav", + "text": "一個重要科技走廊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148057/296.wav", + "text": "但是這兩個產業園區" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148057/297.wav", + "text": "我們民眾或者地方政府" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148057/298.wav", + "text": "癡癡的在等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148057/299.wav", + "text": "已經等到白髮蒼蒼了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148057/300.wav", + "text": "附近的這些民眾跟我講說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148057/301.wav", + "text": "我還要再等十年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148057/302.wav", + "text": "還是要再等二十年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148057/303.wav", + "text": "我都已經升天了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148057/304.wav", + "text": "縣政府加油啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148057/305.wav", + "text": "趕快協調民眾反對的意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148057/306.wav", + "text": "能夠取得共識" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148057/307.wav", + "text": "然後大家一起來努力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148057/308.wav", + "text": "所以院長我希望" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148057/309.wav", + "text": "院長及部長在政策面上去宣示" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148057/310.wav", + "text": "你們支持這個案子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148057/311.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148057/312.wav", + "text": "不好謝謝林委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148057/313.wav", + "text": "內政組的質詢已經" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148056/0.wav", + "text": "院長大家午安" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148056/1.wav", + "text": "是不是還是請陳建仁院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148056/2.wav", + "text": "院長請" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148056/3.wav", + "text": "林委員午安" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148056/4.wav", + "text": "陳院長午安" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148056/5.wav", + "text": "最近在我的選區裡面有兩個都市計畫審查的案子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148056/6.wav", + "text": "中央有問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148056/7.wav", + "text": "一個就是我們蘆洲蘆南蘆北農業區的專案通盤檢討" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148056/8.wav", + "text": "一個是銀新未來城" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148056/9.wav", + "text": "就是要將文中用地變更為衛生福利特定專用區" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148056/10.wav", + "text": "他們對外發布的新聞老是說我們在卡人家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148056/11.wav", + "text": "那這個到底是怎麼一回事" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148056/12.wav", + "text": "好我請內政部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148056/13.wav", + "text": "我跟委員報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148056/14.wav", + "text": "中央不會去卡地方的案子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148056/15.wav", + "text": "剛剛你提到的蘆南蘆北其實最重要的原因是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148056/16.wav", + "text": "相關的委員其實有許多的意見跟建議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148056/17.wav", + "text": "甚至包括相關的社會福利" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148056/18.wav", + "text": "社會住宅等等所占的比例跟面積必須要提高" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148056/19.wav", + "text": "中央的期待是至少要10%" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148056/20.wav", + "text": "不過現在比例是只有5%以下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148056/21.wav", + "text": "因為我們從2020年受理到現在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148056/22.wav", + "text": "據我所知都市計畫委員會專案小組審了6次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148056/23.wav", + "text": "然後同時我們也開始土徵小組的審查也審了2次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148056/24.wav", + "text": "如果我可以參加我本人一定會出席" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148056/25.wav", + "text": "如果不能參加我也會以書面去表達我的意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148056/26.wav", + "text": "我們的土徵小組或是都市計畫的委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148056/27.wav", + "text": "其實也很認真在審查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148056/28.wav", + "text": "他們提出來的問題很多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148056/29.wav", + "text": "我看了會議紀錄以後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148056/30.wav", + "text": "但是經常地方政府其實是沒有回應的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148056/31.wav", + "text": "就是他們的回應都可能拖了幾個月以後才回答" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148056/32.wav", + "text": "這樣時間當然就拖到了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148056/33.wav", + "text": "專業委員所提出的疑問都沒有回答出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148056/34.wav", + "text": "即便回答了新北市政府的回應也是沒有談清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148056/35.wav", + "text": "剛剛講的幾點其實也包括設計不周全" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148056/36.wav", + "text": "譬如說在全部157公頃裡面社宅僅規劃2公頃" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148056/37.wav", + "text": "大家都覺得還不到5%" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148056/38.wav", + "text": "另外再來就是它提出一個銀河灣計畫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148056/39.wav", + "text": "在銀河灣計畫裡面要把我們的三重果菜批發市場搬進來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148056/40.wav", + "text": "那裡面加一個會展中心加一個觀光遊憩設施" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148056/41.wav", + "text": "未來引入的產業交通人流廢物水的量體" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148056/42.wav", + "text": "還有遊憩的人潮規模你的評估你的規劃你的處理上要說明清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148056/43.wav", + "text": "據我所知其實他們再補充進來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148056/44.wav", + "text": "在區段徵收這個案的關聯性都要補充進來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148056/45.wav", + "text": "拖很多的時間也沒有講清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148056/46.wav", + "text": "其中銀河灣計畫內含市場用地" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148056/47.wav", + "text": "也沒有說明該用地的設施設置的必要性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148056/48.wav", + "text": "還有該用地及觀光遊憩設施所衍生的交通量等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148056/49.wav", + "text": "它說明都不完整" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148056/50.wav", + "text": "\n特別是銀河灣計畫裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148056/51.wav", + "text": "如果三重果菜市場批發市場移到我們蘆洲來的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148056/52.wav", + "text": "整體交通動線的規劃產生的交通流量對我們地方交通的衝擊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148056/53.wav", + "text": "它統統都沒有說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148056/54.wav", + "text": "所以在這種狀況裡面當然土徵小組還有談到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148056/55.wav", + "text": "地方政府的財務規劃不清" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148056/56.wav", + "text": "有關批發市場用地醫療用地等9項以外的公設用地評估" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148056/57.wav", + "text": "都以無償方法的撥供需地機關使用是否妥適" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148056/58.wav", + "text": "另外針對這個徵收的市價土地處分的價格等等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148056/59.wav", + "text": "也是要檢視它的合理性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148056/60.wav", + "text": "中央其實很認真在審" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148056/61.wav", + "text": "也在提醒地方政府規劃上的問題和盲點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148056/62.wav", + "text": "還有沒有補充的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148056/63.wav", + "text": "可是大概就是這樣子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148056/64.wav", + "text": "地方政府都沒有正面回應我們的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148056/65.wav", + "text": "回應的也是答非所問或是拖延時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148056/66.wav", + "text": "以我們蘆洲地方來講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148056/67.wav", + "text": "我們希望你不能讓我們未蒙其利先受其害" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148056/68.wav", + "text": "所以草草的趕快就讓它通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148056/69.wav", + "text": "儘速通過就代表說有重視地方的發展" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148056/70.wav", + "text": "還是說我們不能夠讓一個新的都市計畫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148056/71.wav", + "text": "反而變成是一個退步的城市" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148056/72.wav", + "text": "造成城市退步" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148056/73.wav", + "text": "或者說造成城市進步的阻礙" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148056/74.wav", + "text": "這個交通沒辦法出入嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148056/75.wav", + "text": "是嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148056/76.wav", + "text": "委員你說到很關鍵的重點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148056/77.wav", + "text": "如果有什麼問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148056/78.wav", + "text": "或是有什麼建議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148056/79.wav", + "text": "這個地方政府一定要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148056/80.wav", + "text": "如果能夠一次把所有的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148056/81.wav", + "text": "都能夠答復的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148056/82.wav", + "text": "這個速度就會快了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148056/83.wav", + "text": "所以拖的是地方政府" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148056/84.wav", + "text": "如果地方政府推拖拉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148056/85.wav", + "text": "拉沒有辦法提出很好的規劃" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148056/86.wav", + "text": "那這樣子委員的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148056/87.wav", + "text": "我們審查委員的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148056/88.wav", + "text": "沒有得到很好的答復的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148056/89.wav", + "text": "當然這整個期程就會受到影響" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148056/90.wav", + "text": "所以這件事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148056/91.wav", + "text": "我覺得我們也希望" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148056/92.wav", + "text": "地方政府能夠認真的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148056/93.wav", + "text": "就委員所提出來的這些問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148056/94.wav", + "text": "包括委員你剛才所提的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148056/95.wav", + "text": "這都是很關鍵的東西" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148056/96.wav", + "text": "他們一定要能夠答復" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148056/97.wav", + "text": "不能閃避" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148056/98.wav", + "text": "對因為都市計畫重新檢討" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148056/99.wav", + "text": "它非常重要的地方" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148056/100.wav", + "text": "是要讓住在這裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148056/101.wav", + "text": "在蘆洲這裡生活的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148056/102.wav", + "text": "這塊土地的生活機能" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148056/103.wav", + "text": "是變得更好而且更完善" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148056/104.wav", + "text": "我們在這裡就是說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148056/105.wav", + "text": "如果一個地方的政府" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148056/106.wav", + "text": "草草地提出了一個都市計畫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148056/107.wav", + "text": "然後它所規劃的內容" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148056/108.wav", + "text": "事實上是草率的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148056/109.wav", + "text": "然後就要求我們要快速通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148056/110.wav", + "text": "然後就表示說有在做事" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148056/111.wav", + "text": "如果他們不回應我們地方的質疑" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148056/112.wav", + "text": "譬如我剛剛一直在講的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148056/113.wav", + "text": "銀河灣計畫裡面的批發市場" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148056/114.wav", + "text": "批發市場它最重要的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148056/115.wav", + "text": "它最澈底的就是選址錯誤" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148056/116.wav", + "text": "\n我要講說進入我們蘆洲" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148056/117.wav", + "text": "蘆洲的聯外道路" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148056/118.wav", + "text": "其實都要透過三重" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148056/119.wav", + "text": "要嘛就要經過橋梁" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148056/120.wav", + "text": "可是從這幾年的調查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148056/121.wav", + "text": "不論聯外的橋梁" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148056/122.wav", + "text": "橋下的孝義路到疏洪北路到這樣出去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148056/123.wav", + "text": "或是我們永安橋對外的聯外橋梁" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148056/124.wav", + "text": "或是五股四維路要到三重" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148056/125.wav", + "text": "或者是從三重三和路四段" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148056/126.wav", + "text": "這樣子要出去外面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148056/127.wav", + "text": "整個不論晨峰或昏峰" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148056/128.wav", + "text": "我剛剛講的這幾個路口" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148056/129.wav", + "text": "都是嚴重塞車的道路服務水準" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148056/130.wav", + "text": "是F級的現況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148056/131.wav", + "text": "如果再加上105十多公頃" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148056/132.wav", + "text": "要新增加的人口" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148056/133.wav", + "text": "那還會帶來多少車潮和人潮以外" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148056/134.wav", + "text": "批發市場他們說沒關係" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148056/135.wav", + "text": "批發市場的作息" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148056/136.wav", + "text": "跟一般人的正常作息是錯開的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148056/137.wav", + "text": "可是據我們所知不是這樣子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148056/138.wav", + "text": "根據臺北第一果菜市場" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148056/139.wav", + "text": "批發市場的調查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148056/140.wav", + "text": "大貨車進場時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148056/141.wav", + "text": "是下午3點到凌晨2點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148056/142.wav", + "text": "離場的時間是下午4點到凌晨3點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148056/143.wav", + "text": "採購車來買菜的販仔車" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148056/144.wav", + "text": "早上5點到9點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148056/145.wav", + "text": "然後離場的時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148056/146.wav", + "text": "事實上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148056/147.wav", + "text": "也是在上班時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148056/148.wav", + "text": "也就是說南部上來的菜車" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148056/149.wav", + "text": "的來批發市場" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148056/150.wav", + "text": "採購要回去零售市場賣的販仔車" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148056/151.wav", + "text": "早上上班時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148056/152.wav", + "text": "又跟我們是重疊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148056/153.wav", + "text": "我們所有的聯外交通" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148056/154.wav", + "text": "都是F等級了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148056/155.wav", + "text": "如果我們根據新北市現況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148056/156.wav", + "text": "三重果菜市場進出的車輛調查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148056/157.wav", + "text": "大貨車集中是在晚上的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148056/158.wav", + "text": "7點到凌晨3點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148056/159.wav", + "text": "機車是凌晨2點到9點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148056/160.wav", + "text": "也是晚上零點到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148056/161.wav", + "text": "所以看得出來販仔車" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148056/162.wav", + "text": "跟我們上班時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148056/163.wav", + "text": "都是重疊的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148056/164.wav", + "text": "作息並沒有錯開" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148056/165.wav", + "text": "都是重疊的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148056/166.wav", + "text": "上下班都高度重疊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148056/167.wav", + "text": "那我們在說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148056/168.wav", + "text": "它所規劃的交通動線" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148056/169.wav", + "text": "它要我們進到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148056/170.wav", + "text": "果菜批發市場" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148056/171.wav", + "text": "以疏洪道當主要的交通動線" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148056/172.wav", + "text": "可是我要告訴部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148056/173.wav", + "text": "我們疏洪道就以今年為例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148056/174.wav", + "text": "因為豪雨封閉了疏洪十路" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148056/175.wav", + "text": "及其以北部分只出不進" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148056/176.wav", + "text": "8月4號又封閉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148056/177.wav", + "text": "8月10號又封閉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148056/178.wav", + "text": "8月16號又封閉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148056/179.wav", + "text": "8月20號又封閉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148056/180.wav", + "text": "9月1號又封閉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148056/181.wav", + "text": "10月3號又封閉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148056/182.wav", + "text": "所以我們光是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148056/183.wav", + "text": "今年從6月到現在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148056/184.wav", + "text": "就有7次的堤外道路封閉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148056/185.wav", + "text": "甚至封閉有的不只一天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148056/186.wav", + "text": "啦所以我的意思是說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148056/187.wav", + "text": "它的交通動線規劃" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148056/188.wav", + "text": "成這樣子也是災難一場" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148056/189.wav", + "text": "勢必它沒有走疏洪道離場進場" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148056/190.wav", + "text": "到最後就要走我們市區道路" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148056/191.wav", + "text": "而現在市區道路是高度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148056/192.wav", + "text": "跟住民的生活重疊的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148056/193.wav", + "text": "道路服務水準都是F等級的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148056/194.wav", + "text": "所以我們的意思是說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148056/195.wav", + "text": "不要草率的規劃" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148056/196.wav", + "text": "不當的選址" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148056/197.wav", + "text": "要���中央馬上通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148056/198.wav", + "text": "然後禍害住在蘆洲這裡的人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148056/199.wav", + "text": "我們就未蒙其利先受其害" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148056/200.wav", + "text": "所以我們希望要共創雙贏" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148056/201.wav", + "text": "我們要新的都市計畫的規劃檢討" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148056/202.wav", + "text": "然後我們也要完善的配套" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148056/203.wav", + "text": "而不是這樣子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148056/204.wav", + "text": "人家就直接對我們說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148056/205.wav", + "text": "你們中央在卡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148056/206.wav", + "text": "中央要講出一個理由" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148056/207.wav", + "text": "我是說你們應該要可以講得出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148056/208.wav", + "text": "是我跟委員報告一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148056/209.wav", + "text": "你剛剛講得都非常正確" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148056/210.wav", + "text": "今天如果沒有規劃好的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148056/211.wav", + "text": "其實它會變成一場災難" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148056/212.wav", + "text": "地方政府必須要負起責任" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148056/213.wav", + "text": "如果是我們審議的委員提的意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148056/214.wav", + "text": "然後回去之後你也不改" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148056/215.wav", + "text": "又重新送到內政部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148056/216.wav", + "text": "不改責任說是你在卡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148056/217.wav", + "text": "那我們沒有辦法審" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148056/218.wav", + "text": "因為委員已經給了意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148056/219.wav", + "text": "你又不修改" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148056/220.wav", + "text": "又原案送回來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148056/221.wav", + "text": "說實在這不是一個負責任的作法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148056/222.wav", + "text": "因為委員提的基本上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148056/223.wav", + "text": "你可以有一些修正的意見沒有關係" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148056/224.wav", + "text": "但是應該要依照委員的意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148056/225.wav", + "text": "去做相關的調整" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148056/226.wav", + "text": "這樣子案子才有辦法往前進" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148056/227.wav", + "text": "對現在還有一個案子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148056/228.wav", + "text": "大家也說中央的進度落後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148056/229.wav", + "text": "已經放了8個月" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148056/230.wav", + "text": "就是銀新未來城" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148056/231.wav", + "text": "這個銀新未來城當然就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148056/232.wav", + "text": "我們的國中用地" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148056/233.wav", + "text": "因為海砂屋所以遷建了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148056/234.wav", + "text": "留了一個2.5公頃" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148056/235.wav", + "text": "很大的一塊基地" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148056/236.wav", + "text": "它本來要做衛生福利特定專用區" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148056/237.wav", + "text": "我們大家都樂見其成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148056/238.wav", + "text": "因為畢竟參考各個地方" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148056/239.wav", + "text": "很多熟齡居住公共服務" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148056/240.wav", + "text": "還有醫療資源要進來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148056/241.wav", + "text": "我們是多麼的樂觀其成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148056/242.wav", + "text": "啊可是我們發現它" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148056/243.wav", + "text": "它也說你們還在那裡爭議很多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148056/244.wav", + "text": "我們看到它的爭議裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148056/245.wav", + "text": "它的規劃是要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148056/246.wav", + "text": "構想住宿式的長照" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148056/247.wav", + "text": "至少200床" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148056/248.wav", + "text": "但是它的日照服務" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148056/249.wav", + "text": "只有要服務60人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148056/250.wav", + "text": "2.5公頃" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148056/251.wav", + "text": "的日照服務量能是60人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148056/252.wav", + "text": "我們周遭好幾萬的人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148056/253.wav", + "text": "其實老舊的公寓人口老化" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148056/254.wav", + "text": "三重相對於蘆洲" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148056/255.wav", + "text": "當然人口相對是老化的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148056/256.wav", + "text": "大家都會想我老了怎麼辦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148056/257.wav", + "text": "又少子化" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148056/258.wav", + "text": "所以大家都非常期待" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148056/259.wav", + "text": "衛生福利特定專用區" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148056/260.wav", + "text": "事實上可以有日照中心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148056/261.wav", + "text": "就是附服務的友善高齡住宅" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148056/262.wav", + "text": "我們都可以支持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148056/263.wav", + "text": "結果它現在提的是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148056/264.wav", + "text": "全齡友善附服務的居住環境" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148056/265.wav", + "text": "至少500戶" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148056/266.wav", + "text": "我覺得全齡也是一種趨勢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148056/267.wav", + "text": "也不一定要全部都說高齡才可以住" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148056/268.wav", + "text": "但是它要500戶" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148056/269.wav", + "text": "它所占的樓地板面積是相當多的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148056/270.wav", + "text": "我們可以理解" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148056/271.wav", + "text": "如果政府沒有錢的話就做BOT" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148056/272.wav", + "text": "但如果自償性太低" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148056/273.wav", + "text": "也沒有人要來做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148056/274.wav", + "text": "當然要給他們一點誘因" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148056/275.wav", + "text": "我們知道他所提出來的方案中附" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148056/276.wav", + "text": "附服務的友善高齡住宅" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148056/277.wav", + "text": "是高齡化社會的住宅趨勢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148056/278.wav", + "text": "臺北市住都中心和民間企業" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148056/279.wav", + "text": "以公辦都更的方式辦理了一塊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148056/280.wav", + "text": "臺北市信義兒福A1公辦都更" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148056/281.wav", + "text": "它也是主打全齡友善出租宅" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148056/282.wav", + "text": "但是它裡面有一個東西就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148056/283.wav", + "text": "市價打八折的友善高齡社宅" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148056/284.wav", + "text": "我們以前講的社宅大概是給年輕人的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148056/285.wav", + "text": "給經濟弱勢的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148056/286.wav", + "text": "現在我們要提供一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148056/287.wav", + "text": "附服務的友善高齡住宅" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148056/288.wav", + "text": "但也要有打八折的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148056/289.wav", + "text": "而不要把它變成是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148056/290.wav", + "text": "有錢人才能住得起的養生村" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148056/291.wav", + "text": "嘛現在在這裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148056/292.wav", + "text": "的全齡友善住宅" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148056/293.wav", + "text": "其實我們也不要質疑它" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148056/294.wav", + "text": "因為人家要BOT要蓋得下去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148056/295.wav", + "text": "也是必要的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148056/296.wav", + "text": "它現在都是要自付的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148056/297.wav", + "text": "有打折還是社會住宅的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148056/298.wav", + "text": "或是社會住宅精神的友善高齡的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148056/299.wav", + "text": "它現在室內如果10坪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148056/300.wav", + "text": "室內面積如果是17.8坪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148056/301.wav", + "text": "要租2萬5,500" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148056/302.wav", + "text": "室內面積如果有26坪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148056/303.wav", + "text": "可是我拿剛才的臺北市" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148056/304.wav", + "text": "信義區兒福A1公辦都更" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148056/305.wav", + "text": "主打全齡友善住宅來比較" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148056/306.wav", + "text": "人家是有打折的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148056/307.wav", + "text": "所以我們希望有兩個訴求" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148056/308.wav", + "text": "你們的日照中心不能只有60人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148056/309.wav", + "text": "要有打折" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148056/310.wav", + "text": "要至少有打八折的這種社會宅概念" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148056/311.wav", + "text": "\n高齡的人沒有生產力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148056/312.wav", + "text": "沒有賺錢的能力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148056/313.wav", + "text": "他們的租金更應該要被優惠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148056/314.wav", + "text": "而不是有錢人才住得起才住得進來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148056/315.wav", + "text": "所以這個地方是要讓社區的大家都雨露均霑" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148056/316.wav", + "text": "是不是朝這個方向儘速支持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148056/317.wav", + "text": "好謝謝林委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148056/318.wav", + "text": "\n接下來請林委員思銘質詢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148055/0.wav", + "text": "謝謝院長我們請陳院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148055/1.wav", + "text": "院長請" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148055/2.wav", + "text": "黃委員午安" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148055/3.wav", + "text": "院長午安" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148055/4.wav", + "text": "院長我記得上一次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148055/5.wav", + "text": "彰化整個人口不斷地在下降" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148055/6.wav", + "text": "大部分都是移到六都" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148055/7.wav", + "text": "外移人口有70%是移到臺中市" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148055/8.wav", + "text": "今天我希望針對彰化幾個重大建設" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148055/9.wav", + "text": "因為有幾個重大建設" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148055/10.wav", + "text": "我記得上一次也曾詢問過院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148055/11.wav", + "text": "對於彰化市的一些重大建設" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148055/12.wav", + "text": "一定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148055/13.wav", + "text": "委員很關心彰化的整個發展" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148055/14.wav", + "text": "也一再地對我們有所督促" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148055/15.wav", + "text": "我們一定會按照委員所要求的方向" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148055/16.wav", + "text": "再來就是年輕勞動力人口也是外移" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148055/17.wav", + "text": "的非常嚴重" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148055/18.wav", + "text": "彰化在這幾年中所推動的幾個重大建設" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148055/19.wav", + "text": "包括彰化市擴大東區都市計畫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148055/20.wav", + "text": "講了十幾年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148055/21.wav", + "text": "彰化鐵路高架也講了將近20年的時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148055/22.wav", + "text": "還有臺中捷運綠線延伸到彰化" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148055/23.wav", + "text": "有關彰化市東區都市計畫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148055/24.wav", + "text": "部分這部分因為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148055/25.wav", + "text": "之前彰化縣政府有針對彰化市東區都市計畫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148055/26.wav", + "text": "後來內政部給它一些建議就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148055/27.wav", + "text": "以單一地主的台化廠區這個部分先開始做規劃" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148055/28.wav", + "text": "又被退回去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148055/29.wav", + "text": "大家就覺得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148055/30.wav", + "text": "彰化市的擴大東區都市計畫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148055/31.wav", + "text": "是不是又胎死腹中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148055/32.wav", + "text": "我是不是可以請教院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148055/33.wav", + "text": "彰化市東區都市計畫是重中之重" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148055/34.wav", + "text": "也是非常重要的都市計畫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148055/35.wav", + "text": "也談了十幾年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148055/36.wav", + "text": "了來來回回真的需要中央的協助與幫忙" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148055/37.wav", + "text": "所以我是不是可以請教院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148055/38.wav", + "text": "未來這個部分你們是否可以協助地方政府" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148055/39.wav", + "text": "能夠儘速先將單一地主的台化廠區這個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148055/40.wav", + "text": "我相信這些都是地方民眾期待的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148055/41.wav", + "text": "是不是可以先請院長針對這個部分回答" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148055/42.wav", + "text": "好如果地方政府" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148055/43.wav", + "text": "──彰化縣政府有提出相關計畫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148055/44.wav", + "text": "詳細情形我是不是請部長簡單說明一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148055/45.wav", + "text": "我想對於地方的建設中央一定是全力支持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148055/46.wav", + "text": "不過也請彰化縣政府要多多努力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148055/47.wav", + "text": "因為相關提案必須由縣政府提上來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148055/48.wav", + "text": "在幾次審議討論的過程裡面其實還有許多意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148055/49.wav", + "text": "最主要還有兩個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148055/50.wav", + "text": "希望縣政府這邊可以再做一些努力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148055/51.wav", + "text": "第一個就是公共設施用地的比例應該還要再提高" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148055/52.wav", + "text": "可能還要再做一些調整" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148055/53.wav", + "text": "在程序上我們都會儘快進行相關的討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148055/54.wav", + "text": "好我們當然也會催促彰化縣政府" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148055/55.wav", + "text": "內政部這邊是不是可以儘速來審查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148055/56.wav", + "text": "我覺得這個真的是拖很久" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148055/57.wav", + "text": "了而且也是地方期待的一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148055/58.wav", + "text": "程序上沒有問題我們會儘快來加速" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148055/59.wav", + "text": "審議不過最重要的是提案的內容" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148055/60.wav", + "text": "因為這個土地的面積非常大" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148055/61.wav", + "text": "有幾百公頃" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148055/62.wav", + "text": "所以涉及到的是土地的合理利用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148055/63.wav", + "text": "另外就是因為這也涉及私人土地取得的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148055/64.wav", + "text": "所以它的必要性跟公益性合理性都必須要兼顧是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148055/65.wav", + "text": "是我剛剛講的東區都市計畫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148055/66.wav", + "text": "其實也牽涉到臺中捷運綠線延伸到彰化" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148055/67.wav", + "text": "的部分它延伸過來就是彰化的東區都市計畫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148055/68.wav", + "text": "案就這樣來來回回也退了好幾次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148055/69.wav", + "text": "最主要的原因也是因為東區都市計畫的關係" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148055/70.wav", + "text": "記得在第4次他們送行政院的可行性研究計畫當中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148055/71.wav", + "text": "表達希望東區都市計畫跟捷運能夠分開同步進行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148055/72.wav", + "text": "不要因為東區都市計畫卡住" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148055/73.wav", + "text": "針對這個部分是不是可以都市計畫的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148055/74.wav", + "text": "跟捷運綠線是分開而不是把它綁在一起" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148055/75.wav", + "text": "可行性研究報告現在已經送到行政院也" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148055/76.wav", + "text": "但是當然也要看它這個研究報告的內容" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148055/77.wav", + "text": "我們一定會請國發會加速審查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148055/78.wav", + "text": "好因為從可行性評估通過之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148055/79.wav", + "text": "還要綜合規劃還要環評" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148055/80.wav", + "text": "這個預計可能也要好幾年至少67年的時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148055/81.wav", + "text": "如果這個時間再拖的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148055/82.wav", + "text": "讓地方的發展能夠加速" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148055/83.wav", + "text": "對在我們審查的過程當中如果有什麼需要修改的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148055/84.wav", + "text": "我們一定會跟地方好好的溝通" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148055/85.wav", + "text": "這整個綜合規劃的內容" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148055/86.wav", + "text": "經核定完以後還要9年才會完工" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148055/87.wav", + "text": "委員很急著要為縣民爭取福利" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148055/88.wav", + "text": "實際上中央政府也很樂觀其成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148055/89.wav", + "text": "我們看看它的可行性研究報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148055/90.wav", + "text": "做好以後我們就趕快來核定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148055/91.wav", + "text": "好再一個就是鐵路高架" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148055/92.wav", + "text": "我記得從我擔任" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148055/93.wav", + "text": "任立委第一屆的第一個會期" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148055/94.wav", + "text": "就在講彰化鐵路高架" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148055/95.wav", + "text": "蘇貞昌院長有到地方表明行政院已經核定了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148055/96.wav", + "text": "到現在也已經一年半的時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148055/97.wav", + "text": "來來回回的我看到的就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148055/98.wav", + "text": "全體工作小組會議開了好幾次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148055/99.wav", + "text": "可能開了4次5次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148055/100.wav", + "text": "因為這個如果整個規劃完之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148055/101.wav", + "text": "一直到完工 也要12年的時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148055/102.wav", + "text": "也將近20年的時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148055/103.wav", + "text": "從我當議員的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148055/104.wav", + "text": "講到現在我當立委第二屆了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148055/105.wav", + "text": "是不是可以加速" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148055/106.wav", + "text": "如果可以完成的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148055/107.wav", + "text": "我跟委員報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148055/108.wav", + "text": "實際上我們交通部正在積極的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148055/109.wav", + "text": "跟地方政府協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148055/110.wav", + "text": "因為這裡面有關於基地的位置" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148055/111.wav", + "text": "這些東西都還沒有確定下來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148055/112.wav", + "text": "需要達成共識" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148055/113.wav", + "text": "我們會跟地方政府好好地溝通" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148055/114.wav", + "text": "也是按照7月17日的初步協調結果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148055/115.wav", + "text": "在研究當中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148055/116.wav", + "text": "所以我們預計在今年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148055/117.wav", + "text": "11月3號就是下個禮拜" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148055/118.wav", + "text": "就會召開第5次全體工作會議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148055/119.wav", + "text": "我們希望跟彰化縣政府" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148055/120.wav", + "text": "那我們就能夠往前走" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148055/121.wav", + "text": "我們也是很急著大家要往前走" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148055/122.wav", + "text": "但是這需要地方政府也一起來努力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148055/123.wav", + "text": "對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148055/124.wav", + "text": "當然地方政府一定要跟中央一起配合" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148055/125.wav", + "text": "整個重大建設才有辦法去推動" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148055/126.wav", + "text": "所以我也希望就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148055/127.wav", + "text": "去年行政院已經核定了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148055/128.wav", + "text": "到現在又將近2年的時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148055/129.wav", + "text": "在把重大建設能夠加速來推動" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148055/130.wav", + "text": "可是我希望速度能不能再快一點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148055/131.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148055/132.wav", + "text": "對因為後續還有整個我們整個軌道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148055/133.wav", + "text": "還有我們的機務段──花壇的基地" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148055/134.wav", + "text": "對現在就是這些基地" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148055/135.wav", + "text": "軌道的數目都還沒有講清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148055/136.wav", + "text": "能夠積極來推動整個彰化市的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148055/137.wav", + "text": "不論我剛剛講的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148055/138.wav", + "text": "臺中捷運綠線延伸到彰化" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148055/139.wav", + "text": "或者是我們彰化的鐵路高架" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148055/140.wav", + "text": "這對於整個彰化市的都市發展" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148055/141.wav", + "text": "真的有很大很大的影響" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148055/142.wav", + "text": "尤其是這幾個建設都講了一二十年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148055/143.wav", + "text": "對委員在這方面也花了很大的心力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148055/144.wav", + "text": "不斷地在推動" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148055/145.wav", + "text": "我們謝謝您的督促" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148055/146.wav", + "text": "另外一個就是我們會很努力的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148055/147.wav", + "text": "鐵道局好好地趕快跟地方政府達成共識" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148055/148.wav", + "text": "一定要有共識" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148055/149.wav", + "text": "我們會催促他們儘快完" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148055/150.wav", + "text": "有些時候的等待" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148055/151.wav", + "text": "還要再12年的時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148055/152.wav", + "text": "要加速" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148055/153.wav", + "text": "如果能夠加速" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148055/154.wav", + "text": "但是這一定也要地方政府" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148055/155.wav", + "text": "我們有時候是在等地方政府" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148055/156.wav", + "text": "送他們的研究報告出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148055/157.wav", + "text": "還有要修改的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148055/158.wav", + "text": "希望若是有什麼要修改的地方" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148055/159.wav", + "text": "他們也要趕快送" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148055/160.wav", + "text": "就是中央跟地方一定要全力來配合" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148055/161.wav", + "text": "不然我剛剛講的人口外移" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148055/162.wav", + "text": "人口外移其實有一個很大的原因" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148055/163.wav", + "text": "就是整個都市計畫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148055/164.wav", + "text": "整個交通的便利性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148055/165.wav", + "text": "如果可以更完善的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148055/166.wav", + "text": "把人留在彰化" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148055/167.wav", + "text": "所以我在這邊也拜託院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148055/168.wav", + "text": "拜託能夠督促一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148055/169.wav", + "text": "綠線延伸這兩件事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148055/170.wav", + "text": "行政院都當成很重要的工作" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148055/171.wav", + "text": "和國發會加速來跟地方政府" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148055/172.wav", + "text": "我們會全力以赴" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148055/173.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148055/174.wav", + "text": "就覺得好像被遺忘一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148055/175.wav", + "text": "沒有我們沒有遺忘" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148055/176.wav", + "text": "委員在我們不敢遺忘" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148055/177.wav", + "text": "一個重大建設講了一二十年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148055/178.wav", + "text": "感覺好像都沒有一個進展" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148055/179.wav", + "text": "另外一個對於彰化來說很大的建設" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148055/180.wav", + "text": "烏溪的河濱公園在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148055/181.wav", + "text": "前幾年原本也預計" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148055/182.wav", + "text": "要在大肚溪的河畔" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148055/183.wav", + "text": "烏溪河濱" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148055/184.wav", + "text": "當時原本已經要做了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148055/185.wav", + "text": "可是剛好遇到百年大旱" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148055/186.wav", + "text": "所以經濟部水利署就在烏溪旁邊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148055/187.wav", + "text": "能夠儘速完成烏溪的河濱公園" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148055/188.wav", + "text": "院長這邊能夠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148055/189.wav", + "text": "來協助" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148055/190.wav", + "text": "讓彰化有一個比較大型的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148055/191.wav", + "text": "因為彰化幾乎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148055/192.wav", + "text": "都沒有大型的場地" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148055/193.wav", + "text": "所以我們也期待在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148055/194.wav", + "text": "在彰化這邊能夠有一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148055/195.wav", + "text": "就是烏溪的河濱公園" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148055/196.wav", + "text": "所以也拜託院長能夠來協助" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148055/197.wav", + "text": "讓我們彰化能夠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148055/198.wav", + "text": "有一個讓" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148055/199.wav", + "text": "的地方然後又可以讓孩子們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148055/200.wav", + "text": "在假日的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148055/201.wav", + "text": "有一個好的去處" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148055/202.wav", + "text": "好水利署第三" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148055/203.wav", + "text": "好好謝謝黃委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148055/204.wav", + "text": "接下來請林委員淑芬質詢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148054/0.wav", + "text": "謝謝院長我想請陳院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148054/1.wav", + "text": "院長好院長每次雞蛋風波政府都說要打擊黑市" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148054/2.wav", + "text": "你可以看到這一張表上面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148054/3.wav", + "text": "宣稱說黑市價格猖獗" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148054/4.wav", + "text": "一顆雞蛋高達9塊錢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148054/5.wav", + "text": "啦這個是在今年初的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148054/6.wav", + "text": "我相信院長對這些簡報內容跟說過的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148054/7.wav", + "text": "應該還是記憶猶新" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148054/8.wav", + "text": "民眾確實買不到便宜的雞蛋" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148054/9.wav", + "text": "但當時政府也說要啟動物價穩定小組" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148054/10.wav", + "text": "啦我想請教院長一個非常簡單的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148054/11.wav", + "text": "請問行政院穩定物價小組查得如何" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148054/12.wav", + "text": "成效如何" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148054/13.wav", + "text": "政府一直宣稱的黑市到底有沒有查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148054/14.wav", + "text": "法務部跟警政署都有在積極的查緝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148054/15.wav", + "text": "但是因為後來雞蛋的價格" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148054/16.wav", + "text": "在我們開始引進進口雞蛋以後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148054/17.wav", + "text": "確實是有一個平穩的價格出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148054/18.wav", + "text": "在進口雞蛋進來以後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148054/19.wav", + "text": "對院長我跟你講這個相關的規範" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148054/20.wav", + "text": "事實上行政院有籌組" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148054/21.wav", + "text": "就像你講的由法務部主責的物價聯合稽查小組" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148054/22.wav", + "text": "這可以透過刑法第205條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148054/23.wav", + "text": "的規定處三年以下有期徒刑等等之類的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148054/24.wav", + "text": "農業部也可以根據農產品市場交易法第6條來處罰" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148054/25.wav", + "text": "再來公平會也可以有一個叫做防制人為操縱物價專案小組" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148054/26.wav", + "text": "的部分院長過去兩年的檢舉數高達188件" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148054/27.wav", + "text": "你可以看到這個圖表" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148054/28.wav", + "text": "到最後這三個相關的法制度規範" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148054/29.wav", + "text": "開罰的件數通通都是零" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148054/30.wav", + "text": "有喔但是通通沒有半件" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148054/31.wav", + "text": "開罰院長我真的想要請教" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148054/32.wav", + "text": "然後我們也立法也修法賦予政府公權力去查處了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148054/33.wav", + "text": "還是有黑市然後人家來檢舉的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148054/34.wav", + "text": "根本都沒有去查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148054/35.wav", + "text": "不確實大家可以看得到那一段時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148054/36.wav", + "text": "雞蛋的價格是有上來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148054/37.wav", + "text": "有人檢舉以後我們就去稽查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148054/38.wav", + "text": "院長稽查的結果到最後開罰數是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148054/39.wav", + "text": "零件因為農業部的宣稱都已經說得非常清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148054/40.wav", + "text": "一顆雞蛋高達9塊錢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148054/41.wav", + "text": "所以人家一百零兩百件的檢舉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148054/42.wav", + "text": "到最後有這麼多的機制也修法了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148054/43.wav", + "text": "然後開罰的件數是零件" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148054/44.wav", + "text": "我們把雞蛋買回來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148054/45.wav", + "text": "政府把雞蛋買回來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148054/46.wav", + "text": "買到過期放到過期" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148054/47.wav", + "text": "這才是最大的囤蛋商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148054/48.wav", + "text": "結果到現在價格沒有穩住" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148054/49.wav", + "text": "還是一樣的攀" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148054/50.wav", + "text": "查緝本身就有讓價格回穩這樣一個功效" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148054/51.wav", + "text": "因為後來價格平穩以後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148054/52.wav", + "text": "查緝異常囤積的狀況確實就會減少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148054/53.wav", + "text": "院長如果有黑市的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148054/54.wav", + "text": "就應該積極去執法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148054/55.wav", + "text": "我們是很認真去查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148054/56.wav", + "text": "的然後也有執法的認���" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148054/57.wav", + "text": "然後一顆蛋9塊錢等等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148054/58.wav", + "text": "如果到最後抓不到任何黑市" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148054/59.wav", + "text": "那不就跟放羊孩子一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148054/60.wav", + "text": "未來民眾要怎麼相信政府" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148054/61.wav", + "text": "所以應該要積極去查緝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148054/62.wav", + "text": "查緝的過程當中會讓" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148054/63.wav", + "text": "囤積的雞蛋釋出" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148054/64.wav", + "text": "使得價錢合理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148054/65.wav", + "text": "你去查緝的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148054/66.wav", + "text": "我不相信有這麼多的機制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148054/67.wav", + "text": "下到最後的結果是沒有任何一件" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148054/68.wav", + "text": "違反了相關的法規範" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148054/69.wav", + "text": "這是大家所不能夠接受的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148054/70.wav", + "text": "除非根本就不存在黑市" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148054/71.wav", + "text": "我剛才已經講過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148054/72.wav", + "text": "蛋價就會平穩下來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148054/73.wav", + "text": "查緝是很積極" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148054/74.wav", + "text": "再來我想請教公益揭發保護法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148054/75.wav", + "text": "事實上時力黨團在2017年的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148054/76.wav", + "text": "就率先提出過這樣的法案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148054/77.wav", + "text": "因為這個非常重要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148054/78.wav", + "text": "也是司法改革國是會議裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148054/79.wav", + "text": "非常重要的結論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148054/80.wav", + "text": "確實" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148054/81.wav", + "text": "在經過3年的審議之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148054/82.wav", + "text": "在第9屆的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148054/83.wav", + "text": "它沒辦法完成審議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148054/84.wav", + "text": "在這一屆的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148054/85.wav", + "text": "我們也率先" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148054/86.wav", + "text": "到現在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148054/87.wav", + "text": "民進黨也不願意提出" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148054/88.wav", + "text": "自己的院版" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148054/89.wav", + "text": "自己的院版的情況之下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148054/90.wav", + "text": "也沒辦法審" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148054/91.wav", + "text": "那我們到底要等多久" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148054/92.wav", + "text": "在討論的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148054/93.wav", + "text": "因為當時是公私部門" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148054/94.wav", + "text": "兩個都有涵蓋" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148054/95.wav", + "text": "後來我們就希望能夠讓公部門" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148054/96.wav", + "text": "跟上櫃上市公司" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148054/97.wav", + "text": "院長你上次的回答是會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148054/98.wav", + "text": "儘速送到行政院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148054/99.wav", + "text": "會討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148054/100.wav", + "text": "那問題來了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148054/101.wav", + "text": "現在已經是最後一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148054/102.wav", + "text": "會期了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148054/103.wav", + "text": "請問短時間內" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148054/104.wav", + "text": "送到行政院會討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148054/105.wav", + "text": "具體的時間表" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148054/106.wav", + "text": "是什麼是什麼時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148054/107.wav", + "text": "因為現在各界有不同的看法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148054/108.wav", + "text": "特別是企業界" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148054/109.wav", + "text": "院長各界有不同的看法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148054/110.wav", + "text": "這個上一屆行政院就已經送進來了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148054/111.wav", + "text": "現在即便各界有不同看法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148054/112.wav", + "text": "也已經經過3年了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148054/113.wav", + "text": "如果說我們為了這樣的一個爭點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148054/114.wav", + "text": "還沒有辦法送進來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148054/115.wav", + "text": "這是大家沒辦法接受的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148054/116.wav", + "text": "就是因為送來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148054/117.wav", + "text": "在大院裡面沒有辦法審查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148054/118.wav", + "text": "通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148054/119.wav", + "text": "就是因為各界的意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148054/120.wav", + "text": "還沒有共識" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148054/121.wav", + "text": "沒有民進黨過不了的法案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148054/122.wav", + "text": "有多少的法案送進來之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148054/123.wav", + "text": "它還是會保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148054/124.wav", + "text": "並不是說全案都通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148054/125.wav", + "text": "啊是要經過審議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148054/126.wav", + "text": "沒有錯" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148054/127.wav", + "text": "那你現在連送到行政院院會都沒辦法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148054/128.wav", + "text": "從行政院要送到立法院來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148054/129.wav", + "text": "所以我現在要確定的就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148054/130.wav", + "text": "短時間內送到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148054/131.wav", + "text": "行政院院會討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148054/132.wav", + "text": "上次院長也講了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148054/133.wav", + "text": "因為這個會期12月底" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148054/134.wav", + "text": "那這一屆就結束了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148054/135.wav", + "text": "這個案子目前還在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148054/136.wav", + "text": "我們行政院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148054/137.wav", + "text": "審議討論的過程中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148054/138.wav", + "text": "那什麼時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148054/139.wav", + "text": "是說幾個禮拜" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148054/140.wav", + "text": "還是說要一個月" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148054/141.wav", + "text": "我沒有辦法給你一個時間表" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148054/142.wav", + "text": "院長你這樣講大家沒辦法接受" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148054/143.wav", + "text": "啦那是不是可以說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148054/144.wav", + "text": "行政院院會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148054/145.wav", + "text": "然後讓行政院院會有一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148054/146.wav", + "text": "共識通過之後在您主持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148054/147.wav", + "text": "之下能夠送���立法院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148054/148.wav", + "text": "我們會盡最大的努力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148054/149.wav", + "text": "因為現在已經10月底了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148054/150.wav", + "text": "對啦我們會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148054/151.wav", + "text": "盡最大的努力來讓" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148054/152.wav", + "text": "各方的意見都能夠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148054/153.wav", + "text": "建立一個共識" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148054/154.wav", + "text": "院長如果說到最後結果你還是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148054/155.wav", + "text": "不願意把它送到立法院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148054/156.wav", + "text": "來的話大家會認為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148054/157.wav", + "text": "根本就在打假球嘛根本沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148054/158.wav", + "text": "這個決心嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148054/159.wav", + "text": "沒有不是這樣的意思我們要建立好共識" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148054/160.wav", + "text": "但是這個揭弊者保護法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148054/161.wav", + "text": "的條文我們也會放在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148054/162.wav", + "text": "各個不同的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148054/163.wav", + "text": "法案當中我舉一個例子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148054/164.wav", + "text": "像現在我們在修消防法的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148054/165.wav", + "text": "我們也把揭弊者保護" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148054/166.wav", + "text": "的條文放在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148054/167.wav", + "text": "在討論的就是這一個公益揭發" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148054/168.wav", + "text": "保護法已經3年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148054/169.wav", + "text": "過去了如果說連行政院院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148054/170.wav", + "text": "會都沒有辦法通過即便" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148054/171.wav", + "text": "有爭點大家都同意嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148054/172.wav", + "text": "有爭點送進來之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148054/173.wav", + "text": "在立法院審議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148054/174.wav", + "text": "沒有辦法達成共識的會保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148054/175.wav", + "text": "那以這樣的方式每一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148054/176.wav", + "text": "法案都是這樣處理並" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148054/177.wav", + "text": "沒有特別例外所以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148054/178.wav", + "text": "院長真的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148054/179.wav", + "text": "啦短時間內就應該要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148054/180.wav", + "text": "送進來大家能夠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148054/181.wav", + "text": "有一個討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148054/182.wav", + "text": "我們來加速審議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148054/183.wav", + "text": "院長再來就是我想跟你討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148054/184.wav", + "text": "寡婦樓的弊案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148054/185.wav", + "text": "這個脈絡就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148054/186.wav", + "text": "的時候國防部政治作戰局" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148054/187.wav", + "text": "用活化眷村的名義" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148054/188.wav", + "text": "手上的眷村土地" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148054/189.wav", + "text": "這一件是委託內政部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148054/190.wav", + "text": "的五個案子總面積" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148054/191.wav", + "text": "超過7公頃寡婦樓就是其中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148054/192.wav", + "text": "院長我請你一定要特別注意一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148054/193.wav", + "text": "國防部在新竹市的這一些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148054/194.wav", + "text": "都更案許多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148054/195.wav", + "text": "都有非常大的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148054/196.wav", + "text": "其中這一件非常" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148054/197.wav", + "text": "通過然後呢它也" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148054/198.wav", + "text": "拿到這個案子但是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148054/199.wav", + "text": "當時主辦都更招商的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148054/200.wav", + "text": "營建署城鄉分署" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148054/201.wav", + "text": "分署長洪嘉宏" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148054/202.wav", + "text": "106年時被法院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148054/203.wav", + "text": "兩千萬的賄款" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148054/204.wav", + "text": "收了兩千萬然後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148054/205.wav", + "text": "都更案索賄4005百萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148054/206.wav", + "text": "而且判決書寫得非常清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148054/207.wav", + "text": "這個分署長是主動" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148054/208.wav", + "text": "去跟廠商講說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148054/209.wav", + "text": "我現在手上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148054/210.wav", + "text": "有這個案件" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148054/211.wav", + "text": "你們把錢拿來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148054/212.wav", + "text": "這個在臺北地院的判決書" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148054/213.wav", + "text": "裡面都說得非常清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148054/214.wav", + "text": "八年兩個月那這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148054/215.wav", + "text": "案件為什麼只有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148054/216.wav", + "text": "這一家通過其實就是我剛剛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148054/217.wav", + "text": "講的因為洪嘉宏掌握" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148054/218.wav", + "text": "了資格審查中的所有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148054/219.wav", + "text": "所以他就讓" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148054/220.wav", + "text": "昌益集團拿下這個都更案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148054/221.wav", + "text": "也就是說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148054/222.wav", + "text": "從招商開始" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148054/223.wav", + "text": "才會只剩下一家根本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148054/224.wav", + "text": "不是透過公開透明的方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148054/225.wav", + "text": "也毫無正當性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148054/226.wav", + "text": "我質詢過國防部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148054/227.wav", + "text": "案件委託給內政部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148054/228.wav", + "text": "辦理所以最近" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148054/229.wav", + "text": "有發文給內政部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148054/230.wav", + "text": "要不要撤案應該" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148054/231.wav", + "text": "來決定我問內政部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148054/232.wav", + "text": "林部長部長說這是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148054/233.wav", + "text": "國防部委託的本來就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148054/234.wav", + "text": "國防部要決定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148054/235.wav", + "text": "這一件案件" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148054/236.wav", + "text": "行政院是不是可以做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148054/237.wav", + "text": "決定都已經因為貪污" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148054/238.wav", + "text": "污問題被判刑了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148054/239.wav", + "text": "而且是因為貪污" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148054/240.wav", + "text": "標案院長你的態度是什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148054/241.wav", + "text": "我的態度是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148054/242.wav", + "text": "我會請這" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148054/243.wav", + "text": "兩個部會馬上來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148054/244.wav", + "text": "處理相關的後續" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148054/245.wav", + "text": "對院長現在的狀況是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148054/246.wav", + "text": "國防部把它推給內政部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148054/247.wav", + "text": "而內政部的說法是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148054/248.wav", + "text": "我是受你委辦的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148054/249.wav", + "text": "你不決定怎麼會叫我決定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148054/250.wav", + "text": "對此有非常清楚的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148054/251.wav", + "text": "規範所以我不知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148054/252.wav", + "text": "為什麼這樣一個案件還能夠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148054/253.wav", + "text": "繼續這樣推諉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148054/254.wav", + "text": "諉政府採購法第5條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148054/255.wav", + "text": "公正之違反法令行為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148054/256.wav", + "text": "撤銷決標終止契約" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148054/257.wav", + "text": "或解除契約" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148054/258.wav", + "text": "一個招商舞弊的都更案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148054/259.wav", + "text": "政府不是應該要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148054/260.wav", + "text": "趕快撤案嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148054/261.wav", + "text": "部會裡有許多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148054/262.wav", + "text": "案件假設有類似相關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148054/263.wav", + "text": "情況的話相關部會都是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148054/264.wav", + "text": "撤案的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148054/265.wav", + "text": "如果你還不撤的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148054/266.wav", + "text": "不就告訴臺灣社會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148054/267.wav", + "text": "這些奸商官商勾結" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148054/268.wav", + "text": "然後勾結舞弊都沒關係" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148054/269.wav", + "text": "反正最後拿到手了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148054/270.wav", + "text": "即使被查到了被判刑了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148054/271.wav", + "text": "最後還是可以繼續賺" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148054/272.wav", + "text": "還是可以繼續做院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148054/273.wav", + "text": "這個事情我剛才已經講過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148054/274.wav", + "text": "我們會請國防部與內政部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148054/275.wav", + "text": "最佳的處理方法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148054/276.wav", + "text": "委員我跟你報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148054/277.wav", + "text": "代國防部回答" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148054/278.wav", + "text": "不過我們有看到相關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148054/279.wav", + "text": "其實國防部在回應時也有特別提到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148054/280.wav", + "text": "會依法來終止" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148054/281.wav", + "text": "所以這是國防部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148054/282.wav", + "text": "責成內政部與國防部討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148054/283.wav", + "text": "出一個決定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148054/284.wav", + "text": "請院長一定要親自去瞭解這部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148054/285.wav", + "text": "是不是一週內請行政院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148054/286.wav", + "text": "就如何處理提出" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148054/287.wav", + "text": "我們儘快完成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148054/288.wav", + "text": "完成後就送給委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148054/289.wav", + "text": "好謝謝院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148053/0.wav", + "text": "謝謝主席可不可以請一下陳院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148053/1.wav", + "text": "陳院長請" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148053/2.wav", + "text": "孔委員早" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148053/3.wav", + "text": "陳院長早安" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148053/4.wav", + "text": "我想先請教一下院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148053/5.wav", + "text": "今天是跟原住民關係很重大的一個日子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148053/6.wav", + "text": "不知道院長知不知道今天10月27" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148053/7.wav", + "text": "我不太清楚抱歉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148053/8.wav", + "text": "你都不是很清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148053/9.wav", + "text": "你知不知道今天是什麼日子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148053/10.wav", + "text": "還有內政部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148053/11.wav", + "text": "今天對原住民是一個有很重大意義的日子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148053/12.wav", + "text": "是什麼日子你知道嗎10月27日" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148053/13.wav", + "text": "林部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148053/14.wav", + "text": "跟委員報告今天是霧社事件" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148053/15.wav", + "text": "所以還是原民會夷將主委答對了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148053/16.wav", + "text": "今天10月27日" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148053/17.wav", + "text": "是霧社事件抗日93週年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148053/18.wav", + "text": "民國19年1930年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148053/19.wav", + "text": "霧社事件的一個抗日起義紀念碑" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148053/20.wav", + "text": "那邊有一個紀念儀式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148053/21.wav", + "text": "但是因為今天是總質詢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148053/22.wav", + "text": "我為什麼要問院長今天這個日子呢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148053/23.wav", + "text": "上一次因為卡努颱風" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148053/24.wav", + "text": "災情非常慘重" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148053/25.wav", + "text": "我知道部長也有去廬山溫泉嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148053/26.wav", + "text": "林部長也有去廬山溫泉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148053/27.wav", + "text": "要怎麼坐" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148053/28.wav", + "text": "坐影片我都有看到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148053/29.wav", + "text": "林部長也是很早就過去了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148053/30.wav", + "text": "很早就到廬山溫泉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148053/31.wav", + "text": "我老家就是在廬山溫泉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148053/32.wav", + "text": "那個馬黑坡的地方" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148053/33.wav", + "text": "馬黑坡就是以前莫那‧魯道的出生地" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148053/34.wav", + "text": "但是那邊橋也不通" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148053/35.wav", + "text": "路也斷了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148053/36.wav", + "text": "然後還土石流" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148053/37.wav", + "text": "可以說整個都傾洩" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148053/38.wav", + "text": "現在底下的旅館都被埋沒" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148053/39.wav", + "text": "本來是2樓變1樓" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148053/40.wav", + "text": "現在是4樓變1樓" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148053/41.wav", + "text": "現在那個橋" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148053/42.wav", + "text": "我們還正要做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148053/43.wav", + "text": "不管是仁愛鄉的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148053/44.wav", + "text": "蘭嶼是小犬颱風" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148053/45.wav", + "text": "兩個鄉都是遭遇到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148053/46.wav", + "text": "百年來最大的風災" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148053/47.wav", + "text": "我想陳院長跟部長有去過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148053/48.wav", + "text": "你們蘭嶼有沒有去關心過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148053/49.wav", + "text": "有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148053/50.wav", + "text": "蘭嶼在上次小犬風災之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148053/51.wav", + "text": "我就有請部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148053/52.wav", + "text": "然後用跨部會的力量" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148053/53.wav", + "text": "來協助他們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148053/54.wav", + "text": "簡單說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148053/55.wav", + "text": "我知道你有去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148053/56.wav", + "text": "啦我在你後面去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148053/57.wav", + "text": "的因為你可以搭直升機" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148053/58.wav", + "text": "我不能搭直升機" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148053/59.wav", + "text": "我是坐船的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148053/60.wav", + "text": "是跟委員報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148053/61.wav", + "text": "我在大前天的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148053/62.wav", + "text": "去了蘭嶼第二趟" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148053/63.wav", + "text": "這也是院長特別指示" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148053/64.wav", + "text": "在災後重建跨部會的整合之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148053/65.wav", + "text": "去看一下現在執行的情形" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148053/66.wav", + "text": "我們目前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148053/67.wav", + "text": "救急的部分已經完成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148053/68.wav", + "text": "那個先不要談" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148053/69.wav", + "text": "開元港的漁船翻覆" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148053/70.wav", + "text": "開元港的漁船" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148053/71.wav", + "text": "有的有牌照" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148053/72.wav", + "text": "有的沒牌照" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148053/73.wav", + "text": "沒牌照的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148053/74.wav", + "text": "很多都是原住民的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148053/75.wav", + "text": "達悟族" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148053/76.wav", + "text": "的那個部分我們要怎麼補" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148053/77.wav", + "text": "達悟族文化一" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148053/78.wav", + "text": "一個很重要的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148053/79.wav", + "text": "不要分有照或無照" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148053/80.wav", + "text": "我剛才講這是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148053/81.wav", + "text": "達悟文化的一個代表性作品" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148053/82.wav", + "text": "我來跟委員補充" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148053/83.wav", + "text": "院長特別指示" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148053/84.wav", + "text": "要從部落經濟的角度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148053/85.wav", + "text": "來看待這個事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148053/86.wav", + "text": "所以我們不會分有照跟無照" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148053/87.wav", + "text": "第一個是舷外機" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148053/88.wav", + "text": "第二種是拼板舟" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148053/89.wav", + "text": "秘書長還要特別再開一次會議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148053/90.wav", + "text": "針對這一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148053/91.wav", + "text": "我知道我在蘭嶼的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148053/92.wav", + "text": "秘書長有主持一個臨時會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148053/93.wav", + "text": "會我現在的重點是我不想花這個時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148053/94.wav", + "text": "這個災害已經發生很多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148053/95.wav", + "text": "本席是第一個坐船到蘭嶼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148053/96.wav", + "text": "關心災情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148053/97.wav", + "text": "秘書長同時在行政院主持一個會議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148053/98.wav", + "text": "我知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148053/99.wav", + "text": "就是針對蘭嶼的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148053/100.wav", + "text": "不只是船" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148053/101.wav", + "text": "整個基礎建設" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148053/102.wav", + "text": "加油站" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148053/103.wav", + "text": "道路" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148053/104.wav", + "text": "整個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148053/105.wav", + "text": "包括仁愛鄉跟蘭嶼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148053/106.wav", + "text": "因為今天是霧社事件抗日" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148053/107.wav", + "text": "真的要關心重視" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148053/108.wav", + "text": "我們偏遠地區的基礎建設" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148053/109.wav", + "text": "好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148053/110.wav", + "text": "我隨便問一個問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148053/111.wav", + "text": "原民會這邊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148053/112.wav", + "text": "山地鄉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148053/113.wav", + "text": "橋梁" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148053/114.wav", + "text": "就像我們廬山溫泉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148053/115.wav", + "text": "怎麼跨到對岸" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148053/116.wav", + "text": "那座橋" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148053/117.wav", + "text": "將來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148053/118.wav", + "text": "我們是不是要做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148053/119.wav", + "text": "跟委員報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148053/120.wav", + "text": "關於橋梁的修復或是興建" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148053/121.wav", + "text": "我們會按照各部會的分工" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148053/122.wav", + "text": "都會積極來處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148053/123.wav", + "text": "全國的山地鄉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148053/124.wav", + "text": "沒有一個部會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148053/125.wav", + "text": "是要做原住民鄉的橋梁" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148053/126.wav", + "text": "現在連吊橋都沒有單位想做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148053/127.wav", + "text": "除非那個是風景區" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148053/128.wav", + "text": "山地鄉的車行橋梁" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148053/129.wav", + "text": "只有原民會有預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148053/130.wav", + "text": "將來我們要做的橋" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148053/131.wav", + "text": "還是很多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148053/132.wav", + "text": "特別���我們原住民鄉鎮的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148053/133.wav", + "text": "氣候變遷" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148053/134.wav", + "text": "從這一岸跨到對岸" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148053/135.wav", + "text": "因為馬赫坡那邊有一些產業" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148053/136.wav", + "text": "我們怎麼做橋過去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148053/137.wav", + "text": "你們在平地地區" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148053/138.wav", + "text": "弄個什麼大津橋" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148053/139.wav", + "text": "弄個什麼橋" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148053/140.wav", + "text": "但是在原住民鄉鎮" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148053/141.wav", + "text": "只有原民會的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148053/142.wav", + "text": "原住民特色道路橋梁" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148053/143.wav", + "text": "這個經費哪夠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148053/144.wav", + "text": "根本不夠啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148053/145.wav", + "text": "委員我跟你補充" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148053/146.wav", + "text": "那個特色道路是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148053/147.wav", + "text": "原民會來興建橋梁沒有錯" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148053/148.wav", + "text": "但是屬於縣道的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148053/149.wav", + "text": "省道的部分交通部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148053/150.wav", + "text": "還是做統一的處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148053/151.wav", + "text": "現在交通部也不做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148053/152.wav", + "text": "山地鄉的橋都不做了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148053/153.wav", + "text": "院長你可不可以去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148053/154.wav", + "text": "關心一下這個事" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148053/155.wav", + "text": "好我來瞭解" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148053/156.wav", + "text": "山地鄉的橋梁" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148053/157.wav", + "text": "沒有單位要做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148053/158.wav", + "text": "交通部有但交通部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148053/159.wav", + "text": "說只做省道的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148053/160.wav", + "text": "水保局也不做橋啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148053/161.wav", + "text": "那要跟誰要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148053/162.wav", + "text": "只能跟原民會要啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148053/163.wav", + "text": "但原民會的預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148053/164.wav", + "text": "只有78億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148053/165.wav", + "text": "怎麼夠啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148053/166.wav", + "text": "如果確實是在有必要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148053/167.wav", + "text": "興建的情況下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148053/168.wav", + "text": "原民會也可以提出" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148053/169.wav", + "text": "給國發會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148053/170.wav", + "text": "特別是橋梁" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148053/171.wav", + "text": "那個橋一定要有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148053/172.wav", + "text": "第二個我特別請教一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148053/173.wav", + "text": "內政部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148053/174.wav", + "text": "你知道原鄉目前的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148053/175.wav", + "text": "治安怎麼樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148053/176.wav", + "text": "好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148053/177.wav", + "text": "原鄉的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148053/178.wav", + "text": "原住民地區的治安" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148053/179.wav", + "text": "因為原住民的地��非常廣大" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148053/180.wav", + "text": "我沒有辦法說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148053/181.wav", + "text": "每一個鄉的狀況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148053/182.wav", + "text": "從去年你們聯合服勤之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148053/183.wav", + "text": "很多派出所都整併" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148053/184.wav", + "text": "為了警力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148053/185.wav", + "text": "聯合服勤" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148053/186.wav", + "text": "我們現在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148053/187.wav", + "text": "山老鼠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148053/188.wav", + "text": "那警察是要做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148053/189.wav", + "text": "還有一些警力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148053/190.wav", + "text": "像包括仁愛鄉跟尖石鄉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148053/191.wav", + "text": "還要維持清境" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148053/192.wav", + "text": "清境農場和" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148053/193.wav", + "text": "合歡山的那些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148053/194.wav", + "text": "工作要加班勤務等等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148053/195.wav", + "text": "我們原住民部落的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148053/196.wav", + "text": "見警率真的越來越少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148053/197.wav", + "text": "這個部分要怎麼改進" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148053/198.wav", + "text": "我跟委員報告一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148053/199.wav", + "text": "如果是南投的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148053/200.wav", + "text": "我們從10月16號開始" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148053/201.wav", + "text": "還有警專畢業生的派補" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148053/202.wav", + "text": "以及保四總隊的警力支援" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148053/203.wav", + "text": "我們現在讓所屬的分駐派出所" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148053/204.wav", + "text": "有76個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148053/205.wav", + "text": "已經可以回復24小時的運作" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148053/206.wav", + "text": "另外還有5個派出所的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148053/207.wav", + "text": "可以跟鄰近的派出所" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148053/208.wav", + "text": "來進行聯合的服勤" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148053/209.wav", + "text": "83個派出所" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148053/210.wav", + "text": "76個派出所" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148053/211.wav", + "text": "可以24個小時運作" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148053/212.wav", + "text": "仁愛鄉的瑞岩紅香翠巒榮興等派出所" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148053/213.wav", + "text": "這個部分就不是主力的派出所" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148053/214.wav", + "text": "我現在強調的就是這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148053/215.wav", + "text": "我們這部分會陸續" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148053/216.wav", + "text": "看後續警力增補的狀況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148053/217.wav", + "text": "當然也會儘量地來支援" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148053/218.wav", + "text": "有一個問題要請教院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148053/219.wav", + "text": "從我第一屆上任立法院開始" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148053/220.wav", + "text": "為了要加強原住民的警力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148053/221.wav", + "text": "我本來是有建議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148053/222.wav", + "text": "要再繼續重辦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148053/223.wav", + "text": "原住民警員專班特考" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148053/224.wav", + "text": "後來警員專班特考" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148053/225.wav", + "text": "就沒有再辦了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148053/226.wav", + "text": "現在我們山地鄉的派出所" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148053/227.wav", + "text": "都是非原住民比較多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148053/228.wav", + "text": "跟我們溝通什麼都沒問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148053/229.wav", + "text": "幾乎全部都是非原住民多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148053/230.wav", + "text": "原住民警察特別少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148053/231.wav", + "text": "現在我們原住民的公教人員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148053/232.wav", + "text": "警界大概是占三到四成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148053/233.wav", + "text": "所以我想請教院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148053/234.wav", + "text": "目前內政部跟原民會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148053/235.wav", + "text": "跟人事行政總處" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148053/236.wav", + "text": "目前正在研議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148053/237.wav", + "text": "可不可以增加" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148053/238.wav", + "text": "原住民行政警察的類別" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148053/239.wav", + "text": "在原住民特考" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148053/240.wav", + "text": "增加行政警察人員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148053/241.wav", + "text": "這件事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148053/242.wav", + "text": "我知道他們在討論當中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148053/243.wav", + "text": "我是不是請內政部部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148053/244.wav", + "text": "來跟您報告一下進度的情況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148053/245.wav", + "text": "我們是用人機關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148053/246.wav", + "text": "是在考試院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148053/247.wav", + "text": "我們有做了努力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148053/248.wav", + "text": "在111年到112年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148053/249.wav", + "text": "我們警政署曾經有4次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148053/250.wav", + "text": "不過考選部認為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148053/251.wav", + "text": "現在還是停留在十幾年前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148053/252.wav", + "text": "是考選部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148053/253.wav", + "text": "特種考試司的問題嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148053/254.wav", + "text": "還是沒有辦法突破嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148053/255.wav", + "text": "沒有辦法突破" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148053/256.wav", + "text": "可能是你們警政署的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148053/257.wav", + "text": "不是考選部的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148053/258.wav", + "text": "不是不是這個可能不是我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148053/259.wav", + "text": "因為我們有提出我們的建議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148053/260.wav", + "text": "不過考選部認為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148053/261.wav", + "text": "這個答復我在十年前就聽到了啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148053/262.wav", + "text": "到現在還是沒辦法突破" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148053/263.wav", + "text": "是考試院的權責" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148053/264.wav", + "text": "那以行政院的立場" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148053/265.wav", + "text": "如果我們需要有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148053/266.wav", + "text": "特別的原住民行政警察人員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148053/267.wav", + "text": "到原鄉去幫助" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148053/268.wav", + "text": "好的服務的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148053/269.wav", + "text": "那這個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148053/270.wav", + "text": "我們來研議看看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148053/271.wav", + "text": "應該怎麼樣進行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148053/272.wav", + "text": "研議但是考試院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148053/273.wav", + "text": "考選部特種考試司" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148053/274.wav", + "text": "他們是支持的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148053/275.wav", + "text": "十幾年前我協調時是這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148053/276.wav", + "text": "當時警政署是反對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148053/277.wav", + "text": "為什麼呢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148053/278.wav", + "text": "因為它說警察是要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148053/279.wav", + "text": "考訓用合一" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148053/280.wav", + "text": "但是原住民特考就是調查每個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148053/281.wav", + "text": "部會包括外交都有吧" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148053/282.wav", + "text": "司法監獄裡面的這些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148053/283.wav", + "text": "警察的那個都有啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148053/284.wav", + "text": "對但是像外交人員等等這些考試" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148053/285.wav", + "text": "並沒有針對特別的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148053/286.wav", + "text": "不是因為身分別" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148053/287.wav", + "text": "身分別來設這個考試" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148053/288.wav", + "text": "這也就是考試院主要立論的基礎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148053/289.wav", + "text": "我們來考" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148053/290.wav", + "text": "那警察人員裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148053/291.wav", + "text": "我們希望原住民身分的人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148053/292.wav", + "text": "能夠到原鄉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148053/293.wav", + "text": "因為是原住民身分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148053/294.wav", + "text": "不能特別為原住民加開這個特考" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148053/295.wav", + "text": "那原住民行政特考" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148053/296.wav", + "text": "是不是只限原住民身分考" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148053/297.wav", + "text": "這個也是違法的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148053/298.wav", + "text": "委員是不是這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148053/299.wav", + "text": "──因為原則上我們必須尊重考選部的意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148053/300.wav", + "text": "委員關心的這個問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148053/301.wav", + "text": "我們警政署會再來研議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148053/302.wav", + "text": "我希望你們再多努力好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148053/303.wav", + "text": "是我們會來努力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148053/304.wav", + "text": "這個已經最後一個會期了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148053/305.wav", + "text": "禁伐補償" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148053/306.wav", + "text": "受氣候變遷的影響" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148053/307.wav", + "text": "包括很多風災" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148053/308.wav", + "text": "都是在原住民鄉鎮" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148053/309.wav", + "text": "修正通過之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148053/310.wav", + "text": "就開始核發禁伐補償" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148053/311.wav", + "text": "在105年12月16號" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148053/312.wav", + "text": "也有提出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148053/313.wav", + "text": "還有都市計畫區內的保護區" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148053/314.wav", + "text": "風景區" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148053/315.wav", + "text": "��林獎勵跟禁伐補償" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148053/316.wav", + "text": "這是本席提出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148053/317.wav", + "text": "的105年提出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148053/318.wav", + "text": "108年通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148053/319.wav", + "text": "為什麼因為當時行政院都沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148053/320.wav", + "text": "送法案過來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148053/321.wav", + "text": "併案協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148053/322.wav", + "text": "108年通過之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148053/323.wav", + "text": "就開始發放" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148053/324.wav", + "text": "接著2019年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148053/325.wav", + "text": "修法之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148053/326.wav", + "text": "本來是發放每公頃" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148053/327.wav", + "text": "然後增加了補償的區位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148053/328.wav", + "text": "國家公園保護區" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148053/329.wav", + "text": "增加了1,654公頃" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148053/330.wav", + "text": "總共補償的面積是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148053/331.wav", + "text": "6萬7,670公頃" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148053/332.wav", + "text": "總共補償的金額是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148053/333.wav", + "text": "20億3,012萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148053/334.wav", + "text": "但是現在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148053/335.wav", + "text": "我這幾個月" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148053/336.wav", + "text": "都是關心災情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148053/337.wav", + "text": "很多像花蓮卓溪鄉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148053/338.wav", + "text": "南投仁愛鄉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148053/339.wav", + "text": "他們都跟我建議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148053/340.wav", + "text": "補償的金額" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148053/341.wav", + "text": "是不是可以提高" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148053/342.wav", + "text": "建議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148053/343.wav", + "text": "因為我們現在原住民的生活困難" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148053/344.wav", + "text": "非常艱困" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148053/345.wav", + "text": "都運不出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148053/346.wav", + "text": "因為仁愛鄉的高麗菜什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148053/347.wav", + "text": "的運不出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148053/348.wav", + "text": "是不是可以研議提高到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148053/349.wav", + "text": "新臺幣6萬塊錢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148053/350.wav", + "text": "這個部分我想我們會請" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148053/351.wav", + "text": "原民會來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148053/352.wav", + "text": "跟相關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148053/353.wav", + "text": "另外一位委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148053/354.wav", + "text": "我們會研議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148053/355.wav", + "text": "他提出5萬元" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148053/356.wav", + "text": "你當時的答復是什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148053/357.wav", + "text": "我們來研議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148053/358.wav", + "text": "你不是同意他了嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148053/359.wav", + "text": "我們來研議看看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148053/360.wav", + "text": "這樣的情況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148053/361.wav", + "text": "是不是可行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148053/362.wav", + "text": "這個部分需要原民會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148053/363.wav", + "text": "提供相關的資訊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148053/364.wav", + "text": "我們給夷將來回答" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148053/365.wav", + "text": "6萬塊有沒有可能施行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148053/366.wav", + "text": "夷將" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148053/367.wav", + "text": "其實禁伐補償本來是2萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148053/368.wav", + "text": "之後又提升到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148051/0.wav", + "text": "法確定不那" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148051/1.wav", + "text": "地點恐怕都還需要再確認" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148051/2.wav", + "text": "陸委會有關心這個案子嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148051/3.wav", + "text": "副院長已經提告了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148051/4.wav", + "text": "所以我們就由司法單位來做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148051/5.wav", + "text": "要關心一下自己的部屬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148051/6.wav", + "text": "都非常在意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148051/7.wav", + "text": "因為執政黨非常重視國家安全" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148051/8.wav", + "text": "而且" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148051/9.wav", + "text": "當作一個重要的議題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148051/10.wav", + "text": "所以去年在立法院修正了國家安全法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148051/11.wav", + "text": "5月就通過三讀" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148051/12.wav", + "text": "但到現在為止還沒有公告施行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148051/13.wav", + "text": "又要修國家安全法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148051/14.wav", + "text": "若現役的軍人或公務員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148051/15.wav", + "text": "涉及共諜的話要加重刑責二分之一" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148051/16.wav", + "text": "去年5月修正的國家安全法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148051/17.wav", + "text": "到現在還不公布施行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148051/18.wav", + "text": "現在執政黨又要修國家安全法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148051/19.wav", + "text": "這讓大家覺得總喜歡把國家安全" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148051/20.wav", + "text": "這四個字的帽子扣在人家身上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148051/21.wav", + "text": "修法以後就沒人要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148051/22.wav", + "text": "不要讓大家覺得你的愛國" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148051/23.wav", + "text": "賣臺是雷聲大雨點小" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148051/24.wav", + "text": "院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148051/25.wav", + "text": "你怎麼看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148051/26.wav", + "text": "都是在防範境外勢力的介入" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148051/27.wav", + "text": "其實境外勢力講比較直白" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148051/28.wav", + "text": "就是對面的中國大陸" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148051/29.wav", + "text": "請教院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148051/30.wav", + "text": "我們對於國家安全要怎麼維護" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148051/31.wav", + "text": "是不是針對國民黨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148051/32.wav", + "text": "時國家安全很重要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148051/33.wav", + "text": "但針對執政黨就不重要了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148051/34.wav", + "text": "抗中保臺" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148051/35.wav", + "text": "親中賣臺" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148051/36.wav", + "text": "院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148051/37.wav", + "text": "政府的標準在哪裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148051/38.wav", + "text": "您可以說嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148051/39.wav", + "text": "我想���野都受到國家安全法的規範" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148051/40.wav", + "text": "這部分我請陸委會再補充說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148051/41.wav", + "text": "報告委員去年國家安全法修法的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148051/42.wav", + "text": "院長還沒有到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148051/43.wav", + "text": "任當時的修法主要是對國家核心關鍵技術的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148051/44.wav", + "text": "相關人員給予一定程度的管制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148051/45.wav", + "text": "基本上相關單位都已經在進行中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148051/46.wav", + "text": "這是第一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148051/47.wav", + "text": "反而是剛剛您擔心的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148051/48.wav", + "text": "部分是在國家機密保護法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148051/49.wav", + "text": "國家機密保護法在上個禮拜" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148051/50.wav", + "text": "院長主持的院會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148051/51.wav", + "text": "已經通過了要送到大院來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148051/52.wav", + "text": "再請委員多多支持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148051/53.wav", + "text": "所以這一個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148051/54.wav", + "text": "是國家機密保護法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148051/55.wav", + "text": "就是國家安全" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148051/56.wav", + "text": "來院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148051/57.wav", + "text": "請教一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148051/58.wav", + "text": "提出來啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148051/59.wav", + "text": "有人把相關資料" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148051/60.wav", + "text": "我們潛艦的資料" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148051/61.wav", + "text": "送到中共大使館" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148051/62.wav", + "text": "這是他自己講的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148051/63.wav", + "text": "您對於這件事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148051/64.wav", + "text": "有沒有請蔡總統" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148051/65.wav", + "text": "我們的三軍統帥" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148051/66.wav", + "text": "讓黃曙光上將把誰賣臺" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148051/67.wav", + "text": "你現在前面講了一大堆" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148051/68.wav", + "text": "重視國家安全" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148051/69.wav", + "text": "不希望有人賣臺" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148051/70.wav", + "text": "但是你自己現在的上將" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148051/71.wav", + "text": "講出來有人賣臺" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148051/72.wav", + "text": "這已經在進行調查了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148051/73.wav", + "text": "已經在進行調查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148051/74.wav", + "text": "所以我們希望" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148051/75.wav", + "text": "賣臺跟國安" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148051/76.wav", + "text": "不要有藍綠或者政黨的差異" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148051/77.wav", + "text": "我相信所有的朝野政黨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148051/78.wav", + "text": "都是很重視國家的安全" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148051/79.wav", + "text": "而且也都是希望" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148051/80.wav", + "text": "或者國家關鍵設施的保護也好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148051/81.wav", + "text": "都是很關心的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148051/82.wav", + "text": "所以不論朝野" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148051/83.wav", + "text": "我相信大家都同樣的努力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148051/84.wav", + "text": "院長我知道你很難答" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148051/85.wav", + "text": "但是黃曙光上將提到這一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148051/86.wav", + "text": "都已經講這麼白了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148051/87.wav", + "text": "表示他知道是誰" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148051/88.wav", + "text": "你們真的應該請他" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148051/89.wav", + "text": "好好的把他講出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148051/90.wav", + "text": "來下一個問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148051/91.wav", + "text": "這個已經在偵辦了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148051/92.wav", + "text": "我們要相信司法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148051/93.wav", + "text": "\n院長請教一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148051/94.wav", + "text": "今年7月" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148051/95.wav", + "text": "行政院有一位政務委員離職" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148051/96.wav", + "text": "災防辦主任也調任參事" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148051/97.wav", + "text": "請問院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148051/98.wav", + "text": "這是什麼樣的原因" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148051/99.wav", + "text": "呢是生涯規劃嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148051/100.wav", + "text": "還是另外有內幕" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148051/101.wav", + "text": "當時他離職的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148051/102.wav", + "text": "他告訴我說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148051/103.wav", + "text": "是個人的生涯規劃" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148051/104.wav", + "text": "所以他就請辭" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148051/105.wav", + "text": "我也慰留他" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148051/106.wav", + "text": "但是後來他還是決議要離開" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148051/107.wav", + "text": "院長據本席的瞭解" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148051/108.wav", + "text": "性騷擾#MeToo事件" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148051/109.wav", + "text": "所以在這個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148051/110.wav", + "text": "本席想要請教" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148051/111.wav", + "text": "行政院內的性騷擾#MeToo事件" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148051/112.wav", + "text": "有沒有召開" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148051/113.wav", + "text": "申訴評議委員會會議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148051/114.wav", + "text": "有沒有懲處" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148051/115.wav", + "text": "還是這個案件" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148051/116.wav", + "text": "就壓下來無疾而終" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148051/117.wav", + "text": "您知道這事嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148051/118.wav", + "text": "我知道這件事" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148051/119.wav", + "text": "但是這件事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148051/120.wav", + "text": "實際上本院也有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148051/121.wav", + "text": "進行相關事件的瞭解" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148051/122.wav", + "text": "後來我們也召開了性平會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148051/123.wav", + "text": "性平會的結論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148051/124.wav", + "text": "就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148051/125.wav", + "text": "對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148051/126.wav", + "text": "就是因為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148051/127.wav", + "text": "有這件事還是沒有這件事" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148051/128.wav", + "text": "我們就存案了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148051/129.wav", + "text": "那性平會的結論是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148051/130.wav", + "text": "有發生#MeToo還是沒發生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148051/131.wav", + "text": "有結論嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148051/132.wav", + "text": "這個我需要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148051/133.wav", + "text": "所以你有保密的作法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148051/134.wav", + "text": "但是本席要提醒院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148051/135.wav", + "text": "各個單位機關都可能發生#MeToo性騷擾事件" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148051/136.wav", + "text": "但是絕對不能護短" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148051/137.wav", + "text": "沒有護短" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148051/138.wav", + "text": "而且我們都是完全按照性平委員會的規定來辦理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148051/139.wav", + "text": "所以院長一定要堅持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148051/140.wav", + "text": "對於性騷擾#MeToo零容忍" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148051/141.wav", + "text": "這個您可以保證嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148051/142.wav", + "text": "好瞭解" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148051/143.wav", + "text": "下一個議題因為時間很短" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148051/144.wav", + "text": "院長請教一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148051/145.wav", + "text": "羅森伯格重申" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148051/146.wav", + "text": "包括不支持臺灣獨立" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148051/147.wav", + "text": "請教行政院的態度是怎麼樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148051/148.wav", + "text": "我想大家都很清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148051/149.wav", + "text": "維持兩岸的和平" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148051/150.wav", + "text": "是我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148051/151.wav", + "text": "總統在國慶日的時候也講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148051/152.wav", + "text": "這是兩岸需要的共識" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148051/153.wav", + "text": "所以維持兩岸的和平當然很重要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148051/154.wav", + "text": "維持現狀當然是很重要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148051/155.wav", + "text": "需要雙方一起來努力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148051/156.wav", + "text": "單方面的破壞現狀不是我們樂見的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148051/157.wav", + "text": "而且這不只是對於兩岸有所損害" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148051/158.wav", + "text": "更重要的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148051/159.wav", + "text": "是也會使得全世界都受到影響" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148051/160.wav", + "text": "全世界的福祉也會受到傷害" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148051/161.wav", + "text": "院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148051/162.wav", + "text": "過去大家解讀美方所講的話都是說反對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148051/163.wav", + "text": "單方面改變現狀" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148051/164.wav", + "text": "是指反對中國大陸改變" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148051/165.wav", + "text": "但這一次羅森伯格特別指出" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148051/166.wav", + "text": "美國是不支持臺灣獨立" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148051/167.wav", + "text": "這跟現在執政黨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148051/168.wav", + "text": "的黨綱" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148051/169.wav", + "text": "及執政黨的立場" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148051/170.wav", + "text": "有非常大的差異" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148051/171.wav", + "text": "所以本席想要請教" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148051/172.wav", + "text": "你們對於美方講出這樣的話的立場" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148051/173.wav", + "text": "是什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148051/174.wav", + "text": "你是接受" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148051/175.wav", + "text": "還是聽而不聞" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148051/176.wav", + "text": "羅森伯格也有強調" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148051/177.wav", + "text": "要堅定對臺的安全承諾" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148051/178.wav", + "text": "而且他也希望" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148051/179.wav", + "text": "對於兩岸的現狀" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148051/180.wav", + "text": "雙方都要為共同維護" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148051/181.wav", + "text": "在這樣的前提下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148051/182.wav", + "text": "他才說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148051/183.wav", + "text": "不支持臺獨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148051/184.wav", + "text": "講的是不支持臺獨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148051/185.wav", + "text": "但本席的解讀就是反臺獨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148051/186.wav", + "text": "現在要請教行政院要如何因應" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148051/187.wav", + "text": "我們的因應很簡單" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148051/188.wav", + "text": "我們繼續維持現狀" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148051/189.wav", + "text": "繼續努力釋出善意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148051/190.wav", + "text": "來跟" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148051/191.wav", + "text": "做很好的民主對等的對話交流" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148051/192.wav", + "text": "是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148051/193.wav", + "text": "院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148051/194.wav", + "text": "是你對於美方相關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148051/195.wav", + "text": "臺美的關係" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148051/196.wav", + "text": "到現在為止是最好的狀況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148051/197.wav", + "text": "要加強我們的國防自主" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148051/198.wav", + "text": "也給予很多支持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148051/199.wav", + "text": "大家都知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148051/200.wav", + "text": "維持印太地區的開放" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148051/201.wav", + "text": "及自由相當重要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148051/202.wav", + "text": "所以我們是朝著這個目的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148051/203.wav", + "text": "也跟全世界大多數" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148051/204.wav", + "text": "自由民主國家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148051/205.wav", + "text": "希望兩岸能夠繼續" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148051/206.wav", + "text": "前外長楊榮文說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148051/207.wav", + "text": "在中美之間東協不會選邊站" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148051/208.wav", + "text": "請教一下院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148051/209.wav", + "text": "現在我們中華民國" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148051/210.wav", + "text": "臺灣在中美之間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148051/211.wav", + "text": "你認為我們的作法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148051/212.wav", + "text": "是類似新加坡跟東協的作法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148051/213.wav", + "text": "有可能" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148051/214.wav", + "text": "兩岸現況的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148051/215.wav", + "text": "我相信我們絕對不會這樣做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148051/216.wav", + "text": "理念相同的國家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148051/217.wav", + "text": "繼續捍衛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148051/218.wav", + "text": "民主以及和平穩定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148051/219.wav", + "text": "我想這是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148051/220.wav", + "text": "所有自由民主國家的共識" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148051/221.wav", + "text": "自由民主" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148051/222.wav", + "text": "最前線" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148051/223.wav", + "text": "理念相同的國家來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148051/224.wav", + "text": "兩岸的和平穩定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148051/225.wav", + "text": "好謝謝院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148051/226.wav", + "text": "\n最後兩分鐘" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148051/227.wav", + "text": "講一個比較輕鬆的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148051/228.wav", + "text": "院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148051/229.wav", + "text": "本席那天出席了一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148051/230.wav", + "text": "臺灣工作犬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148051/231.wav", + "text": "發展協會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148051/232.wav", + "text": "這是民間自發的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148051/233.wav", + "text": "救難單位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148051/234.wav", + "text": "救難犬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148051/235.wav", + "text": "犬等他們有很多事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148051/236.wav", + "text": "但在這個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148051/237.wav", + "text": "要特別跟院長反映" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148051/238.wav", + "text": "包含我們現在出去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148051/239.wav", + "text": "其他國家救災" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148051/240.wav", + "text": "原本這些救難犬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148051/241.wav", + "text": "貨艙裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148051/242.wav", + "text": "大家希望爭取" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148051/243.wav", + "text": "能夠坐在客艙" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148051/244.wav", + "text": "在這個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148051/245.wav", + "text": "林部長也在這邊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148051/246.wav", + "text": "而且在其他部分對於這些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148051/247.wav", + "text": "可愛狗狗" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148051/248.wav", + "text": "因為這些犬隻也是我們的好弟兄" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148051/249.wav", + "text": "院長願意嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148051/250.wav", + "text": "這個當然啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148051/251.wav", + "text": "我請部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148051/252.wav", + "text": "沒關係" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148051/253.wav", + "text": "因為我只剩下四五分鐘" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148051/254.wav", + "text": "我們會以最高規格來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148051/255.wav", + "text": "這個就拜託院長及部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148051/256.wav", + "text": "最後一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148051/257.wav", + "text": "議題這是我們本土小牙醫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148051/258.wav", + "text": "捍衛臺灣教育公平正義" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148051/259.wav", + "text": "維護全民口腔醫療品質" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148051/260.wav", + "text": "所以希望" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148051/261.wav", + "text": "關於所謂的波波牙醫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148051/262.wav", + "text": "跟我們牙醫制度的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148051/263.wav", + "text": "我們是不是可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148051/264.wav", + "text": "拜託院長多花一點心力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148051/265.wav", + "text": "當然他們有這個陳情書" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148051/266.wav", + "text": "很多立委都簽了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148051/267.wav", + "text": "所以我也過來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148051/268.wav", + "text": "希望呈給院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148051/269.wav", + "text": "院長簽不簽" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148051/270.wav", + "text": "那是另外一回事" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148051/271.wav", + "text": "我們是不是可以多支持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148051/272.wav", + "text": "我們自己本土" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148051/273.wav", + "text": "可以嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148051/274.wav", + "text": "當然啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148051/275.wav", + "text": "支持本土的牙醫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148050/0.wav", + "text": "謝謝院長我請陳院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148050/1.wav", + "text": "還有內政部林部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148050/2.wav", + "text": "我想剛剛游委員也一再為我們警消同仁的權益" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148050/3.wav", + "text": "在這邊跟您請命" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148050/4.wav", + "text": "其實是時間不等我們不能等到下一次災難" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148050/5.wav", + "text": "我們又再檢討" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148050/6.wav", + "text": "所以今天也很慎重其事跟您報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148050/7.wav", + "text": "你應該也有看到他們的晚會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148050/8.wav", + "text": "也有聽到他們的訴求" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148050/9.wav", + "text": "到今天為止" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148050/10.wav", + "text": "我們看到昨天是行政院院會通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148050/11.wav", + "text": "要把他們的權益用特別協會的方式來回應" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148050/12.wav", + "text": "但是還是讓他們大失所望" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148050/13.wav", + "text": "他們期待的是一個完整勞動權的保障" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148050/14.wav", + "text": "能夠用籌組工會這樣的正式地位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148050/15.wav", + "text": "包括現在可能以行政院為首的有消安相關的會報" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148050/16.wav", + "text": "這樣的高層來對話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148050/17.wav", + "text": "他們的建言" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148050/18.wav", + "text": "他們實戰經驗的需求一定不會是無的放矢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148050/19.wav", + "text": "甚至對改革應該是有效" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148050/20.wav", + "text": "為什麼這樣溝通的平臺" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148050/21.wav", + "text": "目前不願意用他們提出來的工會方式來對待" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148050/22.wav", + "text": "因為消防人員本身就是公務人員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148050/23.wav", + "text": "實際上在我們昨天通過的公務人員協會法修正案裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148050/24.wav", + "text": "都有擴增它設立的機會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148050/25.wav", + "text": "而且協商的範圍也有增加" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148050/26.wav", + "text": "您知道他們真正在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148050/27.wav", + "text": "意的是委員我還沒講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148050/28.wav", + "text": "實際上這是一個協會的意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148050/29.wav", + "text": "鄭副院長也召集了各界大家一起來討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148050/30.wav", + "text": "他們為什麼對協會沒有信心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148050/31.wav", + "text": "但是很多的消防人員他們也體認到自己是公務員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148050/32.wav", + "text": "所以他們贊成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148050/33.wav", + "text": "這是一個層次我懂" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148050/34.wav", + "text": "他是身分特定國家考試特殊關係這我懂" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148050/35.wav", + "text": "但是為什麼到目前他們對於協會的建言" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148050/36.wav", + "text": "沒有信心不願意接受" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148050/37.wav", + "text": "你知道關鍵原因在哪裡嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148050/38.wav", + "text": "建言程序他們實戰經驗的需求有得到政府相應的回應" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148050/39.wav", + "text": "我相信今天問題比較好解決" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148050/40.wav", + "text": "可是從這次明揚大火看到的第一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148050/41.wav", + "text": "資訊權退避權等等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148050/42.wav", + "text": "雖然在法規裡面有修訂過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148050/43.wav", + "text": "可是這次他們在救火時拿到的資訊是空白或錯誤的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148050/44.wav", + "text": "甚至是疏漏的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148050/45.wav", + "text": "他會認為國家看到問題不解決" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148050/46.wav", + "text": "國家面對問題改革的時間在他們那邊嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148050/47.wav", + "text": "沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148050/48.wav", + "text": "所以他們一再的用生命的隕逝來告誡政府" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148050/49.wav", + "text": "他是公務員的身分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148050/50.wav", + "text": "他必須有自己的忠誠跟義務" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148050/51.wav", + "text": "來處理他們的處境跟要求" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148050/52.wav", + "text": "合理嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148050/53.wav", + "text": "對等嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148050/54.wav", + "text": "除了他們組工會的這一個訴求" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148050/55.wav", + "text": "我們以公務人員協會法來修正以外" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148050/56.wav", + "text": "另外更重要的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148050/57.wav", + "text": "就是在制度面怎麼樣讓他們能夠得到最好的保障" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148050/58.wav", + "text": "這裡面還有其他的法律要修" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148050/59.wav", + "text": "舉一個例子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148050/60.wav", + "text": "譬如說工廠輔導法裡面就要課責企業工廠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148050/61.wav", + "text": "它需要做很好的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148050/62.wav", + "text": "這是過去發生的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148050/63.wav", + "text": "我們也會來修消防法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148050/64.wav", + "text": "讓他們得到更好的保障" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148050/65.wav", + "text": "所以不是只有工會法才可以解決他們的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148050/66.wav", + "text": "是要全面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148050/67.wav", + "text": "包括預防性的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148050/68.wav", + "text": "平常督檢性的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148050/69.wav", + "text": "到救災性的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148050/70.wav", + "text": "我完全同意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148050/71.wav", + "text": "他們現在身為救災者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148050/72.wav", + "text": "他只在出事的時候成為一個救災時" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148050/73.wav", + "text": "必須要去赴湯蹈火的角色" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148050/74.wav", + "text": "他們的角色真的有賦予他權責相稱" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148050/75.wav", + "text": "他在法制上拿到的刀跟他可以執行的法是相稱的嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148050/76.wav", + "text": "所以我們才會從法律面制度面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148050/77.wav", + "text": "跟執行面三個方面來考慮" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148050/78.wav", + "text": "讓消防的制度越來越好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148050/79.wav", + "text": "除了剛才講的這些以外" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148050/80.wav", + "text": "院長我們就回歸很單純的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148050/81.wav", + "text": "現在所謂化學雲的建置平臺" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148050/82.wav", + "text": "這個也是我們在檢討去年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148050/83.wav", + "text": "工廠所謂的管線配置圖的統合" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148050/84.wav", + "text": "都還要消防署一再的請求要求才建置給他們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148050/85.wav", + "text": "更不要講化學品" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148050/86.wav", + "text": "權責根本不在消防機關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148050/87.wav", + "text": "對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148050/88.wav", + "text": "所以這就是我剛才講的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148050/89.wav", + "text": "你有要求王部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148050/90.wav", + "text": "你有要求經濟部動起來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148050/91.wav", + "text": "超越林部長的速度嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148050/92.wav", + "text": "有我昨天在院會的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148050/93.wav", + "text": "有關的消防法跟工廠輔導法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148050/94.wav", + "text": "都要在最短的時間內提出修法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148050/95.wav", + "text": "你們現在用協會法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148050/96.wav", + "text": "但是其他的部會有動起來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148050/97.wav", + "text": "他們我請內政部跟委員報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148050/98.wav", + "text": "誠如你剛剛在關心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148050/99.wav", + "text": "的其實相關的法制面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148050/100.wav", + "text": "一步一步在建立" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148050/101.wav", + "text": "包括你剛剛提到的退避權" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148050/102.wav", + "text": "資訊權" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148050/103.wav", + "text": "入法等等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148050/104.wav", + "text": "所以是持續在進步" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148050/105.wav", + "text": "剛剛有特別提到化學雲的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148050/106.wav", + "text": "它整合了11個部會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148050/107.wav", + "text": "53個系統" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148050/108.wav", + "text": "現在針對這些化學物品的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148050/109.wav", + "text": "現在院部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148050/110.wav", + "text": "部在幾大科學園區" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148050/111.wav", + "text": "幾大科技產業園區" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148050/112.wav", + "text": "的化學工廠現在的數字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148050/113.wav", + "text": "全部上網公布給你們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148050/114.wav", + "text": "剛剛最後一句話還沒講完" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148050/115.wav", + "text": "本來照計畫的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148050/116.wav", + "text": "就是在今年12月底之前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148050/117.wav", + "text": "化學雲的平臺要整合完畢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148050/118.wav", + "text": "所以時間點原本就是定在這邊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148050/119.wav", + "text": "這是一個兩年的計畫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148050/120.wav", + "text": "從蘇前院長的時候就開始在做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148050/121.wav", + "text": "兩年不等人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148050/122.wav", + "text": "這次明揚就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148050/123.wav", + "text": "超過以30倍為計這樣的資訊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148050/124.wav", + "text": "沒有人知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148050/125.wav", + "text": "會不會再發生類似" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148050/126.wav", + "text": "這就是剛剛院長提到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148050/127.wav", + "text": "的我們接下來要修兩個法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148050/128.wav", + "text": "第一個是消防法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148050/129.wav", + "text": "第二個是經濟部的工廠輔導法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148050/130.wav", + "text": "才有辦法去解決你剛剛提到的這個問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148050/131.wav", + "text": "沒有任何的政治責任" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148050/132.wav", + "text": "覺得他現在有積極面對你們的需求嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148050/133.wav", + "text": "要在最短的時間內" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148050/134.wav", + "text": "你給他多少時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148050/135.wav", + "text": "最短時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148050/136.wav", + "text": "最少在今年內" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148050/137.wav", + "text": "當然是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148050/138.wav", + "text": "跟委員報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148050/139.wav", + "text": "蕭署長也會在10月30日" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148050/140.wav", + "text": "工廠輔導法的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148050/141.wav", + "text": "我也要求經濟部以同樣的速度來10" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148050/142.wav", + "text": "0月底沒有辦法提出草案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148050/143.wav", + "text": "讓這些消防弟兄來確認" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148050/144.wav", + "text": "大家都知道工會的目標" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148050/145.wav", + "text": "大家都擔心工會好像會行使罷工權" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148050/146.wav", + "text": "行使爭議權" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148050/147.wav", + "text": "如果今天制度跟國家對待他是友善的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148050/148.wav", + "text": "是真實的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148050/149.wav", + "text": "是跟著他們一起赴湯蹈火的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148050/150.wav", + "text": "那麼他今天跟罷工有什麼關係" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148050/151.wav", + "text": "不要把工會當作只會來鬧事" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148050/152.wav", + "text": "人家鬧的如果能夠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148050/153.wav", + "text": "揭露我們的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148050/154.wav", + "text": "把我們的不足講出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148050/155.wav", + "text": "大家要感謝他們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148050/156.wav", + "text": "委員我剛才講過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148050/157.wav", + "text": "我們在徵求各方意見的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148050/158.wav", + "text": "當然消權會有他們的建議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148050/159.wav", + "text": "我們也請問他們的意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148050/160.wav", + "text": "並不是每個人都認為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148050/161.wav", + "text": "工會法是一個解決問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148050/162.wav", + "text": "因為只要他們的團結權協商權" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148050/163.wav", + "text": "能夠好好顧及" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148050/164.wav", + "text": "他們也考慮到作為公務員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148050/165.wav", + "text": "你認為對於消防人員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148050/166.wav", + "text": "實際溝通有效比較重要具" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148050/167.wav", + "text": "具體做到改善比較重要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148050/168.wav", + "text": "但是從他們角度來看是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148050/169.wav", + "text": "他們大失所望" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148050/170.wav", + "text": "所以今天他們用很沉痛的方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148050/171.wav", + "text": "來表達對政府的抗議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148050/172.wav", + "text": "這就是消促會提出的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148050/173.wav", + "text": "這一次為什麼大家會這麼沉痛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148050/174.wav", + "text": "是因為犧牲的消防人員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148050/175.wav", + "text": "已經不勝枚舉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148050/176.wav", + "text": "這是你我都知道的事實" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148050/177.wav", + "text": "所以我希望正視他們的訴求並面對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148050/178.wav", + "text": "不管你要不要用修工會法的方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148050/179.wav", + "text": "我也希望勞動部也硬起來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148050/180.wav", + "text": "工會不是洪水猛獸" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148050/181.wav", + "text": "它有時候可以代表" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148050/182.wav", + "text": "在很多體制上面不足的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148050/183.wav", + "text": "給我們奮力一擊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148050/184.wav", + "text": "工會不是毒蛇猛獸" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148050/185.wav", + "text": "我完全同意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148050/186.wav", + "text": "但是消防人員是公務員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148050/187.wav", + "text": "他的團結權協商權" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148050/188.wav", + "text": "怎麼樣來好好保障" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148050/189.wav", + "text": "這也是我們所要顧及的東西" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148050/190.wav", + "text": "而且更重要的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148050/191.wav", + "text": "除了消防人員以外" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148050/192.wav", + "text": "像警察等等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148050/193.wav", + "text": "也也提過可以類似像教師的方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148050/194.wav", + "text": "讓他們涵蓋進來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148050/195.wav", + "text": "所以請大家多參考" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148050/196.wav", + "text": "修法的各種可能性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148050/197.wav", + "text": "因為教師是屬於勞工" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148050/198.wav", + "text": "基隆市的工會也有過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148050/199.wav", + "text": "所以不用跟我講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148050/200.wav", + "text": "那個是屬於勞工的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148050/201.wav", + "text": "比照一般職安法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148050/202.wav", + "text": "你們都覺得不可行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148050/203.wav", + "text": "我們會在消防法裡面來訂" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148050/204.wav", + "text": "能不能得到他們要的相關方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148050/205.wav", + "text": "第二個我們來看科學園區" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148050/206.wav", + "text": "或是科技產業園區" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148050/207.wav", + "text": "消防安檢誰主責的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148050/208.wav", + "text": "現在你們還是要讓" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148050/209.wav", + "text": "讓科技產業園區" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148050/210.wav", + "text": "可以有相關的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148050/211.wav", + "text": "不管在建築方面的審照" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148050/212.wav", + "text": "以及在消安方面的職權" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148050/213.wav", + "text": "未來的改革是什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148050/214.wav", + "text": "要放在哪個地方" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148050/215.wav", + "text": "我來回答一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148050/216.wav", + "text": "跟委員報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148050/217.wav", + "text": "因為它是一個專區" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148050/218.wav", + "text": "是由園區裡面他們來負責" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148050/219.wav", + "text": "您覺得合理嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148050/220.wav", + "text": "這個區域上面的規劃" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148050/221.wav", + "text": "科學園區就要切割給他們嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148050/222.wav", + "text": "因為它是一個專區" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148050/223.wav", + "text": "它是一個特區的概念" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148050/224.wav", + "text": "包括科學園區" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148050/225.wav", + "text": "還有過去所謂的加工出口區等等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148050/226.wav", + "text": "的確是這樣子做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148050/227.wav", + "text": "不過新的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148050/228.wav", + "text": "因為有一些新的案例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148050/229.wav", + "text": "在現在的狀況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148050/230.wav", + "text": "它有委給" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148050/231.wav", + "text": "比如說像消防的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148050/232.wav", + "text": "有委給地方政府" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148050/233.wav", + "text": "有委給地方政府" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148050/234.wav", + "text": "或者是像南科的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148050/235.wav", + "text": "是委給臺南市的消防局" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148050/236.wav", + "text": "我想這個你也很清晰" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148050/237.wav", + "text": "可能做了這樣的決策" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148050/238.wav", + "text": "未來特別是消防安檢勞安的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148050/239.wav", + "text": "是不是一條鞭由國家整體來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148050/240.wav", + "text": "建置訓練" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148050/241.wav", + "text": "然後執法的強制性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148050/242.wav", + "text": "會不會比較有效" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148050/243.wav", + "text": "這個請院長還是要慎重評估" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148050/244.wav", + "text": "對我們會通盤來盤點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148050/245.wav", + "text": "也是基層消防人員的請求" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148050/246.wav", + "text": "我們知道他們的工作強度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148050/247.wav", + "text": "在權益上面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148050/248.wav", + "text": "各地方政府不同" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148050/249.wav", + "text": "剛剛講如果今天成立了協會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148050/250.wav", + "text": "叫消防人員的協會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148050/251.wav", + "text": "他想要去主張" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148050/252.wav", + "text": "他的權益要比照其他縣市" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148050/253.wav", + "text": "或比照全國一致的規定來要求" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148050/254.wav", + "text": "到底有沒有可行性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148050/255.wav", + "text": "也就是剛剛講的協商權本身" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148050/256.wav", + "text": "涵蓋不涵蓋他們所謂的福利或權益" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148050/257.wav", + "text": "以這個為例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148050/258.wav", + "text": "我們看到的是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148050/259.wav", + "text": "臺中市政府消防局" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148050/260.wav", + "text": "40歲以上的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148050/261.wav", + "text": "他們兩年有一次7,000塊的補助" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148050/262.wav", + "text": "或者是單次3,500元" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148050/263.wav", + "text": "來陳情的像南投縣府的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148050/264.wav", + "text": "外勤消防人員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148050/265.wav", + "text": "就說他們只有4,500塊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148050/266.wav", + "text": "也是兩年一次4,500塊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148050/267.wav", + "text": "像這個落差" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148050/268.wav", + "text": "以現在政府對於消防同仁" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148050/269.wav", + "text": "考試是一致的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148050/270.wav", + "text": "剛剛講他們是公務員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148050/271.wav", + "text": "分發到各地之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148050/272.wav", + "text": "相關福利權益不一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148050/273.wav", + "text": "所以就這件事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148050/274.wav", + "text": "從協商權的角度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148050/275.wav", + "text": "會怎麼樣來對待這個事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148050/276.wav", + "text": "好謝謝委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148050/277.wav", + "text": "這個分成兩個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148050/278.wav", + "text": "第一個是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148050/279.wav", + "text": "是屬於地方事務" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148050/280.wav", + "text": "所以地方的縣市長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148050/281.wav", + "text": "或者包括地方政府" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148050/282.wav", + "text": "我們認為應該要給予我們消防同仁" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148050/283.wav", + "text": "包括剛剛提到的這些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148050/284.wav", + "text": "中央當然沒有強制性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148050/285.wav", + "text": "相關的特統" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148050/286.wav", + "text": "行政院其實補助很多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148050/287.wav", + "text": "讓他們消防弟兄的權益一致性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148050/288.wav", + "text": "這個是你們可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148050/289.wav", + "text": "附帶在預算裡面的要求" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148050/290.wav", + "text": "跟委員報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148050/291.wav", + "text": "我想我們消防署" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148050/292.wav", + "text": "可以來訂定一個指引" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148050/293.wav", + "text": "也就是訂定一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148050/294.wav", + "text": "我們認為合理的標準" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148050/295.wav", + "text": "給地方政府" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148050/296.wav", + "text": "來引導他們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148050/297.wav", + "text": "提報一個專案讓他們一致性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148050/298.wav", + "text": "這就是消防法裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148050/299.wav", + "text": "要定職安的規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148050/300.wav", + "text": "嘛在消防法裡面定職安的規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148050/301.wav", + "text": "職安裡面說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148050/302.wav", + "text": "好健檢應該包括哪些項目" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148050/303.wav", + "text": "把這些項目都" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148050/304.wav", + "text": "項目有但是預算不夠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148050/305.wav", + "text": "地方政府說沒錢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148050/306.wav", + "text": "所以這部分中央是不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148050/307.wav", + "text": "可以有一定的規定來給予補助" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148050/308.wav", + "text": "真的回饋消防弟兄所謂協商權之外的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148049/0.wav", + "text": "謝謝院長我要先請陸委會邱太三主委" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148049/1.wav", + "text": "好邱主委請" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148049/2.wav", + "text": "內政部林部長一起謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148049/3.wav", + "text": "主委早" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148049/4.wav", + "text": "主委我只有一點小問題想要請教您" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148049/5.wav", + "text": "因為這兩天的新聞燒很大" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148049/6.wav", + "text": "趙天麟委員他的交往對象" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148049/7.wav", + "text": "大家認為會有國安疑慮" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148049/8.wav", + "text": "我想請教一下陸委會對這樣子的狀況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148049/9.wav", + "text": "有沒有什麼樣的掌握" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148049/10.wav", + "text": "基本上我想昨天法務部蔡部長他已經講了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148049/11.wav", + "text": "全部都已經交由高檢署跟調查局" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148049/12.wav", + "text": "在做相關問題的釐清" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148049/13.wav", + "text": "我們陸委會也把相關資料" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148049/14.wav", + "text": "送給相關的單位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148049/15.wav", + "text": "讓他們去做進一步的確認跟瞭解" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148049/16.wav", + "text": "因為主委也當過法務部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148049/17.wav", + "text": "其實在最近我們是國安五法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148049/18.wav", + "text": "有很多反滲透等等的這些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148049/19.wav", + "text": "我相信陸委會對於這方面的警覺應該要有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148049/20.wav", + "text": "因為不是只有我們跟陸籍人士交往的狀況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148049/21.wav", + "text": "澳門也有我們陸委會的人員在那邊進駐" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148049/22.wav", + "text": "還有香港港澳都有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148049/23.wav", + "text": "因為最近被攻擊的對象也有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148049/24.wav", + "text": "其實我覺得有點可惜" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148049/25.wav", + "text": "因為副院長今天沒有到現場來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148049/26.wav", + "text": "他沒有辦法親自為他" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148049/27.wav", + "text": "委員我想這個不要以訛傳訛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148049/28.wav", + "text": "啦我想鄭副院長已經對網民提出了他的告訴" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148049/29.wav", + "text": "對所以我是覺得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148049/30.wav", + "text": "如果能夠讓副院長可以公開對他的清白" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148049/31.wav", + "text": "來戰清白" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148049/32.wav", + "text": "我覺得這應該是可以的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148049/33.wav", + "text": "啦不過我們還是很希望" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148049/34.wav", + "text": "尤其在港澳這些地���" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148049/35.wav", + "text": "大量的情報行動在進行的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148049/36.wav", + "text": "我認為陸委會也應該要提醒國安部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148049/37.wav", + "text": "謝謝委員的關心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148049/38.wav", + "text": "上個禮拜國家機密保護法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148049/39.wav", + "text": "在院長的主持之下已經通過要送到大院來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148049/40.wav", + "text": "這裡面就包括所有涉密的人員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148049/41.wav", + "text": "如果到大陸或者是到港澳去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148049/42.wav", + "text": "回來的時候要有申報這樣的機制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148049/43.wav", + "text": "在上個禮拜國家機密保護法已經通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148049/44.wav", + "text": "好主委請回" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148049/45.wav", + "text": "因為其實我剛剛之所以認為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148049/46.wav", + "text": "未必是壞事" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148049/47.wav", + "text": "我覺得有事情他可以自己講得更清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148049/48.wav", + "text": "但是我們慣例沒有這樣子安排" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148049/49.wav", + "text": "是但是這個慣例有的時候是可以創造的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148049/50.wav", + "text": "陳冲先生跟施啟揚先生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148049/51.wav", + "text": "在當副院長的時候也來過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148049/52.wav", + "text": "不過我只是在想" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148049/53.wav", + "text": "到副院長11年前的判決書裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148049/54.wav", + "text": "說他被認證去過什麼澳門的九號會館" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148049/55.wav", + "text": "去年當媒體在那邊大肆炒作" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148049/56.wav", + "text": "88會館的問題時" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148049/57.wav", + "text": "副院長也被爆出有進去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148049/58.wav", + "text": "其實不只副院長還包括柯文哲柯主席" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148049/59.wav", + "text": "以前柯市長的時候他們都有進出" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148049/60.wav", + "text": "但是我們發現像這些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148049/61.wav", + "text": "被媒體爆料認為是很嚴重的事情好像" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148049/62.wav", + "text": "中有26個高階警官受到懲處" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148049/63.wav", + "text": "然後他們分別向保訓會來申請復審" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148049/64.wav", + "text": "在他們復審的決定書上面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148049/65.wav", + "text": "對於臺灣的治安是很有貢獻的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148049/66.wav", + "text": "他們依法去行使他們的行政救濟之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148049/67.wav", + "text": "已經有6件被撤銷了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148049/68.wav", + "text": "可是警政署對於應該要還他們清白" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148049/69.wav", + "text": "我覺得還是不夠周延" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148049/70.wav", + "text": "在這一部分我們可不可以對於警察的依法救濟人權事項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148049/71.wav", + "text": "能夠更加的尊重" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148049/72.wav", + "text": "否則感覺上就只打我們小警察縱放高官" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148049/73.wav", + "text": "啦我想保訓會有另作適法之處分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148049/74.wav", + "text": "現在警政署也正在處理當中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148049/75.wav", + "text": "謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148049/76.wav", + "text": "現在回溯到5年前進去的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148049/77.wav", + "text": "然後來予以重懲" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148049/78.wav", + "text": "那時候警察沒有那麼了不起" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148049/79.wav", + "text": "還有透視眼還可以穿梭過去跟未來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148049/80.wav", + "text": "\n不過接下來我比較想要問的是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148049/81.wav", + "text": "有關明揚大火事後的一些檢討事項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148049/82.wav", + "text": "因為大家都很擔心今天公祭明天就忘記了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148049/83.wav", + "text": "可是我知道其實院長非常重視這件事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148049/84.wav", + "text": "部長也很辛苦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148049/85.wav", + "text": "我們吳澤成吳政委我個人是非常尊敬他" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148049/86.wav", + "text": "他在10月3日主持專案會議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148049/87.wav", + "text": "請問是哪一位主持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148049/88.wav", + "text": "災防辦的會議是由吳政委來督導" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148049/89.wav", + "text": "還是吳政委" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148049/90.wav", + "text": "可是我也知道院長在19日的治安會報" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148049/91.wav", + "text": "也有稍微瞭解一下法制的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148049/92.wav", + "text": "那時候吳政委主持的幾個會議裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148049/93.wav", + "text": "大家釐清了有很多的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148049/94.wav", + "text": "有一些不足的地方" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148049/95.wav", + "text": "其實這些問題早在107年張宏陸委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148049/96.wav", + "text": "就提出質詢過也要求" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148049/97.wav", + "text": "要讓消防人員到達現場就可以拿到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148049/98.wav", + "text": "108年沈智慧委員或110年邱臣遠委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148049/99.wav", + "text": "大家都提到過了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148049/100.wav", + "text": "可是我們不是沒有專業" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148049/101.wav", + "text": "真的是執行力不夠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148049/102.wav", + "text": "我上個禮拜去消防訓練中心考察的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148049/103.wav", + "text": "消防署所提出來的報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148049/104.wav", + "text": "我們真的覺得是很有遠見的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148049/105.wav", + "text": "因為我們的消防訓練中心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148049/106.wav", + "text": "現在在亞洲地區是很厲害的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148049/107.wav", + "text": "將來也可以變成世界第一\n" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148049/108.wav", + "text": "譬如給我們看要協助各個工廠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148049/109.wav", + "text": "這些還包括你如何讓金管會協助" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148049/110.wav", + "text": "讓保險理賠把這些防災的理念" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148049/111.wav", + "text": "還有備配等能夠入法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148049/112.wav", + "text": "但是那天他跟我講的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148049/113.wav", + "text": "我還特別拜託陪同去的內政部吳次長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148049/114.wav", + "text": "請他務必要跟部長院長報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148049/115.wav", + "text": "他們的這些研究發現和建議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148049/116.wav", + "text": "其實應該要讓各部會的首長都聽到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148049/117.wav", + "text": "所以我當時有說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148049/118.wav", + "text": "是不是可以請內政部跟院長報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148049/119.wav", + "text": "讓院長在行政院院會裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148049/120.wav", + "text": "不用多5分鐘或10分鐘" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148049/121.wav", + "text": "讓消防署來把他們研究出來的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148049/122.wav", + "text": "或者是我們立法院早就已經多次提出質詢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148049/123.wav", + "text": "院長覺得這樣可行嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148049/124.wav", + "text": "確實就像委員講的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148049/125.wav", + "text": "這些專案報告的內容是相當地好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148049/126.wav", + "text": "它從法律面制度面執行面三方面來做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148049/127.wav", + "text": "在我們的會報當中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148049/128.wav", + "text": "實際上各部會的首長都有參加" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148049/129.wav", + "text": "我覺得目前最重要的就是這個改革方案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148049/130.wav", + "text": "在落實的部分法律面的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148049/131.wav", + "text": "譬如說我們要研修消防法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148049/132.wav", + "text": "這些我們都有請他們積極地改進" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148049/133.wav", + "text": "在制度面的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148049/134.wav", + "text": "我們也把消防措施納入工廠ESG永續發展的報告當中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148049/135.wav", + "text": "是因為我還有其他的議題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148049/136.wav", + "text": "我知道您非常進入狀況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148049/137.wav", + "text": "但對此我還是建議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148049/138.wav", + "text": "要讓各部會瞭解" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148049/139.wav", + "text": "對讓各部會一定要瞭解" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148049/140.wav", + "text": "接下來我比較關心的是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148049/141.wav", + "text": "對於這些警消同仁的照顧" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148049/142.wav", + "text": "倖存的一樣要照顧" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148049/143.wav", + "text": "給他們備極哀榮的追思" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148049/144.wav", + "text": "等我覺得是應該的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148049/145.wav", + "text": "但是留下來的其實很辛苦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148049/146.wav", + "text": "我這邊貼了一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148049/147.wav", + "text": "將近四年前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148049/148.wav", + "text": "我剛剛進入立法院的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148049/149.wav", + "text": "高雄鳳祥分隊的消防車事件" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148049/150.wav", + "text": "我這邊貼出賴統生隊員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148049/151.wav", + "text": "跟曾柏雄分隊長的照片" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148049/152.wav", + "text": "因為曾柏雄現在還留在消防崗位上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148049/153.wav", + "text": "可是他目前仍然每個禮拜都還要回診和復建" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148049/154.wav", + "text": "賴統生已造成永久性的傷害" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148049/155.wav", + "text": "他已經辦理退休了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148049/156.wav", + "text": "\n我覺得我們雖然對於現在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148049/157.wav", + "text": "因公執行危險勤務的警消人員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148049/158.wav", + "text": "有一個失能的照顧辦法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148049/159.wav", + "text": "但是在內政部所管轄的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148049/160.wav", + "text": "因為要追緝失聯外勞逃逸外勞" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148049/161.wav", + "text": "或者是在場海委會的海巡弟兄" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148049/162.wav", + "text": "他們現在很多也是要出生入死的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148049/163.wav", + "text": "所以這個失能照護辦法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148049/164.wav", + "text": "我還是建議行政院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148049/165.wav", + "text": "要以院長的高度看到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148049/166.wav", + "text": "所有同仁能夠照顧到他們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148049/167.wav", + "text": "而且現在還包括" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148049/168.wav", + "text": "但是健保在給付上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148049/169.wav", + "text": "有一些稽核機制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148049/170.wav", + "text": "4個禮拜要換一次或是怎麼樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148049/171.wav", + "text": "或者是公傷假都是短短的兩年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148049/172.wav", + "text": "而這些都要請院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148049/173.wav", + "text": "支持我知道院長真的是沒有話說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148049/174.wav", + "text": "一提出我們警大和警專伙食費的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148049/175.wav", + "text": "馬上把他們的伙食費增加" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148049/176.wav", + "text": "這些都是我們第一線同仁所需要的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148049/177.wav", + "text": "\n我更在意的是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148049/178.wav", + "text": "現在警察缺額5,000" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148049/179.wav", + "text": "消防人員缺額還4,000" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148049/180.wav", + "text": "然後移民署的人員很辛苦的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148049/181.wav", + "text": "他們人數非常非常的不足" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148049/182.wav", + "text": "但是我們看到人總" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148049/183.wav", + "text": "每次他們講的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148049/184.wav", + "text": "我聽了我們都覺得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148049/185.wav", + "text": "要我們自己要去檢討服勤的方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148049/186.wav", + "text": "業務流程要簡化" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148049/187.wav", + "text": "要去任務化" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148049/188.wav", + "text": "要資訊化" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148049/189.wav", + "text": "減少冗事" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148049/190.wav", + "text": "希望我們儘量委外" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148049/191.wav", + "text": "要增加委外" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148049/192.wav", + "text": "我們警察基本上是在承擔" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148049/193.wav", + "text": "很多部會要求我們做的冗事" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148049/194.wav", + "text": "在這段期間之內" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148049/195.wav", + "text": "很多升格的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148049/196.wav", + "text": "各署加人的加人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148049/197.wav", + "text": "比如農業部就加了530個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148049/198.wav", + "text": "環境部264個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148049/199.wav", + "text": "交通部100個等等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148049/200.wav", + "text": "詐的第一線真的非常的辛苦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148049/201.wav", + "text": "但是移民署的人力更是可憐" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148049/202.wav", + "text": "就在去年這個時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148049/203.wav", + "text": "我在這個地方��了蘇院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148049/204.wav", + "text": "人數非常的少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148049/205.wav", + "text": "那時候我不敢要多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148049/206.wav", + "text": "我說可不可以100個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148049/207.wav", + "text": "蘇院長跟我講我豈止給100個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148049/208.wav", + "text": "我要給你162個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148049/209.wav", + "text": "聽了是很感動" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148049/210.wav", + "text": "可是到現在為止" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148049/211.wav", + "text": "大概只補了幾十個而已" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148049/212.wav", + "text": "而且還是聘僱" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148049/213.wav", + "text": "的然後剛剛我唸的要去任務" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148049/214.wav", + "text": "化什麼簡化等等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148049/215.wav", + "text": "等等人總還是用這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148049/216.wav", + "text": "同樣的複製貼上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148049/217.wav", + "text": "就來處理這個問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148049/218.wav", + "text": "\n院長因為我們這些執行公權力的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148049/219.wav", + "text": "我只要看到現在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148049/220.wav", + "text": "我們線上的同仁" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148049/221.wav", + "text": "法務部有一個科技監控中心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148049/222.wav", + "text": "可是他們都不願意用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148049/223.wav", + "text": "還是習慣性的讓警察" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148049/224.wav", + "text": "處理反正防逃機制都丟給警察" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148049/225.wav", + "text": "到最後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148049/226.wav", + "text": "棄保潛逃" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148049/227.wav", + "text": "或者現在朱國榮" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148049/228.wav", + "text": "5億交保" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148049/229.wav", + "text": "但是可憐的是我們警察" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148049/230.wav", + "text": "院長可不可以支持一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148049/231.wav", + "text": "因為部長在這一部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148049/232.wav", + "text": "非常的瞭解" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148049/233.wav", + "text": "他還在很努力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148049/234.wav", + "text": "但是我們真的需要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148049/235.wav", + "text": "院長能夠跟人總交代一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148049/236.wav", + "text": "很多事情真的不是像他們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148049/237.wav", + "text": "用那幾句話就可以一筆勾銷" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148049/238.wav", + "text": "我想讓警消人員人力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148049/239.wav", + "text": "以消防人員為例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148049/240.wav", + "text": "108年到112年就增加3,000人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148049/241.wav", + "text": "消防人員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148049/242.wav", + "text": "院長請您支持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148049/243.wav", + "text": "接下來請賴委員香伶質詢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148623/0.wav", + "text": "謝謝召委請管主委和海保署署長有請管主委和黃署長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148623/1.wav", + "text": "主委好因為我們臺灣算是四面環海對海洋對我們的生活環境息息相關不僅可以平衡氣候供應氧氣甚至80%以上的生物都是以海洋為家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148623/2.wav", + "text": "所以我們在關注陸地上污染問題的同時也不能忽視海洋所造成的影響" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148623/3.wav", + "text": "在海洋生態系中是很重要的角色它可以作為很多海底生物的避風港孕育豐富的魚群維繫生物的多樣性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148623/4.wav", + "text": "我們剛才講的小琉球海域最為嚴重東北角海域是頭一次發生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148623/5.wav", + "text": "珊瑚生態大大衰退請教主委海委會和海保署有沒有針對這類問題和其他單位包括環保署屏東縣政府交通部觀光局" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148623/6.wav", + "text": "跟委員報告感謝委員這麼關心海洋的保育這真的很重要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148623/7.wav", + "text": "還有使用不正當或不是很好的方式捕魚或是過度捕撈都會造成這樣的後果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148623/8.wav", + "text": "我一直覺得海保法很重要的原因就在這裡海保法實施後我們做事才有力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148623/9.wav", + "text": "對策" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148623/10.wav", + "text": "但是整體來說現在大家真的還沒辦法有妥協的共識跟各單位的主要是強勢制定人數管理這條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148623/11.wav", + "text": "規範所以在這個部分我們要繼續努力我們都有在作像遊憩承載量的部分我們有管理的指引以及個案的協調" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148623/12.wav", + "text": "歐盟澳洲和美國等等也有一些針對海洋友善的認證和標章" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148623/13.wav", + "text": "而且權不在海委會我們還是用宣導的方式宣導大家儘量少用另外就是進行水質監測這是我們已經有在做的部分\n另外" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148623/14.wav", + "text": "海洋友善標章海保署已經有在討論我請署長向委員作比較詳細的說明好好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148623/15.wav", + "text": "跟委員報告關於友善海洋標章其實我們談了有一段時間包括跟其他相關部會和一些驗證機關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148623/16.wav", + "text": "我們希望除了像之前環境部針對海廢再回收之外對象可以更廣泛跟海洋友善的都可以納入所以正在討論當中我們希望可以儘快上路" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148623/17.wav", + "text": "的但是權責不在我們這裡所以我們沒有辦法驗證也不能作什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148623/18.wav", + "text": "好好謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148623/19.wav", + "text": "謝謝林文瑞委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148046/0.wav", + "text": "主席在場的委員先進列席的政府機關首長官員會場工作伙伴媒體記者女士先生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148046/1.wav", + "text": "有請衛福部薛部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148046/2.wav", + "text": "有請薛部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148046/3.wav", + "text": "吳玉琴委員跟我和林委員辦了一場公聽會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148046/4.wav", + "text": "結果太相信健保和商業保險" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148046/5.wav", + "text": "都被認為非必要醫療而拒絕理賠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148046/6.wav", + "text": "我們來看一下這些統計" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148046/7.wav", + "text": "在醫療費超過50萬元的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148046/8.wav", + "text": "有32萬的癌友醫療費用超過50萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148046/9.wav", + "text": "53%的標靶治療和13%的免疫治療" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148046/10.wav", + "text": "健保不給付" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148046/11.wav", + "text": "也是我們會去買商業保險的原因" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148046/12.wav", + "text": "我們來看一下健保不給付" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148046/13.wav", + "text": "商業保險有哪些困境呢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148046/14.wav", + "text": "因為我在財政委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148046/15.wav", + "text": "我這段時間對金融有比較深刻的瞭解" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148046/16.wav", + "text": "其實我們健保算是CP值滿高的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148046/17.wav", + "text": "但是在商業保險當中它收了保費" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148046/18.wav", + "text": "不像健保是強制納保" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148046/19.wav", + "text": "它的保費是精算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148046/20.wav", + "text": "不像健保是單一費率" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148046/21.wav", + "text": "一般的保單" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148046/22.wav", + "text": "佣金和管銷費用占了4成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148046/23.wav", + "text": "那怎麼辦你有什麼看法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148046/24.wav", + "text": "是商保補位健保" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148046/25.wav", + "text": "因為健保是一個基礎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148046/26.wav", + "text": "因為許多的商業保險的醫療險" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148046/27.wav", + "text": "對而且健保涵蓋的範圍越來越多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148046/28.wav", + "text": "所以商保可以用到的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148046/29.wav", + "text": "其實就越來越少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148046/30.wav", + "text": "我們想怎麼處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148046/31.wav", + "text": "其實政府開辦的政策保險有兩個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148046/32.wav", + "text": "一個是教育部的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148046/33.wav", + "text": "一個是金管會保險局" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148046/34.wav", + "text": "跟汽機車有關的汽機車強制險" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148046/35.wav", + "text": "部長應該瞭解吧" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148046/36.wav", + "text": "這兩個保險和健保什麼地方不一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148046/37.wav", + "text": "呢首先以學生團保來講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148046/38.wav", + "text": "基本上它幾乎是強制收費" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148046/39.wav", + "text": "因為它是立法的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148046/40.wav", + "text": "不分年齡性別" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148046/41.wav", + "text": "費率單一跟健保很像" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148046/42.wav", + "text": "用整體來算出險率" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148046/43.wav", + "text": "後來修正了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148046/44.wav", + "text": "因為當我們發現學生團保" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148046/45.wav", + "text": "有很多長輩" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148046/46.wav", + "text": "參加社區大學去學校的進修部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148046/47.wav", + "text": "註冊為學生的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148046/48.wav", + "text": "後來他們的死亡給付就排除了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148046/49.wav", + "text": "因為這樣出險率太高了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148046/50.wav", + "text": "根據你的年齡和性別來算費率" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148046/51.wav", + "text": "公辦民營" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148046/52.wav", + "text": "政府辦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148046/53.wav", + "text": "政府是保險人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148046/54.wav", + "text": "由民間的商業保險公司來承保" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148046/55.wav", + "text": "請問部長你覺得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148046/56.wav", + "text": "有沒有可能公私協力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148046/57.wav", + "text": "商業保險來補位健保" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148046/58.wav", + "text": "變成商業保險協同健保來分工" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148046/59.wav", + "text": "你覺得有沒有這個可能性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148046/60.wav", + "text": "類似學生團保" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148046/61.wav", + "text": "和汽機車強制險" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148046/62.wav", + "text": "部長有沒有考慮過這樣的可能性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148046/63.wav", + "text": "這個可能要問金管會會比較" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148046/64.wav", + "text": "金管會我早上才問過他" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148046/65.wav", + "text": "說要來問你們的意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148046/66.wav", + "text": "所以我特別跑" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148046/67.wav", + "text": "來我告訴你有哪些事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148046/68.wav", + "text": "首先你回去問一下你們健保" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148046/69.wav", + "text": "在行政成本的部分很低" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148046/70.wav", + "text": "為什麼因為大資料庫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148046/71.wav", + "text": "全民納保" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148046/72.wav", + "text": "可是商業保險這部分成本很高" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148046/73.wav", + "text": "如何降低" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148046/74.wav", + "text": "我們用商業保險來補位或協同" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148046/75.wav", + "text": "分工健保的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148046/76.wav", + "text": "首先健保資料庫很大" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148046/77.wav", + "text": "健保資料庫對於所有的保險人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148046/78.wav", + "text": "保險公司很重要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148046/79.wav", + "text": "嗎不要外洩" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148046/80.wav", + "text": "我們根據健保資料庫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148046/81.wav", + "text": "將我們的健保被保險人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148046/82.wav", + "text": "做一些區隔之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148046/83.wav", + "text": "跟商業公司來設計保單" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148046/84.wav", + "text": "然後提供給這些被保險人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148046/85.wav", + "text": "讓他自己衡量要不要加保" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148046/86.wav", + "text": "至於保單怎麼設計由保險公司" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148046/87.wav", + "text": "這叫做民辦公營" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148046/88.wav", + "text": "什麼叫民辦公營" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148046/89.wav", + "text": "很多的事情是政府在做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148046/90.wav", + "text": "但是最後的盈虧責任誰在負" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148046/91.wav", + "text": "我們來看看這個電影" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148046/92.wav", + "text": "叫做星際過客" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148046/93.wav", + "text": "我不是要介紹電影" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148046/94.wav", + "text": "就是在太空旅行當中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148046/95.wav", + "text": "因為人工凍齡的裝置故障" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148046/96.wav", + "text": "一個醒過來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148046/97.wav", + "text": "就把另外一個叫醒" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148046/98.wav", + "text": "他們兩個人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148046/99.wav", + "text": "社會階級地位經濟能力不一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148046/100.wav", + "text": "經濟艙一個是商務艙" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148046/101.wav", + "text": "他們吃的住的用的都不一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148046/102.wav", + "text": "這在郵輪上是很常見的情形" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148046/103.wav", + "text": "同樣的道理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148046/104.wav", + "text": "商業保險在商言商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148046/105.wav", + "text": "險不是按照你的健康情況來繳保費" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148046/106.wav", + "text": "也不是按照你的期待的理賠方式來繳保費" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148046/107.wav", + "text": "是根據你的所得能力來繳保費" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148046/108.wav", + "text": "會衡量你的健康條件" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148046/109.wav", + "text": "期待的保額" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148046/110.wav", + "text": "和經濟能力來設計" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148046/111.wav", + "text": "你可能考慮的保單\n" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148046/112.wav", + "text": "所以或許社會保險就像" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148046/113.wav", + "text": "部長說的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148046/114.wav", + "text": "我們全民健保提供基礎的支持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148046/115.wav", + "text": "大家同一個時間上船" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148046/116.wav", + "text": "同一個時間下船" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148046/117.wav", + "text": "但是在船上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148046/118.wav", + "text": "如果有民辦公營的自費保險" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148046/119.wav", + "text": "量能選擇醫療模式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148046/120.wav", + "text": "如果你屬於期望很高" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148046/121.wav", + "text": "經濟能力很好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148046/122.wav", + "text": "你就會去保尖端的醫療保險" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148046/123.wav", + "text": "在這種情況之下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148046/124.wav", + "text": "雖然不應該這樣形容" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148046/125.wav", + "text": "但是事實上健保就是最基層的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148046/126.wav", + "text": "然後再往上加" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148046/127.wav", + "text": "目標保費不要貴" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148046/128.wav", + "text": "產業保險業不要賠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148046/129.wav", + "text": "風險要能夠控管" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148046/130.wav", + "text": "弱體不排除" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148046/131.wav", + "text": "在這種情況下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148046/132.wav", + "text": "衛福部提供資訊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148046/133.wav", + "text": "金管會來管理和精算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148046/134.wav", + "text": "保險公司來代銷" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148046/135.wav", + "text": "這就是一個民辦公營自費的保險" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148046/136.wav", + "text": "區隔於商業保險和健康保險" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148046/137.wav", + "text": "部長有沒有可能考慮" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148046/138.wav", + "text": "這裡面還是有一些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148046/139.wav", + "text": "必須要去考慮" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148046/140.wav", + "text": "像什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148046/141.wav", + "text": "像弱體不排" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148046/142.wav", + "text": "弱體的定義就要很清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148046/143.wav", + "text": "弱體由握有資料的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148046/144.wav", + "text": "因為剛才講資料庫不外流" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148046/145.wav", + "text": "比方說一個癌症的病人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148046/146.wav", + "text": "他可能在0期1期" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148046/147.wav", + "text": "他治療好之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148046/148.wav", + "text": "這不應該被排除" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148046/149.wav", + "text": "復發機率很高的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148046/150.wav", + "text": "��希望保險不能排除" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148046/151.wav", + "text": "這會出問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148046/152.wav", + "text": "商業保險公司" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148046/153.wav", + "text": "我問到的答案都這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148046/154.wav", + "text": "他們就是遇到你的困境" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148046/155.wav", + "text": "不曉得什麼情況之下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148046/156.wav", + "text": "屬於弱體不可以保" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148046/157.wav", + "text": "所以我們這裡的設計" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148046/158.wav", + "text": "不是每個人都可以選擇" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148046/159.wav", + "text": "同樣的保險給付項目" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148046/160.wav", + "text": "也不是每個人都可以選擇" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148046/161.wav", + "text": "同樣的保險額度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148046/162.wav", + "text": "他的健康條件" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148046/163.wav", + "text": "換言之今天我在健保當中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148046/164.wav", + "text": "我可以去選擇屬於A級" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148046/165.wav", + "text": "ABC的健康分級" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148046/166.wav", + "text": "但是設計保單" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148046/167.wav", + "text": "跟商業保險共同來設計" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148046/168.wav", + "text": "保費和保額大家來討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148046/169.wav", + "text": "整個架構就會變成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148046/170.wav", + "text": "健保的附加商業保險" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148046/171.wav", + "text": "有一點像" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148046/172.wav", + "text": "所以叫做民辦公營" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148046/173.wav", + "text": "但是它為什麼不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148046/174.wav", + "text": "健保附加的商業保險呢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148046/175.wav", + "text": "因為是民辦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148046/176.wav", + "text": "是商業保險" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148046/177.wav", + "text": "為什麼是公營" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148046/178.wav", + "text": "因為資料庫都在健保署" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148046/179.wav", + "text": "收費什麼的附加健保來收費" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148046/180.wav", + "text": "但是最終的保險責任" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148046/181.wav", + "text": "這就是跟學生團體保險的差別" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148046/182.wav", + "text": "它是公辦民營" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148046/183.wav", + "text": "這是民辦公營" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148046/184.wav", + "text": "3個月內就商保偕同健保分工" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148046/185.wav", + "text": "提出一個可行性的分析報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148046/186.wav", + "text": "因為金管會主委說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148046/187.wav", + "text": "要等你出報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148046/188.wav", + "text": "他才願意寫報告給我" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148046/189.wav", + "text": "如果我們用委託研究案計畫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148046/190.wav", + "text": "一般都是用一年的時間會比較好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148046/191.wav", + "text": "因為需要外面的專家學者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148046/192.wav", + "text": "和保發中心這些單位一起來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148046/193.wav", + "text": "所以你們願意出這個報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148046/194.wav", + "text": "如果給我們一年時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148046/195.wav", + "text": "我們去委託研究" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148046/196.wav", + "text": "一年我同意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148046/197.wav", + "text": "如果你們可以越早越好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148046/198.wav", + "text": "部長可以承諾嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148046/199.wav", + "text": "因為金管會主委在等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148046/200.wav", + "text": "好那就很例外的在委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148046/201.wav", + "text": "給一年的時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148046/202.wav", + "text": "來提出一個可行性評估報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148046/203.wav", + "text": "也謝謝召委謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148046/204.wav", + "text": "謝謝委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148044/0.wav", + "text": "請薛部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148044/1.wav", + "text": "委員好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148044/2.wav", + "text": "部長好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148044/3.wav", + "text": "請教一下部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148044/4.wav", + "text": "在過去審查預算案的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148044/5.wav", + "text": "曾經有委員針對中醫藥司在長照中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148044/6.wav", + "text": "到底扮演什麼樣的角色" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148044/7.wav", + "text": "提出質疑" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148044/8.wav", + "text": "而中醫藥應用在長照上主要是善用中醫養生保健" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148044/9.wav", + "text": "預防醫學及延緩長者失能的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148044/10.wav", + "text": "為了發揮中醫藥在預防跟調理的特色" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148044/11.wav", + "text": "中醫藥司規劃從2020年到2024年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148044/12.wav", + "text": "補助辦理相關計畫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148044/13.wav", + "text": "請教部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148044/14.wav", + "text": "對這幾年中醫藥司補助辦理的這些計畫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148044/15.wav", + "text": "你知道有哪些嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148044/16.wav", + "text": "幾個方向" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148044/17.wav", + "text": "第一個由中醫的團隊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148044/18.wav", + "text": "去結合當地長照服務的資源" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148044/19.wav", + "text": "提供中醫長照的相關服務" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148044/20.wav", + "text": "就是有6區的中醫團隊去做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148044/21.wav", + "text": "這是在健保的體系裡面去進行的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148044/22.wav", + "text": "是到C據點去做運用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148044/23.wav", + "text": "沒關係剛剛前面部長大致上也有講過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148044/24.wav", + "text": "基本上就是2020年的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148044/25.wav", + "text": "有建立中醫社區" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148044/26.wav", + "text": "跟居家醫療服務的網絡計畫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148044/27.wav", + "text": "隔年有長期照護的服務網絡計畫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148044/28.wav", + "text": "第三年有居家照護網絡計畫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148044/29.wav", + "text": "到第四年還有社區的健康照護網絡計畫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148044/30.wav", + "text": "在計畫執行工作內容的要求" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148044/31.wav", + "text": "中醫藥預防醫學社區講座或衛教活動" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148044/32.wav", + "text": "分區內的各縣市至少一場是長照據點或失智據點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148044/33.wav", + "text": "你們有到過哪些文健站" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148044/34.wav", + "text": "我請司長來說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148044/35.wav", + "text": "好司長知道文健站嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148044/36.wav", + "text": "你們有去過嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148044/37.wav", + "text": "在哪裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148044/38.wav", + "text": "那個印象是對的嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148044/39.wav", + "text": "我們再查查看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148044/40.wav", + "text": "不過如果有我想也不多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148044/41.wav", + "text": "應該很稀少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148044/42.wav", + "text": "因為我一直都很注意你們的動態" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148044/43.wav", + "text": "如果有去而我不知道也是滿稀奇的事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148044/44.wav", + "text": "所以我不知道你的印象是到了哪邊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148044/45.wav", + "text": "另外計畫也要求結合衛福部中藥本草文化節活動" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148044/46.wav", + "text": "配合承辦活動的執行團隊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148044/47.wav", + "text": "在該活動期間於各分區共同辦理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148044/48.wav", + "text": "具中醫藥寓教於樂的中醫藥專題講座或推廣活動" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148044/49.wav", + "text": "每區至少一場" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148044/50.wav", + "text": "這個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148044/51.wav", + "text": "我們有到過哪些文健站" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148044/52.wav", + "text": "你有去過哪些文健站" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148044/53.wav", + "text": "因為前面說有印象後面說沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148044/54.wav", + "text": "所以答案可能是沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148044/55.wav", + "text": "沒有關係" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148044/56.wav", + "text": "可能都是從漢人的角度思維在看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148044/57.wav", + "text": "可能在這個過程當中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148044/58.wav", + "text": "原住民的部分一樣是可以去宣導的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148044/59.wav", + "text": "為了讓原住民長者受到妥善的照顧" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148044/60.wav", + "text": "強化肌力訓練延緩失能甚至食療等等相關課程" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148044/61.wav", + "text": "像我們臺東就有很多文健站" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148044/62.wav", + "text": "他們會結合原住民常用的藥用植物和" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148044/63.wav", + "text": "甚至我曾經去參加活動" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148044/64.wav", + "text": "他們還做一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148044/65.wav", + "text": "我本來以為是茶包泡茶" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148044/66.wav", + "text": "結果是泡腳的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148044/67.wav", + "text": "還好我沒有拿來喝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148044/68.wav", + "text": "所以文健站自己有另外再去找" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148044/69.wav", + "text": "但是它看起來沒有在你們這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148044/70.wav", + "text": "所以這個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148044/71.wav", + "text": "提醒一下中醫藥司長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148044/72.wav", + "text": "文健站已經有五百零多站了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148044/73.wav", + "text": "在這個區塊好好發揮一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148044/74.wav", + "text": "我們長期的飲食文化" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148044/75.wav", + "text": "其實都還是有運用中醫藥的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148044/76.wav", + "text": "其實原住民也是一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148044/77.wav", + "text": "我講中草藥會比較精準" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148044/78.wav", + "text": "所以這個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148044/79.wav", + "text": "要麻煩你們留意一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148044/80.wav", + "text": "請衛福部提出" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148044/81.wav", + "text": "文健站養生保健的衛教宣導計畫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148044/82.wav", + "text": "可以嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148044/83.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148044/84.wav", + "text": "10月份中國醫藥" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148044/85.wav", + "text": "這個標題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148044/86.wav", + "text": "就寫著鬆綁法規" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148044/87.wav", + "text": "創新中藥漢方百億商機" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148044/88.wav", + "text": "我們通常到日本旅遊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148044/89.wav", + "text": "外國遊客都不會錯過到日本藥粧店掃貨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148044/90.wav", + "text": "等等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148044/91.wav", + "text": "還有漢方藥的葛根湯小青龍湯等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148044/92.wav", + "text": "等這些感冒藥或腸胃用藥" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148044/93.wav", + "text": "所以國人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148044/94.wav", + "text": "錢葛根湯" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148044/95.wav", + "text": "小青龍湯是用於風寒客表" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148044/96.wav", + "text": "和惡寒發熱" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148044/97.wav", + "text": "西藥的綜合感冒藥" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148044/98.wav", + "text": "已經有很多是非處方藥" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148044/99.wav", + "text": "民眾在國內藥粧店都可以買得到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148044/100.wav", + "text": "而且我們都說中藥比西藥溫和" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148044/101.wav", + "text": "所以我請教部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148044/102.wav", + "text": "為什麼比較溫和的葛根湯" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148044/103.wav", + "text": "和小青龍湯反而是處方藥" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148044/104.wav", + "text": "所以中醫界對這一類的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148044/105.wav", + "text": "他們會比較堅持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148044/106.wav", + "text": "這一類應該還是要醫師處方" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148044/107.wav", + "text": "所以我剛剛點的那兩個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148044/108.wav", + "text": "有比較多的副作用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148044/109.wav", + "text": "這兩個我倒是沒有特別去瞭解" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148044/110.wav", + "text": "也沒關係" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148044/111.wav", + "text": "因為我既然提到了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148044/112.wav", + "text": "是不是可以針對這兩個品項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148044/113.wav", + "text": "比較一下坊間西藥中藥的感冒藥" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148044/114.wav", + "text": "衛福部宣導推動自我照護" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148044/115.wav", + "text": "大病到大醫院小病到診所" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148044/116.wav", + "text": "小小病民眾可以自我照護" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148044/117.wav", + "text": "但是民眾有小小病" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148044/118.wav", + "text": "我們就會到藥局買藥" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148044/119.wav", + "text": "到藥局買藥卻只有西藥的選擇" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148044/120.wav", + "text": "對於部分有些小小病" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148044/121.wav", + "text": "卻只能到大醫院掛中醫科" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148044/122.wav", + "text": "或者到中醫診所" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148044/123.wav", + "text": "我就點出這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148044/124.wav", + "text": "因為主要的問題就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148044/125.wav", + "text": "中藥並沒有處方藥" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148044/126.wav", + "text": "指示藥和成藥的分類標準" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148044/127.wav", + "text": "中醫藥振興計畫裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148044/128.wav", + "text": "也有提到這個問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148044/129.wav", + "text": "而目前國際間以中藥" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148044/130.wav", + "text": "當其他的國家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148044/131.wav", + "text": "都致力於非處方藥發展的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148044/132.wav", + "text": "你們對這件事情的看法是什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148044/133.wav", + "text": "這個問題你們有想過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148044/134.wav", + "text": "要怎麼處理或怎麼解決" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148044/135.wav", + "text": "當然因應著民眾的需要趨勢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148044/136.wav", + "text": "都可以來做檢討" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148044/137.wav", + "text": "大概是兩個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148044/138.wav", + "text": "一個就是藥食兩用的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148044/139.wav", + "text": "第二個就是剛剛委員提到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148044/140.wav", + "text": "的成藥或指示用藥的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148044/141.wav", + "text": "目前的品項是少的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148044/142.wav", + "text": "也討論很久了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148044/143.wav", + "text": "我猜啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148044/144.wav", + "text": "在國際間是有品質保證的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148044/145.wav", + "text": "我們的技術其實也非常好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148044/146.wav", + "text": "如果臺灣的中醫藥法規制度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148044/147.wav", + "text": "可以與時俱進的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148044/148.wav", + "text": "對於整個中醫藥的發展" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148044/149.wav", + "text": "有很大的幫助" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148044/150.wav", + "text": "本席也相信這個議題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148044/151.wav", + "text": "肯定會掀起一番風雨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148044/152.wav", + "text": "因為這個產業界的討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148044/153.wav", + "text": "都相當激烈" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148044/154.wav", + "text": "我是領教過的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148044/155.wav", + "text": "已經超過2分鐘了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148044/156.wav", + "text": "相關團體大家都要理性討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148044/157.wav", + "text": "因為你們是生命共同體" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148044/158.wav", + "text": "凡事不能只看自己" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148044/159.wav", + "text": "中醫藥各界及食品業的團體" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148044/160.wav", + "text": "要相互合作" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148044/161.wav", + "text": "而不是互相的消滅" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148044/162.wav", + "text": "要拿出智慧" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148044/163.wav", + "text": "要協調溝通" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148044/164.wav", + "text": "當立法委員的才能順利修法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148044/165.wav", + "text": "讓我們臺灣中醫藥的制度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148044/166.wav", + "text": "可以與時俱進" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148044/167.wav", + "text": "攜手再創" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148044/168.wav", + "text": "疫情時期" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148044/169.wav", + "text": "清冠一號" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148044/170.wav", + "text": "享譽國際" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148044/171.wav", + "text": "產業鏈蓬勃發展" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148044/172.wav", + "text": "大賺錢的高峰" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148044/173.wav", + "text": "我今天就很誠實的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148044/174.wav", + "text": "講出你們不敢講的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148044/175.wav", + "text": "大家要合作不要互相消滅" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148044/176.wav", + "text": "謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148044/177.wav", + "text": "謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148044/178.wav", + "text": "謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/0.wav", + "text": "今天的專案報告裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/1.wav", + "text": "講到一些干預我國選舉的因應策略" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/2.wav", + "text": "其中在認知作戰的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/3.wav", + "text": "你們有一個叫提升深度偽造的技術檢測能量" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/4.wav", + "text": "我比較好奇的是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/5.wav", + "text": "你們的技術檢測能量是真的沒有問題嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/6.wav", + "text": "你們最近兩三年有做什麼樣的變革" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/7.wav", + "text": "或是你們硬體設備增加了什麼嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/8.wav", + "text": "預算上有成長的嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/9.wav", + "text": "這一部分法務部調查局有專業人才" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/10.wav", + "text": "也購買了一些先進設備" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/11.wav", + "text": "你確定嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/12.wav", + "text": "我們曾經請他們對外作說明展示過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/13.wav", + "text": "這樣子喔我為什麼要講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/14.wav", + "text": "在109年不久才三年前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/15.wav", + "text": "臺灣高等法院臺南分院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/16.wav", + "text": "有一個關於強制猥褻的判決" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/17.wav", + "text": "判決當中有一個證物" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/18.wav", + "text": "發現現場有錄音及錄影" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/19.wav", + "text": "強制猥褻" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/20.wav", + "text": "嘛而且現場有錄音和錄影" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/21.wav", + "text": "調查局稱待" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/22.wav", + "text": "待鑑資料為數位錄影音檔案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/23.wav", + "text": "而數位錄音內容具有經編輯修改卻難以發現的特性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/24.wav", + "text": "依該局現有的技術難以鑑定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/25.wav", + "text": "109年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/26.wav", + "text": "我很好奇調查局建置的能量" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/27.wav", + "text": "是不是真的能夠因應Deepfake的技術檢測能量" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/28.wav", + "text": "3年前都不行了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/29.wav", + "text": "強制猥褻" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/30.wav", + "text": "說他們沒有這種技術能力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/31.wav", + "text": "3年後做了什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/32.wav", + "text": "這3年裡面做了什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/33.wav", + "text": "變成信心滿滿跟大家說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/34.wav", + "text": "他們檢測能量沒有問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/35.wav", + "text": "這3年來他們進步很多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/36.wav", + "text": "讓調查局來說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/37.wav", + "text": "是謝謝委員關心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/38.wav", + "text": "這個案子我知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/39.wav", + "text": "因為當時他們申請的鑑定是要做聲紋的鑑定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/40.wav", + "text": "這個是由我們鑑識科學處來負責" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/41.wav", + "text": "他提供的帶子是數位的聲紋" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/42.wav", + "text": "那數位的聲紋有它技術上的困難" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/43.wav", + "text": "現在委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/44.wav", + "text": "不是數位的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/45.wav", + "text": "現在的影音檔案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/46.wav", + "text": "有哪些不是數位的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/47.wav", + "text": "你現在說數位聲紋你們很困難" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/48.wav", + "text": "現在每個都是數位化" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/49.wav", + "text": "有哪些影音不是數位的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/50.wav", + "text": "跟委員報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/51.wav", + "text": "我們現在針對Deepfake的技術" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/52.wav", + "text": "提供給我們的程式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/53.wav", + "text": "然後我們交叉比對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/54.wav", + "text": "再經過人工的判別" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/55.wav", + "text": "本身這個鑑別出來我們也不做鑑定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/56.wav", + "text": "但是我們是提出檢測的報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/57.wav", + "text": "這個檢測報告可以說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/58.wav", + "text": "是不是有高度被" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/59.wav", + "text": "鑑定跟檢測報告有什麼不一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/60.wav", + "text": "鑑定的話就是確實是如此" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/61.wav", + "text": "檢測報告就不是確定就是如此" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/62.wav", + "text": "你今天來這邊信心滿滿地說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/63.wav", + "text": "你們都沒問題了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/64.wav", + "text": "可以阻斷境外勢力對臺" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/65.wav", + "text": "認知作戰的案件" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/66.wav", + "text": "可以阻斷假訊息了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/67.wav", + "text": "你現在講的意思是說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/68.wav", + "text": "你們還沒有辦法做到鑑定報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/69.wav", + "text": "你們可以做出一個檢測報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/70.wav", + "text": "你們對數位內容" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/71.wav", + "text": "難以鑑定的地方" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/72.wav", + "text": "那突然就變成說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/73.wav", + "text": "你們可以做檢測" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/74.wav", + "text": "跟委員說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/75.wav", + "text": "因為它是兩種不同的東西" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/76.wav", + "text": "前面那個是聲紋的鑑定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/77.wav", + "text": "後面這個是深度偽造的檢測" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/78.wav", + "text": "好啦我現在就問你" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/79.wav", + "text": "是只針對影像有辦法檢測是不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/80.wav", + "text": "影像跟聲音都可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/81.wav", + "text": "像柯文哲先生前面那個案子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/82.wav", + "text": "好那我知道了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/83.wav", + "text": "\n部長你知道了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/84.wav", + "text": "喔他們還有很多力有未逮的地方" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/85.wav", + "text": "不如你報告的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/86.wav", + "text": "一切都盡在掌握之中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/87.wav", + "text": "沒有辦法鑑定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/88.wav", + "text": "沒有辦法做成鑑定報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/89.wav", + "text": "如果沒有鑑定報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/90.wav", + "text": "在法院裡面是沒有辦法處理的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/91.wav", + "text": "依法是沒有辦法處理的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/92.wav", + "text": "可能很難成為是一個鑑定報告的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/93.wav", + "text": "那我今天不是要講這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/94.wav", + "text": "我是說其實應該要精進的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/95.wav", + "text": "要趕快精進" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/96.wav", + "text": "啦我們在這一段落後的路" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/97.wav", + "text": "其實應該要馬上急起直追啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/98.wav", + "text": "\n我現在還是要談中國介入我們選舉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/99.wav", + "text": "為什麼現在大家講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/100.wav", + "text": "介選這個名詞好像不是我們的傳統語言" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/101.wav", + "text": "大家講中國介入選舉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/102.wav", + "text": "假新聞認知作戰很多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/103.wav", + "text": "包括我們看到Lin bay好油" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/104.wav", + "text": "賓現在林裕紘說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/105.wav", + "text": "他的手機電腦統統在維也納丟掉了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/106.wav", + "text": "那剩下許哲賓" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/107.wav", + "text": "許哲賓的手機跟筆電裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/108.wav", + "text": "有超過100組的臉書帳號" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/109.wav", + "text": "為什麼要討論這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/110.wav", + "text": "是因為2020年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/111.wav", + "text": "三年前兩年多以前而已" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/112.wav", + "text": "臉書曾經關閉過全球58億個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/113.wav", + "text": "沒有在活動的殭屍帳號" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/114.wav", + "text": "所以許哲賓擁有的這些帳號" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/115.wav", + "text": "沒有被刪除沒有被關閉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/116.wav", + "text": "證明它都是有效的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/117.wav", + "text": "不是殭屍帳號" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/118.wav", + "text": "所以他是長期在養的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/119.wav", + "text": "然後沒有被刪除掉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/120.wav", + "text": "這個東西當然有金流" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/121.wav", + "text": "受誰委託才查得出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/122.wav", + "text": "也都可以看到誰在操縱這些案子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/123.wav", + "text": "和操縱這些帳號嘛對不對部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/124.wav", + "text": "個案我想承辦的檢警調" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/125.wav", + "text": "他們會掌握" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/126.wav", + "text": "啦會再往上溯源" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/127.wav", + "text": "或是證據會如何去追索" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/128.wav", + "text": "我想他們都在努力當中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/129.wav", + "text": "因為這個個案還在偵查中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/130.wav", + "text": "好啦你這樣講其實" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/131.wav", + "text": "也是可以啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/132.wav", + "text": "但是我們要講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/133.wav", + "text": "因為認知作戰是現在進行式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/134.wav", + "text": "所以我們一直不斷地根據其實" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/135.wav", + "text": "影響選舉的不是只有買票" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/136.wav", + "text": "更大一部分是認知作戰" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/137.wav", + "text": "連買票的錢都不用了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/138.wav", + "text": "看了人家就相信了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/139.wav", + "text": "所以中國在網路電子戰也定義" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/140.wav", + "text": "它講了很多啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/141.wav", + "text": "包括運用心理戰和戰略" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/142.wav", + "text": "欺騙等手段" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/143.wav", + "text": "動搖軍心民心和政府信念" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/144.wav", + "text": "破壞社會既有的網絡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/145.wav", + "text": "加深原本的對立" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/146.wav", + "text": "這也就是做認知上的攻擊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/147.wav", + "text": "在這種狀況裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/148.wav", + "text": "因為臺灣是民主的國家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/149.wav", + "text": "內部的意見衝突是民主的常態" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/150.wav", + "text": "可是意見衝突會形成認知作戰的溫床" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/151.wav", + "text": "透過個資和分群投放不同的訊息" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/152.wav", + "text": "它去影響投票行為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/153.wav", + "text": "攻擊我們的民主機制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/154.wav", + "text": "而且大家都認知到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/155.wav", + "text": "這個是很嚴重的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/156.wav", + "text": "包括以色列跟哈瑪斯的衝突" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/157.wav", + "text": "他們來請教臺灣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/158.wav", + "text": "到底怎麼去因應這些假訊息" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/159.wav", + "text": "有這件事嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/160.wav", + "text": "過去調查局" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/161.wav", + "text": "跟其他國家的執法單位或情資單位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/162.wav", + "text": "都有一些聯繫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/163.wav", + "text": "大家互相交流" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/164.wav", + "text": "\n但我要講沈伯洋" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/165.wav", + "text": "臺北大學的沈伯洋副教授" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/166.wav", + "text": "針對上一次2020年的選舉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/167.wav", + "text": "他根據臺灣線上聲量排名" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/168.wav", + "text": "備份了千萬筆以上的資料" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/169.wav", + "text": "然後再尋管道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/170.wav", + "text": "蒐集線下的耳語" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/171.wav", + "text": "所謂的線上講的大概是社群軟體" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/172.wav", + "text": "我們看得到的臉書" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/173.wav", + "text": "這些他也透過管道蒐集線下的耳語" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/174.wav", + "text": "就是像通訊軟體的LINE裡面的這些群組" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/175.wav", + "text": "發現當時大選期間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/176.wav", + "text": "至少發生了幾個異常狀態" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/177.wav", + "text": "我現在是說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/178.wav", + "text": "我們對於這一些認知戰的掌握" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/179.wav", + "text": "你是要被動地等到人家去檢舉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/180.wav", + "text": "或是人家來我們才偵辦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/181.wav", + "text": "還是我們主動地要看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/182.wav", + "text": "那你要看什麼內容你知道嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/183.wav", + "text": "因為你們說你們會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/184.wav", + "text": "主動去做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/185.wav", + "text": "你們要怎麼做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/186.wav", + "text": "法務部會行政上來協助" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/187.wav", + "text": "第一線的執法單位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/188.wav", + "text": "因為對於假訊息掌握" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/189.wav", + "text": "刑事警察局" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/190.wav", + "text": "他們也會做網路的巡邏" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/191.wav", + "text": "我的瞭解警政署那邊也有網路巡邏警察" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/192.wav", + "text": "他們也可以知道有一些訊息" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/193.wav", + "text": "網路巡邏警察有效的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/194.wav", + "text": "詐騙集團就沒有用了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/195.wav", + "text": "啦我在臉書看一看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/196.wav", + "text": "很多一頁式廣告就跳出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/197.wav", + "text": "然後google新聞看一看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/198.wav", + "text": "一頁式的詐騙就都出來了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/199.wav", + "text": "更不要講認知作戰" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/200.wav", + "text": "太難了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/201.wav", + "text": "\n我現在講沈伯洋副教授" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/202.wav", + "text": "他講的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/203.wav", + "text": "就是在社群軟體上的異常" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/204.wav", + "text": "有幾個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/205.wav", + "text": "你現在知道怎麼樣異常" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/206.wav", + "text": "你才知道怎麼下手" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/207.wav", + "text": "你才知道怎麼監看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/208.wav", + "text": "我聽你們在說巡邏" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/209.wav", + "text": "巡邏是沒用的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/210.wav", + "text": "啦第一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/211.wav", + "text": "他講整體數據異常" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/212.wav", + "text": "他觀察上一次的選舉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/213.wav", + "text": "2019年10月以前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/214.wav", + "text": "2020年1月選舉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/215.wav", + "text": "嘛在10月以前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/216.wav", + "text": "沒有任何一個單一政治人物" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/217.wav", + "text": "在臉書的聲量超過30%" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/218.wav", + "text": "但是2019年10月以後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/219.wav", + "text": "韓國瑜當時的聲量超過60%" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/220.wav", + "text": "另外在新聞媒體上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/221.wav", + "text": "每天1萬則的報導裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/222.wav", + "text": "平均850則都在討論韓國瑜" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/223.wav", + "text": "而且長達3個月" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/224.wav", + "text": "到他投票以前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/225.wav", + "text": "這個聲量都維持在8%到9%" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/226.wav", + "text": "很高的聲量" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/227.wav", + "text": "啦\n我為什麼講這個是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/228.wav", + "text": "因為我們講一個2016年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/229.wav", + "text": "蔡英文總統當選的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/230.wav", + "text": "你知道那一天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/231.wav", + "text": "他的聲量有多高嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/232.wav", + "text": "他當選了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/233.wav", + "text": "喔開票那一天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/234.wav", + "text": "喔蔡英文總統的聲量不過是5%" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/235.wav", + "text": "而且只有一天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/236.wav", + "text": "那我們來講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/237.wav", + "text": "上一次的總統選舉韓國瑜的聲量" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/238.wav", + "text": "這樣子每天都8%到9%" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/239.wav", + "text": "而且連續3個月" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/240.wav", + "text": "所以這是整體數據上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/241.wav", + "text": "有出現高度不合比例的現象" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/242.wav", + "text": "這個數據不包括" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/243.wav", + "text": "簡體中文的文章" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/244.wav", + "text": "也不包括臉書" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/245.wav", + "text": "在選舉期間刪除的社團" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/246.wav", + "text": "它刪除的社團" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/247.wav", + "text": "99個都是韓國瑜的社團" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/248.wav", + "text": "其中3個社團" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/249.wav", + "text": "超過10萬名的成員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/250.wav", + "text": "都還不包括喔被刪除掉的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/251.wav", + "text": "所以整體數據異常" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/252.wav", + "text": "你們有人在監看這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/253.wav", + "text": "沈伯洋教授做的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/254.wav", + "text": "我們官方有人在做嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/255.wav", + "text": "檢調調查局檢察體系" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/256.wav", + "text": "警政署有嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/257.wav", + "text": "我們對網路的輿論聲量" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/258.wav", + "text": "你們發現最近有什麼異常嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/259.wav", + "text": "我們會持續關注" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/260.wav", + "text": "但願如此是真的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/261.wav", + "text": "但願你們是有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/262.wav", + "text": "啦\n我再講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/263.wav", + "text": "他發現線上異常還有第二個現象" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/264.wav", + "text": "就是Facebook的數據異常" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/265.wav", + "text": "他備份了370個粉專和社團" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/266.wav", + "text": "其中有202個泛藍" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/267.wav", + "text": "168個泛綠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/268.wav", + "text": "兩者在2019年選舉的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/269.wav", + "text": "聲量的提升大部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/270.wav", + "text": "來自於連結和影片分享" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/271.wav", + "text": "但是他發現" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/272.wav", + "text": "有部分特定粉專和社團" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/273.wav", + "text": "只分享特定農場的文章" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/274.wav", + "text": "不符合一般網路" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/275.wav", + "text": "粉絲專業的行為模式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/276.wav", + "text": "由一個世界華人系列的粉專" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/277.wav", + "text": "來看選舉前6個月" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/278.wav", + "text": "該系列的粉專固定分享" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/279.wav", + "text": "或是固定三個連結" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/280.wav", + "text": "整個粉專全部都只分享" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/281.wav", + "text": "這幾個農場或是連結的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/282.wav", + "text": "比重是百分之一" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/283.wav", + "text": "它從不分享其他的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/284.wav", + "text": "這是大量成立粉專和社團" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/285.wav", + "text": "來提高特定政治人物的網路聲量" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/286.wav", + "text": "而這類異常的網路聲量" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/287.wav", + "text": "藍是綠的2倍到3倍" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/288.wav", + "text": "好我今天說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/289.wav", + "text": "很多人都會這樣操作" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/290.wav", + "text": "但我們今天要講的是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/291.wav", + "text": "中國介入我們總統選舉的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/292.wav", + "text": "你就不容小覷了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/293.wav", + "text": "有特定連結" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/294.wav", + "text": "特定粉專" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/295.wav", + "text": "特定農場" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/296.wav", + "text": "\n第三個是在YouTube上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/297.wav", + "text": "異常請問你們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/298.wav", + "text": "就你們觀察當中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/299.wav", + "text": "YouTube有什麼樣的異常現象" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/300.wav", + "text": "如果你們不知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/301.wav", + "text": "沈伯洋的文章你們有看過嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/302.wav", + "text": "如果我們情治單位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/303.wav", + "text": "人家已經做了研究" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/304.wav", + "text": "做了報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/305.wav", + "text": "你們連看也不看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/306.wav", + "text": "好像也不太有道理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/307.wav", + "text": "YouTube通常有什麼樣的異常呢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/308.wav", + "text": "跟委員報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/309.wav", + "text": "我們都會注意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/310.wav", + "text": "我們並不是說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/311.wav", + "text": "我們不會去看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/312.wav", + "text": "我們都會去瞭解" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/313.wav", + "text": "去關心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/314.wav", + "text": "對啊你看過了瞭解了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/315.wav", + "text": "關心了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/316.wav", + "text": "YouTube怎麼異常法嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/317.wav", + "text": "YouTube上面的影音" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/318.wav", + "text": "確實是有一些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/319.wav", + "text": "有境外勢力介入" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/320.wav", + "text": "以及想要操弄的情況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/321.wav", + "text": "這個我們有發現" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/322.wav", + "text": "好那我就分享給部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/323.wav", + "text": "等等大家聽一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/324.wav", + "text": "YouTube的觀看數訂閱數" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/325.wav", + "text": "和捐款連結" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/326.wav", + "text": "他以訂閱數至少2,000以上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/327.wav", + "text": "作為觀察的分水嶺" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/328.wav", + "text": "發現所有異常增加" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/329.wav", + "text": "都發生在同一天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/330.wav", + "text": "就是2019年的10月15日開始" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/331.wav", + "text": "這一類的頻道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/332.wav", + "text": "大量散布選舉相關的爭議訊息" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/333.wav", + "text": "而且按讚數出現異常" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/334.wav", + "text": "有時候影片" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/335.wav", + "text": "有上千個讚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/336.wav", + "text": "有時候一個讚也沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/337.wav", + "text": "是不會這樣子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/338.wav", + "text": "正常的YouTube觀賞" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/339.wav", + "text": "也不會這樣子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/340.wav", + "text": "再看看他們的捐款" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/341.wav", + "text": "因為大量的直播者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/342.wav", + "text": "但可疑的地方是什麼你知道嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/343.wav", + "text": "部分直播者提供的捐款連結" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/344.wav", + "text": "為支付寶或者是微信" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/345.wav", + "text": "此外" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/346.wav", + "text": "以2019年臺灣直播主" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/347.wav", + "text": "捐款排行榜當中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/348.wav", + "text": "前九名有6名是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/349.wav", + "text": "支持韓國瑜的直播主" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/350.wav", + "text": "第一名的是誰你知道嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/351.wav", + "text": "局長你知道嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/352.wav", + "text": "第一名的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/353.wav", + "text": "YouTube直播" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/354.wav", + "text": "臺灣排行榜第一名的是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/355.wav", + "text": "高雄林小姐" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/356.wav", + "text": "這些數據搭配觀看數訂閱數" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/357.wav", + "text": "就發現" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/358.wav", + "text": "她怎麼可能成為臺灣最紅的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/359.wav", + "text": "donate最多的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/360.wav", + "text": "第一名" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/361.wav", + "text": "這個都很容易看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/362.wav", + "text": "我怕的是民間學者在幫忙看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/363.wav", + "text": "我們有沒有人在看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/364.wav", + "text": "然後再講IG和Twitter" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/365.wav", + "text": "IG和Twitter怎麼異常你知道嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/366.wav", + "text": "部長知道嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/367.wav", + "text": "我想你應該不知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/368.wav", + "text": "局長應該也沒辦法講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/369.wav", + "text": "他講的異常" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/370.wav", + "text": "是曾經在選舉前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/371.wav", + "text": "突然出現大量" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/372.wav", + "text": "每個IG的帳號上面都直接寫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/373.wav", + "text": "宣告我的投票意志" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/374.wav", + "text": "他給年輕人看的訊息" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/375.wav", + "text": "IG上面有寫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/376.wav", + "text": "大家都要來宣告我的投票意志" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/377.wav", + "text": "同時大量的人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/378.wav", + "text": "在他們的IG大量帳號" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/379.wav", + "text": "啦不見得是真的自然人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/380.wav", + "text": "他們在IG宣告他們的投票意志" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/381.wav", + "text": "然後討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/382.wav", + "text": "失業率有多高" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/383.wav", + "text": "政府有多無能" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/384.wav", + "text": "然後在一個小時內" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/385.wav", + "text": "同時大量散布" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/386.wav", + "text": "大家都知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/387.wav", + "text": "這些帳號從以前都沒有討論過政治議題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/388.wav", + "text": "新聞報導了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/389.wav", + "text": "揭露了以後這些帳號大量刪除掉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/390.wav", + "text": "然後他們說他們是宣告我的投票意志" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/391.wav", + "text": "宣告意志" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/392.wav", + "text": "這四個字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/393.wav", + "text": "不是臺灣慣用的語言" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/394.wav", + "text": "這種很不尋常" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/395.wav", + "text": "而且很容易發現" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/396.wav", + "text": "理論上應該是很容易" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/397.wav", + "text": "如果你們有在注意的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/398.wav", + "text": "真的在乎的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/399.wav", + "text": "應該也很容易看得到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/400.wav", + "text": "這是線上的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/401.wav", + "text": "他也監督了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/402.wav", + "text": "他也透過管道去看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/403.wav", + "text": "通訊軟體線下的異常" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/404.wav", + "text": "LINE的流量和內容異常" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/405.wav", + "text": "LINE裡面的流量和異常" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/406.wav", + "text": "因為都是私密的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/407.wav", + "text": "人和人之間的通訊而已" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/408.wav", + "text": "你們可以看到什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/409.wav", + "text": "局長部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/410.wav", + "text": "你們可以看到什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/411.wav", + "text": "LINE你們可以看到什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/412.wav", + "text": "淑芬你已經超過8分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/413.wav", + "text": "抱歉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/414.wav", + "text": "再兩分鐘" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/415.wav", + "text": "可以再給我" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/416.wav", + "text": "兩分鐘" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/417.wav", + "text": "好謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/418.wav", + "text": "LINE的流量跟內容異常" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/419.wav", + "text": "根據LINE公司報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/420.wav", + "text": "我想你們不知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/421.wav", + "text": "93億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/422.wav", + "text": "是臺灣人民主要訊息來源之一" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/423.wav", + "text": "跟線上異常一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/424.wav", + "text": "沈伯洋發現" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/425.wav", + "text": "2019年10月以後出現大量" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/426.wav", + "text": "政治類訊息" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/427.wav", + "text": "與之前顯示的新聞數量相似" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/428.wav", + "text": "出現不合比例的高峰" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/429.wav", + "text": "以2019年12月30日那天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/430.wav", + "text": "為例文字訊息占了76%" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/431.wav", + "text": "圖片影音占了24%" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/432.wav", + "text": "影音當中有60%" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/433.wav", + "text": "為中國內容農場影片或抖音影片" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/434.wav", + "text": "若比對闢謠的一些相關的查證" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/435.wav", + "text": "因為LINE裡面有事實查證的訊號" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/436.wav", + "text": "然後發現這裡面有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/437.wav", + "text": "45.44%為假新聞" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/438.wav", + "text": "沈伯洋進一步的去分析這類政治性謠言" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/439.wav", + "text": "發現這類訊息和YouTube一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/440.wav", + "text": "穩定的在特定日期散布" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/441.wav", + "text": "許多簡體字的政治類謠言會自行爆發" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/442.wav", + "text": "然後突然終止" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/443.wav", + "text": "同一天同時爆發然後突然終止" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/444.wav", + "text": "但一般性的謠言不會突然終止" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/445.wav", + "text": "然後在選舉之後LINE群組大量" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/446.wav", + "text": "以那次選舉為例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/447.wav", + "text": "選舉過後仍然有大量影片在瘋傳作票" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/448.wav", + "text": "這類影片是從選舉前做到選舉後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/449.wav", + "text": "然後出現大曝光" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/450.wav", + "text": "不是臺灣的習慣用語" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/451.wav", + "text": "然後被中評社人民日報鳳凰新聞引用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/452.wav", + "text": "最後以影片或文字形式散布到LINEYouTube和Facebook" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/453.wav", + "text": "這些謠言在選舉前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/454.wav", + "text": "一個月就已經做好準備" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/455.wav", + "text": "而且在選後當天直接爆發" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/456.wav", + "text": "\n再來就是地方謠言的異常" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/457.wav", + "text": "就是地方上散布的謠言不是只有口耳相傳" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/458.wav", + "text": "地方散布的有地方報紙免費發放的農民曆" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/459.wav", + "text": "然後就發現有些農民曆當時就寫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/460.wav", + "text": "韓國瑜是奇才" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/461.wav", + "text": "中國武力統一臺灣等論述" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/462.wav", + "text": "那跟地方廣傳的謠言搭配" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/463.wav", + "text": "比如簽署和平協議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/464.wav", + "text": "存款就可以從臺幣變成人民幣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/465.wav", + "text": "我們在都會沒有看到這種小冊子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/466.wav", + "text": "或者是我們這樣的人我們不會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/467.wav", + "text": "可是真的有這樣的農民曆" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/468.wav", + "text": "也真的有這樣的小冊子在某些地方在散布" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/469.wav", + "text": "所以說這樣的樣態各個陣營的網路操盤" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/470.wav", + "text": "盤手不一定是中國直接" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/471.wav", + "text": "當然我們知道協力者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/472.wav", + "text": "或者是直接間接造成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/473.wav", + "text": "不一定是中國直接主導有關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/474.wav", + "text": "這種進攻模式有可能是外宣模式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/475.wav", + "text": "也有粉紅模式也有農場模式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/476.wav", + "text": "當然也有協力模式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/477.wav", + "text": "然後根據發動者的角色不同" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/478.wav", + "text": "會使用不同的進���模式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/479.wav", + "text": "然後造成不同的結果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/480.wav", + "text": "所以面對新型態多樣性的臺灣選舉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/481.wav", + "text": "我們真的是要想說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/482.wav", + "text": "各部會或者主要的法務部調查局" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/483.wav", + "text": "警政署會有哪些調查或反制的措施" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/484.wav", + "text": "你今天如果不講這些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/485.wav", + "text": "只說你們有打擊的信心主動什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/486.wav", + "text": "你們有沒有更具體的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/487.wav", + "text": "面對面對新型態多樣性的臺灣選舉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/488.wav", + "text": "法務部調查局國安局" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/489.wav", + "text": "有沒有針對這些資訊戰認知戰" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/490.wav", + "text": "影響我們的大選" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/491.wav", + "text": "擬定一個專門的監測或調查計畫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/492.wav", + "text": "有沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/493.wav", + "text": "針對選舉查察這一部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/494.wav", + "text": "我們現在在大的地檢署" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/495.wav", + "text": "我們會快速的來處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/496.wav", + "text": "這怎麼夠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/497.wav", + "text": "地檢署自己的業務都辦不完了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/498.wav", + "text": "案子後面已經一大堆了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/499.wav", + "text": "國安單位檢警調" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/500.wav", + "text": "你們應該面對這樣的不容小覷" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/501.wav", + "text": "啊連美國都是非常嚴重的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/502.wav", + "text": "其次還有多種網紅工作室" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/503.wav", + "text": "藉由網紅對外觸及" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/504.wav", + "text": "他上面有一個伸展中心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/505.wav", + "text": "叫很多網紅去直播" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/506.wav", + "text": "光是這一年就達到一億次了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/507.wav", + "text": "所以跨平台的手法越來越多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/508.wav", + "text": "我沒有針對這篇文章" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/509.wav", + "text": "我是要求" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/510.wav", + "text": "希望我們應該要有一個專責" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/511.wav", + "text": "要長期來做這個事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/512.wav", + "text": "國安沒有半個人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/513.wav", + "text": "專責去做都是兼的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/514.wav", + "text": "茲事體大" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148043/515.wav", + "text": "好啦謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148042/0.wav", + "text": "謝謝主席" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148042/1.wav", + "text": "有請薛部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148042/2.wav", + "text": "有請部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148042/3.wav", + "text": "部長好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148042/4.wav", + "text": "部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148042/5.wav", + "text": "本來台灣醫療工會聯合會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148042/6.wav", + "text": "發起一個醫療勞權的大遊行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148042/7.wav", + "text": "本來要走上街頭" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148042/8.wav", + "text": "結果在前一個晚上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148042/9.wav", + "text": "取消遊行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148042/10.wav", + "text": "部長您知道是哪一位長官" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148042/11.wav", + "text": "要求的嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148042/12.wav", + "text": "這沒有要求" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148042/13.wav", + "text": "啦事實上就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148042/14.wav", + "text": "跟他們做一個溝通" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148042/15.wav", + "text": "啦看看這個遊行主要的目的是什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148042/16.wav", + "text": "如果溝通的結果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148042/17.wav", + "text": "他們願意自己就取消的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148042/18.wav", + "text": "那當然是最好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148042/19.wav", + "text": "我們沒有要求" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148042/20.wav", + "text": "所以他們的聲音" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148042/21.wav", + "text": "你們都會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148042/22.wav", + "text": "都會回應就是了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148042/23.wav", + "text": "對他們現" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148042/24.wav", + "text": "這個我們都瞭解" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148042/25.wav", + "text": "但是我們還進一步" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148042/26.wav", + "text": "邀請他們來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148042/27.wav", + "text": "跟我們再進一步的溝通" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148042/28.wav", + "text": "有一些是比較具體細節的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148042/29.wav", + "text": "我們會更深入的去瞭解" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148042/30.wav", + "text": "一定要聆聽我們這些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148042/31.wav", + "text": "醫護人員的心聲" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148042/32.wav", + "text": "因為我們看到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148042/33.wav", + "text": "他們很辛苦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148042/34.wav", + "text": "只要擴大護理系招生名額" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148042/35.wav", + "text": "就可以解決了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148042/36.wav", + "text": "你覺得這樣子可以解決嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148042/37.wav", + "text": "副總統也沒有說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148042/38.wav", + "text": "只要這樣子就可以解決" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148042/39.wav", + "text": "OK好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148042/40.wav", + "text": "只靠著增加這部分就可以了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148042/41.wav", + "text": "我們護理人員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148042/42.wav", + "text": "主要的原因" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148042/43.wav", + "text": "當然就是護病比高" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148042/44.wav", + "text": "三班制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148042/45.wav", + "text": "有時候還花花班表" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148042/46.wav", + "text": "薪資很低" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148042/47.wav", + "text": "所以我們護理人員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148042/48.wav", + "text": "經常會說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148042/49.wav", + "text": "他跟我們警察" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148042/50.wav", + "text": "警消一樣都是血汗的護理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148042/51.wav", + "text": "實在很高" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148042/52.wav", + "text": "最佳的護病比是1比6" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148042/53.wav", + "text": "其實大概每間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148042/54.wav", + "text": "本席其實也看到了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148042/55.wav", + "text": "因為國際間的研究是說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148042/56.wav", + "text": "只要護理人員多照顧1" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148042/57.wav", + "text": "病人的死亡率" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148042/58.wav", + "text": "就會增加7%" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148042/59.wav", + "text": "所以部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148042/60.wav", + "text": "這個護病比我們是不是應該" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148042/61.wav", + "text": "把它入法化" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148042/62.wav", + "text": "是跟委員報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148042/63.wav", + "text": "正跟這些護理團體" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148042/64.wav", + "text": "在討論這個事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148042/65.wav", + "text": "我們希望" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148042/66.wav", + "text": "最好是能夠在今年底以前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148042/67.wav", + "text": "就把這個護病比談出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148042/68.wav", + "text": "對而且要讓他們願意留下來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148042/69.wav", + "text": "因為其實護理人員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148042/70.wav", + "text": "養成也不容易" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148042/71.wav", + "text": "可是他平均年資" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148042/72.wav", + "text": "只有6年半" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148042/73.wav", + "text": "遠低於日本跟美國" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148042/74.wav", + "text": "的我們不是沒有護理人才" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148042/75.wav", + "text": "而是他們不願意進來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148042/76.wav", + "text": "對時間太短" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148042/77.wav", + "text": "以至於我們現在其實" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148042/78.wav", + "text": "我在辦公室裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148042/79.wav", + "text": "經常會接到很多陳情的電話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148042/80.wav", + "text": "他們家裡的長輩親人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148042/81.wav", + "text": "就在急診室裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148042/82.wav", + "text": "急診室人滿為患" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148042/83.wav", + "text": "但是上面因為護士不足" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148042/84.wav", + "text": "所以就關床" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148042/85.wav", + "text": "有可能會把我們的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148042/86.wav", + "text": "基層診所壓得更辛苦了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148042/87.wav", + "text": "因為大醫院進不去了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148042/88.wav", + "text": "在這一部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148042/89.wav", + "text": "行政院有提到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148042/90.wav", + "text": "每一年投入180億的預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148042/91.wav", + "text": "來提升護理人員的數量" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148042/92.wav", + "text": "衛福部覺得這樣可能嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148042/93.wav", + "text": "這個當然是多管齊下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148042/94.wav", + "text": "啦有十幾種的作法加在一起" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148042/95.wav", + "text": "所需要的經費" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148042/96.wav", + "text": "我們粗估是那個樣子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148042/97.wav", + "text": "還是必須要去做推動" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148042/98.wav", + "text": "然後更細緻的一些作法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148042/99.wav", + "text": "還是必須要逐步地去做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148042/100.wav", + "text": "我們有沒有可能在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148042/101.wav", + "text": "今年年底或在這個會期" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148042/102.wav", + "text": "至少把合理三班的護病比入法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148042/103.wav", + "text": "有沒有辦法做到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148042/104.wav", + "text": "我剛剛跟委員報告過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148042/105.wav", + "text": "我們希望大家在今年年底" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148042/106.wav", + "text": "能夠把比例談出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148042/107.wav", + "text": "我們會去設計" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148042/108.wav", + "text": "因為你說三班護病比" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148042/109.wav", + "text": "把它降低下來之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148042/110.wav", + "text": "醫院大概也沒有辦法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148042/111.wav", + "text": "一天就能夠把人補齊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148042/112.wav", + "text": "所以還是要有一個過渡期" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148042/113.wav", + "text": "就是一定要讓他們知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148042/114.wav", + "text": "我們是非常珍視" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148042/115.wav", + "text": "珍重我們這些護理人員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148042/116.wav", + "text": "最後因為我的時間到了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148042/117.wav", + "text": "我不願意占用太多時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148042/118.wav", + "text": "但是最後要務必" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148042/119.wav", + "text": "因為我昨天看到這個新聞" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148042/120.wav", + "text": "我們有很多癌友" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148042/121.wav", + "text": "但是因為那個保單上面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148042/122.wav", + "text": "針對現有實支實付的保單" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148042/123.wav", + "text": "用備註的方式來認列等等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148042/124.wav", + "text": "要保人並沒有看到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148042/125.wav", + "text": "這些我早上有質詢金管會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148042/126.wav", + "text": "金管會說他們已經" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148042/127.wav", + "text": "在跟衛福部這邊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148042/128.wav", + "text": "務必請衛福部一定要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148042/129.wav", + "text": "因為金管會過去曾經" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148042/130.wav", + "text": "金管會曾經在民國99年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148042/131.wav", + "text": "就出手過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148042/132.wav", + "text": "但是我們有很多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148042/133.wav", + "text": "當時的保險人是不友善" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148042/134.wav", + "text": "的也真的沒有與時俱進" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148042/135.wav", + "text": "一定要幫民眾" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148042/136.wav", + "text": "挺身而出好嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148042/137.wav", + "text": "其實是兩個議題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148042/138.wav", + "text": "目前大家關心的主要就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148042/139.wav", + "text": "因為保單裡面註明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148042/140.wav", + "text": "已經是門診就可以做了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148042/141.wav", + "text": "所以這部分的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148042/142.wav", + "text": "保單顯然沒有與時俱進" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148042/143.wav", + "text": "我們也在跟金管會談" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148042/144.wav", + "text": "看看保險公司在這方面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148042/145.wav", + "text": "可以來做一種轉換" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148042/146.wav", + "text": "就是條件轉換的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148042/147.wav", + "text": "產生一個不可控制的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148042/148.wav", + "text": "這是第一點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148042/149.wav", + "text": "尤其是醫療保險的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148042/150.wav", + "text": "一定要很清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148042/151.wav", + "text": "一定要說明清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148042/152.wav", + "text": "謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148041/0.wav", + "text": "謝謝主席請薛瑞元部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148041/1.wav", + "text": "有請部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148041/2.wav", + "text": "因為禮拜六也有同志大遊行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148041/3.wav", + "text": "其中一個包括是不是要保障單身女性生殖的權利" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148041/4.wav", + "text": "這部分不知道衛福部的態度是怎麼樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148041/5.wav", + "text": "我們基本上不反對啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148041/6.wav", + "text": "不反對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148041/7.wav", + "text": "請問什麼時候你們會有比較明確修法的態度跟草案出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148041/8.wav", + "text": "國健署這邊已經找各個相關的團體跟專家討論過了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148041/9.wav", + "text": "因為它都在同一個法裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148041/10.wav", + "text": "所以代理孕母那一個部分共識是還沒有出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148041/11.wav", + "text": "所以單身女性如果要適用人工生殖法去做受精的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148041/12.wav", + "text": "其實衛福部是同意的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148041/13.wav", + "text": "如果這個部分可以跟代理孕母脫鉤" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148041/14.wav", + "text": "是不是可以先放寬先來做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148041/15.wav", + "text": "當然如果能夠這樣子可能會比較好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148041/16.wav", + "text": "這部分需要多久時" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148041/17.wav", + "text": "或是什麼時候以前會有比較明確的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148041/18.wav", + "text": "因為既然都已經有共識" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148041/19.wav", + "text": "而且現在少子化的狀況對於很多的女性來講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148041/20.wav", + "text": "另外關於同志也有類似的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148041/21.wav", + "text": "因為同性配偶一方的生理性別而無法生育等等的狀況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148041/22.wav", + "text": "這部分可不可以適用人工生殖法呢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148041/23.wav", + "text": "這個會一併處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148041/24.wav", + "text": "所以大概什麼時候會比較明確" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148041/25.wav", + "text": "因為禮拜六就有同志大遊行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148041/26.wav", + "text": "既然都已經開放同志結婚了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148041/27.wav", + "text": "如果要做人工生殖有沒有可能" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148041/28.wav", + "text": "我們盡可能來加速處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148041/29.wav", + "text": "好因為我們有提出這樣子的修法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148041/30.wav", + "text": "\n另外就是凍卵的補助" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148041/31.wav", + "text": "我們也希望能夠向下延伸" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148041/32.wav", + "text": "來鼓勵大家提早凍卵" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148041/33.wav", + "text": "否則等到年紀大了���來凍卵" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148041/34.wav", + "text": "再來做這樣生育不孕的補助" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148041/35.wav", + "text": "其實是事倍功半" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148041/36.wav", + "text": "卵這個就要比較謹慎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148041/37.wav", + "text": "但是因為它的效果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148041/38.wav", + "text": "其實凍卵的問題非常的多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148041/39.wav", + "text": "我也希望衛福部能夠關注" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148041/40.wav", + "text": "包括這些醫療院所" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148041/41.wav", + "text": "在一定的溫度品質等等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148041/42.wav", + "text": "做很好的控管" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148041/43.wav", + "text": "這部分其實很多女性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148041/44.wav", + "text": "他也不知道醫院到底有沒有如合約" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148041/45.wav", + "text": "等到你十年後真的需要了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148041/46.wav", + "text": "這個過程之中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148041/47.wav", + "text": "誰來去監督這個凍卵的品質" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148041/48.wav", + "text": "對所以這個問題是比較大的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148041/49.wav", + "text": "所以衛福部就這部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148041/50.wav", + "text": "有沒有在做相關的管理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148041/51.wav", + "text": "因為我們不是說凍完就沒事了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148041/52.wav", + "text": "所以這個在人工生殖機構裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148041/53.wav", + "text": "所以我覺得衛福部就這個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148041/54.wav", + "text": "也要去做不定期的稽核稽查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148041/55.wav", + "text": "然後去給予這些院所相關的保證認證等等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148041/56.wav", + "text": "讓大家知道哪些是值得信任" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148041/57.wav", + "text": "的而且這過程中還需要有不斷電等等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148041/58.wav", + "text": "因為必須在一定的溫度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148041/59.wav", + "text": "一定的情況之下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148041/60.wav", + "text": "才能夠維持它的品質" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148041/61.wav", + "text": "這些都要有人去監督" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148041/62.wav", + "text": "所以衛福部就這個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148041/63.wav", + "text": "是不是也有相關的監管措施" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148041/64.wav", + "text": "監管措施都一直有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148041/65.wav", + "text": "或者是其他的保存機構" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148041/66.wav", + "text": "我們都會定期去做一些好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148041/67.wav", + "text": "那請把這個稽核資料給我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148041/68.wav", + "text": "有不合格或是等等的狀況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148041/69.wav", + "text": "以及你們到底抽查到什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148041/70.wav", + "text": "因為我10月13號總質詢的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148041/71.wav", + "text": "就有詢問過部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148041/72.wav", + "text": "當時您說會去查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148041/73.wav", + "text": "請問到現在查出來了嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148041/74.wav", + "text": "這一個部分的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148041/75.wav", + "text": "我們所知道的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148041/76.wav", + "text": "中國醫藥大學" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148041/77.wav", + "text": "研究所學生臨床實務" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148041/78.wav", + "text": "臨床實務的方法去做的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148041/79.wav", + "text": "在這個學程之內" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148041/80.wav", + "text": "當然短期去做這一個也是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148041/81.wav", + "text": "因為他實習的時間非常長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148041/82.wav", + "text": "裡面一位就是醫藥學院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148041/83.wav", + "text": "院長的親屬等等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148041/84.wav", + "text": "所以這過程" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148041/85.wav", + "text": "也引起很多本土牙醫的不滿" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148041/86.wav", + "text": "包括說沒有經過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148041/87.wav", + "text": "衛福部的選配分發" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148041/88.wav", + "text": "就直接到醫院去實習" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148041/89.wav", + "text": "但是他這種實習是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148041/90.wav", + "text": "對於一般民眾來講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148041/91.wav", + "text": "權益也受損" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148041/92.wav", + "text": "不知道他到底是實習生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148041/93.wav", + "text": "還是牙醫師" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148041/94.wav", + "text": "已經在醫院裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148041/95.wav", + "text": "做這樣子相關的工作了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148041/96.wav", + "text": "這個就是爭議的所在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148041/97.wav", + "text": "所以衛福部不能只聽" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148041/98.wav", + "text": "中國醫藥學院的資料回復" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148041/99.wav", + "text": "而沒有去做實際的查證" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148041/100.wav", + "text": "這也損害到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148041/101.wav", + "text": "我們本土牙醫的權益" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148041/102.wav", + "text": "所以在這過程之中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148041/103.wav", + "text": "我們也希望衛福部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148041/104.wav", + "text": "能夠嚴格的針對這個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148041/105.wav", + "text": "針對這些沒有選配分發" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148041/106.wav", + "text": "卻到醫院裡面假裝實習" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148041/107.wav", + "text": "但實際上已經在做醫療行為的人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148041/108.wav", + "text": "不只是實習成績不能算而已" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148041/109.wav", + "text": "啊重點是這樣的行為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148041/110.wav", + "text": "有沒有任何懲處" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148041/111.wav", + "text": "有沒有任何的後果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148041/112.wav", + "text": "這些目前都沒有非常的明確" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148041/113.wav", + "text": "等於這個名額是假的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148041/114.wav", + "text": "實際上後門就在那裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148041/115.wav", + "text": "大家都走後門就好啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148041/116.wav", + "text": "所以這個對於本土牙醫來講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148041/117.wav", + "text": "是一個滿大的影響" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148041/118.wav", + "text": "這不會是後門" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148041/119.wav", + "text": "啦因為他再怎麼樣實習" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148041/120.wav", + "text": "那個時間跟成績都不能算進去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148041/121.wav", + "text": "第二階段國考的那個資格" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148041/122.wav", + "text": "是不能算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148041/123.wav", + "text": "他不是真正的牙醫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148041/124.wav", + "text": "我們會跟教育部這邊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148041/125.wav", + "text": "再來瞭解一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148041/126.wav", + "text": "其實因為他是實習學生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148041/127.wav", + "text": "所以他還是必須在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148041/128.wav", + "text": "牙醫師的監督底下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148041/129.wav", + "text": "才能做某一些事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148041/130.wav", + "text": "你沒有24小時" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148041/131.wav", + "text": "你根本不知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148041/132.wav", + "text": "他有沒有實際在做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148041/133.wav", + "text": "所以我們也希望" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148041/134.wav", + "text": "要有明確的區別" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148041/135.wav", + "text": "否則民眾根本不知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148041/136.wav", + "text": "他到底是實習還是牙醫師" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148041/137.wav", + "text": "是不是在身分上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148041/138.wav", + "text": "如何能夠讓民眾一目瞭然" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148041/139.wav", + "text": "這樣民眾也能夠發揮監督" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148041/140.wav", + "text": "如果他旁邊沒有牙醫師" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148041/141.wav", + "text": "在監督的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148041/142.wav", + "text": "能去檢舉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148041/143.wav", + "text": "這樣可以嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148041/144.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148041/145.wav", + "text": "好謝謝主席" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148041/146.wav", + "text": "謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148040/0.wav", + "text": "召委我先請教一下法務部的蔡部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148040/1.wav", + "text": "部長因為陸軍第257旅" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148040/2.wav", + "text": "在今年8月時爆發營內新兵鬥毆" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148040/3.wav", + "text": "憲兵隊依照" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148040/4.wav", + "text": "妨害秩序罪嫌把16個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148040/5.wav", + "text": "役男函送法辦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148040/6.wav", + "text": "檢方偵結之後認定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148040/7.wav", + "text": "軍營是封閉單位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148040/8.wav", + "text": "與妨害秩序罪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148040/9.wav", + "text": "的構成要件在公共場所施暴脅迫不符" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148040/10.wav", + "text": "所以處分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148040/11.wav", + "text": "不起訴" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148040/12.wav", + "text": "部長本席是想要請教您" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148040/13.wav", + "text": "對這樣子的案件" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148040/14.wav", + "text": "集合" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148040/15.wav", + "text": "地點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148040/16.wav", + "text": "屬於不特定人可以自由進出但是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148040/17.wav", + "text": "所以連集合場都不算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148040/18.wav", + "text": "公共場所" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148040/19.wav", + "text": "部長您認同他這樣子的認定嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148040/20.wav", + "text": "這值得再研究" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148040/21.wav", + "text": "值得再研究" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148040/22.wav", + "text": "所以它到底是不是公共場所" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148040/23.wav", + "text": "或是特定人可以進出" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148040/24.wav", + "text": "安全的維護不是隨便的人可以進出" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148040/25.wav", + "text": "但是他在那個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148040/26.wav", + "text": "可以來討論的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148040/27.wav", + "text": "我也不是批評這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148040/28.wav", + "text": "不起訴處分怎麼樣因為個案我還是尊重檢察官的決定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148040/29.wav", + "text": "但法律問題是可以討論的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148040/30.wav", + "text": "會有一些人來問本席很多問題比如" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148040/31.wav", + "text": "車禍致死案但是對不起那不是道路" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148040/32.wav", + "text": "道交條例對於道路有特殊的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148040/33.wav", + "text": "規定但是如果連集合場都不算公共場所以後現役軍人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148040/34.wav", + "text": "在營區內對長官或他人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148040/35.wav", + "text": "所做的公然" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148040/36.wav", + "text": "不符合" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148040/37.wav", + "text": "公共場所的要件不是嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148040/38.wav", + "text": "所以我說法律問題是值得討論的是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148040/39.wav", + "text": "因為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148040/40.wav", + "text": "現在部隊裡面都沒有軍法都沒有軍法官了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148040/41.wav", + "text": "可是我們也看到有在營區內連集合場或中山" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148040/42.wav", + "text": "部屬對長官辱罵髒話三字經的案件" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148040/43.wav", + "text": "也有檢察官是以公然" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148040/44.wav", + "text": "侮辱長官罪起訴而且還被法院判刑\n" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148040/45.wav", + "text": "別" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148040/46.wav", + "text": "獨立行使職權" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148040/47.wav", + "text": "但是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148040/48.wav", + "text": "獨立行使職權並不代表他可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148040/49.wav", + "text": "恣意的認定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148040/50.wav", + "text": "你們應該就公共場所這個要件" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148040/51.wav", + "text": "他怎麼可以這樣子就自己決定呢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148040/52.wav", + "text": "委員的指教我們虛心接受因為如果有不同的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148040/53.wav", + "text": "地檢署檢察官" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148040/54.wav", + "text": "對於問題的看法不一致我會邀請高檢署或最高檢察署" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148040/55.wav", + "text": "來大家討論說應該要有一致的看法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148040/56.wav", + "text": "是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148040/57.wav", + "text": "如果照你們這麼講學校也不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148040/58.wav", + "text": "大家可以自由進入的只要這種有門禁的都沒有以後所謂公然侮辱" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148040/59.wav", + "text": "都不能夠成立就很麻煩所以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148040/60.wav", + "text": "還是建議你們一定要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148040/61.wav", + "text": "有一致的說法\n今天本席有看到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148040/62.wav", + "text": "國軍官兵遭對岸吸收" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148040/63.wav", + "text": "洩漏或���付" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148040/64.wav", + "text": "真的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148040/65.wav", + "text": "還不錯因為我看新聞上面講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148040/66.wav", + "text": "這個軍官夫妻洩密案是年初爆發" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148040/67.wav", + "text": "調查局搜索" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148040/68.wav", + "text": "約談之後經檢方起訴了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148040/69.wav", + "text": "今天英國" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148040/70.wav", + "text": "變的這個事情要擬定一些計畫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148040/71.wav", + "text": "美國參議院也說臺灣關係法要加強版等等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148040/72.wav", + "text": "兩岸之間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148040/73.wav", + "text": "即使是在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148040/74.wav", + "text": "友邦之間我們對於" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148040/75.wav", + "text": "防止洩密這問題也是要很小心的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148040/76.wav", + "text": "像這樣子的比如大家都在關心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148040/77.wav", + "text": "如果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148040/78.wav", + "text": "大陸有關單位是長時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148040/79.wav", + "text": "不要說立法委員還有一些處理機敏的人員我們的反情報部門" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148040/80.wav", + "text": "要如何處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148040/81.wav", + "text": "我覺得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148040/82.wav", + "text": "趙委員的這個新聞" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148040/83.wav", + "text": "不要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148040/84.wav", + "text": "單純以緋聞" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148040/85.wav", + "text": "或是什麼外遇感情糾紛來看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148040/86.wav", + "text": "關於機敏國安問題還有反情報的這些問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148040/87.wav", + "text": "因應" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148040/88.wav", + "text": "我們要非常重視對於" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148040/89.wav", + "text": "國家機密的保護問題如果真的有涉及洩密" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148040/90.wav", + "text": "都是屬於國防的話這是外患罪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148040/91.wav", + "text": "是由高檢署" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148040/92.wav", + "text": "所以你們會主動" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148040/93.wav", + "text": "偵查嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148040/94.wav", + "text": "如果有訊息當然會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148040/95.wav", + "text": "檢察官因為告訴告發或其他情事而知有犯罪嫌疑都要主動偵查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148040/96.wav", + "text": "是剛剛其實前面已經有委員講到調查局是負責國內的可是國內的反情報調查局" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148040/97.wav", + "text": "也應該" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148040/98.wav", + "text": "要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148040/99.wav", + "text": "做到嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148040/100.wav", + "text": "\n還有國安局徐副局長本身就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148040/101.wav", + "text": "檢察官出身" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148040/102.wav", + "text": "我真的很寄望你們因為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148040/103.wav", + "text": "本席三十年前在美國讀書的時候國安局也有我的學長到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148040/104.wav", + "text": "什麼CCTV各種的監控" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148040/105.wav", + "text": "基本上你們調查局的安全局的他們全部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148040/106.wav", + "text": "通通都有在掌控所以我也被監控過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148040/107.wav", + "text": "\n我覺得對於我們這些機敏人員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148040/108.wav", + "text": "趙委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148040/109.wav", + "text": "年輕" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148040/110.wav", + "text": "帥氣他可能太相信自己的外表不瞭解自己" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148040/111.wav", + "text": "同時也有很多脆弱的地方" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148040/112.wav", + "text": "在這一部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148040/113.wav", + "text": "不管是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148040/114.wav", + "text": "調查局或者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148040/115.wav", + "text": "國外的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148040/116.wav", + "text": "大陸人士不是自由來臺的他們連來臺灣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148040/117.wav", + "text": "都要申請他們自己內部的許可才會來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148040/118.wav", + "text": "不是自由來臺的他可以這樣子跟" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148040/119.wav", + "text": "趙委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148040/120.wav", + "text": "從2011年就開始認識到現在我們難道都沒有一點點警訊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148040/121.wav", + "text": "也可以提醒這些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148040/122.wav", + "text": "不管是行政官員或是立法委員嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148040/123.wav", + "text": "安全局" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148040/124.wav", + "text": "報告委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148040/125.wav", + "text": "我想" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148040/126.wav", + "text": "我們會配合檢調如果需要任何的資訊我們會全力支援" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148040/127.wav", + "text": "如果只是用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148040/128.wav", + "text": "配合我真的不夠滿意今天說實在的全世界" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148040/129.wav", + "text": "對於" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148040/130.wav", + "text": "如何保密防諜不是只防" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148040/131.wav", + "text": "共諜" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148040/132.wav", + "text": "助理國務卿的案件" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148040/133.wav", + "text": "外國在那邊的人員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148040/134.wav", + "text": "對於他們參與一些機敏業務的人員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148040/135.wav", + "text": "也是一個反間諜的作法你們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148040/136.wav", + "text": "一但司法開始偵辦之後個案你們就不方便介入" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148040/137.wav", + "text": "我覺得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148040/138.wav", + "text": "你們在整個體制上面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148040/139.wav", + "text": "你的反情報體制上面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148040/140.wav", + "text": "怎麼會讓一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148040/141.wav", + "text": "國防外交委員會的召委" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148040/142.wav", + "text": "受到這樣的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148040/143.wav", + "text": "接近" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148040/144.wav", + "text": "而沒有給他提出一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148040/145.wav", + "text": "警訊或怎麼樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148040/146.wav", + "text": "這一部分我請調查局跟" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148040/147.wav", + "text": "安全局事後給我一個報告謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148040/148.wav", + "text": "謝謝游毓蘭委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148039/0.wav", + "text": "謝謝召委請薛部長備詢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148039/1.wav", + "text": "有請部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148039/2.wav", + "text": "委員好部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148039/3.wav", + "text": "先問你一下之前你答應的桃療副院長人事案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148039/4.wav", + "text": "現在又過去一段時間了公告了沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148039/5.wav", + "text": "現在那個公文是在一層也就是說從主秘到次長再到我這邊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148039/6.wav", + "text": "到你這裡了沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148039/7.wav", + "text": "到你這邊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148039/8.wav", + "text": "應該是在主秘或者次長那邊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148039/9.wav", + "text": "這個禮拜應該OK" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148039/10.wav", + "text": "會公告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148039/11.wav", + "text": "不是我們簽核過的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148039/12.wav", + "text": "有人選了沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148039/13.wav", + "text": "沒有沒有我們現在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148039/14.wav", + "text": "要要對外徵選" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148039/15.wav", + "text": "所以要公告嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148039/16.wav", + "text": "對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148039/17.wav", + "text": "然後才會徵選" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148039/18.wav", + "text": "對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148039/19.wav", + "text": "這個禮拜會公告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148039/20.wav", + "text": "今天是禮拜四" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148039/21.wav", + "text": "最慢的話就是下個禮拜一" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148039/22.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148039/23.wav", + "text": "就儘快公告啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148039/24.wav", + "text": "不要有缺額在那裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148039/25.wav", + "text": "令人遐想" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148039/26.wav", + "text": "你們現在還想要把桃療合併到部桃嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148039/27.wav", + "text": "這個人心惶惶" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148039/28.wav", + "text": "啦所以趕快公告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148039/29.wav", + "text": "然後讓有才能的人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148039/30.wav", + "text": "有能力的人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148039/31.wav", + "text": "儘快在這個職缺上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148039/32.wav", + "text": "為桃療來做更多事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148039/33.wav", + "text": "\n另外第二個問題就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148039/34.wav", + "text": "據我所知關於這個指定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148039/35.wav", + "text": "菸品健康風險評估審查報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148039/36.wav", + "text": "歷次審查的會議紀錄" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148039/37.wav", + "text": "到現在你們都不願意提供" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148039/38.wav", + "text": "到底是怎麼樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148039/39.wav", + "text": "就是加熱菸" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148039/40.wav", + "text": "風險評估要審查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148039/41.wav", + "text": "嘛你們開審查會已經開好幾次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148039/42.wav", + "text": "對進度我們都有公告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148039/43.wav", + "text": "會議紀錄" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148039/44.wav", + "text": "是國防機密嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148039/45.wav", + "text": "你越不公開大家越說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148039/46.wav", + "text": "因為現在大家想要加熱菸" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148039/47.wav", + "text": "業者當然希望儘快" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148039/48.wav", + "text": "讓他們的風險評估審查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148039/49.wav", + "text": "可以趕快通過趕快進來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148039/50.wav", + "text": "社會上當然也有些疑慮" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148039/51.wav", + "text": "啦其實我在這邊要再強調一次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148039/52.wav", + "text": "本席的立場很簡單" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148039/53.wav", + "text": "我們當時通過了這樣子的法案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148039/54.wav", + "text": "就是準備接受" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148039/55.wav", + "text": "健康風險評估要做完整" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148039/56.wav", + "text": "因為它畢竟是一種新的菸品" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148039/57.wav", + "text": "很多人也在質疑我說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148039/58.wav", + "text": "現在紙菸已經在吸了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148039/59.wav", + "text": "紙菸可能對人體的傷害更大" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148039/60.wav", + "text": "都已經那麼多人在吸" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148039/61.wav", + "text": "你為什麼不趕快讓加熱菸進來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148039/62.wav", + "text": "很多人會這樣質疑" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148039/63.wav", + "text": "但是我要告訴大家一點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148039/64.wav", + "text": "我的意思是這個新的東西" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148039/65.wav", + "text": "─加熱菸用加熱棒" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148039/66.wav", + "text": "它會產生哪一些化學變化" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148039/67.wav", + "text": "會產生哪一些化學物質" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148039/68.wav", + "text": "這個都是一個新的狀態" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148039/69.wav", + "text": "所以對於這個我們當然要更謹慎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148039/70.wav", + "text": "它會不會更糟" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148039/71.wav", + "text": "也不知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148039/72.wav", + "text": "所以要做健康風險評估" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148039/73.wav", + "text": "會不會比紙菸更糟" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148039/74.wav", + "text": "不知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148039/75.wav", + "text": "它用一種新的方法去加熱它" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148039/76.wav", + "text": "嘛紙菸大家知道是用點的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148039/77.wav", + "text": "然後大家都在講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148039/78.wav", + "text": "紙菸有焦油" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148039/79.wav", + "text": "啊因為要燃燒" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148039/80.wav", + "text": "這個我們知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148039/81.wav", + "text": "但是加熱菸這種加熱方法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148039/82.wav", + "text": "到底會不會產生不一樣的化學物質" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148039/83.wav", + "text": "不知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148039/84.wav", + "text": "對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148039/85.wav", + "text": "所以現在我們的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148039/86.wav", + "text": "所以我要特別強調這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148039/87.wav", + "text": "因為它是一個新的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148039/88.wav", + "text": "菸品所以當我們要讓它正式上市" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148039/89.wav", + "text": "將來很多人會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148039/90.wav", + "text": "會使用這個加熱菸品" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148039/91.wav", + "text": "那這個時候我們就更在意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148039/92.wav", + "text": "它的健康風險評估" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148039/93.wav", + "text": "這個名稱雖然大家有��見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148039/94.wav", + "text": "好像通過以後就是健康的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148039/95.wav", + "text": "不是啦它應該就是風險評估" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148039/96.wav", + "text": "對人體到底會造成哪一些不利的風險" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148039/97.wav", + "text": "尤其是不利的風險" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148039/98.wav", + "text": "這個要好好地評估" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148039/99.wav", + "text": "請你提供資料好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148039/100.wav", + "text": "越公開大家就會越信任" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148039/101.wav", + "text": "好我們回去就來檢討這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148039/102.wav", + "text": "看要怎麼樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148039/103.wav", + "text": "我今天另外一個主題就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148039/104.wav", + "text": "中醫推動長照的概況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148039/105.wav", + "text": "就是中醫的醫療或是藥品" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148039/106.wav", + "text": "協助長照這個領域" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148039/107.wav", + "text": "到底我們做了哪一些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148039/108.wav", + "text": "有在這邊嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148039/109.wav", + "text": "有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148039/110.wav", + "text": "因為我有看到你講過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148039/111.wav", + "text": "在接受西醫治療外" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148039/112.wav", + "text": "長照這一些需要照護的人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148039/113.wav", + "text": "另外尋求中醫師" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148039/114.wav", + "text": "酌予做全身調息養生保健等等治療" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148039/115.wav", + "text": "所以你是肯定的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148039/116.wav", + "text": "啦肯認中醫醫療中醫的藥物" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148039/117.wav", + "text": "或是保養品保健品" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148039/118.wav", + "text": "對於長照或是老人照護" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148039/119.wav", + "text": "包括失智失能這些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148039/120.wav", + "text": "會有一些效果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148039/121.wav", + "text": "你要不要再說明一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148039/122.wav", + "text": "這個中醫你" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148039/123.wav", + "text": "你先說明等一下再給司長說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148039/124.wav", + "text": "中醫進入長照體系的部分大概是兩個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148039/125.wav", + "text": "第一個就是對於那些剛剛也有提到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148039/126.wav", + "text": "的社區關懷據點長照C這些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148039/127.wav", + "text": "比較健康的老人所在的這個地方" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148039/128.wav", + "text": "他們聚集的地方" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148039/129.wav", + "text": "由中醫師進到這些據點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148039/130.wav", + "text": "有嗎現在有進入到這個據點嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148039/131.wav", + "text": "以我看到的數據" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148039/132.wav", + "text": "到底有多少中醫機構或是中醫師有進入" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148039/133.wav", + "text": "有數字嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148039/134.wav", + "text": "應該是有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148039/135.wav", + "text": "應該有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148039/136.wav", + "text": "有沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148039/137.wav", + "text": "我先跟委員報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148039/138.wav", + "text": "A據點B據點還是C據點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148039/139.wav", + "text": "自己去經營據點的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148039/140.wav", + "text": "大概有9個有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148039/141.wav", + "text": "9個地方是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148039/142.wav", + "text": "A" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148039/143.wav", + "text": "中醫師進去經營的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148039/144.wav", + "text": "C據點全國有400多個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148039/145.wav", + "text": "耶只有9個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148039/146.wav", + "text": "所以普及性還是不太" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148039/147.wav", + "text": "這個部分的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148039/148.wav", + "text": "從110年1月1日到111年10月31日的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148039/149.wav", + "text": "了這個報告也出來了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148039/150.wav", + "text": "我手上的資料" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148039/151.wav", + "text": "有登錄進入到這個計畫裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148039/152.wav", + "text": "或者是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148039/153.wav", + "text": "包括BC據點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148039/154.wav", + "text": "直接到個案家去做指導的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148039/155.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148039/156.wav", + "text": "請你把這個資料提供給我" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148039/157.wav", + "text": "因為參與率實在太低了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148039/158.wav", + "text": "現在的A據點有712個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148039/159.wav", + "text": "B據點有8001百多個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148039/160.wav", + "text": "C據點有400多個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148039/161.wav", + "text": "參與這些據點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148039/162.wav", + "text": "長照需要照護或身心調養" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148039/163.wav", + "text": "的這些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148039/164.wav", + "text": "老人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148039/165.wav", + "text": "長輩" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148039/166.wav", + "text": "參與率實在太低了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148039/167.wav", + "text": "第一個你把這個資料給我" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148039/168.wav", + "text": "即參與的比例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148039/169.wav", + "text": "到底有多少據點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148039/170.wav", + "text": "有這些中醫師或機構在協助" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148039/171.wav", + "text": "第二" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148039/172.wav", + "text": "把你們將來如何推廣的計畫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148039/173.wav", + "text": "也提供給我" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148039/174.wav", + "text": "我們還是會找中醫全聯會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148039/175.wav", + "text": "第一個目前狀況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148039/176.wav", + "text": "的統計資料給我" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148039/177.wav", + "text": "參與率是多少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148039/178.wav", + "text": "擴大參與的計畫是什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148039/179.wav", + "text": "以及所有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148039/180.wav", + "text": "我們衛環委員會的其他委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148039/181.wav", + "text": "多久時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148039/182.wav", + "text": "個應該很快" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148039/183.wav", + "text": "給你一個禮拜" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148039/184.wav", + "text": "什麼一個月" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148039/185.wav", + "text": "一個月可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148039/186.wav", + "text": "下一次我不會在這裡了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148039/187.wav", + "text": "兩個禮拜" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148039/188.wav", + "text": "兩個禮拜" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148038/0.wav", + "text": "有請部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148038/1.wav", + "text": "部長辛苦了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148038/2.wav", + "text": "召開一個公聽會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148038/3.wav", + "text": "素食之標示" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148038/4.wav", + "text": "因為這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148038/5.wav", + "text": "標示規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148038/6.wav", + "text": "是從9798年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148038/7.wav", + "text": "到102年有修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148038/8.wav", + "text": "不過修正不多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148038/9.wav", + "text": "但是現在是112年就是10" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148038/10.wav", + "text": "在公聽會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148038/11.wav", + "text": "在推動素食" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148038/12.wav", + "text": "其實現在臺灣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148038/13.wav", + "text": "有14%" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148038/14.wav", + "text": "所以滿多人吃素" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148038/15.wav", + "text": "公聽會主要就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148038/16.wav", + "text": "要符合國際" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148038/17.wav", + "text": "或者是在觀光" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148038/18.wav", + "text": "是可以來接軌" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148038/19.wav", + "text": "所以希望" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148038/20.wav", + "text": "在我們的公告裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148038/21.wav", + "text": "能夠有一些修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148038/22.wav", + "text": "其實也滿簡單的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148038/23.wav", + "text": "只要在標示裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148038/24.wav", + "text": "再多一個Vegan" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148038/25.wav", + "text": "標示名稱" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148038/26.wav", + "text": "有含五辛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148038/27.wav", + "text": "或者是不含五辛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148038/28.wav", + "text": "我們如果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148038/29.wav", + "text": "第六符合國際" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148038/30.wav", + "text": "因為國際只有一個Vegan" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148038/31.wav", + "text": "它是含五辛但是不含" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148038/32.wav", + "text": "動物性蛋白" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148038/33.wav", + "text": "希望這個部分能夠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148038/34.wav", + "text": "請衛福部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148038/35.wav", + "text": "公告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148038/36.wav", + "text": "不知道部長可不可以在年底前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148038/37.wav", + "text": "這個我們就" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148038/38.wav", + "text": "儘量來討論一下趕一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148038/39.wav", + "text": "我想這個不是那麼有爭議的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148038/40.wav", + "text": "對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148038/41.wav", + "text": "再來就是上次質詢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148038/42.wav", + "text": "提到醫預" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148038/43.wav", + "text": "預現在又過了兩個禮拜" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148038/44.wav", + "text": "調解的那個指引" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148038/45.wav", + "text": "如果在子法裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148038/46.wav", + "text": "是不是可以在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148038/47.wav", + "text": "調解會運作辦法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148038/48.wav", + "text": "具體的操作流程" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148038/49.wav", + "text": "或者是操作手冊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148038/50.wav", + "text": "在需要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148038/51.wav", + "text": "調解不成在後續評" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148038/52.wav", + "text": "的部分是不是可以有一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148038/53.wav", + "text": "操作的指引" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148038/54.wav", + "text": "報告委員這部分的SOP" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148038/55.wav", + "text": "我們應該都已經處理好了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148038/56.wav", + "text": "是不是可以先" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148038/57.wav", + "text": "請醫事司給本席參閱一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148038/58.wav", + "text": "委員可不可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148038/59.wav", + "text": "法規會通過之後再給你" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148038/60.wav", + "text": "通過的法規" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148038/61.wav", + "text": "我們已經訂好了但是要在我們部裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148038/62.wav", + "text": "的法規會通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148038/63.wav", + "text": "好通過之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148038/64.wav", + "text": "那有訂指引" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148038/65.wav", + "text": "好感謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148038/66.wav", + "text": "謝謝主席" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148037/0.wav", + "text": "謝謝主席我第一個問題要請教各個行政單位如果有牽涉到你就主動回答我" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148037/1.wav", + "text": "我們看到要阻絕境外勢力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148037/2.wav", + "text": "你們的檢舉獎金也高達2,000萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148037/3.wav", + "text": "可是這個廣告上面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148037/4.wav", + "text": "這個部分不管是境內還是境外" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148037/5.wav", + "text": "不是都應該要阻絕嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148037/6.wav", + "text": "為什麼只有阻絕境外勢力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148037/7.wav", + "text": "你的意思是檢舉獎金只給境外" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148037/8.wav", + "text": "的部分如果不是境外就沒有檢舉獎金" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148037/9.wav", + "text": "你現在嚴查賄選跟斷絕賭盤是只有境外而已" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148037/10.wav", + "text": "境內的你就不在乎是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148037/11.wav", + "text": "沒有因為我們這次查察賄選" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148037/12.wav", + "text": "你只要告訴我境內的你管不管就好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148037/13.wav", + "text": "那境內的有沒有這個檢舉獎金不是2," + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148037/14.wav", + "text": "00萬的檢舉獎金是最高不管" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148037/15.wav", + "text": "境內跟境外都有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148037/16.wav", + "text": "因為沒有把每一項都舉出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148037/17.wav", + "text": "所以境內的無所謂是不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148037/18.wav", + "text": "只要有涉及到犯罪我們都" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148037/19.wav", + "text": "當然境內也有很多賄選也有賭盤也有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148037/20.wav", + "text": "大家不會誤會啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148037/21.wav", + "text": "我誤會啦我看的時候就誤會了我想說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148037/22.wav", + "text": "這是什麼狀況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148037/23.wav", + "text": "的部分只有境外不可以境內是可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148037/24.wav", + "text": "賭盤的部分你單純在臉書上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148037/25.wav", + "text": "我們就講全部境內或境外都一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148037/26.wav", + "text": "過往大家也發現" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148037/27.wav", + "text": "每次碰到選舉都有賭盤" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148037/28.wav", + "text": "或檢調單位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148037/29.wav", + "text": "曾經查過的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148037/30.wav", + "text": "除了最近已經找到兩名之外" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148037/31.wav", + "text": "以及查到的案件有多少件" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148037/32.wav", + "text": "賭盤過去我們也都查了很多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148037/33.wav", + "text": "我知道多少件" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148037/34.wav", + "text": "我手邊沒有過去的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148037/35.wav", + "text": "但我有現在的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148037/36.wav", + "text": "沒關係你會後會補充嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148037/37.wav", + "text": "好過去的我們會補充給" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148037/38.wav", + "text": "依法處置的不是只有查到嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148037/39.wav", + "text": "跟後來的結論是不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148037/40.wav", + "text": "都是一樣的還是不一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148037/41.wav", + "text": "我們可以根據個案來分析" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148037/42.wav", + "text": "但到目前為止還沒有是不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148037/43.wav", + "text": "你還沒有評析過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148037/44.wav", + "text": "他會像雨後春筍一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148037/45.wav", + "text": "今天是某甲" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148037/46.wav", + "text": "這個部分也沒有評估過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148037/47.wav", + "text": "賭盤有大盤小盤" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148037/48.wav", + "text": "不管是大盤小盤都有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148037/49.wav", + "text": "委員說要再分析" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148037/50.wav", + "text": "其實我們是有分析後才知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148037/51.wav", + "text": "這個很嚴重" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148037/52.wav", + "text": "這一次的選舉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148037/53.wav", + "text": "也特別把它列為我們的核心工作" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148037/54.wav", + "text": "所以你從過往的經驗中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148037/55.wav", + "text": "哪一些有可能會像雨後春筍般" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148037/56.wav", + "text": "因此你從過往的data" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148037/57.wav", + "text": "所以我才說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148037/58.wav", + "text": "裡面都是俊男美女" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148037/59.wav", + "text": "其實真的是很好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148037/60.wav", + "text": "但問題是第三段文字的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148037/61.wav", + "text": "拜託刪掉一下因為會引發誤解" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148037/62.wav", + "text": "\n另外一個問題要請教" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148037/63.wav", + "text": "第一個我們是說在臉書上面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148037/64.wav", + "text": "但現在不只是臉書還" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148037/65.wav", + "text": "這些部分你對於它們不同的性質" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148037/66.wav", + "text": "我們都有掌握" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148037/67.wav", + "text": "已經有賭盤的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148037/68.wav", + "text": "有包括" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148037/69.wav", + "text": "有包括" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148037/70.wav", + "text": "所以已經含在裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148037/71.wav", + "text": "全國就分了234件" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148037/72.wav", + "text": "都有非常專注在這一方面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148037/73.wav", + "text": "我沒有再進一步瞭解" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148037/74.wav", + "text": "這234件是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148037/75.wav", + "text": "更多的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148037/76.wav", + "text": "或是他的賭盤其實就在臺灣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148037/77.wav", + "text": "只是他的IP是在境外" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148037/78.wav", + "text": "你現在有看到這樣的情形嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148037/79.wav", + "text": "我們有掌握" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148037/80.wav", + "text": "你看到我的眼睛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148037/81.wav", + "text": "有沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148037/82.wav", + "text": "也有也許他的帳號是放在國外" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148037/83.wav", + "text": "我們也有這種" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148037/84.wav", + "text": "現在到目前為止也有掌握" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148037/85.wav", + "text": "是不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148037/86.wav", + "text": "\n我再請教一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148037/87.wav", + "text": "是資金的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148037/88.wav", + "text": "因為我們知道現在虛擬貨幣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148037/89.wav", + "text": "為什麼上次我會問金管會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148037/90.wav", + "text": "他跟法務部有沒有聯繫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148037/91.wav", + "text": "金管會主委當時是跟我說沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148037/92.wav", + "text": "我聽到時我都嚇壞了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148037/93.wav", + "text": "我後來澄清說是有對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148037/94.wav", + "text": "你說有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148037/95.wav", + "text": "但他說沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148037/96.wav", + "text": "但這不是我今天要問的重點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148037/97.wav", + "text": "我今天要問的重點是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148037/98.wav", + "text": "其實是透過虛擬的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148037/99.wav", + "text": "方式因為虛擬的部分是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148037/100.wav", + "text": "是沒有識別性的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148037/101.wav", + "text": "它是去識別性的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148037/102.wav", + "text": "的確是有這樣的犯罪行為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148037/103.wav", + "text": "並且將來是能夠成案的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148037/104.wav", + "text": "這一部分高檢署跟調查局" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148037/105.wav", + "text": "到目前為止" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148037/106.wav", + "text": "有沒有透過虛擬貨幣的方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148037/107.wav", + "text": "即賭注賭金是用虛擬貨幣下的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148037/108.wav", + "text": "跟委員報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148037/109.wav", + "text": "有關於這個賭金的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148037/110.wav", + "text": "這個我們會密切" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148037/111.wav", + "text": "有沒有虛擬貨幣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148037/112.wav", + "text": "不用密切啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148037/113.wav", + "text": "你本來就應該密切" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148037/114.wav", + "text": "有虛擬貨幣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148037/115.wav", + "text": "除此之外" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148037/116.wav", + "text": "除了虛擬貨幣以外" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148037/117.wav", + "text": "還有用購買遊戲點數的方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148037/118.wav", + "text": "是所以你現在先回答我" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148037/119.wav", + "text": "你要怎麼鎖定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148037/120.wav", + "text": "因為他去識別性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148037/121.wav", + "text": "你現在要怎麼鎖定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148037/122.wav", + "text": "我們有幣流的追蹤軟體" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148037/123.wav", + "text": "的虛擬貨幣到交易所的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148037/124.wav", + "text": "我們可以到交易所去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148037/125.wav", + "text": "透過我們的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148037/126.wav", + "text": "還有境外交易平臺" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148037/127.wav", + "text": "現在金管會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148037/128.wav", + "text": "只有管國內註冊的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148037/129.wav", + "text": "這個我們上次問過金管會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148037/130.wav", + "text": "金管會沒有做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148037/131.wav", + "text": "對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148037/132.wav", + "text": "金管會沒有做的東西" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148037/133.wav", + "text": "如果今天調查局" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148037/134.wav", + "text": "可以做得到的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148037/135.wav", + "text": "沒有跟金管會分享" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148037/136.wav", + "text": "因為我們現在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148037/137.wav", + "text": "是其實是非常多的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148037/138.wav", + "text": "對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148037/139.wav", + "text": "跟委員報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148037/140.wav", + "text": "因為金管會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148037/141.wav", + "text": "是從金融監理的角度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148037/142.wav", + "text": "不是不是不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148037/143.wav", + "text": "它從洗錢防" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148037/144.wav", + "text": "金管會說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148037/145.wav", + "text": "虛擬貨幣的洗錢部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148037/146.wav", + "text": "那你怎麼不跟它分享" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148037/147.wav", + "text": "我們調查局" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148037/148.wav", + "text": "情資交流" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148037/149.wav", + "text": "這樣的一個方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148037/150.wav", + "text": "透過國外的執法單位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148037/151.wav", + "text": "來進行合作" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148037/152.wav", + "text": "不是你沒回答我問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148037/153.wav", + "text": "沒關係你會後給我資料" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148037/154.wav", + "text": "但我的重點是在這裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148037/155.wav", + "text": "我的重點拜託大家聽一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148037/156.wav", + "text": "他現在人是在臺灣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148037/157.wav", + "text": "他的IP是在境外" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148037/158.wav", + "text": "���們看到以前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148037/159.wav", + "text": "在處理別的案子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148037/160.wav", + "text": "時包括我的恐嚇案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148037/161.wav", + "text": "我被恐嚇的案子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148037/162.wav", + "text": "因為他是境外的IP" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148037/163.wav", + "text": "所以你" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148037/164.wav", + "text": "你們查無不法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148037/165.wav", + "text": "然後就結案了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148037/166.wav", + "text": "對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148037/167.wav", + "text": "關於你現在這個案子他" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148037/168.wav", + "text": "然後他是境外的IP" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148037/169.wav", + "text": "你也是說查無不法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148037/170.wav", + "text": "因為他是境外的IP" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148037/171.wav", + "text": "還是怎麼樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148037/172.wav", + "text": "不會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148037/173.wav", + "text": "還是說你要看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148037/174.wav", + "text": "他想要開的賭盤" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148037/175.wav", + "text": "他想要選的是誰" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148037/176.wav", + "text": "然後你才會做這動作" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148037/177.wav", + "text": "跟委員報" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148037/178.wav", + "text": "告關於虛擬貨幣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148037/179.wav", + "text": "我們除了有相關的軟體" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148037/180.wav", + "text": "可以追蹤之外" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148037/181.wav", + "text": "另外就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148037/182.wav", + "text": "他如果要變現的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148037/183.wav", + "text": "他會到交易所去變現" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148037/184.wav", + "text": "他只要一旦要變現的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148037/185.wav", + "text": "不需要啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148037/186.wav", + "text": "他可以透過個別的幣商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148037/187.wav", + "text": "再轉過去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148037/188.wav", + "text": "他變現不需要自己變現" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148037/189.wav", + "text": "沒有那麼笨的人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148037/190.wav", + "text": "你把犯罪行為人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148037/191.wav", + "text": "想得太單純了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148037/192.wav", + "text": "他怎麼會把這個資料" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148037/193.wav", + "text": "他去變現" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148037/194.wav", + "text": "他就算是變現" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148037/195.wav", + "text": "你會看到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148037/196.wav", + "text": "是透過人頭的方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148037/197.wav", + "text": "一個人去一點點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148037/198.wav", + "text": "一點點出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148037/199.wav", + "text": "第一個他不會自己" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148037/200.wav", + "text": "去他一定是轉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148037/201.wav", + "text": "對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148037/202.wav", + "text": "你現在對於虛擬貨幣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148037/203.wav", + "text": "是完全沒有控管" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148037/204.wav", + "text": "你會不會看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148037/205.wav", + "text": "即候選人是誰" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148037/206.wav", + "text": "然後你才決定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148037/207.wav", + "text": "說你要結案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148037/208.wav", + "text": "還是不要結案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148037/209.wav", + "text": "因為我看到恐嚇罪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148037/210.wav", + "text": "我是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148037/211.wav", + "text": "被結案結掉的不是嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148037/212.wav", + "text": "部長那個資料" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148037/213.wav", + "text": "我到現在為止沒拿到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148037/214.wav", + "text": "他說三天之內會給" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148037/215.wav", + "text": "但他說你還沒有簽核" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148037/216.wav", + "text": "所以資料我還沒有拿到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148037/217.wav", + "text": "但那個是小事" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148037/218.wav", + "text": "現在比較重要的事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148037/219.wav", + "text": "是說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148037/220.wav", + "text": "你會不會因為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148037/221.wav", + "text": "他是境外IP" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148037/222.wav", + "text": "你就" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148037/223.wav", + "text": "不管他" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148037/224.wav", + "text": "尤其是當他的候選人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148037/225.wav", + "text": "是特定的候選人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148037/226.wav", + "text": "你不喜歡的候選人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148037/227.wav", + "text": "所以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148037/228.wav", + "text": "你就不管他" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148037/229.wav", + "text": "你就用是境外IP" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148037/230.wav", + "text": "把他結案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148037/231.wav", + "text": "但如果說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148037/232.wav", + "text": "這個候選人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148037/233.wav", + "text": "是你喜歡的候選人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148037/234.wav", + "text": "你要偵辦到底" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148037/235.wav", + "text": "就不結案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148037/236.wav", + "text": "有沒有這樣的情形" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148037/237.wav", + "text": "跟委員報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148037/238.wav", + "text": "可以溯源追查的可能" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148037/239.wav", + "text": "你的標準要一致" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148037/240.wav", + "text": "嘛你如果用境外IP" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148037/241.wav", + "text": "全部結案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148037/242.wav", + "text": "就所有人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148037/243.wav", + "text": "都是用境外IP結案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148037/244.wav", + "text": "如果有人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148037/245.wav", + "text": "是境外IP" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148037/246.wav", + "text": "你不結案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148037/247.wav", + "text": "應該很好回答" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148037/248.wav", + "text": "跟委員報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148037/249.wav", + "text": "我們其實是要看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148037/250.wav", + "text": "個案來判定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148037/251.wav", + "text": "因為我們對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148037/252.wav", + "text": "所有能夠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148037/253.wav", + "text": "溯源的可能性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148037/254.wav", + "text": "我們一定會窮盡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148037/255.wav", + "text": "可是窮盡沒有用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148037/256.wav", + "text": "啊你要有效才有用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148037/257.wav", + "text": "啊窮盡有什麼用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148037/258.wav", + "text": "啊如果你方法不對的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148037/259.wav", + "text": "窮盡也管不了用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148037/260.wav", + "text": "啊但我要提醒的是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148037/261.wav", + "text": "檢調人員的辛苦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148037/262.wav", + "text": "其實我是知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148037/263.wav", + "text": "的因為我常常聽到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148037/264.wav", + "text": "他們的反映" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148037/265.wav", + "text": "所以上次對於" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148037/266.wav", + "text": "詐騙案的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148037/267.wav", + "text": "為什麼沒有拿到錢那個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148037/268.wav", + "text": "拿了14億13億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148037/269.wav", + "text": "拿到錢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148037/270.wav", + "text": "後來總算有了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148037/271.wav", + "text": "但問題現在來了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148037/272.wav", + "text": "原來我們增加" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148037/273.wav", + "text": "檢察官助理的目的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148037/274.wav", + "text": "是為了解決" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148037/275.wav", + "text": "詐騙的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148037/276.wav", + "text": "這個人力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148037/277.wav", + "text": "到底從哪裡來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148037/278.wav", + "text": "的百分比" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148037/279.wav", + "text": "現在人力的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148037/280.wav", + "text": "是怎麼樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148037/281.wav", + "text": "謝謝委員關心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148037/282.wav", + "text": "當初爭取檢察官助理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148037/283.wav", + "text": "就是為了打詐" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148037/284.wav", + "text": "但是每一次遇到選舉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148037/285.wav", + "text": "檢察官都要投入" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148037/286.wav", + "text": "我們選舉查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148037/287.wav", + "text": "對所以打詐" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148037/288.wav", + "text": "不會影響" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148037/289.wav", + "text": "那你人力哪裡來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148037/290.wav", + "text": "辛苦一點吧" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148037/291.wav", + "text": "吧不然選舉查察" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148037/292.wav", + "text": "也是眼前重要的工作" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148037/293.wav", + "text": "所以你不告訴我百分比" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148037/294.wav", + "text": "哪一個百分比" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148037/295.wav", + "text": "跟查賄的百分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148037/296.wav", + "text": "每一個地檢署" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148037/297.wav", + "text": "它會安排做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148037/298.wav", + "text": "會後可以給還是不行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148037/299.wav", + "text": "不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148037/300.wav", + "text": "有專組的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148037/301.wav", + "text": "沒關係" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148037/302.wav", + "text": "對可以啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148037/303.wav", + "text": "我只要知道比例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148037/304.wav", + "text": "我不需要知道誰是誰" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148037/305.wav", + "text": "比例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148037/306.wav", + "text": "對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148037/307.wav", + "text": "我來想辦法看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148037/308.wav", + "text": "到底人力如何分配" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148037/309.wav", + "text": "對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148037/310.wav", + "text": "在回答李德維委員的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148037/311.wav", + "text": "其實憑良心講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148037/312.wav", + "text": "我很有意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148037/313.wav", + "text": "啦因為趙天麟的案子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148037/314.wav", + "text": "他是今年爆出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148037/315.wav", + "text": "他自己不是講說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148037/316.wav", + "text": "已經10年了嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148037/317.wav", + "text": "以前我們在質詢時問" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148037/318.wav", + "text": "問國安局跟調查局的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148037/319.wav", + "text": "職掌怎麼分的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148037/320.wav", + "text": "國安局說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148037/321.wav", + "text": "境外的都歸它" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148037/322.wav", + "text": "國內的事是調查局的事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148037/323.wav", + "text": "境外都歸你" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148037/324.wav", + "text": "這麼長的期間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148037/325.wav", + "text": "國安局不知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148037/326.wav", + "text": "對於合法申請入臺的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148037/327.wav", + "text": "我沒有問你" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148037/328.wav", + "text": "合法申請入臺" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148037/329.wav", + "text": "入臺不是重點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148037/330.wav", + "text": "重點是有沒有牽涉到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148037/331.wav", + "text": "洩漏國家機密" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148037/332.wav", + "text": "對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148037/333.wav", + "text": "現在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148037/334.wav", + "text": "這已經是10年的事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148037/335.wav", + "text": "現在才發生的事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148037/336.wav", + "text": "10年了國安局都不知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148037/337.wav", + "text": "然後每次在問" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148037/338.wav", + "text": "你跟調查局之間的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148037/339.wav", + "text": "跟你都一點關係都沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148037/340.wav", + "text": "你只有管境外的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148037/341.wav", + "text": "我就請問你" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148037/342.wav", + "text": "這個10年的事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148037/343.wav", + "text": "老百姓可以放心嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148037/344.wav", + "text": "這有沒有失職的問題啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148037/345.wav", + "text": "報告委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148037/346.wav", + "text": "這一個案子現在已經" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148037/347.wav", + "text": "有可能" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148037/348.wav", + "text": "不是現在的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148037/349.wav", + "text": "我問你的是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148037/350.wav", + "text": "你10年都不能夠發現" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148037/351.wav", + "text": "這個事情就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148037/352.wav", + "text": "到底你現在鎖定的是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148037/353.wav", + "text": "你要把他抹紅的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148037/354.wav", + "text": "你就鎖定他" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148037/355.wav", + "text": "你是全面的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148037/356.wav", + "text": "你想想看這種事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148037/357.wav", + "text": "10年了你都發現不了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148037/358.wav", + "text": "那你國安局" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148037/359.wav", + "text": "不是失職是幹嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148037/360.wav", + "text": "以前你可以塞給調查局" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148037/361.wav", + "text": "你說這個是境內的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148037/362.wav", + "text": "這麼嚴重的情況之下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148037/363.wav", + "text": "你國安局不知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148037/364.wav", + "text": "你連蛛絲馬跡都不知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148037/365.wav", + "text": "自己把照片外流" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148037/366.wav", + "text": "你才知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148037/367.wav", + "text": "那你國安局" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148037/368.wav", + "text": "不是形同虛設嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148037/369.wav", + "text": "我們還有國家安全嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148037/370.wav", + "text": "你不是講說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148037/371.wav", + "text": "你蒐集情資" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148037/372.wav", + "text": "你剛才還大言不慚的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148037/373.wav", + "text": "都是你國安局做的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148037/374.wav", + "text": "這10年的行為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148037/375.wav", + "text": "又是國防外交委員會的委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148037/376.wav", + "text": "這事情你不知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148037/377.wav", + "text": "還是因為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148037/378.wav", + "text": "他是國防外交委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148037/379.wav", + "text": "是在國防外交嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148037/380.wav", + "text": "對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148037/381.wav", + "text": "你們主要備詢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148037/382.wav", + "text": "是在國防外交" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148037/383.wav", + "text": "所以你是因為知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148037/384.wav", + "text": "他是國防外交委員會的委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148037/385.wav", + "text": "所以你不敢動" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148037/386.wav", + "text": "啊10年的東西你不知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148037/387.wav", + "text": "絕對沒有因為是特定的人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148037/388.wav", + "text": "我們就不會去蒐集資料" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148037/389.wav", + "text": "進來的這一段時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148037/390.wav", + "text": "沒有違常異常現象" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148037/391.wav", + "text": "沒有得到情資" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148037/392.wav", + "text": "也沒有提" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148037/393.wav", + "text": "他的背景他的身分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148037/394.wav", + "text": "有沒有受過特殊的訓練" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148037/395.wav", + "text": "他為什麼接觸" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148037/396.wav", + "text": "這些你通通都不查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148037/397.wav", + "text": "這個我們是在瞭解中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148037/398.wav", + "text": "你現在才在瞭解" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148037/399.wav", + "text": "所以簡單來說所有的事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148037/400.wav", + "text": "是老百姓幫你辦案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148037/401.wav", + "text": "老百姓把資訊出來給你" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148037/402.wav", + "text": "就好了嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148037/403.wav", + "text": "要給我就是你10年之內" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148037/404.wav", + "text": "做了什麼事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148037/405.wav", + "text": "查了什麼事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148037/406.wav", + "text": "好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148037/407.wav", + "text": "接下來請" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148037/408.wav", + "text": "游毓蘭委員發言" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148036/0.wav", + "text": "有請薛部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148036/1.wav", + "text": "會有隨收隨付的這些問題甚至有一些先進國家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148036/2.wav", + "text": "你講的所有理由健保也都是因為健保現在就是這種保險制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148036/3.wav", + "text": "部長你應該知道現在55歲以上人口就有七百零多萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148036/4.wav", + "text": "在20年後臺灣會變成大概有2,100萬人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148036/5.wav", + "text": "65歲以上也會有700萬人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148036/6.wav", + "text": "所以大概在20年後大家要去想像這個數字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148036/7.wav", + "text": "就是每3個臺灣人就有1個是65歲以上的長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148036/8.wav", + "text": "我覺得我們應該在制度上要想清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148036/9.wav", + "text": "因為這件事到底要用稅賦制或保險制我覺得這是可以論辯" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148036/10.wav", + "text": "這是賴副總統的這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148036/11.wav", + "text": "到前8個月只有205億進來而且年增率是負的4.4%" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148036/12.wav", + "text": "簡單講就是我們的財源基礎稅基是減少的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148036/13.wav", + "text": "啦因為我們也知道這些錢而且說實話房地合一稅還不保險為什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148036/14.wav", + "text": "因為國土署也希望這些錢應該不要在長照" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148036/15.wav", + "text": "的因為到底這個稅基還存在嗎稅的來源還那麼多嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148036/16.wav", + "text": "就是到底要不要走向保險的制度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148036/17.wav", + "text": "我覺得這個是真的因為我的前提還是在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148036/18.wav", + "text": "我們未來就有這麼多的長者這件事不好好處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148036/19.wav", + "text": "真的是危險你不能說保險有黑洞" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148036/20.wav", + "text": "如果真的走不下去那沒問題但稅賦制可以走得好嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148036/21.wav", + "text": "這個部分部長能不能回答一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148036/22.wav", + "text": "跟委員報告事實上這個事情的確如委員講的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148036/23.wav", + "text": "如果我們再拉到10年20年之後的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148036/24.wav", + "text": "因為的確我們人口老化的速度跟比例實在是太快了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148036/25.wav", + "text": "所以當然我們要去設那個時間點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148036/26.wav", + "text": "也許是10年或15年之後我們有一個目標" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148036/27.wav", + "text": "就是它可能會是一個hybrid就是一個混合制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148036/28.wav", + "text": "但是不必現在就開始做規劃" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148036/29.wav", + "text": "因為現在做規劃我們還沒有辦法去想像到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148036/30.wav", + "text": "那時候碰到的問題是什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148036/31.wav", + "text": "部長的這個建議我覺得也滿好的我很坦白說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148036/32.wav", + "text": "這樣我反而要請教部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148036/33.wav", + "text": "部裡面現在真的有規劃嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148036/34.wav", + "text": "或者你們曾經有做這個研議嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148036/35.wav", + "text": "因為我們現制的調整還在進行當中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148036/36.wav", + "text": "包括剛剛前一位委員在質詢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148036/37.wav", + "text": "嘛所以這個是我們現階段要去處理的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148036/38.wav", + "text": "要讓他的廣度更廣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148036/39.wav", + "text": "部長這樣好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148036/40.wav", + "text": "最後具體就是您能不能再請部裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148036/41.wav", + "text": "如果真的要進入部長所講hybrid的這種狀況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148036/42.wav", + "text": "推估大概要什麼時候可能要去做這件事" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148036/43.wav", + "text": "這個能不能給我們一個報告也同時給委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148036/44.wav", + "text": "我想這個部分現在要出報告大概有點困難" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148036/45.wav", + "text": "我知道當然" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148036/46.wav", + "text": "我會交代我們國家衛生研究院去做這件事" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148036/47.wav", + "text": "是做一個專案研究好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148036/48.wav", + "text": "對做一個專案研究" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148036/49.wav", + "text": "未來假設10年15年20年以後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148036/50.wav", + "text": "看看要用什麼樣的制度是比較可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148036/51.wav", + "text": "因為這個問題終極是必須處理的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148036/52.wav", + "text": "我覺得保險跟稅賦制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148036/53.wav", + "text": "當然我覺得它混合一陣子也可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148036/54.wav", + "text": "\n最後我還有一個要求" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148036/55.wav", + "text": "就是請部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148036/56.wav", + "text": "但是現在比如以房地合一稅這件事" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148036/57.wav", + "text": "其實國土署這邊也一直希望" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148036/58.wav", + "text": "把房地合一稅多拿回去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148036/59.wav", + "text": "挹注社宅的住宅政策" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148036/60.wav", + "text": "所以這個也要因應一下好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148036/61.wav", + "text": "因為今天還有一個財政部來的報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148036/62.wav", + "text": "財源的來源是你們要負責搞定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148036/63.wav", + "text": "我們希望是拿過來我們專款專用啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148036/64.wav", + "text": "所以我覺得你們還是要想清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148036/65.wav", + "text": "當這個要是損失了未來稅賦的部分要怎麼辦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148036/66.wav", + "text": "這個也要因應嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148036/67.wav", + "text": "是有關��個因應結果能不能" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148036/68.wav", + "text": "在一個月給我們一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148036/69.wav", + "text": "你們認為要怎麼做好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148036/70.wav", + "text": "也給委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148036/71.wav", + "text": "謝謝部長謝謝主席" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148035/0.wav", + "text": "主席本席想邀請部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148035/1.wav", + "text": "有請薛部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148035/2.wav", + "text": "委員好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148035/3.wav", + "text": "部長因應人口老化的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148035/4.wav", + "text": "政府推出了長照政策" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148035/5.wav", + "text": "其中最廣泛的就是長照2.0" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148035/6.wav", + "text": "也因為這樣的使用率" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148035/7.wav", + "text": "是一年一年上升" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148035/8.wav", + "text": "而且我們的老年人口是一直在提升" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148035/9.wav", + "text": "那在這樣的情況之下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148035/10.wav", + "text": "我們可以看到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148035/11.wav", + "text": "政府的財政壓力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148035/12.wav", + "text": "換句話說會越來越龐大" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148035/13.wav", + "text": "的實際支出就有563億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148035/14.wav", + "text": "的穩定性是不佳" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148035/15.wav", + "text": "因為主要的基金來源" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148035/16.wav", + "text": "是靠政府的稅收" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148035/17.wav", + "text": "最容易受到景氣的影響" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148035/18.wav", + "text": "那在這樣的情況之下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148035/19.wav", + "text": "如果財政出現缺口" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148035/20.wav", + "text": "也不能不照顧" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148035/21.wav", + "text": "你就是用公務預算來撥補之" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148035/22.wav", + "text": "但是這個撥補可能會排擠到其他的預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148035/23.wav", + "text": "而且惡化了整個政府的財政" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148035/24.wav", + "text": "因為你的稅收來源" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148035/25.wav", + "text": "包括房地合一稅" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148035/26.wav", + "text": "遺產稅還有贈與稅" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148035/27.wav", + "text": "菸稅" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148035/28.wav", + "text": "大概你的稅收是從這邊來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148035/29.wav", + "text": "所以在這樣的情況之下請教部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148035/30.wav", + "text": "你用稅收的方式來因應" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148035/31.wav", + "text": "所以本席想要請教" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148035/32.wav", + "text": "你們是不是會研議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148035/33.wav", + "text": "稅收制轉向長照的保險制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148035/34.wav", + "text": "那要怎麼樣去健全" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148035/35.wav", + "text": "請做說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148035/36.wav", + "text": "跟委員報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148035/37.wav", + "text": "稅收制是穩定的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148035/38.wav", + "text": "我們現在稅收制的精神是這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148035/39.wav", + "text": "我打算下一個年度要花多少錢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148035/40.wav", + "text": "我就去看有多少錢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148035/41.wav", + "text": "如果不夠的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148035/42.wav", + "text": "我們就還要再" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148035/43.wav", + "text": "公務預算撥補" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148035/44.wav", + "text": "公務預算撥補進來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148035/45.wav", + "text": "就是這個樣子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148035/46.wav", + "text": "那當然委員一定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148035/47.wav", + "text": "那公務預算撥補" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148035/48.wav", + "text": "跟委員報告其實是這個樣子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148035/49.wav", + "text": "我們這個是要跟保險制去做比較" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148035/50.wav", + "text": "保險制看起來就是說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148035/51.wav", + "text": "因為你是保費的收入" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148035/52.wav", + "text": "所以是OK" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148035/53.wav", + "text": "就是好像比較穩定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148035/54.wav", + "text": "就有那些錢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148035/55.wav", + "text": "但是人口持續老化下去的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148035/56.wav", + "text": "它還是會有一天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148035/57.wav", + "text": "原來計收的保費會不足計" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148035/58.wav", + "text": "計收保費不足的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148035/59.wav", + "text": "唯有一條路就是漲保費" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148035/60.wav", + "text": "費率要提升" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148035/61.wav", + "text": "漲保費費率要提升的困難度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148035/62.wav", + "text": "遠比找公務預算再來補貼要難多了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148035/63.wav", + "text": "從我們健保的經驗你就可以看得出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148035/64.wav", + "text": "但是部長你現在討論到這個問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148035/65.wav", + "text": "是因為在公務預算方面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148035/66.wav", + "text": "是非常健全" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148035/67.wav", + "text": "而且蓬勃發展" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148035/68.wav", + "text": "可是你看到目前全世界的狀態" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148035/69.wav", + "text": "我覺得是太樂觀的一個說法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148035/70.wav", + "text": "你去研擬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148035/71.wav", + "text": "AB案等等怎麼樣的方案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148035/72.wav", + "text": "我們的目的就是要真正去照顧" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148035/73.wav", + "text": "你把方案給本席" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148035/74.wav", + "text": "我們會各種方案去提出" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148035/75.wav", + "text": "對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148035/76.wav", + "text": "接下來本席要請教" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148035/77.wav", + "text": "2017年長照2.0服務計畫開辦之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148035/78.wav", + "text": "到了2022年12月底" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148035/79.wav", + "text": "服務的人數大概44萬381人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148035/80.wav", + "text": "需求人數是82千多人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148035/81.wav", + "text": "等於是占了53%" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148035/82.wav", + "text": "其中87%的使用者是65歲以上的長者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148035/83.wav", + "text": "而且是以女性居多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148035/84.wav", + "text": "這樣的數據顯示我們可以看出" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148035/85.wav", + "text": "長照2.0服務��用者的失能程度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148035/86.wav", + "text": "換句話說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148035/87.wav", + "text": "約有一半的長照需求度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148035/88.wav", + "text": "不需要用到長照2.0的情況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148035/89.wav", + "text": "所以本席要請教" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148035/90.wav", + "text": "這五成需求者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148035/91.wav", + "text": "這樣解讀是正確的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148035/92.wav", + "text": "那他的原因是什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148035/93.wav", + "text": "本席不願意相信" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148035/94.wav", + "text": "這五成不需要長照的服務" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148035/95.wav", + "text": "到底原因是什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148035/96.wav", + "text": "那你的2.0十年計畫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148035/97.wav", + "text": "即將在2026年就要結束" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148035/98.wav", + "text": "未來我們要怎麼樣精進來照顧" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148035/99.wav", + "text": "請做說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148035/100.wav", + "text": "需求人數這個沒有問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148035/101.wav", + "text": "對但是那個服務的人數" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148035/102.wav", + "text": "指的是只有用我們的給支付制度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148035/103.wav", + "text": "去做的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148035/104.wav", + "text": "對呀所以剛才我的第一個問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148035/105.wav", + "text": "沒有但是給支付制度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148035/106.wav", + "text": "以外也是已經" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148035/107.wav", + "text": "對呀但本席跟你討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148035/108.wav", + "text": "不可能另外那五成不需要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148035/109.wav", + "text": "包括" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148035/110.wav", + "text": "你說多少錢就服務多少人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148035/111.wav", + "text": "這樣不對嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148035/112.wav", + "text": "應該是需要服務的有多少人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148035/113.wav", + "text": "你必須要找出那個財源嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148035/114.wav", + "text": "對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148035/115.wav", + "text": "在機構裡面的住民" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148035/116.wav", + "text": "其實也用到長照服務" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148035/117.wav", + "text": "只不過不是在給支付制度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148035/118.wav", + "text": "裡面的服務" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148035/119.wav", + "text": "所以在計算的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148035/120.wav", + "text": "那一些已經有在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148035/121.wav", + "text": "我們整個大的計畫裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148035/122.wav", + "text": "去cover到了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148035/123.wav", + "text": "包括外籍看護都有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148035/124.wav", + "text": "所以剛剛本席也跟你說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148035/125.wav", + "text": "如果以這個數字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148035/126.wav", + "text": "五成用不到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148035/127.wav", + "text": "他不是不要用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148035/128.wav", + "text": "不是不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148035/129.wav", + "text": "他有用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148035/130.wav", + "text": "他用大計畫裡面去用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148035/131.wav", + "text": "已經用了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148035/132.wav", + "text": "對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148035/133.wav", + "text": "他用大計畫裡面去用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148035/134.wav", + "text": "但是在委員這邊沒有算進去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148035/135.wav", + "text": "就是你那個44萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148035/136.wav", + "text": "你說明的是五成裡頭" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148035/137.wav", + "text": "有幾成是在大計畫裡頭" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148035/138.wav", + "text": "目前其實算起來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148035/139.wav", + "text": "把那些通通" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148035/140.wav", + "text": "有11萬6,000人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148035/141.wav", + "text": "是在你的44萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148035/142.wav", + "text": "那等於才百分之六十幾" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148035/143.wav", + "text": "對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148035/144.wav", + "text": "衰弱跟失智的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148035/145.wav", + "text": "最後加起來的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148035/146.wav", + "text": "部長你去把那個表格做出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148035/147.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148035/148.wav", + "text": "這邊藏一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148035/149.wav", + "text": "你讓人民" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148035/150.wav", + "text": "並不是那麼清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148035/151.wav", + "text": "我們要找出真正原因" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148035/152.wav", + "text": "到底到目前為止" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148035/153.wav", + "text": "而沒有得到照顧的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148035/154.wav", + "text": "人到底有多少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148035/155.wav", + "text": "我要找的目的是這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148035/156.wav", + "text": "所以我用這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148035/157.wav", + "text": "到底在這裡有幾%" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148035/158.wav", + "text": "到底在那裡有幾%" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148035/159.wav", + "text": "好嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148035/160.wav", + "text": "目前沒有受到照顧的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148035/161.wav", + "text": "大概有23%" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148035/162.wav", + "text": "大概23%" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148035/163.wav", + "text": "對啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148035/164.wav", + "text": "你這樣坦白說就對了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148035/165.wav", + "text": "所以我說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148035/166.wav", + "text": "這23%不是不需要照顧" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148035/167.wav", + "text": "而是沒有照顧到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148035/168.wav", + "text": "第一個問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148035/169.wav", + "text": "怎麼樣能夠穩定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148035/170.wav", + "text": "第二個議題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148035/171.wav", + "text": "請你把統表做出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148035/172.wav", + "text": "你藏的到底在哪裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148035/173.wav", + "text": "剩餘的23%" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148035/174.wav", + "text": "是不是真的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148035/175.wav", + "text": "不知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148035/176.wav", + "text": "所以要拜託你" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148035/177.wav", + "text": "將詳細書面資料給本席" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148035/178.wav", + "text": "因為立足點的公平" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148035/179.wav", + "text": "是民主國家裡頭" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148035/180.wav", + "text": "最根本的人民信賴保護原則" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148035/181.wav", + "text": "得不到照顧" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148035/182.wav", + "text": "我們一起加油好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148035/183.wav", + "text": "謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148035/184.wav", + "text": "謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148035/185.wav", + "text": "\n有請張其祿委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148034/0.wav", + "text": "富士康被查稅算不算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148034/1.wav", + "text": "依照法務部的定義算不算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148034/2.wav", + "text": "第二他查我們的台商富士康" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148034/3.wav", + "text": "在大陸的稅算不算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148034/4.wav", + "text": "查稅不是法務部主管的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148034/5.wav", + "text": "或是對候選人的影響等等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148034/6.wav", + "text": "所以不敢說算也不敢說不算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148034/7.wav", + "text": "這還要深入瞭解" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148034/8.wav", + "text": "還要深入瞭解" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148034/9.wav", + "text": "連署總統副總統候選人的對價關係" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148034/10.wav", + "text": "請問這個東西有沒有牽扯到干預選舉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148034/11.wav", + "text": "這不算干預" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148034/12.wav", + "text": "用金錢或財務的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148034/13.wav", + "text": "那是刑事責任" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148034/14.wav", + "text": "我們查察選舉的單位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148034/15.wav", + "text": "會有一些結論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148034/16.wav", + "text": "因為現在已經在媒體看到一些案例的出現" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148034/17.wav", + "text": "預計大概調查到什麼時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148034/18.wav", + "text": "依地檢署目前的瞭解" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148034/19.wav", + "text": "有幾個地檢署已經有案子在偵辦中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148034/20.wav", + "text": "甚至也有涉嫌人收押禁見當中是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148034/21.wav", + "text": "所以大概什麼時候會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148034/22.wav", + "text": "知道起訴或不起訴" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148034/23.wav", + "text": "就看個案由承辦檢察官來認定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148034/24.wav", + "text": "該起訴就起訴" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148034/25.wav", + "text": "好瞭解謝謝部長\n接著" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148034/26.wav", + "text": "局長日前有一個高雄的里長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148034/27.wav", + "text": "天津市最大的民營醫院所主辦的兩岸基層社區交流" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148034/28.wav", + "text": "費用可以報銷" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148034/29.wav", + "text": "假如民眾參加這種活動的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148034/30.wav", + "text": "請問會有法律上的責任嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148034/31.wav", + "text": "我們會瞭解這跟選舉是否有關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148034/32.wav", + "text": "如果屬於跟選舉有關的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148034/33.wav", + "text": "而且涉及到招待旅遊或餐會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148034/34.wav", + "text": "都有可能涉及賄選" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148034/35.wav", + "text": "假如跟選舉無關就比較沒有問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148034/36.wav", + "text": "若跟選舉無關我們就瞭解一下它的目的是��麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148034/37.wav", + "text": "有沒有提出任何跟競選有關或者鼓勵" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148034/38.wav", + "text": "當時的情資是哪個單位提出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148034/39.wav", + "text": "的這樣的偵辦是不是也要意圖影響選舉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148034/40.wav", + "text": "王立強跨海爆料" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148034/41.wav", + "text": "以陸海空戰的方式來介入相關的選舉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148034/42.wav", + "text": "向心也被起訴" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148034/43.wav", + "text": "限制出境的處分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148034/44.wav", + "text": "但一二審都無罪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148034/45.wav", + "text": "最後當然也是無罪確定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148034/46.wav", + "text": "啦所以請教本席剛剛的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148034/47.wav", + "text": "這個情資是哪個機關提出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148034/48.wav", + "text": "的這件事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148034/49.wav", + "text": "有沒有意圖影響選舉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148034/50.wav", + "text": "局長可以回答嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148034/51.wav", + "text": "還是部長要回答" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148034/52.wav", + "text": "當然跟情資無關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148034/53.wav", + "text": "至於跟選舉有沒有關係" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148034/54.wav", + "text": "是否有相關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148034/55.wav", + "text": "如果涉及到違法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148034/56.wav", + "text": "我們當然就會偵辦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148034/57.wav", + "text": "部長向心案算不算我們今天說的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148034/58.wav", + "text": "境外勢力干預我國選舉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148034/59.wav", + "text": "算還是不算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148034/60.wav", + "text": "向心案我就不講別的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148034/61.wav", + "text": "向心案的王立強是算還是不算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148034/62.wav", + "text": "假如現在馬上就有這樣的案子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148034/63.wav", + "text": "你管還是不管" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148034/64.wav", + "text": "凡是涉及到犯罪的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148034/65.wav", + "text": "只要有告訴告發或其他情事" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148034/66.wav", + "text": "有犯罪嫌疑" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148034/67.wav", + "text": "我們檢察官就要來偵辦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148034/68.wav", + "text": "所以我們是不管他到底是不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148034/69.wav", + "text": "只要有涉及到犯罪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148034/70.wav", + "text": "我們就有責任要去查辦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148034/71.wav", + "text": "好部長你的答案非常官式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148034/72.wav", + "text": "因為這個共諜案最後是無罪確定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148034/73.wav", + "text": "如何確保民眾不會被誣陷" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148034/74.wav", + "text": "現在被誣陷的是向心他是大陸人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148034/75.wav", + "text": "不是中華民國的國民" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148034/76.wav", + "text": "假如是中華民國的國民被這樣爆料誣陷" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148034/77.wav", + "text": "最後都無罪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148034/78.wav", + "text": "影響也影響了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148034/79.wav", + "text": "結果也出來了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148034/80.wav", + "text": "所以我們在處理這種涉及到���事責任" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148034/81.wav", + "text": "有關選舉的案件要非常地謹慎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148034/82.wav", + "text": "要小心不要受到別人的操弄或影響" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148034/83.wav", + "text": "我們要秉公處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148034/84.wav", + "text": "但有案子也不能因為顧及到什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148034/85.wav", + "text": "就不處理這也不行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148034/86.wav", + "text": "所以我們心中還是要有一把尺" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148034/87.wav", + "text": "法務部都在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148034/88.wav", + "text": "本席是要提醒大家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148034/89.wav", + "text": "你們的作法實際上就會影響選舉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148034/90.wav", + "text": "不管是正面或負面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148034/91.wav", + "text": "當然向心案已經過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148034/92.wav", + "text": "了但本席不希望今年又發生這種烏龍事件" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148034/93.wav", + "text": "到最後三審都無罪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148034/94.wav", + "text": "這其實是打了檢警調的臉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148034/95.wav", + "text": "所以在這個部分你們一定要小心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148034/96.wav", + "text": "現在是沒有人在追究" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148034/97.wav", + "text": "大家都說向心走了不追究了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148034/98.wav", + "text": "但要是我是他" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148034/99.wav", + "text": "我也覺得很無辜" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148034/100.wav", + "text": "\n請教國安局副局長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148034/101.wav", + "text": "國安局有要做相關的調查嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148034/102.wav", + "text": "發展組織罪的被發展者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148034/103.wav", + "text": "以及現役軍人向中共效忠的這些行為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148034/104.wav", + "text": "國安局說有必要增訂相關的規範" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148034/105.wav", + "text": "來完備國安法制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148034/106.wav", + "text": "請教有沒有一些修法方向" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148034/107.wav", + "text": "或預計什麼時候會提出\n" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148034/108.wav", + "text": "兩個問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148034/109.wav", + "text": "第一個問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148034/110.wav", + "text": "國安局現在的態度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148034/111.wav", + "text": "如何第二個就是修法的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148034/112.wav", + "text": "報告委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148034/113.wav", + "text": "本局是情報蒐集研析的機關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148034/114.wav", + "text": "我們尊重檢調的職權" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148034/115.wav", + "text": "評估是不是要分案來調查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148034/116.wav", + "text": "我們站在情報機關的立場" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148034/117.wav", + "text": "如果需要本局協助的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148034/118.wav", + "text": "目前國安會主持的會議裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148034/119.wav", + "text": "我們一直在研討中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148034/120.wav", + "text": "就是將參與的部分納入規範" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148034/121.wav", + "text": "那有預計這個會期會提出嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148034/122.wav", + "text": "還是下屆再說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148034/123.wav", + "text": "我們正在努力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148033/0.wav", + "text": "謝謝主席請金管會主委" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148033/1.wav", + "text": "主委我要問一下關於" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148033/2.wav", + "text": "虛擬資產投資以及支付金管會是主管機關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148033/3.wav", + "text": "回頭來看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148033/4.wav", + "text": "指定的這些金融機構" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148033/5.wav", + "text": "就必須要執行洗錢防制內稽內控" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148033/6.wav", + "text": "它的實施內容作業程序" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148033/7.wav", + "text": "執行措施查核方式等這些再接" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148033/8.wav", + "text": "再接上有關於虛擬通貨平台及交易業務事業防制洗錢及" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148033/9.wav", + "text": "打擊資恐辦法第十七條第1項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148033/10.wav", + "text": "就會知道這" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148033/11.wav", + "text": "\n第一個問題就來了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148033/12.wav", + "text": "假設" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148033/13.wav", + "text": "依據洗錢防制法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148033/14.wav", + "text": "登記制度做聲明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148033/15.wav", + "text": "不行啊先申請聲明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148033/16.wav", + "text": "是合法營業的一個前提" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148033/17.wav", + "text": "所以如果沒有完成聲明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148033/18.wav", + "text": "就被登記到名單裡不能營業" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148033/19.wav", + "text": "不是我不太清楚對不起" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148033/20.wav", + "text": "我不應該那樣說我" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148033/21.wav", + "text": "我應該說只有合法登記的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148033/22.wav", + "text": "業者才會被當作是一個正式受認可的平" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148033/23.wav", + "text": "倒過來講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148033/24.wav", + "text": "假設還沒有完成聲明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148033/25.wav", + "text": "就在你們登記的名單裡被公告的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148033/26.wav", + "text": "會嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148033/27.wav", + "text": "會不會被處罰" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148033/28.wav", + "text": "目前來講應該沒有這種情況吧" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148033/29.wav", + "text": "所以是道德約束" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148033/30.wav", + "text": "所以沒有處罰就只有道德約束" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148033/31.wav", + "text": "所以這是勸世文嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148033/32.wav", + "text": "如果沒有登記就不應該營業" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148033/33.wav", + "text": "是但是我現在就倒著講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148033/34.wav", + "text": "如果沒有完成聲明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148033/35.wav", + "text": "沒有被登記入到你們的名單裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148033/36.wav", + "text": "如果我是虛擬資產業者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148033/37.wav", + "text": "我去做了營業的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148033/38.wav", + "text": "我會不會被你們處罰" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148033/39.wav", + "text": "洗錢防制法是有處分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148033/40.wav", + "text": "用洗錢防制法的相關處分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148033/41.wav", + "text": "那我回頭過來問你" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148033/42.wav", + "text": "去登記到底要多少時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148033/43.wav", + "text": "完成聲明到底要多少時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148033/44.wav", + "text": "我去看你們的母法子法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148033/45.wav", + "text": "甚至去看你們的解釋令" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148033/46.wav", + "text": "只有限定業者多少時間之內" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148033/47.wav", + "text": "或什麼條件" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148033/48.wav", + "text": "要來辦理聲明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148033/49.wav", + "text": "及主管機關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148033/50.wav", + "text": "到底是多久" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148033/51.wav", + "text": "沒有這個規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148033/52.wav", + "text": "所以到底是多久" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148033/53.wav", + "text": "就是作業流程的時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148033/54.wav", + "text": "請證期局說明一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148033/55.wav", + "text": "目前而言" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148033/56.wav", + "text": "我們的作業其實都會立刻處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148033/57.wav", + "text": "但是因為現在幾個案件都有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148033/58.wav", + "text": "書件要補正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148033/59.wav", + "text": "所以要等到公司補正來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148033/60.wav", + "text": "我們認為書件合法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148033/61.wav", + "text": "我手上有幾頁的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148033/62.wav", + "text": "洗錢防制法令徵詢聲明書" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148033/63.wav", + "text": "我就請問" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148033/64.wav", + "text": "最近一次的聲明是10月24" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148033/65.wav", + "text": "日名單更新" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148033/66.wav", + "text": "上一次是9月27" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148033/67.wav", + "text": "日再更上次是2月20" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148033/68.wav", + "text": "日有時候經過1個月" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148033/69.wav", + "text": "有時候經過7個月" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148033/70.wav", + "text": "那就表示" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148033/71.wav", + "text": "是大家都是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148033/72.wav", + "text": "有申請" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148033/73.wav", + "text": "經過很久" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148033/74.wav", + "text": "不定期" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148033/75.wav", + "text": "慢慢耗" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148033/76.wav", + "text": "不知道什麼時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148033/77.wav", + "text": "聲明會過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148033/78.wav", + "text": "還是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148033/79.wav", + "text": "你們真的有限定什麼時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148033/80.wav", + "text": "會給予他們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148033/81.wav", + "text": "明確的答覆" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148033/82.wav", + "text": "如果照剛才證期局的說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148033/83.wav", + "text": "必須要提供完整的文件" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148033/84.wav", + "text": "證期局才能夠送審" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148033/85.wav", + "text": "才能夠處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148033/86.wav", + "text": "也要提出足夠的證" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148033/87.wav", + "text": "我是說主管機關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148033/88.wav", + "text": "要不要訂定審酌期限的規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148033/89.wav", + "text": "到底是幾天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148033/90.wav", + "text": "10天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148033/91.wav", + "text": "15天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148033/92.wav", + "text": "30天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148033/93.wav", + "text": "我想問一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148033/94.wav", + "text": "母法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148033/95.wav", + "text": "解釋函令當中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148033/96.wav", + "text": "都沒有提及這項聲明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148033/97.wav", + "text": "申請你們要給人家多少的期限" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148033/98.wav", + "text": "一旦業者送件進來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148033/99.wav", + "text": "行政程序法第51條規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148033/100.wav", + "text": "就全部當作是2個月" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148033/101.wav", + "text": "我是覺得2個月太久了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148033/102.wav", + "text": "你們要以2個月為基礎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148033/103.wav", + "text": "嗎我是覺得15天或" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148033/104.wav", + "text": "最多到30天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148033/105.wav", + "text": "到底過了或沒過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148033/106.wav", + "text": "你們應該要立刻給人家答案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148033/107.wav", + "text": "不可能在那邊慢慢耗" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148033/108.wav", + "text": "你好像慢慢掐死它" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148033/109.wav", + "text": "它還不能唉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148033/110.wav", + "text": "我根據行政程序法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148033/111.wav", + "text": "要求你們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148033/112.wav", + "text": "不定期限" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148033/113.wav", + "text": "的最底線就是行政程序法的兩個月" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148033/114.wav", + "text": "目前來講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148033/115.wav", + "text": "平均大概40天到50天左右" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148033/116.wav", + "text": "主委就訂吧" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148033/117.wav", + "text": "就訂一個給人答復的時間吧" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148033/118.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148033/119.wav", + "text": "我請證期局去研究一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148033/120.wav", + "text": "目前來講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148033/121.wav", + "text": "過去的經驗大概多少天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148033/122.wav", + "text": "讓我們有一個可預期的時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148033/123.wav", + "text": "但是業者也必須要符合相關的規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148033/124.wav", + "text": "好先把時間訂出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148033/125.wav", + "text": "另外回頭來看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148033/126.wav", + "text": "登記就上了名單" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148033/127.wav", + "text": "上了名單就可以營業" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148033/128.wav", + "text": "請問從過去到現在有沒有被除名的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148033/129.wav", + "text": "目前好像有嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148033/130.wav", + "text": "有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148033/131.wav", + "text": "沒有我問這個幹什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148033/132.wav", + "text": "大概有五六件案子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148033/133.wav", + "text": "後來書件沒有補齊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148033/134.wav", + "text": "我們就把它退回去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148033/135.wav", + "text": "你把它除名是一種行政處分嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148033/136.wav", + "text": "沒有它可以隨時補齊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148033/137.wav", + "text": "後再來申請都沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148033/138.wav", + "text": "不你做的這個是什麼行政行為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148033/139.wav", + "text": "你把它除名了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148033/140.wav", + "text": "什麼叫除名" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148033/141.wav", + "text": "本來上名單" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148033/142.wav", + "text": "卻被你拉下來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148033/143.wav", + "text": "我知道有一種叫做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148033/144.wav", + "text": "自己去廢止聲明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148033/145.wav", + "text": "難道都是你們喝完咖啡它自己廢止聲明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148033/146.wav", + "text": "還是你是用什麼行政動作叫它除名" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148033/147.wav", + "text": "你要知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148033/148.wav", + "text": "假設你讓它上名單" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148033/149.wav", + "text": "到底是不是一種行政處分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148033/150.wav", + "text": "假設你讓它從名單下來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148033/151.wav", + "text": "這是行政處分的撤銷廢止還是無效" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148033/152.wav", + "text": "牽連的法律關係都不一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148033/153.wav", + "text": "目前沒有任何一家被我們證期局除名" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148033/154.wav", + "text": "除名就是你在合法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148033/155.wav", + "text": "從名單下來有沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148033/156.wav", + "text": "目前我們沒有處理過這種案件" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148033/157.wav", + "text": "從名單下來沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148033/158.wav", + "text": "銀行局那邊好像有是自動拿下來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148033/159.wav", + "text": "是它們自己申請要拿下來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148033/160.wav", + "text": "它自己那麼乖" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148033/161.wav", + "text": "它是怎麼樣喝了咖啡自己拿下來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148033/162.wav", + "text": "它要從那個名單下來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148033/163.wav", + "text": "主要是因為它來聲明說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148033/164.wav", + "text": "它已經不再經營那個業務" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148033/165.wav", + "text": "所以才從那個名單拿掉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148033/166.wav", + "text": "剛剛證期局說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148033/167.wav", + "text": "它可能還要再補件" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148033/168.wav", + "text": "它上了名單之後從名單" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148033/169.wav", + "text": "現在你說它是自己不做了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148033/170.wav", + "text": "主委在這裡都聽到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148033/171.wav", + "text": "送你四個字亂七八糟" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148033/172.wav", + "text": "真的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148033/173.wav", + "text": "啦如果我講話太重" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148033/174.wav", + "text": "我就不要用那麼強的字眼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148033/175.wav", + "text": "請你們考量一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148033/176.wav", + "text": "因為我都是依法在講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148033/177.wav", + "text": "或是再重新作成新的行政處分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148033/178.wav", + "text": "還是原來那個無效" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148033/179.wav", + "text": "這麼做法律上的這些完全都不一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148033/180.wav", + "text": "不是剛剛兩局在那邊講的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148033/181.wav", + "text": "非常令人詫異" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148033/182.wav", + "text": "再補充一點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148033/183.wav", + "text": "您說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148033/184.wav", + "text": "沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148033/185.wav", + "text": "因為原來是銀行局在負責" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148033/186.wav", + "text": "後來這個業務轉到證期局" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148033/187.wav", + "text": "所以不同局在處理的時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148033/188.wav", + "text": "時程是不太一樣的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148033/189.wav", + "text": "我才不相信" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148033/190.wav", + "text": "過去的廢止都是業者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148033/191.wav", + "text": "自己下據" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148033/192.wav", + "text": "據我瞭解" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148033/193.wav", + "text": "銀行局時期是有一兩家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148033/194.wav", + "text": "自己說不辦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148033/195.wav", + "text": "剛剛他講五六家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148033/196.wav", + "text": "一兩家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148033/197.wav", + "text": "好啦我不苛責" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148033/198.wav", + "text": "我就把這些點出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148033/199.wav", + "text": "謝謝委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148033/200.wav", + "text": "是這樣子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148033/201.wav", + "text": "我不是說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148033/202.wav", + "text": "講了要怎麼樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148033/203.wav", + "text": "只是講有這些事" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148033/204.wav", + "text": "我們要依法看怎麼辦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148033/205.wav", + "text": "法律不夠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148033/206.wav", + "text": "就加強" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148033/207.wav", + "text": "就是修法立法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148033/208.wav", + "text": "或怎麼樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148033/209.wav", + "text": "\n接下來講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148033/210.wav", + "text": "一個很好玩的東西" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148033/211.wav", + "text": "叫做穩定幣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148033/212.wav", + "text": "我們的VASP" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148033/213.wav", + "text": "及交易業務事業指導原則" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148033/214.wav", + "text": "不在原則條文裡面的說明欄" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148033/215.wav", + "text": "鑑於穩定幣對於金融穩定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148033/216.wav", + "text": "有一定影響程度之影響" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148033/217.wav", + "text": "金管會要觀察國際市場" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148033/218.wav", + "text": "及監理規範發展情形之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148033/219.wav", + "text": "再適時研議對境內穩定幣的管理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148033/220.wav", + "text": "我要問這是什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148033/221.wav", + "text": "不寫在指導原則裡面的不指導原則" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148033/222.wav", + "text": "看說明欄是什麼效力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148033/223.wav", + "text": "是能做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148033/224.wav", + "text": "不能做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148033/225.wav", + "text": "我再講一" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148033/226.wav", + "text": "不寫在指導原則裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148033/227.wav", + "text": "故意寫在說明欄裡面的不指導原則" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148033/228.wav", + "text": "這是什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148033/229.wav", + "text": "它有什麼效力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148033/230.wav", + "text": "這個指導原則只是投資性質的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148033/231.wav", + "text": "穩定幣屬於支付性質的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148033/232.wav", + "text": "我們會在下一階段再衡量" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148033/233.wav", + "text": "我問你它是法規命令嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148033/234.wav", + "text": "指導原則不是什麼法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148033/235.wav", + "text": "因為它沒有寫在原則的條文裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148033/236.wav", + "text": "它寫在說明欄" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148033/237.wav", + "text": "說你們要適時研議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148033/238.wav", + "text": "看起來就是暫不指導" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148033/239.wav", + "text": "這到底是什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148033/240.wav", + "text": "我跟你講一個東西" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148033/241.wav", + "text": "朱元璋的軍師劉伯溫有寫勸世文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148033/242.wav", + "text": "我再唸一次第三次了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148033/243.wav", + "text": "不指導的原則" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148033/244.wav", + "text": "不寫在指導原則裡寫在說明欄裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148033/245.wav", + "text": "我真的還要問你" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148033/246.wav", + "text": "你的VASP指導原則是行政指導嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148033/247.wav", + "text": "我拜讀過你跟沈發惠委員的詢答" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148033/248.wav", + "text": "我拜讀過你跟郭國文委員之間的詢答" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148033/249.wav", + "text": "是否是行政指導" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148033/250.wav", + "text": "主委還沒拿定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148033/251.wav", + "text": "你說不一定只是規則" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148033/252.wav", + "text": "你還有其他方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148033/253.wav", + "text": "我都很仔細在看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148033/254.wav", + "text": "今天我就來問它" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148033/255.wav", + "text": "它如果不是行政指導" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148033/256.wav", + "text": "它是什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148033/257.wav", + "text": "它如果是行政指導的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148033/258.wav", + "text": "大問題來了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148033/259.wav", + "text": "行政指導不具法律拘束力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148033/260.wav", + "text": "我們的政策流程" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148033/261.wav", + "text": "一開始就沒有準備一開始就要立法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148033/262.wav", + "text": "因為虛擬資產的種類性質很多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148033/263.wav", + "text": "臺灣的市場狀況如何" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148033/264.wav", + "text": "需要再觀察一段時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148033/265.wav", + "text": "你不如完全不寫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148033/266.wav", + "text": "可不可以在30秒內結束好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148033/267.wav", + "text": "不好意思主席" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148033/268.wav", + "text": "謝謝你的包容" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148033/269.wav", + "text": "\n我說你不如不寫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148033/270.wav", + "text": "啊我再講一次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148033/271.wav", + "text": "不指導寫在指導原則的說明欄裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148033/272.wav", + "text": "裡你就不要寫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148033/273.wav", + "text": "啊因為能做嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148033/274.wav", + "text": "不知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148033/275.wav", + "text": "不能做嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148033/276.wav", + "text": "不知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148033/277.wav", + "text": "是行政指導嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148033/278.wav", + "text": "沒有法律拘束力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148033/279.wav", + "text": "你在跟其他委員的答詢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148033/280.wav", + "text": "過程當中相當矛盾" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148033/281.wav", + "text": "什麼叫行政指導" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148033/282.wav", + "text": "不能夠對於相對人為不利之處置" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148033/283.wav", + "text": "你真的還不知道要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148033/284.wav", + "text": "候就不要寫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148033/285.wav", + "text": "啊或許你可以在其他地方" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148033/286.wav", + "text": "補充說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148033/287.wav", + "text": "這個可能對央行來講更需要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148033/288.wav", + "text": "因為央行對於貨幣的權責" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148033/289.wav", + "text": "職掌" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148033/290.wav", + "text": "你分析它可能比金管會還尤為關鍵" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148033/291.wav", + "text": "啊因為你想管它" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148033/292.wav", + "text": "它你寫這樣似是而非看不清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148033/293.wav", + "text": "人家會回頭問你" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148033/294.wav", + "text": "穩定幣是不是衍生性金融商品" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148033/295.wav", + "text": "或者是具證券性質的虛擬通貨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148033/296.wav", + "text": "人家會回過來問你這些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148033/297.wav", + "text": "但也答不出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148033/298.wav", + "text": "可不可以會後再跟您說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148033/299.wav", + "text": "或者到委員辦公室說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148033/300.wav", + "text": "所以你們要做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148033/301.wav", + "text": "我希望也都是依法來看怎麼樣處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148033/302.wav", + "text": "是謝謝委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148033/303.wav", + "text": "各位請回" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148033/304.wav", + "text": "\n今日登記" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148032/0.wav", + "text": "有請部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148032/1.wav", + "text": "委員好辛苦了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148032/2.wav", + "text": "可以回來長照的議題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148032/3.wav", + "text": "謝謝我想大家還沈浸在美豬當中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148032/4.wav", + "text": "可能尚不宜進行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148032/5.wav", + "text": "臺下的委員請安靜一點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148032/6.wav", + "text": "請暫停時間好嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148032/7.wav", + "text": "請臺下的委員安靜好嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148032/8.wav", + "text": "就是整個長照資源的布建" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148032/9.wav", + "text": "建跟未來有沒有辦法推行長照保險" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148032/10.wav", + "text": "非常有相關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148032/11.wav", + "text": "我們看到整個長照資源的布建" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148032/12.wav", + "text": "目前是17倍" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148032/13.wav", + "text": "但是現在看到目標值成長了將近10倍" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148032/14.wav", + "text": "是不是會有一點concern因為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148032/15.wav", + "text": "結果現在看到B單位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148032/16.wav", + "text": "居然是C單位的兩倍" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148032/17.wav", + "text": "這一定跟當初政策推動的方向" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148032/18.wav", + "text": "有很多人做居家照顧的工作" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148032/19.wav", + "text": "但是你會發覺所有照服員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148032/20.wav", + "text": "半數都在居家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148032/21.wav", + "text": "相關的機構社區" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148032/22.wav", + "text": "反而人都被居家吸走了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148032/23.wav", + "text": "不只這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148032/24.wav", + "text": "很多人畢業以後根本不進臨床" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148032/25.wav", + "text": "直接去當照服員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148032/26.wav", + "text": "當然它是有一定的誘因" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148032/27.wav", + "text": "但是這對我們的教育" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148032/28.wav", + "text": "的確造成了很大的浪費" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148032/29.wav", + "text": "\n我們看到整個長照機構的成長上面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148032/30.wav", + "text": "其實成長很多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148032/31.wav", + "text": "但是都是在居服機構" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148032/32.wav", + "text": "特別是居服機構" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148032/33.wav", + "text": "成長得這麼快的情況之下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148032/34.wav", + "text": "那時候尹祚芊監委" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148032/35.wav", + "text": "其實就已經提醒過部裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148032/36.wav", + "text": "長照機構的成長速度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148032/37.wav", + "text": "真的是超過我們的預期" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148032/38.wav", + "text": "其實提到很多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148032/39.wav", + "text": "但是除了這個以外" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148032/40.wav", + "text": "因為經濟誘因" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148032/41.wav", + "text": "造成現在人力上面的一個困境" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148032/42.wav", + "text": "更提醒我們的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148032/43.wav", + "text": "其實是在長照居服單位的品質上面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148032/44.wav", + "text": "居服單位大概有三類" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148032/45.wav", + "text": "這些個人型" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148032/46.wav", + "text": "包括居護所" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148032/47.wav", + "text": "成立自己的居服單位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148032/48.wav", + "text": "或者比較讓人家擔心的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148032/49.wav", + "text": "就是成長非常快的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148032/50.wav", + "text": "當然比較好的就是那種" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148032/51.wav", + "text": "自己的體系" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148032/52.wav", + "text": "有自己的日照居服居護等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148032/53.wav", + "text": "我們覺得比較放心的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148032/54.wav", + "text": "為什麼會這樣講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148032/55.wav", + "text": "居服機構" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148032/56.wav", + "text": "的確我聽到有人來檢舉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148032/57.wav", + "text": "其實是他挾自己的人頭戶" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148032/58.wav", + "text": "也造成很多居服單位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148032/59.wav", + "text": "所以我比較擔心的是你們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148032/60.wav", + "text": "做得非常好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148032/61.wav", + "text": "會不會有一些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148032/62.wav", + "text": "劣幣驅逐良幣的情形" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148032/63.wav", + "text": "的評鑑成果並不是這麼好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148032/64.wav", + "text": "居然有高達三成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148032/65.wav", + "text": "其實是不合格的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148032/66.wav", + "text": "所以在這樣子的情況之下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148032/67.wav", + "text": "如果我們已經有量了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148032/68.wav", + "text": "在品質上面可不可以來加以管控" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148032/69.wav", + "text": "特別是我們現在知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148032/70.wav", + "text": "像健保可能會抽查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148032/71.wav", + "text": "抽查完了以後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148032/72.wav", + "text": "跟他講這是詐領什麼的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148032/73.wav", + "text": "有問題只需要繳回服務費" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148032/74.wav", + "text": "並沒有相關的罰則" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148032/75.wav", + "text": "所以在這樣子的情況之下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148032/76.wav", + "text": "作假的機率會不會比較高" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148032/77.wav", + "text": "部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148032/78.wav", + "text": "剛剛委員提到了幾個事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148032/79.wav", + "text": "居服單位的評鑑" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148032/80.wav", + "text": "我們已經開始在進行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148032/81.wav", + "text": "之前都還沒有就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148032/82.wav", + "text": "那我們有特約管理辦法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148032/83.wav", + "text": "我們已經訂好了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148032/84.wav", + "text": "基本上應該還要再去查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148032/85.wav", + "text": "讓它有改善的機會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148032/86.wav", + "text": "如果沒有改善的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148032/87.wav", + "text": "可能就停止" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148032/88.wav", + "text": "所以現在真的是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148032/89.wav", + "text": "限期改善而已" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148032/90.wav", + "text": "並沒有相關的罰則" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148032/91.wav", + "text": "對因為特約管理辦法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148032/92.wav", + "text": "才剛上路不久" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148032/93.wav", + "text": "所以我們還是不要說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148032/94.wav", + "text": "一下子就給它處罰" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148032/95.wav", + "text": "瞭解" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148032/96.wav", + "text": "這是第一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148032/97.wav", + "text": "因為人力老實講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148032/98.wav", + "text": "它是一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148032/99.wav", + "text": "有市場機制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148032/100.wav", + "text": "市場機制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148032/101.wav", + "text": "所以我們現在要做的大概" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148032/102.wav", + "text": "職業環境友善" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148032/103.wav", + "text": "對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148032/104.wav", + "text": "住宿��機構裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148032/105.wav", + "text": "也有一些改善的措施" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148032/106.wav", + "text": "會出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148032/107.wav", + "text": "這部分的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148032/108.wav", + "text": "讓它能夠再有一些平衡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148032/109.wav", + "text": "至於要怎麼樣做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148032/110.wav", + "text": "張育美委員在質詢的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148032/111.wav", + "text": "我有提到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148032/112.wav", + "text": "我們會有一個新的計畫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148032/113.wav", + "text": "好的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148032/114.wav", + "text": "B單位的這部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148032/115.wav", + "text": "我可能要稍微說明一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148032/116.wav", + "text": "因為這個可能" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148032/117.wav", + "text": "外界會有一些誤解" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148032/118.wav", + "text": "對因為成長非常的多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148032/119.wav", + "text": "剛開始規劃" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148032/120.wav", + "text": "也就是蔡總統剛上任的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148032/121.wav", + "text": "那時候規劃的ABC" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148032/122.wav", + "text": "是綁在一起的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148032/123.wav", + "text": "就是一個A要去處理幾個B" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148032/124.wav", + "text": "對自己要去管理它的B跟C" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148032/125.wav", + "text": "但是我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148032/126.wav", + "text": "差不多將近一年的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148032/127.wav", + "text": "那時候是陳時中部長上任" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148032/128.wav", + "text": "我知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148032/129.wav", + "text": "上任之後他找我過來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148032/130.wav", + "text": "我們就討論到這一點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148032/131.wav", + "text": "如果把它綁在一起的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148032/132.wav", + "text": "它發展不起來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148032/133.wav", + "text": "因為A是有限的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148032/134.wav", + "text": "切開來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148032/135.wav", + "text": "B歸BA歸A" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148032/136.wav", + "text": "那B的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148032/137.wav", + "text": "就變成有很多種" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148032/138.wav", + "text": "只要提供服務的都算是B" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148032/139.wav", + "text": "服務的單位我們都稱我" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148032/140.wav", + "text": "包括你提供交通服務的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148032/141.wav", + "text": "居服的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148032/142.wav", + "text": "還是居服的單位最多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148032/143.wav", + "text": "最多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148032/144.wav", + "text": "但是各種不同的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148032/145.wav", + "text": "都算是B" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148032/146.wav", + "text": "所以一下子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148032/147.wav", + "text": "B單位就變成很多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148032/148.wav", + "text": "要不然大家就會覺得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148032/149.wav", + "text": "你設那個目標值" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148032/150.wav", + "text": "跟你的政策方向是不一樣的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148032/151.wav", + "text": "因為2.0的那個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148032/152.wav", + "text": "定本是行政院核定的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148032/153.wav", + "text": "所以一下子現在要改" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148032/154.wav", + "text": "就把它拿掉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148032/155.wav", + "text": "當初ABC把它一條龍連貫起來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148032/156.wav", + "text": "的確是有以社區為中心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148032/157.wav", + "text": "用生活圈的概念這樣子做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148032/158.wav", + "text": "當我們現在把它切割掉的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148032/159.wav", + "text": "這個部分的概念" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148032/160.wav", + "text": "要不然我們這些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148032/161.wav", + "text": "一開始推動的美意就沒了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148032/162.wav", + "text": "好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148032/163.wav", + "text": "是不是兩週內" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148032/164.wav", + "text": "我們再請司" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148032/165.wav", + "text": "司長來辦公室說明一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148032/166.wav", + "text": "因為基本上我真的接到了檢舉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148032/167.wav", + "text": "就是在查核跟機制上面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148032/168.wav", + "text": "他們很擔心會有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148032/169.wav", + "text": "劣幣驅逐良幣的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148032/170.wav", + "text": "好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148032/171.wav", + "text": "謝謝部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148032/172.wav", + "text": "謝謝主席" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148031/0.wav", + "text": "我想請教中選會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148031/1.wav", + "text": "假設某間投開票所" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148031/2.wav", + "text": "或是恐攻預告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148031/3.wav", + "text": "中選會要怎麼處置" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148031/4.wav", + "text": "跟委員報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148031/5.wav", + "text": "我們有相關的演練" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148031/6.wav", + "text": "所以就是有備案了啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148031/7.wav", + "text": "有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148031/8.wav", + "text": "我也請教警政署" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148031/9.wav", + "text": "如果明年1月13日全臺開花" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148031/10.wav", + "text": "警政署要怎麼因應按" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148031/11.wav", + "text": "跟中選會在臺南的演練" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148031/12.wav", + "text": "我們會把這個模式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148031/13.wav", + "text": "和標準SOP流程" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148031/14.wav", + "text": "已經做了嗎還是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148031/15.wav", + "text": "已經做了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148031/16.wav", + "text": "副署長好像不太清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148031/17.wav", + "text": "這個炸彈預告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148031/18.wav", + "text": "都是假消息" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148031/19.wav", + "text": "你們會把它當作假消息來處理還是怎麼樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148031/20.wav", + "text": "如果是假消息" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148031/21.wav", + "text": "我們就依處理假消息的原則" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148031/22.wav", + "text": "但是你看中國學生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148031/23.wav", + "text": "張海川大規模的假炸彈消息" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148031/24.wav", + "text": "已經搞得各機關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148031/25.wav", + "text": "翻這一點我很清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148031/26.wav", + "text": "那怎麼辦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148031/27.wav", + "text": "你們的因應作為是什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148031/28.wav", + "text": "信箱的假炸彈訊息" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148031/29.wav", + "text": "第一個我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148031/30.wav", + "text": "會先" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148031/31.wav", + "text": "當做真的來防處" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148031/32.wav", + "text": "當做真的來防處" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148031/33.wav", + "text": "對我們會防處" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148031/34.wav", + "text": "好謝謝因為這是沒有辦法開玩笑的事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148031/35.wav", + "text": "張海川現在人在哪裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148031/36.wav", + "text": "他們應該" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148031/37.wav", + "text": "也有所瞭解人應該" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148031/38.wav", + "text": "不在國內" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148031/39.wav", + "text": "中國公安在5月5日" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148031/40.wav", + "text": "有傳喚張海川到案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148031/41.wav", + "text": "張海川也坦承對臺犯下多起恐嚇案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148031/42.wav", + "text": "然後咧" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148031/43.wav", + "text": "這是法務部講的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148031/44.wav", + "text": "不是是警政署" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148031/45.wav", + "text": "這是警政署講的嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148031/46.wav", + "text": "那就請副署長來回應" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148031/47.wav", + "text": "這個部分並沒有說是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148031/48.wav", + "text": "5月5日他是有去當面澄清" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148031/49.wav", + "text": "說因為有一件是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148031/50.wav", + "text": "被放置假炸彈的消息" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148031/51.wav", + "text": "他否認他有涉及到這個案子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148031/52.wav", + "text": "被傳喚結果5月18日" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148031/53.wav", + "text": "日高雄壽山" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148031/54.wav", + "text": "壽山動物園5月25日國家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148031/55.wav", + "text": "圖書館等單位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148031/56.wav", + "text": "還是接到炸彈恐嚇信" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148031/57.wav", + "text": "不僅如此總統府在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148031/58.wav", + "text": "炸彈恐嚇信" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148031/59.wav", + "text": "刑事局分析手法發現" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148031/60.wav", + "text": "四處恐嚇高鐵機場的中國籍" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148031/61.wav", + "text": "嫌犯張海川的和這些案子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148031/62.wav", + "text": "不排除是同人所為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148031/63.wav", + "text": "這個沒有錯" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148031/64.wav", + "text": "因為這部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148031/65.wav", + "text": "還是要請教部長和各單位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148031/66.wav", + "text": "費及共打經費" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148031/67.wav", + "text": "原本是要凍要刪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148031/68.wav", + "text": "要刪後來在法務部相關同仁" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148031/69.wav", + "text": "苦口婆心的說明之下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148031/70.wav", + "text": "就退讓" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148031/71.wav", + "text": "了但是最近張海川到底在哪裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148031/72.wav", + "text": "你們到底有沒有掌握" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148031/73.wav", + "text": "我們的共打又在哪裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148031/74.wav", + "text": "謝謝委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148031/75.wav", + "text": "支持預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148031/76.wav", + "text": "國際及兩岸事" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148031/77.wav", + "text": "中國那邊的聯繫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148031/78.wav", + "text": "有一個窗口對於這個個案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148031/79.wav", + "text": "如果警政機關有需要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148031/80.wav", + "text": "我們協助" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148031/81.wav", + "text": "或是透過兩岸共打" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148031/82.wav", + "text": "協議來執行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148031/83.wav", + "text": "我們都很樂意來協助" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148031/84.wav", + "text": "國際及兩岸事務司" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148031/85.wav", + "text": "這個案子到現在還沒有到共打的平台去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148031/86.wav", + "text": "看偵辦的單位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148031/87.wav", + "text": "部長那你覺得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148031/88.wav", + "text": "這個案子有沒有這個需求" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148031/89.wav", + "text": "你看已經多久了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148031/90.wav", + "text": "已經搞到他現在恐嚇" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148031/91.wav", + "text": "不是恐嚇臺灣的某一個單位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148031/92.wav", + "text": "兩個單位或三個單位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148031/93.wav", + "text": "其實如果要把它講成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148031/94.wav", + "text": "比較嚴重的話他是在恐嚇" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148031/95.wav", + "text": "幾乎什麼地方都被他恐嚇過了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148031/96.wav", + "text": "啊接下來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148031/97.wav", + "text": "1月13日的總統大選" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148031/98.wav", + "text": "他會不會針對投開票所" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148031/99.wav", + "text": "萬一其中有一個是真的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148031/100.wav", + "text": "那我們怎麼辦我們怎麼預防" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148031/101.wav", + "text": "機關確定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148031/102.wav", + "text": "很多案子都是他這個人所為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148031/103.wav", + "text": "我們還是會全力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148031/104.wav", + "text": "看看怎麼樣把這個人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148031/105.wav", + "text": "能夠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148031/106.wav", + "text": "5月5日之前和之後的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148031/107.wav", + "text": "如出一轍不排除是同人所為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148031/108.wav", + "text": "而這個人到現在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148031/109.wav", + "text": "還沒有辦法到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148031/110.wav", + "text": "還是這個共打平台" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148031/111.wav", + "text": "基本上是虛設" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148031/112.wav", + "text": "還是中國不願意配合" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148031/113.wav", + "text": "當然這個問題非常嚴重" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148031/114.wav", + "text": "只要警政機關認為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148031/115.wav", + "text": "要我們來協助" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148031/116.wav", + "text": "透過我們的窗口" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148031/117.wav", + "text": "執行我們都很樂意配合" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148031/118.wav", + "text": "但是警政機關他們也有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148031/119.wav", + "text": "他們的窗口他們有他們的管道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148031/120.wav", + "text": "我們都會互通訊息" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148031/121.wav", + "text": "我要再就教警政署" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148031/122.wav", + "text": "副署長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148031/123.wav", + "text": "因為部長這樣答復了嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148031/124.wav", + "text": "所以我就請教你" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148031/125.wav", + "text": "我們不能因為這個嫌犯" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148031/126.wav", + "text": "躲在中國就拿他沒輒" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148031/127.wav", + "text": "不應該是這個樣子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148031/128.wav", + "text": "基本上我覺得是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148031/129.wav", + "text": "我知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148031/130.wav", + "text": "大陸的公安也看過他的手機" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148031/131.wav", + "text": "因為他在大陸沒有犯案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148031/132.wav", + "text": "做一個約制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148031/133.wav", + "text": "不是啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148031/134.wav", + "text": "他在中國沒有犯案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148031/135.wav", + "text": "那中國公安5月5日傳喚他去幹什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148031/136.wav", + "text": "傳喚他最主要是因為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148031/137.wav", + "text": "中國大陸有一個航空" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148031/138.wav", + "text": "公司的機上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148031/139.wav", + "text": "被放一個炸彈" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148031/140.wav", + "text": "他們是針對那個案子做偵查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148031/141.wav", + "text": "證明這件事是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148031/142.wav", + "text": "這個學生做的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148031/143.wav", + "text": "所以另外一個角度是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148031/144.wav", + "text": "我們都有去掌握這個狀況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148031/145.wav", + "text": "但另一個角度是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148031/146.wav", + "text": "他對臺灣的恐嚇" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148031/147.wav", + "text": "我們沒辦法跟對岸" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148031/148.wav", + "text": "達成某種程度的默契" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148031/149.wav", + "text": "及處理方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148031/150.wav", + "text": "甚至上到這個因為他們在那邊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148031/151.wav", + "text": "我們會儘量跟他們溝通" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148031/152.wav", + "text": "也有溝通好幾次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148031/153.wav", + "text": "我要請法務部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148031/154.wav", + "text": "警政署還有中選會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148031/155.wav", + "text": "對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148031/156.wav", + "text": "這件事情如果在大選的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148031/157.wav", + "text": "臺灣的大選" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148031/158.wav", + "text": "所以我覺得你們要有因應作為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148031/159.wav", + "text": "要怎麼處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148031/160.wav", + "text": "的相關報告給委員會做參考" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148031/161.wav", + "text": "可以吧" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148031/162.wav", + "text": "我們對所有的投開票所" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148031/163.wav", + "text": "會做一次事先的安全檢查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148031/164.wav", + "text": "做一個清查也會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148031/165.wav", + "text": "確認有沒有炸彈的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148031/166.wav", + "text": "這部分我們會做一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148031/167.wav", + "text": "他要在什麼時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148031/168.wav", + "text": "發動這個恐嚇炸彈" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148031/169.wav", + "text": "並且預告可能在什麼地方" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148031/170.wav", + "text": "坦白說其實我們很難預防" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148031/171.wav", + "text": "你去全國所有的投開票所" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148031/172.wav", + "text": "前置作業這個我知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148031/173.wav", + "text": "啊這是務必要做的事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148031/174.wav", + "text": "但如果再讓他發出這個恐嚇信而" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148031/175.wav", + "text": "我們沒辦法在第一時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148031/176.wav", + "text": "嚇阻這真的會有所影響" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148031/177.wav", + "text": "你再跟人民百姓說這邊沒有炸彈" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148031/178.wav", + "text": "請你來投票" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148031/179.wav", + "text": "那已經為時已晚了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148031/180.wav", + "text": "我剛剛跟大家報告的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148031/181.wav", + "text": "我們會確認這個投開票所是安全的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148031/182.wav", + "text": "我們會先去檢查過一次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148031/183.wav", + "text": "這是沒有問題的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148031/184.wav", + "text": "現場我們都勘查過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148031/185.wav", + "text": "我們會防制這些事情發生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148031/186.wav", + "text": "如果真的有這樣的疑慮" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148031/187.wav", + "text": "正常的程序來預防" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148031/188.wav", + "text": "好沒關係啦你這樣答復我" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148031/189.wav", + "text": "我也可以接受但我還是希望" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148031/190.wav", + "text": "法務部中選會跟警政署" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148031/191.wav", + "text": "可能會有炸彈恐嚇或恐攻的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148031/192.wav", + "text": "可以吧" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148031/193.wav", + "text": "應該沒問題吧" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148031/194.wav", + "text": "有關法務部的部分我會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148031/195.wav", + "text": "跟調查局就這部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148031/196.wav", + "text": "如何做嚴密防範" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148031/197.wav", + "text": "我們會提出一個說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148031/198.wav", + "text": "中選會的部分我們會以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148031/199.wav", + "text": "模擬演練的一個個案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148031/200.wav", + "text": "垂詢的個案來向委員說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148031/201.wav", + "text": "外界有群起仿效" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148031/202.wav", + "text": "是不是允許我們向個別" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148031/203.wav", + "text": "委員說明我們的實地" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148031/204.wav", + "text": "標準作業流程" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148031/205.wav", + "text": "好我最後預告一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148031/206.wav", + "text": "訊息如果三個單位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148031/207.wav", + "text": "在預算協商的時候我會針對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148031/208.wav", + "text": "原本已經退讓的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148031/209.wav", + "text": "有所堅持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148031/210.wav", + "text": "我先跟這三個相關單位預告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148031/211.wav", + "text": "一下謝謝謝謝主席" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148031/212.wav", + "text": "好謝謝劉建國委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148030/0.wav", + "text": "謝謝主席有請主委" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148030/1.wav", + "text": "好請黃主委" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148030/2.wav", + "text": "主委好今天針對幾個問題請教" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148030/3.wav", + "text": "首先我在上次有問過有關健身房的爭議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148030/4.wav", + "text": "也就是合約的問題教練合約沒有給消費者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148030/5.wav", + "text": "不只不給甚至也沒有審閱期" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148030/6.wav", + "text": "所以這些問題包括保險" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148030/7.wav", + "text": "時間暫停一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148030/8.wav", + "text": "就是包括保險的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148030/9.wav", + "text": "就是沒有落實消保法的精神" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148030/10.wav", + "text": "消保法有規定業者與消費者在簽訂定型化契約之前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148030/11.wav", + "text": "需要提供30天的合理審閱期" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148030/12.wav", + "text": "給消費者足夠的審閱時" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148030/13.wav", + "text": "而目前仰賴業者自律" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148030/14.wav", + "text": "每家業者就是有不同的做法跟標準" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148030/15.wav", + "text": "金管會是否可以介入監督保險產品的審閱期" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148030/16.wav", + "text": "保障消費者的權益" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148030/17.wav", + "text": "報告委員這部分其實我們是有參考消保法訂定審閱期" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148030/18.wav", + "text": "其實不是沒有保障消費者權益" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148030/19.wav", + "text": "其實也是有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148030/20.wav", + "text": "我請局長簡單跟您報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148030/21.wav", + "text": "我要問的就是如果有審閱期需要有審閱期" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148030/22.wav", + "text": "那目前是還沒有訂定地很明確嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148030/23.wav", + "text": "請回答" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148030/24.wav", + "text": "跟委員報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148030/25.wav", + "text": "分成兩個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148030/26.wav", + "text": "一個就是由我們有規定1年期以上的人壽保險" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148030/27.wav", + "text": "有3天審閱期" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148030/28.wav", + "text": "其他的部分則是依據消保法的規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148030/29.wav", + "text": "各公司要提供30天以內的審閱期" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148030/30.wav", + "text": "所以這個部分如果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148030/31.wav", + "text": "這個部分必須要每一個保險公司根據商品險種" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148030/32.wav", + "text": "保險局有沒有辦法定一個抽查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148030/33.wav", + "text": "辦法去了解落實的執行情形" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148030/34.wav", + "text": "後續我們來了解一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148030/35.wav", + "text": "本席建議還是要去抽查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148030/36.wav", + "text": "如果沒有落實才能夠加強改進" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148030/37.wav", + "text": "主委可以嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148030/38.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148030/39.wav", + "text": "再來就是針對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148030/40.wav", + "text": "IE的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148030/41.wav", + "text": "就是IPO的衝量之餘審核並不是很嚴謹" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148030/42.wav", + "text": "多次強調我國每年掛牌上市上櫃的企業數量" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148030/43.wav", + "text": "持續增加" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148030/44.wav", + "text": "證交所統計今年上市掛牌家數" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148030/45.wav", + "text": "不僅是近5年來最多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148030/46.wav", + "text": "今年以來也有23家申請上市" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148030/47.wav", + "text": "即將成為明年上市IPO的能量" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148030/48.wav", + "text": "由於生技股櫃" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148030/49.wav", + "text": "櫃轉市的風潮最受關注" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148030/50.wav", + "text": "本席要提醒包含證交所等相關單位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148030/51.wav", + "text": "在積極衝IPO的業量之餘" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148030/52.wav", + "text": "要如何確保相關審核程序的嚴謹" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148030/53.wav", + "text": "我們一向都要求" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148030/54.wav", + "text": "不能只為了量" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148030/55.wav", + "text": "一定要在審查的時候要嚴謹" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148030/56.wav", + "text": "好所以這個部分也希望不要出事" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148030/57.wav", + "text": "的問題針對上市的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148030/58.wav", + "text": "資料在今年的消費爭議33件裡W" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148030/59.wav", + "text": "他們為了能順利上市" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148030/60.wav", + "text": "只有29件" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148030/61.wav", + "text": "就是我們螢幕上看到的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148030/62.wav", + "text": "報告委員根據我的瞭解這家公司已經通過上市了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148030/63.wav", + "text": "但是上市之後交易所還是可以對它做相關內控的監管" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148030/64.wav", + "text": "實際數量也可以跟消保會那邊去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148030/65.wav", + "text": "是不是可以提供給本席" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148030/66.wav", + "text": "好我們會照委員的指示去處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148030/67.wav", + "text": "不過也請容許我說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148030/68.wav", + "text": "其實World Gym本身有目的事業主管機關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148030/69.wav", + "text": "應該也可以同步處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148030/70.wav", + "text": "這個部分我有強調啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148030/71.wav", + "text": "我們也看到包括盜刷的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148030/72.wav", + "text": "管理例如在得知可能有盜刷情形" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148030/73.wav", + "text": "時或者也是要進行抽查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148030/74.wav", + "text": "信用卡的盜刷如果是爭議款項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148030/75.wav", + "text": "都可以要求銀行暫時停止給付" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148030/76.wav", + "text": "如果已經給付應該如" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148030/77.wav", + "text": "該如何要求銀行再把已經扣款的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148030/78.wav", + "text": "委員您這邊如果是有個案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148030/79.wav", + "text": "可以在會後由我們跟您請示" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148030/80.wav", + "text": "把個案交給我們由我們去了解" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148030/81.wav", + "text": "如果金管會是扮演監理的這個角色" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148030/82.wav", + "text": "而不是說個案就處理個案就好了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148030/83.wav", + "text": "他們就去個別和解" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148030/84.wav", + "text": "然後報給我們金管會上市的爭議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148030/85.wav", + "text": "就變那麼少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148030/86.wav", + "text": "所以我覺得還是要從根本面來處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148029/0.wav", + "text": "謝謝主席有請薛部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148029/1.wav", + "text": "請部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148029/2.wav", + "text": "上次跟部長看到這張圖的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148029/3.wav", + "text": "其實是去年年底本來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148029/4.wav", + "text": "要和您討論精準醫療的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148029/5.wav", + "text": "能夠促進所謂的健康餘命（" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148029/6.wav", + "text": "healthy life expectancy" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148029/7.wav", + "text": "）提升民眾的生活品質" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148029/8.wav", + "text": "同時也是降低醫療以及長照的花費" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148029/9.wav", + "text": "當然我知道部長非常清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148029/10.wav", + "text": "老化其實是一個過程" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148029/11.wav", + "text": "不能單分為健康跟生病" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148029/12.wav", + "text": "其實是要以更滾動性的方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148029/13.wav", + "text": "來思考一定要將醫療和照護" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148029/14.wav", + "text": "一起合併來討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148029/15.wav", + "text": "這樣子才比較實際" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148029/16.wav", + "text": "政府無法完全用稅收資源撐起長照" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148029/17.wav", + "text": "需要適度地開放引進民間資金" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148029/18.wav", + "text": "透過所謂的public-private partnership" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148029/19.wav", + "text": "同時強調一定是可以照顧到弱勢團體" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148029/20.wav", + "text": "同時也讓長照的產業跟社福的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148029/21.wav", + "text": "不會引起衝突" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148029/22.wav", + "text": "去年衛福部的李麗芬次長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148029/23.wav", + "text": "衛福部正在研究長照機構法人條例的修法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148029/24.wav", + "text": "也希望鼓勵民間與政府一起推動長照" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148029/25.wav", + "text": "這個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148029/26.wav", + "text": "還是有一些問題必須要去解決" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148029/27.wav", + "text": "因為之前在談這個的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148029/28.wav", + "text": "是不是能夠將資金投入到長照的領域裡面來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148029/29.wav", + "text": "現在來講的話好像壽險業者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148029/30.wav", + "text": "目前的動機沒有那麼強" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148029/31.wav", + "text": "所以這個議題就有一點擱置下來了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148029/32.wav", + "text": "不只是壽險業的資源" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148029/33.wav", + "text": "據我瞭解在衛福部與金管會的同意下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148029/34.wav", + "text": "去年開始推動長照產業的IPO" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148029/35.wav", + "text": "本席認為引進民間資源不僅能促進長照的量能發展" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148029/36.wav", + "text": "同時也提供適度的產業競爭" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148029/37.wav", + "text": "以及公開發行後更透明的公司治理方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148029/38.wav", + "text": "這樣也會對長照的服務跟業者更有幫助" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148029/39.wav", + "text": "\n對於財團化壟斷還有利益導向的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148029/40.wav", + "text": "本席認為可以參考部分歐洲國家的先例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148029/41.wav", + "text": "用適當的規範與制度同時讓產業能夠健康發展" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148029/42.wav", + "text": "民眾的長照資源和健康利益也可以受到保障" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148029/43.wav", + "text": "\n在長照機構公開發行的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148029/44.wav", + "text": "本席也希望衛福部和金管會持續合作" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148029/45.wav", + "text": "消除社會的疑慮並且推動長照注入活水" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148029/46.wav", + "text": "衛福部跟金管會推動長照產業的規劃" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148029/47.wav", + "text": "是否可以在兩週內給本席一份書面報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148029/48.wav", + "text": "給這個報告應該是沒有問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148029/49.wav", + "text": "不過我在這邊稍微跟委員報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148029/50.wav", + "text": "目前的話產業要進入到長照領域" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148029/51.wav", + "text": "我們並沒有阻擋是可以的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148029/52.wav", + "text": "它對於成本的控制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148029/53.wav", + "text": "它會比較快速" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148029/54.wav", + "text": "它有這個好處" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148029/55.wav", + "text": "不過缺點就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148029/56.wav", + "text": "我們要去注意的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148029/57.wav", + "text": "第一個就是透明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148029/58.wav", + "text": "也就是說價格上面對於消費者要非常的透明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148029/59.wav", + "text": "這是第一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148029/60.wav", + "text": "第二個如果它的收入來源" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148029/61.wav", + "text": "也就是說要用到我們長照2.0的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148029/62.wav", + "text": "它要接受我們的稽核" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148029/63.wav", + "text": "大概是這兩個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148029/64.wav", + "text": "接下來要與部長討論的是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148029/65.wav", + "text": "保險制不是私保而是公保" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148029/66.wav", + "text": "在推動這個長照基金賦稅制的長照" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148029/67.wav", + "text": "財源是來自於稅收" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148029/68.wav", + "text": "因此財源會不穩定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148029/69.wav", + "text": "然後有服務受限於預算的情形" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148029/70.wav", + "text": "學習日本的保險制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148029/71.wav", + "text": "或使用付費者模式可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148029/72.wav", + "text": "解決財源不穩定的受限問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148029/73.wav", + "text": "介護保險法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148029/74.wav", + "text": "醫療資源與照護" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148029/75.wav", + "text": "它是每三年定期修法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148029/76.wav", + "text": "然後對社會經濟做出一些改變" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148029/77.wav", + "text": "本席想瞭解的是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148029/78.wav", + "text": "部長有什麼樣的想法嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148029/79.wav", + "text": "大家可以來做一些討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148029/80.wav", + "text": "跟我們目前用的稅收制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148029/81.wav", + "text": "這兩個的優缺點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148029/82.wav", + "text": "是可以討論的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148029/83.wav", + "text": "像貴黨提出來的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148029/84.wav", + "text": "來建這個長照保險的內容" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148029/85.wav", + "text": "我還沒有看到很詳細的規劃" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148029/86.wav", + "text": "也許這中間的規劃" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148029/87.wav", + "text": "大家可以再進一步的討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148029/88.wav", + "text": "就是說是不是一定要用保險" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148029/89.wav", + "text": "才能夠解決那些問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148029/90.wav", + "text": "好其實也是因為這樣子所" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148029/91.wav", + "text": "主權基金的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148029/92.wav", + "text": "在挪威和愛爾蘭" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148029/93.wav", + "text": "我就舉兩個例子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148029/94.wav", + "text": "貢獻政府的預算高達236億美元" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148029/95.wav", + "text": "愛爾蘭本身它用主權基金" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148029/96.wav", + "text": "它也講說因為針對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148029/97.wav", + "text": "人口老化的財務負擔" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148029/98.wav", + "text": "他們要建立這個主權基金" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148029/99.wav", + "text": "政府預算在未來不能持續地撥補" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148029/100.wav", + "text": "這是非常嚴重的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148029/101.wav", + "text": "\n很高興今天跟部長這邊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148029/102.wav", + "text": "還有希望跟財政部主計處" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148029/103.wav", + "text": "一起為長照持續發聲" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148029/104.wav", + "text": "謝謝您" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148029/105.wav", + "text": "我想這一個部分的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148029/106.wav", + "text": "不論是將來有一個主權基金" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148029/107.wav", + "text": "要來挹注" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148029/108.wav", + "text": "還是說用其他的方法來處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148029/109.wav", + "text": "我們的財務一直都是公開透明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148029/110.wav", + "text": "到哪一天出問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148029/111.wav", + "text": "那這個一定是要跟立法院一起來討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148029/112.wav", + "text": "因為我們可能就要另闢財源" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148029/113.wav", + "text": "是從稅收還是在其他的地方" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148029/114.wav", + "text": "都一定是要通過立法院的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148029/115.wav", + "text": "好謝謝部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148029/116.wav", + "text": "謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148028/0.wav", + "text": "我今天排這個議程主要是我上個會期" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148028/1.wav", + "text": "對國土規劃有一些看法跟意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148028/2.wav", + "text": "所以這次特別排這個議程要跟你們來做一些討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148028/3.wav", + "text": "當時因為是經濟委員會的質詢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148028/4.wav", + "text": "所以內政部可能沒有看到我的質詢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148028/5.wav", + "text": "對很多農業縣市都是不公平" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148028/6.wav", + "text": "民生用水或是灌溉用水" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148028/7.wav", + "text": "以及糧食安全你剛剛講的糧食" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148028/8.wav", + "text": "這是屬於國安的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148028/9.wav", + "text": "也是國發會比較關心的議題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148028/10.wav", + "text": "但是糧食自給率是農業長期的目標" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148028/11.wav", + "text": "我了解你的意思" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148028/12.wav", + "text": "很多水源的保護區" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148028/13.wav", + "text": "因為我們的管制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148028/14.wav", + "text": "所以沒有辦法種植" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148028/15.wav", + "text": "也沒有辦法蓋房子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148028/16.wav", + "text": "你們有沒有想過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148028/17.wav", + "text": "十幾年來或是幾百年來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148028/18.wav", + "text": "他們生活在這個地方" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148028/19.wav", + "text": "他們一直都是弱勢之所在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148028/20.wav", + "text": "都是提供給都市人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148028/21.wav", + "text": "讓他們將來的經濟生活過得更好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148028/22.wav", + "text": "實際上臺灣的經濟發展" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148028/23.wav", + "text": "山坡地那些人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148028/24.wav", + "text": "供給了全國的資源" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148028/25.wav", + "text": "才有臺灣今天的經濟" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148028/26.wav", + "text": "或是一個比較公平正義的角度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148028/27.wav", + "text": "去看這樣事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148028/28.wav", + "text": "就是這樣要怎麼樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148028/29.wav", + "text": "達到一個和諧公平正義的社會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148028/30.wav", + "text": "假設今天的國土規劃" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148028/31.wav", + "text": "是一個不公平的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148028/32.wav", + "text": "或是不應該有的轉型正義" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148028/33.wav", + "text": "不正義的轉型" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148028/34.wav", + "text": "糧食供給率要80萬公頃" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148028/35.wav", + "text": "占百分之十" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148028/36.wav", + "text": "8萬公頃" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148028/37.wav", + "text": "嘉義縣7萬多公頃也占百分之十" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148028/38.wav", + "text": "臺南縣也占百分之十" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148028/39.wav", + "text": "屏東縣占百分之十" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148028/40.wav", + "text": "這4個縣市都占" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148028/41.wav", + "text": "占總管制量的百分之十" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148028/42.wav", + "text": "你們都沒看到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148028/43.wav", + "text": "你們有沒有去想" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148028/44.wav", + "text": "要怎麼做公平正義的轉型" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148028/45.wav", + "text": "你們是不正義的轉型" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148028/46.wav", + "text": "你們都是為土地建築為那些城鄉發展區" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148028/47.wav", + "text": "嗎地方農地的這些事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148028/48.wav", + "text": "你們有去解決" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148028/49.wav", + "text": "嗎有在哪些地方幫他們處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148028/50.wav", + "text": "嗎我覺得都沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148028/51.wav", + "text": "不是轉型正義" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148028/52.wav", + "text": "你們是不是應該針對現有的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148028/53.wav", + "text": "今天國土規劃最重要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148028/54.wav", + "text": "的當然是國土的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148028/55.wav", + "text": "資源要怎麼去劃" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148028/56.wav", + "text": "農地的部分要怎麼去劃" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148028/57.wav", + "text": "利用這次國土規劃來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148028/58.wav", + "text": "來做一個整體的規劃" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148028/59.wav", + "text": "現有的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148028/60.wav", + "text": "三七五的部分要怎麼處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148028/61.wav", + "text": "或是國一國二國三" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148028/62.wav", + "text": "這些人你們有沒有一套公平正義" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148028/63.wav", + "text": "對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148028/64.wav", + "text": "你們幾十年來就只是套圖" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148028/65.wav", + "text": "這幾十年來的變化" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148028/66.wav", + "text": "這些長期提供勞力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148028/67.wav", + "text": "提供糧食提供水" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148028/68.wav", + "text": "給我們吃的鄉下小孩傻" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148028/69.wav", + "text": "你們要怎麼保障他" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148028/70.wav", + "text": "我看不到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148028/71.wav", + "text": "嘛整個國土規劃" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148028/72.wav", + "text": "看不到這些東西" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148028/73.wav", + "text": "謝謝委員的指教" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148028/74.wav", + "text": "我想國土計畫這一次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148028/75.wav", + "text": "最主要目的就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148028/76.wav", + "text": "把原本非都市土地" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148028/77.wav", + "text": "用管制的手法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148028/78.wav", + "text": "您剛剛談的很多面向" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148028/79.wav", + "text": "例如有水源區的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148028/80.wav", + "text": "畫能做的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148028/81.wav", + "text": "合法的農業使用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148028/82.wav", + "text": "這些我們要在這次的國土計畫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148028/83.wav", + "text": "做一些整理跟保障" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148028/84.wav", + "text": "您剛剛談的很多面向" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148028/85.wav", + "text": "甚至國有地的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148028/86.wav", + "text": "有賴於其他相關的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148028/87.wav", + "text": "各機關來共同做一個處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148028/88.wav", + "text": "居住的正義" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148028/89.wav", + "text": "祖先就住在那裡了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148028/90.wav", + "text": "我們要利用這個的機會解決" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148028/91.wav", + "text": "第二個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148028/92.wav", + "text": "我們對將來的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148028/93.wav", + "text": "我們在講地方創新" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148028/94.wav", + "text": "你們要怎麼在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148028/95.wav", + "text": "像統籌分配稅" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148028/96.wav", + "text": "我相信統籌分配稅你們也沒考慮到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148028/97.wav", + "text": "面積部分要怎麼去補強" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148028/98.wav", + "text": "你們也沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148028/99.wav", + "text": "地方其實可以規劃一些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148028/100.wav", + "text": "城鄉發展區" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148028/101.wav", + "text": "居住上有困難的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148028/102.wav", + "text": "怎樣去規劃" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148028/103.wav", + "text": "讓他們有一個適當的地方" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148028/104.wav", + "text": "和安居" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148028/105.wav", + "text": "最起碼要解決這些問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148028/106.wav", + "text": "不然你們有什麼意義" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148028/107.wav", + "text": "我請教你們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148028/108.wav", + "text": "在國土規劃有什麼意義" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148028/109.wav", + "text": "比如說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148028/110.wav", + "text": "既有的農業使用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148028/111.wav", + "text": "既有的建築使用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148028/112.wav", + "text": "我想這一次在國土計畫有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148028/113.wav", + "text": "很多民眾都會誤解" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148028/114.wav", + "text": "好像納到國土計畫之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148028/115.wav", + "text": "他就不能再建築使用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148028/116.wav", + "text": "其實不會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148028/117.wav", + "text": "是從事原來的建築使用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148028/118.wav", + "text": "我們還是會讓他繼續做建築使用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148028/119.wav", + "text": "我知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148028/120.wav", + "text": "這一些我們都有去顧慮到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148028/121.wav", + "text": "地方的感受" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148028/122.wav", + "text": "你們都有去解決" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148028/123.wav", + "text": "對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148028/124.wav", + "text": "農地的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148028/125.wav", + "text": "你們要如何解決" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148028/126.wav", + "text": "後他的家要怎麼辦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148028/127.wav", + "text": "他還是可以維持原來的使用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148028/128.wav", + "text": "把這一次國土規劃" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148028/129.wav", + "text": "面臨到的所有問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148028/130.wav", + "text": "我希望你們一次好好檢討" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148028/131.wav", + "text": "然後告訴我們將來要怎麼做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148028/132.wav", + "text": "這是第一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148028/133.wav", + "text": "做的到嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148028/134.wav", + "text": "這個沒問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148028/135.wav", + "text": "我們會讓民眾來充分瞭解" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148028/136.wav", + "text": "我就不瞭解" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148028/137.wav", + "text": "就是因為我不瞭解" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148028/138.wav", + "text": "第二點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148028/139.wav", + "text": "因為你們還是堅持要114年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148028/140.wav", + "text": "但是距離114年公告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148028/141.wav", + "text": "本來是109年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148028/142.wav", + "text": "現在我們延後1年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148028/143.wav", + "text": "要把事情做好比較重要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148028/144.wav", + "text": "而不是急著要在114年公告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148028/145.wav", + "text": "這是我的看法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148028/146.wav", + "text": "所以我要請教" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148028/147.wav", + "text": "最近有人說嘉義縣有一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148028/148.wav", + "text": "農村的整體規劃" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148028/149.wav", + "text": "我請教你" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148028/150.wav", + "text": "農村的整體規劃" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148028/151.wav", + "text": "有符合你們整個程序嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148028/152.wav", + "text": "謝謝委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148028/153.wav", + "text": "其實國土計畫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148028/154.wav", + "text": "114年4月之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148028/155.wav", + "text": "國土計畫也可以通盤檢討" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148028/156.wav", + "text": "你剛談的那個是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148028/157.wav", + "text": "鄉村地區的整體規劃" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148028/158.wav", + "text": "其實只要各地方政府來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148028/159.wav", + "text": "我們都有提供一些補助" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148028/160.wav", + "text": "讓他們來做這個研究" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148028/161.wav", + "text": "鄉村整體規劃完成之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148028/162.wav", + "text": "於特殊土地使用的管制規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148028/163.wav", + "text": "都可以由地方政府來做一個處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148028/164.wav", + "text": "我覺得這是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148028/165.wav", + "text": "很重要的一個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148028/166.wav", + "text": "就是將近一二年的時間裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148028/167.wav", + "text": "你應該把像這種東西" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148028/168.wav", + "text": "假設你真的可以讓他們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148028/169.wav", + "text": "去做一個鄉村的整體規劃" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148028/170.wav", + "text": "訴他們現在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148028/171.wav", + "text": "我們可以用鄉村整體規劃" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148028/172.wav", + "text": "在這個情形下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148028/173.wav", + "text": "你沒有廣為宣導" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148028/174.wav", + "text": "到現在為止大家會人心惶惶" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148028/175.wav", + "text": "啦你說後續還有很多配套措施要做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148028/176.wav", + "text": "你要把這些廣為宣導" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148028/177.wav", + "text": "是不是我們就再繼續" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148028/178.wav", + "text": "跟各地方政府來協助" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148028/179.wav", + "text": "縣市政府有的有做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148028/180.wav", + "text": "地方都有政治的關係" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148028/181.wav", + "text": "有的都是他的人用一用而已" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148028/182.wav", + "text": "所以我的意思" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148028/183.wav", + "text": "次長我今天要跟你講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148028/184.wav", + "text": "你找個時間把這些東西" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148028/185.wav", + "text": "好好的整理一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148028/186.wav", + "text": "我希望帶你們下鄉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148028/187.wav", + "text": "來山區看看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148028/188.wav", + "text": "我們再給它一點時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148028/189.wav", + "text": "做一個通盤的解決" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148028/190.wav", + "text": "我們希望的是一個轉型正義" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148028/191.wav", + "text": "而不是不正義的轉型" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148028/192.wav", + "text": "這是我的願望" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148028/193.wav", + "text": "謝謝委員沒問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148028/194.wav", + "text": "次長我今天跟你講的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148028/195.wav", + "text": "然後給我一份資料" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148028/196.wav", + "text": "我也要找個時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148028/197.wav", + "text": "再跟你好好談一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148028/198.wav", + "text": "好謝謝謝謝委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148027/0.wav", + "text": "剩下79天就要投票了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148027/1.wav", + "text": "有沒有能力確保一個公平公正乾淨的選舉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148027/2.wav", + "text": "我們絕對全力以赴" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148027/3.wav", + "text": "現在最高檢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148027/4.wav", + "text": "也統合了所有的檢警調廉以及移民" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148027/5.wav", + "text": "各個單位通力合作" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148027/6.wav", + "text": "來防堵所有妨害選舉的案件" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148027/7.wav", + "text": "部長你剛剛也講說嚴懲就是最具體的宣導" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148027/8.wav", + "text": "那我們就來看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148027/9.wav", + "text": "看你們能夠嚴懲" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148027/10.wav", + "text": "然後真的能具體" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148027/11.wav", + "text": "落實你們在這邊所承諾的這些事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148027/12.wav", + "text": "今天的報告我大概看了一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148027/13.wav", + "text": "其實文章寫得蠻漂亮的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148027/14.wav", + "text": "係民主政治及國家廉能之基石" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148027/15.wav", + "text": "要全力防制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148027/16.wav", + "text": "包括賄選暴力境外勢力假訊息" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148027/17.wav", + "text": "等等秉持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148027/18.wav", + "text": "無底線無上限無時限" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148027/19.wav", + "text": "心再來報告中也提到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148027/20.wav", + "text": "檢察機關將積極指揮司法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148027/21.wav", + "text": "警察機關從嚴從速偵辦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148027/22.wav", + "text": "防止大選期間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148027/23.wav", + "text": "假訊息影響選情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148027/24.wav", + "text": "並及時通報刪除下架" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148027/25.wav", + "text": "這些你們都寫得很清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148027/26.wav", + "text": "結論再度強調" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148027/27.wav", + "text": "我國為高度民主法治國家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148027/28.wav", + "text": "乾淨的選舉是國家廉能之基石" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148027/29.wav", + "text": "老實講我百分之百同意你們報告所寫的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148027/30.wav", + "text": "百分之百同意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148027/31.wav", + "text": "但是怎麼做做得到嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148027/32.wav", + "text": "所以我開宗明義也問你" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148027/33.wav", + "text": "你們有沒有能力確保" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148027/34.wav", + "text": "我在這邊跟部長再回顧一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148027/35.wav", + "text": "這個月我兩次總質詢提出來的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148027/36.wav", + "text": "議題10月3日預算總質詢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148027/37.wav", + "text": "我問陳建仁院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148027/38.wav", + "text": "院長說立法院立法委員審查國家預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148027/39.wav", + "text": "是法定職責" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148027/40.wav", + "text": "國防部長邱國正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148027/41.wav", + "text": "當場也說潛艦預算是公開預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148027/42.wav", + "text": "從108年到今天都是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148027/43.wav", + "text": "昨天包括現在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148027/44.wav", + "text": "隔壁委員會在審查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148027/45.wav", + "text": "的潛艦預算就是公開預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148027/46.wav", + "text": "公開審查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148027/47.wav", + "text": "這個是部長都有講的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148027/48.wav", + "text": "10月6日施政總質詢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148027/49.wav", + "text": "我再度詢問" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148027/50.wav", + "text": "說我平常問政理性認真" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148027/51.wav", + "text": "從來沒有阻礙過國防的發展" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148027/52.wav", + "text": "也很支持國防" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148027/53.wav", + "text": "這是有國會紀錄的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148027/54.wav", + "text": "所以不管是邱部長也好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148027/55.wav", + "text": "他們確認了第一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148027/56.wav", + "text": "審查預算問政" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148027/57.wav", + "text": "本來就都是立委的法定職責" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148027/58.wav", + "text": "然後呢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148027/59.wav", + "text": "我有沒有擋國防" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148027/60.wav", + "text": "沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148027/61.wav", + "text": "是支持國防" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148027/62.wav", + "text": "而且依法行使我立委的職責" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148027/63.wav", + "text": "我擋潛艦阻國防的看板" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148027/64.wav", + "text": "當天我也質詢了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148027/65.wav", + "text": "部長你在場你承諾" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148027/66.wav", + "text": "尤其在選舉期間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148027/67.wav", + "text": "為了維持選舉的公平" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148027/68.wav", + "text": "會要求各地檢署" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148027/69.wav", + "text": "落實選舉查察工作" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148027/70.wav", + "text": "請問他們掛這樣的看板" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148027/71.wav", + "text": "到底是不是假訊息" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148027/72.wav", + "text": "跟委員說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148027/73.wav", + "text": "委員指教的那個個案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148027/74.wav", + "text": "轉交給承辦檢察機關處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148027/75.wav", + "text": "所以個案應該都已經在處理當中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148027/76.wav", + "text": "結果呢這個事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148027/77.wav", + "text": "不但現在還存在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148027/78.wav", + "text": "10月23日民進黨中央" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148027/79.wav", + "text": "甚至直接開記者會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148027/80.wav", + "text": "發布CF" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148027/81.wav", + "text": "然後說我賣國" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148027/82.wav", + "text": "請問部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148027/83.wav", + "text": "提案審查預算是賣國嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148027/84.wav", + "text": "是這樣嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148027/85.wav", + "text": "請問部長提案凍結預算是不是賣國" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148027/86.wav", + "text": "我尊重委員審查預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148027/87.wav", + "text": "時給我們行政單位的指教" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148027/88.wav", + "text": "那是不是賣國" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148027/89.wav", + "text": "我想沒有那麼嚴重" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148027/90.wav", + "text": "沒有那麼嚴重那是不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148027/91.wav", + "text": "是不是要由承辦的單位來認定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148027/92.wav", + "text": "我想審查預算本來就是委員的職權" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148027/93.wav", + "text": "對嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148027/94.wav", + "text": "他這樣子公然" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148027/95.wav", + "text": "宣稱而且現在民進黨中央的臉書上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148027/96.wav", + "text": "還一樣掛著" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148027/97.wav", + "text": "這不會影響選舉嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148027/98.wav", + "text": "這不是刻意影響選舉嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148027/99.wav", + "text": "請問你們講的乾淨選舉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148027/100.wav", + "text": "是講假的嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148027/101.wav", + "text": "這樣的事情你們都視而不見嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148027/102.wav", + "text": "是嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148027/103.wav", + "text": "如果是這樣的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148027/104.wav", + "text": "部長我剛剛就一直問你" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148027/105.wav", + "text": "提案凍結預算是不是賣國" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148027/106.wav", + "text": "你沒有辦法回答我" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148027/107.wav", + "text": "你說要看個案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148027/108.wav", + "text": "那我讓你看一些個案好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148027/109.wav", + "text": "這些都是個案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148027/110.wav", + "text": "從過去到現在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148027/111.wav", + "text": "潛艦F-16V新式高教機" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148027/112.wav", + "text": "提案的委員都在上面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148027/113.wav", + "text": "有藍綠兩黨還有無黨籍" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148027/114.wav", + "text": "通通都有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148027/115.wav", + "text": "通通都有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148027/116.wav", + "text": "來羅致政有沒有賣國" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148027/117.wav", + "text": "蔡適應有沒有賣國" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148027/118.wav", + "text": "林淑芬有沒有賣國" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148027/119.wav", + "text": "何欣純有沒有賣國" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148027/120.wav", + "text": "莊瑞雄有沒有賣國" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148027/121.wav", + "text": "從過去到現在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148027/122.wav", + "text": "潛艦案是20192020年的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148027/123.wav", + "text": "這些案子也都是過去34年的案子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148027/124.wav", + "text": "提案凍結預算等於賣國" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148027/125.wav", + "text": "我不接受" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148027/126.wav", + "text": "在這個選舉期間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148027/127.wav", + "text": "你們沒有任何作為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148027/128.wav", + "text": "耶如果提案凍結預算叫做賣國" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148027/129.wav", + "text": "這些人通通是賣國" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148027/130.wav", + "text": "更何況我們在第10屆第2會期" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148027/131.wav", + "text": "針對新式高教機的預算凍結案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148027/132.wav", + "text": "是跨黨派大家一起凍結" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148027/133.wav", + "text": "看看這個案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148027/134.wav", + "text": "藍綠無黨全部都在上面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148027/135.wav", + "text": "怎麼不拿出來講咧" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148027/136.wav", + "text": "怎麼選擇性的揭露咧" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148027/137.wav", + "text": "請問法務部及" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148027/138.wav", + "text": "在查察賄選" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148027/139.wav", + "text": "查察影響選舉的單位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148027/140.wav", + "text": "你們眼睛都瞎了嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148027/141.wav", + "text": "還是你們眼睛有顏色咧" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148027/142.wav", + "text": "什麼東西遮蔽了你們的眼睛呢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148027/143.wav", + "text": "為什麼可以任由這樣子的假訊息" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148027/144.wav", + "text": "不斷的放在那裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148027/145.wav", + "text": "部長我才要問你" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148027/146.wav", + "text": "是不是假訊息" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148027/147.wav", + "text": "如果是假訊息" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148027/148.wav", + "text": "就應該要立即處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148027/149.wav", + "text": "相關機關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148027/150.wav", + "text": "應該要瞭解整個選舉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148027/151.wav", + "text": "一定要秉持公平公正來處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148027/152.wav", + "text": "部長你剛剛的宣示" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148027/153.wav", + "text": "我覺得非常重要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148027/154.wav", + "text": "因為要看你們的決心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148027/155.wav", + "text": "嘛你剛剛講到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148027/156.wav", + "text": "到無限的決心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148027/157.wav", + "text": "意思就是說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148027/158.wav", + "text": "不管怎麼樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148027/159.wav", + "text": "就是要讓這一次的選舉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148027/160.wav", + "text": "部長是不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148027/161.wav", + "text": "絕對是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148027/162.wav", + "text": "你不要連這個都不敢講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148027/163.wav", + "text": "不會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148027/164.wav", + "text": "絕對會做到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148027/165.wav", + "text": "一定是這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148027/166.wav", + "text": "你的結論就講得很清楚啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148027/167.wav", + "text": "你就是要乾淨的選舉嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148027/168.wav", + "text": "你們列出來的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148027/169.wav", + "text": "那些干擾選舉的樣態" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148027/170.wav", + "text": "我剛剛都已經拿給你看了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148027/171.wav", + "text": "或許你會說這是個案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148027/172.wav", + "text": "但是我必須跟你講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148027/173.wav", + "text": "如果這些可以舉得出來的個案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148027/174.wav", + "text": "是現在進行式當中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148027/175.wav", + "text": "而你們都可以不處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148027/176.wav", + "text": "都可以視而不見的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148027/177.wav", + "text": "那你講的乾淨選舉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148027/178.wav", + "text": "還能相信嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148027/179.wav", + "text": "這是一般民眾都看得懂的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148027/180.wav", + "text": "也不用欺騙大家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148027/181.wav", + "text": "到底是不是乾淨選舉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148027/182.wav", + "text": "有沒有抹黑" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148027/183.wav", + "text": "哪些是事實" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148027/184.wav", + "text": "哪些是假" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148027/185.wav", + "text": "這個大家心裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148027/186.wav", + "text": "絕對有一把尺" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148027/187.wav", + "text": "但是當我們還相信" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148027/188.wav", + "text": "司法的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148027/189.wav", + "text": "你們應該要進行相關的查察工作" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148027/190.wav", + "text": "嘛否則所謂的防杜賄選也好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148027/191.wav", + "text": "公正選舉也好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148027/192.wav", + "text": "公平或是乾淨選舉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148027/193.wav", + "text": "就變成只是空口說白話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148027/194.wav", + "text": "本席在這邊絕對就事論事" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148027/195.wav", + "text": "我也希望法務部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148027/196.wav", + "text": "能夠依法行政該辦就辦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148027/197.wav", + "text": "否則今天的報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148027/198.wav", + "text": "所講的這些內容" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148027/199.wav", + "text": "真的就變成空口說白話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148027/200.wav", + "text": "而且完全違背了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148027/201.wav", + "text": "你們在裡面所作的相關宣示和承諾" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148027/202.wav", + "text": "司法單位存在的目的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148027/203.wav", + "text": "我們全力以赴" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148027/204.wav", + "text": "一定會按照部裡面的政策" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148027/205.wav", + "text": "來督促所有選舉查察的機關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148027/206.wav", + "text": "務必要公正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148027/207.wav", + "text": "都要一律依法處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148027/208.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148027/209.wav", + "text": "部長既然作這樣的宣示" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148027/210.wav", + "text": "那我們就看你剛剛所講的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148027/211.wav", + "text": "其實嚴查嚴懲就是最好的宣導" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148027/212.wav", + "text": "這個東西恐怕不是嘴巴講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148027/213.wav", + "text": "就好大家也在看你們具體做了哪一些事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148027/214.wav", + "text": "這次公平公正以及乾淨的選舉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148027/215.wav", + "text": "好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148027/216.wav", + "text": "好謝謝委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148027/217.wav", + "text": "謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148027/218.wav", + "text": "謝謝江啟臣委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148026/0.wav", + "text": "賴處長你好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148026/1.wav", + "text": "可能比較少請教你" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148026/2.wav", + "text": "可是你是國際業務處" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148026/3.wav", + "text": "我想請教一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148026/4.wav", + "text": "國際的事務你應該有相當研究" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148026/5.wav", + "text": "不敢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148026/6.wav", + "text": "截至目前為止" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148026/7.wav", + "text": "美國的公債大概發了多少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148026/8.wav", + "text": "大概有30兆美元" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148026/9.wav", + "text": "相當龐大的一個數字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148026/10.wav", + "text": "我們看到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148026/11.wav", + "text": "現在全世界到處都在戰爭" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148026/12.wav", + "text": "既然你上面是寫國際業務處" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148026/13.wav", + "text": "你有沒有詳細去了解" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148026/14.wav", + "text": "整個全世界的訊息是怎麼樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148026/15.wav", + "text": "美國國債那麼多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148026/16.wav", + "text": "它以後還得出來嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148026/17.wav", + "text": "還不出來的話怎麼辦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148026/18.wav", + "text": "會不會破產" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148026/19.wav", + "text": "在俄羅斯" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148026/20.wav", + "text": "曝險的部位是多少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148026/21.wav", + "text": "當初你們曾經給我個數字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148026/22.wav", + "text": "可是現在怎麼處理呢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148026/23.wav", + "text": "全部都爛帳一筆" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148026/24.wav", + "text": "你趕快準備數字給我" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148026/25.wav", + "text": "第三個問題就是以色列" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148026/26.wav", + "text": "在一個月前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148026/27.wav", + "text": "我問所有人沒有人說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148026/28.wav", + "text": "以色列會戰爭" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148026/29.wav", + "text": "以巴的衝突不可能會戰爭" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148026/30.wav", + "text": "實力懸殊那麼大" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148026/31.wav", + "text": "也戰了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148026/32.wav", + "text": "臺灣所有金融機構" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148026/33.wav", + "text": "在以色列" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148026/34.wav", + "text": "附近的曝險部位是多少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148026/35.wav", + "text": "請回答" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148026/36.wav", + "text": "謝謝委員的質詢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148026/37.wav", + "text": "這個部分的彙整" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148026/38.wav", + "text": "可以領導整個臺灣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148026/39.wav", + "text": "因為從香港反送中事件開始" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148026/40.wav", + "text": "我都一直期盼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148026/41.wav", + "text": "臺灣可以取代香港" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148026/42.wav", + "text": "成為亞太金融中心的地位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148026/43.wav", + "text": "像新加坡也好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148026/44.wav", + "text": "香港也好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148026/45.wav", + "text": "可是這一塊一直沒有充分的資訊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148026/46.wav", + "text": "讓金管會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148026/47.wav", + "text": "可以大幅度地" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148026/48.wav", + "text": "你都不答" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148026/49.wav", + "text": "報告委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148026/50.wav", + "text": "2019開始推高階資產管理業務" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148026/51.wav", + "text": "目前證券加銀行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148026/52.wav", + "text": "前兩天還核准一家新的財管銀行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148026/53.wav", + "text": "至於美國國債的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148026/54.wav", + "text": "其實美國的資本市場" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148026/55.wav", + "text": "還是相對非常健全" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148026/56.wav", + "text": "而且深度和廣度都夠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148026/57.wav", + "text": "所以我們的金融機構" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148026/58.wav", + "text": "尤其壽險業其實有一些投資" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148026/59.wav", + "text": "我們也相信以美國本身" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148026/60.wav", + "text": "在世界領導的地位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148026/61.wav", + "text": "我想它的債信是有一定的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148026/62.wav", + "text": "至於俄羅斯的曝險" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148026/63.wav", + "text": "以前有報告過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148026/64.wav", + "text": "其實保險業有一些投資" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148026/65.wav", + "text": "其實目前來講都還算正常" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148026/66.wav", + "text": "但是因為它有些支付管道被制裁" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148026/67.wav", + "text": "所以基本上還在觀察中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148026/68.wav", + "text": "並沒有特別大的損失" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148026/69.wav", + "text": "當初在俄羅斯跟烏克蘭的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148026/70.wav", + "text": "曝險部位是多少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148026/71.wav", + "text": "100兩百多億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148026/72.wav", + "text": "這個金額很大" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148026/73.wav", + "text": "100兩百多億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148026/74.wav", + "text": "現在因為制裁中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148026/75.wav", + "text": "保險公司是持有至到期日" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148026/76.wav", + "text": "所以只是現在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148026/77.wav", + "text": "付息沒有辦法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148026/78.wav", + "text": "拿回來的問題而已" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148026/79.wav", + "text": "不能拿回來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148026/80.wav", + "text": "的現在有幾家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148026/81.wav", + "text": "金額大概是多少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148026/82.wav", + "text": "這100兩百多億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148026/83.wav", + "text": "會不會全部成為泡沫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148026/84.wav", + "text": "你會計上怎麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148026/85.wav", + "text": "目前提列的預期信用損失" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148026/86.wav", + "text": "大概在190億元左右" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148026/87.wav", + "text": "那是抓多少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148026/88.wav", + "text": "會計公報的規定提列" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148026/89.wav", + "text": "就是考慮到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148026/90.wav", + "text": "利息沒有辦法馬上收回的這個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148026/91.wav", + "text": "是那這個也是有可能" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148026/92.wav", + "text": "以後都收不回來的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148026/93.wav", + "text": "報告委員這些記帳上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148026/94.wav", + "text": "都是持有至到期" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148026/95.wav", + "text": "不是用做trading的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148026/96.wav", + "text": "中有一些利息要收的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148026/97.wav", + "text": "因為被制裁" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148026/98.wav", + "text": "所以管道是被限制的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148026/99.wav", + "text": "拿不回來就有一個預期信用損失" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148026/100.wav", + "text": "他們當初投資的計價是用什麼單位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148026/101.wav", + "text": "還是俄羅斯" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148026/102.wav", + "text": "美元跟盧布都有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148026/103.wav", + "text": "盧布貶值很多啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148026/104.wav", + "text": "會有很多的損失" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148026/105.wav", + "text": "就產生了很大的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148026/106.wav", + "text": "危機出現" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148026/107.wav", + "text": "像以色列" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148026/108.wav", + "text": "它的曝險部位是多少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148026/109.wav", + "text": "1003百多億吧" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148026/110.wav", + "text": "這些都是億來億去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148026/111.wav", + "text": "本席現在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148026/112.wav", + "text": "要提的就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148026/113.wav", + "text": "一個新的危機" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148026/114.wav", + "text": "所有的保險業" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148026/115.wav", + "text": "投資海外的部位是有多少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148026/116.wav", + "text": "大概" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148026/117.wav", + "text": "22兆左右" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148026/118.wav", + "text": "有二十幾兆" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148026/119.wav", + "text": "那麼多的錢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148026/120.wav", + "text": "有沒有人在管理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148026/121.wav", + "text": "誰在管理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148026/122.wav", + "text": "裡面都管得到嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148026/123.wav", + "text": "我跟委員報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148026/124.wav", + "text": "我們有信評" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148026/125.wav", + "text": "評有額度的限制與管理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148026/126.wav", + "text": "在公司階層" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148026/127.wav", + "text": "看到特別是以色列戰爭以後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148026/128.wav", + "text": "臺灣的股市" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148026/129.wav", + "text": "跌跌不休" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148026/130.wav", + "text": "每天外資就是不斷地出去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148026/131.wav", + "text": "最近這一兩個月來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148026/132.wav", + "text": "外資跑出去多少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148026/133.wav", + "text": "這個我請證期局" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148026/134.wav", + "text": "張局長說明一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148026/135.wav", + "text": "近年來到現在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148026/136.wav", + "text": "其實整個是淨流入" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148026/137.wav", + "text": "多了107億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148026/138.wav", + "text": "進來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148026/139.wav", + "text": "外資反而是進來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148026/140.wav", + "text": "進出相抵之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148026/141.wav", + "text": "外資是進來一百零多億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148026/142.wav", + "text": "進來的是多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148026/143.wav", + "text": "好那為什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148026/144.wav", + "text": "最近整個股市的情況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148026/145.wav", + "text": "不是很穩定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148026/146.wav", + "text": "前幾個禮拜" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148026/147.wav", + "text": "美國聯準會對於未來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148026/148.wav", + "text": "升息或是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148026/149.wav", + "text": "維持現在利率的情況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148026/150.wav", + "text": "大家覺得高利率的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148026/151.wav", + "text": "時間可能比預期要久" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148026/152.wav", + "text": "另外有些是最近觀察" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148026/153.wav", + "text": "相關企業的財報" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148026/154.wav", + "text": "來講有些影響" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148026/155.wav", + "text": "包括這兩天美國" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148026/156.wav", + "text": "科技股的一些調整" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148026/157.wav", + "text": "大概都會影響到其他國家的股市" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148026/158.wav", + "text": "所以這樣的情況會持續惡化" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148026/159.wav", + "text": "我不敢預測股市不過的確現在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148026/160.wav", + "text": "市局是比較混亂一點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148026/161.wav", + "text": "因為包括中東的衝突" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148026/162.wav", + "text": "俄烏的衝突等等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148026/163.wav", + "text": "對之前有聽到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148026/164.wav", + "text": "因為明年1月13" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148026/165.wav", + "text": "就是總統大選" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148026/166.wav", + "text": "原本有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148026/167.wav", + "text": "此一說是要創造一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148026/168.wav", + "text": "選舉行情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148026/169.wav", + "text": "把股市拉到2萬點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148026/170.wav", + "text": "對執政黨來講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148026/171.wav", + "text": "比較好選" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148026/172.wav", + "text": "現在看起來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148026/173.wav", + "text": "這個選舉行情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148026/174.wav", + "text": "大概就破滅了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148026/175.wav", + "text": "報告委員我們監理官是維持市場秩序" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148026/176.wav", + "text": "沒有所謂的創造行情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148026/177.wav", + "text": "所以也沒有所謂的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148026/178.wav", + "text": "選舉行情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148026/179.wav", + "text": "金管會就是維持市場的秩序" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148026/180.wav", + "text": "其實美國" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148026/181.wav", + "text": "也都很清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148026/182.wav", + "text": "美國2024年底要選舉了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148026/183.wav", + "text": "選舉其實最重要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148026/184.wav", + "text": "就是經濟" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148026/185.wav", + "text": "經濟搞好民眾有感" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148026/186.wav", + "text": "要選舉都很好選" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148026/187.wav", + "text": "那這樣看起來跌跌不休" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148026/188.wav", + "text": "所以就是沒有選舉行情了是不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148026/189.wav", + "text": "前兩天股市也有漲" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148026/190.wav", + "text": "了也不是說都在跌" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148026/191.wav", + "text": "今天大概也是跌吧" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148026/192.wav", + "text": "對今天可能" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148026/193.wav", + "text": "盤勢影響" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148026/194.wav", + "text": "是再繞回來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148026/195.wav", + "text": "臺灣壽險公司" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148026/196.wav", + "text": "元如果把這些錢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148026/197.wav", + "text": "回到臺灣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148026/198.wav", + "text": "提供更多的就業跟工作機會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148026/199.wav", + "text": "不是很好嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148026/200.wav", + "text": "為什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148026/201.wav", + "text": "一直要把臺灣的這些錢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148026/202.wav", + "text": "趕出去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148026/203.wav", + "text": "全部集中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148026/204.wav", + "text": "在這幾家大金控身上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148026/205.wav", + "text": "會不會有危險" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148026/206.wav", + "text": "報告委員其實保險公司" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148026/207.wav", + "text": "要投資海外也有一些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148026/208.wav", + "text": "結構的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148026/209.wav", + "text": "因為國內固定收益市場的深度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148026/210.wav", + "text": "廣度不夠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148026/211.wav", + "text": "所以保險公司才會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148026/212.wav", + "text": "去投資海外" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148026/213.wav", + "text": "也要承擔一些匯率的風險" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148026/214.wav", + "text": "是這些都是金融方面的操作" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148026/215.wav", + "text": "主委您知道現在留職停薪的人數" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148026/216.wav", + "text": "有多少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148026/217.wav", + "text": "有一些提示" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148026/218.wav", + "text": "我不敢確定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148026/219.wav", + "text": "人數相當多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148026/220.wav", + "text": "有沒有超過百萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148026/221.wav", + "text": "這個可能要勞動部他們才能知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148026/222.wav", + "text": "如果說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148026/223.wav", + "text": "這22兆不要去投資" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148026/224.wav", + "text": "臺灣是不是可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148026/225.wav", + "text": "的就業機會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148026/226.wav", + "text": "天期跟收益都要跟" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148026/227.wav", + "text": "保單的發行相互匹配" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148026/228.wav", + "text": "如果沒有這種商品" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148026/229.wav", + "text": "保單匹配" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148026/230.wav", + "text": "天期跟收益" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148026/231.wav", + "text": "那請問保險公司會不會倒" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148026/232.wav", + "text": "保險公司目前都在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148026/233.wav", + "text": "我們穩定的管理中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148026/234.wav", + "text": "不會有特別的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148026/235.wav", + "text": "所以就是博弈" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148026/236.wav", + "text": "全部選擇" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148026/237.wav", + "text": "的方向都是在這幾家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148026/238.wav", + "text": "金控身上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148026/239.wav", + "text": "如果平安無事" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148026/240.wav", + "text": "哇又是一個天大的災難" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148026/241.wav", + "text": "報告委員金融穩定是金管會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148026/242.wav", + "text": "最重要的責任" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148026/243.wav", + "text": "有多少人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148026/244.wav", + "text": "一百零多人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148026/245.wav", + "text": "一百零多人要管50兆怎麼管" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148026/246.wav", + "text": "管好一點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148026/247.wav", + "text": "好各位請回" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148025/0.wav", + "text": "謝謝主席" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148025/1.wav", + "text": "內政部次長和國土管理署署長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148025/2.wav", + "text": "主委國土計畫法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148025/3.wav", + "text": "這件事情會有變化嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148025/4.wav", + "text": "謝謝委員的指導" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148025/5.wav", + "text": "這個鹽業用地" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148025/6.wav", + "text": "未來你們會區分為哪一類" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148025/7.wav", + "text": "當時有的是鹽有的是養" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148025/8.wav", + "text": "養所以我們還是會按照真實的使用區分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148025/9.wav", + "text": "有的是國保有的是農二也有的是農一" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148025/10.wav", + "text": "這當然按照地方政府的要求都是不太一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148025/11.wav", + "text": "所以你們可能還會區分很多塊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148025/12.wav", + "text": "未來鹽業用地還有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148025/13.wav", + "text": "以目前來講地方政府提出來的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148025/14.wav", + "text": "大概除了觀光使用的以外" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148025/15.wav", + "text": "觀光使用的當然就是鹽" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148025/16.wav", + "text": "鹽業用地跟濕地是高度重疊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148025/17.wav", + "text": "如果不在濕地範圍內的鹽業用地" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148025/18.wav", + "text": "你們打算怎麼規劃" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148025/19.wav", + "text": "我們會看地方政府拿出來的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148025/20.wav", + "text": "因為地方政府現在還沒完成審議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148025/21.wav", + "text": "呢我的意思是鹽" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148025/22.wav", + "text": "就像我剛剛講的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148025/23.wav", + "text": "有部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148025/24.wav", + "text": "轉做養殖" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148025/25.wav", + "text": "讓它地目合法化" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148025/26.wav", + "text": "因為轉做養殖是違法養殖" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148025/27.wav", + "text": "對對啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148025/28.wav", + "text": "因為你們對鹽業用地" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148025/29.wav", + "text": "沒有一個清楚的定義" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148025/30.wav", + "text": "如果有這樣的土地適合養殖" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148025/31.wav", + "text": "他就是要養殖" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148025/32.wav", + "text": "\n如果是真正道地的鹽業用地" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148025/33.wav", + "text": "你們要做什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148025/34.wav", + "text": "濕地再擴大" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148025/35.wav", + "text": "然後再把它變成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148025/36.wav", + "text": "這跟濕地是比較沒有關係" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148025/37.wav", + "text": "跟那個沒有關係" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148025/38.wav", + "text": "當然我們在這裡不是說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148025/39.wav", + "text": "要把它放到變濕地" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148025/40.wav", + "text": "使用如果沒有辦法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148025/41.wav", + "text": "之後進入到國土保育" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148025/42.wav", + "text": "保護海岸的功能時這" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148025/43.wav", + "text": "時這部分當然還是要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148025/44.wav", + "text": "進行一些保育" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148025/45.wav", + "text": "所以鹽業用地變成國土保育" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148025/46.wav", + "text": "這個也不對吧" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148025/47.wav", + "text": "它是一個土地" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148025/48.wav", + "text": "這個政府是矛盾的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148025/49.wav", + "text": "龔主委要思考一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148025/50.wav", + "text": "鹽業用地未來的出路" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148025/51.wav", + "text": "就是走向光電" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148025/52.wav", + "text": "至比所謂的漁電共生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148025/53.wav", + "text": "還要適合" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148025/54.wav", + "text": "那就是走向光電" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148025/55.wav", + "text": "你們竟然就棄" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148025/56.wav", + "text": "這些鹽業用地不用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148025/57.wav", + "text": "我現在不是在講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148025/58.wav", + "text": "濕地範圍內的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148025/59.wav", + "text": "我是在講有好大的鹽業用地" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148025/60.wav", + "text": "你們卻沒有讓它發揮效果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148025/61.wav", + "text": "政府現在也不可能" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148025/62.wav", + "text": "恢復曬鹽" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148025/63.wav", + "text": "鹽不可能恢復曬鹽" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148025/64.wav", + "text": "棄置不用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148025/65.wav", + "text": "這件事是錯的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148025/66.wav", + "text": "還是你們有辦法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148025/67.wav", + "text": "在鹽業用地" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148025/68.wav", + "text": "做有效的開發利用行為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148025/69.wav", + "text": "我看也不適合" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148025/70.wav", + "text": "其實光電這件事情是尊重" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148025/71.wav", + "text": "如果能源署有規劃" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148025/72.wav", + "text": "我覺得國土管理署" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148025/73.wav", + "text": "應該要大力捍衛這件事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148025/74.wav", + "text": "計畫你們幾乎都是打退堂鼓\n" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148025/75.wav", + "text": "教經濟部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148025/76.wav", + "text": "我們現在推動的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148025/77.wav", + "text": "事實上我們知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148025/78.wav", + "text": "整套的工廠管理輔導辦法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148025/79.wav", + "text": "母法是由立法委員訂定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148025/80.wav", + "text": "之後你們再去訂子法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148025/81.wav", + "text": "但是子法很多條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148025/82.wav", + "text": "讓一家依工輔法申請的工廠走下去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148025/83.wav", + "text": "如果不能走下去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148025/84.wav", + "text": "第一個就是農業產業群聚的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148025/85.wav", + "text": "不少的相關案件在一一討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148025/86.wav", + "text": "就必須要有隔離綠帶" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148025/87.wav", + "text": "沒有規劃隔離綠帶" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148025/88.wav", + "text": "甚至這個廠房在興" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148025/89.wav", + "text": "興建的時候就已經長在那邊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148025/90.wav", + "text": "該廠房也不會影響到旁邊的農地" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148025/91.wav", + "text": "如果是這樣的情況下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148025/92.wav", + "text": "就只能逼得他拆廠房" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148025/93.wav", + "text": "把他的天車打掉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148025/94.wav", + "text": "把他的廠房拆掉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148025/95.wav", + "text": "這個是你們的目的嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148025/96.wav", + "text": "那不是我們的目的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148025/97.wav", + "text": "未登工廠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148025/98.wav", + "text": "安全的防範上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148025/99.wav", + "text": "我們的用意是這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148025/100.wav", + "text": "至於與現在廠房之間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148025/101.wav", + "text": "所以在這個面向上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148025/102.wav", + "text": "生產製造的程序" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148025/103.wav", + "text": "再做適當的處理委員剛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148025/104.wav", + "text": "不能有水污" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148025/105.wav", + "text": "污消防也必須要做好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148025/106.wav", + "text": "這些前提條件如果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148025/107.wav", + "text": "一一被落實後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148025/108.wav", + "text": "而必須把工廠打掉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148025/109.wav", + "text": "為了做隔離綠帶而必須把工廠打掉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148025/110.wav", + "text": "廠裡面的很多動線都要改變" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148025/111.wav", + "text": "都要被改變" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148025/112.wav", + "text": "所以這件事要檢��" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148025/113.wav", + "text": "我們應該檢討的就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148025/114.wav", + "text": "如果是既有的廠房" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148025/115.wav", + "text": "沒有隔離綠帶的規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148025/116.wav", + "text": "已經蓋到極限的情況下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148025/117.wav", + "text": "但是對這裡沒有造成污染" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148025/118.wav", + "text": "是不是可以讓它繼續生存" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148025/119.wav", + "text": "讓它還是可以把工輔" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148025/120.wav", + "text": "輔法走下去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148025/121.wav", + "text": "跟委員報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148025/122.wav", + "text": "因為這是一個程序" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148025/123.wav", + "text": "您也非常清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148025/124.wav", + "text": "會提改善計畫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148025/125.wav", + "text": "看了改善計畫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148025/126.wav", + "text": "才會涉及到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148025/127.wav", + "text": "這類型的案例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148025/128.wav", + "text": "是否有這種情況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148025/129.wav", + "text": "在改善計畫的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148025/130.wav", + "text": "我們就要掌握住" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148025/131.wav", + "text": "我們願意在第一時間來做掌握" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148025/132.wav", + "text": "沒有錯" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148025/133.wav", + "text": "但是改善計畫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148025/134.wav", + "text": "他們提不出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148025/135.wav", + "text": "就是因為隔離綠帶" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148025/136.wav", + "text": "還不涉及隔離綠帶雖然" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148025/137.wav", + "text": "改善計畫還不涉及隔離綠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148025/138.wav", + "text": "總會有這個問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148025/139.wav", + "text": "啊這個問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148025/140.wav", + "text": "是不是可以在改善計畫中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148025/141.wav", + "text": "以及它的安全性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148025/142.wav", + "text": "是有所彈性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148025/143.wav", + "text": "而不是被1.5米" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148025/144.wav", + "text": "這件事情有可能嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148025/145.wav", + "text": "應該是在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148025/146.wav", + "text": "在改善計畫的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148025/147.wav", + "text": "再一家一家看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148025/148.wav", + "text": "因為改善計畫是一家一家提出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148025/149.wav", + "text": "沒關係改善計畫每一家都要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148025/150.wav", + "text": "做到符合標準" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148025/151.wav", + "text": "這部分他們要投資成本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148025/152.wav", + "text": "這我們都贊成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148025/153.wav", + "text": "他要付出" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148025/154.wav", + "text": "一定要把消防做好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148025/155.wav", + "text": "這都是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148025/156.wav", + "text": "但是總是會有走到最後一步" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148025/157.wav", + "text": "卡到1.5米的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148025/158.wav", + "text": "在改善計畫的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148025/159.wav", + "text": "就要能及早發現這一類" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148025/160.wav", + "text": "案例然後在改善計畫的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148025/161.wav", + "text": "來看他怎麼去做處理最適當" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148025/162.wav", + "text": "改善計畫的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148025/163.wav", + "text": "必須要做到盡善盡美" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148025/164.wav", + "text": "1.5米就不是那麼僵硬了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148025/165.wav", + "text": "是不是這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148025/166.wav", + "text": "必須一個一個個案來看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148025/167.wav", + "text": "做最適當的處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148025/168.wav", + "text": "我理解這句話的意思" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148025/169.wav", + "text": "在個案的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148025/170.wav", + "text": "我們就看改善計畫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148025/171.wav", + "text": "怎麼去說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148025/172.wav", + "text": "這樣好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148025/173.wav", + "text": "是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148025/174.wav", + "text": "好謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148024/0.wav", + "text": "部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148024/1.wav", + "text": "大家辛苦了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148024/2.wav", + "text": "先問候一下真的太辛苦了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148024/3.wav", + "text": "好今天這個議題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148024/4.wav", + "text": "大概不到80天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148024/5.wav", + "text": "所以我們看到臺灣的天空" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148024/6.wav", + "text": "彌漫著很不尋常的氣氛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148024/7.wav", + "text": "比如說我們看到郭台銘的案子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148024/8.wav", + "text": "他已經被中共那邊做全面的查稅" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148024/9.wav", + "text": "一天市值就蒸發了321億人民幣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148024/10.wav", + "text": "這對郭台銘的鴻海來講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148024/11.wav", + "text": "真的是會動搖到他們的資本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148024/12.wav", + "text": "所以對他的殺傷力是非常強" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148024/13.wav", + "text": "已經影響到臺灣民主自由的選舉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148024/14.wav", + "text": "\n看到這樣的情況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148024/15.wav", + "text": "我們可以回想一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148024/16.wav", + "text": "從2020年開始" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148024/17.wav", + "text": "中共就已經是用COVID-19" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148024/18.wav", + "text": "開始放毒給全世界" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148024/19.wav", + "text": "現在又一系列地布局全球做侵略的行動" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148024/20.wav", + "text": "第二年快兩年了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148024/21.wav", + "text": "現在又有一個以哈戰爭" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148024/22.wav", + "text": "它是全面的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148024/23.wav", + "text": "尤其是我們臺灣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148024/24.wav", + "text": "現在我們直接的敵對國家就是中共" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148024/25.wav", + "text": "很明顯" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148024/26.wav", + "text": "到哪一邊都是中共的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148024/27.wav", + "text": "\n其實我們看到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148024/28.wav", + "text": "臺灣和中共" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148024/29.wav", + "text": "我們知道這個問題已經很久了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148024/30.wav", + "text": "臺灣首當其衝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148024/31.wav", + "text": "一直以來它就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148024/32.wav", + "text": "利用我們國內的政黨競爭" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148024/33.wav", + "text": "資源我們國內一些親中勢力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148024/34.wav", + "text": "長期在破壞" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148024/35.wav", + "text": "在最近已經看到問題很嚴重" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148024/36.wav", + "text": "我們很希望大家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148024/37.wav", + "text": "敵愾同仇" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148024/38.wav", + "text": "一定是國內本身要團結" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148024/39.wav", + "text": "一定要瞭解中共" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148024/40.wav", + "text": "共產主義是一個魔鬼惡勢力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148024/41.wav", + "text": "那我們怎麼不能夠大家團結一致對外" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148024/42.wav", + "text": "呢\n我們看到有排山倒海的力量" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148024/43.wav", + "text": "在打擊政府" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148024/44.wav", + "text": "早已經超越一般的言論自由" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148024/45.wav", + "text": "剛才講怎麼樣去查緝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148024/46.wav", + "text": "我想言論自由這一塊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148024/47.wav", + "text": "可能我們慢慢要來檢討" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148024/48.wav", + "text": "因為現在沒有新聞局" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148024/49.wav", + "text": "言論自由有很多方面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148024/50.wav", + "text": "是沒有法律的管制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148024/51.wav", + "text": "所以我們看到隨著" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148024/52.wav", + "text": "臺灣1月份總統大選" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148024/53.wav", + "text": "逼近在抖音及小紅" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148024/54.wav", + "text": "書等多種新媒體到處可以看得到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148024/55.wav", + "text": "總統及立委大選" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148024/56.wav", + "text": "音\n最近臺灣有許多媒體" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148024/57.wav", + "text": "免費受邀" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148024/58.wav", + "text": "有很多村里長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148024/59.wav", + "text": "及宗教團體" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148024/60.wav", + "text": "最近看到的是客家團體" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148024/61.wav", + "text": "用溫水煮青蛙的方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148024/62.wav", + "text": "認知作戰長期開打" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148024/63.wav", + "text": "我們如果不知道他受到恐嚇" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148024/64.wav", + "text": "原來有一位許哲賓先生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148024/65.wav", + "text": "擁有100多個帳號跟密碼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148024/66.wav", + "text": "聽到也是令人很shock的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148024/67.wav", + "text": "\n首先我還是要先感謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148024/68.wav", + "text": "來查這些案子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148024/69.wav", + "text": "可謂是打擊犯罪的成果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148024/70.wav", + "text": "值得我們誇獎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148024/71.wav", + "text": "大家都已經開始" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148024/72.wav", + "text": "卯足勁在防範" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148024/73.wav", + "text": "讓臺灣的民主自由能夠守護" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148024/74.wav", + "text": "全球各民主國家也共同在關注" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148024/75.wav", + "text": "因為各位代表的是正義的力量" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148024/76.wav", + "text": "防守我們臺灣的安全" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148024/77.wav", + "text": "及民主的選舉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148024/78.wav", + "text": "\n我看到報紙" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148024/79.wav", + "text": "報導檢察總長刑泰釗表示" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148024/80.wav", + "text": "我相信大家都一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148024/81.wav", + "text": "對共諜案有嚇阻效果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148024/82.wav", + "text": "就是重判有嚇阻效果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148024/83.wav", + "text": "因為這個是體現司法正義" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148024/84.wav", + "text": "我想最近我們全體總動員起來了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148024/85.wav", + "text": "對國軍也有一個法治教化的功能" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148024/86.wav", + "text": "國防這邊也正面看待" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148024/87.wav", + "text": "要怎麼樣加強我們自己國防的力量" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148024/88.wav", + "text": "正義力量一起起來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148024/89.wav", + "text": "我們也看到檢警調很辛苦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148024/90.wav", + "text": "因為打詐案件我們上個月才在討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148024/91.wav", + "text": "打詐案子太多了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148024/92.wav", + "text": "那案件又多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148024/93.wav", + "text": "現在碰到選舉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148024/94.wav", + "text": "它一樣就趁勢攻進來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148024/95.wav", + "text": "滲透進來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148024/96.wav", + "text": "所以本席覺得臺灣在這幾年真的是非常辛苦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148024/97.wav", + "text": "尤其是檢警調" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148024/98.wav", + "text": "真的是不容易" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148024/99.wav", + "text": "我們看到已經全面開始面對這些惡勢力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148024/100.wav", + "text": "等一下我再請教部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148024/101.wav", + "text": "因為中選會最近被傳出" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148024/102.wav", + "text": "堅持使用可以從箱底塞入選票的紙箱票匭" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148024/103.wav", + "text": "那個時候你們怎麼因應" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148024/104.wav", + "text": "跟委員報告這件事是錯假訊息" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148024/105.wav", + "text": "\n第二個類此的錯假訊息" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148024/106.wav", + "text": "這幾年以來都有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148024/107.wav", + "text": "中選會也多次澄清在案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148024/108.wav", + "text": "最近再傳出這樣的訊息" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148024/109.wav", + "text": "我們一樣是予以嚴正地澄清" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148024/110.wav", + "text": "實際上選務的辦理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148024/111.wav", + "text": "都是公開透明的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148024/112.wav", + "text": "而且選務人員是以地方的公教人員為主力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148024/113.wav", + "text": "來辦理選務" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148024/114.wav", + "text": "所有的投開票例如開票也都有公眾的監督" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148024/115.wav", + "text": "包括有監察員也就是由政黨跟主要的候選人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148024/116.wav", + "text": "公開地來監督開票" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148024/117.wav", + "text": "所以這個部分可以確定是假訊息" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148024/118.wav", + "text": "\n第三個有關紙票匭的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148024/119.wav", + "text": "這個已經行之有年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148024/120.wav", + "text": "早在馬總統任內時期的中選會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148024/121.wav", + "text": "就已經引進紙票匭" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148024/122.wav", + "text": "而且紙票匭也是很多國家使用的法定票匭" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148024/123.wav", + "text": "我們國家也是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148024/124.wav", + "text": "而且我們在相關的選務作業程序上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148024/125.wav", + "text": "讓大家可以確認裡頭是完全沒有任何票數的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148024/126.wav", + "text": "我們選務會是依法辦理的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148024/127.wav", + "text": "我想這是一個案例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148024/128.wav", + "text": "當然它會讓我們有層出不窮的案例出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148024/129.wav", + "text": "所以中選會從過去到現在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148024/130.wav", + "text": "一直都會很積極很謹慎地在準備因應" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148024/131.wav", + "text": "所有大選會碰到的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148024/132.wav", + "text": "\n這一次為了我們臺灣的主權" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148024/133.wav", + "text": "也許我們正在做拉鋸戰" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148024/134.wav", + "text": "這個問題只有加強不會軟下來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148024/135.wav", + "text": "所以這次大選我們真的是要卯足勁啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148024/136.wav", + "text": "因為它要併吞" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148024/137.wav", + "text": "這個境外勢力要併吞" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148024/138.wav", + "text": "中華民國用排山倒海的力量" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148024/139.wav", + "text": "讓我們感覺這個力量之強大" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148024/140.wav", + "text": "要做一些因應和心理準備" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148024/141.wav", + "text": "可能要跟他們講萬一有什麼問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148024/142.wav", + "text": "要有備案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148024/143.wav", + "text": "我想備案很重要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148024/144.wav", + "text": "比如說停電了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148024/145.wav", + "text": "或者怎麼樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148024/146.wav", + "text": "過去一直都有在防範的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148024/147.wav", + "text": "謝謝委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148024/148.wav", + "text": "成立AI生成或深度偽造" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148024/149.wav", + "text": "由專責主任檢察官" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148024/150.wav", + "text": "負責偵辦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148024/151.wav", + "text": "有時候他們說會選擇性辦案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148024/152.wav", + "text": "只針對特定事件進行調查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148024/153.wav", + "text": "未來是不是還會發生類似的情況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148024/154.wav", + "text": "絕對不會選擇性辦案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148024/155.wav", + "text": "只要有可能涉及到刑事責任的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148024/156.wav", + "text": "我想檢察官都會依法來辦理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148024/157.wav", + "text": "\n這一次我們特別在六都的檢察署" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148024/158.wav", + "text": "就是期待要儘速地來瞭解來蒐證" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148024/159.wav", + "text": "如果證明這個訊息是假的��" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148024/160.wav", + "text": "看待任何一件事" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148024/161.wav", + "text": "讓事實呈現真實呈現" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148024/162.wav", + "text": "假的讓它暴露" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148024/163.wav", + "text": "這些惡勢力會慢慢的消弭\n" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148024/164.wav", + "text": "好第二個問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148024/165.wav", + "text": "如雨後春筍般冒出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148024/166.wav", + "text": "但最重要的是針對提供地下賭盤運作的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148024/167.wav", + "text": "是否有具體的計畫要如何去追查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148024/168.wav", + "text": "我相信已經有追查到一部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148024/169.wav", + "text": "剛才有聽到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148024/170.wav", + "text": "但從源頭防堵地下金流要怎麼樣進行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148024/171.wav", + "text": "但我相信越靠近選舉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148024/172.wav", + "text": "金額會越大的進來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148024/173.wav", + "text": "我記得我們在內政委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148024/174.wav", + "text": "的金額已經是我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148024/175.wav", + "text": "難以想像的數字這" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148024/176.wav", + "text": "是不是調查局在查辦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148024/177.wav", + "text": "是不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148024/178.wav", + "text": "跟委員報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148024/179.wav", + "text": "警方還有我們調查局" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148024/180.wav", + "text": "都有好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148024/181.wav", + "text": "幫助特定候選人進行拉票" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148024/182.wav", + "text": "針對這樣一個來自境外勢力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148024/183.wav", + "text": "過去我們有偵辦過這一類案子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148024/184.wav", + "text": "後來也經過法院判刑" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148024/185.wav", + "text": "包括副總統" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148024/186.wav", + "text": "所以層級更高" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148024/187.wav", + "text": "我們會嚴加防杜" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148024/188.wav", + "text": "我們也鼓勵大家提出檢舉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148024/189.wav", + "text": "你們會不會藉由記者會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148024/190.wav", + "text": "在不違反偵查不公開的情況下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148024/191.wav", + "text": "讓外界瞭解" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148024/192.wav", + "text": "我們會要求各地檢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148024/193.wav", + "text": "儘快讓外界瞭解" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148024/194.wav", + "text": "是我想真假訊息難以辨識" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148024/195.wav", + "text": "假訊息太多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148024/196.wav", + "text": "所以民眾需要透過政府正式的記者會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148024/197.wav", + "text": "來跟民眾宣導" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148024/198.wav", + "text": "有些事情還是要透過政府部門正式宣導" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148024/199.wav", + "text": "大家才會有一個方向感" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148024/200.wav", + "text": "這樣可以嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148024/201.wav", + "text": "是謝謝委員指教" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148024/202.wav", + "text": "我們這次也是認為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148024/203.wav", + "text": "嚴辦就是最好的宣導" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148024/204.wav", + "text": "所以只要有辦到一個具體個案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148024/205.wav", + "text": "也會讓外界曉得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148024/206.wav", + "text": "我想就是我們全部檢警調所有單位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148024/207.wav", + "text": "好謝謝湯蕙禎委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148024/208.wav", + "text": "\n接下來我們請" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148023/0.wav", + "text": "引爆了AI浪潮" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148023/1.wav", + "text": "但是金融業應用生成式AI" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148023/2.wav", + "text": "也可能會引發客戶個資外洩的疑慮" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148023/3.wav", + "text": "所以你們在今年4月份的時候進行全面的大調查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148023/4.wav", + "text": "金融機構導入生成式AI運用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148023/5.wav", + "text": "在我們的金融業務裡頭或內部作用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148023/6.wav", + "text": "但是有兩家金融機構規劃導入應用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148023/7.wav", + "text": "而且還有80家的金融機構及周邊單位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148023/8.wav", + "text": "內部行政作業及風險管理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148023/9.wav", + "text": "在這樣的情況之下本席想要請問主委" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148023/10.wav", + "text": "如果金融業運用了AI的演算法時" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148023/11.wav", + "text": "發生了大量帳戶變成警示戶" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148023/12.wav", + "text": "使得該銀行一般客戶遭到凍結" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148023/13.wav", + "text": "洩可能AI的演算法會失控" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148023/14.wav", + "text": "在這樣的情況之下就必須要做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148023/15.wav", + "text": "新加坡歐盟這些國家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148023/16.wav", + "text": "都有將緊急停止機制納入在今年年底的AI指引當中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148023/17.wav", + "text": "請教主委的看法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148023/18.wav", + "text": "我們是不是也會比照如此來進行呢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148023/19.wav", + "text": "謝謝委員指導這個緊急停止機制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148023/20.wav", + "text": "是有在討論中目前還沒有定案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148023/21.wav", + "text": "我想國際證券監督機構有類似這樣的一些討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148023/22.wav", + "text": "我們會參考但是還沒有確定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148023/23.wav", + "text": "你們大概還要討論到什麼時間點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148023/24.wav", + "text": "因為很多的客戶開始緊張" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148023/25.wav", + "text": "其實我們的金融機構" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148023/26.wav", + "text": "真正採用生成式的還沒有那麼多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148023/27.wav", + "text": "現在只是一種預警式的先把這個機制建立好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148023/28.wav", + "text": "因為世界各國已經在用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148023/29.wav", + "text": "我們也可能會碰到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148023/30.wav", + "text": "我們在跟業者討論之後儘快" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148023/31.wav", + "text": "看看能否提前提出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148023/32.wav", + "text": "的儘快是什麼時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148023/33.wav", + "text": "我們看到警示帳戶已經突破10萬戶" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148023/34.wav", + "text": "在這樣的情況之下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148023/35.wav", + "text": "你們針對2022年投資詐欺案件" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148023/36.wav", + "text": "��用人頭帳戶" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148023/37.wav", + "text": "我們也不斷在討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148023/38.wav", + "text": "占比比以前前十大的金融機構" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148023/39.wav", + "text": "在今年6月和7月啟動" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148023/40.wav", + "text": "你們終於也看到這個問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148023/41.wav", + "text": "啟動了專案的金檢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148023/42.wav", + "text": "我們也在討論如此地做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148023/43.wav", + "text": "但是數字一直增加" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148023/44.wav", + "text": "所以本席要在這邊請教主委" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148023/45.wav", + "text": "我們發現人頭戶的前十大銀行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148023/46.wav", + "text": "金檢就犯了九大缺失" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148023/47.wav", + "text": "例如針對短期頻繁開戶" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148023/48.wav", + "text": "或者沒有確實審核就開戶" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148023/49.wav", + "text": "金融機構監測到異常交易" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148023/50.wav", + "text": "或者進行查證" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148023/51.wav", + "text": "這樣子的情況之下難怪它有漏洞" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148023/52.wav", + "text": "難怪你的數字結果論詐騙還是猖獗" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148023/53.wav", + "text": "所以本席想請教" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148023/54.wav", + "text": "現在這樣的情況數字不斷升高" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148023/55.wav", + "text": "這個是過去它們的缺失" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148023/56.wav", + "text": "現在其實很多金融機構" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148023/57.wav", + "text": "都跟警政單位有科技防詐的機制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148023/58.wav", + "text": "用比較科技智慧的方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148023/59.wav", + "text": "去找出可疑的帳戶" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148023/60.wav", + "text": "也有金融資料調閱" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148023/61.wav", + "text": "跟聯防通報的機制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148023/62.wav", + "text": "做一些犯罪偵防的工作" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148023/63.wav", + "text": "這些都在配合" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148023/64.wav", + "text": "科技資訊一直發達" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148023/65.wav", + "text": "我們運用的方式要怎樣去圍堵" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148023/66.wav", + "text": "還是必須要接地氣的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148023/67.wav", + "text": "日新月異的升級版" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148023/68.wav", + "text": "你把這個方案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148023/69.wav", + "text": "再以書面給本席" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148023/70.wav", + "text": "我們一起繼續討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148023/71.wav", + "text": "因為這個問題在人民生活當中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148023/72.wav", + "text": "是非常有卡關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148023/73.wav", + "text": "所以我們必須要讓民眾" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148023/74.wav", + "text": "可以更加地安心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148023/75.wav", + "text": "癌症希望基金會在去年調查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148023/76.wav", + "text": "有2成以上的癌友" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148023/77.wav", + "text": "換句話說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148023/78.wav", + "text": "臺灣人平均擁有超過3張的健康保險" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148023/79.wav", + "text": "7成以上的癌友" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148023/80.wav", + "text": "但是當要提出申請的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148023/81.wav", + "text": "常常因為住院證明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148023/82.wav", + "text": "引發爭議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148023/83.wav", + "text": "導致這些癌友權益受損" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148023/84.wav", + "text": "本席之所以提這個議題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148023/85.wav", + "text": "就是以往我們做化療的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148023/86.wav", + "text": "都必須要住院前一天住院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148023/87.wav", + "text": "但是現在我們的醫療量能也不夠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148023/88.wav", + "text": "醫學也一直在進步" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148023/89.wav", + "text": "很多的化療" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148023/90.wav", + "text": "像現在很多教學級醫院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148023/91.wav", + "text": "就直接在門診旁邊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148023/92.wav", + "text": "開了化療室" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148023/93.wav", + "text": "讓他們直接在那邊化療" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148023/94.wav", + "text": "他休息了12個鐘頭之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148023/95.wav", + "text": "如果OK就離院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148023/96.wav", + "text": "也解除了我們醫療量能" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148023/97.wav", + "text": "但是在我們的保單上面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148023/98.wav", + "text": "它仍舊針對必須要住院的這一環" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148023/99.wav", + "text": "我們要怎麼去解決這個問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148023/100.wav", + "text": "爭議非常地多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148023/101.wav", + "text": "所以本席認為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148023/102.wav", + "text": "因為以往的確" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148023/103.wav", + "text": "統統必須要住院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148023/104.wav", + "text": "現在幾乎8成以上不需要住院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148023/105.wav", + "text": "這樣的情況之下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148023/106.wav", + "text": "如果我們的保單持續如此" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148023/107.wav", + "text": "因為明明白白" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148023/108.wav", + "text": "醫療院所沒有那麼多的病房" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148023/109.wav", + "text": "讓他住院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148023/110.wav", + "text": "經常每一天都在拜託" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148023/111.wav", + "text": "幫忙找個房間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148023/112.wav", + "text": "要去化療" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148023/113.wav", + "text": "所以本席特別提出" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148023/114.wav", + "text": "是不是保險局這邊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148023/115.wav", + "text": "應該要好好討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148023/116.wav", + "text": "怎樣能夠保障" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148023/117.wav", + "text": "癌友的權益不要受損" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148023/118.wav", + "text": "來解決這個問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148023/119.wav", + "text": "健保署有些提案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148023/120.wav", + "text": "我們也跟保險局溝通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148023/121.wav", + "text": "我們請壽險公會深入去研究" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148023/122.wav", + "text": "正在研究中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148023/123.wav", + "text": "正在研究中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148023/124.wav", + "text": "這個議題也是大家都非常關心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148023/125.wav", + "text": "你有沒有給它一個時間點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148023/126.wav", + "text": "等不及" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148023/127.wav", + "text": "我們也真的希望" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148023/128.wav", + "text": "他本來就不需要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148023/129.wav", + "text": "他有在化療" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148023/130.wav", + "text": "我們保險是針對他的功用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148023/131.wav", + "text": "他的功能" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148023/132.wav", + "text": "為什麼一定要強制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148023/133.wav", + "text": "院才肯給付給他呢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148023/134.wav", + "text": "在保險契約中有些約定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148023/135.wav", + "text": "這部分要怎麼處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148023/136.wav", + "text": "壽險公會會再研究" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148023/137.wav", + "text": "你是不是給我們一個時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148023/138.wav", + "text": "可不可以在30秒內結束" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148023/139.wav", + "text": "是不是給我們一個時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148023/140.wav", + "text": "讓大家有一個方向" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148023/141.wav", + "text": "跟委員報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148023/142.wav", + "text": "因為有很多事情需要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148023/143.wav", + "text": "我們來問公會看看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148023/144.wav", + "text": "它初步需要多少時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148023/145.wav", + "text": "請它評估一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148023/146.wav", + "text": "剛剛本席所提出的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148023/147.wav", + "text": "也就是醫療量能不足" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148023/148.wav", + "text": "他不需要住院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148023/149.wav", + "text": "因為醫療升級" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148023/150.wav", + "text": "他真正有化療" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148023/151.wav", + "text": "這個方向應該大家都認同" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148023/152.wav", + "text": "公會提出時間表" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148023/153.wav", + "text": "好不好拜託" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148023/154.wav", + "text": "解決他們的問題謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148022/0.wav", + "text": "有請管主委" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148022/1.wav", + "text": "陳委員好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148022/2.wav", + "text": "主委好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148022/3.wav", + "text": "今年8月間的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148022/4.wav", + "text": "當初行政院說金門要廢除泊地的事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148022/5.wav", + "text": "後來我有在金門跟我們當地的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148022/6.wav", + "text": "漁民還有自用小船的業者召開了協調會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148022/7.wav", + "text": "後來行政院是在9月5日是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148022/8.wav", + "text": "後來有正式地廢除泊地了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148022/9.wav", + "text": "是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148022/10.wav", + "text": "是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148022/11.wav", + "text": "然後辦公室也都站在打擊犯罪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148022/12.wav", + "text": "保護漁民的立場" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148022/13.wav", + "text": "來跟我們做叮嚀" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148022/14.wav", + "text": "這個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148022/15.wav", + "text": "我們打擊犯罪不要污染金門" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148022/16.wav", + "text": "漁業保護" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148022/17.wav", + "text": "合法的活動站在這樣的立場來談泊地的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148022/18.wav", + "text": "討論的結果就是連江縣政府也很支持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148022/19.wav", + "text": "我們最後就留兩個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148022/20.wav", + "text": "是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148022/21.wav", + "text": "留下來的我們不討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148022/22.wav", + "text": "其他20個廢除的泊地部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148022/23.wav", + "text": "我們金門當地的民眾關心的就是說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148022/24.wav", + "text": "包括自用小船業者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148022/25.wav", + "text": "包括漁民關心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148022/26.wav", + "text": "都沒有影響" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148022/27.wav", + "text": "都沒有影響" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148022/28.wav", + "text": "就是還是一樣可以從" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148022/29.wav", + "text": "這個已經" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148022/30.wav", + "text": "但是我想請問就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148022/31.wav", + "text": "泊地取消後我跟您確認這件事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148022/32.wav", + "text": "是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148022/33.wav", + "text": "漁船還有自用小船的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148022/34.wav", + "text": "進出泊地" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148022/35.wav", + "text": "會我有跟你" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148022/36.wav", + "text": "你當場通電話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148022/37.wav", + "text": "漁船跟自用小船還是自由進出" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148022/38.wav", + "text": "署長你回答一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148022/39.wav", + "text": "我想能不能請委員原諒我" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148022/40.wav", + "text": "我實在是說不出口在這裡講說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148022/41.wav", + "text": "廢除的泊地還是可以自由進出" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148022/42.wav", + "text": "因為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148022/43.wav", + "text": "委員知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148022/44.wav", + "text": "如果委員願意原諒的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148022/45.wav", + "text": "我就不這樣宣告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148022/46.wav", + "text": "因為我們就是希望" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148022/47.wav", + "text": "那裡不要再變成是船舶進出的地方" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148022/48.wav", + "text": "但是我們把船舶的進出放在兩個泊地" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148022/49.wav", + "text": "而且兩個泊地當然是夠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148022/50.wav", + "text": "前一陣子我們金門當地的民眾" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148022/51.wav", + "text": "不管是自用小船或漁船的業者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148022/52.wav", + "text": "如果要再把他們自己的船從家裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148022/53.wav", + "text": "再拖到那麼遠的地區" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148022/54.wav", + "text": "對他們的進出是不便的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148022/55.wav", + "text": "當時我有跟你們溝通說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148022/56.wav", + "text": "你們海巡署要加強" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148022/57.wav", + "text": "監控海上的登檢執法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148022/58.wav", + "text": "非法的部分你們就加強取締" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148022/59.wav", + "text": "但是問題就是說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148022/60.wav", + "text": "幾乎都被用來做空船進出" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148022/61.wav", + "text": "然後三更半夜這樣在折磨我們的海巡��對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148022/62.wav", + "text": "這個部分的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148022/63.wav", + "text": "後來就是現在他們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148022/64.wav", + "text": "從那裡進出的時候不用再通知你們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148022/65.wav", + "text": "出去再看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148022/66.wav", + "text": "可是船舶不能夠不經安檢隨意進出" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148022/67.wav", + "text": "國家的規定是百分之百安檢的制度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148022/68.wav", + "text": "如果船舶進出的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148022/69.wav", + "text": "署長是不是比較了解情形" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148022/70.wav", + "text": "可以跟我回答一下嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148022/71.wav", + "text": "當初我們開協調會的這個情形" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148022/72.wav", + "text": "回答一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148022/73.wav", + "text": "因為你不能把金門的民眾就動輒當作是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148022/74.wav", + "text": "非法的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148022/75.wav", + "text": "漁民或是當作賊來看待" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148022/76.wav", + "text": "是謝謝委員的指導" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148022/77.wav", + "text": "因為泊地已經公告廢止" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148022/78.wav", + "text": "如果從20處廢止的泊地進出的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148022/79.wav", + "text": "我們根據海岸巡防法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148022/80.wav", + "text": "他是顯有可疑" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148022/81.wav", + "text": "對啦這個我沒有意見啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148022/82.wav", + "text": "這個我們都是沒有意見啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148022/83.wav", + "text": "這個沒有問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148022/84.wav", + "text": "我看前一陣子還造成一個比較大的糾紛嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148022/85.wav", + "text": "的後來好像還叫國家公園要去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148022/86.wav", + "text": "的造成當地漁民跟這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148022/87.wav", + "text": "這也不是國家公園的事" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148022/88.wav", + "text": "跟委員特別說明一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148022/89.wav", + "text": "我們召開了7次會議為了稽查的這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148022/90.wav", + "text": "會中我們的決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148022/91.wav", + "text": "剛剛您提到的那個國家公園的海邊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148022/92.wav", + "text": "什麼給他堵起來那不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148022/93.wav", + "text": "我們的決議是恢復原貌" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148022/94.wav", + "text": "就是原來那邊有什麼東西像軌條砦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148022/95.wav", + "text": "是有什麼的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148022/96.wav", + "text": "因為被一些不肖業者給移開了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148022/97.wav", + "text": "我不是說海上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148022/98.wav", + "text": "我是說陸地啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148022/99.wav", + "text": "陸地應該不用去做一些路障造成金門漁民" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148022/100.wav", + "text": "都沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148022/101.wav", + "text": "不會再去設一些什麼路障" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148022/102.wav", + "text": "故意讓大家沒有辦法親近海" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148022/103.wav", + "text": "另外就是跟委員說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148022/104.wav", + "text": "原來在泊地的那些船" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148022/105.wav", + "text": "我們現在都有規劃它在附近的漁港" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148022/106.wav", + "text": "所以剛剛委員有考量到它" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148022/107.wav", + "text": "它從庫房拖出來到漁港很遠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148022/108.wav", + "text": "或者怎麼樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148022/109.wav", + "text": "其實那附近有好幾個像羅厝這樣的所有漁港" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148022/110.wav", + "text": "都有開放給這些船隻進出" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148022/111.wav", + "text": "如果它回到這些正常漁港進出的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148022/112.wav", + "text": "我們所有的安檢跟各方面的做法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148022/113.wav", + "text": "這個沒問題啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148022/114.wav", + "text": "對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148022/115.wav", + "text": "不管它從哪裡進出" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148022/116.wav", + "text": "因為臺灣也有這樣的情形嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148022/117.wav", + "text": "臺灣本島也有這樣情形" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148022/118.wav", + "text": "反正不管從哪裡進出你覺得他有嫌疑" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148022/119.wav", + "text": "本來就可以執行你的公權力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148022/120.wav", + "text": "這個我們都沒有疑問" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148022/121.wav", + "text": "我是說不要抱著心態說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148022/122.wav", + "text": "好像大家都一定是賊啊什麼的這種想法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148022/123.wav", + "text": "不會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148022/124.wav", + "text": "因為對金門民眾是顯不公平" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148022/125.wav", + "text": "謝謝委員請放" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148022/126.wav", + "text": "然後來講那個釣魚的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148022/127.wav", + "text": "金門地區現在開放了幾個新湖復國墩羅厝幾個漁港" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148022/128.wav", + "text": "是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148022/129.wav", + "text": "水頭也有開放" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148022/130.wav", + "text": "因為這個部分也是金門現在比較新興的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148022/131.wav", + "text": "當然也慢慢地會變成一個產業" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148022/132.wav", + "text": "我們會來加強" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148022/133.wav", + "text": "縣政府他們提案我們就會來支持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148022/134.wav", + "text": "目前明年度也已經匡列了40萬元在這" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148022/135.wav", + "text": "這個部分可能" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148022/136.wav", + "text": "因為金門這個產業已經在蓬勃發展了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148022/137.wav", + "text": "要看地方政府能有什麼方案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148022/138.wav", + "text": "另外漁村創生計畫在成功那個地方" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148022/139.wav", + "text": "那個是上次我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148022/140.wav", + "text": "對你上次有說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148022/141.wav", + "text": "如果我們缺什麼都會儘量給我們支持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148022/142.wav", + "text": "那當然謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148022/143.wav", + "text": "那種互動式展場的設計" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148022/144.wav", + "text": "還有應該要有的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148022/145.wav", + "text": "我記得好像冷氣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148022/146.wav", + "text": "冷氣都裝好了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148022/147.wav", + "text": "對這個是比較那個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148022/148.wav", + "text": "但是這個整個漁村創生計畫的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148022/149.wav", + "text": "我當然謝謝你們這幾年來預算已經增加" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148022/150.wav", + "text": "5%明年比今年多75%的預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148022/151.wav", + "text": "然後海島學校" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148022/152.wav", + "text": "當然我也看到你們有在這個上回" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148022/153.wav", + "text": "你們主委親自去看也成長了25%了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148022/154.wav", + "text": "但是我想跟您說的是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148022/155.wav", + "text": "像我們金門有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148022/156.wav", + "text": "的傳統像成功漁村復育有一些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148022/157.wav", + "text": "牽罟這種傳統的漁業文化" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148022/158.wav", + "text": "常常辦的花蛤季的這個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148022/159.wav", + "text": "花蛤季這個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148022/160.wav", + "text": "現在都是交通部那邊在跟我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148022/161.wav", + "text": "因為這個也涉及到海洋保育的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148022/162.wav", + "text": "復育嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148022/163.wav", + "text": "是一種傳統的牽罟" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148022/164.wav", + "text": "主委你懂嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148022/165.wav", + "text": "現有的計畫有這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148022/166.wav", + "text": "在成功漁村的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148022/167.wav", + "text": "我想這個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148022/168.wav", + "text": "也是海委會可以大力去幫我們支持的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148022/169.wav", + "text": "因為這個涉及人民親近海洋" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148022/170.wav", + "text": "所以事實上我們有在慢慢地推廣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148022/171.wav", + "text": "也要大力地推廣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148022/172.wav", + "text": "希望這個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148022/173.wav", + "text": "還有我們海委會真的也要大力支持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148022/174.wav", + "text": "好謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148022/175.wav", + "text": "好謝謝陳玉珍委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148021/0.wav", + "text": "委員好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148021/1.wav", + "text": "部長好部長早上我這樣聽行政院副院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148021/2.wav", + "text": "的事件其實法務部是一個檢察體系立場是很超然的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148021/3.wav", + "text": "不能因為某某委員在質疑" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148021/4.wav", + "text": "然後你們就要跳脫這樣在整個體制上也不太合理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148021/5.wav", + "text": "這是我的看法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148021/6.wav", + "text": "不然到時候有很多案件偵查不公開還在偵查階段" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148021/7.wav", + "text": "你來到立法院質詢就要提供這個就有點違反檢察體系" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148021/8.wav", + "text": "超然的立場這是我的看法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148021/9.wav", + "text": "的本席這邊有一個資料" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148021/10.wav", + "text": "選舉警察機關移送的賭盤案件從25件增加到64件" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148021/11.wav", + "text": "假訊息的案件111年移送的有152件" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148021/12.wav", + "text": "212人兩個類型的案件都大幅地成長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148021/13.wav", + "text": "證明現在有一些賭盤以及境外的假訊息干擾到選舉這" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148021/14.wav", + "text": "應該是今天大家都比較關心的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148021/15.wav", + "text": "我認為現在的賭盤還是很猖狂" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148021/16.wav", + "text": "長是不是有什麼遏止的辦法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148021/17.wav", + "text": "謝謝委員的指教" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148021/18.wav", + "text": "確實從過去我們選舉查察的經驗裡面就發覺" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148021/19.wav", + "text": "假訊息和賭盤是會影響到整個選舉的結果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148021/20.wav", + "text": "所以我們這一次特別針對這兩項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148021/21.wav", + "text": "還有包括境外勢力介選" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148021/22.wav", + "text": "這三項就是我們選舉查察核心的重點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148021/23.wav", + "text": "我會要求最高檢高檢還有所有的檢警調廉及移民" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148021/24.wav", + "text": "大家要全力以赴" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148021/25.wav", + "text": "尤其是對這三個重點工作要拿出辦法來嚴加地來防" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148021/26.wav", + "text": "好的部長不然現在假訊息也嚴重" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148021/27.wav", + "text": "還有賭盤整個賭盤的操控" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148021/28.wav", + "text": "這個一定要嚴加地嚴辦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148021/29.wav", + "text": "提報者最高有兩千萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148021/30.wav", + "text": "這個是不是也可以作為發放獎金的標準" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148021/31.wav", + "text": "謝謝委員指教" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148021/32.wav", + "text": "選舉的刑事案件已經對賭盤有獎金的發放" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148021/33.wav", + "text": "最高可以到500萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148021/34.wav", + "text": "元賭盤是沒有問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148021/35.wav", + "text": "假訊息這一次是沒有納進來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148021/36.wav", + "text": "不過我覺得下一次在修正的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148021/37.wav", + "text": "應該也要有一些鼓勵來發放獎金的相關辦法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148021/38.wav", + "text": "所以本席在這邊建議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148021/39.wav", + "text": "假消息的傳播" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148021/40.wav", + "text": "我們也是要鼓勵民眾多來檢舉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148021/41.wav", + "text": "這樣才能嚇阻這些假訊息" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148021/42.wav", + "text": "因為畢竟我們都是當事者要選舉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148021/43.wav", + "text": "以前的原物料" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148021/44.wav", + "text": "現在的價格" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148021/45.wav", + "text": "30元現在已經沒有什麼食材好買了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148021/46.wav", + "text": "現在起碼都要六七十元" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148021/47.wav", + "text": "這一點請部長來回答一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148021/48.wav", + "text": "是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148021/49.wav", + "text": "有關餐會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148021/50.wav", + "text": "如果純粹只是辦活動後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148021/51.wav", + "text": "一些小點心的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148021/52.wav", + "text": "並不會影響到最後他投票的意願" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148021/53.wav", + "text": "我想這是人之常情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148021/54.wav", + "text": "啦我們會關注" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148021/55.wav", + "text": "但是不一定會來偵辦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148021/56.wav", + "text": "會蒐證" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148021/57.wav", + "text": "但是我個人的經驗判斷是比較不會構成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148021/58.wav", + "text": "何況我們也有把這些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148021/59.wav", + "text": "可能涉及到賄選的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148021/60.wav", + "text": "蒐集過去法院的判決" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148021/61.wav", + "text": "什麼狀況下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148021/62.wav", + "text": "過去法院判決是判有賄選的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148021/63.wav", + "text": "什麼狀況下是沒有賄選的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148021/64.wav", + "text": "我們有把它例舉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148021/65.wav", + "text": "列出來公布給民眾" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148021/66.wav", + "text": "所以很清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148021/67.wav", + "text": "\n委員關心的那種餐會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148021/68.wav", + "text": "是說你到餐廳去吃" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148021/69.wav", + "text": "整桌的菜餚等等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148021/70.wav", + "text": "當然那個是絕對禁止" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148021/71.wav", + "text": "如果是辦活動後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148021/72.wav", + "text": "這樣的小餐點的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148021/73.wav", + "text": "在我們過去的實務經驗上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148021/74.wav", + "text": "是不至於會構成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148021/75.wav", + "text": "當然你吃得很豐盛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148021/76.wav", + "text": "那又是另當別論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148021/77.wav", + "text": "又有排骨又有雞腿又有什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148021/78.wav", + "text": "很豐盛的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148021/79.wav", + "text": "這個就會讓檢察官" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148021/80.wav", + "text": "懷疑是不是有賄選的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148021/81.wav", + "text": "可能性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148021/82.wav", + "text": "有起訴的可能性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148021/83.wav", + "text": "但是很單純的只是一個小點心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148021/84.wav", + "text": "我想在實務的判斷上是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148021/85.wav", + "text": "比較難以構成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148021/86.wav", + "text": "好的部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148021/87.wav", + "text": "我再請教一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148021/88.wav", + "text": "問得比較明確一點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148021/89.wav", + "text": "一個吐司麵包60元" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148021/90.wav", + "text": "元會不會構成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148021/91.wav", + "text": "那還是要由檢察官來認定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148021/92.wav", + "text": "我剛剛已經講了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148021/93.wav", + "text": "如果是一個小點心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148021/94.wav", + "text": "午餐晚餐的時間到了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148021/95.wav", + "text": "來參與活動時間很長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148021/96.wav", + "text": "但是只是人之常情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148021/97.wav", + "text": "不會影響到他" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148021/98.wav", + "text": "最後要投票的意願" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148021/99.wav", + "text": "以我個人的經驗過去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148021/100.wav", + "text": "實際上並沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148021/101.wav", + "text": "因為這樣就有判刑" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148021/102.wav", + "text": "比較大的餐會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148021/103.wav", + "text": "會用很豐盛的飲食" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148021/104.wav", + "text": "這就另當別論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148021/105.wav", + "text": "就很單純的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148021/106.wav", + "text": "很單純一個麵包60" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148021/107.wav", + "text": "我想檢察官會認定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148021/108.wav", + "text": "會判斷" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148021/109.wav", + "text": "還是沒辦法很具體" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148021/110.wav", + "text": "我剛剛已經講了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148021/111.wav", + "text": "通案性來看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148021/112.wav", + "text": "它只是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148021/113.wav", + "text": "小點心而已" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148021/114.wav", + "text": "應該是不至於" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148021/115.wav", + "text": "不過這是我個人的判斷" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148021/116.wav", + "text": "啦因為我也是從基層的檢察官做起" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148021/117.wav", + "text": "在實務的判斷上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148021/118.wav", + "text": "我是覺得不至於" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148021/119.wav", + "text": "但是個案的情節" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148021/120.wav", + "text": "還是要尊重檢察官的認定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148021/121.wav", + "text": "好謝謝部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148020/0.wav", + "text": "謝謝主席可不可以請國發會跟原民會好嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148020/1.wav", + "text": "好國發會跟原民會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148020/2.wav", + "text": "主委國土計畫的擬定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148020/3.wav", + "text": "牽涉到我們原住民地區的權益非常大" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148020/4.wav", + "text": "因為原住民地區大概有67%都被列為國土計畫範圍" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148020/5.wav", + "text": "現在有很多問題要解決" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148020/6.wav", + "text": "幾乎百分之八十九十以上都是沒有建照都是非法建造" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148020/7.wav", + "text": "我講的部落是全國的部落" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148020/8.wav", + "text": "第二個是散居在山地鄉的幾個零星住戶" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148020/9.wav", + "text": "好比在部落周邊有一兩戶零星的住戶" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148020/10.wav", + "text": "這個問題要怎麼解決" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148020/11.wav", + "text": "規定有關國土計畫的功能分區" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148020/12.wav", + "text": "規則涉及到原住民族土地跟海域使用管制者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148020/13.wav", + "text": "應該依原住民族基本法第21條規定辦理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148020/14.wav", + "text": "並由中央主管機關會同中央原住民族主管機關定之" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148020/15.wav", + "text": "有很多林地都不是被列為住宅區" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148020/16.wav", + "text": "你不要講整個鄉每個部落都是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148020/17.wav", + "text": "本席處理很多大同鄉尖石鄉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148020/18.wav", + "text": "五峰鄉的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148020/19.wav", + "text": "針對這個你們跟原民會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148020/20.wav", + "text": "是不是有答應要定一個原住民族土地使用管制規則" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148020/21.wav", + "text": "有沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148020/22.wav", + "text": "有不過那個主要是內政部跟原民會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148020/23.wav", + "text": "內政部營建署有沒有來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148020/24.wav", + "text": "這個部分我們要怎麼解決" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148020/25.wav", + "text": "關於原住民族土地使用管制規則" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148020/26.wav", + "text": "說明一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148020/27.wav", + "text": "感謝委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148020/28.wav", + "text": "我們現在跟原民會都有一直在討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148020/29.wav", + "text": "就是做為未來合法居住的範圍" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148020/30.wav", + "text": "因為原住民所要求的建築形式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148020/31.wav", + "text": "跟一般平地比較不一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148020/32.wav", + "text": "重的是建蔽率不是容積率" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148020/33.wav", + "text": "所以就有關這一些未來可能可以被認定為農四的範圍裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148020/34.wav", + "text": "第一個就是範圍大小" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148020/35.wav", + "text": "第二個就是它未來適用的土地使用管制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148020/36.wav", + "text": "這個部分其實我們都有跟原民會保持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148020/37.wav", + "text": "這個早在十年前我在內政委員會就有質詢過營建署" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148020/38.wav", + "text": "現在針對原住民的土地你們說要跟原民會訂定一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148020/39.wav", + "text": "在農四裡面有一些範圍是可以劃的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148020/40.wav", + "text": "這個都會包含在裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148020/41.wav", + "text": "所以這個部分也是我們的確都在協助" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148020/42.wav", + "text": "像您剛剛舉的尖石五峰" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148020/43.wav", + "text": "本席是希望藉由這次國土計畫的公布" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148020/44.wav", + "text": "107年4月30日全國國土計畫發布以前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148020/45.wav", + "text": "就已經存在的保護區既有建物" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148020/46.wav", + "text": "就直接給它合法了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148020/47.wav", + "text": "這個部分我們會整合所有的資料一起來討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148020/48.wav", + "text": "在107年公布全國國土計畫以前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148020/49.wav", + "text": "當然有合法建照的部分是最沒有問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148020/50.wav", + "text": "的現在是有些部落的形式跟大小" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148020/51.wav", + "text": "大家追求的比例都不太一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148020/52.wav", + "text": "這個部分因為族群的不同" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148020/53.wav", + "text": "他們要求的範圍也不同" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148020/54.wav", + "text": "所以這個部分我們的確都有按照不同族群在進行討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148020/55.wav", + "text": "現在還是在討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148020/56.wav", + "text": "對對對而且越來越有共識" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148020/57.wav", + "text": "萬一弄到國土保育區什麼都不能開發" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148020/58.wav", + "text": "部落周邊的那些森林" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148020/59.wav", + "text": "可能是國土保育區啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148020/60.wav", + "text": "但是我們已經居住在那個地方幾十年了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148020/61.wav", + "text": "沒有一個建照" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148020/62.wav", + "text": "照要申請貸款也沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148020/63.wav", + "text": "沒有建照我們連房���修繕" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148020/64.wav", + "text": "申請貸款都不行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148020/65.wav", + "text": "所以這個等於就不是自己的財產" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148020/66.wav", + "text": "我大概十年前就已經" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148020/67.wav", + "text": "跟營建署說了你們說要跟原民會定一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148020/68.wav", + "text": "如果你們跟原民會還在協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148020/69.wav", + "text": "倒不如請國發會主委" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148020/70.wav", + "text": "告委員我先補充說明一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148020/71.wav", + "text": "我們已經送了草案的條文內容" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148020/72.wav", + "text": "一直到112年我們送了4個草案的內容" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148020/73.wav", + "text": "內容裡面其實主要是針對原住民的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148020/74.wav", + "text": "跟祭儀使用上的特殊性來制定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148020/75.wav", + "text": "屬於我們自己原住民土地使用需求上的一些規範" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148020/76.wav", + "text": "原則上我們就朝這個方向來進行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148020/77.wav", + "text": "目前已經開過很多次的會議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148020/78.wav", + "text": "原則上在跟國土署的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148020/79.wav", + "text": "的溝通上共識越來越多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148020/80.wav", + "text": "我相信在114年以前我們會完成制定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148020/81.wav", + "text": "剛剛委員提到有一些部落裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148020/82.wav", + "text": "這個部分我們目前也在處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148020/83.wav", + "text": "因為那些散居的建築物" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148020/84.wav", + "text": "很有可能在國土保育區" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148020/85.wav", + "text": "這個是我們的方向" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148020/86.wav", + "text": "所以只要是在105年以前存在的建築物" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148020/87.wav", + "text": "原則上就會讓它合法化" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148020/88.wav", + "text": "這是我們的目標" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148020/89.wav", + "text": "我們也會跟國土署來好原" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148020/90.wav", + "text": "原民會的目標已經講得很清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148020/91.wav", + "text": "只要是在105年以前的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148020/92.wav", + "text": "跟委員報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148020/93.wav", + "text": "我們雙方其實就是朝向這樣的方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148020/94.wav", + "text": "還有形成農四範圍的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148020/95.wav", + "text": "部分因為各族群的要求不太一致" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148020/96.wav", + "text": "所以這個部分我們還是想辦法讓" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148020/97.wav", + "text": "這樣會比較容易處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148020/98.wav", + "text": "來主委針對這個問題你來說明一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148020/99.wav", + "text": "有共識的話就按照這個方向來進行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148020/100.wav", + "text": "除非有爭議的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148020/101.wav", + "text": "送到行政院協處" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148020/102.wav", + "text": "那會交給我們來協調" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148020/103.wav", + "text": "他們之間的溝通" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148020/104.wav", + "text": "考量是不是可以讓他們持續地使用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148020/105.wav", + "text": "朝這個方向來��行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148020/106.wav", + "text": "我舉個例子烏來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148020/107.wav", + "text": "然後在全國國土計畫範圍" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148020/108.wav", + "text": "看是怎麼處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148020/109.wav", + "text": "現在臺北水源特定區管理局" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148020/110.wav", + "text": "查報取締" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148020/111.wav", + "text": "跟委員報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148020/112.wav", + "text": "因為水源特定區又涉及都市計畫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148020/113.wav", + "text": "還是以保護水源這個概念去處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148020/114.wav", + "text": "所以基本上劃在這個範圍裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148020/115.wav", + "text": "的土地只能重啟原來之使用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148020/116.wav", + "text": "沒有辦法持續去擴增" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148020/117.wav", + "text": "或者是把它做為合法住宅區" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148020/118.wav", + "text": "保護做為目的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148020/119.wav", + "text": "但是讓它重啟原來之使用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148020/120.wav", + "text": "做為一些修繕或必要的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148020/121.wav", + "text": "維護這個部分我們都還有持續在好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148020/122.wav", + "text": "最後一個問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148020/123.wav", + "text": "全國國土計畫審議委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148020/124.wav", + "text": "現在有多少委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148020/125.wav", + "text": "現在有23位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148020/126.wav", + "text": "裡面有沒有原住民" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148020/127.wav", + "text": "我印象中原民會代表也是委員之一" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148020/128.wav", + "text": "全國國土計畫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148020/129.wav", + "text": "審議委員會沒有一個委員是原住民" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148020/130.wav", + "text": "這個要檢討" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148020/131.wav", + "text": "好這個我們會來檢討" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148020/132.wav", + "text": "你要找一個懂得都市計畫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148020/133.wav", + "text": "的原住民專家學者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148020/134.wav", + "text": "不要說原民會有派" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148020/135.wav", + "text": "原民會派的是官方代表" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148020/136.wav", + "text": "啊你要找一個學者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148020/137.wav", + "text": "要有一個代表性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148020/138.wav", + "text": "你們談論國土計畫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148020/139.wav", + "text": "可是67%都是原住民的土地" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148020/140.wav", + "text": "沒有一個審查委員是原住民" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148020/141.wav", + "text": "我們檢討看看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148020/142.wav", + "text": "好謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148020/143.wav", + "text": "好謝謝孔委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148019/0.wav", + "text": "謝謝主席" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148019/1.wav", + "text": "我們請主委" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148019/2.wav", + "text": "有請主委" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148019/3.wav", + "text": "陳委員好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148019/4.wav", + "text": "主委好今天就是要來跟你說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148019/5.wav", + "text": "我的辦公室有協助詢問新竹六福村以及保育動物" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148019/6.wav", + "text": "）提供民眾餵食互動體驗" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148019/7.wav", + "text": "是不是有違反野保法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148019/8.wav", + "text": "當時林務局認真研議了兩個月" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148019/9.wav", + "text": "終於以農牧字第1110714819號" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148019/10.wav", + "text": "函" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148019/11.wav", + "text": "明確函釋基於野保法的精神" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148019/12.wav", + "text": "保育類野生動物應該禁止過度利用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148019/13.wav", + "text": "表演跟人互動之商業行為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148019/14.wav", + "text": "會加劇原生地非法獵捕的情事" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148019/15.wav", + "text": "地方政府要依野保法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148019/16.wav", + "text": "針對業者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148019/17.wav", + "text": "申請是否同意保育類野生動物陳列" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148019/18.wav", + "text": "還有展示之行政處分的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148019/19.wav", + "text": "應該敘明保育類野生動物" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148019/20.wav", + "text": "不得進行表演" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148019/21.wav", + "text": "及與人互動之行為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148019/22.wav", + "text": "對比當時的海保署" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148019/23.wav", + "text": "海保署就是消極回應本辦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148019/24.wav", + "text": "所作之表演跟人互動" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148019/25.wav", + "text": "像遠雄海洋公園" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148019/26.wav", + "text": "是經過地方政府同意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148019/27.wav", + "text": "並無違法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148019/28.wav", + "text": "這個是相當令人傻眼的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148019/29.wav", + "text": "海保署林務局針對保育類海洋生物" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148019/30.wav", + "text": "進行商業性的表演" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148019/31.wav", + "text": "還有跟人互動" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148019/32.wav", + "text": "都有明確函釋主管機關的態度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148019/33.wav", + "text": "不是推給地方政府自己認定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148019/34.wav", + "text": "所以現在要請問署長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148019/35.wav", + "text": "不知道你喜不喜歡看海豚表演" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148019/36.wav", + "text": "和人互動" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148019/37.wav", + "text": "這個表演當然我們知道有受歡迎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148019/38.wav", + "text": "也替業者賺了很多錢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148019/39.wav", + "text": "不過因為這樣利用保育類動物的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148019/40.wav", + "text": "商業行為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148019/41.wav", + "text": "是不是也造成牠們原生地" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148019/42.wav", + "text": "非法獵捕的情事" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148019/43.wav", + "text": "我剛剛和署長做了瞭解" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148019/44.wav", + "text": "因為這件事情沒有報告過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148019/45.wav", + "text": "我覺得最重要的就是說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148019/46.wav", + "text": "這樣的表演其實雖然有海洋教育" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148019/47.wav", + "text": "但是基本上確實對海洋生物" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148019/48.wav", + "text": "海洋動物來講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148019/49.wav", + "text": "造成海洋動物的傷害在哪裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148019/50.wav", + "text": "我們要很確認" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148019/51.wav", + "text": "我認為我是比較傾向於說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148019/52.wav", + "text": "我們做的海洋教育" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148019/53.wav", + "text": "不需要用這樣的方式來做海洋教育" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148019/54.wav", + "text": "我認為我們不需要用這樣的方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148019/55.wav", + "text": "所以朝這個方向" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148019/56.wav", + "text": "我下去以後跟海保署把案子調出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148019/57.wav", + "text": "請他們給我做深入的報告好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148019/58.wav", + "text": "是不是可以也一個月內" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148019/59.wav", + "text": "針對保育類的海洋生物" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148019/60.wav", + "text": "進行商業性表演" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148019/61.wav", + "text": "還有與人互動的行為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148019/62.wav", + "text": "海洋生物主管機關的立場" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148019/63.wav", + "text": "來說明是不是違反海保法精神" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148019/64.wav", + "text": "我們做一個初步的書面報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148019/65.wav", + "text": "好就是這樣子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148019/66.wav", + "text": "再來就是針對水下噪音的指引" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148019/67.wav", + "text": "我們做好了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148019/68.wav", + "text": "然後在進行最後的跨部會的溝通" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148019/69.wav", + "text": "做好了以後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148019/70.wav", + "text": "有兩個意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148019/71.wav", + "text": "一個意見是說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148019/72.wav", + "text": "我們以海事工程為優先" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148019/73.wav", + "text": "先就海事工程的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148019/74.wav", + "text": "我們做指引來供遵循" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148019/75.wav", + "text": "另外一種看法是說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148019/76.wav", + "text": "我們的船舶跟漁業" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148019/77.wav", + "text": "來做水下噪音的指引供依循" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148019/78.wav", + "text": "現在就是說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148019/79.wav", + "text": "船舶要第一階段就加入的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148019/80.wav", + "text": "交通部容或還是叫我們要審慎考慮" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148019/81.wav", + "text": "他們還有一點疑慮" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148019/82.wav", + "text": "那漁業的部分也一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148019/83.wav", + "text": "但是海事工程的指引部分已經有共識" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148019/84.wav", + "text": "所以整體的指引我們都有做好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148019/85.wav", + "text": "就是依委員當初的附帶決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148019/86.wav", + "text": "我們做好了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148019/87.wav", + "text": "但是最後的協調溝通" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148019/88.wav", + "text": "來決定我們公告的範圍的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148019/89.wav", + "text": "委員如果再給我們一個多月的時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148019/90.wav", + "text": "我們來把它完成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148019/91.wav", + "text": "好那另外也是希望就是說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148019/92.wav", + "text": "不產生遮蔽效應為目標" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148019/93.wav", + "text": "這樣子的標準也能夠把它提出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148019/94.wav", + "text": "我們就是參酌了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148019/95.wav", + "text": "歐盟美國" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148019/96.wav", + "text": "還有我們的環境部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148019/97.wav", + "text": "還有更多國家的種種的規範跟標準" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148019/98.wav", + "text": "有廣泛的參酌以後所制定出來的指引" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148019/99.wav", + "text": "也有跟各種團體產業" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148019/100.wav", + "text": "好那就一個月請海保署來提出" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148019/101.wav", + "text": "因為這個會期也很快就會結束" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148019/102.wav", + "text": "我們都會做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148019/103.wav", + "text": "然後都會跟委員維持報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148019/104.wav", + "text": "好最後一個就是請問" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148019/105.wav", + "text": "中國在灰色海域動作頻頻" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148019/106.wav", + "text": "宣稱幾乎整個南海" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148019/107.wav", + "text": "都是它的領土" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148019/108.wav", + "text": "這也可能是用來控制臺灣的關鍵區域" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148019/109.wav", + "text": "這片海域是重要的貨船的航道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148019/110.wav", + "text": "也有豐富的油氣儲槽" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148019/111.wav", + "text": "中國在爭議水域的礁島上面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148019/112.wav", + "text": "建造大型的建築" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148019/113.wav", + "text": "宣稱擁有南海這些海域跟島礁的主權" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148019/114.wav", + "text": "所以不論從國防或者是從資源的角度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148019/115.wav", + "text": "灰色海域的政策是非常的重要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148019/116.wav", + "text": "所以我要請問主委" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148019/117.wav", + "text": "臺灣在灰色海域的戰略是怎樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148019/118.wav", + "text": "我們如何從環境生態研究" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148019/119.wav", + "text": "還有鞏固臺灣在灰色海域的國防能量" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148019/120.wav", + "text": "我們到底要怎麼來做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148019/121.wav", + "text": "好的針對灰色地帶戰略" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148019/122.wav", + "text": "海巡署相關的權責之下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148019/123.wav", + "text": "我們的勤任務其實也在這個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148019/124.wav", + "text": "花了很多的心力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148019/125.wav", + "text": "勤任務的比重也都有在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148019/126.wav", + "text": "最重要當然是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148019/127.wav", + "text": "第一個我們會做重要的監測" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148019/128.wav", + "text": "我們三層的情監偵系統" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148019/129.wav", + "text": "特別是我們要學習去分辨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148019/130.wav", + "text": "是不是民兵船" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148019/131.wav", + "text": "還有他們的研究船的活動" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148019/132.wav", + "text": "是不是純粹是研究船" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148019/133.wav", + "text": "還是其實是情蒐的任務" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148019/134.wav", + "text": "所以重要還是在情報的偵查跟掌握" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148019/135.wav", + "text": "這個部分的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148019/136.wav", + "text": "我們有很努力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148019/137.wav", + "text": "也建立了相當程度的資料庫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148019/138.wav", + "text": "平常的監偵都有在做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148019/139.wav", + "text": "也會跟國際之間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148019/140.wav", + "text": "因為整個其實它不只是臺灣海域" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148019/141.wav", + "text": "最嚴重的應該是南海" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148019/142.wav", + "text": "整個相關國家之間的情報的交流" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148019/143.wav", + "text": "國際的合作" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148019/144.wav", + "text": "我們都有共同地在應處" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148019/145.wav", + "text": "灰色地帶戰略的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148019/146.wav", + "text": "好最後請問主委海保法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148019/147.wav", + "text": "是不是能夠在會期也送到立法院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148019/148.wav", + "text": "是大概目前遇到一個關卡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148019/149.wav", + "text": "就是農業部門要求我們要回過頭" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148019/150.wav", + "text": "再來跟漁民做溝通" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148019/151.wav", + "text": "我們也盤點了一下就是說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148019/152.wav", + "text": "我們過去跟漁業界的溝通" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148019/153.wav", + "text": "目前就停擺了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148019/154.wav", + "text": "對所以我們最後就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148019/155.wav", + "text": "但是我們照做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148019/156.wav", + "text": "我們來用條文下來溝通" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148019/157.wav", + "text": "所以接下來我們就用草案的條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148019/158.wav", + "text": "好謝謝謝謝主委謝謝主席" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148019/159.wav", + "text": "謝謝陳椒華委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148019/160.wav", + "text": "\n接下來有請陳玉珍委" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148017/0.wav", + "text": "龔主委" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148017/1.wav", + "text": "跟主委請教關於地方創生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148017/2.wav", + "text": "的問題但是我想要直接拿一個案例來跟主委討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148017/3.wav", + "text": "其實在國發會的地方創生2.0計畫裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148017/4.wav", + "text": "設了分區輔導中心及專案辦公室" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148017/5.wav", + "text": "這兩個單位各自負責的事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148017/6.wav", + "text": "我相信國發會主委應該非常清楚對嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148017/7.wav", + "text": "遇到法規窒礙難行的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148017/8.wav", + "text": "很多部會在跨部會的溝通上出現了問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148017/9.wav", + "text": "這個部分要請誰幫忙" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148017/10.wav", + "text": "到底是要請所謂的分區輔導中心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148017/11.wav", + "text": "還是專案辦公室" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148017/12.wav", + "text": "還是一旦跟中央主管機關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148017/13.wav", + "text": "有牽扯到相關法規的限制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148017/14.wav", + "text": "他們到底要找誰求救" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148017/15.wav", + "text": "從這邊也會到這邊來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148017/16.wav", + "text": "從這邊也會到這邊都沒有問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148017/17.wav", + "text": "好所以也就是我們可以期待地方創生的夥伴" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148017/18.wav", + "text": "就如同主委剛剛說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148017/19.wav", + "text": "他們的意見最後國發會都會聽見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148017/20.wav", + "text": "不知道你有沒有聽過月桃葉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148017/21.wav", + "text": "主委你有看過月桃葉嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148017/22.wav", + "text": "已經有同仁自己站起來了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148017/23.wav", + "text": "關於這個事情我們辦公室" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148017/24.wav", + "text": "一直在協助處理很多相關的案例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148017/25.wav", + "text": "今天這個不是個案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148017/26.wav", + "text": "它已經是很多地方創生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148017/27.wav", + "text": "新創企業夥伴的通案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148017/28.wav", + "text": "怎麼說呢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148017/29.wav", + "text": "在原鄉有所謂的月桃葉創意料理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148017/30.wav", + "text": "它不僅可以擺盤" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148017/31.wav", + "text": "它也可以做成料理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148017/32.wav", + "text": "在衛福部相關食安平台當中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148017/33.wav", + "text": "衛福部把月桃葉定義為不得食用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148017/34.wav", + "text": "尚不得食用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148017/35.wav", + "text": "可是主委知不知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148017/36.wav", + "text": "或者是現場如果有原民" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148017/37.wav", + "text": "會或農業部的相關代表也請出席" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148017/38.wav", + "text": "我們想要問一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148017/39.wav", + "text": "月桃葉做為一個特色料理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148017/40.wav", + "text": "在地方部落小旅行導覽的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148017/41.wav", + "text": "被拿來做成各式各樣的料理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148017/42.wav", + "text": "這件事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148017/43.wav", + "text": "我相信各位行政主管機關的人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148017/44.wav", + "text": "不會沒有聽過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148017/45.wav", + "text": "就算你是第一次看到生的月桃葉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148017/46.wav", + "text": "你都不會沒有聽過月桃葉的料理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148017/47.wav", + "text": "對嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148017/48.wav", + "text": "對後面已經有人點頭了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148017/49.wav", + "text": "因為它被衛福部定義為尚不得食用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148017/50.wav", + "text": "所以地方創生夥伴遇到相關的特色料理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148017/51.wav", + "text": "要拿來賣的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148017/52.wav", + "text": "或拿來招待到部落" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148017/53.wav", + "text": "來體驗小旅行的遊客的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148017/54.wav", + "text": "就會涉及違反食安法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148017/55.wav", + "text": "\n這個議題牽扯到國發會的地方創生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148017/56.wav", + "text": "牽扯到原民會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148017/57.wav", + "text": "牽扯到農業部和衛福部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148017/58.wav", + "text": "卻有相關的法規綁住了他們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148017/59.wav", + "text": "但是所有行政機關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148017/60.wav", + "text": "都沒有協助他們去整合" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148017/61.wav", + "text": "那請問他們要如何發展地方創生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148017/62.wav", + "text": "我們如何鼓勵青年回到自己的家鄉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148017/63.wav", + "text": "做自己的家鄉能夠做的事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148017/64.wav", + "text": "是謝謝委員關心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148017/65.wav", + "text": "使用的材料確實是非常有特色" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148017/66.wav", + "text": "這也是我們做地方創生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148017/67.wav", + "text": "希望能夠吸引人來地方瞭解的部分這是一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148017/68.wav", + "text": "第二個因為有很多這類食物" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148017/69.wav", + "text": "包括月桃葉還有很多像" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148017/70.wav", + "text": "艾草也是像" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148017/71.wav", + "text": "檳榔荖花艾草這些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148017/72.wav", + "text": "艾草也是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148017/73.wav", + "text": "難道我們要去抓那些阿公阿嬤嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148017/74.wav", + "text": "應該這樣講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148017/75.wav", + "text": "因為食藥署把它列作特殊食物原料" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148017/76.wav", + "text": "目前的寫法是尚不得食用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148017/77.wav", + "text": "我們辦公室其實一直在關心類似的地方創生案例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148017/78.wav", + "text": "事實上今年4月的行政院食安會報上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148017/79.wav", + "text": "有討論過這個議題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148017/80.wav", + "text": "同時我們發現國發會國土處應該很清楚知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148017/81.wav", + "text": "因為國土處應該有聽過類似的事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148017/82.wav", + "text": "到了今年8月我們跟衛福部持續溝通" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148017/83.wav", + "text": "但是在這個議題上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148017/84.wav", + "text": "我們仍然沒有看見國發會原民會農業部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148017/85.wav", + "text": "衛福部如何站在一起橫向溝通" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148017/86.wav", + "text": "協助地方創生的夥伴" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148017/87.wav", + "text": "我們要如何相信地方創生的夥伴" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148017/88.wav", + "text": "可以堅持走下去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148017/89.wav", + "text": "所以這個部分真的要拜託行政機關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148017/90.wav", + "text": "給予他們支持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148017/91.wav", + "text": "如何跨部會溝通協助他們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148017/92.wav", + "text": "\n針對這個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148017/93.wav", + "text": "有沒有機會在一個月內" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148017/94.wav", + "text": "及專案辦公室" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148017/95.wav", + "text": "蒐集他們目前已經知道的相關法規" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148017/96.wav", + "text": "可不可以在一個月內" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148017/97.wav", + "text": "在北中南東相關辦公室把報告蒐集起來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148017/98.wav", + "text": "然後不是只要給我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148017/99.wav", + "text": "也不是只要給委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148017/100.wav", + "text": "而是你們必須要做為一個參考" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148017/101.wav", + "text": "他們如同剛剛主委說的好意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148017/102.wav", + "text": "絕對很重要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148017/103.wav", + "text": "不管是來自專案辦公室還是輔導中心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148017/104.wav", + "text": "所有的意見都要被聽見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148017/105.wav", + "text": "不是只有被聽見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148017/106.wav", + "text": "還要被解決" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148017/107.wav", + "text": "所以一個月內可以給我們有關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148017/108.wav", + "text": "所反映的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148017/109.wav", + "text": "好那就拜託你們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148017/110.wav", + "text": "一定要在這個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148017/111.wav", + "text": "做到我們辦公室也會持續關心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148017/112.wav", + "text": "新創事業上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148017/113.wav", + "text": "已經遇到問題關於法規" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148017/114.wav", + "text": "你看都這麼多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148017/115.wav", + "text": "我們設法協助他們好嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148017/116.wav", + "text": "好好謝謝主委" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148017/117.wav", + "text": "也謝謝各位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148017/118.wav", + "text": "\n接下來要談的是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148017/119.wav", + "text": "行政院的兒少代表" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148017/120.wav", + "text": "有跟我們辦公室反映" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148017/121.wav", + "text": "關於行政院的二級機關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148017/122.wav", + "text": "國發會是屬於" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148017/123.wav", + "text": "尚未成立人權工作小組的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148017/124.wav", + "text": "我想要請教主委" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148017/125.wav", + "text": "為什麼國發會到目前為止" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148017/126.wav", + "text": "沒有成立人權工作小組" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148017/127.wav", + "text": "這個部分我們是不是讓主委" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148017/128.wav", + "text": "先說明一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148017/129.wav", + "text": "因為我們不是執行機關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148017/130.wav", + "text": "所以涉及到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148017/131.wav", + "text": "直接的人權問題比較少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148017/132.wav", + "text": "是這樣嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148017/133.wav", + "text": "做人權教育推廣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148017/134.wav", + "text": "的經驗我相信" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148017/135.wav", + "text": "主委或您的幕僚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148017/136.wav", + "text": "在跟您討論到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148017/137.wav", + "text": "人權工作小組的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148017/138.wav", + "text": "可能有一些誤判" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148017/139.wav", + "text": "但是對於人權工作小組裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148017/140.wav", + "text": "才會有兒少代表這件事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148017/141.wav", + "text": "不知道主委" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148017/142.wav", + "text": "在今天上質詢台之前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148017/143.wav", + "text": "知不知道這個關係" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148017/144.wav", + "text": "我不知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148017/145.wav", + "text": "好沒關係" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148017/146.wav", + "text": "也因為您不知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148017/147.wav", + "text": "所以我就直接跟您分享" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148017/148.wav", + "text": "其實很多兒少代表在問" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148017/149.wav", + "text": "國發會沒有兒少��表這個事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148017/150.wav", + "text": "為什麼會有很大的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148017/151.wav", + "text": "因為國發會所主管的是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148017/152.wav", + "text": "全國的經濟發展" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148017/153.wav", + "text": "社會發展" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148017/154.wav", + "text": "產業發展" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148017/155.wav", + "text": "人力資源發展" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148017/156.wav", + "text": "文化族群發展" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148017/157.wav", + "text": "管制考核及行政與法制革新" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148017/158.wav", + "text": "等國家發展政策" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148017/159.wav", + "text": "當我們在想的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148017/160.wav", + "text": "都是發展發展發展" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148017/161.wav", + "text": "而要享受這個發展的成果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148017/162.wav", + "text": "或者是為了要加入這個發展行列的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148017/163.wav", + "text": "青少年兒少的代表" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148017/164.wav", + "text": "難道他們的聲音" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148017/165.wav", + "text": "不應該被政府機關聽見嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148017/166.wav", + "text": "所以我才會在今天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148017/167.wav", + "text": "想要拜託國發會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148017/168.wav", + "text": "有沒有機會組成相關的人權工作小組" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148017/169.wav", + "text": "邀請兒少代表參與" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148017/170.wav", + "text": "積極參與討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148017/171.wav", + "text": "聽取他們的聲音" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148017/172.wav", + "text": "他們的心聲" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148017/173.wav", + "text": "他們在每一個鄉鎮縣市" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148017/174.wav", + "text": "成長特殊的生活經驗求學經驗" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148017/175.wav", + "text": "納入當行政機關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148017/176.wav", + "text": "在做相關發展的考量的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148017/177.wav", + "text": "讓他們的聲音被聽見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148017/178.wav", + "text": "我相信這個也是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148017/179.wav", + "text": "整個行政院會支持的方向" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148017/180.wav", + "text": "主委這個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148017/181.wav", + "text": "你是第一次聽到沒有問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148017/182.wav", + "text": "但是後續有沒有機會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148017/183.wav", + "text": "給予相關的討論跟回應呢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148017/184.wav", + "text": "好我們來討論一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148017/185.wav", + "text": "有沒有可能" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148017/186.wav", + "text": "在一個月內給我們相關的評估報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148017/187.wav", + "text": "可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148017/188.wav", + "text": "或者是告訴我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148017/189.wav", + "text": "你們在之前的討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148017/190.wav", + "text": "是不是哪裡出現了一些漏洞" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148017/191.wav", + "text": "導致你們的幕僚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148017/192.wav", + "text": "到最後決定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148017/193.wav", + "text": "不成立人權工作小組" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148017/194.wav", + "text": "也就沒有兒少代表" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148017/195.wav", + "text": "一個月內是嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148017/196.wav", + "text": "好我們期待" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148017/197.wav", + "text": "看到這個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148017/198.wav", + "text": "可以往前進" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148017/199.wav", + "text": "未來在這22個機關裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148017/200.wav", + "text": "加入已成立人權工作小組的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148017/201.wav", + "text": "如果你們對人權工作小組" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148017/202.wav", + "text": "很多議題的推動" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148017/203.wav", + "text": "有不清楚的地方" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148017/204.wav", + "text": "也歡迎跟我們辦公室持續討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148017/205.wav", + "text": "好謝謝主委" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148017/206.wav", + "text": "謝謝主席" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148017/207.wav", + "text": "謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148017/208.wav", + "text": "好謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148016/0.wav", + "text": "另外我也要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148016/1.wav", + "text": "在這個地方謝謝一件事" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148016/2.wav", + "text": "因為我們蘭嶼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148016/3.wav", + "text": "有一位災民" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148016/4.wav", + "text": "他接到海巡署的通知" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148016/5.wav", + "text": "他的漁船" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148016/6.wav", + "text": "北方的富貴角" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148016/7.wav", + "text": "今天早上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148016/8.wav", + "text": "我們問了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148016/9.wav", + "text": "好像又漂到了淡水" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148016/10.wav", + "text": "一方面是要謝謝海巡署" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148016/11.wav", + "text": "但是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148016/12.wav", + "text": "這個船主也很頭痛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148016/13.wav", + "text": "因為這艘船" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148016/14.wav", + "text": "修船可能要七八十萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148016/15.wav", + "text": "這個拖船的費用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148016/16.wav", + "text": "它是半沉比較" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148016/17.wav", + "text": "沒辦法拖帶" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148016/18.wav", + "text": "帶我們有派100噸的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148016/19.wav", + "text": "艇在旁邊戒護" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148016/20.wav", + "text": "最好在今天拉回臺灣的漁港" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148016/21.wav", + "text": "因為他們也很怕風向" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148016/22.wav", + "text": "海流" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148016/23.wav", + "text": "如果今天再不處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148016/24.wav", + "text": "搞不好漂到中國" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148016/25.wav", + "text": "到時候變成國際事件" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148016/26.wav", + "text": "更麻煩" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148016/27.wav", + "text": "在這個地方我也代為轉達" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148016/28.wav", + "text": "這件事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148016/29.wav", + "text": "\n另外我們看到海巡署" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148016/30.wav", + "text": "其實也很辛苦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148016/31.wav", + "text": "關於非法越界的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148016/32.wav", + "text": "捕魚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148016/33.wav", + "text": "抽砂" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148016/34.wav", + "text": "現在算是蠻有成效" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148016/35.wav", + "text": "打擊走私非法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148016/36.wav", + "text": "入出境的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148016/37.wav", + "text": "部分我們看到也是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148016/38.wav", + "text": "很有成效" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148016/39.wav", + "text": "但是這也告訴我們查獲的越多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148016/40.wav", + "text": "就是代表走私的情形" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148016/41.wav", + "text": "更加嚴峻" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148016/42.wav", + "text": "中國漁船上面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148016/43.wav", + "text": "而且拒檢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148016/44.wav", + "text": "情況我只是想要表達" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148016/45.wav", + "text": "我們的海巡弟兄" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148016/46.wav", + "text": "其實蠻辛苦的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148016/47.wav", + "text": "所以未來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148016/48.wav", + "text": "如何確保海巡弟兄的安全" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148016/49.wav", + "text": "我想這個可能要去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148016/50.wav", + "text": "注意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148016/51.wav", + "text": "所以我們就很關心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148016/52.wav", + "text": "除了他們的安全" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148016/53.wav", + "text": "還有他們的辛勞" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148016/54.wav", + "text": "還有他們的異動" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148016/55.wav", + "text": "他們願不願意繼續" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148016/56.wav", + "text": "留在海巡作這份工作" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148016/57.wav", + "text": "\n我們看到海委會的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148016/58.wav", + "text": "業務報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148016/59.wav", + "text": "有增編員額" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148016/60.wav", + "text": "我不曉得預算員額有沒有增加" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148016/61.wav", + "text": "所以預算是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148016/62.wav", + "text": "逐年編列" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148016/63.wav", + "text": "我們第一年的預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148016/64.wav", + "text": "都有把第一年要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148016/65.wav", + "text": "增加的員額預算編列進來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148016/66.wav", + "text": "那實際的員額呢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148016/67.wav", + "text": "我們現在都是充足的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148016/68.wav", + "text": "以去年跟今年為例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148016/69.wav", + "text": "我們都有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148016/70.wav", + "text": "剩的預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148016/71.wav", + "text": "也就是說我們現在的預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148016/72.wav", + "text": "所編的錢足夠支付" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148016/73.wav", + "text": "薪資" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148016/74.wav", + "text": "好那我們來看海巡署" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148016/75.wav", + "text": "海巡署的預算員額" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148016/76.wav", + "text": "是有增加的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148016/77.wav", + "text": "雖然是持續" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148016/78.wav", + "text": "進用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148016/79.wav", + "text": "但是我們也發現" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148016/80.wav", + "text": "進用的人數" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148016/81.wav", + "text": "少於退離的人數" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148016/82.wav", + "text": "也就是說退離的人數" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148016/83.wav", + "text": "是很多的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148016/84.wav", + "text": "執行的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148016/85.wav", + "text": "我看到這個數據狀況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148016/86.wav", + "text": "也不是很好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148016/87.wav", + "text": "特別提為什麼我" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148016/88.wav", + "text": "特別重視離退" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148016/89.wav", + "text": "因為以我們原住民" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148016/90.wav", + "text": "來講雖然原住民的人口" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148016/91.wav", + "text": "占全國的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148016/92.wav", + "text": "百分之二點多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148016/93.wav", + "text": "所屬機關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148016/94.wav", + "text": "軍的部分是占" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148016/95.wav", + "text": "8%" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148016/96.wav", + "text": "警的部分是占" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148016/97.wav", + "text": "5%文職的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148016/98.wav", + "text": "就比較少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148016/99.wav", + "text": "沒有大概都是在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148016/100.wav", + "text": "這些年常常" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148016/101.wav", + "text": "接到一些陳情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148016/102.wav", + "text": "我們發現" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148016/103.wav", + "text": "他們服役到期就退伍不續留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148016/104.wav", + "text": "是因為他們覺得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148016/105.wav", + "text": "工作時間缺乏彈性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148016/106.wav", + "text": "不自由另外" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148016/107.wav", + "text": "就是關於待遇福利" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148016/108.wav", + "text": "的部分覺得管教不夠人性化" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148016/109.wav", + "text": "比較多的是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148016/110.wav", + "text": "調職太頻繁" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148016/111.wav", + "text": "就是他從工作" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148016/112.wav", + "text": "當中比較沒有辦法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148016/113.wav", + "text": "在職進修" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148016/114.wav", + "text": "沒有辦法獲得成就感" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148016/115.wav", + "text": "比較不順利" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148016/116.wav", + "text": "對他的退休福利制度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148016/117.wav", + "text": "他也沒有信心勤務" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148016/118.wav", + "text": "他的工作未來沒有辦法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148016/119.wav", + "text": "學以致用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148016/120.wav", + "text": "不曉得主委您覺得怎麼樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148016/121.wav", + "text": "很多的活動攤位都在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148016/122.wav", + "text": "招人招人招人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148016/123.wav", + "text": "但是也要重視怎麼留人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148016/124.wav", + "text": "所以這個部分有沒有想法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148016/125.wav", + "text": "跟委員報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148016/126.wav", + "text": "以今年來講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148016/127.wav", + "text": "剛剛有一個數字容我補充一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148016/128.wav", + "text": "就是到今年9月底的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148016/129.wav", + "text": "我們退職的人力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148016/130.wav", + "text": "大概預判是771個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148016/131.wav", + "text": "但是我們目前的招募" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148016/132.wav", + "text": "是834個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148016/133.wav", + "text": "所以是有超過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148016/134.wav", + "text": "然後可以有一點點增加" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148016/135.wav", + "text": "對我們來講是非常的重要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148016/136.wav", + "text": "我們有一個叫做最低執勤" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148016/137.wav", + "text": "所需的最低人力需求" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148016/138.wav", + "text": "那以最低人力需求來講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148016/139.wav", + "text": "我們目前是超過的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148016/140.wav", + "text": "是OK的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148016/141.wav", + "text": "所以海巡署現在是可以運作" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148016/142.wav", + "text": "沒有問題運作順暢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148016/143.wav", + "text": "但是當我們能夠更充分補充人力的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148016/144.wav", + "text": "大家的負擔相對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148016/145.wav", + "text": "就會比較減輕" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148016/146.wav", + "text": "比較減輕的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148016/147.wav", + "text": "您剛剛講的所謂人性化" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148016/148.wav", + "text": "我們署長也非常地支持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148016/149.wav", + "text": "就是我們的女性同仁" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148016/150.wav", + "text": "因為我們晚上不能散宿" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148016/151.wav", + "text": "晚上不能回家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148016/152.wav", + "text": "所以生了小孩以後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148016/153.wav", + "text": "做母親的事實上要盡母職" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148016/154.wav", + "text": "兩歲以下小孩的媽媽" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148016/155.wav", + "text": "晚上就可以外散宿" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148016/156.wav", + "text": "所以我們逐步地有在改進" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148016/157.wav", + "text": "主委我其實" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148016/158.wav", + "text": "談這些都是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148016/159.wav", + "text": "要提醒海巡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148016/160.wav", + "text": "工作很繁重" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148016/161.wav", + "text": "但是對國家來講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148016/162.wav", + "text": "很重要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148016/163.wav", + "text": "怎麼樣去留人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148016/164.wav", + "text": "我想這部分都要做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148016/165.wav", + "text": "全面性的一個檢討" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148016/166.wav", + "text": "包括時間不夠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148016/167.wav", + "text": "我們的裝備" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148016/168.wav", + "text": "也是非常重要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148016/169.wav", + "text": "但是我看到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148016/170.wav", + "text": "偵蒐裝備" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148016/171.wav", + "text": "像這些雷達探照燈" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148016/172.wav", + "text": "熱顯像儀等等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148016/173.wav", + "text": "我發現經費" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148016/174.wav", + "text": "編列都好少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148016/175.wav", + "text": "甚至像" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148016/176.wav", + "text": "110年是沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148016/177.wav", + "text": "編的時候也編個幾百萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148016/178.wav", + "text": "要有一個穩定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148016/179.wav", + "text": "我想這部分我們是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148016/180.wav", + "text": "支持的好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148016/181.wav", + "text": "那最後給我一分鐘" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148016/182.wav", + "text": "管很寬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148016/183.wav", + "text": "非常地寬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148016/184.wav", + "text": "海洋文化對我們原住民來講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148016/185.wav", + "text": "我相信原住民立委" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148016/186.wav", + "text": "都非常地重視" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148016/187.wav", + "text": "可是我發現" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148016/188.wav", + "text": "我們都無從得到補助" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148016/189.wav", + "text": "我舉個例子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148016/190.wav", + "text": "簡單的兩個例子主委你看一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148016/191.wav", + "text": "這是臺東的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148016/192.wav", + "text": "南島船隊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148016/193.wav", + "text": "他們去夏威夷" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148016/194.wav", + "text": "大洋洲比賽" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148016/195.wav", + "text": "可是你看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148016/196.wav", + "text": "我們在國際比賽即便拿到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148016/197.wav", + "text": "第一名冠軍" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148016/198.wav", + "text": "有辦法讓我們的國旗" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148016/199.wav", + "text": "飄揚嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148016/200.wav", + "text": "但是你看他們是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148016/201.wav", + "text": "被允許的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148016/202.wav", + "text": "南島的名義參加比賽" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148016/203.wav", + "text": "這個是多麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148016/204.wav", + "text": "讓人感動連那些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148016/205.wav", + "text": "國際人士在海外的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148016/206.wav", + "text": "非常的感動驕傲" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148016/207.wav", + "text": "不知道您有沒有看到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148016/208.wav", + "text": "9月的新聞美國" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148016/209.wav", + "text": "菲律賓有在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148016/210.wav", + "text": "討論距離臺灣不到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148016/211.wav", + "text": "200公里的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148016/212.wav", + "text": "巴丹島他們要建港" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148016/213.wav", + "text": "因為這是重要的島鏈" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148016/214.wav", + "text": "但是您知道嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148016/215.wav", + "text": "巴丹島很多的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148016/216.wav", + "text": "合作計畫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148016/217.wav", + "text": "對所以我在想" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148016/218.wav", + "text": "你看連他們的省長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148016/219.wav", + "text": "官員都肯定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148016/220.wav", + "text": "而且也願意讓我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148016/221.wav", + "text": "在他們的美軍預定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148016/222.wav", + "text": "基地跟他們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148016/223.wav", + "text": "會合進入他們的海域" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148016/224.wav", + "text": "我們都是用南島" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148016/225.wav", + "text": "蘭嶼臺灣的名義" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148016/226.wav", + "text": "這個是被允許的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148016/227.wav", + "text": "所以我的意思是說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148016/228.wav", + "text": "我們有時候參加這些比賽" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148016/229.wav", + "text": "拿不到海委會的補助" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148016/230.wav", + "text": "我已經質詢過很多年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148016/231.wav", + "text": "我覺得海委會要編" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148016/232.wav", + "text": "明年已經編了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148016/233.wav", + "text": "我們等一下審的預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148016/234.wav", + "text": "要不然我們老是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148016/235.wav", + "text": "剛剛蘭嶼到巴丹島的巡航" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148016/236.wav", + "text": "我們做了兩件事" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148016/237.wav", + "text": "一個是我們有給一筆補助經費" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148016/238.wav", + "text": "但是我們現在就" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148016/239.wav", + "text": "只有拿到戒護" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148016/240.wav", + "text": "我們要實質的補助經費" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148016/241.wav", + "text": "推動我們的南島文化" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148016/242.wav", + "text": "海洋文化" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148016/243.wav", + "text": "結果今年後來沒有辦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148016/244.wav", + "text": "我們本來已經匡了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148016/245.wav", + "text": "好像是40萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148016/246.wav", + "text": "這就是我們頭痛的地方" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148016/247.wav", + "text": "做這個活動要兩三千萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148016/248.wav", + "text": "就補助那麼一點點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148016/249.wav", + "text": "又不是在島內辦活動" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148016/250.wav", + "text": "所以我要講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148016/251.wav", + "text": "因為我們覺得海委會管很寬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148016/252.wav", + "text": "海洋文化也很重要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148016/253.wav", + "text": "我們的重要性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148016/254.wav", + "text": "要從你們編列的經費" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148016/255.wav", + "text": "去看到底重不重要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148016/256.wav", + "text": "好另外就是剛剛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148016/257.wav", + "text": "我們有和他們聯絡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148016/258.wav", + "text": "最主要是我們輔導他們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148016/259.wav", + "text": "要用部落或地方政府" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148016/260.wav", + "text": "或協會的名義來申請就可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148016/261.wav", + "text": "要看得到它的重要性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148016/262.wav", + "text": "好謝謝主委謝謝主席" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148016/263.wav", + "text": "謝謝伍麗華委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148016/264.wav", + "text": "\n接下來有請陳椒華委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148015/0.wav", + "text": "主委好對於金管會的預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148015/1.wav", + "text": "本席沒有意見大方向我支持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148015/2.wav", + "text": "主委曉不曉得從106年到今年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148015/3.wav", + "text": "到底有多少家上櫃轉上市" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148015/4.wav", + "text": "你大概知道有多少家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148015/5.wav", + "text": "報告委員我必須坦白說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148015/6.wav", + "text": "我不能用猜的這可能要請證期局" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148015/7.wav", + "text": "啦上櫃轉上市這個制度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148015/8.wav", + "text": "已實施多年請教主委" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148015/9.wav", + "text": "這是不是金管會的政策方向" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148015/10.wav", + "text": "上櫃跟上市是兩個不同性質的板塊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148015/11.wav", + "text": "所以會有這個機制去安排" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148015/12.wav", + "text": "最近我發現" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148015/13.wav", + "text": "櫃買跟證交所" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148015/14.wav", + "text": "兩個機構在互相放話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148015/15.wav", + "text": "放話過去當然都在推動" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148015/16.wav", + "text": "包括我本身當金管會主委" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148015/17.wav", + "text": "也都鼓勵上櫃轉上市" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148015/18.wav", + "text": "實施到現在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148015/19.wav", + "text": "既然櫃買跟證交所有不同意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148015/20.wav", + "text": "你要不要就上櫃轉上市這個政策" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148015/21.wav", + "text": "到底它的利弊怎麼樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148015/22.wav", + "text": "我們會進行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148015/23.wav", + "text": "我們大概要兩個月的時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148015/24.wav", + "text": "好因為過去這個政策已經實施多年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148015/25.wav", + "text": "但是其實現在也面臨瓶頸" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148015/26.wav", + "text": "我覺得應該是好好檢討的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148015/27.wav", + "text": "了\n另外最近我們證交所跟相關單位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148015/28.wav", + "text": "有去美國考察對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148015/29.wav", + "text": "是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148015/30.wav", + "text": "（T+1天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148015/31.wav", + "text": "）這樣的制度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148015/32.wav", + "text": "這個目前專案小組在研究" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148015/33.wav", + "text": "因為的確像美國印度可能近期都會去做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148015/34.wav", + "text": "那臺股作為一個國際化的市場" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148015/35.wav", + "text": "如果交割時間跟別人不一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148015/36.wav", + "text": "是不是會影響外資投資" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148015/37.wav", + "text": "那它的優點跟缺點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148015/38.wav", + "text": "主要是它的優點跟缺點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148015/39.wav", + "text": "T+1因為有美國和印度加拿大要實施" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148015/40.wav", + "text": "以歐盟來講它明年也會去正式評估" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148015/41.wav", + "text": "所以我們其實要了解各國的發展狀況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148015/42.wav", + "text": "來做一個確切的政策" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148015/43.wav", + "text": "所以政策方向會實施對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148015/44.wav", + "text": "主委會不會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148015/45.wav", + "text": "我覺得市場是國際化的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148015/46.wav", + "text": "這個事情的政策的確對我們有影響" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148015/47.wav", + "text": "我們會評估到底實施上會有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148015/48.wav", + "text": "哪些問題我們儘量去克服" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148015/49.wav", + "text": "看能不能朝那個方向" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148015/50.wav", + "text": "但還是要做可行性的研究" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148015/51.wav", + "text": "這個評估要多久" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148015/52.wav", + "text": "證交所已研究一段時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148015/53.wav", + "text": "最近又去美國考察" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148015/54.wav", + "text": "這個報告評估的結果大約什麼時候會出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148015/55.wav", + "text": "假如要做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148015/56.wav", + "text": "包括證交所櫃買和券商的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148015/57.wav", + "text": "程式都要改是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148015/58.wav", + "text": "這牽涉到非常廣非常大" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148015/59.wav", + "text": "包括投資人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148015/60.wav", + "text": "當然剛才局長跟我說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148015/61.wav", + "text": "我看如果能夠審慎起見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148015/62.wav", + "text": "來做這個研究" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148015/63.wav", + "text": "三年多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148015/64.wav", + "text": "我相信你做到明年520沒有問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148015/65.wav", + "text": "520的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148015/66.wav", + "text": "你會是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148015/67.wav", + "text": "金管會成立以來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148015/68.wav", + "text": "任期最長的主委對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148015/69.wav", + "text": "我不敢預估" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148015/70.wav", + "text": "努力每一天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148015/71.wav", + "text": "對會是任期最長的主委" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148015/72.wav", + "text": "已經超過3年了對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148015/73.wav", + "text": "有超過3年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148015/74.wav", + "text": "3年幾個月5" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148015/75.wav", + "text": "5月到現在5個月吧" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148015/76.wav", + "text": "已經3年5個月了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148015/77.wav", + "text": "你認為你任內" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148015/78.wav", + "text": "假如要列舉3項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148015/79.wav", + "text": "報告委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148015/80.wav", + "text": "您是我" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148015/81.wav", + "text": "推崇最前面的主委作" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148015/82.wav", + "text": "為我的標竿" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148015/83.wav", + "text": "我自己做的事情不敢給自己" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148015/84.wav", + "text": "總召給我打分數就好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148015/85.wav", + "text": "我不敢打" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148015/86.wav", + "text": "你要我打分數" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148015/87.wav", + "text": "至於什麼做得好什麼做得不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148015/88.wav", + "text": "我也不敢講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148015/89.wav", + "text": "我們先請示召委" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148015/90.wav", + "text": "召委你先打" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148015/91.wav", + "text": "兩位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148015/92.wav", + "text": "各言爾志吧" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148015/93.wav", + "text": "召委不打對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148015/94.wav", + "text": "好我來打" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148015/95.wav", + "text": "召委可以嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148015/96.wav", + "text": "80分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148015/97.wav", + "text": "主委這樣可不可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148015/98.wav", + "text": "你覺得報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148015/99.wav", + "text": "您在主委任內是我的標竿" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148015/100.wav", + "text": "以您為努力的目標" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148015/101.wav", + "text": "您比我高啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148015/102.wav", + "text": "我79分對你打80分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148015/103.wav", + "text": "你還是要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148015/104.wav", + "text": "列舉過去3項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148015/105.wav", + "text": "你覺得過去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148015/106.wav", + "text": "3年5個月來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148015/107.wav", + "text": "我覺得講政績就有點自我吹捧" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148015/108.wav", + "text": "不不會講事實沒關係" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148015/109.wav", + "text": "推動6項政策" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148015/110.wav", + "text": "3項就好不要太多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148015/111.wav", + "text": "我不太好講自己" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148015/112.wav", + "text": "哪個做得好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148015/113.wav", + "text": "跟我的個性不太一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148015/114.wav", + "text": "我還是不講可以嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148015/115.wav", + "text": "大家去評估" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148015/116.wav", + "text": "從現在到明年520" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148015/117.wav", + "text": "你最想做的是什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148015/118.wav", + "text": "報告委員我覺得資本市場的穩" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148015/119.wav", + "text": "定是我最在乎的事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148015/120.wav", + "text": "因為國際間政經" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148015/121.wav", + "text": "環境的波動" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148015/122.wav", + "text": "很多投資人的期待" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148015/123.wav", + "text": "我覺得資本市場的穩健發展" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148015/124.wav", + "text": "是我最在乎的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148015/125.wav", + "text": "好這算一項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148015/126.wav", + "text": "我們就把資本市場的發展" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148015/127.wav", + "text": "作為最重要的目標" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148015/128.wav", + "text": "謝謝總召" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148014/0.wav", + "text": "謝謝主席我們請部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148014/1.wav", + "text": "有請部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148014/2.wav", + "text": "部長好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148014/3.wav", + "text": "部長我想先討論一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148014/4.wav", + "text": "請部長看一下這個圖" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148014/5.wav", + "text": "上升在2017年有一個交叉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148014/6.wav", + "text": "一直到現在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148014/7.wav", + "text": "當然我們也討論了很多包括少子化" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148014/8.wav", + "text": "其實做得還不錯" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148014/9.wav", + "text": "地方很多人都覺得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148014/10.wav", + "text": "小英���統上任之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148014/11.wav", + "text": "一直到現在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148014/12.wav", + "text": "整個長照對於家裡面有長輩" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148014/13.wav", + "text": "需要被照顧的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148014/14.wav", + "text": "或者是臥床的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148014/15.wav", + "text": "真的是讓他們感受很深" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148014/16.wav", + "text": "替他們的家庭解決很多問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148014/17.wav", + "text": "假日的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148014/18.wav", + "text": "的機會所以很多人覺得這個長照" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148014/19.wav", + "text": "真的需要讓它永續" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148014/20.wav", + "text": "下去如果能夠服務得更好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148014/21.wav", + "text": "真的是幫助非常大" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148014/22.wav", + "text": "\n我想請教部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148014/23.wav", + "text": "的長期照顧服務涵蓋率" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148014/24.wav", + "text": "是76.91%" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148014/25.wav", + "text": "有長照需求的人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148014/26.wav", + "text": "未來我們要怎麼再加強" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148014/27.wav", + "text": "我們當然還是要再加強宣導" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148014/28.wav", + "text": "這些沒有受到長照服務的人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148014/29.wav", + "text": "但是有移工的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148014/30.wav", + "text": "有一些也有接受長照的服務" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148014/31.wav", + "text": "現在的重點是那些家人自己照顧" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148014/32.wav", + "text": "的就要特別要去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148014/33.wav", + "text": "藉由各種觸角" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148014/34.wav", + "text": "包括社會安全網等等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148014/35.wav", + "text": "這些觸角去接觸到的就" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148014/36.wav", + "text": "就把他轉介出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148014/37.wav", + "text": "有一些可能他知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148014/38.wav", + "text": "但是他不想用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148014/39.wav", + "text": "必須去做分析" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148014/40.wav", + "text": "比如有的老人家不喜歡自己" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148014/41.wav", + "text": "家人以外的人來照顧他" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148014/42.wav", + "text": "以這部分也是我們努力的方向" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148014/43.wav", + "text": "大約就是這兩類" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148014/44.wav", + "text": "好我也讓部長看一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148014/45.wav", + "text": "是差不多45億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148014/46.wav", + "text": "還有基金的用途" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148014/47.wav", + "text": "這個幅度一直成長的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148014/48.wav", + "text": "你的這個經費到底要從哪幾項稅收" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148014/49.wav", + "text": "跟委員報告這個是預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148014/50.wav", + "text": "基金的用途預算達成率都不錯" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148014/51.wav", + "text": "也就是說編了這麼多預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148014/52.wav", + "text": "差不多就這麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148014/53.wav", + "text": "因為是財政部給我們的資料" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148014/54.wav", + "text": "先做預估" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148014/55.wav", + "text": "今年��起來大概都" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148014/56.wav", + "text": "所以現在是說稅收多少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148014/57.wav", + "text": "你們就做多少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148014/58.wav", + "text": "都比原來的預算超收滿多的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148014/59.wav", + "text": "大概是平平" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148014/60.wav", + "text": "但是我們目前已經累積100多億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148014/61.wav", + "text": "元就是這個原因" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148014/62.wav", + "text": "是所以就是稅收大約是多少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148014/63.wav", + "text": "然後你們隔一年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148014/64.wav", + "text": "的用途大約會花多少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148014/65.wav", + "text": "是由我們來設計的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148014/66.wav", + "text": "我們是先以財政部提供給我們的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148014/67.wav", + "text": "收多少去訂" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148014/68.wav", + "text": "但是後來這些年來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148014/69.wav", + "text": "大概每年都是超收" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148014/70.wav", + "text": "所以就沒有問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148014/71.wav", + "text": "是因為前幾年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148014/72.wav", + "text": "整個臺灣的經濟狀況都還不錯" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148014/73.wav", + "text": "我舉個例子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148014/74.wav", + "text": "111年就是去年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148014/75.wav", + "text": "編的來源是567億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148014/76.wav", + "text": "元但是實際上收的是938億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148014/77.wav", + "text": "光是這一個部分就多了三百零多億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148014/78.wav", + "text": "是所以我想請教" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148014/79.wav", + "text": "部長長照基金的永續經營" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148014/80.wav", + "text": "按照這樣子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148014/81.wav", + "text": "逐年一直在增加的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148014/82.wav", + "text": "也許有一天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148014/83.wav", + "text": "基金的來源" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148014/84.wav", + "text": "可能不足以去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148014/85.wav", + "text": "基金的用途預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148014/86.wav", + "text": "如果是這樣子的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148014/87.wav", + "text": "因為最近大家也一直提到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148014/88.wav", + "text": "基金的來源是用稅收" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148014/89.wav", + "text": "未來有沒有可能" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148014/90.wav", + "text": "我想請教部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148014/91.wav", + "text": "或者是保險" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148014/92.wav", + "text": "長照的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148014/93.wav", + "text": "用這兩方面來支付的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148014/94.wav", + "text": "有沒有針對這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148014/95.wav", + "text": "去做一個規劃" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148014/96.wav", + "text": "在我們長照2.0" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148014/97.wav", + "text": "就已經有一些評估了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148014/98.wav", + "text": "就是保險制和稅收制的一些利弊得失" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148014/99.wav", + "text": "我簡單向委員報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148014/100.wav", + "text": "可能出的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148014/101.wav", + "text": "第一個就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148014/102.wav", + "text": "去規劃資源的布建" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148014/103.wav", + "text": "所以等於是資源布建" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148014/104.wav", + "text": "又要另外從公務預算來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148014/105.wav", + "text": "那目前稅收制的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148014/106.wav", + "text": "我們是包含在裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148014/107.wav", + "text": "這是第一個\n" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148014/108.wav", + "text": "目前的稅收制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148014/109.wav", + "text": "就是我們剛剛講的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148014/110.wav", + "text": "我們先說預算要支出多少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148014/111.wav", + "text": "可以再去尋找財源" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148014/112.wav", + "text": "去爭取財源的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148014/113.wav", + "text": "那未來有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148014/114.wav", + "text": "再另外去爭取財源" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148014/115.wav", + "text": "但是保險制的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148014/116.wav", + "text": "就是隨收隨付" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148014/117.wav", + "text": "我收到的保費" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148014/118.wav", + "text": "就是要把它用掉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148014/119.wav", + "text": "就是這個樣子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148014/120.wav", + "text": "就容易會有浪費出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148014/121.wav", + "text": "就是說不需要花的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148014/122.wav", + "text": "所以必須要把它花掉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148014/123.wav", + "text": "\n第三個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148014/124.wav", + "text": "從其他國家的經驗" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148014/125.wav", + "text": "比方說採保險制的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148014/126.wav", + "text": "德國日本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148014/127.wav", + "text": "稅收在做補助" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148014/128.wav", + "text": "也就是說保險制收入是不足的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148014/129.wav", + "text": "但是保費要去做調整" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148014/130.wav", + "text": "是有困難的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148014/131.wav", + "text": "所以到後來還是用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148014/132.wav", + "text": "所以部長你是覺得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148014/133.wav", + "text": "對民眾或者是對政府的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148014/134.wav", + "text": "是沒有錯" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148014/135.wav", + "text": "資源布建還在進行當中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148014/136.wav", + "text": "是比較有利" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148014/137.wav", + "text": "好謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148014/138.wav", + "text": "其實我們一直覺得長照" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148014/139.wav", + "text": "下真的是做得不錯" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148014/140.wav", + "text": "不過做得不錯也還有一個錯字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148014/141.wav", + "text": "還有可以再加強的地方" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148014/142.wav", + "text": "對永遠都有改進的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148014/143.wav", + "text": "可是還有一些地方需要去加強" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148014/144.wav", + "text": "我們也希望能夠繼續延續下去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148014/145.wav", + "text": "讓需要照顧的人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148014/146.wav", + "text": "能夠得到政府最好的照顧" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148014/147.wav", + "text": "是謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148012/0.wav", + "text": "請農業部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148012/1.wav", + "text": "是現在國際上面大家都非常非常關注的事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148012/2.wav", + "text": "在我們的農業部門裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148012/3.wav", + "text": "那我就直接跟次長和農業部詢問" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148012/4.wav", + "text": "目前農業部門推動漁電共生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148012/5.wav", + "text": "時遇到比較大的挑戰跟困難在哪裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148012/6.wav", + "text": "報告委員漁電共生是以漁為主" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148012/7.wav", + "text": "因為就農業部來講漁業生產還是為主" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148012/8.wav", + "text": "委員好目前遇到最大的困難還是在於" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148012/9.wav", + "text": "怎麼做合作" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148012/10.wav", + "text": "然後以綠電加值的做法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148012/11.wav", + "text": "怎麼去做一些融合" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148012/12.wav", + "text": "好所以是養殖為本綠電加值" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148012/13.wav", + "text": "我知道這一段時間大家在社會上有很多關於光電的討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148012/14.wav", + "text": "不希望光電的設置影響到漁業生產沒有錯次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148012/15.wav", + "text": "現在我們強調養殖為本跟綠電加值" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148012/16.wav", + "text": "如果現在想要來做跟主導這個計畫的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148012/17.wav", + "text": "有些計畫可能過去比較多是能源的廠商在做相關的規劃" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148012/18.wav", + "text": "但接下來開始有一些案場的規劃是漁民來規劃" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148012/19.wav", + "text": "而且漁民的規劃裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148012/20.wav", + "text": "也就是並不會因為光電的設置而放棄養殖" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148012/21.wav", + "text": "次長你覺得這個部分農業部應該大力鼓勵大力輔導嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148012/22.wav", + "text": "沒錯如果漁民自己" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148012/23.wav", + "text": "漁業為本這一定是最重要的前提" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148012/24.wav", + "text": "不用多說一定是要以漁業為本的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148012/25.wav", + "text": "所以如果以漁民為主體來投入來規劃的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148012/26.wav", + "text": "這是不是農業部應該要大力來協助的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148012/27.wav", + "text": "是我們認為這是可以協助的方向" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148012/28.wav", + "text": "我們現在收到南瀛養殖協會的陳情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148012/29.wav", + "text": "尤其是他們自己來做案場的規劃" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148012/30.wav", + "text": "所以他們自己找了綠能的業者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148012/31.wav", + "text": "也包括了由漁民自己基於他們在漁業上面養殖的知能知識" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148012/32.wav", + "text": "來做了相關設計圖" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148012/33.wav", + "text": "甚至還是2019年的全國模範漁民" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148012/34.wav", + "text": "他瞭解漁電共生以後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148012/35.wav", + "text": "讓漁民有多一個收入" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148012/36.wav", + "text": "\n現在他們想要藉由這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148012/37.wav", + "text": "漁民為主的協會來成立平台" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148012/38.wav", + "text": "來協助做管理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148012/39.wav", + "text": "跟業者來協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148012/40.wav", + "text": "甚至不透過土地的仲介" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148012/41.wav", + "text": "希望能夠來保障漁民的權益" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148012/42.wav", + "text": "目前協會有幾百位成員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148012/43.wav", + "text": "第一波已經有十幾位漁民願意來做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148012/44.wav", + "text": "後面還有很多漁民也在觀望之中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148012/45.wav", + "text": "包括他們要求" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148012/46.wav", + "text": "漁民跟業者之間要怎麼樣合乎相關的規範" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148012/47.wav", + "text": "漁民可能會落入比較弱勢的局面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148012/48.wav", + "text": "在跟業者之間的合作可能會有權利上面的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148012/49.wav", + "text": "如果有養殖漁民中間不養了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148012/50.wav", + "text": "他們還是可以找到透過養青聯盟" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148012/51.wav", + "text": "二代三代還可以協助人進駐" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148012/52.wav", + "text": "來確保養殖跟收成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148012/53.wav", + "text": "他們花了很多的力氣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148012/54.wav", + "text": "這個非常重要的前提" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148012/55.wav", + "text": "次長我想問一個問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148012/56.wav", + "text": "當他們做了這麼完整的規劃的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148012/57.wav", + "text": "變成是一個很好的示範" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148012/58.wav", + "text": "而且變成是漁民主導的案例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148012/59.wav", + "text": "我們可以大力來協助跟輔導他們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148012/60.wav", + "text": "一起去完成這樣子的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148012/61.wav", + "text": "好可是現在問題來了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148012/62.wav", + "text": "農業部或漁業署" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148012/63.wav", + "text": "但是這些管理的辦法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148012/64.wav", + "text": "比較像是對這些漁民來做稽核" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148012/65.wav", + "text": "來做管理他們比較少有被輔導的感覺" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148012/66.wav", + "text": "案場相關的設計" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148012/67.wav", + "text": "不太受到農業部的支持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148012/68.wav", + "text": "我自己完全瞭解" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148012/69.wav", + "text": "從農業部的角度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148012/70.wav", + "text": "從漁業署的角度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148012/71.wav", + "text": "或以漁業為主導這個概念受損" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148012/72.wav", + "text": "所以我們要透過一些管理的方法來做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148012/73.wav", + "text": "是漁民想要主動來投入" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148012/74.wav", + "text": "包括他們的養殖計畫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148012/75.wav", + "text": "都是由漁民來主導" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148012/76.wav", + "text": "不是由光電跟能源廠商來主導這時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148012/77.wav", + "text": "我們在管理的思維上面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148012/78.wav", + "text": "是不是就應該做一些改變" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148012/79.wav", + "text": "謝謝委員提醒" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148012/80.wav", + "text": "其實大家要達到的目的是一樣的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148012/81.wav", + "text": "或我們的管理上面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148012/82.wav", + "text": "思考要不要再檢討" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148012/83.wav", + "text": "的部分我們是可以來研議看看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148012/84.wav", + "text": "我想跟大家報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148012/85.wav", + "text": "像這樣子的案例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148012/86.wav", + "text": "假如是漁民" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148012/87.wav", + "text": "主動想要來做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148012/88.wav", + "text": "由漁民來主導的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148012/89.wav", + "text": "我認為我們可以給他們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148012/90.wav", + "text": "多一點彈性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148012/91.wav", + "text": "但是給彈性當然不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148012/92.wav", + "text": "想要怎樣就怎樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148012/93.wav", + "text": "也不是這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148012/94.wav", + "text": "可是我們是不是有可能" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148012/95.wav", + "text": "有一些示範性的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148012/96.wav", + "text": "或是專業的審查機制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148012/97.wav", + "text": "來確認假如是漁民主導的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148012/98.wav", + "text": "在案場的設計上面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148012/99.wav", + "text": "是否可以有一個更有彈性的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148012/100.wav", + "text": "這樣的案子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148012/101.wav", + "text": "假如可以做得出來的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148012/102.wav", + "text": "我知道現在後面還有很多漁民" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148012/103.wav", + "text": "也是秉持著同樣的理念跟前提" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148012/104.wav", + "text": "想要投入到漁電共生裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148012/105.wav", + "text": "去取得雙贏" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148012/106.wav", + "text": "而且這個雙贏" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148012/107.wav", + "text": "不是大家過去擔心的那種" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148012/108.wav", + "text": "主要是以光電為主的方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148012/109.wav", + "text": "而是以漁民為主" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148012/110.wav", + "text": "讓漁民增加收入的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148012/111.wav", + "text": "方式這樣子的做法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148012/112.wav", + "text": "應該是農業部跟漁業署" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148012/113.wav", + "text": "大力協助" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148012/114.wav", + "text": "的應該沒有問題吧" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148012/115.wav", + "text": "是的謝謝委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148012/116.wav", + "text": "我們就朝這個方向來思考" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148012/117.wav", + "text": "好我同意這後面需要一些配套" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148012/118.wav", + "text": "這個配套可能包括" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148012/119.wav", + "text": "一些專業的審查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148012/120.wav", + "text": "包括要有一些現勘" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148012/121.wav", + "text": "包括可能要有一些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148012/122.wav", + "text": "智慧性養殖的監測" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148012/123.wav", + "text": "來確保這些漁業養殖計畫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148012/124.wav", + "text": "可以順利完成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148012/125.wav", + "text": "可以達到政策目標" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148012/126.wav", + "text": "我同意這些事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148012/127.wav", + "text": "這是配套的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148012/128.wav", + "text": "所以我要請問次長跟漁業署" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148012/129.wav", + "text": "可不可以在一個禮拜內" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148012/130.wav", + "text": "可不可以在一個禮拜內" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148012/131.wav", + "text": "下場主導設計計畫的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148012/132.wav", + "text": "有一個管理方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148012/133.wav", + "text": "這個管理方式不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148012/134.wav", + "text": "就開大門不管" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148012/135.wav", + "text": "而是一樣有管理的配套" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148012/136.wav", + "text": "但是是一個以協助" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148012/137.wav", + "text": "跟輔導為精神的思考" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148012/138.wav", + "text": "而不是只是一個管制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148012/139.wav", + "text": "跟稽查跟稽核的思考" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148012/140.wav", + "text": "漁業署可不可能在一個禮拜內" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148012/141.wav", + "text": "跟委員報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148012/142.wav", + "text": "第一個部分是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148012/143.wav", + "text": "整個綠能這一塊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148012/144.wav", + "text": "最主要的問題在於集中鋪排的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148012/145.wav", + "text": "那相關部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148012/146.wav", + "text": "就是像委員所提到的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148012/147.wav", + "text": "下面除了水池以外" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148012/148.wav", + "text": "還是有做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148012/149.wav", + "text": "並沒有放棄養殖" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148012/150.wav", + "text": "是結合了原本農業部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148012/151.wav", + "text": "跟漁業署揭櫫的計畫目標" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148012/152.wav", + "text": "是要養殖為本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148012/153.wav", + "text": "養殖為主的計畫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148012/154.wav", + "text": "是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148012/155.wav", + "text": "謝謝委員這樣子的垂詢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148012/156.wav", + "text": "比較特殊性的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148012/157.wav", + "text": "剛才次長已經有提到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148012/158.wav", + "text": "我們會來大力協助" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148012/159.wav", + "text": "至於在什麼樣的條件下面的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148012/160.wav", + "text": "是不是可以用試驗的方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148012/161.wav", + "text": "現在不是一下就要開大門" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148012/162.wav", + "text": "你可以針對他的條件來做設計" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148012/163.wav", + "text": "如果是漁民為主導" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148012/164.wav", + "text": "漁民為主體的這個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148012/165.wav", + "text": "怎麼樣開一個多一點彈性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148012/166.wav", + "text": "再加上有一些有效管理的配套" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148012/167.wav", + "text": "這部分我都同意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148012/168.wav", + "text": "但是不要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148012/169.wav", + "text": "基於某一些官僚的想法或官僚主義" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148012/170.wav", + "text": "雙贏的初衷打了折扣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148012/171.wav", + "text": "次長副署長可以吧" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148012/172.wav", + "text": "一個禮拜內" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148012/173.wav", + "text": "沒有問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148012/174.wav", + "text": "沒有問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148011/0.wav", + "text": "餐會還有旅遊這也是過去傳統的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148011/1.wav", + "text": "啦現在當然也有很多支付財務的方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148011/2.wav", + "text": "譬如新興的虛擬貨幣第三方支付等等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148011/3.wav", + "text": "我們都有密切在注意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148011/4.wav", + "text": "態樣根據你們法務部的統計分析" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148011/5.wav", + "text": "109年度以現金買票為最大宗占比為46%" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148011/6.wav", + "text": "其次為餐會及贈送禮品" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148011/7.wav", + "text": "各占19%及14%" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148011/8.wav", + "text": "到了去年111年度地方選舉的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148011/9.wav", + "text": "也是以現金買票為主占比更高占" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148011/10.wav", + "text": "贈送禮品則是19%" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148011/11.wav", + "text": "\n剛才部長提到一個重點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148011/12.wav", + "text": "第三方支付現在非常的發達" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148011/13.wav", + "text": "通常都是用這種方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148011/14.wav", + "text": "所以面對這種新興的第三方支付方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148011/15.wav", + "text": "包括LINE Pay" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148011/16.wav", + "text": "Pi錢包街口支付" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148011/17.wav", + "text": "歐付寶等數位支付工具" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148011/18.wav", + "text": "如果把它當作賄選的一個方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148011/19.wav", + "text": "那法務部對於這部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148011/20.wav", + "text": "有沒有做任何的預防" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148011/21.wav", + "text": "就是查察遏阻以這種方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148011/22.wav", + "text": "來作為賄選的一個規劃" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148011/23.wav", + "text": "最高檢它有邀集相關的單位來研擬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148011/24.wav", + "text": "怎麼樣防制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148011/25.wav", + "text": "用這些新興貨幣的方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148011/26.wav", + "text": "或是支付的方式來查察賄選" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148011/27.wav", + "text": "他們都有事先研擬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148011/28.wav", + "text": "其實部長我比較想請問的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148011/29.wav", + "text": "是我們對這些新興的數位賄選案件" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148011/30.wav", + "text": "以目前來講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148011/31.wav", + "text": "未來很有可能大部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148011/32.wav", + "text": "是以這種新興支付工具來作為賄選的方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148011/33.wav", + "text": "把它作為賄選的工具會越來越增加" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148011/34.wav", + "text": "就不是以傳統的現金買票" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148011/35.wav", + "text": "或者贈送禮品的方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148011/36.wav", + "text": "所以未來我們調查局也好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148011/37.wav", + "text": "對於以這種方式來買票的行為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148011/38.wav", + "text": "是不是應該提早做出規劃" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148011/39.wav", + "text": "還是你們這邊會有一個主動" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148011/40.wav", + "text": "我們有主動去瞭解" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148011/41.wav", + "text": "而且蒐集一些相關的資訊來做教育" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148011/42.wav", + "text": "讓偵辦人員也能夠清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148011/43.wav", + "text": "這樣的運作是如何" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148011/44.wav", + "text": "如果用在選舉可能會用什麼方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148011/45.wav", + "text": "這個我們都有預先的一些研討會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148011/46.wav", + "text": "那你向民眾做宣導方面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148011/47.wav", + "text": "呢有沒有去告訴社會大眾" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148011/48.wav", + "text": "很有可能用這種方式來買票" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148011/49.wav", + "text": "有宣導的話我們會用各種方式來讓民眾瞭解" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148011/50.wav", + "text": "是我想這部分可能要儘速去加強建置" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148011/51.wav", + "text": "好謝謝委員提醒" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148011/52.wav", + "text": "第二個問題想請問部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148011/53.wav", + "text": "今年8月22日法務部也修正公布" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148011/54.wav", + "text": "鼓勵檢舉妨害選舉要點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148011/55.wav", + "text": "擴大檢舉範圍" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148011/56.wav", + "text": "把境外勢力及選舉賭盤" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148011/57.wav", + "text": "等妨害選舉的犯罪行為來納入" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148011/58.wav", + "text": "我想先就教部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148011/59.wav", + "text": "所謂的境外勢力它的定義是什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148011/60.wav", + "text": "就是在國內以外" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148011/61.wav", + "text": "的這個境外" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148011/62.wav", + "text": "如果想要影響到整個選舉的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148011/63.wav", + "text": "我們都是把它歸類為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148011/64.wav", + "text": "是那以目前來講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148011/65.wav", + "text": "就是特定指中國大陸" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148011/66.wav", + "text": "也可能有外國要涉及到影響" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148011/67.wav", + "text": "都會在我們整個範圍內" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148011/68.wav", + "text": "所以部長你的意思是說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148011/69.wav", + "text": "不限於指中國大陸" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148011/70.wav", + "text": "或者是港澳" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148011/71.wav", + "text": "其他國家也有可能" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148011/72.wav", + "text": "反滲透法本身就有對於境外勢力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148011/73.wav", + "text": "做一個定義" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148011/74.wav", + "text": "因為我現在看到我們的高層" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148011/75.wav", + "text": "對於明年2024的正副總統大選" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148011/76.wav", + "text": "我看到媒體的報導" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148011/77.wav", + "text": "大部分都是說中共會介入" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148011/78.wav", + "text": "我們一直講說中共會介入" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148011/79.wav", + "text": "所以有什麼徵兆會讓我們的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148011/80.wav", + "text": "或者其他一些政府部門" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148011/81.wav", + "text": "我們的正副總統大選" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148011/82.wav", + "text": "所謂的境外勢力介入" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148011/83.wav", + "text": "有沒有具體的徵兆" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148011/84.wav", + "text": "可以讓我們來做出這樣的判斷" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148011/85.wav", + "text": "國安局來回答" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148011/86.wav", + "text": "因為反滲透法裡面的規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148011/87.wav", + "text": "不是針對某特定國家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148011/88.wav", + "text": "而是對我們中華民國" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148011/89.wav", + "text": "這個我們把它列入" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148011/90.wav", + "text": "除了指中國大陸以外" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148011/91.wav", + "text": "我這樣問好了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148011/92.wav", + "text": "在2020總統大選" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148011/93.wav", + "text": "所謂的境外勢力介入選舉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148011/94.wav", + "text": "除了中國大陸以外" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148011/95.wav", + "text": "有其他國家嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148011/96.wav", + "text": "有沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148011/97.wav", + "text": "這是上一屆的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148011/98.wav", + "text": "那你要提早做預防" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148011/99.wav", + "text": "目前的蒐報大概就是委員所講的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148011/100.wav", + "text": "就是中共這一部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148011/101.wav", + "text": "其他的倒沒有具體的個案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148011/102.wav", + "text": "證明它有干預我們選舉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148011/103.wav", + "text": "中共有介入我們選舉的案例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148011/104.wav", + "text": "選舉嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148011/105.wav", + "text": "我們今年的正副總統大選" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148011/106.wav", + "text": "根據調查局給我的資料" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148011/107.wav", + "text": "去年有5件" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148011/108.wav", + "text": "去年是地方選舉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148011/109.wav", + "text": "我是說今年2024" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148011/110.wav", + "text": "到目前為止有沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148011/111.wav", + "text": "現在離選舉還有八十幾天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148011/112.wav", + "text": "今年我們是情報蒐集" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148011/113.wav", + "text": "把可疑的交給檢調單位來調查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148011/114.wav", + "text": "目前的狀況是這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148011/115.wav", + "text": "還在持續中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148011/116.wav", + "text": "是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148011/117.wav", + "text": "不管是法務部也好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148011/118.wav", + "text": "還是國安局也好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148011/119.wav", + "text": "有關境外勢力介入選舉的界定上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148011/120.wav", + "text": "務必要以中立的角度來進行偵辦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148011/121.wav", + "text": "當然我們行政中立" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148011/122.wav", + "text": "有一分證據說一分話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148011/123.wav", + "text": "沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148011/124.wav", + "text": "怎樣全部丟給中共" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148011/125.wav", + "text": "我想這樣也不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148011/126.wav", + "text": "啦如果有其他境外勢力的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148011/127.wav", + "text": "我們還是要去做查察" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148011/128.wav", + "text": "還是要去做瞭解" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148011/129.wav", + "text": "不要所有的都說是中共" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148011/130.wav", + "text": "我希望你們要中立一點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148011/131.wav", + "text": "是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148011/132.wav", + "text": "沒問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148011/133.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148011/134.wav", + "text": "第三個問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148011/135.wav", + "text": "假新聞的因應措施" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148011/136.wav", + "text": "我想剛才部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148011/137.wav", + "text": "回答賴香伶委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148011/138.wav", + "text": "講得很清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148011/139.wav", + "text": "對於這些用AI深偽技術" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148011/140.wav", + "text": "所製作出來的影音" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148011/141.wav", + "text": "或者是影片也好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148011/142.wav", + "text": "我們會立即地澄清" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148011/143.wav", + "text": "就是對於假訊息" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148011/144.wav", + "text": "只要有民眾檢舉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148011/145.wav", + "text": "或者是在媒體上發布" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148011/146.wav", + "text": "我們一旦瞭解" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148011/147.wav", + "text": "甚至應該不用透過檢舉吧" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148011/148.wav", + "text": "我們應該就會馬上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148011/149.wav", + "text": "主動去瞭解這個訊息的真偽" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148011/150.wav", + "text": "以免大家被假訊息" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148011/151.wav", + "text": "牽著鼻子走" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148011/152.wav", + "text": "嘛所以站在法務部的立場" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148011/153.wav", + "text": "假新聞" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148011/154.wav", + "text": "是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148011/155.wav", + "text": "假訊息企圖要影響選舉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148011/156.wav", + "text": "也是我們這一次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148011/157.wav", + "text": "選舉查察的一個重心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148011/158.wav", + "text": "所以各地的執行小組" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148011/159.wav", + "text": "由檢察長來召集" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148011/160.wav", + "text": "他也會跟當地的檢警調廉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148011/161.wav", + "text": "廉及移民他們都會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148011/162.wav", + "text": "針對假訊息立即地查證" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148011/163.wav", + "text": "如果在查證清楚以後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148011/164.wav", + "text": "應該要對外做澄清說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148011/165.wav", + "text": "是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148011/166.wav", + "text": "所以我的意思是說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148011/167.wav", + "text": "針對我們剛才講的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148011/168.wav", + "text": "鄭文燦副院長這件事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148011/169.wav", + "text": "很多民眾相信他是清白的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148011/170.wav", + "text": "看起來很像是他" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148011/171.wav", + "text": "所以這一點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148011/172.wav", + "text": "站在法務部的立場" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148011/173.wav", + "text": "我覺得你有對外" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148011/174.wav", + "text": "這樣子一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148011/175.wav", + "text": "立即澄清的立���" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148011/176.wav", + "text": "我剛剛有說明過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148011/177.wav", + "text": "個案不宜由我法務部的立場來說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148011/178.wav", + "text": "但是由承辦單位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148011/179.wav", + "text": "看過所有的卷宗" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148011/180.wav", + "text": "做過鑑定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148011/181.wav", + "text": "認定清楚了以後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148011/182.wav", + "text": "有必要對外說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148011/183.wav", + "text": "他們就應該要對外說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148011/184.wav", + "text": "這個就是涉及到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148011/185.wav", + "text": "是不是假訊息的製作" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148011/186.wav", + "text": "說是個案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148011/187.wav", + "text": "這已經不僅僅是一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148011/188.wav", + "text": "個案的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148011/189.wav", + "text": "在媒體上散布" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148011/190.wav", + "text": "這段影片" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148011/191.wav", + "text": "那" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148011/192.wav", + "text": "這不是我" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148011/193.wav", + "text": "是剪輯的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148011/194.wav", + "text": "有人剪接的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148011/195.wav", + "text": "所以這涉及到這則新聞" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148011/196.wav", + "text": "這個影音是不是假的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148011/197.wav", + "text": "我們應該" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148011/198.wav", + "text": "我同意要立即澄清" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148011/199.wav", + "text": "但是說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148011/200.wav", + "text": "是由誰來說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148011/201.wav", + "text": "那法務部是檢察行政的單位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148011/202.wav", + "text": "我會督促" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148011/203.wav", + "text": "承辦的單位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148011/204.wav", + "text": "或是鑑定的單位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148011/205.wav", + "text": "它有結果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148011/206.wav", + "text": "要儘快對外" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148011/207.wav", + "text": "是我想我們的立場就很鮮明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148011/208.wav", + "text": "要立即去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148011/209.wav", + "text": "瞭解去澄清" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148011/210.wav", + "text": "最後一個問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148011/211.wav", + "text": "再請教部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148011/212.wav", + "text": "30元是一個上限" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148011/213.wav", + "text": "沒有改變" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148011/214.wav", + "text": "沒有改變" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148011/215.wav", + "text": "贈送的禮品" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148011/216.wav", + "text": "這樣有沒有構成賄選" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148011/217.wav", + "text": "我的說明是這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148011/218.wav", + "text": "我們偵查的一個門檻" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148011/219.wav", + "text": "因為如果它的價值很低" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148011/220.wav", + "text": "微不足以影響" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148011/221.wav", + "text": "整個選舉的意向的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148011/222.wav", + "text": "我們就不要浪費力氣在這邊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148011/223.wav", + "text": "它超過30元" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148011/224.wav", + "text": "有可能會涉及到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148011/225.wav", + "text": "我們才會啟動" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148011/226.wav", + "text": "偵查是這樣的一個門檻標準" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148011/227.wav", + "text": "不是說認定它" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148011/228.wav", + "text": "構不構成賄選" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148011/229.wav", + "text": "是由承辦的檢察官" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148011/230.wav", + "text": "來認定構不構成犯罪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148011/231.wav", + "text": "但是我們自己要發動" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148011/232.wav", + "text": "偵查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148011/233.wav", + "text": "蒐集證據的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148011/234.wav", + "text": "我們自己是有一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148011/235.wav", + "text": "這樣的標準" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148011/236.wav", + "text": "也告訴所有的民眾" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148011/237.wav", + "text": "超過30元" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148011/238.wav", + "text": "很可能會接受調查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148011/239.wav", + "text": "就是這樣子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148011/240.wav", + "text": "是一個啟動偵查的門檻" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148011/241.wav", + "text": "不代表說他被偵查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148011/242.wav", + "text": "就一定會被起訴" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148011/243.wav", + "text": "對那當然就是個案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148011/244.wav", + "text": "看金額有沒有影響到他投票的意願" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148011/245.wav", + "text": "好另外我想再瞭解一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148011/246.wav", + "text": "我們在辦理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148011/247.wav", + "text": "總部的成立大會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148011/248.wav", + "text": "大會完畢之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148011/249.wav", + "text": "請問這個標準" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148011/250.wav", + "text": "比如說提供100元以內的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148011/251.wav", + "text": "在100元以內" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148011/252.wav", + "text": "這樣會不會構成賄選" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148011/253.wav", + "text": "簡單的飲食" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148011/254.wav", + "text": "刑事案件例舉裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148011/255.wav", + "text": "蒐集了很多法院的判決" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148011/256.wav", + "text": "及法律問題的研究" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148011/257.wav", + "text": "都有把那些具體的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148011/258.wav", + "text": "個案情節蒐集起來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148011/259.wav", + "text": "哪些是構成的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148011/260.wav", + "text": "哪些是很明顯不構成的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148011/261.wav", + "text": "我們有把這些過去的判決" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148011/262.wav", + "text": "來供大家參考" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148011/263.wav", + "text": "所以依照你過去的案例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148011/264.wav", + "text": "如果是很簡單的飲食" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148011/265.wav", + "text": "從這個例舉裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148011/266.wav", + "text": "那是一個活動結束以後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148011/267.wav", + "text": "大家辛勞了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148011/268.wav", + "text": "休息一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148011/269.wav", + "text": "不會影響到你" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148011/270.wav", + "text": "整個投票的意願" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148011/271.wav", + "text": "因為吃了你這個貢丸米粉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148011/272.wav", + "text": "我才要投給你" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148011/273.wav", + "text": "那當然就是由檢察官來認定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148011/274.wav", + "text": "嘛如果不是這樣的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148011/275.wav", + "text": "檢察官也會依照情節" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148011/276.wav", + "text": "看實際的狀況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148011/277.wav", + "text": "好部長你講得很清楚了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148011/278.wav", + "text": "很多民眾有這個疑慮" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148011/279.wav", + "text": "但是如果你是很豐盛的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148011/280.wav", + "text": "哇又是鮑魚魚翅的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148011/281.wav", + "text": "好以上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148011/282.wav", + "text": "謝謝部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148011/283.wav", + "text": "謝謝林思銘委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148011/284.wav", + "text": "我們現在休息5分鐘" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148010/0.wav", + "text": "主委好因為我們通過了氣候變遷因應法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148010/1.wav", + "text": "明定臺灣在2050年前就要達成淨零排放" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148010/2.wav", + "text": "在我們1,791家上市櫃企業裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148010/3.wav", + "text": "承諾的只有118家只佔了7%" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148010/4.wav", + "text": "主委因為我們臺灣是一個出口導向型的國家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148010/5.wav", + "text": "如果沒有做到這一點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148010/6.wav", + "text": "其實未來整個出口都會受到影響" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148010/7.wav", + "text": "主委您有沒有辦法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148010/8.wav", + "text": "再透過我們有怎麼樣的工具" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148010/9.wav", + "text": "其實淨零是大家一起要去努力的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148010/10.wav", + "text": "就發布了上市櫃公司永續發展的路徑圖" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148010/11.wav", + "text": "要求從100億的企業開始" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148010/12.wav", + "text": "應該是2026年開始先做碳的盤查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148010/13.wav", + "text": "然後再做確認一直到2029年2030" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148010/14.wav", + "text": "年所以這個我們是循序漸進去要求" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148010/15.wav", + "text": "而且銀行端部分保險公司端部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148010/16.wav", + "text": "及投資跟授信部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148010/17.wav", + "text": "也會要求依照這樣一個原則" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148010/18.wav", + "text": "去跟他們做一些議合" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148010/19.wav", + "text": "要求這些企業在碳排放方面去做一些努力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148010/20.wav", + "text": "所以這部分都有齊頭並進" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148010/21.wav", + "text": "我相信以金管會目前的努力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148010/22.wav", + "text": "如果能夠照你們的規劃來做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148010/23.wav", + "text": "這個應該是有希望達到的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148010/24.wav", + "text": "但是淨零排放恐怕不只要減碳也要減災" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148010/25.wav", + "text": "最主要是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148010/26.wav", + "text": "本席上次來跟主委請教的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148010/27.wav", + "text": "剛好提到我們現在也規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148010/28.wav", + "text": "要這些上市上櫃公司" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148010/29.wav", + "text": "近年國內的重大公安意外頻傳" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148010/30.wav", + "text": "據保發中心統計" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148010/31.wav", + "text": "近4年的商業火險損失率從27%暴增" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148010/32.wav", + "text": "創歷史新高" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148010/33.wav", + "text": "其中包括美福聯華等知名廠商大火" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148010/34.wav", + "text": "都讓產險業的負擔加重" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148010/35.wav", + "text": "產生本末倒置的狀況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148010/36.wav", + "text": "應該要把這種減災防災的意識" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148010/37.wav", + "text": "一定要納入我們的企業文化之中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148010/38.wav", + "text": "這個其實在公司治理相關文件中本來就有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148010/39.wav", + "text": "委員您垂詢的事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148010/40.wav", + "text": "其實正好日前我們有跟消防署針對這次屏東的火災" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148010/41.wav", + "text": "將來我們怎麼在年報上或是一些永續報告書上做明確的說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148010/42.wav", + "text": "未來朝這個方向去努力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148010/43.wav", + "text": "我們到消防署的消訓中心去的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148010/44.wav", + "text": "針對這個議題其實消防署也提到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148010/45.wav", + "text": "能夠把我們各企業的減災防災部分放進去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148010/46.wav", + "text": "就是不予理賠或排除等手段來促進企業" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148010/47.wav", + "text": "願意承擔起他們應有的責任" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148010/48.wav", + "text": "舉例來講聯華電子在發生過大火之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148010/49.wav", + "text": "因為他們認為要對他們國外的顧客" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148010/50.wav", + "text": "還有保險業者有所承擔" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148010/51.wav", + "text": "但是我們國內還有其他企業比如說像台積電就不願意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148010/52.wav", + "text": "對類似這種企業你們有沒有辦法透過你們的ESG的設計" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148010/53.wav", + "text": "不管是胡蘿蔔還是棍子幫助消防署能夠做到這些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148010/54.wav", + "text": "跟委員報告其實產險公司在訂保費的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148010/55.wav", + "text": "都會看這些公司本身的損害防阻機制做得到不到位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148010/56.wav", + "text": "如果做得很到位的話它的保費是會有加減的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148010/57.wav", + "text": "這部分就是很大的誘因機制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148010/58.wav", + "text": "所以我們還是要更積極一點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148010/59.wav", + "text": "這些的主管部會其實是經濟部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148010/60.wav", + "text": "經濟部對於不同的產業應該要有這個標準" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148010/61.wav", + "text": "個關於我們的癌症病友" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148010/62.wav", + "text": "的很大的新聞就是他們雖然有商保不是完全靠健保" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148010/63.wav", + "text": "但是很多新型的癌症新藥沒有納入給付" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148010/64.wav", + "text": "結果他們買了這個保險" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148010/65.wav", + "text": "還經常被保險業者拿著契約當" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148010/66.wav", + "text": "擋箭牌" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148010/67.wav", + "text": "我們金管會在民國99年曾經針對白內障手術" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148010/68.wav", + "text": "有提過只要有門診就可以給付" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148010/69.wav", + "text": "有這個替代性的處理方法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148010/70.wav", + "text": "但是現在保險公司繼續販售這些不合時宜的短期健康險" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148010/71.wav", + "text": "你們長達13年都沒有督促保險公司處理這些不合時宜的保單" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148010/72.wav", + "text": "這樣子對嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148010/73.wav", + "text": "我必須要說這個案子其實健保署有跟保險局溝通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148010/74.wav", + "text": "所以請主委務必要把我們癌症病友的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148010/75.wav", + "text": "買了很多自己私人的醫療保險" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148010/76.wav", + "text": "就算我過去從來沒有給付過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148010/77.wav", + "text": "也是一樣到75歲就結束了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148010/78.wav", + "text": "所以有一些其實對我們現在的保險人是很不利的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148010/79.wav", + "text": "務必要能夠關照到現在我們全民的需要好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148010/80.wav", + "text": "謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148010/81.wav", + "text": "謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148010/82.wav", + "text": "謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148010/83.wav", + "text": "謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148008/0.wav", + "text": "謝謝主席" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148008/1.wav", + "text": "請薛部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148008/2.wav", + "text": "有請部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148008/3.wav", + "text": "部長好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148008/4.wav", + "text": "首先我要關心的是住宿機構的發展" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148008/5.wav", + "text": "尤其是照顧服務人力的缺乏問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148008/6.wav", + "text": "人力是各項服務的根本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148008/7.wav", + "text": "從我過去幾週所質詢的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148008/8.wav", + "text": "護理人力社工人力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148008/9.wav", + "text": "到今天的照服員人力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148008/10.wav", + "text": "都關乎醫療社會安全網" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148008/11.wav", + "text": "與長照服務的穩健與否" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148008/12.wav", + "text": "請問部長目前住宿機構的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148008/13.wav", + "text": "照服員缺口有多少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148008/14.wav", + "text": "就目前我們所訂的這個設置標準來看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148008/15.wav", + "text": "應該是沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148008/16.wav", + "text": "沒有缺" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148008/17.wav", + "text": "應該是都符合的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148008/18.wav", + "text": "有三萬五千多人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148008/19.wav", + "text": "光住宿機構的人力缺口" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148008/20.wav", + "text": "再加上居家跟社區" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148008/21.wav", + "text": "因為住宿型機構比較辛苦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148008/22.wav", + "text": "流用到別的地方去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148008/23.wav", + "text": "一直都補不滿" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148008/24.wav", + "text": "這個可能是計算方法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148008/25.wav", + "text": "有問題嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148008/26.wav", + "text": "培訓的人數" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148008/27.wav", + "text": "並不是實際執行的人數" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148008/28.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148008/29.wav", + "text": "就業媒合" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148008/30.wav", + "text": "中高齡繫留等等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148008/31.wav", + "text": "以及技術檢定方式充實人力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148008/32.wav", + "text": "人力缺口有些時" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148008/33.wav", + "text": "但如果是讓中高齡者留任" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148008/34.wav", + "text": "其實他們的體力也有限" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148008/35.wav", + "text": "輔具來幫忙" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148008/36.wav", + "text": "還是很吃力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148008/37.wav", + "text": "重點是面對高齡化的長照" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148008/38.wav", + "text": "所以人力政策是很重要的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148008/39.wav", + "text": "長期來講是人力政策" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148008/40.wav", + "text": "短期來講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148008/41.wav", + "text": "彌補缺口" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148008/42.wav", + "text": "你知道目前的狀況就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148008/43.wav", + "text": "一床可能要好幾百萬元結果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148008/44.wav", + "text": "空等床位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148008/45.wav", + "text": "部長你知道嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148008/46.wav", + "text": "沒有滿是因為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148008/47.wav", + "text": "有床卻無人照顧" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148008/48.wav", + "text": "不一定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148008/49.wav", + "text": "不一定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148008/50.wav", + "text": "有些是民眾在選擇" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148008/51.wav", + "text": "住宿型機構" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148008/52.wav", + "text": "品質好的當然就排隊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148008/53.wav", + "text": "隊排得很久" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148008/54.wav", + "text": "會排得很久但有些是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148008/55.wav", + "text": "床數不夠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148008/56.wav", + "text": "部長還是要去看一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148008/57.wav", + "text": "有滿多真的是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148008/58.wav", + "text": "怎麼做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148008/59.wav", + "text": "長照科系畢業的學生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148008/60.wav", + "text": "到後來並沒有投入" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148008/61.wav", + "text": "所以要讓他們投入職場" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148008/62.wav", + "text": "我們希望鼓勵他們來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148008/63.wav", + "text": "投入職場所以當這些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148008/64.wav", + "text": "學生畢業之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148008/65.wav", + "text": "要取得照服員的資格" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148008/66.wav", + "text": "很容易" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148008/67.wav", + "text": "受聘於住宿式機構" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148008/68.wav", + "text": "他要來接受我們的訓練" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148008/69.wav", + "text": "差不多一個禮拜" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148008/70.wav", + "text": "這一個禮拜的訓練內容主要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148008/71.wav", + "text": "有兩個部分第一個是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148008/72.wav", + "text": "遇到疫情的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148008/73.wav", + "text": "要怎麼樣去分艙分流" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148008/74.wav", + "text": "這種感染控制的事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148008/75.wav", + "text": "有多少人呢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148008/76.wav", + "text": "我們希望是一個機構" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148008/77.wav", + "text": "裡面的10%" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148008/78.wav", + "text": "多給他薪資5,000塊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148008/79.wav", + "text": "每一個人薪資多給5,000塊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148008/80.wav", + "text": "好這是改善辦法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148008/81.wav", + "text": "讓年輕人更願意進來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148008/82.wav", + "text": "投入到這一個工作" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148008/83.wav", + "text": "而且是放在住宿式機構的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148008/84.wav", + "text": "這個部分因為住宿式機構" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148008/85.wav", + "text": "災難應變跟" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148008/86.wav", + "text": "的這種需求" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148008/87.wav", + "text": "已經報給行政院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148008/88.wav", + "text": "每個機構增加10%" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148008/89.wav", + "text": "對就現在來看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148008/90.wav", + "text": "將近" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148008/91.wav", + "text": "三萬多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148008/92.wav", + "text": "我們目標先是這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148008/93.wav", + "text": "希望有2,500人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148008/94.wav", + "text": "如果是這樣子就有在做改進計畫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148008/95.wav", + "text": "請問部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148008/96.wav", + "text": "我們在長照推動小組中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148008/97.wav", + "text": "有討論過住宿機構" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148008/98.wav", + "text": "要納入長照給付" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148008/99.wav", + "text": "不是長照保險是長照給付" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148008/100.wav", + "text": "但衛福部後續" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148008/101.wav", + "text": "每年12萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148008/102.wav", + "text": "每個月1萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148008/103.wav", + "text": "請問在發放補助之外" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148008/104.wav", + "text": "住宿機構什麼時候要納入" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148008/105.wav", + "text": "長照給付" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148008/106.wav", + "text": "還有重度失" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148008/107.wav", + "text": "使用長照服務" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148008/108.wav", + "text": "現在談的是住宿型的機構" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148008/109.wav", + "text": "我們分兩邊去做補助" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148008/110.wav", + "text": "第一個補助使用者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148008/111.wav", + "text": "目前是一年12萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148008/112.wav", + "text": "未來還可能再增加" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148008/113.wav", + "text": "另外補助給機構" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148008/114.wav", + "text": "的就是靠各種計畫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148008/115.wav", + "text": "包括我們的品質提升計畫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148008/116.wav", + "text": "及減少就醫方案等等也" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148008/117.wav", + "text": "同時來做處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148008/118.wav", + "text": "一個是補助給機構" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148008/119.wav", + "text": "一個是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148008/120.wav", + "text": "目前是這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148008/121.wav", + "text": "補助給機構" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148008/122.wav", + "text": "我剛剛就提到1到8級的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148008/123.wav", + "text": "長照給付" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148008/124.wav", + "text": "我想不一定要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148008/125.wav", + "text": "把這兩個混在一起" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148008/126.wav", + "text": "因為混在一起會產生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148008/127.wav", + "text": "一些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148008/128.wav", + "text": "副作用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148008/129.wav", + "text": "什麼副作用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148008/130.wav", + "text": "我跟委員報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148008/131.wav", + "text": "其實我們最擔心的就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148008/132.wav", + "text": "upcoding的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148008/133.wav", + "text": "就是他事實上沒有到那個級數" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148008/134.wav", + "text": "在這種情形" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148008/135.wav", + "text": "越多的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148008/136.wav", + "text": "照專一定會有壓力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148008/137.wav", + "text": "可是1到8級是按照" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148008/138.wav", + "text": "專業去分級" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148008/139.wav", + "text": "是由照管專員去執行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148008/140.wav", + "text": "這一個評估" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148008/141.wav", + "text": "目前來講他們做這個評估" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148008/142.wav", + "text": "沒有什麼壓力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148008/143.wav", + "text": "也用這種評估" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148008/144.wav", + "text": "的分級去算補助金額的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148008/145.wav", + "text": "就會有壓力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148008/146.wav", + "text": "7級8級的都比較嚴重" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148008/147.wav", + "text": "坐輪椅或臥床" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148008/148.wav", + "text": "日間照顧機構" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148008/149.wav", + "text": "而居家服務時間又有限" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148008/150.wav", + "text": "這些78級的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148008/151.wav", + "text": "但通常78級都臥床跟" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148008/152.wav", + "text": "坐輪椅" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148008/153.wav", + "text": "78級不一定會到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148008/154.wav", + "text": "這樣的程度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148008/155.wav", + "text": "問題是在住宿式機構" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148008/156.wav", + "text": "的也不限於78級" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148008/157.wav", + "text": "還有居家服務" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148008/158.wav", + "text": "可能會不方便" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148008/159.wav", + "text": "他們出去不方便" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148008/160.wav", + "text": "可能就需要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148008/161.wav", + "text": "機構式的照顧" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148008/162.wav", + "text": "對機構式服務你一個月只補助1萬而已" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148008/163.wav", + "text": "就是沒有完全納入長照" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148008/164.wav", + "text": "這個都可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148008/165.wav", + "text": "再來做一些檢討" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148008/166.wav", + "text": "所以部長同意要再做檢討" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148008/167.wav", + "text": "補助的金額會再提升" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148008/168.wav", + "text": "我們要再算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148008/169.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148008/170.wav", + "text": "OK謝謝我們要多照顧" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148008/171.wav", + "text": "這些勞苦功高的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148008/172.wav", + "text": "老年人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148007/0.wav", + "text": "黃主委" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148007/1.wav", + "text": "之前我有問過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148007/2.wav", + "text": "關於存戶死亡之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148007/3.wav", + "text": "定存到期" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148007/4.wav", + "text": "續存轉期這個事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148007/5.wav", + "text": "後來我們跟各家銀行調資料之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148007/6.wav", + "text": "發現除了民營銀行之外" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148007/7.wav", + "text": "公股銀行有兩種" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148007/8.wav", + "text": "一種會依照約定自動轉期" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148007/9.wav", + "text": "另外一種就是不轉期改活存的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148007/10.wav", + "text": "全臺灣就只有四家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148007/11.wav", + "text": "就是臺銀土銀合庫跟華銀" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148007/12.wav", + "text": "所以這四家是比較細漢是不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148007/13.wav", + "text": "我們也問了財政部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148007/14.wav", + "text": "財政部說因為金管會跟銀行公會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148007/15.wav", + "text": "沒有一致性的規範" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148007/16.wav", + "text": "因此有這樣子的狀況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148007/17.wav", + "text": "所以全臺灣民眾可能不知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148007/18.wav", + "text": "只有臺銀土銀合庫跟華銀的存款戶" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148007/19.wav", + "text": "在存戶死亡之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148007/20.wav", + "text": "他的定存沒有自動續期" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148007/21.wav", + "text": "而直接改活存" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148007/22.wav", + "text": "這部分金管會什麼時候會有一個規範出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148007/23.wav", + "text": "上次委員垂詢之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148007/24.wav", + "text": "我們有交代銀行局跟銀行公會去研究" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148007/25.wav", + "text": "這個部分應該都可以有機會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148007/26.wav", + "text": "就是看銀行的政策" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148007/27.wav", + "text": "因為大部分都是可以轉成定存" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148007/28.wav", + "text": "報告委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148007/29.wav", + "text": "我們現在在請銀行公會研議當中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148007/30.wav", + "text": "要多久啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148007/31.wav", + "text": "這麼簡單的事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148007/32.wav", + "text": "我們上次問到現在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148007/33.wav", + "text": "也拖一個月" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148007/34.wav", + "text": "了存戶的權益一分一秒都在流失" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148007/35.wav", + "text": "這麼簡單的事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148007/36.wav", + "text": "全臺灣就只有這四家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148007/37.wav", + "text": "沒有任何原因" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148007/38.wav", + "text": "請你們訂定一個一致性規範" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148007/39.wav", + "text": "這要拖多久" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148007/40.wav", + "text": "連這種事情都還要拖那麼久" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148007/41.wav", + "text": "我不知道效率在哪裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148007/42.wav", + "text": "是我們儘速辦理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148007/43.wav", + "text": "要多久一個禮拜可不可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148007/44.wav", + "text": "一個禮拜" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148007/45.wav", + "text": "這到底我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148007/46.wav", + "text": "兩個禮拜之後跟委員報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148007/47.wav", + "text": "一點難度都沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148007/48.wav", + "text": "我們兩個禮拜之後跟委員報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148007/49.wav", + "text": "好\n另外我們發現金管會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148007/50.wav", + "text": "近五年的罰鍰收入" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148007/51.wav", + "text": "自從主委你上任之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148007/52.wav", + "text": "每況愈下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148007/53.wav", + "text": "啦從3億2億到現在只剩一億多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148007/54.wav", + "text": "明年你們還自動減少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148007/55.wav", + "text": "從3億2變成2億7" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148007/56.wav", + "text": "你們在放水是不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148007/57.wav", + "text": "啊為什麼這些金控銀行保險" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148007/58.wav", + "text": "防疫保單出了這麼多問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148007/59.wav", + "text": "跟去年比都減少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148007/60.wav", + "text": "大幅度的減少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148007/61.wav", + "text": "請問我們詐騙這麼猖獗" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148007/62.wav", + "text": "民怨沸騰" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148007/63.wav", + "text": "P2P的案件" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148007/64.wav", + "text": "一件又一件" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148007/65.wav", + "text": "imB事件等等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148007/66.wav", + "text": "這些銀行不斷" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148007/67.wav", + "text": "個資外洩" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148007/68.wav", + "text": "可是我們的罰鍰收入" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148007/69.wav", + "text": "卻逐年減少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148007/70.wav", + "text": "到底原因在哪裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148007/71.wav", + "text": "這個罰鍰是很難預測說一定高或低" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148007/72.wav", + "text": "但是預算數" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148007/73.wav", + "text": "其實是一個平均數的概念" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148007/74.wav", + "text": "不是啊主委" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148007/75.wav", + "text": "你上任之前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148007/76.wav", + "text": "每年都是三億多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148007/77.wav", + "text": "你上任之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148007/78.wav", + "text": "開始變2億1億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148007/79.wav", + "text": "越來越少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148007/80.wav", + "text": "所以你上任之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148007/81.wav", + "text": "銀行都表現很好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148007/82.wav", + "text": "都沒有問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148007/83.wav", + "text": "還是你上任之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148007/84.wav", + "text": "都高高舉起" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148007/85.wav", + "text": "輕輕放下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148007/86.wav", + "text": "而且你明年還自動減少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148007/87.wav", + "text": "你的罰鍰收入" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148007/88.wav", + "text": "合理嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148007/89.wav", + "text": "人家是罰鍰2億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148007/90.wav", + "text": "結果開了3億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148007/91.wav", + "text": "是比預算數還要高" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148007/92.wav", + "text": "罰更多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148007/93.wav", + "text": "只有你" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148007/94.wav", + "text": "你還罰不到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148007/95.wav", + "text": "預算3億2" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148007/96.wav", + "text": "你罰1億9" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148007/97.wav", + "text": "明年你還主動減少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148007/98.wav", + "text": "難怪金控都很愛你" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148007/99.wav", + "text": "有這樣的主委" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148007/100.wav", + "text": "當然他們愛不釋手" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148007/101.wav", + "text": "啊為什麼會這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148007/102.wav", + "text": "你覺得合理嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148007/103.wav", + "text": "罰款預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148007/104.wav", + "text": "絕對不會為了衝預算目標去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148007/105.wav", + "text": "那你說其他主委" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148007/106.wav", + "text": "如顧立雄在衝預算目標" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148007/107.wav", + "text": "是不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148007/108.wav", + "text": "人家預算2億罰了3億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148007/109.wav", + "text": "耶代表人家有嚴格在把關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148007/110.wav", + "text": "呢是在放水" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148007/111.wav", + "text": "吧所以這是一個很大的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148007/112.wav", + "text": "喔我希望主委你好好地去了解" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148007/113.wav", + "text": "為什麼你們的預算數" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148007/114.wav", + "text": "逐年減少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148007/115.wav", + "text": "罰不到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148007/116.wav", + "text": "而且明年還主動降低" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148007/117.wav", + "text": "然後你看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148007/118.wav", + "text": "人頭戶最多10銀行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148007/119.wav", + "text": "抓出9缺失" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148007/120.wav", + "text": "等等臺灣有10家銀行的人頭戶" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148007/121.wav", + "text": "被抓出有9大缺失" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148007/122.wav", + "text": "到現在沒有開罰" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148007/123.wav", + "text": "耶詐騙這麼猖獗" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148007/124.wav", + "text": "人頭戶這麼多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148007/125.wav", + "text": "銀行裡應外合地勾結" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148007/126.wav", + "text": "然後到現在沒有罰" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148007/127.wav", + "text": "你跟我說銀行表現很好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148007/128.wav", + "text": "所以不用開罰" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148007/129.wav", + "text": "所以你的罰鍰" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148007/130.wav", + "text": "罰不到預算的目標" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148007/131.wav", + "text": "請問這人頭戶最多的10銀行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148007/132.wav", + "text": "什麼時候要罰" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148007/133.wav", + "text": "這個部分若是抓到缺失" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148007/134.wav", + "text": "裁罰部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148007/135.wav", + "text": "檢查局這邊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148007/136.wav", + "text": "或是銀行局會再處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148007/137.wav", + "text": "光是一個聯邦銀行的通化分行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148007/138.wav", + "text": "詐騙洗錢協助的移轉資金" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148007/139.wav", + "text": "金流就高達5,000萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148007/140.wav", + "text": "3億2你只罰1億9" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148007/141.wav", + "text": "真的看不下去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148007/142.wav", + "text": "啦人頭戶這麼多銀行勾結" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148007/143.wav", + "text": "你一個都沒罰" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148007/144.wav", + "text": "這個不是要衝預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148007/145.wav", + "text": "是要據實去處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148007/146.wav", + "text": "絕對不能說為了要達據" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148007/147.wav", + "text": "據實處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148007/148.wav", + "text": "就是你沒有據實處理放水啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148007/149.wav", + "text": "高高舉起" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148007/150.wav", + "text": "輕輕放下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148007/151.wav", + "text": "啊才會導致從2019年到現在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148007/152.wav", + "text": "罰鍰數愈來愈少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148007/153.wav", + "text": "罰得愈來愈少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148007/154.wav", + "text": "當然銀行就不怕" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148007/155.wav", + "text": "啊反正我這些有問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148007/156.wav", + "text": "內控不彰" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148007/157.wav", + "text": "風控不做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148007/158.wav", + "text": "也不會被罰" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148007/159.wav", + "text": "請問一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148007/160.wav", + "text": "我們的壽險出了這麼多的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148007/161.wav", + "text": "你罰了哪一家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148007/162.wav", + "text": "我們的防疫保單" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148007/163.wav", + "text": "出了這麼多問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148007/164.wav", + "text": "你罰了哪一家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148007/165.wav", + "text": "然後我們的詐騙銀行去勾結" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148007/166.wav", + "text": "你又罰了哪一家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148007/167.wav", + "text": "你的罰鍰數完全不能看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148007/168.wav", + "text": "所以大家才會覺得說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148007/169.wav", + "text": "沒有人在管" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148007/170.wav", + "text": "啊金管會如果不罰" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148007/171.wav", + "text": "你不拿起你的武器" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148007/172.wav", + "text": "這些銀行就如入無人之境" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148007/173.wav", + "text": "到處在亂搞" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148007/174.wav", + "text": "到處在亂來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148007/175.wav", + "text": "然後P2P平台不斷爆雷" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148007/176.wav", + "text": "你告訴我說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148007/177.wav", + "text": "指導原則10月會出爐" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148007/178.wav", + "text": "到現在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148007/179.wav", + "text": "連個公會都沒有出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148007/180.wav", + "text": "你叫他們組公會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148007/181.wav", + "text": "業者不組" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148007/182.wav", + "text": "啊說我這個P2P" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148007/183.wav", + "text": "不是商業團體" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148007/184.wav", + "text": "所以也不是當鋪公會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148007/185.wav", + "text": "那請問這P2P平台" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148007/186.wav", + "text": "到底現在誰在管" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148007/187.wav", + "text": "跟委員報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148007/188.wav", + "text": "指導原則已經" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148007/189.wav", + "text": "在兩個禮拜前公布了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148007/190.wav", + "text": "公會部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148007/191.wav", + "text": "經濟部在處理中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148007/192.wav", + "text": "所以民眾對這部分很在意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148007/193.wav", + "text": "你除了指導原則之外" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148007/194.wav", + "text": "沒有公會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148007/195.wav", + "text": "虛擬幣的問題也是一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148007/196.wav", + "text": "金管會通過了一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148007/197.wav", + "text": "虛擬資產的指導原則" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148007/198.wav", + "text": "針對這些虛擬通貨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148007/199.wav", + "text": "在網路上也開始有詐騙" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148007/200.wav", + "text": "網站也是假的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148007/201.wav", + "text": "這些交易也是假的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148007/202.wav", + "text": "民眾根本不知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148007/203.wav", + "text": "到底是不是真的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148007/204.wav", + "text": "外幣臺幣都可以驗鈔" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148007/205.wav", + "text": "我們有沒有第三方的檢測機制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148007/206.wav", + "text": "讓民眾知道說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148007/207.wav", + "text": "這個網站這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148007/208.wav", + "text": "是真的假的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148007/209.wav", + "text": "這部分能做嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148007/210.wav", + "text": "平台業者向我們登記" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148007/211.wav", + "text": "這部分將來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148007/212.wav", + "text": "他們會陸續加入公會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148007/213.wav", + "text": "這個部分希望能夠趕快啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148007/214.wav", + "text": "因為詐騙真的很猖獗" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148007/215.wav", + "text": "如果金管會要管" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148007/216.wav", + "text": "至少你在虛擬通貨這個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148007/217.wav", + "text": "要有一個檢測機制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148007/218.wav", + "text": "而不是叫業者自律" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148007/219.wav", + "text": "然後就雙手一攤" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148007/220.wav", + "text": "任憑民眾不斷地被詐騙" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148007/221.wav", + "text": "另外今天有傳出" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148007/222.wav", + "text": "鴻海借券兩天回補3萬張" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148007/223.wav", + "text": "疑似是有內線交易大賺一筆" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148007/224.wav", + "text": "套利將近2.4億元" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148007/225.wav", + "text": "請問金管會要不要查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148007/226.wav", + "text": "這個本來股市都有監視機制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148007/227.wav", + "text": "如果有異常一定會去查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148007/228.wav", + "text": "因為這個部分傳出" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148007/229.wav", + "text": "類似這麼大筆的金額" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148007/230.wav", + "text": "絕對就是內部人士" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148007/231.wav", + "text": "才有辦法有這麼多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148007/232.wav", + "text": "這些借券的狀況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148007/233.wav", + "text": "如果是來自內部的內線交易" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148007/234.wav", + "text": "金管會就應該要趕快有動作" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148007/235.wav", + "text": "你們今天有告訴大家說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148007/236.wav", + "text": "你們會去查嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148007/237.wav", + "text": "還是說這些人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148007/238.wav", + "text": "這樣子內線交易公然地" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148007/239.wav", + "text": "做這種事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148007/240.wav", + "text": "好像也不痛不癢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148007/241.wav", + "text": "也不罰也不處理也不監管" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148007/242.wav", + "text": "報告委員交易所都會定期" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148007/243.wav", + "text": "有監視機制去抓" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148007/244.wav", + "text": "這些異常的現象" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148007/245.wav", + "text": "不要等媒體報出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148007/246.wav", + "text": "我們才有動作" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148007/247.wav", + "text": "我們應該要主動地發布" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148007/248.wav", + "text": "然後主動動作" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148007/249.wav", + "text": "讓大家看到我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148007/250.wav", + "text": "雷厲風行的狀況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148007/251.wav", + "text": "那我剛剛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148007/252.wav", + "text": "為什麼這麼氣講到詐騙" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148007/253.wav", + "text": "因為我最近接到好多民眾陳情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148007/254.wav", + "text": "可以換什麼換什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148007/255.wav", + "text": "的很多民眾都被詐騙" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148007/256.wav", + "text": "被詐騙點進去之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148007/257.wav", + "text": "銀行打來問" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148007/258.wav", + "text": "這個是不是有爭議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148007/259.wav", + "text": "他說對啊我要止付" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148007/260.wav", + "text": "且止付之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148007/261.wav", + "text": "當下立刻告訴銀行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148007/262.wav", + "text": "即富邦銀行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148007/263.wav", + "text": "然後當下立刻止付" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148007/264.wav", + "text": "結果怎麼樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148007/265.wav", + "text": "隔了4天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148007/266.wav", + "text": "這個錢還是付出去了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148007/267.wav", + "text": "將近15萬臺幣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148007/268.wav", + "text": "另外一個類似的狀況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148007/269.wav", + "text": "也是昨天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148007/270.wav", + "text": "我們陪民眾到警局去報案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148007/271.wav", + "text": "另外一個民眾也來報案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148007/272.wav", + "text": "盜刷了40萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148007/273.wav", + "text": "當下也是銀行詢問他說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148007/274.wav", + "text": "這個是不是有爭議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148007/275.wav", + "text": "他說對我要止付" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148007/276.wav", + "text": "止付之後還是繼續給他刷" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148007/277.wav", + "text": "還是盜刷" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148007/278.wav", + "text": "等於沒有止付" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148007/279.wav", + "text": "啊對民眾來講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148007/280.wav", + "text": "我當下就告訴銀行說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148007/281.wav", + "text": "這是詐騙我要止付" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148007/282.wav", + "text": "這筆消費有問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148007/283.wav", + "text": "但銀行還是把錢付出去了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148007/284.wav", + "text": "那民眾會有什麼想法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148007/285.wav", + "text": "然後我們的警察" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148007/286.wav", + "text": "每天都在處理這些詐騙案件" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148007/287.wav", + "text": "我就看到兩三個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148007/288.wav", + "text": "都是類似的狀況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148007/289.wav", + "text": "所謂將帥無能累死三軍" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148007/290.wav", + "text": "上面不處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148007/291.wav", + "text": "底下的人真的會累死" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148007/292.wav", + "text": "是可以止付的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148007/293.wav", + "text": "是沒有問題的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148007/294.wav", + "text": "但您剛才講到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148007/295.wav", + "text": "另外那家銀行的事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148007/296.wav", + "text": "我們應該會再去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148007/297.wav", + "text": "因為民眾" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148007/298.wav", + "text": "當下就告訴銀行說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148007/299.wav", + "text": "我要止付" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148007/300.wav", + "text": "而且那時候錢還沒有出去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148007/301.wav", + "text": "這時候銀行就要趕快協助" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148007/302.wav", + "text": "銀行也知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148007/303.wav", + "text": "有很多類似的狀況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148007/304.wav", + "text": "他要思考如何在風控跟防弊的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148007/305.wav", + "text": "能夠及時地預防" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148007/306.wav", + "text": "避免款項出去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148007/307.wav", + "text": "而不是說民眾被盜刷了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148007/308.wav", + "text": "之後錢付出去了我不管" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148007/309.wav", + "text": "這部分我希望金管會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148007/310.wav", + "text": "能夠及時地處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148007/311.wav", + "text": "有一個預防的機制來協助民眾" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148007/312.wav", + "text": "你如果源頭能夠處理好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148007/313.wav", + "text": "就像我們之前做的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148007/314.wav", + "text": "手機感應支付被盜刷" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148007/315.wav", + "text": "就沒有再盜刷啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148007/316.wav", + "text": "能做的能夠協助���" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148007/317.wav", + "text": "幫助我們警方" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148007/318.wav", + "text": "幫助我們檢方" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148007/319.wav", + "text": "減少這些詐騙案件" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148007/320.wav", + "text": "的對社會都是有很大的幫助" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148007/321.wav", + "text": "所以拜託我們金管會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148007/322.wav", + "text": "你們是最關鍵的源頭" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148007/323.wav", + "text": "你們不要求這些銀行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148007/324.wav", + "text": "不從源頭做起" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148007/325.wav", + "text": "後面的人真的會很累" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148007/326.wav", + "text": "罰鍰的事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148007/327.wav", + "text": "這麼多詐騙這樣勾結" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148007/328.wav", + "text": "銀行都不做風控" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148007/329.wav", + "text": "你們也不罰" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148007/330.wav", + "text": "一個手機感應支付的詐騙" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148007/331.wav", + "text": "這麼多的案件" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148007/332.wav", + "text": "過去銀行都不處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148007/333.wav", + "text": "在我們要求之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148007/334.wav", + "text": "綁定身分證就沒事啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148007/335.wav", + "text": "你看這麼簡單的一個動作" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148007/336.wav", + "text": "難道這過程中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148007/337.wav", + "text": "大家的怠惰都不用負責嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148007/338.wav", + "text": "然後民眾被騙了這麼多錢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148007/339.wav", + "text": "這樣你可以接受嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148007/340.wav", + "text": "委員謝謝您的指導" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148007/341.wav", + "text": "因為我發言時間很有限" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148007/342.wav", + "text": "跟花旗合併之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148007/343.wav", + "text": "我們接到很多的陳情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148007/344.wav", + "text": "民眾在花旗銀行的點數" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148007/345.wav", + "text": "你都要自己去辦理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148007/346.wav", + "text": "你要跑哪裡跑哪裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148007/347.wav", + "text": "然後所有的點數資料" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148007/348.wav", + "text": "全部都不見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148007/349.wav", + "text": "了系統都全部更新" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148007/350.wav", + "text": "民眾求訴無門" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148007/351.wav", + "text": "那金管會在幹嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148007/352.wav", + "text": "我們每一週都有跟星展銀行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148007/353.wav", + "text": "去確認它目前合併的進度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148007/354.wav", + "text": "確定進度嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148007/355.wav", + "text": "他們有多少缺失你知道嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148007/356.wav", + "text": "服務量能沒有補充" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148007/357.wav", + "text": "員工超時加班" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148007/358.wav", + "text": "業務責任歸屬難以釐清" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148007/359.wav", + "text": "互踢皮球" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148007/360.wav", + "text": "民眾的陳情抱怨一大堆" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148007/361.wav", + "text": "這不用開罰嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148007/362.wav", + "text": "可以開罰的這麼多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148007/363.wav", + "text": "你告訴我你罰不到3億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148007/364.wav", + "text": "只罰了1億9" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148007/365.wav", + "text": "這些都不是問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148007/366.wav", + "text": "就是因為你不罰" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148007/367.wav", + "text": "他們就不痛不癢擺爛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148007/368.wav", + "text": "你如果罰了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148007/369.wav", + "text": "我告訴你" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148007/370.wav", + "text": "馬上明天就全部處理好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148007/371.wav", + "text": "所以你要開罰" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148007/372.wav", + "text": "啊錢在那裡叫你罰你還不罰" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148007/373.wav", + "text": "還主動降低" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148007/374.wav", + "text": "我真的是覺得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148007/375.wav", + "text": "這個我們真的看不下去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148007/376.wav", + "text": "不是道德勸說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148007/377.wav", + "text": "啦主委我們給你武器給你預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148007/378.wav", + "text": "讓你去罰" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148007/379.wav", + "text": "結果你在那邊苦口婆心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148007/380.wav", + "text": "道德勸說什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148007/381.wav", + "text": "你就要拿起武器對準這些銀行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148007/382.wav", + "text": "啊該罰的就罰" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148007/383.wav", + "text": "啊到底有什麼為難的地方嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148007/384.wav", + "text": "委員謝謝您的指導" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148007/385.wav", + "text": "其實我們就是照您的想法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148007/386.wav", + "text": "好像花旗銀行的事不干它的事一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148007/387.wav", + "text": "如果它不好好處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148007/388.wav", + "text": "你就開罰可以嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148007/389.wav", + "text": "我們會依照法律規定去處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148007/390.wav", + "text": "該罰就罰" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148007/391.wav", + "text": "好因為網銀持續地虧損" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148007/392.wav", + "text": "然還用高利率去吸引客戶" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148007/393.wav", + "text": "虧損愈多的利率愈高" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148007/394.wav", + "text": "這部分對於民眾權益會不會有損害" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148007/395.wav", + "text": "啊因為我們很擔心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148007/396.wav", + "text": "它用這樣子的方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148007/397.wav", + "text": "最後虧損愈來愈大" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148007/398.wav", + "text": "然後民眾權益其實受損" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148007/399.wav", + "text": "因為它用高利率不斷地去吸引民眾" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148007/400.wav", + "text": "最後會不會付不出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148007/401.wav", + "text": "我想我們日常都有在做監理的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148007/402.wav", + "text": "這個部分我們會特別再注意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148007/403.wav", + "text": "虧損愈多的利息愈高" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148007/404.wav", + "text": "還有這種事喔" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148007/405.wav", + "text": "很好笑" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148007/406.wav", + "text": "欸這個要不要罰" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148007/407.wav", + "text": "這也可以罰" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148007/408.wav", + "text": "可以罰的真的很多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148007/409.wav", + "text": "你不要告訴我你罰不到3億好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148007/410.wav", + "text": "好謝謝各位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148006/0.wav", + "text": "主席麻煩請農業部次長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148006/1.wav", + "text": "還有龔主委" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148006/2.wav", + "text": "龔主委" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148006/3.wav", + "text": "委員好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148006/4.wav", + "text": "兩位好我想請問一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148006/5.wav", + "text": "除了農業部之外" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148006/6.wav", + "text": "在不在乎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148006/7.wav", + "text": "我們只有針對民生用品" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148006/8.wav", + "text": "有一個安全的存量" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148006/9.wav", + "text": "好對於民生用品的安全存量" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148006/10.wav", + "text": "我請教一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148006/11.wav", + "text": "我們就先從農業部來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148006/12.wav", + "text": "\n我們的糧食自給率越來越低" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148006/13.wav", + "text": "這個你知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148006/14.wav", + "text": "當我在這邊質詢陳吉仲的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148006/15.wav", + "text": "陳吉仲就承認" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148006/16.wav", + "text": "將來缺糧" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148006/17.wav", + "text": "是一個很嚴重的事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148006/18.wav", + "text": "越來越低" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148006/19.wav", + "text": "現在我們還把農地挪作他用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148006/20.wav", + "text": "缺糧問題是可以應付的嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148006/21.wav", + "text": "謝謝委員關心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148006/22.wav", + "text": "農地作農用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148006/23.wav", + "text": "你先回答缺糧自給率的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148006/24.wav", + "text": "因為其實不管是在整個農村" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148006/25.wav", + "text": "自給率你怎麼解決" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148006/26.wav", + "text": "第二個在農地上耕作生產" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148006/27.wav", + "text": "其實要能夠提高它的質跟量" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148006/28.wav", + "text": "所以你的意思是說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148006/29.wav", + "text": "農地可以越來越少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148006/30.wav", + "text": "只要能夠提高它的質跟量" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148006/31.wav", + "text": "就可以解決我們糧食自給率的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148006/32.wav", + "text": "現在我們的糧食自給率你是訂在多少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148006/33.wav", + "text": "報告委員應該這樣說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148006/34.wav", + "text": "其實糧食自給率是一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148006/35.wav", + "text": "你訂在多少啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148006/36.wav", + "text": "你就不要老是換題目嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148006/37.wav", + "text": "你不知道你就說不知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148006/38.wav", + "text": "就不要浪費大家的時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148006/39.wav", + "text": "農業部對於糧食自給率" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148006/40.wav", + "text": "沒有一個基本標準" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148006/41.wav", + "text": "我們當然希望2040年能達到40希望" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148006/42.wav", + "text": "能夠到40%然後現在把" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148006/43.wav", + "text": "現在它的質量可以提升的依據是什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148006/44.wav", + "text": "應該不會是這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148006/45.wav", + "text": "農地還是要農用為最優先" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148006/46.wav", + "text": "沒有啊你現在不是嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148006/47.wav", + "text": "不要換題目回到前面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148006/48.wav", + "text": "自給率的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148006/49.wav", + "text": "要達到四成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148006/50.wav", + "text": "我們看到每一年都往下降" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148006/51.wav", + "text": "不改進" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148006/52.wav", + "text": "就是說你設定了一個目標" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148006/53.wav", + "text": "不是用來改進的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148006/54.wav", + "text": "如果你有改進的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148006/55.wav", + "text": "你看這個數字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148006/56.wav", + "text": "沒看到你有任何動靜" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148006/57.wav", + "text": "啊你的動靜如果是按照你剛才回答的內容" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148006/58.wav", + "text": "說我改善耕種" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148006/59.wav", + "text": "它會上升但是沒上升" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148006/60.wav", + "text": "所以要嘛就是你沒有因應" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148006/61.wav", + "text": "要嘛就是你因應的基準" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148006/62.wav", + "text": "在因應基準不存在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148006/63.wav", + "text": "或者沒因應的情況之下你不為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148006/64.wav", + "text": "都持續在做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148006/65.wav", + "text": "持續在做但你沒有績效" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148006/66.wav", + "text": "啊你是做了什麼事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148006/67.wav", + "text": "一則是在整個農業技術的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148006/68.wav", + "text": "就是用嘴巴講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148006/69.wav", + "text": "嘴巴講我們的質量就可以改善" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148006/70.wav", + "text": "其實也沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148006/71.wav", + "text": "那你看到實際上面的情形" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148006/72.wav", + "text": "我們從106年到現在為止" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148006/73.wav", + "text": "你嘴巴講了幾年了沒動" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148006/74.wav", + "text": "啊反而是往下跌" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148006/75.wav", + "text": "跌你知道國際缺糧的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148006/76.wav", + "text": "國際間也是一個問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148006/77.wav", + "text": "好國際間也是問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148006/78.wav", + "text": "然後你知道有一些糧食主要出口國" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148006/79.wav", + "text": "現在限制出口你知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148006/80.wav", + "text": "還是你不知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148006/81.wav", + "text": "所以剛剛委員提到的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148006/82.wav", + "text": "不是我問你知道還是不知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148006/83.wav", + "text": "糧食安全確實是國安的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148006/84.wav", + "text": "我沒問你那個問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148006/85.wav", + "text": "你怎麼隨便換題目" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148006/86.wav", + "text": "啊我問你說你知道很多的國家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148006/87.wav", + "text": "尤其是糧食出口國" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148006/88.wav", + "text": "現在限制它的糧食出口" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148006/89.wav", + "text": "你知道這個問題還是你不知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148006/90.wav", + "text": "有些國家有在媒體上看到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148006/91.wav", + "text": "你只有在媒體上看到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148006/92.wav", + "text": "你沒有專業的去看是不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148006/93.wav", + "text": "這不是你農業部該做的事情嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148006/94.wav", + "text": "第一個自給率越來越低" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148006/95.wav", + "text": "從原來的四成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148006/96.wav", + "text": "逐漸下降到現在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148006/97.wav", + "text": "你要讓原來既有的田的生產" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148006/98.wav", + "text": "生產質量能夠上升" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148006/99.wav", + "text": "我們看到它的質量也沒上升" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148006/100.wav", + "text": "作為一個主管機關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148006/101.wav", + "text": "你也知道國際有缺糧的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148006/102.wav", + "text": "就是因為國際有缺糧的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148006/103.wav", + "text": "有一些糧食出口國" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148006/104.wav", + "text": "你也知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148006/105.wav", + "text": "是把農地供作光電用地" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148006/106.wav", + "text": "這個就是你的解法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148006/107.wav", + "text": "你不在乎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148006/108.wav", + "text": "三件事情都是事實" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148006/109.wav", + "text": "但是三件事情沒有直接絕對的因果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148006/110.wav", + "text": "第一個是糧食自給率" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148006/111.wav", + "text": "但我們看到的情形" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148006/112.wav", + "text": "跟我剛剛講的情形不一樣嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148006/113.wav", + "text": "糧食自給率確實要提升" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148006/114.wav", + "text": "這確實是農業部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148006/115.wav", + "text": "第二個在進口的糧食補充這一塊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148006/116.wav", + "text": "我們也持續在做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148006/117.wav", + "text": "但是我們看到你就是口號治國" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148006/118.wav", + "text": "口惠實不至" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148006/119.wav", + "text": "就只是嘴巴" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148006/120.wav", + "text": "說嘴巴說是不能夠解決問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148006/121.wav", + "text": "剛才次長說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148006/122.wav", + "text": "缺糧問題是國安問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148006/123.wav", + "text": "那你做了什麼呢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148006/124.wav", + "text": "我們關心的是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148006/125.wav", + "text": "在緊急狀態的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148006/126.wav", + "text": "可以維持國家的糧食" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148006/127.wav", + "text": "供給3個月到6個月" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148006/128.wav", + "text": "你說3個月到6個月" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148006/129.wav", + "text": "我們看到俄烏戰爭打了多久" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148006/130.wav", + "text": "然後剩下來的就撒手不管了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148006/131.wav", + "text": "事實上在真的緊急狀態的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148006/132.wav", + "text": "我們可以改種" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148006/133.wav", + "text": "因為周轉率會比較高" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148006/134.wav", + "text": "所以你的意思是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148006/135.wav", + "text": "大家沒有米飯吃的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148006/136.wav", + "text": "就吃地瓜番薯" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148006/137.wav", + "text": "是這個意思" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148006/138.wav", + "text": "那個是特殊狀況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148006/139.wav", + "text": "那個是緊急特殊狀" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148006/140.wav", + "text": "你只有負責3到6個月吃米飯" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148006/141.wav", + "text": "然後6個月之後就吃地瓜番薯" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148006/142.wav", + "text": "是這樣子嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148006/143.wav", + "text": "這個怎麼會是一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148006/144.wav", + "text": "行政單位該為的事情呢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148006/145.wav", + "text": "厲害我們現在講下一個問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148006/146.wav", + "text": "我把題目問好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148006/147.wav", + "text": "問完就好了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148006/148.wav", + "text": "進口雞蛋的合約" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148006/149.wav", + "text": "農業部為什麼不每一家都公布" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148006/150.wav", + "text": "你是選擇性的公布嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148006/151.wav", + "text": "中央畜產會有訂合約的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148006/152.wav", + "text": "就是這三家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148006/153.wav", + "text": "三家都公布了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148006/154.wav", + "text": "就是沒有簽約的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148006/155.wav", + "text": "是不是這個意思" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148006/156.wav", + "text": "是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148006/157.wav", + "text": "是可以沒有簽約的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148006/158.wav", + "text": "是不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148006/159.wav", + "text": "雞蛋本來就是可以自由進口" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148006/160.wav", + "text": "這是什麼話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148006/161.wav", + "text": "那現在民間進口的東西" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148006/162.wav", + "text": "也是不簽約的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148006/163.wav", + "text": "啊你不簽約" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148006/164.wav", + "text": "然後你的條款是怎麼遵循呢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148006/165.wav", + "text": "連合約都沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148006/166.wav", + "text": "你的條款是怎麼遵循呢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148006/167.wav", + "text": "有合約的是長期供應" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148006/168.wav", + "text": "其他就是個別" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148006/169.wav", + "text": "短期供應也會有條款" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148006/170.wav", + "text": "啊你的PO在哪裡呢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148006/171.wav", + "text": "你的訂單在哪裡呢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148006/172.wav", + "text": "你好歹訂單也公布一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148006/173.wav", + "text": "可以嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148006/174.wav", + "text": "10月11日質詢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148006/175.wav", + "text": "資料沒給" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148006/176.wav", + "text": "18日我們再拜託你" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148006/177.wav", + "text": "還是沒給" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148006/178.wav", + "text": "今天已經到26日了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148006/179.wav", + "text": "哇厲害" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148006/180.wav", + "text": "我們行政單位厲害" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148006/181.wav", + "text": "就是打死不給資料" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148006/182.wav", + "text": "所以我請教你" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148006/183.wav", + "text": "我剛剛請問你問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148006/184.wav", + "text": "了拜託你要回答" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148006/185.wav", + "text": "有一個最奇怪的事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148006/186.wav", + "text": "院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148006/187.wav", + "text": "院會報告的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148006/188.wav", + "text": ",531" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148006/189.wav", + "text": "萬顆現在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148006/190.wav", + "text": "差了一個月" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148006/191.wav", + "text": "變成15,427萬顆" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148006/192.wav", + "text": "在不到一個月的時間之內" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148006/193.wav", + "text": "多出來的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148006/194.wav", + "text": "896萬顆雞蛋" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148006/195.wav", + "text": "是從哪裡來的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148006/196.wav", + "text": "報告委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148006/197.wav", + "text": "其實在您的資料上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148006/198.wav", + "text": "非常清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148006/199.wav", + "text": "第一張左邊統計" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148006/200.wav", + "text": "是到9月15" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148006/201.wav", + "text": "我知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148006/202.wav", + "text": "我沒有問你那個問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148006/203.wav", + "text": "我知道數量差" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148006/204.wav", + "text": "所以才問你" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148006/205.wav", + "text": "896萬顆從哪裡來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148006/206.wav", + "text": "我剛才的問題是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148006/207.wav", + "text": "是差不到1個月的時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148006/208.wav", + "text": "特別拜託你" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148006/209.wav", + "text": "要注意聽好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148006/210.wav", + "text": "差不到1個月的時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148006/211.wav", + "text": "都有很清楚的資料" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148006/212.wav", + "text": "如果委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148006/213.wav", + "text": "只有你知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148006/214.wav", + "text": "我不知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148006/215.wav", + "text": "啊我現在請教" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148006/216.wav", + "text": "你從哪裡來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148006/217.wav", + "text": "嘛然後我最後面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148006/218.wav", + "text": "或採購的雞蛋" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148006/219.wav", + "text": "第一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148006/220.wav", + "text": "除了你公布的之外" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148006/221.wav", + "text": "是沒有合約的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148006/222.wav", + "text": "然後你要給付多少錢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148006/223.wav", + "text": "損害賠償是多少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148006/224.wav", + "text": "現在金��怎麼算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148006/225.wav", + "text": "因為你連合約都沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148006/226.wav", + "text": "你的金額怎麼算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148006/227.wav", + "text": "是人家喊了價" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148006/228.wav", + "text": "你就賠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148006/229.wav", + "text": "畜產會賠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148006/230.wav", + "text": "還是農業部賠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148006/231.wav", + "text": "謝謝委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148006/232.wav", + "text": "再次詢問這個問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148006/233.wav", + "text": "我沒有再次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148006/234.wav", + "text": "我第一次詢問這個問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148006/235.wav", + "text": "雞蛋的進口採購" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148006/236.wav", + "text": "誰賠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148006/237.wav", + "text": "嘛這麼簡單的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148006/238.wav", + "text": "是農業部賠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148006/239.wav", + "text": "是畜產會賠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148006/240.wav", + "text": "還是農業金庫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148006/241.wav", + "text": "借出去的錢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148006/242.wav", + "text": "變成呆帳" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148006/243.wav", + "text": "到底是誰在負擔這些成本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148006/244.wav", + "text": "還是這個決策錯誤" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148006/245.wav", + "text": "所以我們應該去找陳吉仲" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148006/246.wav", + "text": "到底是怎麼樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148006/247.wav", + "text": "決策確實是有達到政策目標" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148006/248.wav", + "text": "但是在整個採購" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148006/249.wav", + "text": "決策達到政策目標" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148006/250.wav", + "text": "讓全民都賠錢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148006/251.wav", + "text": "這個是你說的決策" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148006/252.wav", + "text": "達到政策目標" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148006/253.wav", + "text": "你原來設定的目標" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148006/254.wav", + "text": "就是要從國人的納稅錢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148006/255.wav", + "text": "把這些錢放進私人口袋" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148006/256.wav", + "text": "這就是你們的政策" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148006/257.wav", + "text": "政策當初是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148006/258.wav", + "text": "讓國人能夠以合理的蛋價" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148006/259.wav", + "text": "買到雞蛋我想這件事情是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148006/260.wav", + "text": "誰賠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148006/261.wav", + "text": "第二個是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148006/262.wav", + "text": "畜產會以自有資金去做融資使用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148006/263.wav", + "text": "它也必須要還農業金庫錢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148006/264.wav", + "text": "還是要還回去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148006/265.wav", + "text": "所以是畜產會付" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148006/266.wav", + "text": "不是農業部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148006/267.wav", + "text": "畜產會是以自有資金來做帳" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148006/268.wav", + "text": "你可不可以回答問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148006/269.wav", + "text": "嘛畜產會還是農業部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148006/270.wav", + "text": "在這件事情上面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148006/271.wav", + "text": "如果要依照採購法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148006/272.wav", + "text": "或者是要給畜產會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148006/273.wav", + "text": "都要依照規次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148006/274.wav", + "text": "因為時間到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148006/275.wav", + "text": "我拜託你" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148006/276.wav", + "text": "次長你講清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148006/277.wav", + "text": "你講清楚再下去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148006/278.wav", + "text": "是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148006/279.wav", + "text": "他問你的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148006/280.wav", + "text": "你就好好答" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148006/281.wav", + "text": "沒有啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148006/282.wav", + "text": "畜產會確實是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148006/283.wav", + "text": "是誰要賠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148006/284.wav", + "text": "是畜產會要賠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148006/285.wav", + "text": "還是農業部要賠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148006/286.wav", + "text": "跟農業金庫借的錢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148006/287.wav", + "text": "都是要還的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148006/288.wav", + "text": "你講這樣還是沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148006/289.wav", + "text": "對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148006/290.wav", + "text": "我相信所有人都聽懂" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148006/291.wav", + "text": "你政府是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148006/292.wav", + "text": "農業部吸收" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148006/293.wav", + "text": "進口的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148006/294.wav", + "text": "沒有差價的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148006/295.wav", + "text": "就是畜產會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148006/296.wav", + "text": "是不是這個意思" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148006/297.wav", + "text": "畜產會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148006/298.wav", + "text": "那就講清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148006/299.wav", + "text": "是謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148006/300.wav", + "text": "好那我也請問你" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148006/301.wav", + "text": "畜產會的錢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148006/302.wav", + "text": "從哪裡來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148006/303.wav", + "text": "畜產會有自有的資金" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148006/304.wav", + "text": "畜產會的自有資金" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148006/305.wav", + "text": "可以這樣用嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148006/306.wav", + "text": "也去跟農業金庫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148006/307.wav", + "text": "做融資" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148006/308.wav", + "text": "你又來了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148006/309.wav", + "text": "我沒有問這個問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148006/310.wav", + "text": "你就把它轉過去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148006/311.wav", + "text": "我問你" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148006/312.wav", + "text": "畜產會的自有資金" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148006/313.wav", + "text": "財源從哪裡來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148006/314.wav", + "text": "畜產會的自有資金" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148006/315.wav", + "text": "當初成立時是由" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148006/316.wav", + "text": "我知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148006/317.wav", + "text": "因為我有圖表" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148006/318.wav", + "text": "我只要問你" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148006/319.wav", + "text": "你使用自有資金" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148006/320.wav", + "text": "為什麼就你可以用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148006/321.wav", + "text": "別人不可以用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148006/322.wav", + "text": "法律沒有規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148006/323.wav", + "text": "自有資金的使用嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148006/324.wav", + "text": "畜產會的資金使用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148006/325.wav", + "text": "是經過董事會同意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148006/326.wav", + "text": "所以董事會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148006/327.wav", + "text": "可以不按照法律的規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148006/328.wav", + "text": "哇我的天啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148006/329.wav", + "text": "現在民間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148006/330.wav", + "text": "不管是社團法人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148006/331.wav", + "text": "財團法人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148006/332.wav", + "text": "董事會做任何的事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148006/333.wav", + "text": "都要按照法律的規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148006/334.wav", + "text": "只有畜產會厲害" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148006/335.wav", + "text": "你現在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148006/336.wav", + "text": "等於是愛做什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148006/337.wav", + "text": "就做什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148006/338.wav", + "text": "你的自有資金" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148006/339.wav", + "text": "可以不按照法律的規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148006/340.wav", + "text": "現在不是全" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148006/341.wav", + "text": "畜牧法裡面有規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148006/342.wav", + "text": "畜產會要做什麼業務" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148006/343.wav", + "text": "不能這樣做這是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148006/344.wav", + "text": "違法的你們自己查一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148006/345.wav", + "text": "哪裡有董事會說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148006/346.wav", + "text": "我決定了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148006/347.wav", + "text": "他可以用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148006/348.wav", + "text": "就可以用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148006/349.wav", + "text": "天啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148006/350.wav", + "text": "為非作歹到極點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148006/351.wav", + "text": "畜產會的所有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148006/352.wav", + "text": "你講清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148006/353.wav", + "text": "說明白" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148006/354.wav", + "text": "在國會殿堂裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148006/355.wav", + "text": "胡說八道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148006/356.wav", + "text": "國會殿堂裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148006/357.wav", + "text": "是用來回答" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148006/358.wav", + "text": "讓全民知道的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148006/359.wav", + "text": "好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148006/360.wav", + "text": "我拜託" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148006/361.wav", + "text": "我已經從11日等到現在了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148006/362.wav", + "text": "拜託他把資料提出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148006/363.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148006/364.wav", + "text": "會後趕快把資料提供給他" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148006/365.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148006/366.wav", + "text": "上次我打電話給你" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148006/367.wav", + "text": "你也是慢了很久啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148006/368.wav", + "text": "謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148006/369.wav", + "text": "今天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148006/370.wav", + "text": "好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148006/371.wav", + "text": "今天可以嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148006/372.wav", + "text": "記得送給委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148006/373.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148006/374.wav", + "text": "好可以嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148006/375.wav", + "text": "今天可以嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148006/376.wav", + "text": "還要跪求" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148006/377.wav", + "text": "我回去還要再整理一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148006/378.wav", + "text": "多久" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148006/379.wav", + "text": "肯定不是今天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148006/380.wav", + "text": "多久" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148006/381.wav", + "text": "沒關係多久" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148006/382.wav", + "text": "能不能給我們一個禮拜" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148006/383.wav", + "text": "東西一定要出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148006/384.wav", + "text": "而且針對問題回答" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148006/385.wav", + "text": "不要寫作文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148006/386.wav", + "text": "好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148006/387.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148006/388.wav", + "text": "謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148004/0.wav", + "text": "最近我看在立法院裡最紅的就是潛艦跟南投" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148004/1.wav", + "text": "剛好你們南投艦也來湊熱鬧" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148004/2.wav", + "text": "關於整個原因依我早上特地在位子上聽你們的答詢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148004/3.wav", + "text": "你們說是機械問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148004/4.wav", + "text": "嘛如果我不看任何資料" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148004/5.wav", + "text": "像這種事情你們叫第二海軍" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148004/6.wav", + "text": "啊\n我們現在一共有多少艦艇" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148004/7.wav", + "text": "到今天為止是164" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148004/8.wav", + "text": "164" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148004/9.wav", + "text": "164" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148004/10.wav", + "text": "以後有沒有辦法都排除像今天這種狀況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148004/11.wav", + "text": "因為那很可怕" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148004/12.wav", + "text": "耶在我看來我覺得發生這種事情觀感會不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148004/13.wav", + "text": "啦會失去信心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148004/14.wav", + "text": "啦尤其是國艦國造" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148004/15.wav", + "text": "這些都是政府的政策" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148004/16.wav", + "text": "在內政委員會在立法院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148004/17.wav", + "text": "大家對你們是大力支持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148004/18.wav", + "text": "喔你們去看整個內政委員會的答詢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148004/19.wav", + "text": "對於你們主委在我們內政委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148004/20.wav", + "text": "也把她尊稱為海洋女神" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148004/21.wav", + "text": "耶大家是對你們有期待" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148004/22.wav", + "text": "啊所以你看每一位委員在質詢時的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148004/23.wav", + "text": "其實對你們都手下留情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148004/24.wav", + "text": "啦這都是表達支持之意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148004/25.wav", + "text": "但是對於這種事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148004/26.wav", + "text": "我要問的就是\n" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148004/27.wav", + "text": "你說現在幾艘" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148004/28.wav", + "text": "現在164164艘" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148004/29.wav", + "text": "都已經到達碼頭了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148004/30.wav", + "text": "你們卻說我以為怎麼樣怎麼樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148004/31.wav", + "text": "以為已經停好了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148004/32.wav", + "text": "結果沒有停好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148004/33.wav", + "text": "那是開什麼玩笑" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148004/34.wav", + "text": "這種事情不應該再發生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148004/35.wav", + "text": "是委員我們會想辦法儘量預防這樣的狀況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148004/36.wav", + "text": "剛才我們主委也有提到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148004/37.wav", + "text": "我們會加強航前的檢查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148004/38.wav", + "text": "是嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148004/39.wav", + "text": "我就說好吧" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148004/40.wav", + "text": "南投艦以後不會發生了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148004/41.wav", + "text": "因為你們又設定了一個什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148004/42.wav", + "text": "了但是其他艦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148004/43.wav", + "text": "都是比照辦理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148004/44.wav", + "text": "也都不能再發生這種事情啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148004/45.wav", + "text": "好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148004/46.wav", + "text": "有164艘" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148004/47.wav", + "text": "那你們現在會開船的人有多少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148004/48.wav", + "text": "我們目前合格的駕駛員有834" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148004/49.wav", + "text": "需求是520" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148004/50.wav", + "text": "那我們人員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148004/51.wav", + "text": "要專業在駕駛的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148004/52.wav", + "text": "但我看過一份資料" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148004/53.wav", + "text": "我們的駕駛員有803十幾人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148004/54.wav", + "text": "耶至於真正的需求數是520員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148004/55.wav", + "text": "足以執行各項任務" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148004/56.wav", + "text": "我是說艦艇的駕駛員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148004/57.wav", + "text": "們的編制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148004/58.wav", + "text": "是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148004/59.wav", + "text": "你們現在編制多少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148004/60.wav", + "text": "到現在是多少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148004/61.wav", + "text": "58" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148004/62.wav", + "text": "58" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148004/63.wav", + "text": "是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148004/64.wav", + "text": "58" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148004/65.wav", + "text": "對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148004/66.wav", + "text": "好比說某個中隊有15艘艇" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148004/67.wav", + "text": "但不是每艘艇同時出去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148004/68.wav", + "text": "所以人員是調度使用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148004/69.wav", + "text": "而我們剛剛講的164艘" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148004/70.wav", + "text": "中只有26艘是大型船艦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148004/71.wav", + "text": "所謂大型船艦就是500噸以上的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148004/72.wav", + "text": "一般則都是100噸以下的巡邏艇" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148004/73.wav", + "text": "巡邏艇的艇長與副艇長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148004/74.wav", + "text": "都是合格的駕駛員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148004/75.wav", + "text": "你們目前是由專責駕駛員負責" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148004/76.wav", + "text": "大船的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148004/77.wav", + "text": "所以至少會有3個駕駛員以上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148004/78.wav", + "text": "所以你們現在人力夠嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148004/79.wav", + "text": "確定夠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148004/80.wav", + "text": "這不要開玩笑" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148004/81.wav", + "text": "不開玩笑" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148004/82.wav", + "text": "現在大家是在立法院裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148004/83.wav", + "text": "而我看到你們的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148004/84.wav", + "text": "的艦艇駕駛員編制這是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148004/85.wav", + "text": "是你們給我的資料" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148004/86.wav", + "text": "107年是72" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148004/87.wav", + "text": "人109年72" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148004/88.wav", + "text": "人你們根本就沒有增加" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148004/89.wav", + "text": "而是到了112年也就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148004/90.wav", + "text": "要是你們人數真的少的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148004/91.wav", + "text": "就要趕快訓練" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148004/92.wav", + "text": "不然你們有那麼多艦艇" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148004/93.wav", + "text": "雖然你說不一定每一艘艦艇都要有一個人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148004/94.wav", + "text": "但如果要嘲笑你的就會說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148004/95.wav", + "text": "你根本就沒有用到那麼多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148004/96.wav", + "text": "沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148004/97.wav", + "text": "跟委員報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148004/98.wav", + "text": "這些人力都持續在訓練" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148004/99.wav", + "text": "為了因應未來的造艦計畫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148004/100.wav", + "text": "這些人力都是逐年在增加當中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148004/101.wav", + "text": "因為我們現在的新艦都是大的船" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148004/102.wav", + "text": "譬如說今年就有3艘大船" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148004/103.wav", + "text": "很簡單" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148004/104.wav", + "text": "啦副主委署長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148004/105.wav", + "text": "不能再發生了好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148004/106.wav", + "text": "以後不會在南投艦發生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148004/107.wav", + "text": "在其他艦也不要再發生了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148004/108.wav", + "text": "畢竟叫做第二海軍" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148004/109.wav", + "text": "也有國艦國造" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148004/110.wav", + "text": "嘛硬體都有了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148004/111.wav", + "text": "但是在軟體上人力的訓練人員的補足" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148004/112.wav", + "text": "整個立法院都在支持你們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148004/113.wav", + "text": "啊\n另外我請海委會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148004/114.wav", + "text": "管主委也上來一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148004/115.wav", + "text": "主委我想特別關心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148004/116.wav", + "text": "跟降低海域活動風險這個問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148004/117.wav", + "text": "啦我看到衛福部的統計" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148004/118.wav", + "text": "事故傷害位居國人死因第八名" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148004/119.wav", + "text": "有6009百多將近700件事故傷害" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148004/120.wav", + "text": "其中意外溺死跟淹沒" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148004/121.wav", + "text": "喔也就是占整體事故傷害的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148004/122.wav", + "text": "就有4.6%將近5%" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148004/123.wav", + "text": "而意外溺死跟淹沒部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148004/124.wav", + "text": "分別排名在第三與第二" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148004/125.wav", + "text": "也就是說這部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148004/126.wav", + "text": "是值得重視的一個議題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148004/127.wav", + "text": "啦\n像今年我看到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148004/128.wav", + "text": "體育改革聯盟發起人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148004/129.wav", + "text": "啦就剛好發生在我們小琉球這個地方" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148004/130.wav", + "text": "令人感到非常遺憾" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148004/131.wav", + "text": "人士都會有這種意外事故發生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148004/132.wav", + "text": "何況是一般民眾" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148004/133.wav", + "text": "\n我要請教主委的就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148004/134.wav", + "text": "夏季到了尾聲" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148004/135.wav", + "text": "今年相關海域活動" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148004/136.wav", + "text": "中大約發生幾件" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148004/137.wav", + "text": "事故跟過去做比較的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148004/138.wav", + "text": "今年有稍微比較減少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148004/139.wav", + "text": "有206件" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148004/140.wav", + "text": "去年同期是228件" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148004/141.wav", + "text": "救難部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148004/142.wav", + "text": "去年人數是339人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148004/143.wav", + "text": "今年是189人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148004/144.wav", + "text": "總體來講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148004/145.wav", + "text": "這個期程是653人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148004/146.wav", + "text": "今年是458人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148004/147.wav", + "text": "有稍降" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148004/148.wav", + "text": "但我們還是必須加強" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148004/149.wav", + "text": "還是要再加油再努力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148004/150.wav", + "text": "明年度在遊憩安全部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148004/151.wav", + "text": "等於增加2倍" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148004/152.wav", + "text": "都聽到主委在講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148004/153.wav", + "text": "你們的宣傳費用編" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148004/154.wav", + "text": "編得很少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148004/155.wav", + "text": "這是一個新的單位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148004/156.wav", + "text": "業務五花八門" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148004/157.wav", + "text": "你們管得多寬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148004/158.wav", + "text": "你知道嗎你們是管最寬的地方" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148004/159.wav", + "text": "是我跟委員說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148004/160.wav", + "text": "剛剛委員很關心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148004/161.wav", + "text": "我們的船真的不能夠再發生像南投那" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148004/162.wav", + "text": "真的要請委員支持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148004/163.wav", + "text": "有一項4年88億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148004/164.wav", + "text": "元明年15億元的預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148004/165.wav", + "text": "事實上今年就已經用了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148004/166.wav", + "text": "第二預備金將近3億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148004/167.wav", + "text": "我相信只要你們提出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148004/168.wav", + "text": "立法院評估有合理性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148004/169.wav", + "text": "大家都會表達強力支持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148004/170.wav", + "text": "所以我們有一項4年計畫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148004/171.wav", + "text": "南投艦是18年的船" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148004/172.wav", + "text": "是機器故障" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148004/173.wav", + "text": "我們現在只能針對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148004/174.wav", + "text": "還沒有出動之前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148004/175.wav", + "text": "還沒開車之前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148004/176.wav", + "text": "先繫纜試車" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148004/177.wav", + "text": "那更要加緊趕快做建置" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148004/178.wav", + "text": "是行前檢查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148004/179.wav", + "text": "減少了是好事" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148004/180.wav", + "text": "以後海委會是不是可以再強化" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148004/181.wav", + "text": "水域活動的意外" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148004/182.wav", + "text": "才有辦法對症下藥" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148004/183.wav", + "text": "好這這部分我倒覺得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148004/184.wav", + "text": "主委可以大刀闊斧來做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148004/185.wav", + "text": "而且我還發現一點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148004/186.wav", + "text": "向海致敬部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148004/187.wav", + "text": "兩個項目目前有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148004/188.wav", + "text": "哪一些項目" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148004/189.wav", + "text": "像委員就非常關心潛水" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148004/190.wav", + "text": "嘛其實潛水" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148004/191.wav", + "text": "時有人帶領是會更好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148004/192.wav", + "text": "我的想法就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148004/193.wav", + "text": "開放山林跟向海致敬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148004/194.wav", + "text": "我很明顯地看到編的預算就是特別多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148004/195.wav", + "text": "新的單位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148004/196.wav", + "text": "產業發展條例已經制定了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148004/197.wav", + "text": "海委會站在海洋業務的角色" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148004/198.wav", + "text": "要去統合要去協調" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148004/199.wav", + "text": "不足的地方趕快" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148004/200.wav", + "text": "好我們最近統合協調的事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148004/201.wav", + "text": "增加了很多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148004/202.wav", + "text": "也都很認真在做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148004/203.wav", + "text": "包括小琉球遊憩乘" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148004/204.wav", + "text": "乘載量的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148004/205.wav", + "text": "針對各不同海洋利用者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148004/206.wav", + "text": "彼此之間意見不一樣的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148004/207.wav", + "text": "我們也��在協調" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148004/208.wav", + "text": "我以前是台灣國家山協理事長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148004/209.wav", + "text": "對於高山嚮導我們以前培訓過很多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148004/210.wav", + "text": "我們趕快也有水域的嚮導現在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148004/211.wav", + "text": "跟溯溪這兩個有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148004/212.wav", + "text": "我們來盤點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148004/213.wav", + "text": "發揮海委會更大的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148004/214.wav", + "text": "啦這個大家給你們支持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148004/215.wav", + "text": "另外我看你們的官網" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148004/216.wav", + "text": "一站式平台每年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148004/217.wav", + "text": "我發現到一個問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148004/218.wav", + "text": "能開發一個app" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148004/219.wav", + "text": "現在是網路app" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148004/220.wav", + "text": "主委不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148004/221.wav", + "text": "你們的網站現在還要先google" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148004/222.wav", + "text": "然後再打一站式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148004/223.wav", + "text": "有幾個民眾" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148004/224.wav", + "text": "還有Go Ocean" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148004/225.wav", + "text": "一般民眾哪會想到跟" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148004/226.wav", + "text": "跟委員報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148004/227.wav", + "text": "我在主管會報就有請他們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148004/228.wav", + "text": "去設計手機app" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148004/229.wav", + "text": "我覺得要改啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148004/230.wav", + "text": "很大" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148004/231.wav", + "text": "app" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148004/232.wav", + "text": "我每一個辦公室都會點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148004/233.wav", + "text": "真的是不錯" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148004/234.wav", + "text": "即時的海象都在上面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148004/235.wav", + "text": "然後告訴你" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148004/236.wav", + "text": "你如果不是專家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148004/237.wav", + "text": "在這裡你不能游泳" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148004/238.wav", + "text": "喔在這裡你不能夠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148004/239.wav", + "text": "衝浪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148004/240.wav", + "text": "好啊主委講得這麼好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148004/241.wav", + "text": "我可以知道海象" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148004/242.wav", + "text": "可以知道這邊的情況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148004/243.wav", + "text": "水質問題是我接觸不到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148004/244.wav", + "text": "我認為你們真的是要想辦法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148004/245.wav", + "text": "有那麼好的內容" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148004/246.wav", + "text": "搞不好也不知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148004/247.wav", + "text": "我們院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148004/248.wav", + "text": "之前跟我說圖資圖檔" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148004/249.wav", + "text": "已經進行到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148004/250.wav", + "text": "安全測試" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148004/251.wav", + "text": "了安全測試通過後就可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148004/252.wav", + "text": "主委立法院不管這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148004/253.wav", + "text": "你缺錢我們給你支持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148004/254.wav", + "text": "你要趕快把它弄出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148004/255.wav", + "text": "啊我們要的就是一個結果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148004/256.wav", + "text": "最後一個問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148004/257.wav", + "text": "召委對不起\n小琉球這個地方" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148004/258.wav", + "text": "你看我們一直在復育" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148004/259.wav", + "text": "小琉球碰到一個很大的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148004/260.wav", + "text": "地方需要觀光" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148004/261.wav", + "text": "那麼多的調查裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148004/262.wav", + "text": "覆蓋率低於10%就屬於失能" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148004/263.wav", + "text": "失能而失去造礁功能沒有辦法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148004/264.wav", + "text": "孕育這些魚類" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148004/265.wav", + "text": "肚仔坪花瓶岩龍蝦洞" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148004/266.wav", + "text": "和蛤板灣六個地方" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148004/267.wav", + "text": "有四個地方" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148004/268.wav", + "text": "旅客進來我們也要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148004/269.wav", + "text": "推廣責任旅遊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148004/270.wav", + "text": "水質當然都變得不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148004/271.wav", + "text": "啊我們在地的人又不敢講要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148004/272.wav", + "text": "要管制請遊客都不要來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148004/273.wav", + "text": "協調我們現在潮間帶" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148004/274.wav", + "text": "已經協調好承載量" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148004/275.wav", + "text": "作人數限制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148004/276.wav", + "text": "但是整體來講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148004/277.wav", + "text": "真的有太多各方面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148004/278.wav", + "text": "意見不一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148004/279.wav", + "text": "我們小平台大平台都持續在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148004/280.wav", + "text": "我的意思就是說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148004/281.wav", + "text": "不然我們就比較大聲一點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148004/282.wav", + "text": "好啦我覺" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148004/283.wav", + "text": "去那裡跟他們說為了整個小琉球的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148004/284.wav", + "text": "永續不解決真的不行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148004/285.wav", + "text": "不然到最後我們會覺得這有點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148004/286.wav", + "text": "殺雞取卵" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148004/287.wav", + "text": "統統都失敗" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148004/288.wav", + "text": "在我們小琉球珊瑚礁就是種不起來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148004/289.wav", + "text": "加油一下好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148004/290.wav", + "text": "好感謝謝謝加油" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148004/291.wav", + "text": "謝謝謝謝莊瑞雄委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148004/292.wav", + "text": "\n賴品妤委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148004/293.wav", + "text": "交書面質詢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148004/294.wav", + "text": "\n接下來請林文瑞委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148002/0.wav", + "text": "謝謝主席拜託請薛部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148002/1.wav", + "text": "有請部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148002/2.wav", + "text": "部長好部長早" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148002/3.wav", + "text": "我們長照 ABC這6年來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148002/4.wav", + "text": "應該給予肯定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148002/5.wav", + "text": "但是有一些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148002/6.wav", + "text": "可能比較複雜" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148002/7.wav", + "text": "不是很多人使用的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148002/8.wav", + "text": "不見得很多鄉親都瞭解" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148002/9.wav", + "text": "所以我在這邊也再次強調" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148002/10.wav", + "text": "我們要多宣導這個1966" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148002/11.wav", + "text": "像我們苗栗的部苗" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148002/12.wav", + "text": "我覺得他們都做的很好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148002/13.wav", + "text": "剛才有委員說你公關費" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148002/14.wav", + "text": "可能不足的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148002/15.wav", + "text": "我倒覺得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148002/16.wav", + "text": "你這個宣導的費用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148002/17.wav", + "text": "也可以多一點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148002/18.wav", + "text": "甚至最近好像也看得到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148002/19.wav", + "text": "皮蛇的廣告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148002/20.wav", + "text": "確實在我們家鄉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148002/21.wav", + "text": "以及身邊也很多人都得到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148002/22.wav", + "text": "我簡單" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148002/23.wav", + "text": "現在巴氏量表的免評範圍" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148002/24.wav", + "text": "除了我們報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148002/25.wav", + "text": "報告裡面有講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148002/26.wav", + "text": "針對使用長照服務持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148002/27.wav", + "text": "肢體障礙罕見疾病呼吸器官" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148002/28.wav", + "text": "或吞嚥機能失去功能等等三大類的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148002/29.wav", + "text": "都有採取多元認定的方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148002/30.wav", + "text": "經失能診斷書專業評估採取" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148002/31.wav", + "text": "簡便的便民措施等等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148002/32.wav", + "text": "我現在主要講的是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148002/33.wav", + "text": "也有許多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148002/34.wav", + "text": "病友的家屬在反映" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148002/35.wav", + "text": "治療的過程也非常的辛苦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148002/36.wav", + "text": "身體可能非常的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148002/37.wav", + "text": "虛弱" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148002/38.wav", + "text": "絕大部分沒有辦法一個人到醫院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148002/39.wav", + "text": "去進行治療" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148002/40.wav", + "text": "也必須要有家屬陪同" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148002/41.wav", + "text": "治療回診" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148002/42.wav", + "text": "往往來回" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148002/43.wav", + "text": "照顧者家庭的壓力非常的大" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148002/44.wav", + "text": "有關這一類的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148002/45.wav", + "text": "但是我也有想過關於" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148002/46.wav", + "text": "癌症我們臺灣醫療" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148002/47.wav", + "text": "水準很高" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148002/48.wav", + "text": "很進步不管說一期" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148002/49.wav", + "text": "二期甚至三期" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148002/50.wav", + "text": "���有恢復得很好的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148002/51.wav", + "text": "後來我想" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148002/52.wav", + "text": "可能在那個時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148002/53.wav", + "text": "在那邊又不太適用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148002/54.wav", + "text": "有點浪費看護" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148002/55.wav", + "text": "所以我也在這邊反映" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148002/56.wav", + "text": "看怎麼樣可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148002/57.wav", + "text": "兩全其美" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148002/58.wav", + "text": "這個也請我們部裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148002/59.wav", + "text": "考慮一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148002/60.wav", + "text": "\n再來就是有關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148002/61.wav", + "text": "常講的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148002/62.wav", + "text": "你們講的叫小規機" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148002/63.wav", + "text": "社區式的照顧服務" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148002/64.wav", + "text": "我們得到的訊息是說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148002/65.wav", + "text": "小規機的夜間服務" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148002/66.wav", + "text": "它使用的前提" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148002/67.wav", + "text": "是必須先使用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148002/68.wav", + "text": "日照服務" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148002/69.wav", + "text": "但是日照服務" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148002/70.wav", + "text": "又不收重度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148002/71.wav", + "text": "失能的對象" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148002/72.wav", + "text": "失能對象" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148002/73.wav", + "text": "他得不到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148002/74.wav", + "text": "好像看得到但他使用不到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148002/75.wav", + "text": "是否可以解決" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148002/76.wav", + "text": "跟委員報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148002/77.wav", + "text": "這一個部分其實我們並沒有限制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148002/78.wav", + "text": "只有在日照" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148002/79.wav", + "text": "使用小規機" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148002/80.wav", + "text": "現在問題是這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148002/81.wav", + "text": "因為夜間夜宿" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148002/82.wav", + "text": "這個部分並" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148002/83.wav", + "text": "所以在人力的安排" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148002/84.wav", + "text": "上面會有困難" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148002/85.wav", + "text": "設置在那邊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148002/86.wav", + "text": "但它就不願意開放" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148002/87.wav", + "text": "部長你如果沒有這樣的限制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148002/88.wav", + "text": "都還OK啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148002/89.wav", + "text": "講話比較不好意思\n" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148002/90.wav", + "text": "另外障礙者也是我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148002/91.wav", + "text": "長照服務的範圍" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148002/92.wav", + "text": "現在他們反映" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148002/93.wav", + "text": "可能時間還可以處理得比較快" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148002/94.wav", + "text": "但對象若是有障礙" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148002/95.wav", + "text": "的脫衣服穿衣服的時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148002/96.wav", + "text": "可能拉得比較長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148002/97.wav", + "text": "所以這部分也" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148002/98.wav", + "text": "一下怎麼處" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148002/99.wav", + "text": "鐘因我們的照服員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148002/100.wav", + "text": "居服員好像服務30分鐘" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148002/101.wav", + "text": "算一件" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148002/102.wav", + "text": "如果時間比較長的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148002/103.wav", + "text": "費用應該也要多一點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148002/104.wav", + "text": "好的這部分我們再來看一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148002/105.wav", + "text": "因為詳細內容" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148002/106.wav", + "text": "我記不太清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148002/107.wav", + "text": "但我記得我們現在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148002/108.wav", + "text": "2.0支付標準" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148002/109.wav", + "text": "完成工作多少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148002/110.wav", + "text": "並不是用時間去算的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148002/111.wav", + "text": "當然委員的意思是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148002/112.wav", + "text": "如果是比較複雜" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148002/113.wav", + "text": "時間要比較長是不是要多給一點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148002/114.wav", + "text": "這部分我們再來檢討看看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148002/115.wav", + "text": "一樣我們確實" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148002/116.wav", + "text": "也要服務好人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148002/117.wav", + "text": "總不能說30分鐘" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148002/118.wav", + "text": "或是衣服還沒穿" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148002/119.wav", + "text": "當然居服員的權益" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148002/120.wav", + "text": "我們也要顧慮到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148002/121.wav", + "text": "因為有鄉親反映" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148002/122.wav", + "text": "席就在這邊跟部長反映\n" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148002/123.wav", + "text": "還有我們在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148002/124.wav", + "text": "評斷長照的指標" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148002/125.wav", + "text": "時平常都是用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148002/126.wav", + "text": "達到一定水準之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148002/127.wav", + "text": "我們就把重點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148002/128.wav", + "text": "失能率" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148002/129.wav", + "text": "我們就要針對每一位長者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148002/130.wav", + "text": "的失能狀況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148002/131.wav", + "text": "訂定復能計畫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148002/132.wav", + "text": "說CA07裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148002/133.wav", + "text": "就是CA07" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148002/134.wav", + "text": "跟CA08" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148002/135.wav", + "text": "CBCD" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148002/136.wav", + "text": "兩個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148002/137.wav", + "text": "CA07跟CA08" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148002/138.wav", + "text": "的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148002/139.wav", + "text": "難度或是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148002/140.wav", + "text": "他可以用的這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148002/141.wav", + "text": "資格也比較難" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148002/142.wav", + "text": "取得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148002/143.wav", + "text": "可是我們看兩邊的件數" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148002/144.wav", + "text": "不管3次4,500" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148002/145.wav", + "text": "或4次6,000" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148002/146.wav", + "text": "都是1次1,500" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148002/147.wav", + "text": "CBCD1,500" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148002/148.wav", + "text": "我沒有意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148002/149.wav", + "text": "我的意思是CA07" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148002/150.wav", + "text": "跟CA08是不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148002/151.wav", + "text": "技術性還是什麼也比較高" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148002/152.wav", + "text": "把CA07CA08" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148002/153.wav", + "text": "剛剛講的CBCD" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148002/154.wav", + "text": "關於這個部分我們會在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148002/155.wav", + "text": "去做討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148002/156.wav", + "text": "如果要講得合理我覺得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148002/157.wav", + "text": "CA07CA08要比CBCD" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148002/158.wav", + "text": "目標" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148002/159.wav", + "text": "謝謝部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148002/160.wav", + "text": "謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148001/0.wav", + "text": "有請黃主委和證期局張局長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148001/1.wav", + "text": "兩位好今天有很多人關心台北股市" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148001/2.wav", + "text": "就這個禮拜來看今天的股市好像不太好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148001/3.wav", + "text": "甚至五年來看其實也不算太差" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148001/4.wav", + "text": "對不對對金管會或證期局來說不是看股市好壞" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148001/5.wav", + "text": "還有我們企業的發展" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148001/6.wav", + "text": "請教主委就任主委一職有幾年了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148001/7.wav", + "text": "三年多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148001/8.wav", + "text": "請問在你任內上市上櫃的IPO有多少家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148001/9.wav", + "text": "現在有1,800多家左右" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148001/10.wav", + "text": "換句話說每年都成長今年先不算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148001/11.wav", + "text": "請問去年前年跟大前年分別各有多少家IPO" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148001/12.wav", + "text": "我記得去年合計大概六十幾家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148001/13.wav", + "text": "去年多少家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148001/14.wav", + "text": "上市24家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148001/15.wav", + "text": "上櫃27家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148001/16.wav", + "text": "創櫃17家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148001/17.wav", + "text": "換句話說每年都還在增加" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148001/18.wav", + "text": "我為什麼問這個問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148001/19.wav", + "text": "行政院主計總處還有其他部會就在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148001/20.wav", + "text": "台灣的超額儲蓄" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148001/21.wav", + "text": "超額儲蓄的定義就是我的儲蓄減掉我的投資" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148001/22.wav", + "text": "就叫超額儲蓄" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148001/23.wav", + "text": "十四點多將近百分之十五" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148001/24.wav", + "text": "相較於周邊的國家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148001/25.wav", + "text": "─日本韓國中國大陸" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148001/26.wav", + "text": "沒有投資在產業" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148001/27.wav", + "text": "來創造更多的財富" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148001/28.wav", + "text": "創造更多的就業機會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148001/29.wav", + "text": "IPO的公司很多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148001/30.wav", + "text": "當然那是在往上衝的階段" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148001/31.wav", + "text": "感覺這幾年IPO好像進入到高原期" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148001/32.wav", + "text": "前兩年的疫情是因素之一" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148001/33.wav", + "text": "當然整個企業的環境可能也有些影響" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148001/34.wav", + "text": "不過我們還是不斷努力增加IPO的數字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148001/35.wav", + "text": "以前還有一些KY股" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148001/36.wav", + "text": "最近這幾年比較少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148001/37.wav", + "text": "KY股要稍微注意一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148001/38.wav", + "text": "我不覺得為了衝家數就要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148001/39.wav", + "text": "KY股所帶來的後遺症" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148001/40.wav", + "text": "很多事務所不是很認真的在處理KY的事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148001/41.wav", + "text": "也造成一些小風波" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148001/42.wav", + "text": "憑良心講像前年去年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148001/43.wav", + "text": "我覺得保險局處理得還不錯" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148001/44.wav", + "text": "當然這不是只有你們的責任" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148001/45.wav", + "text": "蓬勃發展當然就是要創造那個環境" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148001/46.wav", + "text": "我覺得青創這一塊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148001/47.wav", + "text": "資年輕人是我們國家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148001/48.wav", + "text": "衝鋒的主力也是我們國家的未來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148001/49.wav", + "text": "所以在青創這個部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148001/50.wav", + "text": "分可不可以告訴我你有什麼樣的構想" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148001/51.wav", + "text": "我跟委員報告其實我們從2020" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148001/52.wav", + "text": "就開始規劃創新板" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148001/53.wav", + "text": "包括櫃買的戰略新板及交易所的創新板" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148001/54.wav", + "text": "板2021也就是開始後第一年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148001/55.wav", + "text": "創新板並沒有特別的績效" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148001/56.wav", + "text": "但從去年開始" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148001/57.wav", + "text": "創新板已經有一些績效在那個地方了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148001/58.wav", + "text": "很多本來要去國外上市的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148001/59.wav", + "text": "也都覺得台灣可以發展" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148001/60.wav", + "text": "所以就留下來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148001/61.wav", + "text": "未來我們對創新板這一塊會積極去處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148001/62.wav", + "text": "而且它登板的條件也會盡量再有彈性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148001/63.wav", + "text": "我覺得你在參加行政院院會的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148001/64.wav", + "text": "要跟其他部會提出這種看法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148001/65.wav", + "text": "只有往前衝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148001/66.wav", + "text": "台灣才會有未來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148001/67.wav", + "text": "也許有未來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148001/68.wav", + "text": "但相對是比較難的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148001/69.wav", + "text": "我再請教一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148001/70.wav", + "text": "包括本席" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148001/71.wav", + "text": "關心大股東干政的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148001/72.wav", + "text": "一開始你們送行政院的版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148001/73.wav", + "text": "還有限制表決解除或停職" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148001/74.wav", + "text": "對該法人的董事" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148001/75.wav", + "text": "限期處分他的持股" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148001/76.wav", + "text": "我聽到行政院那邊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148001/77.wav", + "text": "所以法案現在也沒有送出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148001/78.wav", + "text": "你們還是只維持罰款的那個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148001/79.wav", + "text": "怎麼會有這麼大的變化" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148001/80.wav", + "text": "是謝謝委員指導" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148001/81.wav", + "text": "我把整個情況很簡單的跟你報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148001/82.wav", + "text": "我們看到過去大股東干政的情況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148001/83.wav", + "text": "的確覺得應該在法律上做規範" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148001/84.wav", + "text": "所以金管會在內部討論的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148001/85.wav", + "text": "的確就有像您所提到的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148001/86.wav", + "text": "對於大股東如果違反公司治理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148001/87.wav", + "text": "有限制出清股票" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148001/88.wav", + "text": "或是限制股票的表決權等等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148001/89.wav", + "text": "但是後來在公聽會中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148001/90.wav", + "text": "外界─不只是業界" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148001/91.wav", + "text": "律師界學界都有對我們一些意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148001/92.wav", + "text": "認為這些東西在執行上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148001/93.wav", + "text": "會有法律定義不明確的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148001/94.wav", + "text": "我們衡量的結果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148001/95.wav", + "text": "因為這個法案還有其他的法案條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148001/96.wav", + "text": "都要通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148001/97.wav", + "text": "我們希望把爭議比較高的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148001/98.wav", + "text": "暫時先做一些調整" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148001/99.wav", + "text": "所以送到行政院的版本是本來就已經拿掉的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148001/100.wav", + "text": "不是行政院給我們的指示" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148001/101.wav", + "text": "可不可以請教一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148001/102.wav", + "text": "他們都有些什麼樣的意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148001/103.wav", + "text": "律師界的意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148001/104.wav", + "text": "是不是請莊局長說請" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148001/105.wav", + "text": "請局長說明一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148001/106.wav", + "text": "報告委員最主要是不當干政" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148001/107.wav", + "text": "的定義問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148001/108.wav", + "text": "不管是律師或學界" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148001/109.wav", + "text": "你的定義範圍就要講清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148001/110.wav", + "text": "我們之前已經有累積一些案例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148001/111.wav", + "text": "不過在定義上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148001/112.wav", + "text": "如果大家覺得還是不夠清楚的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148001/113.wav", + "text": "我們大家在這個行業都待了很久" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148001/114.wav", + "text": "我們就講白話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148001/115.wav", + "text": "有很多政治力量的加入" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148001/116.wav", + "text": "我也不要講誰了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148001/117.wav", + "text": "其實我都很清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148001/118.wav", + "text": "公司治理難道不重要嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148001/119.wav", + "text": "然後就躲在後面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148001/120.wav", + "text": "你們對那些人也罰款過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148001/121.wav", + "text": "對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148001/122.wav", + "text": "大股東沒有罰過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148001/123.wav", + "text": "對公司有罰過錢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148001/124.wav", + "text": "可是他都不怕" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148001/125.wav", + "text": "他還在還是現在進行式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148001/126.wav", + "text": "式並沒有因此而停職" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148001/127.wav", + "text": "現在我們把它解除了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148001/128.wav", + "text": "因為國家的產業政策" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148001/129.wav", + "text": "也必須得配合" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148001/130.wav", + "text": "投資人的權益保護" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148001/131.wav", + "text": "公司治理的尊嚴" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148001/132.wav", + "text": "你只有對公司的罰款" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148001/133.wav", + "text": "對它的某種限制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148001/134.wav", + "text": "或者讓媒體報紙" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148001/135.wav", + "text": "登一登對它的警告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148001/136.wav", + "text": "它不怕的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148001/137.wav", + "text": "它真的不怕" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148001/138.wav", + "text": "它還是我行我素還在繼續搞" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148001/139.wav", + "text": "它並沒有因此而停止" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148001/140.wav", + "text": "箇中原因其實我們都很清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148001/141.wav", + "text": "我今天之所以在這邊講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148001/142.wav", + "text": "我也不要給你們金管會太多壓力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148001/143.wav", + "text": "因為那個壓力你們未必承擔得起" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148001/144.wav", + "text": "但是我要在這邊呼籲" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148001/145.wav", + "text": "難道我們金融秩序不應該維持嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148001/146.wav", + "text": "難道我們公司治理的尊嚴不應該持續嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148001/147.wav", + "text": "對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148001/148.wav", + "text": "還是要想想辦法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148001/149.wav", + "text": "會我們會繼續努力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148001/150.wav", + "text": "還是要想想辦法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148001/151.wav", + "text": "不要因為政治力的介入" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148001/152.wav", + "text": "這個不要跟我講什麼學術學者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148001/153.wav", + "text": "什麼大律師事務所" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148001/154.wav", + "text": "那都是假的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148001/155.wav", + "text": "是編造出來的理由" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148001/156.wav", + "text": "麻煩有權力的人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148001/157.wav", + "text": "那隻黑手不要再伸進去了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148001/158.wav", + "text": "好嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/148001/159.wav", + "text": "謝謝委員謝謝費召委謝謝主委" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147999/0.wav", + "text": "謝謝主席" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147999/1.wav", + "text": "先請教部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147999/2.wav", + "text": "有關於" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147999/3.wav", + "text": "我們應該要讓受刑人可以有投票的權利" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147999/4.wav", + "text": "只要他沒有被褫奪公權" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147999/5.wav", + "text": "我想請教" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147999/6.wav", + "text": "因為其實這不是在其他國家都有案例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147999/7.wav", + "text": "其實臺灣我們的選務人員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147999/8.wav", + "text": "也都是可以造冊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147999/9.wav", + "text": "他不一定要在自己戶籍地的那個投開票所來投票" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147999/10.wav", + "text": "因為我們的選務人員必須整個時間都在那裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147999/11.wav", + "text": "嘛我想請問一下部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147999/12.wav", + "text": "假設中選會OK的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147999/13.wav", + "text": "法務部這邊有沒有什麼窒礙難行的地方" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147999/14.wav", + "text": "在監獄設投開票所" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147999/15.wav", + "text": "如果中選會政策上決定要設" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147999/16.wav", + "text": "當然我們提供場地" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147999/17.wav", + "text": "還有動線等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147999/18.wav", + "text": "等等行政上的配合我們會盡力來達成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147999/19.wav", + "text": "啦主要是政策上的決定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147999/20.wav", + "text": "要不要在我們的監所裡面來設投開票所" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147999/21.wav", + "text": "不可能我們把人帶出去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147999/22.wav", + "text": "因為實在是太多人了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147999/23.wav", + "text": "而且分散在不同的地方" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147999/24.wav", + "text": "當然所以你們這邊是沒有窒礙難行的地方" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147999/25.wav", + "text": "我們可以克服啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147999/26.wav", + "text": "OK那請問一下中選會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147999/27.wav", + "text": "今天是副主委列席是是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147999/28.wav", + "text": "那你們覺得有什麼窒礙難行的地方" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147999/29.wav", + "text": "跟委員報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147999/30.wav", + "text": "我們的兩選罷法規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147999/31.wav", + "text": "所有的選舉必須是依普通平等直接無記名投票" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147999/32.wav", + "text": "且要以公開的方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147999/33.wav", + "text": "換句話說要在共見共聞的方式下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147999/34.wav", + "text": "讓不特定人可以來參與這一個投票的過程" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147999/35.wav", + "text": "尤其是開票要受公眾的監督" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147999/36.wav", + "text": "如果矯正機關內設置投票所" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147999/37.wav", + "text": "是不是符合我們憲法所規定的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147999/38.wav", + "text": "以及法律所規定的投票" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147999/39.wav", + "text": "應該要公開舉行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147999/40.wav", + "text": "開票也應該要公開舉行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147999/41.wav", + "text": "最重要的是這個公開舉行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147999/42.wav", + "text": "必須是不特定人可以自由進出該場所來參觀開票" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147999/43.wav", + "text": "老實說這其實都可���克服的啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147999/44.wav", + "text": "我們現在不是都可以現場直播" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147999/45.wav", + "text": "現場攝影嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147999/46.wav", + "text": "這些都不是理由啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147999/47.wav", + "text": "你覺得其他國家的投開票不是公開嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147999/48.wav", + "text": "也不是說現場觀看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147999/49.wav", + "text": "至少遠距觀看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147999/50.wav", + "text": "老實說我覺得你們這個理由真的是滿爛的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147999/51.wav", + "text": "至少我們知道了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147999/52.wav", + "text": "整個行程上是沒有問題的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147999/53.wav", + "text": "就是中選會現在又搬出了一個奇怪的理由" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147999/54.wav", + "text": "\n好回到今天的題目" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147999/55.wav", + "text": "今天的題目其實是總統副總統大選以及立法委員選舉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147999/56.wav", + "text": "境外勢力干預我國選舉之因應策略及準備情形" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147999/57.wav", + "text": "其實世界新聞年會也提到了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147999/58.wav", + "text": "現在真的是假訊息會影響整個選舉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147999/59.wav", + "text": "我好奇的是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147999/60.wav", + "text": "但是還有一個重點是境外勢力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147999/61.wav", + "text": "我想請教一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147999/62.wav", + "text": "如果境外勢力散播假訊息這要辦哪一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147999/63.wav", + "text": "只要涉及假訊息的傳播或是製造" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147999/64.wav", + "text": "有影響到我們整個選舉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147999/65.wav", + "text": "當然就是我們偵辦的對象" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147999/66.wav", + "text": "所以基本上只要是假訊息就不行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147999/67.wav", + "text": "如果是境外勢力傳播真訊息" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147999/68.wav", + "text": "或者是假境外勢力傳播真的訊息呢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147999/69.wav", + "text": "假境外勢力傳播真的訊息" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147999/70.wav", + "text": "這個當然個案上要由承辦單位來認定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147999/71.wav", + "text": "啦如果是真的訊息" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147999/72.wav", + "text": "如果符合言論自由" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147999/73.wav", + "text": "當然我們要保障" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147999/74.wav", + "text": "如果是境外勢力傳播真的訊息呢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147999/75.wav", + "text": "這算是保障言論自由的一部分嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147999/76.wav", + "text": "還是說這其實是干預我國選舉的一部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147999/77.wav", + "text": "這要個案上來認定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147999/78.wav", + "text": "啦如果是真的訊息" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147999/79.wav", + "text": "本來就是公開的訊息" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147999/80.wav", + "text": "這就沒有什麼違法不違法的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147999/81.wav", + "text": "如果是想要來操弄我們整個選舉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147999/82.wav", + "text": "當然這是我們要查察的對象" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147999/83.wav", + "text": "你沒有回答我" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147999/84.wav", + "text": "就是如果說它是一個真的訊息" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147999/85.wav", + "text": "可是它的來源是境外勢力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147999/86.wav", + "text": "請問副局長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147999/87.wav", + "text": "報告委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147999/88.wav", + "text": "在法律的構成要件裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147999/89.wav", + "text": "如果是真訊息的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147999/90.wav", + "text": "不管它的來源如何" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147999/91.wav", + "text": "我想這是言論自由保護的範疇" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147999/92.wav", + "text": "這個應該不會構成犯罪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147999/93.wav", + "text": "好那在國安上會有任何的顧慮嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147999/94.wav", + "text": "不會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147999/95.wav", + "text": "也不會有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147999/96.wav", + "text": "只要它是真的訊息" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147999/97.wav", + "text": "好所以基本上境外勢力真訊息" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147999/98.wav", + "text": "或者是假境外勢力真訊息" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147999/99.wav", + "text": "都是沒有問題的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147999/100.wav", + "text": "在法律的構成要件是如此" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147999/101.wav", + "text": "部長我請教一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147999/102.wav", + "text": "假境外勢力呢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147999/103.wav", + "text": "會假境外勢力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147999/104.wav", + "text": "我不曉得委員所指的是什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147999/105.wav", + "text": "其實就是反串" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147999/106.wav", + "text": "吧因為其實我們之前也有一些反串的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147999/107.wav", + "text": "那是國內的人反串境外勢力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147999/108.wav", + "text": "那他的目的是什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147999/109.wav", + "text": "構成要件也要看他的主觀" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147999/110.wav", + "text": "如果他的目的是影響選舉呢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147999/111.wav", + "text": "那要看他的行為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147999/112.wav", + "text": "他的目的是要影響選舉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147999/113.wav", + "text": "那麼他的行為有沒有觸犯我們現行的相關法規" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147999/114.wav", + "text": "好所以如果是假境外勢力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147999/115.wav", + "text": "但它是真的訊息的話也沒有問題了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147999/116.wav", + "text": "是這樣嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147999/117.wav", + "text": "這個還要看個案的情節" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147999/118.wav", + "text": "就是違反社會秩序維護法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147999/119.wav", + "text": "那也是違法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147999/120.wav", + "text": "所以也是違法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147999/121.wav", + "text": "違法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147999/122.wav", + "text": "啊只是行政法跟刑法不同而已" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147999/123.wav", + "text": "好基本上你就還是個案處理啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147999/124.wav", + "text": "其實今天大家在講的是副院長這件事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147999/125.wav", + "text": "他也說他提告了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147999/126.wav", + "text": "請問一下你們那邊有收到提告的訊息嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147999/127.wav", + "text": "還是說你們會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147999/128.wav", + "text": "我也是據報導說他要提出相關的訴訟" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147999/129.wav", + "text": "但是我沒有接到我們所屬機關說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147999/130.wav", + "text": "已經收到了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147999/131.wav", + "text": "我相信如果是刑事訴訟的告訴的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147999/132.wav", + "text": "檢察機關收狀以後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147999/133.wav", + "text": "就會依照告訴的內容來做處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147999/134.wav", + "text": "部長應該要好好地徹查啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147999/135.wav", + "text": "不然我們副院長真的是受到困擾很大" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147999/136.wav", + "text": "但是我們的重點不只是這到底是真是假" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147999/137.wav", + "text": "重點是它的源頭是什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147999/138.wav", + "text": "到底是誰丟出這樣子的照片" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147999/139.wav", + "text": "這個我們可以查得到嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147999/140.wav", + "text": "我們會盡全力把事實的真相查明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147999/141.wav", + "text": "就像我們在Line上面很多群組裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147999/142.wav", + "text": "會傳一些似是而非的圖卡也好訊息也好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147999/143.wav", + "text": "我們有辦法追查到源頭嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147999/144.wav", + "text": "可以嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147999/145.wav", + "text": "我們有辦法嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147999/146.wav", + "text": "會傾全力啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147999/147.wav", + "text": "像好油那個案子我們也是就有辦法追嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147999/148.wav", + "text": "要看每個案子的狀況不一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147999/149.wav", + "text": "因為像王鴻薇委員的案子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147999/150.wav", + "text": "你們到現在就還沒追出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147999/151.wav", + "text": "我不曉得那個個案是在哪一個地檢署" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147999/152.wav", + "text": "啦還有他指揮警察或調查局在偵辦中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147999/153.wav", + "text": "啦有沒有後續偵查追查的結果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147999/154.wav", + "text": "因為我們今天其實就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147999/155.wav", + "text": "要談針對影響我們選舉的境外勢力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147999/156.wav", + "text": "到底我們能不能避免他們的干預" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147999/157.wav", + "text": "就是避免境外勢力干預我們的選舉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147999/158.wav", + "text": "到底我們有沒有能力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147999/159.wav", + "text": "我想部長要讓全部的人信服" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147999/160.wav", + "text": "最簡單的是這麼大的一個案子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147999/161.wav", + "text": "副院長的案子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147999/162.wav", + "text": "一定要在選前儘快的讓大家知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147999/163.wav", + "text": "源頭是什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147999/164.wav", + "text": "大家才會知道你到底有沒有辦法溯源" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147999/165.wav", + "text": "才會知道是不是境外勢力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147999/166.wav", + "text": "你才能阻止它的干預" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147999/167.wav", + "text": "任何的案子我們都會傾全力來查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147999/168.wav", + "text": "啦不管他的身分是什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147999/169.wav", + "text": "只要有源頭我們一定會努力去追" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147999/170.wav", + "text": "我請教一下國安局副局長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147999/171.wav", + "text": "像這些照片出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147999/172.wav", + "text": "如果法務部那邊認為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147999/173.wav", + "text": "某些是真某些是假" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147999/174.wav", + "text": "我想你們可能也要查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147999/175.wav", + "text": "嘛因為這牽扯到跟國安有關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147999/176.wav", + "text": "畢竟是我們的副院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147999/177.wav", + "text": "你們有沒有辦法可以查得到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147999/178.wav", + "text": "到底人事時地物是什麼情況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147999/179.wav", + "text": "這件事情是什麼時候發生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147999/180.wav", + "text": "因為CCTV上面其實都有日期" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147999/181.wav", + "text": "到底在什麼位置" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147999/182.wav", + "text": "有哪一些人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147999/183.wav", + "text": "我們是有能力溯源" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147999/184.wav", + "text": "但是情報的部分是沒有辦法公開" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147999/185.wav", + "text": "所以你們可以溯源" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147999/186.wav", + "text": "但是如果這會影響選舉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147999/187.wav", + "text": "你們也不公開嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147999/188.wav", + "text": "不是現在是說這個內容" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147999/189.wav", + "text": "是不是在我們的權責範圍之內" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147999/190.wav", + "text": "這個我們還要再回去研究" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147999/191.wav", + "text": "怎樣才算你們的權責範圍" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147999/192.wav", + "text": "要真正涉及國家安全" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147999/193.wav", + "text": "如果是我們的副院長在對岸" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147999/194.wav", + "text": "有這樣的一個照片被傳出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147999/195.wav", + "text": "影響到我們的選舉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147999/196.wav", + "text": "這樣還不算影響國安嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147999/197.wav", + "text": "所以我們要評估" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147999/198.wav", + "text": "所以這樣子你們還必須要評估" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147999/199.wav", + "text": "不一定會影響國安" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147999/200.wav", + "text": "這個我們還要再研究" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147999/201.wav", + "text": "好謝謝主席謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147998/0.wav", + "text": "我覺得是非常辛苦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147998/1.wav", + "text": "你有沒有覺得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147998/2.wav", + "text": "當下流行什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147998/3.wav", + "text": "今年就變成螺螄粉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147998/4.wav", + "text": "主委你知道螺螄粉是什麼嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147998/5.wav", + "text": "我們有查到幾千公斤" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147998/6.wav", + "text": "3,293公斤" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147998/7.wav", + "text": "就有人走私什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147998/8.wav", + "text": "覺得有認真" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147998/9.wav", + "text": "因為本席在看你們的資料" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147998/10.wav", + "text": "在主委的帶領" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147998/11.wav", + "text": "不過我聽到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147998/12.wav", + "text": "還有300對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147998/13.wav", + "text": "到都覺得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147998/14.wav", + "text": "我還看第二昨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147998/15.wav", + "text": "昨天跟前天又抓到很多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147998/16.wav", + "text": "菸的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147998/17.wav", + "text": "因為臺灣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147998/18.wav", + "text": "四周都是海" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147998/19.wav", + "text": "剛才李德維委員也有說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147998/20.wav", + "text": "走私的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147998/21.wav", + "text": "品或什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147998/22.wav", + "text": "的我不是苛求" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147998/23.wav", + "text": "每天都要到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147998/24.wav", + "text": "派出所報到的人朱" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147998/25.wav", + "text": "朱國榮" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147998/26.wav", + "text": "但在這樣的情況下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147998/27.wav", + "text": "一般來說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147998/28.wav", + "text": "在船的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147998/29.wav", + "text": "我們是不是有把守好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147998/30.wav", + "text": "有錢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147998/31.wav", + "text": "就能辦事" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147998/32.wav", + "text": "有人藏在裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147998/33.wav", + "text": "探討未來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147998/34.wav", + "text": "自己做得不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147998/35.wav", + "text": "沒樣自己想" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147998/36.wav", + "text": "本席在此要向你請教" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147998/37.wav", + "text": "委員報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147998/38.wav", + "text": "走私的打擊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147998/39.wav", + "text": "我用一句話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147998/40.wav", + "text": "就是永恆的奮鬥" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147998/41.wav", + "text": "因為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147998/42.wav", + "text": "真的是春風吹又生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147998/43.wav", + "text": "但我上任以後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147998/44.wav", + "text": "是強力掃蕩" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147998/45.wav", + "text": "跟委員報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147998/46.wav", + "text": "有22個點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147998/47.wav", + "text": "都被當作是合法的泊地" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147998/48.wav", + "text": "本來應該是停靠船舶的地方" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147998/49.wav", + "text": "卻都變成出入港" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147998/50.wav", + "text": "根本沒有停在那裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147998/51.wav", + "text": "都是用貨車" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147998/52.wav", + "text": "載著進去倉庫門" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147998/53.wav", + "text": "關起來之後無" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147998/54.wav", + "text": "是什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147998/55.wav", + "text": "你都看不但" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147998/56.wav", + "text": "來說他們要出港了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147998/57.wav", + "text": "要我們去檢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147998/58.wav", + "text": "查我們的弟兄就很可憐" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147998/59.wav", + "text": "荒郊野外" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147998/60.wav", + "text": "我們還是要檢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147998/61.wav", + "text": "查啊結果一檢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147998/62.wav", + "text": "說他們回來���" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147998/63.wav", + "text": "又要我們去檢查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147998/64.wav", + "text": "結果一檢查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147998/65.wav", + "text": "我們的弟兄姊妹" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147998/66.wav", + "text": "就是被他們這樣折磨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147998/67.wav", + "text": "磨我還沒看是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147998/68.wav", + "text": "在這22個泊地空船出入" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147998/69.wav", + "text": "你看我們的弟兄多可憐" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147998/70.wav", + "text": "對啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147998/71.wav", + "text": "苦不過主委" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147998/72.wav", + "text": "我們全部掃蕩" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147998/73.wav", + "text": "全部公告撤銷" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147998/74.wav", + "text": "留2個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147998/75.wav", + "text": "\n在走私當中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147998/76.wav", + "text": "最惡質的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147998/77.wav", + "text": "其實就是密艙啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147998/78.wav", + "text": "他們都藏在密艙" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147998/79.wav", + "text": "在毒品案中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147998/80.wav", + "text": "如果有一人吸毒" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147998/81.wav", + "text": "在這當中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147998/82.wav", + "text": "當中本席要跟主委探討的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147998/83.wav", + "text": "就是裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147998/84.wav", + "text": "也有害群之馬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147998/85.wav", + "text": "還沒查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147998/86.wav", + "text": "很痛心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147998/87.wav", + "text": "我覺得實在很不應該" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147998/88.wav", + "text": "是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147998/89.wav", + "text": "他離開了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147998/90.wav", + "text": "他自己也知道該走" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147998/91.wav", + "text": "主委" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147998/92.wav", + "text": "我知道他已經離開也" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147998/93.wav", + "text": "該走" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147998/94.wav", + "text": "就是國家的人才" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147998/95.wav", + "text": "才和黨沒關係" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147998/96.wav", + "text": "就是要認真做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147998/97.wav", + "text": "但是我看到在你認真做當中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147998/98.wav", + "text": "還是有不足的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147998/99.wav", + "text": "所以我再向你提議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147998/100.wav", + "text": "要非" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147998/101.wav", + "text": "這是最要緊的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147998/102.wav", + "text": "員報告我們都很痛心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147998/103.wav", + "text": "一個案件" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147998/104.wav", + "text": "兩個案件" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147998/105.wav", + "text": "有害群之馬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147998/106.wav", + "text": "就讓整個海巡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147998/107.wav", + "text": "巡署大家的打拼都化為烏有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147998/108.wav", + "text": "所以這點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147998/109.wav", + "text": "譬如說有些地方" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147998/110.wav", + "text": "我就將人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147998/111.wav", + "text": "調有一個地方" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147998/112.wav", + "text": "我就是這麼做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147998/113.wav", + "text": "這樣是最好\n" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147998/114.wav", + "text": "\n主委" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147998/115.wav", + "text": "再來本席要跟你探討的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147998/116.wav", + "text": "就是海洋驛站的預約" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147998/117.wav", + "text": "我們有13個地方" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147998/118.wav", + "text": "有9個沒辦法預約的情況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147998/119.wav", + "text": "我也知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147998/120.wav", + "text": "人員不足" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147998/121.wav", + "text": "是真正方便" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147998/122.wav", + "text": "雖然我們看到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147998/123.wav", + "text": "只有4個提供預約" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147998/124.wav", + "text": "不必預約" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147998/125.wav", + "text": "隨時可以來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147998/126.wav", + "text": "隨時可以來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147998/127.wav", + "text": "好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147998/128.wav", + "text": "拜託我再花一點時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147998/129.wav", + "text": "我要跟主委講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147998/130.wav", + "text": "巡署有補助海洋保育的教育" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147998/131.wav", + "text": "在這當" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147998/132.wav", + "text": "海巡署補助13個地方" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147998/133.wav", + "text": "方14項海洋保育推廣計畫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147998/134.wav", + "text": "能把嘉義市納入" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147998/135.wav", + "text": "根本與我們住的地方有海還是沒海" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147998/136.wav", + "text": "所以我拜託主委" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147998/137.wav", + "text": "納入嘉義市" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147998/138.wav", + "text": "政府要趕緊提案給我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147998/139.wav", + "text": "若沒提案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147998/140.wav", + "text": "就沒辦法得到中央的補助" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147998/141.wav", + "text": "我們是跟地方講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147998/142.wav", + "text": "要緊既然" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147998/143.wav", + "text": "了就拜託" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147998/144.wav", + "text": "如果有需要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147998/145.wav", + "text": "不願意讓孩" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147998/146.wav", + "text": "已經聯絡了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147998/147.wav", + "text": "已經聯絡了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147998/148.wav", + "text": "市政府沒提案就沒辦法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147998/149.wav", + "text": "其是我們會跟他" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147998/150.wav", + "text": "更需要海的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147998/151.wav", + "text": "對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147998/152.wav", + "text": "如果他們有地方" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147998/153.wav", + "text": "方可以作為教育中心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147998/154.wav", + "text": "我們趕緊幫忙" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147998/155.wav", + "text": "海龜" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147998/156.wav", + "text": "襲》《臺灣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147998/157.wav", + "text": "鯨讚》這兩本書" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147998/158.wav", + "text": "把嘉義市納入" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147998/159.wav", + "text": "因為有時若" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147998/160.wav", + "text": "我們既然有這個輔助多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147998/161.wav", + "text": "多給嘉義市" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147998/162.wav", + "text": "他們是很愛學" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147998/163.wav", + "text": "也很愛參與" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147998/164.wav", + "text": "們海保署" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147998/165.wav", + "text": "去辦過3場教育宣導" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147998/166.wav", + "text": "但是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147998/167.wav", + "text": "謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147998/168.wav", + "text": "謝謝王美惠委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147998/169.wav", + "text": "有請莊瑞雄委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147997/0.wav", + "text": "好請黃主委跟張局長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147997/1.wav", + "text": "主委早本席其實一直以來都非常關心公司治理的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147997/2.wav", + "text": "主委上任之後對於公司治理方面的努力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147997/3.wav", + "text": "包括公司治理3.0所謂永續發展的藍圖" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147997/4.wav", + "text": "特別提到就是要強化多元化針對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147997/5.wav", + "text": "董監事的進修來做規劃" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147997/6.wav", + "text": "包括強化多元化之董事進修課程" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147997/7.wav", + "text": "然後也針對這些進修課程" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147997/8.wav", + "text": "連證期局也編列了相關的預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147997/9.wav", + "text": "要來強化董事會的職能" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147997/10.wav", + "text": "我先就教一下主委" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147997/11.wav", + "text": "包括有哪些單位有哪些課程" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147997/12.wav", + "text": "有多少時數是不是有一些規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147997/13.wav", + "text": "這都是有規定的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147997/14.wav", + "text": "當然訓練單位也都是有一些認證" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147997/15.wav", + "text": "局長如果知道也可以一起補充沒有關係" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147997/16.wav", + "text": "\n因為在這個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147997/17.wav", + "text": "針對訓練的單位其實是最重要的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147997/18.wav", + "text": "畢竟能不能提供正確的課程" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147997/19.wav", + "text": "對於公司治理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147997/20.wav", + "text": "尤其是公發公司來說非常重要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147997/21.wav", + "text": "他也許可能是大股東" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147997/22.wav", + "text": "但他不一定在公司治理上面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147997/23.wav", + "text": "包括這個機構要認證設立達兩年以上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147997/24.wav", + "text": "三年內沒有經過主管機關或事業機關的處分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147997/25.wav", + "text": "然後三年內沒有經過主管機關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147997/26.wav", + "text": "這樣一個懲處" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147997/27.wav", + "text": "第四點它要有自己訓練的場地" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147997/28.wav", + "text": "第五點要有專職的人員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147997/29.wav", + "text": "然後我也在你們網上看到了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147997/30.wav", + "text": "這些就是你們認可的機構" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147997/31.wav", + "text": "一共有30個對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147997/32.wav", + "text": "跟委員報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147997/33.wav", + "text": "現在因為董事的進修我們非常的重視" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147997/34.wav", + "text": "所以我們有進修地圖" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147997/35.wav", + "text": "還有哪些單位是經核可的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147997/36.wav", + "text": "在網站上都有公開" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147997/37.wav", + "text": "好言下之意是有公開" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147997/38.wav", + "text": "那如果今天一個董事" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147997/39.wav", + "text": "他去了不是你們認可的單位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147997/40.wav", + "text": "該怎麼辦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147997/41.wav", + "text": "你們的流程是怎麼樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147997/42.wav", + "text": "比如說今天有一個王某某" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147997/43.wav", + "text": "他任了一個公發公司的董事" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147997/44.wav", + "text": "然後他本來依照規定要有一定的上課時數" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147997/45.wav", + "text": "一年12小時嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147997/46.wav", + "text": "目前來講新任的話是12小時" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147997/47.wav", + "text": "然後續任的話3" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147997/48.wav", + "text": "3如果他去的機構" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147997/49.wav", + "text": "不是現在所認可的30個機構該怎麼辦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147997/50.wav", + "text": "他的董事資格" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147997/51.wav", + "text": "跟委員報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147997/52.wav", + "text": "如果它不是經認可" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147997/53.wav", + "text": "因為必須事前讓單位做一個備案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147997/54.wav", + "text": "就是證交所" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147997/55.wav", + "text": "因為進修辦法是由證交所規範" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147997/56.wav", + "text": "所以假設你去一個A單位是不合格的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147997/57.wav", + "text": "是unqualified" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147997/58.wav", + "text": "這時候證交所不會同意你" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147997/59.wav", + "text": "所以董事去上那個課" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147997/60.wav", + "text": "其實就是浪費了他的時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147997/61.wav", + "text": "會喪失他的資格嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147997/62.wav", + "text": "因為你要知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147997/63.wav", + "text": "如果他今天連專業知識" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147997/64.wav", + "text": "等等的資格都沒有的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147997/65.wav", + "text": "他在所謂審計委員會裡面所做的決策" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147997/66.wav", + "text": "或者是他在董事會裡面所做的決策" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147997/67.wav", + "text": "這樣OK嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147997/68.wav", + "text": "不然的話等於上課" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147997/69.wav", + "text": "這樣的規定不就形同虛設" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147997/70.wav", + "text": "如果發現他在不核可的機構上課了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147997/71.wav", + "text": "會怎麼樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147997/72.wav", + "text": "那個時數會被剔除掉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147997/73.wav", + "text": "會被剔除掉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147997/74.wav", + "text": "對公司會有懲處嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147997/75.wav", + "text": "懲處是不會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147997/76.wav", + "text": "就是公司的董事" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147997/77.wav", + "text": "他去上一些我們不認可的時數" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147997/78.wav", + "text": "等於他的時間就白花了而已" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147997/79.wav", + "text": "所以如果今天有一個機構" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147997/80.wav", + "text": "它是掛羊頭賣狗肉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147997/81.wav", + "text": "然後告訴董監事說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147997/82.wav", + "text": "你可以來我這裡進修課程時數會算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147997/83.wav", + "text": "進去那這樣子是不是縱容了這種所謂" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147997/84.wav", + "text": "其實未經核可的單位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147997/85.wav", + "text": "它可以去開課" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147997/86.wav", + "text": "我要詢問的是這個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147997/87.wav", + "text": "因為我現在查到了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147997/88.wav", + "text": "了臺北市獨立董事協會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147997/89.wav", + "text": "事實上我2021年4月8號" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147997/90.wav", + "text": "在這裡就曾經質詢過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147997/91.wav", + "text": "因為它不是我們金管會所認可的單位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147997/92.wav", + "text": "它是註冊在內政部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147997/93.wav", + "text": "但是它現在用另外一種方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147997/94.wav", + "text": "就是掛羊頭賣狗肉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147997/95.wav", + "text": "我當主辦單位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147997/96.wav", + "text": "我跟一個有核可資格的來合辦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147997/97.wav", + "text": "我必須強調" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147997/98.wav", + "text": "董事的課程不是嘉年華" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147997/99.wav", + "text": "不是廟會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147997/100.wav", + "text": "現在我當主辦單位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147997/101.wav", + "text": "然後我找很多合辦單位來辦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147997/102.wav", + "text": "請問主委這樣合法嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147997/103.wav", + "text": "我想這樣是不合適的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147997/104.wav", + "text": "我們會去查證" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147997/105.wav", + "text": "好這個個案基本上它非常的囂張" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147997/106.wav", + "text": "我剛剛說過的我在2021年4月8號質詢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147997/107.wav", + "text": "它馬上發了一個新聞稿" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147997/108.wav", + "text": "說它要鄭重啟事" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147997/109.wav", + "text": "事我只擷取了第四段" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147997/110.wav", + "text": "讓我來念一下第一" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147997/111.wav", + "text": "點它說它的主管機關是內政部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147997/112.wav", + "text": "它有跟內政部申請來設立人民團體" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147997/113.wav", + "text": "好這跟我質詢的一模一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147997/114.wav", + "text": "然後它第四點說它" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147997/115.wav", + "text": "它是被有心人士來抹黑" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147997/116.wav", + "text": "所以它要維護本會及全體會員的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147997/117.wav", + "text": "名譽跟合法權利" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147997/118.wav", + "text": "本會將對一切不實之污衊行為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147997/119.wav", + "text": "保留法律追訴權" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147997/120.wav", + "text": "首先我問金管會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147997/121.wav", + "text": "它到底是不是一個核可的機構" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147997/122.wav", + "text": "它可以繼續開課嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147997/123.wav", + "text": "如果現在在他這邊上課" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147997/124.wav", + "text": "我在2021年4月8號就質詢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147997/125.wav", + "text": "今天是2023年10月26號" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147997/126.wav", + "text": "已經長達2年6個月" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147997/127.wav", + "text": "這2年6個月當中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147997/128.wav", + "text": "如果有上市公司的董事去這裡上課" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147997/129.wav", + "text": "自認倒楣再多花錢嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147997/130.wav", + "text": "我要求清查這半年來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147997/131.wav", + "text": "他們開了多少課" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147997/132.wav", + "text": "有多少上市櫃公司的董事" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147997/133.wav", + "text": "尤其是董事獨董去上課" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147997/134.wav", + "text": "然後你們是怎麼處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147997/135.wav", + "text": "的然後這些課有沒有認列" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147997/136.wav", + "text": "\n我必須強調的是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147997/137.wav", + "text": "一個公司當中的董事" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147997/138.wav", + "text": "獨董非常的重要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147997/139.wav", + "text": "如果針對他們的課程" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147997/140.wav", + "text": "金管會可以睜一眼閉一眼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147997/141.wav", + "text": "那麼對於公司的治理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147997/142.wav", + "text": "我只能說就像我以前講的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147997/143.wav", + "text": "只是在做作文比賽" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147997/144.wav", + "text": "主委你可以給我一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147997/145.wav", + "text": "非常嚴肅的回答嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147997/146.wav", + "text": "謝謝委員對這個問題的指導" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147997/147.wav", + "text": "我們會照您提示的方向去處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147997/148.wav", + "text": "我們會去查證" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147997/149.wav", + "text": "我要求的是第一這兩年半來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147997/150.wav", + "text": "他們是不是持續用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147997/151.wav", + "text": "掛羊頭賣狗肉的方式在開課" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147997/152.wav", + "text": "還是今天就是讓它賺錢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147997/153.wav", + "text": "然後發現它是不核可" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147997/154.wav", + "text": "的我就讓他再補課" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147997/155.wav", + "text": "我認為公司是蓄意的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147997/156.wav", + "text": "讓這些資格不符合的董事或獨董" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147997/157.wav", + "text": "繼續生存在公司當中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147997/158.wav", + "text": "這是有違公司治理的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147997/159.wav", + "text": "我認為必須要把這個規定講清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147997/160.wav", + "text": "\n首先第一個就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147997/161.wav", + "text": "不核可的公司跟核可的公司" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147997/162.wav", + "text": "用主辦跟合辦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147997/163.wav", + "text": "不要再出現這種混淆社會視聽" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147997/164.wav", + "text": "或者是混淆不瞭解的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147997/165.wav", + "text": "董事或獨董的狀況出現" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147997/166.wav", + "text": "我要求要清查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147997/167.wav", + "text": "兩個禮拜以內給我一個報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147997/168.wav", + "text": "應該要怎麼處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147997/169.wav", + "text": "另外還有一個狀況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147997/170.wav", + "text": "也有一些公司它宣稱" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147997/171.wav", + "text": "可以取得證明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147997/172.wav", + "text": "然後文字敘述很模糊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147997/173.wav", + "text": "比如它說可以到府授課" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147997/174.wav", + "text": "治理的規範不一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147997/175.wav", + "text": "我們說要有訓練場地" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147997/176.wav", + "text": "但現在獨董" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147997/177.wav", + "text": "也可以上家教就對了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147997/178.wav", + "text": "可以嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147997/179.wav", + "text": "照委員提示的這些情況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147997/180.wav", + "text": "我們會去瞭解" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147997/181.wav", + "text": "我們希望能夠有一套" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147997/182.wav", + "text": "完整透明的規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147997/183.wav", + "text": "這些事情我希望" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147997/184.wav", + "text": "公司治理底下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147997/185.wav", + "text": "能夠有一個明確的規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147997/186.wav", + "text": "甚至於像這種很囂張的單位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147997/187.wav", + "text": "我不知道它要提告的是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147997/188.wav", + "text": "立法委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147997/189.wav", + "text": "還是主管機關金管會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147997/190.wav", + "text": "還是今天在場協助" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147997/191.wav", + "text": "把這樣的消息擴散出去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147997/192.wav", + "text": "讓更多獨董或是董事" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147997/193.wav", + "text": "長不要受騙上課的媒體" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147997/194.wav", + "text": "我不知道它想告誰" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147997/195.wav", + "text": "但是我要嚴正澄清" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147997/196.wav", + "text": "的是主委可不可以讓我" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147997/197.wav", + "text": "公開的在國是殿堂講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147997/198.wav", + "text": "主管機關是金管會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147997/199.wav", + "text": "所以如果你轄下設在內政部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147997/200.wav", + "text": "那你就不是一個核可的機關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147997/201.wav", + "text": "否則這個會整個天下大亂" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147997/202.wav", + "text": "我想委員您今天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147997/203.wav", + "text": "垂詢的所有事項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147997/204.wav", + "text": "我們都會兩週之內查證清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147997/205.wav", + "text": "跟您做一個報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147997/206.wav", + "text": "就是有關於灰名單的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147997/207.wav", + "text": "因為我們現在已經公布了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147997/208.wav", + "text": "9家對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147997/209.wav", + "text": "但是如果這9家已經曝光了之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147997/210.wav", + "text": "我比較擔心的是這個銜接期" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147997/211.wav", + "text": "相關的詐騙單位就會說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147997/212.wav", + "text": "喔原來是這9家要先做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147997/213.wav", + "text": "那我們是不是逃到其他地方去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147997/214.wav", + "text": "所以請主委在銜接期的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147997/215.wav", + "text": "是不是現在有什麼方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147997/216.wav", + "text": "可以特別注意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147997/217.wav", + "text": "讓所有的銀行都應該" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147997/218.wav", + "text": "儘快在這個機制之內" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147997/219.wav", + "text": "所以9家只是第一批" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147997/220.wav", + "text": "後面應該趕快接續跟上來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147997/221.wav", + "text": "好另外就是虛擬帳號" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147997/222.wav", + "text": "跟手機帳號的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147997/223.wav", + "text": "我也希望能夠加入灰名單" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147997/224.wav", + "text": "因為現在很多人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147997/225.wav", + "text": "是用手機來當帳號" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147997/226.wav", + "text": "因為比較方便比較好記" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147997/227.wav", + "text": "對方要匯款給你的時候恐怕也是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147997/228.wav", + "text": "如此所以也建議虛擬帳號" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147997/229.wav", + "text": "或是手機帳號" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147997/230.wav", + "text": "如果在整個系統上面來得及的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147997/231.wav", + "text": "是不是也可以一起加入" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147997/232.wav", + "text": "如果虛擬帳號比較慢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147997/233.wav", + "text": "手機因為是跟著個人的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147997/234.wav", + "text": "是不是可以考慮先加入" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147997/235.wav", + "text": "我們下午開會的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147997/236.wav", + "text": "再來討論這件事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147997/237.wav", + "text": "好謝謝主委" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147996/0.wav", + "text": "請薛部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147996/1.wav", + "text": "有請部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147996/2.wav", + "text": "委員好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147996/3.wav", + "text": "部長好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147996/4.wav", + "text": "我今天想要跟你討論一個比較嚴肅的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147996/5.wav", + "text": "對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147996/6.wav", + "text": "根據目前保護司的最新資料" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147996/7.wav", + "text": "家暴被害人的受暴人數在2019年就突破10萬人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147996/8.wav", + "text": "而且每年都在增加" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147996/9.wav", + "text": "去年已經到12萬人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147996/10.wav", + "text": "甚至可能要十幾二十年的時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147996/11.wav", + "text": "這幾個月我接到幾個民間組織的陳情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147996/12.wav", + "text": "這些個案現在長大了他脫離了家庭" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147996/13.wav", + "text": "所以還是可以在未經受害人同意的狀況之下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147996/14.wav", + "text": "甚至在瞭解以後還想辦法接觸個案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147996/15.wav", + "text": "部長你覺得我們下週要審查的家暴法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147996/16.wav", + "text": "有沒有辦法解決這個問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147996/17.wav", + "text": "因為未經個案同意可以直接調閱的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147996/18.wav", + "text": "但是普遍的未經同意可以取得你的個資" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147996/19.wav", + "text": "不管他是親人還是怎麼樣這可能也還是需要討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147996/20.wav", + "text": "我想我們在家暴法的修法裡面可以來討論這一" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147996/21.wav", + "text": "部我跟部長報告確實目前我們看到家暴法的版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147996/22.wav", + "text": "尤其是衛福部的版本裡面還是沒有辦法解決這個問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147996/23.wav", + "text": "我現在在談的是制度性的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147996/24.wav", + "text": "因為我們都很清楚知道有時候有些人會說有保護令" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147996/25.wav", + "text": "可是問題是保護令只有2年的效期" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147996/26.wav", + "text": "尤其他們是在小時候被家暴或性侵" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147996/27.wav", + "text": "其實早就超過了那個時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147996/28.wav", + "text": "更不用講其實有很多人他的身心狀況真的很不適合" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147996/29.wav", + "text": "不斷地到法院去不斷地重新陳述" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147996/30.wav", + "text": "這可能造成他更多的心理負擔跟崩潰" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147996/31.wav", + "text": "\n第二個問題剛剛部長講到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147996/32.wav", + "text": "是沒有錯這裡面牽涉到被害者的個資保護" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147996/33.wav", + "text": "而戶籍法的權責單位是在內政部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147996/34.wav", + "text": "沒有錯" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147996/35.wav", + "text": "不過部長我還是想就我們要解決這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147996/36.wav", + "text": "問題有幾個方法或路徑這部分來跟部長討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147996/37.wav", + "text": "閱覽戶籍登記資料處理原則" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147996/38.wav", + "text": "還是可以讓直系血親在不經過本人的同意下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147996/39.wav", + "text": "就申請閱覽得到戶籍的資料" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147996/40.wav", + "text": "在這個月初10月2號的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147996/41.wav", + "text": "在會議當中國發會跟內政部有建議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147996/42.wav", + "text": "如果當事人因為家庭暴力或性侵害事件" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147996/43.wav", + "text": "有特殊的情形需要限制他的直系血親" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147996/44.wav", + "text": "來申請閱覽他的戶籍謄本或交付戶籍謄本的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147996/45.wav", + "text": "建議在家暴法或性侵害犯罪防治法裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147996/46.wav", + "text": "另外做這部分的規範" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147996/47.wav", + "text": "可是當然現在我們的版本裡面沒有看到相關的規" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147996/48.wav", + "text": "範這是修法的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147996/49.wav", + "text": "這是一條路徑" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147996/50.wav", + "text": "\n關於第二個路徑當然修法的等待" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147996/51.wav", + "text": "也許還需要一點時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147996/52.wav", + "text": "雖然我們現在要開始審查了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147996/53.wav", + "text": "可是其實也有一些民間團體建議另外一個路徑" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147996/54.wav", + "text": "他們說也許有機會可以跟內政部開會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147996/55.wav", + "text": "研議一個註記的方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147996/56.wav", + "text": "他們會來協助處理家暴或性侵的案件" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147996/57.wav", + "text": "他們是委外的單位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147996/58.wav", + "text": "經過他們專業的評估" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147996/59.wav", + "text": "因為他們是委外的單位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147996/60.wav", + "text": "經評估後提出保護令以外的正式公文或相關的證明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147996/61.wav", + "text": "讓受害者可以利用這些證明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147996/62.wav", + "text": "來向戶政機關申請在資料上做一個保護的註記" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147996/63.wav", + "text": "如果在上面有做保護註記的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147996/64.wav", + "text": "調閱被害人的相關資料" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147996/65.wav", + "text": "以保護受害者的人身安全" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147996/66.wav", + "text": "這也是另外一條路徑" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147996/67.wav", + "text": "這條路徑不一定需要修法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147996/68.wav", + "text": "知道有兩個路徑可以處理這個問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147996/69.wav", + "text": "大家可以在相關的條文部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147996/70.wav", + "text": "案特別來處理這個問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147996/71.wav", + "text": "另外一個就是透過保護註記的方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147996/72.wav", + "text": "我覺得都是非常具體的方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147996/73.wav", + "text": "部長我們可不可以往這條路徑" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147996/74.wav", + "text": "直接來做思考" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147996/75.wav", + "text": "快速地來處理這個問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147996/76.wav", + "text": "既然我們在這個會期" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147996/77.wav", + "text": "一定要去處理家暴法的修法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147996/78.wav", + "text": "我想兩個都一起來做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147996/79.wav", + "text": "的話有法的依據會更容易做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147996/80.wav", + "text": "是好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147996/81.wav", + "text": "所以就把它當成一種方法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147996/82.wav", + "text": "我們也同時來做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147996/83.wav", + "text": "那這部分我想" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147996/84.wav", + "text": "要請部長可不可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147996/85.wav", + "text": "當然假設下禮拜我們要審的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147996/86.wav", + "text": "也許需要快速地來做研議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147996/87.wav", + "text": "在條文上面怎麼來處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147996/88.wav", + "text": "我們就一併地把這個問題給解決了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147996/89.wav", + "text": "高興今天聽到部長很正面很" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147996/90.wav", + "text": "這部分要先謝謝部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147996/91.wav", + "text": "但是我們下禮拜" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147996/92.wav", + "text": "我們先試擬一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147996/93.wav", + "text": "然後我們在程序上面看看要怎麼樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147996/94.wav", + "text": "做是不是由委員這邊提出" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147996/95.wav", + "text": "好沒有問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147996/96.wav", + "text": "這部分先謝謝部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147996/97.wav", + "text": "\n部長第二個問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147996/98.wav", + "text": "我要再跟你請教" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147996/99.wav", + "text": "因為我之前也蠻多次關心過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147996/100.wav", + "text": "衛福部很積極地在召開" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147996/101.wav", + "text": "三班護病比標準的討論會議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147996/102.wav", + "text": "我的辦公室其實都有全程參與" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147996/103.wav", + "text": "之前在幾次黨團的討論裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147996/104.wav", + "text": "我知道部長其實非常在意一個問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147996/105.wav", + "text": "那個問題就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147996/106.wav", + "text": "護理師離職的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147996/107.wav", + "text": "要怎麼樣能夠去減緩他們離職的狀況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147996/108.wav", + "text": "我知道部長其實花非常" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147996/109.wav", + "text": "多力氣在想這件事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147996/110.wav", + "text": "但在這幾場會議裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147996/111.wav", + "text": "我也跟部長報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147996/112.wav", + "text": "其實很多護理代表提到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147996/113.wav", + "text": "累積到一定經驗的護理師" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147996/114.wav", + "text": "或是剛生過小孩的護理師" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147996/115.wav", + "text": "確實都因為照顧小孩的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147996/116.wav", + "text": "而必須從護理的職場離開" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147996/117.wav", + "text": "根據衛福部提供的資料我們會發現" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147996/118.wav", + "text": "每年護理人力的增加" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147996/119.wav", + "text": "是以22到24歲" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147996/120.wav", + "text": "剛畢業離開學校未婚的人為主" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147996/121.wav", + "text": "但每年流失的護理師年齡的分析" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147996/122.wav", + "text": "大概是在30到35歲" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147996/123.wav", + "text": "或是36到40歲這幾個年齡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147996/124.wav", + "text": "是流失的最大宗" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147996/125.wav", + "text": "他們來跟我說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147996/126.wav", + "text": "尤其是白班" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147996/127.wav", + "text": "業務最繁忙" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147996/128.wav", + "text": "從早上7點開始" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147996/129.wav", + "text": "就要加班補紀錄" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147996/130.wav", + "text": "一直忙忙忙到傍晚56點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147996/131.wav", + "text": "讓他們很難兼顧到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147996/132.wav", + "text": "家庭比方說小孩的接送" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147996/133.wav", + "text": "可能不一定需要全時段的照顧" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147996/134.wav", + "text": "可能部分時段的照顧" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147996/135.wav", + "text": "其實讓他們很難兼顧" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147996/136.wav", + "text": "也因為可能只是部分時段" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147996/137.wav", + "text": "難以兼顧" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147996/138.wav", + "text": "會讓他們萌生想要離職的念頭" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147996/139.wav", + "text": "回過頭去照顧家庭" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147996/140.wav", + "text": "\n我知道部長其實花了力氣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147996/141.wav", + "text": "包括我們在思考" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147996/142.wav", + "text": "怎麼留住他們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147996/143.wav", + "text": "所以想說夜班的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147996/144.wav", + "text": "怎麼樣提供加給來協助" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147996/145.wav", + "text": "我覺得這都很好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147996/146.wav", + "text": "但是我覺得這裡面有一個問題是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147996/147.wav", + "text": "現在有沒有一種可能" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147996/148.wav", + "text": "可以請衛福部來找" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147996/149.wav", + "text": "包括醫院的代表" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147996/150.wav", + "text": "社家署保護司護理人員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147996/151.wav", + "text": "我們有沒有可能試著來研擬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147996/152.wav", + "text": "友善護理人員的一些托育制度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147996/153.wav", + "text": "如果大家真的在這方面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147996/154.wav", + "text": "因為有照顧家庭" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147996/155.wav", + "text": "照顧小孩的需求" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147996/156.wav", + "text": "從數據看起來是蠻多的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147996/157.wav", + "text": "如果我們能擬訂" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147996/158.wav", + "text": "訂一個友善護理人員的托育制度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147996/159.wav", + "text": "可以協助他們或支持他們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147996/160.wav", + "text": "也許在排班上面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147996/161.wav", + "text": "或是有什麼托育的資源" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147996/162.wav", + "text": "可以支持他們的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147996/163.wav", + "text": "也許在這一塊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147996/164.wav", + "text": "就不會有這麼多人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147996/165.wav", + "text": "因為這個原因而必須離職" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147996/166.wav", + "text": "\n我剛才講的這些部會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147996/167.wav", + "text": "包括照護司社家署醫院代表" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147996/168.wav", + "text": "其實都是在衛福部的管轄之下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147996/169.wav", + "text": "如果我們可以邀集" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147996/170.wav", + "text": "這些單位共同" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147996/171.wav", + "text": "研擬出一個友善托育制度的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147996/172.wav", + "text": "我認為也可以很大程度來緩解" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147996/173.wav", + "text": "部長一直很焦慮" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147996/174.wav", + "text": "或者是很憂慮" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147996/175.wav", + "text": "護理人員離職的這個問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147996/176.wav", + "text": "我們有沒有可能往這個角度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147996/177.wav", + "text": "跟委員報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147996/178.wav", + "text": "您的提議其實是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147996/179.wav", + "text": "我們一個努力的方向" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147996/180.wav", + "text": "但是它的困難是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147996/181.wav", + "text": "醫院裡面的空間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147996/182.wav", + "text": "是非常重要的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147996/183.wav", + "text": "所以在醫院裡面去設的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147996/184.wav", + "text": "很多醫院大概都不是很願意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147996/185.wav", + "text": "效果比較好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147996/186.wav", + "text": "收入會比較好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147996/187.wav", + "text": "解決的一個困難" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147996/188.wav", + "text": "我不是說不行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147996/189.wav", + "text": "因為長遠來講醫院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147996/190.wav", + "text": "其實是讓醫院的人力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147996/191.wav", + "text": "可以更穩定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147996/192.wav", + "text": "這個部分大概是這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147996/193.wav", + "text": "不過有一點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147996/194.wav", + "text": "已經超過2分鐘了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147996/195.wav", + "text": "我很高興的一件事情就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147996/196.wav", + "text": "現在大家會注意到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147996/197.wav", + "text": "家庭的因素" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147996/198.wav", + "text": "會是占護理人員離職的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147996/199.wav", + "text": "最大部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147996/200.wav", + "text": "以前我跟護理界在談的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147996/201.wav", + "text": "他們講的唯一因素就是薪資" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147996/202.wav", + "text": "是所以部長我現在提議說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147996/203.wav", + "text": "沒有一個托育的空間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147996/204.wav", + "text": "甚至大家在講說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147996/205.wav", + "text": "讓護理人員可以有照顧但" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147996/206.wav", + "text": "不離職這個方向的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147996/207.wav", + "text": "在他們的工時或排班上面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147996/208.wav", + "text": "有多一點的彈性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147996/209.wav", + "text": "這個彈性的空間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147996/210.wav", + "text": "可能可以讓他們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147996/211.wav", + "text": "有一點點的時間去兼顧到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147996/212.wav", + "text": "他們可能要照顧小孩" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147996/213.wav", + "text": "或什麼的需求" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147996/214.wav", + "text": "也許在一點點的彈性下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147996/215.wav", + "text": "或者部分的彈性之下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147996/216.wav", + "text": "就可以讓他們獲得多一點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147996/217.wav", + "text": "我覺得這也是可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147996/218.wav", + "text": "研擬的方向" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147996/219.wav", + "text": "所以這一整套的東西" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147996/220.wav", + "text": "當然有空間的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147996/221.wav", + "text": "我們從空間去處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147996/222.wav", + "text": "沒有空間的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147996/223.wav", + "text": "是不是可能從排班的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147996/224.wav", + "text": "彈性去處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147996/225.wav", + "text": "可以往這方面來研議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147996/226.wav", + "text": "我覺得它也可以幫部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147996/227.wav", + "text": "消除很多你現在擔心的事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147996/228.wav", + "text": "對是謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147996/229.wav", + "text": "還是要有一點時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147996/230.wav", + "text": "我知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147996/231.wav", + "text": "三個月的時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147996/232.wav", + "text": "有一個初步的討論方案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147996/233.wav", + "text": "可以跟立法院這邊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147996/234.wav", + "text": "來報告一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147996/235.wav", + "text": "你們初步的想法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147996/236.wav", + "text": "三個月的時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147996/237.wav", + "text": "不是說要多完整" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147996/238.wav", + "text": "但至少有一個方向" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147996/239.wav", + "text": "我們可以往前走好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147996/240.wav", + "text": "這部分好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147994/0.wav", + "text": "涉及到明年二合一選舉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147994/1.wav", + "text": "境外勢力的干預" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147994/2.wav", + "text": "10月16日也就是上禮拜" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147994/3.wav", + "text": "及相關部會如中選會最高檢察署" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147994/4.wav", + "text": "請教部長在這個會議上你們最後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147994/5.wav", + "text": "有沒有做出相應的結論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147994/6.wav", + "text": "賄選這件事情要強力打擊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147994/7.wav", + "text": "士林地檢署以及整個承辦的單位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147994/8.wav", + "text": "大概不是只有對於賄選" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147994/9.wav", + "text": "所以在整體上是什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147994/10.wav", + "text": "因為法律也修正了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147994/11.wav", + "text": "在總統" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147994/12.wav", + "text": "副總統選舉罷免法跟公職人員選舉罷免法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147994/13.wav", + "text": "已經增訂" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147994/14.wav", + "text": "用深偽影音" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147994/15.wav", + "text": "來影響選舉的話已經定有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147994/16.wav", + "text": "我們這一次查察賄選的重點之一" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147994/17.wav", + "text": "我們在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147994/18.wav", + "text": "臺北和士林地檢署分區的座談會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147994/19.wav", + "text": "也由當地的檢察長召集" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147994/20.wav", + "text": "當地的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147994/21.wav", + "text": "檢警調廉與移民" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147994/22.wav", + "text": "等各個執法單位共同座談" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147994/23.wav", + "text": "對於深偽影音的部分也有特別強調" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147994/24.wav", + "text": "柯文哲主席批評賴副總統訪美" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147994/25.wav", + "text": "強力否認這根本不是他的聲音" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147994/26.wav", + "text": "當時第二天我們的發言人就到調查站做了舉報" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147994/27.wav", + "text": "現在已經10月20幾號了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147994/28.wav", + "text": "或者是我們過去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147994/29.wav", + "text": "驗證分析的能力應該是非常精進的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147994/30.wav", + "text": "調查的結果是什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147994/31.wav", + "text": "已經兩個月了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147994/32.wav", + "text": "有關技術的部分可能是委由" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147994/33.wav", + "text": "我們調查局" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147994/34.wav", + "text": "鑑識單位來做鑑識" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147994/35.wav", + "text": "今天局長在這邊我想他也許對這個個案比較瞭解" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147994/36.wav", + "text": "是不是可以由他來說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147994/37.wav", + "text": "好請局長回應" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147994/38.wav", + "text": "謝謝委員的關心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147994/39.wav", + "text": "垂詢這個案子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147994/40.wav", + "text": "不公開的情況之下來跟委員做報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147994/41.wav", + "text": "首先針對這個案件我們臺北市調查處" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147994/42.wav", + "text": "是在今年8月18日" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147994/43.wav", + "text": "分成兩個部分進行調查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147994/44.wav", + "text": "日就立刻向臺北地檢署的檢察官報請指揮" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147994/45.wav", + "text": "由檢察官自己親自來指揮偵辦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147994/46.wav", + "text": "我們進行溯源的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147994/47.wav", + "text": "是不是有被深偽" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147994/48.wav", + "text": "我們也在8月22日" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147994/49.wav", + "text": "對外發布新聞稿" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147994/50.wav", + "text": "我們會對外發布新聞稿的主要原因" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147994/51.wav", + "text": "是今年包含在最高檢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147994/52.wav", + "text": "主持的會議裡面就已經有要求" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147994/53.wav", + "text": "但是為避免這種深偽操控會影響到選舉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147994/54.wav", + "text": "也立刻以新聞稿的方式對外說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147994/55.wav", + "text": "至於現在案件進行的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147994/56.wav", + "text": "因為這個IP來自於境外" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147994/57.wav", + "text": "目前我們也都行文調取了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147994/58.wav", + "text": "回復以後我們會繼續進行偵辦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147994/59.wav", + "text": "方式或是速度也是一件事" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147994/60.wav", + "text": "我也看到你們在8月25日有對外澄清" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147994/61.wav", + "text": "確認可能偽造的機會是很高" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147994/62.wav", + "text": "的但是你們也沒辦法確認就是偽造" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147994/63.wav", + "text": "但是你可以想想看在這個選舉的過程當中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147994/64.wav", + "text": "就丟給特定的一些媒體" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147994/65.wav", + "text": "開始散布" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147994/66.wav", + "text": "鑑識單位花盡所有的心力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147994/67.wav", + "text": "去釐清跟偵辦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147994/68.wav", + "text": "相信這耗費的人力跟專業度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147994/69.wav", + "text": "是非常重的成本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147994/70.wav", + "text": "剛剛部長也講了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147994/71.wav", + "text": "我們在刑法的相關刑度裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147994/72.wav", + "text": "在選罷法裡面也提高了也加進去了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147994/73.wav", + "text": "但是這到底有沒有嚇阻" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147994/74.wav", + "text": "有沒有辦法降低這些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147994/75.wav", + "text": "透過變造方式來介選" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147994/76.wav", + "text": "到現在有沒有各種統計數據" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147994/77.wav", + "text": "是減還是增" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147994/78.wav", + "text": "每一次選舉都會發生這樣的案例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147994/79.wav", + "text": "來偵辦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147994/80.wav", + "text": "但是因為誠如剛剛局長所講的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147994/81.wav", + "text": "它會涉及到境外的帳號" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147994/82.wav", + "text": "有時候會受到一些阻礙" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147994/83.wav", + "text": "後續的偵查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147994/84.wav", + "text": "也許就有一些需要克服的地方" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147994/85.wav", + "text": "不過我們還是會盡全力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147994/86.wav", + "text": "啦像這一次二合一的選舉裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147994/87.wav", + "text": "像剛剛其他兩大黨在質疑的這件事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147994/88.wav", + "text": "然後鑑定後又不能如實如期公告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147994/89.wav", + "text": "周知因為又在偵辦中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147994/90.wav", + "text": "其實那混雜跟各種說故事的成分就變高了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147994/91.wav", + "text": "所以我在想" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147994/92.wav", + "text": "你們在做一個新聞發布或者是確切" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147994/93.wav", + "text": "明確要打擊這個深偽或者是這種" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147994/94.wav", + "text": "介選的部分有沒有別的方式是更有效性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147994/95.wav", + "text": "請你們真的要去研議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147994/96.wav", + "text": "不然這等於是一個故事再疊一個故事" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147994/97.wav", + "text": "其實是沒完沒了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147994/98.wav", + "text": "的所以我相信這是一個技術上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147994/99.wav", + "text": "要趕快想盡辦法去做一個定性的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147994/100.wav", + "text": "\n第二個我想確認一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147994/101.wav", + "text": "另外一個總統參選人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147994/102.wav", + "text": "正在連署中的叫做郭台銘先生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147994/103.wav", + "text": "他也被爆說在中國被查稅這件事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147994/104.wav", + "text": "國內傳回來時當然就沸沸揚揚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147994/105.wav", + "text": "也認定這也是一種介選的方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147994/106.wav", + "text": "而且是中國特定性的不希望他參選等等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147994/107.wav", + "text": "也是有更多的訊息揭露" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147994/108.wav", + "text": "但是這件事情的方式跟我們法務部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147994/109.wav", + "text": "調查局國安局有任何的關聯性嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147994/110.wav", + "text": "你們有沒有任何的角度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147994/111.wav", + "text": "可以對這件事情做介入跟協助的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147994/112.wav", + "text": "不然對郭先生來講他就是一副被挨打的份" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147994/113.wav", + "text": "所有可能會影響到選舉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147994/114.wav", + "text": "的如果有不法的情事" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147994/115.wav", + "text": "我們相信所有參與查察賄選的單位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147994/116.wav", + "text": "他們會投入所有的人力物力來偵辦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147994/117.wav", + "text": "至於這一��查稅的事情有沒有涉及到刑責" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147994/118.wav", + "text": "我看也由他們來蒐集相關的資料" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147994/119.wav", + "text": "所以有在蒐集嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147994/120.wav", + "text": "如果是像他這件事" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147994/121.wav", + "text": "所有的輿情都有在注意有在瞭解" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147994/122.wav", + "text": "好那假設這是一個因為他是在境外" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147994/123.wav", + "text": "嘛在中國對岸被查稅這件事" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147994/124.wav", + "text": "情回到他國內這邊的連署站裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147994/125.wav", + "text": "看起來也查得相當積極" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147994/126.wav", + "text": "就是已經有被收押的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147994/127.wav", + "text": "甚至有一些集團式的方式在處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147994/128.wav", + "text": "這部分過去也有獨立參選人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147994/129.wav", + "text": "用連署的方式來進行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147994/130.wav", + "text": "所以就這部分在法制上有沒有不足的地方" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147994/131.wav", + "text": "目前是有規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147994/132.wav", + "text": "在連署時如果也有行賄事實的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147994/133.wav", + "text": "也是構成刑責" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147994/134.wav", + "text": "法律上並沒有問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147994/135.wav", + "text": "如果是個別的人說簽一份連署單" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147994/136.wav", + "text": "給你一份多少錢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147994/137.wav", + "text": "這件事情現在是用選罷法來處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147994/138.wav", + "text": "還是用其他的法制來處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147994/139.wav", + "text": "選罷法應該有規定吧" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147994/140.wav", + "text": "有沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147994/141.wav", + "text": "中選會可以說明一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147994/142.wav", + "text": "請中選會說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147994/143.wav", + "text": "這個部分是違反選罷法的規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147994/144.wav", + "text": "是違反總統選罷法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147994/145.wav", + "text": "它是有刑責的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147994/146.wav", + "text": "他也是涉及到對價嗎還是什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147994/147.wav", + "text": "個案審認的部分是屬於" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147994/148.wav", + "text": "這個部分要先跟委員來報告說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147994/149.wav", + "text": "整個選舉過程裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147994/150.wav", + "text": "不管是對岸的部分或者是國內自己的連署" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147994/151.wav", + "text": "都發生一些事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147994/152.wav", + "text": "所以我相信這樣的一個查察" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147994/153.wav", + "text": "當然如果有明確的證據該辦就辦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147994/154.wav", + "text": "這個當然是沒有因個別人而有不同的待遇" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147994/155.wav", + "text": "\n最後我們看一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147994/156.wav", + "text": "國安局" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147994/157.wav", + "text": "的部分今年10月4號的報紙上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147994/158.wav", + "text": "中國反間諜法7月1號實施之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147994/159.wav", + "text": "被盤問的數據增加了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147994/160.wav", + "text": "上半年有4起" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147994/161.wav", + "text": "下半年增為9件" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147994/162.wav", + "text": "我當時就有點好奇我應該是算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147994/163.wav", + "text": "上半年還下半年不確定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147994/164.wav", + "text": "總之我的時間點確實我也是被" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147994/165.wav", + "text": "我當時就想說這13件裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147994/166.wav", + "text": "是不是有我的個案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147994/167.wav", + "text": "我們國安局是如何得知" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147994/168.wav", + "text": "這4件跟這7件" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147994/169.wav", + "text": "的是當事人回報給你們還是對岸有訊息" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147994/170.wav", + "text": "會pass到我們這邊的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147994/171.wav", + "text": "有很多他回來並沒有講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147994/172.wav", + "text": "或許沒有人瞭解" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147994/173.wav", + "text": "或許不在這個數字以內" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147994/174.wav", + "text": "是這個數字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147994/175.wav", + "text": "陸委會海基會的這個數字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147994/176.wav", + "text": "才會到我們那裡來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147994/177.wav", + "text": "所以是當事人會跟陸委會回報" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147994/178.wav", + "text": "還是陸委會主動會去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147994/179.wav", + "text": "瞭解之後才pass到國安局這邊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147994/180.wav", + "text": "應該是回報的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147994/181.wav", + "text": "回報的對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147994/182.wav", + "text": "你們認定是跟反間諜法實施" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147994/183.wav", + "text": "有關聯性所以人數增加" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147994/184.wav", + "text": "是這樣嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147994/185.wav", + "text": "不無可能因為這個法律過了以後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147994/186.wav", + "text": "這個數字才開始提高的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147994/187.wav", + "text": "好我想我們對於這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147994/188.wav", + "text": "部分不管是今天來報告的國安局" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147994/189.wav", + "text": "法務部調查局中選會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147994/190.wav", + "text": "對境外介選特別是中國" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147994/191.wav", + "text": "介選但是我相信這個新聞" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147994/192.wav", + "text": "局長自己主動揭露的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147994/193.wav", + "text": "數據大概就是要提醒國人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147994/194.wav", + "text": "現在到對岸去當然相當性的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147994/195.wav", + "text": "涉及到在言論上面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147994/196.wav", + "text": "如果對對岸不利也許" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147994/197.wav", + "text": "有在入境時遭盤查的風險" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147994/198.wav", + "text": "但是我想我們也不能夠自己" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147994/199.wav", + "text": "就把很多的問題無限" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147994/200.wav", + "text": "上綱所以我在這裡做個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147994/201.wav", + "text": "澄清我當時去的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147994/202.wav", + "text": "第一個我的臺胞證並沒有失效" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147994/203.wav", + "text": "這個部分要說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147994/204.wav", + "text": "第二個我被盤查的過程" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147994/205.wav", + "text": "確實也是非常的不合理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147994/206.wav", + "text": "我也親自跟移民署" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147994/207.wav", + "text": "說明過了所以我想如果國人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147994/208.wav", + "text": "有受到這樣的待遇確實國家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147994/209.wav", + "text": "在一定程度的保護上要有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147994/210.wav", + "text": "兩岸關係裡面怎麼樣做處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147994/211.wav", + "text": "不然很多無辜的人可能就" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147994/212.wav", + "text": "被陷於這樣無意義" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147994/213.wav", + "text": "的理由就被做了盤查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147994/214.wav", + "text": "這在人性跟人道上是非常" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147994/215.wav", + "text": "不對的所以在此我也" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147994/216.wav", + "text": "藉這個新聞事件跟大家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147994/217.wav", + "text": "做一點說明希望我們大家一起來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147994/218.wav", + "text": "防制不希望用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147994/219.wav", + "text": "惡意的螺旋造成無辜的人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147994/220.wav", + "text": "受到這樣的盤查跟傷害" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147994/221.wav", + "text": "請大家努力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147992/0.wav", + "text": "主委好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147992/1.wav", + "text": "今天關心預算的同時" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147992/2.wav", + "text": "關心一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147992/3.wav", + "text": "您不會去參選吧" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147992/4.wav", + "text": "會不會被徵召" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147992/5.wav", + "text": "我有還是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147992/6.wav", + "text": "會不會預算你編了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147992/7.wav", + "text": "但是最後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147992/8.wav", + "text": "我跟委員報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147992/9.wav", + "text": "我來海委會以後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147992/10.wav", + "text": "就謹守政務官的身分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147992/11.wav", + "text": "所以我都沒有做什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147992/12.wav", + "text": "很多的政治評論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147992/13.wav", + "text": "很多政治事件" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147992/14.wav", + "text": "這件事情是因為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147992/15.wav", + "text": "過去有我的選區在裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147992/16.wav", + "text": "所以委員關心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147992/17.wav", + "text": "我稍作回答" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147992/18.wav", + "text": "我已經非常大力推薦了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147992/19.wav", + "text": "這個選區3位優秀的議員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147992/20.wav", + "text": "我都覺得他們非常適合" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147992/21.wav", + "text": "我都已經做了這樣的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147992/22.wav", + "text": "今天您在外面受訪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147992/23.wav", + "text": "是要是本席的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147992/24.wav", + "text": "我不會說那麼多啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147992/25.wav", + "text": "就是你當然可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147992/26.wav", + "text": "推薦3位很好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147992/27.wav", + "text": "但是說��們一定會勝選" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147992/28.wav", + "text": "我真的覺得那個字句" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147992/29.wav", + "text": "這給主委做參考" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147992/30.wav", + "text": "我就會講這句話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147992/31.wav", + "text": "一定會勝選" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147992/32.wav", + "text": "不過假如不是您的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147992/33.wav", + "text": "不過委員這個糾正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147992/34.wav", + "text": "我虛心受教" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147992/35.wav", + "text": "謝謝指教" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147992/36.wav", + "text": "請教一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147992/37.wav", + "text": "因為大家真的很支持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147992/38.wav", + "text": "海委會很支持管主委" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147992/39.wav", + "text": "主委昨天有一艘大陸" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147992/40.wav", + "text": "無船名的運補船" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147992/41.wav", + "text": "似乎是機械故障" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147992/42.wav", + "text": "拋錨在七美港外面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147992/43.wav", + "text": "海巡已經依法查扣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147992/44.wav", + "text": "人船押返馬公留置調查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147992/45.wav", + "text": "請問現在調查的狀況怎麼樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147992/46.wav", + "text": "調查沒有那麼快" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147992/47.wav", + "text": "細節好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147992/48.wav", + "text": "謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147992/49.wav", + "text": "委員早" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147992/50.wav", + "text": "謝謝委員關心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147992/51.wav", + "text": "昨天早上凌晨6點5分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147992/52.wav", + "text": "我們逮捕的這艘" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147992/53.wav", + "text": "中國大陸無船名的漁船" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147992/54.wav", + "text": "也就是24號" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147992/55.wav", + "text": "接近25號凌晨的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147992/56.wav", + "text": "我們就已經掌握它" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147992/57.wav", + "text": "我們用雷達跟" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147992/58.wav", + "text": "岸際巡邏的方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147992/59.wav", + "text": "一直在掌握這條船" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147992/60.wav", + "text": "從11浬一直往內" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147992/61.wav", + "text": "因為它是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147992/62.wav", + "text": "手會判斷它是我們一般" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147992/63.wav", + "text": "返七美漁港的漁船" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147992/64.wav", + "text": "巡邏的人去看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147992/65.wav", + "text": "到底是不是漁船" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147992/66.wav", + "text": "這樣兩道手續之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147992/67.wav", + "text": "我們曾經派線上的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147992/68.wav", + "text": "兩艘35噸艇" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147992/69.wav", + "text": "立刻過去處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147992/70.wav", + "text": "當時澎防部正在做火砲射擊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147992/71.wav", + "text": "所以我們有兩艘艇" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147992/72.wav", + "text": "在那邊做安全戒護" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147992/73.wav", + "text": "就是剛剛上一題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147992/74.wav", + "text": "委員特別關心的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147992/75.wav", + "text": "都在做安全戒護" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147992/76.wav", + "text": "我們持續用雷達" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147992/77.wav", + "text": "監控這艘船" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147992/78.wav", + "text": "到早上6點鐘左右" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147992/79.wav", + "text": "已經判定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147992/80.wav", + "text": "它是無船名的中國漁船" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147992/81.wav", + "text": "在七美港港內的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147992/82.wav", + "text": "然後帶回偵查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147992/83.wav", + "text": "剛剛委員想瞭解" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147992/84.wav", + "text": "目前偵查的結果狀況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147992/85.wav", + "text": "因為我沒有在現場" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147992/86.wav", + "text": "但我從它傳回來的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147992/87.wav", + "text": "整個照片跟船艙的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147992/88.wav", + "text": "不像是一般的漁船船員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147992/89.wav", + "text": "他穿著花襯衫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147992/90.wav", + "text": "大陸船員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147992/91.wav", + "text": "所以我可以主觀判定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147992/92.wav", + "text": "他不是一個正常的漁民" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147992/93.wav", + "text": "海上的交易" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147992/94.wav", + "text": "因為他也沒有漁具" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147992/95.wav", + "text": "他的魚艙也沒有漁獲" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147992/96.wav", + "text": "請委員再給我們一點時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147992/97.wav", + "text": "你們就好好地把他查清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147992/98.wav", + "text": "本席覺得這個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147992/99.wav", + "text": "當然是最重要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147992/100.wav", + "text": "碼頭跟行人景觀步道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147992/101.wav", + "text": "這個部分現在的狀況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147992/102.wav", + "text": "如何是人為疏失" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147992/103.wav", + "text": "還是機械故障" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147992/104.wav", + "text": "報告委員是機械故障" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147992/105.wav", + "text": "非常肯定地跟您報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147992/106.wav", + "text": "因為它是左車" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147992/107.wav", + "text": "減速器的顯示器" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147992/108.wav", + "text": "沒有正常顯示" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147992/109.wav", + "text": "比如說它現在顯示" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147992/110.wav", + "text": "已經停車了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147992/111.wav", + "text": "但實際上它的車還沒有停" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147992/112.wav", + "text": "瞭解" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147992/113.wav", + "text": "這個我們已經找到原因了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147992/114.wav", + "text": "我們的南投艦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147992/115.wav", + "text": "完全沒有航安的顧慮" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147992/116.wav", + "text": "因為它的前端是尖出去的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147992/117.wav", + "text": "所以碰到木棧道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147992/118.wav", + "text": "這個木棧道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147992/119.wav", + "text": "我們已經跟港務局講好了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147992/120.wav", + "text": "在下個禮拜五以前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147992/121.wav", + "text": "它就會修復" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147992/122.wav", + "text": "修復的經費23萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147992/123.wav", + "text": "我相信沒有人希望發生這種事" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147992/124.wav", + "text": "但我們還是關心一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147992/125.wav", + "text": "艦隊分署" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147992/126.wav", + "text": "現在會請我們同仁" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147992/127.wav", + "text": "未來加一個動作" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147992/128.wav", + "text": "即繫纜試車" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147992/129.wav", + "text": "試一下這個機械" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147992/130.wav", + "text": "試一下那個機械" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147992/131.wav", + "text": "試車一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147992/132.wav", + "text": "避免再有這種現象發生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147992/133.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147992/134.wav", + "text": "瞭解\n主委請教一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147992/135.wav", + "text": "排放核廢水的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147992/136.wav", + "text": "相關的源頭排放" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147992/137.wav", + "text": "或擴散的資訊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147992/138.wav", + "text": "有我們海委會跟國海院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147992/139.wav", + "text": "都有參與整個監測計畫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147992/140.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147992/141.wav", + "text": "當然大家都非常關心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147992/142.wav", + "text": "因為有關我們臺灣海域的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147992/143.wav", + "text": "生態及環境" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147992/144.wav", + "text": "也很關心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147992/145.wav", + "text": "所以這個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147992/146.wav", + "text": "我們負責取樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147992/147.wav", + "text": "來讓大家安心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147992/148.wav", + "text": "\n另外一個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147992/149.wav", + "text": "風電的基樁" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147992/150.wav", + "text": "您如果坐飛機從旁邊看這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147992/151.wav", + "text": "如何海委會有做研究" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147992/152.wav", + "text": "或相關調查紀錄嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147992/153.wav", + "text": "航安的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147992/154.wav", + "text": "目前還沒有發現" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147992/155.wav", + "text": "有影響" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147992/156.wav", + "text": "偶有一些權益上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147992/157.wav", + "text": "需要協調的地方" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147992/158.wav", + "text": "因為海域就是多元利用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147992/159.wav", + "text": "有時不同的海洋利用者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147992/160.wav", + "text": "彼此間會有權益的衝突" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147992/161.wav", + "text": "所以這個部分偶爾會有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147992/162.wav", + "text": "或整個漁業之間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147992/163.wav", + "text": "這個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147992/164.wav", + "text": "難免會有一些陳抗發生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147992/165.wav", + "text": "我們海巡的工作就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147992/166.wav", + "text": "在這個時候戒護" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147992/167.wav", + "text": "希望能夠很順利" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147992/168.wav", + "text": "和平地解決" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147992/169.wav", + "text": "也很希望他們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147992/170.wav", + "text": "彼此間的溝通" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147992/171.wav", + "text": "也能夠很快地取得共識" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147992/172.wav", + "text": "\n另外在保育的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147992/173.wav", + "text": "目前看起來是這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147992/174.wav", + "text": "將來我們如果把影片拿出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147992/175.wav", + "text": "委員們可以看到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147992/176.wav", + "text": "白海豚跟風機" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147992/177.wav", + "text": "是共同入鏡的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147992/178.wav", + "text": "白海豚的重要棲息地" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147992/179.wav", + "text": "有重疊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147992/180.wav", + "text": "但我們發現" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147992/181.wav", + "text": "白海豚生寶寶" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147992/182.wav", + "text": "游都看得到風機" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147992/183.wav", + "text": "在保育的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147992/184.wav", + "text": "我們會特別重視" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147992/185.wav", + "text": "並且會加強監測" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147992/186.wav", + "text": "我們有監督" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147992/187.wav", + "text": "現在我們也在製作" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147992/188.wav", + "text": "水下噪音防治的指引" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147992/189.wav", + "text": "所以基本上到目前為止" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147992/190.wav", + "text": "整體來講運作算是順暢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147992/191.wav", + "text": "主席再1分鐘" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147992/192.wav", + "text": "了美惠委員已經在等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147992/193.wav", + "text": "了\n兩件事情提醒您" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147992/194.wav", + "text": "有高度的涉外性質" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147992/195.wav", + "text": "所以有關這個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147992/196.wav", + "text": "目前參與哪些國際性的組織會議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147992/197.wav", + "text": "到時候再拜託" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147992/198.wav", + "text": "對拜託給我們相關書面資料" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147992/199.wav", + "text": "另外一個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147992/200.wav", + "text": "國寶集團的朱國榮" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147992/201.wav", + "text": "現在瞭解" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147992/202.wav", + "text": "好像是搭遊艇還是什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147992/203.wav", + "text": "海巡在這個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147992/204.wav", + "text": "有沒有做檢討" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147992/205.wav", + "text": "好的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147992/206.wav", + "text": "當然我們不希望這種事情發生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147992/207.wav", + "text": "好的好謝謝主委" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147992/208.wav", + "text": "這兩件議題我們再跟您做報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147992/209.wav", + "text": "謝謝李德維委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147992/210.wav", + "text": "\n接下來有請王美惠委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147991/0.wav", + "text": "請龔主委" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147991/1.wav", + "text": "龔主委" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147991/2.wav", + "text": "陳委員好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147991/3.wav", + "text": "不利農業經營的判定標準" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147991/4.wav", + "text": "而非自行公告不利耕作區" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147991/5.wav", + "text": "這個部分明顯違反了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147991/6.wav", + "text": "國土計畫的宜維護農地的政策" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147991/7.wav", + "text": "就像圖面上所看到的彰化大城" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147991/8.wav", + "text": "整個區域有三百零多公頃" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147991/9.wav", + "text": "可是當地的農民反對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147991/10.wav", + "text": "因為他們並沒有不利農業耕種" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147991/11.wav", + "text": "國土計畫各個計畫雖然還沒正式施行對於" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147991/12.wav", + "text": "你們如果要劃為不利農業經營耕種" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147991/13.wav", + "text": "要有一個判定的標準" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147991/14.wav", + "text": "請問什麼時候可以儘速把這個標準訂出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147991/15.wav", + "text": "報告委員這個應該是地方政府劃的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147991/16.wav", + "text": "我們現在在第三階段" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147991/17.wav", + "text": "就是還在地方政府劃設" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147991/18.wav", + "text": "請問是地方政府劃的嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147991/19.wav", + "text": "對這個應該是地方政府劃的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147991/20.wav", + "text": "應該不是吧" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147991/21.wav", + "text": "這個是地方政府劃的嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147991/22.wav", + "text": "未來的不利農業耕種" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147991/23.wav", + "text": "要怎麼來判斷" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147991/24.wav", + "text": "是由我們三個部會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147991/25.wav", + "text": "共同去會勘之" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147991/26.wav", + "text": "後把這邊作為一個可發展綠能的潛在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147991/27.wav", + "text": "對你們有會勘" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147991/28.wav", + "text": "這部分在農業部這一邊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147991/29.wav", + "text": "他們針對所謂的低地力地區" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147991/30.wav", + "text": "目前還沒嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147991/31.wav", + "text": "目前還沒對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147991/32.wav", + "text": "不利農業區有幾個判定的標準" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147991/33.wav", + "text": "第一個是長期會淹水的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147991/34.wav", + "text": "第二個是土壤鹽分比較高的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147991/35.wav", + "text": "第三個是根據我們跟農民的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147991/36.wav", + "text": "我希望你們以後要去劃" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147991/37.wav", + "text": "能夠有更明確的依據" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147991/38.wav", + "text": "好不好主委現在我的意思是這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147991/39.wav", + "text": "畢竟你也是兼政委" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147991/40.wav", + "text": "負責督導相關的業務" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147991/41.wav", + "text": "可以嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147991/42.wav", + "text": "可以他們還是有依據" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147991/43.wav", + "text": "依據只是原則" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147991/44.wav", + "text": "原則只是空的好嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147991/45.wav", + "text": "不要告訴我原則就夠了好嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147991/46.wav", + "text": "SRF還沒有跟你們好好談" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147991/47.wav", + "text": "傾倒有關營建土石方處理費" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147991/48.wav", + "text": "土石方的開挖處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147991/49.wav", + "text": "從2019年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147991/50.wav", + "text": "2021年1,150元" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147991/51.wav", + "text": "當下可能已經到達1,500元" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147991/52.wav", + "text": "這樣的高價" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147991/53.wav", + "text": "其實要一筆龐大的費用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147991/54.wav", + "text": "所以現在就發現" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147991/55.wav", + "text": "這些廢土" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147991/56.wav", + "text": "讓年輕人買不起房" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147991/57.wav", + "text": "是非常嚴重的國安問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147991/58.wav", + "text": "我要請政委" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147991/59.wav", + "text": "如果能夠讓這些土砂礫石國有化" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147991/60.wav", + "text": "就是營建的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147991/61.wav", + "text": "超過100立方米的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147991/62.wav", + "text": "如果100立方米以下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147991/63.wav", + "text": "他可以自行處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147991/64.wav", + "text": "如果100立方米以上的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147991/65.wav", + "text": "這些土砂礫石國有化" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147991/66.wav", + "text": "就可以讓他不需要花每立方米" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147991/67.wav", + "text": "每噸1,500塊那麼高價" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147991/68.wav", + "text": "他就不會去亂倒" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147991/69.wav", + "text": "如果有廢棄物的部分再把它分開" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147991/70.wav", + "text": "地方政府公有的土資場" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147991/71.wav", + "text": "這樣子的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147991/72.wav", + "text": "就可以避免讓廢棄物有機可乘" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147991/73.wav", + "text": "讓它跟這些營建廢土混在一起" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147991/74.wav", + "text": "然後到處亂倒" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147991/75.wav", + "text": "有關土砂礫石國有化" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147991/76.wav", + "text": "請問主委" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147991/77.wav", + "text": "你身兼政委的身分可以來推這個政策嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147991/78.wav", + "text": "這個可能還要研擬一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147991/79.wav", + "text": "因為它會涉及到私人產權" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147991/80.wav", + "text": "將來怎麼樣界定的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147991/81.wav", + "text": "這個還是要有一套方" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147991/82.wav", + "text": "如果是私人的土地" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147991/83.wav", + "text": "要做大型建物營建" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147991/84.wav", + "text": "他為他的廢土傷腦筋" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147991/85.wav", + "text": "你把他設計成公有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147991/86.wav", + "text": "他可以不花錢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147991/87.wav", + "text": "就進公有的土資場" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147991/88.wav", + "text": "就不會發生現在北部找不到土資場" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147991/89.wav", + "text": "場連廢棄物丟到南部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147991/90.wav", + "text": "丟到農地" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147991/91.wav", + "text": "農地就大災難" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147991/92.wav", + "text": "只是將挖出來的土砂礫石" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147991/93.wav", + "text": "因為現在已經非常嚴重" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147991/94.wav", + "text": "環境災難就是這些土砂礫石" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147991/95.wav", + "text": "被當作下面埋有害" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147991/96.wav", + "text": "事業廢棄物上面做覆蓋的一個工具" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147991/97.wav", + "text": "所以很嚴重" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147991/98.wav", + "text": "可以來表達一下意見嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147991/99.wav", + "text": "這個是非常值得我們來推的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147991/100.wav", + "text": "感謝委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147991/101.wav", + "text": "營建剩餘土石方的追蹤" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147991/102.wav", + "text": "跟舉發提供我們不少的建議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147991/103.wav", + "text": "還是有區分所有權" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147991/104.wav", + "text": "尤其是私有化" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147991/105.wav", + "text": "會比較難處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147991/106.wav", + "text": "第二個也跟委員報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147991/107.wav", + "text": "乾淨的土方跟砂石粒料" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147991/108.wav", + "text": "是有價料" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147991/109.wav", + "text": "也就是它本身有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147991/110.wav", + "text": "我知道就是有價" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147991/111.wav", + "text": "因為他不願意花每噸1,500塊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147991/112.wav", + "text": "就到處亂丟" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147991/113.wav", + "text": "我所謂有價料就是那個是有價值的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147991/114.wav", + "text": "對所以你讓它進公有土資場變成有價" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147991/115.wav", + "text": "有價值的在私人建案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147991/116.wav", + "text": "是可以買賣的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147991/117.wav", + "text": "您剛剛講的會亂倒" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147991/118.wav", + "text": "那一種基本上都" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147991/119.wav", + "text": "就讓他自己賣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147991/120.wav", + "text": "我們讓他去掉廢棄物" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147991/121.wav", + "text": "但是要請你趕快訂作業指引" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147991/122.wav", + "text": "你先有作業指引" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147991/123.wav", + "text": "讓廢棄物跟這些有價的土砂礫石分開" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147991/124.wav", + "text": "然後可以進公有的土資場" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147991/125.wav", + "text": "如果他願意做國產公有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147991/126.wav", + "text": "就不用再花1,500塊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147991/127.wav", + "text": "如果他願意自己去賣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147991/128.wav", + "text": "他就自己去處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147991/129.wav", + "text": "這樣可以嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147991/130.wav", + "text": "感謝委員這一點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147991/131.wav", + "text": "我們跟環境部現在也拜託主委" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147991/132.wav", + "text": "政委大家一起來推" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147991/133.wav", + "text": "混著這些營建廢土去包裝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147991/134.wav", + "text": "的集耀退輔會的農場" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147991/135.wav", + "text": "現在就是這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147991/136.wav", + "text": "把事業廢棄物跟���建廢棄物混成一片" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147991/137.wav", + "text": "可以嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147991/138.wav", + "text": "可不可以兩個禮拜內" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147991/139.wav", + "text": "再給我你們怎麼執行的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147991/140.wav", + "text": "謝謝陳委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147990/0.wav", + "text": "好主席在場的委員先進列席的政府機關首長官員會場工作夥伴媒體記者女士先生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147990/1.wav", + "text": "有請金管會黃主委及銀行局保險局" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147990/2.wav", + "text": "黃主委兩位局長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147990/3.wav", + "text": "委員早" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147990/4.wav", + "text": "主委早主委" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147990/5.wav", + "text": "本週六有一場同志大遊行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147990/6.wav", + "text": "主委有沒有聽聞這個事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147990/7.wav", + "text": "不好意思是委員垂詢我才知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147990/8.wav", + "text": "根據2023年臺灣同志職場處境調查結果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147990/9.wav", + "text": "你來猜猜看哪些職場對於同志最友善哪些最不友善" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147990/10.wav", + "text": "我先請教一下你覺得軍隊對於同志的職場處境如何" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147990/11.wav", + "text": "我的身分不太適合表示這個意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147990/12.wav", + "text": "金融業則是最不友善之一" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147990/13.wav", + "text": "我還特別去看有沒有寫到立法院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147990/14.wav", + "text": "我們看到一般職場環境有很多很多被投訴的情況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147990/15.wav", + "text": "通過一個提案就是在那之後在那斯達克上市的所有企業" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147990/16.wav", + "text": "必須在董事會當中有兩位多元化董事" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147990/17.wav", + "text": "包含一名女性及一名代表少數族裔" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147990/18.wav", + "text": "是性別多元的一個友善代表" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147990/19.wav", + "text": "甚至到2022年歐洲議會通過規範" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147990/20.wav", + "text": "未來在歐盟上市的公司必須在2026年中以前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147990/21.wav", + "text": "或者全體董事女性要占三分之一" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147990/22.wav", + "text": "其實性別友善性別平等是未來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147990/23.wav", + "text": "包括在ESG治理當中非常重要的一項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147990/24.wav", + "text": "會協調金融機構建立多元性別友善政策" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147990/25.wav", + "text": "研議未來臺灣上市櫃公司可以比照國外" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147990/26.wav", + "text": "董事會要納入多元性別觀點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147990/27.wav", + "text": "我覺得可以朝這個方向處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147990/28.wav", + "text": "而且現在其實也有要求只是是男女性別" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147990/29.wav", + "text": "將來這個部分我們應該儘量多鼓勵大家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147990/30.wav", + "text": "好更進步啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147990/31.wav", + "text": "謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147990/32.wav", + "text": "是防治虛擬帳號預警外卡洗錢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147990/33.wav", + "text": "還有民辦公營商保偕同健保分工" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147990/34.wav", + "text": "來我們看一下新聞常常在提" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147990/35.wav", + "text": "的最近在問打詐的事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147990/36.wav", + "text": "最近銀行是不是已經有強化" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147990/37.wav", + "text": "對虛擬帳號的審查措施有沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147990/38.wav", + "text": "好所以金管會持續督導銀行落實" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147990/39.wav", + "text": "對於申請虛擬帳號第三方支付業者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147990/40.wav", + "text": "或其他公司戶進行審查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147990/41.wav", + "text": "強化客戶的審查措施" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147990/42.wav", + "text": "幫你回顧一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147990/43.wav", + "text": "虛擬帳號為什麼成為詐騙工具" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147990/44.wav", + "text": "過去詐騙者不管是持卡者或商店" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147990/45.wav", + "text": "用信用卡消費" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147990/46.wav", + "text": "跟持卡者或商店確認" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147990/47.wav", + "text": "對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147990/48.wav", + "text": "但是虛擬帳號怎麼用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147990/49.wav", + "text": "虛擬帳號用第三方支付" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147990/50.wav", + "text": "去申請一個虛擬帳號之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147990/51.wav", + "text": "詐騙者用那個虛擬帳號來刷卡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147990/52.wav", + "text": "請問主委" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147990/53.wav", + "text": "你認為這個虛擬帳號在這裡面扮演什麼角色" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147990/54.wav", + "text": "就是被詐騙" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147990/55.wav", + "text": "業者拿去利用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147990/56.wav", + "text": "對因為我們都不是專業的詐騙者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147990/57.wav", + "text": "所以我們不太清楚虛擬帳號" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147990/58.wav", + "text": "過去虛擬帳號用途" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147990/59.wav", + "text": "是類似像學校收註冊費" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147990/60.wav", + "text": "用帳號來區隔出繳款的對象" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147990/61.wav", + "text": "跟交易的內容" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147990/62.wav", + "text": "但是因為虛擬帳號具有一個什麼特質" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147990/63.wav", + "text": "它具有金流斷點的特質" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147990/64.wav", + "text": "銀行局已經針對新申辦做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147990/65.wav", + "text": "強化身分的審查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147990/66.wav", + "text": "那已申辦的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147990/67.wav", + "text": "呢是不是會比照新的規定來重新審查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147990/68.wav", + "text": "有沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147990/69.wav", + "text": "已經跟銀行有往來帳戶的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147990/70.wav", + "text": "跟沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147990/71.wav", + "text": "處理上會不一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147990/72.wav", + "text": "重新會審查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147990/73.wav", + "text": "好但是我們在這裡要提醒一點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147990/74.wav", + "text": "因為虛擬帳號" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147990/75.wav", + "text": "它會形成一個什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147990/76.wav", + "text": "無法追查金流" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147990/77.wav", + "text": "如果在這個當中停留一天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147990/78.wav", + "text": "或怎麼樣延長它的停留才能轉帳" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147990/79.wav", + "text": "我舉例來講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147990/80.wav", + "text": "學校收學生的註冊費會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147990/81.wav", + "text": "申請虛擬帳號" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147990/82.wav", + "text": "我不會當天跟學生收了費" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147990/83.wav", + "text": "學校的正式帳戶裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147990/84.wav", + "text": "其實就某些正常的使用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147990/85.wav", + "text": "你不要讓它馬上可以轉出去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147990/86.wav", + "text": "有助於未來如果發生詐騙的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147990/87.wav", + "text": "才有辦法及時攔截住這個金流" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147990/88.wav", + "text": "主委你願不願意考慮把這個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147990/89.wav", + "text": "納入我們防詐的研議措施" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147990/90.wav", + "text": "虛擬帳號的控管" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147990/91.wav", + "text": "因為會使用虛擬帳號的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147990/92.wav", + "text": "就像剛剛委員說的會有學校" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147990/93.wav", + "text": "可能也會有第三方支付" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147990/94.wav", + "text": "我們是不是再來研議看看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147990/95.wav", + "text": "這個延長撥款的效果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147990/96.wav", + "text": "對就是多長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147990/97.wav", + "text": "才不會妨礙到正常的交易" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147990/98.wav", + "text": "但是也不會讓他迅速地把錢洗" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147990/99.wav", + "text": "我們照委員的提示去研究" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147990/100.wav", + "text": "謝謝國外的贓款現在多了一個東西" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147990/101.wav", + "text": "透過假交易洗錢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147990/102.wav", + "text": "詐騙的目的是要騙你的錢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147990/103.wav", + "text": "但是錢騙到手他要洗了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147990/104.wav", + "text": "才有辦法用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147990/105.wav", + "text": "通常現在的洗錢方式是怎麼樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147990/106.wav", + "text": "通常詐騙業者要透過一個虛設的行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147990/107.wav", + "text": "號透過假交易" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147990/108.wav", + "text": "把他詐騙來的錢從國外" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147990/109.wav", + "text": "洗回到國內來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147990/110.wav", + "text": "他通常會用一個國外的信用卡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147990/111.wav", + "text": "他跟國外銀行申請了一個境外卡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147990/112.wav", + "text": "而且超額的繳費" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147990/113.wav", + "text": "把他詐騙來的錢超額繳費" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147990/114.wav", + "text": "這張卡的額度就變成幾乎是無限" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147990/115.wav", + "text": "然後他在這個時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147990/116.wav", + "text": "透過跟國內的一個假交易" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147990/117.wav", + "text": "但是國內銀行在發現" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147990/118.wav", + "text": "是國外卡的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147990/119.wav", + "text": "他沒有辦法去求證這個國外卡的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147990/120.wav", + "text": "信用卡額度金流及持卡人相關資訊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147990/121.wav", + "text": "他就直接把錢交過去了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147990/122.wav", + "text": "洗錢完成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147990/123.wav", + "text": "他做這個洗錢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147990/124.wav", + "text": "只有這個虛設行號" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147990/125.wav", + "text": "需要繳給政府一個假交易的營業稅" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147990/126.wav", + "text": "他就用這樣的方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147990/127.wav", + "text": "透過國外的信用卡透過虛擬帳號" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147990/128.wav", + "text": "就把錢洗回來了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147990/129.wav", + "text": "\n我們來看一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147990/130.wav", + "text": "這是最近的新聞" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147990/131.wav", + "text": "使用外國信用卡在國內的消費金額大漲" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147990/132.wav", + "text": "啊這邊打錯了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147990/133.wav", + "text": "2019年的全年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147990/134.wav", + "text": "境外的旅客將近600萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147990/135.wav", + "text": "在我們境內" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147990/136.wav", + "text": "用國外信用卡消費金額高達將近500億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147990/137.wav", + "text": "這是疫情前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147990/138.wav", + "text": "還不到一半" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147990/139.wav", + "text": "但是持外國信用卡的消費" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147990/140.wav", + "text": "半年卻已達以前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147990/141.wav", + "text": "這有兩種解釋" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147990/142.wav", + "text": "一個是在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147990/143.wav", + "text": "疫情後到臺灣的觀光客" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147990/144.wav", + "text": "用國外卡所" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147990/145.wav", + "text": "刷的金額特別大方" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147990/146.wav", + "text": "但是有沒有可能" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147990/147.wav", + "text": "就是用這種方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147990/148.wav", + "text": "有參雜著外國信用卡來洗錢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147990/149.wav", + "text": "你來看一看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147990/150.wav", + "text": "如果我們用平均人數來算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147990/151.wav", + "text": "正常的單日刷卡金額" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147990/152.wav", + "text": "應該是一億兩千三百零多萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147990/153.wav", + "text": "比照平均數額大概增加了6,500萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147990/154.wav", + "text": "假設這裡面有一半是洗錢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147990/155.wav", + "text": "從每天每月每半年到每年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147990/156.wav", + "text": "有可能是洗錢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147990/157.wav", + "text": "\n最後請問主委" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147990/158.wav", + "text": "為了防治詐團洗錢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147990/159.wav", + "text": "除了剛剛延長虛擬帳號的撥款天數之外" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147990/160.wav", + "text": "要不要去優先查核目前使用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147990/161.wav", + "text": "虛擬帳號的外國信用卡交易量" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147990/162.wav", + "text": "有沒有異常的增長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147990/163.wav", + "text": "這個我是不是請局長先說明一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147990/164.wav", + "text": "因為信用卡的交易" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147990/165.wav", + "text": "還牽涉到整個卡組織的交易規則" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147990/166.wav", + "text": "針對委員今天的提議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147990/167.wav", + "text": "卡組織還有金融機構一起來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147990/168.wav", + "text": "\n最後很簡單的問" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147990/169.wav", + "text": "前天我跟幾位委員合開了一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147990/170.wav", + "text": "公聽會是關於我們癌友的商保問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147990/171.wav", + "text": "因為被認定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147990/172.wav", + "text": "目前罹患癌症的經濟困境" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147990/173.wav", + "text": "有將近32%" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147990/174.wav", + "text": "是治療金額超過50萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147990/175.wav", + "text": "的其中標靶治療有將近五成三" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147990/176.wav", + "text": "免疫治療超過一成三" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147990/177.wav", + "text": "健保不給付" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147990/178.wav", + "text": "我們癌友之前在健康的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147990/179.wav", + "text": "買商保就是為了這一天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147990/180.wav", + "text": "要用到的時候卻不能用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147990/181.wav", + "text": "健保不給付商保又有很多的困境" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147990/182.wav", + "text": "比如在商業保險當中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147990/183.wav", + "text": "我們注意到了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147990/184.wav", + "text": "其實商業保險" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147990/185.wav", + "text": "實際用在保費的風險成本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147990/186.wav", + "text": "或是安全加成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147990/187.wav", + "text": "這才是大家未來可以享用到的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147990/188.wav", + "text": "\n請問一下在這種情況之下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147990/189.wav", + "text": "過去從自由投保" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147990/190.wav", + "text": "經過了商業保險的保險精算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147990/191.wav", + "text": "而且弱體又拒保的情況之下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147990/192.wav", + "text": "遇到癌症風險的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147990/193.wav", + "text": "健保不給付商保又被拒絕" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147990/194.wav", + "text": "比較好的解決方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147990/195.wav", + "text": "委員這個部分健保署也提了一些想法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147990/196.wav", + "text": "跟保險局有溝通現在請公會在研究中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147990/197.wav", + "text": "我給你一個參考方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147990/198.wav", + "text": "有學者提出" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147990/199.wav", + "text": "過去我們辦學生團保" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147990/200.wav", + "text": "或汽機車強制險的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147990/201.wav", + "text": "他就變成是反向的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147990/202.wav", + "text": "規劃出來是公辦民營" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147990/203.wav", + "text": "還是民辦公營學生團保" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147990/204.wav", + "text": "不分學生的年齡性別都是單一費率" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147990/205.wav", + "text": "以整個團體的出險率來計算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147990/206.wav", + "text": "但是汽車強制險" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147990/207.wav", + "text": "呢他只按照年齡跟性別來計算費率" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147990/208.wav", + "text": "這都跟健保的單一費率不一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147990/209.wav", + "text": "這幾年來商業保險公司" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147990/210.wav", + "text": "願意來承接" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147990/211.wav", + "text": "這樣的汽車強制險" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147990/212.wav", + "text": "也來承接學生團保" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147990/213.wav", + "text": "有沒有可能未來我們來考慮一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147990/214.wav", + "text": "如果能夠讓商保這四成的成本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147990/215.wav", + "text": "變成是由政府機關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147990/216.wav", + "text": "透過我們的健保資料庫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147990/217.wav", + "text": "來區分被保險人的健康情況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147990/218.wav", + "text": "設計保單之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147990/219.wav", + "text": "由商業保險來進行執行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147990/220.wav", + "text": "這樣的模式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147990/221.wav", + "text": "有沒有可能變成是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147990/222.wav", + "text": "民辦公營" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147990/223.wav", + "text": "告委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147990/224.wav", + "text": "學生團體保險" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147990/225.wav", + "text": "是教育部有訂一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147990/226.wav", + "text": "學保的條例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147990/227.wav", + "text": "才能夠達到這樣的效益" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147990/228.wav", + "text": "所以你認為立法了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147990/229.wav", + "text": "才能夠產生用商保跟" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147990/230.wav", + "text": "協力分工是不是這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147990/231.wav", + "text": "其實是教育部有編預算來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147990/232.wav", + "text": "補貼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147990/233.wav", + "text": "也有特補基金對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147990/234.wav", + "text": "有特補基金對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147990/235.wav", + "text": "好所以這的確需要一個法制化" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147990/236.wav", + "text": "也需要政府預算可能的一些擔保" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147990/237.wav", + "text": "\n最後我講一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147990/238.wav", + "text": "有個電影叫做星際過客" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147990/239.wav", + "text": "未來在太空旅行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147990/240.wav", + "text": "男女主角是不同的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147990/241.wav", + "text": "艙等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147990/242.wav", + "text": "結果他們有享受不同的餐點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147990/243.wav", + "text": "被保險人的健康條件" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147990/244.wav", + "text": "大概就是根據這三個方式來運作" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147990/245.wav", + "text": "同樣的道理我們認為社會保障" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147990/246.wav", + "text": "就國人的健康來講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147990/247.wav", + "text": "全民健保提供的是一艘郵輪的基礎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147990/248.wav", + "text": "至於民辦公營的自費保險" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147990/249.wav", + "text": "就是量能選擇你要的醫療模式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147990/250.wav", + "text": "如果你要很高檔的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147990/251.wav", + "text": "那你就去買最尖端的醫療服務" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147990/252.wav", + "text": "大概我們未來可以考慮" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147990/253.wav", + "text": "商業保險跟全民健保" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147990/254.wav", + "text": "可以找出一塊量能選擇" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147990/255.wav", + "text": "醫療模式的民辦公營自費保險" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147990/256.wav", + "text": "\n所以最後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147990/257.wav", + "text": "不管是要補位健保還是偕同健保" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147990/258.wav", + "text": "是不是可以用這個方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147990/259.wav", + "text": "目標保費不要貴" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147990/260.wav", + "text": "業者產業不會賠錢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147990/261.wav", + "text": "商業保險公司不會賠錢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147990/262.wav", + "text": "風險能夠控制弱體也不排除" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147990/263.wav", + "text": "在這種情況之下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147990/264.wav", + "text": "最後請主委來承諾" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147990/265.wav", + "text": "推動商保偕同健保分工的可行性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147990/266.wav", + "text": "可不可以有一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147990/267.wav", + "text": "委託的研究或初步規劃" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147990/268.wav", + "text": "來跟我們做報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147990/269.wav", + "text": "這可能也要看衛福部的想法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147990/270.wav", + "text": "要偕同衛福部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147990/271.wav", + "text": "就是希望你們延長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147990/272.wav", + "text": "虛擬帳號的撥補天數" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147990/273.wav", + "text": "優先查核使用外國信用卡交易的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147990/274.wav", + "text": "虛擬帳號並在3個月內" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147990/275.wav", + "text": "提出書面報告給本委員會可以嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147990/276.wav", + "text": "是的可以我們朝這個方向去處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147990/277.wav", + "text": "至於商保偕同健保分工的可行性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147990/278.wav", + "text": "跟衛福部商議之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147990/279.wav", + "text": "也提出一個可行的期程規劃" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147990/280.wav", + "text": "3個月內提出書面報告可以嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147990/281.wav", + "text": "我們再跟衛福部溝通一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147990/282.wav", + "text": "好謝謝主委謝謝局長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147989/0.wav", + "text": "是不是請部長謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147989/1.wav", + "text": "有請薛部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147989/2.wav", + "text": "部長今天的主題也相當地重要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147989/3.wav", + "text": "我們過去多年來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147989/4.wav", + "text": "在長照方面的奮鬥努力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147989/5.wav", + "text": "部長貢獻非常地多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147989/6.wav", + "text": "建立了一個長照2.0最好的基礎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147989/7.wav", + "text": "當然每一個階段" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147989/8.wav", + "text": "都有每一個階段要做的事" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147989/9.wav", + "text": "我們先來稍微討論一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147989/10.wav", + "text": "請教一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147989/11.wav", + "text": "我們當時在推動長照2.0" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147989/12.wav", + "text": "我們當時就覺得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147989/13.wav", + "text": "在推長照的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147989/14.wav", + "text": "可能要啟動社區的資源" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147989/15.wav", + "text": "因為社區有很多資源" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147989/16.wav", + "text": "在那裡沒有activate" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147989/17.wav", + "text": "沒有把它活化" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147989/18.wav", + "text": "然後結合是很可惜的事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147989/19.wav", + "text": "資源的啟動" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147989/20.wav", + "text": "跟不管是縱向橫向" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147989/21.wav", + "text": "的確都有朝著我們的目標在做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147989/22.wav", + "text": "在我們醫界的看法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147989/23.wav", + "text": "是我們希望建立一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147989/24.wav", + "text": "以社區為基礎的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147989/25.wav", + "text": "最後也放一張圖" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147989/26.wav", + "text": "其實我常常在質詢時拿出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147989/27.wav", + "text": "在2013年日本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147989/28.wav", + "text": "的一張圖" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147989/29.wav", + "text": "他們經過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147989/30.wav", + "text": "介護保險困境以後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147989/31.wav", + "text": "所創造出來的一個整合性的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147989/32.wav", + "text": "社區照護" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147989/33.wav", + "text": "從2013開始推" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147989/34.wav", + "text": "到現在還是往這個方面在努力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147989/35.wav", + "text": "請問部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147989/36.wav", + "text": "這8年來的目標" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147989/37.wav", + "text": "醫療長照" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147989/38.wav", + "text": "建立你覺得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147989/39.wav", + "text": "建立得怎麼樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147989/40.wav", + "text": "跟委員報告一個數字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147989/41.wav", + "text": "目前的話我們的居家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147989/42.wav", + "text": "失能的家庭醫師" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147989/43.wav", + "text": "照顧方案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147989/44.wav", + "text": "收案的已經有20萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147989/45.wav", + "text": "被照顧者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147989/46.wav", + "text": "所以有一定的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147989/47.wav", + "text": "啦但是我們覺得還" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147989/48.wav", + "text": "不太夠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147989/49.wav", + "text": "也就是說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147989/50.wav", + "text": "醫療要跟長照" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147989/51.wav", + "text": "去做結合尤其是在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147989/52.wav", + "text": "居家的這一塊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147989/53.wav", + "text": "我們覺得力道還不夠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147989/54.wav", + "text": "所以接下來從明年開始" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147989/55.wav", + "text": "健保" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147989/56.wav", + "text": "的計畫裡面就會有一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147989/57.wav", + "text": "居家醫療" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147989/58.wav", + "text": "的方案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147989/59.wav", + "text": "另外還會有一個大家醫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147989/60.wav", + "text": "目前有了這些社區" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147989/61.wav", + "text": "醫療群" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147989/62.wav", + "text": "增加它的功能然後能夠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147989/63.wav", + "text": "另外一個就是可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147989/64.wav", + "text": "居家醫療就是醫療團隊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147989/65.wav", + "text": "可以到居家裡面去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147989/66.wav", + "text": "進行某一些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147989/67.wav", + "text": "更多一點然後給付" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147989/68.wav", + "text": "明年度就會來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147989/69.wav", + "text": "讓長照跟醫療" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147989/70.wav", + "text": "更進一步的結合尤其是在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147989/71.wav", + "text": "社區這一塊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147989/72.wav", + "text": "好謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147989/73.wav", + "text": "也寫得非常清楚有這幾個方向" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147989/74.wav", + "text": "在做我感覺" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147989/75.wav", + "text": "學界跟醫界也朝著這幾個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147989/76.wav", + "text": "目標現在所有的演講就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147989/77.wav", + "text": "繞著這幾個主題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147989/78.wav", + "text": "一直在研討討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147989/79.wav", + "text": "我覺得很好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147989/80.wav", + "text": "長照保險" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147989/81.wav", + "text": "不是唯一可行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147989/82.wav", + "text": "的制度不是唯一的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147989/83.wav", + "text": "運用臺灣的特色" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147989/84.wav", + "text": "讓臺灣過去幾十年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147989/85.wav", + "text": "努力經營" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147989/86.wav", + "text": "也許我們可以用更好的方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147989/87.wav", + "text": "來做更多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147989/88.wav", + "text": "更有價值的事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147989/89.wav", + "text": "未來要跨進所謂的長照" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147989/90.wav", + "text": "我們不排除任何一個制度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147989/91.wav", + "text": "也要爭取任何一個資源" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147989/92.wav", + "text": "最重要是對人民有效率在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147989/93.wav", + "text": "資源有限的情況之下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147989/94.wav", + "text": "每個國家的資源一定都是有限的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147989/95.wav", + "text": "怎麼來創造更大的資源" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147989/96.wav", + "text": "賴副總統有提出一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147989/97.wav", + "text": "我們這裡剛好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147989/98.wav", + "text": "有拿到他整理的資料" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147989/99.wav", + "text": "我個人覺得相當完整" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147989/100.wav", + "text": "機構醫療社福的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147989/101.wav", + "text": "一體式服務" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147989/102.wav", + "text": "居家醫療跟長照的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147989/103.wav", + "text": "在過去幾年來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147989/104.wav", + "text": "做得非常完整以外" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147989/105.wav", + "text": "尤其在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147989/106.wav", + "text": "居家醫療" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147989/107.wav", + "text": "居家失能這一塊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147989/108.wav", + "text": "推動得非常用心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147989/109.wav", + "text": "要怎麼樣把它做好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147989/110.wav", + "text": "其中還有推動" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147989/111.wav", + "text": "高齡者家庭醫師制度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147989/112.wav", + "text": "剛才部長說的大家醫制度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147989/113.wav", + "text": "大家醫制度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147989/114.wav", + "text": "因為不限於高齡者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147989/115.wav", + "text": "但是高齡者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147989/116.wav", + "text": "一定在這裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147989/117.wav", + "text": "就是這種制度又" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147989/118.wav", + "text": "我覺得都很好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147989/119.wav", + "text": "不過醫界他們比較擔心現在有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147989/120.wav", + "text": "有很多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147989/121.wav", + "text": "同樣的資源改變一個觀念" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147989/122.wav", + "text": "創造價值" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147989/123.wav", + "text": "這個很棒" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147989/124.wav", + "text": "醫療團隊一直做很多的事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147989/125.wav", + "text": "結果通報後資源沒有進來可是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147989/126.wav", + "text": "了趴在前面了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147989/127.wav", + "text": "一部分當然還是在健保" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147989/128.wav", + "text": "的資源裡面因為涉及到一些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147989/129.wav", + "text": "也有一大部分可能是從長照" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147989/130.wav", + "text": "從什麼長照基金" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147989/131.wav", + "text": "進入居家跟我們的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147989/132.wav", + "text": "長照團隊一起" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147989/133.wav", + "text": "照顧好我們的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147989/134.wav", + "text": "在做長照這件事我們很清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147989/135.wav", + "text": "我們很不希望動用到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147989/136.wav", + "text": "長照本身的資源" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147989/137.wav", + "text": "長照本身的資源就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147989/138.wav", + "text": "好好把長照做好在醫療部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147989/139.wav", + "text": "我把疾病照顧好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147989/140.wav", + "text": "他將來使用長照的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147989/141.wav", + "text": "所以如何在這個轉折" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147989/142.wav", + "text": "醫生去做長照的事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147989/143.wav", + "text": "他還是做本業的事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147989/144.wav", + "text": "但他要和這個長照團隊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147989/145.wav", + "text": "好好地密切合作" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147989/146.wav", + "text": "因為很多長照團隊裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147989/147.wav", + "text": "醫療知識" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147989/148.wav", + "text": "長照有長照的團隊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147989/149.wav", + "text": "長照有長照的資源想像" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147989/150.wav", + "text": "所以在這當中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147989/151.wav", + "text": "這幾天以來都很清楚地" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147989/152.wav", + "text": "告訴大家醫療" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147989/153.wav", + "text": "只是想把醫療做好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147989/154.wav", + "text": "並沒有要去動用到長照以人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147989/155.wav", + "text": "為中心啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147989/156.wav", + "text": "要有醫療團隊的協助" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147989/157.wav", + "text": "也要有長照團隊的照顧" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147989/158.wav", + "text": "家庭醫師的制度裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147989/159.wav", + "text": "意見書而已" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147989/160.wav", + "text": "我覺得這樣還不太夠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147989/161.wav", + "text": "所以有一些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147989/162.wav", + "text": "的居家醫療方案進來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147989/163.wav", + "text": "還有一些是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147989/164.wav", + "text": "長照團隊必須接受" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147989/165.wav", + "text": "不只是開意見書" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147989/166.wav", + "text": "而是臨床" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147989/167.wav", + "text": "實際照顧上的一些建議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147989/168.wav", + "text": "我們希望能做得更好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147989/169.wav", + "text": "非常棒我的下一張就要討論這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147989/170.wav", + "text": "醫療端跟長照端" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147989/171.wav", + "text": "大家不分彼此" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147989/172.wav", + "text": "做哪些事情就從哪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147989/173.wav", + "text": "個專業領域" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147989/174.wav", + "text": "取得資源" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147989/175.wav", + "text": "互相" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147989/176.wav", + "text": "更大的價值這是好事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147989/177.wav", + "text": "這個部分我全力支持\n請看下一張" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147989/178.wav", + "text": "剛剛有提到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147989/179.wav", + "text": "居家失能這" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147989/180.wav", + "text": "非常重要也是部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147989/181.wav", + "text": "剛剛說要踏出下一步" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147989/182.wav", + "text": "是醫界一直提的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147989/183.wav", + "text": "我也不是說一定完全" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147989/184.wav", + "text": "比如怎樣讓" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147989/185.wav", + "text": "要讓更多的醫師願意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147989/186.wav", + "text": "與有更多的意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147989/187.wav", + "text": "還有很多可以做的事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147989/188.wav", + "text": "一直提出來但到現在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147989/189.wav", + "text": "後面還有一個題目但主席站起來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147989/190.wav", + "text": "了這部分能不能再另外回答就好了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147989/191.wav", + "text": "好不好好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147989/192.wav", + "text": "總統也很關心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147989/193.wav", + "text": "部長那時候是次長也" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147989/194.wav", + "text": "一直在推全國的醫界" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147989/195.wav", + "text": "一直在努力請看下一張不好意思" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147989/196.wav", + "text": "後來因為我們對長照" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147989/197.wav", + "text": "非常在意所以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147989/198.wav", + "text": "好在臺北市的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147989/199.wav", + "text": "希望能跟我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147989/200.wav", + "text": "做一個互動討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147989/201.wav", + "text": "再努力的好��好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147989/202.wav", + "text": "給你們參考一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147989/203.wav", + "text": "謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147987/0.wav", + "text": "謝謝主席本席想邀請部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147987/1.wav", + "text": "抱歉因為我要去接外賓所以是不是委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147987/2.wav", + "text": "3分鐘就好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147987/3.wav", + "text": "首先請教部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147987/4.wav", + "text": "大家期待已久努力已久" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147987/5.wav", + "text": "台積電將落腳在我們的中科在我們大雅這個區塊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147987/6.wav", + "text": "是不是確認" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147987/7.wav", + "text": "中科二期這個用地確實當時是要給台積電使用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147987/8.wav", + "text": "對所以目前也是嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147987/9.wav", + "text": "而且是拍板定案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147987/10.wav", + "text": "因為在努力的這個過程當中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147987/11.wav", + "text": "我們有一個部分就是水跟電" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147987/12.wav", + "text": "那水跟電現在中央地方合作" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147987/13.wav", + "text": "對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147987/14.wav", + "text": "好非常的感謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147987/15.wav", + "text": "這是中央跟地方合作達陣成功" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147987/16.wav", + "text": "所以對我們地方來講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147987/17.wav", + "text": "我們非常非常的重視" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147987/18.wav", + "text": "目前由中科也就是國科會這邊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147987/19.wav", + "text": "取得的用地" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147987/20.wav", + "text": "是不是如期會在明年的6月份來交" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147987/21.wav", + "text": "因為這部分目前都是國科會科管局這邊負責" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147987/22.wav", + "text": "確實他們的目標是希望" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147987/23.wav", + "text": "所有的程序走完明年6月的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147987/24.wav", + "text": "所以給部長你的訊息" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147987/25.wav", + "text": "也是到目前為止都依照我們的KPI" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147987/26.wav", + "text": "就是在明年的6月份來交地" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147987/27.wav", + "text": "地對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147987/28.wav", + "text": "好所以我們希望包括這個球場的員工" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147987/29.wav", + "text": "等這些都是由國科會中科局這邊來支應" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147987/30.wav", + "text": "來協調對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147987/31.wav", + "text": "所以我們一起努力達陣成功" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147987/32.wav", + "text": "在明年6月的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147987/33.wav", + "text": "正式交地給台積電" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147987/34.wav", + "text": "帶動地方的繁榮" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147987/35.wav", + "text": "我們一起加油" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147987/36.wav", + "text": "跟內政部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147987/37.wav", + "text": "請杜次長內政部次長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147987/38.wav", + "text": "國土計畫法在2016年制定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147987/39.wav", + "text": "它主要是空間規劃的最上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147987/40.wav", + "text": "畫要確保糧食安全" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147987/41.wav", + "text": "這個非常重要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147987/42.wav", + "text": "但是根據中研院在3月16號所公布的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147987/43.wav", + "text": "農業政策建議書2.0" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147987/44.wav", + "text": "指出依照國土計畫法所劃設的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147987/45.wav", + "text": "雖然比2018年多出了35萬公頃" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147987/46.wav", + "text": "但是它是往山坡地" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147987/47.wav", + "text": "發展導致平地優良的農地會流失" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147987/48.wav", + "text": "數字是增加" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147987/49.wav", + "text": "了他們所規劃的是增加35萬公頃" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147987/50.wav", + "text": "本席要請教" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147987/51.wav", + "text": "生態保育跟增加山坡地" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147987/52.wav", + "text": "災害的風險" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147987/53.wav", + "text": "你們內部有沒有做過考量" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147987/54.wav", + "text": "本席首先要請教農業部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147987/55.wav", + "text": "農業部對於中研院所提出的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147987/56.wav", + "text": "糧食安全農地不夠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147987/57.wav", + "text": "要用山坡地來湊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147987/58.wav", + "text": "這樣的立場是否認同" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147987/59.wav", + "text": "謝謝委員的關心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147987/60.wav", + "text": "其實委員寫的就是很清楚的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147987/61.wav", + "text": "第一個農業生產" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147987/62.wav", + "text": "其實不是依照以前的方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147987/63.wav", + "text": "去計算而是以我們有很多的農業科技加進去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147987/64.wav", + "text": "農業生產的方式也加進去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147987/65.wav", + "text": "所以我們現在估計" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147987/66.wav", + "text": "提供糧食安全所需要的農地" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147987/67.wav", + "text": "大概是75到85公頃" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147987/68.wav", + "text": "但是在中研院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147987/69.wav", + "text": "大概是依照各縣市" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147987/70.wav", + "text": "它提出來的建議書是依照各縣市" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147987/71.wav", + "text": "劃設出來的農業區域" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147987/72.wav", + "text": "相較以往有比較多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147987/73.wav", + "text": "這部分其實有相對很複雜" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147987/74.wav", + "text": "的包括委員提問說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147987/75.wav", + "text": "在山坡地的發展要不要考慮" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147987/76.wav", + "text": "當然保育也很重要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147987/77.wav", + "text": "不是只有生產" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147987/78.wav", + "text": "人的安全" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147987/79.wav", + "text": "環境的安全" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147987/80.wav", + "text": "永續的發生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147987/81.wav", + "text": "其實這些都很重要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147987/82.wav", + "text": "所以就中研院提出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147987/83.wav", + "text": "包括將來我們在內政部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147987/84.wav", + "text": "整個國土的審查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147987/85.wav", + "text": "我們都會就這點來提出意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147987/86.wav", + "text": "好你這樣回答我就放心一點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147987/87.wav", + "text": "因為我們的目的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147987/88.wav", + "text": "也就是希望真正在規劃當中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147987/89.wav", + "text": "能夠達到它的成效" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147987/90.wav", + "text": "你一直點頭" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147987/91.wav", + "text": "那我就放心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147987/92.wav", + "text": "了它在3月16號頒布之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147987/93.wav", + "text": "你們也看了內容" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147987/94.wav", + "text": "也的確誠如你剛才所說的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147987/95.wav", + "text": "是非常的複雜跟多元" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147987/96.wav", + "text": "所以你必須要去盤點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147987/97.wav", + "text": "你必須要去盤點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147987/98.wav", + "text": "等到真正討論的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147987/99.wav", + "text": "才能夠讓民眾放心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147987/100.wav", + "text": "才能夠真正的達到分區" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147987/101.wav", + "text": "這一點非常重要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147987/102.wav", + "text": "你們一旦有規劃什麼樣的方案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147987/103.wav", + "text": "再請順便將資料給本席" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147987/104.wav", + "text": "因為我們一定要超前部署" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147987/105.wav", + "text": "未雨綢繆" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147987/106.wav", + "text": "\n好接下來本席要請國發會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147987/107.wav", + "text": "國發會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147987/108.wav", + "text": "在10月23號通過環境部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147987/109.wav", + "text": "所提的第二期空氣污染防制方案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147987/110.wav", + "text": "這個部分是113年到116年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147987/111.wav", + "text": "全案是行政院核定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147987/112.wav", + "text": "由中央跟國營事業投入766億元" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147987/113.wav", + "text": "來改善我們的空氣品質" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147987/114.wav", + "text": "但據您表示" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147987/115.wav", + "text": "第一期的方案是109年到112年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147987/116.wav", + "text": "您說國營事業單位污染是減半" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147987/117.wav", + "text": "全球COVID-19的疫情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147987/118.wav", + "text": "導致我們跟鄰國的產業" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147987/119.wav", + "text": "產業少了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147987/120.wav", + "text": "所以成功使空氣品質能夠真正改善" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147987/121.wav", + "text": "連續三年都達標" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147987/122.wav", + "text": "而第二期空氣污染防制方案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147987/123.wav", + "text": "主要是針對於哪裡呢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147987/124.wav", + "text": "主要是針對中南部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147987/125.wav", + "text": "中南部在116年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147987/126.wav", + "text": "PM2.5年平均濃度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147987/127.wav", + "text": "微克在這樣的情況之下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147987/128.wav", + "text": "政府花了766億元" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147987/129.wav", + "text": "來加強改善空氣品質的力道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147987/130.wav", + "text": "國發會有沒有跨部會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147987/131.wav", + "text": "是要真正解除本席所說的重點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147987/132.wav", + "text": "怎麼樣讓中火減煤成效" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147987/133.wav", + "text": "更加地顯著" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147987/134.wav", + "text": "才能夠真正地達到你的KPI目標" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147987/135.wav", + "text": "請做說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147987/136.wav", + "text": "報告委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147987/137.wav", + "text": "您剛才提到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147987/138.wav", + "text": "事實上我們都是跨部會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147987/139.wav", + "text": "經過國發會會議以後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147987/140.wav", + "text": "跨部會好我們把焦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147987/141.wav", + "text": "中火減煤怎麼樣改善" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147987/142.wav", + "text": "全區域來講的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147987/143.wav", + "text": "都考量進去所以才會訂定這樣的相關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147987/144.wav", + "text": "相關的什麼作為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147987/145.wav", + "text": "因為如果依照你們目前的動作" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147987/146.wav", + "text": "跟你現在所提出的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147987/147.wav", + "text": "你是達不到的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147987/148.wav", + "text": "啊中火如果沒有減煤" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147987/149.wav", + "text": "你根本不可能達到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147987/150.wav", + "text": "啊你的關鍵就在中火怎麼樣減煤" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147987/151.wav", + "text": "嘛你要怎麼達到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147987/152.wav", + "text": "你要怎麼樣減煤" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147987/153.wav", + "text": "本席要請教的是這一點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147987/154.wav", + "text": "中火的部分經濟部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147987/155.wav", + "text": "主委你不瞭解這個內容" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147987/156.wav", + "text": "你剛剛告訴我說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147987/157.wav", + "text": "你們有跨部會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147987/158.wav", + "text": "但是你這樣的回答" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147987/159.wav", + "text": "環境部有他們的作為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147987/160.wav", + "text": "經濟部也有部分的作為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147987/161.wav", + "text": "那您的作為呢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147987/162.wav", + "text": "你跨部會做統合" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147987/163.wav", + "text": "我一直說國發會是心臟" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147987/164.wav", + "text": "是領袖" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147987/165.wav", + "text": "它要跨部會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147987/166.wav", + "text": "要怎麼減煤" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147987/167.wav", + "text": "各個部會他會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147987/168.wav", + "text": "結果論你的答案怎麼樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147987/169.wav", + "text": "讓中火減煤" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147987/170.wav", + "text": "就是所有的作為之下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147987/171.wav", + "text": "可以達到全國性15微" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147987/172.wav", + "text": "你沒針對本席的問題回答" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147987/173.wav", + "text": "本席再一次請教" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147987/174.wav", + "text": "怎麼樣讓中火減煤這個方案落實" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147987/175.wav", + "text": "這個才是你真正可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147987/176.wav", + "text": "達到你的目標" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147987/177.wav", + "text": "還是經濟部主責" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147987/178.wav", + "text": "是他們的政策" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147987/179.wav", + "text": "我們只是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147987/180.wav", + "text": "那我又要把你扣分了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147987/181.wav", + "text": "因為你又不是一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147987/182.wav", + "text": "統合的lea" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147987/183.wav", + "text": "你又把它推到各部會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147987/184.wav", + "text": "那我們要國發會幹什麼呢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147987/185.wav", + "text": "不是就是每一個部會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147987/186.wav", + "text": "提出來他的作法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147987/187.wav", + "text": "我們統合起來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147987/188.wav", + "text": "你瞭解他的作法嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147987/189.wav", + "text": "他有沒有要將中火減煤" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147987/190.wav", + "text": "他們有相關的規劃" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147987/191.wav", + "text": "有沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147987/192.wav", + "text": "就是說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147987/193.wav", + "text": "有還是沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147987/194.wav", + "text": "主要是什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147987/195.wav", + "text": "這個可能要請經濟部來回答" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147987/196.wav", + "text": "主要是什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147987/197.wav", + "text": "哇" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147987/198.wav", + "text": "主委我真的不知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147987/199.wav", + "text": "要怎麼跟你對談" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147987/200.wav", + "text": "請你詳細去瞭解清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147987/201.wav", + "text": "再給本席回答" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147987/202.wav", + "text": "好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147987/203.wav", + "text": "給你的題目" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147987/204.wav", + "text": "就是你做一個整合" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147987/205.wav", + "text": "怎麼樣讓中火減煤的成效" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147987/206.wav", + "text": "能夠更加的卓著" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147987/207.wav", + "text": "才能夠真正達到你的目標" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147987/208.wav", + "text": "好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147987/209.wav", + "text": "你不要在發言台" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147987/210.wav", + "text": "還轉過去問他們什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147987/211.wav", + "text": "那你這個團隊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147987/212.wav", + "text": "到底是什麼團隊呢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147987/213.wav", + "text": "主政單位是經濟部啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147987/214.wav", + "text": "主政單位當然是經濟部啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147987/215.wav", + "text": "但你剛剛一開頭回答" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147987/216.wav", + "text": "你們是跨部會在開會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147987/217.wav", + "text": "對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147987/218.wav", + "text": "所以至少你們跨部會開會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147987/219.wav", + "text": "時你會知道各部會怎麼做但" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147987/220.wav", + "text": "你現在完全沒有辦法回答出來嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147987/221.wav", + "text": "請你詳細去討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147987/222.wav", + "text": "我還是��功課給你好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147987/223.wav", + "text": "你要真正達到這個目標" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147987/224.wav", + "text": "就是中火一定要減煤" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147987/225.wav", + "text": "才能夠真正達到目標" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147987/226.wav", + "text": "好嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147987/227.wav", + "text": "這也是你自己設的目標嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147987/228.wav", + "text": "你應該知道它的方案是什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147987/229.wav", + "text": "好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147987/230.wav", + "text": "\n接下來本席要請教經濟部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147987/231.wav", + "text": "2021年臺灣經濟成長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147987/232.wav", + "text": "交出突破6%的亮眼成績" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147987/233.wav", + "text": "但是受僱人員的報酬占GDP" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147987/234.wav", + "text": "比重只有43.03%" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147987/235.wav", + "text": "比以往還要低" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147987/236.wav", + "text": "且企業盈餘從1990年的不到30%" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147987/237.wav", + "text": "但是我們看到鄰近國家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147987/238.wav", + "text": "副座這表示什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147987/239.wav", + "text": "表示臺灣的員工不像美國日本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147987/240.wav", + "text": "可以享受到他們所努力的經濟果實" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147987/241.wav", + "text": "對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147987/242.wav", + "text": "我們是36.53%" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147987/243.wav", + "text": "其他國家是50%" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147987/244.wav", + "text": "沒有全民共享" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147987/245.wav", + "text": "本席要跟你討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147987/246.wav", + "text": "中小企業替員工加薪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147987/247.wav", + "text": "這是我們中小企業發展" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147987/248.wav", + "text": "（113）年5月19" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147987/249.wav", + "text": "它是有這樣的規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147987/250.wav", + "text": "所以我們拿出了這個數據" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147987/251.wav", + "text": "來跟你討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147987/252.wav", + "text": "本席具體建議應該要延長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147987/253.wav", + "text": "因為我們好不容易從30%" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147987/254.wav", + "text": "增加到36.53%" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147987/255.wav", + "text": "加了6.53%" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147987/256.wav", + "text": "但是比照美國跟日本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147987/257.wav", + "text": "人家都超過50%了我們用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147987/258.wav", + "text": "這樣子來鼓勵我們的員工" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147987/259.wav", + "text": "提振士氣趕快來做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147987/260.wav", + "text": "讓我們的國力能夠增強" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147987/261.wav", + "text": "所以本席具體建議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147987/262.wav", + "text": "以因應我們物價上漲" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147987/263.wav", + "text": "副座你的看法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147987/264.wav", + "text": "我認同委員所提出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147987/265.wav", + "text": "要我們好好的去做溝通協調" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147987/266.wav", + "text": "來做溝通" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147987/267.wav", + "text": "會朝這個方向要延長嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147987/268.wav", + "text": "所以本席也正式提案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147987/269.wav", + "text": "也希望得到行政部門的支持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147987/270.wav", + "text": "我們一起來幫助企業" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147987/271.wav", + "text": "幫助員工" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147987/272.wav", + "text": "達到三贏的政策" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147987/273.wav", + "text": "將明年（113年）5月19日" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147987/274.wav", + "text": "到期的落日日" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147987/275.wav", + "text": "以協助產業協助員工" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147987/276.wav", + "text": "增加我們的國力好嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147987/277.wav", + "text": "這個方向你認同嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147987/278.wav", + "text": "謝謝委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147987/279.wav", + "text": "這個方向你認同吧" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147987/280.wav", + "text": "我們會來努力朝這個方向" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147987/281.wav", + "text": "這個方向你認同吧" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147987/282.wav", + "text": "認同" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147986/0.wav", + "text": "有請管主委" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147986/1.wav", + "text": "陳委員好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147986/2.wav", + "text": "主委早安" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147986/3.wav", + "text": "我想我今天想要先來問一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147986/4.wav", + "text": "宜蘭有發生賞鯨船" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147986/5.wav", + "text": "擊中這樣一個新聞" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147986/6.wav", + "text": "這在國防委員會也討論了一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147986/7.wav", + "text": "已經進入相關的調查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147986/8.wav", + "text": "已經進入調查的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147986/9.wav", + "text": "就進入調查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147986/10.wav", + "text": "我今天比較想問的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147986/11.wav", + "text": "是針對戒護的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147986/12.wav", + "text": "因為這個部分和" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147986/13.wav", + "text": "我們的海巡是比較相關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147986/14.wav", + "text": "與國防部協調" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147986/15.wav", + "text": "我想從事情發生到現在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147986/16.wav", + "text": "因為我自己是宜蘭在地" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147986/17.wav", + "text": "我知道我們海巡弟兄非常的辛苦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147986/18.wav", + "text": "在這件事情上面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147986/19.wav", + "text": "讓我們海巡署" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147986/20.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147986/21.wav", + "text": "我先把這個數字跟委員報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147986/22.wav", + "text": "就是我們和國軍在這個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147986/23.wav", + "text": "是有合作的機制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147986/24.wav", + "text": "等一下我們署長會做說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147986/25.wav", + "text": "以今年來講累計到現在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147986/26.wav", + "text": "我們大概有92次的戒護" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147986/27.wav", + "text": "是124艘次的艦艇出去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147986/28.wav", + "text": "三年以來大概有360次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147986/29.wav", + "text": "428艘次的船艇" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147986/30.wav", + "text": "參與這些戒護的工作" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147986/31.wav", + "text": "這一次的事件" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147986/32.wav", + "text": "我們請我們周副主委來說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147986/33.wav", + "text": "好謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147986/34.wav", + "text": "委員好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147986/35.wav", + "text": "跟委員特別說明您關心的這次事件" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147986/36.wav", + "text": "這次事件" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147986/37.wav", + "text": "這個通告就包含整個的區塊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147986/38.wav", + "text": "哪些地方是危險區" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147986/39.wav", + "text": "它都有按照規定去做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147986/40.wav", + "text": "當我們收到這個通告之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147986/41.wav", + "text": "海巡署的作法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147986/42.wav", + "text": "一定是立刻通知各相關的安檢所" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147986/43.wav", + "text": "通知附近的這些漁船漁港" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147986/44.wav", + "text": "提醒他們在出港的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147986/45.wav", + "text": "要特別注意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147986/46.wav", + "text": "也都會同時收到通知" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147986/47.wav", + "text": "都會在同一時間收到這些通知" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147986/48.wav", + "text": "我們海巡署" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147986/49.wav", + "text": "唯一有兩個不一樣的地方" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147986/50.wav", + "text": "有一種是它會通知" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147986/51.wav", + "text": "請海巡署派戒護船隻" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147986/52.wav", + "text": "它這次的射擊可能比較長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147986/53.wav", + "text": "或者比較危險" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147986/54.wav", + "text": "考量的事情比較多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147986/55.wav", + "text": "的時候它會請海巡署加派巡防艇" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147986/56.wav", + "text": "完全按照射擊通報它都有發" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147986/57.wav", + "text": "第二種就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147986/58.wav", + "text": "就像剛剛主委報告的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147986/59.wav", + "text": "我們每年跟國防部都有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147986/60.wav", + "text": "每次我們都會依照雙方開會前會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147986/61.wav", + "text": "然後這些風險評估" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147986/62.wav", + "text": "還會開一個檢討會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147986/63.wav", + "text": "這些事情我們都按照SOP在做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147986/64.wav", + "text": "目前跟委員報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147986/65.wav", + "text": "我們執行起來沒有什麼困難" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147986/66.wav", + "text": "執行起來都還算正常" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147986/67.wav", + "text": "好謝謝署長跟主委" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147986/68.wav", + "text": "我今天特別再問一次的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147986/69.wav", + "text": "主要原因是事情發生的當下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147986/70.wav", + "text": "其實我就有關心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147986/71.wav", + "text": "就是對海巡在宜蘭這個地方" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147986/72.wav", + "text": "我覺得因為我們是有電話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147986/73.wav", + "text": "可以做相關的聯繫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147986/74.wav", + "text": "一般民眾或是漁民他們可能不瞭解" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147986/75.wav", + "text": "所以第一時間也會問" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147986/76.wav", + "text": "為什麼海巡沒有出戒護船" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147986/77.wav", + "text": "所以我就要幫忙解釋一邊說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147986/78.wav", + "text": "也有按照SOP去處理了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147986/79.wav", + "text": "並沒有做相關的申請" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147986/80.wav", + "text": "我想也是趁這個機會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147986/81.wav", + "text": "可以做一些相關的說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147986/82.wav", + "text": "再來我當然就是想要再追一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147986/83.wav", + "text": "我也問了管媽海洋保育法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147986/84.wav", + "text": "目前卡在九大爭點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147986/85.wav", + "text": "大概還有四點到五點左右" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147986/86.wav", + "text": "還在持續溝通當中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147986/87.wav", + "text": "所以今天也想要請教一下主委" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147986/88.wav", + "text": "目前的進度大概怎麼樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147986/89.wav", + "text": "再跟委員報告最新的進度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147986/90.wav", + "text": "這九大爭點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147986/91.wav", + "text": "後來我們都完成溝通以後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147986/92.wav", + "text": "把草案版本再經過一次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147986/93.wav", + "text": "跨部會會議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147986/94.wav", + "text": "由政委主持也已經完成了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147986/95.wav", + "text": "就要報院讓它出行政院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147986/96.wav", + "text": "嘛從9月以來本來好幾次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147986/97.wav", + "text": "也要做行政立法協調" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147986/98.wav", + "text": "也做了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147986/99.wav", + "text": "但是就是在這過程之中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147986/100.wav", + "text": "最後一刻農業部門" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147986/101.wav", + "text": "要求我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147986/102.wav", + "text": "要去跟漁民溝通" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147986/103.wav", + "text": "其實我們在修這些草案的過程當中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147986/104.wav", + "text": "農業部門也都有一起參加" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147986/105.wav", + "text": "跨部會的協調會議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147986/106.wav", + "text": "那我們也特別保障了漁民" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147986/107.wav", + "text": "庇護區的劃設" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147986/108.wav", + "text": "或者是禁限制行為的公布" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147986/109.wav", + "text": "制定這些環節" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147986/110.wav", + "text": "我們都用審議會的制度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147986/111.wav", + "text": "讓利害關係者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147986/112.wav", + "text": "共同出席" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147986/113.wav", + "text": "要贏得共識" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147986/114.wav", + "text": "然後才會完成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147986/115.wav", + "text": "所以對漁業權的保護" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147986/116.wav", + "text": "在這些所有重要關鍵的機制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147986/117.wav", + "text": "都用審議會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147986/118.wav", + "text": "然後他們會有代表進來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147986/119.wav", + "text": "一起討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147986/120.wav", + "text": "最後有共識才會往前走" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147986/121.wav", + "text": "充分地得到參與" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147986/122.wav", + "text": "充分地得到共同決策" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147986/123.wav", + "text": "然後也充分地得到權益保障" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147986/124.wav", + "text": "的一個法的設計" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147986/125.wav", + "text": "為了漁業永續" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147986/126.wav", + "text": "及漁業漁權" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147986/127.wav", + "text": "絕對是一個共融夥伴關係" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147986/128.wav", + "text": "已經做了最好的設計" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147986/129.wav", + "text": "最周全的多元參與" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147986/130.wav", + "text": "然後共同夥伴關係" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147986/131.wav", + "text": "但是農業部門卻堅持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147986/132.wav", + "text": "我們還是得回去跟漁民溝通" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147986/133.wav", + "text": "所以就變成這個會期進不來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147986/134.wav", + "text": "就卡在這裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147986/135.wav", + "text": "我也覺得很挫折" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147986/136.wav", + "text": "心裡有挫折感是一回事" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147986/137.wav", + "text": "行動不能有挫折感" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147986/138.wav", + "text": "行動不能有受到挫折" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147986/139.wav", + "text": "所以我們就積極地" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147986/140.wav", + "text": "再來跟漁業界進行說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147986/141.wav", + "text": "我們會補做這一塊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147986/142.wav", + "text": "但是因為需要補做這一塊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147986/143.wav", + "text": "就變成這會期" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147986/144.wav", + "text": "聽起來需要再一些時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147986/145.wav", + "text": "是這是很可惜的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147986/146.wav", + "text": "不會這我也認同" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147986/147.wav", + "text": "因為漁民他們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147986/148.wav", + "text": "多做溝通是很需要的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147986/149.wav", + "text": "我們就是積極地來做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147986/150.wav", + "text": "因為這個過程當中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147986/151.wav", + "text": "如果沒有他們的聲音" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147986/152.wav", + "text": "就算行政院這邊走完了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147986/153.wav", + "text": "正式進到立法院要修法的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147986/154.wav", + "text": "他們反而會有更大的聲音" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147986/155.wav", + "text": "在這過程當中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147986/156.wav", + "text": "可以找他們一起來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147986/157.wav", + "text": "我們曾經有過一次說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147986/158.wav", + "text": "但是那一次的說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147986/159.wav", + "text": "是用懶人包" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147986/160.wav", + "text": "向全國漁會做說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147986/161.wav", + "text": "我們接下來會用條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147986/162.wav", + "text": "來向他們進行說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147986/163.wav", + "text": "對這樣可能會比較好一點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147986/164.wav", + "text": "再辛苦主委" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147986/165.wav", + "text": "麻煩" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147986/166.wav", + "text": "好謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147986/167.wav", + "text": "謝謝陳琬惠委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147986/168.wav", + "text": "\n接下來有請李德維委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147985/0.wav", + "text": "主席好我想要請問部長其實大家對於不管是政治的爭議也好以及近期以來選舉所有的查賄及相關案件其實我們知道對於所有的檢察官都增加了非常多的工作量是不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147985/1.wav", + "text": "每一遇到選舉對我們檢察官還有我們的檢察事務官及警調等等都是一個很大的負擔因為這個一定會影響到正常的工作但是我們還是會全力以赴" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147985/2.wav", + "text": "到底檢察官助理的法制化進程是如何因為這是所有基層檢察官所在意的是不是因為我們希望工作能夠合理化當然需要有人力的充補及增加到底怎麼樣子法制化這是不是能夠說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147985/3.wav", + "text": "謝謝委員的關心我們檢察官的工作負擔確實很重先臨時的有一個檢察官助理人員能夠進駐也可以減緩一些壓力不過我們還是要永遠把它法制化以後才能有固定人員的增額所以確實檢察官助理的法制化現在已經草擬了相關條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147985/4.wav", + "text": "趕快能夠進行立法程序的話將來讓檢察官也可以有一些輔助人員能夠來幫忙" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147985/5.wav", + "text": "現在遇到的困難在哪裡你們已經講很久講一個月了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147985/6.wav", + "text": "沒有很久一兩個禮拜但是我們已經進行中謝謝委員關心也請委員支持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147985/7.wav", + "text": "假訊息也是我們這次查賄的一個主要核心工作但是如何快速有效地來查證訊息的真偽" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147985/8.wav", + "text": "如果能確定它是一個假的訊息應該要立即澄清讓外界瞭解希望也不會影響到整個選舉的公平" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147985/9.wav", + "text": "我們只要對這些訊息來做溯源如果一旦發覺它是利用一些造假的帳號我們就會適時對外揭露讓民眾能夠瞭解這些是假訊息" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147985/10.wav", + "text": "怎麼樣辨別是造假的帳號" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147985/11.wav", + "text": "怎麼樣分辨境外跟境內以及在這樣的工作上面國安局跟你們調查局到底分際如何" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147985/12.wav", + "text": "因為我剛才聽到副局長所說的就是在某一些部分好像是國安局負責調查的而某一些部分是你們調查局負責調查到底中間的分際為何是境內你們負責境外是他們負責還是怎麼樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147985/13.wav", + "text": "兩個都有涉及只要是違法我們就可以進行調查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147985/14.wav", + "text": "所以只要是違法的即便是境外的你們也要負責是不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147985/15.wav", + "text": "到底你們可以講的部分到哪裡總不能每次到立法院什麼都不講吧是不是還是我們要在國防委員會開秘密會議才可以講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147985/16.wav", + "text": "本局的主要工作當然是維護國安國家安全我們會多方去蒐集一些情報" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147985/17.wav", + "text": "如果涉及到不法的我們就移請調查局及司法機關來偵辦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147985/18.wav", + "text": "我們都知道因為選舉有很多法律的規定除了最近連署的問題以外有時候有期程的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147985/19.wav", + "text": "就是競選活動開始以後有些構造成要件才可以搆得上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147985/20.wav", + "text": "所以有些情資我們是蒐集先前部署與瞭解大概的情形是這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147985/21.wav", + "text": "不是不是連署的期程比較前面所以最近有一些案子就發生了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147985/22.wav", + "text": "如果是像賄選或者是意圖使人不當選那個要更後面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147985/23.wav", + "text": "對可是我的問題是當我們事前的偵辦在沒有充足的情況下也可能會影響到選舉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147985/24.wav", + "text": "但是這都是一個因果論就是如果我們事前沒有儘速偵辦的情況下是不是事後也會影響到選舉的公平性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147985/25.wav", + "text": "我們所蒐集的情報根據它的發展有可能會影響到選舉結果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147985/26.wav", + "text": "這個東西我們就儘早給調查單位了所以就已經有注意或者已經立案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147985/27.wav", + "text": "我想這個部分我們會去判斷" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147985/28.wav", + "text": "\n再來我想要請教一下現在的查賄標準是不是以30元為標準賄" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147985/29.wav", + "text": "賄選的標準到底是要怎麼樣認定才不會讓候選人跟選民誤觸法網" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147985/30.wav", + "text": "謝謝委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147985/31.wav", + "text": "不是絕對的標準但是大家有一個共識就是希望東西不要超過30元是有這樣的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147985/32.wav", + "text": "標準當然也有人建議這個標準是不是要提高但是我們覺得大家都有這樣的共識還是維持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147985/33.wav", + "text": "共餐的話就是看這個行為會不會影響到他投票的意願個案上就由承辦的檢調機關來認定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147985/34.wav", + "text": "超過30元也許我們就懷疑這個是不是有要影響選舉的動機" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147985/35.wav", + "text": "所以我們是用這樣來做門檻的認定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147985/36.wav", + "text": "我相信這不管是檢察官或是在所有的職涯上面都會有相同的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147985/37.wav", + "text": "謝謝委員一直很關心彰化地檢署這一位檢察官他病倒了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147983/0.wav", + "text": "謝謝主席主席麻煩請黃主委" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147983/1.wav", + "text": "第一個問題是關於" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147983/2.wav", + "text": "TWQR的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147983/3.wav", + "text": "剛才已經有委員請教過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147983/4.wav", + "text": "但我只是要先請教主委" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147983/5.wav", + "text": "之所以設立的目的是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147983/6.wav", + "text": "是不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147983/7.wav", + "text": "因為你是要便利消費者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147983/8.wav", + "text": "而不是利用消費者的名義" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147983/9.wav", + "text": "絕對不是這樣的情形" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147983/10.wav", + "text": "當然每一個電支" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147983/11.wav", + "text": "支後面的特店是不一樣的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147983/12.wav", + "text": "沒有這個目的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147983/13.wav", + "text": "絕對不是這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147983/14.wav", + "text": "既然是為了消費者的利益" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147983/15.wav", + "text": "消費者因為你的這個設施" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147983/16.wav", + "text": "會不會需要支付額外的手續費" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147983/17.wav", + "text": "當他掃你的Q" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147983/18.wav", + "text": "QR code的時候他會不會需要支付額外的手續費" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147983/19.wav", + "text": "會還是不會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147983/20.wav", + "text": "應該是依照現況去處理吧" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147983/21.wav", + "text": "現況是什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147983/22.wav", + "text": "就是民眾想要知道的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147983/23.wav", + "text": "今天透過你的這個新的設施" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147983/24.wav", + "text": "消費者的權益" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147983/25.wav", + "text": "有受到影響還是沒有受到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147983/26.wav", + "text": "影響你前面講的是為了消費者的利益他" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147983/27.wav", + "text": "會增加還是不會增加" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147983/28.wav", + "text": "我已經講了第三次了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147983/29.wav", + "text": "沒有啊還是維持現況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147983/30.wav", + "text": "第一個我們從消費者的角度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147983/31.wav", + "text": "第二個我們從業者的角度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147983/32.wav", + "text": "我們看到現在在市占" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147983/33.wav", + "text": "占率上面來講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147983/34.wav", + "text": "其實是街口支付最多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147983/35.wav", + "text": "從交易的行為上面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147983/36.wav", + "text": "是街口支付最多嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147983/37.wav", + "text": "你不知道那我告訴你是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147983/38.wav", + "text": "如果從匯兌的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147983/39.wav", + "text": "跟儲值的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147983/40.wav", + "text": "一卡通是最多的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147983/41.wav", + "text": "所以當今天這個QR code在做的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147983/42.wav", + "text": "這個data將來是進到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147983/43.wav", + "text": "那個地方沒有交易的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147983/44.wav", + "text": "交易資料直接進到各個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147983/45.wav", + "text": "是什麼樣子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147983/46.wav", + "text": "報告委員這個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147983/47.wav", + "text": "最後交易的資料還是會分別進" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147983/48.wav", + "text": "這些電支機構" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147983/49.wav", + "text": "你有沒有拿" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147983/50.wav", + "text": "財金公司有沒有拿" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147983/51.wav", + "text": "當他掃了TWQR的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147983/52.wav", + "text": "財金公司會不會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147983/53.wav", + "text": "有他的交易資料會還是不會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147983/54.wav", + "text": "財財金公司不會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147983/55.wav", + "text": "所以他掃了是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147983/56.wav", + "text": "電子支付端這是你說的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147983/57.wav", + "text": "所以你也不是透過這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147983/58.wav", + "text": "來蒐集資料只是單純的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147983/59.wav", + "text": "為了讓消費者方便而已" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147983/60.wav", + "text": "電子支付端的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147983/61.wav", + "text": "我請教你你有沒有考慮過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147983/62.wav", + "text": "公平交易法裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147983/63.wav", + "text": "之所以會有個聯合行為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147983/64.wav", + "text": "聯合壟斷的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147983/65.wav", + "text": "原來它有它的一個商業安排" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147983/66.wav", + "text": "比如說回饋金是比較多的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147983/67.wav", + "text": "透過TWQR之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147983/68.wav", + "text": "回饋金的部分也是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147983/69.wav", + "text": "讓電子支付自己去處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147983/70.wav", + "text": "掃它它的回饋金就多的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147983/71.wav", + "text": "這個會不會因為TWQR" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147983/72.wav", + "text": "會還是不會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147983/73.wav", + "text": "報告委員不會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147983/74.wav", + "text": "\n第二個問題我要請問你" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147983/75.wav", + "text": "關於純網銀" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147983/76.wav", + "text": "主委你知道純網銀的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147983/77.wav", + "text": "按照銀行法的規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147983/78.wav", + "text": "如果它的虧損達" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147983/79.wav", + "text": "資本三分之一的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147983/80.wav", + "text": "你要在三個月內" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147983/81.wav", + "text": "限期叫它補足資本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147983/82.wav", + "text": "虧損達三分之一的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147983/83.wav", + "text": "目前應該都有即時增資" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147983/84.wav", + "text": "沒有到三分之一的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147983/85.wav", + "text": "目前我們看到1月到6月" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147983/86.wav", + "text": "虧損22億元" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147983/87.wav", + "text": "它還沒有虧損到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147983/88.wav", + "text": "有任何的這個訊息" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147983/89.wav", + "text": "一旦有虧損達三分之一" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147983/90.wav", + "text": "你會按照銀行法的規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147983/91.wav", + "text": "立即的要求它補足對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147983/92.wav", + "text": "那個數目不得了耶" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147983/93.wav", + "text": "所以它的影響層面也會很大" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147983/94.wav", + "text": "對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147983/95.wav", + "text": "所以我已經先提醒你了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147983/96.wav", + "text": "\n第三個問題我要請教的是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147983/97.wav", + "text": "的保費我們看到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147983/98.wav", + "text": "所以對保險公司來說是虧" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147983/99.wav", + "text": "目前的理解業者是不是會調漲保費" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147983/100.wav", + "text": "要看不同的險種" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147983/101.wav", + "text": "它的純保費" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147983/102.wav", + "text": "平均來講是不是會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147983/103.wav", + "text": "其實我是從消費端問的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147983/104.wav", + "text": "會不會刺激物價上漲" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147983/105.wav", + "text": "你現在是預期它會調漲" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147983/106.wav", + "text": "還是預期它不會調漲" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147983/107.wav", + "text": "還是你不知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147983/108.wav", + "text": "通案趨勢上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147983/109.wav", + "text": "有漲的也有跌的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147983/110.wav", + "text": "也不見得通通都漲" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147983/111.wav", + "text": "還會有跌的啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147983/112.wav", + "text": "損失率如果低於百分之百" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147983/113.wav", + "text": "的啊是保險局長跟你講的嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147983/114.wav", + "text": "耶我們看到的是再" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147983/115.wav", + "text": "地緣政治風險的關係" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147983/116.wav", + "text": "它不太願意保" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147983/117.wav", + "text": "媒體上面講的這些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147983/118.wav", + "text": "都是錯的嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147983/119.wav", + "text": "不是每一種險種都有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147983/120.wav", + "text": "不要用那個東西來講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147983/121.wav", + "text": "嘛當然沒有百分之百的事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147983/122.wav", + "text": "可是一個趨勢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147983/123.wav", + "text": "跟會不會有這樣的情形" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147983/124.wav", + "text": "對老百姓來講是有關的主委" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147983/125.wav", + "text": "我真的要很誠懇的拜託你" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147983/126.wav", + "text": "事實必須要先讓民間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147983/127.wav", + "text": "知道原因是什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147983/128.wav", + "text": "因為不是只有你要做政策規劃" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147983/129.wav", + "text": "民間也要做因應" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147983/130.wav", + "text": "啊對產業界來講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147983/131.wav", + "text": "要調漲保費這也是一種" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147983/132.wav", + "text": "能只要它是事實啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147983/133.wav", + "text": "但是你不能夠不讓民間知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147983/134.wav", + "text": "今天再保公司的確" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147983/135.wav", + "text": "是有因為地緣政治的關係" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147983/136.wav", + "text": "對不對局長也點頭啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147983/137.wav", + "text": "所以你在這個時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147983/138.wav", + "text": "說要看各類的保險" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147983/139.wav", + "text": "那當然啊誰不知道各類" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147983/140.wav", + "text": "的保險不一樣它的保費也不一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147983/141.wav", + "text": "有些是不會調漲的對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147983/142.wav", + "text": "但我是說一般來講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147983/143.wav", + "text": "現在面臨這樣的情況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147983/144.wav", + "text": "保費會不會上漲" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147983/145.wav", + "text": "主委你真的不需要讓我在這邊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147983/146.wav", + "text": "保費上漲之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147983/147.wav", + "text": "是不是就影響產業界" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147983/148.wav", + "text": "對消費端的部分它的產品" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147983/149.wav", + "text": "服務當然就會上漲" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147983/150.wav", + "text": "就是這麼簡單的問題我們需要這樣講嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147983/151.wav", + "text": "請局長說明一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147983/152.wav", + "text": "報告委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147983/153.wav", + "text": "有沒有因為地緣政治" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147983/154.wav", + "text": "的關係再保公司調漲" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147983/155.wav", + "text": "他們的保費或者不願意保" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147983/156.wav", + "text": "問題就這麼簡單而已" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147983/157.wav", + "text": "需要拖這麼久嗎如果是再保" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147983/158.wav", + "text": "它是的確會嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147983/159.wav", + "text": "一樣關於保險業務的部分有關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147983/160.wav", + "text": "訊息上面講說你會把" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147983/161.wav", + "text": "調降請問我們現在有單一窗口" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147983/162.wav", + "text": "的申訴管道嗎還是沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147983/163.wav", + "text": "第一我們沒有調降" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147983/164.wav", + "text": "代收保費現金所以那個是錯的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147983/165.wav", + "text": "所以還是一樣是5萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147983/166.wav", + "text": "是不是好最起碼你" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147983/167.wav", + "text": "釐清了這很好嘛第二個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147983/168.wav", + "text": "不肖業者你們現在是用什麼方式來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147983/169.wav", + "text": "解決這個問題讓他不會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147983/170.wav", + "text": "再有挪用的情形呢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147983/171.wav", + "text": "就是內控的機制部分來強化" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147983/172.wav", + "text": "透過內控機制強化那都是在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147983/173.wav", + "text": "事發之後解決還是能夠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147983/174.wav", + "text": "阻擋於事情發" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147983/175.wav", + "text": "事前也要做請局長說明對事前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147983/176.wav", + "text": "要用什麼方式解決讓" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147983/177.wav", + "text": "挪用報告委員我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147983/178.wav", + "text": "原來有訂一個業務員挪用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147983/179.wav", + "text": "部分我們今年有做檢討就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147983/180.wav", + "text": "看那個就是看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147983/181.wav", + "text": "那個態樣我們要求保險公司" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147983/182.wav", + "text": "對自行繳費件" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147983/183.wav", + "text": "如果保戶三個月" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147983/184.wav", + "text": "是不是不是這個跟挪用有什麼關係" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147983/185.wav", + "text": "因為這樣我現在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147983/186.wav", + "text": "不肖業者挪用你的回答" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147983/187.wav", + "text": "反而是說在什麼情形下要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147983/188.wav", + "text": "去關懷所以他可以挪用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147983/189.wav", + "text": "不是他去關懷之後就知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147983/190.wav", + "text": "到底這個錢有沒有繳進來是不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147983/191.wav", + "text": "被業務員挪用走了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147983/192.wav", + "text": "是從這邊好是三個月" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147983/193.wav", + "text": "那你有單一窗口申訴管道嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147983/194.wav", + "text": "每一家公司都有一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147983/195.wav", + "text": "專門的所以你沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147983/196.wav", + "text": "單一窗口的申訴管道OK" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147983/197.wav", + "text": "懂那這樣子怎麼防患" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147983/198.wav", + "text": "於未然" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147983/199.wav", + "text": "呢我的問題是你應該去防範" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147983/200.wav", + "text": "而不是等到事情發生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147983/201.wav", + "text": "對不對我下一個問題要請教" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147983/202.wav", + "text": "教高資產客戶的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147983/203.wav", + "text": "還是一樣是保險" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147983/204.wav", + "text": "合計高達600多人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147983/205.wav", + "text": "高達7009百多億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147983/206.wav", + "text": "對這些高資產客戶" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147983/207.wav", + "text": "公股銀行是用加薪6" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147983/208.wav", + "text": "過去這幾年的裁罰" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147983/209.wav", + "text": "應該對整個風氣是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147983/210.wav", + "text": "有一些矯正的作用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147983/211.wav", + "text": "高資產的客戶來講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147983/212.wav", + "text": "因為我剛剛問" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147983/213.wav", + "text": "你要怎麼去控管不要告訴" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147983/214.wav", + "text": "我說問題發生了你去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147983/215.wav", + "text": "他移送到檢調部門而已" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147983/216.wav", + "text": "負責的就是要避免事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147983/217.wav", + "text": "發生要避免於未然" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147983/218.wav", + "text": "不是嗎我們審查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147983/219.wav", + "text": "的時候有責任地圖將來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147983/220.wav", + "text": "出了事負責任的主管要負責" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147983/221.wav", + "text": "但那個都是事後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147983/222.wav", + "text": "嘛我講的是你應該在事前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147983/223.wav", + "text": "我們有檢查的機制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147983/224.wav", + "text": "提出來的事情將來都不會發生我不敢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147983/225.wav", + "text": "說百分之百但是我們會記取" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147983/226.wav", + "text": "以前理專弊端的原因" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147983/227.wav", + "text": "對高端資產的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147983/228.wav", + "text": "強化那我們在國會殿堂裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147983/229.wav", + "text": "講的不等於是白講嘛因為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147983/230.wav", + "text": "講了之後你還是按照以前的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147983/231.wav", + "text": "配息的禁令" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147983/232.wav", + "text": "據說你是要放寬是不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147983/233.wav", + "text": "金控的部分你要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147983/234.wav", + "text": "是可以發給股東我要請教" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147983/235.wav", + "text": "這個是限制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147983/236.wav", + "text": "你不是要放寬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147983/237.wav", + "text": "公司跟一般公司是不一樣的呢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147983/238.wav", + "text": "金融機構跟一般公司" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147983/239.wav", + "text": "是受高度監理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147983/240.wav", + "text": "所以它會比一般公司嚴" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147983/241.wav", + "text": "你所謂的限制很好很好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147983/242.wav", + "text": "所以你並不是要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147983/243.wav", + "text": "放寬你是要限制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147983/244.wav", + "text": "OK那你所謂的限制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147983/245.wav", + "text": "民間知道它跟一般公司" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147983/246.wav", + "text": "的差異性在哪裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147983/247.wav", + "text": "為什麼一般公司可以做金控" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147983/248.wav", + "text": "因為我們看到這個訊息的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147983/249.wav", + "text": "很擔心為什麼很擔心就是說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147983/250.wav", + "text": "欸這個是配合炒股嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147983/251.wav", + "text": "還是是怎麼樣但是今天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147983/252.wav", + "text": "謝謝主委就是沒有這樣的情形" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147983/253.wav", + "text": "你其實不是要放寬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147983/254.wav", + "text": "一般公司可以做的它" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147983/255.wav", + "text": "不行做是不是好謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147982/0.wav", + "text": "主席好有請薛部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147982/1.wav", + "text": "請部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147982/2.wav", + "text": "部長你好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147982/3.wav", + "text": "我相信你一定聽我們講過好多次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147982/4.wav", + "text": "少子化其實是國安危機" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147982/5.wav", + "text": "孩子已經生得少的情況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147982/6.wav", + "text": "之下我們更希望的是一個都不能少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147982/7.wav", + "text": "可是實際上依照國民健康署的統計資料" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147982/8.wav", + "text": "從2012年的23萬到2021年的15.8萬這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147982/9.wav", + "text": "已經是銳減" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147982/10.wav", + "text": "去年更是低於15萬大約是十三點多萬的情況在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147982/11.wav", + "text": "出生率已經很低的情況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147982/12.wav", + "text": "從2012年的百分之九點多到現在是10.61%" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147982/13.wav", + "text": "總共有一萬六千多個孩子是早產兒\n在這個狀況之下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147982/14.wav", + "text": "其實遠高於OECD國家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147982/15.wav", + "text": "而臺灣是千分之四點四" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147982/16.wav", + "text": "意思就是說每1,000個出生時有生命的孩子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147982/17.wav", + "text": "大約有4位會在28天內死亡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147982/18.wav", + "text": "包括您自己也曾經說新生兒的死亡與早產有關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147982/19.wav", + "text": "當然跟遺傳有一部分的關係" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147982/20.wav", + "text": "但是也有一部分是跟早產的比例有相當大的關係" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147982/21.wav", + "text": "在臺灣新生兒死亡原因和早產息息相關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147982/22.wav", + "text": "早產兒的出生比例已經不低了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147982/23.wav", + "text": "而且早產又是新生兒死亡常見的原因之一" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147982/24.wav", + "text": "有一半以上極低體重的早產兒需要靠呼吸器來維持呼吸" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147982/25.wav", + "text": "而早產兒的合併症像黃膽" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147982/26.wav", + "text": "晶狀體後纖維化導致失明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147982/27.wav", + "text": "又或者是臚內出血的影響導致神經傷害" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147982/28.wav", + "text": "都很需要非常多的醫療照顧" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147982/29.wav", + "text": "\n可是我們也看到面對早產兒可能遇到的種種健康問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147982/30.wav", + "text": "早產兒需要更多的營養介入" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147982/31.wav", + "text": "包括藥品的部分和營養的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147982/32.wav", + "text": "光是在醫藥的部分有很多時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147982/33.wav", + "text": "為了希望能讓他們有更足夠的營養" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147982/34.wav", + "text": "他們的營養需求其實也非常多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147982/35.wav", + "text": "舉例來說為了要治療視網膜病變" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147982/36.wav", + "text": "早產兒所需要的眼內注射藥品" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147982/37.wav", + "text": "而且視情況可能需要施打一到三劑" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147982/38.wav", + "text": "為了增加他的卡路里或者是營養攝取" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147982/39.wav", + "text": "醫生也會增加他相對應的營養" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147982/40.wav", + "text": "以母乳添加劑來說每一盒大概是2,000元" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147982/41.wav", + "text": "預估至少要增加2個月大約是10盒" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147982/42.wav", + "text": "所以整體來說我們所看到的統計數據" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147982/43.wav", + "text": "早產兒的家庭支出約為足月兒的5倍左右" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147982/44.wav", + "text": "也就是高出4倍" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147982/45.wav", + "text": "雖然政府說0到6歲國家養" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147982/46.wav", + "text": "我們也看到有持續在精進" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147982/47.wav", + "text": "希望大家養兒育女的負擔能夠減輕" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147982/48.wav", + "text": "可是對早產兒家庭來說負擔仍然非常沉重" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147982/49.wav", + "text": "所以想請教部長早產兒的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147982/50.wav", + "text": "我們是不是應該考慮有一些相對應的政策" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147982/51.wav", + "text": "相對應的措施讓他們能夠比較輕鬆" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147982/52.wav", + "text": "我們希望在少子化的情況之下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147982/53.wav", + "text": "每一個孩子的出生更不應該失去他的生命" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147982/54.wav", + "text": "我們應該持續協助讓他能夠好好活下去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147982/55.wav", + "text": "跟委員報告有關於這個議題的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147982/56.wav", + "text": "疫苗的部分應該是沒有問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147982/57.wav", + "text": "因為他本來的疫苗就是國家公務預算在處理的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147982/58.wav", + "text": "尤其這些嬰兒的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147982/59.wav", + "text": "這算的是自費的比例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147982/60.wav", + "text": "喔所以是非常高的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147982/61.wav", + "text": "所以這個部分我跟委員報告我們會來做檢討" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147982/62.wav", + "text": "我回去會更深入地去了解" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147982/63.wav", + "text": "因為理論上來講大部分是健保會cover" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147982/64.wav", + "text": "滿多藥品和補充品的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147982/65.wav", + "text": "健保應該是沒有cover" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147982/66.wav", + "text": "這我再了解一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147982/67.wav", + "text": "如果說有這樣的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147982/68.wav", + "text": "那我們應該是要把它納進來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147982/69.wav", + "text": "我知道對於一些中低收入戶" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147982/70.wav", + "text": "其實是有給予一些補助比較多的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147982/71.wav", + "text": "可是以11萬來說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147982/72.wav", + "text": "其實對於中低收入戶" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147982/73.wav", + "text": "或者是對一般家庭來說都是非常非常" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147982/74.wav", + "text": "藥品是沒有理由排除在健保之外" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147982/75.wav", + "text": "剛剛提到像眼內注射藥品" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147982/76.wav", + "text": "就是自費項目" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147982/77.wav", + "text": "一支大概就是三萬五到四萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147982/78.wav", + "text": "所以我說我再來了解一下看看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147982/79.wav", + "text": "好我們希望至少部長能夠看見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147982/80.wav", + "text": "早產兒家庭可能遇到沉重的負擔" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147982/81.wav", + "text": "我們也看到早產導致新生兒" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147982/82.wav", + "text": "死亡的部分是非常直接的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147982/83.wav", + "text": "如果我們能夠讓這些早產兒" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147982/84.wav", + "text": "家庭有足夠的支持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147982/85.wav", + "text": "讓這些早產兒受到適當的協助之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147982/86.wav", + "text": "能夠健康地生活下去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147982/87.wav", + "text": "其實有一個原因就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147982/88.wav", + "text": "然後產婦的平均年齡也變高" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147982/89.wav", + "text": "產婦高齡化的話就容易會有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147982/90.wav", + "text": "我們了解但是我們希望既然他" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147982/91.wav", + "text": "經是早產兒的情況之下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147982/92.wav", + "text": "也希望能夠給予他適當的協助" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147982/93.wav", + "text": "因為這個負擔是非常沉重的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147982/94.wav", + "text": "我要再次強調所以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147982/95.wav", + "text": "我們很希望國家也能夠針對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147982/96.wav", + "text": "早產兒的部分給予實際上的協助" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147982/97.wav", + "text": "我們回去再來盤一" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147982/98.wav", + "text": "是不是能夠在一個月內" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147982/99.wav", + "text": "給我們一個初步的分析" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147982/100.wav", + "text": "和可能的方向" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147982/101.wav", + "text": "好謝謝部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147982/102.wav", + "text": "\n接下來要談居家托育的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147982/103.wav", + "text": "我們看到現在大家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147982/104.wav", + "text": "在雙薪家庭的情況之下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147982/105.wav", + "text": "的確很希望能夠增加外送托率" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147982/106.wav", + "text": "這也是國家一直努力的方向" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147982/107.wav", + "text": "增加公幼增加公托等等的方向" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147982/108.wav", + "text": "可是以實際上來說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147982/109.wav", + "text": "現在0到2歲的外送托率" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147982/110.wav", + "text": "大概只有17%" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147982/111.wav", + "text": "其實仍然是非常低的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147982/112.wav", + "text": "我們看到其中有一個問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147982/113.wav", + "text": "在這邊跟部長做個報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147982/114.wav", + "text": "在居家托育的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147982/115.wav", + "text": "2歲以上也可以收另外2位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147982/116.wav", + "text": "可是以現狀來說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147982/117.wav", + "text": "其實是相對應比較充足的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147982/118.wav", + "text": "所以2歲以上幾乎都會去幼兒園" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147982/119.wav", + "text": "所以基本上居家托育" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147982/120.wav", + "text": "收托的大概都是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147982/121.wav", + "text": "0到2歲的程度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147982/122.wav", + "text": "這也是符合我們希望能夠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147982/123.wav", + "text": "增加0到2歲的外送托率" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147982/124.wav", + "text": "但是以現在實際上來說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147982/125.wav", + "text": "他能夠收2位0到2歲的情況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147982/126.wav", + "text": "但是他這樣實際上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147982/127.wav", + "text": "也只能收到大概三萬二左右的費用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147982/128.wav", + "text": "其實對於托育人員來說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147982/129.wav", + "text": "是很不夠他們的生活費的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147982/130.wav", + "text": "所以我們希望這部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147982/131.wav", + "text": "能夠持續來做努力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147982/132.wav", + "text": "同時我們也看到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147982/133.wav", + "text": "2萬7,000名的居家托育人員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147982/134.wav", + "text": "有6成是超過50歲的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147982/135.wav", + "text": "有2成是超過60歲的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147982/136.wav", + "text": "的年齡高齡化的情況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147982/137.wav", + "text": "是越來越嚴重的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147982/138.wav", + "text": "但是新進來的人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147982/139.wav", + "text": "卻是越來越少的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147982/140.wav", + "text": "原因就在於" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147982/141.wav", + "text": "他如果加入托育人員的行列當中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147982/142.wav", + "text": "一個月可能只能收到三萬二的收入" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147982/143.wav", + "text": "這樣子其實很難" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147982/144.wav", + "text": "有一個長期的可能性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147982/145.wav", + "text": "因為的確不太容易生活下去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147982/146.wav", + "text": "所以我們希望在這部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147982/147.wav", + "text": "是不是能夠實際來考量" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147982/148.wav", + "text": "0到2歲的外送托率" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147982/149.wav", + "text": "也應該把居家人員的部分考納進去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147982/150.wav", + "text": "好這個部分我們再來盤一下看看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147982/151.wav", + "text": "這主要的點是說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147982/152.wav", + "text": "我們現在外送" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147982/153.wav", + "text": "我們希望提高" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147982/154.wav", + "text": "但是提高要提高在哪一個部門" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147982/155.wav", + "text": "是托嬰中心比較好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147982/156.wav", + "text": "部長說得很好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147982/157.wav", + "text": "其實我們就是也看不到這部分的資料" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147982/158.wav", + "text": "所以也想請教一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147982/159.wav", + "text": "國家的政策" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147982/160.wav", + "text": "托嬰中心機構裡面的托育" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147982/161.wav", + "text": "跟居家托育等方向和目標是什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147982/162.wav", + "text": "是不是也能夠有一個具體的規劃" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147982/163.wav", + "text": "但是實際上現狀" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147982/164.wav", + "text": "的確需要居家托育的人員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147982/165.wav", + "text": "來協助增加外送托" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147982/166.wav", + "text": "所以這部分要一起來做考量" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147982/167.wav", + "text": "啦如果國家政策是希望" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147982/168.wav", + "text": "居家托育的部分是一個補充性的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147982/169.wav", + "text": "就是變成兩個之間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147982/170.wav", + "text": "要怎麼樣搭配的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147982/171.wav", + "text": "但如果說居家托育是一個主力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147982/172.wav", + "text": "因為這樣子人力才夠的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147982/173.wav", + "text": "那個方法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147982/174.wav", + "text": "我想不論它是主力或是協力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147982/175.wav", + "text": "都會看得到它實際上面對的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147982/176.wav", + "text": "就是他作為一個居家托育人員的情況下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147982/177.wav", + "text": "他可能的月薪最多大概就是三萬二左右" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147982/178.wav", + "text": "其實這是非常難以給予協力的人力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147982/179.wav", + "text": "所以你一邊補得很高" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147982/180.wav", + "text": "如果一邊沒有動的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147982/181.wav", + "text": "那人力就會往另外一邊去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147982/182.wav", + "text": "是部長你說得很清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147982/183.wav", + "text": "所以我們很希望有兩個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147982/184.wav", + "text": "能夠實際來做處理和討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147982/185.wav", + "text": "第一個是我們國家對於" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147982/186.wav", + "text": "0到2歲的外送托率目標到什麼程度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147982/187.wav", + "text": "以及在這個目標之下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147982/188.wav", + "text": "我們希望在機構以及居家的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147982/189.wav", + "text": "大概是多少的比例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147982/190.wav", + "text": "我們長遠的規劃才有辦法知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147982/191.wav", + "text": "我們如何來做調配" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147982/192.wav", + "text": "但是現狀上也要跟部長報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147982/193.wav", + "text": "現在的確少不了居家托育人員的協助" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147982/194.wav", + "text": "這樣的情況下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147982/195.wav", + "text": "是不是應該給予他們足夠的薪水" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147982/196.wav", + "text": "有養活自己的可能性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147982/197.wav", + "text": "才有辦法讓他們願意來投入" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147982/198.wav", + "text": "所以我希望就這兩個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147982/199.wav", + "text": "都���夠有實際的討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147982/200.wav", + "text": "另外一邊就要考慮了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147982/201.wav", + "text": "所以這中間的平衡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147982/202.wav", + "text": "我們還是必須要去顧及" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147982/203.wav", + "text": "我們一起來看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147982/204.wav", + "text": "好所以想請教" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147982/205.wav", + "text": "是不是能夠在一個月內" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147982/206.wav", + "text": "也告訴我們國家的政策到底是什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147982/207.wav", + "text": "雖然我知道一直有在研議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147982/208.wav", + "text": "但是一直沒有看到具體的方向" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147982/209.wav", + "text": "0到2歲的外送托" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147982/210.wav", + "text": "我們希望機構有多少比例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147982/211.wav", + "text": "我們希望居家有多少比例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147982/212.wav", + "text": "兩個月好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147982/213.wav", + "text": "好兩個月" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147982/214.wav", + "text": "第二個部分是居家托育的狀況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147982/215.wav", + "text": "現狀是如此" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147982/216.wav", + "text": "我們如何讓" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/0.wav", + "text": "主席各位首長各位同仁大家好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/1.wav", + "text": "我們對於立法院職權行使" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/2.wav", + "text": "法務部跟相關單位調查中案件" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/3.wav", + "text": "我們先做一下說明也給部長說明一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/4.wav", + "text": "我剛才一開始就說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/5.wav", + "text": "我很樂見王鴻薇委員在立法院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/6.wav", + "text": "直接把證據資料拿出來檢舉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/7.wav", + "text": "讓你們可以調查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/8.wav", + "text": "當初如果馬文君委員在國防委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/9.wav", + "text": "拿到潛艦及其他的國防機密資料" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/10.wav", + "text": "通通用這種方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/11.wav", + "text": "處理他不但有言論免責權" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/12.wav", + "text": "也可能幫國家檢舉一些弊案就很好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/13.wav", + "text": "怎麼會偷偷摸摸的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/14.wav", + "text": "還想要轉手外交部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/15.wav", + "text": "還要轉手法務部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/16.wav", + "text": "然後給韓國的代表處" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/17.wav", + "text": "那個方法就不對嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/18.wav", + "text": "而且那個是國防機密" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/19.wav", + "text": "針對任何案件在立法院裡面提供資料檢舉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/20.wav", + "text": "我都沒有意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/21.wav", + "text": "但是檢舉之後我們的目的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/22.wav", + "text": "就是讓它立案調查對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/23.wav", + "text": "部長我應該沒有理解錯" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/24.wav", + "text": "嘛剛才您收了案件之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/25.wav", + "text": "是不是就可以立案調查了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/26.wav", + "text": "調查我能轉達給有權調查的單位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/27.wav", + "text": "總不能說立法院提供的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/28.wav", + "text": "王鴻薇委員提供的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/29.wav", + "text": "那個袋子裡面完全沒東西" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/30.wav", + "text": "虛晃一招" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/31.wav", + "text": "假按鈴申告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/32.wav", + "text": "根本沒按下去也不會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/33.wav", + "text": "在這邊就負責" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/34.wav", + "text": "嘛有直播有媒體" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/35.wav", + "text": "不管召委跟在場的委員怎麼要求" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/36.wav", + "text": "你總是偵查不公開" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/37.wav", + "text": "不能影響辦案程序" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/38.wav", + "text": "包含剛剛副局長所講的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/39.wav", + "text": "有些調查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/40.wav", + "text": "譬如說你公開了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/41.wav", + "text": "某一些可能性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/42.wav", + "text": "比較敏感" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/43.wav", + "text": "老實講是我們的線民" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/44.wav", + "text": "你只要知道哪一個線索" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/45.wav", + "text": "就可以抓到哪一個人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/46.wav", + "text": "整個布局就沒了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/47.wav", + "text": "所以有些東西可報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/48.wav", + "text": "有些東西不能報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/49.wav", + "text": "但是我都相信檢察官跟法院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/50.wav", + "text": "我的態度是這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/51.wav", + "text": "我非常尊重的林思銘召委" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/52.wav", + "text": "政治作秀完了就結束沒有關係" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/53.wav", + "text": "馬文君就是不如王鴻薇我認為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/54.wav", + "text": "作秀不夠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/55.wav", + "text": "不然在這邊檢舉就好了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/56.wav", + "text": "嘛結果你這樣下去之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/57.wav", + "text": "還要再來這邊報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/58.wav", + "text": "我們比照辦理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/59.wav", + "text": "曾銘宗總召" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/60.wav", + "text": "他是受害者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/61.wav", + "text": "手下就有三個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/62.wav", + "text": "他害了曾總召用他的威望" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/63.wav", + "text": "去做假帳號" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/64.wav", + "text": "去攻擊別人自導自演" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/65.wav", + "text": "他是受害者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/66.wav", + "text": "我用受害者的角度來看他" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/67.wav", + "text": "因為已經收押禁見了嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/68.wav", + "text": "嘛這個案件你也做相同的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/69.wav", + "text": "鑑識跟調查報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/70.wav", + "text": "這是第一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/71.wav", + "text": "第二個對於馬文君委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/72.wav", + "text": "這個案子你們一定分案了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/73.wav", + "text": "嘛不管在誰" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/74.wav", + "text": "手上你也做相同的調查報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/75.wav", + "text": "在立法院裡面公開" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/76.wav", + "text": "部長你可以這樣做嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/77.wav", + "text": "所以這個是分寸原則" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/78.wav", + "text": "跟政黨無關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/79.wav", + "text": "如果大家在政治上攻防" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/80.wav", + "text": "我叫幾個人來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/81.wav", + "text": "這樣子沒完沒了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/82.wav", + "text": "所以這也是兩個黨團之間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/83.wav", + "text": "你要講你的沒關係" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/84.wav", + "text": "但是如果破了那個分際" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/85.wav", + "text": "\n部長我有一個權宜的方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/86.wav", + "text": "不管鑑識的結果怎麼樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/87.wav", + "text": "答應了委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/88.wav", + "text": "或者任何機關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/89.wav", + "text": "你們可以說明的案情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/90.wav", + "text": "這樣可以嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/91.wav", + "text": "這是你們的職權" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/92.wav", + "text": "你去分類一下哪一些可以公開" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/93.wav", + "text": "因為偵查不公開" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/94.wav", + "text": "你們也有你們的裁量權" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/95.wav", + "text": "有一些社會矚目案件" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/96.wav", + "text": "我總是知道現在的進度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/97.wav", + "text": "啊這幾個案子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/98.wav", + "text": "你們法務部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/99.wav", + "text": "自己權衡可以公開哪些部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/100.wav", + "text": "是受害人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/101.wav", + "text": "這個案件" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/102.wav", + "text": "公開說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/103.wav", + "text": "你們去公開不要來立法院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/104.wav", + "text": "第二個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/105.wav", + "text": "許哲賓目前的調查結果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/106.wav", + "text": "你們去公開說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/107.wav", + "text": "第三個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/108.wav", + "text": "馬文君委員涉及" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/109.wav", + "text": "洩漏國防機密的案情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/110.wav", + "text": "你們公開說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/111.wav", + "text": "這樣可以嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/112.wav", + "text": "部長在你們的場合不要來立法院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/113.wav", + "text": "我們這邊負責檢舉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/114.wav", + "text": "不然你就要動用到立法院的調查權" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/115.wav", + "text": "那就大家來談沒有關係" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/116.wav", + "text": "正式來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/117.wav", + "text": "這也表示對每一個偵查個案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/118.wav", + "text": "跟每一個受害者的尊重" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/119.wav", + "text": "有的人是受害者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/120.wav", + "text": "啊我都認為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/121.wav", + "text": "是你們這個許姓黨工害死你了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/122.wav", + "text": "對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/123.wav", + "text": "都要以這個角度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/124.wav", + "text": "沒有判決之前都是受害者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/125.wav", + "text": "嘛所以我覺得檢舉很好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/126.wav", + "text": "但是我們不要破了這個原則" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/127.wav", + "text": "他已經讓步" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/128.wav", + "text": "這三個事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/129.wav", + "text": "王鴻薇委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/130.wav", + "text": "在這裡檢舉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/131.wav", + "text": "鄭運鵬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/132.wav", + "text": "那個鄭文燦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/133.wav", + "text": "他沒檢舉你喔" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/134.wav", + "text": "我是你的受害者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/135.wav", + "text": "你剛剛加害於我還直播" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/136.wav", + "text": "他檢舉鄭文燦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/137.wav", + "text": "所以這只" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/138.wav", + "text": "只是要讓他鑑定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/139.wav", + "text": "鑑定這個影片是真假" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/140.wav", + "text": "嘛也沒有談到後面到底" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/141.wav", + "text": "偵查的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/142.wav", + "text": "嘛那有關另外的案子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/143.wav", + "text": "趙天麟的案子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/144.wav", + "text": "他已經接受了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/145.wav", + "text": "嘛你假設還要扯另外兩個案子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/146.wav", + "text": "OK啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/147.wav", + "text": "再扯" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/148.wav", + "text": "來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/149.wav", + "text": "現在是我的發言時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/150.wav", + "text": "沒關係" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/151.wav", + "text": "我是覺得OK" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/152.wav", + "text": "以後我們互相發言" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/153.wav", + "text": "互相質詢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/154.wav", + "text": "我覺得也很好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/155.wav", + "text": "啦我不知道你有沒有誤解到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/156.wav", + "text": "王鴻薇委員的意圖" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/157.wav", + "text": "喔我認為他是檢舉案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/158.wav", + "text": "但是他為什麼檢舉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/159.wav", + "text": "能不能立案這是另外一件事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/160.wav", + "text": "你認為他只是送個影片給人家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/161.wav", + "text": "但你要鑑識在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/162.wav", + "text": "立法院提出" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/163.wav", + "text": "你就是想影射" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/164.wav", + "text": "嘛你就是想要破壞" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/165.wav", + "text": "鄭文燦副院長的名聲" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/166.wav", + "text": "嘛鄭文燦公開說那不是他啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/167.wav", + "text": "你硬要送" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/168.wav", + "text": "我覺得OK" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/169.wav", + "text": "最後鑑定出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/170.wav", + "text": "一定是很模糊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/171.wav", + "text": "有剪接" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/172.wav", + "text": "說不定沒變造" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/173.wav", + "text": "這我不知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/174.wav", + "text": "他可能是這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/175.wav", + "text": "下指導棋喔" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/176.wav", + "text": "我哪下指導棋" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/177.wav", + "text": "我相信鄭文燦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/178.wav", + "text": "我相信鄭文燦的說法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/179.wav", + "text": "怎麼會下指導棋" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/180.wav", + "text": "對啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/181.wav", + "text": "都還沒鑑定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/182.wav", + "text": "在對我下指導棋" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/183.wav", + "text": "對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/184.wav", + "text": "啦我覺得大家可以信任" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/185.wav", + "text": "委員之間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/186.wav", + "text": "就算不同政黨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/187.wav", + "text": "有不同政治傾向" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/188.wav", + "text": "對每個事件" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/189.wav", + "text": "有不同解讀" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/190.wav", + "text": "我都尊重" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/191.wav", + "text": "但是立法院的原則" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/192.wav", + "text": "跟國會行使職權的分際" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/193.wav", + "text": "剛在王鴻薇委員質詢完之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/194.wav", + "text": "所要求的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/195.wav", + "text": "我也有跟召委報告過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/196.wav", + "text": "我希望大家可以理解" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/197.wav", + "text": "所以如果都提報調查報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/198.wav", + "text": "OK" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/199.wav", + "text": "但是我請法務部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/200.wav", + "text": "不能夠變成政治惡鬥的工具" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/201.wav", + "text": "全部都立案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/202.wav", + "text": "你們在你們的場合裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/203.wav", + "text": "我認為都影響公義" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/204.wav", + "text": "可以有300個假帳號" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/205.wav", + "text": "對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/206.wav", + "text": "這個當然是公義" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/207.wav", + "text": "運鵬哪來的300個假帳號" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/208.wav", + "text": "不要亂說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/209.wav", + "text": "你們看的是報紙寫的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/210.wav", + "text": "我看的也是報紙寫的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/211.wav", + "text": "報紙寫的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/212.wav", + "text": "所以有沒有假帳號" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/213.wav", + "text": "你看你是受害者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/214.wav", + "text": "你都質疑了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/215.wav", + "text": "法務部一起公開" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/216.wav", + "text": "OK對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/217.wav", + "text": "我沒問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/218.wav", + "text": "好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/219.wav", + "text": "來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/220.wav", + "text": "總召你插我的話插到變習慣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/221.wav", + "text": "好啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/222.wav", + "text": "今天我覺得在論辯選舉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/223.wav", + "text": "介入選舉其實是這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/224.wav", + "text": "召委也聽到我的要求了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/225.wav", + "text": "全部都在你們的場合報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/226.wav", + "text": "這是我的要求" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/227.wav", + "text": "那你可以答應我" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/228.wav", + "text": "不需要委員會決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/229.wav", + "text": "我說明一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/230.wav", + "text": "我不會對個案去做評論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/231.wav", + "text": "或是做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/232.wav", + "text": "不是評論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/233.wav", + "text": "去公布進度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/234.wav", + "text": "對公布" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/235.wav", + "text": "也不能公布偵查的內容" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/236.wav", + "text": "啊我要尊重偵辦單位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/237.wav", + "text": "他們的職權" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/238.wav", + "text": "所以在偵辦中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/239.wav", + "text": "在不違反偵查不公開的情況之下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/240.wav", + "text": "他如何公布案情的內容" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/241.wav", + "text": "那由他來做決定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/242.wav", + "text": "不是由法務部來指導" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/243.wav", + "text": "或來干預" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/244.wav", + "text": "或是來這邊報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/245.wav", + "text": "我想我們的態度很清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/246.wav", + "text": "法務部是做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/247.wav", + "text": "檢察行政部分的說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/248.wav", + "text": "嘛政策面我來說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/249.wav", + "text": "我來負責" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/250.wav", + "text": "但是個案的處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/251.wav", + "text": "我尊重檢調單位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/252.wav", + "text": "他們處理的職權" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/253.wav", + "text": "那這樣總召" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/254.wav", + "text": "法務部這樣的原則你們接受嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/255.wav", + "text": "我多次質詢要法務部提統計" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/256.wav", + "text": "跟報告調查他們有沒有違反" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/257.wav", + "text": "偵查不公開的原則" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/258.wav", + "text": "某些不肖檢察官會用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/259.wav", + "text": "他的權勢去透露一些資料給媒體" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/260.wav", + "text": "某種程度是迫害" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/261.wav", + "text": "到最後可能無罪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/262.wav", + "text": "嘛某種程度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/263.wav", + "text": "結果不是這回事" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/264.wav", + "text": "所以大家說無罪推定原則" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/265.wav", + "text": "偵查不公開的原則" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/266.wav", + "text": "對於法務部偵辦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/267.wav", + "text": "有時候會破壞掉他們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/268.wav", + "text": "布建的內容" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/269.wav", + "text": "這些東西都要尊重" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/270.wav", + "text": "法務部長的原則" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/271.wav", + "text": "大家有沒有意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/272.wav", + "text": "大家說好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/273.wav", + "text": "嘛對於剛才王鴻薇委員所提的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/274.wav", + "text": "那幾個案子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/275.wav", + "text": "運鵬我知道你的意思啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/276.wav", + "text": "我想其實今天王鴻薇委員會提出" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/277.wav", + "text": "希望能夠鑑定它的真偽" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/278.wav", + "text": "現在社會大眾都在關心這個案子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/279.wav", + "text": "事關鄭文燦副院長的清白" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/280.wav", + "text": "如果認為他是清白" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/281.wav", + "text": "法務部就我們剛才的決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/282.wav", + "text": "如果法務部認為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/283.wav", + "text": "未來你們鑑識出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/284.wav", + "text": "哪部分是不能公開的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/285.wav", + "text": "基於偵查不公開的原則" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/286.wav", + "text": "我想你們有你們的分際嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/287.wav", + "text": "你們只要在提供給" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/288.wav", + "text": "本委員會的書面報告裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/289.wav", + "text": "詳細的告訴我們所有委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/290.wav", + "text": "這部分依據偵查不公開的原則" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/291.wav", + "text": "已經有彈性給法務部我的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/292.wav", + "text": "發言時間你要講話要經過我同意好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/293.wav", + "text": "由法務部依照他的分際" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/294.wav", + "text": "際去做決定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/295.wav", + "text": "這個案子其實我不曉得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/296.wav", + "text": "啦我對鄭文燦很有信心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/297.wav", + "text": "你不要擔心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/298.wav", + "text": "我剛剛就講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/299.wav", + "text": "我完全相信鄭文燦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/300.wav", + "text": "我對鄭文燦很有信心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/301.wav", + "text": "總召的信心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/302.wav", + "text": "我對他當然有信心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/303.wav", + "text": "但是不能因為總召對他有信心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/304.wav", + "text": "我對他有信心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/305.wav", + "text": "就違反了法務部偵辦的原則" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/306.wav", + "text": "嘛我是在說這件事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/307.wav", + "text": "法務部基於你的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/308.wav", + "text": "你認為這會違反偵查不公開的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/309.wav", + "text": "就不要去揭露" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/310.wav", + "text": "鑑識出來你要依照你的原則" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/311.wav", + "text": "只是我們是希望如果你認為不會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/312.wav", + "text": "在你們的場域裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/313.wav", + "text": "嘛好不好對所有媒體" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/314.wav", + "text": "讓社會大眾瞭解" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/315.wav", + "text": "嘛好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/316.wav", + "text": "沒關係" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/317.wav", + "text": "的我實在是不能去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/318.wav", + "text": "幫這些承辦的單位來說明案情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/319.wav", + "text": "所以你要說行政上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/320.wav", + "text": "的要說政策的我可以來說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/321.wav", + "text": "我來接受質詢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/322.wav", + "text": "但是個案本身的鑑識結果如何" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/323.wav", + "text": "那是鑑定單位去行使職權的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/324.wav", + "text": "嘛我怎麼拿他的報告來這邊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/325.wav", + "text": "我剛才在王鴻薇委員要求" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/326.wav", + "text": "召委要做決議的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/327.wav", + "text": "我就要請你講這些話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/328.wav", + "text": "我並沒有要護航" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/329.wav", + "text": "但是我今天講我的權宜方法是這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/330.wav", + "text": "王鴻薇委員早上所拿的兩個資料" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/331.wav", + "text": "趙天麟委員的案子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/332.wav", + "text": "他們懷疑對方是有目的共諜" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/333.wav", + "text": "然後鄭文燦副院長的影片" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/334.wav", + "text": "被很明確的影射" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/335.wav", + "text": "他的影片可能提供給你了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/336.wav", + "text": "包含我要求的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/337.wav", + "text": "已經收押禁見的Lin" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/338.wav", + "text": "油許哲賓先生涉案的案情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/339.wav", + "text": "也包含馬文君委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/340.wav", + "text": "更嚴重的國防機密的案件" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/341.wav", + "text": "你們一定有立案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/342.wav", + "text": "沒立案趕快講喔" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/343.wav", + "text": "你們法務部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/344.wav", + "text": "你今天答應我" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/345.wav", + "text": "你在你的權責範圍之內" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/346.wav", + "text": "去做可以做的公開說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/347.wav", + "text": "既然大家都認為這些都是公義事件" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/348.wav", + "text": "我也認為裡面有很多被害者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/349.wav", + "text": "被誤會了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/350.wav", + "text": "大家都放消息都匿名嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/351.wav", + "text": "這四個案件" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/352.wav", + "text": "請法務部蔡部長答應我" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/353.wav", + "text": "依法行政的權責範圍之內" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/354.wav", + "text": "去對外說明目前的狀況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/355.wav", + "text": "我再補充說明一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/356.wav", + "text": "這四個案子是個案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/357.wav", + "text": "那我還是不宜逾越我的職權" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/358.wav", + "text": "調查機關辦理的案子拿來說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/359.wav", + "text": "但是我可以請高檢署" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/360.wav", + "text": "就他個案督導的情況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/361.wav", + "text": "辦理的情形" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/362.wav", + "text": "由高檢署來說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/363.wav", + "text": "那是他的權責嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/364.wav", + "text": "在你們那邊說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/365.wav", + "text": "誠如剛剛鄭委員講的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/366.wav", + "text": "我也沒辦法干涉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/367.wav", + "text": "就看他們自己決定嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/368.wav", + "text": "所以我剛剛一開始就講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/369.wav", + "text": "如果當初馬文君委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/370.wav", + "text": "所謂的揭弊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/371.wav", + "text": "國防揭弊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/372.wav", + "text": "是用王鴻薇委員這種形式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/373.wav", + "text": "在這邊處理的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/374.wav", + "text": "今天他不會那麼慘啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/375.wav", + "text": "所以作秀還是有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/376.wav", + "text": "那個手段高低程度高低的差別" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/377.wav", + "text": "啦大家互相學習" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/378.wav", + "text": "好部長就這樣喔" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/379.wav", + "text": "希望你趕快做鑑識" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/380.wav", + "text": "因為你已經告訴社會大眾說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/381.wav", + "text": "這個鑑識的技術是沒有問題的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/382.wav", + "text": "所以今天他就是凸顯這個問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/383.wav", + "text": "希望趕快做鑑識" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/384.wav", + "text": "單位不管高檢署也好調查局也好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/385.wav", + "text": "針對社會矚目的這件事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/386.wav", + "text": "包含鄭文燦副院長的聲明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/387.wav", + "text": "我想他也很希望你們趕快查清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/388.wav", + "text": "趕快去做鑑識" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/389.wav", + "text": "鑑識出來就對外發表一個立場" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/390.wav", + "text": "就是剛才鄭運鵬委員講的對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/391.wav", + "text": "你們的立場說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/392.wav", + "text": "我是要求他對外發表" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/393.wav", + "text": "剛才你們的要求" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/394.wav", + "text": "是要來這邊做報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/395.wav", + "text": "沒有啦我沒有叫他做報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/396.wav", + "text": "我說請他向本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/397.wav", + "text": "向本委員會提出說明而已" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/398.wav", + "text": "我有說報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/399.wav", + "text": "好啦更正更正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/400.wav", + "text": "向本委員會提出說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/401.wav", + "text": "也對外公開說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/402.wav", + "text": "對以及對外說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/403.wav", + "text": "我剛剛的要求" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/404.wav", + "text": "我很怕他們對外說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/405.wav", + "text": "權責機關來對外說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/406.wav", + "text": "我的責任就是我會督促" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/407.wav", + "text": "負責的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/408.wav", + "text": "或鑑識機關趕快儘速辦理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/409.wav", + "text": "在適當的機會讓他們對外說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/410.wav", + "text": "這樣子權責清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/411.wav", + "text": "公開透明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/412.wav", + "text": "皆大歡喜" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/413.wav", + "text": "這樣啦好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/414.wav", + "text": "王鴻薇的提案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/415.wav", + "text": "在不在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/416.wav", + "text": "在啊就是請你們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/417.wav", + "text": "位高檢署和調查局" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/418.wav", + "text": "影片的真偽" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/419.wav", + "text": "在7天內儘速做成鑑識" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/420.wav", + "text": "並對外提出說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/421.wav", + "text": "那不是法務部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/422.wav", + "text": "就是由他們權責機關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/423.wav", + "text": "你要督導" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/424.wav", + "text": "法務部要督導" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/425.wav", + "text": "我會督導" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/426.wav", + "text": "要啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/427.wav", + "text": "也要對我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/428.wav", + "text": "你除了對外說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/429.wav", + "text": "也要向本委會提出說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/430.wav", + "text": "也要答復我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/431.wav", + "text": "拿他們的一個報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/432.wav", + "text": "或是他們對外說明的內容" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/433.wav", + "text": "怎麼不可以對我們本委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/434.wav", + "text": "來向貴委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/435.wav", + "text": "好啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/436.wav", + "text": "OK" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147981/437.wav", + "text": "謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147980/0.wav", + "text": "有請海巡署周署長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147980/1.wav", + "text": "委員早" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147980/2.wav", + "text": "署長我想先請問一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147980/3.wav", + "text": "來我們這邊倒採砂石" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147980/4.wav", + "text": "我們現在執行的情況如何" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147980/5.wav", + "text": "我跟委員特別報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147980/6.wav", + "text": "現在整個抽砂船的狀況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147980/7.wav", + "text": "從109年110" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147980/8.wav", + "text": "簡單就好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147980/9.wav", + "text": "到現在的狀況是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147980/10.wav", + "text": "逐漸減少當中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147980/11.wav", + "text": "我想這個減少跟我們強烈執法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147980/12.wav", + "text": "跟我們立法院通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147980/13.wav", + "text": "這些加重裁罰" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147980/14.wav", + "text": "當事人有加重判刑" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147980/15.wav", + "text": "都有直接的關係" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147980/16.wav", + "text": "所以到今年我們執行的狀況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147980/17.wav", + "text": "剛剛主委在他的報告裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147980/18.wav", + "text": "已經提到了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147980/19.wav", + "text": "我們有驅離9艘" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147980/20.wav", + "text": "對啦我當然知道你們有很努力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147980/21.wav", + "text": "啦可是這個我覺得可能要再分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147980/22.wav", + "text": "啦比如說在澎湖附近的那是一種" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147980/23.wav", + "text": "比如說在金馬地區" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147980/24.wav", + "text": "我們現在就是只能依據土石" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147980/25.wav", + "text": "限制水域裡面我們才能查扣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147980/26.wav", + "text": "有沒有可能說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147980/27.wav", + "text": "為了要解決這個問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147980/28.wav", + "text": "我們將禁止水域" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147980/29.wav", + "text": "跟限制水域擴大一點呢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147980/30.wav", + "text": "這個問題跟委員報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147980/31.wav", + "text": "召開過兩到三次跨部會的會議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147980/32.wav", + "text": "陸委會很多相關的單位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147980/33.wav", + "text": "目前為止就我所知" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147980/34.wav", + "text": "因為我也參加過這個會議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147980/35.wav", + "text": "所以目前還是暫定維持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147980/36.wav", + "text": "現有的禁限制水域的區塊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147980/37.wav", + "text": "對啦行政院是這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147980/38.wav", + "text": "這我們也知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147980/39.wav", + "text": "其實要在這裡問你說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147980/40.wav", + "text": "你希不希望擴大" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147980/41.wav", + "text": "我想你也不好回答啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147980/42.wav", + "text": "不過我倒真的覺得啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147980/43.wav", + "text": "其實在執法的方便性跟必要性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147980/44.wav", + "text": "我個人是認為應該稍微擴大啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147980/45.wav", + "text": "這樣我們的海巡弟兄" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147980/46.wav", + "text": "才不會這樣子跟著危險走啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147980/47.wav", + "text": "不然你像現在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147980/48.wav", + "text": "還沒拍賣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147980/49.wav", + "text": "在沒有拍賣前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147980/50.wav", + "text": "所有停泊費用都要算在裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147980/51.wav", + "text": "其實都增加很多負擔" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147980/52.wav", + "text": "我覺得像這一塊的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147980/53.wav", + "text": "以後我們會不會可以說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147980/54.wav", + "text": "跟其他跨部會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147980/55.wav", + "text": "多久沒有拍賣出去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147980/56.wav", + "text": "就轉給其他看要如何利用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147980/57.wav", + "text": "可以使用再利用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147980/58.wav", + "text": "只還剩下一艘靠泊在我們興達港的基地" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147980/59.wav", + "text": "其他的三艘在今年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147980/60.wav", + "text": "已經全部都處理掉了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147980/61.wav", + "text": "對啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147980/62.wav", + "text": "科技的執法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147980/63.wav", + "text": "有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147980/64.wav", + "text": "我跟你講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147980/65.wav", + "text": "我們在2020年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147980/66.wav", + "text": "的國家海洋政策白皮書裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147980/67.wav", + "text": "它的第參章海上安全與海域安全" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147980/68.wav", + "text": "其實就有講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147980/69.wav", + "text": "要用人工智慧建構海域" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147980/70.wav", + "text": "戰情全方位防護" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147980/71.wav", + "text": "我覺得現在有很多可以用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147980/72.wav", + "text": "無人機無人船水下載具" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147980/73.wav", + "text": "其實我們可以預防" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147980/74.wav", + "text": "可以提前知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147980/75.wav", + "text": "我們海底下這一些地形地貌" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147980/76.wav", + "text": "有沒有被破壞" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147980/77.wav", + "text": "未來求償其實都蠻好用的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147980/78.wav", + "text": "跟委員簡單的說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147980/79.wav", + "text": "我們應該運用科技輔勤的各個方面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147980/80.wav", + "text": "現在這些案子都在執行當中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147980/81.wav", + "text": "我舉例現在我們有一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147980/82.wav", + "text": "也就是像委員所講的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147980/83.wav", + "text": "或者有高低差度的地方" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147980/84.wav", + "text": "就用這些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147980/85.wav", + "text": "署長我的意思是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147980/86.wav", + "text": "對盜採砂石的這一部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147980/87.wav", + "text": "能不能用這些科技的執法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147980/88.wav", + "text": "我們在盜採砂石這個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147980/89.wav", + "text": "就像委員剛剛提到用無人機" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147980/90.wav", + "text": "甚至將來用無人艇" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147980/91.wav", + "text": "可能都可以預早知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147980/92.wav", + "text": "他要進入到我們的禁限制水域" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147980/93.wav", + "text": "這個我們可以做沒有問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147980/94.wav", + "text": "可以做啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147980/95.wav", + "text": "好就這一句話而已" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147980/96.wav", + "text": "請你們努力一下好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147980/97.wav", + "text": "是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147980/98.wav", + "text": "我和鄭天財委員一樣預算一定全力支持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147980/99.wav", + "text": "你們只要能做得好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147980/100.wav", + "text": "我請一下管主委" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147980/101.wav", + "text": "請管主委" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147980/102.wav", + "text": "主委你好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147980/103.wav", + "text": "我知道其實對文化這個部分你也蠻專業的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147980/104.wav", + "text": "其實整個臺灣四面環海" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147980/105.wav", + "text": "很多地方有各種不同的文化" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147980/106.wav", + "text": "像永安漁港" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147980/107.wav", + "text": "桃園的永安漁港" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147980/108.wav", + "text": "其實就有很多的客家文化" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147980/109.wav", + "text": "對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147980/110.wav", + "text": "也都有各種不同的文化" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147980/111.wav", + "text": "我一直覺得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147980/112.wav", + "text": "當然每個部會有每個部會的職掌" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147980/113.wav", + "text": "不過我們現在去海邊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147980/114.wav", + "text": "好像就是哪裡的海鮮比較好吃" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147980/115.wav", + "text": "哪裡有名店" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147980/116.wav", + "text": "我覺得政府已經" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147980/117.wav", + "text": "說向山致敬向海致敬了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147980/118.wav", + "text": "其實這個文化的宣傳" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147980/119.wav", + "text": "和文化的推廣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147980/120.wav", + "text": "非常不夠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147980/121.wav", + "text": "對我的意思就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147980/122.wav", + "text": "這樣不好意思直接講不夠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147980/123.wav", + "text": "跟委員報告今年度海委會的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147980/124.wav", + "text": "我想大家可能一聽就知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147980/125.wav", + "text": "為什麼臺灣人民的海洋意識這麼薄弱" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147980/126.wav", + "text": "海委會沒有宣導經費" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147980/127.wav", + "text": "我們才開始來編海洋意識宣導的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147980/128.wav", + "text": "絕對都會用在海洋教育海洋文化" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147980/129.wav", + "text": "海洋意識海洋素養" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147980/130.wav", + "text": "這些項目之使用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147980/131.wav", + "text": "有的部會是好幾千萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147980/132.wav", + "text": "95萬這個數字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147980/133.wav", + "text": "可能委員或大家一聽就知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147980/134.wav", + "text": "海洋意識的宣導確實" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147980/135.wav", + "text": "不夠所以我的臉書" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147980/136.wav", + "text": "才會全部都變成在宣傳海委會的活動" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147980/137.wav", + "text": "用我的臉書能夠揭露出一點點網路新聞" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147980/138.wav", + "text": "目前我們只能做這樣的努力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147980/139.wav", + "text": "希望明年會不一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147980/140.wav", + "text": "\n內容的部分跟委員報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147980/141.wav", + "text": "請委員放心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147980/142.wav", + "text": "剛剛委員很關心海洋文化" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147980/143.wav", + "text": "列舉了貢寮等等很多地方" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147980/144.wav", + "text": "我們處長沒帶來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147980/145.wav", + "text": "我剛剛問他有沒有帶來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147980/146.wav", + "text": "我們做了一個臺灣傳統海洋文化地圖" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147980/147.wav", + "text": "我們已經做出來了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147980/148.wav", + "text": "有各個地方各個縣市" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147980/149.wav", + "text": "甚至於部落或者是社區" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147980/150.wav", + "text": "譬如海女文化" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147980/151.wav", + "text": "石頭屋文化等等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147980/152.wav", + "text": "有非常多我們整個海洋文化地圖" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147980/153.wav", + "text": "有做出來有盤點出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147980/154.wav", + "text": "第一階段我是請同仁" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147980/155.wav", + "text": "趕快用一個計畫下去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147980/156.wav", + "text": "把在地的文化量能趕快找出來以後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147980/157.wav", + "text": "給他們資源" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147980/158.wav", + "text": "這些海洋的文化" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147980/159.wav", + "text": "我說你老照片或耆老的訪問" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147980/160.wav", + "text": "至少第一階段趕快先蒐集起來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147980/161.wav", + "text": "然後我們要做很好的處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147980/162.wav", + "text": "及很好的展現" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147980/163.wav", + "text": "來創造這些文化的認同感" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147980/164.wav", + "text": "驕傲感" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147980/165.wav", + "text": "然後協助把可以傳承的這個機制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147980/166.wav", + "text": "這個是我們逐步可以來做的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147980/167.wav", + "text": "至少海洋文化的地圖已經有盤點出來了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147980/168.wav", + "text": "主委謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147980/169.wav", + "text": "其實我覺得這種文化就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147980/170.wav", + "text": "保留傳承及參與" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147980/171.wav", + "text": "我覺得到最後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147980/172.wav", + "text": "就是要讓大家參與" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147980/173.wav", + "text": "不只是臺灣人去參與" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147980/174.wav", + "text": "也要讓外國人來參與" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147980/175.wav", + "text": "這樣子對地方的發展才會好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147980/176.wav", + "text": "我們的文化也才會好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147980/177.wav", + "text": "主委對這個方面比我還專業" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147980/178.wav", + "text": "但是就是越有專業的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147980/179.wav", + "text": "人要趕快去做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147980/180.wav", + "text": "我們其實也可以和其他觀光局" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147980/181.wav", + "text": "很多的文化如果讓民眾去參與" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147980/182.wav", + "text": "我認為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147980/183.wav", + "text": "大家都想去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147980/184.wav", + "text": "比如剛剛主委講了很多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147980/185.wav", + "text": "大家可能知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147980/186.wav", + "text": "但去只能看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147980/187.wav", + "text": "不能參與" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147980/188.wav", + "text": "我們現在已經向海致敬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147980/189.wav", + "text": "對體驗才有商機" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147980/190.wav", + "text": "才能讓當地人賺到錢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147980/191.wav", + "text": "賺到錢之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147980/192.wav", + "text": "才會有更多人想要去從事這個行業" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147980/193.wav", + "text": "我們就可以傳承了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147980/194.wav", + "text": "傳承之後更多人參與的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147980/195.wav", + "text": "這個商機一來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147980/196.wav", + "text": "文化可以保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147980/197.wav", + "text": "也創造地方的發展" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147980/198.wav", + "text": "就是大概這個意思" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147980/199.wav", + "text": "好我們來努力謝謝委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147980/200.wav", + "text": "謝謝張宏陸委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147980/201.wav", + "text": "\n現在有請陳琬惠委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147979/0.wav", + "text": "我還是要請教遷村案因為遷村案到最後一個階段了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147979/1.wav", + "text": "我先問一下部長是不是已經把再次修改" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147979/2.wav", + "text": "是我們同仁已經按照跨部會開會的結論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147979/3.wav", + "text": "國發會是不是也已經收到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147979/4.wav", + "text": "對昨天晚上收到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147979/5.wav", + "text": "還需要再開會嗎還是說已經彙整過意見之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147979/6.wav", + "text": "應該差不多了我們儘快處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147979/7.wav", + "text": "那就麻煩國發會儘快送給院裡面好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147979/8.wav", + "text": "因為從2019年4年前的10月8號" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147979/9.wav", + "text": "到底要不要遷及怎麼遷的方案等了4年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147979/10.wav", + "text": "很多修繕也都不好修因為有些擔心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147979/11.wav", + "text": "4年其實滿漫長的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147979/12.wav", + "text": "這個月應該有機會做核定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147979/13.wav", + "text": "了我再問一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147979/14.wav", + "text": "裡面的總經費就我的初步瞭解" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147979/15.wav", + "text": "其實有做了一些增加" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147979/16.wav", + "text": "是因為這個最後都還是要由院裡面來核定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147979/17.wav", + "text": "當時其實我也做過一些爭取" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147979/18.wav", + "text": "也希望對於一些無房無地者能夠做一些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147979/19.wav", + "text": "照顧我也知道部裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147979/20.wav", + "text": "跟高雄縣政府也做了一些努力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147979/21.wav", + "text": "針對物調我們也做了一些準備" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147979/22.wav", + "text": "另外我們當然也做了一些準備金" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147979/23.wav", + "text": "部長不方便講沒關係我來講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147979/24.wav", + "text": "大概準備了40億左右的準備金" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147979/25.wav", + "text": "總數可能會到800億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147979/26.wav", + "text": "能夠更妥善的照顧好鄉親們的權益" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147979/27.wav", + "text": "我想這也是一個負責任的政府" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147979/28.wav", + "text": "該做的從7年前林全院長剛上任之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147979/29.wav", + "text": "跟陳菊市長去跟大林蒲的鄉親們致歉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147979/30.wav", + "text": "為當年政府在規劃的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147979/31.wav", + "text": "沒有一併做處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147979/32.wav", + "text": "讓將近2萬名鄉親在周邊的工業區裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147979/33.wav", + "text": "承受800支煙囪的影響" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147979/34.wav", + "text": "也正式來啟動這個程序" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147979/35.wav", + "text": "我們也希望在10月份的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147979/36.wav", + "text": "有機會儘速來核定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147979/37.wav", + "text": "\n我認為臺灣要進一步往前走的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147979/38.wav", + "text": "給人民一個健康安全的環境" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147979/39.wav", + "text": "是一個基本的條件" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147979/40.wav", + "text": "如果處在一個不安全不健康的環境下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147979/41.wav", + "text": "很難講這是一個進步的國家跟城市" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147979/42.wav", + "text": "特別是上次我想部長很清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147979/43.wav", + "text": "當地的鄉親幾乎非常害怕" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147979/44.wav", + "text": "又發生什麼事了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147979/45.wav", + "text": "他們以為又是一次大的爆炸" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147979/46.wav", + "text": "因為大家不知道到底會發生什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147979/47.wav", + "text": "所以進步的城市應該是要想辦法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147979/48.wav", + "text": "的我們也必須要努力繼續在工業上求發展" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147979/49.wav", + "text": "但是將它跟人民的距離拉開的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147979/50.wav", + "text": "才能夠達成一個多贏的效果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147979/51.wav", + "text": "\n我相信政府現在做的每一步" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147979/52.wav", + "text": "對於將來不管是從人民的角度看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147979/53.wav", + "text": "從產業的角度看各方面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147979/54.wav", + "text": "我認為這都絕對是正確的一步" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147979/55.wav", + "text": "而現在花的這些經費" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147979/56.wav", + "text": "也都會遠遠超出所投入的經費" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147979/57.wav", + "text": "所以我也希望部長跟主委" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147979/58.wav", + "text": "儘快地去促成整件事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147979/59.wav", + "text": "你看我們相關的腳步" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147979/60.wav", + "text": "都非常緊密的在一步一步往前走" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147979/61.wav", + "text": "有意見我們就趕快再來��調各部會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147979/62.wav", + "text": "一旦達成共識就趕快" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147979/63.wav", + "text": "再修改計畫送出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147979/64.wav", + "text": "這是非常複雜的一個遷村" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147979/65.wav", + "text": "大概是有史以來最複雜的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147979/66.wav", + "text": "不容易啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147979/67.wav", + "text": "遷村絕對不是一件容易的事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147979/68.wav", + "text": "但是這也絕對是一個不得已之下的選擇" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147979/69.wav", + "text": "沒有人會願意希望" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147979/70.wav", + "text": "是所以做好妥善的配套也是我們的責任" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147979/71.wav", + "text": "給鄉親們更多的照顧" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147979/72.wav", + "text": "讓他們在離開之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147979/73.wav", + "text": "將來後續不會產生一些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147979/74.wav", + "text": "我認為這也是政府的責任" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147979/75.wav", + "text": "我們做得越細膩關切得越細膩的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147979/76.wav", + "text": "就能夠真正達到我們期待的多贏的效果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147979/77.wav", + "text": "不要讓有些鄉親後來發現" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147979/78.wav", + "text": "確實有因為思慮不周有所遺漏" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147979/79.wav", + "text": "而對他們的權益產生影響" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147979/80.wav", + "text": "等到也許過了5年10年後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147979/81.wav", + "text": "我們都不在這個位置上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147979/82.wav", + "text": "各位也都不是部長了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147979/83.wav", + "text": "我也不是立委了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147979/84.wav", + "text": "還在那些鄉親身上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147979/85.wav", + "text": "也許是他們一輩子必須承受的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147979/86.wav", + "text": "所以我希望一個負責任的政府" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147979/87.wav", + "text": "會做事的政府" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147979/88.wav", + "text": "我們就把這些細節層面都把它做好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147979/89.wav", + "text": "是的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147979/90.wav", + "text": "讓鄉親們感受到一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147979/91.wav", + "text": "有能力執政的政府" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147979/92.wav", + "text": "可以把這件事情處理得很完善" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147979/93.wav", + "text": "再來請教一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147979/94.wav", + "text": "因為這是一個中長期的計畫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147979/95.wav", + "text": "當然做了一些修訂" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147979/96.wav", + "text": "4年前蘇院長核定之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147979/97.wav", + "text": "再做了一次修訂" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147979/98.wav", + "text": "修訂完之後安置計畫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147979/99.wav", + "text": "也會很快地再做一些微調" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147979/100.wav", + "text": "我希望這個安置計畫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147979/101.wav", + "text": "因為我也跟行政院確認過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147979/102.wav", + "text": "跟國發會也確認過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147979/103.wav", + "text": "安置計畫的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147979/104.wav", + "text": "就不用再走那麼複雜" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147979/105.wav", + "text": "的程序我也希望部長能夠在安置計畫的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147979/106.wav", + "text": "在你的內部裡面去做一個處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147979/107.wav", + "text": "能夠儘快地在11月份的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147979/108.wav", + "text": "居民可以做一個選擇" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147979/109.wav", + "text": "就是他們的方案選擇的啟動" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147979/110.wav", + "text": "這部分居民等很久了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147979/111.wav", + "text": "部長可不可以做這樣的一個承諾" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147979/112.wav", + "text": "是安置計畫我們也會密切" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147979/113.wav", + "text": "地跟高雄市政府來協調" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147979/114.wav", + "text": "可以儘快地往前走" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147979/115.wav", + "text": "因為大的方向都已經定了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147979/116.wav", + "text": "不管是從預算規模大大小小的細節" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147979/117.wav", + "text": "送給院長的這整" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147979/118.wav", + "text": "整個中長程計畫裡面都已經定了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147979/119.wav", + "text": "把其中的細項訂得更清楚而已" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147979/120.wav", + "text": "事實上不脫離這個範圍內的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147979/121.wav", + "text": "也都計算出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147979/122.wav", + "text": "怎麼算出這個800億的規模" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147979/123.wav", + "text": "所以都清楚了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147979/124.wav", + "text": "我講的只是行政程序上面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147979/125.wav", + "text": "不要又再會來會去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147979/126.wav", + "text": "不要又再跑到各部會去公文旅行了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147979/127.wav", + "text": "我希望能夠在部裡面去做出決定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147979/128.wav", + "text": "然後跟市政府討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147979/129.wav", + "text": "完趕快做出決定之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147979/130.wav", + "text": "11月來啟動" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147979/131.wav", + "text": "確實動起來了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147979/132.wav", + "text": "好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147979/133.wav", + "text": "部長請朝這個方向來努力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147979/134.wav", + "text": "謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147976/0.wav", + "text": "主委我在報章雜誌上看到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147976/1.wav", + "text": "已經有對外透露了一些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147976/2.wav", + "text": "大概有9家金融機構先行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147976/3.wav", + "text": "預計在明年2月" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147976/4.wav", + "text": "上路透過財金公司聯合稽查徵信方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147976/5.wav", + "text": "來達到這個機制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147976/6.wav", + "text": "這個部分比較像上一次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147976/7.wav", + "text": "我們銀行局長提到的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147976/8.wav", + "text": "所謂事前事中跟事後的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147976/9.wav", + "text": "但是這個事後的末端管理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147976/10.wav", + "text": "我覺得還是有一些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147976/11.wav", + "text": "需要被探討的地方" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147976/12.wav", + "text": "也就是說你在KYC的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147976/13.wav", + "text": "要去怎麼掌握" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147976/14.wav", + "text": "第二個你說1個月統計一次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147976/15.wav", + "text": "問題詐騙集團" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147976/16.wav", + "text": "等到1個月的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147976/17.wav", + "text": "已經不知道詐騙多久了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147976/18.wav", + "text": "依照聯合徵信中心的機制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147976/19.wav", + "text": "有這麼脆弱" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147976/20.wav", + "text": "到1個月一定要弄一次嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147976/21.wav", + "text": "這是第一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147976/22.wav", + "text": "第二個要請教於您" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147976/23.wav", + "text": "銀行遇到這種灰色名單的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147976/24.wav", + "text": "要怎麼做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147976/25.wav", + "text": "這個已經有很多人了稍微異常了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147976/26.wav", + "text": "喔你是不是不要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147976/27.wav", + "text": "有沒有阻絕的權利" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147976/28.wav", + "text": "第三個其他機構什麼時候納入" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147976/29.wav", + "text": "主委局長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147976/30.wav", + "text": "如果覺得有可疑的帳戶" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147976/31.wav", + "text": "現在要設定的轉出行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147976/32.wav", + "text": "他們這邊會得到財金這邊的回饋" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147976/33.wav", + "text": "這個時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147976/34.wav", + "text": "就會回去對這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147976/35.wav", + "text": "要來設定約定轉帳的消費者說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147976/36.wav", + "text": "1個月1次會不會太久" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147976/37.wav", + "text": "如果納入名單當然" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147976/38.wav", + "text": "馬上可以告知" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147976/39.wav", + "text": "我是說你在統計上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147976/40.wav", + "text": "1個月1次會不會太久" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147976/41.wav", + "text": "因為這個是在平台上面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147976/42.wav", + "text": "立刻可以得到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147976/43.wav", + "text": "這個已經被設定多少次了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147976/44.wav", + "text": "所以那個訊息要很快" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147976/45.wav", + "text": "銀行如果接收到這個訊息" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147976/46.wav", + "text": "它會怎麼做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147976/47.wav", + "text": "它會立刻跟這個消費者確認" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147976/48.wav", + "text": "到底認不認識這個約定轉帳的人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147976/49.wav", + "text": "就是做一些善意的提醒" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147976/50.wav", + "text": "他如果執意要進行呢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147976/51.wav", + "text": "那你怎麼辦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147976/52.wav", + "text": "如果覺得真的很可疑的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147976/53.wav", + "text": "還是可以讓這個帳戶不能設定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147976/54.wav", + "text": "對有阻絕的權利" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147976/55.wav", + "text": "好那就是阻詐的效果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147976/56.wav", + "text": "嘛什麼時候這些金融機構會全部納入" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147976/57.wav", + "text": "是在明年1月底" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147976/58.wav", + "text": "會有9家銀行上線" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147976/59.wav", + "text": "預計在113年底的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147976/60.wav", + "text": "絕大部分的銀行都可以上線" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147976/61.wav", + "text": "113年很長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147976/62.wav", + "text": "你要嘛就一次全部都上路就好啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147976/63.wav", + "text": "有這麼困難嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147976/64.wav", + "text": "1月上9家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147976/65.wav", + "text": "2月全部上有沒有可能" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147976/66.wav", + "text": "大概是明年4月底的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147976/67.wav", + "text": "4月底" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147976/68.wav", + "text": "4月底全部上路" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147976/69.wav", + "text": "是不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147976/70.wav", + "text": "好我們現在儘量規劃當中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147976/71.wav", + "text": "啦因為到了明年4月底的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147976/72.wav", + "text": "市場上重要的金融機構" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147976/73.wav", + "text": "重要的金融機構" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147976/74.wav", + "text": "絕大部分都已經網羅了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147976/75.wav", + "text": "以全部為目標好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147976/76.wav", + "text": "\n談到阻詐的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147976/77.wav", + "text": "主委你上次也提到阻" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147976/78.wav", + "text": "阻詐的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147976/79.wav", + "text": "今年的成績好像比去年好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147976/80.wav", + "text": "總共在銀行臨櫃的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147976/81.wav", + "text": "阻詐了48億的阻詐成績" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147976/82.wav", + "text": "那我想請問一下主委" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147976/83.wav", + "text": "有沒有進行統計" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147976/84.wav", + "text": "網路上也有啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147976/85.wav", + "text": "有嗎多少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147976/86.wav", + "text": "網路上是指" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147976/87.wav", + "text": "網路銀行啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147976/88.wav", + "text": "比方說第三方支付" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147976/89.wav", + "text": "要開設虛擬帳戶的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147976/90.wav", + "text": "我們跟數位部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147976/91.wav", + "text": "有合作的機制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147976/92.wav", + "text": "因為我沒有看到統計" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147976/93.wav", + "text": "啦我是沒有看到統計" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147976/94.wav", + "text": "主委就一個事實的樣態" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147976/95.wav", + "text": "我就就教於您" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147976/96.wav", + "text": "如果民眾" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147976/97.wav", + "text": "明明刷了幾百塊錢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147976/98.wav", + "text": "銀行轉帳轉到10萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147976/99.wav", + "text": "那我馬上去跟銀行講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147976/100.wav", + "text": "你覺得銀行應該怎麼做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147976/101.wav", + "text": "它要確認" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147976/102.wav", + "text": "這個轉出去的對象到底是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147976/103.wav", + "text": "誰這應該" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147976/104.wav", + "text": "可以去做一個查證" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147976/105.wav", + "text": "可是就實務上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147976/106.wav", + "text": "銀行都沒有確認" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147976/107.wav", + "text": "它就認為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147976/108.wav", + "text": "這個簡訊認證密碼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147976/109.wav", + "text": "已經授權了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147976/110.wav", + "text": "我銀行就把它匯出去了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147976/111.wav", + "text": "就變成這種狀況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147976/112.wav", + "text": "民眾去要求" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147976/113.wav", + "text": "但它硬要轉出去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147976/114.wav", + "text": "它好像很缺這筆手續費一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147976/115.wav", + "text": "在這樣的情況底下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147976/116.wav", + "text": "銀行跟車手" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147976/117.wav", + "text": "有沒有什麼不同" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147976/118.wav", + "text": "我明明看到我的消費金額" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147976/119.wav", + "text": "是幾百塊錢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147976/120.wav", + "text": "你覺得銀行在當車手" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147976/121.wav", + "text": "還是在當銀行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147976/122.wav", + "text": "這個要看他交易的性質" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147976/123.wav", + "text": "我想委員有特別的個案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147976/124.wav", + "text": "我們可以瞭解" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147976/125.wav", + "text": "通案上如果是信用卡交易" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147976/126.wav", + "text": "應該都可以暫停付款" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147976/127.wav", + "text": "因為現階段沒有一個法源" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147976/128.wav", + "text": "我去查過這是銀行內部所制定的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147976/129.wav", + "text": "爭議款項授權書" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147976/130.wav", + "text": "除非銀行端有缺失" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147976/131.wav", + "text": "否則它都必須一定要付款" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147976/132.wav", + "text": "但問題不是銀行端有缺失" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147976/133.wav", + "text": "啊可是消費者告知的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147976/134.wav", + "text": "這筆錢還是屬於我的錢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147976/135.wav", + "text": "雖然已經有授權了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147976/136.wav", + "text": "但是我要停止" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147976/137.wav", + "text": "你卻還是執意轉出去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147976/138.wav", + "text": "那不就是跟車手一樣嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147976/139.wav", + "text": "委員垂詢的是轉出去的金額" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147976/140.wav", + "text": "跟我要轉的金額不一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147976/141.wav", + "text": "嘛我明明消費幾百塊錢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147976/142.wav", + "text": "然後它轉出去10萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147976/143.wav", + "text": "我就來跟銀行講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147976/144.wav", + "text": "千萬不要再轉出去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147976/145.wav", + "text": "一定要按照這個因為你已經授權完成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147976/146.wav", + "text": "所以我一定要給你轉出去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147976/147.wav", + "text": "這個情況是不是容許" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147976/148.wav", + "text": "我在會後跟同仁再瞭解一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147976/149.wav", + "text": "因為不太清楚那個個案是什麼情況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147976/150.wav", + "text": "對我們是阻詐" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147976/151.wav", + "text": "不應該變成助詐嘛對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147976/152.wav", + "text": "當然" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147976/153.wav", + "text": "所以麻煩主委回去瞭解一下好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147976/154.wav", + "text": "是我們遵照辦理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147976/155.wav", + "text": "主委還有一件事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147976/156.wav", + "text": "這邊大出手的原因" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147976/157.wav", + "text": "結果我們的資金集中在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147976/158.wav", + "text": "還是居高不下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147976/159.wav", + "text": "就代表房價會越高" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147976/160.wav", + "text": "在2022年2" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147976/161.wav", + "text": "2月的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147976/162.wav", + "text": "適用風險係數做一個調整" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147976/163.wav", + "text": "調整完之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147976/164.wav", + "text": "金管會好像就沒事了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147976/165.wav", + "text": "我們同步還有對一些銀行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147976/166.wav", + "text": "授信在不動產集中度比較高的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147976/167.wav", + "text": "其實是非常強的一個管理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147976/168.wav", + "text": "對銀行來講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147976/169.wav", + "text": "有非常大的導正效果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147976/170.wav", + "text": "可是主委總體結果來看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147976/171.wav", + "text": "現在放貸的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147976/172.wav", + "text": "到2023年6月的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147976/173.wav", + "text": "還是37.2%" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147976/174.wav", + "text": "總共金額還是14兆" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147976/175.wav", + "text": "618億有往上攀升" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147976/176.wav", + "text": "沒有往下跌下來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147976/177.wav", + "text": "你手頭還有沒有其他方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147976/178.wav", + "text": "我們基本上是配合" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147976/179.wav", + "text": "行政院健全房市的政策去做處理的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147976/180.wav", + "text": "正常想買房子的權益" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147976/181.wav", + "text": "所以很多事情都要做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147976/182.wav", + "text": "我知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147976/183.wav", + "text": "考慮到消費端" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147976/184.wav", + "text": "考慮到銷售端" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147976/185.wav", + "text": "但是考慮到總體經濟的情況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147976/186.wav", + "text": "但是您垂詢這個集中度過高" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147976/187.wav", + "text": "是不是允許我們瞭解" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147976/188.wav", + "text": "它的原因是什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147976/189.wav", + "text": "就像你之前提到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147976/190.wav", + "text": "所謂的建商建築放貸的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147976/191.wav", + "text": "要注重社會責任" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147976/192.wav", + "text": "你也很重視這問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147976/193.wav", + "text": "委員你5月17號質詢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147976/194.wav", + "text": "我們都有照做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147976/195.wav", + "text": "你就馬上受理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147976/196.wav", + "text": "像這種從優條款" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147976/197.wav", + "text": "基本上也可以達到這種效果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147976/198.wav", + "text": "所以我是希望" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147976/199.wav", + "text": "還有沒有其他機制來做處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147976/200.wav", + "text": "\n另外一個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147976/201.wav", + "text": "是本席曾經在去年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147976/202.wav", + "text": "提出來的一個質詢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147976/203.wav", + "text": "也就是保人變呆人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147976/204.wav", + "text": "當保證人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147976/205.wav", + "text": "沒有告知我說他沒有還" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147976/206.wav", + "text": "我也不清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147976/207.wav", + "text": "但是事隔多年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147976/208.wav", + "text": "我做資產處分的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147976/209.wav", + "text": "銀行告訴我說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147976/210.wav", + "text": "你要繳多少錢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147976/211.wav", + "text": "繳多少錢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147976/212.wav", + "text": "繳多少錢主委你們也有處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147976/213.wav", + "text": "確實你們找銀行公會開會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147976/214.wav", + "text": "訂出一個相關作業方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147976/215.wav", + "text": "要讓保人知悉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147976/216.wav", + "text": "問題是現在發生的都是過去式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147976/217.wav", + "text": "類似的情況還是不斷的發生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147976/218.wav", + "text": "結果你們還是沒有修法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147976/219.wav", + "text": "只有公會的部分修一個內部的準則" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147976/220.wav", + "text": "可是還是沒有辦法解決這個問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147976/221.wav", + "text": "主委" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147976/222.wav", + "text": "我們有做一點制度的改革" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147976/223.wav", + "text": "報告委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147976/224.wav", + "text": "當時確實在公會有討論到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147976/225.wav", + "text": "如果有類似的狀況的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147976/226.wav", + "text": "不過委員現在提到的是以往的案子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147976/227.wav", + "text": "新的制度造成以往的案件沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147976/228.wav", + "text": "實務上面是不是沒有按照規定在做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147976/229.wav", + "text": "這個作業準則很清楚了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147976/230.wav", + "text": "這個作業準則就是屬於未來式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147976/231.wav", + "text": "就是因為過去發生了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147976/232.wav", + "text": "資產都是過去累積的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147976/233.wav", + "text": "我相信在所有銀行當中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147976/234.wav", + "text": "現在超過一年以上的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147976/235.wav", + "text": "保人可能還不清楚的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147976/236.wav", + "text": "你就做一個簡單的作業告訴他說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147976/237.wav", + "text": "你將來如果資產處分的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147976/238.wav", + "text": "我會重新計算利息" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147976/239.wav", + "text": "當初的利息多少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147976/240.wav", + "text": "你可能虧欠銀行大概多少錢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147976/241.wav", + "text": "你至少告知他一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147976/242.wav", + "text": "應該都會要做這樣通知" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147976/243.wav", + "text": "所以我才會說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147976/244.wav", + "text": "我們再去看一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147976/245.wav", + "text": "是不是在執行上面有問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147976/246.wav", + "text": "如果執行上面有問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147976/247.wav", + "text": "不是執行有問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147976/248.wav", + "text": "局長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147976/249.wav", + "text": "我就是說執行已經有問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147976/250.wav", + "text": "出現超過一段時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147976/251.wav", + "text": "委員您垂詢的這個情況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147976/252.wav", + "text": "我們再找銀行公會來研究" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147976/253.wav", + "text": "好麻煩你" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147976/254.wav", + "text": "主委希望能夠斷絕類似的情事產生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147975/0.wav", + "text": "謝謝主席我們請部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147975/1.wav", + "text": "哪一位部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147975/2.wav", + "text": "王部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147975/3.wav", + "text": "謝謝部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147975/4.wav", + "text": "現在台積電1.4奈米廠要落腳在哪裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147975/5.wav", + "text": "大家都非常非常期待" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147975/6.wav", + "text": "各個地方都非常期待" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147975/7.wav", + "text": "所以我今天正式在這裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147975/8.wav", + "text": "跟部長拜託" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147975/9.wav", + "text": "歡迎來臺南" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147975/10.wav", + "text": "因為臺南所有的條件" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147975/11.wav", + "text": "都非常具足" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147975/12.wav", + "text": "尤其台積電5奈米" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147975/13.wav", + "text": "3奈米廠都已經進駐到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147975/14.wav", + "text": "我們臺南所" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147975/15.wav", + "text": "以整個上下游廠商的垂直整合" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147975/16.wav", + "text": "都沒有問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147975/17.wav", + "text": "甚至主客觀條件也沒有問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147975/18.wav", + "text": "還有都市機能交通建設" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147975/19.wav", + "text": "以及重要的水電供應" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147975/20.wav", + "text": "我們為了台積電" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147975/21.wav", + "text": "所付出的協助" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147975/22.wav", + "text": "包括中央給的資源" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147975/23.wav", + "text": "然後大家做了一個完整的整合" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147975/24.wav", + "text": "從水到電" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147975/25.wav", + "text": "可以說盡了非常大的力量" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147975/26.wav", + "text": "就是為了我們的護國神山" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147975/27.wav", + "text": "當時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147975/28.wav", + "text": "我們都已經在準備了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147975/29.wav", + "text": "而且幾乎已經看到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147975/30.wav", + "text": "一個最重要的水電供應雛型" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147975/31.wav", + "text": "型如果是這樣的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147975/32.wav", + "text": "從各種主客觀條件" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147975/33.wav", + "text": "來看我覺得就是要落腳" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147975/34.wav", + "text": "在我們臺南" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147975/35.wav", + "text": "現在大家都在問土地在哪裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147975/36.wav", + "text": "土地沒有問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147975/37.wav", + "text": "在南科三期" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147975/38.wav", + "text": "我相信南科三期還有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147975/39.wav", + "text": "38.91公頃以外" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147975/40.wav", + "text": "我們臺南在旁邊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147975/41.wav", + "text": "所可以提供的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147975/42.wav", + "text": "在114年可以提供A區" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147975/43.wav", + "text": "然後115年提供B區" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147975/44.wav", + "text": "總共有74.84公頃" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147975/45.wav", + "text": "這是屬於臺南的土地" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147975/46.wav", + "text": "啦所以臺南的土地" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147975/47.wav", + "text": "更沒有問題啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147975/48.wav", + "text": "如果他願意來協助的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147975/49.wav", + "text": "那速度更快" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147975/50.wav", + "text": "市有的土地" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147975/51.wav", + "text": "如果市府可以規劃" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147975/52.wav", + "text": "再配合我們南科三期" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147975/53.wav", + "text": "然後甚至配合目前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147975/54.wav", + "text": "在LM區的8.1公頃" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147975/55.wav", + "text": "看台積電要怎麼用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147975/56.wav", + "text": "還有它上下游的廠商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147975/57.wav", + "text": "要怎麼用都沒有問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147975/58.wav", + "text": "\n所以部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147975/59.wav", + "text": "我在這裡深切的期盼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147975/60.wav", + "text": "如果以各方的條件" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147975/61.wav", + "text": "來看不一定要在中科啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147975/62.wav", + "text": "我覺得南科非常重要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147975/63.wav", + "text": "我們所提供的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147975/64.wav", + "text": "臺南市政府的土地" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147975/65.wav", + "text": "並不是南科目前的土地" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147975/66.wav", + "text": "差就差在這裡啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147975/67.wav", + "text": "可是沒有問題啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147975/68.wav", + "text": "我們整個南科的管理範圍" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147975/69.wav", + "text": "因為市府的工業區地" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147975/70.wav", + "text": "跟南科的工業區地" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147975/71.wav", + "text": "是不一樣的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147975/72.wav", + "text": "整個條件" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147975/73.wav", + "text": "及政府可以協助的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147975/74.wav", + "text": "各方資源不一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147975/75.wav", + "text": "這個我們清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147975/76.wav", + "text": "而臺南市政府也願意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147975/77.wav", + "text": "我們當時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147975/78.wav", + "text": "跟他們談的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147975/79.wav", + "text": "臺南市政府說非常願意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147975/80.wav", + "text": "如果南科願意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147975/81.wav", + "text": "把它納入他們的規劃範圍" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147975/82.wav", + "text": "他們也願意啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147975/83.wav", + "text": "重點是怎麼把台積電" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147975/84.wav", + "text": "留在我們臺南" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147975/85.wav", + "text": "怎麼把台積電" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147975/86.wav", + "text": "我們要讓它感受到桃" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147975/87.wav", + "text": "桃園不積極" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147975/88.wav", + "text": "的臺南很積極" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147975/89.wav", + "text": "所以部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147975/90.wav", + "text": "可以幫我們考慮一下嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147975/91.wav", + "text": "非常謝謝委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147975/92.wav", + "text": "我們其實非常高興看到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147975/93.wav", + "text": "地方政府" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147975/94.wav", + "text": "還有包括地方的委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147975/95.wav", + "text": "非常支持台積電" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147975/96.wav", + "text": "到各個地方去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147975/97.wav", + "text": "這個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147975/98.wav", + "text": "我們跟國科會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147975/99.wav", + "text": "在盤點的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147975/100.wav", + "text": "目前都還在討論當中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147975/101.wav", + "text": "你們現在考慮的面向是什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147975/102.wav", + "text": "很多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147975/103.wav", + "text": "包括土地水電" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147975/104.wav", + "text": "這是基本的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147975/105.wav", + "text": "是啊所以我剛剛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147975/106.wav", + "text": "就已經講了嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147975/107.wav", + "text": "土地沒有問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147975/108.wav", + "text": "水電也沒有問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147975/109.wav", + "text": "部長你們也去看過嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147975/110.wav", + "text": "是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147975/111.wav", + "text": "再生水" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147975/112.wav", + "text": "還有電的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147975/113.wav", + "text": "大家都開始在準備" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147975/114.wav", + "text": "大家也溝通了很久" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147975/115.wav", + "text": "所以土地沒有問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147975/116.wav", + "text": "水電沒有問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147975/117.wav", + "text": "這是兩大" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147975/118.wav", + "text": "最基本的要件" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147975/119.wav", + "text": "當然其他還在考量" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147975/120.wav", + "text": "土地跟水電" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147975/121.wav", + "text": "一定是最主要的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147975/122.wav", + "text": "所以我們準備好了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147975/123.wav", + "text": "臺南準備好了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147975/124.wav", + "text": "我們拜託" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147975/125.wav", + "text": "部長給我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147975/126.wav", + "text": "更多關愛的眼神" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147975/127.wav", + "text": "謝謝委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147975/128.wav", + "text": "陳建仁院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147975/129.wav", + "text": "提出我們的需求" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147975/130.wav", + "text": "我們希望能夠在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147975/131.wav", + "text": "不久的將來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147975/132.wav", + "text": "因為這很快" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147975/133.wav", + "text": "就要定案了嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147975/134.wav", + "text": "還要協助一些配套" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147975/135.wav", + "text": "所以要很快就定案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147975/136.wav", + "text": "能夠把臺南的分數" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147975/137.wav", + "text": "打在前面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147975/138.wav", + "text": "謝謝委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147975/139.wav", + "text": "我覺得這很重要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147975/140.wav", + "text": "你們行政部門" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147975/141.wav", + "text": "有沒有給臺南" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147975/142.wav", + "text": "多一些關愛的眼神" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147975/143.wav", + "text": "多一些比較好的印象分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147975/144.wav", + "text": "我相信這都會有影響" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147975/145.wav", + "text": "所以部長再麻煩你" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147975/146.wav", + "text": "另外一個區塊就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147975/147.wav", + "text": "我要正式在這裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147975/148.wav", + "text": "要一些資料" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147975/149.wav", + "text": "透過部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147975/150.wav", + "text": "就是現在森霸在申請變更" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147975/151.wav", + "text": "我需要請問它變更" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147975/152.wav", + "text": "了哪幾項項目" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147975/153.wav", + "text": "因為我覺得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147975/154.wav", + "text": "你們都在放水" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147975/155.wav", + "text": "你們根本就沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147975/156.wav", + "text": "站在第一線" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147975/157.wav", + "text": "去瞭解到底哪些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147975/158.wav", + "text": "跟原始的資料不同" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147975/159.wav", + "text": "跟原始的核准不同" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147975/160.wav", + "text": "看他怎麼提出申請" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147975/161.wav", + "text": "可是這些真的是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147975/162.wav", + "text": "原始的資料嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147975/163.wav", + "text": "還是根本就已經改了很多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147975/164.wav", + "text": "改到你們根本就不知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147975/165.wav", + "text": "什麼是原始的資料" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147975/166.wav", + "text": "這很嚴重" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147975/167.wav", + "text": "耶所以我在這裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147975/168.wav", + "text": "跟部長及署長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147975/169.wav", + "text": "我們已經發文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147975/170.wav", + "text": "經濟委員會的質詢臺當中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147975/171.wav", + "text": "提出要求" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147975/172.wav", + "text": "我們希望在兩個禮拜" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147975/173.wav", + "text": "它現在向我們能源署" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147975/174.wav", + "text": "申請變更的項目" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147975/175.wav", + "text": "而且我要再跟部長說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147975/176.wav", + "text": "它這些變更" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147975/177.wav", + "text": "早就已經都完成了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147975/178.wav", + "text": "完成之後才變更" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147975/179.wav", + "text": "喔你們現在是在做背書" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147975/180.wav", + "text": "當你們要做這個背書" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147975/181.wav", + "text": "你們要很小心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147975/182.wav", + "text": "不要到時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147975/183.wav", + "text": "哪一天烏紗帽不保了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147975/184.wav", + "text": "然後還影響到我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147975/185.wav", + "text": "臺南整個地方上的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147975/186.wav", + "text": "這是我們所擔心的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147975/187.wav", + "text": "這個部分麻煩" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147975/188.wav", + "text": "到底它今天提出了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147975/189.wav", + "text": "多少項的變更" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147975/190.wav", + "text": "因為我都有資料" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147975/191.wav", + "text": "有人檢舉陳情的資料" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147975/192.wav", + "text": "委員你可不可以先給我" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147975/193.wav", + "text": "我怎麼可能先給你" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147975/194.wav", + "text": "啊我可以先漏考題嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147975/195.wav", + "text": "不行吧" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147975/196.wav", + "text": "是你們先要把所有的資料" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147975/197.wav", + "text": "澈底去瞭解" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147975/198.wav", + "text": "包括我所說的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147975/199.wav", + "text": "我已經洩了一題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147975/200.wav", + "text": "啊在1支煙囪裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147975/201.wav", + "text": "原本的要求" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147975/202.wav", + "text": "現在只剩1根管子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147975/203.wav", + "text": "不是2支煙囪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147975/204.wav", + "text": "是1支煙囪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147975/205.wav", + "text": "裡面要2根管子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147975/206.wav", + "text": "那叫所謂的循環排氣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147975/207.wav", + "text": "它現在只1支煙囪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147975/208.wav", + "text": "裡面只有1根管子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147975/209.wav", + "text": "那個排不了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147975/210.wav", + "text": "不是要我看2支煙囪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147975/211.wav", + "text": "我們再跟委員做詳細說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147975/212.wav", + "text": "兩個禮拜我要相關資料" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147975/213.wav", + "text": "我在這裡正式請大家把它把關好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147975/214.wav", + "text": "因為這關係到我們臺南" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147975/215.wav", + "text": "等所有人民的安全問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147975/216.wav", + "text": "謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147972/0.wav", + "text": "有請部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147972/1.wav", + "text": "委員好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147972/2.wav", + "text": "部長好部長我們今天要討論的其實是長照需求逐年增加" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147972/3.wav", + "text": "到底我國應該推行長照的保險制度嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147972/4.wav", + "text": "差不多是這樣的意思啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147972/5.wav", + "text": "之所以要講到長照" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147972/6.wav", + "text": "是不是要能夠變成推行保險制度呢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147972/7.wav", + "text": "還是走現在的賦稅制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147972/8.wav", + "text": "其實是來自於現在坊間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147972/9.wav", + "text": "傳聞傳聞說長照預算會出現赤字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147972/10.wav", + "text": "所以各總統候選人也就紛紛針對這一題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147972/11.wav", + "text": "提出他們的政策和見解" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147972/12.wav", + "text": "以現在三位主要的候選人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147972/13.wav", + "text": "大家都已經知道的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147972/14.wav", + "text": "是主張開辦長照保險檢討現行制度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147972/15.wav", + "text": "坦白講這有講等於沒講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147972/16.wav", + "text": "是主張全面推動長照保險" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147972/17.wav", + "text": "而且他一開口就是希望規模要到2,300億元" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147972/18.wav", + "text": "是延續蔡政府目前的方向認為是用賦稅制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147972/19.wav", + "text": "而且他認為明年成長到876億元" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147972/20.wav", + "text": "以目前的稅收方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147972/21.wav", + "text": "支應長照的財源是足夠的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147972/22.wav", + "text": "部長我現在這樣的認知應該是沒有錯嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147972/23.wav", + "text": "今天你專案報告裡面的回應" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147972/24.wav", + "text": "我看對於長照是否要採保險制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147972/25.wav", + "text": "其實講得不太多也只有後面兩頁" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147972/26.wav", + "text": "那你的態度是怎麼樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147972/27.wav", + "text": "它的重點跟現在制度最大的不同" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147972/28.wav", + "text": "而且也算是它的缺點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147972/29.wav", + "text": "主要是有三個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147972/30.wav", + "text": "第一個長照保險沒有辦法去處理資源布建的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147972/31.wav", + "text": "對現在如果大家要收保費" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147972/32.wav", + "text": "這就是你剛剛說的當時我們健保之所以開辦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147972/33.wav", + "text": "是已經有醫療資源已經布建好了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147972/34.wav", + "text": "所以健保保險一開辦下去以後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147972/35.wav", + "text": "是立刻可以到這些機構下去的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147972/36.wav", + "text": "對除了很偏遠的地區之外大概都沒有問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147972/37.wav", + "text": "但是長照的體系並沒有那麼完全" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147972/38.wav", + "text": "我們目前用稅收制是以支定收" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147972/39.wav", + "text": "也就是說我們預算準備要花多少錢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147972/40.wav", + "text": "我們來看看財源夠不夠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147972/41.wav", + "text": "當然公務預算可以再去增加增加" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147972/42.wav", + "text": "再撥補下去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147972/43.wav", + "text": "但如果是保險制的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147972/44.wav", + "text": "它是叫做隨收隨付" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147972/45.wav", + "text": "所以你拿多少錢來你不能夠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147972/46.wav", + "text": "所以比較不能夠有長期性的計畫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147972/47.wav", + "text": "也不能夠做一些資源性的調" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147972/48.wav", + "text": "啦簡單來講就是這樣子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147972/49.wav", + "text": "收進來的錢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147972/50.wav", + "text": "要給在家庭自己照顧的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147972/51.wav", + "text": "所以用在現在比較可惜" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147972/52.wav", + "text": "這是你們的看法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147972/53.wav", + "text": "最後就會變成現金去負擔" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147972/54.wav", + "text": "第三點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147972/55.wav", + "text": "國外採取保險制的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147972/56.wav", + "text": "現在都沒有辦法支撐下去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147972/57.wav", + "text": "日本德國都已經面臨這樣的困難" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147972/58.wav", + "text": "主要原因是因為高齡化" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147972/59.wav", + "text": "對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147972/60.wav", + "text": "所以他們還是必須要有稅收去補充" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147972/61.wav", + "text": "好部長提出這三個理由" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147972/62.wav", + "text": "我是滿能夠理解的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147972/63.wav", + "text": "就已經對這個題目有很長期的認識" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147972/64.wav", + "text": "所以我們兩邊可以對話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147972/65.wav", + "text": "可是一般社會民眾" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147972/66.wav", + "text": "其實不太能夠瞭解這樣的狀況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147972/67.wav", + "text": "所以我長期的建議是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147972/68.wav", + "text": "衛福部好的政策" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147972/69.wav", + "text": "跟民眾溝通" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147972/70.wav", + "text": "比如您剛剛說的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147972/71.wav", + "text": "賦稅制跟保險制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147972/72.wav", + "text": "的這是一個公共政策" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147972/73.wav", + "text": "到底要採哪一種" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147972/74.wav", + "text": "其實不一定有定論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147972/75.wav", + "text": "而且隨著時間推移" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147972/76.wav", + "text": "社會情勢變化" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147972/77.wav", + "text": "部長當然剛剛看的是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147972/78.wav", + "text": "以現在來講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147972/79.wav", + "text": "我們認為採賦稅制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147972/80.wav", + "text": "是就現在2023年2024的臺灣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147972/81.wav", + "text": "是比較好的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147972/82.wav", + "text": "因為從機構的布建" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147972/83.wav", + "text": "一直到國外" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147972/84.wav", + "text": "跟臺灣一樣的高齡化社會等等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147972/85.wav", + "text": "有三大原因" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147972/86.wav", + "text": "可是事實上賦稅制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147972/87.wav", + "text": "的優點確實是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147972/88.wav", + "text": "無須額外負擔保費" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147972/89.wav", + "text": "社會資源重分配" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147972/90.wav", + "text": "但缺點是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147972/91.wav", + "text": "除政府撥補外" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147972/92.wav", + "text": "各項稅收的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147972/93.wav", + "text": "或者甚至菸捐的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147972/94.wav", + "text": "其實都是比較浮動的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147972/95.wav", + "text": "也難怪會有人主張要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147972/96.wav", + "text": "用保險制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147972/97.wav", + "text": "因為保險制相對來講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147972/98.wav", + "text": "優點的部分是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147972/99.wav", + "text": "財源由政府雇主被保險人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147972/100.wav", + "text": "共同負擔" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147972/101.wav", + "text": "相對穩定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147972/102.wav", + "text": "它收多少就是用多少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147972/103.wav", + "text": "沒有錯" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147972/104.wav", + "text": "但是它收的是很固定的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147972/105.wav", + "text": "但缺點是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147972/106.wav", + "text": "青壯年人會變成負擔的主力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147972/107.wav", + "text": "就這一點大家在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147972/108.wav", + "text": "思考這個政策的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147972/109.wav", + "text": "受薪階級有沒有想過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147972/110.wav", + "text": "其實未來他就是負擔的主力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147972/111.wav", + "text": "而且雇主的保費可能會轉嫁給" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147972/112.wav", + "text": "勞工或社會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147972/113.wav", + "text": "\n這個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147972/114.wav", + "text": "如果用文字的理論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147972/115.wav", + "text": "看不清楚的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147972/116.wav", + "text": "應該把它試算出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147972/117.wav", + "text": "我就用這2,300億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147972/118.wav", + "text": "規模的長照保險" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147972/119.wav", + "text": "來幫大家試算一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147972/120.wav", + "text": "如果是政府四成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147972/121.wav", + "text": "被保險人三成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147972/122.wav", + "text": "雇主三成的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147972/123.wav", + "text": "第一" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147972/124.wav", + "text": "政府的四成920億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147972/125.wav", + "text": "明年的876億還要多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147972/126.wav", + "text": "了這個財源要從哪裡來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147972/127.wav", + "text": "你看這個數字很清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147972/128.wav", + "text": "啊比明年還多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147972/129.wav", + "text": "對啦你可以說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147972/130.wav", + "text": "更多錢我可以做更多項目" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147972/131.wav", + "text": "但你的項目是哪一些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147972/132.wav", + "text": "也要拿出來討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147972/133.wav", + "text": "啊\n第二" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147972/134.wav", + "text": "我們先看最下面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147972/135.wav", + "text": "雇主三成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147972/136.wav", + "text": "已經負擔勞工保險" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147972/137.wav", + "text": "的健康保險之外" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147972/138.wav", + "text": "未來還要再幫你的員工" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147972/139.wav", + "text": "多加一筆長照保險費" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147972/140.wav", + "text": "對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147972/141.wav", + "text": "這是雇主" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147972/142.wav", + "text": "你還要再多加一筆" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147972/143.wav", + "text": "受薪階級的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147972/144.wav", + "text": "你如果是每個月繳交2," + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147972/145.wav", + "text": ",992元的四口之家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147972/146.wav", + "text": "你的薪水是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147972/147.wav", + "text": "目前統計的平均值" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147972/148.wav", + "text": "差不多四萬八" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147972/149.wav", + "text": "八一個月薪水四萬八的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147972/150.wav", + "text": "也就是你一年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147972/151.wav", + "text": "要增加將近一萬元" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147972/152.wav", + "text": "這個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147972/153.wav", + "text": "報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147972/154.wav", + "text": "我想你採用的是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147972/155.wav", + "text": "從零歲開始繳" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147972/156.wav", + "text": "是啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147972/157.wav", + "text": "對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147972/158.wav", + "text": "但是有些國家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147972/159.wav", + "text": "不是這樣子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147972/160.wav", + "text": "他會從比方" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147972/161.wav", + "text": "40歲或者幾歲才開始繳" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147972/162.wav", + "text": "如果是這樣子的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147972/163.wav", + "text": "更高" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147972/164.wav", + "text": "更高" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147972/165.wav", + "text": "所以剛剛文字的理論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147972/166.wav", + "text": "如果大家沒有辦法看清楚的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147972/167.wav", + "text": "衛福部其實應該把它" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147972/168.wav", + "text": "換算成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147972/169.wav", + "text": "人民看得懂的例子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147972/170.wav", + "text": "為什麼要換算成這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147972/171.wav", + "text": "是因為有利於" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147972/172.wav", + "text": "公共政策的討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147972/173.wav", + "text": "那你到底是要賦稅制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147972/174.wav", + "text": "還是要保險制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147972/175.wav", + "text": "這本來就是公共政策" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147972/176.wav", + "text": "這可以討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147972/177.wav", + "text": "但是討論要奠基在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147972/178.wav", + "text": "事實" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147972/179.wav", + "text": "且全面的資料上面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147972/180.wav", + "text": "所以第一" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147972/181.wav", + "text": "現在的長照" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147972/182.wav", + "text": "其實不算有赤字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147972/183.wav", + "text": "沒有赤字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147972/184.wav", + "text": "啊這樣的狀況下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147972/185.wav", + "text": "第一個這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147972/186.wav", + "text": "應該要破謠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147972/187.wav", + "text": "第二" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147972/188.wav", + "text": "個全面的資訊就在於" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147972/189.wav", + "text": "利和弊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147972/190.wav", + "text": "弊的部分同時要講出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147972/191.wav", + "text": "啊比如你在專案報告裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147972/192.wav", + "text": "每次調漲保費都引發抗爭" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147972/193.wav", + "text": "且雇主負擔保費之意願不高" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147972/194.wav", + "text": "恐會轉嫁壓低員工薪資" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147972/195.wav", + "text": "如果就剛才的數字看來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147972/196.wav", + "text": "我相信雇主跟" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147972/197.wav", + "text": "其實會認真地思考" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147972/198.wav", + "text": "\n所以我在在建議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147972/199.wav", + "text": "衛福部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147972/200.wav", + "text": "一直以來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147972/201.wav", + "text": "我們面對的真的就在於" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147972/202.wav", + "text": "你的政策設計執行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147972/203.wav", + "text": "是一回事" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147972/204.wav", + "text": "但是要能夠對社會說清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147972/205.wav", + "text": "又是另外一件事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147972/206.wav", + "text": "因此我今天用這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147972/207.wav", + "text": "跟部長再討論一次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147972/208.wav", + "text": "請用人民聽得懂的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147972/209.wav", + "text": "用我們的日常生活經驗" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147972/210.wav", + "text": "跟社會溝通" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147972/211.wav", + "text": "以爭取最大的支持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147972/212.wav", + "text": "謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147971/0.wav", + "text": "內政部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147971/1.wav", + "text": "你要請管理署署長嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147971/2.wav", + "text": "署長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147971/3.wav", + "text": "就已經完成立法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147971/4.wav", + "text": "中央希望各地方政府必須在114年4月30號" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147971/5.wav", + "text": "能夠發布各縣市的國土計畫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147971/6.wav", + "text": "特別是在第一階段第二階段的說明裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147971/7.wav", + "text": "事實上地方都還不是很瞭解" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147971/8.wav", + "text": "到第三階段國土功能分區圖的草案公布" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147971/9.wav", + "text": "布到地方說明以後大家才" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147971/10.wav", + "text": "覺得奇怪我的土地是住家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147971/11.wav", + "text": "怎麼會被劃入國土保安" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147971/12.wav", + "text": "所以很多地方對於國土計畫法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147971/13.wav", + "text": "我想你們應該都有接收到這些聲音" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147971/14.wav", + "text": "沒有錯吧" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147971/15.wav", + "text": "有的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147971/16.wav", + "text": "縣阿里山森林鐵路經過的鄉鎮" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147971/17.wav", + "text": "只有竹崎站" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147971/18.wav", + "text": "被劃為第一類的城鄉發展區而" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147971/19.wav", + "text": "已其他車站大概通通被劃成為國土保育區" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147971/20.wav", + "text": "連人潮最多的阿里山觀光勝地" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147971/21.wav", + "text": "車站周邊都被劃為國保一國保" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147971/22.wav", + "text": "保二你認為這樣合理嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147971/23.wav", + "text": "你認為像" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147971/24.wav", + "text": "像這樣劃分合理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147971/25.wav", + "text": "謝謝委員的指教" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147971/26.wav", + "text": "國土計畫目前各縣市的劃設" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147971/27.wav", + "text": "當然是由地方政府來劃設" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147971/28.wav", + "text": "被劃成國土一或者是農業用地" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147971/29.wav", + "text": "如果原來就有合法建築使用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147971/30.wav", + "text": "當然可以維持原來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147971/31.wav", + "text": "我知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147971/32.wav", + "text": "我只是提醒" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147971/33.wav", + "text": "國土計畫法這一種規劃方案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147971/34.wav", + "text": "事實上都是採大面積的劃設方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147971/35.wav", + "text": "這一點你也很清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147971/36.wav", + "text": "所以在國土功能分區圖都忽略" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147971/37.wav", + "text": "既存的這些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147971/38.wav", + "text": "聚落還有既存這些產業的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147971/39.wav", + "text": "所以劃下去之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147971/40.wav", + "text": "鄉鎮有的都超過50%都被劃為國土保育區" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147971/41.wav", + "text": "尤其是阿里山鐵路沿線的各鄉鎮" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147971/42.wav", + "text": "譬如阿里山鄉番路鄉竹崎鄉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147971/43.wav", + "text": "如果是這樣子的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147971/44.wav", + "text": "等於影響他們的生存" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147971/45.wav", + "text": "我想利用今天特別在這裡提出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147971/46.wav", + "text": "大家都知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147971/47.wav", + "text": "國保一就是禁止跟限制使用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147971/48.wav", + "text": "事實上他們就很難繼續生存" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147971/49.wav", + "text": "所以我特別用今天再一次提出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147971/50.wav", + "text": "當然國土計畫法還好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147971/51.wav", + "text": "鄉村地區的整體規劃" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147971/52.wav", + "text": "來做一個替代方案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147971/53.wav", + "text": "我也特別要在今天再一次提出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147971/54.wav", + "text": "部分大概我們就已經" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147971/55.wav", + "text": "譬如阿里山鄉番路鄉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147971/56.wav", + "text": "我們向內政部爭取了八百零多萬規劃費用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147971/57.wav", + "text": "現在這三個鄉村地區��體規劃" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147971/58.wav", + "text": "的草案大概也都已經" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147971/59.wav", + "text": "我在這裡要特別提出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147971/60.wav", + "text": "大概第一個是在強調居" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147971/61.wav", + "text": "第二個是產業發展" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147971/62.wav", + "text": "所謂居住正義就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147971/63.wav", + "text": "我們山區這些土地" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147971/64.wav", + "text": "大概都是這些土地" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147971/65.wav", + "text": "他們就在那裡安居" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147971/66.wav", + "text": "但是到國民政府來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147971/67.wav", + "text": "臺就把土地收歸為國有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147971/68.wav", + "text": "所以現在這些土地" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147971/69.wav", + "text": "甚至是不合法違法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147971/70.wav", + "text": "比如竹筍茶葉等都還是種在這個林班地上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147971/71.wav", + "text": "這一次利用國土計畫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147971/72.wav", + "text": "我們是不是也能夠把這些問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147971/73.wav", + "text": "做一次通盤解決" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147971/74.wav", + "text": "反對的聲音也大概沒有了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147971/75.wav", + "text": "目前就是在縣政府國土審議會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147971/76.wav", + "text": "還有財政部農業部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147971/77.wav", + "text": "沒有錯吧" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147971/78.wav", + "text": "國土管理署算是一個主要的業務機關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147971/79.wav", + "text": "沒有錯吧" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147971/80.wav", + "text": "那你認為這個草案送來後還有沒有什麼問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147971/81.wav", + "text": "這個部分你能不能簡單跟我說明一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147971/82.wav", + "text": "當然在國土計畫功能分區圖施行之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147971/83.wav", + "text": "並不代表民眾對他的土地" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147971/84.wav", + "text": "或相關的土地不能做變更" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147971/85.wav", + "text": "他還是可以循國土計畫的通盤檢討" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147971/86.wav", + "text": "另外剛剛委員談到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147971/87.wav", + "text": "鄉村整體規劃的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147971/88.wav", + "text": "的鄉村整體規劃" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147971/89.wav", + "text": "在縣的層級報上來之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147971/90.wav", + "text": "都會很審慎的來促成地方上的需求" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147971/91.wav", + "text": "好我想這樣子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147971/92.wav", + "text": "啦我剛剛也特別跟你說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147971/93.wav", + "text": "署財政部國有財產署" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147971/94.wav", + "text": "讓這個案子早日落實" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147971/95.wav", + "text": "讓我們嘉義縣這些山區的居民都能夠安心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147971/96.wav", + "text": "好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147971/97.wav", + "text": "是謝謝委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147971/98.wav", + "text": "好杜次長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147971/99.wav", + "text": "委員好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147971/100.wav", + "text": "農業部我想簡單啦因為時間關係" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147971/101.wav", + "text": "有關��里山獼猴搶食的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147971/102.wav", + "text": "這個到底有沒有什麼解決方案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147971/103.wav", + "text": "上一次我也特別提到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147971/104.wav", + "text": "但一直到現在為止好像" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147971/105.wav", + "text": "都沒有什麼解決方案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147971/106.wav", + "text": "是不是你能夠簡單" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147971/107.wav", + "text": "好謝謝委員關心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147971/108.wav", + "text": "不管是一般民眾也好或是農民也好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147971/109.wav", + "text": "都很有這方面的概念" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147971/110.wav", + "text": "像臺灣黑熊還有很多野生動物的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147971/111.wav", + "text": "復育狀況都漸漸可以看到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147971/112.wav", + "text": "野生動物就是野生動物" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147971/113.wav", + "text": "大家儘量不要接觸" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147971/114.wav", + "text": "牠也不要把沒有吃完的食物放進" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147971/115.wav", + "text": "進垃圾桶甚至沒有掩蓋好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147971/116.wav", + "text": "這樣很容易招致野生動物來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147971/117.wav", + "text": "講野生動物真的就是野生動物" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147971/118.wav", + "text": "們不要來接觸人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147971/119.wav", + "text": "所以大概只能從人類的行為去處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147971/120.wav", + "text": "他們也會儘量在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147971/121.wav", + "text": "因為如果牠們常常過來這邊吃東西" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147971/122.wav", + "text": "不是你現在說的內容" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147971/123.wav", + "text": "我只是要告訴你獼猴" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147971/124.wav", + "text": "不管是他的果園" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147971/125.wav", + "text": "甚至侵入他的民宅是越來越嚴重" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147971/126.wav", + "text": "我想這一點你也很清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147971/127.wav", + "text": "現在雖然野生動物保育法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147971/128.wav", + "text": "第21條規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147971/129.wav", + "text": "我們大概可以獵捕" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147971/130.wav", + "text": "甚至宰殺" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147971/131.wav", + "text": "民眾是不敢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147971/132.wav", + "text": "那要用什麼方式驅趕呢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147971/133.wav", + "text": "我想這個部分是我今天特別要提出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147971/134.wav", + "text": "但我想不是這個樣子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147971/135.wav", + "text": "現在已經危及公共安全" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147971/136.wav", + "text": "甚至危害到人類的生命安全" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147971/137.wav", + "text": "我們的主管機關都沒有什麼辦法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147971/138.wav", + "text": "坦白講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147971/139.wav", + "text": "基本上也是束手無策" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147971/140.wav", + "text": "他不敢殺" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147971/141.wav", + "text": "殺也不敢驅離" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147971/142.wav", + "text": "做一些消極的防範" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147971/143.wav", + "text": "已我的意思是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147971/144.wav", + "text": "你們要想出一套辦法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147971/145.wav", + "text": "我只是在這裡提醒你" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147971/146.wav", + "text": "讓山區的這些居民" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147971/147.wav", + "text": "有一個安全的空間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147971/148.wav", + "text": "不然你看那些水果果實" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147971/149.wav", + "text": "你知道嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147971/150.wav", + "text": "我們也不敢乾" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147971/151.wav", + "text": "牠對不對我是覺得這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147971/152.wav", + "text": "好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147971/153.wav", + "text": "好謝謝委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147971/154.wav", + "text": "我特別要在這裡再一次提醒你" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147971/155.wav", + "text": "不要每次一說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147971/156.wav", + "text": "大家就兩手一攤" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147971/157.wav", + "text": "這樣也不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147971/158.wav", + "text": "我想你們應該要有辦法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147971/159.wav", + "text": "來應付" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147971/160.wav", + "text": "謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147970/0.wav", + "text": "面對明年元月13號大選" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147970/1.wav", + "text": "跟立委選舉的查察賄選" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147970/2.wav", + "text": "法務部的基本立場" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147970/3.wav", + "text": "是不是可以說明一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147970/4.wav", + "text": "我們會積極地來查察" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147970/5.wav", + "text": "所有妨害選舉的案件" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147970/6.wav", + "text": "還有賭盤假訊息等等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147970/7.wav", + "text": "只要涉及到刑事責任" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147970/8.wav", + "text": "的我們檢察機關會統合調查局" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147970/9.wav", + "text": "還有警政移民廉政" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147970/10.wav", + "text": "大家一起共同來維護選舉的公平" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147970/11.wav", + "text": "部長本席要求" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147970/12.wav", + "text": "在檢調查察賄選的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147970/13.wav", + "text": "必須依法行政" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147970/14.wav", + "text": "不可以只查藍不查綠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147970/15.wav", + "text": "部長能不能做得到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147970/16.wav", + "text": "我們絕對遵守公平公正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147970/17.wav", + "text": "不分黨派" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147970/18.wav", + "text": "只要有違法的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147970/19.wav", + "text": "都會依法辦理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147970/20.wav", + "text": "我也要求檢調" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147970/21.wav", + "text": "在明年大選之前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147970/22.wav", + "text": "不要介入朝野的政治攻防" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147970/23.wav", + "text": "請問檢調能不能做得到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147970/24.wav", + "text": "我們絕對維持中立" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147970/25.wav", + "text": "就是不分黨派不分身分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147970/26.wav", + "text": "不涉入政治" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147970/27.wav", + "text": "完全是依法行事" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147970/28.wav", + "text": "希望部長說到做到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147970/29.wav", + "text": "另外請教國安局副局長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147970/30.wav", + "text": "依照目前掌握的事證" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147970/31.wav", + "text": "是否有境外勢力在干預選舉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147970/32.wav", + "text": "情況怎麼樣可不可以說明一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147970/33.wav", + "text": "我們的確有掌握到一些情資" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147970/34.wav", + "text": "中共還是會運用很多的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147970/35.wav", + "text": "或者是一些同路人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147970/36.wav", + "text": "對我們的選舉有所影響" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147970/37.wav", + "text": "目前具體的事證怎麼樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147970/38.wav", + "text": "可不可以說明更具體一點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147970/39.wav", + "text": "因為涉及到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147970/40.wav", + "text": "因為有很多涉及到個案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147970/41.wav", + "text": "有些情資還在蒐整中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147970/42.wav", + "text": "不方便在這裡提出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147970/43.wav", + "text": "好那國安局怎麼去防止這種情況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147970/44.wav", + "text": "我們收到所有的情資" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147970/45.wav", + "text": "會轉給相關的單位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147970/46.wav", + "text": "如果是屬於行政部門" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147970/47.wav", + "text": "也提早應處" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147970/48.wav", + "text": "如果涉及到違法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147970/49.wav", + "text": "已經符合像選罷法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147970/50.wav", + "text": "或者是反滲透法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147970/51.wav", + "text": "我們會移給調查局" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147970/52.wav", + "text": "及其他司法機關進行查處" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147970/53.wav", + "text": "好接著請教部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147970/54.wav", + "text": "剛剛王鴻薇委員提到了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147970/55.wav", + "text": "這兩天在網路上傳的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147970/56.wav", + "text": "鄭文燦副院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147970/57.wav", + "text": "我是看電視上的報導" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147970/58.wav", + "text": "那你初步判斷" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147970/59.wav", + "text": "這個影片有沒有被變造過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147970/60.wav", + "text": "初步看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147970/61.wav", + "text": "我不能從電視的報導" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147970/62.wav", + "text": "來做一個結論的判斷" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147970/63.wav", + "text": "不過我想當事人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147970/64.wav", + "text": "已經要提出告訴" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147970/65.wav", + "text": "如果告訴" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147970/66.wav", + "text": "繫屬在相關的單位的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147970/67.wav", + "text": "它就會依法來辦理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147970/68.wav", + "text": "影片中的人是不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147970/69.wav", + "text": "鄭文燦副院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147970/70.wav", + "text": "我們不能只憑這樣的報導" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147970/71.wav", + "text": "來做判斷" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147970/72.wav", + "text": "還是要由有權的機關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147970/73.wav", + "text": "依照法定的程序來認定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147970/74.wav", + "text": "好接著請國安局副局長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147970/75.wav", + "text": "有關趙天麟交往的大陸友人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147970/76.wav", + "text": "請問副局長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147970/77.wav", + "text": "知不知道他叫什麼名字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147970/78.wav", + "text": "我目前得到的消息" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147970/79.wav", + "text": "是張晴嗎是不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147970/80.wav", + "text": "他是哪裡人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147970/81.wav", + "text": "曉不曉得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147970/82.wav", + "text": "如果都是從網路上得到的新聞" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147970/83.wav", + "text": "我來回答委員就太不禮貌" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147970/84.wav", + "text": "所以這個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147970/85.wav", + "text": "沒有關係你可以講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147970/86.wav", + "text": "我認為你很有禮貌" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147970/87.wav", + "text": "難得難得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147970/88.wav", + "text": "來不要客氣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147970/89.wav", + "text": "啊這個事情其實是很嚴肅的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147970/90.wav", + "text": "是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147970/91.wav", + "text": "你說吧" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147970/92.wav", + "text": "同仁還沒有給我這一方面的資料" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147970/93.wav", + "text": "現在可以給你" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147970/94.wav", + "text": "不要該給的不給不給又亂給" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147970/95.wav", + "text": "江西萍鄉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147970/96.wav", + "text": "這個是誰你知道嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147970/97.wav", + "text": "前委員這兩天po在臉書上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147970/98.wav", + "text": "確認" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147970/99.wav", + "text": "這個事情發生之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147970/100.wav", + "text": "國安局對張晴這位女士" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147970/101.wav", + "text": "瞭不瞭解" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147970/102.wav", + "text": "我們不好從網路新聞分析" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147970/103.wav", + "text": "不過對於合法申請來臺的陸人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147970/104.wav", + "text": "在臺期間有通報異常或違常的現象" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147970/105.wav", + "text": "我們就會依法注蒐" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147970/106.wav", + "text": "蒐如果有違法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147970/107.wav", + "text": "我們就會送調查局或其他司法機關懲處" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147970/108.wav", + "text": "當時進來就是合法申請" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147970/109.wav", + "text": "沒有通報" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147970/110.wav", + "text": "沒有通報說有違異常現象" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147970/111.wav", + "text": "那他是不是有統戰機構盟員的身" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147970/112.wav", + "text": "目前瞭解中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147970/113.wav", + "text": "瞭解中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147970/114.wav", + "text": "瞭解的時間要多久" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147970/115.wav", + "text": "這個還是要一點時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147970/116.wav", + "text": "耶不然你跟後面那位先生換請他來報" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147970/117.wav", + "text": "有些事情在公開場合不方便說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147970/118.wav", + "text": "能不能說你當副局長會判斷" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147970/119.wav", + "text": "啊你怎麼讓後面的官員決定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147970/120.wav", + "text": "而且我們蒐集是有進展的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147970/121.wav", + "text": "所以我必須要有最新的資訊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147970/122.wav", + "text": "所以初步瞭解張晴女士" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147970/123.wav", + "text": "士過去來臺灣沒有通報" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147970/124.wav", + "text": "沒有通報" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147970/125.wav", + "text": "他是不是中國大陸統戰機構的盟員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147970/126.wav", + "text": "瞭解中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147970/127.wav", + "text": "瞭解中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147970/128.wav", + "text": "可能性高不高" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147970/129.wav", + "text": "這個沒辦法評估" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147970/130.wav", + "text": "他是有意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147970/131.wav", + "text": "故意來接觸" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147970/132.wav", + "text": "趙天麟委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147970/133.wav", + "text": "還是自然發展的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147970/134.wav", + "text": "你初步的看法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147970/135.wav", + "text": "這個我也沒辦法評估" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147970/136.wav", + "text": "那要找誰評估" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147970/137.wav", + "text": "報告委員我們會持續瞭解" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147970/138.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147970/139.wav", + "text": "我是提假設性的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147970/140.wav", + "text": "假設這個張晴小姐是有意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147970/141.wav", + "text": "來跟趙天麟委員接觸" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147970/142.wav", + "text": "又當過三屆國" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147970/143.wav", + "text": "防委員會的召委" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147970/144.wav", + "text": "你認為對國安會不會有影響" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147970/145.wav", + "text": "委員現在問的問題已經到達" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147970/146.wav", + "text": "司法調查的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147970/147.wav", + "text": "階段了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147970/148.wav", + "text": "恐怕應該由" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147970/149.wav", + "text": "負責的機關來處理比較好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147970/150.wav", + "text": "那你認為誰該介入調查你說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147970/151.wav", + "text": "如果涉及軍事機密的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147970/152.wav", + "text": "負責的當然就是臺高檢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147970/153.wav", + "text": "調查局" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147970/154.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147970/155.wav", + "text": "部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147970/156.wav", + "text": "這個案子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147970/157.wav", + "text": "立案調查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147970/158.wav", + "text": "我們的檢調機關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147970/159.wav", + "text": "都會依法辦理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147970/160.wav", + "text": "昨天也講了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147970/161.wav", + "text": "我相信運鵬委員也聽到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147970/162.wav", + "text": "了他接受調查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147970/163.wav", + "text": "我們要求" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147970/164.wav", + "text": "高檢立案調查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147970/165.wav", + "text": "部長贊不贊成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147970/166.wav", + "text": "高檢還有調查局" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147970/167.wav", + "text": "都在蒐集相關的資料" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147970/168.wav", + "text": "來瞭解" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147970/169.wav", + "text": "如果有分案調查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147970/170.wav", + "text": "有進一步調查的必要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147970/171.wav", + "text": "他們一定會採取這樣的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147970/172.wav", + "text": "部長回去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147970/173.wav", + "text": "能不能轉達" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147970/174.wav", + "text": "轉達高檢署" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147970/175.wav", + "text": "立案調查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147970/176.wav", + "text": "有沒有問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147970/177.wav", + "text": "有沒有困難" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147970/178.wav", + "text": "我會轉達委員的意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147970/179.wav", + "text": "好謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147970/180.wav", + "text": "好謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147969/0.wav", + "text": "好黃主委來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147969/1.wav", + "text": "我看剛才賴委員的時間剩下不太夠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147969/2.wav", + "text": "他沒問到的我就幫他問" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147969/3.wav", + "text": "在第12頁跟第13頁這裡有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147969/4.wav", + "text": "交易發展其" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147969/5.wav", + "text": "實施概況它" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147969/6.wav", + "text": "今）年前三季的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147969/7.wav", + "text": "非現金支付交易筆數要達" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147969/8.wav", + "text": "筆希望它的交易金額能夠達到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147969/9.wav", + "text": "新臺幣4.5兆" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147969/10.wav", + "text": "但是後面我看它的實施成果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147969/11.wav", + "text": "上半年達成31.33億筆" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147969/12.wav", + "text": "達到新臺幣3.63兆" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147969/13.wav", + "text": "前三季的目標" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147969/14.wav", + "text": "實施成果寫上半年的成果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147969/15.wav", + "text": "究竟第三季的狀況怎麼樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147969/16.wav", + "text": "我們這個非現金支付" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147969/17.wav", + "text": "前三季到底有沒有達成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147969/18.wav", + "text": "74億筆的交易" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147969/19.wav", + "text": "有沒有達成4." + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147969/20.wav", + "text": "4.5兆元這個金額" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147969/21.wav", + "text": "委員我先跟您抱歉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147969/22.wav", + "text": "我們在預算書呈現的不一致" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147969/23.wav", + "text": "我們會改進" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147969/24.wav", + "text": "我初步先跟您報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147969/25.wav", + "text": "筆數部分我們沒有達到目標" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147969/26.wav", + "text": "但是金額部分有達到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147969/27.wav", + "text": "是不是請局長跟您做比較細部的報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147969/28.wav", + "text": "首先還是一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147969/29.wav", + "text": "致歉就是呈現的方式其實" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147969/30.wav", + "text": "是不太恰當的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147969/31.wav", + "text": "跟委員報告其實整體而言" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147969/32.wav", + "text": "因為我們今年的目標是2023年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147969/33.wav", + "text": "要達到消費的6兆" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147969/34.wav", + "text": "現在這個目標如果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147969/35.wav", + "text": "就以季來看的話其實" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147969/36.wav", + "text": "是已經超前了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147969/37.wav", + "text": "筆數確實還是不夠筆" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147969/38.wav", + "text": "筆數還是不夠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147969/39.wav", + "text": "但是金額是超前就對了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147969/40.wav", + "text": "非現金支付的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147969/41.wav", + "text": "我們在去年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147969/42.wav", + "text": "1月開始" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147969/43.wav", + "text": "就實施這個電支條例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147969/44.wav", + "text": "剛才賴委員也特別提到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147969/45.wav", + "text": "我們就是希望這些電子支付" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147969/46.wav", + "text": "建置這些共同的平台就有利於這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147969/47.wav", + "text": "業者能夠分享服務" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147969/48.wav", + "text": "分享清算消費者在使用上面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147969/49.wav", + "text": "也能夠便利" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147969/50.wav", + "text": "我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147969/51.wav", + "text": "24號對外發表了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147969/52.wav", + "text": "的使用把所有這些QR Code" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147969/53.wav", + "text": "以後去店家就不用說我用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147969/54.wav", + "text": "街口我要掃這個我用哪一個要掃那個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147969/55.wav", + "text": "我們目標是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147969/56.wav", + "text": "都使用同一個QR Code" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147969/57.wav", + "text": "來說都是便利很多對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147969/58.wav", + "text": "是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147969/59.wav", + "text": "過程裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147969/60.wav", + "text": "目前已經加入的兩天前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147969/61.wav", + "text": "加入的有37家金融機構" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147969/62.wav", + "text": "這個電子支付的機構" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147969/63.wav", + "text": "全盈支付一卡通" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147969/64.wav", + "text": "橘子跟歐付寶4家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147969/65.wav", + "text": "未來預計要加入的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147969/66.wav", + "text": "有簡單支付愛金卡全支付" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147969/67.wav", + "text": "悠遊付街口支付" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147969/68.wav", + "text": "加入的這些大概什麼時候可以加入" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147969/69.wav", + "text": "因為現在加入的這4家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147969/70.wav", + "text": "全盈一卡通" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147969/71.wav", + "text": "橘子支付歐付寶" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147969/72.wav", + "text": "其實它還是一部分而已" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147969/73.wav", + "text": "是這個請" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147969/74.wav", + "text": "局長做說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147969/75.wav", + "text": "確實到了明年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147969/76.wav", + "text": "會有更多的加入主要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147969/77.wav", + "text": "會到明年才能完全加入" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147969/78.wav", + "text": "也是因為明年什麼時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147969/79.wav", + "text": "兩個月就是明年明年上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147969/80.wav", + "text": "半年明年上半年也就是說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147969/81.wav", + "text": "對街口跟一卡通" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147969/82.wav", + "text": "街口跟一卡通嘛一卡通已經" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147969/83.wav", + "text": "還沒有在目前我們這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147969/84.wav", + "text": "也就是說我們開了記者會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147969/85.wav", + "text": "說以後大家只要用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147969/86.wav", + "text": "要另外掃目前的狀況是這樣子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147969/87.wav", + "text": "對不對那預計" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147969/88.wav", + "text": "他們還沒加入主要是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147969/89.wav", + "text": "因為他們資訊排程" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147969/90.wav", + "text": "的關係所以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147969/91.wav", + "text": "會到明年才能加入" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147969/92.wav", + "text": "會到明年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147969/93.wav", + "text": "嘛那其他第三方支付像" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147969/94.wav", + "text": "有沒有可能也整合" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147969/95.wav", + "text": "因為我們現在處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147969/96.wav", + "text": "的第三方支付這方面是數位部在管" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147969/97.wav", + "text": "的我們這邊先以電子支付為主" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147969/98.wav", + "text": "消費者不知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147969/99.wav", + "text": "我這個是街口支付" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147969/100.wav", + "text": "不是政府說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147969/101.wav", + "text": "整合了嗎那我街口支付要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147969/102.wav", + "text": "掃一個LINE Pay又不一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147969/103.wav", + "text": "報告委員我想" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147969/104.wav", + "text": "我們先從金管會主管" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147969/105.wav", + "text": "的這些機構來處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147969/106.wav", + "text": "啦未來我們會跟數位部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147969/107.wav", + "text": "再聯繫看看他們對這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147969/108.wav", + "text": "也有提到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147969/109.wav", + "text": "能夠達到15萬家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147969/110.wav", + "text": "TWQR購物的場域你們希望" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147969/111.wav", + "text": "明年要達到15萬家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147969/112.wav", + "text": "目前有多少家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147969/113.wav", + "text": "這些特店主要是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147969/114.wav", + "text": "財金公司他們在整合" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147969/115.wav", + "text": "的所以這個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147969/116.wav", + "text": "所以你不知道你們要監理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147969/117.wav", + "text": "我們數字統計一下再跟委員報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147969/118.wav", + "text": "開記者會公布了大家各個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147969/119.wav", + "text": "單位來了大家去了結果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147969/120.wav", + "text": "怎麼騙人我去的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147969/121.wav", + "text": "都沒有一個地方" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147969/122.wav", + "text": "到底有多少地方可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147969/123.wav", + "text": "我覺得委員您" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147969/124.wav", + "text": "垂詢的是正確的我們會趕快去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147969/125.wav", + "text": "統計出來然後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147969/126.wav", + "text": "儘量在識別上讓消費者清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147969/127.wav", + "text": "好至少就現階段你說明年目標" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147969/128.wav", + "text": "15萬家那你現在已經公布" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147969/129.wav", + "text": "布你不可能是1家都還沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147969/130.wav", + "text": "就公布嘛所以現在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147969/131.wav", + "text": "你們一定有一個數字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147969/132.wav", + "text": "這個現在你們不知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147969/133.wav", + "text": "要問財金公司才知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147969/134.wav", + "text": "其實如果以現在已經加入" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147969/135.wav", + "text": "的應該有一定的規模了啦當然" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147969/136.wav", + "text": "後面還沒有加入的也有一些規模" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147969/137.wav", + "text": "很大的不過委員您" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147969/138.wav", + "text": "垂詢的是對的我們要趕快把" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147969/139.wav", + "text": "已經加入可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147969/140.wav", + "text": "使用的這些特店要讓民眾" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147969/141.wav", + "text": "知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147969/142.wav", + "text": "對主委剛剛有提到這個部分確實" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147969/143.wav", + "text": "是財金公司在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147969/144.wav", + "text": "負責啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147969/145.wav", + "text": "的監理機構所以這些問題我提出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147969/146.wav", + "text": "是希望金管是委員您" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147969/147.wav", + "text": "指導的我完全接受" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147969/148.wav", + "text": "我現在提另外一個問題過去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147969/149.wav", + "text": "你用各家不同的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147969/150.wav", + "text": "支付的QR Code去掃描" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147969/151.wav", + "text": "之後他遇到問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147969/152.wav", + "text": "客服要找誰很清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147969/153.wav", + "text": "在掃碼的過程中如果遇到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147969/154.wav", + "text": "問題他的客服" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147969/155.wav", + "text": "今天早上我還上線" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147969/156.wav", + "text": "官網上面沒有任何" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147969/157.wav", + "text": "客服資訊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147969/158.wav", + "text": "財金公司的官網上面沒有任何的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147969/159.wav", + "text": "客服資訊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147969/160.wav", + "text": "好委員您指導的我們立刻去處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147969/161.wav", + "text": "消費糾紛個資事件" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147969/162.wav", + "text": "你要如何歸責也都不知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147969/163.wav", + "text": "是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147969/164.wav", + "text": "這部分請金管會要跟" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147969/165.wav", + "text": "財金公司這邊來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147969/166.wav", + "text": "既然提出了一個新的整合" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147969/167.wav", + "text": "平台你就應該要有這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147969/168.wav", + "text": "客服機構之" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147969/169.wav", + "text": "之聯絡方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147969/170.wav", + "text": "是委員您指示的事項我們會立刻去處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147969/171.wav", + "text": "到現在好像還是只能綁定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147969/172.wav", + "text": "對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147969/173.wav", + "text": "信用卡什麼時候才可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147969/174.wav", + "text": "的人都綁定信用卡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147969/175.wav", + "text": "你現在只能綁定存款帳號" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147969/176.wav", + "text": "信用卡綁定的支付功能什麼時候才可以上線" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147969/177.wav", + "text": "報告委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147969/178.wav", + "text": "裡面有一些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147969/179.wav", + "text": "比較複雜的關係" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147969/180.wav", + "text": "譬如說還有手續" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147969/181.wav", + "text": "我知道比較複雜那你們的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147969/182.wav", + "text": "目標是怎麼樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147969/183.wav", + "text": "是以後一直使用都不能" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147969/184.wav", + "text": "綁信用卡還是說你們有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147969/185.wav", + "text": "一個預計的什麼樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147969/186.wav", + "text": "的狀況什麼樣的條件" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147969/187.wav", + "text": "什麼樣的時程" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147969/188.wav", + "text": "我們可以綁定信用卡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147969/189.wav", + "text": "報告委員當初我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147969/190.wav", + "text": "想要推這個整合平台的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147969/191.wav", + "text": "其實有考慮到信用卡的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147969/192.wav", + "text": "這個也一定會推" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147969/193.wav", + "text": "只不過現在是先從" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147969/194.wav", + "text": "比較簡單的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147969/195.wav", + "text": "至於那個目標的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147969/196.wav", + "text": "我想是等大家全部上線了之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147969/197.wav", + "text": "明年下半年之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147969/198.wav", + "text": "明年下半年我覺得是不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147969/199.wav", + "text": "同步進行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147969/200.wav", + "text": "你不要說等到明年全部上線之後才" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147969/201.wav", + "text": "開始規劃" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147969/202.wav", + "text": "其實應該要同步進行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147969/203.wav", + "text": "因為現在大部分的成年人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147969/204.wav", + "text": "都綁定信用卡才是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147969/205.wav", + "text": "最方便的支付使用方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147969/206.wav", + "text": "再來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147969/207.wav", + "text": "這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147969/208.wav", + "text": "我看有推廣的活動" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147969/209.wav", + "text": "在現在這個期間內" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147969/210.wav", + "text": "自112年11月1號到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147969/211.wav", + "text": "112年12月31號" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147969/212.wav", + "text": "2個月的時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147969/213.wav", + "text": "見面禮" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147969/214.wav", + "text": "這樣子的推廣活動對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147969/215.wav", + "text": "請局長回答對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147969/216.wav", + "text": "是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147969/217.wav", + "text": "但這個資訊有誰知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147969/218.wav", + "text": "現在有誰在推廣這個資訊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147969/219.wav", + "text": "現在你所說的37家金融機構" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147969/220.wav", + "text": "查了你們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147969/221.wav", + "text": "說的這些官網" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147969/222.wav", + "text": "只有1家財團法人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147969/223.wav", + "text": "農漁會南區資訊中心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147969/224.wav", + "text": "這個推廣活動的優惠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147969/225.wav", + "text": "其他沒有任何一家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147969/226.wav", + "text": "在講誰知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147969/227.wav", + "text": "我是因為要質詢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147969/228.wav", + "text": "我去查我才知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147969/229.wav", + "text": "要不然連我都不知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147969/230.wav", + "text": "就可以享10%的見面禮" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147969/231.wav", + "text": "這部分是不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147969/232.wav", + "text": "加強我們的推廣力度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147969/233.wav", + "text": "要求他們提高這些參與" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147969/234.wav", + "text": "把這個東西讓大家一起推廣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147969/235.wav", + "text": "嘛不然辦這個活動又沒有人知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147969/236.wav", + "text": "這叫什麼推廣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147969/237.wav", + "text": "呢好不好主委" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147969/238.wav", + "text": "好報告委員我想您今天的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147969/239.wav", + "text": "垂詢我們會照您的指示去處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147969/240.wav", + "text": "謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147969/241.wav", + "text": "這部分我是覺得很好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147969/242.wav", + "text": "啦但是我剛剛所提的這些問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147969/243.wav", + "text": "有哪一些部分我們應該" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147969/244.wav", + "text": "在後續" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147969/245.wav", + "text": "趕快要補的就趕快把它補瞭解" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147968/0.wav", + "text": "主委早安" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147968/1.wav", + "text": "主委自從您上任之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147968/2.wav", + "text": "剛剛您在報告的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147968/3.wav", + "text": "在今年5月26號" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147968/4.wav", + "text": "已經三讀通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147968/5.wav", + "text": "在6月21號的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147968/6.wav", + "text": "總統也都已經公告了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147968/7.wav", + "text": "可是大家所關心的是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147968/8.wav", + "text": "我們什麼時候才會正式的施行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147968/9.wav", + "text": "是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147968/10.wav", + "text": "海產條例它要施行的第一步" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147968/11.wav", + "text": "就是我們各部會對於海洋產業的共識" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147968/12.wav", + "text": "就是什麼是海洋產業" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147968/13.wav", + "text": "它的主政單位是什麼部會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147968/14.wav", + "text": "然後相關部會是什麼部會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147968/15.wav", + "text": "然後彼此如何分工" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147968/16.wav", + "text": "各負責什麼樣的內容" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147968/17.wav", + "text": "這個部分需要全部下去做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147968/18.wav", + "text": "跨部會的溝通協調" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147968/19.wav", + "text": "我們在這段期間就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147968/20.wav", + "text": "陸陸續續在做這個部分的溝通協調" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147968/21.wav", + "text": "絕大多數的產業項目" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147968/22.wav", + "text": "都已經協調完成了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147968/23.wav", + "text": "海洋資訊服務" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147968/24.wav", + "text": "還有海洋生物科技" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147968/25.wav", + "text": "最主要是這兩項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147968/26.wav", + "text": "監測的部分也完成了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147968/27.wav", + "text": "對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147968/28.wav", + "text": "本來有三項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147968/29.wav", + "text": "剛剛處長說現在剩下兩項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147968/30.wav", + "text": "這個如果完成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147968/31.wav", + "text": "大概施行的工作" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147968/32.wav", + "text": "我們就可以請行政院來支持了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147968/33.wav", + "text": "\n我們現在是在想" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147968/34.wav", + "text": "這個工作完成以後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147968/35.wav", + "text": "我們還想要更進一步做得更好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147968/36.wav", + "text": "想要把產值抓出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147968/37.wav", + "text": "就是整個海洋產業" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147968/38.wav", + "text": "的各個不同產業中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147968/39.wav", + "text": "我們臺灣的產值是多少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147968/40.wav", + "text": "然後總體海洋產業的產值是多少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147968/41.wav", + "text": "不是溝通完就實施" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147968/42.wav", + "text": "反正不急嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147968/43.wav", + "text": "為什麼不急" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147968/44.wav", + "text": "因為工作我們其實都已經在做了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147968/45.wav", + "text": "做得更成熟" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147968/46.wav", + "text": "所以也是有考慮到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147968/47.wav", + "text": "我們就把產值也算出來的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147968/48.wav", + "text": "所以這個年底會完成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147968/49.wav", + "text": "這件事情我們已經進行到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147968/50.wav", + "text": "快要把產值" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147968/51.wav", + "text": "就是有一些產值" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147968/52.wav", + "text": "它的營業額是海陸不分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147968/53.wav", + "text": "所以這部分比較需要花時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147968/54.wav", + "text": "要不然的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147968/55.wav", + "text": "大部分的產值" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147968/56.wav", + "text": "我們大概也都算得差不多了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147968/57.wav", + "text": "整個加起來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147968/58.wav", + "text": "海洋產業的部分我們目前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147968/59.wav", + "text": "大概是1兆5,000億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147968/60.wav", + "text": "完成了以後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147968/61.wav", + "text": "就可以公告實施" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147968/62.wav", + "text": "就開始實施然後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147968/63.wav", + "text": "後我們在最後這兩個月來作業" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147968/64.wav", + "text": "OK瞭解因為現在還是有一些業者會擔心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147968/65.wav", + "text": "這畢竟是一個產業" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147968/66.wav", + "text": "當然我們很開心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147968/67.wav", + "text": "是現在在抓產值" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147968/68.wav", + "text": "就像主委剛所提到的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147968/69.wav", + "text": "有海洋生技海洋資訊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147968/70.wav", + "text": "海洋觀光跟遊憩等等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147968/71.wav", + "text": "到底是誰要來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147968/72.wav", + "text": "遊憩也分運動" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147968/73.wav", + "text": "還有遊艇船舶" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147968/74.wav", + "text": "所以這都還是要有一些單位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147968/75.wav", + "text": "有所謂的認養就" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147968/76.wav", + "text": "權責單位一定要出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147968/77.wav", + "text": "雖然我們是海洋國家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147968/78.wav", + "text": "可是像我們的海洋產業裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147968/79.wav", + "text": "我們是海洋國家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147968/80.wav", + "text": "可是我們的海洋運動" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147968/81.wav", + "text": "發展是非常的緩慢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147968/82.wav", + "text": "當然我們非常的開心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147968/83.wav", + "text": "我們可以來發展海洋運動" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147968/84.wav", + "text": "權責的部分是非常的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147968/85.wav", + "text": "是不清楚的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147968/86.wav", + "text": "最後教育部認養了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147968/87.wav", + "text": "現在是教育部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147968/88.wav", + "text": "我也在想應該是教育部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147968/89.wav", + "text": "因為像今年初三月份的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147968/90.wav", + "text": "臺灣自由潛水協會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147968/91.wav", + "text": "它在屏東辦理了一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147968/92.wav", + "text": "自由潛水深度賽的運動" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147968/93.wav", + "text": "那時候這個協會有來找我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147968/94.wav", + "text": "它說這個公文往返很多個單位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147968/95.wav", + "text": "有到觀光局去了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147968/96.wav", + "text": "還有地方政府等等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147968/97.wav", + "text": "可是大家幾乎都推來推去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147968/98.wav", + "text": "有點這種狀況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147968/99.wav", + "text": "發生所以單單一個海洋運動" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147968/100.wav", + "text": "到底屬於誰的權責的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147968/101.wav", + "text": "當然現在我們希望OK" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147968/102.wav", + "text": "像潛水這個部分的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147968/103.wav", + "text": "它是海洋運動" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147968/104.wav", + "text": "應該是就屬於" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147968/105.wav", + "text": "教育部體育署的部分了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147968/106.wav", + "text": "對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147968/107.wav", + "text": "其實這個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147968/108.wav", + "text": "屬於運動的部分是體育部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147968/109.wav", + "text": "另外就是休閒的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147968/110.wav", + "text": "是屬於觀光署" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147968/111.wav", + "text": "但是這裡面就出了一件事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147968/112.wav", + "text": "如果它是屬於休閒的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147968/113.wav", + "text": "因為他們也有在用營運的方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147968/114.wav", + "text": "如果是比賽呢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147968/115.wav", + "text": "教練的證照誰發" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147968/116.wav", + "text": "確實很需要我們去介入協調" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147968/117.wav", + "text": "那我們是比較支持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147968/118.wav", + "text": "由教育部來發" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147968/119.wav", + "text": "因為教育部他用運動教練的指標" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147968/120.wav", + "text": "下去考試的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147968/121.wav", + "text": "會更嚴格更專業" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147968/122.wav", + "text": "所以這個部分教育部有接受" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147968/123.wav", + "text": "還有一點就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147968/124.wav", + "text": "關於保險的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147968/125.wav", + "text": "我們經常辦一些運動" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147968/126.wav", + "text": "其實都還是要有所謂的保險" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147968/127.wav", + "text": "像這個臺灣自由潛水協會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147968/128.wav", + "text": "它在3月的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147968/129.wav", + "text": "就是要辦這個比賽" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147968/130.wav", + "text": "其實它那時候要保險" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147968/131.wav", + "text": "可是很多保險公司是拒保的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147968/132.wav", + "text": "它覺得你這是屬於高危險性的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147968/133.wav", + "text": "它現在是拒保的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147968/134.wav", + "text": "找他們來做一個協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147968/135.wav", + "text": "其實我們還有一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147968/136.wav", + "text": "所謂的海域險" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147968/137.wav", + "text": "可是我們的海域險" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147968/138.wav", + "text": "居然是不包含所謂潛水活動" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147968/139.wav", + "text": "它只包含浮潛對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147968/140.wav", + "text": "可是在海底下的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147968/141.wav", + "text": "它就不包括在內了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147968/142.wav", + "text": "像這個部分的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147968/143.wav", + "text": "以後辦這種潛水活動" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147968/144.wav", + "text": "主要是因為沒有可以評估的數據" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147968/145.wav", + "text": "這個部分後來有協調的結果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147968/146.wav", + "text": "就是您剛剛說的委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147968/147.wav", + "text": "也一直努力的在溝通" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147968/148.wav", + "text": "嘛所以就是採個案式的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147968/149.wav", + "text": "如果你是辦活動你是辦比賽" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147968/150.wav", + "text": "個案式的會協助他們有保險" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147968/151.wav", + "text": "另外就是說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147968/152.wav", + "text": "我們承認在這個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147968/153.wav", + "text": "你們去買國外的保險" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147968/154.wav", + "text": "這個部分是是這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147968/155.wav", + "text": "但是國內的保單" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147968/156.wav", + "text": "目前還沒有任何保險公司" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147968/157.wav", + "text": "他們可以作出保單" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147968/158.wav", + "text": "主要是我們還沒有足夠的數據" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147968/159.wav", + "text": "給他們去做評估" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147968/160.wav", + "text": "做精算的基礎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147968/161.wav", + "text": "因為我在想說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147968/162.wav", + "text": "下個月才又開了一次跨部會協調會議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147968/163.wav", + "text": "自由潛水的這一項工作" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147968/164.wav", + "text": "包括說你在做自由潛水" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147968/165.wav", + "text": "要不要有嚮導的制度等等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147968/166.wav", + "text": "這些都有在討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147968/167.wav", + "text": "那細節看委員有沒有需要我們處長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147968/168.wav", + "text": "他可以做比較多的說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147968/169.wav", + "text": "我們來給委員做報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147968/170.wav", + "text": "我想說這部分還是要來努力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147968/171.wav", + "text": "OK因為時間的關係" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147968/172.wav", + "text": "時間的關係" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147968/173.wav", + "text": "我先請主委回座" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147968/174.wav", + "text": "我請海巡署署長上來一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147968/175.wav", + "text": "有一個小問題要問一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147968/176.wav", + "text": "委員早" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147968/177.wav", + "text": "本席最近有接到一些投訴" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147968/178.wav", + "text": "就是我們有些海巡士兵" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147968/179.wav", + "text": "有在反映就是說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147968/180.wav", + "text": "我們在冷氣使用這個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147968/181.wav", + "text": "似乎是看得到吹不到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147968/182.wav", + "text": "因為時間關係我們就快一點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147968/183.wav", + "text": "到底我們使用冷氣這個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147968/184.wav", + "text": "有沒有什麼限制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147968/185.wav", + "text": "是跟委員報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147968/186.wav", + "text": "謝謝委員的關切" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147968/187.wav", + "text": "基層的單位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147968/188.wav", + "text": "就像委員剛剛在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147968/189.wav", + "text": "您的問題裡面所講的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147968/190.wav", + "text": "我們只有限定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147968/191.wav", + "text": "在28度以下不得開" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147968/192.wav", + "text": "而且是室內溫度28度以上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147968/193.wav", + "text": "就可以開啟" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147968/194.wav", + "text": "那麼我想各單位都是因為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147968/195.wav", + "text": "考量節電的原則" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147968/196.wav", + "text": "但是主委今年來以後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147968/197.wav", + "text": "他從兩個方面著手" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147968/198.wav", + "text": "我們的電費預算方面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147968/199.wav", + "text": "已經直接就增編了100兩百多萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147968/200.wav", + "text": "所以增編100兩百多萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147968/201.wav", + "text": "所以使用冷氣的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147968/202.wav", + "text": "我們今年不足的1008百多萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147968/203.wav", + "text": "也是運用我們行政院第一預備金" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147968/204.wav", + "text": "我們也爭取到了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147968/205.wav", + "text": "主委幫我們增加" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147968/206.wav", + "text": "\n第二個方面就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147968/207.wav", + "text": "這些冷氣有很多是屬於老舊的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147968/208.wav", + "text": "它的效能不是很好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147968/209.wav", + "text": "所以在明年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147968/210.wav", + "text": "我們爭取了1005百多萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147968/211.wav", + "text": "我們希望能夠把這些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147968/212.wav", + "text": "基層老舊的冷氣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147968/213.wav", + "text": "署長我們很開心說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147968/214.wav", + "text": "我們有增列了電費的預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147968/215.wav", + "text": "我們希望說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147968/216.wav", + "text": "就像我們有接到的這個投訴" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147968/217.wav", + "text": "譬如說海巡同仁下勤之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147968/218.wav", + "text": "只能待在中山室" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147968/219.wav", + "text": "室備勤室休息跟待命" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147968/220.wav", + "text": "可是隊上的長官規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147968/221.wav", + "text": "不能夠開冷氣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147968/222.wav", + "text": "中午只能流著汗吃飯" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147968/223.wav", + "text": "下午濕著衣服常訓" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147968/224.wav", + "text": "到了晚上還要繼續執勤" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147968/225.wav", + "text": "所以也就是說這種情況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147968/226.wav", + "text": "是不會再發生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147968/227.wav", + "text": "請問署長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147968/228.wav", + "text": "之前曾經發生過這種事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147968/229.wav", + "text": "我承認有這種現象" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147968/230.wav", + "text": "因為他們考量節約能源的關係" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147968/231.wav", + "text": "另外他們總是把人員的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147968/232.wav", + "text": "休息當作首要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147968/233.wav", + "text": "因為我們每天夜間有值勤的人員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147968/234.wav", + "text": "他並不是早上6點鐘就跟一般人起牀" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147968/235.wav", + "text": "他有的是要睡到中午11點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147968/236.wav", + "text": "因為他是夜間的勤務" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147968/237.wav", + "text": "所以我們寢室" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147968/238.wav", + "text": "的冷氣是一直在開啟的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147968/239.wav", + "text": "我們希望能夠得到充分的睡眠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147968/240.wav", + "text": "剛剛委員講的這個中山室" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147968/241.wav", + "text": "或者是我們門口的大廳" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147968/242.wav", + "text": "關於大廳的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147968/243.wav", + "text": "有一個家長說他到這邊來看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147968/244.wav", + "text": "因為我們那個大廳" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147968/245.wav", + "text": "就跟警察局派出所一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147968/246.wav", + "text": "它是一個開放的空間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147968/247.wav", + "text": "如果你一直開著冷氣的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147968/248.wav", + "text": "那會比較浪費能源" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147968/249.wav", + "text": "所以我們的寢室就是生活區" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147968/250.wav", + "text": "就是他們睡覺的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147968/251.wav", + "text": "不過還是得要克服" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147968/252.wav", + "text": "喔如果是說這麼大間你覺得太浪費" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147968/253.wav", + "text": "那是不是另外再準備一個空間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147968/254.wav", + "text": "就是海巡同仁也很辛苦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147968/255.wav", + "text": "啦這部分我是覺得還是要克服" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147968/256.wav", + "text": "節省這個電費" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147968/257.wav", + "text": "可以當作幹部升遷的功績" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147968/258.wav", + "text": "這個事情有嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147968/259.wav", + "text": "這不會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147968/260.wav", + "text": "這不是事實" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147968/261.wav", + "text": "這是誤傳嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147968/262.wav", + "text": "既然有這些聲音出來了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147968/263.wav", + "text": "我想我們還是要想辦法去克服" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147968/264.wav", + "text": "我覺得雖然是一個冷氣的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147968/265.wav", + "text": "問題但可能會影響到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147968/266.wav", + "text": "這部分可能" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147968/267.wav", + "text": "是應該的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147968/268.wav", + "text": "我們應該要去檢討改進" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147967/0.wav", + "text": "我先用1分鐘來請教一下陳次長次長逃逸移工人數最近到9月份又多1,000人出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147967/1.wav", + "text": "00人數是越來越高耶到今年年底會不會超過9萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147967/2.wav", + "text": "報告委員移工的失聯人數總數是一個概念啦其實對勞動部來講我們看的是失聯率" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147967/3.wav", + "text": "因為從COVID之後我們對於各式各樣的移工都做鬆綁的規定所以國內引進的人數相對比較高" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147967/4.wav", + "text": "所以我們看的是逃逸率逃逸率跟去年相較起來其實是降低很多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147967/5.wav", + "text": "沒有我是說我們的政策真的是有問題我一直在強調我們移工的政策絕對有問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147967/6.wav", + "text": "喔這真的我們的警察才8萬而已要怎麼去抓這些人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147967/7.wav", + "text": "尤其我們的專勤大隊才五百零多人真的是沒辦法應付" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147967/8.wav", + "text": "好先請回謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147967/9.wav", + "text": "委員好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147967/10.wav", + "text": "部長4月份的時候你有說我們的長照基金今年首度出現紅字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147967/11.wav", + "text": "你又說沒關係我們還有1,000億至少5年內不會有問題對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147967/12.wav", + "text": "跟委員報告我們那時候是在預算的編列過程當中出現赤字但是結果還是有還是有賸餘" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147967/13.wav", + "text": "確定還有賸餘所以你確定每一年都會有賸餘以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147967/14.wav", + "text": "當然我們都有在注意這件事情啦目前來講的話是還沒有這樣的現象" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147967/15.wav", + "text": "從現在再過5年也還不會出現問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147967/16.wav", + "text": "5年後的話我們再做評估嘛因為每年整個收支的狀況我們沒有辦法估到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147967/17.wav", + "text": "長遠之計應該是要走保險制比較好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147967/18.wav", + "text": "保險制有保險制的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147967/19.wav", + "text": "幾句話先說明一下保險制可能出現的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147967/20.wav", + "text": "因為資源布建很重要萬一開始推保險制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147967/21.wav", + "text": "很多國家也都在推動保險制啊不是只有我們要推動而已其他國家比如韓國日本大家都在推" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147967/22.wav", + "text": "那些都出問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147967/23.wav", + "text": "啦我現在講很多專家的建議也是要走這條路線" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147967/24.wav", + "text": "譬如說像我們的健保制度來講健保制度要開始的時候也是意見很多啊到最後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147967/25.wav", + "text": "現在呢等於說是全世界都在羨慕我們有這個健保制度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147967/26.wav", + "text": "健保也是有問題健保制度我們是可以去參考的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147967/27.wav", + "text": "健保財務現在也是每年都要在那邊斟酌" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147967/28.wav", + "text": "而且有一個重要的差異點跟委員報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147967/29.wav", + "text": "健保開始實施的時候我們醫療機構是已經普遍發展相當多了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147967/30.wav", + "text": "現在長照是幾乎從零開始" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147967/31.wav", + "text": "我要請問你長照2.0真的很好嗎你覺得很滿意嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147967/32.wav", + "text": "不是說很滿意一定有要改進的地方" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147967/33.wav", + "text": "但是跟保險制恐怕沒有關係" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147967/34.wav", + "text": "我現在要說我們的長照制度真的是有需要改進" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147967/35.wav", + "text": "譬如說很多人都申請不到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147967/36.wav", + "text": "了因為你們說不能重複使用這個資源" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147967/37.wav", + "text": "其實不是這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147967/38.wav", + "text": "啦因為你就是沒辦法好好照顧他" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147967/39.wav", + "text": "所以他才要自費去請移工" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147967/40.wav", + "text": "結果他請移工之後你們又不給他" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147967/41.wav", + "text": "你們只給他一個喘息服" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147967/42.wav", + "text": "而已這是不夠的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147967/43.wav", + "text": "啦所以但是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147967/44.wav", + "text": "這次勞動部他們有另外一個計畫在支援" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147967/45.wav", + "text": "你們就是有給" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147967/46.wav", + "text": "而已對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147967/47.wav", + "text": "一年63組乘以2個小時" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147967/48.wav", + "text": "沒辦法叫長照服務來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147967/49.wav", + "text": "就影響到他們的工作" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147967/50.wav", + "text": "解決方案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147967/51.wav", + "text": "還是要走向" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147967/52.wav", + "text": "保險制度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147967/53.wav", + "text": "我們可以思考看看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147967/54.wav", + "text": "我們長照原定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147967/55.wav", + "text": "每3年要檢討一次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147967/56.wav", + "text": "現在已經執行7年了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147967/57.wav", + "text": "每一年都有在檢討" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147967/58.wav", + "text": "有兩個層次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147967/59.wav", + "text": "你是滾動式的檢討嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147967/60.wav", + "text": "滾動式檢討跟總檢討不一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147967/61.wav", + "text": "應該是今年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147967/62.wav", + "text": "在行政院長照推動小組裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147967/63.wav", + "text": "其他的部分長照推動小組" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147967/64.wav", + "text": "也是定期" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147967/65.wav", + "text": "開會做檢討" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147967/66.wav", + "text": "然後在部裡面也有一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147967/67.wav", + "text": "長照推動委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147967/68.wav", + "text": "檢討的制度交給你" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147967/69.wav", + "text": "我覺得你現在來做檢討" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147967/70.wav", + "text": "是最好的人選" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147967/71.wav", + "text": "因為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147967/72.wav", + "text": "有專家說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147967/73.wav", + "text": "保險的長照體系" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147967/74.wav", + "text": "沒有健保醫療體系" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147967/75.wav", + "text": "所以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147967/76.wav", + "text": "部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147967/77.wav", + "text": "可以討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147967/78.wav", + "text": "日到行政院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147967/79.wav", + "text": "醫事人員要總量管制立法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147967/80.wav", + "text": "你們有沒有做正面的回應" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147967/81.wav", + "text": "不做正面回應的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147967/82.wav", + "text": "不排除會到總統府去抗議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147967/83.wav", + "text": "其中有一個就是牙" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147967/84.wav", + "text": "牙醫實習的名額" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147967/85.wav", + "text": "我要請問" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147967/86.wav", + "text": "這個部分委員也知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147967/87.wav", + "text": "我們立法院通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147967/88.wav", + "text": "醫師法修正案之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147967/89.wav", + "text": "就是要去處理這些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147967/90.wav", + "text": "國外學籍的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147967/91.wav", + "text": "所以他們是希望" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147967/92.wav", + "text": "你可以總量管制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147967/93.wav", + "text": "因為再降低這些就消化不完" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147967/94.wav", + "text": "消化不完一定會出問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147967/95.wav", + "text": "所以就是要有一些政策" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147967/96.wav", + "text": "但是你們是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147967/97.wav", + "text": "醫師法的修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147967/98.wav", + "text": "還沒通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147967/99.wav", + "text": "實習名額" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147967/100.wav", + "text": "113年就是明年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147967/101.wav", + "text": "了明年就要降到30名" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147967/102.wav", + "text": "每一年回來的人數" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147967/103.wav", + "text": "有愈來愈多的情形" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147967/104.wav", + "text": "所以那個時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147967/105.wav", + "text": "才說要降下來30個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147967/106.wav", + "text": "這樣來做管制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147967/107.wav", + "text": "但是後來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147967/108.wav", + "text": "醫師法在去年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147967/109.wav", + "text": "就修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147967/110.wav", + "text": "修正完現在只要處理那些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147967/111.wav", + "text": "現有的就好了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147967/112.wav", + "text": "所以你的意思就是沒辦法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147967/113.wav", + "text": "回來都要經過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147967/114.wav", + "text": "教育部的學歷甄試" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147967/115.wav", + "text": "所以現在沒人會出去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147967/116.wav", + "text": "我知道啦你自己也是醫生出身的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147967/117.wav", + "text": "啦所以我們會用一些政策來處理這些事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147967/118.wav", + "text": "前幾天醫護人員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147967/119.wav", + "text": "又上街抗議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147967/120.wav", + "text": "他們說衛福部只發給夜班的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147967/121.wav", + "text": "津貼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147967/122.wav", + "text": "加給他們都非常的不滿意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147967/123.wav", + "text": "有80%的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147967/124.wav", + "text": "護理人員他們都不贊同" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147967/125.wav", + "text": "他們說我們在病房開刀" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147967/126.wav", + "text": "結果只有夜間加給那" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147967/127.wav", + "text": "我們白天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147967/128.wav", + "text": "不會讓這些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147967/129.wav", + "text": "回流" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147967/130.wav", + "text": "最重要的還是要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147967/131.wav", + "text": "大家公平地增加" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147967/132.wav", + "text": "薪水提高薪水" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147967/133.wav", + "text": "這個我們有評估過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147967/134.wav", + "text": "走的會越來越多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147967/135.wav", + "text": "我不會沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147967/136.wav", + "text": "現在已經很多人想要領這個錢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147967/137.wav", + "text": "那些不會出來講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147967/138.wav", + "text": "謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147967/139.wav", + "text": "謝謝委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147967/140.wav", + "text": "謝謝溫委員抱歉我剛才有叫你的名字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147965/0.wav", + "text": "主席我們請經濟部王部長好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147965/1.wav", + "text": "王部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147965/2.wav", + "text": "部長早" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147965/3.wav", + "text": "部長我請問一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147965/4.wav", + "text": "台積電宣布不進駐桃園龍潭科學園區三期" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147965/5.wav", + "text": "這個確定嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147965/6.wav", + "text": "對就晶圓的製造應該不會進駐" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147965/7.wav", + "text": "所以三期它是確定不進去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147965/8.wav", + "text": "因為我們從媒體也看到它自己宣布了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147965/9.wav", + "text": "台積電自己宣布" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147965/10.wav", + "text": "了請問一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147965/11.wav", + "text": "再來會落腳在哪邊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147965/12.wav", + "text": "部長知道嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147965/13.wav", + "text": "針對台積電後續的先進製程的發展" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147965/14.wav", + "text": "確實我們相關的部會會來討論哪裡是合適的地方" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147965/15.wav", + "text": "除了既有的這些園區之外" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147965/16.wav", + "text": "還有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147965/17.wav", + "text": "會在中科嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147965/18.wav", + "text": "中科現在二期就已經在走程序了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147965/19.wav", + "text": "那個部分目前在內政部的審議當中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147965/20.wav", + "text": "那個部分確實也是給台積電" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147965/21.wav", + "text": "但是會做哪一個製程部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147965/22.wav", + "text": "會等這個程序確定之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147965/23.wav", + "text": "台積電這邊才會再看它怎麼宣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147965/24.wav", + "text": "中科二期的程序在走" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147965/25.wav", + "text": "但是程序到底要走多久" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147965/26.wav", + "text": "兩件事" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147965/27.wav", + "text": "因為就我們所知道來講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147965/28.wav", + "text": "這個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147965/29.wav", + "text": "按照國科會的規劃" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147965/30.wav", + "text": "應該是希望明年交地給廠商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147965/31.wav", + "text": "這是第一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147965/32.wav", + "text": "但是就整個先進製程的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147965/33.wav", + "text": "應該還是需要盤點相關的需求" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147965/34.wav", + "text": "我們政府還是會盤點相關需求" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147965/35.wav", + "text": "會來提供合適的土地" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147965/36.wav", + "text": "可能的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147965/37.wav", + "text": "北中南會在北部中部或是南部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147965/38.wav", + "text": "看起來確實如果要尋找比較可行的用地的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147965/39.wav", + "text": "應該是中部以南的地方" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147965/40.wav", + "text": "那是嘉義以南嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147965/41.wav", + "text": "是嘉義縣以南嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147965/42.wav", + "text": "我們沒有這樣限制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147965/43.wav", + "text": "主要是要找第一個合適的用地" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147965/44.wav", + "text": "啦就台積電在哪裡落腳" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147965/45.wav", + "text": "它也不是說這一批土地用完" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147965/46.wav", + "text": "未來就沒有需求" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147965/47.wav", + "text": "需求的土地可能就是一批一批的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147965/48.wav", + "text": "我的意思就是最近" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147965/49.wav", + "text": "退出" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147965/50.wav", + "text": "最有可能的所謂" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147965/51.wav", + "text": "指嘉義縣以南" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147965/52.wav", + "text": "目前至少這一些比較大片一點的土地" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147965/53.wav", + "text": "因為它這個先進製程" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147965/54.wav", + "text": "需要的土地確實用地面積要比較大" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147965/55.wav", + "text": "我所知道好像需要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147965/56.wav", + "text": "至少100公頃以上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147965/57.wav", + "text": "是吧" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147965/58.wav", + "text": "應該是都會需要100公頃以上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147965/59.wav", + "text": "那這樣答案也差不多了吧" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147965/60.wav", + "text": "目前有空地100公頃以上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147965/61.wav", + "text": "所以難怪會用一個南部的南" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147965/62.wav", + "text": "部長會這麼講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147965/63.wav", + "text": "對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147965/64.wav", + "text": "部長謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147965/65.wav", + "text": "是謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147965/66.wav", + "text": "主席我們是不是可以請" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147965/67.wav", + "text": "是委員好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147965/68.wav", + "text": "為什麼我" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147965/69.wav", + "text": "我會請副署長上來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147965/70.wav", + "text": "還有要規劃各種農產業空間布建" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147965/71.wav", + "text": "還有農地相容使用項目" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147965/72.wav", + "text": "及其管制規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147965/73.wav", + "text": "還有要結合對地綠色環境給付" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147965/74.wav", + "text": "等等適度的支持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147965/75.wav", + "text": "然後促進農地資源永續利用與發展" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147965/76.wav", + "text": "對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147965/77.wav", + "text": "對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147965/78.wav", + "text": "好那麼請問一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147965/79.wav", + "text": "空間的規劃" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147965/80.wav", + "text": "引導土地使用管制的思維" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147965/81.wav", + "text": "這個空間的布建你們怎麼做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147965/82.wav", + "text": "就農糧署來講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147965/83.wav", + "text": "要怎麼做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147965/84.wav", + "text": "我們當然就是針對農地的劃設" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147965/85.wav", + "text": "如果說之前幾個部會的報告裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147965/86.wav", + "text": "特別有提到國土計畫法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147965/87.wav", + "text": "針對農業發展地區" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147965/88.wav", + "text": "就會有農一一直到農" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147965/89.wav", + "text": "我們農糧署在推動綠色環境給付計畫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147965/90.wav", + "text": "就會針對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147965/91.wav", + "text": "這些都不用再講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147965/92.wav", + "text": "我的意思就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147965/93.wav", + "text": "你們對優良農地" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147965/94.wav", + "text": "還有包括所有農田水利相關建設" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147965/95.wav", + "text": "跟管理這種種你" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147965/96.wav", + "text": "有什麼樣的空間的布建" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147965/97.wav", + "text": "或是哪一個案例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147965/98.wav", + "text": "可以提出來談的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147965/99.wav", + "text": "可以提出來講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147965/100.wav", + "text": "那當然就是針對農1" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147965/101.wav", + "text": "優良農地" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147965/102.wav", + "text": "是嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147965/103.wav", + "text": "優良農地就是大嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147965/104.wav", + "text": "還是在國土計畫的規劃裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147965/105.wav", + "text": "把大的都規劃好了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147965/106.wav", + "text": "接下來要怎麼落實" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147965/107.wav", + "text": "我覺得這個空間的布建" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147965/108.wav", + "text": "農地的相容等等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147965/109.wav", + "text": "我們可不可以思考一點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147965/110.wav", + "text": "因為我大概對國發會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147965/111.wav", + "text": "說地方創生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147965/112.wav", + "text": "是說到不想說了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147965/113.wav", + "text": "我說到不想說就是因為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147965/114.wav", + "text": "還有坐在冷氣房的思維" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147965/115.wav", + "text": "跟你們農糧署常常下鄉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147965/116.wav", + "text": "那是完全不一樣的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147965/117.wav", + "text": "你們的經驗" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147965/118.wav", + "text": "或者是經歷" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147965/119.wav", + "text": "是個完全不一樣的思考" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147965/120.wav", + "text": "很接近農民" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147965/121.wav", + "text": "也貼近我們的農業" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147965/122.wav", + "text": "那我請問一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147965/123.wav", + "text": "你會覺得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147965/124.wav", + "text": "怎麼樣去增加農民的收入" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147965/125.wav", + "text": "然後可以讓年輕人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147965/126.wav", + "text": "願意留在家鄉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147965/127.wav", + "text": "而不是一個個體戶的協助" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147965/128.wav", + "text": "是一個整個空間的布建" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147965/129.wav", + "text": "過去來說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147965/130.wav", + "text": "空間布建" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147965/131.wav", + "text": "可能是農地重劃" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147965/132.wav", + "text": "這一區我就把它劃成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147965/133.wav", + "text": "劃成灌溉區" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147965/134.wav", + "text": "那就是農地重劃" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147965/135.wav", + "text": "了農地重劃就是水溝啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147965/136.wav", + "text": "路啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147965/137.wav", + "text": "就是做就對了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147965/138.wav", + "text": "我們的思考已經不是把水" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147965/139.wav", + "text": "和路做好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147965/140.wav", + "text": "已經不是這樣了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147965/141.wav", + "text": "這個技術層面的問題來講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147965/142.wav", + "text": "對農水署" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147965/143.wav", + "text": "我覺得這個太簡單" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147965/144.wav", + "text": "太過於簡單" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147965/145.wav", + "text": "了所以現在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147965/146.wav", + "text": "它的經驗值來講的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147965/147.wav", + "text": "這一區可以做什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147965/148.wav", + "text": "這一區應該做什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147965/149.wav", + "text": "我覺得是要回歸到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147965/150.wav", + "text": "一個一個區域來思考" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147965/151.wav", + "text": "這個區域適合做什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147965/152.wav", + "text": "到底目前有沒有農民" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147965/153.wav", + "text": "因為人還是最重要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147965/154.wav", + "text": "人才是最重要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147965/155.wav", + "text": "的所以這個地區適合種什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147965/156.wav", + "text": "人有沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147965/157.wav", + "text": "有沒有人才" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147965/158.wav", + "text": "我是想跟農糧署" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147965/159.wav", + "text": "討論這一方面的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147965/160.wav", + "text": "所以我是覺得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147965/161.wav", + "text": "就你的經驗值來講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147965/162.wav", + "text": "你會怎麼樣去看待地方創生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147965/163.wav", + "text": "怎麼去看待農業的空間布建" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147965/164.wav", + "text": "還有看待怎麼去增加農民的收入" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147965/165.wav", + "text": "跟委員報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147965/166.wav", + "text": "原則上農糧署會針對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147965/167.wav", + "text": "你要怎麼做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147965/168.wav", + "text": "你劃到農一農二又怎麼樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147965/169.wav", + "text": "劃到農一農二" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147965/170.wav", + "text": "它就動不了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147965/171.wav", + "text": "它就一定要做農業" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147965/172.wav", + "text": "從產製儲銷所有的資源" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147965/173.wav", + "text": "投入應該就是要針對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147965/174.wav", + "text": "這一些農業發展地區" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147965/175.wav", + "text": "甚至農業環境的補貼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147965/176.wav", + "text": "也要針對農一農二的補貼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147965/177.wav", + "text": "你要投入什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147965/178.wav", + "text": "然後可以讓這個地區的農業" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147965/179.wav", + "text": "它是升級的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147965/180.wav", + "text": "農民的收入是可以增加的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147965/181.wav", + "text": "的我覺得這是一個很具體的東西" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147965/182.wav", + "text": "這就是一個實踐" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147965/183.wav", + "text": "嘛農業的實踐哲學在哪一邊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147965/184.wav", + "text": "嘛農業的實踐哲學的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147965/185.wav", + "text": "你一定要有一套機制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147965/186.wav", + "text": "然後可以吸引農民願意進來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147965/187.wav", + "text": "起碼合作社（場）設立要滿一年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147965/188.wav", + "text": "你們可能說社（場）一定要滿一年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147965/189.wav", + "text": "是因為它要有業績" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147965/190.wav", + "text": "嘛所以你們的補助設備或設施來講的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147965/191.wav", + "text": "如果這個合作社（場）場主" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147965/192.wav", + "text": "是接受了訂單" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147965/193.wav", + "text": "他有大賣場的訂單" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147965/194.wav", + "text": "然後他覺得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147965/195.wav", + "text": "他這個訂單" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147965/196.wav", + "text": "已經不是他個體戶可以承擔的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147965/197.wav", + "text": "所以他現在就去開始租一個社（場）嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147965/198.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147965/199.wav", + "text": "啦租這個社（場）雖然還沒有滿一年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147965/200.wav", + "text": "但是以過去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147965/201.wav", + "text": "個體戶來講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147965/202.wav", + "text": "他的業績是非常的可觀" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147965/203.wav", + "text": "這個也應該打破過去的思維去考慮" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147965/204.wav", + "text": "對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147965/205.wav", + "text": "好現在我再看一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147965/206.wav", + "text": "把這個溫網室吹成這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147965/207.wav", + "text": "溫室有需要分鄉鎮嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147965/208.wav", + "text": "對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147965/209.wav", + "text": "對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147965/210.wav", + "text": "我們再想想看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147965/211.wav", + "text": "農就提出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147965/212.wav", + "text": "副署長你也跟他見過面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147965/213.wav", + "text": "農跟副署長見過面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147965/214.wav", + "text": "了他們有想法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147965/215.wav", + "text": "他們都是高級" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147965/216.wav", + "text": "也算是高端的知識分子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147965/217.wav", + "text": "投入農業" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147965/218.wav", + "text": "回到自己的故鄉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147965/219.wav", + "text": "政府應該重點輔導他們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147965/220.wav", + "text": "重點輔導他們的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147965/221.wav", + "text": "農業的區域基地" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147965/222.wav", + "text": "然後增加他們的收入" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147965/223.wav", + "text": "所以我們在想" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147965/224.wav", + "text": "他也已經做溫室" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147965/225.wav", + "text": "做了一段時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147965/226.wav", + "text": "已經有經驗了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147965/227.wav", + "text": "可以麻煩一下主席嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147965/228.wav", + "text": "聊天的聲音可不可以小聲一點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147965/229.wav", + "text": "我要說的是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147965/230.wav", + "text": "溫室需要升級" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147965/231.wav", + "text": "需要升級的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147965/232.wav", + "text": "又能夠增加他的收入" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147965/233.wav", + "text": "那他可以做什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147965/234.wav", + "text": "我們要說的是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147965/235.wav", + "text": "上面他種電" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147965/236.wav", + "text": "那麼他個人覺得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147965/237.wav", + "text": "我的遮蔽率也不必到你們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147965/238.wav", + "text": "農委會規定的四成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147965/239.wav", + "text": "我認為三成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147965/240.wav", + "text": "才是最適當的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147965/241.wav", + "text": "然後在這三成遮蔽率" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147965/242.wav", + "text": "的下面種什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147965/243.wav", + "text": "他們已經有經驗" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147965/244.wav", + "text": "在政府的立場來講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147965/245.wav", + "text": "你覺得應不應該就直接投入" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147965/246.wav", + "text": "呢就直接來輔導他們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147965/247.wav", + "text": "可以沒有問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147965/248.wav", + "text": "第一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147965/249.wav", + "text": "我是認為這樣子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147965/250.wav", + "text": "相關的規定都允許" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147965/251.wav", + "text": "意思就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147965/252.wav", + "text": "先有人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147965/253.wav", + "text": "已經有人在那邊了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147965/254.wav", + "text": "我們怎麼樣去輔導他們升級" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147965/255.wav", + "text": "如果像國發會的地方" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147965/256.wav", + "text": "我覺得錢投入下去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147965/257.wav", + "text": "那個是硬體居多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147965/258.wav", + "text": "還是什麼居多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147965/259.wav", + "text": "你可能要去盤點現有的基礎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147965/260.wav", + "text": "所以農業現有的基礎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147965/261.wav", + "text": "第一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147965/262.wav", + "text": "人是最重要的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147965/263.wav", + "text": "可以配合你的空間布建" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147965/264.wav", + "text": "我們就把硬體的資源" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147965/265.wav", + "text": "投入進來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147965/266.wav", + "text": "投入進來的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147965/267.wav", + "text": "怎麼樣去增加他們收入" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147965/268.wav", + "text": "他們主動來建議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147965/269.wav", + "text": "可不可以種電" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147965/270.wav", + "text": "現在農電共生的概念很不一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147965/271.wav", + "text": "現在農電共生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147965/272.wav", + "text": "的電是資本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147965/273.wav", + "text": "是廠商進來投資的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147965/274.wav", + "text": "現在他們想自己做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147965/275.wav", + "text": "要怎麼辦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147965/276.wav", + "text": "呢要怎麼來處理這方面的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147965/277.wav", + "text": "農民是真正在從事農業生產" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147965/278.wav", + "text": "我們可不可以轉一個思維" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147965/279.wav", + "text": "農民是真正在從事農業生產" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147965/280.wav", + "text": "所以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147965/281.wav", + "text": "也由農民直接來投資" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147965/282.wav", + "text": "農民直接來投資" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147965/283.wav", + "text": "他不可能有資本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147965/284.wav", + "text": "要貸款" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147965/285.wav", + "text": "貸款的話要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147965/286.wav", + "text": "專案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147965/287.wav", + "text": "要低利" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147965/288.wav", + "text": "或者是前三年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147965/289.wav", + "text": "可不可以零利率" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147965/290.wav", + "text": "這個機制就要想" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147965/291.wav", + "text": "我就是在跟你討論這個東西" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147965/292.wav", + "text": "這個是可以由空間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147965/293.wav", + "text": "主動跟你提出這樣的案子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147965/294.wav", + "text": "說他要栽培" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147965/295.wav", + "text": "或超過十年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147965/296.wav", + "text": "對這種栽培的作物" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147965/297.wav", + "text": "已經相當有經驗" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147965/298.wav", + "text": "就是缺資金" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147965/299.wav", + "text": "農業部能不能主動" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147965/300.wav", + "text": "跟國發會提出一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147965/301.wav", + "text": "空間布建" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147965/302.wav", + "text": "然後農業升級的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147965/303.wav", + "text": "總是要有一個專案的案例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147965/304.wav", + "text": "我們先來做做看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147965/305.wav", + "text": "農民相關的低利貸款" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147965/306.wav", + "text": "農業部有農業金融署" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147965/307.wav", + "text": "有相關規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147965/308.wav", + "text": "你不要再說那" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147965/309.wav", + "text": "如果我們站在一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147965/310.wav", + "text": "然後怎麼把一個產業整個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147965/311.wav", + "text": "如何增加農民的收入" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147965/312.wav", + "text": "我們也" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147965/313.wav", + "text": "可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147965/314.wav", + "text": "人有人才" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147965/315.wav", + "text": "土地有土地" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147965/316.wav", + "text": "對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147965/317.wav", + "text": "就是差在農民沒有資金" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147965/318.wav", + "text": "他們是一個group" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147965/319.wav", + "text": "用地方創生的概念" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147965/320.wav", + "text": "的一件事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147965/321.wav", + "text": "可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147965/322.wav", + "text": "剛剛提到的那位農民" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147965/323.wav", + "text": "不是那位農民" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147965/324.wav", + "text": "是跟你見過面的那位農民" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147965/325.wav", + "text": "但不是剛剛圖片的那位農民" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147965/326.wav", + "text": "我只是在跟你說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147965/327.wav", + "text": "有很多高知識分子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147965/328.wav", + "text": "還有高學歷的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147965/329.wav", + "text": "人投入農業" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147965/330.wav", + "text": "雖然為數不是很多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147965/331.wav", + "text": "但還是有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147965/332.wav", + "text": "然而我們怎麼樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147965/333.wav", + "text": "讓這批有經驗的農民" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147965/334.wav", + "text": "投入農業" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147965/335.wav", + "text": "因為有政府的協助" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147965/336.wav", + "text": "還有那種資源帶進來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147965/337.wav", + "text": "創造一個不一樣的生產基地" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147965/338.wav", + "text": "好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147965/339.wav", + "text": "的腦袋裡面想" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147965/340.wav", + "text": "的是怎麼樣增加他們的收入" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147965/341.wav", + "text": "可以把他們留在鄉下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147965/342.wav", + "text": "好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147965/343.wav", + "text": "副署長我在思考是這一點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147965/344.wav", + "text": "雲林可以有第一個案例嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147965/345.wav", + "text": "我們願意來協助有意願的農民" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147965/346.wav", + "text": "對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147965/347.wav", + "text": "你們農糧署的思維要去思考" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147965/348.wav", + "text": "要不要創造這樣一個案例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147965/349.wav", + "text": "就是透過政策機制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147965/350.wav", + "text": "可以兌現" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147965/351.wav", + "text": "是這個意思好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147965/352.wav", + "text": "我們就來一起努力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147965/353.wav", + "text": "我就這麼一句話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147965/354.wav", + "text": "我認為四湖的那塊地" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147965/355.wav", + "text": "你要用地方創生的概念進來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147965/356.wav", + "text": "它有光有電" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147965/357.wav", + "text": "我覺得應該要朝向這方面來努力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147965/358.wav", + "text": "農電共生不是交給資本家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147965/359.wav", + "text": "農電共生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147965/360.wav", + "text": "現在可不可以思考一個模式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147965/361.wav", + "text": "就是交給農民" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147965/362.wav", + "text": "地方創生如何去協助農民" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147965/363.wav", + "text": "發展農電共生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147965/364.wav", + "text": "我的��法是這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147965/365.wav", + "text": "思維是這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147965/366.wav", + "text": "好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147965/367.wav", + "text": "我就這樣給你們一些建議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147965/368.wav", + "text": "好謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147964/0.wav", + "text": "謝謝主席及各位先進" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147964/1.wav", + "text": "有請金管會黃主委" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147964/2.wav", + "text": "主委早" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147964/3.wav", + "text": "我想主委應該很關心今天的股市吧" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147964/4.wav", + "text": "一開盤暴跌了兩百多點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147964/5.wav", + "text": "我沒有注意到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147964/6.wav", + "text": "沒有注意到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147964/7.wav", + "text": "你是金管會主委你不注意這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147964/8.wav", + "text": "當然你都是面對到股市的波動" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147964/9.wav", + "text": "不僅僅價跌" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147964/10.wav", + "text": "變成現在的股市是價量齊跌" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147964/11.wav", + "text": "擔心的是市場" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147964/12.wav", + "text": "啊價格高卻沒有量" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147964/13.wav", + "text": "這個市場基本上就" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147964/14.wav", + "text": "不知該怎麼辦了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147964/15.wav", + "text": "我們看到你不斷在講基本面很好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147964/16.wav", + "text": "我們就來講基本面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147964/17.wav", + "text": "工業指數" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147964/18.wav", + "text": "製造生產指數" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147964/19.wav", + "text": "兩者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147964/20.wav", + "text": "年減7%" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147964/21.wav", + "text": "連續16個月負成長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147964/22.wav", + "text": "史上最長的衰退" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147964/23.wav", + "text": "這是臺灣現在面對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147964/24.wav", + "text": "和製造生產指數" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147964/25.wav", + "text": "再看看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147964/26.wav", + "text": "最近" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147964/27.wav", + "text": "無薪假破萬人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147964/28.wav", + "text": "總共四百零多家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147964/29.wav", + "text": "其中製造業占" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147964/30.wav", + "text": "占九成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147964/31.wav", + "text": "你有沒有查一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147964/32.wav", + "text": "上市櫃公司" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147964/33.wav", + "text": "放無薪假的有幾家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147964/34.wav", + "text": "委員指導我會趕快去查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147964/35.wav", + "text": "查一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147964/36.wav", + "text": "現在無薪假有四百零多家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147964/37.wav", + "text": "總共" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147964/38.wav", + "text": "有的是很重要的產業" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147964/39.wav", + "text": "都是傳統產業" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147964/40.wav", + "text": "然後臺幣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147964/41.wav", + "text": "貶個不停" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147964/42.wav", + "text": "證券劃撥存款餘額" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147964/43.wav", + "text": "減少2,000億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147964/44.wav", + "text": "就地緣政治" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147964/45.wav", + "text": "看起來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147964/46.wav", + "text": "有擴大的樣子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147964/47.wav", + "text": "俄烏戰爭還沒結束" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147964/48.wav", + "text": "臺灣持續緊張" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147964/49.wav", + "text": "這些整體因素" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147964/50.wav", + "text": "我怎麼看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147964/51.wav", + "text": "基本面都不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147964/52.wav", + "text": "呢你一直說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147964/53.wav", + "text": "基本面不錯" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147964/54.wav", + "text": "基本面不錯" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147964/55.wav", + "text": "你要不要講一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147964/56.wav", + "text": "回應一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147964/57.wav", + "text": "再給你講一遍" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147964/58.wav", + "text": "因為我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147964/59.wav", + "text": "臺股的漲幅" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147964/60.wav", + "text": "在今年來講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147964/61.wav", + "text": "亞洲來講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147964/62.wav", + "text": "也次於日本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147964/63.wav", + "text": "我們臺股漲了15.71" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147964/64.wav", + "text": "那這樣子的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147964/65.wav", + "text": "為什麼價量齊跌呢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147964/66.wav", + "text": "那因為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147964/67.wav", + "text": "臺股不是沒有漲" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147964/68.wav", + "text": "跌多漲少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147964/69.wav", + "text": "嘛跌個幾天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147964/70.wav", + "text": "漲一天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147964/71.wav", + "text": "漲兩天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147964/72.wav", + "text": "然後就再繼續跌" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147964/73.wav", + "text": "趨勢是向下的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147964/74.wav", + "text": "對吧" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147964/75.wav", + "text": "報告委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147964/76.wav", + "text": "其實並沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147964/77.wav", + "text": "原來300多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147964/78.wav", + "text": "那要加櫃買可能也是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147964/79.wav", + "text": "300多是啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147964/80.wav", + "text": "原來300多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147964/81.wav", + "text": "根據這個事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147964/82.wav", + "text": "你們最近又" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147964/83.wav", + "text": "推一個東西" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147964/84.wav", + "text": "大股東的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147964/85.wav", + "text": "不當干預" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147964/86.wav", + "text": "你們要修" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147964/87.wav", + "text": "金控法跟銀行法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147964/88.wav", + "text": "有這個事" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147964/89.wav", + "text": "但是我們報行政院的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147964/90.wav", + "text": "有些條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147964/91.wav", + "text": "參考公聽會的意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147964/92.wav", + "text": "已經做了調整" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147964/93.wav", + "text": "結果我看了半天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147964/94.wav", + "text": "有關大股東不當的干政" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147964/95.wav", + "text": "你要罰行政院不罰" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147964/96.wav", + "text": "是不是這個意思" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147964/97.wav", + "text": "大股東的罰款沒有拿掉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147964/98.wav", + "text": "沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147964/99.wav", + "text": "大股東只有對他的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147964/100.wav", + "text": "持有股票" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147964/101.wav", + "text": "要他強制賣出" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147964/102.wav", + "text": "或是限制他的表決權" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147964/103.wav", + "text": "那個部分有拿掉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147964/104.wav", + "text": "因為考慮未來執行上的不明確" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147964/105.wav", + "text": "但是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147964/106.wav", + "text": "大股東的罰款還是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147964/107.wav", + "text": "還是在的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147964/108.wav", + "text": "還是在的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147964/109.wav", + "text": "沒有拿掉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147964/110.wav", + "text": "好那我就問你" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147964/111.wav", + "text": "你的版本送到行政院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147964/112.wav", + "text": "行政院最近" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147964/113.wav", + "text": "核定了沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147964/114.wav", + "text": "有審" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147964/115.wav", + "text": "審了之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147964/116.wav", + "text": "目前還在處理中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147964/117.wav", + "text": "是放寬嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147964/118.wav", + "text": "對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147964/119.wav", + "text": "沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147964/120.wav", + "text": "我所瞭解的是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147964/121.wav", + "text": "你們送出去的版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147964/122.wav", + "text": "行政院把它放寬了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147964/123.wav", + "text": "行政院\n局長你說明一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147964/124.wav", + "text": "報告委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147964/125.wav", + "text": "這個因為在預告的期間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147964/126.wav", + "text": "然後公聽會上面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147964/127.wav", + "text": "大家的意見都很多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147964/128.wav", + "text": "所以我們在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147964/129.wav", + "text": "要送行政院之前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147964/130.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147964/131.wav", + "text": "特別是對金融業" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147964/132.wav", + "text": "其實金融業" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147964/133.wav", + "text": "全球投資" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147964/134.wav", + "text": "全球的暴險" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147964/135.wav", + "text": "主委要不要講一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147964/136.wav", + "text": "全球暴險多少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147964/137.wav", + "text": "保險業應該有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147964/138.wav", + "text": "二十幾兆" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147964/139.wav", + "text": "三兆多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147964/140.wav", + "text": "大概二十三" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147964/141.wav", + "text": "全球加起來30兆" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147964/142.wav", + "text": "沒有那麼多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147964/143.wav", + "text": "有啊你剛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147964/144.wav", + "text": "壽險就二十幾兆" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147964/145.wav", + "text": "銀行大概3兆" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147964/146.wav", + "text": "3兆啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147964/147.wav", + "text": "那是投信基金客戶的錢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147964/148.wav", + "text": "啊自己投資的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147964/149.wav", + "text": "我到時候請證期局" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147964/150.wav", + "text": "提供一下資料" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147964/151.wav", + "text": "應該不到30兆" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147964/152.wav", + "text": "我查到的是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147964/153.wav", + "text": "到處投資" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147964/154.wav", + "text": "包括機構" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147964/155.wav", + "text": "包括個人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147964/156.wav", + "text": "總共30兆" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147964/157.wav", + "text": "對美國的暴險15兆" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147964/158.wav", + "text": "這某種程度也不是壞事啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147964/159.wav", + "text": "代表我們很有錢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147964/160.wav", + "text": "敢投資" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147964/161.wav", + "text": "很勇敢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147964/162.wav", + "text": "對中東" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147964/163.wav", + "text": "我上一次跟你講要統計的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147964/164.wav", + "text": "你把它統計出來了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147964/165.wav", + "text": "有跟您報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147964/166.wav", + "text": "中國大陸多少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147964/167.wav", + "text": "1兆左右" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147964/168.wav", + "text": "對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147964/169.wav", + "text": "所以全球暴險" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147964/170.wav", + "text": "臺灣有夠厲害" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147964/171.wav", + "text": "全球布局30兆" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147964/172.wav", + "text": "在全球" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147964/173.wav", + "text": "除了臺灣以外" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147964/174.wav", + "text": "1兆美金" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147964/175.wav", + "text": "散播到全球" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147964/176.wav", + "text": "然後美國15兆" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147964/177.wav", + "text": "中東2.12兆" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147964/178.wav", + "text": "中國大陸1.1兆" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147964/179.wav", + "text": "去外面投資的銀行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147964/180.wav", + "text": "你們怎麼做監理啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147964/181.wav", + "text": "第一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147964/182.wav", + "text": "我跟您報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147964/183.wav", + "text": "如果以保險資金來講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147964/184.wav", + "text": "那個不是保險業" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147964/185.wav", + "text": "的是保戶的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147964/186.wav", + "text": "我知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147964/187.wav", + "text": "但是我們對外投資" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147964/188.wav", + "text": "不論是債券或其他" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147964/189.wav", + "text": "都有平等的要求" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147964/190.wav", + "text": "是投資等級的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147964/191.wav", + "text": "然後也有一些量的管制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147964/192.wav", + "text": "所以基本上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147964/193.wav", + "text": "都是有審慎去做管理的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147964/194.wav", + "text": "請問現在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147964/195.wav", + "text": "國家的銀行去中國大陸" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147964/196.wav", + "text": "監理現在做不做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147964/197.wav", + "text": "有做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147964/198.wav", + "text": "現在不是兩岸關係這麼不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147964/199.wav", + "text": "怎麼做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147964/200.wav", + "text": "有啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147964/201.wav", + "text": "兩岸監理機關之間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147964/202.wav", + "text": "也還是有做監理上的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147964/203.wav", + "text": "你是複委託" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147964/204.wav", + "text": "委託會計師去做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147964/205.wav", + "text": "還是自己去做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147964/206.wav", + "text": "沒有喔" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147964/207.wav", + "text": "我們都是直接的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147964/208.wav", + "text": "需要瞭解的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147964/209.wav", + "text": "都有直接聯繫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147964/210.wav", + "text": "我們的官員到大陸" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147964/211.wav", + "text": "去做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147964/212.wav", + "text": "是不是這個意思" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147964/213.wav", + "text": "目前沒有去啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147964/214.wav", + "text": "但是平常透過電子郵件" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147964/215.wav", + "text": "或交換資訊是有的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147964/216.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147964/217.wav", + "text": "金管會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147964/218.wav", + "text": "你們對於一些金融商品" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147964/219.wav", + "text": "能不碰就不碰" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147964/220.wav", + "text": "這樣一個平臺裡面借貸" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147964/221.wav", + "text": "只要有金流" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147964/222.wav", + "text": "大家就想到金管會要管啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147964/223.wav", + "text": "結果你說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147964/224.wav", + "text": "叫他們組公會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147964/225.wav", + "text": "組不起來呀" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147964/226.wav", + "text": "怎麼辦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147964/227.wav", + "text": "你告訴我" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147964/228.wav", + "text": "的確因為相關業者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147964/229.wav", + "text": "有不同的立場" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147964/230.wav", + "text": "還有既存的業者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147964/231.wav", + "text": "有一些不同的意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147964/232.wav", + "text": "但是經濟部還沒有開會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147964/233.wav", + "text": "嘛還沒有開會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147964/234.wav", + "text": "所以現在還很難定論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147964/235.wav", + "text": "金管會的態度是什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147964/236.wav", + "text": "我們有訂了一個指導原則" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147964/237.wav", + "text": "也希望業者自己組一個公會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147964/238.wav", + "text": "透過銀行之間的要求" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147964/239.wav", + "text": "能夠形成一個管理的機制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147964/240.wav", + "text": "看起來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147964/241.wav", + "text": "還是蠻被動的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147964/242.wav", + "text": "金管會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147964/243.wav", + "text": "我們有參照行政院的指示" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147964/244.wav", + "text": "像日前有訂了一個指導原則" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147964/245.wav", + "text": "所以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147964/246.wav", + "text": "也沒有被動" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147964/247.wav", + "text": "啦我們有開" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147964/248.wav", + "text": "因為P2P" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147964/249.wav", + "text": "大家知道在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147964/250.wav", + "text": "財委會這個地方" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147964/251.wav", + "text": "事不關己" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147964/252.wav", + "text": "不太管的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147964/253.wav", + "text": "因為這個是平臺業" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147964/254.wav", + "text": "你們就定義平臺業" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147964/255.wav", + "text": "出包了imB" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147964/256.wav", + "text": "只要錢在流動" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147964/257.wav", + "text": "金管會就要管" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147964/258.wav", + "text": "大家的期待是這樣子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147964/259.wav", + "text": "委員錢流動就是金管會管" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147964/260.wav", + "text": "我們的權力也太大了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147964/261.wav", + "text": "本來你們權力就很大" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147964/262.wav", + "text": "金融監理跟錢流動" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147964/263.wav", + "text": "沒有必然連結的關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147964/264.wav", + "text": "金融機構裡面的錢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147964/265.wav", + "text": "\n最後一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147964/266.wav", + "text": "最後一個跟你就有關係了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147964/267.wav", + "text": "詐騙犯" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147964/268.wav", + "text": "有的被抓到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147964/269.wav", + "text": "用約定轉帳的帳戶" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147964/270.wav", + "text": "譬如詐騙案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147964/271.wav", + "text": "200萬給A" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147964/272.wav", + "text": "A" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147964/273.wav", + "text": "約定轉帳" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147964/274.wav", + "text": "200萬給B" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147964/275.wav", + "text": "就洗掉了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147964/276.wav", + "text": "請問這個你們怎麼防止" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147964/277.wav", + "text": "報告委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147964/278.wav", + "text": "這個我們會洽相關銀行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147964/279.wav", + "text": "跟財金做一些管理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147964/280.wav", + "text": "下午會開會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147964/281.wav", + "text": "跟您報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147964/282.wav", + "text": "報告委員分兩點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147964/283.wav", + "text": "喔第一個就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147964/284.wav", + "text": "A銀行跟B銀行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147964/285.wav", + "text": "彼此之間的訊息如何溝通" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147964/286.wav", + "text": "財金這邊已經研擬一套方案了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147964/287.wav", + "text": "然後再來的話就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147964/288.wav", + "text": "A銀行跟B銀行之間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147964/289.wav", + "text": "彼此要做什麼事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147964/290.wav", + "text": "你們現在只有管A銀行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147964/291.wav", + "text": "下午我們也會開會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147964/292.wav", + "text": "連B也要管吧" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147964/293.wav", + "text": "對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147964/294.wav", + "text": "A銀行我們都會管" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147964/295.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147964/296.wav", + "text": "最後一個小問題再" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147964/297.wav", + "text": "請教主委" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147964/298.wav", + "text": "LINE Pay" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147964/299.wav", + "text": "現在聽說要再整合一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147964/300.wav", + "text": "QR" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147964/301.wav", + "text": "大家整合一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147964/302.wav", + "text": "這個進度怎麼樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147964/303.wav", + "text": "報告委員您剛才垂" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147964/304.wav", + "text": "垂詢的Apple跟LINE" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147964/305.wav", + "text": "那個是第三方支付" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147964/306.wav", + "text": "啦但是電子支付" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147964/307.wav", + "text": "我們有整合" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147964/308.wav", + "text": "是透過財金公司整合" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147964/309.wav", + "text": "目前前兩天24號有一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147964/310.wav", + "text": "什麼時候可以看到這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147964/311.wav", + "text": "大家整合一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147964/312.wav", + "text": "什麼時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147964/313.wav", + "text": "時間表" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147964/314.wav", + "text": "現在有幾家已經加入了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147964/315.wav", + "text": "所以今年年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147964/316.wav", + "text": "民間的還沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147964/317.wav", + "text": "民間加入的很少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147964/318.wav", + "text": "電支機構已經加入了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147964/319.wav", + "text": "啦已經有8家還9家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147964/320.wav", + "text": "至於那個開戶比較多的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147964/321.wav", + "text": "是到明年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147964/322.wav", + "text": "明年上半年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147964/323.wav", + "text": "明年什麼時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147964/324.wav", + "text": "明年上半年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147964/325.wav", + "text": "明年6月可以嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147964/326.wav", + "text": "明年上半年儘量往這個方向" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147964/327.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147964/328.wav", + "text": "謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147964/329.wav", + "text": "謝謝委員指導" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147963/0.wav", + "text": "請管主委" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147963/1.wav", + "text": "黃委員好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147963/2.wav", + "text": "主委好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147963/3.wav", + "text": "我想先請教我們的主委" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147963/4.wav", + "text": "過去行政院曾經提出" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147963/5.wav", + "text": "繼向山致敬之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147963/6.wav", + "text": "這個親海的相關政策" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147963/7.wav", + "text": "不知道現在這個政策在院裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147963/8.wav", + "text": "有的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147963/9.wav", + "text": "我們還是持續的就向海致敬以來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147963/10.wav", + "text": "我們在明年度的預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147963/11.wav", + "text": "也都有再繼續follow" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147963/12.wav", + "text": "繼續follow" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147963/13.wav", + "text": "我想其中有一項很重要的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147963/14.wav", + "text": "遊憩活動方面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147963/15.wav", + "text": "雖然我們的發展觀光條例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147963/16.wav", + "text": "以及相關的規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147963/17.wav", + "text": "例外禁止" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147963/18.wav", + "text": "但是我們可以看到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147963/19.wav", + "text": "直到目前為止" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147963/20.wav", + "text": "除了少數本來目的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147963/21.wav", + "text": "就是以發展觀光" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147963/22.wav", + "text": "遊憩為主的之外" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147963/23.wav", + "text": "還有少數像高雄市政府" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147963/24.wav", + "text": "在朝這個方向來努力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147963/25.wav", + "text": "事實上我們絕大多數的海域" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147963/26.wav", + "text": "如果你去看各地方政府" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147963/27.wav", + "text": "或是各主管機關的公告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147963/28.wav", + "text": "它的內容其實是倒過來的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147963/29.wav", + "text": "例外開放" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147963/30.wav", + "text": "\n我想這個問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147963/31.wav", + "text": "當然也不完全是海委會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147963/32.wav", + "text": "單方面可以來處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147963/33.wav", + "text": "當初在進行這樣子檢討的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147963/34.wav", + "text": "有請海委會主責" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147963/35.wav", + "text": "來建立所謂的一站式平臺" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147963/36.wav", + "text": "讓我們全國的民眾可以知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147963/37.wav", + "text": "親水的親海的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147963/38.wav", + "text": "這一些遊憩活動" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147963/39.wav", + "text": "更牽涉到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147963/40.wav", + "text": "應該要以什麼樣的平臺" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147963/41.wav", + "text": "什麼樣的程序" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147963/42.wav", + "text": "主管機關來做輔導" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147963/43.wav", + "text": "以及受理申請" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147963/44.wav", + "text": "可以讓我們的業者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147963/45.wav", + "text": "來參與營運這樣的機制及窗口" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147963/46.wav", + "text": "我想現在是相當的缺乏" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147963/47.wav", + "text": "大概都是用零星的個案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147963/48.wav", + "text": "地方政府去發動" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147963/49.wav", + "text": "或是怎麼樣之類的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147963/50.wav", + "text": "我們期待於海委會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147963/51.wav", + "text": "的是因為整個海洋產業發展條例也通過了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147963/52.wav", + "text": "雖然還沒正式實施" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147963/53.wav", + "text": "但我看到你們有一些先導性的計畫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147963/54.wav", + "text": "在這一個預算裡面也有呈現" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147963/55.wav", + "text": "工作也都先在做了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147963/56.wav", + "text": "事實上這一塊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147963/57.wav", + "text": "不管法制面或是機制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147963/58.wav", + "text": "我想海委會可能還是要多用心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147963/59.wav", + "text": "在這個上面去做一些整合" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147963/60.wav", + "text": "事實上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147963/61.wav", + "text": "監察院最近有一個調查報告也有提到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147963/62.wav", + "text": "好像看起來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147963/63.wav", + "text": "最適合做這個溝通平臺的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147963/64.wav", + "text": "還是我們的海委會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147963/65.wav", + "text": "海委會也有回應" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147963/66.wav", + "text": "有公告禁止水域遊憩活動的地方政府" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147963/67.wav", + "text": "規劃民意座談會來做溝通之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147963/68.wav", + "text": "輔導他們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147963/69.wav", + "text": "盡可能的來開放相關的海域或水域" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147963/70.wav", + "text": "雖然可能沒有辦法一開始就把它扭轉過來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147963/71.wav", + "text": "從正面表列變負面表列" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147963/72.wav", + "text": "但是是不是可以讓民眾" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147963/73.wav", + "text": "這個請主委來跟我們說明一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147963/74.wav", + "text": "你們會怎麼做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147963/75.wav", + "text": "好第一個就是海產條例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147963/76.wav", + "text": "的實施日期行政院還沒有公布" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147963/77.wav", + "text": "委員也很關心督促" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147963/78.wav", + "text": "所以我們非常積極的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147963/79.wav", + "text": "在做跨部會的協調溝通" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147963/80.wav", + "text": "最主要是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147963/81.wav", + "text": "海洋產業我們要怎麼樣去定義" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147963/82.wav", + "text": "怎麼樣去分工怎麼樣去認定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147963/83.wav", + "text": "最後去計算產值的這一塊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147963/84.wav", + "text": "如果我們做好了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147963/85.wav", + "text": "我想我們請行政院來公告實施" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147963/86.wav", + "text": "應該就會得到行政院的支持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147963/87.wav", + "text": "我們預計大概年底就會完成這個工作" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147963/88.wav", + "text": "如果快的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147963/89.wav", + "text": "我是比較希望" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147963/90.wav", + "text": "如果年底完成行政院的速度快一點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147963/91.wav", + "text": "看能不能明年1月1日就公告實施" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147963/92.wav", + "text": "如果還來不及的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147963/93.wav", + "text": "頂多就是1月中旬的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147963/94.wav", + "text": "能夠公告實施" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147963/95.wav", + "text": "這個是第一點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147963/96.wav", + "text": "\n第二點是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147963/97.wav", + "text": "雖然它還沒有實施" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147963/98.wav", + "text": "事實上我們的海資處" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147963/99.wav", + "text": "還有我們的國海院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147963/100.wav", + "text": "對於第一個遊憩安全的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147963/101.wav", + "text": "他們已經都開始做到相當成熟的地步了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147963/102.wav", + "text": "另外海資處對於各種遊憩" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147963/103.wav", + "text": "或者是各種產業之間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147963/104.wav", + "text": "需要相互溝通的協調統合工作" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147963/105.wav", + "text": "我看他們好幾個題目" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147963/106.wav", + "text": "都不斷的在和各個領域溝通" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147963/107.wav", + "text": "譬如自由潛水" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147963/108.wav", + "text": "自由潛水的這個系統" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147963/109.wav", + "text": "它會需要和教育部溝通" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147963/110.wav", + "text": "它會需要跟交通部的觀光署溝通" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147963/111.wav", + "text": "而交通部跟教育部之間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147963/112.wav", + "text": "光是對於" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147963/113.wav", + "text": "到底是要交通部觀光的角度切入來主責" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147963/114.wav", + "text": "還是用教育部體育發展的角度來主責" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147963/115.wav", + "text": "這個部分我們就居中做了很多的協調" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147963/116.wav", + "text": "我們比較希望是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147963/117.wav", + "text": "教育部你要扛下來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147963/118.wav", + "text": "所以從這個案例舉例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147963/119.wav", + "text": "我們是協調統合的機構" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147963/120.wav", + "text": "整合的工作需要我們去做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147963/121.wav", + "text": "他們是一個新興的產業" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147963/122.wav", + "text": "這個產業多半比較沒有像房地產" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147963/123.wav", + "text": "或機器設備可以做抵押品" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147963/124.wav", + "text": "所以整個休閒遊憩產業" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147963/125.wav", + "text": "銀行是非常的保守" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147963/126.wav", + "text": "也影響了產業的發展" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147963/127.wav", + "text": "這個部分我們都有在進行溝通協調" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147963/128.wav", + "text": "所以委員關心的海洋要更開放" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147963/129.wav", + "text": "比如說海洋要開放去做帆船遊艇等等的碼頭" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147963/130.wav", + "text": "那海域就開放了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147963/131.wav", + "text": "即我們有遊艇碼頭開闢出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147963/132.wav", + "text": "那海域就開放了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147963/133.wav", + "text": "但是這種產業得不到金融系統的肯定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147963/134.wav", + "text": "就影響了他們產業的發展" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147963/135.wav", + "text": "沒有人願意來做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147963/136.wav", + "text": "海域就沒有辦法開放" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147963/137.wav", + "text": "我們確實都已經開始在進行協調整合" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147963/138.wav", + "text": "好我想這裡有兩個層次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147963/139.wav", + "text": "一個就是剛剛主委講得很正確" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147963/140.wav", + "text": "但是同時要兼顧安全" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147963/141.wav", + "text": "而是在設備以及相關人員的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147963/142.wav", + "text": "訓練上面要先做好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147963/143.wav", + "text": "這當然是需要引入產業" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147963/144.wav", + "text": "這是其中一點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147963/145.wav", + "text": "所以由這個角度去切入的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147963/146.wav", + "text": "要扭轉這個原則跟例外" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147963/147.wav", + "text": "可能就需要讓這個休閒產業成熟化" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147963/148.wav", + "text": "但是可能它往這個方向完整的確保安全的這件事情上面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147963/149.wav", + "text": "過去的建置是做得不夠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147963/150.wav", + "text": "我們也期待海委會持續" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147963/151.wav", + "text": "事實上也有很多個別的協會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147963/152.wav", + "text": "或是民眾他們在反映" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147963/153.wav", + "text": "也不是所有的水上活動或是海域的活動" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147963/154.wav", + "text": "都需要這麼複雜" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147963/155.wav", + "text": "一定要有一個產業在那裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147963/156.wav", + "text": "它才是安全的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147963/157.wav", + "text": "你們內部一些單位對於海岸線" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147963/158.wav", + "text": "有進行風險評估" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147963/159.wav", + "text": "而且是動態即時的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147963/160.wav", + "text": "可能要用這個資料跟地方政府來做溝通" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147963/161.wav", + "text": "因為現在地方政府的公告上大部分都還是維持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147963/162.wav", + "text": "這樣它的第一句話就是禁止" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147963/163.wav", + "text": "然後後面頂多有開放" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147963/164.wav", + "text": "哪些項目要經過申請或什麼之類的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147963/165.wav", + "text": "如果被評定為相對安全或是穩定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147963/166.wav", + "text": "你可以把時間地點或是什麼都列出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147963/167.wav", + "text": "應該可以增加一些自由度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147963/168.wav", + "text": "而不是還是維持依現在的法令" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147963/169.wav", + "text": "還要等到這個地方一定要有一個產業進駐" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147963/170.wav", + "text": "你才要讓它開放" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147963/171.wav", + "text": "我是覺得可能這兩個層面問題都要處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147963/172.wav", + "text": "而不是只有產業的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147963/173.wav", + "text": "我們有特別增加一個經費" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147963/174.wav", + "text": "海域安全的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147963/175.wav", + "text": "如果地方政府認為這一個海域" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147963/176.wav", + "text": "你們需要在海域��憩安全上面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147963/177.wav", + "text": "比如說增加巡守" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147963/178.wav", + "text": "增加救生員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147963/179.wav", + "text": "增加救生設備" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147963/180.wav", + "text": "增加宣導告示" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147963/181.wav", + "text": "你們需要這一些支持的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147963/182.wav", + "text": "我們今年的預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147963/183.wav", + "text": "就再請委員支持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147963/184.wav", + "text": "好這個就是你們可以拿來跟地方政府溝通" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147963/185.wav", + "text": "說服他們的一個工具" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147963/186.wav", + "text": "我們樂觀其成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147963/187.wav", + "text": "希望我們能夠儘早" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147963/188.wav", + "text": "親水這樣的環境" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147963/189.wav", + "text": "前進在規範面跟執行面上面也都能夠一致" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147963/190.wav", + "text": "是舉一個例子好嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147963/191.wav", + "text": "他在之前大武崙不幸事件發生的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147963/192.wav", + "text": "他也很傷感" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147963/193.wav", + "text": "那時候我就有講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147963/194.wav", + "text": "在海域遊憩安全的補助增加為3倍" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147963/195.wav", + "text": "所以這個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147963/196.wav", + "text": "我們也都接受全國各縣市政府視需要來申請" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147963/197.wav", + "text": "我們也希望地方政府能夠積極一點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147963/198.wav", + "text": "謝謝黃世杰委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147962/0.wav", + "text": "謝謝主席" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147962/1.wav", + "text": "有請部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147962/2.wav", + "text": "還有長照司司長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147962/3.wav", + "text": "有請司長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147962/4.wav", + "text": "部長司長早安" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147962/5.wav", + "text": "謠言" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147962/6.wav", + "text": "衛福部有沒有馬上澄清這個議題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147962/7.wav", + "text": "事實上這是10月23日" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147962/8.wav", + "text": "市立聯合醫院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147962/9.wav", + "text": "他講許多醫院的高端" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147962/10.wav", + "text": "流感疫苗都滿出來了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147962/11.wav", + "text": "到醫院裡頭要打公費流感疫苗" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147962/12.wav", + "text": "只能打高端" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147962/13.wav", + "text": "大家都不用再挑了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147962/14.wav", + "text": "部長這是不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147962/15.wav", + "text": "屬實如果要打其他的品牌" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147962/16.wav", + "text": "變成要自費" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147962/17.wav", + "text": "簡報真實的情況是這個樣子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147962/18.wav", + "text": "其實我們有國光" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147962/19.wav", + "text": "諾菲有台灣東洋有高端" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147962/20.wav", + "text": "你是可以有選擇性的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147962/21.wav", + "text": "甚至蔣萬安市長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147962/22.wav", + "text": "衛生局回報這四種品牌疫苗" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147962/23.wav", + "text": "打最多的是國光疫苗" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147962/24.wav", + "text": "臺北市衛生局也回應" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147962/25.wav", + "text": "目前市立聯合醫院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147962/26.wav", + "text": "至少都有兩種以上的廠牌" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147962/27.wav", + "text": "會提供不同的廠牌" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147962/28.wav", + "text": "可以施打" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147962/29.wav", + "text": "不是只能打高端" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147962/30.wav", + "text": "部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147962/31.wav", + "text": "我講的是不是真實的狀況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147962/32.wav", + "text": "沒有錯" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147962/33.wav", + "text": "臺北市政府跟臺北市衛生局" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147962/34.wav", + "text": "所講的都沒有錯" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147962/35.wav", + "text": "都是超過兩種以上的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147962/36.wav", + "text": "超過兩種以上的流感疫苗" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147962/37.wav", + "text": "是可以讓我們的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147962/38.wav", + "text": "市民朋友去做選擇的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147962/39.wav", + "text": "在這個醫生的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147962/40.wav", + "text": "是這樣跟著媒體走" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147962/41.wav", + "text": "報告委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147962/42.wav", + "text": "網紅醫師" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147962/43.wav", + "text": "在他的臉書上面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147962/44.wav", + "text": "因為他本來就是會用這樣的態度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147962/45.wav", + "text": "我們又沒有辦法罰他" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147962/46.wav", + "text": "我們現在是不是自我要求" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147962/47.wav", + "text": "是不是應該要有更強的積極度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147962/48.wav", + "text": "的就是這樣子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147962/49.wav", + "text": "因為我們澄清的速度有快有慢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147962/50.wav", + "text": "沒有影響到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147962/51.wav", + "text": "我們回應會比較慢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147962/52.wav", + "text": "因為我們不想讓他爭流量" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147962/53.wav", + "text": "然後去賺do" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147962/54.wav", + "text": "就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147962/55.wav", + "text": "可是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147962/56.wav", + "text": "大家有一個比較不同的看法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147962/57.wav", + "text": "這會不會變成是一個議題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147962/58.wav", + "text": "不是澄清都是要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147962/59.wav", + "text": "的包括" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147962/60.wav", + "text": "今天委員提到這一件事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147962/61.wav", + "text": "其實是這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147962/62.wav", + "text": "現在各個縣市" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147962/63.wav", + "text": "沒有什麼異樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147962/64.wav", + "text": "但是臺北市是落後的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147962/65.wav", + "text": "不管是在65歲以上的老人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147962/66.wav", + "text": "不管是在學齡前的兒童" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147962/67.wav", + "text": "不管是學生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147962/68.wav", + "text": "或者是醫護人員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147962/69.wav", + "text": "都落後於全國的平均" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147962/70.wav", + "text": "所以我在這邊還是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147962/71.wav", + "text": "再呼籲一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147962/72.wav", + "text": "臺北市趕快去把它打" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147962/73.wav", + "text": "不要在那邊講這一些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147962/74.wav", + "text": "部長我再請教你一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147962/75.wav", + "text": "如果以臺北市為例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147962/76.wav", + "text": "它向來在施打" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147962/77.wav", + "text": "或是這些流感疫苗" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147962/78.wav", + "text": "的教育程度平均來講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147962/79.wav", + "text": "是比較高一點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147962/80.wav", + "text": "應該不會出現這種狀況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147962/81.wav", + "text": "所以這個政府有責任趕快去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147962/82.wav", + "text": "催打" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147962/83.wav", + "text": "是嘛所以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147962/84.wav", + "text": "我們顯然在回應上是慢了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147962/85.wav", + "text": "一拍了嘛他中午" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147962/86.wav", + "text": "講了你們輿" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147962/87.wav", + "text": "輿情的蒐集到了晚上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147962/88.wav", + "text": "你們才去回應他" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147962/89.wav", + "text": "我們把這個案例拿出來討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147962/90.wav", + "text": "因為你的公關室預算編了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147962/91.wav", + "text": "385萬顯然太少了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147962/92.wav", + "text": "因為這是一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147962/93.wav", + "text": "對有一些議題的要求" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147962/94.wav", + "text": "所以我想我們把它提出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147962/95.wav", + "text": "謝謝委員今年在這個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147962/96.wav", + "text": "你已經編太少啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147962/97.wav", + "text": "我們這種宣導預算都會對於" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147962/98.wav", + "text": "集你應該要想一個積極的方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147962/99.wav", + "text": "啊我現在已經很嫌棄" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147962/100.wav", + "text": "你們公關室的預算為什麼編那麼少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147962/101.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147962/102.wav", + "text": "我們來談長照3.0" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147962/103.wav", + "text": "要擴大到18萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147962/104.wav", + "text": "這當然是賴清德" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147962/105.wav", + "text": "本席在上個會期就曾經" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147962/106.wav", + "text": "由於機構的費用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147962/107.wav", + "text": "相當高" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147962/108.wav", + "text": "補助上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147962/109.wav", + "text": "不管是13萬18萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147962/110.wav", + "text": "甚至我今天提到的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147962/111.wav", + "text": "24萬我覺得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147962/112.wav", + "text": "都是我們必須要去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147962/113.wav", + "text": "共同討論的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147962/114.wav", + "text": "住宿長照機構落成了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147962/115.wav", + "text": "有到場與會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147962/116.wav", + "text": "房間的話每床每個月" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147962/117.wav", + "text": "要5萬塊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147962/118.wav", + "text": "5萬5單人是6萬塊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147962/119.wav", + "text": "在我們南部的話看起來好像" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147962/120.wav", + "text": "是貴了一點可是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147962/121.wav", + "text": "還是一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147962/122.wav", + "text": "一床難求為什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147962/123.wav", + "text": "因為它是榮總推出來的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147962/124.wav", + "text": "附屬長照機構還是護理之家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147962/125.wav", + "text": "相對地一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147962/126.wav", + "text": "也都是一床難求" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147962/127.wav", + "text": "我們甚至需要做到這樣的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147962/128.wav", + "text": "選民服務" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147962/129.wav", + "text": "主張應該是要多給" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147962/130.wav", + "text": "為什麼要補助" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147962/131.wav", + "text": "24萬我在這裡試" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147962/132.wav", + "text": "來換算的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147962/133.wav", + "text": "擔我們用最低的薪資" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147962/134.wav", + "text": "你看嘛如果是12萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147962/135.wav", + "text": "的話他必須要再負擔" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147962/136.wav", + "text": "1萬3如果是18萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147962/137.wav", + "text": "我們民眾要負擔8,000塊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147962/138.wav", + "text": "如果24萬的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147962/139.wav", + "text": "其實民眾只要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147962/140.wav", + "text": "負擔3,000塊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147962/141.wav", + "text": "所以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147962/142.wav", + "text": "長照機構如果是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147962/143.wav", + "text": "民眾來講是一個相當" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147962/144.wav", + "text": "我們也希望讓民眾的負擔少一點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147962/145.wav", + "text": "是不是請你說明一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147962/146.wav", + "text": "這部分的話大概是這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147962/147.wav", + "text": "我們會去算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147962/148.wav", + "text": "不管是18萬還是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147962/149.wav", + "text": "委員講的24萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147962/150.wav", + "text": "是怎麼樣因為這個不是等比的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147962/151.wav", + "text": "目前有一些是縣市" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147962/152.wav", + "text": "公費的床" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147962/153.wav", + "text": "一個月是給2萬2" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147962/154.wav", + "text": "只有給2萬2" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147962/155.wav", + "text": "縣市政府編預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147962/156.wav", + "text": "然後是由地方政府來補貼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147962/157.wav", + "text": "那它都必須要擺進去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147962/158.wav", + "text": "部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147962/159.wav", + "text": "你的床確實就是不足" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147962/160.wav", + "text": "把護理之家再補進去的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147962/161.wav", + "text": "也還是不夠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147962/162.wav", + "text": "現在就是布建的計畫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147962/163.wav", + "text": "要加速" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147962/164.wav", + "text": "所以你有一個擴充的計畫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147962/165.wav", + "text": "我們希望" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147962/166.wav", + "text": "你要加速加快" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147962/167.wav", + "text": "齡老化的人口" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147962/168.wav", + "text": "一直在急遽地增加" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147962/169.wav", + "text": "我們國家的社會福利" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147962/170.wav", + "text": "趕不上來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147962/171.wav", + "text": "啊這就是今天本席跟你質詢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147962/172.wav", + "text": "部長加油" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147962/173.wav", + "text": "謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147960/0.wav", + "text": "調查局局長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147960/1.wav", + "text": "最近" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147960/2.wav", + "text": "大家都知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147960/3.wav", + "text": "吵得沸沸揚揚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147960/4.wav", + "text": "這兩宗新聞事實上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147960/5.wav", + "text": "都跟我們今天所談到的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147960/6.wav", + "text": "介入選舉或介入政治" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147960/7.wav", + "text": "或者是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147960/8.wav", + "text": "有沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147960/9.wav", + "text": "危及國安的疑慮" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147960/10.wav", + "text": "以及這裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147960/11.wav", + "text": "有沒有涉及" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147960/12.wav", + "text": "包含有沒有AI的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147960/13.wav", + "text": "這種深偽技術等等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147960/14.wav", + "text": "我要直接在今天的委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147960/15.wav", + "text": "最近行政院副院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147960/16.wav", + "text": "鄭文燦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147960/17.wav", + "text": "所被指涉的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147960/18.wav", + "text": "跟女子開房間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147960/19.wav", + "text": "影片曝光之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147960/20.wav", + "text": "我們的副院長第一時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147960/21.wav", + "text": "年代久遠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147960/22.wav", + "text": "而且影片經過變造" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147960/23.wav", + "text": "造我也有注意到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147960/24.wav", + "text": "我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147960/25.wav", + "text": "有沒有經過變造" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147960/26.wav", + "text": "甚至" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147960/27.wav", + "text": "這個影片" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147960/28.wav", + "text": "是不是被合成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147960/29.wav", + "text": "目前我們都有相關的辨識技術" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147960/30.wav", + "text": "我在這裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147960/31.wav", + "text": "最近在網路上流傳的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147960/32.wav", + "text": "被認為是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147960/33.wav", + "text": "我們行政院副院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147960/34.wav", + "text": "鄭文燦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147960/35.wav", + "text": "到飯店裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147960/36.wav", + "text": "跟女子開房間的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147960/37.wav", + "text": "我不曉得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147960/38.wav", + "text": "鄭文燦副院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147960/39.wav", + "text": "現在到底有沒有提告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147960/40.wav", + "text": "但是因為今天涉及" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147960/41.wav", + "text": "行政院副院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147960/42.wav", + "text": "這樣的行政高層" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147960/43.wav", + "text": "我認為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147960/44.wav", + "text": "一定要趕快" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147960/45.wav", + "text": "做個明確的釐清" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147960/46.wav", + "text": "所以待會兒" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147960/47.wav", + "text": "我就會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147960/48.wav", + "text": "直接" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147960/49.wav", + "text": "把這個影片" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147960/50.wav", + "text": "法務部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147960/51.wav", + "text": "看是不是找相關單位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147960/52.wav", + "text": "告訴我們這個影片" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147960/53.wav", + "text": "有沒有經過剪接" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147960/54.wav", + "text": "有沒有經過變造" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147960/55.wav", + "text": "把這個相關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147960/56.wav", + "text": "調查結果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147960/57.wav", + "text": "提供給我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147960/58.wav", + "text": "委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147960/59.wav", + "text": "一週之內提供給委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147960/60.wav", + "text": "就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147960/61.wav", + "text": "趙天麟委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147960/62.wav", + "text": "大家都知道他是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147960/63.wav", + "text": "因為他承認自己涉入" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147960/64.wav", + "text": "這個外遇對象也曝光" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147960/65.wav", + "text": "是大陸籍的女子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147960/66.wav", + "text": "所以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147960/67.wav", + "text": "現在其實不" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147960/68.wav", + "text": "不分政黨都在質疑" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147960/69.wav", + "text": "這個案子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147960/70.wav", + "text": "有沒有涉及" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147960/71.wav", + "text": "這裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147960/72.wav", + "text": "也特別提到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147960/73.wav", + "text": "有沒有境外敵對勢力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147960/74.wav", + "text": "在介入我們的政治" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147960/75.wav", + "text": "甚至介入我們的選舉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147960/76.wav", + "text": "趙天麟委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147960/77.wav", + "text": "昨天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147960/78.wav", + "text": "也對外表示" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147960/79.wav", + "text": "他說他禁得起考驗" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147960/80.wav", + "text": "他願意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147960/81.wav", + "text": "接受" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147960/82.wav", + "text": "這是趙天麟委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147960/83.wav", + "text": "我沒有違背他的意思" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147960/84.wav", + "text": "並沒有任何人去提告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147960/85.wav", + "text": "外交及國防委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147960/86.wav", + "text": "也沒有做成什麼決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147960/87.wav", + "text": "我覺得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147960/88.wav", + "text": "事關重大" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147960/89.wav", + "text": "趙天麟委員的外遇" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147960/90.wav", + "text": "大陸籍女子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147960/91.wav", + "text": "有沒有涉及" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147960/92.wav", + "text": "國安的相關疑慮" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147960/93.wav", + "text": "我也希望" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147960/94.wav", + "text": "能夠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147960/95.wav", + "text": "一起趕快來做調查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147960/96.wav", + "text": "該澄清的就澄清" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147960/97.wav", + "text": "該追查的就追查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147960/98.wav", + "text": "我在這邊要求" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147960/99.wav", + "text": "趙天麟委員這個案子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147960/100.wav", + "text": "也能在一週內" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147960/101.wav", + "text": "把你們的調查結果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147960/102.wav", + "text": "提交到我們的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147960/103.wav", + "text": "司法及法制委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147960/104.wav", + "text": "和外交及國防委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147960/105.wav", + "text": "兩個委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147960/106.wav", + "text": "都能夠提交" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147960/107.wav", + "text": "包含鄭文燦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147960/108.wav", + "text": "以及趙天麟委員的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147960/109.wav", + "text": "我現在直接" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147960/110.wav", + "text": "送到你們的手上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147960/111.wav", + "text": "你們就可以趕快去辦案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147960/112.wav", + "text": "不要只是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147960/113.wav", + "text": "媒體朋友一直問你們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147960/114.wav", + "text": "但是都沒有動作" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147960/115.wav", + "text": "好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147960/116.wav", + "text": "部長回答一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147960/117.wav", + "text": "因為我時間有限" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147960/118.wav", + "text": "我還有一個很重要的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147960/119.wav", + "text": "問題我就是請他們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147960/120.wav", + "text": "帶回去就要辦案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147960/121.wav", + "text": "對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147960/122.wav", + "text": "本委員會支持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147960/123.wav", + "text": "讓他們趕快把調查報告給我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147960/124.wav", + "text": "另外" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147960/125.wav", + "text": "因為現在正在大選" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147960/126.wav", + "text": "非常非常重要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147960/127.wav", + "text": "法務部有特別提到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147960/128.wav", + "text": "境外資金" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147960/129.wav", + "text": "介選的六種樣態" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147960/130.wav", + "text": "我也注意到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147960/131.wav", + "text": "10月4日" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147960/132.wav", + "text": "蔡明彥局長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147960/133.wav", + "text": "的另外一個樣態" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147960/134.wav", + "text": "卻都沒有在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147960/135.wav", + "text": "既不在法務部的報告裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147960/136.wav", + "text": "國安局的報告裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147960/137.wav", + "text": "我真的不曉得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147960/138.wav", + "text": "是怎麼回事" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147960/139.wav", + "text": "你們的報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147960/140.wav", + "text": "應該是10月4日以後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147960/141.wav", + "text": "做的嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147960/142.wav", + "text": "以是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147960/143.wav", + "text": "信口開河" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147960/144.wav", + "text": "還是怎麼樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147960/145.wav", + "text": "他怎麼講呢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147960/146.wav", + "text": "他說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147960/147.wav", + "text": "我們現在不排除" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147960/148.wav", + "text": "中共" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147960/149.wav", + "text": "會在選舉過程裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147960/150.wav", + "text": "透過政治議題操作" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147960/151.wav", + "text": "對臺灣選民進行認知作戰" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147960/152.wav", + "text": "要注意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147960/153.wav", + "text": "中共可能" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147960/154.wav", + "text": "跟臺灣的公關公司進行民調" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147960/155.wav", + "text": "這些民調發布" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147960/156.wav", + "text": "會對選舉過程產生影響" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147960/157.wav", + "text": "所以我想請問" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147960/158.wav", + "text": "今天照理講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147960/159.wav", + "text": "局長要來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147960/160.wav", + "text": "對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147960/161.wav", + "text": "請問副局長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147960/162.wav", + "text": "你們查到什麼了嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147960/163.wav", + "text": "為什麼局長會這樣說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147960/164.wav", + "text": "又不在法務部的報告裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147960/165.wav", + "text": "我們很怕變成漏網之魚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147960/166.wav", + "text": "副局長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147960/167.wav", + "text": "請問一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147960/168.wav", + "text": "我們國安局現在掌握" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147960/169.wav", + "text": "臺灣有公關公司" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147960/170.wav", + "text": "來發布假民調嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147960/171.wav", + "text": "有沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147960/172.wav", + "text": "有沒有掌握" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147960/173.wav", + "text": "我們有相關的資訊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147960/174.wav", + "text": "但是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147960/175.wav", + "text": "我們還在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147960/176.wav", + "text": "繼續蒐集中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147960/177.wav", + "text": "有沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147960/178.wav", + "text": "鎖定的公關公司" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147960/179.wav", + "text": "有沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147960/180.wav", + "text": "\n這個時間要暫停" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147960/181.wav", + "text": "怎麼樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147960/182.wav", + "text": "有沒有鎖定的公關公司" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147960/183.wav", + "text": "我們有一些資訊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147960/184.wav", + "text": "如果委員要的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147960/185.wav", + "text": "我們可以提供" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147960/186.wav", + "text": "好可以提供給我" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147960/187.wav", + "text": "\n我另外請教一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147960/188.wav", + "text": "你們應該是有鎖定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147960/189.wav", + "text": "才會講這個話嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147960/190.wav", + "text": "對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147960/191.wav", + "text": "有沒有鎖定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147960/192.wav", + "text": "還是只是聽聞" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147960/193.wav", + "text": "這兩者有差別" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147960/194.wav", + "text": "中共會利用這一種手法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147960/195.wav", + "text": "對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147960/196.wav", + "text": "我們認為還在觀察中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147960/197.wav", + "text": "所以變成你們認為是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147960/198.wav", + "text": "好這個有差別" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147960/199.wav", + "text": "我的質詢是很明確" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147960/200.wav", + "text": "另外我想請教" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147960/201.wav", + "text": "2016年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147960/202.wav", + "text": "時行政院很奇怪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147960/203.wav", + "text": "它去制定了公關公司的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147960/204.wav", + "text": "政治背景提示" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147960/205.wav", + "text": "把相關的公關公司" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147960/206.wav", + "text": "出KMTDPP" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147960/207.wav", + "text": "他是什麼出身" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147960/208.wav", + "text": "幫過哪一個政治人物" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147960/209.wav", + "text": "幫蔡英文做文宣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147960/210.wav", + "text": "既然提到公關公司" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147960/211.wav", + "text": "或者說在大選裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147960/212.wav", + "text": "被你們認為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147960/213.wav", + "text": "那請問一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147960/214.wav", + "text": "你們是不是也已經制定了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147960/215.wav", + "text": "新的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147960/216.wav", + "text": "都快8年了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147960/217.wav", + "text": "有或沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147960/218.wav", + "text": "這一方面我們有持續在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147960/219.wav", + "text": "在做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147960/220.wav", + "text": "在做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147960/221.wav", + "text": "好所以你們會有update" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147960/222.wav", + "text": "繼續在對公關公司" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147960/223.wav", + "text": "做政治背景調查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147960/224.wav", + "text": "不是不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147960/225.wav", + "text": "不是做背景調查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147960/226.wav", + "text": "而是如果他有一些跡象顯示" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147960/227.wav", + "text": "是有透過第三地" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147960/228.wav", + "text": "有可能有一些跡象顯示" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147960/229.wav", + "text": "我們才會注意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147960/230.wav", + "text": "不是做政治調查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147960/231.wav", + "text": "不會做全面的背景調查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147960/232.wav", + "text": "所以如果這樣的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147960/233.wav", + "text": "2016年那個就是做錯誤的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147960/234.wav", + "text": "啊對人家公關公司" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147960/235.wav", + "text": "做全面的政治背景調查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147960/236.wav", + "text": "當時是你們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147960/237.wav", + "text": "行政院提出來的喔" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147960/238.wav", + "text": "報告委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147960/239.wav", + "text": "這不是我們局裡面做的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147960/240.wav", + "text": "好這不是你們局裡做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147960/241.wav", + "text": "你們現在沒有對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147960/242.wav", + "text": "公關公司在做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147960/243.wav", + "text": "政治背景調查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147960/244.wav", + "text": "沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147960/245.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147960/246.wav", + "text": "也沒有做任何的鎖定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147960/247.wav", + "text": "這樣看起來你有鎖定喔" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147960/248.wav", + "text": "不是如果有一些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147960/249.wav", + "text": "我們覺得比較異常的接觸" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147960/250.wav", + "text": "我們就會開始注意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147960/251.wav", + "text": "所以你們現在有情資顯示" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147960/252.wav", + "text": "有公關公司" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147960/253.wav", + "text": "接受到這些異常接觸是吧" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147960/254.wav", + "text": "透過境外的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147960/255.wav", + "text": "我們就會比較關注" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147960/256.wav", + "text": "你沒有講得很清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147960/257.wav", + "text": "再提供給我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147960/258.wav", + "text": "謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147959/0.wav", + "text": "游委員好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147959/1.wav", + "text": "謝謝主委我剛剛聽到您的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147959/2.wav", + "text": "口頭報告非常感動我覺得臺灣作為一個海洋" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147959/3.wav", + "text": "國家我們在海洋" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147959/4.wav", + "text": "保育上面的確是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147959/5.wav", + "text": "還要更加地努力也謝謝主委跟所有謝謝委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147959/6.wav", + "text": "不過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147959/7.wav", + "text": "本席想要關心的是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147959/8.wav", + "text": "有關於海勤加給的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147959/9.wav", + "text": "因為海勤加給" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147959/10.wav", + "text": "是依據" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147959/11.wav", + "text": "實際的出海" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147959/12.wav", + "text": "日數" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147959/13.wav", + "text": "同仁的職等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147959/14.wav", + "text": "還有職務" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147959/15.wav", + "text": "來區分為遠洋" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147959/16.wav", + "text": "跟近海" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147959/17.wav", + "text": "每天可以支給" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147959/18.wav", + "text": "550元到1,200元" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147959/19.wav", + "text": "數額不等的海上勤務加給" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147959/20.wav", + "text": "海委會是一個比較特殊的組織因為有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147959/21.wav", + "text": "軍警文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147959/22.wav", + "text": "類別的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147959/23.wav", + "text": "人員在裡面工作" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147959/24.wav", + "text": "當然我在其他委員會也聽到會有委員說軍人最" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147959/25.wav", + "text": "辛苦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147959/26.wav", + "text": "軍人的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147959/27.wav", + "text": "待遇最不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147959/28.wav", + "text": "但是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147959/29.wav", + "text": "我也聽到警察同仁告訴我說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147959/30.wav", + "text": "軍人終生都有保障" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147959/31.wav", + "text": "如果殉職的話他們是終生撫卹" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147959/32.wav", + "text": "但是我們的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147959/33.wav", + "text": "就沒有這樣子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147959/34.wav", + "text": "所以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147959/35.wav", + "text": "這是不容易的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147959/36.wav", + "text": "就是我們海巡署裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147959/37.wav", + "text": "只有海勤加給是不分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147959/38.wav", + "text": "軍警文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147959/39.wav", + "text": "你只要在艦艇上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147959/40.wav", + "text": "服勤" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147959/41.wav", + "text": "有出海執勤的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147959/42.wav", + "text": "事實" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147959/43.wav", + "text": "就可以申請海勤加" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147959/44.wav", + "text": "因為申請海勤加給也不會影響到警職人員他們的警勤加給嘛這" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147959/45.wav", + "text": "應該沒有錯對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147959/46.wav", + "text": "可以重複" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147959/47.wav", + "text": "另外還有一個演訓加給也是可以重複" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147959/48.wav", + "text": "因為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147959/49.wav", + "text": "3月22日" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147959/50.wav", + "text": "我有請主委檢討" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147959/51.wav", + "text": "因為我們的海上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147959/52.wav", + "text": "加給表" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147959/53.wav", + "text": "20年都沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147959/54.wav", + "text": "調升" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147959/55.wav", + "text": "那一天主委是沒有告訴我會不會檢討調" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147959/56.wav", + "text": "不過有提到會有個演訓特別津貼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147959/57.wav", + "text": "所以這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147959/58.wav", + "text": "特別津貼現在是已經開始了嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147959/59.wav", + "text": "演訓津貼開始了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147959/60.wav", + "text": "而且有回溯處理已經發過了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147959/61.wav", + "text": "已經發過了是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147959/62.wav", + "text": "所以會比我們原來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147959/63.wav", + "text": "就是說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147959/64.wav", + "text": "它有在演訓的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147959/65.wav", + "text": "海勤加給是平常你在海上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147959/66.wav", + "text": "執行正常勤任務的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147959/67.wav", + "text": "都可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147959/68.wav", + "text": "演訓是額外如果這又是一個軍演的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147959/69.wav", + "text": "你參加演訓的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147959/70.wav", + "text": "我們又另外再有演訓加給" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147959/71.wav", + "text": "海勤加給就沒有再調整嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147959/72.wav", + "text": "跟委員報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147959/73.wav", + "text": "首先還是要謝謝委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147959/74.wav", + "text": "真的是對於軍警消這個部分的福利" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147959/75.wav", + "text": "長期地把守長期地督促" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147959/76.wav", + "text": "其實也真的很有成果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147959/77.wav", + "text": "最近的成果就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147959/78.wav", + "text": "我們的警勤加給調了15%" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147959/79.wav", + "text": "我們的危險加給也調了15%" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147959/80.wav", + "text": "他們的加班費最高可以調升到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147959/81.wav", + "text": "可申請1萬9,000" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147959/82.wav", + "text": "委員長期有在努力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147959/83.wav", + "text": "然後大家共同努力得到這樣的成果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147959/84.wav", + "text": "\n有關於海勤加給也" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147959/85.wav", + "text": "就是海上職務加給的這個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147959/86.wav", + "text": "軍職警職他們都可以領" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147959/87.wav", + "text": "委員很關心的就是說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147959/88.wav", + "text": "你為什麼要近海遠洋這樣分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147959/89.wav", + "text": "然後為什麼要照職等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147959/90.wav", + "text": "另外就是整體能不能調升10%" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147959/91.wav", + "text": "跟委員報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147959/92.wav", + "text": "因為委員也很關心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147959/93.wav", + "text": "我們有跟行政院爭取" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147959/94.wav", + "text": "爭取了5月份一輪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147959/95.wav", + "text": "7月份一輪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147959/96.wav", + "text": "然後現在又一輪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147959/97.wav", + "text": "然後積極地在爭取當中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147959/98.wav", + "text": "所以現在障礙還是在人總嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147959/99.wav", + "text": "到行政院去以後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147959/100.wav", + "text": "首先當然是人總" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147959/101.wav", + "text": "總人總也會發文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147959/102.wav", + "text": "跟相關的部會徵詢意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147959/103.wav", + "text": "最後一輪我們的公文出去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147959/104.wav", + "text": "還沒有得到回復" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147959/105.wav", + "text": "復這個事情我們都有在積極地爭取" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147959/106.wav", + "text": "目前行政院還沒有作最後的決定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147959/107.wav", + "text": "是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147959/108.wav", + "text": "我��天問我們的署長說有沒有信心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147959/109.wav", + "text": "我有信心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147959/110.wav", + "text": "署長有信心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147959/111.wav", + "text": "主委因為你也知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147959/112.wav", + "text": "過去這幾年來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147959/113.wav", + "text": "為軍警交爭取這些的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147959/114.wav", + "text": "可是要知道真的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147959/115.wav", + "text": "尤其在最近這段時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147959/116.wav", + "text": "臺海兵凶戰危" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147959/117.wav", + "text": "我們的海巡弟兄" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147959/118.wav", + "text": "當然有姐妹" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147959/119.wav", + "text": "啦我們的海巡同仁" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147959/120.wav", + "text": "真的是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147959/121.wav", + "text": "備極辛苦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147959/122.wav", + "text": "可是士氣高昂喔委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147959/123.wav", + "text": "當然是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147959/124.wav", + "text": "輿論一直講兵凶戰危" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147959/125.wav", + "text": "兵凶戰危其實我有點擔心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147959/126.wav", + "text": "會不會讓我們的士氣受影響" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147959/127.wav", + "text": "我們很有信心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147959/128.wav", + "text": "因為我們很認真地在守" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147959/129.wav", + "text": "我的學弟妹們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147959/130.wav", + "text": "尤其是我自己教過的學生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147959/131.wav", + "text": "我更是有信心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147959/132.wav", + "text": "不過我倒是建議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147959/133.wav", + "text": "如果需要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147959/134.wav", + "text": "因為你再怎麼樣也是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147959/135.wav", + "text": "從我們內政委員會出去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147959/136.wav", + "text": "的如果有必要的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147959/137.wav", + "text": "召委兩個都願意幫你們排考察" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147959/138.wav", + "text": "讓人總那些唱反調的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147959/139.wav", + "text": "就是認為要衡平的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147959/140.wav", + "text": "去經歷一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147959/141.wav", + "text": "那個黑水溝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147959/142.wav", + "text": "跟委員報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147959/143.wav", + "text": "他們要去彙整是因為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147959/144.wav", + "text": "就要會主總" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147959/145.wav", + "text": "他們也會會像國發" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147959/146.wav", + "text": "我這一題問得是比較久一點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147959/147.wav", + "text": "我們會努力的去溝通" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147959/148.wav", + "text": "我還是要再追到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147959/149.wav", + "text": "我其實在第2會期" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147959/150.wav", + "text": "一開始就提出這個問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147959/151.wav", + "text": "因為艦隊分署" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147959/152.wav", + "text": "署第12到第16海巡隊長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147959/153.wav", + "text": "的職等實在是太低了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147959/154.wav", + "text": "比如岸���隊的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147959/155.wav", + "text": "不管下面人數多少或怎麼樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147959/156.wav", + "text": "也都是上校以上的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147959/157.wav", + "text": "比如嘉義隊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147959/158.wav", + "text": "它的幅員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147959/159.wav", + "text": "其實涵蓋好幾個縣市" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147959/160.wav", + "text": "居然它的海巡隊長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147959/161.wav", + "text": "啊你如何去和" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147959/162.wav", + "text": "和當地的其他情治機關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147959/163.wav", + "text": "或者是地方政府來做協調" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147959/164.wav", + "text": "當時一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147959/165.wav", + "text": "人總還是用衡平性考量等等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147959/166.wav", + "text": "我覺得在這個時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147959/167.wav", + "text": "真的是要幫他們講話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147959/168.wav", + "text": "要不要讓我們艦隊分署長來說明一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147959/169.wav", + "text": "是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147959/170.wav", + "text": "他很積極在幫忙這件事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147959/171.wav", + "text": "謝謝委員的關心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147959/172.wav", + "text": "事實上我們的乙種隊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147959/173.wav", + "text": "不比以往" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147959/174.wav", + "text": "包括我們現在任務的繁重性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147959/175.wav", + "text": "都不比以往" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147959/176.wav", + "text": "包括我們要前推到24浬去執行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147959/177.wav", + "text": "有些狀況是要和友軍單位去做協調的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147959/178.wav", + "text": "就是我們現在講的乙種海巡隊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147959/179.wav", + "text": "在這個聯繫協調上面的確是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147959/180.wav", + "text": "主委所以這個麻煩您好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147959/181.wav", + "text": "因為人總那邊也有很多你的學生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147959/182.wav", + "text": "我們一起來幫他們解決這個問題好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147959/183.wav", + "text": "好的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147959/184.wav", + "text": "剛剛我們副主委兼署長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147959/185.wav", + "text": "也覺得我們其實是持續的溝通" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147959/186.wav", + "text": "海巡署在周副主委領導之下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147959/187.wav", + "text": "他對這幾件事情也非常非常的積極在溝通" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147959/188.wav", + "text": "剛剛副主委也表示很有信心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147959/189.wav", + "text": "我們會很努力的再積極來爭取" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147959/190.wav", + "text": "因為現在確實不一樣了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147959/191.wav", + "text": "我們新的艦艇不斷的在造" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147959/192.wav", + "text": "現在勤任務的內容也有些不同" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147959/193.wav", + "text": "我們不能夠只是去看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147959/194.wav", + "text": "用這些指標去看就這樣子做區分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147959/195.wav", + "text": "我們會來努力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147959/196.wav", + "text": "我跟召委再借1分鐘的時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147959/197.wav", + "text": "我也要請我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147959/198.wav", + "text": "一定要支持海委會的預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147959/199.wav", + "text": "因為海委會的預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147959/200.wav", + "text": "今年比去年減少了1億2,000多萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147959/201.wav", + "text": "可是我再看下去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147959/202.wav", + "text": "我更嚇一跳" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147959/203.wav", + "text": "主要因為海委會本身" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147959/204.wav", + "text": "內部的大概是增加2億3,000萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147959/205.wav", + "text": "海保署增加3,800萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147959/206.wav", + "text": "只有海巡署" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147959/207.wav", + "text": "是減少了8億1,800多萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147959/208.wav", + "text": "主要是造艦的經費" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147959/209.wav", + "text": "是造艦的經費" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147959/210.wav", + "text": "對新建造艦的經費有減少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147959/211.wav", + "text": "因為陸陸續續造好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147959/212.wav", + "text": "造對照計畫陸陸續續造好交船" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147959/213.wav", + "text": "主要是那一塊減少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147959/214.wav", + "text": "委員但是那一塊減少以後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147959/215.wav", + "text": "我們又非常多的案子補進來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147959/216.wav", + "text": "所以最後只差那1億多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147959/217.wav", + "text": "海巡弟兄用的很凶" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147959/218.wav", + "text": "還有他們的車輛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147959/219.wav", + "text": "也務必一定要維持他們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147959/220.wav", + "text": "委員很注意細節" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147959/221.wav", + "text": "這兩項就是我們新增了大量預算的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147959/222.wav", + "text": "這真的是為了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147959/223.wav", + "text": "他們執勤最基本的安全要做的事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147959/224.wav", + "text": "是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147959/225.wav", + "text": "所以這一部分就是要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147959/226.wav", + "text": "懇請我們海委會各級長官" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147959/227.wav", + "text": "一定要顧慮到我們在第一線的這些同仁" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147959/228.wav", + "text": "有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147959/229.wav", + "text": "謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147959/230.wav", + "text": "好非常感謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147959/231.wav", + "text": "謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147959/232.wav", + "text": "謝謝游召委\n" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147959/233.wav", + "text": "接下來有請黃世杰委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147958/0.wav", + "text": "我請教" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147958/1.wav", + "text": "因為立法院的預算中心報告呼籲說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147958/2.wav", + "text": "金管會應要密切注意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147958/3.wav", + "text": "這些壽險業的流動性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147958/4.wav", + "text": "啊根據預算中心的報告中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147958/5.wav", + "text": "近5年來的統計" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147958/6.wav", + "text": "呈現出保費收入是大於保險給付" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147958/7.wav", + "text": "反觀今年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147958/8.wav", + "text": "截至6月底為止" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147958/9.wav", + "text": "保險給付" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147958/10.wav", + "text": "超越了保費收入的總額" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147958/11.wav", + "text": "1兆1,087億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147958/12.wav", + "text": "高達" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147958/13.wav", + "text": "由於5年來壽險業者的保險給付" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147958/14.wav", + "text": "占保費收入比例逐年增加" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147958/15.wav", + "text": "今年更出現" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147958/16.wav", + "text": "保險給付大於保費收入的情況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147958/17.wav", + "text": "請問你認為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147958/18.wav", + "text": "這是不是兩者出現死亡交叉的訊息" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147958/19.wav", + "text": "是不是這樣子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147958/20.wav", + "text": "報告委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147958/21.wav", + "text": "我很感謝您的指教" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147958/22.wav", + "text": "但是我想保險流動性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147958/23.wav", + "text": "不是只把保費收入減保費支出" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147958/24.wav", + "text": "得出來的就是它的gap" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147958/25.wav", + "text": "不是這樣子看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147958/26.wav", + "text": "因為保險公司" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147958/27.wav", + "text": "本身還有一些流動性的部位在帳上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147958/28.wav", + "text": "我特別跟委員報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147958/29.wav", + "text": "其實過去這一兩年來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147958/30.wav", + "text": "我們對於保險業本身流動性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147958/31.wav", + "text": "也非常的關心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147958/32.wav", + "text": "因為利率走高" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147958/33.wav", + "text": "的確有些保單" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147958/34.wav", + "text": "到期或是它解約的成本比較低的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147958/35.wav", + "text": "保戶是有可能會提前解約" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147958/36.wav", + "text": "或是說你新保費的收入是會比較慢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147958/37.wav", + "text": "但是流動性的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147958/38.wav", + "text": "不是一個大家會關心的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147958/39.wav", + "text": "我們都有密切地注意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147958/40.wav", + "text": "主委" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147958/41.wav", + "text": "保險業的經營成本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147958/42.wav", + "text": "是不是逐漸地提升" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147958/43.wav", + "text": "要是說不是死亡交叉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147958/44.wav", + "text": "那又為什麼會出現保險給付" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147958/45.wav", + "text": "占保費收入的比例逐年增加的統計結果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147958/46.wav", + "text": "就是我剛剛跟您報告的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147958/47.wav", + "text": "因為利率比較高" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147958/48.wav", + "text": "所以對於有些保" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147958/49.wav", + "text": "某些類型保單的意願會受到影響" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147958/50.wav", + "text": "但是我們也有給保險公司" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147958/51.wav", + "text": "比方說附賣回一些規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147958/52.wav", + "text": "所以保險公司應該有足夠的方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147958/53.wav", + "text": "去支應它的流動性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147958/54.wav", + "text": "主委" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147958/55.wav", + "text": "啊因為針對立法院預算中心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147958/56.wav", + "text": "對壽險業流動性的警訊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147958/57.wav", + "text": "金管會回應說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147958/58.wav", + "text": "除了保險收入衰退外" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147958/59.wav", + "text": "保險給付主要是解約的給付增加所導致" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147958/60.wav", + "text": "因為一方面是保費收入的衰退" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147958/61.wav", + "text": "另外一方面是解約導致給付增加" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147958/62.wav", + "text": "請問如果這樣的趨勢不變的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147958/63.wav", + "text": "你認為壽險業者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147958/64.wav", + "text": "有哪些方法能夠因應" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147958/65.wav", + "text": "其實我們去年也提高了宣告利率" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147958/66.wav", + "text": "讓國內的保單" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147958/67.wav", + "text": "對既有的這些保戶保費" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147958/68.wav", + "text": "會不會出現大幅度調漲的狀況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147958/69.wav", + "text": "應該不會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147958/70.wav", + "text": "因為保費的計提主要是看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147958/71.wav", + "text": "基本上是由死差利差費差" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147958/72.wav", + "text": "統一去做一個規劃" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147958/73.wav", + "text": "有沒有哪些措施能夠協助這些壽險業者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147958/74.wav", + "text": "渡過這樣的黑暗期" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147958/75.wav", + "text": "我們一直都在協助" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147958/76.wav", + "text": "就像剛剛跟您報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147958/77.wav", + "text": "的比方說我們今年年初" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147958/78.wav", + "text": "對於保險業附賣回的這些債券" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147958/79.wav", + "text": "給了一些寬還的措施" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147958/80.wav", + "text": "讓它必要的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147958/81.wav", + "text": "可以做一些流動性的支應" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147958/82.wav", + "text": "另外在宣告利率上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147958/83.wav", + "text": "也會在必要時做一些適時調整" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147958/84.wav", + "text": "是不是依舊只能靠他們自己" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147958/85.wav", + "text": "你認為呢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147958/86.wav", + "text": "我想主管機關跟業者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147958/87.wav", + "text": "險業總保費收入的組成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147958/88.wav", + "text": "不論是初年度的保費" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147958/89.wav", + "text": "或是續年度的保費" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147958/90.wav", + "text": "近五年來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147958/91.wav", + "text": "就算今年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147958/92.wav", + "text": "今年上半年的總保費收入" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147958/93.wav", + "text": "也是近三年來同期的新低" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147958/94.wav", + "text": "保發中心表示" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147958/95.wav", + "text": "上半年總保費收入衰退" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147958/96.wav", + "text": "是受到整個經濟環境面臨不確定性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147958/97.wav", + "text": "以及主管機關對於儲蓄型產品" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147958/98.wav", + "text": "的監管趨嚴等影響" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147958/99.wav", + "text": "壽險市場處於這樣的環境" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147958/100.wav", + "text": "要怎麼樣維持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147958/101.wav", + "text": "保費收得多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147958/102.wav", + "text": "是不是表示它獲利多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147958/103.wav", + "text": "其實這不見得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147958/104.wav", + "text": "為什麼現在儲蓄型保險" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147958/105.wav", + "text": "我們會稍微比較嚴謹" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147958/106.wav", + "text": "就是從2018年2019" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147958/107.wav", + "text": "年很多保費暴衝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147958/108.wav", + "text": "可是這些暴衝保費" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147958/109.wav", + "text": "反而未來收了保費之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147958/110.wav", + "text": "保險公司不見得能賺錢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147958/111.wav", + "text": "現在希望調整它的商品結構" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147958/112.wav", + "text": "2026年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147958/113.wav", + "text": "財報呈現劇烈變化" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147958/114.wav", + "text": "尤其是損益表的變化最大" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147958/115.wav", + "text": "請問你認為國內壽險業者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147958/116.wav", + "text": "準備好了嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147958/117.wav", + "text": "報告委員謝謝您" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147958/118.wav", + "text": "垂詢這個問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147958/119.wav", + "text": "基本上接軌的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147958/120.wav", + "text": "會考慮國內保險業發展的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147958/121.wav", + "text": "就在地化措施和過渡化措施" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147958/122.wav", + "text": "做適度的調整" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147958/123.wav", + "text": "來協助業者做比較平穩的因應" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147958/124.wav", + "text": "不會讓業者有過多太劇烈的變動" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147958/125.wav", + "text": "上個禮拜你用華爾街投資人的名言" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147958/126.wav", + "text": "來對股市信心喊話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147958/127.wav", + "text": "你說投資人的行為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147958/128.wav", + "text": "就好像是在攀爬憂慮之牆" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147958/129.wav", + "text": "尤其是牛市時" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147958/130.wav", + "text": "許多不確定性和負面因素" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147958/131.wav", + "text": "可是投資人對於整個市場發展趨勢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147958/132.wav", + "text": "還是有信心的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147958/133.wav", + "text": "以你上個禮拜的講法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147958/134.wav", + "text": "本席是不是可以解讀為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147958/135.wav", + "text": "應該是牛市" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147958/136.wav", + "text": "其實從寬鬆貨幣政策實施到現在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147958/137.wav", + "text": "大家覺得股市" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147958/138.wav", + "text": "可是卻一直往前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147958/139.wav", + "text": "所以基本上還是有信心的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147958/140.wav", + "text": "當然因為地緣政治的關係" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147958/141.wav", + "text": "及一些企業財報的影響" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147958/142.wav", + "text": "的確最近波動比��大" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147958/143.wav", + "text": "以目前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147958/144.wav", + "text": "整體國際環境" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147958/145.wav", + "text": "未完全恢復的狀態" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147958/146.wav", + "text": "而且在國內經濟也還沒有完全" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147958/147.wav", + "text": "舉攀爬憂慮之牆的名言" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147958/148.wav", + "text": "對散戶股民信心喊話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147958/149.wav", + "text": "我想主管機關的重點是認為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147958/150.wav", + "text": "我們有我們的基本面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147958/151.wav", + "text": "希望投資大眾" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147958/152.wav", + "text": "在考量外觀情況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147958/153.wav", + "text": "整個國際政經情況變化之下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147958/154.wav", + "text": "資本市場的基本面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147958/155.wav", + "text": "你認為這些散戶是不是會信賴政府" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147958/156.wav", + "text": "進而穩定股市" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147958/157.wav", + "text": "讓喊話變成反效果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147958/158.wav", + "text": "變得更疲乏" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147958/159.wav", + "text": "我們的態度一直是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147958/160.wav", + "text": "認為臺灣資本市場的產業結構" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147958/161.wav", + "text": "有它的競爭力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147958/162.wav", + "text": "至於個別投資人怎麼去解讀" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147958/163.wav", + "text": "我想我們就尊重" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147958/164.wav", + "text": "事實上所謂投資人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147958/165.wav", + "text": "應該是從個人企業乃至於國家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147958/166.wav", + "text": "都是具備" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147958/167.wav", + "text": "台股投資人的身分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147958/168.wav", + "text": "分是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147958/169.wav", + "text": "否能夠成功攀爬憂慮之牆" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147958/170.wav", + "text": "也就是具備" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147958/171.wav", + "text": "因為不確定的負面因素" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147958/172.wav", + "text": "所帶來的負面判斷力的條件" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147958/173.wav", + "text": "卻有很大的差別" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147958/174.wav", + "text": "過去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147958/175.wav", + "text": "憂慮之牆的出現" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147958/176.wav", + "text": "程度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147958/177.wav", + "text": "有像現在這麼多元嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147958/178.wav", + "text": "其實去年我們經歷的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147958/179.wav", + "text": "所以我想" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147958/180.wav", + "text": "台股是有韌性的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147958/181.wav", + "text": "我們會展現韌性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147958/182.wav", + "text": "穩健前行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147958/183.wav", + "text": "你認為未來的頻率" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147958/184.wav", + "text": "會比現在還" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147958/185.wav", + "text": "報告委員我很難預測未來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147958/186.wav", + "text": "其實未來不是任何人所能夠完全預知" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147958/187.wav", + "text": "能夠自我攀爬憂慮之牆" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147958/188.wav", + "text": "來克服" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147958/189.wav", + "text": "這牆所帶來的負面條件" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147958/190.wav", + "text": "當然是一件好事" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147958/191.wav", + "text": "請問主委你認為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147958/192.wav", + "text": "攀爬憂慮之牆" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147958/193.wav", + "text": "對大多數個體戶散戶" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147958/194.wav", + "text": "來說到底是容易的事" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147958/195.wav", + "text": "還是困難的事" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147958/196.wav", + "text": "我想還是八個字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147958/197.wav", + "text": "審慎選股" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147958/198.wav", + "text": "每個投資人自己對自己的投資" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147958/199.wav", + "text": "去做最終的判斷" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147958/200.wav", + "text": "謝謝委員指導" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147956/0.wav", + "text": "揭弊重大金融不法案件的檢舉獎金" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147956/1.wav", + "text": "對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147956/2.wav", + "text": "從40萬提高到400萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147956/3.wav", + "text": "增加了10倍" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147956/4.wav", + "text": "在2021年提高了之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147956/5.wav", + "text": "2023年的6月" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147956/6.wav", + "text": "就是今年的6月又要修正提高" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147956/7.wav", + "text": "上限從400萬提高到500萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147956/8.wav", + "text": "這短短一年多提高的原因在哪裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147956/9.wav", + "text": "部分原因也是因為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147956/10.wav", + "text": "立委對於我們的檢舉獎金覺得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147956/11.wav", + "text": "沒有誘因" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147956/12.wav", + "text": "所以希望我們能夠提高" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147956/13.wav", + "text": "當然我們也覺得在金融監理上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147956/14.wav", + "text": "主管機關的監理是一回事" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147956/15.wav", + "text": "社會的監督也很重要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147956/16.wav", + "text": "如果有一些吹哨的行為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147956/17.wav", + "text": "除了在法律上保護他之外" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147956/18.wav", + "text": "也應該給他適當的獎酬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147956/19.wav", + "text": "對於揭弊這件事情有幫助嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147956/20.wav", + "text": "就我的瞭解有有的單位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147956/21.wav", + "text": "提高了之後才增加檢舉的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147956/22.wav", + "text": "應該是有幫助" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147956/23.wav", + "text": "可能還沒有給到那麼高" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147956/24.wav", + "text": "啦就是一般的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147956/25.wav", + "text": "這個天花板提高了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147956/26.wav", + "text": "啦檢舉的人變多了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147956/27.wav", + "text": "但是檢舉之後獲得的獎金還是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147956/28.wav", + "text": "要看他檢舉的事實" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147956/29.wav", + "text": "內容到底有沒有符合比較高的獎金水位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147956/30.wav", + "text": "好過去揭弊主要是在哪一個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147956/31.wav", + "text": "在銀行在保險還是在證券期貨呢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147956/32.wav", + "text": "我的瞭解好像是證券比較多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147956/33.wav", + "text": "這類的東西" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147956/34.wav", + "text": "除了一般的檢舉之外" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147956/35.wav", + "text": "其實前一陣子網路上看了很多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147956/36.wav", + "text": "現在比較少了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147956/37.wav", + "text": "然後叫大家來投資" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147956/38.wav", + "text": "現在有比較少的原因是什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147956/39.wav", + "text": "一方面可能因為打詐所以對他們有一些威嚇的作用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147956/40.wav", + "text": "當然包括我們的周邊和證期局對於這部分非法的投顧" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147956/41.wav", + "text": "平常也都有在觀察" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147956/42.wav", + "text": "是不是因為Meta公司現在也採取比較合作的態度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147956/43.wav", + "text": "我覺得就是我剛才跟您報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147956/44.wav", + "text": "的因為投信投顧法第7條之1修正之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147956/45.wav", + "text": "是有這個力量" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147956/46.wav", + "text": "所以跨國公司也比較願意跟臺灣的政府配合了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147956/47.wav", + "text": "因為有法律依據了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147956/48.wav", + "text": "是好謝謝你" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147956/49.wav", + "text": "再來就是要跟你請教資安網路攻擊的狀況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147956/50.wav", + "text": "其實這個每一年每一年都一直在增加" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147956/51.wav", + "text": "啊那麼我們的防護能力現在怎麼樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147956/52.wav", + "text": "其實過去這幾年來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147956/53.wav", + "text": "尤其金融機構有時候會接到DDoS的那種攻擊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147956/54.wav", + "text": "啦重點是我們從那個時候開始就希望金融機構要建立一套流量清洗的機制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147956/55.wav", + "text": "因為DDoS等於是在門前那邊打擾你" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147956/56.wav", + "text": "進入不了你的官網去查詢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147956/57.wav", + "text": "通常你很難防範別人來攻擊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147956/58.wav", + "text": "但是你必須做好它攻擊的時候你有抵禦的能力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147956/59.wav", + "text": "所以大概每個金融機構都要求去買那個流量清洗" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147956/60.wav", + "text": "跟幾個電信廠商買" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147956/61.wav", + "text": "看它買的量大" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147956/62.wav", + "text": "所以多多少少會影響" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147956/63.wav", + "text": "可是影響的時間就看你準備得充足或不充足" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147956/64.wav", + "text": "就是它一直來跟你占空間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147956/65.wav", + "text": "讓本來要跟你查詢的人進不來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147956/66.wav", + "text": "那有沒有其他態樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147956/67.wav", + "text": "以及今年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147956/68.wav", + "text": "到現在為止" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147956/69.wav", + "text": "你有沒有發現什麼重大的個案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147956/70.wav", + "text": "有產生損失的狀況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147956/71.wav", + "text": "目前是沒有啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147956/72.wav", + "text": "以前是因為譬如說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147956/73.wav", + "text": "券商委託第三方去做一些資訊處理的工作" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147956/74.wav", + "text": "可能中間有一些去年前年是有些類似這樣的個案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147956/75.wav", + "text": "或者更去年譬如說現在大家很關心的是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147956/76.wav", + "text": "委外廠商本身的資安做得好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147956/77.wav", + "text": "在那一個公司的網站被對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147956/78.wav", + "text": "岸滲入類似這種問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147956/79.wav", + "text": "今年都沒有出現這樣子的狀況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147956/80.wav", + "text": "目前看起來還有有的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147956/81.wav", + "text": "也不是很嚴重的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147956/82.wav", + "text": "好因為今年3月新的東西" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147956/83.wav", + "text": "─ChatGPT出來了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147956/84.wav", + "text": "這種生成式的AI" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147956/85.wav", + "text": "啦關於這一部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147956/86.wav", + "text": "ChatGPT生成式的AI" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147956/87.wav", + "text": "使用了之後到現在也半年多了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147956/88.wav", + "text": "有沒有發現有什麼樣的狀況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147956/89.wav", + "text": "報告委員我們其實當年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147956/90.wav", + "text": "出來之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147956/91.wav", + "text": "當時也在財委會開議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147956/92.wav", + "text": "我們有要求金融" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147956/93.wav", + "text": "其實大部分業者都還沒有用到那樣子的一個程度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147956/94.wav", + "text": "我們隨後也有訂了AI原則" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147956/95.wav", + "text": "跨部會小組去審查的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147956/96.wav", + "text": "我們這個原則大概已經訂了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147956/97.wav", + "text": "將來會根據這個原則" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147956/98.wav", + "text": "在年底之前訂定細則" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147956/99.wav", + "text": "去處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147956/100.wav", + "text": "其實各國都在監理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147956/101.wav", + "text": "啦對這種生成式AI" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147956/102.wav", + "text": "要非常非常地慎重" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147956/103.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147956/104.wav", + "text": "最後我也是要跟你請教" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147956/105.wav", + "text": "上次我在院會總質詢的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147956/106.wav", + "text": "影子銀行這些狀況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147956/107.wav", + "text": "現在有沒有比較清楚的界定跟分工" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147956/108.wav", + "text": "在我們部會主管裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147956/109.wav", + "text": "我們金管會這部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147956/110.wav", + "text": "包括消金公司" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147956/111.wav", + "text": "租賃公司" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147956/112.wav", + "text": "經濟部的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147956/113.wav", + "text": "我們會再跟它聯繫看看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147956/114.wav", + "text": "當然租賃公會部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147956/115.wav", + "text": "我們也會主動去瞭解一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147956/116.wav", + "text": "現在事實上有很多是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147956/117.wav", + "text": "假借商品買賣的形式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147956/118.wav", + "text": "但是其實是在行借貸之實" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147956/119.wav", + "text": "啦你有聽過這樣子的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147956/120.wav", + "text": "嗎譬如說它是一個附買回" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147956/121.wav", + "text": "但是等於變相的分期付款" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147956/122.wav", + "text": "等於是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147956/123.wav", + "text": "BNPL這種方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147956/124.wav", + "text": "它其實是一個變形" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147956/125.wav", + "text": "要規避金融的管理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147956/126.wav", + "text": "是不是這樣的意義" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147956/127.wav", + "text": "借貸本來就是民法上的行為所以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147956/128.wav", + "text": "不見得一定是要受制於金融監理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147956/129.wav", + "text": "啦但是重點是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147956/130.wav", + "text": "消費者必須很清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147956/131.wav", + "text": "它的條件是什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147956/132.wav", + "text": "是不是很明確很透明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147956/133.wav", + "text": "這部分我們透過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147956/134.wav", + "text": "自己管的金融機構的BNPL" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147956/135.wav", + "text": "或是租賃公會辦的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147956/136.wav", + "text": "都有把這些原則" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147956/137.wav", + "text": "讓租賃公會去參考" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147956/138.wav", + "text": "等於是地下的借貸" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147956/139.wav", + "text": "因為你們所管的是特許的金融機構" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147956/140.wav", + "text": "那它這個規模當然不是那麼大" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147956/141.wav", + "text": "但它在做的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147956/142.wav", + "text": "有可能會有很多脫法的行為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147956/143.wav", + "text": "不能夠超過1516%" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147956/144.wav", + "text": "嘛那它可能變相的是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147956/145.wav", + "text": "分期償還的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147956/146.wav", + "text": "利率是接近" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147956/147.wav", + "text": "然後它再給你加一些手續費" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147956/148.wav", + "text": "加上一些什麼雜七雜八的費用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147956/149.wav", + "text": "加一加其實就是超過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147956/150.wav", + "text": "了這個當然就是一個悲哀" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147956/151.wav", + "text": "啦就是財務困難的人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147956/152.wav", + "text": "他要去取得融資" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147956/153.wav", + "text": "本來就困難" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147956/154.wav", + "text": "那困難之後又要遇到這樣子的剝削" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147956/155.wav", + "text": "經濟部其實在民國94年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147956/156.wav", + "text": "有訂了一個相關這種" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147956/157.wav", + "text": "融資公司租賃公司" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147956/158.wav", + "text": "契約跟定價的規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147956/159.wav", + "text": "當然這個我不能代表經濟部講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147956/160.wav", + "text": "但是這個部分不是沒有規範" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147956/161.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147956/162.wav", + "text": "關於金管會跟4個局的預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147956/163.wav", + "text": "我看你們主要的預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147956/164.wav", + "text": "裡歲出的部分幾乎都是人事經費" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147956/165.wav", + "text": "是我們大部分都是人事" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147956/166.wav", + "text": "經費然後就是因為我們在板橋大樓" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147956/167.wav", + "text": "有很多共用管理維修的經費" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147956/168.wav", + "text": "是其實也沒什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147956/169.wav", + "text": "主要就是人員的經費" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147956/170.wav", + "text": "最坦白就是領薪水" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147956/171.wav", + "text": "就占掉絕大多數了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147956/172.wav", + "text": "報告委員其實多年來都是這樣子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147956/173.wav", + "text": "我知道多年來都是這樣子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147956/174.wav", + "text": "啊所以我是說你們的預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147956/175.wav", + "text": "如果要做一個比較大怎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147956/176.wav", + "text": "怎麼樣子計畫的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147956/177.wav", + "text": "在我的看法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147956/178.wav", + "text": "啦將來當然不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147956/179.wav", + "text": "因為我們立法委員不能做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147956/180.wav", + "text": "增加預算的提案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147956/181.wav", + "text": "只是跟你建議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147956/182.wav", + "text": "如果真的有需要的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147956/183.wav", + "text": "我們也是願意支持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147956/184.wav", + "text": "是謝謝委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147956/185.wav", + "text": "謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147955/0.wav", + "text": "我們邀請潘部長還有臺大陳校長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147955/1.wav", + "text": "有請潘部長陳校長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147955/2.wav", + "text": "委員好部長校長就" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147955/3.wav", + "text": "就新竹地區" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147955/4.wav", + "text": "或是其他縣市" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147955/5.wav", + "text": "很多人都不瞭解新竹的狀況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147955/6.wav", + "text": "常常會瞠目結舌" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147955/7.wav", + "text": "我們那邊缺學校" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147955/8.wav", + "text": "不是大學" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147955/9.wav", + "text": "是缺小學缺國中缺高中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147955/10.wav", + "text": "完全沒有少子化的困難" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147955/11.wav", + "text": "難剛剛他提到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147955/12.wav", + "text": "106年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147955/13.wav", + "text": "超額的學生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147955/14.wav", + "text": "竟然多達1007百多人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147955/15.wav", + "text": "高中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147955/16.wav", + "text": "所以這個這個狀況真的很不一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147955/17.wav", + "text": "在全臺灣整體上是少子化" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147955/18.wav", + "text": "就是新竹縣新竹市沒有這個問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147955/19.wav", + "text": "主要是就業機會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147955/20.wav", + "text": "產業發達就業機會多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147955/21.wav", + "text": "年輕人就業" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147955/22.wav", + "text": "然後薪資水準也高" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147955/23.wav", + "text": "敢生能養" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147955/24.wav", + "text": "啦現在臺灣少子化這麼嚴重" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147955/25.wav", + "text": "所以在那個地區" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147955/26.wav", + "text": "有這種成效" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147955/27.wav", + "text": "我們要鼓勵" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147955/28.wav", + "text": "用各種政策" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147955/29.wav", + "text": "各種優惠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147955/30.wav", + "text": "因為在其他地方你去鼓勵" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147955/31.wav", + "text": "不一定有用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147955/32.wav", + "text": "喔最近大家都在問年輕人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147955/33.wav", + "text": "要生小孩" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147955/34.wav", + "text": "那補助到底要多少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147955/35.wav", + "text": "你才覺得有效" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147955/36.wav", + "text": "因為他生養一個小孩" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147955/37.wav", + "text": "確實壓力沉重" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147955/38.wav", + "text": "但是在新竹沒有這個問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147955/39.wav", + "text": "我們那邊的補助不是最優惠的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147955/40.wav", + "text": "但是敢生能養" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147955/41.wav", + "text": "竟然沒辦法有足夠的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147955/42.wav", + "text": "要想辦法解決問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147955/43.wav", + "text": "我每次質詢都會提這個問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147955/44.wav", + "text": "\n由於時間的關係" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147955/45.wav", + "text": "106年邱顯智委員剛剛也提過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147955/46.wav", + "text": "其實跟我們開過很多次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147955/47.wav", + "text": "他本身也是新竹人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147955/48.wav", + "text": "所以他對新竹地區瞭解" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147955/49.wav", + "text": "但是到現在都沒有解決方案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147955/50.wav", + "text": "啦\n而我們要求臺大陳校長在這裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147955/51.wav", + "text": "你們校地閒置二十年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147955/52.wav", + "text": "不然你也撥出來設高中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147955/53.wav", + "text": "你們以前承諾要設4個學院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147955/54.wav", + "text": "在臺大竹北校區" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147955/55.wav", + "text": "到現在二十年過去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147955/56.wav", + "text": "啦連個學院都沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147955/57.wav", + "text": "要不要來設高中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147955/58.wav", + "text": "也說教育部法令面不行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147955/59.wav", + "text": "所以地閒置著長草" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147955/60.wav", + "text": "高中蓋不出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147955/61.wav", + "text": "這是什麼政府" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147955/62.wav", + "text": "啊都是在教育部體系" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147955/63.wav", + "text": "你部長你要不要負起責任" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147955/64.wav", + "text": "突破法令的限制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147955/65.wav", + "text": "讓閒置的土地" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147955/66.wav", + "text": "可以設高中滿足地方��需求" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147955/67.wav", + "text": "那也是在辦教育" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147955/68.wav", + "text": "你事後把那個方案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147955/69.wav", + "text": "因應106年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147955/70.wav", + "text": "到底你有什麼方案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147955/71.wav", + "text": "解決這些缺額" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147955/72.wav", + "text": "就沒有辦法入學的這個問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147955/73.wav", + "text": "用書面報告給我" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147955/74.wav", + "text": "最後30秒鐘請陳部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147955/75.wav", + "text": "您每次的反映都有效" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147955/76.wav", + "text": "你當時反映竹北地區" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147955/77.wav", + "text": "委員你知道那個新興計畫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147955/78.wav", + "text": "光你們竹北" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147955/79.wav", + "text": "就拿了17億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147955/80.wav", + "text": "連六家國中都有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147955/81.wav", + "text": "過幾年之後就變高中了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147955/82.wav", + "text": "高中就沒辦法滿足了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147955/83.wav", + "text": "現在要來解決的是高中的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147955/84.wav", + "text": "所以邱委員跟您所關心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147955/85.wav", + "text": "的問題我也請國教署要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147955/86.wav", + "text": "突破法令限制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147955/87.wav", + "text": "陳校長你新上任" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147955/88.wav", + "text": "我只是要報告你的努力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147955/89.wav", + "text": "書面資料提供給我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147955/90.wav", + "text": "我們要解決方案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147955/91.wav", + "text": "\n陳校長我也看到你的誠意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147955/92.wav", + "text": "有各種計畫利用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147955/93.wav", + "text": "你還提出一個建議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147955/94.wav", + "text": "生醫園區" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147955/95.wav", + "text": "這個叫做竹科" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147955/96.wav", + "text": "的生醫園區" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147955/97.wav", + "text": "臺大在裡面有設" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147955/98.wav", + "text": "臺大分院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147955/99.wav", + "text": "也許在那邊可以設立所謂" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147955/100.wav", + "text": "生醫實驗中學" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147955/101.wav", + "text": "到時候說法令限制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147955/102.wav", + "text": "你們兩個要講好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147955/103.wav", + "text": "你提出方案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147955/104.wav", + "text": "請你詳細的把你這個idea" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147955/105.wav", + "text": "用地要在哪裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147955/106.wav", + "text": "法令限制是什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147955/107.wav", + "text": "如何突破" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147955/108.wav", + "text": "需要修法就趕快送" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147955/109.wav", + "text": "因為之前臺大一直講一個問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147955/110.wav", + "text": "他說他們沒有教育學院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147955/111.wav", + "text": "所以他沒有辦法設" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147955/112.wav", + "text": "臺大" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147955/113.wav", + "text": "這個就是法令限制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147955/114.wav", + "text": "要來協助解決" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147955/115.wav", + "text": "時間的關係現在召委一直看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147955/116.wav", + "text": "生醫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147955/117.wav", + "text": "實驗中學" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147955/118.wav", + "text": "你的計畫方向" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147955/119.wav", + "text": "是怎麼樣可能碰到的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147955/120.wav", + "text": "問題會是哪一些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147955/121.wav", + "text": "這樣我們才知道如何解決這些問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147955/122.wav", + "text": "是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147955/123.wav", + "text": "可不可以提供書面資料給我" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147955/124.wav", + "text": "會後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147955/125.wav", + "text": "因為不想占用其他委員的時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147955/126.wav", + "text": "請會後以書面回答剛剛本席所提的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147955/127.wav", + "text": "以及教育委員會的其他委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147955/128.wav", + "text": "謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147954/0.wav", + "text": "有請部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147954/1.wav", + "text": "部長好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147954/2.wav", + "text": "層出不窮" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147954/3.wav", + "text": "當然對幼兒園有比較嚴密的規範" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147954/4.wav", + "text": "比較嚴格的規範" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147954/5.wav", + "text": "他沒辦法保護自己" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147954/6.wav", + "text": "所以才需要國家透過法律" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147954/7.wav", + "text": "透過相關制度去保護他" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147954/8.wav", + "text": "在今年七月" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147954/9.wav", + "text": "就曾經爆發新竹市的某一個幼兒園" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147954/10.wav", + "text": "就是性侵害" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147954/11.wav", + "text": "他的小孩事實上就是送到幼兒園" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147954/12.wav", + "text": "事實上是掛羊頭賣狗肉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147954/13.wav", + "text": "也就是說表面上是幼兒園" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147954/14.wav", + "text": "實際上是用補習班的方式去經營" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147954/15.wav", + "text": "變成用兩面手法來矇騙家長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147954/16.wav", + "text": "所以搞到最後才發現" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147954/17.wav", + "text": "這個違法的行為人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147954/18.wav", + "text": "事實上根本也不是教保員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147954/19.wav", + "text": "也不具幼兒園教師的資格" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147954/20.wav", + "text": "而只是一個工讀生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147954/21.wav", + "text": "事實上現在在幼兒園" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147954/22.wav", + "text": "已經是一個常見的違規方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147954/23.wav", + "text": "也就是說他設立的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147954/24.wav", + "text": "但是實際上家長以為是進入到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147954/25.wav", + "text": "符合高度嚴密規範的幼兒園" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147954/26.wav", + "text": "實際上僅僅是補習班" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147954/27.wav", + "text": "能夠去修法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147954/28.wav", + "text": "起來我們的版本事實上非常簡單" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147954/29.wav", + "text": "部長可以參考一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147954/30.wav", + "text": "我們事實上已經提出" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147954/31.wav", + "text": "也就是說這個事情監察院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147954/32.wav", + "text": "在2022年的時候也提過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147954/33.wav", + "text": "學生在數個機構之間遊走" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147954/34.wav", + "text": "一下幼兒園一下補習班" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147954/35.wav", + "text": "然後業者就是在規避這些法令" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147954/36.wav", + "text": "讓家長無所適從" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147954/37.wav", + "text": "然後地方主管機關也難以稽查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147954/38.wav", + "text": "也表示說這樣的查核是有困難的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147954/39.wav", + "text": "所以我們的版本非常簡單" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147954/40.wav", + "text": "第一個就是修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147954/41.wav", + "text": "訂補習班招收6歲以下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147954/42.wav", + "text": "幼兒進行全日拖照顧的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147954/43.wav", + "text": "他在師資在師生比在環境" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147954/44.wav", + "text": "在相關的設施設備跟評鑑機制項目等等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147954/45.wav", + "text": "都比照幼教法的相關規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147954/46.wav", + "text": "然後也明定說他應該要報" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147954/47.wav", + "text": "直轄縣市政府機關核准" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147954/48.wav", + "text": "並且加註於立案證書上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147954/49.wav", + "text": "以供家長辨別" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147954/50.wav", + "text": "支不支持這樣主張的修法跟這樣的方向" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147954/51.wav", + "text": "我跟委員報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147954/52.wav", + "text": "當然從執行面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147954/53.wav", + "text": "確實我們對幼兒園這部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147954/54.wav", + "text": "就如現在幼教雙條例的修訂" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147954/55.wav", + "text": "確實是用一個更保護小小孩的條例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147954/56.wav", + "text": "包含對教保人員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147954/57.wav", + "text": "那補習班的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147954/58.wav", + "text": "因為過往招收的對象" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147954/59.wav", + "text": "服務的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147954/60.wav", + "text": "它有它的空間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147954/61.wav", + "text": "不像幼兒園這樣的規範" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147954/62.wav", + "text": "對於那個個案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147954/63.wav", + "text": "新竹市政府當然就有責" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147954/64.wav", + "text": "部長現在的問題是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147954/65.wav", + "text": "就會以幼兒園跟補習班同名" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147954/66.wav", + "text": "這樣的方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147954/67.wav", + "text": "也在招收6歲以下的幼童" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147954/68.wav", + "text": "所以我們才會說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147954/69.wav", + "text": "如果這個補習班在招收" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147954/70.wav", + "text": "也就是說不要讓他有這樣的漏洞" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147954/71.wav", + "text": "部長你瞭解" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147954/72.wav", + "text": "委員提的這個方向跟用意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147954/73.wav", + "text": "我本身是支持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147954/74.wav", + "text": "原來的目的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147954/75.wav", + "text": "就不是要招收這些小小孩" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147954/76.wav", + "text": "所以在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147954/77.wav", + "text": "所以當他這樣做的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147954/78.wav", + "text": "我們希望他也受到嚴格的規範" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147954/79.wav", + "text": "那教育部是不是可以在兩週內" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147954/80.wav", + "text": "的修法期程跟規劃" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147954/81.wav", + "text": "委員這個法規可能要讓我們評估一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147954/82.wav", + "text": "因為涉及的面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147954/83.wav", + "text": "沒關係那你可以提出一個委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147954/84.wav", + "text": "委員可能有一個前提" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147954/85.wav", + "text": "啦教育部的政策並不支持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147954/86.wav", + "text": "我先跟委員報告一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147954/87.wav", + "text": "教育部目前的政策並不支持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147954/88.wav", + "text": "小小孩直接進到補習班" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147954/89.wav", + "text": "這是一個大前提" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147954/90.wav", + "text": "修法後把它轉成合法化" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147954/91.wav", + "text": "的這個問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147954/92.wav", + "text": "不是說修法合法化" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147954/93.wav", + "text": "而是把這個漏洞補起來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147954/94.wav", + "text": "你可能沒有清楚了解" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147954/95.wav", + "text": "這個讓我們在政策上面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147954/96.wav", + "text": "做一個評估好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147954/97.wav", + "text": "那下一個就是說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147954/98.wav", + "text": "我們在新竹有召開過公聽會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147954/99.wav", + "text": "部裡面的署長等等也有來參加" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147954/100.wav", + "text": "116年龍年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147954/101.wav", + "text": "龍年就快到了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147954/102.wav", + "text": "首批的高中生入學" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147954/103.wav", + "text": "增班跟增加師資的訴求" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147954/104.wav", + "text": "國教署的書面答復也認為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147954/105.wav", + "text": "未來還需要因應116年龍年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147954/106.wav", + "text": "首批進入高中就學的學生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147954/107.wav", + "text": "去做滾動式的檢討" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147954/108.wav", + "text": "並且研議增班" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147954/109.wav", + "text": "近期會在新竹市召開公聽會嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147954/110.wav", + "text": "我跟委員報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147954/111.wav", + "text": "委員所反映的確實是這個區域裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147954/112.wav", + "text": "我們需要去面對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147954/113.wav", + "text": "的所以在116學年度確實將" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147954/114.wav", + "text": "會增加將近10" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147954/115.wav", + "text": "增班的學生將近300人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147954/116.wav", + "text": "我看你們的報告是將近300人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147954/117.wav", + "text": "大概1007" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147954/118.wav", + "text": "委員這部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147954/119.wav", + "text": "因為會跨縣市我想" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147954/120.wav", + "text": "我們會請新竹縣市" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147954/121.wav", + "text": "還有應該是苗栗" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147954/122.wav", + "text": "一起來做個討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147954/123.wav", + "text": "因為國教署也跟我親自討論過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147954/124.wav", + "text": "已經有一個初步的規劃" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147954/125.wav", + "text": "也希望跟縣市" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147954/126.wav", + "text": "一起從幾個不同類型的學校" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147954/127.wav", + "text": "來滿足這個需求" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147954/128.wav", + "text": "新竹縣就已經668人了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147954/129.wav", + "text": "新竹市將近1,140人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147954/130.wav", + "text": "苗栗縣是945人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147954/131.wav", + "text": "竹竹苗增班的學生就將近300人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147954/132.wav", + "text": "跟林次長去考察建功高中的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147954/133.wav", + "text": "我們就會發現" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147954/134.wav", + "text": "這個完全中學" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147954/135.wav", + "text": "等於是它一組行政人員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147954/136.wav", + "text": "要負擔這個高中跟國中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147954/137.wav", + "text": "的這麼多人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147954/138.wav", + "text": "一組行政人力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147954/139.wav", + "text": "國中一年級就有14至15班" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147954/140.wav", + "text": "高中一年級就有8班" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147954/141.wav", + "text": "整個學校66" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147954/142.wav", + "text": "未來如果龍年增班開班之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147954/143.wav", + "text": "的人數更是難以應付" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147954/144.wav", + "text": "所以我們希望" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147954/145.wav", + "text": "教育部於兩週內提出" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147954/146.wav", + "text": "因應龍年增班後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147954/147.wav", + "text": "主席再給我1分鐘的時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147954/148.wav", + "text": "我問一個問題\n" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147954/149.wav", + "text": "部長之前提到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147954/150.wav", + "text": "滑輪溜冰協會的兩個教練" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147954/151.wav", + "text": "林詠翔教練" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147954/152.wav", + "text": "違反性侵害防治法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147954/153.wav", + "text": "嘛而黃明嵩教練" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147954/154.wav", + "text": "因為家暴跟賭博事件" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147954/155.wav", + "text": "被停止教練的權利" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147954/156.wav", + "text": "已經被停權了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147954/157.wav", + "text": "已經說不能夠再參加" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147954/158.wav", + "text": "亞運什麼等等之類的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147954/159.wav", + "text": "拿到識別證進入比賽場地" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147954/160.wav", + "text": "然後調查報告明顯指出" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147954/161.wav", + "text": "這是不應該出現的場合" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147954/162.wav", + "text": "甚至還可以在場邊指導" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147954/163.wav", + "text": "還是體育署的官員也在場" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147954/164.wav", + "text": "其實我覺得很難過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147954/165.wav", + "text": "難過林詠翔教練的這個案件" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147954/166.wav", + "text": "屬實自己也承認" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147954/167.wav", + "text": "那個被害人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147954/168.wav", + "text": "當時12歲" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147954/169.wav", + "text": "部長做過國小老師" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147954/170.wav", + "text": "我自己有2個女兒" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147954/171.wav", + "text": "一個國小五年級" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147954/172.wav", + "text": "一個國中一年級" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147954/173.wav", + "text": "做性侵害犯罪防治法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147954/174.wav", + "text": "所定義的這些性侵害行為之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147954/175.wav", + "text": "人家過了二十年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147954/176.wav", + "text": "才長出勇氣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147954/177.wav", + "text": "講出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147954/178.wav", + "text": "好不容易講出來之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147954/179.wav", + "text": "你就將他停權了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147954/180.wav", + "text": "嘛你知道嗎部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147954/181.wav", + "text": "每次看到這個受害人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147954/182.wav", + "text": "寄給我的陳情資料的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147954/183.wav", + "text": "我真的非常難過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147954/184.wav", + "text": "那一些都是看不過去的人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147954/185.wav", + "text": "拍到林詠翔教練" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147954/186.wav", + "text": "黃明嵩教練" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147954/187.wav", + "text": "就是在現場" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147954/188.wav", + "text": "這對於被害人是情何以堪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147954/189.wav", + "text": "我跟體育署講了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147954/190.wav", + "text": "部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147954/191.wav", + "text": "我覺得你應該要正視這個事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147954/192.wav", + "text": "想一想" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147954/193.wav", + "text": "如果這是我們的女兒" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147954/194.wav", + "text": "想一想" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147954/195.wav", + "text": "這樣的作法就是欺負人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147954/196.wav", + "text": "這樣是不對的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147954/197.wav", + "text": "被停權了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147954/198.wav", + "text": "還可以這樣子搞" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147954/199.wav", + "text": "這是不對的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147954/200.wav", + "text": "也請教育部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147954/201.wav", + "text": "給予這個被害人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147954/202.wav", + "text": "一個最起碼的公道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147954/203.wav", + "text": "我們是不是請教育部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147954/204.wav", + "text": "體育署" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147954/205.wav", + "text": "做詳細的報告好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147954/206.wav", + "text": "不是你應該要去調查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147954/207.wav", + "text": "給這個受害人一個完整的詳" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147954/208.wav", + "text": "包含這次在中國" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147954/209.wav", + "text": "因為他們各個單向協會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147954/210.wav", + "text": "的聯繫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147954/211.wav", + "text": "這部分本來第一時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147954/212.wav", + "text": "我就跟署長說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147954/213.wav", + "text": "這是完全沒辦法接受的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147954/214.wav", + "text": "是所以後續當然" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147954/215.wav", + "text": "中國的這個協會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147954/216.wav", + "text": "邀請他這跟我們的法律無關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147954/217.wav", + "text": "但是如果涉及" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147954/218.wav", + "text": "現在他去杭州亞運" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147954/219.wav", + "text": "然後這個受害人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147954/220.wav", + "text": "也提供給教育部跟體育署" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147954/221.wav", + "text": "已經都認為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147954/222.wav", + "text": "這樣是不對的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147954/223.wav", + "text": "而現在是不是又在亞錦賽" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147954/224.wav", + "text": "署長知道嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147954/225.wav", + "text": "報告委員基本上他已經被我們撤銷" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147954/226.wav", + "text": "他的教練證了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147954/227.wav", + "text": "這次也不是在中國這部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147954/228.wav", + "text": "所以跟中國的協會比較好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147954/229.wav", + "text": "當時我們也是蠻錯愕的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147954/230.wav", + "text": "加上他的陳年舊案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147954/231.wav", + "text": "我們面臨的困難是他現在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147954/232.wav", + "text": "的選手又非常不避諱" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147954/233.wav", + "text": "地在得獎之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147954/234.wav", + "text": "找他拍照" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147954/235.wav", + "text": "是這樣嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147954/236.wav", + "text": "如果是這樣的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147954/237.wav", + "text": "那是不是這些選手" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147954/238.wav", + "text": "可能本來他就是一個國家隊級的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147954/239.wav", + "text": "教練等等之類的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147954/240.wav", + "text": "而有這樣非常委屈的狀況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147954/241.wav", + "text": "那是不是將來任何一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147954/242.wav", + "text": "國際賽事你都已經把他撤銷了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147954/243.wav", + "text": "而他還是可以到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147954/244.wav", + "text": "下一個又不知道是什麼賽事" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147954/245.wav", + "text": "當作塑膠啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147954/246.wav", + "text": "這樣子到底這些被害人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147954/247.wav", + "text": "你讓這些被害人情何以堪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147954/248.wav", + "text": "你根本就沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147954/249.wav", + "text": "地給他們一個相應的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147954/250.wav", + "text": "邱委員不好意思啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147954/251.wav", + "text": "如果在法律上還能制裁" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147954/252.wav", + "text": "委員我們一起討論一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147954/253.wav", + "text": "我對這個事情是永遠不會放過的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147954/254.wav", + "text": "對啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147954/255.wav", + "text": "報告一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147954/256.wav", + "text": "邱委員抱歉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147954/257.wav", + "text": "我們現在請林為洲委員質詢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147953/0.wav", + "text": "謝謝主席請許部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147953/1.wav", + "text": "有請" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147953/2.wav", + "text": "陳委員好部長好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147953/3.wav", + "text": "要跟職安衛專職人員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147953/4.wav", + "text": "現在就是包括保安監督人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147953/5.wav", + "text": "要納進來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147953/6.wav", + "text": "請問什麼時候可以完成勾稽" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147953/7.wav", + "text": "跟防火管理人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147953/8.wav", + "text": "大概什麼時候可以完成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147953/9.wav", + "text": "年底前好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147953/10.wav", + "text": "火災意外事故因而去世" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147953/11.wav", + "text": "你覺得是不是很冤枉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147953/12.wav", + "text": "當然" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147953/13.wav", + "text": "很冤枉嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147953/14.wav", + "text": "其實可以防範可以避免" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147953/15.wav", + "text": "很重要的就是要落實申報" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147953/16.wav", + "text": "這些危險的化學藥品" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147953/17.wav", + "text": "或是有囤積堆置的情形" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147953/18.wav", + "text": "部長同不同意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147953/19.wav", + "text": "同意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147953/20.wav", + "text": "好我上個禮拜有召開公聽會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147953/21.wav", + "text": "你們依職安法去要求業者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147953/22.wav", + "text": "一些化學物品" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147953/23.wav", + "text": "對但是現在應該是全面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147953/24.wav", + "text": "申報應該要申報的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147953/25.wav", + "text": "不是只有危險化學藥品" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147953/26.wav", + "text": "該申報的化學藥品" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147953/27.wav", + "text": "然後跟經濟部和環境部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147953/28.wav", + "text": "該申報的大大小小工廠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147953/29.wav", + "text": "都能夠在雲端" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147953/30.wav", + "text": "有一個平台能夠清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147953/31.wav", + "text": "委員這個我同意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147953/32.wav", + "text": "就是說每個部會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147953/33.wav", + "text": "可能根據各自不同的權責" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147953/34.wav", + "text": "就是整合" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147953/35.wav", + "text": "你不反對嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147953/36.wav", + "text": "但是勞動部可以扮演一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147953/37.wav", + "text": "重要的稽查的角色嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147953/38.wav", + "text": "可以嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147953/39.wav", + "text": "每個部會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147953/40.wav", + "text": "我知道你們就依職安法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147953/41.wav", + "text": "來落實" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147953/42.wav", + "text": "該編列預算就是委辦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147953/43.wav", + "text": "北中南就是重點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147953/44.wav", + "text": "一年查個兩三次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147953/45.wav", + "text": "跟實地去抽查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147953/46.wav", + "text": "如果落實的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147953/47.wav", + "text": "大大小小工廠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147953/48.wav", + "text": "應該就不會亂堆置這些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147953/49.wav", + "text": "會導致意外的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147953/50.wav", + "text": "可以嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147953/51.wav", + "text": "請問大概多久能夠讓本席" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147953/52.wav", + "text": "瞭解你們是可以完成的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147953/53.wav", + "text": "一個月嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147953/54.wav", + "text": "署長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147953/55.wav", + "text": "謝謝委員提醒" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147953/56.wav", + "text": "張子敬張政委" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147953/57.wav", + "text": "召集化學雲精進的機制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147953/58.wav", + "text": "各部會po出資料到化學雲" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147953/59.wav", + "text": "各部會再" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147953/60.wav", + "text": "所以包括我們職安署" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147953/61.wav", + "text": "也可以用到消防署和" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147953/62.wav", + "text": "和工廠輔導法的資料" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147953/63.wav", + "text": "變成我們稽核的機制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147953/64.wav", + "text": "還是要先讓我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147953/65.wav", + "text": "調整勞檢能量" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147953/66.wav", + "text": "但是我們一定會盤" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147953/67.wav", + "text": "因為高危險的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147953/68.wav", + "text": "我們要做比較好的稽核" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147953/69.wav", + "text": "稽核現場儲存的資料" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147953/70.wav", + "text": "跟我們瞭解的資料" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147953/71.wav", + "text": "是不是有落差" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147953/72.wav", + "text": "但是本席認為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147953/73.wav", + "text": "抽查很重要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147953/74.wav", + "text": "不要讓很多工廠認為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147953/75.wav", + "text": "自己不是屬於高危險" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147953/76.wav", + "text": "就疏忽了這個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147953/77.wav", + "text": "可以對我們會善用這個資料" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147953/78.wav", + "text": "再做明年整個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147953/79.wav", + "text": "就是抽查的頻率" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147953/80.wav", + "text": "委員我們同意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147952/0.wav", + "text": "謝謝主席" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147952/1.wav", + "text": "請部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147952/2.wav", + "text": "體育署" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147952/3.wav", + "text": "還有高教有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147952/4.wav", + "text": "鄭署長高等教育司" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147952/5.wav", + "text": "朱司長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147952/6.wav", + "text": "委員好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147952/7.wav", + "text": "部長好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147952/8.wav", + "text": "部長這裡有一個陳情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147952/9.wav", + "text": "就是���科大" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147952/10.wav", + "text": "圈養馬匹數隻" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147952/11.wav", + "text": "數隻非常地瘦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147952/12.wav", + "text": "所以陳情人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147952/13.wav", + "text": "如果依馬匹體態" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147952/14.wav", + "text": "評分標準來看的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147952/15.wav", + "text": "牠的評分是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147952/16.wav", + "text": "1就是很瘦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147952/17.wav", + "text": "狀況堪虞" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147952/18.wav", + "text": "陳情人也有跟屏東縣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147952/19.wav", + "text": "政府反映" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147952/20.wav", + "text": "屏東縣政府是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147952/21.wav", + "text": "專業人員去看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147952/22.wav", + "text": "然後認定馬是沒有問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147952/23.wav", + "text": "這個是屬於生科系" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147952/24.wav", + "text": "用途" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147952/25.wav", + "text": "隻是不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147952/26.wav", + "text": "需要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147952/27.wav", + "text": "然後是不是有違反動保法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147952/28.wav", + "text": "有不當" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147952/29.wav", + "text": "飼養的情形請部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147952/30.wav", + "text": "這邊可不可以來調查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147952/31.wav", + "text": "我跟委員報告一下因為校長今天剛好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147952/32.wav", + "text": "有出席是不是可以請校長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147952/33.wav", + "text": "先跟委員說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147952/34.wav", + "text": "什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147952/35.wav", + "text": "跟委員報告一下這些馬是生科系" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147952/36.wav", + "text": "老師飼養的牠屬於教學" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147952/37.wav", + "text": "牠是屬於他教學的一部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147952/38.wav", + "text": "好那現在有沒有過瘦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147952/39.wav", + "text": "是不是可以請" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147952/40.wav", + "text": "校方" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147952/41.wav", + "text": "還有教育部能夠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147952/42.wav", + "text": "調查然後在一個禮拜內" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147952/43.wav", + "text": "好我們請人去調查一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147952/44.wav", + "text": "好謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147952/45.wav", + "text": "我已經問過部長好幾次了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147952/46.wav", + "text": "經過這幾次瞭解" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147952/47.wav", + "text": "就是因為陳情人越來越" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147952/48.wav", + "text": "多甚至後來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147952/49.wav", + "text": "彰化縣消保官" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147952/50.wav", + "text": "去要到他們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147952/51.wav", + "text": "的消費爭議有33" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147952/52.wav", + "text": "件其中20件" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147952/53.wav", + "text": "就是屬於Wo" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147952/54.wav", + "text": "有辦法有能力去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147952/55.wav", + "text": "管理健身房" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147952/56.wav", + "text": "的消費爭議嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147952/57.wav", + "text": "跟委員報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147952/58.wav", + "text": "這個當然有相關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147952/59.wav", + "text": "定型化的契約可以做一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147952/60.wav", + "text": "依循" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147952/61.wav", + "text": "體育署作為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147952/62.wav", + "text": "事業的主管單位本來就有這個權責" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147952/63.wav", + "text": "至於剛才委員提到的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147952/64.wav", + "text": "因為這裡面也會涉及到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147952/65.wav", + "text": "對是體育署負責但是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147952/66.wav", + "text": "我現在要問部長因為之前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147952/67.wav", + "text": "已經跟你問過好幾" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147952/68.wav", + "text": "有懷疑就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147952/69.wav", + "text": "體育署" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147952/70.wav", + "text": "有沒有辦法去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147952/71.wav", + "text": "上市嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147952/72.wav", + "text": "上市的資料裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147952/73.wav", + "text": "在2023年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147952/74.wav", + "text": "申報的會員爭議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147952/75.wav", + "text": "才33件" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147952/76.wav", + "text": "那我剛剛有給你" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147952/77.wav", + "text": "爭議在33件裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147952/78.wav", + "text": "就占有20件" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147952/79.wav", + "text": "嘛所以它" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147952/80.wav", + "text": "提報金管會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147952/81.wav", + "text": "相關單位去上市申請" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147952/82.wav", + "text": "的這個資料是不是有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147952/83.wav", + "text": "造假或者是不實" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147952/84.wav", + "text": "體育署把" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147952/85.wav", + "text": "的這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147952/86.wav", + "text": "去瞭解" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147952/87.wav", + "text": "然後把相關的爭議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147952/88.wav", + "text": "都在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147952/89.wav", + "text": "一個禮拜內給本席可以嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147952/90.wav", + "text": "因為可能還涉及跨部會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147952/91.wav", + "text": "是不是再給體育署長一點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147952/92.wav", + "text": "好再來就是剛剛請問部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147952/93.wav", + "text": "現在他們涉及盜刷" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147952/94.wav", + "text": "合約也不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147952/95.wav", + "text": "消費者本身" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147952/96.wav", + "text": "健身房教練的合約" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147952/97.wav", + "text": "會員的合約目前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147952/98.wav", + "text": "還沒有發現" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147952/99.wav", + "text": "但是好幾個陳情人都是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147952/100.wav", + "text": "屬於信用卡被" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147952/101.wav", + "text": "盜刷然後教練合約" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147952/102.wav", + "text": "出問題被" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147952/103.wav", + "text": "所以我還是要部長具體" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147952/104.wav", + "text": "回答" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147952/105.wav", + "text": "到底有沒有辦法去管理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147952/106.wav", + "text": "目前健身房的這些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147952/107.wav", + "text": "我請署長跟委員報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147952/108.wav", + "text": "報告委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147952/109.wav", + "text": "我覺得基本上就是犯罪行為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147952/110.wav", + "text": "這沒有什麼好再多說了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147952/111.wav", + "text": "希望世界健身能夠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147952/112.wav", + "text": "積極給予改善" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147952/113.wav", + "text": "他們之前的新聞稿的確也" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147952/114.wav", + "text": "聲明他們會暫時停止" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147952/115.wav", + "text": "但是本席是要體育署" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147952/116.wav", + "text": "告訴我們怎麼管理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147952/117.wav", + "text": "以後你們到底要怎麼去管理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147952/118.wav", + "text": "對第二件事情就是針對委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147952/119.wav", + "text": "上一次提到的一週五堂課" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147952/120.wav", + "text": "以上這部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147952/121.wav", + "text": "我們在幾年前跟消保處" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147952/122.wav", + "text": "已經找業者還有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147952/123.wav", + "text": "當時訂出一週不得超過五堂課的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147952/124.wav", + "text": "但是因為你們沒有去查核" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147952/125.wav", + "text": "導致現在他們根本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147952/126.wav", + "text": "沒有照規矩來走" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147952/127.wav", + "text": "基本上這是一個商業行為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147952/128.wav", + "text": "當然講話術是屬於比較負面的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147952/129.wav", + "text": "我想對於這樣的商業行為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147952/130.wav", + "text": "教練做一些行銷的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147952/131.wav", + "text": "我是要知道體育署" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147952/132.wav", + "text": "後續要怎麼管" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147952/133.wav", + "text": "我們在跟消保處研議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147952/134.wav", + "text": "是不是可以在簽名處" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147952/135.wav", + "text": "因為他推銷的手段" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147952/136.wav", + "text": "基本上我們沒有辦法去做太多的限制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147952/137.wav", + "text": "但是你們是目的事業主管機關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147952/138.wav", + "text": "你們沒辦法那誰要管" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147952/139.wav", + "text": "但是他的確也有行銷的自由" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147952/140.wav", + "text": "這部分我們的確在警語的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147952/141.wav", + "text": "可以來做一個限制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147952/142.wav", + "text": "我是希望我們相關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147952/143.wav", + "text": "主管機關能夠告訴我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147952/144.wav", + "text": "你們後續要怎麼來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147952/145.wav", + "text": "還有簽約給我們一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147952/146.wav", + "text": "比較具體的你們能夠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147952/147.wav", + "text": "把它管理好的作法可以嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147952/148.wav", + "text": "好跟委員報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147952/149.wav", + "text": "研議就針對他們所出現" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147952/150.wav", + "text": "的這些現象包含過度行銷" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147952/151.wav", + "text": "甚至有一點點是不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147952/152.wav", + "text": "欺騙了消費者這部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147952/153.wav", + "text": "還有相關需要修改的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147952/154.wav", + "text": "法規命令是不是可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147952/155.wav", + "text": "更明確" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147952/156.wav", + "text": "多久告訴我們你們多久拿得出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147952/157.wav", + "text": "一個月之內好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147952/158.wav", + "text": "好謝謝謝謝主席" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147952/159.wav", + "text": "好謝謝陳椒華委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147951/0.wav", + "text": "謝謝主席主席麻煩請潘部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147951/1.wav", + "text": "然後是臺大陳校長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147951/2.wav", + "text": "屏東科技大學張校長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147951/3.wav", + "text": "南北再加一個外島" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147951/4.wav", + "text": "委員好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147951/5.wav", + "text": "我先請台大等3位校長好了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147951/6.wav", + "text": "部長稍待一下請稍等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147951/7.wav", + "text": "\n臺大陳校長請教一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147951/8.wav", + "text": "臺大今年休學的人數" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147951/9.wav", + "text": "您知道嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147951/10.wav", + "text": "對於臺大今年休學人數的比例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147951/11.wav", + "text": "我直接跟您說答案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147951/12.wav", + "text": "上學期休了769" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147951/13.wav", + "text": "人這是去年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147951/14.wav", + "text": "臺大非常棒" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147951/15.wav", + "text": "在你們的網站上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147951/16.wav", + "text": "就有休學人數" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147951/17.wav", + "text": "\n接下來請金門大學回答好了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147951/18.wav", + "text": "金門大學陳校長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147951/19.wav", + "text": "應該不到1成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147951/20.wav", + "text": "啊不到1成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147951/21.wav", + "text": "七百零多人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147951/22.wav", + "text": "差不多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147951/23.wav", + "text": "我要去查一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147951/24.wav", + "text": "要查一下是不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147951/25.wav", + "text": "好沒關係" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147951/26.wav", + "text": "好\n臺大陳校長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147951/27.wav", + "text": "一個學期多少錢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147951/28.wav", + "text": "大學部學費大概是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147951/29.wav", + "text": "6萬3,000元左右" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147951/30.wav", + "text": "6萬3,000六" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147951/31.wav", + "text": "六萬多元左右" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147951/32.wav", + "text": "好六萬多元以760人來算好了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147951/33.wav", + "text": "一年大概差個4,500萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147951/34.wav", + "text": "元對臺大的預算有影響嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147951/35.wav", + "text": "基本上對臺大的預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147951/36.wav", + "text": "影響比較小" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147951/37.wav", + "text": "可是我們很希望" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147951/38.wav", + "text": "學生能夠好好學習" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147951/39.wav", + "text": "最近推出一項措施" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147951/40.wav", + "text": "就是讓學生可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147951/41.wav", + "text": "所以有些學生休學" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147951/42.wav", + "text": "並不是因為他的學習" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147951/43.wav", + "text": "所以我們現在才會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147951/44.wav", + "text": "跟教育部在合作" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147951/45.wav", + "text": "未來大學" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147951/46.wav", + "text": "學生都能夠有好的學習" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147951/47.wav", + "text": "請問另外兩位校長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147951/48.wav", + "text": "你們休學的學生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147951/49.wav", + "text": "沒有繳學費" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147951/50.wav", + "text": "對你們學校的收支會有影響嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147951/51.wav", + "text": "還是差別不大" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147951/52.wav", + "text": "加減有影響" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147951/53.wav", + "text": "加減有影響" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147951/54.wav", + "text": "好沒問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147951/55.wav", + "text": "謝謝3位校長可以回座" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147951/56.wav", + "text": "了\n部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147951/57.wav", + "text": "請教您回去之後有瞭解" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147951/58.wav", + "text": "現在每年休學的人數是多少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147951/59.wav", + "text": "連公立學校公立大學" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147951/60.wav", + "text": "校長的講法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147951/61.wav", + "text": "對學校的收入還是有些許的影響" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147951/62.wav", + "text": "請問對私立大學怎麼辦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147951/63.wav", + "text": "你現在教育部的規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147951/64.wav", + "text": "就是只要休學" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147951/65.wav", + "text": "一毛錢都不用繳" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147951/66.wav", + "text": "合理嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147951/67.wav", + "text": "部長這經費是不是由你教育部來補" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147951/68.wav", + "text": "包含公立或者私立的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147951/69.wav", + "text": "高中職也一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147951/70.wav", + "text": "部長補或不補" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147951/71.wav", + "text": "休學的現在教育部的規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147951/72.wav", + "text": "喔休學是不用繳" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147951/73.wav", + "text": "一毛錢學雜費" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147951/74.wav", + "text": "還是教育部兩手一攤" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147951/75.wav", + "text": "─我規定是這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147951/76.wav", + "text": "成果你自己擔" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147951/77.wav", + "text": "是這個意思嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147951/78.wav", + "text": "部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147951/79.wav", + "text": "跟委員報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147951/80.wav", + "text": "現在如果學生是在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147951/81.wav", + "text": "註冊日跟開學後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147951/82.wav", + "text": "辦理休學" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147951/83.wav", + "text": "仍然還是會有部分的負擔" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147951/84.wav", + "text": "但是只要在註冊日前休學可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147951/85.wav", + "text": "一毛錢都不用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147951/86.wav", + "text": "繳是還是不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147951/87.wav", + "text": "部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147951/88.wav", + "text": "委員我想這個議題可能不只是從經費" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147951/89.wav", + "text": "啦至於說經費上是不是教育部再做一個研議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147951/90.wav", + "text": "但是如果變成是學生來承擔" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147951/91.wav", + "text": "我也覺得未必是部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147951/92.wav", + "text": "本席給你建議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147951/93.wav", + "text": "啦低收入戶原住民或者有特殊狀況的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147951/94.wav", + "text": "但是現在真的有很多包含" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147951/95.wav", + "text": "臺清交政大" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147951/96.wav", + "text": "這些優秀的學生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147951/97.wav", + "text": "他休學的其中重要原因之一" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147951/98.wav", + "text": "是出國讀書" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147951/99.wav", + "text": "啊我們學校給他留了一個位置" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147951/100.wav", + "text": "必須替他保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147951/101.wav", + "text": "但是他的選擇是出國讀書" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147951/102.wav", + "text": "這樣子我們還應該為他付所有的費用嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147951/103.wav", + "text": "部長你願不願意思考一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147951/104.wav", + "text": "我跟委員報告我想各校對休學的年限都有規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147951/105.wav", + "text": "你教育部的總規定就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147951/106.wav", + "text": "這很清楚嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147951/107.wav", + "text": "嘛教育部自己網站都有啊部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147951/108.wav", + "text": "委員如果就經費上的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147951/109.wav", + "text": "我想我們可以做一個思考" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147951/110.wav", + "text": "啦但是譬如讓學生有一個選擇的機會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147951/111.wav", + "text": "這一點想要用經費直接綁住" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147951/112.wav", + "text": "我也覺得未必是有具體的成效" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147951/113.wav", + "text": "所以反過來除了你說要到國外去升學" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147951/114.wav", + "text": "我們現在為什麼委員也知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147951/115.wav", + "text": "去修學位授予法的那個重大" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147951/116.wav", + "text": "事情我想校長們也越來越熟悉這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147951/117.wav", + "text": "事實上也許是讓學生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147951/118.wav", + "text": "從剛開始入學到未來的發展" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147951/119.wav", + "text": "實質學位授予法是給予很大的空間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147951/120.wav", + "text": "學生也可以有這樣的機會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147951/121.wav", + "text": "啦我想這個如果在校內" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147951/122.wav", + "text": "能夠跟學生多做一些傳達" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147951/123.wav", + "text": "休學的這種可能性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147951/124.wav", + "text": "因為沒有說他一定非必要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147951/125.wav", + "text": "只有休學才能夠重新來過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147951/126.wav", + "text": "所以好啊部長我知道你不願意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147951/127.wav", + "text": "啦但是本席建議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147951/128.wav", + "text": "他對於學校收入的影響是非常大" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147951/129.wav", + "text": "的所以教育部要是不改變" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147951/130.wav", + "text": "沒關係建議部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147951/131.wav", + "text": "不分公私立你只要這樣規定的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147951/132.wav", + "text": "相關學費教育部專案補助" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147951/133.wav", + "text": "可不可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147951/134.wav", + "text": "可不可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147951/135.wav", + "text": "這樣子好了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147951/136.wav", + "text": "現場我剛剛算了一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147951/137.wav", + "text": "47個大學校長在這邊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147951/138.wav", + "text": "請問你們學校" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147951/139.wav", + "text": "休學學生超過100個人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147951/140.wav", + "text": "或者100個人以上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147951/141.wav", + "text": "的可以舉手嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147951/142.wav", + "text": "我相信還有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147951/143.wav", + "text": "好謝謝不好意思" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147951/144.wav", + "text": "部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147951/145.wav", + "text": "真的很實際地跟您報告主席" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147951/146.wav", + "text": "已經站起來了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147951/147.wav", + "text": "再次地希望" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147951/148.wav", + "text": "假如教育部是這樣子規定的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147951/149.wav", + "text": "受害的不要是學校" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147951/150.wav", + "text": "你覺得對於學生是好的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147951/151.wav", + "text": "請你全額補助" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147951/152.wav", + "text": "否則底下的校長少一個學生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147951/153.wav", + "text": "就少一個學費的收入" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147951/154.wav", + "text": "謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147951/155.wav", + "text": "謝謝部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147951/156.wav", + "text": "謝謝主席" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147951/157.wav", + "text": "好謝謝李德維委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147949/0.wav", + "text": "好謝謝主席我們麻煩王部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147949/1.wav", + "text": "來王部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147949/2.wav", + "text": "部長好我一直認為整個交通系統就跟人的血液循環一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147949/3.wav", + "text": "但是你在規劃整個系統的過程中要確保整個系統是順暢的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147949/4.wav", + "text": "我們會遇到外面沒有路可以走" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147949/5.wav", + "text": "的狀況這件事情我知道不是只有你們的責任" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147949/6.wav", + "text": "要有不同的交通管道要走不同的系統" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147949/7.wav", + "text": "比較安全大車小車不要塞在一起" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147949/8.wav", + "text": "或者是地方縣市政府在你們的我們站在安全的維護上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147949/9.wav", + "text": "某些道路大型貨運車是不能進去的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147949/10.wav", + "text": "以���地方縣市政府沒有通盤整理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147949/11.wav", + "text": "瞭解到底還有哪些地方有這樣卡關的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147949/12.wav", + "text": "兩邊的貨運車下來之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147949/13.wav", + "text": "包含龍井大肚那邊我們會沒有路可以讓貨運車走" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147949/14.wav", + "text": "像你在第十二條規定要去監管相關的貨運業者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147949/15.wav", + "text": "或者是大型車業者的過程裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147949/16.wav", + "text": "我也希望你們回去看相關的規範" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147949/17.wav", + "text": "這些要真的能夠落實" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147949/18.wav", + "text": "你要有路給人家走簡單說是這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147949/19.wav", + "text": "甚至貨櫃從臺中港區" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147949/20.wav", + "text": "可是你們沒有路可以讓他走" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147949/21.wav", + "text": "這個路我們可以去做一些區分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147949/22.wav", + "text": "可是整條血液循環系統" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147949/23.wav", + "text": "我跟林委員報告你談得很對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147949/24.wav", + "text": "我們在十二條談到運輸業的角色" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147949/25.wav", + "text": "主要是說運輸業管理規則" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147949/26.wav", + "text": "剛才談到道路建設" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147949/27.wav", + "text": "比如說讓他有進出的道路" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147949/28.wav", + "text": "甚至停車" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147949/29.wav", + "text": "對現在我們卸貨是有問題的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147949/30.wav", + "text": "我們最近也跟地方政府談這個事" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147949/31.wav", + "text": "當然道路建設這個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147949/32.wav", + "text": "我們持續讓它能夠通" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147949/33.wav", + "text": "很多都會區幾乎都是紅線" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147949/34.wav", + "text": "對完全沒有卸貨區" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147949/35.wav", + "text": "他只要一停下來就被檢舉違法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147949/36.wav", + "text": "每個人都被記點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147949/37.wav", + "text": "對我覺得應該有適當的卸貨區" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147949/38.wav", + "text": "或是可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147949/39.wav", + "text": "臨時停車的黃線" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147949/40.wav", + "text": "這個你要跟地方政府有我們的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147949/41.wav", + "text": "他根本沒有地方停" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147949/42.wav", + "text": "真的到城市裡面的路" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147949/43.wav", + "text": "對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147949/44.wav", + "text": "完全沒有辦法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147949/45.wav", + "text": "我覺得應該適當的規劃有一些可以停" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147949/46.wav", + "text": "我們請地方" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147949/47.wav", + "text": "一定要檢討趕快處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147949/48.wav", + "text": "問題是你們的法規裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147949/49.wav", + "text": "沒有那些相關的線讓他停" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147949/50.wav", + "text": "除了道路通行以外" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147949/51.wav", + "text": "當然我知道停車是警政系統處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147949/52.wav", + "text": "對你們核定了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147949/53.wav", + "text": "結果合法業者到了地方" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147949/54.wav", + "text": "沒有一個地方可以停下來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147949/55.wav", + "text": "進行他的業務" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147949/56.wav", + "text": "這個請儘速處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147949/57.wav", + "text": "再來我們自己" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147949/58.wav", + "text": "大家都非常關注" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147949/59.wav", + "text": "我還是要跟你確認幾件事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147949/60.wav", + "text": "我們現在看到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147949/61.wav", + "text": "車站遴選標準要符合" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147949/62.wav", + "text": "量次銜接等等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147949/63.wav", + "text": "對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147949/64.wav", + "text": "你們現在看到臺" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147949/65.wav", + "text": "政府送上來的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147949/66.wav", + "text": "它能夠運輸的交通量" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147949/67.wav", + "text": "以及設置站點未來規劃的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147949/68.wav", + "text": "你們現在是採取什麼樣的態度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147949/69.wav", + "text": "目前大概是這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147949/70.wav", + "text": "包括運量" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147949/71.wav", + "text": "這些考量" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147949/72.wav", + "text": "你們現在有發現哪幾個站的運量" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147949/73.wav", + "text": "特別低嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147949/74.wav", + "text": "還是說有看到哪裡運量" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147949/75.wav", + "text": "其實可能會高" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147949/76.wav", + "text": "但是市府沒有考慮" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147949/77.wav", + "text": "目前倒是沒有這個問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147949/78.wav", + "text": "是在沙鹿站他們也考慮到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147949/79.wav", + "text": "沙鹿陸橋跟未來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147949/80.wav", + "text": "鐵路高架相關的規劃" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147949/81.wav", + "text": "蓋捷運的時候先拆沙鹿陸橋" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147949/82.wav", + "text": "對到時候兩個沒辦法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147949/83.wav", + "text": "又跟捷運也不知道高層在哪裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147949/84.wav", + "text": "所以現在最大的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147949/85.wav", + "text": "沙鹿站現在你們認為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147949/86.wav", + "text": "會跟鐵路銜接以及陸橋的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147949/87.wav", + "text": "陸地運輸會有衝突" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147949/88.wav", + "text": "因為地方在高架化部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147949/89.wav", + "text": "一直沒有提出方案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147949/90.wav", + "text": "我們不知道到時候要怎麼過去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147949/91.wav", + "text": "然後設站" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147949/92.wav", + "text": "沙鹿站要不要移也是一個問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147949/93.wav", + "text": "但是這地方現在地方政府還沒有提出" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147949/94.wav", + "text": "所以現在還沒有把資料給你們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147949/95.wav", + "text": "對所以我們覺得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147949/96.wav", + "text": "這個是我們目前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147949/97.wav", + "text": "沙鹿站這邊正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147949/98.wav", + "text": "我們看到2020年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147949/99.wav", + "text": "正英站的設置" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147949/100.wav", + "text": "規劃當時臺中市交通局局長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147949/101.wav", + "text": "認為人口的預測不多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147949/102.wav", + "text": "你們手頭上有沒有資料告訴我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147949/103.wav", + "text": "比方未來十年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147949/104.wav", + "text": "雖然現在人不多但未來人會變多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147949/105.wav", + "text": "有沒有這樣的資料" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147949/106.wav", + "text": "他們有提出這樣的資料" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147949/107.wav", + "text": "認為正英站未來多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147949/108.wav", + "text": "未來多有多多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147949/109.wav", + "text": "你們手上有資料嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147949/110.wav", + "text": "他在報告裡面是有談到正英站" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147949/111.wav", + "text": "因為我現在看到的捷運B8站" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147949/112.wav", + "text": "的估計從122年到140年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147949/113.wav", + "text": "全日進出運量是排最後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147949/114.wav", + "text": "細節部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147949/115.wav", + "text": "對這樣的設站做出解釋" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147949/116.wav", + "text": "沒有接受" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147949/117.wav", + "text": "所以我最後再請教" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147949/118.wav", + "text": "臺中市政府現在送給你們的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147949/119.wav", + "text": "每一個站點設置" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147949/120.wav", + "text": "與會議報告有給你們這樣的結論嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147949/121.wav", + "text": "有沒有其他的評估" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147949/122.wav", + "text": "周邊的銜接等等有沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147949/123.wav", + "text": "請會後把資料給我們辦公室好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147949/124.wav", + "text": "謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147948/0.wav", + "text": "謝謝主席" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147948/1.wav", + "text": "有請潘部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147948/2.wav", + "text": "請部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147948/3.wav", + "text": "好在請潘部長前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147948/4.wav", + "text": "因為今天很難得有這麼多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147948/5.wav", + "text": "國立大學的校長來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147948/6.wav", + "text": "我今天的主題是性別平等教育法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147948/7.wav", + "text": "跟性別平等教育" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147948/8.wav", + "text": "因為校長們剛剛坐了很久" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147948/9.wav", + "text": "可能會很累" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147948/10.wav", + "text": "所以讓大家提振一下精神" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147948/11.wav", + "text": "請問各位校長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147948/12.wav", + "text": "自己的學校" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147948/13.wav", + "text": "有沒有設置性別友善廁所" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147948/14.wav", + "text": "舉手好嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147948/15.wav", + "text": "不錯" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147948/16.wav", + "text": "現在我眼睛看到大概差不多有一半" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147948/17.wav", + "text": "那我想" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147948/18.wav", + "text": "只有一半的原因應該是有些校長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147948/19.wav", + "text": "並不知道謝謝大家請把手放下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147948/20.wav", + "text": "我們從教育部這邊的統計資料" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147948/21.wav", + "text": "知道我們的母數有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147948/22.wav", + "text": "148所大學院校" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147948/23.wav", + "text": "其實已經有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147948/24.wav", + "text": "119所學校" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147948/25.wav", + "text": "有了性別友善廁所" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147948/26.wav", + "text": "但是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147948/27.wav", + "text": "希望大家更努力進步" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147948/28.wav", + "text": "的是比率的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147948/29.wav", + "text": "我給大家看一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147948/30.wav", + "text": "這個是英國愛丁堡大學的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147948/31.wav", + "text": "性別友善廁所分布圖" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147948/32.wav", + "text": "大家可以看一下你們的螢幕" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147948/33.wav", + "text": "黃色中間有一個小洞的就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147948/34.wav", + "text": "而且你在學校的網頁上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147948/35.wav", + "text": "很容易找到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147948/36.wav", + "text": "全校只有一個或者非常少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147948/37.wav", + "text": "校長們應該發現" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147948/38.wav", + "text": "搶廁所很痛苦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147948/39.wav", + "text": "目前我們看到的數字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147948/40.wav", + "text": "都非常好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147948/41.wav", + "text": "可是比率上是兩千多人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147948/42.wav", + "text": "才有一間性別友善廁所" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147948/43.wav", + "text": "多數的學生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147948/44.wav", + "text": "都支持性別友善廁所" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147948/45.wav", + "text": "而且只有7.3%的同學" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147948/46.wav", + "text": "說他們沒有用過性別友善廁所" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147948/47.wav", + "text": "所以這個gender neutral" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147948/48.wav", + "text": "或是 all gender的廁所" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147948/49.wav", + "text": "其實是所有人都可以用的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147948/50.wav", + "text": "所以事實上大家可以考慮" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147948/51.wav", + "text": "是不是能夠增加" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147948/52.wav", + "text": "或者是沒有的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147948/53.wav", + "text": "那二三十所大學" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147948/54.wav", + "text": "也可以繼續努力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147948/55.wav", + "text": "這是第一題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147948/56.wav", + "text": "你們知不知道自己的學校" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147948/57.wav", + "text": "有沒有性別友善宿舍" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147948/58.wav", + "text": "有的請舉手好嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147948/59.wav", + "text": "兩位舉手" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147948/60.wav", + "text": "不知道這裡面是不是有政大的校長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147948/61.wav", + "text": "政大校長有舉手" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147948/62.wav", + "text": "謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147948/63.wav", + "text": "根據我們的資料" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147948/64.wav", + "text": "政大幾乎是唯一有性別友善宿舍的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147948/65.wav", + "text": "學校中山跟臺大" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147948/66.wav", + "text": "有在規劃中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147948/67.wav", + "text": "只是因為疫情或者是工程" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147948/68.wav", + "text": "還沒完成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147948/69.wav", + "text": "這也是一個好事可以繼續努力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147948/70.wav", + "text": "另外我也要特別" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147948/71.wav", + "text": "都有專人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147948/72.wav", + "text": "協助跨性別的學生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147948/73.wav", + "text": "這也是值得肯定的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147948/74.wav", + "text": "我們剛剛以愛丁堡大學為例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147948/75.wav", + "text": "你就可以知道國外" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147948/76.wav", + "text": "上廁所的基本權益" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147948/77.wav", + "text": "我們臺灣在這個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147948/78.wav", + "text": "可以跟上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147948/79.wav", + "text": "事實上不是只有愛丁堡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147948/80.wav", + "text": "我發現連印度的大學都有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147948/81.wav", + "text": "像澳洲在網路上也可以找得到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147948/82.wav", + "text": "在歐洲美國都有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147948/83.wav", + "text": "如果校長們不熟悉的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147948/84.wav", + "text": "那也希望可以熟悉校園裡的這些狀況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147948/85.wav", + "text": "三題我們在暑假" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147948/86.wav", + "text": "因為#MeToo修了性平三法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147948/87.wav", + "text": "其中也修了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147948/88.wav", + "text": "性別平等教育法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147948/89.wav", + "text": "請問校長你們知不知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147948/90.wav", + "text": "這次修法後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147948/91.wav", + "text": "學生的實習場域" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147948/92.wav", + "text": "也被納入" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147948/93.wav", + "text": "性別平等教育法的適用範圍嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147948/94.wav", + "text": "來之前就知道的請舉一下手" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147948/95.wav", + "text": "好嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147948/96.wav", + "text": "謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147948/97.wav", + "text": "我非常肯定這些舉手的校長們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147948/98.wav", + "text": "在我們這次修法後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147948/99.wav", + "text": "如果學生到產學合作" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147948/100.wav", + "text": "學校安排的企業實習" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147948/101.wav", + "text": "有和學生簽署指導人員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147948/102.wav", + "text": "契約的企業人員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147948/103.wav", + "text": "如果對實習學生性騷" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147948/104.wav", + "text": "也適用性別平等教育法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147948/105.wav", + "text": "事實上可以對學校申訴" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147948/106.wav", + "text": "學校也要負責調查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147948/107.wav", + "text": "受害學生的所屬學校" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147948/108.wav", + "text": "也必須敦促這些實習單位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147948/109.wav", + "text": "採取立即" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147948/110.wav", + "text": "而有效的糾正跟補救" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147948/111.wav", + "text": "措施" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147948/112.wav", + "text": "我也在這個時候希望大家能夠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147948/113.wav", + "text": "更百分之百的落實" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147948/114.wav", + "text": "性別平等教育法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147948/115.wav", + "text": "不要讓任何一個學生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147948/116.wav", + "text": "其實我也要幫大學校長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147948/117.wav", + "text": "跟教育部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147948/118.wav", + "text": "請命一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147948/119.wav", + "text": "看是不是能夠增加一些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147948/120.wav", + "text": "性平申訴機制的資源" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147948/121.wav", + "text": "教育部可能說大學應該要自己出" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147948/122.wav", + "text": "那我是想跟部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147948/123.wav", + "text": "討論一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147948/124.wav", + "text": "根據我蒐集到的資料" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147948/125.wav", + "text": "某國立大學總共三萬多位學生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147948/126.wav", + "text": "一年其實有超過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147948/127.wav", + "text": "200件性平事件" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147948/128.wav", + "text": "在今年七八月的#MeToo" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147948/129.wav", + "text": "發生前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147948/130.wav", + "text": "只有一位專職的人員在辦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147948/131.wav", + "text": "這些事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147948/132.wav", + "text": "在#MeToo之後他們增加了兩個人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147948/133.wav", + "text": "總共三個人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147948/134.wav", + "text": "其中正職公務員只有一人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147948/135.wav", + "text": "各位可以想到這樣子會非常" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147948/136.wav", + "text": "容易漏接" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147948/137.wav", + "text": "因為業務真的是太多了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147948/138.wav", + "text": "然後在我辦了立法院的公聽會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147948/139.wav", + "text": "以後也有不少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147948/140.wav", + "text": "擔任過學校" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147948/141.wav", + "text": "調查小組的成員說他們是憑著熱血" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147948/142.wav", + "text": "有時候一個會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147948/143.wav", + "text": "從早上開到下午" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147948/144.wav", + "text": "那這樣子的情況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147948/145.wav", + "text": "到底如何能夠讓" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147948/146.wav", + "text": "有心的熱情的性平" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147948/147.wav", + "text": "專業人員願意來做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147948/148.wav", + "text": "調查小組的成員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147948/149.wav", + "text": "這個部分並不是問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147948/150.wav", + "text": "所以我在想教育部應該要研議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147948/151.wav", + "text": "是否增加對大專院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147948/152.wav", + "text": "校性平申訴機制的補助" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147948/153.wav", + "text": "以解決目前人力經費的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147948/154.wav", + "text": "這是晚一點部長可以回應的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147948/155.wav", + "text": "就是我們也在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147948/156.wav", + "text": "這一波的#MeToo中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147948/157.wav", + "text": "我的辦公室收到很多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147948/158.wav", + "text": "大學生的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147948/159.wav", + "text": "陳情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147948/160.wav", + "text": "他們其實已經有跟自己大學" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147948/161.wav", + "text": "的性平會申訴了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147948/162.wav", + "text": "可是礙於一些學校的規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147948/163.wav", + "text": "沒有辦法得到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147948/164.wav", + "text": "學生權益的保障" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147948/165.wav", + "text": "其中有一個例子就是因為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147948/166.wav", + "text": "指導教授性騷學生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147948/167.wav", + "text": "該生因故要換" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147948/168.wav", + "text": "整個論文題目" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147948/169.wav", + "text": "而且中間要換指導教授的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147948/170.wav", + "text": "還受到阻撓" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147948/171.wav", + "text": "我們去了解了一下發現" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147948/172.wav", + "text": "研究生要換指導教授的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147948/173.wav", + "text": "有83%" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147948/174.wav", + "text": "須要原指導教授的同意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147948/175.wav", + "text": "只有17%" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147948/176.wav", + "text": "相對地比較讓學生的權益" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147948/177.wav", + "text": "這裡面有臺科大" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147948/178.wav", + "text": "成大陽交大" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147948/179.wav", + "text": "海大體大護理健康大學" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147948/180.wav", + "text": "相對比較受到尊重的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147948/181.wav", + "text": "當然我們並沒有覺得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147948/182.wav", + "text": "現在就要改變這麼多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147948/183.wav", + "text": "可是針對性平事件" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147948/184.wav", + "text": "指導教授就是性平事件" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147948/185.wav", + "text": "加害者的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147948/186.wav", + "text": "依照性別工作平等法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147948/187.wav", + "text": "就是雇主要立刻處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147948/188.wav", + "text": "不能讓他們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147948/189.wav", + "text": "繼續被指導被監督" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147948/190.wav", + "text": "但是我們看到的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147948/191.wav", + "text": "就是各公立大學還是反應比較慢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147948/192.wav", + "text": "最近臺大研究生協會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147948/193.wav", + "text": "已經在教務會議提案通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147948/194.wav", + "text": "修改指導教授" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147948/195.wav", + "text": "跟研究生的互動準則" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147948/196.wav", + "text": "在性別事件成立後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147948/197.wav", + "text": "研究生可以主動解除" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147948/198.wav", + "text": "指導關係" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147948/199.wav", + "text": "\n可是我也要提醒大家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147948/200.wav", + "text": "性別事件的成立" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147948/201.wav", + "text": "有的時候耗時非常久" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147948/202.wav", + "text": "也就是從申訴之後到成立" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147948/203.wav", + "text": "我並沒有標準答案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147948/204.wav", + "text": "但我希望部長也許可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147948/205.wav", + "text": "邀請相關專業人員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147948/206.wav", + "text": "跟大學代表來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147948/207.wav", + "text": "有座談會討論一下好嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147948/208.wav", + "text": "可是學生權" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147948/209.wav", + "text": "尤其是性別平等教育法所重視的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147948/210.wav", + "text": "在性別事件中學生的權利" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147948/211.wav", + "text": "特別是研究生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147948/212.wav", + "text": "我覺得這其實是茲事體大" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147948/213.wav", + "text": "1分鐘之內會結束" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147948/214.wav", + "text": "然後部長1分鐘" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147948/215.wav", + "text": "我想今天應該是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147948/216.wav", + "text": "的教育部是不是可以做3件事" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147948/217.wav", + "text": "第一鼓勵" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147948/218.wav", + "text": "也敦促各大專院校" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147948/219.wav", + "text": "積極地增設性別友善" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147948/220.wav", + "text": "廁所跟性別友善宿舍" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147948/221.wav", + "text": "大專院校對於性別事件" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147948/222.wav", + "text": "處理的人力跟經費狀況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147948/223.wav", + "text": "如果真的是經費不足" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147948/224.wav", + "text": "那教育部也可以評估" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147948/225.wav", + "text": "是否能夠補助" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147948/226.wav", + "text": "並於相關標準裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147948/227.wav", + "text": "另訂定提高" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147948/228.wav", + "text": "調查小組成員的支給費用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147948/229.wav", + "text": "行政院的規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147948/230.wav", + "text": "但我也看到在稿費上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147948/231.wav", + "text": "不同性質的稿費" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147948/232.wav", + "text": "其實是不同的差異非常地大" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147948/233.wav", + "text": "譬如說審查費用就非常高" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147948/234.wav", + "text": "所以這部分我覺得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147948/235.wav", + "text": "應該是有些空間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147948/236.wav", + "text": "─我讀過一些調查報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147948/237.wav", + "text": "其實不是只花寫字的時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147948/238.wav", + "text": "分析研究的時間就非常地多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147948/239.wav", + "text": "而且坐在那裡調查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147948/240.wav", + "text": "聽當事人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147948/241.wav", + "text": "這些性別" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147948/242.wav", + "text": "暴力的相關經驗" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147948/243.wav", + "text": "是一種很痛苦的專業" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147948/244.wav", + "text": "所以這部分希望教育部能" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147948/245.wav", + "text": "增加這些費用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147948/246.wav", + "text": "讓專業可���提升" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147948/247.wav", + "text": "跟研究生的互動準則" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147948/248.wav", + "text": "如果遇到性別事件之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147948/249.wav", + "text": "是不是能夠好好討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147948/250.wav", + "text": "能讓他解除指導關係" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147948/251.wav", + "text": "關係終止後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147948/252.wav", + "text": "研究成果的歸屬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147948/253.wav", + "text": "也要能夠比現在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147948/254.wav", + "text": "更為保障相關學生的權益" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147948/255.wav", + "text": "好嗎這三件事教育部是不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147948/256.wav", + "text": "可以努力評估" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147948/257.wav", + "text": "謝謝委員關於第一件" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147948/258.wav", + "text": "性別友善廁所" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147948/259.wav", + "text": "與宿舍的部分有一項指引" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147948/260.wav", + "text": "在去年發布" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147948/261.wav", + "text": "我也謝謝校長們都" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147948/262.wav", + "text": "盡力在這方面逐步推動" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147948/263.wav", + "text": "這部分教育部也會跟大學" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147948/264.wav", + "text": "\n第二人力這部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147948/265.wav", + "text": "可能比較有其限制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147948/266.wav", + "text": "啦但是在經費上我剛才也跟司長提到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147948/267.wav", + "text": "應該盡力地" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147948/268.wav", + "text": "協助大學因為不是每個學校" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147948/269.wav", + "text": "都一定會發生所以在人力部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147948/270.wav", + "text": "我的建議對我們來評估了解" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147948/271.wav", + "text": "但是經費上的需求我覺得是應該給" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147948/272.wav", + "text": "予多一些協助" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147948/273.wav", + "text": "邀大學還有幾個專家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147948/274.wav", + "text": "大家一起會商一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147948/275.wav", + "text": "看看怎麼樣能夠在性平三法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147948/276.wav", + "text": "事件的重視因為這裡面確實也有很多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147948/277.wav", + "text": "需要的隔離" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147948/278.wav", + "text": "指導寫作這方面如果發生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147948/279.wav", + "text": "怎麼處理會比較適切" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147948/280.wav", + "text": "確實要邀集相關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147948/281.wav", + "text": "方面包含大學做一些討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147948/282.wav", + "text": "好謝謝部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147948/283.wav", + "text": "那麼是不是在2個月之內可以給我一份" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147948/284.wav", + "text": "初步報告說明你們的評估好嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147948/285.wav", + "text": "好謝謝部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147948/286.wav", + "text": "性別平等教育能夠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147948/287.wav", + "text": "保障弱勢與所有人的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147948/288.wav", + "text": "努力謝謝大家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147948/289.wav", + "text": "部長請回座" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/0.wav", + "text": "好謝謝主席我們有請潘文忠部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/1.wav", + "text": "有請部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/2.wav", + "text": "委員好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/3.wav", + "text": "而且我相信你除了有看之外也有詳讀與瞭解" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/4.wav", + "text": "因為這份2023年臺灣兒少學習狀況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/5.wav", + "text": "調查報告裡的一些數字我們看過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/6.wav", + "text": "覺得非常驚訝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/7.wav", + "text": "60%的學生學習疲勞" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/8.wav", + "text": "在課業焦慮上呈現失眠的狀況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/9.wav", + "text": "13.8%常常頭痛和胃痛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/10.wav", + "text": "更可怕的是24.8%曾經有自傷或自殺的念頭" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/11.wav", + "text": "不曉得部長看過這份調查報告的數字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/12.wav", + "text": "跟委員報告臺灣的孩子在面對各界的期待" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/13.wav", + "text": "確實對他們在學習上有很多的壓力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/14.wav", + "text": "當然我還是要這樣子講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/15.wav", + "text": "現在的父母每一個都心疼孩子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/16.wav", + "text": "總期待他能夠在有限的時間裡面做最充分的學習" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/17.wav", + "text": "的要讓孩子多花一點時間在自己的成長過程" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/18.wav", + "text": "部長你的回答我真的非常錯愕" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/19.wav", + "text": "之前教育部的回答是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/20.wav", + "text": "現在每週的上課時數沒有增加" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/21.wav", + "text": "當時你們是這樣回答你今天的回答更是荒謬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/22.wav", + "text": "好像這些壓力全部都是來自於家長所給的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/23.wav", + "text": "我要講家長給的壓力不是沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/24.wav", + "text": "但是我們整個教育制度難道沒有引導家長或是給孩子壓力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/25.wav", + "text": "我認為這樣的回答不太好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/26.wav", + "text": "所以我們現在看到孩子在教育現場" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/27.wav", + "text": "展現出來呈現出來這樣的壓力這" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/28.wav", + "text": "這到底是哪裡來的家長給的為什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/29.wav", + "text": "這個期待從哪裡來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/30.wav", + "text": "那我們又應該怎麼樣去改變這樣的狀況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/31.wav", + "text": "可是我們又要思考" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/32.wav", + "text": "我們的責任是什麼我們的義務是什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/33.wav", + "text": "我們能為教育現場改變什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/34.wav", + "text": "這才是重點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/35.wav", + "text": "我不是讓你今天來這個地方指責家長而已" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/36.wav", + "text": "我不是說家長都沒有問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/37.wav", + "text": "委員我不是要指責家長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/38.wav", + "text": "我們也是我覺得第一時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/39.wav", + "text": "部長你今天必須要收拾" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/40.wav", + "text": "過去你在質詢時的不尊重和不禮貌" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/41.wav", + "text": "因為你今天是教育部的大家長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/42.wav", + "text": "所有大學的校長都在這個地方" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/43.wav", + "text": "希望今天不要再搶話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/44.wav", + "text": "\n我今天要講的是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/45.wav", + "text": "一定也會覺得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/46.wav", + "text": "家長的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/47.wav", + "text": "我們應該要怎麼樣引導他" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/48.wav", + "text": "們來配合孩子多元的學習" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/49.wav", + "text": "的來想一想應該要做些什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/50.wav", + "text": "這才是重點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/51.wav", + "text": "這是本席要提醒你的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/52.wav", + "text": "\n第二個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/53.wav", + "text": "82.6%這個比率非常大" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/54.wav", + "text": "其中這82.6%當中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/55.wav", + "text": "76%的孩子說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/56.wav", + "text": "這個壓力第一名來自於" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/57.wav", + "text": "製作學習歷程檔案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/58.wav", + "text": "這個數字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/59.wav", + "text": "我覺得這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/60.wav", + "text": "部裡面和部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/61.wav", + "text": "因為從108新課綱上路" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/62.wav", + "text": "學習歷程檔案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/63.wav", + "text": "就出過很多次的狀況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/64.wav", + "text": "當然每次狀況一出現" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/65.wav", + "text": "學習歷程檔案的本意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/66.wav", + "text": "這點要儘量做到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/67.wav", + "text": "有幾個數字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/68.wav", + "text": "我要請部長看一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/69.wav", + "text": "從112學年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/70.wav", + "text": "我們就可以看到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/71.wav", + "text": "繁星招生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/72.wav", + "text": "但是實際錄取的是14%" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/73.wav", + "text": "申請入學" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/74.wav", + "text": "但是實際錄取的只有38%" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/75.wav", + "text": "其實學習歷程檔案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/76.wav", + "text": "是重要的評分依據" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/77.wav", + "text": "我們來看分發入學" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/78.wav", + "text": "核定的名額為22%" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/79.wav", + "text": "但是最後實際錄取" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/80.wav", + "text": "卻高達41%" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/81.wav", + "text": "特殊選才占比較少部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/82.wav", + "text": "教師團體也好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/83.wav", + "text": "孩子也好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/84.wav", + "text": "給他們的壓力真的非常大" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/85.wav", + "text": "所以很多人後來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/86.wav", + "text": "都放棄這個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/87.wav", + "text": "等一下我要跟部長討論一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/88.wav", + "text": "同時我們也知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/89.wav", + "text": "其實有些孩子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/90.wav", + "text": "他想要進入頂尖大學" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/91.wav", + "text": "要準備學習歷程檔案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/92.wav", + "text": "能把自己的升學成績做到最好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/93.wav", + "text": "那個雙重壓力真的很可怕" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/94.wav", + "text": "這個數據" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/95.wav", + "text": "為什麼會有這個問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/96.wav", + "text": "學習歷程檔案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/97.wav", + "text": "是不是可以請部長說明一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/98.wav", + "text": "謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/99.wav", + "text": "跟委員報告一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/100.wav", + "text": "學習歷程檔案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/101.wav", + "text": "只是升學的條件之一" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/102.wav", + "text": "他並不是完全要做這件事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/103.wav", + "text": "也不斷地提醒" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/104.wav", + "text": "能夠充分的表達" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/105.wav", + "text": "其實他們已經不斷地不斷地" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/106.wav", + "text": "地跟學生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/107.wav", + "text": "尤其像委外來做這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/108.wav", + "text": "在大學甄試的過程中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/109.wav", + "text": "我們要相信大學的教授" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/110.wav", + "text": "瞭解什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/111.wav", + "text": "我剛才所講的並不是要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/112.wav", + "text": "把責任推給家長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/113.wav", + "text": "而是希望家長能夠瞭解" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/114.wav", + "text": "也要相信大學" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/115.wav", + "text": "不要無謂的增加" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/116.wav", + "text": "和很多額外的時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/117.wav", + "text": "這個才是我要講的事" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/118.wav", + "text": "情委員您也擔任家長團體的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/119.wav", + "text": "代表在這個過程中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/120.wav", + "text": "我們也希望能夠有機會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/121.wav", + "text": "多讓孩子要面對的是未來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/122.wav", + "text": "部長這一點我同意你的說法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/123.wav", + "text": "本席也是家長會長協會的理事長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/124.wav", + "text": "教改教改" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/125.wav", + "text": "其中一項我們很希望" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/126.wav", + "text": "能夠改掉的就是家長的想法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/127.wav", + "text": "但我們要怎麼樣去配合" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/128.wav", + "text": "讓孩子能夠更好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/129.wav", + "text": "其實家長不是不信任大學教授" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/130.wav", + "text": "家長是不信任現在這套制度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/131.wav", + "text": "原本我們設計這套制度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/132.wav", + "text": "我們是希望" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/133.wav", + "text": "用多元的方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/134.wav", + "text": "來讓不同條件的孩子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/135.wav", + "text": "減少他們的升學壓力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/136.wav", + "text": "同時也降低過去軍備競賽的狀況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/137.wav", + "text": "可是我們從這個數字上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/138.wav", + "text": "看到怎麼會108新課綱上路到現在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/139.wav", + "text": "82%壓力大的孩子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/140.wav", + "text": "其中大部分的人都說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/141.wav", + "text": "怎麼和高中端" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/142.wav", + "text": "學習歷程檔案有沒有必要繼續" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/143.wav", + "text": "如果要繼續有沒有需要做修改" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/144.wav", + "text": "我想這是這個數字背後所呈現出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/145.wav", + "text": "我們可以再努力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/146.wav", + "text": "\n剛才我們說到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/147.wav", + "text": "非常可怕" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/148.wav", + "text": "那就是有24.8%的學生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/149.wav", + "text": "曾經因為課業壓力過大" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/150.wav", + "text": "而有自傷或自殺的念頭" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/151.wav", + "text": "這是很恐怖的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/152.wav", + "text": "的因為這是調查的數據部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/153.wav", + "text": "長我們來看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/154.wav", + "text": "學生自傷或自殺通報案件數" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/155.wav", + "text": "各級學校加起來是1,089件" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/156.wav", + "text": "應該是部長你第一次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/157.wav", + "text": "當時是這樣的數據" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/158.wav", + "text": "也就是新課綱上路之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/159.wav", + "text": "暴增到4,310件" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/160.wav", + "text": "我們可以看到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/161.wav", + "text": "新課綱上路後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/162.wav", + "text": "109年再次倍增" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/163.wav", + "text": "變成800多件" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/164.wav", + "text": "這是各級學校曾經通報上來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/165.wav", + "text": "自殺或自傷的案件數" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/166.wav", + "text": "這是其一" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/167.wav", + "text": "\n第二個我們可以來參考一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/168.wav", + "text": "大專院校的通報案件數" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/169.wav", + "text": "首次在111年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/170.wav", + "text": "超越了高中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/171.wav", + "text": "為什麼本席要講這一點呢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/172.wav", + "text": "因為我們都知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/173.wav", + "text": "一般來講剛好這時是青春期" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/174.wav", + "text": "又是升學壓力最大的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/175.wav", + "text": "過去比率比較高的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/176.wav", + "text": "都是在高中的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/177.wav", + "text": "可是111年大專院校首次超越" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/178.wav", + "text": "高中我覺得這個數字值得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/179.wav", + "text": "我們來探討中間的問題是什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/180.wav", + "text": "\n再來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/181.wav", + "text": "不管是本席" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/182.wav", + "text": "或是教文委員會的委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/183.wav", + "text": "其實我們都有針對這個問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/184.wav", + "text": "應該要修正或想辦法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/185.wav", + "text": "由1比1,200調降到1比900" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/186.wav", + "text": "其實這個我們已經提過很多次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/187.wav", + "text": "了但是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/188.wav", + "text": "學生輔導法的修正版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/189.wav", + "text": "不知道你們是不是真的有心要做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/190.wav", + "text": "就我的瞭解" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/191.wav", + "text": "因為1比1,200" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/192.wav", + "text": "真的沒有辦法可以照顧到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/193.wav", + "text": "應該也在現場" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/194.wav", + "text": "讓我看一下好嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/195.wav", + "text": "好政大也在現場" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/196.wav", + "text": "長期守護校園心理健康計畫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/197.wav", + "text": "大概是8年左右" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/198.wav", + "text": "慢慢的它調整成1比1,000" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/199.wav", + "text": "有率先的這樣做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/200.wav", + "text": "舉手讓我看一下好嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/201.wav", + "text": "請放下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/202.wav", + "text": "我覺得不管資源或條件他們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/203.wav", + "text": "可能都沒有辦法自己做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/204.wav", + "text": "能夠自己做的真的比較少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/205.wav", + "text": "所以我們都在嗷嗷待補的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/206.wav", + "text": "這是很多委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/207.wav", + "text": "部長你說明一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/208.wav", + "text": "現在進度到哪裡了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/209.wav", + "text": "我們要等到下一屆" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/210.wav", + "text": "再重頭來過一次嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/211.wav", + "text": "是我跟委員報告一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/212.wav", + "text": "委員我說明一下這個通報數字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/213.wav", + "text": "沒有自殺或自傷的法律通報規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/214.wav", + "text": "所以這個時間點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/215.wav", + "text": "109以後一定要依法通報" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/216.wav", + "text": "所以數字上應該說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/217.wav", + "text": "早期可能有發生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/218.wav", + "text": "但沒有通報" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/219.wav", + "text": "所以數字的變化" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/220.wav", + "text": "有這個意義在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/221.wav", + "text": "當然自殺自傷" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/222.wav", + "text": "都是我們應該去重視的議題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/223.wav", + "text": "也許他們團體發表的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/224.wav", + "text": "108課綱把它當成好像" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/225.wav", + "text": "是現階段造成唯一的原因" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/226.wav", + "text": "如果委員你從大學校院的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/227.wav", + "text": "這個數字上來看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/228.wav", + "text": "大學照說跟108課綱" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/229.wav", + "text": "其實是不太會有直接的部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/230.wav", + "text": "你這個要分兩個部分來看對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/231.wav", + "text": "所以我才會說這個數字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/232.wav", + "text": "我把它稍微釐清一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/233.wav", + "text": "委員提到這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/234.wav", + "text": "我想也是委員一直在關注的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/235.wav", + "text": "學生輔導法現在是在行政院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/236.wav", + "text": "但是對大學長期專輔" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/237.wav", + "text": "人力不足過高的這部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/238.wav", + "text": "達到1比1,200" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/239.wav", + "text": "我在113年的預算已經反應" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/240.wav", + "text": "會直接就按照這個法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/241.wav", + "text": "未修訂前我們先調成1比900" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/242.wav", + "text": "我想這個對大學學生的需求" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/243.wav", + "text": "是否完成通過修法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/244.wav", + "text": "我們就先行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/245.wav", + "text": "部長我覺得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/246.wav", + "text": "我們趕快就先行這件事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/247.wav", + "text": "我是給你肯定的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/248.wav", + "text": "但是無論如何" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/249.wav", + "text": "我覺得修法這件事是根本的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/250.wav", + "text": "我們大家來拚嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/251.wav", + "text": "是不是可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/252.wav", + "text": "我們拚拚看這個時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/253.wav", + "text": "讓行政院趕快送上來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/254.wav", + "text": "我相信召委馬上排" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/255.wav", + "text": "我們大家努力一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/256.wav", + "text": "不是不能過的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/257.wav", + "text": "我也希望我們再努力試試看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/258.wav", + "text": "但是我還是肯定部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/259.wav", + "text": "在這個修法的行政院版本還沒有送上來之前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/260.wav", + "text": "我們先做是對的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/261.wav", + "text": "還是差一截" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/262.wav", + "text": "好這個我們來努力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/263.wav", + "text": "接下來還是針對這個問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/264.wav", + "text": "我再提一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/265.wav", + "text": "好像只有18個學校" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/266.wav", + "text": "有給學生心理健康假" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/267.wav", + "text": "國立大學當中的47個學校" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/268.wav", + "text": "也只有10個學校實施" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/269.wav", + "text": "也就是說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/270.wav", + "text": "有的學校有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/271.wav", + "text": "有的學校沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/272.wav", + "text": "但學生都是學生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/273.wav", + "text": "我覺得這樣子很奇怪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/274.wav", + "text": "我們是不是應該要訂定一套" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/275.wav", + "text": "讓各校有得依循去做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/276.wav", + "text": "是謝謝委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/277.wav", + "text": "我想不止大學" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/278.wav", + "text": "在這方面可能都有這樣的需求" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/279.wav", + "text": "這段時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/280.wav", + "text": "教育部也持續在蒐集" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/281.wav", + "text": "幾所已經試行的學校" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/282.wav", + "text": "因為當時在談這個議題的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/283.wav", + "text": "各界有一些不同的想法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/284.wav", + "text": "不一樣的看法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/285.wav", + "text": "尤其謝謝我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/286.wav", + "text": "這18所學校" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/287.wav", + "text": "已經開始在前進" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/288.wav", + "text": "我相信一定有累積" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/289.wav", + "text": "可以有一個很好的參考" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/290.wav", + "text": "部長我想應該也是這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/291.wav", + "text": "本席的意見還是我們加速" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/292.wav", + "text": "因為大家有不同的看法跟意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/293.wav", + "text": "我覺得把這些不同的看法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/294.wav", + "text": "跟意見整合起來以後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/295.wav", + "text": "我們去找出一個最適當方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/296.wav", + "text": "讓各大專院校" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/297.wav", + "text": "嘛我們的輔導人員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/298.wav", + "text": "未來要追蹤關心的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/299.wav", + "text": "其實也是滿好的一件事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/300.wav", + "text": "所以請部長這邊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/301.wav", + "text": "能夠加速的去研擬好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/302.wav", + "text": "最後我想有一點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/303.wav", + "text": "本席這次在總質詢的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/304.wav", + "text": "要解決護理師荒" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/305.wav", + "text": "他提出要增加" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/306.wav", + "text": "護理系所招生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/307.wav", + "text": "員額這件事" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/308.wav", + "text": "當天您也在場" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/309.wav", + "text": "\n我們來看一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/310.wav", + "text": "因為當天我們有看到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/311.wav", + "text": "護衛類的人數" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/312.wav", + "text": "每一年一直下降" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/313.wav", + "text": "到去年有2,779人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/314.wav", + "text": "今年只有2,400" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/315.wav", + "text": "就已經非常的低了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/316.wav", + "text": "報考人數低" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/317.wav", + "text": "然後我們今天也看到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/318.wav", + "text": "註冊率也低" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/319.wav", + "text": "所以現在的狀況是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/320.wav", + "text": "沒有人要去考" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/321.wav", + "text": "也低的情況之下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/322.wav", + "text": "我不太理解" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/323.wav", + "text": "護理系所員額" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/324.wav", + "text": "就可以解決護理荒" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/325.wav", + "text": "本席認為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/326.wav", + "text": "是搞錯重點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/327.wav", + "text": "不過那一天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/328.wav", + "text": "陳建仁院長說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/329.wav", + "text": "這個數字是錯誤的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/330.wav", + "text": "麻煩一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/331.wav", + "text": "因為這個數字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/332.wav", + "text": "也是部裡面給的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/333.wav", + "text": "部長能不能在這邊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/334.wav", + "text": "說明一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/335.wav", + "text": "委員說數字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/336.wav", + "text": "跟委員報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/337.wav", + "text": "這幾年我們統計到的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/338.wav", + "text": "確實報考的人數" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/339.wav", + "text": "那您先看一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/340.wav", + "text": "這個表上面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/341.wav", + "text": "的數字有沒有錯" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/342.wav", + "text": "這部分應該是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/343.wav", + "text": "只有統測的數據" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/344.wav", + "text": "但我們還有一般大學" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/345.wav", + "text": "對先看統測數據" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/346.wav", + "text": "我們還有一般大學" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/347.wav", + "text": "不我們先看統測" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/348.wav", + "text": "這個部分的數字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/349.wav", + "text": "這個數據我要請技職司" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/350.wav", + "text": "查核一下才有辦法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/351.wav", + "text": "講但我要報告的是說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/352.wav", + "text": "這幾年受到疫情的影響" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/353.wav", + "text": "護理同仁非常的辛苦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/354.wav", + "text": "這個也可能會影響" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/355.wav", + "text": "他們報考的心情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/356.wav", + "text": "我們也在觀察" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/357.wav", + "text": "這個疫情已經比較平息" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/358.wav", + "text": "112會是一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/359.wav", + "text": "後續我們再持續觀察的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/360.wav", + "text": "置的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/361.wav", + "text": "這個也確實是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/362.wav", + "text": "世衛組織給各國的說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/363.wav", + "text": "因為年紀老化" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/364.wav", + "text": "人口越來越多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/365.wav", + "text": "所需要的護理的人力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/366.wav", + "text": "不只是臺灣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/367.wav", + "text": "世界各國都是被要求" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/368.wav", + "text": "他們說面對2030" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/369.wav", + "text": "如果不能再增加" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/370.wav", + "text": "未來一定會出現" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/371.wav", + "text": "很大照護的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/372.wav", + "text": "部長這個真的是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/373.wav", + "text": "我們在講東" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/374.wav", + "text": "你們在講西" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/375.wav", + "text": "因為要增加護理人員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/376.wav", + "text": "增加護理系的學生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/377.wav", + "text": "這個本來就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/378.wav", + "text": "因為護理荒要增加人數" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/379.wav", + "text": "沒有人說不要增加" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/380.wav", + "text": "啊世界各國都是要增加" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/381.wav", + "text": "這是OK的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/382.wav", + "text": "現在問題是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/383.wav", + "text": "你要怎麼讓這些孩子們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/384.wav", + "text": "願意來報考" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/385.wav", + "text": "你要怎麼讓他們願意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/386.wav", + "text": "這才是重點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/387.wav", + "text": "你只是要增加" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/388.wav", + "text": "護理系所招生員額" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/389.wav", + "text": "我們現在連報考率都不足了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/390.wav", + "text": "你增加招生員額" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/391.wav", + "text": "有什麼意義" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/392.wav", + "text": "我剛才只是回答委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/393.wav", + "text": "報考率" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/394.wav", + "text": "在討論包含護理人員的待遇" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/395.wav", + "text": "衛福部這邊也會再改變" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/396.wav", + "text": "好好的去溝通一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/397.wav", + "text": "跨部會的會議也好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/398.wav", + "text": "就是不是只有增加員額" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/399.wav", + "text": "因為我們的現場狀況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/400.wav", + "text": "是報考人數不足" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/401.wav", + "text": "註冊率不足" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/402.wav", + "text": "這個數據" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/403.wav", + "text": "我麻煩你提供給院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/404.wav", + "text": "我們大家要一起想辦法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/405.wav", + "text": "才有辦法解決護理荒" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/406.wav", + "text": "如果只有在員額這個地方" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/407.wav", + "text": "打轉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/408.wav", + "text": "我想是沒有辦法解決這個問題的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/409.wav", + "text": "好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/410.wav", + "text": "這個帶回去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/411.wav", + "text": "\n最後我想" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/412.wav", + "text": "明裕次長一起主席" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/413.wav", + "text": "兩個問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/414.wav", + "text": "第一個問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/415.wav", + "text": "我們來看一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/416.wav", + "text": "這個是現在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/417.wav", + "text": "老舊廁所改善專案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/418.wav", + "text": "經費核定的一個狀況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/419.wav", + "text": "高雄市拿到最多的經費" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/420.wav", + "text": "2億180萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/421.wav", + "text": "平均每一個學生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/422.wav", + "text": "拿到的這個經費" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/423.wav", + "text": "臺南" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/424.wav", + "text": "高雄有1,040" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/425.wav", + "text": "0補助都非常非常的多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/426.wav", + "text": "而" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/427.wav", + "text": "本席所在的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/428.wav", + "text": "平均每一個孩子在這個專案上面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/429.wav", + "text": "只能拿到566塊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/430.wav", + "text": "而新北" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/431.wav", + "text": "在這一次我們整個老舊廁所" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/432.wav", + "text": "整修工程的核定上面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/433.wav", + "text": "非常非常的不公平" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/434.wav", + "text": "我不願意說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/435.wav", + "text": "這裡面有藍綠之分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/436.wav", + "text": "在野執政之分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/437.wav", + "text": "我覺得這樣說是不好的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/438.wav", + "text": "因為我永遠相信" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/439.wav", + "text": "部長您以及您的同仁" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/440.wav", + "text": "對待我們在教育部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/441.wav", + "text": "對待我們的孩子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/442.wav", + "text": "不會有政黨意識" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/443.wav", + "text": "跟藍綠之分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/444.wav", + "text": "每一個孩子都是我們的寶貝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/445.wav", + "text": "但是從這個經費上來看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/446.wav", + "text": "的確會有這樣的一個問題在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/447.wav", + "text": "本席也爭取了非常久" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/448.wav", + "text": "或許你可以說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/449.wav", + "text": "因為其他縣市" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/450.wav", + "text": "的老舊廁所就非常多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/451.wav", + "text": "所以我給的經費多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/452.wav", + "text": "但是不好意思" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/453.wav", + "text": "我們桃園市提出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/454.wav", + "text": "非常多的需求" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/455.wav", + "text": "到現在的滿足點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/456.wav", + "text": "還不到百分之五十" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/457.wav", + "text": "林明裕次長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/458.wav", + "text": "過去是我們的教育局的局長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/459.wav", + "text": "他最瞭解" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/460.wav", + "text": "桃園有沒有這樣的需求" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/461.wav", + "text": "是不是可以請林明裕次長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/462.wav", + "text": "為我們桃園說一句話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/463.wav", + "text": "謝謝委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/464.wav", + "text": "關心桃園市各級學校的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/465.wav", + "text": "的確從這個數字看來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/466.wav", + "text": "桃園市的孩子看起來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/467.wav", + "text": "受益的金額是比較低" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/468.wav", + "text": "但是委員您也當過議員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/469.wav", + "text": "那麼多屆" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/470.wav", + "text": "也擔任立法委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/471.wav", + "text": "之前我們在桃園市" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/472.wav", + "text": "做了一大批" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/473.wav", + "text": "我們自己用市款" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/474.wav", + "text": "所以這個核定數" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/475.wav", + "text": "稍微落後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/476.wav", + "text": "我們以後是不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/477.wav", + "text": "再來評估來加強" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/478.wav", + "text": "謝謝委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/479.wav", + "text": "您的回答讓我們非常的失望" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/480.wav", + "text": "你的回答真的讓我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/481.wav", + "text": "非常的痛心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/482.wav", + "text": "非常的失望" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/483.wav", + "text": "而且你還嘻皮笑臉的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/484.wav", + "text": "你這種嘻皮笑臉的樣子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/485.wav", + "text": "你笑得出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/486.wav", + "text": "委員我想我們對於" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/487.wav", + "text": "國教這方面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/488.wav", + "text": "協助地方政府" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/489.wav", + "text": "至於這個方案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/490.wav", + "text": "已經有多數" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/491.wav", + "text": "都是以學校" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/492.wav", + "text": "比較迫切的需求為優先" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/493.wav", + "text": "不管是廁所" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/494.wav", + "text": "或者像老舊校舍的整修" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/495.wav", + "text": "包含PU跑道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/496.wav", + "text": "這個確實不會去考量什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/497.wav", + "text": "政黨這一方面的因素" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/498.wav", + "text": "已經壞到不行了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/499.wav", + "text": "怎麼會去考慮到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/500.wav", + "text": "執政的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/501.wav", + "text": "至於目前因為還有部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/502.wav", + "text": "也正在看看縣市這邊的需求" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/503.wav", + "text": "委員如果服務的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/504.wav", + "text": "所在以及你所瞭解到的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/505.wav", + "text": "也讓我們知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/506.wav", + "text": "因為確實損壞不足的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/507.wav", + "text": "一定是最為優先的考慮" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/508.wav", + "text": "部長目前我們沒有詳細的數字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/509.wav", + "text": "因為國教署一直沒有給我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/510.wav", + "text": "但本席知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/511.wav", + "text": "桃園現在的核定率不到百分之五十" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/512.wav", + "text": "但是桃園不是只有你們眼中看到的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/513.wav", + "text": "那一些比較新的新設校" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/514.wav", + "text": "我們有很多的老舊廁所" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/515.wav", + "text": "真的亟待中央伸出援手來給我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/516.wav", + "text": "那既然這是一個專案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/517.wav", + "text": "就不應該去考慮到說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/518.wav", + "text": "縣市政府你要不要自己去想辦法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/519.wav", + "text": "縣市政府已經非常努力了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/520.wav", + "text": "我相信每一個縣市政府都是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/521.wav", + "text": "那就是因為不足所以我們有專案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/522.wav", + "text": "專案下來其實應該要公平" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/523.wav", + "text": "今天桃園或者是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/524.wav", + "text": "我們看到新北臺北" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/525.wav", + "text": "我覺得如果是落差很大的地方" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/526.wav", + "text": "甚至於臺中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/527.wav", + "text": "我們應該即刻下去看一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/528.wav", + "text": "我們能不能提高這樣的補助" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/529.wav", + "text": "所以我在這邊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/530.wav", + "text": "要為了我們沒有獲得公平對待的縣市" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/531.wav", + "text": "能夠在會後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/532.wav", + "text": "幫我們整個盤點一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/533.wav", + "text": "我跟委員報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/534.wav", + "text": "在前面有幾波關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/535.wav", + "text": "說的現在正在進行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/536.wav", + "text": "我也特別請陳院長這邊來支持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/537.wav", + "text": "因為學校還有好多老舊廁所" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/538.wav", + "text": "需要改善" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/539.wav", + "text": "目前是分批在處理的過程" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/540.wav", + "text": "我會請署長再特別留意一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/541.wav", + "text": "好請主席再給我最後1分鐘" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/542.wav", + "text": "一樣是跟林明裕次長有關係" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/543.wav", + "text": "因為今天大家都晚嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/544.wav", + "text": "那我這個問題很重要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/545.wav", + "text": "已經超過吳思瑤的極限了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/546.wav", + "text": "所以我們現在是以吳思瑤為標準嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/547.wav", + "text": "不是不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/548.wav", + "text": "以30秒內" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/549.wav", + "text": "再給我1分鐘好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/550.wav", + "text": "我們是以吳思瑤的時間為極限" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/551.wav", + "text": "意思是這樣嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/552.wav", + "text": "不是因為剛剛吳思瑤超時" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/553.wav", + "text": "我沒有注意到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/554.wav", + "text": "那我再最後1分鐘" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/555.wav", + "text": "桃園市公立幼兒園的營養午餐" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/556.wav", + "text": "我們的餐標明顯低於" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/557.wav", + "text": "本席這三個禮拜來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/558.wav", + "text": "不斷的爭取" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/559.wav", + "text": "我們桃園的孩子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/560.wav", + "text": "尤其是公立幼兒園的孩子們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/561.wav", + "text": "真的很辛苦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/562.wav", + "text": "目前我們的餐標明顯落後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/563.wav", + "text": "這個部分我跟部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/564.wav", + "text": "拜託過很多次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/565.wav", + "text": "能不能讓我們桃園市的孩子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/566.wav", + "text": "稍微吃得好一點點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/567.wav", + "text": "能夠提高到88塊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/568.wav", + "text": "因為畢竟現在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/569.wav", + "text": "臺中是96" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/570.wav", + "text": "高雄是92" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/571.wav", + "text": "臺北有91" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/572.wav", + "text": "我們希望拉到水準以上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/573.wav", + "text": "關於這一點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/574.wav", + "text": "因為林明裕次長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/575.wav", + "text": "也是來自於我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/576.wav", + "text": "桃園市教育局" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/577.wav", + "text": "的餐標長年都低於其他六都" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/578.wav", + "text": "這一點能不能繼續" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/579.wav", + "text": "為我們桃園來請命" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/580.wav", + "text": "委員上次提醒" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/581.wav", + "text": "我也已經特別請署長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/582.wav", + "text": "整個再盤點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/583.wav", + "text": "他們已經做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/584.wav", + "text": "了整理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/585.wav", + "text": "近期會跟我做一個專案的說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/586.wav", + "text": "之後我想對桃園" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/587.wav", + "text": "還有幾個縣市" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/588.wav", + "text": "會一起來處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/589.wav", + "text": "因為林次長在桃園服務過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/590.wav", + "text": "他當時也很努力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/591.wav", + "text": "委員那麼關心龍山國小" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/592.wav", + "text": "不知道有幾所的老舊廁所" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/593.wav", + "text": "但是因為有需要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/594.wav", + "text": "委員用心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/595.wav", + "text": "還是全力支持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/596.wav", + "text": "那個幾乎是一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/597.wav", + "text": "非常大的協助案子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/598.wav", + "text": "詳細說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/599.wav", + "text": "公立幼兒園的餐費" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/600.wav", + "text": "近期" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/601.wav", + "text": "國教署這邊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/602.wav", + "text": "請部長會後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/603.wav", + "text": "到我辦公室" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/604.wav", + "text": "再跟我做詳細說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/605.wav", + "text": "請部長或次長去說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/606.wav", + "text": "謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/607.wav", + "text": "部長次長請回" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/608.wav", + "text": "謝謝萬美玲委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147947/609.wav", + "text": "再來是我質詢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147946/0.wav", + "text": "謝謝主席是不是有請我們代理部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147946/1.wav", + "text": "部長因為我跟翁召委同一區" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147946/2.wav", + "text": "現在你說你們的拆除標已經招標" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147946/3.wav", + "text": "這個也講好久了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147946/4.wav", + "text": "現在到底拖的原因是什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147946/5.wav", + "text": "我們現在已經報院了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147946/6.wav", + "text": "我們會儘快爭取核定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147946/7.wav", + "text": "第二個部分在規劃的過程中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147946/8.wav", + "text": "從20億要提高到將近30幾億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147946/9.wav", + "text": "所以造成這些經費的不確定性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147946/10.wav", + "text": "讓我們沒有辦法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147946/11.wav", + "text": "因為地方是配合你們這樣的政策" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147946/12.wav", + "text": "這個政策就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147946/13.wav", + "text": "當時你們為了要把豬肉升級" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147946/14.wav", + "text": "未來豬肉可以外銷" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147946/15.wav", + "text": "然後要做到HACCP" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147946/16.wav", + "text": "講得這麼的讚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147946/17.wav", + "text": "你也知道這個肉品市場" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147946/18.wav", + "text": "原本是屬於朴子農會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147946/19.wav", + "text": "自己在經營" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147946/20.wav", + "text": "所以他有裡面的員工" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147946/21.wav", + "text": "他們整個拍賣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147946/22.wav", + "text": "他們的屠宰就停下來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147946/23.wav", + "text": "部長你知道這影響所及" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147946/24.wav", + "text": "有多少人嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147946/25.wav", + "text": "針對他們停的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147946/26.wav", + "text": "我們也引導到鄰近的地區" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147946/27.wav", + "text": "地區我們也會來做更積極的協助" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147946/28.wav", + "text": "你們更積極的協助事實上也都在拖" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147946/29.wav", + "text": "耶我有一直跟你們講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147946/30.wav", + "text": "我之前可能是跟前部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147946/31.wav", + "text": "這個我會再列管" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147946/32.wav", + "text": "我再跟你講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147946/33.wav", + "text": "以前在拍賣場的員工" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147946/34.wav", + "text": "已持續沒有工作" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147946/35.wav", + "text": "這是第一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147946/36.wav", + "text": "我們當時是跟他們說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147946/37.wav", + "text": "如果未來有現代化屠宰場後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147946/38.wav", + "text": "過去屠宰場的員工" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147946/39.wav", + "text": "因為這過去就是屠宰場" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147946/40.wav", + "text": "所以有很多在做豬肉運輸的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147946/41.wav", + "text": "在做運輸的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147946/42.wav", + "text": "承銷的也有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147946/43.wav", + "text": "承銷的也有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147946/44.wav", + "text": "到鄰近的市場" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147946/45.wav", + "text": "你知道多鄰近嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147946/46.wav", + "text": "臺南北港" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147946/47.wav", + "text": "這跟朴子都有相當的距離" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147946/48.wav", + "text": "耶運輸的成本也針對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147946/49.wav", + "text": "運輸的差額我們有補貼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147946/50.wav", + "text": "你們補貼的錢有下去了嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147946/51.wav", + "text": "下去了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147946/52.wav", + "text": "這個案子我會專案去列管" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147946/53.wav", + "text": "因為你們現在只說物價調整" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147946/54.wav", + "text": "你們一定要保持規模品質" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147946/55.wav", + "text": "這是第一" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147946/56.wav", + "text": "個不過你們不能拖" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147946/57.wav", + "text": "後面有勞工的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147946/58.wav", + "text": "副產業的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147946/59.wav", + "text": "這個部分我會專門去處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147946/60.wav", + "text": "看看怎麼樣協助他們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147946/61.wav", + "text": "我們一個月內把這些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147946/62.wav", + "text": "事情處理完好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147946/63.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147946/64.wav", + "text": "包括拆除標" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147946/65.wav", + "text": "嘛這些事情要先確定下來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147946/66.wav", + "text": "你要先穩定軍心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147946/67.wav", + "text": "對這個案幾乎已經是不想" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147946/68.wav", + "text": "支持的狀態了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147946/69.wav", + "text": "不會的我們會再親自去溝通" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147946/70.wav", + "text": "你要溝通好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147946/71.wav", + "text": "要穩定軍心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147946/72.wav", + "text": "不然這個屠宰場以後誰" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147946/73.wav", + "text": "會有信心原來跟農委會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147946/74.wav", + "text": "畜產會合作" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147946/75.wav", + "text": "是可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147946/76.wav", + "text": "創造共同利潤的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147946/77.wav", + "text": "但現在看到的卻是地方" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147946/78.wav", + "text": "民怨四起" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147946/79.wav", + "text": "這樣不行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147946/80.wav", + "text": "第二個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147946/81.wav", + "text": "問題應該和林務局有關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147946/82.wav", + "text": "現在碳權交易所已經成立了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147946/83.wav", + "text": "我想要跟林務局討論的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147946/84.wav", + "text": "是過去的平地造林" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147946/85.wav", + "text": "我相信林務局也很清" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147946/86.wav", + "text": "楚過去從事平地造林的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147946/87.wav", + "text": "因為沒有所謂碳權的概念" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147946/88.wav", + "text": "所以過去所造的林" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147946/89.wav", + "text": "沒有負碳的效果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147946/90.wav", + "text": "尤其有很多平地造林" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147946/91.wav", + "text": "白千層" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147946/92.wav", + "text": "它的造林效果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147946/93.wav", + "text": "不好這就" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147946/94.wav", + "text": "表示它所產生出來的二氧化碳" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147946/95.wav", + "text": "比它吸收的二氧化碳" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147946/96.wav", + "text": "還要多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147946/97.wav", + "text": "所以過去的平地造林嚴格說起來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147946/98.wav", + "text": "2050淨零碳排的總目標" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147946/99.wav", + "text": "部長你認同" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147946/100.wav", + "text": "我跟委員報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147946/101.wav", + "text": "樹如果樹會長大的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147946/102.wav", + "text": "不會說它放出的二氧化碳比吸收的還多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147946/103.wav", + "text": "但是相對的不同樹種" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147946/104.wav", + "text": "不同的樹種會不一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147946/105.wav", + "text": "對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147946/106.wav", + "text": "事實上這在國際也有排行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147946/107.wav", + "text": "我知道林業署也有一些建議的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147946/108.wav", + "text": "嘛未來平地造林之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147946/109.wav", + "text": "你們是要繼續補助它" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147946/110.wav", + "text": "它的林木不變" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147946/111.wav", + "text": "還是說你們要朝向" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147946/112.wav", + "text": "符合你們自己研究" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147946/113.wav", + "text": "或是國際研究的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147946/114.wav", + "text": "而且這些有效的樹木" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147946/115.wav", + "text": "還可以創造更多的林下經濟" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147946/116.wav", + "text": "我跟委員報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147946/117.wav", + "text": "現在平地造林大概" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147946/118.wav", + "text": "有一萬三千多公頃" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147946/119.wav", + "text": "我們分三個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147946/120.wav", + "text": "一個部分是它已經有所謂" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147946/121.wav", + "text": "棲地和地景的價值" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147946/122.wav", + "text": "我們後續每年還會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147946/123.wav", + "text": "有棲地和地景價值的很少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147946/124.wav", + "text": "啦很多平地造林都是放在那裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147946/125.wav", + "text": "老鼠蛇爬到別人的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147946/126.wav", + "text": "木材生產的價值" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147946/127.wav", + "text": "每一公頃大概會給8萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147946/128.wav", + "text": "元同時也會給他一些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147946/129.wav", + "text": "林的獎勵金" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147946/130.wav", + "text": "十年大概會有5到10萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147946/131.wav", + "text": "我要強調的是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147946/132.wav", + "text": "因為現在要推動所謂的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147946/133.wav", + "text": "未來會創造很大的價值" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147946/134.wav", + "text": "除了本身農業林業的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147946/135.wav", + "text": "經濟之外他們也要創造" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147946/136.wav", + "text": "碳匯價值" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147946/137.wav", + "text": "2050年的碳中和" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147946/138.wav", + "text": "現在碳權交易所已經成立了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147946/139.wav", + "text": "嘉義這個地方有光電產業" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147946/140.wav", + "text": "漁電共生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147946/141.wav", + "text": "也算是面積最大的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147946/142.wav", + "text": "因為台糖的土地這麼多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147946/143.wav", + "text": "看起來整個東石的平地造林非常多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147946/144.wav", + "text": "都需要轉型" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147946/145.wav", + "text": "所以我具體建議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147946/146.wav", + "text": "農業科技園區" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147946/147.wav", + "text": "農業部的農業科技園區" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147946/148.wav", + "text": "屏東" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147946/149.wav", + "text": "臺南" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147946/150.wav", + "text": "苗栗" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147946/151.wav", + "text": "花蓮" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147946/152.wav", + "text": "現在已經和屏東結合在一起" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147946/153.wav", + "text": "臺南是蘭花園區" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147946/154.wav", + "text": "屏東是生技園區" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147946/155.wav", + "text": "屏東是生技園區" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147946/156.wav", + "text": "的碳中和" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147946/157.wav", + "text": "我們需要從事更多這方面研究" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147946/158.wav", + "text": "包括嘉義有很多人在養蚵" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147946/159.wav", + "text": "到底蚵殼的產生過程" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147946/160.wav", + "text": "碳匯" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147946/161.wav", + "text": "這件事情我也希望農業部要加緊研究" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147946/162.wav", + "text": "或是由農業部率先" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147946/163.wav", + "text": "朝向2050淨零碳排的研究" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147946/164.wav", + "text": "所謂的農業科技園區" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147946/165.wav", + "text": "可以研究" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147946/166.wav", + "text": "更多的森林碳匯" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147946/167.wav", + "text": "海洋藍匯" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147946/168.wav", + "text": "土地" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147946/169.wav", + "text": "黃色碳匯" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147946/170.wav", + "text": "都和農業有關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147946/171.wav", + "text": "都是需要研究人員的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147946/172.wav", + "text": "應該要在嘉義成立農業科技園區" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147946/173.wav", + "text": "議題比較大" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147946/174.wav", + "text": "可是我們可以開始著手來研究" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147946/175.wav", + "text": "我同意委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147946/176.wav", + "text": "就是說一個生技園區要成立" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147946/177.wav", + "text": "一定要週邊產業的支持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147946/178.wav", + "text": "在嘉義地區其實有很多農業循環" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147946/179.wav", + "text": "資源的場域是可以利用的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147946/180.wav", + "text": "我們先盤點這個產業的需求" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147946/181.wav", + "text": "包括養豬的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147946/182.wav", + "text": "尿會創造出大量的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147946/183.wav", + "text": "所以我們先做產業的分析" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147946/184.wav", + "text": "和相關量能的分析以後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147946/185.wav", + "text": "去支持這樣的園區" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147946/186.wav", + "text": "不然沒有產業支持的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147946/187.wav", + "text": "沒有錯" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147946/188.wav", + "text": "這個要研究的方向太廣了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147946/189.wav", + "text": "還要擴散型的研究" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147946/190.wav", + "text": "一起加入研究" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147946/191.wav", + "text": "所以才會有這樣的園區" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147946/192.wav", + "text": "擴大評估" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147946/193.wav", + "text": "事實上背後都含有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147946/194.wav", + "text": "所謂的碳中和" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147946/195.wav", + "text": "它可以達到它的效果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147946/196.wav", + "text": "包括減少化學肥" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147946/197.wav", + "text": "鼓勵有機肥" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147946/198.wav", + "text": "這也有所謂的土壤碳這實在有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147946/199.wav", + "text": "太多東西需要研究了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147946/200.wav", + "text": "謝謝蔡召委的質詢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147945/0.wav", + "text": "行人優先交通安全行動綱領" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147945/1.wav", + "text": "我今天要問的問題不是很大" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147945/2.wav", + "text": "在永續提升人車安全" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147945/3.wav", + "text": "道從線改變到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147945/4.wav", + "text": "真的有個面這當然" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147945/5.wav", + "text": "表面上好像有人行道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147945/6.wav", + "text": "這個法規就是市區道��及附屬工程" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147945/7.wav", + "text": "以營建署即現在的城鄉發展署" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147945/8.wav", + "text": "也要準備上來一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147945/9.wav", + "text": "法規裡講得很清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147945/10.wav", + "text": "1.5公尺" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147945/11.wav", + "text": "就算經主管機關同意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147945/12.wav", + "text": "也不得小於0.9" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147945/13.wav", + "text": "公尺且人行道上的機車" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147945/14.wav", + "text": "就是不鼓勵做這件事" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147945/15.wav", + "text": "不應該又是人行道又是機車格" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147945/16.wav", + "text": "如果真的有必要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147945/17.wav", + "text": "那麼淨寬還是不能小於1.5公尺" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147945/18.wav", + "text": "上我就直接講完再請部長一起回答" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147945/19.wav", + "text": "\n部長你看這個圖" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147945/20.wav", + "text": "以我現在在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147945/21.wav", + "text": "跑的文山區來講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147945/22.wav", + "text": "現在這個問題在哪裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147945/23.wav", + "text": "機車格跟綠色的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147945/24.wav", + "text": "這些點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147945/25.wav", + "text": "我們其實是有法規的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147945/26.wav", + "text": "在這個地方" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147945/27.wav", + "text": "主根本不知道你現在劃下去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147945/28.wav", + "text": "所以現在這地方該怎麼紓" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147945/29.wav", + "text": "紓解一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147945/30.wav", + "text": "或者說讓大家更清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147945/31.wav", + "text": "未來又該怎麼落實" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147945/32.wav", + "text": "一邊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147945/33.wav", + "text": "一方面另一邊劃人行道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147945/34.wav", + "text": "各分各的一邊是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147945/35.wav", + "text": "人行沒有方向性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147945/36.wav", + "text": "所以另外一邊留人行道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147945/37.wav", + "text": "這一邊就是機車格但" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147945/38.wav", + "text": "有時候這個就是要考慮" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147945/39.wav", + "text": "坦白說有時候就是一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147945/40.wav", + "text": "取捨有時候可能就" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147945/41.wav", + "text": "印象沒有錯的話它已" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147945/42.wav", + "text": "只是機車格還沒有塗銷掉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147945/43.wav", + "text": "結果機車主就覺得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147945/44.wav", + "text": "好像還是可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147945/45.wav", + "text": "市區道路及附屬工程" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147945/46.wav", + "text": "其實很多時候我們是辦不到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147945/47.wav", + "text": "的如果真的不能辦到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147945/48.wav", + "text": "那麼騎樓之間的整治" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147945/49.wav", + "text": "要大刀闊斧處理一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147945/50.wav", + "text": "我跟委員報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147945/51.wav", + "text": "我們現在也在想一個問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147945/52.wav", + "text": "如果可以的話就縮減車道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147945/53.wav", + "text": "把一米五留出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147945/54.wav", + "text": "需求很高那巷道另外一邊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147945/55.wav", + "text": "至少要把標線型人行道畫出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147945/56.wav", + "text": "地方可以劃設機車停車格" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147945/57.wav", + "text": "再怎麼說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147945/58.wav", + "text": "優先順序就是一個很困難的取捨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147945/59.wav", + "text": "您看看這個圖人都走在外面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147945/60.wav", + "text": "我們真的要洗刷人行地獄" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147945/61.wav", + "text": "把人的權益擺在最前面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147945/62.wav", + "text": "那麼精神也會往這個方向走" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147945/63.wav", + "text": "畢竟人本交通還是要做這件事" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147945/64.wav", + "text": "這個麻煩部長謝謝部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147945/65.wav", + "text": "謝謝主席" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147944/0.wav", + "text": "要麻煩請美女司長上台" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147944/1.wav", + "text": "部長認真看簡報就好了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147944/2.wav", + "text": "委員好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147944/3.wav", + "text": "勞工保險跟普通商業保險" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147944/4.wav", + "text": "有什麼不同的地方" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147944/5.wav", + "text": "勞工保險是社會保險" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147944/6.wav", + "text": "\n一般的商業保險" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147944/7.wav", + "text": "可不可以改變契約" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147944/8.wav", + "text": "可不可以在保險到期的前幾年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147944/9.wav", + "text": "改變投保金額或增加保費" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147944/10.wav", + "text": "雙方如果同意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147944/11.wav", + "text": "還是可以改變" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147944/12.wav", + "text": "是這樣子嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147944/13.wav", + "text": "我聽到這樣感覺有點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147944/14.wav", + "text": "開心也很意外" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147944/15.wav", + "text": "我一直以為商業保險是不可以改變的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147944/16.wav", + "text": "是這樣嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147944/17.wav", + "text": "下面的人好像有不同的意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147944/18.wav", + "text": "欸部長搖頭說不行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147944/19.wav", + "text": "沒關係我今天沒有要討論商業保險" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147944/20.wav", + "text": "但是這個答案讓大家有點意外就是了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147944/21.wav", + "text": "用最高的60個月" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147944/22.wav", + "text": "給付保障是比較好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147944/23.wav", + "text": "其實主要也是要保障勞工的生活" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147944/24.wav", + "text": "已經存在了許多年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147944/25.wav", + "text": "那你們對於這個問題的本質" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147944/26.wav", + "text": "有沒有掌握基本資料" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147944/27.wav", + "text": "跟持續監控" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147944/28.wav", + "text": "我們都持續在監控勞保財務的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147944/29.wav", + "text": "所以你們的基本資料也都掌握得非常好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147944/30.wav", + "text": "請領年金的人次大概是多少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147944/31.wav", + "text": "到8月為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147944/32.wav", + "text": "為止年金的數字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147944/33.wav", + "text": "你們這邊寫159萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147944/34.wav", + "text": "159萬是去年年底" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147944/35.wav", + "text": "你是說今年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147944/36.wav", + "text": "好你有最新" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147944/37.wav", + "text": "的數字但是你交報告也沒有要update這個資料" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147944/38.wav", + "text": "好就差不多169萬人次啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147944/39.wav", + "text": "年金一次性給付的人次大概有多少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147944/40.wav", + "text": "在我們的年金選擇率大概占92%" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147944/41.wav", + "text": "委員是講今年嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147944/42.wav", + "text": "對你剛剛回答我今年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147944/43.wav", + "text": "不然你要按照你在報告上面的資訊去回答" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147944/44.wav", + "text": "等一下我會問你比例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147944/45.wav", + "text": "所以你要告訴我同一年的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147944/46.wav", + "text": "就是112年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147944/47.wav", + "text": "1月到8月" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147944/48.wav", + "text": "你有沒有講錯" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147944/49.wav", + "text": "是四萬五千多人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147944/50.wav", + "text": "對是106十九萬五千" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147944/51.wav", + "text": "好那這樣的比例是大概多少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147944/52.wav", + "text": "馬上算一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147944/53.wav", + "text": "好心跟善良的主席" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147944/54.wav", + "text": "會在你思考的時間幫我暫停" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147944/55.wav", + "text": "給我多一點點的時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147944/56.wav", + "text": "現在就是選擇年金的比例就是92%" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147944/57.wav", + "text": "這是今年的嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147944/58.wav", + "text": "好那你等一下自己好好算一算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147944/59.wav", + "text": "\n好在過去幾年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147944/60.wav", + "text": "請領老年年金的比例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147944/61.wav", + "text": "是穩定增加" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147944/62.wav", + "text": "減少還是維持一個平穩的狀態" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147944/63.wav", + "text": "是在增加慢慢在增加" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147944/64.wav", + "text": "不過最近大概都維持在92%" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147944/65.wav", + "text": "長期統計的資料" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147944/66.wav", + "text": "請問你們有針對不同的支付級距" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147944/67.wav", + "text": "在觀察請領年金的比例嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147944/68.wav", + "text": "有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147944/69.wav", + "text": "那現在年金月領的範圍" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147944/70.wav", + "text": "介於多少錢之間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147944/71.wav", + "text": "也就是說最低跟最高的金額" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147944/72.wav", + "text": "各是多少錢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147944/73.wav", + "text": "如果用萬元為級距來看的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147944/74.wav", + "text": "目前最多的是1萬到2萬的47%" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147944/75.wav", + "text": "不過2萬到3萬其實也占了36%" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147944/76.wav", + "text": "我是問你多少錢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147944/77.wav", + "text": "就是1萬到2萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147944/78.wav", + "text": "我這一題很簡單" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147944/79.wav", + "text": "我只是問你" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147944/80.wav", + "text": "月領範圍介於多少錢之間而已" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147944/81.wav", + "text": "委員是問最高領多少錢嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147944/82.wav", + "text": "對啊最低跟最高多少錢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147944/83.wav", + "text": "各是多少錢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147944/84.wav", + "text": "最高是五萬兩千多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147944/85.wav", + "text": "五萬兩千多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147944/86.wav", + "text": "對最低可能就是基本保障的300多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147944/87.wav", + "text": "因為國勞併計的關係" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147944/88.wav", + "text": "可以併計國保年資" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147944/89.wav", + "text": "15年以後可以領" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147944/90.wav", + "text": "勞保這邊的年金" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147944/91.wav", + "text": "所以最低是300多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147944/92.wav", + "text": "你們後面兜不太起來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147944/93.wav", + "text": "好沒關係" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147944/94.wav", + "text": "因為我是參考你們後面這個資料" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147944/95.wav", + "text": "你講得不一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147944/96.wav", + "text": "我先跳過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147944/97.wav", + "text": "時有沒有發現" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147944/98.wav", + "text": "領得少的勞工朋友" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147944/99.wav", + "text": "我們就看這一張就好了好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147944/100.wav", + "text": "你們給大家的報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147944/101.wav", + "text": "不要再拿其他的資料" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147944/102.wav", + "text": "你等一下也不曉得你在答什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147944/103.wav", + "text": "我們就針對這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147944/104.wav", + "text": "我現在這個問題很簡單" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147944/105.wav", + "text": "有沒有發現領得少的勞工朋友" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147944/106.wav", + "text": "依照勞保局的經驗跟統計" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147944/107.wav", + "text": "沒有差異" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147944/108.wav", + "text": "可是我從這張表看的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147944/109.wav", + "text": "這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147944/110.wav", + "text": "比如說你這一張" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147944/111.wav", + "text": "會比較多一些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147944/112.wav", + "text": "錢領得少的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147944/113.wav", + "text": "他就會比較傾向" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147944/114.wav", + "text": "一次性請領" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147944/115.wav", + "text": "這樣子的人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147944/116.wav", + "text": "是比較多的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147944/117.wav", + "text": "資料應該是沒有這樣明顯" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147944/118.wav", + "text": "的差異" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147944/119.wav", + "text": "對但是你那個資料" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147944/120.wav", + "text": "我們也是沒看到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147944/121.wav", + "text": "因為按照你們這張表" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147944/122.wav", + "text": "錢領的多的人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147944/123.wav", + "text": "選擇每個月領的也比較多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147944/124.wav", + "text": "他覺得他每個月請領" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147944/125.wav", + "text": "就可以顧到每個月的生活" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147944/126.wav", + "text": "對一般來講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147944/127.wav", + "text": "跟我們這邊的資料一對照看起來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147944/128.wav", + "text": "結論是不太" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147944/129.wav", + "text": "一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147944/130.wav", + "text": "普遍高齡化所以大部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147944/131.wav", + "text": "的人會選擇年金因為他是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147944/132.wav", + "text": "依照我們的統計" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147944/133.wav", + "text": "統計是滿好奇的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147944/134.wav", + "text": "你再提供給我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147944/135.wav", + "text": "是從這邊的表格看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147944/136.wav", + "text": "所以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147944/137.wav", + "text": "有剛剛我講的那個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147944/138.wav", + "text": "狀態現在就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147944/139.wav", + "text": "不同職業別的退休勞工" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147944/140.wav", + "text": "請領一次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147944/141.wav", + "text": "是不是有可能" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147944/142.wav", + "text": "也是不一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147944/143.wav", + "text": "這個部分你們有沒有針對不同" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147944/144.wav", + "text": "職業別的退休勞工去看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147944/145.wav", + "text": "沒有這部分勞保局沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147944/146.wav", + "text": "做這樣的分析統計" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147944/147.wav", + "text": "好如果沒有的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147944/148.wav", + "text": "那我可能要在這裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147944/149.wav", + "text": "好心地提醒你你可能" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147944/150.wav", + "text": "要去看一下好我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147944/151.wav", + "text": "是不知道因為我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147944/152.wav", + "text": "也沒有能力去做統計" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147944/153.wav", + "text": "但是這個是你工作範圍內的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147944/154.wav", + "text": "所以你要去看好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147944/155.wav", + "text": "你們如果準備好我就會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147944/156.wav", + "text": "看起來是沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147944/157.wav", + "text": "兼職的勞工也是同時" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147944/158.wav", + "text": "有兩個投保單位這個勞工" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147944/159.wav", + "text": "在請領年金的時候你們是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147944/160.wav", + "text": "怎麼計算是兩邊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147944/161.wav", + "text": "都可以請領嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147944/162.wav", + "text": "年金就是投保薪資如果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147944/163.wav", + "text": "超過30天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147944/164.wav", + "text": "就是同一期間超過30天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147944/165.wav", + "text": "投保薪資可以合併計算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147944/166.wav", + "text": "最高就是那個上限" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147944/167.wav", + "text": "就是投保薪資加起來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147944/168.wav", + "text": "就是全部都可以請領" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147944/169.wav", + "text": "就是了不是領兩個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147944/170.wav", + "text": "這個是另外一個問題未來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147944/171.wav", + "text": "會再討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147944/172.wav", + "text": "我提出這些問題主要是在提醒" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147944/173.wav", + "text": "你們你們制訂重大的政策" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147944/174.wav", + "text": "時要思考三個重要的層面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147944/175.wav", + "text": "就是時機程度跟比例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147944/176.wav", + "text": "只關注年金砍多少的程度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147944/177.wav", + "text": "怎麼去開源節流很多專家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147944/178.wav", + "text": "也都告訴我們說餅就這麼大" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147944/179.wav", + "text": "要從哪裡切切幾塊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147944/180.wav", + "text": "切多少遇到這樣的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147944/181.wav", + "text": "勞保政策的幕僚主管其實" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147944/182.wav", + "text": "是可以利用數據來說話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147944/183.wav", + "text": "的掌握未來的走勢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147944/184.wav", + "text": "跟預期的變動是你們要做的功課" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147944/185.wav", + "text": "本質主要是保障勞工朋友" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147944/186.wav", + "text": "的退休生活所以裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147944/187.wav", + "text": "涉及的基本生活所需" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147944/188.wav", + "text": "是隨著少子化的現象" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147944/189.wav", + "text": "一定會減少所以進水量" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147944/190.wav", + "text": "和出水量的差異變大" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147944/191.wav", + "text": "水量所以這個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147944/192.wav", + "text": "最重要的就是說你們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147944/193.wav", + "text": "是不是要去精算未來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147944/194.wav", + "text": "人口比例上採取逐步" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147944/195.wav", + "text": "就是讓勞保" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147944/196.wav", + "text": "退休金領得少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147944/197.wav", + "text": "的人降低一次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147944/198.wav", + "text": "請領的意願然後讓他們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147944/199.wav", + "text": "甚至沒有減損這樣子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147944/200.wav", + "text": "應該就不會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147944/201.wav", + "text": "對勞保的公平性產生影響" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147944/202.wav", + "text": "所以今天我" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147944/203.wav", + "text": "在這邊你沒有準備好的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147944/204.wav", + "text": "部分麻煩你整理好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147944/205.wav", + "text": "再提供給我們辦公室" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147944/206.wav", + "text": "好謝謝謝謝委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147944/207.wav", + "text": "下一位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147943/0.wav", + "text": "請陳部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147943/1.wav", + "text": "你辛苦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147943/2.wav", + "text": "了第一件事情就是我上次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147943/3.wav", + "text": "院會質詢的��候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147943/4.wav", + "text": "提到這次小犬颱風的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147943/5.wav", + "text": "應該要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147943/6.wav", + "text": "請問你們現在研究的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147943/7.wav", + "text": "從上次委員的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147943/8.wav", + "text": "我們內部也很仔細的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147943/9.wav", + "text": "評估" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147943/10.wav", + "text": "我想我們一定會朝向" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147943/11.wav", + "text": "委員的想法跟期待" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147943/12.wav", + "text": "而努力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147943/13.wav", + "text": "朝向你今天就給我一個明確的答" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147943/14.wav", + "text": "會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147943/15.wav", + "text": "跟委員報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147943/16.wav", + "text": "現在災害貸款" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147943/17.wav", + "text": "舊貸的餘額大概有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147943/18.wav", + "text": "14億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147943/19.wav", + "text": "未來可能申請的信貸" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147943/20.wav", + "text": "預估免息一年大概" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147943/21.wav", + "text": "要3,200萬元左右" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147943/22.wav", + "text": "部長這會有困難嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147943/23.wav", + "text": "一定會朝這個方向去努力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147943/24.wav", + "text": "多久可以給我答案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147943/25.wav", + "text": "我現在就可以給你" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147943/26.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147943/27.wav", + "text": "我們可以同意這樣的一個作為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147943/28.wav", + "text": "來協助農民因為這次小犬颱風" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147943/29.wav", + "text": "期限大概" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147943/30.wav", + "text": "半年左右我們先來處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147943/31.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147943/32.wav", + "text": "受災的農民" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147943/33.wav", + "text": "什麼錢都在花" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147943/34.wav", + "text": "但是遇到災害這種農民的利息錢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147943/35.wav", + "text": "卻沒有辦法補貼就" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147943/36.wav", + "text": "就算有補貼他們也很艱苦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147943/37.wav", + "text": "苦實際上還是不夠成本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147943/38.wav", + "text": "我覺得這不是大有為的政府" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147943/39.wav", + "text": "所以你今天作的決策" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147943/40.wav", + "text": "我向你致謝謝謝你" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147943/41.wav", + "text": "這是第一點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147943/42.wav", + "text": "農業專業貸款的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147943/43.wav", + "text": "當然我們有補貼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147943/44.wav", + "text": "利息但是農業補貼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147943/45.wav", + "text": "政策什麼時候開始規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147943/46.wav", + "text": "必須要檢附統一" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147943/47.wav", + "text": "發票" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147943/48.wav", + "text": "委員這個可能有點誤會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147943/49.wav", + "text": "我可不可以請農業金" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147943/50.wav", + "text": "明不是每一個都要檢附發票的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147943/51.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147943/52.wav", + "text": "專案農貸要檢附發票" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147943/53.wav", + "text": "是指資本支出的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147943/54.wav", + "text": "一定要檢附發票" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147943/55.wav", + "text": "他是可以開統一發票的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147943/56.wav", + "text": "要能夠開統一發票" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147943/57.wav", + "text": "是這樣子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147943/58.wav", + "text": "當然在這當中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147943/59.wav", + "text": "不是不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147943/60.wav", + "text": "但是情理上面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147943/61.wav", + "text": "可以稍微" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147943/62.wav", + "text": "通融一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147943/63.wav", + "text": "舉例來說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147943/64.wav", + "text": "今天一個農民很艱苦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147943/65.wav", + "text": "要申請貸款" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147943/66.wav", + "text": "結果我們叫他要檢附統一發票" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147943/67.wav", + "text": "資本支出要有統一發票" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147943/68.wav", + "text": "在這種情況下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147943/69.wav", + "text": "事實上讓農民多負擔5%" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147943/70.wav", + "text": "的稅金" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147943/71.wav", + "text": "對於融資" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147943/72.wav", + "text": "都會儘量幫助農民" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147943/73.wav", + "text": "最近一定要求" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147943/74.wav", + "text": "地方農會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147943/75.wav", + "text": "一定要檢附統一發票" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147943/76.wav", + "text": "我跟委員說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147943/77.wav", + "text": "剛剛有說過資本支出的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147943/78.wav", + "text": "那間公司" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147943/79.wav", + "text": "本身就應該要開立發票" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147943/80.wav", + "text": "如果你叫他不要開" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147943/81.wav", + "text": "反而是幫助他逃漏稅" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147943/82.wav", + "text": "發票的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147943/83.wav", + "text": "很沒道理的是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147943/84.wav", + "text": "比如他的信用額" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147943/85.wav", + "text": "你們知道嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147943/86.wav", + "text": "有沒有這樣的情形跟" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147943/87.wav", + "text": "委員報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147943/88.wav", + "text": "我們並沒有這樣子的規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147943/89.wav", + "text": "我們只有規定什麼情況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147943/90.wav", + "text": "是我最近在基層碰到的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147943/91.wav", + "text": "當然因為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147943/92.wav", + "text": "但我是認為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147943/93.wav", + "text": "我們對於農民的貸款" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147943/94.wav", + "text": "尤其是辛苦的農民" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147943/95.wav", + "text": "我希望不要給太多的刁難" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147943/96.wav", + "text": "或者讓他們增加額外的支出" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147943/97.wav", + "text": "啦這是我基本的一個觀念" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147943/98.wav", + "text": "所以假設資本支出" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147943/99.wav", + "text": "我們來考量假設他可以開收據" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147943/100.wav", + "text": "的我也希望你們可以朝向這個方向" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147943/101.wav", + "text": "給他們有一個通融" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147943/102.wav", + "text": "的管道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147943/103.wav", + "text": "像那種要撥款給他" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147943/104.wav", + "text": "我覺得這個都矯枉過正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147943/105.wav", + "text": "都過度了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147943/106.wav", + "text": "處理一下好不好我們地方農會有遇到這些問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147943/107.wav", + "text": "第二點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147943/108.wav", + "text": "看到一個新聞" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147943/109.wav", + "text": "說要喝高粱" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147943/110.wav", + "text": "救高鐵" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147943/111.wav", + "text": "有看到這個新聞嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147943/112.wav", + "text": "以前你們主委也說過這些話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147943/113.wav", + "text": "嘛現在臺南市的市長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147943/114.wav", + "text": "我現在要跟你說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147943/115.wav", + "text": "成績很好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147943/116.wav", + "text": "這個是好事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147943/117.wav", + "text": "但是我有一個原則我認為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147943/118.wav", + "text": "認為今天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147943/119.wav", + "text": "希望" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147943/120.wav", + "text": "都有烘乾費用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147943/121.wav", + "text": "麼你們不給高粱烘乾費用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147943/122.wav", + "text": "我跟委員報告那是內含的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147943/123.wav", + "text": "不是外加的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147943/124.wav", + "text": "稻穀是外加的其實是都有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147943/125.wav", + "text": "我跟你說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147943/126.wav", + "text": "你這樣說我不能接受" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147943/127.wav", + "text": "你們可以考慮" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147943/128.wav", + "text": "不要把它當成內含啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147943/129.wav", + "text": "因為我們今天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147943/130.wav", + "text": "要鼓勵一項政策" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147943/131.wav", + "text": "今天我們也一樣配合你們的政策" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147943/132.wav", + "text": "包括學甲" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147943/133.wav", + "text": "佳里等地方配合" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147943/134.wav", + "text": "轉作高粱" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147943/135.wav", + "text": "我跟委員報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147943/136.wav", + "text": "我們回去會檢討" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147943/137.wav", + "text": "也拜託委員跟金門縣政府" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147943/138.wav", + "text": "高我這邊都會處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147943/139.wav", + "text": "你如果金門酒" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147943/140.wav", + "text": "金門酒廠替我們臺灣在解決問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147943/141.wav", + "text": "我們的品種是客製化金門用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147943/142.wav", + "text": "來協助" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147943/143.wav", + "text": "你告訴我不要內含" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147943/144.wav", + "text": "高粱的烘乾費用可以補助嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147943/145.wav", + "text": "有多少錢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147943/146.wav", + "text": "你現在算一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147943/147.wav", + "text": "樣子兩千公頃到底多少錢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147943/148.wav", + "text": "烘乾費用是多少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147943/149.wav", + "text": "你說連這個也做不" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147943/150.wav", + "text": "我們回去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147943/151.wav", + "text": "重新檢視一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147943/152.wav", + "text": "烘乾費用應該可以怎麼樣調整" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147943/153.wav", + "text": "再來問你" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147943/154.wav", + "text": "我要說的是以前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147943/155.wav", + "text": "稻穀有玉米也要有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147943/156.wav", + "text": "要求轉作為什麼不做這項工作" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147943/157.wav", + "text": "我跟委員報告我們都是為了農民" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147943/158.wav", + "text": "啦農民收入" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147943/159.wav", + "text": "就是金門酒廠的收購價也要提高" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147943/160.wav", + "text": "你叫臺灣公賣局" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147943/161.wav", + "text": "啦臺灣菸酒公賣局認真做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147943/162.wav", + "text": "我們自己政府" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147943/163.wav", + "text": "財政部所管的單位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147943/164.wav", + "text": "不做這些工作你連這個也在計較" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147943/165.wav", + "text": "我們是為了農民" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147943/166.wav", + "text": "我知道啦你叫臺灣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147943/167.wav", + "text": "你努力了很多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147943/168.wav", + "text": "你如果要去那裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147943/169.wav", + "text": "我們大家一起努力如果是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147943/170.wav", + "text": "為了農民我都可以陪你去努力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147943/171.wav", + "text": "但我要說的是政策性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147943/172.wav", + "text": "要怎麼讓水流的面積降低" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147943/173.wav", + "text": "要怎麼讓他們多元化去生產" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147943/174.wav", + "text": "這些雜糧能夠節水" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147943/175.wav", + "text": "第三點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147943/176.wav", + "text": "現在整個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147943/177.wav", + "text": "包括拆除的我們已經發包" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147943/178.wav", + "text": "後續就是說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147943/179.wav", + "text": "沒什麼進度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147943/180.wav", + "text": "在我不想浪費你的時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147943/181.wav", + "text": "你們做的很無理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147943/182.wav", + "text": "你回去再好好研究" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147943/183.wav", + "text": "下次我們再來討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147943/184.wav", + "text": "因為我不想占用大家時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147943/185.wav", + "text": "謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147942/0.wav", + "text": "另外今天現場有那麼多位大學校長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147942/1.wav", + "text": "校長也一起備詢請臺灣大學陳校長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147942/2.wav", + "text": "好校��們請" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147942/3.wav", + "text": "不好意思讓校長們活動一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147942/4.wav", + "text": "好好謝謝召委" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147942/5.wav", + "text": "召委部長好各位校長好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147942/6.wav", + "text": "我為什麼要特別要邀請很多的校長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147942/7.wav", + "text": "我自己本身也是完全來自學術界" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147942/8.wav", + "text": "非常謝謝我自己任教的母校" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147942/9.wav", + "text": "最主要的就是有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147942/10.wav", + "text": "尤其我們公立學校的老師" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147942/11.wav", + "text": "也就是上個會期由我擔任召委的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147942/12.wav", + "text": "後要請各位校長上來談一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147942/13.wav", + "text": "到底大家覺得這樣子是不是足夠的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147942/14.wav", + "text": "本身就來自於高教界" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147942/15.wav", + "text": "問題剛才鄭委員在談這件事" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147942/16.wav", + "text": "確實是個大問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147942/17.wav", + "text": "而且我們已經真正喪失競爭力了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147942/18.wav", + "text": "這是一個事實" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147942/19.wav", + "text": "但是能夠給" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147942/20.wav", + "text": "我想也已經是真的有造福到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147942/21.wav", + "text": "我們還是謝謝教育部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147942/22.wav", + "text": "因為過去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147942/23.wav", + "text": "大概還沒有這麼高幅度的加薪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147942/24.wav", + "text": "所以部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147942/25.wav", + "text": "我還是要請教一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147942/26.wav", + "text": "您覺得這件事之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147942/27.wav", + "text": "還有沒有什麼其他的機會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147942/28.wav", + "text": "是謝謝委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147942/29.wav", + "text": "留才的這部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147942/30.wav", + "text": "其實各界都很關注" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147942/31.wav", + "text": "包括校長們其實也一直在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147942/32.wav", + "text": "所以才有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147942/33.wav", + "text": "我們希望能夠在高教領域" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147942/34.wav", + "text": "在待遇等各方面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147942/35.wav", + "text": "如委員所提到的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147942/36.wav", + "text": "除了一般的加薪之外" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147942/37.wav", + "text": "我們對大學教授" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147942/38.wav", + "text": "副教授助理教授" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147942/39.wav", + "text": "有15%的學術加給" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147942/40.wav", + "text": "加給原先教育部跟各大學" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147942/41.wav", + "text": "共同合作的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147942/42.wav", + "text": "部分以及彈性薪資的做法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147942/43.wav", + "text": "就一致性與" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147942/44.wav", + "text": "也能夠有不同的待遇" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147942/45.wav", + "text": "這部分教育部也持續在擴大" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147942/46.wav", + "text": "謝謝部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147942/47.wav", + "text": "因為真��非常非常久了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147942/48.wav", + "text": "大概都是跟著軍公教的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147942/49.wav", + "text": "我們這一次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147942/50.wav", + "text": "其實我很坦白說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147942/51.wav", + "text": "我自己進入國會這4年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147942/52.wav", + "text": "我也覺得如果能夠為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147942/53.wav", + "text": "高教界做一點點小小的貢獻" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147942/54.wav", + "text": "也是從這邊開始" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147942/55.wav", + "text": "因為您是整個我們高等校" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147942/56.wav", + "text": "您覺得這樣夠嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147942/57.wav", + "text": "有沒有其他的部分不足" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147942/58.wav", + "text": "其實還有其他的政策" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147942/59.wav", + "text": "但是我們也很知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147942/60.wav", + "text": "多數的老師如果透過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147942/61.wav", + "text": "彈性薪資平均能加1.5萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147942/62.wav", + "text": "元到2萬元我覺得就已經差不多了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147942/63.wav", + "text": "我想很多資訊都已經展現" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147942/64.wav", + "text": "我們這邊的薪資水準" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147942/65.wav", + "text": "當然不能跟鄰近的國家相比" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147942/66.wav", + "text": "不過我覺得還有一塊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147942/67.wav", + "text": "也許可以再加強一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147942/68.wav", + "text": "是請校長指示" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147942/69.wav", + "text": "因為我陸續聽一些老師" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147942/70.wav", + "text": "說他們到快要退休的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147942/71.wav", + "text": "算了一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147942/72.wav", + "text": "結果不敢退休而且還要再延退" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147942/73.wav", + "text": "所以最近延退的情況當然是會比較多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147942/74.wav", + "text": "非常謝謝周校長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147942/75.wav", + "text": "請大家在這邊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147942/76.wav", + "text": "發言其實真的是希望大家也進來國會殿堂" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147942/77.wav", + "text": "這是真的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147942/78.wav", + "text": "我完全認同剛才我們周校長談到的這件事" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147942/79.wav", + "text": "哪有敢退休的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147942/80.wav", + "text": "25年到了之後其實真的沒有人敢退" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147942/81.wav", + "text": "休想要多延都可能" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147942/82.wav", + "text": "就是因為我們這個頂到天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147942/83.wav", + "text": "受傷最重的就是我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147942/84.wav", + "text": "大學教授這也是個事實" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147942/85.wav", + "text": "繼續備詢部長您看一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147942/86.wav", + "text": "學生素質低落" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147942/87.wav", + "text": "的狀況請問現在高教公共化" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147942/88.wav", + "text": "會不會有素質平庸的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147942/89.wav", + "text": "因為我也必須誠實說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147942/90.wav", + "text": "我們要節省一下時間我就" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147942/91.wav", + "text": "多說一兩個問題再一起請部長與校長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147942/92.wav", + "text": "\n我們公立的學校" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147942/93.wav", + "text": "包括臺大清大等學校" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147942/94.wav", + "text": "大學校長都在這裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147942/95.wav", + "text": "再直接往下一起講完" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147942/96.wav", + "text": "國家重點產學條例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147942/97.wav", + "text": "我們當然是鼓勵增設學校" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147942/98.wav", + "text": "我必須坦白說這是好的方向" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147942/99.wav", + "text": "好的政策但是我們的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147942/100.wav", + "text": "生員就是這麼有限" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147942/101.wav", + "text": "現在就是公立學校不斷的在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147942/102.wav", + "text": "增加私立" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147942/103.wav", + "text": "學校大概也完全招不到生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147942/104.wav", + "text": "甚至公立學校增加之後還有往內" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147942/105.wav", + "text": "跟原來的學院之間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147942/106.wav", + "text": "其實也有搶學生的狀況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147942/107.wav", + "text": "所以有請" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147942/108.wav", + "text": "因為其實之前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147942/109.wav", + "text": "的問題可是這個問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147942/110.wav", + "text": "是不是反而是我們公立" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147942/111.wav", + "text": "學校不斷的擴增" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147942/112.wav", + "text": "請問陳校長您怎麼看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147942/113.wav", + "text": "尤其臺大是最領先的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147942/114.wav", + "text": "但是另一方面我們又不斷擴增" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147942/115.wav", + "text": "臺大陳校長謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147942/116.wav", + "text": "謝謝委員您剛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147942/117.wav", + "text": "替我們爭取了15%的學術" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147942/118.wav", + "text": "我們這幾年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147942/119.wav", + "text": "有統計過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147942/120.wav", + "text": "有關於這幾年進入臺灣大學的學生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147942/121.wav", + "text": "現況108課" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147942/122.wav", + "text": "綱事實上是鼓勵" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147942/123.wav", + "text": "學生多元學習" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147942/124.wav", + "text": "會需要再加強" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147942/125.wav", + "text": "我們有另外有開設" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147942/126.wav", + "text": "設加深加廣的課" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147942/127.wav", + "text": "針對幾個基礎科目" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147942/128.wav", + "text": "我問過相關學系" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147942/129.wav", + "text": "譬如說數學系" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147942/130.wav", + "text": "在第一年之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147942/131.wav", + "text": "事實上學生的程度跟以往" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147942/132.wav", + "text": "並沒有太大的差距" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147942/133.wav", + "text": "是謝謝校長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147942/134.wav", + "text": "質疑是不是我們公立" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147942/135.wav", + "text": "其實這也是一個老問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147942/136.wav", + "text": "我在總質詢的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147942/137.wav", + "text": "也請教過部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147942/138.wav", + "text": "代表當然我們是很不錯" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147942/139.wav", + "text": "但是另外一方面私校教育" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147942/140.wav", + "text": "到底還要不要讓它持續" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147942/141.wav", + "text": "其實當然它是有一定的競合" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147942/142.wav", + "text": "這個我們必須誠實說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147942/143.wav", + "text": "謝謝陳校長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147942/144.wav", + "text": "所有的校長都深深有感" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147942/145.wav", + "text": "我不能說政策一定不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147942/146.wav", + "text": "這些政策" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147942/147.wav", + "text": "學校的頂大的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147942/148.wav", + "text": "大家真的覺得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147942/149.wav", + "text": "來讓大學寫答案嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147942/150.wav", + "text": "游揆" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147942/151.wav", + "text": "各位校長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147942/152.wav", + "text": "我講的游揆不是現在的游錫堃院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147942/153.wav", + "text": "而是當行政院長時" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147942/154.wav", + "text": "的游錫堃院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147942/155.wav", + "text": "公教分離" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147942/156.wav", + "text": "行政法人化" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147942/157.wav", + "text": "他甚至講出這些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147942/158.wav", + "text": "簡單的講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147942/159.wav", + "text": "當然這個我長期都有跟部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147942/160.wav", + "text": "我們要出那麼多的題目" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147942/161.wav", + "text": "來讓大學解答" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147942/162.wav", + "text": "可是彼此之間對接得不是很好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147942/163.wav", + "text": "甚至我們真的要談大學自主" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147942/164.wav", + "text": "我不瞞各位說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147942/165.wav", + "text": "讓政府的角色" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147942/166.wav", + "text": "其實就是讓大學可以真正的往法人化" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147942/167.wav", + "text": "你說要公共" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147942/168.wav", + "text": "也沒有問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147942/169.wav", + "text": "教育部的手能不能夠少一點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147942/170.wav", + "text": "甚至不用耗費" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147942/171.wav", + "text": "去幫大學出題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147942/172.wav", + "text": "因為現場難得有這麼重要領導" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147942/173.wav", + "text": "你覺得是不是這樣比較好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147942/174.wav", + "text": "不要讓我們都是教育部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147942/175.wav", + "text": "大學" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147942/176.wav", + "text": "支持高教" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147942/177.wav", + "text": "和管理能不能鬆綁" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147942/178.wav", + "text": "有沒有這樣子的方向" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147942/179.wav", + "text": "你覺得呢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147942/180.wav", + "text": "真的有幫助" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147942/181.wav", + "text": "要刪除那個一定要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147942/182.wav", + "text": "我們沒有要刪除我們是支持的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147942/183.wav", + "text": "沈校長當時成大" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147942/184.wav", + "text": "曾試辦過法人化" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147942/185.wav", + "text": "你覺得是不是要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147942/186.wav", + "text": "共出資沒有問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147942/187.wav", + "text": "特別的說了當時" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147942/188.wav", + "text": "游錫堃當行政院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147942/189.wav", + "text": "希望公教分離行政法人化" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147942/190.wav", + "text": "而且當時成大也有試辦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147942/191.wav", + "text": "校長覺得這樣好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147942/192.wav", + "text": "我們前前任校長為了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147942/193.wav", + "text": "法人化" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147942/194.wav", + "text": "當時他對成大一百零多個系所一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147942/195.wav", + "text": "我想那個時候的時空背景" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147942/196.wav", + "text": "就沒有成功的實施" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147942/197.wav", + "text": "其實現在教育部對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147942/198.wav", + "text": "自主也給予相當大的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147942/199.wav", + "text": "彈性至少這是我現在當校長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147942/200.wav", + "text": "要法人化或要如何提升" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147942/201.wav", + "text": "根據現在的背景重新來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147942/202.wav", + "text": "考慮" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147942/203.wav", + "text": "希望各位校長都有機會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147942/204.wav", + "text": "大學法人化這個議題在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147942/205.wav", + "text": "美國日本香港" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147942/206.wav", + "text": "尤其校長您是從國外對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147942/207.wav", + "text": "我在美國任教二十多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147942/208.wav", + "text": "年這個議題也" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147942/209.wav", + "text": "討論了很久當然美國" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147942/210.wav", + "text": "有50個州每個州政府" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147942/211.wav", + "text": "大學自主" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147942/212.wav", + "text": "的方式都有一些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147942/213.wav", + "text": "不一樣對他們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147942/214.wav", + "text": "UCLAUC Berkeley就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147942/215.wav", + "text": "公法人學校但是它還是有很標準" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147942/216.wav", + "text": "的States University" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147942/217.wav", + "text": "它還有私校系統比如南加" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147942/218.wav", + "text": "大這種所以它是3個系統" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147942/219.wav", + "text": "都存在我們是不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147942/220.wav", + "text": "報告您看美國的像日本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147942/221.wav", + "text": "全部都完成法人化了當時他們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147942/222.wav", + "text": "在講法人化時跟臺灣是同" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147942/223.wav", + "text": "京都大學到東北大學全部都是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147942/224.wav", + "text": "有過去沒有完成的經驗" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147942/225.wav", + "text": "是不是應該這樣因為這樣才能" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147942/226.wav", + "text": "真的讓大學自主就是公共出資" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147942/227.wav", + "text": "但是經營管理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147942/228.wav", + "text": "由大學自主這樣會不會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147942/229.wav", + "text": "更好校長對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147942/230.wav", + "text": "這些國家的經驗來講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147942/231.wav", + "text": "法人化可以多元化的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147942/232.wav", + "text": "去探索並不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147942/233.wav", + "text": "二選一的這種方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147942/234.wav", + "text": "陽明交通大學林校長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147942/235.wav", + "text": "林校長因為之前前校長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147942/236.wav", + "text": "說不要都只有教育部大學" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147942/237.wav", + "text": "校長怎麼看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147942/238.wav", + "text": "我覺得這有兩個面向第一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147942/239.wav", + "text": "的日本朋友在大學" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147942/240.wav", + "text": "學校的營運方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147942/241.wav", + "text": "獨立法人時沒有改變還是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147942/242.wav", + "text": "以校務會議的方式來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147942/243.wav", + "text": "指導單位所以他們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147942/244.wav", + "text": "現在感覺有點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147942/245.wav", + "text": "的達到行政法人化" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147942/246.wav", + "text": "的目的這是第一點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147942/247.wav", + "text": "\n第二點他們也提到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147942/248.wav", + "text": "似乎因為這樣的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147942/249.wav", + "text": "改變" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147942/250.wav", + "text": "高等教育的補助" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147942/251.wav", + "text": "回過頭來看希望當時" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147942/252.wav", + "text": "在設立這個的時候能夠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147942/253.wav", + "text": "有一些些的保障以上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147942/254.wav", + "text": "對於高教的付出" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147942/255.wav", + "text": "其實我自己" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147942/256.wav", + "text": "我始終有很深的感受" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147942/257.wav", + "text": "對國家貢獻那麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147942/258.wav", + "text": "多可是常常有一個問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147942/259.wav", + "text": "反而保障得比別人更少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147942/260.wav", + "text": "因為我們在立法院有一個經驗" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147942/261.wav", + "text": "我們覺得每一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147942/262.wav", + "text": "性都比我們更高高" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147942/263.wav", + "text": "大家都兢兢業業的在做研究" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147942/264.wav", + "text": "反而對自己的權益" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147942/265.wav", + "text": "有機會能夠夠表達他們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147942/266.wav", + "text": "心聲\n部長我們也知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147942/267.wav", + "text": "這個我們完全承認但是我們也希望" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147942/268.wav", + "text": "很多我今天也就不多囉嗦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147942/269.wav", + "text": "百年樹人因為這是我們最重要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147942/270.wav", + "text": "繼續的精進好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147942/271.wav", + "text": "謝謝部長不好意思我跟委員補充" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147942/272.wav", + "text": "一下就好確實委員所" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147942/273.wav", + "text": "指成的方向也是教育部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147942/274.wav", + "text": "這幾年持續努力的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147942/275.wav", + "text": "就像高教深耕計畫其實" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147942/276.wav", + "text": "發展為主體的思考" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147942/277.wav", + "text": "這裡面沒有太多的細節" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147942/278.wav", + "text": "要求就是希望用學校這個概念" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147942/279.wav", + "text": "第二個這次要謝謝大院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147942/280.wav", + "text": "創新條例其實這" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147942/281.wav", + "text": "能藉由這個發展來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147942/282.wav", + "text": "來解開過去太多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147942/283.wav", + "text": "法規對於大學辦學的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147942/284.wav", + "text": "我們會持續朝向讓大學" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147942/285.wav", + "text": "有更大的自主空間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147942/286.wav", + "text": "好我們會繼續支持所有大專院校的預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147942/287.wav", + "text": "好謝謝謝謝部長請回" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147942/288.wav", + "text": "謝謝張其祿委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147942/289.wav", + "text": "\n現在請萬美玲委員質詢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147941/0.wav", + "text": "謝謝主席我們邀請交通部王國材王部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147941/1.wav", + "text": "邱委員好部長直接切入重點我想7年來臺灣的交通亂象越演越烈" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147941/2.wav", + "text": "以111年比較105年其實車輛數只成長了6.2%" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147941/3.wav", + "text": "但是車禍數卻成長了23%死傷的人數也成長了23.8%" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147941/4.wav", + "text": "如果再以111年對照97年的數據車禍數跟死傷人數都暴增了1.2倍" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147941/5.wav", + "text": "整個的案件從17萬件成長到37.6萬件" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147941/6.wav", + "text": "死傷人數從22.97萬人增加到50.22萬人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147941/7.wav", + "text": "這不是經濟成長率這是死傷成長率所以這是非常嚴重的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147941/8.wav", + "text": "\n交通部投入這麼多的預算今天終於把交通道路安全基本法提出" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147941/9.wav", + "text": "在態度上我們給予肯定但是很多的內容我們必須回到一個重點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147941/10.wav", + "text": "其實剛剛很多委員也提到中央與地方政府必須要同心協力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147941/11.wav", + "text": "也要能夠把相關的政策落實到基層人民的教育也是一個重點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147941/12.wav", + "text": "所以只靠一邊是沒有用的\n我想先就教一個問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147941/13.wav", + "text": "新北市中和的一個主要幹道景平路的一個路口" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147941/14.wav", + "text": "這個路口的標線型人行道劃設得對不對以現在目前看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147941/15.wav", + "text": "但是我覺得它已經是設法劃出一個人行道讓人家走" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147941/16.wav", + "text": "但是的確它本身在劃設上比如如果行人在走車子在進出本身會有衝突" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147941/17.wav", + "text": "對沒有錯所以這個就是我們剛剛看到這是一個實際的案例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147941/18.wav", + "text": "這個就是政策計畫與實際執行上的一個落差" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147941/19.wav", + "text": "尤其這種政府不當的交通規劃設施���實很容易就造成交通事故的主要原因之一" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147941/20.wav", + "text": "萬一發生車禍這個就是很直接的一個問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147941/21.wav", + "text": "因為你看這個加油站的車可能要進出還有自行車行人在走" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147941/22.wav", + "text": "到底進去加油要怎麼出來如果照規定的話是不是又變成要穿越人行道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147941/23.wav", + "text": "甚至可能會撞上行人或自行車這個就是執行上的一個落差" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147941/24.wav", + "text": "\n我們的法律修正之後地方政府怎麼執行這是一個重點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147941/25.wav", + "text": "包含其實我現在看起來就是中央地方政府互相甩鍋" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147941/26.wav", + "text": "很多時候如果這個事情有兩個人以上負責就是沒有人負責" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147941/27.wav", + "text": "這一次我們也是希望避免掉這個修法的盲點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147941/28.wav", + "text": "所以這個是沒有針對道路設計規劃入法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147941/29.wav", + "text": "也沒有納入道路建設管理機關責任的主要原因" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147941/30.wav", + "text": "\n我們現在回到看這次修法的重點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147941/31.wav", + "text": "我們認為有一些指標性的KPI應該還是要納入到整個上位法的精神裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147941/32.wav", + "text": "尤其交通部對外承諾道安改善目標是2030年7年內道安死亡人數要降低30%" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147941/33.wav", + "text": "本席認為這個目標太保守距離交通零死亡願景太遠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147941/34.wav", + "text": "民眾黨團就是我的版本本席的版本要求5年內每10萬人口的死亡數" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147941/35.wav", + "text": "應該降至10人以下10年內應該降至5人以下接近先進國家標準" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147941/36.wav", + "text": "請問部長是否同意這個標準來入法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147941/37.wav", + "text": "的道路交通安全政策基本法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147941/38.wav", + "text": "也是實施了幾十年慢慢有成果出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147941/39.wav", + "text": "我們有算過我想我們第一階段還是以2030" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147941/40.wav", + "text": "我覺得太保守了我覺得要態度出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147941/41.wav", + "text": "你不能這個東西跟日本這樣比你的死亡人數是人家6倍" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147941/42.wav", + "text": "你如果以人口數經濟條件與整個國家開發程度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147941/43.wav", + "text": "我們是落後國家交通安全的一個環境這個沒有道理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147941/44.wav", + "text": "我們當然就是目標" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147941/45.wav", + "text": "而且既然你要展現出政府的一個態度你這個目標不能定那麼低" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147941/46.wav", + "text": "KPI定太低了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147941/47.wav", + "text": "2030年7年內才降低30%" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147941/48.wav", + "text": "5年內每10萬人口我們要求降至10人以下這有困難嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147941/49.wav", + "text": "還是你認為會超過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147941/50.wav", + "text": "它7年就是每年大概5%" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147941/51.wav", + "text": "我們不要講percent數我們講人數我們講人數絕對值" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147941/52.wav", + "text": "的確邱委員談到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147941/53.wav", + "text": "每10萬人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147941/54.wav", + "text": "10人以下有沒有辦法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147941/55.wav", + "text": "��死是一個目標我們我們來討論一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147941/56.wav", + "text": "好不好這一次修法這是我們表達的重點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147941/57.wav", + "text": "\n第二個本席認為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147941/58.wav", + "text": "還有一個重點就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147941/59.wav", + "text": "者我們認為還是應該跟地方政府精準打擊分級分流" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147941/60.wav", + "text": "譬如說1公里500公尺800公尺還是2公里" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147941/61.wav", + "text": "其實都是弱勢行人行走的密集區域" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147941/62.wav", + "text": "這個部分有沒有辦法做到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147941/63.wav", + "text": "是我跟委員報告剛剛有提到基本法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147941/64.wav", + "text": "下面有數十個作用法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147941/65.wav", + "text": "我們會在作用法裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147941/66.wav", + "text": "比如說在市區道路及附屬工程設計規範裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147941/67.wav", + "text": "要不要規範這個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147941/68.wav", + "text": "但是我們的訴求也沒有很多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147941/69.wav", + "text": "就是把幾個重點抓出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147941/70.wav", + "text": "第一個是KPI第二個弱勢行人交通寧靜區" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147941/71.wav", + "text": "第三個我們要納入公民監督" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147941/72.wav", + "text": "跟人民參與的機制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147941/73.wav", + "text": "這是我們這次修法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147941/74.wav", + "text": "版本跟你們最大的不同上位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147941/75.wav", + "text": "上位法基本上是一個態度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147941/76.wav", + "text": "如果你有把這些納進去的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147941/77.wav", + "text": "但是剛剛我們看到中和景平路那個狀況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147941/78.wav", + "text": "就是地方政府的認知跟你們有落差" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147941/79.wav", + "text": "執行上就像你們一直說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147941/80.wav", + "text": "地方政府要努力一點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147941/81.wav", + "text": "是不是掌握不夠確實" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147941/82.wav", + "text": "因為你的法的態度就不夠明確" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147941/83.wav", + "text": "啊既然今天道路交通安全基本法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147941/84.wav", + "text": "這個上位法出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147941/85.wav", + "text": "你應該把KPI都訂定進去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147941/86.wav", + "text": "啊首先執行方向" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147941/87.wav", + "text": "譬如說我們剛剛講每10萬人的人數" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147941/88.wav", + "text": "第二個通學巷交通寧靜區" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147941/89.wav", + "text": "這個是政府宣示態度的一個重點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147941/90.wav", + "text": "第三個應該把學者的建議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147941/91.wav", + "text": "最後就是要把交通3E" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147941/92.wav", + "text": "這樣的態度納進去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147941/93.wav", + "text": "我想到執法端提高罰則加強稽查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147941/94.wav", + "text": "新的道路規劃" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147941/95.wav", + "text": "要以人本交通為原則" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147941/96.wav", + "text": "但是最重要的還是教育" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147941/97.wav", + "text": "教育的部分是不是應該納入" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147941/98.wav", + "text": "就教部長希望可以納入這次修法的重點跟條文裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147941/99.wav", + "text": "跟邱委員報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147941/100.wav", + "text": "有一個基本法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147941/101.wav", + "text": "下面數十個作用法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147941/102.wav", + "text": "巷要放在哪一個作用法裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147941/103.wav", + "text": "我們會把它寫清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147941/104.wav", + "text": "如果有把它放入" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147941/105.wav", + "text": "尤其在相關的條文裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147941/106.wav", + "text": "如果你有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147941/107.wav", + "text": "通學巷弱勢行人優先" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147941/108.wav", + "text": "這部分你們去評估一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147941/109.wav", + "text": "到時候實際審查法案的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147941/110.wav", + "text": "我們我們會提出我們的訴求" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147941/111.wav", + "text": "\n最後本席認為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147941/112.wav", + "text": "既然歐洲能日本能韓國也能" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147941/113.wav", + "text": "做到每10萬人口死亡人數5人以下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147941/114.wav", + "text": "日本甚至在3人以下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147941/115.wav", + "text": "臺灣不管是經濟條件人口結構" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147941/116.wav", + "text": "我們都符合先進國家的標準" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147941/117.wav", + "text": "所以不應該在基本的食衣安全住行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147941/118.wav", + "text": "這個行的問題沒有辦法跟上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147941/119.wav", + "text": "臺灣沒有推拖的本錢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147941/120.wav", + "text": "我希望政府可以仁民愛物" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147941/121.wav", + "text": "還是以保障行人的路權為主" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147941/122.wav", + "text": "還是把態度展現出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147941/123.wav", + "text": "這也是部長這一任非常重要的任務" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147941/124.wav", + "text": "以上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147940/0.wav", + "text": "請部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147940/1.wav", + "text": "剛剛許委員的質詢裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147940/2.wav", + "text": "這個宣導車全國有幾輛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147940/3.wav", + "text": "6輛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147940/4.wav", + "text": "全國6輛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147940/5.wav", + "text": "我的意思是說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147940/6.wav", + "text": "第一個先盤點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147940/7.wav", + "text": "你說有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147940/8.wav", + "text": "到底我們做到多少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147940/9.wav", + "text": "做到什麼程度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147940/10.wav", + "text": "6輛本身又是什麼樣的車" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147940/11.wav", + "text": "車裡面的設備" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147940/12.wav", + "text": "還有宣導的教案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147940/13.wav", + "text": "還有它到底是到哪裡去宣導" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147940/14.wav", + "text": "跟哪些民間團體合作" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147940/15.wav", + "text": "或者是到哪些學校去宣導" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147940/16.wav", + "text": "這個你可不可以事後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147940/17.wav", + "text": "給我一個書面報告好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147940/18.wav", + "text": "你總是要先盤點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147940/19.wav", + "text": "你才知道怎麼精進" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147940/20.wav", + "text": "對不對好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147940/21.wav", + "text": "我們今天要談的是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147940/22.wav", + "text": "道路交通安全基本法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147940/23.wav", + "text": "我想還路於民是大家的共識" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147940/24.wav", + "text": "還路於民的前提就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147940/25.wav", + "text": "人車大家都要安全" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147940/26.wav", + "text": "所以我一向的主張是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147940/27.wav", + "text": "人本還有人車法規" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147940/28.wav", + "text": "還有道路的設計規劃等等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147940/29.wav", + "text": "這個都是今天很多委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147940/30.wav", + "text": "所關心的面向" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147940/31.wav", + "text": "大家都支持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147940/32.wav", + "text": "但是最困難的是什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147940/33.wav", + "text": "法規面工程面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147940/34.wav", + "text": "還有如何落實如何執行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147940/35.wav", + "text": "我大概盤點的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147940/36.wav", + "text": "有那麼多的法規" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147940/37.wav", + "text": "有那麼多的子法規" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147940/38.wav", + "text": "也聽到很多委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147940/39.wav", + "text": "包括委員提到的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147940/40.wav", + "text": "我們現在騎樓管理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147940/41.wav", + "text": "怎麼管理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147940/42.wav", + "text": "是地方還是中央" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147940/43.wav", + "text": "可以透過這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147940/44.wav", + "text": "通過之後就能夠解決嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147940/45.wav", + "text": "或者是大家關心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147940/46.wav", + "text": "最近昨天發生的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147940/47.wav", + "text": "遊覽車事件" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147940/48.wav", + "text": "砂石車煞" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147940/49.wav", + "text": "造成了重大的交通事故" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147940/50.wav", + "text": "大型車的管理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147940/51.wav", + "text": "遊覽車的管理等等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147940/52.wav", + "text": "透過這個基本法的通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147940/53.wav", + "text": "就能夠解決問題嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147940/54.wav", + "text": "還有我們剛剛有委員提到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147940/55.wav", + "text": "違規的罰款" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147940/56.wav", + "text": "收入分配及運用辦法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147940/57.wav", + "text": "我們現在是不是要求" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147940/58.wav", + "text": "地方政府要專款專用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147940/59.wav", + "text": "或者是很多委員在關心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147940/60.wav", + "text": "設計規範也好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147940/61.wav", + "text": "能不能全國統一" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147940/62.wav", + "text": "還是要因地制宜" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147940/63.wav", + "text": "其實這些這麼多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147940/64.wav", + "text": "大大小小的問題都在於" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147940/65.wav", + "text": "全國人民都在等著希望" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147940/66.wav", + "text": "在行政院行人交通" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147940/67.wav", + "text": "安全的政策綱領之下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147940/68.wav", + "text": "我們有院版的道路" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147940/69.wav", + "text": "交通安全基本法的版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147940/70.wav", + "text": "但是第一個我們如何落實" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147940/71.wav", + "text": "所以我剛剛第一" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147940/72.wav", + "text": "個我們盤點了沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147940/73.wav", + "text": "相關的法規要修正了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147940/74.wav", + "text": "要盤點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147940/75.wav", + "text": "\n第二個我們要怎麼樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147940/76.wav", + "text": "給人民一個時程表" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147940/77.wav", + "text": "我今天這個基本法通過之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147940/78.wav", + "text": "未來行政院在交通部的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147940/79.wav", + "text": "領導之下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147940/80.wav", + "text": "怎麼做才能夠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147940/81.wav", + "text": "達到人民的期待" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147940/82.wav", + "text": "期程又在哪裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147940/83.wav", + "text": "我今天要提醒的是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147940/84.wav", + "text": "不是一個基本法通過了之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147940/85.wav", + "text": "所有的問題都能夠解決" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147940/86.wav", + "text": "部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147940/87.wav", + "text": "是我對召委" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147940/88.wav", + "text": "這張圖非常敬佩" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147940/89.wav", + "text": "這是我們的精神" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147940/90.wav", + "text": "基本法是一個上位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147940/91.wav", + "text": "旁邊我們都統稱叫作用法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147940/92.wav", + "text": "所謂訂定了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147940/93.wav", + "text": "包括各個中央政府" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147940/94.wav", + "text": "地方政府與各部會的責任" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147940/95.wav", + "text": "但是它個別回去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147940/96.wav", + "text": "是各有責任" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147940/97.wav", + "text": "但是權責的劃分能不能明確" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147940/98.wav", + "text": "然後各自在各自的子法規" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147940/99.wav", + "text": "相關的子法規裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147940/100.wav", + "text": "如何能夠調整" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147940/101.wav", + "text": "如何能夠落實" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147940/102.wav", + "text": "要讓人民有感" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147940/103.wav", + "text": "這才是最重要的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147940/104.wav", + "text": "大家期待那麼大" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147940/105.wav", + "text": "道路交通安全基本法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147940/106.wav", + "text": "大家期待很大" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147940/107.wav", + "text": "是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147940/108.wav", + "text": "作用法的檢討" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147940/109.wav", + "text": "是要納在基本法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147940/110.wav", + "text": "我覺得非常支持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147940/111.wav", + "text": "我聽到各個委員不分黨派" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147940/112.wav", + "text": "大家都希望道路交通安全" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147940/113.wav", + "text": "很重要很重要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147940/114.wav", + "text": "行人車輛管理等等都要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147940/115.wav", + "text": "不是一個基本法通過之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147940/116.wav", + "text": "好像國人的期待" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147940/117.wav", + "text": "就會達到滿足了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147940/118.wav", + "text": "國人的期待" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147940/119.wav", + "text": "作為主責單位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147940/120.wav", + "text": "你要給我們一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147940/121.wav", + "text": "你要如何盤點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147940/122.wav", + "text": "要求其他部會如何配合" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147940/123.wav", + "text": "調整修訂的期程表" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147940/124.wav", + "text": "未來我們要達到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147940/125.wav", + "text": "什麼樣的目標" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147940/126.wav", + "text": "我覺得這個才是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147940/127.wav", + "text": "最重要的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147940/128.wav", + "text": "對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147940/129.wav", + "text": "我再給你一點點時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147940/130.wav", + "text": "召委講得很對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147940/131.wav", + "text": "基本法沒辦法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147940/132.wav", + "text": "把很多在作用法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147940/133.wav", + "text": "或是你剛才談的子法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147940/134.wav", + "text": "把東西都丟到這裡來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147940/135.wav", + "text": "這變得很龐大" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147940/136.wav", + "text": "我覺得這次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147940/137.wav", + "text": "還有幾位委員提到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147940/138.wav", + "text": "就是作用法的檢討" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147940/139.wav", + "text": "在基本法裡面定下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147940/140.wav", + "text": "我覺得非常支持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147940/141.wav", + "text": "我想這一部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147940/142.wav", + "text": "我們會就" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147940/143.wav", + "text": "該檢討哪些作用法部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147940/144.wav", + "text": "至少在說明欄裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147940/145.wav", + "text": "你在什麼時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147940/146.wav", + "text": "最少在說明欄裡面盤點出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147940/147.wav", + "text": "是我們再來處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147940/148.wav", + "text": "我覺得非常好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147940/149.wav", + "text": "接下來審查的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147940/150.wav", + "text": "\n第二個時程表" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147940/151.wav", + "text": "所謂的時程表就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147940/152.wav", + "text": "交通部自己要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147940/153.wav", + "text": "有盤點之外" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147940/154.wav", + "text": "自己要有想法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147940/155.wav", + "text": "還有跟各部會的配合" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147940/156.wav", + "text": "各部會又如何來配合" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147940/157.wav", + "text": "時程裡面來配合" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147940/158.wav", + "text": "我覺得這樣子才是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147940/159.wav", + "text": "負責任的做法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147940/160.wav", + "text": "不然我們會辜負國人的期待" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147940/161.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147940/162.wav", + "text": "我們事實上現在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147940/163.wav", + "text": "也是在盤點相關子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147940/164.wav", + "text": "或是這個作用法的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147940/165.wav", + "text": "所以下一次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147940/166.wav", + "text": "我們逐條審查的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147940/167.wav", + "text": "我希望可以看到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147940/168.wav", + "text": "我今天的要求" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147940/169.wav", + "text": "我們有一些方向" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147940/170.wav", + "text": "很多的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147940/171.wav", + "text": "比如隨便講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147940/172.wav", + "text": "地方的自治條例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147940/173.wav", + "text": "什麼時候做好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147940/174.wav", + "text": "我們頂多給它一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147940/175.wav", + "text": "幾年內做好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147940/176.wav", + "text": "沒辦法定下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147940/177.wav", + "text": "我當然知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147940/178.wav", + "text": "但是地方" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147940/179.wav", + "text": "政府地方自治的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147940/180.wav", + "text": "你要給予時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147940/181.wav", + "text": "我們其他部會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147940/182.wav", + "text": "相關的法律" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147940/183.wav", + "text": "也要給時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147940/184.wav", + "text": "但是我們自己相關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147940/185.wav", + "text": "中央部會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147940/186.wav", + "text": "給的時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147940/187.wav", + "text": "就不能太離譜地長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147940/188.wav", + "text": "就要要求" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147940/189.wav", + "text": "所以我們應該是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147940/190.wav", + "text": "在某一個期限內" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147940/191.wav", + "text": "要把哪一些的作用法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147940/192.wav", + "text": "做一個檢討" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147940/193.wav", + "text": "是嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147940/194.wav", + "text": "這個才是負責任的做法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147940/195.wav", + "text": "很好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147940/196.wav", + "text": "不然現在國人期待" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147940/197.wav", + "text": "好像一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147940/198.wav", + "text": "通過了之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147940/199.wav", + "text": "什麼問題都能夠解決嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147940/200.wav", + "text": "不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147940/201.wav", + "text": "這要跟人民說清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147940/202.wav", + "text": "而且要讓國人的期待" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147940/203.wav", + "text": "是能夠落實的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147940/204.wav", + "text": "這是第一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147940/205.wav", + "text": "第二個我覺得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147940/206.wav", + "text": "事權的統一" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147940/207.wav", + "text": "我們現在提出" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147940/208.wav", + "text": "基本法的草案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147940/209.wav", + "text": "有納六都" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147940/210.wav", + "text": "中央道路交通安全會報" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147940/211.wav", + "text": "由行政院長擔任召集人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147940/212.wav", + "text": "你剛剛有說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147940/213.wav", + "text": "現在不只是直轄市的代表" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147940/214.wav", + "text": "你剛剛說是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147940/215.wav", + "text": "各地方政府" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147940/216.wav", + "text": "各級地方政府" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147940/217.wav", + "text": "對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147940/218.wav", + "text": "對啊我們現在檢討" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147940/219.wav", + "text": "是覺得全部進來好了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147940/220.wav", + "text": "全部進來嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147940/221.wav", + "text": "對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147940/222.wav", + "text": "好全部進來了之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147940/223.wav", + "text": "我們如何事權統一" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147940/224.wav", + "text": "基本法裡面有明定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147940/225.wav", + "text": "各要各負的責任" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147940/226.wav", + "text": "各要各做的事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147940/227.wav", + "text": "我剛剛在我的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147940/228.wav", + "text": "提案說明裡面有提到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147940/229.wav", + "text": "我的版本裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147940/230.wav", + "text": "我是建議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147940/231.wav", + "text": "把這個安全會報" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147940/232.wav", + "text": "道安會報" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147940/233.wav", + "text": "把它明確化" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147940/234.wav", + "text": "所以我在我的版本裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147940/235.wav", + "text": "有入法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147940/236.wav", + "text": "司長在做報告的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147940/237.wav", + "text": "是說不用啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147940/238.wav", + "text": "但是我覺得這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147940/239.wav", + "text": "我們可以再討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147940/240.wav", + "text": "好我們再討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147940/241.wav", + "text": "好最後時間的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147940/242.wav", + "text": "我們的4年400億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147940/243.wav", + "text": "甚至內政部國土署" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147940/244.wav", + "text": "說不是只有400億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147940/245.wav", + "text": "甚至600多億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147940/246.wav", + "text": "問題是光是在交通部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147940/247.wav", + "text": "主導的這4年400億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147940/248.wav", + "text": "有這個預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147940/249.wav", + "text": "短中長期的行人交通安全" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147940/250.wav", + "text": "政策綱領" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147940/251.wav", + "text": "提出4年400億的預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147940/252.wav", + "text": "問題是我到現在還問不到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147940/253.wav", + "text": "你們告訴我" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147940/254.wav", + "text": "是要分配型還是競爭型" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147940/255.wav", + "text": "要釋出給各地方政府去執行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147940/256.wav", + "text": "部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147940/257.wav", + "text": "我們明年的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147940/258.wav", + "text": "已經提出703個路口" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147940/259.wav", + "text": "703個路口" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147940/260.wav", + "text": "是你們自己盤點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147940/261.wav", + "text": "其中跟地方政府" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147940/262.wav", + "text": "我們盤點1,000個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147940/263.wav", + "text": "然後跟他們討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147940/264.wav", + "text": "最後確定在703個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147940/265.wav", + "text": "最後確定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147940/266.wav", + "text": "最近確定703個路口" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147940/267.wav", + "text": "明年要完成的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147940/268.wav", + "text": "總共是用多少錢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147940/269.wav", + "text": "703個多少錢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147940/270.wav", + "text": "他們計畫要提" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147940/271.wav", + "text": "我們現在就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147940/272.wav", + "text": "只要它提出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147940/273.wav", + "text": "我們就補助" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147940/274.wav", + "text": "所以不是競爭型的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147940/275.wav", + "text": "現在事實上他們提的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147940/276.wav", + "text": "還不如我們想像多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147940/277.wav", + "text": "比方提1,00" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147940/278.wav", + "text": "0它要做大概700多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147940/279.wav", + "text": "我們現在還在鼓勵" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147940/280.wav", + "text": "原因在哪裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147940/281.wav", + "text": "你們當初" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147940/282.wav", + "text": "喊出4年400億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147940/283.wav", + "text": "是怎麼樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147940/284.wav", + "text": "有這個數字出來的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147940/285.wav", + "text": "你既然現在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147940/286.wav", + "text": "給我一個答案是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147940/287.wav", + "text": "地方政府提出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147940/288.wav", + "text": "要改善的路口" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147940/289.wav", + "text": "不如我們想像中的多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147940/290.wav", + "text": "跟召委報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147940/291.wav", + "text": "地方政府" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147940/292.wav", + "text": "也應該更積極" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147940/293.wav", + "text": "我們中央這麼積極" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147940/294.wav", + "text": "把錢也補貼了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147940/295.wav", + "text": "當然他們在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147940/296.wav", + "text": "實施這些訓練設施改善" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147940/297.wav", + "text": "可能碰到有些困難" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147940/298.wav", + "text": "我剛才講703" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147940/299.wav", + "text": "個是明年底要完工的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147940/300.wav", + "text": "明年底要完工" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147940/301.wav", + "text": "703處的路口" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147940/302.wav", + "text": "都是各地方政府出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147940/303.wav", + "text": "給我一個書面資料" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147940/304.wav", + "text": "我們來討論一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147940/305.wav", + "text": "為什麼地方政府" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147940/306.wav", + "text": "竟然比中央想的還要少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147940/307.wav", + "text": "到底怎麼樣去規劃" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147940/308.wav", + "text": "分配這些預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147940/309.wav", + "text": "我們定的標準門檻" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147940/310.wav", + "text": "到底是什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147940/311.wav", + "text": "我剛剛講補助的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147940/312.wav", + "text": "門檻要求是什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147940/313.wav", + "text": "我覺得這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147940/314.wav", + "text": "其實要講清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147940/315.wav", + "text": "好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147940/316.wav", + "text": "我接下來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147940/317.wav", + "text": "其他的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147940/318.wav", + "text": "我再書面好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147940/319.wav", + "text": "謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147939/0.wav", + "text": "部長好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147939/1.wav", + "text": "也聽了不少人對於行人路權的意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147939/2.wav", + "text": "現在交通部有沒有這個概念要處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147939/3.wav", + "text": "現在我們比較主要的博物館是鐵路博物館" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147939/4.wav", + "text": "縣市政府也有一些像兒童交通博物館" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147939/5.wav", + "text": "或是交通公園這類的目前是這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147939/6.wav", + "text": "臺北市以前有現在已經沒了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147939/7.wav", + "text": "現在設在哪裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147939/8.wav", + "text": "對啊現在已經改了現在我們高雄鳳山也要設一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147939/9.wav", + "text": "就像你看的那些圖片" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147939/10.wav", + "text": "部長可以參考一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147939/11.wav", + "text": "兒童交通博物館的重點在體驗" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147939/12.wav", + "text": "那個都是模擬現狀" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147939/13.wav", + "text": "就是在博物館中一個很大的空間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147939/14.wav", + "text": "可以開車還有道路" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147939/15.wav", + "text": "就乾脆帶來這裡玩" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147939/16.wav", + "text": "類似這樣子的設施不知道部長有沒有去考察過或有沒有這樣的概念" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147939/17.wav", + "text": "我看過很多兒童交通公園" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147939/18.wav", + "text": "博物館主要是臺北市汀州路" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147939/19.wav", + "text": "後來變成由民間經營" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147939/20.wav", + "text": "對此我個人是非常的支持就是說從小教育" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147939/21.wav", + "text": "讓他知道這個環境有那種感覺" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147939/22.wav", + "text": "我是非常支持這樣的一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147939/23.wav", + "text": "你看這個蠟筆小新圖還滿好玩的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147939/24.wav", + "text": "那事實上前面這個小朋友你怎麼可以往後看呢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147939/25.wav", + "text": "這個都是交通安全的場景那其實他就是在玩" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147939/26.wav", + "text": "我是覺得如果有一個這樣子的場域" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147939/27.wav", + "text": "讓小朋友假日就可以去玩" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147939/28.wav", + "text": "小朋友玩得開心又可以寓教於樂" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147939/29.wav", + "text": "我不知道部長覺得這個想法可不可行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147939/30.wav", + "text": "很好滿好的事實上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147939/31.wav", + "text": "我是覺得大家可以把最好或是國外的經驗納進來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147939/32.wav", + "text": "但是他們的內容更實務我覺得滿好的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147939/33.wav", + "text": "我們再回來看賴清德副總統提出的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147939/34.wav", + "text": "行人路權政見─秉持以人為本智慧科技" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147939/35.wav", + "text": "兩大原則希望2030年將死亡率降低50%" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147939/36.wav", + "text": "達到零死亡目標對這個部分以交通部的角度您覺得可行嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147939/37.wav", + "text": "應該是2030年行人死亡率降低50%" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147939/38.wav", + "text": "然後所有的死亡率降低30%" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147939/39.wav", + "text": "目前我們訂的大概是類似這樣的目標" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147939/40.wav", + "text": "我們全力以赴" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147939/41.wav", + "text": "因為我看到交通部事實上也做了一些事" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147939/42.wav", + "text": "比如在今年的8月我們也推動了一些道安" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147939/43.wav", + "text": "安完成了357公里行人道的建置" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147939/44.wav", + "text": "包括明年的現在有703個路口都已經與地方討論完畢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147939/45.wav", + "text": "畢明年一年內完成都已經在處理了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147939/46.wav", + "text": "這方面的執行的確是有進步" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147939/47.wav", + "text": "在這中間就是持續一直降" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147939/48.wav", + "text": "我希望能有一個規劃" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147939/49.wav", + "text": "讓我們也可以看看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147939/50.wav", + "text": "是不是有按照規劃的程序" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147939/51.wav", + "text": "交通部是不是可以對交通安全博物館" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147939/52.wav", + "text": "開始用一點心做規劃" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147939/53.wav", + "text": "我們看看日本的交通安全教育" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147939/54.wav", + "text": "其實真的是做得不錯" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147939/55.wav", + "text": "大家可以參考一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147939/56.wav", + "text": "你看他們的交通安全隊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147939/57.wav", + "text": "圖片左上方的這個叫做交通安全車" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147939/58.wav", + "text": "這個車子就是到各校園去做一些宣導" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147939/59.wav", + "text": "你可以看到他們做得很扎實" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147939/60.wav", + "text": "幼稚園一年至少一次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147939/61.wav", + "text": "每次至少一個小時" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147939/62.wav", + "text": "國小生是以步行者的角度為主" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147939/63.wav", + "text": "國中生以騎乘者角度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147939/64.wav", + "text": "高中生以騎乘機車的角度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147939/65.wav", + "text": "為主我要講的是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147939/66.wav", + "text": "這個是很有規劃的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147939/67.wav", + "text": "很有系統的在做交通安全的教育" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147939/68.wav", + "text": "這麼有系統的去做交通安全教育的規劃" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147939/69.wav", + "text": "我跟委員報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147939/70.wav", + "text": "現在監理所也有行動的監理車" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147939/71.wav", + "text": "看怎麼樣來讓它更精進" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147939/72.wav", + "text": "你看他最底下這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147939/73.wav", + "text": "你看它巡迴教育專車已經做到第四代了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147939/74.wav", + "text": "所以你可以看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147939/75.wav", + "text": "其實已經有讓它更豐富" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147939/76.wav", + "text": "我想我們也來參考對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147939/77.wav", + "text": "我的意思就是要做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147939/78.wav", + "text": "我是提供他們的資訊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147939/79.wav", + "text": "讓交通部能夠了解" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147939/80.wav", + "text": "很有系統的在做這一件事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147939/81.wav", + "text": "\n然後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147939/82.wav", + "text": "之前林佳龍還是部長的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147939/83.wav", + "text": "我也曾經問過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147939/84.wav", + "text": "有沒有考慮設陸海空鐵公路等等這些博物館" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147939/85.wav", + "text": "交通部現在有沒有這個思考" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147939/86.wav", + "text": "現在鐵道博物館很多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147939/87.wav", + "text": "鐵道博物館非常多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147939/88.wav", + "text": "南部就是屏東" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147939/89.wav", + "text": "航空博物館" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147939/90.wav", + "text": "對啦因為我曾經建議過在桃園機場" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147939/91.wav", + "text": "海洋博物館有民間設的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147939/92.wav", + "text": "所以我最後一個建議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147939/93.wav", + "text": "整合型的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147939/94.wav", + "text": "對高雄正好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147939/95.wav", + "text": "有陸軍官校海軍官校空軍官校" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147939/96.wav", + "text": "國防部還有一塊地叫做明德班" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147939/97.wav", + "text": "那塊地現在有在做古蹟修復" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147939/98.wav", + "text": "古蹟修復之外" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147939/99.wav", + "text": "如果是以交通部的角度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147939/100.wav", + "text": "甚至有兒童交通博物館" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147939/101.wav", + "text": "或者是公園" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147939/102.wav", + "text": "用這樣子的概念" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147939/103.wav", + "text": "剛才蠟筆小新那個玩法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147939/104.wav", + "text": "所以是不是就是在全國" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147939/105.wav", + "text": "它其實最後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147939/106.wav", + "text": "也會變成一個很好的觀光景點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147939/107.wav", + "text": "\n我剛剛給部���看那個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147939/108.wav", + "text": "這個小朋友是臺灣人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147939/109.wav", + "text": "他就是到日本去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147939/110.wav", + "text": "覺得很好玩他就下去玩了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147939/111.wav", + "text": "他們的小朋友也很多人去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147939/112.wav", + "text": "所以我是覺得這個概念" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147939/113.wav", + "text": "又可以做觀光" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147939/114.wav", + "text": "又可以做交通安全訓練教育等等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147939/115.wav", + "text": "的概念臺灣目前就是看不到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147939/116.wav", + "text": "我們就是去蒐集這個資訊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147939/117.wav", + "text": "給交通部參考" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147939/118.wav", + "text": "就是有沒有機會在臺灣可以看得到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147939/119.wav", + "text": "是不是請部長規劃一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147939/120.wav", + "text": "我想包含剛才談到道安的宣導車" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147939/121.wav", + "text": "或是兒童交通的公園等等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147939/122.wav", + "text": "我想我們繼續來精進" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147939/123.wav", + "text": "對希望部長可以規劃" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147939/124.wav", + "text": "好謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147938/0.wav", + "text": "委員好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147938/1.wav", + "text": "先前因為颱風接力侵臺" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147938/2.wav", + "text": "導致國內蔬菜價格居高不下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147938/3.wav", + "text": "昨天牛番茄秋葵" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147938/4.wav", + "text": "每公斤的批發進貨價是120" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147938/5.wav", + "text": "元甜椒150" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147938/6.wav", + "text": "元辣椒140" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147938/7.wav", + "text": "元玉米筍140" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147938/8.wav", + "text": "元青蔥235" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147938/9.wav", + "text": "元綠竹筍320" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147938/10.wav", + "text": "元臺北高麗菜的市場零售價" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147938/11.wav", + "text": "每台斤已經到120元到160元不等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147938/12.wav", + "text": "換算下來一顆還是要200元" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147938/13.wav", + "text": "颱風過去已經將近一個月" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147938/14.wav", + "text": "了農業部現在有沒有任何的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147938/15.wav", + "text": "產銷調節措施" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147938/16.wav", + "text": "因為菜價真的很高" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147938/17.wav", + "text": "非常謝謝委員關心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147938/18.wav", + "text": "一類是短期葉菜類" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147938/19.wav", + "text": "短期葉菜類復耕會比較快" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147938/20.wav", + "text": "大概是三個禮拜到四個禮拜就會出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147938/21.wav", + "text": "可能會達到兩個月左右" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147938/22.wav", + "text": "所以在這段過渡時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147938/23.wav", + "text": "可能我們本身對價格" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147938/24.wav", + "text": "下個月起蔬菜的價格會逐步回穩" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147938/25.wav", + "text": "對這是整體的價格" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147938/26.wav", + "text": "好我們先以葉菜" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147938/27.wav", + "text": "譬如高麗菜而言" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147938/28.wav", + "text": "可能回到什麼樣的價格" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147938/29.wav", + "text": "甚至你認為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147938/30.wav", + "text": "高麗菜的價格怎麼樣才合理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147938/31.wav", + "text": "現在高麗菜的價格" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147938/32.wav", + "text": "昨天二十一塊多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147938/33.wav", + "text": "過往的一般水平了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147938/34.wav", + "text": "還有配合滾動倉儲釋出" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147938/35.wav", + "text": "大概10月底到11月初" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147938/36.wav", + "text": "應該會回到往昔的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147938/37.wav", + "text": "大概四十多塊的價格" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147938/38.wav", + "text": "您是說在11月初" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147938/39.wav", + "text": "基本上會回到四十多塊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147938/40.wav", + "text": "11月初基本上會回到平常的水平" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147938/41.wav", + "text": "部分品項可能還要再晚一點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147938/42.wav", + "text": "因為它是需要一點時間的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147938/43.wav", + "text": "農業部為了降低蔬菜生產的風險" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147938/44.wav", + "text": "結構加強型的溫網室設施" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147938/45.wav", + "text": "請問到現在你們輔導設置了多少公頃" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147938/46.wav", + "text": "明年預算編多少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147938/47.wav", + "text": "明年預計要輔導到多少公頃" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147938/48.wav", + "text": "目前為止大概是2,200公頃左右" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147938/49.wav", + "text": "這是設施的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147938/50.wav", + "text": "明年我們規劃大概是200到300公頃" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147938/51.wav", + "text": "\n我也跟委員報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147938/52.wav", + "text": "造成很多影響以後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147938/53.wav", + "text": "進到這些溫室裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147938/54.wav", + "text": "比起之前是相對穩定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147938/55.wav", + "text": "設施農業是我們一直在推的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147938/56.wav", + "text": "今年編明年這個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147938/57.wav", + "text": "13.7億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147938/58.wav", + "text": "200公頃左右" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147938/59.wav", + "text": "雞蛋的價格昨天也降了2元" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147938/60.wav", + "text": "元批發價明天會從55元回到53" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147938/61.wav", + "text": "元您現在評估蛋荒的危機" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147938/62.wav", + "text": "是不是已經大概解除了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147938/63.wav", + "text": "現在狀況怎麼樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147938/64.wav", + "text": "我跟委員說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147938/65.wav", + "text": "其實我們一直希望能夠建構很好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147938/66.wav", + "text": "這個供應" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147938/67.wav", + "text": "以我們現在所得到的資訊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147938/68.wav", + "text": "包括蛋中雞跟蛋雞的數量" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147938/69.wav", + "text": "跟每天的產蛋率" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147938/70.wav", + "text": "供需平衡的水準" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147938/71.wav", + "text": "大概2,400萬顆左右" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147938/72.wav", + "text": "其實可以滿足" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147938/73.wav", + "text": "我們現在目前國內的需求" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147938/74.wav", + "text": "過去這一個多月來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147938/75.wav", + "text": "因為大家對於進口雞蛋的疑慮" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147938/76.wav", + "text": "然後有些不實的訊息造成一些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147938/77.wav", + "text": "特別是在學童的營養午餐" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147938/78.wav", + "text": "禁止液蛋的供應" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147938/79.wav", + "text": "但是學童營養午餐的供應" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147938/80.wav", + "text": "都是國產" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147938/81.wav", + "text": "規定一定都是國產" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147938/82.wav", + "text": "因為時間少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147938/83.wav", + "text": "就是您認為蛋荒的狀況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147938/84.wav", + "text": "是不是大致解除" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147938/85.wav", + "text": "但是我們要觀察" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147938/86.wav", + "text": "全球性的疫病" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147938/87.wav", + "text": "跟國內的疫病" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147938/88.wav", + "text": "禽流感的發展情形" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147938/89.wav", + "text": "所以我們也不能掉以輕心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147938/90.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147938/91.wav", + "text": "部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147938/92.wav", + "text": "您上次有講到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147938/93.wav", + "text": "10月11日在立法院有說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147938/94.wav", + "text": "農業部在研究" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147938/95.wav", + "text": "調降進口雞蛋的關稅" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147938/96.wav", + "text": "請問現行的關稅是多少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147938/97.wav", + "text": "30%" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147938/98.wav", + "text": "30%" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147938/99.wav", + "text": "好請教農業部現在研議得怎麼樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147938/100.wav", + "text": "調降多少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147938/101.wav", + "text": "我想" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147938/102.wav", + "text": "我剛才說的就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147938/103.wav", + "text": "我們所有的進口雞蛋一定是滿足" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147938/104.wav", + "text": "國內的不足" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147938/105.wav", + "text": "所以我們會去監控國內的生產量" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147938/106.wav", + "text": "然後維持一個安全的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147938/107.wav", + "text": "如果這個庫存沒辦法滿足的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147938/108.wav", + "text": "我們就會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147938/109.wav", + "text": "以降低關稅的方式請貿易商進口" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147938/110.wav", + "text": "而且是分階段的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147938/111.wav", + "text": "所以你不是整體的調降" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147938/112.wav", + "text": "而是視國內的狀況來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147938/113.wav", + "text": "時間到了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147938/114.wav", + "text": "主席對不起" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147938/115.wav", + "text": "\n禽流感的好發季" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147938/116.wav", + "text": "當然在冬季" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147938/117.wav", + "text": "請問農業部現在對於" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147938/118.wav", + "text": "狀況是怎麼樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147938/119.wav", + "text": "我想分為幾個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147938/120.wav", + "text": "我們已經啟動了秋冬的防疫狀況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147938/121.wav", + "text": "禽流感的場域週遭" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147938/122.wav", + "text": "我們會加強監控" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147938/123.wav", + "text": "一些檢測" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147938/124.wav", + "text": "很重要的就是我們會從" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147938/125.wav", + "text": "化製場" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147938/126.wav", + "text": "死亡雞隻" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147938/127.wav", + "text": "然後回溯到原來的蛋場" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147938/128.wav", + "text": "有發病的蛋場" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147938/129.wav", + "text": "而不會擴散" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147938/130.wav", + "text": "所以我們有一套跟生物" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147938/131.wav", + "text": "跟生物安全防治有關的作為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147938/132.wav", + "text": "當然就提醒農業部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147938/133.wav", + "text": "這一部分真的有關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147938/134.wav", + "text": "謝謝主席謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147937/0.wav", + "text": "產業發展司商業發展" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147937/1.wav", + "text": "好經濟部相關的官員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147937/2.wav", + "text": "好次長好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147937/3.wav", + "text": "環團最近對這個很有意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147937/4.wav", + "text": "我本人也有很大的疑慮" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147937/5.wav", + "text": "就是現在經濟部在發展綠能" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147937/6.wav", + "text": "次長知不知道焚化爐也是可以發電" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147937/7.wav", + "text": "焚化爐是燒垃圾對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147937/8.wav", + "text": "燒垃圾可以發電" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147937/9.wav", + "text": "但是焚化爐燒的垃圾" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147937/10.wav", + "text": "那它的發電是綠能嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147937/11.wav", + "text": "這個我們請能源署副署長來說明一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147937/12.wav", + "text": "是嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147937/13.wav", + "text": "焚化爐你簡單回答" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147937/14.wav", + "text": "一直都是把它放在再生能源那一塊去計算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147937/15.wav", + "text": "焚化爐錯了你答錯了你再回去查一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147937/16.wav", + "text": "因為它含有高含量的塑膠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147937/17.wav", + "text": "所以它的躉購價比汽電共生廠的躉購價還低" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147937/18.wav", + "text": "所以它不是綠能" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147937/19.wav", + "text": "另外一個系統在處理的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147937/20.wav", + "text": "好沒關係我今天也是要產業發展署" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147937/21.wav", + "text": "還有我們相關商業發展署來瞭解" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147937/22.wav", + "text": "因為我們知道事業廢棄物循環再利用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147937/23.wav", + "text": "然後會做成固體混合廢棄物" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147937/24.wav", + "text": "這個成分有塑膠有紙有污泥有廢液有廢油" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147937/25.wav", + "text": "做成的產品叫做SRF" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147937/26.wav", + "text": "這個SRF根據它的製程" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147937/27.wav", + "text": "它主要是污泥油泥有機廢溶劑" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147937/28.wav", + "text": "還有半導體製造業產生的廢液廢溶劑" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147937/29.wav", + "text": "所以它裡面有很多重金屬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147937/30.wav", + "text": "它們都叫做一級致癌物" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147937/31.wav", + "text": "請問經濟部如果這個SRF作為燃料" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147937/32.wav", + "text": "因為你們說綠能" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147937/33.wav", + "text": "說明這個主要使用者是工業鍋爐" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147937/34.wav", + "text": "水泥旋窯煉焦爐煉鋼業的熔爐" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147937/35.wav", + "text": "然後不涵蓋廢棄物焚化爐" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147937/36.wav", + "text": "那我請問次長這個SRF" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147937/37.wav", + "text": "叫做固體再生燃料" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147937/38.wav", + "text": "因為它沒有規範不能燒" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147937/39.wav", + "text": "哪裡不能燒" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147937/40.wav", + "text": "你們經濟部來燒這個SRF" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147937/41.wav", + "text": "請問你們願不願意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147937/42.wav", + "text": "它會產生戴奧辛會產生重金屬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147937/43.wav", + "text": "都是一級致癌物" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147937/44.wav", + "text": "所以現在已經發生民宅就在燒SRF" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147937/45.wav", + "text": "然後產生這些毒氣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147937/46.wav", + "text": "居民已經在抗議了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147937/47.wav", + "text": "還沒有訂出規範" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147937/48.wav", + "text": "哪裡可以燒哪裡不能燒" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147937/49.wav", + "text": "但你們經濟部已經允許在使用了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147937/50.wav", + "text": "所以我要請經濟部好好去注意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147937/51.wav", + "text": "到底燒出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147937/52.wav", + "text": "──燒出戴奧辛燒出重金屬要怎麼辦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147937/53.wav", + "text": "次長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147937/54.wav", + "text": "我們基本的態度就是我們一" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147937/55.wav", + "text": "會遵守環保署有關的排放規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147937/56.wav", + "text": "至於實際的情況我請那個產發署" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147937/57.wav", + "text": "我是擔心你們還沒有訂規範" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147937/58.wav", + "text": "因為環保署現在沒訂規範" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147937/59.wav", + "text": "啊環保署現在還沒訂規範" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147937/60.wav", + "text": "啊所以我要你們經濟部先搞清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147937/61.wav", + "text": "現在不管它是不是綠能" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147937/62.wav", + "text": "當然是其中一個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147937/63.wav", + "text": "因為綠能它可以躉購" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147937/64.wav", + "text": "它以後要賺那個碳費碳權" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147937/65.wav", + "text": "但這個部分我們以後再說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147937/66.wav", + "text": "我現在先請包括產業發展署" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147937/67.wav", + "text": "綜合規劃司商業發展署" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147937/68.wav", + "text": "甚至包括能源署" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147937/69.wav", + "text": "未來我們也會問環境部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147937/70.wav", + "text": "這個要訂清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147937/71.wav", + "text": "啦等於是說你們把燃料" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147937/72.wav", + "text": "然後包裝那個紙" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147937/73.wav", + "text": "包裝塑膠去燒" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147937/74.wav", + "text": "改了名字叫做綠能" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147937/75.wav", + "text": "然後騙大家這個叫綠能" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147937/76.wav", + "text": "所以就是安全的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147937/77.wav", + "text": "其實它是很不安全" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147937/78.wav", + "text": "原因很簡單" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147937/79.wav", + "text": "它有污泥" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147937/80.wav", + "text": "它有半導體製造業的廢液" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147937/81.wav", + "text": "它可能含有重金屬的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147937/82.wav", + "text": "有害廢棄物都會混在一起" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147937/83.wav", + "text": "因為很容易就可以混在一起" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147937/84.wav", + "text": "沒有辦法去確認" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147937/85.wav", + "text": "你沒有辦法去分析的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147937/86.wav", + "text": "那個分析費用很高" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147937/87.wav", + "text": "民眾沒有辦法去證明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147937/88.wav", + "text": "次長拜託經濟部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147937/89.wav", + "text": "把這個部分釐清好嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147937/90.wav", + "text": "因為這個還沒有大量被使用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147937/91.wav", + "text": "我是希望這個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147937/92.wav", + "text": "你們一定要釐清" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147937/93.wav", + "text": "這個真的是把廢棄物當作燃料在燒" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147937/94.wav", + "text": "沒有訂清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147937/95.wav", + "text": "那我再回來最前面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147937/96.wav", + "text": "你只是限定好了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147937/97.wav", + "text": "你限定工業鍋爐" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147937/98.wav", + "text": "要搞清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147937/99.wav", + "text": "不然旁邊的人都慘了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147937/100.wav", + "text": "就是會一直在吸廢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147937/101.wav", + "text": "好謝謝主席" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147936/0.wav", + "text": "謝謝主席主席請一下許部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147936/1.wav", + "text": "楊委員好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147936/2.wav", + "text": "部長好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147936/3.wav", + "text": "對於勞保基金" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147936/4.wav", + "text": "一直沒有一個改革的方案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147936/5.wav", + "text": "我一直是非常有意見的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147936/6.wav", + "text": "我先讓你說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147936/7.wav", + "text": "你們沒有提出方案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147936/8.wav", + "text": "那你們的改革方向是什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147936/9.wav", + "text": "報告委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147936/10.wav", + "text": "現在在財務面的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147936/11.wav", + "text": "可以做的改善就" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147936/12.wav", + "text": "就是政府這邊會持續撥補" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147936/13.wav", + "text": "這個是很重要的用來維持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147936/14.wav", + "text": "讓它有投資收益的活水" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147936/15.wav", + "text": "這是第一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147936/16.wav", + "text": "所以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147936/17.wav", + "text": "還是還沒有改革之前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147936/18.wav", + "text": "你懂我的意思嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147936/19.wav", + "text": "就是撥補是勞保基金改革" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147936/20.wav", + "text": "勞保年金改革的方向之一" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147936/21.wav", + "text": "還是在沒有提出方案之前的緊急配套" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147936/22.wav", + "text": "報告委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147936/23.wav", + "text": "它其實應該可以說是改革的一環" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147936/24.wav", + "text": "從過去兩次的勞保改革方案草案我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147936/25.wav", + "text": "我們都可以看到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147936/26.wav", + "text": "政府撥補是這個草案裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147936/27.wav", + "text": "一定有的一個面向" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147936/28.wav", + "text": "我們等於是先做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147936/29.wav", + "text": "好還有呢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147936/30.wav", + "text": "另外就是說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147936/31.wav", + "text": "目前我們也依法調整" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147936/32.wav", + "text": "保險的費率" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147936/33.wav", + "text": "另外就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147936/34.wav", + "text": "納保跟給付的審核" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147936/35.wav", + "text": "也要去做一些強化" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147936/36.wav", + "text": "這些都是屬於行政作為的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147936/37.wav", + "text": "另外我們也請業務單位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147936/38.wav", + "text": "參酌國外" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147936/39.wav", + "text": "的經驗因為現在國外的年金也" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147936/40.wav", + "text": "也面臨改革的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147936/41.wav", + "text": "大家參考國外的經驗" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147936/42.wav", + "text": "看看怎麼來面對財務的改善" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147936/43.wav", + "text": "部長我覺得我們參考太久了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147936/44.wav", + "text": "所以你剛剛講的就是一個撥補" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147936/45.wav", + "text": "一個調高費率" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147936/46.wav", + "text": "就是多繳" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147936/47.wav", + "text": "對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147936/48.wav", + "text": "然後一個就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147936/49.wav", + "text": "各項給付的嚴格查核" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147936/50.wav", + "text": "還有呢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147936/51.wav", + "text": "對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147936/52.wav", + "text": "就是給付和納保" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147936/53.wav", + "text": "還有一些可能保費拖欠或其他的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147936/54.wav", + "text": "他的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147936/55.wav", + "text": "對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147936/56.wav", + "text": "其實那個都是很細微的東西" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147936/57.wav", + "text": "那個基本上並不是改革的大方向" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147936/58.wav", + "text": "整個大方案一直沒有出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147936/59.wav", + "text": "嘛因為沒有出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147936/60.wav", + "text": "我現在是問你大的方向" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147936/61.wav", + "text": "所以就是一個撥補跟一個多繳" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147936/62.wav", + "text": "會不會有少領的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147936/63.wav", + "text": "目前這個部分還沒有任何的定論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147936/64.wav", + "text": "因為其實" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147936/65.wav", + "text": "少繳這部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147936/66.wav", + "text": "聽取各界" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147936/67.wav", + "text": "大家是反對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147936/68.wav", + "text": "因為大家現在是一萬八千多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147936/69.wav", + "text": "當然反對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147936/70.wav", + "text": "因為超過千萬的勞工裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147936/71.wav", + "text": "領不到兩萬塊的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147936/72.wav", + "text": "占了那麼高的比例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147936/73.wav", + "text": "那以目前的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147936/74.wav", + "text": "通貨膨脹跟物價指數上揚的情況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147936/75.wav", + "text": "兩萬本來就已經接近貧窮線了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147936/76.wav", + "text": "是接近貧窮線喔不是最低生活所需" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147936/77.wav", + "text": "不是一個方向" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147936/78.wav", + "text": "部長這時候說的個意思是這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147936/79.wav", + "text": "這個還沒有定論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147936/80.wav", + "text": "這個沒有定論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147936/81.wav", + "text": "我的意思是說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147936/82.wav", + "text": "我說方向上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147936/83.wav", + "text": "這個是不是一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147936/84.wav", + "text": "在改革裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147936/85.wav", + "text": "政府要多擔待一些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147936/86.wav", + "text": "勞工的權益" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147936/87.wav", + "text": "那當然調整的面向就會連動" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147936/88.wav", + "text": "會不會延後退休年限" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147936/89.wav", + "text": "會不會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147936/90.wav", + "text": "我現在問的是你們規劃的方向" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147936/91.wav", + "text": "因為你方案一直沒有出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147936/92.wav", + "text": "嘛剛剛李委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147936/93.wav", + "text": "說部長當了五年多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147936/94.wav", + "text": "整體的方案沒有出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147936/95.wav", + "text": "最少在方向上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147936/96.wav", + "text": "你們朝哪個方向走" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147936/97.wav", + "text": "你應該有一些概念" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147936/98.wav", + "text": "對報告委員剛剛講的是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147936/99.wav", + "text": "法定的退休年齡資格" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147936/100.wav", + "text": "資格是一個議題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147936/101.wav", + "text": "這樣的一個建議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147936/102.wav", + "text": "那部長你的立場" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147936/103.wav", + "text": "牽涉的層面會比較多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147936/104.wav", + "text": "也不失為一個大家可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147936/105.wav", + "text": "但是要討論要有共識" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147936/106.wav", + "text": "每一個面向都會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147936/107.wav", + "text": "部長我還是先跟你溝通一個觀念" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147936/108.wav", + "text": "任何的改革" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147936/109.wav", + "text": "不可能有共識" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147936/110.wav", + "text": "再從另外一個層次來看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147936/111.wav", + "text": "要有共識" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147936/112.wav", + "text": "必須要先拋出方案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147936/113.wav", + "text": "才有產生共識的可能" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147936/114.wav", + "text": "絕對不可能說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147936/115.wav", + "text": "勞動部不拋出" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147936/116.wav", + "text": "或不提出改革方案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147936/117.wav", + "text": "然後一直說沒有共識" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147936/118.wav", + "text": "所有的改革" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147936/119.wav", + "text": "一定不可能有共識" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147936/120.wav", + "text": "普發1萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147936/121.wav", + "text": "那個大家都有共識" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147936/122.wav", + "text": "像你這種不可能有共識" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147936/123.wav", + "text": "這個是第一點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147936/124.wav", + "text": "\n第二點要尋求共識" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147936/125.wav", + "text": "也必須要有一個東西出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147936/126.wav", + "text": "先有一個改革方案出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147936/127.wav", + "text": "才能夠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147936/128.wav", + "text": "讓大家討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147936/129.wav", + "text": "提出意見尋求共識" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147936/130.wav", + "text": "方案沒有出來然後一直說沒有共識" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147936/131.wav", + "text": "在這邊回答的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147936/132.wav", + "text": "講過好幾次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147936/133.wav", + "text": "沒有共識" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147936/134.wav", + "text": "然而要有共識必須要你們有提出方案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147936/135.wav", + "text": "我也不想耽誤大家太多時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147936/136.wav", + "text": "遲遲不改革" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147936/137.wav", + "text": "多數勞工" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147936/138.wav", + "text": "所以他們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147936/139.wav", + "text": "已經有一點惶恐" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147936/140.wav", + "text": "反正撥補以後就是常態了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147936/141.wav", + "text": "我也不要再跟你" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147936/142.wav", + "text": "到114年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147936/143.wav", + "text": "超過2,600億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147936/144.wav", + "text": "我不算這個數字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147936/145.wav", + "text": "部長贊不贊成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147936/146.wav", + "text": "把政府" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147936/147.wav", + "text": "撥補基金跟" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147936/148.wav", + "text": "政府負擔" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147936/149.wav", + "text": "最終的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147936/150.wav", + "text": "給付責任入法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147936/151.wav", + "text": "我贊同" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147936/152.wav", + "text": "既然贊同能不能" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147936/153.wav", + "text": "請提出修法版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147936/154.wav", + "text": "報告委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147936/155.wav", + "text": "如果簡單針對這兩個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147936/156.wav", + "text": "但是重點是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147936/157.wav", + "text": "這個版本提出後可能大家不會滿意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147936/158.wav", + "text": "說只有修這兩" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147936/159.wav", + "text": "拖了這麼多年的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147936/160.wav", + "text": "年金改革的制度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147936/161.wav", + "text": "讓廣大的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147936/162.wav", + "text": "勞動者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147936/163.wav", + "text": "不安心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147936/164.wav", + "text": "那就先把這個入法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147936/165.wav", + "text": "安定民心的作用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147936/166.wav", + "text": "謝謝委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147936/167.wav", + "text": "這個雖然" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147936/168.wav", + "text": "是你目前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147936/169.wav", + "text": "最確定的改革方案裡面的一條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147936/170.wav", + "text": "可是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147936/171.wav", + "text": "並沒有規定這" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147936/172.wav", + "text": "等你們提出方案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147936/173.wav", + "text": "其實在明年520之前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147936/174.wav", + "text": "那是不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147936/175.wav", + "text": "可以先把政府負擔" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147936/176.wav", + "text": "最終責任" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147936/177.wav", + "text": "法律來宣示" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147936/178.wav", + "text": "政府對勞工" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147936/179.wav", + "text": "退休以後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147936/180.wav", + "text": "的生活責無旁貸" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147936/181.wav", + "text": "我覺得這是一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147936/182.wav", + "text": "執政黨必須要宣示" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147936/183.wav", + "text": "的決心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147936/184.wav", + "text": "其實也是我們的根本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147936/185.wav", + "text": "義務" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147936/186.wav", + "text": "你們直接先提" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147936/187.wav", + "text": "我不覺得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147936/188.wav", + "text": "單修這個條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147936/189.wav", + "text": "會有人反對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147936/190.wav", + "text": "大家反對不是反對你" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147936/191.wav", + "text": "這個條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147936/192.wav", + "text": "大家是反對你沒有提出整體的方案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147936/193.wav", + "text": "好那我們就先" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147936/194.wav", + "text": "安一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147936/195.wav", + "text": "廣大勞工的心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147936/196.wav", + "text": "謝謝委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147936/197.wav", + "text": "我們來研究一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147936/198.wav", + "text": "你們不要研究" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147936/199.wav", + "text": "不是我們也必須" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147936/200.wav", + "text": "有一些討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147936/201.wav", + "text": "要等你們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147936/202.wav", + "text": "其實這是我們一再對外宣示的立場" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147936/203.wav", + "text": "要等你們整體的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147936/204.wav", + "text": "不知要等到什麼時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147936/205.wav", + "text": "不要等到像剛剛李德維" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147936/206.wav", + "text": "委員講的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147936/207.wav", + "text": "等到政黨輪替" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147935/0.wav", + "text": "有請農業部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147935/1.wav", + "text": "謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147935/2.wav", + "text": "請農業部部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147935/3.wav", + "text": "員好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147935/4.wav", + "text": "部長好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147935/5.wav", + "text": "上個月在院會質詢的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147935/6.wav", + "text": "當時您也有正面的承諾跟支持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147935/7.wav", + "text": "今天關於預算的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147935/8.wav", + "text": "我們想要請教相關的經費規劃細節" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147935/9.wav", + "text": "稍微簡單計算一下表示" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147935/10.wav", + "text": "如果在學童的營養午餐當中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147935/11.wav", + "text": "每個月多增加一次國產鮮乳" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147935/12.wav", + "text": "必須增加1.8億元經費" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147935/13.wav", + "text": "而且還要搭配調修TGAP的規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147935/14.wav", + "text": "才可以把國產保久乳納入三章一Q的食材" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147935/15.wav", + "text": "農業部畜牧司在上週也已經公開對外" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147935/16.wav", + "text": "表示我們有看到新聞稿" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147935/17.wav", + "text": "會在半年內完成相關的學童乳政策的配套措施" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147935/18.wav", + "text": "目前是不是已經有討論到關於這個經費規劃的來源" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147935/19.wav", + "text": "還有因為TGAP的規定調修之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147935/20.wav", + "text": "是不是也有相關的預算需要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147935/21.wav", + "text": "在預算編列裡討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147935/22.wav", + "text": "我先跟委員說明一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147935/23.wav", + "text": "第一個我們要處理的是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147935/24.wav", + "text": "這些乳品要變成TGAP" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147935/25.wav", + "text": "我們現在規劃是一週一次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147935/26.wav", + "text": "不是一個月一次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147935/27.wav", + "text": "一週一次嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147935/28.wav", + "text": "我們希望" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147935/29.wav", + "text": "你們希望一週一次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147935/30.wav", + "text": "所以1.8億元是一週一次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147935/31.wav", + "text": "沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147935/32.wav", + "text": "一個月一次才1.8億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147935/33.wav", + "text": "元我們期待是一週一次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147935/34.wav", + "text": "相對的這些需求的增加" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147935/35.wav", + "text": "也會帶動前端" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147935/36.wav", + "text": "產量整個經費大概是7億元左右" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147935/37.wav", + "text": "我們會儘快向行政院爭取" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147935/38.wav", + "text": "因為教育部是整個學童午餐的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147935/39.wav", + "text": "部長如果你都已經說得這麼美好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147935/40.wav", + "text": "我可以問一下這個時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147935/41.wav", + "text": "在半年還是三個月內" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147935/42.wav", + "text": "會有比較進一步的討論結果呢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147935/43.wav", + "text": "我想這個牽涉到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147935/44.wav", + "text": "溯源的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147935/45.wav", + "text": "因為溯源要花一點時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147935/46.wav", + "text": "對而且也需要跟酪農端有一些討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147935/47.wav", + "text": "三個月可以完成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147935/48.wav", + "text": "好三個月可以完成好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147935/49.wav", + "text": "好我們就先期待這個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147935/50.wav", + "text": "繼續往下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147935/51.wav", + "text": "如果有任何跟產業端的溝通" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147935/52.wav", + "text": "或是跟教育部的溝通" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147935/53.wav", + "text": "也歡迎跟我們辦公室持續保持討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147935/54.wav", + "text": "好謝謝農業部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147935/55.wav", + "text": "\n接下來跟部長討論食農教育" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147935/56.wav", + "text": "這件事情我相信部長一定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147935/57.wav", + "text": "印象深刻但是我們認為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147935/58.wav", + "text": "農業部早在相關的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147935/59.wav", + "text": "食農教育法推進的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147935/60.wav", + "text": "其實就有自己的食農教育平台" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147935/61.wav", + "text": "而且這個平台上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147935/62.wav", + "text": "也有非常多好用的資訊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147935/63.wav", + "text": "可是我們覺得很可惜的是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147935/64.wav", + "text": "這個食農教育整合資訊平台" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147935/65.wav", + "text": "在2022年農業部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147935/66.wav", + "text": "通過食農教育法的時候我們查了一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147935/67.wav", + "text": "有食農教育的教案手冊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147935/68.wav", + "text": "還有一些農村再生的案例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147935/69.wav", + "text": "也就是說其實農業部已經做了一些事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147935/70.wav", + "text": "可是如果以大家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147935/71.wav", + "text": "習慣在LINE或Facebook等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147935/72.wav", + "text": "社群媒體傳播的所謂懶人包" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147935/73.wav", + "text": "或圖文分享" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147935/74.wav", + "text": "卻停留在2020年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147935/75.wav", + "text": "沒有其他新的資訊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147935/76.wav", + "text": "我們覺得這個部分真的有點可惜" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147935/77.wav", + "text": "不知道部長您覺得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147935/78.wav", + "text": "呢因為臺灣有這麼豐富的農產" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147935/79.wav", + "text": "漁產畜產的商品產品" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147935/80.wav", + "text": "但是卻沒有辦法透過圖文懶人包" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147935/81.wav", + "text": "讓學校老師或是學生家長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147935/82.wav", + "text": "有機會知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147935/83.wav", + "text": "會不會很可惜啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147935/84.wav", + "text": "照委員所提到的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147935/85.wav", + "text": "我們的更新只到2020" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147935/86.wav", + "text": "年我覺得的確要檢討" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147935/87.wav", + "text": "我想會後我會去開相關的專案會議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147935/88.wav", + "text": "因為我知道現在這些資訊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147935/89.wav", + "text": "我們剛好成立資訊司以後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147935/90.wav", + "text": "正在有系統地" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147935/91.wav", + "text": "改版我也希望" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147935/92.wav", + "text": "趁這個機會在改版的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147935/93.wav", + "text": "能夠把所有資訊更新" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147935/94.wav", + "text": "因為如同剛剛部長您說的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147935/95.wav", + "text": "如果資訊司確實已經在做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147935/96.wav", + "text": "農業部網路資訊的調整" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147935/97.wav", + "text": "務必要把跟民眾溝通" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147935/98.wav", + "text": "做好食農教育這個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147935/99.wav", + "text": "因為其實農業部真的已經花了很多時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147935/100.wav", + "text": "做了很多事" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147935/101.wav", + "text": "如果只是在資訊的揭露跟民眾溝通這裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147935/102.wav", + "text": "好像漏了一些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147935/103.wav", + "text": "我會覺得真的很可惜" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147935/104.wav", + "text": "會更積極的去處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147935/105.wav", + "text": "好所以如果有機會讓這個資訊平台" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147935/106.wav", + "text": "更靠近一般民眾的想像" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147935/107.wav", + "text": "除了您剛剛說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147935/108.wav", + "text": "的資訊司的規劃之外" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147935/109.wav", + "text": "我們有機會要求在一個短的時間內" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147935/110.wav", + "text": "看到相關規劃的報告嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147935/111.wav", + "text": "例如一個月內" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147935/112.wav", + "text": "我們很好奇資訊司" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147935/113.wav", + "text": "除了整理這些該有的透露在網路上的資訊之外" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147935/114.wav", + "text": "如何跟民眾溝通" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147935/115.wav", + "text": "是學校老師們也很想做的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147935/116.wav", + "text": "一個月內嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147935/117.wav", + "text": "好如果老師們有相關的素材" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147935/118.wav", + "text": "我相信老師也很樂意分享給學生還有家長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147935/119.wav", + "text": "了解我想除了系統更新以外" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147935/120.wav", + "text": "相對的內容物的填充跟豐富" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147935/121.wav", + "text": "也是非常重要的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147935/122.wav", + "text": "我們也會跟其他的學校" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147935/123.wav", + "text": "以及同樣領域的人蒐集" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147935/124.wav", + "text": "謝謝主席" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147934/0.wav", + "text": "主計長好有一件事想跟主計長聊一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147934/1.wav", + "text": "所以我想藉用這個機會跟主計長報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147934/2.wav", + "text": "所以你對嘉義的狀況應該熟悉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147934/3.wav", + "text": "嘉義在沿海地區" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147934/4.wav", + "text": "因為長庚醫院是一個教學醫院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147934/5.wav", + "text": "長庚醫院大概就是把沿海整個鄉鎮" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147934/6.wav", + "text": "包括8鄉鎮大概整個醫療資源都集中在朴子市" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147934/7.wav", + "text": "它每萬人的醫師數是很高的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147934/8.wav", + "text": "但是你看相對的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147934/9.wav", + "text": "這邊的每萬人醫生數" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147934/10.wav", + "text": "都是個位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147934/11.wav", + "text": "數甚至有的才達1個人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147934/12.wav", + "text": "1萬人差不多1個醫生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147934/13.wav", + "text": "我們在沿海地區沒有辦法創造所謂的分級醫療" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147934/14.wav", + "text": "整個長庚醫院必須把我們那邊的老人家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147934/15.wav", + "text": "所有的就醫全部都集中在長庚醫院才能服務" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147934/16.wav", + "text": "所謂的三級醫療幾乎是沒有的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147934/17.wav", + "text": "我要跟主計長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147934/18.wav", + "text": "本來我們朴子還有一家部立的朴子醫院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147934/19.wav", + "text": "但是部立的朴子醫院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147934/20.wav", + "text": "變得這一家朴子醫院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147934/21.wav", + "text": "沒有辦法像其他的部立醫院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147934/22.wav", + "text": "可能落在偏遠地區" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147934/23.wav", + "text": "所以有一些像是醫療巡迴的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147934/24.wav", + "text": "在他未滿65歲以前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147934/25.wav", + "text": "可以考慮續留在地方服務" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147934/26.wav", + "text": "基於這個原因" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147934/27.wav", + "text": "我們才會希望朴子醫院在東石設立分院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147934/28.wav", + "text": "在東石設立分院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147934/29.wav", + "text": "我們也不是說要在東石這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147934/30.wav", + "text": "發展性不夠的地方" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147934/31.wav", + "text": "蓋一個大醫院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147934/32.wav", + "text": "我們不是要蓋一個大醫院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147934/33.wav", + "text": "這個預算大概900多萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147934/34.wav", + "text": "元所以它只是一個很基礎型的醫院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147934/35.wav", + "text": "它蓋這個基礎型醫院有什麼好處" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147934/36.wav", + "text": "它馬上就從醫療資源豐沛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147934/37.wav", + "text": "每萬人醫生數少於10" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147934/38.wav", + "text": "所以就是基於這個原因" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147934/39.wav", + "text": "我們爭取東石醫院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147934/40.wav", + "text": "然後你要叫朴子醫院去承擔" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147934/41.wav", + "text": "蓋這家醫院所有的預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147934/42.wav", + "text": "叫朴子醫院說要蓋就" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147934/43.wav", + "text": "就自己蓋" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147934/44.wav", + "text": "裡面的醫生會沒有士氣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147934/45.wav", + "text": "既然國發會願意負擔一半的預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147934/46.wav", + "text": "主計總處我覺得這件事你要幫我們促成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147934/47.wav", + "text": "如果是通過的計畫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147934/48.wav", + "text": "然後送行政院通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147934/49.wav", + "text": "樂觀其成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147934/50.wav", + "text": "但是我必須說明一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147934/51.wav", + "text": "它應該把財務規劃做好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147934/52.wav", + "text": "委員應該很了解原來的華濟醫院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147934/53.wav", + "text": "我們不希望最後變成華濟醫院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147934/54.wav", + "text": "主計長我剛有跟你報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147934/55.wav", + "text": "我們這個東石醫院跟華濟醫院不一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147934/56.wav", + "text": "我們的量體差很多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147934/57.wav", + "text": "我們並不是要一個很大量體的醫院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147934/58.wav", + "text": "但是我們這一家醫院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147934/59.wav", + "text": "重點是因為它落在東石" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147934/60.wav", + "text": "它可以進入變成所謂" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147934/61.wav", + "text": "地區它就可以得到更多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147934/62.wav", + "text": "包括巡迴醫生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147934/63.wav", + "text": "這樣的一些優勢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147934/64.wav", + "text": "讓未來的部立朴子醫院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147934/65.wav", + "text": "才會壯大起來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147934/66.wav", + "text": "我們讓部立的朴子醫院壯大起來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147934/67.wav", + "text": "才有辦法做到嘉義海線的分級醫療" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147934/68.wav", + "text": "對我同意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147934/69.wav", + "text": "只要通過衛福部的醫療網發展計畫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147934/70.wav", + "text": "然後經過體系行政院國發會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147934/71.wav", + "text": "然後行政院通過主計總處就會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147934/72.wav", + "text": "我最近來召開一個協調會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147934/73.wav", + "text": "我希望衛福部那邊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147934/74.wav", + "text": "大家來協調一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147934/75.wav", + "text": "這件事情都已經走到了現在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147934/76.wav", + "text": "我希望我們真正來促成好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147934/77.wav", + "text": "對我們是說他們通過計畫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147934/78.wav", + "text": "把責任都是賴主計總處不通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147934/79.wav", + "text": "好我相信他們不會這樣做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147934/80.wav", + "text": "啦現在就是差臨門一腳而已" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147934/81.wav", + "text": "好所以就謝謝主計長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147934/82.wav", + "text": "我是不是有請財政部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147934/83.wav", + "text": "委員好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147934/84.wav", + "text": "部長好因為今天的這個主題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147934/85.wav", + "text": "受僱人員報酬占GDP比例的一個創新低" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147934/86.wav", + "text": "貧富差距十年新高" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147934/87.wav", + "text": "我具體跟部長這邊說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147934/88.wav", + "text": "事實上我覺得財政部應該" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147934/89.wav", + "text": "要去思考一件事" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147934/90.wav", + "text": "也就是說公司如果辦理員工的伙食" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147934/91.wav", + "text": "的用具跟設備" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147934/92.wav", + "text": "甚至是說員工旅遊費用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147934/93.wav", + "text": "以及員工的一些福利" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147934/94.wav", + "text": "我們希望這部分應該把它列為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147934/95.wav", + "text": "可扣抵公司" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147934/96.wav", + "text": "如果這部分一樣是創造" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147934/97.wav", + "text": "公司對於勞工的福利" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147934/98.wav", + "text": "樂觀其成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147934/99.wav", + "text": "然後去擴大這樣可以扣抵的一個項目" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147934/100.wav", + "text": "我覺得財政部應該來思考這件事好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147934/101.wav", + "text": "跟委員報告這個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147934/102.wav", + "text": "公司為員工福利而支出的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147934/103.wav", + "text": "都可以列為公司的一個費用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147934/104.wav", + "text": "可以去做扣除" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147934/105.wav", + "text": "對它的營所稅可以有所降低" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147934/106.wav", + "text": "這個是部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147934/107.wav", + "text": "那對營業稅這個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147934/108.wav", + "text": "是公司要自己用的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147934/109.wav", + "text": "比如說它買了蛋糕或茶品等等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147934/110.wav", + "text": "它是自己用的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147934/111.wav", + "text": "這個部分的營業稅" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147934/112.wav", + "text": "依照現行制度是沒有辦法扣抵" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147934/113.wav", + "text": "但是它整個買東西" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147934/114.wav", + "text": "整個含營業稅這個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147934/115.wav", + "text": "是可以進到它的費用去扣抵的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147934/116.wav", + "text": "好沒關係" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147934/117.wav", + "text": "我覺得這個細部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147934/118.wav", + "text": "未來有機會再來討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147934/119.wav", + "text": "公司有盈餘" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147934/120.wav", + "text": "然後創造更多的員工福利" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147934/121.wav", + "text": "那這件事是正面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147934/122.wav", + "text": "而且值得我們去努力的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147934/123.wav", + "text": "謝謝委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147934/124.wav", + "text": "謝謝各位請回" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147933/0.wav", + "text": "部長早" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147933/1.wav", + "text": "今天我當然還是要延續" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147933/2.wav", + "text": "我在總質詢的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147933/3.wav", + "text": "特別針對閣揆提出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147933/4.wav", + "text": "我們的高教經費嚴重不足" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147933/5.wav", + "text": "那麼長年以來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147933/6.wav", + "text": "已經面臨了一個全面崩塌的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147933/7.wav", + "text": "重大國家危機" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147933/8.wav", + "text": "我認為都已經有20年了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147933/9.wav", + "text": "長期以往大家長年來都很關心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147933/10.wav", + "text": "提出很多的檢討跟討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147933/11.wav", + "text": "但萬流歸宗" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147933/12.wav", + "text": "啦巧婦難為無米之炊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147933/13.wav", + "text": "重點就在於" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147933/14.wav", + "text": "非常嚴重的不足" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147933/15.wav", + "text": "僧多粥少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147933/16.wav", + "text": "但是那天的質詢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147933/17.wav", + "text": "其實讓我非常地失望" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147933/18.wav", + "text": "也非常地遺憾" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147933/19.wav", + "text": "因為毫無碰觸到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147933/20.wav", + "text": "高教真正面臨的危機和問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147933/21.wav", + "text": "到底足不足夠的這個數字上面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147933/22.wav", + "text": "閣揆他非常激動地一直不斷地堅持說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147933/23.wav", + "text": "我們的投入已經很足夠了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147933/24.wav", + "text": "我為什麼說我很失望" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147933/25.wav", + "text": "我為什麼對閣揆提出這個問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147933/26.wav", + "text": "因為他跟蘇貞昌不同" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147933/27.wav", + "text": "他是臺灣高教長期所培養的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147933/28.wav", + "text": "頂尖菁英人才" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147933/29.wav", + "text": "而且也在臺灣最高的研究單位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147933/30.wav", + "text": "受到非常高的禮遇" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147933/31.wav", + "text": "理論上我的期待是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147933/32.wav", + "text": "他應該對高教的困境" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147933/33.wav", + "text": "有很多體會才對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147933/34.wav", + "text": "但是得到的反應卻剛好相反" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147933/35.wav", + "text": "\n不過沒關係" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147933/36.wav", + "text": "第一個我覺得還是要正本清源" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147933/37.wav", + "text": "我當時就有講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147933/38.wav", + "text": "這個數字的來源" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147933/39.wav", + "text": "它根據OECD的標準所做的計算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147933/40.wav", + "text": "那麼我是立法委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147933/41.wav", + "text": "我在立法院進行預算會期的總質詢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147933/42.wav", + "text": "談的當然是國家公部門的投入跟預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147933/43.wav", + "text": "嘛所以根據高教工會的統計" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147933/44.wav", + "text": "它根據我剛剛說的OECD的計算方法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147933/45.wav", + "text": "這個是所謂的公部門的投入" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147933/46.wav", + "text": "什麼叫做公部門的投入" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147933/47.wav", + "text": "然後把剩下的兩樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147933/48.wav", + "text": "再加上高教深耕的經費及大學" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147933/49.wav", + "text": "教學卓越計畫這些非常態性的補助" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147933/50.wav", + "text": "所以他們計算出來是GDP的0.39%" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147933/51.wav", + "text": "就這件事情在去年也曾經" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147933/52.wav", + "text": "因為他們的指正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147933/53.wav", + "text": "請教育部在提供給OECD的數字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147933/54.wav", + "text": "必須做更改" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147933/55.wav", + "text": "因為計算的方式就公部門跟私部門的定義" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147933/56.wav", + "text": "有明顯的錯誤" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147933/57.wav", + "text": "\n我現在所呈現的這一份" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147933/58.wav", + "text": "就是今年教育部發行的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147933/59.wav", + "text": "教育部發行的不是鄭麗文發行的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147933/60.wav", + "text": "教育部發行的教育統計指標之國際比較" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147933/61.wav", + "text": "2023年最新版" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147933/62.wav", + "text": "我們看到中華民國ROC在第一欄" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147933/63.wav", + "text": "像這上面寫的依照OECD的定義" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147933/64.wav", + "text": "區分公部門及私部門" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147933/65.wav", + "text": "即便是這個教育部所做的表格" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147933/66.wav", + "text": "也只有0.5" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147933/67.wav", + "text": "%它的1.2%的數字哪裡來的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147933/68.wav", + "text": "就是加上了私部門的0.7" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147933/69.wav", + "text": "%嘛那我今天在質詢閣揆" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147933/70.wav", + "text": "我怎麼可能去談私部門" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147933/71.wav", + "text": "呢當然談的就是我們的國家政府預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147933/72.wav", + "text": "\n這是一個預算會期" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147933/73.wav", + "text": "今天我們討論的是教育部的預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147933/74.wav", + "text": "即便是閣揆口中說的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147933/75.wav", + "text": "公部門再加上私部門" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147933/76.wav", + "text": "也不是他說的國家預算給國科會的補助" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147933/77.wav", + "text": "他根本都說錯了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147933/78.wav", + "text": "部長你回去私下向院長報告一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147933/79.wav", + "text": "我再把它講完" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147933/80.wav", + "text": "如果院長講的的確是這個數字1.2" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147933/81.wav", + "text": "%因為他講1.2" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147933/82.wav", + "text": "即便是公加私" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147933/83.wav", + "text": "OECD的平均也是1.5" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147933/84.wav", + "text": "%不是1.2" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147933/85.wav", + "text": "%我們並沒有超過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147933/86.wav", + "text": "我講的是公部門的投入" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147933/87.wav", + "text": "高教工會所計算的0.39" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147933/88.wav", + "text": "%或是教育部所計算的0.5%都沒有關係" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147933/89.wav", + "text": "%相比的確是有一個非常大的落差" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147933/90.wav", + "text": "回過頭來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147933/91.wav", + "text": "所以今天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147933/92.wav", + "text": "到底高教的經費��不夠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147933/93.wav", + "text": "嘛我那一天也問了閣揆" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147933/94.wav", + "text": "我提出來了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147933/95.wav", + "text": "包括多年來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147933/96.wav", + "text": "我們都沒有在百大裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147933/97.wav", + "text": "我們跌出了全世界百大大學" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147933/98.wav", + "text": "臺灣是掛零啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147933/99.wav", + "text": "然後我們嚴重地缺乏專業教師" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147933/100.wav", + "text": "我們的師生比這麼地低" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147933/101.wav", + "text": "臺灣高教的亂象" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147933/102.wav", + "text": "今天這個時間怎麼夠我講呢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147933/103.wav", + "text": "我們在教育委員會也討論過多次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147933/104.wav", + "text": "而且不是這兩年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147933/105.wav", + "text": "我剛剛講了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147933/106.wav", + "text": "這已經存在長年了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147933/107.wav", + "text": "昨天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147933/108.wav", + "text": "郭位校長送了這本書給我" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147933/109.wav", + "text": "他講的是兩岸三地他的經驗他的比較" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147933/110.wav", + "text": "書裡面有談到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147933/111.wav", + "text": "我們的人均在四小龍裡面與" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147933/112.wav", + "text": "新加坡韓國香港比起來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147933/113.wav", + "text": "我們的人均GDP是最低的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147933/114.wav", + "text": "但是我們的人均大學數是最高的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147933/115.wav", + "text": "這就是當年我們的政策" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147933/116.wav", + "text": "嘛可是我們的表現是最差的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147933/117.wav", + "text": "僧多粥少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147933/118.wav", + "text": "我剛剛講被踢出百大掛蛋" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147933/119.wav", + "text": "再來看這也是郭位老師在書裡面提到的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147933/120.wav", + "text": "也是這些國家裡頭" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147933/121.wav", + "text": "最低的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147933/122.wav", + "text": "我們的大學生應屆畢業生的起薪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147933/123.wav", + "text": "也是最低的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147933/124.wav", + "text": "在書裡面有一句話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147933/125.wav", + "text": "我昨天看了我真的很有感" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147933/126.wav", + "text": "高等教育" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147933/127.wav", + "text": "不是在擺地攤" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147933/128.wav", + "text": "完全不需要灌注資源" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147933/129.wav", + "text": "說來就來說走就走" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147933/130.wav", + "text": "我們的高等教育教學研究也不是社會福利" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147933/131.wav", + "text": "參與者可以不計表現資源分配人人有份" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147933/132.wav", + "text": "\n書裡面也提到了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147933/133.wav", + "text": "特別提到臺灣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147933/134.wav", + "text": "號稱高教普及最澈底的確是如此" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147933/135.wav", + "text": "但在四小龍裡頭" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147933/136.wav", + "text": "畢業生起薪最低" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147933/137.wav", + "text": "教授薪水最低" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147933/138.wav", + "text": "士氣也最低" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147933/139.wav", + "text": "這一些才是我今天真正想要跟" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147933/140.wav", + "text": "我們的政府討論的基本根本的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147933/141.wav", + "text": "這是臺灣真正的國力來源" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147933/142.wav", + "text": "我們未來是拚軟實力不是硬實力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147933/143.wav", + "text": "知識經濟決定了臺灣整體國家的競爭能力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147933/144.wav", + "text": "我們現在有護國神山連" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147933/145.wav", + "text": "接下來講的是創新創新創新靠什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147933/146.wav", + "text": "靠成功的高等教育" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147933/147.wav", + "text": "高等教育的問題還需要我在這邊講嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147933/148.wav", + "text": "我們只是在思考根本的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147933/149.wav", + "text": "如果今天台灣過去沒錢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147933/150.wav", + "text": "那現在有錢了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147933/151.wav", + "text": "啊為什麼今天會談這個問題原因" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147933/152.wav", + "text": "就是我們的財務狀況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147933/153.wav", + "text": "並不如同政府所說的大幅提升" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147933/154.wav", + "text": "\n今年度國家總預算的總數提升" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147933/155.wav", + "text": "也是歷年以來最高" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147933/156.wav", + "text": "簡報今年的國家總預算增幅高達7.2%" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147933/157.wav", + "text": "教育部主管的占比" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147933/158.wav", + "text": "卻是下降而沒有看到升高" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147933/159.wav", + "text": "這是怎麼回事" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147933/160.wav", + "text": "尤其去年降了這麼多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147933/161.wav", + "text": "我們希望教育的投入與預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147933/162.wav", + "text": "要年年增加" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147933/163.wav", + "text": "要補助私校的學費" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147933/164.wav", + "text": "嘛可以挹注219億元" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147933/165.wav", + "text": "真是令人心很痛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147933/166.wav", + "text": "啊有錢為什麼沒有直接投注給學校" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147933/167.wav", + "text": "郭位教授都說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147933/168.wav", + "text": "我們台灣叫做均貧的高等教育" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147933/169.wav", + "text": "因為學校最多投入的經費資源最少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147933/170.wav", + "text": "每個人平均就是少得可憐" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147933/171.wav", + "text": "才會導致我們整個結構性跟體質" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147933/172.wav", + "text": "根本就是已經先天不良" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147933/173.wav", + "text": "後天失調" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147933/174.wav", + "text": "我們的高等教育病了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147933/175.wav", + "text": "會否認這樣的現象" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147933/176.wav", + "text": "呢我真的是覺得太不可思議了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147933/177.wav", + "text": "\n你不認我的數字沒有關係" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147933/178.wav", + "text": "我們高等教育經費非常充足沒有問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147933/179.wav", + "text": "如果是這樣的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147933/180.wav", + "text": "我們都不用檢討也不用討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147933/181.wav", + "text": "更遑論改革高等教育" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147933/182.wav", + "text": "我們大家都是臺灣高等教育栽培出來的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147933/183.wav", + "text": "人才我覺得我們都有這一份責任" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147933/184.wav", + "text": "為臺灣的高等教育說話爭取" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147933/185.wav", + "text": "我們大家共體時艱" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147933/186.wav", + "text": "今天國家有錢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147933/187.wav", + "text": "為什麼第一個不是想到我們的教育呢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147933/188.wav", + "text": "問題出在哪裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147933/189.wav", + "text": "今天國家有錢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147933/190.wav", + "text": "為什麼沒有想到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147933/191.wav", + "text": "臺大已經被踢出百大多久了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147933/192.wav", + "text": "我們的國家覺得現在這樣很正常" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147933/193.wav", + "text": "我們的高等教育呈現這樣的水準" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147933/194.wav", + "text": "在國際上呈現這樣的表現" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147933/195.wav", + "text": "我實在是沒有辦法接受" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147933/196.wav", + "text": "在審預算的同時" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147933/197.wav", + "text": "從根本的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147933/198.wav", + "text": "政府的心態" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147933/199.wav", + "text": "教育部的心態究竟是什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147933/200.wav", + "text": "而且我提這個問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147933/201.wav", + "text": "與藍綠無關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147933/202.wav", + "text": "啊你也可以說是藍綠共業都可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147933/203.wav", + "text": "對臺灣高等教育" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147933/204.wav", + "text": "有基本認識的人都知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147933/205.wav", + "text": "怎麼可能會有好的表現呢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147933/206.wav", + "text": "這樣的高等教育" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147933/207.wav", + "text": "未來臺灣怎麼跟人家競爭" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147933/208.wav", + "text": "部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147933/209.wav", + "text": "就按照教育部的計算也沒有關係" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147933/210.wav", + "text": "這是一個很好的機會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147933/211.wav", + "text": "嘛既然民進黨喜歡撒幣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147933/212.wav", + "text": "也有幣可以撒" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147933/213.wav", + "text": "那我只是拜託你們把幣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147933/214.wav", + "text": "這些還有私校加起來的各家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147933/215.wav", + "text": "高等教育大學" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147933/216.wav", + "text": "身上不能把錢花在他們身上嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147933/217.wav", + "text": "不要告訴我他們的錢都很夠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147933/218.wav", + "text": "好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147933/219.wav", + "text": "謝謝委員您的質詢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147933/220.wav", + "text": "我也在院長旁邊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147933/221.wav", + "text": "我要稍微說明一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147933/222.wav", + "text": "臺灣的高教經費已經很足夠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147933/223.wav", + "text": "這部分有錄影可證" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147933/224.wav", + "text": "第二院長當天所講的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147933/225.wav", + "text": "0.39%是高教工會統計" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147933/226.wav", + "text": "數據不是委員您的統計" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147933/227.wav", + "text": "是啊我說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147933/228.wav", + "text": "他問我數字來源" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147933/229.wav", + "text": "嘛我說這是高教工會的數字來源" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147933/230.wav", + "text": "在說明的過程當中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147933/231.wav", + "text": "已事實上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147933/232.wav", + "text": "因為院長自己擔任過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147933/233.wav", + "text": "國科會的主委" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147933/234.wav", + "text": "他很了解國科會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147933/235.wav", + "text": "長期有很多的經費" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147933/236.wav", + "text": "是用在協助大學" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147933/237.wav", + "text": "學者專家的研究" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147933/238.wav", + "text": "如果以最新的統計" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147933/239.wav", + "text": "一年當中大概有378億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147933/240.wav", + "text": "元是補助大學學者專" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147933/241.wav", + "text": "家院長其實是要表達" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147933/242.wav", + "text": "高教工會提出的0.39" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147933/243.wav", + "text": "這是我想向委員再補充說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147933/244.wav", + "text": "但他是有講1.2" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147933/245.wav", + "text": "對我的意思" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147933/246.wav", + "text": "怎麼可能把國科會的預算加進去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147933/247.wav", + "text": "會有1.2" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147933/248.wav", + "text": "是所以我是說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147933/249.wav", + "text": "怎麼可能占GDP的1.2" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147933/250.wav", + "text": "高教經費或教育經費" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147933/251.wav", + "text": "一定是永遠不夠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147933/252.wav", + "text": "所以他應該要回答我" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147933/253.wav", + "text": "沒有關係" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147933/254.wav", + "text": "那一天過了就過了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147933/255.wav", + "text": "我今天目的就在這裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147933/256.wav", + "text": "我們教育部的認識" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147933/257.wav", + "text": "就我剛才講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147933/258.wav", + "text": "的確是很嚴重不足" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147933/259.wav", + "text": "嘛你看看教授的待遇" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147933/260.wav", + "text": "我真是不好意思講臺灣這些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147933/261.wav", + "text": "教授他們真的是為國犧牲" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147933/262.wav", + "text": "為國付出啊是丐幫嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147933/263.wav", + "text": "包含高教" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147933/264.wav", + "text": "高教今年增加的預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147933/265.wav", + "text": "是25%" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147933/266.wav", + "text": "我剛才已經講過了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147933/267.wav", + "text": "這是長年累積的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147933/268.wav", + "text": "問題我們是希望" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147933/269.wav", + "text": "非常重大的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147933/270.wav", + "text": "也不只是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147933/271.wav", + "text": "大學老師個人的福利問題而已" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147933/272.wav", + "text": "是教育事業" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147933/273.wav", + "text": "問題高教的重要性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147933/274.wav", + "text": "不能又要馬兒好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147933/275.wav", + "text": "又要馬兒不吃草" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147933/276.wav", + "text": "我們都還能夠在高教領域裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147933/277.wav", + "text": "頂天立地" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147933/278.wav", + "text": "有那般優異的表現" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147933/279.wav", + "text": "否則臺灣奇蹟是怎麼創造出來的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147933/280.wav", + "text": "但現在我們已經不斷的被別人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147933/281.wav", + "text": "迎頭趕過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147933/282.wav", + "text": "我們是正在面臨教育崩解的危機" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147933/283.wav", + "text": "表現政府更大的決心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147933/284.wav", + "text": "表現政府更大的誠意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147933/285.wav", + "text": "爭取\n部長我一直講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147933/286.wav", + "text": "我非常的支持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147933/287.wav", + "text": "經費由公部門政府預算的挹注" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147933/288.wav", + "text": "嚴重不足" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147933/289.wav", + "text": "我們大家都樂觀其成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147933/290.wav", + "text": "事實上也不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147933/291.wav", + "text": "啦它算的是我們學生的學雜費" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147933/292.wav", + "text": "回過頭來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147933/293.wav", + "text": "希望在這個部分我剛才講了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147933/294.wav", + "text": "如果有錢的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147933/295.wav", + "text": "不要把錢拿去補助學生的學雜費" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147933/296.wav", + "text": "請把錢拿給學校" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147933/297.wav", + "text": "讓學校能提升教學研究的品質" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147933/298.wav", + "text": "專心的做科研工作" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147933/299.wav", + "text": "否則怎麼跟香港新加坡比" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147933/300.wav", + "text": "現在連大陸都比不過啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147933/301.wav", + "text": "\n部長拜託拜託" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147933/302.wav", + "text": "替我們的高等教育請命發聲" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147933/303.wav", + "text": "船堅炮利遠比不上我們高等教育" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147933/304.wav", + "text": "所培育出來的人才知識創新" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147933/305.wav", + "text": "這才是我們的立國之本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147933/306.wav", + "text": "也是我們未來國安的基石" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147933/307.wav", + "text": "絕對不是那些大炮" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147933/308.wav", + "text": "把我們的錢花在高等教育上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147933/309.wav", + "text": "謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147933/310.wav", + "text": "謝謝委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147933/311.wav", + "text": "我再補充一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147933/312.wav", + "text": "教育的預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147933/313.wav", + "text": "在113年是全體部會排名第三位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147933/314.wav", + "text": "跟社福只差幾十億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147933/315.wav", + "text": "所以行政院支持重視教育" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147933/316.wav", + "text": "我想是從數據就可以看得出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147933/317.wav", + "text": "部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147933/318.wav", + "text": "既然您還很想回答" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147933/319.wav", + "text": "其實我後面還有重要的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147933/320.wav", + "text": "不只是學生被霸凌" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147933/321.wav", + "text": "這個問題在國際上長期都很受重視" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147933/322.wav", + "text": "對這個事情本身的認知都還不夠正視" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147933/323.wav", + "text": "視也沒有事件的統計" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147933/324.wav", + "text": "到底有多少老師被暴力相向被霸凌" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147933/325.wav", + "text": "保護措施管道好像非常的不足" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147933/326.wav", + "text": "不是好像而是事實" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147933/327.wav", + "text": "卻有三成的老師是不快樂的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147933/328.wav", + "text": "壓力指數也高達7" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147933/329.wav", + "text": "也就是我們對於保護" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147933/330.wav", + "text": "到目前為止都還相當嚴重不足" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147933/331.wav", + "text": "的觀念似乎在臺灣社會裡越來越淡薄了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147933/332.wav", + "text": "連老師都會被暴力相向" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147933/333.wav", + "text": "這個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147933/334.wav", + "text": "也希望教育部能夠正視" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147933/335.wav", + "text": "問題好不好謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147933/336.wav", + "text": "好謝謝委員好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147933/337.wav", + "text": "潘部長請回" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147933/338.wav", + "text": "謝謝鄭麗文委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147931/0.wav", + "text": "請部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147931/1.wav", + "text": "今天定這個題目" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147931/2.wav", + "text": "因為勞工退休金的制度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147931/3.wav", + "text": "大家都很關心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147931/4.wav", + "text": "我剛剛聽到好幾位委員質詢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147931/5.wav", + "text": "大家很關心一個問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147931/6.wav", + "text": "是要你改革" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147931/7.wav", + "text": "不是要你解決" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147931/8.wav", + "text": "我今天不是要你提解決方案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147931/9.wav", + "text": "今天的報告真正的重點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147931/10.wav", + "text": "有回答到我們今天的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147931/11.wav", + "text": "是在第3頁第4行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147931/12.wav", + "text": "最後2個字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147931/13.wav", + "text": "就是研議勞動部永遠在研議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147931/14.wav", + "text": "那我們希望的是什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147931/15.wav", + "text": "我們希望的是第5行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147931/16.wav", + "text": "的勞工保險財務改善因應的對策" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147931/17.wav", + "text": "立法院今天希望勞動部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147931/18.wav", + "text": "部長提出來的是對策" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147931/19.wav", + "text": "但是這個對策並不是要你" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147931/20.wav", + "text": "一勞永逸地去解決" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147931/21.wav", + "text": "你可以嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147931/22.wav", + "text": "報告委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147931/23.wav", + "text": "你現在的改善" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147931/24.wav", + "text": "就是撥補" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147931/25.wav", + "text": "對撥補是其中之一" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147931/26.wav", + "text": "我們依法調整費率" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147931/27.wav", + "text": "我們強化納保跟給付的審核" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147931/28.wav", + "text": "年金的改革經驗" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147931/29.wav", + "text": "這都是我們目前在改善的方法之一" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147931/30.wav", + "text": "但是具體的方案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147931/31.wav", + "text": "我真的跟委員報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147931/32.wav", + "text": "這個才是不容易" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147931/33.wav", + "text": "所以剛剛為洲委員講的是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147931/34.wav", + "text": "請你提方向" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147931/35.wav", + "text": "也可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147931/36.wav", + "text": "剛剛會被時代" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147931/37.wav", + "text": "時代力量的邱委員訐譙" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147931/38.wav", + "text": "啊你這裡面什麼都沒提" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147931/39.wav", + "text": "啊你就是報告了現狀" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147931/40.wav", + "text": "然後就說困難很多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147931/41.wav", + "text": "態度審慎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147931/42.wav", + "text": "持續蒐集" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147931/43.wav", + "text": "溝通各界" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147931/44.wav", + "text": "參酌先進國家年金制度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147931/45.wav", + "text": "然後研議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147931/46.wav", + "text": "立法院慢慢等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147931/47.wav", + "text": "你就是這個意思" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147931/48.wav", + "text": "我們上千萬勞工勞保年金要破產" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147931/49.wav", + "text": "啦勞工是民進黨心中最軟的那一塊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147931/50.wav", + "text": "啊部長記得嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147931/51.wav", + "text": "記不記得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147931/52.wav", + "text": "蔡總統說的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147931/53.wav", + "text": "記得吧" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147931/54.wav", + "text": "所以你要硬起來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147931/55.wav", + "text": "啊你要做出事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147931/56.wav", + "text": "你要跟蔡總統交代" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147931/57.wav", + "text": "勞保是政府辦的保險" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147931/58.wav", + "text": "的確有財務的問題要去面對解決" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147931/59.wav", + "text": "但是政府不會讓它破產" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147931/60.wav", + "text": "也不會讓它倒" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147931/61.wav", + "text": "做一些財務的調整" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147931/62.wav", + "text": "明年520以後可能是我在那裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147931/63.wav", + "text": "你站在這裡來問我" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147931/64.wav", + "text": "部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147931/65.wav", + "text": "我們現在要的是方向" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147931/66.wav", + "text": "要的是改革的方向" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147931/67.wav", + "text": "我沒有要你解決" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147931/68.wav", + "text": "時間我不要再跟你扯這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147931/69.wav", + "text": "明年撥補1,200億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147931/70.wav", + "text": "請問還差多少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147931/71.wav", + "text": "假如想要平衡的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147931/72.wav", + "text": "還差多少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147931/73.wav", + "text": "光講明年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147931/74.wav", + "text": "我們不講未來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147931/75.wav", + "text": "不講以前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147931/76.wav", + "text": "明年1,200億夠不夠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147931/77.wav", + "text": "明年夠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147931/78.wav", + "text": "所以明年可以打平就對了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147931/79.wav", + "text": "對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147931/80.wav", + "text": "我跟委員報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147931/81.wav", + "text": "現在的基金" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147931/82.wav", + "text": "餘額到8月底" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147931/83.wav", + "text": "是8,670億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147931/84.wav", + "text": "從106年就開始了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147931/85.wav", + "text": "每年都有逆差的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147931/86.wav", + "text": "基本上是沒有問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147931/87.wav", + "text": "像我們現在1月到8月" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147931/88.wav", + "text": "億就是450億再加上100億特別預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147931/89.wav", + "text": "投資運用獲利881億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147931/90.wav", + "text": "好沒關係部長數字不重要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147931/91.wav", + "text": "你只要說夠就好了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147931/92.wav", + "text": "你的報告裡面有寫到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147931/93.wav", + "text": "現在提出" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147931/94.wav", + "text": "剛剛也有委員提出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147931/95.wav", + "text": "高薪資的人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147931/96.wav", + "text": "比較願意提撥" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147931/97.wav", + "text": "那我想請教的是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147931/98.wav", + "text": "勞動部現在針對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147931/99.wav", + "text": "所謂中低薪資的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147931/100.wav", + "text": "人有沒有什麼辦法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147931/101.wav", + "text": "有什麼新的獎勵措施" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147931/102.wav", + "text": "剛剛講過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147931/103.wav", + "text": "以高薪資所得的為主" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147931/104.wav", + "text": "那你現在針對中低薪資" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147931/105.wav", + "text": "有沒有想出什麼樣的方法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147931/106.wav", + "text": "有更優惠的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147931/107.wav", + "text": "或者鼓勵雇主" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147931/108.wav", + "text": "給予什麼樣的協助" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147931/109.wav", + "text": "有新的改善的方法嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147931/110.wav", + "text": "你有沒有重視" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147931/111.wav", + "text": "為什麼有些人不提供" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147931/112.wav", + "text": "可能因素很多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147931/113.wav", + "text": "他們可能有自己的理財規" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147931/114.wav", + "text": "劃或者是覺得他的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147931/115.wav", + "text": "薪資是不夠負擔的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147931/116.wav", + "text": "但是我也要跟委員說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147931/117.wav", + "text": "平均是六點多萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147931/118.wav", + "text": "我跟委員報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147931/119.wav", + "text": "其實我們從薪資級距第五級" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147931/120.wav", + "text": "2萬8,801元開始" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147931/121.wav", + "text": "前面也有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147931/122.wav", + "text": "就是從兩萬800多開始" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147931/123.wav", + "text": "已經快要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147931/124.wav", + "text": "貼近基本工資了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147931/125.wav", + "text": "有十三萬多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147931/126.wav", + "text": "十三萬多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147931/127.wav", + "text": "在104萬裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147931/128.wav", + "text": "占十三萬多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147931/129.wav", + "text": "3萬6,000的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147931/130.wav", + "text": "了等一會主席又要站起來了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147931/131.wav", + "text": "反正本席" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147931/132.wav", + "text": "就是提醒你" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147931/133.wav", + "text": "我們真正要幫助的是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147931/134.wav", + "text": "更重要的中低收入的勞工" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147931/135.wav", + "text": "所以好好想辦法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147931/136.wav", + "text": "否則明年520" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147931/137.wav", + "text": "你就要站過來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147931/138.wav", + "text": "好不好部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147931/139.wav", + "text": "你要加油" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147931/140.wav", + "text": "啦當了五年多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147931/141.wav", + "text": "這麼長命的勞動部部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147931/142.wav", + "text": "不容易" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147931/143.wav", + "text": "啊你加油啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147931/144.wav", + "text": "好不好謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147930/0.wav", + "text": "謝謝主席主席幫我請一下朱主計長莊部長經濟部陳次長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147930/1.wav", + "text": "今天這個題目其實就是回到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147930/2.wav", + "text": "我們人民最關心的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147930/3.wav", + "text": "也是利用這個題目" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147930/4.wav", + "text": "來檢驗一下政府" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147930/5.wav", + "text": "政務官雖然你不管" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147930/6.wav", + "text": "啦但是你們至少在院會可以反映" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147930/7.wav", + "text": "主計長我先請教一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147930/8.wav", + "text": "你們GDP的計算公式是什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147930/9.wav", + "text": "計算公式就是我們從生產面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147930/10.wav", + "text": "它有從支出面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147930/11.wav", + "text": "我們臺灣GDP計算的公式是什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147930/12.wav", + "text": "一個在主計總處算是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147930/13.wav", + "text": "消費投資政府支出出口進口是多少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147930/14.wav", + "text": "這個是支出面還有生產面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147930/15.wav", + "text": "基本上臺灣計算就是這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147930/16.wav", + "text": "民間消費加上民間投資" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147930/17.wav", + "text": "加上政府支出" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147930/18.wav", + "text": "我們GDP今年為什麼成長疲弱不振" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147930/19.wav", + "text": "主要的原因是什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147930/20.wav", + "text": "消費是好的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147930/21.wav", + "text": "消費是OK的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147930/22.wav", + "text": "投資成長率是比較低" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147930/23.wav", + "text": "出口是怎麼樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147930/24.wav", + "text": "是下降的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147930/25.wav", + "text": "為什麼下降" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147930/26.wav", + "text": "待會兒我會請教" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147930/27.wav", + "text": "經濟部的次長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147930/28.wav", + "text": "我請教一下經濟部次長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147930/29.wav", + "text": "報告委員我們去詢請問一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147930/30.wav", + "text": "出口為什麼沒有成長那麼好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147930/31.wav", + "text": "相對於去年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147930/32.wav", + "text": "我們哪些地區是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147930/33.wav", + "text": "國際市場方面出口的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147930/34.wav", + "text": "你是次長你今天是代表經濟部來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147930/35.wav", + "text": "中國大陸和香港的部分是比較負成長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147930/36.wav", + "text": "對美國對歐洲是有微幅成長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147930/37.wav", + "text": "對東南亞也成長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147930/38.wav", + "text": "最近的需求比較疲弱" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147930/39.wav", + "text": "主計長我跟你講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147930/40.wav", + "text": "大概是看到一些大項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147930/41.wav", + "text": "其實我們今年GDP" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147930/42.wav", + "text": "國外的IMF" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147930/43.wav", + "text": "%你們說有1.5%左右沒有關係" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147930/44.wav", + "text": "但是也都不多啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147930/45.wav", + "text": "成長20%30%" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147930/46.wav", + "text": "所以帶動整個GDP就往下降" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147930/47.wav", + "text": "是不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147930/48.wav", + "text": "但是我問你什麼你就講什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147930/49.wav", + "text": "如果我沒有問你你再講話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147930/50.wav", + "text": "我就對你很大聲" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147930/51.wav", + "text": "我們來看出口的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147930/52.wav", + "text": "主要就是在大陸和香港" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147930/53.wav", + "text": "沒有增加" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147930/54.wav", + "text": "嘛甚至在減少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147930/55.wav", + "text": "我們以前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147930/56.wav", + "text": "講說臺灣賺它多少錢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147930/57.wav", + "text": "大陸講說它賺多少錢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147930/58.wav", + "text": "數字差很多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147930/59.wav", + "text": "但是你去看看今年的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147930/60.wav", + "text": "我拿到的數字是看到8月底" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147930/61.wav", + "text": "對大陸地區包括香港" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147930/62.wav", + "text": "就是減少很多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147930/63.wav", + "text": "嘛所以為什麼有人會提到ECFA的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147930/64.wav", + "text": "我們ECFA一年至少賺人家10" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147930/65.wav", + "text": "億美金的稅率優惠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147930/66.wav", + "text": "這是政策面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147930/67.wav", + "text": "我再請教一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147930/68.wav", + "text": "你人生買的第一個房" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147930/69.wav", + "text": "子你大概幾歲結婚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147930/70.wav", + "text": "大家不要笑" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147930/71.wav", + "text": "這是年輕人的心聲" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147930/72.wav", + "text": "我31歲結婚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147930/73.wav", + "text": "你幾歲買第一個房子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147930/74.wav", + "text": "你父母或岳父母送的不算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147930/75.wav", + "text": "我30歲左右就分期付款買房子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147930/76.wav", + "text": "我的小孩" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147930/77.wav", + "text": "我小孩的朋友" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147930/78.wav", + "text": "我們年齡沒有差幾歲" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147930/79.wav", + "text": "很多年輕人現在45歲以下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147930/80.wav", + "text": "我們那個時代" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147930/81.wav", + "text": "只要存到了買房子的頭款" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147930/82.wav", + "text": "我就敢買房子了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147930/83.wav", + "text": "因為我知道我明年的薪水會增加" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147930/84.wav", + "text": "會超過我的月付" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147930/85.wav", + "text": "現在的年輕人不是這樣子想" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147930/86.wav", + "text": "他們覺得你們那個時候是你們命好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147930/87.wav", + "text": "你們剝奪了我們這一代" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147930/88.wav", + "text": "這是年輕人普遍對社會不滿" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147930/89.wav", + "text": "他們的心聲" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147930/90.wav", + "text": "事實上也是如此" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147930/91.wav", + "text": "啊我們這一代" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147930/92.wav", + "text": "大概都是三十幾歲就買房子了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147930/93.wav", + "text": "努力一點的40歲以前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147930/94.wav", + "text": "大概都可以買房子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147930/95.wav", + "text": "現在呢40歲以前可以買房子的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147930/96.wav", + "text": "我跟你講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147930/97.wav", + "text": "在臺北" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147930/98.wav", + "text": "全臺灣不到10%" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147930/99.wav", + "text": "跟我們那個時候大概70%80%" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147930/100.wav", + "text": "可以買房子的差別就是在這裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147930/101.wav", + "text": "再請教一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147930/102.wav", + "text": "你們的報告裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147930/103.wav", + "text": "在統計裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147930/104.wav", + "text": "平均所得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147930/105.wav", + "text": "你們現在都不講平均所得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147930/106.wav", + "text": "都講中位數" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147930/107.wav", + "text": "這是什麼原因" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147930/108.wav", + "text": "因為中位數比平均低" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147930/109.wav", + "text": "當然" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147930/110.wav", + "text": "啊為什麼在統計上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147930/111.wav", + "text": "通常我們在做檢驗" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147930/112.wav", + "text": "都是假設它是一個什麼分配" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147930/113.wav", + "text": "我們假設它是常態分配" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147930/114.wav", + "text": "我們假設常態分配" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147930/115.wav", + "text": "如果是說兩邊完全對稱的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147930/116.wav", + "text": "常態分配裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147930/117.wav", + "text": "平均數跟中位數就同一點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147930/118.wav", + "text": "現在是右偏" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147930/119.wav", + "text": "現在是右偏" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147930/120.wav", + "text": "為什麼右偏呢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147930/121.wav", + "text": "而且偏得很多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147930/122.wav", + "text": "這就代表什麼東西" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147930/123.wav", + "text": "代表所得不平均" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147930/124.wav", + "text": "嘛我常常舉一個例子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147930/125.wav", + "text": "一個腳" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147930/126.wav", + "text": "踏在100度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147930/127.wav", + "text": "另外一個腳" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147930/128.wav", + "text": "踏在0度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147930/129.wav", + "text": "你說這平均50度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147930/130.wav", + "text": "這感受就不一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147930/131.wav", + "text": "100度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147930/132.wav", + "text": "你的皮會被燙破" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147930/133.wav", + "text": "0度你會覺得很冷" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147930/134.wav", + "text": "結果你看的是中位數" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147930/135.wav", + "text": "只能描述中位數" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147930/136.wav", + "text": "所得分配不均" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147930/137.wav", + "text": "我們的事務官" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147930/138.wav", + "text": "事務官做不了決定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147930/139.wav", + "text": "都是政務官" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147930/140.wav", + "text": "你們來做決定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147930/141.wav", + "text": "為什麼會變成這樣子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147930/142.wav", + "text": "這是你們的政策出了問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147930/143.wav", + "text": "1990年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147930/144.wav", + "text": "我們的GDP" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147930/145.wav", + "text": "不能真正反映在實際的狀況上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147930/146.wav", + "text": "我們這五項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147930/147.wav", + "text": "很多總經的學者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147930/148.wav", + "text": "但是沒有想到比這還要好的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147930/149.wav", + "text": "但我就實際拿這個來看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147930/150.wav", + "text": "1990年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147930/151.wav", + "text": "分給勞工的是51.7%" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147930/152.wav", + "text": "近的數字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147930/153.wav", + "text": "是前年的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147930/154.wav", + "text": "43.03%" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147930/155.wav", + "text": "日本美國都超過50%" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147930/156.wav", + "text": "韓國" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147930/157.wav", + "text": "這就代表" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147930/158.wav", + "text": "勞工享受經濟的成果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147930/159.wav", + "text": "比日本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147930/160.wav", + "text": "比美國" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147930/161.wav", + "text": "比韓國要差" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147930/162.wav", + "text": "我們的盈餘" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147930/163.wav", + "text": "分給投資的人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147930/164.wav", + "text": "就是股東" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147930/165.wav", + "text": "從1990年的不到30%" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147930/166.wav", + "text": "到現在是36.53%" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147930/167.wav", + "text": "換句話說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147930/168.wav", + "text": "經濟的果實" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147930/169.wav", + "text": "沒有全民共享" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147930/170.wav", + "text": "而是傾斜" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147930/171.wav", + "text": "這天平是不平均的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147930/172.wav", + "text": "這個數字這樣解釋" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147930/173.wav", + "text": "你同意嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147930/174.wav", + "text": "就有講到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147930/175.wav", + "text": "因為我都聽了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147930/176.wav", + "text": "我都仔細聽了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147930/177.wav", + "text": "你還有什麼其他新的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147930/178.wav", + "text": "你是想要來辯論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147930/179.wav", + "text": "是不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147930/180.wav", + "text": "我沒有要辯論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147930/181.wav", + "text": "這就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147930/182.wav", + "text": "32年的數字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147930/183.wav", + "text": "我們是拿總經來講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147930/184.wav", + "text": "這個也不需要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147930/185.wav", + "text": "去抹脂" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147930/186.wav", + "text": "塗粉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147930/187.wav", + "text": "這個狀況就是如此" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147930/188.wav", + "text": "嘛這就是大家的感覺" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147930/189.wav", + "text": "事實上反映的成果就是如此" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147930/190.wav", + "text": "平均數中位數" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147930/191.wav", + "text": "我們現在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147930/192.wav", + "text": "%68%的人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147930/193.wav", + "text": "比平均數來得低" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147930/194.wav", + "text": "太偏了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147930/195.wav", + "text": "這是貧富懸殊太偏了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147930/196.wav", + "text": "我們再從稅務上來看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147930/197.wav", + "text": "我跟" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147930/198.wav", + "text": "財政部長講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147930/199.wav", + "text": "這20年其實很多的稅改" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147930/200.wav", + "text": "我若有時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147930/201.wav", + "text": "我可以慢慢的講給你聽" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147930/202.wav", + "text": "張盛和犯了一點錯" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147930/203.wav", + "text": "你們上任的部長犯了一點錯" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147930/204.wav", + "text": "都造成所得平均越來越厲害" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147930/205.wav", + "text": "你們上任部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147930/206.wav", + "text": "分離課稅" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147930/207.wav", + "text": "這就是圖利" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147930/208.wav", + "text": "講寬一點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147930/209.wav", + "text": "才會造成你的所得平均越差越大" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147930/210.wav", + "text": "部長張盛和我跟他很熟" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147930/211.wav", + "text": "你們前任部長是我臺北大學的同事" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147930/212.wav", + "text": "我私下都跟他們講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147930/213.wav", + "text": "我說你們會造成所得平均越來越差" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147930/214.wav", + "text": "果不其然就是如此" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147930/215.wav", + "text": "這是你們財政部的事" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147930/216.wav", + "text": "你不要去怪社會大眾" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147930/217.wav", + "text": "你不要怪年輕人不努力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147930/218.wav", + "text": "結果就是如此" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147930/219.wav", + "text": "就是你們的政策影響到現在所有的產出" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147930/220.wav", + "text": "在生產線上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147930/221.wav", + "text": "你的input" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147930/222.wav", + "text": "經過一個throughput" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147930/223.wav", + "text": "後來就是output" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147930/224.wav", + "text": "你投什麼因" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147930/225.wav", + "text": "這個東西不是說在批評你們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147930/226.wav", + "text": "但是你看這5年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147930/227.wav", + "text": "所得平均" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147930/228.wav", + "text": "財富分配越來越差" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147930/229.wav", + "text": "還有啊主計總處也不光是罵你們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147930/230.wav", + "text": "我覺得是對的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147930/231.wav", + "text": "我們現在一天到晚看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147930/232.wav", + "text": "到前20%和後20%的所得比" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147930/233.wav", + "text": "太多的眉眉角角" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147930/234.wav", + "text": "因為很多很有錢的人是不繳稅的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147930/235.wav", + "text": "剛才講證券所得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147930/236.wav", + "text": "用分離課稅" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147930/237.wav", + "text": "那當然就會扭曲" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147930/238.wav", + "text": "我覺得可以看到真實面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147930/239.wav", + "text": "不是只有所得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147930/240.wav", + "text": "很多有錢人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147930/241.wav", + "text": "臺灣的地下經濟這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147930/242.wav", + "text": "好了我最後請教一個問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147930/243.wav", + "text": "地下經濟占我們的經濟" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147930/244.wav", + "text": "比重有多高" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147930/245.wav", + "text": "那要看地下經濟的定義" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147930/246.wav", + "text": "好吧你來講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147930/247.wav", + "text": "我讓你先定義" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147930/248.wav", + "text": "你來告訴我這個數字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147930/249.wav", + "text": "我們在做國民所得估計的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147930/250.wav", + "text": "地下經濟是有考慮在裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147930/251.wav", + "text": "除非它是非法的經濟" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147930/252.wav", + "text": "你不要講那麼多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147930/253.wav", + "text": "一般的經濟學者講的地下經濟" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147930/254.wav", + "text": "他們有些人認為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147930/255.wav", + "text": "沒有透過租稅體系的就是地下經濟" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147930/256.wav", + "text": "這個東西我覺得我是可以接受的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147930/257.wav", + "text": "沒有透過租稅" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147930/258.wav", + "text": "所產出來的結果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147930/259.wav", + "text": "總稱就是地下經濟" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147930/260.wav", + "text": "占三分之一" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147930/261.wav", + "text": "所以你們所得平均" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147930/262.wav", + "text": "看這個東西" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147930/263.wav", + "text": "是看偏的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147930/264.wav", + "text": "是看歪的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147930/265.wav", + "text": "國富調查我是覺得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147930/266.wav", + "text": "至少可以還原一點真相" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147930/267.wav", + "text": "不要粉飾太平" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147930/268.wav", + "text": "真的不要粉飾太平" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147930/269.wav", + "text": "粉飾太平是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147930/270.wav", + "text": "讓年輕一代越來越討厭這個政府" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147930/271.wav", + "text": "因為年輕一代對年長者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147930/272.wav", + "text": "越來越有對抗的意思" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147930/273.wav", + "text": "這個社會上的不和諧是誰造成的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147930/274.wav", + "text": "就是政府" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147930/275.wav", + "text": "你不要跟我講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147930/276.wav", + "text": "不是你可以管的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147930/277.wav", + "text": "但是你是政務官" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147930/278.wav", + "text": "老百姓更不能管" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147930/279.wav", + "text": "我們的事務官也只會表達一點意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147930/280.wav", + "text": "但是最後產出的結果卻是全民承受" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147930/281.wav", + "text": "今天之所以這樣子排" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147930/282.wav", + "text": "現在政府或以後的政府" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147930/283.wav", + "text": "當政務官的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147930/284.wav", + "text": "務實一點替人民想想" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147930/285.wav", + "text": "一定要想出方法來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147930/286.wav", + "text": "我的政黨在執政的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147930/287.wav", + "text": "我一直給他們很多的意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147930/288.wav", + "text": "我們現在當在野黨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147930/289.wav", + "text": "給他們意見聽都不聽" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147930/290.wav", + "text": "像你們聽都不聽" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147930/291.wav", + "text": "就會造成今天這樣的結果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147930/292.wav", + "text": "我跟你講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147930/293.wav", + "text": "所得平均的問題在臺灣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147930/294.wav", + "text": "是惡化的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147929/0.wav", + "text": "謝謝主席我想請部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147929/1.wav", + "text": "有請部長謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147929/2.wav", + "text": "這個當然是攸關國人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147929/3.wav", + "text": "包括1,000萬的臺灣勞工影響甚鉅" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147929/4.wav", + "text": "結果一看之後我嚇了一跳" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147929/5.wav", + "text": "薄薄5頁部長你自己也是律師這可以接受嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147929/6.wav", + "text": "然後其中2頁還是封面等於只有3頁" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147929/7.wav", + "text": "而且還是攸關這麼重要的一個議題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147929/8.wav", + "text": "這3頁上面除了放上公開的統計" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147929/9.wav", + "text": "簡單交代勞保勞退投保跟扣繳的現況之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147929/10.wav", + "text": "這3頁裡面包含了這些統計" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147929/11.wav", + "text": "扣掉這些統計之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147929/12.wav", + "text": "對於這一個退休制度的改革跟它的精進" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147929/13.wav", + "text": "現在大家要看的就是怎麼辦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147929/14.wav", + "text": "勞保都已經要破產了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147929/15.wav", + "text": "到底這個改革的方案精進方案是什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147929/16.wav", + "text": "結果隻字未提" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147929/17.wav", + "text": "這麼隨便又怠惰的行政行為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147929/18.wav", + "text": "把這些勞工的權益當塑膠嘛部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147929/19.wav", + "text": "勞工退休制度的改革" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147929/20.wav", + "text": "是一個現在進行式當中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147929/21.wav", + "text": "啦目前是還沒有具體的方案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147929/22.wav", + "text": "所以我們沒有辦法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147929/23.wav", + "text": "我想如果已經有方案也不可能只有3頁" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147929/24.wav", + "text": "恐怕要寫30頁都不只" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147929/25.wav", + "text": "我們是就目前大致上的勞保及" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147929/26.wav", + "text": "勞退的情形跟大家做說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147929/27.wav", + "text": "至於最重要的改革方案部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147929/28.wav", + "text": "這是現在進行式我們還在溝通" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147929/29.wav", + "text": "還在蒐集各界意見凝聚共識當中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147929/30.wav", + "text": "所以這個部分我也請各位能夠諒解" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147929/31.wav", + "text": "我們也願意積極地去面對問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147929/32.wav", + "text": "重視這個問題並且來解決" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147929/33.wav", + "text": "部長如果像你講的這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147929/34.wav", + "text": "還在跟社會各界溝通方案現在還沒定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147929/35.wav", + "text": "那麼這個報告的內容也應該要指出這一點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147929/36.wav", + "text": "嘛到底現在的進度是什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147929/37.wav", + "text": "我相信除了部長自己是律師之外" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147929/38.wav", + "text": "其他的勞動部所屬公務員官員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147929/39.wav", + "text": "後這麼辛辛苦苦進入勞動部的體系裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147929/40.wav", + "text": "勞保勞退制度改革" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147929/41.wav", + "text": "增進勞工退休生活的題目" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147929/42.wav", + "text": "你交了5頁的報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147929/43.wav", + "text": "2頁是封面3頁是圖表" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147929/44.wav", + "text": "然後裡面對於勞保勞退制度改革" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147929/45.wav", + "text": "隻字未提這讓人無法接受耶部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147929/46.wav", + "text": "就要交30頁啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147929/47.wav", + "text": "難道臺灣的國會議員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147929/48.wav", + "text": "連讀一個30頁的報告都沒辦法嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147929/49.wav", + "text": "這也太小看人了吧" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147929/50.wav", + "text": "\n現在這麼嚴重的一個問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147929/51.wav", + "text": "方案未定也會有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147929/52.wav", + "text": "第一個方案第二個方案第三個方案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147929/53.wav", + "text": "第四個方案等全部的方案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147929/54.wav", + "text": "到底是什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147929/55.wav", + "text": "應該要拿出來大家來討論嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147929/56.wav", + "text": "什麼叫做審議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147929/57.wav", + "text": "它的意義不就是在這裡嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147929/58.wav", + "text": "排了一個專案報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147929/59.wav", + "text": "說實在的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147929/60.wav", + "text": "比小學生的報告還不如啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147929/61.wav", + "text": "今天你如果到小學裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147929/62.wav", + "text": "告訴大家說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147929/63.wav", + "text": "老師定一個題目" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147929/64.wav", + "text": "大家來討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147929/65.wav", + "text": "這個報告老師要給幾分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147929/66.wav", + "text": "能夠接受嗎部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147929/67.wav", + "text": "你自己是律師耶" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147929/68.wav", + "text": "交出一個5頁的狀紙" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147929/69.wav", + "text": "其中2頁是封面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147929/70.wav", + "text": "3頁都是圖表" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147929/71.wav", + "text": "法官可以接受" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147929/72.wav", + "text": "對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147929/73.wav", + "text": "所以這個最起碼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147929/74.wav", + "text": "就是你要有一個態度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147929/75.wav", + "text": "那個態度就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147929/76.wav", + "text": "我們認真的面對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147929/77.wav", + "text": "勞保即將要破產" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147929/78.wav", + "text": "這麼嚴重的一個問題嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147929/79.wav", + "text": "都是這麼的敷衍" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147929/80.wav", + "text": "這麼怠惰這麼隨便" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147929/81.wav", + "text": "這麼草率的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147929/82.wav", + "text": "那大家很明顯的就會知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147929/83.wav", + "text": "你根本就沒���把這些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147929/84.wav", + "text": "勞工的權益當作一回事嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147929/85.wav", + "text": "從111年度勞保" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147929/86.wav", + "text": "年金給付金額的級距" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147929/87.wav", + "text": "可以看到平均不到2萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147929/88.wav", + "text": "月領是低於兩萬是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147929/89.wav", + "text": "這樣的狀況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147929/90.wav", + "text": "你可以看到在111年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147929/91.wav", + "text": "這一張圖表可以顯示什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147929/92.wav", + "text": "就是薪資越低" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147929/93.wav", + "text": "越不會自提" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147929/94.wav", + "text": "那就沒有辦法保障低薪的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147929/95.wav", + "text": "勞工" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147929/96.wav", + "text": "所以這些基層這些艱苦人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147929/97.wav", + "text": "這些最基層" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147929/98.wav", + "text": "低薪的勞工" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147929/99.wav", + "text": "這是一個多麼嚴肅的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147929/100.wav", + "text": "\n最後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147929/101.wav", + "text": "部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147929/102.wav", + "text": "勞保破產這個問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147929/103.wav", + "text": "許多委員也提過了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147929/104.wav", + "text": "用撥補的方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147929/105.wav", + "text": "是一個解方嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147929/106.wav", + "text": "部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147929/107.wav", + "text": "報告委員我一直說明說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147929/108.wav", + "text": "的確是需要解決" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147929/109.wav", + "text": "輕忽這個問題我們都非常重視" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147929/110.wav", + "text": "也想辦法來因應" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147929/111.wav", + "text": "解決的方法之一是先穩定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147929/112.wav", + "text": "所以用撥補" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147929/113.wav", + "text": "的方式這個就是要來穩定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147929/114.wav", + "text": "基金的流量" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147929/115.wav", + "text": "那其他面向的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147929/116.wav", + "text": "來瞭解大家的意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147929/117.wav", + "text": "我們願意來廣納" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147929/118.wav", + "text": "我們就是認為這是一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147929/119.wav", + "text": "關係到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147929/120.wav", + "text": "千萬勞工非常重要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147929/121.wav", + "text": "複雜的議題我們必須" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147929/122.wav", + "text": "負責任地去把這些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147929/123.wav", + "text": "問題用理性的對話凝聚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147929/124.wav", + "text": "來進行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147929/125.wav", + "text": "所以我們絕對沒有輕忽" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147929/126.wav", + "text": "也沒有怠惰而是用更審慎的態度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147929/127.wav", + "text": "來解決" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147929/128.wav", + "text": "及面對這個問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147929/129.wav", + "text": "所以我們不會去迴避它" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147929/130.wav", + "text": "部長我想請教" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147929/131.wav", + "text": "用缺乏社會共識" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147929/132.wav", + "text": "好那我講一下就是說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147929/133.wav", + "text": "如果確實" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147929/134.wav", + "text": "持續在跟團體溝通討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147929/135.wav", + "text": "我具體的訴求" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147929/136.wav", + "text": "向國會提出會議紀錄跟討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147929/137.wav", + "text": "的進度你總得要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147929/138.wav", + "text": "有一個進度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147929/139.wav", + "text": "嘛現在你在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147929/140.wav", + "text": "這裡答詢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147929/141.wav", + "text": "之前在報章雜誌" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147929/142.wav", + "text": "上面你所講的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147929/143.wav", + "text": "我們收集起來就是缺乏" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147929/144.wav", + "text": "社會共識還在跟工會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147929/145.wav", + "text": "討論還在跟雇主團體討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147929/146.wav", + "text": "等等你的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147929/147.wav", + "text": "說法都是這樣嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147929/148.wav", + "text": "那是不是能夠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147929/149.wav", + "text": "有一個定期的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147929/150.wav", + "text": "回答這一題就好了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147929/151.wav", + "text": "\n是不是可以定期地" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147929/152.wav", + "text": "確實地向國會提出會議紀錄" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147929/153.wav", + "text": "跟討論的進度部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147929/154.wav", + "text": "的方式我請業務單位來做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147929/155.wav", + "text": "部長真的啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147929/156.wav", + "text": "我語重心長這個關係到這麼多人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147929/157.wav", + "text": "你基本上就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147929/158.wav", + "text": "應該提出一個討論的進度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147929/159.wav", + "text": "否則的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147929/160.wav", + "text": "排了一個專案報告專案報告下去之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147929/161.wav", + "text": "5頁裡面有2頁是封面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147929/162.wav", + "text": "我們能夠接受嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147929/163.wav", + "text": "這對這個委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147929/164.wav", + "text": "是非常不尊重的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147928/0.wav", + "text": "請代主委" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147928/1.wav", + "text": "請陳部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147928/2.wav", + "text": "有遭虐的嫌疑" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147928/3.wav", + "text": "曾跟屏東縣政府檢舉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147928/4.wav", + "text": "我在這裡請農業部一個禮拜" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147928/5.wav", + "text": "醫對所謂的牛病專家跟馬匹專家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147928/6.wav", + "text": "跟委員報告牛跟馬是完全不一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147928/7.wav", + "text": "對基本上牛是偶" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147928/8.wav", + "text": "牛病的專家去看這個馬匹" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147928/9.wav", + "text": "國內相關的草食性動物專家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147928/10.wav", + "text": "其實還是有分領域" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147928/11.wav", + "text": "我們可以來請包括后里還有其他的馬匹專家也一起來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147928/12.wav", + "text": "因為這個案子已經陳情非常久了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147928/13.wav", + "text": "屏東縣政府好像沒有處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147928/14.wav", + "text": "\n再來要跟代部長講一件很嚴肅的事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147928/15.wav", + "text": "─我們的農糧署發假消息" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147928/16.wav", + "text": "農糧署為什麼發假消息" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147928/17.wav", + "text": "針對花蓮瑞穗" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147928/18.wav", + "text": "好的柚子都賣不出去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147928/19.wav", + "text": "而且價格也殺得非常低" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147928/20.wav", + "text": "甚至一斤不到一塊錢這樣的情況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147928/21.wav", + "text": "我昨天召開記者會用意就是希望" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147928/22.wav", + "text": "還有行銷規劃" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147928/23.wav", + "text": "結果我昨天開完記者會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147928/24.wav", + "text": "農糧署就發了這個假消息" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147928/25.wav", + "text": "他們要把他們滯銷的柚子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147928/26.wav", + "text": "拿到農業部來抗議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147928/27.wav", + "text": "因為昨天發的新聞稿" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147928/28.wav", + "text": "有許多錯誤" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147928/29.wav", + "text": "包括說現在滯銷的都是次級品" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147928/30.wav", + "text": "可是農友表示他們現在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147928/31.wav", + "text": "也滯銷啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147928/32.wav", + "text": "為什麼農糧署要這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147928/33.wav", + "text": "再次來傷害我們的農民" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147928/34.wav", + "text": "現在他們要把所有滯" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147928/35.wav", + "text": "滯銷的優良品從瑞穗拿到農業部來抗議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147928/36.wav", + "text": "我跟委員說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147928/37.wav", + "text": "不是在一天同時採收的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147928/38.wav", + "text": "它有一個時間點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147928/39.wav", + "text": "那麼它的果實大概分兩類" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147928/40.wav", + "text": "請代部長去看一下他們發的新聞稿" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147928/41.wav", + "text": "他們說多數農友皆已銷售完畢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147928/42.wav", + "text": "而且價格也不穩定啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147928/43.wav", + "text": "目前已經到產季末要結束了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147928/44.wav", + "text": "價格其實賣得非常好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147928/45.wav", + "text": "以我們現在的資訊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147928/46.wav", + "text": "代部長收到的資訊是錯的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147928/47.wav", + "text": "現在樹上的優良品也不去採收了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147928/48.wav", + "text": "根本賣不出去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147928/49.wav", + "text": "不是你講的優良品也賣得非常好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147928/50.wav", + "text": "錯" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147928/51.wav", + "text": "文旦的果實越大" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147928/52.wav", + "text": "它的品質越差" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147928/53.wav", + "text": "現在掛在樹上的都是一些次級品" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147928/54.wav", + "text": "因為前一陣子颱風過境吸收水" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147928/55.wav", + "text": "你沒有聽到我剛剛的說明嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147928/56.wav", + "text": "我剛剛說農友表示" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147928/57.wav", + "text": "目前滯銷的是有產銷履歷的非次級品啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147928/58.wav", + "text": "你現在還沒有確定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147928/59.wav", + "text": "就說他們滯銷的都是次級品" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147928/60.wav", + "text": "差別在這裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147928/61.wav", + "text": "我跟委員說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147928/62.wav", + "text": "我想農業部沒辦法認同這樣的事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147928/63.wav", + "text": "農業部可以查清楚嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147928/64.wav", + "text": "今天農友要把所有好的滯銷的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147928/65.wav", + "text": "柚子運到農業部來抗議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147928/66.wav", + "text": "我相信如果你去問所有種植文旦的果農" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147928/67.wav", + "text": "包括西部的東部的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147928/68.wav", + "text": "其實大部分的農友都滿支持我們農業部的政策" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147928/69.wav", + "text": "特別是優良果實的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147928/70.wav", + "text": "今年的價格是八年來最高的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147928/71.wav", + "text": "我們也讓它去加工做成精油" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147928/72.wav", + "text": "讓它可以有多元循環的利用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147928/73.wav", + "text": "少數的一些農友如果管理不當" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147928/74.wav", + "text": "那麼這些管理不當應該是農民" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147928/75.wav", + "text": "所以你現在又再次傷害我們瑞穗的農民嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147928/76.wav", + "text": "滯銷的都是次級品嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147928/77.wav", + "text": "你現在回答我的還是這樣嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147928/78.wav", + "text": "其實我們農業部門針對文旦本身" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147928/79.wav", + "text": "那你今天下班之前能夠給我數據嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147928/80.wav", + "text": "滯銷的是哪些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147928/81.wav", + "text": "有沒有非次級" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147928/82.wav", + "text": "下班前可以給我嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147928/83.wav", + "text": "我下班前可能沒辦法給你" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147928/84.wav", + "text": "那你需要幾天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147928/85.wav", + "text": "不是因為委員要求的這些數據不夠明確" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147928/86.wav", + "text": "我知道沒關係" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147928/87.wav", + "text": "農業部可以調查清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147928/88.wav", + "text": "兩天內或三天內可以給本席嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147928/89.wav", + "text": "今天先確認農糧署是不是發布假訊息" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147928/90.wav", + "text": "就是現在滯銷的是優良品還是次級品可以嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147928/91.wav", + "text": "我想大果的部分是一個次級品" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147928/92.wav", + "text": "但如果大果裡面夾雜少量的這些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147928/93.wav", + "text": "你現在還沒有調查就告訴我是少量" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147928/94.wav", + "text": "我沒辦法相信你啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147928/95.wav", + "text": "我請你調查之後再來說明可以嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147928/96.wav", + "text": "我跟委員說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147928/97.wav", + "text": "幾乎每天都到文旦園那邊去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147928/98.wav", + "text": "我告訴代部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147928/99.wav", + "text": "我要了一兩個禮拜的數據一直要不到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147928/100.wav", + "text": "到昨天的記者會也沒有給我正確的數據" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147928/101.wav", + "text": "那麼代部長要調查嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147928/102.wav", + "text": "你先告訴我要不要調查之後再來確認" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147928/103.wav", + "text": "就瑞穗啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147928/104.wav", + "text": "你就問農會啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147928/105.wav", + "text": "好那麼你要幾天嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147928/106.wav", + "text": "我沒辦法普查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147928/107.wav", + "text": "如果委員知道哪些農友有這樣的抱怨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147928/108.wav", + "text": "我們可以去瞭解到底是哪邊出問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147928/109.wav", + "text": "這個資料可以找" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147928/110.wav", + "text": "但如果說要普查所有的果農" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147928/111.wav", + "text": "量有多少是不是次級品優良品" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147928/112.wav", + "text": "你們都沒辦法查嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147928/113.wav", + "text": "難道要像雞蛋一樣都是查不清楚嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147928/114.wav", + "text": "我要跟委員說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147928/115.wav", + "text": "農業在瑞穗那邊有850公頃" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147928/116.wav", + "text": "好那你要幾天才查得清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147928/117.wav", + "text": "我沒有辦法做普查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147928/118.wav", + "text": "好代部長你需要幾天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147928/119.wav", + "text": "來告訴我瑞穗現在滯銷的量還有多少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147928/120.wav", + "text": "你需要幾天嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147928/121.wav", + "text": "一個禮拜可以嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147928/122.wav", + "text": "報告我們的文旦買賣是自由買賣的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147928/123.wav", + "text": "而不是說統一交到農業" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147928/124.wav", + "text": "你就去查有沒有滯銷嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147928/125.wav", + "text": "我可以講一個大概的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147928/126.wav", + "text": "我不可能每一個去普查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147928/127.wav", + "text": "好請你快講需要多少天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147928/128.wav", + "text": "報告委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147928/129.wav", + "text": "告訴我要多少天可以嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147928/130.wav", + "text": "因為下一位委員在等我了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147928/131.wav", + "text": "我們會請農會鄉鎮公所跟縣市政府一起來查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147928/132.wav", + "text": "請你們告訴我不要叫別人告訴我" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147928/133.wav", + "text": "請農業部告訴我不要把責任推給別人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147928/134.wav", + "text": "我告訴委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147928/135.wav", + "text": "大家一起為農民的產品去行銷這非常好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147928/136.wav", + "text": "但是中央跟地方一定是合作的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147928/137.wav", + "text": "拜託主席請代部長回答" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147928/138.wav", + "text": "是不是一個禮拜或三天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147928/139.wav", + "text": "這個資訊我們很難調查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147928/140.wav", + "text": "我不是不給" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147928/141.wav", + "text": "我真的不是不給" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147928/142.wav", + "text": "你們沒能力調查嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147928/143.wav", + "text": "目前滯銷的量有多少沒辦法調查嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147928/144.wav", + "text": "估一個量不行嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147928/145.wav", + "text": "因為我們現在都還在輔導當中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147928/146.wav", + "text": "我告訴你現在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147928/147.wav", + "text": "花蓮農會說次級果有900噸" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147928/148.wav", + "text": "到現在為止到底是幾噸" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147928/149.wav", + "text": "你們沒辦法調查嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147928/150.wav", + "text": "真的是無能到極點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147928/151.wav", + "text": "然後這900噸是怎麼樣得到的一個訊息" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147928/152.wav", + "text": "在最近的時間裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147928/153.wav", + "text": "把相關的資料整理一下給我們委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147927/0.wav", + "text": "謝謝主席秘書長在我要質詢前先請教你一件事" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147927/1.wav", + "text": "我聽到你答復委員的一席話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147927/2.wav", + "text": "讓我有點不能理解怎麼會這樣答復也" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147927/3.wav", + "text": "是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147927/4.wav", + "text": "不要因為文字長這樣就預設不能協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147927/5.wav", + "text": "可能會有些誤解" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147927/6.wav", + "text": "所以我是用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147927/7.wav", + "text": "因為實際上我們與消防署基層同仁" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147927/8.wav", + "text": "對很多安全事項都有在溝通" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147927/9.wav", + "text": "所以我們不會是不能協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147927/10.wav", + "text": "那是違反這樣的一個狀況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147927/11.wav", + "text": "才會不能協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147927/12.wav", + "text": "不要因為文字長這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147927/13.wav", + "text": "我講得有點快" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147927/14.wav", + "text": "然後認為這件事沒有納入協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147927/15.wav", + "text": "我講得可能快了一點不好意思" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147927/16.wav", + "text": "我不是在找你的語病你不要誤會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147927/17.wav", + "text": "因為你答復這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147927/18.wav", + "text": "就代表這文字長這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147927/19.wav", + "text": "這已經有問題了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147927/20.wav", + "text": "所以大家才會誤解" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147927/21.wav", + "text": "應該是這麼說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147927/22.wav", + "text": "我的措辭有點太快" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147927/23.wav", + "text": "不不但如果你現在要再修正你的措辭" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147927/24.wav", + "text": "就代表這文字長這樣是正常的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147927/25.wav", + "text": "其實是沒有問題的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147927/26.wav", + "text": "所以不應該用文字長這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147927/27.wav", + "text": "文字長這樣也算是正常" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147927/28.wav", + "text": "但剛剛聽起來就覺得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147927/29.wav", + "text": "文字長這樣是不正常" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147927/30.wav", + "text": "那我現在要提醒你" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147927/31.wav", + "text": "我覺得這文字長這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147927/32.wav", + "text": "是真的不太正常" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147927/33.wav", + "text": "所以容易造成人家誤解" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147927/34.wav", + "text": "你看2004年到2023" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147927/35.wav", + "text": "我沒有這個數字不好意思" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147927/36.wav", + "text": "總共五十八位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147927/37.wav", + "text": "這樣的數字讓我們難以承受" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147927/38.wav", + "text": "有五十八個消防弟兄" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147927/39.wav", + "text": "而喪失自己的生命" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147927/40.wav", + "text": "這些消防弟兄一直希望可以組工會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147927/41.wav", + "text": "對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147927/42.wav", + "text": "也因此打算從公務人員協會法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147927/43.wav", + "text": "特種公務員協會所涵蓋的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147927/44.wav", + "text": "司法人員主計人員關務人員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147927/45.wav", + "text": "警察人員及醫事人員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147927/46.wav", + "text": "於消防還是納入警察人員的範疇裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147927/47.wav", + "text": "這個其實銓敘部有責任" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147927/48.wav", + "text": "沒關係" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147927/49.wav", + "text": "我一件一件講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147927/50.wav", + "text": "我只是要凸顯這文字確實是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147927/51.wav", + "text": "長這樣真的是有問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147927/52.wav", + "text": "你們的草案一出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147927/53.wav", + "text": "確定有跟這些消防人員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147927/54.wav", + "text": "的相關代表溝通過嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147927/55.wav", + "text": "跟委員報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147927/56.wav", + "text": "我們在110年就有一次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147927/57.wav", + "text": "110年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147927/58.wav", + "text": "召開諮詢會時也有找他們一起來討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147927/59.wav", + "text": "今年6月" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147927/60.wav", + "text": "屏東那個事件之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147927/61.wav", + "text": "有再溝通過嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147927/62.wav", + "text": "沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147927/63.wav", + "text": "那沒有為什麼你們會急就章" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147927/64.wav", + "text": "因為本來就在準備" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147927/65.wav", + "text": "然後為因應這事件" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147927/66.wav", + "text": "需要來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147927/67.wav", + "text": "提升初擬一項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147927/68.wav", + "text": "畢竟有些法案具有複雜性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147927/69.wav", + "text": "透過各種方式來溝通協調" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147927/70.wav", + "text": "這個我都尊重" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147927/71.wav", + "text": "但從110年到今年6月" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147927/72.wav", + "text": "我們不願意見到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147927/73.wav", + "text": "怎麼不找他們一起來討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147927/74.wav", + "text": "而且他們有這樣的訴求" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147927/75.wav", + "text": "所以你們的文字提出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147927/76.wav", + "text": "才會讓秘書長講出這種話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147927/77.wav", + "text": "這文字長這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147927/78.wav", + "text": "但是也期待大家不要誤會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147927/79.wav", + "text": "不要去預設他不能協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147927/80.wav", + "text": "這是其一" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147927/81.wav", + "text": "我只是提醒" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147927/82.wav", + "text": "我真的是用討論的心情來跟你們討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147927/83.wav", + "text": "不然秘書長的鬍鬚會越來越白" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147927/84.wav", + "text": "\n第二件事" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147927/85.wav", + "text": "們增加了第4款和第8" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147927/86.wav", + "text": "工作簡化" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147927/87.wav", + "text": "業績績效評核基準" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147927/88.wav", + "text": "訓練及進修" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147927/89.wav", + "text": "員工身心健康協助" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147927/90.wav", + "text": "還有全國" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147927/91.wav", + "text": "一致性規定之各機關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147927/92.wav", + "text": "的福利措施" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147927/93.wav", + "text": "你們還同時規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147927/94.wav", + "text": "有下列各款情形者不得提出" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147927/95.wav", + "text": "尤其是第4款" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147927/96.wav", + "text": "與國防安全海巡相關事項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147927/97.wav", + "text": "或足以妨害警政" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147927/98.wav", + "text": "役政移民" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147927/99.wav", + "text": "消防及災害防救等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147927/100.wav", + "text": "整體勤務執行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147927/101.wav", + "text": "安全事項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147927/102.wav", + "text": "我要請教部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147927/103.wav", + "text": "消防員有什麼無關消防" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147927/104.wav", + "text": "救災的事項可以跟機關協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147927/105.wav", + "text": "第3款的勤休方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147927/106.wav", + "text": "就一定跟消防能力的配置" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147927/107.wav", + "text": "就成為不得協商的項目" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147927/108.wav", + "text": "它是可以協商的項目" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147927/109.wav", + "text": "對在上面是可以協商的項目" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147927/110.wav", + "text": "但對照你們的第4款" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147927/111.wav", + "text": "消防災害" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147927/112.wav", + "text": "防救等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147927/113.wav", + "text": "整體勤務執行安全事項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147927/114.wav", + "text": "這邊講到的是足以妨害" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147927/115.wav", + "text": "害整體勤務執行安全事項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147927/116.wav", + "text": "足以妨害的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147927/117.wav", + "text": "會妨害的才會有不得協商的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147927/118.wav", + "text": "如果是提升增進的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147927/119.wav", + "text": "���是可以的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147927/120.wav", + "text": "原則上我們會根據他所提供的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147927/121.wav", + "text": "參酌相關機關的意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147927/122.wav", + "text": "這個是不是構成足以妨不" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147927/123.wav", + "text": "不是你對照" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147927/124.wav", + "text": "不要說文字長這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147927/125.wav", + "text": "我就覺得它跟消防人力的配置" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147927/126.wav", + "text": "跟救災的勤務有關係" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147927/127.wav", + "text": "對這個是可以協商的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147927/128.wav", + "text": "因為前面講的是可以協商的事項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147927/129.wav", + "text": "整體勤務執行的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147927/130.wav", + "text": "這個才不能協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147927/131.wav", + "text": "本來勤休方式就是可以協商的事" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147927/132.wav", + "text": "除非這個勤休方式的要求" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147927/133.wav", + "text": "譬如他提出的意見是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147927/134.wav", + "text": "我就不出勤" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147927/135.wav", + "text": "或者是我必須要週休" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147927/136.wav", + "text": "3日4日" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147927/137.wav", + "text": "這種會妨害整體" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147927/138.wav", + "text": "勤務執行的事項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147927/139.wav", + "text": "能夠提升的都是可以協商的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147927/140.wav", + "text": "會造成妨害的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147927/141.wav", + "text": "當然是不能協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147927/142.wav", + "text": "你說可以提升的就可以協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147927/143.wav", + "text": "對都是可以協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147927/144.wav", + "text": "的只要是增進他們勤務安全所執行的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147927/145.wav", + "text": "事項都可以協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147927/146.wav", + "text": "我覺得這個有很大的盲點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147927/147.wav", + "text": "你要不要思考一下這種講法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147927/148.wav", + "text": "是這部分我們是根據那次的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147927/149.wav", + "text": "諮詢會議參考學者的意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147927/150.wav", + "text": "跟他們參與者的意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147927/151.wav", + "text": "抱歉參考學者意見還有參考誰的意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147927/152.wav", + "text": "學者的意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147927/153.wav", + "text": "對還有誰的意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147927/154.wav", + "text": "還有消促會的代表我們也邀請他們出席諮詢會議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147927/155.wav", + "text": "你說今年六月" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147927/156.wav", + "text": "對六月的那一場諮詢會議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147927/157.wav", + "text": "有消防員的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147927/158.wav", + "text": "代表參加" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147927/159.wav", + "text": "你確定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147927/160.wav", + "text": "完你不要太急好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147927/161.wav", + "text": "那基本上他們對你們提出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147927/162.wav", + "text": "的這個修正草案應該是接受" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147927/163.wav", + "text": "應該不會有意��" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147927/164.wav", + "text": "因為最後修正草案出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147927/165.wav", + "text": "並沒有完全" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147927/166.wav", + "text": "把諮詢會議各方意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147927/167.wav", + "text": "是嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147927/168.wav", + "text": "學者提供的意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147927/169.wav", + "text": "我跟委員報告一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147927/170.wav", + "text": "還是採納這些消防" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147927/171.wav", + "text": "代表者的意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147927/172.wav", + "text": "當然不可能全部採納" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147927/173.wav", + "text": "這個我接受但是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147927/174.wav", + "text": "你如果全部都採用學者的意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147927/175.wav", + "text": "就這一項是採納" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147927/176.wav", + "text": "學者的意見我可以這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147927/177.wav", + "text": "我沒有辦法表達到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147927/178.wav", + "text": "讓你可以認定我講的方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147927/179.wav", + "text": "或讓你可以不要預設" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147927/180.wav", + "text": "我講的對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147927/181.wav", + "text": "不過我覺得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147927/182.wav", + "text": "你答復我的是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147927/183.wav", + "text": "有問題的說法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147927/184.wav", + "text": "啦文字的部分我們到時候都可以來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147927/185.wav", + "text": "就提醒一下如果委員去對照" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147927/186.wav", + "text": "現在這個條文的寫法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147927/187.wav", + "text": "本來第4項寫的是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147927/188.wav", + "text": "與國防安全警政" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147927/189.wav", + "text": "獄政消防及災害防救等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147927/190.wav", + "text": "事項相關者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147927/191.wav", + "text": "跟這些事項相關的都" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147927/192.wav", + "text": "不能協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147927/193.wav", + "text": "所以很明顯的會有委員所講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147927/194.wav", + "text": "意見認為這樣的話對於協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147927/195.wav", + "text": "事項的限制太嚴格了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147927/196.wav", + "text": "不能協商的話是不是太過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147927/197.wav", + "text": "限縮了那個協商空間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147927/198.wav", + "text": "所以他們這次才把這個條文修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147927/199.wav", + "text": "這些整體" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147927/200.wav", + "text": "勤務執行安全的事項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147927/201.wav", + "text": "讓不能協商的範圍被縮小" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147927/202.wav", + "text": "這樣子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147927/203.wav", + "text": "我現在講一個現狀" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147927/204.wav", + "text": "所以我們把這個文字變成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147927/205.wav", + "text": "足以妨害" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147927/206.wav", + "text": "是足以妨害的前提" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147927/207.wav", + "text": "呢它現在的人力一直很吃緊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147927/208.wav", + "text": "人力一直吃緊的情況下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147927/209.wav", + "text": "又不能去協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147927/210.wav", + "text": "因為我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147927/211.wav", + "text": "擔心它足以妨害到整個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147927/212.wav", + "text": "那這不是白搭了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147927/213.wav", + "text": "我們的樣態是這樣我們現在的人力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147927/214.wav", + "text": "是這個人力的增補" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147927/215.wav", + "text": "不是協商就能夠決定的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147927/216.wav", + "text": "很多要依法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147927/217.wav", + "text": "比如我們不能夠協商說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147927/218.wav", + "text": "可以進用不合格的消防人員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147927/219.wav", + "text": "這個當然就不能協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147927/220.wav", + "text": "因為那是法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147927/221.wav", + "text": "我講的範圍應該不是這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147927/222.wav", + "text": "部長把我講的那個內容" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147927/223.wav", + "text": "了不是這樣啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147927/224.wav", + "text": "照理講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147927/225.wav", + "text": "如果你們今天提出來版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147927/226.wav", + "text": "現在看起來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147927/227.wav", + "text": "他們是希望" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147927/228.wav", + "text": "這個能夠換一個軌道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147927/229.wav", + "text": "去適用工會法這個軌道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147927/230.wav", + "text": "就是這一件事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147927/231.wav", + "text": "如果修的他們可以接受" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147927/232.wav", + "text": "我想這件事情又是不一樣的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147927/233.wav", + "text": "一個進行式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147927/234.wav", + "text": "有一些可能就是解讀上的落差" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147927/235.wav", + "text": "對照都會知道我們這次修的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147927/236.wav", + "text": "一定都比以前的放寬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147927/237.wav", + "text": "就像委員剛剛講的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147927/238.wav", + "text": "沒有百分之百可以完全" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147927/239.wav", + "text": "接受某一方的所有主張" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147927/240.wav", + "text": "我們修法當然不可能" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147927/241.wav", + "text": "馬上一次就到位這個我都可以理解" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147927/242.wav", + "text": "有些該到位的也是要到位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147927/243.wav", + "text": "基層的弟兄希望能夠提出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147927/244.wav", + "text": "溝通所" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147927/245.wav", + "text": "以我們在這個法律裡面除了規範協商的範圍" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147927/246.wav", + "text": "當然他還有建議事項的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147927/247.wav", + "text": "制定過程中的參與" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147927/248.wav", + "text": "對於這幾個部分如" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147927/249.wav", + "text": "人力部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147927/250.wav", + "text": "我們並沒有列在第7條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147927/251.wav", + "text": "因為這裡面牽涉到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147927/252.wav", + "text": "預算或者是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147927/253.wav", + "text": "或其他規範" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147927/254.wav", + "text": "所以它沒有辦法用透過雙方協商的方式來解決" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147927/255.wav", + "text": "但如果有這樣的問題其實" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147927/256.wav", + "text": "現在實務上我們消促會的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147927/257.wav", + "text": "基層同仁也一直密切地跟署長對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147927/258.wav", + "text": "對各種事項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147927/259.wav", + "text": "尤其是提升安全部分的溝通" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147927/260.wav", + "text": "我的瞭解是這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147927/261.wav", + "text": "書長的意思我瞭解" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147927/262.wav", + "text": "都沒辦法去做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147927/263.wav", + "text": "對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147927/264.wav", + "text": "勤休可以協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147927/265.wav", + "text": "只要不違反" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147927/266.wav", + "text": "服務法上那個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147927/267.wav", + "text": "加班時數上限" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147927/268.wav", + "text": "等等的規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147927/269.wav", + "text": "其實勤休方式是可以協商的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147927/270.wav", + "text": "可是你的人力就不足了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147927/271.wav", + "text": "你叫他們怎麼協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147927/272.wav", + "text": "那個就是另外一個解讀的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147927/273.wav", + "text": "也還可以做勤休方式的協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147927/274.wav", + "text": "部長你不能答復我這樣的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147927/275.wav", + "text": "到時候這個版本送出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147927/276.wav", + "text": "會很難修秘" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147927/277.wav", + "text": "六月還跟他們有過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147927/278.wav", + "text": "這樣一個諮詢會議對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147927/279.wav", + "text": "他們提出訴求有的或許你們可以採納" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147927/280.wav", + "text": "有的不一定可以採納" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147927/281.wav", + "text": "還在跟行政院討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147927/282.wav", + "text": "明天行政院會銜之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147927/283.wav", + "text": "就會送出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147927/284.wav", + "text": "所以這個禮拜就可以送過來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147927/285.wav", + "text": "這個禮拜送出來之前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147927/286.wav", + "text": "是不是還可以跟消防員的代表" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147927/287.wav", + "text": "有一個協商的機會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147927/288.wav", + "text": "因為文字部分考試院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147927/289.wav", + "text": "行政院會銜完大概就沒有辦法更動" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147927/290.wav", + "text": "但我想在立法院討論的時候我們都很願意來溝通" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147927/291.wav", + "text": "我要跟委員報告的是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147927/292.wav", + "text": "因為大家對於這個事件都很關心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147927/293.wav", + "text": "也講到要趕快來修改工會法等等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147927/294.wav", + "text": "或是公務員適用工會的體系" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147927/295.wav", + "text": "但這的確是茲事體大" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147927/296.wav", + "text": "有非常多的配套需要去處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147927/297.wav", + "text": "如果時程上希望儘可能儘" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147927/298.wav", + "text": "或是協商方面的權益將" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147927/299.wav", + "text": "可能是這個會期想要完成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147927/300.wav", + "text": "比較快的途徑" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147927/301.wav", + "text": "所以我們就加快腳步趕快把" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147927/302.wav", + "text": "銓敘部一直在研究的協會法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147927/303.wav", + "text": "來我們也是考量到時間快速的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147927/304.wav", + "text": "不過比工會法這部分討論起來可能" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147927/305.wav", + "text": "來得比較沒有那麼複雜" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147927/306.wav", + "text": "秘書長我再簡單回應一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147927/307.wav", + "text": "工會法是一件事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147927/308.wav", + "text": "又是另外一件事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147927/309.wav", + "text": "對於這件事情公部門當然" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147927/310.wav", + "text": "可以階段性的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147927/311.wav", + "text": "來做一些善意的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147927/312.wav", + "text": "主政主責之下個人感" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147927/313.wav", + "text": "因為時間關係我沒辦法再細究下去日" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147927/314.wav", + "text": "送到立院來還是有討論的空間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147927/315.wav", + "text": "不過這個草案要出來之前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147927/316.wav", + "text": "沒辦法百分之百讓大家接受" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147927/317.wav", + "text": "最起碼也要有七八十分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147927/318.wav", + "text": "這樣的草案送到立院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147927/319.wav", + "text": "如果反過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147927/320.wav", + "text": "是專家學者可以接受" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147927/321.wav", + "text": "公務員消防員沒辦法接受" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147927/322.wav", + "text": "的這種草案送到立院來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147927/323.wav", + "text": "謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147926/0.wav", + "text": "謝謝主席本席想邀請部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147926/1.wav", + "text": "部長請" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147926/2.wav", + "text": "部長好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147926/3.wav", + "text": "據9月14號媒體的報導" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147926/4.wav", + "text": "台中港近海原本的漁場是廣闊的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147926/5.wav", + "text": "漁獲量也非常豐盛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147926/6.wav", + "text": "但因港務公司近年不斷地圍海造地" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147926/7.wav", + "text": "漁民賴以生存的漁場範圍等於會減少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147926/8.wav", + "text": "尤其從三十幾年前開始港區許多的廠房增設" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147926/9.wav", + "text": "備造成我們的海域跟漁場受到污染" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147926/10.wav", + "text": "導致我們的漁場不斷被限縮" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147926/11.wav", + "text": "損及漁民的權益" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147926/12.wav", + "text": "所以本席要請教部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147926/13.wav", + "text": "台中港建港以及港區範圍不斷的在擴大" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147926/14.wav", + "text": "造成原來漁場大幅的限縮" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147926/15.wav", + "text": "交通部是不是應該要善盡職責" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147926/16.wav", + "text": "督導港務公司來檢視" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147926/17.wav", + "text": "所有的流程是不是完善" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147926/18.wav", + "text": "而不是把他圈著不跟漁民來談判" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147926/19.wav", + "text": "讓漁民來抗議讓漁民來圍堵" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147926/20.wav", + "text": "台中港是一個國際港這樣是會鬧國際笑話的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147926/21.wav", + "text": "要怎麼樣去協助我們的漁民找出解決的方案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147926/22.wav", + "text": "因為從最早" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147926/23.wav", + "text": "大船小船一直穿梭" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147926/24.wav", + "text": "因為這是一個國際港那我們要怎麼樣達到一個均衡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147926/25.wav", + "text": "呢雙方都有立場所以在不斷的抗爭不斷的協調" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147926/26.wav", + "text": "後我們終於完成了87艘漁筏的事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147926/27.wav", + "text": "當然國家的政策我們必須要配合" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147926/28.wav", + "text": "但是我們漁民的權利要怎麼辦呢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147926/29.wav", + "text": "謝謝楊委員關心這個課題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147926/30.wav", + "text": "一般來說在我們劃設商港的時候就要做一些補償" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147926/31.wav", + "text": "但是擴大的部分有一些地方好像沒有補償到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147926/32.wav", + "text": "這一點我已經跟他們董事長談" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147926/33.wav", + "text": "或是後面擴大商港" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147926/34.wav", + "text": "的部分如果有對民眾沒有補償的部分應該審慎來考慮" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147926/35.wav", + "text": "要協助好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147926/36.wav", + "text": "好我會請他們協助" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147926/37.wav", + "text": "要協助喔那我們繼續來努力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147926/38.wav", + "text": "因為本席也希望能夠讓民眾得到他們應該有的權益" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147926/39.wav", + "text": "益地方必須要和諧" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147926/40.wav", + "text": "這個就由他們去討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147926/41.wav", + "text": "到底是哪些擴大部分當時沒有做到補償" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147926/42.wav", + "text": "對包括沙灘也沒有給人家補償" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147926/43.wav", + "text": "就一併討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147926/44.wav", + "text": "你一定要告訴港務公司" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147926/45.wav", + "text": "我們一起來努力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147926/46.wav", + "text": "接下來本席要請教" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147926/47.wav", + "text": "的是四方客運在臺中市有13條路" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147926/48.wav", + "text": "但從4月份就欠員工的薪資" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147926/49.wav", + "text": "這讓我們的學生真的是苦不堪言" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147926/50.wav", + "text": "上班族也苦不堪言" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147926/51.wav", + "text": "那近期又爆出了財務問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147926/52.wav", + "text": "無預警的停止" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147926/53.wav", + "text": "4家公車業者來替代" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147926/54.wav", + "text": "但是這絕對不是一個長遠之計" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147926/55.wav", + "text": "所以本席要請教" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147926/56.wav", + "text": "四方公司" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147926/57.wav", + "text": "欠薪之事目前是由公路局" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147926/58.wav", + "text": "介入處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147926/59.wav", + "text": "而四方公司的母公司" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147926/60.wav", + "text": "是唐榮車輛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147926/61.wav", + "text": "享有跟中油簽約的合作備忘錄" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147926/62.wav", + "text": "開發了電動巴士" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147926/63.wav", + "text": "配合外交部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147926/64.wav", + "text": "這些的紅利都打進了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147926/65.wav", + "text": "中美洲的友邦市場" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147926/66.wav", + "text": "這個是非常好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147926/67.wav", + "text": "幫我們宣導" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147926/68.wav", + "text": "可以跟世界接軌" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147926/69.wav", + "text": "重點是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147926/70.wav", + "text": "它影響到我們民眾乘車的權益" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147926/71.wav", + "text": "我認為交通部也有責任" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147926/72.wav", + "text": "應該要出面來協調" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147926/73.wav", + "text": "因為這已經嚴重地危害到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147926/74.wav", + "text": "四方客運應該是屬於" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147926/75.wav", + "text": "臺中市政府應該有在處理中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147926/76.wav", + "text": "我們看看要怎麼樣來協助" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147926/77.wav", + "text": "因為現在公路局也介入" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147926/78.wav", + "text": "了我們也希望" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147926/79.wav", + "text": "畢竟你是交通部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147926/80.wav", + "text": "它如果是一般民營公司" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147926/81.wav", + "text": "但它的母公司是唐榮" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147926/82.wav", + "text": "雖然唐榮也是公司" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147926/83.wav", + "text": "可是它跟政府有合作" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147926/84.wav", + "text": "人民希望的就是一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147926/85.wav", + "text": "能夠得到一個方便性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147926/86.wav", + "text": "好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147926/87.wav", + "text": "中央政府跟地方政府" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147926/88.wav", + "text": "一起來協助" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147926/89.wav", + "text": "解決我們這個問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147926/90.wav", + "text": "好嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147926/91.wav", + "text": "臺中市政府這邊看看怎麼處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147926/92.wav", + "text": "最後一個議題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147926/93.wav", + "text": "斗六段發生遊覽車" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147926/94.wav", + "text": "跟小客車碰撞" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147926/95.wav", + "text": "事故造成了這麼大的傷亡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147926/96.wav", + "text": "本席要請教" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147926/97.wav", + "text": "因為我們的遊覽車" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147926/98.wav", + "text": "這個有多久沒有調整" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147926/99.wav", + "text": "跟委員報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147926/100.wav", + "text": "事實上我們對這個都有解釋過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147926/101.wav", + "text": "制定的有多久沒調" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147926/102.wav", + "text": "其實我請他們算過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147926/103.wav", + "text": "的可以承受到90公斤" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147926/104.wav", + "text": "55公斤是讓他算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147926/105.wav", + "text": "可是它上面還是寫55公斤" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147926/106.wav", + "text": "你應該要宣告給民眾了解" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147926/107.wav", + "text": "啊以55公斤為計算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147926/108.wav", + "text": "單位已經多久沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147926/109.wav", + "text": "核定座位數所使用的55公斤" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147926/110.wav", + "text": "是參考日本的規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147926/111.wav", + "text": "日本到現在還是用55公斤" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147926/112.wav", + "text": "那為什麼我們要依照日本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147926/113.wav", + "text": "啊幾十年了還是55公斤" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147926/114.wav", + "text": "當然" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147926/115.wav", + "text": "你說55公斤是依照日本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147926/116.wav", + "text": "如此我們不一定要依照" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147926/117.wav", + "text": "香港現在是54公斤" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147926/118.wav", + "text": "所以臺灣現在的平均數呢你要去查一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147926/119.wav", + "text": "我要跟委員報告的就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147926/120.wav", + "text": "跟安全有關的動態煞車跟傾斜" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147926/121.wav", + "text": "是90公斤" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147926/122.wav", + "text": "對最高90" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147926/123.wav", + "text": "那為什麼還要寫一個55" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147926/124.wav", + "text": "因為日本嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147926/125.wav", + "text": "不是因為那個是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147926/126.wav", + "text": "那香港是54" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147926/127.wav", + "text": "第一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147926/128.wav", + "text": "你們去審視一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147926/129.wav", + "text": "嘛我就不止55公斤" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147926/130.wav", + "text": "第一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147926/131.wav", + "text": "用來算座位數" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147926/132.wav", + "text": "是用大概90公斤" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147926/133.wav", + "text": "你要讓社會大眾了解" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147926/134.wav", + "text": "那為什麼要寫一個55" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147926/135.wav", + "text": "你也不要答復我說什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147926/136.wav", + "text": "公斤我們不是跟著日本走" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147926/137.wav", + "text": "目前自己的狀況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147926/138.wav", + "text": "看大概平均是多少公斤" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147926/139.wav", + "text": "謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147925/0.wav", + "text": "謝謝主席" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147925/1.wav", + "text": "請主席邀請王部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147925/2.wav", + "text": "王部長請" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147925/3.wav", + "text": "陳委員好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147925/4.wav", + "text": "部長早安" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147925/5.wav", + "text": "早" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147925/6.wav", + "text": "年底12月的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147925/7.wav", + "text": "國外的媒體CNN報導" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147925/8.wav", + "text": "都指出我們臺灣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147925/9.wav", + "text": "的交通是危險的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147925/10.wav", + "text": "所以事實上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147925/11.wav", + "text": "這種交通的一個亂象" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147925/12.wav", + "text": "我們也知道不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147925/13.wav", + "text": "一天兩天形成的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147925/14.wav", + "text": "隨著時代的變遷跟發展" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147925/15.wav", + "text": "經過幾十年來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147925/16.wav", + "text": "慢慢累積造成目前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147925/17.wav", + "text": "這樣子的一個現況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147925/18.wav", + "text": "我們執政者當然" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147925/19.wav", + "text": "也是要勇於面對跟承擔" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147925/20.wav", + "text": "並解決這個問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147925/21.wav", + "text": "\n我們看到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147925/22.wav", + "text": "行政院今年5月" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147925/23.wav", + "text": "25號跟8月29號" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147925/24.wav", + "text": "行人優先交通政策綱領" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147925/25.wav", + "text": "跟行人交通安全政策綱領" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147925/26.wav", + "text": "也是有宣示要從四大面向" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147925/27.wav", + "text": "來改善這個狀況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147925/28.wav", + "text": "就是包括工程教育監理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147925/29.wav", + "text": "還有執法這四個面向" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147925/30.wav", + "text": "在8月29號的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147925/31.wav", + "text": "行人交通安全政策綱領裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147925/32.wav", + "text": "也有提到就是未來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147925/33.wav", + "text": "改善道安的三大精進作為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147925/34.wav", + "text": "其中一項就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147925/35.wav", + "text": "推動道路交通安全基本法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147925/36.wav", + "text": "我想這個也是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147925/37.wav", + "text": "社會在期待的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147925/38.wav", + "text": "所以我們今天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147925/39.wav", + "text": "委員會也是針對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147925/40.wav", + "text": "道路交通安全基本法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147925/41.wav", + "text": "\n我想這個問題現在是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147925/42.wav", + "text": "的就是社會大眾" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147925/43.wav", + "text": "都認為這是應該要去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147925/44.wav", + "text": "面對跟解決的一個問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147925/45.wav", + "text": "我們政府也有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147925/46.wav", + "text": "陸續發布相對的一個政策" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147925/47.wav", + "text": "地方也有針對一些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147925/48.wav", + "text": "危險路口在做一些改善" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147925/49.wav", + "text": "會是目前大家都" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147925/50.wav", + "text": "有共識的一個概念" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147925/51.wav", + "text": "會形成行人地獄" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147925/52.wav", + "text": "就是很多行人道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147925/53.wav", + "text": "通道車道或者是騎樓" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147925/54.wav", + "text": "所以行人就是會被迫走到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147925/55.wav", + "text": "真的造成了險象環生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147925/56.wav", + "text": "可是我們要去思考" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147925/57.wav", + "text": "另外一個問題就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147925/58.wav", + "text": "我們要還路於民的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147925/59.wav", + "text": "有停車需求的汽車也好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147925/60.wav", + "text": "機車也好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147925/61.wav", + "text": "我們要怎麼去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147925/62.wav", + "text": "解決這個問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147925/63.wav", + "text": "因為我們不能解決這個問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147925/64.wav", + "text": "卻造成另外一個問題的產生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147925/65.wav", + "text": "跟委員報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147925/66.wav", + "text": "我們就是剛才提到的幾個措施" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147925/67.wav", + "text": "是我們現在的重點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147925/68.wav", + "text": "我們現在就是編400億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147925/69.wav", + "text": "就是做所謂實體人行道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147925/70.wav", + "text": "跟人行道的貫通" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147925/71.wav", + "text": "當然騎樓的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147925/72.wav", + "text": "我們也跟地方政府在做討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147925/73.wav", + "text": "目前的處罰條例裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147925/74.wav", + "text": "如果真的停車位不夠的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147925/75.wav", + "text": "可以劃騎樓" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147925/76.wav", + "text": "當機車的停車位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147925/77.wav", + "text": "但是不准停汽車" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147925/78.wav", + "text": "當然是把它退出騎樓" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147925/79.wav", + "text": "整齊線讓行人能夠通行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147925/80.wav", + "text": "然後剛才談到很多路障的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147925/81.wav", + "text": "我們現在路邊的這些障礙物" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147925/82.wav", + "text": "現在也是列入" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147925/83.wav", + "text": "我們這個400億裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147925/84.wav", + "text": "在做討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147925/85.wav", + "text": "現在也正在進行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147925/86.wav", + "text": "我們去年底到今年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147925/87.wav", + "text": "就行人這個課題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147925/88.wav", + "text": "是所有人都覺得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147925/89.wav", + "text": "這是應該改善的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147925/90.wav", + "text": "現在行政院也面對這個題目" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147925/91.wav", + "text": "人行的設施" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147925/92.wav", + "text": "我們的指引在5月就已經給地方了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147925/93.wav", + "text": "我想我們就一起來努力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147925/94.wav", + "text": "跟委員報告就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147925/95.wav", + "text": "我們7月8月9月" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147925/96.wav", + "text": "這3個月" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147925/97.wav", + "text": "整個道安的死亡數據" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147925/98.wav", + "text": "都已經有下降的趨勢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147925/99.wav", + "text": "我們希望" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147925/100.wav", + "text": "這是一個好的開始" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147925/101.wav", + "text": "我們繼續來努力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147925/102.wav", + "text": "是我們知道臺灣是全世界" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147925/103.wav", + "text": "機車使用率最高的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147925/104.wav", + "text": "機車族真的是非常多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147925/105.wav", + "text": "停車上的一個需求" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147925/106.wav", + "text": "我們也要同時做一個考量" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147925/107.wav", + "text": "本席覺得過去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147925/108.wav", + "text": "在整個都市的發展裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147925/109.wav", + "text": "不管是自小客車" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147925/110.wav", + "text": "停車空間的一個需求" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147925/111.wav", + "text": "真的是不夠的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147925/112.wav", + "text": "所以剛剛部長也有提到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147925/113.wav", + "text": "就是未來改善道安的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147925/114.wav", + "text": "那我們這400億裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147925/115.wav", + "text": "沒有那個是屬於我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147925/116.wav", + "text": "未來我們在改善道安的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147925/117.wav", + "text": "考量相關的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147925/118.wav", + "text": "要不然的話對整個都市" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147925/119.wav", + "text": "例子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147925/120.wav", + "text": "當時他們的交通事故" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147925/121.wav", + "text": "死亡人數高達一萬六千多人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147925/122.wav", + "text": "馬上訂定了一個交通安全" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147925/123.wav", + "text": "對策基本法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147925/124.wav", + "text": "啟動相關的改善措施" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147925/125.wav", + "text": "他們的交通事故" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147925/126.wav", + "text": "死亡人數已經降到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147925/127.wav", + "text": "看來也經過了將近" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147925/128.wav", + "text": "50年的時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147925/129.wav", + "text": "在此要先請教部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147925/130.wav", + "text": "的是對我們整個國內交通的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147925/131.wav", + "text": "我們現在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147925/132.wav", + "text": "是希望到2030" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147925/133.wav", + "text": "年能將死亡人數降低" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147925/134.wav", + "text": "是2030" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147925/135.wav", + "text": "年其實在這種基本法裡面若" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147925/136.wav", + "text": "全國都動起來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147925/137.wav", + "text": "中央地方各部會都動起來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147925/138.wav", + "text": "如果能傾全國的力量" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147925/139.wav", + "text": "我是覺得可以往這個目標來進行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147925/140.wav", + "text": "好這是大家要一起努力的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147925/141.wav", + "text": "如同一棵樹長歪了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147925/142.wav", + "text": "一下子馬上做到的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147925/143.wav", + "text": "還是要透過各種方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147925/144.wav", + "text": "慢慢將它導正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147925/145.wav", + "text": "所以本席認為我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147925/146.wav", + "text": "交通部宣示的這四大面向" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147925/147.wav", + "text": "尤其是教育這個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147925/148.wav", + "text": "真的非常重要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147925/149.wav", + "text": "我們看到事實上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147925/150.wav", + "text": "方有很多交通安全的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147925/151.wav", + "text": "改善就是針對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147925/152.wav", + "text": "種將行人穿越道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147925/153.wav", + "text": "可是這個狀況又衍生另外一種" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147925/154.wav", + "text": "交通事故就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147925/155.wav", + "text": "不小心撞上庇護島的情況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147925/156.wav", + "text": "所以對這個部分我們應該要好好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147925/157.wav", + "text": "去思考如何才能讓這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147925/158.wav", + "text": "庇護島更安全" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147925/159.wav", + "text": "當然庇護島反光" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147925/160.wav", + "text": "尤其是晚上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147925/161.wav", + "text": "那個反光要特別" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147925/162.wav", + "text": "也要檢討" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147925/163.wav", + "text": "路口我們還有另外一種" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147925/164.wav", + "text": "畫設行車引導線的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147925/165.wav", + "text": "標線跟反光的一些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147925/166.wav", + "text": "標誌這些都要加強" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147925/167.wav", + "text": "對這個部分應該是要加強" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147925/168.wav", + "text": "教育宣導然後包括" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147925/169.wav", + "text": "我們看到國外針對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147925/170.wav", + "text": "已經有引進LED路面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147925/171.wav", + "text": "以前我在高雄" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147925/172.wav", + "text": "有做過就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147925/173.wav", + "text": "的時候那邊會顯示" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147925/174.wav", + "text": "是整個行人道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147925/175.wav", + "text": "有試辦過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147925/176.wav", + "text": "我後來離開了就不知道後來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147925/177.wav", + "text": "是我想這個部分應該可以讓" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147925/178.wav", + "text": "行人在穿越馬路時" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147925/179.wav", + "text": "更安全尤其是晚上的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147925/180.wav", + "text": "相關的比較安全的設施我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147925/181.wav", + "text": "都非常支持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147925/182.wav", + "text": "不管是業者還是由外引進我們都支持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147924/0.wav", + "text": "謝謝主席本席邀請我們交通部王部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147924/1.wav", + "text": "部長好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147924/2.wav", + "text": "就是我們每一年交通事故的件數" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147924/3.wav", + "text": "尤其死亡人數都沒有辦法降下來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147924/4.wav", + "text": "現在那個大型車輛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147924/5.wav", + "text": "我今天跟你講大型車輛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147924/6.wav", + "text": "每年都破一萬件" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147924/7.wav", + "text": "當時我們就說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147924/8.wav", + "text": "希望如何能夠降低大型車輛車禍造成的傷害" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147924/9.wav", + "text": "我們當時就有提到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147924/10.wav", + "text": "尤其最近4年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147924/11.wav", + "text": "從2019年就破萬件" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147924/12.wav", + "text": "每年都增加" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147924/13.wav", + "text": "你有沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147924/14.wav", + "text": "看到從2019年到2022年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147924/15.wav", + "text": "每年都破一萬件" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147924/16.wav", + "text": "而且每年大概有四百個人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147924/17.wav", + "text": "不幸地死在大客車" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147924/18.wav", + "text": "大型車輛的事故" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147924/19.wav", + "text": "你當部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147924/20.wav", + "text": "你知不知道2021年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147924/21.wav", + "text": "交通部有來申請一條3億3,000萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147924/22.wav", + "text": "預算讓大型車輛裝主動預警輔助系統" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147924/23.wav", + "text": "你知不知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147924/24.wav", + "text": "知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147924/25.wav", + "text": "他們現在在進行中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147924/26.wav", + "text": "應該是驗證差不多了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147924/27.wav", + "text": "就是要幫他們裝大型車輛預警輔助系統" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147924/28.wav", + "text": "2021年開始預算通過了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147924/29.wav", + "text": "說要分3年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147924/30.wav", + "text": "分3年到今年應該是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147924/31.wav", + "text": "最少也做2年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147924/32.wav", + "text": "了這個輔助系統" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147924/33.wav", + "text": "交通部說要自己研發啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147924/34.wav", + "text": "你知不知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147924/35.wav", + "text": "交通部為什麼要自己研發呢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147924/36.wav", + "text": "路政司" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147924/37.wav", + "text": "啦路政司就說要把視野輔助系統" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147924/38.wav", + "text": "防撞輔助系統" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147924/39.wav", + "text": "車道偏移輔助系統" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147924/40.wav", + "text": "胎壓偵測" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147924/41.wav", + "text": "盲點警示" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147924/42.wav", + "text": "疲勞偵測" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147924/43.wav", + "text": "數位行車紀錄器" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147924/44.wav", + "text": "還有酒精鎖" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147924/45.wav", + "text": "總共8個功能" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147924/46.wav", + "text": "要併做一個系統" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147924/47.wav", + "text": "我知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147924/48.wav", + "text": "駕駛輔助系統很多種它是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147924/49.wav", + "text": "希望有一個能" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147924/50.wav", + "text": "能把它整合" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147924/51.wav", + "text": "譬如一開始先裝主動預警" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147924/52.wav", + "text": "後面裝這個酒精鎖等等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147924/53.wav", + "text": "就一起加進去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147924/54.wav", + "text": "把所有的功能都整合進來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147924/55.wav", + "text": "這一套可能是全世界最先進的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147924/56.wav", + "text": "所以到目前為止" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147924/57.wav", + "text": "好像做不出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147924/58.wav", + "text": "這個部分跟委員報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147924/59.wav", + "text": "確實開發過程是不容易" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147924/60.wav", + "text": "能從研發測試" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147924/61.wav", + "text": "八合一的整體驗證報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147924/62.wav", + "text": "目前在做資料輸出格式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147924/63.wav", + "text": "校預計應該從下個月" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147924/64.wav", + "text": "可以開始進行80" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147924/65.wav", + "text": "我5月質詢的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147924/66.wav", + "text": "你們兩位跟我講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147924/67.wav", + "text": "今年要裝2,400臺" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147924/68.wav", + "text": "你現在又變800臺啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147924/69.wav", + "text": "沒關係也沒關係反正剩" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147924/70.wav", + "text": "反正剩三分之一也不錯" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147924/71.wav", + "text": "我自己降低標準啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147924/72.wav", + "text": "但是你這個系統要能夠用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147924/73.wav", + "text": "本來是說今年底做2,400" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147924/74.wav", + "text": "你現在說今年底先裝800臺" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147924/75.wav", + "text": "大概要裝到明年4月" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147924/76.wav", + "text": "但是裝上去不知道能不能用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147924/77.wav", + "text": "測試完是到明年底" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147924/78.wav", + "text": "完成是不是這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147924/79.wav", + "text": "跟委員報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147924/80.wav", + "text": "系統八合一的整體驗證功能" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147924/81.wav", + "text": "下個月應該可以開始" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147924/82.wav", + "text": "安裝到車子上面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147924/83.wav", + "text": "這個部分就是由我們運研所來做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147924/84.wav", + "text": "介面這些相關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147924/85.wav", + "text": "大概下個月開始裝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147924/86.wav", + "text": "800輛可以安裝完成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147924/87.wav", + "text": "這是一個開發的計畫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147924/88.wav", + "text": "我們會把這些相關的介面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147924/89.wav", + "text": "把它弄成產業的標準" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147924/90.wav", + "text": "未來使用中車輛的一個補助安裝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147924/91.wav", + "text": "長這個速度已經很慢了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147924/92.wav", + "text": "啦我們全國大貨車有幾臺你知道嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147924/93.wav", + "text": "啦因為你這個系統太先進" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147924/94.wav", + "text": "了所以只有一家在做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147924/95.wav", + "text": "結果2,400臺做不到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147924/96.wav", + "text": "現在一年做800臺" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147924/97.wav", + "text": "全國全部裝滿" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147924/98.wav", + "text": "可能要幾十年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147924/99.wav", + "text": "我是覺得後面應該更快" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147924/100.wav", + "text": "的確在開發過程發生一些延誤" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147924/101.wav", + "text": "到明年3月800輛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147924/102.wav", + "text": "未來這種輔助系統非常多元" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147924/103.wav", + "text": "可能會一直加進去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147924/104.wav", + "text": "你不要再亂加了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147924/105.wav", + "text": "趕快把這個做好就很厲害了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147924/106.wav", + "text": "不要再亂加什麼功能" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147924/107.wav", + "text": "因為有這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147924/108.wav", + "text": "這個計畫延宕那麼久" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147924/109.wav", + "text": "你知道吧" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147924/110.wav", + "text": "因為我們統計出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147924/111.wav", + "text": "每次大車如果出了事" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147924/112.wav", + "text": "很多人常常講的就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147924/113.wav", + "text": "視野有一個死角" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147924/114.wav", + "text": "對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147924/115.wav", + "text": "現在3億3,000萬給你們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147924/116.wav", + "text": "現在離原先的速度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147924/117.wav", + "text": "減慢了不要緊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147924/118.wav", + "text": "全國有幾十萬輛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147924/119.wav", + "text": "你這是要做到何年何月" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147924/120.wav", + "text": "\n另外這次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147924/121.wav", + "text": "我想請你們把那個計畫再重新整理好了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147924/122.wav", + "text": "到底你預計多久" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147924/123.wav", + "text": "可以把這個計畫全部完成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147924/124.wav", + "text": "好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147924/125.wav", + "text": "你之前的那個計畫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147924/126.wav", + "text": "全部都做不到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147924/127.wav", + "text": "了所以整個時程要重新排好\n" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147924/128.wav", + "text": "另外這次不幸發生了遊覽車的事故" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147924/129.wav", + "text": "駕駛是很大的一個原因" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147924/130.wav", + "text": "對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147924/131.wav", + "text": "部長你知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147924/132.wav", + "text": "我們國家有學歐盟" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147924/133.wav", + "text": "我們的大車" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147924/134.wav", + "text": "都要再回來接受6個小時的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147924/135.wav", + "text": "大客車職業駕駛的定期訓練" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147924/136.wav", + "text": "部長你知道嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147924/137.wav", + "text": "現在有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147924/138.wav", + "text": "這是學歐盟" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147924/139.wav", + "text": "歐盟是每5年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147924/140.wav", + "text": "要回來35個小時" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147924/141.wav", + "text": "然後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147924/142.wav", + "text": "歐盟除了給你一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147924/143.wav", + "text": "駕照以外" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147924/144.wav", + "text": "還會給你一個藍色的標誌" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147924/145.wav", + "text": "回來重新訓練" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147924/146.wav", + "text": "我們臺灣是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147924/147.wav", + "text": "每3年回來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147924/148.wav", + "text": "這6個小時" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147924/149.wav", + "text": "我希望" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147924/150.wav", + "text": "要很落實" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147924/151.wav", + "text": "大客車駕駛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147924/152.wav", + "text": "說他說這是彼此在浪費時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147924/153.wav", + "text": "反正你們公總" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147924/154.wav", + "text": "他們就去那邊上課" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147924/155.wav", + "text": "上完課就做一個測驗" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147924/156.wav", + "text": "部長你知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147924/157.wav", + "text": "每年測驗沒有及格" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147924/158.wav", + "text": "很少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147924/159.wav", + "text": "不會超過兩個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147924/160.wav", + "text": "也就是說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147924/161.wav", + "text": "萬分之一的機會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147924/162.wav", + "text": "你才會不及格" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147924/163.wav", + "text": "你去考那個測驗" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147924/164.wav", + "text": "要考不及格" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147924/165.wav", + "text": "絕不可能" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147924/166.wav", + "text": "很困難" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147924/167.wav", + "text": "例如" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147924/168.wav", + "text": "考試中有一題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147924/169.wav", + "text": "你的口腔要怎麼樣才會最好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147924/170.wav", + "text": "第一個不嚼檳榔" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147924/171.wav", + "text": "不吸菸不喝酒" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147924/172.wav", + "text": "第二" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147924/173.wav", + "text": "個若出現嘴破" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147924/174.wav", + "text": "斑點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147924/175.wav", + "text": "腫起來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147924/176.wav", + "text": "不要急著就醫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147924/177.wav", + "text": "再持續觀察" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147924/178.wav", + "text": "第三" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147924/179.wav", + "text": "飲食及生活作息" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147924/180.wav", + "text": "要常刷牙" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147924/181.wav", + "text": "請問哪個比較正確" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147924/182.wav", + "text": "你這是衛福部在考試" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147924/183.wav", + "text": "你那個受訓的東西" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147924/184.wav", + "text": "應該要跟行車安全有關係" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147924/185.wav", + "text": "是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147924/186.wav", + "text": "就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147924/187.wav", + "text": "你的意思是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147924/188.wav", + "text": "叫他不要嚼檳榔就對了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147924/189.wav", + "text": "因為有些大型車的駕駛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147924/190.wav", + "text": "會嚼檳榔" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147924/191.wav", + "text": "嚼檳榔不是用考試的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147924/192.wav", + "text": "大家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147924/193.wav", + "text": "我跟你講歐盟要求" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147924/194.wav", + "text": "求每5年回來考試" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147924/195.wav", + "text": "很嚴格���訓練" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147924/196.wav", + "text": "你要實地去駕駛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147924/197.wav", + "text": "有新的設備" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147924/198.wav", + "text": "還要實地操作" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147924/199.wav", + "text": "臺灣是沒有啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147924/200.wav", + "text": "臺灣是放影片給你看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147924/201.wav", + "text": "啦在那邊看PowerPoint" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147924/202.wav", + "text": "所以才會出現這" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147924/203.wav", + "text": "這些有問題的駕駛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147924/204.wav", + "text": "像這次的這位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147924/205.wav", + "text": "他已經違規那麼多次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147924/206.wav", + "text": "了你知道這種重新測驗" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147924/207.wav", + "text": "其實應該是一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147924/208.wav", + "text": "很重要的教育訓練" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147924/209.wav", + "text": "這種做表面功夫的就不要做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147924/210.wav", + "text": "的既然要請他們回來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147924/211.wav", + "text": "就真的排一些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147924/212.wav", + "text": "對彼此都是有用的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147924/213.wav", + "text": "跟行車安全有關係的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147924/214.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147924/215.wav", + "text": "就是整個課程" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147924/216.wav", + "text": "很簡單的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147924/217.wav", + "text": "考試的結果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147924/218.wav", + "text": "中只有1個人不及格" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147924/219.wav", + "text": "根本就不必要浪費大家的時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147924/220.wav", + "text": "我會請他們來檢討" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147924/221.wav", + "text": "我是覺得這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147924/222.wav", + "text": "應該要很嚴肅地面對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147924/223.wav", + "text": "你要學歐盟就學好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147924/224.wav", + "text": "把人家的課程學好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147924/225.wav", + "text": "不然你就不要亂學亂做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147924/226.wav", + "text": "好謝謝部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147924/227.wav", + "text": "謝謝局長謝謝司長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147924/228.wav", + "text": "好謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147923/0.wav", + "text": "謝謝主席" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147923/1.wav", + "text": "有請部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147923/2.wav", + "text": "部長之前行政院陳建仁院長在總質詢的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147923/3.wav", + "text": "有被問到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147923/4.wav", + "text": "臺灣高教經費只占國內 GDP的0.39%" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147923/5.wav", + "text": "行政院的回應是說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147923/6.wav", + "text": "2019臺灣高教的教育經費占GDP的比率是1.2%" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147923/7.wav", + "text": "而不是0.39%" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147923/8.wav", + "text": "不過高教產業工會是說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147923/9.wav", + "text": "高教經費有分公部門跟私部門的來源" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147923/10.wav", + "text": "如果只有公部門是反映政府挹注高教所承擔的經費" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147923/11.wav", + "text": "那私部門的來源當然就沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147923/12.wav", + "text": "所以這裡講的所謂0.39%" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147923/13.wav", + "text": "是公部門挹注高教的常態性經費" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147923/14.wav", + "text": "高教產業工會認為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147923/15.wav", + "text": "行政院刻意沒有區分所謂的公部門私部門的高教經費" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147923/16.wav", + "text": "感覺好像有點要透過把私部門的高教經費混入" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147923/17.wav", + "text": "\n我想教育是國家發展的重中之重" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147923/18.wav", + "text": "除了在高中以下打好基礎外" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147923/19.wav", + "text": "眼光如果要放長遠一點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147923/20.wav", + "text": "高教人才的培育確是我們臺灣跟世界競爭接軌的關鍵" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147923/21.wav", + "text": "在經費上我覺得勢必要投入更大的心力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147923/22.wav", + "text": "力所以本席是要肯定教育部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147923/23.wav", + "text": "甚至中研院國科會我們相關的部會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147923/24.wav", + "text": "其實在提高高教人才的獎補助金" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147923/25.wav", + "text": "來培養更多的人才" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147923/26.wav", + "text": "這個部分我們是肯定的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147923/27.wav", + "text": "可是話講回來跟其他國家相比" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147923/28.wav", + "text": "我們還是有比較低的疑慮" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147923/29.wav", + "text": "所以我們要怎麼樣更努力來提升公部門方面的高教經費" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147923/30.wav", + "text": "是我跟委員報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147923/31.wav", + "text": "確實院長在回應的內容上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147923/32.wav", + "text": "因為院長對高教也瞭解" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147923/33.wav", + "text": "而且知道高教經費的來源" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147923/34.wav", + "text": "絕對不只教育部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147923/35.wav", + "text": "尤其臺灣我想不管國科會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147923/36.wav", + "text": "等我們幾個相關的部會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147923/37.wav", + "text": "尤其國科會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147923/38.wav", + "text": "協助我們大學很多的學者專家進行研究" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147923/39.wav", + "text": "啦所以院長當時的回應是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147923/40.wav", + "text": "不是只有教育部的預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147923/41.wav", + "text": "才是高教計算的基準" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147923/42.wav", + "text": "\n剛才談到公私的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147923/43.wav", + "text": "從OECD的統計" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147923/44.wav", + "text": "它確實也都是從全面性的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147923/45.wav", + "text": "GDP所涵蓋的就是全面的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147923/46.wav", + "text": "不太可能將相關的資源去除不算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147923/47.wav", + "text": "所以確實這一方面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147923/48.wav", + "text": "在整個統計的基礎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147923/49.wav", + "text": "還有所提到的這一些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147923/50.wav", + "text": "當然對於高教的投入確實要不斷地再增加" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147923/51.wav", + "text": "從今年預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147923/52.wav", + "text": "應該不只是今年預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147923/53.wav", + "text": "這幾年來儘管我們的學生數是減少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147923/54.wav", + "text": "但是高教的預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147923/55.wav", + "text": "就教育部的部分還是逐年增加" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147923/56.wav", + "text": "不管從高教深耕計畫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147923/57.wav", + "text": "在未來的5年所增加的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147923/58.wav", + "text": "也多出一百零多億來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147923/59.wav", + "text": "另外對於今年所反映出來的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147923/60.wav", + "text": "注在高教人才這方面的斷層" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147923/61.wav", + "text": "經過大家的討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147923/62.wav", + "text": "今年也提出5年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147923/63.wav", + "text": "元然後跟大學一起努力來做國際招生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147923/64.wav", + "text": "都認為臺灣有這個條件" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147923/65.wav", + "text": "也有這個能量來做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147923/66.wav", + "text": "所以今年我們特別再增列了七點多億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147923/67.wav", + "text": "元這也是一個幾年的中程計畫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147923/68.wav", + "text": "我想這方面的經費永遠不夠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147923/69.wav", + "text": "但是確實在這幾年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147923/70.wav", + "text": "我們也持續來增加" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147923/71.wav", + "text": "會跟大學一起來共同努力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147923/72.wav", + "text": "好我們要儘量加速" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147923/73.wav", + "text": "然後跟OECD的國家能並駕齊驅" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147923/74.wav", + "text": "\n另外想跟您探討108課綱的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147923/75.wav", + "text": "兒少團體兒福聯盟宣稱說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147923/76.wav", + "text": "108課綱上路後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147923/77.wav", + "text": "學生上課跟補習的時間很長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147923/78.wav", + "text": "每天有考不完的試" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147923/79.wav", + "text": "寫不完的練習題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147923/80.wav", + "text": "還要製作學習歷程" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147923/81.wav", + "text": "學生除了去學校上課以外" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147923/82.wav", + "text": "有6成的學生放學後還要補習" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147923/83.wav", + "text": "10點才回家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147923/84.wav", + "text": "回到家可能吃個宵夜洗個澡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147923/85.wav", + "text": "又要自習到半夜12點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147923/86.wav", + "text": "然後隔天6點就要起床上學" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147923/87.wav", + "text": "有超過9成3的學生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147923/88.wav", + "text": "認為他睡不到8個小時" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147923/89.wav", + "text": "甚至有3成7的孩子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147923/90.wav", + "text": "只能睡5至6個小時" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147923/91.wav", + "text": "學生每天學習超過10個小時" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147923/92.wav", + "text": "比大人上班平均89個小時還多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147923/93.wav", + "text": "進一步導致有6成學生的學習" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147923/94.wav", + "text": "疲勞感越來越高" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147923/95.wav", + "text": "\n不過我也清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147923/96.wav", + "text": "在108課綱還沒有實施前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147923/97.wav", + "text": "其實學生所謂的課後補習" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147923/98.wav", + "text": "每天埋首苦讀到半夜" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147923/99.wav", + "text": "的狀況本來就有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147923/100.wav", + "text": "你認為108課綱造成學生的疲勞感增加" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147923/101.wav", + "text": "這是一個主因嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147923/102.wav", + "text": "或者你有分析" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147923/103.wav", + "text": "的學習疲勞感增加" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147923/104.wav", + "text": "那主要原因是什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147923/105.wav", + "text": "是謝謝委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147923/106.wav", + "text": "因為委員剛才在談這個過程當中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147923/107.wav", + "text": "有提到一個很關鍵的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147923/108.wav", + "text": "部分其實絕對不是108課綱或哪一個階段的課綱" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147923/109.wav", + "text": "把臺灣孩子的學習變得晚上要補習到幾點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147923/110.wav", + "text": "好像就少了哪一樣沒學到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147923/111.wav", + "text": "我想這是在一個社會裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147923/112.wav", + "text": "的108課綱其實沒有增加時數" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147923/113.wav", + "text": "這個我想委員也瞭解" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147923/114.wav", + "text": "關鍵是我們本來一直希望改變的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147923/115.wav", + "text": "是多一點時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147923/116.wav", + "text": "讓學生有一些彈性的學習課程" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147923/117.wav", + "text": "因為過去學校就是有機會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147923/118.wav", + "text": "就塞滿了所有考試要考的科目" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147923/119.wav", + "text": "讓孩子少了很多很多可以對自己的瞭解" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147923/120.wav", + "text": "或對外界的瞭解" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147923/121.wav", + "text": "\n在高中職的階段增加了這樣的選修" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147923/122.wav", + "text": "但是是從原來必修的考量之下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147923/123.wav", + "text": "總時數並沒有改變" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147923/124.wav", + "text": "原因也是不要讓孩子在大學端" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147923/125.wav", + "text": "就是他發現自己不知道為什麼選讀了這個科系" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147923/126.wav", + "text": "可能是因為他考到多少分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147923/127.wav", + "text": "就選了選了之後進到學校" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147923/128.wav", + "text": "不應該來這裡或不想來這裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147923/129.wav", + "text": "或不想繼續留下來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147923/130.wav", + "text": "我覺得整個社會要看到的是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147923/131.wav", + "text": "孩子到了這個階段才開始恍然大悟" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147923/132.wav", + "text": "我為什麼進到這個教室" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147923/133.wav", + "text": "這個其實是臺灣孩子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147923/134.wav", + "text": "對家長心態的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147923/135.wav", + "text": "他不得已在那個階段" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147923/136.wav", + "text": "讓孩子不要再思考未來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147923/137.wav", + "text": "只要先考完試升完學" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147923/138.wav", + "text": "可是孩子的生涯不只這一段" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147923/139.wav", + "text": "啦這個才是108課綱在推動的過程當��" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147923/140.wav", + "text": "在負擔上希望不要增加" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147923/141.wav", + "text": "但是能留一點空間給孩子思考這一段" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147923/142.wav", + "text": "如果父母為了求好心切" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147923/143.wav", + "text": "再把孩子的空間又用補習去取代了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147923/144.wav", + "text": "其實是非常可惜" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147923/145.wav", + "text": "\n我想臺大葉丙成教授也曾經在這個議題上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147923/146.wav", + "text": "也看到很多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147923/147.wav", + "text": "他做了一個分享" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147923/148.wav", + "text": "也關心到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147923/149.wav", + "text": "如果家長們能重新再思考一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147923/150.wav", + "text": "孩子人生的長途發展" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147923/151.wav", + "text": "多一點時間讓他去瞭解自己" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147923/152.wav", + "text": "也瞭解他未來想要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147923/153.wav", + "text": "什麼這個不是一蹴可幾" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147923/154.wav", + "text": "需要一點時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147923/155.wav", + "text": "所以這一段也正是108課綱" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147923/156.wav", + "text": "比較期待能夠逐步地去引導" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147923/157.wav", + "text": "能夠讓孩子對自己對未來有多一點的理解" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147923/158.wav", + "text": "而不要等到大學" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147923/159.wav", + "text": "等到出了社會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147923/160.wav", + "text": "才發現他的人生要重新思考" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147923/161.wav", + "text": "重新再去瞭解" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147923/162.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147923/163.wav", + "text": "之前全教總有發表過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147923/164.wav", + "text": "高中職階段教育現況的問卷調查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147923/165.wav", + "text": "有超過5成的高中職教師" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147923/166.wav", + "text": "是認同108課綱的方向" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147923/167.wav", + "text": "可是整體的規劃不夠合理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147923/168.wav", + "text": "導致師生的負擔重" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147923/169.wav", + "text": "\n在這份調查中有超過一半的老師認為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147923/170.wav", + "text": "課程諮詢師沒有發揮一定的功能" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147923/171.wav", + "text": "調查歸納出" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147923/172.wav", + "text": "沒有發揮功能的原因是因為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147923/173.wav", + "text": "課諮老師與科任老師" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147923/174.wav", + "text": "還有輔導室的功能有點重疊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147923/175.wav", + "text": "學生遇到問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147923/176.wav", + "text": "會直接找比較熟的老師" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147923/177.wav", + "text": "課諮老師的專業不足" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147923/178.wav", + "text": "一開始的培訓可能就過於簡化" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147923/179.wav", + "text": "再來就是時間不夠人力不足" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147923/180.wav", + "text": "所以很多課諮老師是一般老師去兼任的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147923/181.wav", + "text": "這些老師本來就有自己的事情要做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147923/182.wav", + "text": "所以他可能很難挪出���間來幫助學生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147923/183.wav", + "text": "\n本席想請教的是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147923/184.wav", + "text": "從教學現場的資源來看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147923/185.wav", + "text": "是否足夠照顧到每位學生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147923/186.wav", + "text": "課諮老師也就沒有辦法去解說到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147923/187.wav", + "text": "不同領域" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147923/188.wav", + "text": "的科別課程或生涯規劃" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147923/189.wav", + "text": "如果老師沒有時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147923/190.wav", + "text": "和心力照顧到每個學生的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147923/191.wav", + "text": "加上家長是成績至上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147923/192.wav", + "text": "一時半刻也難以動搖" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147923/193.wav", + "text": "那學生就要另外補習" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147923/194.wav", + "text": "成績至上的升學制度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147923/195.wav", + "text": "到現在我們想要減輕學科比重" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147923/196.wav", + "text": "強調多元發展的這種制度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147923/197.wav", + "text": "確實讓學生無所適從" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147923/198.wav", + "text": "所以家長及老師對於課綱精神的誤解" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147923/199.wav", + "text": "跟不理解造成學生的壓力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147923/200.wav", + "text": "是委員提到一個非常關鍵" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147923/201.wav", + "text": "的部分確實課諮老師是協助學生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147923/202.wav", + "text": "或相關概念裡面一個很重要的諮詢者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147923/203.wav", + "text": "到目前為止全國大概有1萬6,000位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147923/204.wav", + "text": "專業訓練" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147923/205.wav", + "text": "但是剛才委員提到的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147923/206.wav", + "text": "這方面確實給他在這方面的資源" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147923/207.wav", + "text": "還是希望能夠再補充" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147923/208.wav", + "text": "這部分我覺得很必要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147923/209.wav", + "text": "因為以後他們應該要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147923/210.wav", + "text": "很多孩子還不太瞭解之前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147923/211.wav", + "text": "課諮老師其實是一個很重要的諮詢者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147923/212.wav", + "text": "因為全教總對這個議題也滿深入" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147923/213.wav", + "text": "我們再跟他們來做一個會商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147923/214.wav", + "text": "他們在現場應該有收集到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147923/215.wav", + "text": "我想這部分我們再來精進" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147923/216.wav", + "text": "好再30秒" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147923/217.wav", + "text": "接著要討論學習歷程檔案的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147923/218.wav", + "text": "因為歷程檔案跟升學掛鉤" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147923/219.wav", + "text": "嘛很多人只是為了升學" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147923/220.wav", + "text": "就花大錢去找補習班" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147923/221.wav", + "text": "來協助美化學習檔案的內容" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147923/222.wav", + "text": "再來去年四技" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147923/223.wav", + "text": "四技二專的甄選入學中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147923/224.wav", + "text": "用學習歷程檔案或用PDF檔" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147923/225.wav", + "text": "當作備審資料的比率" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147923/226.wav", + "text": "可是在112學年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147923/227.wav", + "text": "用學檔作為備審資料的比率" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147923/228.wav", + "text": "掉到41.2%" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147923/229.wav", + "text": "用PDF檔當作備審資料" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147923/230.wav", + "text": "變成58.8%" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147923/231.wav", + "text": "因為PDF檔呈現的是比較彈性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147923/232.wav", + "text": "不會受既定的格式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147923/233.wav", + "text": "所以要呈現多元術科表現的技職生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147923/234.wav", + "text": "可能就不會用學檔來當備審資料" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147923/235.wav", + "text": "可是學生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147923/236.wav", + "text": "平常是用學檔來記錄學習資料" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147923/237.wav", + "text": "所以到高三要申請學校的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147923/238.wav", + "text": "這樣會不會有多做一道工的感覺" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147923/239.wav", + "text": "\n我當然肯定108課綱推行的這幾年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147923/240.wav", + "text": "教育部有持續在改進" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147923/241.wav", + "text": "可是備審資料的相關問題還是存在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147923/242.wav", + "text": "所以請教部長怎麼看108課綱推行到今天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147923/243.wav", + "text": "學習歷程檔案所衍生出的各種問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147923/244.wav", + "text": "教育部要怎麼樣再精進" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147923/245.wav", + "text": "減低學生在學科跟備審資料間蠟燭兩頭燒" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147923/246.wav", + "text": "導致學生越來越疲累這個問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147923/247.wav", + "text": "跟委員報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147923/248.wav", + "text": "對於學習歷程檔案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147923/249.wav", + "text": "的設計作為升學使用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147923/250.wav", + "text": "絕對是它的用途之一" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147923/251.wav", + "text": "而不是唯一啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147923/252.wav", + "text": "因為學習歷程的概念" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147923/253.wav", + "text": "其實是讓學生過往" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147923/254.wav", + "text": "在面對考試" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147923/255.wav", + "text": "能夠有一些省思" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147923/256.wav", + "text": "這個其實是搭配108課綱真正的重點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147923/257.wav", + "text": "當然在整個使用上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147923/258.wav", + "text": "確實升學還是一個很大的吸引力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147923/259.wav", + "text": "因為我們在升學的管道裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147923/260.wav", + "text": "確實也沒有硬性規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147923/261.wav", + "text": "你必須要完全用學習歷程檔案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147923/262.wav", + "text": "員也知道之前過渡階段" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147923/263.wav", + "text": "還有很多可能是重考的學生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147923/264.wav", + "text": "也不可能讓他沒有機會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147923/265.wav", + "text": "至於技職體系的學生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147923/266.wav", + "text": "確實他在整個應用這方面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147923/267.wav", + "text": "與一般普通高中升大學" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147923/268.wav", + "text": "是比較不一致" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147923/269.wav", + "text": "所以我們從平均值來看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147923/270.wav", + "text": "一般普通高中學生到大學" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147923/271.wav", + "text": "技職體系的學生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147923/272.wav", + "text": "在應用上可能就沒有那麼高" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147923/273.wav", + "text": "但是我還是歸結地說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147923/274.wav", + "text": "它不是唯一啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147923/275.wav", + "text": "因為委員理解" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147923/276.wav", + "text": "也支持108課綱" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147923/277.wav", + "text": "我跟委員報告一個實際的情況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147923/278.wav", + "text": "108課綱推行這幾年來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147923/279.wav", + "text": "我們學生實際的狀況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147923/280.wav", + "text": "我自己也有機會參與很多很多的場合" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147923/281.wav", + "text": "我發現有非常多的學生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147923/282.wav", + "text": "也許只是一般社區型的高中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147923/283.wav", + "text": "他在很多的場合" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147923/284.wav", + "text": "甚至曾經跟蔡總統他們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147923/285.wav", + "text": "辦的這種座談裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147923/286.wav", + "text": "我發現這些孩子在思考" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147923/287.wav", + "text": "其實說真話已經不像過去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147923/288.wav", + "text": "包含我們自己年代的年輕人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147923/289.wav", + "text": "我覺得這是因為是他在學習過程當中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147923/290.wav", + "text": "有更多更多的機會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147923/291.wav", + "text": "我們也常說這個是108課綱比較期待的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147923/292.wav", + "text": "尤其要面對未來這麼大的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147923/293.wav", + "text": "考試這幾個科目就可以來應付" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147923/294.wav", + "text": "我想這個確實要有一段" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147923/295.wav", + "text": "歷程我們再來做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147923/296.wav", + "text": "是有看到一些進步" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147923/297.wav", + "text": "不過我覺得還是要更精進一些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147923/298.wav", + "text": "我們會持續來進行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147923/299.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147923/300.wav", + "text": "部長辛苦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147923/301.wav", + "text": "謝謝主席" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147923/302.wav", + "text": "潘部長請回" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147922/0.wav", + "text": "主席可不可以請審計長財政部長主計長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147922/1.wav", + "text": "幾位首長大家好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147922/2.wav", + "text": "好事實上貧富懸殊越來越大" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147922/3.wav", + "text": "這是大家非常關心的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147922/4.wav", + "text": "社會越來越不安定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147922/5.wav", + "text": "大家都在比" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147922/6.wav", + "text": "不斷攀比的結果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147922/7.wav", + "text": "發現年輕人不吃不喝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147922/8.wav", + "text": "不斷地努力未來沒有希望" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147922/9.wav", + "text": "\n主計長年��人不吃不喝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147922/10.wav", + "text": "以月薪5萬塊來說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147922/11.wav", + "text": "他要多少年才可以買一個房子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147922/12.wav", + "text": "這一類的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147922/13.wav", + "text": "我們已經在做了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147922/14.wav", + "text": "就像租金補貼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147922/15.wav", + "text": "我們一年就會有大概300億左右" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147922/16.wav", + "text": "不能保證一定有房子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147922/17.wav", + "text": "大家住的問題都能夠解決" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147922/18.wav", + "text": "那你覺得你做得好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147922/19.wav", + "text": "那個不是我做的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147922/20.wav", + "text": "那個是內政部在處理謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147922/21.wav", + "text": "可是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147922/22.wav", + "text": "現在民怨高漲" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147922/23.wav", + "text": "買東西也貴" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147922/24.wav", + "text": "薪水不漲萬物飆漲" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147922/25.wav", + "text": "\n主計長你有沒有常常去菜市場買東西" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147922/26.wav", + "text": "有啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147922/27.wav", + "text": "你要問哪一個價格" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147922/28.wav", + "text": "我問哪一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147922/29.wav", + "text": "我隨便問一個好了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147922/30.wav", + "text": "我就是要問一個價格" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147922/31.wav", + "text": "你是有備而來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147922/32.wav", + "text": "我請問你" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147922/33.wav", + "text": "買雞蛋" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147922/34.wav", + "text": "這個是最基本的題目" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147922/35.wav", + "text": "十年前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147922/36.wav", + "text": "雞蛋一斤多少錢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147922/37.wav", + "text": "十年前我又不在這個位置" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147922/38.wav", + "text": "我可以跟你講現在的雞蛋一盒" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147922/39.wav", + "text": "好現在雞蛋一斤多少錢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147922/40.wav", + "text": "現在雞蛋一臺斤" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147922/41.wav", + "text": "大概是8到10粒一盒" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147922/42.wav", + "text": "大概是70塊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147922/43.wav", + "text": "可是你要想想看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147922/44.wav", + "text": "這個我都去查過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147922/45.wav", + "text": "大概在十年前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147922/46.wav", + "text": "你看從25漲到現在你不要說70漲" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147922/47.wav", + "text": "50都漲了一倍以上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147922/48.wav", + "text": "一般人的平均薪水是多少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147922/49.wav", + "text": "十年前一般人的薪水" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147922/50.wav", + "text": "大概是三萬多塊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147922/51.wav", + "text": "三萬多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147922/52.wav", + "text": "那到今年呢今年也一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147922/53.wav", + "text": "就是很多物價飆漲那麼多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147922/54.wav", + "text": "可是薪水的漲幅" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147922/55.wav", + "text": "是很低的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147922/56.wav", + "text": "他還是喘不過氣\n" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147922/57.wav", + "text": "計長我們現在討論這個的目的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147922/58.wav", + "text": "最重要就是要找到一個什麼樣的方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147922/59.wav", + "text": "\n麻煩經濟部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147922/60.wav", + "text": "的臺灣跟新加坡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147922/61.wav", + "text": "新加坡的國民所得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147922/62.wav", + "text": "成長非常多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147922/63.wav", + "text": "最主要是新加坡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147922/64.wav", + "text": "有未來的遠景" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147922/65.wav", + "text": "在立法院多次質詢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147922/66.wav", + "text": "就跟你講以前那個反送中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147922/67.wav", + "text": "香港的這些問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147922/68.wav", + "text": "臺灣可以取代" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147922/69.wav", + "text": "很多香港的地位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147922/70.wav", + "text": "把臺灣變成是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147922/71.wav", + "text": "亞太的金融中心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147922/72.wav", + "text": "把臺灣變成是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147922/73.wav", + "text": "最開放的國度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147922/74.wav", + "text": "讓全世界的資金可以進來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147922/75.wav", + "text": "可是你們做了什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147922/76.wav", + "text": "就經濟部的業務內容" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147922/77.wav", + "text": "我們主要是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147922/78.wav", + "text": "招來外人投資" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147922/79.wav", + "text": "外人投資這幾年下來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147922/80.wav", + "text": "已經有超過2兆以上的投資" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147922/81.wav", + "text": "這裡面當然也有包括" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147922/82.wav", + "text": "投資臺灣三大方案裡面的招商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147922/83.wav", + "text": "目前我們外人投資裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147922/84.wav", + "text": "主要比方綠能" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147922/85.wav", + "text": "雲端服務半導體相關產業" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147922/86.wav", + "text": "在製造業方面投資成長很多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147922/87.wav", + "text": "這樣的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147922/88.wav", + "text": "從供給面來創造新的資金" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147922/89.wav", + "text": "這方面是我們努力的方向" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147922/90.wav", + "text": "你不講綠能還好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147922/91.wav", + "text": "你講了綠能大家都想到雲豹" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147922/92.wav", + "text": "你講那個都是幾個少數人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147922/93.wav", + "text": "在賺的錢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147922/94.wav", + "text": "本席是希望" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147922/95.wav", + "text": "雨露均霑" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147922/96.wav", + "text": "你要帶動讓所有年輕人有希望" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147922/97.wav", + "text": "讓他願意在這個地方" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147922/98.wav", + "text": "這塊土地付出更多心血" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147922/99.wav", + "text": "流更多的汗" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147922/100.wav", + "text": "他的未來是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147922/101.wav", + "text": "可以有期待的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147922/102.wav", + "text": "可是不是啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147922/103.wav", + "text": "你現在整個扭曲了這個情況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147922/104.wav", + "text": "都是讓富者越富" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147922/105.wav", + "text": "貧者越貧啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147922/106.wav", + "text": "為什麼不像新加坡一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147922/107.wav", + "text": "你們可能人數" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147922/108.wav", + "text": "照抄" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147922/109.wav", + "text": "你也怕抄錯" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147922/110.wav", + "text": "那給你抄百分之八十九十就好了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147922/111.wav", + "text": "你也可以在國際上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147922/112.wav", + "text": "站上一個好的舞臺啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147922/113.wav", + "text": "\n最後我請教一下財政部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147922/114.wav", + "text": "部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147922/115.wav", + "text": "在你的領導之下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147922/116.wav", + "text": "昨天聽到一個好消息" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147922/117.wav", + "text": "就是兆豐" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147922/118.wav", + "text": "率先" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147922/119.wav", + "text": "每個人加薪4.5%" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147922/120.wav", + "text": "以上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147922/121.wav", + "text": "推動的嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147922/122.wav", + "text": "委員我想" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147922/123.wav", + "text": "公股民營的銀行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147922/124.wav", + "text": "是屬於公司治理的範圍" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147922/125.wav", + "text": "它看它的營運績效財務狀況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147922/126.wav", + "text": "及人力成本的費用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147922/127.wav", + "text": "這個部分其實有6家公股" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147922/128.wav", + "text": "民營的銀行都會在明年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147922/129.wav", + "text": "大部分的銀行都調多少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147922/130.wav", + "text": "大概在4%到5%之間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147922/131.wav", + "text": "不一定啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147922/132.wav", + "text": "4%左右" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147922/133.wav", + "text": "因為你帶了一個領頭羊的示範" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147922/134.wav", + "text": "請問所有軍公教" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147922/135.wav", + "text": "明年調薪的幅度是多少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147922/136.wav", + "text": "主計長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147922/137.wav", + "text": "四點幾倍" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147922/138.wav", + "text": "有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147922/139.wav", + "text": "你剛剛講幾倍" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147922/140.wav", + "text": "不要緊張啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147922/141.wav", + "text": "積極的態度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147922/142.wav", + "text": "就是明年軍公教" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147922/143.wav", + "text": "全會調薪百分之四點幾就對了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147922/144.wav", + "text": "但是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147922/145.wav", + "text": "百分之四點幾只是一點點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147922/146.wav", + "text": "物價漲幅都超過百分之一十二十了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147922/147.wav", + "text": "你調個百分之四五" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147922/148.wav", + "text": "事實上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147922/149.wav", + "text": "是杯水車薪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147922/150.wav", + "text": "啊我舉個例子好了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147922/151.wav", + "text": "關務署" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147922/152.wav", + "text": "我們看到這幾年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147922/153.wav", + "text": "如果塞港的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147922/154.wav", + "text": "或者是貨物進出多的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147922/155.wav", + "text": "人員來得多的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147922/156.wav", + "text": "統統晚上要加班" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147922/157.wav", + "text": "啊請問一下部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147922/158.wav", + "text": "你知道這些海關人員的辛苦嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147922/159.wav", + "text": "每次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147922/160.wav", + "text": "員額大概800多人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147922/161.wav", + "text": "可是事實上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147922/162.wav", + "text": "真正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147922/163.wav", + "text": "也只有6007千人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147922/164.wav", + "text": "招聘不到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147922/165.wav", + "text": "請問他們一般員工的薪資是多少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147922/166.wav", + "text": "為什麼沒有人要去海關上班呢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147922/167.wav", + "text": "因為非常辛苦海關有的要三班" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147922/168.wav", + "text": "輪班" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147922/169.wav", + "text": "對半夜有時候還要加班" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147922/170.wav", + "text": "然後關區又都比較在偏遠的地方" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147922/171.wav", + "text": "確實有很大的交通上也不是那麼方便" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147922/172.wav", + "text": "他們一個月薪水大概多少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147922/173.wav", + "text": "大家聽聽看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147922/174.wav", + "text": "報告委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147922/175.wav", + "text": "要看職等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147922/176.wav", + "text": "中間大概是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147922/177.wav", + "text": "6萬左右吧" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147922/178.wav", + "text": "5萬6萬左右" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147922/179.wav", + "text": "好部長你知不知道現在一個電焊工" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147922/180.wav", + "text": "就是在工地裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147922/181.wav", + "text": "他一天的薪資多少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147922/182.wav", + "text": "有3,000" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147922/183.wav", + "text": "主計長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147922/184.wav", + "text": "大概是300多啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147922/185.wav", + "text": "不過他的工時不固定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147922/186.wav", + "text": "300多要去哪裡請" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147922/187.wav", + "text": "不一定有啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147922/188.wav", + "text": "你的公司請得比較多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147922/189.wav", + "text": "你請3,000電" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147922/190.wav", + "text": "那個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147922/191.wav", + "text": "大概是300多元" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147922/192.wav", + "text": "可是他300多元" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147922/193.wav", + "text": "他不一定每天都有工作" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147922/194.wav", + "text": "難怪政府的標案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147922/195.wav", + "text": "每次都流標" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147922/196.wav", + "text": "因為流標了6次沒人要標" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147922/197.wav", + "text": "你現在還在那個300多元" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147922/198.wav", + "text": "你去問一下一般的建築工地" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147922/199.wav", + "text": "在請電龜都是一萬多元以上啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147922/200.wav", + "text": "所以馬上就" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147922/201.wav", + "text": "差了3倍" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147922/202.wav", + "text": "跟民間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147922/203.wav", + "text": "他們搶這些人的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147922/204.wav", + "text": "是背道而馳的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147922/205.wav", + "text": "這些薪資結構" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147922/206.wav", + "text": "你們應該要多多去探訪一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147922/207.wav", + "text": "事實就是擺在眼前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147922/208.wav", + "text": "啦如果說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147922/209.wav", + "text": "黑手類似這一類" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147922/210.wav", + "text": "做20天就二十幾萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147922/211.wav", + "text": "好的人員願意待在海關裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147922/212.wav", + "text": "半夜還要去工作" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147922/213.wav", + "text": "三班制還要輪班" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147922/214.wav", + "text": "工作壓力又大" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147922/215.wav", + "text": "你們的薪資結構" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147922/216.wav", + "text": "海關的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147922/217.wav", + "text": "因為還有很多相關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147922/218.wav", + "text": "的我是先舉這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147922/219.wav", + "text": "海關的部分你們薪資有沒有檢討過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147922/220.wav", + "text": "這一套薪資結構是在什麼時候訂的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147922/221.wav", + "text": "人總的一個薪資結構" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147922/222.wav", + "text": "按照公務人員的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147922/223.wav", + "text": "薪資結構是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147922/224.wav", + "text": "人事總處那邊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147922/225.wav", + "text": "規定的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147922/226.wav", + "text": "應該把" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147922/227.wav", + "text": "現實的情況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147922/228.wav", + "text": "跟人事總局這邊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147922/229.wav", + "text": "要參考要討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147922/230.wav", + "text": "你們都沒討論過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147922/231.wav", + "text": "請問上一次討論是什麼時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147922/232.wav", + "text": "有關於薪資結構的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147922/233.wav", + "text": "每年都會有薪資" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147922/234.wav", + "text": "審議委員會在審查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147922/235.wav", + "text": "你上一次討論是什麼時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147922/236.wav", + "text": "每年一次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147922/237.wav", + "text": "大概都在五六月的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147922/238.wav", + "text": "好五六月的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147922/239.wav", + "text": "你有沒有參加這個會議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147922/240.wav", + "text": "有人參加" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147922/241.wav", + "text": "主計長這個是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147922/242.wav", + "text": "攸關年輕人未來的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147922/243.wav", + "text": "發展" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147922/244.wav", + "text": "你不參加" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147922/245.wav", + "text": "大家想說別人講的話聽不進去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147922/246.wav", + "text": "因為大家對主計長講的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147922/247.wav", + "text": "會比較認真聽" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147922/248.wav", + "text": "雖然有時候也會講錯" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147922/249.wav", + "text": "預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147922/250.wav", + "text": "至於您剛才講的工人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147922/251.wav", + "text": "那個是有證照的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147922/252.wav", + "text": "才一天一萬多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147922/253.wav", + "text": "主計長你們真的要帶動一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147922/254.wav", + "text": "啦年輕人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147922/255.wav", + "text": "都要嗷嗷待哺" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147922/256.wav", + "text": "啊不要講遠的講近的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147922/257.wav", + "text": "講現場的記者好了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147922/258.wav", + "text": "他們是最被剝削的一群" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147922/259.wav", + "text": "啦從頭到尾" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147922/260.wav", + "text": "20年來錢就是三四萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147922/261.wav", + "text": "到現在還是三四萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147922/262.wav", + "text": "也都沒漲" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147922/263.wav", + "text": "而且記者都跑第一線" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147922/264.wav", + "text": "有時候出了狀況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147922/265.wav", + "text": "大風大雨或槍擊案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147922/266.wav", + "text": "最終就是要調薪嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147922/267.wav", + "text": "政府要做到這一點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147922/268.wav", + "text": "啊而且你們都是說明的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147922/269.wav", + "text": "好我再講一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147922/270.wav", + "text": "財政部部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147922/271.wav", + "text": "賦稅署" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147922/272.wav", + "text": "今天有來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147922/273.wav", + "text": "我們現在看得到的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147922/274.wav", + "text": "的請問地下經濟你們有沒有去抓" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147922/275.wav", + "text": "國家稅收" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147922/276.wav", + "text": "還有很大一塊沒有去收" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147922/277.wav", + "text": "啊造成極度的不公平" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147922/278.wav", + "text": "請問" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147922/279.wav", + "text": "臺北市有多少的金主" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147922/280.wav", + "text": "金主" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147922/281.wav", + "text": "金主" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147922/282.wav", + "text": "啦地下借貸" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147922/283.wav", + "text": "你們有去查過嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147922/284.wav", + "text": "他們每年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147922/285.wav", + "text": "都是20%以上在收" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147922/286.wav", + "text": "啊請問他們有沒有報" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147922/287.wav", + "text": "租金或者是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147922/288.wav", + "text": "借貸的所得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147922/289.wav", + "text": "可能他就沒有報才會稱為地下經濟" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147922/290.wav", + "text": "對為什麼這一塊你們不去查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147922/291.wav", + "text": "有我們其實在擴大稅基" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147922/292.wav", + "text": "基部分一直在努力包含金流的一些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147922/293.wav", + "text": "好你查查看我看看你的成果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147922/294.wav", + "text": "在哪裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147922/295.wav", + "text": "你這個偏頗讓富者越來越" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147922/296.wav", + "text": "富貧者越來越貧" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147922/297.wav", + "text": "啊薪資結構" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147922/298.wav", + "text": "一毛都跑不掉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147922/299.wav", + "text": "這些金主外面放貸" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147922/300.wav", + "text": "他有報嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147922/301.wav", + "text": "有報租金所得嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147922/302.wav", + "text": "有報你資料讓我看一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147922/303.wav", + "text": "我想這個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147922/304.wav", + "text": "既然稱為地下經濟的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147922/305.wav", + "text": "那你就要消滅這個地下經濟" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147922/306.wav", + "text": "啊社會才公平" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147922/307.wav", + "text": "謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147921/0.wav", + "text": "有請部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147921/1.wav", + "text": "林委員好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147921/2.wav", + "text": "好臨提沒有通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147921/3.wav", + "text": "但是質詢還是同樣的問題再" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147921/4.wav", + "text": "來問你啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147921/5.wav", + "text": "就是關於勞保" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147921/6.wav", + "text": "勞保年金改革" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147921/7.wav", + "text": "到底要怎麼做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147921/8.wav", + "text": "明年撥補" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147921/9.wav", + "text": "明年是1,200億公務預算的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147921/10.wav", + "text": "然後另外還有100億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147921/11.wav", + "text": "還有100億的特別預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147921/12.wav", + "text": "明年是1,300" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147921/13.wav", + "text": "1,300億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147921/14.wav", + "text": "撥補進去以後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147921/15.wav", + "text": "後年還要撥補嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147921/16.wav", + "text": "報告委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147921/17.wav", + "text": "其實之前院的立場就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147921/18.wav", + "text": "會持續撥補" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147921/19.wav", + "text": "當然金額我們必須看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147921/20.wav", + "text": "整個政府的財務狀況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147921/21.wav", + "text": "你覺得這是一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147921/22.wav", + "text": "解決問題的方法嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147921/23.wav", + "text": "報告委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147921/24.wav", + "text": "這是解決問題的方法之一" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147921/25.wav", + "text": "不是唯一啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147921/26.wav", + "text": "只是因為這個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147921/27.wav", + "text": "是大家比較有共識的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147921/28.wav", + "text": "像今年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147921/29.wav", + "text": "流量" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147921/30.wav", + "text": "因為退休之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147921/31.wav", + "text": "要領的人很多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147921/32.wav", + "text": "你一定要讓人領得到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147921/33.wav", + "text": "是還有就是說我們也透過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147921/34.wav", + "text": "因為基金穩定的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147921/35.wav", + "text": "投資運用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147921/36.wav", + "text": "股市比較好一點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147921/37.wav", + "text": "那就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147921/38.wav", + "text": "對收入就多一點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147921/39.wav", + "text": "活水可以進來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147921/40.wav", + "text": "像去年股債都雙跌" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147921/41.wav", + "text": "整個基金大概就是虧損" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147921/42.wav", + "text": "的但是今年我們大概" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147921/43.wav", + "text": "有11.6%" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147921/44.wav", + "text": "這個我覺得都是一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147921/45.wav", + "text": "財源的挹注啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147921/46.wav", + "text": "也是補充財源的方法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147921/47.wav", + "text": "但是你看這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147921/48.wav", + "text": "撥補" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147921/49.wav", + "text": "逐年一直增加" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147921/50.wav", + "text": "已經達到1,300億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147921/51.wav", + "text": "了請問部長你知不知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147921/52.wav", + "text": "明年公務預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147921/53.wav", + "text": "的總預算多少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147921/54.wav", + "text": "大概啦大概" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147921/55.wav", + "text": "2兆國營事業那一部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147921/56.wav", + "text": "不要算的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147921/57.wav", + "text": "呢純粹機關這邊的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147921/58.wav", + "text": "大概多少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147921/59.wav", + "text": "我是記整個數字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147921/60.wav", + "text": "大概1兆啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147921/61.wav", + "text": "大家想像一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147921/62.wav", + "text": "國營事業的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147921/63.wav", + "text": "那一些我們把它扣掉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147921/64.wav", + "text": "政府機關這邊的公務預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147921/65.wav", + "text": "一年大概1兆" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147921/66.wav", + "text": ",200億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147921/67.wav", + "text": "特別預算再加下去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147921/68.wav", + "text": "就變1,300億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147921/69.wav", + "text": "勞保年金的洞" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147921/70.wav", + "text": "將來可能越補越多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147921/71.wav", + "text": "這個會有什麼結果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147921/72.wav", + "text": "我們的整體國家財政" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147921/73.wav", + "text": "會失衡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147921/74.wav", + "text": "啦大家想像一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147921/75.wav", + "text": "結果就要拿出1,200億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147921/76.wav", + "text": "12%" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147921/77.wav", + "text": "到13%去撥補" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147921/78.wav", + "text": "勞保年金的虧損" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147921/79.wav", + "text": "大家記不記得另外一個數字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147921/80.wav", + "text": "台電的虧損" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147921/81.wav", + "text": "明年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147921/82.wav", + "text": "要撥補多少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147921/83.wav", + "text": "這個部長可能不知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147921/84.wav", + "text": "預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147921/85.wav", + "text": "因為政策" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147921/86.wav", + "text": "綠能政策各種政策" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147921/87.wav", + "text": "所以就虧損1,000億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147921/88.wav", + "text": "但不能讓它倒" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147921/89.wav", + "text": "啊所以就補它1,000億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147921/90.wav", + "text": "然後勞保年金" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147921/91.wav", + "text": "也不能讓它倒" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147921/92.wav", + "text": "補它1,200億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147921/93.wav", + "text": "以後我們的總預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147921/94.wav", + "text": "統統在補洞" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147921/95.wav", + "text": "啦請問將來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147921/96.wav", + "text": "新興計畫國家建設" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147921/97.wav", + "text": "的錢從哪裡來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147921/98.wav", + "text": "啊我的意思是說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147921/99.wav", + "text": "這不是方法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147921/100.wav", + "text": "嘛這不是方法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147921/101.wav", + "text": "不是制度性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147921/102.wav", + "text": "解決問題的方法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147921/103.wav", + "text": "到最後全部的錢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147921/104.wav", + "text": "都拿去補這些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147921/105.wav", + "text": "非補不可的洞" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147921/106.wav", + "text": "那我們的國家建設" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147921/107.wav", + "text": "財政就整個停滯" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147921/108.wav", + "text": "到最後的結果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147921/109.wav", + "text": "可能就產生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147921/110.wav", + "text": "像很多我們聽到的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147921/111.wav", + "text": "外國那種國家破產" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147921/112.wav", + "text": "債務無法償還的狀況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147921/113.wav", + "text": "嘛比如說希臘" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147921/114.wav", + "text": "比如說我們聽聞過的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147921/115.wav", + "text": "這些歐洲幾小國" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147921/116.wav", + "text": "之前發生的這種狀況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147921/117.wav", + "text": "所以這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147921/118.wav", + "text": "看有什麼制度性的方法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147921/119.wav", + "text": "好啦你已經講了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147921/120.wav", + "text": "我就一直問你" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147921/121.wav", + "text": "嘛你是上任最久的部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147921/122.wav", + "text": "再說一次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147921/123.wav", + "text": "勞保���金改革方案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147921/124.wav", + "text": "提不出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147921/125.wav", + "text": "我就跟你講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147921/126.wav", + "text": "撥補不是一個制度性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147921/127.wav", + "text": "解決問題的辦法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147921/128.wav", + "text": "嘛而且越補越多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147921/129.wav", + "text": "本來可能要去做建設的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147921/130.wav", + "text": "買飛機的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147921/131.wav", + "text": "也許要去做社會福利的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147921/132.wav", + "text": "把它撥補過來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147921/133.wav", + "text": "後那邊就少掉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147921/134.wav", + "text": "啊因為總預算就是1兆" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147921/135.wav", + "text": "嘛所以這是方法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147921/136.wav", + "text": "勞保年金改革方案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147921/137.wav", + "text": "在你卸任之前提出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147921/138.wav", + "text": "有辦法承諾嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147921/139.wav", + "text": "具體承諾" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147921/140.wav", + "text": "五年多了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147921/141.wav", + "text": "還是沒有期" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147921/142.wav", + "text": "但是我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147921/143.wav", + "text": "蔡總統也上任七年多了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147921/144.wav", + "text": "一直說要提" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147921/145.wav", + "text": "勞保年金改革" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147921/146.wav", + "text": "你作為一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147921/147.wav", + "text": "在任最久的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147921/148.wav", + "text": "蔡總統上任之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147921/149.wav", + "text": "在任最久的勞動部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147921/150.wav", + "text": "要確保勞工的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147921/151.wav", + "text": "一方面確保勞工的權益" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147921/152.wav", + "text": "繳了保費" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147921/153.wav", + "text": "之後將來領得到該領的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147921/154.wav", + "text": "然後也要確保國家財政" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147921/155.wav", + "text": "不會失衡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147921/156.wav", + "text": "不會破產" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147921/157.wav", + "text": "你的方案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147921/158.wav", + "text": "他說我們的公務預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147921/159.wav", + "text": "有2.8兆" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147921/160.wav", + "text": "啦明年是2.8兆" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147921/161.wav", + "text": "那個含國營事業" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147921/162.wav", + "text": "對報告委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147921/163.wav", + "text": "了那是方法之一不是唯一" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147921/164.wav", + "text": "啦其他當然還有一些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147921/165.wav", + "text": "方案的面向都要去處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147921/166.wav", + "text": "就是說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147921/167.wav", + "text": "你的改革方案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147921/168.wav", + "text": "改革方案我就" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147921/169.wav", + "text": "不是撥補方案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147921/170.wav", + "text": "撥補是方案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147921/171.wav", + "text": "那也是方案之一" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147921/172.wav", + "text": "但不是解決問題的辦法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147921/173.wav", + "text": "不是唯一辦法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147921/174.wav", + "text": "欠多少你們補多少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147921/175.wav", + "text": "是挖東牆補西牆" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147921/176.wav", + "text": "委員因為這兩年的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147921/177.wav", + "text": "其他整體國家預算的平衡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147921/178.wav", + "text": "沒有基本上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147921/179.wav", + "text": "因為這個主總" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147921/180.wav", + "text": "一定會去考量" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147921/181.wav", + "text": "是在不影響其他" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147921/182.wav", + "text": "經濟建設的情況下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147921/183.wav", + "text": "你稍微提一個方向" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147921/184.wav", + "text": "勞保年金改革的方向" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147921/185.wav", + "text": "有沒有方向" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147921/186.wav", + "text": "現在還沒有方案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147921/187.wav", + "text": "但有沒有方向" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147921/188.wav", + "text": "如果你連方向都沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147921/189.wav", + "text": "一個大概的方向都沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147921/190.wav", + "text": "那你要如何提方案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147921/191.wav", + "text": "我們目前就是以穩定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147921/192.wav", + "text": "其他各個面向" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147921/193.wav", + "text": "我們會積極的來跟各界" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147921/194.wav", + "text": "至於期程的部分我們會看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147921/195.wav", + "text": "整個溝通的結果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147921/196.wav", + "text": "廣納各界的意見之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147921/197.wav", + "text": "會周延的來做規劃" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147921/198.wav", + "text": "啦然後我們才會有具體方案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147921/199.wav", + "text": "到最後才會落實到法案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147921/200.wav", + "text": "嘛提出法案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147921/201.wav", + "text": "\n好剛剛臨時提案裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147921/202.wav", + "text": "已經有提到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147921/203.wav", + "text": "按照臨時提案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147921/204.wav", + "text": "請你用書面給我們做回答" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147921/205.wav", + "text": "就是針對勞保年金" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147921/206.wav", + "text": "改革方案的一個大方向" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147921/207.wav", + "text": "提出你們研究了五年多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147921/208.wav", + "text": "到底研究出什麼成果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147921/209.wav", + "text": "最少提出幾個建議的方向" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147921/210.wav", + "text": "有助於將來我們提法案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147921/211.wav", + "text": "要修法的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147921/212.wav", + "text": "總要有一個方向" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147921/213.wav", + "text": "請你用書面回答本席" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147921/214.wav", + "text": "及其他委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147921/215.wav", + "text": "謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147921/216.wav", + "text": "不好意思" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147921/217.wav", + "text": "補充宣告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147920/0.wav", + "text": "主席有請陳部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147920/1.wav", + "text": "來陳部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147920/2.wav", + "text": "陳部長好我接著蔡委員的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147920/3.wav", + "text": "關於依親打工的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147920/4.wav", + "text": "到底目前行政院的態度是怎麼樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147920/5.wav", + "text": "很多的小農還是不斷跟我們反映" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147920/6.wav", + "text": "因為季節性的關係" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147920/7.wav", + "text": "高密度的採收" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147920/8.wav", + "text": "其實都沒有一些外勞" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147920/9.wav", + "text": "如果能夠短期內假日的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147920/10.wav", + "text": "有依親打工或許比較可行一點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147920/11.wav", + "text": "報告委員這一部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147920/12.wav", + "text": "我們已經提了一個方案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147920/13.wav", + "text": "並行文到勞動部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147920/14.wav", + "text": "現在最主要的癥結是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147920/15.wav", + "text": "是在審查的機制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147920/16.wav", + "text": "我們當時是希望由農業部來審查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147920/17.wav", + "text": "就是已經來到臺灣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147920/18.wav", + "text": "能夠直接登記後就可以到農場去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147920/19.wav", + "text": "們什麼時候要跟勞動部進行政策的對話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147920/20.wav", + "text": "勞動部現在勞動部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147920/21.wav", + "text": "部還是希望依照就服法的方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147920/22.wav", + "text": "要依照外籍移工申請的審查機制去辦理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147920/23.wav", + "text": "所以就是沒有辦法達到那個效益" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147920/24.wav", + "text": "所以我們還在針對這個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147920/25.wav", + "text": "我跟委員說明一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147920/26.wav", + "text": "我們本身希望農業部可以針對這個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147920/27.wav", + "text": "因為我們目前知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147920/28.wav", + "text": "基本上很難請一整年的外勞" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147920/29.wav", + "text": "最大的問題在這邊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147920/30.wav", + "text": "啦第二個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147920/31.wav", + "text": "你如果要短期間的引用的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147920/32.wav", + "text": "勞動部現在有一個模式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147920/33.wav", + "text": "現在比較淡季" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147920/34.wav", + "text": "它聘請的外勞等於是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147920/35.wav", + "text": "它可以媒合給其他的行業別" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147920/36.wav", + "text": "讓他能夠extra不用增加錢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147920/37.wav", + "text": "跟不同產業之間可以媒合" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147920/38.wav", + "text": "那麼也可以把過餘的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147920/39.wav", + "text": "短期媒合給農業" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147920/40.wav", + "text": "你們也可以寫這樣方案對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147920/41.wav", + "text": "這個部分我想我們跟委員的想法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147920/42.wav", + "text": "跟方��是一致的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147920/43.wav", + "text": "但是相對的因為勞動部現在有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147920/44.wav", + "text": "很明確的規範在那邊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147920/45.wav", + "text": "我們一直在協調說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147920/46.wav", + "text": "沒有你一個是引進他們的是引進" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147920/47.wav", + "text": "我現在談的是媒合" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147920/48.wav", + "text": "是國內的媒合" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147920/49.wav", + "text": "我的意思是司長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147920/50.wav", + "text": "你可以把這個想法跟他們說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147920/51.wav", + "text": "因為他們現在已經有這個辦法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147920/52.wav", + "text": "不同的行業企業之間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147920/53.wav", + "text": "或者是不忙的狀態" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147920/54.wav", + "text": "這部分勞動部認為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147920/55.wav", + "text": "據做這個工作" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147920/56.wav", + "text": "的探親外籍人士" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147920/57.wav", + "text": "他要做體檢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147920/58.wav", + "text": "沒有我現在跟你談的已經是不一樣的樣態了啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147920/59.wav", + "text": "司長你聽不懂我的意思" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147920/60.wav", + "text": "的勞工媒合啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147920/61.wav", + "text": "申請其他類別的移工是可以轉到農業的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147920/62.wav", + "text": "已經有這個機制了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147920/63.wav", + "text": "有這個機制可是不足啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147920/64.wav", + "text": "很多小農不知道啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147920/65.wav", + "text": "我是在說短期的我意思是說短期" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147920/66.wav", + "text": "的這些要納入啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147920/67.wav", + "text": "是在農糧的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147920/68.wav", + "text": "現在已經開放了未來這部分會解決" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147920/69.wav", + "text": "我在跟你說小農" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147920/70.wav", + "text": "老農津貼的排富條款要改啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147920/71.wav", + "text": "是500萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147920/72.wav", + "text": "房價指數換算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147920/73.wav", + "text": "已經高達800萬了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147920/74.wav", + "text": "你要面對這個問題啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147920/75.wav", + "text": "其他八大福利措施一起處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147920/76.wav", + "text": "為什麼要配合" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147920/77.wav", + "text": "沒有因為國家本身的福利制度是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147920/78.wav", + "text": "沒有這個排富你就單一排富" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147920/79.wav", + "text": "不合理就應該要調整" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147920/80.wav", + "text": "就如同我們的老農津貼一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147920/81.wav", + "text": "做調整經濟成長率做調整" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147920/82.wav", + "text": "這是同樣的道理啊四年調一次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147920/83.wav", + "text": "調到8,080同樣的道理啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147920/84.wav", + "text": "所以我說我們會後會來做一些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147920/85.wav", + "text": "兩個禮拜給我一個明確的答復" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147920/86.wav", + "text": "不然��問那麼久你們都沒有答復" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147920/87.wav", + "text": "復\n接下來農地徵收之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147920/88.wav", + "text": "的農保資格要怎麼處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147920/89.wav", + "text": "即3年但3年之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147920/90.wav", + "text": "老農基本上都沒有感覺" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147920/91.wav", + "text": "沒有感覺的情況底下等到他真的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147920/92.wav", + "text": "喪失資格他要領的時候卻被告知說不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147920/93.wav", + "text": "他已經沒有農保的資格了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147920/94.wav", + "text": "這個部分有沒有補救方法有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147920/95.wav", + "text": "追溯的一個可能性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147920/96.wav", + "text": "報告委員這部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147920/97.wav", + "text": "都沒有取得土地我們都會去提醒" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147920/98.wav", + "text": "來維持農保的資格" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147920/99.wav", + "text": "老農就靠這一個農保" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147920/100.wav", + "text": "而已結果他因為配合" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147920/101.wav", + "text": "政府的政策徵收" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147920/102.wav", + "text": "然後就失去這個資格" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147920/103.wav", + "text": "我常常遇到這種案子司長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147920/104.wav", + "text": "如果是這個業務" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147920/105.wav", + "text": "至少在六四四清查的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147920/106.wav", + "text": "我們都會你要去幫忙" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147920/107.wav", + "text": "你們要協助一下嘛好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147920/108.wav", + "text": "就是做專案協助一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147920/109.wav", + "text": "不然配合你政策而失去土地的農民" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147920/110.wav", + "text": "居然沒有辦法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147920/111.wav", + "text": "受到農保的保障這不是很荒謬嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147920/112.wav", + "text": "我們的自給率很高不會受到影響" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147920/113.wav", + "text": "但相對的乳品還是有替代的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147920/114.wav", + "text": "母牛越來越少的情況下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147920/115.wav", + "text": "到時候就會有肉源來源不足" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147920/116.wav", + "text": "它會衝擊到整個牛肉湯的產業" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147920/117.wav", + "text": "我跟委員說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147920/118.wav", + "text": "能對我們酪農產生的衝擊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147920/119.wav", + "text": "其實我們已經做好了一個完整的規劃" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147920/120.wav", + "text": "我現在跟你談的不是肉牛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147920/121.wav", + "text": "我是談肉牛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147920/122.wav", + "text": "也就是牛肉湯─臺南最有名的牛肉湯" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147920/123.wav", + "text": "我們淘汰的乳牛可以進到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147920/124.wav", + "text": "是現在肉品來源" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147920/125.wav", + "text": "以後就會受到排擠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147920/126.wav", + "text": "乳品開放進口之後會讓我們的市場變小" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147920/127.wav", + "text": "乳牛的人會越來越少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147920/128.wav", + "text": "牛肉湯的貨源也會越來越少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147920/129.wav", + "text": "你聽不懂我的意思" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147920/130.wav", + "text": "所以你不能只" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147920/131.wav", + "text": "還要從牛肉湯部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147920/132.wav", + "text": "可能會造成的衝擊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147920/133.wav", + "text": "提出一個因應方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147920/134.wav", + "text": "了解我想我們也會從消費端本身" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147920/135.wav", + "text": "要維持一個牛肉的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147920/136.wav", + "text": "對啊你們只想到乳牛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147920/137.wav", + "text": "沒有想到另外相關的牛肉產業" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147920/138.wav", + "text": "相關的產業鏈" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147920/139.wav", + "text": "麻煩你評估一下一個月給本席一個報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147920/140.wav", + "text": "謝謝主席" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147920/141.wav", + "text": "我們接下來請鍾佳濱" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147919/0.wav", + "text": "謝謝召委有請陳部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147919/1.wav", + "text": "我想農糧署的胡署長也一起好嗎謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147919/2.wav", + "text": "是陳部長好我相信我們很努力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147919/3.wav", + "text": "所以不管是農民的退休金或者是保險" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147919/4.wav", + "text": "或者是灌溉設施我們都已經有進展了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147919/5.wav", + "text": "但是我們現在遇到了一個非常難處理的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147919/6.wav", + "text": "就是農業廢棄物" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147919/7.wav", + "text": "農業廢棄物分成兩種一種當然就是塑膠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147919/8.wav", + "text": "比如說我們南投種木瓜的名間種茶的生薑的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147919/9.wav", + "text": "火龍果的都有這些塑膠的載體" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147919/10.wav", + "text": "那這件事情呢我在第9屆立委的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147919/11.wav", + "text": "就有跟農糧署還有當時的環保署" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147919/12.wav", + "text": "現在的環境部來做推動" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147919/13.wav", + "text": "那我跟大家講這件事情看起來好像有進展" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147919/14.wav", + "text": "可是實質上沒解決我們先來看這張照片" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147919/15.wav", + "text": "這個是我親自去名間鄉的垃圾場" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147919/16.wav", + "text": "它堆置的除了這些家庭的垃圾之外" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147919/17.wav", + "text": "很多都是農業廢棄物已經超過40噸" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147919/18.wav", + "text": "\n農業廢棄物我剛剛講有兩種" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147919/19.wav", + "text": "嘛一個是有機質那個我們都可以做循環使用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147919/20.wav", + "text": "待會我們再講我們就先講這些無機質好了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147919/21.wav", + "text": "我可以跟大家講在第9屆的時候我們針對魚池鄉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147919/22.wav", + "text": "比如說你是種香菇的你有太空包" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147919/23.wav", + "text": "那個已經有制度化的回收了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147919/24.wav", + "text": "可是如果你是種蘭花的他的這些需要做的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147919/25.wav", + "text": "或者是你種絲瓜的抑草蓆沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147919/26.wav", + "text": "我先跟你講你們現在在做的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147919/27.wav", + "text": "你們現在就是比如說等蘭花產期之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147919/28.wav", + "text": "或者是銷售期之後蘭花一般都是過年後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147919/29.wav", + "text": "做這些塑膠廢棄物的回收" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147919/30.wav", + "text": "可是如果是種絲瓜或蔬菜" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147919/31.wav", + "text": "就是看產期之後做塑膠物的回收" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147919/32.wav", + "text": "可是發生了什麼事情呢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147919/33.wav", + "text": "農民好不容易辛苦的把這些垃圾塑膠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147919/34.wav", + "text": "很重喔捲好然後送到集合的定點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147919/35.wav", + "text": "結果可能因為土太多水太多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147919/36.wav", + "text": "你要叫這些農民怎麼辦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147919/37.wav", + "text": "不是只有農民啊不管是一起來打拚的公所" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147919/38.wav", + "text": "還是農會也很尷尬啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147919/39.wav", + "text": "啊都已經拿來了你說不能收" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147919/40.wav", + "text": "你農委會應該跟環境部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147919/41.wav", + "text": "因為你們農委會規劃很多的農機具" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147919/42.wav", + "text": "然後環境部應該要來針對不同的類型" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147919/43.wav", + "text": "PPPU等各式各樣的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147919/44.wav", + "text": "要有一個回收機制你們來串聯" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147919/45.wav", + "text": "那時候我跟一個大哥他已經八十幾歲了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147919/46.wav", + "text": "他說很簡單的啦你有辦法把那個果汁機" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147919/47.wav", + "text": "拿來做回收機" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147919/48.wav", + "text": "就是乾脆做一個大型的機具" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147919/49.wav", + "text": "全部旋轉把土跟水留在當地" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147919/50.wav", + "text": "把塑膠擠壓成小小的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147919/51.wav", + "text": "就可以完成了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147919/52.wav", + "text": "所以我拜託好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147919/53.wav", + "text": "這件事情我一定會讓環境部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147919/54.wav", + "text": "跟農業部來開公聽會討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147919/55.wav", + "text": "要不然是非常嚴重的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147919/56.wav", + "text": "因為你若是在有種菜的地方" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147919/57.wav", + "text": "我相信你也知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147919/58.wav", + "text": "啦比較晚的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147919/59.wav", + "text": "很遠的田地就冒黑煙了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147919/60.wav", + "text": "那是怎樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147919/61.wav", + "text": "但他也沒辦法越來越多了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147919/62.wav", + "text": "嘛不然就是下大雨的時候就跟著放水流" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147919/63.wav", + "text": "這件事情你一定要處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147919/64.wav", + "text": "所以我說目前的試辦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147919/65.wav", + "text": "顯然泥土跟水沒辦法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147919/66.wav", + "text": "你要想辦法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147919/67.wav", + "text": "看是不是可以設計一個農機具" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147919/68.wav", + "text": "而且我想像它是移動型的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147919/69.wav", + "text": "它可以開去田地開去山邊回收" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147919/70.wav", + "text": "然後就把土跟水留在當地" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147919/71.wav", + "text": "把塑膠壓縮就可以回收" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147919/72.wav", + "text": "你可以去做比賽" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147919/73.wav", + "text": "啊從臺大到中興到屏科大" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147919/74.wav", + "text": "都有農機的相關系" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147919/75.wav", + "text": "我跟委員說明一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147919/76.wav", + "text": "您剛才講到一個重點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147919/77.wav", + "text": "就是這些事業廢棄物" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147919/78.wav", + "text": "即一些無機的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147919/79.wav", + "text": "其最困難的就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147919/80.wav", + "text": "它的土跟一些水造成一些困擾" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147919/81.wav", + "text": "然後現在我們也跟試驗改良場所" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147919/82.wav", + "text": "場所有一些類似徵案的概念" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147919/83.wav", + "text": "農膜回收機不好用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147919/84.wav", + "text": "為什麼你知道嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147919/85.wav", + "text": "類似" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147919/86.wav", + "text": "但那就是沒辦法把土跟水用掉嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147919/87.wav", + "text": "我不是說不要用農膜回收機" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147919/88.wav", + "text": "但是你應該要針對需求" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147919/89.wav", + "text": "不然這樣好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147919/90.wav", + "text": "你可不可以要求農糧署長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147919/91.wav", + "text": "跟我到名間鄉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147919/92.wav", + "text": "去找名間鄉公所" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147919/93.wav", + "text": "到南投去找南投市公所" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147919/94.wav", + "text": "因為你們現在在試辦的是在魚池鄉公所" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147919/95.wav", + "text": "是不是容許我來簡單答復" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147919/96.wav", + "text": "事實上我們已經有專案核定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147919/97.wav", + "text": "埔里要設立一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147919/98.wav", + "text": "可以處理農膜" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147919/99.wav", + "text": "還有這些樹枝枝條這些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147919/100.wav", + "text": "這是不一樣的兩件事" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147919/101.wav", + "text": "樹枝是有機質" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147919/102.wav", + "text": "農膜是無機關於" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147919/103.wav", + "text": "農膜的回收" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147919/104.wav", + "text": "如果你在定點的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147919/105.wav", + "text": "你就會遇到第二個難題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147919/106.wav", + "text": "你要叫一個80歲的農民" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147919/107.wav", + "text": "喔我建議你一定要去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147919/108.wav", + "text": "用能夠循環回收的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147919/109.wav", + "text": "對啦所以我們現在埔里" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147919/110.wav", + "text": "的計畫就可以設了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147919/111.wav", + "text": "設了之後就馬上可以處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147919/112.wav", + "text": "我們已經跟名間鄉公所" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147919/113.wav", + "text": "因為環保單位已經要統一來收" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147919/114.wav", + "text": "我剛剛說的很簡單" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147919/115.wav", + "text": "不是公所來洗啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147919/116.wav", + "text": "說你剛剛提到名間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147919/117.wav", + "text": "它的清潔隊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147919/118.wav", + "text": "主要是處理家庭垃圾的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147919/119.wav", + "text": "但農業廢棄物來的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147919/120.wav", + "text": "它也不能不處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147919/121.wav", + "text": "然後你要這些清潔人員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147919/122.wav", + "text": "要去刷嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147919/123.wav", + "text": "要去沖嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147919/124.wav", + "text": "所以我要跟你講的很簡單" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147919/125.wav", + "text": "就去規劃" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147919/126.wav", + "text": "一個農機具試辦的方案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147919/127.wav", + "text": "嘛看怎麼樣可以快速的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147919/128.wav", + "text": "不管它是用洗捲的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147919/129.wav", + "text": "過程有沖水" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147919/130.wav", + "text": "還是我剛剛講的一個阿伯" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147919/131.wav", + "text": "跟我講果汁機的打法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147919/132.wav", + "text": "你們要來做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147919/133.wav", + "text": "啦我可以百分之百跟你說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147919/134.wav", + "text": "你去現場看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147919/135.wav", + "text": "去做你會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147919/136.wav", + "text": "我瞭解" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147919/137.wav", + "text": "我們臺南場已經有開發這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147919/138.wav", + "text": "了能夠把土跟塑膠布本身" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147919/139.wav", + "text": "做一個分離" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147919/140.wav", + "text": "已經有了對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147919/141.wav", + "text": "好那可不可以拜託" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147919/142.wav", + "text": "由你來指揮農糧署" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147919/143.wav", + "text": "跟我跟名間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147919/144.wav", + "text": "還有南投市公所來處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147919/145.wav", + "text": "這個事情一定要處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147919/146.wav", + "text": "我相信你也知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147919/147.wav", + "text": "看到那些黑煙你就會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147919/148.wav", + "text": "但是你可以說什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147919/149.wav", + "text": "所以你說要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147919/150.wav", + "text": "要什麼時候我們現在來說時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147919/151.wav", + "text": "我想我們會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147919/152.wav", + "text": "一個月內" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147919/153.wav", + "text": "我跟農糧署署長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147919/154.wav", + "text": "來跟名間鄉還有南投市" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147919/155.wav", + "text": "來討論這件事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147919/156.wav", + "text": "我很快的講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147919/157.wav", + "text": "我跟大家講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147919/158.wav", + "text": "農廢不是廢棄物" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147919/159.wav", + "text": "特別是循環經濟" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147919/160.wav", + "text": "這一個杯子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147919/161.wav", + "text": "當然我只是拿選舉的樣品" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147919/162.wav", + "text": "它其實有跟臺灣的大企業合作" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147919/163.wav", + "text": "它完全適用有機質" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147919/164.wav", + "text": "可以做生活用品" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147919/165.wav", + "text": "而且目前已經跟經濟部在談" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147919/166.wav", + "text": "臺灣是不是可以去創造" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147919/167.wav", + "text": "因為他們有得到國外的專利" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147919/168.wav", + "text": "我不是在講單一廠商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147919/169.wav", + "text": "我相信你們現在在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147919/170.wav", + "text": "任何的超級市場" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147919/171.wav", + "text": "做的有機生活的農產品" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147919/172.wav", + "text": "這些東西" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147919/173.wav", + "text": "不是只能做生活用品而已" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147919/174.wav", + "text": "細碎的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147919/175.wav", + "text": "比如說竹子可以做竹劍" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147919/176.wav", + "text": "可以做筷子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147919/177.wav", + "text": "可以做牙籤" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147919/178.wav", + "text": "到最後細碎的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147919/179.wav", + "text": "它就可以擠壓成燃料棒" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147919/180.wav", + "text": "目前的紙廠有在收喔" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147919/181.wav", + "text": "所以我覺得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147919/182.wav", + "text": "你要系統性地來做這些事" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147919/183.wav", + "text": "不管是我剛剛講的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147919/184.wav", + "text": "無機農廢的回收" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147919/185.wav", + "text": "或者是產業的循環" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147919/186.wav", + "text": "或者是生質燃料棒" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147919/187.wav", + "text": "這些事情都應該做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147919/188.wav", + "text": "我最後只問一件事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147919/189.wav", + "text": "待會郭委員會來回復" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147919/190.wav", + "text": "我們曾經討論過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147919/191.wav", + "text": "探親幫農" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147919/192.wav", + "text": "就是我們新住民的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147919/193.wav", + "text": "爸爸媽媽來臺灣打工" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147919/194.wav", + "text": "他可以幫忙採茶" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147919/195.wav", + "text": "他可以幫忙採收火龍果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147919/196.wav", + "text": "這件事情是要有進度的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147919/197.wav", + "text": "我知道我時間已經到了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147919/198.wav", + "text": "所以我跟郭委員聯合質詢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147919/199.wav", + "text": "後續請郭委員來討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147919/200.wav", + "text": "辛苦了謝謝大家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147918/0.wav", + "text": "謝謝主席謝謝召委" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147918/1.wav", + "text": "秘書長好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147918/2.wav", + "text": "各位處長或主計長副主計長大家好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147918/3.wav", + "text": "本席過去也是公務員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147918/4.wav", + "text": "當然就私人來講很多人認為說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147918/5.wav", + "text": "要是不能領到退休金或者領少了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147918/6.wav", + "text": "一般來講大家心裡都會很care" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147918/7.wav", + "text": "我們認為國家要永續" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147918/8.wav", + "text": "我們一定還是可以領得到錢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147918/9.wav", + "text": "領多領少能夠照顧到生活就好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147918/10.wav", + "text": "其實我個人並不在意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147918/11.wav", + "text": "一定要領到滿滿多少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147918/12.wav", + "text": "像我們18%也沒有了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147918/13.wav", + "text": "我也OK" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147918/14.wav", + "text": "但是我自己很幸運" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147918/15.wav", + "text": "還可以繼續再當立法委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147918/16.wav", + "text": "所以我想當我們持平地去討論這個問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147918/17.wav", + "text": "也不能說不重要其實也很重要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147918/18.wav", + "text": "因為公務人員一輩子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147918/19.wav", + "text": "戮力在公務上也要有相當的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147918/20.wav", + "text": "酬勞跟退休的給付" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147918/21.wav", + "text": "\n另外我請教一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147918/22.wav", + "text": "退撫基金的管理局長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147918/23.wav", + "text": "本席過去也擔任過勞動局局長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147918/24.wav", + "text": "勞退的舊制叫做提撥制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147918/25.wav", + "text": "很多工廠到將近15年的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147918/26.wav", + "text": "它可能就要解散並關廠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147918/27.wav", + "text": "所以讓很多勞工領不到退休金" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147918/28.wav", + "text": "何況資遣費都拿不到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147918/29.wav", + "text": "到民國94年7月1日勞退新制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147918/30.wav", + "text": "開始施行以後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147918/31.wav", + "text": "他的底薪的6%" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147918/32.wav", + "text": "然後他自己還可以自願再繳付" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147918/33.wav", + "text": "勞工不會領不到退休金" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147918/34.wav", + "text": "因為老闆要提繳6%" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147918/35.wav", + "text": "這6%看他的那個基本的數字是多少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147918/36.wav", + "text": "所繳的就是多少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147918/37.wav", + "text": "所以老闆經常會壓低他的薪資" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147918/38.wav", + "text": "但是又為了要留住勞工" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147918/39.wav", + "text": "因此會把獎金提高" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147918/40.wav", + "text": "至少會讓他平衡一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147918/41.wav", + "text": "現在勞退金是沒有問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147918/42.wav", + "text": "那麼現在我們自己軍公教人員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147918/43.wav", + "text": "現在也開始有新制了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147918/44.wav", + "text": "今年7月1日開始我們就要實行新制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147918/45.wav", + "text": "那我們來問一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147918/46.wav", + "text": "因為我們軍公教" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147918/47.wav", + "text": "國家永續" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147918/48.wav", + "text": "軍公教的這些退休金" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147918/49.wav", + "text": "應該就可以永續" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147918/50.wav", + "text": "應該沒有什麼問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147918/51.wav", + "text": "守護好我們中華民國臺灣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147918/52.wav", + "text": "也可以保障我們所有軍公教的退休金" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147918/53.wav", + "text": "保障全體的國民" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147918/54.wav", + "text": "過去有所謂八百零壯士的這個陳抗" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147918/55.wav", + "text": "現在有沒有逐步改進了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147918/56.wav", + "text": "目前沒有這個現象" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147918/57.wav", + "text": "都已經有拉高了吧" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147918/58.wav", + "text": "對我們國軍在這一段都沒有問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147918/59.wav", + "text": "都沒有問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147918/60.wav", + "text": "喔沒有人在陳抗" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147918/61.wav", + "text": "了不過過去八百零壯士" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147918/62.wav", + "text": "不過我想慢慢考慮" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147918/63.wav", + "text": "像比較高階退伍退休的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147918/64.wav", + "text": "應該薪資都還滿高的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147918/65.wav", + "text": "都還可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147918/66.wav", + "text": "我認為只要退休生活過得去就好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147918/67.wav", + "text": "不用斤斤計較" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147918/68.wav", + "text": "啦國家永續我們一定領得到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147918/69.wav", + "text": "我相信這個看法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147918/70.wav", + "text": "應該大家都可以認同" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147918/71.wav", + "text": "了其實現在的制度對國軍也很照顧" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147918/72.wav", + "text": "OK好謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147918/73.wav", + "text": "就會比年金改革後提前5年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147918/74.wav", + "text": "剛才有講到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147918/75.wav", + "text": "在2046年會用罄" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147918/76.wav", + "text": "但是去年我們有修正通過公務人員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147918/77.wav", + "text": "還有公立學校教職員退休資遣撫卹條例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147918/78.wav", + "text": "明定就是由政府分年編列預算來進行撥補" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147918/79.wav", + "text": "這讓大家很安心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147918/80.wav", + "text": "了會分年撥補了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147918/81.wav", + "text": "但現在就是行政院先給我們100億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147918/82.wav", + "text": "雖然低於勞保撥補金額" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147918/83.wav", + "text": "看起來有很多人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147918/84.wav", + "text": "是不是要吃味" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147918/85.wav", + "text": "不用吃味" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147918/86.wav", + "text": "我覺得不必" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147918/87.wav", + "text": "啦因為勞工人數真的很多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147918/88.wav", + "text": "真的是要用那麼多錢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147918/89.wav", + "text": "因為他們要求繳費繳得少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147918/90.wav", + "text": "所以沒有撥補那麼多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147918/91.wav", + "text": "公教退撫基金" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147918/92.wav", + "text": "公務人員教育人員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147918/93.wav", + "text": "每年分別需要撥補大概285億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147918/94.wav", + "text": "這個數字對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147918/95.wav", + "text": "對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147918/96.wav", + "text": "喔實際能夠撥補的金額" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147918/97.wav", + "text": "的差距對於這個撥補不足的地方" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147918/98.wav", + "text": "我們會怎麼去說明調整的方法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147918/99.wav", + "text": "因為我們現在才先撥補100億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147918/100.wav", + "text": "當家總是要全體考量" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147918/101.wav", + "text": "要全面的像是國防外交什麼都要顧" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147918/102.wav", + "text": "到2046年還沒到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147918/103.wav", + "text": "我們認為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147918/104.wav", + "text": "只要我們自己負責的這個單位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147918/105.wav", + "text": "撥補將來會有大空缺" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147918/106.wav", + "text": "總是有調整的空間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147918/107.wav", + "text": "不會說這會丟臉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147918/108.wav", + "text": "我想沒有什麼丟臉問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147918/109.wav", + "text": "當家難" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147918/110.wav", + "text": "啦只要當過家的人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147918/111.wav", + "text": "都會面面考慮" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147918/112.wav", + "text": "不是只有考慮我們軍公教人員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147918/113.wav", + "text": "但會保證讓你有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147918/114.wav", + "text": "所以國家要富強" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147918/115.wav", + "text": "大家一起合力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147918/116.wav", + "text": "嘛不要大家看衰" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147918/117.wav", + "text": "全世界也看到我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147918/118.wav", + "text": "民主國家經濟力也夠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147918/119.wav", + "text": "這些都足以讓我們覺得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147918/120.wav", + "text": "我們很有遠景" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147918/121.wav", + "text": "不需要看衰" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147918/122.wav", + "text": "不曉得你們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147918/123.wav", + "text": "會怎麼樣還是秘書長這邊會不會怎麼樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147918/124.wav", + "text": "再跟我回" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147918/125.wav", + "text": "謝謝委員關心這個問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147918/126.wav", + "text": "我再補充兩句" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147918/127.wav", + "text": "第一個就是說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147918/128.wav", + "text": "他現在依法應該領多少退休金" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147918/129.wav", + "text": "不會因為這個撥補的速度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147918/130.wav", + "text": "因為法律上他該領多少就領多少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147918/131.wav", + "text": "所以不會有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147918/132.wav", + "text": "老闆賴皮或怎麼樣的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147918/133.wav", + "text": "我剛才一直在想" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147918/134.wav", + "text": "我覺得會變成這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147918/135.wav", + "text": "依法政府要負這個責任" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147918/136.wav", + "text": "的那麼將來就要補的多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147918/137.wav", + "text": "如果一開始補的多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147918/138.wav", + "text": "那他後面就可���補的少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147918/139.wav", + "text": "是用一個平均數字去看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147918/140.wav", + "text": "不管採取哪一種策略或速度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147918/141.wav", + "text": "基於國家財政整體分配" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147918/142.wav", + "text": "考量到明年的各種預算配置問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147918/143.wav", + "text": "教育的學費補貼要處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147918/144.wav", + "text": "還是生育部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147918/145.wav", + "text": "還是國防等等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147918/146.wav", + "text": "我們尊重主總最後對預算的調控" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147918/147.wav", + "text": "最終都是政府要去扛起責任" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147918/148.wav", + "text": "跟多多少少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147918/149.wav", + "text": "因為越早補完當然就越安心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147918/150.wav", + "text": "如何分配財政負擔的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147918/151.wav", + "text": "有跟企業界討論過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147918/152.wav", + "text": "我當老闆的人一定會照顧" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147918/153.wav", + "text": "可能要先在哪邊集中一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147918/154.wav", + "text": "訂單會多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147918/155.wav", + "text": "生產的良率我都要照顧" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147918/156.wav", + "text": "到不是只有放錢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147918/157.wav", + "text": "那個錢起碼還可以用三年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147918/158.wav", + "text": "三年過後我會再補" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147918/159.wav", + "text": "啊我賺的錢我一定補" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147918/160.wav", + "text": "這就是當老闆" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147918/161.wav", + "text": "嘛老闆不太可能說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147918/162.wav", + "text": "我就把錢放在那邊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147918/163.wav", + "text": "先讓公司遇到危機" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147918/164.wav", + "text": "我想不會有人這樣當老闆" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147918/165.wav", + "text": "這個老闆給我一個概念" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147918/166.wav", + "text": "我可以理解" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147918/167.wav", + "text": "我們今天雖然是100億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147918/168.wav", + "text": "但隨時都記得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147918/169.wav", + "text": "看看整個國家的預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147918/170.wav", + "text": "這是正常老闆的作法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147918/171.wav", + "text": "對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147918/172.wav", + "text": "對應剛剛一位委員的說法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147918/173.wav", + "text": "大概才516萬由於" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147918/174.wav", + "text": "有能力的都不做了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147918/175.wav", + "text": "剩下沒有能力的接" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147918/176.wav", + "text": "手以致積欠了教職員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147918/177.wav", + "text": "完全不理會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147918/178.wav", + "text": "有關您幫我轉達好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147918/179.wav", + "text": "當然我在總質詢時也會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147918/180.wav", + "text": "直接跟教育部長講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147918/181.wav", + "text": "這點您幫我跟他提一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/0.wav", + "text": "首先要再次感謝部長和署長對本席選區學校的支持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/1.wav", + "text": "從校舍的整修建到足球場地到操場跑道的改善" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/2.wav", + "text": "對認真辦學的師長們和引頸期盼有安全的校舍" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/3.wav", + "text": "有新的操場以及標準足球場地的孩子們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/4.wav", + "text": "來講真的是很振奮的實質鼓勵" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/5.wav", + "text": "所以我要代表彰化縣的學校" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/6.wav", + "text": "這也要謝謝委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/7.wav", + "text": "因為委員很關心學校也幫我們瞭解及反映學校的需求" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/8.wav", + "text": "謝謝但是針對明年在泰國舉辦的亞洲室內運動會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/9.wav", + "text": "在此也希望體育署在接收到相關參賽的資料時" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/10.wav", + "text": "能夠審慎評估將五人制的足球隊納入代表隊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/11.wav", + "text": "真的非常期待大家都有很高的期望" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/12.wav", + "text": "我們也相信我們的選手一定都可以有亮眼的好成績" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/13.wav", + "text": "所以是不是請體育署可以大力來協助" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/14.wav", + "text": "剛才署長特別提到已經會納入考量" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/15.wav", + "text": "\n接下來我來跟部長討論一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/16.wav", + "text": "預計10月27日28日在香港舉辦的香港高等教育展" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/17.wav", + "text": "國立大學要用全銜來參展" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/18.wav", + "text": "也建議在這樣的爭議情況之下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/19.wav", + "text": "是不是國立大學就不要出席" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/20.wav", + "text": "所以參展的校數現在是由50所變成39所" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/21.wav", + "text": "未來會不會在香港繼續辦理高等教育展" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/22.wav", + "text": "跟委員報告確實各大學不管是國立大學或私立大學" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/23.wav", + "text": "因為我們有相關擴增招收國際學生的計畫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/24.wav", + "text": "也組成了兩個非常重要跟企業一起合作的聯盟" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/25.wav", + "text": "所以這個整體發展會這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/26.wav", + "text": "但是在這樣招收國際學生的過程當中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/27.wav", + "text": "我們也不同意接受我們的大學" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/28.wav", + "text": "尤其是國立的大學被矮化" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/29.wav", + "text": "這個其實都是特定的區域才會給我們這樣的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/30.wav", + "text": "我想我們持續招生一定會來做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/31.wav", + "text": "但是如果要到當地的高等教育展" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/32.wav", + "text": "卻被要求不能掛什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/33.wav", + "text": "我覺得這有辱我們的國格" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/34.wav", + "text": "這樣的狀況其實也不是個案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/35.wav", + "text": "10月17日在越南辦理的越南臺灣高等教育展" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/36.wav", + "text": "也硬是將我們的國名改成中國臺灣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/37.wav", + "text": "這種事情未來也許還會持續發生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/38.wav", + "text": "因為有政治力的介入" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/39.wav", + "text": "未來我���海外聯合招生委員會到其他國家辦展的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/40.wav", + "text": "如果持續遇到這樣的狀況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/41.wav", + "text": "海外聯招會的成立用意良善" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/42.wav", + "text": "其實我們應該吸收更多的海外學生來臺" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/43.wav", + "text": "本席覺得這是很正面的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/44.wav", + "text": "也是非常必要的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/45.wav", + "text": "但是如果是因為我國的國際狀況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/46.wav", + "text": "在學術交流以及孩子未來的學習" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/47.wav", + "text": "都被這樣的政治手段跟政治力介入" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/48.wav", + "text": "這真的是非常遺憾" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/49.wav", + "text": "的成員都要保持聯繫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/50.wav", + "text": "我們要有一個準則可以依循" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/51.wav", + "text": "當然招生很重要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/52.wav", + "text": "我們希望海外的學子能夠來臺學習" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/53.wav", + "text": "也希望我們有學生的交流" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/54.wav", + "text": "但是我們國家的尊嚴與國格" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/55.wav", + "text": "在其他國家有這樣的政治意識操作之下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/56.wav", + "text": "其實我們要有堅定的立場來捍衛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/57.wav", + "text": "所以這個部分也請教育部隨時關注" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/58.wav", + "text": "謝謝委員的提醒" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/59.wav", + "text": "不管世大運或亞運其實也是充分的溝通" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/60.wav", + "text": "像這些我都認為是可溝通" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/61.wav", + "text": "部長您從前當學生的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/62.wav", + "text": "有繳過學生會的會費嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/63.wav", + "text": "我讀的是公立的學校沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/64.wav", + "text": "好那您覺得學生應該要繳會費嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/65.wav", + "text": "學生會的會費" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/66.wav", + "text": "跟委員報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/67.wav", + "text": "依照大學法還有大學法施行細則" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/68.wav", + "text": "因為大學法第33條明定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/69.wav", + "text": "學生是學生會的當然會員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/70.wav", + "text": "並得向學生收取會費" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/71.wav", + "text": "最近發生的就是有學生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/72.wav", + "text": "沒有繳交學生會的會費" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/73.wav", + "text": "被學生會提告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/74.wav", + "text": "判決結果是他必須要繳會費" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/75.wav", + "text": "所以我們辦公室接到非常多學生來反映" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/76.wav", + "text": "其實孩子們的想法很簡單" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/77.wav", + "text": "實際上學生會也沒有提供他們什麼樣實質的協助" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/78.wav", + "text": "所以他們會覺得不繳應該是沒有關係" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/79.wav", + "text": "結果現在判決說一定要繳這樣子的新聞" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/80.wav", + "text": "讓孩子們十分的憂心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/81.wav", + "text": "學生會的會費是強制的嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/82.wav", + "text": "教育部這邊的想法是什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/83.wav", + "text": "當然本席這邊只是要轉達學生的憂心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/84.wav", + "text": "因為教育部的態度很重要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/85.wav", + "text": "到底這個得收會費" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/86.wav", + "text": "跟強制收會費" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/87.wav", + "text": "不繳會被告這樣子的事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/88.wav", + "text": "當然學生會是學生自治很重要的一環" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/89.wav", + "text": "學生會其實應該透過持續地爭取學權" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/90.wav", + "text": "辦理活動讓學生們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/91.wav", + "text": "認同學生會而來繳交會費" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/92.wav", + "text": "這是規定嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/93.wav", + "text": "法把它修成不是得向學生收取會費" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/94.wav", + "text": "而是應向學生來收取會費" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/95.wav", + "text": "部長您的看法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/96.wav", + "text": "跟委員報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/97.wav", + "text": "雖然法院有做出這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/98.wav", + "text": "還是屬於個案性的裁決" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/99.wav", + "text": "這部分依目前大學法或大學法施行細則" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/100.wav", + "text": "學生即使沒有繳會費" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/101.wav", + "text": "也不影響他的權益" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/102.wav", + "text": "這個是法原來的精神" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/103.wav", + "text": "所以在這種前提之下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/104.wav", + "text": "最重要的還有一個過程" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/105.wav", + "text": "有關大學學生會相關運作的辦法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/106.wav", + "text": "其實這裡面有一個非常重要的歷程" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/107.wav", + "text": "就是它如果要收費收費的方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/108.wav", + "text": "是要經過一個公開討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/109.wav", + "text": "所議決的程序來完成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/110.wav", + "text": "所以我想這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/111.wav", + "text": "不管從法制面或是運作" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/112.wav", + "text": "面其實有它一套的機制在運作" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/113.wav", + "text": "教育部不會因為這個判決" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/114.wav", + "text": "而馬上去修法改變" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/115.wav", + "text": "原來的這個立法精神" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/116.wav", + "text": "好謝謝部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/117.wav", + "text": "所以剛剛部長表達了這是一個個案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/118.wav", + "text": "教育部這邊也應該能夠理解" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/119.wav", + "text": "來讓他們自己去決定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/120.wav", + "text": "怎麼去面對這樣的事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/121.wav", + "text": "\n接下來想要跟部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/122.wav", + "text": "我們孩子們讀書讀得夠不夠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/123.wav", + "text": "有沒有足夠的經費來買書籍" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/124.wav", + "text": "根據國家圖書館的報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/125.wav", + "text": "110年學校圖書" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/126.wav", + "text": "購置經費平均下來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/127.wav", + "text": "元國中是165元" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/128.wav", + "text": "高級中等學校是128" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/129.wav", + "text": "元這樣子的預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/130.wav", + "text": "讀書的這個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/131.wav", + "text": "從這個統計數字來看當然" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/132.wav", + "text": "還可以再增加" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/133.wav", + "text": "在113年會多編列圖書的預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/134.wav", + "text": "但是即使這樣子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/135.wav", + "text": "本席想要表達的是我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/136.wav", + "text": "希望孩子可以多讀書愛讀書" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/137.wav", + "text": "也有足夠的書籍可以提供" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/138.wav", + "text": "他們在喜愛閱讀的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/139.wav", + "text": "然後到學校到採購" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/140.wav", + "text": "這樣的時程其實是很長的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/141.wav", + "text": "所以本席" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/142.wav", + "text": "在18歲到21歲" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/143.wav", + "text": "如果是中小學的學生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/144.wav", + "text": "我們是不是可以規劃" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/145.wav", + "text": "給國中小的孩子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/146.wav", + "text": "類似這樣子的方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/147.wav", + "text": "讓孩子們有更多的預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/148.wav", + "text": "可以決定自己想要看的書籍" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/149.wav", + "text": "我跟委員報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/150.wav", + "text": "確實113年的預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/151.wav", + "text": "是當時我特別請國教署" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/152.wav", + "text": "一定要編出一個常態固定的預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/153.wav", + "text": "所以今年先編了3億元" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/154.wav", + "text": "這個是過去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/155.wav", + "text": "因為國教署也有心要幫助" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/156.wav", + "text": "可是都是用年度剩餘的款項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/157.wav", + "text": "也沒有一個專用的科目" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/158.wav", + "text": "我想113年是一個新的改變" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/159.wav", + "text": "而關於在中小學的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/160.wav", + "text": "讓孩子有更充足的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/161.wav", + "text": "預算購書這方面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/162.wav", + "text": "我覺得這個在未來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/163.wav", + "text": "當然是一個可以發展的方向" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/164.wav", + "text": "但我也跟委員報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/165.wav", + "text": "閱讀包含很多習慣養成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/166.wav", + "text": "的階段各學校" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/167.wav", + "text": "我想在那個過程裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/168.wav", + "text": "結合我們現在編列的專款" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/169.wav", + "text": "這是我們第一個階段" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/170.wav", + "text": "要做努力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/171.wav", + "text": "的讓孩子養成更好的閱讀習慣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/172.wav", + "text": "畢竟在圖書館裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/173.wav", + "text": "藏書其實是更多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/174.wav", + "text": "也更豐富" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/175.wav", + "text": "而且也可以即時汰舊換新" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/176.wav", + "text": "不然有些學校一擺" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/177.wav", + "text": "可能幾年的書從來沒換過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/178.wav", + "text": "也沒有補充新書" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/179.wav", + "text": "孩子當然不感興趣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/180.wav", + "text": "因為我們從數字上來看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/181.wav", + "text": "當然也很感謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/182.wav", + "text": "部長跟教育部這邊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/183.wav", + "text": "在113年會多編列3億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/184.wav", + "text": "只是這個在執行上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/185.wav", + "text": "其他的方式來搭配" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/186.wav", + "text": "發現金就會有成效" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/187.wav", + "text": "閱讀的習慣是要從小" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/188.wav", + "text": "慢慢地培養跟養成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/189.wav", + "text": "比較有鼓勵作用的情況下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/190.wav", + "text": "讓孩子們可以有更多的資源" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/191.wav", + "text": "來閱讀書籍" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/192.wav", + "text": "我覺得這也是一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/193.wav", + "text": "可以參考的方向" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/194.wav", + "text": "委員我們先從113" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/195.wav", + "text": "有個固定預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/196.wav", + "text": "來做在有固定預算以後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/197.wav", + "text": "就不會變成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/198.wav", + "text": "年底到底還有沒有剩下的款項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/199.wav", + "text": "來執行所以剛才講的常常" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/200.wav", + "text": "購書有不確定感" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/201.wav", + "text": "\n委員我們在整個推動後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/202.wav", + "text": "會搭配未來的閱讀計畫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/203.wav", + "text": "注意用這樣的一個經驗" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/204.wav", + "text": "來思考未來在擴充" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/205.wav", + "text": "孩子的圖書資源上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/206.wav", + "text": "我們可以再怎麼做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/207.wav", + "text": "好謝謝部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/208.wav", + "text": "多編列的這3億元的預算下來之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/209.wav", + "text": "我們再來檢視這個成效" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/210.wav", + "text": "看可以怎麼樣來做檢討" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/211.wav", + "text": "是因為委員很關心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/212.wav", + "text": "也是一個很關心孩子的媽媽" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/213.wav", + "text": "閱讀習慣其實是要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/214.wav", + "text": "所以我們也推動閱讀教師" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/215.wav", + "text": "計畫讓孩子有一個正確的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/216.wav", + "text": "所以其實閱讀習慣的養成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/217.wav", + "text": "在小學是非常非常重要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/218.wav", + "text": "是我們現在在努力的也是這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/219.wav", + "text": "好謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/220.wav", + "text": "本席要跟部長跟署長來討論一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/221.wav", + "text": "眾多委員一起努力爭取的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/222.wav", + "text": "青春動滋券現在的使用狀況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/223.wav", + "text": "部長跟署長你們覺得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/224.wav", + "text": "目前我們青春動滋券使用的成效如何" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/225.wav", + "text": "跟委員報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/226.wav", + "text": "因為以後是常態化" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/227.wav", + "text": "了所以未來我們覺得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/228.wav", + "text": "應該再擴充更多合作的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/229.wav", + "text": "商家讓孩子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/230.wav", + "text": "可以更加地便利" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/231.wav", + "text": "但是我也跟委員報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/232.wav", + "text": "因為這個就比較希望孩子是真的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/233.wav", + "text": "去運動或觀賞運動" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/234.wav", + "text": "賽會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/235.wav", + "text": "而不是像我們初期曾經做過一次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/236.wav", + "text": "的他可以買東買西" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/237.wav", + "text": "什麼都可以買" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/238.wav", + "text": "那個其實是達不到運動的效果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/239.wav", + "text": "現在體育署給的資料是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/240.wav", + "text": "實際的使用人數是33萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/241.wav", + "text": "所以這個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/242.wav", + "text": "總共的領券率" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/243.wav", + "text": "是三成九" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/244.wav", + "text": "領券成功後的抵用率" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/245.wav", + "text": "是五成三" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/246.wav", + "text": "這樣的成效好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/247.wav", + "text": "但是今天我要跟大家討論的是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/248.wav", + "text": "我們青春動滋券" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/249.wav", + "text": "會成為詐騙集團的目標" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/250.wav", + "text": "不知道署長跟部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/251.wav", + "text": "有沒有相因應的措施" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/252.wav", + "text": "詐騙集團其實原本的目標" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/253.wav", + "text": "是文化禮金" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/254.wav", + "text": "但是文化禮金的使用需要雙證件" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/255.wav", + "text": "所以他們把目標轉移到體育署的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/256.wav", + "text": "青春動滋券" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/257.wav", + "text": "盜用的筆數是48筆" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/258.wav", + "text": "因為它比較容易在不用那麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/259.wav", + "text": "嚴謹的機制裡面就可以去使用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/260.wav", + "text": "網路上跟學生社團" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/261.wav", + "text": "也有很多青春動滋券的收購文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/262.wav", + "text": "當然文化禮金" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/263.wav", + "text": "但是動滋券是最多的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/264.wav", + "text": "收購金額從200到350都有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/265.wav", + "text": "不知道署長跟部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/266.wav", + "text": "有什麼相因應的措施" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/267.wav", + "text": "我跟委員報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/268.wav", + "text": "青春動滋券確實還可以再多加宣傳" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/269.wav", + "text": "因為今年是第一年常態化" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/270.wav", + "text": "是從6月" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/271.wav", + "text": "有整整一年的時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/272.wav", + "text": "也會再多加宣導" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/273.wav", + "text": "讓更多年輕的同學可以來應用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/274.wav", + "text": "對於防弊的這部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/275.wav", + "text": "確實文化部用雙證件的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/276.wav", + "text": "我們也有做學習" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/277.wav", + "text": "所以其實可以參考" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/278.wav", + "text": "已經確定了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/279.wav", + "text": "所以從10月16號開始我們就啟用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/280.wav", + "text": "也要用健保卡號" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/281.wav", + "text": "雙證件的概念" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/282.wav", + "text": "這個部分我覺得應該要做到防弊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/283.wav", + "text": "啦不然會變成另外一個弊端" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/284.wav", + "text": "好謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/285.wav", + "text": "部長跟署長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/286.wav", + "text": "在滾動的檢討之下有將這樣的機制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/287.wav", + "text": "實際的領券人就是使用使用者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/288.wav", + "text": "我們其實也真的是要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/289.wav", + "text": "成為習慣這是我們的原意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/290.wav", + "text": "部長再請留步我最後再問一個問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/291.wav", + "text": "臺北市警察" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/292.wav", + "text": "局大安分局的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/293.wav", + "text": "統計去年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/294.wav", + "text": "截至今年3月" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/295.wav", + "text": "受理的詐騙的案件中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/296.wav", + "text": "有21%的被害人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/297.wav", + "text": "是學生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/298.wav", + "text": "尤其是大學生居多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/299.wav", + "text": "學生受騙的案件" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/300.wav", + "text": "類型大概是三種" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/301.wav", + "text": "就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/302.wav", + "text": "解除分期付款" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/303.wav", + "text": "假網拍以及色情應召" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/304.wav", + "text": "詐財這三類是在比較前面的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/305.wav", + "text": "占整體詐騙" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/306.wav", + "text": "詐欺案件57.1%" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/307.wav", + "text": "刑事警察局" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/308.wav", + "text": "其實大同小異也差不多是這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/309.wav", + "text": "學生很容易受騙的類型" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/310.wav", + "text": "還有一種是投資詐騙" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/311.wav", + "text": "還有假網拍及購物詐騙" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/312.wav", + "text": "但是其實這些詐騙" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/313.wav", + "text": "手法存在已久" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/314.wav", + "text": "一再地上當一再地受騙" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/315.wav", + "text": "有瞭解到這個部分嗎是我們的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/316.wav", + "text": "防詐宣導不夠落實嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/317.wav", + "text": "跟委員報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/318.wav", + "text": "這個確實不只是教育部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/319.wav", + "text": "因為包含行政院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/320.wav", + "text": "會用跨部會的意思是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/321.wav", + "text": "很多的資訊跟犯罪樣態" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/322.wav", + "text": "其實一直不斷地" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/323.wav", + "text": "我們在整個資訊整合" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/324.wav", + "text": "的方面還要持續地做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/325.wav", + "text": "我們希望能夠更全面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/326.wav", + "text": "但是在這裡還是要呼籲" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/327.wav", + "text": "天下絕對沒有白吃的午餐" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/328.wav", + "text": "可能要先讓自己瞭解天下沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/329.wav", + "text": "其實要有警覺性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/330.wav", + "text": "就是剛才部長說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/331.wav", + "text": "有好康的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/332.wav", + "text": "要去思考背面到底是什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/333.wav", + "text": "根據我們統計的數據" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/334.wav", + "text": "來看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/335.wav", + "text": "學生族群除了是被詐騙的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/336.wav", + "text": "大宗以外其實也是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/337.wav", + "text": "協助詐騙的族群" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/338.wav", + "text": "尤其是大學生的階段" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/339.wav", + "text": "從2018年開始不時就有新聞" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/340.wav", + "text": "報導說學生來擔任車手" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/341.wav", + "text": "這樣的情事" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/342.wav", + "text": "尤其在寒暑假打工比較多的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/343.wav", + "text": "案例就又更多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/344.wav", + "text": "甚至有傳出詐騙集團" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/345.wav", + "text": "深入校園來進行車手的招攬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/346.wav", + "text": "所以一個班級裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/347.wav", + "text": "可能有一到兩位學生在放假期間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/348.wav", + "text": "學生加入的原因" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/349.wav", + "text": "就是輕信詐騙集團" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/350.wav", + "text": "犯案是不會留案底的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/351.wav", + "text": "喔加上有高報酬的誘惑" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/352.wav", + "text": "讓學生們誤入歧途" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/353.wav", + "text": "治安會議的時候我們從前會提醒" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/354.wav", + "text": "長者注意詐騙可是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/355.wav", + "text": "其實現在的長者反而警覺性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/356.wav", + "text": "比較高我會跟長者說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/357.wav", + "text": "你們家的孩子你們家的孫子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/358.wav", + "text": "畢業之後找工作或是寒暑假在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/359.wav", + "text": "打工的時候你一定要幫他注意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/360.wav", + "text": "如果工作很輕鬆薪水很高" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/361.wav", + "text": "你一定要提醒他後面一定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/362.wav", + "text": "提醒孩子有時候就真的是孩子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/363.wav", + "text": "的警覺性不夠\n根據" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/364.wav", + "text": "警政署的統計111年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/365.wav", + "text": "青少年犯罪類型" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/366.wav", + "text": "涉及詐欺案件有1萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/367.wav", + "text": "1,437人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/368.wav", + "text": "是最大宗占整體" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/369.wav", + "text": "比例高達26.4%" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/370.wav", + "text": "整體青少年犯罪比率" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/371.wav", + "text": "增加" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/372.wav", + "text": "111年犯詐欺案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/373.wav", + "text": "的青少年比110" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/374.wav", + "text": "年還增加了1,421" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/375.wav", + "text": "人占整體的犯罪比率增加了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/376.wav", + "text": "14.19%" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/377.wav", + "text": "112年截止到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/378.wav", + "text": "18歲到23歲的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/379.wav", + "text": "較上年度也增加了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/380.wav", + "text": "11.51%" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/381.wav", + "text": "在學生階段的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/382.wav", + "text": "詐騙被害人較上年度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/383.wav", + "text": "增加超過27%" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/384.wav", + "text": "所以會有一種" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/385.wav", + "text": "狀況好像是學生騙學生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/386.wav", + "text": "就是這些學生被騙了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/387.wav", + "text": "來騙其他學生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/388.wav", + "text": "這樣的狀況我不知道部長您的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/389.wav", + "text": "看法跟教育部現在掌握的情況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/390.wav", + "text": "是怎樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/391.wav", + "text": "我們從前關心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/392.wav", + "text": "一些年紀比較大或是獨居的可能" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/393.wav", + "text": "會被騙但是現在其實年紀大的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/394.wav", + "text": "他們警覺性都是夠的反而是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/395.wav", + "text": "這些學生\n我也知道教育部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/396.wav", + "text": "跟學校其實一直都有在做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/397.wav", + "text": "反詐的宣導但是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/398.wav", + "text": "我們看一下這個統計的數字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/399.wav", + "text": "你看上面的點閱率" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/400.wav", + "text": "我們很多學校的網站上面都會放" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/401.wav", + "text": "跟一些相關的影片但是其實" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/402.wav", + "text": "沒有人會去看可能是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/403.wav", + "text": "因為不夠生活化可能是因為沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/404.wav", + "text": "很生動或者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/405.wav", + "text": "不是情境式的讓學生去融入" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/406.wav", + "text": "這個我們如果只是很形式化的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/407.wav", + "text": "只是很僵式的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/408.wav", + "text": "騙的宣導其實對學生來講沒有走到他" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/409.wav", + "text": "心裡面他沒有去警覺" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/410.wav", + "text": "這樣的情境這樣的情形其實就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/411.wav", + "text": "已經接觸到詐騙的邊緣了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/412.wav", + "text": "這個部分部長您有什麼看法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/413.wav", + "text": "有關在傳達宣導" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/414.wav", + "text": "的這方面我想教育部跟" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/415.wav", + "text": "跨部會還有跟學校我們會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/416.wav", + "text": "持續來做至於怎麼樣的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/417.wav", + "text": "路徑內容可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/418.wav", + "text": "接受這個我想我們也要不斷地來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/419.wav", + "text": "一定要讓他瞭解" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/420.wav", + "text": "才有可能提高他的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/421.wav", + "text": "警覺這部分我們來持續" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/422.wav", + "text": "加強因為不管是被騙跟騙人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/423.wav", + "text": "都是增加的所以這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/424.wav", + "text": "部分我們一定要讓防騙防" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/425.wav", + "text": "詐的宣導可以落實" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/426.wav", + "text": "這樣的教育必須要紮在他們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/427.wav", + "text": "的心裡紮在他們的腦海裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/428.wav", + "text": "一直都有跨部會在做我想這方面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/429.wav", + "text": "跟學校之間緊密" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/430.wav", + "text": "的連結還更必要好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147917/431.wav", + "text": "謝謝部長這個部分希望能夠再加強" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147916/0.wav", + "text": "好主計長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147916/1.wav", + "text": "也是今天的重點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147916/2.wav", + "text": "主要國家的所得差距" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147916/3.wav", + "text": "都有逐步上升的現象" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147916/4.wav", + "text": "主計總處所公布��" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147916/5.wav", + "text": "由6.07倍逐年增加到6.15倍" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147916/6.wav", + "text": "其他國家包括日本等等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147916/7.wav", + "text": "也都有微幅的增加" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147916/8.wav", + "text": "請問一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147916/9.wav", + "text": "因為2022年的所得差距" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147916/10.wav", + "text": "是11月會公布" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147916/11.wav", + "text": "布目前預計的狀況會是怎麼樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147916/12.wav", + "text": "我國的確像委員所講的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147916/13.wav", + "text": "我們未來要看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147916/14.wav", + "text": "因為如果是財政措施以前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147916/15.wav", + "text": "的確各國都會有一個差距" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147916/16.wav", + "text": "可是如果財政措施以後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147916/17.wav", + "text": "我們的所得差距會改善很多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147916/18.wav", + "text": "像我們的一些社會福利措施" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147916/19.wav", + "text": "使我們的倍數減少了1.34倍" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147916/20.wav", + "text": "布2022所得差距" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147916/21.wav", + "text": "會比今年增加的倍數再增加嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147916/22.wav", + "text": "會再擴大嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147916/23.wav", + "text": "我不敢講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147916/24.wav", + "text": "因為還沒有實際的數字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147916/25.wav", + "text": "最主要是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147916/26.wav", + "text": "我們有三倍券五倍券" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147916/27.wav", + "text": "而且加發6,000塊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147916/28.wav", + "text": "因為高所得加" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147916/29.wav", + "text": "還有普發現金" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147916/30.wav", + "text": "是原因之一" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147916/31.wav", + "text": "有助於所得差距縮小" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147916/32.wav", + "text": "對我並不是說要贊同這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147916/33.wav", + "text": "就像有錢人增加6,000塊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147916/34.wav", + "text": "低所得也增加6,000塊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147916/35.wav", + "text": "這個應該是杯水車薪吧" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147916/36.wav", + "text": "這麼大的範圍" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147916/37.wav", + "text": "或者是這麼有成效" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147916/38.wav", + "text": "那你就多發幾次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147916/39.wav", + "text": "我們所得差距就可以拉近" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147916/40.wav", + "text": "花在真正的弱勢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147916/41.wav", + "text": "不一定要花在每一個人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147916/42.wav", + "text": "因為分子分母" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147916/43.wav", + "text": "對所以重點應該是弱勢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147916/44.wav", + "text": "是不是要排富" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147916/45.wav", + "text": "才會有助於弱勢的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147916/46.wav", + "text": "畢竟有資源有限" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147916/47.wav", + "text": "社會福利措施" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147916/48.wav", + "text": "一定要有排富的措施" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147916/49.wav", + "text": "其他就是包括近十年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147916/50.wav", + "text": "受僱員工的勞動報酬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147916/51.wav", + "text": "我們也發現經常性薪資的占比" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147916/52.wav", + "text": "拿回來家裡做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147916/53.wav", + "text": "那一種的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147916/54.wav", + "text": "這樣是不是也會衝擊到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147916/55.wav", + "text": "及其他相關福利反而減少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147916/56.wav", + "text": "用其他方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147916/57.wav", + "text": "讓他的薪資維持一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147916/58.wav", + "text": "對於他的退休金等等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147916/59.wav", + "text": "也都會造成影響" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147916/60.wav", + "text": "這個就是我們時常講的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147916/61.wav", + "text": "因為有些人寧可在家裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147916/62.wav", + "text": "工作能夠自由一點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147916/63.wav", + "text": "這個可能不只是個人的因素" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147916/64.wav", + "text": "企業的因素" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147916/65.wav", + "text": "也可能是主要的原因" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147916/66.wav", + "text": "不是因為個人想要自由一點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147916/67.wav", + "text": "而是企業在相關成本的考量上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147916/68.wav", + "text": "降低了本薪的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147916/69.wav", + "text": "而用其他的部分去補" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147916/70.wav", + "text": "這個的確是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147916/71.wav", + "text": "對於勞工的權益就受到影響" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147916/72.wav", + "text": "現在公司的營收表現亮眼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147916/73.wav", + "text": "包括之前我們的稅收超過預期" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147916/74.wav", + "text": "很多來自於營利事業所得稅等等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147916/75.wav", + "text": "但是員工的報酬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147916/76.wav", + "text": "占GDP的分配比卻是逐年下降" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147916/77.wav", + "text": "在這種情況之下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147916/78.wav", + "text": "我們如何去要求這些企業" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147916/79.wav", + "text": "當他賺錢的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147916/80.wav", + "text": "能夠分享給這些企業的員工" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147916/81.wav", + "text": "我們是不是也請財政部經濟部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147916/82.wav", + "text": "因為過去政府確實有很多的政策" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147916/83.wav", + "text": "想要去鼓勵縮小貧富差距" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147916/84.wav", + "text": "希望企業能夠把獲利分享給員工" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147916/85.wav", + "text": "但是改善的成效" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147916/86.wav", + "text": "如果從數據來看非常有限" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147916/87.wav", + "text": "反而受僱員工的報酬占GDP的比率" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147916/88.wav", + "text": "卻是逐年下降" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147916/89.wav", + "text": "代表營運成果並沒有實際跟員工分享" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147916/90.wav", + "text": "然而105年經濟部就有一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147916/91.wav", + "text": "行政院改善所得分配" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147916/92.wav", + "text": "具體方案的執行檢討" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147916/93.wav", + "text": "到現在112年已經7年過去了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147916/94.wav", + "text": "還在檢討如何改善所得分配的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147916/95.wav", + "text": "越來越有限而且非常不彰" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147916/96.wav", + "text": "甚至之前所推出的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147916/97.wav", + "text": "中小企業加薪減稅方案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147916/98.wav", + "text": "真正實施的只有一次而已" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147916/99.wav", + "text": "而且實施的家數也非常少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147916/100.wav", + "text": "減稅的額度也非常少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147916/101.wav", + "text": "臺灣的中小企業超過159萬家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147916/102.wav", + "text": "竟然只有1,000家適用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147916/103.wav", + "text": "以中小企業發展條例所看到的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147916/104.wav", + "text": "租稅優惠額度130%" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147916/105.wav", + "text": "但是必須要失業率連續六個月" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147916/106.wav", + "text": "高於3.78%才能適用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147916/107.wav", + "text": "所以成效非常有限" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147916/108.wav", + "text": "這也是大家一直在檢討的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147916/109.wav", + "text": "所謂的加薪減稅" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147916/110.wav", + "text": "如何能夠擴大讓經濟能夠正向的循環" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147916/111.wav", + "text": "讓企業願意聘僱更多的勞工" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147916/112.wav", + "text": "願意幫勞工加薪來減稅" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147916/113.wav", + "text": "才能夠帶動" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147916/114.wav", + "text": "不管是縮小貧富差距" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147916/115.wav", + "text": "或是整個經濟上能夠有內需" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147916/116.wav", + "text": "然後帶動消費" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147916/117.wav", + "text": "而不是只發三倍券五倍券或是6,000塊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147916/118.wav", + "text": "這個其實是短期的治標不治本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147916/119.wav", + "text": "長期的企業幫員工加薪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147916/120.wav", + "text": "或是帶動整體的經濟" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147916/121.wav", + "text": "如何讓企業幫員工加薪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147916/122.wav", + "text": "加薪減稅就是當初我們認為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147916/123.wav", + "text": "有效的一個方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147916/124.wav", + "text": "但實際上根本看得到吃不到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147916/125.wav", + "text": "沒有企業在用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147916/126.wav", + "text": "\n我想要問一下經濟部跟財政部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147916/127.wav", + "text": "服務業占臺灣就業人口六成以上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147916/128.wav", + "text": "非常的多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147916/129.wav", + "text": "但服務業的薪資反而是最低的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147916/130.wav", + "text": "導致他們還要去做其他的兼差" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147916/131.wav", + "text": "來彌補薪資的不足" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147916/132.wav", + "text": "但是服務業的成本人力就是占最高的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147916/133.wav", + "text": "如果幫員工加薪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147916/134.wav", + "text": "當然他的獲利也會減少非常多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147916/135.wav", + "text": "如果政府能夠適時的加薪減稅" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147916/136.wav", + "text": "鼓勵這些企業願意幫員工加薪的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147916/137.wav", + "text": "相較的對於我們政府來講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147916/138.wav", + "text": "能夠釋放一些讓員工能夠得到相對的加薪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147916/139.wav", + "text": "這其實是幫助多數的臺灣勞工" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147916/140.wav", + "text": "因為我們的服務業就業人口就占六成以上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147916/141.wav", + "text": "之下政府到底站在什麼角度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147916/142.wav", + "text": "要求企業分享獲利給員工" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147916/143.wav", + "text": "如何幫助這些基層的員工" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147916/144.wav", + "text": "服務業的員工讓他們能夠加薪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147916/145.wav", + "text": "政府有什麼具體作為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147916/146.wav", + "text": "報告委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147916/147.wav", + "text": "有關服務業的員工要加薪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147916/148.wav", + "text": "從經濟部的業務角度來看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147916/149.wav", + "text": "最重要的是要提升服務業的獲利" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147916/150.wav", + "text": "它的獲利提升才有能力為員工加薪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147916/151.wav", + "text": "所以我們怎麼樣強健服務業的體質" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147916/152.wav", + "text": "包括輔導服務業使用數位化" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147916/153.wav", + "text": "還有其他比較科技的工具" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147916/154.wav", + "text": "去擴大它的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147916/155.wav", + "text": "不是你一定要有誘因" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147916/156.wav", + "text": "嘛它有獲利" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147916/157.wav", + "text": "但它會不會把這個獲利分享給員工" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147916/158.wav", + "text": "會不會幫員工加薪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147916/159.wav", + "text": "又是另一回事" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147916/160.wav", + "text": "這才是我們剛剛所講的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147916/161.wav", + "text": "在這個情況之下你的誘因在哪裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147916/162.wav", + "text": "你雖然有這個加薪減稅的中小企業" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147916/163.wav", + "text": "條例但是根本沒有辦法適用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147916/164.wav", + "text": "看得到吃不到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147916/165.wav", + "text": "所以你應該要提出其他的作法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147916/166.wav", + "text": "中小企業發展條例這個條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147916/167.wav", + "text": "我們內部目前在檢討" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147916/168.wav", + "text": "評估也在跟財政部討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147916/169.wav", + "text": "我們的方向是傾向繼續延長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147916/170.wav", + "text": "另外會去檢討它的門檻適用範圍" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147916/171.wav", + "text": "還有申請程序等等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147916/172.wav", + "text": "希望對於門檻予以檢討" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147916/173.wav", + "text": "擴大適用範圍來簡化程序" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147916/174.wav", + "text": "主計長如果我們能夠幫員工" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147916/175.wav", + "text": "尤其是服務業加薪減稅" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147916/176.wav", + "text": "相對於你剛剛所說的什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147916/177.wav", + "text": "6,000元三倍券五倍券效益" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147916/178.wav", + "text": "是不是更大" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147916/179.wav", + "text": "對那個是比較長期的措施" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147916/180.wav", + "text": "三倍五倍券或者6,000塊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147916/181.wav", + "text": "所以長期的我們沒做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147916/182.wav", + "text": "啊你做一個短期的但是長期的不做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147916/183.wav", + "text": "最快多久能不能在年底之前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147916/184.wav", + "text": "讓大家看到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147916/185.wav", + "text": "我們政府對於這些中小企業" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147916/186.wav", + "text": "對服務業加薪減稅的決心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147916/187.wav", + "text": "跟願意去提升臺灣整體經濟的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147916/188.wav", + "text": "角度上能夠大幅的釋放利多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147916/189.wav", + "text": "包括延長能夠延長多久" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147916/190.wav", + "text": "因為落日到明年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147916/191.wav", + "text": "延長之後有多少企業能夠適用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147916/192.wav", + "text": "因為依照你現在這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147916/193.wav", + "text": "規定臺灣的中小企業" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147916/194.wav", + "text": "超過159萬家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147916/195.wav", + "text": "居然只有1,000家適用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147916/196.wav", + "text": "這個合理嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147916/197.wav", + "text": "經濟部跟財政部已經在努力之中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147916/198.wav", + "text": "努力中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147916/199.wav", + "text": "所以最快什麼時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147916/200.wav", + "text": "我們可以看到這個方案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147916/201.wav", + "text": "我們希望能夠擴大適用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147916/202.wav", + "text": "這是第一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147916/203.wav", + "text": "能夠嘉惠到基層服務業" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147916/204.wav", + "text": "跟基層員工" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147916/205.wav", + "text": "然後你們能夠提出" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147916/206.wav", + "text": "的包括現在稅收超過預期的狀況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147916/207.wav", + "text": "下你能夠帶動企業加薪減稅" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147916/208.wav", + "text": "一方面能夠帶動經濟" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147916/209.wav", + "text": "一方面也符合我們現在的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147916/210.wav", + "text": "稅收狀況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147916/211.wav", + "text": "這部分就是需要財政部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147916/212.wav", + "text": "大家一起努力去推動" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147916/213.wav", + "text": "啊這個年底前能夠有方案出來嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147916/214.wav", + "text": "跟委員報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147916/215.wav", + "text": "中小企業這個條例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147916/216.wav", + "text": "剛剛經濟部次長已經講過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147916/217.wav", + "text": "另外這個條例是在明年5月19號落日" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147916/218.wav", + "text": "所以在落日之前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147916/219.wav", + "text": "我們會全盤做一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147916/220.wav", + "text": "落日之前太晚了啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147916/221.wav", + "text": "因為落日之前你就發現" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147916/222.wav", + "text": "它有很多窒礙難行的問題嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147916/223.wav", + "text": "105年到現在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147916/224.wav", + "text": "也這麼長一段時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147916/225.wav", + "text": "根本沒有在用嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147916/226.wav", + "text": "101年就已經實施到現在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147916/227.wav", + "text": "10年來你說只有1,000家適用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147916/228.wav", + "text": "而且它減稅的額度是多少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147916/229.wav", + "text": "減稅了多少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147916/230.wav", + "text": "這個部分其實不高" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147916/231.wav", + "text": "我們數字會再提供" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147916/232.wav", + "text": "不高是多少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147916/233.wav", + "text": "因為它的家數也不多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147916/234.wav", + "text": "另外要跟委員報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147916/235.wav", + "text": "所以根本等於沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147916/236.wav", + "text": "嘛有等於沒有的東西用了10年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147916/237.wav", + "text": "所以代表過去這10年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147916/238.wav", + "text": "你根本沒有努力在幫員工加薪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147916/239.wav", + "text": "沒有努力協助這些中小企業" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147916/240.wav", + "text": "服務業" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147916/241.wav", + "text": "讓他們可以幫員工加薪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147916/242.wav", + "text": "所以為什麼現在大家會認為臺灣薪資過低" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147916/243.wav", + "text": "因為沒有具體的政策誘因" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147916/244.wav", + "text": "你明知道這個東西" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147916/245.wav", + "text": "你還擺了10年然後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147916/246.wav", + "text": "後到現在還跟我說要再研議一年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147916/247.wav", + "text": "過去的10年就應該" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147916/248.wav", + "text": "滾動式的調整跟修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147916/249.wav", + "text": "所以我們希望年底之前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147916/250.wav", + "text": "能夠有新的方案出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147916/251.wav", + "text": "協助我們這些中小企業還有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147916/252.wav", + "text": "服務業加薪減稅" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147916/253.wav", + "text": "讓大家可以看到這個可不可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147916/254.wav", + "text": "規劃一個多數都能夠適用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147916/255.wav", + "text": "而不是像現在這樣一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147916/256.wav", + "text": "看得到吃不到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147916/257.wav", + "text": "有等於沒有的方案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147916/258.wav", + "text": "\n因為審計長也在希望您好好的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147916/259.wav", + "text": "監督瞭解好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147916/260.wav", + "text": "未來的這個條例一定要能夠擴大適用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147916/261.wav", + "text": "能夠帶動我們的經濟" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147916/262.wav", + "text": "跟帶動我們的基層員工能夠加薪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147915/0.wav", + "text": "我們請部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147915/1.wav", + "text": "最近怎樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147915/2.wav", + "text": "有沒有回新社" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147915/3.wav", + "text": "上次回去的時候是端午節" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147915/4.wav", + "text": "那���很久沒有回去了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147915/5.wav", + "text": "要回去看一看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147915/6.wav", + "text": "不要忘了你的老家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147915/7.wav", + "text": "我就來提醒你一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147915/8.wav", + "text": "第一個新社白冷圳的節餘水計畫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147915/9.wav", + "text": "這個我們講了很多年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147915/10.wav", + "text": "了好不容易去年底也開始要動" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147915/11.wav", + "text": "總共分五期" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147915/12.wav", + "text": "經費是5.03億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147915/13.wav", + "text": "這部分當然本席樂見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147915/14.wav", + "text": "地方也非常殷切期盼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147915/15.wav", + "text": "可是目前的工程進度似乎遇到了一些瓶頸" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147915/16.wav", + "text": "現在進度到底怎麼樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147915/17.wav", + "text": "誠如委員所說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147915/18.wav", + "text": "這個工程一共有五期" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147915/19.wav", + "text": "第一期跟第二期工程" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147915/20.wav", + "text": "在去年都核定了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147915/21.wav", + "text": "其中第一期工程今年已經發包了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147915/22.wav", + "text": "廠商也都在備料當中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147915/23.wav", + "text": "準備等新社花海活動結束之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147915/24.wav", + "text": "因為那個工程是在道路底下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147915/25.wav", + "text": "所以第一第二期的發包工作" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147915/26.wav", + "text": "完成了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147915/27.wav", + "text": "第一期已經發包完成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147915/28.wav", + "text": "那第二期經費已經有了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147915/29.wav", + "text": "現在臺中市政府正在進行發包的作業" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147915/30.wav", + "text": "那第三期呢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147915/31.wav", + "text": "第三期我們已經在今年核定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147915/32.wav", + "text": "設計規劃的作業" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147915/33.wav", + "text": "也已經發包出去了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147915/34.wav", + "text": "現在已經完成基本設計了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147915/35.wav", + "text": "第三期發包出去了嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147915/36.wav", + "text": "第三期的設計" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147915/37.wav", + "text": "設計發包" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147915/38.wav", + "text": "設計的發包已經出去了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147915/39.wav", + "text": "流標" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147915/40.wav", + "text": "對那就是第二期的工程" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147915/41.wav", + "text": "因為流標" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147915/42.wav", + "text": "為什麼流標" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147915/43.wav", + "text": "那什麼時候可以順利招標" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147915/44.wav", + "text": "現在臺中市政府" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147915/45.wav", + "text": "已經重新檢討預算給我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147915/46.wav", + "text": "你那個公文就可以批快一點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147915/47.wav", + "text": "我想我們會儘快籌措" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147915/48.wav", + "text": "自己要顧" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147915/49.wav", + "text": "啊我們自己的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147915/50.wav", + "text": "因為物價上漲" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147915/51.wav", + "text": "所以要趕快" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147915/52.wav", + "text": "把那個經費的差距" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147915/53.wav", + "text": "這不要拖啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147915/54.wav", + "text": "你拖越久物價會持續漲" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147915/55.wav", + "text": "你早點做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147915/56.wav", + "text": "還可以省下一點錢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147915/57.wav", + "text": "可以嗎部長可以吧" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147915/58.wav", + "text": "所以這部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147915/59.wav", + "text": "另外一個也是進度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147915/60.wav", + "text": "有關甜柿專區" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147915/61.wav", + "text": "你們10月20號" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147915/62.wav", + "text": "有發一個公文給臺中市政府" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147915/63.wav", + "text": "說有一個修正計畫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147915/64.wav", + "text": "那個修正計畫應該是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147915/65.wav", + "text": "包括其他單位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147915/66.wav", + "text": "有一些建議或者意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147915/67.wav", + "text": "要臺中市政府說明的對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147915/68.wav", + "text": "對重新根據一些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147915/69.wav", + "text": "其他單位的意見去做一些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147915/70.wav", + "text": "這些多不多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147915/71.wav", + "text": "啊要回答的多不多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147915/72.wav", + "text": "應該還好吧" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147915/73.wav", + "text": "主要是圖面的確認" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147915/74.wav", + "text": "修正應該不多啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147915/75.wav", + "text": "應該短期內可以回復給你們吧有沒有期限" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147915/76.wav", + "text": "他只要他來我們就會馬上處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147915/77.wav", + "text": "來就馬上處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147915/78.wav", + "text": "你們有沒有要求他回答的期限" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147915/79.wav", + "text": "11月中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147915/80.wav", + "text": "你們中央應該也要給地方一個要求" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147915/81.wav", + "text": "那11月中回復完之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147915/82.wav", + "text": "就走內部程序" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147915/83.wav", + "text": "對如果說沒問題的話我們就會走內部的程序" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147915/84.wav", + "text": "大概要多久" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147915/85.wav", + "text": "我們在內部的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147915/86.wav", + "text": "如果過來以後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147915/87.wav", + "text": "會會農糧署那農糧署之前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147915/88.wav", + "text": "因為產業主管機關已經都確認了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147915/89.wav", + "text": "所以這個部分很快完了以後就" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147915/90.wav", + "text": "報部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147915/91.wav", + "text": "報我們這邊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147915/92.wav", + "text": "然後我們確定以後就會去處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147915/93.wav", + "text": "還要到院是不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147915/94.wav", + "text": "不用吧應該你們直接就處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147915/95.wav", + "text": "了所以照理講應該很快啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147915/96.wav", + "text": "是很快我希望年底以前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147915/97.wav", + "text": "給我們一個好消息啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147915/98.wav", + "text": "地方政府" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147915/99.wav", + "text": "押個時間給地方政府嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147915/100.wav", + "text": "當然我們也希望地方政府" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147915/101.wav", + "text": "應該要針對這些疑問" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147915/102.wav", + "text": "讓你們趕快進行後續的程序作業" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147915/103.wav", + "text": "因為這10年了不要再拖了啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147915/104.wav", + "text": "我希望在你任內完成啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147915/105.wav", + "text": "因為這是一個示範性的計畫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147915/106.wav", + "text": "因為以前這林班地" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147915/107.wav", + "text": "在那邊耕作的農民" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147915/108.wav", + "text": "還有就是到底什麼樣子的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147915/109.wav", + "text": "林班地可以因為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147915/110.wav", + "text": "專區然後解編" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147915/111.wav", + "text": "我覺得這是一個示範性的計畫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147915/112.wav", + "text": "如果你們做得好的話可以幫一些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147915/113.wav", + "text": "在灰色地帶的這一部分做解套" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147915/114.wav", + "text": "讓真的想耕作" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147915/115.wav", + "text": "的也能夠耕作" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147915/116.wav", + "text": "然後他們也能夠有他的這個身分啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147915/117.wav", + "text": "所以這個示範計畫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147915/118.wav", + "text": "我認為是蠻重要的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147915/119.wav", + "text": "雖然前面花了很多時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147915/120.wav", + "text": "但是如果把它做出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147915/121.wav", + "text": "有它指標性的意義" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147915/122.wav", + "text": "就好像上次我質詢你關於" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147915/123.wav", + "text": "菇寮那個事情一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147915/124.wav", + "text": "中央跟地方之間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147915/125.wav", + "text": "常常會給人家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147915/126.wav", + "text": "一種互踢皮球的感覺" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147915/127.wav", + "text": "但如果透過這幾個案子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147915/128.wav", + "text": "你能夠做出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147915/129.wav", + "text": "那就代表" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147915/130.wav", + "text": "部長你要展現你領導力的地方" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147915/131.wav", + "text": "針對問題可以解決問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147915/132.wav", + "text": "解決問題還是最重要的啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147915/133.wav", + "text": "好不好包括剛剛提到的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147915/134.wav", + "text": "那一個還有這個甜柿專區" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147915/135.wav", + "text": "這都是我們希望" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147915/136.wav", + "text": "趕快不要再拖了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147915/137.wav", + "text": "再來就是說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147915/138.wav", + "text": "上次我有問你那個新社花海" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147915/139.wav", + "text": "應該準備得差不多了才對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147915/140.wav", + "text": "因為11號就要開幕了嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147915/141.wav", + "text": "對我也跟委員報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147915/142.wav", + "text": "這次的花海我們也跟臺中市政府協調" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147915/143.wav", + "text": "是用一個聯合開幕的方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147915/144.wav", + "text": "包括花海跟花毯" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147915/145.wav", + "text": "因為在同一個地區" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147915/146.wav", + "text": "不要各自開幕啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147915/147.wav", + "text": "當然" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147915/148.wav", + "text": "臺中市政府一個善意的回應" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147915/149.wav", + "text": "我們就會朝這個方向去做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147915/150.wav", + "text": "開幕前我會邀請" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147915/151.wav", + "text": "農業部這邊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147915/152.wav", + "text": "不管是你或者是次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147915/153.wav", + "text": "次長來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147915/154.wav", + "text": "先前會勘一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147915/155.wav", + "text": "我們希望把一些問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147915/156.wav", + "text": "做最後的檢視" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147915/157.wav", + "text": "因為我認為今年會很多人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147915/158.wav", + "text": "我認為今年會很多人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147915/159.wav", + "text": "我隨時掌握新社花海" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147915/160.wav", + "text": "相關的一個進度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147915/161.wav", + "text": "包括我們農業部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147915/162.wav", + "text": "該做的整個園區的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147915/163.wav", + "text": "也包括臺中市政府這些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147915/164.wav", + "text": "因為去年你們沒有辦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147915/165.wav", + "text": "去年是你們一塊地" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147915/166.wav", + "text": "給臺中市政府辦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147915/167.wav", + "text": "因為沒有辦的關係" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147915/168.wav", + "text": "所以今年重新回來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147915/169.wav", + "text": "我覺得會帶來不少的人潮" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147915/170.wav", + "text": "那也因此我們希望" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147915/171.wav", + "text": "這是一件好事" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147915/172.wav", + "text": "可是要準備好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147915/173.wav", + "text": "現在整個田區種植大概達到76%" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147915/174.wav", + "text": "不是要拉到100" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147915/175.wav", + "text": "因為花" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147915/176.wav", + "text": "嘛我知道它有二三十天的時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147915/177.wav", + "text": "我們一定把最完美" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147915/178.wav", + "text": "在開幕的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147915/179.wav", + "text": "接下來我會找個時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147915/180.wav", + "text": "邀請你這邊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147915/181.wav", + "text": "如果你沒有空的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147915/182.wav", + "text": "不要開幕之後問題跑出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147915/183.wav", + "text": "到時候中央地方又推來推去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147915/184.wav", + "text": "對民眾來講絕對是最大的損失" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147915/185.wav", + "text": "馬上要進入" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147915/186.wav", + "text": "柑橘跟茂谷的產季" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147915/187.wav", + "text": "對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147915/188.wav", + "text": "那你也知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147915/189.wav", + "text": "柑橘茂谷在臺中的產量是最多的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147915/190.wav", + "text": "我們差不多到隔年的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147915/191.wav", + "text": "比如說明年的二三月或四月" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147915/192.wav", + "text": "我們就要去傷腦筋一件事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147915/193.wav", + "text": "外銷的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147915/194.wav", + "text": "產量跟銷售的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147915/195.wav", + "text": "所以這部分你們今年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147915/196.wav", + "text": "有沒有提早準備" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147915/197.wav", + "text": "預估跟準備" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147915/198.wav", + "text": "柑橘類的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147915/199.wav", + "text": "其實我們跟臺中市政府合作得非常好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147915/200.wav", + "text": "包括一起共同做行銷" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147915/201.wav", + "text": "一起共同去做外銷的這些宣導" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147915/202.wav", + "text": "這個部分我們會持續地跟臺中市政府" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147915/203.wav", + "text": "來做一些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147915/204.wav", + "text": "行銷外銷還有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147915/205.wav", + "text": "加工的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147915/206.wav", + "text": "外銷運輸的一些補助" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147915/207.wav", + "text": "你們今年有準備嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147915/208.wav", + "text": "對已經有一個外銷的獎勵部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147915/209.wav", + "text": "有喔" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147915/210.wav", + "text": "好會後的資料會給你" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147915/211.wav", + "text": "因為我希望預做準備" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147915/212.wav", + "text": "啦預做準備的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147915/213.wav", + "text": "一方面就是說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147915/214.wav", + "text": "讓農民心裡有一個底" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147915/215.wav", + "text": "他們可以好好的來採收" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147915/216.wav", + "text": "然後讓市場上去賣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147915/217.wav", + "text": "而不要有一些預估的心理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147915/218.wav", + "text": "好像今年價格會怎麼樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147915/219.wav", + "text": "會怎麼樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147915/220.wav", + "text": "反而影響到農民的收益" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147915/221.wav", + "text": "而且也會打亂了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147915/222.wav", + "text": "一些相關配套上面的步調" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147915/223.wav", + "text": "所以這越早準備越好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147915/224.wav", + "text": "我也跟委員說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147915/225.wav", + "text": "其實在整個重要農產品的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147915/226.wav", + "text": "我們在年初的時候就有完整的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147915/227.wav", + "text": "一個規劃" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147915/228.wav", + "text": "預判嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147915/229.wav", + "text": "或是在國內的這些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147915/230.wav", + "text": "加工的拉引" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147915/231.wav", + "text": "這個部分我們在年初的時候就開始" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147915/232.wav", + "text": "然後會滾動地去看實際天候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147915/233.wav", + "text": "那請你把最新的預判" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147915/234.wav", + "text": "還有準備的資料給本席好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147915/235.wav", + "text": "那後續我們也會根據實際的狀況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147915/236.wav", + "text": "再跟農委會這邊來做討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147915/237.wav", + "text": "看怎麼樣來幫忙農民" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147915/238.wav", + "text": "OK好瞭解" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147915/239.wav", + "text": "好謝謝江委員的質詢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147915/240.wav", + "text": "我們接下來請蔡培慧委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147914/0.wav", + "text": "部長你好今天是勞動部關於勞退勞保的改革專報" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147914/1.wav", + "text": "我先問部長一個我相信是很基本的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147914/2.wav", + "text": "但是卻很困擾非常多的勞工" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147914/3.wav", + "text": "就是如果不適用勞基法到底可不可以保勞保" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147914/4.wav", + "text": "不適用勞基法到底能不能可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147914/5.wav", + "text": "只要有僱傭關係" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147914/6.wav", + "text": "有僱傭關係就可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147914/7.wav", + "text": "旁邊的幕僚需要幫忙補充嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147914/8.wav", + "text": "好所以不適用勞基法能不能保勞保" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147914/9.wav", + "text": "可以可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147914/10.wav", + "text": "原因是我們有一個相關的列表" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147914/11.wav", + "text": "就是這一張跟部長報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147914/12.wav", + "text": "勞動部有訂出一個例外排除勞基法適用的列表" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147914/13.wav", + "text": "就是以上這些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147914/14.wav", + "text": "所以部長剛剛的回答基本上是沒有錯" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147914/15.wav", + "text": "即便排除適用勞基法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147914/16.wav", + "text": "也是可以保勞保" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147914/17.wav", + "text": "我相信大家應該都很清楚了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147914/18.wav", + "text": "我想要跟部長分享關於運動員的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147914/19.wav", + "text": "亞運剛剛結束" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147914/20.wav", + "text": "有不少職業球員都表現得很好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147914/21.wav", + "text": "不知道部長平常有沒有在關注體育運動" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147914/22.wav", + "text": "我相信應該是您生活的一部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147914/23.wav", + "text": "但是其實我們職棒職籃" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147914/24.wav", + "text": "即便不適用勞基法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147914/25.wav", + "text": "也都有善盡職責幫球員投保" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147914/26.wav", + "text": "在這一陣子的研究" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147914/27.wav", + "text": "卻發現有一些國營事業" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147914/28.wav", + "text": "帶頭違法叫旗下的球員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147914/29.wav", + "text": "自己去職業工會加保" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147914/30.wav", + "text": "部長你身為部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147914/31.wav", + "text": "你覺得這個作法妥當嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147914/32.wav", + "text": "不是很妥當" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147914/33.wav", + "text": "臺酒的高層去做溝通" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147914/34.wav", + "text": "他們正在處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147914/35.wav", + "text": "我們聽到部長說在處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147914/36.wav", + "text": "所以我們辦公室這邊積極的建議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147914/37.wav", + "text": "希望勞動部除了剛剛部長所說的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147914/38.wav", + "text": "我們也希望還有其他國營事業" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147914/39.wav", + "text": "球隊勞保投保的狀況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147914/40.wav", + "text": "我就跟司長說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147914/41.wav", + "text": "你要整個瞭解一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147914/42.wav", + "text": "對整個國營事業的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147914/43.wav", + "text": "對不要讓我們的國營事業帶頭違法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147914/44.wav", + "text": "真心想要替球員拜託許部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147914/45.wav", + "text": "有沒有機會在行政院院會的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147914/46.wav", + "text": "主動提示其他相關部會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147914/47.wav", + "text": "不要因為本位主義" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147914/48.wav", + "text": "或者是曲解勞動法規" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147914/49.wav", + "text": "陷政府於帶頭違法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147914/50.wav", + "text": "苛刻運動員這個聯想" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147914/51.wav", + "text": "不要讓我們的行政機關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147914/52.wav", + "text": "落入這個困境好嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147914/53.wav", + "text": "我利用臨時動議的機會來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147914/54.wav", + "text": "謝謝部長用臨時動議的方法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147914/55.wav", + "text": "\n我們來看一下下一個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147914/56.wav", + "text": "延續關於職業運動的討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147914/57.wav", + "text": "我們發現臺灣職籃" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147914/58.wav", + "text": "目前出現了第一支解散的球隊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147914/59.wav", + "text": "其實對球員的工作" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147914/60.wav", + "text": "籃壇及社會一般的球迷來說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147914/61.wav", + "text": "其實都是一個很重大的衝擊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147914/62.wav", + "text": "他們是被排除適用的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147914/63.wav", + "text": "原本大解法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147914/64.wav", + "text": "想要保護的勞工權益" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147914/65.wav", + "text": "不應該因為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147914/66.wav", + "text": "他們是不是適用勞基法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147914/67.wav", + "text": "而有所差異" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147914/68.wav", + "text": "這個部分我不知道部長清不清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147914/69.wav", + "text": "委員這個沒有關係" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147914/70.wav", + "text": "喔適不適用勞基法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147914/71.wav", + "text": "跟剛剛那個勞保一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147914/72.wav", + "text": "只要有僱傭" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147914/73.wav", + "text": "僱傭關係就適用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147914/74.wav", + "text": "也許我們後續的建議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147914/75.wav", + "text": "您已經比較有把握���" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147914/76.wav", + "text": "我們希望由勞動部這邊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147914/77.wav", + "text": "主動聯繫相關工會的組織" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147914/78.wav", + "text": "看看有沒有這個問題需要協助" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147914/79.wav", + "text": "好好謝謝部長的承諾" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147914/80.wav", + "text": "相關的大解法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147914/81.wav", + "text": "有沒有需要研修的評估" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147914/82.wav", + "text": "也許也可以跟相關的球團討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147914/83.wav", + "text": "或跟相關的運動員討論好嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147914/84.wav", + "text": "好好謝謝部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147914/85.wav", + "text": "最後一個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147914/86.wav", + "text": "其實勞動部一直站在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147914/87.wav", + "text": "鼓勵成立工會的角度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147914/88.wav", + "text": "也有相關的實施要點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147914/89.wav", + "text": "立意良善" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147914/90.wav", + "text": "我們來看相關資料" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147914/91.wav", + "text": "111年裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147914/92.wav", + "text": "成立工會的數量是84家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147914/93.wav", + "text": "可是真的知道要來申請" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147914/94.wav", + "text": "相關補助的只有10家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147914/95.wav", + "text": "家核定的只有7家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147914/96.wav", + "text": "也就是說真的實際成功" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147914/97.wav", + "text": "可以申請到補助的只有8%" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147914/98.wav", + "text": "我們聽了很多工會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147914/99.wav", + "text": "告訴我們相關的聲音" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147914/100.wav", + "text": "其實不是他們不想申請" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147914/101.wav", + "text": "而是這個相關的辦法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147914/102.wav", + "text": "有很多比較不合理的要求" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147914/103.wav", + "text": "不好意思" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147914/104.wav", + "text": "我們就快速" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147914/105.wav", + "text": "的跟部長討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147914/106.wav", + "text": "可不可以加強宣導鼓勵申請" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147914/107.wav", + "text": "讓相關的工會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147914/108.wav", + "text": "第二個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147914/109.wav", + "text": "有沒有機會回溯" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147914/110.wav", + "text": "在疫情期間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147914/111.wav", + "text": "有工會因為不知道相關政策" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147914/112.wav", + "text": "而錯過申請" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147914/113.wav", + "text": "\n最後簡化申請門檻" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147914/114.wav", + "text": "落實政策的美意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147914/115.wav", + "text": "這個部分可不可以進一步的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147914/116.wav", + "text": "在一個月內給我們相關的報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147914/117.wav", + "text": "好好謝謝部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147914/118.wav", + "text": "今天快速跟部長溝通到這邊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147914/119.wav", + "text": "謝謝也謝謝主席" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147914/120.wav", + "text": "我們今天聽到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147914/121.wav", + "text": "所有部長的承諾" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147914/122.wav", + "text": "本席辦公室後續" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147914/123.wav", + "text": "會再跟勞動部積極討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147913/0.wav", + "text": "謝謝主席楊瓊瓔發言" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147913/1.wav", + "text": "邀請部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147913/2.wav", + "text": "有請部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147913/3.wav", + "text": "楊委員好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147913/4.wav", + "text": "部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147913/5.wav", + "text": "接續剛剛的議題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147913/6.wav", + "text": "也是我今天要慎重跟你討論的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147913/7.wav", + "text": "非常不公平" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147913/8.wav", + "text": "非常不公平" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147913/9.wav", + "text": "現在的醫病比" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147913/10.wav", + "text": "已經懸殊非常大" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147913/11.wav", + "text": "在這樣的情況之下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147913/12.wav", + "text": "最近我們竟然" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147913/13.wav", + "text": "區域性醫院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147913/14.wav", + "text": "教學級醫院診所" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147913/15.wav", + "text": "從8001,2001,500" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147913/16.wav", + "text": "護理師人員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147913/17.wav", + "text": "都一樣是護理師" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147913/18.wav", + "text": "我今天在區域性醫院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147913/19.wav", + "text": "我今天在教學級醫院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147913/20.wav", + "text": "我今天在診所" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147913/21.wav", + "text": "我仍舊叫做護理師" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147913/22.wav", + "text": "啊為什麼連政府" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147913/23.wav", + "text": "在補助的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147913/24.wav", + "text": "健保切的都不一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147913/25.wav", + "text": "這讓人家覺得非常" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147913/26.wav", + "text": "不平等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147913/27.wav", + "text": "因為在職場上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147913/28.wav", + "text": "立足點的公平" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147913/29.wav", + "text": "\n我再重複講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147913/30.wav", + "text": "你必須要去講出這一點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147913/31.wav", + "text": "怎麼可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147913/32.wav", + "text": "以醫院有分等級" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147913/33.wav", + "text": "我今天在區域性醫院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147913/34.wav", + "text": "我在教學級醫院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147913/35.wav", + "text": "我在診所" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147913/36.wav", + "text": "診所給800" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147913/37.wav", + "text": "這個給1,200" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147913/38.wav", + "text": "這個給1,500" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147913/39.wav", + "text": "立足點的不公平" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147913/40.wav", + "text": "嘛邏輯怎麼可以如此呢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147913/41.wav", + "text": "我今天為了回我的家鄉服務" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147913/42.wav", + "text": "我願意在診所服務" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147913/43.wav", + "text": "這樣也是一個非常" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147913/44.wav", + "text": "讓我們尊敬的護理師" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147913/45.wav", + "text": "在教學醫院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147913/46.wav", + "text": "他也是我們非常尊敬的護理師" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147913/47.wav", + "text": "為什麼連政府都帶頭" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147913/48.wav", + "text": "這樣的不公平" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147913/49.wav", + "text": "這絕對是我們容不下的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147913/50.wav", + "text": "好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147913/51.wav", + "text": "現在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147913/52.wav", + "text": "所有的醫療界也開始出聲" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147913/53.wav", + "text": "我們當民意代表的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147913/54.wav", + "text": "的醫病比差那麼多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147913/55.wav", + "text": "護理師人員那麼辛苦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147913/56.wav", + "text": "有什麼理由" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147913/57.wav", + "text": "不可以如此" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147913/58.wav", + "text": "好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147913/59.wav", + "text": "您剛剛回答我們最專業" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147913/60.wav", + "text": "我們都一起" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147913/61.wav", + "text": "這不分藍綠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147913/62.wav", + "text": "大家都是為了我們全民的健康" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147913/63.wav", + "text": "至少你讓工作者要立足點的公平" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147913/64.wav", + "text": "你剛才答復的是兩個禮拜內" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147913/65.wav", + "text": "多久時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147913/66.wav", + "text": "兩個禮拜" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147913/67.wav", + "text": "趕快去研討好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147913/68.wav", + "text": "告訴政府" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147913/69.wav", + "text": "不能這樣欺負我們的護理師" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147913/70.wav", + "text": "從護士的名稱" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147913/71.wav", + "text": "好不容易得到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147913/72.wav", + "text": "政府的一個尊敬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147913/73.wav", + "text": "這個當中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147913/74.wav", + "text": "的革命情感" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147913/75.wav", + "text": "讓我們是非常的感動" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147913/76.wav", + "text": "所以沒有理由" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147913/77.wav", + "text": "這樣藐視我們的護理師" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147913/78.wav", + "text": "還自己主動給我們分級" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147913/79.wav", + "text": "怎麼可以如此" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147913/80.wav", + "text": "你覺得這樣子也不對嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147913/81.wav", + "text": "對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147913/82.wav", + "text": "所以兩個禮拜內" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147913/83.wav", + "text": "將書面資料給本席" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147913/84.wav", + "text": "再開研討會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147913/85.wav", + "text": "好好的去做到立足點公平" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147913/86.wav", + "text": "讓他們至少可以放心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147913/87.wav", + "text": "放心去照顧我們所有的病人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147913/88.wav", + "text": "好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147913/89.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147913/90.wav", + "text": "那我們理念一致\n" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147913/91.wav", + "text": "繼續我們來討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147913/92.wav", + "text": "公教人員退撫新制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147913/93.wav", + "text": "今年7月1號開始上路" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147913/94.wav", + "text": "路強制提撥率是15%" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147913/95.wav", + "text": "又是一個立足點的不公平" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147913/96.wav", + "text": "應我們看到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147913/97.wav", + "text": "2005年7月1號開始" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147913/98.wav", + "text": "到勞工的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147913/99.wav", + "text": "個人退休金專戶" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147913/100.wav", + "text": "能夠試圖去改善" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147913/101.wav", + "text": "舊制沒有辦法累積年資" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147913/102.wav", + "text": "以及勞工" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147913/103.wav", + "text": "因為資方" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147913/104.wav", + "text": "或逃避而領不到退休金的這些問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147913/105.wav", + "text": "我們的目的是要怎麼樣去協助" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147913/106.wav", + "text": "我們的勞工可以安穩" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147913/107.wav", + "text": "制要求雇主提撥2%到15%的月薪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147913/108.wav", + "text": "我們看到了這個情況會產生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147913/109.wav", + "text": "的問題也就是核准退休時的平均月薪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147913/110.wav", + "text": "當月的平均月薪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147913/111.wav", + "text": "──他退休時的平均月薪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147913/112.wav", + "text": "新制勞工的退休金" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147913/113.wav", + "text": "變相會縮水" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147913/114.wav", + "text": "而且讓勞工會有點隱憂" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147913/115.wav", + "text": "隱憂什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147913/116.wav", + "text": "物價調高" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147913/117.wav", + "text": "物價飛漲" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147913/118.wav", + "text": "通膨因素" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147913/119.wav", + "text": "而讓他們沒有辦法生活" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147913/120.wav", + "text": "我們來用數字告訴你" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147913/121.wav", + "text": "112年8月底" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147913/122.wav", + "text": "也就是上上個月" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147913/123.wav", + "text": "勞退新制總提繳人數是746萬7,145人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147913/124.wav", + "text": "提繳人數的13.95%" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147913/125.wav", + "text": "所以本席在這邊請教部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147913/126.wav", + "text": "要確認勞工" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147913/127.wav", + "text": "能夠有充分的退休金" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147913/128.wav", + "text": "我們在那邊討論了很多次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147913/129.wav", + "text": "本席一直要求" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147913/130.wav", + "text": "是你們現在在做的這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147913/131.wav", + "text": "你要透過什麼樣的方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147913/132.wav", + "text": "目前只有13%多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147913/133.wav", + "text": "你要用怎麼樣的方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147913/134.wav", + "text": "去宣導" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147913/135.wav", + "text": "也就是降" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147913/136.wav", + "text": "他們認為退休金不足的一個隱憂" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147913/137.wav", + "text": "請做說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147913/138.wav", + "text": "報告委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147913/139.wav", + "text": "其實我們這幾年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147913/140.wav", + "text": "就光以109年來來比較就好了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147913/141.wav", + "text": "這幾年這樣努力下來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147913/142.wav", + "text": "多了將近4%" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147913/143.wav", + "text": "啦人數有提升" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147913/144.wav", + "text": "到底自提的好處是什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147913/145.wav", + "text": "包括保證收益" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147913/146.wav", + "text": "包括稅負優惠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147913/147.wav", + "text": "包括未來退休給付" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147913/148.wav", + "text": "有勞保加勞退" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147913/149.wav", + "text": "會更有保障等等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147913/150.wav", + "text": "我們都會去做宣導" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147913/151.wav", + "text": "那為什麼你們有做宣導" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147913/152.wav", + "text": "但是現在只有13.95%" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147913/153.wav", + "text": "\n接下來本席要跟你討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147913/154.wav", + "text": "的是2022年我們在找原因" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147913/155.wav", + "text": "為什麼你講的都很好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147913/156.wav", + "text": "但是人家不要去做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147913/157.wav", + "text": "原因在哪裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147913/158.wav", + "text": "我們看到了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147913/159.wav", + "text": "高所得勞工" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147913/160.wav", + "text": "相對比中低所得勞工為高" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147913/161.wav", + "text": "你有沒有發覺這個問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147913/162.wav", + "text": "所以通膨的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147913/163.wav", + "text": "讓他們也感到很憂心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147913/164.wav", + "text": "因為中低層的會怕" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147913/165.wav", + "text": "嘛在這樣子的情況之下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147913/166.wav", + "text": "我們看到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147913/167.wav", + "text": "也都有多元管道在推銷" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147913/168.wav", + "text": "就誠如剛才部長所說的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147913/169.wav", + "text": "但是我個人認為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147913/170.wav", + "text": "到目前為止" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147913/171.wav", + "text": "怎麼樣可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147913/172.wav", + "text": "去降低勞工的負擔" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147913/173.wav", + "text": "才能夠有效地" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147913/174.wav", + "text": "地讓勞工放心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147913/175.wav", + "text": "的退休生活是夠的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147913/176.wav", + "text": "你應該要從這一點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147913/177.wav", + "text": "去做宣導" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147913/178.wav", + "text": "譬如說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147913/179.wav", + "text": "你們在全國舉辦退休" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147913/180.wav", + "text": "制度說明會的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147913/181.wav", + "text": "金管會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147913/182.wav", + "text": "去做你應該透過這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147913/183.wav", + "text": "讓他們實際上能夠真正的放心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147913/184.wav", + "text": "從觀念導入" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147913/185.wav", + "text": "他才能夠真正放心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147913/186.wav", + "text": "要不然你說得很好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147913/187.wav", + "text": "啊請說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147913/188.wav", + "text": "個情況在宣導會跟勞工講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147913/189.wav", + "text": "跟委員報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147913/190.wav", + "text": "我們也針對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147913/191.wav", + "text": "因為大學畢業生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147913/192.wav", + "text": "馬上要進入職場" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147913/193.wav", + "text": "超前部署" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147913/194.wav", + "text": "對超前部署" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147913/195.wav", + "text": "因為很多是年輕人不曉得的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147913/196.wav", + "text": "不好意思" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147913/197.wav", + "text": "楊委員超過2分鐘" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147913/198.wav", + "text": "我們就針對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147913/199.wav", + "text": "請你將這個書面資料給本席" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147913/200.wav", + "text": "因為我要告訴你一個問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147913/201.wav", + "text": "很重要的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147913/202.wav", + "text": "勞保的財政能夠穩定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147913/203.wav", + "text": "行政院承諾" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147913/204.wav", + "text": "明年1,200億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147913/205.wav", + "text": "另外還有特別預算300億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147913/206.wav", + "text": "但是我個人認為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147913/207.wav", + "text": "只能夠救急" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147913/208.wav", + "text": "所以我要你提一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147913/209.wav", + "text": "書面資料給本席" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147913/210.wav", + "text": "也就是你要怎麼樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147913/211.wav", + "text": "讓勞保財政穩定作業" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147913/212.wav", + "text": "你的年金改革" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147913/213.wav", + "text": "接下來會怎麼做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147913/214.wav", + "text": "請你把書面資料給本席" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147913/215.wav", + "text": "我們從根來解決" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147913/216.wav", + "text": "這樣才有辦法去穩定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147913/217.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147913/218.wav", + "text": "謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147912/0.wav", + "text": "先請教退撫基金管理局局長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147912/1.wav", + "text": "我看到你們的報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147912/2.wav", + "text": "提到配合年改自107年7月1日" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147912/3.wav", + "text": "施行逐年調降退休金計算基準" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147912/4.wav", + "text": "以及軍公教人員調降退休（職伍）所得後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147912/5.wav", + "text": "各級政府所節省之退撫經費" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147912/6.wav", + "text": "全數挹注退撫基金" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147912/7.wav", + "text": "我可能國文不大好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147912/8.wav", + "text": "你把它減下來了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147912/9.wav", + "text": "所以才讓你這一個洞變小" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147912/10.wav", + "text": "這樣算挹注嗎它" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147912/11.wav", + "text": "它的意思是說原來要發的錢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147912/12.wav", + "text": "因為年改以後它就減少了嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147912/13.wav", + "text": "那個錢政府還要再去編預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147912/14.wav", + "text": "挹注到這個基金來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147912/15.wav", + "text": "所以你本來答應要給別人的錢減少了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147912/16.wav", + "text": "老實說頂多只能說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147912/17.wav", + "text": "是減少基金的缺口" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147912/18.wav", + "text": "員可能有一個誤會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147912/19.wav", + "text": "舊制原來恩給制的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147912/20.wav", + "text": "都是政府去編預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147912/21.wav", + "text": "並不是從那個基金裡面支出的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147912/22.wav", + "text": "所以有一些節省會節省在基金" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147912/23.wav", + "text": "就是委員的意思就是少花了那些錢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147912/24.wav", + "text": "但是有一些原來是政府另外要編預算的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147912/25.wav", + "text": "還是要再挹注基金" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147912/26.wav", + "text": "anyway" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147912/27.wav", + "text": "它就沒有少編" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147912/28.wav", + "text": "就是因為你少給了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147912/29.wav", + "text": "anyway" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147912/30.wav", + "text": "如果你還是堅持這是挹注的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147912/31.wav", + "text": "可能是我的中文跟你的中文學得不大一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147912/32.wav", + "text": "其實是2023年6月的新聞" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147912/33.wav", + "text": "那時候你們告訴大家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147912/34.wav", + "text": "不會在135年就用罄" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147912/35.wav", + "text": "罄會在140年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147912/36.wav", + "text": "因為你調降了公務人員退休所得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147912/37.wav", + "text": "節省了1,600億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147912/38.wav", + "text": "老實說我覺得你只能說到這裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147912/39.wav", + "text": "因為這樣子所以節省1,600億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147912/40.wav", + "text": "後面的什麼挹注" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147912/41.wav", + "text": "我真的覺得我不知道為什麼可以用這樣子的字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147912/42.wav", + "text": "再來最後在9月26號的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147912/43.wav", + "text": "你們又改口了說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147912/44.wav", + "text": "確實" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147912/45.wav", + "text": "是在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147912/46.wav", + "text": "135年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147912/47.wav", + "text": "就會用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147912/48.wav", + "text": "那是因為新制實施" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147912/49.wav", + "text": "就是112年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147912/50.wav", + "text": "初任公務員的新的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147912/51.wav", + "text": "儲金制實施以後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147912/52.wav", + "text": "才會從140年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147912/53.wav", + "text": "提早到135年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147912/54.wav", + "text": "這是不同原因" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147912/55.wav", + "text": "好6月的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147912/56.wav", + "text": "不知道新制要上路是不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147912/57.wav", + "text": "還是6月的時候你們沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147912/58.wav", + "text": "不是剛剛的意思就是說原來講140年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147912/59.wav", + "text": "就是剛完成年改的時候重新估算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147912/60.wav", + "text": "年改的那個時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147912/61.wav", + "text": "112年新制還沒有立法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147912/62.wav", + "text": "所以112年新制立法完成之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147912/63.wav", + "text": "我我知道112年的時候新制還沒有立法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147912/64.wav", + "text": "不過112年6月的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147912/65.wav", + "text": "你應該知道新制快要立法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147912/66.wav", + "text": "你們都已經" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147912/67.wav", + "text": "是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147912/68.wav", + "text": "所以它會提前5年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147912/69.wav", + "text": "沒有不知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147912/70.wav", + "text": "所以你們覺得有可能不會完成嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147912/71.wav", + "text": "不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147912/72.wav", + "text": "我們沒有這個問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147912/73.wav", + "text": "啊因為新制的確會讓公務員的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147912/74.wav", + "text": "提前5年這個我們一直都知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147912/75.wav", + "text": "對所以當時候人家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147912/76.wav", + "text": "就是在跟你說這件事情你還硬拗" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147912/77.wav", + "text": "說沒有問題是140年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147912/78.wav", + "text": "沒有我沒有這樣說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147912/79.wav", + "text": "退輔基金將比年改後原估計" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147912/80.wav", + "text": "時程提前5年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147912/81.wav", + "text": "你看一下你" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147912/82.wav", + "text": "6月26日的新聞" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147912/83.wav", + "text": "退輔基金135年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147912/84.wav", + "text": "會破產" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147912/85.wav", + "text": "對吧" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147912/86.wav", + "text": "是不曉得它當時主張的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147912/87.wav", + "text": "135年是根據什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147912/88.wav", + "text": "精算以後140年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147912/89.wav", + "text": "是我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147912/90.wav", + "text": "預計會用罄的年度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147912/91.wav", + "text": "年改以後已經從130年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147912/92.wav", + "text": "延後到140年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147912/93.wav", + "text": "所以135年那個數字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147912/94.wav", + "text": "是不對的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147912/95.wav", + "text": "但它如果因為新制以後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147912/96.wav", + "text": "我從頭到尾只想告訴你們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147912/97.wav", + "text": "誠實地對待你的員工" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147912/98.wav", + "text": "因為前面講是改革" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147912/99.wav", + "text": "不盡理想的結果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147912/100.wav", + "text": "有個洞所以要撥補對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147912/101.wav", + "text": "因為新制所以造成提前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147912/102.wav", + "text": "所以你的精算報告也寫出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147912/103.wav", + "text": "剛剛許多委員也提到了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147912/104.wav", + "text": "就是要撥補100億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147912/105.wav", + "text": "左右" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147912/106.wav", + "text": "那你們也提了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147912/107.wav", + "text": "你們確實是跟行政院提" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147912/108.wav", + "text": "公務人員要194億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147912/109.wav", + "text": "教育部那邊是提123億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147912/110.wav", + "text": "結果你們只被核准50億50億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147912/111.wav", + "text": "對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147912/112.wav", + "text": "什麼感覺" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147912/113.wav", + "text": "當然不滿意要繼續爭取" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147912/114.wav", + "text": "有爭取到嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147912/115.wav", + "text": "當然沒有爭取到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147912/116.wav", + "text": "如果第一年就這樣子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147912/117.wav", + "text": "這麼地不誠實" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147912/118.wav", + "text": "誰還相信你" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147912/119.wav", + "text": "當時我記得我們修法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147912/120.wav", + "text": "老實說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147912/121.wav", + "text": "已經很不滿意了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147912/122.wav", + "text": "最後退一步說好吧" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147912/123.wav", + "text": "至少你撥補新制造成的這個洞" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147912/124.wav", + "text": "大家信任你了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147912/125.wav", + "text": "而且這還有法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147912/126.wav", + "text": "現行退撫基金以健全基金財務" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147912/127.wav", + "text": "確實它沒有明定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147912/128.wav", + "text": "多少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147912/129.wav", + "text": "可是你覺得這樣算健全基金財務嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147912/130.wav", + "text": "所以政府一定要負起這個責任" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147912/131.wav", + "text": "你覺得今年的50億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147912/132.wav", + "text": "算負起責任嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147912/133.wav", + "text": "我們當然站在考試院的立場" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147912/134.wav", + "text": "你覺得這樣子政府有負起責任嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147912/135.wav", + "text": "我覺得它不能只看第一年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147912/136.wav", + "text": "不能只看第一年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147912/137.wav", + "text": "請問一下這任政府到什麼時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147912/138.wav", + "text": "你的任期到什麼時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147912/139.wav", + "text": "我的任期到明年8月31號" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147912/140.wav", + "text": "不看第一年那看什麼時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147912/141.wav", + "text": "看不是你任期的時候嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147912/142.wav", + "text": "這個法律是不是你在場的時候審" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147912/143.wav", + "text": "的是不是你任期的時候審的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147912/144.wav", + "text": "是不是你答應的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147912/145.wav", + "text": "沒有錯" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147912/146.wav", + "text": "然後你說不能看你任期的時候撥補" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147912/147.wav", + "text": "我的意思是說它有沒有符合這條法律的精神" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147912/148.wav", + "text": "不是只看一年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147912/149.wav", + "text": "因為這條法律的精神就是希望它能夠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147912/150.wav", + "text": "我跟你說這個法律寫得很鬆" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147912/151.wav", + "text": "它只說健全基金財務" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147912/152.wav", + "text": "到底夠不夠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147912/153.wav", + "text": "到底健不健全其實就是看你的臉皮" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147912/154.wav", + "text": "夠不夠厚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147912/155.wav", + "text": "如果你覺得50億算是健全的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147912/156.wav", + "text": "你幹嘛提一百零多億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147912/157.wav", + "text": "所以我剛剛有說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147912/158.wav", + "text": "這個並不是我們滿意的結果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147912/159.wav", + "text": "但是我們會繼續爭取" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147912/160.wav", + "text": "我只是要你白話地說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147912/161.wav", + "text": "這樣就是不健全" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147912/162.wav", + "text": "這樣就是政府" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147912/163.wav", + "text": "一再地說謊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147912/164.wav", + "text": "你知道嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147912/165.wav", + "text": "現在公務人員的薪水" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147912/166.wav", + "text": "你覺得跟我們一般民間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147912/167.wav", + "text": "差多少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147912/168.wav", + "text": "有吸引力嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147912/169.wav", + "text": "跟基本工資的距離" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147912/170.wav", + "text": "的確是越來越近" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147912/171.wav", + "text": "你覺得現在社會的低薪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147912/172.wav", + "text": "政府有沒有責任" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147912/173.wav", + "text": "社會這幾年的薪資" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147912/174.wav", + "text": "所得已經有改善了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147912/175.wav", + "text": "當然當然整體來說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147912/176.wav", + "text": "政府都要來努力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147912/177.wav", + "text": "當一個最大的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147912/178.wav", + "text": "雇主" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147912/179.wav", + "text": "最重要的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147912/180.wav", + "text": "老實說我們任何一個資訊部門" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147912/181.wav", + "text": "都比民間任何一間公司的資訊部門" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147912/182.wav", + "text": "還要大" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147912/183.wav", + "text": "它的預算規模都還要大" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147912/184.wav", + "text": "我們的人事也是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147912/185.wav", + "text": "大部分企業" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147912/186.wav", + "text": "你如果沒有用好的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147912/187.wav", + "text": "薪資好的待遇" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147912/188.wav", + "text": "甚至是出爾反爾你開出去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147912/189.wav", + "text": "的條件還一直打折" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147912/190.wav", + "text": "你憑什麼可以吸引優秀" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147912/191.wav", + "text": "的人才如果你沒有優秀的人才" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147912/192.wav", + "text": "不要說優秀的人才至少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147912/193.wav", + "text": "是OK的人才來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147912/194.wav", + "text": "你沒有這些人才來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147912/195.wav", + "text": "你覺得國家有前途嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147912/196.wav", + "text": "退休金政府一定會支給他" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147912/197.wav", + "text": "這個沒有問題當然我們考量" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147912/198.wav", + "text": "財務的部分我們當然希望" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147912/199.wav", + "text": "撥補的速度要加快" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147912/200.wav", + "text": "而且未來必須要加快" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147912/201.wav", + "text": "我也不會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147912/202.wav", + "text": "用這個角度來看我並不是說它不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147912/203.wav", + "text": "我的事我的意思是說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147912/204.wav", + "text": "解決這個財務狀況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147912/205.wav", + "text": "需要時間不是第一年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147912/206.wav", + "text": "所以你現在跟我承諾的是未來而不是你的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147912/207.wav", + "text": "任期內我覺得這非常" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147912/208.wav", + "text": "地可笑跟委員報告因為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147912/209.wav", + "text": "撥補這個事情的確不是考試院決定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147912/210.wav", + "text": "當然所以我只是要你大聲" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147912/211.wav", + "text": "地講行政院撥得不夠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147912/212.wav", + "text": "當時候我們在審法案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147912/213.wav", + "text": "的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147912/214.wav", + "text": "是不是你答應的行政院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147912/215.wav", + "text": "有沒有授權你答應這樣子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147912/216.wav", + "text": "的法條OK這也是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147912/217.wav", + "text": "行政院送進來的這個法條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147912/218.wav", + "text": "有跟行政院確認過行政院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147912/219.wav", + "text": "也同意這個規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147912/220.wav", + "text": "所以就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147912/221.wav", + "text": "說話不算話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147912/222.wav", + "text": "從年改到現在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147912/223.wav", + "text": "一再地打折連去年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147912/224.wav", + "text": "公教人員都已經" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147912/225.wav", + "text": "退讓一步了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147912/226.wav", + "text": "你們還可以再打折" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147912/227.wav", + "text": "這樣子的國家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147912/228.wav", + "text": "到底有什麼希望" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147912/229.wav", + "text": "政府單位都這樣做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147912/230.wav", + "text": "民間單位是不是也跟著這樣做就好啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147912/231.wav", + "text": "因為反正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147912/232.wav", + "text": "我也不用對我的員工太好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147912/233.wav", + "text": "政府也這樣做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147912/234.wav", + "text": "啊其他地方都這樣做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147912/235.wav", + "text": "啊他也跑不到哪裡去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147912/236.wav", + "text": "公務人員很重要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147912/237.wav", + "text": "你看一下下一個圖" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147912/238.wav", + "text": "這是我們在網路上找到的一個資料" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147912/239.wav", + "text": "在民國" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147912/240.wav", + "text": "教人員的薪資大概是民間的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147912/241.wav", + "text": "我們可以吸引人才" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147912/242.wav", + "text": "我想在座許多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147912/243.wav", + "text": "比較資深的公務人員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147912/244.wav", + "text": "真的都是早期進來的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147912/245.wav", + "text": "大家不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147912/246.wav", + "text": "只有要一個鐵飯碗" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147912/247.wav", + "text": "大家認為這是一個很好的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147912/248.wav", + "text": "金飯碗" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147912/249.wav", + "text": "所以可以吸引到好的人來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147912/250.wav", + "text": "為政府工作" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147912/251.wav", + "text": "因為他覺得你也沒有別的地方可以去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147912/252.wav", + "text": "啊那為什麼我們不帶頭呢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147912/253.wav", + "text": "為什麼政府不帶頭呢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147912/254.wav", + "text": "如果政府可以有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147912/255.wav", + "text": "很好的條件給我們的公務人員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147912/256.wav", + "text": "可以吸引很多人才的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147912/257.wav", + "text": "民間也會跟我們搶人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147912/258.wav", + "text": "我只是提醒你們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147912/259.wav", + "text": "這" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147912/260.wav", + "text": "真的很丟臉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147912/261.wav", + "text": "一再的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147912/262.wav", + "text": "不守承諾" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147912/263.wav", + "text": "如果哪一個老闆" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147912/264.wav", + "text": "不要說現在開的薪水不是很好看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147912/265.wav", + "text": "還有很多的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147912/266.wav", + "text": "不良紀錄開出去的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147912/267.wav", + "text": "條件最後都還打折" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147912/268.wav", + "text": "誰還會去應徵" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147912/269.wav", + "text": "還要考試" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147912/270.wav", + "text": "謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147911/0.wav", + "text": "謝謝主席" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147911/1.wav", + "text": "有請我們交通部王部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147911/2.wav", + "text": "你們的簡稱是這樣嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147911/3.wav", + "text": "啦沒有很土的感覺" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147911/4.wav", + "text": "兩位早" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147911/5.wav", + "text": "的是道路交通安全基本法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147911/6.wav", + "text": "我想大家期待已久" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147911/7.wav", + "text": "所有委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147911/8.wav", + "text": "大家也非常期待" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147911/9.wav", + "text": "在內容討論之中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147911/10.wav", + "text": "能夠真正來提供一些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147911/11.wav", + "text": "在行人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147911/12.wav", + "text": "甚至交通安全上的保障" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147911/13.wav", + "text": "這是大家的期待" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147911/14.wav", + "text": "先提一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147911/15.wav", + "text": "對於行人的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147911/16.wav", + "text": "我們聽到部長說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147911/17.wav", + "text": "大概會提供400億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147911/18.wav", + "text": "來改善這樣一個環境" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147911/19.wav", + "text": "對於人行道的計畫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147911/20.wav", + "text": "的大概會到六百零多億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147911/21.wav", + "text": "先不管這個錢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147911/22.wav", + "text": "會投入很多的力量" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147911/23.wav", + "text": "及很多的經費" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147911/24.wav", + "text": "來做一個處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147911/25.wav", + "text": "但是民間相關的團體" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147911/26.wav", + "text": "來拼道安" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147911/27.wav", + "text": "但是我們現在的人行道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147911/28.wav", + "text": "到底及不及格" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147911/29.wav", + "text": "\n我想先問內政部好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147911/30.wav", + "text": "內政部營建署" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147911/31.wav", + "text": "尤其在桃園" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147911/32.wav", + "text": "我看起來人行道有四種" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147911/33.wav", + "text": "依照強度不太同" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147911/34.wav", + "text": "第一個是針對人行道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147911/35.wav", + "text": "有高低差的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147911/36.wav", + "text": "人可以走在一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147911/37.wav", + "text": "完整的人行道上面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147911/38.wav", + "text": "這是第一種情況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147911/39.wav", + "text": "第二種在所有的舊社區" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147911/40.wav", + "text": "是用騎樓空出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147911/41.wav", + "text": "還是有一個保障" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147911/42.wav", + "text": "雖然很多騎樓都被堵住了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147911/43.wav", + "text": "但是第二種類型就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147911/44.wav", + "text": "第三種的保障稍微低一點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147911/45.wav", + "text": "現在一直在推動" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147911/46.wav", + "text": "因為沒辦法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147911/47.wav", + "text": "就是標線型的人行道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147911/48.wav", + "text": "大家就是憑良心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147911/49.wav", + "text": "的車就不要停上去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147911/50.wav", + "text": "要小心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147911/51.wav", + "text": "你知道嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147911/52.wav", + "text": "最差的一種就是沒人行道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147911/53.wav", + "text": "那種叫做人車爭道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147911/54.wav", + "text": "對於我們現在人車爭道的情況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147911/55.wav", + "text": "審計部跟預算中心的報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147911/56.wav", + "text": "我們執行這麼久的人行道普及率" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147911/57.wav", + "text": "仍然沒有到五成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147911/58.wav", + "text": "你的看法如何" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147911/59.wav", + "text": "因為有一些是以前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147911/60.wav", + "text": "早期的狀況遺留下來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147911/61.wav", + "text": "的所以我們現在在這邊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147911/62.wav", + "text": "也去爭取經費" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147911/63.wav", + "text": "來協助地方政府" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147911/64.wav", + "text": "還是以實體人行道為原則" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147911/65.wav", + "text": "至於有一些現在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147911/66.wav", + "text": "為了人行安全的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147911/67.wav", + "text": "我們也會允許它暫時先設置一些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147911/68.wav", + "text": "標線型的人行道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147911/69.wav", + "text": "來維護人行的安全" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147911/70.wav", + "text": "至於地方政府現在所提的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147911/71.wav", + "text": "一些申請案件來講的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147911/72.wav", + "text": "我們都是以實體人行道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147911/73.wav", + "text": "這個會期來拜訪我的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147911/74.wav", + "text": "特別提到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147911/75.wav", + "text": "因為大家都知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147911/76.wav", + "text": "最不安全就是人車爭道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147911/77.wav", + "text": "真的還沒有人行道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147911/78.wav", + "text": "過去我們看了這麼多年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147911/79.wav", + "text": "尤其內政部在執行的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147911/80.wav", + "text": "不管是人行道的改善" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147911/81.wav", + "text": "─人本專案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147911/82.wav", + "text": "大家都來看同樣的地方" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147911/83.wav", + "text": "我曾經看過一條人行道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147911/84.wav", + "text": "就已經有人行道了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147911/85.wav", + "text": "是A類比較安全的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147911/86.wav", + "text": "一鋪再鋪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147911/87.wav", + "text": "然後委員也樂此不疲" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147911/88.wav", + "text": "來那邊檢查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147911/89.wav", + "text": "大家都非常快樂" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147911/90.wav", + "text": "回去得第一名第二名" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147911/91.wav", + "text": "然後就結束了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147911/92.wav", + "text": "他走完這條人行道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147911/93.wav", + "text": "之後下面就沒有人行道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147911/94.wav", + "text": "所以民眾一直在期待" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147911/95.wav", + "text": "我也跟部長說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147911/96.wav", + "text": "假設你們兩個部會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147911/97.wav", + "text": "湊起來有這麼多錢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147911/98.wav", + "text": "到底有多少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147911/99.wav", + "text": "是你要逐步讓沒有人行道的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147911/100.wav", + "text": "變成有人行道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147911/101.wav", + "text": "我覺得這個東西要去努力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147911/102.wav", + "text": "你去找的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147911/103.wav", + "text": "一定有一些是可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147911/104.wav", + "text": "我相信這個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147911/105.wav", + "text": "你一定要努力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147911/106.wav", + "text": "啊不然每一次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147911/107.wav", + "text": "你們這些錢一下去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147911/108.wav", + "text": "我先講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147911/109.wav", + "text": "到時候地方政府" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147911/110.wav", + "text": "又是把已經有人行道的部分看看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147911/111.wav", + "text": "哪裡不平" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147911/112.wav", + "text": "把磚變成壓花地坪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147911/113.wav", + "text": "壓花地坪再變磚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147911/114.wav", + "text": "變來變去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147911/115.wav", + "text": "我覺得有人行道不平" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147911/116.wav", + "text": "當然也要改善" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147911/117.wav", + "text": "在人行道上面不平" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147911/118.wav", + "text": "確實會跌倒" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147911/119.wav", + "text": "但是人車爭道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147911/120.wav", + "text": "其實很明顯" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147911/121.wav", + "text": "\n第二個問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147911/122.wav", + "text": "事實上我知道內政部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147911/123.wav", + "text": "人行道但是現在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147911/124.wav", + "text": "跟我們的關係也蠻大的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147911/125.wav", + "text": "都市計畫省道的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147911/126.wav", + "text": "當時全國的交通" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147911/127.wav", + "text": "大概都以車為主" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147911/128.wav", + "text": "就在我們的省道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147911/129.wav", + "text": "一個區塊一個區塊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147911/130.wav", + "text": "也發覺這個問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147911/131.wav", + "text": "我看你們過去五年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147911/132.wav", + "text": "針對既有人行道改善" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147911/133.wav", + "text": "真的不短" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147911/134.wav", + "text": "32公里算是有努力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147911/135.wav", + "text": "但仔細一看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147911/136.wav", + "text": "我的天啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147911/137.wav", + "text": "總計是35公里" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147911/138.wav", + "text": "其中32公里大概有九成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147911/139.wav", + "text": "就是我剛剛說的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147911/140.wav", + "text": "已經有人行道的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147911/141.wav", + "text": "再幫它擦脂抹粉一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147911/142.wav", + "text": "更平整" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147911/143.wav", + "text": "讓大家來檢查的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147911/144.wav", + "text": "你看我有一個新的人行道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147911/145.wav", + "text": "但是它都是舊的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147911/146.wav", + "text": "針對我們最擔心的是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147911/147.wav", + "text": "新設人行道2公里" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147911/148.wav", + "text": "標線型人行道0.5公里" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147911/149.wav", + "text": "人行的需求遠遠超過這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147911/150.wav", + "text": "未來要怎麼做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147911/151.wav", + "text": "是我先跟委員報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147911/152.wav", + "text": "這個我跟我們局長有討論過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147911/153.wav", + "text": "過去的確公路局所管的省道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147911/154.wav", + "text": "很多在郊區" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147911/155.wav", + "text": "所以他們的人行道真的是比" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147911/156.wav", + "text": "內政部所設的人行道少很多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147911/157.wav", + "text": "但是我有跟他談到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147911/158.wav", + "text": "包括有一些風景區" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147911/159.wav", + "text": "比較多的地方也應該設人行道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147911/160.wav", + "text": "這次400億裡面公總會有120億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147911/161.wav", + "text": "我是有要求他們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147911/162.wav", + "text": "對於剛才所談到新設人行道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147911/163.wav", + "text": "不足的部分來補強" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147911/164.wav", + "text": "我目前已經有這樣子交代他們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147911/165.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147911/166.wav", + "text": "針對現在青埔的發展" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147911/167.wav", + "text": "它有連接我們另外一個社區過嶺之間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147911/168.wav", + "text": "有很多的聚落" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147911/169.wav", + "text": "你們先去研究好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147911/170.wav", + "text": "跟公路總局" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147911/171.wav", + "text": "事實上從前瞻計畫的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147911/172.wav", + "text": "我們地方在爭取" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147911/173.wav", + "text": "現在我們看到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147911/174.wav", + "text": "中壢舊市區停車的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147911/175.wav", + "text": "現在正在做中壢國小二期的工程" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147911/176.wav", + "text": "在我們舊市區" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147911/177.wav", + "text": "已經有交通部公路總局的一個補助" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147911/178.wav", + "text": "3年前我特別提了我們中正公園" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147911/179.wav", + "text": "也是舊市區地下停車場" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147911/180.wav", + "text": "這個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147911/181.wav", + "text": "我們的部長局長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147911/182.wav", + "text": "也有依承諾來幫忙" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147911/183.wav", + "text": "現在正在施工" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147911/184.wav", + "text": "青埔地區發展快速" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147911/185.wav", + "text": "我在去年12月質詢的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147911/186.wav", + "text": "那時候旁邊很多的建設都還沒完成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147911/187.wav", + "text": "青埔這邊的中壢停十停車場的一個計畫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147911/188.wav", + "text": "其實我陸續講了大概兩年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147911/189.wav", + "text": "啦局長我大概跟你講幾次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147911/190.wav", + "text": "78次應該有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147911/191.wav", + "text": "十委員一直關心這個停車場未來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147911/192.wav", + "text": "我跟你提的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147911/193.wav", + "text": "需求還沒那麼急迫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147911/194.wav", + "text": "現在已經不是未來式了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147911/195.wav", + "text": "會展中心蓋好了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147911/196.wav", + "text": "然後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147911/197.wav", + "text": "作為這次世界客家博覽會的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147911/198.wav", + "text": "場地世界館現在要變成科技圖書館" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147911/199.wav", + "text": "未來旁邊創新研發中心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147911/200.wav", + "text": "他們停車場怎麼規劃我不清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147911/201.wav", + "text": "但是這一塊停車場" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147911/202.wav", + "text": "是非常急迫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147911/203.wav", + "text": "滿重要的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147911/204.wav", + "text": "這個部分目前處理得怎麼樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147911/205.wav", + "text": "我們整個在前瞻裡面停車場計畫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147911/206.wav", + "text": "已經跑好幾年了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147911/207.wav", + "text": "剛才你提的停車場都做完了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147911/208.wav", + "text": "因為我們的經費都分配完" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147911/209.wav", + "text": "現在就是賸餘款" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147911/210.wav", + "text": "我也請局長把它記下來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147911/211.wav", + "text": "如果有賸餘款" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147911/212.wav", + "text": "的話賸餘款就是發包後有賸" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147911/213.wav", + "text": "或是沒做的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147911/214.wav", + "text": "這部分我們會優先把它放進去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147911/215.wav", + "text": "部長事實上它已經" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147911/216.wav", + "text": "各地的賸餘款" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147911/217.wav", + "text": "其實我所知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147911/218.wav", + "text": "因為你發包第一期出去的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147911/219.wav", + "text": "很多的評估有問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147911/220.wav", + "text": "退回來的賸餘款真的不少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147911/221.wav", + "text": "所以我們桃園市政府針對停十" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147911/222.wav", + "text": "立體停車場這個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147911/223.wav", + "text": "又提案進來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147911/224.wav", + "text": "也經過你們委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147911/225.wav", + "text": "原則上審議通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147911/226.wav", + "text": "的部分他們補件在上個禮拜四也補來了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147911/227.wav", + "text": "什麼時候可以做一個決定出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147911/228.wav", + "text": "大概要多久會有決定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147911/229.wav", + "text": "跟委員報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147911/230.wav", + "text": "它是10月19號補件" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147911/231.wav", + "text": "停車場的樓層數跟停車的總經費" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147911/232.wav", + "text": "我們會再做一個審查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147911/233.wav", + "text": "現在的結餘款當" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147911/234.wav", + "text": "還是會考慮到桃園市政府" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147911/235.wav", + "text": "是不是儘量把中壢停十" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147911/236.wav", + "text": "好那我算第10次跟你拜託" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147911/237.wav", + "text": "它現在丟進來有幾個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147911/238.wav", + "text": "但這個沒有排在前面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147911/239.wav", + "text": "這需求真的是滿大的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147911/240.wav", + "text": "跟桃園市政府討論一下好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147910/0.wav", + "text": "謝謝主席我想請交通部王部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147910/1.wav", + "text": "部長好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147910/2.wav", + "text": "部長上週末發生新竹的科技公司員工" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147910/3.wav", + "text": "造成4人不幸罹難" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147910/4.wav", + "text": "這是一個非常悲痛的事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147910/5.wav", + "text": "尤其是有一對母子出遊卻遇到不幸" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147910/6.wav", + "text": "實在非常令人非常心痛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147910/7.wav", + "text": "過去有多達9次超速違規的紀錄" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147910/8.wav", + "text": "健全通運有限公司進行查核" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147910/9.wav", + "text": "事後發現違反公路法第77條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147910/10.wav", + "text": "跟汽車運輸業管理規則第十九條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147910/11.wav", + "text": "而開罰9萬塊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147910/12.wav", + "text": "事後的開罰" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147910/13.wav", + "text": "發現它有這樣的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147910/14.wav", + "text": "公司在交通部的評鑑裡面卻得到甲等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147910/15.wav", + "text": "公路總局在評鑑的新聞稿還說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147910/16.wav", + "text": "公路總局鼓勵機關團體及民眾" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147910/17.wav", + "text": "參考評鑑成績來選擇承租遊覽車" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147910/18.wav", + "text": "共同提升國內遊覽車自主專業化" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147910/19.wav", + "text": "治理營運安全與服務品質" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147910/20.wav", + "text": "也就是說這個評鑑的目的是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147910/21.wav", + "text": "當這個新竹的科技公司要辦員工旅遊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147910/22.wav", + "text": "它的承辦人看到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147910/23.wav", + "text": "民眾去選擇這樣的遊覽車公司" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147910/24.wav", + "text": "結果卻發現" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147910/25.wav", + "text": "原來它的駕駛有9次的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147910/26.wav", + "text": "到最後也發生了天人永隔" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147910/27.wav", + "text": "白髮人送黑髮人的慘劇" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147910/28.wav", + "text": "就發現這個公司沒有善盡管理的責任" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147910/29.wav", + "text": "跟它後來發生的事實完全都不符合" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147910/30.wav", + "text": "未來民眾到底要怎麼相信交通部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147910/31.wav", + "text": "怎麼相信公路總局" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147910/32.wav", + "text": "到底這個評鑑出了什麼問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147910/33.wav", + "text": "它之前的評鑑期間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147910/34.wav", + "text": "並沒有發生重大的事故" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147910/35.wav", + "text": "評鑑時我們就會把它改列為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147910/36.wav", + "text": "民眾在選擇遊覽車的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147910/37.wav", + "text": "駕駛是要吊銷駕照" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147910/38.wav", + "text": "依照公路法最高額先處罰它9萬元" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147910/39.wav", + "text": "還有吊扣牌照7個月" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147910/40.wav", + "text": "在事前的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147910/41.wav", + "text": "他已經有多達9次的超速違規紀錄" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147910/42.wav", + "text": "然後它基本上也沒有對它的駕駛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147910/43.wav", + "text": "去進行有效的管理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147910/44.wav", + "text": "這樣的情況之下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147910/45.wav", + "text": "你的評鑑還能夠給它甲等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147910/46.wav", + "text": "這是一個非常qualify" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147910/47.wav", + "text": "還是這個評鑑" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147910/48.wav", + "text": "只不過是虛應故事" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147910/49.wav", + "text": "根本就沒有從這些違規的紀錄" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147910/50.wav", + "text": "或者它到底有沒有認真的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147910/51.wav", + "text": "類似這樣的狀況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147910/52.wav", + "text": "肇事的駕駛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147910/53.wav", + "text": "從2015年到現在超速9次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147910/54.wav", + "text": "業者沒有善盡監督的責任" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147910/55.wav", + "text": "然後這個公司事實上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147910/56.wav", + "text": "也都沒事繼續放任" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147910/57.wav", + "text": "我從交通部上面的網站" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147910/58.wav", + "text": "臺灣遊覽車駕駛違規的紀錄" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147910/59.wav", + "text": "其實有很多也都非常嚴重" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147910/60.wav", + "text": "甚至也有酒駕的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147910/61.wav", + "text": "顯然也不只是健全" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147910/62.wav", + "text": "到公路總局的網路上面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147910/63.wav", + "text": "隨便抓都有很多的紀錄" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147910/64.wav", + "text": "這個也是不是一個個案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147910/65.wav", + "text": "總共被處罰了9次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147910/66.wav", + "text": "但是業者根本不會受到任何的處罰" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147910/67.wav", + "text": "所以它當然也不會去管理它的駕駛者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147910/68.wav", + "text": "就讓這個危險的駕駛者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147910/69.wav", + "text": "載著一車四五十個人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147910/70.wav", + "text": "全家人帶著小孩出遊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147910/71.wav", + "text": "然後發生這樣的事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147910/72.wav", + "text": "跟運輸規則的規定找出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147910/73.wav", + "text": "我們可以看一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147910/74.wav", + "text": "會對業者警告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147910/75.wav", + "text": "大客車的駕駛者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147910/76.wav", + "text": "然後對業者警告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147910/77.wav", + "text": "到第2次的時候就處罰了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147910/78.wav", + "text": "停止使用10日車一次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147910/79.wav", + "text": "也就是說你的車假設有10台" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147910/80.wav", + "text": "我就停你1輛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147910/81.wav", + "text": "讓你痛嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147910/82.wav", + "text": "第2次的時候就10日車" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147910/83.wav", + "text": "第3次的時候就20日車" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147910/84.wav", + "text": "逐漸地加重處罰" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147910/85.wav", + "text": "反觀臺灣的業者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147910/86.wav", + "text": "根本就不痛不癢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147910/87.wav", + "text": "但日本有對業者的課責" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147910/88.wav", + "text": "臺灣是不是也應該比照日本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147910/89.wav", + "text": "對業者課以處分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147910/90.wav", + "text": "現在我們對駕駛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147910/91.wav", + "text": "就是按照處罰條例相關規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147910/92.wav", + "text": "對業者的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147910/93.wav", + "text": "我們有定期的評鑑" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147910/94.wav", + "text": "也是評鑑的項目" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147910/95.wav", + "text": "個別駕駛在客運業" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147910/96.wav", + "text": "我們有3年要回訓一次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147910/97.wav", + "text": "的規定我昨天大概做一個檢討" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147910/98.wav", + "text": "除了現在的記點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147910/99.wav", + "text": "我覺得可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147910/100.wav", + "text": "就他們這種連續犯的行為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147910/101.wav", + "text": "不一定要3年回訓" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147910/102.wav", + "text": "這顯然有問題等一下再談" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147910/103.wav", + "text": "業者是不是也應該要被課責" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147910/104.wav", + "text": "因為你可以看到像昨天在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147910/105.wav", + "text": "在隧道裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147910/106.wav", + "text": "也是一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147910/107.wav", + "text": "對於這些業者要拿出管理的態度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147910/108.wav", + "text": "我舉個例子請交通部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147910/109.wav", + "text": "真的要認真地去思考" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147910/110.wav", + "text": "日本就是用如果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147910/111.wav", + "text": "駕駛超速1次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147910/112.wav", + "text": "第1次給業者警告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147910/113.wav", + "text": "就對這個業者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147910/114.wav", + "text": "停車10日處分了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147910/115.wav", + "text": "才會去管理它的駕駛者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147910/116.wav", + "text": "\n第二個部分是談到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147910/117.wav", + "text": "我必須要講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147910/118.wav", + "text": "為什麼你會把有問題的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147910/119.wav", + "text": "遊覽車公司還是評鑑為甲等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147910/120.wav", + "text": "因為你的評鑑項目非常草率嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147910/121.wav", + "text": "這邊還包括一大堆" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147910/122.wav", + "text": "都是跟安全無關的項目" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147910/123.wav", + "text": "我們今天為什麼要評鑑" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147910/124.wav", + "text": "就是因為這個竹科的公司" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147910/125.wav", + "text": "要辦旅遊的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147910/126.wav", + "text": "看到交通部認證這是甲等的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147910/127.wav", + "text": "非常放心嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147910/128.wav", + "text": "你現在不是這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147910/129.wav", + "text": "這一些一大堆" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147910/130.wav", + "text": "跟安全無關的項目" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147910/131.wav", + "text": "根本沒有辦法去幫助民眾" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147910/132.wav", + "text": "辨別安全度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147910/133.wav", + "text": "思請主席給我1分鐘的時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147910/134.wav", + "text": "我講一下有關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147910/135.wav", + "text": "從駕駛休息設施到日常的車輛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147910/136.wav", + "text": "營運的管理到事故" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147910/137.wav", + "text": "和被行政處分的紀錄" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147910/138.wav", + "text": "一目瞭然它" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147910/139.wav", + "text": "非常非常的困難" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147910/140.wav", + "text": "非常非常的嚴格" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147910/141.wav", + "text": "要維持每年都要在80分以上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147910/142.wav", + "text": "部長就這個評鑑的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147910/143.wav", + "text": "我覺得真的可以認真來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147910/144.wav", + "text": "效法日本的狀況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147910/145.wav", + "text": "是不是可以比照日本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147910/146.wav", + "text": "由獨立的具有廣泛社會代表性的委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147910/147.wav", + "text": "去制定一個安全認證標準" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147910/148.wav", + "text": "大家非常認真的來做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147910/149.wav", + "text": "遊覽車安全的評鑑" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147910/150.wav", + "text": "是的確遊覽車的評鑑" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147910/151.wav", + "text": "可以檢討" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147910/152.wav", + "text": "尤其有關於安全" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147910/153.wav", + "text": "以及對業者的課責部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147910/154.wav", + "text": "我想這部分我們來加強" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147910/155.wav", + "text": "點進去看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147910/156.wav", + "text": "你的資訊都是個別駕駛者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147910/157.wav", + "text": "違規的紀錄等等之類的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147910/158.wav", + "text": "我知道這個沒辦法決定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147910/159.wav", + "text": "到底哪一個遊覽車安全" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147910/160.wav", + "text": "那像日本的狀況是什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147910/161.wav", + "text": "日本的狀況是一目瞭然" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147910/162.wav", + "text": "你可以輸入看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147910/163.wav", + "text": "看他的肇事紀錄到底是什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147910/164.wav", + "text": "一目瞭然從最低的公司" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147910/165.wav", + "text": "到最高的公司" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147910/166.wav", + "text": "讓人要來聘請遊覽車公司的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147910/167.wav", + "text": "可以做一個一目瞭然的決定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147910/168.wav", + "text": "等於你還是要跟其他的公司" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147910/169.wav", + "text": "能夠有一個評比" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147910/170.wav", + "text": "第一個違規的業者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147910/171.wav", + "text": "是不是應該要受行政處分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147910/172.wav", + "text": "第二個能夠有一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147910/173.wav", + "text": "獨立安全的評鑑認證制度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147910/174.wav", + "text": "第三個這個資訊要公開化" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147910/175.wav", + "text": "而且要有可相提並論性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147910/176.wav", + "text": "這是最重要的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147910/177.wav", + "text": "因為有可相提並論性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147910/178.wav", + "text": "我才知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147910/179.wav", + "text": "到底哪一家遊覽車公司" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147910/180.wav", + "text": "是最安全的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147910/181.wav", + "text": "哪一家是比較不安全的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147910/182.wav", + "text": "哪一家是我可以選擇的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147910/183.wav", + "text": "提供給本委員會委員及邱委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147910/184.wav", + "text": "好謝謝主席" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147909/0.wav", + "text": "謝謝召委" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147909/1.wav", + "text": "請王部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147909/2.wav", + "text": "臺灣確實對行人並不太穩定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147909/3.wav", + "text": "我們來看你們給我們的統計數據" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147909/4.wav", + "text": "總件數是逐年攀升" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147909/5.wav", + "text": "如果以111年來看的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147909/6.wav", + "text": "已經有37萬5,844件" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147909/7.wav", + "text": "我剛唸的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147909/8.wav", + "text": "都不願意去唸37萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147909/9.wav", + "text": "我覺得應該是3萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147909/10.wav", + "text": "但實際數字是37萬5,844件" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147909/11.wav", + "text": "可是還有一個更令人擔心的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147909/12.wav", + "text": "就是有3,064人死亡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147909/13.wav", + "text": "受傷看到這些數字會覺得很驚慌" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147909/14.wav", + "text": "可是如果我們再去看你們統計" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147909/15.wav", + "text": "因為112年1到6月" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147909/16.wav", + "text": "換句話說是才半年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147909/17.wav", + "text": "已經發生的件數是20萬1,880件" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147909/18.wav", + "text": "就多了1萬3,958件" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147909/19.wav", + "text": "比例多了7.4%" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147909/20.wav", + "text": "我講這些數據是要告訴您" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147909/21.wav", + "text": "這件事情很嚴重" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147909/22.wav", + "text": "所以我們要訂定這個專法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147909/23.wav", + "text": "但是在訂定這個專法的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147909/24.wav", + "text": "我相信大部分人的想法跟理念" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147909/25.wav", + "text": "都是一致的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147909/26.wav", + "text": "我特別針對管理及教育跟您討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147909/27.wav", + "text": "\n在管理的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147909/28.wav", + "text": "我相信且" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147909/29.wav", + "text": "且也仔細地看了你的專法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147909/30.wav", + "text": "然後我自己針對人行道路" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147909/31.wav", + "text": "的部分做了一個加強" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147909/32.wav", + "text": "為什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147909/33.wav", + "text": "因為如果你在臺北市" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147909/34.wav", + "text": "或者是在桃園市" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147909/35.wav", + "text": "都可以看到人行道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147909/36.wav", + "text": "都有滑坡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147909/37.wav", + "text": "可是在南投縣都還不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147909/38.wav", + "text": "你們要有一個標準規範" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147909/39.wav", + "text": "去規範各個鄉鎮公所" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147909/40.wav", + "text": "及縣市政府怎麼做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147909/41.wav", + "text": "相對的規範就要有相對的罰則" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147909/42.wav", + "text": "跟相對的獎勵" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147909/43.wav", + "text": "這樣子才能夠全臺灣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147909/44.wav", + "text": "一致可不要覺得南投是偏鄉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147909/45.wav", + "text": "就可以不顧" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147909/46.wav", + "text": "因為南投有多少觀光客" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147909/47.wav", + "text": "有多少人是因為這個高低差" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147909/48.wav", + "text": "就滑倒" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147909/49.wav", + "text": "特別是老人家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147909/50.wav", + "text": "這件事情我很清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147909/51.wav", + "text": "\n第二個是教育" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147909/52.wav", + "text": "我們都說要遵守規則" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147909/53.wav", + "text": "要走斑馬線" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147909/54.wav", + "text": "這樣夠嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147909/55.wav", + "text": "還不夠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147909/56.wav", + "text": "我在2013年11月出了車禍" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147909/57.wav", + "text": "是被一個大學生撞的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147909/58.wav", + "text": "他在轉彎的時候並沒有減速" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147909/59.wav", + "text": "我是拿著手機但沒有講電話在過斑馬線" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147909/60.wav", + "text": "被一個在大馬路轉彎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147909/61.wav", + "text": "卻沒有減速的人撞了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147909/62.wav", + "text": "我覺得我能康復不錯" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147909/63.wav", + "text": "當然後遺症也滿多的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147909/64.wav", + "text": "可是我要說的事情是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147909/65.wav", + "text": "難道我們考完駕照就好了嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147909/66.wav", + "text": "或者是說我們可以從通識教育" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147909/67.wav", + "text": "也會到各地去宣導" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147909/68.wav", + "text": "或怎麼樣的落差" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147909/69.wav", + "text": "機車騎士要怎麼注意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147909/70.wav", + "text": "駕駛人又要怎麼注意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147909/71.wav", + "text": "這個是重中之重" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147909/72.wav", + "text": "我能夠存活下來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147909/73.wav", + "text": "要感謝老天爺" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147909/74.wav", + "text": "跟感謝醫師的照顧" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147909/75.wav", + "text": "當時是真的非常嚴重" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147909/76.wav", + "text": "我昏迷了十幾天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147909/77.wav", + "text": "我媽媽都擔心我可能就這樣了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147909/78.wav", + "text": "所以我要說的事情是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147909/79.wav", + "text": "我們在法規上有做了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147909/80.wav", + "text": "但是在執行上還有落差" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147909/81.wav", + "text": "就沒有放入你的基本法規" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147909/82.wav", + "text": "是不是應該放入" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147909/83.wav", + "text": "請部長回應" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147909/84.wav", + "text": "是我跟委員報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147909/85.wav", + "text": "有關人行道的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147909/86.wav", + "text": "新的法規" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147909/87.wav", + "text": "比如市區道路及附屬工程設計規範" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147909/88.wav", + "text": "或是公路路線設計規範" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147909/89.wav", + "text": "新的法規都擺進去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147909/90.wav", + "text": "了的確舊的在過去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147909/91.wav", + "text": "像南投這些比較偏鄉的縣市" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147909/92.wav", + "text": "很多沒有按照這個規範來做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147909/93.wav", + "text": "我們現在的想法就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147909/94.wav", + "text": "行人交通安全設施條例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147909/95.wav", + "text": "在這個設施條例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147909/96.wav", + "text": "中比如該設的斜坡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147909/97.wav", + "text": "該設的人行道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147909/98.wav", + "text": "騎樓的管理等等什麼都放到這裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147909/99.wav", + "text": "也就是說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147909/100.wav", + "text": "這個新的設施條例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147909/101.wav", + "text": "現在的這些設施做一個改善" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147909/102.wav", + "text": "新的部分大概在我們的相關法規" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147909/103.wav", + "text": "已經都開始重視行人這一塊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147909/104.wav", + "text": "好如果是這樣的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147909/105.wav", + "text": "就告訴我們一個期程" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147909/106.wav", + "text": "為什麼呢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147909/107.wav", + "text": "因為這件事情是最簡單的事" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147909/108.wav", + "text": "而且這件事情是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147909/109.wav", + "text": "每個人都用得到的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147909/110.wav", + "text": "不管是牽著小孩" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147909/111.wav", + "text": "或者是老人家拿著柺杖" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147909/112.wav", + "text": "我覺得這個緩坡是做得到的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147909/113.wav", + "text": "請給我一個期程" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147909/114.wav", + "text": "你總是要有一些規範吧" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147909/115.wav", + "text": "內政部的行人交通安全設施條例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147909/116.wav", + "text": "準備下個會期" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147909/117.wav", + "text": "下個會期" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147909/118.wav", + "text": "好且不管下個會期或上個會期" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147909/119.wav", + "text": "你們總應該" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147909/120.wav", + "text": "我剛剛講的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147909/121.wav", + "text": "你的規範出來了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147909/122.wav", + "text": "要有獎勵也要懲處" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147909/123.wav", + "text": "我覺得我們各個版本裡頭" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147909/124.wav", + "text": "我明白的跟你講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147909/125.wav", + "text": "你一定要把民間專業人士" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147909/126.wav", + "text": "或者是性別比例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147909/127.wav", + "text": "直接訂定在母法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147909/128.wav", + "text": "要不然的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147909/129.wav", + "text": "地方政府會不甩你" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147909/130.wav", + "text": "而且我必須要講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147909/131.wav", + "text": "為什麼我說要性別比例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147909/132.wav", + "text": "因為趕著上班的人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147909/133.wav", + "text": "跟推著娃娃車的媽媽" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147909/134.wav", + "text": "是兩個心情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147909/135.wav", + "text": "我們應該把這些心情都納入" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147909/136.wav", + "text": "所以拜託你" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147909/137.wav", + "text": "在這個版本裡頭" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147909/138.wav", + "text": "要納入性別比例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147909/139.wav", + "text": "\n最後我要講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147909/140.wav", + "text": "是5月10號發生的事件" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147909/141.wav", + "text": "來看下一張" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147909/142.wav", + "text": "你就會看到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147909/143.wav", + "text": "我們有很多的捷運" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147909/144.wav", + "text": "看起來是很快速" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147909/145.wav", + "text": "可是我們並沒有去規範" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147909/146.wav", + "text": "物所形成的危害" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147909/147.wav", + "text": "我相信你知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147909/148.wav", + "text": "我在講哪一個事件" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147909/149.wav", + "text": "就在5月的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147909/150.wav", + "text": "我的好朋友" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147909/151.wav", + "text": "林淑雅就這樣不見了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147909/152.wav", + "text": "但是我們沒有看到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147909/153.wav", + "text": "你們的報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147909/154.wav", + "text": "啊你們的報告在哪裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147909/155.wav", + "text": "你們總不能說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147909/156.wav", + "text": "有啦有請臺中捷運" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147909/157.wav", + "text": "臺中市政府去做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147909/158.wav", + "text": "耶你要告訴我" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147909/159.wav", + "text": "你們的規範在哪裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147909/160.wav", + "text": "他們的報告有進展" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147909/161.wav", + "text": "而且去要求捷運行駛的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147909/162.wav", + "text": "如果有工程設施也好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147909/163.wav", + "text": "建築設施也好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147909/164.wav", + "text": "興建過程也好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147909/165.wav", + "text": "要怎麼樣來調整" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147909/166.wav", + "text": "或者是說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147909/167.wav", + "text": "你在發生災難的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147909/168.wav", + "text": "我一而再再而三" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147909/169.wav", + "text": "的再次強調" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147909/170.wav", + "text": "明明她有一段時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147909/171.wav", + "text": "是可以被救出來的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147909/172.wav", + "text": "可是因為她在軌道裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147909/173.wav", + "text": "而你們只檢查車廂" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147909/174.wav", + "text": "耶這些事情是不是也應該要規範" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147909/175.wav", + "text": "因為整個撞擊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147909/176.wav", + "text": "到底會造成人命" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147909/177.wav", + "text": "什麼樣的撞擊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147909/178.wav", + "text": "這些事情不是只有說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147909/179.wav", + "text": "消防局要做的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147909/180.wav", + "text": "或是誰要做的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147909/181.wav", + "text": "前提是你們的規範要完善" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147909/182.wav", + "text": "是對於臺中捷運" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147909/183.wav", + "text": "在5月10日發生這個狀況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147909/184.wav", + "text": "第一個是臨軌工程的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147909/185.wav", + "text": "過去對於旁邊的建築" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147909/186.wav", + "text": "是沒有規範的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147909/187.wav", + "text": "沒有規範" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147909/188.wav", + "text": "而且我覺得這件事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147909/189.wav", + "text": "沒有規範" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147909/190.wav", + "text": "人命就這樣喪失了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147909/191.wav", + "text": "是所以這個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147909/192.wav", + "text": "就監理面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147909/193.wav", + "text": "包括鄰近建築的施工" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147909/194.wav", + "text": "一定要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147909/195.wav", + "text": "在緊急煞車的處理是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147909/196.wav", + "text": "在車裡面而沒有在站" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147909/197.wav", + "text": "前面有狀況但車還是在跑" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147909/198.wav", + "text": "所以這真的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147909/199.wav", + "text": "如果在站上有一個按鈕" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147909/200.wav", + "text": "它就煞車" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147909/201.wav", + "text": "現在變成要跑到車上去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147909/202.wav", + "text": "按按鈕那就變得非常的緊急" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147909/203.wav", + "text": "本來就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147909/204.wav", + "text": "啊而且我覺得有些人根本就不知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147909/205.wav", + "text": "還要越過一個檻" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147909/206.wav", + "text": "檻才能找到那個按鈕" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147909/207.wav", + "text": "更何況第三個搜救" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147909/208.wav", + "text": "搜救的確在這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147909/209.wav", + "text": "課當然他們都很努力要去搜救" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147909/210.wav", + "text": "結果這也有這樣的一個疏忽" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147909/211.wav", + "text": "疏忽掉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147909/212.wav", + "text": "這件事情真的是可以申請國賠的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147909/213.wav", + "text": "而且我相信任何一個生命喪失" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147909/214.wav", + "text": "是最難過的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147909/215.wav", + "text": "也沒有人希望發生這樣的事" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147909/216.wav", + "text": "我相信淑雅也是在提醒我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147909/217.wav", + "text": "我們��有不完善的地方" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147909/218.wav", + "text": "這件事情你們要訂好規範" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147909/219.wav", + "text": "要督促中捷跟臺中市政府" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147909/220.wav", + "text": "好除了交通部所管的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147909/221.wav", + "text": "在內政部所管的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147909/222.wav", + "text": "我們也一起來討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147909/223.wav", + "text": "我們就來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147909/224.wav", + "text": "給我一個時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147909/225.wav", + "text": "啊因為你說正在修訂" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147909/226.wav", + "text": "可是5月10日到現在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147909/227.wav", + "text": "也已經5個月過去了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147909/228.wav", + "text": "好麻煩你們給我一份報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147909/229.wav", + "text": "謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147908/0.wav", + "text": "謝謝主席有請陳代理部長和漁業署張署長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147908/1.wav", + "text": "請部長部長署長8月24日日本啟動核廢水的排放" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147908/2.wav", + "text": "主要影響範圍大概是日本海域及北太平洋" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147908/3.wav", + "text": "我們往年在北太平洋所捕撈的漁獲量大概有多少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147908/4.wav", + "text": "北太平洋我們主要的漁獲是秋刀魚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147908/5.wav", + "text": "對除了秋刀魚還有哪些魚種" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147908/6.wav", + "text": "主要還是秋刀魚為主" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147908/7.wav", + "text": "去年大概就是6萬多公噸" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147908/8.wav", + "text": "6萬多公噸" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147908/9.wav", + "text": "最近是10月21日進來900噸" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147908/10.wav", + "text": "對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147908/11.wav", + "text": "你們檢驗的相關作為是逐批檢驗" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147908/12.wav", + "text": "我們是一船一船的逐船檢驗" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147908/13.wav", + "text": "逐船檢驗" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147908/14.wav", + "text": "我跟委員說明一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147908/15.wav", + "text": "自從日本福島核廢水公告要排放以後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147908/16.wav", + "text": "其實我們已經有成立一個跨部會的專案對我知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147908/17.wav", + "text": "我知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147908/18.wav", + "text": "那個逐船檢驗你要檢驗6萬噸" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147908/19.wav", + "text": "如果按照往年的補獲量是6萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147908/20.wav", + "text": "3艘" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147908/21.wav", + "text": "一個是漁獲一個是海域本身" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147908/22.wav", + "text": "即便如此但是還是會有一些疑慮" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147908/23.wav", + "text": "即便你檢驗都安全都OK都符合標準" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147908/24.wav", + "text": "6萬噸有一部分是外銷國際市場" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147908/25.wav", + "text": "一部分是國內的消費" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147908/26.wav", + "text": "主要還是以外銷為主" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147908/27.wav", + "text": "國內消費" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147908/28.wav", + "text": "是飼料嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147908/29.wav", + "text": "不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147908/30.wav", + "text": "主要還是做食用的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147908/31.wav", + "text": "食用的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147908/32.wav", + "text": "是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147908/33.wav", + "text": "比例是多少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147908/34.wav", + "text": "外銷和國內使用的大概是多少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147908/35.wav", + "text": "我印象裡面內銷的部分大概占30%左右" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147908/36.wav", + "text": "大部分是外銷" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147908/37.wav", + "text": "是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147908/38.wav", + "text": "7成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147908/39.wav", + "text": "所以大概有4萬噸左右是外銷" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147908/40.wav", + "text": "差不多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147908/41.wav", + "text": "目前出口到中國的數量還有多少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147908/42.wav", + "text": "輸中停止了以後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147908/43.wav", + "text": "目前我們石斑魚並沒有外銷中國大陸" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147908/44.wav", + "text": "為什麼數據還有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147908/45.wav", + "text": "因為它是6月之前的數據" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147908/46.wav", + "text": "111年是去年還有數據啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147908/47.wav", + "text": "因為是去年6月2日之後才停止" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147908/48.wav", + "text": "所以目前是沒有任何的石斑魚出口到中國對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147908/49.wav", + "text": "是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147908/50.wav", + "text": "目前的外銷量是多少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147908/51.wav", + "text": "我們石斑魚年產量大概12,0" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147908/52.wav", + "text": "我知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147908/53.wav", + "text": "我知道數字我都已經有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147908/54.wav", + "text": "我是說你一定要比我更清楚啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147908/55.wav", + "text": "是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147908/56.wav", + "text": ",038噸" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147908/57.wav", + "text": "全盛時期多少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147908/58.wav", + "text": ",000左右" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147908/59.wav", + "text": "14,000噸" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147908/60.wav", + "text": "現在剩下6,000噸對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147908/61.wav", + "text": "對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147908/62.wav", + "text": "6,000噸主要還是集中在幾個市場" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147908/63.wav", + "text": "大概是日本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147908/64.wav", + "text": "主要是這3個大概就占了8成左右" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147908/65.wav", + "text": ",000現在變成6,000只剩下4成左右的出口量" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147908/66.wav", + "text": "國內市場又沒有辦法消費那麼多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147908/67.wav", + "text": "當然會影響石斑魚的產業發展" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147908/68.wav", + "text": "部分也有逐步的減少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147908/69.wav", + "text": "相對的你外銷的量過往是比較高" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147908/70.wav", + "text": "現在是比較低" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147908/71.wav", + "text": "同樣的產業的結構現在也正在調整" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147908/72.wav", + "text": "內銷市場一定有它的限制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147908/73.wav", + "text": "爆炸性的成長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147908/74.wav", + "text": "但外銷的空間很大" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147908/75.wav", + "text": "但你要分散市場" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147908/76.wav", + "text": "所以你要拿出積極作為不是減少產量" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147908/77.wav", + "text": "減少養殖量" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147908/78.wav", + "text": "一個部分是調節我們國內的整個結構" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147908/79.wav", + "text": "另外一個部分我們會增加一些國外的市場" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147908/80.wav", + "text": "在美國的部分其實有增加" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147908/81.wav", + "text": "不只美國其他的市場" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147908/82.wav", + "text": "對東南亞都有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147908/83.wav", + "text": "恢復到過去一萬四的水平" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147908/84.wav", + "text": "的國家多元化" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147908/85.wav", + "text": "這個你們積極度不夠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147908/86.wav", + "text": "瞭解我們會更努力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147908/87.wav", + "text": "我希望你要有一個目標管理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147908/88.wav", + "text": "例如明年你們的外銷產值要輔導" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147908/89.wav", + "text": "後年到一萬二" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147908/90.wav", + "text": "大後年要恢復到一萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147908/91.wav", + "text": "目標量來做管理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147908/92.wav", + "text": "另外綠電部分是漁電共生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147908/93.wav", + "text": "跟農電共生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147908/94.wav", + "text": "但是共生就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147908/95.wav", + "text": "要有種電" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147908/96.wav", + "text": "也要養魚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147908/97.wav", + "text": "也要務農對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147908/98.wav", + "text": "你們有沒有統計過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147908/99.wav", + "text": "但是不養魚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147908/100.wav", + "text": "或者是在農田裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147908/101.wav", + "text": "但是沒有做任何的耕作" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147908/102.wav", + "text": "你有沒有統計這種數量" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147908/103.wav", + "text": "所用的面積大概是兩千一百零多公頃" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147908/104.wav", + "text": "我們特別啟動了一些事實的查核" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147908/105.wav", + "text": "以臺南市來講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147908/106.wav", + "text": "沒有真的在種養殖的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147908/107.wav", + "text": "已經被廢止的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147908/108.wav", + "text": "的至少有6件" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147908/109.wav", + "text": "嘉義縣的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147908/110.wav", + "text": "所以他一定要養殖對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147908/111.wav", + "text": "對他一定要養殖" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147908/112.wav", + "text": "沒有養殖的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147908/113.wav", + "text": "我們就會廢止他的許可" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147908/114.wav", + "text": "所以我們現在很積極的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147908/115.wav", + "text": "你要實地去查核" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147908/116.wav", + "text": "就是你要種電也要養魚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147908/117.wav", + "text": "不要影響到養殖漁業的發展" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147908/118.wav", + "text": "或者漁民就不做了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147908/119.wav", + "text": "他就有很好的收入" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147908/120.wav", + "text": "對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147908/121.wav", + "text": "現在有一個查核的機制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147908/122.wav", + "text": "全國是2,100公頃的漁電共生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147908/123.wav", + "text": "對目前用所使用的土地面積" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147908/124.wav", + "text": "19場裡面廢止6場" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147908/125.wav", + "text": "對然後嘉義的部分6場都廢掉了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147908/126.wav", + "text": "所以你們還是要實地去查核" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147908/127.wav", + "text": "有時候他只是應付一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147908/128.wav", + "text": "第一年他可能有養魚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147908/129.wav", + "text": "到第二年他就不養了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147908/130.wav", + "text": "對所以我們會持續去做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147908/131.wav", + "text": "一些抽樣的管理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147908/132.wav", + "text": "有一些他可能養的量比較少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147908/133.wav", + "text": "好像表面上看起來有養" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147908/134.wav", + "text": "但是我們會從他的放養量" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147908/135.wav", + "text": "對這個我們會堅持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147908/136.wav", + "text": "那農電的部分呢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147908/137.wav", + "text": "農電我們完全沒有開放" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147908/138.wav", + "text": "農地的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147908/139.wav", + "text": "我們完全沒有開放去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147908/140.wav", + "text": "到目前為止都沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147908/141.wav", + "text": "只有在屋頂式的溫室部分才有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147908/142.wav", + "text": "就是有設施的部分才有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147908/143.wav", + "text": "所以未來也不會開放" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147908/144.wav", + "text": "目前我們不開放" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147908/145.wav", + "text": "我們不開放農電" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147908/146.wav", + "text": "因為現在我們提供的這兩萬多公頃" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147908/147.wav", + "text": "用到漁電的部分才十分之一而已" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147908/148.wav", + "text": "可以用在漁電共生的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147908/149.wav", + "text": "另外美國的NOAA" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147908/150.wav", + "text": "列出非法漁業名單臺灣又上榜" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147908/151.wav", + "text": "占了八成左右" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147908/152.wav", + "text": "非法漁業的名單對我們國際名聲造成影響" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147908/153.wav", + "text": "會不會對我們的遠洋漁業造成一些影響" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147908/154.wav", + "text": "我想是一定的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147908/155.wav", + "text": "不過我們也是一定要符合" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147908/156.wav", + "text": "在處理IUU的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147908/157.wav", + "text": "我們也跟漁民" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147908/158.wav", + "text": "及漁業組織做了一個非常好的溝通" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147908/159.wav", + "text": "也部分引入了相關的法案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147908/160.wav", + "text": "為什麼會被列入這個名單裡面呢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147908/161.wav", + "text": "主要是因為什麼樣的原因" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147908/162.wav", + "text": "漁獲跟混獲是一個非常重要的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147908/163.wav", + "text": "有些混獲的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147908/164.wav", + "text": "為什麼日本韓國不會被列入" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147908/165.wav", + "text": "列入的理由是什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147908/166.wav", + "text": "有兩個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147908/167.wav", + "text": "一個是IUU的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147908/168.wav", + "text": "主要是提供臺灣有9艘漁船" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147908/169.wav", + "text": "對鯊魚割鰭棄身" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147908/170.wav", + "text": "但是這9艘是哪9艘" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147908/171.wav", + "text": "他們並沒有提出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147908/172.wav", + "text": "我們正在進一步瞭解" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147908/173.wav", + "text": "另外一個就是人權的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147908/174.wav", + "text": "強迫勞動" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147908/175.wav", + "text": "那個是我們的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147908/176.wav", + "text": "就是你們相關的法律規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147908/177.wav", + "text": "才會造成強迫勞動" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147908/178.wav", + "text": "涉及強迫勞動的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147908/179.wav", + "text": "強迫勞動它是根據2022年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147908/180.wav", + "text": "系統性的在改善相關的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147908/181.wav", + "text": "這個有問題馬上就處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147908/182.wav", + "text": "有強迫勞動的這些事實" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147908/183.wav", + "text": "那是哪些漁船造成的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147908/184.wav", + "text": "哪些漁船所做的強迫勞動行為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147908/185.wav", + "text": "你們有沒有具體掌握" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147908/186.wav", + "text": "目前NOAA它所依據的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147908/187.wav", + "text": "還是一些國際的NGO所提供的訊息" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147908/188.wav", + "text": "有些經過我們國內的調查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147908/189.wav", + "text": "並沒有相關的事證" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147908/190.wav", + "text": "所以這部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147908/191.wav", + "text": "我們也跟勞工部在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147908/192.wav", + "text": "做相關的溝通" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147908/193.wav", + "text": "另外在進口替代的部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147908/194.wav", + "text": "國產米事實上有很多的功能" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147908/195.wav", + "text": "不只是食用而已" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147908/196.wav", + "text": "也可以取代進口飼料玉米" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147908/197.wav", + "text": "畜試所有發表成果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147908/198.wav", + "text": "國產稻米可以一定程度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147908/199.wav", + "text": "取代進口玉米飼料" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147908/200.wav", + "text": "這個部分已經成熟了嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147908/201.wav", + "text": "我跟委員說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147908/202.wav", + "text": "現在最主要的這些國產米" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147908/203.wav", + "text": "當時在COVID-19的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147908/204.wav", + "text": "因為進口玉米的壓力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147908/205.wav", + "text": "所以我們有請畜試所去做開發" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147908/206.wav", + "text": "這個部分技術已經完全是可行的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147908/207.wav", + "text": "對最主要我們現在也積極的跟飼料廠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147908/208.wav", + "text": "推廣因為最主要是飼料廠要��意用我們的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147908/209.wav", + "text": "要讓他們安心跟放心說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147908/210.wav", + "text": "沒有問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147908/211.wav", + "text": "我會持續的去跟飼料廠推廣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147908/212.wav", + "text": "你有這個技術" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147908/213.wav", + "text": "你已經也證明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147908/214.wav", + "text": "國產稻米可以取代進口飼料玉米" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147908/215.wav", + "text": "那你們要去推廣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147908/216.wav", + "text": "我想我們會更積極的去跟飼料廠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147908/217.wav", + "text": "拿出具體的作法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147908/218.wav", + "text": "瞭解" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147908/219.wav", + "text": "謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147907/0.wav", + "text": "謝謝主席主席有請審計長以及財政部部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147907/1.wav", + "text": "審計長以及財政部部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147907/2.wav", + "text": "莊部長你先稍候我先來詢問審計長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147907/3.wav", + "text": "占GDP比率創新低貧富差距十年新高等等的專題報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147907/4.wav", + "text": "告當然除了財政部經濟部主計總處到場之外" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147907/5.wav", + "text": "審計部也來了現在剛好是預算會期" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147907/6.wav", + "text": "我也想要就教審計長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147907/7.wav", + "text": "當然就是監督整個預算的執行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147907/8.wav", + "text": "如果有一個行政部門的預算多增加了86萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147907/9.wav", + "text": "但是新增的任務單位卻沒有任何的公開資訊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147907/10.wav", + "text": "也沒有出現在該機關的網站上面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147907/11.wav", + "text": "那麼對審計部來講會給予什麼樣的審計意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147907/12.wav", + "text": "比如說是財政部好了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147907/13.wav", + "text": "它多了一個新任的單位然後多了86萬的預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147907/14.wav", + "text": "可是卻找不到公開資訊來瞭解它是做什麼事情的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147907/15.wav", + "text": "這個時候審計部會寫一些審計意見嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147907/16.wav", + "text": "我們會請機關來補上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147907/17.wav", + "text": "審計長我不知道是不是因為今天這個題目" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147907/18.wav", + "text": "是屬於比較特別" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147907/19.wav", + "text": "的所以來了一個叫做關鍵審計議題發展委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147907/20.wav", + "text": "對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147907/21.wav", + "text": "因為我特別好奇所以我去了解了一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147907/22.wav", + "text": "你們的一廳二廳三廳四廳五廳六廳" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147907/23.wav", + "text": "或是這陣子被在野黨不斷認為有問題的特別預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147907/24.wav", + "text": "包括審計部也都出了審計意見的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147907/25.wav", + "text": "但是卻出現了一個就像我剛剛前面講的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147907/26.wav", + "text": "這一個我不知道是哪裡來的機關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147907/27.wav", + "text": "但是好像在2020年的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147907/28.wav", + "text": "它出現了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147907/29.wav", + "text": "在你們的組織���程裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147907/30.wav", + "text": "有一個叫做關鍵審計議題發展委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147907/31.wav", + "text": "而且現在已經變成是一個單獨的委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147907/32.wav", + "text": "所以審計部是認為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147907/33.wav", + "text": "所以需要一個關鍵審計議題委員會是嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147907/34.wav", + "text": "有什麼特別的題目" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147907/35.wav", + "text": "我們就用這個審計議題的委員會來出題目嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147907/36.wav", + "text": "請問這個單位是在怎麼樣的狀況出現的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147907/37.wav", + "text": "謝謝委員的關心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147907/38.wav", + "text": "這個是參考美國聯邦審計署GAO 的作法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147907/39.wav", + "text": "他們都是以機關為主" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147907/40.wav", + "text": "就是像今天的議題是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147907/41.wav", + "text": "未來兩年裡面算很重要的生活成本增加" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147907/42.wav", + "text": "所以我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147907/43.wav", + "text": "所以它審計誰" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147907/44.wav", + "text": "它審計議題嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147907/45.wav", + "text": "那它看誰的預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147907/46.wav", + "text": "它是整合議題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147907/47.wav", + "text": "那它看誰的預算執行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147907/48.wav", + "text": "所以它是幕僚單位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147907/49.wav", + "text": "對它整合議題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147907/50.wav", + "text": "所以審計部需要一個幕僚單位來審計別人的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147907/51.wav", + "text": "還是審計我們立法院的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147907/52.wav", + "text": "這個是來看出" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147907/53.wav", + "text": "整個國家未來的發展趨勢以及風險趨勢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147907/54.wav", + "text": "我們就以議題為主" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147907/55.wav", + "text": "因為現在的議題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147907/56.wav", + "text": "食安牽涉到農業部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147907/57.wav", + "text": "也牽涉到衛福部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147907/58.wav", + "text": "所以這需要一個單位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147907/59.wav", + "text": "慢慢的把它整合起來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147907/60.wav", + "text": "來看一個全貌" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147907/61.wav", + "text": "可能會對國家施政會比較好一點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147907/62.wav", + "text": "所以謝謝委員的關心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147907/63.wav", + "text": "好我很關心的原因是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147907/64.wav", + "text": "我相信審計單位必須要公正客觀" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147907/65.wav", + "text": "之前我特別提出來就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147907/66.wav", + "text": "你們在網站上面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147907/67.wav", + "text": "被人家質疑從2020年到現在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147907/68.wav", + "text": "都沒有發過任何一個澄清" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147907/69.wav", + "text": "我說過了你們的審計意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147907/70.wav", + "text": "如果被扭曲了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147907/71.wav", + "text": "被帶風向了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147907/72.wav", + "text": "或是被錯誤的報導" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147907/73.wav", + "text": "你要幫自己講話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147907/74.wav", + "text": "以現在這個為例審計部說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147907/75.wav", + "text": "因為我已經有六廳" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147907/76.wav", + "text": "是以單位為意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147907/77.wav", + "text": "我現在連議題都要來審計" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147907/78.wav", + "text": "我就覺得很奇怪了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147907/79.wav", + "text": "如果是這樣的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147907/80.wav", + "text": "這是審計部原本應該要有的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147907/81.wav", + "text": "該執行的功能嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147907/82.wav", + "text": "還是只是為了審計而審計" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147907/83.wav", + "text": "然後幫這個預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147907/84.wav", + "text": "或者幫人在找" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147907/85.wav", + "text": "這是我在網站上看到的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147907/86.wav", + "text": "我現在找不到審計議題發展委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147907/87.wav", + "text": "到底在哪裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147907/88.wav", + "text": "我也找不到地方" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147907/89.wav", + "text": "但可以看得出來的是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147907/90.wav", + "text": "如果按照你們有編列的預算的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147907/91.wav", + "text": "113年度多增加了86萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147907/92.wav", + "text": "是要給學者專家出席會議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147907/93.wav", + "text": "我不知道這個審計委員會裡面的人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147907/94.wav", + "text": "是從這六廳裡面調過來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147907/95.wav", + "text": "還是要另外再找專家學者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147907/96.wav", + "text": "然後你就幫這些專家學者找錢嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147907/97.wav", + "text": "如果是這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147907/98.wav", + "text": "審計長你現在講的所有的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147907/99.wav", + "text": "在場除了經濟部財政部之外" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147907/100.wav", + "text": "還有別的部會都在這裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147907/101.wav", + "text": "你如果可以用這樣的方式回答的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147907/102.wav", + "text": "別的部會可不可以也用這個方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147907/103.wav", + "text": "這個我覺得我必須要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147907/104.wav", + "text": "站在一個民意代表的角度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147907/105.wav", + "text": "這個會期畢竟是預算會期" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147907/106.wav", + "text": "也要好好實質的來看這個預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147907/107.wav", + "text": "有沒有疊床架屋" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147907/108.wav", + "text": "審計部有沒有出現一個所謂的神祕組織" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147907/109.wav", + "text": "到底做什麼不知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147907/110.wav", + "text": "然後你說我現在就要一個議題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147907/111.wav", + "text": "要食安要薪資" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147907/112.wav", + "text": "它會變成是一個太上單位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147907/113.wav", + "text": "沒有東西它不能管" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147907/114.wav", + "text": "我覺得在這個角度上面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147907/115.wav", + "text": "真的刮別人鬍子以前要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147907/116.wav", + "text": "先把自己的鬍子刮��淨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147907/117.wav", + "text": "謝謝委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147907/118.wav", + "text": "我們會注意到這件事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147907/119.wav", + "text": "除了您來擔任主委" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147907/120.wav", + "text": "然後副主委一人之外" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147907/121.wav", + "text": "其餘的委員都是派專家學者嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147907/122.wav", + "text": "專家學者的費用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147907/123.wav", + "text": "是從這86萬來出嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147907/124.wav", + "text": "專家學者一般只有來領出席費" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147907/125.wav", + "text": "各廳廳長也會參與" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147907/126.wav", + "text": "那有必要多一個這樣的委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147907/127.wav", + "text": "然後再疊床架屋的組織底下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147907/128.wav", + "text": "因為現在在看一些問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147907/129.wav", + "text": "要客觀公正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147907/130.wav", + "text": "所以這些委員會認為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147907/131.wav", + "text": "我們這樣出來的一些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147907/132.wav", + "text": "要怎麼查要怎麼那個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147907/133.wav", + "text": "它會協助我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147907/134.wav", + "text": "因為我們審計" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147907/135.wav", + "text": "大部分的同仁" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147907/136.wav", + "text": "都是屬於會計的背景審計的背景" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147907/137.wav", + "text": "或是土木的背景" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147907/138.wav", + "text": "啦有關於這個委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147907/139.wav", + "text": "到底在做什麼事" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147907/140.wav", + "text": "然後它未來怎麼規劃" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147907/141.wav", + "text": "我希望能夠在一週內給我一個報告好嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147907/142.wav", + "text": "好謝謝委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147907/143.wav", + "text": "我們會給委員一個報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147907/144.wav", + "text": "委員好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147907/145.wav", + "text": "有關於土地的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147907/146.wav", + "text": "臺灣的土地面積很小" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147907/147.wav", + "text": "我們知道財政部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147907/148.wav", + "text": "都不斷在針對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147907/149.wav", + "text": "或者私用國有地的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147907/150.wav", + "text": "來做清收跟瞭解" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147907/151.wav", + "text": "我現在發現" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147907/152.wav", + "text": "國有地在被閒置的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147907/153.wav", + "text": "所謂的閒置國有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147907/154.wav", + "text": "非公用土地的比率" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147907/155.wav", + "text": "有逐年上升" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147907/156.wav", + "text": "但是其實不高" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147907/157.wav", + "text": "那麼這占有百分之十點九三的國有土地" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147907/158.wav", + "text": "是表示你們清查得非常好嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147907/159.wav", + "text": "越來越多的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147907/160.wav", + "text": "你們有沒有想法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147907/161.wav", + "text": "要做一個整體的規��" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147907/162.wav", + "text": "跟委員報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147907/163.wav", + "text": "我們的閒置土地的面積" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147907/164.wav", + "text": "那表示我們在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147907/165.wav", + "text": "因為我們就把占用排除了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147907/166.wav", + "text": "目前來說是一個空地的狀態" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147907/167.wav", + "text": "當然閒置土地的利用非常重要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147907/168.wav", + "text": "因為它都是屬於國家的資源" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147907/169.wav", + "text": "所以這個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147907/170.wav", + "text": "我們持續的用各種多元的方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147907/171.wav", + "text": "譬如說跟地方政府" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147907/172.wav", + "text": "或目的事業主管機關來合作開發" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147907/173.wav", + "text": "我們可能會提供給社會住宅" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147907/174.wav", + "text": "還有社福機構來做長照" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147907/175.wav", + "text": "適合開發的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147907/176.wav", + "text": "甚至可以做社宅的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147907/177.wav", + "text": "就會來跟地方政府合作" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147907/178.wav", + "text": "是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147907/179.wav", + "text": "這個方向其實非常好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147907/180.wav", + "text": "現在民間的聲音所謂居住正義" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147907/181.wav", + "text": "除了囤房稅的推動之外" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147907/182.wav", + "text": "怎麼樣增加社宅的數量" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147907/183.wav", + "text": "是非常重要的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147907/184.wav", + "text": "剛剛您提到的是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147907/185.wav", + "text": "有關跟地方政府合作" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147907/186.wav", + "text": "現在你們自己也主動" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147907/187.wav", + "text": "的不動產開發嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147907/188.wav", + "text": "這個就是社宅部分的使用嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147907/189.wav", + "text": "因為我看你們有編列了一筆" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147907/190.wav", + "text": "開發國有土地不動產" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147907/191.wav", + "text": "但是這個預算不高" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147907/192.wav", + "text": "只有900萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147907/193.wav", + "text": "所以這是一個未來的目標嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147907/194.wav", + "text": "還是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147907/195.wav", + "text": "可不可以講一下這900萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147907/196.wav", + "text": "要做怎麼樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147907/197.wav", + "text": "因為900萬感覺起來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147907/198.wav", + "text": "大概也只能規劃" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147907/199.wav", + "text": "這規劃的方向是什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147907/200.wav", + "text": "是把這些閒置的土地" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147907/201.wav", + "text": "依照各個縣市" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147907/202.wav", + "text": "比如表上所列出來的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147907/203.wav", + "text": "從臺北市六都的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147907/204.wav", + "text": "還是它" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147907/205.wav", + "text": "它只是提出一個計畫案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147907/206.wav", + "text": "因為這個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147907/207.wav", + "text": "民眾會想知道的是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147907/208.wav", + "text": "到底" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147907/209.wav", + "text": "財政部國有財產署" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147907/210.wav", + "text": "扮演的是什麼樣的角色" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147907/211.wav", + "text": "國產署在開發上的一個轉型" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147907/212.wav", + "text": "過往可能跟地方政府" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147907/213.wav", + "text": "或目的事業主管機關合作開發" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147907/214.wav", + "text": "但現在它更走向" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147907/215.wav", + "text": "自行主導開發" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147907/216.wav", + "text": "也就是把主導權" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147907/217.wav", + "text": "己這個經費" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147907/218.wav", + "text": "可能就如同上面所列的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147907/219.wav", + "text": "比如要做先期規劃" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147907/220.wav", + "text": "招商說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147907/221.wav", + "text": "等等這個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147907/222.wav", + "text": "第一個國產署會先去找出" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147907/223.wav", + "text": "適合開發的土地以後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147907/224.wav", + "text": "如果需要的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147907/225.wav", + "text": "更詳細的補充" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147907/226.wav", + "text": "我只是要強調" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147907/227.wav", + "text": "整理出來的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147907/228.wav", + "text": "至少六都加起來還有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147907/229.wav", + "text": "450公頃" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147907/230.wav", + "text": "我相信在土地利用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147907/231.wav", + "text": "土地活化或者是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147907/232.wav", + "text": "社宅的開發上面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147907/233.wav", + "text": "還是非常有遠景的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147907/234.wav", + "text": "是創造資產的價值" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147907/235.wav", + "text": "我想這是委員關心的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147907/236.wav", + "text": "謝謝委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147907/237.wav", + "text": "好謝謝各位請回" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147906/0.wav", + "text": "謝謝主席我想請部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147906/1.wav", + "text": "有請部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147906/2.wav", + "text": "陳委員好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147906/3.wav", + "text": "部長好好久不見好久沒來這裡跟部長見面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147906/4.wav", + "text": "我想請教部長因為外委的時間比較短" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147906/5.wav", + "text": "所以我就直接切入主題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147906/6.wav", + "text": "大家對於消防職安有很多的討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147906/7.wav", + "text": "但我更想討論的其實是公安的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147906/8.wav", + "text": "光是去年吊臂掉到中捷列車" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147906/9.wav", + "text": "今年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147906/10.wav", + "text": "對今年對不起我說錯了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147906/11.wav", + "text": "的施工這也是個人施工所造成的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147906/12.wav", + "text": "今年111年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147906/13.wav", + "text": "去年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147906/14.wav", + "text": "是111年但今年我們的確看到很多重大的公安事件" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147906/15.wav", + "text": "是職災的直接給付就有66.8億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147906/16.wav", + "text": "更何況還有所謂間接造成的經濟損失" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147906/17.wav", + "text": "對於職災的防範勞動部的態度是什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147906/18.wav", + "text": "都需要很大的檢討及反省" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147906/19.wav", + "text": "我不曉得勞動部在這方面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147906/20.wav", + "text": "報告委員其實我們這幾年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147906/21.wav", + "text": "我們一直覺得安全是最重要的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147906/22.wav", + "text": "預防勝於治療" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147906/23.wav", + "text": "沒有人願意發生這樣的職災" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147906/24.wav", + "text": "當然" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147906/25.wav", + "text": "職災預防的部分要更落實" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147906/26.wav", + "text": "過量囤積等等這些問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147906/27.wav", + "text": "現在院裡面由吳澤成政委" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147906/28.wav", + "text": "召集相關部會來做一些重新" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147906/29.wav", + "text": "討論不管是法令的精進各種措施" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147906/30.wav", + "text": "如何防範未然都在努力當中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147906/31.wav", + "text": "對所以剛剛部長講得非常好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147906/32.wav", + "text": "另外就是企業的課責" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147906/33.wav", + "text": "公共安全" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147906/34.wav", + "text": "一定是責無旁貸" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147906/35.wav", + "text": "所以這時候勞動部就應該" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147906/36.wav", + "text": "也就是職安衛的勞檢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147906/37.wav", + "text": "到底有沒有把這些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147906/38.wav", + "text": "應該遵守的事項都做好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147906/39.wav", + "text": "包括我們的宣導及輔導" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147906/40.wav", + "text": "我們一再去做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147906/41.wav", + "text": "非常好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147906/42.wav", + "text": "其實部長已經回答出我的答案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147906/43.wav", + "text": "職安衛人員其實是很重要的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147906/44.wav", + "text": "除了職安衛人員以外" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147906/45.wav", + "text": "其實在廠裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147906/46.wav", + "text": "是50人以上有臨場" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147906/47.wav", + "text": "所謂的職業衛生護理師" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147906/48.wav", + "text": "您剛剛提到預防的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147906/49.wav", + "text": "我們看到職業衛生護理師" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147906/50.wav", + "text": "包括疾病的早期發現" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147906/51.wav", + "text": "就去做疾病管理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147906/52.wav", + "text": "委託一個勞工健康服務效益" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147906/53.wav", + "text": "相關績效指標與執行現況評估的調查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147906/54.wav", + "text": "雖然這個調查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147906/55.wav", + "text": "現在還只有期中報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147906/56.wav", + "text": "但在這個期中報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147906/57.wav", + "text": "職護做了很多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147906/58.wav", + "text": "部長剛剛講的事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147906/59.wav", + "text": "我們是如何透過事前預防" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147906/60.wav", + "text": "rn雖然現在只有45份" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147906/61.wav", + "text": "做這麼多耶" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147906/62.wav", + "text": "在做這麼多的情況之下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147906/63.wav", + "text": "他還要去兼任職安衛人員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147906/64.wav", + "text": "人資工作總務工作" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147906/65.wav", + "text": "部長覺得這樣合理嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147906/66.wav", + "text": "值多少錢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147906/67.wav", + "text": "我們剛剛講的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147906/68.wav", + "text": "的這些事都要做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147906/69.wav", + "text": "而且一定要有相關的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147906/70.wav", + "text": "結果薪水多少錢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147906/71.wav", + "text": "周署長一直在旁邊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147906/72.wav", + "text": "提醒答案已經給我了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147906/73.wav", + "text": "我剛剛講的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147906/74.wav", + "text": "45家的調查結果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147906/75.wav", + "text": "四當然也有很好的職場" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147906/76.wav", + "text": "這還不包括後面的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147906/77.wav", + "text": "一些分紅" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147906/78.wav", + "text": "我們非常感激" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147906/79.wav", + "text": "我們有一個KOL" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147906/80.wav", + "text": "職護的薪資調查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147906/81.wav", + "text": "58%不到四萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147906/82.wav", + "text": "甚至28%不到三萬五" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147906/83.wav", + "text": "五再給部長看一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147906/84.wav", + "text": "這一個調查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147906/85.wav", + "text": "更糟糕的是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147906/86.wav", + "text": "我們這些國營官股" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147906/87.wav", + "text": "部長您看一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147906/88.wav", + "text": "根本不是用護理師來聘" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147906/89.wav", + "text": "這些國營官股" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147906/90.wav", + "text": "是評價人員服務員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147906/91.wav", + "text": "其他服務員的薪資" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147906/92.wav", + "text": "你覺得這樣合理嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147906/93.wav", + "text": "不合理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147906/94.wav", + "text": "對啊這真的很虧待我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147906/95.wav", + "text": "不用輪班" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147906/96.wav", + "text": "所以跟臨床護理師不一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147906/97.wav", + "text": "行政院一直在講的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147906/98.wav", + "text": "津貼就會造成這樣的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147906/99.wav", + "text": "護理人員必須要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147906/100.wav", + "text": "因為夜班加給以後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147906/101.wav", + "text": "的薪水才會高" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147906/102.wav", + "text": "有做一個健康勞動力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147906/103.wav", + "text": "永續領航企業的選拔" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147906/104.wav", + "text": "勞動部有沒有其他的紅蘿蔔" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147906/105.wav", + "text": "就像剛剛講的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147906/106.wav", + "text": "您調查的這45家企業" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147906/107.wav", + "text": "我們的護理人員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147906/108.wav", + "text": "勞動部可不可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147906/109.wav", + "text": "拿出一些態度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147906/110.wav", + "text": "降低災害的減災平臺" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147906/111.wav", + "text": "我透過那個平臺" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147906/112.wav", + "text": "邀請各國公營事業" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147906/113.wav", + "text": "招考的類型名稱" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147906/114.wav", + "text": "真的太過分了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147906/115.wav", + "text": "對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147906/116.wav", + "text": "非常謝謝部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147906/117.wav", + "text": "真的是非常阿莎力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147906/118.wav", + "text": "給我一個書面報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147906/119.wav", + "text": "好感謝感謝謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147905/0.wav", + "text": "有請潘部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147905/1.wav", + "text": "教育的議題非常非常多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147905/2.wav", + "text": "接下來的質詢我儘量在一個小時以內把它問完" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147905/3.wav", + "text": "我們今天對本委員的委員稍微好一點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147905/4.wav", + "text": "最近家長團體有提出說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147905/5.wav", + "text": "全國家長最關心的10大教育議題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147905/6.wav", + "text": "當然要討論的問題非常多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147905/7.wav", + "text": "我現在先來討論有關校園霸凌的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147905/8.wav", + "text": "那為什麼要討論這個問題呢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147905/9.wav", + "text": "因為教育部有霸凌防治準則" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147905/10.wav", + "text": "其在8月份的時候提出這個草案的公告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147905/11.wav", + "text": "公告以後各界都有很多意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147905/12.wav", + "text": "到現在還沒有辦法上路" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147905/13.wav", + "text": "我先來探討幾個問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147905/14.wav", + "text": "校園霸凌的通報數逐年攀升" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147905/15.wav", + "text": "連續4年都破1,000案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147905/16.wav", + "text": "但是成案比率卻大幅下降" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147905/17.wav", + "text": "到底是什麼原因" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147905/18.wav", + "text": "107年時確認的比率還有三成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147905/19.wav", + "text": "到去年只剩下11%" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147905/20.wav", + "text": "今年上半年剩下7%" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147905/21.wav", + "text": "校園霸凌為什麼難以成案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147905/22.wav", + "text": "這是我們要來探討的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147905/23.wav", + "text": "草案什麼時候可以上路" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147905/24.wav", + "text": "看起來是遙遙無期" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147905/25.wav", + "text": "不會遙遙無期" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147905/26.wav", + "text": "就明年2月112學年度第二學期" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147905/27.wav", + "text": "好這個時候一定會上路" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147905/28.wav", + "text": "一定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147905/29.wav", + "text": "一定好所以多久的時間就會上路" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147905/30.wav", + "text": "明年的2月" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147905/31.wav", + "text": "就第二個學期開始" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147905/32.wav", + "text": "好第二個學期以前一定要上路" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147905/33.wav", + "text": "那這段時間你們要去盤點一些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147905/34.wav", + "text": "大家質疑的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147905/35.wav", + "text": "包括" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147905/36.wav", + "text": "過去的定義持續性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147905/37.wav", + "text": "現在要超出一般社會通念可忍受的程度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147905/38.wav", + "text": "這樣他們才有辦法依循" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147905/39.wav", + "text": "所以你要告訴他們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147905/40.wav", + "text": "定義跟認定的方式是什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147905/41.wav", + "text": "現在問題就出在這裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147905/42.wav", + "text": "現在還有一些教育團體提出來說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147905/43.wav", + "text": "這次的草案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147905/44.wav", + "text": "減少了輔導相關條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147905/45.wav", + "text": "大部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147905/46.wav", + "text": "都是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147905/47.wav", + "text": "一些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147905/48.wav", + "text": "像法院式的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147905/49.wav", + "text": "重調查式條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147905/50.wav", + "text": "也就是說重調查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147905/51.wav", + "text": "輕輔導" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147905/52.wav", + "text": "當然你也會有不同意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147905/53.wav", + "text": "但是也值得參考" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147905/54.wav", + "text": "讓你們去盤點調整" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147905/55.wav", + "text": "各個樣態要怎麼處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147905/56.wav", + "text": "你們要去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147905/57.wav", + "text": "做一些各個樣態的模擬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147905/58.wav", + "text": "然後給各個學校參照" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147905/59.wav", + "text": "除了校園霸凌" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147905/60.wav", + "text": "校園暴力也是層出不窮" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147905/61.wav", + "text": "但是霸凌有霸凌防制準則" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147905/62.wav", + "text": "有沒有什麼法來處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147905/63.wav", + "text": "辦法注意事項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147905/64.wav", + "text": "但這是針對老師" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147905/65.wav", + "text": "了學生對老師施暴" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147905/66.wav", + "text": "那麼學生對老師施暴" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147905/67.wav", + "text": "的處理機制是什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147905/68.wav", + "text": "最近就有這樣的案例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147905/69.wav", + "text": "怎麼辦呢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147905/70.wav", + "text": "怎麼處理呢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147905/71.wav", + "text": "如何防制校園暴力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147905/72.wav", + "text": "因為這個也是全國家長團體" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147905/73.wav", + "text": "最關切的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147905/74.wav", + "text": "校園霸凌校園暴力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147905/75.wav", + "text": "校園安全毒品等這些���題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147905/76.wav", + "text": "都是家長團體最關心議題的第二位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147905/77.wav", + "text": "所以教育部責無旁貸" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147905/78.wav", + "text": "好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147905/79.wav", + "text": "有沒有處理機制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147905/80.wav", + "text": "是謝謝委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147905/81.wav", + "text": "把各界的意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147905/82.wav", + "text": "再做一個整理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147905/83.wav", + "text": "因為在執行面過去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147905/84.wav", + "text": "如果從學校自我的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147905/85.wav", + "text": "包含對於整個事件的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147905/86.wav", + "text": "處理審議過程" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147905/87.wav", + "text": "確實是有不足的地方" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147905/88.wav", + "text": "所以這次重新檢討" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147905/89.wav", + "text": "有關霸凌準則" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147905/90.wav", + "text": "但是我們一樣再收集" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147905/91.wav", + "text": "其他相關意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147905/92.wav", + "text": "目前已經做到最後的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147905/93.wav", + "text": "另外弄一個規範出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147905/94.wav", + "text": "我跟委員報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147905/95.wav", + "text": "最近可能出現的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147905/96.wav", + "text": "也是我們要去注意的議題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147905/97.wav", + "text": "很多老師確實受到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147905/98.wav", + "text": "這部分教育部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147905/99.wav", + "text": "在處理上其實我們也" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147905/100.wav", + "text": "案件" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147905/101.wav", + "text": "多數都是一些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147905/102.wav", + "text": "我們要從源頭" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147905/103.wav", + "text": "一起處理的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147905/104.wav", + "text": "很多可能都是學生情緒" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147905/105.wav", + "text": "我瞭解啦不是一個普遍性的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147905/106.wav", + "text": "還應該動不到去立一個規範" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147905/107.wav", + "text": "對但是這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147905/108.wav", + "text": "我們也會提出一套作法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147905/109.wav", + "text": "好感謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147905/110.wav", + "text": "請吳林輝司長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147905/111.wav", + "text": "還有技職司" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147905/112.wav", + "text": "楊玉惠司長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147905/113.wav", + "text": "我們來探討一下技職教育的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147905/114.wav", + "text": "根據預算中心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147905/115.wav", + "text": "提出來的數字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147905/116.wav", + "text": "大專院校高級中等學校" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147905/117.wav", + "text": "學生數全面性的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147905/118.wav", + "text": "下降" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147905/119.wav", + "text": "但是下降比率最高的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147905/120.wav", + "text": "還是技職體系的學生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147905/121.wav", + "text": "大專技職體系學生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147905/122.wav", + "text": "下降了23%" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147905/123.wav", + "text": "然後大專院校學生人數" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147905/124.wav", + "text": "下降15%" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147905/125.wav", + "text": "高中就更嚴重了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147905/126.wav", + "text": "高中學生人數下降了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147905/127.wav", + "text": "34%可是高" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147905/128.wav", + "text": "職學生的占比高達" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147905/129.wav", + "text": "45%" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147905/130.wav", + "text": "整個國家在培育技職人才的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147905/131.wav", + "text": "少子化" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147905/132.wav", + "text": "產業需求的人力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147905/133.wav", + "text": "現在一定是匱乏的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147905/134.wav", + "text": "好除了少子化這個原因之外" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147905/135.wav", + "text": "其實還有很大的原因" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147905/136.wav", + "text": "很多專家大概也都已經點出這個問題了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147905/137.wav", + "text": "──技職生學術化" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147905/138.wav", + "text": "可是我還是想辦法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147905/139.wav", + "text": "升學之後技職不見了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147905/140.wav", + "text": "而想辦法追求學術" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147905/141.wav", + "text": "根據人力銀行的調查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147905/142.wav", + "text": "全臺灣的職缺總數" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147905/143.wav", + "text": "在今年10月的時候有108萬個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147905/144.wav", + "text": "其中有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147905/145.wav", + "text": "四分之三的職缺屬於技職類" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147905/146.wav", + "text": "然後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147905/147.wav", + "text": "屬於專業" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147905/148.wav", + "text": "群科的高中生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147905/149.wav", + "text": "有將近87%畢業後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147905/150.wav", + "text": "選擇進入一般大學" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147905/151.wav", + "text": "司楊司長其實這個問題我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147905/152.wav", + "text": "已經探討好多年了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147905/153.wav", + "text": "技職司其實也非常非常努力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147905/154.wav", + "text": "可是怎麼辦呢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147905/155.wav", + "text": "也就是說技職學生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147905/156.wav", + "text": "的比率大幅" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147905/157.wav", + "text": "下降造成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147905/158.wav", + "text": "各個產業缺工問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147905/159.wav", + "text": "非常非常嚴重" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147905/160.wav", + "text": "現在都找不到工" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147905/161.wav", + "text": "想要引進外籍移工" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147905/162.wav", + "text": "那就更困難了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147905/163.wav", + "text": "也是另外一個問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147905/164.wav", + "text": "技職司可能要針對最近" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147905/165.wav", + "text": "這些探討提出一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147905/166.wav", + "text": "挽救臺灣技職教育" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147905/167.wav", + "text": "想辦法留住臺灣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147905/168.wav", + "text": "技職人才幫忙產業找出路" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147905/169.wav", + "text": "的相關白皮書" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147905/170.wav", + "text": "這一定要的嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147905/171.wav", + "text": "好像這次選舉也有很多候選人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147905/172.wav", + "text": "提出相關說法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147905/173.wav", + "text": "但他們不會比楊司長內行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147905/174.wav", + "text": "一定要為了挽救技職生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147905/175.wav", + "text": "我跟委員打岔一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147905/176.wav", + "text": "我看了以後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147905/177.wav", + "text": "也發現這個議題裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147905/178.wav", + "text": "可能有些數字誤解了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147905/179.wav", + "text": "我們技高的學生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147905/180.wav", + "text": "升學到科大" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147905/181.wav", + "text": "的比重是高的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147905/182.wav", + "text": "提到說87%" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147905/183.wav", + "text": "一般大學不是這個比" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147905/184.wav", + "text": "怎麼可能" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147905/185.wav", + "text": "而且這幾年還逐年下降" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147905/186.wav", + "text": "現在這部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147905/187.wav", + "text": "有去報考分發大概是400多位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147905/188.wav", + "text": "而且從110到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147905/189.wav", + "text": "112年最新的數字是降下來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147905/190.wav", + "text": "這個你們澄清一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147905/191.wav", + "text": "但是臺灣技職教育" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147905/192.wav", + "text": "以及協助臺灣技職人才" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147905/193.wav", + "text": "為產業所需" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147905/194.wav", + "text": "我跟委員補充一點就好了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147905/195.wav", + "text": "現在我們檢討過去產學" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147905/196.wav", + "text": "一定要講一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147905/197.wav", + "text": "現在技高到科大的合作" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147905/198.wav", + "text": "案子是過去的3倍" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147905/199.wav", + "text": "我們也希望對接到產業的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147905/200.wav", + "text": "這個案子我們會持續再延伸" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147905/201.wav", + "text": "感謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147905/202.wav", + "text": "感謝部長感謝司長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147905/203.wav", + "text": "\n好國教署講完技職教育" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147905/204.wav", + "text": "我們來談準公共幼兒園" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147905/205.wav", + "text": "的教保員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147905/206.wav", + "text": "我想問一下什麼時候可以調薪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147905/207.wav", + "text": "今年有調1,000元" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147905/208.wav", + "text": "可是調1,000元他們的起薪也只有3萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147905/209.wav", + "text": "元比非營利幼兒園的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147905/210.wav", + "text": "少了非常非常多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147905/211.wav", + "text": "臺灣明年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147905/212.wav", + "text": "1月的基本工資是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147905/213.wav", + "text": "27,470元" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147905/214.wav", + "text": "可是經過專業訓練" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147905/215.wav", + "text": "取得證照的準公共" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147905/216.wav", + "text": "教保員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147905/217.wav", + "text": "才3萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147905/218.wav", + "text": "講了2年了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147905/219.wav", + "text": "在這個地方也大概來了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147905/220.wav", + "text": "30個立法委員倡議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147905/221.wav", + "text": "教育部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147905/222.wav", + "text": "沒有任何回應" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147905/223.wav", + "text": "合理嗎你來看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147905/224.wav", + "text": "非營利幼兒園這個也是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147905/225.wav", + "text": "教育部的單位起" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147905/226.wav", + "text": "起薪就3萬8" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147905/227.wav", + "text": "社政單位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147905/228.wav", + "text": "部分衛福部的公共化托育人員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147905/229.wav", + "text": "起薪是3萬5" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147905/230.wav", + "text": "遠遠大過於準公共幼兒園" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147905/231.wav", + "text": "教保員的起薪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147905/232.wav", + "text": "如果我們這個部分不調薪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147905/233.wav", + "text": "造成的結果就是這些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147905/234.wav", + "text": "經過專業訓練有證照的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147905/235.wav", + "text": "準公共的教保員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147905/236.wav", + "text": "不然你叫他們要如何以3萬塊錢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147905/237.wav", + "text": "繼續在這裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147905/238.wav", + "text": "工作如果有機會他們一定跑到非營利去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147905/239.wav", + "text": "跑到公共化托育啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147905/240.wav", + "text": "一定是這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147905/241.wav", + "text": "因為他們工作內容幾乎都一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147905/242.wav", + "text": "他們受到的專業" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147905/243.wav", + "text": "訓練也都一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147905/244.wav", + "text": "但是我們國家卻用這樣的制度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147905/245.wav", + "text": "讓他們受到同樣教育" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147905/246.wav", + "text": "同樣訓練取得同樣證照" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147905/247.wav", + "text": "卻在不同的國家體系" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147905/248.wav", + "text": "可以領到不同的酬勞" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147905/249.wav", + "text": "我想請問一下署長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147905/250.wav", + "text": "如果是你兒子他會在準公共幼兒園" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147905/251.wav", + "text": "當教保員嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147905/252.wav", + "text": "還是他會跑到非營利幼兒園" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147905/253.wav", + "text": "去當教保員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147905/254.wav", + "text": "這是個太清楚的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147905/255.wav", + "text": "這個問題如果不處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147905/256.wav", + "text": "教育部不處理也沒有關係" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147905/257.wav", + "text": "但是會造成什麼呢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147905/258.wav", + "text": "推動的準公共幼兒園" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147905/259.wav", + "text": "現場就會出現" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147905/260.wav", + "text": "這些老師的流動率非常高" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147905/261.wav", + "text": "因為留不住這些教保員啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147905/262.wav", + "text": "怎麼辦呢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147905/263.wav", + "text": "調整薪資" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147905/264.wav", + "text": "是一個起碼要做的事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147905/265.wav", + "text": "可是教育部沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147905/266.wav", + "text": "任何回應到目前為止" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147905/267.wav", + "text": "找了非常多的理由" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147905/268.wav", + "text": "我點出這個問題其實你們也回應" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147905/269.wav", + "text": "很久了我今天也不想" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147905/270.wav", + "text": "占用時間讓你們回答" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147905/271.wav", + "text": "這個問題很嚴重拜託" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147905/272.wav", + "text": "一定要去處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147905/273.wav", + "text": "顯然不合理嘛怎麼會3萬塊錢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147905/274.wav", + "text": "怎麼會準公共" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147905/275.wav", + "text": "園教保員的薪資只有3萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147905/276.wav", + "text": "我們剛剛講到青年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147905/277.wav", + "text": "的問題過去處理的青年儲蓄帳戶" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147905/278.wav", + "text": "本來到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147905/279.wav", + "text": "111年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147905/280.wav", + "text": "後來想要再延長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147905/281.wav", + "text": "因為過去看起來並沒有完全成功" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147905/282.wav", + "text": "現在要到114年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147905/283.wav", + "text": "這一段時間有沒有新的做法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147905/284.wav", + "text": "不然的話到114年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147905/285.wav", + "text": "這個政策還是不會成功啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147905/286.wav", + "text": "怎麼處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147905/287.wav", + "text": "我跟委員報告一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147905/288.wav", + "text": "剛才委員談到準公共幼兒園" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147905/289.wav", + "text": "因為它的基本屬性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147905/290.wav", + "text": "還是私立的性質" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147905/291.wav", + "text": "公立幼兒園確實有差別" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147905/292.wav", + "text": "公和私的薪資待遇" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147905/293.wav", + "text": "不太可能用一個政府" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147905/294.wav", + "text": "統一規範" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147905/295.wav", + "text": "但是在後續明年開始啟動的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147905/296.wav", + "text": "第三期" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147905/297.wav", + "text": "我想這部分我們會加以檢討" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147905/298.wav", + "text": "委員提到這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147905/299.wav", + "text": "部分因為前面我談到產學" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147905/300.wav", + "text": "攜手2.0的計畫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147905/301.wav", + "text": "其實過去有不少學生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147905/302.wav", + "text": "有點像是做產學的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147905/303.wav", + "text": "但是他選了這個方案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147905/304.wav", + "text": "在產學攜手2.0後我們希望把它釐清" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147905/305.wav", + "text": "這個方案其實是針對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147905/306.wav", + "text": "參與者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147905/307.wav", + "text": "事實上減少的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147905/308.wav", + "text": "他已經清楚了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147905/309.wav", + "text": "所以人數是往那邊移動" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147905/310.wav", + "text": "這一部分我們會在執行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147905/311.wav", + "text": "因為這項計畫要執行到114年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147905/312.wav", + "text": "所以你們大概還有兩年的時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147905/313.wav", + "text": "努力因為退出的人數是每一年在增加" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147905/314.wav", + "text": "因為我們希望吸納的不是產學" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147905/315.wav", + "text": "攜手的學生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147905/316.wav", + "text": "他已經很清楚了沒有必要去走這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147905/317.wav", + "text": "瞭解\n講到青年的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147905/318.wav", + "text": "這個署的預算非常少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147905/319.wav", + "text": "當然也不曉得應該做什麼樣的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147905/320.wav", + "text": "執掌" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147905/321.wav", + "text": "業務去協助青年的發展和規劃" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147905/322.wav", + "text": "我剛剛所講的儲蓄專案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147905/323.wav", + "text": "然後去壯遊遊學" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147905/324.wav", + "text": "但是這些對青年整體發展" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147905/325.wav", + "text": "的幫助是有限的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147905/326.wav", + "text": "竟然會變成選舉的議題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147905/327.wav", + "text": "當然有人提出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147905/328.wav", + "text": "是不是應該推動青年基本法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147905/329.wav", + "text": "有人主張" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147905/330.wav", + "text": "要把青年署" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147905/331.wav", + "text": "移撥到國發會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147905/332.wav", + "text": "我想請問一下教育部的立場你同意把青年署" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147905/333.wav", + "text": "署移撥到國發會嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147905/334.wav", + "text": "跟委員報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147905/335.wav", + "text": "因為青年署確實可以在它的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147905/336.wav", + "text": "目標功能各方面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147905/337.wav", + "text": "往這個方向在做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147905/338.wav", + "text": "尤其是現在青年署" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147905/339.wav", + "text": "除了剛才委員所提到的這幾個項目" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147905/340.wav", + "text": "其實還承載一個跟教育" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147905/341.wav", + "text": "關連性非常高的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147905/342.wav", + "text": "就是國中畢業未升學未就業" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147905/343.wav", + "text": "的部分陳署長上任之後已經從過去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147905/344.wav", + "text": "服務三百零多個人現在已經到三千多個人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147905/345.wav", + "text": "我想在這個方向上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147905/346.wav", + "text": "應該是持續來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147905/347.wav", + "text": "將青年署的功能發揮" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147905/348.wav", + "text": "我當然捨不得青年署移撥到國發會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147905/349.wav", + "text": "不要讓青年署變成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147905/350.wav", + "text": "食之無味棄之可惜的單位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147904/0.wav", + "text": "謝謝主席" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147904/1.wav", + "text": "我現在先談一下公務人員協會的這個修法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147904/2.wav", + "text": "啦我們對於聯合國公民和政治權利國際公約" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147904/3.wav", + "text": "它已經內國法化了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147904/4.wav", + "text": "其實已明定我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147904/5.wav", + "text": "包括為保障其" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147904/6.wav", + "text": "本身利益而組織及加入工會之權利" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147904/7.wav", + "text": "並不禁止對軍警人員行使此種權利加以合法限制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147904/8.wav", + "text": "我們其實已經內國法化了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147904/9.wav", + "text": "以後但是我來看這個修法裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147904/10.wav", + "text": "秘書長你知道我們教師也可以組工會吧" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147904/11.wav", + "text": "是我知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147904/12.wav", + "text": "當時教師組工會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147904/13.wav", + "text": "本來政府的態度也是相當地強硬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147904/14.wav", + "text": "為什麼會同意呢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147904/15.wav", + "text": "我印象中是在馬總統時代" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147904/16.wav", + "text": "那個討論過程細節" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147904/17.wav", + "text": "我沒有很瞭解" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147904/18.wav", + "text": "對當時為什麼不是修在公務人員協會法裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147904/19.wav", + "text": "因為教育人員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147904/20.wav", + "text": "不是抱歉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147904/21.wav", + "text": "對它是直接在工會法裡面就放寬了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147904/22.wav", + "text": "教師得依本法組織及加入工會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147904/23.wav", + "text": "那勞工團結權" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147904/24.wav", + "text": "修法的理由有講到─" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147904/25.wav", + "text": "對提升勞動條件的確保是至為重要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147904/26.wav", + "text": "它也是參照經濟社會文化權利國際公約" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147904/27.wav", + "text": "還有公民與政治權利國際公約" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147904/28.wav", + "text": "都內國法化了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147904/29.wav", + "text": "也參照ILO第八十七號公約的精神" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147904/30.wav", + "text": "所以就這樣子修法放進去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147904/31.wav", + "text": "\n教師的團結權" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147904/32.wav", + "text": "它上面有寫說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147904/33.wav", + "text": "與一般勞工同受保障" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147904/34.wav", + "text": "但僅於這個工會組織型態" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147904/35.wav", + "text": "考量其特殊性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147904/36.wav", + "text": "修正條文第6條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147904/37.wav", + "text": "另予限制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147904/38.wav", + "text": "原為第3項規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147904/39.wav", + "text": "就是說大概限制他們不得罷工" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147904/40.wav", + "text": "啦所以顯然就是結" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147904/41.wav", + "text": "議題你們是說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147904/42.wav", + "text": "法那我有一點好奇看一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147904/43.wav", + "text": "修法版本第23條講說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147904/44.wav", + "text": "公務人員協會以會員或會員代表大會為最高機關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147904/45.wav", + "text": "其中第2項講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147904/46.wav", + "text": "下列事項應經會員或會員代表大會的議決" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147904/47.wav", + "text": "他們的會員大會可以提出協商事項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147904/48.wav", + "text": "可是協商機制在哪裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147904/49.wav", + "text": "你們說他們可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147904/50.wav", + "text": "在協會裡面行使團結權" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147904/51.wav", + "text": "跟你們一起行使" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147904/52.wav", + "text": "第一個就是結社團結權" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147904/53.wav", + "text": "接下來就要有協商權" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147904/54.wav", + "text": "一般勞工協商不成的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147904/55.wav", + "text": "當然還有爭議權可以罷工" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147904/56.wav", + "text": "我們不討論你們的團結權門檻有多高" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147904/57.wav", + "text": "雖然想要組工會的消防人員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147904/58.wav", + "text": "認為門檻非常高" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147904/59.wav", + "text": "但是你說在公務人員協會法裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147904/60.wav", + "text": "修法就可以讓他們有團結權" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147904/61.wav", + "text": "要落實到能夠協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147904/62.wav", + "text": "啊可是他的協商機制在哪裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147904/63.wav", + "text": "哪裡有規範到協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147904/64.wav", + "text": "協會法裡面有這個機制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147904/65.wav", + "text": "哪裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147904/66.wav", + "text": "哪裡有講到協商這樣的字眼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147904/67.wav", + "text": "第7條規定公務人員協會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147904/68.wav", + "text": "對於下列事項可以提出協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147904/69.wav", + "text": "我們這次也增加了很多協商項目" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147904/70.wav", + "text": "可以協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147904/71.wav", + "text": "而且過去就已經有協商的例子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147904/72.wav", + "text": "協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147904/73.wav", + "text": "工作簡化" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147904/74.wav", + "text": "績效評核" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147904/75.wav", + "text": "訓練進修" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147904/76.wav", + "text": "原來有協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147904/77.wav", + "text": "爭議裁決是不同層次的機制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147904/78.wav", + "text": "但是如果去查整本法律" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147904/79.wav", + "text": "看得到那個程序" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147904/80.wav", + "text": "我看你們的這個版本就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147904/81.wav", + "text": "舊法新法的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147904/82.wav", + "text": "因為它是部分條文修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147904/83.wav", + "text": "所以沒有把全部的條文都列出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147904/84.wav", + "text": "協商事項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147904/85.wav", + "text": "我這裡有版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147904/86.wav", + "text": "我現在唸的就是你們新的版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147904/87.wav", + "text": "業務績效評核基準" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147904/88.wav", + "text": "第6款訓練及進修" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147904/89.wav", + "text": "第7款員工身心健康協助" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147904/90.wav", + "text": "第8款非全國一致性規定的福利措施" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147904/91.wav", + "text": "對你是講這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147904/92.wav", + "text": "但是對消防人員來講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147904/93.wav", + "text": "委員你關心的程序" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147904/94.wav", + "text": "應該是協會法第28條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147904/95.wav", + "text": "有說公務人員協會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147904/96.wav", + "text": "依照第7條提出協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147904/97.wav", + "text": "應就協商事項之性質" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147904/98.wav", + "text": "向各該事項主管機關提出" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147904/99.wav", + "text": "這個就在後面的第29條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147904/100.wav", + "text": "第3條這些條文裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147904/101.wav", + "text": "到第31條就有規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147904/102.wav", + "text": "如果協商不成就進入調解程序" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147904/103.wav", + "text": "所以第32條後面又有調解的規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147904/104.wav", + "text": "後面還有爭議裁決" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147904/105.wav", + "text": "對我現在講的是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147904/106.wav", + "text": "消防人員為什麼要組工會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147904/107.wav", + "text": "而不是使用你們這個機制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147904/108.wav", + "text": "消促會的秘書長說的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147904/109.wav", + "text": "我們想要的是跟行政機關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147904/110.wav", + "text": "對等協商的權利" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147904/111.wav", + "text": "他們想要談的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147904/112.wav", + "text": "不是你們開放的這些項目" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147904/113.wav", + "text": "工作簡化業績績效而已" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147904/114.wav", + "text": "他們要爭取的是人力配置" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147904/115.wav", + "text": "裝備等問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147904/116.wav", + "text": "還有檢討救災現場相關的核心因素" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147904/117.wav", + "text": "可是你們現在修法講的是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147904/118.wav", + "text": "員工身心健康協助" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147904/119.wav", + "text": "福利措施訓練進修" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147904/120.wav", + "text": "這當然也很重要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147904/121.wav", + "text": "更核心的是我剛剛講的那些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147904/122.wav", + "text": "去爭取權利的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147904/123.wav", + "text": "經常被各縣市首長及消防署問到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147904/124.wav", + "text": "你憑什麼代表全臺灣的消防員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147904/125.wav", + "text": "二級機關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147904/126.wav", + "text": "他們可以有團結權" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147904/127.wav", + "text": "門檻要800人400人以上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147904/128.wav", + "text": "相對於我們一般組工會是30人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147904/129.wav", + "text": "你們是要求400人800人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147904/130.wav", + "text": "這樣的門檻" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147904/131.wav", + "text": "跟委員報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147904/132.wav", + "text": "因為協會法的設計是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147904/133.wav", + "text": "協會成立以後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147904/134.wav", + "text": "有法定的參與權跟協商地位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147904/135.wav", + "text": "所以它的代表性要稍微高一點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147904/136.wav", + "text": "我們當然也考慮到過去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147904/137.wav", + "text": "依協會法不容易組成是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147904/138.wav", + "text": "對你把800變成400" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147904/139.wav", + "text": "然後再降到200" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147904/140.wav", + "text": "但是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147904/141.wav", + "text": "還有一個總員額五分之一" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147904/142.wav", + "text": "但是我問你" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147904/143.wav", + "text": "組工會有這麼高的門檻嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147904/144.wav", + "text": "他用工會法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147904/145.wav", + "text": "我們就是30人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147904/146.wav", + "text": "教師組工會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147904/147.wav", + "text": "但工會沒有法定的參與權" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147904/148.wav", + "text": "跟協商地位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147904/149.wav", + "text": "因為工會要有團體協約的協商地位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147904/150.wav", + "text": "還是需要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147904/151.wav", + "text": "二分之一以上的員工" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147904/152.wav", + "text": "他們還有勞資會議這個機制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147904/153.wav", + "text": "勞資會議是至少3個月必須開一次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147904/154.wav", + "text": "第一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147904/155.wav", + "text": "第二個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147904/156.wav", + "text": "團體協約法裡面講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147904/157.wav", + "text": "這個發動權不是說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147904/158.wav", + "text": "行政機關要開" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147904/159.wav", + "text": "他可以自己發動" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147904/160.wav", + "text": "勞資雙方都可以發動" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147904/161.wav", + "text": "然後雙方都必須進入協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147904/162.wav", + "text": "是強制協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147904/163.wav", + "text": "都要提出對應方案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147904/164.wav", + "text": "而且如果協商不成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147904/165.wav", + "text": "當然還有爭議權" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147904/166.wav", + "text": "講的好像" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147904/167.wav", + "text": "你們的門檻" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147904/168.wav", + "text": "人家也講得很清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147904/169.wav", + "text": "這個門檻對他們來講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147904/170.wav", + "text": "簡直是達不到的羞辱式修法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147904/171.wav", + "text": "他們的想法是這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147904/172.wav", + "text": "消防員工作權益促進會的講法是說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147904/173.wav", + "text": "簡直是擴大團結" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147904/174.wav", + "text": "委員這是個誤會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147904/175.wav", + "text": "雖然你們增加項目" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147904/176.wav", + "text": "但是主管機關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147904/177.wav", + "text": "還是握有最終的裁示" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147904/178.wav", + "text": "能決定是否要納入協商範圍" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147904/179.wav", + "text": "所以他們還是認為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147904/180.wav", + "text": "這個有協商等於沒有協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147904/181.wav", + "text": "當然他們還想要有爭議權" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147904/182.wav", + "text": "至於爭議權" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147904/183.wav", + "text": "要不要擱置" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147904/184.wav", + "text": "或者要不要給予" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147904/185.wav", + "text": "如果是教師工會的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147904/186.wav", + "text": "當然是先擱置下來了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147904/187.wav", + "text": "光是講團結權" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147904/188.wav", + "text": "結社權" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147904/189.wav", + "text": "門檻就設定這麼高" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147904/190.wav", + "text": "而且只有團結權沒有給他" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147904/191.wav", + "text": "協商就是要尊嚴" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147904/192.wav", + "text": "如果最後都要等雇" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147904/193.wav", + "text": "主管機關握有最終的裁示權的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147904/194.wav", + "text": "跟委員說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147904/195.wav", + "text": "有關於門檻的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147904/196.wav", + "text": "雖然我們規定二級機關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147904/197.wav", + "text": "跟三級機關有一定的人數" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147904/198.wav", + "text": "但還有一個是編制員額的五分之一" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147904/199.wav", + "text": "的編制員額少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147904/200.wav", + "text": "其實五分之一就不到30個人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147904/201.wav", + "text": "但是我們規定最少要30個人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147904/202.wav", + "text": "所以有58個機關是30個人就可以成立" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147904/203.wav", + "text": "沒關係這個都是你的講法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147904/204.wav", + "text": "我現在問秘書長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147904/205.wav", + "text": "你支不支持他們有團結權" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147904/206.wav", + "text": "協會法就是團結權的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147904/207.wav", + "text": "可是人家講這是一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147904/208.wav", + "text": "門檻高到達不到的團結權" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147904/209.wav", + "text": "其實消防員同仁全國有一萬多人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147904/210.wav", + "text": "可是有一些如果要跟地方政府" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147904/211.wav", + "text": "他還是可以跟地方政府協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147904/212.wav", + "text": "但是他的門檻就是比一般的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147904/213.wav", + "text": "還要高很有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147904/214.wav", + "text": "團結權" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147904/215.wav", + "text": "有實質能夠對等的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147904/216.wav", + "text": "如果你給他一個團結權" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147904/217.wav", + "text": "可是沒有權利平等關係的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147904/218.wav", + "text": "調解就有調解委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147904/219.wav", + "text": "調解上面是爭議裁決" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147904/220.wav", + "text": "爭議裁決也有爭議裁決" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147904/221.wav", + "text": "最終還是由主管機關裁決" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147904/222.wav", + "text": "不是那一個主管機關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147904/223.wav", + "text": "爭議裁決的委員是行政機關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147904/224.wav", + "text": "沒有錯" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147904/225.wav", + "text": "是啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147904/226.wav", + "text": "但是我們在勞雇關係裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147904/227.wav", + "text": "資方雇主的另一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147904/228.wav", + "text": "資方代表來裁決" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147904/229.wav", + "text": "因為是私部門的勞資在協調" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147904/230.wav", + "text": "最後就會回到政府的機制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147904/231.wav", + "text": "但是不可避免最後要協調" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147904/232.wav", + "text": "爭議裁決還是用政府的機制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147904/233.wav", + "text": "因為沒有更上位的層次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147904/234.wav", + "text": "委員剛剛講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147904/235.wav", + "text": "他們想要討論一些議題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147904/236.wav", + "text": "這個協商權之外也有建議權" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147904/237.wav", + "text": "研修過程的參與" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147904/238.wav", + "text": "現在我的意思是說它" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147904/239.wav", + "text": "它們其實都是類似" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147904/240.wav", + "text": "建議權而不是協商權" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147904/241.wav", + "text": "也有協商權" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147904/242.wav", + "text": "就是他們的協商權也像建議權" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147904/243.wav", + "text": "這個建議權第一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147904/244.wav", + "text": "可以提出來討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147904/245.wav", + "text": "但理論上還是建議的屬性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147904/246.wav", + "text": "特別你們在建議的屬性裡面都是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147904/247.wav", + "text": "資方發動的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147904/248.wav", + "text": "我要開會我必須要通知你" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147904/249.wav", + "text": "然後你可以建議什麼東西" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147904/250.wav", + "text": "是得建議什麼東西" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147904/251.wav", + "text": "這樣子而已" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147904/252.wav", + "text": "看你們就是覺得會不會擔心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147904/253.wav", + "text": "公務人員協會參與太多決定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147904/254.wav", + "text": "效率" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147904/255.wav", + "text": "或你們認為在行政上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147904/256.wav", + "text": "會讓你們有窒" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147904/257.wav", + "text": "窒礙難行之處" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147904/258.wav", + "text": "會花很多心力在這裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147904/259.wav", + "text": "我們可以看看其他國家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147904/260.wav", + "text": "你們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147904/261.wav", + "text": "這樣子看起來好像要開放" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147904/262.wav", + "text": "他們組工會可是事實上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147904/263.wav", + "text": "他們協同參與的功能" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147904/264.wav", + "text": "幾乎都剝奪掉了變成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147904/265.wav", + "text": "形式上的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147904/266.wav", + "text": "\n以德國來講德國的公職" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147904/267.wav", + "text": "組織代表性原則有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147904/268.wav", + "text": "以各自選舉程序選出相當" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147904/269.wav", + "text": "人數的代表組成針對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147904/270.wav", + "text": "不同身分的成員有不同的參與" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147904/271.wav", + "text": "雖然不是工會也沒有罷工權" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147904/272.wav", + "text": "所有的公職人員要共同參與" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147904/273.wav", + "text": "的公務人員當然完" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147904/274.wav", + "text": "義務你一直在講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147904/275.wav", + "text": "我們有協商權請求權" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147904/276.wav", + "text": "可是你們的機關或" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147904/277.wav", + "text": "首長不願意或不積極回應" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147904/278.wav", + "text": "的協商機制的協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147904/279.wav", + "text": "代表事實上也是沒辦法的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147904/280.wav", + "text": "所以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147904/281.wav", + "text": "在這種狀況下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147904/282.wav", + "text": "他們不接受這樣的修法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147904/283.wav", + "text": "然後放在這種架構裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147904/284.wav", + "text": "我想補充兩點第一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147904/285.wav", + "text": "我要問的是你們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147904/286.wav", + "text": "要在這個會期就馬上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147904/287.wav", + "text": "通過公務人員協會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147904/288.wav", + "text": "法的修正嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147904/289.wav", + "text": "我們的想法是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147904/290.wav", + "text": "要不要通過當然是尊重立法院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147904/291.wav", + "text": "的討論但是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147904/292.wav", + "text": "修協會法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147904/293.wav", + "text": "我們也不是這一次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147904/294.wav", + "text": "才突然匆匆提出事實上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147904/295.wav", + "text": "也醞釀了一段時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147904/296.wav", + "text": "因為人家也訴求很久了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147904/297.wav", + "text": "對事實上他們也反映過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147904/298.wav", + "text": "因為沒有自己專屬的協會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147904/299.wav", + "text": "所以沒有辦法反映他們特定的需求" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147904/300.wav", + "text": "對現在的協會運作以及整個成立的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147904/301.wav", + "text": "協會法修法的理由希望讓它的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147904/302.wav", + "text": "成立更容易門檻更下降" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147904/303.wav", + "text": "然後它的功能可以更擴大" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147904/304.wav", + "text": "所以這次所有的條文基本上都是朝向" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147904/305.wav", + "text": "放寬降低門檻這樣的方向" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147904/306.wav", + "text": "但是他們說你的降低門檻根本沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147904/307.wav", + "text": "都是言不及義" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147904/308.wav", + "text": "爭議裁決委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147904/309.wav", + "text": "還是行政" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147904/310.wav", + "text": "說了算也就是你們的主管" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147904/311.wav", + "text": "機關說了算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147904/312.wav", + "text": "銓敘部保訓會和人總" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147904/313.wav", + "text": "各有1位代表但是雙方" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147904/314.wav", + "text": "都可以各自推派" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147904/315.wav", + "text": "2位另外還有隨機" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147904/316.wav", + "text": "學者專家或者是原來的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147904/317.wav", + "text": "名單中再去抽所以它" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147904/318.wav", + "text": "那個主管機關而" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147904/319.wav", + "text": "而是超然的主管機關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147904/320.wav", + "text": "協會的人只有2個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147904/321.wav", + "text": "其他全部都是行政" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147904/322.wav", + "text": "主管機關這裡面當然包含" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147904/323.wav", + "text": "你們聘僱的2個學者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147904/324.wav", + "text": "那如果2個都是抽到他們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147904/325.wav", + "text": "因為雙方各自" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147904/326.wav", + "text": "還是那個裁決委員會基本上它要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147904/327.wav", + "text": "行使它的職權就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147904/328.wav", + "text": "要單獨來判斷" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147904/329.wav", + "text": "爭議到底要如何處理是比較適當" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147904/330.wav", + "text": "的這個不是我們銓敘部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147904/331.wav", + "text": "去主導的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147904/332.wav", + "text": "提案這個建議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147904/333.wav", + "text": "是不是未來在修法的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147904/334.wav", + "text": "好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147904/335.wav", + "text": "現在你講的是修法但是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147904/336.wav", + "text": "促進會是希望不要在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147904/337.wav", + "text": "這個架構裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147904/338.wav", + "text": "希望不要放在這個架構裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147904/339.wav", + "text": "他們不希望放在這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147904/340.wav", + "text": "架構裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147904/341.wav", + "text": "或者是這個架構其實要講的更" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147904/342.wav", + "text": "能夠有對等尊嚴的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147904/343.wav", + "text": "協商如果你擱置" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147904/344.wav", + "text": "這個爭議權的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147904/345.wav", + "text": "行政部門也都很擔心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147904/346.wav", + "text": "的人參與度越高" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147904/347.wav", + "text": "對行政來講更不方便" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147904/348.wav", + "text": "他們當然也是這樣子一路走來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147904/349.wav", + "text": "始終是這樣子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147904/350.wav", + "text": "瞭解所以這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147904/351.wav", + "text": "可能還要一段時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147904/352.wav", + "text": "我希望各機關能重視" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147904/353.wav", + "text": "協會的成立" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147904/354.wav", + "text": "有這樣的管道跟機制的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147904/355.wav", + "text": "最後還是會有權益促進會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147904/356.wav", + "text": "一直來對話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147904/357.wav", + "text": "我記得當時教師要組工會的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147904/358.wav", + "text": "大家也是想很多也是擔心很多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147904/359.wav", + "text": "結果它就直接通過了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147904/360.wav", + "text": "其實也沒發生什麼事" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147904/361.wav", + "text": "事或教師為了權益為了協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147904/362.wav", + "text": "而杯葛了什麼或影響了什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147904/363.wav", + "text": "好像也沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147904/364.wav", + "text": "贊成的只是在法制面上到底要怎麼來促成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147904/365.wav", + "text": "心理建設要有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147904/366.wav", + "text": "他們會更大幅度的參與到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147904/367.wav", + "text": "行政管理上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147904/368.wav", + "text": "人事上有干預" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147904/369.wav", + "text": "你的建議他們應該都聽到了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147904/370.wav", + "text": "好啦我知道啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147904/371.wav", + "text": "沒有人要質詢了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147904/372.wav", + "text": "這麼久也沒人來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147904/373.wav", + "text": "你剛剛說林德福" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147904/374.wav", + "text": "質詢完要休息" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147904/375.wav", + "text": "林德福又沒有來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147904/376.wav", + "text": "他先離開了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147904/377.wav", + "text": "謝謝林淑芬委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147903/0.wav", + "text": "首先我想要請教因為今年度雞蛋問題吵得沸沸揚揚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147903/1.wav", + "text": "那我想要問一下因為現在慢慢進入到秋冬了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147903/2.wav", + "text": "雞蛋的供需狀況目前怎麼樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147903/3.wav", + "text": "我想跟委員說明雞蛋我們從3月開始" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147903/4.wav", + "text": "所以現在的雞蛋供應量已經逐漸回穩到過往的一個水平" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147903/5.wav", + "text": "新母雞有進來達到了3,400萬隻" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147903/6.wav", + "text": "現在每天的供蛋量可以到2,400萬顆" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147903/7.wav", + "text": "對接近2,400萬顆這個2,400萬顆就是我們過往的一個水準" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147903/8.wav", + "text": "所以在這樣一個情況之下我們希望後續不要有疫情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147903/9.wav", + "text": "那相對的我們的國產雞蛋就可以穩定供應" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147903/10.wav", + "text": "所以現在國產雞蛋穩定供應給國人使用現在狀況是穩定的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147903/11.wav", + "text": "的一些不實訊息造成國人對於進口雞蛋的疑慮" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147903/12.wav", + "text": "這個我覺得可能農業部還是要持續宣導" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147903/13.wav", + "text": "對我們會持續宣導" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147903/14.wav", + "text": "我覺得它是個好的東西國人也很愛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147903/15.wav", + "text": "我看到很多中小學營養午餐也因為這樣的因素" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147903/16.wav", + "text": "結果就變成蛋的料理被拿掉我覺得這很可惜因" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147903/17.wav", + "text": "因為孩子們在發育的過程中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147903/18.wav", + "text": "整個雞蛋在營養午餐的部分我們很明確規範它是國產雞蛋" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147903/19.wav", + "text": "所以這個部分我們跟教育部一定是這樣一個嚴格的規範" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147903/20.wav", + "text": "我也在這邊呼籲這些各縣市應該重新去考量" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147903/21.wav", + "text": "國產雞蛋在這樣一個把關之下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147903/22.wav", + "text": "應該可以讓我們的國產雞蛋能夠恢復供應到我們的學童" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147903/23.wav", + "text": "一方面我還是希望農業部要更積極對外" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147903/24.wav", + "text": "甚至讓國人恢復對於雞蛋的信心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147903/25.wav", + "text": "前陣子這樣的風波我相信那個信心面一定會受到一些影響" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147903/26.wav", + "text": "但我認為應該恢復大家對於雞蛋的信心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147903/27.wav", + "text": "恢復之後另外一方面也要鼓勵各地方政府" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147903/28.wav", + "text": "甚至各學校的部分雞蛋其實還是一個很好的營養來源" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147903/29.wav", + "text": "如果因為這樣而讓我們的孩子們減少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147903/30.wav", + "text": "攝取到雞蛋其實我覺得這是很可惜的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147903/31.wav", + "text": "我希望這個部分農業部要持續" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147903/32.wav", + "text": "我想這個持續來進行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147903/33.wav", + "text": "對我們會持續去增加它的韌性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147903/34.wav", + "text": "好那我問一下因為接下來開始進入秋冬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147903/35.wav", + "text": "將來有沒有可能雞蛋上的需求量會再持續增加上來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147903/36.wav", + "text": "我想一般來講冬天的話雞蛋的需求量會再增加" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147903/37.wav", + "text": "如果沒有疫情的話相對的這個供應量是夠的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147903/38.wav", + "text": "但是因為從過往的一些經驗禽流感" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147903/39.wav", + "text": "那我問一下部長好了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147903/40.wav", + "text": "又發生雞蛋需求量大的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147903/41.wav", + "text": "上次有提過讓民間進口的方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147903/42.wav", + "text": "這個會來考慮嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147903/43.wav", + "text": "對我們已經有做一個規劃" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147903/44.wav", + "text": "特別是在年底到一月之間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147903/45.wav", + "text": "過往好發禽流感疫病的期間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147903/46.wav", + "text": "我們會提前去隨時監控這樣的情況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147903/47.wav", + "text": "如果萬一有發生的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147903/48.wav", + "text": "對如果有的話我們會啟動" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147903/49.wav", + "text": "讓貿易商可以自由進口的方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147903/50.wav", + "text": "來補充我們國內的不足" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147903/51.wav", + "text": "好接下來我要請教一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147903/52.wav", + "text": "因為這段時間從2021年開始" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147903/53.wav", + "text": "我們有一些農產品" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147903/54.wav", + "text": "輸中受到一些影響" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147903/55.wav", + "text": "不管是從鳳梨釋迦���霧石斑魚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147903/56.wav", + "text": "包括柑橘類的水果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147903/57.wav", + "text": "包括一些魚白帶魚竹筴魚秋刀魚魷魚等等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147903/58.wav", + "text": "這些部分目前都還是受到影響嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147903/59.wav", + "text": "還是有些已經陸續做了一些解凍" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147903/60.wav", + "text": "我想跟委員說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147903/61.wav", + "text": "相對的ECFA的18個品項裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147903/62.wav", + "text": "其中有五大類是跟魚產品有關的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147903/63.wav", + "text": "然後13個品項是跟農糧產品有關的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147903/64.wav", + "text": "前幾年農糧的部分水果的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147903/65.wav", + "text": "很多都已經被禁止了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147903/66.wav", + "text": "然後在魚的部分也有被禁止" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147903/67.wav", + "text": "同樣的在一些魚的部分被禁止了以後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147903/68.wav", + "text": "事實上有一些是到大陸去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147903/69.wav", + "text": "我先問一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147903/70.wav", + "text": "目前逐漸有部分恢復" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147903/71.wav", + "text": "的只有釋迦跟魚類包括白帶或竹筴魚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147903/72.wav", + "text": "這是部分但其他部分目前都還是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147903/73.wav", + "text": "只有7家有通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147903/74.wav", + "text": "實際上我們今年的魚產貿易額" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147903/75.wav", + "text": "其實非常非常的低" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147903/76.wav", + "text": "表示說其實" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147903/77.wav", + "text": "占比上其實是低的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147903/78.wav", + "text": "所以相對的表示" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147903/79.wav", + "text": "我們在其他方面的行銷" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147903/80.wav", + "text": "也達到一定的效果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147903/81.wav", + "text": "是我想我們走向全世界的通路" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147903/82.wav", + "text": "啦當然一個自由市場" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147903/83.wav", + "text": "其實相對都是比較穩定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147903/84.wav", + "text": "比較不容易受到政治干擾" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147903/85.wav", + "text": "因為我們也知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147903/86.wav", + "text": "中國這邊其實一直有介入臺灣的選舉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147903/87.wav", + "text": "還有沒有其他品項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147903/88.wav", + "text": "有可能在大選前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147903/89.wav", + "text": "剩下不到3個月時間在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147903/90.wav", + "text": "大選前可能成為中國對臺灣影響的一個武器" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147903/91.wav", + "text": "我跟委員說明一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147903/92.wav", + "text": "其實我們已經做好了不同情境的分析" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147903/93.wav", + "text": "在不同的情境之下一些相關的作法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147903/94.wav", + "text": "包括它的應對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147903/95.wav", + "text": "所以都有做了準備就對了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147903/96.wav", + "text": "都已經做了準備" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147903/97.wav", + "text": "但是在這邊也不方便說哪一些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147903/98.wav", + "text": "我知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147903/99.wav", + "text": "我們當然不希望這件事情發生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147903/100.wav", + "text": "啦但是我覺得都還是要做萬全的準備" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147903/101.wav", + "text": "對我們已經做了一些萬全" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147903/102.wav", + "text": "如果萬一有任何" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147903/103.wav", + "text": "因為畢竟中國現在是習近平領導的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147903/104.wav", + "text": "這是一個專制威權的國家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147903/105.wav", + "text": "非理性的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147903/106.wav", + "text": "也是非自由的市場" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147903/107.wav", + "text": "所以往往它的判斷和決定就會影響很多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147903/108.wav", + "text": "如果它做了一些不合理的判斷和決定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147903/109.wav", + "text": "想要去影響臺灣選舉的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147903/110.wav", + "text": "我認為我們應該要做萬全的準備" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147903/111.wav", + "text": "準備另外一方面也讓國人做有充分信心的準備" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147903/112.wav", + "text": "我們能夠有效的去把它降到最低" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147903/113.wav", + "text": "把效應降到最低" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147903/114.wav", + "text": "也是這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147903/115.wav", + "text": "當你的效應降到最低" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147903/116.wav", + "text": "沒有效果的作為往往它" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147903/117.wav", + "text": "它就不見得會做了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147903/118.wav", + "text": "要不斷的協助我們的業者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147903/119.wav", + "text": "不斷的協助我們的農民" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147903/120.wav", + "text": "去把這件事情做好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147903/121.wav", + "text": "對這個部分我們已經在做了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147903/122.wav", + "text": "好那就有做了萬全準備沒" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147903/123.wav", + "text": "沒關係細項部分就讓你們去做努力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147903/124.wav", + "text": "我就不特別去問\n" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147903/125.wav", + "text": "再來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147903/126.wav", + "text": "中國前兩天有辦了兩岸的農業交流會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147903/127.wav", + "text": "陸委會說看不出對臺的好處" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147903/128.wav", + "text": "農業部的看法呢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147903/129.wav", + "text": "我想過往兩岸都經常有這種" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147903/130.wav", + "text": "所謂的農業交流會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147903/131.wav", + "text": "都遠優於整個大陸" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147903/132.wav", + "text": "把我們的技術" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147903/133.wav", + "text": "我們的品種引到大陸去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147903/134.wav", + "text": "我們在這個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147903/135.wav", + "text": "所以這個還是請農業部要審慎注意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147903/136.wav", + "text": "因為畢竟這樣的交流會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147903/137.wav", + "text": "我們的很多品項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147903/138.wav", + "text": "我們的技術" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147903/139.wav", + "text": "我們的人才" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147903/140.wav", + "text": "我們的品種其實都是很不錯的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147903/141.wav", + "text": "它大量去種植的��候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147903/142.wav", + "text": "往往回銷回來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147903/143.wav", + "text": "回打回來我們的市場" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147903/144.wav", + "text": "就會產生重大影響" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147903/145.wav", + "text": "所以這個請農業部也務必要注意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147903/146.wav", + "text": "而且也要不斷讓人家知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147903/147.wav", + "text": "這樣的交流會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147903/148.wav", + "text": "到底是對臺灣有什麼樣的影響" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147903/149.wav", + "text": "恐怕也要讓更多的人知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147903/150.wav", + "text": "往往很多的品種" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147903/151.wav", + "text": "或者人才或者技術被人家取得了之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147903/152.wav", + "text": "回打回來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147903/153.wav", + "text": "我們遭受很重大的影響" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147903/154.wav", + "text": "對對我們是一個傷害" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147903/155.wav", + "text": "日本其實就是一個很顯著的例子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147903/156.wav", + "text": "顯然整個品種被取得之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147903/157.wav", + "text": "它的價格就大幅的受到了影響" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147903/158.wav", + "text": "\n最後我再問一個問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147903/159.wav", + "text": "是我們很重要的一個產業" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147903/160.wav", + "text": "我們有做了一些減船的計畫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147903/161.wav", + "text": "因為我們的配額也受到限制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147903/162.wav", + "text": "減船其實是讓有些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147903/163.wav", + "text": "願意退場的能夠退場" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147903/164.wav", + "text": "讓這個更健全" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147903/165.wav", + "text": "我不知道這個減船計畫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147903/166.wav", + "text": "現在進行到哪邊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147903/167.wav", + "text": "我跟委員說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147903/168.wav", + "text": "在整個遠洋漁業" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147903/169.wav", + "text": "是一個非常重要的措施" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147903/170.wav", + "text": "我們在今年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147903/171.wav", + "text": "也專案送到行政院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147903/172.wav", + "text": "應該將近有7億的預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147903/173.wav", + "text": "大概有7億的預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147903/174.wav", + "text": "我們在爭取大概7億的預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147903/175.wav", + "text": "去做這些不同噸級的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147903/176.wav", + "text": "包括沿近海" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147903/177.wav", + "text": "還有包括遠洋部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147903/178.wav", + "text": "部長署長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147903/179.wav", + "text": "讓整個遠洋漁業" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147903/180.wav", + "text": "更加的健全發展" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147903/181.wav", + "text": "讓一些要退場的能夠退場" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147903/182.wav", + "text": "能夠更有效的運用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147903/183.wav", + "text": "所以我希望這件事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147903/184.wav", + "text": "也儘快和院裡面溝通" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147903/185.wav", + "text": "儘快能夠核定下來好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147903/186.wav", + "text": "讓整個這個產業" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147903/187.wav", + "text": "能夠更健全來發展" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147903/188.wav", + "text": "對我們會積極的爭取" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147902/0.wav", + "text": "請許部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147902/1.wav", + "text": "有請部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147902/2.wav", + "text": "洪委員好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147902/3.wav", + "text": "部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147902/4.wav", + "text": "最近諾貝爾獎的得主陸續公布" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147902/5.wav", + "text": "布部長知不知道今年諾貝爾經濟學獎得主" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147902/6.wav", + "text": "就是在研究女性在勞動市場裡面很多的處境" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147902/7.wav", + "text": "其實在臺灣也有很多重要的學者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147902/8.wav", + "text": "部長請你先看一下這個圖" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147902/9.wav", + "text": "左邊是男性右邊是女性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147902/10.wav", + "text": "以年齡來作為區分的時候它的圖形" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147902/11.wav", + "text": "跟其他的國家看起來有些不一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147902/12.wav", + "text": "其他的國家看起來都有兩個高峯" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147902/13.wav", + "text": "但臺灣的女性勞參率只有單峯" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147902/14.wav", + "text": "尤其是在25歲到29歲之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147902/15.wav", + "text": "就一路下降" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147902/16.wav", + "text": "你知不知道這原因是什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147902/17.wav", + "text": "對那為什麼只有單峯" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147902/18.wav", + "text": "主要是之後可能因為結婚生育" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147902/19.wav", + "text": "還有料理家務的需要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147902/20.wav", + "text": "這個是根據衛福部的調查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147902/21.wav", + "text": "女性會逐漸的退出職場" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147902/22.wav", + "text": "為什麼別的國家的二度就業" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147902/23.wav", + "text": "可以讓它看起來有個雙峯的圖形" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147902/24.wav", + "text": "可是我們的就是一路下降" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147902/25.wav", + "text": "他如果因為結婚生育離職的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147902/26.wav", + "text": "其實在小孩長大" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147902/27.wav", + "text": "以後他應該可以再回來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147902/28.wav", + "text": "他們要重返職場的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147902/29.wav", + "text": "對這些女性勞工來講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147902/30.wav", + "text": "可能不像國外這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147902/31.wav", + "text": "請問部長以勞動部的立場" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147902/32.wav", + "text": "希望臺灣的勞工二度就業率" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147902/33.wav", + "text": "是提升還是下降" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147902/34.wav", + "text": "我希望提升" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147902/35.wav", + "text": "我想部長說得很清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147902/36.wav", + "text": "我們都希望提升" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147902/37.wav", + "text": "但是我要跟部長分享" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147902/38.wav", + "text": "跟旅宿業移工的新聞" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147902/39.wav", + "text": "我想知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147902/40.wav", + "text": "有很大部分的勞工" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147902/41.wav", + "text": "其實都是靠服務業跟旅宿業" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147902/42.wav", + "text": "在支撐他們的就業職位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147902/43.wav", + "text": "那引進外籍移工增加" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147902/44.wav", + "text": "或更大程度的開放" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147902/45.wav", + "text": "會不會影響本國勞工的就業" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147902/46.wav", + "text": "尤其是中年二度就業的勞工" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147902/47.wav", + "text": "我想這會成為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147902/48.wav", + "text": "接下來在勞動市場裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147902/49.wav", + "text": "一個非常重要的議題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147902/50.wav", + "text": "所以部長我想請問" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147902/51.wav", + "text": "現在產業或部會打算要開放" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147902/52.wav", + "text": "引進更多的外籍勞工" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147902/53.wav", + "text": "尤其是剛才說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147902/54.wav", + "text": "勞動部有沒有做什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147902/55.wav", + "text": "為臺灣勞工權益把關的措施" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147902/56.wav", + "text": "本國勞工的就業必須優先" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147902/57.wav", + "text": "大概有六成都是女性參與" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147902/58.wav", + "text": "其中中高齡的占了36%" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147902/59.wav", + "text": "所以我們擔心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147902/60.wav", + "text": "貿然開放其實會衝擊到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147902/61.wav", + "text": "中高齡跟二度就業的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147902/62.wav", + "text": "可是部長現在政府釋放出" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147902/63.wav", + "text": "接下來要在服務業" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147902/64.wav", + "text": "跟旅宿業開放的訊息了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147902/65.wav", + "text": "所以這個憂慮已成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147902/66.wav", + "text": "對但是報告委員我們其實" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147902/67.wav", + "text": "你們把關的措施是什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147902/68.wav", + "text": "報告委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147902/69.wav", + "text": "其實行政院也有對外說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147902/70.wav", + "text": "開放的前提是必須已" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147902/71.wav", + "text": "疫後缺工的協助方案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147902/72.wav", + "text": "參加我們的中高齡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147902/73.wav", + "text": "高齡者就業計畫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147902/74.wav", + "text": "還有包括我們現在推出的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147902/75.wav", + "text": "婦女二度就業計畫都找不到人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147902/76.wav", + "text": "這樣才有開放的條件" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147902/77.wav", + "text": "當然交通部有提案權" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147902/78.wav", + "text": "但是他提案之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147902/79.wav", + "text": "要經過我們勞動部的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147902/80.wav", + "text": "政策諮詢小組的評估" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147902/81.wav", + "text": "所以這個部分不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147902/82.wav", + "text": "還是要經過政策的評估" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147902/83.wav", + "text": "才能夠做一個決定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147902/84.wav", + "text": "部長你剛才講到幾個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147902/85.wav", + "text": "我認為很關鍵的數據" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147902/86.wav", + "text": "實證的數據來看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147902/87.wav", + "text": "服務業的從業人員裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147902/88.wav", + "text": "其實女性占了七成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147902/89.wav", + "text": "而且大家都知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147902/90.wav", + "text": "服務業相對於製造業" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147902/91.wav", + "text": "薪資水平是比較低的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147902/92.wav", + "text": "而且它也是比較高" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147902/93.wav", + "text": "替代性的職缺" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147902/94.wav", + "text": "尤其大部分以女性為主" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147902/95.wav", + "text": "外籍勞工的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147902/96.wav", + "text": "中老年女性就業機會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147902/97.wav", + "text": "部長同意嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147902/98.wav", + "text": "同意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147902/99.wav", + "text": "相比於其他國家的勞參率" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147902/100.wav", + "text": "呈現雙峯" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147902/101.wav", + "text": "二度就業婦女" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147902/102.wav", + "text": "回到職場的機會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147902/103.wav", + "text": "跟回到職場的環境" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147902/104.wav", + "text": "看起來比臺灣友善" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147902/105.wav", + "text": "才會有雙峯" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147902/106.wav", + "text": "峯我們原本在這方面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147902/107.wav", + "text": "已經比其他國家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147902/108.wav", + "text": "來得不友善了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147902/109.wav", + "text": "今天如果我們又" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147902/110.wav", + "text": "沒有經過完整的評估" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147902/111.wav", + "text": "或完整的把關措施" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147902/112.wav", + "text": "就貿然的再開放" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147902/113.wav", + "text": "更多的外籍勞工" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147902/114.wav", + "text": "進入旅宿業或服務業" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147902/115.wav", + "text": "我很擔心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147902/116.wav", + "text": "右邊這條紅線" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147902/117.wav", + "text": "會更陡峭" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147902/118.wav", + "text": "會更一路下滑" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147902/119.wav", + "text": "更沒有支撐力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147902/120.wav", + "text": "離其他國家的雙峯更遠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147902/121.wav", + "text": "會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147902/122.wav", + "text": "所以部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147902/123.wav", + "text": "我們現在服務業女性占七成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147902/124.wav", + "text": "旅宿業占五成多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147902/125.wav", + "text": "甚至剛剛部長說到六成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147902/126.wav", + "text": "而且很多都是二度就業的婦女" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147902/127.wav", + "text": "部長剛才講到婚育" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147902/128.wav", + "text": "我今天還沒跟你討論到婚育" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147902/129.wav", + "text": "或家庭中的分工結構" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147902/130.wav", + "text": "對女性的不友善" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147902/131.wav", + "text": "所以造成這個問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147902/132.wav", + "text": "之後我們可以再討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147902/133.wav", + "text": "但是光憑現在開放移工" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147902/134.wav", + "text": "對於二度就業婦女的狀況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147902/135.wav", + "text": "我說實話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147902/136.wav", + "text": "到現在還沒有看到一份" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147902/137.wav", + "text": "很精確的評估或把關機制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147902/138.wav", + "text": "包括很多人在說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147902/139.wav", + "text": "是不是這個相關措施" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147902/140.wav", + "text": "應該要有性別影響評估" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147902/141.wav", + "text": "勞動部有沒有打算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147902/142.wav", + "text": "在開放服務業或旅宿業的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147902/143.wav", + "text": "報告委員我認為必須" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147902/144.wav", + "text": "因為這個提案單位是交通部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147902/145.wav", + "text": "其實行政院有指示" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147902/146.wav", + "text": "就業市場的影響" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147902/147.wav", + "text": "評估剛剛委員所講的這個影響評估" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147902/148.wav", + "text": "我覺得這是可以要求" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147902/149.wav", + "text": "我說的影響評估" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147902/150.wav", + "text": "不只是看起來把所有的勞工" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147902/151.wav", + "text": "都當作均值" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147902/152.wav", + "text": "而是從性別的觀點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147902/153.wav", + "text": "應該要有一個性別影響評估" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147902/154.wav", + "text": "這個性別影響評估" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147902/155.wav", + "text": "的前提甚至在我們已經相比" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147902/156.wav", + "text": "其他國家更不友善的女性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147902/157.wav", + "text": "二度就業的機會上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147902/158.wav", + "text": "在這個基礎上再去做評估" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147902/159.wav", + "text": "把男性女性都當作是一樣的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147902/160.wav", + "text": "報告委員可能要精準的對焦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147902/161.wav", + "text": "開放的是房務清潔人員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147902/162.wav", + "text": "女性而且是中高齡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147902/163.wav", + "text": "因為經過統計現在我們全國的房務人員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147902/164.wav", + "text": "八成以上是中高齡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147902/165.wav", + "text": "所以部長我要再提醒" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147902/166.wav", + "text": "我們其實有很多觀光區域" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147902/167.wav", + "text": "所以我們有很多的旅宿業" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147902/168.wav", + "text": "過去相關的工作" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147902/169.wav", + "text": "很可能都是原住民勞工" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147902/170.wav", + "text": "在做我都認為我們現在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147902/171.wav", + "text": "要開放服務業旅宿業" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147902/172.wav", + "text": "外籍勞工的工作上除了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147902/173.wav", + "text": "性別影響評估" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147902/174.wav", + "text": "之外族羣影響評估要不要做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147902/175.wav", + "text": "部長你覺得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147902/176.wav", + "text": "這個我覺得應該" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147902/177.wav", + "text": "部長那你覺得這件事情是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147902/178.wav", + "text": "開放的主管機關要做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147902/179.wav", + "text": "還是勞動部自己就應該做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147902/180.wav", + "text": "我們會同時來做照" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147902/181.wav", + "text": "照理說應該是提案的單位要去做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147902/182.wav", + "text": "但我覺得這一題我們責無旁貸" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147902/183.wav", + "text": "部長我希望你堅持這個回答" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147902/184.wav", + "text": "今天交通部要不要做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147902/185.wav", + "text": "我們會來要求它" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147902/186.wav", + "text": "但我認為勞動部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147902/187.wav", + "text": "作為這方面的主管機關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147902/188.wav", + "text": "性別影響評估" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147902/189.wav", + "text": "跟族羣影響評估" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147902/190.wav", + "text": "你們都應該扎扎實實的做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147902/191.wav", + "text": "把到底影響的狀況是什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147902/192.wav", + "text": "呈現讓國人知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147902/193.wav", + "text": "我現在不是說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147902/194.wav", + "text": "我們絕對不能開放" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147902/195.wav", + "text": "不是這個意思" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147902/196.wav", + "text": "但是開放的好跟壞" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147902/197.wav", + "text": "尤其是在哪些層面上的影響" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147902/198.wav", + "text": "會比其他國家更巨大" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147902/199.wav", + "text": "這個事情應該清楚的呈現出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147902/200.wav", + "text": "所以這部分我要麻煩部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147902/201.wav", + "text": "我覺得勞動部應該" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147902/202.wav", + "text": "至少把相關的專業評估" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147902/203.wav", + "text": "資訊讓大家一併的來做決策" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147902/204.wav", + "text": "我再說一次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147902/205.wav", + "text": "我們不是說絕對不行開" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147902/206.wav", + "text": "或一定要開" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147902/207.wav", + "text": "不是這個意思" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147902/208.wav", + "text": "但哪些重要的評估的原則" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147902/209.wav", + "text": "我們必須做到把資訊呈現" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147902/210.wav", + "text": "讓國人知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147902/211.wav", + "text": "假設開放對我們臺灣影響不會太大" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147902/212.wav", + "text": "對各方面尤其是原本就相對弱勢的女性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147902/213.wav", + "text": "尤其是中年的就業女性的衝擊不會太大" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147902/214.wav", + "text": "我們在這前提之下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147902/215.wav", + "text": "大家可以放心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147902/216.wav", + "text": "可是如果影響很大的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147902/217.wav", + "text": "那大家就要想" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147902/218.wav", + "text": "我們要不要付出這個代價" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147902/219.wav", + "text": "可是誰能夠提供這個專業的資訊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147902/220.wav", + "text": "其實是勞動部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147902/221.wav", + "text": "我希望勞動部把這個把關的角色" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147902/222.wav", + "text": "給承擔起來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147902/223.wav", + "text": "應該沒有問題吧" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147902/224.wav", + "text": "可以把這相關的評估提出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147902/225.wav", + "text": "兩份性別影響評估" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147902/226.wav", + "text": "跟族羣影響評估" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147902/227.wav", + "text": "兩個月可以嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147902/228.wav", + "text": "兩個月可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147902/229.wav", + "text": "把相關的評估提供出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147902/230.wav", + "text": "讓大家做相關的參考跟審議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147899/0.wav", + "text": "請部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147899/1.wav", + "text": "召委好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147899/2.wav", + "text": "部長好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147899/3.wav", + "text": "是這樣子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147899/4.wav", + "text": "我今天主要是針對10月5號的書面質詢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147899/5.wav", + "text": "我對那個答復不滿意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147899/6.wav", + "text": "所以希望趁這個時間來跟您口頭上請教" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147899/7.wav", + "text": "希望您能給更具體的答復" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147899/8.wav", + "text": "的2023年全球退休金指數" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147899/9.wav", + "text": "臺灣只是排名倒數第九位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147899/10.wav", + "text": "請問部長您的看法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147899/11.wav", + "text": "報告委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147899/12.wav", + "text": "其實如果以勞保來看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147899/13.wav", + "text": "我們沒有比較差" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147899/14.wav", + "text": "平均請領勞保年金的月投保薪資大概是三萬七" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147899/15.wav", + "text": "年資30年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147899/16.wav", + "text": "它的所得替代率大概是46.5%" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147899/17.wav", + "text": "OECD則是42.2%" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147899/18.wav", + "text": "所以如果單看勞保" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147899/19.wav", + "text": "我們是沒有比較差" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147899/20.wav", + "text": "所以它為什麼會排到第九" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147899/21.wav", + "text": "不是第九" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147899/22.wav", + "text": "因為我們的退休金不只勞保" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147899/23.wav", + "text": "包括我們軍公教" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147899/24.wav", + "text": "所以它是不是對象是哪一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147899/25.wav", + "text": "如果說單以我負責的勞保" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147899/26.wav", + "text": "說我倒數第九" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147899/27.wav", + "text": "我大概不服氣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147899/28.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147899/29.wav", + "text": "那可能這個報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147899/30.wav", + "text": "要請同事們有機會再看看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147899/31.wav", + "text": "因為這個我辦公室" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147899/32.wav", + "text": "您的部會分享" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147899/33.wav", + "text": "臺灣目前面臨到勞保要破產" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147899/34.wav", + "text": "勞保以我的感覺是大水庫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147899/35.wav", + "text": "高齡化少子化" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147899/36.wav", + "text": "未來繳得多一定是領得少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147899/37.wav", + "text": "這是逃不了的現實" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147899/38.wav", + "text": "勞退是個人專戶" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147899/39.wav", + "text": "沒有破產危機" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147899/40.wav", + "text": "但是自提比率不開放自選" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147899/41.wav", + "text": "43.4%的勞工贊成自選" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147899/42.wav", + "text": "沒有想法的占37%" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147899/43.wav", + "text": "不贊成的大概占19%" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147899/44.wav", + "text": "相較起來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147899/45.wav", + "text": "對比起來贊成還是占多數" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147899/46.wav", + "text": "贊成其實有3個原因" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147899/47.wav", + "text": "第一個就是退休金是自己的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147899/48.wav", + "text": "希望自選投資標的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147899/49.wav", + "text": "31%有選這樣的原因" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147899/50.wav", + "text": "開放自選可以增加收入" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147899/51.wav", + "text": "大概21%有選這樣的原因" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147899/52.wav", + "text": "他們個人有投資理財觀念" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147899/53.wav", + "text": "願意承擔風險" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147899/54.wav", + "text": "\n我國在2013年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147899/55.wav", + "text": "私校退撫開放自選" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147899/56.wav", + "text": "今年公教退撫新制度也開放了自選" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147899/57.wav", + "text": "而目前只剩勞退還沒有開放自選" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147899/58.wav", + "text": "開放自選之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147899/59.wav", + "text": "都有保留保證收益的選項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147899/60.wav", + "text": "私校對於穩健型積極型" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147899/61.wav", + "text": "收益優於勞退更快速累積退休金" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147899/62.wav", + "text": "其實我的勞退版本主要是自提" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147899/63.wav", + "text": "不過目前跨黨派委員的提案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147899/64.wav", + "text": "都是集中在自提要開放自選的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147899/65.wav", + "text": "一部分勞工希望自己的錢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147899/66.wav", + "text": "自己怎麼樣用更快速的累積資金" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147899/67.wav", + "text": "同時一部分的勞工希望維持現狀" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147899/68.wav", + "text": "所以也保留原本的保證收益的選項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147899/69.wav", + "text": "部長在勞退自提先開辦的自選是有規劃嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147899/70.wav", + "text": "是否有一個時程表可以分享一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147899/71.wav", + "text": "謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147899/72.wav", + "text": "報告委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147899/73.wav", + "text": "這一題其實我們一直有人倡議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147899/74.wav", + "text": "啦包括委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147899/75.wav", + "text": "包括我們民間很多倡議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147899/76.wav", + "text": "業務單位也一直很關注這個議題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147899/77.wav", + "text": "我們其實在去年也針對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147899/78.wav", + "text": "因為過去的調查可能不是那麼精確" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147899/79.wav", + "text": "應該算前年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147899/80.wav", + "text": "前年特別針對自選的部分去做了一個調查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147899/81.wav", + "text": "的確像剛剛委員所講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147899/82.wav", + "text": "的大概43%的勞工是贊成的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147899/83.wav", + "text": "不過這裡面我們有特別再去問" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147899/84.wav", + "text": "如果你贊成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147899/85.wav", + "text": "那你會不會參加" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147899/86.wav", + "text": "其中很爽快地說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147899/87.wav", + "text": "我會參加的是9.3%" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147899/88.wav", + "text": "另外有72.9%" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147899/89.wav", + "text": "就是將近73%" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147899/90.wav", + "text": "我要看看你這個投資標的內容之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147899/91.wav", + "text": "再來做決定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147899/92.wav", + "text": "另外其他沒有想法的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147899/93.wav", + "text": "大概占14%" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147899/94.wav", + "text": "還是交由政府投資運用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147899/95.wav", + "text": "也就是說他雖然贊成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147899/96.wav", + "text": "但是其實你如果再去細究" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147899/97.wav", + "text": "你是不是就會參加" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147899/98.wav", + "text": "他其實是有點保守" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147899/99.wav", + "text": "他可能還會考慮比較多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147899/100.wav", + "text": "啦當然因為這個就牽涉到委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147899/101.wav", + "text": "剛剛講的他要自擔風險的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147899/102.wav", + "text": "他就要看你的投資標的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147899/103.wav", + "text": "的當然這一題到底要不要開放" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147899/104.wav", + "text": "我沒有說絕對行或不行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147899/105.wav", + "text": "我是覺得因為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147899/106.wav", + "text": "所以這幾年我是先把自提的比例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147899/107.wav", + "text": "儘量拉高" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147899/108.wav", + "text": "現在拉到快14%" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147899/109.wav", + "text": "了已經104萬人參加了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147899/110.wav", + "text": "勞工的理財" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147899/111.wav", + "text": "專業知識要有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147899/112.wav", + "text": "否則的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147899/113.wav", + "text": "你貿然開放" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147899/114.wav", + "text": "縱使讓他自選" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147899/115.wav", + "text": "他可能不曉得要選什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147899/116.wav", + "text": "啦所以我們也透過金管會來幫忙" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147899/117.wav", + "text": "讓勞工來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147899/118.wav", + "text": "強化他的理財投資" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147899/119.wav", + "text": "\n不過倒是說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147899/120.wav", + "text": "因為這裡面包括勞團" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147899/121.wav", + "text": "他其實會有反對的意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147899/122.wav", + "text": "而他反對的意見是第一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147899/123.wav", + "text": "他認為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147899/124.wav", + "text": "認為我們勞退基金" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147899/125.wav", + "text": "目前的績效沒有比" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147899/126.wav", + "text": "民間業者差" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147899/127.wav", + "text": "勞動基金還是要有一定的社會角色" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147899/128.wav", + "text": "因為它畢竟是勞工的老本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147899/129.wav", + "text": "所以它確實是安全穩定是最重要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147899/130.wav", + "text": "如果要自選的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147899/131.wav", + "text": "那就回歸市場機制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147899/132.wav", + "text": "啊讓我們的業者提出好的條件" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147899/133.wav", + "text": "好的商品" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147899/134.wav", + "text": "讓勞工來購買" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147899/135.wav", + "text": "他認為不必經由勞退" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147899/136.wav", + "text": "另外他覺得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147899/137.wav", + "text": "覺得如果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147899/138.wav", + "text": "變成要增加政府的成本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147899/139.wav", + "text": "他們有這樣的考量" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147899/140.wav", + "text": "擔心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147899/141.wav", + "text": "啦也會擔心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147899/142.wav", + "text": "這個自選投資的基金" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147899/143.wav", + "text": "會不會以後淪為民間業者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147899/144.wav", + "text": "資金調節的工具" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147899/145.wav", + "text": "所以他們的考量就是會比較謹慎一點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147899/146.wav", + "text": "是一個很重大的變革" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147899/147.wav", + "text": "雖然我們現在沒有期程" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147899/148.wav", + "text": "但是我會說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147899/149.wav", + "text": "我還是努力把那個自提" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147899/150.wav", + "text": "提比例提高" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147899/151.wav", + "text": "大家也有一些投資的專業理財知識" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147899/152.wav", + "text": "我們可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147899/153.wav", + "text": "再來做一些審慎的評估" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147899/154.wav", + "text": "結論是說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147899/155.wav", + "text": "我們立法院最後的會期" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147899/156.wav", + "text": "是要把自提提升為目標" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147899/157.wav", + "text": "目前還沒有時程" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147899/158.wav", + "text": "那是否可以考慮" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147899/159.wav", + "text": "呢因為畢竟這個自選的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147899/160.wav", + "text": "也不是強制的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147899/161.wav", + "text": "只是說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147899/162.wav", + "text": "其實剛剛我有看到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147899/163.wav", + "text": "許多業界" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147899/164.wav", + "text": "也是對這個非常期待" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147899/165.wav", + "text": "讓勞工更有選擇" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147899/166.wav", + "text": "因為勞工的種類" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147899/167.wav", + "text": "講了有很多種" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147899/168.wav", + "text": "我覺得以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147899/169.wav", + "text": "外資跟投資者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147899/170.wav", + "text": "把臺灣這個市場" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147899/171.wav", + "text": "作為投入的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147899/172.wav", + "text": "其實也是一個考量之一" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147899/173.wav", + "text": "啦就是一個很標竿性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147899/174.wav", + "text": "在這個會期" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147899/175.wav", + "text": "排出一個時程表" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147899/176.wav", + "text": "跟同仁們討論一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147899/177.wav", + "text": "再跟同仁討論看看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147899/178.wav", + "text": "好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147899/179.wav", + "text": "謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147898/0.wav", + "text": "主席好我想請潘部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147898/1.wav", + "text": "好請部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147898/2.wav", + "text": "謝謝主席今天讓我們所有委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147898/3.wav", + "text": "我也希望能得到像吳思瑤委員的對待" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147898/4.wav", + "text": "也能暢所欲言" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147898/5.wav", + "text": "剛剛吳思瑤委員有跟主席特別講一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147898/6.wav", + "text": "現在也跟主席特別報告一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147898/7.wav", + "text": "瞭解瞭解" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147898/8.wav", + "text": "我想一開始的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147898/9.wav", + "text": "今天有這麼多的國立大學校長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147898/10.wav", + "text": "以及醫院院長都在這邊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147898/11.wav", + "text": "一定會碰到招標的事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147898/12.wav", + "text": "所以我要特別提到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147898/13.wav", + "text": "FIFA Quality Pro認證這件事以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147898/14.wav", + "text": "及楠梓文中足球館" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147898/15.wav", + "text": "我之前質詢過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147898/16.wav", + "text": "要再特別提這部分呢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147898/17.wav", + "text": "高雄市政府" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147898/18.wav", + "text": "楠梓文中足球場規劃階段" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147898/19.wav", + "text": "未妥與外界及利害關係人溝通" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147898/20.wav", + "text": "球場定位與規劃內容" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147898/21.wav", + "text": "致球場配置未盡妥適" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147898/22.wav", + "text": "專案管理廠商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147898/23.wav", + "text": "未詳實審查統包商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147898/24.wav", + "text": "送審資料" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147898/25.wav", + "text": "不符統包設計規範" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147898/26.wav", + "text": "仍足以使用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147898/27.wav", + "text": "高雄市政府審計單位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147898/28.wav", + "text": "所提出的一個報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147898/29.wav", + "text": "我為什麼要特別提這個點呢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147898/30.wav", + "text": "你們也特別把這部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147898/31.wav", + "text": "列出來也" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147898/32.wav", + "text": "就是楠梓文中足球館" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147898/33.wav", + "text": "你們覺得這個東西合法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147898/34.wav", + "text": "你們找了一些學者專家表示它合法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147898/35.wav", + "text": "因為我覺得它其實是一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147898/36.wav", + "text": "我也想請部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147898/37.wav", + "text": "表示一個態度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147898/38.wav", + "text": "它在一開始招標的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147898/39.wav", + "text": "就直接要求" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147898/40.wav", + "text": "符合 FIFA Quality Pro的認證" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147898/41.wav", + "text": "也許讓他們屬意的廠商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147898/42.wav", + "text": "得標" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147898/43.wav", + "text": "變更契約內容" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147898/44.wav", + "text": "變成不需要FIFA Quality Pro" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147898/45.wav", + "text": "這差很多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147898/46.wav", + "text": "竟然只要求他退60萬的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147898/47.wav", + "text": "認證費用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147898/48.wav", + "text": "然後就讓他過關了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147898/49.wav", + "text": "各位校長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147898/50.wav", + "text": "你們聽得懂我的意思嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147898/51.wav", + "text": "你們在做很多招標案的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147898/52.wav", + "text": "如果這樣的狀態" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147898/53.wav", + "text": "很多招標案是不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147898/54.wav", + "text": "可以都比照效法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147898/55.wav", + "text": "所以我想問一下對於這樣的狀態" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147898/56.wav", + "text": "部長你認同嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147898/57.wav", + "text": "跟委員報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147898/58.wav", + "text": "因為委員關心足球場" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147898/59.wav", + "text": "設計案有一段時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147898/60.wav", + "text": "也跟委員有做一個報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147898/61.wav", + "text": "高雄市在執行這個方案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147898/62.wav", + "text": "確實在過程當中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147898/63.wav", + "text": "它們也因為有徵詢相關的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147898/64.wav", + "text": "事後做了一些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147898/65.wav", + "text": "變更的過程" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147898/66.wav", + "text": "這個當然就像委員說的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147898/67.wav", + "text": "它還是符合相關的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147898/68.wav", + "text": "法律規範" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147898/69.wav", + "text": "至於這個案例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147898/70.wav", + "text": "像委員提醒的後續" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147898/71.wav", + "text": "能夠更" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147898/72.wav", + "text": "審慎地考慮到場地的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147898/73.wav", + "text": "條件需求及未來的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147898/74.wav", + "text": "長期目標可能就不會發生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147898/75.wav", + "text": "在招標後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147898/76.wav", + "text": "在經過專家諮詢的一些意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147898/77.wav", + "text": "後的調整" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147898/78.wav", + "text": "部長你這樣回答因為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147898/79.wav", + "text": "為這麼多國立大學校長在這邊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147898/80.wav", + "text": "大家都在開標案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147898/81.wav", + "text": "如果說這樣的狀態" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147898/82.wav", + "text": "是可以的大家比照效法那整個環境" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147898/83.wav", + "text": "會有多亂" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147898/84.wav", + "text": "針對楠梓文中足球場的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147898/85.wav", + "text": "我希望部長跟體育署長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147898/86.wav", + "text": "效益" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147898/87.wav", + "text": "尊嚴的作法因為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147898/88.wav", + "text": "\n接下來我想問" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147898/89.wav", + "text": "因為在上一次的質詢當中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147898/90.wav", + "text": "本席有特別提到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147898/91.wav", + "text": "一個融合教育相關的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147898/92.wav", + "text": "融合教育" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147898/93.wav", + "text": "障礙者權利公約" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147898/94.wav", + "text": "所以教育部這邊也希望" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147898/95.wav", + "text": "公立幼兒園集中式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147898/96.wav", + "text": "特教班融合教育計畫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147898/97.wav", + "text": "部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147898/98.wav", + "text": "OK本席" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147898/99.wav", + "text": "教育部質詢的時候提了一個臨時提案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147898/100.wav", + "text": "表示政府重視融合教育" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147898/101.wav", + "text": "卻沒有配套措施" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147898/102.wav", + "text": "近年來班級特殊生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147898/103.wav", + "text": "比例增加" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147898/104.wav", + "text": "一般有提報為特殊生者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147898/105.wav", + "text": "每班大概有1到3名有些更多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147898/106.wav", + "text": "且不含入班後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147898/107.wav", + "text": "教師察覺到的疑似生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147898/108.wav", + "text": "那特教生比例升高的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147898/109.wav", + "text": "特教助理員時數少的情況之下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147898/110.wav", + "text": "普幼生的受教權" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147898/111.wav", + "text": "受到嚴重的影響" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147898/112.wav", + "text": "也降低老師的教學品質" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147898/113.wav", + "text": "和學童的教育" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147898/114.wav", + "text": "班級有特殊生就要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147898/115.wav", + "text": "增設1個助理員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147898/116.wav", + "text": "除了對特教生友善照顧" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147898/117.wav", + "text": "更能夠落實國家政策" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147898/118.wav", + "text": "重視幼兒的整體教育" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147898/119.wav", + "text": "這樣的主張沒有錯吧部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147898/120.wav", + "text": "委員應該這樣說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147898/121.wav", + "text": "融合教育是一個比較全面性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147898/122.wav", + "text": "不只是在學前這個階段" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147898/123.wav", + "text": "剛剛我們前面幾位委員關心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147898/124.wav", + "text": "不管專任或" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147898/125.wav", + "text": "增加服務時數" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147898/126.wav", + "text": "對於一般班級裡的特教生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147898/127.wav", + "text": "對老師對學生他才能夠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147898/128.wav", + "text": "真正提供好的服務品質" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147898/129.wav", + "text": "113年所啟動的就是這樣的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147898/130.wav", + "text": "能夠針對公立幼兒園普通班" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147898/131.wav", + "text": "有特殊生的班級" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147898/132.wav", + "text": "要增加特教助理員的名額" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147898/133.wav", + "text": "或者是時數" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147898/134.wav", + "text": "以維護並促進幼生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147898/135.wav", + "text": "這個案子其實也通過了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147898/136.wav", + "text": "可是我們看了所有相關特殊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147898/137.wav", + "text": "這次總共有42億9,383萬元" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147898/138.wav", + "text": "大概只佔7%" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147898/139.wav", + "text": "融合教育如果這麼重要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147898/140.wav", + "text": "我們希望融合教育這邊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147898/141.wav", + "text": "能夠得到更多的資源" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147898/142.wav", + "text": "並不是要去排擠原本特殊教育的資源" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147898/143.wav", + "text": "部長這個部分可不可以做到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147898/144.wav", + "text": "這也許是學前組這邊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147898/145.wav", + "text": "委員看到的預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147898/146.wav", + "text": "我跟委員報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147898/147.wav", + "text": "第一個專任特教輔導員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147898/148.wav", + "text": "在未來4年會增加1,600" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147898/149.wav", + "text": "人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147898/150.wav", + "text": "113年的預算就會增加1.2億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147898/151.wav", + "text": "我會請署長整理後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147898/152.wav", + "text": "讓委員瞭解整體的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147898/153.wav", + "text": "所以不只是這麼少的比例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147898/154.wav", + "text": "好謝謝部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147898/155.wav", + "text": "因為我覺得融合教育如果現在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147898/156.wav", + "text": "也符合聯合國的精神" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147898/157.wav", + "text": "能夠真正做好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147898/158.wav", + "text": "而不會影響到相關學生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147898/159.wav", + "text": "好謝謝委員提醒我們會朝這個方向來做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147898/160.wav", + "text": "好謝謝部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147898/161.wav", + "text": "接下來我想再問一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147898/162.wav", + "text": "因為之前在講私校退場機制時" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147898/163.wav", + "text": "特別提到的狀態是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147898/164.wav", + "text": "希望能夠讓" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147898/165.wav", + "text": "公私立的學生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147898/166.wav", + "text": "要補助私立學校" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147898/167.wav", + "text": "現在打算從明年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147898/168.wav", + "text": "開始所以今年提了1個預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147898/169.wav", + "text": "有165.7億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147898/170.wav", + "text": "學生每個人3.5萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147898/171.wav", + "text": "部長這個3.5萬是怎麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147898/172.wav", + "text": "算出來的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147898/173.wav", + "text": "跟委員報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147898/174.wav", + "text": "公立跟私立學校" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147898/175.wav", + "text": "的差距是5萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147898/176.wav", + "text": "滿大的一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147898/177.wav", + "text": "負擔差別" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147898/178.wav", + "text": "達到協助比如像七成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147898/179.wav", + "text": "這樣的概念" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147898/180.wav", + "text": "這當然不可能完全拉齊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147898/181.wav", + "text": "所以當時就是以差額5萬的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147898/182.wav", + "text": "左右來估算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147898/183.wav", + "text": "大概有75%的私立大專" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147898/184.wav", + "text": "占到82.36%" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147898/185.wav", + "text": "其實很高所以有些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147898/186.wav", + "text": "比較特殊極端的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147898/187.wav", + "text": "大學都有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147898/188.wav", + "text": "可能就要背到八九十萬的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147898/189.wav", + "text": "貸款" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147898/190.wav", + "text": "這一點謝謝委員這麼深入瞭解" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147898/191.wav", + "text": "們做過這幾次也發現到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147898/192.wav", + "text": "學生尤其" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147898/193.wav", + "text": "已經有差不多將近74萬名學生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147898/194.wav", + "text": "是將近1004百多億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147898/195.wav", + "text": "從上次疫後的那次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147898/196.wav", + "text": "一次性的我們發現" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147898/197.wav", + "text": "終究不能從源頭" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147898/198.wav", + "text": "的差距就比較能夠讓學生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147898/199.wav", + "text": "可能不用再背負" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147898/200.wav", + "text": "學貸負擔" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147898/201.wav", + "text": "落實所以本席希望" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147898/202.wav", + "text": "我想這是一個方向" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147898/203.wav", + "text": "明年肯定是來不及" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147898/204.wav", + "text": "可是我們希望這是一個方向" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147898/205.wav", + "text": "我們長期關注" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147898/206.wav", + "text": "情況所以也希望這個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147898/207.wav", + "text": "能夠有效地去協助" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147898/208.wav", + "text": "學生能夠得到比較好的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147898/209.wav", + "text": "教育資源" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147898/210.wav", + "text": "部長在這邊大概先做一個簡單的說法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147898/211.wav", + "text": "\n接下來要再" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147898/212.wav", + "text": "問的其實是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147898/213.wav", + "text": "資訊與科技教育行政及督導─" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147898/214.wav", + "text": "資訊科技融入教" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147898/215.wav", + "text": "數位學習相關的經費30億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147898/216.wav", + "text": "萬的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147898/217.wav", + "text": "數��學習精進方案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147898/218.wav", + "text": "就在這裡面所以本席" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147898/219.wav", + "text": "上次提到班班有網路" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147898/220.wav", + "text": "生生用平板是不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147898/221.wav", + "text": "就在這筆預算當中去執行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147898/222.wav", + "text": "在咬耳朵你可能沒有聽到我的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147898/223.wav", + "text": "我說我上次在質詢的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147898/224.wav", + "text": "提到班班有網路" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147898/225.wav", + "text": "此持續推動預算是不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147898/226.wav", + "text": "用這個項下的預算去執行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147898/227.wav", + "text": "是因為它是一個持續性的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147898/228.wav", + "text": "是嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147898/229.wav", + "text": "因為生生用平板" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147898/230.wav", + "text": "老師怎麼去教" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147898/231.wav", + "text": "大螢幕的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147898/232.wav", + "text": "小的平板那老師怎麼跟小朋友" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147898/233.wav", + "text": "溝通如果教室裡面沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147898/234.wav", + "text": "一個大平板跟他同步連線" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147898/235.wav", + "text": "的時候那老師要怎麼教" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147898/236.wav", + "text": "所以本席特別提到對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147898/237.wav", + "text": "這個也是很多教育現場" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147898/238.wav", + "text": "的老師他們跟本席反映" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147898/239.wav", + "text": "的問題可是在本席" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147898/240.wav", + "text": "及地方政府提出幾次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147898/241.wav", + "text": "打槍了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147898/242.wav", + "text": "那本席後來再跟教育部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147898/243.wav", + "text": "索資的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147898/244.wav", + "text": "你們也給了一部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147898/245.wav", + "text": "你們大約會有七千萬要來做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147898/246.wav", + "text": "很少一千萬買不了幾個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147898/247.wav", + "text": "我們既然要做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147898/248.wav", + "text": "生生有平板是不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147898/249.wav", + "text": "真的能夠走進校園" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147898/250.wav", + "text": "這樣老師在教學的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147898/251.wav", + "text": "才能真正方便" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147898/252.wav", + "text": "才能真正使用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147898/253.wav", + "text": "我跟委員報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147898/254.wav", + "text": "委員現在提的是我們接續" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147898/255.wav", + "text": "相關計畫但是往前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147898/256.wav", + "text": "委員之前我們在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147898/257.wav", + "text": "審議前瞻計畫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147898/258.wav", + "text": "時也可以瞭解到第一期第二期" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147898/259.wav", + "text": "總共投入了135億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147898/260.wav", + "text": "當時在做的就是協助各縣市" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147898/261.wav", + "text": "中年級以上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147898/262.wav", + "text": "���三年級以上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147898/263.wav", + "text": "）整個建置將近7萬間的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147898/264.wav", + "text": "智慧教室" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147898/265.wav", + "text": "那這裡面當然當時" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147898/266.wav", + "text": "也因應學校" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147898/267.wav", + "text": "老師們的使用習慣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147898/268.wav", + "text": "所以這個智慧型的教室裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147898/269.wav", + "text": "事實上就是大螢幕的概念" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147898/270.wav", + "text": "委員所說的觸控式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147898/271.wav", + "text": "有些學校是延續用原來的投影機" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147898/272.wav", + "text": "螢幕的方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147898/273.wav", + "text": "其實在前瞻" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147898/274.wav", + "text": "計畫裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147898/275.wav", + "text": "曾經做過就是剛才跟委員報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147898/276.wav", + "text": "以並不是從零開始的概念" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147898/277.wav", + "text": "是反映目前的教育現場" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147898/278.wav", + "text": "很多人他們覺得就是有缺" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147898/279.wav", + "text": "部長能夠在這個部分儘" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147898/280.wav", + "text": "儘可能去滿足" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147898/281.wav", + "text": "所以之後我想說請部長跟" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147898/282.wav", + "text": "司到本辦這邊來溝通" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147898/283.wav", + "text": "我會請資科司整個再盤整一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147898/284.wav", + "text": "但是剛才跟委員報告的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147898/285.wav", + "text": "智慧教室都是新設" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147898/286.wav", + "text": "期限如果說今天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147898/287.wav", + "text": "它不足是因為沒有裝設足夠的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147898/288.wav", + "text": "數量我們再來考慮" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147898/289.wav", + "text": "否則原來選擇" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147898/290.wav", + "text": "投影機的方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147898/291.wav", + "text": "現在本席反映的狀態" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147898/292.wav", + "text": "也要做智慧教室" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147898/293.wav", + "text": "其實他們就是覺得有不足" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147898/294.wav", + "text": "部長剛剛也提到就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147898/295.wav", + "text": "如果之前用別的方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147898/296.wav", + "text": "那我們當然就不會再爭取" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147898/297.wav", + "text": "可是如果沒有的時候我們就希望" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147898/298.wav", + "text": "部長這邊能夠多加支持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147898/299.wav", + "text": "預算規模很大" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147898/300.wav", + "text": "剛剛跟委員報告有135億左右" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147898/301.wav", + "text": "所以這個部分我們再跟縣市" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147898/302.wav", + "text": "瞭解他們所謂的不足是哪一些部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147898/303.wav", + "text": "然後我們再來籌編" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147898/304.wav", + "text": "準備後續的相關預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147898/305.wav", + "text": "我們可以來做這方面的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147898/306.wav", + "text": "一些爭取" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147898/307.wav", + "text": "OK那我們再請資科司事後到本辦公室" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147898/308.wav", + "text": "這邊來做一個溝通" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147898/309.wav", + "text": "\n我最後要再問一個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147898/310.wav", + "text": "就是有關於液蛋的事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147898/311.wav", + "text": "因為上個月" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147898/312.wav", + "text": "就開始禁止營養午餐" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147898/313.wav", + "text": "使用液蛋" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147898/314.wav", + "text": "當時其實部長您跟陳建仁" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147898/315.wav", + "text": "院長大概都表示" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147898/316.wav", + "text": "我記得當時我還查了一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147898/317.wav", + "text": "媒體報導說您的原話是說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147898/318.wav", + "text": "一味禁止使用液蛋" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147898/319.wav", + "text": "不是最好的方法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147898/320.wav", + "text": "而是要嚴格查禁" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147898/321.wav", + "text": "不讓不合規範的蛋品" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147898/322.wav", + "text": "進到校園" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147898/323.wav", + "text": "那本席想問的狀態是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147898/324.wav", + "text": "而且你第二天就發文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147898/325.wav", + "text": "本來就應該要用國產蛋" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147898/326.wav", + "text": "混用國外的蛋" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147898/327.wav", + "text": "跟國內的蛋" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147898/328.wav", + "text": "蛋混充液蛋那個狀態" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147898/329.wav", + "text": "所以我想問一下部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147898/330.wav", + "text": "我們要怎麼樣去嚴格查禁" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147898/331.wav", + "text": "因為你把這個責任" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147898/332.wav", + "text": "推到每個學校的教育現場" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147898/333.wav", + "text": "那教育現場他們要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147898/334.wav", + "text": "怎麼去查禁這個液蛋的標示" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147898/335.wav", + "text": "跟委員報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147898/336.wav", + "text": "當時社會大眾在關注這個議題時農業部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147898/337.wav", + "text": "直接一再對外說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147898/338.wav", + "text": "都是國產蛋" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147898/339.wav", + "text": "這是他說明的第一個前提" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147898/340.wav", + "text": "契約範本已經嚴格到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147898/341.wav", + "text": "只要你敢用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147898/342.wav", + "text": "混用或是冒用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147898/343.wav", + "text": "撤除解約" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147898/344.wav", + "text": "防護之下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147898/345.wav", + "text": "但仍有部分地方政府禁止用液" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147898/346.wav", + "text": "學生飲食均衡會發生問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147898/347.wav", + "text": "所以我當時才會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147898/348.wav", + "text": "特別作說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147898/349.wav", + "text": "農業部當時也特別提到說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147898/350.wav", + "text": "他們有所謂的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147898/351.wav", + "text": "混合蛋其實都在他們的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147898/352.wav", + "text": "冷鏈倉庫裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147898/353.wav", + "text": "並沒有流到市面上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147898/354.wav", + "text": "所以我才會說當學校" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147898/355.wav", + "text": "每天都去查核的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147898/356.wav", + "text": "應該就這個工作上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147898/357.wav", + "text": "來處理而不是用禁止的方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147898/358.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147898/359.wav", + "text": "你的回答我理解" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147898/360.wav", + "text": "只是說因為這樣的公文發下去的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147898/361.wav", + "text": "感覺好像就是一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147898/362.wav", + "text": "沒有負責任的狀態" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147898/363.wav", + "text": "我們當然希望在整個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147898/364.wav", + "text": "教育校園現場的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147898/365.wav", + "text": "大家能夠吃到營養的蛋" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147898/366.wav", + "text": "而且是安全不要有混充" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147898/367.wav", + "text": "有一個月了有些縣市他們還是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147898/368.wav", + "text": "繼續禁用那後續要怎麼樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147898/369.wav", + "text": "再請部長這邊再跟本辦公室做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147898/370.wav", + "text": "一個回應" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147898/371.wav", + "text": "不過跟委員補充報告因為我想學校" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147898/372.wav", + "text": "只要有人提供給他們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147898/373.wav", + "text": "更上層的食材來源" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147898/374.wav", + "text": "只要有用到都要跟他們解約" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147898/375.wav", + "text": "並不是說要學校單獨承擔" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147898/376.wav", + "text": "因為一層一層的法規" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147898/377.wav", + "text": "我會這樣問是因為你們9月21號" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147898/378.wav", + "text": "自己去承擔所以我就覺得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147898/379.wav", + "text": "發文當中感覺有點推卸責任的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147898/380.wav", + "text": "那現在這沒問題我們之後再做溝通" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147898/381.wav", + "text": "\n最後我要再問一個東西" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147898/382.wav", + "text": "就是在我們跟教育部索資的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147898/383.wav", + "text": "跟國教署這邊現在彭署長也" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147898/384.wav", + "text": "已經站在旁邊了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147898/385.wav", + "text": "在補助地方政府高中以下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147898/386.wav", + "text": "各級學校改善" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147898/387.wav", + "text": "設施設備的資料裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147898/388.wav", + "text": "裡面有一部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147898/389.wav", + "text": "比新竹縣苗栗都少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147898/390.wav", + "text": "而且少很多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147898/391.wav", + "text": "所以本席希望就這個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147898/392.wav", + "text": "亦即針對強化數位教學" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147898/393.wav", + "text": "暨學習資訊應用環境的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147898/394.wav", + "text": "其實新竹市得到的預算非常非常的少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147898/395.wav", + "text": "我們想瞭��一下情況到底是如何" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147898/396.wav", + "text": "相關的教育資源到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147898/397.wav", + "text": "新竹市這邊來的能夠更多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147898/398.wav", + "text": "這是我們非常期待的一個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147898/399.wav", + "text": "大概是這樣子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147898/400.wav", + "text": "你們給我們的資料" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147898/401.wav", + "text": "我想之後再請教育部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147898/402.wav", + "text": "相關單位再到本辦公室來做說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147898/403.wav", + "text": "跟委員報告這些資源" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147898/404.wav", + "text": "都會按照學校校數" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147898/405.wav", + "text": "班級數學生數的規模做考量" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147898/406.wav", + "text": "司跟委員說明好其實" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147898/407.wav", + "text": "新竹市跟新竹縣不應該差這麼多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147898/408.wav", + "text": "新竹縣其實得到的也不多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147898/409.wav", + "text": "所以我們希望幫新竹縣市的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147898/410.wav", + "text": "學校爭取到更多的教育資源" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147898/411.wav", + "text": "謝謝主席也給我這麼長的時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147898/412.wav", + "text": "謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147896/0.wav", + "text": "謝謝主席麻煩請審計長主計長財政部長經濟部陳次長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147896/1.wav", + "text": "請4位首長4" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147896/2.wav", + "text": "4位好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147896/3.wav", + "text": "第一個問題要請教主計長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147896/4.wav", + "text": "我們今年的GDP能夠保1.5%嗎你的估算是1.61%對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147896/5.wav", + "text": "可是我們看到IMF在你公布之後的當天立即打臉你" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147896/6.wav", + "text": "%標普也下降到0.5" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147896/7.wav", + "text": "%我現在請教你" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147896/8.wav", + "text": "今年的GDP很務實的到底能夠保多少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147896/9.wav", + "text": "因為目前的數據資料並沒有辦法顯示出明年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147896/10.wav", + "text": "所以你不肯講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147896/11.wav", + "text": "因為11月要公布理論上來講你現在已經有一點點概念了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147896/12.wav", + "text": "這總可以講吧" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147896/13.wav", + "text": "你也不能講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147896/14.wav", + "text": "好沒關係" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147896/15.wav", + "text": "我下一個問題要請教財政部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147896/16.wav", + "text": "主計總處不能講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147896/17.wav", + "text": "連會不會調都不能講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147896/18.wav", + "text": "我們看一下財政部的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147896/19.wav", + "text": "已經有47%的申報戶免" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147896/20.wav", + "text": "免繳稅你覺得很光榮嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147896/21.wav", + "text": "你覺得很光榮" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147896/22.wav", + "text": "這是你的政績" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147896/23.wav", + "text": "這是在呈現上我們對於所得較低的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147896/24.wav", + "text": "讓他免稅減輕租稅負擔" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147896/25.wav", + "text": "這個是你��政績" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147896/26.wav", + "text": "你認為均貧──讓我們的國人均貧" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147896/27.wav", + "text": "不用繳稅是財政部的政績" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147896/28.wav", + "text": "這不是均貧" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147896/29.wav", + "text": "這是均貧啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147896/30.wav", + "text": "已經有47%申報戶免繳稅了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147896/31.wav", + "text": "我們真正的目的是讓大家均富" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147896/32.wav", + "text": "因為我們提高了相關的免稅額" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147896/33.wav", + "text": "這一篇小編的內容你看過沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147896/34.wav", + "text": "我看過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147896/35.wav", + "text": "所以並不是小編當道你當擺設" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147896/36.wav", + "text": "你是真的看過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147896/37.wav", + "text": "而且你也不在乎年輕人低薪的壓力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147896/38.wav", + "text": "你不在乎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147896/39.wav", + "text": "你覺得這個是你的政績" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147896/40.wav", + "text": "我們來檢討一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147896/41.wav", + "text": "為什麼年輕人會苦哈哈" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147896/42.wav", + "text": "我們看到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147896/43.wav", + "text": "弊案連連" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147896/44.wav", + "text": "就別講說是什麼超思啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147896/45.wav", + "text": "然後快篩啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147896/46.wav", + "text": "高端啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147896/47.wav", + "text": "雲豹啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147896/48.wav", + "text": "別講這些民眾所知的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147896/49.wav", + "text": "我們看一下實質薪資" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147896/50.wav", + "text": "這個數據來源其實也是從主計總處" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147896/51.wav", + "text": "我們看到從109年的全年到111年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147896/52.wav", + "text": "直線下降的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147896/53.wav", + "text": "所以每個人每月的實質" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147896/54.wav", + "text": "往下大家可以看到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147896/55.wav", + "text": "是不是有往上揚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147896/56.wav", + "text": "的確是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147896/57.wav", + "text": "我們看到GDP的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147896/58.wav", + "text": "2021年的時候是高達92.6萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147896/59.wav", + "text": "中位數的部分是50.6萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147896/60.wav", + "text": "是很明顯的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147896/61.wav", + "text": "它的差異性是越來越大" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147896/62.wav", + "text": "我們再看一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147896/63.wav", + "text": "所以你會看到貧富差距是擴大" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147896/64.wav", + "text": "也就是說臺灣從K型的經濟" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147896/65.wav", + "text": "因為你們的貢獻" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147896/66.wav", + "text": "我們看到這個變成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147896/67.wav", + "text": "我們看一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147896/68.wav", + "text": "每個人每月的經常性薪資" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147896/69.wav", + "text": "109年的時候還是正數" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147896/70.wav", + "text": "到110年的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147896/71.wav", + "text": "變成負數" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147896/72.wav", + "text": "負成長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147896/73.wav", + "text": "111年的地方" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147896/74.wav", + "text": "更是負成長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147896/75.wav", + "text": "理論上來講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147896/76.wav", + "text": "主計長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147896/77.wav", + "text": "或者是我們在座的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147896/78.wav", + "text": "如果你有體會到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147896/79.wav", + "text": "趕不上GDP成長的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147896/80.wav", + "text": "你應該就會有所為嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147896/81.wav", + "text": "對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147896/82.wav", + "text": "你應該就會有所為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147896/83.wav", + "text": "對不起不好意思" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147896/84.wav", + "text": "我把審計" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147896/85.wav", + "text": "最近幾個月是正成長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147896/86.wav", + "text": "你怎麼能夠比整個月呢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147896/87.wav", + "text": "你厲害耶" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147896/88.wav", + "text": "你就像財政部一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147896/89.wav", + "text": "因為你在講那個時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147896/90.wav", + "text": "你會不會調整的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147896/91.wav", + "text": "你說你現在不能夠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147896/92.wav", + "text": "只差幾天而已" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147896/93.wav", + "text": "你都不能夠講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147896/94.wav", + "text": "然後現在這個是全年度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147896/95.wav", + "text": "比的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147896/96.wav", + "text": "你就拿幾個月的東西來比" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147896/97.wav", + "text": "那我跟你講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147896/98.wav", + "text": "所以我就講說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147896/99.wav", + "text": "你沉迷數字遊戲" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147896/100.wav", + "text": "你喜歡去湊數字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147896/101.wav", + "text": "然後你喜歡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147896/102.wav", + "text": "箭射過去之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147896/103.wav", + "text": "你用那個數字去湊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147896/104.wav", + "text": "當人家在做全年度的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147896/105.wav", + "text": "比較的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147896/106.wav", + "text": "你有看哪一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147896/107.wav", + "text": "對於它財報的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147896/108.wav", + "text": "是可以從對它有利的區間去做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147896/109.wav", + "text": "你連你要求民間的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147896/110.wav", + "text": "你都做不到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147896/111.wav", + "text": "然後你行政單位可以用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147896/112.wav", + "text": "你想要講好聽的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147896/113.wav", + "text": "所以我就講說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147896/114.wav", + "text": "這壞習慣嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147896/115.wav", + "text": "我們再看一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147896/116.wav", + "text": "審計部連續地示警你" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147896/117.wav", + "text": "你到底有沒有看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147896/118.wav", + "text": "審計部���你的報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147896/119.wav", + "text": "還是說你把它擺在一邊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147896/120.wav", + "text": "你都有看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147896/121.wav", + "text": "110年的總決算報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147896/122.wav", + "text": "勞工薪資成長率" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147896/123.wav", + "text": "漲幅趨緩" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147896/124.wav", + "text": "它其實已經講得很圓融了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147896/125.wav", + "text": "已經怕刺激到你這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147896/126.wav", + "text": "曾經是他的長官的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147896/127.wav", + "text": "但是111年它" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147896/128.wav", + "text": "它已經忍無可忍它" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147896/129.wav", + "text": "它就講說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147896/130.wav", + "text": "居住成本年年攀升" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147896/131.wav", + "text": "加劇可支配所得不均" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147896/132.wav", + "text": "你說你有看它的報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147896/133.wav", + "text": "那你到底有沒有看報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147896/134.wav", + "text": "有沒有看進去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147896/135.wav", + "text": "啊審計部連續地示警你" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147896/136.wav", + "text": "你就是不理會它" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147896/137.wav", + "text": "是因為它曾經是你的部屬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147896/138.wav", + "text": "所以你不理會它嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147896/139.wav", + "text": "民眾的心情難受" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147896/140.wav", + "text": "啊你今天不是就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147896/141.wav", + "text": "我們講說行政單位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147896/142.wav", + "text": "應該是公僕嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147896/143.wav", + "text": "你這個是奴高震主啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147896/144.wav", + "text": "你是完全不把它當一回事嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147896/145.wav", + "text": "主計長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147896/146.wav", + "text": "我不接受你這種說法謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147896/147.wav", + "text": "你不接受" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147896/148.wav", + "text": "但是你的行為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147896/149.wav", + "text": "為什麼要表現" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147896/150.wav", + "text": "我覺得很奇怪啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147896/151.wav", + "text": "你的行為做的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147896/152.wav", + "text": "你言行不一致" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147896/153.wav", + "text": "看我們再看一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147896/154.wav", + "text": "您的報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147896/155.wav", + "text": "你的白紙黑字都講說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147896/156.wav", + "text": "每個人的差距倍數" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147896/157.wav", + "text": "從90年代是4.16到4.59" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147896/158.wav", + "text": "這個區間在變動" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147896/159.wav", + "text": "然後你就講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147896/160.wav", + "text": "是3.84到4.29" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147896/161.wav", + "text": "然後到110年到111年的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147896/162.wav", + "text": "變成3.91到3.93" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147896/163.wav", + "text": "你厲害" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147896/164.wav", + "text": "跟110年度到111年度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147896/165.wav", + "text": "你能夠張著眼睛說瞎話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147896/166.wav", + "text": "它是縮小趨勢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147896/167.wav", + "text": "在你這裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147896/168.wav", + "text": "唯一可以縮小的趨勢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147896/169.wav", + "text": "是你拿來比較90年代" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147896/170.wav", + "text": "或者你拿來比較100年代的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147896/171.wav", + "text": "最高標準" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147896/172.wav", + "text": "你自己的數字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147896/173.wav", + "text": "你自己的報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147896/174.wav", + "text": "你也能夠張著眼睛說瞎話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147896/175.wav", + "text": "我們看一下審計部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147896/176.wav", + "text": "審計部都告訴你說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147896/177.wav", + "text": "倍數從6.07倍" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147896/178.wav", + "text": "增加到111年度的6.15倍" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147896/179.wav", + "text": "所得差距成擴大趨勢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147896/180.wav", + "text": "我們講說審計部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147896/181.wav", + "text": "前面已經跟你講了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147896/182.wav", + "text": "然後你不聽" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147896/183.wav", + "text": "然後你實際上面的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147896/184.wav", + "text": "剛才你自己的數據" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147896/185.wav", + "text": "人家給你看了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147896/186.wav", + "text": "你還要去捏造" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147896/187.wav", + "text": "用幾個月的期間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147896/188.wav", + "text": "然後接下來你還要講說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147896/189.wav", + "text": "明明是有擴大的趨勢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147896/190.wav", + "text": "你還要張著眼睛說瞎話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147896/191.wav", + "text": "說它是縮小的趨勢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147896/192.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147896/193.wav", + "text": "我們看到目前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147896/194.wav", + "text": "主計總處做了什麼事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147896/195.wav", + "text": "沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147896/196.wav", + "text": "你就是去玩這些數字遊戲" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147896/197.wav", + "text": "但是我還是要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147896/198.wav", + "text": "很懇切地提醒主計總處" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147896/199.wav", + "text": "很多的民間企業" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147896/200.wav", + "text": "是看著你的數據" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147896/201.wav", + "text": "去做自己的規劃" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147896/202.wav", + "text": "或者是你為了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147896/203.wav", + "text": "要給老百姓洗腦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147896/204.wav", + "text": "然後你提供這些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147896/205.wav", + "text": "我們看到的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147896/206.wav", + "text": "你知道在國外" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147896/207.wav", + "text": "錯誤的數據有責任" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147896/208.wav", + "text": "在國外連提供數據去誤導" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147896/209.wav", + "text": "導都是有責任的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147896/210.wav", + "text": "你如果再講說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147896/211.wav", + "text": "你follow OECD" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147896/212.wav", + "text": "政府的資訊透明的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147896/213.wav", + "text": "那你第一個就不及格" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147896/214.wav", + "text": "另外一個就是經濟部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147896/215.wav", + "text": "經濟部我請問你一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147896/216.wav", + "text": "你們現在在做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147896/217.wav", + "text": "任何的解決方案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147896/218.wav", + "text": "找企業界來喝咖啡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147896/219.wav", + "text": "或者是閉門造車嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147896/220.wav", + "text": "你有務實地解決嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147896/221.wav", + "text": "還是找企業界來喝咖啡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147896/222.wav", + "text": "然後叫人家加薪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147896/223.wav", + "text": "我們跟企業界的諮商諮詢討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147896/224.wav", + "text": "好你覺得務實" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147896/225.wav", + "text": "我們來看一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147896/226.wav", + "text": "你的報告上面講說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147896/227.wav", + "text": "你要怎麼樣強化加薪的動能" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147896/228.wav", + "text": "你說你要創造高科技產業" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147896/229.wav", + "text": "優質的工作" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147896/230.wav", + "text": "跟高薪的機會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147896/231.wav", + "text": "我們看到原來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147896/232.wav", + "text": "勞動部次長講說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147896/233.wav", + "text": "年輕人的薪資低" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147896/234.wav", + "text": "是因為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147896/235.wav", + "text": "但我請教你" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147896/236.wav", + "text": "你的六缺問題解了嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147896/237.wav", + "text": "沒解吧" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147896/238.wav", + "text": "缺水缺電缺工缺土地" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147896/239.wav", + "text": "缺人才缺投資" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147896/240.wav", + "text": "你解了嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147896/241.wav", + "text": "沒解" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147896/242.wav", + "text": "啊我們看到實際上面的數字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147896/243.wav", + "text": "你六缺的問題沒解" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147896/244.wav", + "text": "啊我們看到產業有沒有出走" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147896/245.wav", + "text": "產業是出走" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147896/246.wav", + "text": "啊我們看到台積電到哪裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147896/247.wav", + "text": "呢我們看到台積電到美國投資" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147896/248.wav", + "text": "到日本投資" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147896/249.wav", + "text": "然後這些問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147896/250.wav", + "text": "不僅僅六缺問題沒有解" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147896/251.wav", + "text": "產業出走" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147896/252.wav", + "text": "我請問你" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147896/253.wav", + "text": "你也在講話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147896/254.wav", + "text": "是他在質詢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147896/255.wav", + "text": "還是你在質詢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147896/256.wav", + "text": "他會留時間給你講嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147896/257.wav", + "text": "太不像話了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147896/258.wav", + "text": "就因為你喝喝咖啡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147896/259.wav", + "text": "人家就必須要買單" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147896/260.wav", + "text": "因為你是行政單位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147896/261.wav", + "text": "高高在上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147896/262.wav", + "text": "民不與官鬥" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147896/263.wav", + "text": "所以你怎麼說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147896/264.wav", + "text": "它就必須要怎麼做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147896/265.wav", + "text": "然後上次我很訝異的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147896/266.wav", + "text": "就是我請教你們在做規劃的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147896/267.wav", + "text": "有沒有考慮到國際的局勢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147896/268.wav", + "text": "部長的回答是說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147896/269.wav", + "text": "他只顧產業的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147896/270.wav", + "text": "他不管國際的局勢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147896/271.wav", + "text": "我的天啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147896/272.wav", + "text": "經濟部是這樣的態度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147896/273.wav", + "text": "就是閉門造車" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147896/274.wav", + "text": "你的產業規劃" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147896/275.wav", + "text": "剛剛在回應委員講的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147896/276.wav", + "text": "說產業出走" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147896/277.wav", + "text": "最近外人投資是在成長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147896/278.wav", + "text": "也就是說產業不但沒有出走" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147896/279.wav", + "text": "其實臺灣的投資是成長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147896/280.wav", + "text": "我跟你講次長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147896/281.wav", + "text": "我真的不想讓你難堪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147896/282.wav", + "text": "所以我沒講另外一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147896/283.wav", + "text": "有多少是真的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147896/284.wav", + "text": "\n我下一個趕快" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147896/285.wav", + "text": "因為時間到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147896/286.wav", + "text": "無薪假的人數破萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147896/287.wav", + "text": "這個警訊重現" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147896/288.wav", + "text": "你們現在在台上的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147896/289.wav", + "text": "4位知道還是不知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147896/290.wav", + "text": "這個你們知道還是不知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147896/291.wav", + "text": "你知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147896/292.wav", + "text": "很好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147896/293.wav", + "text": "總算你的幕僚不錯" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147896/294.wav", + "text": "\n在這樣的情況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147896/295.wav", + "text": "下無薪假單週暴增逾一成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147896/296.wav", + "text": "再加上我本來說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147896/297.wav", + "text": "的ECFA造成的影響" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147896/298.wav", + "text": "臺中地區" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147896/299.wav", + "text": "對於這些主計長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147896/300.wav", + "text": "很理直氣壯的說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147896/301.wav", + "text": "今年在能不能保一的情況之下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147896/302.wav", + "text": "ECFA不納入考慮" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147896/303.wav", + "text": "臺灣的企業能夠讓你們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147896/304.wav", + "text": "這樣子閉門造車" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147896/305.wav", + "text": "這樣子玩" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147896/306.wav", + "text": "嗎你這不是荒唐" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147896/307.wav", + "text": "免稅的人超過47%" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147896/308.wav", + "text": "然後你在考慮經營成長率的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147896/309.wav", + "text": "不考慮ECFA" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147896/310.wav", + "text": "T然後自己閉門造車" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147896/311.wav", + "text": "然後說我喝喝咖啡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147896/312.wav", + "text": "你就得加薪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147896/313.wav", + "text": "你們是不是荒唐" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147896/314.wav", + "text": "不過今天我要讚揚審計長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147896/315.wav", + "text": "謝謝審計長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147896/316.wav", + "text": "不屈不撓" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147896/317.wav", + "text": "在壓力之下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147896/318.wav", + "text": "還能夠做出真實的報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147896/319.wav", + "text": "以上謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147896/320.wav", + "text": "好謝謝各位請" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147895/0.wav", + "text": "署長\n部長署長看你們的預算書農田水利的建設" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147895/1.wav", + "text": "你們3年編了113億我一直在查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147895/2.wav", + "text": "你這個農田水利建設113億是要擴大非輪灌地區的建設" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147895/3.wav", + "text": "但是我現在到苗栗我沒有看到你們在苗栗有什麼建設啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147895/4.wav", + "text": "我可不可以請我們署長回答一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147895/5.wav", + "text": "好\n署長有沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147895/6.wav", + "text": "有有有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147895/7.wav", + "text": "110如果在苗栗大概比例占了多少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147895/8.wav", + "text": "因為我從來沒有看見感覺到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147895/9.wav", + "text": "有像在苗栗的大湖事實上我們之前也有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147895/10.wav", + "text": "你把110年度到112年度農田水利建設裡面總經費113億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147895/11.wav", + "text": "到底在苗栗花在哪個地方讓我曉得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147895/12.wav", + "text": "好沒有問題我們可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147895/13.wav", + "text": "好不好趕快整理給我" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147895/14.wav", + "text": "再來你們今年度的預算裡面有一個平地農路改善工程" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147895/15.wav", + "text": "3年經費編了24.56億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147895/16.wav", + "text": "裡面你們說包括農地重劃區" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147895/17.wav", + "text": "但是我發覺我們苗栗很多農地重劃區" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147895/18.wav", + "text": "我到你那邊你們都跟我講沒有錢那這個錢到底花到哪裡啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147895/19.wav", + "text": "我對你不錯怎麼到你那邊都說沒有錢讓我很頭痛啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147895/20.wav", + "text": "後來才有以前都沒有後來是被我問" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147895/21.wav", + "text": "我說我要看你們的預算書" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147895/22.wav", + "text": "你們才吞吞吐吐地拿出來大方一點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147895/23.wav", + "text": "我那邊的農地重劃很多啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147895/24.wav", + "text": "那個都已經破破爛爛了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147895/25.wav", + "text": "你現在是當部長的人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147895/26.wav", + "text": "你這邊我是看了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147895/27.wav", + "text": "你的平地農路改善啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147895/28.wav", + "text": "還有包括農地重劃區" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147895/29.wav", + "text": "要用在灌溉排的地方" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147895/30.wav", + "text": "其他的你不要管太多啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147895/31.wav", + "text": "還是挪到別的地方" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147895/32.wav", + "text": "沒有沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147895/33.wav", + "text": "黨的命令在執行這些計畫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147895/34.wav", + "text": "到平地大概都是灌溉溝渠裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147895/35.wav", + "text": "農地重劃都是你們灌溉溝渠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147895/36.wav", + "text": "你要加強在這個地方" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147895/37.wav", + "text": "持署現在我們把你們算清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147895/38.wav", + "text": "不會啦不會啦委員我們不會這樣子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147895/39.wav", + "text": "我為什麼今天叫你們兩個大官來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147895/40.wav", + "text": "署平地農路改善" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147895/41.wav", + "text": "的話我不講山坡地" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147895/42.wav", + "text": "我講平地改善" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147895/43.wav", + "text": "婆水保的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147895/44.wav", + "text": "你也說包括農地重劃區" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147895/45.wav", + "text": "你們的農地重劃區" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147895/46.wav", + "text": "今年15億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147895/47.wav", + "text": "到底你會不會從我去找你們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147895/48.wav", + "text": "水保署說這個不是它的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147895/49.wav", + "text": "這個是農水署的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147895/50.wav", + "text": "我去找農水署它也說不是它的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147895/51.wav", + "text": "是水保的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147895/52.wav", + "text": "錢編在你那邊不要把" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147895/53.wav", + "text": "弄來唬弄去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147895/54.wav", + "text": "明年度預算大概9.59億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147895/55.wav", + "text": "啦整個經費大概是47億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147895/56.wav", + "text": "有關於農村水保署跟農田水利署" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147895/57.wav", + "text": "本身所應該負的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147895/58.wav", + "text": "他們有很明確的一個分工" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147895/59.wav", + "text": "所以不會說互相卸責" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147895/60.wav", + "text": "有啦有明確的分工" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147895/61.wav", + "text": "農地重劃區應該是農水" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147895/62.wav", + "text": "對農地重劃是農水署" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147895/63.wav", + "text": "裡面有很多住家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147895/64.wav", + "text": "有的住家比較少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147895/65.wav", + "text": "我只要求你" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147895/66.wav", + "text": "地方政府沒有錢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147895/67.wav", + "text": "幾十年都沒有修補" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147895/68.wav", + "text": "特別跟我加強一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147895/69.wav", + "text": "你們兩個單位不要再拖" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147895/70.wav", + "text": "只有���開預算書你們才嚇到說好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147895/71.wav", + "text": "好不" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147895/72.wav", + "text": "好做事情不" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147895/73.wav", + "text": "不會啦輕重緩急我們分得很清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147895/74.wav", + "text": "好兩位署長請回座" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147895/75.wav", + "text": "陳部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147895/76.wav", + "text": "這個在陳主委的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147895/77.wav", + "text": "我就提醒交代了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147895/78.wav", + "text": "應該跟農糧署有關係" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147895/79.wav", + "text": "我現在選舉選得很難" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147895/80.wav", + "text": "因為在陳主委的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147895/81.wav", + "text": "我有特別跟你們討論到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147895/82.wav", + "text": "在休耕的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147895/83.wav", + "text": "國有耕地" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147895/84.wav", + "text": "只有領取節水獎勵金" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147895/85.wav", + "text": "但是他要繳土地稅金" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147895/86.wav", + "text": "有休耕補助" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147895/87.wav", + "text": "還有節水獎勵" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147895/88.wav", + "text": "耕作的農民" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147895/89.wav", + "text": "只有節水獎勵" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147895/90.wav", + "text": "沒有休耕補助" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147895/91.wav", + "text": "國有農地的農民" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147895/92.wav", + "text": "你說他沒有去翻耕所以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147895/93.wav", + "text": "所以不予補助" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147895/94.wav", + "text": "而私有農地的農民" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147895/95.wav", + "text": "是有補助" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147895/96.wav", + "text": "國有農地的農民" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147895/97.wav", + "text": "你們沒有辦法讓他交公糧" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147895/98.wav", + "text": "它再生稻" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147895/99.wav", + "text": "有時後面下雨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147895/100.wav", + "text": "他們把稻子種回去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147895/101.wav", + "text": "我跟他說我們要到國有財產署" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147895/102.wav", + "text": "去協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147895/103.wav", + "text": "為什麼我一定要堅持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147895/104.wav", + "text": "這一點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147895/105.wav", + "text": "因為休耕是政府的政策" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147895/106.wav", + "text": "農民配合你的政策" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147895/107.wav", + "text": "休耕不是他願意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147895/108.wav", + "text": "休耕是你們叫他休耕" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147895/109.wav", + "text": "的他也沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147895/110.wav", + "text": "休耕補助" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147895/111.wav", + "text": "還要繳" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147895/112.wav", + "text": "不然你們兩項就要選擇一項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147895/113.wav", + "text": "你給他休耕補助讓他去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147895/114.wav", + "text": "去繳給國有財產署" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147895/115.wav", + "text": "這好幾千公頃的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147895/116.wav", + "text": "耶你要把我害的悽慘落魄" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147895/117.wav", + "text": "結果都沒有解決" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147895/118.wav", + "text": "我們因為選舉在忙沒有追你們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147895/119.wav", + "text": "這是一個制度的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147895/120.wav", + "text": "你不能這樣說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147895/121.wav", + "text": "不是我要打斷你的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147895/122.wav", + "text": "我是農民" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147895/123.wav", + "text": "農民都一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147895/124.wav", + "text": "是你的政策" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147895/125.wav", + "text": "叫我不要去耕種" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147895/126.wav", + "text": "不是啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147895/127.wav", + "text": "所以我們會去協調" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147895/128.wav", + "text": "所以我今天講重點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147895/129.wav", + "text": "的過去了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147895/130.wav", + "text": "換我來替你們開" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147895/131.wav", + "text": "我常常在說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147895/132.wav", + "text": "嘛我想說你們很有能力的人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147895/133.wav", + "text": "原來也是如此一般而已" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147895/134.wav", + "text": "有時候在土地管理的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147895/135.wav", + "text": "角度跟我們農業部的角度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147895/136.wav", + "text": "就要像我們經濟部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147895/137.wav", + "text": "說的沒有困難的工作就" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147895/138.wav", + "text": "不是工作你們要學習一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147895/139.wav", + "text": "你們現在從" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147895/140.wav", + "text": "農委會改為農業部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147895/141.wav", + "text": "給我拜託一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147895/142.wav", + "text": "啦不然你們有困難" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147895/143.wav", + "text": "換我來協調兩邊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147895/144.wav", + "text": "你們最少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147895/145.wav", + "text": "主委參加它才會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147895/146.wav", + "text": "重視問題的嚴重" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147895/147.wav", + "text": "性要由首長參加我再把國有財產" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147895/148.wav", + "text": "署首長找出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147895/149.wav", + "text": "我覺得這個問題很不公平" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147895/150.wav", + "text": "我一定要解決" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147895/151.wav", + "text": "這樣好嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147895/152.wav", + "text": "我來召開比較快" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147895/153.wav", + "text": "說陳主委應該可以解決" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147895/154.wav", + "text": "都沒有做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147895/155.wav", + "text": "到我被你們害變成了騙子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147895/156.wav", + "text": "好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147895/157.wav", + "text": "趕快開一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147895/158.wav", + "text": "不然我兩個禮拜馬上召開協調會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147895/159.wav", + "text": "我做事情沒有像你們一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147895/160.wav", + "text": "我們尊重委員開的一個協調會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147895/161.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147895/162.wav", + "text": "拜託一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147895/163.wav", + "text": "我���來召開你們跟我配合" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147895/164.wav", + "text": "我也想知道何時" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147895/165.wav", + "text": "為什麼不敢答" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147895/166.wav", + "text": "民意代表" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147895/167.wav", + "text": "召開的一個協調" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147895/168.wav", + "text": "唉選舉要到了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147895/169.wav", + "text": "耶你跟我說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147895/170.wav", + "text": "你不趕快辦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147895/171.wav", + "text": "就是有意思讓我落選" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147895/172.wav", + "text": "我不知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147895/173.wav", + "text": "我跟委員報告因為土地" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147895/174.wav", + "text": "不是我們主管好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147895/175.wav", + "text": "趕快做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147895/176.wav", + "text": "不然兩個禮拜我會召開" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147895/177.wav", + "text": "颱風的海風很嚴重" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147895/178.wav", + "text": "剛剛有提到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147895/179.wav", + "text": "農業保險" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147895/180.wav", + "text": "是全面性的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147895/181.wav", + "text": "農糧署署長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147895/182.wav", + "text": "海風一吹過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147895/183.wav", + "text": "海水一淹過剛開始的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147895/184.wav", + "text": "一兩個禮拜" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147895/185.wav", + "text": "西湖鄉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147895/186.wav", + "text": "竄來竄去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147895/187.wav", + "text": "現在我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147895/188.wav", + "text": "苗栗縣海岸地區" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147895/189.wav", + "text": "非常的嚴重" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147895/190.wav", + "text": "包括後龍的水稻" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147895/191.wav", + "text": "受損我希望安排下個禮拜" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147895/192.wav", + "text": "趕快去會勘" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147895/193.wav", + "text": "像通霄" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147895/194.wav", + "text": "受災害的地區" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147895/195.wav", + "text": "部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147895/196.wav", + "text": "委員報告水稻的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147895/197.wav", + "text": "我們一般是用水稻的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147895/198.wav", + "text": "保險去處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147895/199.wav", + "text": "非常特殊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147895/200.wav", + "text": "所以我們同時也啟動了天然災害的救助" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147895/201.wav", + "text": "以我所瞭解" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147895/202.wav", + "text": "的苑裡通霄都已經要公告了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147895/203.wav", + "text": "這個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147895/204.wav", + "text": "因為水稻這些遲發性的災損" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147895/205.wav", + "text": "我們已經公告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147895/206.wav", + "text": "你要用天然災害補償" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147895/207.wav", + "text": "因為這個是區域性的好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147895/208.wav", + "text": "對我們會根據實際的受損狀況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147895/209.wav", + "text": "好這個拜託一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147895/210.wav", + "text": "尤其我剛剛講���那個地方" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147895/211.wav", + "text": "我瞭解實際" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147895/212.wav", + "text": "際的情況是怎麼樣我們會去處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147895/213.wav", + "text": "幾千公頃國有耕地" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147895/214.wav", + "text": "大家都來跟我陳情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147895/215.wav", + "text": "拜託一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147895/216.wav", + "text": "不然兩個禮拜我自行召開協調會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147895/217.wav", + "text": "你們要做趕快做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147895/218.wav", + "text": "好不好謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147895/219.wav", + "text": "拜託" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147894/0.wav", + "text": "謝謝主席" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147894/1.wav", + "text": "請勞動部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147894/2.wav", + "text": "有請部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147894/3.wav", + "text": "張委員好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147894/4.wav", + "text": "部長今天我們委員會專題報告的題目是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147894/5.wav", + "text": "勞工退休金制度改革" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147894/6.wav", + "text": "那檢視勞保基金整體的財務狀況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147894/7.wav", + "text": "在106年到111年的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147894/8.wav", + "text": "已經連續6年的保費收支短絀" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147894/9.wav", + "text": "回顧102年到111年這10年之間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147894/10.wav", + "text": "我國勞工保險老年年金給付的金額" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147894/11.wav", + "text": "在102年是76億而已" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147894/12.wav", + "text": "到111年增加到3,381億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147894/13.wav", + "text": "也就是增加了3,305億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147894/14.wav", + "text": "超過了43倍" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147894/15.wav", + "text": "是這麼多的倍數" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147894/16.wav", + "text": "考量我國107年已經邁入了高齡社會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147894/17.wav", + "text": "推估將在114年邁入超高齡社會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147894/18.wav", + "text": "未來老年給付負擔會持續的擴增" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147894/19.wav", + "text": "勞保基金111年底" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147894/20.wav", + "text": "精算負債12.32兆" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147894/21.wav", + "text": "老年給付占比達97.44%" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147894/22.wav", + "text": "是勞保基金主要的負擔" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147894/23.wav", + "text": "現在面臨超高齡社會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147894/24.wav", + "text": "未來老年給付的負擔會更為嚴重" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147894/25.wav", + "text": "剛剛我也聽到王委員很生氣也很激動" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147894/26.wav", + "text": "部長在此要求勞動部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147894/27.wav", + "text": "儘速提出勞保改革方案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147894/28.wav", + "text": "這才是改善勞保基金財務狀況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147894/29.wav", + "text": "的釜底抽薪之策" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147894/30.wav", + "text": "部長你認為呢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147894/31.wav", + "text": "報告委員這個勞保改革的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147894/32.wav", + "text": "我們一定會重視" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147894/33.wav", + "text": "也一定會提出因應的方案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147894/34.wav", + "text": "那時間呢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147894/35.wav", + "text": "持續蒐集意見凝聚共識之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147894/36.wav", + "text": "年底可以嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147894/37.wav", + "text": "年底沒有辦法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147894/38.wav", + "text": "然後有60萬個投保單位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147894/39.wav", + "text": "各類型的勞工都不同" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147894/40.wav", + "text": "這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147894/41.wav", + "text": "對各類型不同" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147894/42.wav", + "text": "對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147894/43.wav", + "text": "這個要考慮的問題很多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147894/44.wav", + "text": "每個類型勞工的想法都不同" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147894/45.wav", + "text": "所以我跟委員說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147894/46.wav", + "text": "這是一個算浩大的工程" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147894/47.wav", + "text": "我想我們會努力去做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147894/48.wav", + "text": "可以先提出方案啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147894/49.wav", + "text": "先提出方案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147894/50.wav", + "text": "不是說提出方案就要立即執行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147894/51.wav", + "text": "應該要跟我們勞工" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147894/52.wav", + "text": "來溝通" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147894/53.wav", + "text": "基本上因為這牽涉到這麼多人的權益" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147894/54.wav", + "text": "勞工的權益" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147894/55.wav", + "text": "那我想這個應該是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147894/56.wav", + "text": "我們在大家理性對話有共識之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147894/57.wav", + "text": "這樣會比較妥當" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147894/58.wav", + "text": "否則" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147894/59.wav", + "text": "有時候你說草擬一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147894/60.wav", + "text": "一下子就變成說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147894/61.wav", + "text": "準備要這樣改" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147894/62.wav", + "text": "那勞工" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147894/63.wav", + "text": "要提出方案才知道怎麼跟" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147894/64.wav", + "text": "社會來達成共識" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147894/65.wav", + "text": "可以提出" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147894/66.wav", + "text": "都會有一些面向" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147894/67.wav", + "text": "當然勞工也都知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147894/68.wav", + "text": "包括一些學者專家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147894/69.wav", + "text": "也會建議從新的面向去考量" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147894/70.wav", + "text": "所以我們在溝通" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147894/71.wav", + "text": "的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147894/72.wav", + "text": "也會針對這些面向去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147894/73.wav", + "text": "瞭解" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147894/74.wav", + "text": "聽取各界的意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147894/75.wav", + "text": "好的意見我們都會參採" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147894/76.wav", + "text": "然後最後來做一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147894/77.wav", + "text": "並凝聚共識" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147894/78.wav", + "text": "我們會來提出" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147894/79.wav", + "text": "好部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147894/80.wav", + "text": "就是儘速提出" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147894/81.wav", + "text": "勞保改革方案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147894/82.wav", + "text": "我本來希望你年底" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147894/83.wav", + "text": "半年也都可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147894/84.wav", + "text": "有這麼多各行各業" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147894/85.wav", + "text": "還有學者專家的意見想法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147894/86.wav", + "text": "所以要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147894/87.wav", + "text": "儘速" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147894/88.wav", + "text": "我們會努力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147894/89.wav", + "text": "大家都知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147894/90.wav", + "text": "臺灣即將進入" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147894/91.wav", + "text": "超高齡社會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147894/92.wav", + "text": "另外要重視的議題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147894/93.wav", + "text": "就是中高齡就業的議題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147894/94.wav", + "text": "勞動部在今年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147894/95.wav", + "text": "5月正式啟動" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147894/96.wav", + "text": "中高齡者及高齡者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147894/97.wav", + "text": "就業促進的計畫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147894/98.wav", + "text": "結合衛福部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147894/99.wav", + "text": "教育部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147894/100.wav", + "text": "預定3年內投入98億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147894/101.wav", + "text": "這98億是要做什麼呢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147894/102.wav", + "text": "以中高齡者勞參率" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147894/103.wav", + "text": "70%為目標" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147894/104.wav", + "text": "中高齡者及高齡者就業" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147894/105.wav", + "text": "但是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147894/106.wav", + "text": "提出的方案內容" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147894/107.wav", + "text": "引起外界批評" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147894/108.wav", + "text": "我想你也知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147894/109.wav", + "text": "是怎麼批評呢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147894/110.wav", + "text": "他說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147894/111.wav", + "text": "我們過度依賴" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147894/112.wav", + "text": "發放補助" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147894/113.wav", + "text": "錦上添花" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147894/114.wav", + "text": "為什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147894/115.wav", + "text": "企業" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147894/116.wav", + "text": "雇主" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147894/117.wav", + "text": "不會只因你的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147894/118.wav", + "text": "就來決定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147894/119.wav", + "text": "他自己" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147894/120.wav", + "text": "要不要離職" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147894/121.wav", + "text": "跟這個補助" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147894/122.wav", + "text": "不太有關係" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147894/123.wav", + "text": "那是一對一啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147894/124.wav", + "text": "重要的是要改革" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147894/125.wav", + "text": "為什麼會離職" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147894/126.wav", + "text": "勞動部近期是否針對中高齡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147894/127.wav", + "text": "還有高齡勞工" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147894/128.wav", + "text": "進行職場的調查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147894/129.wav", + "text": "還有他離職的原因是什麼呢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147894/130.wav", + "text": "你補助他" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147894/131.wav", + "text": "就可以降低離職率啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147894/132.wav", + "text": "部長請問你什麼原因" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147894/133.wav", + "text": "報告委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147894/134.wav", + "text": "其實我們這個3年計畫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147894/135.wav", + "text": "補助只是其中之一你說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147894/136.wav", + "text": "其中之一" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147894/137.wav", + "text": "我很高興聽到是其中之一" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147894/138.wav", + "text": "還有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147894/139.wav", + "text": "適性的工作職缺" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147894/140.wav", + "text": "符合" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147894/141.wav", + "text": "適性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147894/142.wav", + "text": "包括針對不同產業的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147894/143.wav", + "text": "職務再設計" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147894/144.wav", + "text": "看怎麼樣讓中高齡者高齡者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147894/145.wav", + "text": "在工作上會比較順" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147894/146.wav", + "text": "就職務再設計" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147894/147.wav", + "text": "服務的指引" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147894/148.wav", + "text": "另外我們也有推動一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147894/149.wav", + "text": "我現在跟你打岔一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147894/150.wav", + "text": "我們不是只有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147894/151.wav", + "text": "發錢補助" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147894/152.wav", + "text": "我們還有其他的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147894/153.wav", + "text": "補助只是曇花一現" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147894/154.wav", + "text": "我要跟你講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147894/155.wav", + "text": "你剛剛所提的都是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147894/156.wav", + "text": "們認為有做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147894/157.wav", + "text": "但是我要提到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147894/158.wav", + "text": "你們勞動部在2016年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147894/159.wav", + "text": "所做的評估" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147894/160.wav", + "text": "你看到現在幾年了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147894/161.wav", + "text": "現在是20" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147894/162.wav", + "text": "臺灣1,153萬的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147894/163.wav", + "text": "勞動人口中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147894/164.wav", + "text": "有高達" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147894/165.wav", + "text": "萬占五分之一的人口" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147894/166.wav", + "text": "因為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147894/167.wav", + "text": "要照顧" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147894/168.wav", + "text": "失能失智" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147894/169.wav", + "text": "身心障礙家人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147894/170.wav", + "text": "影響工作" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147894/171.wav", + "text": "每年有17.8萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147894/172.wav", + "text": "人減少工時請假或彈性調整" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147894/173.wav", + "text": "每年有13萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147894/174.wav", + "text": "人因照顧而離職" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147894/175.wav", + "text": "而民間團體進行調查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147894/176.wav", + "text": "是中高齡的勞工" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147894/177.wav", + "text": "在職照顧者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147894/178.wav", + "text": "這些人離職" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147894/179.wav", + "text": "是什麼就" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147894/180.wav", + "text": "是為了照顧家裡的老人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147894/181.wav", + "text": "啊所以我們是不是應該" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147894/182.wav", + "text": "採釜底抽薪的方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147894/183.wav", + "text": "問他為什麼離職" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147894/184.wav", + "text": "應該是這樣子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147894/185.wav", + "text": "剛剛你說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147894/186.wav", + "text": "補助是其中之一" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147894/187.wav", + "text": "我說我很高興" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147894/188.wav", + "text": "聽到補助是之一" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147894/189.wav", + "text": "可是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147894/190.wav", + "text": "我們要知道真正的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147894/191.wav", + "text": "原因是什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147894/192.wav", + "text": "裡面的數字很清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147894/193.wav", + "text": "有五分之一的勞工" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147894/194.wav", + "text": "家裡失能失智" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147894/195.wav", + "text": "身心障礙的家人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147894/196.wav", + "text": "而影響工作" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147894/197.wav", + "text": "你知道嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147894/198.wav", + "text": "所以要如何" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147894/199.wav", + "text": "其實對於" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147894/200.wav", + "text": "前3個月到6個月就" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147894/201.wav", + "text": "他是不會離職的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147894/202.wav", + "text": "我們有這個統計" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147894/203.wav", + "text": "在他需要回去照顧老人家之前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147894/204.wav", + "text": "為什麼這些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147894/205.wav", + "text": "很多就是因為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147894/206.wav", + "text": "結婚生育" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147894/207.wav", + "text": "還有照顧" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147894/208.wav", + "text": "對生育的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147894/209.wav", + "text": "我們有生育的特別辦法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147894/210.wav", + "text": "家務的需求" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147894/211.wav", + "text": "尤其像" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147894/212.wav", + "text": "那個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147894/213.wav", + "text": "就是完善的長照制度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147894/214.wav", + "text": "其實也是會有幫助" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147894/215.wav", + "text": "那就是要跟" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147894/216.wav", + "text": "衛福部合作對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147894/217.wav", + "text": "可以調整彈性的工時" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147894/218.wav", + "text": "也會讓這些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147894/219.wav", + "text": "中高齡者高齡者在就業上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147894/220.wav", + "text": "會比較有彈性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147894/221.wav", + "text": "就是大家一起來合作" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147894/222.wav", + "text": "從各個面向來做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147894/223.wav", + "text": "其實為了留住中高齡員工" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147894/224.wav", + "text": "我剛剛講有五分之一" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147894/225.wav", + "text": "是因為照顧長者而離職對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147894/226.wav", + "text": "那企業應該打造" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147894/227.wav", + "text": "友善照顧職場才對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147894/228.wav", + "text": "友善照顧職場" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147894/229.wav", + "text": "有以下四個條件" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147894/230.wav", + "text": "請你看一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147894/231.wav", + "text": "幫助員工具備相關知識等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147894/232.wav", + "text": "還有關懷有照顧需求的員工" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147894/233.wav", + "text": "讓員工在有需求的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147894/234.wav", + "text": "不要輕易離職" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147894/235.wav", + "text": "並協助員工整合可用的照顧資源" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147894/236.wav", + "text": "也就是說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147894/237.wav", + "text": "請你跟衛福部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147894/238.wav", + "text": "跨部會合作" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147894/239.wav", + "text": "讓企業能夠鏈結" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147894/240.wav", + "text": "相關長照資源" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147894/241.wav", + "text": "讓有照顧需求的員工" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147894/242.wav", + "text": "可以快速得到協助" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147894/243.wav", + "text": "你說對嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147894/244.wav", + "text": "對一定要把它放進去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147894/245.wav", + "text": "所以不能只有剛剛講的一次性的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147894/246.wav", + "text": "就是說離職就補助你" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147894/247.wav", + "text": "那個是曇花一現" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147894/248.wav", + "text": "所以這樣子是不是比較是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147894/249.wav", + "text": "釜底抽薪的方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147894/250.wav", + "text": "其他各種" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147894/251.wav", + "text": "包括這些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147894/252.wav", + "text": "打造友善照顧職場" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147894/253.wav", + "text": "是不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147894/254.wav", + "text": "謝謝部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147894/255.wav", + "text": "謝謝委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147893/0.wav", + "text": "我等召委坐定因為我要接著你的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147893/1.wav", + "text": "我就說依法行政" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147893/2.wav", + "text": "公務人員當然教育人員也一樣啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147893/3.wav", + "text": "請你告訴我條文裡面哪一個是寫叫你用淨現金流" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147893/4.wav", + "text": "退撫基金用罄年度提前之財務缺口" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147893/5.wav", + "text": "就是說新制建立了會造成舊制提前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147893/6.wav", + "text": "它是規定要按照這樣一個結果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147893/7.wav", + "text": "來撥款補助之請問" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147893/8.wav", + "text": "哪裡有寫說是看現金流" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147893/9.wav", + "text": "對如委員所講的它並沒有說要用現金流" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147893/10.wav", + "text": "所以現在實際的金額也是超過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147893/11.wav", + "text": "讓我講年改舊制改革新制建立" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147893/12.wav", + "text": "是不是我們這幾年做的事" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147893/13.wav", + "text": "我們是不是要負起責任" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147893/14.wav", + "text": "也要向大家交代嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147893/15.wav", + "text": "現在有幾個問題第一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147893/16.wav", + "text": "所謂的用罄年度提早的這一個缺口" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147893/17.wav", + "text": "我說一句實在話建立新制之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147893/18.wav", + "text": "所有收納的錢都不會到舊制去了嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147893/19.wav", + "text": "所以真正的缺口絕對不只是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147893/20.wav", + "text": "用罄年度提前的這個缺口而已" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147893/21.wav", + "text": "絕對不只是用罄年度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147893/22.wav", + "text": "但我們在條文裡面也沒有辦法說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147893/23.wav", + "text": "到底新制多少缺口以及怎麼樣寫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147893/24.wav", + "text": "給它一個文字出來叫做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147893/25.wav", + "text": "用罄年度提前我們要分年撥補之" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147893/26.wav", + "text": "也沒告訴你是看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147893/27.wav", + "text": "第一個這就已經小於真正新制所造成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147893/28.wav", + "text": "的沒有挹注到舊制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147893/29.wav", + "text": "就已經小於它的財務了啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147893/30.wav", + "text": "第二個也沒有告訴你說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147893/31.wav", + "text": "要用淨現金流你們為什麼自我劃線" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147893/32.wav", + "text": "這對以後不能交代啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147893/33.wav", + "text": "你要知道一句話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147893/34.wav", + "text": "長長久久領到老" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147893/35.wav", + "text": "去查一下這句話誰講的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147893/36.wav", + "text": "年改的召集人現在的行政院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147893/37.wav", + "text": "不能漏氣啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147893/38.wav", + "text": "有幾個方法在撥補" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147893/39.wav", + "text": "第一個方法就是現在看到的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147893/40.wav", + "text": "主計總處跳出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147893/41.wav", + "text": "說現在淨現金流的流入流出" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147893/42.wav", + "text": "我們撥補50億算不錯了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147893/43.wav", + "text": "這是最渺小的講法耶" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147893/44.wav", + "text": "你這個講法造成了什麼問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147893/45.wav", + "text": "到139年的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147893/46.wav", + "text": "精算結果的淨現金流是300多億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147893/47.wav", + "text": "你連新制的分年撥補" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147893/48.wav", + "text": "都還要丟給以後的人哪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147893/49.wav", + "text": "如果你是用淨現金流的觀念" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147893/50.wav", + "text": "來做分年撥補的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147893/51.wav", + "text": "你連新制用罄年度所要做的撥補" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147893/52.wav", + "text": "都還留給以後的人啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147893/53.wav", + "text": "這幾年我們在做年改" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147893/54.wav", + "text": "有舊制跟新制欸" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147893/55.wav", + "text": "這種話講得出口" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147893/56.wav", + "text": "沒道理啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147893/57.wav", + "text": "他覺得我配合政府的政策" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147893/58.wav", + "text": "那政府如何展現一個決心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147893/59.wav", + "text": "我還沒有跟你講說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147893/60.wav", + "text": "不要跟我講說285億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147893/61.wav", + "text": "那個是新舊制一起" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147893/62.wav", + "text": "要長長久久的事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147893/63.wav", + "text": "我先不講到那裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147893/64.wav", + "text": "我就是講你要給大家一個信心的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147893/65.wav", + "text": "起碼前幾年先來大量挹注" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147893/66.wav", + "text": "用罄年度提早新制造成的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147893/67.wav", + "text": "先在前幾年做一些給人家看嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147893/68.wav", + "text": "所以有所謂的10年平均" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147893/69.wav", + "text": "294億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147893/70.wav", + "text": "我沒說錯吧" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147893/71.wav", + "text": "當然如果你還要再加上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147893/72.wav", + "text": "教育人員的123" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147893/73.wav", + "text": "\n我先講公務人員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147893/74.wav", + "text": "就是說不要到140年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147893/75.wav", + "text": "就是舊制提前到135年要用罄" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147893/76.wav", + "text": "那我們現在補足也讓它到140年用罄" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147893/77.wav", + "text": "根據法律條文第93條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147893/78.wav", + "text": "那我起碼在現在先展現一個決心給大家看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147893/79.wav", + "text": "我用10年平均" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147893/80.wav", + "text": "這是個強心劑" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147893/81.wav", + "text": "大家會有感" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147893/82.wav", + "text": "知道現在的政府負起責任了嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147893/83.wav", + "text": "好啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147893/84.wav", + "text": "這個194億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147893/85.wav", + "text": "我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147893/86.wav", + "text": "棄之如敝屣還是什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147893/87.wav", + "text": "我們沒採用啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147893/88.wav", + "text": "沒採用你起碼採用一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147893/89.wav", + "text": "用罄年度之前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147893/90.wav", + "text": "就是到140年的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147893/91.wav", + "text": "我們來算一個平均分年的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147893/92.wav", + "text": "撥補" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147893/93.wav", + "text": "那叫100億啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147893/94.wav", + "text": "這你也沒採用啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147893/95.wav", + "text": "那你今天要跟人家講淨現金流" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147893/96.wav", + "text": "講得過去嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147893/97.wav", + "text": "你們前面與其他委員的詢答" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147893/98.wav", + "text": "我都有很仔細在聽" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147893/99.wav", + "text": "我們也不是用現金流" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147893/100.wav", + "text": "所以我們100億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147893/101.wav", + "text": "主計總處" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147893/102.wav", + "text": "你們對外講的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147893/103.wav", + "text": "你們有講哪些話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147893/104.wav", + "text": "我跟你講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147893/105.wav", + "text": "我自己是執政黨的立委" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147893/106.wav", + "text": "講到這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147893/107.wav", + "text": "我火氣都上來了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147893/108.wav", + "text": "人家覺得自己執政黨怎麼這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147893/109.wav", + "text": "但是你去看你們的發言嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147893/110.wav", + "text": "不然你今天要告訴我說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147893/111.wav", + "text": "兩年對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147893/112.wav", + "text": "這個淨現金流有多少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147893/113.wav", + "text": "你們還在講這個東西" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147893/114.wav", + "text": "我不是苛責" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147893/115.wav", + "text": "但是我現在講一個道理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147893/116.wav", + "text": "這條法律當中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147893/117.wav", + "text": "你自己也講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147893/118.wav", + "text": "沒有看到淨現金流的東西" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147893/119.wav", + "text": "為什麼今天跑出來這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147893/120.wav", + "text": "是跟現金流有關的文字出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147893/121.wav", + "text": "\n我剛剛講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147893/122.wav", + "text": "新舊制要一起處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147893/123.wav", + "text": "你要知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147893/124.wav", + "text": "除了新制這個缺口" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147893/125.wav", + "text": "我們依法用罄年度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147893/126.wav", + "text": "要挹注補足以外" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147893/127.wav", + "text": "要不要展現決心給人家看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147893/128.wav", + "text": "還是說到103十幾年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147893/129.wav", + "text": "104十年的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147893/130.wav", + "text": "那一年的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147893/131.wav", + "text": "差要300多億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147893/132.wav", + "text": "也是叫以後的人負責" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147893/133.wav", + "text": "這個條文後面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147893/134.wav", + "text": "立刻還寫了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147893/135.wav", + "text": "包括舊制過去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147893/136.wav", + "text": "所造成的財務不健全" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147893/137.wav", + "text": "還要做耶" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147893/138.wav", + "text": "還要做耶" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147893/139.wav", + "text": "\n現在有關於新制造成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147893/140.wav", + "text": "用罄年度的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147893/141.wav", + "text": "部分我們就是這個態度了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147893/142.wav", + "text": "那關於整體舊制以後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147893/143.wav", + "text": "就是今天還沒有適用到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147893/144.wav", + "text": "新制的最後一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147893/145.wav", + "text": "現在進來的公務人員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147893/146.wav", + "text": "也要到他退休的那一天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147893/147.wav", + "text": "能夠領得到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147893/148.wav", + "text": "那現在針對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147893/149.wav", + "text": "新制用罄年度這部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147893/150.wav", + "text": "你不先宣示一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147893/151.wav", + "text": "你不先用力一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147893/152.wav", + "text": "你不用10年平均" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147893/153.wav", + "text": "你也不用到140年的平均" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147893/154.wav", + "text": "不是用194億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147893/155.wav", + "text": "也不是用100億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147893/156.wav", + "text": "那後面的人怎麼會相信針" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147893/157.wav", + "text": "健全財務" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147893/158.wav", + "text": "我們政府當下在做年改" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147893/159.wav", + "text": "做新舊制變動的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147893/160.wav", + "text": "其實是有考慮到後面的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147893/161.wav", + "text": "而不是把責任丟給後面的人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147893/162.wav", + "text": "回答看看吧" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147893/163.wav", + "text": "跟委員報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147893/164.wav", + "text": "當然從考試院的立場" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147893/165.wav", + "text": "我們也積極的來爭取" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147893/166.wav", + "text": "所以在未來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147893/167.wav", + "text": "當50加50這個金額" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147893/168.wav", + "text": "就如委員剛剛講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147893/169.wav", + "text": "就新制實施後的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147893/170.wav", + "text": "這個水位不要影響來說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147893/171.wav", + "text": "它平均來講還是不夠的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147893/172.wav", + "text": "所以不不不" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147893/173.wav", + "text": "秘書長我再次糾正你" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147893/174.wav", + "text": "你如果真的講水位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147893/175.wav", + "text": "那又不一樣了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147893/176.wav", + "text": "水位要看現在舊制的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147893/177.wav", + "text": "水池有多少錢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147893/178.wav", + "text": "然後到哪一年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147893/179.wav", + "text": "我們現在條文就給你寫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147893/180.wav", + "text": "用罄年度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147893/181.wav", + "text": "所以它會衍生出" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147893/182.wav", + "text": "到底是用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147893/183.wav", + "text": "總共用罄年度之前的年平均" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147893/184.wav", + "text": "還是展示決心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147893/185.wav", + "text": "用10年的平均就先做了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147893/186.wav", + "text": "以後再去考慮" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147893/187.wav", + "text": "填舊制的財務缺口" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147893/188.wav", + "text": "還是說像你們現在講的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147893/189.wav", + "text": "淨現金流" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147893/190.wav", + "text": "我重複講三遍了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147893/191.wav", + "text": "我講得很清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147893/192.wav", + "text": "我相信你們都能夠理解" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147893/193.wav", + "text": "總而言之" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147893/194.wav", + "text": "我們當然會在我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147893/195.wav", + "text": "業管的範圍之內" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147893/196.wav", + "text": "但是因���國家整體財政分配" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147893/197.wav", + "text": "在主計總處這邊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147893/198.wav", + "text": "這個過程中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147893/199.wav", + "text": "我的確跟主計總處" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147893/200.wav", + "text": "這些財務缺口" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147893/201.wav", + "text": "因為也不是只有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147893/202.wav", + "text": "我們公教人員這個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147893/203.wav", + "text": "所以我想主計總處這邊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147893/204.wav", + "text": "可能要分配" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147893/205.wav", + "text": "要思考的範圍" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147893/206.wav", + "text": "會比我們職掌的範" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147893/207.wav", + "text": "最後也只能去理解" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147893/208.wav", + "text": "跟尊重主計總處這邊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147893/209.wav", + "text": "他們從整體的眼光" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147893/210.wav", + "text": "必須要去做的資源分配" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147893/211.wav", + "text": "我講兩點指正你" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147893/212.wav", + "text": "第一點你剛剛說的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147893/213.wav", + "text": "如果是在我們修法前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147893/214.wav", + "text": "你這樣講的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147893/215.wav", + "text": "你們覺得修法會過嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147893/216.wav", + "text": "你剛剛講的這一席話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147893/217.wav", + "text": "或者你們今天在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147893/218.wav", + "text": "司法法制委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147893/219.wav", + "text": "所答詢的這些話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147893/220.wav", + "text": "假如是在修法前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147893/221.wav", + "text": "你們都這樣講的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147893/222.wav", + "text": "修法會過嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147893/223.wav", + "text": "修法前有說淨現金" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147893/224.wav", + "text": "流這些東西嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147893/225.wav", + "text": "修法前有沒有說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147893/226.wav", + "text": "一些展現信心的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147893/227.wav", + "text": "有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147893/228.wav", + "text": "\n第二點指正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147893/229.wav", + "text": "我們今天還沒有論到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147893/230.wav", + "text": "285億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147893/231.wav", + "text": "耶世世代代領得到長長久久" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147893/232.wav", + "text": "領到老" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147893/233.wav", + "text": "我們還沒有論到285億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147893/234.wav", + "text": "新舊制一起來的財務健全" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147893/235.wav", + "text": "我們還沒論到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147893/236.wav", + "text": "不是講臺灣的財政經濟" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147893/237.wav", + "text": "都相當不錯" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147893/238.wav", + "text": "你在這個時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147893/239.wav", + "text": "到教育體系" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147893/240.wav", + "text": "這些犧牲奉獻" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147893/241.wav", + "text": "大家也配合政府做改革的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147893/242.wav", + "text": "人應該給他們一點信心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147893/243.wav", + "text": "啊怎麼會在這裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147893/244.wav", + "text": "斤斤計較" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147893/245.wav", + "text": "以執政黨的立委來講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147893/246.wav", + "text": "我話講這樣太重了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147893/247.wav", + "text": "但是我不得不講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147893/248.wav", + "text": "我準備了一堆" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147893/249.wav", + "text": "這個大問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147893/250.wav", + "text": "再加上那個預算的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147893/251.wav", + "text": "問一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147893/252.wav", + "text": "你們有沒有去跟其他的基金" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147893/253.wav", + "text": "你們現在在做定存的收益" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147893/254.wav", + "text": "別人也在做定存的收益" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147893/255.wav", + "text": "我順便指教這個問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147893/256.wav", + "text": "你們的定存收益寫多少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147893/257.wav", + "text": "1.586%" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147893/258.wav", + "text": "喔現在哪裡的大額定存" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147893/259.wav", + "text": "還有這麼高" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147893/260.wav", + "text": "喔你要知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147893/261.wav", + "text": "其他基金要不要我念念看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147893/262.wav", + "text": "勞保勞退" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147893/263.wav", + "text": "國保" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147893/264.wav", + "text": "你去看人家的定存" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147893/265.wav", + "text": "收益率才多少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147893/266.wav", + "text": "你去看現在各大銀行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147893/267.wav", + "text": "牌架上公告的價格" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147893/268.wav", + "text": "你們怎麼還會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147893/269.wav", + "text": "有這樣的一個定存收益率" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147893/270.wav", + "text": "你的總體收益率的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147893/271.wav", + "text": "在做投資的那20%部位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147893/272.wav", + "text": "欸誰有辦法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147893/273.wav", + "text": "可是如果考慮你的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147893/274.wav", + "text": "再加上你後面訂的總體收益率" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147893/275.wav", + "text": "那你投資的部位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147893/276.wav", + "text": "也只有20%要去弄" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147893/277.wav", + "text": "可以弄到八點多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147893/278.wav", + "text": "可以回答我嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147893/279.wav", + "text": "我看你們的目標收益率" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147893/280.wav", + "text": "加權收益率" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147893/281.wav", + "text": "相較於我所查的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147893/282.wav", + "text": "委員您提的可能是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147893/283.wav", + "text": "我們新的儲金制度下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147893/284.wav", + "text": "我們對於風險最低的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147893/285.wav", + "text": "或是我們在統一運用是啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147893/286.wav", + "text": "你預算書就這樣寫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147893/287.wav", + "text": "我都看預算書" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147893/288.wav", + "text": "我都看預算書" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147893/289.wav", + "text": "對那是依法規定用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147893/290.wav", + "text": "6家銀行的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147893/291.wav", + "text": "二年期小額" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147893/292.wav", + "text": "定期存款的利率" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147893/293.wav", + "text": "所以我們加總起來是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147893/294.wav", + "text": "1.5866這個數字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147893/295.wav", + "text": "那當然實際上我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147893/296.wav", + "text": "目前在統一運用期" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147893/297.wav", + "text": "的時間的確金額比較小" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147893/298.wav", + "text": "我們可以用小額存款" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147893/299.wav", + "text": "但是未來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147893/300.wav", + "text": "如果累積到大額的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147893/301.wav", + "text": "那可能就沒有辦法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147893/302.wav", + "text": "你講的有矛盾" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147893/303.wav", + "text": "沒關係因為我的時間占用太多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147893/304.wav", + "text": "對所以我們其實在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147893/305.wav", + "text": "預算裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147893/306.wav", + "text": "的編製是有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147893/307.wav", + "text": "不只是存款這個運用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147893/308.wav", + "text": "因為現在在質詢當中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147893/309.wav", + "text": "\n這好幾個在投資績效" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147893/310.wav", + "text": "相較於過去過去的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147893/311.wav", + "text": "現在的管理局儲金組" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147893/312.wav", + "text": "以及相較於其他基金" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147893/313.wav", + "text": "定存的或者是委外的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147893/314.wav", + "text": "或者是自行經營的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147893/315.wav", + "text": "我有找到好幾個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147893/316.wav", + "text": "真的是非常謬誤的地方" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147893/317.wav", + "text": "我都是用其他的基金" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147893/318.wav", + "text": "如勞保勞退" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147893/319.wav", + "text": "國保等等來比較" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147893/320.wav", + "text": "希望能夠有時間充分討論一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147893/321.wav", + "text": "或者萬一是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147893/322.wav", + "text": "跟其他不一樣的地方" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147893/323.wav", + "text": "我們再來做一個溝通" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147893/324.wav", + "text": "不要在這個預算的部分上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147893/325.wav", + "text": "出現問題以上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147893/326.wav", + "text": "謝謝江永昌委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147893/327.wav", + "text": "\n接下來請吳琪銘委員發言" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147892/0.wav", + "text": "謝謝主席邀請王部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147892/1.wav", + "text": "王部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147892/2.wav", + "text": "部長行政院從今年開始未來七年內包括今年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147892/3.wav", + "text": "在內要編列四百零億預算來改善道安" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147892/4.wav", + "text": "題部長也表示將著重在交通工程方面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147892/5.wav", + "text": "因為近年來臺灣的交通事故" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147892/6.wav", + "text": "雖然看起來數據差不多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147892/7.wav", + "text": "每年大概有三千多人因交通事故死亡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147892/8.wav", + "text": "輕重傷三四十萬人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147892/9.wav", + "text": "從法制面執行面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147892/10.wav", + "text": "與道路交通的安全改善面來做處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147892/11.wav", + "text": "據行政院版的基本法草案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147892/12.wav", + "text": "第23條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147892/13.wav", + "text": "提到各級政府為執行道路交通安全所需之政策或措施" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147892/14.wav", + "text": "應規劃及提供足夠經費" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147892/15.wav", + "text": "並視實際需要合理分配之" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147892/16.wav", + "text": "本我自己提的版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147892/17.wav", + "text": "則是要各級政府" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147892/18.wav", + "text": "明確改善計畫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147892/19.wav", + "text": "依照道路交通違規" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147892/20.wav", + "text": "罰款收入分配及應用辦法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147892/21.wav", + "text": "罰款的75%交給直轄市縣（市）政府使用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147892/22.wav", + "text": "這75%裡又規定縣（市）政府" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147892/23.wav", + "text": "至少要提撥12%作為交通執法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147892/24.wav", + "text": "與交通安全改善之經費" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147892/25.wav", + "text": "部長你知道這項法律規定嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147892/26.wav", + "text": "75%交給縣（市）政府" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147892/27.wav", + "text": "又從這75%裡拿12%作為交通安全改善經費" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147892/28.wav", + "text": "部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147892/29.wav", + "text": "因為現在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147892/30.wav", + "text": "這筆經費已經淪為縣（市）首長與警察局長的小金庫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147892/31.wav", + "text": "了所以該怎麼落實執行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147892/32.wav", + "text": "這是我今天提出的修法方向" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147892/33.wav", + "text": "然將罰款的75%交給縣（市）政府" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147892/34.wav", + "text": "做大水庫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147892/35.wav", + "text": "但你的水庫卻變成他的小金庫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147892/36.wav", + "text": "12%至少要提高到24%" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147892/37.wav", + "text": "至少提高一倍" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147892/38.wav", + "text": "而且要專款專用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147892/39.wav", + "text": "不能淪為小金庫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147892/40.wav", + "text": "這是我今天所提出的辦法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147892/41.wav", + "text": "不曉得部長看法怎麼樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147892/42.wav", + "text": "我初步覺得12%太少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147892/43.wav", + "text": "但各縣（市）政府都覺得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147892/44.wav", + "text": "其他的88%可以做其他應用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147892/45.wav", + "text": "到各級政府對道安的經費編列得非常少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147892/46.wav", + "text": "甚至有的根本沒怎麼編" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147892/47.wav", + "text": "基本法上有這樣規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147892/48.wav", + "text": "你們內部就可以做處理了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147892/49.wav", + "text": "因為他們��分配上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147892/50.wav", + "text": "我建議還是要提高" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147892/51.wav", + "text": "然後專款專用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147892/52.wav", + "text": "強調希望能夠明確納入交通工程技師專業" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147892/53.wav", + "text": "或規範所以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147892/54.wav", + "text": "讓交通工程方面的專業技師" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147892/55.wav", + "text": "這是我的想法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147892/56.wav", + "text": "交通工程技師簽證" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147892/57.wav", + "text": "我很想支持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147892/58.wav", + "text": "這是可以再討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147892/59.wav", + "text": "劃凡每一項工程完工要由技師" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147892/60.wav", + "text": "是不是在作用法裡修改" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147892/61.wav", + "text": "但這精神我同意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147892/62.wav", + "text": "因為我們發現很多交通配置不合理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147892/63.wav", + "text": "這種不合理的狀況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147892/64.wav", + "text": "說明別的地方我不曉得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147892/65.wav", + "text": "臺九線" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147892/66.wav", + "text": "上的人行道但實際上這是路肩" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147892/67.wav", + "text": "銷後就變成沒有人行道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147892/68.wav", + "text": "部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147892/69.wav", + "text": "這是人行道還是路肩" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147892/70.wav", + "text": "其實本來是路肩" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147892/71.wav", + "text": "發生車禍的地方" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147892/72.wav", + "text": "既不像路肩也不像人行道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147892/73.wav", + "text": "還是一段路肩一段人行道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147892/74.wav", + "text": "根本沒有人行道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147892/75.wav", + "text": "我覺得縣（市）政府有責任" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147892/76.wav", + "text": "就從我剛剛講的那筆經費裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147892/77.wav", + "text": "提出具體的改善交通安全計畫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147892/78.wav", + "text": "並落實執行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147892/79.wav", + "text": "我要求的是這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147892/80.wav", + "text": "不曉得部長的看法怎麼樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147892/81.wav", + "text": "規定縣（市）政府每年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147892/82.wav", + "text": "年度道路交通安全執行計畫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147892/83.wav", + "text": "未來我們會針對執行計畫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147892/84.wav", + "text": "如標誌標線號誌的檢討" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147892/85.wav", + "text": "人行道的興建等等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147892/86.wav", + "text": "會請他寫在執行計畫裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147892/87.wav", + "text": "攸關國人的生命財產安全" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147892/88.wav", + "text": "我覺得應該公告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147892/89.wav", + "text": "哪些表現好的我們應該獎勵他們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147892/90.wav", + "text": "就以這方面的經費來獎勵" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147892/91.wav", + "text": "這樣至少有獎勵跟處罰的機制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147892/92.wav", + "text": "所以這次修法我們支持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147892/93.wav", + "text": "意思就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147892/94.wav", + "text": "行政院道安會報裡會一一點出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147892/95.wav", + "text": "請縣（市）政府按照什麼規範趕快去處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147892/96.wav", + "text": "最後一個問題近來國光客運在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147892/97.wav", + "text": "減少班次的情形非常嚴重" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147892/98.wav", + "text": "桃機直達宜蘭的直達車" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147892/99.wav", + "text": "讓民眾等車等到苦不堪言" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147892/100.wav", + "text": "影響國道客運營運" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147892/101.wav", + "text": "運價雖然是縣（市）政府的事" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147892/102.wav", + "text": "但不合理的運價就應該檢討" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147892/103.wav", + "text": "所以我想一併瞭解因為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147892/104.wav", + "text": "因為運價沒有調整" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147892/105.wav", + "text": "司機薪水就沒有辦法提高" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147892/106.wav", + "text": "所以請不到司機造成營運困難" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147892/107.wav", + "text": "所以今天最重要的問題就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147892/108.wav", + "text": "你要跟縣市政府談這個事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147892/109.wav", + "text": "因為中央補助很多的經費" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147892/110.wav", + "text": "縣內客運的補助" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147892/111.wav", + "text": "這個要納入考量" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147892/112.wav", + "text": "否則縣市政府把錢兜著" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147892/113.wav", + "text": "也不調整他們的運價" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147892/114.wav", + "text": "讓業者沒辦法生存" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147892/115.wav", + "text": "這樣不是惡性循環嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147892/116.wav", + "text": "業者沒辦法生存" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147892/117.wav", + "text": "當然就減班啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147892/118.wav", + "text": "甚至這個班次就停駛了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147892/119.wav", + "text": "今天宜蘭縣的國光客運" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147892/120.wav", + "text": "跟統聯從桃機到宜蘭直達車的這個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147892/121.wav", + "text": "都有發生這個問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147892/122.wav", + "text": "我希望那個部長承諾一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147892/123.wav", + "text": "下去檢討處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147892/124.wav", + "text": "我請他們跟地方政府再討論一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147892/125.wav", + "text": "另外就是缺司機的缺工問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147892/126.wav", + "text": "現在我們也有一些補助計畫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147892/127.wav", + "text": "就是幫忙來訓練司機" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147892/128.wav", + "text": "現在大概有六百零多個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147892/129.wav", + "text": "連去年加起來已經超過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147892/130.wav", + "text": "100兩百多位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147892/131.wav", + "text": "因為你們從今年3月到明年2月底" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147892/132.wav", + "text": "要推出就業獎勵方案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147892/133.wav", + "text": "對現在已經在做了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147892/134.wav", + "text": "今年已經六百零多個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147892/135.wav", + "text": "去年應該是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147892/136.wav", + "text": "去年五百零多個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147892/137.wav", + "text": "所以我們到現在已經在全國" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147892/138.wav", + "text": "超過1,200位駕駛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147892/139.wav", + "text": "好今天我主要提到三個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147892/140.wav", + "text": "部分我再強調一遍就是汽" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147892/141.wav", + "text": "汽燃費跟交通罰款專款專用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147892/142.wav", + "text": "用引進交通技師的專業" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147892/143.wav", + "text": "提升地方道安改善的能量" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147892/144.wav", + "text": "這是第一點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147892/145.wav", + "text": "第二點就是台" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147892/146.wav", + "text": "9線的這個部分去查一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147892/147.wav", + "text": "嘛我們責無旁貸" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147892/148.wav", + "text": "要求縣市政府來配合" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147892/149.wav", + "text": "該怎麼處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147892/150.wav", + "text": "就怎麼處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147892/151.wav", + "text": "第三個就是我剛剛講的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147892/152.wav", + "text": "班次嚴重的減少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147892/153.wav", + "text": "以上希望能夠一併檢討" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147892/154.wav", + "text": "謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147892/155.wav", + "text": "好謝謝陳歐珀委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147891/0.wav", + "text": "主席請部長陳局長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147891/1.wav", + "text": "部長跟陳局長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147891/2.wav", + "text": "部長新澳隧道這個嚴重的車禍" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147891/3.wav", + "text": "這是非常嚴重的事情是不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147891/4.wav", + "text": "是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147891/5.wav", + "text": "造成1死11人輕重傷" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147891/6.wav", + "text": "你有看那個影片嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147891/7.wav", + "text": "網路上傳的影片" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147891/8.wav", + "text": "有看到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147891/9.wav", + "text": "他根本沒有煞車嘛對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147891/10.wav", + "text": "是不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147891/11.wav", + "text": "那個大型車輛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147891/12.wav", + "text": "有裝AEB" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147891/13.wav", + "text": "這是屬於標配裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147891/14.wav", + "text": "AEB裝上去之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147891/15.wav", + "text": "它減少了一萬九千多次的車禍" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147891/16.wav", + "text": "那你覺得AEB是不是非常重要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147891/17.wav", + "text": "我想未來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147891/18.wav", + "text": "自動停煞" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147891/19.wav", + "text": "這些駕駛輔助系統" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147891/20.wav", + "text": "都是我們討論的一個方向" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147891/21.wav", + "text": "你要討論多久" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147891/22.wav", + "text": "跟委員報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147891/23.wav", + "text": "自動緊急煞車系統的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147891/24.wav", + "text": "從今年1月1號開始" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147891/25.wav", + "text": "新車都要嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147891/26.wav", + "text": "都要配嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147891/27.wav", + "text": "那部長為什麼都不知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147891/28.wav", + "text": "大家也不知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147891/29.wav", + "text": "這是很重要的事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147891/30.wav", + "text": "欸我跟你講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147891/31.wav", + "text": "你們當公務人員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147891/32.wav", + "text": "一般都是有轎車" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147891/33.wav", + "text": "公家車載你們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147891/34.wav", + "text": "我們是自己買的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147891/35.wav", + "text": "像我從很年輕就買" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147891/36.wav", + "text": "有安全氣囊的有ABS的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147891/37.wav", + "text": "也有AEB的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147891/38.wav", + "text": "這個我都會買" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147891/39.wav", + "text": "為什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147891/40.wav", + "text": "這個真的還是安全很重要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147891/41.wav", + "text": "還有ESP的自動防滑" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147891/42.wav", + "text": "以前國產車出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147891/43.wav", + "text": "我們常講那什麼神車" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147891/44.wav", + "text": "大街小巷在跑" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147891/45.wav", + "text": "為什麼ESP都沒有裝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147891/46.wav", + "text": "你們也沒有強制它要裝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147891/47.wav", + "text": "也沒有變成標配" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147891/48.wav", + "text": "造成很多車禍" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147891/49.wav", + "text": "大家競爭很厲害的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147891/50.wav", + "text": "它變標配了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147891/51.wav", + "text": "這種東西" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147891/52.wav", + "text": "啊部長交通部還有公務總局" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147891/53.wav", + "text": "一定要自己先把它作為標配" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147891/54.wav", + "text": "你不能說出了事情之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147891/55.wav", + "text": "才來標配" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147891/56.wav", + "text": "你懂我的意思嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147891/57.wav", + "text": "這個安全的東西很重要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147891/58.wav", + "text": "是不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147891/59.wav", + "text": "讓民眾瞭解說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147891/60.wav", + "text": "我要買車的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147891/61.wav", + "text": "我要買這些標配" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147891/62.wav", + "text": "多一份保障" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147891/63.wav", + "text": "這是非常重要的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147891/64.wav", + "text": "你知道嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147891/65.wav", + "text": "部長有沒有道理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147891/66.wav", + "text": "你們不能拖來拖去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147891/67.wav", + "text": "到現在1月新的車都有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147891/68.wav", + "text": "舊的車沒裝AEB怎麼辦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147891/69.wav", + "text": "舊型車大型車" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147891/70.wav", + "text": "不管是砂石車遊覽車" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147891/71.wav", + "text": "請你說明一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147891/72.wav", + "text": "是不是要加裝還是強制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147891/73.wav", + "text": "還是我們訂一個法規" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147891/74.wav", + "text": "還是怎麼樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147891/75.wav", + "text": "是車輛整體的一個設計" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147891/76.wav", + "text": "我知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147891/77.wav", + "text": "因為還要負責那個ABS煞車" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147891/78.wav", + "text": "什麼一大堆是不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147891/79.wav", + "text": "你有沒有預計" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147891/80.wav", + "text": "預計什麼時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147891/81.wav", + "text": "尤其大眾運輸的車" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147891/82.wav", + "text": "或大型的車遊覽車" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147891/83.wav", + "text": "或是大型的砂石車可以退" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147891/84.wav", + "text": "沒有裝這個東西" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147891/85.wav", + "text": "這部分跟委員報告一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147891/86.wav", + "text": "這樣子一個整車" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147891/87.wav", + "text": "因為我們國家沒有定說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147891/88.wav", + "text": "分10年以後就是半年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147891/89.wav", + "text": "你是不是要制定一個年限" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147891/90.wav", + "text": "這個年限到了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147891/91.wav", + "text": "全部都要汰換" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147891/92.wav", + "text": "有沒有道理是不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147891/93.wav", + "text": "就是透過加強檢驗" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147891/94.wav", + "text": "跟相關的部分來做一個處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147891/95.wav", + "text": "好要儘速趕快制定法規" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147891/96.wav", + "text": "\n另外一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147891/97.wav", + "text": "大家都知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147891/98.wav", + "text": "臺鐵現在要公司化" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147891/99.wav", + "text": "有人說董事長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147891/100.wav", + "text": "還有總經理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147891/101.wav", + "text": "那很多人有意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147891/102.wav", + "text": "我是沒什麼意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147891/103.wav", + "text": "這個是我們交通部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147891/104.wav", + "text": "還有國家一個政策" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147891/105.wav", + "text": "但是有人說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147891/106.wav", + "text": "明年元月上牌之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147891/107.wav", + "text": "臺鐵很多人要辭職是不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147891/108.wav", + "text": "部長有嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147891/109.wav", + "text": "據傳有2,000人到3,000人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147891/110.wav", + "text": "有這麼多嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147891/111.wav", + "text": "現在我請杜微局長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147891/112.wav", + "text": "第一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147891/113.wav", + "text": "有一個六加一的優退" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147891/114.wav", + "text": "優退嘛對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147891/115.wav", + "text": "六加一就是7個月的優退" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147891/116.wav", + "text": "國營事業在過去交通部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147891/117.wav", + "text": "都領4.4個月比" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147891/118.wav", + "text": "起現在臺鐵都領2個月" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147891/119.wav", + "text": "那這意思是說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147891/120.wav", + "text": "他就是可以領到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147891/121.wav", + "text": "比7個月還多的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147891/122.wav", + "text": "還多的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147891/123.wav", + "text": "所以現在這個訊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147891/124.wav", + "text": "在全國各地" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147891/125.wav", + "text": "你預計有多少人會退" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147891/126.wav", + "text": "他們估計說有兩千人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147891/127.wav", + "text": "今這些人退了之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147891/128.wav", + "text": "這是預估" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147891/129.wav", + "text": "現在在談就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147891/130.wav", + "text": "勸他們不要退" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147891/131.wav", + "text": "勸他們不要退" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147891/132.wav", + "text": "今年鐵路特考考了八百零多個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147891/133.wav", + "text": "這樣補得進來嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147891/134.wav", + "text": "能平衡嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147891/135.wav", + "text": "加速來訓練" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147891/136.wav", + "text": "大家對臺鐵公司要有信對啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147891/137.wav", + "text": "現在最重要的就是你講的這句話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147891/138.wav", + "text": "你要呼籲" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147891/139.wav", + "text": "不要為那幾個月" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147891/140.wav", + "text": "就全部都退休了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147891/141.wav", + "text": "是不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147891/142.wav", + "text": "上還是需要時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147891/143.wav", + "text": "是不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147891/144.wav", + "text": "馬上就訓練好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147891/145.wav", + "text": "哪有這種事" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147891/146.wav", + "text": "你是百年老店" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147891/147.wav", + "text": "所以一代傳一代" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147891/148.wav", + "text": "一代要交接一代" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147891/149.wav", + "text": "都是經驗法則" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147891/150.wav", + "text": "經驗規則" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147891/151.wav", + "text": "是不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147891/152.wav", + "text": "所以大家要有信心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147891/153.wav", + "text": "也就是未來會領更多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147891/154.wav", + "text": "臺鐵公司未來會更好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147891/155.wav", + "text": "所以大家應該留下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147891/156.wav", + "text": "公司化就可以領更多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147891/157.wav", + "text": "是不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147891/158.wav", + "text": "有賺錢就領更多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147891/159.wav", + "text": "這方式你要跟他們講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147891/160.wav", + "text": "好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147890/0.wav", + "text": "到底有沒有缺口的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147890/1.wav", + "text": "詳細瞭解了這個制度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147890/2.wav", + "text": "7月1日退撫新制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147890/3.wav", + "text": "上路之後初" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147890/4.wav", + "text": "初任公務人員開始" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147890/5.wav", + "text": "適用個人專戶的新退撫制度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147890/6.wav", + "text": "也就是說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147890/7.wav", + "text": "舊的退撫基金原本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147890/8.wav", + "text": "有700億元要繳進來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147890/9.wav", + "text": "但是到了今年7月1號" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147890/10.wav", + "text": "開始舊制退撫基金" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147890/11.wav", + "text": "將沒有初任公務人員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147890/12.wav", + "text": "的加入" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147890/13.wav", + "text": "就會面臨斷流的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147890/14.wav", + "text": "危機因" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147890/15.wav", + "text": "進來我們老一輩的人員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147890/16.wav", + "text": "又陸續退休" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147890/17.wav", + "text": "面臨雪上加霜" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147890/18.wav", + "text": "也就是說會提早用罄" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147890/19.wav", + "text": "剛剛你也提到了嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147890/20.wav", + "text": "大概什麼是時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147890/21.wav", + "text": "你今天的書面報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147890/22.wav", + "text": "也寫得很清楚為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147890/23.wav", + "text": "為落實前述退撫法第93條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147890/24.wav", + "text": "本部於112年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147890/25.wav", + "text": "3月13日" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147890/26.wav", + "text": "邀集教育部及財政部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147890/27.wav", + "text": "行政院主計總處等有關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147890/28.wav", + "text": "機關開會研商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147890/29.wav", + "text": "並獲至結論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147890/30.wav", + "text": "在先撥補初任公務人員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147890/31.wav", + "text": "實施個人專戶制度後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147890/32.wav", + "text": "現行公務人員退撫基金" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147890/33.wav", + "text": "會提前五年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147890/34.wav", + "text": "及教育部於立法過程中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147890/35.wav", + "text": "委託進行精算的結果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147890/36.wav", + "text": "是自113年起" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147890/37.wav", + "text": "分10年撥補" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147890/38.wav", + "text": "其中公務人員的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147890/39.wav", + "text": "由銓敘部每年編列" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147890/40.wav", + "text": "預算撥補新臺幣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147890/41.wav", + "text": "194億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147890/42.wav", + "text": "教育人員的部分就由教育部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147890/43.wav", + "text": "每年編列預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147890/44.wav", + "text": "撥補123億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147890/45.wav", + "text": "並請行政院主計總處進行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147890/46.wav", + "text": "但是你" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147890/47.wav", + "text": "們依上開會議決議提出" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147890/48.wav", + "text": "113年度的概算後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147890/49.wav", + "text": "最後經行政院最終" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147890/50.wav", + "text": "核列撥補50億元" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147890/51.wav", + "text": "這屬行政院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147890/52.wav", + "text": "就政府年度預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147890/53.wav", + "text": "為整體分配的權責" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147890/54.wav", + "text": "\n現在問題就來了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147890/55.wav", + "text": "是113年度起" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147890/56.wav", + "text": "要分10年撥補" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147890/57.wav", + "text": "公務人員是要撥" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147890/58.wav", + "text": "194億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147890/59.wav", + "text": "教育人員就是由教育部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147890/60.wav", + "text": "123億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147890/61.wav", + "text": "但是我現在很好奇" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147890/62.wav", + "text": "50億各50億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147890/63.wav", + "text": "這50億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147890/64.wav", + "text": "是行政院核定的是不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147890/65.wav", + "text": "依照這個報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147890/66.wav", + "text": "行政院的意思是說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147890/67.wav", + "text": "我們要做預算的整體分配" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147890/68.wav", + "text": "但是考試院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147890/69.wav", + "text": "銓敘部是你的轄下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147890/70.wav", + "text": "為什麼你自己明明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147890/71.wav", + "text": "公務人員部分每年要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147890/72.wav", + "text": "補194億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147890/73.wav", + "text": "為什麼你也跟著" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147890/74.wav", + "text": "只撥補50億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147890/75.wav", + "text": "其實從112年新制在討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147890/76.wav", + "text": "還沒有立法之前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147890/77.wav", + "text": "整個討論過程中我們都意識到有這個問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147890/78.wav", + "text": "所以我們跟主計長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147890/79.wav", + "text": "也一直有溝通" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147890/80.wav", + "text": "跟教育部國防部一起討論出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147890/81.wav", + "text": "或者10年的平均" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147890/82.wav", + "text": "就是這樣的數字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147890/83.wav", + "text": "當然就法律的精神來說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147890/84.wav", + "text": "這並不是法律的規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147890/85.wav", + "text": "而是一個建議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147890/86.wav", + "text": "所以明年是50加50" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147890/87.wav", + "text": "並不表示未來每年都應該是50加50" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147890/88.wav", + "text": "事實上我剛剛在報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147890/89.wav", + "text": "你剛剛提到這不是法律的規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147890/90.wav", + "text": "但這是你們精算的結果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147890/91.wav", + "text": "這也是為什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147890/92.wav", + "text": "後來這些教育團體" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147890/93.wav", + "text": "全教總他們會出來開記者會說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147890/94.wav", + "text": "奇怪明明你們自己的報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147890/95.wav", + "text": "你們自己精算的結果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147890/96.wav", + "text": "而且你們也講說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147890/97.wav", + "text": "要分10年公務人員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147890/98.wav", + "text": "就是194億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147890/99.wav", + "text": "教育人員就是123億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147890/100.wav", + "text": "結果你們最後的結果只有50億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147890/101.wav", + "text": "所以就打臉你們自己" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147890/102.wav", + "text": "因為當時我們提出來撥補的方案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147890/103.wav", + "text": "也有分10年15年跟20年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147890/104.wav", + "text": "與會的人員基本上都希望" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147890/105.wav", + "text": "能夠越早撥補這樣對基金越有利" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147890/106.wav", + "text": "因為整體國家的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147890/107.wav", + "text": "負擔也會越輕" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147890/108.wav", + "text": "所以我們才會講說政府" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147890/109.wav", + "text": "尤其是考試院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147890/110.wav", + "text": "但明年開始你就沒有按照" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147890/111.wav", + "text": "你的精算結果去做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147890/112.wav", + "text": "我們大概會提早" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147890/113.wav", + "text": "5年用罄嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147890/114.wav", + "text": "結果第一年你就打臉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147890/115.wav", + "text": "自己了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147890/116.wav", + "text": "教育部這邊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147890/117.wav", + "text": "行政院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147890/118.wav", + "text": "主計總處的部分我也問一下副主計長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147890/119.wav", + "text": "我看你的報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147890/120.wav", + "text": "你說明年撥補" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147890/121.wav", + "text": "50億各50億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147890/122.wav", + "text": "缺口好像只有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147890/123.wav", + "text": "20億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147890/124.wav", + "text": "喔你認為只有20億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147890/125.wav", + "text": "喔怎麼會跟銓敘部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147890/126.wav", + "text": "精算的結果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147890/127.wav", + "text": "差那麼多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147890/128.wav", + "text": "而是說這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147890/129.wav", + "text": "缺口我是要用幾年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147890/130.wav", + "text": "來把它做撥補" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147890/131.wav", + "text": "而這194億跟123億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147890/132.wav", + "text": "這個缺口我希望" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147890/133.wav", + "text": "10年把它補足" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147890/134.wav", + "text": "是135年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147890/135.wav", + "text": "112年所以是二十幾年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147890/136.wav", + "text": "以後而現在這個是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147890/137.wav", + "text": "那次會議中大家的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147890/138.wav", + "text": "一個期待就是說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147890/139.wav", + "text": "這個缺口可不可以在10年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147890/140.wav", + "text": "內就把它補足主計總處" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147890/141.wav", + "text": "實際的缺口今年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147890/142.wav", + "text": "跟明年兩年加起來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147890/143.wav", + "text": "是20億所以我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147890/144.wav", + "text": "100億所以基本上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147890/145.wav", + "text": "這只是我" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147890/146.wav", + "text": "到時候會付不出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147890/147.wav", + "text": "就覺得很奇怪因為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147890/148.wav", + "text": "你們是一直依照你們的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147890/149.wav", + "text": "精算因為你們在今年3月" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147890/150.wav", + "text": "的時候也就是第8次的精" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147890/151.wav", + "text": "算報告中就寫得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147890/152.wav", + "text": "很清楚說我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147890/153.wav", + "text": "總共的缺口是多少剛才講了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147890/154.wav", + "text": "有2兆多鄭" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147890/155.wav", + "text": "鄭委員是講2兆7啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147890/156.wav", + "text": "之前嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147890/157.wav", + "text": "所以已經到2兆7了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147890/158.wav", + "text": "如果是這樣子你" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147890/159.wav", + "text": "卻告訴我" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147890/160.wav", + "text": "這個負債明年你們只要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147890/161.wav", + "text": "去撥補100億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147890/162.wav", + "text": "就夠了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147890/163.wav", + "text": "那你到底有沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147890/164.wav", + "text": "真的要讓它" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147890/165.wav", + "text": "到底你要如何處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147890/166.wav", + "text": "這就是一個缺口啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147890/167.wav", + "text": "剛剛講的所謂2兆5的概念" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147890/168.wav", + "text": "我們今天所講的缺口二" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147890/169.wav", + "text": "二者是不太" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147890/170.wav", + "text": "我們這個缺口是從" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147890/171.wav", + "text": "概念來看我一定讓它" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147890/172.wav", + "text": "付就是我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147890/173.wav", + "text": "公教人員的權益他該領到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147890/174.wav", + "text": "你現在講現金流嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147890/175.wav", + "text": "因為新制的實施你會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147890/176.wav", + "text": "舊制的這些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147890/177.wav", + "text": "人因為新制之後不會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147890/178.wav", + "text": "再有錢進來嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147890/179.wav", + "text": "所以你會提早用罄" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147890/180.wav", + "text": "所以才要靠你們的撥補嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147890/181.wav", + "text": "精算的結果是如果分10年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147890/182.wav", + "text": "撥補每一年政府要撥多少錢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147890/183.wav", + "text": "才不會用罄才不會造成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147890/184.wav", + "text": "提早5年用罄" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147890/185.wav", + "text": "你們都在精算報告上寫得很清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147890/186.wav", + "text": "但是你在第一年明年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147890/187.wav", + "text": "你就沒有按照原來精算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147890/188.wav", + "text": "的結果去做撥補嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147890/189.wav", + "text": "我現在意思是這樣跟你說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147890/190.wav", + "text": "的我們算的結果明年大概" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147890/191.wav", + "text": "20億就夠了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147890/192.wav", + "text": "你是在講明年但是你為什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147890/193.wav", + "text": "你自己的報告也有講說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147890/194.wav", + "text": "未來打算要怎麼做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147890/195.wav", + "text": "你已經講得很清楚了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147890/196.wav", + "text": "所以大家才會對你們有疑慮嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147890/197.wav", + "text": "不然你後年又跟我講說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147890/198.wav", + "text": "後年依照我現金流的計算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147890/199.wav", + "text": "也大概只要撥補" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147890/200.wav", + "text": "政府要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147890/201.wav", + "text": "我想這也是你們自己精算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147890/202.wav", + "text": "出來的一個情況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147890/203.wav", + "text": "嘛依照退撫基金" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147890/204.wav", + "text": "第8次精算報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147890/205.wav", + "text": "如果要讓退撫基金可以永續" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147890/206.wav", + "text": "50年你要永續性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147890/207.wav", + "text": "嘛公務人員和教育人員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147890/208.wav", + "text": "的基金每年須撥補" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147890/209.wav", + "text": "如果你要達到它的永續性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147890/210.wav", + "text": "這跟剛剛我們講的100億或是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147890/211.wav", + "text": "銓敘部自己精算的194億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147890/212.wav", + "text": "達到永續性是要撥285億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147890/213.wav", + "text": "但你講說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147890/214.wav", + "text": "因為銓敘部在3月13號邀請教育部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147890/215.wav", + "text": "來協商所以以十年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147890/216.wav", + "text": "嘛我們現在最大的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147890/217.wav", + "text": "大家最大的疑惑就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147890/218.wav", + "text": "你們為什麼沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147890/219.wav", + "text": "依照這個精算報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147890/220.wav", + "text": "去逐年做撥補" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147890/221.wav", + "text": "這個精算報告是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147890/222.wav", + "text": "有很多的假設" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147890/223.wav", + "text": "嘛我依法的撥補" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147890/224.wav", + "text": "撥補嘛所以我們現在就" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147890/225.wav", + "text": "的確依法分年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147890/226.wav", + "text": "撥補確保它一定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147890/227.wav", + "text": "負最終保證" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147890/228.wav", + "text": "保證責任只是說你們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147890/229.wav", + "text": "沒有依照你們精算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147890/230.wav", + "text": "的結果去做撥補" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147890/231.wav", + "text": "所以會讓人很擔心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147890/232.wav", + "text": "很擔心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147890/233.wav", + "text": "部長這邊也有提到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147890/234.wav", + "text": "報告也沒有去考慮到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147890/235.wav", + "text": "我們政府會撥補" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147890/236.wav", + "text": "所以未來它在第9次會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147890/237.wav", + "text": "再重新精算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147890/238.wav", + "text": "預算也已經編了啦其實我是希望" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147890/239.wav", + "text": "缺口" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147890/240.wav", + "text": "我是希望按照你們精算的結果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147890/241.wav", + "text": "去做撥補啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147890/242.wav", + "text": "不要讓這些公務人員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147890/243.wav", + "text": "都在擔心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147890/244.wav", + "text": "啦怎麼講的是一套做的又是一套" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147890/245.wav", + "text": "好不好以上謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147889/0.wav", + "text": "部長部長我想勞退以及勞保的改革" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147889/1.wav", + "text": "其實勢在必行也必須要嚴正面對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147889/2.wav", + "text": "我相信你一定知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147889/3.wav", + "text": "可是我們今天看到你們的專題報告專案報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147889/4.wav", + "text": "裡面卻只有薄薄的3頁" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147889/5.wav", + "text": "甚至在最後的結語和未來展望" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147889/6.wav", + "text": "是完全看不到勞保改革的具體方向" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147889/7.wav", + "text": "就像作文比賽一樣寫了一些文字而已" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147889/8.wav", + "text": "其實完全沒有看到具體的內容" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147889/9.wav", + "text": "我想我們需要的專案報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147889/10.wav", + "text": "是能夠告訴大家我們面對勞保的狀況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147889/11.wav", + "text": "勞保未來要如何來推動改革" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147889/12.wav", + "text": "勞退制度如何來做改革" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147889/13.wav", + "text": "應該要有一個具體的方向" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147889/14.wav", + "text": "為什麼你們只呈現這樣子薄薄的3頁" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147889/15.wav", + "text": "而且完全看不到任何具體的時程" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147889/16.wav", + "text": "和任何具體的方向" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147889/17.wav", + "text": "報告委員因為勞保跟勞退改革" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147889/18.wav", + "text": "所以才更應該要逐步來做確認" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147889/19.wav", + "text": "方向和時間點都應該要清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147889/20.wav", + "text": "簡單來說因為我們目前還沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147889/21.wav", + "text": "具體的改革方案出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147889/22.wav", + "text": "目前還在尋求共識傾聽意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147889/23.wav", + "text": "好沒錯我們在尋求共識" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147889/24.wav", + "text": "是不是應該齊力來做溝通" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147889/25.wav", + "text": "所以昨天勞動部勞保司的司長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147889/26.wav", + "text": "來做預算溝通的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147889/27.wav", + "text": "我們要求勞保改革持續溝通" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147889/28.wav", + "text": "是不是應該每半年或是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147889/29.wav", + "text": "每經過多久時間就告訴大家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147889/30.wav", + "text": "溝通到哪裡可能有幾個方向" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147889/31.wav", + "text": "我們會具體來做進一步的確認" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147889/32.wav", + "text": "結果司長居然告訴我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147889/33.wav", + "text": "勞保改革需要天時地利人和" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147889/34.wav", + "text": "像最低工資法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147889/35.wav", + "text": "我們要過其實很快就可以過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147889/36.wav", + "text": "勞保改革我們需要等待適合的時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147889/37.wav", + "text": "請教部長這種說法你能認同嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147889/38.wav", + "text": "我們到底要等待些什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147889/39.wav", + "text": "等待什麼叫適合的時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147889/40.wav", + "text": "這不是一個好的說法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147889/41.wav", + "text": "我要說的是勞保改革" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147889/42.wav", + "text": "以及勞退制度的改革" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147889/43.wav", + "text": "是全體勞工朋友的權益" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147889/44.wav", + "text": "是應該以民意為基礎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147889/45.wav", + "text": "來保障他們的權益" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147889/46.wav", + "text": "而不是為誰抬轎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147889/47.wav", + "text": "又或者是等待什麼樣的時機點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147889/48.wav", + "text": "如果一再地告訴我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147889/49.wav", + "text": "其實要過現在就可以過了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147889/50.wav", + "text": "我們只是在等待適合的時間點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147889/51.wav", + "text": "要配合天時地利人和" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147889/52.wav", + "text": "我想請教是要配合什麼東西" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147889/53.wav", + "text": "沒有沒有什麼配合天時地利人和" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147889/54.wav", + "text": "因為我剛剛講這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147889/55.wav", + "text": "非常地生氣耶" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147889/56.wav", + "text": "是啊這是我們對待勞工朋友的權益" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147889/57.wav", + "text": "和決心嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147889/58.wav", + "text": "各種型態的勞工又不同" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147889/59.wav", + "text": "其實它要思考的層面非常多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147889/60.wav", + "text": "完全同意啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147889/61.wav", + "text": "就是因為思考層面很多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147889/62.wav", + "text": "我們才要具體來把關和推進" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147889/63.wav", + "text": "嘛而不是告訴我說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147889/64.wav", + "text": "要過就可以過了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147889/65.wav", + "text": "我們現在只是在等待天時地利人和" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147889/66.wav", + "text": "與適合的時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147889/67.wav", + "text": "這樣的說明是不恰當的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147889/68.wav", + "text": "是所以我們看不到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147889/69.wav", + "text": "具體如何來推進" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147889/70.wav", + "text": "我們在今天報告裡面的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147889/71.wav", + "text": "結語以及未來展望" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147889/72.wav", + "text": "我覺得完全就是在玩文字遊戲" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147889/73.wav", + "text": "和作文比賽而已" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147889/74.wav", + "text": "這不是大家所期待的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147889/75.wav", + "text": "既然它很難推動" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147889/76.wav", + "text": "很難具體達到共識" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147889/77.wav", + "text": "就應該更認真地去走好每一步" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147889/78.wav", + "text": "做好溝通和調解的過程" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147889/79.wav", + "text": "以及具體地來做一些方向的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147889/80.wav", + "text": "討論和推進" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147889/81.wav", + "text": "我想這才是對的方式吧" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147889/82.wav", + "text": "是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147889/83.wav", + "text": "我們每次都說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147889/84.wav", + "text": "勞工朋友的權益很重要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147889/85.wav", + "text": "可是我們卻看到這樣的報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147889/86.wav", + "text": "和給我這樣子的答案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147889/87.wav", + "text": "我覺得非常沒有辦法接受" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147889/88.wav", + "text": "我們希望能夠嚴正來面對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147889/89.wav", + "text": "而且也希望勞動部能夠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147889/90.wav", + "text": "更加深切地檢討" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147889/91.wav", + "text": "並且來討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147889/92.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147889/93.wav", + "text": "部長我覺得這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147889/94.wav", + "text": "子的作法真的沒有辦法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147889/95.wav", + "text": "讓大家接受" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147889/96.wav", + "text": "這關係到勞工朋友" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147889/97.wav", + "text": "這麼多人的權益" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147889/98.wav", + "text": "您剛剛也提到了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147889/99.wav", + "text": "不應該是用這種態度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147889/100.wav", + "text": "我們希望勞動部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147889/101.wav", + "text": "真的應該要做嚴格的把關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147889/102.wav", + "text": "並且具體地推進" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147889/103.wav", + "text": "接下來我們要請教" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147889/104.wav", + "text": "航空業性別平等的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147889/105.wav", + "text": "我國的國籍航空" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147889/106.wav", + "text": "陸續發生了一些涉及" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147889/107.wav", + "text": "空服員性別工作平等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147889/108.wav", + "text": "相關權益的事件" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147889/109.wav", + "text": "所以我們想請教" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147889/110.wav", + "text": "是不是應該要具體來促成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147889/111.wav", + "text": "企業遵守性別平等工作法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147889/112.wav", + "text": "並且落實CEDAW的精神" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147889/113.wav", + "text": "是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147889/114.wav", + "text": "好我們看到幾個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147889/115.wav", + "text": "當時不管是我們在討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147889/116.wav", + "text": "這些地勤以及空服員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147889/117.wav", + "text": "相對權益不夠對等的情況之下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147889/118.wav", + "text": "能夠來爭取平等的情況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147889/119.wav", + "text": "但是卻看到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147889/120.wav", + "text": "實際上的作法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147889/121.wav", + "text": "調整前有落差" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147889/122.wav", + "text": "空服員男性女性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147889/123.wav", + "text": "以及空服及地勤的狀況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147889/124.wav", + "text": "不一的情況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147889/125.wav", + "text": "在調整後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147889/126.wav", + "text": "來做到平等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147889/127.wav", + "text": "可是這並不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147889/128.wav", + "text": "我們在推動性別平等的目標" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147889/129.wav", + "text": "我們希望的是要能夠一起來提升" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147889/130.wav", + "text": "讓他們都能夠達到同樣的權利" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147889/131.wav", + "text": "而不是用削弱的方式來做處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147889/132.wav", + "text": "這樣的情況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147889/133.wav", + "text": "其實我們在上一次的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147889/134.wav", + "text": "性別平等工作法的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147889/135.wav", + "text": "也提到了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147889/136.wav", + "text": "目前性別平等工作法的第9條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147889/137.wav", + "text": "和第10條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147889/138.wav", + "text": "有特別提到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147889/139.wav", + "text": "不得因為有這樣子的情況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147889/140.wav", + "text": "而有差別待遇" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147889/141.wav", + "text": "而且在第10條也提到了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147889/142.wav", + "text": "不得以降低其他受僱者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147889/143.wav", + "text": "薪資的方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147889/144.wav", + "text": "來規避前項的規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147889/145.wav", + "text": "其實就是希望在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147889/146.wav", + "text": "各種福利上面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147889/147.wav", + "text": "是能夠一起向上提升的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147889/148.wav", + "text": "而不是一體共同減低的情況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147889/149.wav", + "text": "在當時的修法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147889/150.wav", + "text": "希望能夠提出" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147889/151.wav", + "text": "修正動議來增訂罰則" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147889/152.wav", + "text": "限制僱主用降低" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147889/153.wav", + "text": "其他受僱者的福利" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147889/154.wav", + "text": "和第10條的情況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147889/155.wav", + "text": "可是當時並沒有辦法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147889/156.wav", + "text": "達成共識來做推進" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147889/157.wav", + "text": "所以想請教部長的是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147889/158.wav", + "text": "針對這樣子的情況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147889/159.wav", + "text": "惡意來規避" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147889/160.wav", + "text": "性別工作平等法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147889/161.wav", + "text": "第9條的雇主" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147889/162.wav", + "text": "是不是應該要避免發生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147889/163.wav", + "text": "它福利的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147889/164.wav", + "text": "本來就不能片面更改" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147889/165.wav", + "text": "當然如果有被侵害的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147889/166.wav", + "text": "一定是可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147889/167.wav", + "text": "藉由申訴來救濟" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147889/168.wav", + "text": "剛剛委員提的這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147889/169.wav", + "text": "所以申訴之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147889/170.wav", + "text": "我們可以怎麼樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147889/171.wav", + "text": "來做具體的協助" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147889/172.wav", + "text": "部長應該認同" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147889/173.wav", + "text": "不應該用降低的方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147889/174.wav", + "text": "而應該是一體來做提升" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147889/175.wav", + "text": "所以這部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147889/176.wav", + "text": "他好像有提" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147889/177.wav", + "text": "10月2號有向本部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147889/178.wav", + "text": "提出來了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147889/179.wav", + "text": "後續會依法來審議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147889/180.wav", + "text": "桃園的答辯" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147889/181.wav", + "text": "我們會依法來處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147889/182.wav", + "text": "所以部長認同" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147889/183.wav", + "text": "其實應該是把這兩者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147889/184.wav", + "text": "一起向上提升到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147889/185.wav", + "text": "而不是向下來做降低" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147889/186.wav", + "text": "當然當然是的確因為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147889/187.wav", + "text": "真正的平等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147889/188.wav", + "text": "是應該要讓勞工的福利" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147889/189.wav", + "text": "實質的平等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147889/190.wav", + "text": "不是形式的去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147889/191.wav", + "text": "另外一個性別" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147889/192.wav", + "text": "我想這樣是不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147889/193.wav", + "text": "所以剛剛提到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147889/194.wav", + "text": "勞動部也收到了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147889/195.wav", + "text": "這樣子的申訴在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147889/196.wav", + "text": "在這樣的情況之下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147889/197.wav", + "text": "因為要等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147889/198.wav", + "text": "桃園這邊的答辯" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147889/199.wav", + "text": "收到以後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147889/200.wav", + "text": "依法來進行審議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147889/201.wav", + "text": "也會依法來處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147889/202.wav", + "text": "所以桃園的答辯" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147889/203.wav", + "text": "預計什麼時候會提出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147889/204.wav", + "text": "什麼時候能夠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147889/205.wav", + "text": "具體來做協助" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147889/206.wav", + "text": "會處理總不能一直等待" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147889/207.wav", + "text": "都有一個時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147889/208.wav", + "text": "要提出答辯" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147889/209.wav", + "text": "我們一定會要求" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147889/210.wav", + "text": "它在期限內" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147889/211.wav", + "text": "要提出答辯" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147889/212.wav", + "text": "是所以我想請教" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147889/213.wav", + "text": "勞動部什麼時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147889/214.wav", + "text": "會處理這件事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147889/215.wav", + "text": "沒有辦法持續等待" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147889/216.wav", + "text": "因為這並不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147889/217.wav", + "text": "第一次發生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147889/218.wav", + "text": "之前在制服的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147889/219.wav", + "text": "也曾經發生過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147889/220.wav", + "text": "我們當時在修法的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147889/221.wav", + "text": "就提出來了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147889/222.wav", + "text": "我們希望至少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147889/223.wav", + "text": "在沒有辦法落入" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147889/224.wav", + "text": "子法的情況之下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147889/225.wav", + "text": "能夠具體地" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147889/226.wav", + "text": "在個案上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147889/227.wav", + "text": "來做協助和處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147889/228.wav", + "text": "報告委員一般案件" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147889/229.wav", + "text": "三個月內會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147889/230.wav", + "text": "我們是不是可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147889/231.wav", + "text": "進入10月11月12月" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147889/232.wav", + "text": "所以11月能不能" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147889/233.wav", + "text": "往前推進一些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147889/234.wav", + "text": "因為這其實一再的發生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147889/235.wav", + "text": "我覺得真的很遺憾" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147889/236.wav", + "text": "好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147889/237.wav", + "text": "接下來一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147889/238.wav", + "text": "是有關服儀的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147889/239.wav", + "text": "有男女不平等的情況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147889/240.wav", + "text": "長期以來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147889/241.wav", + "text": "女性空服員的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147889/242.wav", + "text": "服務專業常常被忽略" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147889/243.wav", + "text": "取而代之的就是物化" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147889/244.wav", + "text": "甚至是這樣子的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147889/245.wav", + "text": "職業意象" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147889/246.wav", + "text": "2015年的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147889/247.wav", + "text": "我們看到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147889/248.wav", + "text": "華航新制服的設計師" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147889/249.wav", + "text": "就直言地表示" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147889/250.wav", + "text": "如果空姐的制服" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147889/251.wav", + "text": "不能引人遐想" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147889/252.wav", + "text": "那是設計師的失敗" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147889/253.wav", + "text": "當時就遭到許多的批判" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147889/254.wav", + "text": "但是直至2023年的現在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147889/255.wav", + "text": "我們仍然看到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147889/256.wav", + "text": "有些政黨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147889/257.wav", + "text": "在舉辦女性後援會的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147889/258.wav", + "text": "用窄裙鏤空上衣的裝扮" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147889/259.wav", + "text": "來籌組空姐應援團" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147889/260.wav", + "text": "也遭到空服員工會的譴責" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147889/261.wav", + "text": "認為這是錯誤的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147889/262.wav", + "text": "就性別平等的視角" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147889/263.wav", + "text": "更不應該如此處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147889/264.wav", + "text": "甚至會加深惡化了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147889/265.wav", + "text": "對女性空服員的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147889/266.wav", + "text": "刻板印象" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147889/267.wav", + "text": "\n當然我們看到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147889/268.wav", + "text": "對於服儀有不同的要求" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147889/269.wav", + "text": "過去也曾經常常看到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147889/270.wav", + "text": "它有違反性別平等的意涵" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147889/271.wav", + "text": "我們回到空服員的身上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147889/272.wav", + "text": "其實像這些空服員們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147889/273.wav", + "text": "他們當時在做飛安演習" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147889/274.wav", + "text": "又或者是在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147889/275.wav", + "text": "做地勤訓練的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147889/276.wav", + "text": "都是穿著褲裝的工作服" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147889/277.wav", + "text": "可是到了實際上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147889/278.wav", + "text": "執行勤務的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147889/279.wav", + "text": "卻要求女性空服員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147889/280.wav", + "text": "只能穿著裙裝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147889/281.wav", + "text": "這完全不是出自於" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147889/282.wav", + "text": "工作專業的考量" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147889/283.wav", + "text": "而是在幫他們的外貌" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147889/284.wav", + "text": "以及他們的打扮" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147889/285.wav", + "text": "所以我們看到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147889/286.wav", + "text": "這些空服員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147889/287.wav", + "text": "們透過工會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147889/288.wav", + "text": "來向桃園市政府的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147889/289.wav", + "text": "性平會來申訴" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147889/290.wav", + "text": "是有違反性工法的可能性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147889/291.wav", + "text": "但是桃園市政府卻以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147889/292.wav", + "text": "航空公司並沒有規劃" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147889/293.wav", + "text": "女性要穿著褲裝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147889/294.wav", + "text": "以及這不是用性別為出發點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147889/295.wav", + "text": "而給予不利對待的情況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147889/296.wav", + "text": "認為沒有違反性工法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147889/297.wav", + "text": "所以只有建議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147889/298.wav", + "text": "希望他們把褲裝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147889/299.wav", + "text": "第一個是就" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147889/300.wav", + "text": "職業的安全上來說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147889/301.wav", + "text": "其實也已經有提出來了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147889/302.wav", + "text": "如果裙裝搭配絲襪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147889/303.wav", + "text": "可能會有相關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147889/304.wav", + "text": "危險上的影響" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147889/305.wav", + "text": "第二個部分是在於" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147889/306.wav", + "text": "如果他們在進行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147889/307.wav", + "text": "飛安演練的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147889/308.wav", + "text": "是著褲裝來做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147889/309.wav", + "text": "工作規劃練習的情況之下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147889/310.wav", + "text": "顯示他們的工作需求" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147889/311.wav", + "text": "其實是以褲裝為主要會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147889/312.wav", + "text": "符合他們工作需求" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147889/313.wav", + "text": "可是執行勤務卻要求" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147889/314.wav", + "text": "他們穿裙裝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147889/315.wav", + "text": "我們認為這已經" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147889/316.wav", + "text": "違反了性別平等的概念" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147889/317.wav", + "text": "想請教部長的看法如何" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147889/318.wav", + "text": "能不能接受" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147889/319.wav", + "text": "桃園市政府的說法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147889/320.wav", + "text": "報告委員我想這個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147889/321.wav", + "text": "不管是服儀" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147889/322.wav", + "text": "或其他的公司對於員工" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147889/323.wav", + "text": "的一些作為要求" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147889/324.wav", + "text": "所以像剛才看到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147889/325.wav", + "text": "有職安的風險" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147889/326.wav", + "text": "而且工作上的需求" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147889/327.wav", + "text": "我們會來跟地方政府" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147889/328.wav", + "text": "做一些瞭解" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147889/329.wav", + "text": "也做一些溝通" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147889/330.wav", + "text": "同時也會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147889/331.wav", + "text": "是不是先說出" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147889/332.wav", + "text": "勞動部的態度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147889/333.wav", + "text": "認為是不是需要做調整" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147889/334.wav", + "text": "是不是有影響到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147889/335.wav", + "text": "性別平等的可能性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147889/336.wav", + "text": "啦這個會有影響到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147889/337.wav", + "text": "不排除的意思是有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147889/338.wav", + "text": "還是沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147889/339.wav", + "text": "按照您剛剛的質詢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147889/340.wav", + "text": "先做這樣的回答" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147889/341.wav", + "text": "但是具體的我還是要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147889/342.wav", + "text": "這已經不是個案了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147889/343.wav", + "text": "其實女性空服員的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147889/344.wav", + "text": "服裝問題已經討論過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147889/345.wav", + "text": "非常多年了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147889/346.wav", + "text": "性別平等的觀點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147889/347.wav", + "text": "來處理相關的這些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147889/348.wav", + "text": "不好意思委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147889/349.wav", + "text": "超過2分鐘了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147889/350.wav", + "text": "好瞭解" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147889/351.wav", + "text": "所以我們想提到的是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147889/352.wav", + "text": "其實像各種" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147889/353.wav", + "text": "包括國際上也都正視" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147889/354.wav", + "text": "他們的專業" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147889/355.wav", + "text": "和尊嚴的情況之下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147889/356.wav", + "text": "我們希望能夠持續推進" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147889/357.wav", + "text": "部長您今天說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147889/358.wav", + "text": "沒有辦法理解" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147889/359.wav", + "text": "沒有辦法現在就知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147889/360.wav", + "text": "狀況其實這真的不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147889/361.wav", + "text": "現在就發生的狀況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147889/362.wav", + "text": "很多次也發生過很多年了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147889/363.wav", + "text": "我認為勞動部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147889/364.wav", + "text": "站在捍衛勞工權益" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147889/365.wav", + "text": "以及職場安全的原則下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147889/366.wav", + "text": "應該要嚴正地表態" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147889/367.wav", + "text": "並且具體來處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147889/368.wav", + "text": "希望勞動部能夠一起加油" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147889/369.wav", + "text": "謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147889/370.wav", + "text": "謝謝委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147888/0.wav", + "text": "主計長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147888/1.wav", + "text": "主計長好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147888/2.wav", + "text": "就是薪資的三條線" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147888/3.wav", + "text": "但是比較關鍵的我個人認為是在藍線的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147888/4.wav", + "text": "就是每人每月經常性實質薪資的部分才是一個關鍵" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147888/5.wav", + "text": "對照於基本工資這幾年政策上的一個工具的使用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147888/6.wav", + "text": "基本工資成長了25.6%" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147888/7.wav", + "text": "但是實質薪資成長只有4.2%" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147888/8.wav", + "text": "如果再對照我們的經濟成長率" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147888/9.wav", + "text": "大概成長了19.4%" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147888/10.wav", + "text": "以至於目前為止" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147888/11.wav", + "text": "我們整個貧富差距率的指標高達6.15倍" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147888/12.wav", + "text": "這都是環環相扣的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147888/13.wav", + "text": "我想這個部分主計長應該都非常清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147888/14.wav", + "text": "某個程度來說就是我們的經濟成長率" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147888/15.wav", + "text": "並沒有所謂經濟學家所講的達到那個下滲的效果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147888/16.wav", + "text": "它本來是有築底堆高的一個效用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147888/17.wav", + "text": "因為你掌握了各部會的預算大權" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147888/18.wav", + "text": "你看看我算一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147888/19.wav", + "text": "喔就第一等份基本工資的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147888/20.wav", + "text": "大概有105十五萬的勞工朋友" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147888/21.wav", + "text": "它都有調升上漲" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147888/22.wav", + "text": "因為基本工資推高的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147888/23.wav", + "text": "第一等份就是最靠近基本工資的這一群" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147888/24.wav", + "text": "19.95" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147888/25.wav", + "text": "%另外一個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147888/26.wav", + "text": "第一階段的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147888/27.wav", + "text": "第二階段跟第三階段的勞工朋友" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147888/28.wav", + "text": "成長大概百分之九至十" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147888/29.wav", + "text": "也就是它的邊際效益其��是在遞減" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147888/30.wav", + "text": "而實質上他們真的絕對的薪資金額" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147888/31.wav", + "text": "也不過是在五萬到八萬上下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147888/32.wav", + "text": "如果再加上房價跟通膨部分的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147888/33.wav", + "text": "相對而言被剝奪感就蠻嚴重的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147888/34.wav", + "text": "主計長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147888/35.wav", + "text": "所以我們雖然在基本工資" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147888/36.wav", + "text": "有付出了一些努力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147888/37.wav", + "text": "但是有一群人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147888/38.wav", + "text": "感受不到薪資有成長的這種效果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147888/39.wav", + "text": "中間那個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147888/40.wav", + "text": "主計長你講的沒有錯" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147888/41.wav", + "text": "就是中間那一層" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147888/42.wav", + "text": "我為了這個問題也問了行政院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147888/43.wav", + "text": "政次也請上來一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147888/44.wav", + "text": "員工酬勞" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147888/45.wav", + "text": "而酬勞兩個字有很多不同的解釋方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147888/46.wav", + "text": "都不一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147888/47.wav", + "text": "可是我們看到企業多半的作法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147888/48.wav", + "text": "都是前者而非後者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147888/49.wav", + "text": "就是給獎金居多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147888/50.wav", + "text": "以至於在薪資的部分經濟學所說的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147888/51.wav", + "text": "那個下滲的效果非常有限" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147888/52.wav", + "text": "次長你有沒有什麼方法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147888/53.wav", + "text": "報告委員臺灣的企業" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147888/54.wav", + "text": "尤其是中小企業常常有一個狀況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147888/55.wav", + "text": "就是賺錢的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147888/56.wav", + "text": "它用獎金委員講的沒有錯" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147888/57.wav", + "text": "但是它虧錢也比較不會資遣員工" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147888/58.wav", + "text": "啦不過我來這邊開會之前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147888/59.wav", + "text": "王部長特別交代" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147888/60.wav", + "text": "他願意個人採取措施來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147888/61.wav", + "text": "籲請呼籲企業老闆" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147888/62.wav", + "text": "應該幫員工加薪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147888/63.wav", + "text": "共享經濟成長的籲" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147888/64.wav", + "text": "籲請企業老闆加薪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147888/65.wav", + "text": "我從上個會期到這個會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147888/66.wav", + "text": "期都請陳建仁院長講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147888/67.wav", + "text": "了企業會來要水要電要土地" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147888/68.wav", + "text": "還有要勞工要移工" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147888/69.wav", + "text": "什麼都要就是不加薪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147888/70.wav", + "text": "所以這個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147888/71.wav", + "text": "不是政府都只有給" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147888/72.wav", + "text": "你也要懂得要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147888/73.wav", + "text": "其實透過政府部門的強烈呼籲跟要求" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147888/74.wav", + "text": "要建構其社會責任形象的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147888/75.wav", + "text": "也應該多少要付出一些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147888/76.wav", + "text": "我們支持這個政策" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147888/77.wav", + "text": "支持這個政策" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147888/78.wav", + "text": "但是你們有沒有什麼具體的作法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147888/79.wav", + "text": "你也要常常打一下電話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147888/80.wav", + "text": "經常打電話給經團連" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147888/81.wav", + "text": "你有打過電話嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147888/82.wav", + "text": "我們其實在很多措施裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147888/83.wav", + "text": "都有把企業對員工加薪列入獎勵" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147888/84.wav", + "text": "次長我待會再請教你問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147888/85.wav", + "text": "看到這些數字以你這麼聰明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147888/86.wav", + "text": "你有沒有什麼方法可以建議相關部會怎麼做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147888/87.wav", + "text": "主管部會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147888/88.wav", + "text": "當主管部會跟你要錢的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147888/89.wav", + "text": "你有沒有什麼辦法告訴他們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147888/90.wav", + "text": "讓企業能夠多加薪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147888/91.wav", + "text": "我不能用這個手段" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147888/92.wav", + "text": "去管它的預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147888/93.wav", + "text": "你不能用你的聰明才智來讓整個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147888/94.wav", + "text": "成長多一點嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147888/95.wav", + "text": "薪資在經濟學上等於勞動的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147888/96.wav", + "text": "邊際生產力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147888/97.wav", + "text": "如何讓勞動的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147888/98.wav", + "text": "邊際生產力提高" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147888/99.wav", + "text": "你不要再歸結於邊際生產力的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147888/100.wav", + "text": "而是企業成果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147888/101.wav", + "text": "在心態上不願意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147888/102.wav", + "text": "它不是撥給公積金" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147888/103.wav", + "text": "或是董監事的酬勞增加" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147888/104.wav", + "text": "而不願意給勞工朋友增加" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147888/105.wav", + "text": "這恐怕是分配最關鍵的原因" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147888/106.wav", + "text": "不要再歸結於邊際生產力的問題了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147888/107.wav", + "text": "臺灣的勞工素質算很高了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147888/108.wav", + "text": "\n接下來請財政部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147888/109.wav", + "text": "財政部長剛剛有提" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147888/110.wav", + "text": "到中小企業加薪抵稅的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147888/111.wav", + "text": "已經達到退場機制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147888/112.wav", + "text": "不是你主政" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147888/113.wav", + "text": "但是如果沒有辦法達到抵稅效果的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147888/114.wav", + "text": "你們當初在彙整" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147888/115.wav", + "text": "這個條件的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147888/116.wav", + "text": "你剛剛提到接下來要改變一些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147888/117.wav", + "text": "稅則的方���" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147888/118.wav", + "text": "讓企業更願意加薪更願意來抵稅的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147888/119.wav", + "text": "當初經濟部在第" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147888/120.wav", + "text": "第二行第三行就有一個數字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147888/121.wav", + "text": "經濟景氣指數" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147888/122.wav", + "text": "支付薪資額度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147888/123.wav", + "text": "130%" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147888/124.wav", + "text": "的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147888/125.wav", + "text": "作為營所稅減免" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147888/126.wav", + "text": "不管它有沒有需要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147888/127.wav", + "text": "透過營所稅的減免" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147888/128.wav", + "text": "在所謂的經濟景氣指標的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147888/129.wav", + "text": "你們怎麼定義呢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147888/130.wav", + "text": "定義規定在第2條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147888/131.wav", + "text": "係指按照發布之失業率" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147888/132.wav", + "text": "連續六個月高於一定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147888/133.wav", + "text": "數值" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147888/134.wav", + "text": "怎麼會用失業率" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147888/135.wav", + "text": "作為一個指標呢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147888/136.wav", + "text": "失業率不是落後指標" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147888/137.wav", + "text": "一定數值的情況下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147888/138.wav", + "text": "可是3.78%這幾年都沒有發生過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147888/139.wav", + "text": "你用一個子法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147888/140.wav", + "text": "來阻擋母法的落實" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147888/141.wav", + "text": "這不是自相矛盾嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147888/142.wav", + "text": "次長部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147888/143.wav", + "text": "聽說這個條文是你們兩個部會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147888/144.wav", + "text": "討論出來的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147888/145.wav", + "text": "當時的背景" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147888/146.wav", + "text": "是10年以前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147888/147.wav", + "text": "當時可能國內的失業率比較高" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147888/148.wav", + "text": "你不能看失業率比較高" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147888/149.wav", + "text": "就用失業率作為指標" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147888/150.wav", + "text": "而是要有合理性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147888/151.wav", + "text": "現在失業率不高了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147888/152.wav", + "text": "那這個條款就不用用了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147888/153.wav", + "text": "而且現在是要加薪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147888/154.wav", + "text": "GDP成長率" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147888/155.wav", + "text": "有能力再加薪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147888/156.wav", + "text": "怎麼用失業率呢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147888/157.wav", + "text": "在失業率的情況下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147888/158.wav", + "text": "勞方已經沒有什麼議價能力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147888/159.wav", + "text": "他怎麼會要求你加薪呢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147888/160.wav", + "text": "次長這個邏輯不通" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147888/161.wav", + "text": "嘛部長你不認為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147888/162.wav", + "text": "這邏輯不通嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147888/163.wav", + "text": "這個��分確實" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147888/164.wav", + "text": "因為明年5月19日就落日" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147888/165.wav", + "text": "所以經濟部也已經準備" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147888/166.wav", + "text": "思考要怎麼樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147888/167.wav", + "text": "去調整其適用範圍" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147888/168.wav", + "text": "那麼日出條款的內容" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147888/169.wav", + "text": "能不能看到希望" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147888/170.wav", + "text": "讓它的條件能夠更合適" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147888/171.wav", + "text": "我想這個部分經濟部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147888/172.wav", + "text": "用子法來封殺母法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147888/173.wav", + "text": "哪有這種道理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147888/174.wav", + "text": "針對能夠落實的部分真正讓所謂的下滲" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147888/175.wav", + "text": "透過制度的引進" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147888/176.wav", + "text": "我們現在制度上的工具" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147888/177.wav", + "text": "中間的部分都沒有感受到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147888/178.wav", + "text": "我們要為中間的這群人來努力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147888/179.wav", + "text": "這群人做努力呢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147888/180.wav", + "text": "我們看所得稅優化" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147888/181.wav", + "text": "的部分薪資所得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147888/182.wav", + "text": "占各類所得高達71%" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147888/183.wav", + "text": "錢越多的人當然要繳越高的比率" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147888/184.wav", + "text": "可是優化的結果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147888/185.wav", + "text": "121萬至453萬的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147888/186.wav", + "text": "這一群人增幅最大" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147888/187.wav", + "text": "就小那沒話說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147888/188.wav", + "text": "反倒是500萬至1,000萬的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147888/189.wav", + "text": "增幅越少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147888/190.wav", + "text": "這就違反了累進稅率的概念" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147888/191.wav", + "text": "沒有達到財富重分配的效果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147888/192.wav", + "text": "你有沒有發現這個數字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147888/193.wav", + "text": "之前我問你的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147888/194.wav", + "text": "你說因為105年有修改" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147888/195.wav", + "text": "所以不能跟109年來做比較" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147888/196.wav", + "text": "那我現在就用109年與110" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147888/197.wav", + "text": "年來看同樣一套制度修改之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147888/198.wav", + "text": "比較的結果優化的結果就是這種狀況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147888/199.wav", + "text": "那不是逆分配嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147888/200.wav", + "text": "所得稅制優化的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147888/201.wav", + "text": "其實我們一直都在調整改進" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147888/202.wav", + "text": "有關的免稅額" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147888/203.wav", + "text": "與特別扣除額我們都會隨著CPI" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147888/204.wav", + "text": "這些相關的數據我們都可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147888/205.wav", + "text": "這個優化的問題是不是有達到所謂" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147888/206.wav", + "text": "財產重分配的效果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147888/207.wav", + "text": "另外一個部分薪資所得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147888/208.wav", + "text": "占所有所得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147888/209.wav", + "text": "71%" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147888/210.wav", + "text": "相對其他國家來說還是很高" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147888/211.wav", + "text": "這個部分有沒有可能降到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147888/212.wav", + "text": "70%以下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147888/213.wav", + "text": "占70%以上但是透過稅制以後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147888/214.wav", + "text": "近七成都是適用12%" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147888/215.wav", + "text": "日後有沒有要朝向再下降的可能性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147888/216.wav", + "text": "來做一個檢討" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147888/217.wav", + "text": "也許可以有沒有成為你的政策目標" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147888/218.wav", + "text": "有沒有持續下降" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147888/219.wav", + "text": "謝謝委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147887/0.wav", + "text": "請陳部長部長今年23月乾旱造成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147887/1.wav", + "text": "農業部在4月28日就公告了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147887/2.wav", + "text": "沒有錯吧" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147887/3.wav", + "text": "昨天我去大埔" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147887/4.wav", + "text": "我收到很多大埔鄉親的陳情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147887/5.wav", + "text": "說到現在為止" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147887/6.wav", + "text": "很多查勘的案件都沒有辦理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147887/7.wav", + "text": "請問林業署有沒有這回事" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147887/8.wav", + "text": "我知道報告委員我們都已經完成初勘了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147887/9.wav", + "text": "什麼時候完成初勘到現在為止" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147887/10.wav", + "text": "你要知道4月28日到今天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147887/11.wav", + "text": "到現在為止" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147887/12.wav", + "text": "有一些案子會拖比較久" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147887/13.wav", + "text": "是因為農民的資料不齊全" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147887/14.wav", + "text": "還有一些樣態是沒有續約" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147887/15.wav", + "text": "他之前一直沒有續約" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147887/16.wav", + "text": "所以他必須要完成續約" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147887/17.wav", + "text": "在有約的狀態下才能夠進行後續" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147887/18.wav", + "text": "部長我現在講的意思就是說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147887/19.wav", + "text": "不管什麼原因" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147887/20.wav", + "text": "到現在民眾還沒有接到整個補助款" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147887/21.wav", + "text": "這個是不合理的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147887/22.wav", + "text": "今天是十月二十幾號了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147887/23.wav", + "text": "足足五個月了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147887/24.wav", + "text": "為什麼是這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147887/25.wav", + "text": "聽說關子嶺工作站到現在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147887/26.wav", + "text": "還壓了一百零多件" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147887/27.wav", + "text": "還沒有去查勘為什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147887/28.wav", + "text": "好到現在為止還沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147887/29.wav", + "text": "啦你回去再查就知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147887/30.wav", + "text": "還有一百零多件還沒有去查勘" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147887/31.wav", + "text": "還沒有辦理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147887/32.wav", + "text": "署長我問你一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147887/33.wav", + "text": "各鄉鎮大概都已經領了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147887/34.wav", + "text": "剩下的就是大埔" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147887/35.wav", + "text": "到現在為止" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147887/36.wav", + "text": "整個行政程序還沒有完備" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147887/37.wav", + "text": "所以你沒有辦法核撥這些補助款" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147887/38.wav", + "text": "我現在問你" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147887/39.wav", + "text": "12月以前有辦法辦理完成嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147887/40.wav", + "text": "可以把錢撥到農民的手裡嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147887/41.wav", + "text": "可以不可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147887/42.wav", + "text": "可以我們已經有要求了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147887/43.wav", + "text": "好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147887/44.wav", + "text": "最起碼啦現在是10月" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147887/45.wav", + "text": "在10月底以前要申請甚至要完成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147887/46.wav", + "text": "我想11月中旬你都可以核撥" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147887/47.wav", + "text": "啦我幫你延到12月這樣可以嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147887/48.wav", + "text": "沒問題吧" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147887/49.wav", + "text": "部長有問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147887/50.wav", + "text": "怠惰沒有話講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147887/51.wav", + "text": "我以為都已經完成了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147887/52.wav", + "text": "哪有23月發生的事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147887/53.wav", + "text": "4月公告5月" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147887/54.wav", + "text": "到現在10月足足5個月都還沒有辦理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147887/55.wav", + "text": "這實在離譜到極點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147887/56.wav", + "text": "10月24號農業部公告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147887/57.wav", + "text": "稻米災害現金救助" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147887/58.wav", + "text": "和低利貸款的地區" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147887/59.wav", + "text": "嘉義大概就是布袋鹿草" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147887/60.wav", + "text": "義竹等六個鄉鎮" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147887/61.wav", + "text": "我要請問一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147887/62.wav", + "text": "同樣是稻穀的產量減量" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147887/63.wav", + "text": "甚至品質下降" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147887/64.wav", + "text": "為什麼都沒有列入" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147887/65.wav", + "text": "稻農哀哀叫這是什麼原因" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147887/66.wav", + "text": "它的受損率大概沒有達到20%" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147887/67.wav", + "text": "0%只有10%左右" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147887/68.wav", + "text": "所以沒辦法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147887/69.wav", + "text": "但是因為整個水稻的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147887/70.wav", + "text": "我們有農業保險" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147887/71.wav", + "text": "如果達到一個損害的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147887/72.wav", + "text": "我們用農業保險還是照樣可以去做理賠的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147887/73.wav", + "text": "我是覺得事實上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147887/74.wav", + "text": "鎮這一次小犬颱風也造成很大的傷害" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147887/75.wav", + "text": "我們是希望你們重新再看一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147887/76.wav", + "text": "有一個很大的傷害" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147887/77.wav", + "text": "是不是你們積極再看有沒有什麼補救" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147887/78.wav", + "text": "受損的為什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147887/79.wav", + "text": "那邊的鄉鎮就有補助這邊就沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147887/80.wav", + "text": "所以這邊有播種" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147887/81.wav", + "text": "通盤再討論一下看一下好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147887/82.wav", + "text": "跟委員報告水稻有可能有延遲性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147887/83.wav", + "text": "它可能沒辦法馬上呈現" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147887/84.wav", + "text": "如果有延遲性我們會再" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147887/85.wav", + "text": "同不同意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147887/86.wav", + "text": "接下來我想再請教一下部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147887/87.wav", + "text": "我看今天的預算書裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147887/88.wav", + "text": "特別有提到大阿里山" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147887/89.wav", + "text": "軸帶百年躍升建設" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147887/90.wav", + "text": "這個計畫是幾年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147887/91.wav", + "text": "四年四年總共多少經費" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147887/92.wav", + "text": "主要的內容是什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147887/93.wav", + "text": "大阿里山要提升為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147887/94.wav", + "text": "國際級觀光區域的最後一哩路" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147887/95.wav", + "text": "所以它是一個跨部會的計畫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147887/96.wav", + "text": "包含農業部交通部文化部原民會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147887/97.wav", + "text": "我們在過去這一年多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147887/98.wav", + "text": "都有共同來研議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147887/99.wav", + "text": "也包含兩個地方政府" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147887/100.wav", + "text": "就是嘉義縣跟嘉義市" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147887/101.wav", + "text": "這部分也都跟兩個地方政府都討論過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147887/102.wav", + "text": "主要就是要用老景點新生命的這種" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147887/103.wav", + "text": "下一個百年的任務沒有錯吧" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147887/104.wav", + "text": "其實應該這樣講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147887/105.wav", + "text": "所以很多土地都叫做林班地" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147887/106.wav", + "text": "很多土地的受限是以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147887/107.wav", + "text": "而未來的一百零年我們應該要很清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147887/108.wav", + "text": "嘉義山區阿里山森林鐵路的沿線" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147887/109.wav", + "text": "大概都是以觀光為主" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147887/110.wav", + "text": "事實上要有一個新的思維模式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147887/111.wav", + "text": "我們也在朝這個方向" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147887/112.wav", + "text": "正式要核定這個計畫之前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147887/113.wav", + "text": "有特別提出了幾個重點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147887/114.wav", + "text": "阿里山地區的住宿設施不足" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147887/115.wav", + "text": "所以應該研議相關的民宿土地管制等限制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147887/116.wav", + "text": "來加強住宿設施的發展沒有錯吧" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147887/117.wav", + "text": "所以簡單講就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147887/118.wav", + "text": "未來的民宿還有土地的限制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147887/119.wav", + "text": "這些管制的辦法及管���條例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147887/120.wav", + "text": "事實上我們是應該要重新做一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147887/121.wav", + "text": "全面性的檢討" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147887/122.wav", + "text": "沒有錯吧" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147887/123.wav", + "text": "行政院公文的指示大概是這樣子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147887/124.wav", + "text": "我們也是朝這個方向" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147887/125.wav", + "text": "所以現在嘉義山區就是有一些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147887/126.wav", + "text": "民宿事實上都沒辦法合法化" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147887/127.wav", + "text": "但是它還是存在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147887/128.wav", + "text": "事實上有它的必須性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147887/129.wav", + "text": "尤其是林班地的解編問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147887/130.wav", + "text": "事實上我們應該做全面性的討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147887/131.wav", + "text": "在那裡它永遠就沒辦法投資" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147887/132.wav", + "text": "沒有辦法升級" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147887/133.wav", + "text": "所以我們是希望怎麼去做解編" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147887/134.wav", + "text": "事實上它已經沒有辦法林農了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147887/135.wav", + "text": "這些土地就是要去做一個全面性的討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147887/136.wav", + "text": "你認為呢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147887/137.wav", + "text": "謝謝委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147887/138.wav", + "text": "這個部分因為林班地的解編" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147887/139.wav", + "text": "先前可能要透過一些相關規定的處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147887/140.wav", + "text": "如果政策是這樣子的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147887/141.wav", + "text": "相關的這些法令就是要去做修正了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147887/142.wav", + "text": "沒有錯吧" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147887/143.wav", + "text": "所以我覺得這都是我們應該要擬出來的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147887/144.wav", + "text": "還有一個很重要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147887/145.wav", + "text": "的就是行政院這個公文裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147887/146.wav", + "text": "包括纜車索道等方式能夠延伸林鐵的範圍" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147887/147.wav", + "text": "我過去也曾經提到阿里山纜車" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147887/148.wav", + "text": "或者我最近特別提到梅山纜車" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147887/149.wav", + "text": "這個都是符合現在行政院的政策方向" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147887/150.wav", + "text": "沒有錯吧部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147887/151.wav", + "text": "是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147887/152.wav", + "text": "沒有錯吧" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147887/153.wav", + "text": "未來四年大概有66億的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147887/154.wav", + "text": "阿里山軸帶百年計畫的經費" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147887/155.wav", + "text": "事實上都是符合現在我們的計畫內容" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147887/156.wav", + "text": "所以我們希望你們能夠積極地" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147887/157.wav", + "text": "這個規劃大概什麼時候可以出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147887/158.wav", + "text": "這個就是剛剛跟委員報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147887/159.wav", + "text": "會透過跨部會跟跨縣市" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147887/160.wav", + "text": "跟未來的經營機關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147887/161.wav", + "text": "確定了之後就會來進行調研跟規劃" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147887/162.wav", + "text": "最後一點我想要在這裡再一次提醒林業署" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147887/163.wav", + "text": "是我們阿里山地區非常重要的觀光資產" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147887/164.wav", + "text": "但是自從它斷了以後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147887/165.wav", + "text": "全線通車就遙遙無期" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147887/166.wav", + "text": "沒有錯吧" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147887/167.wav", + "text": "我記得我2021年提出質詢的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147887/168.wav", + "text": "你們說是2023年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147887/169.wav", + "text": "就是今年會通車嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147887/170.wav", + "text": "嘛我最近看到農業部林鐵處" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147887/171.wav", + "text": "你們的新聞竟然是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147887/172.wav", + "text": "林鐵希望在113年（2024年）全線通車" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147887/173.wav", + "text": "這樣你們到底是幾年才要通車" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147887/174.wav", + "text": "委員我們在今年底會完成鋪軌" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147887/175.wav", + "text": "因為現在隧道內正在進行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147887/176.wav", + "text": "你們的理由很多啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147887/177.wav", + "text": "你們的理由有夠多啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147887/178.wav", + "text": "我不瞭解你們到底要拖到什麼時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147887/179.wav", + "text": "這些確實都有影響" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147887/180.wav", + "text": "疫情也有影響" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147887/181.wav", + "text": "錢都已經給你們了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147887/182.wav", + "text": "不是預算都已經給你們了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147887/183.wav", + "text": "嗎我們四十億的復原經費不是都過了嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147887/184.wav", + "text": "因為山區裡面經常會下雨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147887/185.wav", + "text": "所以有一些地面水過高的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147887/186.wav", + "text": "我們可能還要處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147887/187.wav", + "text": "隧道才能過去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147887/188.wav", + "text": "部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147887/189.wav", + "text": "你不要替他們講話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147887/190.wav", + "text": "你要去做行政的究責" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147887/191.wav", + "text": "你要去追查瞭解為什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147887/192.wav", + "text": "特別成立一個林鐵處" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147887/193.wav", + "text": "竟然整個施工的品質這麼低" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147887/194.wav", + "text": "而且時間是這麼長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147887/195.wav", + "text": "2021你們信誓旦旦說2023" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147887/196.wav", + "text": "現在不知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147887/197.wav", + "text": "2024也不知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147887/198.wav", + "text": "我們希望明年6月以前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147887/199.wav", + "text": "6月以前是你現在講的啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147887/200.wav", + "text": "事實上過去我們在這裡一直在講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147887/201.wav", + "text": "一直在講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147887/202.wav", + "text": "我就不知道阿里山鐵路" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147887/203.wav", + "text": "為什麼沒有辦法全線通車" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147887/204.wav", + "text": "我就搞不清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147887/205.wav", + "text": "每年都在推" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147887/206.wav", + "text": "我是希望林業署跟林鐵處" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147887/207.wav", + "text": "一定要有人為這次的延宕" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147887/208.wav", + "text": "我們真的要去調查一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147887/209.wav", + "text": "這樣就隨便他們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147887/210.wav", + "text": "對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147887/211.wav", + "text": "我是覺得阿里山鐵道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147887/212.wav", + "text": "如果能夠復甦的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147887/213.wav", + "text": "對整個阿里山的觀光是有幫助" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147887/214.wav", + "text": "到現在為止" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147887/215.wav", + "text": "都不積極啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147887/216.wav", + "text": "整個專案我會去瞭解" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147887/217.wav", + "text": "要去調查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147887/218.wav", + "text": "到底誰應該負這個責任" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147887/219.wav", + "text": "好我會去瞭解" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147887/220.wav", + "text": "我已經問好幾次了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147887/221.wav", + "text": "你們的答復就是這樣子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147887/222.wav", + "text": "都跟你們沒關係" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147887/223.wav", + "text": "我們會跟委員做一些直接的報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147887/224.wav", + "text": "沒辦法啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147887/225.wav", + "text": "這不是理由喔" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147887/226.wav", + "text": "好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147887/227.wav", + "text": "瞭解" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147887/228.wav", + "text": "好謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/0.wav", + "text": "好謝謝主席請潘部長好有請潘部長朱司長可能也一起好有請朱司長委員好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/1.wav", + "text": "謝謝部長謝謝司長謝謝所有的大學校長每年一次可以跟大家對話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/2.wav", + "text": "我真的非常珍惜這個寶貴的機會也希望大家務必來聆聽今天思瑤的質詢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/3.wav", + "text": "因為我會為大家帶來非常多的好消息" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/4.wav", + "text": "\n高教進步看得見好還要更好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/5.wav", + "text": "好消息我們5年50億的新宿舍運動" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/6.wav", + "text": "正在日本等著接受日本Good Design大獎的肯定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/7.wav", + "text": "\n本席現在出示的是Good Design大獎的官網" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/8.wav", + "text": "我們真的要覺得非常驕傲" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/9.wav", + "text": "上面秀出來的分別是陽交大的十二舍" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/10.wav", + "text": "的宿舍我們的新宿舍運動得到世界設計大獎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/11.wav", + "text": "看得見成績我們給自己拍拍手" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/12.wav", + "text": "5年50億新宿舍運動在2019年上路" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/13.wav", + "text": "我們讓高教的教育思維翻轉了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/14.wav", + "text": "這幾天有一位法國記者每天貼身採訪我" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/15.wav", + "text": "跟拍我的行程他問我一件事" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/16.wav", + "text": "思瑤你投入政治工作擔任立委第7年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/17.wav", + "text": "你最有成就感的一件事是什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/18.wav", + "text": "我跟他分享就是我爭取了大��的新宿舍運動" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/19.wav", + "text": "過去國家不拿預算來幫助大學蓋宿舍" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/20.wav", + "text": "現在我們做到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/21.wav", + "text": "了謝謝各個大學大家都投入" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/22.wav", + "text": "我們讓學生是主體" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/23.wav", + "text": "讓高教改革來回應學生的實際需求" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/24.wav", + "text": "讓生活就是學習" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/25.wav", + "text": "讓學習不只是在教室裡發展更全方位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/26.wav", + "text": "而多元的全人教育" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/27.wav", + "text": "宿舍不只是宿舍" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/28.wav", + "text": "再一次謝謝大家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/29.wav", + "text": "我也謝謝蘇貞昌院長的鼎力支持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/30.wav", + "text": "校長們看一看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/31.wav", + "text": "蒐尋引擎按下去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/32.wav", + "text": "跳出來的都是壞新聞" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/33.wav", + "text": "現在翻轉了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/34.wav", + "text": "只要Google大學宿舍" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/35.wav", + "text": "壞印象變好新聞" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/36.wav", + "text": "新宿舍運動的成果真的看得見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/37.wav", + "text": "天下雜誌說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/38.wav", + "text": "新宿舍運動是人生群居生活的重要實驗室影響一生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/39.wav", + "text": "天下雜誌又說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/40.wav", + "text": "全臺宿舍再造動起來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/41.wav", + "text": "高教更溫暖更貼心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/42.wav", + "text": "上報說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/43.wav", + "text": "政大的化南新村改建變學生宿舍" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/44.wav", + "text": "超級搶手" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/45.wav", + "text": "聯合報說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/46.wav", + "text": "五星級的宿舍又+1" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/47.wav", + "text": "蛋黃區東吳大學有容宿舍開張了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/48.wav", + "text": "聯合報又說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/49.wav", + "text": "擺脫最爛宿舍汙名" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/50.wav", + "text": "嘉義大學花1億元來改造新宿舍迎新生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/51.wav", + "text": "聯合新聞網說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/52.wav", + "text": "東海大學成功翻轉了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/53.wav", + "text": "新建宿舍即將完工" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/54.wav", + "text": "讓它的招生率也提高了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/55.wav", + "text": "自由時報說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/56.wav", + "text": "工業風的體育館宿舍像旅館" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/57.wav", + "text": "全臺校園美感升級成搶手空間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/58.wav", + "text": "我也要肯定勤益科大" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/59.wav", + "text": "我們陳建仁院長也率隊去考察了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/60.wav", + "text": "自由時報的報導" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/61.wav", + "text": "是超級舒適" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/62.wav", + "text": "勤益科大斥資7.8億宿舍啟用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/63.wav", + "text": "而且大一生都保證能夠入住" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/64.wav", + "text": "這就是我們努力的成果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/65.wav", + "text": "壞消息都變好新聞" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/66.wav", + "text": "我們可以做得更好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/67.wav", + "text": "也謝謝臺上的潘部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/68.wav", + "text": "跟我們辛苦的朱司長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/69.wav", + "text": "不管是用具體的預算來整建改善" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/70.wav", + "text": "或者是提高建築貸款的利息補貼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/71.wav", + "text": "幫助各校去興建宿舍" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/72.wav", + "text": "甚至是對於弱勢學生的租金補貼全面加碼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/73.wav", + "text": "另外一個是校外興建學生社會住宅空床補助" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/74.wav", + "text": "這個部分只有兩個學校提出申請" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/75.wav", + "text": "我們大家可以不放棄來爭取" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/76.wav", + "text": "謝謝教育部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/77.wav", + "text": "97所公私立大學爭相加入參與度高達65%" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/78.wav", + "text": "但是還有35%的學校沒有跟上來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/79.wav", + "text": "我們一個一個來盤點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/80.wav", + "text": "公立大學參與的有32校已經是90%了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/81.wav", + "text": "大家知道我們有一個非常專業的輔導團" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/82.wav", + "text": "他們是入校入舍去輔導" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/83.wav", + "text": "通過輔導團就可以拿到國家的補助" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/84.wav", + "text": "但目前只有通過50%" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/85.wav", + "text": "即便如此" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/86.wav", + "text": "公立的一般大學是全類之冠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/87.wav", + "text": "我這裡要肯定已經通過的16校" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/88.wav", + "text": "請我點名的校長可以起立接受我們的肯定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/89.wav", + "text": "好嗎陽明交大提出了四案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/90.wav", + "text": "林奇宏校長請大家鼓勵一下好嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/91.wav", + "text": "成功大學提出了三個宿舍方案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/92.wav", + "text": "請沈孟儒校長接受大家的肯定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/93.wav", + "text": "嘉義大學提出了兩案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/94.wav", + "text": "林校長請起立接受大家的肯定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/95.wav", + "text": "這些都是參與度非常高" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/96.wav", + "text": "當然還有其他學校" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/97.wav", + "text": "也都提案了現在在輔導團的輔導中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/98.wav", + "text": "希望能夠得到好成果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/99.wav", + "text": "現在我要點名的就不用起立了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/100.wav", + "text": "大家聽在心裡就好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/101.wav", + "text": "停止輔導或撤案的學校有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/102.wav", + "text": "彰化師範大學臺北教育大學臺中教育大學體育大學" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/103.wav", + "text": "臺灣體育運動大學臺北大學臺東大學" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/104.wav", + "text": "而從未參與的學校���三校" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/105.wav", + "text": "高雄師範大學臺灣海洋大學" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/106.wav", + "text": "還有臺北市主管的市立大學" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/107.wav", + "text": "任何學校有困難我知道是非戰之罪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/108.wav", + "text": "但是吳思瑤的辦公室這五六年來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/109.wav", + "text": "各大學的校長總務長不斷的穿梭" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/110.wav", + "text": "我跟教育部跟高教司司長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/111.wav", + "text": "永遠為每個學校找出解決的方法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/112.wav", + "text": "大家不要放棄" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/113.wav", + "text": "\n我們來看技專校院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/114.wav", + "text": "也請我點名的校長起立" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/115.wav", + "text": "接受大家的鼓勵" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/116.wav", + "text": "臺中科大陳同孝校長謝謝你們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/117.wav", + "text": "很好很好繼續做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/118.wav", + "text": "臺灣戲曲學院的李揚校長在嗎謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/119.wav", + "text": "臺灣戲曲學院就是碰到困難" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/120.wav", + "text": "在我辦公室來協調的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/121.wav", + "text": "公立技職校院輔導中的學校" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/122.wav", + "text": "有臺北科大雲林科大高雄科大" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/123.wav", + "text": "高雄餐旅大學臺北護理健康大學" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/124.wav", + "text": "輔導中都期待有好成果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/125.wav", + "text": "現在要點名的是停止輔導" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/126.wav", + "text": "被撤案的有三個學校" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/127.wav", + "text": "臺灣科大澎湖科大臺東專科學校" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/128.wav", + "text": "從頭到尾沒有辦法參與的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/129.wav", + "text": "沒有加入的有屏東科大" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/130.wav", + "text": "跟臺南護理專科學校" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/131.wav", + "text": "而臺北商業大學沒有加入" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/132.wav", + "text": "但是臺北商業大學我們有找出其他的方案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/133.wav", + "text": "可能要跟台糖來合作" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/134.wav", + "text": "所以我們會為每一個學校找方法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/135.wav", + "text": "大家真的不要放棄" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/136.wav", + "text": "新宿舍運動好還要更好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/137.wav", + "text": "多還要更多Never stop" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/138.wav", + "text": "陽明交大的林奇宏校長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/139.wav", + "text": "我們已經通過四案了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/140.wav", + "text": "可是還要再送新案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/141.wav", + "text": "謝謝陽交大" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/142.wav", + "text": "成功大學的沈校長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/143.wav", + "text": "請接受我們的鼓勵" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/144.wav", + "text": "成大已經通過三個案子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/145.wav", + "text": "還要再送案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/146.wav", + "text": "暨南國際大學的武校長請起立好嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/147.wav", + "text": "謝謝您" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/148.wav", + "text": "我們已經通過兩個案子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/149.wav", + "text": "可是我們還在送新案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/150.wav", + "text": "中山大學的鄭校長您好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/151.wav", + "text": "謝謝你們我們通過一案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/152.wav", + "text": "可是還在送新案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/153.wav", + "text": "臺南藝術大學詹景裕校長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/154.wav", + "text": "我們也通過了一案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/155.wav", + "text": "可是也在送新案了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/156.wav", + "text": "謝謝你" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/157.wav", + "text": "我們有通過一案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/158.wav", + "text": "臺大也持續會再送新案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/159.wav", + "text": "臺灣藝術大學的鐘校長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/160.wav", + "text": "跟東華大學的趙校長兩位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/161.wav", + "text": "也非常謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/162.wav", + "text": "學校還有持續的案子要送出" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/163.wav", + "text": "\n輔導團認為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/164.wav", + "text": "還有機會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/165.wav", + "text": "還有潛力可以再送案的學校有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/166.wav", + "text": "臺灣師範大學" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/167.wav", + "text": "中央大學" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/168.wav", + "text": "清華大學" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/169.wav", + "text": "屏東大學" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/170.wav", + "text": "政治大學" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/171.wav", + "text": "中興大學" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/172.wav", + "text": "聯合大學" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/173.wav", + "text": "高雄大學" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/174.wav", + "text": "宜蘭大學" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/175.wav", + "text": "金門大學" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/176.wav", + "text": "以及中正大學" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/177.wav", + "text": "也就是專家已經入校入舍去看過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/178.wav", + "text": "認為我剛剛點名的這11校" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/179.wav", + "text": "都還有機會可以再送案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/180.wav", + "text": "都還有可能獲得國家珍貴預算的補助" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/181.wav", + "text": "所以never stop" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/182.wav", + "text": "思瑤在這裡多花一點時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/183.wav", + "text": "謝謝范雲召委給我多一點時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/184.wav", + "text": "我無論如何要藉這個機會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/185.wav", + "text": "鼓勵大家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/186.wav", + "text": "我們要造福學生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/187.wav", + "text": "大家注意聽喔" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/188.wav", + "text": "一校多宿舍是常態沒有錯嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/189.wav", + "text": "所以我們必須從" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/190.wav", + "text": "以學校的校數來思考" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/191.wav", + "text": "要進入以宿舍的棟數" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/192.wav", + "text": "有沒有加入來思考" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/193.wav", + "text": "這裡我要提醒部長跟司長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/194.wav", + "text": "以臺灣大學為例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/195.wav", + "text": "陳文章校長在這裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/196.wav", + "text": "臺大有20棟學生宿舍" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/197.wav", + "text": "5棟BOT" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/198.wav", + "text": "已經通過的是一個案子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/199.wav", + "text": "當然臺大還在找其他的機會在送案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/200.wav", + "text": "我以臺大的例子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/201.wav", + "text": "我是臺大校友" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/202.wav", + "text": "拿自己的學校來講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/203.wav", + "text": "我們還有20棟左右" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/204.wav", + "text": "新宿舍運動都可以來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/205.wav", + "text": "有的人可以住到新宿舍運動的好宿舍" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/206.wav", + "text": "有的人繼續住" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/207.wav", + "text": "過去壞印象的宿舍" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/208.wav", + "text": "我想教育的平權" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/209.wav", + "text": "居住的平權" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/210.wav", + "text": "我們從大學的宿舍來落實" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/211.wav", + "text": "所以我也請部長跟司長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/212.wav", + "text": "要從以校數來思考" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/213.wav", + "text": "轉化為以各校的宿舍棟數來思考" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/214.wav", + "text": "因為目前教育部給我的資料" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/215.wav", + "text": "也都是學校參與的數" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/216.wav", + "text": "我們也可能因此而滿足" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/217.wav", + "text": "譬如90%的公立大學都加入" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/218.wav", + "text": "但是如果再細部去探究" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/219.wav", + "text": "各校還有多數的宿舍並沒有被加入" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/220.wav", + "text": "這裡我也跟大家分享" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/221.wav", + "text": "私立不如國立" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/222.wav", + "text": "技專校院不如一般大學" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/223.wav", + "text": "這是現在新宿舍運動" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/224.wav", + "text": "推動上路到現在看到的一個事實" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/225.wav", + "text": "所以教育部也已經端出新的方案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/226.wav", + "text": "技職校院的學校校長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/227.wav", + "text": "可以更大步的來邁進" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/228.wav", + "text": "Good news又一個好消息" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/229.wav", + "text": "思瑤上上週質詢了陳建仁院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/230.wav", + "text": "新宿舍運動第1期5年50億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/231.wav", + "text": "預算即將用完" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/232.wav", + "text": "第2期教育部初估要5年33億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/233.wav", + "text": "陳建仁院長也 say yes" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/234.wav", + "text": "無上限的來投入" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/235.wav", + "text": "我在這裡提醒部長跟司長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/236.wav", + "text": "我們當初的計算恐怕是以校數來計算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/237.wav", + "text": "如果以宿舍的棟數來計算33" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/238.wav", + "text": "所以這個部分我也會持續來盯您" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/239.wav", + "text": "各位校長分享給你們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/240.wav", + "text": "精進的方案在這裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/241.wav", + "text": "因為經過第一個梯次5年的經驗累積" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/242.wav", + "text": "我們看到有更好的作法要提升" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/243.wav", + "text": "也就是整建的經費再加碼了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/244.wav", + "text": "最近缺料缺人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/245.wav", + "text": "經費整個提升造價提升" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/246.wav", + "text": "所以教育部研議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/247.wav", + "text": "過去每床補助4.2萬會提升到5.2萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/248.wav", + "text": "可是學生的住宿寢室也應當改一改" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/249.wav", + "text": "教育部也在思考怎麼樣來擴大跟納入" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/250.wav", + "text": "第三個多元空間的需求" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/251.wav", + "text": "我們非常關心的心理諮商空間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/252.wav", + "text": "能不能夠在宿舍裡頭就讓學生可以使用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/253.wav", + "text": "性別友善的宿舍以及育兒友善的需求" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/254.wav", + "text": "很多學生甚至碩博士已經有家庭的需求" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/255.wav", + "text": "這都在新宿舍運動的2.0" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/256.wav", + "text": "會讓這些多元的宿舍功能被滿足被實踐" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/257.wav", + "text": "各位大學校長請加入好嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/258.wav", + "text": "政大" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/259.wav", + "text": "我們政大的校長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/260.wav", + "text": "校長好您起立就好了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/261.wav", + "text": "好案子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/262.wav", + "text": "我看到政大一個最新的案例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/263.wav", + "text": "也就是政大" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/264.wav", + "text": "化南新村本來是教職員宿舍" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/265.wav", + "text": "它被指定為文化資產之後必須要修復" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/266.wav", + "text": "在修復的過程" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/267.wav", + "text": "中他們認為這個空間可以打開讓學生使用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/268.wav", + "text": "林洲民建築師設計的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/269.wav", + "text": "喔這段時間可以成為中繼宿舍" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/270.wav", + "text": "讓學生在蓋新宿舍的過程沒有空窗" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/271.wav", + "text": "所以政大化南新村以住代護" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/272.wav", + "text": "整修28棟的文化資產群" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/273.wav", + "text": "讓學生可以入住每棟6至8名" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/274.wav", + "text": "媒體更關切的是這是臺灣第一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/275.wav", + "text": "男女生可以一起住的宿舍" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/276.wav", + "text": "它有前瞻進步的思維" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/277.wav", + "text": "讓我們的大學宿舍可以活化文化資產" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/278.wav", + "text": "也可以進行地方創生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/279.wav", + "text": "新宿舍運動也有Added-Value" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/280.wav", + "text": "老師教職員宿舍" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/281.wav", + "text": "在修的過程或是這些空間本身" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/282.wav", + "text": "就可以讓學生入住以住代護" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/283.wav", + "text": "這是文化資產界最新的活化文資" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/284.wav", + "text": "參與及體驗文化資產" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/285.wav", + "text": "它開啟了居住的新想像" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/286.wav", + "text": "它開啟了文化保存的新生力軍" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/287.wav", + "text": "它也是地方創生的實踐" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/288.wav", + "text": "思瑤今天花這麼多時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/289.wav", + "text": "把新宿舍運動再一次跟大家分享" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/290.wav", + "text": "我們要入校入舍入心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/291.wav", + "text": "這才是一個成功的政策" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/292.wav", + "text": "Never Stop我們的使命" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/293.wav", + "text": "非常謝謝主席給我機會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/294.wav", + "text": "我太高興可以看到這麼多校長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/295.wav", + "text": "再把好消息告訴大家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/296.wav", + "text": "吳思瑤要求" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/297.wav", + "text": "300億的租金補貼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/298.wav", + "text": "因為民法的修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/299.wav", + "text": "讓成人從20歲下降到18歲" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/300.wav", + "text": "換言之18歲的大學生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/301.wav", + "text": "也可以請領國家的300億租金補貼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/302.wav", + "text": "兩件事情請大學校長來幫忙" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/303.wav", + "text": "第一件是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/304.wav", + "text": "校外賃居的學生請幫忙" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/305.wav", + "text": "不讓學生去請領的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/306.wav", + "text": "惡房東現在高教司已經建立一個輔導機制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/307.wav", + "text": "的學生也可以請領租屋補貼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/308.wav", + "text": "我的助理就是受惠者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/309.wav", + "text": "第二個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/310.wav", + "text": "校內住宿住大學宿舍的學生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/311.wav", + "text": "未來也可以請領租金補貼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/312.wav", + "text": "但是跟校外賃居" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/313.wav", + "text": "補貼金額不一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/314.wav", + "text": "教育部正在跟內政部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/315.wav", + "text": "大家一起來幫助學生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/316.wav", + "text": "讓學生可以請領" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/317.wav", + "text": "\nI'm so sorry" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/318.wav", + "text": "最後一頁在這裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/319.wav", + "text": "也謝謝大家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/320.wav", + "text": "去年我站在這裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/321.wav", + "text": "質詢總預算的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/322.wav", + "text": "我也分享給各個大學校長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/323.wav", + "text": "這麼多的學生輕生了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/324.wav", + "text": "他沒辦法度過情緒的難關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/325.wav", + "text": "60%以上的學生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/326.wav", + "text": "選擇輕生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/327.wav", + "text": "時並沒有受到大學" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/328.wav", + "text": "任何的心理輔導諮商救助" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/329.wav", + "text": "換言之我們的心理諮商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/330.wav", + "text": "六成因此我們開始建立" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/331.wav", + "text": "心理健康的軟硬體" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/332.wav", + "text": "包括教育部要修" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/333.wav", + "text": "學生輔導法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/334.wav", + "text": "把1比1,200的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/335.wav", + "text": "心輔師資比例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/336.wav", + "text": "軟硬體我們都在做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/337.wav", + "text": "思瑤一定跟著大家一起拚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/338.wav", + "text": "但是這件事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/339.wav", + "text": "分享給大家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/340.wav", + "text": "心理健康假" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/341.wav", + "text": "在我去年10月20日質詢的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/342.wav", + "text": "只有2個學校有心理假" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/343.wav", + "text": "當初在這裡接受我的表揚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/344.wav", + "text": "是中山大學鄭校長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/345.wav", + "text": "以及實踐大學的校長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/346.wav", + "text": "當初只有2校" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/347.wav", + "text": "經過這一年的努力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/348.wav", + "text": "各校學生非常重視這件事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/349.wav", + "text": "我光是接受各大學學生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/350.wav", + "text": "來專訪關於心理健康" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/351.wav", + "text": "心理假的推動" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/352.wav", + "text": "就至少有十多個學生團體" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/353.wav", + "text": "這代表學生在乎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/354.wav", + "text": "所以臺灣師範大學" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/355.wav", + "text": "政治大學" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/356.wav", + "text": "暨南大學" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/357.wav", + "text": "成功大學" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/358.wav", + "text": "屏東科大" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/359.wav", + "text": "嘉義大學" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/360.wav", + "text": "臺北大學" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/361.wav", + "text": "臺灣大學" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/362.wav", + "text": "沒有跟上來的學校" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/363.wav", + "text": "心理健康假" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/364.wav", + "text": "不只是讓學生放假而已" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/365.wav", + "text": "可以幫助我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/366.wav", + "text": "看到哪些學生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/367.wav", + "text": "家庭有狀況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/368.wav", + "text": "或是情感上失戀了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/369.wav", + "text": "���級處遇制度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/370.wav", + "text": "能follow上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/371.wav", + "text": "不再漏接每一個孩子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/372.wav", + "text": "這是心理健康假" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/373.wav", + "text": "非常重要的一個意義" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/374.wav", + "text": "這是這個任期最後一次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/375.wav", + "text": "謝謝潘部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/376.wav", + "text": "謝謝高教司司長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/377.wav", + "text": "因為有你們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/378.wav", + "text": "讓我們高教的進步" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/379.wav", + "text": "謝謝委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/380.wav", + "text": "確實是委員的倡議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/381.wav", + "text": "蘇貞昌院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/382.wav", + "text": "的全力支持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/383.wav", + "text": "所以啟動了這個宿舍" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/384.wav", + "text": "運動這個過程" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/385.wav", + "text": "委員剛才如數家珍" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/386.wav", + "text": "關心及協助" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/387.wav", + "text": "也謝謝委員剛才" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/388.wav", + "text": "這些好的改變" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/389.wav", + "text": "上次去參觀" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/390.wav", + "text": "勤益科大的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/391.wav", + "text": "我也再度反映" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/392.wav", + "text": "學校校長們的需求" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/393.wav", + "text": "跟心聲" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/394.wav", + "text": "不只是第一期5年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/395.wav", + "text": "後續也應該第" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/396.wav", + "text": "恐怕還不夠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/397.wav", + "text": "陳院長也承諾" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/398.wav", + "text": "新宿舍運動2.0" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/399.wav", + "text": "至於未來改造的方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/400.wav", + "text": "我們也會蒐集" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/401.wav", + "text": "學校所反映的意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/402.wav", + "text": "不管是建造成本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/403.wav", + "text": "或是空間的使用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/404.wav", + "text": "可以再怎麼樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/405.wav", + "text": "好我們我再跟委員補充報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/406.wav", + "text": "還在修法的過程" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/407.wav", + "text": "對於大學而言" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/408.wav", + "text": "校長們也關注" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/409.wav", + "text": "已經把它做成1比900" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/410.wav", + "text": "也會在113年的預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/411.wav", + "text": "就來實現" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/412.wav", + "text": "吳思瑤的版本是1比800" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/413.wav", + "text": "你們原本是1比1," + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/414.wav", + "text": "0現在可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/415.wav", + "text": "折衷變成1比900" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/416.wav", + "text": "這都是很大的躍進" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/417.wav", + "text": "現在還有15所大學" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/418.wav", + "text": "大家一起加油" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/419.wav", + "text": "臺北時間2點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/420.wav", + "text": "我們可以一起上網看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/421.wav", + "text": "臺灣的新宿舍運動" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/422.wav", + "text": "每一位校長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/423.wav", + "text": "都是獲獎者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/424.wav", + "text": "再一次向大家致意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/425.wav", + "text": "感謝大家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/426.wav", + "text": "非常謝謝范雲召委" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/427.wav", + "text": "給我這麼多的時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/428.wav", + "text": "感謝您" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/429.wav", + "text": "謝謝大家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/430.wav", + "text": "司長最棒" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/431.wav", + "text": "謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147886/432.wav", + "text": "謝謝吳思瑤委員的質詢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147885/0.wav", + "text": "謝謝召委請王部長跟公路總局陳局長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147885/1.wav", + "text": "請部長跟局長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147885/2.wav", + "text": "李委員好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147885/3.wav", + "text": "部長10月19日客運公會全聯會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147885/4.wav", + "text": "這個漲價恐怕是高達三成左右" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147885/5.wav", + "text": "部長的態度是如何請簡單說明一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147885/6.wav", + "text": "按照行政程序來審查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147885/7.wav", + "text": "有一定的程序跟標準" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147885/8.wav", + "text": "但我要提醒部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147885/9.wav", + "text": "客運的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147885/10.wav", + "text": "是運量的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147885/11.wav", + "text": "而不是票價的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147885/12.wav", + "text": "以前高鐵說要漲價" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147885/13.wav", + "text": "時我就提醒高鐵跟交通部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147885/14.wav", + "text": "高鐵的問題是在運量" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147885/15.wav", + "text": "而不是在票價" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147885/16.wav", + "text": "所以推出很多相關優惠票價" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147885/17.wav", + "text": "像是自由座早鳥座學生票等等的優惠措施" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147885/18.wav", + "text": "人數是減少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147885/19.wav", + "text": "但人數減少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147885/20.wav", + "text": "你應該去提升它的接駁效率" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147885/21.wav", + "text": "交通運輸的效率" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147885/22.wav", + "text": "而且我要提醒部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147885/23.wav", + "text": "這種票價的調整" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147885/24.wav", + "text": "政府也要補貼對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147885/25.wav", + "text": "陳局長請說明一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147885/26.wav", + "text": "跟委員報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147885/27.wav", + "text": "他們現在所提的是運價的調整" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147885/28.wav", + "text": "運價是反映它的營運成本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147885/29.wav", + "text": "營運成本不一定是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147885/30.wav", + "text": "跟上次一般公路客運" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147885/31.wav", + "text": "對啊以前這種補貼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147885/32.wav", + "text": "有分一種是客運的營運虧損補貼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147885/33.wav", + "text": "另外一種" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147885/34.wav", + "text": "是屬於這種票價差價的補貼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147885/35.wav", + "text": "如果調整到三成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147885/36.wav", + "text": "政府要補貼嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147885/37.wav", + "text": "跟委員報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147885/38.wav", + "text": "跟一般公路客運" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147885/39.wav", + "text": "其實他們在運價成本已經有調整" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147885/40.wav", + "text": "這一次全聯會所送的是國道客運" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147885/41.wav", + "text": "營運成本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147885/42.wav", + "text": "我還是要提醒局長跟部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147885/43.wav", + "text": "國道客運的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147885/44.wav", + "text": "是在運量而不是在票價" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147885/45.wav", + "text": "如何提升它的安全" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147885/46.wav", + "text": "它的服務它的效率" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147885/47.wav", + "text": "這才是重點啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147885/48.wav", + "text": "也要督促業者去提升相關的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147885/49.wav", + "text": "我要提醒部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147885/50.wav", + "text": "這要審慎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147885/51.wav", + "text": "這關係到國道客運的安全" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147885/52.wav", + "text": "服務以及相關的票價" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147885/53.wav", + "text": "這都關係到整體的交通運輸" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147885/54.wav", + "text": "請說明一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147885/55.wav", + "text": "18項成本來調運價" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147885/56.wav", + "text": "會用補貼的方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147885/57.wav", + "text": "讓它不要調" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147885/58.wav", + "text": "剛才有談到如果它調了之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147885/59.wav", + "text": "運量已經不足又再調高" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147885/60.wav", + "text": "但它現在送進來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147885/61.wav", + "text": "我們會先就它整個運價調整的方案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147885/62.wav", + "text": "先按照我們的行政" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147885/63.wav", + "text": "遊覽車所發生的重大" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147885/64.wav", + "text": "交通事故" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147885/65.wav", + "text": "造成駕駛及乘客" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147885/66.wav", + "text": "15人緊急避難" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147885/67.wav", + "text": "雖然沒有傷亡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147885/68.wav", + "text": "但也造成很大的驚嚇" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147885/69.wav", + "text": "10月21日" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147885/70.wav", + "text": "遊覽車超速跟小客車的碰撞" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147885/71.wav", + "text": "這也造成四死十" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147885/72.wav", + "text": "還有在遊覽車的行李室" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147885/73.wav", + "text": "旅客不幸死亡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147885/74.wav", + "text": "這些對於" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147885/75.wav", + "text": "大眾運輸不管是客運" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147885/76.wav", + "text": "國道客運" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147885/77.wav", + "text": "遊覽車" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147885/78.wav", + "text": "都讓民眾產生很大的疑慮" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147885/79.wav", + "text": "尤其像是國道客運" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147885/80.wav", + "text": "火燒車" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147885/81.wav", + "text": "國道客運變成火車" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147885/82.wav", + "text": "這讓民眾沒有辦法接受" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147885/83.wav", + "text": "對於大眾運輸" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147885/84.wav", + "text": "都是很大的衝擊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147885/85.wav", + "text": "102輛對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147885/86.wav", + "text": "地再去重新檢查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147885/87.wav", + "text": "98輛是正常" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147885/88.wav", + "text": "的4輛有異常" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147885/89.wav", + "text": "有關後續的處置情形請說明一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147885/90.wav", + "text": "發生事故的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147885/91.wav", + "text": "第一個我們當然擔心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147885/92.wav", + "text": "會不會有通案的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147885/93.wav", + "text": "像委員所說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147885/94.wav", + "text": "來做一個確認跟檢查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147885/95.wav", + "text": "它的102輛同型車輛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147885/96.wav", + "text": "所以它是停駛要做檢修" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147885/97.wav", + "text": "查驗他的安全紀錄" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147885/98.wav", + "text": "都要確實地再去落實督促" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147885/99.wav", + "text": "\n另外遊覽車超速" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147885/100.wav", + "text": "跟小客車碰撞這件事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147885/101.wav", + "text": "雖然有相關的裁罰" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147885/102.wav", + "text": "裁罰也才9萬而已" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147885/103.wav", + "text": "耶而且有吊扣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147885/104.wav", + "text": "但是你要知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147885/105.wav", + "text": "造成4個人死亡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147885/106.wav", + "text": "17個人受傷" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147885/107.wav", + "text": "相關的處置" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147885/108.wav", + "text": "除了裁罰之外" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147885/109.wav", + "text": "你有察覺到什麼問題嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147885/110.wav", + "text": "跟業者報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147885/111.wav", + "text": "跟委員報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147885/112.wav", + "text": "在高速公路上面不當的超車" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147885/113.wav", + "text": "其實他要被吊銷駕照" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147885/114.wav", + "text": "其實我們對於他違反公路法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147885/115.wav", + "text": "我們用最高額來處罰" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147885/116.wav", + "text": "當然對於他安全的管理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147885/117.wav", + "text": "其實公路法還有一個會停止他的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147885/118.wav", + "text": "公司車輛營業" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147885/119.wav", + "text": "部長跟局長我要提醒你" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147885/120.wav", + "text": "們我們要去落實車輛的維修" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147885/121.wav", + "text": "還有保養" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147885/122.wav", + "text": "這是第一個重要的工作" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147885/123.wav", + "text": "第二個要加強行前的檢查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147885/124.wav", + "text": "第三" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147885/125.wav", + "text": "我們針對駕駛的訓練" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147885/126.wav", + "text": "以前他第一次要上路之前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147885/127.wav", + "text": "他必須在3年內有相關的受訓經驗" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147885/128.wav", + "text": "每半年也要有一次安全的講習" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147885/129.wav", + "text": "但是這個都要加強" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147885/130.wav", + "text": "逃生引導的這些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147885/131.wav", + "text": "訓練" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147885/132.wav", + "text": "包括這些駕駛人還有相關的乘客" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147885/133.wav", + "text": "要有基本的安全觀念" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147885/134.wav", + "text": "部長我現在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147885/135.wav", + "text": "再嚴肅地問你一次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147885/136.wav", + "text": "國道客運有這麼多的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147885/137.wav", + "text": "然後運量也減少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147885/138.wav", + "text": "它的服務品質是需要提升的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147885/139.wav", + "text": "現在票價" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147885/140.wav", + "text": "號稱要調整三成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147885/141.wav", + "text": "到底你的態度是如何" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147885/142.wav", + "text": "你要跟社會大眾來說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147885/143.wav", + "text": "我想還是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147885/144.wav", + "text": "應該先養量" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147885/145.wav", + "text": "啦所以我是傾向" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147885/146.wav", + "text": "於由政府來吸收" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147885/147.wav", + "text": "目前初步是這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147885/148.wav", + "text": "但是不是三成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147885/149.wav", + "text": "審議委員會的審議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147885/150.wav", + "text": "政府吸收" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147885/151.wav", + "text": "但是你也要去督促這些業者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147885/152.wav", + "text": "相關的安全相關的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147885/153.wav", + "text": "服務品質相關的運輸" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147885/154.wav", + "text": "績效要提升出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147885/155.wav", + "text": "運量減少然後都要政府來補貼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147885/156.wav", + "text": "先審查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147885/157.wav", + "text": "我們是想說如果再" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147885/158.wav", + "text": "提高這個票價" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147885/159.wav", + "text": "就是惡性循環越來越" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147885/160.wav", + "text": "那個所以這部分我們會討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147885/161.wav", + "text": "部長要站在消費者的態度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147885/162.wav", + "text": "保障" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147885/163.wav", + "text": "消費者旅行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147885/164.wav", + "text": "大眾運輸的安全這是最重要的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147885/165.wav", + "text": "對於票價的調整" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147885/166.wav", + "text": "要以最嚴謹的態度來處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147885/167.wav", + "text": "我再請���一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147885/168.wav", + "text": "有關於遊覽車" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147885/169.wav", + "text": "相關的這一種大家都知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147885/170.wav", + "text": "滅火器消防設備" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147885/171.wav", + "text": "是我們安全檢查表" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147885/172.wav", + "text": "必要的檢查項目之一對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147885/173.wav", + "text": "但是連續3年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147885/174.wav", + "text": "裁罰樣態裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147885/175.wav", + "text": "最高的也是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147885/176.wav", + "text": "滅火器的逾期跟" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147885/177.wav", + "text": "失效對不對說明一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147885/178.wav", + "text": "一定會檢查那我們在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147885/179.wav", + "text": "路邊的聯合稽查部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147885/180.wav", + "text": "其實也會去看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147885/181.wav", + "text": "局長2021年到現在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147885/182.wav", + "text": "滅火器逾期或者是失效的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147885/183.wav", + "text": "裁罰件數高達" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147885/184.wav", + "text": "459件" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147885/185.wav", + "text": "今（2023）年到現在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147885/186.wav", + "text": "逾期或者失效就有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147885/187.wav", + "text": "147件" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147885/188.wav", + "text": "我們的安全檢查表" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147885/189.wav", + "text": "有列這個項目" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147885/190.wav", + "text": "然後這也是基本的一個滅火" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147885/191.wav", + "text": "小火的時候趕快還可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147885/192.wav", + "text": "做處理但是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147885/193.wav", + "text": "逾期或失效的比例這麼高" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147885/194.wav", + "text": "這個要加強督導" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147885/195.wav", + "text": "來說明一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147885/196.wav", + "text": "包括檢驗跟路邊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147885/197.wav", + "text": "攔檢稽查的時候我們會來加強" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147885/198.wav", + "text": "跟駕駛本身在出車前的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147885/199.wav", + "text": "自我檢查我想這個部分我們要再要求" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147885/200.wav", + "text": "部長我最後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147885/201.wav", + "text": "再嚴肅地提醒你" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147885/202.wav", + "text": "國道客運跟遊覽車" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147885/203.wav", + "text": "都是重要的公路運輸" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147885/204.wav", + "text": "交通工具也關係到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147885/205.wav", + "text": "旅遊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147885/206.wav", + "text": "也是人民交通工具" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147885/207.wav", + "text": "的重要載具之一" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147885/208.wav", + "text": "但是最近一再地發生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147885/209.wav", + "text": "這些火燒車" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147885/210.wav", + "text": "或是相關的交通意外事故" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147885/211.wav", + "text": "讓民眾的疑慮" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147885/212.wav", + "text": "加深交通部對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147885/213.wav", + "text": "於民眾的安全負有��重要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147885/214.wav", + "text": "的責任要督促相關的業者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147885/215.wav", + "text": "好沒問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147885/216.wav", + "text": "好謝謝李昆澤委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147885/217.wav", + "text": "接著我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147884/0.wav", + "text": "部長請" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147884/1.wav", + "text": "部長好部長我想" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147884/2.wav", + "text": "本席今天還是要跟你再來討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147884/3.wav", + "text": "EMU 3000座椅的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147884/4.wav", + "text": "因為政府花了非常多的錢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147884/5.wav", + "text": "200多億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147884/6.wav", + "text": "當然優點我們要去肯定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147884/7.wav", + "text": "比如座位數比較多設計比較明亮" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147884/8.wav", + "text": "因為它也不是傾斜式列車" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147884/9.wav", + "text": "所以相對比較平穩" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147884/10.wav", + "text": "這個都要去肯定它" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147884/11.wav", + "text": "大家也看到臺鐵局在這件事情上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147884/12.wav", + "text": "從一開始成立了設計團隊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147884/13.wav", + "text": "這個我們都要去肯定它" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147884/14.wav", + "text": "但是政府花那麼多錢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147884/15.wav", + "text": "本席在這裡請教一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147884/16.wav", + "text": "部長你曾經" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147884/17.wav", + "text": "搭乘新自強號EMU 300" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147884/18.wav", + "text": "大概快4個半" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147884/19.wav", + "text": "你有搭過吧" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147884/20.wav", + "text": "臺東到臺北" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147884/21.wav", + "text": "第一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147884/22.wav", + "text": "你有這樣長途搭乘的經驗" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147884/23.wav", + "text": "但是你搭乘的經驗" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147884/24.wav", + "text": "可能和一般人不會一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147884/25.wav", + "text": "因為你不可能一個人坐" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147884/26.wav", + "text": "我猜你一定是公務行程" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147884/27.wav", + "text": "會洽談公務等等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147884/28.wav", + "text": "純粹的休息來搭乘這一輛列車" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147884/29.wav", + "text": "本席在談的就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147884/30.wav", + "text": "我要強調一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147884/31.wav", + "text": "坐的習慣是每個人都不一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147884/32.wav", + "text": "這個我可以同意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147884/33.wav", + "text": "但是現在臺鐵局" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147884/34.wav", + "text": "到底有沒有去針對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147884/35.wav", + "text": "反映這個座椅的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147884/36.wav", + "text": "應該可以讓它更好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147884/37.wav", + "text": "有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147884/38.wav", + "text": "我們政府投資那麼多錢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147884/39.wav", + "text": "以前沒有先做消費習慣調查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147884/40.wav", + "text": "好啦亡羊補牢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147884/41.wav", + "text": "在這件事情上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147884/42.wav", + "text": "部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147884/43.wav", + "text": "本席在這裡講座椅" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147884/44.wav", + "text": "不知道講了第5次還第6次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147884/45.wav", + "text": "他們有調整不知道幾度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147884/46.wav", + "text": "也沒有人知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147884/47.wav", + "text": "哪一班的列車" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147884/48.wav", + "text": "調整大家也無從比較起" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147884/49.wav", + "text": "我跟委員報" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147884/50.wav", + "text": "告大概兩個課題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147884/51.wav", + "text": "EMU 3000的座椅" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147884/52.wav", + "text": "水杯架他們現在要裝了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147884/53.wav", + "text": "當時在美學設計的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147884/54.wav", + "text": "有整體的想到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147884/55.wav", + "text": "這個部分我也請它再做檢討" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147884/56.wav", + "text": "它也在檢討中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147884/57.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147884/58.wav", + "text": "部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147884/59.wav", + "text": "我現在要講的其實就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147884/60.wav", + "text": "我一直在強調" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147884/61.wav", + "text": "臺鐵要用科學的方法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147884/62.wav", + "text": "或者用企業的方法去面對這件事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147884/63.wav", + "text": "你幫它想" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147884/64.wav", + "text": "公司有消費者反映這件事情的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147884/65.wav", + "text": "如何的去重視它" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147884/66.wav", + "text": "然後科學的調查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147884/67.wav", + "text": "這到底是極少部分的意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147884/68.wav", + "text": "或者是很重要的意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147884/69.wav", + "text": "如何去區分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147884/70.wav", + "text": "坦白講我在這裡講這麼久" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147884/71.wav", + "text": "了部長你如果沒有向臺鐵局瞭解" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147884/72.wav", + "text": "臺鐵局到現在都還沒有具體這樣做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147884/73.wav", + "text": "上次委員提過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147884/74.wav", + "text": "我已經交代他們局長在做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147884/75.wav", + "text": "剛剛談的這兩件事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147884/76.wav", + "text": "我現在當然也不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147884/77.wav", + "text": "以我個人的乘坐習慣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147884/78.wav", + "text": "來衡量這件事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147884/79.wav", + "text": "部長我一直在想臺鐵要科學的去面對這件事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147884/80.wav", + "text": "不然很浪費" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147884/81.wav", + "text": "花那麼多錢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147884/82.wav", + "text": "我們要討論就是要讓它更好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147884/83.wav", + "text": "讓它更好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147884/84.wav", + "text": "你要讓大家百分之百" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147884/85.wav", + "text": "滿意大概有點困難" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147884/86.wav", + "text": "不過至少要比現在更好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147884/87.wav", + "text": "好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147884/88.wav", + "text": "部長你再要求臺鐵局" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147884/89.wav", + "text": "你們的期程還有你們怎麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147884/90.wav", + "text": "麼面對這件事情的方法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147884/91.wav", + "text": "好我請他們局長做一點調查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147884/92.wav", + "text": "就大部分的民眾" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147884/93.wav", + "text": "對這個座椅的看法怎麼樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147884/94.wav", + "text": "如果大部分都是這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147884/95.wav", + "text": "我覺得他們可能要做更大的調整" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147884/96.wav", + "text": "一定要做調整" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147884/97.wav", + "text": "啦部長我跟你" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147884/98.wav", + "text": "講因為習慣坐直的人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147884/99.wav", + "text": "如果傾斜度彎一點的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147884/100.wav", + "text": "他其實還可以坐正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147884/101.wav", + "text": "習慣傾斜一點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147884/102.wav", + "text": "的人沒有辦法傾斜的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147884/103.wav", + "text": "而且長途搭乘" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147884/104.wav", + "text": "臺東到臺北" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147884/105.wav", + "text": "單趟總共有10班的EMU 3000" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147884/106.wav", + "text": "平均時間大概要4個小時又20分鐘" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147884/107.wav", + "text": "搭乘的時間平均來講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147884/108.wav", + "text": "4個小時又20分鐘左右" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147884/109.wav", + "text": "所以那個是一個很長距離的搭乘" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147884/110.wav", + "text": "那個舒適度是要被考慮進去的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147884/111.wav", + "text": "本來把它優先放在花東" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147884/112.wav", + "text": "是希望提供花東便利" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147884/113.wav", + "text": "如果有這樣的聲音" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147884/114.wav", + "text": "我已經交辦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147884/115.wav", + "text": "請他們趕快" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147884/116.wav", + "text": "運量提升是大家可以肯定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147884/117.wav", + "text": "明亮大家都可以肯定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147884/118.wav", + "text": "但我們現在討論就是希望它能夠更" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147884/119.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147884/120.wav", + "text": "越好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147884/121.wav", + "text": "不然如果你沒有把握" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147884/122.wav", + "text": "你也可以先做部分的改善" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147884/123.wav", + "text": "讓大家可以做比較" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147884/124.wav", + "text": "你就講哪一個列車" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147884/125.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147884/126.wav", + "text": "好我趕快請他們把那個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147884/127.wav", + "text": "局長好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147884/128.wav", + "text": "填補公共運輸的缺口" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147884/129.wav", + "text": "所以也補助一些非都市的地方" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147884/130.wav", + "text": "如幸福巴士" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147884/131.wav", + "text": "或幸福小黃的路線" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147884/132.wav", + "text": "全國總共161條的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147884/133.wav", + "text": "我們根據110年度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147884/134.wav", + "text": "6月整體利用的比例來講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147884/135.wav", + "text": "乘坐率是30.51" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147884/136.wav", + "text": "%就是小黃巴士整體的利用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147884/137.wav", + "text": "其中我們臺東縣總共有55條路線" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147884/138.wav", + "text": "受到補助" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147884/139.wav", + "text": "整體的利用率是31.92" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147884/140.wav", + "text": "%空駛率是25.93%" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147884/141.wav", + "text": "沒有破50%或更高" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147884/142.wav", + "text": "滿高的主要原因是因為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147884/143.wav", + "text": "營運的時間跟規劃的班次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147884/144.wav", + "text": "其實這是主要的原因" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147884/145.wav", + "text": "或幸福小黃" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147884/146.wav", + "text": "直接到目的地的機率可能不多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147884/147.wav", + "text": "而是要對接" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147884/148.wav", + "text": "看起來還沒有辦法具體落實" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147884/149.wav", + "text": "所以雖然" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147884/150.wav", + "text": "中央政府有這樣的美意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147884/151.wav", + "text": "不過整體的利用率還是無法提高" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147884/152.wav", + "text": "陳局長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147884/153.wav", + "text": "有關這個部分你有沒有什麼改善的方法有跟委" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147884/154.wav", + "text": "是開固定時間的班次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147884/155.wav", + "text": "就像委員所說幸" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147884/156.wav", + "text": "士不會是開很長途" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147884/157.wav", + "text": "或是長途的公路客運" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147884/158.wav", + "text": "時間的部分我想是要再做一個檢討" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147884/159.wav", + "text": "我們會會同公所再來做討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147884/160.wav", + "text": "中央政府有這樣的一個政策跟美意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147884/161.wav", + "text": "但實際執行的規劃路線" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147884/162.wav", + "text": "其實是由地方去執行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147884/163.wav", + "text": "我覺得這個要大家彼此互相合作" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147884/164.wav", + "text": "跟大都會所面對的交通問題是不一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147884/165.wav", + "text": "的臺北臺中及高雄" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147884/166.wav", + "text": "將散居在各地的民眾" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147884/167.wav", + "text": "特別是老人家長輩比較多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147884/168.wav", + "text": "如何讓他們便利地連接到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147884/169.wav", + "text": "他想要去的地方" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147884/170.wav", + "text": "這個部分是最多的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147884/171.wav", + "text": "所以臺東的交通如果可以弄好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147884/172.wav", + "text": "以臺東為例的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147884/173.wav", + "text": "不是只有負責給予補助給予錢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147884/174.wav", + "text": "運研所的人才庫總是比地方多很多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147884/175.wav", + "text": "這個部分可不可以實際去負責" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147884/176.wav", + "text": "每個鄉鎮" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147884/177.wav", + "text": "所遇到的狀況可能會不一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147884/178.wav", + "text": "比如臺東跟花蓮彰化可能遇到的狀況會不一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147884/179.wav", + "text": "當成一個具體的成績來把它做好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147884/180.wav", + "text": "最起碼要對接到鐵路局或幹線讓" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147884/181.wav", + "text": "它的運輸是非常方便便利的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147884/182.wav", + "text": "我們現在其實已經有針對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147884/183.wav", + "text": "空駛率高的路線及班次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147884/184.wav", + "text": "來做檢討" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147884/185.wav", + "text": "找到它實際的需求" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147884/186.wav", + "text": "我們會會同運研所的地區區域研究" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147884/187.wav", + "text": "中心跟公所把實際需求找出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147884/188.wav", + "text": "如果有具體更進一步的資料也麻煩給我參考" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147884/189.wav", + "text": "謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147882/0.wav", + "text": "主席我們請朱主計長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147882/1.wav", + "text": "請主計長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147882/2.wav", + "text": "委員好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147882/3.wav", + "text": "幾位委員的質詢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147882/4.wav", + "text": "占我們GDP的比例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147882/5.wav", + "text": "你說占到5%喔" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147882/6.wav", + "text": "那是我剛才算錯把兩個混淆在一起" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147882/7.wav", + "text": "因為我們的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147882/8.wav", + "text": "低收入戶大概有28萬人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147882/9.wav", + "text": "所以兩個合起來大概有五十幾萬人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147882/10.wav", + "text": "占總人口的大概2.5%" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147882/11.wav", + "text": "另外我們也公布一個叫做相對貧窮率" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147882/12.wav", + "text": "相對貧窮率就是說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147882/13.wav", + "text": "你的可支配所得占中位數50%以下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147882/14.wav", + "text": "我們叫做相對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147882/15.wav", + "text": "我剛才講錯因為有個相對貧窮率" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147882/16.wav", + "text": "這部分我們是7%左右謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147882/17.wav", + "text": "所以你剛剛講錯了嘛對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147882/18.wav", + "text": "我想說我們的低收入戶跟中低收入戶加起來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147882/19.wav", + "text": "占GDP的占比到5%那很高呢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147882/20.wav", + "text": "你講錯了嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147882/21.wav", + "text": "對講錯了是人口的占" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147882/22.wav", + "text": "但是它占GDP的占比沒有到那麼高嘛對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147882/23.wav", + "text": "差不多2.5%左右嘛對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147882/24.wav", + "text": "讓人聽了嚇一跳啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147882/25.wav", + "text": "我知道兩個大概都是28萬人左右" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147882/26.wav", + "text": "我是除以那個除錯了謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147882/27.wav", + "text": "是的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147882/28.wav", + "text": "受僱人員的報酬跟營業盈餘的分配比例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147882/29.wav", + "text": "大概從民國81年開始到現在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147882/30.wav", + "text": "我們的受僱人員報酬的占比一路下滑" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147882/31.wav", + "text": "卻一路上升" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147882/32.wav", + "text": "是的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147882/33.wav", + "text": "所以就這個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147882/34.wav", + "text": "你看這個統計數字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147882/35.wav", + "text": "你會認為說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147882/36.wav", + "text": "一則以憂" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147882/37.wav", + "text": "但是一則也可以喜" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147882/38.wav", + "text": "為什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147882/39.wav", + "text": "這代表我們越來越資本密集跟技術密集" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147882/40.wav", + "text": "我們的國家的資本跟技術越來越密集" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147882/41.wav", + "text": "但是另外一方面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147882/42.wav", + "text": "因為資本跟技術密集" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147882/43.wav", + "text": "大部分是比較屬於高所得的一群" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147882/44.wav", + "text": "所以我們就要有一些社會福利措施來改變" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147882/45.wav", + "text": "不只社會福利措施" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147882/46.wav", + "text": "就是說這個數字的呈現" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147882/47.wav", + "text": "我們把數字拿出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147882/48.wav", + "text": "大家有貧富差距擴大的感覺" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147882/49.wav", + "text": "對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147882/50.wav", + "text": "但是事實上它也是一個產業結構" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147882/51.wav", + "text": "我們的產業結構改變的一個狀況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147882/52.wav", + "text": "所以不管是誰在馬英九執政的8年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147882/53.wav", + "text": "裡面也是一路下滑下降也沒有回升過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147882/54.wav", + "text": "因為這就是產業結構的變化趨勢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147882/55.wav", + "text": "我們還是要面對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147882/56.wav", + "text": "能不能讓勞動薪酬再成長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147882/57.wav", + "text": "人民最關心的事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147882/58.wav", + "text": "剛剛主計長也講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147882/59.wav", + "text": "能夠擴散到其他的領域" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147882/60.wav", + "text": "我想這也是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147882/61.wav", + "text": "在經濟學上所謂薪資" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147882/62.wav", + "text": "要跟勞動的邊際生產力相等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147882/63.wav", + "text": "所以我們要提高薪資" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147882/64.wav", + "text": "從比較長期的方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147882/65.wav", + "text": "更多的在職訓練" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147882/66.wav", + "text": "讓他的附加價值能夠提高" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147882/67.wav", + "text": "我有去翻你們主計" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147882/68.wav", + "text": "叫主計處時期的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147882/69.wav", + "text": "資料從2010年到現在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147882/70.wav", + "text": "跟盈餘比例的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147882/71.wav", + "text": "2010年的時候你們提到最大的問題就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147882/72.wav", + "text": "勞動全球化及產業大量外移中國" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147882/73.wav", + "text": "導致我國薪資報酬的分配比率下滑" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147882/74.wav", + "text": "一直到2016年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147882/75.wav", + "text": "你們的分析" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147882/76.wav", + "text": "還是製造業外移" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147882/77.wav", + "text": "導致我們受僱人員的薪資占比一直下降" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147882/78.wav", + "text": "對因為製造業外移讓我們勞動階級的工作機會減少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147882/79.wav", + "text": "我就趕快看國內其他主要政黨的主張" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147882/80.wav", + "text": "結果去翻了國民黨的智庫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147882/81.wav", + "text": "這是國民黨官方智庫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147882/82.wav", + "text": "財團法人國家政策研究基金會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147882/83.wav", + "text": "針對如何改變這個問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147882/84.wav", + "text": "他們的解方是兩岸服貿協議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147882/85.wav", + "text": "它說簽署兩岸服貿協議可以解決這個問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147882/86.wav", + "text": "2023年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147882/87.wav", + "text": "了也還有總統候選人說要重啟服貿" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147882/88.wav", + "text": "就是要用兩岸服貿協議來解決這個問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147882/89.wav", + "text": "主計長兩岸服貿協議的簽署" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147882/90.wav", + "text": "能夠有助於" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147882/91.wav", + "text": "我們講的提高勞動人員薪資的分配比例嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147882/92.wav", + "text": "因為這個比較是屬於國發會或經濟部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147882/93.wav", + "text": "的問題就是服貿的這種規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147882/94.wav", + "text": "要談這個問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147882/95.wav", + "text": "針對此事對症下藥" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147882/96.wav", + "text": "問題第一個就是提高工資" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147882/97.wav", + "text": "引導來提高工資" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147882/98.wav", + "text": "第二個就是企業的利益分配要合理化" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147882/99.wav", + "text": "這兩個目標我們對症下藥" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147882/100.wav", + "text": "就是針對這兩個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147882/101.wav", + "text": "對我非常同意委員的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147882/102.wav", + "text": "我們就鼓勵臺商回臺投資" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147882/103.wav", + "text": "以及國內的根留臺灣這個措施" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147882/104.wav", + "text": "好那提高薪資的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147882/105.wav", + "text": "大家所提的方向大概第一個就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147882/106.wav", + "text": "鼓勵企業加薪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147882/107.wav", + "text": "至於政府自己的政策工具" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147882/108.wav", + "text": "就是提高基本工資" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147882/109.wav", + "text": "大概只有這兩個政策手段" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147882/110.wav", + "text": "這些民間的產業" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147882/111.wav", + "text": "大概就是這兩個方向" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147882/112.wav", + "text": "是的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147882/113.wav", + "text": "臺灣基本工資的調整情形" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147882/114.wav", + "text": "其實調整了相當的幅度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147882/115.wav", + "text": "我們用這八年跟前八年來比較" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147882/116.wav", + "text": "從2010年到2015年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147882/117.wav", + "text": "那八年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147882/118.wav", + "text": "只調整五次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147882/119.wav", + "text": "在民進黨執政的這八年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147882/120.wav", + "text": "這八年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147882/121.wav", + "text": "調了多少次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147882/122.wav", + "text": "對每年都有調" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147882/123.wav", + "text": "只是在疫情期間調幅比較少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147882/124.wav", + "text": "但是整個總計" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147882/125.wav", + "text": "剛剛說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147882/126.wav", + "text": "前八年調漲了2,728元" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147882/127.wav", + "text": "最近這八年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147882/128.wav", + "text": "3倍調整了6,461元" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147882/129.wav", + "text": "對我們原來在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147882/130.wav", + "text": "2105年的時候是20,008元" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147882/131.wav", + "text": "現在到明年1月的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147882/132.wav", + "text": "26,400" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147882/133.wav", + "text": "政府有一個最重要的政策" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147882/134.wav", + "text": "法制化所以我們有一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147882/135.wav", + "text": "最低工資法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147882/136.wav", + "text": "立法院衛環委員會那邊審查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147882/137.wav", + "text": "對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147882/138.wav", + "text": "最低工資" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147882/139.wav", + "text": "能夠改善它" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147882/140.wav", + "text": "它的法制化過程" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147882/141.wav", + "text": "希望能夠讓它" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147882/142.wav", + "text": "我們希望大院支持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147882/143.wav", + "text": "其中就放進了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147882/144.wav", + "text": "最新的條件" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147882/145.wav", + "text": "就是我們今天的主題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147882/146.wav", + "text": "──國民生產毛額" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147882/147.wav", + "text": "及成本構成之分配比率" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147882/148.wav", + "text": "法草案第9條裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147882/149.wav", + "text": "把它放進去作為考量" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147882/150.wav", + "text": "部分\n剛才賴委員也提到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147882/151.wav", + "text": "在鼓勵民間加薪的這個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147882/152.wav", + "text": "2024年要落日" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147882/153.wav", + "text": "就是明年5月19日要落日" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147882/154.wav", + "text": "我們會往延長的方向" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147882/155.wav", + "text": "那個是財政部跟經濟部的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147882/156.wav", + "text": "一個共同協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147882/157.wav", + "text": "不過那個方式就是剛才" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147882/158.wav", + "text": "大家有提到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147882/159.wav", + "text": "因為那個適用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147882/160.wav", + "text": "我們請經濟部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147882/161.wav", + "text": "用加薪來減稅的這個辦法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147882/162.wav", + "text": "��中小企業發展條例裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147882/163.wav", + "text": "所定的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147882/164.wav", + "text": "這個剛剛也講過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147882/165.wav", + "text": "適用的家數很少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147882/166.wav", + "text": "但是我們的目的不是要讓它" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147882/167.wav", + "text": "我們怎麼會制定一個法制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147882/168.wav", + "text": "讓中小企業適用而適用的很少呢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147882/169.wav", + "text": "我們應該是用一個法制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147882/170.wav", + "text": "來鼓勵大家讓中小企業都會想" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147882/171.wav", + "text": "這才是正確的方向" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147882/172.wav", + "text": "嘛所以我們現在這個辦法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147882/173.wav", + "text": "其實是有問題的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147882/174.wav", + "text": "啦是有一些問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147882/175.wav", + "text": "我們除了往延長的方向之外" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147882/176.wav", + "text": "這些問題也要改變" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147882/177.wav", + "text": "大多數的中小企業" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147882/178.wav", + "text": "其實很多的中小企業" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147882/179.wav", + "text": "如果沒有免徵的這些中小企業" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147882/180.wav", + "text": "它現在要申請這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147882/181.wav", + "text": "反而變得非常繁瑣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147882/182.wav", + "text": "當然就沒有這個意願了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147882/183.wav", + "text": "所以在未來這個制度改變的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147882/184.wav", + "text": "現在這個制度的這些問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147882/185.wav", + "text": "我覺得是不是能夠一併納入檢討" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147882/186.wav", + "text": "鼓勵更多的中小企業" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147882/187.wav", + "text": "適用這一條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147882/188.wav", + "text": "是我們會跟財政部討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147882/189.wav", + "text": "整個大方向就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147882/190.wav", + "text": "針對怎麼簡化程序" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147882/191.wav", + "text": "怎麼擴大適用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147882/192.wav", + "text": "對怎麼提高中小企業的意願" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147882/193.wav", + "text": "提高你的意願" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147882/194.wav", + "text": "啊讓中小企業希望它能夠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147882/195.wav", + "text": "我趕快加薪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147882/196.wav", + "text": "能夠來抵稅" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147882/197.wav", + "text": "嘛而現在制定這個法律" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147882/198.wav", + "text": "明年就要落日了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147882/199.wav", + "text": "結果適用的沒幾家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147882/200.wav", + "text": "好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147882/201.wav", + "text": "我們來一併檢討" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147881/0.wav", + "text": "現在大選快要到了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147881/1.wav", + "text": "公務人員是不是應該行政中立" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147881/2.wav", + "text": "是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147881/3.wav", + "text": "應該行政中立" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147881/4.wav", + "text": "好我們來看一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147881/5.wav", + "text": "這���很多都是立委候選人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147881/6.wav", + "text": "這裡面有些人其實並不具立委的身分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147881/7.wav", + "text": "但是有一個共同的特色就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147881/8.wav", + "text": "在這些立委候選人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147881/9.wav", + "text": "有的甚至是雙政務官雙主菜" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147881/10.wav", + "text": "我想請問一下秘書長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147881/11.wav", + "text": "這樣有沒有違反行政中立" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147881/12.wav", + "text": "行政中立法有一些適用對象的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147881/13.wav", + "text": "謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147881/14.wav", + "text": "因為行政中立法適用對象" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147881/15.wav", + "text": "原則上不及於政務人員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147881/16.wav", + "text": "但是有一部分依照法令" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147881/17.wav", + "text": "是必須獨立行使職權的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147881/18.wav", + "text": "才適用行政中立法的規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147881/19.wav", + "text": "大量的在幫特定政黨的立委候選人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147881/20.wav", + "text": "來幫他贊聲" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147881/21.wav", + "text": "或者幫他開說明會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147881/22.wav", + "text": "這都沒有違反行政中立是不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147881/23.wav", + "text": "你們的認定是這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147881/24.wav", + "text": "因為他如果不是適用對象" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147881/25.wav", + "text": "就不會構成違反行政中立法的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147881/26.wav", + "text": "是不是都是行政部門的首長是吧" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147881/27.wav", + "text": "有些是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147881/28.wav", + "text": "有些是都是啊對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147881/29.wav", + "text": "我剛剛講的這些政務官" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147881/30.wav", + "text": "現在大選將屆" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147881/31.wav", + "text": "我們行政中立講了這麼久" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147881/32.wav", + "text": "可是到現在為止" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147881/33.wav", + "text": "因為你們可以去鑽這些行政漏洞" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147881/34.wav", + "text": "他不是在上班時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147881/35.wav", + "text": "不然就是他並不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147881/36.wav", + "text": "我們行政中立法規範的對象" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147881/37.wav", + "text": "現在所謂的行政中立形同具文不是嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147881/38.wav", + "text": "請問一下考試院的長官" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147881/39.wav", + "text": "這樣的風氣此風可長嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147881/40.wav", + "text": "從行政中立法制定以來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147881/41.wav", + "text": "各個政黨執政的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147881/42.wav", + "text": "其實都是這樣的一個規範" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147881/43.wav", + "text": "因為所有的政務人員原則上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147881/44.wav", + "text": "因為行政中立是要求常任文官" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147881/45.wav", + "text": "特別需要保持行政中立" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147881/46.wav", + "text": "所以所以政務官不需要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147881/47.wav", + "text": "政務官挾龐大的行政資源" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147881/48.wav", + "text": "來去做助選的機器" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147881/49.wav", + "text": "完全沒有差" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147881/50.wav", + "text": "然後我也看到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147881/51.wav", + "text": "他們都以所謂的施政願景說明會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147881/52.wav", + "text": "是現任立委" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147881/53.wav", + "text": "或者現在並不具立委身分的人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147881/54.wav", + "text": "政黨我直接說這政黨就是民進黨而已" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147881/55.wav", + "text": "啊國民黨沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147881/56.wav", + "text": "時代力量沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147881/57.wav", + "text": "民眾黨沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147881/58.wav", + "text": "無黨籍沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147881/59.wav", + "text": "所以這一點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147881/60.wav", + "text": "如果今天我們要維繫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147881/61.wav", + "text": "我們的一個文官制度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147881/62.wav", + "text": "我們可以這樣子放任" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147881/63.wav", + "text": "我覺得這只是讓我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147881/64.wav", + "text": "整個行政中立全部鬆動" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147881/65.wav", + "text": "這些長官的行程" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147881/66.wav", + "text": "有沒有秘書隨行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147881/67.wav", + "text": "他有沒有派車" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147881/68.wav", + "text": "當然有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147881/69.wav", + "text": "這樣濫用行政資源" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147881/70.wav", + "text": "這還只是部分而已" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147881/71.wav", + "text": "喔還有很多是雙主菜" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147881/72.wav", + "text": "好幾個部長通通都在現場" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147881/73.wav", + "text": "如果可以這樣的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147881/74.wav", + "text": "我覺得我們現在的執政黨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147881/75.wav", + "text": "做出最壞最壞的示範" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147881/76.wav", + "text": "把行政中立踩在腳底下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147881/77.wav", + "text": "\n另外我要請問一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147881/78.wav", + "text": "公務人員協會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147881/79.wav", + "text": "消防人員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147881/80.wav", + "text": "因為在幾次慘痛的教訓下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147881/81.wav", + "text": "希望能夠組工會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147881/82.wav", + "text": "最近提出了一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147881/83.wav", + "text": "公務人員協會法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147881/84.wav", + "text": "條文的修正草案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147881/85.wav", + "text": "對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147881/86.wav", + "text": "我想特別請教的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147881/87.wav", + "text": "因為在裡面做了一些修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147881/88.wav", + "text": "特別增加了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147881/89.wav", + "text": "中央三級或相當三級" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147881/90.wav", + "text": "這裡面感覺上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147881/91.wav", + "text": "應該是為了要因應" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147881/92.wav", + "text": "消防人員他們希望能夠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147881/93.wav", + "text": "因為現在把條文修正為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147881/94.wav", + "text": "包含中央二級或相當二級" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147881/95.wav", + "text": "機關的公務人員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147881/96.wav", + "text": "還有三級跟相當三級" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147881/97.wav", + "text": "機關的公務人員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147881/98.wav", + "text": "裡面還有一個特種" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147881/99.wav", + "text": "特種公務人員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147881/100.wav", + "text": "但是相對的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147881/101.wav", + "text": "你們在第7條條文裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147881/102.wav", + "text": "又去規範了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147881/103.wav", + "text": "這些關於" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147881/104.wav", + "text": "裡面有一個很重要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147881/105.wav", + "text": "就是勤休的方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147881/106.wav", + "text": "但是你們在第2項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147881/107.wav", + "text": "又特別針對協商事項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147881/108.wav", + "text": "做了一些除外的規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147881/109.wav", + "text": "包含與國防相關海巡相關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147881/110.wav", + "text": "安全相關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147881/111.wav", + "text": "還有足以妨害" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147881/112.wav", + "text": "及災害防救等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147881/113.wav", + "text": "整體勤務執行安全事項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147881/114.wav", + "text": "\n所以我想請問一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147881/115.wav", + "text": "這第7條的修正是怎麼樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147881/116.wav", + "text": "是未來公務人員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147881/117.wav", + "text": "可以成立協會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147881/118.wav", + "text": "然後提出協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147881/119.wav", + "text": "比如說包含他的環境" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147881/120.wav", + "text": "還有他勤休的方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147881/121.wav", + "text": "但是你們又排除了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147881/122.wav", + "text": "這些人員是不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147881/123.wav", + "text": "我直接用白話文講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147881/124.wav", + "text": "是不是就是海巡署" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147881/125.wav", + "text": "警政署矯正署移民署" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147881/126.wav", + "text": "這些都不含在裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147881/127.wav", + "text": "是這個意思嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147881/128.wav", + "text": "你可不可以說明一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147881/129.wav", + "text": "不是這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147881/130.wav", + "text": "妨害這些工作的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147881/131.wav", + "text": "整體勤務執行安全事項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147881/132.wav", + "text": "才是不得協商的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147881/133.wav", + "text": "但是如果能夠提升改善" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147881/134.wav", + "text": "促進的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147881/135.wav", + "text": "就都是可以協商的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147881/136.wav", + "text": "所以如果是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147881/137.wav", + "text": "你覺得會妨害" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147881/138.wav", + "text": "這些事項的對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147881/139.wav", + "text": "對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147881/140.wav", + "text": "會妨害這些事項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147881/141.wav", + "text": "基本上銓敘部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147881/142.wav", + "text": "當然會跟相關主管機關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147881/143.wav", + "text": "去瞭解情況再來判斷" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147881/144.wav", + "text": "所以誰會妨害" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147881/145.wav", + "text": "呢比如你們的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147881/146.wav", + "text": "修法說明裡面特別提到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147881/147.wav", + "text": "為什麼會有這樣的修法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147881/148.wav", + "text": "跟國防安全很重要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147881/149.wav", + "text": "海巡對國安也很重要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147881/150.wav", + "text": "所以去認定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147881/151.wav", + "text": "足不足以妨害的單位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147881/152.wav", + "text": "嘛就是他的主管機關是不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147881/153.wav", + "text": "對我的意思是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147881/154.wav", + "text": "是不是就是內政部認定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147881/155.wav", + "text": "足不足以妨害" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147881/156.wav", + "text": "整體勤務的執行安全" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147881/157.wav", + "text": "是不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147881/158.wav", + "text": "原則上我們會徵詢他的意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147881/159.wav", + "text": "但不受他意見的拘束" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147881/160.wav", + "text": "我們會再做判斷" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147881/161.wav", + "text": "因為如果不能協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147881/162.wav", + "text": "或協商有爭議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147881/163.wav", + "text": "最後還是有後面的調解" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147881/164.wav", + "text": "我們只是擔心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147881/165.wav", + "text": "這個看起來是放寬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147881/166.wav", + "text": "說實在的消防人員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147881/167.wav", + "text": "用他們的生命換來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147881/168.wav", + "text": "對於他們籌組工會的高度重視" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147881/169.wav", + "text": "然後行政院考試院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147881/170.wav", + "text": "必須作出回應" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147881/171.wav", + "text": "因此而有這個修正草案的提出" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147881/172.wav", + "text": "當然這裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147881/173.wav", + "text": "消防人員如果可以做的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147881/174.wav", + "text": "那麼警察可不可以做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147881/175.wav", + "text": "一部兩制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147881/176.wav", + "text": "可是現在所有的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147881/177.wav", + "text": "如果這一些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147881/178.wav", + "text": "足不足以妨害" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147881/179.wav", + "text": "都是由他們的主管機關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147881/180.wav", + "text": "如果我們講勞資雙方" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147881/181.wav", + "text": "吧這邊就變成資方來決定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147881/182.wav", + "text": "所以會不會使得他們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147881/183.wav", + "text": "未來的協商權" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147881/184.wav", + "text": "跟他們的協商空間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147881/185.wav", + "text": "大為被壓縮" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147881/186.wav", + "text": "你看你們在裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147881/187.wav", + "text": "還特別" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147881/188.wav", + "text": "提到內政部考量" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147881/189.wav", + "text": "在討論這些修正草案的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147881/190.wav", + "text": "一定是內政部有很多意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147881/191.wav", + "text": "對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147881/192.wav", + "text": "跟委員報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147881/193.wav", + "text": "因為這個法的主管機關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147881/194.wav", + "text": "是我們銓敘部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147881/195.wav", + "text": "解釋當然是我們銓敘部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147881/196.wav", + "text": "我們會參考" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147881/197.wav", + "text": "主管機關的意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147881/198.wav", + "text": "這一條草案的這個修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147881/199.wav", + "text": "是根據學者專家的建議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147881/200.wav", + "text": "因為他們認為原來的規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147881/201.wav", + "text": "確實限制太過嚴格" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147881/202.wav", + "text": "所以要放寬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147881/203.wav", + "text": "這一條的修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147881/204.wav", + "text": "絕對是放寬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147881/205.wav", + "text": "至於委員擔心的事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147881/206.wav", + "text": "我們銓敘部當然會考量" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147881/207.wav", + "text": "他的主管機關考量下來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147881/208.wav", + "text": "做判斷" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147881/209.wav", + "text": "但是你剛剛回答我" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147881/210.wav", + "text": "就是未來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147881/211.wav", + "text": "是不是足以妨害" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147881/212.wav", + "text": "還是要跟主管機關考量" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147881/213.wav", + "text": "你在條文裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147881/214.wav", + "text": "沒有含及的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147881/215.wav", + "text": "移民消防之外的他們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147881/216.wav", + "text": "就一律可以組成協會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147881/217.wav", + "text": "他們一律可以去做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147881/218.wav", + "text": "你們在第7條所規定的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147881/219.wav", + "text": "這些相關協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147881/220.wav", + "text": "第7條第1項可以協商的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147881/221.wav", + "text": "事項範圍都可以協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147881/222.wav", + "text": "好所以只要不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147881/223.wav", + "text": "屬於這幾個項目的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147881/224.wav", + "text": "都可以協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147881/225.wav", + "text": "這個法其實對公務人員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147881/226.wav", + "text": "有很大的影響" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147881/227.wav", + "text": "我們當然是爭取了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147881/228.wav", + "text": "過勞的狀況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147881/229.wav", + "text": "但是這邊看起來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147881/230.wav", + "text": "你們又把它含及" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147881/231.wav", + "text": "的更擴大" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147881/232.wav", + "text": "甚至" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147881/233.wav", + "text": "關務的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147881/234.wav", + "text": "所以只要不在這幾項裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147881/235.wav", + "text": "未來全部都可以協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147881/236.wav", + "text": "就不要再去跟主管機關說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147881/237.wav", + "text": "不行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147881/238.wav", + "text": "你這個勤休" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147881/239.wav", + "text": "休是妨害我的什麼運作" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147881/240.wav", + "text": "然後就不准是不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147881/241.wav", + "text": "因為大家可能看到這個文字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147881/242.wav", + "text": "會有一些解讀上面的落差" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147881/243.wav", + "text": "在實務上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147881/244.wav", + "text": "我們看現在消防署" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147881/245.wav", + "text": "跟我們的基層同仁" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147881/246.wav", + "text": "也都在討論很多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147881/247.wav", + "text": "如何提升安全的事項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147881/248.wav", + "text": "所以我想大概" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147881/249.wav", + "text": "未來這些事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147881/250.wav", + "text": "是不可以協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147881/251.wav", + "text": "而且我們這裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147881/252.wav", + "text": "對照原條文來看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147881/253.wav", + "text": "它的確是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147881/254.wav", + "text": "把不能協商的範圍" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147881/255.wav", + "text": "縮到最小" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147881/256.wav", + "text": "因為這次消防人員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147881/257.wav", + "text": "高度重視" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147881/258.wav", + "text": "是因為他們用生命換來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147881/259.wav", + "text": "的但是你們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147881/260.wav", + "text": "今天修了這個法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147881/261.wav", + "text": "它就不僅僅只是消防人員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147881/262.wav", + "text": "對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147881/263.wav", + "text": "也想知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147881/264.wav", + "text": "我的權益是什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147881/265.wav", + "text": "消防人員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147881/266.wav", + "text": "如果可以組工會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147881/267.wav", + "text": "我們警察可不可以組工會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147881/268.wav", + "text": "他們一樣會有這樣的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147881/269.wav", + "text": "希望這樣的爭取跟質疑" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147881/270.wav", + "text": "所以這個法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147881/271.wav", + "text": "我覺得到時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147881/272.wav", + "text": "當然也一定會拿出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147881/273.wav", + "text": "再做更詳細的討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147881/274.wav", + "text": "但是怎麼樣去保障" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147881/275.wav", + "text": "我們公務人員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147881/276.wav", + "text": "其實滿重要的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147881/277.wav", + "text": "謝謝委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147880/0.wav", + "text": "我們請部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147880/1.wav", + "text": "有請部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147880/2.wav", + "text": "部長今天的主題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147880/3.wav", + "text": "相當重要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147880/4.wav", + "text": "但是也牽涉很廣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147880/5.wav", + "text": "我們從你今天的報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147880/6.wav", + "text": "還有各位委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147880/7.wav", + "text": "非常有智慧的質詢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147880/8.wav", + "text": "中都勾勒出一些方向" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147880/9.wav", + "text": "當然剛剛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147880/10.wav", + "text": "然後讓政策弄得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147880/11.wav", + "text": "更好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147880/12.wav", + "text": "我想是大家一起努力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147880/13.wav", + "text": "其實全世界所有的事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147880/14.wav", + "text": "都是資源有限" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147880/15.wav", + "text": "怎麼樣分配好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147880/16.wav", + "text": "包括價值" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147880/17.wav", + "text": "怎麼樣創造" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147880/18.wav", + "text": "尊嚴怎麼樣維護" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147880/19.wav", + "text": "這些事情都要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147880/20.wav", + "text": "我就不直接去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147880/21.wav", + "text": "處理這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147880/22.wav", + "text": "最重要的是還有很多事情我們可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147880/23.wav", + "text": "處理也許可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147880/24.wav", + "text": "創造更多的勞工" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147880/25.wav", + "text": "尤其是中高齡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147880/26.wav", + "text": "迎接這樣一個社會的勞工" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147880/27.wav", + "text": "照顧" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147880/28.wav", + "text": "這個部分我們來思考一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147880/29.wav", + "text": "\n當然我們知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147880/30.wav", + "text": "國際間的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147880/31.wav", + "text": "聯合國也提出了永續發展目標" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147880/32.wav", + "text": "項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147880/33.wav", + "text": "良好的健康及社會福利這個跟勞工當然有關係" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147880/34.wav", + "text": "第8項所謂的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147880/35.wav", + "text": "decent work" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147880/36.wav", + "text": "我們翻成體面的工作" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147880/37.wav", + "text": "他的職業為榮" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147880/38.wav", + "text": "尊嚴勞動" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147880/39.wav", + "text": "當然收入也要一定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147880/40.wav", + "text": "收入不太好好像也不太體面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147880/41.wav", + "text": "經濟發展" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147880/42.wav", + "text": "SDGs裡面跟勞工比較有關係" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147880/43.wav", + "text": "的所以看起來增進勞工" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147880/44.wav", + "text": "健康跟福祉其實是可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147880/45.wav", + "text": "還是可以促進聯合" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147880/46.wav", + "text": "部長你對這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147880/47.wav", + "text": "有什麼看法你先說一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147880/48.wav", + "text": "跟委員報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147880/49.wav", + "text": "接下來就是高齡化" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147880/50.wav", + "text": "但是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147880/51.wav", + "text": "我們的高齡者現在都" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147880/52.wav", + "text": "算健康" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147880/53.wav", + "text": "所以我們都希望他能夠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147880/54.wav", + "text": "健康地老化" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147880/55.wav", + "text": "然後還能夠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147880/56.wav", + "text": "續留職場" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147880/57.wav", + "text": "但是健康一定要擺第一" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147880/58.wav", + "text": "也是我們勞動部的重點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147880/59.wav", + "text": "針對高齡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147880/60.wav", + "text": "衛生指引這個可以供" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147880/61.wav", + "text": "雇主參考及運用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147880/62.wav", + "text": "另外各區委員也都很關心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147880/63.wav", + "text": "所以我們各區的健康服務中心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147880/64.wav", + "text": "也都有輔導" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147880/65.wav", + "text": "中小企業來運用補助的資源" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147880/66.wav", + "text": "推動" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147880/67.wav", + "text": "工作環境的改善還有健康" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147880/68.wav", + "text": "中高齡及高齡者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147880/69.wav", + "text": "尊嚴勞動可以落實" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147880/70.wav", + "text": "這幾年我們也一直在提" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147880/71.wav", + "text": "法案這些年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147880/72.wav", + "text": "來我們可以看到勞動部上上下下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147880/73.wav", + "text": "針對該做的事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147880/74.wav", + "text": "殫精竭慮地在努力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147880/75.wav", + "text": "這個部分我必須要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147880/76.wav", + "text": "給勞動部最大的一個肯定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147880/77.wav", + "text": "跟支持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147880/78.wav", + "text": "剛剛部長也有提到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147880/79.wav", + "text": "在增進勞工健康跟福祉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147880/80.wav", + "text": "祉的部分的確也是我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147880/81.wav", + "text": "一直在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147880/82.wav", + "text": "這裡討論的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147880/83.wav", + "text": "勞動部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147880/84.wav", + "text": "推動中小企業臨場健康" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147880/85.wav", + "text": "服務補助計畫等等的這些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147880/86.wav", + "text": "參與很久" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147880/87.wav", + "text": "除了在幾十年前我就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147880/88.wav", + "text": "職醫的醫師" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147880/89.wav", + "text": "我有執照" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147880/90.wav", + "text": "部門主任的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147880/91.wav", + "text": "我在臺大醫院就推動" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147880/92.wav", + "text": "臺大醫院跟某一個建設公司" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147880/93.wav", + "text": "在討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147880/94.wav", + "text": "我們去幫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147880/95.wav", + "text": "幫所有的員工做健檢以外" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147880/96.wav", + "text": "也做了很多健康促進的措施" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147880/97.wav", + "text": "當然那已經是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147880/98.wav", + "text": "十幾年前的事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147880/99.wav", + "text": "我覺得能夠這樣做的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147880/100.wav", + "text": "企業感覺上真的都是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147880/101.wav", + "text": "的不管他創造的品質" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147880/102.wav", + "text": "或照顧員工所" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147880/103.wav", + "text": "所呈現的力量" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147880/104.wav", + "text": "都會在社會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147880/105.wav", + "text": "上一直受到尊重" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147880/106.wav", + "text": "這個計畫到現在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147880/107.wav", + "text": "也還在做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147880/108.wav", + "text": "當然其他有些單位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147880/109.wav", + "text": "有些公司也都有來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147880/110.wav", + "text": "給他看一下我們這些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147880/111.wav", + "text": "認可顧問機構" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147880/112.wav", + "text": "查詢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147880/113.wav", + "text": "這個是怎麼評審的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147880/114.wav", + "text": "健康顧問公司" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147880/115.wav", + "text": "不像我過去的經驗" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147880/116.wav", + "text": "是跟醫療機構" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147880/117.wav", + "text": "報告委員我" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147880/118.wav", + "text": "說明一下我們目前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147880/119.wav", + "text": "投入勞工健康服務的機構" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147880/120.wav", + "text": "認可的顧問機構" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147880/121.wav", + "text": "有34家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147880/122.wav", + "text": "然後醫院跟診所" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147880/123.wav", + "text": "有331家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147880/124.wav", + "text": "這兩者都是特約" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147880/125.wav", + "text": "來提供" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147880/126.wav", + "text": "勞工的健康服務" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147880/127.wav", + "text": "跟我過去的經驗" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147880/128.wav", + "text": "也不只臺大醫院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147880/129.wav", + "text": "我想很多醫院應該都有它自己的報告委員因為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147880/130.wav", + "text": "醫院跟診所沒有問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147880/131.wav", + "text": "但是顧問" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147880/132.wav", + "text": "比較嚴格審查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147880/133.wav", + "text": "對既然我們已經很重視職場的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147880/134.wav", + "text": "健康促進" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147880/135.wav", + "text": "我覺得就要利用現有的很多資源" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147880/136.wav", + "text": "包括何必" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147880/137.wav", + "text": "如果醫療機構已經做得很好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147880/138.wav", + "text": "我也不反對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147880/139.wav", + "text": "但是你們要去評這樣你們就很累" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147880/140.wav", + "text": "就是很有品牌的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147880/141.wav", + "text": "嘛它去接到什麼我相信大家都有信心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147880/142.wav", + "text": "它絕對不會做得不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147880/143.wav", + "text": "但是顧問公司" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147880/144.wav", + "text": "你就要花很多功夫去評審" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147880/145.wav", + "text": "我是不知道你們這個中間的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147880/146.wav", + "text": "過程是怎樣去處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147880/147.wav", + "text": "啦沒關係我關心的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147880/148.wav", + "text": "只是這個量能跟品質" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147880/149.wav", + "text": "有沒有足夠因為這個太重要了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147880/150.wav", + "text": "真的要動用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147880/151.wav", + "text": "很多的方式資源" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147880/152.wav", + "text": "不是你只想那一兩個問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147880/153.wav", + "text": "我們有很多可以做的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147880/154.wav", + "text": "我也關心中高齡及高齡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147880/155.wav", + "text": "特別是在未來中高齡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147880/156.wav", + "text": "我們現在的定義是45歲以上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147880/157.wav", + "text": "45歲到64歲" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147880/158.wav", + "text": "是中高齡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147880/159.wav", + "text": "65歲以上是高齡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147880/160.wav", + "text": "關心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147880/161.wav", + "text": "啦當然健康的照顧要從" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147880/162.wav", + "text": "年輕時生活習慣的改變" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147880/163.wav", + "text": "這是不變的道理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147880/164.wav", + "text": "但是畢竟在中高齡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147880/165.wav", + "text": "高齡還是比較需要有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147880/166.wav", + "text": "具體的一個措施" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147880/167.wav", + "text": "這部分我想未來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147880/168.wav", + "text": "今天因為時間的關係會後提供給我這部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147880/169.wav", + "text": "你們做了哪些事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147880/170.wav", + "text": "在中高齡及高齡的就業" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147880/171.wav", + "text": "部分其實還是有他的困難" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147880/172.wav", + "text": "我先聲明過去幾年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147880/173.wav", + "text": "包括上一屆我們在討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147880/174.wav", + "text": "中高齡的時候我們還是擔心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147880/175.wav", + "text": "你一直留任他" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147880/176.wav", + "text": "會不會影響到年輕人的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147880/177.wav", + "text": "升遷機會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147880/178.wav", + "text": "到底有哪些工作" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147880/179.wav", + "text": "會適合我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147880/180.wav", + "text": "中高齡高齡或再就業者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147880/181.wav", + "text": "要把它列出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147880/182.wav", + "text": "這樣才不會搶到年輕人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147880/183.wav", + "text": "要做的工作" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147880/184.wav", + "text": "嘛現在年輕人可能不想做的工作" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147880/185.wav", + "text": "我們中高齡還可以做的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147880/186.wav", + "text": "有哪些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147880/187.wav", + "text": "就安排這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147880/188.wav", + "text": "而且大家比較甘願" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147880/189.wav", + "text": "這個部分部長有什麼看法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147880/190.wav", + "text": "因為我們認為中高齡高齡者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147880/191.wav", + "text": "應該是要跟著年輕的一代" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147880/192.wav", + "text": "大家一起合作" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147880/193.wav", + "text": "所以我們說世代合作青銀共融" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147880/194.wav", + "text": "中高齡高齡者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147880/195.wav", + "text": "他們主要是技術經驗" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147880/196.wav", + "text": "人際關係可能會比" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147880/197.wav", + "text": "年輕人好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147880/198.wav", + "text": "但是年輕人可能是創意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147880/199.wav", + "text": "還有一些新的科技" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147880/200.wav", + "text": "在工作上會有區別" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147880/201.wav", + "text": "對但是這個區別我一直" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147880/202.wav", + "text": "沒有看出來是哪些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147880/203.wav", + "text": "媒合合適的會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147880/204.wav", + "text": "這個其實在我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147880/205.wav", + "text": "全國各就業服務中心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147880/206.wav", + "text": "因為這個不只在勞工" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147880/207.wav", + "text": "在很多的職場其實都會發生這種事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147880/208.wav", + "text": "那都要靠老闆的智慧" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147880/209.wav", + "text": "或領導團隊的智慧" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147880/210.wav", + "text": "我覺得國家應該" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147880/211.wav", + "text": "接納我們的中高齡高齡者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147880/212.wav", + "text": "這個部分也希望未來能夠看得到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147880/213.wav", + "text": "能夠看得到這樣的一個規劃好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147880/214.wav", + "text": "更具體的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147880/215.wav", + "text": "今天也提到很多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147880/216.wav", + "text": "怎麼樣協助" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147880/217.wav", + "text": "這個部分今天你在報告的後面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147880/218.wav", + "text": "也有提到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147880/219.wav", + "text": "我想這個部分是很重要我們一起來努力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147880/220.wav", + "text": "好謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147880/221.wav", + "text": "謝謝委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147879/0.wav", + "text": "部長早安" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147879/1.wav", + "text": "天我們討論四個問題好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147879/2.wav", + "text": "我們今天探討這四個問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147879/3.wav", + "text": "\n部長我請問一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147879/4.wav", + "text": "農業部在明年度的預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147879/5.wav", + "text": "農業管理─動物保護管理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147879/6.wav", + "text": "你們新增了113年到116年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147879/7.wav", + "text": "建置我國寵物管理及產業健全發展計畫對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147879/8.wav", + "text": "對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147879/9.wav", + "text": "好所以有想到寵物" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147879/10.wav", + "text": "113年到116年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147879/11.wav", + "text": "寵物管理的發展計畫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147879/12.wav", + "text": "有想到寵物" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147879/13.wav", + "text": "有啊我們當然有想到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147879/14.wav", + "text": "對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147879/15.wav", + "text": "有想到寵物那流浪狗呢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147879/16.wav", + "text": "我想在一個動物保護的過程中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147879/17.wav", + "text": "寵物管理是一個區塊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147879/18.wav", + "text": "寵物的話你是花了113年到116年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147879/19.wav", + "text": "你看這整整幾年的時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147879/20.wav", + "text": "4年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147879/21.wav", + "text": "對所以你有4年的產業健全發展計畫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147879/22.wav", + "text": "所以流浪狗是要健全發展" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147879/23.wav", + "text": "報告委員我們是推動友善動物社會的中程計畫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147879/24.wav", + "text": "這部分也是4年計畫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147879/25.wav", + "text": "4年計畫做了什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147879/26.wav", + "text": "程是從民國幾年開始這個4年計畫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147879/27.wav", + "text": "基本上是從108年開始" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147879/28.wav", + "text": "要結束了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147879/29.wav", + "text": "要進入第二期" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147879/30.wav", + "text": "現在是進入第二期" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147879/31.wav", + "text": "所以第一期已經結束了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147879/32.wav", + "text": "對應該是到今年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147879/33.wav", + "text": "好到今年現在已經年末了嘛對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147879/34.wav", + "text": "那你第一期的計畫做得怎麼樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147879/35.wav", + "text": "野狗有沒有減少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147879/36.wav", + "text": "以目前我們的統計數字大概" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147879/37.wav", + "text": "還是要健全發展" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147879/38.wav", + "text": "大概維持在15萬5,000到16萬之間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147879/39.wav", + "text": "是增加還是減少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147879/40.wav", + "text": "是逐年增加還是逐年減少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147879/41.wav", + "text": "趨勢上來講還是維持平穩大概都是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147879/42.wav", + "text": "平穩" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147879/43.wav", + "text": "你就回答這個問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147879/44.wav", + "text": "不是平穩" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147879/45.wav", + "text": "如果以現在的數量" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147879/46.wav", + "text": "平穩就等於你還是沒有成績" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147879/47.wav", + "text": "啊你就是零" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147879/48.wav", + "text": "啊你還是零" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147879/49.wav", + "text": "還是說你要怎麼去處置牠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147879/50.wav", + "text": "是增加還是減少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147879/51.wav", + "text": "如果流浪狗是減少的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147879/52.wav", + "text": "那說不定可以說有政績" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147879/53.wav", + "text": "啊如果是增加" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147879/54.wav", + "text": "又怎麼交代呢對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147879/55.wav", + "text": "\n部長你看第一段" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147879/56.wav", + "text": "有15萬9,697隻" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147879/57.wav", + "text": "啊調查的結果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147879/58.wav", + "text": "跟2020年比較起來的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147879/59.wav", + "text": "是增加了2.46%" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147879/60.wav", + "text": "只有800多隻" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147879/61.wav", + "text": "將近16萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147879/62.wav", + "text": "結果你的收容所不到1萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147879/63.wav", + "text": "那其他呢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147879/64.wav", + "text": "其他的狗跑到哪裡去了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147879/65.wav", + "text": "花了這麼大的心思啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147879/66.wav", + "text": "那流浪狗呢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147879/67.wav", + "text": "流浪狗呢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147879/68.wav", + "text": "\n我們再看一看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147879/69.wav", + "text": "你看看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147879/70.wav", + "text": "沒有辦法在年度完成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147879/71.wav", + "text": "我知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147879/72.wav", + "text": "不是多次流標" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147879/73.wav", + "text": "就是前置作業延宕" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147879/74.wav", + "text": "都沒有辦法在年度內完成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147879/75.wav", + "text": "所以歲出保留數" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147879/76.wav", + "text": "你保留了多少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147879/77.wav", + "text": "9,144萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147879/78.wav", + "text": "是你當年度法定預算的比例都要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147879/79.wav", + "text": "超過五成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147879/80.wav", + "text": "會不會離譜啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147879/81.wav", + "text": "會不會離譜" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147879/82.wav", + "text": "依我看起來是離譜的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147879/83.wav", + "text": "我們之前有在檢討有關於" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147879/84.wav", + "text": "最主要是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147879/85.wav", + "text": "不是這個都是問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147879/86.wav", + "text": "這個問題也是老問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147879/87.wav", + "text": "但是部長我的意思就是說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147879/88.wav", + "text": "即使是老掉牙的問題你還是要處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147879/89.wav", + "text": "這個我們都清楚譬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147879/90.wav", + "text": "收容所的量能不足" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147879/91.wav", + "text": "到末端野生動物" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147879/92.wav", + "text": "我覺得以動物管理上來講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147879/93.wav", + "text": "農業部好像太著重於" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147879/94.wav", + "text": "因為動保法的通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147879/95.wav", + "text": "所以重點都放在寵物" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147879/96.wav", + "text": "反而是流浪狗這一塊的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147879/97.wav", + "text": "我們是看不到的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147879/98.wav", + "text": "我是要提醒部長這一點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147879/99.wav", + "text": "我我覺得輕重分不清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147879/100.wav", + "text": "你要解決我們的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147879/101.wav", + "text": "流浪狗的問題不先處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147879/102.wav", + "text": "寵物有主人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147879/103.wav", + "text": "好的不然它就不叫寵物" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147879/104.wav", + "text": "一家一家在開" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147879/105.wav", + "text": "連我們農業縣雲林縣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147879/106.wav", + "text": "我也發現最近新開了好多家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147879/107.wav", + "text": "寵物店" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147879/108.wav", + "text": "那流浪狗呢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147879/109.wav", + "text": "提醒就這個部分我想流浪犬的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147879/110.wav", + "text": "我們應該要不能說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147879/111.wav", + "text": "寵物的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147879/112.wav", + "text": "你應該訂出目標" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147879/113.wav", + "text": "就明年度年底來講的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147879/114.wav", + "text": "你預計流浪狗要少多少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147879/115.wav", + "text": "收容所要蓋多少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147879/116.wav", + "text": "我會來加強" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147879/117.wav", + "text": "請問一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147879/118.wav", + "text": "農保排富條款已經" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147879/119.wav", + "text": "訂了多久" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147879/120.wav", + "text": "這個規定訂了多久" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147879/121.wav", + "text": "中間應該有過一些檢討" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147879/122.wav", + "text": "曾經有過檢討" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147879/123.wav", + "text": "那麼這個不動產方面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147879/124.wav", + "text": "已經訂了幾年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147879/125.wav", + "text": "呱啦一大堆就對了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147879/126.wav", + "text": "我們在107年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147879/127.wav", + "text": "好個人的話所有的土地及房屋的價值" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147879/128.wav", + "text": "合計達500萬以上的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147879/129.wav", + "text": "就不能領取老農津貼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147879/130.wav", + "text": "然後我的晚年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147879/131.wav", + "text": "我的不動產不可以超過500萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147879/132.wav", + "text": "你想想看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147879/133.wav", + "text": "現在500萬以下的不動產" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147879/134.wav", + "text": "會長成什麼樣子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147879/135.wav", + "text": "現在的時代" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147879/136.wav", + "text": "以我們鄉下好了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147879/137.wav", + "text": "如果不超過500萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147879/138.wav", + "text": "我請問那個不動產會長什麼樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147879/139.wav", + "text": "我就請問部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147879/140.wav", + "text": "就在鄉下地方" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147879/141.wav", + "text": "你的不動產不要超過500萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147879/142.wav", + "text": "要在500萬以下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147879/143.wav", + "text": "如果500萬以上的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147879/144.wav", + "text": "你就不能領取老農津貼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147879/145.wav", + "text": "長什麼樣子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147879/146.wav", + "text": "以現在的房屋價格來講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147879/147.wav", + "text": "是有一些困難的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147879/148.wav", + "text": "是有可以檢討的空間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147879/149.wav", + "text": "好請部長檢討好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147879/150.wav", + "text": "好謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147879/151.wav", + "text": "這個檢討要有時效給我" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147879/152.wav", + "text": "反正我會一直盯著" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147879/153.wav", + "text": "我是不好意思問你" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147879/154.wav", + "text": "你可不可以下個月給我答案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147879/155.wav", + "text": "好如果同步的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147879/156.wav", + "text": "我就等你的同步好了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147879/157.wav", + "text": "如果有這種情形" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147879/158.wav", + "text": "還不能達到災害補助" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147879/159.wav", + "text": "我們今天會四方會勘" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147879/160.wav", + "text": "會四方會勘" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147879/161.wav", + "text": "四個單位就對了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147879/162.wav", + "text": "要去會勘嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147879/163.wav", + "text": "為什麼今天才會勘" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147879/164.wav", + "text": "我都不斷地反映" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147879/165.wav", + "text": "上個禮拜" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147879/166.wav", + "text": "就已經有災害" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147879/167.wav", + "text": "了不可能今天它是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147879/168.wav", + "text": "我跟委員報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147879/169.wav", + "text": "我們農業部本身的跟所署跟分署很快" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147879/170.wav", + "text": "可是相對在認定的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147879/171.wav", + "text": "還要縣市政府還要公所這邊的人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147879/172.wav", + "text": "他們現在有一部分在勘災" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147879/173.wav", + "text": "有一部分可能因為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147879/174.wav", + "text": "特殊的關係他不來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147879/175.wav", + "text": "不來就沒辦法啟動這樣的會勘" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147879/176.wav", + "text": "所以我們就儘量安排" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147879/177.wav", + "text": "部長今年這個小犬颱風" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147879/178.wav", + "text": "對雲林縣來講是雙重" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147879/179.wav", + "text": "的第一重是無" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147879/180.wav", + "text": "無電" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147879/181.wav", + "text": "即使有水無電一樣沒水" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147879/182.wav", + "text": "所以是兩重的傷害" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147879/183.wav", + "text": "第一沒有電" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147879/184.wav", + "text": "的就是雲林縣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147879/185.wav", + "text": "第二因為沒有電" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147879/186.wav", + "text": "加上小犬颱風17級風" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147879/187.wav", + "text": "所以又受到第二重的傷害" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147879/188.wav", + "text": "我那邊也是最嚴重" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147879/189.wav", + "text": "意思是我們的效率" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147879/190.wav", + "text": "已經趕成這個樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147879/191.wav", + "text": "不會等到縣市政府公告的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147879/192.wav", + "text": "應該是今天下午或明天早上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147879/193.wav", + "text": "有電就沒有水" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147879/194.wav", + "text": "雨風很大會造成什麼傷害" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147879/195.wav", + "text": "第一作物會被吹乾" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147879/196.wav", + "text": "會乾枯對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147879/197.wav", + "text": "設施一定會破掉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147879/198.wav", + "text": "面積達到20%哪一條規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147879/199.wav", + "text": "哪一條的災害救助規" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147879/200.wav", + "text": "規定溫室溫網室的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147879/201.wav", + "text": "應該沒有這個規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147879/202.wav", + "text": "以溫室的設施" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147879/203.wav", + "text": "應該是沒有20%這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147879/204.wav", + "text": "是嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147879/205.wav", + "text": "所以哪有什麼溫室要補助" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147879/206.wav", + "text": "我跟你講光是這件事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147879/207.wav", + "text": "我都被你們搞混掉了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147879/208.wav", + "text": "啦這個邏輯不通" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147879/209.wav", + "text": "我們會去檢討這個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147879/210.wav", + "text": "應該就是全面開放了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147879/211.wav", + "text": "我們回去一定會檢討這個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147879/212.wav", + "text": "因為它不適用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147879/213.wav", + "text": "所以部長你可不可以很清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147879/214.wav", + "text": "地就宣布跟我們講清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147879/215.wav", + "text": "頭沒有任何一個條文規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147879/216.wav", + "text": "所以就沒有所謂的統計" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147879/217.wav", + "text": "也沒有所謂的會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147879/218.wav", + "text": "我瞭解" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147879/219.wav", + "text": "我認同委員的意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147879/220.wav", + "text": "資材受損如果是因為颱風受損的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147879/221.wav", + "text": "如果有受損的話我們會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147879/222.wav", + "text": "依實際的相關金額去做補助" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147879/223.wav", + "text": "好謝謝部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147879/224.wav", + "text": "部長我再請問一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147879/225.wav", + "text": "土壤的碳匯問題當然就會考慮到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147879/226.wav", + "text": "農廢到底品項有哪些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147879/227.wav", + "text": "數量有哪些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147879/228.wav", + "text": "地點都會在哪裡對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147879/229.wav", + "text": "我們也透過書面質詢請" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147879/230.wav", + "text": "請你看一下簡報這是你們給我的資料" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147879/231.wav", + "text": "（以前還是農委會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147879/232.wav", + "text": "）業將完備生物炭分級" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147879/233.wav", + "text": "分類標準" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147879/234.wav", + "text": "然後要建置農剩料" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147879/235.wav", + "text": "資訊的平台以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147879/236.wav", + "text": "提供穩定料源" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147879/237.wav", + "text": "協助料源掌握及再" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147879/238.wav", + "text": "利用之媒合作業" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147879/239.wav", + "text": "做了沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147879/240.wav", + "text": "平台在哪裡在我雲林縣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147879/241.wav", + "text": "你建置在哪裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147879/242.wav", + "text": "我雲林縣的農剩料是什麼品項是什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147879/243.wav", + "text": "數量是多少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147879/244.wav", + "text": "部長不可以再這樣下去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147879/245.wav", + "text": "螺絲釘哪有鬆散到這種程度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147879/246.wav", + "text": "不是這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147879/247.wav", + "text": "嗎如果沒有這些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147879/248.wav", + "text": "農剩料要怎麼發展成生物" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147879/249.wav", + "text": "我瞭解委員一直關心其實" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147879/250.wav", + "text": "農廢料農剩料或者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147879/251.wav", + "text": "農業剩餘資材本身一定要有一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147879/252.wav", + "text": "料源的資訊這樣的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147879/253.wav", + "text": "後面拉才拉得出去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147879/254.wav", + "text": "我們現在已經有規劃好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147879/255.wav", + "text": "但是規劃好以後規劃是一件事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147879/256.wav", + "text": "要實際做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147879/257.wav", + "text": "你們連書都做出來了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147879/258.wav", + "text": "農委會連一本書都做出來了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147879/259.wav", + "text": "做到討論生物" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147879/260.wav", + "text": "實務上應該要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147879/261.wav", + "text": "更積極地去做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147879/262.wav", + "text": "這個業務是誰負責的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147879/263.wav", + "text": "的局處署相關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147879/264.wav", + "text": "農剩料森林的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147879/265.wav", + "text": "有森林的所以才要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147879/266.wav", + "text": "有一個平台這個平台是誰負責" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147879/267.wav", + "text": "是在我們的永續" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147879/268.wav", + "text": "永續司司長是誰" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147879/269.wav", + "text": "請問一下什麼時候可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147879/270.wav", + "text": "把資訊平台做出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147879/271.wav", + "text": "已經規劃好可是還沒有上路" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147879/272.wav", + "text": "之前我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147879/273.wav", + "text": "什麼時候可以上路" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147879/274.wav", + "text": "因為還有很多技術的細節" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147879/275.wav", + "text": "資訊平台的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147879/276.wav", + "text": "現在的那些廢料" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147879/277.wav", + "text": "部長我不跟你談了我就用主決議來處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147879/278.wav", + "text": "謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147878/0.wav", + "text": "有請部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147878/1.wav", + "text": "部長好今天大家都關心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147878/2.wav", + "text": "如果照這樣的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147878/3.wav", + "text": "會不會再過幾年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147878/4.wav", + "text": "勞保就破產" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147878/5.wav", + "text": "其實地方都會這樣講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147878/6.wav", + "text": "我剛剛也看到其他委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147878/7.wav", + "text": "這幾年當中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147878/8.wav", + "text": "還要政府撥補" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147878/9.wav", + "text": "是逐年在增加當中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147878/10.wav", + "text": "因為疫後特別預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147878/11.wav", + "text": "可以撥補到這個大水庫裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147878/12.wav", + "text": "巧慧委員特別提到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147878/13.wav", + "text": "未來如果沒有這樣撥補的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147878/14.wav", + "text": "會不會就造成勞保基金" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147878/15.wav", + "text": "我是不是可以先請" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147878/16.wav", + "text": "部長回答一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147878/17.wav", + "text": "勞工保險是政府辦的保險" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147878/18.wav", + "text": "政府一定會負起" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147878/19.wav", + "text": "最後給付的責任" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147878/20.wav", + "text": "所以這也是我剛剛說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147878/21.wav", + "text": "的有政府就不會倒" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147878/22.wav", + "text": "它的意義在這裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147878/23.wav", + "text": "勞工真的不用擔心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147878/24.wav", + "text": "這件事情已經喊了好多年了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147878/25.wav", + "text": "不管是從整個收支" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147878/26.wav", + "text": "或者費率的提高等等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147878/27.wav", + "text": "我們是以現在可以做的作為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147878/28.wav", + "text": "儘量能夠把基金的財務" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147878/29.wav", + "text": "當然未來的改革" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147878/30.wav", + "text": "也是一定必須去面對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147878/31.wav", + "text": "的但是就誠如剛剛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147878/32.wav", + "text": "牽涉到千萬勞工的權益" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147878/33.wav", + "text": "光投保單位有60萬個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147878/34.wav", + "text": "而且每個勞工" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147878/35.wav", + "text": "各種勞動類型都不同" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147878/36.wav", + "text": "委員很清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147878/37.wav", + "text": "有企業工會產業工會職業工會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147878/38.wav", + "text": "每個勞工的狀況都不同" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147878/39.wav", + "text": "大家去溝通" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147878/40.wav", + "text": "傾聽蒐集各界的意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147878/41.wav", + "text": "有好的想法好的意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147878/42.wav", + "text": "我們都願意廣納進來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147878/43.wav", + "text": "請領勞保年金的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147878/44.wav", + "text": "是提早退休的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147878/45.wav", + "text": "差不多有78%是55歲到65歲" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147878/46.wav", + "text": "以後要65歲才能退休" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147878/47.wav", + "text": "可以利用這樣的延緩" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147878/48.wav", + "text": "鼓勵大家不要提早退休" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147878/49.wav", + "text": "尤其是工會部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147878/50.wav", + "text": "部長可以針對工會部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147878/51.wav", + "text": "做一些宣導" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147878/52.wav", + "text": "平均退休年齡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147878/53.wav", + "text": "是62歲就是今年度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147878/54.wav", + "text": "體力還可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147878/55.wav", + "text": "也想要繼續工作" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147878/56.wav", + "text": "對我們有展延退休的設計" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147878/57.wav", + "text": "所以是有照顧他" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147878/58.wav", + "text": "誘因如果他願意延緩" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147878/59.wav", + "text": "是能有更大的誘因" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147878/60.wav", + "text": "也許我到65歲" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147878/61.wav", + "text": "他有一些技術性的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147878/62.wav", + "text": "能力希望他可以延退" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147878/63.wav", + "text": "再增加一些誘因" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147878/64.wav", + "text": "讓這些體力還可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147878/65.wav", + "text": "再做一些貢獻的人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147878/66.wav", + "text": "可以繼續留在職場" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147878/67.wav", + "text": "發展署針對這種" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147878/68.wav", + "text": "中高齡高齡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147878/69.wav", + "text": "措施也有3年計畫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147878/70.wav", + "text": "這些都是我們的誘因" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147878/71.wav", + "text": "或重返職場" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147878/72.wav", + "text": "在退休的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147878/73.wav", + "text": "有沒有什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147878/74.wav", + "text": "來研究看看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147878/75.wav", + "text": "好接下來我想請教部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147878/76.wav", + "text": "也在立法院這邊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147878/77.wav", + "text": "做了一些抗議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147878/78.wav", + "text": "部長針對這個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147878/79.wav", + "text": "的一個溝通" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147878/80.wav", + "text": "對我們建立一個對話平臺" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147878/81.wav", + "text": "對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147878/82.wav", + "text": "遇有爭議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147878/83.wav", + "text": "我們就會邀請業者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147878/84.wav", + "text": "像上次那個薪酬短少的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147878/85.wav", + "text": "所以他們馬上就暫停而" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147878/86.wav", + "text": "而以原來的為準" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147878/87.wav", + "text": "會有一個對話平臺" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147878/88.wav", + "text": "讓他們雙方有進一步" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147878/89.wav", + "text": "全臺灣外送員有十幾萬人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147878/90.wav", + "text": "是不是有專法可以保障他們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147878/91.wav", + "text": "我想請教部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147878/92.wav", + "text": "報告委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147878/93.wav", + "text": "其實我知道他們很期待" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147878/94.wav", + "text": "有全世界都有外送員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147878/95.wav", + "text": "但目前有專法的只有西班牙" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147878/96.wav", + "text": "事實上實施的效果也沒有很好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147878/97.wav", + "text": "有些是承攬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147878/98.wav", + "text": "有些是僱用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147878/99.wav", + "text": "但你也知道如果要用僱用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147878/100.wav", + "text": "要以勞基法勞工來看待" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147878/101.wav", + "text": "有利的方向去設計" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147878/102.wav", + "text": "我們也希望他是一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147878/103.wav", + "text": "健康安全的勞動者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147878/104.wav", + "text": "所以這個事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147878/105.wav", + "text": "我們現在是認為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147878/106.wav", + "text": "其他的機制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147878/107.wav", + "text": "包括對話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147878/108.wav", + "text": "所以變成你們是一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147878/109.wav", + "text": "兩邊的對溝通的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147878/110.wav", + "text": "外送員的勞動權益" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147878/111.wav", + "text": "不會任意被剝削" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147878/112.wav", + "text": "最後一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147878/113.wav", + "text": "彰化的薪資排名全國倒數" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147878/114.wav", + "text": "因為彰化中小企業最多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147878/115.wav", + "text": "中小企業的老闆也覺得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147878/116.wav", + "text": "職業結構" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147878/117.wav", + "text": "也許這邊大部分是做水五金的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147878/118.wav", + "text": "或者是做輪胎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147878/119.wav", + "text": "的可能他們需要的技術人員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147878/120.wav", + "text": "不太一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147878/121.wav", + "text": "勞動部會針對地區產業的不一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147878/122.wav", + "text": "而特別開這樣的職訓班" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147878/123.wav", + "text": "讓願意留鄉的年輕人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147878/124.wav", + "text": "原本沒有這方面的技術" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147878/125.wav", + "text": "了因為彰化薪資排名全國倒數" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147878/126.wav", + "text": "有報告委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147878/127.wav", + "text": "我們有中彰投分署" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147878/128.wav", + "text": "他們其實都有針對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147878/129.wav", + "text": "轄區的產業特性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147878/130.wav", + "text": "到委員彰化的服務處" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147878/131.wav", + "text": "我請他去跟你說明清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147878/132.wav", + "text": "看看我們有哪些面向沒有照顧到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147878/133.wav", + "text": "卻找不到人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147878/134.wav", + "text": "這個到底要怎麼解決" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147878/135.wav", + "text": "對啊我覺得勞動部一方面應該要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147878/136.wav", + "text": "找不到人有很多因素" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147878/137.wav", + "text": "有時候不一定是勞工" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147878/138.wav", + "text": "有時候是資方" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147878/139.wav", + "text": "問題譬如勞動條件" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147878/140.wav", + "text": "工作環境薪資等等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147878/141.wav", + "text": "會有很多問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147878/142.wav", + "text": "這個沒有關係" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147878/143.wav", + "text": "因為我們其實" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147878/144.wav", + "text": "也可以特地為你量身訂做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147878/145.wav", + "text": "就是說這個業主" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147878/146.wav", + "text": "需要什麼樣的人才" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147878/147.wav", + "text": "然後做一些訓練" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147878/148.wav", + "text": "讓他們有人才可以用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147878/149.wav", + "text": "是就是訓用合一" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147878/150.wav", + "text": "啦針對產業的需求" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147878/151.wav", + "text": "加強技能訓練" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147878/152.wav", + "text": "但是就是說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147878/153.wav", + "text": "會有很多問題需要去釐清" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147878/154.wav", + "text": "這我知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147878/155.wav", + "text": "跟地方政府大家一起配合" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147878/156.wav", + "text": "好不好好好謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147878/157.wav", + "text": "謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147877/0.wav", + "text": "謝謝主席" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147877/1.wav", + "text": "有請財政部莊部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147877/2.wav", + "text": "委員好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147877/3.wav", + "text": "早" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147877/4.wav", + "text": "我追問一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147877/5.wav", + "text": "你上個禮拜在這裡有回答了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147877/6.wav", + "text": "就是這一次的APEC" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147877/7.wav", + "text": "你會去嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147877/8.wav", + "text": "是行政院核了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147877/9.wav", + "text": "APEC財長會議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147877/10.wav", + "text": "是美國的財長葉倫主持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147877/11.wav", + "text": "請問你有沒有機會跟他" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147877/12.wav", + "text": "一對一進行會議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147877/13.wav", + "text": "因為他是主持人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147877/14.wav", + "text": "我們會儘量去跟他接洽" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147877/15.wav", + "text": "有沒有機會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147877/16.wav", + "text": "臺美租稅協議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147877/17.wav", + "text": "雙重減稅" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147877/18.wav", + "text": "有沒有可能" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147877/19.wav", + "text": "跟委員報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147877/20.wav", + "text": "在那個場合" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147877/21.wav", + "text": "也許沒有辦法談細節" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147877/22.wav", + "text": "我們一定會表達希望能夠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147877/23.wav", + "text": "我看到美國參議院通過了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147877/24.wav", + "text": "美臺快速雙重" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147877/25.wav", + "text": "稅收減免法案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147877/26.wav", + "text": "爭取跟他見面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147877/27.wav", + "text": "跟他見面談這個事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147877/28.wav", + "text": "原來是我們急" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147877/29.wav", + "text": "美國不急" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147877/30.wav", + "text": "現在看起來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147877/31.wav", + "text": "美國也急" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147877/32.wav", + "text": "對吧" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147877/33.wav", + "text": "是的沒有錯" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147877/34.wav", + "text": "這樣對對的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147877/35.wav", + "text": "沒錯" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147877/36.wav", + "text": "委員說的是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147877/37.wav", + "text": "因為現在還要經過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147877/38.wav", + "text": "眾議院的院會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147877/39.wav", + "text": "然後再到參議院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147877/40.wav", + "text": "議長都不在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147877/41.wav", + "text": "經簽署以後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147877/42.wav", + "text": "其實我們雙邊簽了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147877/43.wav", + "text": "一個國際文書" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147877/44.wav", + "text": "讓它的這個法案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147877/45.wav", + "text": "跟我們的文書生效" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147877/46.wav", + "text": "明年6月以前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147877/47.wav", + "text": "可不可以期待" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147877/48.wav", + "text": "我們期待是這樣子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147877/49.wav", + "text": "也許" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147877/50.wav", + "text": "明年6月" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147877/51.wav", + "text": "可以簽下來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147877/52.wav", + "text": "簽下來以後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147877/53.wav", + "text": "我們這邊的程序" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147877/54.wav", + "text": "很快可以走完" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147877/55.wav", + "text": "讓雙邊生效" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147877/56.wav", + "text": "因為我們等於是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147877/57.wav", + "text": "一個承諾" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147877/58.wav", + "text": "請問範圍是不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147877/59.wav", + "text": "包括個人和企業" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147877/60.wav", + "text": "現在我們有不少工程師" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147877/61.wav", + "text": "對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147877/62.wav", + "text": "他馬上就要面臨這個問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147877/63.wav", + "text": "這裡要繳稅" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147877/64.wav", + "text": "那邊也要繳稅" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147877/65.wav", + "text": "這次有幾個重點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147877/66.wav", + "text": "第一個就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147877/67.wav", + "text": "還有個人薪資" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147877/68.wav", + "text": "所得的雙重課稅" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147877/69.wav", + "text": "以及企業利潤的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147877/70.wav", + "text": "對這三方面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147877/71.wav", + "text": "因為是我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147877/72.wav", + "text": "臺商在那邊投資所" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147877/73.wav", + "text": "我們的稅收會增加還是減少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147877/74.wav", + "text": "基本上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147877/75.wav", + "text": "我們大概估了一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147877/76.wav", + "text": "在我們臺灣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147877/77.wav", + "text": "也有投資" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147877/78.wav", + "text": "大概266億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147877/79.wav", + "text": "臺商在美國" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147877/80.wav", + "text": "投資是285億美金" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147877/81.wav", + "text": "看起來雙方的金額差距不大" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147877/82.wav", + "text": "所以對稅收部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147877/83.wav", + "text": "因為雙方都是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147877/84.wav", + "text": "課稅權重新分配" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147877/85.wav", + "text": "所以對稅收影響不大" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147877/86.wav", + "text": "但是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147877/87.wav", + "text": "好的租稅環境" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147877/88.wav", + "text": "可以讓" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147877/89.wav", + "text": "美國更多的投資進來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147877/90.wav", + "text": "對我們的稅基" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147877/91.wav", + "text": "事實上是可以擴大" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147877/92.wav", + "text": "可是一般來講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147877/93.wav", + "text": "一大一小" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147877/94.wav", + "text": "美國大我們小" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147877/95.wav", + "text": "一大一小" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147877/96.wav", + "text": "其實都是小的吃虧" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147877/97.wav", + "text": "大的占便宜" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147877/98.wav", + "text": "看了一些法案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147877/99.wav", + "text": "我看過研究報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147877/100.wav", + "text": "也是指" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147877/101.wav", + "text": "是因為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147877/102.wav", + "text": "我們看了一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147877/103.wav", + "text": "調降後的稅率" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147877/104.wav", + "text": "我們跟其他國家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147877/105.wav", + "text": "所簽的租稅協定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147877/106.wav", + "text": "基本上是沒有比較差" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147877/107.wav", + "text": "我們來看今天的題目" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147877/108.wav", + "text": "請主計長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147877/109.wav", + "text": "先請問財政部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147877/110.wav", + "text": "看到受僱人員薪資" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147877/111.wav", + "text": "占GDP的比例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147877/112.wav", + "text": "臺灣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147877/113.wav", + "text": "是逐年下降" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147877/114.wav", + "text": "也指出現在已經降到43" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147877/115.wav", + "text": "%美國日本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147877/116.wav", + "text": "甚至歐盟" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147877/117.wav", + "text": "企業所賺的錢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147877/118.wav", + "text": "但是臺灣的企業" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147877/119.wav", + "text": "已經降到43" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147877/120.wav", + "text": "所以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147877/121.wav", + "text": "鼓勵企業加薪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147877/122.wav", + "text": "很重要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147877/123.wav", + "text": "我個人也有提案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147877/124.wav", + "text": "中小企業的加薪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147877/125.wav", + "text": "當費用乘以130" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147877/126.wav", + "text": "%我要把它提高到200" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147877/127.wav", + "text": "你剛剛提到的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147877/128.wav", + "text": "是中小企業條例裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147877/129.wav", + "text": "對於基層員工加薪的��薪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147877/130.wav", + "text": "對加薪幅度的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147877/131.wav", + "text": "%我要把它擴大為乘以200" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147877/132.wav", + "text": "這個部分剛剛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147877/133.wav", + "text": "經濟部也報告過了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147877/134.wav", + "text": "經濟部已經針對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147877/135.wav", + "text": "適用的範圍" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147877/136.wav", + "text": "以及對象" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147877/137.wav", + "text": "委員所提到的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147877/138.wav", + "text": "加成減除" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147877/139.wav", + "text": "除的部分要提高" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147877/140.wav", + "text": "是不是也一起" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147877/141.wav", + "text": "你們現在有沒有腹案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147877/142.wav", + "text": "我們要不要再延" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147877/143.wav", + "text": "為200%可以嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147877/144.wav", + "text": "報告委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147877/145.wav", + "text": "我們的方向是繼續延長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147877/146.wav", + "text": "延長幾年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147877/147.wav", + "text": "這個要再諮商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147877/148.wav", + "text": "諮商我們要跟財政部來討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147877/149.wav", + "text": "原來是幾年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147877/150.wav", + "text": "到明年5月19日落日" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147877/151.wav", + "text": "再延10年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147877/152.wav", + "text": "是不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147877/153.wav", + "text": "這個我們要討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147877/154.wav", + "text": "但是我們方向上是要延長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147877/155.wav", + "text": "讓它繼續有效" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147877/156.wav", + "text": "幅度增加" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147877/157.wav", + "text": "這個誘因才足夠啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147877/158.wav", + "text": "我看你的申請家數很少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147877/159.wav", + "text": "對吧" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147877/160.wav", + "text": "我們會朝正面來思考" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147877/161.wav", + "text": "部長你要不要告訴我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147877/162.wav", + "text": "家數很少啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147877/163.wav", + "text": "家數是不多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147877/164.wav", + "text": "大概只有100多家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147877/165.wav", + "text": "金也很少啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147877/166.wav", + "text": "不讓他回答" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147877/167.wav", + "text": "稅多少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147877/168.wav", + "text": "什麼東西多少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147877/169.wav", + "text": "稅的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147877/170.wav", + "text": "減少多少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147877/171.wav", + "text": "因為這樣子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147877/172.wav", + "text": "稅減少多少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147877/173.wav", + "text": "我所知道只有幾億而已" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147877/174.wav", + "text": "但是那個味道不一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147877/175.wav", + "text": "因為130%的幅度不夠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147877/176.wav", + "text": "可以吧" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147877/177.wav", + "text": "這個部分我們再一起討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147877/178.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147877/179.wav", + "text": "問主計長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147877/180.wav", + "text": "中小企業大部分都是查定課徵" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147877/181.wav", + "text": "所以那個辦法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147877/182.wav", + "text": "適用的人會比較少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147877/183.wav", + "text": "200%以後就會多了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147877/184.wav", + "text": "我們來看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147877/185.wav", + "text": "計總處公布的數字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147877/186.wav", + "text": "臺灣現在平均薪資多少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147877/187.wav", + "text": "現在大概是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147877/188.wav", + "text": "你知道有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147877/189.wav", + "text": "68%" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147877/190.wav", + "text": "的人領不到平均薪資" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147877/191.wav", + "text": "總薪資大概是五萬多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147877/192.wav", + "text": "那是包含年終獎金" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147877/193.wav", + "text": "這個就是嚴重的地方" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147877/194.wav", + "text": "貧富差距越來越嚴重" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147877/195.wav", + "text": "連薪資也是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147877/196.wav", + "text": "領高的越來越高" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147877/197.wav", + "text": "都很高" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147877/198.wav", + "text": "可是一般民生消費" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147877/199.wav", + "text": "的行業都很低" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147877/200.wav", + "text": "這是一個很嚴重的事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147877/201.wav", + "text": "因此我要請教你" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147877/202.wav", + "text": "我們看到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147877/203.wav", + "text": "最近工業" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147877/204.wav", + "text": "製造生產指數" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147877/205.wav", + "text": "年減7%" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147877/206.wav", + "text": "外銷也13黑" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147877/207.wav", + "text": "今年GDP" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147877/208.wav", + "text": "2是不太可能" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147877/209.wav", + "text": "在1%以上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147877/210.wav", + "text": "你可不可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147877/211.wav", + "text": "來打包票" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147877/212.wav", + "text": "保證1%以上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147877/213.wav", + "text": "我不能夠打包票" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147877/214.wav", + "text": "因為這是國民所得統計" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147877/215.wav", + "text": "評審委員會去評審" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147877/216.wav", + "text": "異常能力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147877/217.wav", + "text": "保1幾乎等於沒有了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147877/218.wav", + "text": "保1幾乎等於沒有成長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147877/219.wav", + "text": "CPI又一直持續上升" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147877/220.wav", + "text": "一個百分點的成長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147877/221.wav", + "text": "原來一開始" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147877/222.wav", + "text": "現在又講2%已經沒有了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147877/223.wav", + "text": "所以你們講的話是自打嘴巴" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147877/224.wav", + "text": "現在怎麼樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147877/225.wav", + "text": "1.6%1.7%左右" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147877/226.wav", + "text": "可是這個月" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147877/227.wav", + "text": "是2.75" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147877/228.wav", + "text": "對現在大概是2.14%左右" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147877/229.wav", + "text": "大家擔心的二次通膨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147877/230.wav", + "text": "會不會發生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147877/231.wav", + "text": "我沒有聽過二次通膨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147877/232.wav", + "text": "通膨是一年算一次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147877/233.wav", + "text": "沒有所謂二次通膨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147877/234.wav", + "text": "有了現在再來一次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147877/235.wav", + "text": "通膨是多少才算通膨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147877/236.wav", + "text": "所以現在沒有停滯性通膨的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147877/237.wav", + "text": "我們的經濟還在成長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147877/238.wav", + "text": "1%算成長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147877/239.wav", + "text": "現在在打流感疫苗" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147877/240.wav", + "text": "我們看到很多的縣市" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147877/241.wav", + "text": "我相信很多立委在跑攤都有看到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147877/242.wav", + "text": "他們現在不要打高端" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147877/243.wav", + "text": "高端買了70萬劑" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147877/244.wav", + "text": "如果打不完又要銷毀" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147877/245.wav", + "text": "而且" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147877/246.wav", + "text": "現在打電話去診所" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147877/247.wav", + "text": "詢問都說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147877/248.wav", + "text": "其他的沒有了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147877/249.wav", + "text": "只有高端" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147877/250.wav", + "text": "強迫打高端" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147877/251.wav", + "text": "結果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147877/252.wav", + "text": "這種情況之下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147877/253.wav", + "text": "我就請教你" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147877/254.wav", + "text": "如果打不完銷毀這個事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147877/255.wav", + "text": "你要不要查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147877/256.wav", + "text": "我們都會瞭解" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147877/257.wav", + "text": "第二個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147877/258.wav", + "text": "你有沒有去查一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147877/259.wav", + "text": "為什麼衛福部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147877/260.wav", + "text": "這麼體貼照顧高端" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147877/261.wav", + "text": "高端1月到7月的營業額" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147877/262.wav", + "text": "是零" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147877/263.wav", + "text": "8月份下了70萬劑" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147877/264.wav", + "text": "它有一億多的收入" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147877/265.wav", + "text": "個公司這個樣子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147877/266.wav", + "text": "它是跟韓國GC公司" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147877/267.wav", + "text": "合作GC公司是不錯的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147877/268.wav", + "text": "那你直接進口GC" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147877/269.wav", + "text": "的疫苗" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147877/270.wav", + "text": "給它進來包裝分裝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147877/271.wav", + "text": "然後給它賺一手" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147877/272.wav", + "text": "為什麼這個樣子這裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147877/273.wav", + "text": "你要不要去瞭解一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147877/274.wav", + "text": "我們要瞭解它整個採購" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147877/275.wav", + "text": "這個不會再" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147877/276.wav", + "text": "封存30年吧" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147877/277.wav", + "text": "這個應該沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147877/278.wav", + "text": "今天老實講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147877/279.wav", + "text": "專門做疫苗的公司" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147877/280.wav", + "text": "它認真做我們就" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147877/281.wav", + "text": "鼓勵" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147877/282.wav", + "text": "但這是讓這個政府把它弄壞的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147877/283.wav", + "text": "過去那個 COVID-19的疫苗" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147877/284.wav", + "text": "30年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147877/285.wav", + "text": "造成大家怕" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147877/286.wav", + "text": "這裡面太黑箱了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147877/287.wav", + "text": "所以高端整個被污名化" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147877/288.wav", + "text": "就是衛福部自己" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147877/289.wav", + "text": "種的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147877/290.wav", + "text": "大家看到高端就怕" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147877/291.wav", + "text": "現在也是一樣啊為什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147877/292.wav", + "text": "你不直接從韓國進來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147877/293.wav", + "text": "就好了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147877/294.wav", + "text": "既然是好的疫苗" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147877/295.wav", + "text": "也通過三期什麼之類的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147877/296.wav", + "text": "就敢打但卻要經過高端" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147877/297.wav", + "text": "大家就怕為什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147877/298.wav", + "text": "就是這個政府把它弄壞" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147877/299.wav", + "text": "了今天的高端被污名化" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147877/300.wav", + "text": "它要怪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147877/301.wav", + "text": "要怪民進黨政府" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147877/302.wav", + "text": "謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147876/0.wav", + "text": "謝謝主席" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147876/1.wav", + "text": "我想請部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147876/2.wav", + "text": "有請潘部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147876/3.wav", + "text": "部長辛苦了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147876/4.wav", + "text": "每個禮拜都來我們立法院值班" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147876/5.wav", + "text": "大家有太多的問題要詢問您" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147876/6.wav", + "text": "期待部裡面的大力支持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147876/7.wav", + "text": "因為今天的時間比較短" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147876/8.wav", + "text": "所以我可能講快一點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147876/9.wav", + "text": "的聘用不足感到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147876/10.wav", + "text": "感到很擔憂" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147876/11.wav", + "text": "甚至還蓋宿舍留人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147876/12.wav", + "text": "我覺得這都是中央跟地方協力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147876/13.wav", + "text": "非常好的一些範例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147876/14.wav", + "text": "特別是我們在2017年的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147876/15.wav", + "text": "教育發展條例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147876/16.wav", + "text": "我們有專案聘任" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147876/17.wav", + "text": "經過調查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147876/18.wav", + "text": "學校的老師也告訴我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147876/19.wav", + "text": "學校的可用資源" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147876/20.wav", + "text": "教師研習的資源" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147876/21.wav", + "text": "都有明顯改善" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147876/22.wav", + "text": "我覺得這就是政策非常有力道的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147876/23.wav", + "text": "\n但我們也看到另一個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147876/24.wav", + "text": "就是老師的行政loading" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147876/25.wav", + "text": "並沒有改變" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147876/26.wav", + "text": "達77%的人都說沒有改變" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147876/27.wav", + "text": "或者變得更差" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147876/28.wav", + "text": "因為偏鄉學校的老師大概就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147876/29.wav", + "text": "12到13人而已" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147876/30.wav", + "text": "他要負責教學" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147876/31.wav", + "text": "又要負責輔導" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147876/32.wav", + "text": "又要負責總務這些等等的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147876/33.wav", + "text": "所以對他們來說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147876/34.wav", + "text": "擔任行政工作就是一個最主要的負擔" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147876/35.wav", + "text": "在聯合報2023年的抽樣調查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147876/36.wav", + "text": "有447份" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147876/37.wav", + "text": "發現老師不留任的一個原因" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147876/38.wav", + "text": "他不願意留任" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147876/39.wav", + "text": "跟非山非市的學校" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147876/40.wav", + "text": "有新增一個經費作業要點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147876/41.wav", + "text": "就可以增加1名行政人員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147876/42.wav", + "text": "但我想請問部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147876/43.wav", + "text": "您覺得現在有多少偏鄉學校" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147876/44.wav", + "text": "有嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147876/45.wav", + "text": "的班級數未達7班" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147876/46.wav", + "text": "但是你覺得有幫助到他們嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147876/47.wav", + "text": "委員所提的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147876/48.wav", + "text": "其實我們還會考慮到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147876/49.wav", + "text": "現在在做法上委員剛剛提的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147876/50.wav", + "text": "當時設置這個條例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147876/51.wav", + "text": "本來就希望有外加的一些措施" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147876/52.wav", + "text": "包含我們思考合理員額編制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147876/53.wav", + "text": "也是一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147876/54.wav", + "text": "不是全部同樣都用增加人力的概念" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147876/55.wav", + "text": "合理員額編制在偏鄉總共增加大概2,000位人力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147876/56.wav", + "text": "我告訴你有1,062" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147876/57.wav", + "text": "並沒有因為您的這個條例而受惠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147876/58.wav", + "text": "更糟糕的是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147876/59.wav", + "text": "對不起我直接講更糟糕的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147876/60.wav", + "text": "其實您在108年的���候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147876/61.wav", + "text": "這個措施已經告訴我們7班以上才有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147876/62.wav", + "text": "本來就是7班以上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147876/63.wav", + "text": "可以多1個行政人力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147876/64.wav", + "text": "可是偏鄉7班以上的本來就少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147876/65.wav", + "text": "有新增這個條例根本形同虛設" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147876/66.wav", + "text": "這個問題是在這裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147876/67.wav", + "text": "對不對您自己看一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147876/68.wav", + "text": "這兩個都是7班以上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147876/69.wav", + "text": "所以真的沒有幫助到他們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147876/70.wav", + "text": "感覺是有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147876/71.wav", + "text": "因為非山非市偏鄉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147876/72.wav", + "text": "其實各有協助的重點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147876/73.wav", + "text": "在偏鄉條例裡的偏鄉學校" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147876/74.wav", + "text": "我剛剛跟委員報告的合理員額編制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147876/75.wav", + "text": "尤其國中的部分更嚴重" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147876/76.wav", + "text": "因為國中要專長任教" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147876/77.wav", + "text": "老師總數根本都達不到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147876/78.wav", + "text": "每個領域可以有專長老師" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147876/79.wav", + "text": "我們增加的是不同的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147876/80.wav", + "text": "所以不叫做行政人力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147876/81.wav", + "text": "但是但事實上他們的loading還是重的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147876/82.wav", + "text": "這一點我一定承認" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147876/83.wav", + "text": "因為學校的結構就是這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147876/84.wav", + "text": "麻雀雖小五臟俱全" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147876/85.wav", + "text": "這部分我跟委員報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147876/86.wav", + "text": "為什麼我們一直在發展電腦化相關的系統" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147876/87.wav", + "text": "大家都不想做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147876/88.wav", + "text": "所以去做電腦化系統" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147876/89.wav", + "text": "因為大家都不想當主管" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147876/90.wav", + "text": "委員這部分我也在每年的局處長會議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147876/91.wav", + "text": "提出來因為我們要從行政機關檢討起" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147876/92.wav", + "text": "即使是老師兼行政" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147876/93.wav", + "text": "也都會碰到同樣的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147876/94.wav", + "text": "大家都不想兼行政" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147876/95.wav", + "text": "嘛我們現在看到的是最新的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147876/96.wav", + "text": "今年10月初才看到的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147876/97.wav", + "text": "本來是錄取率四成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147876/98.wav", + "text": "變成報名率四成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147876/99.wav", + "text": "因為大家都不想做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147876/100.wav", + "text": "最大的一個問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147876/101.wav", + "text": "你看看組長的加給" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147876/102.wav", + "text": "就可以到5,300" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147876/103.wav", + "text": "主任加給也是5,300但" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147876/104.wav", + "text": "但還要經���考試" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147876/105.wav", + "text": "他必須要有主任的經驗" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147876/106.wav", + "text": "可是如果人家連主任都不想做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147876/107.wav", + "text": "未來我們就變成校長荒了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147876/108.wav", + "text": "對不起我時間真的不夠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147876/109.wav", + "text": "並解決他們的行政loading" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147876/110.wav", + "text": "未來擔任主任能不能增加一些誘因" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147876/111.wav", + "text": "讓大家願意做這件工" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147876/112.wav", + "text": "作當然部長有提到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147876/113.wav", + "text": "可以減少他們的行政loading" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147876/114.wav", + "text": "可是最大的一個問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147876/115.wav", + "text": "是最新的人就會被委派" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147876/116.wav", + "text": "因為沒有人要做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147876/117.wav", + "text": "嘛所以對他們來說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147876/118.wav", + "text": "既要適應新的任務" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147876/119.wav", + "text": "然後又要做這些電腦化" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147876/120.wav", + "text": "的工作反而是增加一些loading" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147876/121.wav", + "text": "解決一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147876/122.wav", + "text": "\n我還有兩題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147876/123.wav", + "text": "我非常謝謝彭署長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147876/124.wav", + "text": "我3月提出這個問題以後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147876/125.wav", + "text": "而且他也非常阿莎力地" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147876/126.wav", + "text": "由他來協調地方教育局" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147876/127.wav", + "text": "可以執登在教育局" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147876/128.wav", + "text": "甚至也發函給所有學校" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147876/129.wav", + "text": "他可以行政職代" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147876/130.wav", + "text": "還是有很大的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147876/131.wav", + "text": "就是什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147876/132.wav", + "text": "薪資嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147876/133.wav", + "text": "剛剛張廖萬堅委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147876/134.wav", + "text": "當你的時薪低到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147876/135.wav", + "text": "人家都不願意來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147876/136.wav", + "text": "學校的校護根本沒有辦法請假" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147876/137.wav", + "text": "開過協調會以後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147876/138.wav", + "text": "問了所有的地方教育局" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147876/139.wav", + "text": "結果回復" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147876/140.wav", + "text": "就停在這裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147876/141.wav", + "text": "沒有後續了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147876/142.wav", + "text": "所以我是不是再請大家研議一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147876/143.wav", + "text": "我們不能事情做一半" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147876/144.wav", + "text": "啊雖然只有一個地方有意願" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147876/145.wav", + "text": "然後後面呢我們有沒有什麼樣的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147876/146.wav", + "text": "誘因再去push" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147876/147.wav", + "text": "其他現在能夠做的事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147876/148.wav", + "text": "好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147876/149.wav", + "text": "��就已經承諾了但現在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147876/150.wav", + "text": "看起來就是停在這裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147876/151.wav", + "text": "我們上次講了以後你們就立刻辦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147876/152.wav", + "text": "我真的覺得這個其實就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147876/153.wav", + "text": "立院和行政最好的配合" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147876/154.wav", + "text": "\n彭署長我們再繼續加油好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147876/155.wav", + "text": "我還有一題對不起" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147876/156.wav", + "text": "我上禮拜有請教過部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147876/157.wav", + "text": "部長也說會全力配合" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147876/158.wav", + "text": "提到在護理人力的招生上面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147876/159.wav", + "text": "應該要有一些具體策略" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147876/160.wav", + "text": "如果現在要針對科大或普大" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147876/161.wav", + "text": "再外加10%" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147876/162.wav", + "text": "其實學校老師是壓力很大的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147876/163.wav", + "text": "所以昨天劉政次和楊次長來了以後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147876/164.wav", + "text": "就說不能只針對護理來補助" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147876/165.wav", + "text": "那怎麼辦呢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147876/166.wav", + "text": "現在行政院給你的目標就是這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147876/167.wav", + "text": "啊你不能告訴我那怎麼辦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147876/168.wav", + "text": "而是應該要有具體的方案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147876/169.wav", + "text": "才對所以是不是請部長想想" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147876/170.wav", + "text": "看還有沒有針對護理系招生缺額" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147876/171.wav", + "text": "更重要的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147876/172.wav", + "text": "還有增加公職護理師的比例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147876/173.wav", + "text": "我想請問一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147876/174.wav", + "text": "在座有成大附醫的李院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147876/175.wav", + "text": "臺大附醫的吳院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147876/176.wav", + "text": "還有陽大附醫的副院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147876/177.wav", + "text": "貴院公職護理師的比例有多少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147876/178.wav", + "text": "有沒有辦法達到衛福部提到的五成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147876/179.wav", + "text": "公職護理師的比例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147876/180.wav", + "text": "可以到五成嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147876/181.wav", + "text": "這個是行政院的目標" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147876/182.wav", + "text": "當時在行政院跨部會的討論裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147876/183.wav", + "text": "大家會用最大的力量來往前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147876/184.wav", + "text": "那是榮總嘛不管" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147876/185.wav", + "text": "啦我們現在是教育部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147876/186.wav", + "text": "不這個是行政院跨部會的要求" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147876/187.wav", + "text": "因為我們公立學校的醫院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147876/188.wav", + "text": "就3所而已" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147876/189.wav", + "text": "本身也會跟著行政院這個規範" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147876/190.wav", + "text": "我們會跟著行政院的規範" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147876/191.wav", + "text": "我跟委員補充報告一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147876/192.wav", + "text": "像學校護理師的相關待遇" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147876/193.wav", + "text": "這涉及跟地方的協調" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147876/194.wav", + "text": "這個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147876/195.wav", + "text": "了啊這當然就是中央提供一些誘因" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147876/196.wav", + "text": "地方就會來做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147876/197.wav", + "text": "所有的教育經費" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147876/198.wav", + "text": "我們能做的事情就不多了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147876/199.wav", + "text": "沒有沒有我現在只是說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147876/200.wav", + "text": "中央有一些誘因來做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147876/201.wav", + "text": "但是像代理教師也是一步一步向前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147876/202.wav", + "text": "我要跟委員講的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147876/203.wav", + "text": "是這不是效率的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147876/204.wav", + "text": "如果中央只下達指令" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147876/205.wav", + "text": "給地方做當地方不做的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147876/206.wav", + "text": "這個事情也不會算完" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147876/207.wav", + "text": "我覺得楊司長跟劉政次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147876/208.wav", + "text": "很多時候是中央給紅蘿蔔就好了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147876/209.wav", + "text": "我們沒有要中央全部做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147876/210.wav", + "text": "前面講到現在學校護理師職" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147876/211.wav", + "text": "我想這幾年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147876/212.wav", + "text": "中央和地方的教育事務" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147876/213.wav", + "text": "一步一步向前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147876/214.wav", + "text": "是因為大家能夠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147876/215.wav", + "text": "不是下指令就能做事" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147876/216.wav", + "text": "至於剛才委員提到的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147876/217.wav", + "text": "增設這些科系的護理師" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147876/218.wav", + "text": "不是二技喔" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147876/219.wav", + "text": "是四年制的科大和普大" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147876/220.wav", + "text": "有跟我在討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147876/221.wav", + "text": "我們會去尋求一個比較可行的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147876/222.wav", + "text": "辦法當然部分也會跨部會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147876/223.wav", + "text": "啦委員應該是這樣的概念" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147876/224.wav", + "text": "部裡面要負責的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147876/225.wav", + "text": "主責單位寫得很清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147876/226.wav", + "text": "就是教育部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147876/227.wav", + "text": "委員談誘因的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147876/228.wav", + "text": "我們會去斟酌可行的方向是什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147876/229.wav", + "text": "好的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147876/230.wav", + "text": "謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147876/231.wav", + "text": "部長請回" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147875/0.wav", + "text": "我想如果不撥補" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147875/1.wav", + "text": "不撥補的結論當然就是有缺口" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147875/2.wav", + "text": "這還要問" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147875/3.wav", + "text": "不然怎麼會有修法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147875/4.wav", + "text": "怎麼會有撥補入法對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147875/5.wav", + "text": "所以撥補是現在處理缺口的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147875/6.wav", + "text": "當然你們還會說可以用投資" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147875/7.wav", + "text": "但也跟整體上面公務人員的退撫制度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147875/8.wav", + "text": "新舊制一切割之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147875/9.wav", + "text": "舊制裡面本來就已經沒有新進人員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147875/10.wav", + "text": "這也是一個結構上的因素所致" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147875/11.wav", + "text": "你們第8次精算報告裡面的資料" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147875/12.wav", + "text": "我想請秘書長跟部長也看一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147875/13.wav", + "text": "從公務人員教育人員軍職人員這三類人來講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147875/14.wav", + "text": "這個燈號本身的意義到底大不大" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147875/15.wav", + "text": "財務永續的設算之下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147875/16.wav", + "text": "都是正數的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147875/17.wav", + "text": "到黃燈就是介於" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147875/18.wav", + "text": "到紅燈的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147875/19.wav", + "text": "就是基於一個負數的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147875/20.wav", + "text": "風險就比較高了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147875/21.wav", + "text": "但是如果從剛剛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147875/22.wav", + "text": "鄭運鵬委員質詢的角度來看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147875/23.wav", + "text": "部長這個會有紅燈的可能嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147875/24.wav", + "text": "到目前為止還是屬於黃燈" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147875/25.wav", + "text": "未來當然有可能會進入到紅燈" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147875/26.wav", + "text": "那個就是我們將來要去做調整的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147875/27.wav", + "text": "因為我們會有每5年檢討的調整機制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147875/28.wav", + "text": "如果遇到紅燈的時候當然就要去檢討" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147875/29.wav", + "text": "怎麼樣去因應" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147875/30.wav", + "text": "然後讓它不要再繼續落入紅燈" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147875/31.wav", + "text": "那現在設算的基礎包括這個精算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147875/32.wav", + "text": "沒有把你們現在制度上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147875/33.wav", + "text": "要把政府撥補算進去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147875/34.wav", + "text": "所以如果算進去的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147875/35.wav", + "text": "會有紅燈這件事嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147875/36.wav", + "text": "因為我不太看得懂" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147875/37.wav", + "text": "以你們現在的作法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147875/38.wav", + "text": "又說平均要維持30年的財務永續" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147875/39.wav", + "text": "軍職這部分都是綠燈" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147875/40.wav", + "text": "起碼這10年8年內都沒有問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147875/41.wav", + "text": "它會降下去的原因是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147875/42.wav", + "text": "整體上面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147875/43.wav", + "text": "新進者少了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147875/44.wav", + "text": "設算不對了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147875/45.wav", + "text": "不然它的顏色會變" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147875/46.wav", + "text": "當然要看整個基金的收入" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147875/47.wav", + "text": "還有包括運用收入跟實際上收繳收入" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147875/48.wav", + "text": "如果有大幅改變的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147875/49.wav", + "text": "當然就會有這個情況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147875/50.wav", + "text": "所以112年新制實施以後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147875/51.wav", + "text": "但會不會大幅減少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147875/52.wav", + "text": "因為這都是精算是預估值" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147875/53.wav", + "text": "所以不確定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147875/54.wav", + "text": "那當然保留一個紅燈" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147875/55.wav", + "text": "是一般指標燈號應該要有的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147875/56.wav", + "text": "因為那就是你非採取措施不可了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147875/57.wav", + "text": "但理論上我們原來要求是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147875/58.wav", + "text": "我們希望它永遠不會出現紅燈" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147875/59.wav", + "text": "所以我們會有每5年調整機制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147875/60.wav", + "text": "就會讓它避免出現紅燈" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147875/61.wav", + "text": "但是今天這三個一比較" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147875/62.wav", + "text": "看起來教育人員會先落入黃燈" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147875/63.wav", + "text": "然後到118年就落到63%了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147875/64.wav", + "text": "所以這5年內" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147875/65.wav", + "text": "教育人員對於他們自己" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147875/66.wav", + "text": "會不會落入紅燈這個憂慮是存在的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147875/67.wav", + "text": "這個是第一個數字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147875/68.wav", + "text": "但是因為現在法制上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147875/69.wav", + "text": "已經沒有讓我們可以自動調整費率的機制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147875/70.wav", + "text": "所以能夠不落入紅燈的唯一因素" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147875/71.wav", + "text": "可能就是我們未來在精算裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147875/72.wav", + "text": "把挹注這件事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147875/73.wav", + "text": "當作一個主要的基金來源" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147875/74.wav", + "text": "也許就沒有紅燈的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147875/75.wav", + "text": "是這樣嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147875/76.wav", + "text": "因為第8次精算的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147875/77.wav", + "text": "還沒有法定撥補機制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147875/78.wav", + "text": "所以將來第9次精算的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147875/79.wav", + "text": "因為撥補還會有收益的狀況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147875/80.wav", + "text": "納進來當然就會有不同" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147875/81.wav", + "text": "所以這個燈號是參考" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147875/82.wav", + "text": "但是也要讓公務教育" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147875/83.wav", + "text": "軍職人員瞭解" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147875/84.wav", + "text": "未來第9次的算法可能就不同" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147875/85.wav", + "text": "現在有撥補跟沒有撥補的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147875/86.wav", + "text": "風險分析裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147875/87.wav", + "text": "以公務人員為例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147875/88.wav", + "text": "我們如果以不撥補來講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147875/89.wav", + "text": "基金出現虧損這個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147875/90.wav", + "text": "的時間是來到140年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147875/91.wav", + "text": "公務人員新人另立新制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147875/92.wav", + "text": "不參加退撫基金" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147875/93.wav", + "text": "但是只補100億的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147875/94.wav", + "text": "也是到140年左右" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147875/95.wav", + "text": "這是什麼樣的分析" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147875/96.wav", + "text": "是新舊制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147875/97.wav", + "text": "都參加原來的基金" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147875/98.wav", + "text": "但另立新基金如果沒有撥補" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147875/99.wav", + "text": "是到135年就是會從140年提早到135年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147875/100.wav", + "text": "這裡的假設" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147875/101.wav", + "text": "是如果未來50年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147875/102.wav", + "text": "延後到原來的140年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147875/103.wav", + "text": "延後5年而已嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147875/104.wav", + "text": "補了100億下去之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147875/105.wav", + "text": "延後5年可是延後5年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147875/106.wav", + "text": "跟新舊沒有分開的年限" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147875/107.wav", + "text": "又一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147875/108.wav", + "text": "所以才說新舊分開" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147875/109.wav", + "text": "到底要救什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147875/110.wav", + "text": "依照年改的結果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147875/111.wav", + "text": "但是因為實施" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147875/112.wav", + "text": "112年新制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147875/113.wav", + "text": "會讓它提早到135年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147875/114.wav", + "text": "那我們的目標就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147875/115.wav", + "text": "因為新制實施所造成的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147875/116.wav", + "text": "缺口就是從140年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147875/117.wav", + "text": "提早到135年這件事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147875/118.wav", + "text": "必須要用撥補來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147875/119.wav", + "text": "讓它回到140年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147875/120.wav", + "text": "這就是為什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147875/121.wav", + "text": "所以你們只是讓它維持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147875/122.wav", + "text": "年而怎麼樣可以達到140" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147875/123.wav", + "text": "因為年改當時的目標就是維持一個世代" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147875/124.wav", + "text": "那個時候一個世代" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147875/125.wav", + "text": "是25到30年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147875/126.wav", + "text": "我們現在已經統一" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147875/127.wav", + "text": "未來就是看30年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147875/128.wav", + "text": "讓它在30年內不會用罄" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147875/129.wav", + "text": "而如果我們從現在開始算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147875/130.wav", + "text": "讓它30年後不會用罄" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147875/131.wav", + "text": "大概就是回到140年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147875/132.wav", + "text": "如果說285億的挹注" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147875/133.wav", + "text": "所謂的NA" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147875/134.wav", + "text": "這個英文的代碼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147875/135.wav", + "text": "我不太確定你們的意思" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147875/136.wav", + "text": "所以如果每年撥補28" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147875/137.wav", + "text": "就是不會有用罄了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147875/138.wav", + "text": "永遠水位都在那邊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147875/139.wav", + "text": "目前我們的政策是決定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147875/140.wav", + "text": "每年先撥補公務100億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147875/141.wav", + "text": "教育人員100億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147875/142.wav", + "text": "是這樣嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147875/143.wav", + "text": "沒有現在決定是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147875/144.wav", + "text": "各50億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147875/145.wav", + "text": "沒有50億是明年的狀況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147875/146.wav", + "text": "並不是每一年都是這個數字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147875/147.wav", + "text": "如果撥補多少就可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147875/148.wav", + "text": "大概就是要200億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147875/149.wav", + "text": "嗎他剛剛講的意思" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147875/150.wav", + "text": "是50年內每年各100億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147875/151.wav", + "text": "教育人員是236億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147875/152.wav", + "text": "大概是這個數字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147875/153.wav", + "text": "所以明年只撥各50" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147875/154.wav", + "text": "億照理說就有缺口的意思" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147875/155.wav", + "text": "怎麼會說沒有缺口" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147875/156.wav", + "text": "因為撥補的概念並不是每年一個固定的數字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147875/157.wav", + "text": "我相信主計總" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147875/158.wav", + "text": "我們現在看短期5年內的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147875/159.wav", + "text": "可能都是50億50億或100" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147875/160.wav", + "text": "億也都有缺口" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147875/161.wav", + "text": "啊如果照你講的285億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147875/162.wav", + "text": "才是所謂的永續性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147875/163.wav", + "text": "100億是可以維持到30年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147875/164.wav", + "text": "跟委員提到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147875/165.wav", + "text": "因為講的那個缺口" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147875/166.wav", + "text": "如果是原來制度造成的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147875/167.wav", + "text": "也就潛藏負債的那個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147875/168.wav", + "text": "要未來50年都補滿" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147875/169.wav", + "text": "才會一年需要兩百多億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147875/170.wav", + "text": "而現在我們談的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147875/171.wav", + "text": "如果是因為新制造成的缺口" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147875/172.wav", + "text": "我們要讓它回到原來的140年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147875/173.wav", + "text": "就有兩種" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147875/174.wav", + "text": "一種是分50年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147875/175.wav", + "text": "每年撥多少億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147875/176.wav", + "text": "年但這個不是在補原來那個制度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147875/177.wav", + "text": "已經造成的潛藏缺口" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147875/178.wav", + "text": "所以整個潛藏缺口加進來的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147875/179.wav", + "text": "用285億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147875/180.wav", + "text": "就不會有任何的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147875/181.wav", + "text": "對如果是整個原來基金的缺口" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147875/182.wav", + "text": "一起補的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147875/183.wav", + "text": "就是285億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147875/184.wav", + "text": "所以目前政策上就是明年50億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147875/185.wav", + "text": "你們有規劃" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147875/186.wav", + "text": "未來5年內大概要補多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147875/187.wav", + "text": "因為依照現行退撫法的規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147875/188.wav", + "text": "是要先補新制所造成的缺口" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147875/189.wav", + "text": "才會補後續的原來基金的缺口" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147875/190.wav", + "text": "那這樣是幾年後才會補到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147875/191.wav", + "text": "原來基金的舊債缺口" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147875/192.wav", + "text": "就是前面的缺口先補完" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147875/193.wav", + "text": "所以要到140年之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147875/194.wav", + "text": "才會開始補舊制的缺口" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147875/195.wav", + "text": "不一定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147875/196.wav", + "text": "我想這些問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147875/197.wav", + "text": "大家雖然都有財務永續的期待" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147875/198.wav", + "text": "能不能提早增加撥補的數額" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147875/199.wav", + "text": "當然就是看我們財務的規劃" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147875/200.wav", + "text": "目前這個有沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147875/201.wav", + "text": "基金來源來讓你們做撥補" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147875/202.wav", + "text": "政府有沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147875/203.wav", + "text": "這次50億是從哪裡勻過來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147875/204.wav", + "text": "這個是由主計處這邊來編列預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147875/205.wav", + "text": "現在依照法定的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147875/206.wav", + "text": "是年改節餘經費的挹注" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147875/207.wav", + "text": "那個部分是法定的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147875/208.wav", + "text": "但是這個數字會變" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147875/209.wav", + "text": "接下來會越來越高" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147875/210.wav", + "text": "到了一個年度又會開始下降" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147875/211.wav", + "text": "是所以這是兩筆錢嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147875/212.wav", + "text": "這個50億從哪裡勻支過來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147875/213.wav", + "text": "這個就是我們整個歲出" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147875/214.wav", + "text": "去安排配置的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147875/215.wav", + "text": "所以有沒有把歲計賸餘的錢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147875/216.wav", + "text": "沒有這樣的對應關係" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147875/217.wav", + "text": "我OK最後我想跟秘書長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147875/218.wav", + "text": "部長們分享" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147875/219.wav", + "text": "就是這整個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147875/220.wav", + "text": "基金的用罄" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147875/221.wav", + "text": "基金餘額的不足" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147875/222.wav", + "text": "不會只有在軍公教的體系" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147875/223.wav", + "text": "勞工跟未來的國保" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147875/224.wav", + "text": "都有相關性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147875/225.wav", + "text": "有說過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147875/226.wav", + "text": "了我想我們還是要面對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147875/227.wav", + "text": "農民國民年金的社會保險裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147875/228.wav", + "text": "有一個基礎的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147875/229.wav", + "text": "無條件基本收入" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147875/230.wav", + "text": "這樣子才能夠去處理現在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147875/231.wav", + "text": "少子化造成人口結構上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147875/232.wav", + "text": "去養我們這些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147875/233.wav", + "text": "六七十歲的長輩" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147875/234.wav", + "text": "因為我在推動公共年金" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147875/235.wav", + "text": "改革委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147875/236.wav", + "text": "在我們這個司法法制委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147875/237.wav", + "text": "已經有討論過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147875/238.wav", + "text": "但是還沒有成立" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147875/239.wav", + "text": "所以未來也期待我們秘書長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147875/240.wav", + "text": "也可以推動也跟勞動部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147875/241.wav", + "text": "農業部或者是內政部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147875/242.wav", + "text": "來討論看看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147875/243.wav", + "text": "因為這個共同性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147875/244.wav", + "text": "無條件基本收入的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147875/245.wav", + "text": "會比未來我們永遠要面對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147875/246.wav", + "text": "少子化人口結構下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147875/247.wav", + "text": "造成的沉重基金負擔" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147875/248.wav", + "text": "在行政院裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147875/249.wav", + "text": "去推動這個對話的可能性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147875/250.wav", + "text": "如果需要我們的意見的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147875/251.wav", + "text": "我們很願意來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147875/252.wav", + "text": "因為這個攸關財政跟稅收" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147875/253.wav", + "text": "所以聽起來比較像是行政院的業務" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147875/254.wav", + "text": "行政院業務" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147875/255.wav", + "text": "好我想我這個也是跟大家期勉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147875/256.wav", + "text": "就是一個制度修修補補" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147875/257.wav", + "text": "如果預算跟基金不足的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147875/258.wav", + "text": "權益就可能受到影響" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147875/259.wav", + "text": "這對大家的公平性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147875/260.wav", + "text": "都會受到質疑好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147875/261.wav", + "text": "請努力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147875/262.wav", + "text": "謝謝主席" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147874/0.wav", + "text": "謝謝主席我們請部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147874/1.wav", + "text": "好陳部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147874/2.wav", + "text": "部長我們要給民眾正確的訊息" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147874/3.wav", + "text": "啦營養午餐是我們從過去到現在非常重視的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147874/4.wav", + "text": "甚至我們要求所有學校的營養午餐相關的農產品都要有履歷" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147874/5.wav", + "text": "而且都要是我們臺灣自己生產的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147874/6.wav", + "text": "對三章一Q" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147874/7.wav", + "text": "對所以這個基本上從過去到現在沒有改變過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147874/8.wav", + "text": "完全沒有改變過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147874/9.wav", + "text": "不能說因為現在有一些政治的語言" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147874/10.wav", + "text": "然後掩蓋了我們對於營養午餐的一個認知" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147874/11.wav", + "text": "甚至讓家長有恐慌" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147874/12.wav", + "text": "這不能有任何打折的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147874/13.wav", + "text": "也就是我們要跟家長說得很清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147874/14.wav", + "text": "現在所有在外面的紛紛擾擾" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147874/15.wav", + "text": "跟我們的營養午餐不會有直接的關係" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147874/16.wav", + "text": "因為我們有把關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147874/17.wav", + "text": "上在政策上就已經做了很好的把關了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147874/18.wav", + "text": "從教育部學校端" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147874/19.wav", + "text": "在學校端就已經有被要求要做管控" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147874/20.wav", + "text": "所以三章一Q還有我們的生產履歷" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147874/21.wav", + "text": "還有我們所有地方自產的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147874/22.wav", + "text": "甚至要要求如果能協助我們地方生產的一些農民的產品" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147874/23.wav", + "text": "都要優先是不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147874/24.wav", + "text": "是不是這個樣子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147874/25.wav", + "text": "我跟委員說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147874/26.wav", + "text": "其實營養午餐本身" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147874/27.wav", + "text": "國產的三章一Q覆蓋率已經達到98.2%了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147874/28.wav", + "text": "其實代表的就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147874/29.wav", + "text": "我們的營養午餐一定是用我們國產的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147874/30.wav", + "text": "一定是儘可能用我們在地的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147874/31.wav", + "text": "所以目前各縣市針對液蛋的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147874/32.wav", + "text": "不是儘可能" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147874/33.wav", + "text": "是現在因為有這個要求" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147874/34.wav", + "text": "教育部也要求了各縣市政府" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147874/35.wav", + "text": "除非是各縣市政府自己沒有去做好把關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147874/36.wav", + "text": "我們的中央政策很清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147874/37.wav", + "text": "是給了各地方政府要做這樣的一個方向" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147874/38.wav", + "text": "所以不是儘可能" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147874/39.wav", + "text": "而是我們本來就要求你一定要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147874/40.wav", + "text": "在這樣的一個把關當中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147874/41.wav", + "text": "為了小孩子的安全" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147874/42.wav", + "text": "不論是什麼進口" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147874/43.wav", + "text": "我們都不管" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147874/44.wav", + "text": "我們要求的是在地" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147874/45.wav", + "text": "在地食材才是我們一直要求" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147874/46.wav", + "text": "在營養午餐當中的一個關鍵" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147874/47.wav", + "text": "對我們在相關的規範" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147874/48.wav", + "text": "所以你不能說儘可能不要再用這幾個字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147874/49.wav", + "text": "這幾個字在我們營養午餐的範疇裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147874/50.wav", + "text": "是完全不可能被看到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147874/51.wav", + "text": "否則就是各地方政府把關不嚴" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147874/52.wav", + "text": "所以我也認為如果有這樣的訊息" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147874/53.wav", + "text": "我們就要從各縣市政府去瞭解" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147874/54.wav", + "text": "哪一個教育局沒有把關好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147874/55.wav", + "text": "哪一個教育局沒有要求學校去做好處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147874/56.wav", + "text": "這才是重點啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147874/57.wav", + "text": "怎麼可以被從地方反攻到中央說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147874/58.wav", + "text": "政策哪裡不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147874/59.wav", + "text": "政策沒有不對啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147874/60.wav", + "text": "我們的營養午餐從頭到尾" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147874/61.wav", + "text": "整個SOP跟把關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147874/62.wav", + "text": "在跟教育部的平臺" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147874/63.wav", + "text": "跟地方政府間都沒有改變過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147874/64.wav", + "text": "完全沒有改變" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147874/65.wav", + "text": "完全沒有改變過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147874/66.wav", + "text": "甚至是越來越嚴格" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147874/67.wav", + "text": "所以我覺得這個一定要要求" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147874/68.wav", + "text": "既然有委員提出這樣的疑問" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147874/69.wav", + "text": "要求教育部馬上要求各縣市政府的教育局" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147874/70.wav", + "text": "自我調查自我評估" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147874/71.wav", + "text": "你們自己沒做到嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147874/72.wav", + "text": "現在各縣市政府誰執政最多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147874/73.wav", + "text": "反而要由中央來吸收" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147874/74.wav", + "text": "這是什麼道理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147874/75.wav", + "text": "我們已經要求營養午餐就是要把關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147874/76.wav", + "text": "把關把關再把關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147874/77.wav", + "text": "對於小孩子的安全食安沒有任何折扣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147874/78.wav", + "text": "這從過去到現在就是這樣子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147874/79.wav", + "text": "我們希望農業部也要硬起來啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147874/80.wav", + "text": "過去跟現在從來沒改變過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147874/81.wav", + "text": "所以要求責令教育部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147874/82.wav", + "text": "是不是地方政府有鬆動" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147874/83.wav", + "text": "這才是問題啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147874/84.wav", + "text": "如果沒有鬆動" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147874/85.wav", + "text": "那全部就是在地食材" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147874/86.wav", + "text": "怎麼會有什麼叫進口不進口的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147874/87.wav", + "text": "\n另外一個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147874/88.wav", + "text": "外勞的人數往上提升到1.2萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147874/89.wav", + "text": "提升了1倍" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147874/90.wav", + "text": "可是你並沒有針對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147874/91.wav", + "text": "我們現在所面臨的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147874/92.wav", + "text": "我們面臨的問題是什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147874/93.wav", + "text": "你現在是由各地方的農漁會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147874/94.wav", + "text": "還有非營利組織" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147874/95.wav", + "text": "來成立調度平臺" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147874/96.wav", + "text": "可是要成為調度平臺" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147874/97.wav", + "text": "它本身要盡到管理之責" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147874/98.wav", + "text": "對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147874/99.wav", + "text": "有哪些是它有能力可以盡到管理之責的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147874/100.wav", + "text": "都因為這個被卡關了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147874/101.wav", + "text": "是不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147874/102.wav", + "text": "我們早就已經有設立平臺了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147874/103.wav", + "text": "為什麼讓人民無感" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147874/104.wav", + "text": "然後讓有些候選人居然喊出說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147874/105.wav", + "text": "我要再成立平臺" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147874/106.wav", + "text": "明明我們的平臺就成立啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147874/107.wav", + "text": "我們在2017年就成立了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147874/108.wav", + "text": "那為什麼無感" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147874/109.wav", + "text": "人家喊出這個話題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147874/110.wav", + "text": "好像一下子又變成一個議題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147874/111.wav", + "text": "不對啊我們在做啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147874/112.wav", + "text": "那為什麼人民會無感" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147874/113.wav", + "text": "農民會無感" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147874/114.wav", + "text": "就是因為我們被這個管理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147874/115.wav", + "text": "我跟委員說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147874/116.wav", + "text": "之前大概都是要透過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147874/117.wav", + "text": "像您剛才講的這些農會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147874/118.wav", + "text": "有一個團體來做一起調度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147874/119.wav", + "text": "這個調度的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147874/120.wav", + "text": "當然必須盡一些管理責任" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147874/121.wav", + "text": "很多人會害怕" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147874/122.wav", + "text": "那現在我們也同樣已經" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147874/123.wav", + "text": "跟勞動部取得一個共識" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147874/124.wav", + "text": "就是農民本身自己也可以申請" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147874/125.wav", + "text": "然後也不會再像過往" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147874/126.wav", + "text": "一定要有一個團體的調度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147874/127.wav", + "text": "才能夠達成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147874/128.wav", + "text": "所以未來我想這個情況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147874/129.wav", + "text": "農民可以申請" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147874/130.wav", + "text": "那農民怎麼管理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147874/131.wav", + "text": "農民本身就回到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147874/132.wav", + "text": "他自己就可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147874/133.wav", + "text": "自主管理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147874/134.wav", + "text": "個別管理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147874/135.wav", + "text": "對個別管理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147874/136.wav", + "text": "這樣的話就回到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147874/137.wav", + "text": "所以嘛農業部你今天一直在跟大家說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147874/138.wav", + "text": "我們的人數有增加" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147874/139.wav", + "text": "從600變成一萬二" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147874/140.wav", + "text": "這是一個重點而已" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147874/141.wav", + "text": "剛剛部長你所講的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147874/142.wav", + "text": "才是另外一個重點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147874/143.wav", + "text": "他可以自主管理啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147874/144.wav", + "text": "可以由我們的農業需求者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147874/145.wav", + "text": "外勞需求者自行來做個別管理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147874/146.wav", + "text": "自主管理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147874/147.wav", + "text": "讓過去這整個所謂的統一管理跟平臺" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147874/148.wav", + "text": "更寬鬆" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147874/149.wav", + "text": "所以就打掉了所謂的平臺嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147874/150.wav", + "text": "因為要統一管理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147874/151.wav", + "text": "所以要平臺" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147874/152.wav", + "text": "現在如果可以自主管理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147874/153.wav", + "text": "幹嘛要平臺" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147874/154.wav", + "text": "不過我想平臺的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147874/155.wav", + "text": "還是有它維持的必要性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147874/156.wav", + "text": "因為有時候季節性的需求" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147874/157.wav", + "text": "還是可以調度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147874/158.wav", + "text": "但是另外一個重點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147874/159.wav", + "text": "但是這個平臺已經不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147874/160.wav", + "text": "你要把這個平臺的概念" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147874/161.wav", + "text": "跟過去的平臺不一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147874/162.wav", + "text": "這樣子你才能去符合農民的需求嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147874/163.wav", + "text": "不是像現在每一次在選舉當中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147874/164.wav", + "text": "亂喊一通" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147874/165.wav", + "text": "明明我們已經在做了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147874/166.wav", + "text": "可是因為民眾的接受" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147874/167.wav", + "text": "跟我們農業部的敘述有落差" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147874/168.wav", + "text": "我剛剛所講的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147874/169.wav", + "text": "你們現在在外面說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147874/170.wav", + "text": "有啊我們現在增加了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147874/171.wav", + "text": "從600變成一萬二" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147874/172.wav", + "text": "可是農民感覺是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147874/173.wav", + "text": "因為他要透過那個平臺" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147874/174.wav", + "text": "農漁會如果不幫他們管理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147874/175.wav", + "text": "他們還是沒辦法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147874/176.wav", + "text": "很多農漁會也認為他" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147874/177.wav", + "text": "他要負責管理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147874/178.wav", + "text": "他也不要啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147874/179.wav", + "text": "那現在改變了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147874/180.wav", + "text": "現在可以自主管理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147874/181.wav", + "text": "你們要講出重點啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147874/182.wav", + "text": "瞭解" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147874/183.wav", + "text": "所以這個才能去改變" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147874/184.wav", + "text": "我們現在所謂的缺工嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147874/185.wav", + "text": "2021年我們農耕業" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147874/186.wav", + "text": "農戶缺工就缺了6.3%" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147874/187.wav", + "text": "畜牧業就缺了6.6%" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147874/188.wav", + "text": "我們也看到了所有資料顯示" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147874/189.wav", + "text": "年輕人根本都沒有辦法投進來嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147874/190.wav", + "text": "甚至監察院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147874/191.wav", + "text": "勞動力人口不足而且高齡化" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147874/192.wav", + "text": "但是現階段沒有實際盤點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147874/193.wav", + "text": "跟掌握農業的實際需求" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147874/194.wav", + "text": "還有人力缺口" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147874/195.wav", + "text": "政策上路之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147874/196.wav", + "text": "邊看邊做邊改" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147874/197.wav", + "text": "這沒有問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147874/198.wav", + "text": "我覺得既然監察院這麼說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147874/199.wav", + "text": "我們直球對決嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147874/200.wav", + "text": "我們就是改啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147874/201.wav", + "text": "沒有辦法讓人民" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147874/202.wav", + "text": "讓民眾有直接的感受" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147874/203.wav", + "text": "農漁會不幫你管理就完蛋了啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147874/204.wav", + "text": "好現在改變了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147874/205.wav", + "text": "我們可以自主管理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147874/206.wav", + "text": "\n另外一個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147874/207.wav", + "text": "就是我們一定要強調的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147874/208.wav", + "text": "現在很多青農" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147874/209.wav", + "text": "基本上都回到我們地方" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147874/210.wav", + "text": "我必須說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147874/211.wav", + "text": "我們臺南已經把整個青農" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147874/212.wav", + "text": "組合起來了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147874/213.wav", + "text": "可是我們中央的資源在哪裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147874/214.wav", + "text": "感受不到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147874/215.wav", + "text": "感受不到我們給了他" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147874/216.wav", + "text": "多少的這些資源" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147874/217.wav", + "text": "我們怎麼協助他" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147874/218.wav", + "text": "去做很多的一些研發" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147874/219.wav", + "text": "甚至農業的轉型" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147874/220.wav", + "text": "我覺得這才是重要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147874/221.wav", + "text": "我想非常謝謝委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147874/222.wav", + "text": "其實我們在技術面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147874/223.wav", + "text": "在資源面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147874/224.wav", + "text": "都有非常多的投入" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147874/225.wav", + "text": "我們也有更大的力道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147874/226.wav", + "text": "不要再講機械化" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147874/227.wav", + "text": "機械化原本就要做了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147874/228.wav", + "text": "不要講機械化" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147874/229.wav", + "text": "機械化本來就要做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147874/230.wav", + "text": "我是說如何在整個轉型" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147874/231.wav", + "text": "缺工的部分來協助他們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147874/232.wav", + "text": "我拜託部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147874/233.wav", + "text": "我們升格農業部了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147874/234.wav", + "text": "嘛大家有期待" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147874/235.wav", + "text": "預算可以協助所有青農的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147874/236.wav", + "text": "到我辦公室" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147873/0.wav", + "text": "部長我們今天委員會要討論的是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147873/1.wav", + "text": "勞工退休金制度改革" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147873/2.wav", + "text": "我想現在勞工退休最重要的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147873/3.wav", + "text": "兩大安全支柱其實就是勞工的退休金制度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147873/4.wav", + "text": "這在2005年做的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147873/5.wav", + "text": "然後還有勞工保險是在1960年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147873/6.wav", + "text": "就已經設計有這樣的狀況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147873/7.wav", + "text": "要討論的其實就是勞保" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147873/8.wav", + "text": "啦因為勞工退休金制度在2005才做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147873/9.wav", + "text": "就等於是自己有自己的帳戶" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147873/10.wav", + "text": "其實算滿穩定的逐步前進\n" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147873/11.wav", + "text": "\n最想要問的就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147873/12.wav", + "text": "這個網路上也有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147873/13.wav", + "text": "啦甚至是我剛剛要來這邊質詢之前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147873/14.wav", + "text": "電視也正在播" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147873/15.wav", + "text": "一個勞工到底要準備多少退休金" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147873/16.wav", + "text": "才可以有安全的退休生活" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147873/17.wav", + "text": "真的讓大家都覺得非常地心慌" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147873/18.wav", + "text": "可是政府釋出的消息" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147873/19.wav", + "text": "或者是網路不停的消息" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147873/20.wav", + "text": "其實就是說我們勞保快要倒了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147873/21.wav", + "text": "啊因為入不敷出" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147873/22.wav", + "text": "啊所以再過幾年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147873/23.wav", + "text": "可能大家都領不到退休金" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147873/24.wav", + "text": "光是這句話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147873/25.wav", + "text": "部長你怎麼看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147873/26.wav", + "text": "你有沒有什麼簡短扼要的回應" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147873/27.wav", + "text": "有政府就不會倒" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147873/28.wav", + "text": "這個是政府辦的保險" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147873/29.wav", + "text": "套用我們蘇前院長的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147873/30.wav", + "text": "有政府就不會倒" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147873/31.wav", + "text": "有政府就不會倒" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147873/32.wav", + "text": "因為這是政府辦的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147873/33.wav", + "text": "辦的保險" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147873/34.wav", + "text": "其實我們也真的非常謝謝蘇前院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147873/35.wav", + "text": "因為勞保的各種改革方案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147873/36.wav", + "text": "其實都有一個共同的議題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147873/37.wav", + "text": "就是要撥補" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147873/38.wav", + "text": "是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147873/39.wav", + "text": "政府撥補是一個很重要的面向" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147873/40.wav", + "text": "而這個面向" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147873/41.wav", + "text": "其實就在蘇院長109年的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147873/42.wav", + "text": "沒有錯" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147873/43.wav", + "text": "一直到明年的1,200億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147873/44.wav", + "text": "再加上特別預算是2,670億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147873/45.wav", + "text": "連續4年撥補" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147873/46.wav", + "text": "其實行政院這邊對外也有講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147873/47.wav", + "text": "會再持續撥補" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147873/48.wav", + "text": "但是當然撥補" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147873/49.wav", + "text": "金額必須視政府的財政狀況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147873/50.wav", + "text": "非常好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147873/51.wav", + "text": "部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147873/52.wav", + "text": "我今天就是就政府撥補的題目" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147873/53.wav", + "text": "跟您做第一輪的請教" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147873/54.wav", + "text": "因為確實是從106年開始" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147873/55.wav", + "text": "其實是小於支出" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147873/56.wav", + "text": "如果在這個狀況下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147873/57.wav", + "text": "一二三勉強算是穩定的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147873/58.wav", + "text": "因為基金運用的收益" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147873/59.wav", + "text": "還有投資收益的不一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147873/60.wav", + "text": "可能得到的金額就會不一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147873/61.wav", + "text": "尤其策略都偏保守" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147873/62.wav", + "text": "能不能夠有收入" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147873/63.wav", + "text": "確實是一個不穩定的狀況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147873/64.wav", + "text": "如果我們就這個圖表來看的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147873/65.wav", + "text": "去年這一年的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147873/66.wav", + "text": "我們的收益狀況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147873/67.wav", + "text": "隨著全球市場不太好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147873/68.wav", + "text": "就往下掉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147873/69.wav", + "text": "每個勞工會虧損多少多少錢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147873/70.wav", + "text": "所以我完全同意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147873/71.wav", + "text": "政府的撥補是可以執行的狀況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147873/72.wav", + "text": "我們從109年開始這樣撥補" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147873/73.wav", + "text": "甚至是在112年疫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147873/74.wav", + "text": "還編列了300億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147873/75.wav", + "text": "分三年來給付" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147873/76.wav", + "text": "請問這個有法源嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147873/77.wav", + "text": "政府撥補勞工保險基金" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147873/78.wav", + "text": "這件事情有法源嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147873/79.wav", + "text": "有前例嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147873/80.wav", + "text": "有什麼可以參考" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147873/81.wav", + "text": "現在的政府決定要這樣做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147873/82.wav", + "text": "也是因為我們這幾年經濟不錯" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147873/83.wav", + "text": "說實在的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147873/84.wav", + "text": "大家每次都在說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147873/85.wav", + "text": "超收超收" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147873/86.wav", + "text": "其實它是超過預期的稅收" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147873/87.wav", + "text": "所以我們有這樣的錢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147873/88.wav", + "text": "可以來做這樣的撥補" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147873/89.wav", + "text": "最明顯的就是疫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147873/90.wav", + "text": "疫後特別預算編列的這個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147873/91.wav", + "text": "政府的方向對大家經濟做得好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147873/92.wav", + "text": "所以我們可以拿來做這件事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147873/93.wav", + "text": "如果未來沒有這樣的狀況呢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147873/94.wav", + "text": "委員在問有沒有依據" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147873/95.wav", + "text": "基本上這是一個給付行政" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147873/96.wav", + "text": "是啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147873/97.wav", + "text": "給付行政只要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147873/98.wav", + "text": "意思是以後如果我改變態度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147873/99.wav", + "text": "一定會有政府" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147873/100.wav", + "text": "現在雖然沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147873/101.wav", + "text": "這是一個給付行政" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147873/102.wav", + "text": "只要政府有財源" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147873/103.wav", + "text": "經過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147873/104.wav", + "text": "預算就是我們執行的一個依據" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147873/105.wav", + "text": "你要確定下一任的政府" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147873/106.wav", + "text": "跟我們現在的態度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147873/107.wav", + "text": "想法是一樣的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147873/108.wav", + "text": "我們要不要來討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147873/109.wav", + "text": "要不要法制化" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147873/110.wav", + "text": "如有虧損" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147873/111.wav", + "text": "在中央勞工保險局" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147873/112.wav", + "text": "未成立前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147873/113.wav", + "text": "應由中央主管機關審核撥補" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147873/114.wav", + "text": "這是在未成立前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147873/115.wav", + "text": "可是現在已經成立了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147873/116.wav", + "text": "都已經某程度的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147873/117.wav", + "text": "法制化了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147873/118.wav", + "text": "所以要求政府撥補" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147873/119.wav", + "text": "應該可以是制度化的來執行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147873/120.wav", + "text": "是不是也應該可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147873/121.wav", + "text": "往這個方向前進" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147873/122.wav", + "text": "既然我們都覺得它是好的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147873/123.wav", + "text": "對人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147873/124.wav", + "text": "對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147873/125.wav", + "text": "國家制度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147873/126.wav", + "text": "不應該完全綁在一起" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147873/127.wav", + "text": "就是應該要把" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147873/128.wav", + "text": "長治久安的制度構建起來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147873/129.wav", + "text": "現在我們都已經看到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147873/130.wav", + "text": "勞保有這樣的困境" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147873/131.wav", + "text": "而這不是臺灣獨有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147873/132.wav", + "text": "這是舉世皆然" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147873/133.wav", + "text": "美國英國法國" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147873/134.wav", + "text": "根本都已經是走到街上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147873/135.wav", + "text": "就是為了退休金制度的變革" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147873/136.wav", + "text": "引起社會這麼大的紛爭" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147873/137.wav", + "text": "因為有足夠的稅收" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147873/138.wav", + "text": "也讓這個困境" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147873/139.wav", + "text": "延緩一點發生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147873/140.wav", + "text": "這個撥補" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147873/141.wav", + "text": "我想請問的是部長的看法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147873/142.wav", + "text": "是我認同" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147873/143.wav", + "text": "你認同" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147873/144.wav", + "text": "我認為政府撥補勞保基金" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147873/145.wav", + "text": "是一個可以讓勞保基金" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147873/146.wav", + "text": "穩定的態度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147873/147.wav", + "text": "也是更可以揭示" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147873/148.wav", + "text": "──有政府勞保就不會倒" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147873/149.wav", + "text": "這可以更展現它的態度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147873/150.wav", + "text": "政府撥補勞保基金" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147873/151.wav", + "text": "應該要法制化" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147873/152.wav", + "text": "我也看到你今天的報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147873/153.wav", + "text": "請問部長勞保永續經營" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147873/154.wav", + "text": "還有什麼方法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147873/155.wav", + "text": "剛剛我們說勞保基金" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147873/156.wav", + "text": "第二個你自己" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147873/157.wav", + "text": "是二三四包括調整勞保費率" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147873/158.wav", + "text": "延後退休年齡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147873/159.wav", + "text": "改變給付條件" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147873/160.wav", + "text": "大概就這幾項方法了吧" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147873/161.wav", + "text": "還有其他的嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147873/162.wav", + "text": "主要的項目大概" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147873/163.wav", + "text": "但是這幾項的溝通就不容易" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147873/164.wav", + "text": "對啊最難的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147873/165.wav", + "text": "到底要採用哪一項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147873/166.wav", + "text": "還有每一項裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147873/167.wav", + "text": "的細部到底是什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147873/168.wav", + "text": "龐雜的過程" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147873/169.wav", + "text": "世界各國在爭吵的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147873/170.wav", + "text": "也是因為這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147873/171.wav", + "text": "即延後退休年齡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147873/172.wav", + "text": "尤其是改變給付條件" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147873/173.wav", + "text": "我們有深刻的感受和體" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147873/174.wav", + "text": "要凝聚共識" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147873/175.wav", + "text": "你採哪一個方案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147873/176.wav", + "text": "我問你的是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147873/177.wav", + "text": "凝聚共識的方案是什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147873/178.wav", + "text": "我也知道現在還沒有共識" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147873/179.wav", + "text": "也是在傾聽意見裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147873/180.wav", + "text": "瞭解大家對問題的爭議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147873/181.wav", + "text": "然後去說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147873/182.wav", + "text": "這是一個非常不容易的過程" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147873/183.wav", + "text": "可是要能夠把世界各國" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147873/184.wav", + "text": "目前的狀況讓大家知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147873/185.wav", + "text": "第一這不是臺灣獨有的狀況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147873/186.wav", + "text": "第二我們要把過去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147873/187.wav", + "text": "辛苦的經驗" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147873/188.wav", + "text": "要能夠深刻的記憶" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147873/189.wav", + "text": "都是必須要能夠採行的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147873/190.wav", + "text": "這一二三四之外" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147873/191.wav", + "text": "我個人也認為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147873/192.wav", + "text": "和研議勞退及勞保" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147873/193.wav", + "text": "老年給付整合的可行性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147873/194.wav", + "text": "也應該要列入" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147873/195.wav", + "text": "改革的方案裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147873/196.wav", + "text": "我認為這是可以一併研議的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147873/197.wav", + "text": "\n今天在這裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147873/198.wav", + "text": "我也知道共識很難" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147873/199.wav", + "text": "但比起提出方案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147873/200.wav", + "text": "尋求共識" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147873/201.wav", + "text": "是最重要的一個步驟" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147873/202.wav", + "text": "我另外再多提一點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147873/203.wav", + "text": "勞保基金這件事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147873/204.wav", + "text": "朝法制化的方向" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147873/205.wav", + "text": "我認為這" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147873/206.wav", + "text": "對未來長治久安" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147873/207.wav", + "text": "是一個很大的幫忙" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147873/208.wav", + "text": "部長應該認同啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147873/209.wav", + "text": "認同" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147873/210.wav", + "text": "那就先往這樣前進" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147873/211.wav", + "text": "如果部長有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147873/212.wav", + "text": "任何方案的建議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147873/213.wav", + "text": "請不吝提供各委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147873/214.wav", + "text": "謝謝委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147872/0.wav", + "text": "委員早" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147872/1.wav", + "text": "主計長早" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147872/2.wav", + "text": "臺灣目前的自營作業者據統計大概" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147872/3.wav", + "text": "有131萬人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147872/4.wav", + "text": "在總工作人口裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147872/5.wav", + "text": "另外雇主還有44萬人占3.9%" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147872/6.wav", + "text": "所以兩者加起來大概是百分之十五點多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147872/7.wav", + "text": "基本上這兩類人賺的錢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147872/8.wav", + "text": "因為他沒有領薪水" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147872/9.wav", + "text": "當然將來還要再繳稅" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147872/10.wav", + "text": "所以沒有辦法區分薪資或是盈餘" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147872/11.wav", + "text": "有這樣的狀況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147872/12.wav", + "text": "都是這樣子統計的嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147872/13.wav", + "text": "一般都是這樣子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147872/14.wav", + "text": "但是我要跟委員報告一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147872/15.wav", + "text": "比其他國家高非常多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147872/16.wav", + "text": "所以才會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147872/17.wav", + "text": "是什麼原因高的非常多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147872/18.wav", + "text": "就是臺灣人寧為雞首不為牛後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147872/19.wav", + "text": "希望自己開" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147872/20.wav", + "text": "個商店這樣的觀念嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147872/21.wav", + "text": "所以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147872/22.wav", + "text": "這個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147872/23.wav", + "text": "有沒有辦法在統計的時候更精細一點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147872/24.wav", + "text": "如果跟剛剛那個能夠區分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147872/25.wav", + "text": "更能清楚地看出" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147872/26.wav", + "text": "到底是屬於他的營業盈餘" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147872/27.wav", + "text": "還是屬於薪資" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147872/28.wav", + "text": "那部分實在很難切" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147872/29.wav", + "text": "沒有辦法切" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147872/30.wav", + "text": "如果把它獲得的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147872/31.wav", + "text": "照平均薪資" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147872/32.wav", + "text": "拿出來算薪資的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147872/33.wav", + "text": "剩下來再算盈餘的部分這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147872/34.wav", + "text": "應該有多少薪資" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147872/35.wav", + "text": "這樣子的話以後可能會更清楚一點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147872/36.wav", + "text": "讓它的樣貌更清楚一點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147872/37.wav", + "text": "另外" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147872/38.wav", + "text": "也有提到我們的製造業也好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147872/39.wav", + "text": "各領域也好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147872/40.wav", + "text": "有一些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147872/41.wav", + "text": "所謂的外籍移工" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147872/42.wav", + "text": "也有占了相當多的比例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147872/43.wav", + "text": "現在的移工人數是多少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147872/44.wav", + "text": "現在移工人數" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147872/45.wav", + "text": "大概是70萬人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147872/46.wav", + "text": "這70萬人所領的薪資有算到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147872/47.wav", + "text": "臺灣的統計裡面嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147872/48.wav", + "text": "因為一般外籍移工的薪資大概" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147872/49.wav", + "text": "跟國內的勞工比起來是相對於比較" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147872/50.wav", + "text": "接近基本工資對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147872/51.wav", + "text": "對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147872/52.wav", + "text": "所��他們領多少薪資也會影響到這個計算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147872/53.wav", + "text": "所以如果有一天我們的外" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147872/54.wav", + "text": "籍移工的人數占比如果再提升" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147872/55.wav", + "text": "也可能會影響到這個統計數字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147872/56.wav", + "text": "因為現在政府好像有打算要再多開放一些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147872/57.wav", + "text": "外籍移工來到臺灣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147872/58.wav", + "text": "對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147872/59.wav", + "text": "據估計也可能" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147872/60.wav", + "text": "大概在5萬到78萬之間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147872/61.wav", + "text": "這些逃跑外勞所領的薪水你怎麼有辦法統計得到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147872/62.wav", + "text": "沒有辦法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147872/63.wav", + "text": "對啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147872/64.wav", + "text": "所以那個沒有在這個統計數字裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147872/65.wav", + "text": "某一家企業我現在不講合不合法的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147872/66.wav", + "text": "它用了3個逃跑的外籍移工" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147872/67.wav", + "text": "結果他的企業裡面這3個外籍移工的薪資" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147872/68.wav", + "text": "該給他的就沒有算到統計數字裡面來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147872/69.wav", + "text": "對我們在做五年一次工商普查的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147872/70.wav", + "text": "會有一些校正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147872/71.wav", + "text": "剛剛的對答裡面也有很多是有道理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147872/72.wav", + "text": "但是我覺得也有一些聽起來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147872/73.wav", + "text": "應該要把觀念再講得更仔細" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147872/74.wav", + "text": "更正確一點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147872/75.wav", + "text": "他說薪資都沒有增加我是反對這一點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147872/76.wav", + "text": "其實這幾年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147872/77.wav", + "text": "個別的薪資有沒有增加我們是不知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147872/78.wav", + "text": "當然就勞工的角度來講可能不滿意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147872/79.wav", + "text": "可是就雇主的角度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147872/80.wav", + "text": "──商業總會等等這一類的團體" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147872/81.wav", + "text": "每次都在那邊哀哀叫說你們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147872/82.wav", + "text": "讓經營者更加的困難等等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147872/83.wav", + "text": "是不是有這樣的狀況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147872/84.wav", + "text": "對是有這樣的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147872/85.wav", + "text": "這個狀況不過我必須說明一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147872/86.wav", + "text": "有關我們的薪資沒有增加" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147872/87.wav", + "text": "我的報告第五頁裡面有一個表" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147872/88.wav", + "text": "因為最近物價比較波動" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147872/89.wav", + "text": "所以實質薪資" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147872/90.wav", + "text": "是有比較下降的趨勢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147872/91.wav", + "text": "但是還是正成長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147872/92.wav", + "text": "實質薪資到去年都還正成長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147872/93.wav", + "text": "但是今年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147872/94.wav", + "text": "最近幾個月有負成長的現象" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147872/95.wav", + "text": "所以就不知道了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147872/96.wav", + "text": "我的意思是說在基本觀念上面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147872/97.wav", + "text": "要更精進" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147872/98.wav", + "text": "應該是這樣講薪資增加的速度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147872/99.wav", + "text": "不如預期" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147872/100.wav", + "text": "而不是說每一年薪資都沒有增加" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147872/101.wav", + "text": "我覺得扣這樣的帽子很奇怪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147872/102.wav", + "text": "因為在我來看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147872/103.wav", + "text": "每一年的基本工資都有在增加" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147872/104.wav", + "text": "而且基本工資增加" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147872/105.wav", + "text": "的比例是3%4%" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147872/106.wav", + "text": "或許還不能盡如人意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147872/107.wav", + "text": "但是就雇主跟勞工的角度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147872/108.wav", + "text": "都各有意見對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147872/109.wav", + "text": "是因為我們今年（112年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147872/110.wav", + "text": "外銷情況比較差" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147872/111.wav", + "text": "的報酬比較低" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147872/112.wav", + "text": "所以會有這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147872/113.wav", + "text": "外銷情況變好了以後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147872/114.wav", + "text": "這種現象會改善" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147872/115.wav", + "text": "好剛剛這是統計數字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147872/116.wav", + "text": "我要問有關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147872/117.wav", + "text": "有關現在中低收入戶的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147872/118.wav", + "text": "請問現在臺灣的中低收入戶大概有多少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147872/119.wav", + "text": "中低收入戶看看是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147872/120.wav", + "text": "怎麼定義" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147872/121.wav", + "text": "按照一般我們的定義" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147872/122.wav", + "text": "低收入戶的占比大概是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147872/123.wav", + "text": "我們的低收入戶資料" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147872/124.wav", + "text": "大概是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147872/125.wav", + "text": "百分比是不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147872/126.wav", + "text": "總戶數的百分之二點多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147872/127.wav", + "text": "那中低收入戶呢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147872/128.wav", + "text": "我現在問的是中低收入戶" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147872/129.wav", + "text": "因為低收入戶的收入真的很少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147872/130.wav", + "text": "那中低收入戶的比例大概是多少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147872/131.wav", + "text": "低收入戶跟中低" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147872/132.wav", + "text": "合起來大概是百分之五點多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147872/133.wav", + "text": "五點多%" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147872/134.wav", + "text": "也就是說大概20個家庭裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147872/135.wav", + "text": "有1個是屬於這樣的家庭" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147872/136.wav", + "text": "問一個比較實際的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147872/137.wav", + "text": "如果你要讓這些中低收入戶" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147872/138.wav", + "text": "能夠過生活的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147872/139.wav", + "text": "有關計算中低收入戶的基準" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147872/140.wav", + "text": "要適時向上拉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147872/141.wav", + "text": "我不知道數字我是舉例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147872/142.wav", + "text": "30萬以下算中低收入戶" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147872/143.wav", + "text": "假設是這樣隨著物價指數的提升" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147872/144.wav", + "text": "這個數字要往上拉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147872/145.wav", + "text": "不要經年不動" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147872/146.wav", + "text": "補助是每四年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147872/147.wav", + "text": "隨著物價指數會調" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147872/148.wav", + "text": "明年的1月1號就會調" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147872/149.wav", + "text": "會調多少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147872/150.wav", + "text": "我現在手頭沒有帶資料我們會補給委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147872/151.wav", + "text": "如果我沒記錯" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147872/152.wav", + "text": "大概會調百分之四到五之間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147872/153.wav", + "text": "比CPI還要高" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147872/154.wav", + "text": "但是這是四年累積的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147872/155.wav", + "text": "對是四年的累積" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147872/156.wav", + "text": "不只4%到5" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147872/157.wav", + "text": "有一年CPI是負但" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147872/158.wav", + "text": "我覺得這幾年加起來一定不只4%到5" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147872/159.wav", + "text": "%我在這邊要為中低收入戶請命" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147872/160.wav", + "text": "為什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147872/161.wav", + "text": "因為其實你在這邊講說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147872/162.wav", + "text": "萬一國人全部都變有錢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147872/163.wav", + "text": "它的貧富差距" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147872/164.wav", + "text": "也一樣不一定會縮小" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147872/165.wav", + "text": "但是我們整個國家整個社會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147872/166.wav", + "text": "最需要照顧的是這些中低收入者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147872/167.wav", + "text": "我們不能讓他掉落到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147872/168.wav", + "text": "社會安全網之外嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147872/169.wav", + "text": "所以在疫情期間尤其是到去年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147872/170.wav", + "text": "都還有我們的中低收入戶" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147872/171.wav", + "text": "都有加對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147872/172.wav", + "text": "說適時檢討中低收入戶" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147872/173.wav", + "text": "不應該四年才檢討一次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147872/174.wav", + "text": "中低收入戶的生活" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147872/175.wav", + "text": "今天新聞上看到一個好消息" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147872/176.wav", + "text": "以前還有來服務處陳情的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147872/177.wav", + "text": "民眾她明明就已經活不下去了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147872/178.wav", + "text": "然後還跟她講說對不起" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147872/179.wav", + "text": "你不符合資格什麼原因不符合資格" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147872/180.wav", + "text": "她娘家那一邊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147872/181.wav", + "text": "的兄弟共有的祖厝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147872/182.wav", + "text": "因為她是嫁出去的女兒" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147872/183.wav", + "text": "在臺灣人的習慣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147872/184.wav", + "text": "上這已經跟她無關了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147872/185.wav", + "text": "但是在法律上面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147872/186.wav", + "text": "將來她還是有繼承權" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147872/187.wav", + "text": "還把她算一份" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147872/188.wav", + "text": "所以把它計入中低收入戶的基準" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147872/189.wav", + "text": "今天有說要把這個東西" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147872/190.wav", + "text": "檢討拿掉我認為是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147872/191.wav", + "text": "相當有道理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147872/192.wav", + "text": "所以我們的社會福利法尤其是社會救助法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147872/193.wav", + "text": "可以來討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147872/194.wav", + "text": "對除了這個要討論之外另外我是希望" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147872/195.wav", + "text": "這幾年我都認為你的工作" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147872/196.wav", + "text": "年年要注意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147872/197.wav", + "text": "中低收入戶的基準" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147872/198.wav", + "text": "的這些人真正辛苦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147872/199.wav", + "text": "的不是20%" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147872/200.wav", + "text": "是這5%" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147872/201.wav", + "text": "如果他真的掉出社會安全網沒有辦法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147872/202.wav", + "text": "承接的時候他其實就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147872/203.wav", + "text": "活不下去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147872/204.wav", + "text": "大家共同來努力謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147872/205.wav", + "text": "希望你能夠瞭解" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147872/206.wav", + "text": "我們的目的加油" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147872/207.wav", + "text": "謝謝謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147872/208.wav", + "text": "各位請回" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147871/0.wav", + "text": "委員好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147871/1.wav", + "text": "部長早" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147871/2.wav", + "text": "其實我們都會期待" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147871/3.wav", + "text": "就是大概會有什麼樣的一個新的政策" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147871/4.wav", + "text": "特教法經過大修" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147871/5.wav", + "text": "本席全程參與" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147871/6.wav", + "text": "家長團體" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147871/7.wav", + "text": "特教團體也全程在監看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147871/8.wav", + "text": "14年沒有修的特教法坦白講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147871/9.wav", + "text": "各界期待很深" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147871/10.wav", + "text": "也感謝教育部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147871/11.wav", + "text": "從去年的131.4億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147871/12.wav", + "text": "看起來是增加了21億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147871/13.wav", + "text": "占教育部的預算比例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147871/14.wav", + "text": "特教預算是4.51" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147871/15.wav", + "text": "%反而比112年度的4.53%下降" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147871/16.wav", + "text": "為什麼會有這個現象" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147871/17.wav", + "text": "呢其實部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147871/18.wav", + "text": "過去這一任裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147871/19.wav", + "text": "三年多來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147871/20.wav", + "text": "我們教育部跟行政院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147871/21.wav", + "text": "定了很多專案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147871/22.wav", + "text": "包括班班有冷氣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147871/23.wav", + "text": "編了357.9億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147871/24.wav", + "text": "補助地方" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147871/25.wav", + "text": "我看地方如果按照那個預算跟中央配合" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147871/26.wav", + "text": "大概要20年才能夠達到班班有冷氣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147871/27.wav", + "text": "也定了一個200億左右的生生有平板" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147871/28.wav", + "text": "建置高國中小學" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147871/29.wav", + "text": "國教的數位環境學習環境" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147871/30.wav", + "text": "像運動環境的改善也編了50億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147871/31.wav", + "text": "地方也非常有感" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147871/32.wav", + "text": "\n但是今年在審特教法的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147871/33.wav", + "text": "本席本來想要把4.5%的預算提高到5%" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147871/34.wav", + "text": "因為違反財政紀律法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147871/35.wav", + "text": "所以我們不要去修" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147871/36.wav", + "text": "但承諾一定會增加預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147871/37.wav", + "text": "我們看到預算數字是增加了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147871/38.wav", + "text": "部長但比例卻降低了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147871/39.wav", + "text": "為什麼我這樣說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147871/40.wav", + "text": "我們看一看回顧一下當時本席做的附帶決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147871/41.wav", + "text": "其實我們在特教法修了之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147871/42.wav", + "text": "增加了非常多的項目" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147871/43.wav", + "text": "包括我們普特融合教育的推動" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147871/44.wav", + "text": "學前教育階段特殊教育的實施" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147871/45.wav", + "text": "包括校園無障礙設施的改善" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147871/46.wav", + "text": "包括分散式資源班師生比的降低" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147871/47.wav", + "text": "包括特教教師超額負擔" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147871/48.wav", + "text": "包括特教助理員合理的待遇" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147871/49.wav", + "text": "包括特教學生支持服務系統建置" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147871/50.wav", + "text": "包括資優及雙殊教育的重視" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147871/51.wav", + "text": "包括第2期特殊教育的中程計畫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147871/52.wav", + "text": "這還是在我的附帶決議裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147871/53.wav", + "text": "看得到的項目" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147871/54.wav", + "text": "這些項目我們增加了二十一點多億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147871/55.wav", + "text": "21億左右" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147871/56.wav", + "text": "為什麼特教經費總數增加" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147871/57.wav", + "text": "比例卻減少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147871/58.wav", + "text": "從預算來看是這樣子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147871/59.wav", + "text": "我們其實也看到上個月底" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147871/60.wav", + "text": "教育部規劃說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147871/61.wav", + "text": "回應我們特教法的修法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147871/62.wav", + "text": "4年要增聘1,600位特教助理員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147871/63.wav", + "text": "因為現場已經受不了了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147871/64.wav", + "text": "其實我們看看去年在審的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147871/65.wav", + "text": "很多大學端的家長團體" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147871/66.wav", + "text": "包括高中以下的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147871/67.wav", + "text": "你看111年112年113年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147871/68.wav", + "text": "111年8億10億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147871/69.wav", + "text": "明年要編到14億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147871/70.wav", + "text": "高中以下的45億50億到64億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147871/71.wav", + "text": "大學端我們當時也有很多檢討" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147871/72.wav", + "text": "我們經費確實都增加了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147871/73.wav", + "text": "但夠嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147871/74.wav", + "text": "來回應這樣夠嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147871/75.wav", + "text": "\n我們來討論一下特教助理員的待遇" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147871/76.wav", + "text": "本席在上個禮拜" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147871/77.wav", + "text": "曾經到臺中啟聰學校現場去看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147871/78.wav", + "text": "應家長團體的陳情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147871/79.wav", + "text": "我看了真的心裡滿難過的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147871/80.wav", + "text": "就是我們的特教助理員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147871/81.wav", + "text": "來我們看一下六都的特教助理員的比較" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147871/82.wav", + "text": "臺北市是最好的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147871/83.wav", + "text": "他的月薪是3萬2,425元起薪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147871/84.wav", + "text": "如果他的年資增加敘薪增加" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147871/85.wav", + "text": "他會到四萬兩千多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147871/86.wav", + "text": "而且有晉薪的制度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147871/87.wav", + "text": "有年終獎金" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147871/88.wav", + "text": "薪資待遇就停在2萬8,534" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147871/89.wav", + "text": "元而且" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147871/90.wav", + "text": "沒有任何敘薪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147871/91.wav", + "text": "晉薪的制度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147871/92.wav", + "text": "桃園本來舊制是有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147871/93.wav", + "text": "從3萬6到4萬2" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147871/94.wav", + "text": "新制反而降到2萬8" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147871/95.wav", + "text": "齊一標準" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147871/96.wav", + "text": "學臺中跟新北比較不好的制度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147871/97.wav", + "text": "是停留在2萬8,534" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147871/98.wav", + "text": "元我現在是講月薪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147871/99.wav", + "text": "喔還不講時薪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147871/100.wav", + "text": "臺南高雄有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147871/101.wav", + "text": "但是也是從2萬62萬8起薪到3萬6左右" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147871/102.wav", + "text": "頒定了一個標準是中庸的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147871/103.wav", + "text": "兩萬八千多到三萬六千多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147871/104.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147871/105.wav", + "text": "規劃開始4年徵聘" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147871/106.wav", + "text": "1,600位特教助理員來改善" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147871/107.wav", + "text": "我們特殊教育的第一現場" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147871/108.wav", + "text": "那他們的待遇又如何呢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147871/109.wav", + "text": "我們看一下���福體系跟社福體系的比較" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147871/110.wav", + "text": "國教署所設計的特教助理員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147871/111.wav", + "text": "的薪點跟各方面制度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147871/112.wav", + "text": "月薪是2萬8,534元到3萬6,316" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147871/113.wav", + "text": "元時薪是176到211" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147871/114.wav", + "text": "元長照居服員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147871/115.wav", + "text": "2018年的均薪已經到3萬8,498" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147871/116.wav", + "text": "元時薪也至少223" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147871/117.wav", + "text": "元跟" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147871/118.wav", + "text": "特教助理員比較相近的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147871/119.wav", + "text": "從26k到30k" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147871/120.wav", + "text": "明年開始要調到33.7k了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147871/121.wav", + "text": "低薪的教保員30到34k" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147871/122.wav", + "text": "也調到37.7k了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147871/123.wav", + "text": "我請教一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147871/124.wav", + "text": "部長你說增加了1,600位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147871/125.wav", + "text": "他們的調薪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147871/126.wav", + "text": "明年如果按照公務人員調4%之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147871/127.wav", + "text": "其實都接近3萬了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147871/128.wav", + "text": "那你說3萬以上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147871/129.wav", + "text": "真的夠嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147871/130.wav", + "text": "今年開學" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147871/131.wav", + "text": "特教學校找不到特教助理員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147871/132.wav", + "text": "找不到時薪的學生助理員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147871/133.wav", + "text": "還沒有像啟聰學校" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147871/134.wav", + "text": "都是中重度的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147871/135.wav", + "text": "那些特教助理員那麼辛苦的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147871/136.wav", + "text": "也找不到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147871/137.wav", + "text": "所以部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147871/138.wav", + "text": "我想請教" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147871/139.wav", + "text": "我剛才講的這些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147871/140.wav", + "text": "就是說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147871/141.wav", + "text": "我們國教署" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147871/142.wav", + "text": "是不是應該要帶頭起薪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147871/143.wav", + "text": "落漆衛福體系社福體系都比我們高" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147871/144.wav", + "text": "比照身障機構的生活服務員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147871/145.wav", + "text": "對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147871/146.wav", + "text": "補助特教助理員的經費" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147871/147.wav", + "text": "可是你看看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147871/148.wav", + "text": "六都一國好幾制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147871/149.wav", + "text": "所以特教法大修了之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147871/150.wav", + "text": "明年開始" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147871/151.wav", + "text": "我們增加了這些預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147871/152.wav", + "text": "各縣市如果薪資都還是不一" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147871/153.wav", + "text": "那我們在現場的這些家長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147871/154.wav", + "text": "跟特教生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147871/155.wav", + "text": "真的足夠嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147871/156.wav", + "text": "部長你回應我" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147871/157.wav", + "text": "我先回應委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147871/158.wav", + "text": "整個特教經費" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147871/159.wav", + "text": "今年教育的總預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147871/160.wav", + "text": "已經跨過23%的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147871/161.wav", + "text": "比那個門檻還增加了兩百多億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147871/162.wav", + "text": "為什麼不是用最高的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147871/163.wav", + "text": "換句話說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147871/164.wav", + "text": "我們教育資源增加" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147871/165.wav", + "text": "但特教資源的增加幅度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147871/166.wav", + "text": "是低於我們整體教育" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147871/167.wav", + "text": "應該這樣子講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147871/168.wav", + "text": "因為實質增加21億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147871/169.wav", + "text": "委員剛才你那個列表" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147871/170.wav", + "text": "過去如果只是在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147871/171.wav", + "text": "講那個比例門檻" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147871/172.wav", + "text": "那差異很大" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147871/173.wav", + "text": "今年會增加21億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147871/174.wav", + "text": "主要是當時我也評估" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147871/175.wav", + "text": "整體的教育預算應該要增加" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147871/176.wav", + "text": "所以也謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147871/177.wav", + "text": "行政院主計總處這邊的支持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147871/178.wav", + "text": "這個我了解" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147871/179.wav", + "text": "對所以它增加21億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147871/180.wav", + "text": "這個大概是過去幾年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147871/181.wav", + "text": "累積都沒有這個額度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147871/182.wav", + "text": "這個我剛才一開始就感謝了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147871/183.wav", + "text": "但是我是要提醒部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147871/184.wav", + "text": "我說我們其實" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147871/185.wav", + "text": "14年沒有修的特教法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147871/186.wav", + "text": "在修法的過程裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147871/187.wav", + "text": "來自於高中以下的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147871/188.wav", + "text": "這些學生團體跟大學端" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147871/189.wav", + "text": "他們有不斷地陳情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147871/190.wav", + "text": "每一個立委都收到了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147871/191.wav", + "text": "所以我的意思就是說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147871/192.wav", + "text": "其實我們因為14年的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147871/193.wav", + "text": "我們剛才提到說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147871/194.wav", + "text": "不管是學生那種班班有冷氣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147871/195.wav", + "text": "或者是生生有平板" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147871/196.wav", + "text": "這種專案改善" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147871/197.wav", + "text": "我覺得特教生的學習環境" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147871/198.wav", + "text": "你看十七萬多的特教學生是增加的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147871/199.wav", + "text": "為什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147871/200.wav", + "text": "因為以前沒有被鑑別出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147871/201.wav", + "text": "以前不想送去學校" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147871/202.wav", + "text": "現在送去了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147871/203.wav", + "text": "那我們的資源" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147871/204.wav", + "text": "如果還停留在那樣的階段" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147871/205.wav", + "text": "的特教生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147871/206.wav", + "text": "沒有受到好的學習環境" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147871/207.wav", + "text": "大學端也一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147871/208.wav", + "text": "所以我認為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147871/209.wav", + "text": "部長你應該好好思考" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147871/210.wav", + "text": "跟行政院反映一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147871/211.wav", + "text": "我們特教法修了這樣子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147871/212.wav", + "text": "我們增加21億沒有錯" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147871/213.wav", + "text": "這十七萬多人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147871/214.wav", + "text": "就十七萬多個家庭" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147871/215.wav", + "text": "我們現在有很多專案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147871/216.wav", + "text": "都在改善弱勢家庭" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147871/217.wav", + "text": "租金補貼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147871/218.wav", + "text": "學費補貼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147871/219.wav", + "text": "但這些特教生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147871/220.wav", + "text": "17萬個家庭" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147871/221.wav", + "text": "到底夠不夠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147871/222.wav", + "text": "我跟委員接續報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147871/223.wav", + "text": "也因為有這21億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147871/224.wav", + "text": "往後應該也會以這樣的一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147871/225.wav", + "text": "延續的成長才能去規劃" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147871/226.wav", + "text": "特教法後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147871/227.wav", + "text": "我們所需的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147871/228.wav", + "text": "包含像委員講的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147871/229.wav", + "text": "特教助理員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147871/230.wav", + "text": "我完全認同" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147871/231.wav", + "text": "30k是不夠的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147871/232.wav", + "text": "對的我們應該再努" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147871/233.wav", + "text": "再努力跟各縣市" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147871/234.wav", + "text": "做一個溝通" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147871/235.wav", + "text": "我去現場看的感受" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147871/236.wav", + "text": "如果是在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147871/237.wav", + "text": "各國中小的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147871/238.wav", + "text": "坦白講是比較輕度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147871/239.wav", + "text": "中度的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147871/240.wav", + "text": "已經都還有家長去現場" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147871/241.wav", + "text": "輔助老師跟學生助理員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147871/242.wav", + "text": "或者是所謂的特教助理員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147871/243.wav", + "text": "老師才有辦法教" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147871/244.wav", + "text": "在啟聰學校" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147871/245.wav", + "text": "那種比較中重度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147871/246.wav", + "text": "或極重度的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147871/247.wav", + "text": "他要餵食" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147871/248.wav", + "text": "上廁所要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147871/249.wav", + "text": "1比10" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147871/250.wav", + "text": "也是1比10" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147871/251.wav", + "text": "一般的融合教育也是1比10" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147871/252.wav", + "text": "老師沒有辦法教" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147871/253.wav", + "text": "在啟聰學校沒辦法教" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147871/254.wav", + "text": "他只能跟特教助理員一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147871/255.wav", + "text": "就是去幫忙這些特教助理員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147871/256.wav", + "text": "去幫忙照顧" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147871/257.wav", + "text": "我了解" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147871/258.wav", + "text": "一般融合教育的資源班" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147871/259.wav", + "text": "跟我們的啟聰學校裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147871/260.wav", + "text": "或比較需要照顧的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147871/261.wav", + "text": "這個的比例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147871/262.wav", + "text": "也應該做一些改善" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147871/263.wav", + "text": "所以這一次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147871/264.wav", + "text": "增加特教的經費" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147871/265.wav", + "text": "其實也" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147871/266.wav", + "text": "我們委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147871/267.wav", + "text": "為什麼會提出" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147871/268.wav", + "text": "以及增加服務時數" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147871/269.wav", + "text": "因為這是融合教育當中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147871/270.wav", + "text": "在普通班裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147871/271.wav", + "text": "一定要的支持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147871/272.wav", + "text": "還有一些孩子的特別需求" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147871/273.wav", + "text": "另外像心評工作的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147871/274.wav", + "text": "我知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147871/275.wav", + "text": "這個我都" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147871/276.wav", + "text": "對對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147871/277.wav", + "text": "相關的特教經費落實" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147871/278.wav", + "text": "所以今年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147871/279.wav", + "text": "擴大21億元的費用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147871/280.wav", + "text": "都是要啟動後面這幾年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147871/281.wav", + "text": "所需要的這些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147871/282.wav", + "text": "這個我都肯定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147871/283.wav", + "text": "這是一系列的計畫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147871/284.wav", + "text": "這個我都肯定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147871/285.wav", + "text": "我剛剛有提到一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147871/286.wav", + "text": "薪資的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147871/287.wav", + "text": "看清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147871/288.wav", + "text": "這些特教助理員非常辛苦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147871/289.wav", + "text": "為什麼學校會請不到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147871/290.wav", + "text": "他的薪資待遇" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147871/291.wav", + "text": "我還沒講時薪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147871/292.wav", + "text": "時薪真的是更少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147871/293.wav", + "text": "沒有人要去做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147871/294.wav", + "text": "找不到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147871/295.wav", + "text": "都是��長自己跑去學校" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147871/296.wav", + "text": "甚至老師去幫忙" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147871/297.wav", + "text": "學校的愛心志工協助" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147871/298.wav", + "text": "這個對嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147871/299.wav", + "text": "我們看一下長照的居服員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147871/300.wav", + "text": "2018年到三萬八千多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147871/301.wav", + "text": "身障機構的生活服務員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147871/302.wav", + "text": "明年也調到33.7K" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147871/303.wav", + "text": "K部長只跟我們說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147871/304.wav", + "text": "增加1,600位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147871/305.wav", + "text": "每位會在3萬以上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147871/306.wav", + "text": "3萬夠嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147871/307.wav", + "text": "請得到人嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147871/308.wav", + "text": "這些現場的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147871/309.wav", + "text": "特教生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147871/310.wav", + "text": "被照顧及重視的程度夠嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147871/311.wav", + "text": "委員國教署正在就" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147871/312.wav", + "text": "幾個系列的計畫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147871/313.wav", + "text": "做這方面的研擬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147871/314.wav", + "text": "委員今天有特別提到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147871/315.wav", + "text": "包含時薪及" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147871/316.wav", + "text": "我想我們會朝向" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147871/317.wav", + "text": "這要跟縣市做一個溝通" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147871/318.wav", + "text": "兩個問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147871/319.wav", + "text": "第一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147871/320.wav", + "text": "我們在審預算的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147871/321.wav", + "text": "我真的會詢問" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147871/322.wav", + "text": "你們1,600位的特教助理員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147871/323.wav", + "text": "跟生活助理員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147871/324.wav", + "text": "不管是月薪時薪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147871/325.wav", + "text": "你們有沒有打算要調高" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147871/326.wav", + "text": "要不要比照" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147871/327.wav", + "text": "身障機構的生活服務員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147871/328.wav", + "text": "他是最像的嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147871/329.wav", + "text": "至少不低於嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147871/330.wav", + "text": "這是第一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147871/331.wav", + "text": "第二個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147871/332.wav", + "text": "六都都說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147871/333.wav", + "text": "這是他們的自治管理權限" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147871/334.wav", + "text": "做一年是兩萬八" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147871/335.wav", + "text": "沒有晉薪制度的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147871/336.wav", + "text": "你們有沒有要去協調" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147871/337.wav", + "text": "這個以前有些學校的代理教師" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147871/338.wav", + "text": "在暑假寒假沒有薪水" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147871/339.wav", + "text": "現在不是都有了嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147871/340.wav", + "text": "這當然是地方的權限" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147871/341.wav", + "text": "但是由中央補助" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147871/342.wav", + "text": "所以我們怎麼協調" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147871/343.wav", + "text": "這兩個問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147871/344.wav", + "text": "我審預算一定會再問" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147871/345.wav", + "text": "因為今天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147871/346.wav", + "text": "主席給的時間不夠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147871/347.wav", + "text": "坦白講我只能問這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147871/348.wav", + "text": "體育的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147871/349.wav", + "text": "在審預算的時候我一樣會問" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147871/350.wav", + "text": "我審預算的時候一定會再提" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147871/351.wav", + "text": "擬出具體的方案來回應" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147871/352.wav", + "text": "部長我講的方向是對的吧" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147871/353.wav", + "text": "我想協調縣市" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147871/354.wav", + "text": "把一些制度建立起來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147871/355.wav", + "text": "包含待遇部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147871/356.wav", + "text": "還有特教助理員的薪資待遇" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147871/357.wav", + "text": "還有中重度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147871/358.wav", + "text": "及輕度的這些員額比例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147871/359.wav", + "text": "其實是不夠的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147871/360.wav", + "text": "確實從這次特教法的修法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147871/361.wav", + "text": "往後要發展得比較好的基礎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147871/362.wav", + "text": "我們持續" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147871/363.wav", + "text": "這是一個起點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147871/364.wav", + "text": "修法就是一個起點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147871/365.wav", + "text": "第一年這樣的經費" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147871/366.wav", + "text": "我知道你們已經" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147871/367.wav", + "text": "在挪了但我覺得比例真的還是不夠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147871/368.wav", + "text": "我希望審預算的時候能夠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147871/369.wav", + "text": "詳細回復本席" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147871/370.wav", + "text": "謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147871/371.wav", + "text": "好部長請回" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147871/372.wav", + "text": "謝謝張廖萬堅委員的質詢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147871/373.wav", + "text": "\n再來我們請陳靜敏" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147870/0.wav", + "text": "謝謝主席各位首長各位同仁大家好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147870/1.wav", + "text": "首先我先跟著剛才謝委員提到的弊端請教一下秘書長好了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147870/2.wav", + "text": "看到的應該是炒股比較多或者接受招待" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147870/3.wav", + "text": "就炒股票啦應該是沒有錯嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147870/4.wav", + "text": "炒股票不是炒低應該是炒高" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147870/5.wav", + "text": "而且大家不爽的是拿大家的錢下去買特定股票" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147870/6.wav", + "text": "然後他自己跟著買跟著賺錢沒有錯吧" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147870/7.wav", + "text": "所以如果以結論來看的話某種程度他把它炒高了之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147870/8.wav", + "text": "如果他把它變現可能對基金還有挹注會不會是這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147870/9.wav", + "text": "這個細節我就沒有很瞭解就是跟打假球一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147870/10.wav", + "text": "棒球如果打假球吃禁藥吃禁藥導致全壘打多是球隊贏" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147870/11.wav", + "text": "但是如果他收錢放水那是球隊輸" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147870/12.wav", + "text": "過去臺灣發生的是因為薪資低所以放水" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147870/13.wav", + "text": "放水之後球隊就輸掉了所以其他隊員就很不甘願" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147870/14.wav", + "text": "他認為他打擊率這麼高投手盡力了結果隊員放水" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147870/15.wav", + "text": "不管是給對手暗號或是用什麼方式導致球隊輸掉了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147870/16.wav", + "text": "但是現在在比的美國職棒大聯盟的比賽" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147870/17.wav", + "text": "他們的犯規都是吃禁藥讓自己成績好身價高" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147870/18.wav", + "text": "結果球隊的戰績反而好大家就不甘願" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147870/19.wav", + "text": "不甘願是因為他吃禁藥所以造成自然體質的選手" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147870/20.wav", + "text": "比輸他但是對球隊整體來說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147870/21.wav", + "text": "他那一種作弊美國職棒那種作弊是有益的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147870/22.wav", + "text": "但是我們政府的基金操作是不能靠作弊這樣你理解我的意思嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147870/23.wav", + "text": "我要釐清一下這個弊端的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147870/24.wav", + "text": "當然他是操守的問題被抓去關是活該的不應該" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147870/25.wav", + "text": "如此因為他也有可能會接受飲宴" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147870/26.wav", + "text": "特別用我們的基金去買特定的股票他有可能會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147870/27.wav", + "text": "但那種股票通常來說也有點問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147870/28.wav", + "text": "希望用國家這種基金的資源讓它的話題炒高一點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147870/29.wav", + "text": "然後有些人在這中間賺一手" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147870/30.wav", + "text": "但是它整體上並不會造成我們的虧損" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147870/31.wav", + "text": "或可預期的獲利減低這個是道理啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147870/32.wav", + "text": "至於剛才謝委員希望每一年都有10%" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147870/33.wav", + "text": "那不太可能是因為臺灣的景氣狀況好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147870/34.wav", + "text": "所以整體來說在平均以上已經厲害了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147870/35.wav", + "text": "但是以後儲金制你可能可以選擇或怎麼樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147870/36.wav", + "text": "大概自己眼光好就會好一點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147870/37.wav", + "text": "我只是要講這個弊端並不是造成基金少賺" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147870/38.wav", + "text": "弊端是不行但是它的結果對基金來說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147870/39.wav", + "text": "並不是影響那麼大而且盤子幾千億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147870/40.wav", + "text": "就是這樣的平衡會造成少數的狀況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147870/41.wav", + "text": "不管是弊端或者有些公司經營不善" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147870/42.wav", + "text": "或者整體大盤怎麼樣它還是有一個平衡感" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147870/43.wav", + "text": "你還是會有一定的獲利平均" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147870/44.wav", + "text": "應該是這樣才對解釋一下而已" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147870/45.wav", + "text": "\n今天在講退撫基金的缺口" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147870/46.wav", + "text": "得四平八穩我來跟你們討論一下是不是這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147870/47.wav", + "text": "我們之前的退撫舊制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147870/48.wav", + "text": "大家���稱18%其實也不止18%" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147870/49.wav", + "text": "是84年22歲進來於65歲退休的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147870/50.wav", + "text": "大概是127年之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147870/51.wav", + "text": "我們適用舊制的全部退休這個有沒有錯" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147870/52.wav", + "text": "大概再十多年全舊制的就退休了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147870/53.wav", + "text": "如果餘命到82歲大概144年之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147870/54.wav", + "text": "如果依照法定退休年齡來算應該大概是這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147870/55.wav", + "text": "但是那個平均餘命因為還會再變動" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147870/56.wav", + "text": "當然當然希望延長啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147870/57.wav", + "text": "退撫新制這個名詞也怪怪的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147870/58.wav", + "text": "害我們後面還寫錯" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147870/59.wav", + "text": "簡報右下角的舊制那兩個字應該是新制才對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147870/60.wav", + "text": "制如果最後一位112年進來的22歲同仁" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147870/61.wav", + "text": "平均餘命也算82歲大概172年之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147870/62.wav", + "text": "退休的人都是退撫儲金制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147870/63.wav", + "text": "應該是這樣沒有錯" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147870/64.wav", + "text": "在這次年改已經結束的退撫新制來看的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147870/65.wav", + "text": "退撫基金要負的責任是到172年左右" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147870/66.wav", + "text": "所以我們還有60年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147870/67.wav", + "text": "從現在開始大概有60年可以慢慢的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147870/68.wav", + "text": "挹注這樣的講法有沒有錯" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147870/69.wav", + "text": "部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147870/70.wav", + "text": "就是基金制差不多到172年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147870/71.wav", + "text": "還有60年可以慢慢來補助" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147870/72.wav", + "text": "所以今天的專題報告說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147870/73.wav", + "text": "有沒有缺口我是覺得看起來好像沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147870/74.wav", + "text": "我算給你們看看有沒有算錯" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147870/75.wav", + "text": "也釐清一下大家的觀念" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147870/76.wav", + "text": "到目前為止的精算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147870/77.wav", + "text": "未來50年我們可能的負債" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147870/78.wav", + "text": "是3兆4,800億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147870/79.wav", + "text": "大概3兆5,000億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147870/80.wav", + "text": "我們目前算得出來的提撥" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147870/81.wav", + "text": "但是大家也慢慢繳會提存進去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147870/82.wav", + "text": "部長這有沒有錯" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147870/83.wav", + "text": "如果照著我們111年的決算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147870/84.wav", + "text": "應該提撥的是1,422億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147870/85.wav", + "text": "實際上是1,212億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147870/86.wav", + "text": "中間還有些短差" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147870/87.wav", + "text": "應該也沒有錯" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147870/88.wav", + "text": "好再下來我們看一下113年度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147870/89.wav", + "text": "各基金的補助跟挹注" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147870/90.wav", + "text": "退輔會有133億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147870/91.wav", + "text": "銓敘部有65.8億加50億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147870/92.wav", + "text": "教育部有104億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147870/93.wav", + "text": "合計有354億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147870/94.wav", + "text": "這個也沒有錯" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147870/95.wav", + "text": "差額大概會有210億是剛剛算的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147870/96.wav", + "text": "也就是9月的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147870/97.wav", + "text": "全教總去抗爭的意思在這邊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147870/98.wav", + "text": "看起來這個差額很大" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147870/99.wav", + "text": "也會有年改成果的挹注" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147870/100.wav", + "text": "我覺得這個事實上是沒有缺口" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147870/101.wav", + "text": "怎麼講呢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147870/102.wav", + "text": "我們來看一下年改的成效" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147870/103.wav", + "text": "新制舊制的年改成效" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147870/104.wav", + "text": "大概就是18%的補貼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147870/105.wav", + "text": "它的高峰在103年（2014年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147870/106.wav", + "text": "）高峰569億已經過去了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147870/107.wav", + "text": "然後113年（2024年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147870/108.wav", + "text": "所以我們每一年從高峰到現在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147870/109.wav", + "text": "已經減少支出388億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147870/110.wav", + "text": "部長這個有沒有錯" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147870/111.wav", + "text": "如果你不熟局長回答也沒關係" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147870/112.wav", + "text": "應該是這樣嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147870/113.wav", + "text": "是年改節省的經費" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147870/114.wav", + "text": "對就是第一次新制舊制的交替" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147870/115.wav", + "text": "18%省下來的支出減少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147870/116.wav", + "text": "這是多的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147870/117.wav", + "text": "我們新的年改精神也希望" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147870/118.wav", + "text": "這個應該大部分要補助回去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147870/119.wav", + "text": "未來的50年我們的負債是3兆4,800" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147870/120.wav", + "text": "要發出去的大概是2兆7,000" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147870/121.wav", + "text": "億剛剛講也沒有錯" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147870/122.wav", + "text": "大概是這個數字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147870/123.wav", + "text": "所以我們去看那個2兆7,000億是不是缺口" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147870/124.wav", + "text": "政府一定要下去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147870/125.wav", + "text": "這個才是今天這個基金缺口" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147870/126.wav", + "text": "要如何補的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147870/127.wav", + "text": "我看起來毫無缺口的理論是這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147870/128.wav", + "text": "啦這個數字不會錯" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147870/129.wav", + "text": "因為這是精算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147870/130.wav", + "text": "每一個人都算得出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147870/131.wav", + "text": "\n我看起來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147870/132.wav", + "text": "收入是沒有缺口才對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147870/133.wav", + "text": "第一個我們有50年到60年可以補" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147870/134.wav", + "text": "口剩下1兆" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147870/135.wav", + "text": "如果照平��這樣算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147870/136.wav", + "text": "所以如果平均每一年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147870/137.wav", + "text": "維持在354億我覺得還OK" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147870/138.wav", + "text": "各機關都有它的責任額" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147870/139.wav", + "text": "缺口剩1兆" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147870/140.wav", + "text": "但你也會對這些公務人員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147870/141.wav", + "text": "自己提撥的慢慢收" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147870/142.wav", + "text": "照著繳費收入50年補1兆" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147870/143.wav", + "text": "應該還算簡單" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147870/144.wav", + "text": "啦每一年至少收200億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147870/145.wav", + "text": "嘛這200億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147870/146.wav", + "text": "要補1兆其實50年就處理掉了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147870/147.wav", + "text": "所以看起來一定會高於1兆" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147870/148.wav", + "text": "因為現在111年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147870/149.wav", + "text": "已經有1,212億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147870/150.wav", + "text": "當然新制結束之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147870/151.wav", + "text": "改成儲金制大家往儲金制提撥" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147870/152.wav", + "text": "新制的人會降低" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147870/153.wav", + "text": "但是現在是1,200" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147870/154.wav", + "text": "億以後還會再增加一些然後掉下來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147870/155.wav", + "text": "平均200億應該沒有問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147870/156.wav", + "text": "我判斷" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147870/157.wav", + "text": "6年年改2017年實施的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147870/158.wav", + "text": "只是大家看每一年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147870/159.wav", + "text": "撥的有210億的缺口" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147870/160.wav", + "text": "但是照著大家繳費的狀況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147870/161.wav", + "text": "財政狀況應該是沒有缺口才對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147870/162.wav", + "text": "部長我這樣算對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147870/163.wav", + "text": "有沒有我們算錯的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147870/164.wav", + "text": "補1兆數學上是沒問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147870/165.wav", + "text": "為人數會下降" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147870/166.wav", + "text": "那當然前面就要稍微多一點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147870/167.wav", + "text": "但是你的費率也不能提高了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147870/168.wav", + "text": "嘛至少現在有1,200" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147870/169.wav", + "text": "當然會很低" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147870/170.wav", + "text": "但是我說平均200億在50" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147870/171.wav", + "text": "就算有缺口也不多吧" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147870/172.wav", + "text": "還是你們有算另外一個版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147870/173.wav", + "text": "說沒有喔" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147870/174.wav", + "text": "負最後支付責任本來就是沒有缺口" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147870/175.wav", + "text": "現在只是預估大家覺得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147870/176.wav", + "text": "信賴政府" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147870/177.wav", + "text": "才會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147870/178.wav", + "text": "希望能夠先把" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147870/179.wav", + "text": "教育人員是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147870/180.wav", + "text": "236億公務人員是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147870/181.wav", + "text": "285億每年要提" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147870/182.wav", + "text": "這個是提早把" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147870/183.wav", + "text": "所有的都" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147870/184.wav", + "text": "撥補才會有這樣金額" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147870/185.wav", + "text": "如果照這樣算其實到最後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147870/186.wav", + "text": "剩下沒有多少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147870/187.wav", + "text": "就是政府來負最後支付責任" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147870/188.wav", + "text": "其實應該本來就是沒有問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147870/189.wav", + "text": "秘書長你也參考啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147870/190.wav", + "text": "我剛剛一開始講的重點是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147870/191.wav", + "text": "你們的報告書裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147870/192.wav", + "text": "不管是考試院也好銓敘部也好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147870/193.wav", + "text": "你們報告書裡面都寫得太" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147870/194.wav", + "text": "保守" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147870/195.wav", + "text": "了當然這個算法我早上也花了很長時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147870/196.wav", + "text": "我也很難理解" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147870/197.wav", + "text": "每次過了就忘了那麼多制度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147870/198.wav", + "text": "你可以把表拿出來給大家看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147870/199.wav", + "text": "因為每一個人都可以去檢查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147870/200.wav", + "text": "你寫得都" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147870/201.wav", + "text": "四平八穩的數字很少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147870/202.wav", + "text": "這樣子你要大家相信你" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147870/203.wav", + "text": "也不容易" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147870/204.wav", + "text": "所以你不如說我平均幾年攤多少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147870/205.wav", + "text": "大概就是這個樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147870/206.wav", + "text": "子這樣應該大家就可以認知到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147870/207.wav", + "text": "我一年平均200億的收益應該不難" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147870/208.wav", + "text": "表格寫得清楚一點以後50年怎樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147870/209.wav", + "text": "60年怎樣這樣比較清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147870/210.wav", + "text": "最終支付責任在政府" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147870/211.wav", + "text": "因為缺口大的不在這裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147870/212.wav", + "text": "我認為軍公教都不會有問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147870/213.wav", + "text": "啦以上謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147870/214.wav", + "text": "謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147869/0.wav", + "text": "非常感謝主席楊瓊瓔發言邀請部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147869/1.wav", + "text": "請陳部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147869/2.wav", + "text": "部長好部長針對社會保險業務跟農民保險業務" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147869/3.wav", + "text": "你的社會保險負擔比112年增加了68.17億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147869/4.wav", + "text": "當然我們看到你的原因是說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147869/5.wav", + "text": "農民月投保金額提高" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147869/6.wav", + "text": "所以等於在補助保險的部分也會提高" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147869/7.wav", + "text": "與預估撥補農保的虧損增加所致" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147869/8.wav", + "text": "農保開辦從112年7月底開始" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147869/9.wav", + "text": "累計的虧損是這麼多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147869/10.wav", + "text": "不只會影響到財政" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147869/11.wav", + "text": "也會影響我農民的權益" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147869/12.wav", + "text": "所以在這樣的情況之下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147869/13.wav", + "text": "本席要請教部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147869/14.wav", + "text": "以農立國的臺灣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147869/15.wav", + "text": "是我非常非常尊敬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147869/16.wav", + "text": "的沒有農民就沒有臺灣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147869/17.wav", + "text": "所以在這樣的情況之下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147869/18.wav", + "text": "農民的重要性是不可言喻" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147869/19.wav", + "text": "的而農保就是為了要提高農民" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147869/20.wav", + "text": "足夠的生活保障" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147869/21.wav", + "text": "跟醫療照顧" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147869/22.wav", + "text": "這是最重要的政策" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147869/23.wav", + "text": "所以在這樣的情況之下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147869/24.wav", + "text": "對於我們農保虧損的狀況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147869/25.wav", + "text": "農業部要怎麼去因應" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147869/26.wav", + "text": "謝謝委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147869/27.wav", + "text": "福利制度之一環" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147869/28.wav", + "text": "對非常重要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147869/29.wav", + "text": "所以你要怎麼因應" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147869/30.wav", + "text": "我們會儘量讓真正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147869/31.wav", + "text": "符合農保的被保險人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147869/32.wav", + "text": "所以我們會更仔細地去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147869/33.wav", + "text": "讓真正需要農保的這些人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147869/34.wav", + "text": "早期有一些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147869/35.wav", + "text": "並不是實際從農" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147869/36.wav", + "text": "部長你今天回答這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147869/37.wav", + "text": "沒有針對本席的提問" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147869/38.wav", + "text": "啊你怎麼會如此講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147869/39.wav", + "text": "呢你是農業部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147869/40.wav", + "text": "耶本席跟你說的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147869/41.wav", + "text": "你針對這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147869/42.wav", + "text": "要怎麼去因應" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147869/43.wav", + "text": "啊你首先以你部長的身分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147869/44.wav", + "text": "應該是你的財政" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147869/45.wav", + "text": "要怎麼去處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147869/46.wav", + "text": "這才是重點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147869/47.wav", + "text": "我跟委員說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147869/48.wav", + "text": "對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147869/49.wav", + "text": "虧損持續的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147869/50.wav", + "text": "我剛才講了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147869/51.wav", + "text": "我們會去清理相關的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147869/52.wav", + "text": "是不是符合相關的規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147869/53.wav", + "text": "這是我們持續在做的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147869/54.wav", + "text": "就是不會讓一些不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147869/55.wav", + "text": "需���" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147869/56.wav", + "text": "部長你還是重複講這件事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147869/57.wav", + "text": "第二個部分是增加" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147869/58.wav", + "text": "這個人家持續都在做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147869/59.wav", + "text": "而且答案告訴你" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147869/60.wav", + "text": "虧空的這麼多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147869/61.wav", + "text": "你身為部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147869/62.wav", + "text": "提高保費的利率本身" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147869/63.wav", + "text": "財政的狀況之下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147869/64.wav", + "text": "我們希望" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147869/65.wav", + "text": "但是我們也不希望" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147869/66.wav", + "text": "因為這樣子而增加農民的負擔" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147869/67.wav", + "text": "所以會導致" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147869/68.wav", + "text": "但是相對地如果虧損的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147869/69.wav", + "text": "我想以政府的立場來講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147869/70.wav", + "text": "一些撥補的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147869/71.wav", + "text": "這一句話就是本席討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147869/72.wav", + "text": "這個議題的重點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147869/73.wav", + "text": "政府要怎麼樣去撥補" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147869/74.wav", + "text": "這一句話是重點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147869/75.wav", + "text": "所以在整個農民福利體系的藍圖裡頭" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147869/76.wav", + "text": "要包括農民在從事" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147869/77.wav", + "text": "從業的基本保障" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147869/78.wav", + "text": "風險分攤以及退休後的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147869/79.wav", + "text": "在這樣的情況之下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147869/80.wav", + "text": "我希望不要讓農民去憂心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147869/81.wav", + "text": "我參加了這個體系" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147869/82.wav", + "text": "不要以後我得不到保障" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147869/83.wav", + "text": "這是本席的重點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147869/84.wav", + "text": "所以你剛剛講的一點本席認同" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147869/85.wav", + "text": "虧補的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147869/86.wav", + "text": "政府要怎麼樣去撥補" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147869/87.wav", + "text": "你們必須要在結果的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147869/88.wav", + "text": "要結果論達到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147869/89.wav", + "text": "讓農民安心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147869/90.wav", + "text": "你把你們目前希望要怎麼樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147869/91.wav", + "text": "去調整的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147869/92.wav", + "text": "接下來本席要請教" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147869/93.wav", + "text": "為了加強整個產業的國際行銷" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147869/94.wav", + "text": "在113年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147869/95.wav", + "text": "你的預算裡頭" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147869/96.wav", + "text": "我們要怎麼樣去突破關稅" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147869/97.wav", + "text": "跟非關稅貿易的障礙" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147869/98.wav", + "text": "新南向政策" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147869/99.wav", + "text": "來引導我們整個產業" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147869/100.wav", + "text": "能夠全球布局" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147869/101.wav", + "text": "促進我們的出口市場可以多元化" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147869/102.wav", + "text": "我相信這是你年度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147869/103.wav", + "text": "最重要的目標之一" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147869/104.wav", + "text": "是不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147869/105.wav", + "text": "但是我們看到受到疫情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147869/106.wav", + "text": "國際運費的高漲" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147869/107.wav", + "text": "以及氣候變遷的影響" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147869/108.wav", + "text": "加上中國大陸" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147869/109.wav", + "text": "暫停了我們的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147869/110.wav", + "text": "鳳梨釋迦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147869/111.wav", + "text": "在111年裡頭" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147869/112.wav", + "text": "我們又看到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147869/113.wav", + "text": "了14.31%跟7.63%" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147869/114.wav", + "text": "但是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147869/115.wav", + "text": "我們的進口卻不斷地在增加" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147869/116.wav", + "text": "進口的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147869/117.wav", + "text": "152.75億美元" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147869/118.wav", + "text": "28.5億美元" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147869/119.wav", + "text": "這樣的幅度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147869/120.wav", + "text": "我們統計起來是23%" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147869/121.wav", + "text": "尤其在今年1月到8月底" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147869/122.wav", + "text": "你的貿易逆差" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147869/123.wav", + "text": "95.14億美元了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147869/124.wav", + "text": "在這樣的情況之下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147869/125.wav", + "text": "本席要請教部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147869/126.wav", + "text": "我們的出口貿易逆差的原因" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147869/127.wav", + "text": "到底是什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147869/128.wav", + "text": "你的目標是年年達不到標" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147869/129.wav", + "text": "是不達標的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147869/130.wav", + "text": "耶這怎麼辦呢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147869/131.wav", + "text": "你要拿出什麼樣的方案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147869/132.wav", + "text": "讓我們的農民能夠安心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147869/133.wav", + "text": "來因為COVID-19的關係" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147869/134.wav", + "text": "其實我們的進口量跟出口量" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147869/135.wav", + "text": "你還這麼回答" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147869/136.wav", + "text": "不要美化數字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147869/137.wav", + "text": "本席已經告訴你數字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147869/138.wav", + "text": "你還跟我說差不多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147869/139.wav", + "text": "但是因為整個生產成本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147869/140.wav", + "text": "單價提高了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147869/141.wav", + "text": "所以整個金額才有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147869/142.wav", + "text": "比較大的差異性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147869/143.wav", + "text": "我也非常敬重你" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147869/144.wav", + "text": "你是專家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147869/145.wav", + "text": "你現在應該是以農業部長的立場" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147869/146.wav", + "text": "跟身分來談論事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147869/147.wav", + "text": "這樣子才能夠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147869/148.wav", + "text": "handle整場" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147869/149.wav", + "text": "我們數字已經告訴你了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147869/150.wav", + "text": "了你應該緊張" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147869/151.wav", + "text": "我們要怎麼樣去協助民眾" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147869/152.wav", + "text": "把方案告訴我" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147869/153.wav", + "text": "這才是本席在詢答當中要的東西" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147869/154.wav", + "text": "第一個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147869/155.wav", + "text": "就是我們會持續地去加強" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147869/156.wav", + "text": "這個力道本身" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147869/157.wav", + "text": "如果以剛才委員所提到的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147869/158.wav", + "text": "因為大陸一些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147869/159.wav", + "text": "暫停我們輸入的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147869/160.wav", + "text": "我們農民的收益不受影響" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147869/161.wav", + "text": "所以你們就收購" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147869/162.wav", + "text": "這是基本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147869/163.wav", + "text": "本席希望的是多元的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147869/164.wav", + "text": "市場" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147869/165.wav", + "text": "對所以我們現在不斷地" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147869/166.wav", + "text": "增加一些高端市場" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147869/167.wav", + "text": "從數據來看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147869/168.wav", + "text": "像美國日本已經取代了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147869/169.wav", + "text": "中國大陸成為我們全臺灣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147869/170.wav", + "text": "好了就這個議題你也書面資料給本席" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147869/171.wav", + "text": "你把你的方案給本席" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147869/172.wav", + "text": "最後一個議題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147869/173.wav", + "text": "我們看到受到進口雞蛋的影響" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147869/174.wav", + "text": "買氣下降是不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147869/175.wav", + "text": "我們看到營養午餐" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147869/176.wav", + "text": "因為大家怕了所以液蛋不能用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147869/177.wav", + "text": "軍隊也還沒有恢復供應" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147869/178.wav", + "text": "臺北蛋商公會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147869/179.wav", + "text": "10月24日" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147869/180.wav", + "text": "布蛋價從原本產地的每台斤" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147869/181.wav", + "text": "45.5元" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147869/182.wav", + "text": "產地價43.5元批發價53.5" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147869/183.wav", + "text": "元在你們的資訊平臺裡頭" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147869/184.wav", + "text": "目前為止" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147869/185.wav", + "text": "你的產蛋雞" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147869/186.wav", + "text": "雞總共有多少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147869/187.wav", + "text": "3,392萬隻" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147869/188.wav", + "text": "你的日產是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147869/189.wav", + "text": "11萬8,000箱" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147869/190.wav", + "text": "1箱是以200顆" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147869/191.wav", + "text": "來計算對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147869/192.wav", + "text": "所以這樣的情況有稍微在恢復" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147869/193.wav", + "text": "但是距離我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147869/194.wav", + "text": "國人每日所需求的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147869/195.wav", + "text": "12萬2,000箱到12萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147869/196.wav", + "text": "4,000箱還有缺口" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147869/197.wav", + "text": "我又憂心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147869/198.wav", + "text": "不要來但是禽流感" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147869/199.wav", + "text": "在這個時間是嚴峻的考驗" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147869/200.wav", + "text": "在這樣的情況之下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147869/201.wav", + "text": "請教部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147869/202.wav", + "text": "你的雞蛋供應是不是可以穩定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147869/203.wav", + "text": "產蛋率" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147869/204.wav", + "text": "失衡了之後你要怎麼處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147869/205.wav", + "text": "請做說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147869/206.wav", + "text": "雞蛋的部分以農業部的立場" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147869/207.wav", + "text": "一定是穩定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147869/208.wav", + "text": "我們國內雞蛋的生產" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147869/209.wav", + "text": "這個雞蛋的生產我們預估" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147869/210.wav", + "text": "大概在月底的時候就已經可以達到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147869/211.wav", + "text": "我們整個國內的供需" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147869/212.wav", + "text": "現在這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147869/213.wav", + "text": "國內的供需每日的需求是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147869/214.wav", + "text": "12萬2,000箱到12萬4,000" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147869/215.wav", + "text": "你說到年底可以嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147869/216.wav", + "text": "到月底可以嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147869/217.wav", + "text": "10月底可以達到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147869/218.wav", + "text": "不要搶購蛋" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147869/219.wav", + "text": "國內的復養跟國內的這些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147869/220.wav", + "text": "老母雞的淘汰很順利" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147869/221.wav", + "text": "所以整個量" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147869/222.wav", + "text": "這些價格的下降應該是短期的現象" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147869/223.wav", + "text": "我們尊重市場機制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147869/224.wav", + "text": "最主要是因為液蛋的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147869/225.wav", + "text": "是用殼蛋" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147869/226.wav", + "text": "因為之前大家對進口蛋的這些疑慮" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147869/227.wav", + "text": "所以導致很多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147869/228.wav", + "text": "營養午餐本身" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147869/229.wav", + "text": "還有很多加工的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147869/230.wav", + "text": "也造成了一些困擾" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147869/231.wav", + "text": "我們希望儘" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147869/232.wav", + "text": "儘快地讓消費者恢復信心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147869/233.wav", + "text": "縣市政府能夠重新考量" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147869/234.wav", + "text": "其實我們國內的蛋供應" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147869/235.wav", + "text": "你要讓人家重新考量" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147869/236.wav", + "text": "你必須要讓人家安心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147869/237.wav", + "text": "沒有一個家長可以放心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147869/238.wav", + "text": "這個是目前的狀況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147869/239.wav", + "text": "所以我們還是希望" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147869/240.wav", + "text": "應該有責任要怎麼樣讓民眾放心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147869/241.wav", + "text": "來使用液蛋" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147869/242.wav", + "text": "知道它是安全的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147869/243.wav", + "text": "這才是我們今天討論的一個重點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147869/244.wav", + "text": "對我們學校的部分是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147869/245.wav", + "text": "一律用國產的液蛋" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147869/246.wav", + "text": "這是在規定上面就已經明文規定的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147869/247.wav", + "text": "不實的部分造成的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147869/248.wav", + "text": "部長你現在談到這個你願意承認" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147869/249.wav", + "text": "我說你是非常接地氣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147869/250.wav", + "text": "的之前的那些事件" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147869/251.wav", + "text": "讓民眾心驚驚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147869/252.wav", + "text": "縣市首長也會怕" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147869/253.wav", + "text": "因為孩子都是我們的寶貝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147869/254.wav", + "text": "所以在營養午餐方面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147869/255.wav", + "text": "大家還不敢使用的情況之下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147869/256.wav", + "text": "你們要怎麼樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147869/257.wav", + "text": "去讓人民安心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147869/258.wav", + "text": "這個才是我們要跟你討論的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147869/259.wav", + "text": "好不好你們去找出方法讓大家放心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147869/260.wav", + "text": "一個錯誤的政策" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147869/261.wav", + "text": "一個錯誤的動作" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147869/262.wav", + "text": "導致這麼多的危險" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147869/263.wav", + "text": "進口雞蛋本身進來的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147869/264.wav", + "text": "都沒有所謂的安全疑慮" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147869/265.wav", + "text": "慮相關的這些問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147869/266.wav", + "text": "部長你如果再這麼回答" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147869/267.wav", + "text": "我又要扣你分了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147869/268.wav", + "text": "民眾的結果論是憂心的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147869/269.wav", + "text": "政府讓民眾有憂心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147869/270.wav", + "text": "就是政府有問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147869/271.wav", + "text": "是來自於很多不確實的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147869/272.wav", + "text": "不確實的訊息可以發生在我們社會上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147869/273.wav", + "text": "你是政府部門尤其你是主管單位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147869/274.wav", + "text": "更要釐清對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147869/275.wav", + "text": "我們會努力地去讓民眾知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147869/276.wav", + "text": "其實當初的缺口進口雞蛋本身" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147869/277.wav", + "text": "因為一個好的城市" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147869/278.wav", + "text": "你必須要讓民眾有最基本的條件" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147869/279.wav", + "text": "─吃的安心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147869/280.wav", + "text": "對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147869/281.wav", + "text": "好一起加油" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147869/282.wav", + "text": "謝謝楊瓊瓔委員的質詢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147868/0.wav", + "text": "謝謝主席" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147868/1.wav", + "text": "還有勞發署蔡署長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147868/2.wav", + "text": "有請" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147868/3.wav", + "text": "部長2018年2月26號就職" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147868/4.wav", + "text": "你算是非常長壽長命的一個部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147868/5.wav", + "text": "做得很好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147868/6.wav", + "text": "\n今天我們針對觀光的旅宿業" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147868/7.wav", + "text": "這個議題跟部長跟署長做討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147868/8.wav", + "text": "交通部部長在這個禮拜" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147868/9.wav", + "text": "接受訪問" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147868/10.wav", + "text": "時特別提到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147868/11.wav", + "text": "是關於缺工的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147868/12.wav", + "text": "達到5,500人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147868/13.wav", + "text": "其實有一些觀旅" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147868/14.wav", + "text": "觀旅業業者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147868/15.wav", + "text": "可是一樣還是沒有辦法吸引到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147868/16.wav", + "text": "真的沒有辦法補足" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147868/17.wav", + "text": "部長在10月18號受訪的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147868/18.wav", + "text": "也特別講到旅" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147868/19.wav", + "text": "目前沒有時間表" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147868/20.wav", + "text": "勞動部希望優先站在本國勞工就業的立場" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147868/21.wav", + "text": "其實我們都知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147868/22.wav", + "text": "我們當然要先" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147868/23.wav", + "text": "我們還沒有辦法找出一個比較好的專業的意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147868/24.wav", + "text": "然後旅宿業缺工就是存在而且這麼嚴重" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147868/25.wav", + "text": "當然不是只有我們臺灣是這樣的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147868/26.wav", + "text": "的本席在這裡請問部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147868/27.wav", + "text": "針對我這一個問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147868/28.wav", + "text": "你怎麼說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147868/29.wav", + "text": "因為以整個服務業來講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147868/30.wav", + "text": "目前是我們國人主要的就業機會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147868/31.wav", + "text": "大概六成都是國人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147868/32.wav", + "text": "然後其中從事旅宿業的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147868/33.wav", + "text": "女性就大概有六成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147868/34.wav", + "text": "這裡面旅宿業的中高齡占了將近三成六" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147868/35.wav", + "text": "所以針對旅宿業的移工開放" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147868/36.wav", + "text": "我們必須第一個要去思考的是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147868/37.wav", + "text": "會不會衝擊到本國的就業" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147868/38.wav", + "text": "尤其是女性中高齡二度就業婦女的就業機會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147868/39.wav", + "text": "這是我們優先要考量" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147868/40.wav", + "text": "的\n第二個就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147868/41.wav", + "text": "關於旅宿業缺工的問題我們也瞭解" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147868/42.wav", + "text": "其實從去年開始" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147868/43.wav", + "text": "我們就透過全國的就業服務站來幫忙媒合" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147868/44.wav", + "text": "也專案媒合" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147868/45.wav", + "text": "今年5月1日" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147868/46.wav", + "text": "我們更推出擴大" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147868/47.wav", + "text": "從5月1日到目前為止" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147868/48.wav", + "text": "跟委員報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147868/49.wav", + "text": "大概他們提報出來的缺額是1,148人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147868/50.wav", + "text": "而我們幫他推薦的人數" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147868/51.wav", + "text": "將近5倍的人數" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147868/52.wav", + "text": "但是媒合率只有四百零多人不到五成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147868/53.wav", + "text": "這個數字代表什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147868/54.wav", + "text": "報告委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147868/55.wav", + "text": "他有缺工是有人要去應徵要做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147868/56.wav", + "text": "喔不是沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147868/57.wav", + "text": "但為什麼媒合率這麼低" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147868/58.wav", + "text": "我跟委員報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147868/59.wav", + "text": "我們去瞭解後業者是說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147868/60.wav", + "text": "他們的體能" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147868/61.wav", + "text": "但是到底是哪些體能健康條件" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147868/62.wav", + "text": "沒有很具體的說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147868/63.wav", + "text": "勞方的部分我們也去瞭解" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147868/64.wav", + "text": "他們都在等候通知但都沒有通知" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147868/65.wav", + "text": "好部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147868/66.wav", + "text": "顯然你這樣分析的一個結論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147868/67.wav", + "text": "這個市場性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147868/68.wav", + "text": "中高齡的二度就業" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147868/69.wav", + "text": "其實我們是有一個鼓勵方案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147868/70.wav", + "text": "因為一個人可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147868/71.wav", + "text": "什麼觀旅業還找不到員工" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147868/72.wav", + "text": "呢到底問題出在哪裡呢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147868/73.wav", + "text": "擴大就業缺工的媒合方案來講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147868/74.wav", + "text": "是有人來應徵喔不是沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147868/75.wav", + "text": "現在是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147868/76.wav", + "text": "不是來應徵的人太少了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147868/77.wav", + "text": "嘛所以你們媒合力太低了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147868/78.wav", + "text": "是啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147868/79.wav", + "text": "那就是你的誘因不夠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147868/80.wav", + "text": "政府的誘因不夠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147868/81.wav", + "text": "其實我跟你講部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147868/82.wav", + "text": "我要謝謝你上個月" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147868/83.wav", + "text": "跟我到南部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147868/84.wav", + "text": "去跟我們這些螺絲業者座談" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147868/85.wav", + "text": "螺絲業者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147868/86.wav", + "text": "因為一開始的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147868/87.wav", + "text": "就是第一個月第二個月" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147868/88.wav", + "text": "他們可能" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147868/89.wav", + "text": "他們就穩定下來了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147868/90.wav", + "text": "那有沒有機會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147868/91.wav", + "text": "婦女的二度就業" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147868/92.wav", + "text": "我們現在先把這個問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147868/93.wav", + "text": "觀光旅遊業" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147868/94.wav", + "text": "因為也開始復甦了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147868/95.wav", + "text": "當然我們希望勞動部在10月底" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147868/96.wav", + "text": "一定要你們平衡討論的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147868/97.wav", + "text": "11月初" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147868/98.wav", + "text": "可不可以給一個初步的說法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147868/99.wav", + "text": "因為你要跟著上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147868/100.wav", + "text": "若你不跟著上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147868/101.wav", + "text": "你要知道一家飯店倒了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147868/102.wav", + "text": "他要再蓋一家新的飯店" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147868/103.wav", + "text": "起碼要3年5年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147868/104.wav", + "text": "所以基本上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147868/105.wav", + "text": "如果他們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147868/106.wav", + "text": "運用我們的擴大就業方案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147868/107.wav", + "text": "運用我們的中高齡及高齡的就業方案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147868/108.wav", + "text": "二度就業婦女方案沒有辦法媒合" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147868/109.wav", + "text": "移工開放" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147868/110.wav", + "text": "但是我要跟委員報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147868/111.wav", + "text": "移工開放" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147868/112.wav", + "text": "就自己決定說OK" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147868/113.wav", + "text": "會做了很多嚴謹的準備" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147868/114.wav", + "text": "我們會走行政程序" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147868/115.wav", + "text": "所以部長加把勁" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147868/116.wav", + "text": "二度就業婦女" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147868/117.wav", + "text": "重返職場的不容易" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147868/118.wav", + "text": "你訂定了3年14" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147868/119.wav", + "text": "14萬的女性勞動力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147868/120.wav", + "text": "你已經把目標訂好了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147868/121.wav", + "text": "其實在這個政策上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147868/122.wav", + "text": "你面臨到的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147868/123.wav", + "text": "能趕快去解決" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147868/124.wav", + "text": "因為我們知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147868/125.wav", + "text": "婦女二度就業" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147868/126.wav", + "text": "其實是穩定勞動市場" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147868/127.wav", + "text": "一個很大很大的基礎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147868/128.wav", + "text": "只要在二度就業" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147868/129.wav", + "text": "可以穩定下來的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147868/130.wav", + "text": "其實後續他們都可以在職場上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147868/131.wav", + "text": "在20歲到29歲" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147868/132.wav", + "text": "是一個高峯期" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147868/133.wav", + "text": "再來退出來了以後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147868/134.wav", + "text": "他們可能因為生小孩" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147868/135.wav", + "text": "可是在未來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147868/136.wav", + "text": "你在中高齡的預算編列" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147868/137.wav", + "text": "裡頭我們沒有看到預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147868/138.wav", + "text": "這個是怎麼一回事" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147868/139.wav", + "text": "可以請部長說明嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147868/140.wav", + "text": "因為我們這個計畫是9月1日" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147868/141.wav", + "text": "我們明年的預算是3.5億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147868/142.wav", + "text": "光我們自己勞動部就3.5億了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147868/143.wav", + "text": "相關的哪些可以補助" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147868/144.wav", + "text": "以雇主來講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147868/145.wav", + "text": "他如果願意調整工時" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147868/146.wav", + "text": "因為有些二度就業婦女" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147868/147.wav", + "text": "可能還是要兼顧家庭" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147868/148.wav", + "text": "他工時可以調整" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147868/149.wav", + "text": "為期一年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147868/150.wav", + "text": "對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147868/151.wav", + "text": "就是我們給雇主3,000為期" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147868/152.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147868/153.wav", + "text": "所以這個都有具體的計畫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147868/154.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147868/155.wav", + "text": "我們有細部的計畫都出來了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147868/156.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147868/157.wav", + "text": "這是9月才上路" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147868/158.wav", + "text": "然後我們預算也出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147868/159.wav", + "text": "執行的計畫也出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147868/160.wav", + "text": "我再給委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147868/161.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147868/162.wav", + "text": "謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147868/163.wav", + "text": "那就拜託部長將細部的計畫給我" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147868/164.wav", + "text": "謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147868/165.wav", + "text": "謝謝主席" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147867/0.wav", + "text": "謝謝主席是不是請財政部莊部長還有主計總處的朱主計長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147867/1.wav", + "text": "委員早" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147867/2.wav", + "text": "部長因為從近年的財政部綜合所得稅" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147867/3.wav", + "text": "申報統計的資料" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147867/4.wav", + "text": "行政院主計總處的家庭收支調查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147867/5.wav", + "text": "這兩項統計調查都顯示" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147867/6.wav", + "text": "我國的所得分配沒有看到改善" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147867/7.wav", + "text": "稅制改革對於縮小貧富差距的期待" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147867/8.wav", + "text": "似乎也沒有出現" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147867/9.wav", + "text": "我請問部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147867/10.wav", + "text": "全國民眾貧富差距越來越大" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147867/11.wav", + "text": "你認為外界對政府" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147867/12.wav", + "text": "整個稅制規劃做得夠不夠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147867/13.wav", + "text": "所得重分配的要求" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147867/14.wav", + "text": "你認為有沒有道理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147867/15.wav", + "text": "跟委員報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147867/16.wav", + "text": "在這個部分財政部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147867/17.wav", + "text": "在社會各界一直關注下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147867/18.wav", + "text": "我們也都努力在做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147867/19.wav", + "text": "所得稅能夠達到量能課稅的原則" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147867/20.wav", + "text": "我想在這個部分也跟委員報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147867/21.wav", + "text": "是不需要課稅的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147867/22.wav", + "text": "以及剛才報告裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147867/23.wav", + "text": "免稅額以及標準扣除等等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147867/24.wav", + "text": "特別扣除額各項的扣除額" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147867/25.wav", + "text": "都隨著CPI的調整" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147867/26.wav", + "text": "我們也都會跟著調整" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147867/27.wav", + "text": "就是讓所謂的中低所得者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147867/28.wav", + "text": "能夠減輕租稅負擔" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147867/29.wav", + "text": "甚至不需要繳稅" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147867/30.wav", + "text": "像我們剛剛提到有305萬戶" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147867/31.wav", + "text": "大概占47%的申報戶" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147867/32.wav", + "text": "不需要繳稅" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147867/33.wav", + "text": "另外也跟委員報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147867/34.wav", + "text": "適用最高稅率40%的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147867/35.wav", + "text": "總體申報戶是不到1%" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147867/36.wav", + "text": "但是他繳的稅是占全部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147867/37.wav", + "text": "應繳稅額的45%" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147867/38.wav", + "text": "可以看出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147867/39.wav", + "text": "高所得者繳的稅負是占大部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147867/40.wav", + "text": "就是貧富差距越來越大" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147867/41.wav", + "text": "對另外我們也透過租稅的收入比較好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147867/42.wav", + "text": "來做相關的津貼補助" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147867/43.wav", + "text": "本席也清楚政府推動稅改" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147867/44.wav", + "text": "但不只政府不符合多數民眾的期待" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147867/45.wav", + "text": "貧富差距甚至於還逐漸地擴大" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147867/46.wav", + "text": "那我請問部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147867/47.wav", + "text": "政府稅改到底做不" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147867/48.wav", + "text": "呢有沒有辦法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147867/49.wav", + "text": "那個所得的一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147867/50.wav", + "text": "重分配政策的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147867/51.wav", + "text": "一般來講是支出面的效果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147867/52.wav", + "text": "所以我們可以看到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147867/53.wav", + "text": "如果沒有財政收支改變的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147867/54.wav", + "text": "我們的所得分配" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147867/55.wav", + "text": "最高的20%跟最低的20%" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147867/56.wav", + "text": "會差7.63倍" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147867/57.wav", + "text": "可是由於公共支出" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147867/58.wav", + "text": "我們縮減了1.34倍" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147867/59.wav", + "text": "那個租稅的效果大概只有0.14倍" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147867/60.wav", + "text": "要是說沒有辦法不行的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147867/61.wav", + "text": "那是不是整個執政不力所導致" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147867/62.wav", + "text": "如果可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147867/63.wav", + "text": "那為什麼不但" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147867/64.wav", + "text": "沒有見到正面的成效" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147867/65.wav", + "text": "還繼續拉大貧富差距" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147867/66.wav", + "text": "貧富差距" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147867/67.wav", + "text": "如果是說就每人所得來看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147867/68.wav", + "text": "因為我們臺灣的家庭結構" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147867/69.wav", + "text": "裡面的人數減少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147867/70.wav", + "text": "來衡量的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147867/71.wav", + "text": "大概是怎麼樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147867/72.wav", + "text": "是比較不準" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147867/73.wav", + "text": "所以如果用每人來衡量的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147867/74.wav", + "text": "是有一個縮小的差距" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147867/75.wav", + "text": "不像民國90年代" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147867/76.wav", + "text": "有大概四倍多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147867/77.wav", + "text": "100年代是3.84到4.2" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147867/78.wav", + "text": "像今年大概縮小到3.93倍" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147867/79.wav", + "text": "有縮小的趨勢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147867/80.wav", + "text": "貧富差距一直擴大" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147867/81.wav", + "text": "到最後變成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147867/82.wav", + "text": "會不會變這個樣子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147867/83.wav", + "text": "就要注重一些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147867/84.wav", + "text": "所以從105年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147867/85.wav", + "text": "我們的社福預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147867/86.wav", + "text": "今年的7,130億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147867/87.wav", + "text": "部長還有主計長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147867/88.wav", + "text": "高所得者的總所得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147867/89.wav", + "text": "幾乎不會受到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147867/90.wav", + "text": "經濟不景氣或疫情影響" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147867/91.wav", + "text": "甚至逆勢增加" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147867/92.wav", + "text": "但是低所得這些人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147867/93.wav", + "text": "的總額卻受到嚴重影響而減少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147867/94.wav", + "text": "應是近年貧富差距" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147867/95.wav", + "text": "更加嚴重的是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147867/96.wav", + "text": "從受僱者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147867/97.wav", + "text": "勞動報酬占GDP的比重" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147867/98.wav", + "text": "就可以看出勞工" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147867/99.wav", + "text": "從整個經濟大餅中分得多少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147867/100.wav", + "text": "表示勞工分的越多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147867/101.wav", + "text": "勞工實質薪資成長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147867/102.wav", + "text": "追不上創造產出的這些成長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147867/103.wav", + "text": "更凸顯整個獲利分配" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147867/104.wav", + "text": "偏重企業" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147867/105.wav", + "text": "忽略勞工的失衡現象" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147867/106.wav", + "text": "���不是這樣子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147867/107.wav", + "text": "那個是因為我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147867/108.wav", + "text": "逐漸走向資本跟技術密集" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147867/109.wav", + "text": "走向資本跟技術密集的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147867/110.wav", + "text": "資本的報酬就會提高" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147867/111.wav", + "text": "營業盈餘就會增加" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147867/112.wav", + "text": "受僱人員報酬會減少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147867/113.wav", + "text": "所以我們要用其他措施" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147867/114.wav", + "text": "以及我剛才講的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147867/115.wav", + "text": "所得差距擴大" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147867/116.wav", + "text": "是不是高低所得者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147867/117.wav", + "text": "掌握的資本差距" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147867/118.wav", + "text": "持續加大所導致" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147867/119.wav", + "text": "是不是這樣子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147867/120.wav", + "text": "者的儲蓄比例比較高" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147867/121.wav", + "text": "他能夠用儲蓄的錢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147867/122.wav", + "text": "所以如我剛才所講的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147867/123.wav", + "text": "國內產業都屬於資本密集型的產業" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147867/124.wav", + "text": "而且按照資本持有的比例態樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147867/125.wav", + "text": "話語權在誰身上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147867/126.wav", + "text": "你認為具有多數資本者及掌握話語權的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147867/127.wav", + "text": "憑什麼理由和立場" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147867/128.wav", + "text": "我們在中華民國是一人一票" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147867/129.wav", + "text": "任何人都有發言權" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147867/130.wav", + "text": "社會重分配" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147867/131.wav", + "text": "主要是貧富差距擴大" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147867/132.wav", + "text": "是不爭的事實" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147867/133.wav", + "text": "當下就是這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147867/134.wav", + "text": "近年來更嚴重的是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147867/135.wav", + "text": "薪資調整根本追不上物價上漲幅度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147867/136.wav", + "text": "導致可分配所得越來越少的趨勢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147867/137.wav", + "text": "在我今天的報告第5頁" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147867/138.wav", + "text": "會不會在未來變成常態" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147867/139.wav", + "text": "會不會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147867/140.wav", + "text": "重分配的政策" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147867/141.wav", + "text": "社會福利措施" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147867/142.wav", + "text": "不要污名化" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147867/143.wav", + "text": "名化說是大撒幣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147867/144.wav", + "text": "如果認為不會是常態" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147867/145.wav", + "text": "到底是依據哪裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147867/146.wav", + "text": "難道政府能夠保證一定會出現" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147867/147.wav", + "text": "企業主大發慈悲心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147867/148.wav", + "text": "願意全面大幅" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147867/149.wav", + "text": "會不會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147867/150.wav", + "text": "經濟發展的趨勢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147867/151.wav", + "text": "資本越來越密��" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147867/152.wav", + "text": "技術越來越密集" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147867/153.wav", + "text": "所以那些資本的報酬就會增加" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147867/154.wav", + "text": "去改善這種所得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147867/155.wav", + "text": "因為全球生產結構成本轉變" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147867/156.wav", + "text": "以及追求淨零成本增加" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147867/157.wav", + "text": "導致2%3%的通膨率這" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147867/158.wav", + "text": "你認為這樣的看法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147867/159.wav", + "text": "到底是有依據還是過於偏頗" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147867/160.wav", + "text": "沒有實施以前會有這種趨勢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147867/161.wav", + "text": "如果實施財政措施" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147867/162.wav", + "text": "我們就可以改善這些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147867/163.wav", + "text": "所以也希望大院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147867/164.wav", + "text": "能夠支持各項社會福利" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147867/165.wav", + "text": "為了維持整個收支的平衡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147867/166.wav", + "text": "對於生活上的各種花費" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147867/167.wav", + "text": "多半會量入為出" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147867/168.wav", + "text": "只是曾幾何時" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147867/169.wav", + "text": "過去三餐吃便當" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147867/170.wav", + "text": "只是為了方便性的考量" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147867/171.wav", + "text": "現在買便當" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147867/172.wav", + "text": "除了方便性以外" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147867/173.wav", + "text": "多數人口中的CP值" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147867/174.wav", + "text": "變得更重要了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147867/175.wav", + "text": "當可支配所得中的三餐" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147867/176.wav", + "text": "過去選擇買便當" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147867/177.wav", + "text": "到現在轉變成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147867/178.wav", + "text": "買哪種便當比較便宜" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147867/179.wav", + "text": "比較划算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147867/180.wav", + "text": "你認為人民的貧窮感" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147867/181.wav", + "text": "是不是會越來越深" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147867/182.wav", + "text": "會不會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147867/183.wav", + "text": "貧窮感是採相對的概念" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147867/184.wav", + "text": "不是絕對的概念" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147867/185.wav", + "text": "就是我跟高所得比" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147867/186.wav", + "text": "現在連買個便當" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147867/187.wav", + "text": "都要考慮再考慮" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147867/188.wav", + "text": "對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147867/189.wav", + "text": "如果連買三餐" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147867/190.wav", + "text": "較我請問你你認為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147867/191.wav", + "text": "能夠期待整個娛樂經濟消費提升嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147867/192.wav", + "text": "人民又怎麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147867/193.wav", + "text": "靠政府找到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147867/194.wav", + "text": "睽違多年的幸福感" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147867/195.wav", + "text": "幾乎沒有嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147867/196.wav", + "text": "就是我剛才所講的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147867/197.wav", + "text": "要透過社會福利措施" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147867/198.wav", + "text": "讓他的可支配所得增加" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147867/199.wav", + "text": "謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147867/200.wav", + "text": "各界預測經濟成長率" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147867/201.wav", + "text": "以及觀察實際數字的同時" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147867/202.wav", + "text": "政府更應該關注 GDP" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147867/203.wav", + "text": "是不是應該更客觀" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147867/204.wav", + "text": "貼近民眾的感受" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147867/205.wav", + "text": "因為近幾年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147867/206.wav", + "text": "看到政府公布的GDP數值" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147867/207.wav", + "text": "都讓大多數的民眾" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147867/208.wav", + "text": "有看得到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147867/209.wav", + "text": "你認為呢是不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147867/210.wav", + "text": "推出財政措施之前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147867/211.wav", + "text": "會有這種現象" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147867/212.wav", + "text": "但是要透過財政措施來改善" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147867/213.wav", + "text": "謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147867/214.wav", + "text": "民眾認為有分配不均的可能" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147867/215.wav", + "text": "你認為這樣的看法是不是正確" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147867/216.wav", + "text": "的確推出財政措施之前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147867/217.wav", + "text": "會有這種現象" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147867/218.wav", + "text": "但是要透過財政措施來改善" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147867/219.wav", + "text": "不是偏見吧" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147867/220.wav", + "text": "我沒有說偏見謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147867/221.wav", + "text": "你認為要怎麼樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147867/222.wav", + "text": "才能夠符合民眾的期待" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147867/223.wav", + "text": "到底政府的責任大" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147867/224.wav", + "text": "還是企業主的責任比較大" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147867/225.wav", + "text": "我認為你們應該提出一些措施" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147867/226.wav", + "text": "讓人民有感" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147867/227.wav", + "text": "升人民的痛苦指數越來越高" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147867/228.wav", + "text": "因為他的薪水沒有增加" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147867/229.wav", + "text": "對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147867/230.wav", + "text": "你買任何東西" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147867/231.wav", + "text": "都一定要審慎的選擇" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147867/232.wav", + "text": "要量入為出" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147867/233.wav", + "text": "對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147867/234.wav", + "text": "像這些問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147867/235.wav", + "text": "我認為政府應該把它納進去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147867/236.wav", + "text": "因為講實在話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147867/237.wav", + "text": "現階段很多民眾" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147867/238.wav", + "text": "所得的薪水" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147867/239.wav", + "text": "所拿的錢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147867/240.wav", + "text": "要買一樣東西都是考慮再考慮" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147867/241.wav", + "text": "謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147867/242.wav", + "text": "各位請回" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147866/0.wav", + "text": "部長感冒��苦了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147866/1.wav", + "text": "關於營養午餐的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147866/2.wav", + "text": "我相信部長知道我們辦公室跟蔡培慧委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147866/3.wav", + "text": "還有其他教育及文化委員會的委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147866/4.wav", + "text": "跟部長分享一個比較新的進度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147866/5.wav", + "text": "其實我們這一次到南投去辦了座談會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147866/6.wav", + "text": "或團膳業者都提出了一些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147866/7.wav", + "text": "我們覺得聽起來很可怕的荒謬故事" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147866/8.wav", + "text": "後續不管是因為這個故事的因應" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147866/9.wav", + "text": "該做什麼事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147866/10.wav", + "text": "跟國教署這邊會積極的討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147866/11.wav", + "text": "也請部長在這邊先簡單承諾我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147866/12.wav", + "text": "是不是有機會在這個會期" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147866/13.wav", + "text": "再進一步針對這個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147866/14.wav", + "text": "不管是在預算案處理的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147866/15.wav", + "text": "再繼續討論營養午餐的議題可以嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147866/16.wav", + "text": "是謝謝委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147866/17.wav", + "text": "我想委員長期關注營養午餐專法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147866/18.wav", + "text": "也確實從上一次提案到現在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147866/19.wav", + "text": "我想我也聽到很多很多的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147866/20.wav", + "text": "這方面很好的一些建議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147866/21.wav", + "text": "當時也確實經過一個過渡階段" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147866/22.wav", + "text": "去實踐有關尤其最難的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147866/23.wav", + "text": "因為時間有限部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147866/24.wav", + "text": "我們就之後再討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147866/25.wav", + "text": "我想這部分我們會繼續蒐集資料" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147866/26.wav", + "text": "接下來談一下偏鄉老師的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147866/27.wav", + "text": "部長剛剛在口頭報告的時候提到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147866/28.wav", + "text": "有相關的一些辦法在解決" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147866/29.wav", + "text": "那我們跟部長分享一些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147866/30.wav", + "text": "些目前很多偏鄉校長給我們的建議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147866/31.wav", + "text": "他們提到之前偏鄉教育條例裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147866/32.wav", + "text": "有所謂的專聘老師還有公費生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147866/33.wav", + "text": "以致他們沒有辦法借調" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147866/34.wav", + "text": "就算是同一個縣市的偏鄉學校也不行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147866/35.wav", + "text": "所以對很多教學經驗豐富的老師來說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147866/36.wav", + "text": "他們其實不想去這些地方" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147866/37.wav", + "text": "是部長跟署長都來自教育基層" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147866/38.wav", + "text": "你們應該知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147866/39.wav", + "text": "其實很多偏鄉的現場" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147866/40.wav", + "text": "必須要混齡或混班教學" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147866/41.wav", + "text": "一年級跟六年級的學生混在一起教學" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147866/42.wav", + "text": "都必須要有教學經驗豐富的老師" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147866/43.wav", + "text": "才能夠有辦法一次對付這麼多小孩" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147866/44.wav", + "text": "但是偏偏很多經驗豐富的老師" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147866/45.wav", + "text": "在相關的福利跟資源調配上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147866/46.wav", + "text": "他們其實很不願意去這些地方" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147866/47.wav", + "text": "所以偏鄉校長們也在想" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147866/48.wav", + "text": "如果就只是讓很多年輕的老師去現場" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147866/49.wav", + "text": "然後從偏鄉教育感覺到很多的挫折" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147866/50.wav", + "text": "不僅年輕老師不願意去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147866/51.wav", + "text": "很多教學經驗豐富的老師可能也不想去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147866/52.wav", + "text": "所以我們之後會想要再跟教育部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147866/53.wav", + "text": "跟國教署積極討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147866/54.wav", + "text": "如何產生一個好的配套鼓勵措施" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147866/55.wav", + "text": "讓教學經驗豐富的老師" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147866/56.wav", + "text": "願意有點像long stay一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147866/57.wav", + "text": "去個三年五年交換研究的概念" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147866/58.wav", + "text": "跟當地的社區" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147866/59.wav", + "text": "當地的願意留下來教書的年輕人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147866/60.wav", + "text": "就算是代理代課老師" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147866/61.wav", + "text": "他也可以分享他的經驗" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147866/62.wav", + "text": "這個部分今天就快速在這邊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147866/63.wav", + "text": "跟部長還有署長先報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147866/64.wav", + "text": "我們後續也會再找教育部持續討論好嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147866/65.wav", + "text": "好我想這部分謝謝委員再蒐集一些意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147866/66.wav", + "text": "因為現在正在做相關的修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147866/67.wav", + "text": "如果地方學校校長能夠提供一些好的建議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147866/68.wav", + "text": "進而能達到這個目標" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147866/69.wav", + "text": "我們再來做一些調整" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147866/70.wav", + "text": "好謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147866/71.wav", + "text": "我相信部長一直都很關心體育選手" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147866/72.wav", + "text": "那我們就快速跟部長討論一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147866/73.wav", + "text": "這次亞運後的一些問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147866/74.wav", + "text": "題目有點多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147866/75.wav", + "text": "其實我們還是要感謝體育署" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147866/76.wav", + "text": "預算八年倍增的目標" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147866/77.wav", + "text": "目前公務預算56億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147866/78.wav", + "text": "運發基金有70億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147866/79.wav", + "text": "亞運結束" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147866/80.wav", + "text": "帕運開始" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147866/81.wav", + "text": "而且2024年的奧運" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147866/82.wav", + "text": "大家都非常期待" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147866/83.wav", + "text": "不管是因為金牌的想像" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147866/84.wav", + "text": "可能會不大一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147866/85.wav", + "text": "應該還有很多問題需要解決" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147866/86.wav", + "text": "管理是為了訓練" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147866/87.wav", + "text": "而不是為了長官安心的要件" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147866/88.wav", + "text": "我們之前到國訓中心考察" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147866/89.wav", + "text": "例如國訓中心的長官要求選手" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147866/90.wav", + "text": "要把被子摺好才能出門" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147866/91.wav", + "text": "要求選手應依照片規定擺放物品" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147866/92.wav", + "text": "甚至有女生選手在宿舍擺放娃娃" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147866/93.wav", + "text": "收起來不可以出現" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147866/94.wav", + "text": "在其他國家的訓練中心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147866/95.wav", + "text": "到底會不會出現這樣荒謬的狀況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147866/96.wav", + "text": "難道國訓中心的長官認為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147866/97.wav", + "text": "多擺一個玩偶我們就會少一面金牌嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147866/98.wav", + "text": "還是把這樣的管理變成管制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147866/99.wav", + "text": "我們就可以多一面金牌嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147866/100.wav", + "text": "是用北韓跟中國那樣的極權式管理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147866/101.wav", + "text": "才能夠產出這麼多金牌" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147866/102.wav", + "text": "我相信一定也非常同意我們的說法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147866/103.wav", + "text": "只是我們如何不要讓國訓中心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147866/104.wav", + "text": "變成比較高級的軍營" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147866/105.wav", + "text": "能夠保障選手的人權" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147866/106.wav", + "text": "時間有限" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147866/107.wav", + "text": "這個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147866/108.wav", + "text": "我都覺得需要讓教育部這邊知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147866/109.wav", + "text": "也希望透過署長讓國訓中心知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147866/110.wav", + "text": "更多的改革" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147866/111.wav", + "text": "\n接下來要談運動心理學" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147866/112.wav", + "text": "這次我們覺得很可惜" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147866/113.wav", + "text": "先講一下關於自傷的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147866/114.wav", + "text": "我們之前跟國訓中心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147866/115.wav", + "text": "要了一個關於選手自傷事件的資料" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147866/116.wav", + "text": "相關的資料顯示在銀幕的左手邊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147866/117.wav", + "text": "部長可以看一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147866/118.wav", + "text": "我們當時收到國訓中心的回復說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147866/119.wav", + "text": "是已經呈報該中心長官還有總教練給予協助" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147866/120.wav", + "text": "後來這個選手也確定已經歸建" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147866/121.wav", + "text": "建都先不要管當時處理的很多狀況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147866/122.wav", + "text": "但是我們實際上聽到的問題是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147866/123.wav", + "text": "自傷事情並非突發" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147866/124.wav", + "text": "其實有很多的累積" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147866/125.wav", + "text": "再來就是當時在國訓中心裡面的運動心理老師" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147866/126.wav", + "text": "所做的方法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147866/127.wav", + "text": "是把大家都找在一起" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147866/128.wav", + "text": "甚至把那個自傷的選手也叫過來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147866/129.wav", + "text": "然後說大家要怎樣怎樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147866/130.wav", + "text": "完全沒有去識別化" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147866/131.wav", + "text": "完全沒有保護那個選手的情況下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147866/132.wav", + "text": "我實在不知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147866/133.wav", + "text": "這是什麼樣的運動心理專業" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147866/134.wav", + "text": "\n我們回過頭來看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147866/135.wav", + "text": "其實運動心理專業應該是要被尊重的專業" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147866/136.wav", + "text": "之前很多立法委員也提出很多的建議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147866/137.wav", + "text": "給了7名運科心理專業人員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147866/138.wav", + "text": "但是運科心理專業人員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147866/139.wav", + "text": "的專業在國訓中心裡面有沒有被尊重" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147866/140.wav", + "text": "他們有沒有提供適當的增能" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147866/141.wav", + "text": "然後讓這些運動心理專業老師" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147866/142.wav", + "text": "相信他們可以全然地支持選手" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147866/143.wav", + "text": "而不是只聽長官的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147866/144.wav", + "text": "在這個部分也希望跟部長後續再積極地討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147866/145.wav", + "text": "\n時間真的好短" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147866/146.wav", + "text": "再來就是我們很想知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147866/147.wav", + "text": "自傷的選手" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147866/148.wav", + "text": "他在9月已經歸建" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147866/149.wav", + "text": "通常就國訓中心的角度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147866/150.wav", + "text": "歸建後就不關它的事了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147866/151.wav", + "text": "那我們很好奇這個自傷的選手" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147866/152.wav", + "text": "後續的心理諮商資源" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147866/153.wav", + "text": "國訓中心難道就真的認為沒有它的事了嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147866/154.wav", + "text": "可是不要忘記這個選手" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147866/155.wav", + "text": "是在國訓中心的管制跟管理底下造成那個傷害" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147866/156.wav", + "text": "所以是不是可以請體育署" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147866/157.wav", + "text": "或者是教育部國訓中心這邊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147866/158.wav", + "text": "我們都認為應該要繼續支持這個選手" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147866/159.wav", + "text": "雖然我現在不知道在他歸建後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147866/160.wav", + "text": "到底還有沒有給予心理諮商的資源" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147866/161.wav", + "text": "給予他協助" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147866/162.wav", + "text": "這個部分可不可以請署長快速回應一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147866/163.wav", + "text": "報告委員目前這位選手" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147866/164.wav", + "text": "是屬於臺中大學的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147866/165.wav", + "text": "他是柔道的選手" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147866/166.wav", + "text": "那我們中心這邊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147866/167.wav", + "text": "都已經去識別化了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147866/168.wav", + "text": "署長就不要再講出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147866/169.wav", + "text": "對我知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147866/170.wav", + "text": "我是說這邊的執行長剛剛有回應" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147866/171.wav", + "text": "已經轉介到學校端繼續給予支持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147866/172.wav", + "text": "好那我是問國訓中心還是要給予資源" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147866/173.wav", + "text": "因為學校端我想所有在場的立法委員都知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147866/174.wav", + "text": "大學端的心理輔導資源其實已經嚴重不足" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147866/175.wav", + "text": "而且如同署長知道的可能運動心理專業的心理諮商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147866/176.wav", + "text": "跟一般的心理諮商對選手來說是有不同的需求" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147866/177.wav", + "text": "好這個部分我們後續都會再跟體育署討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147866/178.wav", + "text": "\n接下來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147866/179.wav", + "text": "關於國訓中心的支援人員部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147866/180.wav", + "text": "亞運這一次的支援人員名單" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147866/181.wav", + "text": "在9月國訓中心提供給我們的資料" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147866/182.wav", + "text": "以及亞運後我們希望國訓中心可以進一步說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147866/183.wav", + "text": "到底運科人員的分工的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147866/184.wav", + "text": "我們發現國訓中心居然把運科處副處長列為運科人員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147866/185.wav", + "text": "但是我們後來討論之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147866/186.wav", + "text": "我在意的其實不是去了幾個人的相關數字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147866/187.wav", + "text": "而是去的人到底有沒有對選手教練" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147866/188.wav", + "text": "及整個團隊產生支援的功能" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147866/189.wav", + "text": "明明是管理的職責卻算入運科人員的作法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147866/190.wav", + "text": "我怎麼想都想不通" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147866/191.wav", + "text": "也許署長等一下可以再告訴我" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147866/192.wav", + "text": "\n對我們來說運動科學不應該是門面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147866/193.wav", + "text": "怎麼說呢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147866/194.wav", + "text": "我們發現這一次很多的新聞" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147866/195.wav", + "text": "有很多的選手跟教練他們在比賽的壓力之下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147866/196.wav", + "text": "都只能透過跟自己的教練討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147866/197.wav", + "text": "而創造心理平衡的空間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147866/198.wav", + "text": "對照國訓中心昨天給我們的資料" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147866/199.wav", + "text": "跟國訓網站上的名單" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147866/200.wav", + "text": "我們發現東京奧運以後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147866/201.wav", + "text": "立法院推著國訓中心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147866/202.wav", + "text": "聘進來的7個運動心理老師" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147866/203.wav", + "text": "在這次一個都沒有帶出去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147866/204.wav", + "text": "我不知道這是對於運動心理的不信任" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147866/205.wav", + "text": "還是對於立法院之前給他這個支持的無言抗議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147866/206.wav", + "text": "我們認為選手跟教練" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147866/207.wav", + "text": "有權利也有資格享受像這樣的專業服務跟待遇" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147866/208.wav", + "text": "讓他們在面對得金牌的���力底下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147866/209.wav", + "text": "他們必須要有好的心理出口" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147866/210.wav", + "text": "我看部長很想回答" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147866/211.wav", + "text": "生物力學的博士" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147866/212.wav", + "text": "對在運動心理的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147866/213.wav", + "text": "上次亞運的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147866/214.wav", + "text": "是有派一位運動心理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147866/215.wav", + "text": "針對射箭選手的需求" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147866/216.wav", + "text": "我們有派過去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147866/217.wav", + "text": "至於其他的運動心理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147866/218.wav", + "text": "諮商老師" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147866/219.wav", + "text": "他在留營的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147866/220.wav", + "text": "我們這邊有跟國訓中心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147866/221.wav", + "text": "在做一個探討" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147866/222.wav", + "text": "未來我們會尊重專業" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147866/223.wav", + "text": "如果運動心理老師" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147866/224.wav", + "text": "跟選手認為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147866/225.wav", + "text": "用視訊的方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147866/226.wav", + "text": "效果比較差" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147866/227.wav", + "text": "我們當然未來會做一些檢討" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147866/228.wav", + "text": "去改正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147866/229.wav", + "text": "其實視訊的方法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147866/230.wav", + "text": "真的是因為疫情的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147866/231.wav", + "text": "心理師到了現場" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147866/232.wav", + "text": "營養師到了現場" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147866/233.wav", + "text": "能夠給予他們的支持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147866/234.wav", + "text": "比起視訊絕對要來得好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147866/235.wav", + "text": "我相信所有的專業人員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147866/236.wav", + "text": "都應該可以理解" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147866/237.wav", + "text": "\n主席對不起" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147866/238.wav", + "text": "\n我們還要談一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147866/239.wav", + "text": "運動賽會的機會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147866/240.wav", + "text": "請留給專業的選手" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147866/241.wav", + "text": "跟後勤" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147866/242.wav", + "text": "而不是所有的長官" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147866/243.wav", + "text": "跟老師" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147866/244.wav", + "text": "這個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147866/245.wav", + "text": "我們想要請教育部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147866/246.wav", + "text": "再次地給予選手承諾" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147866/247.wav", + "text": "因為2024奧運即將來臨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147866/248.wav", + "text": "我們真的不希望" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147866/249.wav", + "text": "就算我們能夠派出去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147866/250.wav", + "text": "但符合資格的選手" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147866/251.wav", + "text": "數量不多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147866/252.wav", + "text": "所以我們認為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147866/253.wav", + "text": "他們更應該要有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147866/254.wav", + "text": "好的運動後勤支援" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147866/255.wav", + "text": "這個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147866/256.wav", + "text": "也想要請部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147866/257.wav", + "text": "在這裡給予承諾" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147866/258.wav", + "text": "謝謝委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147866/259.wav", + "text": "剛才從國訓中心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147866/260.wav", + "text": "跟選手的一些規範" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147866/261.wav", + "text": "我想我會請體育署" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147866/262.wav", + "text": "跟國訓中心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147866/263.wav", + "text": "再做一個整理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147866/264.wav", + "text": "我也要跟委員報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147866/265.wav", + "text": "確實這些年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147866/266.wav", + "text": "我們的選手出賽" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147866/267.wav", + "text": "不只是在競技方面的表現" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147866/268.wav", + "text": "舉止各方面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147866/269.wav", + "text": "其實都有很大的進步" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147866/270.wav", + "text": "至於有一些規範" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147866/271.wav", + "text": "是不是過度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147866/272.wav", + "text": "我會請他們做一個檢討" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147866/273.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147866/274.wav", + "text": "就是他們後勤專業的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147866/275.wav", + "text": "一定是以選手跟教練" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147866/276.wav", + "text": "不是參賽的名額" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147866/277.wav", + "text": "我們講的是後勤的人員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147866/278.wav", + "text": "這個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147866/279.wav", + "text": "也許請體育署長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147866/280.wav", + "text": "再跟部長說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147866/281.wav", + "text": "我們就先簡單帶過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147866/282.wav", + "text": "之後我們也會再跟" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147866/283.wav", + "text": "教育部積極地討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147866/284.wav", + "text": "\n最後我要談解編後的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147866/285.wav", + "text": "之前很多委員都提醒到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147866/286.wav", + "text": "不管是零用金" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147866/287.wav", + "text": "或者是小英總統" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147866/288.wav", + "text": "也幫選手加保勞健保" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147866/289.wav", + "text": "這個相關的費用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147866/290.wav", + "text": "大家都知道了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147866/291.wav", + "text": "但是在這一次來說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147866/292.wav", + "text": "滑輪的柯福軒" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147866/293.wav", + "text": "女足的李佩容" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147866/294.wav", + "text": "他們都有相關的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147866/295.wav", + "text": "受傷紀錄" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147866/296.wav", + "text": "不知道體育署這邊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147866/297.wav", + "text": "有沒有請奧會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147866/298.wav", + "text": "幫所有的選手" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147866/299.wav", + "text": "完成後續的保險理賠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147866/300.wav", + "text": "怎麼說呢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147866/301.wav", + "text": "因為很多選手回來之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147866/302.wav", + "text": "他們可能要繼續比賽" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147866/303.wav", + "text": "或者是他的工作狀況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147866/304.wav", + "text": "他可能不知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147866/305.wav", + "text": "怎麼去處理這個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147866/306.wav", + "text": "那我們認為不只是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147866/307.wav", + "text": "體育署的慰問金紅包" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147866/308.wav", + "text": "相關保險的支持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147866/309.wav", + "text": "應該要積極地協助選手" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147866/310.wav", + "text": "所以我們想要強烈地要求" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147866/311.wav", + "text": "除了現場的紅包" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147866/312.wav", + "text": "體育署的慰問金" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147866/313.wav", + "text": "體育署應該協同" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147866/314.wav", + "text": "組訓單位追蹤" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147866/315.wav", + "text": "並且協助選手" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147866/316.wav", + "text": "完成後續的保險理賠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147866/317.wav", + "text": "或是長期的失能" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147866/318.wav", + "text": "之前我們也跟金管會討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147866/319.wav", + "text": "就是關於第二點的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147866/320.wav", + "text": "我們希望金管會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147866/321.wav", + "text": "可以協同教育部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147866/322.wav", + "text": "積極討論其他適合的保險" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147866/323.wav", + "text": "讓所有的運動員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147866/324.wav", + "text": "可以上場比賽" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147866/325.wav", + "text": "不管是為了國家得金牌" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147866/326.wav", + "text": "還是為了他自己的成就" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147866/327.wav", + "text": "里程碑" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147866/328.wav", + "text": "這個部分都想要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147866/329.wav", + "text": "請教育部體育署" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147866/330.wav", + "text": "再積極地跟金管會討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147866/331.wav", + "text": "委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147866/332.wav", + "text": "保險等等的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147866/333.wav", + "text": "這個機制都有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147866/334.wav", + "text": "是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147866/335.wav", + "text": "我們知道是有的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147866/336.wav", + "text": "後續協助他們完成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147866/337.wav", + "text": "保險理賠的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147866/338.wav", + "text": "還有其他" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147866/339.wav", + "text": "我們想要再次提醒" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147866/340.wav", + "text": "有很多很多的事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147866/341.wav", + "text": "錢都已經有了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147866/342.wav", + "text": "個人很好奇" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147866/343.wav", + "text": "這些選手他們在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147866/344.wav", + "text": "歸建解編之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147866/345.wav", + "text": "可能就面臨失業的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147866/346.wav", + "text": "那有沒有可能" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147866/347.wav", + "text": "從立法院端" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147866/348.wav", + "text": "我們���來研議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147866/349.wav", + "text": "另外一個可能" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147866/350.wav", + "text": "相關的儲訓選手" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147866/351.wav", + "text": "或是陪練員的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147866/352.wav", + "text": "零用金檢討之外" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147866/353.wav", + "text": "可不可以就選手" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147866/354.wav", + "text": "在歸建後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147866/355.wav", + "text": "也許是一個月到半年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147866/356.wav", + "text": "的失業補助部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147866/357.wav", + "text": "能夠給予更多的討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147866/358.wav", + "text": "我知道這個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147866/359.wav", + "text": "可是我們會積極地" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147866/360.wav", + "text": "再跟教育部討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147866/361.wav", + "text": "謝謝主席" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147866/362.wav", + "text": "不好意思" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147866/363.wav", + "text": "謝謝部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147866/364.wav", + "text": "謝謝署長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147865/0.wav", + "text": "有請部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147865/1.wav", + "text": "部長早請教你" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147865/2.wav", + "text": "據勞保局的統計" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147865/3.wav", + "text": "我們的總支出是4,800億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147865/4.wav", + "text": "逆差將近400億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147865/5.wav", + "text": "我們已經連續六年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147865/6.wav", + "text": "根據勞保局的統計" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147865/7.wav", + "text": "2028年就是差不多117年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147865/8.wav", + "text": "可能就會破產" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147865/9.wav", + "text": "如果破產" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147865/10.wav", + "text": "千萬勞工就會血本無歸5" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147865/11.wav", + "text": "5年後就會破產了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147865/12.wav", + "text": "這要怎麼處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147865/13.wav", + "text": "我們的行政院長有說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147865/14.wav", + "text": "明年要撥補1,000億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147865/15.wav", + "text": "1,200億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147865/16.wav", + "text": "因為他說不排除再加碼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147865/17.wav", + "text": "0億後來我們正式編列是1,200" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147865/18.wav", + "text": "好我要請問" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147865/19.wav", + "text": "現在每年都用撥補的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147865/20.wav", + "text": "方式以後我們都沒有改革的方案嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147865/21.wav", + "text": "我們的改革方案在哪裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147865/22.wav", + "text": "還是每一年都只是撥補" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147865/23.wav", + "text": "我們是不是應該" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147865/24.wav", + "text": "要提出比較好的方案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147865/25.wav", + "text": "報告委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147865/26.wav", + "text": "一定要來處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147865/27.wav", + "text": "這要改嘛對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147865/28.wav", + "text": "但是我要向委員報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147865/29.wav", + "text": "因為勞保人口有1,000萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147865/30.wav", + "text": "投保單位���有60萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147865/31.wav", + "text": "雙方的權益" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147865/32.wav", + "text": "各種類型都有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147865/33.wav", + "text": "你們已經執政七年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147865/34.wav", + "text": "目前還沒有一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147865/35.wav", + "text": "完整的改革方案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147865/36.wav", + "text": "七年半" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147865/37.wav", + "text": "但是我們有一點就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147865/38.wav", + "text": "雜牽涉層面廣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147865/39.wav", + "text": "少有共識的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147865/40.wav", + "text": "你現" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147865/41.wav", + "text": "勞資政學大" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147865/42.wav", + "text": "我覺得這樣講不太對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147865/43.wav", + "text": "總統上任後對於年金改革" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147865/44.wav", + "text": "他也沒有得到共識" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147865/45.wav", + "text": "就直接改了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147865/46.wav", + "text": "為什麼這個就一定要有共識" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147865/47.wav", + "text": "其實你們要提出一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147865/48.wav", + "text": "更好的方案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147865/49.wav", + "text": "對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147865/50.wav", + "text": "我們會持續跟" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147865/51.wav", + "text": "當然我現在要說的是你" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147865/52.wav", + "text": "你們已經執政七年半了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147865/53.wav", + "text": "這是最後一個會期" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147865/54.wav", + "text": "如果應該要改的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147865/55.wav", + "text": "就要趕快改" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147865/56.wav", + "text": "不能一拖再拖" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147865/57.wav", + "text": "主治醫師說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147865/58.wav", + "text": "其他醫生一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147865/59.wav", + "text": "重病很傷重了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147865/60.wav", + "text": "我們還在拖" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147865/61.wav", + "text": "這等於是錯過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147865/62.wav", + "text": "所以我覺得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147865/63.wav", + "text": "是不是要趕快看要怎麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147865/64.wav", + "text": "改革不能一直拖" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147865/65.wav", + "text": "一拖再拖" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147865/66.wav", + "text": "除了撥補以外" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147865/67.wav", + "text": "真的沒有其他方案了嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147865/68.wav", + "text": "改革的面向很多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147865/69.wav", + "text": "我們會針對各個面向" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147865/70.wav", + "text": "因為都牽涉到大家的權益" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147865/71.wav", + "text": "我們會持續去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147865/72.wav", + "text": "溝通蒐集意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147865/73.wav", + "text": "那就像我剛剛說的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147865/74.wav", + "text": "推動的期程" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147865/75.wav", + "text": "我們也會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147865/76.wav", + "text": "審慎周全來規劃" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147865/77.wav", + "text": "因為這個議題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147865/78.wav", + "text": "牽涉的層面太寬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147865/79.wav", + "text": "其實很多專家學者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147865/80.wav", + "text": "他們也有建議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147865/81.wav", + "text": "這不是我講的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147865/82.wav", + "text": "是專家講的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147865/83.wav", + "text": "只是提出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147865/84.wav", + "text": "我要請問你" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147865/85.wav", + "text": "嗎等一下讓我說完" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147865/86.wav", + "text": "因為如果要提高" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147865/87.wav", + "text": "對年輕世代" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147865/88.wav", + "text": "是不公平的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147865/89.wav", + "text": "馬上見效的就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147865/90.wav", + "text": "降低給付" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147865/91.wav", + "text": "請問部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147865/92.wav", + "text": "這個方案你能夠接受" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147865/93.wav", + "text": "還是反對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147865/94.wav", + "text": "報告委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147865/95.wav", + "text": "我跟你講一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147865/96.wav", + "text": "那是專家講的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147865/97.wav", + "text": "目前勞工提領的年金給付每月" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147865/98.wav", + "text": "對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147865/99.wav", + "text": "去年我們跟" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147865/100.wav", + "text": "跟他們討論的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147865/101.wav", + "text": "他們對於" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147865/102.wav", + "text": "要調降給付就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147865/103.wav", + "text": "委員剛剛說的專家建議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147865/104.wav", + "text": "他們認為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147865/105.wav", + "text": "影響到他們退休的保障" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147865/106.wav", + "text": "所以多數都是反對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147865/107.wav", + "text": "啦因此我才說這塊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147865/108.wav", + "text": "年紀大的退休人員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147865/109.wav", + "text": "所以1萬8," + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147865/110.wav", + "text": "000真的不夠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147865/111.wav", + "text": "政府照顧這些退休的勞工" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147865/112.wav", + "text": "其實不是只有年金給付的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147865/113.wav", + "text": "等等有很多其他各部會的資源" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147865/114.wav", + "text": "老年生活的安全" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147865/115.wav", + "text": "包括他的經濟他的照護" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147865/116.wav", + "text": "這要整體去看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147865/117.wav", + "text": "當然年金的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147865/118.wav", + "text": "分大家很重視" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147865/119.wav", + "text": "所以我現在是說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147865/120.wav", + "text": "我們要趕快提出改" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147865/121.wav", + "text": "我們不能延宕" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147865/122.wav", + "text": "如果延宕下來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147865/123.wav", + "text": "你們說要問這個要問那個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147865/124.wav", + "text": "國民年金改革就不用問了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147865/125.wav", + "text": "這個改革還要問來問去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147865/126.wav", + "text": "拖來拖去拖到最後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147865/127.wav", + "text": "要怎麼處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147865/128.wav", + "text": "沒有一套是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147865/129.wav", + "text": "這個用這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147865/130.wav", + "text": "另外一個就一定要用那樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147865/131.wav", + "text": "其實是不一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147865/132.wav", + "text": "趕快想辦法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147865/133.wav", + "text": "提出改革方案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147865/134.wav", + "text": "你這樣子結果一直延宕" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147865/135.wav", + "text": "一直延宕到時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147865/136.wav", + "text": "的你不要像" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147865/137.wav", + "text": "總統講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147865/138.wav", + "text": "2024年不是我的事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147865/139.wav", + "text": "了不能這樣想" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147865/140.wav", + "text": "我們不能" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147865/141.wav", + "text": "報告委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147865/142.wav", + "text": "這個我們會努力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147865/143.wav", + "text": "我們要趕快" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147865/144.wav", + "text": "穩定基金的財源" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147865/145.wav", + "text": "財源然後跟各界理性對話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147865/146.wav", + "text": "蒐集意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147865/147.wav", + "text": "再對話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147865/148.wav", + "text": "還再對話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147865/149.wav", + "text": "這樣子不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147865/150.wav", + "text": "啦這不能怪你" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147865/151.wav", + "text": "我也沒有怪你" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147865/152.wav", + "text": "這是我們的歷史共業" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147865/153.wav", + "text": "過去就是這樣延續下來的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147865/154.wav", + "text": "但是我希望你" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147865/155.wav", + "text": "你們趕快提出一個方案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147865/156.wav", + "text": "延宕改革到時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147865/157.wav", + "text": "我們也是扛起" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147865/158.wav", + "text": "其中一份責任" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147865/159.wav", + "text": "因為你做67年了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147865/160.wav", + "text": "對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147865/161.wav", + "text": "沒有啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147865/162.wav", + "text": "五年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147865/163.wav", + "text": "現在請問另外一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147865/164.wav", + "text": "勞退為了要增加退休所得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147865/165.wav", + "text": "現在有很多人建議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147865/166.wav", + "text": "除了這個以外" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147865/167.wav", + "text": "還有人建議勞退自選機制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147865/168.wav", + "text": "專家建議勞退自選" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147865/169.wav", + "text": "開放平臺給他們自己選" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147865/170.wav", + "text": "或是增加勞退的撥補" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147865/171.wav", + "text": "但是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147865/172.wav", + "text": "部長你們都不同意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147865/173.wav", + "text": "你們對這個方案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147865/174.wav", + "text": "你們說這樣子不行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147865/175.wav", + "text": "萬一虧損要怎樣辦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147865/176.wav", + "text": "要把勞工的退休金" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147865/177.wav", + "text": "是不是這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147865/178.wav", + "text": "其實" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147865/179.wav", + "text": "這都是專家建議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147865/180.wav", + "text": "但是我們要聽別人的建議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147865/181.wav", + "text": "關於建議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147865/182.wav", + "text": "當然我們會斟酌" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147865/183.wav", + "text": "這牽涉制度的變革" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147865/184.wav", + "text": "權利的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147865/185.wav", + "text": "我們都會比較審慎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147865/186.wav", + "text": "尤其這個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147865/187.wav", + "text": "勞團也反對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147865/188.wav", + "text": "所以這個議題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147865/189.wav", + "text": "是很敏感的議題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147865/190.wav", + "text": "我是想說努力的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147865/191.wav", + "text": "第一個讓自提增加" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147865/192.wav", + "text": "人數增加" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147865/193.wav", + "text": "讓我們的勞工有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147865/194.wav", + "text": "理財專業知識" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147865/195.wav", + "text": "各種制度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147865/196.wav", + "text": "只要是對勞工有利" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147865/197.wav", + "text": "我們都可以來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147865/198.wav", + "text": "就是對勞工要有益" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147865/199.wav", + "text": "所以我們看看多方的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147865/200.wav", + "text": "去年證券市場" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147865/201.wav", + "text": "自選機制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147865/202.wav", + "text": "他們如果自選" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147865/203.wav", + "text": "私校的選的也不錯" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147865/204.wav", + "text": "有68%的民眾" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147865/205.wav", + "text": "都支持勞退自選" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147865/206.wav", + "text": "\n我現在問最後一個問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147865/207.wav", + "text": "他們有五大訴求" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147865/208.wav", + "text": "其中之一就是免繳就業安定基金" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147865/209.wav", + "text": "發署就馬上回新聞稿說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147865/210.wav", + "text": "符合這幾項的人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147865/211.wav", + "text": "就可以免繳費" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147865/212.wav", + "text": "他們有發這則新聞" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147865/213.wav", + "text": "第二點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147865/214.wav", + "text": "因為時間關係" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147865/215.wav", + "text": "我就直接問" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147865/216.wav", + "text": "這些人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147865/217.wav", + "text": "其實有七個人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147865/218.wav", + "text": "只有一個人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147865/219.wav", + "text": "不用繳這個安定基金" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147865/220.wav", + "text": "如果有房子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147865/221.wav", + "text": "就不能算低收入戶" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147865/222.wav", + "text": "但是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147865/223.wav", + "text": "這七個人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147865/224.wav", + "text": "重症者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147865/225.wav", + "text": "從事生產" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147865/226.wav", + "text": "所以都沒有收入" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147865/227.wav", + "text": "他們沒有收入" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147865/228.wav", + "text": "但還要再請人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147865/229.wav", + "text": "不是可以不要繳就業安定基金" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147865/230.wav", + "text": "把這2,000塊給他的看護" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147865/231.wav", + "text": "或外籍看護" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147865/232.wav", + "text": "外籍看護多了2" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147865/233.wav", + "text": "這是他們的訴求" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147865/234.wav", + "text": "委員這個問題我們來研究" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147865/235.wav", + "text": "因為現在社政對於" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147865/236.wav", + "text": "就是你如果有房子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147865/237.wav", + "text": "就不符合" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147865/238.wav", + "text": "這房子也不是他有錢買" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147865/239.wav", + "text": "委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147865/240.wav", + "text": "要照顧這些重症的家庭" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147865/241.wav", + "text": "我請業務單位來研究" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147865/242.wav", + "text": "這個要修法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147865/243.wav", + "text": "就看減輕或減免" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147865/244.wav", + "text": "我們都可以來研究" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147865/245.wav", + "text": "但是這要修法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147865/246.wav", + "text": "第一個問題你有沒有問" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147865/247.wav", + "text": "他你有沒有看到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147865/248.wav", + "text": "他們的回應" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147865/249.wav", + "text": "他回應的新聞稿你有看到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147865/250.wav", + "text": "我有看到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147865/251.wav", + "text": "嗎他們的訴求就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147865/252.wav", + "text": "請部長會後再跟溫委員說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147865/253.wav", + "text": "請部長考慮一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147865/254.wav", + "text": "看可以怎麼改進" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147865/255.wav", + "text": "造福一下這些重症者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147865/256.wav", + "text": "謝謝溫委員謝謝部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147865/257.wav", + "text": "因為我們也覺得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147864/0.wav", + "text": "我想要請問秘書長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147864/1.wav", + "text": "就是說現在考選部的統計資料裡面有顯示" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147864/2.wav", + "text": "公務人員高考三級考試" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147864/3.wav", + "text": "暨普通考試的報名人數" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147864/4.wav", + "text": "需用名額是各用人機關報缺過來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147864/5.wav", + "text": "所以我們這邊是做一個彙整" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147864/6.wav", + "text": "如果說他背後的原因" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147864/7.wav", + "text": "當然就表示可能新的缺" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147864/8.wav", + "text": "或是流動的速度變慢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147864/9.wav", + "text": "所以他新開出來的缺" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147864/10.wav", + "text": "用報考試缺的部分也會減少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147864/11.wav", + "text": "有可能是這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147864/12.wav", + "text": "有關報名人數的下降" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147864/13.wav", + "text": "一個是跟少子化的趨勢有關係" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147864/14.wav", + "text": "第二個部分可能跟民間的經濟" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147864/15.wav", + "text": "就業狀況比較好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147864/16.wav", + "text": "那也有相對的吸力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147864/17.wav", + "text": "這個也有關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147864/18.wav", + "text": "因為過去以來通常公務人員的高考" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147864/19.wav", + "text": "考試是非常的熱門" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147864/20.wav", + "text": "以及搶手的是嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147864/21.wav", + "text": "大概有不一樣的狀況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147864/22.wav", + "text": "我們觀察過去20年的經驗是這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147864/23.wav", + "text": "有一個高峰大概在民國100年101年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147864/24.wav", + "text": "那個時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147864/25.wav", + "text": "那個時候因為剛好碰到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147864/26.wav", + "text": "有一個金融海嘯" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147864/27.wav", + "text": "所以民間的就業狀況比較差" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147864/28.wav", + "text": "起薪比較低" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147864/29.wav", + "text": "因此那個時候報考公務人員人數" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147864/30.wav", + "text": "的確衝到一個新高" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147864/31.wav", + "text": "但是那個新高" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147864/32.wav", + "text": "我覺得是一個比較特別的狀況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147864/33.wav", + "text": "因為回看到再更早之前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147864/34.wav", + "text": "民國九十幾年的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147864/35.wav", + "text": "所以它可能跟民間經濟狀況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147864/36.wav", + "text": "有一個連動" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147864/37.wav", + "text": "啦但是這幾年我們認為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147864/38.wav", + "text": "所以是因為少子化的狀況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147864/39.wav", + "text": "還是因為民間的情況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147864/40.wav", + "text": "都有以考試院的評估來說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147864/41.wav", + "text": "這兩個都有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147864/42.wav", + "text": "因為我們也看到世界各國" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147864/43.wav", + "text": "都有一個共通的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147864/44.wav", + "text": "就是他們都在跟民間競逐人才" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147864/45.wav", + "text": "特別是某一些專業的人才" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147864/46.wav", + "text": "的確都在搶人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147864/47.wav", + "text": "那日韓呢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147864/48.wav", + "text": "日韓也是一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147864/49.wav", + "text": "所以所以日韓的公務人員考試" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147864/50.wav", + "text": "也下降嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147864/51.wav", + "text": "他們也都有這個問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147864/52.wav", + "text": "很多國家都有類似的狀況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147864/53.wav", + "text": "像我去年在日本跟他們討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147864/54.wav", + "text": "他們也覺得說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147864/55.wav", + "text": "現在跟民間要搶人非常的辛苦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147864/56.wav", + "text": "請問你們現在推的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147864/57.wav", + "text": "這個文官團的制度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147864/58.wav", + "text": "我認為它是一個起步" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147864/59.wav", + "text": "整個政府機關在用人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147864/60.wav", + "text": "用人機關非常多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147864/61.wav", + "text": "考試院是辦理考試的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147864/62.wav", + "text": "我們去招募這些學生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147864/63.wav", + "text": "一方面是希望讓學生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147864/64.wav", + "text": "更瞭解公務員的角色" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147864/65.wav", + "text": "職責以及這個工作的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147864/66.wav", + "text": "挑戰跟樂趣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147864/67.wav", + "text": "也是希望他們多一點瞭解" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147864/68.wav", + "text": "但是我們也希望能夠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147864/69.wav", + "text": "跟其他用人機關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147864/70.wav", + "text": "行政部門一起合作" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147864/71.wav", + "text": "大家都要去校園徵才" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147864/72.wav", + "text": "所以有些機關的首長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147864/73.wav", + "text": "已經開始到校園裡面去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147864/74.wav", + "text": "做一些特殊的招募" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147864/75.wav", + "text": "你們有跟什麼部會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147864/76.wav", + "text": "我們的資安人才非常的缺乏" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147864/77.wav", + "text": "但是其實校園的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147864/78.wav", + "text": "同學對於相關的資訊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147864/79.wav", + "text": "或者是他們是否願意進入" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147864/80.wav", + "text": "行政部門" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147864/81.wav", + "text": "就資安的部分來服務" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147864/82.wav", + "text": "政府部門遇到資安人員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147864/83.wav", + "text": "這個部分的確是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147864/84.wav", + "text": "有必要再加強" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147864/85.wav", + "text": "我們知道開始" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147864/86.wav", + "text": "有一些這樣的趨勢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147864/87.wav", + "text": "有一些特殊特考特用的機關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147864/88.wav", + "text": "他們也會願意進入校園" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147864/89.wav", + "text": "去跟學生溝通" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147864/90.wav", + "text": "希望能招募優秀的人才" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147864/91.wav", + "text": "委員關心到像資安這個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147864/92.wav", + "text": "而我們公部門的薪資" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147864/93.wav", + "text": "所以在競爭人才上面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147864/94.wav", + "text": "上次人事長來他說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147864/95.wav", + "text": "他覺得我們資安人才的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147864/96.wav", + "text": "薪資跟業界的差不多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147864/97.wav", + "text": "應該還是會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147864/98.wav", + "text": "差很多是不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147864/99.wav", + "text": "會有一點落差才對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147864/100.wav", + "text": "有一個落差是不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147864/101.wav", + "text": "對所以你認為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147864/102.wav", + "text": "最大的原因是因為薪資的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147864/103.wav", + "text": "但是他們會覺得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147864/104.wav", + "text": "如果能夠到政府來服務" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147864/105.wav", + "text": "顯然有一個誘因" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147864/106.wav", + "text": "就是他們可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147864/107.wav", + "text": "有很好的磨練" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147864/108.wav", + "text": "因為政府在處理的資安" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147864/109.wav", + "text": "可能是相對有規模" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147864/110.wav", + "text": "或挑戰性比較高的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147864/111.wav", + "text": "所以是複雜度比較高的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147864/112.wav", + "text": "對所以也有些人覺得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147864/113.wav", + "text": "來政府做個幾年也不錯" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147864/114.wav", + "text": "所以你有跟數位部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147864/115.wav", + "text": "一起去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147864/116.wav", + "text": "一起來討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147864/117.wav", + "text": "我們最近也在討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147864/118.wav", + "text": "那你們有一起去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147864/119.wav", + "text": "校園徵才嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147864/120.wav", + "text": "現在校園徵才這部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147864/121.wav", + "text": "考選部這邊的這些行動" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147864/122.wav", + "text": "是考選部這邊自己在處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147864/123.wav", + "text": "跟用人機關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147864/124.wav", + "text": "一起去校園徵才" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147864/125.wav", + "text": "這個部分倒是還沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147864/126.wav", + "text": "做到這樣的規模" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147864/127.wav", + "text": "因為我們一直受限於" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147864/128.wav", + "text": "我們的資源很有限" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147864/129.wav", + "text": "不過考選部組織" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147864/130.wav", + "text": "最近的調整也是把" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147864/131.wav", + "text": "招募人力這樣的一個工作" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147864/132.wav", + "text": "的一個重要項目" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147864/133.wav", + "text": "所以我想這個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147864/134.wav", + "text": "我們應該會做得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147864/135.wav", + "text": "越來越積極" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147864/136.wav", + "text": "我們曾總召所說的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147864/137.wav", + "text": "精算報告裡面我們看到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147864/138.wav", + "text": "在2042年之前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147864/139.wav", + "text": "政府其實每" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147864/140.wav", + "text": "200到300億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147864/141.wav", + "text": "這個撥補的高峰期" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147864/142.wav", + "text": "總共約要撥補500多億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147864/143.wav", + "text": "這樣子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147864/144.wav", + "text": "5,065億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147864/145.wav", + "text": "這樣子的金額" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147864/146.wav", + "text": "到底我們目前政府的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147864/147.wav", + "text": "財政預算有沒有辦法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147864/148.wav", + "text": "能夠確保撥補" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147864/149.wav", + "text": "退撫基金的金額" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147864/150.wav", + "text": "因為這個都是根據" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147864/151.wav", + "text": "各種假設去試算的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147864/152.wav", + "text": "所以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147864/153.wav", + "text": "那實際上呢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147864/154.wav", + "text": "實際上就是我們每年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147864/155.wav", + "text": "變數的情形" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147864/156.wav", + "text": "退休資遣撫卹法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147864/157.wav", + "text": "跟教育人員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147864/158.wav", + "text": "退休資遣撫卹條例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147864/159.wav", + "text": "依法它的規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147864/160.wav", + "text": "我們就是會去撥補" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147864/161.wav", + "text": "所以這是絕對沒有問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147864/162.wav", + "text": "那明年呢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147864/163.wav", + "text": "明年我們應該要撥補的是多少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147864/164.wav", + "text": "因為明年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147864/165.wav", + "text": "那明年呢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147864/166.wav", + "text": "明年預估要撥補多少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147864/167.wav", + "text": "精算出來的缺口" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147864/168.wav", + "text": "是150億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147864/169.wav", + "text": "150億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147864/170.wav", + "text": "今年是5億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147864/171.wav", + "text": "明年是15億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147864/172.wav", + "text": "所以缺口是20億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147864/173.wav", + "text": "我們已經編列100億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147864/174.wav", + "text": "所以是足夠的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147864/175.wav", + "text": "那怎麼樣子才能確保" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147864/176.wav", + "text": "未來這些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147864/177.wav", + "text": "要撥補的財源都足夠呢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147864/178.wav", + "text": "有沒有辦法達到更高的效率呢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147864/179.wav", + "text": "對所以它會有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147864/180.wav", + "text": "它如果效率更高" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147864/181.wav", + "text": "那就更能確保" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147864/182.wav", + "text": "對那我們局長呢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147864/183.wav", + "text": "這是你負責的嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147864/184.wav", + "text": "還是是周部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147864/185.wav", + "text": "是基管局是負責" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147864/186.wav", + "text": "基金的收支管理運用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147864/187.wav", + "text": "所以整個操作" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147864/188.wav", + "text": "是基管局在負責" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147864/189.wav", + "text": "所以舊有的也是你" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147864/190.wav", + "text": "從成立以來的績效" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147864/191.wav", + "text": "大概有4.07%" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147864/192.wav", + "text": "相較於國際上的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147864/193.wav", + "text": "其他退休基金" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147864/194.wav", + "text": "大概都差不多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147864/195.wav", + "text": "譬如說以日本而言" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147864/196.wav", + "text": "收益率是3.9" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147864/197.wav", + "text": "韓國也是三點多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147864/198.wav", + "text": "大概是在這個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147864/199.wav", + "text": "當然我們如果能夠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147864/200.wav", + "text": "更積極的操作" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147864/201.wav", + "text": "到目前為止" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147864/202.wav", + "text": "到八月是10.08" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147864/203.wav", + "text": "對八月底之前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147864/204.wav", + "text": "10.08" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147864/205.wav", + "text": "10.8" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147864/206.wav", + "text": "每年都像今年這樣子嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147864/207.wav", + "text": "當然我們是從" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147864/208.wav", + "text": "多個面向去積極" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147864/209.wav", + "text": "提升我們基金" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147864/210.wav", + "text": "管理的績效" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147864/211.wav", + "text": "包括我們去多元的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147864/212.wav", + "text": "尋找投資機會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147864/213.wav", + "text": "然後更注重相關的風險" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147864/214.wav", + "text": "另外在委外的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147864/215.wav", + "text": "我們也是選" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147864/216.wav", + "text": "委外的操作機構" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147864/217.wav", + "text": "進行多元的分散風險" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147864/218.wav", + "text": "希望能夠更提高" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147864/219.wav", + "text": "那怎麼樣減少委外的弊端呢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147864/220.wav", + "text": "我們除了每天掌握" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147864/221.wav", + "text": "他們買賣股票的狀況之外" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147864/222.wav", + "text": "我們每月取得報表" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147864/223.wav", + "text": "每季還會邀請他們到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147864/224.wav", + "text": "我們局裡來進行簡報" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147864/225.wav", + "text": "以瞭解他們相關的操作" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147864/226.wav", + "text": "我們另外有一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147864/227.wav", + "text": "去進行稽查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147864/228.wav", + "text": "所以我們希望" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147864/229.wav", + "text": "不應該再發生任何" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147864/230.wav", + "text": "是這樣子的方式嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147864/231.wav", + "text": "他們應該也是類似的機制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147864/232.wav", + "text": "也是這樣的機制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147864/233.wav", + "text": "可是過去也曾經發生過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147864/234.wav", + "text": "對不對是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147864/235.wav", + "text": "要怎麼樣確保" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147864/236.wav", + "text": "我們未來的退撫基金" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147864/237.wav", + "text": "不會發生這樣的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147864/238.wav", + "text": "按照這樣子的方���" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147864/239.wav", + "text": "是否有辦法確保" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147864/240.wav", + "text": "還是過去是不是有什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147864/241.wav", + "text": "步驟做得不夠詳細" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147864/242.wav", + "text": "其實我們的稽核制度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147864/243.wav", + "text": "已經非常嚴密了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147864/244.wav", + "text": "我們其實非常掌握" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147864/245.wav", + "text": "他們每天進出的狀況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147864/246.wav", + "text": "我們所以你們退撫基金比較嚴密" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147864/247.wav", + "text": "跟委員報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147864/248.wav", + "text": "從上次您提到那個事件之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147864/249.wav", + "text": "我們跟行政院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147864/250.wav", + "text": "有一個聯合的會議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147864/251.wav", + "text": "勞動部的基金管理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147864/252.wav", + "text": "銓敘部的基金管理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147864/253.wav", + "text": "兩邊同步提升" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147864/254.wav", + "text": "所以現在已經是做到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147864/255.wav", + "text": "相對嚴密了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147864/256.wav", + "text": "而且這個我們都有邀請" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147864/257.wav", + "text": "金管會一起來加入" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147864/258.wav", + "text": "也做過一些訪查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147864/259.wav", + "text": "並把這個標準都拉得更高" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147864/260.wav", + "text": "所以在那個事件之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147864/261.wav", + "text": "我們雙方都有再把這個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147864/262.wav", + "text": "做了相對的改善" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147864/263.wav", + "text": "好我們相信" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147864/264.wav", + "text": "因為我們還是要確保" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147864/265.wav", + "text": "所有公務人員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147864/266.wav", + "text": "攬才希望新進的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147864/267.wav", + "text": "人才即學校的學生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147864/268.wav", + "text": "願意投入公務部門" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147864/269.wav", + "text": "可以確保未來所有公務部門" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147864/270.wav", + "text": "退休以後的退休生活" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147864/271.wav", + "text": "謝衣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147863/0.wav", + "text": "我一定比你剛才還好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147863/1.wav", + "text": "好謝謝主席我是不是請一下陳部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147863/2.wav", + "text": "請陳部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147863/3.wav", + "text": "委員早" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147863/4.wav", + "text": "部長早" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147863/5.wav", + "text": "今天我想請教您兩個問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147863/6.wav", + "text": "第一個是現在氣候變遷加劇" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147863/7.wav", + "text": "我們的整個病蟲害" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147863/8.wav", + "text": "我們的農藥的用量要在2027年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147863/9.wav", + "text": "從基期年的9,139公噸下降到4,570公噸" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147863/10.wav", + "text": "要達到農藥減量的目標" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147863/11.wav", + "text": "但是我們看了一下現在的統計" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147863/12.wav", + "text": "其實農藥根本沒有減量" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147863/13.wav", + "text": "甚至在非基期年的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147863/14.wav", + "text": "用量去年的用量還高達9,392.3萬公噸" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147863/15.wav", + "text": "去年不是基期年它還高於這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147863/16.wav", + "text": "量所以農藥減半看起來是遙遙無期" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147863/17.wav", + "text": "因為氣候變遷有很多病蟲害" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147863/18.wav", + "text": "所以加速農民使用農藥的用量" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147863/19.wav", + "text": "我們的農藥用量也要更多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147863/20.wav", + "text": "這種高風險的農藥可能也要開始被禁用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147863/21.wav", + "text": "所以他們必須買更多的量才能除掉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147863/22.wav", + "text": "部長你覺得這樣會不會變成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147863/23.wav", + "text": "慢慢的惡性循環下去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147863/24.wav", + "text": "我要跟委員說明的是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147863/25.wav", + "text": "我們推動農藥減量" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147863/26.wav", + "text": "其實它背後的目的是希望農民能夠合理用藥" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147863/27.wav", + "text": "讓我們的農產品更安全" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147863/28.wav", + "text": "這是最重要的核心精神" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147863/29.wav", + "text": "另一方面我們也希望" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147863/30.wav", + "text": "農民在噴藥的時候能夠更安全" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147863/31.wav", + "text": "所以在農藥減半這樣子的議題之下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147863/32.wav", + "text": "其實我們更強調的是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147863/33.wav", + "text": "讓農藥的風險降低" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147863/34.wav", + "text": "第一個我們把非常多的劇毒農藥" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147863/35.wav", + "text": "都已經讓它退場" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147863/36.wav", + "text": "這些劇毒農藥" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147863/37.wav", + "text": "特別很多是跟神經毒有關的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147863/38.wav", + "text": "很容易造成一些神經性的病害" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147863/39.wav", + "text": "另一個部分就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147863/40.wav", + "text": "我們現在把農藥做不同風險的分級" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147863/41.wav", + "text": "相對於高風險農藥" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147863/42.wav", + "text": "退場的比例已經比基期年降了20%" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147863/43.wav", + "text": "換句話說我們用這樣的方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147863/44.wav", + "text": "能夠讓我們的農藥也達到實質減量" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147863/45.wav", + "text": "部長你剛剛講的是你們現在在操作的方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147863/46.wav", + "text": "有一點要提出來跟你討論就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147863/47.wav", + "text": "什麼樣叫做精準用藥" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147863/48.wav", + "text": "精準用藥這件事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147863/49.wav", + "text": "其實它也涵蓋在我們未來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147863/50.wav", + "text": "也就是推動到一半" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147863/51.wav", + "text": "還沒有完成立法的植物醫師法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147863/52.wav", + "text": "要有植物醫師的協助農民在第一線" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147863/53.wav", + "text": "才有辦法精準的用藥" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147863/54.wav", + "text": "所以這個法令和我們現在在談的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147863/55.wav", + "text": "其實是息息相關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147863/56.wav", + "text": "另外一個大概是概念上的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147863/57.wav", + "text": "就是說我們現在到市場上去買蔬菜水果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147863/58.wav", + "text": "賣相好的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147863/59.wav", + "text": "沒有蟲咬過的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147863/60.wav", + "text": "很漂亮的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147863/61.wav", + "text": "你知道農民在田間的管理很重要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147863/62.wav", + "text": "賣相要很漂亮的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147863/63.wav", + "text": "有沒有可能在食農教育上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147863/64.wav", + "text": "其實賣相差並不代表這個蔬果是有問題的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147863/65.wav", + "text": "反而是因為它的農藥放得不夠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147863/66.wav", + "text": "我覺得這個區塊的教育是很重要的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147863/67.wav", + "text": "到底植物醫師法什麼時候能夠推動" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147863/68.wav", + "text": "美濃147米又得獎了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147863/69.wav", + "text": "高佩琳小姐" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147863/70.wav", + "text": "讓美濃的稻米能夠得到冠軍" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147863/71.wav", + "text": "所以這個植物醫師" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147863/72.wav", + "text": "包括你們現在推動的所謂儲備植物醫師" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147863/73.wav", + "text": "對於地方的農民或農會來講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147863/74.wav", + "text": "其實我們都是殷切期盼的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147863/75.wav", + "text": "部長可不可以回答一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147863/76.wav", + "text": "到底植物醫師法現在的進度如何" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147863/77.wav", + "text": "我們有沒有可能在這一屆裡頭完成三讀" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147863/78.wav", + "text": "然後讓它順利通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147863/79.wav", + "text": "就已經經過行政院審查了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147863/80.wav", + "text": "最主要是醫師這兩個字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147863/81.wav", + "text": "有一點不一樣的感覺" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147863/82.wav", + "text": "後來我們經過努力協調的結果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147863/83.wav", + "text": "因為我們在乎的是實際面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147863/84.wav", + "text": "所以我們改成植物診療師法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147863/85.wav", + "text": "這樣的方式大家都能接受" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147863/86.wav", + "text": "我們就會儘快送進立法院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147863/87.wav", + "text": "而且我們也希望它排在優先法案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147863/88.wav", + "text": "也希望能夠在這個會期之內就能夠通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147863/89.wav", + "text": "因為植物診療師或植物醫師本身" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147863/90.wav", + "text": "對於農民的精準用藥" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147863/91.wav", + "text": "是一個非常重要的協助" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147863/92.wav", + "text": "我們要講到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147863/93.wav", + "text": "診療植物或是精準用藥" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147863/94.wav", + "text": "讓農藥的藥量減少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147863/95.wav", + "text": "我覺得這都是環環相扣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147863/96.wav", + "text": "讓臺灣的��業能夠更精進" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147863/97.wav", + "text": "不管是植物醫師或植物診療師" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147863/98.wav", + "text": "對我們已經排入優先法案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147863/99.wav", + "text": "我覺得這可能也要請農業部再加緊努力一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147863/100.wav", + "text": "好嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147863/101.wav", + "text": "好剛才委員特別提到賣相的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147863/102.wav", + "text": "如果消費者能夠接受" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147863/103.wav", + "text": "它是安全的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147863/104.wav", + "text": "但是它賣相不是那麼漂亮的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147863/105.wav", + "text": "那相對的前段的農民" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147863/106.wav", + "text": "我們也會做訓練" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147863/107.wav", + "text": "以後這個部分我們會持續來努力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147863/108.wav", + "text": "22億補助農機具對不對明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147863/109.wav", + "text": "這一台鏟裝機" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147863/110.wav", + "text": "這台東西交通部也不認可" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147863/111.wav", + "text": "農業部也不認為它叫做農機" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147863/112.wav", + "text": "所以這台東西變成四不管三不管" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147863/113.wav", + "text": "不知它該如何處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147863/114.wav", + "text": "都需要這一台" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147863/115.wav", + "text": "田間的鏟裝機" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147863/116.wav", + "text": "它所以農民買這一台機器" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147863/117.wav", + "text": "沒有辦法得到農機的補助" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147863/118.wav", + "text": "但它用在田間非常的多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147863/119.wav", + "text": "這一台機器" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147863/120.wav", + "text": "其實不能在田間小路產業道路上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147863/121.wav", + "text": "行走比如它在A田區協助搬完東西之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147863/122.wav", + "text": "要到B田區去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147863/123.wav", + "text": "它必須要上貨車開過去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147863/124.wav", + "text": "然後才能到B田區" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147863/125.wav", + "text": "有可能AB田區只是在隔壁一條路或" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147863/126.wav", + "text": "或是隔兩三塊田" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147863/127.wav", + "text": "如果你認真要抓它是違法的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147863/128.wav", + "text": "違法的話就有可能被沒入或被銷毀" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147863/129.wav", + "text": "考量農民實際的需要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147863/130.wav", + "text": "能不能承認它" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147863/131.wav", + "text": "讓它可以合法它" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147863/132.wav", + "text": "它一定不會開到大馬路上去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147863/133.wav", + "text": "但是至少它在產業道路上面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147863/134.wav", + "text": "或田區上面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147863/135.wav", + "text": "它其實不需要再用另外一台貨車載著它" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147863/136.wav", + "text": "有時候田間小路非常的小" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147863/137.wav", + "text": "還不見得能夠開一台貨車上去載這一台請問" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147863/138.wav", + "text": "部長你怎麼看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147863/139.wav", + "text": "其實我也知道有��多農業機械" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147863/140.wav", + "text": "不是在一塊田區" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147863/141.wav", + "text": "操作特別是小田區" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147863/142.wav", + "text": "A田區完了以後還要到B田區去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147863/143.wav", + "text": "可能跨了一條小的農路而已" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147863/144.wav", + "text": "因為現在這整個的主管是在交通部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147863/145.wav", + "text": "但整個農業的鏟叉車本身" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147863/146.wav", + "text": "營建的用得很多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147863/147.wav", + "text": "工業也用得很多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147863/148.wav", + "text": "我想我們會後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147863/149.wav", + "text": "也可以再跟交通部商量" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147863/150.wav", + "text": "我覺得這可以再特別去討論一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147863/151.wav", + "text": "對比如說可以掛農牌" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147863/152.wav", + "text": "還是用什麼樣的方式去做區別" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147863/153.wav", + "text": "嘛我知道像這種鏟叉車" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147863/154.wav", + "text": "在營建業一定是用得特別多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147863/155.wav", + "text": "但是現在在農業的使用上其實也不少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147863/156.wav", + "text": "是一種方便也是一種協助" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147863/157.wav", + "text": "這麼多的貨這麼多的農產" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147863/158.wav", + "text": "就像我上次也跟你們提到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147863/159.wav", + "text": "一次都是40公斤裝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147863/160.wav", + "text": "現在農民幾乎都是七八十歲" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147863/161.wav", + "text": "請你們跟肥料公司" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147863/162.wav", + "text": "協調請台肥是不是能夠把它改成小包裝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147863/163.wav", + "text": "也方便農民搬運" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147863/164.wav", + "text": "可以有各種不同的包裝形式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147863/165.wav", + "text": "但是不能因為變成小包裝而變成變相加價" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147863/166.wav", + "text": "這件事情要特別強調" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147863/167.wav", + "text": "現有農民的體力狀況和實際需求" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147863/168.wav", + "text": "這個部分是不是能夠請農業部再跟交通部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147863/169.wav", + "text": "會的我想我們會跟交通部協調" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147863/170.wav", + "text": "是在一個特定的區位內" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147863/171.wav", + "text": "產業道路田區裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147863/172.wav", + "text": "你硬性規定他還要另外一輛貨車來載" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147863/173.wav", + "text": "這個有點太不近人情我知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147863/174.wav", + "text": "我想我們會儘量跟交通部做一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147863/175.wav", + "text": "而且這台機器好像也不能得到你們的農機補助" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147863/176.wav", + "text": "所以不能做農機補助對農民來講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147863/177.wav", + "text": "他也是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147863/178.wav", + "text": "不過特定的一些使用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147863/179.wav", + "text": "我們其實現在也在內部討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147863/180.wav", + "text": "研議一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147863/181.wav", + "text": "我知道你不可能現在給我答案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147863/182.wav", + "text": "但是我希望農業部能夠好好地研議一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147863/183.wav", + "text": "謝謝委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147861/0.wav", + "text": "謝謝召委今天召委排的是原退撫基金財務缺口怎麼補" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147861/1.wav", + "text": "的專題報告其實我看了三個報告包括主計總處包括秘書長包括銓敘部的報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147861/2.wav", + "text": "這些報告在作文一點誠意都沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147861/3.wav", + "text": "為什麼缺口到底多少缺口多少這三份報告沒講耶" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147861/4.wav", + "text": "你缺口多少都沒講要怎麼撥補誰要講秘書長缺口到底多少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147861/5.wav", + "text": "因為這個缺口每一年當然就依照收支的狀況會有調整" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147861/6.wav", + "text": "但是那個潛在的缺口確實是2.5兆" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147861/7.wav", + "text": "部長你這樣不及格你跟我講精確你還要問局長今天這是你的題目啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147861/8.wav", + "text": "部長自己說多少我們現在談的缺口是一個估算值" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147861/9.wav", + "text": "我當然知道精算當然是因為新制實施以後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147861/10.wav", + "text": "它造成我們原來的精算缺口你跟我講舊的你跟我講舊的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147861/11.wav", + "text": "當然要精算啊多少原來你什麼時候精算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147861/12.wav", + "text": "第8次精算結果是根據109年12月31日那個時點所做的精算結果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147861/13.wav", + "text": "好那多少缺口多少這是你今天的題目你還要問局長局長不准講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147861/14.wav", + "text": "那是未提存的負債廢話潛在負債多少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147861/15.wav", + "text": "對我剛剛講2.5兆你們這三份報告上面多少金額都不講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147861/16.wav", + "text": "主席他們藐視你啊你出了題目他們給你作文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147861/17.wav", + "text": "下次再排一次啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147861/18.wav", + "text": "缺口多少都不講你怎麼撥補" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147861/19.wav", + "text": "政府顯然不重視公務人員的權益" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147861/20.wav", + "text": "你看勞保從109年開始撥補200億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147861/21.wav", + "text": "110年撥補220億111年撥補300億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147861/22.wav", + "text": "112年撥補450億疫後特別預算還撥補100億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147861/23.wav", + "text": "今年是撥補1,200億疫後特別預算還有撥補100億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147861/24.wav", + "text": "明年撥補100億總共已經撥補了2,670億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147861/25.wav", + "text": "部長公務人員的部分到現在撥補多少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147861/26.wav", + "text": "公務人員的部分現在是依照年改節省經費的挹注" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147861/27.wav", + "text": "撥補是根據現在法定的規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147861/28.wav", + "text": "要從明年開始編預算撥補" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147861/29.wav", + "text": "這個預算明年撥補是公教人員各50億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147861/30.wav", + "text": "各50億你看政府都不重視公務人員的權益秘" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147861/31.wav", + "text": "書長你們以後怎麼撥補這2兆" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147861/32.wav", + "text": "這個部分因為現在這個在法律裡面已經有明定政府的責任" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147861/33.wav", + "text": "了當然它並沒有說每年要撥補多少金額" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147861/34.wav", + "text": "但是從精神上來看原來公務員這個基金的用罄年限是140年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147861/35.wav", + "text": "所以至少要維持這樣的一個水位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147861/36.wav", + "text": "你講的是新制啦我問你的是舊制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147861/37.wav", + "text": "所以這個部分就要請主計總處這邊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147861/38.wav", + "text": "再衡量國家財政支出狀況儘可能來做撥補" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147861/39.wav", + "text": "以後撥補至少要1,500億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147861/40.wav", + "text": "那我們也要求啊因為政府都不重視公務人員權益啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147861/41.wav", + "text": "\n接著就是考試院的權責似乎大家都不太" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147861/42.wav", + "text": "太care你們的權責" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147861/43.wav", + "text": "請教消防人員想要成立工會考試院的立場怎麼樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147861/44.wav", + "text": "跟委員報告考試院考量到就是說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147861/45.wav", + "text": "如果我們希望積極儘快地來改善現在公務人員的結社權益" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147861/46.wav", + "text": "那最快的方法是修公務人員協會法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147861/47.wav", + "text": "那工會法這個議題當然是可以被討論事實上也討論很久了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147861/48.wav", + "text": "我們看到過去的紀錄過去從陳總統跟馬總統時代" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147861/49.wav", + "text": "考試院跟行政院都有溝通過這個議題但是都沒有結論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147861/50.wav", + "text": "所以表示它的確是比較複雜的議題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147861/51.wav", + "text": "因為它牽涉到了包含協商的範圍爭議權也就是罷工權到底要不要納入" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147861/52.wav", + "text": "這些複雜議題甚至包含如果是轉軌到工會法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147861/53.wav", + "text": "適用工會法的話協會制度要不要存在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147861/54.wav", + "text": "所以它討論起來會比較久" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147861/55.wav", + "text": "那考量到說大家都希望在這個會期很有限的立法時間裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147861/56.wav", + "text": "儘快有一些成果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147861/57.wav", + "text": "所以我們才趕快提出了協會法的修正案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147861/58.wav", + "text": "希望能夠提升他的結社權" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147861/59.wav", + "text": "因為這關係到絕大部分公務人員的權利" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147861/60.wav", + "text": "歐美是不是公務人員可以成立工會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147861/61.wav", + "text": "成立工會這個議題處理起來就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147861/62.wav", + "text": "不是你就答我的問題就是歐美是不是也會成立工會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147861/63.wav", + "text": "在有的國家是可以成立工會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147861/64.wav", + "text": "對不起我沒有很深入的研究" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147861/65.wav", + "text": "那誰知道那銓敘部部長你也不能再問旁邊吧" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147861/66.wav", + "text": "這個是你們的權責" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147861/67.wav", + "text": "就各國的情況因為各國的公務人員制度確實有不同的地方" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147861/68.wav", + "text": "有些國家像日本韓國根本就是不能組織工會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147861/69.wav", + "text": "尤其是消防跟警察其實還有區分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147861/70.wav", + "text": "有些國家是消防可以警察不可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147861/71.wav", + "text": "哪些國家可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147861/72.wav", + "text": "英國的部分警察是組織協會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147861/73.wav", + "text": "法國的部分他們是可以組織公會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147861/74.wav", + "text": "德國的部分原則上他結社組織雖然是工會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147861/75.wav", + "text": "但大部分都是限制他罷工" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147861/76.wav", + "text": "日本的部分公務員不是組織工會而是組織職員團體" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147861/77.wav", + "text": "那警消也都是不得罷工或怠工" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147861/78.wav", + "text": "韓國的部分基本上他們可以組織工會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147861/79.wav", + "text": "但原則上也是不能罷工或怠工" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147861/80.wav", + "text": "所以各國的情況並不是很一致" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147861/81.wav", + "text": "你不用答我我也知道當然每個國家不一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147861/82.wav", + "text": "所以我的意思是說既然其他國家很多國家可以組成工會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147861/83.wav", + "text": "我是贊成讓他組工會尤其是消防員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147861/84.wav", + "text": "但是我也贊同不准罷工" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147861/85.wav", + "text": "秘書長所以考試院的立場是不贊成讓消防員組工會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147861/86.wav", + "text": "應該是說我們覺得協會法的修法速度會比較快" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147861/87.wav", + "text": "那也實質上有幫助" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147861/88.wav", + "text": "事實上過去消促會比較早以前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147861/89.wav", + "text": "他們也的確跟我們反映過說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147861/90.wav", + "text": "要不就是可能只能加入內政部的協會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147861/91.wav", + "text": "而內政部現在還沒有組成協會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147861/92.wav", + "text": "所以的確他們沒有辦法表達他們特殊的權益" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147861/93.wav", + "text": "所以我們這次修法才特地用一個特種協會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147861/94.wav", + "text": "讓消防員或警察都可以有自己單獨的協會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147861/95.wav", + "text": "\n考試院就這個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147861/96.wav", + "text": "我必須承認我們13屆還沒有就這個議題做過完整的討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147861/97.wav", + "text": "但是我可以跟委員報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147861/98.wav", + "text": "過去考試院在這個議題上的確是保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147861/99.wav", + "text": "就公務員組協會的部分的確是保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147861/100.wav", + "text": "在過去四屆我看到的紀錄的討論裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147861/101.wav", + "text": "大家是說因為我們國家公務員的體制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147861/102.wav", + "text": "跟勞工體制的確是有根本的不同" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147861/103.wav", + "text": "所以就由公務員這邊設計他獨有的體制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147861/104.wav", + "text": "秘書長考試院要不要進一步研究評估" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147861/105.wav", + "text": "讓部分的公務員組工會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147861/106.wav", + "text": "如果部分公務員組部分公務員不組的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147861/107.wav", + "text": "那這個界限怎麼劃分就變成另外一個議題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147861/108.wav", + "text": "別的國家也這樣子呀" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147861/109.wav", + "text": "剛剛周部長也講了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147861/110.wav", + "text": "其實每一國對公務員界限劃分都不太一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147861/111.wav", + "text": "譬如說在英國他的警消在地方都不" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147861/112.wav", + "text": "所以考試院連要不要去研究也都不願意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147861/113.wav", + "text": "當然我們可以來研究" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147860/0.wav", + "text": "謝謝召委" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147860/1.wav", + "text": "請許部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147860/2.wav", + "text": "請許部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147860/3.wav", + "text": "早" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147860/4.wav", + "text": "今天召委排定的議程為勞工退休金的制度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147860/5.wav", + "text": "我們很關心勞工退休後的經濟安全保障" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147860/6.wav", + "text": "最近也有一些勞退" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147860/7.wav", + "text": "所以今天就" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147860/8.wav", + "text": "有機會能夠在這個專報上面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147860/9.wav", + "text": "跟您討論有關退休金裡面自提的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147860/10.wav", + "text": "要不要自選的議題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147860/11.wav", + "text": "大概是三個支柱" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147860/12.wav", + "text": "支柱一個是社會保險" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147860/13.wav", + "text": "一個是社會救助" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147860/14.wav", + "text": "這個部分是建構在各種不同" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147860/15.wav", + "text": "所以你退休後可以有社會保險的年金給付" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147860/16.wav", + "text": "資產調查的是低所得或一定所得以下的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147860/17.wav", + "text": "非調查式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147860/18.wav", + "text": "而且非資產調查的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147860/19.wav", + "text": "到現在的老農津貼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147860/20.wav", + "text": "大概是屬於這種" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147860/21.wav", + "text": "非繳費式的社會津貼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147860/22.wav", + "text": "\n這個架構部長應該也蠻熟的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147860/23.wav", + "text": "的勞工保險是用社會保險" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147860/24.wav", + "text": "而且我們現在的制度是確定給付" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147860/25.wav", + "text": "勞保剛剛部長也提到了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147860/26.wav", + "text": "勞保撥補的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147860/27.wav", + "text": "這幾年在勞保的討論過程中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147860/28.wav", + "text": "還要聽取各界的聲音" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147860/29.wav", + "text": "因為它牽扯到100多萬的人口" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147860/30.wav", + "text": "所以它確實是需要討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147860/31.wav", + "text": "現在政府的作為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147860/32.wav", + "text": "明年就會有1,200億的投入" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147860/33.wav", + "text": "政府可以做的就先做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147860/34.wav", + "text": "另外一個是勞退新制的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147860/35.wav", + "text": "從94年開始實施勞退新制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147860/36.wav", + "text": "這個是強制提撥" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147860/37.wav", + "text": "另外一個是鼓勵勞工自提" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147860/38.wav", + "text": "1%到6%" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147860/39.wav", + "text": "這個自提的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147860/40.wav", + "text": "保證收益" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147860/41.wav", + "text": "可以自己決定要不要提撥提撥多少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147860/42.wav", + "text": "政府在這個制度上面的設計" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147860/43.wav", + "text": "\n我現在要討論的是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147860/44.wav", + "text": "因為最近媒體有在報導" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147860/45.wav", + "text": "剛剛有些資料也提到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147860/46.wav", + "text": "過去勞退自提的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147860/47.wav", + "text": "其實才98" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147860/48.wav", + "text": "萬但是今年3月破百了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147860/49.wav", + "text": "現在已經到104萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147860/50.wav", + "text": "大概占14%左右吧" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147860/51.wav", + "text": "我看數字大概是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147860/52.wav", + "text": "提撥人數" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147860/53.wav", + "text": "增幅是不是比較大" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147860/54.wav", + "text": "有增幅嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147860/55.wav", + "text": "我們都有增幅的統計" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147860/56.wav", + "text": "包括他的薪資級距" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147860/57.wav", + "text": "我們都有做增幅級距的統計" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147860/58.wav", + "text": "薪資是六萬多塊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147860/59.wav", + "text": "比我們的薪資中位數" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147860/60.wav", + "text": "高所以這代表什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147860/61.wav", + "text": "比較願意自提的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147860/62.wav", + "text": "才有能力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147860/63.wav", + "text": "不然生食都無夠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147860/64.wav", + "text": "乾這大概是一般勞工會有的心情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147860/65.wav", + "text": "可能剩下3萬出頭而已" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147860/66.wav", + "text": "因為我還有其他像" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147860/67.wav", + "text": "自付額的部分再扣下來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147860/68.wav", + "text": "可能我的生活就很拮据了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147860/69.wav", + "text": "可能要有一定所得的人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147860/70.wav", + "text": "我們鼓勵他自提的過程中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147860/71.wav", + "text": "他願意自提" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147860/72.wav", + "text": "提\n下一個是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147860/73.wav", + "text": "要來比較" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147860/74.wav", + "text": "美國401（k）退休計畫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147860/75.wav", + "text": "我們跟它的架構" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147860/76.wav", + "text": "看起來好像很相似" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147860/77.wav", + "text": "但是其實是不太一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147860/78.wav", + "text": "對制度是不一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147860/79.wav", + "text": "我們雇主的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147860/80.wav", + "text": "6%是強制提撥但" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147860/81.wav", + "text": "他們沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147860/82.wav", + "text": "他們和我" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147860/83.wav", + "text": "我們這些基金" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147860/84.wav", + "text": "運用局統一來管理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147860/85.wav", + "text": "但是他們是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147860/86.wav", + "text": "勞工參加雇主提供的計畫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147860/87.wav", + "text": "的地方在勞退金裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147860/88.wav", + "text": "剛部長也有稍微提到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147860/89.wav", + "text": "其實都有每年結算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147860/90.wav", + "text": "就有一些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147860/91.wav", + "text": "每年會分配收益" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147860/92.wav", + "text": "但就是要到他" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147860/93.wav", + "text": "60歲的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147860/94.wav", + "text": "才可以60歲時" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147860/95.wav", + "text": "我們還有一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147860/96.wav", + "text": "保證收益的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147860/97.wav", + "text": "對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147860/98.wav", + "text": "所以這也是最大的不同" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147860/99.wav", + "text": "就是政府負擔的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147860/100.wav", + "text": "401這個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147860/101.wav", + "text": "沒有所謂保證收益" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147860/102.wav", + "text": "它完全是勞工要自擔風險" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147860/103.wav", + "text": "然後自選" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147860/104.wav", + "text": "大家有這樣的聲音的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147860/105.wav", + "text": "其實我們很擔心的是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147860/106.wav", + "text": "自選當然是要自擔風險" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147860/107.wav", + "text": "所以你就不能要求政府做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147860/108.wav", + "text": "運用的基本上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147860/109.wav", + "text": "制度的設計是不同的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147860/110.wav", + "text": "因為現在整個是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147860/111.wav", + "text": "由基金運用局統一來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147860/112.wav", + "text": "投資運用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147860/113.wav", + "text": "當然政府照顧勞工" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147860/114.wav", + "text": "所以我們有保證收益" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147860/115.wav", + "text": "但如果是自選的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147860/116.wav", + "text": "基本上就是他要自擔風險" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147860/117.wav", + "text": "就沒有這些稅負" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147860/118.wav", + "text": "或者保證收益的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147860/119.wav", + "text": "所以我自己在整理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147860/120.wav", + "text": "制度的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147860/121.wav", + "text": "像社會保險" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147860/122.wav", + "text": "相信我們就是希望" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147860/123.wav", + "text": "它收益保守" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147860/124.wav", + "text": "所以它趨向保守" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147860/125.wav", + "text": "要保人的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147860/126.wav", + "text": "的薪水會比較高一點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147860/127.wav", + "text": "跟委員報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147860/128.wav", + "text": "勞工的退休老本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147860/129.wav", + "text": "我們是以穩健安全" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147860/130.wav", + "text": "不能失覺" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147860/131.wav", + "text": "所以我們有保證收益" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147860/132.wav", + "text": "但是我們希望" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147860/133.wav", + "text": "是能夠創造好的長期效益" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147860/134.wav", + "text": "所以最近在討論一些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147860/135.wav", + "text": "或是各種不同的組合" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147860/136.wav", + "text": "我就會有點擔心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147860/137.wav", + "text": "因為這種混合裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147860/138.wav", + "text": "可以租稅減免" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147860/139.wav", + "text": "又可以有政府的保證" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147860/140.wav", + "text": "然後收入門檻" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147860/141.wav", + "text": "高一點所得的人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147860/142.wav", + "text": "才有可能去自提" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147860/143.wav", + "text": "提所以我很擔心會有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147860/144.wav", + "text": "所得逆分配的效應" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147860/145.wav", + "text": "我比較擔心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147860/146.wav", + "text": "的因此我覺得在政策上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147860/147.wav", + "text": "我們可以再來仔細" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147860/148.wav", + "text": "一個是勞保" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147860/149.wav", + "text": "制再來怎麼樣讓" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147860/150.wav", + "text": "我想在中高齡者及高齡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147860/151.wav", + "text": "者就業促進法裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147860/152.wav", + "text": "我們就一直很希望" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147860/153.wav", + "text": "活力老化裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147860/154.wav", + "text": "兼具經濟安全" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147860/155.wav", + "text": "再就業的過程裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147860/156.wav", + "text": "是不是可以同時領勞工退休金" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147860/157.wav", + "text": "勞保年金" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147860/158.wav", + "text": "不是公職" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147860/159.wav", + "text": "就是一般就業的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147860/160.wav", + "text": "這兩個就是我再一份工作" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147860/161.wav", + "text": "勞保年金勞工退休金" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147860/162.wav", + "text": "再加一份" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147860/163.wav", + "text": "重返職場的薪水" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147860/164.wav", + "text": "可能會是更加級" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147860/165.wav", + "text": "級更往上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147860/166.wav", + "text": "我們還要保障他的勞工職災保險" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147860/167.wav", + "text": "又可以繼續投保" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147860/168.wav", + "text": "對對沒錯" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147860/169.wav", + "text": "所以我還是要在這邊再倡議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147860/170.wav", + "text": "也請勞動部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147860/171.wav", + "text": "能夠一起來倡議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147860/172.wav", + "text": "讓我們的老人經濟安全" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147860/173.wav", + "text": "除了勞工保險" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147860/174.wav", + "text": "勞退金之外" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147860/175.wav", + "text": "其實還有一份就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147860/176.wav", + "text": "再貢獻再工作的過程中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147860/177.wav", + "text": "促進經濟安全" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147860/178.wav", + "text": "促進社會參與跟健康促進的議題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147860/179.wav", + "text": "好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147860/180.wav", + "text": "對於中高齡高齡的就業" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147860/181.wav", + "text": "我們會繼續努力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147860/182.wav", + "text": "那我們就再繼續努力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147852/0.wav", + "text": "謝謝主席" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147852/1.wav", + "text": "吳署長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147852/2.wav", + "text": "部長好署長好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147852/3.wav", + "text": "自從CNN將我們評為行人地獄" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147852/4.wav", + "text": "以及近幾年來接二連三的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147852/5.wav", + "text": "都促使政府去加強整個交通的改革" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147852/6.wav", + "text": "從校園周邊暨行車安全道路改善計畫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147852/7.wav", + "text": "都顯示政府有決心來改革交通的狀況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147852/8.wav", + "text": "現在市區道路跟都市計畫內的道路" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147852/9.wav", + "text": "道路是由原來的營建署主導" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147852/10.wav", + "text": "的省道國道快速道路才是交通部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147852/11.wav", + "text": "負責以目前國土署的道路品質提升計畫來看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147852/12.wav", + "text": "都只是提供各縣市政府針對市區道路興建之補助提出申請" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147852/13.wav", + "text": "國土署會在審查後核定補助款" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147852/14.wav", + "text": "本席的意思就是說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147852/15.wav", + "text": "在政策上是可以跟地方政府來做指導的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147852/16.wav", + "text": "我今天就要針對國土署所規範的車道寬度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147852/17.wav", + "text": "認為說瘦身可能比較好聽一點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147852/18.wav", + "text": "因為說減縮大家就會很" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147852/19.wav", + "text": "心也就是說在討論車道減縮之前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147852/20.wav", + "text": "你看那個圖" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147852/21.wav", + "text": "公尺以臺北市區主要的道路來看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147852/22.wav", + "text": "單一方向常常會有3個車道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147852/23.wav", + "text": "如果以中央分隔島為基準" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147852/24.wav", + "text": "由內而外依序是二條內車道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147852/25.wav", + "text": "跟一條外車道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147852/26.wav", + "text": "臺北市就有比較奇怪的地方" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147852/27.wav", + "text": "有9成的內車道寬約3.4" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147852/28.wav", + "text": "公尺外車道則是從3公尺到7公尺" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147852/29.wav", + "text": "會讓許多違停的駕駛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147852/30.wav", + "text": "認為自己停在路邊沒什麼關係" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147852/31.wav", + "text": "旁邊反正還有位置可以過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147852/32.wav", + "text": "（2022年）2月國土署也發布了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147852/33.wav", + "text": "你們當初的規範是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147852/34.wav", + "text": "主要道路跟次要道路的外車道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147852/35.wav", + "text": "不宜超過4.5" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147852/36.wav", + "text": "公尺對於我們營建署首次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147852/37.wav", + "text": "有那麼多的專家學者給你們肯定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147852/38.wav", + "text": "把多出來的空間留給行人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147852/39.wav", + "text": "是從以車為本倒轉為以人為本的一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147852/40.wav", + "text": "汽機車代步通勤" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147852/41.wav", + "text": "所以只要提到車道減縮的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147852/42.wav", + "text": "用路人第一個想到的就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147852/43.wav", + "text": "這樣會不會影響到我的行車效率" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147852/44.wav", + "text": "或者會整個加遽交通的堵塞" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147852/45.wav", + "text": "還有交通事故的增加" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147852/46.wav", + "text": "有委託陽明大學運輸研究中心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147852/47.wav", + "text": "研究是以臺北市為對象" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147852/48.wav", + "text": "你們的那個研究成果顯示" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147852/49.wav", + "text": "車道減縮以後不會提升事故" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147852/50.wav", + "text": "也不會大幅降低車速" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147852/51.wav", + "text": "澈底推翻了我們一般人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147852/52.wav", + "text": "這個研究報告也提到車道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147852/53.wav", + "text": "減縮以後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147852/54.wav", + "text": "若以外車道5公尺當基準" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147852/55.wav", + "text": "減縮到3公尺的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147852/56.wav", + "text": "反而交通事故會降低30%" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147852/57.wav", + "text": "會有更多的車子鑽來鑽去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147852/58.wav", + "text": "或者是有超速的行為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147852/59.wav", + "text": "車道減縮後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147852/60.wav", + "text": "後反而讓駕駛人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147852/61.wav", + "text": "會更小心地去駕駛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147852/62.wav", + "text": "這個是國內" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147852/63.wav", + "text": "的部分鄰近國家的韓國" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147852/64.wav", + "text": "也去做車道的改造" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147852/65.wav", + "text": "車道也都瘦身到2.8到3公尺" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147852/66.wav", + "text": "日本更是針對道路進行分級" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147852/67.wav", + "text": "市區道路" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147852/68.wav", + "text": "主要都是以2.75到3公尺為主" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147852/69.wav", + "text": "做出這樣一個車道減縮" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147852/70.wav", + "text": "對交通環境的改善" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147852/71.wav", + "text": "都是正面的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147852/72.wav", + "text": "既然是正面的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147852/73.wav", + "text": "無論是留給行人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147852/74.wav", + "text": "或自行車道停車格" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147852/75.wav", + "text": "還是貨運裝卸" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147852/76.wav", + "text": "區這些其實本席都認為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147852/77.wav", + "text": "藉此來盤點對用路人的一個需要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147852/78.wav", + "text": "所以要請教部長跟跟署長的就是在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147852/79.wav", + "text": "們現在現有的政策工具裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147852/80.wav", + "text": "在道路品質提升計畫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147852/81.wav", + "text": "因為你們都要給他們補助" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147852/82.wav", + "text": "對這些車道寬度的進行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147852/83.wav", + "text": "本來是以車為本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147852/84.wav", + "text": "轉為以人為本的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147852/85.wav", + "text": "這樣一個改變" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147852/86.wav", + "text": "我不曉得你們的看法跟政策方向" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147852/87.wav", + "text": "感謝委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147852/88.wav", + "text": "委員真的做了很多深入的瞭解" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147852/89.wav", + "text": "我們現在不管是提升道路品質" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147852/90.wav", + "text": "永續行人安全計畫裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147852/91.wav", + "text": "對於車道的要求" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147852/92.wav", + "text": "的確就像剛剛委員所講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147852/93.wav", + "text": "的對於一般車道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147852/94.wav", + "text": "我們大概就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147852/95.wav", + "text": "希望它能夠調整到3米" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147852/96.wav", + "text": "轉向車道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147852/97.wav", + "text": "左轉車道大概是2.8" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147852/98.wav", + "text": "米當然右轉的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147852/99.wav", + "text": "所需要的寬度會稍微寬一點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147852/100.wav", + "text": "這個我們都是照這樣來審查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147852/101.wav", + "text": "目標就是盡可能空出比較完整的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147852/102.wav", + "text": "第二個就是說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147852/103.wav", + "text": "因為過寬的車道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147852/104.wav", + "text": "反而容易產生並排" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147852/105.wav", + "text": "車輛交錯的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147852/106.wav", + "text": "這是造成車禍肇事率很高的一個原因" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147852/107.wav", + "text": "所以適當的縮減" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147852/108.wav", + "text": "就可以現在的問題是說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147852/109.wav", + "text": "科學上是如此" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147852/110.wav", + "text": "沒錯" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147852/111.wav", + "text": "因為會更專注" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147852/112.wav", + "text": "市長的人你很清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147852/113.wav", + "text": "但是用路人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147852/114.wav", + "text": "的第一個想法就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147852/115.wav", + "text": "然後一定會壅塞" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147852/116.wav", + "text": "一定會造成交通事故" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147852/117.wav", + "text": "搞不好你去做個民調" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147852/118.wav", + "text": "委員你剛剛講對了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147852/119.wav", + "text": "因為剛剛話只講了一半" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147852/120.wav", + "text": "我們只講車道寬度的縮減" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147852/121.wav", + "text": "但實際上並不代表" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147852/122.wav", + "text": "整個用路面積的縮減" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147852/123.wav", + "text": "你了解嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147852/124.wav", + "text": "對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147852/125.wav", + "text": "單位時間能夠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147852/126.wav", + "text": "通行的車輛的面積" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147852/127.wav", + "text": "其實並沒有減少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147852/128.wav", + "text": "但因為我們通常" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147852/129.wav", + "text": "有時候在講的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147852/130.wav", + "text": "只講了一半" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147852/131.wav", + "text": "只講說車道要縮減" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147852/132.wav", + "text": "民眾的一個直覺" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147852/133.wav", + "text": "就覺得車道縮減" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147852/134.wav", + "text": "了所以我可能速度會變慢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147852/135.wav", + "text": "實際上在市區的道路" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147852/136.wav", + "text": "不會有這個問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147852/137.wav", + "text": "因為市區道路" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147852/138.wav", + "text": "本來就是限速" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147852/139.wav", + "text": "的可能限速不超過50" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147852/140.wav", + "text": "所以車道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147852/141.wav", + "text": "為什麼科學的數據" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147852/142.wav", + "text": "國外的經驗都顯示說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147852/143.wav", + "text": "反而會更安全" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147852/144.wav", + "text": "它的原因是在這邊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147852/145.wav", + "text": "所以接下來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147852/146.wav", + "text": "在政策上我們就會這樣去要求" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147852/147.wav", + "text": "我們現在是往這個方向" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147852/148.wav", + "text": "在做處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147852/149.wav", + "text": "的確也在跟地方政府" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147852/150.wav", + "text": "大家形成共識" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147852/151.wav", + "text": "但剛剛委員講到一個重點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147852/152.wav", + "text": "就是我們用路人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147852/153.wav", + "text": "的直覺或者他習慣上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147852/154.wav", + "text": "只catch到一半" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147852/155.wav", + "text": "實際上我們研究的成果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147852/156.wav", + "text": "嘛所以其實並不會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147852/157.wav", + "text": "產生大家直覺認" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147852/158.wav", + "text": "認為因為這樣一定會塞車" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147852/159.wav", + "text": "或者會比較不方便" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147852/160.wav", + "text": "的情況在經驗上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147852/161.wav", + "text": "或科學數據上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147852/162.wav", + "text": "實際上應該是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147852/163.wav", + "text": "但是政策要推行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147852/164.wav", + "text": "要溝通" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147852/165.wav", + "text": "這個要跟老百姓" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147852/166.wav", + "text": "一些用路人在觀念" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147852/167.wav", + "text": "上有衝突的地方確實" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147852/168.wav", + "text": "要溝通不然你說在科學上可行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147852/169.wav", + "text": "別的國家也是這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147852/170.wav", + "text": "我們理論上講的都可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147852/171.wav", + "text": "跟你提一個經驗" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147852/172.wav", + "text": "我們一直在講一個政策" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147852/173.wav", + "text": "叫做社會住宅" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147852/174.wav", + "text": "大家還記不記得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147852/175.wav", + "text": "我們剛推社會住宅的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147852/176.wav", + "text": "也是怎麼講都沒有用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147852/177.wav", + "text": "因為老百姓就覺得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147852/178.wav", + "text": "社會住宅是什麼樣的東西" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147852/179.wav", + "text": "可是經過時間去實踐" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147852/180.wav", + "text": "大家看到了那個成果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147852/181.wav", + "text": "所以我們在推這個政策的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147852/182.wav", + "text": "的確應該也要找一些地方" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147852/183.wav", + "text": "讓它執行的成果出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147852/184.wav", + "text": "他才會更有信心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147852/185.wav", + "text": "我們在政策推廣上面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147852/186.wav", + "text": "才能夠更順利" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147852/187.wav", + "text": "我都讓部長都很完整的回答" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147852/188.wav", + "text": "所以主席我最後還有一個問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147852/189.wav", + "text": "部長提到社會住宅" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147852/190.wav", + "text": "那我要追問的就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147852/191.wav", + "text": "現在社會住宅" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147852/192.wav", + "text": "嘛住了6年以後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147852/193.wav", + "text": "大家會問" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147852/194.wav", + "text": "然後呢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147852/195.wav", + "text": "達到一定比例以後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147852/196.wav", + "text": "我相信你一定會開始去研議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147852/197.wav", + "text": "居住年限延長的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147852/198.wav", + "text": "延長多久" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147852/199.wav", + "text": "本席也認為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147852/200.wav", + "text": "可以參考一些基礎的數據" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147852/201.wav", + "text": "比如說住滿6年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147852/202.wav", + "text": "社宅以後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147852/203.wav", + "text": "是不是已經順利購屋" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147852/204.wav", + "text": "等樣本數" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147852/205.wav", + "text": "來進一步做一個政策的規劃" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147852/206.wav", + "text": "剛才李德維委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147852/207.wav", + "text": "你們那個政策已經跳票了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147852/208.wav", + "text": "年蔡總統提出的這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147852/209.wav", + "text": "20萬戶的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147852/210.wav", + "text": "不管是直接興建還是包租代" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147852/211.wav", + "text": "嗎說大聲一點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147852/212.wav", + "text": "這個到明年底的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147852/213.wav", + "text": "不只不會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147852/214.wav", + "text": "可能還會有微幅的超出" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147852/215.wav", + "text": "很有信心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147852/216.wav", + "text": "啦還是同樣的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147852/217.wav", + "text": "部長你當過市長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147852/218.wav", + "text": "現在有的縣市長會說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147852/219.wav", + "text": "沒有啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147852/220.wav", + "text": "要不要把我自己蓋的扣掉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147852/221.wav", + "text": "我相信這個政策" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147852/222.wav", + "text": "本來就是二階段" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147852/223.wav", + "text": "我們一直在講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147852/224.wav", + "text": "我們的住宅法在2018年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147852/225.wav", + "text": "中央政府才直接下場" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147852/226.wav", + "text": "在第一階段的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147852/227.wav", + "text": "本來就是地方跟中央" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147852/228.wav", + "text": "大家一起來合作" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147852/229.wav", + "text": "土地的部分中央來給你幫忙" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147852/230.wav", + "text": "規劃費的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147852/231.wav", + "text": "中央來給你幫忙" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147852/232.wav", + "text": "不然你當過市長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147852/233.wav", + "text": "的跟中央都沒有關係" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147852/234.wav", + "text": "那你們就做白工" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147852/235.wav", + "text": "了啊最後給部長來答復一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147852/236.wav", + "text": "我再強調一次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147852/237.wav", + "text": "其實住宅的一個政策" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147852/238.wav", + "text": "是需要中央跟地方政府" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147852/239.wav", + "text": "大家一起合作" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147852/240.wav", + "text": "所以社會住宅" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147852/241.wav", + "text": "的的確確是臺灣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147852/242.wav", + "text": "一定要走的路" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147852/243.wav", + "text": "委員知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147852/244.wav", + "text": "接下來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147852/245.wav", + "text": "更多社會住宅興建完成之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147852/246.wav", + "text": "我們還會有後續配套" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147852/247.wav", + "text": "譬如說你剛才提到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147852/248.wav", + "text": "我們現在住6年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147852/249.wav", + "text": "這個機制都會不斷做調整" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147852/250.wav", + "text": "能夠讓民眾的居住壓力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147852/251.wav", + "text": "是整個社會住宅" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147852/252.wav", + "text": "最重要的一個目的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147852/253.wav", + "text": "我們社會住宅存量" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147852/254.wav", + "text": "會占整個住宅的幾" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147852/255.wav", + "text": "大概2.5%左右" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147852/256.wav", + "text": "2.5%" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147852/257.wav", + "text": "我認為這要加油" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147852/258.wav", + "text": "啦韓國從1990年推動到現在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147852/259.wav", + "text": "他們的住宅存量是8%" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147852/260.wav", + "text": "是荷蘭40%" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147852/261.wav", + "text": "法國15%" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147852/262.wav", + "text": "澳洲5%" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147852/263.wav", + "text": "我們現在才剛推動" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147852/264.wav", + "text": "部長也說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147852/265.wav", + "text": "讓比較弱勢的人可以居住" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147852/266.wav", + "text": "候再延長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147852/267.wav", + "text": "\n但是部長其實有另外1張支票" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147852/268.wav", + "text": "我們一起來期許" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147852/269.wav", + "text": "我總質詢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147852/270.wav", + "text": "首購族" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147852/271.wav", + "text": "買房子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147852/272.wav", + "text": "部長要怎麼幫忙支持他們這是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147852/273.wav", + "text": "你的大支票" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147852/274.wav", + "text": "這當然牽涉到很多部會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147852/275.wav", + "text": "我很擔心你收回去了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147852/276.wav", + "text": "不會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147852/277.wav", + "text": "這部分最重要的是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147852/278.wav", + "text": "我們其實都已經規劃" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147852/279.wav", + "text": "我們會努力來推動" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147851/0.wav", + "text": "有請林部長委員好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147851/1.wav", + "text": "其實在這4年這一屆的任期裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147851/2.wav", + "text": "我們在非都市土地的使用上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147851/3.wav", + "text": "尤其是怎麼處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147851/4.wav", + "text": "跟違法建物的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147851/5.wav", + "text": "其實我們在立法院有搭起一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147851/6.wav", + "text": "部會跟民間之間很重要的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147851/7.wav", + "text": "農地違章工廠平台會議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147851/8.wav", + "text": "定期邀請經濟部內政部農業部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147851/9.wav", + "text": "大概每三個月開一次會在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147851/10.wav", + "text": "其實解決了非常多這幾十年來累積的一些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147851/11.wav", + "text": "農地違章工廠的疑難雜症\n" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147851/12.wav", + "text": "\n在工輔法上路之後對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147851/13.wav", + "text": "於這幾年的陣痛期" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147851/14.wav", + "text": "我想民間團體扮演了非常非常重要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147851/15.wav", + "text": "幫助政府解決長年問題的角色" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147851/16.wav", + "text": "我在這邊跟部長分享" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147851/17.wav", + "text": "其實最重要的就是透過資訊公開的做法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147851/18.wav", + "text": "所以民間可以協助中央政府一起來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147851/19.wav", + "text": "監督地方政府必須落實" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147851/20.wav", + "text": "也讓很多事情能夠真正推進下去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147851/21.wav", + "text": "甚至在這過程裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147851/22.wav", + "text": "第一線很多的民眾" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147851/23.wav", + "text": "其實也幫助中央跟地方政府" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147851/24.wav", + "text": "去檢舉這些違法的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147851/25.wav", + "text": "就是說在我們現在工輔法修訂以後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147851/26.wav", + "text": "還有違法的農地違章建築跟工廠的角色" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147851/27.wav", + "text": "一個非常非常重要的監督力量\n" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147851/28.wav", + "text": "\n我先請問部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147851/29.wav", + "text": "我家附近的農地在沒有合法變更地目的狀況之下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147851/30.wav", + "text": "就蓋了一個違法的鐵皮建築" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147851/31.wav", + "text": "我應該可以向地方政府檢舉對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147851/32.wav", + "text": "那我檢舉的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147851/33.wav", + "text": "地方政府可以把是誰檢舉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147851/34.wav", + "text": "是我檢舉的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147851/35.wav", + "text": "這件事情跟被檢舉人說嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147851/36.wav", + "text": "部長可以嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147851/37.wav", + "text": "不行嘛對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147851/38.wav", + "text": "部長沒有錯" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147851/39.wav", + "text": "但現在非常荒唐非常荒謬的事情是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147851/40.wav", + "text": "接到民眾陳情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147851/41.wav", + "text": "請託協助民眾向彰化縣政府" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147851/42.wav", + "text": "檢舉農地違法興建的建物之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147851/43.wav", + "text": "居然彰化縣政府就把檢舉人的單位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147851/44.wav", + "text": "大刺刺的白紙黑字寫在公文上面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147851/45.wav", + "text": "寄給被檢舉人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147851/46.wav", + "text": "這就有點像是在跟違法的民眾" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147851/47.wav", + "text": "違法的工廠說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147851/48.wav", + "text": "你看就是他檢舉你的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147851/49.wav", + "text": "是他害你被罰錢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147851/50.wav", + "text": "部長你可以看這個公文的最下面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147851/51.wav", + "text": "我都還知道把被檢舉人遮起來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147851/52.wav", + "text": "但彰化縣政府居然在這個公文裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147851/53.wav", + "text": "把協助檢舉的彰化縣環境保護聯盟" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147851/54.wav", + "text": "直接寫在上面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147851/55.wav", + "text": "所以一點都不意外" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147851/56.wav", + "text": "這些檢舉的民眾果不其然" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147851/57.wav", + "text": "就接到恐嚇電話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147851/58.wav", + "text": "部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147851/59.wav", + "text": "他們果不其然就接到了恐嚇電話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147851/60.wav", + "text": "包括辱罵的電話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147851/61.wav", + "text": "而且這不是第一次發生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147851/62.wav", + "text": "是接二連三的發生了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147851/63.wav", + "text": "部長彰化縣政府把檢舉人的資訊寄給" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147851/64.wav", + "text": "你覺得這個問題在哪裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147851/65.wav", + "text": "我不好去揣測說問題在哪裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147851/66.wav", + "text": "不過第一個這個很明顯" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147851/67.wav", + "text": "這種檢舉案件應該都要用密件來處理才對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147851/68.wav", + "text": "我想這個應該有相關行政上面的一個疏失" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147851/69.wav", + "text": "違章建築處理辦法第9條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147851/70.wav", + "text": "但是現在彰化縣政府卻這樣幹" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147851/71.wav", + "text": "其實在彰化縣自己受理違章建築檢舉要點第6條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147851/72.wav", + "text": "也規定應該要保密" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147851/73.wav", + "text": "所以現在是彰化縣政府連自己所訂的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147851/74.wav", + "text": "如果民間的參與跟幫忙監督的力量" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147851/75.wav", + "text": "可以被彰化縣政府這樣間接的恐嚇" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147851/76.wav", + "text": "甚至造成某些限縮" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147851/77.wav", + "text": "那以後還有誰敢檢舉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147851/78.wav", + "text": "尤其這不只是中央的規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147851/79.wav", + "text": "地方也這樣規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147851/80.wav", + "text": "所以部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147851/81.wav", + "text": "很明文的要求地方政府" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147851/82.wav", + "text": "應該要落實你們主管的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147851/83.wav", + "text": "違章建築管理辦法中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147851/84.wav", + "text": "保護檢舉人的義務這部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147851/85.wav", + "text": "部長可以嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147851/86.wav", + "text": "以正式的公文函文給他" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147851/87.wav", + "text": "部長我甚至都覺得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147851/88.wav", + "text": "這個事情應該要送到監察院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147851/89.wav", + "text": "到底為什麼彰化縣政府要這樣做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147851/90.wav", + "text": "是不是就是要削弱民間檢舉的力量" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147851/91.wav", + "text": "甚至是不是跟被檢舉人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147851/92.wav", + "text": "有什麼樣不正當的關係" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147851/93.wav", + "text": "大家真的都會往這個地方去聯想" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147851/94.wav", + "text": "所以本席要麻煩內政部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147851/95.wav", + "text": "基層公務員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147851/96.wav", + "text": "要有一個更明確的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147851/97.wav", + "text": "教育輔導方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147851/98.wav", + "text": "告訴他在法規上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147851/99.wav", + "text": "這樣的做法其實已經重重違法了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147851/100.wav", + "text": "而且這只會削弱未來我們處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147851/101.wav", + "text": "相關法規" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147851/102.wav", + "text": "落實法規的力道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147851/103.wav", + "text": "它不只是一個疏失" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147851/104.wav", + "text": "甚至會造成我們在執行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147851/105.wav", + "text": "執行工輔法的任務時會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147851/106.wav", + "text": "更難執行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147851/107.wav", + "text": "更難落實" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147851/108.wav", + "text": "我覺得這是大家最不能接受的地方" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147851/109.wav", + "text": "部長我們可以加強對基層公務員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147851/110.wav", + "text": "包括彰化縣政府相關的輔導跟要求嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147851/111.wav", + "text": "可以吧" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147851/112.wav", + "text": "因為這已經違反個人資料" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147851/113.wav", + "text": "保護法的相關規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147851/114.wav", + "text": "內政部接下來要拿出作為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147851/115.wav", + "text": "因為這不是第一次了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147851/116.wav", + "text": "已經是一而再" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147851/117.wav", + "text": "再而三" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147851/118.wav", + "text": "彰化縣政府都繼續幹這樣的事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147851/119.wav", + "text": "我想我們沒有辦法接受" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147851/120.wav", + "text": "是我們會來處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147851/121.wav", + "text": "謝謝洪申翰委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147851/122.wav", + "text": "\n接下來請莊瑞雄委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147850/0.wav", + "text": "突然間我覺得我滿與有榮焉的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147850/1.wav", + "text": "因為前面幾位委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147850/2.wav", + "text": "只問到副部長而已" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147850/3.wav", + "text": "還好輪到我做壓軸" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147850/4.wav", + "text": "就可以請教一下部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147850/5.wav", + "text": "因為這個條例其實還滿重要的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147850/6.wav", + "text": "我想請教一下部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147850/7.wav", + "text": "這個條例是誰發想出來的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147850/8.wav", + "text": "是國防部的參謀發想" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147850/9.wav", + "text": "還是部長發想" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147850/10.wav", + "text": "還是外部單位發想出來的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147850/11.wav", + "text": "這個單位好像我們當初在考量" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147850/12.wav", + "text": "跨部會也有建議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147850/13.wav", + "text": "既然役期延長了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147850/14.wav", + "text": "為什麼不再多提供一些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147850/15.wav", + "text": "他本來應該有的權益可以拿到的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147850/16.wav", + "text": "那我們有彈性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147850/17.wav", + "text": "所以退役以後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147850/18.wav", + "text": "他如果以後從事勞工職這" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147850/19.wav", + "text": "這個自然就會接續" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147850/20.wav", + "text": "他沒有從事勞工職" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147850/21.wav", + "text": "等於是保險金也是給他保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147850/22.wav", + "text": "但有個但書要60歲以後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147850/23.wav", + "text": "那就是勞退條例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147850/24.wav", + "text": "勞工退休金條例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147850/25.wav", + "text": "他都沒有擔任過勞工" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147850/26.wav", + "text": "OK為什麼問這個問題的原因" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147850/27.wav", + "text": "是因為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147850/28.wav", + "text": "類似的意見其實以前有討論過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147850/29.wav", + "text": "國防部在這個部分的看法是認為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147850/30.wav", + "text": "他不符合勞工的資格" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147850/31.wav", + "text": "所以不應該把他列為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147850/32.wav", + "text": "勞工退休金的提撥範圍" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147850/33.wav", + "text": "沒錯吧你了解我講的意思" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147850/34.wav", + "text": "有沒有講到關於退伍的這件事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147850/35.wav", + "text": "（退伍金的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147850/36.wav", + "text": "所以我現在先問一個問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147850/37.wav", + "text": "就是目前這樣的義務役" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147850/38.wav", + "text": "一年的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147850/39.wav", + "text": "你們幫他提撥了之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147850/40.wav", + "text": "條例裡面的相關規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147850/41.wav", + "text": "因為你們也幫他提撥了一年的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147850/42.wav", + "text": "軍中退伍金" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147850/43.wav", + "text": "不會吧不會重疊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147850/44.wav", + "text": "是外加的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147850/45.wav", + "text": "怎麼會沒有重疊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147850/46.wav", + "text": "為什麼不會有重疊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147850/47.wav", + "text": "基本上這是外加的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147850/48.wav", + "text": "我當然知道外加" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147850/49.wav", + "text": "同時有勞工退休金的年資" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147850/50.wav", + "text": "也有軍人保險的年資對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147850/51.wav", + "text": "是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147850/52.wav", + "text": "軍人保險年資包括哪些東西" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147850/53.wav", + "text": "你們軍人保險條例裡面寫得很清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147850/54.wav", + "text": "啊除了他的因公傷殘" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147850/55.wav", + "text": "那些列為範圍之外" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147850/56.wav", + "text": "也包括他的退休金沒錯吧" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147850/57.wav", + "text": "是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147850/58.wav", + "text": "也包括他的年資吧" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147850/59.wav", + "text": "你聽懂我剛才講的意思了嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147850/60.wav", + "text": "國防部國防部認為有疑慮的地方" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147850/61.wav", + "text": "如果把他們當成勞工退休金" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147850/62.wav", + "text": "的提撥範圍的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147850/63.wav", + "text": "會不會造成一個狀況就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147850/64.wav", + "text": "因為這兩個都是國家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147850/65.wav", + "text": "訂定的制度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147850/66.wav", + "text": "一個是在國防部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147850/67.wav", + "text": "一個在勞動部所屬的單位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147850/68.wav", + "text": "我們幫他提撥到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147850/69.wav", + "text": "勞工退休金的專戶裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147850/70.wav", + "text": "但在提撥的過程中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147850/71.wav", + "text": "事實上還有一個軍人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147850/72.wav", + "text": "保險的帳戶也在提撥" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147850/73.wav", + "text": "這裡面有規定到共同一件事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147850/74.wav", + "text": "就是關於年資跟退休的事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147850/75.wav", + "text": "這個部分是當時很多人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147850/76.wav", + "text": "為什麼會這樣問原因是因為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147850/77.wav", + "text": "我們除了義務役的官士" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147850/78.wav", + "text": "服役一年還有替代役對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147850/79.wav", + "text": "還是有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147850/80.wav", + "text": "明年度也有替代役吧" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147850/81.wav", + "text": "還是替代役全部取消" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147850/82.wav", + "text": "有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147850/83.wav", + "text": "全部替代役都有對不對好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147850/84.wav", + "text": "替代役的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147850/85.wav", + "text": "有沒有也納入勞工退休金的範圍內" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147850/86.wav", + "text": "有一年期以上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147850/87.wav", + "text": "94年次以後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147850/88.wav", + "text": "替代役也有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147850/89.wav", + "text": "報告委員有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147850/90.wav", + "text": "第1項第2款" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147850/91.wav", + "text": "以前有沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147850/92.wav", + "text": "也就是明年1月1日開始" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147850/93.wav", + "text": "以前沒有這個法令規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147850/94.wav", + "text": "那我問你" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147850/95.wav", + "text": "你知不知道以前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147850/96.wav", + "text": "對於替代役的年資部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147850/97.wav", + "text": "曾經做過一個解釋" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147850/98.wav", + "text": "認為他們應該去買國民年金" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147850/99.wav", + "text": "在替代役實施條例第56條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147850/100.wav", + "text": "已經修法通過了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147850/101.wav", + "text": "之前是寫國民年金對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147850/102.wav", + "text": "明年度開始替代役" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147850/103.wav", + "text": "就變成勞工退休金對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147850/104.wav", + "text": "就要看他退役以後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147850/105.wav", + "text": "不是嘛提撥是提撥到國民年金" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147850/106.wav", + "text": "還是提撥到勞工退休金" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147850/107.wav", + "text": "聽到沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147850/108.wav", + "text": "是勞保帳戶嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147850/109.wav", + "text": "但就是在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147850/110.wav", + "text": "勞保局" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147850/111.wav", + "text": "我當然知道是勞保局" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147850/112.wav", + "text": "但是勞保帳戶嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147850/113.wav", + "text": "是勞工退休金的個人帳戶" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147850/114.wav", + "text": "對啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147850/115.wav", + "text": "不是勞工保險的那個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147850/116.wav", + "text": "那是不同的帳戶" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147850/117.wav", + "text": "那是兩個不同的制度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147850/118.wav", + "text": "是啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147850/119.wav", + "text": "拜託一下你是長官耶" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147850/120.wav", + "text": "問這個你都搞不清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147850/121.wav", + "text": "因為我保過很多年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147850/122.wav", + "text": "勞保我很清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147850/123.wav", + "text": "所以我現在講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147850/124.wav", + "text": "到底是國民年金" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147850/125.wav", + "text": "還是勞工退休金帳戶" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147850/126.wav", + "text": "報告委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147850/127.wav", + "text": "替代役的部分也是一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147850/128.wav", + "text": "這次在行政院版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147850/129.wav", + "text": "也都有提到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147850/130.wav", + "text": "他在服役期間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147850/131.wav", + "text": "有主辦機關會幫他提" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147850/132.wav", + "text": "就是改成一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147850/133.wav", + "text": "勞工退休金帳戶" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147850/134.wav", + "text": "因為以前是放在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147850/135.wav", + "text": "國民年金帳戶裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147850/136.wav", + "text": "國民年金的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147850/137.wav", + "text": "他可以提撥" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147850/138.wav", + "text": "你們自己作的解釋" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147850/139.wav", + "text": "裡面寫的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147850/140.wav", + "text": "我有看到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147850/141.wav", + "text": "所以我剛剛才問你們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147850/142.wav", + "text": "107年你們資料還有更新過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147850/143.wav", + "text": "國民年金是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147850/144.wav", + "text": "勞工退休金" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147850/145.wav", + "text": "這次是準用勞工退休金條例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147850/146.wav", + "text": "所以會在服役期間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147850/147.wav", + "text": "幫他提繳退休金" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147850/148.wav", + "text": "我知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147850/149.wav", + "text": "你們自己在替代役" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147850/150.wav", + "text": "裡面寫得很清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147850/151.wav", + "text": "年滿25歲" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147850/152.wav", + "text": "男屬於國民年金" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147850/153.wav", + "text": "保險人納保範圍" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147850/154.wav", + "text": "是那是保險的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147850/155.wav", + "text": "跟" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147850/156.wav", + "text": "是分開來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147850/157.wav", + "text": "那一塊就對了\n" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147850/158.wav", + "text": "我想請教一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147850/159.wav", + "text": "別的委員也有問到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147850/160.wav", + "text": "過去服義務役的官士兵" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147850/161.wav", + "text": "能否自費買勞退的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147850/162.wav", + "text": "你們後來有沒有想" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147850/163.wav", + "text": "覺得可行還是不可行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147850/164.wav", + "text": "這個還是有人在關心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147850/165.wav", + "text": "讓大家都知道一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147850/166.wav", + "text": "如果93年的來跟你抗議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147850/167.wav", + "text": "差一年差那麼多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147850/168.wav", + "text": "怎麼辦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147850/169.wav", + "text": "這個就是一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147850/170.wav", + "text": "法的施行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147850/171.wav", + "text": "的一個起始點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147850/172.wav", + "text": "好所以這個就是很明確地" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147850/173.wav", + "text": "跟大家講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147850/174.wav", + "text": "94年次以前是沒有的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147850/175.wav", + "text": "是94年次以後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147850/176.wav", + "text": "就是以一年的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147850/177.wav", + "text": "這個部分會衍生到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147850/178.wav", + "text": "反映的一個問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147850/179.wav", + "text": "未滿20年的志願役同仁" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147850/180.wav", + "text": "能不能改買勞退年資" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147850/181.wav", + "text": "因為他如果沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147850/182.wav", + "text": "給他" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147850/183.wav", + "text": "月退的年資" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147850/184.wav", + "text": "那些都不算了嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147850/185.wav", + "text": "對所以他們也主張" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147850/186.wav", + "text": "有沒有可能讓他" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147850/187.wav", + "text": "勞退年資" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147850/188.wav", + "text": "義務役的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147850/189.wav", + "text": "已經是給他" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147850/190.wav", + "text": "用勞退的年資了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147850/191.wav", + "text": "而沒辦法領取" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147850/192.wav", + "text": "月退俸的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147850/193.wav", + "text": "國防部能不能研究" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147850/194.wav", + "text": "這個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147850/195.wav", + "text": "未來讓他用自費方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147850/196.wav", + "text": "買勞退的年資" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147850/197.wav", + "text": "這是他們有人問的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147850/198.wav", + "text": "你們要講清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147850/199.wav", + "text": "因為這是兩套" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147850/200.wav", + "text": "沒錯" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147850/201.wav", + "text": "所以我們沒有做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147850/202.wav", + "text": "一個銜接的規劃" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147850/203.wav", + "text": "因為軍人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147850/204.wav", + "text": "已經依據" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147850/205.wav", + "text": "的計算方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147850/206.wav", + "text": "請領基準" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147850/207.wav", + "text": "是兩個不一樣的制度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147850/208.wav", + "text": "所以目前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147850/209.wav", + "text": "其實勞工退休金條例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147850/210.wav", + "text": "也沒有買年資" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147850/211.wav", + "text": "是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147850/212.wav", + "text": "我看到有一些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147850/213.wav", + "text": "人有再提出這個問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147850/214.wav", + "text": "所以我想" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147850/215.wav", + "text": "就這個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147850/216.wav", + "text": "請教一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147850/217.wav", + "text": "國防部也讓國防部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147850/218.wav", + "text": "可以很明確地" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147850/219.wav", + "text": "讓大家瞭解一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147850/220.wav", + "text": "按照規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147850/221.wav", + "text": "他可以去買" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147850/222.wav", + "text": "公職年資" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147850/223.wav", + "text": "對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147850/224.wav", + "text": "併計" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147850/225.wav", + "text": "併計" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147850/226.wav", + "text": "就是可以買那個年資" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147850/227.wav", + "text": "把它算進去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147850/228.wav", + "text": "後來轉軍職" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147850/229.wav", + "text": "能不能有軍職的年資併計" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147850/230.wav", + "text": "就是等於" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147850/231.wav", + "text": "考上職業軍人以後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147850/232.wav", + "text": "對他如果轉服" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147850/233.wav", + "text": "是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147850/234.wav", + "text": "替代役男可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147850/235.wav", + "text": "如果是義務役的阿兵哥" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147850/236.wav", + "text": "可不可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147850/237.wav", + "text": "可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147850/238.wav", + "text": "義務役轉志願役的軍士官" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147850/239.wav", + "text": "有一個銜接" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147850/240.wav", + "text": "做了一年義" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147850/241.wav", + "text": "役轉志願役軍人的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147850/242.wav", + "text": "我義務役的那一年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147850/243.wav", + "text": "能不能算成我軍中的年資" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147850/244.wav", + "text": "可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147850/245.wav", + "text": "他完成一個退撫基金" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147850/246.wav", + "text": "補繳的一次撥補後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147850/247.wav", + "text": "就可以年資銜接" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147850/248.wav", + "text": "就可以領得20年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147850/249.wav", + "text": "確定嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147850/250.wav", + "text": "還是要實際是退休年資" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147850/251.wav", + "text": "因為這個大家都很關心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147850/252.wav", + "text": "再確認一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147850/253.wav", + "text": "如果他是替代役" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147850/254.wav", + "text": "未來他的公職退休金" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147850/255.wav", + "text": "他可以自己買年資併計" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147850/256.wav", + "text": "如果是義務役的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147850/257.wav", + "text": "因為他們現在是提撥" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147850/258.wav", + "text": "勞工退休金" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147850/259.wav", + "text": "如果他考上公職" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147850/260.wav", + "text": "這個部分的年資" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147850/261.wav", + "text": "也可以讓他買嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147850/262.wav", + "text": "如果他不是替代役" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147850/263.wav", + "text": "而是義務役的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147850/264.wav", + "text": "可不可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147850/265.wav", + "text": "轉公職可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147850/266.wav", + "text": "義務役轉公職也可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147850/267.wav", + "text": "可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147850/268.wav", + "text": "義務役轉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147850/269.wav", + "text": "志願役" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147850/270.wav", + "text": "是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147850/271.wav", + "text": "替代役未來轉軍職" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147850/272.wav", + "text": "可不可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147850/273.wav", + "text": "是義務役" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147850/274.wav", + "text": "不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147850/275.wav", + "text": "我就說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147850/276.wav", + "text": "他是義務役的替代役" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147850/277.wav", + "text": "他不是在部隊裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147850/278.wav", + "text": "所以他有可能在內政部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147850/279.wav", + "text": "也有可能在勞動部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147850/280.wav", + "text": "或地方政府" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147850/281.wav", + "text": "他做了一年的替代役之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147850/282.wav", + "text": "決定去當職業軍人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147850/283.wav", + "text": "他的年資" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147850/284.wav", + "text": "能不能併到職業軍人的年資" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147850/285.wav", + "text": "可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147850/286.wav", + "text": "也可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147850/287.wav", + "text": "我想再讓大家知道一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147850/288.wav", + "text": "\n第一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147850/289.wav", + "text": "如果是替代役" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147850/290.wav", + "text": "服役完一年之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147850/291.wav", + "text": "明年度的替代役" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147850/292.wav", + "text": "也是一年吧" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147850/293.wav", + "text": "還是一年兩個月" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147850/294.wav", + "text": "94年次是一年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147850/295.wav", + "text": "之後呢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147850/296.wav", + "text": "都是一年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147850/297.wav", + "text": "規劃是一年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147850/298.wav", + "text": "他服役完一年之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147850/299.wav", + "text": "假設他考上公職" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147850/300.wav", + "text": "是可以併公職的年資計算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147850/301.wav", + "text": "即便現在我們幫他提撥" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147850/302.wav", + "text": "勞工退休金" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147850/303.wav", + "text": "所以不論他是服役公職" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147850/304.wav", + "text": "或最後他決定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147850/305.wav", + "text": "轉服志願役軍人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147850/306.wav", + "text": "同樣的道理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147850/307.wav", + "text": "他如果現在是在國防部的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147850/308.wav", + "text": "義務役士兵" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147850/309.wav", + "text": "如果決定轉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147850/310.wav", + "text": "志願役的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147850/311.wav", + "text": "也可以合併計算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147850/312.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147850/313.wav", + "text": "還有軍訓課" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147850/314.wav", + "text": "對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147850/315.wav", + "text": "有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147850/316.wav", + "text": "明年度開始" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147850/317.wav", + "text": "還能不能抵" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147850/318.wav", + "text": "還是可以依規定折抵" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147850/319.wav", + "text": "定折抵最多可以抵多少天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147850/320.wav", + "text": "30天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147850/321.wav", + "text": "30天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147850/322.wav", + "text": "一年期義務役最多30天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147850/323.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147850/324.wav", + "text": "抵的30天算不算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147850/325.wav", + "text": "勞工退休金的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147850/326.wav", + "text": "不算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147850/327.wav", + "text": "以實際在營服役的天數來算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147850/328.wav", + "text": "也要讓大家知道一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147850/329.wav", + "text": "我剛才講的這幾個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147850/330.wav", + "text": "明年度才開始執行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147850/331.wav", + "text": "可能會遇到的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147850/332.wav", + "text": "我會建議國防部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147850/333.wav", + "text": "專責的網站" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147850/334.wav", + "text": "讓大家知道一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147850/335.wav", + "text": "有關義務役官士" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147850/336.wav", + "text": "權益你我他的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147850/337.wav", + "text": "我剛剛問的這些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147850/338.wav", + "text": "有很多是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147850/339.wav", + "text": "我們蒐集到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147850/340.wav", + "text": "一般役男" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147850/341.wav", + "text": "或家長的意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147850/342.wav", + "text": "我覺得有必要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147850/343.wav", + "text": "也請國防部相關單位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147850/344.wav", + "text": "因為明年度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147850/345.wav", + "text": "進到部隊的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147850/346.wav", + "text": "可能數量會越來越多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147850/347.wav", + "text": "以上謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147850/348.wav", + "text": "好謝謝委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147849/0.wav", + "text": "有請次長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147849/1.wav", + "text": "次長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147849/2.wav", + "text": "陳委員好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147849/3.wav", + "text": "次長好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147849/4.wav", + "text": "本席" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147849/5.wav", + "text": "沒有關係" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147849/6.wav", + "text": "次長和副部長都做一樣的事" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147849/7.wav", + "text": "副部長其實本席" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147849/8.wav", + "text": "並不是很熟悉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147849/9.wav", + "text": "眷村的脈絡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147849/10.wav", + "text": "也接到非常多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147849/11.wav", + "text": "遺眷遭國防部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147849/12.wav", + "text": "拆屋還地案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147849/13.wav", + "text": "其中一個很重要的關鍵" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147849/14.wav", + "text": "就是國防部能夠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147849/15.wav", + "text": "提供" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147849/16.wav", + "text": "他們民國43年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147849/17.wav", + "text": "進駐臺灣的美國中情局" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147849/18.wav", + "text": "第三勢力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147849/19.wav", + "text": "華人美軍之相關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147849/20.wav", + "text": "資料" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147849/21.wav", + "text": "如果不提供" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147849/22.wav", + "text": "證明他們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147849/23.wav", + "text": "就是美軍" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147849/24.wav", + "text": "所以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147849/25.wav", + "text": "在這裡請國防部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147849/26.wav", + "text": "兩週內提供" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147849/27.wav", + "text": "炎明新村陳情人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147849/28.wav", + "text": "張台鳳女士" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147849/29.wav", + "text": "所要求的相關資料" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147849/30.wav", + "text": "包括" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147849/31.wav", + "text": "當時" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147849/32.wav", + "text": "美國中情局第三勢力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147849/33.wav", + "text": "華人美軍" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147849/34.wav", + "text": "美援撥款之資遣費" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147849/35.wav", + "text": "經費" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147849/36.wav", + "text": "之款項清單" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147849/37.wav", + "text": "還有1954年至1956年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147849/38.wav", + "text": "美軍顧問團" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147849/39.wav", + "text": "函至國防部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147849/40.wav", + "text": "引介華人美軍之相關公文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147849/41.wav", + "text": "兩個禮拜內提供" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147849/42.wav", + "text": "歷史脈絡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147849/43.wav", + "text": "證明國防部處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147849/44.wav", + "text": "本案的正當性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147849/45.wav", + "text": "沒有我只是希望" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147849/46.wav", + "text": "能夠提供" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147849/47.wav", + "text": "兩週我們回去再看看那個時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147849/48.wav", + "text": "可以嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147849/49.wav", + "text": "有關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147849/50.wav", + "text": "眷改的其中還有國安六村" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147849/51.wav", + "text": "副部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147849/52.wav", + "text": "這個案子嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147849/53.wav", + "text": "因為這個案子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147849/54.wav", + "text": "目前國防部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147849/55.wav", + "text": "修法來解決" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147849/56.wav", + "text": "其中的3個村包括" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147849/57.wav", + "text": "等就會被排除" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147849/58.wav", + "text": "補助的範圍" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147849/59.wav", + "text": "也讓原來享有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147849/60.wav", + "text": "由國防部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147849/61.wav", + "text": "代為興建" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147849/62.wav", + "text": "住宅的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147849/63.wav", + "text": "補助方式就會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147849/64.wav", + "text": "吳斯懷委員也有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147849/65.wav", + "text": "協助召開協調會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147849/66.wav", + "text": "政戰局這邊表示他們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147849/67.wav", + "text": "不違法為什麼要修法呢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147849/68.wav", + "text": "為什麼要修法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147849/69.wav", + "text": "委員好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147849/70.wav", + "text": "政戰局這邊跟委員說明一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147849/71.wav", + "text": "因為當初6" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147849/72.wav", + "text": "6個村的住戶在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147849/73.wav", + "text": "眷改條例裡其" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147849/74.wav", + "text": "其身分沒有辦法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147849/75.wav", + "text": "身分所以沒辦法列入眷改" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147849/76.wav", + "text": "已經推動" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147849/77.wav", + "text": "2月22日" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147849/78.wav", + "text": "審竣但是要完成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147849/79.wav", + "text": "院會的程序之後再送" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147849/80.wav", + "text": "因為這個陳情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147849/81.wav", + "text": "修法對他們來講並不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147849/82.wav", + "text": "符合正義的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147849/83.wav", + "text": "特殊脈絡專案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147849/84.wav", + "text": "來處理也請副部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147849/85.wav", + "text": "再研議這個案子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147849/86.wav", + "text": "修法的方式處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147849/87.wav", + "text": "報告委員我想這二個我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147849/88.wav", + "text": "都去討論至於怎麼樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147849/89.wav", + "text": "能夠讓這樣的一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147849/90.wav", + "text": "是好事啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147849/91.wav", + "text": "兩全其美我們回去再跟" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147849/92.wav", + "text": "相關單位討論再跟委員做報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147849/93.wav", + "text": "好最後就是有關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147849/94.wav", + "text": "新竹北赤" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147849/95.wav", + "text": "土崎新村案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147849/96.wav", + "text": "因為這個案子也" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147849/97.wav", + "text": "涉及" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147849/98.wav", + "text": "弊案包括世紀" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147849/99.wav", + "text": "主要就是昌益公司" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147849/100.wav", + "text": "行賄的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147849/101.wav", + "text": "新竹跟財團" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147849/102.wav", + "text": "還每個月付幾十萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147849/103.wav", + "text": "所以這個案子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147849/104.wav", + "text": "能夠重新" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147849/105.wav", + "text": "終止相關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147849/106.wav", + "text": "就是說這個都更案其實" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147849/107.wav", + "text": "希望能夠考量" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147849/108.wav", + "text": "會後再跟委員說明這個案子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147849/109.wav", + "text": "的最新狀況好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147849/110.wav", + "text": "讓陳情人得到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147849/111.wav", + "text": "更合理的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147848/0.wav", + "text": "有請副部長謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147848/1.wav", + "text": "美國提出關於中共的軍力報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147848/2.wav", + "text": "他幾乎每年都會做評估" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147848/3.wav", + "text": "從2018以後陸陸續續" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147848/4.wav", + "text": "大概都類似這幾個情境" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147848/5.wav", + "text": "這六個情境最可能是老共會動武的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147848/6.wav", + "text": "是不是只有這六個情境" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147848/7.wav", + "text": "還是會有其他的情境" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147848/8.wav", + "text": "評估跟美國一樣嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147848/9.wav", + "text": "還是有其他可能的因素" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147848/10.wav", + "text": "也會造成武力犯臺" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147848/11.wav", + "text": "報告委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147848/12.wav", + "text": "中共軍力報告書的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147848/13.wav", + "text": "事實上來講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147848/14.wav", + "text": "而有不一樣的觀點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147848/15.wav", + "text": "但都逃不出這樣的一個範疇" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147848/16.wav", + "text": "對於美方這樣的一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147848/17.wav", + "text": "除了這六個以外" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147848/18.wav", + "text": "我們認為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147848/19.wav", + "text": "就像委員所強調的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147848/20.wav", + "text": "一定還會有所謂的其他因素" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147848/21.wav", + "text": "還有不同的國際情勢改變" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147848/22.wav", + "text": "干擾也好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147848/23.wav", + "text": "或者在國際上的作為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147848/24.wav", + "text": "也好你認為還有沒有其他因素" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147848/25.wav", + "text": "可能會造成犯臺" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147848/26.wav", + "text": "除此之外" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147848/27.wav", + "text": "當然還有其他因素" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147848/28.wav", + "text": "像什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147848/29.wav", + "text": "今天任何的一個軍事行動他" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147848/30.wav", + "text": "他那麼近距離接觸" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147848/31.wav", + "text": "行為就會有擦槍走火的意外" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147848/32.wav", + "text": "所以就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147848/33.wav", + "text": "當這樣的意外發生的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147848/34.wav", + "text": "這是我們不可預料的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147848/35.wav", + "text": "所以一種就是你剛剛提到的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147848/36.wav", + "text": "也就是除了這六種以外" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147848/37.wav", + "text": "另外可能造成擦槍走火的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147848/38.wav", + "text": "包括美國或者西方國家常在講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147848/39.wav", + "text": "的就是危險跟不專業的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147848/40.wav", + "text": "這樣不專業的行為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147848/41.wav", + "text": "這樣子的軍事行為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147848/42.wav", + "text": "就像這幾天在南海的衝突" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147848/43.wav", + "text": "包括南海包括加拿大" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147848/44.wav", + "text": "跟他們之間的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147848/45.wav", + "text": "是的國際情勢的改變" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147848/46.wav", + "text": "會產生很多的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147848/47.wav", + "text": "我再請教" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147848/48.wav", + "text": "這個是一種嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147848/49.wav", + "text": "看起來其實機會也不小" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147848/50.wav", + "text": "不小" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147848/51.wav", + "text": "因為現在大家彼此在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147848/52.wav", + "text": "南海也好東海也好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147848/53.wav", + "text": "臺灣海峽也好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147848/54.wav", + "text": "飛來飛去繞來繞去這" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147848/55.wav", + "text": "尤其在一些灰色地帶" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147848/56.wav", + "text": "相互遇到的頻率是很高的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147848/57.wav", + "text": "當然就增加衝突的可能" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147848/58.wav", + "text": "另外一種" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147848/59.wav", + "text": "比如去年裴洛西來臺" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147848/60.wav", + "text": "對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147848/61.wav", + "text": "也被稱作是第四次的臺海危機" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147848/62.wav", + "text": "這個算不算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147848/63.wav", + "text": "報告委員那個已經在邊緣了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147848/64.wav", + "text": "如果依照這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147848/65.wav", + "text": "在邊緣其實就差" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147848/66.wav", + "text": "是差在任何一方引起他的強烈" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147848/67.wav", + "text": "如果這中間又有擦槍走火" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147848/68.wav", + "text": "就爆發了嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147848/69.wav", + "text": "對這個是邊緣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147848/70.wav", + "text": "瀕臨邊緣是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147848/71.wav", + "text": "但這樣的情境" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147848/72.wav", + "text": "但這都在他的觀察範圍裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147848/73.wav", + "text": "觀察範圍裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147848/74.wav", + "text": "對都在他的觀察範圍裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147848/75.wav", + "text": "因為對於中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147848/76.wav", + "text": "所以這是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147848/77.wav", + "text": "六大範疇以外的其他" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147848/78.wav", + "text": "美國國防部在聽證會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147848/79.wav", + "text": "他認為很多的情境都可能會發生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147848/80.wav", + "text": "包含平常" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147848/81.wav", + "text": "像裴洛西事件" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147848/82.wav", + "text": "就類似部分封鎖的概念" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147848/83.wav", + "text": "這仍然是他的觀察" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147848/84.wav", + "text": "對啊所以類似部分封鎖" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147848/85.wav", + "text": "或者是準備封鎖這樣的作為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147848/86.wav", + "text": "最後武力犯臺的可能" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147848/87.wav", + "text": "他講得非常清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147848/88.wav", + "text": "所付出的代價非常高" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147848/89.wav", + "text": "攔檢商船的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147848/90.wav", + "text": "但是他認為說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147848/91.wav", + "text": "所以在某種程度上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147848/92.wav", + "text": "還在他的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147848/93.wav", + "text": "他說不是迫在眉睫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147848/94.wav", + "text": "但是也不可避免" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147848/95.wav", + "text": "但是有可能引起擦槍走火" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147848/96.wav", + "text": "失控" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147848/97.wav", + "text": "是的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147848/98.wav", + "text": "美國跟中共一直在講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147848/99.wav", + "text": "分期管控的機制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147848/100.wav", + "text": "也就是害怕這種事情發生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147848/101.wav", + "text": "所謂的干擾作為有很多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147848/102.wav", + "text": "灰色地帶也很多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147848/103.wav", + "text": "也有發生在兩岸上面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147848/104.wav", + "text": "昨天菲律賓的船就和中共的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147848/105.wav", + "text": "對那是菲律賓跟中共" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147848/106.wav", + "text": "我們跟中共的飛機也好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147848/107.wav", + "text": "船隻也好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147848/108.wav", + "text": "發生這種事的頻率高不高" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147848/109.wav", + "text": "就是危險跟不專業的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147848/110.wav", + "text": "我們有沒有被他攔截" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147848/111.wav", + "text": "這種危險跟不專業的干擾" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147848/112.wav", + "text": "次數多不多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147848/113.wav", + "text": "報告委員其實頻率還滿高的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147848/114.wav", + "text": "多少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147848/115.wav", + "text": "Ely Ratner" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147848/116.wav", + "text": "對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147848/117.wav", + "text": "他之前有開記者會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147848/118.wav", + "text": "說200次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147848/119.wav", + "text": "他們的頻率" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147848/120.wav", + "text": "統計出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147848/121.wav", + "text": "我跟委員報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147848/122.wav", + "text": "我們的頻率有沒有比他高" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147848/123.wav", + "text": "事實上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147848/124.wav", + "text": "我跟委員報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147848/125.wav", + "text": "在臺海周邊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147848/126.wav", + "text": "出現的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147848/127.wav", + "text": "不是美軍就是日本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147848/128.wav", + "text": "再不然就是我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147848/129.wav", + "text": "所以這個機率幾乎是相等的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147848/130.wav", + "text": "這很高" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147848/131.wav", + "text": "耶如果是這樣的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147848/132.wav", + "text": "你要想" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147848/133.wav", + "text": "這就是為什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147848/134.wav", + "text": "擔心會擦槍走火" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147848/135.wav", + "text": "不光是美中之間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147848/136.wav", + "text": "還有兩岸之間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147848/137.wav", + "text": "還有日本跟他們之間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147848/138.wav", + "text": "這個機率是要相乘的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147848/139.wav", + "text": "不是相加的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147848/140.wav", + "text": "因為他們接觸的頻率" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147848/141.wav", + "text": "比我們還高" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147848/142.wav", + "text": "所以他的統計資料" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147848/143.wav", + "text": "副部長我再問一件事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147848/144.wav", + "text": "既然頻率這麼高" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147848/145.wav", + "text": "顯然你們必須要做好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147848/146.wav", + "text": "萬一擦槍走火的準備" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147848/147.wav", + "text": "當然" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147848/148.wav", + "text": "你們第一時間的準備" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147848/149.wav", + "text": "是什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147848/150.wav", + "text": "報告委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147848/151.wav", + "text": "這是按照我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147848/152.wav", + "text": "所有突發狀況的處置" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147848/153.wav", + "text": "來應處" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147848/154.wav", + "text": "一個是軍事的處置" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147848/155.wav", + "text": "一個是政治的處置" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147848/156.wav", + "text": "對政治的處置就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147848/157.wav", + "text": "如果有這種情況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147848/158.wav", + "text": "發生的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147848/159.wav", + "text": "一定會召開" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147848/160.wav", + "text": "國家安全會議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147848/161.wav", + "text": "那是國內" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147848/162.wav", + "text": "對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147848/163.wav", + "text": "所以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147848/164.wav", + "text": "這中間所謂的誤判" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147848/165.wav", + "text": "或擦槍走火的事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147848/166.wav", + "text": "兩岸之間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147848/167.wav", + "text": "有沒有溝通的管道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147848/168.wav", + "text": "態勢的擴大" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147848/169.wav", + "text": "因為如果是純粹的擦槍走火" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147848/170.wav", + "text": "或者因為誤判" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147848/171.wav", + "text": "跟危險行為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147848/172.wav", + "text": "我們當然要嚇阻這樣的行為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147848/173.wav", + "text": "但是萬一這樣的擦撞" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147848/174.wav", + "text": "衝撞" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147848/175.wav", + "text": "衝突發生的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147848/176.wav", + "text": "你們的管控機制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147848/177.wav", + "text": "報告委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147848/178.wav", + "text": "你有沒有看到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147848/179.wav", + "text": "最近美國國防部一直在講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147848/180.wav", + "text": "他們的管道被中斷了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147848/181.wav", + "text": "對啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147848/182.wav", + "text": "就是這是一個全世界都被" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147848/183.wav", + "text": "阻擋在外面的危險信號" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147848/184.wav", + "text": "所以這件事情是一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147848/185.wav", + "text": "是那怎麼辦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147848/186.wav", + "text": "在美國的立場" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147848/187.wav", + "text": "所以希望能夠接觸" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147848/188.wav", + "text": "能夠有一些管道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147848/189.wav", + "text": "就是communication" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147848/190.wav", + "text": "就是communication" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147848/191.wav", + "text": "就是military to military" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147848/192.wav", + "text": "for the crisis" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147848/193.wav", + "text": "希望能逐步強化" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147848/194.wav", + "text": "但是到現在為止都" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147848/195.wav", + "text": "現在有恢復了嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147848/196.wav", + "text": "還沒恢復" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147848/197.wav", + "text": "所以現在是相當危險的狀態" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147848/198.wav", + "text": "所以我們希望" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147848/199.wav", + "text": "所有理念相近的國家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147848/200.wav", + "text": "大家應該還是要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147848/201.wav", + "text": "平心靜氣地來看這件事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147848/202.wav", + "text": "現在看起來就是說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147848/203.wav", + "text": "跟危險的頻率這麼高的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147848/204.wav", + "text": "是不好的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147848/205.wav", + "text": "或者灰色地帶的干擾" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147848/206.wav", + "text": "頻率這麼高" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147848/207.wav", + "text": "不只發生在兩岸" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147848/208.wav", + "text": "還發生在美中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147848/209.wav", + "text": "還發生在日本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147848/210.wav", + "text": "跟他們之間的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147848/211.wav", + "text": "要國際共同譴責" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147848/212.wav", + "text": "或者是擦槍走火的機率" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147848/213.wav", + "text": "我們的應處" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147848/214.wav", + "text": "這個應處真的很關鍵" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147848/215.wav", + "text": "我們負責執行任務的人的壓力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147848/216.wav", + "text": "這部分你要怎麼處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147848/217.wav", + "text": "是的謝謝委員提醒" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147848/218.wav", + "text": "因為稍有不小心的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147848/219.wav", + "text": "恐怕可能不是單一的小衝突而已" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147848/220.wav", + "text": "不小心有可能就擴大了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147848/221.wav", + "text": "所以這個應處" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147848/222.wav", + "text": "是謝謝委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147848/223.wav", + "text": "整個SOP啦好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147848/224.wav", + "text": "謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147847/0.wav", + "text": "陳委員好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147847/1.wav", + "text": "那我們就跟您再往下討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147847/2.wav", + "text": "上一次我們提到關於輿論在討論恢復軍審的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147847/3.wav", + "text": "我要先說今天提關於役男義務役服役期間提繳退休金條例草案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147847/4.wav", + "text": "我們辦公室是支持的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147847/5.wav", + "text": "因為這個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147847/6.wav", + "text": "我相信大家都有共識" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147847/7.wav", + "text": "是謝謝委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147847/8.wav", + "text": "但是恢復軍審的討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147847/9.wav", + "text": "我們覺得還是相關地重要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147847/10.wav", + "text": "是不是可以請相關的主管也一併上來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147847/11.wav", + "text": "我們想要���論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147847/12.wav", + "text": "其實我們辦公室一直認為軍審制度跟軍紀維護因果關係的這件事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147847/13.wav", + "text": "其實都很需要商榷" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147847/14.wav", + "text": "很需要討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147847/15.wav", + "text": "事實上我們認為領導統御的問題在於有沒有行政上的有效管理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147847/16.wav", + "text": "是不是要恢復軍審" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147847/17.wav", + "text": "才能夠展現領導統御行政管理能力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147847/18.wav", + "text": "這件事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147847/19.wav", + "text": "我們覺得有很大的爭議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147847/20.wav", + "text": "這個新聞" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147847/21.wav", + "text": "我相信柏副應該有看見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147847/22.wav", + "text": "不知道柏副" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147847/23.wav", + "text": "副在這個新聞點上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147847/24.wav", + "text": "您看見的是什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147847/25.wav", + "text": "我們國防部在看這個軍紀事件的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147847/26.wav", + "text": "從以前到現在為止" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147847/27.wav", + "text": "軍紀的維護都是很嚴謹的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147847/28.wav", + "text": "所以這件事情對國防部本身來講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147847/29.wav", + "text": "我們也檢討內部管理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147847/30.wav", + "text": "是不是有什麼疏失" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147847/31.wav", + "text": "但是這件事情我們必須要很嚴正地講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147847/32.wav", + "text": "在軍隊中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147847/33.wav", + "text": "是不被允許的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147847/34.wav", + "text": "這個我們絕對認同" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147847/35.wav", + "text": "嚴肅軍紀" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147847/36.wav", + "text": "所以在領導統御上來講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147847/37.wav", + "text": "我們必須要把這件事情很正式說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147847/38.wav", + "text": "在未來來講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147847/39.wav", + "text": "也會請求司法部門在這個方面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147847/40.wav", + "text": "做溝通" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147847/41.wav", + "text": "所以我們法律事務司" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147847/42.wav", + "text": "也會持續再跟相關的單位來做溝通" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147847/43.wav", + "text": "不過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147847/44.wav", + "text": "因為我們剛剛聽到柏副說的這些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147847/45.wav", + "text": "其實我們都認同" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147847/46.wav", + "text": "因為軍紀的維護本來就有它的特殊性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147847/47.wav", + "text": "而且有它的必要性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147847/48.wav", + "text": "只是因為恢復軍審討論這件事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147847/49.wav", + "text": "其實我們知道國防部裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147847/50.wav", + "text": "自己本來就有刑懲併行的原則" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147847/51.wav", + "text": "這個事件" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147847/52.wav", + "text": "其實相關的士兵也收到國防部裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147847/53.wav", + "text": "有悔過15天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147847/54.wav", + "text": "到禁足6日的相關處分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147847/55.wav", + "text": "我相信柏副" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147847/56.wav", + "text": "你應該是知道後續他們的處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147847/57.wav", + "text": "只是說恢復軍審" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147847/58.wav", + "text": "跟這樣子展現領導統御能力之間的因果關係" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147847/59.wav", + "text": "我們都覺得有必要再多多討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147847/60.wav", + "text": "因為對於現在的很多年輕人來說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147847/61.wav", + "text": "他們在比較民主自由的校園氛圍下長大" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147847/62.wav", + "text": "尤其是我們要把義務役延長到1年的這個期間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147847/63.wav", + "text": "年輕學子們要面對的是這樣的軍紀跟理解" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147847/64.wav", + "text": "跟他們過往認為軍審已經暫停了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147847/65.wav", + "text": "這個部分會不會有很大的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147847/66.wav", + "text": "其實我們辦公室從上一次質詢完之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147847/67.wav", + "text": "國防部目前的說法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147847/68.wav", + "text": "目前在平時應該不會有這個問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147847/69.wav", + "text": "所以想要再一次確認" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147847/70.wav", + "text": "是不是這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147847/71.wav", + "text": "現行是這樣子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147847/72.wav", + "text": "報告委員我還是必須強調" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147847/73.wav", + "text": "這些所有都是一個手段" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147847/74.wav", + "text": "但它目的是什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147847/75.wav", + "text": "目的就是嚴肅軍紀" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147847/76.wav", + "text": "這樣子的一個情況下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147847/77.wav", + "text": "事實上我們現有的法規在刑懲併行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147847/78.wav", + "text": "是不是周延" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147847/79.wav", + "text": "延我想所有相關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147847/80.wav", + "text": "議題都在立法院討論過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147847/81.wav", + "text": "我們也尊重所有社會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147847/82.wav", + "text": "對於國防部的監督" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147847/83.wav", + "text": "未來是不是在刑懲併行之外" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147847/84.wav", + "text": "在戰時的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147847/85.wav", + "text": "是有軍法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147847/86.wav", + "text": "平常時期是不是要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147847/87.wav", + "text": "我們還是要尋求最大的共識" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147847/88.wav", + "text": "那重點是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147847/89.wav", + "text": "還是要如何維持軍紀的完整性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147847/90.wav", + "text": "其實國防部也有自己的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147847/91.wav", + "text": "陸海空軍懲罰法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147847/92.wav", + "text": "還有國軍權益保障" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147847/93.wav", + "text": "我想在柏副您這邊的說明之下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147847/94.wav", + "text": "我相信大家會對國防部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147847/95.wav", + "text": "在這個議題上有信心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147847/96.wav", + "text": "而不要讓很多的媒體操作成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147847/97.wav", + "text": "好像國防部要霸道地" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147847/98.wav", + "text": "恢復軍審這件事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147847/99.wav", + "text": "所以我想我們就是再次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147847/100.wav", + "text": "我們不會霸道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147847/101.wav", + "text": "我們都是尊重所有的社會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147847/102.wav", + "text": "大家的討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147847/103.wav", + "text": "好那我最後1分鐘嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147847/104.wav", + "text": "關於在預算案裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147847/105.wav", + "text": "我們看到其實國軍團膳的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147847/106.wav", + "text": "我們就快速提醒一下國防部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147847/107.wav", + "text": "其實有相關多的案子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147847/108.wav", + "text": "我相信在國防部裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147847/109.wav", + "text": "有非常多關於用餐的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147847/110.wav", + "text": "因為一天三餐" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147847/111.wav", + "text": "加上現在大家都說廚工難找" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147847/112.wav", + "text": "相關的預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147847/113.wav", + "text": "我們絕對會支持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147847/114.wav", + "text": "因為我們也希望國軍弟兄姐妹們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147847/115.wav", + "text": "在基本的生理需求" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147847/116.wav", + "text": "用餐這件事情是被滿足的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147847/117.wav", + "text": "可是因為一直都會有相關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147847/118.wav", + "text": "食安問題的產生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147847/119.wav", + "text": "環境衛生這個問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147847/120.wav", + "text": "其實一直都有類似的新聞" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147847/121.wav", + "text": "所以我們這邊就快速邀請國防部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147847/122.wav", + "text": "也拜託國防部一定要在這個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147847/123.wav", + "text": "加強監督相關得標廠商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147847/124.wav", + "text": "或者是相關的因應措施" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147847/125.wav", + "text": "必須要讓他們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147847/126.wav", + "text": "在基本的生理需求上被滿足" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147847/127.wav", + "text": "而不會擔心有相關的風險" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147847/128.wav", + "text": "是報告委員您所重視的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147847/129.wav", + "text": "就是我們平常都在做的例行工作" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147847/130.wav", + "text": "當然我們希望我們所有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147847/131.wav", + "text": "在用餐方面的品質也好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147847/132.wav", + "text": "能夠符合我們社會的期待" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147847/133.wav", + "text": "同時跟委員報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147847/134.wav", + "text": "我們都是身在其中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147847/135.wav", + "text": "我們會隨時反映到我們承辦單位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147847/136.wav", + "text": "所以他們壓力很大" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147847/137.wav", + "text": "但是這個是一個整體性的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147847/138.wav", + "text": "所以國防部長期" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147847/139.wav", + "text": "在改善團膳的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147847/140.wav", + "text": "是我們永遠都在做的事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147847/141.wav", + "text": "請委員放心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147847/142.wav", + "text": "如果有看���任何需要建議給我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147847/143.wav", + "text": "的我們隨時歡迎委員的建議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147847/144.wav", + "text": "好也謝謝柏副" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147847/145.wav", + "text": "謝謝謝謝主席" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147846/0.wav", + "text": "謝謝主席是不是麻煩主席有請柏副部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147846/1.wav", + "text": "賴委員好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147846/2.wav", + "text": "役期還有提升待遇以外的全民國防政策以外" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147846/3.wav", + "text": "我們近年的國防政策不外乎就是推動國防自主" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147846/4.wav", + "text": "還有不對稱戰力的整備採購" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147846/5.wav", + "text": "這是我們重要的方向" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147846/6.wav", + "text": "國際間的合作或其他國家的軍事動向" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147846/7.wav", + "text": "但是就幾個事實" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147846/8.wav", + "text": "請教你第一個中國解放軍的騷擾" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147846/9.wav", + "text": "是從遠程擦邊球開始" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147846/10.wav", + "text": "這兩年逐漸靠近飛越海峽中線" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147846/11.wav", + "text": "目前更將圍臺列為常態訓練" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147846/12.wav", + "text": "而且目標其實也不只臺灣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147846/13.wav", + "text": "包含鄰國日本菲律賓都深受其擾" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147846/14.wav", + "text": "再來臺灣位於第一島鏈正中間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147846/15.wav", + "text": "西太平洋上非常關鍵的戰略要地" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147846/16.wav", + "text": "國防部自己9月剛發布的2023年版國防報告書資料" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147846/17.wav", + "text": "我們不只具有軍事上的重要意義" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147846/18.wav", + "text": "在貿易民生上也是一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147846/19.wav", + "text": "因為全球大概有50%的貨輪需要經過臺灣海峽" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147846/20.wav", + "text": "臺北飛航情報區總共有18條國際航線" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147846/21.wav", + "text": "目前無人機在中共擾臺偵察機中大概占了五成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147846/22.wav", + "text": "其實也反映了一件事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147846/23.wav", + "text": "就是中國已經有量產遠端遙控大型無人機的能力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147846/24.wav", + "text": "而且部分機種可擴充掛載武器" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147846/25.wav", + "text": "所以我們也需要應對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147846/26.wav", + "text": "\n確實也是因為這樣子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147846/27.wav", + "text": "我想提一件事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147846/28.wav", + "text": "下週三就要開始審國防部的預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147846/29.wav", + "text": "根據我的瞭解" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147846/30.wav", + "text": "有委員個人提了一百零多案刪減或凍結預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147846/31.wav", + "text": "也有特別針對幾項採購項目" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147846/32.wav", + "text": "例如說遙控無人機防禦系統" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147846/33.wav", + "text": "例如說魚叉飛彈海岸防衛系統" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147846/34.wav", + "text": "或者是人攜式短程防空飛彈" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147846/35.wav", + "text": "或者是新一代輕型巡防艦籌建案等等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147846/36.wav", + "text": "更不用說現在新聞上面已經" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147846/37.wav", + "text": "鬧得沸沸揚揚的潛艦國造第二階段的預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147846/38.wav", + "text": "這些採購項目" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147846/39.wav", + "text": "是不是都跟促進國防自主" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147846/40.wav", + "text": "或者不對稱作戰的用途有相關有直接的關係" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147846/41.wav", + "text": "謝謝委員這麼深入的問題探討" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147846/42.wav", + "text": "從國際局勢看到現在我們所建立的戰力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147846/43.wav", + "text": "其實無非就是因為因應臺海局勢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147846/44.wav", + "text": "我們所做的任何事必須要先從國防自主開始" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147846/45.wav", + "text": "因為自己的國家自己救" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147846/46.wav", + "text": "不對稱戰力現在是全世界在國際的戰爭上來講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147846/47.wav", + "text": "比如烏克蘭和俄羅斯的戰爭" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147846/48.wav", + "text": "所以國防部在未來來講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147846/49.wav", + "text": "我們也是朝這方面來建立我們所謂的不對稱戰力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147846/50.wav", + "text": "來抗衡中共現在的大舉入侵" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147846/51.wav", + "text": "是所以聽起來我剛剛講的這些東西" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147846/52.wav", + "text": "就是要能夠抵抗中共侵略非常重要的項目" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147846/53.wav", + "text": "有些是採購" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147846/54.wav", + "text": "我就要想要問國防部這邊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147846/55.wav", + "text": "既然這些東西這麼重要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147846/56.wav", + "text": "我必須要講一個事實" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147846/57.wav", + "text": "本席看到國防部近期的回應" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147846/58.wav", + "text": "我認為太基本太軟" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147846/59.wav", + "text": "其實針對這些東西" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147846/60.wav", + "text": "既然OK啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147846/61.wav", + "text": "我們在立法院都知道這個東西很重要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147846/62.wav", + "text": "在國防部都知道說這些東西非常重要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147846/63.wav", + "text": "那其實我覺得國防部是不是就應該要有更多的說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147846/64.wav", + "text": "我要在這裡強調" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147846/65.wav", + "text": "當然作為一個立法委員的職責" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147846/66.wav", + "text": "是監督政府施政" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147846/67.wav", + "text": "還有為預算把關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147846/68.wav", + "text": "這個是沒有問題的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147846/69.wav", + "text": "但是應該要是怎麼樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147846/70.wav", + "text": "應該要是該花的錢我們要花" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147846/71.wav", + "text": "需要省的我們才要來斤斤計較" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147846/72.wav", + "text": "我就拿我剛剛自己講到的潛艦國造第二階段的原型艦籌建來看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147846/73.wav", + "text": "三十九億多的預算被提案凍結了3億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147846/74.wav", + "text": "會不會影響未來的規劃" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147846/75.wav", + "text": "一定會嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147846/76.wav", + "text": "其實剛才前一個趙天麟委員也有在問這個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147846/77.wav", + "text": "國防部自己也都說一定會影響" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147846/78.wav", + "text": "嘛所以我們是不是應該要往最糟糕的方向去想" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147846/79.wav", + "text": "如果到時候沒有成功地解凍" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147846/80.wav", + "text": "等於就是變成說要縮水" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147846/81.wav", + "text": "耶是要用36億的規模去籌建規劃這件事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147846/82.wav", + "text": "那少了這些錢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147846/83.wav", + "text": "其實有可能就是會東砍西砍" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147846/84.wav", + "text": "甚至去壓縮某一些部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147846/85.wav", + "text": "既然如此" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147846/86.wav", + "text": "國防部在回應上是不是就應該更積極一點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147846/87.wav", + "text": "我在這邊講的並不是說要強硬地去反擊特定的委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147846/88.wav", + "text": "並不是這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147846/89.wav", + "text": "而是我認為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147846/90.wav", + "text": "國防部應該要把你的立場講清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147846/91.wav", + "text": "去說明清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147846/92.wav", + "text": "為什麼要購買這些東西" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147846/93.wav", + "text": "然後為什麼要去發展這些東西" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147846/94.wav", + "text": "把這些用途要解釋得更加地清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147846/95.wav", + "text": "讓臺灣人知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147846/96.wav", + "text": "為什麼要去花這些錢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147846/97.wav", + "text": "否則對於民眾來說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147846/98.wav", + "text": "他看了新聞" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147846/99.wav", + "text": "他好像只是覺得說吵來吵去嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147846/100.wav", + "text": "但是他無法去了解背後的重要性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147846/101.wav", + "text": "我覺得這其實是國防部應該要站出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147846/102.wav", + "text": "更加積極說明的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147846/103.wav", + "text": "這個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147846/104.wav", + "text": "副部長這邊是不是能夠承諾我" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147846/105.wav", + "text": "其實國防部應該要出來更積極地講清楚這件事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147846/106.wav", + "text": "捍衛我們國防部自己的立場" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147846/107.wav", + "text": "我想我們國防部在每一年編預算的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147846/108.wav", + "text": "都是很審慎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147846/109.wav", + "text": "依照作戰的需求" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147846/110.wav", + "text": "依照國防需求" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147846/111.wav", + "text": "還有我們國家財務的裕度審慎編列" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147846/112.wav", + "text": "我們都是全力爭取我們的預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147846/113.wav", + "text": "以支持我們的國防" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147846/114.wav", + "text": "委員有行使職權審查的權力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147846/115.wav", + "text": "我們表示尊重" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147846/116.wav", + "text": "但是我們全力爭取" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147846/117.wav", + "text": "用在我們的國防安全上面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147846/118.wav", + "text": "我剛才也有提到就是說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147846/119.wav", + "text": "我當然也是同意國防部說的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147846/120.wav", + "text": "審查預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147846/121.wav", + "text": "這些設備不管是採購" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147846/122.wav", + "text": "或者是說發展我們自己的自主國防" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147846/123.wav", + "text": "都非常重要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147846/124.wav", + "text": "所以我也在這裡要求希望國防部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147846/125.wav", + "text": "我希望可以看到國防部站出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147846/126.wav", + "text": "為什麼我們要編列這些預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147846/127.wav", + "text": "為什麼這些設備非常重要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147846/128.wav", + "text": "其實我鼓勵啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147846/129.wav", + "text": "也建議國防部應該要站出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147846/130.wav", + "text": "去對我們的國民講清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147846/131.wav", + "text": "畢竟國防部不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147846/132.wav", + "text": "只有要面對立法委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147846/133.wav", + "text": "同時臺灣人如果有疑惑的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147846/134.wav", + "text": "其實也應該要出來清楚地說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147846/135.wav", + "text": "這個部分是不是能夠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147846/136.wav", + "text": "請國防部再來加強" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147846/137.wav", + "text": "謝謝主席謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147845/0.wav", + "text": "趙委員好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147845/1.wav", + "text": "副部長好首先想請教一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147845/2.wav", + "text": "因為最近大家有討論到潛艦國造的海鯤號" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147845/3.wav", + "text": "海鯤艦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147845/4.wav", + "text": "接下來會進入到戰術測評" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147845/5.wav", + "text": "我就看到我們的預算書裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147845/6.wav", + "text": "來進行第二階段原型艦籌建" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147845/7.wav", + "text": "那大概是哪些內容需要這樣的費用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147845/8.wav", + "text": "我想請海軍參謀長來說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147845/9.wav", + "text": "報告委員三十九億多是在明年的計畫預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147845/10.wav", + "text": "對大概是什麼樣的內容" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147845/11.wav", + "text": "它就是讓我們繼續再做後面整個包含測試" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147845/12.wav", + "text": "付了零附件的錢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147845/13.wav", + "text": "也就是說你在進行戰術測評的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147845/14.wav", + "text": "所需要的人事費" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147845/15.wav", + "text": "這個是屬於機密預算的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147845/16.wav", + "text": "我們不在這邊跟委員報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147845/17.wav", + "text": "我們可以到委員辦公室跟委員說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147845/18.wav", + "text": "至少你現在書面上有寫到一些相關的東西" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147845/19.wav", + "text": "大概是一些相關的內容" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147845/20.wav", + "text": "這樣子的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147845/21.wav", + "text": "我想請教" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147845/22.wav", + "text": "被凍結的情形之下會有什麼樣的影響" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147845/23.wav", + "text": "被凍結的狀況之下的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147845/24.wav", + "text": "我們在後面執行上面來講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147845/25.wav", + "text": "當然會有一些影響" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147845/26.wav", + "text": "但是我們會盡全力跟委員做說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147845/27.wav", + "text": "OK就是說我們的目標是2025年成軍" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147845/28.wav", + "text": "所以明年的測評跟測評後相關的優化" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147845/29.wav", + "text": "變成是明年的時間要完成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147845/30.wav", + "text": "所以我們如果把明年這個預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147845/31.wav", + "text": "做某種程度的凍結的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147845/32.wav", + "text": "有可能會導致你的節點受到一點影響" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147845/33.wav", + "text": "報告委員當然會有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147845/34.wav", + "text": "就凍結的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147845/35.wav", + "text": "會跟所有的委員做報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147845/36.wav", + "text": "好因為馬上就要審查了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147845/37.wav", + "text": "但是到時候你們一定要把它講得很清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147845/38.wav", + "text": "我們看到這次以色列被哈瑪斯突擊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147845/39.wav", + "text": "突擊裡面有發射非常多的火箭彈" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147845/40.wav", + "text": "他們是用鐵穹系統" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147845/41.wav", + "text": "這個是我們有看到的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147845/42.wav", + "text": "可是我看到最新的報導裡面有提到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147845/43.wav", + "text": "他們現在似乎也要部署鐵束系統" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147845/44.wav", + "text": "用雷射的方式打無人機" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147845/45.wav", + "text": "可能要在2025年納入以色列的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147845/46.wav", + "text": "第一個你們瞭解這個情況嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147845/47.wav", + "text": "第二個好像我們有類似鐵束的系統" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147845/48.wav", + "text": "就是雷護專案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147845/49.wav", + "text": "目前有繼續進行嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147845/50.wav", + "text": "有順利嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147845/51.wav", + "text": "是不是可以說明一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147845/52.wav", + "text": "我請中科院來說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147845/53.wav", + "text": "報告委員因為這個案子是機密案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147845/54.wav", + "text": "它是關鍵技術的研發" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147845/55.wav", + "text": "目前執行都很順利" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147845/56.wav", + "text": "今年會結案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147845/57.wav", + "text": "6項關鍵技術都已經掌握了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147845/58.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147845/59.wav", + "text": "這樣的話私下你再跟我們做一下說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147845/60.wav", + "text": "在義務役服役期間提撥退休金的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147845/61.wav", + "text": "第一個入伍日期的差異" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147845/62.wav", + "text": "會不會影響到退休金撥給的月份數" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147845/63.wav", + "text": "我的意思是說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147845/64.wav", + "text": "假設我們每月以30日做計算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147845/65.wav", + "text": "如果我是在15號或20號" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147845/66.wav", + "text": "或什麼時間來入伍的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147845/67.wav", + "text": "這個部分的差異" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147845/68.wav", + "text": "要怎麼去做退休金的計算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147845/69.wav", + "text": "報告委員這是個好問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147845/70.wav", + "text": "因為入營和退伍的時間不一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147845/71.wav", + "text": "還有減免的時間不一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147845/72.wav", + "text": "但是我們永遠都是以他在營這段時間來計算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147845/73.wav", + "text": "所以不會用月或破月" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147845/74.wav", + "text": "而是以他實際服役的天數來計算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147845/75.wav", + "text": "所以就是說不管他這個月剩幾天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147845/76.wav", + "text": "第二個問題應該也是一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147845/77.wav", + "text": "就是軍訓等等的折抵天數" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147845/78.wav", + "text": "上限是30天不管是十幾天或多少天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147845/79.wav", + "text": "退休金也是照你剛剛講的原則處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147845/80.wav", + "text": "那是因為在學校" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147845/81.wav", + "text": "我們是從實際入營開始起算到退伍" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147845/82.wav", + "text": "的在營期間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147845/83.wav", + "text": "反正就是入營多少天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147845/84.wav", + "text": "不會因為月中月初而有差別" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147845/85.wav", + "text": "好再來下一個題目也是跟這個有點類似" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147845/86.wav", + "text": "就是我們現在有一個義務役的基本薪資" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147845/87.wav", + "text": "我們知道是兩萬出頭" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147845/88.wav", + "text": "但是因為有特殊加給" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147845/89.wav", + "text": "依照不同的專長會有特殊的加給" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147845/90.wav", + "text": "加給如果去換算6%" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147845/91.wav", + "text": "一年這樣下來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147845/92.wav", + "text": "這個在預算書裡面目前沒有看到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147845/93.wav", + "text": "你們有算在裡面嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147845/94.wav", + "text": "有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147845/95.wav", + "text": "跟委員報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147845/96.wav", + "text": "因為我們第一年入營的役男大概9001百多元" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147845/97.wav", + "text": "原則上分發都是以守備部隊為主" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147845/98.wav", + "text": "基本上這些專業加給的項目" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147845/99.wav", + "text": "在明年裡面是目前還沒有開列的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147845/100.wav", + "text": "所以我們編的預算都是按照實際的需求來編列" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147845/101.wav", + "text": "是不會有出現這些特殊的加給情況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147845/102.wav", + "text": "目前比較少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147845/103.wav", + "text": "因為原則上都是以常備部隊為主" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147845/104.wav", + "text": "他都是高中畢業沒有再升學的役男為主" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147845/105.wav", + "text": "即使是有也不會影響到整個預算的支用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147845/106.wav", + "text": "OK也就是說因為人數少到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147845/107.wav", + "text": "其實你們的預算都足以支應" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147845/108.wav", + "text": "不影響" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147845/109.wav", + "text": "但是未來如果等到他到達了一定的量" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147845/110.wav", + "text": "出現了這樣的情況你們就會編進去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147845/111.wav", + "text": "畢業舉例來講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147845/112.wav", + "text": "比如很多無人機的操縱手" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147845/113.wav", + "text": "他可能在民間就有證照" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147845/114.wav", + "text": "如果取得這樣的證照" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147845/115.wav", + "text": "照我們就輔導他加入高專長的訓練" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147845/116.wav", + "text": "雖然是900多人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147845/117.wav", + "text": "但是真的入營的人數來講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147845/118.wav", + "text": "不會是這樣子的人數可能會比較少一點點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147845/119.wav", + "text": "但是我們現有的預算額度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147845/120.wav", + "text": "足以支應這樣的特殊專長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147845/121.wav", + "text": "畢竟是少數" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147845/122.wav", + "text": "瞭解" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147845/123.wav", + "text": "反正就是實質編列" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147845/124.wav", + "text": "未來如果真的不管多少數" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147845/125.wav", + "text": "有這樣特殊加給的人出現" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147845/126.wav", + "text": "你們就會按照多少錢去換算他的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147845/127.wav", + "text": "瞭解謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147844/0.wav", + "text": "請林右昌林部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147844/1.wav", + "text": "部長辛苦了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147844/2.wav", + "text": "部長本席待會要跟您討論幾個議題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147844/3.wav", + "text": "其實今天早上很多委員也有在關心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147844/4.wav", + "text": "所以有很多私校沒有辦法維持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147844/5.wav", + "text": "這一些私校退場之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147844/6.wav", + "text": "影響到的其實就是當地的一些經濟的活力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147844/7.wav", + "text": "還有教育部其實" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147844/8.wav", + "text": "也都有主張就是說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147844/9.wav", + "text": "是不是這些私校退場之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147844/10.wav", + "text": "可以作為社會住宅之用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147844/11.wav", + "text": "其實我們有在考慮" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147844/12.wav", + "text": "署長好像有提到其實我們可能還要看地點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147844/13.wav", + "text": "絕大部分還是集中在西部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147844/14.wav", + "text": "可能可以規劃為社宅的校舍" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147844/15.wav", + "text": "有沒有盤點出我們可以利用的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147844/16.wav", + "text": "有嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147844/17.wav", + "text": "這個應該這樣說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147844/18.wav", + "text": "其實私校退場的主責單位是教育部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147844/19.wav", + "text": "教育部會針對這些私校的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147844/20.wav", + "text": "我們內政部還有包括衛福部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147844/21.wav", + "text": "相關部會會一起來協助跟參與" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147844/22.wav", + "text": "教育部評估完之後我們自己也會評估" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147844/23.wav", + "text": "它的區位是否適合" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147844/24.wav", + "text": "其他的轉型使用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147844/25.wav", + "text": "我們的確有在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147844/26.wav", + "text": "這是舉個例子明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147844/27.wav", + "text": "明道的部分我們的確有在評估" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147844/28.wav", + "text": "做部分的因為它的校地很大" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147844/29.wav", + "text": "沒有辦法全部都做社宅" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147844/30.wav", + "text": "但我們的確有在評估" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147844/31.wav", + "text": "至於其他的部分可能其他部會還有運用的方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147844/32.wav", + "text": "對因為我們不用再自己" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147844/33.wav", + "text": "蓋其實也有學校華麗轉身的例子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147844/34.wav", + "text": "最成功的是哪裡知道嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147844/35.wav", + "text": "委員指的是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147844/36.wav", + "text": "對啊就是學校華麗轉身" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147844/37.wav", + "text": "但不一定是指社宅" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147844/38.wav", + "text": "學校其實很好利用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147844/39.wav", + "text": "知道立法院的前身是哪裡嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147844/40.wav", + "text": "這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147844/41.wav", + "text": "這個我還真不知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147844/42.wav", + "text": "真的不知道嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147844/43.wav", + "text": "臺北州立第二高等女學校" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147844/44.wav", + "text": "立法院都可以這樣用了幾十年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147844/45.wav", + "text": "目前我所知道的創生社宅" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147844/46.wav", + "text": "好像是在東部還有澎湖" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147844/47.wav", + "text": "我真的覺得還蠻可惜的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147844/48.wav", + "text": "我們可以引進長照" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147844/49.wav", + "text": "以及剛才提到的青創" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147844/50.wav", + "text": "地方創生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147844/51.wav", + "text": "連結其他的部會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147844/52.wav", + "text": "像衛福部可能可以引進長照" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147844/53.wav", + "text": "教育部則是幼教的部分等等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147844/54.wav", + "text": "跟意見也是現在正在做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147844/55.wav", + "text": "的比如教育部盤出來之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147844/56.wav", + "text": "某一個學校有護理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147844/57.wav", + "text": "但是它可能準備要退場" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147844/58.wav", + "text": "這個時候教育部的力量會進來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147844/59.wav", + "text": "第二個部分就是譬如可以把長照" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147844/60.wav", + "text": "或者是照顧的機構" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147844/61.wav", + "text": "另外可能還可以參考" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147844/62.wav", + "text": "這樣子有一個好處是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147844/63.wav", + "text": "另外也可以滿足我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147844/64.wav", + "text": "剛剛在講的老人住宅" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147844/65.wav", + "text": "或者是包括長照照護的這些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147844/66.wav", + "text": "我們好像也在推共宅是不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147844/67.wav", + "text": "部長有帶我們去看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147844/68.wav", + "text": "青銀共宅對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147844/69.wav", + "text": "這部分其實都會朝這些目標來規劃" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147844/70.wav", + "text": "有各個部會其實已經有在整合" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147844/71.wav", + "text": "教育部都有跨部會在整合" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147844/72.wav", + "text": "OK好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147844/73.wav", + "text": "這部分需要跨部會來努力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147844/74.wav", + "text": "再來是第二個議題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147844/75.wav", + "text": "剛剛好幾位委員都有關心到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147844/76.wav", + "text": "怎麼都沒有收到租金補貼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147844/77.wav", + "text": "效率真的是沒有想像中的這麼快" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147844/78.wav", + "text": "因為當初我們有拍胸脯說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147844/79.wav", + "text": "三個月內就可以核發出去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147844/80.wav", + "text": "已經等超過三個月了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147844/81.wav", + "text": "怎麼還沒有看到租金補貼下來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147844/82.wav", + "text": "將近50萬在申請" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147844/83.wav", + "text": "去年22萬戶的舊戶對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147844/84.wav", + "text": "我跟委員報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147844/85.wav", + "text": "比較細一點7" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147844/86.wav", + "text": "申請的戶數是37萬餘戶" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147844/87.wav", + "text": "舊戶帶入的是22萬餘戶" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147844/88.wav", + "text": "另外新申請的有15萬戶" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147844/89.wav", + "text": "所以這也是為什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147844/90.wav", + "text": "因為申請非常踴躍" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147844/91.wav", + "text": "即7月就35萬戶" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147844/92.wav", + "text": "大概是5萬戶申請" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147844/93.wav", + "text": "9月份是4.5萬戶" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147844/94.wav", + "text": "所以我們會盡快" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147844/95.wav", + "text": "在11月份之前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147844/96.wav", + "text": "把7月份第一批申請的37萬戶" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147844/97.wav", + "text": "現在申請還滿踴躍的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147844/98.wav", + "text": "我們的人力到底夠不夠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147844/99.wav", + "text": "因為往後可能會越來越多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147844/100.wav", + "text": "而且之前可能還有一些房東" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147844/101.wav", + "text": "沒有辦法配合" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147844/102.wav", + "text": "或不想配合" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147844/103.wav", + "text": "這個跟查稅沒關係" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147844/104.wav", + "text": "一定不會影響到查稅的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147844/105.wav", + "text": "可能有些房東就覺得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147844/106.wav", + "text": "可能就會有越來越多的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147844/107.wav", + "text": "是不是全都是外包給勞務公司" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147844/108.wav", + "text": "沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147844/109.wav", + "text": "很多都還是我們自己同仁" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147844/110.wav", + "text": "我們當然也有跟人總增" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147844/111.wav", + "text": "增請相關人員人力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147844/112.wav", + "text": "不過也請委員繼續給我們加油" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147844/113.wav", + "text": "當然就會影響到整個租金補貼的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147844/114.wav", + "text": "舊戶要重新審核" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147844/115.wav", + "text": "舊戶累積加上新戶的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147844/116.wav", + "text": "絕對會影響到整個時程" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147844/117.wav", + "text": "署長有提到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147844/118.wav", + "text": "也有讓我們擔心的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147844/119.wav", + "text": "電費的繳納證明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147844/120.wav", + "text": "還有門牌證明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147844/121.wav", + "text": "不然的話就要村里長證明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147844/122.wav", + "text": "到最後的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147844/123.wav", + "text": "可能還是要村里長來證明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147844/124.wav", + "text": "可是村里長會覺得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147844/125.wav", + "text": "要證明這個部分的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147844/126.wav", + "text": "可能還是要跟房東討論一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147844/127.wav", + "text": "如果房東不願意的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147844/128.wav", + "text": "他們還是沒有辦法證明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147844/129.wav", + "text": "這四個都拿不到的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147844/130.wav", + "text": "就沒辦法申請了嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147844/131.wav", + "text": "我了解" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147844/132.wav", + "text": "如果不給應該是房東故意不給" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147844/133.wav", + "text": "因為自來水費都是對房東" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147844/134.wav", + "text": "因為他沒有獨立的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147844/135.wav", + "text": "我了解這個部分是不是看表來證明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147844/136.wav", + "text": "但是以表來證明基本上這種屋頂加蓋" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147844/137.wav", + "text": "分表我們來研究看看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147844/138.wav", + "text": "分表有沒有可能做一點證明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147844/139.wav", + "text": "你把他們納入" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147844/140.wav", + "text": "了會不會變成看得到吃不到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147844/141.wav", + "text": "這部分可能還是要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147844/142.wav", + "text": "我了解現在大部分都已經解決" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147844/143.wav", + "text": "如果委員的確看到有這樣的案例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147844/144.wav", + "text": "我們再來研究看看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147844/145.wav", + "text": "用表的認定看看有沒有機會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147844/146.wav", + "text": "部長跟署長請回" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147843/0.wav", + "text": "我先從一個問題來提問" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147843/1.wav", + "text": "我們有招聘法裔的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147843/2.wav", + "text": "來飛幻象" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147843/3.wav", + "text": "跟假想敵中隊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147843/4.wav", + "text": "進行模擬對抗" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147843/5.wav", + "text": "媒體有報還拍到他們穿的飛行衣都不一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147843/6.wav", + "text": "這個事情方不方便聊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147843/7.wav", + "text": "可以詢問嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147843/8.wav", + "text": "委員好我是空軍參謀長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147843/9.wav", + "text": "有沒有這個事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147843/10.wav", + "text": "報告委員各種對我們有利的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147843/11.wav", + "text": "聯合訓練我們���要按計畫執行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147843/12.wav", + "text": "這種招募是我們自己用民間契約去招募" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147843/13.wav", + "text": "還是透過政府間的合作" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147843/14.wav", + "text": "這比較不適合在公開的評論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147843/15.wav", + "text": "不方便講的話你可以講我可以尊重" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147843/16.wav", + "text": "因為英國美國法國德國" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147843/17.wav", + "text": "最近針對他們的飛行員去解放軍那邊訓練" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147843/18.wav", + "text": "包括澳洲也有他們是要法辦的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147843/19.wav", + "text": "如果法國的飛行員可以來我們這邊訓練" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147843/20.wav", + "text": "且基本上是在國家的默契下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147843/21.wav", + "text": "那是OK" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147843/22.wav", + "text": "我們臺灣也不會幹非法的事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147843/23.wav", + "text": "第二個問題也一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147843/24.wav", + "text": "如果不方便你就不回答" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147843/25.wav", + "text": "我們有幻象" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147843/26.wav", + "text": "但是我們面對的敵情也很嚴峻" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147843/27.wav", + "text": "所以這種國際上的協訓" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147843/28.wav", + "text": "我覺得這是好的方法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147843/29.wav", + "text": "我們不見得每個都能送到國外去受訓" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147843/30.wav", + "text": "在臺灣自己的空域受訓更好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147843/31.wav", + "text": "那還有沒有其他國家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147843/32.wav", + "text": "已退的飛行員在協助我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147843/33.wav", + "text": "報告委員你談的這個問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147843/34.wav", + "text": "我都沒有辦法回答你" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147843/35.wav", + "text": "因為這不是在公開場合能夠回答" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147843/36.wav", + "text": "不適合談就不適合談" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147843/37.wav", + "text": "我現在繼續請教" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147843/38.wav", + "text": "如果有外籍的人在我們這裡做協訓" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147843/39.wav", + "text": "通常都是在空機嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147843/40.wav", + "text": "因為他飛的應該是我們的飛機" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147843/41.wav", + "text": "當遇到緊急狀況的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147843/42.wav", + "text": "他要不要去支應緊急狀況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147843/43.wav", + "text": "還是不能去支應我們的緊急狀況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147843/44.wav", + "text": "報告委員回到前一題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147843/45.wav", + "text": "這都是假設的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147843/46.wav", + "text": "我沒有辦法回答你" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147843/47.wav", + "text": "提醒你們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147843/48.wav", + "text": "但有時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147843/49.wav", + "text": "什麼時候發生敵情我們不知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147843/50.wav", + "text": "那這樣的飛機這樣的狀況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147843/51.wav", + "text": "要怎麼因應你們自己去思考" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147843/52.wav", + "text": "我在這邊也不揭露" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147843/53.wav", + "text": "參謀長先請回" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147843/54.wav", + "text": "\n我們今天在審相��的草案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147843/55.wav", + "text": "我倒是要提一個問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147843/56.wav", + "text": "關於現役" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147843/57.wav", + "text": "我有跟陸軍參謀長聊過這個事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147843/58.wav", + "text": "就是說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147843/59.wav", + "text": "四年的合約" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147843/60.wav", + "text": "當他要續約的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147843/61.wav", + "text": "必須連續三年考績甲等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147843/62.wav", + "text": "這副" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147843/63.wav", + "text": "知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147843/64.wav", + "text": "因為一約就是四年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147843/65.wav", + "text": "第一年進來就犯了錯" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147843/66.wav", + "text": "那一年考績被打乙等也就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147843/67.wav", + "text": "第二年考績打乙等了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147843/68.wav", + "text": "就算他後面兩年考績是甲" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147843/69.wav", + "text": "他都不能續約" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147843/70.wav", + "text": "哦這產生第一個管理上的問題就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147843/71.wav", + "text": "反正他做得再好或再爛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147843/72.wav", + "text": "後面考績特優都不能續約" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147843/73.wav", + "text": "就是四年裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147843/74.wav", + "text": "要續約的那個年度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147843/75.wav", + "text": "要連續三年甲等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147843/76.wav", + "text": "其中有一個乙等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147843/77.wav", + "text": "他就不能續約了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147843/78.wav", + "text": "第一個管理上的問題就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147843/79.wav", + "text": "他已經沒希望了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147843/80.wav", + "text": "我要是部隊領導幹部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147843/81.wav", + "text": "帶這個兵我會擔心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147843/82.wav", + "text": "第二個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147843/83.wav", + "text": "年輕人犯了錯" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147843/84.wav", + "text": "變成一次考績乙等之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147843/85.wav", + "text": "他幾乎不能續約" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147843/86.wav", + "text": "哪怕他後面表現得多好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147843/87.wav", + "text": "也就是四年內考績要有三次甲等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147843/88.wav", + "text": "這跟連續三年考績甲等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147843/89.wav", + "text": "不知柏副部長對這件事情有什麼看法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147843/90.wav", + "text": "報告委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147843/91.wav", + "text": "基於我們對於紀律的遵守" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147843/92.wav", + "text": "尤其是軍人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147843/93.wav", + "text": "當然" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147843/94.wav", + "text": "事實上他們進來的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147843/95.wav", + "text": "我就已經講得非常清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147843/96.wav", + "text": "必須在這種條件下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147843/97.wav", + "text": "才可以續約" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147843/98.wav", + "text": "這是一個先決條件" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147843/99.wav", + "text": "至於他為什麼會犯這個錯" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147843/100.wav", + "text": "我個人的看法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147843/101.wav", + "text": "是他應該為他的錯負責任" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147843/102.wav", + "text": "這是第一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147843/103.wav", + "text": "第二個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147843/104.wav", + "text": "後來變甲等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147843/105.wav", + "text": "他有改過向善的方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147843/106.wav", + "text": "繼續留住他" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147843/107.wav", + "text": "我覺得還是要回到最初" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147843/108.wav", + "text": "我不是進入到個案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147843/109.wav", + "text": "我的意思是說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147843/110.wav", + "text": "我現在來簽約" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147843/111.wav", + "text": "當了義務兵" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147843/112.wav", + "text": "我有四年的合約" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147843/113.wav", + "text": "我第一年甲等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147843/114.wav", + "text": "第二年變乙等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147843/115.wav", + "text": "或者我第三年變乙等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147843/116.wav", + "text": "我就已經知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147843/117.wav", + "text": "我絕對不能續約了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147843/118.wav", + "text": "啦這個兵他已經知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147843/119.wav", + "text": "他後面怎麼表現好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147843/120.wav", + "text": "都不能續約了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147843/121.wav", + "text": "所以後面做個60分就好了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147843/122.wav", + "text": "我發現過實際的案例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147843/123.wav", + "text": "帶著四年一約的士官" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147843/124.wav", + "text": "去喝酒" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147843/125.wav", + "text": "結果帶頭喝酒" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147843/126.wav", + "text": "他還可以繼續下去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147843/127.wav", + "text": "但是那兩個要簽約的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147843/128.wav", + "text": "考績一個乙等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147843/129.wav", + "text": "他們就不能留下來了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147843/130.wav", + "text": "都做到上士了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147843/131.wav", + "text": "我不是要講那些犯錯的人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147843/132.wav", + "text": "不該付出代價" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147843/133.wav", + "text": "犯錯考績該怎麼打就" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147843/134.wav", + "text": "我現在講的是部隊管理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147843/135.wav", + "text": "也就是一個合約四年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147843/136.wav", + "text": "它最後三年一定要連續甲等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147843/137.wav", + "text": "才能續約" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147843/138.wav", + "text": "可能他在第二年或第三年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147843/139.wav", + "text": "犯錯被打成乙等之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147843/140.wav", + "text": "我們在管理上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147843/141.wav", + "text": "對這個兵就要變成特別注意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147843/142.wav", + "text": "另外一種管理方式是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147843/143.wav", + "text": "當中不能有兩年乙等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147843/144.wav", + "text": "最多一次乙等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147843/145.wav", + "text": "就是四分之三要甲等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147843/146.wav", + "text": "這也是一種管��方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147843/147.wav", + "text": "這是科學" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147843/148.wav", + "text": "這沒有什麼對或錯" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147843/149.wav", + "text": "所以我提供給部隊參考看看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147843/150.wav", + "text": "我們來參考報告委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147843/151.wav", + "text": "您的所有建議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147843/152.wav", + "text": "國防部在研擬的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147843/153.wav", + "text": "也要考量到犯錯的本質" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147843/154.wav", + "text": "現在打乙幾乎都不用去研究犯錯" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147843/155.wav", + "text": "使後面兩年是甲等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147843/156.wav", + "text": "都統統不能續約" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147843/157.wav", + "text": "沒有什麼本質的研究" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147843/158.wav", + "text": "另外一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147843/159.wav", + "text": "問題跟不適服也有關係" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147843/160.wav", + "text": "就是說前幾年有一些不適服的狀況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147843/161.wav", + "text": "他現在要回去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147843/162.wav", + "text": "我們一律都不採納" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147843/163.wav", + "text": "我也跟陸軍提過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147843/164.wav", + "text": "因為當時他不適服" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147843/165.wav", + "text": "洪慈庸委員提出來的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147843/166.wav", + "text": "很多人因為不適服而離開" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147843/167.wav", + "text": "有的人可能是生病" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147843/168.wav", + "text": "有的人是不適應" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147843/169.wav", + "text": "有的人是家裡有事" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147843/170.wav", + "text": "也做了相當時間了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147843/171.wav", + "text": "他現在要回來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147843/172.wav", + "text": "我還是建議有個考核" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147843/173.wav", + "text": "啦不適合就不讓他回來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147843/174.wav", + "text": "但他確實是適合當年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147843/175.wav", + "text": "也許家裡有事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147843/176.wav", + "text": "他離開了兩三年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147843/177.wav", + "text": "他要回來了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147843/178.wav", + "text": "可以針對個案考量" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147843/179.wav", + "text": "因為我們要培養一個基層幹部不容易" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147843/180.wav", + "text": "我們現在變成一條線" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147843/181.wav", + "text": "只要報過不適服" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147843/182.wav", + "text": "就統統不讓他們回來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147843/183.wav", + "text": "適服不適服該不該回來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147843/184.wav", + "text": "還是要有一個考核標準" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147843/185.wav", + "text": "這是第二個建議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147843/186.wav", + "text": "我們會納入參考" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147843/187.wav", + "text": "各位先請回" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147843/188.wav", + "text": "我想詢問一份資料" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147843/189.wav", + "text": "請你提供" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147843/190.wav", + "text": "我問過你們的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147843/191.wav", + "text": "功率放大器的個案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147843/192.wav", + "text": "我看網路上也都有在傳" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147843/193.wav", + "text": "前面有七到八家投標" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147843/194.wav", + "text": "後來只有兩家投標" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147843/195.wav", + "text": "有一家可能用中國製的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147843/196.wav", + "text": "這一段我沒意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147843/197.wav", + "text": "本來都不能用中國製的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147843/198.wav", + "text": "所以就變成只剩一家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147843/199.wav", + "text": "這是前段" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147843/200.wav", + "text": "這個功率放大器的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147843/201.wav", + "text": "第二段出現什麼問題呢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147843/202.wav", + "text": "這一家要來交貨的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147843/203.wav", + "text": "不符合我們正負15的標準" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147843/204.wav", + "text": "我們合約寫了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147843/205.wav", + "text": "我也跟你們研究合約" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147843/206.wav", + "text": "我看這合約寫的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147843/207.wav", + "text": "內容你們並沒有吃虧太多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147843/208.wav", + "text": "你們竟然就去修改合約" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147843/209.wav", + "text": "就是既修改合約" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147843/210.wav", + "text": "又加了錢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147843/211.wav", + "text": "它知道這個合約是寫這樣子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147843/212.wav", + "text": "它來履約" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147843/213.wav", + "text": "結果驗收不能過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147843/214.wav", + "text": "不只修改合約" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147843/215.wav", + "text": "第三次驗收時你們還加了錢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147843/216.wav", + "text": "後面就說它變合格了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147843/217.wav", + "text": "這是一個兩三年前的案子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147843/218.wav", + "text": "面對這樣的案子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147843/219.wav", + "text": "你們稽核或監察的相關機制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147843/220.wav", + "text": "在那一段改合約和改規格的過程" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147843/221.wav", + "text": "有沒有人介入關心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147843/222.wav", + "text": "但並不是在我們開標" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147843/223.wav", + "text": "有委員來詢問你們會留下紀錄嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147843/224.wav", + "text": "是在後面的階段" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147843/225.wav", + "text": "有委員詢問你們會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147843/226.wav", + "text": "依規定留下紀錄嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147843/227.wav", + "text": "應該有吧" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147843/228.wav", + "text": "有留紀錄" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147843/229.wav", + "text": "前一段七八家要來投標" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147843/230.wav", + "text": "好奇怪後來只剩兩家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147843/231.wav", + "text": "兩家都是外商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147843/232.wav", + "text": "有一家是made in China所以被" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147843/233.wav", + "text": "結果這一家交貨竟然不合格" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147843/234.wav", + "text": "不合格後你們審視了合約" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147843/235.wav", + "text": "你們通常沒有那麼體貼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147843/236.wav", + "text": "也沒有經過工程會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147843/237.wav", + "text": "也沒有經過仲裁" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147843/238.wav", + "text": "你們就把合約改了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147843/239.wav", + "text": "改了之後又加了錢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147843/240.wav", + "text": "然後它就過了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147843/241.wav", + "text": "在這當中有人來關心這個案子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147843/242.wav", + "text": "有確實是有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147843/243.wav", + "text": "事後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147843/244.wav", + "text": "那你們這個資料要備好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147843/245.wav", + "text": "再向委員報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147843/246.wav", + "text": "包括後續的精進作為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147843/247.wav", + "text": "包括這個合約的修改過程" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147843/248.wav", + "text": "交不了貨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147843/249.wav", + "text": "這個標就應該要廢掉重標了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147843/250.wav", + "text": "為什麼你們自己改標案的合約" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147843/251.wav", + "text": "而且還要加錢進去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147843/252.wav", + "text": "那一家就讓它驗收過關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147843/253.wav", + "text": "程序上我覺得怪怪的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147843/254.wav", + "text": "你們很少這麼體貼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147843/255.wav", + "text": "自己承認自己的合約錯了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147843/256.wav", + "text": "而且還自己加了錢它" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147843/257.wav", + "text": "它前兩次驗收不過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147843/258.wav", + "text": "第三次讓它過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147843/259.wav", + "text": "因為加了錢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147843/260.wav", + "text": "材料就換了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147843/261.wav", + "text": "那個合約改的過程" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147843/262.wav", + "text": "和有人關心有沒有因果關係" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147843/263.wav", + "text": "有沒有不適切的地方" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147843/264.wav", + "text": "你們至少要有一個報告出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147843/265.wav", + "text": "好不好謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147843/266.wav", + "text": "謝謝委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147842/0.wav", + "text": "我想請內政部林部長以及警政署黃署長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147842/1.wav", + "text": "有請林部長黃署長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147842/2.wav", + "text": "部長首先我想請教新竹寡婦樓的都更案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147842/3.wav", + "text": "這個是國防部委託內政部營建署在103年招商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147842/4.wav", + "text": "當時只有理銘一家通過資格審查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147842/5.wav", + "text": "因為它只有一家通過資格審查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147842/6.wav", + "text": "當然到最後也拿到這個案子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147842/7.wav", + "text": "結果當時主辦都更招商的營建署城鄉分署長洪嘉宏" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147842/8.wav", + "text": "在106年因為寡婦樓這個案件" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147842/9.wav", + "text": "收了昌益集團2,000萬的賄款" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147842/10.wav", + "text": "跟在新竹另外兩個遠雄的都更案索賄4,500萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147842/11.wav", + "text": "被收押" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147842/12.wav", + "text": "他在去年被臺北地院依貪污治罪條例判處" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147842/13.wav", + "text": "八��二個月的有期徒刑" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147842/14.wav", + "text": "這個案件已經都發生這麼嚴重的弊案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147842/15.wav", + "text": "而且在判決書裡面其實講得非常清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147842/16.wav", + "text": "為什麼只有理銘一家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147842/17.wav", + "text": "竟然只有一家通過資格審查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147842/18.wav", + "text": "其實就是洪嘉宏當時" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147842/19.wav", + "text": "不斷地把這些資訊都洩漏給理銘" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147842/20.wav", + "text": "導致到最後只有它能夠通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147842/21.wav", + "text": "其他人都沒辦法通過的這個狀況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147842/22.wav", + "text": "對這個弊案的回應到底是什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147842/23.wav", + "text": "因為國防部在其他的案件" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147842/24.wav", + "text": "如果有涉及到不法情況之下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147842/25.wav", + "text": "終止契約所在多有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147842/26.wav", + "text": "如果涉有不法依法終止" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147842/27.wav", + "text": "結果國防部現在竟然發一個函給內政部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147842/28.wav", + "text": "請問部長或署長不知道有沒有收到這個函" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147842/29.wav", + "text": "國防部的方式就是它" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147842/30.wav", + "text": "它要發函給當時簽約的內政部營建署" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147842/31.wav", + "text": "因為是你去簽的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147842/32.wav", + "text": "所以它現在要問你" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147842/33.wav", + "text": "到底它要不要終止" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147842/34.wav", + "text": "意思嗎有沒有收到這個函" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147842/35.wav", + "text": "署長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147842/36.wav", + "text": "我們跟國防部的部分其實之前已經終止了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147842/37.wav", + "text": "因為我們是屬於協助它的部對啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147842/38.wav", + "text": "你被它委任嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147842/39.wav", + "text": "對所以我們已經跟它終止" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147842/40.wav", + "text": "現在它發函問你它" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147842/41.wav", + "text": "它發函給內政部國土管理署城鄉分署" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147842/42.wav", + "text": "它要問你的是它" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147842/43.wav", + "text": "它到底要不要跟理銘做終止" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147842/44.wav", + "text": "國防部的意思就是它" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147842/45.wav", + "text": "它委任你去簽的嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147842/46.wav", + "text": "跟委員報告我們之前已經告訴它我們自己終止掉這個案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147842/47.wav", + "text": "我知道啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147842/48.wav", + "text": "現在你接到這個函嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147842/49.wav", + "text": "你有沒有接到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147842/50.wav", + "text": "還沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147842/51.wav", + "text": "如果你接到這個函" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147842/52.wav", + "text": "它現在是要問你它" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147842/53.wav", + "text": "它要不要去終止這個跟理銘的都更" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147842/54.wav", + "text": "可是它是屬於委託國防部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147842/55.wav", + "text": "它委託你啦我知道對啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147842/56.wav", + "text": "委託人自己要決定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147842/57.wav", + "text": "不是我們受委託人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147842/58.wav", + "text": "但是它現在的意思就是它" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147842/59.wav", + "text": "它委託你" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147842/60.wav", + "text": "結果你們的分署長去收人家2,000萬它" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147842/61.wav", + "text": "它是委託人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147842/62.wav", + "text": "委託你們去辦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147842/63.wav", + "text": "結果你們的分署長去收人家2,000萬被依貪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147842/64.wav", + "text": "貪污治罪條例判刑八年二個月" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147842/65.wav", + "text": "它現在要發文問你" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147842/66.wav", + "text": "你的建議是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147842/67.wav", + "text": "要不要終止" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147842/68.wav", + "text": "讓只有理銘一家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147842/69.wav", + "text": "可以通過這個資格" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147842/70.wav", + "text": "到最後也取得這個標案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147842/71.wav", + "text": "我跟委員報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147842/72.wav", + "text": "第一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147842/73.wav", + "text": "因為當時有委託關係" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147842/74.wav", + "text": "我已經終止了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147842/75.wav", + "text": "所以基本上委託我的這個內容" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147842/76.wav", + "text": "它可以決定它要不要繼續接受這個內容" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147842/77.wav", + "text": "因為基本上我已經願意解除掉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147842/78.wav", + "text": "而且事實上也解除了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147842/79.wav", + "text": "剩下的只是國防部願不願意就這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147842/80.wav", + "text": "當時委託所代辦的內容" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147842/81.wav", + "text": "要不要繼續承認" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147842/82.wav", + "text": "這個釐清一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147842/83.wav", + "text": "你終止的是你跟國防部的委託" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147842/84.wav", + "text": "也就是因為我們自己也發現中間發生了弊端" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147842/85.wav", + "text": "所以我們自己主動把它終止掉了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147842/86.wav", + "text": "對你跟國防部的關係終止掉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147842/87.wav", + "text": "對而且我們不認為這樣的方式應該要繼續走下去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147842/88.wav", + "text": "你認為不應該繼續走下去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147842/89.wav", + "text": "所以你的建議是如果你回函" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147842/90.wav", + "text": "因為它已經回函副本給我" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147842/91.wav", + "text": "所以我才知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147842/92.wav", + "text": "嘛你應該也收到了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147842/93.wav", + "text": "我問一下你回復的方式是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147842/94.wav", + "text": "都更不應該繼續下去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147842/95.wav", + "text": "對嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147842/96.wav", + "text": "應該是這麼說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147842/97.wav", + "text": "國防部要不要走都更" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147842/98.wav", + "text": "其實他是可以去判斷" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147842/99.wav", + "text": "的只是說你走了都更" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147842/100.wav", + "text": "要不要繼續這個原有的案子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147842/101.wav", + "text": "我覺得他依照相關的法令規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147842/102.wav", + "text": "應該是可以自己來做判斷" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147842/103.wav", + "text": "不應該由我們當時受委任的態度來處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147842/104.wav", + "text": "到底這個終止" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147842/105.wav", + "text": "是內政部來判斷" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147842/106.wav", + "text": "還是國防部來判斷" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147842/107.wav", + "text": "我對這個案子的細節不是很了解" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147842/108.wav", + "text": "不過剛剛委員垂詢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147842/109.wav", + "text": "詢我聽起來的這個道理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147842/110.wav", + "text": "應該分成兩部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147842/111.wav", + "text": "如果有涉弊的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147842/112.wav", + "text": "這是一件事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147842/113.wav", + "text": "第二個主管機關或是說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147842/114.wav", + "text": "現在已經請回到國防部的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147842/115.wav", + "text": "的針對這個案子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147842/116.wav", + "text": "發生這個事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147842/117.wav", + "text": "他應該可以自行認定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147842/118.wav", + "text": "他是不是因為這邊是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147842/119.wav", + "text": "他有沒有涉及不法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147842/120.wav", + "text": "因為這個涉及不法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147842/121.wav", + "text": "而去終止原本這個計畫的執行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147842/122.wav", + "text": "部長現在的來龍去脈是這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147842/123.wav", + "text": "這個城鄉分署的分署長被判刑" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147842/124.wav", + "text": "這個委託人是國防部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147842/125.wav", + "text": "是國防部委託內政部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147842/126.wav", + "text": "我去問國防部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147842/127.wav", + "text": "國防部說他要發文去問內政部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147842/128.wav", + "text": "因為是內政部去跟人家簽的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147842/129.wav", + "text": "所以現在到底是國防部要去做判斷" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147842/130.wav", + "text": "還是內政部要去做判斷" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147842/131.wav", + "text": "還是說大家互踢皮球" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147842/132.wav", + "text": "皮球雖說已經判刑了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147842/133.wav", + "text": "結果這個都更案還可以繼續下去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147842/134.wav", + "text": "委員因為他是現在的送件人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147842/135.wav", + "text": "所以他可以依法認定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147842/136.wav", + "text": "這個案子要不要走下去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147842/137.wav", + "text": "他如果再回過頭去問當初" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147842/138.wav", + "text": "受委託的營建署這樣很怪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147842/139.wav", + "text": "對所以你認為應該是由國防部來判斷" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147842/140.wav", + "text": "那我再請教" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147842/141.wav", + "text": "你認為一個內政部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147842/142.wav", + "text": "去簽的都更契約" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147842/143.wav", + "text": "國防部委託內政部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147842/144.wav", + "text": "內政部去簽了一個都更契約" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147842/145.wav", + "text": "這個簽約的分署長已經被判刑" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147842/146.wav", + "text": "然後法院認為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147842/147.wav", + "text": "就是因為他去索賄" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147842/148.wav", + "text": "所以才導致理銘一家去得到這個標案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147842/149.wav", + "text": "嘛部長你認為這樣應不應該撤回" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147842/150.wav", + "text": "部長你要有個態度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147842/151.wav", + "text": "啦如果是這樣都沒辦法回答" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147842/152.wav", + "text": "因為我前一個問題已經回答你了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147842/153.wav", + "text": "對啊你覺得這個是國防部委託內政部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147842/154.wav", + "text": "也說自己覺得有問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147842/155.wav", + "text": "所以現在已經終止跟國防部的這個委託了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147842/156.wav", + "text": "對不對但是當時受委託後變成內政部去辦招商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147842/157.wav", + "text": "內政部去跟人家簽的約" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147842/158.wav", + "text": "所以國防部現在才會說要來問你" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147842/159.wav", + "text": "啊現在你以部長的角度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147842/160.wav", + "text": "後來這個分署長已經被判刑了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147842/161.wav", + "text": "你覺得這應不應該要撤回" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147842/162.wav", + "text": "部長我還是要說明一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147842/163.wav", + "text": "沒有我要讓部長回答" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147842/164.wav", + "text": "這沒有那麼困難" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147842/165.wav", + "text": "委託人簽約人全部都是國防部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147842/166.wav", + "text": "不是內政部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147842/167.wav", + "text": "你被他委託嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147842/168.wav", + "text": "我只是代辦程序" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147842/169.wav", + "text": "對啊你跟他有一個受託的關係沒問題啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147842/170.wav", + "text": "你是代簽人沒有問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147842/171.wav", + "text": "我知道你是代理人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147842/172.wav", + "text": "但我要問的是部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147842/173.wav", + "text": "部長如果你受國防部委託去代理簽這個約" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147842/174.wav", + "text": "之後這個分署長已經被判刑了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147842/175.wav", + "text": "委員你剛剛的這個邏輯我真的聽不太懂" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147842/176.wav", + "text": "為什麼會聽不太懂" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147842/177.wav", + "text": "因為國防部現在就是要來問你" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147842/178.wav", + "text": "我剛剛已經回答過了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147842/179.wav", + "text": "所以你認為是國防部要去判斷" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147842/180.wav", + "text": "謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147842/181.wav", + "text": "我剛剛已經回答過了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147842/182.wav", + "text": "署長抱歉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147842/183.wav", + "text": "我問一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147842/184.wav", + "text": "這個爆閃燈" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147842/185.wav", + "text": "發生了許多的糾紛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147842/186.wav", + "text": "不管現在是什麼狀況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147842/187.wav", + "text": "都裝上這個爆閃燈" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147842/188.wav", + "text": "我問交通部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147842/189.wav", + "text": "這個爆閃燈裝了之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147842/190.wav", + "text": "可能反而會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147842/191.wav", + "text": "妨礙到交通的安全" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147842/192.wav", + "text": "因為它會一閃嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147842/193.wav", + "text": "有一個騎士他就把這個爆閃燈" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147842/194.wav", + "text": "拿掉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147842/195.wav", + "text": "拿掉之後蘆竹分局" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147842/196.wav", + "text": "竟然開了一個罰單" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147842/197.wav", + "text": "給他那個罰單是依照社會秩序維護法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147842/198.wav", + "text": "第75條第1項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147842/199.wav", + "text": "擅自操縱路燈或交通號誌者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147842/200.wav", + "text": "來處罰" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147842/201.wav", + "text": "我想請教署長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147842/202.wav", + "text": "這個爆閃燈到底是屬於路燈" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147842/203.wav", + "text": "還是交通號誌" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147842/204.wav", + "text": "這個是一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147842/205.wav", + "text": "交通的輔助設備" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147842/206.wav", + "text": "就是要提醒用路人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147842/207.wav", + "text": "提醒他的用意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147842/208.wav", + "text": "而不是交通號誌" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147842/209.wav", + "text": "所以你認為是交通號誌嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147842/210.wav", + "text": "不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147842/211.wav", + "text": "既然在不是的情況之下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147842/212.wav", + "text": "它顯然不是路燈當" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147842/213.wav", + "text": "然它也不是交通號誌" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147842/214.wav", + "text": "這樣可以依照社會秩序維護法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147842/215.wav", + "text": "擅自操縱路燈或交通號誌者嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147842/216.wav", + "text": "我再交代這個分局" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147842/217.wav", + "text": "如果可以聲明異議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147842/218.wav", + "text": "署長說得非常清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147842/219.wav", + "text": "爆閃燈根本不是標準的道路標示" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147842/220.wav", + "text": "號誌裝設等等之類的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147842/221.wav", + "text": "都不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147842/222.wav", + "text": "那有沒有法源依據" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147842/223.wav", + "text": "沒有法源依據啊署長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147842/224.wav", + "text": "其實這個爆閃燈" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147842/225.wav", + "text": "裝了之後可能更妨礙到交通" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147842/226.wav", + "text": "我具體要求" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147842/227.wav", + "text": "希望內政部警政署" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147842/228.wav", + "text": "一週內可以函詢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147842/229.wav", + "text": "全臺灣的各分局" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147842/230.wav", + "text": "說明這個爆閃燈的風險" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147842/231.wav", + "text": "表達不鼓勵" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147842/232.wav", + "text": "使用的立場" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147842/233.wav", + "text": "謹慎地使用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147842/234.wav", + "text": "各縣市的交通局處" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147842/235.wav", + "text": "或交通的權責機關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147842/236.wav", + "text": "去實地會勘評估" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147842/237.wav", + "text": "以確保安全" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147842/238.wav", + "text": "委員這部分是不是容我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147842/239.wav", + "text": "跟交通部再商議一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147842/240.wav", + "text": "對因為這個問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147842/241.wav", + "text": "你看有這麼多的紛爭" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147842/242.wav", + "text": "其實他還是有一定的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147842/243.wav", + "text": "路段的確會有部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147842/244.wav", + "text": "長法源在哪裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147842/245.wav", + "text": "剛剛在講它並不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147842/246.wav", + "text": "但是它是可以輔助的設施" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147842/247.wav", + "text": "是啊但它是號誌嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147842/248.wav", + "text": "它也不是路燈嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147842/249.wav", + "text": "它不需要是號誌也不需要是路燈" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147842/250.wav", + "text": "所以從頭到尾沒有法源的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147842/251.wav", + "text": "它唯一能有法源依據" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147842/252.wav", + "text": "有故障的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147842/253.wav", + "text": "會發生危險嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147842/254.wav", + "text": "謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147842/255.wav", + "text": "邱顯智邱委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147842/256.wav", + "text": "差不多就這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147842/257.wav", + "text": "沒有法源依據" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147842/258.wav", + "text": "但又是一個很好的輔助工具" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147842/259.wav", + "text": "與人為善" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147842/260.wav", + "text": "沒有法律依據" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147842/261.wav", + "text": "不是交通部長認為這可能" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147842/262.wav", + "text": "更妨礙交通" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147842/263.wav", + "text": "所以這個部分才是值得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147842/264.wav", + "text": "跟專業人士去討論的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147842/265.wav", + "text": "OK讓他們研究一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147842/266.wav", + "text": "邱委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147842/267.wav", + "text": "部長請回" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147842/268.wav", + "text": "署長請回準備充分功力十足" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147842/269.wav", + "text": "稍嫌冗長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147841/0.wav", + "text": "謝謝主席麻煩請副部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147841/1.wav", + "text": "馬委員好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147841/2.wav", + "text": "副部長好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147841/3.wav", + "text": "副部長我想要請教" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147841/4.wav", + "text": "國防部有沒有為特定的政黨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147841/5.wav", + "text": "或者是個別的委員服務" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147841/6.wav", + "text": "沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147841/7.wav", + "text": "是一視同仁" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147841/8.wav", + "text": "所以我們要求所屬的每個人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147841/9.wav", + "text": "都要確保行政中立是這樣子嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147841/10.wav", + "text": "那我想請教一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147841/11.wav", + "text": "這次我們提案截止的時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147841/12.wav", + "text": "是在何召委要求的10月19號下午五點鐘" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147841/13.wav", + "text": "本席的辦公室1點30分把紙本文件送到委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147841/14.wav", + "text": "4點40分電子檔親送委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147841/15.wav", + "text": "這個部分有特別的委員可以提早獲得的原因是什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147841/16.wav", + "text": "關於這個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147841/17.wav", + "text": "我想我們國防部在程序上來講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147841/18.wav", + "text": "都依照外交及國防委員會的程序來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147841/19.wav", + "text": "可是事實上就是有委員拿到了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147841/20.wav", + "text": "甚至在公告以前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147841/21.wav", + "text": "因為你如果拿到的是一般的文書資料" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147841/22.wav", + "text": "我們沒話講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147841/23.wav", + "text": "有委員親筆簽名的文書資料" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147841/24.wav", + "text": "在五點以前其實是沒有對外的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147841/25.wav", + "text": "如果不是國防部提供" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147841/26.wav", + "text": "不然就是委員會提供" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147841/27.wav", + "text": "如果國防部沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147841/28.wav", + "text": "那現在是指控委員會是嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147841/29.wav", + "text": "報告委員我想這個事情還是需要去釐清" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147841/30.wav", + "text": "清至少在國防部的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147841/31.wav", + "text": "我相信我們國防部的同仁" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147841/32.wav", + "text": "非常遵守外交及國防委員會的程序" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147841/33.wav", + "text": "所以可能是委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147841/34.wav", + "text": "是不是請召委可以調查清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147841/35.wav", + "text": "因為這個部分讓大家覺得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147841/36.wav", + "text": "國防部是不是有行政中立的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147841/37.wav", + "text": "是不是配合某些委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147841/38.wav", + "text": "在做一些特別的一搭一唱的演出" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147841/39.wav", + "text": "因為國防部會讓我們覺得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147841/40.wav", + "text": "在聯合執政黨攻擊在野黨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147841/41.wav", + "text": "而且是要逼迫立法委員撤案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147841/42.wav", + "text": "不要針對某些提案去提出質疑" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147841/43.wav", + "text": "現在我們要在這裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147841/44.wav", + "text": "因為這裡有公開的錄音錄影" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147841/45.wav", + "text": "我們希望國防部在這裡有一個態度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147841/46.wav", + "text": "至少可以做到什麼樣的程度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147841/47.wav", + "text": "報告委員我們國防部的立場" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147841/48.wav", + "text": "在立法院一向是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147841/49.wav", + "text": "依照立法院委員行使職權的相關法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147841/50.wav", + "text": "規來遵守行政中��" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147841/51.wav", + "text": "這個基調和這個原則我們永遠不變" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147841/52.wav", + "text": "這個基調不變沒有錯" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147841/53.wav", + "text": "可是事實已經發生了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147841/54.wav", + "text": "所以不是用理論來這裡說明就好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147841/55.wav", + "text": "我們要知道是不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147841/56.wav", + "text": "國防部在委員會的說詞" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147841/57.wav", + "text": "跟某些執政黨的委員套招" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147841/58.wav", + "text": "意圖阻止在野黨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147841/59.wav", + "text": "揭開特定案件的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147841/60.wav", + "text": "或者甚至惡意攻擊在野黨的委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147841/61.wav", + "text": "這個難怪要有大嘴巴條款" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147841/62.wav", + "text": "這個也很公開" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147841/63.wav", + "text": "這也沒有什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147841/64.wav", + "text": "可是居然可以在大家都公開之前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147841/65.wav", + "text": "就可以拿到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147841/66.wav", + "text": "或者甚至在臉書做這樣的攻擊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147841/67.wav", + "text": "這是非常可惡的一個行為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147841/68.wav", + "text": "我想國防部要取得大家的信任" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147841/69.wav", + "text": "是中立的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147841/70.wav", + "text": "這些我希望都可以確實去做到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147841/71.wav", + "text": "因為有很多的委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147841/72.wav", + "text": "在近期好像都有一些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147841/73.wav", + "text": "配合的說法跟演出" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147841/74.wav", + "text": "當然未來司法在調查的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147841/75.wav", + "text": "都會一一釐清" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147841/76.wav", + "text": "這個部分我們還是要求國防部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147841/77.wav", + "text": "剛剛我們提到的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147841/78.wav", + "text": "如果是委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147841/79.wav", + "text": "也請召委" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147841/80.wav", + "text": "要特別調查清楚好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147841/81.wav", + "text": "我想要請教" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147841/82.wav", + "text": "最近接到一個陳情案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147841/83.wav", + "text": "有一個75歲的老先生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147841/84.wav", + "text": "他在民國56年的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147841/85.wav", + "text": "入伍陸軍的義務役" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147841/86.wav", + "text": "57年因為在外島" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147841/87.wav", + "text": "清理鐵絲網觸雷" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147841/88.wav", + "text": "炸傷他的右下肢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147841/89.wav", + "text": "他下腿中段都被截除" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147841/90.wav", + "text": "所以被核定因公" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147841/91.wav", + "text": "致身心障礙一等殘" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147841/92.wav", + "text": "他從18歲開始" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147841/93.wav", + "text": "回到社會上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147841/94.wav", + "text": "他也沒有辦法正常的工作" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147841/95.wav", + "text": "他從18歲到現在75歲" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147841/96.wav", + "text": "不管是志願役" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147841/97.wav", + "text": "或者是義務役" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147841/98.wav", + "text": "他們為國犧牲" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147841/99.wav", + "text": "其實都是同樣的付出" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147841/100.wav", + "text": "所以在85年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147841/101.wav", + "text": "修訂法律把義務役士官兵" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147841/102.wav", + "text": "納入贍養金的發放對象" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147841/103.wav", + "text": "這也是政府應應該有的德政" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147841/104.wav", + "text": "希望可以彌補對義務役士官兵" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147841/105.wav", + "text": "導致傷殘" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147841/106.wav", + "text": "這是國家應該要做的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147841/107.wav", + "text": "\n現在問題來了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147841/108.wav", + "text": "這個陳情人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147841/109.wav", + "text": "人在相關彌補規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147841/110.wav", + "text": "頒訂後他通通不知情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147841/111.wav", + "text": "其實只在青年日報" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147841/112.wav", + "text": "或者一些特殊的管道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147841/113.wav", + "text": "做這樣資訊的露出而已" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147841/114.wav", + "text": "所以大家都不是太清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147841/115.wav", + "text": "他也不知道他有贍養金可以領" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147841/116.wav", + "text": "國防部到最後只核定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147841/117.wav", + "text": "他在104年以後可以領取" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147841/118.wav", + "text": "因為他是在役政署的官員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147841/119.wav", + "text": "去慰問的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147841/120.wav", + "text": "發現他的生活非常的清苦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147841/121.wav", + "text": "非常的困難才告訴他" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147841/122.wav", + "text": "他可以領這筆錢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147841/123.wav", + "text": "110年向高等行政法院提起訴訟" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147841/124.wav", + "text": "今年5月" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147841/125.wav", + "text": "臺北高等行政法院也判決" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147841/126.wav", + "text": "該老先生勝訴" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147841/127.wav", + "text": "他可以請領國家給與他的照顧贍養金" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147841/128.wav", + "text": "國防部也應該給與核發" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147841/129.wav", + "text": "而且可以回溯領取205十多萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147841/130.wav", + "text": "這是他的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147841/131.wav", + "text": "這是國家應該要給他的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147841/132.wav", + "text": "也是他應得的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147841/133.wav", + "text": "我們現在不知道的是為什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147841/134.wav", + "text": "陸軍司令部還要提起上訴" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147841/135.wav", + "text": "這個不是他的錢嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147841/136.wav", + "text": "報告委員我請法律司來講這個案子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147841/137.wav", + "text": "委員好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147841/138.wav", + "text": "報告委員這個案子我們大概有一些瞭解" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147841/139.wav", + "text": "這個案子因為它前面那一段請領的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147841/140.wav", + "text": "因為它有一些類案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147841/141.wav", + "text": "類案陸軍他們都是按照" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147841/142.wav", + "text": "相同的標準來處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147841/143.wav", + "text": "我剛剛有提到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147841/144.wav", + "text": "你沒有提起訴訟" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147841/145.wav", + "text": "當然可能大家沒有一個依據" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147841/146.wav", + "text": "可是他已經打了行政訴訟" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147841/147.wav", + "text": "而且法院也判決他勝訴" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147841/148.wav", + "text": "我們現在在講的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147841/149.wav", + "text": "其實你是可以不用再上訴" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147841/150.wav", + "text": "因為我們有很多的判例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147841/151.wav", + "text": "包括有些土地的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147841/152.wav", + "text": "有人告了你們一審輸了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147841/153.wav", + "text": "你馬上土地就給人家了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147841/154.wav", + "text": "有很多廠商告了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147841/155.wav", + "text": "你們在一審輸了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147841/156.wav", + "text": "馬上就賠錢給人家兩" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147841/157.wav", + "text": "百五十多萬是一個18歲的青年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147841/158.wav", + "text": "為國家付出他的右下肢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147841/159.wav", + "text": "還有他的右眼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147841/160.wav", + "text": "他瞎了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147841/161.wav", + "text": "他下半肢斷了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147841/162.wav", + "text": "現在75歲" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147841/163.wav", + "text": "一直都過著非常困難的生活" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147841/164.wav", + "text": "今天他也勝訴了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147841/165.wav", + "text": "我不知道為什麼我們的國家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147841/166.wav", + "text": "今天我們把4個月的役期" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147841/167.wav", + "text": "役期延到1年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147841/168.wav", + "text": "未來我們要怎麼照顧我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147841/169.wav", + "text": "所有的軍士官兵" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147841/170.wav", + "text": "要怎麼樣讓所有的國人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147841/171.wav", + "text": "相信我們國家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147841/172.wav", + "text": "為國犧牲的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147841/173.wav", + "text": "可以真的照顧他們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147841/174.wav", + "text": "\n這個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147841/175.wav", + "text": "我想不是用法律" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147841/176.wav", + "text": "因為規定並沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147841/177.wav", + "text": "說你一審敗訴以後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147841/178.wav", + "text": "一定要上訴" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147841/179.wav", + "text": "並沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147841/180.wav", + "text": "在很多的預算上面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147841/181.wav", + "text": "不管是工程" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147841/182.wav", + "text": "不管是其他的國防支出" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147841/183.wav", + "text": "廠商如果要調高的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147841/184.wav", + "text": "甚至是以億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147841/185.wav", + "text": "這個是人家應得的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147841/186.wav", + "text": "他只是不知道資訊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147841/187.wav", + "text": "為什麼你們會輸" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147841/188.wav", + "text": "國防部為什麼會輸" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147841/189.wav", + "text": "就是法官認為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147841/190.wav", + "text": "你們露出的資訊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147841/191.wav", + "text": "受害人也就是陳情人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147841/192.wav", + "text": "他根本沒有辦法看到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147841/193.wav", + "text": "他也沒有辦法獲知" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147841/194.wav", + "text": "所以他才會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147841/195.wav", + "text": "喪失這樣的一個機會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147841/196.wav", + "text": "我們請國防部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147841/197.wav", + "text": "如果應該要照顧的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147841/198.wav", + "text": "人家已經為國家犧牲了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147841/199.wav", + "text": "這是他的錢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147841/200.wav", + "text": "我們國家要給他的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147841/201.wav", + "text": "不要因為其他的理由" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147841/202.wav", + "text": "在沒有相關的規定之下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147841/203.wav", + "text": "硬要這樣子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147841/204.wav", + "text": "他75歲了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147841/205.wav", + "text": "他還可以再多久" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147841/206.wav", + "text": "我們不要說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147841/207.wav", + "text": "啦請你檢視這樣子的作法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147841/208.wav", + "text": "可以怎麼做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147841/209.wav", + "text": "因為你們之前已經提過了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147841/210.wav", + "text": "如果你對一個為國家犧牲的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147841/211.wav", + "text": "都是國家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147841/212.wav", + "text": "造成他這樣子的生活" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147841/213.wav", + "text": "都斤斤計較" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147841/214.wav", + "text": "我不知道誰" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147841/215.wav", + "text": "會願意為國家付出" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147841/216.wav", + "text": "這是一個態度的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147841/217.wav", + "text": "這個也是我們國防部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147841/218.wav", + "text": "照顧軍人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147841/219.wav", + "text": "一個基本的核心價值" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147841/220.wav", + "text": "請你們思考完以後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147841/221.wav", + "text": "再來跟我們說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147840/0.wav", + "text": "部長請" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147840/1.wav", + "text": "委員好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147840/2.wav", + "text": "上次跟您請教過關於數位青年T大使" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147840/3.wav", + "text": "經過了三週" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147840/4.wav", + "text": "我們辦公室其實一直有在跟數發部討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147840/5.wav", + "text": "來談一談往下延伸的可能性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147840/6.wav", + "text": "而且也知道孩子們現在的數位相關媒體" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147840/7.wav", + "text": "載具的應用技術一定比我們小時候那個年代好很多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147840/8.wav", + "text": "但是當時在跟部長討論到這個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147840/9.wav", + "text": "時我們認為要及早培訓及早挖掘" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147840/10.wav", + "text": "甚至讓孩子及早探索這件事情真的非常重要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147840/11.wav", + "text": "所以我們在想有沒有機會再次跟數發部強調" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147840/12.wav", + "text": "如何跟教育部這邊合作搭配高中職" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147840/13.wav", + "text": "不管是學習歷程" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147840/14.wav", + "text": "因為其實數發部自己也有辦類似的活動" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147840/15.wav", + "text": "往下扎根的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147840/16.wav", + "text": "或者是有沒有機會透過社團的方法選修課的方法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147840/17.wav", + "text": "或者是多元課程的方法跟教育部來談這個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147840/18.wav", + "text": "讓孩子們可以及早加入T大使的行列" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147840/19.wav", + "text": "這個部分請部長先回" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147840/20.wav", + "text": "其實我之前也有跟一些畢業的T大使對談" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147840/21.wav", + "text": "有些是技術高中就是委員這張簡報說的高職朋友" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147840/22.wav", + "text": "他們確實也都有提到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147840/23.wav", + "text": "實習課程是一個可能的進入" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147840/24.wav", + "text": "希望我們跟國教署來進行討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147840/25.wav", + "text": "所以很謝謝委員highlight這件事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147840/26.wav", + "text": "這部分是不是請數產署" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147840/27.wav", + "text": "就明年可以改變的部分做一些具體的說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147840/28.wav", + "text": "或是再用書面給我們一個報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147840/29.wav", + "text": "但是更多實行討論的細節" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147840/30.wav", + "text": "如果在跟國教署討論有遇到困難" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147840/31.wav", + "text": "也歡迎找我們辦公室共同討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147840/32.wav", + "text": "因為如果如同部長說的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147840/33.wav", + "text": "很多青年學子確實是有感的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147840/34.wav", + "text": "那我們就持續讓這個事情進行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147840/35.wav", + "text": "好謝謝部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147840/36.wav", + "text": "\n我們來看下一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147840/37.wav", + "text": "其實非常多委員都有提到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147840/38.wav", + "text": "但是我們不要忘記一個新的科技" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147840/39.wav", + "text": "的確還是有它的好處" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147840/40.wav", + "text": "這個好事我想部長你一定認識畫面上這位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147840/41.wav", + "text": "他持續在做AI助教AI家教的事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147840/42.wav", + "text": "他本來在做的事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147840/43.wav", + "text": "是協助孩子在一對一課程的補救教學的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147840/44.wav", + "text": "然後他發現AI是一個好老師" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147840/45.wav", + "text": "甚至在情緒的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147840/46.wav", + "text": "在教育年會也在線上談到了這個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147840/47.wav", + "text": "不知道部長覺得有沒有可能" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147840/48.wav", + "text": "由數發部來將相關的補助資源" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147840/49.wav", + "text": "用來協助臺灣學生面對AI助教AI家教的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147840/50.wav", + "text": "因為其實教育部一直有在做數位學習的補救教學的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147840/51.wav", + "text": "但是如果有數發部的資源來投注這個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147840/52.wav", + "text": "我相信對孩子們會更加有力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147840/53.wav", + "text": "力請部長回應" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147840/54.wav", + "text": "我國二之後都是靠線上的學習" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147840/55.wav", + "text": "所以這個我一向都是非常關心非常在意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147840/56.wav", + "text": "委員所提到的其實在臺灣民間包含均一等等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147840/57.wav", + "text": "有投入相當多的資源在做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147840/58.wav", + "text": "那我們所能夠幫忙的其實是去確保" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147840/59.wav", + "text": "各行各業在運用這些AI的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147840/60.wav", + "text": "它是可以信任的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147840/61.wav", + "text": "不會變成小孩跟這個家教互動" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147840/62.wav", + "text": "這個是我們責無旁貸" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147840/63.wav", + "text": "的所以這部分數產署也有編列" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147840/64.wav", + "text": "預算包含我們年底即將建立AI驗測中心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147840/65.wav", + "text": "特別就是在像GPT-4" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147840/66.wav", + "text": "它會不會講一些其實從我們這邊看起來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147840/67.wav", + "text": "不應該這樣教小孩的事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147840/68.wav", + "text": "這個部分我們會來幫忙做驗測" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147840/69.wav", + "text": "好這個部分我們也會持續跟你們討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147840/70.wav", + "text": "我相信在教育端確實很需要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147840/71.wav", + "text": "數發部這邊資源的協助" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147840/72.wav", + "text": "以上謝謝部長謝謝主席" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147840/73.wav", + "text": "謝謝陳培瑜委員謝謝部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147839/0.wav", + "text": "對於圓山飯店這個包" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147839/1.wav", + "text": "我想圓山跟圓山工會都已經有解釋說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147839/2.wav", + "text": "本部並沒有要求他們要有英文菜單" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147839/3.wav", + "text": "但是我們資安署的朋友" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147839/4.wav", + "text": "在第一時間發生之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147839/5.wav", + "text": "當然是有更正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147839/6.wav", + "text": "好啦所以重點就是不願意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147839/7.wav", + "text": "就是當場就已經處理了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147839/8.wav", + "text": "部長請教一下有關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147839/9.wav", + "text": "民主網絡司" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147839/10.wav", + "text": "在你今天的報告第5頁裡面提到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147839/11.wav", + "text": "連結國際民主網絡力量" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147839/12.wav", + "text": "強化網路發展數位韌性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147839/13.wav", + "text": "請教一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147839/14.wav", + "text": "美國是不是民主國家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147839/15.wav", + "text": "當然是我們民主網絡裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147839/16.wav", + "text": "特別是臺美經貿談判的主要對象" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147839/17.wav", + "text": "臺灣中華民國當然是名列前茅但" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147839/18.wav", + "text": "美國不是民主國家耶" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147839/19.wav", + "text": "美國只是部分民主" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147839/20.wav", + "text": "有跟我們的友邦做網路連結嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147839/21.wav", + "text": "當然都有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147839/22.wav", + "text": "這個是不是請我們盈志司長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147839/23.wav", + "text": "沒關係部長我先跟你說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147839/24.wav", + "text": "我們現在的友邦裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147839/25.wav", + "text": "史瓦帝尼是專制政權" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147839/26.wav", + "text": "這是經濟學人全世界的報告裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147839/27.wav", + "text": "寫的在我們的友邦裡面海地也是專制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147839/28.wav", + "text": "瓜地馬拉是混合" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147839/29.wav", + "text": "貝里斯也是混合" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147839/30.wav", + "text": "所以我們友邦裡面民主國家很少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147839/31.wav", + "text": "你幾乎看不到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147839/32.wav", + "text": "我是不知道他們有沒有把教廷放進去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147839/33.wav", + "text": "所以你的民主網絡司" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147839/34.wav", + "text": "跟不跟我們的友邦連結" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147839/35.wav", + "text": "你想清楚再說喔" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147839/36.wav", + "text": "因為你的民主網絡司" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147839/37.wav", + "text": "是要跟民主國家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147839/38.wav", + "text": "國際民主網絡的力量來連結" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147839/39.wav", + "text": "等一下我們並不是說民主國家的網路" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147839/40.wav", + "text": "我們是說各國裡面的民主網絡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147839/41.wav", + "text": "所以就算是專制集權" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147839/42.wav", + "text": "有防火牆的那種國家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147839/43.wav", + "text": "裡面也有在做民主工作的朋友" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147839/44.wav", + "text": "這些朋友也是我們民主網絡的工作對象" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147839/45.wav", + "text": "所以你的意思" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147839/46.wav", + "text": "是有防火牆跟專制集權有關嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147839/47.wav", + "text": "就是如果他們比較沒有言論自由等等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147839/48.wav", + "text": "我們所投資的這些技術" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147839/49.wav", + "text": "也可以讓他們的言論比較" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147839/50.wav", + "text": "不會被竄改查禁等等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147839/51.wav", + "text": "部長請教一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147839/52.wav", + "text": "數位發展部說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147839/53.wav", + "text": "已經持續積極地" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147839/54.wav", + "text": "防堵詐騙" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147839/55.wav", + "text": "明年也會繼續協助電商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147839/56.wav", + "text": "第三方支付或遊戲業者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147839/57.wav", + "text": "提升防詐能力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147839/58.wav", + "text": "請教你如何具體來協助這些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147839/59.wav", + "text": "業者提升防詐能力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147839/60.wav", + "text": "因為這三個是我們所主管" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147839/61.wav", + "text": "的其實最具體的就是去確保" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147839/62.wav", + "text": "他們在蒐集大家個資的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147839/63.wav", + "text": "不會因為下游物流業或什麼關係" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147839/64.wav", + "text": "把大家的手機號碼什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147839/65.wav", + "text": "就這樣傳出去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147839/66.wav", + "text": "這個是所謂的隱碼技術" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147839/67.wav", + "text": "這部分我想數產署" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147839/68.wav", + "text": "花了相當多的力氣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147839/69.wav", + "text": "也有一些成效" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147839/70.wav", + "text": "請教部長多個國家紛紛要求" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147839/71.wav", + "text": "像GoogleFacebook這些平臺" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147839/72.wav", + "text": "應該要提供媒體的分潤" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147839/73.wav", + "text": "而臺灣這個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147839/74.wav", + "text": "是由數發部來與這些平臺洽商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147839/75.wav", + "text": "數發部也負責相關的立法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147839/76.wav", + "text": "但這個部分感覺起來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147839/77.wav", + "text": "數發部比較消極" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147839/78.wav", + "text": "這些平臺其實已經表達" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147839/79.wav", + "text": "願意遵循臺灣的法令" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147839/80.wav", + "text": "但是我們到現在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147839/81.wav", + "text": "好像沒有看到相關的立法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147839/82.wav", + "text": "甚至連草案也沒有看到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147839/83.wav", + "text": "媒體議價立法進度怎麼樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147839/84.wav", + "text": "好謝謝委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147839/85.wav", + "text": "給我們機會說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147839/86.wav", + "text": "Google當然已經有提出" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147839/87.wav", + "text": "3年3億元的數位轉型" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147839/88.wav", + "text": "相關的基金" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147839/89.wav", + "text": "這次我自費去京都" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147839/90.wav", + "text": "參加聯合國的網際網路治理論壇" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147839/91.wav", + "text": "特別是在生成式AI" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147839/92.wav", + "text": "造成非常多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147839/93.wav", + "text": "希望年底之前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147839/94.wav", + "text": "可以先有一個說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147839/95.wav", + "text": "最後兩個問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147839/96.wav", + "text": "因為時間很短" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147839/97.wav", + "text": "第一個剛剛主席講得非常好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147839/98.wav", + "text": "其實民眾只希望看到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147839/99.wav", + "text": "這個非常非常重要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147839/100.wav", + "text": "所以這個部分一定要拿出成效" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147839/101.wav", + "text": "否則數發部難辭其咎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147839/102.wav", + "text": "第二個問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147839/103.wav", + "text": "剛剛大家特別講到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147839/104.wav", + "text": "出國的經費" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147839/105.wav", + "text": "我剛剛在臺下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147839/106.wav", + "text": "還跟其他委員在聊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147839/107.wav", + "text": "我們立委出國" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147839/108.wav", + "text": "一個人都沒有編三十幾萬的經費" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147839/109.wav", + "text": "我們立委去美國" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147839/110.wav", + "text": "去8天你剛剛說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147839/111.wav", + "text": "沒有旅遊的行程" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147839/112.wav", + "text": "要是有旅遊行程" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147839/113.wav", + "text": "你編那麼多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147839/114.wav", + "text": "我還有點支持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147839/115.wav", + "text": "然後你跟我說要花這麼多錢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147839/116.wav", + "text": "我就不理解啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147839/117.wav", + "text": "不覺得嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147839/118.wav", + "text": "因為開會是最不花錢的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147839/119.wav", + "text": "開會只是你人到那裡住了飯店" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147839/120.wav", + "text": "早上起來開會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147839/121.wav", + "text": "頂多交通費" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147839/122.wav", + "text": "跑來跑去坐計程車" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147839/123.wav", + "text": "你要是真的去旅遊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147839/124.wav", + "text": "這個景點要多少門票" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147839/125.wav", + "text": "那個景點怎麼樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147839/126.wav", + "text": "也許費用很高" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147839/127.wav", + "text": "所以也難怪大家今天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147839/128.wav", + "text": "都盯著你數發部出國的經費" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147839/129.wav", + "text": "我也不想多講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147839/130.wav", + "text": "反正你好好去思考" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147839/131.wav", + "text": "怎麼會成為眾矢之的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147839/132.wav", + "text": "謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147839/133.wav", + "text": "是我想特別是我們主管的電商遊戲" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147839/134.wav", + "text": "第三方支付" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147839/135.wav", + "text": "這個我們一定來加強" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147839/136.wav", + "text": "謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147838/0.wav", + "text": "謝謝主席" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147838/1.wav", + "text": "請林部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147838/2.wav", + "text": "有請林部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147838/3.wav", + "text": "部長好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147838/4.wav", + "text": "部長有關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147838/5.wav", + "text": "我們政務次長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147838/6.wav", + "text": "明天就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147838/7.wav", + "text": "立法院要針對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147838/8.wav", + "text": "選委會的委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147838/9.wav", + "text": "是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147838/10.wav", + "text": "部長就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147838/11.wav", + "text": "我上次在質詢的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147838/12.wav", + "text": "有請教吳容輝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147838/13.wav", + "text": "他曾經" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147838/14.wav", + "text": "雲豹公司" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147838/15.wav", + "text": "張建偉有碰過面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147838/16.wav", + "text": "那我有問過他" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147838/17.wav", + "text": "他說他不認識" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147838/18.wav", + "text": "張建偉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147838/19.wav", + "text": "這個問題就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147838/20.wav", + "text": "跟雲豹公司" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147838/21.wav", + "text": "給臺鹽1億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147838/22.wav", + "text": "1億再轉給" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147838/23.wav", + "text": "一個子公司" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147838/24.wav", + "text": "─縱橫家這件" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147838/25.wav", + "text": "事情那我今天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147838/26.wav", + "text": "要質詢部長就是說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147838/27.wav", + "text": "是不是可以讓你" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147838/28.wav", + "text": "把這件事情能夠在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147838/29.wav", + "text": "今天下班前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147838/30.wav", + "text": "用書面給本席" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147838/31.wav", + "text": "一個確認到底" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147838/32.wav", + "text": "吳容輝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147838/33.wav", + "text": "次長認不認識" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147838/34.wav", + "text": "縱橫家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147838/35.wav", + "text": "認不認識" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147838/36.wav", + "text": "雲豹公司的張建偉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147838/37.wav", + "text": "我跟委員報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147838/38.wav", + "text": "如果是這個事情因為他" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147838/39.wav", + "text": "已經在這邊─" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147838/40.wav", + "text": "在國會殿堂上面正式答復你" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147838/41.wav", + "text": "那這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147838/42.wav", + "text": "有需要特別請" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147838/43.wav", + "text": "部長可以協助嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147838/44.wav", + "text": "因為在去年嘉義縣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147838/45.wav", + "text": "議會副議長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147838/46.wav", + "text": "親自帶張建偉去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147838/47.wav", + "text": "找我們那時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147838/48.wav", + "text": "是臺鹽綠能的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147838/49.wav", + "text": "吳容輝董事長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147838/50.wav", + "text": "委員我想跟你報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147838/51.wav", + "text": "我在這裡是要跟" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147838/52.wav", + "text": "部長說次長在上次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147838/53.wav", + "text": "質詢的時候說謊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147838/54.wav", + "text": "所以我今天要請你" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147838/55.wav", + "text": "協助讓他" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147838/56.wav", + "text": "能夠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147838/57.wav", + "text": "澄清一下他上次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147838/58.wav", + "text": "質詢回答" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147838/59.wav", + "text": "是錯誤的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147838/60.wav", + "text": "部長再麻煩你" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147838/61.wav", + "text": "可以嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147838/62.wav", + "text": "再來就是這一次金鐘獎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147838/63.wav", + "text": "的節目" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147838/64.wav", + "text": "節目是有獲獎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147838/65.wav", + "text": "啦這個節目" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147838/66.wav", + "text": "我們國土署" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147838/67.wav", + "text": "知道嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147838/68.wav", + "text": "就是現在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147838/69.wav", + "text": "有在一些廣播" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147838/70.wav", + "text": "頻道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147838/71.wav", + "text": "就是電視頻道播的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147838/72.wav", + "text": "營業中二" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147838/73.wav", + "text": "這個是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147838/74.wav", + "text": "開發山坡地" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147838/75.wav", + "text": "嘛那署長知道嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147838/76.wav", + "text": "署長在這個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147838/77.wav", + "text": "因為它第一集" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147838/78.wav", + "text": "的節目有獲獎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147838/79.wav", + "text": "那第二集節目" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147838/80.wav", + "text": "未來可能有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147838/81.wav", + "text": "更多的實境節目" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147838/82.wav", + "text": "請問我們內政部怎麼樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147838/83.wav", + "text": "去讓更多節目" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147838/84.wav", + "text": "能夠瞭解這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147838/85.wav", + "text": "作法是違法的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147838/86.wav", + "text": "我們都有通知地方政府" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147838/87.wav", + "text": "而且已經開罰兩次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147838/88.wav", + "text": "這個節目公然播放" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147838/89.wav", + "text": "就是去示範這個違法的行為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147838/90.wav", + "text": "啦因為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147838/91.wav", + "text": "它的節目" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147838/92.wav", + "text": "從這個臺播完再賣給" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147838/93.wav", + "text": "另外一個臺" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147838/94.wav", + "text": "這個顯然是不妥" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147838/95.wav", + "text": "也麻煩內政部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147838/96.wav", + "text": "能夠關心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147838/97.wav", + "text": "再來我再請教" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147838/98.wav", + "text": "你知道我們內政部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147838/99.wav", + "text": "在人本交通" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147838/100.wav", + "text": "主責的項目嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147838/101.wav", + "text": "人本的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147838/102.wav", + "text": "我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147838/103.wav", + "text": "第一個通學環境" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147838/104.wav", + "text": "步道的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147838/105.wav", + "text": "人行道的部分對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147838/106.wav", + "text": "還是只有通學的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147838/107.wav", + "text": "市區道路內的人行道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147838/108.wav", + "text": "只有學生通學的人行道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147838/109.wav", + "text": "還是所有的人行道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147838/110.wav", + "text": "你們負責哪一個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147838/111.wav", + "text": "我們計畫道路內的人行道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147838/112.wav", + "text": "當然通行的部分是我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147838/113.wav", + "text": "騎樓也是你們負責" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147838/114.wav", + "text": "對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147838/115.wav", + "text": "因為交通委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147838/116.wav", + "text": "就快要排審" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147838/117.wav", + "text": "道路交通安全基本法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147838/118.wav", + "text": "那我要請問我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147838/119.wav", + "text": "內政部負責的項目" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147838/120.wav", + "text": "能夠把它入法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147838/121.wav", + "text": "能夠讓我們知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147838/122.wav", + "text": "內政部實際執行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147838/123.wav", + "text": "是哪些業務" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147838/124.wav", + "text": "可以請署長來說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147838/125.wav", + "text": "你們的業務要放入" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147838/126.wav", + "text": "道路交通安全基本法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147838/127.wav", + "text": "的內容你們要放哪些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147838/128.wav", + "text": "是一個基本的法條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147838/129.wav", + "text": "大概就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147838/130.wav", + "text": "描述它整個政策" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147838/131.wav", + "text": "執行的方向" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147838/132.wav", + "text": "但是就國土管理署來講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147838/133.wav", + "text": "本身負責的是屬於" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147838/134.wav", + "text": "所以我們自己也會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147838/135.wav", + "text": "訂定一個條例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147838/136.wav", + "text": "我知道你們會訂定但是道路交通安全" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147838/137.wav", + "text": "將你們內政部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147838/138.wav", + "text": "負責的項目寫清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147838/139.wav", + "text": "好嗎可以嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147838/140.wav", + "text": "部長這個真的很重要不然" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147838/141.wav", + "text": "一直以為扮演" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147838/142.wav", + "text": "協助的角色" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147838/143.wav", + "text": "所以讓我們現在人行道都沒辦法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147838/144.wav", + "text": "暢通" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147838/145.wav", + "text": "騎樓也沒辦法暢通" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147838/146.wav", + "text": "只好走到馬路上結果就發生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147838/147.wav", + "text": "意外事故" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147838/148.wav", + "text": "所以這個非常重要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147838/149.wav", + "text": "跟委員報告其實大部分的預算都在我們這邊執行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147838/150.wav", + "text": "我相信你們很願意做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147838/151.wav", + "text": "但是現在就是希望在法裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147838/152.wav", + "text": "能夠寫清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147838/153.wav", + "text": "希望內政部的業務能夠寫清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147838/154.wav", + "text": "這一次讓我們訂定一個專法來執行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147838/155.wav", + "text": "部長回答一下好嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147838/156.wav", + "text": "就是要入法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147838/157.wav", + "text": "我想這部分就是已經" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147838/158.wav", + "text": "入法而且剛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147838/159.wav", + "text": "還沒入法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147838/160.wav", + "text": "是現在要定法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147838/161.wav", + "text": "部長了解" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147838/162.wav", + "text": "現在地政司有關地籍" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147838/163.wav", + "text": "套繪的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147838/164.wav", + "text": "地籍套繪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147838/165.wav", + "text": "出現非常多的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147838/166.wav", + "text": "主要的原因就是用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147838/167.wav", + "text": "空照圖去套" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147838/168.wav", + "text": "繪舊的地籍圖" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147838/169.wav", + "text": "所以很多房子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147838/170.wav", + "text": "結果用面積" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147838/171.wav", + "text": "來說明說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147838/172.wav", + "text": "它的面積一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147838/173.wav", + "text": "結果整個房子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147838/174.wav", + "text": "都要被拆了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147838/175.wav", + "text": "所以這個問題滿嚴重" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147838/176.wav", + "text": "請問部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147838/177.wav", + "text": "這是地政司負責" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147838/178.wav", + "text": "嘛我們現在怎麼來解決" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147838/179.wav", + "text": "因為連國土測繪中心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147838/180.wav", + "text": "都淪為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147838/181.wav", + "text": "協助地方地政單位的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147838/182.wav", + "text": "幫兇" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147838/183.wav", + "text": "去做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147838/184.wav", + "text": "證詞導致" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147838/185.wav", + "text": "民宅要被拆" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147838/186.wav", + "text": "就沒有辦法釐清" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147838/187.wav", + "text": "我先拜託" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147838/188.wav", + "text": "有爭議的要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147838/189.wav", + "text": "重測" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147838/190.wav", + "text": "委員我跟你報告兩點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147838/191.wav", + "text": "第一個我們不會直接用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147838/192.wav", + "text": "空照圖去套匯" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147838/193.wav", + "text": "這個絕對不會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147838/194.wav", + "text": "重新做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147838/195.wav", + "text": "重劃或重測是可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147838/196.wav", + "text": "的嗎希望內政部能夠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147838/197.wav", + "text": "編列預算做重新的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147838/198.wav", + "text": "測量可以嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147838/199.wav", + "text": "有爭議的話當然可以進行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147838/200.wav", + "text": "調處可以重測" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147838/201.wav", + "text": "不過重測應該需要相關的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147838/202.wav", + "text": "司長回答一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147838/203.wav", + "text": "因為現在國土測繪中心我個人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147838/204.wav", + "text": "國土測繪中心已經淪為幫兇了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147838/205.wav", + "text": "委員我跟你報告我想這不可能" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147838/206.wav", + "text": "繪是有一個公權力在做執行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147838/207.wav", + "text": "就是沒有實際鑑" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147838/208.wav", + "text": "的地籍圖的現象" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147838/209.wav", + "text": "已經有好多個案例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147838/210.wav", + "text": "是這樣了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147838/211.wav", + "text": "跟委員報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147838/212.wav", + "text": "事實上一定會請雙方來指界" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147838/213.wav", + "text": "但是雙方沒有來指界的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147838/214.wav", + "text": "我們會參照舊圖" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147838/215.wav", + "text": "事實上我們的測量員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147838/216.wav", + "text": "還是會到現地去做實地的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147838/217.wav", + "text": "空照圖來做套好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147838/218.wav", + "text": "但是現在的確問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147838/219.wav", + "text": "滿多的陳情人滿多的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147838/220.wav", + "text": "也讓部長了解" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147838/221.wav", + "text": "這個問題滿嚴重" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147838/222.wav", + "text": "委員我跟你報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147838/223.wav", + "text": "其實這個在地方" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147838/224.wav", + "text": "經常會看到三圖套不起來的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147838/225.wav", + "text": "但是這就是要去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147838/226.wav", + "text": "解決的謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147838/227.wav", + "text": "好謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147838/228.wav", + "text": "謝謝陳椒華委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147838/229.wav", + "text": "\n接著有請邱顯智委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147837/0.wav", + "text": "謝謝主席" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147837/1.wav", + "text": "我委員好副部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147837/2.wav", + "text": "副部長不好意思" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147837/3.wav", + "text": "但是這個整個制度改變以後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147837/4.wav", + "text": "大家升官了以後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147837/5.wav", + "text": "很多該要求的還是要要求" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147837/6.wav", + "text": "\n我相信國人對國軍的形象" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147837/7.wav", + "text": "第一個期待的就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147837/8.wav", + "text": "有戰力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147837/9.wav", + "text": "有戰力民眾感受到的就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147837/10.wav", + "text": "對國軍整個形象" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147837/11.wav", + "text": "除了最基本的軍紀要求以外" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147837/12.wav", + "text": "以這次來看的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147837/13.wav", + "text": "你看這個演習的一些意外" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147837/14.wav", + "text": "在我們宜蘭" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147837/15.wav", + "text": "這個就是一個疏忽" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147837/16.wav", + "text": "就是一個疏忽" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147837/17.wav", + "text": "我不曉得你們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147837/18.wav", + "text": "對這個看法是怎麼樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147837/19.wav", + "text": "以過去來看的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147837/20.wav", + "text": "國軍這幾年發生的一些意外" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147837/21.wav", + "text": "從2016年雄三" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147837/22.wav", + "text": "雄三反艦飛彈的誤射事件" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147837/23.wav", + "text": "一共20幾起這樣的意外" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147837/24.wav", + "text": "也都造成了不少人員的殉職" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147837/25.wav", + "text": "以飛彈誤射來看的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147837/26.wav", + "text": "雄三那個部分是1死3傷" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147837/27.wav", + "text": "2021年阿帕契直升機" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147837/28.wav", + "text": "在我們屏東恆春機場演習的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147837/29.wav", + "text": "所幸這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147837/30.wav", + "text": "到最後那個發射架也找回來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147837/31.wav", + "text": "了你今年8月" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147837/32.wav", + "text": "在我們屏東九鵬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147837/33.wav", + "text": "當初這個也沒有投入目標" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147837/34.wav", + "text": "旁邊那個海巡艦艇" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147837/35.wav", + "text": "也有驚無險" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147837/36.wav", + "text": "都是要跨單位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147837/37.wav", + "text": "這個真的要再加強" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147837/38.wav", + "text": "我相信國軍的戰力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147837/39.wav", + "text": "一定都可以提升" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147837/40.wav", + "text": "這一些演練也都有必要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147837/41.wav", + "text": "但是這個難看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147837/42.wav", + "text": "真的不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147837/43.wav", + "text": "我苦口婆心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147837/44.wav", + "text": "像我們那邊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147837/45.wav", + "text": "我們那邊碰到的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147837/46.wav", + "text": "是你們在九鵬那邊射擊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147837/47.wav", + "text": "太平洋那個地方射出去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147837/48.wav", + "text": "一射出去你知道嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147837/49.wav", + "text": "一射完以後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147837/50.wav", + "text": "很多漁民就抗議了對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147837/51.wav", + "text": "對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147837/52.wav", + "text": "那個魚就三個月不會回來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147837/53.wav", + "text": "魚就嚇到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147837/54.wav", + "text": "最基本的像橫向聯繫的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147837/55.wav", + "text": "請教你的看法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147837/56.wav", + "text": "報告委員我想國軍近期所發生這些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147837/57.wav", + "text": "意外事件頻傳" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147837/58.wav", + "text": "這個事情我們也深切的檢討" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147837/59.wav", + "text": "尤其是我們在要求演習前的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147837/60.wav", + "text": "我們時刻在檢討" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147837/61.wav", + "text": "如果發生這些事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147837/62.wav", + "text": "我們事後對於下次的防範" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147837/63.wav", + "text": "也會有一個機制來做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147837/64.wav", + "text": "希望把所有的這種意外情況降到最低" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147837/65.wav", + "text": "這些都是謝謝委員給我們的指導" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147837/66.wav", + "text": "我想國防部在這個部分虛心受教" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147837/67.wav", + "text": "所以相同的事情不要再發生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147837/68.wav", + "text": "不要一再重演" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147837/69.wav", + "text": "這個有時候造成無辜生命的傷亡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147837/70.wav", + "text": "最主要是對國軍的聲譽真的不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147837/71.wav", + "text": "另外我一直都會去拜讀你們的國防報告書" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147837/72.wav", + "text": "自從我們的義務役期改回來1年以後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147837/73.wav", + "text": "義務役上戰場" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147837/74.wav", + "text": "什麼青年上戰場" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147837/75.wav", + "text": "本席的看法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147837/76.wav", + "text": "我倒不是站在政黨的看法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147837/77.wav", + "text": "你現在真正以俄烏戰爭來看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147837/78.wav", + "text": "或者以巴戰爭來看的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147837/79.wav", + "text": "只要是戰場的地方" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147837/80.wav", + "text": "沒有誰上不上戰場" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147837/81.wav", + "text": "連民眾都在戰場上面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147837/82.wav", + "text": "其實我們是分成主戰部隊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147837/83.wav", + "text": "與守備部隊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147837/84.wav", + "text": "這個外界在炒作的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147837/85.wav", + "text": "我認為國防部沒有講清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147837/86.wav", + "text": "本來就是兩階段" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147837/87.wav", + "text": "第一個階段是俗稱的下部隊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147837/88.wav", + "text": "再來就會分發" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147837/89.wav", + "text": "那會不會到主戰部隊去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147837/90.wav", + "text": "有人把主戰部隊講成就是上戰場" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147837/91.wav", + "text": "主戰部隊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147837/92.wav", + "text": "我記得你本來在政策在推的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147837/93.wav", + "text": "就講得很清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147837/94.wav", + "text": "也就是也要他願意嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147837/95.wav", + "text": "請你再講一次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147837/96.wav", + "text": "報告委員我們在政策" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147837/97.wav", + "text": "他就是守備部隊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147837/98.wav", + "text": "但是在這裡面有幾個條件" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147837/99.wav", + "text": "在駐在地分發的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147837/100.wav", + "text": "比如你是離外島的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147837/101.wav", + "text": "他可以依照他自願的遴選方式來執行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147837/102.wav", + "text": "第二個他必須要符合" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147837/103.wav", + "text": "主戰部隊高專長的需求" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147837/104.wav", + "text": "還要經過鑑測" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147837/105.wav", + "text": "還要經過審查才能夠去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147837/106.wav", + "text": "第三個如果報名人數" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147837/107.wav", + "text": "超過我們的預期的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147837/108.wav", + "text": "尤其是在離外島" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147837/109.wav", + "text": "我們還必須透過抽籤的方式來執行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147837/110.wav", + "text": "但是主要目的要講得非常清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147837/111.wav", + "text": "將來所有1年期的義務役期" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147837/112.wav", + "text": "期就是以守備部隊分發為主" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147837/113.wav", + "text": "缺員的部分來看的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147837/114.wav", + "text": "缺乏人力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147837/115.wav", + "text": "第二個缺乏比較完善的人力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147837/116.wav", + "text": "你在訓練" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147837/117.wav", + "text": "或簽證率嚴重不足" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147837/118.wav", + "text": "這個我都很擔心去影響到整個戰力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147837/119.wav", + "text": "這種現象普遍發生在陸軍海軍主戰的裝甲" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147837/120.wav", + "text": "機步旅與艦艇上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147837/121.wav", + "text": "而成熟的砲兵裝甲" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147837/122.wav", + "text": "艦艇各種專長簽證" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147837/123.wav", + "text": "\n面對現在少子化" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147837/124.wav", + "text": "國際上在談的都是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147837/125.wav", + "text": "近期我們也看到俄" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147837/126.wav", + "text": "烏戰爭裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147837/127.wav", + "text": "軍事實力被普遍認為比較弱的地方" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147837/128.wav", + "text": "就會去發展" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147837/129.wav", + "text": "副部長提到的無人機部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147837/130.wav", + "text": "一個不對稱的戰力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147837/131.wav", + "text": "你說它" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147837/132.wav", + "text": "需要很多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147837/133.wav", + "text": "它其實也不只消耗還有偵蒐" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147837/134.wav", + "text": "你不如把它當成是彈藥" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147837/135.wav", + "text": "水下載具的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147837/136.wav", + "text": "有關目前我們水下無人載具的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147837/137.wav", + "text": "中科院以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147837/138.wav", + "text": "龍德公司打造多用途的水下載具" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147837/139.wav", + "text": "預計今年年底以前可以完成建造" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147837/140.wav", + "text": "本席非常認同" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147837/141.wav", + "text": "國防部或者中科院這樣的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147837/142.wav", + "text": "但目前也沒有看到國防部把" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147837/143.wav", + "text": "把水下無人載具這個概念" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147837/144.wav", + "text": "本席倒認為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147837/145.wav", + "text": "這個我們可以去做加強" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147837/146.wav", + "text": "不曉得副部長的看法怎麼樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147837/147.wav", + "text": "報告委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147837/148.wav", + "text": "在研發階段有關於所有軍事屬性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147837/149.wav", + "text": "裝備" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147837/150.wav", + "text": "採取低調保密的措施來做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147837/151.wav", + "text": "因為這裡面還牽扯到很多技術" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147837/152.wav", + "text": "我們是不是成熟" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147837/153.wav", + "text": "我想這些東西我們都在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147837/154.wav", + "text": "中科院努力的情況下希望有一天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147837/155.wav", + "text": "能夠達到這樣的戰力需求" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147837/156.wav", + "text": "我有夠低調" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147837/157.wav", + "text": "你們這一本沒寫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147837/158.wav", + "text": "的我都沒有問你" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147837/159.wav", + "text": "們所以有夠低調" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147837/160.wav", + "text": "的我的意思就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147837/161.wav", + "text": "真的戰力要去提升的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147837/162.wav", + "text": "我們確實要趕快去做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147837/163.wav", + "text": "是的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147837/164.wav", + "text": "好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147837/165.wav", + "text": "努力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147836/0.wav", + "text": "謝謝召委我請部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147836/1.wav", + "text": "來部長請" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147836/2.wav", + "text": "隔壁警政署到比利時英國法國10天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147836/3.wav", + "text": "編9.9萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147836/4.wav", + "text": "我已經跟他們講連編預算都不會編" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147836/5.wav", + "text": "所以你們這邊真的是還不錯" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147836/6.wav", + "text": "\n不過我想請教一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147836/7.wav", + "text": "這個月20日" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147836/8.wav", + "text": "金管會針對P2P平臺發布3項指導原則" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147836/9.wav", + "text": "包括不得涉及金融特許業務" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147836/10.wav", + "text": "設立6項風險控管機制及明定7項保護措施" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147836/11.wav", + "text": "這些指導原則發布之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147836/12.wav", + "text": "其實從2016年到現在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147836/13.wav", + "text": "P2P業者已經有26家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147836/14.wav", + "text": "而且現在是詐騙橫行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147836/15.wav", + "text": "金管會不是主管機關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147836/16.wav", + "text": "還發布這個指導原則" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147836/17.wav", + "text": "而且他們說他們今年要跟金融機關合作" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147836/18.wav", + "text": "透過金融監理沙盒來新增2案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147836/19.wav", + "text": "防詐和反洗錢的業者申請" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147836/20.wav", + "text": "部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147836/21.wav", + "text": "因為P2P是FinTech的一種" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147836/22.wav", + "text": "在以資訊流取代資金流" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147836/23.wav", + "text": "和人工流的同時" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147836/24.wav", + "text": "就是一家網路數位科技公司" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147836/25.wav", + "text": "根據你們的組織法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147836/26.wav", + "text": "已經明定數發部的職責" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147836/27.wav", + "text": "包括數位科技應用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147836/28.wav", + "text": "與創新發展環境之建構所以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147836/29.wav", + "text": "這個政策指導和監督" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147836/30.wav", + "text": "應該都是你們不是嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147836/31.wav", + "text": "我想委員剛剛提到一個很好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147836/32.wav", + "text": "的金融監理沙盒這個概念出現" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147836/33.wav", + "text": "是我還在擔任政委的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147836/34.wav", + "text": "當時就是希望裡面值得大家信任的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147836/35.wav", + "text": "這些工具透過實證" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147836/36.wav", + "text": "讓大家看到原來這個創新的做法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147836/37.wav", + "text": "也值得信任" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147836/38.wav", + "text": "所以在這個過程裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147836/39.wav", + "text": "包含透過AI防詐等等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147836/40.wav", + "text": "都有相關的獎補助計畫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147836/41.wav", + "text": "去讓他們能夠往" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147836/42.wav", + "text": "值得信任的方向來發展" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147836/43.wav", + "text": "部長但是我要問一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147836/44.wav", + "text": "你們到底做了些什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147836/45.wav", + "text": "跟委員報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147836/46.wav", + "text": "我們在防詐上面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147836/47.wav", + "text": "主要是防堵和防阻" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147836/48.wav", + "text": "所以在防堵的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147836/49.wav", + "text": "我們會希望跟金管會也好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147836/50.wav", + "text": "NCC也好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147836/51.wav", + "text": "去確保我們主管的地方先做起" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147836/52.wav", + "text": "你們現在是每個人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147836/53.wav", + "text": "都說是對方的都跟自己無關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147836/54.wav", + "text": "沒有沒有第三方支付是我們管" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147836/55.wav", + "text": "啊但是我們來登錄的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147836/56.wav", + "text": "我們去把它公布出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147836/57.wav", + "text": "金管會就說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147836/58.wav", + "text": "除非數位部認得的這些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147836/59.wav", + "text": "第三方支付業者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147836/60.wav", + "text": "不然以後就不再發虛擬帳號了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147836/61.wav", + "text": "這樣子好不好P2P這方面的管控" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147836/62.wav", + "text": "你們數位部做了些什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147836/63.wav", + "text": "給本席一個書面報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147836/64.wav", + "text": "我們用書面來跟委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147836/65.wav", + "text": "因為我們看到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147836/66.wav", + "text": "其實大家都在講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147836/67.wav", + "text": "你們是錢多事少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147836/68.wav", + "text": "出國多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147836/69.wav", + "text": "啦但是我講實話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147836/70.wav", + "text": "你們拿了這麼多錢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147836/71.wav", + "text": "連要求臉書下架" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147836/72.wav", + "text": "都比警政署做得慢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147836/73.wav", + "text": "我們是幫警政署建立" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147836/74.wav", + "text": "那個快速通報的管道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147836/75.wav", + "text": "他們在使用的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147836/76.wav", + "text": "因為他們是執法機關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147836/77.wav", + "text": "所以你們是幕後的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147836/78.wav", + "text": "我們是建立那個管道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147836/79.wav", + "text": "當然是讓警政署能夠快速反應" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147836/80.wav", + "text": "如果我們建立快速通報" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147836/81.wav", + "text": "那就沒有道理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147836/82.wav", + "text": "好所以您剛剛也跟我講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147836/83.wav", + "text": "因為針對明揚大火" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147836/84.wav", + "text": "我希望你們一定要做好這方面的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147836/85.wav", + "text": "不是他們現在講的什麼化學雲" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147836/86.wav", + "text": "毒物雲這個雲那個雲" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147836/87.wav", + "text": "消防弟兄到現場的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147836/88.wav", + "text": "這些雲端資料" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147836/89.wav", + "text": "你這個有做到嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147836/90.wav", + "text": "就是委員之前是詢問我們數政司" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147836/91.wav", + "text": "但其實提供這些消防弟兄" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147836/92.wav", + "text": "好像那個路肩一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147836/93.wav", + "text": "就是電信公司能夠分出一大塊頻寬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147836/94.wav", + "text": "給這些弟兄來用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147836/95.wav", + "text": "這個是放在我們的靭性司" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147836/96.wav", + "text": "和資源司的工作" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147836/97.wav", + "text": "除此之外去跟消防弟兄" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147836/98.wav", + "text": "這部分也是我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147836/99.wav", + "text": "數產署的工作" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147836/100.wav", + "text": "所以我想這3個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147836/101.wav", + "text": "很謝謝委員上次的提醒" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147836/102.wav", + "text": "後來我們內部有釐清過了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147836/103.wav", + "text": "是所以你們數" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147836/104.wav", + "text": "要針對我們現在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147836/105.wav", + "text": "外面很多第一線同仁" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147836/106.wav", + "text": "是我想資料治理和開放" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147836/107.wav", + "text": "這部分我們責無旁貸" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147836/108.wav", + "text": "不過委員的簡報說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147836/109.wav", + "text": "黑手是有一點誇張" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147836/110.wav", + "text": "但是資料治理和開放" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147836/111.wav", + "text": "我們責無旁貸這沒有問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147836/112.wav", + "text": "跟你們提過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147836/113.wav", + "text": "你們不可以讓" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147836/114.wav", + "text": "打火弟兄到了第一線" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147836/115.wav", + "text": "廠商提供一個書面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147836/116.wav", + "text": "去印出這個資料給我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147836/117.wav", + "text": "這個都太慢了好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147836/118.wav", + "text": "第一個他們要有充足的頻寬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147836/119.wav", + "text": "第二個資料要整合" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147836/120.wav", + "text": "這兩個部分我們會來加" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147836/121.wav", + "text": "在頻寬的解決" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147836/122.wav", + "text": "或在硬體上面的資源" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147836/123.wav", + "text": "一定要充足好嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147836/124.wav", + "text": "謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147835/0.wav", + "text": "媒體已經報導很多了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147835/1.wav", + "text": "我知道在數位部來講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147835/2.wav", + "text": "你們應該算要非常注意detail" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147835/3.wav", + "text": "非常細節" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147835/4.wav", + "text": "有些部會的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147835/5.wav", + "text": "差一點看起來差不多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147835/6.wav", + "text": "但你差一點可能網路程式就跑不動了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147835/7.wav", + "text": "所以這整個來講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147835/8.wav", + "text": "因為你當天舉辦的是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147835/9.wav", + "text": "跨國網路攻防演練" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147835/10.wav", + "text": "請了很多的國際貴賓" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147835/11.wav", + "text": "當然這個晚宴本來就是一個小事" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147835/12.wav", + "text": "主要是這個演練" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147835/13.wav", + "text": "後面就吃個飯" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147835/14.wav", + "text": "吃到最後這一道菜上面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147835/15.wav", + "text": "寫的是中華人民共和國嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147835/16.wav", + "text": "那我就要請問一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147835/17.wav", + "text": "你們事前都沒人知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147835/18.wav", + "text": "雖然我不在現場" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147835/19.wav", + "text": "但是就在現場資安署的同仁" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147835/20.wav", + "text": "他們事前是有送菜單" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147835/21.wav", + "text": "但那都是中文的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147835/22.wav", + "text": "就是為什麼到了現場突然有英文的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147835/23.wav", + "text": "後來圓山那邊的說法是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147835/24.wav", + "text": "他們有一位熱心的同仁" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147835/25.wav", + "text": "基於貼心服務" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147835/26.wav", + "text": "而當天就把這一道菜翻成英文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147835/27.wav", + "text": "那你覺得呢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147835/28.wav", + "text": "我覺得就圓山大飯店" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147835/29.wav", + "text": "我看這個英文形容這個菜色的字句" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147835/30.wav", + "text": "都在他電腦裡面已經擺好了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147835/31.wav", + "text": "我一直在想一件事" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147835/32.wav", + "text": "這個菜單不知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147835/33.wav", + "text": "已經放在多少人桌上過了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147835/34.wav", + "text": "我在擔心這件事" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147835/35.wav", + "text": "啊不過當然這部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147835/36.wav", + "text": "這個菜也不是你數發部的事" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147835/37.wav", + "text": "但是我覺得像這樣的一個情況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147835/38.wav", + "text": "你有沒有去瞭解" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147835/39.wav", + "text": "因為圓山大飯店" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147835/40.wav", + "text": "也算是屬於交通部的一份子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147835/41.wav", + "text": "你有沒有去瞭解" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147835/42.wav", + "text": "它是不是經年累月都這樣搞" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147835/43.wav", + "text": "就是按照圓山的說法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147835/44.wav", + "text": "這道菜確實是第一次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147835/45.wav", + "text": "在有外賓的場合" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147835/46.wav", + "text": "被點到而出現" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147835/47.wav", + "text": "然後他們很熱心地" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147835/48.wav", + "text": "自己把它翻過來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147835/49.wav", + "text": "我們並沒有要求" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147835/50.wav", + "text": "要英文菜單或翻譯" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147835/51.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147835/52.wav", + "text": "因為當天據傳" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147835/53.wav", + "text": "很多的外賓看到這樣的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147835/54.wav", + "text": "也非常非常驚奇" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147835/55.wav", + "text": "很好奇" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147835/56.wav", + "text": "拍照的拍照" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147835/57.wav", + "text": "甚至有覺得這一輩子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147835/58.wav", + "text": "可能碰到一次的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147835/59.wav", + "text": "把菜單都帶走" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147835/60.wav", + "text": "第一次看到這樣的情況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147835/61.wav", + "text": "沒有這種事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147835/62.wav", + "text": "報告委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147835/63.wav", + "text": "其實是我們自己先發現" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147835/64.wav", + "text": "所以我們就立刻" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147835/65.wav", + "text": "所以你們自己先發現" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147835/66.wav", + "text": "所以立刻把牌子收走" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147835/67.wav", + "text": "還是怎樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147835/68.wav", + "text": "我們就立刻反映" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147835/69.wav", + "text": "而且我們有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147835/70.wav", + "text": "有跟外賓在搶這個牌子嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147835/71.wav", + "text": "沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147835/72.wav", + "text": "因為總共只有3個牌子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147835/73.wav", + "text": "都沒有被帶走" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147835/74.wav", + "text": "是留下來的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147835/75.wav", + "text": "真的嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147835/76.wav", + "text": "明天網路上拍賣的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147835/77.wav", + "text": "你們要查一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147835/78.wav", + "text": "那請問一下唐部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147835/79.wav", + "text": "不過我覺得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147835/80.wav", + "text": "你們真的要注意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147835/81.wav", + "text": "真的這個事情應該要小心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147835/82.wav", + "text": "我們會再更加要求" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147835/83.wav", + "text": "因為這種大活動" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147835/84.wav", + "text": "我們自己吃個飯" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147835/85.wav", + "text": "這麼多的貴賓來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147835/86.wav", + "text": "這個事情的嚴重程度是蠻大" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147835/87.wav", + "text": "我希望你們再細心一點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147835/88.wav", + "text": "我們絕對會更加去要求" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147835/89.wav", + "text": "還沒人發現" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147835/90.wav", + "text": "\n那我就請教一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147835/91.wav", + "text": "剛剛很多人談到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147835/92.wav", + "text": "出國的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147835/93.wav", + "text": "你們這些委辦費" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147835/94.wav", + "text": "你剛成立的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147835/95.wav", + "text": "請你來我辦公室" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147835/96.wav", + "text": "我特別關心這件事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147835/97.wav", + "text": "整個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147835/98.wav", + "text": "感覺你們要多少人力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147835/99.wav", + "text": "我們在討論這個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147835/100.wav", + "text": "我特別在問一件事" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147835/101.wav", + "text": "你請的人力都專業" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147835/102.wav", + "text": "很多計畫什麼的都可以自己做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147835/103.wav", + "text": "大部分的情況如何" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147835/104.wav", + "text": "當然少部分勢必有一些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147835/105.wav", + "text": "是不是要委外的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147835/106.wav", + "text": "的委辦費112年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147835/107.wav", + "text": "部分在你們送進來的這個預算書" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147835/108.wav", + "text": "看到了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147835/109.wav", + "text": "去年13.79億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147835/110.wav", + "text": "到了我們要審的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147835/111.wav", + "text": "明年的預算裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147835/112.wav", + "text": "目前看到是28.52億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147835/113.wav", + "text": "如果以自己做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147835/114.wav", + "text": "跟委外來講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147835/115.wav", + "text": "你委外已經占69%了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147835/116.wav", + "text": "請問一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147835/117.wav", + "text": "因為你這樣外包" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147835/118.wav", + "text": "嘛外包給圓山飯店" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147835/119.wav", + "text": "嘛出了錯就是圓山飯店" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147835/120.wav", + "text": "你外包了這麼多東西" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147835/121.wav", + "text": "到底你們的權責" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147835/122.wav", + "text": "你們自己的責任" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147835/123.wav", + "text": "有沒有外包" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147835/124.wav", + "text": "因為我過去聽過很多事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147835/125.wav", + "text": "跟我們回答" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147835/126.wav", + "text": "出了事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147835/127.wav", + "text": "你們在外包的過程中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147835/128.wav", + "text": "到底你們的責任" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147835/129.wav", + "text": "不要說到最後誰唉呀" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147835/130.wav", + "text": "我的外包廠商出錯了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147835/131.wav", + "text": "請問一下你們這個委辦費" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147835/132.wav", + "text": "立法院的數據有沒有錯" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147835/133.wav", + "text": "說明一下智慧防詐的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147835/134.wav", + "text": "就我所知" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147835/135.wav", + "text": "之前也有委員問到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147835/136.wav", + "text": "像資安院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147835/137.wav", + "text": "這是我們所屬的行政法人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147835/138.wav", + "text": "那個是因為預算編列上面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147835/139.wav", + "text": "沒有辦法說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147835/140.wav", + "text": "就是資安院變成預算的一部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147835/141.wav", + "text": "所以變成我們編了一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147835/142.wav", + "text": "指定補捐助" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147835/143.wav", + "text": "在資安院執行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147835/144.wav", + "text": "但是當然負責" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147835/145.wav", + "text": "因為我也是資安院董事長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147835/146.wav", + "text": "我們當然是會負責的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147835/147.wav", + "text": "所以資安院花多少錢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147835/148.wav", + "text": "還是請資安署說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147835/149.wav", + "text": "預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147835/150.wav", + "text": "還是院長有來嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147835/151.wav", + "text": "院長預算多少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147835/152.wav", + "text": "元嘛就藏在這個位置" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147835/153.wav", + "text": "用麥克風回答" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147835/154.wav", + "text": "因為行政法人不能編單位預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147835/155.wav", + "text": "所以是數位部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147835/156.wav", + "text": "為了執行重大的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147835/157.wav", + "text": "資安技術研發" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147835/158.wav", + "text": "人才培訓等等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147835/159.wav", + "text": "來委託" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147835/160.wav", + "text": "我們各司加上資安署" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147835/161.wav", + "text": "加在一起七點多億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147835/162.wav", + "text": "預算跟成果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147835/163.wav", + "text": "這個到年底才看得出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147835/164.wav", + "text": "到明年你到底執行得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147835/165.wav", + "text": "如何我不知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147835/166.wav", + "text": "現在資安院你的預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147835/167.wav", + "text": "目前我第一次看到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147835/168.wav", + "text": "我們真的是希望" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147835/169.wav", + "text": "你們的效果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147835/170.wav", + "text": "包括兩個署" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147835/171.wav", + "text": "能夠發揮集體內外的戰力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147835/172.wav", + "text": "你們現在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147835/173.wav", + "text": "就算扣掉這七點多億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147835/174.wav", + "text": "委辦費的這個預算還是增加" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147835/175.wav", + "text": "我一直在這邊提醒部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147835/176.wav", + "text": "你們這些委外的品質要求" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147835/177.wav", + "text": "它到底能力如何" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147835/178.wav", + "text": "我覺得你們要非常慎重地管控" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147835/179.wav", + "text": "好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147835/180.wav", + "text": "當然" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147835/181.wav", + "text": "當然你們可能是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147835/182.wav", + "text": "然後分散在不同的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147835/183.wav", + "text": "部分你的數位部編2個人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147835/184.wav", + "text": "資安署編3個人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147835/185.wav", + "text": "譬如美國資訊安全大會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147835/186.wav", + "text": "就是大家先講好了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147835/187.wav", + "text": "我們要5個人去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147835/188.wav", + "text": "預算分在兩個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147835/189.wav", + "text": "因為我這邊去2個人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147835/190.wav", + "text": "你的署裡面要去3個人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147835/191.wav", + "text": "有些是攻防" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147835/192.wav", + "text": "有些是通訊的是分開來的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147835/193.wav", + "text": "對所以大家都要一起去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147835/194.wav", + "text": "一個會議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147835/195.wav", + "text": "那坐的飛機會不會一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147835/196.wav", + "text": "當然儘可能會安排相同的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147835/197.wav", + "text": "住的飯店會不會一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147835/198.wav", + "text": "但是奇怪了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147835/199.wav", + "text": "元一個人大概3" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147835/200.wav", + "text": "如果次長級的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147835/201.wav", + "text": "差不多是這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147835/202.wav", + "text": "對一個人34萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147835/203.wav", + "text": "那你們資安署呢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147835/204.wav", + "text": "資安署的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147835/205.wav", + "text": "資安署你們一個人編多少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147835/206.wav", + "text": "111萬4,000" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147835/207.wav", + "text": "現在一個人編多少錢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147835/208.wav", + "text": "報告委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147835/209.wav", + "text": "因為我們的級別不同" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147835/210.wav", + "text": "我們大部分去的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147835/211.wav", + "text": "是你們一個人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147835/212.wav", + "text": "為什麼編37萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147835/213.wav", + "text": "比他們高3萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147835/214.wav", + "text": "哪一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147835/215.wav", + "text": "我數字都給你了啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147835/216.wav", + "text": "你們編了111.4萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147835/217.wav", + "text": "給3個人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147835/218.wav", + "text": "一個人大概37.1萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147835/219.wav", + "text": "報告委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147835/220.wav", + "text": "我們有一個主管是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147835/221.wav", + "text": "然後帶2個同仁" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147835/222.wav", + "text": "去參加這個會議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147835/223.wav", + "text": "不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147835/224.wav", + "text": "我不知道你們在做什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147835/225.wav", + "text": "大家已經很質疑" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147835/226.wav", + "text": "這個出國的事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147835/227.wav", + "text": "你們出國" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147835/228.wav", + "text": "西沒關係" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147835/229.wav", + "text": "你到時候做出來給大家看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147835/230.wav", + "text": "有出國報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147835/231.wav", + "text": "我只���在想" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147835/232.wav", + "text": "你們現在一個人去美國" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147835/233.wav", + "text": "不是80天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147835/234.wav", + "text": "什麼級的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147835/235.wav", + "text": "誰要去我不清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147835/236.wav", + "text": "可是資安署" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147835/237.wav", + "text": "總有一些比較中層的技術人員去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147835/238.wav", + "text": "我直接說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147835/239.wav", + "text": "我個人是覺得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147835/240.wav", + "text": "這個預算有點離譜" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147835/241.wav", + "text": "請問一下你們是發包" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147835/242.wav", + "text": "他們自己去報銷" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147835/243.wav", + "text": "去找一家廠商來招標" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147835/244.wav", + "text": "還是採取報銷差旅費的方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147835/245.wav", + "text": "報告委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147835/246.wav", + "text": "我們是自己買機票" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147835/247.wav", + "text": "然後自己訂住宿" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147835/248.wav", + "text": "所以是核實支付" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147835/249.wav", + "text": "就是按照他的級別" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147835/250.wav", + "text": "這是沒有任何彈性的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147835/251.wav", + "text": "就是核實支付" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147835/252.wav", + "text": "所以一個人編37" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147835/253.wav", + "text": "萬是會用完嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147835/254.wav", + "text": "我們因為有一個主管" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147835/255.wav", + "text": "帶著2個同仁一起去參加" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147835/256.wav", + "text": "所以其實主管那個部分的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147835/257.wav", + "text": "預算比較多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147835/258.wav", + "text": "因為它是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147835/259.wav", + "text": "反正我跟你講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147835/260.wav", + "text": "我已經快講不出話來了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147835/261.wav", + "text": "因為就我個人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147835/262.wav", + "text": "我在鄉鎮市公所" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147835/263.wav", + "text": "編過類似的預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147835/264.wav", + "text": "好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147835/265.wav", + "text": "如果去美國" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147835/266.wav", + "text": "一個人編十幾萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147835/267.wav", + "text": "就要被罵一整天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147835/268.wav", + "text": "了我們在議會也待過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147835/269.wav", + "text": "去美國8" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147835/270.wav", + "text": "8天說真的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147835/271.wav", + "text": "可能坐個商務艙" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147835/272.wav", + "text": "大概15萬18萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147835/273.wav", + "text": "20萬以內" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147835/274.wav", + "text": "你現在一個人編37" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147835/275.wav", + "text": "我們要你們去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147835/276.wav", + "text": "不是去玩的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147835/277.wav", + "text": "對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147835/278.wav", + "text": "不是要去五星級" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147835/279.wav", + "text": "六星級飯店的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147835/280.wav", + "text": "是要你們帶腦袋去吸收回來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147835/281.wav", + "text": "所以我想說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147835/282.wav", + "text": "你們有些部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147835/283.wav", + "text": "嘛要學習這麼多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147835/284.wav", + "text": "3到5人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147835/285.wav", + "text": "去把它學回來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147835/286.wav", + "text": "在我們數位部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147835/287.wav", + "text": "在我們署裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147835/288.wav", + "text": "做一個教學" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147835/289.wav", + "text": "嘛你們一次去十五六人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147835/290.wav", + "text": "花了國家這麼多預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147835/291.wav", + "text": "你不要怪別人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147835/292.wav", + "text": "我想要先感謝委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147835/293.wav", + "text": "其實很公允" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147835/294.wav", + "text": "啦就是包含種子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147835/295.wav", + "text": "這樣的作用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147835/296.wav", + "text": "我們當然是實報實支" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147835/297.wav", + "text": "不管是機票因為燃油" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147835/298.wav", + "text": "或什麼關係" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147835/299.wav", + "text": "而變多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147835/300.wav", + "text": "或者到最後因為匯率而變少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147835/301.wav", + "text": "這個都會按照實際的狀況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147835/302.wav", + "text": "來核銷" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147835/303.wav", + "text": "得讓一般民眾" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147835/304.wav", + "text": "真的沒辦法接受" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147835/305.wav", + "text": "要33萬到37萬去8天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147835/306.wav", + "text": "美國旅遊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147835/307.wav", + "text": "現在我想不管" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147835/308.wav", + "text": "各黨派大家聽到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147835/309.wav", + "text": "我覺得你們要回去好好檢討" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147835/310.wav", + "text": "我出去是絕對不會旅遊的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147835/311.wav", + "text": "至於細項的編列標準" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147835/312.wav", + "text": "我們再以書面回復委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147835/313.wav", + "text": "好謝謝魯委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147834/0.wav", + "text": "主席請部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147834/1.wav", + "text": "委員好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147834/2.wav", + "text": "部長你號稱是民進黨政府裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147834/3.wav", + "text": "最聰明的部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147834/4.wav", + "text": "是不是唯一聰明的部長我們再來請教一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147834/5.wav", + "text": "這一年多來數位部成立到現在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147834/6.wav", + "text": "你覺得到現在成績如何" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147834/7.wav", + "text": "是謝謝委員讓我們有機會說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147834/8.wav", + "text": "我想不管是發放6,000元相當順利" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147834/9.wav", + "text": "或者是引進OneWeb低軌衛星等等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147834/10.wav", + "text": "我想大家都有看到我們對於建��韌性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147834/11.wav", + "text": "（Resilience）是有幫助" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147834/12.wav", + "text": "所以你對你自評的成績是滿意的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147834/13.wav", + "text": "本席讓你看一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147834/14.wav", + "text": "草根影響力文教基金會發布" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147834/15.wav", + "text": "對於政府打詐騙的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147834/16.wav", + "text": "不滿意高達53%" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147834/17.wav", + "text": "這是5月5號的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147834/18.wav", + "text": "好再過來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147834/19.wav", + "text": "8月23號" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147834/20.wav", + "text": "八宇國際股份有限公司所做的網路民意調查結果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147834/21.wav", + "text": "對於臺灣詐騙事件是否已經有改善" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147834/22.wav", + "text": "不同意占72%" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147834/23.wav", + "text": "對於假消息假新聞是否有改善" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147834/24.wav", + "text": "不同意占70%" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147834/25.wav", + "text": "\n唐部長現在民間對您最大的印象" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147834/26.wav", + "text": "對大家最大的幫忙就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147834/27.wav", + "text": "要點餐的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147834/28.wav", + "text": "要點麵線的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147834/29.wav", + "text": "第一個會想到我們數位部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147834/30.wav", + "text": "你這個成效卓著\n" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147834/31.wav", + "text": "接下來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147834/32.wav", + "text": "我們看一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147834/33.wav", + "text": "您就職到現在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147834/34.wav", + "text": "我們的詐騙案到底是增加還是減少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147834/35.wav", + "text": "從109年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147834/36.wav", + "text": "110年2萬4,000件" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147834/37.wav", + "text": "111年成立數位部以後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147834/38.wav", + "text": "今年1到7月已經有1萬9,000" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147834/39.wav", + "text": "等於是2萬件" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147834/40.wav", + "text": "了跟去年同期比" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147834/41.wav", + "text": "去年才1萬6,000件" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147834/42.wav", + "text": "今年到現在已經有2萬件" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147834/43.wav", + "text": "受害人數" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147834/44.wav", + "text": "都不斷地往上提升" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147834/45.wav", + "text": "部長有什麼看法沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147834/46.wav", + "text": "謝謝委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147834/47.wav", + "text": "我想自從打詐五法通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147834/48.wav", + "text": "以及個資法罰則加重" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147834/49.wav", + "text": "就我們所主管的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147834/50.wav", + "text": "包含綜合性電商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147834/51.wav", + "text": "包含遊戲點數的詐騙" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147834/52.wav", + "text": "也從單月1,500件" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147834/53.wav", + "text": "降到600件上下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147834/54.wav", + "text": "甚至還不到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147834/55.wav", + "text": "由我們主管的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147834/56.wav", + "text": "當然有一些改善" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147834/57.wav", + "text": "但是當然就如同委員所指出的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147834/58.wav", + "text": "有更多的我們可以來防堵" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147834/59.wav", + "text": "跟防阻的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147834/60.wav", + "text": "我們國家整體的詐騙案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147834/61.wav", + "text": "還不斷地往上攀升" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147834/62.wav", + "text": "國家推出數位部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147834/63.wav", + "text": "叫打詐國家隊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147834/64.wav", + "text": "結果這個打詐國家隊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147834/65.wav", + "text": "出來以後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147834/66.wav", + "text": "詐騙案是越加的猖狂" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147834/67.wav", + "text": "表示第一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147834/68.wav", + "text": "你們被看破手腳" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147834/69.wav", + "text": "第二個你們能力不足" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147834/70.wav", + "text": "集團雨後春筍的成立" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147834/71.wav", + "text": "因為現在是最適合詐騙的年代" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147834/72.wav", + "text": "現在不只詐騙集團到處廣布" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147834/73.wav", + "text": "現在也往下扎根" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147834/74.wav", + "text": "了年輕的孩子們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147834/75.wav", + "text": "被拉到詐騙集團的比比皆是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147834/76.wav", + "text": "我們實在是覺得我們的國家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147834/77.wav", + "text": "竟然防詐的能力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147834/78.wav", + "text": "還比不上詐騙集團成長的能力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147834/79.wav", + "text": "所以詐騙數不斷地在增加" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147834/80.wav", + "text": "本席再請教一下部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147834/81.wav", + "text": "您認為現在詐騙案的刑責夠重嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147834/82.wav", + "text": "自從打詐五法把它加重之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147834/83.wav", + "text": "特別是個資法修法之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147834/84.wav", + "text": "關於業者的連帶責任" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147834/85.wav", + "text": "特別像臉書這樣的業者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147834/86.wav", + "text": "或者是說我們所主管的綜合性電商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147834/87.wav", + "text": "這部分都有相當的加重" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147834/88.wav", + "text": "所以現在的刑責你滿意嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147834/89.wav", + "text": "可以遏制詐騙集團再增加嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147834/90.wav", + "text": "以我們所主管綜合性電商來講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147834/91.wav", + "text": "我想剛剛也有委員質詢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147834/92.wav", + "text": "滿清楚的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147834/93.wav", + "text": "就是最重能夠罰到1,500萬之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147834/94.wav", + "text": "他們配合包含像導入隱碼技術" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147834/95.wav", + "text": "等等的意願都大幅提高" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147834/96.wav", + "text": "好本席暫且相信您今天所提到的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147834/97.wav", + "text": "我要特別在這裡強調" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147834/98.wav", + "text": "本席叫什麼名字你知道嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147834/99.wav", + "text": "滿資深的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147834/100.wav", + "text": "當然啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147834/101.wav", + "text": "好數位部在成立以前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147834/102.wav", + "text": "關係到本人利用本人的詐騙案還沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147834/103.wav", + "text": "數位部成立以後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147834/104.wav", + "text": "最近連我的臉書都被詐騙集團" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147834/105.wav", + "text": "本席真的認為我們數位部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147834/106.wav", + "text": "連立法委員的臉書都被盜用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147834/107.wav", + "text": "可見詐騙集團有多麼看不起數位部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147834/108.wav", + "text": "我們有報警" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147834/109.wav", + "text": "後來他們撤掉了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147834/110.wav", + "text": "我們去抓人了以後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147834/111.wav", + "text": "他就開始撤掉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147834/112.wav", + "text": "所以本席在這裡讓你了解" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147834/113.wav", + "text": "連傅崐萁都被詐騙集團盜用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147834/114.wav", + "text": "何況我們一般基層的這些小老百姓" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147834/115.wav", + "text": "要如何相信什麼是真什麼是假" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147834/116.wav", + "text": "\n本席再請教一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147834/117.wav", + "text": "明年我們預算是多少錢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147834/118.wav", + "text": "以公務預算是從57億成長到73億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147834/119.wav", + "text": "73億好謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147834/120.wav", + "text": "你們出國預算是多少錢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147834/121.wav", + "text": "應該是0.5億吧就是加起來1部2" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147834/122.wav", + "text": "0.5億5,000萬好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147834/123.wav", + "text": "那比例是多少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147834/124.wav", + "text": "是千分之" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147834/125.wav", + "text": "本席幫你算過了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147834/126.wav", + "text": "我們看一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147834/127.wav", + "text": "國防部是千分之零點三五" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147834/128.wav", + "text": "農業部是千分之零點四" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147834/129.wav", + "text": "四四經濟部是千分之零點二一" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147834/130.wav", + "text": "本席滿好奇的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147834/131.wav", + "text": "你們是千分之七" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147834/132.wav", + "text": "這個數字有打錯了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147834/133.wav", + "text": "國防部應該是千分之" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147834/134.wav", + "text": "你們是千分之七" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147834/135.wav", + "text": "本席設想一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147834/136.wav", + "text": "有什麼樣的定期會議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147834/137.wav", + "text": "你們非得一定要到歐洲" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147834/138.wav", + "text": "歐洲來回要幾個小時你知道嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147834/139.wav", + "text": "如果是直飛的話10個小時左右" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147834/140.wav", + "text": "剛好那個地方有直飛嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147834/141.wav", + "text": "臺灣的飛機有這麼順暢嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147834/142.wav", + "text": "委員您的第一欄這邊的分母" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147834/143.wav", + "text": "您可以看到我們在14個部裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147834/144.wav", + "text": "公務預算是排名最後的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147834/145.wav", + "text": "所以光是這個位數就跟人家差了2個位數" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147834/146.wav", + "text": "所以嘛部長你又講對了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147834/147.wav", + "text": "你這麼少的預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147834/148.wav", + "text": "卻要用這麼高的比例去出國" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147834/149.wav", + "text": "本席請教一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147834/150.wav", + "text": "國防部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147834/151.wav", + "text": "關係國家安全這麼重大的事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147834/152.wav", + "text": "很多都必須要面對面談的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147834/153.wav", + "text": "整個國防部才千分之零點三五的出國預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147834/154.wav", + "text": "這真的是要笑死人了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147834/155.wav", + "text": "並不是這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147834/156.wav", + "text": "國防部有多少事情要面談" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147834/157.wav", + "text": "要飛到其他國家去為了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147834/158.wav", + "text": "國防機密要直接面談的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147834/159.wav", + "text": "才千分之零點三五" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147834/160.wav", + "text": "你們是千分之七" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147834/161.wav", + "text": "現在網路要認證要簽約" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147834/162.wav", + "text": "要支付統統沒有問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147834/163.wav", + "text": "你們數位部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147834/164.wav", + "text": "竟然1年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147834/165.wav", + "text": "本席看你們應該改個名字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147834/166.wav", + "text": "叫郊遊旅遊部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147834/167.wav", + "text": "出差旅遊部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147834/168.wav", + "text": "請問一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147834/169.wav", + "text": "現在數位部還在石器時代嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147834/170.wav", + "text": "可以回答了嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147834/171.wav", + "text": "石器時代嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147834/172.wav", + "text": "你請回答" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147834/173.wav", + "text": "我們今年所編列的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147834/174.wav", + "text": "跟明年相比多出來的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147834/175.wav", + "text": "是因為經貿談判裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147834/176.wav", + "text": "APEC臺歐臺美等等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147834/177.wav", + "text": "這些從別的部會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147834/178.wav", + "text": "移撥或部分移撥到本部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147834/179.wav", + "text": "所以這本來就是要當場" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147834/180.wav", + "text": "去進行談判的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147834/181.wav", + "text": "那資安當然也必須要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147834/182.wav", + "text": "面對面地去討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147834/183.wav", + "text": "資安要面對面地討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147834/184.wav", + "text": "因為現在是摩登原始人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147834/185.wav", + "text": "連飛鴿傳書都用不到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147834/186.wav", + "text": "演訓攻防" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147834/187.wav", + "text": "要面對面去談" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147834/188.wav", + "text": "又有一些像國際的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147834/189.wav", + "text": "像我最近自費出席" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147834/190.wav", + "text": "這部分雖然我是自費" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147834/191.wav", + "text": "但是在那上面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147834/192.wav", + "text": "如果實體去的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147834/193.wav", + "text": "也可以見到一百零多國的代表" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147834/194.wav", + "text": "唐部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147834/195.wav", + "text": "您聽說是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147834/196.wav", + "text": "現在行政院智慧最高" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147834/197.wav", + "text": "最聰明的部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147834/198.wav", + "text": "沒有想到現在任何事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147834/199.wav", + "text": "你們還是要面對面去談" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147834/200.wav", + "text": "現在線上的會議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147834/201.wav", + "text": "已經是全世界的普羅共識了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147834/202.wav", + "text": "還要飛這麼遠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147834/203.wav", + "text": "本席幫你算過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147834/204.wav", + "text": "待轉機來回要40個小時" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147834/205.wav", + "text": "我們一定要去歐洲郊遊嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147834/206.wav", + "text": "要去旅遊嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147834/207.wav", + "text": "不是郊遊而是進行經貿談判跟資安的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147834/208.wav", + "text": "經貿談判" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147834/209.wav", + "text": "經濟部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147834/210.wav", + "text": "好你講到經貿談判" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147834/211.wav", + "text": "經濟部占的比例有多少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147834/212.wav", + "text": "我們國家的經濟什麼時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147834/213.wav", + "text": "輪到你們在談判" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147834/214.wav", + "text": "因為我們現在剛好就是在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147834/215.wav", + "text": "數位貿易的談判唐部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147834/216.wav", + "text": "本席再問你最後一個問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147834/217.wav", + "text": "特別多的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147834/218.wav", + "text": "明年用在花東地區" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147834/219.wav", + "text": "花蓮臺東地區" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147834/220.wav", + "text": "你們大概的補助款還是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147834/221.wav", + "text": "預算編列是多少錢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147834/222.wav", + "text": "以我所知在我們普及服務基金" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147834/223.wav", + "text": "以及其他的相關基金部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147834/224.wav", + "text": "都有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147834/225.wav", + "text": "那您這邊列出來的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147834/226.wav", + "text": "應該是花東基金這一類的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147834/227.wav", + "text": "所以不能只看這一張表" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147834/228.wav", + "text": "我的意思是這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147834/229.wav", + "text": "本席現在看到的是零" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147834/230.wav", + "text": "花蓮是零" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147834/231.wav", + "text": "臺東是零" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147834/232.wav", + "text": "這不是花東基金" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147834/233.wav", + "text": "這是你們的總預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147834/234.wav", + "text": "你回去看一下你們的預算書" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147834/235.wav", + "text": "本��還會再碰到你" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147834/236.wav", + "text": "你回去看清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147834/237.wav", + "text": "謝謝傅崐萁委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147834/238.wav", + "text": "謝謝部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147833/0.wav", + "text": "謝謝主席麻煩請一下副部長好嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147833/1.wav", + "text": "軍備局謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147833/2.wav", + "text": "柏副辛苦了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147833/3.wav", + "text": "不會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147833/4.wav", + "text": "今天早上還是很多人來關心前陣子宜蘭賞鯨船的意外" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147833/5.wav", + "text": "我的觀點不在於責任的歸屬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147833/6.wav", + "text": "我倒是想要知道一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147833/7.wav", + "text": "軍備局的規格鑑測中心兵器試驗場對海空實彈射擊的報告單中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147833/8.wav", + "text": "有提到分送單位總共有39個以上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147833/9.wav", + "text": "這些單位都是一律放在一起一起發送出去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147833/10.wav", + "text": "我為什麼這樣問" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147833/11.wav", + "text": "第一個這是東北角宜蘭的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147833/12.wav", + "text": "但是你們也發到高雄市海洋局" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147833/13.wav", + "text": "為什麼要發到高雄市海洋局" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147833/14.wav", + "text": "那個砲彈會飛到高雄嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147833/15.wav", + "text": "不是所有的船都要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147833/16.wav", + "text": "跟委員報告我們發的是主管單位所有的船隻" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147833/17.wav", + "text": "好那我問一下是不是每一次都會針對這39個單位都一起發" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147833/18.wav", + "text": "好那我再請教一下為什麼只針對漁船" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147833/19.wav", + "text": "商船" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147833/20.wav", + "text": "或者未來還有郵輪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147833/21.wav", + "text": "或者還有遊艇" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147833/22.wav", + "text": "請問你要發給哪個單位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147833/23.wav", + "text": "是哪個單位在管理這些的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147833/24.wav", + "text": "這次不就是出現這樣的疏漏嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147833/25.wav", + "text": "因為你們那邊也請漁業電台要發布" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147833/26.wav", + "text": "漁業電台發布是針對海上作業的漁船" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147833/27.wav", + "text": "除了漁船以外還有那麼多船" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147833/28.wav", + "text": "有沒有狀況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147833/29.wav", + "text": "也就是說你們在不管是聯合偵監的系統裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147833/30.wav", + "text": "你們疏忽了現在在海面上作業的船隻" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147833/31.wav", + "text": "不會只有漁船" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147833/32.wav", + "text": "還有商船有娛樂用的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147833/33.wav", + "text": "有遊艇" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147833/34.wav", + "text": "然後你也知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147833/35.wav", + "text": "最近我們跟沖繩那邊也會有郵輪互相往來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147833/36.wav", + "text": "出了什麼狀況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147833/37.wav", + "text": "跟委員報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147833/38.wav", + "text": "我們所有公告在網站上面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147833/39.wav", + "text": "的都是公開的資訊這個都可以看到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147833/40.wav", + "text": "我知道我在問你說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147833/41.wav", + "text": "這三四十個就是一個統一的格式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147833/42.wav", + "text": "只要每一次有任何試驗場域的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147833/43.wav", + "text": "你就全臺灣各地全部一起發嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147833/44.wav", + "text": "但是我就問你海上作業的船隻" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147833/45.wav", + "text": "不是只有漁船還有娛樂用船啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147833/46.wav", + "text": "還有遊艇還有郵輪啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147833/47.wav", + "text": "還有其他的啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147833/48.wav", + "text": "海上作業的船隻非常多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147833/49.wav", + "text": "所以這個疏漏其實必須要好好的檢討不是嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147833/50.wav", + "text": "報告委員你所提到的這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147833/51.wav", + "text": "我們國防部也在看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147833/52.wav", + "text": "從委員剛才所講的39個單位夠不夠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147833/53.wav", + "text": "但據我所知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147833/54.wav", + "text": "像這樣一個區域的砲彈射擊的資料" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147833/55.wav", + "text": "事實上應該是在所有的海域" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147833/56.wav", + "text": "所以不是你們的錯" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147833/57.wav", + "text": "你們有通知但是這個賞鯨船" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147833/58.wav", + "text": "因為這個已經進入到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147833/59.wav", + "text": "我在這邊不再做評論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147833/60.wav", + "text": "但將來我們會修法的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147833/61.wav", + "text": "事實上已經提到法的位階了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147833/62.wav", + "text": "可能會在哪裡發生這樣的情況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147833/63.wav", + "text": "我們都必須要詳實檢討" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147833/64.wav", + "text": "麻煩一下好嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147833/65.wav", + "text": "因為未來只會多不會少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147833/66.wav", + "text": "包括整個臺灣海峽" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147833/67.wav", + "text": "商船等等經過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147833/68.wav", + "text": "但是產生這樣的意外" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147833/69.wav", + "text": "坦白講整個周末大家都揑了一大把冷汗" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147833/70.wav", + "text": "賞鯨船三四十個人好嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147833/71.wav", + "text": "再來有關義務役提繳退休金的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147833/72.wav", + "text": "本其實都一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147833/73.wav", + "text": "我搞不清楚為什麼他們再重新提" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147833/74.wav", + "text": "我倒是想知道一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147833/75.wav", + "text": "義務役所提繳的所需經費" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147833/76.wav", + "text": "是由公務預算來支應還是預備金" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147833/77.wav", + "text": "尤其是第一年的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147833/78.wav", + "text": "好麻煩一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147833/79.wav", + "text": "它是由各主辦機關編列公務預算來支應" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147833/80.wav", + "text": "包括第一年開始嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147833/81.wav", + "text": "是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147833/82.wav", + "text": "那第一年開始現在來得及嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147833/83.wav", + "text": "我們已經有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147833/84.wav", + "text": "是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147833/85.wav", + "text": "已經列進去你保證百分之百都通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147833/86.wav", + "text": "對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147833/87.wav", + "text": "是不是這樣子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147833/88.wav", + "text": "所需的增列預算大概是1.5億元左右" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147833/89.wav", + "text": "是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147833/90.wav", + "text": "那入營的役男估計是9,127員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147833/91.wav", + "text": "員這個部分是從什麼時候開始" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147833/92.wav", + "text": "趕快入營的話會更好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147833/93.wav", + "text": "是不是這樣子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147833/94.wav", + "text": "113年1月25號會有第一批的役男進來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147833/95.wav", + "text": "就是明年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147833/96.wav", + "text": "就會有第一批進來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147833/97.wav", + "text": "所以國防部都準備好了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147833/98.wav", + "text": "是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147833/99.wav", + "text": "還包括營舍" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147833/100.wav", + "text": "還是跟以前一樣要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147833/101.wav", + "text": "報告委員我們這些東西" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147833/102.wav", + "text": "都按照我們計畫管制行程來做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147833/103.wav", + "text": "跟國人說明我們整備的狀況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147833/104.wav", + "text": "從這個禮拜開始" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147833/105.wav", + "text": "必須要了解的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147833/106.wav", + "text": "和我們未來準備的方向" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147833/107.wav", + "text": "我想" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147833/108.wav", + "text": "我們現在都準備好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147833/109.wav", + "text": "只是等到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147833/110.wav", + "text": "明年1月份的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147833/111.wav", + "text": "當第一批役男進來時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147833/112.wav", + "text": "那些人就好像是我們的檢查者一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147833/113.wav", + "text": "來檢視我們到底做得好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147833/114.wav", + "text": "這些我們國防部在目前來講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147833/115.wav", + "text": "我們都" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147833/116.wav", + "text": "好那我再請教一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147833/117.wav", + "text": "你們16號的時候表示" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147833/118.wav", + "text": "一年期義務役男" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147833/119.wav", + "text": "以分發本外島及中樞防衛的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147833/120.wav", + "text": "守備部隊為主" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147833/121.wav", + "text": "守備部隊做什麼事" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147833/122.wav", + "text": "10月16號你們的新聞稿" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147833/123.wav", + "text": "您說那個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147833/124.wav", + "text": "新聞稿" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147833/125.wav", + "text": "一年期的義務役" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147833/126.wav", + "text": "役還是以守備部隊為主" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147833/127.wav", + "text": "守備部隊也包括本島外島跟中樞" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147833/128.wav", + "text": "當然當然我剛剛有強調說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147833/129.wav", + "text": "他可以依照其志願" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147833/130.wav", + "text": "我可以依照他的選項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147833/131.wav", + "text": "但是他去必須要依照他的專長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147833/132.wav", + "text": "比如他高專長的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147833/133.wav", + "text": "我們都會在每周的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147833/134.wav", + "text": "例行記者會上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147833/135.wav", + "text": "跟所有役男來做說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147833/136.wav", + "text": "好我再請教一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147833/137.wav", + "text": "我們也有立委提案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147833/138.wav", + "text": "邀中國校友來臺唱" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147833/139.wav", + "text": "以正視聽" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147833/140.wav", + "text": "我想請教一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147833/141.wav", + "text": "在中國大陸還有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147833/142.wav", + "text": "活著的黃埔軍校校友嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147833/143.wav", + "text": "我不是指他的子孫還有嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147833/144.wav", + "text": "我不知道請陸軍官校回答" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147833/145.wav", + "text": "黃埔軍校遷到臺灣來已經多久" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147833/146.wav", + "text": "了遷到鳳山多久了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147833/147.wav", + "text": "報告委員有關於" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147833/148.wav", + "text": "我問你黃埔軍校遷到臺灣來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147833/149.wav", + "text": "有多久了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147833/150.wav", + "text": "38年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147833/151.wav", + "text": "38年過來不是嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147833/152.wav", + "text": "38年到現在多久了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147833/153.wav", + "text": "你加加減減就知道了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147833/154.wav", + "text": "七十多年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147833/155.wav", + "text": "七十多年現在還有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147833/156.wav", + "text": "活著的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147833/157.wav", + "text": "正宗的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147833/158.wav", + "text": "當時在中國大陸的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147833/159.wav", + "text": "黃埔軍校的正統校友嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147833/160.wav", + "text": "據瞭解是有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147833/161.wav", + "text": "還是有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147833/162.wav", + "text": "中華民國黃埔軍校" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147833/163.wav", + "text": "邀請他來臺灣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147833/164.wav", + "text": "然後聽我們唱中華民國國歌" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147833/165.wav", + "text": "然後再唱黃埔軍校校歌" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147833/166.wav", + "text": "他們願意來嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147833/167.wav", + "text": "我跟委員報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147833/168.wav", + "text": "我們軍校也是軍事營區" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147833/169.wav", + "text": "港澳陸籍人士" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147833/170.wav", + "text": "是不可以進入營區" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147833/171.wav", + "text": "所以跟以正視聽沒有關係" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147833/172.wav", + "text": "而且他如果願意來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147833/173.wav", + "text": "回去的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147833/174.wav", + "text": "等於就是會被判刑不是嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147833/175.wav", + "text": "到這個地方來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147833/176.wav", + "text": "他們效忠的是中華人民共和國" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147833/177.wav", + "text": "不是效忠中華民國" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147833/178.wav", + "text": "這是一個很奇特的提案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147833/179.wav", + "text": "但是我是覺得蠻有趣的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147833/180.wav", + "text": "我們可以再繼續看一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147833/181.wav", + "text": "這變成是兩軍" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147833/182.wav", + "text": "來互相交流" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147833/183.wav", + "text": "這不是邀他們來唱卡拉OK" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147833/184.wav", + "text": "要看清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147833/185.wav", + "text": "而且是我們國軍" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147833/186.wav", + "text": "就像你講的黃埔軍校" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147833/187.wav", + "text": "現在也是等於軍事營區" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147833/188.wav", + "text": "也許他現在還是人民解放軍的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147833/189.wav", + "text": "高級幹部也不一定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147833/190.wav", + "text": "就到我們營區來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147833/191.wav", + "text": "這不是很莫名其妙" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147833/192.wav", + "text": "所以這個提案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147833/193.wav", + "text": "可能我們要好好來看一下好嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147833/194.wav", + "text": "好謝謝委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147832/0.wav", + "text": "謝謝主席" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147832/1.wav", + "text": "有請國家公園署" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147832/2.wav", + "text": "有請國家公園署" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147832/3.wav", + "text": "署長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147832/4.wav", + "text": "委員好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147832/5.wav", + "text": "署長您好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147832/6.wav", + "text": "我們是109年開放山林對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147832/7.wav", + "text": "對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147832/8.wav", + "text": "那您覺得開放山林之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147832/9.wav", + "text": "是不是會增加" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147832/10.wav", + "text": "確實增加非常多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147832/11.wav", + "text": "因為剛好那時候碰到疫情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147832/12.wav", + "text": "所以國內這些喜愛山林的人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147832/13.wav", + "text": "巔峰時是在111（" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147832/14.wav", + "text": "真的署長你有看這個資料" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147832/15.wav", + "text": "講得很精準" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147832/16.wav", + "text": "確實開放山林之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147832/17.wav", + "text": "從過去平均" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147832/18.wav", + "text": "每年一百零多件" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147832/19.wav", + "text": "突然暴增到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147832/20.wav", + "text": "109年的六百多件" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147832/21.wav", + "text": "110年有六百多件" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147832/22.wav", + "text": "去年達到高峰802件" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147832/23.wav", + "text": "我看到這些違規的類型" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147832/24.wav", + "text": "很多屬於" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147832/25.wav", + "text": "到核准區���外的地區" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147832/26.wav", + "text": "搭帳篷" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147832/27.wav", + "text": "進入公告禁止的區域" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147832/28.wav", + "text": "進入生態保育區" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147832/29.wav", + "text": "遙控機具或者是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147832/30.wav", + "text": "燃放煙火" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147832/31.wav", + "text": "關於山屋的整體改善計畫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147832/32.wav", + "text": "是有的對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147832/33.wav", + "text": "跟委員報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147832/34.wav", + "text": "針對山屋的改善計畫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147832/35.wav", + "text": "我們的山屋總共有31座" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147832/36.wav", + "text": "排雲山莊早就好了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147832/37.wav", + "text": "有30座行政院也非常重視" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147832/38.wav", + "text": "到目前為止" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147832/39.wav", + "text": "我們大概已經完成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147832/40.wav", + "text": "整建的有17座" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147832/41.wav", + "text": "還有8座" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147832/42.wav", + "text": "新建的也完成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147832/43.wav", + "text": "了大概到明年底最後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147832/44.wav", + "text": "最後往雪山方向的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147832/45.wav", + "text": "三六九山屋" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147832/46.wav", + "text": "應該全部就可以完成了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147832/47.wav", + "text": "請教一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147832/48.wav", + "text": "我看到你們在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147832/49.wav", + "text": "辦理國家公園山屋" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147832/50.wav", + "text": "整體改善計畫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147832/51.wav", + "text": "是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147832/52.wav", + "text": "請問一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147832/53.wav", + "text": "實際施作的經費要多少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147832/54.wav", + "text": "因為這是業務費" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147832/55.wav", + "text": "跟委員報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147832/56.wav", + "text": "我剛剛提到的從過去以來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147832/57.wav", + "text": "我們大概要花三億多的經費" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147832/58.wav", + "text": "就是剛剛講的這30座" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147832/59.wav", + "text": "等於是明年度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147832/60.wav", + "text": "明年度可能不只喔" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147832/61.wav", + "text": "應該三六九山屋就要付掉700多萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147832/62.wav", + "text": "你們的預算書是這麼寫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147832/63.wav", + "text": "好我等一下再看一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147832/64.wav", + "text": "到底有什麼問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147832/65.wav", + "text": "跟委員報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147832/66.wav", + "text": "是執行的業務費" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147832/67.wav", + "text": "工程費是另外的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147832/68.wav", + "text": "是啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147832/69.wav", + "text": "我知道那是業務費" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147832/70.wav", + "text": "所以我想問" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147832/71.wav", + "text": "你們實際施作的經費內容" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147832/72.wav", + "text": "我看不到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147832/73.wav", + "text": "大概是700多萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147832/74.wav", + "text": "那當然是整個施工所需要的費用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147832/75.wav", + "text": "我先請教一下署長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147832/76.wav", + "text": "您認為興建山屋" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147832/77.wav", + "text": "它最大的功能是什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147832/78.wav", + "text": "當然是可以提供" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147832/79.wav", + "text": "我們國人到山上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147832/80.wav", + "text": "有一個很安全的住宿環境" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147832/81.wav", + "text": "所以就是減少山難的意思" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147832/82.wav", + "text": "對對對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147832/83.wav", + "text": "所以很重要嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147832/84.wav", + "text": "是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147832/85.wav", + "text": "對於這些山友來講很重要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147832/86.wav", + "text": "是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147832/87.wav", + "text": "對原住民來講重不重要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147832/88.wav", + "text": "也是很重要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147832/89.wav", + "text": "重要在哪裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147832/90.wav", + "text": "我們可以分享到什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147832/91.wav", + "text": "委員是不是想提到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147832/92.wav", + "text": "大同大禮部落的這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147832/93.wav", + "text": "我是想要瞭解" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147832/94.wav", + "text": "它其實是一個友善的概念" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147832/95.wav", + "text": "跟當地的環境友善" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147832/96.wav", + "text": "跟當地的人友善" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147832/97.wav", + "text": "山林共管" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147832/98.wav", + "text": "但是我們感受不到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147832/99.wav", + "text": "啊舉個例子來講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147832/100.wav", + "text": "我之前也質詢過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147832/101.wav", + "text": "我希望能夠有登山基地" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147832/102.wav", + "text": "是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147832/103.wav", + "text": "有了嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147832/104.wav", + "text": "我們之前在太魯閣是有設立登山學校" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147832/105.wav", + "text": "我之前質詢過蘇貞昌院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147832/106.wav", + "text": "啊我想要了解" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147832/107.wav", + "text": "到底有沒有規劃" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147832/108.wav", + "text": "還是質詢完了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147832/109.wav", + "text": "允諾了後面就忘記了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147832/110.wav", + "text": "對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147832/111.wav", + "text": "太管處的那個是什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147832/112.wav", + "text": "奇萊山的那個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147832/113.wav", + "text": "今年6月" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147832/114.wav", + "text": "還用直升機" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147832/115.wav", + "text": "吊那些建材" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147832/116.wav", + "text": "是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147832/117.wav", + "text": "今年6月" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147832/118.wav", + "text": "那個已經完成了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147832/119.wav", + "text": "對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147832/120.wav", + "text": "啊花了多少錢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147832/121.wav", + "text": "大概100多萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147832/122.wav", + "text": "所以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147832/123.wav", + "text": "啊玉山國家公園的新觀高山屋" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147832/124.wav", + "text": "1005百多萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147832/125.wav", + "text": "這是明年的預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147832/126.wav", + "text": "是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147832/127.wav", + "text": "你剛剛講的三六九" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147832/128.wav", + "text": "對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147832/129.wav", + "text": "那登山基地呢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147832/130.wav", + "text": "署長是這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147832/131.wav", + "text": "這好像是做一個規劃" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147832/132.wav", + "text": "那就很慘啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147832/133.wav", + "text": "這是去年3月的質詢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147832/134.wav", + "text": "去年3月質詢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147832/135.wav", + "text": "今年還在規劃" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147832/136.wav", + "text": "也看不到預算的編列" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147832/137.wav", + "text": "表示根本不當一回事" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147832/138.wav", + "text": "不會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147832/139.wav", + "text": "我要怎麼知道你們很重視" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147832/140.wav", + "text": "我接下來要講的署長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147832/141.wav", + "text": "您剛剛講對了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147832/142.wav", + "text": "的今年4月" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147832/143.wav", + "text": "張景森政委也開了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147832/144.wav", + "text": "副本也給我了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147832/145.wav", + "text": "你們已經開了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147832/146.wav", + "text": "輔導在地原住民那些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147832/147.wav", + "text": "已經離開的部落" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147832/148.wav", + "text": "被政府遷村留下來的那些房子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147832/149.wav", + "text": "請你們輔導它民宿化" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147832/150.wav", + "text": "它就是現成的山屋啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147832/151.wav", + "text": "為什麼要花一億多蓋呢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147832/152.wav", + "text": "這可能跟這些地點也有關係" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147832/153.wav", + "text": "但我跟委員報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147832/154.wav", + "text": "委員所關心的這個案子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147832/155.wav", + "text": "我也有特別留意了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147832/156.wav", + "text": "在國家公園裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147832/157.wav", + "text": "原住民部落可以做民宿" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147832/158.wav", + "text": "大概就是只有大同大禮部落而已" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147832/159.wav", + "text": "其他的大概也" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147832/160.wav", + "text": "不好意思" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147832/161.wav", + "text": "很多地方" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147832/162.wav", + "text": "喔舊好茶也很多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147832/163.wav", + "text": "喔很多人到那邊登山" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147832/164.wav", + "text": "我知道的很多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147832/165.wav", + "text": "啊我們都可以把它輔導" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147832/166.wav", + "text": "變山屋" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147832/167.wav", + "text": "嘛因為很多遊客去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147832/168.wav", + "text": "啊我可以介紹很多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147832/169.wav", + "text": "可以來我辦公室" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147832/170.wav", + "text": "我介紹很多的點給各位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147832/171.wav", + "text": "好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147832/172.wav", + "text": "你們來編列經費好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147832/173.wav", + "text": "署長其實我要表達的只是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147832/174.wav", + "text": "山林共管" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147832/175.wav", + "text": "要考慮到當地人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147832/176.wav", + "text": "當地人不是只有收到垃圾" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147832/177.wav", + "text": "你知道嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147832/178.wav", + "text": "登山客不買東西的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147832/179.wav", + "text": "很環保的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147832/180.wav", + "text": "只有帶來什麼呢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147832/181.wav", + "text": "他們的垃圾" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147832/182.wav", + "text": "帶來他們的腳蹤碳足" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147832/183.wav", + "text": "是這個我們會來做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147832/184.wav", + "text": "啦也跟委員特別報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147832/185.wav", + "text": "瞭解" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147832/186.wav", + "text": "像我在雪霸的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147832/187.wav", + "text": "就是從我最早開始的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147832/188.wav", + "text": "所以我是相當地重視" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147832/189.wav", + "text": "是所以我就是最後要講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147832/190.wav", + "text": "您做過很多管理處的處長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147832/191.wav", + "text": "你應該很明白" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147832/192.wav", + "text": "是不是可以好好地" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147832/193.wav", + "text": "至少讓我安心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147832/194.wav", + "text": "嘛我可以跟族人交代好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147832/195.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147832/196.wav", + "text": "不要讓我的質詢落空" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147832/197.wav", + "text": "嘛人家院長也答應過我" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147832/198.wav", + "text": "好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147832/199.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147832/200.wav", + "text": "謝謝署長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147832/201.wav", + "text": "好謝謝委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147832/202.wav", + "text": "不好意思" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147832/203.wav", + "text": "因為時間的關係" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147832/204.wav", + "text": "我還要問一個營建署的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147832/205.wav", + "text": "就1分鐘" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147832/206.wav", + "text": "剩下的再到辦公室討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147832/207.wav", + "text": "是國土管理署" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147832/208.wav", + "text": "署長我很快速地講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147832/209.wav", + "text": "就兩件事" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147832/210.wav", + "text": "你知道原住民有很多的慣習" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147832/211.wav", + "text": "跟我們一般的國人不一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147832/212.wav", + "text": "像我們的名字就被毀掉了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147832/213.wav", + "text": "我講這次國土計畫��居住習慣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147832/214.wav", + "text": "原住民有很多喜歡獨立戶" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147832/215.wav", + "text": "像布農族泰雅族很多獨立戶" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147832/216.wav", + "text": "但是沒有辦法被劃為農四" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147832/217.wav", + "text": "因為按照規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147832/218.wav", + "text": "通案性聚落要15戶以上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147832/219.wav", + "text": "後來我們有質詢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147832/220.wav", + "text": "你們說那個叫微型聚落" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147832/221.wav", + "text": "但是至少要3棟以上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147832/222.wav", + "text": "如果這樣子算的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147832/223.wav", + "text": "光是一個五峰鄉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147832/224.wav", + "text": "還是有100多戶" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147832/225.wav", + "text": "沒有辦法被劃入農四" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147832/226.wav", + "text": "然後你們就說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147832/227.wav", + "text": "它可以做一個原住民族土地的管制規則" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147832/228.wav", + "text": "可以去做例外規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147832/229.wav", + "text": "署長是這樣嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147832/230.wav", + "text": "沒錯" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147832/231.wav", + "text": "那請問一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147832/232.wav", + "text": "到底那個原民會的例外規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147832/233.wav", + "text": "什麼時候出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147832/234.wav", + "text": "這個我們已經有跟他們開會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147832/235.wav", + "text": "討論過好幾次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147832/236.wav", + "text": "請問一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147832/237.wav", + "text": "這個跟委員報告就是說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147832/238.wav", + "text": "從15戶降到3戶" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147832/239.wav", + "text": "現在是已經確定了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147832/240.wav", + "text": "那一戶的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147832/241.wav", + "text": "一戶二戶這個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147832/242.wav", + "text": "的確因為原民會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147832/243.wav", + "text": "他們現在也在討論就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147832/244.wav", + "text": "他們過去的經驗裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147832/245.wav", + "text": "這種戶數其實不算多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147832/246.wav", + "text": "但是就像委員講的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147832/247.wav", + "text": "他寧可就在某些聚落" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147832/248.wav", + "text": "是但是他也存在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147832/249.wav", + "text": "啊他也存在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147832/250.wav", + "text": "這個部分我們也是希望說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147832/251.wav", + "text": "他能不能適度地找出一些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147832/252.wav", + "text": "我知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147832/253.wav", + "text": "我只想問什麼時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147832/254.wav", + "text": "因為我也問過很多次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147832/255.wav", + "text": "最近的會議是8月14號" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147832/256.wav", + "text": "對那因為我們後來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147832/257.wav", + "text": "又有把一些修正意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147832/258.wav", + "text": "那麼下一次的會議什麼時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147832/259.wav", + "text": "11月還會再開" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147832/260.wav", + "text": "11月就要有答案好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147832/261.wav", + "text": "好我會儘快把這個答案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147832/262.wav", + "text": "很多人都在問" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147832/263.wav", + "text": "瞭解" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147832/264.wav", + "text": "那另外我也是想要問你" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147832/265.wav", + "text": "一件事我很重視的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147832/266.wav", + "text": "就是我8月也開過一個會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147832/267.wav", + "text": "─原住民族的土地" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147832/268.wav", + "text": "要去界定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147832/269.wav", + "text": "我們有好多的原住民" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147832/270.wav", + "text": "是住在原保地上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147832/271.wav", + "text": "但是非原住民行政區" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147832/272.wav", + "text": "怎麼辦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147832/273.wav", + "text": "這個部分我也跟委員報" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147832/274.wav", + "text": "告我們其實8月份也有討論過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147832/275.wav", + "text": "這也是原民會要主動出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147832/276.wav", + "text": "我們到時候也一併" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147832/277.wav", + "text": "好謝謝署長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147832/278.wav", + "text": "謝謝主席" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147832/279.wav", + "text": "謝謝伍麗華委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147832/280.wav", + "text": "現在我們休息5分鐘" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147831/0.wav", + "text": "謝謝主席我們是不是請副部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147831/1.wav", + "text": "好有請謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147831/2.wav", + "text": "黃委員好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147831/3.wav", + "text": "副部長好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147831/4.wav", + "text": "條例是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147831/5.wav", + "text": "我們建軍備戰非常重要的一環" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147831/6.wav", + "text": "我們當然要全力照顧這些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147831/7.wav", + "text": "但反過來說我們也很擔心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147831/8.wav", + "text": "志願役的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147831/9.wav", + "text": "這兩年有一個趨勢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147831/10.wav", + "text": "監察院的報告大家都看到了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147831/11.wav", + "text": "剛才也有委員提到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147831/12.wav", + "text": "從110年到111年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147831/13.wav", + "text": "比例下降" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147831/14.wav", + "text": "到今年6月底又下降了2.62" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147831/15.wav", + "text": "%也就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147831/16.wav", + "text": "兵力報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147831/17.wav", + "text": "你們的目標" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147831/18.wav", + "text": "但是志願役並沒有要縮編" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147831/19.wav", + "text": "志願役是要持原有規模" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147831/20.wav", + "text": "結果沒想到連續兩個年度都產生這樣的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147831/21.wav", + "text": "副部長先說明一下你們自己檢討" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147831/22.wav", + "text": "到底是什麼樣的情形造成這樣的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147831/23.wav", + "text": "觀察近年來因為少子化的趨勢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147831/24.wav", + "text": "還有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147831/25.wav", + "text": "事實上國防部在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147831/26.wav", + "text": "碰到瓶頸" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147831/27.wav", + "text": "舉例來講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147831/28.wav", + "text": "在所有招募工作上來講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147831/29.wav", + "text": "跟" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147831/30.wav", + "text": "臺清交的學生永遠是在名列前茅的公司" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147831/31.wav", + "text": "我們招募的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147831/32.wav", + "text": "攤位看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147831/33.wav", + "text": "終於有兩個人來問" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147831/34.wav", + "text": "說要招募我們問要考什麼軍種" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147831/35.wav", + "text": "你不能這樣講你要去改善" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147831/36.wav", + "text": "當然我是講這個現象" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147831/37.wav", + "text": "他說請問" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147831/38.wav", + "text": "他是來問路的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147831/39.wav", + "text": "與社會徵才的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147831/40.wav", + "text": "國軍的確是弱勢但是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147831/41.wav", + "text": "我們在這方面的改善措施從" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147831/42.wav", + "text": "走入校園" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147831/43.wav", + "text": "到學校去做這些招募工作" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147831/44.wav", + "text": "但是這些東西" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147831/45.wav", + "text": "必須要有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147831/46.wav", + "text": "誘因" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147831/47.wav", + "text": "我覺得最重要的誘因是什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147831/48.wav", + "text": "就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147831/49.wav", + "text": "事實上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147831/50.wav", + "text": "自己" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147831/51.wav", + "text": "的志業來出發" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147831/52.wav", + "text": "最後變成他的職業" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147831/53.wav", + "text": "我想這些東西是我們國防部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147831/54.wav", + "text": "很多欠缺的地方要去改進的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147831/55.wav", + "text": "尤其我們提了很多方案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147831/56.wav", + "text": "ROTC也好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147831/57.wav", + "text": "甚至於我們今天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147831/58.wav", + "text": "在中正預校的招募" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147831/59.wav", + "text": "讓他有誘因到軍隊中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147831/60.wav", + "text": "每一個時間都在檢討" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147831/61.wav", + "text": "當然這裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147831/62.wav", + "text": "走的下降的這些比例數" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147831/63.wav", + "text": "多半" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147831/64.wav", + "text": "有幾個因素" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147831/65.wav", + "text": "第一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147831/66.wav", + "text": "第二" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147831/67.wav", + "text": "有很多人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147831/68.wav", + "text": "認為在這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147831/69.wav", + "text": "條件情況下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147831/70.wav", + "text": "我們都予以尊重" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147831/71.wav", + "text": "所以說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147831/72.wav", + "text": "因為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147831/73.wav", + "text": "第一個叫老生常談" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147831/74.wav", + "text": "事實上你講的大部分都是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147831/75.wav", + "text": "中長期的結構問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147831/76.wav", + "text": "但是我們現在在講的是一個短期的現象" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147831/77.wav", + "text": "因為在110年之前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147831/78.wav", + "text": "從106年開始到現在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147831/79.wav", + "text": "事實上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147831/80.wav", + "text": "前面並沒有這個問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147831/81.wav", + "text": "總人數來看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147831/82.wav", + "text": "並沒有這麼嚴重呈現" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147831/83.wav", + "text": "每年下降的趨勢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147831/84.wav", + "text": "所以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147831/85.wav", + "text": "我現在跟你講的是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147831/86.wav", + "text": "這兩年到底發生什麼事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147831/87.wav", + "text": "你們要覈實去檢討" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147831/88.wav", + "text": "不是再拿這些老生常談的內容出來講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147831/89.wav", + "text": "國軍的招募在社會上是弱勢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147831/90.wav", + "text": "這個聽起來好像言之成理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147831/91.wav", + "text": "我們也遇到非常多的陳情案件" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147831/92.wav", + "text": "服役期滿之後要再" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147831/93.wav", + "text": "我們遇到非常多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147831/94.wav", + "text": "同袍" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147831/95.wav", + "text": "他們其實" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147831/96.wav", + "text": "非常願意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147831/97.wav", + "text": "礙於你們非常嚴格的規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147831/98.wav", + "text": "只要稍微有一些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147831/99.wav", + "text": "都會被汰除" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147831/100.wav", + "text": "他們指出一個很嚴重的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147831/101.wav", + "text": "很多的實兵戰鬥部隊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147831/102.wav", + "text": "這個是很大的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147831/103.wav", + "text": "我剛剛講的這些現象" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147831/104.wav", + "text": "還有你要針對短期內" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147831/105.wav", + "text": "突然間發生的狀況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147831/106.wav", + "text": "是很大的數字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147831/107.wav", + "text": "這是一個突然" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147831/108.wav", + "text": "所以不要再拿這個結構性的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147831/109.wav", + "text": "如果副部長只有這樣的回答" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147831/110.wav", + "text": "我就懷疑" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147831/111.wav", + "text": "國軍沒有在檢討" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147831/112.wav", + "text": "你們自己看到這個數字的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147831/113.wav", + "text": "到底孰" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147831/114.wav", + "text": "對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147831/115.wav", + "text": "不能只看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147831/116.wav", + "text": "要提前離役的這些人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147831/117.wav", + "text": "招募的時候每" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147831/118.wav", + "text": "為什麼招不到人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147831/119.wav", + "text": "少子化也不是這兩年的事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147831/120.wav", + "text": "我是覺得剛剛國" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147831/121.wav", + "text": "防部所提出來的說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147831/122.wav", + "text": "令我感到非常憂心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147831/123.wav", + "text": "很重要的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147831/124.wav", + "text": "優良的裝備給" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147831/125.wav", + "text": "給我們的國軍" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147831/126.wav", + "text": "我們需要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147831/127.wav", + "text": "且訓練精實的人力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147831/128.wav", + "text": "但首先要讓人家留下來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147831/129.wav", + "text": "要招得到人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147831/130.wav", + "text": "人留得下來你才有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147831/131.wav", + "text": "足夠的人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147831/132.wav", + "text": "就算你用無人機" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147831/133.wav", + "text": "也要有人操控" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147831/134.wav", + "text": "對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147831/135.wav", + "text": "所以這個問題是很" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147831/136.wav", + "text": "根本很嚴重的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147831/137.wav", + "text": "是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147831/138.wav", + "text": "我們希望" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147831/139.wav", + "text": "國軍" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147831/140.wav", + "text": "一定要核實去檢討" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147831/141.wav", + "text": "不能夠再繼續往下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147831/142.wav", + "text": "是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147831/143.wav", + "text": "回去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147831/144.wav", + "text": "委託研究計畫都不為過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147831/145.wav", + "text": "一定要好好的檢討這件事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147831/146.wav", + "text": "好嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147831/147.wav", + "text": "是謝謝委員的建議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147830/0.wav", + "text": "謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147830/1.wav", + "text": "洩密的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147830/2.wav", + "text": "講得沸沸揚揚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147830/3.wav", + "text": "我覺得這是我們國家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147830/4.wav", + "text": "重要的政策" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147830/5.wav", + "text": "臺灣人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147830/6.wav", + "text": "還覺得自己很厲" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147830/7.wav", + "text": "他覺得他沒有錯" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147830/8.wav", + "text": "說實在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147830/9.wav", + "text": "的在地方上看起來聽起來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147830/10.wav", + "text": "非常的痛心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147830/11.wav", + "text": "在國內" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147830/12.wav", + "text": "有不一樣的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147830/13.wav", + "text": "理念不一樣的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147830/14.wav", + "text": "怎麼樣吵架" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147830/15.wav", + "text": "都沒有關係" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147830/16.wav", + "text": "可是對外" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147830/17.wav", + "text": "你的胳臂要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147830/18.wav", + "text": "清我們臺灣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147830/19.wav", + "text": "的重要性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147830/20.wav", + "text": "他是在想什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147830/21.wav", + "text": "的重要性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147830/22.wav", + "text": "要讓外國人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147830/23.wav", + "text": "看輕臺灣人的意思" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147830/24.wav", + "text": "我並不是說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147830/25.wav", + "text": "你一定要去批評" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147830/26.wav", + "text": "任何一個人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147830/27.wav", + "text": "來你回答一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147830/28.wav", + "text": "謝謝委員在這方面的議題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147830/29.wav", + "text": "給我們指導" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147830/30.wav", + "text": "我想愛護國家的心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147830/31.wav", + "text": "是我們2,300萬人的共識" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147830/32.wav", + "text": "愛國情操" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147830/33.wav", + "text": "不管表現在朝野" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147830/34.wav", + "text": "大家是一致的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147830/35.wav", + "text": "我想對臺灣的民主自由" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147830/36.wav", + "text": "是一個表率" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147830/37.wav", + "text": "這樣子的一個行徑" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147830/38.wav", + "text": "大家能夠一致化" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147830/39.wav", + "text": "能夠確保臺灣的安全" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147830/40.wav", + "text": "我覺得這是我們臺灣人最大的共識" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147830/41.wav", + "text": "副部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147830/42.wav", + "text": "當我們努力做得那麼好的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147830/43.wav", + "text": "如果有某人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147830/44.wav", + "text": "這非常不應該" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147830/45.wav", + "text": "不認為要跟你們協調" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147830/46.wav", + "text": "告知你們才對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147830/47.wav", + "text": "第二點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147830/48.wav", + "text": "是現在他有提案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147830/49.wav", + "text": "刪減也好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147830/50.wav", + "text": "到今天為止" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147830/51.wav", + "text": "你們有沒有到他的辦公室解釋" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147830/52.wav", + "text": "請你回答一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147830/53.wav", + "text": "一貫的立場是尊重立法院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147830/54.wav", + "text": "行使所有的職權" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147830/55.wav", + "text": "當然是尊重" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147830/56.wav", + "text": "有意見監督" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147830/57.wav", + "text": "不對可是監督要監督對地方" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147830/58.wav", + "text": "我們也要審預算了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147830/59.wav", + "text": "到目前為止" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147830/60.wav", + "text": "你們有去跟他解釋嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147830/61.wav", + "text": "到目前為止他有意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147830/62.wav", + "text": "委員提案的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147830/63.wav", + "text": "我們各單位都有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147830/64.wav", + "text": "派相關人員到各委員不" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147830/65.wav", + "text": "我現在問��有意見的人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147830/66.wav", + "text": "這麼明確了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147830/67.wav", + "text": "也到了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147830/68.wav", + "text": "他算最大的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147830/69.wav", + "text": "跟您報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147830/70.wav", + "text": "國防部在每年處理預算的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147830/71.wav", + "text": "任何一個委員提案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147830/72.wav", + "text": "我們都必須要到委員辦公室說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147830/73.wav", + "text": "我們在審預算到現在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147830/74.wav", + "text": "只要有意見的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147830/75.wav", + "text": "了我最主要是要了解這一點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147830/76.wav", + "text": "因為不要被找麻煩說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147830/77.wav", + "text": "他有意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147830/78.wav", + "text": "你們都沒有去解釋" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147830/79.wav", + "text": "再來看他要怎麼刪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147830/80.wav", + "text": "凍結讓百姓自己認清" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147830/81.wav", + "text": "是在保護臺灣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147830/82.wav", + "text": "還是在出賣臺灣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147830/83.wav", + "text": "\n副部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147830/84.wav", + "text": "本席要跟你談義務役" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147830/85.wav", + "text": "等於是政府聘任" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147830/86.wav", + "text": "聘任的政府要幫他存" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147830/87.wav", + "text": "有關這個財源是由各個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147830/88.wav", + "text": "辦理提繳退休金事務的主辦機關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147830/89.wav", + "text": "編列預算來支應" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147830/90.wav", + "text": "你們要怎麼做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147830/91.wav", + "text": "是不是明年就有辦法編" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147830/92.wav", + "text": "6%" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147830/93.wav", + "text": "都已經有編列了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147830/94.wav", + "text": "我們明年預判大概9001百多人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147830/95.wav", + "text": "編了1.5億元的預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147830/96.wav", + "text": "預算足以支應沒有問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147830/97.wav", + "text": "這樣就是沒問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147830/98.wav", + "text": "問題因為我們要他們來服役" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147830/99.wav", + "text": "服役也要給他們保障" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147830/100.wav", + "text": "也要提撥這是他們權利如" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147830/101.wav", + "text": "不定可以當志願役" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147830/102.wav", + "text": "讓這些孩子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147830/103.wav", + "text": "第二點說不定他會認為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147830/104.wav", + "text": "以上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147828/0.wav", + "text": "現在是副部長我們有請副部長謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147828/1.wav", + "text": "其實有很多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147828/2.wav", + "text": "外面的聲音或媒體" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147828/3.wav", + "text": "或是報名減少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147828/4.wav", + "text": "實際上有這種情況嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147828/5.wav", + "text": "報告委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147828/6.wav", + "text": "有關於志願役人力不足的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147828/7.wav", + "text": "事實上近些年來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147828/8.wav", + "text": "我們國防部在招募工作上來講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147828/9.wav", + "text": "不遺餘力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147828/10.wav", + "text": "還有留營率上來講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147828/11.wav", + "text": "我們都會在這方面做努力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147828/12.wav", + "text": "所以你所講志願役不足的這種情況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147828/13.wav", + "text": "事實上以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147828/14.wav", + "text": "我們國防部現在的編制數來講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147828/15.wav", + "text": "在戰備需求上來講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147828/16.wav", + "text": "能夠滿足我們現在的需求" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147828/17.wav", + "text": "但是我們仍然不滿意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147828/18.wav", + "text": "我們希望未來在離退也好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147828/19.wav", + "text": "在招募工作上來講要積極努力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147828/20.wav", + "text": "來爭取我們志願役人力的補充" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147828/21.wav", + "text": "好其實我覺得就是要講清楚就好了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147828/22.wav", + "text": "那也有很多媒體說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147828/23.wav", + "text": "我們因為兵員不足" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147828/24.wav", + "text": "所以義務役男" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147828/25.wav", + "text": "將會成為主戰部隊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147828/26.wav", + "text": "可是我記得國防部的回應不是這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147828/27.wav", + "text": "我們今天所有軍人穿上軍服" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147828/28.wav", + "text": "他就有義務要保衛自己的國家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147828/29.wav", + "text": "在我們的規定裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147828/30.wav", + "text": "他都是軍人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147828/31.wav", + "text": "來行使" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147828/32.wav", + "text": "那我們也必須要強調" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147828/33.wav", + "text": "這裡面有些在義務役高專長領域上來講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147828/34.wav", + "text": "他希望能夠加入到主戰部隊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147828/35.wav", + "text": "我們也不反對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147828/36.wav", + "text": "那這個必須要經過我們相關的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147828/37.wav", + "text": "審查程序看他的條件是不是符合" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147828/38.wav", + "text": "自願分發的條件" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147828/39.wav", + "text": "我們未來也採結合戶籍所在地" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147828/40.wav", + "text": "讓我們的役男能夠守護自己的家園" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147828/41.wav", + "text": "守土有責的這種概念" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147828/42.wav", + "text": "事實上從自己的家鄉出發" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147828/43.wav", + "text": "我覺得這也是我們未來考量的因素" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147828/44.wav", + "text": "所以有關於主戰部隊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147828/45.wav", + "text": "守備部隊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147828/46.wav", + "text": "我個人是覺得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147828/47.wav", + "text": "他一旦穿上軍服" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147828/48.wav", + "text": "他有他選擇" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147828/49.wav", + "text": "保衛家園的權利和義務" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147828/50.wav", + "text": "那我們將來如何來規劃" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147828/51.wav", + "text": "一個好的完整的義務" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147828/52.wav", + "text": "我們都已經照" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147828/53.wav", + "text": "我們的計畫在實施當中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147828/54.wav", + "text": "其實你講得很明確" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147828/55.wav", + "text": "我認為應該就是一句話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147828/56.wav", + "text": "義務役就是以守備為主" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147828/57.wav", + "text": "我覺得就是一句話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147828/58.wav", + "text": "你自己有專長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147828/59.wav", + "text": "自己要報效國家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147828/60.wav", + "text": "他義務役也可以轉志願役" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147828/61.wav", + "text": "是我們很希望他轉志願役" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147828/62.wav", + "text": "所以剛剛那些都是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147828/63.wav", + "text": "應該就是一句話定調" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147828/64.wav", + "text": "義務役就是以守備為主" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147828/65.wav", + "text": "對不對是的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147828/66.wav", + "text": "我覺得穿上軍服就是守護國家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147828/67.wav", + "text": "就是為了臺灣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147828/68.wav", + "text": "這塊領土上所有人民的安全" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147828/69.wav", + "text": "也不知道這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147828/70.wav", + "text": "是不是百分之百正確" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147828/71.wav", + "text": "目前志願役跟替代役" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147828/72.wav", + "text": "他們的主副食餐費" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147828/73.wav", + "text": "其實是不大一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147828/74.wav", + "text": "是不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147828/75.wav", + "text": "根據我手頭上的資料" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147828/76.wav", + "text": "比如說替代役" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147828/77.wav", + "text": "的主副食餐費" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147828/78.wav", + "text": "平均大概1天118元" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147828/79.wav", + "text": "就是大概96元" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147828/80.wav", + "text": "這個中間是不是有落差" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147828/81.wav", + "text": "我請後次室長跟委員報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147828/82.wav", + "text": "跟委員報告一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147828/83.wav", + "text": "我們現在已經就這個落差" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147828/84.wav", + "text": "並向行政院做一些爭取" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147828/85.wav", + "text": "行政院也允諾" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147828/86.wav", + "text": "可以在明年度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147828/87.wav", + "text": "所以明年度就都會一樣了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147828/88.wav", + "text": "對都會一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147828/89.wav", + "text": "平均水平都一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147828/90.wav", + "text": "如果是這樣就好了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147828/91.wav", + "text": "我也是在軍營裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147828/92.wav", + "text": "我會覺得怪怪的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147828/93.wav", + "text": "我也會心裡不平衡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147828/94.wav", + "text": "就會改了嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147828/95.wav", + "text": "這個已經在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147828/96.wav", + "text": "持續的規劃當中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147828/97.wav", + "text": "我們希望在明年能夠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147827/0.wav", + "text": "謝謝主席我們請唐鳳部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147827/1.wav", + "text": "請唐部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147827/2.wav", + "text": "委員好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147827/3.wav", + "text": "部長好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147827/4.wav", + "text": "我想今天很多委員都在關心有關防詐騙" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147827/5.wav", + "text": "所以本席今天的質詢也是有關防詐以及資安的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147827/6.wav", + "text": "詐騙數越來越多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147827/7.wav", + "text": "我想這是不爭的事實" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147827/8.wav", + "text": "不管是網路上或是我們走訪基層" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147827/9.wav", + "text": "都會對於數位發展部的成立有很大的期待" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147827/10.wav", + "text": "這一兩年來這個期待反而變成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147827/11.wav", + "text": "有一點覺得怎麼會是這個樣子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147827/12.wav", + "text": "問號問號問號" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147827/13.wav", + "text": "很多人民無感" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147827/14.wav", + "text": "認為我們的數位發展部成立之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147827/15.wav", + "text": "還有整個機制法制的作業" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147827/16.wav", + "text": "很慢很慢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147827/17.wav", + "text": "所以人民無感" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147827/18.wav", + "text": "而治安的警訊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147827/19.wav", + "text": "我相信今年1到7月詐欺案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147827/20.wav", + "text": "或者是詐騙案都是第一名" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147827/21.wav", + "text": "這個不用我講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147827/22.wav", + "text": "你應該也心裡清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147827/23.wav", + "text": "那我就要請問一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147827/24.wav", + "text": "剛剛培慧委員有提到一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147827/25.wav", + "text": "在中南部城鄉差距比較大的地方" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147827/26.wav", + "text": "所謂比較鄉下的地方" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147827/27.wav", + "text": "我們用什麼樣的話語去告訴我們一般的人民" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147827/28.wav", + "text": "什麼叫詐騙" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147827/29.wav", + "text": "因為要阻斷詐騙之前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147827/30.wav", + "text": "要先教他們怎麼去分辨真假" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147827/31.wav", + "text": "對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147827/32.wav", + "text": "而分辨真假" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147827/33.wav", + "text": "你們有提出一個策略叫做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147827/34.wav", + "text": "T大使防詐大使" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147827/35.wav", + "text": "剛剛你們有回答培慧委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147827/36.wav", + "text": "但是我想進一步再請問一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147827/37.wav", + "text": "我們現在在今年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147827/38.wav", + "text": "看到明年度的預算書裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147827/39.wav", + "text": "你們增加了多少預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147827/40.wav", + "text": "打算增加多少人力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147827/41.wav", + "text": "打算怎麼樣去配置" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147827/42.wav", + "text": "讓人民有感" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147827/43.wav", + "text": "認為數位發展部的成立" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147827/44.wav", + "text": "是真正的深入民間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147827/45.wav", + "text": "要去告訴大家不要被騙" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147827/46.wav", + "text": "我想這部分就是社會發展的計畫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147827/47.wav", + "text": "包含智慧防詐的3億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147827/48.wav", + "text": "以及您剛剛提到的T大使" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147827/49.wav", + "text": "是不是請正華稍微說明一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147827/50.wav", + "text": "來署長請" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147827/51.wav", + "text": "讓我們有說明的機會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147827/52.wav", + "text": "第一個就是剛剛提到的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147827/53.wav", + "text": "如果我們在社會發展的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147827/54.wav", + "text": "部長帶著我們去行政院爭取到3億的預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147827/55.wav", + "text": "這個到時候請委員會這邊多給我們指導" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147827/56.wav", + "text": "所以明年會有3億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147827/57.wav", + "text": "3億是專門做打詐的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147827/58.wav", + "text": "T大使是其中一個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147827/59.wav", + "text": "T大使的部分其實因為之前的計畫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147827/60.wav", + "text": "在推T大使的計畫是說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147827/61.wav", + "text": "這些非資管資工領域的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147827/62.wav", + "text": "來受過一些數位的訓練之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147827/63.wav", + "text": "其實當初不是打詐" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147827/64.wav", + "text": "當初是讓他到數位的人才的pool可以變多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147827/65.wav", + "text": "然後可以到不同的廠商去協助" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147827/66.wav", + "text": "說不定他本來是類似機械業者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147827/67.wav", + "text": "現在T大使他們有幫我們說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147827/68.wav", + "text": "他們也想要去那邊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147827/69.wav", + "text": "然後做行銷數位行銷等等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147827/70.wav", + "text": "這些新的工具" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147827/71.wav", + "text": "來我們釐清一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147827/72.wav", + "text": "因為你上次回答其他委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147827/73.wav", + "text": "時讓大家引導大家認為T大使是在做防詐" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147827/74.wav", + "text": "沒有沒有抱歉那個沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147827/75.wav", + "text": "來來來剛才培慧委員有提到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147827/76.wav", + "text": "嘛除了這個社會發展計畫裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147827/77.wav", + "text": "這個三億多爭取到預算我們一定支持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147827/78.wav", + "text": "第一個人從哪裡來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147827/79.wav", + "text": "第二個培訓的過程裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147827/80.wav", + "text": "我們現在針對社區防詐" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147827/81.wav", + "text": "是不是應該要配置相當的人力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147827/82.wav", + "text": "結合地方的警政跟民政人力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147827/83.wav", + "text": "比如說今天是九九重陽節" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147827/84.wav", + "text": "在這之前很多社區都在辦九九重陽活動" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147827/85.wav", + "text": "就是一些老人家來參加" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147827/86.wav", + "text": "我們如何結合警政民政體系" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147827/87.wav", + "text": "甚至社會資源體系" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147827/88.wav", + "text": "我們T大使可以是防詐的一個中堅部隊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147827/89.wav", + "text": "可以配合地方好好的去宣傳" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147827/90.wav", + "text": "讓人家對數位發展部的成立" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147827/91.wav", + "text": "願意來支持阻詐反詐" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147827/92.wav", + "text": "國家隊到底有沒有用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147827/93.wav", + "text": "人民才會有感對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147827/94.wav", + "text": "跟委員報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147827/95.wav", + "text": "因為行政院包括識詐的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147827/96.wav", + "text": "其實各部會都有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147827/97.wav", + "text": "這個是因為蔡委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147827/98.wav", + "text": "上次在交通委員會有質詢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147827/99.wav", + "text": "我們我們就下去中部那裡試行看看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147827/100.wav", + "text": "所以明年的部分這樣的一個機制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147827/101.wav", + "text": "會列入我們的計畫裡頭去推動" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147827/102.wav", + "text": "列入計畫裡面而且是占一定的比例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147827/103.wav", + "text": "跟譬如說現在九九重陽節" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147827/104.wav", + "text": "還是中秋節晚會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147827/105.wav", + "text": "那個可能跟行政院內政的體系來處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147827/106.wav", + "text": "我們提供教材教法這個沒有問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147827/107.wav", + "text": "我們會提供這些資源" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147827/108.wav", + "text": "因為我現在在基層看到的警政" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147827/109.wav", + "text": "很努力的在做反詐宣導" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147827/110.wav", + "text": "但是這個教材個案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147827/111.wav", + "text": "什麼是真什麼是假" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147827/112.wav", + "text": "都還不確定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147827/113.wav", + "text": "像我昨天幫你宣傳" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147827/114.wav", + "text": "我跟你講大部分的人都還不知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147827/115.wav", + "text": "要實際收到才會知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147827/116.wav", + "text": "要讓大家對政府的反詐" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147827/117.wav", + "text": "那你就要讓人家有感" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147827/118.wav", + "text": "要讓一般民眾有感" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147827/119.wav", + "text": "就是要明確的告訴他" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147827/120.wav", + "text": "第一個宣傳要到位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147827/121.wav", + "text": "第二個我們要教導什麼是詐騙" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147827/122.wav", + "text": "什麼不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147827/123.wav", + "text": "這個東西既然政府有作為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147827/124.wav", + "text": "那就要做到底" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147827/125.wav", + "text": "完全同意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147827/126.wav", + "text": "好譬如說第二個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147827/127.wav", + "text": "我接下來要說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147827/128.wav", + "text": "我希望增加" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147827/129.wav", + "text": "預算增加人力來結合" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147827/130.wav", + "text": "第二個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147827/131.wav", + "text": "我們電信的詐欺案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147827/132.wav", + "text": "這個我相信" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147827/133.wav", + "text": "大家也都跟你講過了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147827/134.wav", + "text": "我昨天又幫你宣導" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147827/135.wav", + "text": "我跟你講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147827/136.wav", + "text": "很多人也都還不知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147827/137.wav", + "text": "之前在上一次的質詢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147827/138.wav", + "text": "我要求部長您跟NCC要結合" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147827/139.wav", + "text": "各電信業者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147827/140.wav", + "text": "您說數位發展部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147827/141.wav", + "text": "要在技術上支持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147827/142.wav", + "text": "那NCC要要求各電信業者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147827/143.wav", + "text": "手機業者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147827/144.wav", + "text": "一定要做到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147827/145.wav", + "text": "這個部分現在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147827/146.wav", + "text": "你們兩個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147827/147.wav", + "text": "部會合作到什麼進度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147827/148.wav", + "text": "我們所屬的法人TTC" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147827/149.wav", + "text": "已經參考國外的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147827/150.wav", + "text": "已經有提出具體的作法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147827/151.wav", + "text": "這部分我們會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147827/152.wav", + "text": "跟NCC密切的來研究" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147827/153.wav", + "text": "具體的作法是什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147827/154.wav", + "text": "你跟NCC" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147827/155.wav", + "text": "來簡單來講你講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147827/156.wav", + "text": "一般人聽得懂的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147827/157.wav", + "text": "不好意思" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147827/158.wav", + "text": "我昨天幫你跟老人家宣導" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147827/159.wav", + "text": "大家一直點頭說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147827/160.wav", + "text": "對對對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147827/161.wav", + "text": "政府這樣做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147827/162.wav", + "text": "對對對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147827/163.wav", + "text": "有感的是什麼你要用白話文講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147827/164.wav", + "text": "啊我現在手機常常收到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147827/165.wav", + "text": "詐騙的簡訊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147827/166.wav", + "text": "政府可以從源頭" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147827/167.wav", + "text": "要求電信業者怎麼過濾" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147827/168.wav", + "text": "怎麼幫我阻斷" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147827/169.wav", + "text": "政府有沒有強制的手段" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147827/170.wav", + "text": "要求電信業者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147827/171.wav", + "text": "不能傳出這樣的簡訊內容" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147827/172.wav", + "text": "對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147827/173.wav", + "text": "你要這樣講人家才會聽得懂" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147827/174.wav", + "text": "你不要跟我講聯防" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147827/175.wav", + "text": "你先跟我講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147827/176.wav", + "text": "好我儘量淺白" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147827/177.wav", + "text": "啦這部分是NCC做的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147827/178.wav", + "text": "可是NCC又說是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147827/179.wav", + "text": "對對對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147827/180.wav", + "text": "我儘量淺白說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147827/181.wav", + "text": "就是有時候簡訊裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147827/182.wav", + "text": "是只傳文字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147827/183.wav", + "text": "有的時候會傳一個網址" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147827/184.wav", + "text": "它會有一個底線" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147827/185.wav", + "text": "這個底線點開" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147827/186.wav", + "text": "就有可能連到詐騙的網站" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147827/187.wav", + "text": "所以只傳文字的這種簡訊發送" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147827/188.wav", + "text": "比較沒有問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147827/189.wav", + "text": "但是如果裡面要傳這種" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147827/190.wav", + "text": "有連線網址的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147827/191.wav", + "text": "這個網址如果之前NCC" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147827/192.wav", + "text": "沒有看過的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147827/193.wav", + "text": "這種簡訊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147827/194.wav", + "text": "就必須先註冊這個網址" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147827/195.wav", + "text": "真的沒有問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147827/196.wav", + "text": "所以這樣子的一個SOP" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147827/197.wav", + "text": "你跟NCC" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147827/198.wav", + "text": "現在能夠跟各電信業者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147827/199.wav", + "text": "手機業者做到什麼程度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147827/200.wav", + "text": "如同委員所說的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147827/201.wav", + "text": "這個每一個電信業者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147827/202.wav", + "text": "都要配合才有用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147827/203.wav", + "text": "嘛不然只要有一個不配合" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147827/204.wav", + "text": "所以現在就你所知" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147827/205.wav", + "text": "就我所知" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147827/206.wav", + "text": "NCC是已經全部都納管" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147827/207.wav", + "text": "就我所知" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147827/208.wav", + "text": "好那請問一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147827/209.wav", + "text": "我會再跟NCC確認" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147827/210.wav", + "text": "電信業者之外的一些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147827/211.wav", + "text": "委外的代操作簡訊業務的業者呢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147827/212.wav", + "text": "一樣嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147827/213.wav", + "text": "對如果它大宗發送" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147827/214.wav", + "text": "裡面又有網址" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147827/215.wav", + "text": "然後NCC這邊又沒有看過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147827/216.wav", + "text": "那它就必須註冊完" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147827/217.wav", + "text": "成才能夠發送" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147827/218.wav", + "text": "是嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147827/219.wav", + "text": "部長我現在要跟你講的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147827/220.wav", + "text": "就是這樣子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147827/221.wav", + "text": "要用簡短直白的話語" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147827/222.wav", + "text": "讓一般人聽得懂" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147827/223.wav", + "text": "政府在反詐裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147827/224.wav", + "text": "到底有什麼具體作為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147827/225.wav", + "text": "這樣子才會有感" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147827/226.wav", + "text": "是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147827/227.wav", + "text": "你講國際聯防4個字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147827/228.wav", + "text": "一般人聽不懂" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147827/229.wav", + "text": "理解委員的不好意思" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147827/230.wav", + "text": "接著我就要問" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147827/231.wav", + "text": "除了手機" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147827/232.wav", + "text": "還有很多委員關心平台" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147827/233.wav", + "text": "內政部有訂子法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147827/234.wav", + "text": "在數位發展部的溝通之下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147827/235.wav", + "text": "NCC的配合之下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147827/236.wav", + "text": "行政院說我們平台現在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147827/237.wav", + "text": "要負連帶賠償責任" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147827/238.wav", + "text": "要求平台業者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147827/239.wav", + "text": "24小時內要移除" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147827/240.wav", + "text": "違者至少罰12萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147827/241.wav", + "text": "請問一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147827/242.wav", + "text": "平台是包含哪些平台" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147827/243.wav", + "text": "就部長你所知" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147827/244.wav", + "text": "現在以內政部165來講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147827/245.wav", + "text": "其實最大宗的就是臉書（Facebook" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147827/246.wav", + "text": "臉書之外呢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147827/247.wav", + "text": "當然包含像" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147827/248.wav", + "text": "GoogleYouTube等等這些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147827/249.wav", + "text": "是IG算臉書的一部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147827/250.wav", + "text": "還有你剛剛講的Google" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147827/251.wav", + "text": "對這些大概都是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147827/252.wav", + "text": "我們有幫忙建立" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147827/253.wav", + "text": "這種快速通報的通道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147827/254.wav", + "text": "所以我會建議部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147827/255.wav", + "text": "行政院既然有這樣子的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147827/256.wav", + "text": "打詐綱領" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147827/257.wav", + "text": "有打詐國家隊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147827/258.wav", + "text": "像這個東西" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147827/259.wav", + "text": "第一個我們要宣導" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147827/260.wav", + "text": "讓一般國人知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147827/261.wav", + "text": "政府現在已經立法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147827/262.wav", + "text": "要求我們平常生活中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147827/263.wav", + "text": "所用到的這些網路平台" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147827/264.wav", + "text": "詐騙廣告最猖狂的平台" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147827/265.wav", + "text": "我們已經要求它" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147827/266.wav", + "text": "第一個24小時內要移除" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147827/267.wav", + "text": "而這些訊息" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147827/268.wav", + "text": "很多人還不知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147827/269.wav", + "text": "我瞭解" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147827/270.wav", + "text": "是政府強力規範的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147827/271.wav", + "text": "一般人也還不知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147827/272.wav", + "text": "好我想我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147827/273.wav", + "text": "跟我們所主管的電商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147827/274.wav", + "text": "綜合電商跟遊戲業者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147827/275.wav", + "text": "在他們的版面上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147827/276.wav", + "text": "去做這方面的宣導" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147827/277.wav", + "text": "這個我們一定來做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147827/278.wav", + "text": "我覺得從各種方面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147827/279.wav", + "text": "既然我們有打詐國家隊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147827/280.wav", + "text": "而且大家對我們數位發展部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147827/281.wav", + "text": "又有那麼大的期待" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147827/282.wav", + "text": "我覺得真的是要拜託部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147827/283.wav", + "text": "跟我們的團隊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147827/284.wav", + "text": "如何能夠讓民眾" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147827/285.wav", + "text": "對政府有信心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147827/286.wav", + "text": "我相信這些具體的作法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147827/287.wav", + "text": "要一一向國人說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147827/288.wav", + "text": "而且要讓他們明白" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147827/289.wav", + "text": "最重要的是要宣傳" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147827/290.wav", + "text": "好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147827/291.wav", + "text": "謝謝委員謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147826/0.wav", + "text": "謝謝主席" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147826/1.wav", + "text": "我們請部長再撥駕一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147826/2.wav", + "text": "部長請" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147826/3.wav", + "text": "委員好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147826/4.wav", + "text": "部長請教一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147826/5.wav", + "text": "很多民眾搞不清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147826/6.wav", + "text": "為什麼網路上會說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147826/7.wav", + "text": "好像我們沒有作為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147826/8.wav", + "text": "當然我相信數位部做了很多事" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147826/9.wav", + "text": "就是你們還沒有看到而已" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147826/10.wav", + "text": "兩岸如果發生戰爭" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147826/11.wav", + "text": "通訊設備海底電纜" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147826/12.wav", + "text": "透過衛星微波等等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147826/13.wav", + "text": "而且我覺得這個不只是防患未然" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147826/14.wav", + "text": "因為像我們這樣布建下去後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147826/15.wav", + "text": "如果有颱風地震等等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147826/16.wav", + "text": "有一些電信基地臺有問題的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147826/17.wav", + "text": "也可以支援警消" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147826/18.wav", + "text": "甚至支援當地的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147826/19.wav", + "text": "這個時候就會很有感" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147826/20.wav", + "text": "部長我們是用微波嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147826/21.wav", + "text": "還是用什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147826/22.wav", + "text": "一個是說在各個電信中間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147826/23.wav", + "text": "有一個災難漫遊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147826/24.wav", + "text": "候就算你不是那一家電信的使用者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147826/25.wav", + "text": "就可以互相漫遊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147826/26.wav", + "text": "這是第一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147826/27.wav", + "text": "如果那一個地區對外的光纖" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147826/28.wav", + "text": "全部都斷掉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147826/29.wav", + "text": "包含微波和衛星的兩條路" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147826/30.wav", + "text": "可以傳出去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147826/31.wav", + "text": "現在數位部幫忙規劃好的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147826/32.wav", + "text": "就是如果三大電信" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147826/33.wav", + "text": "沒有全被毀掉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147826/34.wav", + "text": "就可以互相漫遊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147826/35.wav", + "text": "如果三大電信商都被毀掉了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147826/36.wav", + "text": "我們還可以藉由微波和衛星" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147826/37.wav", + "text": "所以我們還是可以保持國內的通訊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147826/38.wav", + "text": "不會中斷" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147826/39.wav", + "text": "對這個就很重要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147826/40.wav", + "text": "這點數位部可以保證" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147826/41.wav", + "text": "當然" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147826/42.wav", + "text": "這是我們明年要做的陸海空三維韌性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147826/43.wav", + "text": "是最重要的目標" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147826/44.wav", + "text": "人家說數位部沒作為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147826/45.wav", + "text": "你就可以這樣跟他們講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147826/46.wav", + "text": "其實我覺得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147826/47.wav", + "text": "先講一個比較大的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147826/48.wav", + "text": "我們現在要選舉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147826/49.wav", + "text": "了所以要講鳳山做了很多地方建設" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147826/50.wav", + "text": "講到後來大家都搞不清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147826/51.wav", + "text": "明明做了很多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147826/52.wav", + "text": "條所以要怎麼才能讓人民" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147826/53.wav", + "text": "很清楚你做了什麼事" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147826/54.wav", + "text": "我舉個例子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147826/55.wav", + "text": "說明像陳其邁招商台積電到高雄" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147826/56.wav", + "text": "這是我招商才有的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147826/57.wav", + "text": "如果沒有許智傑三井不會到鳳山" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147826/58.wav", + "text": "這個目前就是集中宣傳三井這家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147826/59.wav", + "text": "家超級大型百貨公司" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147826/60.wav", + "text": "以這個為例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147826/61.wav", + "text": "數位部是不是應該先宣傳了一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147826/62.wav", + "text": "衛星當然是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147826/63.wav", + "text": "你要用一個簡單明顯易懂的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147826/64.wav", + "text": "譬如斷訊的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147826/65.wav", + "text": "保證不斷訊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147826/66.wav", + "text": "保證國人在任何的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147826/67.wav", + "text": "國安情況之下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147826/68.wav", + "text": "在被切斷海底電纜的任何情況之下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147826/69.wav", + "text": "保證不斷訊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147826/70.wav", + "text": "這個講法非常好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147826/71.wav", + "text": "謝謝委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147826/72.wav", + "text": "我們之後會使用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147826/73.wav", + "text": "而且這件事是很大的事" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147826/74.wav", + "text": "是讓國人心安" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147826/75.wav", + "text": "也讓人知道說沒有數位部這個就做不了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147826/76.wav", + "text": "對不對至少數位部做了一項感受得到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147826/77.wav", + "text": "瞭解" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147826/78.wav", + "text": "好不好這是第一個大" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147826/79.wav", + "text": "剛剛培慧問的詐騙這個很討厭" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147826/80.wav", + "text": "防詐" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147826/81.wav", + "text": "防詐方面有做什麼大的東西" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147826/82.wav", + "text": "111簡訊平臺馬上就要啟動" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147826/83.wav", + "text": "這個是大家都看得到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147826/84.wav", + "text": "所以這個要宣傳" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147826/85.wav", + "text": "國安通信中斷時能夠保持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147826/86.wav", + "text": "通訊反詐方面如何反詐" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147826/87.wav", + "text": "現在有這麼多的自媒體" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147826/88.wav", + "text": "這麼多不同的訊息" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147826/89.wav", + "text": "詐騙集團此時數位部到底做了什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147826/90.wav", + "text": "因此而減少多少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147826/91.wav", + "text": "還有另外一個我覺得滿重要的就是發放現金600" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147826/92.wav", + "text": "雖然我響應委員的提議還沒有領" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147826/93.wav", + "text": "但絕大部分的人都有領" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147826/94.wav", + "text": "而且在發放過程裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147826/95.wav", + "text": "真的是沒有出什麼個資資安事件" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147826/96.wav", + "text": "我想很快未來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147826/97.wav", + "text": "用這套系統發放的話大家也會很有感" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147826/98.wav", + "text": "OK" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147826/99.wav", + "text": "怎麼樣宣傳" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147826/100.wav", + "text": "對國人其實這也是安心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147826/101.wav", + "text": "通訊中斷時可以安國人的心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147826/102.wav", + "text": "可以保持聯絡因為我把系統" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147826/103.wav", + "text": "要宣傳一下至少這是我們已經做的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147826/104.wav", + "text": "好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147826/105.wav", + "text": "是只有看左邊這家媒體" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147826/106.wav", + "text": "的影音頻道的那個節目的人投票" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147826/107.wav", + "text": "是非常特定的群眾" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147826/108.wav", + "text": "結果不是全民的結果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147826/109.wav", + "text": "我在這邊稍微澄清一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147826/110.wav", + "text": "OK" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147826/111.wav", + "text": "所以算是有刻意的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147826/112.wav", + "text": "沒關係" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147826/113.wav", + "text": "這個我們也懂" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147826/114.wav", + "text": "如果有一些是被刻意扭曲的民調數字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147826/115.wav", + "text": "我們就僅供參考" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147826/116.wav", + "text": "我現在重點就是這個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147826/117.wav", + "text": "希望數位部可以做一個比較大的宣傳" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147826/118.wav", + "text": "年底可以補到90%" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147826/119.wav", + "text": "報告委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147826/120.wav", + "text": "非常謝謝委員的關心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147826/121.wav", + "text": "努力在年底往90%的方向前進" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147826/122.wav", + "text": "我們有商調" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147826/123.wav", + "text": "有答應要來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147826/124.wav", + "text": "但還沒真的來的可以到80%以上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147826/125.wav", + "text": "謝謝委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147826/126.wav", + "text": "謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147826/127.wav", + "text": "微軟在2020" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147826/128.wav", + "text": "年曾計畫招募20萬個資安人才" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147826/129.wav", + "text": "預計2024年完成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147826/130.wav", + "text": "但聽說現在已經完成了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147826/131.wav", + "text": "不簡單" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147826/132.wav", + "text": "他們要20萬人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147826/133.wav", + "text": "人就是兩三百人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147826/134.wav", + "text": "已經找好了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147826/135.wav", + "text": "所以我要給部長一個建議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147826/136.wav", + "text": "有時候雖然很堅持我們的原則" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147826/137.wav", + "text": "不過處理事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147826/138.wav", + "text": "時有時候人家會覺得我們太柔了一點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147826/139.wav", + "text": "所以必須要求資安署資安院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147826/140.wav", + "text": "啦你看人家20萬人三年完成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147826/141.wav", + "text": "我們才幾百人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147826/142.wav", + "text": "積極一點就過了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147826/143.wav", + "text": "可以儘快完成我們原來要有的建置" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147826/144.wav", + "text": "題也就是重大公共建設預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147826/145.wav", + "text": "裡有個機關資料傳輸韌性強化暨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147826/146.wav", + "text": "發放共用基礎平臺建置計畫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147826/147.wav", + "text": "這個在預算書裡找不到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147826/148.wav", + "text": "不是找不到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147826/149.wav", + "text": "是我們管理費用編在這邊之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147826/150.wav", + "text": "其他各個真的接的那個機關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147826/151.wav", + "text": "共建是編在那些機關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147826/152.wav", + "text": "這叫化整為零" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147826/153.wav", + "text": "是化零為整吧" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147826/154.wav", + "text": "這樣執行時才會順暢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147826/155.wav", + "text": "後面要再送" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147826/156.wav", + "text": "來所以趕快彌補一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147826/157.wav", + "text": "我也知道你們放在哪裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147826/158.wav", + "text": "總之這部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147826/159.wav", + "text": "還是要把它彙整起來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147826/160.wav", + "text": "這樣我們立委要審才會有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147826/161.wav", + "text": "這個是應該的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147826/162.wav", + "text": "這個部分希望你們儘快再改一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147826/163.wav", + "text": "沒問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147826/164.wav", + "text": "這樣預算審查才不會有問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147826/165.wav", + "text": "謝謝委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147826/166.wav", + "text": "好謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147825/0.wav", + "text": "謝謝召委麻煩邀請唐部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147825/1.wav", + "text": "部長請" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147825/2.wav", + "text": "委員好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147825/3.wav", + "text": "是部長你好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147825/4.wav", + "text": "我先以學生的模式來請教老師" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147825/5.wav", + "text": "因為你有最堅強的駭客身分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147825/6.wav", + "text": "我一直好奇就是如同假消息" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147825/7.wav", + "text": "它也是同一個訊息" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147825/8.wav", + "text": "就在很多地方轉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147825/9.wav", + "text": "我們有很多地方性的群組" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147825/10.wav", + "text": "國姓也好南投也好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147825/11.wav", + "text": "它通常就會出現" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147825/12.wav", + "text": "啦什麼行李箱" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147825/13.wav", + "text": "要拍賣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147825/14.wav", + "text": "或是說我上次多買了一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147825/15.wav", + "text": "iphone耳機然後要拍賣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147825/16.wav", + "text": "純原木的傢俱要拍賣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147825/17.wav", + "text": "這些訊息" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147825/18.wav", + "text": "不是只出現一次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147825/19.wav", + "text": "可能是因為我在南投" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147825/20.wav", + "text": "所以幾乎每個鄉鎮的群組我都有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147825/21.wav", + "text": "它是在每個群組都出現過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147825/22.wav", + "text": "也很可能3個月之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147825/23.wav", + "text": "又出現一次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147825/24.wav", + "text": "且不管個資或不管其他" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147825/25.wav", + "text": "純粹就科學的角度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147825/26.wav", + "text": "就是科技訊息辨別的角度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147825/27.wav", + "text": "難道不能針對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147825/28.wav", + "text": "頻繁重複出現的訊息" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147825/29.wav", + "text": "去追它的IP" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147825/30.wav", + "text": "然後再從IP一直去追" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147825/31.wav", + "text": "到源頭嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147825/32.wav", + "text": "這是不難的事" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147825/33.wav", + "text": "以我的理解就" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147825/34.wav", + "text": "像您剛剛提到的是LINE群組" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147825/35.wav", + "text": "臉書也有兩個都有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147825/36.wav", + "text": "對他們現在確實就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147825/37.wav", + "text": "然後很多人舉報的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147825/38.wav", + "text": "那就會把它變成可能詐騙的帳號" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147825/39.wav", + "text": "去降低他的觸及率" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147825/40.wav", + "text": "問題是並沒有降低" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147825/41.wav", + "text": "如果降低了我為什麼會在3個月之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147825/42.wav", + "text": "又看到重複的內容" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147825/43.wav", + "text": "而且我可以跟你講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147825/44.wav", + "text": "重複的內容在群組" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147825/45.wav", + "text": "不管它是在LINE或是臉書" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147825/46.wav", + "text": "就連照片都是一樣的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147825/47.wav", + "text": "所以這就很容易辨識" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147825/48.wav", + "text": "我都還沒有去做數位的連結" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147825/49.wav", + "text": "我也沒有去做影像的辨識" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147825/50.wav", + "text": "就可以知道是詐騙" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147825/51.wav", + "text": "我認為你們並沒有積極在做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147825/52.wav", + "text": "這個就是剛才跟委員提到的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147825/53.wav", + "text": "產業署的智慧防詐" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147825/54.wav", + "text": "可是智慧防詐這件事情對我來講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147825/55.wav", + "text": "明年編列都太慢了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147825/56.wav", + "text": "比如說我先給大家看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147825/57.wav", + "text": "這跟公部門都有關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147825/58.wav", + "text": "我們繼續看到下一頁你會看到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147825/59.wav", + "text": "我這裡有汽車燃料費逾期" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147825/60.wav", + "text": "遠通來提醒" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147825/61.wav", + "text": "還有停車費還沒繳" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147825/62.wav", + "text": "而且違規的部分你有一筆交通" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147825/63.wav", + "text": "違規那個一筆" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147825/64.wav", + "text": "這些簡訊都很頻繁這些全都是公部門" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147825/65.wav", + "text": "就算是您說的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147825/66.wav", + "text": "明年才有預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147825/67.wav", + "text": "難道不應該由你來召集各個部會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147825/68.wav", + "text": "或是您說的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147825/69.wav", + "text": "行政院的防詐中心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147825/70.wav", + "text": "應該要針對這些簡訊花招" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147825/71.wav", + "text": "我們就會有一個111的平臺" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147825/72.wav", + "text": "那以後這種簡訊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147825/73.wav", + "text": "很快只要不是111發出來的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147825/74.wav", + "text": "那大家就知道是假的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147825/75.wav", + "text": "那你可以告訴我說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147825/76.wav", + "text": "針對這些查詢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147825/77.wav", + "text": "你大概可以有什麼具體的效果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147825/78.wav", + "text": "你不能只跟我講說明天有什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147825/79.wav", + "text": "明年有什麼因為這些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147825/80.wav", + "text": "都��事實這些都是詐騙" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147825/81.wav", + "text": "看起來不多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147825/82.wav", + "text": "可是大家也不想要違規" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147825/83.wav", + "text": "可是你一旦開始繳之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147825/84.wav", + "text": "你就陷入了你的帳號被" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147825/85.wav", + "text": "他就會持續針對你出各種不同的花招" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147825/86.wav", + "text": "你怎麼辦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147825/87.wav", + "text": "現在像這個.vip" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147825/88.wav", + "text": ".top這些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147825/89.wav", + "text": "可不可以讓你的T大使" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147825/90.wav", + "text": "也去查看去舉報" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147825/91.wav", + "text": "找一個族群" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147825/92.wav", + "text": "這個是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147825/93.wav", + "text": "南投的詐騙案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147825/94.wav", + "text": "調所有的資料" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147825/95.wav", + "text": "我可以唸給你聽" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147825/96.wav", + "text": "差不多在高中階段大學階段" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147825/97.wav", + "text": "每年都有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147825/98.wav", + "text": "150筆的詐騙案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147825/99.wav", + "text": "然後剛剛出入社會有173筆" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147825/100.wav", + "text": "剛剛可能有了孩子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147825/101.wav", + "text": "或結婚了每年有178筆" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147825/102.wav", + "text": "每年有123筆" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147825/103.wav", + "text": "全部每年的詐騙金額" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147825/104.wav", + "text": "平均大概都" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147825/105.wav", + "text": "超過3億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147825/106.wav", + "text": "這只是南投" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147825/107.wav", + "text": "這只是我剛剛講的這些數據實" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147825/108.wav", + "text": "在非常嚴重" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147825/109.wav", + "text": "嚴重的不得了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147825/110.wav", + "text": "而且詐騙數" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147825/111.wav", + "text": "跟詐騙額度不減反增" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147825/112.wav", + "text": "這些都是具體的數據" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147825/113.wav", + "text": "也是警政署給我的數據" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147825/114.wav", + "text": "我可以把這些原始數據都提供給你" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147825/115.wav", + "text": "我一直在想一個可能性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147825/116.wav", + "text": "因為你是唐鳳" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147825/117.wav", + "text": "就讓大家去使用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147825/118.wav", + "text": "如果讓他能夠去打怪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147825/119.wav", + "text": "去打詐騙累積了100件" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147825/120.wav", + "text": "還可以升級我說的是真的遊戲" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147825/121.wav", + "text": "把這些詐騙" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147825/122.wav", + "text": "方式比如說剛剛我們講的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147825/123.wav", + "text": "根本就不存在的傢俱" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147825/124.wav", + "text": "你可否去發展這些遊戲" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147825/125.wav", + "text": "就是先模擬體驗一下這樣子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147825/126.wav", + "text": "之後就不會再中招因為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147825/127.wav", + "text": "我覺得現在的防詐騙" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147825/128.wav", + "text": "真的感覺上好像就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147825/129.wav", + "text": "既然你自己是一個數位科技的高手" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147825/130.wav", + "text": "你就應該想盡辦法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147825/131.wav", + "text": "加以防堵而不是按照既有的行政程序" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147825/132.wav", + "text": "去做防堵啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147825/133.wav", + "text": "當然像" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147825/134.wav", + "text": "我們明天這個111的簡訊平臺" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147825/135.wav", + "text": "就不是在既有的行政程序" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147825/136.wav", + "text": "那個是在我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147825/137.wav", + "text": "綜合了各司署的能力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147825/138.wav", + "text": "然後在今年就直接" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147825/139.wav", + "text": "啟動的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147825/140.wav", + "text": "只要各個地方跟中央部會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147825/141.wav", + "text": "都來使用111" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147825/142.wav", + "text": "你講的這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147825/143.wav", + "text": "還是沒有回答到我的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147825/144.wav", + "text": "您講的也是由發訊息的部門" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147825/145.wav", + "text": "來發111" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147825/146.wav", + "text": "可是社會大眾" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147825/147.wav", + "text": "像是一個高中生一個國中生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147825/148.wav", + "text": "一個大學生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147825/149.wav", + "text": "他們並不知道111啊更不要講一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147825/150.wav", + "text": "還在社照長照的阿嬤" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147825/151.wav", + "text": "她也不知道111啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147825/152.wav", + "text": "我絕對不反對你現在做的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147825/153.wav", + "text": "我只是提醒你" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147825/154.wav", + "text": "是有能力在既有的行政支援之外" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147825/155.wav", + "text": "再發展新的方法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147825/156.wav", + "text": "我覺得數位部真的要對陣下藥啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147825/157.wav", + "text": "我很感謝之前的呂署長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147825/158.wav", + "text": "我們去針對老人家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147825/159.wav", + "text": "說唱跳也好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147825/160.wav", + "text": "可是不能只有這種針對老人的方法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147825/161.wav", + "text": "你應該要分齡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147825/162.wav", + "text": "如同我剛剛跟你分析的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147825/163.wav", + "text": "就是要分齡我發現" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147825/164.wav", + "text": "國中升高中階段是一個惶恐期" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147825/165.wav", + "text": "是一個會被詐騙期" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147825/166.wav", + "text": "我也知道青少年比如說網路詐騙" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147825/167.wav", + "text": "你可以看到它" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147825/168.wav", + "text": "它的詐欺比率18-23歲" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147825/169.wav", + "text": "24-29歲30-39歲" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147825/170.wav", + "text": "這些人被詐欺的比例都是很高的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147825/171.wav", + "text": "受害者也是年輕人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147825/172.wav", + "text": "我們只是以他的年齡的占比" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147825/173.wav", + "text": "為例然後我要說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147825/174.wav", + "text": "這些類型" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147825/175.wav", + "text": "全部是政府提供的資料" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147825/176.wav", + "text": "你應該都會掌握到這些訊息只是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147825/177.wav", + "text": "你要怎麼對症下藥" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147825/178.wav", + "text": "我自己覺得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147825/179.wav", + "text": "有T大使是好事" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147825/180.wav", + "text": "可是有T大使這件事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147825/181.wav", + "text": "你一定要先做一件事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147825/182.wav", + "text": "為什麼呢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147825/183.wav", + "text": "因為如果年輕人會被詐騙" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147825/184.wav", + "text": "顯然他們上過數學課或" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147825/185.wav", + "text": "物理化學課但" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147825/186.wav", + "text": "他就是沒上過反詐騙課" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147825/187.wav", + "text": "你為什麼不去上反詐騙課呢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147825/188.wav", + "text": "我是認真講的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147825/189.wav", + "text": "針對什麼對象" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147825/190.wav", + "text": "都由你去跟教育部長好好溝通" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147825/191.wav", + "text": "100%一定要讓孩子們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147825/192.wav", + "text": "在他學習的過程" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147825/193.wav", + "text": "就可以具有這樣的敏銳度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147825/194.wav", + "text": "要不然" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147825/195.wav", + "text": "如果你只是去說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147825/196.wav", + "text": "你要怎麼要去講PPT" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147825/197.wav", + "text": "怎麼樣去宣傳" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147825/198.wav", + "text": "那是沒有意義的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147825/199.wav", + "text": "你們應該拿出實例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147825/200.wav", + "text": "我會很誠摯地講的原因是因為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147825/201.wav", + "text": "我覺得這些人他們會被騙" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147825/202.wav", + "text": "如果他知道這個是詐騙" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147825/203.wav", + "text": "在他可以經過反思" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147825/204.wav", + "text": "他不會被騙" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147825/205.wav", + "text": "所以你要告訴我啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147825/206.wav", + "text": "你要在你的專業跟能力之外" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147825/207.wav", + "text": "請說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147825/208.wav", + "text": "之前呂正華署長其實" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147825/209.wav", + "text": "有率隊跟一些檢察官" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147825/210.wav", + "text": "開發像剛剛您提到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147825/211.wav", + "text": "也有一些實際的實地試驗成效" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147825/212.wav", + "text": "是不是請署長快速跟你說明一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147825/213.wav", + "text": "謝謝委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147825/214.wav", + "text": "比較" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147825/215.wav", + "text": "因為那些年輕的T大使朋友" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147825/216.wav", + "text": "譬如Apple用台語來說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147825/217.wav", + "text": "果牌類似這個老人家會比較清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147825/218.wav", + "text": "我相信你們有在做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147825/219.wav", + "text": "我只是要再一次提醒" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147825/220.wav", + "text": "唐鳳是專業" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147825/221.wav", + "text": "他可以依據他的專業" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147825/222.wav", + "text": "去發展反詐騙的課程" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147825/223.wav", + "text": "這是我們對你的期許" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147825/224.wav", + "text": "也相信您做得到的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147825/225.wav", + "text": "謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147823/0.wav", + "text": "部長AIT羅森伯格女士" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147823/1.wav", + "text": "第三次來臺" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147823/2.wav", + "text": "你與他第四次見面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147823/3.wav", + "text": "你還請他吃了紅豆餅" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147823/4.wav", + "text": "深入交換臺美重大的議題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147823/5.wav", + "text": "那討論了什麼議題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147823/6.wav", + "text": "沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147823/7.wav", + "text": "他沒有談到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147823/8.wav", + "text": "那可不可以稍微談一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147823/9.wav", + "text": "他跟您特別談了些什麼樣的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147823/10.wav", + "text": "我想大概就是對於全社會韌性相關的一個課題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147823/11.wav", + "text": "全社會韌性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147823/12.wav", + "text": "譬如說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147823/13.wav", + "text": "全社會韌性包括許多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147823/14.wav", + "text": "特別是我們的防救災" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147823/15.wav", + "text": "其實做得滿好的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147823/16.wav", + "text": "我們在今年年初土耳其震災的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147823/17.wav", + "text": "世界上有看到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147823/18.wav", + "text": "這次也有19個國家派員或者來觀摩" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147823/19.wav", + "text": "所以我們這邊跟美方" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147823/20.wav", + "text": "在這個部分有相關的合作或者互動嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147823/21.wav", + "text": "消防署其實一直以來都有合作的一個項目跟互動" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147823/22.wav", + "text": "瞭解" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147823/23.wav", + "text": "繼新竹縣新埔鎮代會主席" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147823/24.wav", + "text": "北新加油站總經理王增基" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147823/25.wav", + "text": "因為給鴻海創辦人郭台銘連署的民眾提供獎金而被羈押" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147823/26.wav", + "text": "昨天又發生了雙北地區疑似有連署站涉嫌" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147823/27.wav", + "text": "花錢買個資" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147823/28.wav", + "text": "聲押禁見6個人交保" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147823/29.wav", + "text": "請問部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147823/30.wav", + "text": "現在你們掌握的狀況怎麼樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147823/31.wav", + "text": "這是個案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147823/32.wav", + "text": "還是普遍性的一個狀況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147823/33.wav", + "text": "委員好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147823/34.wav", + "text": "法務部在最高檢的指���之下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147823/35.wav", + "text": "廉政署等的查賄團隊都在進行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147823/36.wav", + "text": "只要有線索有情資都會查辦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147823/37.wav", + "text": "這兩個個案就是一個情資反映以後去追查出來的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147823/38.wav", + "text": "目前還有幾個個案都在進行中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147823/39.wav", + "text": "所以現在有的個案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147823/40.wav", + "text": "您可以稍微講述一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147823/41.wav", + "text": "目前大概回報的狀況怎麼樣呢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147823/42.wav", + "text": "就是現在除了新竹跟臺北還有其他相關的回報嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147823/43.wav", + "text": "其實各縣市都有在蒐報" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147823/44.wav", + "text": "於具體的數據" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147823/45.wav", + "text": "所以比較不便說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147823/46.wav", + "text": "這也列為我們蒐報的項目" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147823/47.wav", + "text": "好謝謝署長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147823/48.wav", + "text": "部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147823/49.wav", + "text": "外界也有一位大律師說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147823/50.wav", + "text": "民眾簽署連署書支持特定參選人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147823/51.wav", + "text": "可以獲得400元" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147823/52.wav", + "text": "看似有對價關係" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147823/53.wav", + "text": "但是被連署人目前還不是選舉的候選人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147823/54.wav", + "text": "還無法適用選舉罷免法的規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147823/55.wav", + "text": "更何況這些不特定的民眾" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147823/56.wav", + "text": "雖然連署支持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147823/57.wav", + "text": "譬如被連署人來選總統" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147823/58.wav", + "text": "投票的時候也不一定會投給他" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147823/59.wav", + "text": "似乎難構成賄選" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147823/60.wav", + "text": "請問部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147823/61.wav", + "text": "現在您這邊的看法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147823/62.wav", + "text": "您認為真的不構成賄選嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147823/63.wav", + "text": "這個應該還是要用選罷法的相關規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147823/64.wav", + "text": "本席認為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147823/65.wav", + "text": "連署活動絕對應該要遵守" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147823/66.wav", + "text": "總統副總統選舉罷免法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147823/67.wav", + "text": "以及相關的規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147823/68.wav", + "text": "因為在這個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147823/69.wav", + "text": "假如現在按照外界有人講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147823/70.wav", + "text": "他最後不一定成為候選人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147823/71.wav", + "text": "或者成為候選人也不一定會投他" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147823/72.wav", + "text": "但是在這個部分已經發生了金錢上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147823/73.wav", + "text": "所以當然希望包含內政部在內" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147823/74.wav", + "text": "警政署對這一部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147823/75.wav", + "text": "絕對不能容許有違法的行為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147823/76.wav", + "text": "甚至於有地方幫派的介入" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147823/77.wav", + "text": "當然要請警察機關也要特別注意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147823/78.wav", + "text": "好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147823/79.wav", + "text": "請教一下部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147823/80.wav", + "text": "義交街頭揮汗指揮" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147823/81.wav", + "text": "計時論酬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147823/82.wav", + "text": "不分公私單位申請" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147823/83.wav", + "text": "但同屬民力的義警民防" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147823/84.wav", + "text": "卻因所在縣市而有所不同" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147823/85.wav", + "text": "可以把各縣市對於這些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147823/86.wav", + "text": "相關的一些等於算是協勤費" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147823/87.wav", + "text": "可以把它做一些整合嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147823/88.wav", + "text": "我們現在正在進行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147823/89.wav", + "text": "整個民防體系的一個革新" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147823/90.wav", + "text": "我們要處理的不單只是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147823/91.wav", + "text": "委員剛剛所關心協勤的這個問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147823/92.wav", + "text": "還有包括它的訓練" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147823/93.wav", + "text": "甚至包括裝備的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147823/94.wav", + "text": "我們正在進行整個革新" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147823/95.wav", + "text": "好因為這部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147823/96.wav", + "text": "據本席瞭解" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147823/97.wav", + "text": "各縣市對於這個都有一些不相同的規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147823/98.wav", + "text": "所以這個部分當然要拜託內政部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147823/99.wav", + "text": "儘量能夠來做相關的統合跟整理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147823/100.wav", + "text": "否則這樣子對於各縣市" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147823/101.wav", + "text": "甚至於民防義警義交" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147823/102.wav", + "text": "我覺得其實內政部可以做更多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147823/103.wav", + "text": "是謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147823/104.wav", + "text": "我跟委員補充一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147823/105.wav", + "text": "像你提到的義交" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147823/106.wav", + "text": "這是行之有年有一定的制度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147823/107.wav", + "text": "另外義警巡守及民防的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147823/108.wav", + "text": "我們可能會分優先順序來做處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147823/109.wav", + "text": "因為他們在平時運作的狀況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147823/110.wav", + "text": "有一些差別" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147823/111.wav", + "text": "我們可能會從義警先來處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147823/112.wav", + "text": "對當然這部分本席瞭解" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147823/113.wav", + "text": "做的事情都不同" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147823/114.wav", + "text": "這我瞭解" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147823/115.wav", + "text": "國土管理署表示" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147823/116.wav", + "text": "有關於國內社會住宅的推動狀況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147823/117.wav", + "text": "今年底可以到九萬五" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147823/118.wav", + "text": "五規劃中有3萬8,278" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147823/119.wav", + "text": "戶明年可以達成12萬戶的目標" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147823/120.wav", + "text": "請教一下部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147823/121.wav", + "text": "現在完工的大概有多少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147823/122.wav", + "text": "明年底以前完工的大概有多少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147823/123.wav", + "text": "好請署長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147823/124.wav", + "text": "的確是如同委員剛剛所說的這個數字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147823/125.wav", + "text": "但是因為中央跟地方" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147823/126.wav", + "text": "分計的時間點不一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147823/127.wav", + "text": "所以目前來講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147823/128.wav", + "text": "大概最多也只有2萬多戶" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147823/129.wav", + "text": "可以完工" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147823/130.wav", + "text": "就是2萬多戶" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147823/131.wav", + "text": "嘛這個一旦發包執行就一定會完成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147823/132.wav", + "text": "的確是有一點跳票" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147823/133.wav", + "text": "沒關係" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147823/134.wav", + "text": "不會跟委員報告其實" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147823/135.wav", + "text": "沒關係" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147823/136.wav", + "text": "沒關係署長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147823/137.wav", + "text": "據瞭解政府規劃將一些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147823/138.wav", + "text": "私校退場後的校地" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147823/139.wav", + "text": "轉型成為社會住宅來使用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147823/140.wav", + "text": "但是退場的私校現在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147823/141.wav", + "text": "比較多的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147823/142.wav", + "text": "是在比較偏遠的地方" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147823/143.wav", + "text": "方請教現在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147823/144.wav", + "text": "大概的規劃是怎麼樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147823/145.wav", + "text": "其實不單純只有做社會住宅" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147823/146.wav", + "text": "啦也有一些政府機關的進駐" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147823/147.wav", + "text": "一起來活化這些地方" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147823/148.wav", + "text": "社會住宅是其中的一個選項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147823/149.wav", + "text": "不是每一個地方都會去做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147823/150.wav", + "text": "我們也會挑適合的地點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147823/151.wav", + "text": "時間快到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147823/152.wav", + "text": "了最後一個問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147823/153.wav", + "text": "為了擺脫行人地獄的惡名" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147823/154.wav", + "text": "陳建仁院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147823/155.wav", + "text": "喊出7年要投入400億元的預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147823/156.wav", + "text": "交通部執行有關公路總局" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147823/157.wav", + "text": "所屬省道部分各地方道路" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147823/158.wav", + "text": "則由營建署發包各地執行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147823/159.wav", + "text": "整體經費約410億元" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147823/160.wav", + "text": "請問現在的狀況怎麼樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147823/161.wav", + "text": "還是署長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147823/162.wav", + "text": "這是中央補助地方發包" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147823/163.wav", + "text": "為了要精進案件的品質" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147823/164.wav", + "text": "因為我們本來就是人本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147823/165.wav", + "text": "了我們是要精進案件的品質" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147823/166.wav", + "text": "所以是用隨到隨審的方式來���" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147823/167.wav", + "text": "但是要求規劃的內容" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147823/168.wav", + "text": "跟執行的方式要到位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147823/169.wav", + "text": "所以陸陸續續都已經在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147823/170.wav", + "text": "所以現在各縣市等於是把" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147823/171.wav", + "text": "提案送到營建署這邊來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147823/172.wav", + "text": "對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147823/173.wav", + "text": "經費有問題嗎現在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147823/174.wav", + "text": "經費沒有什麼問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147823/175.wav", + "text": "現在都是要查核他們的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147823/176.wav", + "text": "提案內容" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147823/177.wav", + "text": "我們希望做到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147823/178.wav", + "text": "可以解決問題的地方" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147823/179.wav", + "text": "謝謝謝謝主席謝謝部長及署長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147823/180.wav", + "text": "\n接下來請洪申翰委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147822/0.wav", + "text": "因為這個都是本席很常接到的陳情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147822/1.wav", + "text": "也希望來討論看看有沒有什麼更好的精進措施" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147822/2.wav", + "text": "\n第一個我們可以從簡報上看到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147822/3.wav", + "text": "目前申請租金補貼條件裡面關於家庭成員的規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147822/4.wav", + "text": "在現行的規定裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147822/5.wav", + "text": "家庭成員包含申請人本人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147822/6.wav", + "text": "申請人配偶和未成年子女" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147822/7.wav", + "text": "並不包含申請人的父母" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147822/8.wav", + "text": "當然我也知道當時為什麼會這樣規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147822/9.wav", + "text": "其實是因為以前常有一個狀況也常被民眾詬病" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147822/10.wav", + "text": "就是父母持有房屋" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147822/11.wav", + "text": "導致今天在外縣市求學或工作的小孩沒辦法去申請這個租金補貼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147822/12.wav", + "text": "當然我對於現在這樣子的處理方式是認同的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147822/13.wav", + "text": "因為可以讓在外地求學工作的年輕人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147822/14.wav", + "text": "不受到父母也許可能在鄉下擁有房產的限制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147822/15.wav", + "text": "但是他也能夠申請補貼來減低都市生活的負擔" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147822/16.wav", + "text": "但是現在的狀況就是這個制度還是有漏掉的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147822/17.wav", + "text": "有一種狀況是補貼的申請人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147822/18.wav", + "text": "雖然他們家庭每人每月平均所得高於現在的規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147822/19.wav", + "text": "所以無法申請租金補貼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147822/20.wav", + "text": "可是實際上的狀況是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147822/21.wav", + "text": "他們其實有扶養同住的父母" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147822/22.wav", + "text": "卻因為父母沒有收入也沒有辦法被納入家庭成員來計算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147822/23.wav", + "text": "導致家庭每人每月平均所得其實是被高估甚至是嚴重高估的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147822/24.wav", + "text": "\n我們再看簡報上我寫的資料內政部提供關於扶養比的統計" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147822/25.wav", + "text": "其實可以看到這5年來以本���所在的新北為例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147822/26.wav", + "text": "扶養比真的是不斷不斷地提高" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147822/27.wav", + "text": "從2018年的34.71%到2022年的40.03" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147822/28.wav", + "text": "%青壯年的扶養負擔其實是一直在提高的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147822/29.wav", + "text": "這個大家也都知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147822/30.wav", + "text": "而且新聞也常常報" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147822/31.wav", + "text": "但是因為申請租金補貼條件" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147822/32.wav", + "text": "的家庭成員不納入同戶籍成年直系親屬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147822/33.wav", + "text": "導致現在的制度沒有顧及部分青壯年扶養父母的負擔不斷提高" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147822/34.wav", + "text": "而且這個在本席所在的新北市其實很常見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147822/35.wav", + "text": "也沒有去考慮到三代同堂共同租屋的型態" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147822/36.wav", + "text": "申請人的父母如果是在受申請人或其配偶監護宣告的狀態下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147822/37.wav", + "text": "就可以納入家庭成員計算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147822/38.wav", + "text": "可是要受監護宣告也要有一定的條件跟難度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147822/39.wav", + "text": "啦事實上大部分並不是這樣的狀態" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147822/40.wav", + "text": "所以我們沒有辦法假設所有來申請租金補貼的人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147822/41.wav", + "text": "他們的爸媽都是受到監護宣告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147822/42.wav", + "text": "這個也不符合現在的狀況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147822/43.wav", + "text": "\n我舉一個例子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147822/44.wav", + "text": "目前我看到臺北市有考量到這個情形" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147822/45.wav", + "text": "所以它有把家庭成員擴大範圍擴大到同戶籍的父母" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147822/46.wav", + "text": "也提供加碼補助去降低青壯年扶養的負擔" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147822/47.wav", + "text": "所以我在這邊想要請問部長就我剛剛講的這個情況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147822/48.wav", + "text": "我相信本席收到這麼多陳情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147822/49.wav", + "text": "內政部一定也收到非常多的反映" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147822/50.wav", + "text": "目前針對這個狀況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147822/51.wav", + "text": "內政部有沒有什麼適當的措施" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147822/52.wav", + "text": "或是能不能去研議適度地去放寬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147822/53.wav", + "text": "申請補貼家庭成員範圍的可行性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147822/54.wav", + "text": "是我非常贊成委員剛剛講的這個建議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147822/55.wav", + "text": "我想我們會來研議把它做放寬的處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147822/56.wav", + "text": "不過我也補充一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147822/57.wav", + "text": "其實是有考慮到父母擁有房子的這個問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147822/58.wav", + "text": "不過我個人是覺得這兩個可以切開來看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147822/59.wav", + "text": "扶養的部分把它納進來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147822/60.wav", + "text": "如果他父母是擁有房子房產的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147822/61.wav", + "text": "這個當然就會變成資格不符" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147822/62.wav", + "text": "那自然就會剔除" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147822/63.wav", + "text": "是我們會支持這個方向" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147822/64.wav", + "text": "會來做相關的研議儘快來處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147822/65.wav", + "text": "當然可以有一些配套去處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147822/66.wav", + "text": "舉個例子像我看到臺北市" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147822/67.wav", + "text": "針對這個情形是要入戶籍" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147822/68.wav", + "text": "當然這可以去討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147822/69.wav", + "text": "因為現行租屋補貼其實變成不需要入戶籍" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147822/70.wav", + "text": "所以這中間一來一往" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147822/71.wav", + "text": "我們到底要怎麼去做這個規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147822/72.wav", + "text": "我們可以再詳細地討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147822/73.wav", + "text": "不過我非常高興聽到部長同意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147822/74.wav", + "text": "我們要往這個方向去處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147822/75.wav", + "text": "\n我第二個想跟部長討論的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147822/76.wav", + "text": "其實也是常常被反映的狀況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147822/77.wav", + "text": "因為說實在話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147822/78.wav", + "text": "現在租金補貼的宣傳" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147822/79.wav", + "text": "我覺得做得跟過去比起來是好非常多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147822/80.wav", + "text": "所以除了很多房客知道以外" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147822/81.wav", + "text": "同時也有很多的房東知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147822/82.wav", + "text": "現在申請租金補貼是不需要房東同意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147822/83.wav", + "text": "也不需要房東的身分證" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147822/84.wav", + "text": "所以就變成一個狀況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147822/85.wav", + "text": "從這個新的規定施行以來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147822/86.wav", + "text": "上有政策下有對策" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147822/87.wav", + "text": "是一定會發生的狀況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147822/88.wav", + "text": "嘛我們就可以看到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147822/89.wav", + "text": "有很多的房東在知道有租金補貼的消息後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147822/90.wav", + "text": "為了避免他本身出租的事實曝光" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147822/91.wav", + "text": "也為了避免房客去申請租金補貼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147822/92.wav", + "text": "會發生什麼狀況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147822/93.wav", + "text": "他會拒絕跟房客再續簽新的紙本租賃契約" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147822/94.wav", + "text": "只用舊的合約去備註" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147822/95.wav", + "text": "或者還有一種方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147822/96.wav", + "text": "就是用通訊軟體約定的方式去續約" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147822/97.wav", + "text": "雖然在法律上面用舊合約備註" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147822/98.wav", + "text": "或者是用通訊軟體續約" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147822/99.wav", + "text": "都是有效的租約" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147822/100.wav", + "text": "這個在民法上是有效的租約" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147822/101.wav", + "text": "但是目前我們申請租金補貼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147822/102.wav", + "text": "還是以書面做形式審查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147822/103.wav", + "text": "如果沒有完整的租期" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147822/104.wav", + "text": "其實就不符合申請的資格" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147822/105.wav", + "text": "導致我們新的規定上路之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147822/106.wav", + "text": "還是很多房客沒有辦法去申請租金補貼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147822/107.wav", + "text": "\n當然本席也知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147822/108.wav", + "text": "在實務上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147822/109.wav", + "text": "如果是在舊的租約上備註新的租賃期間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147822/110.wav", + "text": "或是約定續約1年等等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147822/111.wav", + "text": "是具有定期租賃契約性質的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147822/112.wav", + "text": "你們這邊還是會發放補貼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147822/113.wav", + "text": "但也就是像我講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147822/114.wav", + "text": "的我接到很多陳情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147822/115.wav", + "text": "很多房東很聰明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147822/116.wav", + "text": "他們會刻意避免去續簽紙本的租賃契約" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147822/117.wav", + "text": "定期租約" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147822/118.wav", + "text": "除了只用通訊軟體續約之外" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147822/119.wav", + "text": "也會像我這張簡報上講的方式來自動續約" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147822/120.wav", + "text": "所以我在這裡想要請問部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147822/121.wav", + "text": "面對現在越來越多花樣百出的這種情形" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147822/122.wav", + "text": "內政部能不能考慮去用查核租屋事實的方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147822/123.wav", + "text": "審查租金補貼的依據" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147822/124.wav", + "text": "或者是說你們應該也知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147822/125.wav", + "text": "現在花樣越來越多了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147822/126.wav", + "text": "你們有沒有什麼新的措施" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147822/127.wav", + "text": "可以去因應目前的狀況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147822/128.wav", + "text": "第一個我想還是在消除房東的疑慮" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147822/129.wav", + "text": "行政院這邊已經通過要送到立法院這邊來審" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147822/130.wav", + "text": "就是針對房東不查稅的這個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147822/131.wav", + "text": "已經在這一次申請把它納到住宅法裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147822/132.wav", + "text": "所以這個第一點是讓房東放心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147822/133.wav", + "text": "第二個是對於舊約註記的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147822/134.wav", + "text": "其實這個部分我們是承認的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147822/135.wav", + "text": "現在的難處是在他提的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147822/136.wav", + "text": "你要怎麼去查核這個事實" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147822/137.wav", + "text": "這一點的確就會浪費比較多時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147822/138.wav", + "text": "說明舊約註記我們是可以接受" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147822/139.wav", + "text": "不過中間一定會有來來回回的一些補件" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147822/140.wav", + "text": "或是補充證明的這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147822/141.wav", + "text": "過程所以大家相互間都要有一些耐性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147822/142.wav", + "text": "因為我們還是會溯及至你申請當月起算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147822/143.wav", + "text": "這個部分我們盡可能去開放承認一些項目" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147822/144.wav", + "text": "只是要花費一些時間而已" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147822/145.wav", + "text": "我當然是持正面的態度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147822/146.wav", + "text": "的而且我們也收到滿多的反映" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147822/147.wav", + "text": "就是除了剛才說的那種用舊約去���約的方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147822/148.wav", + "text": "其實現在很多都變成在LINE上面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147822/149.wav", + "text": "都在LINE上面去講這" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147822/150.wav", + "text": "所以我才說我們也必須要開始去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147822/151.wav", + "text": "要求補這一些東西" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147822/152.wav", + "text": "這個部分我們內部的作業" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147822/153.wav", + "text": "當然會盡可能朝這方面去承認" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147822/154.wav", + "text": "但是也要給我們一點時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147822/155.wav", + "text": "就是跟當事人要去做一些溝通" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147822/156.wav", + "text": "因為有時候他的註記" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147822/157.wav", + "text": "最麻煩的就是大家有時候LINE又用代號" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147822/158.wav", + "text": "又不用本名或什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147822/159.wav", + "text": "你就很難再反覆去查證" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147822/160.wav", + "text": "之類的所以我們都要花很多時間去查證" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147822/161.wav", + "text": "也肯定內政部有發現這個狀況要來處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147822/162.wav", + "text": "不過我要再次提醒" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147822/163.wav", + "text": "的是很多房客遇到這種情況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147822/164.wav", + "text": "但是沒有辦法跟房東去要求" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147822/165.wav", + "text": "再簽一份新的租約的原因" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147822/166.wav", + "text": "你也很清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147822/167.wav", + "text": "房東這邊其實有防備心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147822/168.wav", + "text": "房客這邊當然也是怕被趕出去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147822/169.wav", + "text": "也不敢再要求" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147822/170.wav", + "text": "所以我才希望" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147822/171.wav", + "text": "內政部應該要去研擬其他的措施" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147822/172.wav", + "text": "例如用查核租屋事實的方法來進行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147822/173.wav", + "text": "房東這邊你們也應該要去宣導" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147822/174.wav", + "text": "因為這種不定期的租約" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147822/175.wav", + "text": "這種民事契約的本質上面來說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147822/176.wav", + "text": "它其實對房東本身來說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147822/177.wav", + "text": "也是有一定的風險" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147822/178.wav", + "text": "嚴格上來講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147822/179.wav", + "text": "它是有點違反消保法的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147822/180.wav", + "text": "你們也要去不斷地宣導" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147822/181.wav", + "text": "沒有必要因小失大" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147822/182.wav", + "text": "所以我建議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147822/183.wav", + "text": "除了研擬協助房客的措施之外" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147822/184.wav", + "text": "也應該要去持續地研究" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147822/185.wav", + "text": "要怎麼去向房東宣導" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147822/186.wav", + "text": "不定期租約這件事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147822/187.wav", + "text": "本身不一定對房東是有利" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147822/188.wav", + "text": "還會有刻意簽不定期租約" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147822/189.wav", + "text": "會產生的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147822/190.wav", + "text": "房東雙管齊下的方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147822/191.wav", + "text": "一起來建立一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147822/192.wav", + "text": "更完整的租屋福利體系" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147822/193.wav", + "text": "這個要再麻煩了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147822/194.wav", + "text": "然後我這次也有提出相關的預算案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147822/195.wav", + "text": "今天沒有辦法講細節" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147822/196.wav", + "text": "到時候審預算的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147822/197.wav", + "text": "我們再來討論細節" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147822/198.wav", + "text": "謝謝主席好謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147821/0.wav", + "text": "我們兩個制度都有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147821/1.wav", + "text": "現在實際上在一些案子裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147821/2.wav", + "text": "我們抽完籤之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147821/3.wav", + "text": "其實是有輪候制的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147821/4.wav", + "text": "所以是有的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147821/5.wav", + "text": "我們現在是抽籤完" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147821/6.wav", + "text": "然後有輪候制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147821/7.wav", + "text": "現行的制度是這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147821/8.wav", + "text": "輪候制有輪候制的優點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147821/9.wav", + "text": "但也有它的缺點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147821/10.wav", + "text": "抽籤好像是每次歸零" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147821/11.wav", + "text": "然後又來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147821/12.wav", + "text": "當然很多國外" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147821/13.wav", + "text": "的國家是用輪候制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147821/14.wav", + "text": "那有一個好處就是自" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147821/15.wav", + "text": "己大概知道什麼時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147821/16.wav", + "text": "可以有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147821/17.wav", + "text": "可是我們也必須講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147821/18.wav", + "text": "如果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147821/19.wav", + "text": "房子蓋的比較晚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147821/20.wav", + "text": "或什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147821/21.wav", + "text": "其實也都有問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147821/22.wav", + "text": "但是現在有很多的聲音" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147821/23.wav", + "text": "說要輪候制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147821/24.wav", + "text": "我必須要講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147821/25.wav", + "text": "很多人也不知道我們現行的制度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147821/26.wav", + "text": "其實抽籤裡面還有輪候制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147821/27.wav", + "text": "我不知道部長有沒有注意到這一點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147821/28.wav", + "text": "很多人還不清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147821/29.wav", + "text": "是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147821/30.wav", + "text": "可能會有這個狀況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147821/31.wav", + "text": "所以我會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147821/32.wav", + "text": "說我們有沒有一個思考就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147821/33.wav", + "text": "其實" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147821/34.wav", + "text": "都會區裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147821/35.wav", + "text": "比如六都" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147821/36.wav", + "text": "可不可以把他們分開" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147821/37.wav", + "text": "沒有那麼大的壓力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147821/38.wav", + "text": "用輪候制的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147821/39.wav", + "text": "其實可能人家會比較清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147821/40.wav", + "text": "我的意思是說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147821/41.wav", + "text": "我們現在抽籤完" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147821/42.wav", + "text": "有輪候制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147821/43.wav", + "text": "但有一些沒有那麼緊的地方" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147821/44.wav", + "text": "是不是也可以跟地方政府協調" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147821/45.wav", + "text": "那個沒有那麼緊的地方" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147821/46.wav", + "text": "我們用輪候制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147821/47.wav", + "text": "讓大家就可以很清楚地" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147821/48.wav", + "text": "地知道自己大概什麼時候可以有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147821/49.wav", + "text": "這樣子的思考方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147821/50.wav", + "text": "你覺得可不可行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147821/51.wav", + "text": "非常謝謝委員的建議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147821/52.wav", + "text": "我想這個我們應該來思考" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147821/53.wav", + "text": "我們把它做一個適當的區分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147821/54.wav", + "text": "即便是六都裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147821/55.wav", + "text": "的需求其實也是不太一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147821/56.wav", + "text": "特別是你也知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147821/57.wav", + "text": "雙北的需求特別高" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147821/58.wav", + "text": "我們可以做一些需求的調查之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147821/59.wav", + "text": "來做一個適度的區分跟安排" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147821/60.wav", + "text": "好謝謝部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147821/61.wav", + "text": "另外" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147821/62.wav", + "text": "剛好署長在這裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147821/63.wav", + "text": "署長我們補助地方" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147821/64.wav", + "text": "其實很多錢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147821/65.wav", + "text": "我舉一個例子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147821/66.wav", + "text": "騎樓整平計畫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147821/67.wav", + "text": "署長你知不知道這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147821/68.wav", + "text": "跟委員報告我們通常都是放在提升" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147821/69.wav", + "text": "行人環境" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147821/70.wav", + "text": "還有人本的道路裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147821/71.wav", + "text": "通常都放在那裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147821/72.wav", + "text": "去做補助" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147821/73.wav", + "text": "不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147821/74.wav", + "text": "有一個問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147821/75.wav", + "text": "們補助新北市" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147821/76.wav", + "text": "在我們板橋" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147821/77.wav", + "text": "補助8個案優先" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147821/78.wav", + "text": "喔現在完成了幾個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147821/79.wav", + "text": "1個都沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147821/80.wav", + "text": "2021年的計畫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147821/81.wav", + "text": "1個都沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147821/82.wav", + "text": "2021年完成的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147821/83.wav", + "text": "對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147821/84.wav", + "text": "你知道嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147821/85.wav", + "text": "完全都沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147821/86.wav", + "text": "喔後來是審計部要求改善" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147821/87.wav", + "text": "新北市的養工處" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147821/88.wav", + "text": "才開始加速施作" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147821/89.wav", + "text": "然後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147821/90.wav", + "text": "改善才1.2公里" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147821/91.wav", + "text": "瞭解" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147821/92.wav", + "text": "有些的確是不好溝通" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147821/93.wav", + "text": "店家也不好溝通" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147821/94.wav", + "text": "那當然跟市府的積極度也有關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147821/95.wav", + "text": "署長我要探討一個問題就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147821/96.wav", + "text": "你是根據它的計畫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147821/97.wav", + "text": "才會補助它錢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147821/98.wav", + "text": "對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147821/99.wav", + "text": "它錢把你要了把你騙走了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147821/100.wav", + "text": "然後它就不執行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147821/101.wav", + "text": "就擺爛在那邊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147821/102.wav", + "text": "我覺得這個很奇怪吧" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147821/103.wav", + "text": "對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147821/104.wav", + "text": "這個部分的確" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147821/105.wav", + "text": "我們大概都是只有在年度的督導" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147821/106.wav", + "text": "才會特別去檢視一下它的狀況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147821/107.wav", + "text": "我現在講的是我們2021年補助的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147821/108.wav", + "text": "今年已經幾年了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147821/109.wav", + "text": "對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147821/110.wav", + "text": "我為什麼特別舉這個例子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147821/111.wav", + "text": "還有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147821/112.wav", + "text": "我們現在有補助人行道的改善工程" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147821/113.wav", + "text": "對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147821/114.wav", + "text": "我跟你講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147821/115.wav", + "text": "我們補助給它" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147821/116.wav", + "text": "市政府提出計畫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147821/117.wav", + "text": "來結果到了地方" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147821/118.wav", + "text": "我跟你講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147821/119.wav", + "text": "它擴充了你的計畫也好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147821/120.wav", + "text": "或它更改了你的計畫也好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147821/121.wav", + "text": "把本來要做人行道的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147821/122.wav", + "text": "又多增加了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147821/123.wav", + "text": "其實我們錢還是得照給" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147821/124.wav", + "text": "跟委員報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147821/125.wav", + "text": "在前幾年都會有這樣的狀況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147821/126.wav", + "text": "現在的議題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147821/127.wav", + "text": "實務上設計出來的效果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147821/128.wav", + "text": "的我們才會來做最後的核定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147821/129.wav", + "text": "我們從今年開始會試著讓民眾來提案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147821/130.wav", + "text": "民眾提案可能提出的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147821/131.wav", + "text": "還是真正問題的核心點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147821/132.wav", + "text": "過去可能市府會覺得不好做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147821/133.wav", + "text": "有一點避開" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147821/134.wav", + "text": "我們現在的做法是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147821/135.wav", + "text": "兩軌進行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147821/136.wav", + "text": "我們也希望找出最應該要解決的問題點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147821/137.wav", + "text": "我們針對那個問題點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147821/138.wav", + "text": "要求市府一定要去改善" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147821/139.wav", + "text": "這是我們在今年會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147821/140.wav", + "text": "我舉個例子給你" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147821/141.wav", + "text": "在我們板橋長江路的人行道改善" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147821/142.wav", + "text": "市政府" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147821/143.wav", + "text": "拖拖拉拉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147821/144.wav", + "text": "然後人家一問" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147821/145.wav", + "text": "它就說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147821/146.wav", + "text": "這是內政部補助的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147821/147.wav", + "text": "它把責任都推給內政部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147821/148.wav", + "text": "你啞巴吃黃連" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147821/149.wav", + "text": "連你們也要去督導" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147821/150.wav", + "text": "啊其實我覺得像人行道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147821/151.wav", + "text": "你們必須要去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147821/152.wav", + "text": "它到底做得怎麼樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147821/153.wav", + "text": "有沒有照做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147821/154.wav", + "text": "不然它把責任推給你" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147821/155.wav", + "text": "我跟你講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147821/156.wav", + "text": "如果好了之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147821/157.wav", + "text": "它說那是它做的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147821/158.wav", + "text": "如果有任何問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147821/159.wav", + "text": "都是中央的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147821/160.wav", + "text": "委員非常謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147821/161.wav", + "text": "我是這樣子覺得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147821/162.wav", + "text": "但我更覺得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147821/163.wav", + "text": "應該要把資訊公開" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147821/164.wav", + "text": "也就是各個縣市政府" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147821/165.wav", + "text": "申請計畫之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147821/166.wav", + "text": "地方政府的市議會市議員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147821/167.wav", + "text": "基本上沒有這樣的資料" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147821/168.wav", + "text": "他也不曉得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147821/169.wav", + "text": "中央補助了相關的計畫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147821/170.wav", + "text": "到底執行的情形如何" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147821/171.wav", + "text": "所以我個人覺得要督促" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147821/172.wav", + "text": "或者讓整個執行率能夠更好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147821/173.wav", + "text": "就是應該把資訊做揭露" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147821/174.wav", + "text": "透明化" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147821/175.wav", + "text": "知道實際的執行狀況是怎麼樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147821/176.wav", + "text": "這是第一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147821/177.wav", + "text": "\n第二個我們過去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147821/178.wav", + "text": "當然會想到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147821/179.wav", + "text": "或者不給它案子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147821/180.wav", + "text": "可是這個到時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147821/181.wav", + "text": "又產生另外的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147821/182.wav", + "text": "到時候全部都推" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147821/183.wav", + "text": "說中央不給錢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147821/184.wav", + "text": "所以我覺得中央已經給資源了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147821/185.wav", + "text": "地方政府要努力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147821/186.wav", + "text": "特別這些案子都是地方提出來的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147821/187.wav", + "text": "所以我覺得資訊揭露是一個好方法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147821/188.wav", + "text": "當然督導督促的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147821/189.wav", + "text": "我們也會來進行謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147821/190.wav", + "text": "部長你說資訊揭露" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147821/191.wav", + "text": "我就是強調要資訊揭露" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147821/192.wav", + "text": "因為很多人不知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147821/193.wav", + "text": "這個到底誰發包的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147821/194.wav", + "text": "反正他就推說這個是中央的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147821/195.wav", + "text": "我覺得要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147821/196.wav", + "text": "做一個清點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147821/197.wav", + "text": "然後公布" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147821/198.wav", + "text": "讓地方政府也才有壓力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147821/199.wav", + "text": "要不然什麼事情都做不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147821/200.wav", + "text": "我跟你講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147821/201.wav", + "text": "它跟你拖得更久" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147821/202.wav", + "text": "反正都沒差" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147821/203.wav", + "text": "反正它就可以講說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147821/204.wav", + "text": "這是中央的錢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147821/205.wav", + "text": "它只要講是中央的錢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147821/206.wav", + "text": "地方所有的人就認為是中央的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147821/207.wav", + "text": "民眾會誤會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147821/208.wav", + "text": "對好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147821/209.wav", + "text": "謝謝張宏陸委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147821/210.wav", + "text": "\n有請賴品妤委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147820/0.wav", + "text": "好謝謝主席我們邀請國防部邱國正邱部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147820/1.wav", + "text": "委員好部長我們關心一下國際情勢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147820/2.wav", + "text": "為了因應中東跟俄烏戰爭的情事" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147820/3.wav", + "text": "美國總統拜登在20日要求國會為大規模安全計畫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147820/4.wav", + "text": "撥款將近1,060億美元" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147820/5.wav", + "text": "折合臺幣大約是3兆4,268億元" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147820/6.wav", + "text": "用於支應烏克蘭跟以色列對抗中國等議題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147820/7.wav", + "text": "其中有74億美元用於對抗中國大陸" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147820/8.wav", + "text": "希望確保臺灣能夠阻止中國的攻擊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147820/9.wav", + "text": "但是從目前公開揭露的資料" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147820/10.wav", + "text": "這個部分都還沒有具體提到臺灣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147820/11.wav", + "text": "請問國防部對於這個部分是不是有所掌握" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147820/12.wav", + "text": "美方會不會增加對臺的新的軍事援助" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147820/13.wav", + "text": "對抗中國的話要強化印太這一方面的作為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147820/14.wav", + "text": "表達我們不會因為輿情或者國外" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147820/15.wav", + "text": "一報導了以後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147820/16.wav", + "text": "我們就調整我們建軍備戰的方向或步調" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147820/17.wav", + "text": "不會的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147820/18.wav", + "text": "大方向不會調整" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147820/19.wav", + "text": "不會調整因為建軍備戰是我們自己的事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147820/20.wav", + "text": "我們聊一個比較相關的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147820/21.wav", + "text": "因為去年在俄烏戰爭開打之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147820/22.wav", + "text": "其實美方對臺的軍購進度上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147820/23.wav", + "text": "有受到一些影響" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147820/24.wav", + "text": "那這次以巴的衝突會不會有一些具體的影響" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147820/25.wav", + "text": "甚至是對於美方在支援印太地區這方面的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147820/26.wav", + "text": "會不會有相關的影響" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147820/27.wav", + "text": "跟委員報告我們也很關切這個議題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147820/28.wav", + "text": "上回俄烏戰爭的確整個世界大概有很多東西都有受到影響" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147820/29.wav", + "text": "到目前為止看不出任何跡象" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147820/30.wav", + "text": "因為以色列本身的軍備也是滿充足的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147820/31.wav", + "text": "哪個國家要支援它" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147820/32.wav", + "text": "而影響到其他原本有交流的這些國家到目前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147820/33.wav", + "text": "但是我們從這次以巴戰爭中可以看到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147820/34.wav", + "text": "新的戰爭模式包含飛彈和無人機的運用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147820/35.wav", + "text": "其實從俄烏戰爭就有這樣的端倪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147820/36.wav", + "text": "現在是新型態作戰的重點跟主力攻擊的一個方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147820/37.wav", + "text": "甚至是一個先鋒部隊打頭陣的基礎戰術" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147820/38.wav", + "text": "其實可以看到無人機的運用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147820/39.wav", + "text": "我們可以看到目前陸軍的營級戰鬥部隊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147820/40.wav", + "text": "長期缺裝現在部隊只獲得旋翼型偵蒐無人機" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147820/41.wav", + "text": "但是戰術偵蒐車輛沒有辦法到位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147820/42.wav", + "text": "並且銳指專案的系統仍在鑑測的階段" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147820/43.wav", + "text": "離實戰化其實還有段距離" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147820/44.wav", + "text": "的部分關於我們整個備戰的一個進度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147820/45.wav", + "text": "請問國防部對於提升聯兵營的戰力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147820/46.wav", + "text": "包含提升無人機的戰力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147820/47.wav", + "text": "反制無人機裝備跟戰術偵蒐車輛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147820/48.wav", + "text": "何時可以去加強進度跟部分到位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147820/49.wav", + "text": "建軍備戰是���續不斷要努力的工作" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147820/50.wav", + "text": "的確有一些裝備目前還沒有到位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147820/51.wav", + "text": "但基本上國軍的聯兵營從成立以後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147820/52.wav", + "text": "其他像是無人機" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147820/53.wav", + "text": "我們當時有規劃" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147820/54.wav", + "text": "到班級到班級就有無人機" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147820/55.wav", + "text": "已經下到班級" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147820/56.wav", + "text": "都可以操作" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147820/57.wav", + "text": "所以這也是不斷在努力的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147820/58.wav", + "text": "目前已經起步了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147820/59.wav", + "text": "沒有說只是個計畫擺在那邊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147820/60.wav", + "text": "義務役從4個月改成1年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147820/61.wav", + "text": "全國人民都支持這樣的一個方向" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147820/62.wav", + "text": "但是我們也知道現在少子女化" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147820/63.wav", + "text": "其實對於不管是國軍和產業缺工" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147820/64.wav", + "text": "甚至私校退場都有很大的直接影響" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147820/65.wav", + "text": "\n接著我要延續下來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147820/66.wav", + "text": "延長義務役期間相關整備工作" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147820/67.wav", + "text": "跟提繳退休金條例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147820/68.wav", + "text": "第一個我們先談到編" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147820/69.wav", + "text": "目前國軍包含第一類戰鬥部隊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147820/70.wav", + "text": "編現比都不及八成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147820/71.wav", + "text": "包含國軍去年志願役的人數" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147820/72.wav", + "text": "比110年減少了5,492人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147820/73.wav", + "text": "而今年到6月底的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147820/74.wav", + "text": "也降到15萬5,000人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147820/75.wav", + "text": "比去年再減少4,174人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147820/76.wav", + "text": "所以逐年遞減" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147820/77.wav", + "text": "是現在可預期的狀況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147820/78.wav", + "text": "因此不管新型態的戰爭" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147820/79.wav", + "text": "或者是相關新型態的武器" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147820/80.wav", + "text": "有機無人的一個狀況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147820/81.wav", + "text": "尤其新型態的武器裝備" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147820/82.wav", + "text": "籌獲之後還有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147820/83.wav", + "text": "後續操作人力跟培訓的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147820/84.wav", + "text": "其實目前從人口的結構" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147820/85.wav", + "text": "來看編現比的分配" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147820/86.wav", + "text": "跟新型態武器的多元化" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147820/87.wav", + "text": "看起來國軍在這方面的準備" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147820/88.wav", + "text": "所以我想瞭解一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147820/89.wav", + "text": "這個部分目前的進度如何" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147820/90.wav", + "text": "誠如委員所講的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147820/91.wav", + "text": "但國軍不會以少子化" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147820/92.wav", + "text": "所以兵員不足" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147820/93.wav", + "text": "作為��個藉口不會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147820/94.wav", + "text": "我們自己內部要有所調整" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147820/95.wav", + "text": "譬如說我們的主戰兵力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147820/96.wav", + "text": "主戰部隊裡面也有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147820/97.wav", + "text": "戰鬥支援或勤務支援的兵力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147820/98.wav", + "text": "我們做通盤檢討以後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147820/99.wav", + "text": "把這個戰鬥支援的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147820/100.wav", + "text": "變成一個主戰成員之一的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147820/101.wav", + "text": "那麼其他一般的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147820/102.wav", + "text": "將來不管志願役" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147820/103.wav", + "text": "或者役期比較短的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147820/104.wav", + "text": "他可以補充到勤務支援部隊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147820/105.wav", + "text": "或者戰鬥支援部隊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147820/106.wav", + "text": "這也是可以提升整體兵力的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147820/107.wav", + "text": "跟國軍的榮譽感要重" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147820/108.wav", + "text": "所以今天在審的這個條例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147820/109.wav", + "text": "其實本黨團有提出" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147820/110.wav", + "text": "相關的版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147820/111.wav", + "text": "今天的提案說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147820/112.wav", + "text": "支持國防部的版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147820/113.wav", + "text": "但是有一些細節還是要討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147820/114.wav", + "text": "本項條例目前政黨協調" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147820/115.wav", + "text": "通過實施日期為何" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147820/116.wav", + "text": "還有相關提繳作業" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147820/117.wav", + "text": "今天這個議程審查條例通過之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147820/118.wav", + "text": "過去服義務役的人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147820/119.wav", + "text": "是不是可以回溯適用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147820/120.wav", + "text": "就是這個年資有沒有累積計算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147820/121.wav", + "text": "這兩個問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147820/122.wav", + "text": "您具體回答就可以了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147820/123.wav", + "text": "因為從94年以後出生的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147820/124.wav", + "text": "才有遇到這些役期延長的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147820/125.wav", + "text": "嘛所以原則上並沒有追溯" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147820/126.wav", + "text": "94年以前出生服過兵役的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147820/127.wav", + "text": "這樣的話大概" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147820/128.wav", + "text": "未來役男如果退伍之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147820/129.wav", + "text": "考取公教人員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147820/130.wav", + "text": "服兵役的勞保年資" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147820/131.wav", + "text": "是不是可以併計" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147820/132.wav", + "text": "已經提繳的勞退金" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147820/133.wav", + "text": "是不是可以轉入公教人員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147820/134.wav", + "text": "新制的退撫基金" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147820/135.wav", + "text": "年資可以按照規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147820/136.wav", + "text": "併計到公教年資" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147820/137.wav", + "text": "提繳的6%的退休金" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147820/138.wav", + "text": "退休金專戶裡面是不移動的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147820/139.wav", + "text": "可以合併計算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147820/140.wav", + "text": "我最後提供一個建議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147820/141.wav", + "text": "我想現在不管是全民國防" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147820/142.wav", + "text": "或是今天我們要談的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147820/143.wav", + "text": "義務役服役期間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147820/144.wav", + "text": "提繳退休金的條例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147820/145.wav", + "text": "有幾個重點就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147820/146.wav", + "text": "要提高國軍的誘因" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147820/147.wav", + "text": "跟他的榮譽感" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147820/148.wav", + "text": "我們的編現比以利後續在全民國防" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147820/149.wav", + "text": "上的一個戰備準備" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147820/150.wav", + "text": "我想這個是這一次立法的一個重點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147820/151.wav", + "text": "至於相關的進度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147820/152.wav", + "text": "我們還是會持續" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147820/153.wav", + "text": "透過預算的提案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147820/154.wav", + "text": "還有相關的質詢去follow" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147820/155.wav", + "text": "也希望國防部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147820/156.wav", + "text": "定期來跟外交及國防委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147820/157.wav", + "text": "作說明跟報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147820/158.wav", + "text": "以上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147820/159.wav", + "text": "謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147819/0.wav", + "text": "謝謝主席請主席邀請唐鳳部長部長委" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147819/1.wav", + "text": "部長早安" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147819/2.wav", + "text": "我們知道資安就是國安" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147819/3.wav", + "text": "這是我們一再強調的一個觀念" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147819/4.wav", + "text": "有做一個所謂責任的等級" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147819/5.wav", + "text": "由高到低分了五級" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147819/6.wav", + "text": "針對不同的等級" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147819/7.wav", + "text": "我們有不同管理的一個面向" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147819/8.wav", + "text": "包括管理面技術面以及認知訓練面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147819/9.wav", + "text": "本席在這邊想請教一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147819/10.wav", + "text": "跟民生息息相關的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147819/11.wav", + "text": "果菜市場或者是肉品市場" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147819/12.wav", + "text": "應該是屬於哪一個等級" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147819/13.wav", + "text": "其實是要看它是不是自己建置了它自己的系統" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147819/14.wav", + "text": "這個時候等級就會比較高" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147819/15.wav", + "text": "或者它都是用它的上級機關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147819/16.wav", + "text": "或者其他已經有共構的系統" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147819/17.wav", + "text": "這個時候等級就比較低" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147819/18.wav", + "text": "比較難一概而論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147819/19.wav", + "text": "才發生的就是彰化的肉品市場" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147819/20.wav", + "text": "跟臺中的肉品市場" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147819/21.wav", + "text": "所以導致豬隻沒有辦法拍賣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147819/22.wav", + "text": "請問部長你覺得這個嚴不嚴重" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147819/23.wav", + "text": "實際影響到民生當然就嚴重" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147819/24.wav", + "text": "我們跟它想想看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147819/25.wav", + "text": "的而且是真的是針對性的一個攻擊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147819/26.wav", + "text": "它導致我們的豬隻或者是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147819/27.wav", + "text": "果菜市場沒有辦法拍賣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147819/28.wav", + "text": "是不是會導致我們國內" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147819/29.wav", + "text": "也會導致民怨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147819/30.wav", + "text": "對其實委員講得非常好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147819/31.wav", + "text": "他們是有全國人民的個資等等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147819/32.wav", + "text": "當然機密性來說是非常的重要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147819/33.wav", + "text": "但是有些是跟民生相關的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147819/34.wav", + "text": "這個時候的可用性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147819/35.wav", + "text": "即使它當機當了大概幾個小時" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147819/36.wav", + "text": "這個時候這個威脅反而更大" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147819/37.wav", + "text": "因為這是大家每天要用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147819/38.wav", + "text": "所以針對這個情況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147819/39.wav", + "text": "因為已經有發生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147819/40.wav", + "text": "所以我們也不排除" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147819/41.wav", + "text": "受到這樣特定的一個攻擊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147819/42.wav", + "text": "在這樣的情況之下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147819/43.wav", + "text": "我們要怎樣來因應" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147819/44.wav", + "text": "避免這樣的情況發生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147819/45.wav", + "text": "我想在資安署的規劃裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147819/46.wav", + "text": "不只是本來的對於機密性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147819/47.wav", + "text": "完整性等等的防護" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147819/48.wav", + "text": "其實有的時候不是被網攻" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147819/49.wav", + "text": "而是一下子太多人湧上來使用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147819/50.wav", + "text": "這樣子也會塞車" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147819/51.wav", + "text": "也會有可用性的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147819/52.wav", + "text": "所以我們是透過數位韌性這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147819/53.wav", + "text": "概念去擴大了傳統資安" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147819/54.wav", + "text": "能夠主動地提供一些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147819/55.wav", + "text": "共用的有韌性的元件" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147819/56.wav", + "text": "就好像它的建材比較好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147819/57.wav", + "text": "換上去之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147819/58.wav", + "text": "就可以承受比較大的壓力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147819/59.wav", + "text": "這部分我們都持續在做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147819/60.wav", + "text": "這個是我們數位部應該做的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147819/61.wav", + "text": "基礎設施的一個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147819/62.wav", + "text": "可是就機關來說它" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147819/63.wav", + "text": "就是資安意識的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147819/64.wav", + "text": "或者是人力的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147819/65.wav", + "text": "在這部分我們數位部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147819/66.wav", + "text": "有可以提供協助的地方" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147819/67.wav", + "text": "是這個其實在我們新的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147819/68.wav", + "text": "中因為資安法在預告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147819/69.wav", + "text": "時我們有收到一些意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147819/70.wav", + "text": "所以可能還要再1個月左右" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147819/71.wav", + "text": "才會送到行政院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147819/72.wav", + "text": "但是裡面就有提到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147819/73.wav", + "text": "在發生這種嚴重事情的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147819/74.wav", + "text": "我們可以暫時性的去調度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147819/75.wav", + "text": "其他機關的資安人員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147819/76.wav", + "text": "當然一方面來排除問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147819/77.wav", + "text": "二方面也是學到說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147819/78.wav", + "text": "怎麼樣來解決方法比較好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147819/79.wav", + "text": "在他們回到他們機關後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147819/80.wav", + "text": "也可以使用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147819/81.wav", + "text": "是所以部長的意思" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147819/82.wav", + "text": "就是我們在目前的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147819/83.wav", + "text": "就是會把這個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147819/84.wav", + "text": "我們的修法草案裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147819/85.wav", + "text": "有這樣的想法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147819/86.wav", + "text": "在草案裡面就有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147819/87.wav", + "text": "把它納入考量" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147819/88.wav", + "text": "藉由這樣一個例子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147819/89.wav", + "text": "我們就要去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147819/90.wav", + "text": "思考未來各種的狀況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147819/91.wav", + "text": "來避免這種狀況的發生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147819/92.wav", + "text": "有關普及通訊傳播的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147819/93.wav", + "text": "以及強化通訊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147819/94.wav", + "text": "傳播網路的韌性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147819/95.wav", + "text": "是我們重要的政策" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147819/96.wav", + "text": "是重點的施政目標" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147819/97.wav", + "text": "我們也知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147819/98.wav", + "text": "臺灣就是一個海島" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147819/99.wav", + "text": "我們的地理環境" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147819/100.wav", + "text": "就是一座海島" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147819/101.wav", + "text": "或是受到攻擊的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147819/102.wav", + "text": "會造成我們整個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147819/103.wav", + "text": "也會影響到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147819/104.wav", + "text": "不管是國防" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147819/105.wav", + "text": "等各項資安的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147819/106.wav", + "text": "都會受到很大的衝擊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147819/107.wav", + "text": "所以我們對於發展" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147819/108.wav", + "text": "就顯得特別的重要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147819/109.wav", + "text": "我們也看到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147819/110.wav", + "text": "最近我們部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147819/111.wav", + "text": "接受訪問的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147819/112.wav", + "text": "也有特別提到這個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147819/113.wav", + "text": "是不是也可以請部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147819/114.wav", + "text": "再說明一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147819/115.wav", + "text": "目前我們的進度怎麼樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147819/116.wav", + "text": "以及未來的期程" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147819/117.wav", + "text": "上什麼時候可以完成這個建置" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147819/118.wav", + "text": "包含中軌道跟低軌道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147819/119.wav", + "text": "是非常有價值" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147819/120.wav", + "text": "我們大概會先挑十幾個地方" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147819/121.wav", + "text": "特別像是離島" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147819/122.wav", + "text": "如果斷掉了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147819/123.wav", + "text": "就沒有別的方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147819/124.wav", + "text": "備援的這些地方" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147819/125.wav", + "text": "這些我們就會優先" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147819/126.wav", + "text": "來驗證及測試" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147819/127.wav", + "text": "確保它資安沒有問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147819/128.wav", + "text": "及可用性沒有問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147819/129.wav", + "text": "之後我們明年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147819/130.wav", + "text": "就會擴大建置" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147819/131.wav", + "text": "到明年年底" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147819/132.wav", + "text": "就會有707十多個點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147819/133.wav", + "text": "建置出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147819/134.wav", + "text": "\n除了我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147819/135.wav", + "text": "自己的這個計畫之外" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147819/136.wav", + "text": "因為我們也是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147819/137.wav", + "text": "商用頻譜的主管機關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147819/138.wav", + "text": "所以現在也有電信" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147819/139.wav", + "text": "商提出申請" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147819/140.wav", + "text": "未來等我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147819/141.wav", + "text": "低軌衛星" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147819/142.wav", + "text": "民間如果也想要租用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147819/143.wav", + "text": "也可以去向電信商租用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147819/144.wav", + "text": "運作比較成熟的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147819/145.wav", + "text": "就是馬斯克的星鏈" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147819/146.wav", + "text": "所以我們會跟" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147819/147.wav", + "text": "去英國談到的就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147819/148.wav", + "text": "因為英國政府" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147819/149.wav", + "text": "對於OneWeb這家公司" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147819/150.wav", + "text": "它有所謂的特別股" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147819/151.wav", + "text": "跟黃金股" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147819/152.wav", + "text": "等於是說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147819/153.wav", + "text": "它可以用否決權的方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147819/154.wav", + "text": "來確保只有它信任的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147819/155.wav", + "text": "供應鏈的夥伴" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147819/156.wav", + "text": "能夠進入OneWeb" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147819/157.wav", + "text": "所以這個在資安上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147819/158.wav", + "text": "相對來講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147819/159.wav", + "text": "是比較沒有問題的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147819/160.wav", + "text": "委員提到Starlink" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147819/161.wav", + "text": "或者是Kuiper" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147819/162.wav", + "text": "或者是其他的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147819/163.wav", + "text": "對於資安的要求" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147819/164.wav", + "text": "我們都很願意來驗測" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147819/165.wav", + "text": "低軌道衛星這個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147819/166.wav", + "text": "能夠加速相關的期程" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147819/167.wav", + "text": "謝謝委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147819/168.wav", + "text": "我們也知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147819/169.wav", + "text": "很多委員都在關心的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147819/170.wav", + "text": "總統跟立委的大選" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147819/171.wav", + "text": "所以我們也看到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147819/172.wav", + "text": "真的是滿天飛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147819/173.wav", + "text": "而且就是針對政府的施政" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147819/174.wav", + "text": "來做一個惡意的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147819/175.wav", + "text": "所以就這個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147819/176.wav", + "text": "我們數發部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147819/177.wav", + "text": "可以有什麼樣的積極作為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147819/178.wav", + "text": "尤其是在網站上面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147819/179.wav", + "text": "甚至還有一些深偽─" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147819/180.wav", + "text": "就是合成的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147819/181.wav", + "text": "包含嘴型聲音" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147819/182.wav", + "text": "甚至影片" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147819/183.wav", + "text": "來冒充特定候選人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147819/184.wav", + "text": "像這樣子的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147819/185.wav", + "text": "其實全球的民主國家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147819/186.wav", + "text": "因為現在AI" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147819/187.wav", + "text": "幾乎沒有成本了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147819/188.wav", + "text": "所以我想大家都是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147819/189.wav", + "text": "非常的警惕" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147819/190.wav", + "text": "這是第一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147819/191.wav", + "text": "同樣的狀況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147819/192.wav", + "text": "也發現在我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147819/193.wav", + "text": "所主管的電商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147819/194.wav", + "text": "上所以也有電商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147819/195.wav", + "text": "它的整個網站" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147819/196.wav", + "text": "它網址只差一個字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147819/197.wav", + "text": "就被別人整個co過去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147819/198.wav", + "text": "但是你在那邊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147819/199.wav", + "text": "下單什麼都買不到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147819/200.wav", + "text": "而是會被騙" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147819/201.wav", + "text": "所以針對這樣子的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147819/202.wav", + "text": "整個網站" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147819/203.wav", + "text": "一頁式詐騙的情況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147819/204.wav", + "text": "我們在5月" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147819/205.wav", + "text": "就已經啟動了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147819/206.wav", + "text": "DNS RPZ的機制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147819/207.wav", + "text": "我們電商的協會等等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147819/208.wav", + "text": "他們都可以透過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147819/209.wav", + "text": "及時舉報通報的方法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147819/210.wav", + "text": "來讓整個網域" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147819/211.wav", + "text": "可以變成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147819/212.wav", + "text": "如果有候選人的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147819/213.wav", + "text": "整個網站被冒充" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147819/214.wav", + "text": "也可以循相同的方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147819/215.wav", + "text": "當然不是說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147819/216.wav", + "text": "我們自己來發動" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147819/217.wav", + "text": "而是包含檢警調" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147819/218.wav", + "text": "等等來合作" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147819/219.wav", + "text": "剛剛部長回復的是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147819/220.wav", + "text": "針對網站的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147819/221.wav", + "text": "本席呈現的這個畫面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147819/222.wav", + "text": "的一個散播" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147819/223.wav", + "text": "我覺得這個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147819/224.wav", + "text": "真的是更嚴重" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147819/225.wav", + "text": "這是我手機收到的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147819/226.wav", + "text": "所以針對這個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147819/227.wav", + "text": "可以因應的措施嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147819/228.wav", + "text": "就是以行政院所提出來的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147819/229.wav", + "text": "就是快速的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147819/230.wav", + "text": "用正確的訊息" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147819/231.wav", + "text": "精準的去回應" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147819/232.wav", + "text": "跟我們部會相關的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147819/233.wav", + "text": "當然我們一定都會自己來做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147819/234.wav", + "text": "\n第二個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147819/235.wav", + "text": "包含委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147819/236.wav", + "text": "委員講到的圖卡等等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147819/237.wav", + "text": "我們也能夠加深" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147819/238.wav", + "text": "去跟像事實查核中心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147819/239.wav", + "text": "或者一些民間第三方" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147819/240.wav", + "text": "的這種查核組織" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147819/241.wav", + "text": "我之前在擔任政委的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147819/242.wav", + "text": "大概跟這一些組織" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147819/243.wav", + "text": "多少都有一些接觸" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147819/244.wav", + "text": "所以我想這部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147819/245.wav", + "text": "我們一定會更緊密來聯防" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147819/246.wav", + "text": "如果他們需要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147819/247.wav", + "text": "一些相關的技術支援等等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147819/248.wav", + "text": "就這部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147819/249.wav", + "text": "因為我們在防詐這邊的技術" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147819/250.wav", + "text": "大概有一些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147819/251.wav", + "text": "是在權責機關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147819/252.wav", + "text": "包含NCC等等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147819/253.wav", + "text": "也可以用來防假啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147819/254.wav", + "text": "但是技術的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147819/255.wav", + "text": "那我覺得這個假訊息" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147819/256.wav", + "text": "對整個政府傷害很大" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147819/257.wav", + "text": "所以我們希望" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147819/258.wav", + "text": "在這個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147819/259.wav", + "text": "能夠加強這個力道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147819/260.wav", + "text": "我們所督導的四個法人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147819/261.wav", + "text": "在這方面的技術投資上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147819/262.wav", + "text": "繼續精進" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147819/263.wav", + "text": "OK好謝謝部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147818/0.wav", + "text": "請部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147818/1.wav", + "text": "委員好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147818/2.wav", + "text": "部長好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147818/3.wav", + "text": "刑事局公布今年第二季" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147818/4.wav", + "text": "解除分期" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147818/5.wav", + "text": "付款詐騙" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147818/6.wav", + "text": "高風險賣場的前五名" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147818/7.wav", + "text": "購物旋轉拍賣跟" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147818/8.wav", + "text": "威秀影城等等之類的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147818/9.wav", + "text": "我想請教" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147818/10.wav", + "text": "因為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147818/11.wav", + "text": "電商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147818/12.wav", + "text": "外洩個資之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147818/13.wav", + "text": "引發詐騙的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147818/14.wav", + "text": "層出不窮" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147818/15.wav", + "text": "警政署跟刑事局非常努力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147818/16.wav", + "text": "目前電商個資外洩" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147818/17.wav", + "text": "的情形仍然很嚴重" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147818/18.wav", + "text": "不是目前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147818/19.wav", + "text": "因為這份是到第三季現在第四季了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147818/20.wav", + "text": "最近幾週上面已經沒有這些了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147818/21.wav", + "text": "這是112年第二季" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147818/22.wav", + "text": "你今天講的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147818/23.wav", + "text": "這個部分我想請教" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147818/24.wav", + "text": "你說打詐綱領1.5" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147818/25.wav", + "text": "要落實行政裁罰" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147818/26.wav", + "text": "請問針對數位部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147818/27.wav", + "text": "所主管的電商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147818/28.wav", + "text": "有沒有依照個資法落實行政裁罰" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147818/29.wav", + "text": "修法前我們其實已經開了一些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147818/30.wav", + "text": "罰單出去細節是不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147818/31.wav", + "text": "跟您就是分修法前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147818/32.wav", + "text": "跟修法後好沒關係" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147818/33.wav", + "text": "謝謝委員讓我們有說明的機會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147818/34.wav", + "text": "從商業司移過來之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147818/35.wav", + "text": "行政院的打詐辦公室一起在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147818/36.wav", + "text": "推動修法前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147818/37.wav", + "text": "我們有裁罰2家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147818/38.wav", + "text": "這個裁罰後還是有些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147818/39.wav", + "text": "修法前裁罰2家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147818/40.wav", + "text": "這個修法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147818/41.wav", + "text": "提高從2萬到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147818/42.wav", + "text": "20萬提高到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147818/43.wav", + "text": "1,500萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147818/44.wav", + "text": "請問修法後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147818/45.wav", + "text": "裁罰幾家跟委員報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147818/46.wav", + "text": "修法之後因為現在這個表是第二季" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147818/47.wav", + "text": "內政部警政署跟我們有很密切的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147818/48.wav", + "text": "聯繫因此通報的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147818/49.wav", + "text": "在第三季大幅降低" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147818/50.wav", + "text": "上面的這些名單都有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147818/51.wav", + "text": "超過10件就會通報" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147818/52.wav", + "text": "通報的數字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147818/53.wav", + "text": "過你還沒有開出第一張" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147818/54.wav", + "text": "的罰單對嗎沒有錯" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147818/55.wav", + "text": "因為它都降低了降低就不" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147818/56.wav", + "text": "要去罰人家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147818/57.wav", + "text": "但是部長我必須要提醒" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147818/58.wav", + "text": "輔導改善等等之類的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147818/59.wav", + "text": "第二個它直接可以開罰" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147818/60.wav", + "text": "我必須要講從5月修法到現在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147818/61.wav", + "text": "非常清楚嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147818/62.wav", + "text": "還沒有開出半張的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147818/63.wav", + "text": "罰單對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147818/64.wav", + "text": "案件來的時候到最後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147818/65.wav", + "text": "都遁入輔導" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147818/66.wav", + "text": "實際上第三季到現在第四季了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147818/67.wav", + "text": "您剛剛提到的這些高風險" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147818/68.wav", + "text": "如果去看165網站的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147818/69.wav", + "text": "已經沒有列在上面了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147818/70.wav", + "text": "你跟我講的跟刑事局跟我講的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147818/71.wav", + "text": "我所接收到的訊息" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147818/72.wav", + "text": "數位部要告訴大家說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147818/73.wav", + "text": "賣場的部分事實上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147818/74.wav", + "text": "都已經改善了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147818/75.wav", + "text": "臺灣沒有這個問題所以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147818/76.wav", + "text": "也不需要開罰" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147818/77.wav", + "text": "意思是這樣嗎如果真的有發生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147818/78.wav", + "text": "個資事件當然我們在三個月之內" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147818/79.wav", + "text": "會把它調查清楚也會裁罰但" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147818/80.wav", + "text": "但委員現在是用這張簡報" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147818/81.wav", + "text": "說它們是高風險那我是就這一張簡報" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147818/82.wav", + "text": "好這是第二季啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147818/83.wav", + "text": "第三季現在是第三季" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147818/84.wav", + "text": "到目前為止他們每兩週都有數字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147818/85.wav", + "text": "你認為現在已經大幅" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147818/86.wav", + "text": "降低了事實上是降低到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147818/87.wav", + "text": "基本上已經不用了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147818/88.wav", + "text": "直接用輔導的方式嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147818/89.wav", + "text": "如果調查確定我們當然還是會裁罰" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147818/90.wav", + "text": "好我想確定一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147818/91.wav", + "text": "像松果好了臺北市警局" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147818/92.wav", + "text": "寫的這個松果購物" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147818/93.wav", + "text": "署長你知道嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147818/94.wav", + "text": "有處理嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147818/95.wav", + "text": "跟委員報告松果的部分在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147818/96.wav", + "text": "有請它要輔導改善" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147818/97.wav", + "text": "在新法的部分到9月" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147818/98.wav", + "text": "我們可以提供這個數據" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147818/99.wav", + "text": "所以也是用輔導的方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147818/100.wav", + "text": "輔導的方式就對了產業的發展" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147818/101.wav", + "text": "就是要一邊健康一邊要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147818/102.wav", + "text": "輔導讓它做得更便利" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147818/103.wav", + "text": "所以一邊把健康保護好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147818/104.wav", + "text": "同時也要推動數位產業部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147818/105.wav", + "text": "大家當然非常放心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147818/106.wav", + "text": "對不對但是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147818/107.wav", + "text": "實際上的狀況是臺灣的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147818/108.wav", + "text": "詐騙問題還是層出不窮" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147818/109.wav", + "text": "如果你今天告訴大家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147818/110.wav", + "text": "臺灣都沒有詐騙案件了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147818/111.wav", + "text": "大家可不可以接受不是這個意思" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147818/112.wav", + "text": "我們是講我們主管的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147818/113.wav", + "text": "我必須要講現在是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147818/114.wav", + "text": "開罰我要講的是這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147818/115.wav", + "text": "為什麼在法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147818/116.wav", + "text": "可以直接開罰的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147818/117.wav", + "text": "罰的情況之下從5" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147818/118.wav", + "text": "5月開始到現在已經10月了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147818/119.wav", + "text": "臺灣的電商這麼多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147818/120.wav", + "text": "排名這麼多第三季的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147818/121.wav", + "text": "除非它" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147818/122.wav", + "text": "如果你說零的話大家可以接受" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147818/123.wav", + "text": "但為什麼你可以有一個權限" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147818/124.wav", + "text": "署長說因為產業的發展" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147818/125.wav", + "text": "這個法沒有給你這個權限" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147818/126.wav", + "text": "這個法是改" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147818/127.wav", + "text": "直接開罰" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147818/128.wav", + "text": "從5月到10月" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147818/129.wav", + "text": "的罰單" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147818/130.wav", + "text": "而你的描述好像在說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147818/131.wav", + "text": "企業的這種電商平臺" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147818/132.wav", + "text": "歌舞昇平這個問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147818/133.wav", + "text": "已經不存在了從第二季" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147818/134.wav", + "text": "到第三季大幅下降" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147818/135.wav", + "text": "之後現在已經不存在了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147818/136.wav", + "text": "沒有說不存在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147818/137.wav", + "text": "我要講的只是大幅下降" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147818/138.wav", + "text": "有用因為從電商的角度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147818/139.wav", + "text": "來看它如果不投資隱" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147818/140.wav", + "text": "隱碼技術等等的資安改善" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147818/141.wav", + "text": "所以所以部長是說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147818/142.wav", + "text": "後即便你沒有開出第一" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147818/143.wav", + "text": "張你都完全沒有開出第一張" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147818/144.wav", + "text": "但是已經有這麼大的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147818/145.wav", + "text": "輔導的情形" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147818/146.wav", + "text": "並且在會後二週內提出" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147818/147.wav", + "text": "一個書面報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147818/148.wav", + "text": "這個問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147818/149.wav", + "text": "被詐騙之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147818/150.wav", + "text": "請問部長你認為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147818/151.wav", + "text": "臉書詐騙要怎麼管" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147818/152.wav", + "text": "數位部花這麼多預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147818/153.wav", + "text": "去做智慧防詐" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147818/154.wav", + "text": "等等有沒有辦法用在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147818/155.wav", + "text": "臉書上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147818/156.wav", + "text": "應該是可以防詐雷達的概念" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147818/157.wav", + "text": "實際通報詐騙的案件" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147818/158.wav", + "text": "中這些商品大概長成什麼樣子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147818/159.wav", + "text": "我們有一個AI的模型" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147818/160.wav", + "text": "有這個模型之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147818/161.wav", + "text": "不管是電商主動來掃描" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147818/162.wav", + "text": "或是從第三方" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147818/163.wav", + "text": "所以答案是可以嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147818/164.wav", + "text": "臉書阻詐於" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147818/165.wav", + "text": "二個禮拜內提出一個書面報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147818/166.wav", + "text": "但是明年會開始有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147818/167.wav", + "text": "預算投入" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147818/168.wav", + "text": "當然沒問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147818/169.wav", + "text": "我們非常期待數位部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147818/170.wav", + "text": "願意拿出一個態度來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147818/171.wav", + "text": "處理這個問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147818/172.wav", + "text": "跟聯防平臺的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147818/173.wav", + "text": "要如何推動" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147818/174.wav", + "text": "因為現在看起來實際上採用隱碼技術" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147818/175.wav", + "text": "遠時科技有導入物流的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147818/176.wav", + "text": "隱碼機制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147818/177.wav", + "text": "賣場目前都不在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147818/178.wav", + "text": "計畫的推動" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147818/179.wav", + "text": "名單內" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147818/180.wav", + "text": "鼓勵嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147818/181.wav", + "text": "用鼓勵的方式鼓勵業者去做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147818/182.wav", + "text": "這個良心事業嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147818/183.wav", + "text": "新的個資法出來之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147818/184.wav", + "text": "如果它沒有導入像隱碼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147818/185.wav", + "text": "資安聯防的技術而被我們發現" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147818/186.wav", + "text": "新法上路之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147818/187.wav", + "text": "竟然還有新的這種事件" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147818/188.wav", + "text": "就會直接裁罰了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147818/189.wav", + "text": "所以它們應該都是很有動機的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147818/190.wav", + "text": "不是所以現在的重點是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147818/191.wav", + "text": "你要不要設一個門檻" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147818/192.wav", + "text": "然後去強制性推動" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147818/193.wav", + "text": "否則的話到最後大家都沒有加入" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147818/194.wav", + "text": "大家都認為這是往前進了一步" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147818/195.wav", + "text": "只有用鼓勵的方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147818/196.wav", + "text": "它是用它自己in-house的開發能力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147818/197.wav", + "text": "來做這方面的工作" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147818/198.wav", + "text": "不一定是買外面的解決方案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147818/199.wav", + "text": "但是要從你的角度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147818/200.wav", + "text": "所以從你的角度你要鼓勵業者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147818/201.wav", + "text": "但是加入之後很多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147818/202.wav", + "text": "有高風險的業者它還是沒加入" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147818/203.wav", + "text": "那你要不要設一個門檻" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147818/204.wav", + "text": "強制性的方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147818/205.wav", + "text": "數位經濟相關的個資" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147818/206.wav", + "text": "安全維護辦法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147818/207.wav", + "text": "所以這部分我們是不是就跟署長來討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147818/208.wav", + "text": "然後我們書面回復委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147818/209.wav", + "text": "好謝謝主席" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147818/210.wav", + "text": "請書面回復邱委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147816/0.wav", + "text": "部長請" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147816/1.wav", + "text": "在國際之間越來越受到關注" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147816/2.wav", + "text": "當然俄烏戰爭的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147816/3.wav", + "text": "大家也討論到低軌衛星的通訊功能" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147816/4.wav", + "text": "越顯出相關通訊的重要性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147816/5.wav", + "text": "軍事專家對以色列偵測方面也多所討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147816/6.wav", + "text": "我們看到這幾年來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147816/7.wav", + "text": "這種非同步軌道衛星" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147816/8.wav", + "text": "包括中軌道跟低軌道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147816/9.wav", + "text": "當然這種非同步的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147816/10.wav", + "text": "對臺灣未來的發展也是非常重要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147816/11.wav", + "text": "數位部在這方面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147816/12.wav", + "text": "不管是商用計畫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147816/13.wav", + "text": "或者是這些衛星的非商用計畫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147816/14.wav", + "text": "目前的進度大概如何" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147816/15.wav", + "text": "簡單說明一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147816/16.wav", + "text": "謝謝委員讓我們有機會說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147816/17.wav", + "text": "確實委員剛剛提到的中軌跟低軌" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147816/18.wav", + "text": "我們現在就非常積極地在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147816/19.wav", + "text": "進行驗測" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147816/20.wav", + "text": "包含中軌SES跟低軌OneWeb" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147816/21.wav", + "text": "跟我們合作做這個驗測這是第一點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147816/22.wav", + "text": "\n另外委員提到的就是包含" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147816/23.wav", + "text": "然後進行分析等等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147816/24.wav", + "text": "的部分這部分我們也透過像" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147816/25.wav", + "text": "跟國際的這些友人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147816/26.wav", + "text": "瞭解到最尖端的技術特別是透過AI方法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147816/27.wav", + "text": "有哪些我們沒有注意到的事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147816/28.wav", + "text": "上當然有一些相關的法令出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147816/29.wav", + "text": "去年11月" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147816/30.wav", + "text": "我們首度開放業者申請商用衛星執照" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147816/31.wav", + "text": "有基本的一些規範" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147816/32.wav", + "text": "包括不得有大陸地區投資人的投資" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147816/33.wav", + "text": "應該要符合有關機關的國家安全考量" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147816/34.wav", + "text": "政府的應變訊息" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147816/35.wav", + "text": "仍然可以在國內外傳遞" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147816/36.wav", + "text": "不一定要在國內設置" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147816/37.wav", + "text": "衛星設備而是透過合作方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147816/38.wav", + "text": "預計明年底將要設置773個點位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147816/39.wav", + "text": "我們也要協助驗證這非常重要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147816/40.wav", + "text": "以及政府民生系統等等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147816/41.wav", + "text": "\n我們再來看看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147816/42.wav", + "text": "好像業者提供的服務" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147816/43.wav", + "text": "是比較偏重海事的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147816/44.wav", + "text": "就是提供漁船" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147816/45.wav", + "text": "或者配合中軌道衛星" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147816/46.wav", + "text": "航空器等等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147816/47.wav", + "text": "都是偏重海事" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147816/48.wav", + "text": "是不可以被忽略的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147816/49.wav", + "text": "這點請部長說明一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147816/50.wav", + "text": "因為在漁船商船上面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147816/51.wav", + "text": "如果主要是用同步軌道衛星" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147816/52.wav", + "text": "就是最高的那種" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147816/53.wav", + "text": "那它的單位傳輸成本相當高" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147816/54.wav", + "text": "所以我想第一波是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147816/55.wav", + "text": "因為看到這邊有商機" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147816/56.wav", + "text": "因為用非同步的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147816/57.wav", + "text": "單位成本就會下降" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147816/58.wav", + "text": "所以漁船商船會比較願意買" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147816/59.wav", + "text": "最底下寫說跟OneWeb合作" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147816/60.wav", + "text": "這部分就有陸上固定地點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147816/61.wav", + "text": "那麼你提到的偏鄉或者高山等等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147816/62.wav", + "text": "就可以在這邊來處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147816/63.wav", + "text": "部長我現在就是要提醒你" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147816/64.wav", + "text": "有4家業者要進行溝通" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147816/65.wav", + "text": "跟偏遠地區的通訊服務" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147816/66.wav", + "text": "部分還是應該要加強" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147816/67.wav", + "text": "尚未遞件申請的業者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147816/68.wav", + "text": "跟偏遠地區的服務" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147816/69.wav", + "text": "部長簡單說明一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147816/70.wav", + "text": "是因為我們有其他政策工具" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147816/71.wav", + "text": "像普及服務基金等等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147816/72.wav", + "text": "我們會透過這些政策工具來引導" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147816/73.wav", + "text": "透過所謂的Backhaul" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147816/74.wav", + "text": "就是他提供一般的4G5G服務" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147816/75.wav", + "text": "但他後面是透過衛星後傳" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147816/76.wav", + "text": "委員剛剛提到的真的很偏遠的地方" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147816/77.wav", + "text": "光纖比較拉不到的那些少數區域" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147816/78.wav", + "text": "這部分我們會積極的來辦理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147816/79.wav", + "text": "部長我們剛才提到的是商用衛星部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147816/80.wav", + "text": "現在再來討論非商用衛星的規劃情形" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147816/81.wav", + "text": "基地臺衛星後傳鏈路站點有5個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147816/82.wav", + "text": "國外非同步軌道衛星終端設備站點有1個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147816/83.wav", + "text": "就是說我們預計到11月底" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147816/84.wav", + "text": "確定的這些第一階段布置的點位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147816/85.wav", + "text": "以及明年3月底要確定的整體站點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147816/86.wav", + "text": "目前都還沒有開始建置" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147816/87.wav", + "text": "不是這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147816/88.wav", + "text": "跟委員解釋一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147816/89.wav", + "text": "這部分的建置特別是如果是低軌的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147816/90.wav", + "text": "它的設備本身是相當輕的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147816/91.wav", + "text": "目前車載絕對沒有問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147816/92.wav", + "text": "甚至之後背包載都沒有問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147816/93.wav", + "text": "在這個情況下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147816/94.wav", + "text": "我們就是先蒐集一波需求" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147816/95.wav", + "text": "跟國科會一起來安排" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147816/96.wav", + "text": "我們先在哪裡進行測試" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147816/97.wav", + "text": "在測試取得數據之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147816/98.wav", + "text": "這些是可以移動的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147816/99.wav", + "text": "所以我們現在就是在蒐集這些需求" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147816/100.wav", + "text": "部長對於整體所需站點的評估" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147816/101.wav", + "text": "要跟國科會內政部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147816/102.wav", + "text": "還有國防單位持續協調" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147816/103.wav", + "text": "就是說在驗測的同時" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147816/104.wav", + "text": "要評估所需建置的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147816/105.wav", + "text": "當然這不是數位部來主導" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147816/106.wav", + "text": "因為有國防部跟內政部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147816/107.wav", + "text": "軍民通用資安技術研發的補助計畫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147816/108.wav", + "text": "在建置站點的同時" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147816/109.wav", + "text": "要跟民間合作" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147816/110.wav", + "text": "這些非同步衛星系統相關的資安漏洞" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147816/111.wav", + "text": "沒錯這個就是驗測計畫的目的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147816/112.wav", + "text": "就是在它實際落地變成商用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147816/113.wav", + "text": "任何人都可以租" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147816/114.wav", + "text": "也就是在沒有700個點的限制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147816/115.wav", + "text": "之前我們先要確定它的資安" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147816/116.wav", + "text": "端到端加密等等沒有問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147816/117.wav", + "text": "這是第一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147816/118.wav", + "text": "\n第二個是我們也要知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147816/119.wav", + "text": "實際的情形比如三家主要的電信" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147816/120.wav", + "text": "如果有一二家失去訊號" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147816/121.wav", + "text": "基地臺被破壞" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147816/122.wav", + "text": "特別像颱風地震這樣的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147816/123.wav", + "text": "我們能不能透過災難漫遊的方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147816/124.wav", + "text": "讓剩下的那一家提供給所有人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147816/125.wav", + "text": "使用至少是警消人員或相關的援助" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147816/126.wav", + "text": "來使用等這些都測試無誤之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147816/127.wav", + "text": "當商用的低軌開放了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147816/128.wav", + "text": "那需要的人包含你剛剛提到的學校等等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147816/129.wav", + "text": "就用商用的去租用就可以了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147816/130.wav", + "text": "這些驗證計畫完成之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147816/131.wav", + "text": "預估全國離島偏鄉學校醫院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147816/132.wav", + "text": "避難中心警察局消防局等等的場所" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147816/133.wav", + "text": "但誠如我剛才說的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147816/134.wav", + "text": "這不是數位部來主導" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147816/135.wav", + "text": "就租用就好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147816/136.wav", + "text": "越來越嚴重" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147816/137.wav", + "text": "較為嚴重的第三級事件" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147816/138.wav", + "text": "今年8月就發生了13件" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147816/139.wav", + "text": "這是自2020年1月起統計" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147816/140.wav", + "text": "到現在最多的一個月" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147816/141.wav", + "text": "這種資安的攻擊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147816/142.wav", + "text": "臺灣的狀況是非常的嚴重" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147816/143.wav", + "text": "部長的責任也非常清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147816/144.wav", + "text": "不管是策略面管理面跟技術面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147816/145.wav", + "text": "的資安署人力不足" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147816/146.wav", + "text": "這讓我們很擔憂" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147816/147.wav", + "text": "我們核心的重要業務單位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147816/148.wav", + "text": "其實到職率都低於65%" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147816/149.wav", + "text": "來署長簡單說明一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147816/150.wav", + "text": "麻煩署長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147816/151.wav", + "text": "好非常謝謝委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147816/152.wav", + "text": "我們真的很努力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147816/153.wav", + "text": "然後薪水當然跟業界沒得比" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147816/154.wav", + "text": "但是我們現在很努力地透過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147816/155.wav", + "text": "讓他更有未來的發展力等等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147816/156.wav", + "text": "所以我們現在的到職率有到80%" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147816/157.wav", + "text": "好部長我覺得資安署人力要趕快補充" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147816/158.wav", + "text": "針對資安署人力不足" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147816/159.wav", + "text": "我有二個簡單的建議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147816/160.wav", + "text": "資訊人員適用公務人員專業加給" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147816/161.wav", + "text": "給做為基礎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147816/162.wav", + "text": "針對資通安全人才來調整專業加給這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147816/163.wav", + "text": "徵才的競爭力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147816/164.wav", + "text": "第二必須規劃出具體的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147816/165.wav", + "text": "資通安全研習課程" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147816/166.wav", + "text": "鼓勵非資訊專業出身的公務人員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147816/167.wav", + "text": "來上課進修" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147816/168.wav", + "text": "和基本能力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147816/169.wav", + "text": "部長說明一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147816/170.wav", + "text": "是我想委員提的這個方向非常好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147816/171.wav", + "text": "我們明年度也有編列相關的預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147816/172.wav", + "text": "就是希望有興趣轉職" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147816/173.wav", + "text": "成為表(二十)資訊人員的公務同仁" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147816/174.wav", + "text": "都可以透過進修的方式來達到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147815/0.wav", + "text": "主席早安有請部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147815/1.wav", + "text": "有請林部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147815/2.wav", + "text": "委員早" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147815/3.wav", + "text": "部長早安" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147815/4.wav", + "text": "針對宜蘭縣內的一些需求" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147815/5.wav", + "text": "剛剛王美惠委員也有提到也" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147815/6.wav", + "text": "通學廊道的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147815/7.wav", + "text": "其實這部分對地方來說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147815/8.wav", + "text": "確實是非常重要的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147815/9.wav", + "text": "正在推動校園周邊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147815/10.wav", + "text": "道路改善計畫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147815/11.wav", + "text": "從113年到116年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147815/12.wav", + "text": "總共有400億的預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147815/13.wav", + "text": "周邊道路的安全" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147815/14.wav", + "text": "改善學童用路的空間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147815/15.wav", + "text": "新的預算評估報告裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147815/16.wav", + "text": "可以看到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147815/17.wav", + "text": "各縣市已經提報的件數" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147815/18.wav", + "text": "和已經核定的件數比率" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147815/19.wav", + "text": "提到嘉義市的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147815/20.wav", + "text": "也算是倒數幾" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147815/21.wav", + "text": "幾名從這張圖表來觀察" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147815/22.wav", + "text": "宜蘭縣各學校目前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147815/23.wav", + "text": "提了21個案件" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147815/24.wav", + "text": "只有被核定12件" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147815/25.wav", + "text": "核定的比率只有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147815/26.wav", + "text": "57%" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147815/27.wav", + "text": "未核定比率位列全臺縣市" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147815/28.wav", + "text": "倒數第三" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147815/29.wav", + "text": "遠比平均被核定比率" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147815/30.wav", + "text": "也有到宜蘭羅東國小" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147815/31.wav", + "text": "及成功國小會勘" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147815/32.wav", + "text": "鼓勵宜蘭縣政府可以積極" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147815/33.wav", + "text": "提出計畫來解決" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147815/34.wav", + "text": "行人的困擾" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147815/35.wav", + "text": "但是很遺憾雖然宜蘭的學校" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147815/36.wav", + "text": "一直都非常積極" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147815/37.wav", + "text": "但是提到現在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147815/38.wav", + "text": "內政部有一些都還沒有核定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147815/39.wav", + "text": "學童的安全應該要怎麼辦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147815/40.wav", + "text": "這項計畫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147815/41.wav", + "text": "也非常高" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147815/42.wav", + "text": "我只是想要請教部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147815/43.wav", + "text": "率是倒數的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147815/44.wav", + "text": "提案的內容" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147815/45.wav", + "text": "提案的劃定範圍" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147815/46.wav", + "text": "有一些問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147815/47.wav", + "text": "從中央的角度我們非常願意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147815/48.wav", + "text": "這項政策經費也沒有問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147815/49.wav", + "text": "不過我們非常希望地方政府提案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147815/50.wav", + "text": "的水準和整體規劃" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147815/51.wav", + "text": "的時候速度就會很快" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147815/52.wav", + "text": "如果提案的內容範圍" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147815/53.wav", + "text": "不完整的話那速度就會慢了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147815/54.wav", + "text": "謝謝部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147815/55.wav", + "text": "曾到宜蘭市的凱旋國小" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147815/56.wav", + "text": "縣府旁邊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147815/57.wav", + "text": "小則是位於蘇澳鎮我覺得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147815/58.wav", + "text": "得像這些學校" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147815/59.wav", + "text": "原先的狀況都滿適合" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147815/60.wav", + "text": "在這中間我想要請" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147815/61.wav", + "text": "縣府的溝通上可能要麻煩幫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147815/62.wav", + "text": "我們多加強輔導" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147815/63.wav", + "text": "就像部長剛才說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147815/64.wav", + "text": "的立意很好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147815/65.wav", + "text": "但有時候件數這樣來來回回" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147815/66.wav", + "text": "實在有一點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147815/67.wav", + "text": "真正該改的地方所以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147815/68.wav", + "text": "以就會拖到時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147815/69.wav", + "text": "針對這部分如果縣府這邊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147815/70.wav", + "text": "我覺得不是送件而已" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147815/71.wav", + "text": "出之前到底遇到什麼問題可能要麻煩" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147815/72.wav", + "text": "地方在送件的速度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147815/73.wav", + "text": "上面要改的部分就說白" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147815/74.wav", + "text": "一點不要來來回回" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147815/75.wav", + "text": "就趕快教一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147815/76.wav", + "text": "我覺得這樣比較快" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147815/77.wav", + "text": "可不可以請部長承諾做相關的協助" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147815/78.wav", + "text": "會的我們都會來協助和輔導" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147815/79.wav", + "text": "謝謝部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147815/80.wav", + "text": "再麻煩部長和署長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147815/81.wav", + "text": "謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147815/82.wav", + "text": "\n再來要非常謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147815/83.wav", + "text": "生活圈道路計畫的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147815/84.wav", + "text": "之前本席在這邊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147815/85.wav", + "text": "也問過非常多次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147815/86.wav", + "text": "在此要感謝部長的幫忙" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147815/87.wav", + "text": "應該已經有一些進展" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147815/88.wav", + "text": "就是這個禮拜即將要開幕" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147815/89.wav", + "text": "的轉運站附近週遭的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147815/90.wav", + "text": "這邊不要塞車會有一個好的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147815/91.wav", + "text": "轉運站包括週遭的道路" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147815/92.wav", + "text": "都可以進行相關改善" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147815/93.wav", + "text": "提出這個問題之後你們也非常關心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147815/94.wav", + "text": "這個部分是不是可以請部長說明一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147815/95.wav", + "text": "這個已經審得差不多了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147815/96.wav", + "text": "經費是三億多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147815/97.wav", + "text": "我想基本上沒有問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147815/98.wav", + "text": "還有一些地方配合款的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147815/99.wav", + "text": "\n再來我想提一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147815/100.wav", + "text": "對宜蘭交通改善的方向" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147815/101.wav", + "text": "到底它重視的是什麼樣的區塊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147815/102.wav", + "text": "應該是縣內的運輸" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147815/103.wav", + "text": "還是市區間的運輸" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147815/104.wav", + "text": "對宜蘭縣的區域發展" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147815/105.wav", + "text": "定位比較偏重" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147815/106.wav", + "text": "為主像大家討論比較多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147815/107.wav", + "text": "的都是國道5號和高鐵" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147815/108.wav", + "text": "要不要來宜蘭" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147815/109.wav", + "text": "所以今天我想就教兩個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147815/110.wav", + "text": "一個部分是市區的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147815/111.wav", + "text": "有一點微幅的下降" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147815/112.wav", + "text": "一直很關心有關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147815/113.wav", + "text": "針對這兩個部分想要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147815/114.wav", + "text": "請教部長它有可能在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147815/115.wav", + "text": "生活圈道路的計畫裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147815/116.wav", + "text": "做一併的思考" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147815/117.wav", + "text": "嗎宜4宜6現在當然有在做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147815/118.wav", + "text": "但是像宜4的拓寬只有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147815/119.wav", + "text": "前面這一段" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147815/120.wav", + "text": "後面那一段其實是沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147815/121.wav", + "text": "生活圈道路的方式來做相關的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147815/122.wav", + "text": "都非常塞如果它可以納進" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147815/123.wav", + "text": "生活圈道路的計畫或許" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147815/124.wav", + "text": "可以解決地方長期" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147815/125.wav", + "text": "一直希望它拓寬的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147815/126.wav", + "text": "如果是在都市計畫內的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147815/127.wav", + "text": "當然是我們國土管理署的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147815/128.wav", + "text": "權責如果是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147815/129.wav", + "text": "都市計畫外這看起來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147815/130.wav", + "text": "像都市計畫外" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147815/131.wav", + "text": "我們再確認一下如果是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147815/132.wav", + "text": "都市計畫內的話我們當然可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147815/133.wav", + "text": "來協助但如果是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147815/134.wav", + "text": "都外的話就是歸公路總局" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147815/135.wav", + "text": "好那就麻煩" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147815/136.wav", + "text": "完之後也請給" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147815/137.wav", + "text": "本席辦公室一份" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147815/138.wav", + "text": "份報告看看能不能" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147815/139.wav", + "text": "題謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147815/140.wav", + "text": "謝謝謝謝陳琬惠委員接下來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147815/141.wav", + "text": "請張宏陸委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147814/0.wav", + "text": "謝謝召委有請部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147814/1.wav", + "text": "部長好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147814/2.wav", + "text": "部長我就接續剛剛吳斯" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147814/3.wav", + "text": "吳斯懷委員也在關心的事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147814/4.wav", + "text": "曾經因為俄烏戰爭等等而" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147814/5.wav", + "text": "而有所延遲" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147814/6.wav", + "text": "會不會影響到美國對臺的支援" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147814/7.wav", + "text": "或是協助呢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147814/8.wav", + "text": "跟委員報告初步來看的話應該不會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147814/9.wav", + "text": "因為以色列這個國家本身的軍事裝備" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147814/10.wav", + "text": "囤儲各方面是還滿豐厚的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147814/11.wav", + "text": "當然我們也不樂見再有這種狀況發生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147814/12.wav", + "text": "密切注意當中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147814/13.wav", + "text": "到目前為止沒有這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147814/14.wav", + "text": "所以我們會準備好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147814/15.wav", + "text": "就是此外我們也看到了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147814/16.wav", + "text": "不小心誤擊1艘賞鯨船" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147814/17.wav", + "text": "其實本席比較在意的是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147814/18.wav", + "text": "其實非常地謹慎和小心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147814/19.wav", + "text": "在射擊通報的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147814/20.wav", + "text": "也會通報港務局漁業署海巡署等單位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147814/21.wav", + "text": "必要的時候也會有一些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147814/22.wav", + "text": "比如說兩棲的海龍部隊會在旁警戒" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147814/23.wav", + "text": "但是船舶誤闖射擊管制區的事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147814/24.wav", + "text": "其實是時有所聞的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147814/25.wav", + "text": "我想請教部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147814/26.wav", + "text": "對於蓄意不聽勸阻" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147814/27.wav", + "text": "闖入射擊管制海域的船隻" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147814/28.wav", + "text": "現在好像只有用社維法第71條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147814/29.wav", + "text": "對於這樣的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147814/30.wav", + "text": "我們除了加派兵力警戒之外" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147814/31.wav", + "text": "國防部有沒有思考到其他的解決辦法呢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147814/32.wav", + "text": "我跟委員報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147814/33.wav", + "text": "臺灣就這麼大的地方" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147814/34.wav", + "text": "不管是平常土地的運用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147814/35.wav", + "text": "或者海上運用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147814/36.wav", + "text": "只要一牽扯到射擊的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147814/37.wav", + "text": "多多少少都會帶給民間一些困擾" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147814/38.wav", + "text": "我們也很有這個經驗" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147814/39.wav", + "text": "更加知道平常要做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147814/40.wav", + "text": "很好的溝通協調" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147814/41.wav", + "text": "事實上這個地方我們也行之多年了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147814/42.wav", + "text": "從民國62年就在這個地方做實驗" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147814/43.wav", + "text": "其他大概不會有什麼問題發生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147814/44.wav", + "text": "所以這一回發生這件事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147814/45.wav", + "text": "我們並沒有說不是我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147814/46.wav", + "text": "但我也沒說國軍有什麼疏失" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147814/47.wav", + "text": "所以剛才把這個問題講得很清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147814/48.wav", + "text": "就是幾個單位大家共同來看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147814/49.wav", + "text": "都覺得滿訝異的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147814/50.wav", + "text": "對所以現在還在查證當中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147814/51.wav", + "text": "題說迫擊砲假彈誤擊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147814/52.wav", + "text": "國軍認疏失" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147814/53.wav", + "text": "我們要查證" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147814/54.wav", + "text": "所以對於為什麼會搞得紛紛擾擾呢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147814/55.wav", + "text": "比較周延保守一點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147814/56.wav", + "text": "可是我們要講得很周延" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147814/57.wav", + "text": "它的標題一出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147814/58.wav", + "text": "也是訓練課題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147814/59.wav", + "text": "我們也沒什麼好抱怨的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147814/60.wav", + "text": "就把它當作是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147814/61.wav", + "text": "對我們同仁訓練的一個課題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147814/62.wav", + "text": "是不過我倒是建議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147814/63.wav", + "text": "啦因為我們對於這種" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147814/64.wav", + "text": "規範不明確的情形" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147814/65.wav", + "text": "我知道國防部已經提了一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147814/66.wav", + "text": "軍事營區安全維護條例草案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147814/67.wav", + "text": "已經到院了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147814/68.wav", + "text": "劃入軍事營區的定義" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147814/69.wav", + "text": "但是對於未經許可進入軍事園區的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147814/70.wav", + "text": "只有行政處罰" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147814/71.wav", + "text": "本席實在認為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147814/72.wav", + "text": "還是可以考慮其他" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147814/73.wav", + "text": "比較具有嚇阻作用的一些刑罰" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147814/74.wav", + "text": "也請部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147814/75.wav", + "text": "跟蔡總統大軍談的時機" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147814/76.wav", + "text": "把這個條例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147814/77.wav", + "text": "列為這個會期的優先法案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147814/78.wav", + "text": "這個著眼不是要限制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147814/79.wav", + "text": "而是為了要維護他的安全" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147814/80.wav", + "text": "歷年來我們每次演訓" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147814/81.wav", + "text": "大概都可以做得還不錯" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147814/82.wav", + "text": "偶爾會有一些突然冒泡的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147814/83.wav", + "text": "這會影響到他的安全" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147814/84.wav", + "text": "也影響到我們進度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147814/85.wav", + "text": "這我們一定要持續努力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147814/86.wav", + "text": "假如說你違背了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147814/87.wav", + "text": "你不能講你不知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147814/88.wav", + "text": "我們公告了該要罰或是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147814/89.wav", + "text": "該要怎麼樣的強硬措施" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147814/90.wav", + "text": "我們也一併把它擺進去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147814/91.wav", + "text": "好剛剛其實吳委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147814/92.wav", + "text": "他們都有提到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147814/93.wav", + "text": "我們在行使立法委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147814/94.wav", + "text": "職權的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147814/95.wav", + "text": "很多名嘴都是無的放矢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147814/96.wav", + "text": "廣義的國防部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147814/97.wav", + "text": "所聘用的這些人員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147814/98.wav", + "text": "但是我覺得像" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147814/99.wav", + "text": "或政論節目上面講的這些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147814/100.wav", + "text": "其實本席覺得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147814/101.wav", + "text": "這已經是分化" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147814/102.wav", + "text": "我們退伍軍人的團結" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147814/103.wav", + "text": "因為我們就看到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147814/104.wav", + "text": "海陸大戰都已經出來了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147814/105.wav", + "text": "或者是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147814/106.wav", + "text": "這些都有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147814/107.wav", + "text": "但是我覺得有些事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147814/108.wav", + "text": "國防部有政治作戰局" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147814/109.wav", + "text": "對於這種可能會形成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147814/110.wav", + "text": "一些分化的言論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147814/111.wav", + "text": "我覺得應該要有立場" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147814/112.wav", + "text": "應該要有說法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147814/113.wav", + "text": "我跟委員報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147814/114.wav", + "text": "其實有時候名嘴專家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147814/115.wav", + "text": "從我們軍中出去的同仁袍澤" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147814/116.wav", + "text": "我們也覺得滿遺憾的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147814/117.wav", + "text": "但我有兩個做法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147814/118.wav", + "text": "第一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147814/119.wav", + "text": "聽他講了以後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147814/120.wav", + "text": "我們把他列進去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147814/121.wav", + "text": "我們要查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147814/122.wav", + "text": "不講為了提告與否" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147814/123.wav", + "text": "我們也的確要站住立場" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147814/124.wav", + "text": "有沒有這種事情發生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147814/125.wav", + "text": "有的話我們要改" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147814/126.wav", + "text": "第一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147814/127.wav", + "text": "我也跟我們現役同仁講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147814/128.wav", + "text": "前面都有案子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147814/129.wav", + "text": "嘛大家也搞得很難過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147814/130.wav", + "text": "我們袍澤之間不應該" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147814/131.wav", + "text": "落到這種地步" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147814/132.wav", + "text": "我希望我們現在退伍的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147814/133.wav", + "text": "不管是軍官或士官兵" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147814/134.wav", + "text": "也好有前面這些例子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147814/135.wav", + "text": "可以參考的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147814/136.wav", + "text": "可以做一個很好的定論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147814/137.wav", + "text": "要不要再採取這些方法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147814/138.wav", + "text": "來表達個人意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147814/139.wav", + "text": "我是覺得滿遺憾的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147814/140.wav", + "text": "看到都是以前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147814/141.wav", + "text": "以前有些同仁都認得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147814/142.wav", + "text": "我還是很希望在這個時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147814/143.wav", + "text": "我們全國所有國軍都要團結" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147814/144.wav", + "text": "我自己都認為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147814/145.wav", + "text": "我是軍警一家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147814/146.wav", + "text": "我都非常非常在意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147814/147.wav", + "text": "我們國軍弟兄" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147814/148.wav", + "text": "在這裡面受到任何的傷害" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147814/149.wav", + "text": "因此我也懇求國防部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147814/150.wav", + "text": "一定要據理力爭" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147814/151.wav", + "text": "啊尤其這個戰鬥加給" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147814/152.wav", + "text": "我剛剛也聽到部長在回答" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147814/153.wav", + "text": "包括像憲兵" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147814/154.wav", + "text": "我們很多人在幫憲兵講話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147814/155.wav", + "text": "military police" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147814/156.wav", + "text": "所以跟我還更近一點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147814/157.wav", + "text": "\n其實所有的軍種" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147814/158.wav", + "text": "在整個總體作戰裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147814/159.wav", + "text": "都扮演一樣重要的角色" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147814/160.wav", + "text": "所以戰鬥加給" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147814/161.wav", + "text": "偏重某一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147814/162.wav", + "text": "就像我們警察" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147814/163.wav", + "text": "不是只有鑑識人員重要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147814/164.wav", + "text": "第一線派出所的警員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147814/165.wav", + "text": "也是很重要的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147814/166.wav", + "text": "所以部長您在爭取的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147814/167.wav", + "text": "我當然知道人事總處" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147814/168.wav", + "text": "絕對一定會講什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147814/169.wav", + "text": "每次都用這種五四三的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147814/170.wav", + "text": "來打壓我們國軍" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147814/171.wav", + "text": "在爭取應該的加給上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147814/172.wav", + "text": "剛剛我還在內政委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147814/173.wav", + "text": "像我們警消" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147814/174.wav", + "text": "因公去搶救火災" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147814/175.wav", + "text": "或者是在槍戰之中受傷" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147814/176.wav", + "text": "你還把他視為是一般的公務人員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147814/177.wav", + "text": "什麼公傷假兩年的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147814/178.wav", + "text": "或者是還有什麼健保的潛規則" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147814/179.wav", + "text": "這實在是沒有正視到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147814/180.wav", + "text": "這些工作的特殊性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147814/181.wav", + "text": "所以務必要請部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147814/182.wav", + "text": "退役上校子女教育補助費的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147814/183.wav", + "text": "一定要幫我們的國軍袍澤" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147814/184.wav", + "text": "繼續再把聲量放大" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147814/185.wav", + "text": "我們做你的後盾好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147814/186.wav", + "text": "是謝謝委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147813/0.wav", + "text": "部長你好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147813/1.wav", + "text": "部長本席今天要先跟你探討租金補貼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147813/2.wav", + "text": "剛剛我也聽了你的工作報告你在業務報告裡有講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147813/3.wav", + "text": "或是結婚的租金補助" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147813/4.wav", + "text": "有看到地方的青年也好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147813/5.wav", + "text": "都有需要這個補助所以在2022年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147813/6.wav", + "text": "從111年到114年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147813/7.wav", + "text": "部長我是要跟你請教" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147813/8.wav", + "text": "據我所瞭解" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147813/9.wav", + "text": "3個月內" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147813/10.wav", + "text": "就會核定給他" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147813/11.wav", + "text": "第一階段" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147813/12.wav", + "text": "核定25萬3,0" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147813/13.wav", + "text": "54戶" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147813/14.wav", + "text": "還有23萬3,0" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147813/15.wav", + "text": "73戶" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147813/16.wav", + "text": "還沒有核定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147813/17.wav", + "text": "本席要跟部長請教" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147813/18.wav", + "text": "麼時候才有辦法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147813/19.wav", + "text": "核定跟" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147813/20.wav", + "text": "委員報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147813/21.wav", + "text": "的目標是55萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147813/22.wav", + "text": "已經核定的是26萬3,005戶" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147813/23.wav", + "text": "已經撥款的是25萬8,477戶" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147813/24.wav", + "text": "你剛剛提到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147813/25.wav", + "text": "10月份已經撥完的這個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147813/26.wav", + "text": "部長我現在是要問" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147813/27.wav", + "text": "我們現在正在加緊趕辦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147813/28.wav", + "text": "11月份的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147813/29.wav", + "text": "會把7月申請的所有戶數" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147813/30.wav", + "text": "11月份" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147813/31.wav", + "text": "因為本席在去年的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147813/32.wav", + "text": "就有提議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147813/33.wav", + "text": "就以申請那天為準" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147813/34.wav", + "text": "是不是這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147813/35.wav", + "text": "是是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147813/36.wav", + "text": "是嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147813/37.wav", + "text": "因為很多百姓都會煩惱" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147813/38.wav", + "text": "都會覺得我們做事" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147813/39.wav", + "text": "吞吞有的人會覺得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147813/40.wav", + "text": "到底你們錢是何時要給我部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147813/41.wav", + "text": "因為一般的百姓會這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147813/42.wav", + "text": "委員報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147813/43.wav", + "text": "我們其實速度已經很快了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147813/44.wav", + "text": "因為這要部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147813/45.wav", + "text": "你如果這樣講我不認同" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147813/46.wav", + "text": "沒有啦委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147813/47.wav", + "text": "講實在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147813/48.wav", + "text": "的我知道我們本身的辛苦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147813/49.wav", + "text": "不過有這麼多人來申請" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147813/50.wav", + "text": "七十幾萬人來申請" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147813/51.wav", + "text": "二十幾萬人要核定的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147813/52.wav", + "text": "不好意思剛剛講錯了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147813/53.wav", + "text": "那是中產的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147813/54.wav", + "text": "我們租金申請的部分是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147813/55.wav", + "text": "49萬多對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147813/56.wav", + "text": "將近50萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147813/57.wav", + "text": "不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147813/58.wav", + "text": "現在補助這個補助那" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147813/59.wav", + "text": "那個亂七八糟" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147813/60.wav", + "text": "煞我現在講的是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147813/61.wav", + "text": "你剛才也有講到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147813/62.wav", + "text": "到11月有辦法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147813/63.wav", + "text": "撥款給這些申請的人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147813/64.wav", + "text": "的艱苦人生活有困難" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147813/65.wav", + "text": "要非常留意要趕緊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147813/66.wav", + "text": "我們都寫3個月以內" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147813/67.wav", + "text": "可能不是3個月內" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147813/68.wav", + "text": "所以我們對這個要留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147813/69.wav", + "text": "意剛才部長所說的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147813/70.wav", + "text": "剛才他說的不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147813/71.wav", + "text": "將近50萬戶" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147813/72.wav", + "text": "到現在有23萬多戶" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147813/73.wav", + "text": "還沒補助讓" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147813/74.wav", + "text": "要趕快" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147813/75.wav", + "text": "確實因為包括舊的申請" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147813/76.wav", + "text": "戶他們的資格有的稍微有變動" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147813/77.wav", + "text": "所以那個過程中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147813/78.wav", + "text": "我們要再重複查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147813/79.wav", + "text": "也很注重" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147813/80.wav", + "text": "害怕有發生變動" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147813/81.wav", + "text": "是啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147813/82.wav", + "text": "差不了多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147813/83.wav", + "text": "少要有作為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147813/84.wav", + "text": "因為也有的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147813/85.wav", + "text": "事實上到現在有23萬多戶" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147813/86.wav", + "text": "我們會趕" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147813/87.wav", + "text": "要趕快" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147813/88.wav", + "text": "本席再問你一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147813/89.wav", + "text": "的206戶加144戶" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147813/90.wav", + "text": "卻差將近200戶" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147813/91.wav", + "text": "本席在這裡跟你探討" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147813/92.wav", + "text": "探討社會住宅" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147813/93.wav", + "text": "對嘉義市非常有幫助" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147813/94.wav", + "text": "是不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147813/95.wav", + "text": "我們可以找東區的土地再蓋" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147813/96.wav", + "text": "是小英總統的政見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147813/97.wav", + "text": "也是他想要幫助" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147813/98.wav", + "text": "青年也好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147813/99.wav", + "text": "是不是能夠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147813/100.wav", + "text": "好多謝委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147813/101.wav", + "text": "提醒我想這部分沒問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147813/102.wav", + "text": "我們來檢討" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147813/103.wav", + "text": "因為講實在嘉義市非常需要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147813/104.wav", + "text": "\n再來部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147813/105.wav", + "text": "到行人安全設施" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147813/106.wav", + "text": "當然我們是為了要保障" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147813/107.wav", + "text": "當然每一個縣市" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147813/108.wav", + "text": "罰款也都一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147813/109.wav", + "text": "不過在我們嘉義市的興業路也好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147813/110.wav", + "text": "垂楊路也好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147813/111.wav", + "text": "講實在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147813/112.wav", + "text": "讓人走沒有錯" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147813/113.wav", + "text": "我們要去保障他們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147813/114.wav", + "text": "但是嘉義市的環境" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147813/115.wav", + "text": "是騎機車的比開車的更多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147813/116.wav", + "text": "興業路被你們改的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147813/117.wav", + "text": "現在機車要和" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147813/118.wav", + "text": "我們要改" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147813/119.wav", + "text": "更好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147813/120.wav", + "text": "不是改的讓當地百姓" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147813/121.wav", + "text": "我們補助地方" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147813/122.wav", + "text": "我跟你報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147813/123.wav", + "text": "這些相關的案都是地方提出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147813/124.wav", + "text": "規劃設計" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147813/125.wav", + "text": "施工也都是地方政對啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147813/126.wav", + "text": "部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147813/127.wav", + "text": "我是要跟你講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147813/128.wav", + "text": "當然要做什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147813/129.wav", + "text": "是要地方縣市" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147813/130.wav", + "text": "計���送到我們這裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147813/131.wav", + "text": "審查完後才讓他們做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147813/132.wav", + "text": "不過不能" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147813/133.wav", + "text": "你們錢給他們就好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147813/134.wav", + "text": "你們委員也要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147813/135.wav", + "text": "是不是你們去瞭解一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147813/136.wav", + "text": "當然我們也要保障人行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147813/137.wav", + "text": "道行人行的安全" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147813/138.wav", + "text": "我們也會不忍心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147813/139.wav", + "text": "只是目前這裡騎機車的和" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147813/140.wav", + "text": "署長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147813/141.wav", + "text": "你應該是對嘉義市很瞭解的人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147813/142.wav", + "text": "我瞭解" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147813/143.wav", + "text": "我知道委員的意思" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147813/144.wav", + "text": "應該地方政府要更有彈性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147813/145.wav", + "text": "你補助的人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147813/146.wav", + "text": "讓它做得更好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147813/147.wav", + "text": "瞭解" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147813/148.wav", + "text": "這個部分我們接下來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147813/149.wav", + "text": "和市府進行業務探討的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147813/150.wav", + "text": "好拜託修正以後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147813/151.wav", + "text": "謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147813/152.wav", + "text": "謝謝王美惠委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147812/0.wav", + "text": "部長辛苦了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147812/1.wav", + "text": "我想剛剛吳委員也提到那個提案的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147812/2.wav", + "text": "真的我也一肚子火" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147812/3.wav", + "text": "好像被掃射到一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147812/4.wav", + "text": "其實我相信你當部長這麼久" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147812/5.wav", + "text": "從總長到部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147812/6.wav", + "text": "看到那麼多立法院的情況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147812/7.wav", + "text": "你非常了解" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147812/8.wav", + "text": "我們立法委員提案是正常的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147812/9.wav", + "text": "其實國防委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147812/10.wav", + "text": "包括外交外交可能還好啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147812/11.wav", + "text": "很多人都不願進來因為不熟" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147812/12.wav", + "text": "但我們是待久了也稍微熟" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147812/13.wav", + "text": "很多人還是不了解" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147812/14.wav", + "text": "國防部的預算怎麼去運作的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147812/15.wav", + "text": "或者是整個武器設備" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147812/16.wav", + "text": "提案是正常的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147812/17.wav", + "text": "執政黨要護航預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147812/18.wav", + "text": "但是也不能要求在野黨不准提預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147812/19.wav", + "text": "尤其機密預算都不准提" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147812/20.wav", + "text": "哇還把它統計出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147812/21.wav", + "text": "然後就開始打" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147812/22.wav", + "text": "我是覺得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147812/23.wav", + "text": "機密預算都是案號" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147812/24.wav", + "text": "都是代號" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147812/25.wav", + "text": "你們沒有去看其他委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147812/26.wav", + "text": "我們國防委員會提了幾個案子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147812/27.wav", + "text": "只是要求說明或了解" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147812/28.wav", + "text": "都不行嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147812/29.wav", + "text": "所以我是覺得莫名其妙" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147812/30.wav", + "text": "執政黨要護航也護航得太過頭了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147812/31.wav", + "text": "反而為難到國防部了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147812/32.wav", + "text": "為什麼大家都是變得意氣用事" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147812/33.wav", + "text": "所以我想部長應該都了解" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147812/34.wav", + "text": "我們很多提案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147812/35.wav", + "text": "即使是刪凍刪減" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147812/36.wav", + "text": "刪減比較少啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147812/37.wav", + "text": "而且召委都會說少刪一點少刪一點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147812/38.wav", + "text": "即使是凍結甚至有一些是撤案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147812/39.wav", + "text": "今兵凶戰危的時機當中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147812/40.wav", + "text": "國防自主大家非常支持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147812/41.wav", + "text": "但是有些不瞭解的地方" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147812/42.wav", + "text": "需要有績效的地方" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147812/43.wav", + "text": "絕對會在預算審查當中提出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147812/44.wav", + "text": "也希望各軍種提出說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147812/45.wav", + "text": "這是很簡單的邏輯" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147812/46.wav", + "text": "怎麼會搞得亂七八糟" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147812/47.wav", + "text": "是因為選舉的關係嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147812/48.wav", + "text": "我是覺得部長你委屈了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147812/49.wav", + "text": "但是我們也希望" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147812/50.wav", + "text": "不要特別針對個人在攻擊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147812/51.wav", + "text": "大家也不好看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147812/52.wav", + "text": "對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147812/53.wav", + "text": "我希望委員體諒" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147812/54.wav", + "text": "不過我跟委員插個口" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147812/55.wav", + "text": "事實上我並不覺得我很委屈" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147812/56.wav", + "text": "啦因為國防部也應該有這個責任" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147812/57.wav", + "text": "去做說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147812/58.wav", + "text": "也不願意造成紛紛擾擾" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147812/59.wav", + "text": "有些東西我們努力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147812/60.wav", + "text": "跟大家做說明以後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147812/61.wav", + "text": "就沒這個問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147812/62.wav", + "text": "所以國防部也有這個責任" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147812/63.wav", + "text": "你跟執政黨講一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147812/64.wav", + "text": "不要護航護得太厲害" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147812/65.wav", + "text": "這個法案的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147812/66.wav", + "text": "我的意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147812/67.wav", + "text": "部長你常常提" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147812/68.wav", + "text": "現在臺海戰場根本沒有前後方的關係" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147812/69.wav", + "text": "雖然我們一直強調" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147812/70.wav", + "text": "義務役大概是守備部隊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147812/71.wav", + "text": "志願役大概是主戰部隊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147812/72.wav", + "text": "但實際上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147812/73.wav", + "text": "說真的一發生戰事的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147812/74.wav", + "text": "真的不分前後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147812/75.wav", + "text": "我是支持你這個論點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147812/76.wav", + "text": "但是我希望瞭解的是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147812/77.wav", + "text": "守備部隊的訓練" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147812/78.wav", + "text": "主戰部隊的訓練一不一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147812/79.wav", + "text": "最大差別" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147812/80.wav", + "text": "就是他每一年度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147812/81.wav", + "text": "進入基地測考的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147812/82.wav", + "text": "就是主戰部隊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147812/83.wav", + "text": "守備部隊要轉成主戰部隊的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147812/84.wav", + "text": "怎麼去轉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147812/85.wav", + "text": "如果訓練不夠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147812/86.wav", + "text": "如何轉換" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147812/87.wav", + "text": "由這個問題再講到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147812/88.wav", + "text": "今天的法案審查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147812/89.wav", + "text": "現在義務役已經要改成1年但" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147812/90.wav", + "text": "志願役和義務役還是有差別的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147812/91.wav", + "text": "但我覺得對志願役的軍士官兵來講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147812/92.wav", + "text": "真的要調薪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147812/93.wav", + "text": "剛剛有講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147812/94.wav", + "text": "人事總處一直再把你們退" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147812/95.wav", + "text": "或公務人員的4%有沒有調" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147812/96.wav", + "text": "但是一些加給也該調了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147812/97.wav", + "text": "應該要做調整了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147812/98.wav", + "text": "因為人事總處常常用它的觀點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147812/99.wav", + "text": "來看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147812/100.wav", + "text": "但實際上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147812/101.wav", + "text": "國防部的軍士官兵" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147812/102.wav", + "text": "尤其是志願役完全都不一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147812/103.wav", + "text": "除了基本的調薪之外" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147812/104.wav", + "text": "我覺得加給也要做一些調整" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147812/105.wav", + "text": "\n我舉一個簡單的例子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147812/106.wav", + "text": "兵到將官都是統一1萬元" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147812/107.wav", + "text": "的加給剛剛一疊的加給我都看不懂" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147812/108.wav", + "text": "有地勤加給" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147812/109.wav", + "text": "給空勤加給" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147812/110.wav", + "text": "聘僱加給" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147812/111.wav", + "text": "等還有新增留營慰助金" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147812/112.wav", + "text": "元新增網路戰加給是5,000到5萬元" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147812/113.wav", + "text": "元��兵士官督導長主管加給" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147812/114.wav", + "text": "士官長專業加給" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147812/115.wav", + "text": "那個級距那麼大" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147812/116.wav", + "text": "每個人到底是領什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147812/117.wav", + "text": "說真的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147812/118.wav", + "text": "我想幫你們調薪要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147812/119.wav", + "text": "我還不曉得從何下手" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147812/120.wav", + "text": "就是希望你們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147812/121.wav", + "text": "在專業加給這一塊重新檢討" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147812/122.wav", + "text": "有的可能112年有調整" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147812/123.wav", + "text": "了可是有的大概" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147812/124.wav", + "text": "5年10年都沒有做調整了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147812/125.wav", + "text": "了這樣怎麼會招得到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147812/126.wav", + "text": "志願役的士兵" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147812/127.wav", + "text": "或者是士官呢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147812/128.wav", + "text": "因為實際上薪水是差不多的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147812/129.wav", + "text": "是二萬多三萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147812/130.wav", + "text": "志願役士兵的責任訓練" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147812/131.wav", + "text": "各方面都是加重非常多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147812/132.wav", + "text": "的不像義務役一年就走了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147812/133.wav", + "text": "對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147812/134.wav", + "text": "最多是教召而已" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147812/135.wav", + "text": "如何去說服人事總處" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147812/136.wav", + "text": "或者是直接由我們做決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147812/137.wav", + "text": "要求人事總處" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147812/138.wav", + "text": "進行你們加給的調整" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147812/139.wav", + "text": "至於怎麼做合理的調整" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147812/140.wav", + "text": "或是相關單位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147812/141.wav", + "text": "初步的規劃給你們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147812/142.wav", + "text": "絕對招不到兵" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147812/143.wav", + "text": "在兵凶戰危" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147812/144.wav", + "text": "家長也怕" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147812/145.wav", + "text": "那年輕人怎麼想" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147812/146.wav", + "text": "他幹麼負這個責任" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147812/147.wav", + "text": "當然還是留得下來一些人才" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147812/148.wav", + "text": "不然攬才留才都很難的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147812/149.wav", + "text": "部長你講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147812/150.wav", + "text": "我跟委員簡單報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147812/151.wav", + "text": "事實上國軍的加給" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147812/152.wav", + "text": "給不亂有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147812/153.wav", + "text": "有分地區" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147812/154.wav", + "text": "有分部隊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147812/155.wav", + "text": "有分專業" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147812/156.wav", + "text": "所以我們也不多講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147812/157.wav", + "text": "而且這裡面還包含年資" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147812/158.wav", + "text": "有分多少年資" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147812/159.wav", + "text": "但是現在委員也是好意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147812/160.wav", + "text": "對提升我們不管是各種加給" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147812/161.wav", + "text": "志願役" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147812/162.wav", + "text": "最高跟最低" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147812/163.wav", + "text": "也算是一個加的方法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147812/164.wav", + "text": "這都是可以研議的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147812/165.wav", + "text": "可是就像你們的專業加給" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147812/166.wav", + "text": "給大大小小" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147812/167.wav", + "text": "統統1萬元也怪怪的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147812/168.wav", + "text": "將軍的責任跟兵的責任" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147812/169.wav", + "text": "總是不一樣以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147812/170.wav", + "text": "以這個例子來講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147812/171.wav", + "text": "我覺得都有調整的必要性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147812/172.wav", + "text": "不積極的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147812/173.wav", + "text": "人事總處根本不把你看在眼裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147812/174.wav", + "text": "永遠不會幫你們調整加給" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147812/175.wav", + "text": "我舉一個簡單例子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147812/176.wav", + "text": "今天海巡也有到場" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147812/177.wav", + "text": "海巡裡面有從" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147812/178.wav", + "text": "轉任的現在稱為海巡署" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147812/179.wav", + "text": "有分海巡和岸巡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147812/180.wav", + "text": "岸巡是國防部的軍" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147812/181.wav", + "text": "士兵也有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147812/182.wav", + "text": "對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147812/183.wav", + "text": "他也是算軍種他" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147812/184.wav", + "text": "軍職" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147812/185.wav", + "text": "他是有軍職的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147812/186.wav", + "text": "有軍職的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147812/187.wav", + "text": "對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147812/188.wav", + "text": "有公務人員招募進來但是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147812/189.wav", + "text": "三種人的薪水不一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147812/190.wav", + "text": "沒錯" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147812/191.wav", + "text": "最差的就是軍職" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147812/192.wav", + "text": "所以他做得很叉叉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147812/193.wav", + "text": "人都覺得不想當了因為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147812/194.wav", + "text": "人少事多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147812/195.wav", + "text": "要做的做得要死" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147812/196.wav", + "text": "不做的就在那邊閒著" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147812/197.wav", + "text": "所以很多人就離職了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147812/198.wav", + "text": "為什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147812/199.wav", + "text": "同一個單位裡面的人領得少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147812/200.wav", + "text": "保七的領得多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147812/201.wav", + "text": "就像我剛剛講的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147812/202.wav", + "text": "你們的夜點費是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147812/203.wav", + "text": "4個小時60元但" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147812/204.wav", + "text": "他們是按公務人員的加班費計算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147812/205.wav", + "text": "所以單單這種差距" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147812/206.wav", + "text": "我就搞不清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147812/207.wav", + "text": "為什麼會不一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147812/208.wav", + "text": "能不能整合" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147812/209.wav", + "text": "當然要看政府到底是什麼態度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147812/210.wav", + "text": "跟公務人員體系招募的都不一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147812/211.wav", + "text": "我覺得很怪異啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147812/212.wav", + "text": "\n總而言之" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147812/213.wav", + "text": "我希望國防部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147812/214.wav", + "text": "還是好好的把所" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147812/215.wav", + "text": "加給整理一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147812/216.wav", + "text": "尤其是基礎的加給" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147812/217.wav", + "text": "招募的兵士官" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147812/218.wav", + "text": "可能要稍微提升一點點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147812/219.wav", + "text": "他們才有意願" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147812/220.wav", + "text": "也招不到士官嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147812/221.wav", + "text": "你沒有把薪資提高的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147812/222.wav", + "text": "工作價值感就低\n" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147812/223.wav", + "text": "另外因為時間關係" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147812/224.wav", + "text": "有空跟我解釋一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147812/225.wav", + "text": "或者是等一下在進行預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147812/226.wav", + "text": "指出2023到2026年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147812/227.wav", + "text": "00艘滾裝船" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147812/228.wav", + "text": "這個新聞一出來我" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147812/229.wav", + "text": "心如果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147812/230.wav", + "text": "他們是用軍管民用的方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147812/231.wav", + "text": "在港口海面上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147812/232.wav", + "text": "做集結的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147812/233.wav", + "text": "這樣我們怎麼因應" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147812/234.wav", + "text": "汰除濟陽級艦之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147812/235.wav", + "text": "未來的紀德級艦等等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147812/236.wav", + "text": "比較輕型的船艦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147812/237.wav", + "text": "都建造完成之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147812/238.wav", + "text": "未來可以做一些對抗" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147812/239.wav", + "text": "這種民船當軍船用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147812/240.wav", + "text": "當運補用的方式的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147812/241.wav", + "text": "不管是物資" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147812/242.wav", + "text": "都是用運補方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147812/243.wav", + "text": "在做部署的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147812/244.wav", + "text": "我們有沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147812/245.wav", + "text": "相信國防部也有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147812/246.wav", + "text": "有在注意這個消息" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147812/247.wav", + "text": "也要提醒一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147812/248.wav", + "text": "人家真的是無所不用其極" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147812/249.wav", + "text": "尤其是用運補的方式做結合" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147812/250.wav", + "text": "當然" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147812/251.wav", + "text": "我們也有我們的偵測方向" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147812/252.wav", + "text": "但是這一塊也希望國防部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147812/253.wav", + "text": "海軍給予說明好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147812/254.wav", + "text": "應該要做的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147812/255.wav", + "text": "這是本務工作" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147812/256.wav", + "text": "在得到以後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147812/257.wav", + "text": "因為一般民間會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147812/258.wav", + "text": "馬上把它變成一個議題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147812/259.wav", + "text": "事實上我們以前也做過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147812/260.wav", + "text": "滾裝貨輪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147812/261.wav", + "text": "裝貨裝人都可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147812/262.wav", + "text": "我們絕對不會掉以輕心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147812/263.wav", + "text": "只要對我們不利的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147812/264.wav", + "text": "只要對我們不利" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147812/265.wav", + "text": "我們都很謹慎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147812/266.wav", + "text": "來做評估" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147812/267.wav", + "text": "我們也要研發一個克制之道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147812/268.wav", + "text": "這是我們國軍的本務工作之一" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147812/269.wav", + "text": "好謝謝部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147811/0.wav", + "text": "好有請林部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147811/1.wav", + "text": "委員好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147811/2.wav", + "text": "部長好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147811/3.wav", + "text": "因為最近這個議題還是造成非常多爭議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147811/4.wav", + "text": "特別在桃園有非常多個案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147811/5.wav", + "text": "尤其是航空城的案子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147811/6.wav", + "text": "我稍微查了一下法令" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147811/7.wav", + "text": "常常都會徵收建築改良物" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147811/8.wav", + "text": "依照土地徵收條例第31條的規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147811/9.wav", + "text": "是用徵收當時的重建價格估定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147811/10.wav", + "text": "依照第3項的規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147811/11.wav", + "text": "查估的工作由地方政府來做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147811/12.wav", + "text": "依照土徵條例查估基準應該" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147811/13.wav", + "text": "由中央主管機關定之" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147811/14.wav", + "text": "定我們看到依照這個規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147811/15.wav", + "text": "訂定出來的建築改良物" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147811/16.wav", + "text": "徵收補償查估基準" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147811/17.wav", + "text": "從民國100年之後就沒有再修正過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147811/18.wav", + "text": "一直沿用到現在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147811/19.wav", + "text": "只有第四點的一句話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147811/20.wav", + "text": "建物重建價格之核算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147811/21.wav", + "text": "以拆除面積乘以重建單價計算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147811/22.wav", + "text": "當然拆除面積就是看你徵收多少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147811/23.wav", + "text": "嘛但是這個重建單價" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147811/24.wav", + "text": "又把它丟到由地方政府去訂" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147811/25.wav", + "text": "換句話說法律的授權本來是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147811/26.wav", + "text": "地方負責做執行的工作" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147811/27.wav", + "text": "但是怎麼計算重建價格" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147811/28.wav", + "text": "應該由中央來訂定這個標準" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147811/29.wav", + "text": "結果不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147811/30.wav", + "text": "啊所以現在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147811/31.wav", + "text": "很多案子都在爭議評點的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147811/32.wav", + "text": "都在爭議到底應該要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147811/33.wav", + "text": "依照什麼樣的方式來計算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147811/34.wav", + "text": "各縣市政府跟直轄市政府" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147811/35.wav", + "text": "在訂定這樣一個單價的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147811/36.wav", + "text": "事實上很多時候是互相比來比去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147811/37.wav", + "text": "不見得比較都會區的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147811/38.wav", + "text": "訂出來的單價就會比較高" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147811/39.wav", + "text": "就會造成很多人認為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147811/40.wav", + "text": "這個是有爭議的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147811/41.wav", + "text": "\n我們再看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147811/42.wav", + "text": "其實還有第二個問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147811/43.wav", + "text": "第一個問題是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147811/44.wav", + "text": "到底應不應該由中央統一來訂定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147811/45.wav", + "text": "依照建築的平均營建成本來訂" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147811/46.wav", + "text": "第二個問題是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147811/47.wav", + "text": "並沒有去區分一般徵收或區段徵收" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147811/48.wav", + "text": "也沒有去管量體的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147811/49.wav", + "text": "徵收當時的重建價格" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147811/50.wav", + "text": "事實上是會出問題的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147811/51.wav", + "text": "特別是區段徵收的情形" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147811/52.wav", + "text": "因為對於未來財務獲利的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147811/53.wav", + "text": "事實上都會比較保守" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147811/54.wav", + "text": "所以也造成地方政府有很多誘因" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147811/55.wav", + "text": "跟查估的時間點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147811/56.wav", + "text": "會造成很多時間差的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147811/57.wav", + "text": "所以這對民眾來講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147811/58.wav", + "text": "他的相對剝奪感很重" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147811/59.wav", + "text": "\n也就是說政府把我的土地" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147811/60.wav", + "text": "跟我的建物刻意地操作之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147811/61.wav", + "text": "讓我用比較低的價格" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147811/62.wav", + "text": "然後嘴巴上講說是重建價格" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147811/63.wav", + "text": "但事實上是如果我拿了你的補償" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147811/64.wav", + "text": "我在當時要去其他地方購買" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147811/65.wav", + "text": "房屋來居住的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147811/66.wav", + "text": "事實上經常都是不足的情形" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147811/67.wav", + "text": "所以這就是為什麼我會認為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147811/68.wav", + "text": "這麼多區段徵收案件" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147811/69.wav", + "text": "地主的第一個反應就是我不要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147811/70.wav", + "text": "因為太多的前例造成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147811/71.wav", + "text": "好像講得比較嚴重一點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147811/72.wav", + "text": "就是家破人亡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147811/73.wav", + "text": "住一輩子的房子被徵收掉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147811/74.wav", + "text": "結果這個案子又一直拖一直拖" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147811/75.wav", + "text": "\n我們知道一個徵收案件" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147811/76.wav", + "text": "至少都要三五年以上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147811/77.wav", + "text": "甚至像航空城這麼大" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147811/78.wav", + "text": "的做到10年20年都可能" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147811/79.wav", + "text": "大家一直在這個不確定的環境底下做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147811/80.wav", + "text": "從100年到現在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147811/81.wav", + "text": "甚至土徵條例這個規定得更久" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147811/82.wav", + "text": "這麼多的個案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147811/83.wav", + "text": "產生這麼多的爭議問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147811/84.wav", + "text": "為什麼從來沒有啟動去檢討" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147811/85.wav", + "text": "這樣的規定是否合適" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147811/86.wav", + "text": "\n從執行面我們發現非常多問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147811/87.wav", + "text": "因為這個表面上看起來好像合理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147811/88.wav", + "text": "在被徵收的這個過程裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147811/89.wav", + "text": "特別是希望我們要強調居住正義" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147811/90.wav", + "text": "但是我們卻沒有辦法用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147811/91.wav", + "text": "來確保我們的民眾被徵收之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147811/92.wav", + "text": "可以在沒有太多損失的情況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147811/93.wav", + "text": "不用再去貸款" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147811/94.wav", + "text": "他可以蓋回或買回一個跟自己" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147811/95.wav", + "text": "原來的房子水準相近的房子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147811/96.wav", + "text": "這個問題很嚴重部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147811/97.wav", + "text": "\n如果這個問題不改善的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147811/98.wav", + "text": "未來我相信除了抗爭行動不斷" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147811/99.wav", + "text": "國家要推動任何的建設" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147811/100.wav", + "text": "都會遇到愈來愈大的困難" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147811/101.wav", + "text": "甚至很多現在都會訴諸法院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147811/102.wav", + "text": "現在不管是都市計畫也好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147811/103.wav", + "text": "或是區段徵收也好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147811/104.wav", + "text": "事實上人民都可以上法院去討公道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147811/105.wav", + "text": "如果政府沒有做好因應的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147811/106.wav", + "text": "未來你有什麼計畫可以執行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147811/107.wav", + "text": "所以我是建議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147811/108.wav", + "text": "這個你們一定要好好去檢討" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147811/109.wav", + "text": "有沒有一個修法的方向可以提出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147811/110.wav", + "text": "我想這部分我先請司長回應" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147811/111.wav", + "text": "然後我再來作補充" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147811/112.wav", + "text": "跟委員說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147811/113.wav", + "text": "事實��整個不管是徵收的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147811/114.wav", + "text": "或是一般徵收的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147811/115.wav", + "text": "事實上也都是委託" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147811/116.wav", + "text": "是第一個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147811/117.wav", + "text": "每個建物的成本事實上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147811/118.wav", + "text": "所以這個部分我們是有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147811/119.wav", + "text": "建物的成本去做一些估價" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147811/120.wav", + "text": "\n至於委員提到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147811/121.wav", + "text": "我們是不是來訂一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147811/122.wav", + "text": "估價基準我們內政部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147811/123.wav", + "text": "是有訂一個基準在那邊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147811/124.wav", + "text": "如果說有必要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147811/125.wav", + "text": "我想我們會再來做一些修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147811/126.wav", + "text": "你那個基準的法令定得都很" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147811/127.wav", + "text": "那是一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147811/128.wav", + "text": "實施條文只有一條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147811/129.wav", + "text": "啊其他的實質的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147811/130.wav", + "text": "單價到底是怎麼樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147811/131.wav", + "text": "還是由地方政府去訂" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147811/132.wav", + "text": "對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147811/133.wav", + "text": "所以這等於是放棄自己的權利" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147811/134.wav", + "text": "嘛法律授權這個基準應該由你來訂" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147811/135.wav", + "text": "但是你說沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147811/136.wav", + "text": "沒有我們讓地方政府去訂" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147811/137.wav", + "text": "然後造成很多的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147811/138.wav", + "text": "實務上最大的問題是什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147811/139.wav", + "text": "現在都用所謂的評點制度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147811/140.wav", + "text": "評點制度有二個階段" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147811/141.wav", + "text": "第一個建物的某些結構" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147811/142.wav", + "text": "譬如樓地板" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147811/143.wav", + "text": "牆壁主結構多少點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147811/144.wav", + "text": "然後什麼多少點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147811/145.wav", + "text": "那些都是固定的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147811/146.wav", + "text": "然後再乘上這個評點的單價" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147811/147.wav", + "text": "在這個過程中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147811/148.wav", + "text": "人民被徵收的房屋" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147811/149.wav", + "text": "千奇什麼樣子都有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147811/150.wav", + "text": "所以很多時候都會說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147811/151.wav", + "text": "為什麼我這個不算進去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147811/152.wav", + "text": "為什麼我家的水井不能算進去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147811/153.wav", + "text": "為什麼我們其他的東西沒有算進去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147811/154.wav", + "text": "陽台為什麼沒有算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147811/155.wav", + "text": "甚至我做了很多比較高單價的裝潢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147811/156.wav", + "text": "或者是什麼都沒有算進去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147811/157.wav", + "text": "所以查估的過程沒有錯" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147811/158.wav", + "text": "估價師會來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147811/159.wav", + "text": "但卻不是用一般市場上的估價方式在估" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147811/160.wav", + "text": "而是用你們授權地方政府去訂的那個系統去估" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147811/161.wav", + "text": "事實上幾乎都是有落差的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147811/162.wav", + "text": "只會少不會多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147811/163.wav", + "text": "啦\n甚至民眾都還會拿出單據跟你講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147811/164.wav", + "text": "我當年就是花多少錢蓋這個東西" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147811/165.wav", + "text": "的為什麼你現在估給我的重建價格" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147811/166.wav", + "text": "遠遠低估我當初所花的費用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147811/167.wav", + "text": "又過二三十年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147811/168.wav", + "text": "甚至是四五十年的房子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147811/169.wav", + "text": "也還是一樣有這個問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147811/170.wav", + "text": "所以我是認為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147811/171.wav", + "text": "你們現在所定的這個所謂的基準" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147811/172.wav", + "text": "實在太簡陋了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147811/173.wav", + "text": "地方政府據以訂定的那個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147811/174.wav", + "text": "又跟實情有很大的落差" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147811/175.wav", + "text": "所以我是認為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147811/176.wav", + "text": "你們應該要把它詳列出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147811/177.wav", + "text": "好非常謝謝黃委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147811/178.wav", + "text": "我想有幾個部分要來做說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147811/179.wav", + "text": "第一個是民進黨政府非常重視人民的財產權" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147811/180.wav", + "text": "所以你剛剛提到了區段徵收" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147811/181.wav", + "text": "區段徵收有幾個重要的基本原則" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147811/182.wav", + "text": "第一個它必須要符合必要性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147811/183.wav", + "text": "所以剛剛你在講查估的這些細節" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147811/184.wav", + "text": "我想我會請地政司來做檢討" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147811/185.wav", + "text": "因為很多會在執行面的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147811/186.wav", + "text": "可能的確會發生一些問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147811/187.wav", + "text": "那我們會來做這個檢討" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147811/188.wav", + "text": "然後儘快地有一個新的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147811/189.wav", + "text": "基準或者是新的原則指引與規範出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147811/190.wav", + "text": "我們在下個月" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147811/191.wav", + "text": "希望在內委會針對這個議題開一個公聽會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147811/192.wav", + "text": "讓你們可以直接感受到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147811/193.wav", + "text": "我是認為因為這個問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147811/194.wav", + "text": "過去都讓地方政府自己去處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147811/195.wav", + "text": "但是現在已經變成不是地方政府能夠自己handle了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147811/196.wav", + "text": "你們的這個查估基準真的要重新檢討" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147811/197.wav", + "text": "因為造成太多問題了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147811/198.wav", + "text": "現在不要講航空城的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147811/199.wav", + "text": "為什麼龍科三期" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147811/200.wav", + "text": "乃至於其他很多的科學園區" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147811/201.wav", + "text": "過去為了國家產業發展要去推動的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147811/202.wav", + "text": "遇到的問題都一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147811/203.wav", + "text": "只要是區段徵收沒有一個沒有遇到這些相關問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147811/204.wav", + "text": "的但是我們的政府一直都沒有積極去檢討" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147811/205.wav", + "text": "你們在法令上面是不是真的造成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147811/206.wav", + "text": "了執行層面必然發生的這些問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147811/207.wav", + "text": "所以我是希望你們自己一定要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147811/208.wav", + "text": "把這個規定定好來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147811/209.wav", + "text": "以上謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147811/210.wav", + "text": "好謝謝黃世杰委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147811/211.wav", + "text": "\n現在有請王美惠委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147810/0.wav", + "text": "部長請" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147810/1.wav", + "text": "部長辛苦了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147810/2.wav", + "text": "首先我先問一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147810/3.wav", + "text": "國軍明年調薪4%" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147810/4.wav", + "text": "我要問退役軍人呢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147810/5.wav", + "text": "﹖當初年金改革的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147810/6.wav", + "text": "我從街頭到立法院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147810/7.wav", + "text": "極力為退伍軍人爭取" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147810/8.wav", + "text": "他應有的權益" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147810/9.wav", + "text": "現在已經在逐年刪減中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147810/10.wav", + "text": "現在現職增加了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147810/11.wav", + "text": "退役只有2%" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147810/12.wav", + "text": "我們再爭取可能沒有辦法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147810/13.wav", + "text": "但是我要問問部長的態度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147810/14.wav", + "text": "當年不同時期" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147810/15.wav", + "text": "時是同樣年資同樣階級" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147810/16.wav", + "text": "但是退休後領的退休金" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147810/17.wav", + "text": "這三年多我不斷地在爭取" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147810/18.wav", + "text": "但我想要聽聽國防部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147810/19.wav", + "text": "部長的意思" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147810/20.wav", + "text": "因為這個不是導正年金改革" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147810/21.wav", + "text": "缺失而已" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147810/22.wav", + "text": "大法官的釋憲案也有所說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147810/23.wav", + "text": "所以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147810/24.wav", + "text": "不要把退伍軍人跟現役軍人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147810/25.wav", + "text": "明顯的切割" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147810/26.wav", + "text": "每天每個月" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147810/27.wav", + "text": "每年都有退伍軍人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147810/28.wav", + "text": "每年也有新進人員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147810/29.wav", + "text": "你要照顧退役軍人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147810/30.wav", + "text": "就是讓現役軍人安心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147810/31.wav", + "text": "讓他退休後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147810/32.wav", + "text": "獲得足夠的保障" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147810/33.wav", + "text": "而不會溯及既往" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147810/34.wav", + "text": "就把它改掉了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147810/35.wav", + "text": "部長對這件事的看法呢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147810/36.wav", + "text": "我跟委員報告不管在役" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147810/37.wav", + "text": "或者退役" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147810/38.wav", + "text": "每個人不論有工作" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147810/39.wav", + "text": "或沒有工作" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147810/40.wav", + "text": "他養家活口這個任務" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147810/41.wav", + "text": "是不會脫掉的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147810/42.wav", + "text": "不是退了以後就不用生活" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147810/43.wav", + "text": "不用養家了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147810/44.wav", + "text": "所以對於他該有的權益" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147810/45.wav", + "text": "我們絕對要爭取" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147810/46.wav", + "text": "上升" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147810/47.wav", + "text": "生活步調各方面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147810/48.wav", + "text": "這個我希望你在行政院會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147810/49.wav", + "text": "或者軍事會談的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147810/50.wav", + "text": "跟蔡總統跟行政院好好爭取" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147810/51.wav", + "text": "這個不只關乎退伍軍人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147810/52.wav", + "text": "所以希望部長針對這方面繼續努力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147810/53.wav", + "text": "好的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147810/54.wav", + "text": "接著請問海基魚叉飛彈" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147810/55.wav", + "text": "之妥善率偏低" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147810/56.wav", + "text": "本屆航太展的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147810/57.wav", + "text": "國防部還不希望" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147810/58.wav", + "text": "增程型雄三去參展" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147810/59.wav", + "text": "因為怕洩密" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147810/60.wav", + "text": "但是從中科院的照片我們可以看到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147810/61.wav", + "text": "雄三雄二跟" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147810/62.wav", + "text": "魚叉的射擊成果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147810/63.wav", + "text": "但是我們也知道魚叉的妥善率" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147810/64.wav", + "text": "5年來都低於部頒標準" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147810/65.wav", + "text": "我們從媒體" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147810/66.wav", + "text": "知道的訊息是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147810/67.wav", + "text": "魚叉也可以打到300公里" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147810/68.wav", + "text": "但是美方賣我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147810/69.wav", + "text": "的是140的簡單版" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147810/70.wav", + "text": "是不是這回事" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147810/71.wav", + "text": "這是一個問題等一下一起回答" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147810/72.wav", + "text": "我們有各種國造的美製的武器" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147810/73.wav", + "text": "它的整體" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147810/74.wav", + "text": "系統整合的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147810/75.wav", + "text": "不要買到便宜的東西" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147810/76.wav", + "text": "結果系統整合花更多的錢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147810/77.wav", + "text": "從武器載台" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147810/78.wav", + "text": "所���這一方面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147810/79.wav", + "text": "我希望也能夠一併有個答案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147810/80.wav", + "text": "兵棋推演的結論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147810/81.wav", + "text": "歐美智庫都有評斷" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147810/82.wav", + "text": "共軍的船團一半" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147810/83.wav", + "text": "那麼至少要一倍以上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147810/84.wav", + "text": "有沒有一併思考" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147810/85.wav", + "text": "這幾個問題是不是可以一起回答" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147810/86.wav", + "text": "事實上我們雄二雄三" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147810/87.wav", + "text": "是自己國家所研發出來的裝備也是滿好的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147810/88.wav", + "text": "大家也一直在努力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147810/89.wav", + "text": "以後不管對它的量的提升" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147810/90.wav", + "text": "性能的提升" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147810/91.wav", + "text": "這個工作在海空戰力提升當中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147810/92.wav", + "text": "也是列進去的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147810/93.wav", + "text": "我想請海軍來跟你做說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147810/94.wav", + "text": "請參謀長簡短回答" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147810/95.wav", + "text": "報告委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147810/96.wav", + "text": "針對魚叉飛彈的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147810/97.wav", + "text": "目前我們在戰備彈數是沒有問題的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147810/98.wav", + "text": "但是妥善率就如同委員所說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147810/99.wav", + "text": "我們現在有一些關鍵" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147810/100.wav", + "text": "這個時間上面的確是有延遲" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147810/101.wav", + "text": "在今年年底到明年上半年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147810/102.wav", + "text": "會陸陸續續回來我們就可以完成恢復" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147810/103.wav", + "text": "魚叉的射程呢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147810/104.wav", + "text": "委員比您瞭解的要長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147810/105.wav", + "text": "要增加" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147810/106.wav", + "text": "好希望你們如實的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147810/107.wav", + "text": "面對這個問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147810/108.wav", + "text": "系統整合的問題呢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147810/109.wav", + "text": "報告委員您放心雄二雄三和魚叉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147810/110.wav", + "text": "叉的系統是一定要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147810/111.wav", + "text": "是一定要完成那完成了沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147810/112.wav", + "text": "現在初步階段已經完成了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147810/113.wav", + "text": "什麼時候大概可以完成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147810/114.wav", + "text": "我們的魚叉飛彈都到齊的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147810/115.wav", + "text": "就已經整合完成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147810/116.wav", + "text": "好希望部長能夠承認" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147810/117.wav", + "text": "這個承諾" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147810/118.wav", + "text": "接著我想問" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147810/119.wav", + "text": "這個問題本席" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147810/120.wav", + "text": "問好幾次了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147810/121.wav", + "text": "我們蔡政府這七年下了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147810/122.wav", + "text": "四百零多億美元的訂單" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147810/123.wav", + "text": "將近五成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147810/124.wav", + "text": "190億美元" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147810/125.wav", + "text": "就是五千八百多億臺幣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147810/126.wav", + "text": "是延遲交貨的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147810/127.wav", + "text": "我們算一算這個帳" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147810/128.wav", + "text": "李登輝執政" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147810/129.wav", + "text": "十二年軍購" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147810/130.wav", + "text": "的經費" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147810/131.wav", + "text": "陳水扁八年軍購" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147810/132.wav", + "text": "馬英九總統執政" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147810/133.wav", + "text": "預算降到205億美元" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147810/134.wav", + "text": "我們蔡總統執政" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147810/135.wav", + "text": "這七年而已" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147810/136.wav", + "text": "四百零多億美元" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147810/137.wav", + "text": "這是歷史新高" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147810/138.wav", + "text": "但是延遲交貨到將近50%" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147810/139.wav", + "text": "我們也瞭解" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147810/140.wav", + "text": "軍購是政府對政府" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147810/141.wav", + "text": "所以它沒有罰則" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147810/142.wav", + "text": "可是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147810/143.wav", + "text": "媒體跟民眾都不能接受" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147810/144.wav", + "text": "延宕得這麼厲害" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147810/145.wav", + "text": "這麼多的錢壓在那裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147810/146.wav", + "text": "影響我們的建軍備戰" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147810/147.wav", + "text": "但是我們對它" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147810/148.wav", + "text": "毫無辦法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147810/149.wav", + "text": "這部分我不曉得國防部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147810/150.wav", + "text": "有沒有採取較具體的措施" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147810/151.wav", + "text": "美國是我們堅定的盟友" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147810/152.wav", + "text": "光是一個軍備" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147810/153.wav", + "text": "你都給我們延遲到這個程度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147810/154.wav", + "text": "天天叫我們買這個買那個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147810/155.wav", + "text": "如期如質交貨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147810/156.wav", + "text": "我跟委員報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147810/157.wav", + "text": "當然我這邊不宜" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147810/158.wav", + "text": "多幫老美講話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147810/159.wav", + "text": "講了好像變成我們在幫它一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147810/160.wav", + "text": "事實上它的延宕" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147810/161.wav", + "text": "大家知道有一些是時間往後延" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147810/162.wav", + "text": "但整個終止的時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147810/163.wav", + "text": "並沒有變" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147810/164.wav", + "text": "當初我們也跟它談" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147810/165.wav", + "text": "很多管道不管是國安方面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147810/166.wav", + "text": "我們自己駐外方面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147810/167.wav", + "text": "我們是國防部跟國防部之間來談" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147810/168.wav", + "text": "都強調不能往後延" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147810/169.wav", + "text": "事實上它有很多因素" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147810/170.wav", + "text": "講了以後我們有些能接受" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147810/171.wav", + "text": "有些沒辦法接受" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147810/172.wav", + "text": "一直在努力當中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147810/173.wav", + "text": "但我跟委員保證" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147810/174.wav", + "text": "它所拖的時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147810/175.wav", + "text": "兩三年可以獲得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147810/176.wav", + "text": "最後的時間一直沒有變" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147810/177.wav", + "text": "我們絕對可能明年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147810/178.wav", + "text": "本來要交多少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147810/179.wav", + "text": "不要緊你總要有替代方案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147810/180.wav", + "text": "把一些模擬訓練器" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147810/181.wav", + "text": "這都是我們的作為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147810/182.wav", + "text": "我希望部長透過國安高層" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147810/183.wav", + "text": "要給美國一點壓力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147810/184.wav", + "text": "告訴它你是我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147810/185.wav", + "text": "最堅實的朋友" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147810/186.wav", + "text": "但是你的作為好像並沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147810/187.wav", + "text": "達到政治上的含義" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147810/188.wav", + "text": "\n最後一點點時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147810/189.wav", + "text": "我再請問部長一個問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147810/190.wav", + "text": "這段時間有關我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147810/191.wav", + "text": "預算凍結的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147810/192.wav", + "text": "執政黨的立委" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147810/193.wav", + "text": "批評我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147810/194.wav", + "text": "這是朝野對立" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147810/195.wav", + "text": "這個也無可厚非" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147810/196.wav", + "text": "但是有很多案子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147810/197.wav", + "text": "這些網路上的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147810/198.wav", + "text": "名嘴在那邊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147810/199.wav", + "text": "胡說八道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147810/200.wav", + "text": "指指點點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147810/201.wav", + "text": "這也就算了你國防部也管不到他" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147810/202.wav", + "text": "但是你國防研究院的這些人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147810/203.wav", + "text": "出來指指點點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147810/204.wav", + "text": "我就不能接受了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147810/205.wav", + "text": "我不曉得部長你管不管得到國防研究院的這些研究員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147810/206.wav", + "text": "我跟委員報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147810/207.wav", + "text": "第一個我表達一下我們國防部對於委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147810/208.wav", + "text": "剛剛也有很多媒體或者同仁也問過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147810/209.wav", + "text": "我想委員是依據" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147810/210.wav", + "text": "沒有什麼好意惡意的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147810/211.wav", + "text": "沒有這個問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147810/212.wav", + "text": "關於國防部的態度我也講過針對問題我們要給予答案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147810/213.wav", + "text": "要不斷解說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147810/214.wav", + "text": "所以我剛剛也一再強調從我擔任部長到現在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147810/215.wav", + "text": "我沒有遇到哪個委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147810/216.wav", + "text": "故意做刁難" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147810/217.wav", + "text": "他之所以會提出質疑的確" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147810/218.wav", + "text": "是民意所付託他的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147810/219.wav", + "text": "我只提醒部長一件事" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147810/220.wav", + "text": "立法委員你也管不到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147810/221.wav", + "text": "但是國防研究院的這些院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147810/222.wav", + "text": "研究員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147810/223.wav", + "text": "是國防部裡面的一員你管得到他" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147810/224.wav", + "text": "你叫他不要胡說八道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147810/225.wav", + "text": "講刺針飛彈" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147810/226.wav", + "text": "批評來批評去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147810/227.wav", + "text": "是怎麼樣我凍結你們的預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147810/228.wav", + "text": "你們有意見嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147810/229.wav", + "text": "如果你再讓這些國防部體制內的人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147810/230.wav", + "text": "在媒體放話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147810/231.wav", + "text": "我告訴部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147810/232.wav", + "text": "我就刪減全部預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147810/233.wav", + "text": "大家來談" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147810/234.wav", + "text": "你讓他們對我這個立法委員的凍結" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147810/235.wav", + "text": "有那麼多意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147810/236.wav", + "text": "那麼多指導" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147810/237.wav", + "text": "你是立法委員的上級單位指導我" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147810/238.wav", + "text": "你不可以這樣子你應該怎麼樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147810/239.wav", + "text": "你根本就不懂" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147810/240.wav", + "text": "這是你懂還是我懂" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147810/241.wav", + "text": "我不懂我管預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147810/242.wav", + "text": "我監督你們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147810/243.wav", + "text": "我當軍人四十四年我會不瞭解嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147810/244.wav", + "text": "所以我覺得部長約束一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147810/245.wav", + "text": "你部內管得到的人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147810/246.wav", + "text": "不要再對外講預算的事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147810/247.wav", + "text": "不要再講這些建軍的事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147810/248.wav", + "text": "他沒有資格對外" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147810/249.wav", + "text": "只有你有資格" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147810/250.wav", + "text": "只有發言人有資格" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147810/251.wav", + "text": "建議部長回去告訴他們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147810/252.wav", + "text": "不要再對外亂講話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147810/253.wav", + "text": "再指名道姓我就不客氣了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147810/254.wav", + "text": "我們有再好的交情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147810/255.wav", + "text": "再好的同袍情誼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147810/256.wav", + "text": "指名道姓污辱到我的人格和專業" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147810/257.wav", + "text": "很抱歉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147810/258.wav", + "text": "我還真沒注意到這一塊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147810/259.wav", + "text": "但我跟我們同仁強調" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147810/260.wav", + "text": "跟對外的講法都一致" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147810/261.wav", + "text": "委員有他的責任所在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147810/262.wav", + "text": "我們有這個責任" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147810/263.wav", + "text": "要做說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147810/264.wav", + "text": "沒有講哪一個人故意擋" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147810/265.wav", + "text": "絕對不會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147810/266.wav", + "text": "對我建議部長就告訴他們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147810/267.wav", + "text": "約束一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147810/268.wav", + "text": "政治上的操作我沒有意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147810/269.wav", + "text": "但是如果羞辱到我的人格" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147810/270.wav", + "text": "羞辱到我的專業" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147810/271.wav", + "text": "我在這邊很大聲的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147810/272.wav", + "text": "告訴各位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147810/273.wav", + "text": "邱先生你是認識我很多年的人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147810/274.wav", + "text": "在座的各位同仁" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147810/275.wav", + "text": "我們大家攤在檯面上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147810/276.wav", + "text": "跳出來比國防專業" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147810/277.wav", + "text": "我相信我不會輸你們幾個人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147810/278.wav", + "text": "那就來談嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147810/279.wav", + "text": "如果要跳到媒體上面對面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147810/280.wav", + "text": "我接受挑戰" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147810/281.wav", + "text": "大家來談" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147810/282.wav", + "text": "但是需要搞成這樣子嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147810/283.wav", + "text": "我這麼支持你們國防部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147810/284.wav", + "text": "所有的建軍備戰" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147810/285.wav", + "text": "我做多少球給你們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147810/286.wav", + "text": "我不忍心再苛責你們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147810/287.wav", + "text": "你們有多少為難之處我還不清楚嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147810/288.wav", + "text": "但是需要搞成這個樣子嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147810/289.wav", + "text": "不是對部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147810/290.wav", + "text": "我希望你好好約束一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147810/291.wav", + "text": "不要再對外放話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147810/292.wav", + "text": "再放話我就不客氣了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147810/293.wav", + "text": "我要維護我個人的尊嚴跟榮譽" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147810/294.wav", + "text": "還有我的專業好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147810/295.wav", + "text": "部長抱歉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147808/0.wav", + "text": "謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147808/1.wav", + "text": "部長請" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147808/2.wav", + "text": "部長請教一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147808/3.wav", + "text": "立法委員在立法院裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147808/4.wav", + "text": "對相關的國防預算提出" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147808/5.wav", + "text": "不管是刪除或者是凍結案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147808/6.wav", + "text": "你覺得這是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147808/7.wav", + "text": "或者反對國軍嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147808/8.wav", + "text": "我跟委員報告絕對不��這樣子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147808/9.wav", + "text": "我也跟外面媒體或者朋友" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147808/10.wav", + "text": "委員有這個責任" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147808/11.wav", + "text": "要監督我們國防" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147808/12.wav", + "text": "不管是預算的支用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147808/13.wav", + "text": "各方面工作推動" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147808/14.wav", + "text": "這是責任代表民意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147808/15.wav", + "text": "我們國防部也有責任" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147808/16.wav", + "text": "一定要把它講清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147808/17.wav", + "text": "造成誤會都不樂見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147808/18.wav", + "text": "所以目前我的認定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147808/19.wav", + "text": "是絕對沒有哪個委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147808/20.wav", + "text": "就算有要刪要減" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147808/21.wav", + "text": "他總有個理由" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147808/22.wav", + "text": "我們也要努力去說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147808/23.wav", + "text": "我們接觸到目前為止" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147808/24.wav", + "text": "只要說明得體" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147808/25.wav", + "text": "並沒有哪一個刻意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147808/26.wav", + "text": "在跟我們作對不會的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147808/27.wav", + "text": "好那就好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147808/28.wav", + "text": "當然大家都非常關心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147808/29.wav", + "text": "潛艦國造這個案子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147808/30.wav", + "text": "的確現在發展的方向" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147808/31.wav", + "text": "也不是太相同" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147808/32.wav", + "text": "會不會再有所謂的弊案發生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147808/33.wav", + "text": "因為過去也發生了相關的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147808/34.wav", + "text": "慶富案這些很多的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147808/35.wav", + "text": "由於黃曙光上將的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147808/36.wav", + "text": "發言的確引發" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147808/37.wav", + "text": "重大爭議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147808/38.wav", + "text": "這裡面包含賣臺" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147808/39.wav", + "text": "所以其實前二次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147808/40.wav", + "text": "本席在這邊質詢的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147808/41.wav", + "text": "都要求包含政戰總局" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147808/42.wav", + "text": "在內" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147808/43.wav", + "text": "必須好好去瞭解內部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147808/44.wav", + "text": "到底發生什麼問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147808/45.wav", + "text": "甚至於送到所謂中共大使館" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147808/46.wav", + "text": "桌上的資料" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147808/47.wav", + "text": "這是不是賣臺" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147808/48.wav", + "text": "是不是叛國" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147808/49.wav", + "text": "這是非常非常嚴重的部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147808/50.wav", + "text": "鬧到這種地步我們也要澈底檢討" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147808/51.wav", + "text": "事實上我個人接部長以後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147808/52.wav", + "text": "我給他們一個很強烈觀念" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147808/53.wav", + "text": "任何事情推動不要單一" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147808/54.wav", + "text": "單��" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147808/55.wav", + "text": "單線會出問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147808/56.wav", + "text": "該有調查的該有組紀的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147808/57.wav", + "text": "這些人都不能少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147808/58.wav", + "text": "為什麼因為大家參與了以後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147808/59.wav", + "text": "說這是機敏的找那麼多人來會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147808/60.wav", + "text": "會如果這個機敏工作" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147808/61.wav", + "text": "因為人的參與而洩密" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147808/62.wav", + "text": "就代表我們國軍在保密" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147808/63.wav", + "text": "這一塊做得很差" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147808/64.wav", + "text": "那我們更加要檢討" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147808/65.wav", + "text": "到目前為止我們以後工作方向" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147808/66.wav", + "text": "還是一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147808/67.wav", + "text": "就要防止以往曾經" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147808/68.wav", + "text": "發生的類案不能再發生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147808/69.wav", + "text": "所以這一點我們一直在努力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147808/70.wav", + "text": "當中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147808/71.wav", + "text": "甚至於賣臺的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147808/72.wav", + "text": "請部長一定要繼續追查下去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147808/73.wav", + "text": "疑似誤擊賞鯨船" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147808/74.wav", + "text": "現在這個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147808/75.wav", + "text": "到底我們的迫擊砲練習彈有沒有打到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147808/76.wav", + "text": "賞鯨船上面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147808/77.wav", + "text": "跟委員報告從案發以後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147808/78.wav", + "text": "我們這兩天包含星期六星期天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147808/79.wav", + "text": "專案小組都在跑" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147808/80.wav", + "text": "我不幫他們講話這是他們應該要做的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147808/81.wav", + "text": "但我們目前為什麼沒有辦法那麼快地做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147808/82.wav", + "text": "為什麼因為要釐清" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147808/83.wav", + "text": "也講得很清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147808/84.wav", + "text": "一個垂直的落體" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147808/85.wav", + "text": "跟一個平行的這兩者差別很大" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147808/86.wav", + "text": "平行的是打到水之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147808/87.wav", + "text": "漂起來這個我們也不排除" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147808/88.wav", + "text": "因為還沒有一個定論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147808/89.wav", + "text": "但各種的可能" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147808/90.wav", + "text": "釐清不是我們單方面講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147808/91.wav", + "text": "船的東家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147808/92.wav", + "text": "大家共同決定這樣做是合理的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147808/93.wav", + "text": "步驟以後由第三方確認了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147808/94.wav", + "text": "我們才能夠對外做說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147808/95.wav", + "text": "針對這個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147808/96.wav", + "text": "部長因為有一個所謂的公告管制區" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147808/97.wav", + "text": "所以現在有個爭議就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147808/98.wav", + "text": "到底這艘船是在安全" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147808/99.wav", + "text": "公告管制區之外" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147808/100.wav", + "text": "或者之內我覺得這部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147808/101.wav", + "text": "其實也非常關鍵" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147808/102.wav", + "text": "當然也提醒部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147808/103.wav", + "text": "跟委員做說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147808/104.wav", + "text": "我們公告的這個管制區裡面的的確確" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147808/105.wav", + "text": "他的船沒有進來因" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147808/106.wav", + "text": "因為他有航跡圖" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147808/107.wav", + "text": "航跡圖本身漁會有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147808/108.wav", + "text": "所以確實沒有進到所謂的管制區" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147808/109.wav", + "text": "這個我可以確定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147808/110.wav", + "text": "好部長因為時間有限" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147808/111.wav", + "text": "再請教一下國軍依部隊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147808/112.wav", + "text": "任務性質屬性來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147808/113.wav", + "text": "核發戰鬥部隊加給" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147808/114.wav", + "text": "不過憲兵指揮部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147808/115.wav", + "text": "所屬的各聯隊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147808/116.wav", + "text": "卻沒有辦法支領戰鬥部隊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147808/117.wav", + "text": "加給國防部雖然有向" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147808/118.wav", + "text": "行政院爭取但人事總處" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147808/119.wav", + "text": "認為不宜再擴大認定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147808/120.wav", + "text": "戰鬥部隊的適用單位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147808/121.wav", + "text": "反對的理由" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147808/122.wav", + "text": "為何主要的理由是什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147808/123.wav", + "text": "因為當初我們在歸類" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147808/124.wav", + "text": "時就想第一類第二類" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147808/125.wav", + "text": "要怎麼樣來分呢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147808/126.wav", + "text": "步兵連是第一類" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147808/127.wav", + "text": "憲兵因為是戰鬥支援部隊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147808/128.wav", + "text": "就變成第二類但我們也發覺" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147808/129.wav", + "text": "事實上憲兵跟步兵一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147808/130.wav", + "text": "他也要服很多勤務" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147808/131.wav", + "text": "他也要建基地他還要經過很多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147808/132.wav", + "text": "的戰訓本務的測考" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147808/133.wav", + "text": "所以我們現在也在努力地讓他提升" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147808/134.wav", + "text": "所以這個國防部還會持續爭取" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147808/135.wav", + "text": "會我們一定會幫他爭取" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147808/136.wav", + "text": "我們要公平" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147808/137.wav", + "text": "當中的界定要很清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147808/138.wav", + "text": "所以我跟委員報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147808/139.wav", + "text": "您問的問題爭議很多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147808/140.wav", + "text": "戰鬥部隊裡面有勤務支援人員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147808/141.wav", + "text": "勤務支援單位裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147808/142.wav", + "text": "還有戰鬥部隊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147808/143.wav", + "text": "所以這個當初���什麼會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147808/144.wav", + "text": "以單位來劃分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147808/145.wav", + "text": "利弊存在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147808/146.wav", + "text": "我們會儘量滿足" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147808/147.wav", + "text": "每個單位一個任務需求" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147808/148.wav", + "text": "很合理的給予他待遇" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147808/149.wav", + "text": "好部長最後一個問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147808/150.wav", + "text": "然後您去思考一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147808/151.wav", + "text": "退役的上校若是有兩名子女" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147808/152.wav", + "text": "就讀私立大學" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147808/153.wav", + "text": "他的退休俸的總額" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147808/154.wav", + "text": "退役的中校少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147808/155.wav", + "text": "退後領俸的比例原則" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147808/156.wav", + "text": "所以這個部分請國防部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147808/157.wav", + "text": "上校的退伍人員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147808/158.wav", + "text": "被剝奪感" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147808/159.wav", + "text": "這個請部長回去研究" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147808/160.wav", + "text": "事實上我當初有很多提議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147808/161.wav", + "text": "上校層級退伍的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147808/162.wav", + "text": "他的子女那時候都在讀高中大學" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147808/163.wav", + "text": "基於這個原因我們一定努力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147808/164.wav", + "text": "來幫他爭取" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147807/0.wav", + "text": "謝謝主席邀請唐部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147807/1.wav", + "text": "部長好現在科技環境越來越創新競爭也越來越激烈" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147807/2.wav", + "text": "我們數發部肩負著一個任務不只是國家的數位轉型" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147807/3.wav", + "text": "我覺得包括民間企業的數位轉型" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147807/4.wav", + "text": "這個是很重要的發展方向" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147807/5.wav", + "text": "甚至我們要把這些新的概念新的理念新的價值" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147807/6.wav", + "text": "推廣到每個國人的腦子裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147807/7.wav", + "text": "我想這是很重要的事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147807/8.wav", + "text": "面對這些創新新思維的工作" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147807/9.wav", + "text": "都還在數發部很後面的地方" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147807/10.wav", + "text": "所以要整個政府動起來整個社會動起來整個國人動起來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147807/11.wav", + "text": "確實是很艱鉅的工作" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147807/12.wav", + "text": "因此你們的肩膀扛的責任非常重" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147807/13.wav", + "text": "是帶動國家怎麼樣前進的原動力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147807/14.wav", + "text": "這個引擎是在你這邊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147807/15.wav", + "text": "謝謝委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147807/16.wav", + "text": "我想藉這個地方跟部長做一些勉勵" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147807/17.wav", + "text": "事實上外界不是很了解" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147807/18.wav", + "text": "甚至誤解我們編那麼多經費做什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147807/19.wav", + "text": "做一套有利的說帖" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147807/20.wav", + "text": "跟外界多溝通瞭解" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147807/21.wav", + "text": "\n現在數位��濟衍生吸金詐騙" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147807/22.wav", + "text": "甚至市場監管的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147807/23.wav", + "text": "這一些也必須由數發部參與其中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147807/24.wav", + "text": "主管機關當然不是你" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147807/25.wav", + "text": "但是我剛剛講你們是帶動國家進步的引擎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147807/26.wav", + "text": "你必須參與其中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147807/27.wav", + "text": "協助整個政府整個社會整個民間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147807/28.wav", + "text": "本席之前也提到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147807/29.wav", + "text": "現在推動5G建設" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147807/30.wav", + "text": "這個是數發部的重要業務" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147807/31.wav", + "text": "我想請教一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147807/32.wav", + "text": "現在宜蘭縣5G的普及率怎麼樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147807/33.wav", + "text": "我想先跟委員報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147807/34.wav", + "text": "業者已經進行到九成多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147807/35.wav", + "text": "現在其實主要是在偏鄉地區" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147807/36.wav", + "text": "的電波人口涵蓋率大概是七成左右" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147807/37.wav", + "text": "我們當然會用各種政策工具讓" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147807/38.wav", + "text": "你知道5G現在宜蘭的普及率多少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147807/39.wav", + "text": "跟委員報告5G的普及率" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147807/40.wav", + "text": "我推的是地方文化5G的一些應用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147807/41.wav", + "text": "就是剛剛講的七成多這" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147807/42.wav", + "text": "子啦這個還沒有達到全面化的5G" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147807/43.wav", + "text": "那個是三星的事" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147807/44.wav", + "text": "實上宜蘭縣冬山還有大同南澳" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147807/45.wav", + "text": "責成相關單位積極改善好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147807/46.wav", + "text": "對當然像委員這一張圖" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147807/47.wav", + "text": "但是速度還不是非常快" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147807/48.wav", + "text": "宜蘭縣發展觀光" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147807/49.wav", + "text": "現在都已經改善了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147807/50.wav", + "text": "現在全國大概都通了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147807/51.wav", + "text": "對我們先就不通的地方都改善" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147807/52.wav", + "text": "之後像您說速度可以更快" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147807/53.wav", + "text": "這部分我們好很多地方你們列管一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147807/54.wav", + "text": "不通的地方改善一下好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147807/55.wav", + "text": "只要用QR code就可以取代護照辦理入境" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147807/56.wav", + "text": "及購買免稅品等等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147807/57.wav", + "text": "客到那邊覺得很便利" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147807/58.wav", + "text": "他們國家的發展是很進步的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147807/59.wav", + "text": "數發部具有數位轉型跟支援的角色" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147807/60.wav", + "text": "交通部觀光署跟財政部關務署" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147807/61.wav", + "text": "大家一起推動" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147807/62.wav", + "text": "讓臺灣觀光的復甦能夠跟上國際" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147807/63.wav", + "text": "是其實關務署跟移民署分別" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147807/64.wav", + "text": "都已經有這樣的線上填報系統" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147807/65.wav", + "text": "日本這一套系統的好處" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147807/66.wav", + "text": "是用一個設計制度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147807/67.wav", + "text": "把他們整合在一起讓體驗更好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147807/68.wav", + "text": "這部分我們可以幫忙" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147807/69.wav", + "text": "這個會後你提供資料" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147807/70.wav", + "text": "好的請說明辦理情形怎麼樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147807/71.wav", + "text": "\n另外我有看到NFT" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147807/72.wav", + "text": "某些委員也說NFT的主管機關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147807/73.wav", + "text": "主要是管虛擬貨幣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147807/74.wav", + "text": "權責單位到底怎麼分類比較好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147807/75.wav", + "text": "對NFT做了比較限量的憑證" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147807/76.wav", + "text": "其實是一種跨境電子簽章的應用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147807/77.wav", + "text": "有關跨境電子簽章這件事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147807/78.wav", + "text": "我們有做電子簽章法的相關修法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147807/79.wav", + "text": "這一週應該會送到行政院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147807/80.wav", + "text": "應該很快會送到大院審議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147807/81.wav", + "text": "應該針對全世界新的趨向導向" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147807/82.wav", + "text": "作為一個發展方向" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147807/83.wav", + "text": "我們應該因應並與時俱進來有的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147807/84.wav", + "text": "應該很快會送過來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147807/85.wav", + "text": "每個日本人都能夠用數位資產" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147807/86.wav", + "text": "促進數位產業的發展" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147807/87.wav", + "text": "應該扮演這樣的角色" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147807/88.wav", + "text": "不曉得部長對這個有沒有什麼看法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147807/89.wav", + "text": "是我完全同意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147807/90.wav", + "text": "數位創新基礎建設" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147807/91.wav", + "text": "也是把它當作一種跨境的公共建設" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147807/92.wav", + "text": "可以確保國人在其他國家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147807/93.wav", + "text": "有這樣的數位資產" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147807/94.wav", + "text": "我們這邊也可以認" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147807/95.wav", + "text": "反過來也是一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147807/96.wav", + "text": "這個很重要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147807/97.wav", + "text": "日本的這一組人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147807/98.wav", + "text": "其實跟我們一直都有交流" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147807/99.wav", + "text": "政府部門的橫向溝通很重要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147807/100.wav", + "text": "真的沒有這樣的思維" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147807/101.wav", + "text": "我剛剛講你是引擎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147807/102.wav", + "text": "你要去啟動他們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147807/103.wav", + "text": "在行政院會報" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147807/104.wav", + "text": "因為我剛剛講你是一個引擎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147807/105.wav", + "text": "這又是很創新的一些概念" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147807/106.wav", + "text": "你在國際的聲望都非常棒" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147807/107.wav", + "text": "有一個���重要就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147807/108.wav", + "text": "各部會現在說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147807/109.wav", + "text": "不適用電子簽章的這些業務" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147807/110.wav", + "text": "未來3年之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147807/111.wav", + "text": "如果他們不立法的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147807/112.wav", + "text": "這也是很大的一步" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147807/113.wav", + "text": "在立院討論的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147807/114.wav", + "text": "希望委員支持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147807/115.wav", + "text": "這樣我們就有一個依據" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147807/116.wav", + "text": "跟其他各部會說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147807/117.wav", + "text": "大家一起來跟上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147807/118.wav", + "text": "電簽法上次我也問過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147807/119.wav", + "text": "了你說這個會期" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147807/120.wav", + "text": "我們這個禮拜" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147807/121.wav", + "text": "就會送到行政院審議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147807/122.wav", + "text": "院會通過就會送過來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147807/123.wav", + "text": "你推動的成效怎麼樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147807/124.wav", + "text": "這個也應該瞭解" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147807/125.wav", + "text": "如果廣泛應用到商業使用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147807/126.wav", + "text": "這一點你要有企圖心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147807/127.wav", + "text": "我們是不是補充書面給委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147807/128.wav", + "text": "好我今天主要的質詢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147807/129.wav", + "text": "有三點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147807/130.wav", + "text": "儘速完備宜蘭地區" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147807/131.wav", + "text": "網路基地臺的建置" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147807/132.wav", + "text": "平衡城鄉數位落差" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147807/133.wav", + "text": "尤其是東部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147807/134.wav", + "text": "剛剛陳雪生委員提到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147807/135.wav", + "text": "離島也差不多是這樣子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147807/136.wav", + "text": "認為蔡總統" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147807/137.wav", + "text": "推動前瞻基礎建設計畫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147807/138.wav", + "text": "那個目標" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147807/139.wav", + "text": "他是2016年當選" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147807/140.wav", + "text": "2017年就開始" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147807/141.wav", + "text": "推動前瞻基礎建設" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147807/142.wav", + "text": "在教育方面已經達到城鄉均衡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147807/143.wav", + "text": "比如交通現在已經啟動了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147807/144.wav", + "text": "但是還沒有達到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147807/145.wav", + "text": "數位的部分應該比較簡單" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147807/146.wav", + "text": "日本很積極推動數位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147807/147.wav", + "text": "這個都值得我們借" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147807/148.wav", + "text": "我想你在日本也" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147807/149.wav", + "text": "日本那些好的地方" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147807/150.wav", + "text": "我們要吸收" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147807/151.wav", + "text": "最重要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147807/152.wav", + "text": "全民的意識" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147807/153.wav", + "text": "��謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147806/0.wav", + "text": "主席謝謝麻煩請唐鳳部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147806/1.wav", + "text": "委員好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147806/2.wav", + "text": "加上現在大家也都對於數發部非常期待" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147806/3.wav", + "text": "就是針對詐騙的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147806/4.wav", + "text": "要嚴格進行源頭管理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147806/5.wav", + "text": "我不知道部長有沒有聽說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147806/6.wav", + "text": "也都有很多警務同仁開始在宣導" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147806/7.wav", + "text": "可能是用深偽技術" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147806/8.wav", + "text": "AI變造" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147806/9.wav", + "text": "請教部長有掌握嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147806/10.wav", + "text": "事實上我們上次在這邊討論的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147806/11.wav", + "text": "我就有就這種深偽技術" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147806/12.wav", + "text": "表示我們必須用源頭的方法管理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147806/13.wav", + "text": "你也期待我們就是要去做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147806/14.wav", + "text": "這個我記得的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147806/15.wav", + "text": "像之前有的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147806/16.wav", + "text": "這樣子我們也擔心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147806/17.wav", + "text": "選舉奧步到最後八十幾天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147806/18.wav", + "text": "會不會再度發生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147806/19.wav", + "text": "有大量的AI生成這種" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147806/20.wav", + "text": "半真半假的文宣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147806/21.wav", + "text": "請問數位部這邊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147806/22.wav", + "text": "可以怎麼樣來做規範和管理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147806/23.wav", + "text": "謝謝委員讓我們有機會說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147806/24.wav", + "text": "其實如果在內容和傳播上面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147806/25.wav", + "text": "它就是以假亂真已經無法分辨的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147806/26.wav", + "text": "我們就只能夠從" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147806/27.wav", + "text": "好比像說政府發的簡訊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147806/28.wav", + "text": "是從111出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147806/29.wav", + "text": "好比像說您剛剛提到候選人等等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147806/30.wav", + "text": "他可能有藍勾勾或其他" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147806/31.wav", + "text": "溯源的方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147806/32.wav", + "text": "所有其他的可能就要推定成都是機器人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147806/33.wav", + "text": "這個跟以前不一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147806/34.wav", + "text": "以前在網路上是覺得對面一定是人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147806/35.wav", + "text": "除非他的表現開始像機器人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147806/36.wav", + "text": "但是未來可能就是要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147806/37.wav", + "text": "認為大概都是機器人除非是你本來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147806/38.wav", + "text": "已經認識的或者是這些像111" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147806/39.wav", + "text": "這樣子可以相信的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147806/40.wav", + "text": "以及這些藍勾勾的溯源" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147806/41.wav", + "text": "不是啊部長我還是沒有聽到一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147806/42.wav", + "text": "比較積極的具有可行性應對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147806/43.wav", + "text": "啊因為現在美國" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147806/44.wav", + "text": "智庫也都示警有可能" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147806/45.wav", + "text": "有一些生成的AI會影響" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147806/46.wav", + "text": "臺灣2024總統大選" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147806/47.wav", + "text": "還是在政令宣導還是告訴大家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147806/48.wav", + "text": "如果就是藍勾勾的話現在哪一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147806/49.wav", + "text": "藍勾勾" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147806/50.wav", + "text": "我們現在擔心的是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147806/51.wav", + "text": "不管是從詐騙的手法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147806/52.wav", + "text": "就是現在如果有深偽技術" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147806/53.wav", + "text": "變成假冒特定人士" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147806/54.wav", + "text": "明明不是他講的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147806/55.wav", + "text": "卻用他的照片他的動畫他的嘴型" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147806/56.wav", + "text": "篩出他講的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147806/57.wav", + "text": "那這樣子要怎麼處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147806/58.wav", + "text": "我們第一時間可以怎麼應變" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147806/59.wav", + "text": "兩件事情一個是說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147806/60.wav", + "text": "這個宣導是有用的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147806/61.wav", + "text": "就是用深偽來合成我的影像和聲音" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147806/62.wav", + "text": "越快越多地" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147806/63.wav", + "text": "讓大家知道現在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147806/64.wav", + "text": "隨便就可以合成這樣的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147806/65.wav", + "text": "東西實際看到沒有藍勾勾傳這樣的影像的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147806/66.wav", + "text": "大家就比較不會被騙" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147806/67.wav", + "text": "就知道說以前是P圖" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147806/68.wav", + "text": "現在可以P影像這是第一件事" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147806/69.wav", + "text": "全部都仿冒過去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147806/70.wav", + "text": "以前不容易但是現在有AI這個非常容易" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147806/71.wav", + "text": "那我們對於網路品牌" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147806/72.wav", + "text": "有沒有相關的約束能力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147806/73.wav", + "text": "因為我們現在看到的是源頭出來之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147806/74.wav", + "text": "重點是散播散播怎麼樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147806/75.wav", + "text": "快速如果它不是一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147806/76.wav", + "text": "確認真偽的訊息" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147806/77.wav", + "text": "網路平臺怎麼約束" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147806/78.wav", + "text": "其實在2019年的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147806/79.wav", + "text": "特別就是境外像之前他們可以透過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147806/80.wav", + "text": "打廣告就是對廣告部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147806/81.wav", + "text": "長講2019年本席告訴你一個數字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147806/82.wav", + "text": "詐騙案倍增暴增" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147806/83.wav", + "text": "就是從2019年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147806/84.wav", + "text": "開始逐步成長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147806/85.wav", + "text": "到去年2022年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147806/86.wav", + "text": "有做如果真的有效" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147806/87.wav", + "text": "不會到2022年詐騙案變新高" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147806/88.wav", + "text": "所以現在已經2023年了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147806/89.wav", + "text": "總統也即將要再改選了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147806/90.wav", + "text": "我們現在怎麼樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147806/91.wav", + "text": "因應新的技術" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147806/92.wav", + "text": "不要還停留原地人家都已經上太空了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147806/93.wav", + "text": "我們數發部怎麼感覺起來還在殺豬公" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147806/94.wav", + "text": "還在拿2019年事情來說嘴" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147806/95.wav", + "text": "我還沒有講完" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147806/96.wav", + "text": "可不可以針對問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147806/97.wav", + "text": "回答問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147806/98.wav", + "text": "本席今天不是在跟你聊天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147806/99.wav", + "text": "本席今天是質詢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147806/100.wav", + "text": "不要再回顧歷史了好嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147806/101.wav", + "text": "對於網路平臺有約束力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147806/102.wav", + "text": "是第一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147806/103.wav", + "text": "像您提到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147806/104.wav", + "text": "投資詐騙的這個型態" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147806/105.wav", + "text": "它如果不在限時內下架它" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147806/106.wav", + "text": "它要負連帶責任" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147806/107.wav", + "text": "就是被騙了多少它到最後會要連帶賠多少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147806/108.wav", + "text": "這是滿新的一個概念" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147806/109.wav", + "text": "哪一條法令可以這樣子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147806/110.wav", + "text": "約束我們數發部可以嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147806/111.wav", + "text": "這個就是金管會的就是金融投資" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147806/112.wav", + "text": "部長你剛剛講到一個是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147806/113.wav", + "text": "本席在其他地方還沒有聽到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147806/114.wav", + "text": "直接跟平臺來做求償" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147806/115.wav", + "text": "是這樣嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147806/116.wav", + "text": "而且它知道之後還不下架" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147806/117.wav", + "text": "所以這是三個階段" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147806/118.wav", + "text": "中間它就是24小時" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147806/119.wav", + "text": "要下架不然有罰則" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147806/120.wav", + "text": "這個是內政部已經有訂定了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147806/121.wav", + "text": "但如果它一直都不配合" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147806/122.wav", + "text": "到最後在上面都還是有這些投資詐騙" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147806/123.wav", + "text": "然後如果有人被騙了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147806/124.wav", + "text": "按照金管會已經修了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147806/125.wav", + "text": "已經通過的打詐五法之一" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147806/126.wav", + "text": "這是它有連帶的責任" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147806/127.wav", + "text": "所以平臺也可以負連帶責任" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147806/128.wav", + "text": "是不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147806/129.wav", + "text": "本席為什麼還是要再一次提醒" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147806/130.wav", + "text": "最主要就是因為現在只剩八十幾天的時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147806/131.wav", + "text": "所有的訊息" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147806/132.wav", + "text": "重點在於是要給臺灣一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147806/133.wav", + "text": "讓大家能夠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147806/134.wav", + "text": "自己來決定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147806/135.wav", + "text": "自己的候選人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147806/136.wav", + "text": "我想這一點是不分黨派朝野" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147806/137.wav", + "text": "大家共同努力的方向" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147806/138.wav", + "text": "現在數發部也要修正資安法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147806/139.wav", + "text": "要明確規定禁止" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147806/140.wav", + "text": "有沒有定義什麼是危害國家資安產品" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147806/141.wav", + "text": "是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147806/142.wav", + "text": "謝謝委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147806/143.wav", + "text": "因為你現在有講到不會公布" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147806/144.wav", + "text": "危害資安產品的名單" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147806/145.wav", + "text": "是因為怕洗產地" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147806/146.wav", + "text": "我們現在到底掌握多少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147806/147.wav", + "text": "產品的清單" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147806/148.wav", + "text": "是這部分就我們盤點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147806/149.wav", + "text": "中共能夠實質控制的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147806/150.wav", + "text": "包含軟體服務跟硬體" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147806/151.wav", + "text": "這部分在某些部會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147806/152.wav", + "text": "如果還有在使用我們是限期讓它" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147806/153.wav", + "text": "汰換而且是透過一些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147806/154.wav", + "text": "像斷網等等的方式確保" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147806/155.wav", + "text": "它就是不會有後門或者即使有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147806/156.wav", + "text": "也不會影響到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147806/157.wav", + "text": "這部分是不是請資安署來回答" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147806/158.wav", + "text": "來簡要報告我們現在掌握多少清單" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147806/159.wav", + "text": "有多少品項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147806/160.wav", + "text": "範圍有多少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147806/161.wav", + "text": "大概有十幾個面向" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147806/162.wav", + "text": "十幾個大項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147806/163.wav", + "text": "有多少產品" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147806/164.wav", + "text": "還在使用的大概有100多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147806/165.wav", + "text": "個產品" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147806/166.wav", + "text": "公部門還在使用中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147806/167.wav", + "text": "的有100多種是我們認定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147806/168.wav", + "text": "不是100多種是100多個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147806/169.wav", + "text": "要汰換" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147806/170.wav", + "text": "而且是限制性的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147806/171.wav", + "text": "使用就是它必須經過資安長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147806/172.wav", + "text": "同意的使用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147806/173.wav", + "text": "有一些部會需要查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147806/174.wav", + "text": "某些資料庫剛好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147806/175.wav", + "text": "是對岸的品牌" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147806/176.wav", + "text": "可是那個資料庫是它" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147806/177.wav", + "text": "業務需要它必須去查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147806/178.wav", + "text": "所以它是特別簽准" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147806/179.wav", + "text": "其他的部分都斷網" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147806/180.wav", + "text": "所以現在名單沒有公布" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147806/181.wav", + "text": "但是政府部門有掌握" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147806/182.wav", + "text": "各部門都有掌握這樣子會不會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147806/183.wav", + "text": "我們政府也常常會有發包的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147806/184.wav", + "text": "來使用這個要不要公布" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147806/185.wav", + "text": "如同之前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147806/186.wav", + "text": "臺鐵車站的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147806/187.wav", + "text": "那個螢幕也有被人家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147806/188.wav", + "text": "駭客入侵那時候臺鐵也" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147806/189.wav", + "text": "推說那是發包下游廠商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147806/190.wav", + "text": "那是廣告代理商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147806/191.wav", + "text": "沒有推我上任之後簽了第一份" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147806/192.wav", + "text": "公文就是在這樣的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147806/193.wav", + "text": "公眾場域只要它是公部門的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147806/194.wav", + "text": "像臺鐵這樣就比照" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147806/195.wav", + "text": "公務網路一樣也要是啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147806/196.wav", + "text": "這個清單的部分因為現在看起來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147806/197.wav", + "text": "這個清單也是所謂源頭管理的一環嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147806/198.wav", + "text": "除了公部門因為你現在又講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147806/199.wav", + "text": "這個名單的類別" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147806/200.wav", + "text": "範圍是國家機密嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147806/201.wav", + "text": "當然我們是以統計的方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147806/202.wav", + "text": "來公布像剛才署長回答您" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147806/203.wav", + "text": "但是只要任何公部門它的採購" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147806/204.wav", + "text": "資安專責人員等等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147806/205.wav", + "text": "這個跟我們查詢是沒有問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147806/206.wav", + "text": "這就是模糊空間三不管地帶" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147806/207.wav", + "text": "像您剛剛講到出租廣告場域等等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147806/208.wav", + "text": "這些都必須要連帶" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147806/209.wav", + "text": "第二個我們也有像共同供應契約" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147806/210.wav", + "text": "列在上面的就是我們已經看過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147806/211.wav", + "text": "沒有問題兩個以上機關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147806/212.wav", + "text": "一起都在用的它只要挑這裡面的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147806/213.wav", + "text": "就比較不會出問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147806/214.wav", + "text": "就要限制廠商只能挑" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147806/215.wav", + "text": "如果裡面沒有那麼就要來跟我們詢問" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147806/216.wav", + "text": "是整個公務系統都沒有用過的一個產品" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147806/217.wav", + "text": "我們就會來看是不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147806/218.wav", + "text": "北京政權對它有實質控制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147806/219.wav", + "text": "部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147806/220.wav", + "text": "本席還是再次強調" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147806/221.wav", + "text": "當然資安是我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147806/222.wav", + "text": "大家共同來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147806/223.wav", + "text": "消極的作為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147806/224.wav", + "text": "都不妥" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147806/225.wav", + "text": "部長最後本席再提醒一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147806/226.wav", + "text": "這次國人覺得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147806/227.wav", + "text": "沸沸揚揚吵得爭議很大" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147806/228.wav", + "text": "的就是數發部這次有500多萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147806/229.wav", + "text": "編列的出國費用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147806/230.wav", + "text": "出國經費差旅費" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147806/231.wav", + "text": "我想請教有哪一項參加的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147806/232.wav", + "text": "會議約定了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147806/233.wav", + "text": "主辦單位明確是不能遠端" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147806/234.wav", + "text": "參與或者是沒有規劃線上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147806/235.wav", + "text": "互動" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147806/236.wav", + "text": "我先請教有哪一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147806/237.wav", + "text": "我們要參與的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147806/238.wav", + "text": "或是沒有規劃線上互動" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147806/239.wav", + "text": "剛剛提到的APEC臺歐" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147806/240.wav", + "text": "以及臺美等等數位經貿的這種談判" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147806/241.wav", + "text": "這本來在其他的部會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147806/242.wav", + "text": "這樣子的談判基本上都是實體" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147806/243.wav", + "text": "除了在疫情的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147806/244.wav", + "text": "少數事務性的是線上之外" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147806/245.wav", + "text": "可是那個就是多出來的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147806/246.wav", + "text": "全國國人都在看為什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147806/247.wav", + "text": "數發部有編列500多萬的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147806/248.wav", + "text": "出國經費越來越高" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147806/249.wav", + "text": "明明數發部在預算書裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147806/250.wav", + "text": "也跟各界邀功稱" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147806/251.wav", + "text": "數發部透過線上視訊會議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147806/252.wav", + "text": "多次參與了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147806/253.wav", + "text": "網際網路區域名稱以及" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147806/254.wav", + "text": "位置指配機構等等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147806/255.wav", + "text": "是可以線上參與有些沒有辦法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147806/256.wav", + "text": "而且更重要的是數發部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147806/257.wav", + "text": "還有參加很多相關的國際會議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147806/258.wav", + "text": "不是主要的業務部會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147806/259.wav", + "text": "可以有某個例子嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147806/260.wav", + "text": "聯合國氣候變遷大會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147806/261.wav", + "text": "主管機關是誰" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147806/262.wav", + "text": "氣候變遷主管機關是誰" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147806/263.wav", + "text": "我國氣候變遷主管機關是誰" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147806/264.wav", + "text": "是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147806/265.wav", + "text": "國際傳播協會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147806/266.wav", + "text": "亞洲電信資訊展" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147806/267.wav", + "text": "請問主管機關是誰" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147806/268.wav", + "text": "不過這部分我們就是韌性司跟" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147806/269.wav", + "text": "部長所以你如果希望" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147806/270.wav", + "text": "本席拿出來打臉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147806/271.wav", + "text": "國人越來越看到數發部編列那麼多的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147806/272.wav", + "text": "但是明顯有很多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147806/273.wav", + "text": "參與的會議並不是主要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147806/274.wav", + "text": "主管機關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147806/275.wav", + "text": "不是這樣這樣不會讓大家覺得有濫用公帑之虞嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147806/276.wav", + "text": "再加上明明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147806/277.wav", + "text": "還是可以用所謂遠端" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147806/278.wav", + "text": "或是線上參與" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147806/279.wav", + "text": "為什麼沒有考慮遠端或線上參與" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147806/280.wav", + "text": "我們能遠端線上參與的其實都遠端" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147806/281.wav", + "text": "線上參與我剛剛提到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147806/282.wav", + "text": "的經貿談判等等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147806/283.wav", + "text": "所以你現在是跟社會大眾講500多萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147806/284.wav", + "text": "已經是省了費用了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147806/285.wav", + "text": "是不是你是不是在跟國人講500多萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147806/286.wav", + "text": "大家誤會了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147806/287.wav", + "text": "500多萬已經是省了費用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147806/288.wav", + "text": "確實是已經省了費用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147806/289.wav", + "text": "我們多出來的部分就是經貿談判" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147806/290.wav", + "text": "部長你敢講但是本席" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147806/291.wav", + "text": "以及國人不一定敢聽" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147806/292.wav", + "text": "本席只是提醒" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147806/293.wav", + "text": "讓國人外界有這樣的印象" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147806/294.wav", + "text": "如果數發部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147806/295.wav", + "text": "還沒有辦法深刻檢討" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147806/296.wav", + "text": "自我感覺良好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147806/297.wav", + "text": "國人真的只會看在眼裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147805/0.wav", + "text": "謝謝我們美麗的召委" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147805/1.wav", + "text": "是不是請部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147805/2.wav", + "text": "部長請" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147805/3.wav", + "text": "委員好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147805/4.wav", + "text": "部長我們今天質詢輕鬆一點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147805/5.wav", + "text": "執政黨最近在馬祖放狗咬人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147805/6.wav", + "text": "養了一隻狗" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147805/7.wav", + "text": "狗不只在那邊亂喊亂叫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147805/8.wav", + "text": "還衍生了其他的狗也到那邊叫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147805/9.wav", + "text": "新華公司有一個臺馬輪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147805/10.wav", + "text": "它的定位系統錯亂" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147805/11.wav", + "text": "個資外洩" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147805/12.wav", + "text": "部長知道這回事嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147805/13.wav", + "text": "可能請委員指教" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147805/14.wav", + "text": "好不只這條狗還有很多野狗" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147805/15.wav", + "text": "監察院也跑去查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147805/16.wav", + "text": "監察院錢很多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147805/17.wav", + "text": "沒事跑到那邊逛逛風景也就罷了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147805/18.wav", + "text": "他們說縣政府有責任也有缺失" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147805/19.wav", + "text": "數發部有沒有確認這個事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147805/20.wav", + "text": "你知道嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147805/21.wav", + "text": "因為我們只是綜合式電商的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147805/22.wav", + "text": "個資主管機關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147805/23.wav", + "text": "希望數發部派一組人馬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147805/24.wav", + "text": "到那邊去看看好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147805/25.wav", + "text": "到底怎麼回事好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147805/26.wav", + "text": "你們不能不聞不問啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147805/27.wav", + "text": "當然如果需要行政調查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147805/28.wav", + "text": "監察院有沒有調查你們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147805/29.wav", + "text": "這件事情以我所知是沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147805/30.wav", + "text": "監察院要去調查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147805/31.wav", + "text": "調查交通部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147805/32.wav", + "text": "啊怎麼調查縣政府" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147805/33.wav", + "text": "呢然後本席在這邊當立法委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147805/34.wav", + "text": "還扯到我頭上來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147805/35.wav", + "text": "說我怠惰失職" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147805/36.wav", + "text": "如果我怠惰失職的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147805/37.wav", + "text": "你們是什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147805/38.wav", + "text": "部長你要下臺喔" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147805/39.wav", + "text": "交通部長也要下臺啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147805/40.wav", + "text": "行政調查可以請" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147805/41.wav", + "text": "資安院幫忙各個部會主管的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147805/42.wav", + "text": "你們什麼時候派人去調查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147805/43.wav", + "text": "因為您是現在才提到這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147805/44.wav", + "text": "如果您提供一些細節包含" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147805/45.wav", + "text": "需要怎麼樣的協助等會後我們可以協助縣府" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147805/46.wav", + "text": "不能為了選舉在那邊亂吼亂叫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147805/47.wav", + "text": "是不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147805/48.wav", + "text": "我當然恪守行政中立我並沒有參加選舉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147805/49.wav", + "text": "我知道我知道你沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147805/50.wav", + "text": "我今天不會那麼客氣跟你講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147805/51.wav", + "text": "你也很客氣地到過我辦公室" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147805/52.wav", + "text": "對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147805/53.wav", + "text": "缺個肉也是連江縣政府" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147805/54.wav", + "text": "也扯到本席" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147805/55.wav", + "text": "那是軍中的問題嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147805/56.wav", + "text": "搞得排連營" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147805/57.wav", + "text": "陸軍司令都跑去跟阿兵哥道歉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147805/58.wav", + "text": "就一個人缺肉嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147805/59.wav", + "text": "我們一大堆船在那邊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147805/60.wav", + "text": "可以來租啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147805/61.wav", + "text": "不能讓我們白跑嘛對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147805/62.wav", + "text": "們龍蝦出口本來就合法出口嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147805/63.wav", + "text": "龍蝦誰講不能出去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147805/64.wav", + "text": "不在禁止之列嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147805/65.wav", + "text": "對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147805/66.wav", + "text": "出去20隻耶有問題嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147805/67.wav", + "text": "結果海巡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147805/68.wav", + "text": "岸巡機動查巡隊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147805/69.wav", + "text": "監察院和" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147805/70.wav", + "text": "調查局調查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147805/71.wav", + "text": "統統都在調查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147805/72.wav", + "text": "不要上班了搞得雞飛狗跳" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147805/73.wav", + "text": "連我們立法院也有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147805/74.wav", + "text": "居然" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147805/75.wav", + "text": "函要求去調查連江縣政府" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147805/76.wav", + "text": "我也可以啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147805/77.wav", + "text": "我也可以每天對交通部出10個函" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147805/78.wav", + "text": "要求所有的工程我全部都" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147805/79.wav", + "text": "要瞭解" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147805/80.wav", + "text": "那你們每個單位每天來10個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147805/81.wav", + "text": "人向我報告好了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147805/82.wav", + "text": "你們不用上班嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147805/83.wav", + "text": "跟你們沒關係" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147805/84.wav", + "text": "我是講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147805/85.wav", + "text": "臺馬輪的訂位系統" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147805/86.wav", + "text": "個資外洩跟本席有關係嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147805/87.wav", + "text": "你回答我" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147805/88.wav", + "text": "有沒有關係" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147805/89.wav", + "text": "任何個資外洩" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147805/90.wav", + "text": "我想是那個個資外洩它的主管機關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147805/91.wav", + "text": "是立法委員的問題還是你們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147805/92.wav", + "text": "數發部的問題你們有沒有責任" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147805/93.wav", + "text": "t微風或者是所有其他" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147805/94.wav", + "text": "不管它主管機關是誰" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147805/95.wav", + "text": "我們資安院都可以來協助行政" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147805/96.wav", + "text": "你們很忙的耶" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147805/97.wav", + "text": "最近詐騙集團那麼多你們很忙的剛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147805/98.wav", + "text": "剛才陳椒華委員在那邊質詢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147805/99.wav", + "text": "你們應該有印刷費吧" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147805/100.wav", + "text": "你們要告訴民眾" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147805/101.wav", + "text": "預防詐騙" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147805/102.wav", + "text": "要怎麼樣預防" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147805/103.wav", + "text": "莫名其妙" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147805/104.wav", + "text": "來了很多字的那種電話國外來的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147805/105.wav", + "text": "不要去接它" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147805/106.wav", + "text": "它接了就會上當" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147805/107.wav", + "text": "是不是有一些SOP的程序" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147805/108.wav", + "text": "你們告訴民眾嘛廣發" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147805/109.wav", + "text": "嘛印刷費沒多少錢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147805/110.wav", + "text": "這個錢我想不要小氣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147805/111.wav", + "text": "理解委員的意思" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147805/112.wav", + "text": "而且我們現在也跟包含電商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147805/113.wav", + "text": "或其他遊戲業者合作在他們的網站上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147805/114.wav", + "text": "或產品上也都有打這些訊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147805/115.wav", + "text": "監察院沒有調查你們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147805/116.wav", + "text": "監察院為什麼沒有調查你們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147805/117.wav", + "text": "這是執政黨你們內部的事" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147805/118.wav", + "text": "怎麼關係到地方政府呢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147805/119.wav", + "text": "甚至扯到立法院來說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147805/120.wav", + "text": "我怠惰失職我如果怠惰失職你要怎麼樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147805/121.wav", + "text": "你說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147805/122.wav", + "text": "因為這句話並不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147805/123.wav", + "text": "沒關係他叫得越凶我就罵你罵得越凶" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147805/124.wav", + "text": "我不只罵你喔我還罵交通部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147805/125.wav", + "text": "還要罵NCC統統罵" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147805/126.wav", + "text": "每天罵" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147805/127.wav", + "text": "不是罵一天就算了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147805/128.wav", + "text": "有這樣的道理嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147805/129.wav", + "text": "是不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147805/130.wav", + "text": "\n你什麼時候派人去查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147805/131.wav", + "text": "只要是該個資的主管機關提出" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147805/132.wav", + "text": "希望我們行政調查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147805/133.wav", + "text": "我們幾乎都是當天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147805/134.wav", + "text": "就可以出動" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147805/135.wav", + "text": "你們去查完向我回報好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147805/136.wav", + "text": "我想我們就先跟" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147805/137.wav", + "text": "這件事情的目的事業主管機關取得聯絡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147805/138.wav", + "text": "對嘛帶點藥去嘛好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147805/139.wav", + "text": "瘋狗一樣每天在那邊亂喊亂叫的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147805/140.wav", + "text": "帶點藥去給人家吃嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147805/141.wav", + "text": "你不要搞得每天在罵人啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147805/142.wav", + "text": "我才不理他呢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147805/143.wav", + "text": "用匿名的我根本不理他" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147805/144.wav", + "text": "是瞭解" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147805/145.wav", + "text": "委員修養" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147805/146.wav", + "text": "你們去查一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147805/147.wav", + "text": "\n好最近還有一件事" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147805/148.wav", + "text": "2號海纜線" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147805/149.wav", + "text": "斷了你知道嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147805/150.wav", + "text": "因為有備援迴路" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147805/151.wav", + "text": "所以目前還沒有造成什麼太大的影響" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147805/152.wav", + "text": "那現在呢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147805/153.wav", + "text": "2號斷了沒有影響" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147805/154.wav", + "text": "3號等一下再斷了也沒有影響" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147805/155.wav", + "text": "就會回到微波嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147805/156.wav", + "text": "你有微波嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147805/157.wav", + "text": "所以統統斷了也沒關係" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147805/158.wav", + "text": "到年底的話我們微波會整個拓寬到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147805/159.wav", + "text": "我請問為什麼斷了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147805/160.wav", + "text": "這部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147805/161.wav", + "text": "我在會前沒有掌握" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147805/162.wav", + "text": "NCC告訴我" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147805/163.wav", + "text": "要保密" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147805/164.wav", + "text": "我也保密了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147805/165.wav", + "text": "可是第三天第四天報紙登得比誰都大" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147805/166.wav", + "text": "是誰搞斷的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147805/167.wav", + "text": "在那邊徘徊34次了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147805/168.wav", + "text": "啦是不是徘徊34次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147805/169.wav", + "text": "啊你們用衛星監控嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147805/170.wav", + "text": "是什麼船" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147805/171.wav", + "text": "你們要掌握情資嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147805/172.wav", + "text": "是不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147805/173.wav", + "text": "我們有快艇啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147805/174.wav", + "text": "是我想海巡署這一部分確實有跟我們做討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147805/175.wav", + "text": "要有結果啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147805/176.wav", + "text": "你們要跟我回報這個事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147805/177.wav", + "text": "啊你不能講說委員去猜" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147805/178.wav", + "text": "每天要看新聞嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147805/179.wav", + "text": "這種重大事故我希望" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147805/180.wav", + "text": "數發部以後跟我回報一下好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147805/181.wav", + "text": "你透過那個張登傑嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147805/182.wav", + "text": "他是我們馬祖優秀的青年啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147805/183.wav", + "text": "你透過他跟我聯繫嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147805/184.wav", + "text": "好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147805/185.wav", + "text": "我同意他是優秀的青年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147805/186.wav", + "text": "你不方便天天打電話給我" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147805/187.wav", + "text": "你可以找張登傑打電話給我嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147805/188.wav", + "text": "是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147805/189.wav", + "text": "瞭解" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147805/190.wav", + "text": "至於指定特定的同仁" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147805/191.wav", + "text": "我想我們儘量配合啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147805/192.wav", + "text": "特定同仁我倒沒講什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147805/193.wav", + "text": "我只是說他跟我們比較熟" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147805/194.wav", + "text": "瞭解瞭解" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147805/195.wav", + "text": "我沒有跟你關說什麼事喔" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147805/196.wav", + "text": "好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147805/197.wav", + "text": "會啦那麼優秀你們該提拔都會提拔" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147805/198.wav", + "text": "的我知道啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147805/199.wav", + "text": "瞭解委員的意思" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147805/200.wav", + "text": "召委都在笑" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147805/201.wav", + "text": "\n你查一下好不好不要冤枉好人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147805/202.wav", + "text": "啦說我怠惰失職" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147805/203.wav", + "text": "本席怠惰失職你們統統都要免職了啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147805/204.wav", + "text": "對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147805/205.wav", + "text": "我想我們能夠支援的行政調查部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147805/206.wav", + "text": "部長你查一下跟我回報好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147804/0.wav", + "text": "謝謝主席" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147804/1.wav", + "text": "請唐部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147804/2.wav", + "text": "委員早" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147804/3.wav", + "text": "部長早" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147804/4.wav", + "text": "陳建仁院長在立法院說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147804/5.wav", + "text": "政府發現詐騙廣告會要求平台" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147804/6.wav", + "text": "在24小時內下架" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147804/7.wav", + "text": "各網路平台配合情形不錯" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147804/8.wav", + "text": "我必須要說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147804/9.wav", + "text": "24小時下架是最基本的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147804/10.wav", + "text": "結果我們的院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147804/11.wav", + "text": "卻拿來當政績得意洋洋" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147804/12.wav", + "text": "這樣的態度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147804/13.wav", + "text": "對於臺灣打詐" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147804/14.wav", + "text": "是毫無幫助的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147804/15.wav", + "text": "而且各平台" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147804/16.wav", + "text": "真的都配合得不錯嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147804/17.wav", + "text": "我打一個大問號" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147804/18.wav", + "text": "我很懷疑" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147804/19.wav", + "text": "\n所以這邊要請教唐鳳部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147804/20.wav", + "text": "目前數發部在打詐工作上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147804/21.wav", + "text": "做了哪些事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147804/22.wav", + "text": "對於打詐數發部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147804/23.wav", + "text": "覺得自己該做的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147804/24.wav", + "text": "都做了嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147804/25.wav", + "text": "好謝謝委員讓我們有機會說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147804/26.wav", + "text": "我想最近的這個新聞" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147804/27.wav", + "text": "是因為內政部警政署" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147804/28.wav", + "text": "有訂定一個辦法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147804/29.wav", + "text": "之前24小時下架" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147804/30.wav", + "text": "配合是一個情況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147804/31.wav", + "text": "但現在是會有明確的罰則" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147804/32.wav", + "text": "如果不配合的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147804/33.wav", + "text": "這是警政署的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147804/34.wav", + "text": "我們的防詐工作" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147804/35.wav", + "text": "主要就是防堵跟防阻" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147804/36.wav", + "text": "就是在資訊流跟金流這兩個方面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147804/37.wav", + "text": "盡可能讓詐騙" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147804/38.wav", + "text": "不要傳遞到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147804/39.wav", + "text": "舉例來講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147804/40.wav", + "text": "我們明天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147804/41.wav", + "text": "就會把111這個簡訊平台" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147804/42.wav", + "text": "啟用之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147804/43.wav", + "text": "只要是111發出來的簡訊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147804/44.wav", + "text": "大家就知道是公部門的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147804/45.wav", + "text": "如果公部門都使用的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147804/46.wav", + "text": "其他冒充公部門" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147804/47.wav", + "text": "大家就會知道是詐騙了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147804/48.wav", + "text": "所以目前就是簡訊這個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147804/49.wav", + "text": "部長你先前也接受媒體採訪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147804/50.wav", + "text": "就是出現假冒候選人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147804/51.wav", + "text": "或者是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147804/52.wav", + "text": "在檢調要求" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147804/53.wav", + "text": "下數位部會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147804/54.wav", + "text": "協助停止解析網域" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147804/55.wav", + "text": "斷開網站跟民眾的連結" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147804/56.wav", + "text": "有鑑於現今的假訊息" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147804/57.wav", + "text": "多是透過社群媒體來傳播" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147804/58.wav", + "text": "陸續有委員表示" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147804/59.wav", + "text": "臉書和LINE" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147804/60.wav", + "text": "遭不明人士冒用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147804/61.wav", + "text": "對此數發部有什麼樣的防範" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147804/62.wav", + "text": "台我們都有協助" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147804/63.wav", + "text": "所謂的綠色通道或紅色通道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147804/64.wav", + "text": "就是快速的檢舉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147804/65.wav", + "text": "他們就必須快速處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147804/66.wav", + "text": "因為像委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147804/67.wav", + "text": "或者其他候選人來講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147804/68.wav", + "text": "警政署快速處理嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147804/69.wav", + "text": "來協助的這是第一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147804/70.wav", + "text": "所以先前林俊憲委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147804/71.wav", + "text": "表示臉書遭冒用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147804/72.wav", + "text": "同時通知數發部警政署" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147804/73.wav", + "text": "不久警政署來電說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147804/74.wav", + "text": "已經下架完畢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147804/75.wav", + "text": "數發部則是晚了1個小時回覆" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147804/76.wav", + "text": "那就表示我們建立警政署" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147804/77.wav", + "text": "和平台中間的通道是有用的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147804/78.wav", + "text": "所以這個你們認為是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147804/79.wav", + "text": "你們有協助而得來的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147804/80.wav", + "text": "是這樣嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147804/81.wav", + "text": "快速補充一點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147804/82.wav", + "text": "那為什麼你們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147804/83.wav", + "text": "晚了1個小時才回覆呢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147804/84.wav", + "text": "因為我們是建立這個管道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147804/85.wav", + "text": "警政署也是運用這個管道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147804/86.wav", + "text": "不過我快速補充一點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147804/87.wav", + "text": "您看到網站上面的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147804/88.wav", + "text": "在臉書還沒有下架時" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147804/89.wav", + "text": "當然不要點進去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147804/90.wav", + "text": "但如果你點進去就" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147804/91.wav", + "text": "會看到那個網域" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147804/92.wav", + "text": "那你怎麼告訴民眾" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147804/93.wav", + "text": "不要點進去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147804/94.wav", + "text": "我都點進去了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147804/95.wav", + "text": "對但如果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147804/96.wav", + "text": "像您這邊看到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147804/97.wav", + "text": ".vn之類的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147804/98.wav", + "text": "那你怎麼不教民眾" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147804/99.wav", + "text": "包括我" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147804/100.wav", + "text": "怎麼判斷" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147804/101.wav", + "text": "可不可以點進去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147804/102.wav", + "text": "是我想先說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147804/103.wav", + "text": ".vn這樣的網站" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147804/104.wav", + "text": "這些都是可以透過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147804/105.wav", + "text": "網域停止解析" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147804/106.wav", + "text": "那民眾知道了嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147804/107.wav", + "text": "民眾知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147804/108.wav", + "text": "像這種釣魚詐騙" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147804/109.wav", + "text": "的訊息層出不窮" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147804/110.wav", + "text": "我跟我的朋友" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147804/111.wav", + "text": "我們很多都收到這樣的訊息" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147804/112.wav", + "text": "我們怎麼知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147804/113.wav", + "text": "我們不可以點進去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147804/114.wav", + "text": "之後包括個資" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147804/115.wav", + "text": "都曝光了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147804/116.wav", + "text": "啟動了這個網域" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147804/117.wav", + "text": "RPZ的機制之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147804/118.wav", + "text": "不慎點進去.vn的網站" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147804/119.wav", + "text": "顯示這個網域已經處理了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147804/120.wav", + "text": "一層就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147804/121.wav", + "text": "它是冒充政府的訊息" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147804/122.wav", + "text": "部長你認為數" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147804/123.wav", + "text": "數發部現在已經處理得當了嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147804/124.wav", + "text": "每天還是有很多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147804/125.wav", + "text": "啊很多這樣的假訊息" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147804/126.wav", + "text": "整個一站式網站的冒充" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147804/127.wav", + "text": "電商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147804/128.wav", + "text": "好不容易架設的電商網站" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147804/129.wav", + "text": "網域只差了一個字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147804/130.wav", + "text": "這樣的型態" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147804/131.wav", + "text": "現在越來越多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147804/132.wav", + "text": "你們5月開始就知道了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147804/133.wav", + "text": "但為什麼到現在越來越多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147804/134.wav", + "text": "我們5月就啟動了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147804/135.wav", + "text": "這些被冒充的電商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147804/136.wav", + "text": "我是9月28日" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147804/137.wav", + "text": "第一次看到我不知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147804/138.wav", + "text": "結果第二天凌晨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147804/139.wav", + "text": "我的信用卡就被盜刷了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147804/140.wav", + "text": "今天已經是10月23日" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147804/141.wav", + "text": "日我要請教部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147804/142.wav", + "text": "越來越嚴重" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147804/143.wav", + "text": "是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147804/144.wav", + "text": "就像剛剛講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147804/145.wav", + "text": "這些網域是當有人舉報" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147804/146.wav", + "text": "這看起來是詐騙網站" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147804/147.wav", + "text": "您跟Facebook舉報的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147804/148.wav", + "text": "這部分我們會有一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147804/149.wav", + "text": "快速的通道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147804/150.wav", + "text": "以後同樣一個網域" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147804/151.wav", + "text": "部長因為你講的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147804/152.wav", + "text": "我真的沒辦法知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147804/153.wav", + "text": "這樣有沒有效" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147804/154.wav", + "text": "你今天是不是可以告訴我" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147804/155.wav", + "text": "或是社會大眾" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147804/156.wav", + "text": "如果我們收到這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147804/157.wav", + "text": "不實的訊息" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147804/158.wav", + "text": "釣魚或者是詐騙訊息" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147804/159.wav", + "text": "我們要怎麼處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147804/160.wav", + "text": "因為包括我的朋友" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147804/161.wav", + "text": "要怎麼辦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147804/162.wav", + "text": "大家都很恐慌" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147804/163.wav", + "text": "其實最簡單的就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147804/164.wav", + "text": "如果裡面有附上網址" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147804/165.wav", + "text": "而這個發信的人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147804/166.wav", + "text": "不是你之前聯絡簿裡的朋友" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147804/167.wav", + "text": "也不是像111" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147804/168.wav", + "text": "已經認證的帳號的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147804/169.wav", + "text": "就不要點進去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147804/170.wav", + "text": "這是最簡單的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147804/171.wav", + "text": "透過你今天這樣說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147804/172.wav", + "text": "民眾就可以知道怎麼處理了嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147804/173.wav", + "text": "答案就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147804/174.wav", + "text": "不要點進去就好了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147804/175.wav", + "text": "是這樣嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147804/176.wav", + "text": "但是如果有人不慎點進去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147804/177.wav", + "text": "然後他去檢舉了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147804/178.wav", + "text": "那我們剛剛講的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147804/179.wav", + "text": "網域停止解析的機制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147804/180.wav", + "text": "有什麼樣的防範" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147804/181.wav", + "text": "或者是處罰機制嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147804/182.wav", + "text": "如果沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147804/183.wav", + "text": "這些假訊息越來越多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147804/184.wav", + "text": "就是無能啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147804/185.wav", + "text": "剛剛有講到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147804/186.wav", + "text": "24小時是基本的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147804/187.wav", + "text": "也就是如果不下架就罰款等等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147804/188.wav", + "text": "所以我們現在都是在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147804/189.wav", + "text": "比24小時還要前面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147804/190.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147804/191.wav", + "text": "數發部能夠給我們一個好的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147804/192.wav", + "text": "能夠信用的一個防" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147804/193.wav", + "text": "不然我們會覺得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147804/194.wav", + "text": "你們現在防詐機制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147804/195.wav", + "text": "像剛剛資" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147804/196.wav", + "text": "防詐騙" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147804/197.wav", + "text": "是不是很多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147804/198.wav", + "text": "請問部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147804/199.wav", + "text": "防制詐騙都外包嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147804/200.wav", + "text": "不是這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147804/201.wav", + "text": "我們資安署" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147804/202.wav", + "text": "所編列的預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147804/203.wav", + "text": "是用來強化公部門" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147804/204.wav", + "text": "跟關鍵基礎設施" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147804/205.wav", + "text": "抵抗網攻" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147804/206.wav", + "text": "特別是跨境網攻" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147804/207.wav", + "text": "所以是政策的擬定而已嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147804/208.wav", + "text": "真正的詐騙的防制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147804/209.wav", + "text": "制要靠誰來幫我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147804/210.wav", + "text": "我們特別綜合電商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147804/211.wav", + "text": "遊戲或第三方支付" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147804/212.wav", + "text": "位產業署的預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147804/213.wav", + "text": "好那還是在數發部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147804/214.wav", + "text": "但我覺得數發部現在做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147804/215.wav", + "text": "我自己的信用卡都被盜刷" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147804/216.wav", + "text": "我是今天才跟部長講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147804/217.wav", + "text": "這真的是很嚴重" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147804/218.wav", + "text": "\n再來問一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147804/219.wav", + "text": "投票電子連署" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147804/220.wav", + "text": "就已經完成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147804/221.wav", + "text": "行政院資安團隊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147804/222.wav", + "text": "跟數位發展部資通安全署" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147804/223.wav", + "text": "建議加強的42項措施" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147804/224.wav", + "text": "資安署已經完成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147804/225.wav", + "text": "複測確認資安無虞" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147804/226.wav", + "text": "請問部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147804/227.wav", + "text": "我們現在大概" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147804/228.wav", + "text": "可以上路了嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147804/229.wav", + "text": "我們所負責的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147804/230.wav", + "text": "就是提出資安的建議事項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147804/231.wav", + "text": "這件事情關於做到之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147804/232.wav", + "text": "他們什麼時候要啟用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147804/233.wav", + "text": "可能要回到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147804/234.wav", + "text": "中選會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147804/235.wav", + "text": "好由他們來決定就是了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147804/236.wav", + "text": "你們認為資安無虞" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147804/237.wav", + "text": "對之前檢測出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147804/238.wav", + "text": "他們都有改善" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147804/239.wav", + "text": "好謝謝主席再給我1分鐘就好了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147804/240.wav", + "text": "30秒" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147804/241.wav", + "text": "資通安全管理法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147804/242.wav", + "text": "修法的爭議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147804/243.wav", + "text": "有沒有明列" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147804/244.wav", + "text": "禁用中國資通" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147804/245.wav", + "text": "我們看到現在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147804/246.wav", + "text": "數發部還是以沿用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147804/247.wav", + "text": "2018年舊的函釋" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147804/248.wav", + "text": "就是第三地區" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147804/249.wav", + "text": "含陸資成分的廠商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147804/250.wav", + "text": "及在臺" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147804/251.wav", + "text": "陸資的廠商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147804/252.wav", + "text": "從嚴認定的範圍" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147804/253.wav", + "text": "但是行政院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147804/254.wav", + "text": "秘書長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147804/255.wav", + "text": "函在2020年12月8日" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147804/256.wav", + "text": "已經提到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147804/257.wav", + "text": "大陸廠牌認定方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147804/258.wav", + "text": "由填報機關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147804/259.wav", + "text": "從嚴認定所有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147804/260.wav", + "text": "屬大陸廠牌" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147804/261.wav", + "text": "者無論其原產地" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147804/262.wav", + "text": "於我國大陸地區" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147804/263.wav", + "text": "或第三地區等這些產品" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147804/264.wav", + "text": "都應該納入填報範圍" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147804/265.wav", + "text": "現在數發部用舊的函釋" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147804/266.wav", + "text": "釋請問" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147804/267.wav", + "text": "你們的考量" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147804/268.wav", + "text": "為什麼會是這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147804/269.wav", + "text": "很大的風險" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147804/270.wav", + "text": "這二個沒有矛盾" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147804/271.wav", + "text": "委員如果看簡報右下角它" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147804/272.wav", + "text": "是所謂的大陸廠牌" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147804/273.wav", + "text": "無論它原產地在哪裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147804/274.wav", + "text": "都要填報" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147804/275.wav", + "text": "這確實是這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147804/276.wav", + "text": "第三地區" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147804/277.wav", + "text": "如果它只是含有陸資" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147804/278.wav", + "text": "但是從判斷上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147804/279.wav", + "text": "不是中共實質控制的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147804/280.wav", + "text": "這個不算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147804/281.wav", + "text": "那你為什麼不用2020年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147804/282.wav", + "text": "12月18日的行政院秘書" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147804/283.wav", + "text": "這兩個是在講同一件事" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147804/284.wav", + "text": "您看簡報右下角在講的是廠牌" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147804/285.wav", + "text": "陳委員我請數發部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147804/286.wav", + "text": "用書面回答您好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147804/287.wav", + "text": "請你用書面寫清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147804/288.wav", + "text": "再回本辦公室" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147804/289.wav", + "text": "好的謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147804/290.wav", + "text": "接下來質詢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147803/0.wav", + "text": "早發言請建築研究所" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147803/1.wav", + "text": "王所長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147803/2.wav", + "text": "氣候變遷與溫室效應所造成的全球" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147803/3.wav", + "text": "全球暖化" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147803/4.wav", + "text": "當然已經" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147803/5.wav", + "text": "很嚴重威脅到我們人類的生活" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147803/6.wav", + "text": "節能減碳和永續發展" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147803/7.wav", + "text": "現在也變成全球" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147803/8.wav", + "text": "嚴重關切的課題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147803/9.wav", + "text": "我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147803/10.wav", + "text": "建築產業的能源消耗" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147803/11.wav", + "text": "資料看起來差不多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147803/12.wav", + "text": "占的比率很高" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147803/13.wav", + "text": "隨著全球淨零排碳的趨勢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147803/14.wav", + "text": "更需要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147803/15.wav", + "text": "積極因應" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147803/16.wav", + "text": "那麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147803/17.wav", + "text": "我們在蓋房子的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147803/18.wav", + "text": "環境的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147803/19.wav", + "text": "所以房地產業" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147803/20.wav", + "text": "者也應該��頭重視" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147803/21.wav", + "text": "因此在這裡要請教王所長就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147803/22.wav", + "text": "我國針對綠建築相關獎勵辦法的措施" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147803/23.wav", + "text": "有哪些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147803/24.wav", + "text": "請" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147803/25.wav", + "text": "所長說明一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147803/26.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147803/27.wav", + "text": "跟委員報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147803/28.wav", + "text": "現在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147803/29.wav", + "text": "民眾比較歡迎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147803/30.wav", + "text": "歡迎有績效的是在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147803/31.wav", + "text": "都市更新" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147803/32.wav", + "text": "跟危老重建" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147803/33.wav", + "text": "已經有列入容積獎勵" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147803/34.wav", + "text": "按照不同的等級" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147803/35.wav", + "text": "可以得到不同比例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147803/36.wav", + "text": "從2%到10%" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147803/37.wav", + "text": "在地方政府" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147803/38.wav", + "text": "他們對於重劃區" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147803/39.wav", + "text": "都市計畫自" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147803/40.wav", + "text": "治條例裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147803/41.wav", + "text": "也是有把" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147803/42.wav", + "text": "綠建築列到他們的獎勵範圍裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147803/43.wav", + "text": "只有這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147803/44.wav", + "text": "是我國推動全國" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147803/45.wav", + "text": "建築研究發展的領頭羊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147803/46.wav", + "text": "是責無旁貸" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147803/47.wav", + "text": "為了因應自然及社會環境的變遷" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147803/48.wav", + "text": "我們建築研究所" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147803/49.wav", + "text": "是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147803/50.wav", + "text": "因為我參照建築" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147803/51.wav", + "text": "研究所所提供的資料就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147803/52.wav", + "text": "到去年年底綠建築的普及率" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147803/53.wav", + "text": "在16.4%到20%" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147803/54.wav", + "text": "起起落落" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147803/55.wav", + "text": "前年的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147803/56.wav", + "text": "20.2" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147803/57.wav", + "text": "%所以從這項數據我們可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147803/58.wav", + "text": "看得出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147803/59.wav", + "text": "我國綠建築的普及率" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147803/60.wav", + "text": "不是呈現" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147803/61.wav", + "text": "出逐年遞增的趨勢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147803/62.wav", + "text": "你再看更早之前的數據" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147803/63.wav", + "text": "近十年來呈現高低起伏波動的狀態" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147803/64.wav", + "text": "而最高普及率" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147803/65.wav", + "text": "這個已經是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147803/66.wav", + "text": "7年前的數據" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147803/67.wav", + "text": "所以在這裡要請教王所長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147803/68.wav", + "text": "我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147803/69.wav", + "text": "綠建築的普及率" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147803/70.wav", + "text": "因為我們的綠建築" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147803/71.wav", + "text": "不是法令強制的規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147803/72.wav", + "text": "所以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147803/73.wav", + "text": "對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147803/74.wav", + "text": "但是我們的獎勵措施" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147803/75.wav", + "text": "危老跟都更案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147803/76.wav", + "text": "還有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147803/77.wav", + "text": "地方政府針對他們一些重劃區" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147803/78.wav", + "text": "有這個獎勵" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147803/79.wav", + "text": "啦其他一般的地區是沒有獎勵的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147803/80.wav", + "text": "是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147803/81.wav", + "text": "20%到17%" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147803/82.wav", + "text": "其實對我們臺灣來講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147803/83.wav", + "text": "雖然我們的綠建築" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147803/84.wav", + "text": "數量不是全世界最高的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147803/85.wav", + "text": "但是按照這個比率來講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147803/86.wav", + "text": "我們是全世界最高的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147803/87.wav", + "text": "譬如" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147803/88.wav", + "text": "LED" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147803/89.wav", + "text": "比我們還早" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147803/90.wav", + "text": "可是他們現在的普及率" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147803/91.wav", + "text": "另外委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147803/92.wav", + "text": "關心的地球暖化的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147803/93.wav", + "text": "其實我們配合2050淨零路徑的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147803/94.wav", + "text": "以後從今年7月1日開始" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147803/95.wav", + "text": "建築能效" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147803/96.wav", + "text": "就是針對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147803/97.wav", + "text": "建築物在使用階段" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147803/98.wav", + "text": "它的二氧化碳排放量" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147803/99.wav", + "text": "及能源使用量" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147803/100.wav", + "text": "我們開始要求必須降低" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147803/101.wav", + "text": "日公有建築物開始實施" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147803/102.wav", + "text": "以後慢慢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147803/103.wav", + "text": "會從公有建築" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147803/104.wav", + "text": "物逐漸來擴展到私有建築物" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147803/105.wav", + "text": "而且依照國發會的規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147803/106.wav", + "text": "以後這個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147803/107.wav", + "text": "我們會用法令強制來實施" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147803/108.wav", + "text": "因為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147803/109.wav", + "text": "我們不是用強制性的但是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147803/110.wav", + "text": "在各方面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147803/111.wav", + "text": "角色不用參考外國" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147803/112.wav", + "text": "我們現在是依照臺灣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147803/113.wav", + "text": "一定要走到這種程度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147803/114.wav", + "text": "我們也可以走在世界的前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147803/115.wav", + "text": "不管是獎勵措施也好或者是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147803/116.wav", + "text": "我們綠建築的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147803/117.wav", + "text": "這應該是很重要的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147803/118.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147803/119.wav", + "text": "有時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147803/120.wav", + "text": "一般的百姓感" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147803/121.wav", + "text": "一間房子本來300萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147803/122.wav", + "text": "會變成350萬價值的意思" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147803/123.wav", + "text": "有這種不肖業者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147803/124.wav", + "text": "來抬高他的房價" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147803/125.wav", + "text": "建築研究所" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147803/126.wav", + "text": "止或加強宣導宣傳" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147803/127.wav", + "text": "這個部分我們有做過研究" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147803/128.wav", + "text": "綠建築有分為五個等級" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147803/129.wav", + "text": "大概鑽石級的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147803/130.wav", + "text": "如果你是在銀級以下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147803/131.wav", + "text": "或者黃金級以下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147803/132.wav", + "text": "其實增加很少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147803/133.wav", + "text": "如果是銅級" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147803/134.wav", + "text": "幾乎是沒有什麼增加" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147803/135.wav", + "text": "我們有把研究的報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147803/136.wav", + "text": "一直宣傳" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147803/137.wav", + "text": "另外" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147803/138.wav", + "text": "我們為了宣傳綠建築" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147803/139.wav", + "text": "建築也舉辦很多活動" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147803/140.wav", + "text": "包括國中國小" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147803/141.wav", + "text": "有辦繪畫比賽" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147803/142.wav", + "text": "到成年的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147803/143.wav", + "text": "我們都免費來做解說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147803/144.wav", + "text": "讓民眾能夠深入瞭解" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147803/145.wav", + "text": "這個部分我們會再加強來做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147803/146.wav", + "text": "如果是智慧建築的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147803/147.wav", + "text": "所以它的製造成本當然比較高" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147803/148.wav", + "text": "不然照理說綠建築應該是平價" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147803/149.wav", + "text": "不浪費能源高效率CP值又高" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147803/150.wav", + "text": "的環保產品" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147803/151.wav", + "text": "所以說不但不會提高營建成本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147803/152.wav", + "text": "相反地應該會降低成本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147803/153.wav", + "text": "房價應該也會因此降低" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147803/154.wav", + "text": "建築研究所" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147803/155.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147803/156.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147803/157.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147803/158.wav", + "text": "謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/147803/159.wav", + "text": "謝謝林文瑞委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/0.wav", + "text": "\n關於租賃住宅市場發展及管理條例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/1.wav", + "text": "部分條文的修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/2.wav", + "text": "我們內政委員會上個會期" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/3.wav", + "text": "審查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/4.wav", + "text": "通過的條文有第10條及第十一條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/5.wav", + "text": "條保留的條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/6.wav", + "text": "有第五條增訂第十三條之一第十六條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/7.wav", + "text": "增訂第十六條之一" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/8.wav", + "text": "至第十六條之六" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/9.wav", + "text": "增訂第十七條之一" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/10.wav", + "text": "第三十四條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/11.wav", + "text": "第四章章名增訂第三十五條之一第" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/12.wav", + "text": "三十八條增訂第三十八條之一" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/13.wav", + "text": "日召開朝野協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/14.wav", + "text": "因此今天再繼續協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/15.wav", + "text": "當時已請內政部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/16.wav", + "text": "各委員所提的條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/17.wav", + "text": "今天內政部也提出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/18.wav", + "text": "就依照保留的條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/19.wav", + "text": "繼續討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/20.wav", + "text": "保留條文第5條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/21.wav", + "text": "希望能把租賃關係" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/22.wav", + "text": "全部朝向適用消費關係的方向" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/23.wav", + "text": "之後確實無法完全非常乾淨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/24.wav", + "text": "的這麼做但是在深度評估之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/25.wav", + "text": "我們認為還是可以朝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/26.wav", + "text": "適用消費關係的方向立法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/27.wav", + "text": "我們也支持這樣的修法方向" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/28.wav", + "text": "吳委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/29.wav", + "text": "其實我們有不同的版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/30.wav", + "text": "所以你們在文字上有什麼建議我" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/31.wav", + "text": "就上次協商的意見回去有做過討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/32.wav", + "text": "假設現在全面適用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/33.wav", + "text": "無論是具有消費關係" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/34.wav", + "text": "租賃契約出租人及承租人間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/35.wav", + "text": "視為消費關係" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/36.wav", + "text": "適用消費者保護法相關規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/37.wav", + "text": "因為第5條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/38.wav", + "text": "後段還有規定非具消費關係者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/39.wav", + "text": "其應約定及不得約定事項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/40.wav", + "text": "由中央主管機關定之" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/41.wav", + "text": "之我們這邊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/42.wav", + "text": "將它改成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/43.wav", + "text": "租賃契約出租人及承租人間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/44.wav", + "text": "視為具消費關係" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/45.wav", + "text": "適用消費者保護法相關規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/46.wav", + "text": "它不是消費者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/47.wav", + "text": "我們還是用約定及不得約定事項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/48.wav", + "text": "各位委員請大家看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/49.wav", + "text": "內政部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/50.wav", + "text": "可以嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/51.wav", + "text": "我們與消費者保護處" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/52.wav", + "text": "出租行為反覆等等請問這個函釋會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/53.wav", + "text": "作為一個什麼樣的備註" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/54.wav", + "text": "視為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/55.wav", + "text": "消保法的適用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/56.wav", + "text": "好我說明一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/57.wav", + "text": "非" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/58.wav", + "text": "具消費關係其實這是很難去界定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/59.wav", + "text": "所以行政院才會有那個函釋" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/60.wav", + "text": "釋假設我們現在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/61.wav", + "text": "修改成這樣的方" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/62.wav", + "text": "去界定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/63.wav", + "text": "只要是租賃關係" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/64.wav", + "text": "對這邊已經寫得很明確了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/65.wav", + "text": "對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/66.wav", + "text": "謝謝鄭委" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/67.wav", + "text": "吳委員可以嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/68.wav", + "text": "消費關係的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/69.wav", + "text": "當然就適用消保法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/70.wav", + "text": "但本席記得當時的討論有一個疑慮" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/71.wav", + "text": "無過失責任的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/72.wav", + "text": "這個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/73.wav", + "text": "是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/74.wav", + "text": "否要涵蓋進來也" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/75.wav", + "text": "就是適用消保法之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/76.wav", + "text": "本席記得這些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/77.wav", + "text": "無過失責任好像是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/78.wav", + "text": "這個部分是否要釐清一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/79.wav", + "text": "我們的疑慮是在適用消保法之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/80.wav", + "text": "之處或是有些疑慮的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/81.wav", + "text": "協商討論確實提過是不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/82.wav", + "text": "租賃的整個爭議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/83.wav", + "text": "大部分都是屬於" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/84.wav", + "text": "會比較少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/85.wav", + "text": "押金返還" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/86.wav", + "text": "侵權行為的爭議會比較少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/87.wav", + "text": "可能會比較嚴重一點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/88.wav", + "text": "妨害到逃生的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/89.wav", + "text": "甚至侵害到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/90.wav", + "text": "因此如果把個人房東都排除於" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/91.wav", + "text": "消保法第7條的無過失責任之外" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/92.wav", + "text": "的權益保障是不足的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/93.wav", + "text": "所以我們認為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/94.wav", + "text": "也要放進來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/95.wav", + "text": "無過失責任並非全面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/96.wav", + "text": "的其實它有提到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/97.wav", + "text": "自己是無過失者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/98.wav", + "text": "法院得減輕他的賠償責任" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/99.wav", + "text": "消保法對於房東應負的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/100.wav", + "text": "先改正一次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/101.wav", + "text": "再予以處罰" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/102.wav", + "text": "像我們之前講的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/103.wav", + "text": "我們一樣是命他先改善" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/104.wav", + "text": "罰則過重的問題存在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/105.wav", + "text": "內政部提出的新方向" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/106.wav", + "text": "但是本席想請教" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/107.wav", + "text": "提案版本中原" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/108.wav", + "text": "本針對第2項也有再做補充將" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/109.wav", + "text": "並以出租為業者等等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/110.wav", + "text": "不知道內政部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/111.wav", + "text": "當時是否參考過民" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/112.wav", + "text": "不需要將它寫得如" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/113.wav", + "text": "如此精準或明確請" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/114.wav", + "text": "其實是因為消費關係" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/115.wav", + "text": "及非消費關係" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/116.wav", + "text": "到底要如何界定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/117.wav", + "text": "所以它才會提出一個函釋" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/118.wav", + "text": "所有的租賃全面適用消保法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/119.wav", + "text": "是不是以房屋出租為業" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/120.wav", + "text": "我們就支持院版的條文沒有問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/121.wav", + "text": "適用消保法的處理因為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/122.wav", + "text": "而且是包羅萬象" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/123.wav", + "text": "如果又全部適用於消保法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/124.wav", + "text": "是否已經足夠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/125.wav", + "text": "委員目前消保官" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/126.wav", + "text": "並沒有特別去界定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/127.wav", + "text": "是否有消費關係" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/128.wav", + "text": "對於委員的關心我們收到了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/129.wav", + "text": "其實消保官都相當任勞任怨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/130.wav", + "text": "是否具有消費關係" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/131.wav", + "text": "只要民眾基於租賃房屋的糾紛提出申訴" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/132.wav", + "text": "如果不是房東的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/133.wav", + "text": "現在全部都界定為消費關係之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/134.wav", + "text": "預期會增加" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/135.wav", + "text": "的案件數可能也不會太多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/136.wav", + "text": "應該與現在是一樣的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/137.wav", + "text": "因為現在大概也不會去區分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/138.wav", + "text": "到底有沒有消費" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/139.wav", + "text": "關係其實這個認定還挺有困難性存在的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/140.wav", + "text": "各位委員還有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/141.wav", + "text": "吳委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/142.wav", + "text": "房客的部分是由消保官處理至" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/143.wav", + "text": "於房東的部分是按照" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/144.wav", + "text": "後面的配套處理或" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/145.wav", + "text": "如果這個條文通過的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/146.wav", + "text": "房客房東全部都在那邊處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/147.wav", + "text": "考慮它的量應該是不會增加很多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/148.wav", + "text": "就照內政部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/149.wav", + "text": "內政部有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/150.wav", + "text": "建議的條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/151.wav", + "text": "租賃要全面實價登錄的法條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/152.wav", + "text": "是不是一併處理租賃" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/153.wav", + "text": "全面實價登錄的理想性非常高" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/154.wav", + "text": "國外有部分國家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/155.wav", + "text": "會針對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/156.wav", + "text": "出租的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/157.wav", + "text": "甚至有些也針對個人房東出租的住宅" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/158.wav", + "text": "要求強制登錄" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/159.wav", + "text": "及交易安全品質的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/160.wav", + "text": "要求租金" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/161.wav", + "text": "也全部實價登錄並且要對外公布" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/162.wav", + "text": "全世界沒有這樣的國家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/163.wav", + "text": "也沒有任何國家可能做得到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/164.wav", + "text": "有一部分要求租金登錄的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/165.wav", + "text": "但它必須要付費查詢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/166.wav", + "text": "這是國外的經驗" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/167.wav", + "text": "不強制以書面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/168.wav", + "text": "立約而且是債權契約" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/169.wav", + "text": "話行政稽核的成本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/170.wav", + "text": "其實我們也找過22個地方政府開會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/171.wav", + "text": "所有地方政府一致反對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/172.wav", + "text": "有非常多的理由" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/173.wav", + "text": "我們當然不是只問反對與否" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/174.wav", + "text": "同時也要知道它的問題它的理由是什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/175.wav", + "text": "是所有縣市都反對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/176.wav", + "text": "真的要做的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/177.wav", + "text": "他們的人力能不能承擔" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/178.wav", + "text": "並請大家報出需要的人力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/179.wav", + "text": "提報出來的人力加總可能是三百零多人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/180.wav", + "text": "各縣市加起來要三百零多人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/181.wav", + "text": "才可能有辦法某種程度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/182.wav", + "text": "不過大家還是會擔憂" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/183.wav", + "text": "\n因此能否請委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/184.wav", + "text": "我們去強化" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/185.wav", + "text": "租屋實價登錄的範圍" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/186.wav", + "text": "納入實價登錄" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/187.wav", + "text": "避免納入一般個人房東的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/188.wav", + "text": "因為那個難度確實太高" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/189.wav", + "text": "恐怕到時候反而造成民怨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/190.wav", + "text": "甚至讓租屋更檯面化" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/191.wav", + "text": "以上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/192.wav", + "text": "當我們談到居住問題時" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/193.wav", + "text": "一部分當然是在於房價" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/194.wav", + "text": "一部分則是租屋黑市的情況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/195.wav", + "text": "供需狀況如何" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/196.wav", + "text": "以及相關資訊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/197.wav", + "text": "的盤點應該更加清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/198.wav", + "text": "過一個矛盾現象" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/199.wav", + "text": "象現在租賃的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/200.wav", + "text": "不放入實價登錄" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/201.wav", + "text": "但同時又提到該如何了解租賃市場" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/202.wav", + "text": "我們又得到一個答案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/203.wav", + "text": "但是它沒有辦法完整的考量" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/204.wav", + "text": "所以我們現在無法做這樣的分析" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/205.wav", + "text": "其實這兩個說法是衝突的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/206.wav", + "text": "相關部會主管機關如何了解" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/207.wav", + "text": "租賃市場的樣態到底租賃市場" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/208.wav", + "text": "實際上長什麼樣子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/209.wav", + "text": "可能都非常低" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/210.wav", + "text": "大家在街頭上隨口" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/211.wav", + "text": "所以我們要如何" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/212.wav", + "text": "做好租賃市場的管理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/213.wav", + "text": "因為沒有實價登錄" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/214.wav", + "text": "租屋市場的資訊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/215.wav", + "text": "大概是五十幾萬筆" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/216.wav", + "text": "大概有八十幾萬到一百萬的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/217.wav", + "text": "租屋樣態" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/218.wav", + "text": "所以我們掌握的比例非常高" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/219.wav", + "text": "大概是十七八萬筆" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/220.wav", + "text": "至於包租代管的資訊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/221.wav", + "text": "totoal有將近8萬筆左右" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/222.wav", + "text": "包租契約有1萬5,000筆" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/223.wav", + "text": "就是未來可以透過實價登錄" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/224.wav", + "text": "再將它轉化出來提供的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/225.wav", + "text": "也就是說未來的租屋實價登錄" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/226.wav", + "text": "就從17萬8," + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/227.wav", + "text": "筆再加上包租契約的1萬5," + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/228.wav", + "text": "當然一部分是由政府內部掌握" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/229.wav", + "text": "一部分可以對外公開讓民眾查詢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/230.wav", + "text": "\n至於這些資料的相關分析" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/231.wav", + "text": "其實我們內部也都正在做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/232.wav", + "text": "了後續針對租屋市場" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/233.wav", + "text": "的一些訊息分析樣態" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/234.wav", + "text": "相關的統計分析" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/235.wav", + "text": "的就是持續更新" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/236.wav", + "text": "讓社會大眾知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/237.wav", + "text": "市場一般的需求" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/238.wav", + "text": "交易訊息都要公開" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/239.wav", + "text": "未必要到百分之百的全面揭露" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/240.wav", + "text": "有人分析" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/241.wav", + "text": "有人解讀" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/242.wav", + "text": "有人掌握那個訊息" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/243.wav", + "text": "一點主計總處公布的租金指數" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/244.wav", + "text": "租金漲幅的感覺不一" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/245.wav", + "text": "實際上主計總處的租金指數" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/246.wav", + "text": "而那個定義確實會壓縮到漲幅" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/247.wav", + "text": "至於後續我們要不要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/248.wav", + "text": "發布租金指數" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/249.wav", + "text": "現在的資料去分析" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/250.wav", + "text": "其實租屋市場的異質性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/251.wav", + "text": "比買賣市場還要大" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/252.wav", + "text": "可能因為有冷氣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/253.wav", + "text": "或沒有冷氣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/254.wav", + "text": "不一樣所以它的異質性很大" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/255.wav", + "text": "每一筆資料出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/256.wav", + "text": "這間房子到底是租貴了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/257.wav", + "text": "了或租便宜了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/258.wav", + "text": "真的還是casebycase" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/259.wav", + "text": "這是困難的地方" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/260.wav", + "text": "雖然它與揭露透明有關係" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/261.wav", + "text": "但是沒有那麼的緊密" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/262.wav", + "text": "我們也希望" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/263.wav", + "text": "讓租屋資訊更加透明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/264.wav", + "text": "未來也會揭露更多的訊息" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/265.wav", + "text": "剛才提到租屋市場的相關分析" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/266.wav", + "text": "會定期揭露" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/267.wav", + "text": "我們希望讓這個話題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/268.wav", + "text": "在立法院及社會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/269.wav", + "text": "而具有共識之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/270.wav", + "text": "發布一個狀態是沒有問題的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/271.wav", + "text": "謝謝次長的說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/272.wav", + "text": "八九十萬的租屋市場" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/273.wav", + "text": "更完善的將住宅安全" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/274.wav", + "text": "也視為租屋安全指標" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/275.wav", + "text": "所以本席相信這個揭露" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/276.wav", + "text": "剛剛說1.5萬戶" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/277.wav", + "text": "是包租代管的量體" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/278.wav", + "text": "包租而已因此在資訊揭露的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/279.wav", + "text": "就是指包租" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/280.wav", + "text": "之前我們也說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/281.wav", + "text": "過有300億元的租屋補貼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/282.wav", + "text": "是授予主管機關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/283.wav", + "text": "可以公布" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/284.wav", + "text": "或是它就作為租稅的資訊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/285.wav", + "text": "沒有辦法公布" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/286.wav", + "text": "因此那個資訊要在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/287.wav", + "text": "可以被你們做漸進式的處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/288.wav", + "text": "因為他拿了政府的錢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/289.wav", + "text": "加入我們的租屋市場" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/290.wav", + "text": "如果我們潛在性的有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/291.wav", + "text": "八十幾萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/292.wav", + "text": "在300億元下去之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/293.wav", + "text": "可能會有30萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/294.wav", + "text": "願意加入政府的租金補貼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/295.wav", + "text": "因為給了房東誘因" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/296.wav", + "text": "所以他就會將" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/297.wav", + "text": "資訊公開" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/298.wav", + "text": "在我們的財稅資料" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/299.wav", + "text": "可以如何做二次的揭露" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/300.wav", + "text": "這個揭露" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/301.wav", + "text": "有沒有利弊上的考慮" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/302.wav", + "text": "以上是主要詢問的地方" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/303.wav", + "text": "樣是揭露的利弊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/304.wav", + "text": "請你先讓我們了解一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/305.wav", + "text": "根據我們的一般印象" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/306.wav", + "text": "到底造成的效益是什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/307.wav", + "text": "你們是否委託研究過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/308.wav", + "text": "實價登錄的結果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/309.wav", + "text": "我就無法買到25" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/310.wav", + "text": "萬元因此事實到底是什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/311.wav", + "text": "有沒有研究資料" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/312.wav", + "text": "有沒有科學的研究" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/313.wav", + "text": "這是第一點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/314.wav", + "text": "必須要有研究" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/315.wav", + "text": "我們才知道利弊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/316.wav", + "text": "我們才知道實情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/317.wav", + "text": "現在的仲介" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/318.wav", + "text": "都是拿實價登錄說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/319.wav", + "text": "一坪已經漲到多少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/320.wav", + "text": "就沒有機會了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/321.wav", + "text": "對於房價的效益是什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/322.wav", + "text": "售屋與租屋的差別" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/323.wav", + "text": "售屋要不就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/324.wav", + "text": "看得出來是二手的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/325.wav", + "text": "要不就是新的建案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/326.wav", + "text": "但是租屋就是屋況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/327.wav", + "text": "差異非常的大" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/328.wav", + "text": "沒有相同的標準" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/329.wav", + "text": "租金實價登錄的結果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/330.wav", + "text": "會造成什麼效應" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/331.wav", + "text": "本席認為我們也需要知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/332.wav", + "text": "到底是利或弊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/333.wav", + "text": "我先從管委員的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/334.wav", + "text": "房價市場的實價登錄" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/335.wav", + "text": "本質上在推動初期" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/336.wav", + "text": "我們就已經對外說過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/337.wav", + "text": "而外界也都認同" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/338.wav", + "text": "實價登錄會有一個效果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/339.wav", + "text": "就是助漲及助跌" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/340.wav", + "text": "因為它的訊息透明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/341.wav", + "text": "所以在市場" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/342.wav", + "text": "如同剛剛管委員所言" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/343.wav", + "text": "言現在已經到這個價格了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/344.wav", + "text": "但是在跌的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/345.wav", + "text": "其實也會發生同樣的效果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/346.wav", + "text": "可能還會跌更多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/347.wav", + "text": "它就會有這樣的效應" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/348.wav", + "text": "對於這個制度本質上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/349.wav", + "text": "度時本來就有這樣的理解" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/350.wav", + "text": "如果炒作氛圍更大" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/351.wav", + "text": "它的效果就會更大" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/352.wav", + "text": "賣壓大餘屋大的地方" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/353.wav", + "text": "這個效果也會跟著更大" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/354.wav", + "text": "照這樣講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/355.wav", + "text": "對買方都不利" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/356.wav", + "text": "啊對不對當它助跌的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/357.wav", + "text": "仲介會說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/358.wav", + "text": "你再不賣就會跌更多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/359.wav", + "text": "喔這時候會止跌" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/360.wav", + "text": "他就買不到更低的價錢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/361.wav", + "text": "這時賣方必須要折讓更多才賣得出去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/362.wav", + "text": "但是時間會縮短" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/363.wav", + "text": "這就是實價登錄" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/364.wav", + "text": "但實質上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/365.wav", + "text": "它也不是主要影響漲跌的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/366.wav", + "text": "因素因為漲跌還是以其他經濟因素" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/367.wav", + "text": "及市場因素為主軸" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/368.wav", + "text": "所以實價登錄" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/369.wav", + "text": "只是讓它的幅度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/370.wav", + "text": "可能比原來的大一點點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/371.wav", + "text": "不過循環的時間也會因此而縮短" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/372.wav", + "text": "因為它的反映會提前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/373.wav", + "text": "才會比較快" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/374.wav", + "text": "總之它的效果大約是這樣的狀況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/375.wav", + "text": "在漲價時" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/376.wav", + "text": "實價登錄可能會有某些炒家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/377.wav", + "text": "他要炒作的區域定錨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/378.wav", + "text": "但是跌的時候不會有人主動" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/379.wav", + "text": "除非有那種非常急於脫售的價格" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/380.wav", + "text": "因為價格被破壞" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/381.wav", + "text": "這就是跌價的定錨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/382.wav", + "text": "效果不過這個部分還是要看區域" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/383.wav", + "text": "不會是普遍" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/384.wav", + "text": "的現象而剛剛我講的漲跌及時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/385.wav", + "text": "就是一個普遍的現象" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/386.wav", + "text": "關於租屋市場的實價登錄" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/387.wav", + "text": "確實剛剛管委員也提到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/388.wav", + "text": "因為租屋市場的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/389.wav", + "text": "異質性或品質落差非常大" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/390.wav", + "text": "這間的房東把房子裝潢得美倫美奐" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/391.wav", + "text": "就是三四十年老房子的樣子放在那邊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/392.wav", + "text": "它的租金甚至可能會相差1" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/393.wav", + "text": "實價登錄資訊揭露及掌握的同時" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/394.wav", + "text": "把這裡面所有細緻的設施設備" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/395.wav", + "text": "及屋況如此充分的呈現出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/396.wav", + "text": "調查成本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/397.wav", + "text": "會高到更可怕" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/398.wav", + "text": "現在大約有十七八萬筆資料" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/399.wav", + "text": "也就是包租約" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/400.wav", + "text": "大概有1萬5,000筆" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/401.wav", + "text": "未來都會揭露出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/402.wav", + "text": "其他部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/403.wav", + "text": "可能還有三十幾萬筆" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/404.wav", + "text": "是政府內部掌握的資料" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/405.wav", + "text": "我們透過統計分析" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/406.wav", + "text": "告訴大家大致上現在的租金狀況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/407.wav", + "text": "大約是如何" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/408.wav", + "text": "當然在這背後都還有一些社會教育" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/409.wav", + "text": "但是比較難" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/410.wav", + "text": "可以拿幾個案例做比較" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/411.wav", + "text": "因為它的相對內容比較完整" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/412.wav", + "text": "現實上各國在這個部分確實" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/413.wav", + "text": "以上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/414.wav", + "text": "還有要發言" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/415.wav", + "text": "內政部掌握的30萬筆資料進行分析" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/416.wav", + "text": "租金如何" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/417.wav", + "text": "對應到的品質如何" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/418.wav", + "text": "但剛剛同時又說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/419.wav", + "text": "因為租屋市場的變異比較多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/420.wav", + "text": "對應到的品質是如何" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/421.wav", + "text": "我講的是一般的品質" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/422.wav", + "text": "不是講品質的落" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/423.wav", + "text": "的中位數或平均的品質水準" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/424.wav", + "text": "大概到哪裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/425.wav", + "text": "當你多一台冷氣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/426.wav", + "text": "這是沒辦法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/427.wav", + "text": "如何知道中位數的品質是什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/428.wav", + "text": "既然你沒有那個資料" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/429.wav", + "text": "怎麼會知道它對應到的品質" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/430.wav", + "text": "\n剛剛你不是說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/431.wav", + "text": "只能知道租屋市場的租金" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/432.wav", + "text": "它的品質內容" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/433.wav", + "text": "現在又說我們可以知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/434.wav", + "text": "中位數對應到的品質" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/435.wav", + "text": "我講的品質可能是它的面積" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/436.wav", + "text": "它的屋齡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/437.wav", + "text": "及它的房屋結構" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/438.wav", + "text": "之類最基本的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/439.wav", + "text": "主要品質內容而已" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/440.wav", + "text": "另外一個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/441.wav", + "text": "過去我們一直在談" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/442.wav", + "text": "我們有租屋補助等等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/443.wav", + "text": "但是相信大家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/444.wav", + "text": "一旦申請租屋補助" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/445.wav", + "text": "之後租金就會變成是透明的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/446.wav", + "text": "同時房東可能就會被課稅" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/447.wav", + "text": "更加透明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/448.wav", + "text": "以及讓這些房東被課稅" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/449.wav", + "text": "應該是一件符合公平正義的事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/450.wav", + "text": "因為我們都沒要求" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/451.wav", + "text": "設房客去報稅" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/452.wav", + "text": "也很清楚這是會發生的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/453.wav", + "text": "如果大家注意到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/454.wav", + "text": "增加的幅度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/455.wav", + "text": "從一開始可能是456萬到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/456.wav", + "text": "到前年double變成12萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/457.wav", + "text": "最後有32萬申請" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/458.wav", + "text": "實質上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/459.wav", + "text": "還是有很多房東及房客" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/460.wav", + "text": "確實還有部分房東" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/461.wav", + "text": "對於這個信任度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/462.wav", + "text": "感到質疑認為今天讓房客去申請租補" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/463.wav", + "text": "等等會不會被政府掌握" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/464.wav", + "text": "於是就要被追稅" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/465.wav", + "text": "但是實質上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/466.wav", + "text": "這些年來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/467.wav", + "text": "因為在法條已經明文規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/468.wav", + "text": "不得作為課稅的依據" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/469.wav", + "text": "這是在法裡面已經明定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/470.wav", + "text": "是因為過去房東可能不相信" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/471.wav", + "text": "然而最後的事實證明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/472.wav", + "text": "的資料而被課稅" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/473.wav", + "text": "所以這是信心建構的過程" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/474.wav", + "text": "有30萬個房東參加" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/475.wav", + "text": "參加經過一年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/476.wav", + "text": "課稅時不" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/477.wav", + "text": "會有房東說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/478.wav", + "text": "自己因為這樣而被課稅" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/479.wav", + "text": "信心就會逐步建立" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/480.wav", + "text": "及信任的過程" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/481.wav", + "text": "而我們也是要不斷不斷的去傳遞" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/482.wav", + "text": "當然財政部還是會有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/483.wav", + "text": "它另外查稅的機制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/484.wav", + "text": "進行普查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/485.wav", + "text": "無論你有沒有參加" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/486.wav", + "text": "租金補貼的申請" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/487.wav", + "text": "一視同仁" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/488.wav", + "text": "的全面進行普查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/489.wav", + "text": "進行我們當然是尊重它" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/490.wav", + "text": "的作法其實這是兩軌不一樣的事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/491.wav", + "text": "健全這個租屋市場" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/492.wav", + "text": "以上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/493.wav", + "text": "增訂第十三條之1" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/494.wav", + "text": "不修大家有沒有意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/495.wav", + "text": "不修與保留是兩件事" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/496.wav", + "text": "主席你的意思是怎樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/497.wav", + "text": "保留就保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/498.wav", + "text": "不要就講不修" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/499.wav", + "text": "因為不修的意思是維持原條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/500.wav", + "text": "所以現在是怎樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/501.wav", + "text": "保留好了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/502.wav", + "text": "本席現在是問大家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/503.wav", + "text": "保留好了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/504.wav", + "text": "不修啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/505.wav", + "text": "大家有沒有意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/506.wav", + "text": "不修或不予增訂" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/507.wav", + "text": "大家有沒有意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/508.wav", + "text": "就不增訂" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/509.wav", + "text": "有沒有要做附帶決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/510.wav", + "text": "如果有需要再去提" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/511.wav", + "text": "增訂第十三條之1" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/512.wav", + "text": "1不予" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/513.wav", + "text": "予增訂" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/514.wav", + "text": "\n第四章章名維持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/515.wav", + "text": "增訂第35條之1" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/516.wav", + "text": "1不予增訂" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/517.wav", + "text": "\n增訂第39條之1" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/518.wav", + "text": "1不予增訂" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/519.wav", + "text": "\n第46條維持現行條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/520.wav", + "text": "第十六條之1至第十六條之六" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/521.wav", + "text": "請一併說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/522.wav", + "text": "內政部今天印出來的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/523.wav", + "text": "因為我們將議題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/524.wav", + "text": "因為它是連帶的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/525.wav", + "text": "連貫的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/526.wav", + "text": "第46條的部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/527.wav", + "text": "部分因為我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/528.wav", + "text": "後面會修正第34條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/529.wav", + "text": "所以第46條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/530.wav", + "text": "要維持曾銘" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/531.wav", + "text": "所以還是要嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/532.wav", + "text": "這個還是需要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/533.wav", + "text": "46條最後再談" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/534.wav", + "text": "你們要記得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/535.wav", + "text": "拿出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/536.wav", + "text": "好第46條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/537.wav", + "text": "最後再談" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/538.wav", + "text": "內政部書面資料的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/539.wav", + "text": "為(二)還沒有談" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/540.wav", + "text": "對連動的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/541.wav", + "text": "好先討論(四" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/542.wav", + "text": "這個部分就是剛剛所講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/543.wav", + "text": "包租代管的實價登錄" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/544.wav", + "text": "我們同意把" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/545.wav", + "text": "轉租約" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/546.wav", + "text": "納入實價登錄" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/547.wav", + "text": "條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/548.wav", + "text": "在第2頁的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/549.wav", + "text": "租賃住宅服務業" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/550.wav", + "text": "應於" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/551.wav", + "text": "將其受託管理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/552.wav", + "text": "承租或轉租" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/553.wav", + "text": "租賃住宅之相關資訊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/554.wav", + "text": "一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/555.wav", + "text": "是30天內就要申報" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/556.wav", + "text": "如果是透過仲介" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/557.wav", + "text": "要來申報的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/558.wav", + "text": "一樣是30天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/559.wav", + "text": "所以我們又" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/560.wav", + "text": "提前讓它更即時" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/561.wav", + "text": "第38條的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/562.wav", + "text": "委員有提到要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/563.wav", + "text": "將包租代管全面納入" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/564.wav", + "text": "第34條之對不起" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/565.wav", + "text": "第34條之1是新增訂" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/566.wav", + "text": "請各位委員參閱" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/567.wav", + "text": "包租業之" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/568.wav", + "text": "租賃住宅轉租案件" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/569.wav", + "text": "應於簽訂轉租契約之" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/570.wav", + "text": "日起三十日內" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/571.wav", + "text": "向直轄市縣（市）主管機關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/572.wav", + "text": "申報登錄" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/573.wav", + "text": "成交案件實際資訊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/574.wav", + "text": "（以下簡稱" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/575.wav", + "text": "申報登錄資訊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/576.wav", + "text": "前項申報登錄資訊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/577.wav", + "text": "除涉及個人資料外" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/578.wav", + "text": "得提供查詢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/579.wav", + "text": "第1項申報登錄資訊類別" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/580.wav", + "text": "內容與前項提供之內容方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/581.wav", + "text": "收費費額及其他" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/582.wav", + "text": "應遵行事項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/583.wav", + "text": "準用不動產經紀業管理條例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/584.wav", + "text": "第24條之1" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/585.wav", + "text": "第5項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/586.wav", + "text": "所定辦法之規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/587.wav", + "text": "為查核申報登錄資訊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/588.wav", + "text": "得向包租業或次承租人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/589.wav", + "text": "要求查詢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/590.wav", + "text": "閱有關文件或提出說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/591.wav", + "text": "受查核者不得規避" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/592.wav", + "text": "妨礙或拒絕" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/593.wav", + "text": "前項查核不得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/594.wav", + "text": "逾確保申報登錄資訊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/595.wav", + "text": "正確性目的之必要範圍" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/596.wav", + "text": "這是內政部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/597.wav", + "text": "建議增��之條文以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/598.wav", + "text": "因應轉租的資料" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/599.wav", + "text": "這一條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/600.wav", + "text": "基本上跟當時民眾黨提案的方向" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/601.wav", + "text": "但還是有一點點小小的差別" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/602.wav", + "text": "我們可以給予支持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/603.wav", + "text": "稍微要請教一個問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/604.wav", + "text": "因為你這邊規定的是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/605.wav", + "text": "包租業之租賃住宅轉租案件" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/606.wav", + "text": "那麼包租業者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/607.wav", + "text": "我不知道等一下可以解釋一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/608.wav", + "text": "\n另外一個就是民眾黨版的規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/609.wav", + "text": "用這個有沒有可能" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/610.wav", + "text": "也把它放進去呢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/611.wav", + "text": "當然在大方向" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/612.wav", + "text": "往這樣的方向走" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/613.wav", + "text": "因為30日的那個部分更好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/614.wav", + "text": "我們是給予支持的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/615.wav", + "text": "修法的想法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/616.wav", + "text": "但是等一下請稍微解釋一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/617.wav", + "text": "我對於內政部現在的修正方向是支持的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/618.wav", + "text": "因為本來在包租代管或租賃業部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/619.wav", + "text": "實價登錄申報登錄" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/620.wav", + "text": "都很清楚的讓更多民眾可以瞭解" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/621.wav", + "text": "但是剛剛內政部解釋了第34條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/622.wav", + "text": "這個在立法上有一些疑慮" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/623.wav", + "text": "沒有第34條之一" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/624.wav", + "text": "所以內政部不能自己新增" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/625.wav", + "text": "啊你不能自己新增" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/626.wav", + "text": "把這些文字放進去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/627.wav", + "text": "比較像是把二條合併在一起" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/628.wav", + "text": "我覺得你們立法技術要解決" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/629.wav", + "text": "不能自己再訂定新條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/630.wav", + "text": "因為沒有委員提案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/631.wav", + "text": "啊所以這個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/632.wav", + "text": "可能你們要注意一下立法請" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/633.wav", + "text": "因為我們自己的想法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/634.wav", + "text": "是希望包租代管的資料都" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/635.wav", + "text": "可以登錄查詢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/636.wav", + "text": "雖然大方向是希望能夠更加透明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/637.wav", + "text": "所以想請教的是以包租代管業" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/638.wav", + "text": "是轉租案件" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/639.wav", + "text": "有多少是承租案件" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/640.wav", + "text": "或多少是受委託管理等等的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/641.wav", + "text": "這樣我��才知道這樣的數據量是否足夠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/642.wav", + "text": "賃服務業裡面的資訊都公開" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/643.wav", + "text": "會遇到什麼困境或是影響嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/644.wav", + "text": "如果沒有的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/645.wav", + "text": "為什麼不能朝這個方向來努力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/646.wav", + "text": "因為公開的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/647.wav", + "text": "除了時代力量之外" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/648.wav", + "text": "包括吳玉琴委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/649.wav", + "text": "其實應該都是朝向這個方向" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/650.wav", + "text": "我來回應一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/651.wav", + "text": "首先謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/652.wav", + "text": "我很快問一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/653.wav", + "text": "第3項為什麼會有收費費" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/654.wav", + "text": "額是誰跟誰收" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/655.wav", + "text": "這是有什麼打算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/656.wav", + "text": "我們回去會再考量看看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/657.wav", + "text": "怎麼加到第34條這邊\n" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/658.wav", + "text": "剛剛張委員以及王委員所提到的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/659.wav", + "text": "為什麼我們現在只限定在轉租的資訊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/660.wav", + "text": "才要實價登錄" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/661.wav", + "text": "跟委員報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/662.wav", + "text": "因為以包租來講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/663.wav", + "text": "事實上那是包租業" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/664.wav", + "text": "的整個房子包過來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/665.wav", + "text": "並不是市場的行情價格" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/666.wav", + "text": "代管的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/667.wav", + "text": "它只是代理做一些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/668.wav", + "text": "事實上這個租金的行情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/669.wav", + "text": "事實上並沒有完全可以掌握" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/670.wav", + "text": "當然可能有一些他知道租金" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/671.wav", + "text": "行情可是有一些他並不知道租金" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/672.wav", + "text": "行情所以以代管業來講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/673.wav", + "text": "他也沒有完全掌握到這個租金的行情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/674.wav", + "text": "以我們目前瞭解的整個市場的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/675.wav", + "text": "我們認為轉租事實上是有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/676.wav", + "text": "轉到承租人這邊來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/677.wav", + "text": "所以那個租金的行情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/678.wav", + "text": "事實上是可以掌握到的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/679.wav", + "text": "所以我們現在才選擇" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/680.wav", + "text": "轉租事實上是可以的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/681.wav", + "text": "\n第二個問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/682.wav", + "text": "有二位委員問到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/683.wav", + "text": "我們對外提供查詢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/684.wav", + "text": "實價登錄那邊一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/685.wav", + "text": "你要來下載我們的大量資料" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/686.wav", + "text": "事實上要經過向內政部的許可" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/687.wav", + "text": "並向內政部繳費繳費之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/688.wav", + "text": "我們才會讓你下載這個大量資料" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/689.wav", + "text": "如果一筆要整個拿走的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/690.wav", + "text": "個別查詢是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/691.wav", + "text": "我知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/692.wav", + "text": "其實我們常常看到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/693.wav", + "text": "內政部也好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/694.wav", + "text": "主計總處也好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/695.wav", + "text": "常常公布的數據" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/696.wav", + "text": "讓一般民眾都覺得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/697.wav", + "text": "很不可思議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/698.wav", + "text": "或是免費的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/699.wav", + "text": "讓研究機構大量的下降" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/700.wav", + "text": "降其實會大量下載" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/701.wav", + "text": "大概就是研究機構啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/702.wav", + "text": "如果研究機構能夠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/703.wav", + "text": "很簡單的存取這些資料的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/704.wav", + "text": "我覺得他們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/705.wav", + "text": "等於是免費在幫政府做研究" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/706.wav", + "text": "其實我們的收費不高" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/707.wav", + "text": "經常向政府下載資料買資料" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/708.wav", + "text": "其實都還在研究可負擔的狀況下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/709.wav", + "text": "對不起那個收費其實不高" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/710.wav", + "text": "啦不足100M的話是2,000元" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/711.wav", + "text": "到500M）是4,000元" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/712.wav", + "text": "500M以上的話是6,000元" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/713.wav", + "text": "所以這個費用其實不高" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/714.wav", + "text": "不然有人會漫無限制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/715.wav", + "text": "對不起我剛剛有點分心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/716.wav", + "text": "了我請教一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/717.wav", + "text": "這個查詢系統在哪裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/718.wav", + "text": "在政府機關嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/719.wav", + "text": "所以是你們提供查詢嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/720.wav", + "text": "對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/721.wav", + "text": "資訊是你們要提供查詢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/722.wav", + "text": "你們會有相關查詢的機制出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/723.wav", + "text": "為什麼要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/724.wav", + "text": "現在就有這個查詢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/725.wav", + "text": "大量的資料" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/726.wav", + "text": "逐筆查不用錢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/727.wav", + "text": "甚至我們每一個月" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/728.wav", + "text": "update上去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/729.wav", + "text": "那個月的資料放上去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/730.wav", + "text": "其實也都讓大家freedownload" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/731.wav", + "text": "但是如果是��個資料庫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/732.wav", + "text": "或是臺北市從古至今" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/733.wav", + "text": "所有的資料要一次download" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/734.wav", + "text": "那樣就要收費" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/735.wav", + "text": "100M收2,000元" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/736.wav", + "text": "其實是避免" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/737.wav", + "text": "一大堆人來申請" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/738.wav", + "text": "真的有需要的人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/739.wav", + "text": "可是分二種嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/740.wav", + "text": "一種是營利單位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/741.wav", + "text": "一種是非營利的查詢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/742.wav", + "text": "非營利的查詢也要收費" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/743.wav", + "text": "其實費用不高" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/744.wav", + "text": "所以我們沒有區分營利與非營利" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/745.wav", + "text": "時可能跟財政部要一些所得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/746.wav", + "text": "稅資料我可能一次要好幾萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/747.wav", + "text": "甚至10萬塊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/748.wav", + "text": "因為還有上機費等等等等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/749.wav", + "text": "但是我們這個就只是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/750.wav", + "text": "用資料庫2,000元4,000元" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/751.wav", + "text": "幾乎就可以把全部的資料都拿到了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/752.wav", + "text": "現在其實是公民審議的時代" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/753.wav", + "text": "就可以做公民審議的工作" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/754.wav", + "text": "他就是公民調查官" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/755.wav", + "text": "在這個的時代" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/756.wav", + "text": "我們每個月會有一個新的資料檔" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/757.wav", + "text": "上去的那個批次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/758.wav", + "text": "是不要錢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/759.wav", + "text": "的所以每次只要在固定時間去freedownload" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/760.wav", + "text": "這個部分都沒有問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/761.wav", + "text": "這樣他就自動更新" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/762.wav", + "text": "這不是成本的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/763.wav", + "text": "是資料管理的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/764.wav", + "text": "有一個解方" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/765.wav", + "text": "不是你們其實" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/766.wav", + "text": "可以把收費費額拿掉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/767.wav", + "text": "可是為了解決你的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/768.wav", + "text": "就是避免人家一直來抓資料" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/769.wav", + "text": "你可以限制他一次下載的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/770.wav", + "text": "最大量" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/771.wav", + "text": "那他可以分批" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/772.wav", + "text": "他是來向我們申請" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/773.wav", + "text": "我們給他的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/774.wav", + "text": "不是他自己抓" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/775.wav", + "text": "的不可能讓他自己抓" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/776.wav", + "text": "不是自己抓" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/777.wav", + "text": "了大家才會對這個寫法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/778.wav", + "text": "不能夠理解" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/779.wav", + "text": "第2項規定的提供查詢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/780.wav", + "text": "這個是免費" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/781.wav", + "text": "收費費額" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/782.wav", + "text": "其他可提供是不是免費" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/783.wav", + "text": "就像我去查你一定會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/784.wav", + "text": "隱匿部分我就看到了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/785.wav", + "text": "可是你的第3項是在講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/786.wav", + "text": "第1項申請的收費費額" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/787.wav", + "text": "是不是第2項的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/788.wav", + "text": "所以第2項是不是得免費提供" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/789.wav", + "text": "第2項的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/790.wav", + "text": "可以寫得免費提供" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/791.wav", + "text": "然後你的第1項申報登錄" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/792.wav", + "text": "等等的收費標準" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/793.wav", + "text": "第2項的免費查詢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/794.wav", + "text": "你就可以區別了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/795.wav", + "text": "寫成免費查詢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/796.wav", + "text": "第3項才處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/797.wav", + "text": "非免費查詢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/798.wav", + "text": "什麼樣的情形是免費" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/799.wav", + "text": "這邊不寫的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/800.wav", + "text": "你沒有聽懂我的意思" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/801.wav", + "text": "第2項寫得免費提供查詢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/802.wav", + "text": "跟第3項收費費額" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/803.wav", + "text": "這二個是不同的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/804.wav", + "text": "data的提供方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/805.wav", + "text": "嘛資訊提供方式不同" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/806.wav", + "text": "當然有些要收費" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/807.wav", + "text": "都有售屋" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/808.wav", + "text": "售屋的實價登錄都有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/809.wav", + "text": "文字上幾乎是大同小異" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/810.wav", + "text": "人家會以為每查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/811.wav", + "text": "第3項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/812.wav", + "text": "方式收費費額" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/813.wav", + "text": "準用那個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/814.wav", + "text": "辦法的規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/815.wav", + "text": "賴委員的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/816.wav", + "text": "不是沒問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/817.wav", + "text": "啦所以才造成賴委員這樣解讀" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/818.wav", + "text": "啦\n因為你的主詞是第1項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/819.wav", + "text": "申報資料" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/820.wav", + "text": "嘛可是你到收費費額的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/821.wav", + "text": "就不是第1項了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/822.wav", + "text": "你二個主詞都是第1項開頭" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/823.wav", + "text": "嘛所以賴委員講的沒錯" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/824.wav", + "text": "啊是你們的文字有問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/825.wav", + "text": "怎麼會沒問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/826.wav", + "text": "第1項沒有收費問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/827.wav", + "text": "第1項沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/828.wav", + "text": "所以那個收費費額" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/829.wav", + "text": "就必須是第2項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/830.wav", + "text": "或者是前項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/831.wav", + "text": "前項提供之內容方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/832.wav", + "text": "與切開" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/833.wav", + "text": "前項收費費額" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/834.wav", + "text": "法制單位有沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/835.wav", + "text": "之1" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/836.wav", + "text": "可以放在第34條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/837.wav", + "text": "我們可以把它放在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/838.wav", + "text": "原來的提案條文就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/839.wav", + "text": "34條之1" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/840.wav", + "text": "的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/841.wav", + "text": "項次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/842.wav", + "text": "文字再做調整" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/843.wav", + "text": "原來民眾黨版的條文就" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/844.wav", + "text": "很長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/845.wav", + "text": "曾銘宗委員的版本有沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/846.wav", + "text": "整理之後再處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/847.wav", + "text": "書面資料(四)還有第38條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/848.wav", + "text": "要不要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/849.wav", + "text": "說明一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/850.wav", + "text": "有關係嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/851.wav", + "text": "有連帶嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/852.wav", + "text": "第38條是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/853.wav", + "text": "因為我們有把轉租" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/854.wav", + "text": "放進來了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/855.wav", + "text": "第38條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/856.wav", + "text": "所以這個部分還是要改" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/857.wav", + "text": "所以要變成第38條是不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/858.wav", + "text": "就變成還是要改" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/859.wav", + "text": "內容部分大家有沒有意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/860.wav", + "text": "內政部所提供的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/861.wav", + "text": "的建議條文是第36" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/862.wav", + "text": "條之2當然第36條之2" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/863.wav", + "text": "還是要把它" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/864.wav", + "text": "第38條看有沒有辦法做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/865.wav", + "text": "條次的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/866.wav", + "text": "很難分嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/867.wav", + "text": "很難合在一起" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/868.wav", + "text": "我們依照委員的意見我們把它修到第38條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/869.wav", + "text": "不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/870.wav", + "text": "罰款的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/871.wav", + "text": "就是違反的罰款部分都要在第38條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/872.wav", + "text": "後面去放" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/873.wav", + "text": "就民眾黨版的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/874.wav", + "text": "第38條跟你" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/875.wav", + "text": "之2再予以整理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/876.wav", + "text": "整理到第38條那邊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/877.wav", + "text": "就是第5項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/878.wav", + "text": "我們版本的第5項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/879.wav", + "text": "所以就是用我們的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/880.wav", + "text": "沒關係這個還要再整理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/881.wav", + "text": "\n接下來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/882.wav", + "text": "處理內政部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/883.wav", + "text": "牽涉到的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/884.wav", + "text": "就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/885.wav", + "text": "主席剛剛真的有立法技術上的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/886.wav", + "text": "行政部門可能忽略了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/887.wav", + "text": "他們想在第38條來處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/888.wav", + "text": "但自己弄了個第36條之2" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/889.wav", + "text": "本席跟時代力量的提案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/890.wav", + "text": "有第38條之一" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/891.wav", + "text": "有這個條次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/892.wav", + "text": "所以我的意思是內" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/893.wav", + "text": "部的第36條之2" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/894.wav", + "text": "要不要改成第38條之一" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/895.wav", + "text": "就是把它的條文放在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/896.wav", + "text": "第38條之一" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/897.wav", + "text": "因為我們有新增條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/898.wav", + "text": "之2就請內政部再去整理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/899.wav", + "text": "跟委員報告一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/900.wav", + "text": "有關修正第十六條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/901.wav", + "text": "增訂第十六條之一" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/902.wav", + "text": "第十六條之六" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/903.wav", + "text": "將" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/904.wav", + "text": "住宅租賃爭議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/905.wav", + "text": "調處修正為調解" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/906.wav", + "text": "並賦予調解結果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/907.wav", + "text": "具有民事法院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/908.wav", + "text": "效力的這一節" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/909.wav", + "text": "我來說明\n有關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/910.wav", + "text": "在11月18日" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/911.wav", + "text": "日邀集行政院消保處" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/912.wav", + "text": "及各縣市政府" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/913.wav", + "text": "大家覺得租賃住宅的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/914.wav", + "text": "糾紛事實上目前已經有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/915.wav", + "text": "還有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/916.wav", + "text": "調處已經有多元" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/917.wav", + "text": "事實上也滿重的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/918.wav", + "text": "並沒有實益" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/919.wav", + "text": "400多件其實" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/920.wav", + "text": "以上這幾種機制都能" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/921.wav", + "text": "這個部分不需要再去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/922.wav", + "text": "增訂把它變成為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/923.wav", + "text": "謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/924.wav", + "text": "你們的意思就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/925.wav", + "text": "(二)的這幾條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/926.wav", + "text": "條文就先不修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/927.wav", + "text": "也不增訂" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/928.wav", + "text": "問各位委員有沒有意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/929.wav", + "text": "有時候可以一步一步" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/930.wav", + "text": "來下一次也可以再修" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/931.wav", + "text": "在第十六條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/932.wav", + "text": "會提出這樣的修訂是因為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/933.wav", + "text": "看到我們原來條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/934.wav", + "text": "等於是零" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/935.wav", + "text": "沒有人會去用這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/936.wav", + "text": "所謂的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/937.wav", + "text": "調處" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/938.wav", + "text": "裡面沒有人會採用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/939.wav", + "text": "這一條所以我們覺得這一" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/940.wav", + "text": "多元我也是主張要有多元" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/941.wav", + "text": "機制所以文字如果能" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/942.wav", + "text": "修正的話應該把剛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/943.wav", + "text": "剛內政部提到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/944.wav", + "text": "的我們現在是用消費者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/945.wav", + "text": "保護法的消費爭議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/946.wav", + "text": "調解也有不動產的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/947.wav", + "text": "紛爭調處有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/948.wav", + "text": "鄉鎮市區調解委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/949.wav", + "text": "的調解及法院的調解" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/950.wav", + "text": "當然法院調解不需要在這邊寫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/951.wav", + "text": "啦那個回到司法的程序" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/952.wav", + "text": "提的比較是鄉市區" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/953.wav", + "text": "的調解可以放進來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/954.wav", + "text": "如果你們不動我沒" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/955.wav", + "text": "意見因為主要的糾紛現在都回到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/956.wav", + "text": "沒有功能的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/957.wav", + "text": "條文因為現在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/958.wav", + "text": "執行的情況是掛零的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/959.wav", + "text": "所以我是覺得這條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/960.wav", + "text": "400多件只有三件" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/961.wav", + "text": "這個部分就先" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/962.wav", + "text": "各位有沒有意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/963.wav", + "text": "因為剛剛談到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/964.wav", + "text": "第十六條不修嘛我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/965.wav", + "text": "有一個附帶決議也有給主席" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/966.wav", + "text": "一份了就是加強" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/967.wav", + "text": "附帶決議等一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/968.wav", + "text": "我們先把條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/969.wav", + "text": "第38條之2你們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/970.wav", + "text": "再考量一下是不是要把剛才那個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/971.wav", + "text": "第38條之2你們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/972.wav", + "text": "現在就處理(五)" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/973.wav", + "text": "是不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/974.wav", + "text": "有啊一開始就處理了啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/975.wav", + "text": "一開始的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/976.wav", + "text": "沒關係" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/977.wav", + "text": "他們會再整理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/978.wav", + "text": "關(五)的部分是委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/979.wav", + "text": "租賃租金支出" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/980.wav", + "text": "改列特別扣除額" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/981.wav", + "text": "並提高額度至30萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/982.wav", + "text": "元這是增訂第十七條之1" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/983.wav", + "text": "這個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/984.wav", + "text": "時財政部也有一些意見這個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/985.wav", + "text": "我們尊重財政部的意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/986.wav", + "text": "是不是請財政部來做一些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/987.wav", + "text": "回應" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/988.wav", + "text": "所得稅法第十七條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/989.wav", + "text": "各項扣除額的提案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/990.wav", + "text": "目前非常多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/991.wav", + "text": "大概有44案53項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/992.wav", + "text": "其中房租" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/993.wav", + "text": "列扣的提案有1案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/994.wav", + "text": "房租特別扣除額" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/995.wav", + "text": "的提案有6案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/996.wav", + "text": "在這邊不處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/997.wav", + "text": "那邊再綜合考量" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/998.wav", + "text": "謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/999.wav", + "text": "張委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/1000.wav", + "text": "謝謝主席對於這一點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/1001.wav", + "text": "坦白說這個在財委會那邊已經談" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/1002.wav", + "text": "我們就尊重現在內委會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/1003.wav", + "text": "增訂第十七條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/1004.wav", + "text": "之1就不予增訂" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/1005.wav", + "text": "\n這樣的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/1006.wav", + "text": "我們都處理好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/1007.wav", + "text": "然後再做條次的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/1008.wav", + "text": "不好意思" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/1009.wav", + "text": "第46條是最後一條沒錯" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/1010.wav", + "text": "可是剛剛行政部門" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/1011.wav", + "text": "有提出第36條之1" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/1012.wav", + "text": "就是罰則的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/1013.wav", + "text": "我們可以讓你塞到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/1014.wav", + "text": "第38條之1但是內容" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/1015.wav", + "text": "應約定與不得約定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/1016.wav", + "text": "的處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/1017.wav", + "text": "嘛我們是要他改正然後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/1018.wav", + "text": "罰3萬元到30萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/1019.wav", + "text": "元這對個別房東的部分會不會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/1020.wav", + "text": "罰得太重我知道這個好像是仿照消保" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/1021.wav", + "text": "這個都是從消保法搬過來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/1022.wav", + "text": "所以形式上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/1023.wav", + "text": "是業者嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/1024.wav", + "text": "是業者包租是業者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/1025.wav", + "text": "因為應約定以後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/1026.wav", + "text": "應約定及不得約定只剩下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/1027.wav", + "text": "而已這裡沒有個人房東" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/1028.wav", + "text": "個人房東沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/1029.wav", + "text": "金額也不低" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/1030.wav", + "text": "修法版本的金額是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/1031.wav", + "text": "一樣的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/1032.wav", + "text": "那個之前的都" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/1033.wav", + "text": "一樣的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/1034.wav", + "text": "因為現在已經" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/1035.wav", + "text": "不分了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/1036.wav", + "text": "消保法去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/1037.wav", + "text": "又要去界定什麼叫小房東" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/1038.wav", + "text": "什麼叫一宅的房東" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/1039.wav", + "text": "這個就很難去界定了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/1040.wav", + "text": "所以就一體適用消保法的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/1041.wav", + "text": "對啦那個沒有辦法再去分了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/1042.wav", + "text": "現在只剩下包租業者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/1043.wav", + "text": "應約定及不得約定事項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/1044.wav", + "text": "這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/1045.wav", + "text": "我們先請" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/1046.wav", + "text": "內政部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/1047.wav", + "text": "去整理條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/1048.wav", + "text": "大原則我們都" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/1049.wav", + "text": "整理條文完了之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/1050.wav", + "text": "先給各黨團看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/1051.wav", + "text": "各黨團如果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/1052.wav", + "text": "沒有意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/1053.wav", + "text": "有點困難" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/1054.wav", + "text": "上次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/1055.wav", + "text": "請大家再看一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/1056.wav", + "text": "尤其請內政部再看一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/1057.wav", + "text": "還有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/1058.wav", + "text": "內政委員會審查時" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/1059.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/1060.wav", + "text": "在委員會審查的時候有3項附帶決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/1061.wav", + "text": "也請看一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/1062.wav", + "text": "對於附帶決議如果有不同意的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/1063.wav", + "text": "我們就先不通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/1064.wav", + "text": "到時候要提反正到時候要提還是可以提反" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/1065.wav", + "text": "最後就是送" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/1066.wav", + "text": "內政委員會審查本案所保留之3項附帶決議均不通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/1067.wav", + "text": "日民眾黨所提之附帶決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/1068.wav", + "text": "王委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/1069.wav", + "text": "應該是保留啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/1070.wav", + "text": "好是這樣的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/1071.wav", + "text": "因為保留的話就還要再朝野協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/1072.wav", + "text": "本來就要啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/1073.wav", + "text": "送院長協商啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/1074.wav", + "text": "你們還要送院協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/1075.wav", + "text": "要不然就現在討論啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/1076.wav", + "text": "現在不討論直接不" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/1077.wav", + "text": "處理然後又不能" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/1078.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/1079.wav", + "text": "那就全部保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/1080.wav", + "text": "3項附帶決議就保留對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/1081.wav", + "text": "那個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/1082.wav", + "text": "內政委員會審查時" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/1083.wav", + "text": "保留之附帶決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/1084.wav", + "text": "送協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/1085.wav", + "text": "今天所提的附帶決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/1086.wav", + "text": "有關今天的協商結論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/1087.wav", + "text": "我來唸一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/1088.wav", + "text": "這是內政委員會整理的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/1089.wav", + "text": "確認一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/1090.wav", + "text": "協商結論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/1091.wav", + "text": "一" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/1092.wav", + "text": "協商通過條文第5條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/1093.wav", + "text": "第34條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/1094.wav", + "text": "增訂第38條之1" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/1095.wav", + "text": "增訂第38條之2" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/1096.wav", + "text": "第46條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/1097.wav", + "text": "張其祿等6" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/1098.wav", + "text": "）二" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/1099.wav", + "text": "不予修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/1100.wav", + "text": "維持現行條文章" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/1101.wav", + "text": "第十六條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/1102.wav", + "text": "第四章章名" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/1103.wav", + "text": "第三" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/1104.wav", + "text": "十八條\n三" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/1105.wav", + "text": "第十三條之1" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/1106.wav", + "text": "第十六條之一" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/1107.wav", + "text": "至第十六條���六" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/1108.wav", + "text": "第十七條之一" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/1109.wav", + "text": "第三十五條之一" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/1110.wav", + "text": "第三十九條之一" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/1111.wav", + "text": "四通過附帶決議1項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/1112.wav", + "text": "其餘均照審查會審查結果通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/1113.wav", + "text": "條號及條文中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/1114.wav", + "text": "引述之條號授權議事人員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/1115.wav", + "text": "請王委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/1116.wav", + "text": "協商結論是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/1117.wav", + "text": "那我不要簽協商結論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/1118.wav", + "text": "剛剛不是說第38條之1還要再修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/1119.wav", + "text": "你們還要再回去思考嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/1120.wav", + "text": "剛剛那個不是協商結論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/1121.wav", + "text": "剛剛那個變成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/1122.wav", + "text": "是那二條的修正案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/1123.wav", + "text": "是那幾個條文的修正案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/1124.wav", + "text": "跟簽不簽協商結論無關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/1125.wav", + "text": "主席現在才在唸協商結論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/1126.wav", + "text": "他唸完了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/1127.wav", + "text": "你現在是希望協商結論要保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/1128.wav", + "text": "剛剛通過了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/1129.wav", + "text": "他們想保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/1130.wav", + "text": "現在主席宣布通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/1131.wav", + "text": "內政部不是說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/1132.wav", + "text": "要回去思考一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/1133.wav", + "text": "我們建議的方式嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/1134.wav", + "text": "那麼應該是保留送協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/1135.wav", + "text": "怎麼會是通過之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/1136.wav", + "text": "如果有意見再提修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/1137.wav", + "text": "這個部分大家都簽名了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/1138.wav", + "text": "你也簽名了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/1139.wav", + "text": "反正還要送院協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/1140.wav", + "text": "每一條都還可以再討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/1141.wav", + "text": "因為還要送院協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/1142.wav", + "text": "今天大家說還要送院協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/1143.wav", + "text": "今天的結論是不需要送院協商的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/1144.wav", + "text": "當然今天就沒有辦法做決定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/1145.wav", + "text": "所以還有機會談的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/1146.wav", + "text": "包括" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/1147.wav", + "text": "在委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/1148.wav", + "text": "如果不送協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/1149.wav", + "text": "今天就要處理附帶決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/1150.wav", + "text": "今天不處理附帶決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/1151.wav", + "text": "就是要送協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/1152.wav", + "text": "我們就照剛才所宣讀的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/1153.wav", + "text": "大家的意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/1154.wav", + "text": "是還要再送院協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/1155.wav", + "text": "嘛所以本案就送院協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/1156.wav", + "text": "就不要再送院協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/1157.wav", + "text": "因為下次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/1158.wav", + "text": "我們的臨時會都是處理預算案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/1159.wav", + "text": "這個會期沒有通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/1160.wav", + "text": "就是明年的56月啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/1161.wav", + "text": "我是說能夠先解決" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/1162.wav", + "text": "附帶決議有什麼問題就好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/1163.wav", + "text": "我同意啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/1164.wav", + "text": "是我們就先來討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/1165.wav", + "text": "而不是不討論直接否決啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/1166.wav", + "text": "要說明否決的理由吧" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/1167.wav", + "text": "不是說不通過就結束啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/1168.wav", + "text": "如果今天不要送院長協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/1169.wav", + "text": "就應該照程序" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/1170.wav", + "text": "把這個部分處理掉啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/1171.wav", + "text": "我來釐清一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/1172.wav", + "text": "內政委員會也聽一下看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/1173.wav", + "text": "我講的對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/1174.wav", + "text": "附帶決議就算我們在這邊沒有通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/1175.wav", + "text": "院會二三讀的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/1176.wav", + "text": "是不是也是可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/1177.wav", + "text": "一樣可以送啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/1178.wav", + "text": "還是可以送" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/1179.wav", + "text": "各黨團還是可以送" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/1180.wav", + "text": "各黨團還是可以再送附帶決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/1181.wav", + "text": "在院會的時候再討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/1182.wav", + "text": "看大家要不要通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/1183.wav", + "text": "所以還是有機會再送附帶決議的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/1184.wav", + "text": "不是今天沒有通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/1185.wav", + "text": "不是啦我的意思是說附帶決議要被不通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/1186.wav", + "text": "也應該要說明理由吧" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/1187.wav", + "text": "就是要說明理由" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/1188.wav", + "text": "怎麼會是直接不通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/1189.wav", + "text": "如果部會有困難或是理由合理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/1190.wav", + "text": "我們也可以接受不通過啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/1191.wav", + "text": "就直接不通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/1192.wav", + "text": "然後說以後如果要提就自己再去提" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/1193.wav", + "text": "因為在二三讀的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/1194.wav", + "text": "就不會有討論的機會了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/1195.wav", + "text": "了還是不知道困難度在哪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/1196.wav", + "text": "事實上在委員會的時候有談啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/1197.wav", + "text": "委員會的時候其實有談" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/1198.wav", + "text": "有啊附帶決議當初" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/1199.wav", + "text": "在委員會的時候當然有談啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/1200.wav", + "text": "有談了才保留的啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/1201.wav", + "text": "\n請吳委" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/1202.wav", + "text": "如果可以的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/1203.wav", + "text": "我們今天如果能夠有共識" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/1204.wav", + "text": "就不需要再送院長協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/1205.wav", + "text": "所以剛剛王委員也是希望說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/1206.wav", + "text": "有一些疑慮我們也在沉澱" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/1207.wav", + "text": "因為怎麼樣讓文字或是想法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/1208.wav", + "text": "要不要在這一次一步到位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/1209.wav", + "text": "還是就回到消保法的適用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/1210.wav", + "text": "雖然對小房東是有點嚴苛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/1211.wav", + "text": "所以目前好像可以先這樣做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/1212.wav", + "text": "內政部要說明能不能做到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/1213.wav", + "text": "如果是已經入法了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/1214.wav", + "text": "當然就可以不用再列" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/1215.wav", + "text": "如果做不到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/1216.wav", + "text": "或是文字可以修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/1217.wav", + "text": "或是怎麼修正到你們可以做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/1218.wav", + "text": "我覺得這是部裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/1219.wav", + "text": "也可以再去做調整的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/1220.wav", + "text": "不能說完全做不到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/1221.wav", + "text": "做不到的原因在哪裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/1222.wav", + "text": "也要說明一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/1223.wav", + "text": "這個我百分之百尊重財政部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/1224.wav", + "text": "我們真的完全沒有介入的空間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/1225.wav", + "text": "還要我們來做書面報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/1226.wav", + "text": "我們最後提出的一樣是很虛的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/1227.wav", + "text": "要不要建立平臺網站" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/1228.wav", + "text": "包租代管" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/1229.wav", + "text": "轉租的相關資訊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/1230.wav", + "text": "這個已經入法了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/1231.wav", + "text": "嘛這本來就做得到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/1232.wav", + "text": "以我覺得這部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/1233.wav", + "text": "能不能用我們現在修法的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/1234.wav", + "text": "去替代就好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/1235.wav", + "text": "\n第三個附帶" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/1236.wav", + "text": "帶決議其實就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/1237.wav", + "text": "租屋實價登錄" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/1238.wav", + "text": "第三個部分主要是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/1239.wav", + "text": "針對這些經濟弱勢者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/1240.wav", + "text": "無力負擔高價房價者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/1241.wav", + "text": "包括社宅的資訊應該要更加透明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/1242.wav", + "text": "的部分第二個部分我同意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/1243.wav", + "text": "啦因為現在已經入法了我覺得沒有問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/1244.wav", + "text": "但第三個主要是針對弱勢者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/1245.wav", + "text": "的部分我們希望能夠含這些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/1246.wav", + "text": "社宅的相關狀況能夠提供一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/1247.wav", + "text": "比較清楚的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/1248.wav", + "text": "是去做個評估我們並不是說要直接" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/1249.wav", + "text": "對啦這個是要求建構網路平臺" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/1250.wav", + "text": "又特別是針對他們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/1251.wav", + "text": "我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/1252.wav", + "text": "主管機關研議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/1253.wav", + "text": "研議資訊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/1254.wav", + "text": "研議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/1255.wav", + "text": "就是研議分析與公開" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/1256.wav", + "text": "資料包含" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/1257.wav", + "text": "這些吧" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/1258.wav", + "text": "好請宣讀一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/1259.wav", + "text": "第三個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/1260.wav", + "text": "決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/1261.wav", + "text": "需求爰要求中央" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/1262.wav", + "text": "主管機關研議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/1263.wav", + "text": "分析" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/1264.wav", + "text": "定期包租" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/1265.wav", + "text": "代管社會住宅" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/1266.wav", + "text": "租金補貼之相關資訊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/1267.wav", + "text": "包含但不限" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/1268.wav", + "text": "於承租人身分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/1269.wav", + "text": "性別居住" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/1270.wav", + "text": "縣市" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/1271.wav", + "text": "租屋面積租屋房型" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/1272.wav", + "text": "並以一般身分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/1273.wav", + "text": "及各款弱勢身分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/1274.wav", + "text": "分類以落實" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/1275.wav", + "text": "租屋市場公開" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/1276.wav", + "text": "與透明化" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/1277.wav", + "text": "請於三個月內提交" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/1278.wav", + "text": "上開書面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/1279.wav", + "text": "報告至立法院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/1280.wav", + "text": "這邊還有一個附帶決議是民眾黨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/1281.wav", + "text": "附件1的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/1282.wav", + "text": "不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/1283.wav", + "text": "不是那個是我們今天提的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/1284.wav", + "text": "就是剛才講不通過的其中一案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/1285.wav", + "text": "案我們就撤掉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/1286.wav", + "text": "內政委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/1287.wav", + "text": "附帶決議第1案就撤" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/1288.wav", + "text": "第2案不通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/1289.wav", + "text": "\n這樣就不用送" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/1290.wav", + "text": "我們剛剛有協調" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/1291.wav", + "text": "38條之1我們也沒有堅持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/1292.wav", + "text": "就先回到消保法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/1293.wav", + "text": "文字修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/1294.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/1295.wav", + "text": "我們就照這樣來處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14697/1296.wav", + "text": "謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14696/0.wav", + "text": "內政部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14696/1.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14696/2.wav", + "text": "考量謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14696/3.wav", + "text": "請張委員其祿發言" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14696/4.wav", + "text": "謝謝主席" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14696/5.wav", + "text": "財委會那邊已經談很" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14696/6.wav", + "text": "你塞到第38條之1" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14696/7.wav", + "text": "如果沒有意見好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14696/8.wav", + "text": "\n請問各位對附帶決議有沒有意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14696/9.wav", + "text": "那這個如果這樣的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14696/10.wav", + "text": "公開啦就是資" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14696/11.wav", + "text": "有沒有啦他" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14696/12.wav", + "text": "爰要求中央主管機關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14696/13.wav", + "text": "可以喔" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/0.wav", + "text": "繼續研商公務人員個人專戶制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1.wav", + "text": "退休資遣撫卹法草案等5案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/2.wav", + "text": "相關事宜首先" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/3.wav", + "text": "首考試院秘書長劉建忻先生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/4.wav", + "text": "銓敘部部長周志宏先生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/5.wav", + "text": "教育部部長潘文忠先生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/6.wav", + "text": "行政院人事行政總處副人事長懷敘先生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/7.wav", + "text": "我們又走了一趟現在還是從頭再來針對保留條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/8.wav", + "text": "員也可以適用因為新制要從明年7月1日才適用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/9.wav", + "text": "假設影響不是太大" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/10.wav", + "text": "那我們建議保留給目前已經在任的公務員有一個選擇的權利" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/11.wav", + "text": "譬如3年內5年內等等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/12.wav", + "text": "這個事情從委員會討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/13.wav", + "text": "時委員會就一直很堅持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/14.wav", + "text": "上次協商時也很堅持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/15.wav", + "text": "我的意思是行政部門有沒有做過精確評估" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/16.wav", + "text": "假設某個程度開放給現職人員讓他們有選擇權利" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/17.wav", + "text": "財務的影響會有多大" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/18.wav", + "text": "請你們具體說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/19.wav", + "text": "好請針對曾總召的意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/20.wav", + "text": "根據我們精算的結果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/21.wav", + "text": "如果不開放現職人員選擇新制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/22.wav", + "text": "用罄年限會提早到135年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/23.wav", + "text": "如果要維持到140年用罄的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/24.wav", + "text": "撥補金額大概是1,940億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/25.wav", + "text": "然後可以分10年撥補" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/26.wav", + "text": "但如果開放年資3年以下適用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/27.wav", + "text": "不管是三分之一二分之一" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/28.wav", + "text": "還是全數人員都會增加支出" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/29.wav", + "text": "如果是三分之一大概是2,050億增加110億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/30.wav", + "text": "二分之一大概會是2,110億增加170億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/31.wav", + "text": "如果全數人員都轉的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/32.wav", + "text": "大概會到2,280億增加340億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/33.wav", + "text": "如果是開放年資5年以下若" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/34.wav", + "text": "會到2,220億增加280億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/35.wav", + "text": "會到2,380億增加440億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/36.wav", + "text": "如果年資5年以下全數現職人員轉換" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/37.wav", + "text": "會到2,790億增加850億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/38.wav", + "text": "這只是公務人員的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/39.wav", + "text": "而公立學校教職員部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/40.wav", + "text": "的也是有相當的金額" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/41.wav", + "text": "因為這樣會擴大政府" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/42.wav", + "text": "而且會影響現在退撫基金的財務" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/43.wav", + "text": "所以建議還是維持考試院的版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/44.wav", + "text": "有沒有意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/45.wav", + "text": "請林奕華委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/46.wav", + "text": "因為這條條文牽涉到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/47.wav", + "text": "我們現在在談的舊制部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/48.wav", + "text": "即比較年輕的公教警消人員的權益" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/49.wav", + "text": "部分因為新制影響" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/50.wav", + "text": "也只撥補那幾年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/51.wav", + "text": "但是問題在於" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/52.wav", + "text": "在於只撥補那幾年的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/53.wav", + "text": "公務人員部分等於是140年還是會破產" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/54.wav", + "text": "然後教育人員在139年還是會破產" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/55.wav", + "text": "對於這些年輕的公教警消來說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/56.wav", + "text": "變成未來他們覺得前途不確定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/57.wav", + "text": "最後他們領不領得到退休金" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/58.wav", + "text": "但最終支付責任是支付多少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/59.wav", + "text": "這都有可能" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/60.wav", + "text": "所以變成是讓這些年輕的公教人員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/61.wav", + "text": "對未來有不確定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/62.wav", + "text": "如果對舊制他們不確定領得到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/63.wav", + "text": "我們就不能剝奪人家去選擇新制的權利" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/64.wav", + "text": "所以我還是覺得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/65.wav", + "text": "若是對舊制有這樣的一個疑慮" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/66.wav", + "text": "而不讓他們去選擇新制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/67.wav", + "text": "應該讓公教人員能夠有這樣的選擇權" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/68.wav", + "text": "對他們來說是比較公平的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/69.wav", + "text": "然後再黃世杰委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/70.wav", + "text": "謝謝主席" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/71.wav", + "text": "簡單講跟奕華委員剛剛講得一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/72.wav", + "text": "老實說第3條要討論的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/73.wav", + "text": "我們要先討論的是第93條第98條要怎麼處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/74.wav", + "text": "假設第93條第98條你願意將" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/75.wav", + "text": "將按年提撥入法的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/76.wav", + "text": "至少留在舊制的人比較有信心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/77.wav", + "text": "覺得說OK" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/78.wav", + "text": "啦我們不是在這裡被當肥羊而已" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/79.wav", + "text": "一年一年的扒皮" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/80.wav", + "text": "最後到了我退休的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/81.wav", + "text": "到底能領到什麼都不知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/82.wav", + "text": "還不准我走" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/83.wav", + "text": "只是要我繼續在這裡付錢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/84.wav", + "text": "然後最終得到的是什麼都不知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/85.wav", + "text": "談第3條之前我們要先知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/86.wav", + "text": "個人專戶的第93條第98" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/87.wav", + "text": "條到底要怎麼處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/88.wav", + "text": "謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/89.wav", + "text": "請黃世杰委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/90.wav", + "text": "我想這個題目大概從委員會逐條審查的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/91.wav", + "text": "一路到現在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/92.wav", + "text": "啦那時候我的主張即" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/93.wav", + "text": "我提出來的建議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/94.wav", + "text": "與剛剛兩位委員講的也是類似" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/95.wav", + "text": "的因為開放選擇權" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/96.wav", + "text": "是直接衝擊到舊制的財務結構" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/97.wav", + "text": "那時候我才會堅持要求銓" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/98.wav", + "text": "要做試算的資料出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/99.wav", + "text": "就是剛才他們唸的那些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/100.wav", + "text": "現在舊制的這些人員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/101.wav", + "text": "今年是最後一批進來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/102.wav", + "text": "從明年的7月1號開始就都是新制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/103.wav", + "text": "如果我們要關這個門的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/104.wav", + "text": "撥補的義務上面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/105.wav", + "text": "能更明確的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/106.wav", + "text": "當時我其實就有提出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/107.wav", + "text": "就是我今天看到的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/108.wav", + "text": "林奕華委員所提" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/109.wav", + "text": "93條及第98條的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/110.wav", + "text": "更為具體的政府撥補義務的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/111.wav", + "text": "不要再去討論第3條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/112.wav", + "text": "所謂選擇權的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/113.wav", + "text": "既然都有比較具體的條文文字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/114.wav", + "text": "就讓考試院及教育部這邊來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/115.wav", + "text": "先請說明之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/116.wav", + "text": "我們再回來討論第3條的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/117.wav", + "text": "我覺得這樣會比較快" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/118.wav", + "text": "等一下再回頭" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/119.wav", + "text": "來處理\n處理第6條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/120.wav", + "text": "考試院提案條文通過\n請林" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/121.wav", + "text": "\n請林委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/122.wav", + "text": "的條文第6條規範的都屬於監理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/123.wav", + "text": "事項也就是監理會的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/124.wav", + "text": "在監理會當中不管是公務人員或老師" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/125.wav", + "text": "都希望能夠讓公務人員代表" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/126.wav", + "text": "或公務人員推薦的學者專家代表" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/127.wav", + "text": "老師的部分我本來就有提" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/128.wav", + "text": "案今天針對公務人員的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/129.wav", + "text": "要是針對監理的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/130.wav", + "text": "我認為機關代表和公務人員代表" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/131.wav", + "text": "是不能等同的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/132.wav", + "text": "因為機關代表所代表的是機關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/133.wav", + "text": "而公務人員代表才是代表公務人員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/134.wav", + "text": "其實老師的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/135.wav", + "text": "透過教師組織" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/136.wav", + "text": "推派相關的代表" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/137.wav", + "text": "以及他們所推薦的學者專家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/138.wav", + "text": "因為我們希望能夠發揮比較大的監理功能" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/139.wav", + "text": "所以我認為相關人數" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/140.wav", + "text": "不得少於總數的二分之一" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/141.wav", + "text": "我覺得這是一個應該要走的方向" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/142.wav", + "text": "拜託大家可以予以同意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/143.wav", + "text": "謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/144.wav", + "text": "其實在12月2日" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/145.wav", + "text": "周部長說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/146.wav", + "text": "銓敘部長並不是財經專業人士" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/147.wav", + "text": "所以未來要退出退撫基金管理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/148.wav", + "text": "我們都知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/149.wav", + "text": "銓敘部在規劃的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/150.wav", + "text": "保守型" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/151.wav", + "text": "穩健型" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/152.wav", + "text": "積極型" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/153.wav", + "text": "及人身週期型的投資選擇方案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/154.wav", + "text": "這是參考私校儲金" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/155.wav", + "text": "制度可是當我們拿私校儲金的組織設計" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/156.wav", + "text": "來修法時銓" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/157.wav", + "text": "銓敘部的意見又很多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/158.wav", + "text": "13日的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/159.wav", + "text": "周部長又說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/160.wav", + "text": "如果監理會的組織寫明統計" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/161.wav", + "text": "精算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/162.wav", + "text": "財經" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/163.wav", + "text": "法律" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/164.wav", + "text": "專業" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/165.wav", + "text": "以本席所提草案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/166.wav", + "text": "第6條來看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/167.wav", + "text": "用上述四種專業等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/168.wav", + "text": "四類人各一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/169.wav", + "text": "就算銓敘部另外再找其他的專業資格" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/170.wav", + "text": "也說得通" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/171.wav", + "text": "並沒有違法的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/172.wav", + "text": "本席實在不知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/173.wav", + "text": "有什麼窒礙難行之處" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/174.wav", + "text": "為什麼銓敘部一直不願意在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/175.wav", + "text": "監理會裡面寫上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/176.wav", + "text": "專業資格的種類" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/177.wav", + "text": "以上就是我的意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/178.wav", + "text": "謝謝院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/179.wav", + "text": "其實" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/180.wav", + "text": "有這方面的專業" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/181.wav", + "text": "機關代表" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/182.wav", + "text": "我自己的業務忙得要死" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/183.wav", + "text": "我去的話也是到現場才看資料" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/184.wav", + "text": "真的啊我在那邊當了五年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/185.wav", + "text": "\n我的意思是說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/186.wav", + "text": "假設有更多的財經專業" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/187.wav", + "text": "我覺得這並沒有什麼不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/188.wav", + "text": "而且大家的立場一致" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/189.wav", + "text": "都希望把監理做好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/190.wav", + "text": "這部分的範圍很廣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/191.wav", + "text": "包括精算統計財經法律" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/192.wav", + "text": "你們就不要為了這件事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/193.wav", + "text": "不然如果都是機關代表去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/194.wav", + "text": "到時候還是要考試院負責任" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/195.wav", + "text": "拘泥於這些文字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/196.wav", + "text": "對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/197.wav", + "text": "什麼不是財經" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/198.wav", + "text": "我的意思是說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/199.wav", + "text": "他並沒有寫得很細" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/200.wav", + "text": "謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/201.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/202.wav", + "text": "這個很明顯有不同意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/203.wav", + "text": "我剛才是說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/204.wav", + "text": "照考試院的意見通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/205.wav", + "text": "民眾黨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/206.wav", + "text": "我本來想就先暫時保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/207.wav", + "text": "的時候也談過具精算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/208.wav", + "text": "人事背景財經法律等等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/209.wav", + "text": "應該已經回答過這一段" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/210.wav", + "text": "林奕華委員提到代表人數" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/211.wav", + "text": "不得總數二分之一" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/212.wav", + "text": "這部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/213.wav", + "text": "分我相信大家都知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/214.wav", + "text": "監理會裡面很多機關代表" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/215.wav", + "text": "確實如曾總召講的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/216.wav", + "text": "自己的本業繁忙之外" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/217.wav", + "text": "是否真的達到監理之職" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/218.wav", + "text": "所以如果把機關代表部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/219.wav", + "text": "騰出來給公務人員代表" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/220.wav", + "text": "或公務人員推薦之代表" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/221.wav", + "text": "我覺得這個比較回歸到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/222.wav", + "text": "他願意擔負起監理的職責" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/223.wav", + "text": "如果他做得不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/224.wav", + "text": "經過一任兩任不再獲得推薦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/225.wav", + "text": "不至於機關代表一定要去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/226.wav", + "text": "去到那裡也沒辦法發揮作用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/227.wav", + "text": "所以我建議這個臨時的提案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/228.wav", + "text": "是不是大家可以多支持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/229.wav", + "text": "我有不同意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/230.wav", + "text": "現在你們這一排都是一樣意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/231.wav", + "text": "我有不同意見也要講一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/232.wav", + "text": "吧不然就保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/233.wav", + "text": "不行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/234.wav", + "text": "這是兩項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/235.wav", + "text": "上一次也講過很清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/236.wav", + "text": "那個有另外的子法在處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/237.wav", + "text": "在第2項你把機關代表都拿掉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/238.wav", + "text": "第2項沒有機關代表" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/239.wav", + "text": "機關代表全部沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/240.wav", + "text": "第1項有沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/241.wav", + "text": "有政府機關代表" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/242.wav", + "text": "你把這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/243.wav", + "text": "你要看第1項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/244.wav", + "text": "第1項有政府機關代表" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/245.wav", + "text": "你要看一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/246.wav", + "text": "你漏看了前面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/247.wav", + "text": "你沒有看到啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/248.wav", + "text": "你是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/249.wav", + "text": "第2項有改" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/250.wav", + "text": "第1項也有改" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/251.wav", + "text": "第1項就是列舉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/252.wav", + "text": "上次就談過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/253.wav", + "text": "你今天的版本才拿到桌子上來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/254.wav", + "text": "上次是用口頭講的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/255.wav", + "text": "這個版本在這裡大家看一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/256.wav", + "text": "中公務人員代表及公務人員推薦之學者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/257.wav", + "text": "要超過二分之一" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/258.wav", + "text": "這些人來主導一切" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/259.wav", + "text": "你自己當機關代表" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/260.wav", + "text": "你不負責是你的事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/261.wav", + "text": "不是所有的機關代表" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/262.wav", + "text": "不是你聽我說我" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/263.wav", + "text": "不是你剛剛講的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/264.wav", + "text": "這個到底是不是這樣的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/265.wav", + "text": "後機關代表" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/266.wav", + "text": "機關是屬於沒有主導權的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/267.wav", + "text": "因為公務人員代表" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/268.wav", + "text": "及他們推薦的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/269.wav", + "text": "這樣的主導性完全逆轉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/270.wav", + "text": "主導性逆轉的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/271.wav", + "text": "政府要負責的東西" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/272.wav", + "text": "這樣的設計對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/273.wav", + "text": "值得討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/274.wav", + "text": "是不是這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/275.wav", + "text": "我表達最後意見好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/276.wav", + "text": "好最後意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/277.wav", + "text": "我們有不同意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/278.wav", + "text": "我知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/279.wav", + "text": "也討論很久" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/280.wav", + "text": "了我建議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/281.wav", + "text": "請考試院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/282.wav", + "text": "融合大家的意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/283.wav", + "text": "弄一點文字出來看看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/284.wav", + "text": "我不知道它融合得出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/285.wav", + "text": "有沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/286.wav", + "text": "還是都不改" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/287.wav", + "text": "先保留吧" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/288.wav", + "text": "報告院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/289.wav", + "text": "我的看法是這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/290.wav", + "text": "因為真的沒剩幾條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/291.wav", + "text": "如果保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/292.wav", + "text": "我怕是不是就要表決" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/293.wav", + "text": "是全部要照你的意思才可以是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/294.wav", + "text": "我也有我的意思" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/295.wav", + "text": "你要照我的意思" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/296.wav", + "text": "其實我要講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/297.wav", + "text": "監理會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/298.wav", + "text": "不是管理委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/299.wav", + "text": "不然我們現在讓考試院您稍微" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/300.wav", + "text": "再讓我陳述一下好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/301.wav", + "text": "我就舉一個例子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/302.wav", + "text": "次長在投票的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/303.wav", + "text": "他代表的是機關的意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/304.wav", + "text": "機關的意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/305.wav", + "text": "有時候跟個人的意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/306.wav", + "text": "不一定一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/307.wav", + "text": "但因為這是監理會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/308.wav", + "text": "所以對公務人員來講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/309.wav", + "text": "對老師來講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/310.wav", + "text": "那個影響他們的權益甚大" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/311.wav", + "text": "所以我真的覺得在監理會的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/312.wav", + "text": "占一定比例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/313.wav", + "text": "不要少於二分之一" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/314.wav", + "text": "不要看到我們就" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/315.wav", + "text": "全部都排除" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/316.wav", + "text": "我真的覺得這是可以討論的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/317.wav", + "text": "我甚至也希望能聽一聽" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/318.wav", + "text": "行政部門的意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/319.wav", + "text": "搞不好他們也覺得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/320.wav", + "text": "這個東西是做得到的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/321.wav", + "text": "謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/322.wav", + "text": "他們兩位等一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/323.wav", + "text": "要發表高見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/324.wav", + "text": "見\n考試院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/325.wav", + "text": "你們的意見怎樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/326.wav", + "text": "說明一下監理會現在的運作" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/327.wav", + "text": "第一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/328.wav", + "text": "其實監理會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/329.wav", + "text": "也不太會用表決來處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/330.wav", + "text": "在實務運作上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/331.wav", + "text": "其實我覺得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/332.wav", + "text": "不需要那麼介意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/333.wav", + "text": "第二個我要說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/334.wav", + "text": "監理會裡的政府機關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/335.wav", + "text": "不是統統都是中央部會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/336.wav", + "text": "第二個我們還有五席" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/337.wav", + "text": "地方政府的代表" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/338.wav", + "text": "所以有直轄市跟縣市的代表" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/339.wav", + "text": "大家想像中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/340.wav", + "text": "好像政府��關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/341.wav", + "text": "最後就會團結" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/342.wav", + "text": "一模一樣的意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/343.wav", + "text": "其實也不會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/344.wav", + "text": "就會變成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/345.wav", + "text": "其實必要進來的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/346.wav", + "text": "中央加地方" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/347.wav", + "text": "機關代表數" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/348.wav", + "text": "已經相當多了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/349.wav", + "text": "如果再加" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/350.wav", + "text": "我們的專家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/351.wav", + "text": "現在也納進來成為委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/352.wav", + "text": "其實公教都有好幾位代表進來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/353.wav", + "text": "就是做意見監督" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/354.wav", + "text": "即看著資料" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/355.wav", + "text": "針對基金管理的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/356.wav", + "text": "績效來做詢問" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/357.wav", + "text": "第一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/358.wav", + "text": "我覺得二分之一" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/359.wav", + "text": "不會像各位想像中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/360.wav", + "text": "好像需要動到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/361.wav", + "text": "過半數的表決" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/362.wav", + "text": "那一個過半數的權力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/363.wav", + "text": "另外一部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/364.wav", + "text": "也是跟大家說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/365.wav", + "text": "機關代表並不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/366.wav", + "text": "統統都是中央派" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/367.wav", + "text": "還有地方派" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/368.wav", + "text": "再用二分之一去匡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/369.wav", + "text": "因為機關數已經夠多了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/370.wav", + "text": "再加上二分之一" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/371.wav", + "text": "沒有二分之一" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/372.wav", + "text": "但是也有專業的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/373.wav", + "text": "你們贊不贊成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/374.wav", + "text": "剛才因為有兩位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/375.wav", + "text": "黃世杰委員跟羅委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/376.wav", + "text": "就組成的成員有專業人員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/377.wav", + "text": "我們當然覺得這是可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/378.wav", + "text": "但是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/379.wav", + "text": "因為過去如果是用列舉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/380.wav", + "text": "可能就會變成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/381.wav", + "text": "會占掉很多名額" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/382.wav", + "text": "游委員提到的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/383.wav", + "text": "和現在林委員提到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/384.wav", + "text": "他是用或等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/385.wav", + "text": "如果是這樣的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/386.wav", + "text": "稍微有點彈性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/387.wav", + "text": "我們覺得OK" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/388.wav", + "text": "所以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/389.wav", + "text": "如果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/390.wav", + "text": "第1項讓我們有彈性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/391.wav", + "text": "第2項不要定二分之一" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/392.wav", + "text": "我們覺得是不是這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/393.wav", + "text": "折衷一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/394.wav", + "text": "比較能夠讓委員會運作" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/395.wav", + "text": "否則規定二分之一" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/396.wav", + "text": "其組成會非常困難" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/397.wav", + "text": "羅委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/398.wav", + "text": "我覺得要釐清一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/399.wav", + "text": "因為你對第1項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/400.wav", + "text": "模糊甚至矛盾" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/401.wav", + "text": "我舉個例子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/402.wav", + "text": "你在第1項提到具" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/403.wav", + "text": "具統計專業等等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/404.wav", + "text": "專家學者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/405.wav", + "text": "但它如何產生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/406.wav", + "text": "基本上是沒有提到的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/407.wav", + "text": "可是你在第2項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/408.wav", + "text": "提到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/409.wav", + "text": "公務員代表及" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/410.wav", + "text": "公務人員推薦之專家代表" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/411.wav", + "text": "意思就是說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/412.wav", + "text": "第1項裡的專家學" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/413.wav", + "text": "者就是公務人員推薦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/414.wav", + "text": "不是機關去遴聘的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/415.wav", + "text": "這樣就很奇怪啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/416.wav", + "text": "公務人員去推薦的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/417.wav", + "text": "到底專家學者是誰來遴聘" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/418.wav", + "text": "還是只能由公務人員推薦的代表" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/419.wav", + "text": "來扮演那個專家學者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/420.wav", + "text": "這個不釐清的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/421.wav", + "text": "這兩條之間是有很多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/422.wav", + "text": "扞格的地方" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/423.wav", + "text": "所以我們建議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/424.wav", + "text": "就是不採第2項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/425.wav", + "text": "但是可以採第1項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/426.wav", + "text": "是啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/427.wav", + "text": "讓專家多元" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/428.wav", + "text": "但是不要就卡住了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/429.wav", + "text": "因為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/430.wav", + "text": "有時候我們會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/431.wav", + "text": "依實際上的需要去聘" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/432.wav", + "text": "比如委員的提案裡面提到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/433.wav", + "text": "這個統計精算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/434.wav", + "text": "其實我們有關統計精算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/435.wav", + "text": "都是委外" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/436.wav", + "text": "還有doublecheck複核制度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/437.wav", + "text": "所以實際上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/438.wav", + "text": "監理會裡是不是要統計精算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/439.wav", + "text": "剛才曾總召有說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/440.wav", + "text": "請你們把文字再整理一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/441.wav", + "text": "我再釐清一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/442.wav", + "text": "現在考試院的立場是否就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/443.wav", + "text": "第1項可以考慮用或" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/444.wav", + "text": "對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/445.wav", + "text": "這樣可以接受嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/446.wav", + "text": "你要或的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/447.wav", + "text": "要或到什麼程度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/448.wav", + "text": "他這麼阿莎力或" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/449.wav", + "text": "可能只有一個啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/450.wav", + "text": "你放心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/451.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/452.wav", + "text": "柯總召建議保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/453.wav", + "text": "我可不可以請教一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/454.wav", + "text": "因為你剛剛提到的機關代表" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/455.wav", + "text": "讓我有點擔心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/456.wav", + "text": "通常中央是派怎樣的人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/457.wav", + "text": "地方政府是派怎樣的人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/458.wav", + "text": "現行情況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/459.wav", + "text": "業務上會相關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/460.wav", + "text": "我舉個例子好了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/461.wav", + "text": "臺北市派誰" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/462.wav", + "text": "看它派誰" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/463.wav", + "text": "通常是派誰" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/464.wav", + "text": "這其實就是很大的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/465.wav", + "text": "考試院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/466.wav", + "text": "因為這些人就要占掉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/467.wav", + "text": "很多的名額" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/468.wav", + "text": "利害關係人的代表" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/469.wav", + "text": "提高到二分之一的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/470.wav", + "text": "會變成整個組成太多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/471.wav", + "text": "我覺得聽了很恐怖" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/472.wav", + "text": "大部分是不具相關背景的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/473.wav", + "text": "他可能在聘請上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/474.wav", + "text": "會以部長為代表" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/475.wav", + "text": "可是真正來開會的人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/476.wav", + "text": "或首長都會請有專業的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/477.wav", + "text": "人員如主計或財政人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/478.wav", + "text": "我們公務機關裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/479.wav", + "text": "以市政府來講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/480.wav", + "text": "會有幾個人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/481.wav", + "text": "具有基金相關的專業" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/482.wav", + "text": "具有財經相關的專業" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/483.wav", + "text": "我跟你報告一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/484.wav", + "text": "因為我以前擔任過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/485.wav", + "text": "桃園市政府的出席" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/486.wav", + "text": "有兩個部分要考慮" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/487.wav", + "text": "第一個是interest的代表" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/488.wav", + "text": "這是我們公務員的錢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/489.wav", + "text": "第二個就是要有專業" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/490.wav", + "text": "所以過去調和的方式就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/491.wav", + "text": "每一個機關有它的代表" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/492.wav", + "text": "另外聘請學者專家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/493.wav", + "text": "是代表專業（professional" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/494.wav", + "text": "你認為利益團體的代表" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/495.wav", + "text": "就是這些公務員各機關的代表" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/496.wav", + "text": "他們沒有專業" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/497.wav", + "text": "所以你去challenge這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/498.wav", + "text": "全部進到這個監理會裡面來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/499.wav", + "text": "其實所謂的公務人員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/500.wav", + "text": "推薦專家代表" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/501.wav", + "text": "有個意圖是想要把兩種身分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/502.wav", + "text": "merge起來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/503.wav", + "text": "但是我知道自己的專業能力不夠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/504.wav", + "text": "所以我要找專家去替我做這件事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/505.wav", + "text": "所以等於他是被委任的人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/506.wav", + "text": "這是你的意思嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/507.wav", + "text": "對不對\n現在我們就要討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/508.wav", + "text": "在這個監理會裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/509.wav", + "text": "改成這樣的制度可不可行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/510.wav", + "text": "因為公務人員推薦專家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/511.wav", + "text": "由誰來推薦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/512.wav", + "text": "是所謂的團體來推薦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/513.wav", + "text": "還是由各機關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/514.wav", + "text": "現在是由各機關去代表這個interest" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/515.wav", + "text": "因為這個是公務員的退撫基金" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/516.wav", + "text": "所以各機關本身就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/517.wav", + "text": "各公務人員的組成單位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/518.wav", + "text": "所以由中央各部會輪流擔任代表" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/519.wav", + "text": "各地方政府也是輪流擔任代表" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/520.wav", + "text": "譬如這一年是臺北" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/521.wav", + "text": "然後會一直rotate" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/522.wav", + "text": "中央部會也是一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/523.wav", + "text": "不可能同時各部會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/524.wav", + "text": "2030個一起來開會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/525.wav", + "text": "地方政府二十幾個統統都來開會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/526.wav", + "text": "不會有這種情形" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/527.wav", + "text": "但是因為他們都是代表" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/528.wav", + "text": "所有公務人員的利益雖" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/529.wav", + "text": "雖然現在的制度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/530.wav", + "text": "沒有明文寫在法條裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/531.wav", + "text": "在舊制子法的訂定和運作就是這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/532.wav", + "text": "所以我們現在要討論的是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/533.wav", + "text": "如果要打破這兩種身分分開聘任" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/534.wav", + "text": "有兩種方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/535.wav", + "text": "一種是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/536.wav", + "text": "就讓各個輪值的這些部會或地方政府" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/537.wav", + "text": "也可以派專家來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/538.wav", + "text": "但這個專家就" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/539.wav", + "text": "就是你派誰來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/540.wav", + "text": "他就要代表你" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/541.wav", + "text": "然這個專家與政府之間的關係是什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/542.wav", + "text": "就會亂掉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/543.wav", + "text": "因為我們現在派來的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/544.wav", + "text": "代表人就是這一個機關的首長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/545.wav", + "text": "或縣長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/546.wav", + "text": "具體指派誰來代表他出席" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/547.wav", + "text": "這是兩回事" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/548.wav", + "text": "可是這個機關代表真正代表就是那個首長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/549.wav", + "text": "他派的這個代表可以不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/550.wav", + "text": "這個機關的公務員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/551.wav", + "text": "就算首長沒有時間來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/552.wav", + "text": "也一定會派機關裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/553.wav", + "text": "我認為對這個事情最專業的人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/554.wav", + "text": "所以他們剛剛才會回答為什麼要派財政主計" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/555.wav", + "text": "對於這件事情相對最清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/556.wav", + "text": "的他不會派工務局長來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/557.wav", + "text": "所以我的意思是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/558.wav", + "text": "也不是只有公務人員團體可以去找" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/559.wav", + "text": "你全部都要開放" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/560.wav", + "text": "誰是qualified的人可以進來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/561.wav", + "text": "這可能都要重新想" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/562.wav", + "text": "過因為我們過去從來沒有這樣做過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/563.wav", + "text": "我們現在如果很即興的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/564.wav", + "text": "我覺得還要再想一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/565.wav", + "text": "如果你是這個利益團體的代表" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/566.wav", + "text": "代表你本身的利益出席" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/567.wav", + "text": "這完全沒有任何疑義" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/568.wav", + "text": "我們多年來都是這樣做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/569.wav", + "text": "如果我們遴聘學者專家來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/570.wav", + "text": "也是沒有問題的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/571.wav", + "text": "但是你要把兩個身分結合在一起的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/572.wav", + "text": "如果我們已經開放" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/573.wav", + "text": "讓每一個利益團體的代表" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/574.wav", + "text": "全部都派學者專家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/575.wav", + "text": "我們還需要再聘請學者專家嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/576.wav", + "text": "所代表的監理方向到底是什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/577.wav", + "text": "因為我們要知道你所指派專家的想法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/578.wav", + "text": "跟你自己本身維護你自己的利益" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/579.wav", + "text": "以上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/580.wav", + "text": "是不是暫時保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/581.wav", + "text": "好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/582.wav", + "text": "因為現在有不同的意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/583.wav", + "text": "柯總召是建議保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/584.wav", + "text": "頂多就是第1項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/585.wav", + "text": "第2項就不要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/586.wav", + "text": "剛才他有講因" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/587.wav", + "text": "實務上會有困擾" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/588.wav", + "text": "利害關係人代表在推的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/589.wav", + "text": "我問一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/590.wav", + "text": "現行的情況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/591.wav", + "text": "利害關係人占比大概是多少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/592.wav", + "text": "我們剛講的是公務人員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/593.wav", + "text": "因為公務人員可以由市政府派人來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/594.wav", + "text": "如果是教師呢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/595.wav", + "text": "其利害關係人的比例是多少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/596.wav", + "text": "其實地方政府都是利害關係人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/597.wav", + "text": "它不是不是教師" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/598.wav", + "text": "以公務人員來講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/599.wav", + "text": "目前我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/600.wav", + "text": "其中4人是由協會推派" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/601.wav", + "text": "1人是銓敘部推派" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/602.wav", + "text": "軍職人員代表2人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/603.wav", + "text": "由國防部推派" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/604.wav", + "text": "教育人員代表3人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/605.wav", + "text": "1人是由全教會推派" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/606.wav", + "text": "1人是全教總推派" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/607.wav", + "text": "另外1人是教育部推派" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/608.wav", + "text": "目前的組成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/609.wav", + "text": "跟你講大團體都有了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/610.wav", + "text": "這樣比例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/611.wav", + "text": "因為中央部會就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/612.wav", + "text": "行政院及考試院的秘書長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/613.wav", + "text": "銓敘部國防部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/614.wav", + "text": "財政部教育部行政院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/615.wav", + "text": "主計總處跟人事總處" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/616.wav", + "text": "其他���該都是屬於" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/617.wav", + "text": "利害關係人代表" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/618.wav", + "text": "因為地方政府就是利害關係人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/619.wav", + "text": "對我們是19到23個人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/620.wav", + "text": "地方政府的5個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/621.wav", + "text": "人其實就是利害關係人代表" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/622.wav", + "text": "因為他們是代表" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/623.wav", + "text": "現在意見不一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/624.wav", + "text": "我們就暫時保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/625.wav", + "text": "大家可以再溝通看看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/626.wav", + "text": "第7條大家有什麼意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/627.wav", + "text": "第7條是有關管理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/628.wav", + "text": "啦對不起" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/629.wav", + "text": "就退撫基金的管理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/630.wav", + "text": "你們只負責提撥" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/631.wav", + "text": "對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/632.wav", + "text": "理其實我有跟銓敘部長討論過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/633.wav", + "text": "你們會有一個平臺" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/634.wav", + "text": "平臺上面本來也會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/635.wav", + "text": "會有不同基金的選擇" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/636.wav", + "text": "公教團體現在一直說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/637.wav", + "text": "他們希望比照私校" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/638.wav", + "text": "甚至由私校來管" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/639.wav", + "text": "我承認確實由私校來管" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/640.wav", + "text": "那個難度真的很高" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/641.wav", + "text": "利害關係人或什麼的會很糾結" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/642.wav", + "text": "但是技術上可行的是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/643.wav", + "text": "你可以在上面做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/644.wav", + "text": "複製四個表現" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/645.wav", + "text": "跟私校的基金表現" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/646.wav", + "text": "一模一樣的基金" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/647.wav", + "text": "這是可以做到的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/648.wav", + "text": "就像是我們的大盤指數" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/649.wav", + "text": "也有大盤指數基金" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/650.wav", + "text": "啊你是可以複製的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/651.wav", + "text": "這在投資上面是非常容易" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/652.wav", + "text": "的所以你們只要答應這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/653.wav", + "text": "我覺得這些公教人員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/654.wav", + "text": "就會安心一點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/655.wav", + "text": "至少他們有這個選擇" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/656.wav", + "text": "已經討論過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/657.wav", + "text": "了哪有政府在負責" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/658.wav", + "text": "卻比照私校" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/659.wav", + "text": "才用財團法人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/660.wav", + "text": "你們這些版本長得都一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/661.wav", + "text": "我知道啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/662.wav", + "text": "你現在��另外創造一個議題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/663.wav", + "text": "四個什麼指數" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/664.wav", + "text": "我跟你講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/665.wav", + "text": "第一個我們要先確定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/666.wav", + "text": "現在桌上的版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/667.wav", + "text": "朝野都有提" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/668.wav", + "text": "那是不可行的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/669.wav", + "text": "不可能政府" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/670.wav", + "text": "現在在負責改為財團法人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/671.wav", + "text": "所以我們針對版本先來談" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/672.wav", + "text": "你另外講的東西" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/673.wav", + "text": "要有文字化" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/674.wav", + "text": "我們不知道怎麼討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/675.wav", + "text": "請游委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/676.wav", + "text": "謝謝主席" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/677.wav", + "text": "了大家可能沒有機會看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/678.wav", + "text": "其中我只是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/679.wav", + "text": "要求一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/680.wav", + "text": "我是認為應該要有代表性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/681.wav", + "text": "就是也要有退休團體" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/682.wav", + "text": "第7條我們現在不是在看第" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/683.wav", + "text": "每一個人都長得一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/684.wav", + "text": "退休團體" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/685.wav", + "text": "你們現在都講給外面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/686.wav", + "text": "看電視的人在看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/687.wav", + "text": "拜託" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/688.wav", + "text": "我講穿了就是如此" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/689.wav", + "text": "對不起" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/690.wav", + "text": "也是主席指定我可以發言" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/691.wav", + "text": "麻煩總召" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/692.wav", + "text": "不要這樣子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/693.wav", + "text": "強凌弱眾暴寡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/694.wav", + "text": "本席實在不瞭解" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/695.wav", + "text": "教授擔任" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/696.wav", + "text": "大約一半的管理會委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/697.wav", + "text": "都是專家學者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/698.wav", + "text": "銓敘部說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/699.wav", + "text": "因為會有洩密的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/700.wav", + "text": "為什麼銓敘" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/701.wav", + "text": "銓敘部自行選任的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/702.wav", + "text": "沒有內線交易等操守的疑慮" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/703.wav", + "text": "由退休團體" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/704.wav", + "text": "就會有這樣的疑慮" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/705.wav", + "text": "在司法及法制委員會其實也質詢過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/706.wav", + "text": "跟國安基金執秘阮" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/707.wav", + "text": "那時候發現政府" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/708.wav", + "text": "雖然從來沒有依法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/709.wav", + "text": "借用過退撫基金來幫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/710.wav", + "text": "國安基金護盤" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/711.wav", + "text": "但卻不願意刪除" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/712.wav", + "text": "法律授權的條款" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/713.wav", + "text": "所以這是外界的疑慮" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/714.wav", + "text": "有很多退休" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/715.wav", + "text": "都很擔心自己的老本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/716.wav", + "text": "會被政府" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/717.wav", + "text": "拿去做政策護盤" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/718.wav", + "text": "所以本席的提案版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/719.wav", + "text": "規定管理會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/720.wav", + "text": "退休團體的成員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/721.wav", + "text": "參加" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/722.wav", + "text": "最好是有三分之二" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/723.wav", + "text": "當然有人說新制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/724.wav", + "text": "新制的退撫基金管理會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/725.wav", + "text": "既然是政府的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/726.wav", + "text": "它不是私人投資" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/727.wav", + "text": "但是既然銓敘部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/728.wav", + "text": "已經初步決定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/729.wav", + "text": "銓敘部長會退出" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/730.wav", + "text": "就應該貫徹政府退出" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/731.wav", + "text": "管理的方向" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/732.wav", + "text": "在現在的這17名" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/733.wav", + "text": "管理委員會委員裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/734.wav", + "text": "外部專家學者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/735.wav", + "text": "占了8個接近過半" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/736.wav", + "text": "如果政府覺得三分之二太多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/737.wav", + "text": "也可以提出" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/738.wav", + "text": "你們可以接受的比例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/739.wav", + "text": "但是本席認為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/740.wav", + "text": "謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/741.wav", + "text": "第7條是管理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/742.wav", + "text": "這兩個有點不一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/743.wav", + "text": "要負的責任就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/744.wav", + "text": "如果我沒記錯的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/745.wav", + "text": "方向就是要成立類似" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/746.wav", + "text": "勞動部的基金管理局" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/747.wav", + "text": "是一樣的方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/748.wav", + "text": "也就是說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/749.wav", + "text": "基金的成敗" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/750.wav", + "text": "由政府組織行政機關來管理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/751.wav", + "text": "當然要受監理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/752.wav", + "text": "就是由政府來承擔" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/753.wav", + "text": "但是如果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/754.wav", + "text": "要依照大家現在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/755.wav", + "text": "提議的方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/756.wav", + "text": "去改變它的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/757.wav", + "text": "管理組織變成是由利害" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/758.wav", + "text": "關係人的團體" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/759.wav", + "text": "未來這個基金的成敗" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/760.wav", + "text": "是不是就是自行負擔" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/761.wav", + "text": "綁在一起的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/762.wav", + "text": "你要拿到這個管理的權力的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/763.wav", + "text": "可是監理是監督嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/764.wav", + "text": "管理不是喔管理就是操盤" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/765.wav", + "text": "你要多數的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/766.wav", + "text": "三分之二的學者專家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/767.wav", + "text": "每一個人的意見都不一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/768.wav", + "text": "這個疑問必須被解答" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/769.wav", + "text": "這樣的制度設計" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/770.wav", + "text": "最後誰來承擔管理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/771.wav", + "text": "因此前面如何形成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/772.wav", + "text": "管理委員會的機制就很重要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/773.wav", + "text": "員變成錢丟回去讓他們自己管" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/774.wav", + "text": "不是政府替他們管" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/775.wav", + "text": "他們自己管的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/776.wav", + "text": "這些群體如何形成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/777.wav", + "text": "並承擔責任的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/778.wav", + "text": "我覺得需要相當完整的說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/779.wav", + "text": "不是只在意管理機關的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/780.wav", + "text": "請羅委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/781.wav", + "text": "我也是呼應剛剛黃世杰委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/782.wav", + "text": "提的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/783.wav", + "text": "權跟責一定是相符的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/784.wav", + "text": "而造成虧損的連帶責任" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/785.wav", + "text": "目前其他委員所提的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/786.wav", + "text": "另外成立單獨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/787.wav", + "text": "的公務人員代表還有外面的學者專家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/788.wav", + "text": "加進去管理萬一" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/789.wav", + "text": "有虧損的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/790.wav", + "text": "誰負這個責任" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/791.wav", + "text": "政府可以兩手一攤" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/792.wav", + "text": "啊又不是它做的決定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/793.wav", + "text": "所造成的投資損失" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/794.wav", + "text": "政府及其他人民不用負這個責任" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/795.wav", + "text": "對不對第二個這邊還有一個問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/796.wav", + "text": "就是你們的設計上有很多所謂的任期制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/797.wav", + "text": "時間到人就走了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/798.wav", + "text": "最後倒掉的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/799.wav", + "text": "不在他的任期內就好了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/800.wav", + "text": "就能確保這個投資不會出問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/801.wav", + "text": "更不要說我們還有一個監理單位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/802.wav", + "text": "所以我覺得責任還是由" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/803.wav", + "text": "否則這些專家學者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/804.wav", + "text": "不用到立法院備詢不用被我們監督" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/805.wav", + "text": "他們是獨立的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/806.wav", + "text": "所以我覺得一旦權責混淆掉之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/807.wav", + "text": "政府的連帶責任就不見了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/808.wav", + "text": "反而會對公務員的保障出問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/809.wav", + "text": "而且" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/810.wav", + "text": "你看游毓蘭委員這個設計" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/811.wav", + "text": "的第3項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/812.wav", + "text": "還要委託給私校" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/813.wav", + "text": "哪有政府可以委託給私校管理委員會去管理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/814.wav", + "text": "呢這有高度的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/815.wav", + "text": "道德風險" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/816.wav", + "text": "院長各黨團幹部以及" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/817.wav", + "text": "所有與會同仁" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/818.wav", + "text": "退撫條例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/819.wav", + "text": "最主要就是要保障公教" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/820.wav", + "text": "跟公職" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/821.wav", + "text": "未來退休之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/822.wav", + "text": "我相信在座各位大部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/823.wav", + "text": "都是公務人員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/824.wav", + "text": "及公教人員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/825.wav", + "text": "我們每一位委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/826.wav", + "text": "而是為了各位的退休金" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/827.wav", + "text": "我相信所有團體" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/828.wav", + "text": "是說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/829.wav", + "text": "過去由退撫基金" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/830.wav", + "text": "代操的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/831.wav", + "text": "他們認定世界上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/832.wav", + "text": "所有國際PensionFund" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/833.wav", + "text": "是不是可以就這個方面說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/834.wav", + "text": "制度設定上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/835.wav", + "text": "經營績效" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/836.wav", + "text": "這些退休基金" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/837.wav", + "text": "所有團體" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/838.wav", + "text": "是這個退休金" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/839.wav", + "text": "上網更新" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/840.wav", + "text": "你們可以做到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/841.wav", + "text": "的最大程度是怎麼樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/842.wav", + "text": "我相信今天除了在這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/843.wav", + "text": "場外還有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/844.wav", + "text": "很多相關的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/845.wav", + "text": "利害關係人在觀看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/846.wav", + "text": "我覺得考試院跟銓敘部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/847.wav", + "text": "是不是可以就這部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/848.wav", + "text": "讓他們可以非常" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/849.wav", + "text": "地瞭解也代表你們是負責任地" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/850.wav", + "text": "地設計這個制度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/851.wav", + "text": "請吳委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/852.wav", + "text": "我同意謝委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/853.wav", + "text": "如何更公開透明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/854.wav", + "text": "的決心是什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/855.wav", + "text": "要由政府全權管理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/856.wav", + "text": "因為政府會負責任到底" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/857.wav", + "text": "我們知道新制度的責任就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/858.wav", + "text": "就是兩年定存利率而已" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/859.wav", + "text": "我想請教一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/860.wav", + "text": "保證支付的決心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/861.wav", + "text": "的誰知道接下來的20年利率" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/862.wav", + "text": "是什麼情況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/863.wav", + "text": "假設都不是這麼容易" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/864.wav", + "text": "績效搞不好都還達不到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/865.wav", + "text": "政府的決心到底" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/866.wav", + "text": "是什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/867.wav", + "text": "如果政府真的有決心的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/868.wav", + "text": "請先表現出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/869.wav", + "text": "請先把第93條第98條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/870.wav", + "text": "你願意按年依照精算結果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/871.wav", + "text": "來提撥的誠意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/872.wav", + "text": "先入法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/873.wav", + "text": "讓我們來看看政府願意負責任的決心是什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/874.wav", + "text": "我們再來談談第3條及第7條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/875.wav", + "text": "如果政府真的有這個決心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/876.wav", + "text": "要負責任的話我們再來談第3條及第7條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/877.wav", + "text": "謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/878.wav", + "text": "接下來請林奕華委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/879.wav", + "text": "發言再來陳椒華委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/880.wav", + "text": "大家都說得差不多了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/881.wav", + "text": "其實也是相關的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/882.wav", + "text": "當然我不否認" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/883.wav", + "text": "自己的權益這也是理所當然" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/884.wav", + "text": "為什麼他們會說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/885.wav", + "text": "希望組成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/886.wav", + "text": "財團法人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/887.wav", + "text": "就是因為對政府信心度不夠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/888.wav", + "text": "嘛就像剛剛怡玎說的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/889.wav", + "text": "之前到現在的信心度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/890.wav", + "text": "不足" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/891.wav", + "text": "假如像執政黨說的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/892.wav", + "text": "政府要負責任" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/893.wav", + "text": "所以第7條要由政府來負責任" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/894.wav", + "text": "柯總召就應��接受" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/895.wav", + "text": "第6條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/896.wav", + "text": "監理要讓利害相關人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/897.wav", + "text": "如果第7條堅持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/898.wav", + "text": "要維持政府的版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/899.wav", + "text": "我認為第6條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/900.wav", + "text": "執政黨就應該要放出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/901.wav", + "text": "讓真正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/902.wav", + "text": "相關的利害關係人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/903.wav", + "text": "能夠有一半以上的人數" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/904.wav", + "text": "現在走到民主制度裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/905.wav", + "text": "我覺得這才是讓目前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/906.wav", + "text": "所有公教人員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/907.wav", + "text": "得以放心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/908.wav", + "text": "在中間都有角色" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/909.wav", + "text": "可以去參與" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/910.wav", + "text": "我現在是很客觀的來說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/911.wav", + "text": "所以我也希望柯總召可以接受" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/912.wav", + "text": "我當然希望因為這是回應" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/913.wav", + "text": "大家對政府沒有信心的一個提案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/914.wav", + "text": "一定要政府來做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/915.wav", + "text": "給相關的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/916.wav", + "text": "公教人員能夠有一半" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/917.wav", + "text": "以上的席次讓他們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/918.wav", + "text": "在過程中得以來監理政府" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/919.wav", + "text": "的運作謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/920.wav", + "text": "發言我向大家報告一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/921.wav", + "text": "他講完就由柯總召講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/922.wav", + "text": "可是剛才柯總召在發言的時候批評我" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/923.wav", + "text": "教職員退休撫恤基金" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/924.wav", + "text": "管理委員會辦理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/925.wav", + "text": "對不對如果是管理委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/926.wav", + "text": "會辦理他們的管理情形" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/927.wav", + "text": "是怎麼樣這麼多年來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/928.wav", + "text": "如果管理得不錯表示" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/929.wav", + "text": "也放心讓" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/930.wav", + "text": "管理委員會去管理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/931.wav", + "text": "為什麼到公務人員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/932.wav", + "text": "政府如果管理操作" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/933.wav", + "text": "不好至少有政府做後盾" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/934.wav", + "text": "邏輯其實也不通所以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/935.wav", + "text": "剛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/936.wav", + "text": "如果是政府" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/937.wav", + "text": "來管理的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/938.wav", + "text": "更開放由更多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/939.wav", + "text": "人員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/940.wav", + "text": "進行監理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/941.wav", + "text": "這樣應該" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/942.wav", + "text": "會讓大家更能參與" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/943.wav", + "text": "制度應該還是比較好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/944.wav", + "text": "下來請柯總召" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/945.wav", + "text": "我希望大家講話的邏輯是一致的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/946.wav", + "text": "好好管理好好監理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/947.wav", + "text": "外面的財團法人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/948.wav", + "text": "就是這樣寫啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/949.wav", + "text": "\n寫說交給財團法人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/950.wav", + "text": "到底你的目的是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/951.wav", + "text": "得耶" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/952.wav", + "text": "你是我們立法院的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/953.wav", + "text": "不可能用這個得啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/954.wav", + "text": "是得但前面幾條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/955.wav", + "text": "其他的都是要交給財團法人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/956.wav", + "text": "坦白講這些都是障眼法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/957.wav", + "text": "外面的人這個我們能放心嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/958.wav", + "text": "外面的人這也是教育部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/959.wav", + "text": "財團法人這是教育部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/960.wav", + "text": "我跟你講過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/961.wav", + "text": "政府全部退出然後交給外面的財團法人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/962.wav", + "text": "撥補入法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/963.wav", + "text": "財團法人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/964.wav", + "text": "連貪污治罪條例都不適用耶" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/965.wav", + "text": "我跟你講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/966.wav", + "text": "這個大家都想說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/967.wav", + "text": "說管理好的話可以賺錢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/968.wav", + "text": "這個我不否認" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/969.wav", + "text": "法假如這樣的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/970.wav", + "text": "我們就保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/971.wav", + "text": "百分之百障眼法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/972.wav", + "text": "不好意思" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/973.wav", + "text": "柯總召因為司法及法制委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/974.wav", + "text": "你很少來啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/975.wav", + "text": "因為我要負責最後的總體協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/976.wav", + "text": "所以你們在開會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/977.wav", + "text": "誰講什麼話我都很清楚的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/978.wav", + "text": "我是非常負責" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/979.wav", + "text": "因為剛才有說他講完就保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/980.wav", + "text": "所以是不是就保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/981.wav", + "text": "院長我剛才提議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/982.wav", + "text": "讓銓敘部說明清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/983.wav", + "text": "未來他們怎麼樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/984.wav", + "text": "管理這個基金" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/985.wav", + "text": "因為場外也很多人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/986.wav", + "text": "昨天有跟個別委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/987.wav", + "text": "場外有很多退休" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/988.wav", + "text": "想要瞭解未來銓敘" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/989.wav", + "text": "銓敘部說明如果說完" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/990.wav", + "text": "好不好好就不再延了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/991.wav", + "text": "報告院長及各位委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/992.wav", + "text": "所有的提案都是基於對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/993.wav", + "text": "過去退撫基金投資" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/994.wav", + "text": "效益的不信任" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/995.wav", + "text": "但事實證明私立" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/996.wav", + "text": "得比我們好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/997.wav", + "text": "目前為止的統計世界各國也不見得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/998.wav", + "text": "都比我們好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/999.wav", + "text": "長期來看我們是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1000.wav", + "text": "值得信任的長期" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1001.wav", + "text": "來看私校並沒有比較好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1002.wav", + "text": "我們確實是參考私校的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1003.wav", + "text": "參考因為這是新的制度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1004.wav", + "text": "我們當然需要重新設計" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1005.wav", + "text": "但我們會考量過去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1006.wav", + "text": "的實際經驗" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1007.wav", + "text": "自主投資運用方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1008.wav", + "text": "的整個程序" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1009.wav", + "text": "我們都有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1010.wav", + "text": "包括遴選投資顧問公司信託" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1011.wav", + "text": "也都瞭解私校是如何運作" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1012.wav", + "text": "都會讓他們來參與" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1013.wav", + "text": "但實際上的運作" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1014.wav", + "text": "委員剛才所提到的退休人員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1015.wav", + "text": "新制沒有退休人員的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1016.wav", + "text": "開始實施所以沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1017.wav", + "text": "退休人員代表的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1018.wav", + "text": "議制嚴格來講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1019.wav", + "text": "沒有負責的問題委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1020.wav", + "text": "任期到就結束了做錯決策" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1021.wav", + "text": "因此未來我們希望改成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1022.wav", + "text": "類似勞動基金運用局銓敘" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1023.wav", + "text": "主委因為我也不是專業" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1024.wav", + "text": "雖然現在改了條文說法律" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1025.wav", + "text": "但我自認不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1026.wav", + "text": "在專業上去領導" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1027.wav", + "text": "他們因此我們希望將來能夠專業化" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1028.wav", + "text": "並且委員會決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1029.wav", + "text": "的決策效率也比較緩慢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1030.wav", + "text": "制相關的配套措施考試院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1031.wav", + "text": "已經有配套的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1032.wav", + "text": "組織法修正方案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1033.wav", + "text": "也會提到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1034.wav", + "text": "大院來我們確定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1035.wav", + "text": "地設計新的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1036.wav", + "text": "我們的透明度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1037.wav", + "text": "基金專戶的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1038.wav", + "text": "權益保障的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1039.wav", + "text": "程度不會低於私校" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1040.wav", + "text": "但我們有可課責性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1041.wav", + "text": "一個財團法人它沒辦法負起" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1042.wav", + "text": "決策錯誤的責任他們是無法承擔" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1043.wav", + "text": "的我只能這樣先跟大家說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1044.wav", + "text": "好本條照考試" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1045.wav", + "text": "院提案通過可以不可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1046.wav", + "text": "保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1047.wav", + "text": "請大家看第28條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1048.wav", + "text": "第28條因為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1049.wav", + "text": "有協商了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1050.wav", + "text": "大家都有協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1051.wav", + "text": "我們照協商建議條文的內容" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1052.wav", + "text": "第28條通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1053.wav", + "text": "\n現在換看第二案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1054.wav", + "text": "保留條文第93條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1055.wav", + "text": "第93條大家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1056.wav", + "text": "如果沒有意見就照" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1057.wav", + "text": "考試院提案通過這樣可以嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1058.wav", + "text": "你要說明是嗎請" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1059.wav", + "text": "考試院說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1060.wav", + "text": "第一案的部分還有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1061.wav", + "text": "第33條跟第62條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1062.wav", + "text": "法制局有提供我們一些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1063.wav", + "text": "文字修正的建議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1064.wav", + "text": "那我們也提出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1065.wav", + "text": "我說明一下公務人員的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1066.wav", + "text": "部分是第93條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1067.wav", + "text": "學校的部分是第98條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1068.wav", + "text": "但內容都是一樣的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1069.wav", + "text": "第一個是第2項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1070.wav", + "text": "要不要擬定的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1071.wav", + "text": "以政府來說大家會覺得說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1072.wav", + "text": "都不需要寫因為第4條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1073.wav", + "text": "已經是這樣但是我們認為寫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1074.wav", + "text": "了代表我們的一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1075.wav", + "text": "所節省提撥" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1076.wav", + "text": "支出應全數" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1077.wav", + "text": "挹注退撫基金不得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1078.wav", + "text": "很重要且要入法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1079.wav", + "text": "後面萬一生變" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1080.wav", + "text": "這一項可以安定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1081.wav", + "text": "的心所以我們還是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1082.wav", + "text": "希望這一項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1083.wav", + "text": "能夠加進去這是非常重要的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1084.wav", + "text": "\n第3項的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1085.wav", + "text": "跟原來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1086.wav", + "text": "銓敘部教育部的差別" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1087.wav", + "text": "是在於如果按照" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1088.wav", + "text": "原來銓敘部跟教育部的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1089.wav", + "text": "版本它是補小" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1090.wav", + "text": "洞不是補大洞" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1091.wav", + "text": "的實施造成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1092.wav", + "text": "舊制提早破產" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1093.wav", + "text": "新制出現造成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1094.wav", + "text": "對舊制的衝擊提早" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1095.wav", + "text": "破產那幾年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1096.wav", + "text": "的錢它願意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1097.wav", + "text": "撥補回來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1098.wav", + "text": "老師可能是139" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1099.wav", + "text": "年變成133" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1100.wav", + "text": "年它可能就撥補" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1101.wav", + "text": "那6年中間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1102.wav", + "text": "的差額它願意來撥補" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1103.wav", + "text": "但是以這樣補" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1104.wav", + "text": "的公教人員到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1105.wav", + "text": "了139年140年正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1106.wav", + "text": "是他們正在領或準備" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1107.wav", + "text": "要領的時候就是已經" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1108.wav", + "text": "破產了那他們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1109.wav", + "text": "要怎麼領他們怎麼確保他們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1110.wav", + "text": "未來的退休金是無虞的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1111.wav", + "text": "\n所以我們正在要求的是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1112.wav", + "text": "我的條文是改成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1113.wav", + "text": "退撫基金之財務" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1114.wav", + "text": "缺口由政府" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1115.wav", + "text": "依退撫基金財務精算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1116.wav", + "text": "結果如有不足之處" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1117.wav", + "text": "應逐年編列" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1118.wav", + "text": "跟現在勞工" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1119.wav", + "text": "是逐年編列" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1120.wav", + "text": "一樣的道理就是逐年來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1121.wav", + "text": "我不是要補小的而是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1122.wav", + "text": "缺口上讓所有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1123.wav", + "text": "舊制的公務人員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1124.wav", + "text": "可以在這邊確定不會再" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1125.wav", + "text": "被二次年改" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1126.wav", + "text": "或是領不到相關的錢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1127.wav", + "text": "拜託一定要讓所有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1128.wav", + "text": "能夠安心地在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1129.wav", + "text": "第一現場工作" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1130.wav", + "text": "包括公務人員包括警察包" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1131.wav", + "text": "括消防人員包括老師" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1132.wav", + "text": "所以這部分要麻煩能夠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1133.wav", + "text": "照我們的版本通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1134.wav", + "text": "政府就是雇主" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1135.wav", + "text": "不要讓自己已經是惡老闆" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1136.wav", + "text": "又變成讓年輕人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1137.wav", + "text": "對政府沒有信心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1138.wav", + "text": "這也務必要拜託謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1139.wav", + "text": "接下來請游委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1140.wav", + "text": "其實我們知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1141.wav", + "text": "在107年年改時當" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1142.wav", + "text": "當時的目的是希望財政" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1143.wav", + "text": "可以永續經營" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1144.wav", + "text": "今年7月" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1145.wav", + "text": "銓敘部發布的第八次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1146.wav", + "text": "精算報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1147.wav", + "text": "舊的基金一次撥補" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1148.wav", + "text": "在公務員的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1149.wav", + "text": "285億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1150.wav", + "text": "元教師的部分236億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1151.wav", + "text": "達成永續" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1152.wav", + "text": "\n我在12月2日" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1153.wav", + "text": "也問過周部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1154.wav", + "text": "他也表示" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1155.wav", + "text": "考試院體系也很想" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1156.wav", + "text": "一次永續撥補但行政院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1157.wav", + "text": "跟主計總處不一定支持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1158.wav", + "text": "於是我今天其實在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1159.wav", + "text": "總統府的預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1160.wav", + "text": "請秘書長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1161.wav", + "text": "和副秘書長帶回去給" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1162.wav", + "text": "總統因為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1163.wav", + "text": "過去幾年勞工" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1164.wav", + "text": "的基金" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1165.wav", + "text": "已經撥補了1,000億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1166.wav", + "text": "蔡英文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1167.wav", + "text": "是中華民國的總統" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1168.wav", + "text": "不是勞工的總統" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1169.wav", + "text": "他也是我們軍公教" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1170.wav", + "text": "退休軍公教的總統" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1171.wav", + "text": "所以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1172.wav", + "text": "剛剛我們聽到不管" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1173.wav", + "text": "是黃委員羅委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1174.wav", + "text": "或柯總召都在講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1175.wav", + "text": "這個是政府的責任" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1176.wav", + "text": "既然要負起責任來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1177.wav", + "text": "不如就把這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1178.wav", + "text": "讓舊制不要像" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1179.wav", + "text": "陳國樑教授" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1180.wav", + "text": "的投書他" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1181.wav", + "text": "特別講了現在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1182.wav", + "text": "這個年改之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1183.wav", + "text": "因為舊的退撫基金在經濟" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1184.wav", + "text": "成長減緩" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1185.wav", + "text": "人口結構逐漸" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1186.wav", + "text": "高齡化及少子化" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1187.wav", + "text": "失衡而且設立新制之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1188.wav", + "text": "又會切斷新進財源" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1189.wav", + "text": "問題更加嚴重" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1190.wav", + "text": "公務人員跟" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1191.wav", + "text": "的退撫基金還因為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1192.wav", + "text": "年改的變動" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1193.wav", + "text": "提前破產" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1194.wav", + "text": "5年及4年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1195.wav", + "text": "如果不選擇財務永續" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1196.wav", + "text": "的方案一次撥補" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1197.wav", + "text": "就是把這個風險丟給公教" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1198.wav", + "text": "各位要負起責任" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1199.wav", + "text": "這不是什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1200.wav", + "text": "這是國家的責任" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1201.wav", + "text": "國家是所有退休" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1202.wav", + "text": "公教的雇主" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1203.wav", + "text": "就應該負起責任" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1204.wav", + "text": "不要做奧" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1205.wav", + "text": "雇主好不好謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1206.wav", + "text": "請柯總召" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1207.wav", + "text": "我們進入比較實質的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1208.wav", + "text": "像政府不負責" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1209.wav", + "text": "我想大家立場都一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1210.wav", + "text": "我們就進入比較實際" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1211.wav", + "text": "性的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1212.wav", + "text": "也就是說我們現在有林委員奕華的版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1213.wav", + "text": "版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1214.wav", + "text": "各級政府所節省" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1215.wav", + "text": "提撥費率之退撫經費支出" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1216.wav", + "text": "不得挪作他用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1217.wav", + "text": "應該有點一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1218.wav", + "text": "又有點不大一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1219.wav", + "text": "針對這個來討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1220.wav", + "text": "就開始要逐年撥補" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1221.wav", + "text": "應該針對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1222.wav", + "text": "這個直接進入實質討論比較好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1223.wav", + "text": "不必再做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1224.wav", + "text": "其他的理由說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1225.wav", + "text": "\n到底考試院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1226.wav", + "text": "能不能接受" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1227.wav", + "text": "和考試院的第2項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1228.wav", + "text": "哪裡有不同" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1229.wav", + "text": "是不是可以併在一起或怎麼樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1230.wav", + "text": "接下來請賴香伶委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1231.wav", + "text": "柯總召也是很務實性的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1232.wav", + "text": "兩個版本的差別" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1233.wav", + "text": "如果照考試院的保留版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1234.wav", + "text": "來看是因為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1235.wav", + "text": "實施新制之後造成用罄" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1236.wav", + "text": "年度提前的財務" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1237.wav", + "text": "缺口所以只提前個5年6年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1238.wav", + "text": "就只有針對這56年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1239.wav", + "text": "大概加總千億左右" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1240.wav", + "text": "去逐年編列預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1241.wav", + "text": "造成的這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1242.wav", + "text": "安全準備跟林奕華委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1243.wav", + "text": "談到的沒有以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1244.wav", + "text": "設算的這個金額來比照" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1245.wav", + "text": "當然是林委員的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1246.wav", + "text": "保障比較周延而且" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1247.wav", + "text": "財務上好像沒有那麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1248.wav", + "text": "我真的很希望等一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1249.wav", + "text": "考試院說明的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1250.wav", + "text": "當時這個版本的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1251.wav", + "text": "立法理由" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1252.wav", + "text": "是什麼為什麼要這樣子寫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1253.wav", + "text": "第二個大家都在問" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1254.wav", + "text": "未來要40年後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1255.wav", + "text": "整個才會過渡到個人帳戶" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1256.wav", + "text": "制公務同仁教師同仁都" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1257.wav", + "text": "全數退休了則" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1258.wav", + "text": "落日應該會發生在30年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1259.wav", + "text": "或40年後所以總體" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1260.wav", + "text": "來財務要輕一點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1261.wav", + "text": "才對因為人就會往新制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1262.wav", + "text": "部分跟第9" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1263.wav", + "text": "98條或剛剛講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1264.wav", + "text": "的第93條之間怎麼會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1265.wav", + "text": "需要在立法裡面用勾連" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1266.wav", + "text": "的方式也就是說退撫新制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1267.wav", + "text": "現有舊制度的財務缺口" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1268.wav", + "text": "新制之後政府要負" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1269.wav", + "text": "15%的百分之六十五" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1270.wav", + "text": "你們是基於財務問題才" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1271.wav", + "text": "做出這些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1272.wav", + "text": "設計嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1273.wav", + "text": "如果是這樣整個就變成在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1274.wav", + "text": "第63條所以這三個的關係" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1275.wav", + "text": "是不是也一併說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1276.wav", + "text": "這是我的意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1277.wav", + "text": "我簡單講一下可能請" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1278.wav", + "text": "一下為什麼你們當初只" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1279.wav", + "text": "想入法補這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1280.wav", + "text": "小洞如果今天從頭到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1281.wav", + "text": "尾一直強調的是政府" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1282.wav", + "text": "會負最終責任" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1283.wav", + "text": "你們都願意把這個小小" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1284.wav", + "text": "的部分責任入法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1285.wav", + "text": "照考試院的提案通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1286.wav", + "text": "有沒有問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1287.wav", + "text": "有問題就保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1288.wav", + "text": "好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1289.wav", + "text": "那就保留好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1290.wav", + "text": "要回答" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1291.wav", + "text": "我首先說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1292.wav", + "text": "原來考試院版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1293.wav", + "text": "是因為我們建立" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1294.wav", + "text": "新制度使得11" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1295.wav", + "text": "以後的新進公務員不會參加" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1296.wav", + "text": "原有的退撫基金所以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1297.wav", + "text": "退撫基金的收入會減少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1298.wav", + "text": "影響到它的財務" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1299.wav", + "text": "建立後所造成的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1300.wav", + "text": "財務缺口是因為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1301.wav", + "text": "我們建立制度造成的一定要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1302.wav", + "text": "法定撥補所以我們照規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1303.wav", + "text": "撥補這個缺口" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1304.wav", + "text": "會從140年提前到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1305.wav", + "text": "130年我們要它回到140年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1306.wav", + "text": "要撥補因為是我們建立制度造成的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1307.wav", + "text": "至於原有基金的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1308.wav", + "text": "問題那個是原來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1309.wav", + "text": "制度先天不良" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1310.wav", + "text": "後天失調造成的結果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1311.wav", + "text": "它確實有非常" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1312.wav", + "text": "是從過去就應該有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1313.wav", + "text": "但我們條文上已經有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1314.wav", + "text": "政府負最後支付保證責任" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1315.wav", + "text": "至於這個最後支付" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1316.wav", + "text": "保證責任是不是要到最後才來負" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1317.wav", + "text": "要提前來撥補" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1318.wav", + "text": "這個當然是政策考量要看國家的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1319.wav", + "text": "財政如果說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1320.wav", + "text": "7月1日以後在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1321.wav", + "text": "政府撥補" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1322.wav", + "text": "這個新制造成的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1323.wav", + "text": "缺口的同時也能" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1324.wav", + "text": "對舊制適當地做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1325.wav", + "text": "一些撥補我覺得我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1326.wav", + "text": "也是樂觀其成但這要看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1327.wav", + "text": "國家財政負擔" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1328.wav", + "text": "的問題但我們至少要確保" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1329.wav", + "text": "新制的建立對現行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1330.wav", + "text": "基金的影響一定要先把它補起來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1331.wav", + "text": "請黃委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1332.wav", + "text": "包含在委員會審查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1333.wav", + "text": "跟今天一開始" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1334.wav", + "text": "我也認為這兩條需要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1335.wav", + "text": "表現一些誠意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1336.wav", + "text": "很多公教人員團體的陳情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1337.wav", + "text": "大家還是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1338.wav", + "text": "對於二次年改" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1339.wav", + "text": "的可能性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1340.wav", + "text": "覺得有心理創傷" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1341.wav", + "text": "要平衡的兩件事情是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1342.wav", + "text": "剛剛部長其實也講得很清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1343.wav", + "text": "負最終財務責任這件事情是原來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1344.wav", + "text": "法條就有的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1345.wav", + "text": "現在要求進一步的東西" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1346.wav", + "text": "要逐年撥補" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1347.wav", + "text": "什麼時候計算的結果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1348.wav", + "text": "用那個結果去逐年撥補" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1349.wav", + "text": "這件事情要明定出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1350.wav", + "text": "這樣讓大家更有保障" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1351.wav", + "text": "政府的財務彈性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1352.wav", + "text": "因為它的缺口" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1353.wav", + "text": "不會是平均每年多少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1354.wav", + "text": "所以這裡面還有一些變數" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1355.wav", + "text": "包含國際的經濟" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1356.wav", + "text": "以及這個基金本身的盈虧" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1357.wav", + "text": "等都會影響" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1358.wav", + "text": "因為我們的精算其實只是設算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1359.wav", + "text": "嘛所以這個財務" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1360.wav", + "text": "撥補的責任" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1361.wav", + "text": "要不要寫到這麼具體" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1362.wav", + "text": "因為這個不像我們現在所謂的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1363.wav", + "text": "而小缺口為什麼我們可以算得很清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1364.wav", + "text": "是因為它發生的時間是比較近的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1365.wav", + "text": "然後它的影響範圍" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1366.wav", + "text": "是比較可以確定的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1367.wav", + "text": "所以我們甚至連開放選擇權之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1368.wav", + "text": "因為它的時間是比較近的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1369.wav", + "text": "造成了一個新的缺口" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1370.wav", + "text": "當然我們在立法上就要立刻" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1371.wav", + "text": "但是上次在年改之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1372.wav", + "text": "我們已經把這個預期" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1373.wav", + "text": "可能破產的年限" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1374.wav", + "text": "往後延了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1375.wav", + "text": "當然這個舊制關門了之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1376.wav", + "text": "它還會存續幾十年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1377.wav", + "text": "因為領的人繼續領" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1378.wav", + "text": "它就必須要存續幾十年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1379.wav", + "text": "但是它需要撥補的時間點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1380.wav", + "text": "是不是從現在就要開始做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1381.wav", + "text": "我覺得也不一定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1382.wav", + "text": "註明要把政府在某個時間點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1383.wav", + "text": "要去啟動這樣的計算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1384.wav", + "text": "然後要逐年去撥補" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1385.wav", + "text": "但是文字上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1386.wav", + "text": "是不是要像現在的版本這樣寫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1387.wav", + "text": "好像我現在就要開始去算好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1388.wav", + "text": "然後現在就要開始撥補" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1389.wav", + "text": "我覺得這個可能還是要給" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1390.wav", + "text": "行政院特別是主計" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1391.wav", + "text": "財主這邊一些彈性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1392.wav", + "text": "至於文字怎麼調整" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1393.wav", + "text": "我是建議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1394.wav", + "text": "真正需要財務彈性的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1395.wav", + "text": "也不是考試院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1396.wav", + "text": "所以是不是把這個需求" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1397.wav", + "text": "讓行政院這邊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1398.wav", + "text": "這個promise的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1399.wav", + "text": "以上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1400.wav", + "text": "請林委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1401.wav", + "text": "之前召委本身有當過代表" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1402.wav", + "text": "又是律師" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1403.wav", + "text": "所以他對這個問題是非常非常瞭解" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1404.wav", + "text": "現在造成衝擊或不確定性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1405.wav", + "text": "有提到的年輕一輩的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1406.wav", + "text": "公教警消人員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1407.wav", + "text": "我覺得我們真的有這個責任" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1408.wav", + "text": "要不然我們如果沒有辦法確定下來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1409.wav", + "text": "要負責任" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1410.wav", + "text": "因為目前我們是立法委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1411.wav", + "text": "現在在審這個法包括政府部門的同仁" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1412.wav", + "text": "也是一樣我們在為未來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1413.wav", + "text": "的世代在負責" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1414.wav", + "text": "所以剛才" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1415.wav", + "text": "他就很清楚地說到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1416.wav", + "text": "我們應該是要為整體負責" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1417.wav", + "text": "而且負所謂的最終支付責任" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1418.wav", + "text": "我們不是希望說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1419.wav", + "text": "可能又透過再一次年改" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1420.wav", + "text": "讓政府減少負擔" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1421.wav", + "text": "那也是叫政府負最終" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1422.wav", + "text": "支付責任啊只是它負擔" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1423.wav", + "text": "的更少而已" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1424.wav", + "text": "這不是我們要的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1425.wav", + "text": "很多公教人員都很受傷" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1426.wav", + "text": "而且我還有一個要說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1427.wav", + "text": "像當時我們在修" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1428.wav", + "text": "公服法大家還記得嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1429.wav", + "text": "如果以現在年改的狀況之下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1430.wav", + "text": "要你開放公務人員可以去做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1431.wav", + "text": "跟他利益無關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1432.wav", + "text": "的兼職" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1433.wav", + "text": "也不行嘛就變成公教" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1434.wav", + "text": "上很高的要求" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1435.wav", + "text": "他除了自己的本業之外" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1436.wav", + "text": "去兼個課之類" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1437.wav", + "text": "的但他是不能去打工的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1438.wav", + "text": "連想去開個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1439.wav", + "text": "Uber都不行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1440.wav", + "text": "或是說下班要去當個外送員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1441.wav", + "text": "都不行耶" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1442.wav", + "text": "因為我們對公教人員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1443.wav", + "text": "就是有這麼高的要求" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1444.wav", + "text": "所以當我們對公教人員有這麼高" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1445.wav", + "text": "的要求的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1446.wav", + "text": "相對地我們一定要對他" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1447.wav", + "text": "起碼可以有達到應該要有的保障" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1448.wav", + "text": "嘛所以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1449.wav", + "text": "在這樣的前提之下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1450.wav", + "text": "文字應該是很中性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1451.wav", + "text": "的因為我是說財務" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1452.wav", + "text": "缺口的部分是由" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1453.wav", + "text": "政府依退撫基金財務" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1454.wav", + "text": "精算結果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1455.wav", + "text": "如有不足之處應逐年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1456.wav", + "text": "編列等等這樣下來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1457.wav", + "text": "所以是根據" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1458.wav", + "text": "因為如果我們現在不開始撥補" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1459.wav", + "text": "到後面洞愈大的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1460.wav", + "text": "政府的財務負擔會愈重" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1461.wav", + "text": "所以逐年來撥補" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1462.wav", + "text": "是減少未來的負擔" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1463.wav", + "text": "院長很清楚像現在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1464.wav", + "text": "我都覺得這樣很好啊都是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1465.wav", + "text": "政府負責嘛勞工" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1466.wav", + "text": "每年至少撥補200億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1467.wav", + "text": "明年甚至因為稅收" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1468.wav", + "text": "多還撥補了450" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1469.wav", + "text": "億元對勞工" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1470.wav", + "text": "公教人員是不是也能" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1471.wav", + "text": "受到一樣的待遇" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1472.wav", + "text": "農保也" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1473.wav", + "text": "為他們在為國家做事" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1474.wav", + "text": "安定感所以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1475.wav", + "text": "再次麻煩第93條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1476.wav", + "text": "和第98條的重要性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1477.wav", + "text": "一旦修了之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1478.wav", + "text": "說真的第3條大家也不會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1479.wav", + "text": "跑了啦不會想說要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1480.wav", + "text": "跑到新制去因為他舊制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1481.wav", + "text": "確定有保障" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1482.wav", + "text": "所以院長您要做一個英明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1483.wav", + "text": "的裁決尤" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1484.wav", + "text": "尤其對現在年輕一輩的公教" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1485.wav", + "text": "93條和第98條真的太重要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1486.wav", + "text": "的院長能夠在這邊做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1487.wav", + "text": "一個最好的調處謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1488.wav", + "text": "好如果我可以裁決" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1489.wav", + "text": "的話那就簡單了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1490.wav", + "text": "但是我們協商是合議制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1491.wav", + "text": "部長志宏說明一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1492.wav", + "text": "說完我們就做一個決定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1493.wav", + "text": "林奕華委員的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1494.wav", + "text": "有兩個問題我先" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1495.wav", + "text": "提出來第一個現行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1496.wav", + "text": "前項人員適用重行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1497.wav", + "text": "建立退撫制度後各級政府" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1498.wav", + "text": "所節省提撥費率之退撫經費" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1499.wav", + "text": "其實依照新制政府" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1500.wav", + "text": "還是要負擔也是要提撥沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1501.wav", + "text": "節省所以第2項的規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1502.wav", + "text": "基本上是不會發生的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1503.wav", + "text": "因為我們費率" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1504.wav", + "text": "一樣都是15%" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1505.wav", + "text": "所以沒有節省的問題如果照" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1506.wav", + "text": "它有一個是降到12%的這" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1507.wav", + "text": "才有節省的問題我們都是15%所以沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1508.wav", + "text": "節省\n第二個是有關後面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1509.wav", + "text": "第3項不受" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1510.wav", + "text": "預算法的限制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1511.wav", + "text": "這個雖然在私校退撫有但是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1512.wav", + "text": "總處溝通的結果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1513.wav", + "text": "有教育部經費" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1514.wav", + "text": "結餘可以流用的問題所以才要特別規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1515.wav", + "text": "但我們是法定支出這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1516.wav", + "text": "沒有要排除預算法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1517.wav", + "text": "規定的必要所以後半段" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1518.wav", + "text": "也是多餘的至於" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1519.wav", + "text": "有關財務缺口因為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1520.wav", + "text": "林委員這個寫法看起來是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1521.wav", + "text": "但我們的寫法是小" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1522.wav", + "text": "缺口一定要先補大" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1523.wav", + "text": "缺口如何補再來考量" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1524.wav", + "text": "所以稍微不太一樣這樣就要看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1525.wav", + "text": "看他們覺得條文要怎麼調整" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1526.wav", + "text": "比較適當" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1527.wav", + "text": "好我" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1528.wav", + "text": "便當現在要做決定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1529.wav", + "text": "不然等一下你們會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1530.wav", + "text": "我們現在就要準備" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1531.wav", + "text": "不然等一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1532.wav", + "text": "不要買" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1533.wav", + "text": "有關於" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1534.wav", + "text": "剛才討論的第93條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1535.wav", + "text": "因為意見沒有一致我們還是保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1536.wav", + "text": "請問主計總處現在誰在現場" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1537.wav", + "text": "因為我剛剛比較晚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1538.wav", + "text": "到主計總處能不能回應" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1539.wav", + "text": "呢我們剛剛有講因" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1540.wav", + "text": "部長也沒有反對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1541.wav", + "text": "他再怎麼講還是意見不一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1542.wav", + "text": "報告院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1543.wav", + "text": "我不覺得有意見不一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1544.wav", + "text": "耶剛剛召委的說法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1545.wav", + "text": "他也認為是可以調整的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1546.wav", + "text": "也是這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1547.wav", + "text": "可以再討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1548.wav", + "text": "我們應該先保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1549.wav", + "text": "有一個共識再提出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1550.wav", + "text": "今天沒有辦法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1551.wav", + "text": "\n你聽了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1552.wav", + "text": "會後你們就可以馬上溝通" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1553.wav", + "text": "不要放周部長走" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1554.wav", + "text": "啊你用吃便當的時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1555.wav", + "text": "保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1556.wav", + "text": "我怕保留明天就表決" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1557.wav", + "text": "這樣就變成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1558.wav", + "text": "很可惜" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1559.wav", + "text": "可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1560.wav", + "text": "\n現在請大家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1561.wav", + "text": "看第三案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1562.wav", + "text": "第三案的第3條第6條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1563.wav", + "text": "跟第7條一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1564.wav", + "text": "嘛所以我們現在就看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1565.wav", + "text": "第29條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1566.wav", + "text": "第29條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1567.wav", + "text": "教育部有提再修正的意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1568.wav", + "text": "29條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1569.wav", + "text": "建議條文通過好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1570.wav", + "text": "為已經協商過了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1571.wav", + "text": "第29條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1572.wav", + "text": "好那就通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1573.wav", + "text": "\n請大家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1574.wav", + "text": "看保留條文第21條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1575.wav", + "text": "這個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1576.wav", + "text": "也有協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1577.wav", + "text": "的結論就照" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1578.wav", + "text": "考試院行政院的提案通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1579.wav", + "text": "第五案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1580.wav", + "text": "公務人員保險法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1581.wav", + "text": "通過的部分你就不要再講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1582.wav", + "text": "沒有啦院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1583.wav", + "text": "所以就拜託一下照" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1584.wav", + "text": "協商建議條文通過這是你們有協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1585.wav", + "text": "的剛才通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1586.wav", + "text": "最後是文字的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1587.wav", + "text": "還是原則的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1588.wav", + "text": "那一條因為有委員有意見所" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1589.wav", + "text": "才保留沒" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1590.wav", + "text": "我已經宣布通過了結果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1591.wav", + "text": "你們現在卻有意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1592.wav", + "text": "主席剛才的速度比較快像" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1593.wav", + "text": "我手上都沒有第十六條的版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1594.wav", + "text": "手上都沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1595.wav", + "text": "到底第十六條的問題在哪裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1596.wav", + "text": "協商版本不是出來了嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1597.wav", + "text": "你們又有什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1598.wav", + "text": "因為當時鄭" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1599.wav", + "text": "鄭委員有一個修正案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1600.wav", + "text": "我們對鄭委員的修正案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1601.wav", + "text": "還有一些意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1602.wav", + "text": "後來我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1603.wav", + "text": "稍微研究一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1604.wav", + "text": "再修正文字讓它更精確" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1605.wav", + "text": "報告主席" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1606.wav", + "text": "我手上這本是12月2日的協商條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1607.wav", + "text": "那時候我們還沒簽而" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1608.wav", + "text": "15日的建議版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1609.wav", + "text": "應該以這個來討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1610.wav", + "text": "文字稍微做了調整" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1611.wav", + "text": "請大家看一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1612.wav", + "text": "最新的版本12月15日" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1613.wav", + "text": "協商建議條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1614.wav", + "text": "大家如果沒有意見我們就通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1615.wav", + "text": "我就宣布通過了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1616.wav", + "text": "就照最新的協商建議條文通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1617.wav", + "text": "\n再來看保留條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1618.wav", + "text": "第21條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1619.wav", + "text": "第21條也有協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1620.wav", + "text": "就是把原來鄭委員的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1621.wav", + "text": "最新的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1622.wav", + "text": "同樣的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1623.wav", + "text": "就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1624.wav", + "text": "放在同一份資料的後面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1625.wav", + "text": "第21條通過\n" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1626.wav", + "text": "現在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1627.wav", + "text": "就是保留的保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1628.wav", + "text": "通過的通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1629.wav", + "text": "但是有關條文裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1630.wav", + "text": "我們有請法制局" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1631.wav", + "text": "看過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1632.wav", + "text": "請法制局來向大家報告一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1633.wav", + "text": "如果大家同意的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1634.wav", + "text": "文字提供意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1635.wav", + "text": "好請法制局" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1636.wav", + "text": "法制局有把我們看到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1637.wav", + "text": "一些條文需要做文字調整的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1638.wav", + "text": "有事先印發給" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1639.wav", + "text": "原則上銓敘部有看了我們的建議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1640.wav", + "text": "在今天提出的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1641.wav", + "text": "條文裡面有採納我們的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1642.wav", + "text": "修正意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1643.wav", + "text": "教職員個人專戶制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1644.wav", + "text": "的第十一條目前並沒有採納法制局的建議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1645.wav", + "text": "所以是否請院長就請" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1646.wav", + "text": "各部會說明他們今天提出的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1647.wav", + "text": "修正條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1648.wav", + "text": "剛才法制局" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1649.wav", + "text": "報告了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1650.wav", + "text": "主管部會有沒有什麼意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1651.wav", + "text": "文字調整" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1652.wav", + "text": "你們知道嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1653.wav", + "text": "好請" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1654.wav", + "text": "第33條第62條我們接受法制局的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1655.wav", + "text": "建議我們有協商的條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1656.wav", + "text": "教育部再補充說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1657.wav", + "text": "剛才法制局是指第十一" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1658.wav", + "text": "版有一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1659.wav", + "text": "專業金融機構" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1660.wav", + "text": "或專業機構" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1661.wav", + "text": "辦理法制局給我們的建議是說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1662.wav", + "text": "建議可以刪除" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1663.wav", + "text": "跟院長及各位委員報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1664.wav", + "text": "在實務上應該不會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1665.wav", + "text": "有影響" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1666.wav", + "text": "如果根據法制局的建議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1667.wav", + "text": "這跟公務人員的退撫條例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1668.wav", + "text": "相較他們也是沒有加專業" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1669.wav", + "text": "兩字所以教育部這邊建議專業" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1670.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1671.wav", + "text": "現在就法制局" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1672.wav", + "text": "所提出來的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1673.wav", + "text": "主管部會都同意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1674.wav", + "text": "我們文字就照這樣院長等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1675.wav", + "text": "法制局提什麼條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1676.wav", + "text": "來我問你哪一條都答不出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1677.wav", + "text": "教育人員是第十一條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1678.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1679.wav", + "text": "草稿" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1680.wav", + "text": "我們今天的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1681.wav", + "text": "大家如果有意見可以改不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1682.wav", + "text": "布就算了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1683.wav", + "text": "我想" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1684.wav", + "text": "這個我" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1685.wav", + "text": "趕快印給大家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1686.wav", + "text": "院長剛才不是說要再討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1687.wav", + "text": "不是要再討論嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1688.wav", + "text": "不是如果你們還有意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1689.wav", + "text": "剛才說是先保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1690.wav", + "text": "你們可以繼續說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1691.wav", + "text": "現在看他們有些也說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1692.wav", + "text": "可以修啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1693.wav", + "text": "剛才不是說有些可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1694.wav", + "text": "對啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1695.wav", + "text": "要主動你們把要修的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1696.wav", + "text": "明天就表決" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1697.wav", + "text": "非常粗暴" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1698.wav", + "text": "這太粗暴了太粗暴了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1699.wav", + "text": "明天用表決" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1700.wav", + "text": "太粗暴了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1701.wav", + "text": "沒有協" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1702.wav", + "text": "有一些能接受的就接受" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1703.wav", + "text": "的剛剛有幾條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1704.wav", + "text": "文字趕快拿出來還" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1705.wav", + "text": "還是一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1706.wav", + "text": "撥補的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1707.wav", + "text": "你們只補小洞" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1708.wav", + "text": "年輕的公教人員要怎麼辦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1709.wav", + "text": "不是你講的為準" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1710.wav", + "text": "負最後支付責任" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1711.wav", + "text": "休息10分鐘" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1712.wav", + "text": "也要補一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1713.wav", + "text": "我想大家意思都一樣但" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1714.wav", + "text": "但是現在在這裡面的人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1715.wav", + "text": "沒有一個能決定這件事" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1716.wav", + "text": "因為是主計總處在出錢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1717.wav", + "text": "所以這兩條保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1718.wav", + "text": "談談好有結果我們再共同提案就好了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1719.wav", + "text": "好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1720.wav", + "text": "子要達到原來的政策目的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1721.wav", + "text": "反正保留的只有六條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1722.wav", + "text": "我談看看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1723.wav", + "text": "這樣談起來就是各四條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1724.wav", + "text": "條如果可以就共同提案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1725.wav", + "text": "來報告今天的協商結論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1726.wav", + "text": "但是還可以修改" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1727.wav", + "text": "讓大家思考" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1728.wav", + "text": "這是很多委員的建議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1729.wav", + "text": "如果大家沒有意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1730.wav", + "text": "下一次就提出來協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1731.wav", + "text": "子讓大家看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1732.wav", + "text": "如果大家同意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1733.wav", + "text": "就四個黨團大家一起提案院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1734.wav", + "text": "有一件比較重要的事也" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1735.wav", + "text": "就是延會的事" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1736.wav", + "text": "我們今天來談一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1737.wav", + "text": "這會期要延會到什麼時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1738.wav", + "text": "了我們就把法定預算處理完畢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1739.wav", + "text": "譬如今天這個有時間性的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1740.wav", + "text": "假如大家沒有意見的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1741.wav", + "text": "我們就延會到1月13日這樣就" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1742.wav", + "text": "不用到臨時會去表決那樣沒用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1743.wav", + "text": "把總預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1744.wav", + "text": "及重要法案處理完畢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1745.wav", + "text": "協商能處理多少就算多少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1746.wav", + "text": "不過延會的時候只" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1747.wav", + "text": "不開委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1748.wav", + "text": "大家有共識的話先簽起來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1749.wav", + "text": "延會不是可以開委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1750.wav", + "text": "不開委員會了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1751.wav", + "text": "就開院會處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1752.wav", + "text": "我們每天在協商法案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1753.wav", + "text": "不開委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1754.wav", + "text": "了通常都沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1755.wav", + "text": "都是在處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1756.wav", + "text": "其實可以開委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1757.wav", + "text": "不需要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1758.wav", + "text": "一個月以後再處理也來不及" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1759.wav", + "text": "我們通常在臨時會都是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1760.wav", + "text": "只有開院會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1761.wav", + "text": "委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1762.wav", + "text": "延會和委員會中心主義" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1763.wav", + "text": "沒有關係" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1764.wav", + "text": "過去通常是用臨時會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1765.wav", + "text": "臨時會可以處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1766.wav", + "text": "這些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1767.wav", + "text": "照往例都是這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1768.wav", + "text": "所以這部分是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1769.wav", + "text": "這是第一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1770.wav", + "text": "這要先處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1771.wav", + "text": "至於這個部分要有人提案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1772.wav", + "text": "我們今天突然拿出來都沒有聽過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1773.wav", + "text": "回去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1774.wav", + "text": "這個不用付委嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1775.wav", + "text": "現在還沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1776.wav", + "text": "給大家看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1777.wav", + "text": "下一次黨團協商時再來協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1778.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1779.wav", + "text": "那就這樣喔" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1780.wav", + "text": "我現在來宣讀一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1781.wav", + "text": "因為第6條其實有修正文字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1782.wav", + "text": "要不要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1783.wav", + "text": "看一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1784.wav", + "text": "我是建議如果第2條可以接受" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1785.wav", + "text": "沒有啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1786.wav", + "text": "第6條保留了第6條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1787.wav", + "text": "不是保留了嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1788.wav", + "text": "剛剛有說第6條可以修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1789.wav", + "text": "我們剛剛跟委員溝通" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1790.wav", + "text": "第6條第1項的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1791.wav", + "text": "第6條如果可以修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1792.wav", + "text": "第7條我是覺得我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1793.wav", + "text": "也許" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1794.wav", + "text": "就讓政府來做嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1795.wav", + "text": "但第6條要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1796.wav", + "text": "加強它的監理機制這樣子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1797.wav", + "text": "剛剛那個部長前面也有講到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1798.wav", + "text": "到前面就是統計精算人事行政" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1799.wav", + "text": "財經或法律等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1800.wav", + "text": "這個文字我們可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1801.wav", + "text": "因為這個有彈性嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1802.wav", + "text": "至於後面第2項二分之一的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1803.wav", + "text": "公務人員代表及" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1804.wav", + "text": "學者專家代表" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1805.wav", + "text": "總數" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1806.wav", + "text": "超過二分之一" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1807.wav", + "text": "也吻合我們現在運作上的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1808.wav", + "text": "等一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1809.wav", + "text": "先保留好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1810.wav", + "text": "這個先談" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1811.wav", + "text": "你現在談到一半" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1812.wav", + "text": "突然投降" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1813.wav", + "text": "政府幹這個事" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1814.wav", + "text": "投降已" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1815.wav", + "text": "半天你現在突然" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1816.wav", + "text": "等一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1817.wav", + "text": "那要講清楚再來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1818.wav", + "text": "總召等一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1819.wav", + "text": "我很溫柔地講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1820.wav", + "text": "你誤會他了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1821.wav", + "text": "你誤會他了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1822.wav", + "text": "不是由公務員推派喔" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1823.wav", + "text": "對不起" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1824.wav", + "text": "不是推薦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1825.wav", + "text": "我現在再確定一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1826.wav", + "text": "第1項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1827.wav", + "text": "統計" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1828.wav", + "text": "精算人事行政財經或法律等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1829.wav", + "text": "者這個你們可以接受" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1830.wav", + "text": "OK" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1831.wav", + "text": "但是第2項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1832.wav", + "text": "什麼二分之一" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1833.wav", + "text": "那一塊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1834.wav", + "text": "他又說有啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1835.wav", + "text": "我就是要問這個事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1836.wav", + "text": "剛才一直講沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1837.wav", + "text": "你最後一刻講有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1838.wav", + "text": "大家要先溝通一下嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1839.wav", + "text": "學者專家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1840.wav", + "text": "其實現在的運作就超過了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1841.wav", + "text": "剛剛是說團體推薦學者專家嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1842.wav", + "text": "這個當然" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1843.wav", + "text": "現實上不太可能這樣運作啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1844.wav", + "text": "現在不要團體推薦了啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1845.wav", + "text": "學者專家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1846.wav", + "text": "本來就在我們規劃的那個範圍" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1847.wav", + "text": "但那個是銓敘部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1848.wav", + "text": "去邀請學者專家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1849.wav", + "text": "擔任委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1850.wav", + "text": "所以我們原來的學者專家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1851.wav", + "text": "並不是團體推薦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1852.wav", + "text": "但是加上民間的專家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1853.wav", + "text": "也就是非政府機關的人員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1854.wav", + "text": "是超過二分之一啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1855.wav", + "text": "但是那個學者專家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1856.wav", + "text": "當然是銓敘部這邊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1857.wav", + "text": "花了一二十分鐘在講這個事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1858.wav", + "text": "你這個有地方的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1859.wav", + "text": "也有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1860.wav", + "text": "也有中央的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1861.wav", + "text": "到底是屬於哪一邊的quota" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1862.wav", + "text": "這是很複雜的一個問題嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1863.wav", + "text": "所以你這個沒有設計好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1864.wav", + "text": "怎麼可以突然又說可以呢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1865.wav", + "text": "它很複雜嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1866.wav", + "text": "剛本來的意見是說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1867.wav", + "text": "學者專家由團體來推薦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1868.wav", + "text": "啦而這樣做就會有剛剛黃委員講的那個狀況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1869.wav", + "text": "要由公教人員來推薦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1870.wav", + "text": "我們原來的條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1871.wav", + "text": "學者專家是銓敘部這邊來找啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1872.wav", + "text": "現在這個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1873.wav", + "text": "委員這邊是可以接受的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1874.wav", + "text": "他們這些人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1875.wav", + "text": "又要推薦學者專家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1876.wav", + "text": "你也要推薦學者專家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1877.wav", + "text": "地方也要中央也要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1878.wav", + "text": "到底要怎麼弄嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1879.wav", + "text": "所以沒有講清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1880.wav", + "text": "突然投降我們當然不會答應" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1881.wav", + "text": "現在就沒有推薦了啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1882.wav", + "text": "沒有推薦了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1883.wav", + "text": "好息怒息怒" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1884.wav", + "text": "不是誤會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1885.wav", + "text": "我從頭到尾都在注意你們在搞什麼鬼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1886.wav", + "text": "均照考試院提案通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1887.wav", + "text": "\n四其餘均照審查會審查結果通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1888.wav", + "text": "\n第二案協商結論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1889.wav", + "text": "一第93條保留送院會處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1890.wav", + "text": "\n二其餘照審查會審查結果通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1891.wav", + "text": "\n第三案協商結論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1892.wav", + "text": "\n四其餘均照審查會審查結果通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1893.wav", + "text": "跟你們再談好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1894.wav", + "text": "第93條及第98條包括剛才那一條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1895.wav", + "text": "投降條款都一起談好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1896.wav", + "text": "人我們不可能當場被賣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1897.wav", + "text": "有關於延會部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1898.wav", + "text": "延會至112年元月13日（星期五）為止" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1899.wav", + "text": "\n大家看可不可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1900.wav", + "text": "員會全部等一下延會的部分我們再修正一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1901.wav", + "text": "一下我們建議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1902.wav", + "text": "果同時召開委員會那些委員被綁在委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1903.wav", + "text": "會但又要來朝野協商這邊處理各部會的預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1904.wav", + "text": "我覺得是浪費時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1905.wav", + "text": "元旦連假完的第一個禮拜" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1906.wav", + "text": "讓我們黨團幹部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1907.wav", + "text": "及相關委員會的召委委員來這邊專心處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1908.wav", + "text": "委員會出來之後保留預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1909.wav", + "text": "第二個禮拜才有時間處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1910.wav", + "text": "院會要表決的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1911.wav", + "text": "所以我建議還是回到我們講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1912.wav", + "text": "延會期間都只開院會不開委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1913.wav", + "text": "不要明天再講好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1914.wav", + "text": "這個慣例一向都是如此開委員會要幹什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1915.wav", + "text": "大家不要這樣拖延跟林奕" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1916.wav", + "text": "奕華委員講到底" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1917.wav", + "text": "而且跟曾" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1918.wav", + "text": "下午1點還在跟他談" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1919.wav", + "text": "啦講到1點半都還在講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1920.wav", + "text": "最重要的是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1921.wav", + "text": "預算還有前瞻四期" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1922.wav", + "text": "各委員會的審查結果送出來在院會處理嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1923.wav", + "text": "還有就是在院會上面對很多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1924.wav", + "text": "可以處理的就趕快處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1925.wav", + "text": "都來不及了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1926.wav", + "text": "至於專案報告其實也沒有什麼意思" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1927.wav", + "text": "開臨時會也都是這樣啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1928.wav", + "text": "所以我們就比較務實一點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1929.wav", + "text": "我們很懇切的來談啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1930.wav", + "text": "不必等到明天再談" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1931.wav", + "text": "我答應你們的事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1932.wav", + "text": "一定會儘量想" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1933.wav", + "text": "像剛才那個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1934.wav", + "text": "第6條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1935.wav", + "text": "我們會再研究看看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1936.wav", + "text": "們你們要提案也無所謂嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1937.wav", + "text": "可以的我們就共同提案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1938.wav", + "text": "因為這不是我在這裡能夠答應的事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1939.wav", + "text": "這是很實際的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1940.wav", + "text": "所以大家就很誠懇的來處理很多事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1941.wav", + "text": "總召還有第6條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1942.wav", + "text": "對第6條的監理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1943.wav", + "text": "明天早上確定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1944.wav", + "text": "你們放心啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1945.wav", + "text": "你冷靜一點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1946.wav", + "text": "我有說要故意我來簽" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1947.wav", + "text": "第一點大家對保留的部分可以持續溝通" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1948.wav", + "text": "第二點如果簽署完畢我們就依協商結論在院會進行後續的程序" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1949.wav", + "text": "有關發言部分就依剛才的討論通過由議事處處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14694/1950.wav", + "text": "散會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/0.wav", + "text": "各位先進" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1.wav", + "text": "我們現在開始要進行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/2.wav", + "text": "立法院朝野黨團協商會議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/3.wav", + "text": "退休資遣撫卹法草案等5案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/4.wav", + "text": "相關事宜（如附表" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/5.wav", + "text": "）這是民進黨黨團提案的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/6.wav", + "text": "我來介紹一下今天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/7.wav", + "text": "列席的政府各部會首長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/8.wav", + "text": "首先介紹考試院秘書長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/9.wav", + "text": "劉建忻先生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/10.wav", + "text": "再來介紹銓敘部部長周志宏先生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/11.wav", + "text": "劉永慧小姐行政院人事行政總處" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/12.wav", + "text": "副人事長懷敘先生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/13.wav", + "text": "提案黨團說明一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/14.wav", + "text": "首先就第一案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/15.wav", + "text": "公務人員個人帳戶制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/16.wav", + "text": "退休資遣撫卹法草案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/17.wav", + "text": "有關於委員會審查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/18.wav", + "text": "保留條文的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/19.wav", + "text": "其中總共有12條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/20.wav", + "text": "另外因為配合委員的意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/21.wav", + "text": "要做修改的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/22.wav", + "text": "必須要配合再修正一條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/23.wav", + "text": "有關於第3條的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/24.wav", + "text": "主要是涉及到現職人員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/25.wav", + "text": "能不能參加" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/26.wav", + "text": "112年7月1日以後的新制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/27.wav", + "text": "這個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/28.wav", + "text": "請問是每一條大致講一下嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/29.wav", + "text": "第二案是有關於" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/30.wav", + "text": "現行的公務人員退休資遣撫卹法第93條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/31.wav", + "text": "和第95條修正草案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/32.wav", + "text": "其中保留一條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/33.wav", + "text": "就是第93條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/34.wav", + "text": "缺口政府撥補的規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/35.wav", + "text": "因為各委員有其他不同版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/36.wav", + "text": "考試院是希望能夠維持考試院的版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/37.wav", + "text": "這個是有關現行的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/38.wav", + "text": "公務人員退休資遣撫卹法的規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/39.wav", + "text": "是不是由教育部做說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/40.wav", + "text": "我們先討論第一案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/41.wav", + "text": "等一下再進行第二案第三案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/42.wav", + "text": "因為第一案有好幾條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/43.wav", + "text": "現在就開始看大家有什麼意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/44.wav", + "text": "針對剛才部長���提到的第一" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/45.wav", + "text": "一案好像這邊有好幾條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/46.wav", + "text": "我們就逐條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/47.wav", + "text": "從第3條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/48.wav", + "text": "第3條我剛剛聽考試院的講法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/49.wav", + "text": "好像還是希望照你們的提案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/50.wav", + "text": "可不可以解釋一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/51.wav", + "text": "我們知道以新制來說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/52.wav", + "text": "財政負擔是比較輕的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/53.wav", + "text": "長遠來說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/54.wav", + "text": "如果對財政負擔比較輕的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/55.wav", + "text": "怎麼不是鼓勵我們現有人員轉到新制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/56.wav", + "text": "反而限制他們不能轉到新制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/57.wav", + "text": "我簡單說明一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/58.wav", + "text": "因為如果從112年7月1日" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/59.wav", + "text": "新進人員都不再參加以後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/60.wav", + "text": "現有退撫基金的財務會受到影響" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/61.wav", + "text": "因為它沒有新進人員繳納的這些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/62.wav", + "text": "退撫基金提撥的金額" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/63.wav", + "text": "因此它的用罄年限會分別提早5年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/64.wav", + "text": "即到135年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/65.wav", + "text": "而轉到新制的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/66.wav", + "text": "現有基金的缺口會越來越大" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/67.wav", + "text": "另外不見得對現職人員有利" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/68.wav", + "text": "所謂的有利是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/69.wav", + "text": "個人專戶制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/70.wav", + "text": "而去獲得最後專戶制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/71.wav", + "text": "度裡面的退撫給與" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/72.wav", + "text": "\n就現行制度來看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/73.wav", + "text": "確定給付制有其優點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/74.wav", + "text": "個人專戶制也有其優缺點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/75.wav", + "text": "彼此之間不見得都是哪一個制度最好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/76.wav", + "text": "但依照我們的分析" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/77.wav", + "text": "轉到新制相對是比較不利的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/78.wav", + "text": "又要提早幾年用罄" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/79.wav", + "text": "所以我們基本上希望" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/80.wav", + "text": "建立新制也儘量確保現行的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/81.wav", + "text": "儘可能財務不要受到太大影響" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/82.wav", + "text": "一定的撥補責任以後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/83.wav", + "text": "讓它的財務還是能夠健全運作" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/84.wav", + "text": "對於現職人員來講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/85.wav", + "text": "退撫資金受到太大衝擊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/86.wav", + "text": "撥補的部分我們等一下再來講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/87.wav", + "text": "說新制不一定對現行人員比較好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/88.wav", + "text": "或公務人員來跟我們要求的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/89.wav", + "text": "他們希望能夠讓他們自己選擇" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/90.wav", + "text": "他如果真的覺得新制沒有比較好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/91.wav", + "text": "他就留在舊制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/92.wav", + "text": "我們要求的只是開放讓他們選擇" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/93.wav", + "text": "再來剛才你說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/94.wav", + "text": "現職人員移到新制的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/95.wav", + "text": "可能會加速我們基金破產的時程" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/96.wav", + "text": "但是你沒有講的另外一句話是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/97.wav", + "text": "如果他們都沒有離開的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/98.wav", + "text": "到時候破產的時候洞會更大" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/99.wav", + "text": "簡而言之就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/100.wav", + "text": "短期中期來說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/101.wav", + "text": "你希望這些人留下來繼續" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/102.wav", + "text": "挹注這個水庫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/103.wav", + "text": "但是你沒有告訴這些人的是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/104.wav", + "text": "破產的時候那個洞會更大" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/105.wav", + "text": "因為這些人到時候我們也是要確定給付" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/106.wav", + "text": "因為確定給付到他退休的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/107.wav", + "text": "那個洞會更大" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/108.wav", + "text": "所以你一直沒有告訴人家的是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/109.wav", + "text": "就算他們全部留下來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/110.wav", + "text": "如果不建立新制的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/111.wav", + "text": "不是不建立新制而" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/112.wav", + "text": "而是建立新制之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/113.wav", + "text": "現職人員還是留在舊制的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/114.wav", + "text": "你只是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/115.wav", + "text": "政府負有最後的支付責任" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/116.wav", + "text": "到底最後的支付責任是怎麼樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/117.wav", + "text": "我們經過了一次年改" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/118.wav", + "text": "我們不知道支付責任到底" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/119.wav", + "text": "負不負責" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/120.wav", + "text": "我覺得大家已經看到了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/121.wav", + "text": "並沒有負完全的責任" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/122.wav", + "text": "你們第一次年改負責任的方法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/123.wav", + "text": "大家已經看過了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/124.wav", + "text": "如果是這種負責任的方法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/125.wav", + "text": "那真的不用了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/126.wav", + "text": "讓大家自由選擇" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/127.wav", + "text": "不要把我留在這裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/128.wav", + "text": "叫我繼續支付" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/129.wav", + "text": "然後破產的那一天才告訴我" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/130.wav", + "text": "不好意思我們打個折吧" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/131.wav", + "text": "為什麼不可能" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/132.wav", + "text": "那可以保證嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/133.wav", + "text": "我們可以先來談那個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/134.wav", + "text": "有關第3條部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/135.wav", + "text": "因為這是滿重要的一個條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/136.wav", + "text": "既然我們有原來的舊制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/137.wav", + "text": "和現在要成立的新制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/138.wav", + "text": "訴求是希望能夠讓" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/139.wav", + "text": "現職的公教警消" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/140.wav", + "text": "可以有選擇的權利" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/141.wav", + "text": "有選擇權" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/142.wav", + "text": "而不是由我們來認定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/143.wav", + "text": "另外剛才吳怡玎委員講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/144.wav", + "text": "到一個很重要的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/145.wav", + "text": "這個年改" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/146.wav", + "text": "當然剛才部長提到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/147.wav", + "text": "政府負最終支付責任" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/148.wav", + "text": "其實在法條中本來就有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/149.wav", + "text": "但後來我們看到這次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/150.wav", + "text": "政府是如何負最終的責任" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/151.wav", + "text": "是用年改的方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/152.wav", + "text": "減少大家的退休領取" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/153.wav", + "text": "來達到最終支付的責任" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/154.wav", + "text": "並不是真正按照像軍" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/155.wav", + "text": "軍農勞一樣的方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/156.wav", + "text": "來保障它本身的基金" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/157.wav", + "text": "唯一一個就是公教警消" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/158.wav", + "text": "政府不願意逐年撥補" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/159.wav", + "text": "所以後來你們用了一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/160.wav", + "text": "叫作年改的方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/161.wav", + "text": "職的公教人員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/162.wav", + "text": "有沒有可能再二次年改" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/163.wav", + "text": "大家都不在這個位置上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/164.wav", + "text": "沒有人可以在這邊保證" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/165.wav", + "text": "啊所以我覺得應該要給" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/166.wav", + "text": "公教警消人員一個選擇權" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/167.wav", + "text": "\n另外我想提出的是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/168.wav", + "text": "的黃召委有要求" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/169.wav", + "text": "如果選擇新制度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/170.wav", + "text": "對退撫基金的財務影響" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/171.wav", + "text": "的但這一點要跟主席報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/172.wav", + "text": "我覺得今天在討論這個條文的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/173.wav", + "text": "我們會沒辦法討論的原因是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/174.wav", + "text": "就以我自己最熟悉的老師來說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/175.wav", + "text": "因為一張是公務人員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/176.wav", + "text": "一張是教師" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/177.wav", + "text": "在教師的結清方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/178.wav", + "text": "只寫了一次退休金" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/179.wav", + "text": "有年資3年年資5年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/180.wav", + "text": "等等的狀況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/181.wav", + "text": "有多少人去轉換新制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/182.wav", + "text": "提出對財務影響的估算表" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/183.wav", + "text": "但是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/184.wav", + "text": "報告主席" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/185.wav", + "text": "以我自己的認知" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/186.wav", + "text": "老師選擇一次退休大概只有一成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/187.wav", + "text": "都是逐月" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/188.wav", + "text": "黃召委非常用心良苦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/189.wav", + "text": "要求部會提出一份財務影響" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/190.wav", + "text": "分析但這份資料我們其實沒有辦法當依據的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/191.wav", + "text": "逐月領的狀況之下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/192.wav", + "text": "到底它的影響是什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/193.wav", + "text": "這兩者是不一樣的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/194.wav", + "text": "我覺得今天在資料不足的狀況之下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/195.wav", + "text": "清楚地討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/196.wav", + "text": "對於這一點可能主席也要裁決一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/197.wav", + "text": "因為這個茲事體大" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/198.wav", + "text": "對很多人的權益影響很大的事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/199.wav", + "text": "事情我是不是能夠請主席" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/200.wav", + "text": "銓敘部跟教育部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/201.wav", + "text": "提出一份更精確的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/202.wav", + "text": "我們才有辦法很清楚地瞭解狀況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/203.wav", + "text": "第3條及後續很多的法律原則" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/204.wav", + "text": "這一點我先表達自己意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/205.wav", + "text": "也請主席能夠做清楚的裁決" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/206.wav", + "text": "謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/207.wav", + "text": "接下來請邱委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/208.wav", + "text": "謝謝院長及各個黨團黨鞭" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/209.wav", + "text": "鞭今天針對這個法案的協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/210.wav", + "text": "我想有三個重點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/211.wav", + "text": "退撫舊制需要完整地保障" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/212.wav", + "text": "所以定期撥補的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/213.wav", + "text": "我們建議一定要入法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/214.wav", + "text": "尤其政府在退撫條例第8條所說的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/215.wav", + "text": "由政府負擔最後支付的保證責任" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/216.wav", + "text": "這部分還是要保障" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/217.wav", + "text": "政府既然答應了就要做到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/218.wav", + "text": "第二個重點大概是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/219.wav", + "text": "新制要將利害關係人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/220.wav", + "text": "列入監理跟管理的組織之中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/221.wav", + "text": "這樣才能有效達到監理跟管理的效用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/222.wav", + "text": "自願提撥額度增加主管機關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/223.wav", + "text": "按月提繳相同的金額" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/224.wav", + "text": "增加教職員及公務人員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/225.wav", + "text": "減緩新制帶來長壽" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/226.wav", + "text": "主管機關和相關部會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/227.wav", + "text": "財政紀律的原則之下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/228.wav", + "text": "其實應該要把相關的機制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/229.wav", + "text": "跟風險評估跟大家說明清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/230.wav", + "text": "千萬不能報喜不報憂" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/231.wav", + "text": "所以有幾項條文的內容" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/232.wav", + "text": "我想必需要審慎討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/233.wav", + "text": "第一點根據教育部12月7日提出的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/234.wav", + "text": "開放現職公立學校教職員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/235.wav", + "text": "選擇新制對退撫基金的財務影響" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/236.wav", + "text": "從這份書面報告的資料可以看出" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/237.wav", + "text": "如果開放年資3年以下的現職人員轉換新制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/238.wav", + "text": "制用罄的年度是相同" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/239.wav", + "text": "的雖然有撥補數上升的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/240.wav", + "text": "但這個平衡對於現制新進教職人員的保障" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/241.wav", + "text": "會不會產生過多的相對剝奪感" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/242.wav", + "text": "我想這個部分都是必須要考慮的重點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/243.wav", + "text": "相關法案沒有版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/244.wav", + "text": "但是我們今天有提出4個修正動議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/245.wav", + "text": "等一下逐條討論的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/246.wav", + "text": "細節等一下賴委員會再補充" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/247.wav", + "text": "其實在第3條的爭議這個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/248.wav", + "text": "現職公務人員以及公教人員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/249.wav", + "text": "對於這條條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/250.wav", + "text": "他們都希望給予他們選擇的權利" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/251.wav", + "text": "銓敘部在過往的討論中都認為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/252.wav", + "text": "會導致更多財務負擔" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/253.wav", + "text": "但是誠如剛才銓敘部所言" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/254.wav", + "text": "新制對於政府的財務負擔是最輕的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/255.wav", + "text": "你們是怎麼樣評估說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/256.wav", + "text": "如果讓現在的公務人員跟公教人員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/257.wav", + "text": "有選擇權的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/258.wav", + "text": "會導致更大的財務缺口" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/259.wav", + "text": "從制度的設計可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/260.wav", + "text": "舊制的制度是比新制好的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/261.wav", + "text": "按理說大家應該會選擇舊制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/262.wav", + "text": "而不會選擇新制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/263.wav", + "text": "所以你們試算的結果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/264.wav", + "text": "���不是把所有人都試算到新制裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/265.wav", + "text": "你應該要說明清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/266.wav", + "text": "目前公務人員跟公教人員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/267.wav", + "text": "選擇的權利應該是一個民主國家的常態" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/268.wav", + "text": "如果不能選擇" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/269.wav", + "text": "你們的理由應該要足夠充分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/270.wav", + "text": "有一些爭點我說明一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/271.wav", + "text": "讓大家可以比較快" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/272.wav", + "text": "有效率地進行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/273.wav", + "text": "最大的爭議而需要決策" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/274.wav", + "text": "所以剛剛有些委員提到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/275.wav", + "text": "關於資料提供說明不足的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/276.wav", + "text": "因為後面有一些條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/277.wav", + "text": "有作出調整跟讓步" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/278.wav", + "text": "所以我是建議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/279.wav", + "text": "或其他幾個比較有爭議性的部分包含" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/280.wav", + "text": "可以選擇跳槽到新制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/281.wav", + "text": "以及在什麼樣的條件下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/282.wav", + "text": "對國家的財務影響到底是多少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/283.wav", + "text": "基金的管理跟監理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/284.wav", + "text": "很多委員都有不同的意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/285.wav", + "text": "大概就是要擴大跟落實" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/286.wav", + "text": "受益方的參與" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/287.wav", + "text": "的相關團體及代表" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/288.wav", + "text": "公開透明跟落實" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/289.wav", + "text": "在管理機關的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/290.wav", + "text": "現在考試院提出來的版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/291.wav", + "text": "在專業性跟監管的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/292.wav", + "text": "以及確保基金的運作穩健" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/293.wav", + "text": "這些法益上面的平衡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/294.wav", + "text": "可能需要比較長的時間討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/295.wav", + "text": "一些已經達成共識的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/296.wav", + "text": "譬如42" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/297.wav", + "text": "已經做出回應了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/298.wav", + "text": "就是要取消上限的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/299.wav", + "text": "在還沒有達到退休年齡之前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/300.wav", + "text": "就要領回" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/301.wav", + "text": "除了一次領回之外" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/302.wav", + "text": "也可以改為領月退" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/303.wav", + "text": "不要讓錢一次就統統被領走而消失" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/304.wav", + "text": "了這些其實都已經有些共識" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/305.wav", + "text": "我是建議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/306.wav", + "text": "如果遇到爭議的條文而且討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/307.wav", + "text": "沒有結論我們就暫保留往下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/308.wav", + "text": "接下來請鄭委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/309.wav", + "text": "謝謝院長還有所有與會同仁所有的部會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/310.wav", + "text": "針對第3條的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/311.wav", + "text": "我們覺得讓公務人員跟公教人員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/312.wav", + "text": "面臨的處境完全不同" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/313.wav", + "text": "我們覺得讓所有的公務人員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/314.wav", + "text": "跟公教人員有選擇權" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/315.wav", + "text": "如這樣做的時候到底有多少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/316.wav", + "text": "這裡面用了幾個假設數字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/317.wav", + "text": "包括三分之一二分之一" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/318.wav", + "text": "退撫基金第8次精算報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/319.wav", + "text": "選擇月退的公教人員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/320.wav", + "text": "選擇月退的公務人員大概占96%" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/321.wav", + "text": "我看到的數字是這樣子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/322.wav", + "text": "那麼地精準跟確實" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/323.wav", + "text": "幾個提案我發現" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/324.wav", + "text": "同樣的共識我們在這部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/325.wav", + "text": "都覺得應該讓所有的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/326.wav", + "text": "公務人員跟公教人員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/327.wav", + "text": "選擇權我覺得這是很重要的一部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/328.wav", + "text": "之前處理勞退的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/329.wav", + "text": "也是讓他們有選擇權" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/330.wav", + "text": "能讓所有的公務跟公教人員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/331.wav", + "text": "大家都還記得嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/332.wav", + "text": "所以新舊制轉銜的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/333.wav", + "text": "舊制的保障跟保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/334.wav", + "text": "一直是個大問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/335.wav", + "text": "採取缺口的分年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/336.wav", + "text": "撥補" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/337.wav", + "text": "分年撥補的比例是什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/338.wav", + "text": "這會影響到現職" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/339.wav", + "text": "公教同仁願不願意轉新制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/340.wav", + "text": "看是考試院或是哪一位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/341.wav", + "text": "要處理一下保留跟" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/342.wav", + "text": "得到大家的支持是很" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/343.wav", + "text": "關鍵的第二個是選擇" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/344.wav", + "text": "最近問很多公務同仁" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/345.wav", + "text": "年資深淺確實會影響" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/346.wav", + "text": "選擇所以到底是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/347.wav", + "text": "3年還是5年可選擇" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/348.wav", + "text": "這也涉及到現在財務" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/349.wav", + "text": "未來保障制度的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/350.wav", + "text": "期間內同時足額提撥" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/351.wav", + "text": "那就是保障年資" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/352.wav", + "text": "深的人如果你是後面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/353.wav", + "text": "比較資淺的人看得到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/354.wav", + "text": "他留在舊制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/355.wav", + "text": "就覺得有保障" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/356.wav", + "text": "幾個委員在說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/357.wav", + "text": "就這個制度是不是要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/358.wav", + "text": "逐條進行但我覺得應該把" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/359.wav", + "text": "整個配套報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/360.wav", + "text": "清楚再進行才會比較周延" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/361.wav", + "text": "因為一條一條看其實不知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/362.wav", + "text": "前後之間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/363.wav", + "text": "的利害關係是什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/364.wav", + "text": "所以我建議修法討論應該不" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/365.wav", + "text": "只有逐條的作" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/366.wav", + "text": "還有沒有其他意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/367.wav", + "text": "院長各位同仁" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/368.wav", + "text": "及各部會首長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/369.wav", + "text": "主要的問題在於" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/370.wav", + "text": "適用對象是1" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/371.wav", + "text": "112年7月1日以後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/372.wav", + "text": "初次依公務人員任用法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/373.wav", + "text": "及其相關法律任用的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/374.wav", + "text": "到底你要讓這些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/375.wav", + "text": "時間點以後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/376.wav", + "text": "跟國家的法律關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/377.wav", + "text": "係是個人專戶制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/378.wav", + "text": "的退休撫卹" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/379.wav", + "text": "還是過去本來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/380.wav", + "text": "已經有一個制度而你要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/381.wav", + "text": "改變這樣的法律關係" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/382.wav", + "text": "並讓他們也可以適用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/383.wav", + "text": "你的政策決定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/384.wav", + "text": "的考量因素何在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/385.wav", + "text": "也許是國家財政的考量" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/386.wav", + "text": "或者是各種信賴保護的考量" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/387.wav", + "text": "等等之類的我覺得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/388.wav", + "text": "作出這樣的政策決定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/389.wav", + "text": "之最終根據何在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/390.wav", + "text": "這個當初106年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/391.wav", + "text": "這個問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/392.wav", + "text": "曾經討論過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/393.wav", + "text": "也爭辯過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/394.wav", + "text": "當初行政院送來的案子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/395.wav", + "text": "並沒有要建立" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/396.wav", + "text": "後來在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/397.wav", + "text": "增加一個當然外面有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/398.wav", + "text": "人在遊說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/399.wav", + "text": "後來也立了法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/400.wav", + "text": "從" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/401.wav", + "text": "112年7月1日開始" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/402.wav", + "text": "用新制來處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/403.wav", + "text": "建立了一個新的制度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/404.wav", + "text": "沒有所謂選擇權的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/405.wav", + "text": "\n我們談選擇權的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/406.wav", + "text": "要討論哪幾個面向" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/407.wav", + "text": "到底哪些人有選擇權" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/408.wav", + "text": "要怎麼去切" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/409.wav", + "text": "誰可以人數" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/410.wav", + "text": "還有整個財務狀況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/411.wav", + "text": "造成舊制的衝擊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/412.wav", + "text": "慮到底這個制度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/413.wav", + "text": "要怎麼建立要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/414.wav", + "text": "討論到未來整個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/415.wav", + "text": "制度的穩定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/416.wav", + "text": "與財務方面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/417.wav", + "text": "當然假如這個新制以後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/418.wav", + "text": "監理等等包括" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/419.wav", + "text": "政府應該" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/420.wav", + "text": "這都可以討論的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/421.wav", + "text": "但是現在我們從" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/422.wav", + "text": "一開始的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/423.wav", + "text": "大家就為了吵這個選擇權的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/424.wav", + "text": "我就覺得似乎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/425.wav", + "text": "過去一開始的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/426.wav", + "text": "的立法意旨完全不一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/427.wav", + "text": "我們是討論一個新的制度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/428.wav", + "text": "你要再回到過去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/429.wav", + "text": "然後再夾雜" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/430.wav", + "text": "要有高度共識可能" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/431.wav", + "text": "沒有那麼簡單" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/432.wav", + "text": "這是我的看法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/433.wav", + "text": "我剛剛仔細聽了一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/434.wav", + "text": "也談到按月撥補" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/435.wav", + "text": "包括監理的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/436.wav", + "text": "但是他對選擇權" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/437.wav", + "text": "也相當保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/438.wav", + "text": "啊不到3年以下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/439.wav", + "text": "所以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/440.wav", + "text": "5年以下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/441.wav", + "text": "為什麼不是1年2年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/442.wav", + "text": "就財務結構設計上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/443.wav", + "text": "我覺得會極度不穩定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/444.wav", + "text": "要不要這個先保留一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/445.wav", + "text": "暫時保留好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/446.wav", + "text": "會再回來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/447.wav", + "text": "會再回來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/448.wav", + "text": "好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/449.wav", + "text": "來當作財務影響的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/450.wav", + "text": "九成是用月退的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/451.wav", + "text": "式你們這個用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/452.wav", + "text": "林委員比較注意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/453.wav", + "text": "我們往下走再講好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/454.wav", + "text": "等到第三案的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/455.wav", + "text": "我們會討論到教育人員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/456.wav", + "text": "這應該OK吧" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/457.wav", + "text": "先處理但是資料" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/458.wav", + "text": "同時要準備給我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/459.wav", + "text": "等一下說明給你聽" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/460.wav", + "text": "我們一個問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/461.wav", + "text": "不能跳到後面的案子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/462.wav", + "text": "就是第3條的依據" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/463.wav", + "text": "第3條的依據就是這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/464.wav", + "text": "我知道有些部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/465.wav", + "text": "有些團體有些意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/466.wav", + "text": "後來他們也整合認為這個也不宜" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/467.wav", + "text": "其實公教是連動的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/468.wav", + "text": "可是因為我提老師" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/469.wav", + "text": "沒提公務人員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/470.wav", + "text": "可是我覺得其實心態上可以開放一點點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/471.wav", + "text": "因為兩者是一樣的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/472.wav", + "text": "資料要給就一起給" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/473.wav", + "text": "只是說只給一次退休金" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/474.wav", + "text": "林委員要的資料你們儘量提供" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/475.wav", + "text": "等一下還會回頭來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/476.wav", + "text": "以給我們進行第6條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/477.wav", + "text": "第6條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/478.wav", + "text": "好像大家有沒有意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/479.wav", + "text": "嘛沒有意見就照考試院提案通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/480.wav", + "text": "第6條是在講監理機關的組成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/481.wav", + "text": "對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/482.wav", + "text": "版是只有專家代表" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/483.wav", + "text": "機關代表" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/484.wav", + "text": "還有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/485.wav", + "text": "專業的人員代表" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/486.wav", + "text": "過去勞退專戶的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/487.wav", + "text": "基金還有勞保" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/488.wav", + "text": "基金" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/489.wav", + "text": "你們現在是不是只有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/490.wav", + "text": "機關代表教職員代表專家代表" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/491.wav", + "text": "公立學校" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/492.wav", + "text": "教職員代表" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/493.wav", + "text": "還是公務員部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/494.wav", + "text": "兩個一起兩個都一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/495.wav", + "text": "嘛所以我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/496.wav", + "text": "建議是不是可以有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/497.wav", + "text": "協會等這種代表" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/498.wav", + "text": "的組成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/499.wav", + "text": "會列入公務人員代表這個沒問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/500.wav", + "text": "公務人員代表也有協會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/501.wav", + "text": "現況就是這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/502.wav", + "text": "所以跟教師的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/503.wav", + "text": "不能併看現在要分頭看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/504.wav", + "text": "瞭解" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/505.wav", + "text": "林委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/506.wav", + "text": "因為事實上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/507.wav", + "text": "兩者是相關的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/508.wav", + "text": "一起討論也有助於主席" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/509.wav", + "text": "到時候一起做決定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/510.wav", + "text": "因為不太可能公" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/511.wav", + "text": "警消是一個制度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/512.wav", + "text": "而老師是一個制度應該" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/513.wav", + "text": "會是連動的所以我就" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/514.wav", + "text": "一起來看兩個的相關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/515.wav", + "text": "\n我們主張" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/516.wav", + "text": "能夠減至越少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/517.wav", + "text": "越好就是政府退出" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/518.wav", + "text": "新儲金的管理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/519.wav", + "text": "就是教職員代表" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/520.wav", + "text": "及教職員推薦專家代表" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/521.wav", + "text": "人數不得少於總數" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/522.wav", + "text": "讓相關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/523.wav", + "text": "權力來做相關的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/524.wav", + "text": "監管所以這個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/525.wav", + "text": "應該是跟行政院版本比較不一樣的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/526.wav", + "text": "角色越少越好不然" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/527.wav", + "text": "每次都是政府角色很大" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/528.wav", + "text": "到後來出現問題之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/529.wav", + "text": "基本上乾脆讓相關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/530.wav", + "text": "的成員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/531.wav", + "text": "為例的話就是希望教職員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/532.wav", + "text": "代表及教職員推薦專家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/533.wav", + "text": "代表人數不得少於總數" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/534.wav", + "text": "二分之一這是我的版本謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/535.wav", + "text": "談公務人員好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/536.wav", + "text": "一起談這兩個是一樣的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/537.wav", + "text": "這一條是一樣的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/538.wav", + "text": "對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/539.wav", + "text": "公教人員跟公務人員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/540.wav", + "text": "的團體他們都" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/541.wav", + "text": "主張要公開透明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/542.wav", + "text": "長得一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/543.wav", + "text": "說明一下好了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/544.wav", + "text": "公務人員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/545.wav", + "text": "文字上不太一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/546.wav", + "text": "意思一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/547.wav", + "text": "嘛\n文字絕對長得不一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/548.wav", + "text": "啊先談" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/549.wav", + "text": "第6條對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/550.wav", + "text": "現在就是講第6條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/551.wav", + "text": "第6條是不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/552.wav", + "text": "就照考試院提案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/553.wav", + "text": "這個茲事體大" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/554.wav", + "text": "那些人都不必負責" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/555.wav", + "text": "也不可能" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/556.wav", + "text": "團體進來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/557.wav", + "text": "那是不是政府應該要負最後的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/558.wav", + "text": "當然" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/559.wav", + "text": "最後一定是政府負責" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/560.wav", + "text": "是不是應該要負" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/561.wav", + "text": "你也要提前撥補" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/562.wav", + "text": "一條一條來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/563.wav", + "text": "郭國文委員好像也有來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/564.wav", + "text": "提案的委員當時" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/565.wav", + "text": "應該在委員會審查時都有表達過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/566.wav", + "text": "了比較綜合性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/567.wav", + "text": "的來看考試院現在是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/568.wav", + "text": "不準備採取任何" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/569.wav", + "text": "其他委員的建議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/570.wav", + "text": "就照他們的版本還是考試院有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/571.wav", + "text": "綜整看過其他建議之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/572.wav", + "text": "酌修文字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/573.wav", + "text": "所以我們提的跟幾個委員的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/574.wav", + "text": "類似就是如果以公務人員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/575.wav", + "text": "的為例我們希望它的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/576.wav", + "text": "機關代表公務人員代表以及具" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/577.wav", + "text": "統計精算財經或法律" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/578.wav", + "text": "與不入法你們有沒有什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/579.wav", + "text": "委員大概都是著重在精算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/580.wav", + "text": "財務法務法律背景" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/581.wav", + "text": "這個更嚴謹的去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/582.wav", + "text": "修正我覺得對於新制的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/583.wav", + "text": "公務員來講比較能夠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/584.wav", + "text": "確保因為如果是新制未來的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/585.wav", + "text": "個人帳戶" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/586.wav", + "text": "包括什麼保守型穩健型" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/587.wav", + "text": "積極型" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/588.wav", + "text": "類此種種都涉及到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/589.wav", + "text": "比較專業性的那這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/590.wav", + "text": "委員會的監理就不是過去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/591.wav", + "text": "那種退撫大水庫之類的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/592.wav", + "text": "代表性裡面可以酌" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/593.wav", + "text": "就精算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/594.wav", + "text": "統計財政等文字入法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/595.wav", + "text": "這個等一下請考試院說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/596.wav", + "text": "我的版本也是這樣子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/597.wav", + "text": "所以朝野都有類似的版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/598.wav", + "text": "我們當然希望" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/599.wav", + "text": "專家學者的範圍" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/600.wav", + "text": "可以更彈性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/601.wav", + "text": "因為現在如果訂死是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/602.wav", + "text": "統計精算財務或法律" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/603.wav", + "text": "它就必須要在委員裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/604.wav", + "text": "占一定比例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/605.wav", + "text": "相對來講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/606.wav", + "text": "參與的機會當然就少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/607.wav", + "text": "所以我們也可以在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/608.wav", + "text": "辦法裡面詳細去訂" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/609.wav", + "text": "在組成的時候比較容易組織" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/610.wav", + "text": "其實以公務人員來講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/611.wav", + "text": "退撫基金的負責管理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/612.wav", + "text": "全部都是公務人員在管" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/613.wav", + "text": "各政府機關代表派的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/614.wav", + "text": "也都是現職公務人員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/615.wav", + "text": "所以就公務人員這部分來講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/616.wav", + "text": "公務人員代表機關代表" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/617.wav", + "text": "其實大家都很兢兢業業的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/618.wav", + "text": "建立退休撫恤金這個比較沒有問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/619.wav", + "text": "都是利害關係人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/620.wav", + "text": "至於專家學者主要是組成方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/621.wav", + "text": "看能不能稍微不要訂那麼死" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/622.wav", + "text": "因為一旦訂下去以後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/623.wav", + "text": "就非得要有這些背景的人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/624.wav", + "text": "會排擠到其他可能需要的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/625.wav", + "text": "讓我們彈性稍微大一點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/626.wav", + "text": "將來我們再訂這個辦法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/627.wav", + "text": "公務人員監理委員會組成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/628.wav", + "text": "也是比較彈性的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/629.wav", + "text": "不是直接在法律上把這些專業" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/630.wav", + "text": "就訂死了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/631.wav", + "text": "所以是不是可以給我們一點彈性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/632.wav", + "text": "讓我們來組" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/633.wav", + "text": "讓各位委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/634.wav", + "text": "主席" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/635.wav", + "text": "就我對制度上的理解" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/636.wav", + "text": "提供給大家參考" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/637.wav", + "text": "在監理委員會層級" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/638.wav", + "text": "它某個程度在代表性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/639.wav", + "text": "上會比功能性的比重" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/640.wav", + "text": "還來得重要一點點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/641.wav", + "text": "所以利害關係人的法人代表" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/642.wav", + "text": "基本上有納入的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/643.wav", + "text": "也占有一個比較大的比重" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/644.wav", + "text": "從其組成我們其實看得出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/645.wav", + "text": "是比較屬於功能性的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/646.wav", + "text": "功能性的部分也占有一定比例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/647.wav", + "text": "是不要把它訂得這麼死" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/648.wav", + "text": "大家可以考量一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/649.wav", + "text": "應該大於功能性會比較好一點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/650.wav", + "text": "坦白講現在幾個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/651.wav", + "text": "個別委員的版本針對學者專家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/652.wav", + "text": "部分是寫得滿死的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/653.wav", + "text": "就是學者專家只能是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/654.wav", + "text": "統計精算財經或法律等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/655.wav", + "text": "實務背景之專家學者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/656.wav", + "text": "沒有其他的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/657.wav", + "text": "你們現在這個構想裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/658.wav", + "text": "你們有可能邀聘他" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/659.wav", + "text": "他加入這個委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/660.wav", + "text": "還是說你們實務上就只有這幾類專家而已" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/661.wav", + "text": "沒有其實還有很多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/662.wav", + "text": "有關退撫基金的專家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/663.wav", + "text": "即有關退撫制度的專家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/664.wav", + "text": "那個基本上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/665.wav", + "text": "公共行政等等對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/666.wav", + "text": "社會背景的專家也有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/667.wav", + "text": "保險背景的也有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/668.wav", + "text": "所以我們基本上還需要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/669.wav", + "text": "滿多元的不是只有這三類而已" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/670.wav", + "text": "我的看法是這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/671.wav", + "text": "不管民進黨或國民黨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/672.wav", + "text": "source還是一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/673.wav", + "text": "因為文字寫得一樣應該就是外面團體來的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/674.wav", + "text": "source大" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/675.wav", + "text": "大家講白話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/676.wav", + "text": "張廖萬堅委員的版本還是一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/677.wav", + "text": "嘛大家都都是同一個source來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/678.wav", + "text": "的我們今天在這裡要很冷靜地" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/679.wav", + "text": "來面對這個問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/680.wav", + "text": "這裡面包括保險都沒有寫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/681.wav", + "text": "銓敘部有回答" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/682.wav", + "text": "我覺得應該就是照行政院版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/683.wav", + "text": "不要把它訂死" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/684.wav", + "text": "以後他們在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/685.wav", + "text": "組織法上面會寫嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/686.wav", + "text": "這一題應該不必很爭辯" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/687.wav", + "text": "因為這都" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/688.wav", + "text": "這麼久了該怎麼樣子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/689.wav", + "text": "子法都會定得很清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/690.wav", + "text": "各位有什麼相關意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/691.wav", + "text": "它應該都會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/692.wav", + "text": "納入才對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/693.wav", + "text": "但是我們這裡列舉性的太死了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/694.wav", + "text": "監理會的組成人員以外" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/695.wav", + "text": "其實所有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/696.wav", + "text": "在職的公務人員跟公教人員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/697.wav", + "text": "他們在意的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/698.wav", + "text": "還有一項是實質監督" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/699.wav", + "text": "就是實質監督" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/700.wav", + "text": "考核我覺得銓敘" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/701.wav", + "text": "也應該要說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/702.wav", + "text": "以及監理的組成到底有沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/703.wav", + "text": "實權可以來考核" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/704.wav", + "text": "績效以及未來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/705.wav", + "text": "能夠提高整個監理的效能" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/706.wav", + "text": "人員跟公教人員他們在意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/707.wav", + "text": "是不是能夠達到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/708.wav", + "text": "績效能夠保障他們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/709.wav", + "text": "嘛這個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/710.wav", + "text": "在新的制度裡面你們怎麼訂的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/711.wav", + "text": "應該也要說明給所有的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/712.wav", + "text": "公務人員和公教人員瞭解" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/713.wav", + "text": "好大家意見不一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/714.wav", + "text": "\n請部長說明一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/715.wav", + "text": "事項程序和人員組成會有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/716.wav", + "text": "另外一個法規命令來做進一步的規範" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/717.wav", + "text": "我們希望在那個地方" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/718.wav", + "text": "把它定清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/719.wav", + "text": "我們現行的公務人員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/720.wav", + "text": "業務跟職責將來就" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/721.wav", + "text": "會比照我們都會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/722.wav", + "text": "我剛才提出的應該很明顯" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/723.wav", + "text": "就是希望銓敘部可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/724.wav", + "text": "有別於以往的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/725.wav", + "text": "新的監理機制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/726.wav", + "text": "因為過去所有的公教人員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/727.wav", + "text": "跟公務人員他們質疑" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/728.wav", + "text": "的是整個退休" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/729.wav", + "text": "機制不夠彰顯" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/730.wav", + "text": "沒有辦法讓整個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/731.wav", + "text": "儲金的效率提升" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/732.wav", + "text": "我覺得銓敘部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/733.wav", + "text": "應該要讓所有的公務人員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/734.wav", + "text": "他們可以清楚地瞭解" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/735.wav", + "text": "你們未來的監理機制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/736.wav", + "text": "提高這個基金運用的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/737.wav", + "text": "效率" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/738.wav", + "text": "提到第6條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/739.wav", + "text": "現行沒有所謂考核的制度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/740.wav", + "text": "所以我們大家的各" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/741.wav", + "text": "版本都有提到考核" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/742.wav", + "text": "二字請教現在的監理機關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/743.wav", + "text": "的部分是怎麼做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/744.wav", + "text": "文字是在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/745.wav", + "text": "辦法還是哪個機制裡面有考核" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/746.wav", + "text": "要說明一下嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/747.wav", + "text": "那個考核是指" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/748.wav", + "text": "績效考核" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/749.wav", + "text": "法工作表現的考核" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/750.wav", + "text": "基金操作的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/751.wav", + "text": "績效考核" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/752.wav", + "text": "不是公務人員的考核是基金操作的考核" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/753.wav", + "text": "操作的成果都還要報監理會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/754.wav", + "text": "監理會都有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/755.wav", + "text": "很明確定期的考核" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/756.wav", + "text": "這個是沒有問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/757.wav", + "text": "可是問題是大家對於現行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/758.wav", + "text": "不彰的問題非常在意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/759.wav", + "text": "所以希望有新的考核" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/760.wav", + "text": "我們公務人員退休撫卹基金的績效" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/761.wav", + "text": "並不是太差" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/762.wav", + "text": "過去長久以來公務員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/763.wav", + "text": "會有一個錯誤印象" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/764.wav", + "text": "那是早期的印象其實我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/765.wav", + "text": "目前操作" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/766.wav", + "text": "不會比私立學校退撫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/767.wav", + "text": "基金差" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/768.wav", + "text": "甚至我們今年���表現比他們好很多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/769.wav", + "text": "就退撫基金長期來看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/770.wav", + "text": "到去年為止" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/771.wav", + "text": "平均投報率" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/772.wav", + "text": "我意思是說如果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/773.wav", + "text": "你們的績效不錯" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/774.wav", + "text": "就可以訂出一個新的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/775.wav", + "text": "透明公開地" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/776.wav", + "text": "公教人員都可以清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/777.wav", + "text": "瞭解不是現行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/778.wav", + "text": "你們的制度不夠透明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/779.wav", + "text": "公務及公教人員無法瞭解" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/780.wav", + "text": "他們要求要一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/781.wav", + "text": "問題癥結點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/782.wav", + "text": "我簡單講一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/783.wav", + "text": "公務人員也好教職人員也好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/784.wav", + "text": "負責最後的2%" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/785.wav", + "text": "給付的話他們會覺得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/786.wav", + "text": "監理由你們來做也OK" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/787.wav", + "text": "說服大家的也就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/788.wav", + "text": "謝衣鳯委員剛剛一直提到的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/789.wav", + "text": "長年來說你們的績效" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/790.wav", + "text": "並沒有比私校的還差這個我承認" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/791.wav", + "text": "可是我們從新聞" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/792.wav", + "text": "至少要舉個例子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/793.wav", + "text": "監督避免我們在新聞上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/794.wav", + "text": "看到這些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/795.wav", + "text": "不好的事件再次發生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/796.wav", + "text": "是不是我們往下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/797.wav", + "text": "沒有意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/798.wav", + "text": "第7條如果沒有意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/799.wav", + "text": "我們就照考試院的意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/800.wav", + "text": "通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/801.wav", + "text": "有意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/802.wav", + "text": "請吳委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/803.wav", + "text": "沒關係啊現在是確定提撥" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/804.wav", + "text": "給付的多或少至少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/805.wav", + "text": "是2%嘛對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/806.wav", + "text": "我們當初也" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/807.wav", + "text": "如果舊制績效大概可以維持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/808.wav", + "text": "也就是說盈虧自負" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/809.wav", + "text": "你就讓他自己來管" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/810.wav", + "text": "自己的風險自己承擔" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/811.wav", + "text": "私校也是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/812.wav", + "text": "這樣做所以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/813.wav", + "text": "教職員也好公務人員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/814.wav", + "text": "自己來管由你們來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/815.wav", + "text": "監督這沒有問題再來如果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/816.wav", + "text": "由你們管由你們監督到底是誰" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/817.wav", + "text": "在管誰在監督誰在監督誰誰在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/818.wav", + "text": "管誰啊這有點分不清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/819.wav", + "text": "我想第7條的部分大概" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/820.wav", + "text": "一樣是個人帳戶私校管理委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/821.wav", + "text": "的成員可以完全由繳費" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/822.wav", + "text": "關係人擔任但是公校卻不行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/823.wav", + "text": "這樣公校教師" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/824.wav", + "text": "的人權是不是跟私校" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/825.wav", + "text": "私校之間有點落差" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/826.wav", + "text": "管理委員會主委是由銓敘部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/827.wav", + "text": "的部長兼任而監理會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/828.wav", + "text": "是由考試院副院長兼任" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/829.wav", + "text": "都是考試院的官員會不會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/830.wav", + "text": "員兼裁判的問題這部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/831.wav", + "text": "我想等一下應該要說明第三個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/832.wav", + "text": "這最重要私校退撫基金" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/833.wav", + "text": "因為自己的退休金自己管" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/834.wav", + "text": "所以不容有舞弊的空間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/835.wav", + "text": "但是最大的特色在於" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/836.wav", + "text": "公布一次性的績效請問" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/837.wav", + "text": "主席" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/838.wav", + "text": "其實是第6條延伸的因為第6條是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/839.wav", + "text": "是關於公務人員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/840.wav", + "text": "退休撫卹基金管理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/841.wav", + "text": "機關的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/842.wav", + "text": "針對這部分我有更具體" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/843.wav", + "text": "審酌儲金規模情況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/844.wav", + "text": "輔導各機關及公務人員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/845.wav", + "text": "代表組成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/846.wav", + "text": "儲金管理委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/847.wav", + "text": "把公務人員代表納入組成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/848.wav", + "text": "進去在儲金管理委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/849.wav", + "text": "的成員當中我們也希望由公務人員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/850.wav", + "text": "代表及依法成立之公務人員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/851.wav", + "text": "團體所推薦之專家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/852.wav", + "text": "學者代表不少於總數" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/853.wav", + "text": "的三分之二此外" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/854.wav", + "text": "此外儲金管理委員會的任期是3年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/855.wav", + "text": "得連任一次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/856.wav", + "text": "中華民國私立學校教職員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/857.wav", + "text": "退休撫卹離職" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/858.wav", + "text": "他們是更透明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/859.wav", + "text": "更清楚地讓大家知道情況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/860.wav", + "text": "所以我們也希望公務人員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/861.wav", + "text": "這部分是不是能夠比照對此我在後面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/862.wav", + "text": "甚至還補了一段文字即" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/863.wav", + "text": "退撫基金管理機構未成立前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/864.wav", + "text": "得委託" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/865.wav", + "text": "財團法人中華民國私立學校" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/866.wav", + "text": "教職員退休撫卹離職" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/867.wav", + "text": "資遣儲金管理委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/868.wav", + "text": "之這部分就是因為之前已經有私校" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/869.wav", + "text": "成績擺在這邊基本上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/870.wav", + "text": "是滿意的至少我們還沒有看到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/871.wav", + "text": "有太多的抱怨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/872.wav", + "text": "這是一個新制我們也希望這種抱怨能夠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/873.wav", + "text": "減少在公務體系中不要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/874.wav", + "text": "再出現像之前的抱怨因為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/875.wav", + "text": "整個管理的狀態" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/876.wav", + "text": "確實出現很多新聞事件" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/877.wav", + "text": "讓很多的人都很擔心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/878.wav", + "text": "所以我們希望透過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/879.wav", + "text": "這樣一個新的制度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/880.wav", + "text": "後續就比較不會有一些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/881.wav", + "text": "謝謝主席" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/882.wav", + "text": "就是一樣的條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/883.wav", + "text": "在精神" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/884.wav", + "text": "上跟剛才很多委員的意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/885.wav", + "text": "也是雷同的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/886.wav", + "text": "也就是說剛剛第6條講的是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/887.wav", + "text": "監理機制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/888.wav", + "text": "跟以前比起來可能多了公務人員代表" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/889.wav", + "text": "但還是沒有寫到比例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/890.wav", + "text": "是多少我一直認為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/891.wav", + "text": "機關代表不等於是公務人員代表" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/892.wav", + "text": "因為機關代表代表" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/893.wav", + "text": "的是機關公務人員代表" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/894.wav", + "text": "才是真正代表公務人員\n" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/895.wav", + "text": "的部分也是一樣的概念除" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/896.wav", + "text": "的部分剛剛有提到我們還是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/897.wav", + "text": "看還是以政府" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/898.wav", + "text": "所以我們希望在公務人員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/899.wav", + "text": "部分能夠籌組" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/900.wav", + "text": "中華民國公務" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/901.wav", + "text": "人員退休撫卹儲金" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/902.wav", + "text": "管理委員會而成員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/903.wav", + "text": "代表及依法成立之公務人員團體" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/904.wav", + "text": "所推薦之專家學者代表" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/905.wav", + "text": "不少於總數的三分之二" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/906.wav", + "text": "學校的部分一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/907.wav", + "text": "是成立中華民國公立學校教職員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/908.wav", + "text": "退休撫卹儲金管理委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/909.wav", + "text": "這部分是一樣的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/910.wav", + "text": "我們希望公立學校教職員代表及" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/911.wav", + "text": "依法成立之公立學校教職員團體" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/912.wav", + "text": "所推薦之專家學者代表不少於" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/913.wav", + "text": "總數的三分之二" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/914.wav", + "text": "是任期制即3年得連任一次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/915.wav", + "text": "的第6條跟行政院版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/916.wav", + "text": "很不一樣的地方" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/917.wav", + "text": "也回歸到主要的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/918.wav", + "text": "相關利害關係人請柯" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/919.wav", + "text": "第7條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/920.wav", + "text": "管理機關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/921.wav", + "text": "都長得一樣都是同一個來源來遊說的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/922.wav", + "text": "你要把它改成財團法人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/923.wav", + "text": "在還沒有改為財團法人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/924.wav", + "text": "以前要委託給私校財團法人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/925.wav", + "text": "去做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/926.wav", + "text": "我想兩邊制度設計的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/927.wav", + "text": "十幾年前修正時是我在處理的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/928.wav", + "text": "能夠建立" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/929.wav", + "text": "也是這個行業出身" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/930.wav", + "text": "是銀行方面的嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/931.wav", + "text": "發生人為的弊病" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/932.wav", + "text": "沒有一個制度不會發生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/933.wav", + "text": "人為的弊病" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/934.wav", + "text": "包括政府機關也一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/935.wav", + "text": "委託給私校後私校再委託給外面的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/936.wav", + "text": "投顧公司" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/937.wav", + "text": "這些一定會有問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/938.wav", + "text": "所以就是你的選擇問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/939.wav", + "text": "選擇看是要穩定型的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/940.wav", + "text": "保守型的或是績效型的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/941.wav", + "text": "但是到最後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/942.wav", + "text": "絕對都不會很好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/943.wav", + "text": "不是大眾想像得那麼好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/944.wav", + "text": "所以像私校現在也在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/945.wav", + "text": "檢討" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/946.wav", + "text": "因為整體表現有時是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/947.wav", + "text": "輸給一個平均值" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/948.wav", + "text": "所以這部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/949.wav", + "text": "大家要想清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/950.wav", + "text": "財團法人的樣態" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/951.wav", + "text": "過去也有人談到行政法人的樣態" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/952.wav", + "text": "財團法人樣態" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/953.wav", + "text": "可是實際上他們真的做得很好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/954.wav", + "text": "值得討論\n" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/955.wav", + "text": "這一題外面的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/956.wav", + "text": "但是制度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/957.wav", + "text": "成立這麼久以來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/958.wav", + "text": "被挑戰的也不少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/959.wav", + "text": "當然我們的勞金局也會發生問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/960.wav", + "text": "所有的都一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/961.wav", + "text": "人為的東西" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/962.wav", + "text": "沒有一個制度能夠完全" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/963.wav", + "text": "不可能請" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/964.wav", + "text": "請邱總召" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/965.wav", + "text": "對這種監理或是管理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/966.wav", + "text": "組織的信任" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/967.wav", + "text": "就有兩種嘛要嘛就是它" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/968.wav", + "text": "它來自公眾的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/969.wav", + "text": "就像銓敘部許多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/970.wav", + "text": "也難說哪一種方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/971.wav", + "text": "的監理制度孰" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/972.wav", + "text": "孰優孰劣我覺得是各有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/973.wav", + "text": "是你在做這樣的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/974.wav", + "text": "為什麼選擇A而不選擇B" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/975.wav", + "text": "路徑而且選擇這樣的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/976.wav", + "text": "能夠儘可能減少它所產生的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/977.wav", + "text": "制度裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/978.wav", + "text": "或多或少都有可能會發生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/979.wav", + "text": "大家也同意只是你如何" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/980.wav", + "text": "能夠在儘可能的範圍之內" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/981.wav", + "text": "法的目的就是要預先" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/982.wav", + "text": "讓這樣的生活事實發生時" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/983.wav", + "text": "應該可以讓相關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/984.wav", + "text": "接下來是謝衣鳯委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/985.wav", + "text": "仍然沒有共識的話我們就暫時" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/986.wav", + "text": "保留然後往後走亦即全部走一趟" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/987.wav", + "text": "謝委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/988.wav", + "text": "管理基金的處理不一定比較好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/989.wav", + "text": "我們也可以認同" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/990.wav", + "text": "管理委員會主委由銓敘部部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/991.wav", + "text": "監理會主委由考試院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/992.wav", + "text": "12月6日陳瑞敏" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/993.wav", + "text": "審計長在委員會說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/994.wav", + "text": "撥補公務人員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/995.wav", + "text": "基金是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/996.wav", + "text": "285億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/997.wav", + "text": "公教職員基金" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/998.wav", + "text": "是236億的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/999.wav", + "text": "減少未來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1000.wav", + "text": "政府要支出7,000億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1001.wav", + "text": "那是不是現在就" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1002.wav", + "text": "提出撥補" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1003.wav", + "text": "我覺得柯總召可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1004.wav", + "text": "你處理私校基金的方法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1005.wav", + "text": "來做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1006.wav", + "text": "提前撥補的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1007.wav", + "text": "會減少未來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1008.wav", + "text": "7,000億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1009.wav", + "text": "每年撥補多少可以討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1010.wav", + "text": "但不是把所有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1011.wav", + "text": "金額全部提前撥補出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1012.wav", + "text": "我是指285億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1013.wav", + "text": "和236億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1014.wav", + "text": "撥補沒有辦法一次撥補" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1015.wav", + "text": "因為這種制度面的關係" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1016.wav", + "text": "基金管理的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1017.wav", + "text": "制度上的實驗" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1018.wav", + "text": "那是把它弄成一個財團" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1019.wav", + "text": "部分是比較偏行政機關的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1020.wav", + "text": "如果依照行政機關的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1021.wav", + "text": "組成來做一個管理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1022.wav", + "text": "行政機關的關聯性越高" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1023.wav", + "text": "究責的可能性越高" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1024.wav", + "text": "這個意見提供給你做參考" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1025.wav", + "text": "其實除非" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1026.wav", + "text": "讓所有利害關係人自行去操作" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1027.wav", + "text": "代操模式不論是基金管理局" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1028.wav", + "text": "基本上都選擇代操代操還是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1029.wav", + "text": "找另外一群人來進行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1030.wav", + "text": "基金的操作也不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1031.wav", + "text": "這些組成人員或者是行政機關的人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1032.wav", + "text": "其實後端的模式都是一樣的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1033.wav", + "text": "這裡有個問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1034.wav", + "text": "公務人員管理部分一旦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1035.wav", + "text": "有問題時至少他們還有貪污治罪條例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1036.wav", + "text": "到最後貪污治罪條例都用不上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1037.wav", + "text": "財團法人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1038.wav", + "text": "連公務人員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1039.wav", + "text": "相關的貪瀆條例都用不上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1040.wav", + "text": "一個制度的變革���想清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1041.wav", + "text": "到最後還是委託別人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1042.wav", + "text": "院長剛才說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1043.wav", + "text": "我是希望不要講等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1044.wav", + "text": "後再回頭好不" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1045.wav", + "text": "暫時保留我們先看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1046.wav", + "text": "第9條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1047.wav", + "text": "有協商建議條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1048.wav", + "text": "建議條文通過好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1049.wav", + "text": "建議條文通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1050.wav", + "text": "第9條也不行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1051.wav", + "text": "42年上限" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1052.wav", + "text": "對已經協商通過了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1053.wav", + "text": "第9條OK" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1054.wav", + "text": "家看第十一條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1055.wav", + "text": "現行公務人員明年就是提到請大家看第" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1056.wav", + "text": "十一條大家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1057.wav", + "text": "有什麼意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1058.wav", + "text": "十一條沒有意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1059.wav", + "text": "考試院提案通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1060.wav", + "text": "請看第十二條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1061.wav", + "text": "第十一條等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1062.wav", + "text": "第十二條有沒有意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1063.wav", + "text": "若沒有意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1064.wav", + "text": "照考試院提案通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1065.wav", + "text": "\n請看第十五條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1066.wav", + "text": "而且有建議條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1067.wav", + "text": "十五條是配合第九條的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1068.wav", + "text": "第十五條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1069.wav", + "text": "有建議條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1070.wav", + "text": "若沒有意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1071.wav", + "text": "第十五條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1072.wav", + "text": "照協商建議條文通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1073.wav", + "text": "請看第28條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1074.wav", + "text": "也是有協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1075.wav", + "text": "建議條文司" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1076.wav", + "text": "司法院有意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1077.wav", + "text": "列席單位司法院今天對於第2" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1078.wav", + "text": "第28條有提出書面意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1079.wav", + "text": "很不好意思我們在今天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1080.wav", + "text": "的立法體例就" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1081.wav", + "text": "月退休金部分公務員有三個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1082.wav", + "text": "第2款有三目" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1083.wav", + "text": "可以選攤提給付" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1084.wav", + "text": "保險年金司法院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1085.wav", + "text": "的意見主要是針對第三個選項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1086.wav", + "text": "在月退休金的概念下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1087.wav", + "text": "與���職公務人員退撫法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1088.wav", + "text": "月退休金就是國家給付" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1089.wav", + "text": "專戶裡面所有的金額" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1090.wav", + "text": "提清然後一次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1091.wav", + "text": "接下來就依照這個保險" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1092.wav", + "text": "契約的約定由保險公司" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1093.wav", + "text": "來定期給付保險" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1094.wav", + "text": "年金這樣一個給付" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1095.wav", + "text": "的性質其實已經不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1096.wav", + "text": "公法上的關係為什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1097.wav", + "text": "因為國家已經脫離了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1098.wav", + "text": "當公務員把專戶的錢領光了以後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1099.wav", + "text": "國家其實已脫離這個責任" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1100.wav", + "text": "也就是說國家不再去處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1101.wav", + "text": "後續依照保險" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1102.wav", + "text": "契約做定期給付的保險年金" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1103.wav", + "text": "部分我們認為這個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1104.wav", + "text": "跟月退休金並列" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1105.wav", + "text": "會讓公務員產生誤判" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1106.wav", + "text": "你的意思是說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1107.wav", + "text": "第2款有三目" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1108.wav", + "text": "第三目應該拉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1109.wav", + "text": "為另外一款" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1110.wav", + "text": "因為前面二目是國家的後面第三目" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1111.wav", + "text": "保險年金是私人的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1112.wav", + "text": "大家有沒有意見對司法院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1113.wav", + "text": "剛才的建議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1114.wav", + "text": "考試院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1115.wav", + "text": "考試院有沒有意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1116.wav", + "text": "基本上把這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1117.wav", + "text": "保險年金視為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1118.wav", + "text": "概念這部分在勞退" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1119.wav", + "text": "這樣設計的因為它是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1120.wav", + "text": "改換成用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1121.wav", + "text": "保險金做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1122.wav", + "text": "定期的給付" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1123.wav", + "text": "還是屬於我們這邊講的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1124.wav", + "text": "而且它不是讓公務員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1125.wav", + "text": "結清以後到市場上去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1126.wav", + "text": "這個保險年金是由我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1127.wav", + "text": "退撫基金管理機關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1128.wav", + "text": "因為這個是要特別設計" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1129.wav", + "text": "的有關保險年金的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1130.wav", + "text": "是不是能夠先" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1131.wav", + "text": "暫時維持因為它牽涉到好幾個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1132.wav", + "text": "條文而且這個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1133.wav", + "text": "不是很急迫要修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1134.wav", + "text": "因為新制上路以後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1135.wav", + "text": "起碼大概20年才會有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1136.wav", + "text": "這個需求所以是不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1137.wav", + "text": "新制進行的狀況檢討" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1138.wav", + "text": "一定的修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1139.wav", + "text": "是謝謝主席" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1140.wav", + "text": "不必講太多講太多大家也聽不了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1141.wav", + "text": "第28條第1項第2款" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1142.wav", + "text": "第三目將保險年金列為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1143.wav", + "text": "我們是建議單獨列一款" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1144.wav", + "text": "不要跟一次性退休金" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1145.wav", + "text": "及月退休金" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1146.wav", + "text": "它自己單獨成為一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1147.wav", + "text": "那個介面不同啦一個是由公務機關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1148.wav", + "text": "出面一個是個人出面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1149.wav", + "text": "由公務機關出面還是國家保障的一個延續" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1150.wav", + "text": "個人的話當然是國家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1151.wav", + "text": "跟個人的義務已經結清那不一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1152.wav", + "text": "所以這一條司法院的見解" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1153.wav", + "text": "跟考試院原來的設計" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1154.wav", + "text": "是有一個概念上的落差" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1155.wav", + "text": "司法院再來做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1156.wav", + "text": "你們再去溝通好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1157.wav", + "text": "你們再溝通啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1158.wav", + "text": "他們的主張是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1159.wav", + "text": "應該放在另外一款" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1160.wav", + "text": "今天勞保局有人來嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1161.wav", + "text": "司法院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1162.wav", + "text": "我有聽懂你的意思啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1163.wav", + "text": "你們再溝通" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1164.wav", + "text": "你們再溝通" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1165.wav", + "text": "第28條就暫時保留啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1166.wav", + "text": "沒關係啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1167.wav", + "text": "喔我懂你的意思對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1168.wav", + "text": "是不是脫離國家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1169.wav", + "text": "我懂" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1170.wav", + "text": "你們再溝通啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1171.wav", + "text": "既然司法院有提出這樣的意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1172.wav", + "text": "考試院也尊重一下去跟他們多溝通啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1173.wav", + "text": "我能不能請問一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1174.wav", + "text": "哪一條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1175.wav", + "text": "以二次為限" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1176.wav", + "text": "我覺得有必要一定要這樣規定嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1177.wav", + "text": "我覺得那是為了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1178.wav", + "text": "管理方便" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1179.wav", + "text": "你對哪一個條文有意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1180.wav", + "text": "第28條的哪個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1181.wav", + "text": "就是以二次為限" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1182.wav", + "text": "是覺得在規定上一定要寫嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1183.wav", + "text": "一年二次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1184.wav", + "text": "一年二次已經算滿頻繁" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1185.wav", + "text": "我的意思是大家也不會沒事去調整" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1186.wav", + "text": "一定是有狀況才會調整" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1187.wav", + "text": "對啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1188.wav", + "text": "又是以政府的角度在思考問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1189.wav", + "text": "既然是他的個人專戶" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1190.wav", + "text": "你為什麼要去限制他" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1191.wav", + "text": "要怎麼處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1192.wav", + "text": "但是這樣的規範其實可以讓個人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1193.wav", + "text": "我覺得這又是一個父權觀念" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1194.wav", + "text": "你從政府的角度覺得給" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1195.wav", + "text": "機會每一次都要謹慎思考" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1196.wav", + "text": "但是我覺得站在他的立場" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1197.wav", + "text": "你為什麼要去限制他的次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1198.wav", + "text": "這個也會有很多行政成本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1199.wav", + "text": "所以你是以行政成本來考量" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1200.wav", + "text": "因為行政成本會轉嫁到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1201.wav", + "text": "所以我剛剛講你是站在你的行政成本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1202.wav", + "text": "跟管理方便" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1203.wav", + "text": "我覺得不應該限制次數" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1204.wav", + "text": "我覺得應該要尊重" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1205.wav", + "text": "重因為一般人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1206.wav", + "text": "不會沒事去調整" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1207.wav", + "text": "但不可能每個月都去調整嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1208.wav", + "text": "我是覺得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1209.wav", + "text": "一年二次已經算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1210.wav", + "text": "沒有我覺得既然是個人專戶" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1211.wav", + "text": "我比較認為應該要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1212.wav", + "text": "鬆綁" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1213.wav", + "text": "以鬆綁的角度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1214.wav", + "text": "因為他要自己負責" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1215.wav", + "text": "啊他要自己負責" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1216.wav", + "text": "嘛所以我覺得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1217.wav", + "text": "不要限制他一年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1218.wav", + "text": "現在因為司法院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1219.wav", + "text": "有一點意見他們要再溝通一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1220.wav", + "text": "所以這一條暫時保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1221.wav", + "text": "你的意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1222.wav", + "text": "沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1223.wav", + "text": "沒有意見我們就照考試院的意見通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1224.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1225.wav", + "text": "慢一點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1226.wav", + "text": "比較快" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1227.wav", + "text": "看到後面第三欄會很麻煩" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1228.wav", + "text": "每個人都是同樣團體拿出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1229.wav", + "text": "好沒有意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1230.wav", + "text": "照考試院提案通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1231.wav", + "text": "第33條有經過協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1232.wav", + "text": "而且有建議條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1233.wav", + "text": "我們是不是就照協商建議條文通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1234.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1235.wav", + "text": "照協商建議條文通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1236.wav", + "text": "\n請看第56條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1237.wav", + "text": "這一條也是有經過協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1238.wav", + "text": "而且有建議條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1239.wav", + "text": "我們是不是照協商建議條文通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1240.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1241.wav", + "text": "沒有意見的話就照協商建議條文通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1242.wav", + "text": "大家有沒有意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1243.wav", + "text": "有意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1244.wav", + "text": "吳委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1245.wav", + "text": "我們還是希望按" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1246.wav", + "text": "把450億元分40年撥補" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1247.wav", + "text": "1年100億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1248.wav", + "text": "勞保舊轉新那時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1249.wav", + "text": "8兆元誰付得起" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1250.wav", + "text": "所以我們希望" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1251.wav", + "text": "現在就可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1252.wav", + "text": "儘快開始按年撥補了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1253.wav", + "text": "謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1254.wav", + "text": "請謝委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1255.wav", + "text": "預計在140年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1256.wav", + "text": "基金破產" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1257.wav", + "text": "如果推行新制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1258.wav", + "text": "人員部分是在135年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1259.wav", + "text": "破產所以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1260.wav", + "text": "他們就只願意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1261.wav", + "text": "到140年這個缺口" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1262.wav", + "text": "但是我想要請問政府" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1263.wav", + "text": "不是說會負完全的支付責任" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1264.wav", + "text": "嗎那未來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1265.wav", + "text": "140年以後的呢或者是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1266.wav", + "text": "如果提前破產呢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1267.wav", + "text": "為什麼政府沒有辦法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1268.wav", + "text": "我覺得只限一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1269.wav", + "text": "公務人員及公教人員的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1270.wav", + "text": "保障的確讓人家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1271.wav", + "text": "覺得稍顯不足" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1272.wav", + "text": "你的意思是什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1273.wav", + "text": "意思就是這一條暫時保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1274.wav", + "text": "林奕華委員也點頭" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1275.wav", + "text": "了我們就暫時保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1276.wav", + "text": "林奕華委員發言完畢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1277.wav", + "text": "我們就保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1278.wav", + "text": "我要先跟主席報告一下因為這個條文非常" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1279.wav", + "text": "關鍵如果我們沒有把" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1280.wav", + "text": "分年編列預算來撥補" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1281.wav", + "text": "其實你會讓現在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1282.wav", + "text": "的公務人員對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1283.wav", + "text": "分年沒有沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1284.wav", + "text": "分年編列預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1285.wav", + "text": "分年沒有喔" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1286.wav", + "text": "但問題是你只針對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1287.wav", + "text": "我們要的是現在就要開始逐年撥補" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1288.wav", + "text": "要現在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1289.wav", + "text": "就開始喔" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1290.wav", + "text": "說明一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1291.wav", + "text": "我們不是只要你們撥補" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1292.wav", + "text": "我知道委員的意思" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1293.wav", + "text": "因為造成財務缺口" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1294.wav", + "text": "現在政府會分年編列預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1295.wav", + "text": "撥補" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1296.wav", + "text": "這個部分我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1297.wav", + "text": "都有持續跟主計總處來協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1298.wav", + "text": "我想這個條文放在這邊沒有問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1299.wav", + "text": "現有的基金" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1300.wav", + "text": "的那個缺口" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1301.wav", + "text": "但是這個部分其實跟剛剛的兩個討論有關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1302.wav", + "text": "第一個就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1303.wav", + "text": "基金其實公務人員壓力最大" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1304.wav", + "text": "的就是那個用罄年限" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1305.wav", + "text": "陣痛不過它讓這個基金的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1306.wav", + "text": "壽命往後延長了一個世代" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1307.wav", + "text": "也讓我們可以比較從容" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1308.wav", + "text": "地再去處理這個問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1309.wav", + "text": "轉新制有關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1310.wav", + "text": "舊制轉新制的人越多這個洞就會越大" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1311.wav", + "text": "金額當然也會越高" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1312.wav", + "text": "\n當然此處還是牽涉到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1313.wav", + "text": "現在這個退撫基金" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1314.wav", + "text": "不足額提撥的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1315.wav", + "text": "那我想我們繼續來強化這個基金" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1316.wav", + "text": "經營的績效當然其他" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1317.wav", + "text": "涉及制度面的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1318.wav", + "text": "這個可能不是我們考試院的權責" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1319.wav", + "text": "當然也不是只有考慮軍公教的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1320.wav", + "text": "退休基金等整體的考量" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1321.wav", + "text": "考量因為條文上政府會負最終的責任" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1322.wav", + "text": "不會再推二次年改" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1323.wav", + "text": "所以我相信這部分應該可以讓大家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1324.wav", + "text": "先不用那麼操心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1325.wav", + "text": "好那是不是就保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1326.wav", + "text": "我覺得這個分兩個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1327.wav", + "text": "還有一個我覺得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1328.wav", + "text": "目前省下來各級機關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1329.wav", + "text": "所節省提撥費率" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1330.wav", + "text": "之退撫經費支出" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1331.wav", + "text": "應全數挹注" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1332.wav", + "text": "退撫基金" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1333.wav", + "text": "確定未來不會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1334.wav", + "text": "被調整掉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1335.wav", + "text": "已經有這樣的規定了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1336.wav", + "text": "現行退撫法有規定全數挹注" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1337.wav", + "text": "並比照本條例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1338.wav", + "text": "第4條規定之期程辦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1339.wav", + "text": "我知道在實務上是這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1340.wav", + "text": "依照法律規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1341.wav", + "text": "現在是實務上是這樣做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1342.wav", + "text": "你拿來給我看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1343.wav", + "text": "\n另外一個就是我剛剛講的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1344.wav", + "text": "要撥補的部分是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1345.wav", + "text": "第1項退撫制度實施之日起" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1346.wav", + "text": "要逐年編列" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1347.wav", + "text": "越早編列越好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1348.wav", + "text": "我們有協調" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1349.wav", + "text": "啦如果今年年底" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1350.wav", + "text": "案通過明年7月1日上路" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1351.wav", + "text": "就編到後年的預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1352.wav", + "text": "開始撥補" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1353.wav", + "text": "你看這兩年其實稅收超收" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1354.wav", + "text": "非常多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1355.wav", + "text": "因為現在法律還沒有通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1356.wav", + "text": "法律一旦通過就開始" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1357.wav", + "text": "兩年都稅收超收" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1358.wav", + "text": "明年就沒有這樣要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1359.wav", + "text": "農保也撥補" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1360.wav", + "text": "勞保也撥補" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1361.wav", + "text": "軍人也撥補" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1362.wav", + "text": "請教柯總召" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1363.wav", + "text": "召這跟預算法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1364.wav", + "text": "第23條及第六十幾條的關係" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1365.wav", + "text": "會有撥補上的問題嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1366.wav", + "text": "因為現在都用公務預算對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1367.wav", + "text": "之前從200億300億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1368.wav", + "text": "到450億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1369.wav", + "text": "但是好像總的撥補都會受到預算法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1370.wav", + "text": "所以是不是要在這裡加註" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1371.wav", + "text": "文字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1372.wav", + "text": "你知道預算法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1373.wav", + "text": "這個要不要你知" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1374.wav", + "text": "間有不受預算法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1375.wav", + "text": "第23條第62條及第63" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1376.wav", + "text": "3條規定的限制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1377.wav", + "text": "明年的預算1001百多億的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1378.wav", + "text": "還債裡面就講到勞保" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1379.wav", + "text": "占了450億對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1380.wav", + "text": "對所以我說這個如果再編入" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1381.wav", + "text": "有空間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1382.wav", + "text": "對所以要不要寫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1383.wav", + "text": "因為這個size不一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1384.wav", + "text": "勞保的size那麼大這個size沒有這麼大" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1385.wav", + "text": "好所以就剩下第2款" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1386.wav", + "text": "就是剛剛講要不要把它" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1387.wav", + "text": "挪為他用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1388.wav", + "text": "法律上的文字在哪裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1389.wav", + "text": "把這個確認一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1390.wav", + "text": "我們有三項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1391.wav", + "text": "有嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1392.wav", + "text": "所以各級政府節省提撥的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1393.wav", + "text": "經費" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1394.wav", + "text": "全數挹注退撫基金" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1395.wav", + "text": "不得挪作他用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1396.wav", + "text": "這有在退撫條例對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1397.wav", + "text": "都同意了嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1398.wav", + "text": "保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1399.wav", + "text": "保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1400.wav", + "text": "受預算法這些規定是不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1401.wav", + "text": "應該要寫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1402.wav", + "text": "好第二案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1403.wav", + "text": "就保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1404.wav", + "text": "因為第三案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1405.wav", + "text": "等於跟第一案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1406.wav", + "text": "嘛所以第三案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1407.wav", + "text": "保留就保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1408.wav", + "text": "行第四案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1409.wav", + "text": "這一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1410.wav", + "text": "啊一樣就保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1411.wav", + "text": "第98條保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1412.wav", + "text": "好我們繼續看第五" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1413.wav", + "text": "第五案是什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1414.wav", + "text": "公務人員保險法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1415.wav", + "text": "部分條文修正草案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1416.wav", + "text": "已經協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1417.wav", + "text": "我們是不是就照協商建議條文通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1418.wav", + "text": "十六條及第" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1419.wav", + "text": "二十一條保留好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1420.wav", + "text": "第五案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1421.wav", + "text": "已經走到底" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1422.wav", + "text": "我們剛才有承諾說從頭再走回來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1423.wav", + "text": "有照你們的意思" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1424.wav", + "text": "資料沒有送來沒有辦法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1425.wav", + "text": "什麼樣的資料" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1426.wav", + "text": "資料應該要提出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1427.wav", + "text": "他沒有辦法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1428.wav", + "text": "啦請院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1429.wav", + "text": "我建議休息10分鐘好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1430.wav", + "text": "溝通一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1431.wav", + "text": "他們就是在等你的資料" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1432.wav", + "text": "以口頭說明也可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1433.wav", + "text": "拜四再進行一次協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1434.wav", + "text": "好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1435.wav", + "text": "我們再找一個時間來協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1436.wav", + "text": "我剛剛跟你們講的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1437.wav", + "text": "就是先走過一遍然後從頭再來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1438.wav", + "text": "我講話算話因" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1439.wav", + "text": "因為現在還沒有充分的溝通所以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1440.wav", + "text": "我們就延到禮拜四來溝通" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1441.wav", + "text": "這樣好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1442.wav", + "text": "好好溝通一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1443.wav", + "text": "至少要有默契吧" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1444.wav", + "text": "否則我們不知道要支持考試院還是司法院很難" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1445.wav", + "text": "禮拜四還是下午2時30分開始" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1446.wav", + "text": "禮拜四還是下午2時30分協商大家有沒有意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1447.wav", + "text": "沒有意見如果沒有意見就這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1448.wav", + "text": "禮拜四要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1449.wav", + "text": "好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1450.wav", + "text": "禮拜四下午4時繼續進" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1451.wav", + "text": "謝謝大家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14681/1452.wav", + "text": "辛苦了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14679/0.wav", + "text": "委員郭國文等19人委員鄭正鈐等21人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14679/1.wav", + "text": "及委員林宜瑾等21人分別" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14679/2.wav", + "text": "委員鄭正鈐等22人及委員吳斯懷等16人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14679/3.wav", + "text": "百零條條文修正草案案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14679/4.wav", + "text": "大家好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14679/5.wav", + "text": "有共識的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14679/6.wav", + "text": "局我" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14679/7.wav", + "text": "還是公" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14679/8.wav", + "text": "所以我們建" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14679/9.wav", + "text": "所以這個部分應該" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14679/10.wav", + "text": "我說明一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14679/11.wav", + "text": "這樣重大的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14679/12.wav", + "text": "入法這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14679/13.wav", + "text": "圍可以更" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14679/14.wav", + "text": "法裡面詳細去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14679/15.wav", + "text": "提升我覺得銓敘部應該" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14679/16.wav", + "text": "考核這個是沒有問題的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14679/17.wav", + "text": "有一個錯誤印象那是早期的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14679/18.wav", + "text": "多\n我覺得這個是要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14679/19.wav", + "text": "有沒有意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14679/20.wav", + "text": "其實現在是最好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14679/21.wav", + "text": "我們是不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14679/22.wav", + "text": "保法第十六條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14679/23.wav", + "text": "不好意思" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14679/24.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14679/25.wav", + "text": "沒有意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14679/26.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14679/27.wav", + "text": "現在散會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14672/0.wav", + "text": "法律名稱開始各位委員對於法律名稱有沒有意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14672/1.wav", + "text": "到本條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14672/2.wav", + "text": "主席各位委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14672/3.wav", + "text": "也應該要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14672/4.wav", + "text": "放在這裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14672/5.wav", + "text": "有討論你剛剛也有提到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14672/6.wav", + "text": "要不要讓" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14672/7.wav", + "text": "一下謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14672/8.wav", + "text": "要發言的如果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14672/9.wav", + "text": "沒有的話我們就" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14671/0.wav", + "text": "因為今天有很多會議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14671/1.wav", + "text": "要不要說明一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14671/2.wav", + "text": "為什麼主委今天沒有來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14671/3.wav", + "text": "主席報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14671/4.wav", + "text": "所以由我代理出席" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14671/5.wav", + "text": "有審查過了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14671/6.wav", + "text": "因為條文非常多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14671/7.wav", + "text": "版本也有好幾個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14671/8.wav", + "text": "大家都有很多的意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14671/9.wav", + "text": "所以很多條文都保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14671/10.wav", + "text": "法律名稱" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14671/11.wav", + "text": "對於法律名稱有沒" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14671/12.wav", + "text": "意見行政院版是原住民族保留地管理利用條例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14671/13.wav", + "text": "委員的版本是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14671/14.wav", + "text": "開發管理利用條例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14671/15.wav", + "text": "我提的是原住民族保留地管理利用條例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14671/16.wav", + "text": "有提到是不是要把權利回復" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14671/17.wav", + "text": "放進去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14671/18.wav", + "text": "也有提到權利回復" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14671/19.wav", + "text": "過去夷將主委" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14671/20.wav", + "text": "是政務副主委我是常務副主委的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14671/21.wav", + "text": "他也一直強調" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14671/22.wav", + "text": "應該是叫權利回復" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14671/23.wav", + "text": "對於這個名稱" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14671/24.wav", + "text": "我們考量到權利回復也是屬於管理的範疇" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14671/25.wav", + "text": "我們希望用管理利用條例就好了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14671/26.wav", + "text": "反正在相關的條文裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14671/27.wav", + "text": "有提到權利回復的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14671/28.wav", + "text": "叫原住民族保留地管理利用條例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14671/29.wav", + "text": "我們先看行政院版第1條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14671/30.wav", + "text": "為承認及回復原住民族對於原住民族土地之權利" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14671/31.wav", + "text": "所以前提是要回復" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14671/32.wav", + "text": "原住民族保留地之權利回復" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14671/33.wav", + "text": "取得處分計畫管理及利用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14671/34.wav", + "text": "所以看起來管理沒有辦法包含" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14671/35.wav", + "text": "其他的尤其是權利回復取得處分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14671/36.wav", + "text": "因為我自己提案的法案名稱" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14671/37.wav", + "text": "最主要的原因如同主席剛剛說的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14671/38.wav", + "text": "因為第1條就開宗明義" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14671/39.wav", + "text": "這個法案最主要的精神是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14671/40.wav", + "text": "為了回復跟承認原住民的土地權利" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14671/41.wav", + "text": "利如果能夠留下這四個字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14671/42.wav", + "text": "基本上也可以讓一般大眾理解" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14671/43.wav", + "text": "如果我們從原基法第2條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14671/44.wav", + "text": "我是這樣看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14671/45.wav", + "text": "有關原住民族保留地權利回復" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14671/46.wav", + "text": "主詞不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14671/47.wav", + "text": "權利回復應該是某種人受損的權利回復" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14671/48.wav", + "text": "或者是某種人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14671/49.wav", + "text": "這是土地的權利回復" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14671/50.wav", + "text": "所以還是保留好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14671/51.wav", + "text": "文詞好像是不通的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14671/52.wav", + "text": "好這個法案名稱就保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14671/53.wav", + "text": "上次唯一沒有意見的就是第一章總則" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14671/54.wav", + "text": "\n行政院版第1條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14671/55.wav", + "text": "為承認及回復原住民族對於原住民族土地之權利" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14671/56.wav", + "text": "規劃原住民族保留地之合理利用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14671/57.wav", + "text": "促進原住民族之生存發展" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14671/58.wav", + "text": "依憲法增修條文第10條第十二項及原住民族基本法第二十條第三項規定制定本條例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14671/59.wav", + "text": "主要聚焦在原住民族基本法第二十條第三項的規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14671/60.wav", + "text": "本席的版本是第一項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14671/61.wav", + "text": "因為寫第三項的話就會涉及到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14671/62.wav", + "text": "一點即今天這個法案只有保留地" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14671/63.wav", + "text": "沒有提到傳統領域" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14671/64.wav", + "text": "所以就會有這個疑慮" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14671/65.wav", + "text": "從陳水扁總統時代到馬英九總統" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14671/66.wav", + "text": "也就是根據原住民族基本法第二十條第三項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14671/67.wav", + "text": "唯獨現在蔡總統執政快七年了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14671/68.wav", + "text": "原住民族土地及海域法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14671/69.wav", + "text": "原住民族保留地管理利用條例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14671/70.wav", + "text": "認為既然要做所謂的分流立法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14671/71.wav", + "text": "而政院版是第2條第3項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14671/72.wav", + "text": "如果要比較" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14671/73.wav", + "text": "範圍哪一個廣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14671/74.wav", + "text": "當然是第3項比第1項廣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14671/75.wav", + "text": "如果是第1項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14671/76.wav", + "text": "的自然資源" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14671/77.wav", + "text": "跟土地在一起" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14671/78.wav", + "text": "那就沒有海域" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14671/79.wav", + "text": "而鄭委員是最關心海域" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14671/80.wav", + "text": "部分所以第3項跟第1項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14671/81.wav", + "text": "應該都是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14671/82.wav", + "text": "鄭委員一向主張的完整內容" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14671/83.wav", + "text": "就是兩個加起來才是完整內容" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14671/84.wav", + "text": "反而是引用第3項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14671/85.wav", + "text": "引用第1項的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14671/86.wav", + "text": "自然資源也加進來一起" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14671/87.wav", + "text": "那麼整個院版的結構就全部要修改" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14671/88.wav", + "text": "所以如果現在還不能處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14671/89.wav", + "text": "就只好再保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14671/90.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14671/91.wav", + "text": "我們可以先保留原" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14671/92.wav", + "text": "民會也再思考一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14671/93.wav", + "text": "你們可以參考其他" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14671/94.wav", + "text": "原住民族的專法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14671/95.wav", + "text": "原住民族教育法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14671/96.wav", + "text": "裡面就只有寫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14671/97.wav", + "text": "而沒有引用原住民族��本法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14671/98.wav", + "text": "雖然原住民族基本法裡也有寫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14671/99.wav", + "text": "它只有寫憲法增修條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14671/100.wav", + "text": "請原民會回去再跟主委" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14671/101.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14671/102.wav", + "text": "接下來處理第2條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14671/103.wav", + "text": "行政院版本是原住民族保留地之權利" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14671/104.wav", + "text": "回復取得處分計畫管理及利用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14671/105.wav", + "text": "等事項依本條例之規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14671/106.wav", + "text": "只是後面多了本條例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14671/107.wav", + "text": "未規定者適用其他法律之規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14671/108.wav", + "text": "但現在的立法體例好像沒有了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14671/109.wav", + "text": "本條例未規定者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14671/110.wav", + "text": "適用其他法律" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14671/111.wav", + "text": "定請法務部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14671/112.wav", + "text": "跟委員報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14671/113.wav", + "text": "因為這一條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14671/114.wav", + "text": "沒有涉及到具體的法律效果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14671/115.wav", + "text": "在不同的立法體例上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14671/116.wav", + "text": "有一些會這樣寫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14671/117.wav", + "text": "而有一些法律也沒有這幾個文字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14671/118.wav", + "text": "我們可能就是尊重大院的考量及決定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14671/119.wav", + "text": "因為在立法體例上並沒有明確說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14671/120.wav", + "text": "有什麼妥當或不妥當的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14671/121.wav", + "text": "另外麻煩你說明一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14671/122.wav", + "text": "我看了一下我們國家所有的法律" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14671/123.wav", + "text": "的主詞都是人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14671/124.wav", + "text": "或者是人所受損之權利" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14671/125.wav", + "text": "利啦這裡是土地做主詞" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14671/126.wav", + "text": "當然你加個之比較好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14671/127.wav", + "text": "剛剛在講法規名稱的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14671/128.wav", + "text": "沒有之是絕對不通" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14671/129.wav", + "text": "這裡加個之好像稍微比較好一點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14671/130.wav", + "text": "但是畢竟還是原住民土地之權利回復" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14671/131.wav", + "text": "的文字到底有沒有問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14671/132.wav", + "text": "之取得其實就是權利回復中的一種" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14671/133.wav", + "text": "即所有權的權利回復" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14671/134.wav", + "text": "嘛那是原住民土地之取得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14671/135.wav", + "text": "你現在的主詞是原住民土地之權利回復" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14671/136.wav", + "text": "是誰的權利回復" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14671/137.wav", + "text": "變成是原住民土地的權利回復" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14671/138.wav", + "text": "這個主詞對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14671/139.wav", + "text": "呢原住民土地本身當主詞了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14671/140.wav", + "text": "你們說明一下好嗎那" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14671/141.wav", + "text": "嗎那個之當然會好一點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14671/142.wav", + "text": "那絕對不可行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14671/143.wav", + "text": "嘛這裡加個之好像又好一點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14671/144.wav", + "text": "如果是用於原住民族土地權利" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14671/145.wav", + "text": "利就是一個財產權的權利回復" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14671/146.wav", + "text": "所以應該是權利之回復" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14671/147.wav", + "text": "嘛但是後面就沒辦法直接加取得了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14671/148.wav", + "text": "你知道我的意思嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14671/149.wav", + "text": "現在變成原住民土地之權利回復" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14671/150.wav", + "text": "真的有問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14671/151.wav", + "text": "啦我是認為有問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14671/152.wav", + "text": "主詞是原住民土地" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14671/153.wav", + "text": "而土地本身怎麼會有權利" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14671/154.wav", + "text": "我擁有原住民土地的權利" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14671/155.wav", + "text": "所以之應該是在權利的後面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14671/156.wav", + "text": "你們回去好好瞭解一下好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14671/157.wav", + "text": "我覺得這個文字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14671/158.wav", + "text": "是不是要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14671/159.wav", + "text": "我想這是一個法條名稱的敘述方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14671/160.wav", + "text": "剛剛委員提的就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14671/161.wav", + "text": "你的主詞是要用人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14671/162.wav", + "text": "還是要用權利" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14671/163.wav", + "text": "或是你要加一個之" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14671/164.wav", + "text": "我想它是一個名稱描述方式的問題而已" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14671/165.wav", + "text": "所以這部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14671/166.wav", + "text": "還是尊重委員的考量" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14671/167.wav", + "text": "委員就是有疑慮才問你們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14671/168.wav", + "text": "我們就是有疑慮" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14671/169.wav", + "text": "即不知道是這樣還是那樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14671/170.wav", + "text": "啊你說尊重我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14671/171.wav", + "text": "大家會覺得比較妥當" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14671/172.wav", + "text": "那是一個描述方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14671/173.wav", + "text": "我想它並沒有一個什麼特別的規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14671/174.wav", + "text": "或是要求" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14671/175.wav", + "text": "的原住民族保留地之權利回復" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14671/176.wav", + "text": "這是一件事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14671/177.wav", + "text": "原住民族保留地之取得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14671/178.wav", + "text": "取得所有權而" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14671/179.wav", + "text": "原住民族保留地之處分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14671/180.wav", + "text": "原住民族保留地之計畫之管理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14671/181.wav", + "text": "之利用文字應該還可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14671/182.wav", + "text": "我來試著釐清" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14671/183.wav", + "text": "現在最主要就是說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14671/184.wav", + "text": "它本來是國有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14671/185.wav", + "text": "或是縣市有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14671/186.wav", + "text": "直轄市有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14671/187.wav", + "text": "即本來是公有的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14671/188.wav", + "text": "然後我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14671/189.wav", + "text": "劃定為原住民族保留地" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14671/190.wav", + "text": "權利回復的開始" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14671/191.wav", + "text": "原住民族保留地之權利回復" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14671/192.wav", + "text": "主席我看懂了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14671/193.wav", + "text": "不是權利回復" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14671/194.wav", + "text": "而是土地回復及海域回復" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14671/195.wav", + "text": "就是原住民土地" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14671/196.wav", + "text": "就回復為原住民土地" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14671/197.wav", + "text": "原住民族之海域" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14671/198.wav", + "text": "就回復為原住民族之海域" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14671/199.wav", + "text": "這是原基法第2條的寫法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14671/200.wav", + "text": "原基法第2條沒有權利兩個字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14671/201.wav", + "text": "權利的主體必須是人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14671/202.wav", + "text": "土地怎麼會有權利" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14671/203.wav", + "text": "所以原基法沒有錯" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14671/204.wav", + "text": "是這裡突然跑出權利兩個字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14671/205.wav", + "text": "它是原住民族土地之回復" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14671/206.wav", + "text": "就回復為原住民族之土地" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14671/207.wav", + "text": "就回復為原住民族之海域" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14671/208.wav", + "text": "再斟酌一下文字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14671/209.wav", + "text": "就是把權利拿掉是不" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14671/210.wav", + "text": "2條第3項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14671/211.wav", + "text": "只有寫到回復取得處分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14671/212.wav", + "text": "原則上把權利拿掉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14671/213.wav", + "text": "你們回去之後再找政委斟酌一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14671/214.wav", + "text": "但原則上是把權利拿掉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14671/215.wav", + "text": "\n接下來處理第3條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14671/216.wav", + "text": "除了行政院版之外另" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14671/217.wav", + "text": "還有廖國棟委員及" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14671/218.wav", + "text": "最主要是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14671/219.wav", + "text": "自治權" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14671/220.wav", + "text": "就" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14671/221.wav", + "text": "原住民族自治區政府" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14671/222.wav", + "text": "說明一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14671/223.wav", + "text": "各位委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14671/224.wav", + "text": "各位行政官員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14671/225.wav", + "text": "其實我們討論這個案子已經有一段時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14671/226.wav", + "text": "立場和態度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14671/227.wav", + "text": "一些主見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14671/228.wav", + "text": "還是回到原點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14671/229.wav", + "text": "我覺得行政單位要再加強" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14671/230.wav", + "text": "最起碼你們要跟各提案委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14671/231.wav", + "text": "��來沒有找我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14671/232.wav", + "text": "這是很奇怪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14671/233.wav", + "text": "的所以今天突然要協商的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14671/234.wav", + "text": "我們變成沒有一個好的基礎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14671/235.wav", + "text": "討論比較細膩一點的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14671/236.wav", + "text": "我想行政單位真的要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14671/237.wav", + "text": "更積極來面對所有委員的提案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14671/238.wav", + "text": "而不是一直堅持你們所提的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14671/239.wav", + "text": "而不是一定要按照你們的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14671/240.wav", + "text": "版本我必須先表達這個立場" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14671/241.wav", + "text": "芳安副主任委" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14671/242.wav", + "text": "我們有到廖委員辦公室" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14671/243.wav", + "text": "做過兩次溝通" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14671/244.wav", + "text": "一定要在協商之前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14671/245.wav", + "text": "同時也要跟各位委員溝通" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14671/246.wav", + "text": "這部分我們都有做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14671/247.wav", + "text": "所以今年5月12日" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14671/248.wav", + "text": "由林政委召集各部會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14671/249.wav", + "text": "\n關於廖委員的版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14671/250.wav", + "text": "包括原住民族土地及海域調查處理委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14671/251.wav", + "text": "應該要另外以法律定之" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14671/252.wav", + "text": "如果放在這裡面的話不只" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14671/253.wav", + "text": "整個會變複雜" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14671/254.wav", + "text": "而且會亂掉請委員參考" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14671/255.wav", + "text": "謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14671/256.wav", + "text": "林政務委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14671/257.wav", + "text": "是這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14671/258.wav", + "text": "上個會期結束之前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14671/259.wav", + "text": "朝野協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14671/260.wav", + "text": "因為柯總召跟我講說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14671/261.wav", + "text": "行政院還要再討論一次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14671/262.wav", + "text": "所以那一次就延期" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14671/263.wav", + "text": "林政務委員既然已經有討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14671/264.wav", + "text": "你剛剛也有提到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14671/265.wav", + "text": "這應該要事先提供給" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14671/266.wav", + "text": "順利" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14671/267.wav", + "text": "這是一個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14671/268.wav", + "text": "還有一個部分我先問一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14671/269.wav", + "text": "ahe委員應該還記得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14671/270.wav", + "text": "就是我們在審查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14671/271.wav", + "text": "包括委員的版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14671/272.wav", + "text": "就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14671/273.wav", + "text": "宗教團體以自然人名義" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14671/274.wav", + "text": "對原住民" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14671/275.wav", + "text": "要放在這個條例裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14671/276.wav", + "text": "還沒有是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14671/277.wav", + "text": "這部分好像是以現行的法律" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14671/278.wav", + "text": "請處長說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14671/279.wav", + "text": "跟委員報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14671/280.wav", + "text": "這部分事實上那時候委員有提出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14671/281.wav", + "text": "我們也說在協商時" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14671/282.wav", + "text": "所以這個部分是有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14671/283.wav", + "text": "原住民宗教團體以原住民名義登記" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14671/284.wav", + "text": "因為那時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14671/285.wav", + "text": "不要放在內政部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14671/286.wav", + "text": "宗教團體以自然人名義" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14671/287.wav", + "text": "所以那個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14671/288.wav", + "text": "你是要放在這裡嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14671/289.wav", + "text": "可以嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14671/290.wav", + "text": "可以放在原住民族保留地管理利用條例嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14671/291.wav", + "text": "好等一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14671/292.wav", + "text": "現在可以先印這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14671/293.wav", + "text": "要不要讓我們回去看一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14671/294.wav", + "text": "你們再來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14671/295.wav", + "text": "謝謝管委員的建議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14671/296.wav", + "text": "而且夷將主委今天正好有事" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14671/297.wav", + "text": "你們回去還要問他" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14671/298.wav", + "text": "林政務委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14671/299.wav", + "text": "有再召集過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14671/300.wav", + "text": "也把行政院版" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14671/301.wav", + "text": "現在有放在桌上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14671/302.wav", + "text": "拿回去看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14671/303.wav", + "text": "再檢視一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14671/304.wav", + "text": "原住民族宗教團體" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14671/305.wav", + "text": "──也在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14671/306.wav", + "text": "影印裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14671/307.wav", + "text": "要補影印給" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14671/308.wav", + "text": "內政委員會的委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14671/309.wav", + "text": "再加上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14671/310.wav", + "text": "有提版本的提案委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14671/311.wav", + "text": "像廖國棟委員陳瑩委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14671/312.wav", + "text": "賴瑞隆" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14671/313.wav", + "text": "他們有共同提案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14671/314.wav", + "text": "這樣可以嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14671/315.wav", + "text": "請陳委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14671/316.wav", + "text": "因為我剛剛晚了幾分鐘進來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14671/317.wav", + "text": "第1條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14671/318.wav", + "text": "我補充一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14671/319.wav", + "text": "特別是在法案名稱上面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14671/320.wav", + "text": "做了一個比較大的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14671/321.wav", + "text": "變革" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14671/322.wav", + "text": "等於顛覆了大家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14671/323.wav", + "text": "我把原住民個人擁有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14671/324.wav", + "text": "修改為原住民族繼留地" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14671/325.wav", + "text": "雖然看起來只是改一個名稱" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14671/326.wav", + "text": "可能會連動" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14671/327.wav", + "text": "在作用上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14671/328.wav", + "text": "或許沒有什麼變化" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14671/329.wav", + "text": "但是我覺得在意涵上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14671/330.wav", + "text": "對原住民來講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14671/331.wav", + "text": "很多人都有講過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14671/332.wav", + "text": "在400年前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14671/333.wav", + "text": "或更早之前原住民就在這塊土地上生活" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14671/334.wav", + "text": "改變在這個島上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14671/335.wav", + "text": "或所有居民先來後到的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14671/336.wav", + "text": "沿用至今" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14671/337.wav", + "text": "高砂族保留地" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14671/338.wav", + "text": "保留這個名稱" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14671/339.wav", + "text": "政府施予" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14671/340.wav", + "text": "或政府保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14671/341.wav", + "text": "原住民土地的意思" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14671/342.wav", + "text": "但是我們原住民族的土地" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14671/343.wav", + "text": "那邊繼承而來的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14671/344.wav", + "text": "國家保留或賦予" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14671/345.wav", + "text": "所以我才主張" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14671/346.wav", + "text": "繼留地因為保留地" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14671/347.wav", + "text": "這個名詞嚴格來講對我們原住民" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14671/348.wav", + "text": "是一個不正義的名稱" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14671/349.wav", + "text": "所以我才提出這樣的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14671/350.wav", + "text": "主張\n我在原基" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14671/351.wav", + "text": "法的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14671/352.wav", + "text": "也有提案修改保留地" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14671/353.wav", + "text": "大家參考" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14671/354.wav", + "text": "希望下次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14671/355.wav", + "text": "有一個好的進展" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14671/356.wav", + "text": "剛才委員所講的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14671/357.wav", + "text": "去思考這個問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14671/358.wav", + "text": "提出一個說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14671/359.wav", + "text": "\n還有沒有要發言的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14671/360.wav", + "text": "如果沒有的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14671/361.wav", + "text": "協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14671/362.wav", + "text": "謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/0.wav", + "text": "時我們現在開始協商會議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/1.wav", + "text": "本日協商關於" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/2.wav", + "text": "新退撫制度個人專戶之相關法案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/3.wav", + "text": "共計5個主題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/4.wav", + "text": "分別為公教人員保險法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/5.wav", + "text": "部分條文修正草案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/6.wav", + "text": "公務人員個人專戶制退休資遣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/7.wav", + "text": "撫卹法草案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/8.wav", + "text": "公務人員退休資遣撫卹法第93條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/9.wav", + "text": "及第95條條文修正草案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/10.wav", + "text": "公立學校教職員個人專戶制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/11.wav", + "text": "退休資遣撫卹條例草案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/12.wav", + "text": "以及公立學校" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/13.wav", + "text": "撫卹條例第98條及第一百零條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/14.wav", + "text": "條文修正草案等5案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/15.wav", + "text": "因為委員會審查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/16.wav", + "text": "也有一段時間了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/17.wav", + "text": "大概是上個會期" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/18.wav", + "text": "這會期因為在等待總質詢跟預算審查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/19.wav", + "text": "所以我們現在才進行協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/20.wav", + "text": "兩位部長就" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/21.wav", + "text": "條文逐條審查的過程" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/22.wav", + "text": "其實很多委員都有提出" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/23.wav", + "text": "非常多意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/24.wav", + "text": "回去試算包含" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/25.wav", + "text": "給舊制人員機會結算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/26.wav", + "text": "建議條文跟修改的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/27.wav", + "text": "周部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/28.wav", + "text": "主席各位委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/29.wav", + "text": "公務人員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/30.wav", + "text": "個人專戶制退休資遣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/31.wav", + "text": "撫卹法相關的幾個法案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/32.wav", + "text": "今天要協商的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/33.wav", + "text": "報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/34.wav", + "text": "委員會審查的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/35.wav", + "text": "委員提了很多意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/36.wav", + "text": "之後我們也跟相關團體" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/37.wav", + "text": "有過一些溝通" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/38.wav", + "text": "最後有一些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/39.wav", + "text": "部分當然" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/40.wav", + "text": "我們有參採委員的意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/41.wav", + "text": "但有些部分我們覺得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/42.wav", + "text": "考試院所提的版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/43.wav", + "text": "\n首先公教人員保險法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/44.wav", + "text": "的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/45.wav", + "text": "審查會有保留兩條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/46.wav", + "text": "其中第十六條主要涉及" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/47.wav", + "text": "公保的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/48.wav", + "text": "養老給付一次養老給付" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/49.wav", + "text": "從42個月調整為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/50.wav", + "text": "48個月" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/51.wav", + "text": "另外就是採計年資" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/52.wav", + "text": "從35年調高為40年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/53.wav", + "text": "在審查過程當中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/54.wav", + "text": "有委員的意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/55.wav", + "text": "在112年新制以後的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/56.wav", + "text": "才做這樣的調整" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/57.wav", + "text": "就不做調整" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/58.wav", + "text": "我們覺得基本上應該還是要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/59.wav", + "text": "新的建議協商條文是希望採" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/60.wav", + "text": "也就是說在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/61.wav", + "text": "公教人員保險法修正條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/62.wav", + "text": "施行以後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/63.wav", + "text": "我們才採計他的年資" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/64.wav", + "text": "逐年採計" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/65.wav", + "text": "一直到最高上限48個月" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/66.wav", + "text": "還有年資採計最高" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/67.wav", + "text": "到40年為止" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/68.wav", + "text": "這樣的一個條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/69.wav", + "text": "第二十一條就可以不用再" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/70.wav", + "text": "修就是一併修正第" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/71.wav", + "text": "上述規定就可以了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/72.wav", + "text": "這是有關於公教人員保險" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/73.wav", + "text": "\n至於公務人員個人專戶制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/74.wav", + "text": "退休資遣撫卹法草案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/75.wav", + "text": "大概保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/76.wav", + "text": "了12個條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/77.wav", + "text": "經過我們跟相關團體溝通" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/78.wav", + "text": "以及審慎研議後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/79.wav", + "text": "大概有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/80.wav", + "text": "4個條文我們考慮" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/81.wav", + "text": "可以參採委員的意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/82.wav", + "text": "就這些保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/83.wav", + "text": "第3條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/84.wav", + "text": "有關適用對象部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/85.wav", + "text": "影響比較不大" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/86.wav", + "text": "如果有三分之一" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/87.wav", + "text": "的現職人員轉換大概會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/88.wav", + "text": "維持在135年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/89.wav", + "text": "但如果年資3年以下者有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/90.wav", + "text": "二分之一現職人員轉換" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/91.wav", + "text": "就會提前到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/92.wav", + "text": "134年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/93.wav", + "text": "全數現職人員轉換也是提前到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/94.wav", + "text": "134年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/95.wav", + "text": "70億元及340億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/96.wav", + "text": "元如果是年資5年以下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/97.wav", + "text": "的人員有三分之一轉換" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/98.wav", + "text": "用罄年度會提前到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/99.wav", + "text": "134年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/100.wav", + "text": "國庫會增加280億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/101.wav", + "text": "元如果是二分之一的現職人員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/102.wav", + "text": "也��提前到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/103.wav", + "text": "134年用罄" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/104.wav", + "text": "罄會增加440億元左右" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/105.wav", + "text": "如果全數" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/106.wav", + "text": "現職人員都轉換" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/107.wav", + "text": "會提前到133年用罄" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/108.wav", + "text": "罄國庫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/109.wav", + "text": "增加的負擔會到850億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/110.wav", + "text": "對基金會有的影響" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/111.wav", + "text": "於10年以上跟15年以上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/112.wav", + "text": "所以並沒有建議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/113.wav", + "text": "這部分的考量" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/114.wav", + "text": "以下的現職轉換都會對現行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/115.wav", + "text": "負擔更增加" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/116.wav", + "text": "我們還是建議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/117.wav", + "text": "現職人員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/118.wav", + "text": "就不要轉換到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/119.wav", + "text": "新制來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/120.wav", + "text": "\n關於第6條及第7條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/121.wav", + "text": "涉及到退撫基金的管理機制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/122.wav", + "text": "來接受" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/123.wav", + "text": "因為這樣比較能夠及時" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/124.wav", + "text": "如果要另外規劃新的組織" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/125.wav", + "text": "跟管理方式其實是緩不濟急" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/126.wav", + "text": "\n有關保留條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/127.wav", + "text": "上限42年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/128.wav", + "text": "我們參採各位委員意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/129.wav", + "text": "做一些調整" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/130.wav", + "text": "基本上這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/131.wav", + "text": "對公務人員來講是合理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/132.wav", + "text": "也是有利的所以我們參採" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/133.wav", + "text": "委員的建議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/134.wav", + "text": "還有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/135.wav", + "text": "已經審查通過的第五十六條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/136.wav", + "text": "也要配合修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/137.wav", + "text": "這部分我們有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/138.wav", + "text": "修正條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/139.wav", + "text": "還可以再提出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/140.wav", + "text": "我們希望還是照考試院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/141.wav", + "text": "通過的版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/142.wav", + "text": "審議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/143.wav", + "text": "另外第二十八條的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/144.wav", + "text": "不再規定每月不得少於5,00" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/145.wav", + "text": "0元且要用千元為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/146.wav", + "text": "為單位這個部分我們也尊重委員的意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/147.wav", + "text": "來進行調整" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/148.wav", + "text": "第33條的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/149.wav", + "text": "主要是有關遺族" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/150.wav", + "text": "委員的建議遺族得選擇" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/151.wav", + "text": "月支領亡故" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/152.wav", + "text": "亡故人員個人專戶內賸餘金額" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/153.wav", + "text": "按月領取期間亡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/154.wav", + "text": "亡故退休人員個人專戶" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/155.wav", + "text": "代為投資" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/156.wav", + "text": "其運用受益不得低於當地銀行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/157.wav", + "text": "二年期定期存款利率" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/158.wav", + "text": "如有不足由國庫補足" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/159.wav", + "text": "之這是我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/160.wav", + "text": "的期待" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/161.wav", + "text": "專戶制的部分大概有12條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/162.wav", + "text": "規定其中有4條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/163.wav", + "text": "我們採納委員建議的意見來做調整" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/164.wav", + "text": "\n另外現行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/165.wav", + "text": "公務人員退休" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/166.wav", + "text": "個人專戶制實施後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/167.wav", + "text": "所造成的財務缺口由" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/168.wav", + "text": "政府依照" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/169.wav", + "text": "精算結果分年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/170.wav", + "text": "該部分由於考量到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/171.wav", + "text": "負擔的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/172.wav", + "text": "謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/173.wav", + "text": "一致的部分先讓行政單位說明完畢再請" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/174.wav", + "text": "委員發言" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/175.wav", + "text": "就委員會審查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/176.wav", + "text": "過程中及我們要求" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/177.wav", + "text": "各位委員教育部就以下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/178.wav", + "text": "兩個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/179.wav", + "text": "第一個部分有關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/180.wav", + "text": "新制當時審查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/181.wav", + "text": "後有保留12條條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/182.wav", + "text": "第二個是針對配套" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/183.wav", + "text": "跟委員報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/184.wav", + "text": "因為公教有很多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/185.wav", + "text": "有特別說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/186.wav", + "text": "因此在這方面等一下我會比較簡要地" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/187.wav", + "text": "地跟委員補充" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/188.wav", + "text": "\n首先針對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/189.wav", + "text": "個人專戶的部分保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/190.wav", + "text": "原本舊制的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/191.wav", + "text": "比如年資不超過10年的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/192.wav", + "text": "也特別請我們做一個分析" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/193.wav", + "text": "因為公跟教確實" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/194.wav", + "text": "不同因此我花一點時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/195.wav", + "text": "跟委員報告目前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/196.wav", + "text": "有關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/197.wav", + "text": "公立學校的部分原本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/198.wav", + "text": "民國137年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/199.wav", + "text": "有二分之一轉換" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/200.wav", + "text": "話用罄年限變化不大" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/201.wav", + "text": "是130億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/202.wav", + "text": "就會提早一年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/203.wav", + "text": "經費是260億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/204.wav", + "text": "元如果以5年做一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/205.wav", + "text": "設算有二分之一現職人員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/206.wav", + "text": "的話延後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/207.wav", + "text": "的時間不變但" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/208.wav", + "text": "增加金額為220億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/209.wav", + "text": "轉換的話就會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/210.wav", + "text": "提前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/211.wav", + "text": "是440億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/212.wav", + "text": "有二分之一轉換的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/213.wav", + "text": "就會提前到132" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/214.wav", + "text": "2年即提前一年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/215.wav", + "text": "所需經費是440億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/216.wav", + "text": "年資15年以下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/217.wav", + "text": "的這部分即使二分之一轉換" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/218.wav", + "text": "也會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/219.wav", + "text": "再提前2年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/220.wav", + "text": "如果是全數轉換" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/221.wav", + "text": "就會提前到129年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/222.wav", + "text": "這個影響當然就更大" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/223.wav", + "text": "所需經費分別是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/224.wav", + "text": "提醒我們做的教育人員試算部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/225.wav", + "text": "這跟公務人員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/226.wav", + "text": "部分還是有一些差異" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/227.wav", + "text": "相關的數據就如" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/228.wav", + "text": "同向委員報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/229.wav", + "text": "的內容\n針對第6條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/230.wav", + "text": "都希望能夠提高教職員代表" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/231.wav", + "text": "不要少於三分之二" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/232.wav", + "text": "學者專家機關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/233.wav", + "text": "及教師組織代表" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/234.wav", + "text": "但是教育人員的組成可能比公務人員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/235.wav", + "text": "要達到三分之二的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/236.wav", + "text": "教職員代表及學者專家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/237.wav", + "text": "在整個實務結構上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/238.wav", + "text": "但是我們有試算過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/239.wav", + "text": "是有機會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/240.wav", + "text": "的彈性可能比較不足因此建" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/241.wav", + "text": "但在實際執行上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/242.wav", + "text": "的因為這都關係到教職員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/243.wav", + "text": "應該要有更高比例的參與" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/244.wav", + "text": "我們覺得這個方向是有必要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/245.wav", + "text": "的但那個比例可能研訂在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/246.wav", + "text": "\n第7條的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/247.wav", + "text": "基金管理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/248.wav", + "text": "甚至提到教育部本身" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/249.wav", + "text": "教育部針對這部分的分析是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/250.wav", + "text": "還是能夠由具" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/251.wav", + "text": "公法性質的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/252.wav", + "text": "機構來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/253.wav", + "text": "比較能夠合理課責跟監督" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/254.wav", + "text": "我也要跟委員報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/255.wav", + "text": "如果以那個基金額度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/256.wav", + "text": "又要另立一個專門管" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/257.wav", + "text": "操作都是一個難題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/258.wav", + "text": "還是維持委託" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/259.wav", + "text": "目前的基管會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/260.wav", + "text": "等各方面我們會努力達成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/261.wav", + "text": "教育部的評估" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/262.wav", + "text": "用這樣的方式比較能夠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/263.wav", + "text": "管理跟監督" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/264.wav", + "text": "以及連帶的第十六條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/265.wav", + "text": "周部長向委員做了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/266.wav", + "text": "應該也會同步" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/267.wav", + "text": "委員也有提到相" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/268.wav", + "text": "更適切的調整" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/269.wav", + "text": "\n有關第十一條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/270.wav", + "text": "周部長的建議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/271.wav", + "text": "另外有幾個相關的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/272.wav", + "text": "條文第十二條第三十三" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/273.wav", + "text": "未滿5年離職" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/274.wav", + "text": "相關經費還保留在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/275.wav", + "text": "可以準用自主投資因" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/276.wav", + "text": "因為他的錢還沒領回去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/277.wav", + "text": "可不可以這樣思考" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/278.wav", + "text": "其實未滿5年的額度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/279.wav", + "text": "這些經費不高以外" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/280.wav", + "text": "另外也考量到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/281.wav", + "text": "有更高的風險" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/282.wav", + "text": "對於已離職人員的考量" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/283.wav", + "text": "剛才銓敘部周部長所提的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/284.wav", + "text": "一樣我們建議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/285.wav", + "text": "維持原來行政院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/286.wav", + "text": "\n關於第29條剛才周部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/287.wav", + "text": "也有報告的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/288.wav", + "text": "教育部也會同步" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/289.wav", + "text": "限制得太嚴格" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/290.wav", + "text": "毫無彈性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/291.wav", + "text": "在條文審查的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/292.wav", + "text": "我們再跟委員一起會商指教" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/293.wav", + "text": "能夠再做一點彈性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/294.wav", + "text": "處理這樣應該會更" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/295.wav", + "text": "剛才周部長也提到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/296.wav", + "text": "部分原來院版" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/297.wav", + "text": "確實是比較好意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/298.wav", + "text": "的但是有點太過把它" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/299.wav", + "text": "也會跟銓敘" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/300.wav", + "text": "如果這部分也能夠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/301.wav", + "text": "個人專戶的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/302.wav", + "text": "跟委員做報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/303.wav", + "text": "\n另外一個是原來舊制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/304.wav", + "text": "舊制的配套" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/305.wav", + "text": "了主要是在整個財務的相關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/306.wav", + "text": "規劃跟撥補的機制上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/307.wav", + "text": "我想這部分是不是也能夠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/308.wav", + "text": "行政院版以上這兩部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/309.wav", + "text": "謝謝兩位部長的說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/310.wav", + "text": "我想確認一下各位委員都有拿到他們今天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/311.wav", + "text": "準備的這些條文資料嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/312.wav", + "text": "謝謝主席" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/313.wav", + "text": "銓敘部及教育部的部長都在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/314.wav", + "text": "今天我們在協調這個法案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/315.wav", + "text": "我從第三第四會期" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/316.wav", + "text": "一直到現在都持續關注" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/317.wav", + "text": "這個議題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/318.wav", + "text": "我們感覺到不夠明確" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/319.wav", + "text": "不夠清楚為什麼呢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/320.wav", + "text": "有關財務精算的制度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/321.wav", + "text": "方向作業期程" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/322.wav", + "text": "這些都沒有很明確" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/323.wav", + "text": "我想朝野立委辦公室都有接到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/324.wav", + "text": "很多現職跟退休" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/325.wav", + "text": "公務人員老師的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/326.wav", + "text": "建議跟質疑" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/327.wav", + "text": "所以我們今天作為民意代表" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/328.wav", + "text": "在這邊再次提出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/329.wav", + "text": "銓敘部在草案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/330.wav", + "text": "擬定的時候一再地宣稱" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/331.wav", + "text": "政府會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/332.wav", + "text": "負最終支付保證責任" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/333.wav", + "text": "我們從年改的時候吵到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/334.wav", + "text": "現在這麼多年了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/335.wav", + "text": "年金改革之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/336.wav", + "text": "實質損失" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/337.wav", + "text": "已經造成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/338.wav", + "text": "我要特別在這裡先說一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/339.wav", + "text": "當年年金改革" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/340.wav", + "text": "時我是退伍軍人代表" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/341.wav", + "text": "我全程參與" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/342.wav", + "text": "年改會議包含街頭" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/343.wav", + "text": "抗爭一直到現在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/344.wav", + "text": "所以我對這些事情的來龍去脈" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/345.wav", + "text": "非常地清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/346.wav", + "text": "\n我想先提幾個具體" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/347.wav", + "text": "的建議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/348.wav", + "text": "根據銓敘部委外辦理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/349.wav", + "text": "第八次的精算報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/350.wav", + "text": "中112年7月1日" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/351.wav", + "text": "以後新進的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/352.wav", + "text": "公務人員會採" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/353.wav", + "text": "新的退撫制度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/354.wav", + "text": "但是對現行的退撫制度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/355.wav", + "text": "會有一定的衝擊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/356.wav", + "text": "也就是現行的退撫基金" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/357.wav", + "text": "會提前發生收不抵支的狀況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/358.wav", + "text": "剛才部長也有說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/359.wav", + "text": "會提前破產" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/360.wav", + "text": "但是我看到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/361.wav", + "text": "你們對於新產生的資金破口" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/362.wav", + "text": "有編列預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/363.wav", + "text": "來挹注" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/364.wav", + "text": "可是對現制的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/365.wav", + "text": "就沒有了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/366.wav", + "text": "和公立學校的教職人員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/367.wav", + "text": "相關的法案修正條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/368.wav", + "text": "這一些能不能在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/369.wav", + "text": "舊制的撥補機制裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/370.wav", + "text": "確定財源" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/371.wav", + "text": "這是多數公教" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/372.wav", + "text": "人員的心聲" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/373.wav", + "text": "我希望各位委員給予支持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/374.wav", + "text": "是投資報酬率" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/375.wav", + "text": "我們原來有監理委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/376.wav", + "text": "管理委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/377.wav", + "text": "但問題不在這個機制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/378.wav", + "text": "而是在你的績效" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/379.wav", + "text": "跟球員兼裁判" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/380.wav", + "text": "的問題現在都沒有明確界定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/381.wav", + "text": "你現在又要成立一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/382.wav", + "text": "基金管理局" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/383.wav", + "text": "這個我們認為不妥當" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/384.wav", + "text": "退休資遣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/385.wav", + "text": "撫卹的權益" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/386.wav", + "text": "我希望要經過充分討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/387.wav", + "text": "因為新成立一個組織" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/388.wav", + "text": "很多問題相對會產生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/389.wav", + "text": "我想這個茲事體大" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/390.wav", + "text": "在一個制度轉換的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/391.wav", + "text": "上剛才我聽" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/392.wav", + "text": "兩位部長也有提到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/393.wav", + "text": "這是一個新制轉換的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/394.wav", + "text": "機制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/395.wav", + "text": "不管是確定給付制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/396.wav", + "text": "或確定提撥制都沒有100%" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/397.wav", + "text": "的優劣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/398.wav", + "text": "不一定都能賺錢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/399.wav", + "text": "關鍵是政府的效率與誠信" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/400.wav", + "text": "\n這個案子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/401.wav", + "text": "我們希望你從公務人員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/402.wav", + "text": "個人專戶制退撫法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/403.wav", + "text": "教職員個人專戶制退撫法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/404.wav", + "text": "都有律定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/405.wav", + "text": "這件事情我們希望的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/406.wav", + "text": "這些公教人員希望的是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/407.wav", + "text": "給他們一個選擇的機會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/408.wav", + "text": "他們自己選擇" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/409.wav", + "text": "要加入不加入" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/410.wav", + "text": "然後自負盈虧" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/411.wav", + "text": "又不增加政府的負擔" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/412.wav", + "text": "不增加你的預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/413.wav", + "text": "為什麼要堅持不同意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/414.wav", + "text": "你們願不願意做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/415.wav", + "text": "的問題很多朝野立委都有相關的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/416.wav", + "text": "提案你讓他有機會選" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/417.wav", + "text": "我是這個制度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/418.wav", + "text": "新舊交替的邊緣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/419.wav", + "text": "我願意這樣子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/420.wav", + "text": "我負全責不要政府負責" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/421.wav", + "text": "為什麼不可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/422.wav", + "text": "\n以上幾個說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/423.wav", + "text": "希望朝野立委都能夠站在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/424.wav", + "text": "我要提醒兩位部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/425.wav", + "text": "軍公教" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/426.wav", + "text": "警是國家的四大支柱" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/427.wav", + "text": "要讓他願意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/428.wav", + "text": "為政府效力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/429.wav", + "text": "優秀人才願意來當公務員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/430.wav", + "text": "現職的惶惶不安" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/431.wav", + "text": "未來年輕人還願不願意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/432.wav", + "text": "當公務員當老師" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/433.wav", + "text": "我想兩位部長要從國家層級思考" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/434.wav", + "text": "政府對這" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/435.wav", + "text": "四類族群現在是談公教" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/436.wav", + "text": "對他們的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/437.wav", + "text": "未來現在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/438.wav", + "text": "及將來要幹公教人員的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/439.wav", + "text": "他有沒有信心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/440.wav", + "text": "建議從這幾個角度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/441.wav", + "text": "透過民意代表" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/442.wav", + "text": "讓各位聽到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/443.wav", + "text": "我也建議朝野立委大家一起支持這個案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/444.wav", + "text": "給公教人員一點鼓勵" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/445.wav", + "text": "及對願景的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/446.wav", + "text": "確認信任度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/447.wav", + "text": "也就是政府的誠信" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/448.wav", + "text": "謝謝主席今天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/449.wav", + "text": "安排這次的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/450.wav", + "text": "黨團協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/451.wav", + "text": "我們今天要協商的是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/452.wav", + "text": "112年重行建立" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/453.wav", + "text": "個人專戶退撫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/454.wav", + "text": "制度包裹的四個法案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/455.wav", + "text": "也經過我們委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/456.wav", + "text": "的審查跟公聽會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/457.wav", + "text": "發現有疑慮" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/458.wav", + "text": "銓敘部也表達過可能有調整的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/459.wav", + "text": "空間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/460.wav", + "text": "\n本席有三個問題想請教銓敘部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/461.wav", + "text": "希望之前承諾" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/462.wav", + "text": "鬆口有調整空間的方向" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/463.wav", + "text": "是真的有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/464.wav", + "text": "空間不要重蹈" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/465.wav", + "text": "審查公務員服務法的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/466.wav", + "text": "覆轍" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/467.wav", + "text": "每次在會議上說要聽委員的意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/468.wav", + "text": "重要的疑問會去釐清" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/469.wav", + "text": "但是到最後我們發現都是虛晃" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/470.wav", + "text": "所以請各位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/471.wav", + "text": "能夠明確" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/472.wav", + "text": "回答本席的議題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/473.wav", + "text": "如果沒有明確" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/474.wav", + "text": "的善意回應本席" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/475.wav", + "text": "認為今天的協商其實就不應該" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/476.wav", + "text": "再開下去\n" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/477.wav", + "text": "剛剛其實" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/478.wav", + "text": "吳委員也有提到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/479.wav", + "text": "自從第八次公務員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/480.wav", + "text": "退撫基金的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/481.wav", + "text": "精算報告在7月公布" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/482.wav", + "text": "之後幾乎所有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/483.wav", + "text": "的退休團體都在訴求" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/484.wav", + "text": "精算報告建議好幾個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/485.wav", + "text": "撥補方案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/486.wav", + "text": "以前的公教人員退撫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/487.wav", + "text": "基金撥補各100億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/488.wav", + "text": "元大概可以撐到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/489.wav", + "text": "140年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/490.wav", + "text": "如果對公務人員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/491.wav", + "text": "元公立教職員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/492.wav", + "text": "達到永續" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/493.wav", + "text": "今年11月16日" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/494.wav", + "text": "我們看到退撫基金" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/495.wav", + "text": "監理會作成決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/496.wav", + "text": "金額撥補" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/497.wav", + "text": "爭取但是本席看到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/498.wav", + "text": "那次的監理會周部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/499.wav", + "text": "跟監理委員在爭執" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/500.wav", + "text": "要使用通過還是參考" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/501.wav", + "text": "最後使用參考" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/502.wav", + "text": "所以本席擔心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/503.wav", + "text": "這是不是就像立法院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/504.wav", + "text": "裡面所通過的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/505.wav", + "text": "主決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/506.wav", + "text": "到最後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/507.wav", + "text": "什麼都做不到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/508.wav", + "text": "也沒有什麼拘束力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/509.wav", + "text": "退休軍公教族群都在問" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/510.wav", + "text": "銓敘部究竟" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/511.wav", + "text": "會撥補多少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/512.wav", + "text": "還是會延續" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/513.wav", + "text": "107年年改以來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/514.wav", + "text": "一毛錢都不撥補" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/515.wav", + "text": "勞保基金相比" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/516.wav", + "text": "勞保在政府宣示" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/517.wav", + "text": "最後支付責任" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/518.wav", + "text": "是由政府來擔負之下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/519.wav", + "text": "109年撥補了200億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/520.wav", + "text": "元110年220億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/521.wav", + "text": "元111年300億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/522.wav", + "text": "元112年還要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/523.wav", + "text": "編450億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/524.wav", + "text": "周部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/525.wav", + "text": "您在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/526.wav", + "text": "司委會做了很多次的宣示" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/527.wav", + "text": "因為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/528.wav", + "text": "公務員的退撫基金" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/529.wav", + "text": "最後也跟勞保基金一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/530.wav", + "text": "是由政府來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/531.wav", + "text": "負起最後的支付責任" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/532.wav", + "text": "沒錯" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/533.wav", + "text": "\n我們所得替代率" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/534.wav", + "text": "從107年開始逐年下降" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/535.wav", + "text": "這是剝第一層皮" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/536.wav", + "text": "銓敘部今年2月" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/537.wav", + "text": "宣示公教" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/538.wav", + "text": "保險部分研" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/539.wav", + "text": "研議要比照退撫基金" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/540.wav", + "text": "調2%有機會調升" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/541.wav", + "text": "結果沒有下文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/542.wav", + "text": "這是剝第二層皮" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/543.wav", + "text": "112年起" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/544.wav", + "text": "退撫基金提撥" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/545.wav", + "text": "從14%提升到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/546.wav", + "text": "15%" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/547.wav", + "text": "年金給付是沒有增加的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/548.wav", + "text": "個人自繳部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/549.wav", + "text": "隨之提升" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/550.wav", + "text": "依照俸點每個人要多繳" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/551.wav", + "text": "348元至" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/552.wav", + "text": "1,810元不等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/553.wav", + "text": "這是再剝一層" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/554.wav", + "text": "第三層皮" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/555.wav", + "text": "\n今天我們協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/556.wav", + "text": "公務人員退休資遣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/557.wav", + "text": "撫卹法第93條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/558.wav", + "text": "公立學校教職員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/559.wav", + "text": "退休資遣撫卹條例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/560.wav", + "text": "第98條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/561.wav", + "text": "考試院版就是把政府提案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/562.wav", + "text": "的撥補責任" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/563.wav", + "text": "限縮在建立個人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/564.wav", + "text": "帳戶新制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/565.wav", + "text": "帶來的虧損" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/566.wav", + "text": "誠如本席前面所敘述的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/567.wav", + "text": "我們至少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/568.wav", + "text": "已經被剝了三層皮" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/569.wav", + "text": "如果再這樣限制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/570.wav", + "text": "不就是剝到第四層" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/571.wav", + "text": "獨厚勞保" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/572.wav", + "text": "獨厚勞工" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/573.wav", + "text": "公教就該死嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/574.wav", + "text": "到底我們還可以被剝幾層皮" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/575.wav", + "text": "當然本席也要肯定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/576.wav", + "text": "周部長也提到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/577.wav", + "text": "我們現場的修正案已經刪除4" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/578.wav", + "text": "論述也改為比較正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/579.wav", + "text": "你們在這部分的努力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/580.wav", + "text": "但是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/581.wav", + "text": "跟勞保的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/582.wav", + "text": "差距是如此的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/583.wav", + "text": "天差地別" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/584.wav", + "text": "軍公教團體" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/585.wav", + "text": "退休團體" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/586.wav", + "text": "也拒絕去協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/587.wav", + "text": "因為我們在公聽會上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/588.wav", + "text": "有聽到部長告訴大家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/589.wav", + "text": "個人專戶新制的管理組織" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/590.wav", + "text": "還沒有定案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/591.wav", + "text": "但是今年9月" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/592.wav", + "text": "監理會就在進行考試院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/593.wav", + "text": "內部的法制作業程序" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/594.wav", + "text": "所以到底有定案還是沒有定案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/595.wav", + "text": "難道又在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/596.wav", + "text": "騙立法委員嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/597.wav", + "text": "\n有關個人專戶新制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/598.wav", + "text": "要交由什麼管理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/599.wav", + "text": "組織來經營" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/600.wav", + "text": "各種版本主張非常多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/601.wav", + "text": "有的委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/602.wav", + "text": "認為交給臺灣銀行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/603.wav", + "text": "考試院版是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/604.wav", + "text": "給現有的管理會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/605.wav", + "text": "或是另設新組織的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/606.wav", + "text": "空間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/607.wav", + "text": "本席其實已經講過非常" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/608.wav", + "text": "多次我覺得教育部的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/609.wav", + "text": "營運的非常好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/610.wav", + "text": "我們有沒有機會可以做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/611.wav", + "text": "4月28日公聽會上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/612.wav", + "text": "周部長親口說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/613.wav", + "text": "你們廣納意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/614.wav", + "text": "不會堅持己見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/615.wav", + "text": "你們也會做一些組織調整" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/616.wav", + "text": "所以未必將來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/617.wav", + "text": "就一定會再採取" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/618.wav", + "text": "現在的委員會制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/619.wav", + "text": "可能會做一些組織調整" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/620.wav", + "text": "讓利害關係" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/621.wav", + "text": "人及團體來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/622.wav", + "text": "參與" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/623.wav", + "text": "本席其實也提過好多次的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/624.wav", + "text": "希望在你們的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/625.wav", + "text": "管理委員會裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/626.wav", + "text": "能夠讓退休" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/627.wav", + "text": "警消都能" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/628.wav", + "text": "有足夠的代表員額在裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/629.wav", + "text": "銓敘部在立法院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/630.wav", + "text": "跟立法委員退休團體說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/631.wav", + "text": "個人帳戶的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/632.wav", + "text": "經營組織" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/633.wav", + "text": "還在調整不會堅持己政" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/634.wav", + "text": "可是在9月16日" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/635.wav", + "text": "監理會報告組織法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/636.wav", + "text": "要改制的草案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/637.wav", + "text": "又把現行的基金管理委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/638.wav", + "text": "改制成管理局" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/639.wav", + "text": "要增加大概40人的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/640.wav", + "text": "編制員額" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/641.wav", + "text": "所以左手" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/642.wav", + "text": "還在跟我們協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/643.wav", + "text": "本來還有可能" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/644.wav", + "text": "委託臺銀委託私校儲金" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/645.wav", + "text": "或改組現行的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/646.wav", + "text": "管理會納入退休團體" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/647.wav", + "text": "推薦的代表等等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/648.wav", + "text": "這些對案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/649.wav", + "text": "是全部都否決了嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/650.wav", + "text": "所以你們主要的訴求" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/651.wav", + "text": "就是要成立管理局嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/652.wav", + "text": "這樣說來我們今天到底有多少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/653.wav", + "text": "協商的空間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/654.wav", + "text": "所謂的不會堅持己見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/655.wav", + "text": "己見真的是如此嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/656.wav", + "text": "難道是要我們來當" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/657.wav", + "text": "你們的橡皮圖章嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/658.wav", + "text": "以上的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/659.wav", + "text": "具體回答" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/660.wav", + "text": "如果沒有明確善意的回應" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/661.wav", + "text": "本席累了準備回去了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/662.wav", + "text": "謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/663.wav", + "text": "請周部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/664.wav", + "text": "剛剛兩位委員的提問" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/665.wav", + "text": "有關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/666.wav", + "text": "游委員剛剛提的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/667.wav", + "text": "我想我必須要再一次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/668.wav", + "text": "說明清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/669.wav", + "text": "首先有關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/670.wav", + "text": "撥補的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/671.wav", + "text": "因為銓敘部提出了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/672.wav", + "text": "新的個人帳戶制退休撫卹" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/673.wav", + "text": "這個是一定要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/674.wav", + "text": "撥補" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/675.wav", + "text": "因為這是政府制度改革造成的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/676.wav", + "text": "至於原有基金的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/677.wav", + "text": "這個一定是要看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/678.wav", + "text": "國家整體的財政狀況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/679.wav", + "text": "銓敘部本身" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/680.wav", + "text": "撥補的權限" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/681.wav", + "text": "來做決定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/682.wav", + "text": "但是我們確實一直在跟" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/683.wav", + "text": "希望能夠對現制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/684.wav", + "text": "定額的撥補" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/685.wav", + "text": "來解決" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/686.wav", + "text": "讓它能夠更加朝向" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/687.wav", + "text": "永續經營" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/688.wav", + "text": "這個是我們一直在努力的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/689.wav", + "text": "\n當天退撫基金監理會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/690.wav", + "text": "在討論的是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/691.wav", + "text": "監理會到底有沒有權力決定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/692.wav", + "text": "還是我們只是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/693.wav", + "text": "有建議權而已" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/694.wav", + "text": "因為監理會本身的權責裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/695.wav", + "text": "並沒有辦法決定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/696.wav", + "text": "──周弘憲副院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/697.wav", + "text": "才會建議說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/698.wav", + "text": "用參考" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/699.wav", + "text": "跟行政院爭取做最大" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/700.wav", + "text": "可能的撥補" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/701.wav", + "text": "但這不是我們監理會的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/702.wav", + "text": "權限也不是銓敘部能夠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/703.wav", + "text": "做決定的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/704.wav", + "text": "行政院協商的過程當中也有一再地提出" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/705.wav", + "text": "這是要先說明的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/706.wav", + "text": "\n第二個有關退撫基金組織的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/707.wav", + "text": "調整確實" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/708.wav", + "text": "委員有很多建議的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/709.wav", + "text": "版本但我們評估" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/710.wav", + "text": "最可能立即上手的大概就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/711.wav", + "text": "現有的退撫基金" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/712.wav", + "text": "管理委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/713.wav", + "text": "決策效率" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/714.wav", + "text": "並不是特別好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/715.wav", + "text": "特別是像退撫基金管理委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/716.wav", + "text": "是由銓敘部部長兼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/717.wav", + "text": "主任委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/718.wav", + "text": "財經專業人士" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/719.wav", + "text": "管理委員會做決策的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/720.wav", + "text": "加上管理委員會又是一個合議制的組織" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/721.wav", + "text": "所有決策都要經過合議制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/722.wav", + "text": "議制委員會通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/723.wav", + "text": "很多投資決策的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/724.wav", + "text": "效率是比較差的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/725.wav", + "text": "所以經過考試院內部的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/726.wav", + "text": "認為先把它改成管理局" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/727.wav", + "text": "的組織形態" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/728.wav", + "text": "並配合新制儲金的管理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/729.wav", + "text": "儲金的管理方式就必須要增加員額" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/730.wav", + "text": "也趁這個機會來調整" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/731.wav", + "text": "讓它決策能夠比較有效率" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/732.wav", + "text": "銓敘部部長不再兼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/733.wav", + "text": "退撫基金管理委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/734.wav", + "text": "的主任委員讓專業人士" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/735.wav", + "text": "銓敘部將來就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/736.wav", + "text": "做監理的工作" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/737.wav", + "text": "\n在監理委員會我們會儘量讓" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/738.wav", + "text": "所有利害關係人都能夠參與" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/739.wav", + "text": "監理甚至在投資" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/740.wav", + "text": "上我們也可以參採他們的意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/741.wav", + "text": "但是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/742.wav", + "text": "運作相對來講好像" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/743.wav", + "text": "效益" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/744.wav", + "text": "其實是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/745.wav", + "text": "不如我們退撫基金的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/746.wav", + "text": "所以如果要參採私法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/747.wav", + "text": "型態來管理公部門的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/748.wav", + "text": "退休撫卹基金" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/749.wav", + "text": "應該也不會太放心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/750.wav", + "text": "比較不好的情況下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/751.wav", + "text": "其實它的投資收益是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/752.wav", + "text": "低很多的比我們退撫基金" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/753.wav", + "text": "績效還要差很多所以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/754.wav", + "text": "是不是那麼可靠我覺得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/755.wav", + "text": "還是要重新考量因此我們不建議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/756.wav", + "text": "採納私校退撫基金" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/757.wav", + "text": "來代為操作" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/758.wav", + "text": "的方式\n但是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/759.wav", + "text": "臺銀本身沒有意願我們確實有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/760.wav", + "text": "徵詢過臺銀現在在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/761.wav", + "text": "今年的績效表現也不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/762.wav", + "text": "退撫儲金" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/763.wav", + "text": "不是我們沒有努力過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/764.wav", + "text": "而是我們嘗試過但基本上是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/765.wav", + "text": "不可行所以才會朝向" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/766.wav", + "text": "退撫基金的組織來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/767.wav", + "text": "提高它將來的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/768.wav", + "text": "這是我們在做的\n確實" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/769.wav", + "text": "也是最近才定案因為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/770.wav", + "text": "考試院沒有通過這些組織調整" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/771.wav", + "text": "的都是我們銓敘部跟" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/772.wav", + "text": "退撫基金管理委員會在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/773.wav", + "text": "研議中確實" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/774.wav", + "text": "調整公務人員退休" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/775.wav", + "text": "退撫基金" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/776.wav", + "text": "管理局還有銓敘部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/777.wav", + "text": "組織法的相關配套" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/778.wav", + "text": "最近考試院才剛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/779.wav", + "text": "決議通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/780.wav", + "text": "很快地送到大院來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/781.wav", + "text": "審議這是配合整個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/782.wav", + "text": "112年新制的配套措施" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/783.wav", + "text": "委員還可以再做指教謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/784.wav", + "text": "所以部長的說法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/785.wav", + "text": "是對於" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/786.wav", + "text": "基金的撥補" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/787.wav", + "text": "你們完全無能為力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/788.wav", + "text": "都是在行政院這邊行政院置之" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/789.wav", + "text": "不理就是了是不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/790.wav", + "text": "因為這個數據我剛剛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/791.wav", + "text": "我們有提過如果對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/792.wav", + "text": "公務員的退撫基金" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/793.wav", + "text": "撥補" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/794.wav", + "text": "285億元公立" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/795.wav", + "text": "教職員的基金" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/796.wav", + "text": "億元就可以達到永續" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/797.wav", + "text": "這個是沒有問題的對不" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/798.wav", + "text": "對這個數據是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/799.wav", + "text": "真的但是中華民國" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/800.wav", + "text": "政府的行政院是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/801.wav", + "text": "置之不理的他們眼中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/802.wav", + "text": "只有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/803.wav", + "text": "我們看到勞保109" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/804.wav", + "text": "年撥補200億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/805.wav", + "text": "元110年220億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/806.wav", + "text": "元111年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/807.wav", + "text": "300億元112年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/808.wav", + "text": "450億元沒錯嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/809.wav", + "text": "我講的這些都沒錯對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/810.wav", + "text": "那我只好號召所有退休" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/811.wav", + "text": "軍公教再" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/812.wav", + "text": "出來抗暴" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/813.wav", + "text": "反抗這個暴政對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/814.wav", + "text": "謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/815.wav", + "text": "鄭正鈐委員跟范雲委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/816.wav", + "text": "也到了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/817.wav", + "text": "不知道大家剛才有沒有看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/818.wav", + "text": "分別就委員會審查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/819.wav", + "text": "相關的議題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/820.wav", + "text": "讓幾位委員分別來發問" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/821.wav", + "text": "我們是不是就依照一樣的程序請" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/822.wav", + "text": "兩位委員就你們所關心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/823.wav", + "text": "有發新的建議部分大家都" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/824.wav", + "text": "有拿到吧哪一位要先" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/825.wav", + "text": "謝謝主席關於" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/826.wav", + "text": "保險法部分條文修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/827.wav", + "text": "公務人員個人專戶" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/828.wav", + "text": "的部分我對於第3條比較有一些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/829.wav", + "text": "有很多細節想要討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/830.wav", + "text": "已經在職的公務人員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/831.wav", + "text": "也加入新法所訂定的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/832.wav", + "text": "個人專戶制退休制度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/833.wav", + "text": "現有的公教人員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/834.wav", + "text": "看他們是不是要加入我覺得這是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/835.wav", + "text": "很重要的一個部分至於" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/836.wav", + "text": "的幾個理由包括財政負擔" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/837.wav", + "text": "都是可以解決的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/838.wav", + "text": "公務人員給他們一個選擇權" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/839.wav", + "text": "我覺得這是我們在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/840.wav", + "text": "謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/841.wav", + "text": "剛才有唸一些數字出來試算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/842.wav", + "text": "不管公跟教" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/843.wav", + "text": "可能" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/844.wav", + "text": "會後我再請他們提供其他相關的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/845.wav", + "text": "我是認為這可以討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/846.wav", + "text": "但是他有很多不同條件類型" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/847.wav", + "text": "然後政府要多負擔的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/848.wav", + "text": "費用是不等的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/849.wav", + "text": "協商時大家再來把這些數字共同" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/850.wav", + "text": "等一下我請他回應你的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/851.wav", + "text": "大概就這一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/852.wav", + "text": "我的問題也相關可不可以一起" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/853.wav", + "text": "委之前我辦公室有請銓" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/854.wav", + "text": "應該要精算出數字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/855.wav", + "text": "我還沒看到現場的資料" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/856.wav", + "text": "之前我辦公室給我的資料" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/857.wav", + "text": "我覺得還是滿" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/858.wav", + "text": "符合我原來的訴求" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/859.wav", + "text": "也就是應該要給" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/860.wav", + "text": "年輕的現職人員一個轉換的機會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/861.wav", + "text": "模仿勞退新舊制轉換" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/862.wav", + "text": "和跟教育部之前都有在媒體報導" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/863.wav", + "text": "新退撫制度所得替代率會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/864.wav", + "text": "高過現制既沒有增加" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/865.wav", + "text": "政府負擔又沒有現制破產的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/866.wav", + "text": "如果只適用於112年以後新進" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/867.wav", + "text": "沒有提供選擇權" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/868.wav", + "text": "的年輕公務人員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/869.wav", + "text": "算出來的數字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/870.wav", + "text": "我們是不是能夠爭取" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/871.wav", + "text": "開放讓年資5年內" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/872.wav", + "text": "的人員結清轉換" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/873.wav", + "text": "而且就要求他在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/874.wav", + "text": "新制上路的一年內做出決定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/875.wav", + "text": "我想一年的時間夠長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/876.wav", + "text": "比較年輕新進來的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/877.wav", + "text": "人不會覺得相對剝奪感" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/878.wav", + "text": "理性的選擇當然" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/879.wav", + "text": "不曉得你們評估起來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/880.wav", + "text": "上限的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/881.wav", + "text": "人數也沒有那麼多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/882.wav", + "text": "你訂在那邊非常奇怪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/883.wav", + "text": "超過42年年資的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/884.wav", + "text": "雇主仍然要負起繼續提撥" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/885.wav", + "text": "我們政府是公教人員的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/886.wav", + "text": "雇主就不應該逃避" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/887.wav", + "text": "很少數年資" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/888.wav", + "text": "42年以上的提撥責任" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/889.wav", + "text": "我是覺得這個他們已經" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/890.wav", + "text": "接受了已經接受了在剛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/891.wav", + "text": "剛發的資料裡面不好意思" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/892.wav", + "text": "那太好了所以這點你們已經接受了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/893.wav", + "text": "有聽我講過我覺得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/894.wav", + "text": "裡面政府可以增額" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/895.wav", + "text": "提撥做為獎勵的機制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/896.wav", + "text": "就是第9條第2項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/897.wav", + "text": "有操作上的困難" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/898.wav", + "text": "周部長是不是能夠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/899.wav", + "text": "看看到底要怎麼處理或是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/900.wav", + "text": "增加自願增額提撥等等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/901.wav", + "text": "可以取消上限" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/902.wav", + "text": "獎勵機制的部分尤其是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/903.wav", + "text": "教育高教留才因為我們現在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/904.wav", + "text": "退休金又砍了你現在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/905.wav", + "text": "不是長期的預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/906.wav", + "text": "有這個彈性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/907.wav", + "text": "\n另外比較小的議題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/908.wav", + "text": "明訂退撫儲金運用範圍" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/909.wav", + "text": "跟自主投資的相關規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/910.wav", + "text": "增加退休金領取的彈性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/911.wav", + "text": "資遣之公務員若申請" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/912.wav", + "text": "暫不請領退撫儲金" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/913.wav", + "text": "應該准許他辦理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/914.wav", + "text": "自主投資並自負盈虧" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/915.wav", + "text": "比較小的事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/916.wav", + "text": "今天如果能回應的話是不是能回應" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/917.wav", + "text": "修正動議是針對第" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/918.wav", + "text": "57條我後來發現" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/919.wav", + "text": "調查確定的我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/920.wav", + "text": "第57條有個修正動議待會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/921.wav", + "text": "我們認為原本只有說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/922.wav", + "text": "教職員在職期間涉有校園" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/923.wav", + "text": "性侵害案件先行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/924.wav", + "text": "退休資遣或離職後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/925.wav", + "text": "始經判處有期徒刑以上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/926.wav", + "text": "之刑確定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/927.wav", + "text": "應自始剝奪其" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/928.wav", + "text": "個人專戶等等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/929.wav", + "text": "就是剝奪他的退休金" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/930.wav", + "text": "的性平小組" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/931.wav", + "text": "確定就應該要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/932.wav", + "text": "做因為現在判刑確定的時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/933.wav", + "text": "會拖得非常長所以我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/934.wav", + "text": "希望能夠增加或" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/935.wav", + "text": "經學校性別平等教育委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/936.wav", + "text": "組成之相關委員會調查確認" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/937.wav", + "text": "有性侵害行為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/938.wav", + "text": "屬實並經主管" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/939.wav", + "text": "機關核准解聘者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/940.wav", + "text": "所以這裡面已經有兩層" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/941.wav", + "text": "應該要這樣處理會比較" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/942.wav", + "text": "合理否則會變成一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/943.wav", + "text": "漏洞因為這裡已經講得很明確" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/944.wav", + "text": "是性侵害案件" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/945.wav", + "text": "總之這部分希望" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/946.wav", + "text": "大家可以支持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/947.wav", + "text": "來回應一下范雲委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/948.wav", + "text": "因為范委員剛剛講的有一些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/949.wav", + "text": "爭點其實他們已經有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/950.wav", + "text": "至於你最後所提的修正動議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/951.wav", + "text": "因為我們要處理的是明年開始" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/952.wav", + "text": "適用的退撫新制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/953.wav", + "text": "新制他們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/954.wav", + "text": "要被剝奪退休金" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/955.wav", + "text": "可能還有很長一段時間才會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/956.wav", + "text": "出現" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/957.wav", + "text": "我們是不是可以不要在這個制度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/958.wav", + "text": "要建立的時候來做因為那是會連動" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/959.wav", + "text": "的不可能只改這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/960.wav", + "text": "然後舊制那個部分不去改" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/961.wav", + "text": "對不對所以是不是用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/962.wav", + "text": "另外一包再去處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/963.wav", + "text": "要趕快建立新制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/964.wav", + "text": "新制不會是最快需要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/965.wav", + "text": "適用這個條文的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/966.wav", + "text": "你懂我的意思嗎因為明年開始他們才會進來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/967.wav", + "text": "至少5年才會開始有人被資遣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/968.wav", + "text": "或是被退掉可能也要20年以後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/969.wav", + "text": "他們才會有人需要用到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/970.wav", + "text": "這條去剝奪他未來的退休金" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/971.wav", + "text": "所以在此" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/972.wav", + "text": "此給你這個建議但" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/973.wav", + "text": "你要提出我們還是尊重" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/974.wav", + "text": "但最好是不要再橫生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/975.wav", + "text": "\n接著請潘部長回應一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/976.wav", + "text": "剛剛范雲委員所提未回" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/977.wav", + "text": "剛剛范委員所提的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/978.wav", + "text": "關心的其實在這次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/979.wav", + "text": "彈性上的調整" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/980.wav", + "text": "再請委員參考書面資料" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/981.wav", + "text": "我就兩個部分來跟" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/982.wav", + "text": "換軌的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/983.wav", + "text": "確實教育部跟銓敘部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/984.wav", + "text": "有對公教的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/985.wav", + "text": "有一張詳細的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/986.wav", + "text": "罄年限等方面的資料" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/987.wav", + "text": "確實這部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/988.wav", + "text": "仔細審酌" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/989.wav", + "text": "部分當時教育部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/990.wav", + "text": "也確實很詳細的評估" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/991.wav", + "text": "有關教育人員這一塊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/992.wav", + "text": "但在在整體考量上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/993.wav", + "text": "各個相關的階段" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/994.wav", + "text": "包含校際之間也有它的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/995.wav", + "text": "差異性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/996.wav", + "text": "所以我們評估後發現" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/997.wav", + "text": "會出現有的老師有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/998.wav", + "text": "有的老師沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/999.wav", + "text": "可能在大學任教的可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/1000.wav", + "text": "可能在高中以下又不可以等等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/1001.wav", + "text": "所以後來經評估" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/1002.wav", + "text": "一個很強烈很大的期待" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/1003.wav", + "text": "教育部認為比較" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/1004.wav", + "text": "相關人員的待遇" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/1005.wav", + "text": "之前我們有提升過一次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/1006.wav", + "text": "我想委員也知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/1007.wav", + "text": "類似這樣的方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/1008.wav", + "text": "可能比較不會影響" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/1009.wav", + "text": "退休人員的權益" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/1010.wav", + "text": "所以也會跟行政院人事" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/1011.wav", + "text": "樣比較朝向" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/1012.wav", + "text": "來提升" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/1013.wav", + "text": "如果有涉及到本職的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/1014.wav", + "text": "其實也跟他未來的退休是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/1015.wav", + "text": "有關聯性的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/1016.wav", + "text": "跟委員做個報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/1017.wav", + "text": "剛才主席也有裁示" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/1018.wav", + "text": "了只是在此有一個建議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/1019.wav", + "text": "支持這樣的方向" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/1020.wav", + "text": "因為從過去幾個案例也發現" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/1021.wav", + "text": "有這個情況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/1022.wav", + "text": "當然這個動議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/1023.wav", + "text": "的部分如果有必要我們也會在現" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/1024.wav", + "text": "現制的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/1025.wav", + "text": "加上同樣的條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/1026.wav", + "text": "至於這部分我也跟主席報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/1027.wav", + "text": "如果必然要往這個方向走" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/1028.wav", + "text": "或許同步實施" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/1029.wav", + "text": "我們尊重主席及" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/1030.wav", + "text": "這項議題這樣處理是必要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/1031.wav", + "text": "的也確實比較能夠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/1032.wav", + "text": "因為過去就有案例了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/1033.wav", + "text": "同時也認為應該要由政府機關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/1034.wav", + "text": "做適切的處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/1035.wav", + "text": "針對以上這兩部分謹向" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/1036.wav", + "text": "在場委員及各機關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/1037.wav", + "text": "代表有沒有要補充的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/1038.wav", + "text": "不是全部都有代表來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/1039.wav", + "text": "而且現在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/1040.wav", + "text": "顯然無法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/1041.wav", + "text": "作成結論簽名" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/1042.wav", + "text": "的宣告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/1043.wav", + "text": "因為大家可以表達的意見都表達" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/1044.wav", + "text": "你們剛剛唸的數字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/1045.wav", + "text": "也就是精算之後的結果因為在場委員都沒有拿到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/1046.wav", + "text": "書面資料根本不可能記得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/1047.wav", + "text": "請你們會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/1048.wav", + "text": "本日協商過程" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/1049.wav", + "text": "公開發言內容均已" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/1050.wav", + "text": "錄音錄影並列入紀錄" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/1051.wav", + "text": "討論過程中有共識之部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/1052.wav", + "text": "將作為後續協商之依據" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/1053.wav", + "text": "因仍有條文內容" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/1054.wav", + "text": "留待繼續溝通" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/1055.wav", + "text": "依例不作結論簽名" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/1056.wav", + "text": "職權行使法第十二章相關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14643/1057.wav", + "text": "規定定期繼續" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/0.wav", + "text": "現在開始開會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1.wav", + "text": "\n各位黨團代表委員先進及行政院部門代表大家午安" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2.wav", + "text": "進行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/3.wav", + "text": "社環委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/4.wav", + "text": "併案審查行政院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/5.wav", + "text": "函請審議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/6.wav", + "text": "精神衛生法修正草案等16案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/7.wav", + "text": "及委員范雲等18人擬具" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/8.wav", + "text": "精神衛生法部分條文修正草案第二輪保留條文之協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/9.wav", + "text": "現在進行討論精神衛生法保留第2條之條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/10.wav", + "text": "61頁" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/11.wav", + "text": "）請衛福部說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/12.wav", + "text": "還沒走完" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/13.wav", + "text": "這是第二輪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/14.wav", + "text": "走完後的第二輪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/15.wav", + "text": "第二輪到第2條而已" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/16.wav", + "text": "兩位委員都很清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/17.wav", + "text": "我們這是第二輪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/18.wav", + "text": "但上次走到第十九條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/19.wav", + "text": "所以我們從第二十條開始" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/20.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/21.wav", + "text": "所以原則上我們建議希望這一條照修正的版本通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/22.wav", + "text": "王婉諭委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/23.wav", + "text": "積極處理的那個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/24.wav", + "text": "做一個說明看能不能把它列進去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/25.wav", + "text": "就是積極性社區危機處理的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/26.wav", + "text": "應該是這一條有關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/27.wav", + "text": "社區處理我們會在第3條的名詞解釋部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/28.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/29.wav", + "text": "因為第3條是保留的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/30.wav", + "text": "所以回頭還要到第3條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/31.wav", + "text": "我們再來處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/32.wav", + "text": "\n我建議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/33.wav", + "text": "因為這個已經有過多次討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/34.wav", + "text": "所謂的第8款" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/35.wav", + "text": "個案管理服務" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/36.wav", + "text": "支持服務的方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/37.wav", + "text": "照這個條文通過然後在處理第3條時" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/38.wav", + "text": "第三輪的時候討論第3條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/39.wav", + "text": "這樣是不是比較順一點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/40.wav", + "text": "所以還是先保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/41.wav", + "text": "對是不是等討論到第3條時先把附帶決議處理掉之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/42.wav", + "text": "表示我們認為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/43.wav", + "text": "第27條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/44.wav", + "text": "第27條這邊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/45.wav", + "text": "最主要是把" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/46.wav", + "text": "的心理衛生宣導" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/47.wav", + "text": "拿掉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/48.wav", + "text": "主要是因為心理衛生宣導跟心理衛生促進" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/49.wav", + "text": "是重疊的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/50.wav", + "text": "心理衛生宣導是心理促進中間的一環" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/51.wav", + "text": "而已所以我們建議避免重複" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/52.wav", + "text": "而把心理衛生宣導" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/53.wav", + "text": "這個我們上一次保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/54.wav", + "text": "上次的爭議應該是在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/55.wav", + "text": "就是之前不論是我或是玉琴委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/56.wav", + "text": "陳情假設非疑似病人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/57.wav", + "text": "應該要做介接" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/58.wav", + "text": "但是因為每次接電話的人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/59.wav", + "text": "都是不同的角色" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/60.wav", + "text": "導致一下叫他找A單位協助" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/61.wav", + "text": "就能夠得到支持的人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/62.wav", + "text": "不知道該怎麼辦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/63.wav", + "text": "之後就會打來民意代表的辦公室" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/64.wav", + "text": "感覺上我們就變成單一窗口" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/65.wav", + "text": "幫他介接這些資源" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/66.wav", + "text": "上次在衛福部溝通的時候是說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/67.wav", + "text": "其實這部分未來要避免這樣的情況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/68.wav", + "text": "就應該用心衛中心來做單一窗口的作法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/69.wav", + "text": "未來如何讓這些心衛中心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/70.wav", + "text": "能夠發揮這樣的功能" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/71.wav", + "text": "如何做培力及整體機制如何做處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/72.wav", + "text": "的部分能夠給我們說明或是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/73.wav", + "text": "如何能夠讓它發揮功能" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/74.wav", + "text": "可能還在設置當中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/75.wav", + "text": "還有如何讓他們能夠慢慢培" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/76.wav", + "text": "專業的能力都還需要進行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/77.wav", + "text": "是不是能夠就這部分先說明一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/78.wav", + "text": "請衛福部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/79.wav", + "text": "說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/80.wav", + "text": "我這邊說明一下我們要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/81.wav", + "text": "廣設心衛中心71處" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/82.wav", + "text": "當然就是希望提供" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/83.wav", + "text": "心理健康促進服務" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/84.wav", + "text": "還有在社區的精神病人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/85.wav", + "text": "所以當民眾" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/86.wav", + "text": "如果有相關議題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/87.wav", + "text": "還是到心衛中心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/88.wav", + "text": "尋求一些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/89.wav", + "text": "協助的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/90.wav", + "text": "的角色它提供的是心理健康" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/91.wav", + "text": "如果要問到相關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/92.wav", + "text": "的一些福利" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/93.wav", + "text": "是回答問題而已" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/94.wav", + "text": "它是要提供服務的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/95.wav", + "text": "所以心衛中心是沒有辦法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/96.wav", + "text": "單獨來完成這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/97.wav", + "text": "社政或是衛政的資源" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/98.wav", + "text": "這個部分我們都可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/99.wav", + "text": "訓練就是讓心衛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/100.wav", + "text": "有人來諮詢的時候他" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/101.wav", + "text": "這個應該是結合哪裡的資源" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/102.wav", + "text": "其實正在建一個資料庫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/103.wav", + "text": "我們上次在討論說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/104.wav", + "text": "裡面都要有一個單一窗口" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/105.wav", + "text": "也會透過每個心衛中心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/106.wav", + "text": "應該不是都單一窗口" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/107.wav", + "text": "而是專責的窗口" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/108.wav", + "text": "這個部分我們會靠整個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/109.wav", + "text": "比較不建議用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/110.wav", + "text": "的概念即個案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/111.wav", + "text": "到這裡就得到所有協助" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/112.wav", + "text": "因為這個可能是心衛中心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/113.wav", + "text": "其實我們整個社安網" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/114.wav", + "text": "資源的連結" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/115.wav", + "text": "窗口都是心衛中心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/116.wav", + "text": "我想像" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/117.wav", + "text": "疾病方面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/118.wav", + "text": "的諮詢一定是找心衛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/119.wav", + "text": "中心不會再找" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/120.wav", + "text": "或是醫療機構" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/121.wav", + "text": "因為已經有心衛中心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/122.wav", + "text": "了只是心衛中心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/123.wav", + "text": "如果明天打電話過去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/124.wav", + "text": "又換了一個人也不知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/125.wav", + "text": "之前的狀況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/126.wav", + "text": "我擔心的是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/127.wav", + "text": "大概是這個意思" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/128.wav", + "text": "25處未來是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/129.wav", + "text": "的部分我們一定會來加強" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/130.wav", + "text": "這個都需要一些時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/131.wav", + "text": "讓我們的同仁知道相關的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/132.wav", + "text": "我想請教一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/133.wav", + "text": "雖然持續在進步中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/134.wav", + "text": "狀況是否應該由中央" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/135.wav", + "text": "比如國會聯絡人或衛福部的誰" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/136.wav", + "text": "假設有遇到這種狀況就能夠請你們協助" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/137.wav", + "text": "實際上心衛中心到底遇到什麼狀況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/138.wav", + "text": "這可能也是一個讓大家知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/139.wav", + "text": "下半年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/140.wav", + "text": "心健司才組了一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/141.wav", + "text": "輔導團" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/142.wav", + "text": "心衛中心的同仁" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/143.wav", + "text": "for心衛中心而已我們也知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/144.wav", + "text": "心衛中心才剛成立" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/145.wav", + "text": "對啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/146.wav", + "text": "我們在這裡也要提醒" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/147.wav", + "text": "單位通常打電話去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/148.wav", + "text": "都是一個人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/149.wav", + "text": "在接電話類似總機" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/150.wav", + "text": "接電話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/151.wav", + "text": "但我覺得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/152.wav", + "text": "心衛中心的角色不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/153.wav", + "text": "接電話的時候就要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/154.wav", + "text": "面對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/155.wav", + "text": "精神疾病患者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/156.wav", + "text": "他就要處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/157.wav", + "text": "來反映問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/158.wav", + "text": "因為他本身就是要被" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/159.wav", + "text": "的人很重要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/160.wav", + "text": "階段就能夠處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/161.wav", + "text": "將來跟其" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/162.wav", + "text": "不太一樣對於這種" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/163.wav", + "text": "專線或是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/164.wav", + "text": "接電話的人的訓練" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/165.wav", + "text": "可能是不一樣的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/166.wav", + "text": "對我們心衛中心其實全部都是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/167.wav", + "text": "專業人員沒有行政人員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/168.wav", + "text": "專業訓練是可以的因為心衛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/169.wav", + "text": "聘請的就是心理師" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/170.wav", + "text": "社工師護理師" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/171.wav", + "text": "職能治療師" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/172.wav", + "text": "專業人員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/173.wav", + "text": "其實是沒有行政人員全部都是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/174.wav", + "text": "已經具有一定的專業" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/175.wav", + "text": "過一些訓練往上加" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/176.wav", + "text": "避免產生剛才講的狀況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/177.wav", + "text": "好聽起來是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/178.wav", + "text": "這個輔導團的執行大概會用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/179.wav", + "text": "怎麼樣的模式進行就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/180.wav", + "text": "心衛中心的輔導團" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/181.wav", + "text": "這個年度已經完成那下半" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/182.wav", + "text": "年的部分是心健" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/183.wav", + "text": "司自己為了心衛中心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/184.wav", + "text": "再組了一個專家輔導團" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/185.wav", + "text": "還有心理師等等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/186.wav", + "text": "每個心衛中心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/187.wav", + "text": "這次還希望針對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/188.wav", + "text": "不同的專業人員能夠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/189.wav", + "text": "對話以瞭解他們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/190.wav", + "text": "我們會用這種方式來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/191.wav", + "text": "進行所以它會是一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/192.wav", + "text": "不定期的如果有需要的時候就儘快" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/193.wav", + "text": "來處理比如個案研討的部分假設" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/194.wav", + "text": "累積到一定的是我們現在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/195.wav", + "text": "算是舊條文可是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/196.wav", + "text": "我想在社安網推動" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/197.wav", + "text": "之後心衛中心非常" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/198.wav", + "text": "重要從過去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/199.wav", + "text": "大概有點小虛設的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/200.wav", + "text": "情形現在要整體布建" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/201.wav", + "text": "到71個點所以它確實" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/202.wav", + "text": "服務機制\n" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/203.wav", + "text": "對於王委員擔心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/204.wav", + "text": "或是認為有需要的單一窗口可能現在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/205.wav", + "text": "有其難度因為它要跨好幾個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/206.wav", + "text": "不同的部會不是單獨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/207.wav", + "text": "由心衛中心衛生單位或" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/208.wav", + "text": "社政單位就可以完成\n" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/209.wav", + "text": "現在是讓它可以扮演個管" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/210.wav", + "text": "的角色使進來的個案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/211.wav", + "text": "不漏接我想這部分應該是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/212.wav", + "text": "衛福部會積極來協助" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/213.wav", + "text": "或是積極盯著各" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/214.wav", + "text": "心衛中心能夠將" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/215.wav", + "text": "而且轉介我想這部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/216.wav", + "text": "是我們關心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/217.wav", + "text": "的因此這個條文應該可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/218.wav", + "text": "先照行政院的版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/219.wav", + "text": "那其他文字應該" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/220.wav", + "text": "比較沒問題所以本席" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/221.wav", + "text": "支持照行政院版" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/222.wav", + "text": "修正通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/223.wav", + "text": "好各位委員沒有其他" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/224.wav", + "text": "意見第27條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/225.wav", + "text": "修正版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/226.wav", + "text": "協商通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/227.wav", + "text": "一下第28條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/228.wav", + "text": "對修正動議等到後面再來處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/229.wav", + "text": "那個是委員會通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/230.wav", + "text": "的所以現在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/231.wav", + "text": "先處理保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/232.wav", + "text": "這部分跟大家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/233.wav", + "text": "保證" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/234.wav", + "text": "32條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/235.wav", + "text": "條大概只有幾個地方有修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/236.wav", + "text": "第2項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/237.wav", + "text": "與其" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/238.wav", + "text": "這個是贅字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/239.wav", + "text": "然後將第3項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/240.wav", + "text": "的其戶籍所在地或" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/241.wav", + "text": "因為前面已經有清楚的說明了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/242.wav", + "text": "所以將這些字拿掉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/243.wav", + "text": "這算是贅字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/244.wav", + "text": "最後倒數3行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/245.wav", + "text": "非屬嚴重病人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/246.wav", + "text": "或者是心衛社工要到醫院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/247.wav", + "text": "參與他的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/248.wav", + "text": "出院前準備會議的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/249.wav", + "text": "也可以參加" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/250.wav", + "text": "所以我們在說明欄裡面加了一個說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/251.wav", + "text": "至非屬嚴重病人者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/252.wav", + "text": "地方主管機關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/253.wav", + "text": "視需求必要時" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/254.wav", + "text": "亦得派員參與" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/255.wav", + "text": "以上說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/256.wav", + "text": "當患者非屬嚴重病人的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/257.wav", + "text": "課責地方主管機關一定要派員參加" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/258.wav", + "text": "但是現實狀況就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/259.wav", + "text": "當地方主管機關或是比較願意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/260.wav", + "text": "卻被拒絕在這樣的情況下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/261.wav", + "text": "要來做處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/262.wav", + "text": "是寫在我們審議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/263.wav", + "text": "版本對照表裡面的說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/264.wav", + "text": "第23456" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/265.wav", + "text": "立法理由的說明欄" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/266.wav", + "text": "如果要放在說明欄" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/267.wav", + "text": "至少是放在立法理由的說明欄" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/268.wav", + "text": "這個是會在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/269.wav", + "text": "立法說明裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/270.wav", + "text": "如果確認會放在立法說明裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/271.wav", + "text": "正式的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/272.wav", + "text": "立法說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/273.wav", + "text": "這一條我們也溝通了很久" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/274.wav", + "text": "每一個入住精神病院的人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/275.wav", + "text": "在入院第一天起" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/276.wav", + "text": "都能夠有一個個性化的出院計畫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/277.wav", + "text": "根據他們的意願跟偏好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/278.wav", + "text": "在他們需要的支持下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/279.wav", + "text": "返回社區" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/280.wav", + "text": "我原來的版本就是希望能夠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/281.wav", + "text": "增加病人同意的條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/282.wav", + "text": "但是跟衛福部溝通了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/283.wav", + "text": "所以我這邊有兩個附帶決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/284.wav", + "text": "一個是希望主管機關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/285.wav", + "text": "未來可以評估" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/286.wav", + "text": "出院準備計畫執行的品質" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/287.wav", + "text": "逐步被納入醫院的評鑑" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/288.wav", + "text": "至少現在就可以開始評估" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/289.wav", + "text": "另外一個附帶決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/290.wav", + "text": "就是希望精神" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/291.wav", + "text": "醫療機構在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/292.wav", + "text": "住院的病人病情穩定或" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/293.wav", + "text": "康復而沒有繼續住院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/294.wav", + "text": "治療必要時應該協助他們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/295.wav", + "text": "擬定出院準備計畫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/296.wav", + "text": "居家照護等等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/297.wav", + "text": "而且擬定的過程應該要包括" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/298.wav", + "text": "病人參與的機制以落實病人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/299.wav", + "text": "自主" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/300.wav", + "text": "機構出院準備計畫能夠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/301.wav", + "text": "落實這些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/302.wav", + "text": "衛福部應該要研擬相關的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/303.wav", + "text": "誘因逐步提升" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/304.wav", + "text": "作為主管機關應該可以給" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/305.wav", + "text": "他們一些誘因不要只是處罰" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/306.wav", + "text": "希望可以逐步落實" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/307.wav", + "text": "\n我這邊有附帶決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/308.wav", + "text": "我的提案目前也有吳玉琴委員的連署" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/309.wav", + "text": "我先說一下謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/310.wav", + "text": "會有討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/311.wav", + "text": "各位委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/312.wav", + "text": "衛福部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/313.wav", + "text": "修正建議的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/314.wav", + "text": "版本協商通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/315.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/316.wav", + "text": "63條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/317.wav", + "text": "請看第204頁左方" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/318.wav", + "text": "第63條這邊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/319.wav", + "text": "衛福部協商通過之" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/320.wav", + "text": "建議按照我們的修正版" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/321.wav", + "text": "司法院應該沒意見吧" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/322.wav", + "text": "司法院有沒有意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/323.wav", + "text": "當時是司法院有意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/324.wav", + "text": "就精神衛生法修正草案第63條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/325.wav", + "text": "部分已經有徵詢法律" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/326.wav", + "text": "扶助基金會意見因為法律扶助基金會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/327.wav", + "text": "政府單位委託的專案像勞動部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/328.wav", + "text": "的委託專案考量到勞工" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/329.wav", + "text": "人數比較多類型比較多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/330.wav", + "text": "如果用法規命令規定的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/331.wav", + "text": "它扶助的範圍跟內容會比較明確" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/332.wav", + "text": "不過相對來說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/333.wav", + "text": "有一個缺點就是調整的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/334.wav", + "text": "執行專案的時候就沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/335.wav", + "text": "訂定法規命令像原民會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/336.wav", + "text": "的執行會比較有彈性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/337.wav", + "text": "\n基金會也是認為精" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/338.wav", + "text": "精神衛生法強制住院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/339.wav", + "text": "適用的對象跟扶助的內容" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/340.wav", + "text": "及案件類型比較特定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/341.wav", + "text": "跟檢警陪偵的案件比較相似" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/342.wav", + "text": "所以基金會立場是毋" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/343.wav", + "text": "由中央主管機關另以辦法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/344.wav", + "text": "定之不過就司法院的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/345.wav", + "text": "立場還是建議要增訂同條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/346.wav", + "text": "第3項關於授權中央主管機關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/347.wav", + "text": "訂定辦法主要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/348.wav", + "text": "主要是基於三點理由\n第一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/349.wav", + "text": "是希望有專業的規劃" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/350.wav", + "text": "以及國會的監督因為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/351.wav", + "text": "就第63條草案第1項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/352.wav", + "text": "的部分必要法律扶助" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/353.wav", + "text": "的具體內容比較不明確所以由" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/354.wav", + "text": "專業的中央主管機關規劃" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/355.wav", + "text": "具體的執行內容確實有它的必要性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/356.wav", + "text": "還有國會監督" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/357.wav", + "text": "是現行民主國家非常重要的原則" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/358.wav", + "text": "所以建議增列" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/359.wav", + "text": "命令的規定可以透過法規命令的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/360.wav", + "text": "訂定還有修正程序比如" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/361.wav", + "text": "像草案的公告以及" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/362.wav", + "text": "必要時得舉行聽證這部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/363.wav", + "text": "在行政程序法第105條及第105條有規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/364.wav", + "text": "以及最終的提報國會審查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/365.wav", + "text": "這在中央法規標準法第7條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/366.wav", + "text": "立法院職權行使法第6條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/367.wav", + "text": "及第63條也有規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/368.wav", + "text": "這部分可以落實多元參與" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/369.wav", + "text": "及國會監督的民主原則" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/370.wav", + "text": "委託契約的框架" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/371.wav", + "text": "授權以行政契約" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/372.wav", + "text": "的方式委託民間辦理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/373.wav", + "text": "如果有增訂第3項規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/374.wav", + "text": "可以具體規範中央主管機關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/375.wav", + "text": "事先擬定契約" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/376.wav", + "text": "簽訂的綱要性架構" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/377.wav", + "text": "以及通報方式可以訂定一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/378.wav", + "text": "遵守辦法讓契約的兩造" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/379.wav", + "text": "有締約的框架跟指引" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/380.wav", + "text": "指引也有透明的法規命令" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/381.wav", + "text": "可以檢視這個行政" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/382.wav", + "text": "契約簽訂的內容是不是跟" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/383.wav", + "text": "母法規範的意旨一致避免" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/384.wav", + "text": "契約內容約定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/385.wav", + "text": "的結果跟法律規範的意旨有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/386.wav", + "text": "就目前法律扶助基金會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/387.wav", + "text": "其他行政委託專案的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/388.wav", + "text": "受勞動部委託辦理的勞工" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/389.wav", + "text": "訴訟扶助專案是從" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/390.wav", + "text": "勞資爭議處理法授權訂定的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/391.wav", + "text": "勞資爭議法律及生活費用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/392.wav", + "text": "扶助辦法所規定的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/393.wav", + "text": "雖然原民會的部分沒有法規命令" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/394.wav", + "text": "但是也有行政規則" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/395.wav", + "text": "也就是以推動原住民族" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/396.wav", + "text": "做為契約架構" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/397.wav", + "text": "這部分在實務上都有簽約參考" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/398.wav", + "text": "所以這部分應該沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/399.wav", + "text": "什麼窒礙難行的狀況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/400.wav", + "text": "我們尊重國會的立法職權" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/401.wav", + "text": "不過還是建議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/402.wav", + "text": "在精神衛生法修正草案第63條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/403.wav", + "text": "周全以上謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/404.wav", + "text": "這個就是我們比較擔心的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/405.wav", + "text": "我們處理到最後一條的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/406.wav", + "text": "就會碰到施行日期" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/407.wav", + "text": "附帶條件像" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/408.wav", + "text": "要去訂定法規" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/409.wav", + "text": "另外訂定辦法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/410.wav", + "text": "都會延後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/411.wav", + "text": "開始實施的時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/412.wav", + "text": "所以這都是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/413.wav", + "text": "我們比較擔心的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/414.wav", + "text": "增加第3項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/415.wav", + "text": "扶助申請資格" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/416.wav", + "text": "範圍審核委託辦理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/417.wav", + "text": "通報方式等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/418.wav", + "text": "事項之辦法由中央" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/419.wav", + "text": "主管機關定之" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/420.wav", + "text": "還是不需要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/421.wav", + "text": "時間又延宕" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/422.wav", + "text": "衛福部也有深思" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/423.wav", + "text": "若以這二項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/424.wav", + "text": "不用增加第3項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/425.wav", + "text": "法律扶助是可以做的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/426.wav", + "text": "確定是可以做在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/427.wav", + "text": "其他的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/428.wav", + "text": "法律也有這種情形" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/429.wav", + "text": "\n各位委員有沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/430.wav", + "text": "不同的意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/431.wav", + "text": "沒有的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/432.wav", + "text": "我們就要按照衛福部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/433.wav", + "text": "提供的意見來通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/434.wav", + "text": "同意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/435.wav", + "text": "好本條按照衛福部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/436.wav", + "text": "建議的修正條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/437.wav", + "text": "協商通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/438.wav", + "text": "\n接著我們處理第" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/439.wav", + "text": "第81條主要就是跟第2" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/440.wav", + "text": "第28條連動" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/441.wav", + "text": "所以第28條如果沒處理第8" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/442.wav", + "text": "第81條就會一直沒辦法處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/443.wav", + "text": "所以就先保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/444.wav", + "text": "好第81條先保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/445.wav", + "text": "主席" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/446.wav", + "text": "議事人員這樣的建議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/447.wav", + "text": "真的不適合" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/448.wav", + "text": "第二輪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/449.wav", + "text": "應該是要全面把所有的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/450.wav", + "text": "討論尤其這個都關係到後面的罰則" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/451.wav", + "text": "則應該對第28條就要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/452.wav", + "text": "先處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/453.wav", + "text": "我還有另外的建議是第65條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/454.wav", + "text": "所以這邊保留等一下又要回來再看一次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/455.wav", + "text": "我知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/456.wav", + "text": "我的建議是我們先把第二輪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/457.wav", + "text": "run完然後中間休息討論一下第三輪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/458.wav", + "text": "怎麼進行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/459.wav", + "text": "這樣子啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/460.wav", + "text": "因為只有後面幾條而已" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/461.wav", + "text": "再走一次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/462.wav", + "text": "走一次以後就要用協商的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/463.wav", + "text": "哪幾條要一起處理就要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/464.wav", + "text": "拿出來一起處理對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/465.wav", + "text": "再去那邊處理這個處理那個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/466.wav", + "text": "兩條要一起處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/467.wav", + "text": "所以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/468.wav", + "text": "我們等一下用協商的方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/469.wav", + "text": "因為剩下的條文也不多\n" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/470.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/471.wav", + "text": "這個就先保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/472.wav", + "text": "跟第65條有關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/473.wav", + "text": "第65條也是保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/474.wav", + "text": "委員會是有通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/475.wav", + "text": "你們有修正動議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/476.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/477.wav", + "text": "這個先保留等一下處理修正動議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/478.wav", + "text": "時一併處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/479.wav", + "text": "施行日期" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/480.wav", + "text": "部分我覺得這個今天要討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/481.wav", + "text": "我們上一次有給他們時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/482.wav", + "text": "去跟司法院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/483.wav", + "text": "才能訂定出相關的子法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/484.wav", + "text": "辦法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/485.wav", + "text": "總要有一個時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/486.wav", + "text": "各位委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/487.wav", + "text": "我覺得要堅持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/488.wav", + "text": "要訂出一個時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/489.wav", + "text": "有人提案來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/490.wav", + "text": "訂子法就處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/491.wav", + "text": "沒有人提案就會一直放著" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/492.wav", + "text": "就不能開始施" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/493.wav", + "text": "行啊請衛福部說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/494.wav", + "text": "這個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/495.wav", + "text": "我們有去盤" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/496.wav", + "text": "最主要是授權辦法就有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/497.wav", + "text": "真的是一個法規的制定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/498.wav", + "text": "跟團體討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/499.wav", + "text": "然後要寫法條之後還要到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/500.wav", + "text": "衛福部的法規會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/501.wav", + "text": "我們衛福部這邊需要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/502.wav", + "text": "兩年的時間讓我們把" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/503.wav", + "text": "27個相關的法規" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/504.wav", + "text": "能夠制定可是委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/505.wav", + "text": "資源布建服務部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/506.wav", + "text": "我之前都有說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/507.wav", + "text": "因為目前資源布建" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/508.wav", + "text": "建部分我們現在的經費主要是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/509.wav", + "text": "社安網的經費" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/510.wav", + "text": "社安網的經費本來就是5年的計畫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/511.wav", + "text": "到114年那個錢其實" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/512.wav", + "text": "都有得到行政院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/513.wav", + "text": "我們用自己的公務預算還是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/514.wav", + "text": "公彩回饋金也" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/515.wav", + "text": "都有一些方案在進行當中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/516.wav", + "text": "所以在資源布建部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/517.wav", + "text": "其實不會因為這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/518.wav", + "text": "法還沒有生效就會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/519.wav", + "text": "停頓或是經費就沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/520.wav", + "text": "這個部分其實是不用擔心的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/521.wav", + "text": "\n另外我們現在也在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/522.wav", + "text": "積極研議一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/523.wav", + "text": "身心障礙資源布建" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/524.wav", + "text": "那個部分也有把" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/525.wav", + "text": "部分的資源都一併" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/526.wav", + "text": "放進去在規劃當中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/527.wav", + "text": "因此在這邊只是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/528.wav", + "text": "我們相關的辦法真的太多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/529.wav", + "text": "作業真的需要時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/530.wav", + "text": "在預算部分其實我們都" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/531.wav", + "text": "有相關的計畫跟來源" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/532.wav", + "text": "所以我們一定會按照這樣的計畫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/533.wav", + "text": "執行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/534.wav", + "text": "以上說明謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/535.wav", + "text": "兩年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/536.wav", + "text": "進行相關的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/537.wav", + "text": "修法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/538.wav", + "text": "各位委員大家午安" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/539.wav", + "text": "剛剛次長說的兩年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/540.wav", + "text": "請教一下不知道有沒有包括" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/541.wav", + "text": "對不起" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/542.wav", + "text": "因為專家參審法庭" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/543.wav", + "text": "未來強制住院的法官保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/544.wav", + "text": "可能必須要仰賴衛福部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/545.wav", + "text": "精神科醫師還有病權團體" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/546.wav", + "text": "在那之後我們才能夠進行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/547.wav", + "text": "遴選作業還有這些相關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/548.wav", + "text": "期程的準備" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/549.wav", + "text": "所以我們是不是可以再" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/550.wav", + "text": "跟衛福部盤點一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/551.wav", + "text": "如果要納入第五章的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/552.wav", + "text": "專家參審法官保留這個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/553.wav", + "text": "我們兩院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/554.wav", + "text": "需要多久的期程" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/555.wav", + "text": "如果剛剛次長說的兩年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/556.wav", + "text": "不包括這個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/557.wav", + "text": "那可能就是要看這個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/558.wav", + "text": "加上去之後需要多久的時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/559.wav", + "text": "我們再針對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/560.wav", + "text": "司法院主管的家事事件法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/561.wav", + "text": "還有這些相關配套的法律" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/562.wav", + "text": "這樣子好嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/563.wav", + "text": "上一次的結論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/564.wav", + "text": "已經是這樣子了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/565.wav", + "text": "現在還是同樣的結論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/566.wav", + "text": "沒有跟主席報告剛剛次長說的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/567.wav", + "text": "這兩年不包括跟司法院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/568.wav", + "text": "要會同訂定的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/569.wav", + "text": "我知道我們上一次協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/570.wav", + "text": "跟司法院要去討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/571.wav", + "text": "結果你們討論出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/572.wav", + "text": "的還是不包括第五章" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/573.wav", + "text": "也沒有期程" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/574.wav", + "text": "專家參審的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/575.wav", + "text": "一定還要再加上這個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/576.wav", + "text": "我們上次在協商的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/577.wav", + "text": "就是希望司法院可以稍微抓一下進度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/578.wav", + "text": "不然沒抓進度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/579.wav", + "text": "如果要三讀通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/580.wav", + "text": "到底什麼時候施" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/581.wav", + "text": "之間有訂不出時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/582.wav", + "text": "其實不是司法院訂不出時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/583.wav", + "text": "而是衛福部要推薦給我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/584.wav", + "text": "這個時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/585.wav", + "text": "就應該要執行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/586.wav", + "text": "我們要配合的部分就是在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/587.wav", + "text": "於專家參審的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/588.wav", + "text": "這些名單" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/589.wav", + "text": "嘛其實現在我們本來就有一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/590.wav", + "text": "審查會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/591.wav", + "text": "名單只是這些名單在我們提供出來之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/592.wav", + "text": "其他的訓練" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/593.wav", + "text": "可是這個訓練可能還是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/594.wav", + "text": "需要由司法院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/595.wav", + "text": "來訓練他們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/596.wav", + "text": "單就提供專家名單" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/597.wav", + "text": "我想我們現在提供" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/598.wav", + "text": "都沒有太大的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/599.wav", + "text": "因為專家還需要經過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/600.wav", + "text": "訓練他必須要知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/601.wav", + "text": "司法的程序以及他在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/602.wav", + "text": "參審中的位置要扮演的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/603.wav", + "text": "配套所需要的時間確實要再久" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/604.wav", + "text": "一點所以我剛剛提的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/605.wav", + "text": "兩年是以目前我們衛福部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/606.wav", + "text": "可以兩年來施行謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/607.wav", + "text": "主席我想要再釐清" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/608.wav", + "text": "因為在這個過程中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/609.wav", + "text": "我覺得上次聽" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/610.wav", + "text": "司法院講完之後我就覺得要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/611.wav", + "text": "拆開來處理所謂拆開來處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/612.wav", + "text": "就是我們這整部法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/613.wav", + "text": "第五章法官保留原則" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/614.wav", + "text": "的罰則可能要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/615.wav", + "text": "由行政院跟司法院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/616.wav", + "text": "協商訂定時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/617.wav", + "text": "我為什麼這樣講因為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/618.wav", + "text": "上一次會議司法院跟我們說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/619.wav", + "text": "它還有一個法要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/620.wav", + "text": "修正那個法要修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/621.wav", + "text": "所涉及的不是只有司法院提出來的時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/622.wav", + "text": "還有我們立法院的時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/623.wav", + "text": "他們到底要什麼時候才能" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/624.wav", + "text": "你那個法的修正如果要配合這一次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/625.wav", + "text": "精神衛生法的修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/626.wav", + "text": "你們什麼時候會將法案送過來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/627.wav", + "text": "而我們立法院也要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/628.wav", + "text": "積極配合修法這個時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/629.wav", + "text": "變成很難確定所以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/630.wav", + "text": "我覺得第五章法官保留原則" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/631.wav", + "text": "整章可能要另訂" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/632.wav", + "text": "施行的時間因為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/633.wav", + "text": "還有立法院的進度確實" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/634.wav", + "text": "是比較難掌握所以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/635.wav", + "text": "到時候在文字上是不是可以有兩個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/636.wav", + "text": "這個有辦法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/637.wav", + "text": "我們這個施行的日期" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/638.wav", + "text": "寫在最後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/639.wav", + "text": "這一條那有沒有辦法把" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/640.wav", + "text": "第五章" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/641.wav", + "text": "另列讓它跟其他" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/642.wav", + "text": "立法技術上可以這樣處理嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/643.wav", + "text": "我要提醒" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/644.wav", + "text": "第89條可能也要配套來看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/645.wav", + "text": "因為第89條也有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/646.wav", + "text": "所謂施行的時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/647.wav", + "text": "那一部分要怎麼規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/648.wav", + "text": "文字可能也要配套來做修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/649.wav", + "text": "要這樣修正的話可能第8" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/650.wav", + "text": "第89條也要配合修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/651.wav", + "text": "好等一下請衛福部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/652.wav", + "text": "回答不過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/653.wav", + "text": "針對衛福部剛剛回答時說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/654.wav", + "text": "因為有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/655.wav", + "text": "參審" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/656.wav", + "text": "的關係" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/657.wav", + "text": "所以有一些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/658.wav", + "text": "專家或是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/659.wav", + "text": "要進入到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/660.wav", + "text": "司法院的體系" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/661.wav", + "text": "法官保留的那一部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/662.wav", + "text": "可能也要經過一些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/663.wav", + "text": "訓練你認為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/664.wav", + "text": "你們的委員早就都準備" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/665.wav", + "text": "好了現在也有名單了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/666.wav", + "text": "參審可能要多少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/667.wav", + "text": "的訓練據我所知是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/668.wav", + "text": "不需要訓練" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/669.wav", + "text": "參審" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/670.wav", + "text": "都是如此" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/671.wav", + "text": "他們不需要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/672.wav", + "text": "法律專家反而" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/673.wav", + "text": "不能擔任" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/674.wav", + "text": "國民參審的國民" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/675.wav", + "text": "法官像律師都不行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/676.wav", + "text": "我的意思" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/677.wav", + "text": "是什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/678.wav", + "text": "而不是懂很多法律" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/679.wav", + "text": "參審的這些人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/680.wav", + "text": "是法律人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/681.wav", + "text": "嗎不是啊反而是排除" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/682.wav", + "text": "掉法律人才能擔任" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/683.wav", + "text": "國民法官" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/684.wav", + "text": "參審的精神不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/685.wav", + "text": "在於法律專業我的意思" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/686.wav", + "text": "是這樣所以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/687.wav", + "text": "請司法院說明他們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/688.wav", + "text": "完整的法律訓練" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/689.wav", + "text": "審嗎這個跟你們參審" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/690.wav", + "text": "的精神是一致的嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/691.wav", + "text": "是這樣嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/692.wav", + "text": "召委我來報告一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/693.wav", + "text": "國民法官的確像召委您" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/694.wav", + "text": "由國民來參與" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/695.wav", + "text": "刑事審判但是精神" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/696.wav", + "text": "衛生法的專家參審不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/697.wav", + "text": "有兩種一個是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/698.wav", + "text": "醫療背景的專家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/699.wav", + "text": "但是他進來是擔任法官的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/700.wav", + "text": "角色所以其實怎麼讓一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/701.wav", + "text": "精神科醫生瞭解司法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/702.wav", + "text": "社會正義他代表的是什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/703.wav", + "text": "他不是繼續扮演醫生的角色" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/704.wav", + "text": "但是他其實具有醫療的背景" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/705.wav", + "text": "那病權團體" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/706.wav", + "text": "本來可能是NGO團體" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/707.wav", + "text": "但是經過衛福部指定這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/708.wav", + "text": "病權團體進來參審之後它的代表也是成為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/709.wav", + "text": "法官這裡面他可能" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/710.wav", + "text": "必須要具有一些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/711.wav", + "text": "消極資格並且" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/712.wav", + "text": "還要具有一些積極的資格" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/713.wav", + "text": "所以這個部分跟國民參審是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/714.wav", + "text": "不一樣的國民參審" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/715.wav", + "text": "就不是法官嗎國民" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/716.wav", + "text": "它是國民參與刑事審判" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/717.wav", + "text": "其實是要去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/718.wav", + "text": "對於這樣重大的刑事案件" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/719.wav", + "text": "他的一些想法但是精神" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/720.wav", + "text": "衛生法的專家參審不然" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/721.wav", + "text": "培訓也是需要的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/722.wav", + "text": "這個部分要向各位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/723.wav", + "text": "所以剛剛衛福部說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/724.wav", + "text": "未來衛福部指定這些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/725.wav", + "text": "醫療的精神科醫生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/726.wav", + "text": "我們還要過濾他們的一些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/727.wav", + "text": "資格包含我剛剛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/728.wav", + "text": "提到的我們要有一些遴選的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/729.wav", + "text": "辦法還要列冊經由" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/730.wav", + "text": "最後他才有可能成為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/731.wav", + "text": "精神衛生法未來專家參審" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/732.wav", + "text": "目前大概應該有15個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/733.wav", + "text": "還必須要遵守倫理規範" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/734.wav", + "text": "他在就職前還要進行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/735.wav", + "text": "他可能不瞭解司法權" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/736.wav", + "text": "報告\n至於期程" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/737.wav", + "text": "的部分也可以跟" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/738.wav", + "text": "吳委員報告家事事件法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/739.wav", + "text": "的部分我們目前已經就" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/740.wav", + "text": "配套在研擬準備當中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/741.wav", + "text": "期完成三讀" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/742.wav", + "text": "我們的家事事件法會在最快的時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/743.wav", + "text": "協助我們在司法及法制委員會能夠完成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/744.wav", + "text": "謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/745.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/746.wav", + "text": "衛福部第9" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/747.wav", + "text": "有沒有辦法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/748.wav", + "text": "分開來規定施行日期" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/749.wav", + "text": "第幾章" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/750.wav", + "text": "可能是如何" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/751.wav", + "text": "還有其他的施行日期" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/752.wav", + "text": "是什麼時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/753.wav", + "text": "這樣把它分開來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/754.wav", + "text": "好報告召委" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/755.wav", + "text": "我們今天有提" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/756.wav", + "text": "修正意見建議的文字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/757.wav", + "text": "是第92條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/758.wav", + "text": "依本法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/759.wav", + "text": "除第五章" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/760.wav", + "text": "第82條第1項第3" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/761.wav", + "text": "款及第4款" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/762.wav", + "text": "施行日期由行政院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/763.wav", + "text": "會同司法院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/764.wav", + "text": "定之外自公布後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/765.wav", + "text": "二年施行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/766.wav", + "text": "我們就是把第五章" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/767.wav", + "text": "處罰的條款" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/768.wav", + "text": "都讓它" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/769.wav", + "text": "司法院來定出" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/770.wav", + "text": "我們還沒有印出來還沒給委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/771.wav", + "text": "第92條就會跟第89條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/772.wav", + "text": "委員有沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/773.wav", + "text": "再印一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/774.wav", + "text": "一起看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/775.wav", + "text": "主席" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/776.wav", + "text": "最後第三輪的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/777.wav", + "text": "第28條跟我的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/778.wav", + "text": "最後協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/779.wav", + "text": "針對第92條如果是這樣寫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/780.wav", + "text": "本法除第五章第82條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/781.wav", + "text": "第1項第3款及第4款" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/782.wav", + "text": "施行日期" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/783.wav", + "text": "由行政院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/784.wav", + "text": "會同司法院定之" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/785.wav", + "text": "外" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/786.wav", + "text": "自公布後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/787.wav", + "text": "二年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/788.wav", + "text": "我們看其他的立法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/789.wav", + "text": "施行日期" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/790.wav", + "text": "除" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/791.wav", + "text": "對這樣會比較順一點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/792.wav", + "text": "謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/793.wav", + "text": "好第92條本法施行日期" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/794.wav", + "text": "第1項第3款及第4款" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/795.wav", + "text": "由行政院會同" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/796.wav", + "text": "司法院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/797.wav", + "text": "定之外自公布後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/798.wav", + "text": "二年施行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/799.wav", + "text": "就是把施行日期" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/800.wav", + "text": "放在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/801.wav", + "text": "本法之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/802.wav", + "text": "把它調到前面其他的文字不變" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/803.wav", + "text": "各位委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/804.wav", + "text": "這樣可以嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/805.wav", + "text": "公布後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/806.wav", + "text": "二年施行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/807.wav", + "text": "二年內" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/808.wav", + "text": "立法上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/809.wav", + "text": "可以提早嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/810.wav", + "text": "二年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/811.wav", + "text": "實施但是我可以提早嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/812.wav", + "text": "如果照你這個文字那可以提早嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/813.wav", + "text": "就不行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/814.wav", + "text": "啊如果二年內" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/815.wav", + "text": "實施呢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/816.wav", + "text": "可以這樣立法嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/817.wav", + "text": "二年內施" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/818.wav", + "text": "行然後它在一年半的時候就做了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/819.wav", + "text": "可以嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/820.wav", + "text": "可以要求一年半" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/821.wav", + "text": "都希望可以及早" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/822.wav", + "text": "已經準備好了包括心衛中心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/823.wav", + "text": "個案管理等等都準備好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/824.wav", + "text": "法制局有人在場嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/825.wav", + "text": "如果是二年內施行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/826.wav", + "text": "它的施行日期是不太明確的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/827.wav", + "text": "也可以請" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/828.wav", + "text": "司法院跟法務部表示意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/829.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/830.wav", + "text": "請專家表示意見請" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/831.wav", + "text": "法務部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/832.wav", + "text": "主席各位委員大家好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/833.wav", + "text": "多久施行這件事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/834.wav", + "text": "依目前的現行法制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/835.wav", + "text": "體例都是寫自" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/836.wav", + "text": "公布後一年三個月" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/837.wav", + "text": "六個月或二年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/838.wav", + "text": "施行這樣的體例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/839.wav", + "text": "例這個日期即使是到一年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/840.wav", + "text": "後三個月後或半年後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/841.wav", + "text": "其實它日期是確定的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/842.wav", + "text": "是跟著公布日而走的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/843.wav", + "text": "所以它是可得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/844.wav", + "text": "而知的確定日期" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/845.wav", + "text": "這樣對人民的保障是比較" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/846.wav", + "text": "如果明定自公布後二年內" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/847.wav", + "text": "而且這個法律" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/848.wav", + "text": "涉及到一些權利義務的規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/849.wav", + "text": "保障是比較沒有的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/850.wav", + "text": "所以還是建議維持現有的體例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/851.wav", + "text": "自公布後一年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/852.wav", + "text": "看是需要哪一段時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/853.wav", + "text": "這樣才是符合現行的法制體例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/854.wav", + "text": "以上說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/855.wav", + "text": "請司法院表示意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/856.wav", + "text": "主席我們跟法務部的意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/857.wav", + "text": "是一樣的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/858.wav", + "text": "然後不知道是哪一個時間點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/859.wav", + "text": "上次討論時我們是希望可以在一年內" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/860.wav", + "text": "施行但還是有些困難" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/861.wav", + "text": "有點太久了如果現在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/862.wav", + "text": "衛福部覺得二年是一個有把握的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/863.wav", + "text": "時間是不是要再努力一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/864.wav", + "text": "比如說我們就是確定一年六個月" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/865.wav", + "text": "一直在搖頭" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/866.wav", + "text": "我們還有一個法制作業" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/867.wav", + "text": "之前就提到光是我們法規會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/868.wav", + "text": "要把那二十幾個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/869.wav", + "text": "二年內完成相關法制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/870.wav", + "text": "困難度而且還要預告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/871.wav", + "text": "困難的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/872.wav", + "text": "如果有附帶決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/873.wav", + "text": "然後你們那些子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/874.wav", + "text": "子法訂定的速度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/875.wav", + "text": "有提早" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/876.wav", + "text": "那有沒有可能" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/877.wav", + "text": "用附帶決議讓它提早" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/878.wav", + "text": "施行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/879.wav", + "text": "好像也不行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/880.wav", + "text": "如果一年六個月不行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/881.wav", + "text": "則一年九個月可不可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/882.wav", + "text": "一年有困難我們可以理解" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/883.wav", + "text": "因為大概有27個相關子法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/884.wav", + "text": "要訂定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/885.wav", + "text": "所以它需要時間也需要跟團體進行討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/886.wav", + "text": "可是說一年半沒辦法執行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/887.wav", + "text": "或沒辦法做到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/888.wav", + "text": "我就覺得你們對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/889.wav", + "text": "我覺得應該可以在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/890.wav", + "text": "一年半來完成相關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/891.wav", + "text": "的程序包括法規的預告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/892.wav", + "text": "一年半我覺得是適合的時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/893.wav", + "text": "團體的期待" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/894.wav", + "text": "來看可能二年真的太久了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/895.wav", + "text": "且公布二年後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/896.wav", + "text": "施行可能很多的措施很多的權利義務" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/897.wav", + "text": "都要二年後才發生效力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/898.wav", + "text": "所以如果能提早" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/899.wav", + "text": "就儘量提早" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/900.wav", + "text": "我們這邊3位委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/901.wav", + "text": "都是主張一年半" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/902.wav", + "text": "包括我" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/903.wav", + "text": "也主張一年半" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/904.wav", + "text": "衛福部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/905.wav", + "text": "跟委員們報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/906.wav", + "text": "大家期待能快一點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/907.wav", + "text": "但根據我們過去執行的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/908.wav", + "text": "經驗即使是最厲害的人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/909.wav", + "text": "沒辦法做到更多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/910.wav", + "text": "這是頂級了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/911.wav", + "text": "且這些都是我們副司長層級" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/912.wav", + "text": "要去做的事如果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/913.wav", + "text": "要更快實在是真的有困難" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/914.wav", + "text": "因為我們也並不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/915.wav", + "text": "所有的人都懂這個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/916.wav", + "text": "這是需要滿專業的人才能處理的所以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/917.wav", + "text": "真的是有困難" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/918.wav", + "text": "所以我們硬壓成二年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/919.wav", + "text": "7個子法要寫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/920.wav", + "text": "其實我們也很想快一點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/921.wav", + "text": "否則壓力也會很大" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/922.wav", + "text": "各位委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/923.wav", + "text": "剛好是總統宣誓就職前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/924.wav", + "text": "這樣是不是滿圓滿的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/925.wav", + "text": "如果可以這樣的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/926.wav", + "text": "一年六個月" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/927.wav", + "text": "就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/928.wav", + "text": "差不多在明年的56月" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/929.wav", + "text": "行如果12月" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/930.wav", + "text": "不好意思這條應該還滿關鍵的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/931.wav", + "text": "最後協商時再來討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/932.wav", + "text": "因為我們不能在此停滯" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/933.wav", + "text": "我們還有兩個條文要處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/934.wav", + "text": "OK這個如果有處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/935.wav", + "text": "就會連同第89條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/936.wav", + "text": "一起處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/937.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/938.wav", + "text": "那就暫行保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/939.wav", + "text": "還沒有處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/940.wav", + "text": "現在就等於是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/941.wav", + "text": "第三輪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/942.wav", + "text": "第二輪都還沒有處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/943.wav", + "text": "已經走完了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/944.wav", + "text": "我們現在走完第二輪了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/945.wav", + "text": "對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/946.wav", + "text": "剛剛走完第二輪而" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/947.wav", + "text": "而第二輪保留的條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/948.wav", + "text": "文包括第3條第十九條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/949.wav", + "text": "審查會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/950.wav", + "text": "通過的條文而" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/951.wav", + "text": "委員有再" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/952.wav", + "text": "提修正動議的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/953.wav", + "text": "包括第一條第二十二條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/954.wav", + "text": "三十九條及第六十五條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/955.wav", + "text": "這些是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/956.wav", + "text": "委員會審查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/957.wav", + "text": "查通過但" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/958.wav", + "text": "委員有再提出修正動議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/959.wav", + "text": "的等一下就" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/960.wav", + "text": "是一起討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/961.wav", + "text": "把修正動議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/962.wav", + "text": "跟第二輪保留的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/963.wav", + "text": "條文全部合在一起討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/964.wav", + "text": "附帶決議還是放在後面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/965.wav", + "text": "我們在這裡就可以處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/966.wav", + "text": "萬一附帶決議沒有結論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/967.wav", + "text": "整個條文進入二讀的時程" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/968.wav", + "text": "但是這個法案我覺得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/969.wav", + "text": "有些部分不太一樣因為我們的法條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/970.wav", + "text": "到底要不要讓步這件事情是要看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/971.wav", + "text": "附帶決議做得如何" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/972.wav", + "text": "恐怕法條的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/973.wav", + "text": "就會持續保留狀態" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/974.wav", + "text": "所以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/975.wav", + "text": "要問一下議事人員是不是在逐條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/976.wav", + "text": "整包一起討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/977.wav", + "text": "如果相關附帶決議通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/978.wav", + "text": "我想應該更釐清一點就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/979.wav", + "text": "有一些附帶決議我們就連帶處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/980.wav", + "text": "但有些是整部法的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/981.wav", + "text": "相關附帶決議我們到最後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/982.wav", + "text": "再處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/983.wav", + "text": "就不一定要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/984.wav", + "text": "現在處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/985.wav", + "text": "5分鐘來協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/986.wav", + "text": "是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/987.wav", + "text": "我們就討論一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/988.wav", + "text": "我想主要就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/989.wav", + "text": "加了所謂心理不適" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/990.wav", + "text": "時都已經討論很多次了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/991.wav", + "text": "相關的討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/992.wav", + "text": "了我記得好像" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/993.wav", + "text": "附帶決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/994.wav", + "text": "條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/995.wav", + "text": "我們就維持委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/996.wav", + "text": "通過的條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/997.wav", + "text": "各位委員有沒有其他意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/998.wav", + "text": "沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/999.wav", + "text": "第3條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1000.wav", + "text": "剛剛在我們協商的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1001.wav", + "text": "王婉諭委員是不是有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1002.wav", + "text": "相關的附帶決議跟第3條有關呢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1003.wav", + "text": "衛福部說明一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1004.wav", + "text": "現在的協商結論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1005.wav", + "text": "社會參與自立生活" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1006.wav", + "text": "委員關心的部分就是建議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1007.wav", + "text": "危機的一些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1008.wav", + "text": "我們建議用附帶決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1009.wav", + "text": "時代力量" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1010.wav", + "text": "對這個附帶決議我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1011.wav", + "text": "是遵照辦理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1012.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1013.wav", + "text": "大家手上應該都有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1014.wav", + "text": "附帶決議\n請" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1015.wav", + "text": "王委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1016.wav", + "text": "主要問題在於名詞怎麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1017.wav", + "text": "界定大家想像是一樣的也就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1018.wav", + "text": "在還沒有到疑似病人之前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1019.wav", + "text": "本席接受衛福部的建議亦即" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1020.wav", + "text": "亦即不要用這樣的新名詞來定義" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1021.wav", + "text": "但是目前正在進行的這些計畫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1022.wav", + "text": "所以我們針對第3條提出附帶決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1023.wav", + "text": "感謝衛福部支持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1024.wav", + "text": "就按照" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1025.wav", + "text": "衛福部所提" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1026.wav", + "text": "修正條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1027.wav", + "text": "協商通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1028.wav", + "text": "附帶決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1029.wav", + "text": "\n另外民眾黨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1030.wav", + "text": "針對第3條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1031.wav", + "text": "第7款所提的附帶決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1032.wav", + "text": "衛福部有看到嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1033.wav", + "text": "這部分我們都已經把它寫在法條裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1034.wav", + "text": "因此建議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1035.wav", + "text": "這是不是可以撤案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1036.wav", + "text": "OK那就不予處理\n" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1037.wav", + "text": "\n第3條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1038.wav", + "text": "條文協商通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1039.wav", + "text": "第" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1040.wav", + "text": "十九條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1041.wav", + "text": "第十九條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1042.wav", + "text": "我們建議增加第二項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1043.wav", + "text": "也就是委員所關心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1044.wav", + "text": "社區支持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1045.wav", + "text": "如何布建" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1046.wav", + "text": "得依轄內精神病人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1047.wav", + "text": "服務需求與社區支持資源分布情形" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1048.wav", + "text": "積極布建" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1049.wav", + "text": "精神病人社區支持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1050.wav", + "text": "服務資源" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1051.wav", + "text": "藉由增加第十九條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1052.wav", + "text": "第二項來加以規範" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1053.wav", + "text": "衛福部提出的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1054.wav", + "text": "修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1055.wav", + "text": "條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1056.wav", + "text": "協商通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1057.wav", + "text": "處理第" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1058.wav", + "text": "的話其實第2條也是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1059.wav", + "text": "第3條的附帶決議已經通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1060.wav", + "text": "因為第3條已經有處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1061.wav", + "text": "附帶決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1062.wav", + "text": "那麼第2條就按照" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1063.wav", + "text": "衛福部所提" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1064.wav", + "text": "修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1065.wav", + "text": "條文協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1066.wav", + "text": "通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1067.wav", + "text": "第" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1068.wav", + "text": "再修正動議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1069.wav", + "text": "本席辦公室提的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1070.wav", + "text": "請說明一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1071.wav", + "text": "這是這一份的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1072.wav", + "text": "第4案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1073.wav", + "text": "增加以電子文件製" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1074.wav", + "text": "製作及貯存" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1075.wav", + "text": "這是電子病歷的概念" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1076.wav", + "text": "病歷的概念了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1077.wav", + "text": "所以我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1078.wav", + "text": "所以就是在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1079.wav", + "text": "這個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1080.wav", + "text": "最後第幾項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1081.wav", + "text": "跟我們原來的條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1082.wav", + "text": "第22條第3項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1083.wav", + "text": "就修正��" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1084.wav", + "text": "要比較一下改變的地方" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1085.wav", + "text": "對於這個第3項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1086.wav", + "text": "我沒有意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1087.wav", + "text": "但是因為後面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1088.wav", + "text": "所以我比較建議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1089.wav", + "text": "這一項是不是放在最後面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1090.wav", + "text": "避免影響該條項次的改變" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1091.wav", + "text": "進而影響後面條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1092.wav", + "text": "第82條有針對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1093.wav", + "text": "第22條第3項規定接受評鑑" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1094.wav", + "text": "如果放在最後面不曉得有沒有影響" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1095.wav", + "text": "所以林委員的提案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1096.wav", + "text": "也有一個罰則的動議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1097.wav", + "text": "我們已經調在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1098.wav", + "text": "第82條第2款" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1099.wav", + "text": "修正版本第82條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1100.wav", + "text": "我們已經有針對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1101.wav", + "text": "一併做修正了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1102.wav", + "text": "所以還是可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1103.wav", + "text": "放在第3項沒問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1104.wav", + "text": "這跟通過條文的最後一款" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1105.wav", + "text": "也有一些差異" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1106.wav", + "text": "所以確認一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1107.wav", + "text": "是照修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1108.wav", + "text": "動議還是要照原本通過的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1109.wav", + "text": "條次因為看起來好像有一些差異" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1110.wav", + "text": "內容有一些不一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1111.wav", + "text": "有一個電子病歷" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1112.wav", + "text": "的授權辦法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1113.wav", + "text": "所以增加了第3項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1114.wav", + "text": "一項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1115.wav", + "text": "有一個授權辦法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1116.wav", + "text": "就是在第" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1117.wav", + "text": "第3項增列" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1118.wav", + "text": "的方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1119.wav", + "text": "最後一項是在整個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1120.wav", + "text": "授權辦法的部分增加" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1121.wav", + "text": "第3項業務紀錄之製作方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1122.wav", + "text": "與內容等等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1123.wav", + "text": "把它" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1124.wav", + "text": "授權的事項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1125.wav", + "text": "之一" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1126.wav", + "text": "因為增加了第3項裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1127.wav", + "text": "的文字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1128.wav", + "text": "所以在這邊也同時" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1129.wav", + "text": "調整將第3" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1130.wav", + "text": "項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1131.wav", + "text": "業務紀錄之製作方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1132.wav", + "text": "與內容" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1133.wav", + "text": "那就按照" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1134.wav", + "text": "本辦公室所提" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1135.wav", + "text": "修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1136.wav", + "text": "動議的條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1137.wav", + "text": "協商通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1138.wav", + "text": "\n接著處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1139.wav", + "text": "修正動議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1140.wav", + "text": "的第26條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1141.wav", + "text": "4案的第6頁" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1142.wav", + "text": "針對第26條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1143.wav", + "text": "這個我們所提的修正動議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1144.wav", + "text": "這條最主要是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1145.wav", + "text": "病人之範圍" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1146.wav", + "text": "增加之範圍" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1147.wav", + "text": "雖然在本法裡面其實病人本身有定義" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1148.wav", + "text": "定義通報的範圍" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1149.wav", + "text": "這是沒有問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1150.wav", + "text": "第1項也有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1151.wav", + "text": "地方主管機關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1152.wav", + "text": "應" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1153.wav", + "text": "針對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1154.wav", + "text": "所轄醫療機構" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1155.wav", + "text": "通報及通知" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1156.wav", + "text": "對文字這樣修改" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1157.wav", + "text": "可以嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1158.wav", + "text": "第1項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1159.wav", + "text": "還有第3項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1160.wav", + "text": "增加了之範圍" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1161.wav", + "text": "如果沒有意見的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1162.wav", + "text": "本條就按照林為洲委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1163.wav", + "text": "所提的修正動議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1164.wav", + "text": "協商通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1165.wav", + "text": "吳委員所提的修正條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1166.wav", + "text": "就是刪除行政院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1167.wav", + "text": "版本的第2款" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1168.wav", + "text": "有扶養義務者經" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1169.wav", + "text": "通知後無故未盡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1170.wav", + "text": "尊重委員的意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1171.wav", + "text": "主席這個修正動議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1172.wav", + "text": "是王委員跟" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1173.wav", + "text": "范委員也都有提" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1174.wav", + "text": "第2款是新增的文字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1175.wav", + "text": "沒有這樣的文字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1176.wav", + "text": "所以在這邊多課以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1177.wav", + "text": "課以家屬扶養義務" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1178.wav", + "text": "人的角色應該是回到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1179.wav", + "text": "民法就可以有相關的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1180.wav", + "text": "聽取我們的建議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1181.wav", + "text": "其實是回復到原來的條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1182.wav", + "text": "吳委員王委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1183.wav", + "text": "及范委員所提" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1184.wav", + "text": "修正動議條文協商通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1185.wav", + "text": "我再唸一次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1186.wav", + "text": "第28條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1187.wav", + "text": "吳玉琴委員范雲委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1188.wav", + "text": "王婉諭委員所提" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1189.wav", + "text": "修正動議條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1190.wav", + "text": "協商通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1191.wav", + "text": "第" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1192.wav", + "text": "也是修正動議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1193.wav", + "text": "修正動議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1194.wav", + "text": "就有會客的權利這樣是不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1195.wav", + "text": "還要把律師接見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1196.wav", + "text": "特別納入但他並未被" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1197.wav", + "text": "羈押所以不是接見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1198.wav", + "text": "的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1199.wav", + "text": "醫療機構" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1200.wav", + "text": "擔心也會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1201.wav", + "text": "有答應要制訂指引" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1202.wav", + "text": "不影響其" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1203.wav", + "text": "律師接見的權利對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1204.wav", + "text": "何況也不是接見只有被羈押" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1205.wav", + "text": "的才叫接見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1206.wav", + "text": "本來就可以見律師" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1207.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1208.wav", + "text": "問題所以是不是一起討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1209.wav", + "text": "第13案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1210.wav", + "text": "我們看一下第13案的附帶決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1211.wav", + "text": "以用附帶決議方式稍微" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1212.wav", + "text": "部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1213.wav", + "text": "請說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1214.wav", + "text": "因為後面第二段第三段" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1215.wav", + "text": "寫得很細節" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1216.wav", + "text": "已經針對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1217.wav", + "text": "限制會客" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1218.wav", + "text": "或通訊自由的例外做了指引" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1219.wav", + "text": "而且我們還需要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1220.wav", + "text": "找相關的人員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1221.wav", + "text": "包括病人病人家屬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1222.wav", + "text": "以及權益團體一起來共同研擬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1223.wav", + "text": "討論所以是不是保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1224.wav", + "text": "第一段至於第二段第三段" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1225.wav", + "text": "我們跟團體一起討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1226.wav", + "text": "之後有一些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1227.wav", + "text": "共識與結論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1228.wav", + "text": "我們之所以會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1229.wav", + "text": "這樣列就是因為擔心在討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1230.wav", + "text": "在第二段第三段都是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1231.wav", + "text": "不保險就是建請評估" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1232.wav", + "text": "這幾個方法對這幾個部分可能" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1233.wav", + "text": "要考慮進去在討論當中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1234.wav", + "text": "不要遺漏這幾個可行的方向" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1235.wav", + "text": "會客名單是不是一定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1236.wav", + "text": "只能用會客名單來確保" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1237.wav", + "text": "會客的權利" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1238.wav", + "text": "在討論這個方案時" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1239.wav", + "text": "不要忘了可能有這個選擇" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1240.wav", + "text": "是支持的只是提供我們的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1241.wav", + "text": "看法可能有這幾種做法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1242.wav", + "text": "請衛福部參酌" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1243.wav", + "text": "例如最後一段有關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1244.wav", + "text": "手機的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1245.wav", + "text": "目前全世界對這個都還沒有共識" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1246.wav", + "text": "處理這個問題但到目前為止" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1247.wav", + "text": "有些國家有嘗試一些方法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1248.wav", + "text": "但也都沒有一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1249.wav", + "text": "討論到目前都還沒得到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1250.wav", + "text": "結論其實我們已經在進行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1251.wav", + "text": "既保障其他人的權益" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1252.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1253.wav", + "text": "怎麼修改" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1254.wav", + "text": "第一段" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1255.wav", + "text": "建議在第二段" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1256.wav", + "text": "限並應保障住院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1257.wav", + "text": "病人之律師接見權利" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1258.wav", + "text": "因為已經不以親屬關係" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1259.wav", + "text": "羈押才會有接見的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1260.wav", + "text": "所以建議將第二段" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1261.wav", + "text": "最後一句刪除" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1262.wav", + "text": "在另針對自由通訊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1263.wav", + "text": "之權利" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1264.wav", + "text": "此" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1265.wav", + "text": "的內容建議刪除" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1266.wav", + "text": "就是另針對自由通訊之權利" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1267.wav", + "text": "建請衛福部或可參考" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1268.wav", + "text": "以電子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1269.wav", + "text": "方式為管理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1270.wav", + "text": "也建議刪除" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1271.wav", + "text": "只保留最後一句" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1272.wav", + "text": "而非一律禁止" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1273.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1274.wav", + "text": "修正動議的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1275.wav", + "text": "文字予以修改" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1276.wav", + "text": "的文字通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1277.wav", + "text": "第28條吳玉琴委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1278.wav", + "text": "范雲委員王婉諭委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1279.wav", + "text": "剛才有一個修正動議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1280.wav", + "text": "刪除第2款" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1281.wav", + "text": "有第2款" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1282.wav", + "text": "你們再簽一次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1283.wav", + "text": "把這個新的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1284.wav", + "text": "再簽一次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1285.wav", + "text": "其實你們有刪除" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1286.wav", + "text": "但只是修正動議放在右邊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1287.wav", + "text": "再寫一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1288.wav", + "text": "你們再簽一次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1289.wav", + "text": "照理說修正動議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1290.wav", + "text": "都要放左邊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1291.wav", + "text": "\n原條文放右邊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1292.wav", + "text": "第65條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1293.wav", + "text": "也有修正動議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1294.wav", + "text": "條文都是連動的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1295.wav", + "text": "這個部分包括第74條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1296.wav", + "text": "65條都是連動的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1297.wav", + "text": "所以我們一併做修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1298.wav", + "text": "加上除有第74條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1299.wav", + "text": "規定得繼續進行之情形外" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1300.wav", + "text": "強制住院期滿" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1301.wav", + "text": "新增的文字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1302.wav", + "text": "第2項是嚴重病人有前條第1款情形時" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1303.wav", + "text": "法院強制住院之裁定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1304.wav", + "text": "視為撤銷" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1305.wav", + "text": "並停止執行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1306.wav", + "text": "這是司法院這邊提供的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1307.wav", + "text": "這個是在修正動議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1308.wav", + "text": "第6頁" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1309.wav", + "text": "本席所提的則是在第4案的第8頁" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1310.wav", + "text": "說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1311.wav", + "text": "各位委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1312.wav", + "text": "第65條就誠如剛剛吳委員提到的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1313.wav", + "text": "這個部分是指" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1314.wav", + "text": "如果有這樣一個情形" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1315.wav", + "text": "就是應該要立即" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1316.wav", + "text": "停止的情形" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1317.wav", + "text": "第2款增加的部分是因為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1318.wav", + "text": "這個部分是強制住院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1319.wav", + "text": "期滿但是第74條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1320.wav", + "text": "的這個部分是除外的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1321.wav", + "text": "所以增加這個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1322.wav", + "text": "可以比較具體明確" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1323.wav", + "text": "至於第2項的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1324.wav", + "text": "不需要再經過法院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1325.wav", + "text": "所以我們用視為撤銷" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1326.wav", + "text": "並且停止執行就是如果有第1款" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1327.wav", + "text": "病情改善沒有繼續" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1328.wav", + "text": "強制住院必要的時候以上說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1329.wav", + "text": "謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1330.wav", + "text": "衛福部有沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1331.wav", + "text": "意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1332.wav", + "text": "修正條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1333.wav", + "text": "協商通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1334.wav", + "text": "\n接著處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1335.wav", + "text": "第" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1336.wav", + "text": "保留條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1337.wav", + "text": "大本的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1338.wav", + "text": "251頁" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1339.wav", + "text": "第81條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1340.wav", + "text": "因為前面我們已經把親屬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1341.wav", + "text": "後面的家屬或" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1342.wav", + "text": "所以就只有保護人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1343.wav", + "text": "精神照護機構人員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1344.wav", + "text": "違反的時候才會被處罰" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1345.wav", + "text": "正為病人之保護人或" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1346.wav", + "text": "而不是頓號請" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1347.wav", + "text": "把文字提出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1348.wav", + "text": "條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1349.wav", + "text": "修正通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1350.wav", + "text": "第" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1351.wav", + "text": "82條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1352.wav", + "text": "主席上次是因為第65條保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1353.wav", + "text": "應該沒有了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1354.wav", + "text": "沒有主" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1355.wav", + "text": "主席你自己有提案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1356.wav", + "text": "好我們看一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1357.wav", + "text": "是啦剛剛前面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1358.wav", + "text": "第82條是因為我們前面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1359.wav", + "text": "病歷所以對於這個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1360.wav", + "text": "我們把處罰的項次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1361.wav", + "text": "針對前面的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1362.wav", + "text": "修正做對應的調整" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1363.wav", + "text": "所以第82條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1364.wav", + "text": "要照" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1365.wav", + "text": "召委的版本通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1366.wav", + "text": "其實我們已經有文字了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1367.wav", + "text": "\n第82條就按照" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1368.wav", + "text": "林為洲委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1369.wav", + "text": "所提修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1370.wav", + "text": "條文協商通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1371.wav", + "text": "第92條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1372.wav", + "text": "年度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1373.wav", + "text": "什麼時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1374.wav", + "text": "要開始施行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1375.wav", + "text": "主要就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1376.wav", + "text": "施行日期" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1377.wav", + "text": "要怎麼訂" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1378.wav", + "text": "定除第五章的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1379.wav", + "text": "沒有問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1380.wav", + "text": "嘛除第五章" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1381.wav", + "text": "第82條第1項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1382.wav", + "text": "第3款及第4款" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1383.wav", + "text": "再來就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1384.wav", + "text": "由行政院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1385.wav", + "text": "會同司法院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1386.wav", + "text": "定之外" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1387.wav", + "text": "二年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1388.wav", + "text": "還是一年半" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1389.wav", + "text": "一年半可以嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1390.wav", + "text": "長服法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1391.wav", + "text": "長服法不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1392.wav", + "text": "修訂子法的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1393.wav", + "text": "實在是很大幅度的修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1394.wav", + "text": "幾乎全面都要改" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1395.wav", + "text": "也是這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1396.wav", + "text": "要改的地方真的很多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1397.wav", + "text": "所以請委員們多包涵一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1398.wav", + "text": "可以做這件事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1399.wav", + "text": "中間要跟團體" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1400.wav", + "text": "NGO協商的地方很多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1401.wav", + "text": "不是我們自己" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1402.wav", + "text": "內部訂定就好了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1403.wav", + "text": "困難點是在這裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1404.wav", + "text": "那些都要安排" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1405.wav", + "text": "會議跟時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1406.wav", + "text": "各位委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1407.wav", + "text": "我覺" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1408.wav", + "text": "我們還是把日期" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1409.wav", + "text": "定在一年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1410.wav", + "text": "九個月" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1411.wav", + "text": "這樣才有一點壓力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1412.wav", + "text": "給他們要積極" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1413.wav", + "text": "不要怠惰" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1414.wav", + "text": "還是一年半" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1415.wav", + "text": "就一年半就好了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1416.wav", + "text": "不要一年半" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1417.wav", + "text": "日期是一定要訂" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1418.wav", + "text": "先訂一年半好了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1419.wav", + "text": "然後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1420.wav", + "text": "你們回去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1421.wav", + "text": "因為我們距離二讀三讀" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1422.wav", + "text": "還有一段時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1423.wav", + "text": "你們就去盤點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1424.wav", + "text": "如果一年半OK" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1425.wav", + "text": "就好了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1426.wav", + "text": "各位委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1427.wav", + "text": "今天我們如果出委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1428.wav", + "text": "議事人員已經告訴我" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1429.wav", + "text": "兩個禮拜後就可以二三讀" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1430.wav", + "text": "任務" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1431.wav", + "text": "所以這一條這邊一定要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1432.wav", + "text": "你們自己說的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1433.wav", + "text": "現在次長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1434.wav", + "text": "施行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1435.wav", + "text": "距離現在是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1436.wav", + "text": "1年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1437.wav", + "text": "很期待因為這次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1438.wav", + "text": "一次大修" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1439.wav", + "text": "這次真的是整部法的大修" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1440.wav", + "text": "我也知道衛福部當然壓力很大" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1441.wav", + "text": "要負責的大大小小的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1442.wav", + "text": "法扶那一條的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1443.wav", + "text": "有舊的舊的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1444.wav", + "text": "因為也要跟團體溝通" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1445.wav", + "text": "行政部門這邊可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1446.wav", + "text": "看到他們列出來27部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1447.wav", + "text": "大大小小的子法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1448.wav", + "text": "看到也覺得有點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1449.wav", + "text": "量很大" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1450.wav", + "text": "行政部門可以跟團體" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1451.wav", + "text": "充分溝通因為這次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1452.wav", + "text": "精神衛生法修法的過程中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1453.wav", + "text": "團體有非常非常多的意見進來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1454.wav", + "text": "期盼能夠修得更好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1455.wav", + "text": "但另一個因素是不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1456.wav", + "text": "行政部門跟團體的溝通顯然" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1457.wav", + "text": "不太夠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1458.wav", + "text": "或是行政部門讓他們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1459.wav", + "text": "表達意見的機會不太多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1460.wav", + "text": "所以造成他們所有的意見都反映到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1461.wav", + "text": "立法委員這邊來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1462.wav", + "text": "因為我知道為難你們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1463.wav", + "text": "也怕因此減少跟團體的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1464.wav", + "text": "互動我也希望他們能夠充分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1465.wav", + "text": "地跟團體互動" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1466.wav", + "text": "跟團體的互動我相信需要時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1467.wav", + "text": "因為溝通是需要一點時間的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1468.wav", + "text": "所以如果給二年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1469.wav", + "text": "可以跟團體比較充分地溝通" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1470.wav", + "text": "不要讓他們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1471.wav", + "text": "的聲音一直都只能反映" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1472.wav", + "text": "跟他們進行相關的溝通而且要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1473.wav", + "text": "或是創新方案的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1474.wav", + "text": "就能夠把他們的意見納進來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1475.wav", + "text": "其他委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1476.wav", + "text": "有沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1477.wav", + "text": "意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1478.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1479.wav", + "text": "第92條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1480.wav", + "text": "就尊重" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1481.wav", + "text": "衛福部所提的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1482.wav", + "text": "施行的時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1483.wav", + "text": "本法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1484.wav", + "text": "施行日期對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1485.wav", + "text": "就直接拿來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1486.wav", + "text": "\n我們再念一次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1487.wav", + "text": "第92條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1488.wav", + "text": "修改" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1489.wav", + "text": "跟主席報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1490.wav", + "text": "因為搭配第92條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1491.wav", + "text": "有一個施行日期的差別" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1492.wav", + "text": "我們建議第89條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1493.wav", + "text": "修正之條文施行前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1494.wav", + "text": "修正前規定強制住院者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1495.wav", + "text": "底下文字都" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1496.wav", + "text": "維持原來審查會的文字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1497.wav", + "text": "這樣的話我們覺得會稍微" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1498.wav", + "text": "再清楚一點在適用上比較" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1499.wav", + "text": "不會有疑問" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1500.wav", + "text": "因此我們建議在第89條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1501.wav", + "text": "第1項第二句" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1502.wav", + "text": "增加3個字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1503.wav", + "text": "以上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1504.wav", + "text": "因為當時我們在討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1505.wav", + "text": "施行時間的時候確實會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1506.wav", + "text": "有一點困惑第89條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1507.wav", + "text": "繼續強制住院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1508.wav", + "text": "對於文字的修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1509.wav", + "text": "當時我也是請" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1510.wav", + "text": "文字修正但是不是請" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1511.wav", + "text": "幫我們看一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1512.wav", + "text": "建議是分成兩部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1513.wav", + "text": "等於是分開施行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1514.wav", + "text": "第五章第82條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1515.wav", + "text": "由行政院會同司法院定之" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1516.wav", + "text": "則是自公布後二年施行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1517.wav", + "text": "這樣看起來第89條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1518.wav", + "text": "和最後一條有關係的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1519.wav", + "text": "第1項比較接近的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1520.wav", + "text": "由行政院會同司法院定之" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1521.wav", + "text": "這個日期因為它是涉及" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1522.wav", + "text": "強制住院的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1523.wav", + "text": "所以這邊的條文是中華民國" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1524.wav", + "text": "○年○月○日修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1525.wav", + "text": "之條文施行前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1526.wav", + "text": "依修正前規定強制住院者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1527.wav", + "text": "○年○月○日修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1528.wav", + "text": "之條文施行前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1529.wav", + "text": "而這個施行的日期" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1530.wav", + "text": "是由行政院會同" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1531.wav", + "text": "司法院定之" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1532.wav", + "text": "所以等到那個定之" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1533.wav", + "text": "的日期出來以後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1534.wav", + "text": "這個條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1535.wav", + "text": "才會繼續施行前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1536.wav", + "text": "2個院會同施行的日期" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1537.wav", + "text": "到底有多久時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1538.wav", + "text": "\n如果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1539.wav", + "text": "會同指定的時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1540.wav", + "text": "115年1月1日" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1541.wav", + "text": "那就是115年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1542.wav", + "text": "1月1日" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1543.wav", + "text": "修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1544.wav", + "text": "之條文施行前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1545.wav", + "text": "大概就是這個意思" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1546.wav", + "text": "\n不是不" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1547.wav", + "text": "是中華民國○年○月○日" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1548.wav", + "text": "這個○年○月○日" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1549.wav", + "text": "應該是指" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1550.wav", + "text": "這次三讀的日期" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1551.wav", + "text": "○年○月○日" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1552.wav", + "text": "這3個數字是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1553.wav", + "text": "這次修正條文的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1554.wav", + "text": "三讀日期" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1555.wav", + "text": "至於什麼時候是施行前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1556.wav", + "text": "就要另定施行日期" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1557.wav", + "text": "115年1月1日施行前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1558.wav", + "text": "所以這個條文可能解釋成假設" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1559.wav", + "text": "三讀日期是111年12月1日" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1560.wav", + "text": "115年1月1日" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1561.wav", + "text": "那就變成中華民國111年12月1日" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1562.wav", + "text": "修正之條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1563.wav", + "text": "解釋上會說是115年1月1日施行前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1564.wav", + "text": "是這樣的意思" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1565.wav", + "text": "○年○月○日是三讀的日期" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1566.wav", + "text": "條文施行前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1567.wav", + "text": "他們二個會同指定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1568.wav", + "text": "的那個時間之前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1569.wav", + "text": "是這個意思" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1570.wav", + "text": "第二句" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1571.wav", + "text": "還要再改嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1572.wav", + "text": "已依修正前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1573.wav", + "text": "規定強制住院者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1574.wav", + "text": "你們本來是加了3個字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1575.wav", + "text": "修正前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1576.wav", + "text": "是嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1577.wav", + "text": "\n剛剛他這樣的解釋" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1578.wav", + "text": "條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1579.wav", + "text": "修正是一回事" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1580.wav", + "text": "一個日期" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1581.wav", + "text": "就是三讀" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1582.wav", + "text": "又是一個日期" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1583.wav", + "text": "所以是有2個日期沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1584.wav", + "text": "有共識是二年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1585.wav", + "text": "條文要修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1586.wav", + "text": "三讀之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1587.wav", + "text": "公布然後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1588.wav", + "text": "二年後實施所以前面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1589.wav", + "text": "這樣子解釋OK" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1590.wav", + "text": "那第二句這邊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1591.wav", + "text": "有要再修改嗎還是已" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1592.wav", + "text": "規定強制住院者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1593.wav", + "text": "然後接下來這樣OK嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1594.wav", + "text": "召委我說明一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1595.wav", + "text": "我們現在的第89條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1596.wav", + "text": "這裡○年○月" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1597.wav", + "text": "○日指的是我們三讀" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1598.wav", + "text": "通過的那一天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1599.wav", + "text": "這樣是不是應該就不需要在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1600.wav", + "text": "增加修正前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1601.wav", + "text": "的原意因為這一條主要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1602.wav", + "text": "是要去處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1603.wav", + "text": "施行後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1604.wav", + "text": "對施行前他強制住院的這個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1605.wav", + "text": "需要在施行之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1606.wav", + "text": "法官保留的一個許可" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1607.wav", + "text": "除外的規定應該是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1608.wav", + "text": "不生影響解釋上當然" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1609.wav", + "text": "是依照舊法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1610.wav", + "text": "許可這個強制住院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1611.wav", + "text": "再去聲請" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1612.wav", + "text": "強制住院這樣的一個許可" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1613.wav", + "text": "應該是不需要再增加" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1614.wav", + "text": "修正前3個字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1615.wav", + "text": "如何謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1616.wav", + "text": "請王婉諭委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1617.wav", + "text": "我想就剛才法務部的解釋" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1618.wav", + "text": "再釐清一下就是這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1619.wav", + "text": "施行前會有2個日期" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1620.wav", + "text": "一個是剛才我們討論出來的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1621.wav", + "text": "行政院會同" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1622.wav", + "text": "司法院討論出來的日期" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1623.wav", + "text": "這樣子的情況下這個施行前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1624.wav", + "text": "指的是前者這個施行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1625.wav", + "text": "還是後者這個施行這個不用再定義" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1626.wav", + "text": "可以指的是司法院這部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1627.wav", + "text": "的施行日期" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1628.wav", + "text": "如果他是涉及到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1629.wav", + "text": "強制住院相關事項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1630.wav", + "text": "應該是跟司法院會同的那個日期" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1631.wav", + "text": "因為跟司法院會同的日期" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1632.wav", + "text": "才會跟強制住院有關係" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1633.wav", + "text": "謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1634.wav", + "text": "所以就不只是二年的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1635.wav", + "text": "就是司法院行政院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1636.wav", + "text": "要會同去訂定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1637.wav", + "text": "相關的法令之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1638.wav", + "text": "也不用再增加了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1639.wav", + "text": "維持原來的條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1640.wav", + "text": "就可以了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1641.wav", + "text": "維持委員會所通過的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1642.wav", + "text": "條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1643.wav", + "text": "\n我再提一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1644.wav", + "text": "剛剛議事人員有跟我們講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1645.wav", + "text": "就是關於第21條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1646.wav", + "text": "第3項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1647.wav", + "text": "最後倒數第二行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1648.wav", + "text": "依各該" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1649.wav", + "text": "專門職業技術人員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1650.wav", + "text": "是法規還是法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1651.wav", + "text": "辦理執業登記" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1652.wav", + "text": "因為第22條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1653.wav", + "text": "第2項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1654.wav", + "text": "應依各該醫事人員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1655.wav", + "text": "法規辦理執業登記" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1656.wav", + "text": "所以是不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1657.wav", + "text": "要加一個規" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1658.wav", + "text": "倒數第二行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1659.wav", + "text": "得依各該專門" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1660.wav", + "text": "職業技術人員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1661.wav", + "text": "法規辦理執業登記" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1662.wav", + "text": "好像法規比較" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1663.wav", + "text": "有道理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1664.wav", + "text": "是不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1665.wav", + "text": "修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1666.wav", + "text": "第21條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1667.wav", + "text": "第3項倒數第二行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1668.wav", + "text": "規字所以是法規" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1669.wav", + "text": "完了現在處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1670.wav", + "text": "附帶決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1671.wav", + "text": "主席我有一個提醒" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1672.wav", + "text": "條文可能也請" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1673.wav", + "text": "專門委員再處理一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1674.wav", + "text": "我的那一條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1675.wav", + "text": "要插在第24條第25" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1676.wav", + "text": "因為條次的變動真的還滿大的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1677.wav", + "text": "怎麼處理會比較恰當是不是請" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1678.wav", + "text": "專門委員說明一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1679.wav", + "text": "請議事人員回答" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1680.wav", + "text": "增訂第十六條之1" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1681.wav", + "text": "先暫訂第二十四條之一" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1682.wav", + "text": "順序會授權議事人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1683.wav", + "text": "員調整因為有增訂一條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1684.wav", + "text": "文到時候在院會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1685.wav", + "text": "二讀的時候還是會先念" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1686.wav", + "text": "到三讀的時候我們請" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1687.wav", + "text": "衛福部協助把整個條文全部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1688.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1689.wav", + "text": "附帶決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1690.wav", + "text": "委員會保留下來的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1691.wav", + "text": "附帶決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1692.wav", + "text": "現場提出的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1693.wav", + "text": "附帶決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1694.wav", + "text": "通過2案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1695.wav", + "text": "然後再處理委員會的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1696.wav", + "text": "這樣比較好處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1697.wav", + "text": "比較不會亂" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1698.wav", + "text": "不予處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1699.wav", + "text": "第3案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1700.wav", + "text": "最後一段的最後一行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1701.wav", + "text": "修正為相關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1702.wav", + "text": "專業人員之培訓" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1703.wav", + "text": "規劃原來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1704.wav", + "text": "來的督導與考核" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1705.wav", + "text": "好可以接受" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1706.wav", + "text": "好第3案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1707.wav", + "text": "修正通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1708.wav", + "text": "規劃的部分要儘可能做好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1709.wav", + "text": "建議第4案是不是不予處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1710.wav", + "text": "個人隱私及匿" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1711.wav", + "text": "范雲委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1712.wav", + "text": "有連署除" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1713.wav", + "text": "之外王婉諭委員也有連署" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1714.wav", + "text": "他說其他法規已經有規範" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1715.wav", + "text": "OK那我可以接受好那" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1716.wav", + "text": "案就不予處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1717.wav", + "text": "第5案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1718.wav", + "text": "好像沒有討論到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1719.wav", + "text": "就所謂的最低" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1720.wav", + "text": "服務標準" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1721.wav", + "text": "相關的制度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1722.wav", + "text": "最低服務標準" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1723.wav", + "text": "因為以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1724.wav", + "text": "我們是按照失能的等級來提供" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1725.wav", + "text": "所以我覺得很難" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1726.wav", + "text": "有一個所謂的國家的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1727.wav", + "text": "最低服務標準" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1728.wav", + "text": "是不是也不予處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1729.wav", + "text": "沒有最低的服務標準" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1730.wav", + "text": "可以支持的情況下我們當然是希望" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1731.wav", + "text": "能夠給予病人最好的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1732.wav", + "text": "請王婉諭委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1733.wav", + "text": "這應該是根據我們第二次國家審查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1734.wav", + "text": "報告國際委員們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1735.wav", + "text": "給出的結論性意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1736.wav", + "text": "建議我們應該要有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1737.wav", + "text": "應該是完全沒有討論過這件事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1738.wav", + "text": "是不是先" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1739.wav", + "text": "就這部分努力一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1740.wav", + "text": "而不是直接告訴我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1741.wav", + "text": "我們的建議你們不採納" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1742.wav", + "text": "對文字可以怎麼修改" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1743.wav", + "text": "因為你說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1744.wav", + "text": "我們國家沒有最低" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1745.wav", + "text": "的標準這句話聽起來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1746.wav", + "text": "很怪你知道嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1747.wav", + "text": "連最低標準都做不到的意思" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1748.wav", + "text": "這一題我們剛剛釐清了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1749.wav", + "text": "因為它是在CRPD" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1750.wav", + "text": "身障機構這邊所謂的最低" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1751.wav", + "text": "服務標準我們現在就是說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1752.wav", + "text": "評為丙等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1753.wav", + "text": "那當然一定要退場" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1754.wav", + "text": "就是最低因為這個涉及評鑑" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1755.wav", + "text": "不符合丙等的話就要退場" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1756.wav", + "text": "也有評鑑" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1757.wav", + "text": "可是它可能不是退場" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1758.wav", + "text": "而是可能沒有辦法拿到健保" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1759.wav", + "text": "的錢我的意思是二" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1760.wav", + "text": "二者的機制可能" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1761.wav", + "text": "所以是不是要用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1762.wav", + "text": "最低服務標準" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1763.wav", + "text": "標準其實我們一定有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1764.wav", + "text": "督導跟評鑑這部分一定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1765.wav", + "text": "其實有訂定長照" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1766.wav", + "text": "服務品質的基準" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1767.wav", + "text": "如果你們覺得用最低服務標準不適切" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1768.wav", + "text": "是不是一樣比照就是有最低" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1769.wav", + "text": "跟委員報告沒有這樣的概念" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1770.wav", + "text": "因為這是醫療機構及" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1771.wav", + "text": "執行非常多年了遠比" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1772.wav", + "text": "更久所以那個標準是更嚴格" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1773.wav", + "text": "來從設置開始" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1774.wav", + "text": "每個縣市衛生局還每年要督考" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1775.wav", + "text": "的機制是更複雜的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1776.wav", + "text": "但是它的寫法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1777.wav", + "text": "不是這種寫法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1778.wav", + "text": "現在這個寫法是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1779.wav", + "text": "醫療機構的要求只會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1780.wav", + "text": "更嚴格因為它牽涉到人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1781.wav", + "text": "生命的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1782.wav", + "text": "其實我們也有設標" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1783.wav", + "text": "長服法講的是設標" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1784.wav", + "text": "機構也有設標然後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1785.wav", + "text": "也有評鑑除此之外" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1786.wav", + "text": "還有督導考核" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1787.wav", + "text": "照護機構來講如果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1788.wav", + "text": "講如果不過的話連健保" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1789.wav", + "text": "是一個很" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1790.wav", + "text": "大的懲罰只是說它" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1791.wav", + "text": "不是一個最低服務標準的概念" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1792.wav", + "text": "加強對於" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1793.wav", + "text": "各類" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1794.wav", + "text": "精神照護機構的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1795.wav", + "text": "督導與評鑑大概可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1796.wav", + "text": "這樣子寫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1797.wav", + "text": "王委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1798.wav", + "text": "他的意思是本來就有一些標準" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1799.wav", + "text": "設立標準評鑑標準都有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1800.wav", + "text": "制定國家的最低標準" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1801.wav", + "text": "因為這些不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1802.wav", + "text": "新的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1803.wav", + "text": "機構本來就有標準" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1804.wav", + "text": "不會是所謂的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1805.wav", + "text": "國家最低服務標準" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1806.wav", + "text": "所以是不是可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1807.wav", + "text": "就\n請王委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1808.wav", + "text": "第4條是針對這個服務的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1809.wav", + "text": "做出一個標準" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1810.wav", + "text": "照護機構在這個情況之下恐怕沒" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1811.wav", + "text": "辦法訂定更為嚴苛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1812.wav", + "text": "第5行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1813.wav", + "text": "基準之立法體例針對各類" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1814.wav", + "text": "精神服務制定國家最低標準" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1815.wav", + "text": "或是制定國家品質" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1816.wav", + "text": "是服務對服務長照服務" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1817.wav", + "text": "應依第4條制定基準" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1818.wav", + "text": "的規範而" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1819.wav", + "text": "精神障礙的服務也有一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1820.wav", + "text": "某種程度符合了我們應" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1821.wav", + "text": "之國際審查意見是不是可行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1822.wav", + "text": "照護" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1823.wav", + "text": "精神相關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1824.wav", + "text": "服務" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1825.wav", + "text": "精神照護機構" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1826.wav", + "text": "精神專科醫院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1827.wav", + "text": "都有設置標準" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1828.wav", + "text": "也都有評鑑" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1829.wav", + "text": "剛剛我說這兩個都不是身障機構" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1830.wav", + "text": "不是那麼好的一些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1831.wav", + "text": "機構要有退場機制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1832.wav", + "text": "所以我們分為甲乙丙丁級丙" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1833.wav", + "text": "級的一定要退場乙級的就限期要求" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1834.wav", + "text": "辦法改善也會讓他們退場" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1835.wav", + "text": "要我們制定的最低服務標準" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1836.wav", + "text": "也都有評鑑" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1837.wav", + "text": "所以我覺得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1838.wav", + "text": "一樣可是我們真的願意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1839.wav", + "text": "精神照護機構的督導與評鑑" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1840.wav", + "text": "因此這個附帶決議是不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1841.wav", + "text": "修正為針對精神衛生法第" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1842.wav", + "text": "4條第十二款" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1843.wav", + "text": "』建請衛生福利部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1844.wav", + "text": "應加強督導" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1845.wav", + "text": "說明一下就我所知長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1846.wav", + "text": "長服機構應該也有相關的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1847.wav", + "text": "這樣子的概念性之\n因此" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1848.wav", + "text": "某種程度上會覺得我們在精神" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1849.wav", + "text": "衛生或精神照護的領域不夠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1850.wav", + "text": "的方向只是族群和對象" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1851.wav", + "text": "不同而已因此" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1852.wav", + "text": "建請是不是在這裡能夠把此" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1853.wav", + "text": "概念放進去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1854.wav", + "text": "我們只是你就醫院的部分是歸" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1855.wav", + "text": "在哪裡康復之家又歸在哪裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1856.wav", + "text": "我記得我們這邊唯一的授權辦法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1857.wav", + "text": "是在於精神" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1858.wav", + "text": "護理之家因為只有精神" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1859.wav", + "text": "護理之家沒有所謂設置" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1860.wav", + "text": "這次在精神衛生法才有訂定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1861.wav", + "text": "授權辦法其他的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1862.wav", + "text": "醫院就是回到醫療法的設置" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1863.wav", + "text": "而康復之家的部分你們是放在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1864.wav", + "text": "哪裡也放在醫療機構當中嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1865.wav", + "text": "所以在精神衛生法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1866.wav", + "text": "就只有針對──那我剛剛可能講錯就" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1867.wav", + "text": "只有針對精神復健" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1868.wav", + "text": "裡面去設置標準" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1869.wav", + "text": "裡面去設置標準所以我們這邊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1870.wav", + "text": "康復之家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1871.wav", + "text": "的設置標準裡面一定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1872.wav", + "text": "有一個授權辦法我們當然就會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1873.wav", + "text": "設置標準裡面去規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1874.wav", + "text": "所以這是不一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1875.wav", + "text": "的就是我們這個精神照護" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1876.wav", + "text": "機構是分散在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1877.wav", + "text": "不同的法律去做規範的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1878.wav", + "text": "國家最低服務標準其實是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1879.wav", + "text": "國際審查會議的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1880.wav", + "text": "結論所以保留那個字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1881.wav", + "text": "眼應該沒有什麼問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1882.wav", + "text": "機構我剛剛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1883.wav", + "text": "已經說明了我們這個精神" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1884.wav", + "text": "照護機構有的在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1885.wav", + "text": "醫療機構有的在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1886.wav", + "text": "護理之家屬於照護機構" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1887.wav", + "text": "授權辦法都不是身心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1888.wav", + "text": "障礙機構" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1889.wav", + "text": "那你會建議保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1890.wav", + "text": "它這個精神然後如果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1891.wav", + "text": "可以通過的話要怎麼修呢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1892.wav", + "text": "我剛剛有建議啊就是針對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1893.wav", + "text": "這幾款的各類精神照護" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1894.wav", + "text": "機構建請" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1895.wav", + "text": "衛福部應加強督導" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1896.wav", + "text": "及評鑑因為其實本來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1897.wav", + "text": "就都有相關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1898.wav", + "text": "服務標準你覺得要刪掉嗎是這樣嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1899.wav", + "text": "在醫療相關機構沒有所謂" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1900.wav", + "text": "最低服務標準的概念" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1901.wav", + "text": "他是說制定就" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1902.wav", + "text": "就是透過評鑑" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1903.wav", + "text": "不一樣在醫療" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1904.wav", + "text": "機構評鑑裡面沒有這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1905.wav", + "text": "所謂最低服務" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1906.wav", + "text": "而是在我們的評鑑" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1907.wav", + "text": "這樣可以得幾分那樣可以得幾分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1908.wav", + "text": "怎麼樣可以有及格以上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1909.wav", + "text": "的分數怎麼樣是不及格的分數" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1910.wav", + "text": "是一種最低" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1911.wav", + "text": "服務標準的體現" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1912.wav", + "text": "服務標準" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1913.wav", + "text": "搞不清楚是什麼意思" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1914.wav", + "text": "因為大家關心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1915.wav", + "text": "的是國家最低服務標準" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1916.wav", + "text": "的前提是精神照護機構" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1917.wav", + "text": "精神照護機構在我們的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1918.wav", + "text": "是醫療機構護理之家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1919.wav", + "text": "相關的心理治療所" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1920.wav", + "text": "心理諮商所職能治療所" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1921.wav", + "text": "精神復健機構及" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1922.wav", + "text": "社工事務所這是精神" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1923.wav", + "text": "照護機構如果只有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1924.wav", + "text": "\n大概比較有相關的設立" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1925.wav", + "text": "標準相關專業人員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1926.wav", + "text": "是沒有的所以在這個地方" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1927.wav", + "text": "督導和評鑑" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1928.wav", + "text": "精神復健機構或照護" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1929.wav", + "text": "還有很多這在剛剛的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1930.wav", + "text": "所以我是建議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1931.wav", + "text": "好如果沒有結論我們就保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1932.wav", + "text": "剛剛次長的建議是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1933.wav", + "text": "精神照護機構" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1934.wav", + "text": "加強督導及評鑑" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1935.wav", + "text": "我覺得這個後面應該是要落實相關的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1936.wav", + "text": "機構的部分大概都在設立標準" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1937.wav", + "text": "丙等丁等都應該要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1938.wav", + "text": "做相關的改善不然就要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1939.wav", + "text": "停辦了我們其實也有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1940.wav", + "text": "真的不改善就停辦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1941.wav", + "text": "了這個部分其實有相關的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1942.wav", + "text": "可不可以這樣修改" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1943.wav", + "text": "好那就修改" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1944.wav", + "text": "好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1945.wav", + "text": "\n文字修改一下把文字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1946.wav", + "text": "修改出來\n繼續" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1947.wav", + "text": "處理第" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1948.wav", + "text": "第6案我們建議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1949.wav", + "text": "專業人員之培訓規劃" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1950.wav", + "text": "你的意思是因為專業人員訓練都還沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1951.wav", + "text": "所以沒辦法到督導和考核我理解" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1952.wav", + "text": "所以還是一樣就建請衛福部還是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1953.wav", + "text": "要積極進行培訓的規劃" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1954.wav", + "text": "把文字列出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1955.wav", + "text": "你們討論過了嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1956.wav", + "text": "內政部警政署" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1957.wav", + "text": "警政署" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1958.wav", + "text": "要拿麥克風" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1959.wav", + "text": "要收音" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1960.wav", + "text": "有關游委員第8條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1961.wav", + "text": "內容跟文字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1962.wav", + "text": "做修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1963.wav", + "text": "我們同意按照修正過的內容" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1964.wav", + "text": "來處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1965.wav", + "text": "修正過的文字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1966.wav", + "text": "你是什麼單位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1967.wav", + "text": "請人事總處" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1968.wav", + "text": "報告委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1969.wav", + "text": "游委員所提的附帶決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1970.wav", + "text": "因為現行警政署" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1971.wav", + "text": "就有用它現有的資源在做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1972.wav", + "text": "諮商的服務" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1973.wav", + "text": "為了避免政府資源的重複" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1974.wav", + "text": "地方警消機關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1975.wav", + "text": "推動內部員工心理健康的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1976.wav", + "text": "事宜最好是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1977.wav", + "text": "優先採行現行與外聘專家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1978.wav", + "text": "合作的機制去處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1979.wav", + "text": "警政署跟消防署的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1980.wav", + "text": "這個作法的基礎上它可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1981.wav", + "text": "加以因應或者是強化" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1982.wav", + "text": "因為它會涉及到機關員額" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1983.wav", + "text": "或者是組織調整所以我們會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1984.wav", + "text": "末段把行政院人事" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1985.wav", + "text": "刪除以上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1986.wav", + "text": "主席" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1987.wav", + "text": "因為這邊也有請衛福部要積極協助" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1988.wav", + "text": "我要先講一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1989.wav", + "text": "防治的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1990.wav", + "text": "整個當中有很多的討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1991.wav", + "text": "其實警消同仁可能會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1992.wav", + "text": "比較希望是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1993.wav", + "text": "一個外部協商的機制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1994.wav", + "text": "如果是編制內的協商其實對他們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1995.wav", + "text": "來講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1996.wav", + "text": "壓力反而是比較大的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1997.wav", + "text": "考核等等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1998.wav", + "text": "警政署或消防署要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/1999.wav", + "text": "再衡量這個部分我們也" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2000.wav", + "text": "尊重你們的整個規劃" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2001.wav", + "text": "可是我們可能也沒有辦法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2002.wav", + "text": "做協助如果在你們的員額內" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2003.wav", + "text": "要去運用的話我們也尊重" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2004.wav", + "text": "是什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2005.wav", + "text": "我看起來我們也沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2006.wav", + "text": "一個合適的角色啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2007.wav", + "text": "所以請把衛生福利部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2008.wav", + "text": "積極協助這個部分的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2009.wav", + "text": "衛生福利部刪除謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2010.wav", + "text": "第7案最後一行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2011.wav", + "text": "把它去掉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2012.wav", + "text": "倒數第二行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2013.wav", + "text": "有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2014.wav", + "text": "至少一名" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2015.wav", + "text": "專���心理專業" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2016.wav", + "text": "人力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2017.wav", + "text": "為其服務" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2018.wav", + "text": "然後再來那" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2019.wav", + "text": "句不要後面是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2020.wav", + "text": "於本法修正通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2021.wav", + "text": "五年內落實" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2022.wav", + "text": "修正通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2023.wav", + "text": "建議將第二行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2024.wav", + "text": "應包含" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2025.wav", + "text": "的應改成建議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2026.wav", + "text": "好那就修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2027.wav", + "text": "通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2028.wav", + "text": "第9案其實跟第10案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2029.wav", + "text": "我是建議第9案不予處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2030.wav", + "text": "比較完整就以第10案為主" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2031.wav", + "text": "好第9案不予處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2032.wav", + "text": "第12案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2033.wav", + "text": "也遵照辦理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2034.wav", + "text": "已經有修文字了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2035.wav", + "text": "溝通過了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2036.wav", + "text": "第14案建議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2037.wav", + "text": "在最後一段" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2038.wav", + "text": "倒數第三行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2039.wav", + "text": "應召集精神" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2040.wav", + "text": "衛生專業人員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2041.wav", + "text": "再來是精神醫療" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2042.wav", + "text": "機構代表" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2043.wav", + "text": "後面病人及家庭照顧" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2044.wav", + "text": "支持者代表也建請" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2045.wav", + "text": "刪除" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2046.wav", + "text": "討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2047.wav", + "text": "能不能說明一下刪除的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2048.wav", + "text": "理由和原因" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2049.wav", + "text": "因為這個部分是在匡列強制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2050.wav", + "text": "治療的費用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2051.wav", + "text": "我們覺得應該是比較相關的人員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2052.wav", + "text": "進來討論即可" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2053.wav", + "text": "所以是精神衛生的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2054.wav", + "text": "專業人員還有這些機構" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2055.wav", + "text": "的代表他們是在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2056.wav", + "text": "執行面所以他們會更清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2057.wav", + "text": "其他較不相關的人員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2058.wav", + "text": "其實是不用納入的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2059.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2060.wav", + "text": "第15案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2061.wav", + "text": "建議最後一行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2062.wav", + "text": "修正通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2063.wav", + "text": "施行後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2064.wav", + "text": "兩個字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2065.wav", + "text": "好說明一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2066.wav", + "text": "後面算來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2067.wav", + "text": "行本來是衛生福利部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2068.wav", + "text": "共同去除" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2069.wav", + "text": "變成衛生福利部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2070.wav", + "text": "會同內政部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2071.wav", + "text": "訂定指定\n後面都一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2072.wav", + "text": "以上是警政署的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2073.wav", + "text": "可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2074.wav", + "text": "好修正通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2075.wav", + "text": "第16案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2076.wav", + "text": "兩頁的提案請" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2077.wav", + "text": "衛福部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2078.wav", + "text": "第16案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2079.wav", + "text": "機制我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2080.wav", + "text": "覺得像這樣一個機制都由" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2081.wav", + "text": "在扮演這樣的角色" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2082.wav", + "text": "建議這個案子是不是不" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2083.wav", + "text": "予處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2084.wav", + "text": "我這個提案跟剛剛好像" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2085.wav", + "text": "洪申翰委員的提案有點像" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2086.wav", + "text": "我想我們就尊重" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2087.wav", + "text": "好第16案不予處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2088.wav", + "text": "第17案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2089.wav", + "text": "建議在第二段" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2090.wav", + "text": "倒數第二行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2091.wav", + "text": "社區支持項目及精神" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2092.wav", + "text": "病神需求這個神" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2093.wav", + "text": "好這個沒問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2094.wav", + "text": "第18案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2095.wav", + "text": "心理衛生中心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2096.wav", + "text": "這幾個字就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2097.wav", + "text": "研議辦理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2098.wav", + "text": "主詞不一定是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2099.wav", + "text": "心理衛生中心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2100.wav", + "text": "第19案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2101.wav", + "text": "第19案建議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2102.wav", + "text": "最後一段倒數" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2103.wav", + "text": "第二行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2104.wav", + "text": "研議出院準備計畫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2105.wav", + "text": "精神醫療機構" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2106.wav", + "text": "誘因能夠有出院準備計畫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2107.wav", + "text": "就接受衛福部的建議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2108.wav", + "text": "第二行的應包含是不是改為建議包含" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2109.wav", + "text": "跟前面的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2110.wav", + "text": "第二行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2111.wav", + "text": "建議包含" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2112.wav", + "text": "應包含" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2113.wav", + "text": "跟剛剛一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2114.wav", + "text": "你們覺得裡面有一些是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2115.wav", + "text": "有困難是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2116.wav", + "text": "也許沒有辦法一次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2117.wav", + "text": "到位所以建議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2118.wav", + "text": "寫法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2119.wav", + "text": "條文裡面其實也有這一些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2120.wav", + "text": "那就先用建議包含" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2121.wav", + "text": "好修正通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2122.wav", + "text": "第一本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2123.wav", + "text": "附帶決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2124.wav", + "text": "第一個附帶決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2125.wav", + "text": "是蘇巧慧委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2126.wav", + "text": "的這個案子嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2127.wav", + "text": "遵照辦理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2128.wav", + "text": "通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2129.wav", + "text": "提案人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2130.wav", + "text": "這案是不是請內政部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2131.wav", + "text": "表示意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2132.wav", + "text": "或是警政署" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2133.wav", + "text": "表示意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2134.wav", + "text": "重點就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2135.wav", + "text": "每年應召集專家學者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2136.wav", + "text": "及第一線執勤人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2137.wav", + "text": "檢討精進" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2138.wav", + "text": "警消人員之訓練" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2139.wav", + "text": "好沒有意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2140.wav", + "text": "照案通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2141.wav", + "text": "第3案也遵照辦理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2142.wav", + "text": "遵照辦理照案通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2143.wav", + "text": "第4案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2144.wav", + "text": "建議在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2145.wav", + "text": "倒數第二行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2146.wav", + "text": "修正成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2147.wav", + "text": "應明定部內分工原則" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2148.wav", + "text": "倒數第二行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2149.wav", + "text": "現在是第4案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2150.wav", + "text": "66頁" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2151.wav", + "text": "蘇巧慧委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2152.wav", + "text": "蔡壁如委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2153.wav", + "text": "林為洲委員王婉諭委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2154.wav", + "text": "所提的附帶決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2155.wav", + "text": "精神疾病病人所需" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2156.wav", + "text": "之精神醫療精神" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2157.wav", + "text": "復健事涉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2158.wav", + "text": "事涉跨領域" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2159.wav", + "text": "資源投注" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2160.wav", + "text": "及專業合作" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2161.wav", + "text": "為使事權明確" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2162.wav", + "text": "中央主管機關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2163.wav", + "text": "衛政主管機關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2164.wav", + "text": "不好意思" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2165.wav", + "text": "沒有第2項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2166.wav", + "text": "只有一項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2167.wav", + "text": "大本的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2168.wav", + "text": "你們沒有嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2169.wav", + "text": "現在在處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2170.wav", + "text": "的是審查會保留的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2171.wav", + "text": "附帶決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2172.wav", + "text": "是第4案嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2173.wav", + "text": "對第4案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2174.wav", + "text": "應敘明衛政及" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2175.wav", + "text": "社政主管事項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2176.wav", + "text": "因為其實不只" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2177.wav", + "text": "衛政社政" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2178.wav", + "text": "應明定部內分工原則" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2179.wav", + "text": "司署共同合作及推動相關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2180.wav", + "text": "事項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2181.wav", + "text": "修正通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2182.wav", + "text": "內政部的事項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2183.wav", + "text": "是不是請內政部表示意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2184.wav", + "text": "請內政部或警政署" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2185.wav", + "text": "說明\n重點就是要求內政部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2186.wav", + "text": "應比照美國危機處理團隊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2187.wav", + "text": "之完整教育訓練計畫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2188.wav", + "text": "納入警察" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2189.wav", + "text": "消防人員之常年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2190.wav", + "text": "訓練" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2191.wav", + "text": "可以嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2192.wav", + "text": "處理精神" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2193.wav", + "text": "危機時" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2194.wav", + "text": "報告主席" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2195.wav", + "text": "內政部消防署第一次發言" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2196.wav", + "text": "有關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2197.wav", + "text": "我們會列在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2198.wav", + "text": "指引裡面我們會來執行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2199.wav", + "text": "附帶決議已經討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2200.wav", + "text": "過游委員提出的第8條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2201.wav", + "text": "我有一個問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2202.wav", + "text": "想要提出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2203.wav", + "text": "警察和" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2204.wav", + "text": "消防單位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2205.wav", + "text": "設置至少一名專職" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2206.wav", + "text": "在倒數第三行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2207.wav", + "text": "這裡面牽涉到經費" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2208.wav", + "text": "申請社安網之經費" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2209.wav", + "text": "因為事涉衛福部是否" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2210.wav", + "text": "可以使用社安網的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2211.wav", + "text": "經費人力這個可能要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2212.wav", + "text": "請衛福部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2213.wav", + "text": "做一個說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2214.wav", + "text": "你們要怎麼改" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2215.wav", + "text": "5案當時在委員會協商是因為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2216.wav", + "text": "我們在法條上面有退讓然後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2217.wav", + "text": "用附帶決議來處理當時是已經承諾" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2218.wav", + "text": "如果沒有的話我們是不是要提再好那" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2219.wav", + "text": "照案通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2220.wav", + "text": "通過的案子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2221.wav", + "text": "類似我不知道是否" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2222.wav", + "text": "要不予處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2223.wav", + "text": "就是出院準備計畫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2224.wav", + "text": "要納入醫院評鑑" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2225.wav", + "text": "經費但是剛剛前一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2226.wav", + "text": "附帶決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2227.wav", + "text": "第11案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2228.wav", + "text": "沒有寫到經費" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2229.wav", + "text": "所以這個案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2230.wav", + "text": "子如果要通過的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2231.wav", + "text": "我們也是遵照" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2232.wav", + "text": "辦理那" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2233.wav", + "text": "公設保護人比較是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2234.wav", + "text": "這個案子是不是可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2235.wav", + "text": "不予處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2236.wav", + "text": "我想請教一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2237.wav", + "text": "但是當時認為這個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2238.wav", + "text": "可能不宜直接用法規才會用附帶決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2239.wav", + "text": "的方式問題在於現在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2240.wav", + "text": "公設保護人的效能" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2241.wav", + "text": "還有他們能夠提供的協助" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2242.wav", + "text": "是有限的不完全是因為公設" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2243.wav", + "text": "系統在設置公設保護人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2244.wav", + "text": "的部分還有一些模糊地帶" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2245.wav", + "text": "所以我們希望未來能夠就這個部分有一些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2246.wav", + "text": "的方式如果你們覺得第7案不行怎麼寫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2247.wav", + "text": "能夠請衛福部這邊修正或是另外" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2248.wav", + "text": "提一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2249.wav", + "text": "因為我們現在改成心健司了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2250.wav", + "text": "心健司之統計" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2251.wav", + "text": "\n第一行文字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2252.wav", + "text": "做這樣的修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2253.wav", + "text": "另外在第二" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2254.wav", + "text": "段" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2255.wav", + "text": "不好意思" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2256.wav", + "text": "因為我這邊的文字有第二段" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2257.wav", + "text": "就是為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2258.wav", + "text": "強化" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2259.wav", + "text": "公設保護人之效能" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2260.wav", + "text": "爰要求中央" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2261.wav", + "text": "主管機關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2262.wav", + "text": "後面是修正的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2263.wav", + "text": "機關落實公設保護" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2264.wav", + "text": "地方主管機關委託" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2265.wav", + "text": "或團體辦理者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2266.wav", + "text": "是不是可以做這樣的修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2267.wav", + "text": "因為這就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2268.wav", + "text": "地方的事項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2269.wav", + "text": "可是這是不" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2270.wav", + "text": "會落入假設地方財政比較困難的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2271.wav", + "text": "情況下就算那個地方衰使" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2272.wav", + "text": "衰使公設保護人沒辦法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2273.wav", + "text": "執行面會跟縣市政府多進行一點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2274.wav", + "text": "討論因為我覺得這個經費" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2275.wav", + "text": "並不是很多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2276.wav", + "text": "只是縣市政府願不願意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2277.wav", + "text": "部分比較是執行面的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2278.wav", + "text": "縣市政府討論因為這筆錢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2279.wav", + "text": "不能夠所有的事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2280.wav", + "text": "都由中央" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2281.wav", + "text": "支出有些地方事項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2282.wav", + "text": "還是要由地方負起責任" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2283.wav", + "text": "是不是能夠變成應積極" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2284.wav", + "text": "輔導或督導" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2285.wav", + "text": "就是把輔導的概念也放進去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2286.wav", + "text": "其實督導是比較" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2287.wav", + "text": "輔導是有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2288.wav", + "text": "幫助的意思" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2289.wav", + "text": "不只是站在旁邊監督" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2290.wav", + "text": "好應輔導" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2291.wav", + "text": "好文字修正通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2292.wav", + "text": "衛福部再擬文字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2293.wav", + "text": "沒有意見就照案通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2294.wav", + "text": "看快一點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2295.wav", + "text": "不好意思" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2296.wav", + "text": "遵照辦理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2297.wav", + "text": "遵照辦理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2298.wav", + "text": "通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2299.wav", + "text": "第9案建議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2300.wav", + "text": "的修正文字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2301.wav", + "text": "就是在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2302.wav", + "text": "第幾段" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2303.wav", + "text": "最後一段" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2304.wav", + "text": "最後一行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2305.wav", + "text": "實際實施內容" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2306.wav", + "text": "實際實施內容" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2307.wav", + "text": "應積極試辦就沒有了後面就不用了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2308.wav", + "text": "可以嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2309.wav", + "text": "意思有相同嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2310.wav", + "text": "前面的第2項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2311.wav", + "text": "其實我比較關注的是中途之家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2312.wav", + "text": "支持跟大家的意見都相似" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2313.wav", + "text": "那邊有做試辦的我OK啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2314.wav", + "text": "前段內容" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2315.wav", + "text": "的積極對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2316.wav", + "text": "文字修正通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2317.wav", + "text": "怎麼樣又要再修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2318.wav", + "text": "對啊你們都把我刪掉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2319.wav", + "text": "例如而已" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2320.wav", + "text": "例如" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2321.wav", + "text": "例如" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2322.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2323.wav", + "text": "文字修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2324.wav", + "text": "也建議做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2325.wav", + "text": "文字修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2326.wav", + "text": "我這邊是在第三行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2327.wav", + "text": "需確保" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2328.wav", + "text": "精神病人及其家屬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2329.wav", + "text": "或照顧者於" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2330.wav", + "text": "可提供具可近性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2331.wav", + "text": "跟我們看的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2332.wav", + "text": "我們建議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2333.wav", + "text": "刪除" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2334.wav", + "text": "社區心理衛生中心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2335.wav", + "text": "之諮詢專線應由專業" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2336.wav", + "text": "以利病人及其家屬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2337.wav", + "text": "保留到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2338.wav", + "text": "需確保" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2339.wav", + "text": "精神病人及其家屬或照顧者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2340.wav", + "text": "可提供具可近性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2341.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2342.wav", + "text": "文字修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2343.wav", + "text": "通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2344.wav", + "text": "我們是建議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2345.wav", + "text": "相關指引" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2346.wav", + "text": "不要寫成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2347.wav", + "text": "精神疾病住院病人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2348.wav", + "text": "生活公約指引" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2349.wav", + "text": "因為這個只有公約" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2350.wav", + "text": "��各精神醫療機構" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2351.wav", + "text": "據以辦理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2352.wav", + "text": "不是參採\n" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2353.wav", + "text": "我們希望能夠據以辦理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2354.wav", + "text": "制定相關指引" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2355.wav", + "text": "精神醫療機構" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2356.wav", + "text": "據以辦理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2357.wav", + "text": "這樣好像更明確" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2358.wav", + "text": "他們要按照那個指引去辦理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2359.wav", + "text": "文字修正後通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2360.wav", + "text": "第12案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2361.wav", + "text": "共同擬定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2362.wav", + "text": "工作指引" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2363.wav", + "text": "改成共同擬定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2364.wav", + "text": "通知流程與教育訓練" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2365.wav", + "text": "課程" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2366.wav", + "text": "所以後面的並辦理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2367.wav", + "text": "相關訓練" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2368.wav", + "text": "相關業務都建議刪除" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2369.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2370.wav", + "text": "改為共同擬定通知流程與教育訓練" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2371.wav", + "text": "課程" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2372.wav", + "text": "好修正後通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2373.wav", + "text": "報告主席" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2374.wav", + "text": "是不是可以提出報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2375.wav", + "text": "哪一案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2376.wav", + "text": "跟主席報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2377.wav", + "text": "整個第12案是一個教育訓練" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2378.wav", + "text": "我們警察跟消防部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2379.wav", + "text": "教育訓練的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2380.wav", + "text": "併入在第12案裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2381.wav", + "text": "來做教育訓練好像比較廣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2382.wav", + "text": "可能也比較專業" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2383.wav", + "text": "所以我提出建議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2384.wav", + "text": "第2案跟第5案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2385.wav", + "text": "併入到第12案裡因為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2386.wav", + "text": "同樣都是教育訓練" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2387.wav", + "text": "的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2388.wav", + "text": "不同意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2389.wav", + "text": "不同的提案人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2390.wav", + "text": "而且是不同的條文之下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2391.wav", + "text": "好不予處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2392.wav", + "text": "剛剛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2393.wav", + "text": "把文字修正後提供給" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2394.wav", + "text": "請議事人員宣告協商結論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2395.wav", + "text": "\n立法院黨團協商結論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2396.wav", + "text": "時間111年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2397.wav", + "text": "10月18日（星期二）下午" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2398.wav", + "text": "1時12分至4時20分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2399.wav", + "text": "111年10月28日（星期五" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2400.wav", + "text": "）下午1時7分至3時17分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2401.wav", + "text": "111年11月4曰（星期五" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2402.wav", + "text": "）下午1時3分至3時14分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2403.wav", + "text": "111年11月8日（星期二" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2404.wav", + "text": "）下午1時5分至3時2分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2405.wav", + "text": "15曰（星期二）下午" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2406.wav", + "text": "1時6分至" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2407.wav", + "text": "地點紅樓101會議室協商主題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2408.wav", + "text": "一本院社會福利及" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2409.wav", + "text": "衛生環境委員會報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2410.wav", + "text": "併案審查行政院函請審議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2411.wav", + "text": "委員王婉諭等17人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2412.wav", + "text": "委員蔣萬安等17人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2413.wav", + "text": "委員林為洲等17人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2414.wav", + "text": "委員邱泰源等23人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2415.wav", + "text": "委員楊瓊瓔等20人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2416.wav", + "text": "委員莊競程等18人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2417.wav", + "text": "台灣民眾黨黨團" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2418.wav", + "text": "分別擬具精神衛生法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2419.wav", + "text": "修正草案及委員賴惠員等18人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2420.wav", + "text": "委員吳玉琴等20人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2421.wav", + "text": "委員葉毓蘭等20人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2422.wav", + "text": "委員林奕華等24人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2423.wav", + "text": "分別擬具精神衛生法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2424.wav", + "text": "部分條文修正草案及委員謝衣鳯等17人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2425.wav", + "text": "擬具精神衛生法第十三條及第十四條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2426.wav", + "text": "條文修正草案委員許淑華等16人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2427.wav", + "text": "擬具精神衛生法第十八條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2428.wav", + "text": "條文修正草案等16案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2429.wav", + "text": "\n二本院委員游毓蘭等17人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2430.wav", + "text": "擬具精神衛生法部分條文修正草案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2431.wav", + "text": "\n三本院委員范雲等18人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2432.wav", + "text": "擬具精神衛生法部分條文修正草案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2433.wav", + "text": "\n協商結論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2434.wav", + "text": "一協商通過條文第3條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2435.wav", + "text": "第4條第5條第8條第十六條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2436.wav", + "text": "如附件" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2437.wav", + "text": "\n二第52條第54條第56條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2438.wav", + "text": "第79條第83條第84條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2439.wav", + "text": "第86條照行政院提案條文通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2440.wav", + "text": "\n三委員王婉諭等17人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2441.wav", + "text": "提案第58條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2442.wav", + "text": "提案第56條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2443.wav", + "text": "委員張育美等16人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2444.wav", + "text": "提案第54條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2445.wav", + "text": "17人提案第59條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2446.wav", + "text": "委員蔣萬安等17人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2447.wav", + "text": "提案第57條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2448.wav", + "text": "提案第55條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2449.wav", + "text": "委員王婉諭等17人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2450.wav", + "text": "提案第62條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2451.wav", + "text": "委員蔣萬安等17人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2452.wav", + "text": "提案第61條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2453.wav", + "text": "委員張育美等16人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2454.wav", + "text": "提案第59條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2455.wav", + "text": "委員王婉諭等17人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2456.wav", + "text": "提案第5條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2457.wav", + "text": "委員蔣萬安等17人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2458.wav", + "text": "提案第48條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2459.wav", + "text": "委員張育美等16人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2460.wav", + "text": "提案第46條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2461.wav", + "text": "其後條次依序變更" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2462.wav", + "text": "本法條次變更及條文內條次調整" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2463.wav", + "text": "授權議事人員處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2464.wav", + "text": "\n六通過附帶決議如附件" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2465.wav", + "text": "\n七其餘照審查會意見通過\n八檢附" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2466.wav", + "text": "本案立法說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2467.wav", + "text": "經歷5次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2468.wav", + "text": "辛苦的協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2469.wav", + "text": "今日終於協商完成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2470.wav", + "text": "謝謝各位協商代表委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2471.wav", + "text": "及各行政機關代表" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2472.wav", + "text": "本日協商到此為止" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14587/2473.wav", + "text": "現在散會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14537/0.wav", + "text": "各位黨團代表委員先進及行政院部門代表大家早安" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14537/1.wav", + "text": "不同的使用方" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14537/2.wav", + "text": "我們就把它歸類在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14537/3.wav", + "text": "所以完全是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14537/4.wav", + "text": "況到底要不要全管菸品管" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14537/5.wav", + "text": "現我覺得這對我們來講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14537/6.wav", + "text": "禁謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14537/7.wav", + "text": "請陳委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14537/8.wav", + "text": "就沒有辦法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14537/9.wav", + "text": "還有很多其他" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14537/10.wav", + "text": "這是第一個問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14537/11.wav", + "text": "心之一啦對於這個部分是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14537/12.wav", + "text": "這個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14537/13.wav", + "text": "我不知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14537/14.wav", + "text": "沒有做致" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14537/15.wav", + "text": "所以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14537/16.wav", + "text": "所以我覺得這一條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14537/17.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/0.wav", + "text": "各位黨團代表委員先進及行政院部門代表大家早安" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1.wav", + "text": "社環委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/2.wav", + "text": "併案審查行政院函請審議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/3.wav", + "text": "菸害防制法修正草案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/4.wav", + "text": "等25案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/5.wav", + "text": "及院會決定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/6.wav", + "text": "逕付二讀與上述" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/7.wav", + "text": "提案併案協商之本院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/8.wav", + "text": "等17人擬具" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/9.wav", + "text": "菸害防制法第4條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/10.wav", + "text": "條文修正草案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/11.wav", + "text": "之黨團協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/12.wav", + "text": "在進行協商前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/13.wav", + "text": "有關本次協商委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/14.wav", + "text": "審查完成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/15.wav", + "text": "之行政院函請審議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/16.wav", + "text": "精神衛生法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/17.wav", + "text": "修正草案等16案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/18.wav", + "text": "於5月23日" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/19.wav", + "text": "第5會期第18次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/20.wav", + "text": "社會福利及衛生環境" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/21.wav", + "text": "委員會召開會議審查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/22.wav", + "text": "完竣時" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/23.wav", + "text": "保留其中39條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/24.wav", + "text": "行政院及委員提案之條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/25.wav", + "text": "交付協商本日協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/26.wav", + "text": "為求聚焦爭取時" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/27.wav", + "text": "時效" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/28.wav", + "text": "問各位協商代表" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/29.wav", + "text": "是否同意本日協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/30.wav", + "text": "就委員會保留條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/31.wav", + "text": "對委員會通過之條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/32.wav", + "text": "還有意見我們再回頭處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/33.wav", + "text": "有意見之條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/34.wav", + "text": "請問各位委員代表" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/35.wav", + "text": "有無意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/36.wav", + "text": "已經通過的條文就暫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/37.wav", + "text": "不處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/38.wav", + "text": "但是等到保留條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/39.wav", + "text": "現在是菸害防制法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/40.wav", + "text": "我只是提到上次協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/41.wav", + "text": "精神衛生法也是這樣的處理方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/42.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/43.wav", + "text": "如果沒有異議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/44.wav", + "text": "\n現在開始進行討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/45.wav", + "text": "菸害防制法保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/46.wav", + "text": "有關第3條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/47.wav", + "text": "菸品的定義" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/48.wav", + "text": "跟用詞" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/49.wav", + "text": "針對大家比較爭議的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/50.wav", + "text": "楊瓊瓔委員林奕華委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/51.wav", + "text": "及蔡易餘委員等相關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/52.wav", + "text": "委員所提出的一些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/53.wav", + "text": "修正案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/54.wav", + "text": "因為我們考量到整個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/55.wav", + "text": "相當困難" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/56.wav", + "text": "欠缺一個完整的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/57.wav", + "text": "定義" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/58.wav", + "text": "也查詢過世界上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/59.wav", + "text": "包括歐盟的指令" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/60.wav", + "text": "還有英國南韓美國之菸草產" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/61.wav", + "text": "產品的相關規範" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/62.wav", + "text": "目前也查不到相關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/63.wav", + "text": "對於加熱菸配件" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/64.wav", + "text": "有明確的定義" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/65.wav", + "text": "毋須在第3條定義裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/66.wav", + "text": "增加這些組合元件的定義" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/67.wav", + "text": "至於相關配套的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/68.wav", + "text": "修正為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/69.wav", + "text": "在第7條第3款" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/70.wav", + "text": "送審健康風險評估資料的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/71.wav", + "text": "應一併送審" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/72.wav", + "text": "必要的組合元件" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/73.wav", + "text": "件文字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/74.wav", + "text": "作為這些該等必要組合元件" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/75.wav", + "text": "的廣告促銷" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/76.wav", + "text": "並以原來第十二條的相關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/77.wav", + "text": "規定來做管理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/78.wav", + "text": "有關類菸品跟" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/79.wav", + "text": "建議維持行政" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/80.wav", + "text": "院版本的方式來通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/81.wav", + "text": "謝謝主席" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/82.wav", + "text": "我還是表達一下民眾黨團的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/83.wav", + "text": "施行細則第2條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/84.wav", + "text": "第2項對於菸酒管理法第3條第1項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/85.wav", + "text": "所稱代用品是指" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/86.wav", + "text": "含有尼古丁用以取代" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/87.wav", + "text": "菸草做為製菸原料之" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/88.wav", + "text": "其他天然植物及加工製品" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/89.wav", + "text": "因此民眾黨的版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/90.wav", + "text": "第2條第1項的規定主要是希望" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/91.wav", + "text": "本法對菸" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/92.wav", + "text": "菸品���定義跟其他" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/93.wav", + "text": "相關法規的規定一致" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/94.wav", + "text": "我們也知道2014年世界衛生組織" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/95.wav", + "text": "以禁止或適當的方式來管制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/96.wav", + "text": "尼古丁及電子煙" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/97.wav", + "text": "2017年更進一步要求以法令" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/98.wav", + "text": "來規範其製造輸入銷售等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/99.wav", + "text": "\n而且近年來國際上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/100.wav", + "text": "已經發生多起電子煙造成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/101.wav", + "text": "人體肺部損傷" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/102.wav", + "text": "甚至致死的案例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/103.wav", + "text": "為了避免電子煙產品" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/104.wav", + "text": "以及未來可能出現" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/105.wav", + "text": "其他不同樣態的尼古丁相關產品" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/106.wav", + "text": "沒有法源的依據" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/107.wav", + "text": "因此將類菸品增訂" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/108.wav", + "text": "在第2款去規範紙" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/109.wav", + "text": "紙菸之外的各類型菸品樣態" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/110.wav", + "text": "\n近年因為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/111.wav", + "text": "加熱菸的興起" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/112.wav", + "text": "而且菸品不論是點燃或是其他方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/113.wav", + "text": "的啟動" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/114.wav", + "text": "不論是否用吸的皆" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/115.wav", + "text": "所以第3款新增" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/116.wav", + "text": "不同的使用方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/117.wav", + "text": "以啟動功能的條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/118.wav", + "text": "因此我們在第3條新增了第2款" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/119.wav", + "text": "將原條文的第2款" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/120.wav", + "text": "是不是也請相關部會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/121.wav", + "text": "剛剛提到的電子煙" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/122.wav", + "text": "成分是不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/123.wav", + "text": "以菸品來製造" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/124.wav", + "text": "為區分我們的類菸品就是電子煙" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/125.wav", + "text": "因為電子煙是用煙油" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/126.wav", + "text": "而它到底含不含尼古丁" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/127.wav", + "text": "我們也不知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/128.wav", + "text": "它就不是菸品衍生而來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/129.wav", + "text": "電子煙的部分我們就把它" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/130.wav", + "text": "歸類在類菸品來加以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/131.wav", + "text": "禁止的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/132.wav", + "text": "一些修正定義其實" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/133.wav", + "text": "相關的吸用嚼用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/134.wav", + "text": "含用聞用還有其他方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/135.wav", + "text": "使用的吸菸行為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/136.wav", + "text": "員所提的相關意見了\n" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/137.wav", + "text": "\n最後有規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/138.wav", + "text": "攜帶已點燃" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/139.wav", + "text": "或已啟動使用功能之菸品" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/140.wav", + "text": "視為前項第3款之吸菸行為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/141.wav", + "text": "所以應該已經把相關的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/142.wav", + "text": "都包含在裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/143.wav", + "text": "補充說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/144.wav", + "text": "現行條文最大的不同就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/145.wav", + "text": "類菸品的定義" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/146.wav", + "text": "現行法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/147.wav", + "text": "條文裡面沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/148.wav", + "text": "類菸品" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/149.wav", + "text": "主要就是針對電子煙" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/150.wav", + "text": "把它" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/151.wav", + "text": "歸類為類菸品" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/152.wav", + "text": "然後是列為禁止之列" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/153.wav", + "text": "主席我覺得還是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/154.wav", + "text": "要請衛福部講清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/155.wav", + "text": "第3條的定義不把" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/156.wav", + "text": "其必要組合元件" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/157.wav", + "text": "就是我們俗稱的載具" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/158.wav", + "text": "關於加熱菸的載具" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/159.wav", + "text": "去做說明剛剛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/160.wav", + "text": "署長的意思是後面有幾條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/161.wav", + "text": "會去處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/162.wav", + "text": "審查的時候我們在把所有條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/163.wav", + "text": "順完之後就會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/164.wav", + "text": "組合元件是分割的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/165.wav", + "text": "情況到底要不要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/166.wav", + "text": "全管菸品管" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/167.wav", + "text": "第7條其實是一個整合的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/168.wav", + "text": "一起處理的但是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/169.wav", + "text": "有沒有一一把這些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/170.wav", + "text": "菸品跟載具統統" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/171.wav", + "text": "署長說很難定義可是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/172.wav", + "text": "不定義的話後面的文字又會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/173.wav", + "text": "一直出現" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/174.wav", + "text": "我覺得這對我們來講反而不清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/175.wav", + "text": "而且會漏掉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/176.wav", + "text": "第3條予以定義" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/177.wav", + "text": "到底菸品跟載具的規範" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/178.wav", + "text": "夠不夠清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/179.wav", + "text": "以及是不是有被規範到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/180.wav", + "text": "現在已經有很多旗艦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/181.wav", + "text": "加熱菸的載具" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/182.wav", + "text": "它已經變成一個商品" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/183.wav", + "text": "而且是很大的商品這些你們怎麼納管" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/184.wav", + "text": "在第7條的風險評估" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/185.wav", + "text": "要去納管怎麼管" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/186.wav", + "text": "只管得到所謂送審的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/187.wav", + "text": "那些沒有送審的就全部都要取締嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/188.wav", + "text": "這個都要講清楚我覺得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/189.wav", + "text": "我簡稱的載具" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/190.wav", + "text": "應該要很清楚地做明確的規範" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/191.wav", + "text": "所以請" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/192.wav", + "text": "部裡面還是要回應得更清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/193.wav", + "text": "請林委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/194.wav", + "text": "謝謝主席" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/195.wav", + "text": "滿重要一個部分就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/196.wav", + "text": "大家也知道我所提版本的態度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/197.wav", + "text": "我是贊成要雙禁" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/198.wav", + "text": "因為我一直很" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/199.wav", + "text": "煙跟加熱菸其實" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/200.wav", + "text": "可能連院長也都分不清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/201.wav", + "text": "分不出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/202.wav", + "text": "因為它長得非常像" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/203.wav", + "text": "所以有些國家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/204.wav", + "text": "就比較容易變成雙開" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/205.wav", + "text": "管理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/206.wav", + "text": "的行政院版本來講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/207.wav", + "text": "一樣會碰到一個問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/208.wav", + "text": "就是不管叫做載具或是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/209.wav", + "text": "是組合元件" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/210.wav", + "text": "提到其他條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/211.wav", + "text": "就沒有提到了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/212.wav", + "text": "第一次在委員會討論的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/213.wav", + "text": "委員們都非常用心地" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/214.wav", + "text": "整體的管理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/215.wav", + "text": "結果我們非常遺憾的是今天看到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/216.wav", + "text": "行政院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/217.wav", + "text": "在面對委員們這麼多的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/218.wav", + "text": "意見之後卻只有在第7條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/219.wav", + "text": "帶到一下而已" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/220.wav", + "text": "的販賣菸品就完全" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/221.wav", + "text": "沒有出現這就是為什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/222.wav", + "text": "衛福部的態度是根本就沒有想要管" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/223.wav", + "text": "組合元件或載具" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/224.wav", + "text": "在審查時跨黨派的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/225.wav", + "text": "共識是認為這個是必須要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/226.wav", + "text": "被管理的可是現在從" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/227.wav", + "text": "我覺得這樣今天的討論真的會很難" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/228.wav", + "text": "再討論下去因為在整個態度上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/229.wav", + "text": "衛福部到底有沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/230.wav", + "text": "抓到起碼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/231.wav", + "text": "哪些部分是我們都有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/232.wav", + "text": "共識的部分起碼要在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/233.wav", + "text": "大家都比較有共識的部分把" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/234.wav", + "text": "條文修好嘛結果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/235.wav", + "text": "連這個都沒有我是覺得滿" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/236.wav", + "text": "必須要在第3條的定義中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/237.wav", + "text": "出現才能夠在整個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/238.wav", + "text": "以行政院版本來講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/239.wav", + "text": "起碼加熱菸的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/240.wav", + "text": "組合元件也是要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/241.wav", + "text": "管理吧可是連" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/242.wav", + "text": "更遑論我的態度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/243.wav", + "text": "謝謝主席" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/244.wav", + "text": "定義的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/245.wav", + "text": "菸草" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/246.wav", + "text": "或者是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/247.wav", + "text": "原料提煉出來的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/248.wav", + "text": "尼古丁成分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/249.wav", + "text": "或者是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/250.wav", + "text": "菸草原料" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/251.wav", + "text": "的成分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/252.wav", + "text": "這些成分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/253.wav", + "text": "基本上就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/254.wav", + "text": "菸草成分但是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/255.wav", + "text": "為類菸品" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/256.wav", + "text": "這樣到底適不" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/257.wav", + "text": "如果我們在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/258.wav", + "text": "那未來到底要怎麼去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/259.wav", + "text": "禁止" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/260.wav", + "text": "這些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/261.wav", + "text": "煙油或者是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/262.wav", + "text": "萃取出來的成分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/263.wav", + "text": "用其他的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/264.wav", + "text": "組裝程式或者是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/265.wav", + "text": "其他包裝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/266.wav", + "text": "進來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/267.wav", + "text": "呢這個部分可能會變成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/268.wav", + "text": "一個模糊地帶" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/269.wav", + "text": "所以我想" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/270.wav", + "text": "這個部分還是要定義清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/271.wav", + "text": "謝謝主席今" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/272.wav", + "text": "到這裡後拿到了這個對照" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/273.wav", + "text": "版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/274.wav", + "text": "因為我們今天協商的這個法案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/275.wav", + "text": "十幾年沒有修正的法案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/276.wav", + "text": "案我覺得因應現在的社會狀況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/277.wav", + "text": "是一定要修的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/278.wav", + "text": "這個也是從最簡單的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/279.wav", + "text": "比如說校園菸品的管理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/280.wav", + "text": "開始做起如果沒有法根本就沒有辦法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/281.wav", + "text": "如果學生攜帶新興菸品的時候到底要做什麼樣的處置" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/282.wav", + "text": "所以法是一定要修正的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/283.wav", + "text": "\n如果回到實務上的問題來講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/284.wav", + "text": "其實大家現在要面對的就是電子煙" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/285.wav", + "text": "和加熱菸" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/286.wav", + "text": "菸行政院有其態度社會上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/287.wav", + "text": "大家也有某程度的共識" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/288.wav", + "text": "但是還不一定啦比如剛剛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/289.wav", + "text": "各位委員的意見其實也不一致" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/290.wav", + "text": "\n我其實有在想" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/291.wav", + "text": "從上一次討論到今天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/292.wav", + "text": "看起來很快就又要開花了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/293.wav", + "text": "讓我們理解" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/294.wav", + "text": "是哪幾條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/295.wav", + "text": "因為我們今天要處理的是加熱菸跟電子煙" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/296.wav", + "text": "嘛新興菸品是今天議題的大宗" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/297.wav", + "text": "不是唯一" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/298.wav", + "text": "是大宗" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/299.wav", + "text": "後面當然還有很多其他的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/300.wav", + "text": "的加熱菸到底是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/301.wav", + "text": "接下來是怎麼樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/302.wav", + "text": "被審查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/303.wav", + "text": "來管理上架的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/304.wav", + "text": "各位委員可能比較能夠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/305.wav", + "text": "有一個完整的概念" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/306.wav", + "text": "因為我們現在是順著條文下去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/307.wav", + "text": "可是它會變成要跳來跳去啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/308.wav", + "text": "不是社會在處理一個問題的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/309.wav", + "text": "是一個環節" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/310.wav", + "text": "所適用的條文從頭到尾" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/311.wav", + "text": "衛福部的態度是什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/312.wav", + "text": "從定義一直到後面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/313.wav", + "text": "是怎麼禁止管理等等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/314.wav", + "text": "是不是也有一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/315.wav", + "text": "橫向的法條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/316.wav", + "text": "適用的階段" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/317.wav", + "text": "我覺得這樣對於委員的審查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/318.wav", + "text": "可能反而會加速" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/319.wav", + "text": "耶因為我們關心的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/320.wav", + "text": "不會有掛一漏萬的狀況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/321.wav", + "text": "這是我對審查條文的建議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/322.wav", + "text": "綜合一���" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/323.wav", + "text": "要不要把" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/324.wav", + "text": "載具" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/325.wav", + "text": "把它定義成菸品" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/326.wav", + "text": "這是第一個問題剛剛林奕華委員特別提到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/327.wav", + "text": "不然後面要怎麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/328.wav", + "text": "管理而吳玉琴委員也有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/329.wav", + "text": "特別提到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/330.wav", + "text": "部分另外一個問題就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/331.wav", + "text": "菸品要不要放在這裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/332.wav", + "text": "我是在想這" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/333.wav", + "text": "不得不去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/334.wav", + "text": "針對電子煙" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/335.wav", + "text": "是大家最有共識要禁的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/336.wav", + "text": "朝野都有共識" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/337.wav", + "text": "但是如果沒有去定義" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/338.wav", + "text": "第1項第2款的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/339.wav", + "text": "這個就是專門" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/340.wav", + "text": "因為是菸害防制法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/341.wav", + "text": "嘛要把它定義成一個東西" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/342.wav", + "text": "然後是被禁止的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/343.wav", + "text": "這樣才有辦法用這個法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/344.wav", + "text": "去禁止電子煙" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/345.wav", + "text": "針對電子煙訂一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/346.wav", + "text": "名稱" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/347.wav", + "text": "菸害防制法就管不到了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/348.wav", + "text": "因為它不在這個法裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/349.wav", + "text": "我猜是這樣啦等一下請衛福部說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/350.wav", + "text": "\n第三個問題就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/351.wav", + "text": "要不要將" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/352.wav", + "text": "將蘇巧慧委員剛才" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/353.wav", + "text": "用順條文的方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/354.wav", + "text": "來討論其實都會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/355.wav", + "text": "原始的爭議點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/356.wav", + "text": "針對電子煙" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/357.wav", + "text": "電子煙是大家有共識" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/358.wav", + "text": "要禁止" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/359.wav", + "text": "的只是條文要怎麼規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/360.wav", + "text": "管制它禁止它" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/361.wav", + "text": "但是加熱菸是有爭議的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/362.wav", + "text": "是要開還是要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/363.wav", + "text": "載具" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/364.wav", + "text": "要不要同樣當作菸品來納管" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/365.wav", + "text": "核心之一" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/366.wav", + "text": "是不是要拿出來大家先討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/367.wav", + "text": "結論你的意思" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/368.wav", + "text": "就是再" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/369.wav", + "text": "再協商好像也��什麼意義" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/370.wav", + "text": "那變成我們以後要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/371.wav", + "text": "先開一個談話會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/372.wav", + "text": "看有沒有結論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/373.wav", + "text": "然後再回到條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/374.wav", + "text": "但是在程序上我是覺得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/375.wav", + "text": "反正我們在委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/376.wav", + "text": "已經處理過了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/377.wav", + "text": "委員會也是碰到同樣的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/378.wav", + "text": "既然有條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/379.wav", + "text": "我們還是按照條文來處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/380.wav", + "text": "如果有爭議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/381.wav", + "text": "就保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/382.wav", + "text": "的比如現在第3條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/383.wav", + "text": "要不要把載具寫在這裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/384.wav", + "text": "專門來指涉電子煙" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/385.wav", + "text": "這樣恰當不恰當" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/386.wav", + "text": "陳椒華委員剛剛特別提到這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/387.wav", + "text": "會不會掛一漏萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/388.wav", + "text": "或是怎麼樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/389.wav", + "text": "因為它並沒有直接寫說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/390.wav", + "text": "電子煙" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/391.wav", + "text": "類菸品這個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/392.wav", + "text": "並不是加熱菸" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/393.wav", + "text": "當然這個我知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/394.wav", + "text": "啊因為加熱菸在物理上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/395.wav", + "text": "是用菸草的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/396.wav", + "text": "嘛而非物理上用菸草" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/397.wav", + "text": "的就會被定義成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/398.wav", + "text": "變成液體萃取物" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/399.wav", + "text": "類菸品就會被禁止" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/400.wav", + "text": "所以才會放在這裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/401.wav", + "text": "我還是要表達一些團體的關心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/402.wav", + "text": "尤其是醫療方面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/403.wav", + "text": "其實我在委員會審查的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/404.wav", + "text": "對於必要組合元件" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/405.wav", + "text": "我是建議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/406.wav", + "text": "還是要看看有沒有可能" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/407.wav", + "text": "新增必要的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/408.wav", + "text": "我還是支持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/409.wav", + "text": "吳玉琴委員剛剛也提出這樣的意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/410.wav", + "text": "邱泰源委員同樣表達這樣的意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/411.wav", + "text": "本席也是支持這樣的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/412.wav", + "text": "修改內容" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/413.wav", + "text": "也就是要把加熱菸的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/414.wav", + "text": "組合元件" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/415.wav", + "text": "菸品定義裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/416.wav", + "text": "這樣才有辦法跟菸品一起來做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/417.wav", + "text": "管理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/418.wav", + "text": "\n請林委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/419.wav", + "text": "我們就請衛福部先回答" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/420.wav", + "text": "加熱菸還是電子煙" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/421.wav", + "text": "是用另外一個煙" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/422.wav", + "text": "而不是這個菸" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/423.wav", + "text": "因為這個菸是一定有菸草" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/424.wav", + "text": "的所以我本來以為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/425.wav", + "text": "品所衍生出來的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/426.wav", + "text": "叫做類菸品" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/427.wav", + "text": "菸品其實我一直以為類菸品講的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/428.wav", + "text": "所以這個可能要說清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/429.wav", + "text": "到底是什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/430.wav", + "text": "是把電子煙加熱菸的定義都寫得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/431.wav", + "text": "很清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/432.wav", + "text": "以非燃燒方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/433.wav", + "text": "加熱液體" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/434.wav", + "text": "這二者是不一樣的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/435.wav", + "text": "所以可能要講的比較清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/436.wav", + "text": "一點要不然的確會誠如剛剛蘇" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/437.wav", + "text": "委員所提一個很重要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/438.wav", + "text": "會不知道到底電子煙是有禁還是沒禁" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/439.wav", + "text": "禁一般外界" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/440.wav", + "text": "會搞不清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/441.wav", + "text": "對於容器的部分我還想要再講一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/442.wav", + "text": "因為以現在這樣來看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/443.wav", + "text": "我不知道有沒有包括新興" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/444.wav", + "text": "它一些所謂的包裝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/445.wav", + "text": "有沒有包括在現在所講的菸品" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/446.wav", + "text": "容器裡面麻煩等一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/447.wav", + "text": "請衛福部再做比較清楚的說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/448.wav", + "text": "主席我補充一下我剛剛的意思不是說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/449.wav", + "text": "要混著審查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/450.wav", + "text": "審查的過程還是要照主席說的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/451.wav", + "text": "那份資料必須是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/452.wav", + "text": "按照社會上大家關心的議題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/453.wav", + "text": "比如電子煙" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/454.wav", + "text": "是依照第幾條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/455.wav", + "text": "所以我們關心的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/456.wav", + "text": "在這部法當中都有被管理到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/457.wav", + "text": "加熱菸又是依照" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/458.wav", + "text": "甚至是它的載具在第幾條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/459.wav", + "text": "所以這些法條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/460.wav", + "text": "如果通過了我們可以很負責任地說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/461.wav", + "text": "對於社會關心的問題我們都處理了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/462.wav", + "text": "剛是說要提補充資料而不是照那個順序來審" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/463.wav", + "text": "電子煙" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/464.wav", + "text": "加熱菸到底是哪一項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/465.wav", + "text": "其實都還搞不太清楚更不要說社會大眾" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/466.wav", + "text": "了大概是這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/467.wav", + "text": "這部法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/468.wav", + "text": "做提綱挈領的說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/469.wav", + "text": "社會關注的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/470.wav", + "text": "部分\n請陳委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/471.wav", + "text": "我曾經質詢過當時我寫了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/472.wav", + "text": "兩個字一" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/473.wav", + "text": "菸草的菸是草字頭" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/474.wav", + "text": "是煙火的煙" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/475.wav", + "text": "電子煙是煙火" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/476.wav", + "text": "的煙" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/477.wav", + "text": "紙菸" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/478.wav", + "text": "菸是草字頭的菸" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/479.wav", + "text": "所以如果類菸品" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/480.wav", + "text": "的類會讓大家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/481.wav", + "text": "搞不清楚的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/482.wav", + "text": "就改成煙品用煙火的煙" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/483.wav", + "text": "這樣就很清楚了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/484.wav", + "text": "大家就不會不知道那個類" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/485.wav", + "text": "針對這個提議等一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/486.wav", + "text": "請衛福部回應" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/487.wav", + "text": "主要是就是那兩個字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/488.wav", + "text": "如果清楚了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/489.wav", + "text": "好等一下請衛福部回應" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/490.wav", + "text": "\n請邱委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/491.wav", + "text": "剛剛聽到大家這麼多不同的意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/492.wav", + "text": "蘇巧慧委員所提的應該要請衛福部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/493.wav", + "text": "資料這個部分我們希望衛福部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/494.wav", + "text": "以加速凝聚我們審查的共識跟進度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/495.wav", + "text": "都還沒有共識的話也可以考慮" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/496.wav", + "text": "一個可以考量的方式請主席參考" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/497.wav", + "text": "以上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/498.wav", + "text": "煙的成分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/499.wav", + "text": "成火字旁的煙就可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/500.wav", + "text": "剛剛前面發言的意思是如果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/501.wav", + "text": "或者是加熱菸" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/502.wav", + "text": "的話以後是很難管的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/503.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/504.wav", + "text": "瞭解" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/505.wav", + "text": "不瞭解不瞭解" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/506.wav", + "text": "不是萃取啦電子煙的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/507.wav", + "text": "物質並不是從菸草的菸" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/508.wav", + "text": "出來改變了它的物理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/509.wav", + "text": "狀態也會被歸納" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/510.wav", + "text": "為類菸品" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/511.wav", + "text": "如果以類菸品的定義" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/512.wav", + "text": "它的原料非常多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/513.wav", + "text": "也有化學合成的也有萃取" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/514.wav", + "text": "對萃取是尼古丁" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/515.wav", + "text": "然後加液體這樣加在一起" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/516.wav", + "text": "萃取出來尼古丁這樣也是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/517.wav", + "text": "電子煙喔" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/518.wav", + "text": "因為它已經改變了它的物理狀態" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/519.wav", + "text": "電子煙跟加熱菸" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/520.wav", + "text": "菸的爭議所在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/521.wav", + "text": "要不要開要不要禁" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/522.wav", + "text": "要不要直接把它定義在這裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/523.wav", + "text": "這樣定義有什麼缺點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/524.wav", + "text": "不要弄一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/525.wav", + "text": "類菸品然後裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/526.wav", + "text": "到底是含有電子煙跟" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/527.wav", + "text": "加熱菸還是只有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/528.wav", + "text": "電子煙而不含加熱菸" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/529.wav", + "text": "我們都不清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/530.wav", + "text": "一般大眾呢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/531.wav", + "text": "你們會這樣做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/532.wav", + "text": "對你們的邏輯是怎麼樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/533.wav", + "text": "你們要把電子煙" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/534.wav", + "text": "加熱菸都定義在這裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/535.wav", + "text": "所以很清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/536.wav", + "text": "你們的態度是要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/537.wav", + "text": "開放加熱菸" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/538.wav", + "text": "然後禁止" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/539.wav", + "text": "電子煙" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/540.wav", + "text": "把它講清楚講清楚有什麼缺點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/541.wav", + "text": "掛一漏萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/542.wav", + "text": "還是怎麼樣請說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/543.wav", + "text": "非常謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/544.wav", + "text": "大家應該知道整部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/545.wav", + "text": "菸害防制法修法的定義" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/546.wav", + "text": "及順序大概就是以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/547.wav", + "text": "菸品跟非菸品來做定義" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/548.wav", + "text": "那麼電子煙就不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/549.wav", + "text": "菸品就歸類到類菸品裡面去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/550.wav", + "text": "就是不管是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/551.wav", + "text": "菸品的原料去萃取改變" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/552.wav", + "text": "以後或者不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/553.wav", + "text": "由其他的化學原料而來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/554.wav", + "text": "它屬於這一類的產品" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/555.wav", + "text": "我們就全部歸類在類菸品" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/556.wav", + "text": "比方現在的電子煙" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/557.wav", + "text": "電子煙可能市面上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/558.wav", + "text": "有很多包括所謂的果汁" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/559.wav", + "text": "口香糖" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/560.wav", + "text": "它用很多很多的名字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/561.wav", + "text": "就寫電子煙三個字尤其是寫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/562.wav", + "text": "成剛剛提到的煙花的煙" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/563.wav", + "text": "種類太多而且沒辦法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/564.wav", + "text": "完全涵蓋在裡面所以我們才" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/565.wav", + "text": "用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/566.wav", + "text": "FCTC給我們的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/567.wav", + "text": "定義從英文這邊來講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/568.wav", + "text": "它就是電子或電子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/569.wav", + "text": "以液體或者以其他" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/570.wav", + "text": "一個物品所以我們才會用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/571.wav", + "text": "我們所謂的加熱菸" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/572.wav", + "text": "加熱式菸品的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/573.wav", + "text": "原料都是菸品所以未來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/574.wav", + "text": "它就落在其他" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/575.wav", + "text": "特有名詞叫做指定之菸品" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/576.wav", + "text": "所以在它還沒有被指定之前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/577.wav", + "text": "還是不屬於菸品" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/578.wav", + "text": "明\n另外剛剛大家也非常" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/579.wav", + "text": "分載具在第7" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/580.wav", + "text": "條裡面來講我們把它納入" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/581.wav", + "text": "要送審健康風險評估時" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/582.wav", + "text": "就一併要把所有的載具" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/583.wav", + "text": "具送出來讓我們審查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/584.wav", + "text": "載具是以正向表列" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/585.wav", + "text": "審查通過後才可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/586.wav", + "text": "販售這些載具不管是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/587.wav", + "text": "單獨販賣或者是一起販賣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/588.wav", + "text": "正向表列的管理方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/589.wav", + "text": "它的廣告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/590.wav", + "text": "裡面來管理第十二條裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/591.wav", + "text": "相關的每一個項目" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/592.wav", + "text": "以菸品的促銷廣告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/593.wav", + "text": "載具的管理方式是一致的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/594.wav", + "text": "至於其他的方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/595.wav", + "text": "做其他的管理只管理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/596.wav", + "text": "它的廣告跟促銷部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/597.wav", + "text": "不管裡面有沒有含尼古丁" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/598.wav", + "text": "只要改���了物理的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/599.wav", + "text": "狀態" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/600.wav", + "text": "第1款" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/601.wav", + "text": "的吸用嚼用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/602.wav", + "text": "含用聞用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/603.wav", + "text": "都把它歸類為類菸品" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/604.wav", + "text": "即使它裡面沒有含尼古丁" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/605.wav", + "text": "只要吸用也是會被歸類" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/606.wav", + "text": "這樣才能比較" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/607.wav", + "text": "寬的來管制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/608.wav", + "text": "只講電子煙" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/609.wav", + "text": "但如果沒有用電子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/610.wav", + "text": "因為電子煙是要用電子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/611.wav", + "text": "嘛我的理解是這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/612.wav", + "text": "類菸品" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/613.wav", + "text": "還是聽聽大家的意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/614.wav", + "text": "\n請陳委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/615.wav", + "text": "也算嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/616.wav", + "text": "如果照你剛剛的解釋" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/617.wav", + "text": "第1款裡面就有規定用聞的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/618.wav", + "text": "也算啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/619.wav", + "text": "用聞的也是禁止" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/620.wav", + "text": "是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/621.wav", + "text": "菸品原料以外的物料" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/622.wav", + "text": "它的物理狀態" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/623.wav", + "text": "變成液體的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/624.wav", + "text": "它的成分可能有尼古丁" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/625.wav", + "text": "也可能沒有尼古丁" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/626.wav", + "text": "都是歸於類菸品嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/627.wav", + "text": "如果是照現在這樣的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/628.wav", + "text": "文字解釋" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/629.wav", + "text": "所有液體的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/630.wav", + "text": "含有尼古丁或不含尼古丁" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/631.wav", + "text": "非電子傳送的這些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/632.wav", + "text": "包括有香料" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/633.wav", + "text": "會是落在這樣的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/634.wav", + "text": "文字內容裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/635.wav", + "text": "很寬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/636.wav", + "text": "所以我會支持譬如說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/637.wav", + "text": "我們的精神是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/638.wav", + "text": "禁電子煙" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/639.wav", + "text": "如果像林奕華委員的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/640.wav", + "text": "很明確的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/641.wav", + "text": "有電子煙加熱菸" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/642.wav", + "text": "我覺得會比較好管" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/643.wav", + "text": "我覺得你們這樣寫以後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/644.wav", + "text": "真的很難管" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/645.wav", + "text": "耶因為我長期關心廢棄物現在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/646.wav", + "text": "廢棄物好難管" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/647.wav", + "text": "喔寫得很模糊就很難管了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/648.wav", + "text": "以上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/649.wav", + "text": "剛剛提到的這些大家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/650.wav", + "text": "很擔心萬一做出來的是一些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/651.wav", + "text": "香精香料等等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/652.wav", + "text": "但是如果是這些而它" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/653.wav", + "text": "拿來使人家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/654.wav", + "text": "吸食或模仿吸食" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/655.wav", + "text": "它就等於是像吸食菸品一樣的行為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/656.wav", + "text": "這樣才會納管" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/657.wav", + "text": "因為就是拿來吸食" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/658.wav", + "text": "讓人模仿吸食" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/659.wav", + "text": "也就是模仿吸菸的行為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/660.wav", + "text": "你看定義有寫到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/661.wav", + "text": "得使人模仿菸品使用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/662.wav", + "text": "那麼聞的就不算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/663.wav", + "text": "一定要有一個載具才算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/664.wav", + "text": "你的意思是這樣嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/665.wav", + "text": "那麼聞的就不算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/666.wav", + "text": "要模仿菸品使用才算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/667.wav", + "text": "所以有那個載具才算嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/668.wav", + "text": "不一定要用載具" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/669.wav", + "text": "有很多方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/670.wav", + "text": "啊現在你看到的電子煙" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/671.wav", + "text": "是用載具沒錯" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/672.wav", + "text": "如果沒有用載具的也算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/673.wav", + "text": "是精油這種用聞的算嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/674.wav", + "text": "精油裡面含有尼古丁的成分算嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/675.wav", + "text": "有人拿一支香菸來聞" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/676.wav", + "text": "我並沒有說他違法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/677.wav", + "text": "是點燃在吸才是違法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/678.wav", + "text": "請陳委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/679.wav", + "text": "我具體建議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/680.wav", + "text": "是不是在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/681.wav", + "text": "第3條第2項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/682.wav", + "text": "原先的類菸品這三個字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/683.wav", + "text": "加上煙品及類菸品" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/684.wav", + "text": "這樣就一網打盡了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/685.wav", + "text": "第1項第2款" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/686.wav", + "text": "了第1項第2款的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/687.wav", + "text": "火字旁的煙" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/688.wav", + "text": "類菸品的菸是那" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/689.wav", + "text": "很多化學藥品化學物質" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/690.wav", + "text": "你怎麼知道它是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/691.wav", + "text": "火字旁的煙品呢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/692.wav", + "text": "你要定義清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/693.wav", + "text": "啊煙品到底是什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/694.wav", + "text": "它只是化合物而已" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/695.wav", + "text": "怎麼知道它叫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/696.wav", + "text": "有的有含尼古丁" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/697.wav", + "text": "有的沒有含尼古" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/698.wav", + "text": "看要怎麼調整" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/699.wav", + "text": "這個就是目前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/700.wav", + "text": "或" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/701.wav", + "text": "會不會比較好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/702.wav", + "text": "大家都非常關心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/703.wav", + "text": "但我們剛剛提到的是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/704.wav", + "text": "原料到底是由菸草改變而來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/705.wav", + "text": "但是這個產品出來了以後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/706.wav", + "text": "必須要以得使人模仿菸品" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/707.wav", + "text": "菸品的方式來使用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/708.wav", + "text": "我們才會定義它是類菸品" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/709.wav", + "text": "所以剛剛提到的有一些東西" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/710.wav", + "text": "是不會被歸到裡面去的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/711.wav", + "text": "模仿像菸這樣來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/712.wav", + "text": "吸食" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/713.wav", + "text": "但是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/714.wav", + "text": "咀嚼的方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/715.wav", + "text": "菸草是用咀嚼的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/716.wav", + "text": "在吸食嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/717.wav", + "text": "它是像口香糖" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/718.wav", + "text": "其實就是菸草在咀嚼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/719.wav", + "text": "所以你說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/720.wav", + "text": "模仿吸菸的方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/721.wav", + "text": "吸菸就有好幾種" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/722.wav", + "text": "看棒球的人都知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/723.wav", + "text": "那算有吸食嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/724.wav", + "text": "菸是菸草直接放嘴吧" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/725.wav", + "text": "個本來就有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/726.wav", + "text": "衛福部國健署" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/727.wav", + "text": "或第十二條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/728.wav", + "text": "衛福部的態度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/729.wav", + "text": "規定得很嚴格" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/730.wav", + "text": "但是載具到底要規範到什麼程度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/731.wav", + "text": "要連同載具一起評估" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/732.wav", + "text": "而且是一組" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/733.wav", + "text": "如果拆開還不行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/734.wav", + "text": "所以以後不是正牌正常的都不能" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/735.wav", + "text": "賣載具" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/736.wav", + "text": "是不是這個意思" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/737.wav", + "text": "\n第二個是後面當然也不能廣告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/738.wav", + "text": "後面有廣告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/739.wav", + "text": "的規定可是我們還有很多���他的條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/740.wav", + "text": "問載具可不可以提供" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/741.wav", + "text": "也就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/742.wav", + "text": "管理的寬嚴度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/743.wav", + "text": "是要寬還是嚴" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/744.wav", + "text": "所談的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/745.wav", + "text": "因為我們之前在委員會審查時" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/746.wav", + "text": "覺得對於載具是要很清楚的去管理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/747.wav", + "text": "但是你們管理的強度要多強" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/748.wav", + "text": "必須要告訴我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/749.wav", + "text": "載具可不可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/750.wav", + "text": "要不要罰" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/751.wav", + "text": "所以我們要問的是你們在態度上對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/752.wav", + "text": "菸品很清楚嚴格" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/753.wav", + "text": "但是對於載具到底嚴格到什麼程度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/754.wav", + "text": "這個也要說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/755.wav", + "text": "因為後面變成拆開來了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/756.wav", + "text": "如果你們在第三條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/757.wav", + "text": "會比較好一點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/758.wav", + "text": "也就是所謂的必要組合元件" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/759.wav", + "text": "是有做一些定義" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/760.wav", + "text": "可是為什麼在臺灣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/761.wav", + "text": "衛生福利部不願意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/762.wav", + "text": "去做定義" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/763.wav", + "text": "這也是我一直感到困惑的地方" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/764.wav", + "text": "所以請你們說明清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/765.wav", + "text": "剛剛提到載具的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/766.wav", + "text": "我們同樣審查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/767.wav", + "text": "配很多個載具" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/768.wav", + "text": "列就可以販售" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/769.wav", + "text": "可以切開販售" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/770.wav", + "text": "也可以組合販售" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/771.wav", + "text": "但是我們只管它的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/772.wav", + "text": "促銷跟廣告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/773.wav", + "text": "對於其他的販售行為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/774.wav", + "text": "其他的行為我們就沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/775.wav", + "text": "對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/776.wav", + "text": "不太一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/777.wav", + "text": "比如未成年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/778.wav", + "text": "人也可以買載具" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/779.wav", + "text": "但那個載具不便宜" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/780.wav", + "text": "不能買菸" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/781.wav", + "text": "只管理促銷跟廣告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/782.wav", + "text": "對於載具是管得比較鬆" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/783.wav", + "text": "大概是這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/784.wav", + "text": "這個在第7條會處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/785.wav", + "text": "要不要把載具管嚴一點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/786.wav", + "text": "第3條的定義" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/787.wav", + "text": "規定裡我覺得這是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/788.wav", + "text": "大家要思考的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/789.wav", + "text": "就會跟菸品採一樣的管制方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/790.wav", + "text": "也就跟著走了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/791.wav", + "text": "電子煙" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/792.wav", + "text": "或其他的類電子煙" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/793.wav", + "text": "還是會太寬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/794.wav", + "text": "陳椒華委員好像認為太寬了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/795.wav", + "text": "到最後反而" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/796.wav", + "text": "會沒有辦法管理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/797.wav", + "text": "\n請陳委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/798.wav", + "text": "聽到剛剛署長的說明就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/799.wav", + "text": "販賣是不管的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/800.wav", + "text": "嘛假如現在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/801.wav", + "text": "類菸品裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/802.wav", + "text": "不管它的成分反正就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/803.wav", + "text": "一些液體的成分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/804.wav", + "text": "得使人模仿" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/805.wav", + "text": "的證明的話我們也" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/806.wav", + "text": "沒辦法去禁對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/807.wav", + "text": "得使人模仿" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/808.wav", + "text": "菸品使用之" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/809.wav", + "text": "什麼什麼但是如果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/810.wav", + "text": "沒有進行模仿的這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/811.wav", + "text": "部分的話我們也" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/812.wav", + "text": "沒辦法去禁止它" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/813.wav", + "text": "它販賣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/814.wav", + "text": "使用如果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/815.wav", + "text": "有人買了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/816.wav", + "text": "這邊買一點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/817.wav", + "text": "然後再買載具我們就" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/818.wav", + "text": "他正在使用的時候才能管" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/819.wav", + "text": "是不是這個樣子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/820.wav", + "text": "如果這個定義是這樣的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/821.wav", + "text": "你的類菸品" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/822.wav", + "text": "如果是這樣子定義我們是很難" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/823.wav", + "text": "去管理它" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/824.wav", + "text": "剛剛所提到的這個不是這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/825.wav", + "text": "分開就可以的啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/826.wav", + "text": "我們是說這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/827.wav", + "text": "一個產品" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/828.wav", + "text": "不管它的組合物或其他相關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/829.wav", + "text": "產品只要被歸到類菸品" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/830.wav", + "text": "禁止輸入禁止販售" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/831.wav", + "text": "甚至展售等等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/832.wav", + "text": "白列舉這些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/833.wav", + "text": "尼古丁" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/834.wav", + "text": "或非尼古丁電子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/835.wav", + "text": "或非電子傳送的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/836.wav", + "text": "這些產品的項目嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/837.wav", + "text": "\n會把它表列出來嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/838.wav", + "text": "這個未來就" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/839.wav", + "text": "會查緝公告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/840.wav", + "text": "沒有聽清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/841.wav", + "text": "未來會怎麼樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/842.wav", + "text": "這個全部被禁止" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/843.wav", + "text": "所以會查緝以後也會公告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/844.wav", + "text": "謝謝主席" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/845.wav", + "text": "就有一個比較大的分歧點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/846.wav", + "text": "了對我來說我剛剛就提到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/847.wav", + "text": "以行政院版本來講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/848.wav", + "text": "是指禁電子煙" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/849.wav", + "text": "就是光賣載具" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/850.wav", + "text": "就可以開一間非常非常" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/851.wav", + "text": "酷炫的店" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/852.wav", + "text": "像這樣的店如果沒有限制的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/853.wav", + "text": "難道這部分不該被管理嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/854.wav", + "text": "以學生來說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/855.wav", + "text": "這不可能" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/856.wav", + "text": "嘛今天如果告訴我比較成年的人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/857.wav", + "text": "可能有時候買一些是為了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/858.wav", + "text": "好玩收藏" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/859.wav", + "text": "來講他買載具就是要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/860.wav", + "text": "啊我們如果連這個都不加入管理的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/861.wav", + "text": "如果連這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/862.wav", + "text": "在這次修法都達不到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/863.wav", + "text": "我是沒辦法接受" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/864.wav", + "text": "啦我覺得這個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/865.wav", + "text": "一定要跟菸本身" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/866.wav", + "text": "一起納管" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/867.wav", + "text": "之前我就說過如果載具不管" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/868.wav", + "text": "電子煙加熱菸" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/869.wav", + "text": "是吸電子煙的嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/870.wav", + "text": "如果都不管的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/871.wav", + "text": "電子煙就是禁假的嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/872.wav", + "text": "謝謝主席" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/873.wav", + "text": "煙跟加熱菸" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/874.wav", + "text": "菸的外觀是不是一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/875.wav", + "text": "有沒有相同" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/876.wav", + "text": "一直重複的就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/877.wav", + "text": "但這個在之前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/878.wav", + "text": "我們其實已經" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/879.wav", + "text": "非常有共識對於電子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/880.wav", + "text": "大家可以討論的方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/881.wav", + "text": "現在又回到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/882.wav", + "text": "跟加熱菸在外型上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/883.wav", + "text": "是不是它們的載具可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/884.wav", + "text": "共用其實" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/885.wav", + "text": "我們就這樣一直轉來轉去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/886.wav", + "text": "的定義我們已經" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/887.wav", + "text": "就繞不出去了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/888.wav", + "text": "我們真的就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/889.wav", + "text": "法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/890.wav", + "text": "當然那是一個好的方法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/891.wav", + "text": "對於電子煙及加熱菸" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/892.wav", + "text": "我們的態度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/893.wav", + "text": "是怎麼樣是一禁" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/894.wav", + "text": "還是要雙禁" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/895.wav", + "text": "載具" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/896.wav", + "text": "要不要把它也" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/897.wav", + "text": "如果定義成菸品就會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/898.wav", + "text": "跟菸品一樣管制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/899.wav", + "text": "包括促銷廣告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/900.wav", + "text": "都會受到限制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/901.wav", + "text": "先用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/902.wav", + "text": "這樣來處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/903.wav", + "text": "然後再去看條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/904.wav", + "text": "都OK啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/905.wav", + "text": "因為也不是這樣做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/906.wav", + "text": "還是要保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/907.wav", + "text": "對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/908.wav", + "text": "我覺得以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/909.wav", + "text": "衛福部的條文設計" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/910.wav", + "text": "基本上就是很清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/911.wav", + "text": "主要吸的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/912.wav", + "text": "就是化學物質" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/913.wav", + "text": "加熱菸就是菸草" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/914.wav", + "text": "至於載具這個東西" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/915.wav", + "text": "現在因為時代進步" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/916.wav", + "text": "了所以我們看到加熱菸的載具" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/917.wav", + "text": "是一個加熱器" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/918.wav", + "text": "如果以過去來說就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/919.wav", + "text": "以前是抽菸斗" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/920.wav", + "text": "事實上一樣的定義" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/921.wav", + "text": "加熱菸" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/922.wav", + "text": "菸一樣是菸草" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/923.wav", + "text": "所以還是抽菸草" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/924.wav", + "text": "化學物質它的來源不明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/925.wav", + "text": "這個是很清楚的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/926.wav", + "text": "衛福部的講法很清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/927.wav", + "text": "這種東西" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/928.wav", + "text": "大家會說不清楚可能" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/929.wav", + "text": "是因為他沒有抽菸所以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/930.wav", + "text": "並不清楚它的架構" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/931.wav", + "text": "如果有抽菸的人就很清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/932.wav", + "text": "知道我抽的是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/933.wav", + "text": "加熱菸或是電子煙" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/934.wav", + "text": "有抽菸的人一定知道啦不會說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/935.wav", + "text": "剛剛抽的是加熱菸我想不至於" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/936.wav", + "text": "會這樣所以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/937.wav", + "text": "對於定義的部分以衛福部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/938.wav", + "text": "的條文架構來說我覺得就夠了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/939.wav", + "text": "啦我們是不是可以再繼續進行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/940.wav", + "text": "下去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/941.wav", + "text": "社會上大家應該都知道自己在幹嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/942.wav", + "text": "而我們也知道自己在幹嘛就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/943.wav", + "text": "如果能夠完整地講出" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/944.wav", + "text": "的分類邏輯是什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/945.wav", + "text": "然後是接到第7條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/946.wav", + "text": "再接第十五條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/947.wav", + "text": "所以三加七加十五" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/948.wav", + "text": "加熱菸的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/949.wav", + "text": "做到什麼程度的管制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/950.wav", + "text": "如果他們能夠把這個程度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/951.wav", + "text": "就可以針對這個政策" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/952.wav", + "text": "也就是行政院這邊提出的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/953.wav", + "text": "交由大家來做評估我覺得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/954.wav", + "text": "之後審查條文其實" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/955.wav", + "text": "是不是可以請衛福部提出" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/956.wav", + "text": "這樣的補充資料讓委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/957.wav", + "text": "在同樣的一個程度上面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/958.wav", + "text": "彼此知道我們現在聚焦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/959.wav", + "text": "在哪裡在哪個程度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/960.wav", + "text": "然後這樣去前進我覺得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/961.wav", + "text": "其實會比較快\n" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/962.wav", + "text": "衛福部可以就這些問題直接" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/963.wav", + "text": "因為這樣看起來今天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/964.wav", + "text": "也還是會有保留條文還是要送院長協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/965.wav", + "text": "那麼是不是可以利用到院長協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/966.wav", + "text": "之前的這段時間請他們提出完整的資料" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/967.wav", + "text": "這樣我們才可以快一點不然開會到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/968.wav", + "text": "現在已經1個小時了一條都還沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/969.wav", + "text": "達成共識這個實在是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/970.wav", + "text": "有結論的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/971.wav", + "text": "後面的問題所以我們花比較多時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/972.wav", + "text": "在討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/973.wav", + "text": "\n請" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/974.wav", + "text": "菸害防制法不是只給吸菸的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/975.wav", + "text": "很多是不吸菸的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/976.wav", + "text": "所以我覺得本來就是要讓吸菸的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/977.wav", + "text": "人跟不吸菸的人都有權利" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/978.wav", + "text": "在這個法條上面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/979.wav", + "text": "說話\n還有一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/980.wav", + "text": "我還是要表達對於" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/981.wav", + "text": "組合元件我是堅持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/982.wav", + "text": "一定要納入管理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/983.wav", + "text": "要不然的話未成年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/984.wav", + "text": "載具啊學校就沒辦法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/985.wav", + "text": "這個問題衛福部真的是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/986.wav", + "text": "真心想要管理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/987.wav", + "text": "這些東西嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/988.wav", + "text": "如果是真心想管理怎麼連載具" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/989.wav", + "text": "要予以納管都" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/990.wav", + "text": "我再次強調第一個我本來的態" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/991.wav", + "text": "光以行政院的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/992.wav", + "text": "我認為載具" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/993.wav", + "text": "納管要不然對於" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/994.wav", + "text": "買載具的部分沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/995.wav", + "text": "對於吸菸要有年齡限制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/996.wav", + "text": "不管是原來的18歲" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/997.wav", + "text": "或現在的21歲或20歲" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/998.wav", + "text": "席先宣告一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/999.wav", + "text": "謝謝主席" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1000.wav", + "text": "我們修法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1001.wav", + "text": "很重要而且民間團體" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1002.wav", + "text": "很關心的是未來我們對於" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1003.wav", + "text": "的管理要怎麼管" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1004.wav", + "text": "條文能夠讓" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1005.wav", + "text": "後續的管理很明確" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1006.wav", + "text": "當然也包括" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1007.wav", + "text": "載具\n剛剛前面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1008.wav", + "text": "如果你說不能進口" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1009.wav", + "text": "又怎麼去規範哪些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1010.wav", + "text": "化學成分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1011.wav", + "text": "可以使用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1012.wav", + "text": "於電子煙的東西" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1013.wav", + "text": "坦白講很難定義" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1014.wav", + "text": "所以這個部分的管理基本上就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1015.wav", + "text": "不好管" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1016.wav", + "text": "這個不好管而載具" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1017.wav", + "text": "也不管" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1018.wav", + "text": "不管有沒有吸" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1019.wav", + "text": "這些東西然後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1020.wav", + "text": "就會去使用嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1021.wav", + "text": "爭執討論的用意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1022.wav", + "text": "如果這個法沒有把它" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1023.wav", + "text": "寫清楚我想" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1024.wav", + "text": "後續管理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1025.wav", + "text": "我覺得寫進去不" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1026.wav", + "text": "困難啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1027.wav", + "text": "寫清楚不困難啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1028.wav", + "text": "譬如電子煙" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1029.wav", + "text": "加熱菸載具" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1030.wav", + "text": "要怎麼管這" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1031.wav", + "text": "不會很困難啊為什麼不寫呢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1032.wav", + "text": "我還是要請" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1033.wav", + "text": "國健署" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1034.wav", + "text": "進去寫清楚沒有什麼困難啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1035.wav", + "text": "為了幫衛福部說話但" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1036.wav", + "text": "載具其實他們也有管" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1037.wav", + "text": "只是講得不清楚在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1038.wav", + "text": "委員會討論的過程中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1039.wav", + "text": "大家覺得載具這件事應該" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1040.wav", + "text": "很清楚的被管理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1041.wav", + "text": "我真的建議在第3" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1042.wav", + "text": "條的定義要能夠把載具" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1043.wav", + "text": "就有菸品" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1044.wav", + "text": "指定菸品的載具" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1045.wav", + "text": "其必要組合元件" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1046.wav", + "text": "這是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1047.wav", + "text": "在定義裡面就應該說清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1048.wav", + "text": "我覺得這會讓大家更清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1049.wav", + "text": "後面你們在規範的其必" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1050.wav", + "text": "其必要組合元件是什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1051.wav", + "text": "其實就是我們簡稱" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1052.wav", + "text": "是加熱器的載具" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1053.wav", + "text": "版本中我看到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1054.wav", + "text": "衛福部努力的是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1055.wav", + "text": "在第7條第十二條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1056.wav", + "text": "及第十五條都有去規範" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1057.wav", + "text": "都不能上市或販" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1058.wav", + "text": "第十二條則是不能" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1059.wav", + "text": "行銷即使" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1060.wav", + "text": "合格也不能行銷" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1061.wav", + "text": "第十五條是不合格的全部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1062.wav", + "text": "禁賣所以其實是有配套" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1063.wav", + "text": "的請衛福部還是要把" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1064.wav", + "text": "可以連貫性地去看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1065.wav", + "text": "整部法到底是怎麼規範的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1066.wav", + "text": "有做但是可能分散在各條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1067.wav", + "text": "起來會很累你知道嗎大家要很熟悉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1068.wav", + "text": "這個法才有辦法把每一個條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1069.wav", + "text": "的相關性連結在一起" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1070.wav", + "text": "請陳椒華委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1071.wav", + "text": "我對這個健康風險" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1072.wav", + "text": "評估是不期待" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1073.wav", + "text": "啦因為他們要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1074.wav", + "text": "怎麼去評估" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1075.wav", + "text": "只要求" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1076.wav", + "text": "廠商提供一些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1077.wav", + "text": "資料所以對於" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1078.wav", + "text": "後續的管控" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1079.wav", + "text": "當然那是第7條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1080.wav", + "text": "不過已經一直在強調說後續" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1081.wav", + "text": "有訂但是後續訂" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1082.wav", + "text": "模糊很難" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1083.wav", + "text": "管啦我要強調很難管" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1084.wav", + "text": "所以還是要再強調" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1085.wav", + "text": "衛福部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1086.wav", + "text": "沒有反對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1087.wav", + "text": "你就把相關的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1088.wav", + "text": "載具" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1089.wav", + "text": "的管理寫清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1090.wav", + "text": "那我們當然也不會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1091.wav", + "text": "一直去反對說這樣糢糊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1092.wav", + "text": "是需要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1093.wav", + "text": "保留的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1094.wav", + "text": "我們現在來作結論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1095.wav", + "text": "還要說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1096.wav", + "text": "好你講一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1097.wav", + "text": "我想" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1098.wav", + "text": "大家很關心的類菸品" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1099.wav", + "text": "就是所謂的電子煙" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1100.wav", + "text": "電子煙包括它的載具" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1101.wav", + "text": "都是禁止在市面上的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1102.wav", + "text": "輸入展示販售" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1103.wav", + "text": "相關的行為都是全面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1104.wav", + "text": "那麼加熱式菸品它就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1105.wav", + "text": "指定菸品它必須" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1106.wav", + "text": "嚴管必須要透過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1107.wav", + "text": "健康風險審查合格以後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1108.wav", + "text": "才能做剛剛提到的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1109.wav", + "text": "製造輸入販售展示" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1110.wav", + "text": "等相關的行為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1111.wav", + "text": "行為\n剛剛提到的載��" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1112.wav", + "text": "市面上所有電子煙" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1113.wav", + "text": "的載具當然是被禁止的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1114.wav", + "text": "所以只有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1115.wav", + "text": "才可以販售" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1116.wav", + "text": "那麼它也是禁止促銷" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1117.wav", + "text": "跟廣告所有的載具" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1118.wav", + "text": "這點也跟大家做個報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1119.wav", + "text": "未成年不可以買或者是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1120.wav", + "text": "不可以提供那是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1121.wav", + "text": "後續的東西目前我們是定義到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1122.wav", + "text": "的載具不能做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1123.wav", + "text": "促銷廣告但是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1124.wav", + "text": "對於後續的販售要不要再" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1125.wav", + "text": "加嚴我想大家還可以再討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1126.wav", + "text": "我們並沒有說加熱器" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1127.wav", + "text": "不管但是管到什麼連" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1128.wav", + "text": "促銷廣告都可以管" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1129.wav", + "text": "以上說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1130.wav", + "text": "主席我是建議這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1131.wav", + "text": "啦因為菸害防制法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1132.wav", + "text": "菸品和菸害" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1133.wav", + "text": "其實就是一般的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1134.wav", + "text": "電子產品" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1135.wav", + "text": "它也沒有菸草" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1136.wav", + "text": "產品不然" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1137.wav", + "text": "啊還有菸斗水菸壺這些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1138.wav", + "text": "我們就要全部都寫進去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1139.wav", + "text": "才有辦法處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1140.wav", + "text": "因為我們已經討論一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1141.wav", + "text": "這個在委員會已經討論過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1142.wav", + "text": "用打火機跟" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1143.wav", + "text": "加熱菸載具來類比" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1144.wav", + "text": "是不恰當的打火機可以點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1145.wav", + "text": "其他的東西" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1146.wav", + "text": "只能用來吸菸" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1147.wav", + "text": "它也不能做別的用途" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1148.wav", + "text": "那個元件與加熱的菸" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1149.wav", + "text": "是綁在一起的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1150.wav", + "text": "各位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1151.wav", + "text": "要休息一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1152.wav", + "text": "還是這一條保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1153.wav", + "text": "休息5分鐘" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1154.wav", + "text": "現在繼續開會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1155.wav", + "text": "針對第3條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1156.wav", + "text": "這樣子很難達成結論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1157.wav", + "text": "我們就保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1158.wav", + "text": "\n現在處理第4條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1159.wav", + "text": "第4條在第8頁" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1160.wav", + "text": "是有關菸品健康福利捐" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1161.wav", + "text": "的金額" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1162.wav", + "text": "扣繳方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1163.wav", + "text": "非常謝謝呂玉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1164.wav", + "text": "蘇治芬委員及民眾黨團提出版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1165.wav", + "text": "那麼這裡面來講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1166.wav", + "text": "菸品的調漲" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1167.wav", + "text": "明定112年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1168.wav", + "text": "114年定額調漲" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1169.wav", + "text": "度可能的經濟狀況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1170.wav", + "text": "人民所得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1171.wav", + "text": "沒有評估而直接訂定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1172.wav", + "text": "擔心會影響到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1173.wav", + "text": "甚至造成民眾的負擔" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1174.wav", + "text": "所以我們還是希望" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1175.wav", + "text": "能夠維持行政院版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1176.wav", + "text": "交給委員會來評估" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1177.wav", + "text": "然後再來決定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1178.wav", + "text": "調漲的幅度或是不調漲的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1179.wav", + "text": "一個狀況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1180.wav", + "text": "\n有關蘇委員和羅致政委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1181.wav", + "text": "希望這個委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1182.wav", + "text": "的單一性別不得少於三分之一" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1183.wav", + "text": "行政院的二三級機關的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1184.wav", + "text": "公私部門" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1185.wav", + "text": "決策參與之性別平等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1186.wav", + "text": "納入性別平等的重要議題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1187.wav", + "text": "那麼相關的委員會如果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1188.wav", + "text": "沒有設定三分之一" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1189.wav", + "text": "三分之一的條款" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1190.wav", + "text": "所以沒有必要再另定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1191.wav", + "text": "定非常謝謝委員的參考" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1192.wav", + "text": "建議維持行政院版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1193.wav", + "text": "各位委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1194.wav", + "text": "這一條好像爭議比較不大" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1195.wav", + "text": "啦因為要調漲菸捐" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1196.wav", + "text": "其實不是只有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1197.wav", + "text": "我們委員會還有財政" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1198.wav", + "text": "這個要聯席處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1199.wav", + "text": "它是說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1200.wav", + "text": "邀集財政經濟" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1201.wav", + "text": "公共衛生及相關領域" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1202.wav", + "text": "都要一起成立委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1203.wav", + "text": "去處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1204.wav", + "text": "那每年的狀況也不太一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1205.wav", + "text": "每兩年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1206.wav", + "text": "邀集一次我是覺得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1207.wav", + "text": "可以接受" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1208.wav", + "text": "對於行政院的第4條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1209.wav", + "text": "我沒有意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1210.wav", + "text": "但是因為我的修正動議裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1211.wav", + "text": "有一個項次是在第5條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1212.wav", + "text": "第5條的發言權" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1213.wav", + "text": "\n第4條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1214.wav", + "text": "終於通過一條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1215.wav", + "text": "第5條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1216.wav", + "text": "之安全準備" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1217.wav", + "text": "癌症防治等相關事項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1218.wav", + "text": "那麼謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1219.wav", + "text": "吳玉琴委員所提希望能夠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1220.wav", + "text": "加入原住民健康" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1221.wav", + "text": "不過要跟委員說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1222.wav", + "text": "因為我們所有的項目" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1223.wav", + "text": "都沒有排他性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1224.wav", + "text": "更加有彈性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1225.wav", + "text": "如果納入了原住民健康" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1226.wav", + "text": "這個事項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1227.wav", + "text": "勢必會排擠到其他" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1228.wav", + "text": "項目的運用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1229.wav", + "text": "所以我們還是建議維持行政院版本來通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1230.wav", + "text": "謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1231.wav", + "text": "請吳玉琴委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1232.wav", + "text": "這個地方我提出的是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1233.wav", + "text": "社會福利後面加了一個原住民健康" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1234.wav", + "text": "原來的菸捐也沒有分對象" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1235.wav", + "text": "可是用在原住民的健康上面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1236.wav", + "text": "有沒有相關的統計" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1237.wav", + "text": "如果你能夠提出相關統計" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1238.wav", + "text": "原住民的健康" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1239.wav", + "text": "可是如果完全沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1240.wav", + "text": "我是覺得這個部分也是我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1241.wav", + "text": "該關注和照顧的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1242.wav", + "text": "各個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1243.wav", + "text": "辦法或者計畫都有在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1244.wav", + "text": "執行我" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1245.wav", + "text": "別以國健署的例子來做說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1246.wav", + "text": "我們其實在原住民" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1247.wav", + "text": "的部分有投注所有的胃癌" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1248.wav", + "text": "篩檢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1249.wav", + "text": "這個對於原住民未來的健康" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1250.wav", + "text": "非常重要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1251.wav", + "text": "發生率偏高" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1252.wav", + "text": "所以我們就利用菸捐的經費來執行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1253.wav", + "text": "執行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1254.wav", + "text": "意外事故的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1255.wav", + "text": "或者偏鄉的這些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1256.wav", + "text": "菸檳酒的計畫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1257.wav", + "text": "在國民健康署特別多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1258.wav", + "text": "過去幾年都有特別投入相關的資源" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1259.wav", + "text": "來提升他們的健康" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1260.wav", + "text": "是不是我們會後再提供給委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1261.wav", + "text": "國健署提供相關的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1262.wav", + "text": "\n請陳椒華委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1263.wav", + "text": "菸品健康福利捐" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1264.wav", + "text": "菸害防制嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1265.wav", + "text": "請問運用在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1266.wav", + "text": "菸害防制的比例目前大概是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1267.wav", + "text": "可不可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1268.wav", + "text": "更主要的運用在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1269.wav", + "text": "對菸害防制不管是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1270.wav", + "text": "在衛教的推播" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1271.wav", + "text": "或正確的健康識能" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1272.wav", + "text": "更重要的是提供" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1273.wav", + "text": "吸菸者一個戒菸的多元" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1274.wav", + "text": "很多慢性疾病跟癌症其實都" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1275.wav", + "text": "與菸害有相關性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1276.wav", + "text": "它是一個風險因子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1277.wav", + "text": "所以我們在做所有的健康" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1278.wav", + "text": "促進計畫都是以菸害防制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1279.wav", + "text": "我們再彙整給委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1280.wav", + "text": "做參考" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1281.wav", + "text": "我的疑問是說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1282.wav", + "text": "現在的菸品健康福利捐" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1283.wav", + "text": "如果單獨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1284.wav", + "text": "用在菸害防制的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1285.wav", + "text": "是小部分的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1286.wav", + "text": "的用意了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1287.wav", + "text": "目前大概" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1288.wav", + "text": "健保做健保的安全準備金" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1289.wav", + "text": "跟補助" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1290.wav", + "text": "經費困難者的保險費用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1291.wav", + "text": "啦\n在我們國民健康署" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1292.wav", + "text": ".2%是用在剛剛我所" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1293.wav", + "text": "中央與地方" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1294.wav", + "text": "的一些醫療費用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1295.wav", + "text": "以上補充說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1296.wav", + "text": "剩下不到27.2%" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1297.wav", + "text": "包括慢性疾病等等相關的費用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1298.wav", + "text": "其實我現在正在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1299.wav", + "text": "福利捐分配" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1300.wav", + "text": "及運作辦法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1301.wav", + "text": "在108年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1302.wav", + "text": "有再修正過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1303.wav", + "text": "在第4條其實是有提到比例分配" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1304.wav", + "text": "剛剛署長回答的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1305.wav", + "text": "是指供罕見疾病" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1306.wav", + "text": "等之醫療費用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1307.wav", + "text": "癌症防治中央與" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1308.wav", + "text": "地方菸害防制及" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1309.wav", + "text": "衛生保健之用它包含" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1310.wav", + "text": "但是這個27.2%" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1311.wav", + "text": "你可以比較明確告訴我們說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1312.wav", + "text": "和菸害有關因為這邊有講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1313.wav", + "text": "中央與地方菸害防制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1314.wav", + "text": "制及衛生保健" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1315.wav", + "text": "之用是在這27.2" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1316.wav", + "text": "%裡面那可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1317.wav", + "text": "告訴我們它實質上的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1318.wav", + "text": "比例是多少嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1319.wav", + "text": "因為它是包括在整個大項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1320.wav", + "text": "裡面我們其實" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1321.wav", + "text": "不太知道它在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1322.wav", + "text": "裡面占的比例我們講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1323.wav", + "text": "菸品健康福利捐" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1324.wav", + "text": "用在相關的像" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1325.wav", + "text": "你剛剛講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1326.wav", + "text": "的癌症等等這些當然也是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1327.wav", + "text": "及衛生保健" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1328.wav", + "text": "這個部分能不能告訴我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1329.wav", + "text": "你到底占的比例是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1330.wav", + "text": "多少我想這是我們關心的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1331.wav", + "text": "\n另外一個因為我們從" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1332.wav", + "text": "之前的房地合一稅" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1333.wav", + "text": "政府部門" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1334.wav", + "text": "它會在某個方面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1335.wav", + "text": "為零那現在當然我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1336.wav", + "text": "在各大項裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1337.wav", + "text": "等等有一個大項的規範" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1338.wav", + "text": "但是我們也很好奇" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1339.wav", + "text": "有確定每一個小項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1340.wav", + "text": "的經費嗎還是會像" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1341.wav", + "text": "房地合一稅一樣後來發現" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1342.wav", + "text": "用在居住正義上是零" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1343.wav", + "text": "在這個辦法裡面提到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1344.wav", + "text": "的內容有沒有事實上是一毛錢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1345.wav", + "text": "知道一下謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1346.wav", + "text": "5.1%然後1%做中央與地方" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1347.wav", + "text": "我跟委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1348.wav", + "text": "報告每一個項目" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1349.wav", + "text": "每一個分項都有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1350.wav", + "text": "額度按照這樣的方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1351.wav", + "text": "因為我們會有一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1352.wav", + "text": "審議小組" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1353.wav", + "text": "所以這些都會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1354.wav", + "text": "提供給審議小組他們都按照" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1355.wav", + "text": "這樣的比例\n剛剛委員很關心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1356.wav", + "text": "中央與地方菸害防制及" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1357.wav", + "text": "衛生保健" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1358.wav", + "text": "那就是由我們中央和地方" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1359.wav", + "text": "來執行相關的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1360.wav", + "text": "衛教或者是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1361.wav", + "text": "衛生保健跟菸害防制之用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1362.wav", + "text": "包括癌症的防治" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1363.wav", + "text": "相關的經費裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1364.wav", + "text": "五癌的篩檢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1365.wav", + "text": "將近有50億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1366.wav", + "text": "元中央的菸害防制及衛生保健" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1367.wav", + "text": "衛生保健" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1368.wav", + "text": "六億多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1369.wav", + "text": "菸害的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1370.wav", + "text": "總共是12億元左右" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1371.wav", + "text": "要給醫療端服務的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1372.wav", + "text": "再提供詳細的資料" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1373.wav", + "text": "給委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1374.wav", + "text": "再麻煩提供" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1375.wav", + "text": "就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1376.wav", + "text": "菸害的健康捐" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1377.wav", + "text": "沒有用在菸害防制如果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1378.wav", + "text": "現在有電子煙" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1379.wav", + "text": "加熱菸這個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1380.wav", + "text": "我們更要加強相關的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1381.wav", + "text": "菸害防請" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1382.wav", + "text": "提供詳細資料給委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1383.wav", + "text": "及各位委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1384.wav", + "text": "行政院版本通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1385.wav", + "text": "\n接著處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1386.wav", + "text": "第7條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1387.wav", + "text": "在第16頁" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1388.wav", + "text": "這個是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1389.wav", + "text": "重要的條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1390.wav", + "text": "第7條中央主管機關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1391.wav", + "text": "公告指定之菸品" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1392.wav", + "text": "業者應於製造或輸入前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1393.wav", + "text": "向中央主管機關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1394.wav", + "text": "申請健康風險評估" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1395.wav", + "text": "審查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1396.wav", + "text": "經核定通過後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1397.wav", + "text": "始得為之" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1398.wav", + "text": "經向中央主管機關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1399.wav", + "text": "依法完成申報之菸品" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1400.wav", + "text": "有新發現" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1401.wav", + "text": "中央主管機關得公告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1402.wav", + "text": "指定其應於一定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1403.wav", + "text": "期限內" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1404.wav", + "text": "申請" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1405.wav", + "text": "健康風險評估審查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1406.wav", + "text": "並應" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1407.wav", + "text": "限期命業者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1408.wav", + "text": "回收及停止製造" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1409.wav", + "text": "輸入申請健康風險" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1410.wav", + "text": "評估審查未經" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1411.wav", + "text": "核定通過者限期" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1412.wav", + "text": "命其回收或銷毀" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1413.wav", + "text": "並禁止製造" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1414.wav", + "text": "應申請健康風險評估" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1415.wav", + "text": "審查之菸品" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1416.wav", + "text": "稱指定菸品" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1417.wav", + "text": "）其健康風險評估" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1418.wav", + "text": "審查之申請程序" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1419.wav", + "text": "應備文件" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1420.wav", + "text": "與資料及必要之組合" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1421.wav", + "text": "元件風險評估審查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1422.wav", + "text": "範圍與審查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1423.wav", + "text": "程序上市後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1424.wav", + "text": "監視與" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1425.wav", + "text": "管控機制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1426.wav", + "text": "核定之廢止" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1427.wav", + "text": "及其他相關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1428.wav", + "text": "事項之辦法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1429.wav", + "text": "由中央主管機關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1430.wav", + "text": "定之指定菸品" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1431.wav", + "text": "扣留於海關者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1432.wav", + "text": "於中央主管機關公告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1433.wav", + "text": "指定後三個月內" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1434.wav", + "text": "未申請健康風險評估審查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1435.wav", + "text": "或已申請健康風險評估審查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1436.wav", + "text": "而未經" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1437.wav", + "text": "核定通過者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1438.wav", + "text": "得由原扣押或" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1439.wav", + "text": "扣留海關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1440.wav", + "text": "前項扣押或扣留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1441.wav", + "text": "於海關之指定菸品" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1442.wav", + "text": "其攜帶或輸入者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1443.wav", + "text": "得於該指定菸品" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1444.wav", + "text": "經核定通過健康風險評估" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1445.wav", + "text": "審查後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1446.wav", + "text": "三個月內領回" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1447.wav", + "text": "屆期未領回者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1448.wav", + "text": "原扣押或扣留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1449.wav", + "text": "海關得逕予銷毀\n" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1450.wav", + "text": "跟大家報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1451.wav", + "text": "禁止" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1452.wav", + "text": "相關的製造輸入" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1453.wav", + "text": "除非它是指定菸品" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1454.wav", + "text": "已經審查通過的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1455.wav", + "text": "在指定菸品的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1456.wav", + "text": "載具部分剛剛提到的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1457.wav", + "text": "在第十二條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1458.wav", + "text": "規範它的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1459.wav", + "text": "廣告跟促銷" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1460.wav", + "text": "各界所關心的指定菸品的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1461.wav", + "text": "健康風險評估的審查內容" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1462.wav", + "text": "如果這一條法令" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1463.wav", + "text": "通過了以後我們將會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1464.wav", + "text": "這個辦法將會依" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1465.wav", + "text": "法制程序來進行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1466.wav", + "text": "預告透過預告程序" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1467.wav", + "text": "來蒐集各界的意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1468.wav", + "text": "PMTA事前審查的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1469.wav", + "text": "制度初步來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1470.wav", + "text": "業者來送這些審查的資料" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1471.wav", + "text": "已知或是應該知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1472.wav", + "text": "或已經公開之健康" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1473.wav", + "text": "安全風險研究的資料" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1474.wav", + "text": "與其他菸品對於" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1475.wav", + "text": "人體健康風險之比較" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1476.wav", + "text": "第二個包括成分排放物" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1477.wav", + "text": "還有檢驗方法之研究" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1478.wav", + "text": "資料第三個成癮性之" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1479.wav", + "text": "研究資料第四" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1480.wav", + "text": "個導致未成年人及" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1481.wav", + "text": "未曾吸菸者與吸菸" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1482.wav", + "text": "有關之研究資料等等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1483.wav", + "text": "這些是審查辦法裡面必須" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1484.wav", + "text": "請林奕華委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1485.wav", + "text": "發言接著是陳椒華委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1486.wav", + "text": "啦因為我自己是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1487.wav", + "text": "主張雙禁" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1488.wav", + "text": "有組合元件的審查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1489.wav", + "text": "所以我是建議第7條直接先" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1490.wav", + "text": "保留因為這會牽涉到整體" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1491.wav", + "text": "到底是雙禁或一開一禁" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1492.wav", + "text": "可能會有不一樣的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1493.wav", + "text": "結果那這一條我如果沒有主張" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1494.wav", + "text": "保留就變成我已經是贊成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1495.wav", + "text": "我要表達我的意見謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1496.wav", + "text": "請陳椒華委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1497.wav", + "text": "在條文裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1498.wav", + "text": "的公告指定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1499.wav", + "text": "之菸品" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1500.wav", + "text": "是多少的量" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1501.wav", + "text": "需要去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1502.wav", + "text": "申請健康風險" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1503.wav", + "text": "評估" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1504.wav", + "text": "然後審定的標準" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1505.wav", + "text": "到底怎麼訂" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1506.wav", + "text": "是後續才要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1507.wav", + "text": "訂嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1508.wav", + "text": "現在所提供的資料我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1509.wav", + "text": "只有要求" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1510.wav", + "text": "業者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1511.wav", + "text": "做的資料還有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1512.wav", + "text": "健康風險的比較" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1513.wav", + "text": "相關的這些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1514.wav", + "text": "那對於我們本土的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1515.wav", + "text": "是不是他們要重做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1516.wav", + "text": "對於本國人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1517.wav", + "text": "的影響" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1518.wav", + "text": "還有對不同年齡層" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1519.wav", + "text": "健康風險的影響" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1520.wav", + "text": "不能只是拿" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1521.wav", + "text": "在國外做的資料" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1522.wav", + "text": "就可以代表" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1523.wav", + "text": "請賴惠員委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1524.wav", + "text": "吳玉琴委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1525.wav", + "text": "可能還是請國健署" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1526.wav", + "text": "我認定啦因為指定之菸品" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1527.wav", + "text": "大概就是所謂的加熱菸" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1528.wav", + "text": "特別經過一個風險評估" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1529.wav", + "text": "當然剛剛林奕華委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1530.wav", + "text": "如果是雙禁那就不用討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1531.wav", + "text": "可是如果要加嚴" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1532.wav", + "text": "管理加熱菸要加嚴" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1533.wav", + "text": "管理就是第7條要來做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1534.wav", + "text": "風險的評估" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1535.wav", + "text": "\n本席在委員會的時候其實" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1536.wav", + "text": "一直有問幾個問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1537.wav", + "text": "待會兒也請署長可以再更清楚地說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1538.wav", + "text": "剛剛在這個條文裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1539.wav", + "text": "指定菸品跟其必要的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1540.wav", + "text": "組合元件都放進來了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1541.wav", + "text": "一起進來做風險評估" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1542.wav", + "text": "也就是說你提出" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1543.wav", + "text": "來的載具可能好幾款" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1544.wav", + "text": "未來要通過才" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1545.wav", + "text": "當然不能廣告但可以販賣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1546.wav", + "text": "其他副廠的就不是你" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1547.wav", + "text": "同意的那就是不能賣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1548.wav", + "text": "這個真的要釐清" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1549.wav", + "text": "\n第二個我們一直在問這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1550.wav", + "text": "風險評估的過程" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1551.wav", + "text": "到底會是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1552.wav", + "text": "怎麼樣的形式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1553.wav", + "text": "是由中央主管機關定之其實是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1554.wav", + "text": "有點空白授權我必須說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1555.wav", + "text": "因為完全不知道你們的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1556.wav", + "text": "風險評估會是什麼樣的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1557.wav", + "text": "內涵當然你剛剛特別提到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1558.wav", + "text": "會參考美國的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1559.wav", + "text": "一些指標" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1560.wav", + "text": "國健署自己的同仁" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1561.wav", + "text": "來做還是會委託像" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1562.wav", + "text": "食藥署就委託了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1563.wav", + "text": "CDE來進行相關的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1564.wav", + "text": "前置作業跟風險評估" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1565.wav", + "text": "因為已經從5月份到現在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1566.wav", + "text": "在我們委員會的討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1567.wav", + "text": "過程中大家對這一塊非常的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1568.wav", + "text": "有疑慮那你們有沒有準備" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1569.wav", + "text": "相關的審查你不能說法過了你" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1570.wav", + "text": "再來準備啊你應該有相關的準備" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1571.wav", + "text": "我知道過去你們有一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1572.wav", + "text": "財團法人安全衛生技術中心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1573.wav", + "text": "這個部分未來會委託" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1574.wav", + "text": "給他們嗎還是你們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1575.wav", + "text": "中心或是財團法人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1576.wav", + "text": "來做相關的評估我覺得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1577.wav", + "text": "你們要有準備我們才放心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1578.wav", + "text": "啊\n你沒有準備每次都是空白授權" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1579.wav", + "text": "如果一個法通過了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1580.wav", + "text": "那你們都說在研議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1581.wav", + "text": "在研議我覺得就有點擔憂" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1582.wav", + "text": "所以請國健署能夠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1583.wav", + "text": "再說明清楚謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1584.wav", + "text": "請蔡易餘委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1585.wav", + "text": "剛剛林奕華委員已經有提到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1586.wav", + "text": "因為他是雙禁所以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1587.wav", + "text": "再去討論這裡面的細節" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1588.wav", + "text": "就不是很必要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1589.wav", + "text": "所以蔡易餘委員發言完以後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1590.wav", + "text": "我們就來處理好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1591.wav", + "text": "第7條我同意保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1592.wav", + "text": "因為事實上在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1593.wav", + "text": "第3條的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1594.wav", + "text": "也有一併講到第7條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1595.wav", + "text": "所以應該是保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1596.wav", + "text": "我要跟召委抱歉一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1597.wav", + "text": "因為剛剛在處理第4條的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1598.wav", + "text": "我有自己的條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1599.wav", + "text": "我的主張是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1600.wav", + "text": "菸品的計價還是要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1601.wav", + "text": "跟國際一樣用重量來計算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1602.wav", + "text": "所以第4" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1603.wav", + "text": "第4條是不是也容許" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1604.wav", + "text": "那個可能" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1605.wav", + "text": "要再寫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1606.wav", + "text": "你的版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1607.wav", + "text": "對我的版本你有版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1608.wav", + "text": "你的修正版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1609.wav", + "text": "再寫一次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1610.wav", + "text": "還是可以再來討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1611.wav", + "text": "等一下還有第二輪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1612.wav", + "text": "對還會有第二輪我們run過一次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1613.wav", + "text": "我跟你講後面如果保留得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1614.wav", + "text": "很快其實第二輪很快" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1615.wav", + "text": "就到了你瞭解嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1616.wav", + "text": "有版本剛剛在討論的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1617.wav", + "text": "你的發言我們都列入紀錄" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1618.wav", + "text": "如果說第7條要保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1619.wav", + "text": "那剛剛的意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1620.wav", + "text": "好像就很難" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1621.wav", + "text": "目前我們看到健康風險" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1622.wav", + "text": "評估的做法是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1623.wav", + "text": "很不明確" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1624.wav", + "text": "我不知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1625.wav", + "text": "保留之後國" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1626.wav", + "text": "答復我們剛剛的要求" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1627.wav", + "text": "是不是要先說明清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1628.wav", + "text": "讓我們先拿到資料" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1629.wav", + "text": "關於" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1630.wav", + "text": "健康風險評估" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1631.wav", + "text": "大家認為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1632.wav", + "text": "有點空白授權到底你們要怎麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1633.wav", + "text": "審查什麼內容" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1634.wav", + "text": "你們能不能提供" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1635.wav", + "text": "更明確" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1636.wav", + "text": "更詳細的資料給委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1637.wav", + "text": "譬如說你們到時候通過的標準" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1638.wav", + "text": "講清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1639.wav", + "text": "謝謝大家的關心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1640.wav", + "text": "有幾個問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1641.wav", + "text": "我們會做一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1642.wav", + "text": "這個審查辦法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1643.wav", + "text": "會依法制程序來進行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1644.wav", + "text": "些資料剛剛我已經補充說明過了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1645.wav", + "text": "要不要有國內的數據" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1646.wav", + "text": "因為這些東西在國內" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1647.wav", + "text": "如果我們都禁止都沒有上市" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1648.wav", + "text": "你要求業者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1649.wav", + "text": "來做國內的數據" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1650.wav", + "text": "乎不知道要怎麼做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1651.wav", + "text": "啦所以我是覺得沒" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1652.wav", + "text": "它的健康風險評估" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1653.wav", + "text": "我想是全球的東西" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1654.wav", + "text": "那目前我們為什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1655.wav", + "text": "要做這麼嚴" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1656.wav", + "text": "因為全世界只有美國在審查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1657.wav", + "text": "所以我們已經做到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1658.wav", + "text": "很高的規格" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1659.wav", + "text": "也跟大家說我們要做這個審查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1660.wav", + "text": "啦所以剛剛提到我們會交給" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1661.wav", + "text": "來做審查委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1662.wav", + "text": "醫學" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1663.wav", + "text": "甚至於其他流行病" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1664.wav", + "text": "相關的專家去審查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1665.wav", + "text": "吳玉琴委員關心的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1666.wav", + "text": "配合多少載具" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1667.wav", + "text": "審查過了以後叫做正向表���" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1668.wav", + "text": "列非審查通過的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1669.wav", + "text": "當然就禁止販售" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1670.wav", + "text": "要跟委員說明清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1671.wav", + "text": "\n那剛剛提到的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1672.wav", + "text": "通過與否" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1673.wav", + "text": "我想那個是委員會專業的審查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1674.wav", + "text": "我沒有辦法跟你講說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1675.wav", + "text": "你符合這個標準就通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1676.wav", + "text": "因為這些風險評估的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1677.wav", + "text": "審查機制絕對不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1678.wav", + "text": "我個人可以來決定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1679.wav", + "text": "請陳椒華委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1680.wav", + "text": "這些健康風險評估" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1681.wav", + "text": "在國內沒辦法做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1682.wav", + "text": "嘛我剛剛聽你的意思是這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1683.wav", + "text": "那如果沒辦法做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1684.wav", + "text": "評估報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1685.wav", + "text": "來做審查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1686.wav", + "text": "嘛請問現在美國的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1687.wav", + "text": "審查通過與" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1688.wav", + "text": "與否的標準是什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1689.wav", + "text": "可不可以告訴我" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1690.wav", + "text": "因為他們已經做了嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1691.wav", + "text": "那你應該知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1692.wav", + "text": "啊他們通過的標準是什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1693.wav", + "text": "我不知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1694.wav", + "text": "我只看到它通過兩種" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1695.wav", + "text": "那你們怎麼沒有做研究" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1696.wav", + "text": "專業的審查標準" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1697.wav", + "text": "沒有啦我的意思是說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1698.wav", + "text": "要用健康風險評估" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1699.wav", + "text": "來審查加熱菸" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1700.wav", + "text": "這個也是告訴國人說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1701.wav", + "text": "會做嚴謹的評估" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1702.wav", + "text": "或者是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1703.wav", + "text": "你們是用健康風險評估" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1704.wav", + "text": "來告訴國人你們會把關嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1705.wav", + "text": "現在事實上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1706.wav", + "text": "你是用國外的結果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1707.wav", + "text": "結果來給我們審查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1708.wav", + "text": "如果國外通過我們這邊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1709.wav", + "text": "大概也沒有什麼依據去反對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1710.wav", + "text": "所以我才會問" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1711.wav", + "text": "通過的標準是什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1712.wav", + "text": "如果你現在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1713.wav", + "text": "我會覺得國健署是不是要再" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1714.wav", + "text": "用功一點啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1715.wav", + "text": "你要再用功一點你不能" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1716.wav", + "text": "隨便這兩頁就說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1717.wav", + "text": "後續會叫業者提供什麼什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1718.wav", + "text": "什麼然後會有委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1719.wav", + "text": "做嚴謹的審查嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1720.wav", + "text": "簡單來說就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1721.wav", + "text": "國外的報告進來國外過了我們也" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1722.wav", + "text": "擋不住啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1723.wav", + "text": "我想是這樣子它" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1724.wav", + "text": "它提出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1725.wav", + "text": "的資料過不過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1726.wav", + "text": "讓我們專業的團隊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1727.wav", + "text": "那我告訴你好嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1728.wav", + "text": "如果要以專業真正嚴謹" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1729.wav", + "text": "地把關你就" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1730.wav", + "text": "在國內做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1731.wav", + "text": "健康風險評估啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1732.wav", + "text": "他們可以委託" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1733.wav", + "text": "國內的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1734.wav", + "text": "專業團隊去做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1735.wav", + "text": "健康風險評估或者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1736.wav", + "text": "看有什麼可行的方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1737.wav", + "text": "我現在不是要刁難" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1738.wav", + "text": "我只是說你們當初" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1739.wav", + "text": "會通過加熱菸" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1740.wav", + "text": "就是要做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1741.wav", + "text": "現在的做法明顯就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1742.wav", + "text": "根本沒辦法做啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1743.wav", + "text": "就是國外過了進來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1744.wav", + "text": "根本也擋不住嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1745.wav", + "text": "我從來都沒有說我們要做健康風險評估" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1746.wav", + "text": "先說明一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1747.wav", + "text": "我們說會嚴格審查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1748.wav", + "text": "會做健康風險評估" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1749.wav", + "text": "審查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1750.wav", + "text": "那麼業者提過來的資料如果沒有辦法說服委員通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1751.wav", + "text": "那它一樣不能上市" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1752.wav", + "text": "所以審查不見得一定會過啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1753.wav", + "text": "好啦我只是跟署長說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1754.wav", + "text": "如果這個是審查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1755.wav", + "text": "那國外怎麼審查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1756.wav", + "text": "你們就加" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1757.wav", + "text": "就是用功一點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1758.wav", + "text": "看清楚國外怎麼審查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1759.wav", + "text": "那我們問了你才會回答���" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1760.wav", + "text": "你剛剛回答我不知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1761.wav", + "text": "我就覺得沒有信心啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1762.wav", + "text": "沒有說這個東西風險到多少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1763.wav", + "text": "我們會去參考啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1764.wav", + "text": "那請問你知不知道國外" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1765.wav", + "text": "健康風險評估怎麼做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1766.wav", + "text": "當然知道它怎麼做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1767.wav", + "text": "它也是成立一個委員會在審查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1768.wav", + "text": "他們怎麼做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1769.wav", + "text": "我在下次協商前可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1770.wav", + "text": "好好看清楚你們有沒有國外" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1771.wav", + "text": "PMTA的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1772.wav", + "text": "可不可以給我一份" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1773.wav", + "text": "電子檔給我" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1774.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1775.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1776.wav", + "text": "最少要看過美國" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1777.wav", + "text": "怎麼審查他國" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1778.wav", + "text": "啦怎麼審查加熱菸的風險評估" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1779.wav", + "text": "還有審查的結果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1780.wav", + "text": "總是有書面資料" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1781.wav", + "text": "因為這個也是國內團體在反對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1782.wav", + "text": "加熱菸的原" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1783.wav", + "text": "請提供給陳椒華委員跟" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1784.wav", + "text": "至少要負責任要提供出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1785.wav", + "text": "要講清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1786.wav", + "text": "再補充一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1787.wav", + "text": "剛剛賴委員在關心上市以後的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1788.wav", + "text": "在發生重大事件的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1789.wav", + "text": "我們會採取必要的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1790.wav", + "text": "原因做出相關的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1791.wav", + "text": "報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1792.wav", + "text": "如果有發現它的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1793.wav", + "text": "或者是上市以後跟它原來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1794.wav", + "text": "那我們會去做相關的管控" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1795.wav", + "text": "做相關機制的處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1796.wav", + "text": "所以我們還會做這些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1797.wav", + "text": "事項的監測跟大家報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1798.wav", + "text": "文就保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1799.wav", + "text": "在第22頁" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1800.wav", + "text": "下列方式為之" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1801.wav", + "text": "購物或其他無法辨識" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1802.wav", + "text": "消費者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1803.wav", + "text": "二開放式貨架或" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1804.wav", + "text": "其他可由消費者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1805.wav", + "text": "直接取得之方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1806.wav", + "text": "三每一販賣單位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1807.wav", + "text": "以少於二十" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1808.wav", + "text": "其內容物" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1809.wav", + "text": "淨重低於十五公克" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1810.wav", + "text": "之包裝方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1811.wav", + "text": "但雪茄不在此限" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1812.wav", + "text": "\n\n非常謝謝大家的關心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1813.wav", + "text": "所以這個條文從原來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1814.wav", + "text": "的或改成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1815.wav", + "text": "及回復到原來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1816.wav", + "text": "的舊條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1817.wav", + "text": "很關心販賣場所是不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1818.wav", + "text": "可以有禁止展示" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1819.wav", + "text": "擔心會對消費者購物的習慣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1820.wav", + "text": "還有零售業者的銷售" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1821.wav", + "text": "行為造成更大的衝擊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1822.wav", + "text": "也考量現行社會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1823.wav", + "text": "的型態在執行面的困難" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1824.wav", + "text": "所以目前還是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1825.wav", + "text": "因為目前全世界大概只有泰國" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1826.wav", + "text": "林奕華委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1827.wav", + "text": "第8條的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1828.wav", + "text": "當然雙禁不會有這個問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1829.wav", + "text": "但是為了避免之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1830.wav", + "text": "所以我覺得這條還是要保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1831.wav", + "text": "因為關鍵是在沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1832.wav", + "text": "元件的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1833.wav", + "text": "去做規範" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1834.wav", + "text": "組合元件也應該要做一些規範" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1835.wav", + "text": "所以這個條文我建議先保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1836.wav", + "text": "謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1837.wav", + "text": "的修正條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1838.wav", + "text": "第4款" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1839.wav", + "text": "為減少青少年接觸" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1840.wav", + "text": "菸品圖片之機會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1841.wav", + "text": "菸品展示之範圍" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1842.wav", + "text": "不應公開陳列展示" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1843.wav", + "text": "增加了這一款" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1844.wav", + "text": "當然看起來是管制得特別嚴" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1845.wav", + "text": "其實當時我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1846.wav", + "text": "這樣子提也是希望" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1847.wav", + "text": "衛福部國健署這邊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1848.wav", + "text": "主管機關能夠針" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1849.wav", + "text": "以陳列" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1850.wav", + "text": "之名" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1851.wav", + "text": "然後常常造成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1852.wav", + "text": "��廣告之嫌" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1853.wav", + "text": "的這種" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1854.wav", + "text": "方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1855.wav", + "text": "有所規範" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1856.wav", + "text": "\n我的意思很簡單" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1857.wav", + "text": "就是它不能做廣告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1858.wav", + "text": "但是所有的便利" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1859.wav", + "text": "超商都把它放在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1860.wav", + "text": "最明顯" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1861.wav", + "text": "的地方" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1862.wav", + "text": "你看那個收銀臺後面都是菸" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1863.wav", + "text": "效果多好啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1864.wav", + "text": "放在最明顯的地方" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1865.wav", + "text": "有廣告之嫌如果你們可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1866.wav", + "text": "提出一些規範" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1867.wav", + "text": "不要禁止陳列" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1868.wav", + "text": "大家可以來討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1869.wav", + "text": "但是你們也不提出" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1870.wav", + "text": "針對現在這種亂象" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1871.wav", + "text": "行廣告之實" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1872.wav", + "text": "最明顯的地方你要收銀的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1873.wav", + "text": "一定看到菸" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1874.wav", + "text": "青少年也好都看到菸" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1875.wav", + "text": "然後可以指著說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1876.wav", + "text": "我要這一款還是那一款" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1877.wav", + "text": "我的意思是說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1878.wav", + "text": "本來它就是禁止廣告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1879.wav", + "text": "但是你不去規範它的陳列" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1880.wav", + "text": "我們就提出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1881.wav", + "text": "要指名購買" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1882.wav", + "text": "你要買菸你就要指名" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1883.wav", + "text": "當然也有其他國家你剛剛有講泰國也是如此" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1884.wav", + "text": "統統不能公開陳列" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1885.wav", + "text": "\n除了未" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1886.wav", + "text": "成年本來就不能買" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1887.wav", + "text": "購買的便利性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1888.wav", + "text": "降低" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1889.wav", + "text": "抽菸的數量跟" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1890.wav", + "text": "就像我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1891.wav", + "text": "以前沒有規範" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1892.wav", + "text": "抽菸的地點現在抽菸" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1893.wav", + "text": "確實有效地" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1894.wav", + "text": "降低抽菸" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1895.wav", + "text": "本來就有菸癮的人會降低抽菸的量" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1896.wav", + "text": "沒有抽菸的人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1897.wav", + "text": "也會減少染上菸癮" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1898.wav", + "text": "的機率因為很不方便" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1899.wav", + "text": "嘛抽菸不方便" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1900.wav", + "text": "買菸不方便" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1901.wav", + "text": "是可以有效" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1902.wav", + "text": "降低抽菸人口及抽菸的量" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1903.wav", + "text": "所以好啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1904.wav", + "text": "你們針對陳列菸品" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1905.wav", + "text": "行政院真的來面對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1906.wav", + "text": "這個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1907.wav", + "text": "醫界把最近WHO" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1908.wav", + "text": "的一些討論意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1909.wav", + "text": "提供給我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1910.wav", + "text": "都有相關的引用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1911.wav", + "text": "關於這個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1912.wav", + "text": "像WHO在2021年就" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1913.wav", + "text": "有報告闡明說加熱" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1914.wav", + "text": "菸被菸商塑造為現代" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1915.wav", + "text": "高科技高品質生活方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1916.wav", + "text": "且其行銷策略瞄準" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1917.wav", + "text": "年輕人使用手段" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1918.wav", + "text": "包括開設花俏的店面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1919.wav", + "text": "陳列等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1920.wav", + "text": "這是在去年WHO" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1921.wav", + "text": "的報告裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1922.wav", + "text": "2022年10月的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1923.wav", + "text": "WHO建議為避免" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1924.wav", + "text": "菸商鑽法律漏洞" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1925.wav", + "text": "各國應確保國內現行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1926.wav", + "text": "菸品控制法規適用於" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1927.wav", + "text": "加熱菸裝置且該裝置" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1928.wav", + "text": "應受嚴格管控" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1929.wav", + "text": "在去年跟今年的一些相關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1930.wav", + "text": "更遑論在我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1931.wav", + "text": "及臺大很多醫生的意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1932.wav", + "text": "目前的趨勢狀況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1933.wav", + "text": "也是有提出這樣的意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1934.wav", + "text": "所以我認為在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1935.wav", + "text": "第8條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1936.wav", + "text": "第9條是有關菸品" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1937.wav", + "text": "品牌名稱及其容器" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1938.wav", + "text": "不得使用或" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1939.wav", + "text": "低焦油或其他" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1940.wav", + "text": "有誤導吸菸無害" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1941.wav", + "text": "健康或危害輕微之虞" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1942.wav", + "text": "之文字及標示" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1943.wav", + "text": "這個部分非常" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1944.wav", + "text": "陳秀寳委員等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1945.wav", + "text": "也跟林奕華委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1946.wav", + "text": "吸食器外包裝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1947.wav", + "text": "不得使用文字及" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1948.wav", + "text": "但我們考量到菸品這些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1949.wav", + "text": "標示" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1950.wav", + "text": "因為菸品是一次購買以後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1951.wav", + "text": "的外包裝拆掉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1952.wav", + "text": "以後大概就丟掉了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1953.wav", + "text": "跟紙菸或者其他" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1954.wav", + "text": "多次打開是有所差別" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1955.wav", + "text": "我們是希望能夠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1956.wav", + "text": "維持行政院的版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1957.wav", + "text": "謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1958.wav", + "text": "前面林奕華委員已經有提" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1959.wav", + "text": "了如果是雙禁的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1960.wav", + "text": "條文就要保留了請問" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1961.wav", + "text": "這個條文如果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1962.wav", + "text": "會不會有所矛盾" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1963.wav", + "text": "這一個條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1964.wav", + "text": "按照你們版本通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1965.wav", + "text": "會有矛盾嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1966.wav", + "text": "因為如果是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1967.wav", + "text": "雙禁" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1968.wav", + "text": "吸食器的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1969.wav", + "text": "吸食器當然是違法的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1970.wav", + "text": "嘛這個條文有需要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1971.wav", + "text": "更改嗎假設是雙禁" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1972.wav", + "text": "這個條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1973.wav", + "text": "還適用嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1974.wav", + "text": "如果有疑慮" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1975.wav", + "text": "大家要保留OK啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1976.wav", + "text": "其實在委員會審查的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1977.wav", + "text": "在第9條有關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1978.wav", + "text": "事項列了淡菸低焦油" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1979.wav", + "text": "或其他有誤導" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1980.wav", + "text": "可能有一個名稱叫做通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1981.wav", + "text": "健康風險評估審查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1982.wav", + "text": "因為第7條未來會有這樣的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1983.wav", + "text": "也是有誤導之嫌" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1984.wav", + "text": "支持能夠加這樣的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1985.wav", + "text": "文字就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1986.wav", + "text": "不要誤導大家說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1987.wav", + "text": "我是經過健康風險評估" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1988.wav", + "text": "通過的那如果加在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1989.wav", + "text": "菸盒上面其實會誤導" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1990.wav", + "text": "菸是經過健康風險評估" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1991.wav", + "text": "在審查的時候其實國健署" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1992.wav", + "text": "有提到可以來加註" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1993.wav", + "text": "健康風險評估" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1994.wav", + "text": "如果這樣寫好像我就是OK的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1995.wav", + "text": "沒問題的這反而是誤導了大家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1996.wav", + "text": "在抽菸的時候會覺得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1997.wav", + "text": "所以這個部分我建議應該要加進去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1998.wav", + "text": "是連動的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/1999.wav", + "text": "跟委員報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/2000.wav", + "text": "已經寫在第十二條裡面了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/2001.wav", + "text": "對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/2002.wav", + "text": "第十二條那我們等一下看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/2003.wav", + "text": "\n請林奕華委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/2004.wav", + "text": "但是因為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/2005.wav", + "text": "還是要避免" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/2006.wav", + "text": "所以我覺得這一條一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/2007.wav", + "text": "就像主席剛剛說的先保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/2008.wav", + "text": "按照剛才" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/2009.wav", + "text": "載具上如果沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/2010.wav", + "text": "多加管理或是年齡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/2011.wav", + "text": "上也沒有限制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/2012.wav", + "text": "那我更覺得在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/2013.wav", + "text": "外包裝上面的加註是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/2014.wav", + "text": "很重要的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/2015.wav", + "text": "因為它本來就是拿來吸菸用的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/2016.wav", + "text": "嘛所以我還是認為要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/2017.wav", + "text": "有個加註就是除了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/2018.wav", + "text": "的外包裝我還是認為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/2019.wav", + "text": "有加註是比較好的謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/2020.wav", + "text": "如果雙禁" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/2021.wav", + "text": "就沒有吸食器" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/2022.wav", + "text": "當然就沒有吸食器" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/2023.wav", + "text": "要不要加註的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/2024.wav", + "text": "我要講的是這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/2025.wav", + "text": "啦各位委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/2026.wav", + "text": "這樣的條文都說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/2027.wav", + "text": "一禁一開" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/2028.wav", + "text": "都不能審了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/2029.wav", + "text": "如此因為我們這次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/2030.wav", + "text": "主要針對加熱菸和" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/2031.wav", + "text": "和電子煙的處理之外" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/2032.wav", + "text": "還有針對紙菸的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/2033.wav", + "text": "原來的紙菸" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/2034.wav", + "text": "我們也有一些加嚴的措施" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/2035.wav", + "text": "法還是有針對紙菸" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/2036.wav", + "text": "增加" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/2037.wav", + "text": "比較重的罰則以及比較" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/2038.wav", + "text": "嚴格的吸食地點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/2039.wav", + "text": "即使一開一禁" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/2040.wav", + "text": "或是雙禁都還有針對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/2041.wav", + "text": "紙菸管制的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/2042.wav", + "text": "一開一禁" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/2043.wav", + "text": "都不能處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/2044.wav", + "text": "我的意思是這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/2045.wav", + "text": "\n當然我們如果要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/2046.wav", + "text": "乾脆一點就" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/2047.wav", + "text": "有點像當時委員會的處理方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/2048.wav", + "text": "但既然我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/2049.wav", + "text": "已經要協商了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/2050.wav", + "text": "應該可以更細緻一點把它分開來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/2051.wav", + "text": "關於一開一禁有爭議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/2052.wav", + "text": "的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/2053.wav", + "text": "前面沒解決當然後面一定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/2054.wav", + "text": "保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/2055.wav", + "text": "但如果不牽涉到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/2056.wav", + "text": "一開一禁的問題是針對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/2057.wav", + "text": "原來的紙菸菸品" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/2058.wav", + "text": "再做更嚴格的管制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/2059.wav", + "text": "或是罰則的加重" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/2060.wav", + "text": "那就不一定跟" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/2061.wav", + "text": "一開一禁有關係" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/2062.wav", + "text": "\n像這一條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/2063.wav", + "text": "我就覺得無論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/2064.wav", + "text": "前面是一開或是一禁" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/2065.wav", + "text": "其實都好像還是可以處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/2066.wav", + "text": "因為它主要是針對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/2067.wav", + "text": "紙菸" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/2068.wav", + "text": "便是雙禁這個菸品" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/2069.wav", + "text": "針對紙菸" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/2070.wav", + "text": "所以也可以討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/2071.wav", + "text": "即使是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/2072.wav", + "text": "兩個都禁了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/2073.wav", + "text": "這邊還是可以處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/2074.wav", + "text": "因為菸品還在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/2075.wav", + "text": "紙菸還在那邊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/2076.wav", + "text": "所以還是可以討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/2077.wav", + "text": "\n我的意思是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/2078.wav", + "text": "要不要比較認真一點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/2079.wav", + "text": "委員會的狀況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/2080.wav", + "text": "就是前面沒解決" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/2081.wav", + "text": "後面的就一路保留下去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/2082.wav", + "text": "還是尊重大家的意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/2083.wav", + "text": "主席抱歉因為你剛剛有先宣告到12點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/2084.wav", + "text": "所以我怕你突然間就結束了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/2085.wav", + "text": "我的想法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/2086.wav", + "text": "其實社會非常關注" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/2087.wav", + "text": "這部法案而且應該要趕快處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/2088.wav", + "text": "以解決問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/2089.wav", + "text": "這點我們都同意主席願意扛這個責任" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/2090.wav", + "text": "我們也覺得很好很敬佩" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/2091.wav", + "text": "但是從剛剛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/2092.wav", + "text": "問題到底要禁多少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/2093.wav", + "text": "開多少這也是個問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/2094.wav", + "text": "其他的條文處理掉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/2095.wav", + "text": "可能好像可以處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/2096.wav", + "text": "萬一它又有牽動呢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/2097.wav", + "text": "\n如果源頭還是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/2098.wav", + "text": "我們這個委員會開完協商之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/2099.wav", + "text": "一定還是會進入立" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/2100.wav", + "text": "立法院的慣行程序就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/2101.wav", + "text": "要到院長協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/2102.wav", + "text": "聽聽看我的主張" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/2103.wav", + "text": "我從今天會議一開始時" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/2104.wav", + "text": "大家想要處理的事項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/2105.wav", + "text": "羅列出來比如今天大家也再次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/2106.wav", + "text": "加熱菸加熱菸裡還" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/2107.wav", + "text": "甚至是其他更細" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/2108.wav", + "text": "一層一層分下去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/2109.wav", + "text": "互相連結國健署" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/2110.wav", + "text": "如果每個委員都有相關的版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/2111.wav", + "text": "下次協商的委員要主動跟" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/2112.wav", + "text": "樣大家開會時就" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/2113.wav", + "text": "來討論事情不能再說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/2114.wav", + "text": "不知道這個在哪裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/2115.wav", + "text": "我覺得這樣會不會比較" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/2116.wav", + "text": "快是否可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/2117.wav", + "text": "直接進入到院長協商的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/2118.wav", + "text": "我個人會這樣建議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/2119.wav", + "text": "這樣好像比較慢一點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/2120.wav", + "text": "儘量努力才不會被" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/2121.wav", + "text": "被人批評委員會根本就怠惰" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/2122.wav", + "text": "針對那個提綱" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/2123.wav", + "text": "挈領一開始你就有提到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/2124.wav", + "text": "那部分請" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/2125.wav", + "text": "我覺得還可以再努力一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/2126.wav", + "text": "下次會議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/2127.wav", + "text": "你就提出來一開始就來討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/2128.wav", + "text": "那一部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/2129.wav", + "text": "\n本日協商會議先到此為止" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/2130.wav", + "text": "下次協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/2131.wav", + "text": "從第9條開始進行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/2132.wav", + "text": "本席" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/2133.wav", + "text": "再擇期召開" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14536/2134.wav", + "text": "協商現在散會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/0.wav", + "text": "\n各位黨團代表委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1.wav", + "text": "先進及行政院部門代表大家午安" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2.wav", + "text": "併案審查行政院函請審議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/3.wav", + "text": "精神衛生法修正草案等16案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/4.wav", + "text": "委員游毓蘭等17人擬具及委員范雲等18人擬具" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/5.wav", + "text": "精神衛生法部分條文修正草案以上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/6.wav", + "text": "二案為院會逕付二讀提案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/7.wav", + "text": "送交黨團協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/8.wav", + "text": "在進行協商前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/9.wav", + "text": "有關本次協商委員會審查完成之" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/10.wav", + "text": "行政院函請審議精神衛生法修正草案等16案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/11.wav", + "text": "本席在5月2日社會福利及衛生環境委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/12.wav", + "text": "召開會議審查時" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/13.wav", + "text": "保留其中36條行政院及委員提案之條文交付協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/14.wav", + "text": "另有委員游毓蘭等17人擬具" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/15.wav", + "text": "及委員范雲等18人擬具之" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/16.wav", + "text": "逕付二讀提案版本也併案交付本次協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/17.wav", + "text": "經查也都涵蓋在委員會審查報告之範圍內" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/18.wav", + "text": "因此本日協商為求聚焦爭取立法時效" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/19.wav", + "text": "本席想請問各位協商委員代表是否原則同意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/20.wav", + "text": "本委員會完成審查通過之條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/21.wav", + "text": "暫不討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/22.wav", + "text": "本日僅先就委員會保留之條文進行協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/23.wav", + "text": "嗣後如對委員會通過條文還有意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/24.wav", + "text": "再繼續進行協商討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/25.wav", + "text": "\n意思是這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/26.wav", + "text": "這個是程序" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/27.wav", + "text": "我們徵求大家的同意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/28.wav", + "text": "我們先就保留的條文進行協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/29.wav", + "text": "協商當然如果有委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/30.wav", + "text": "文提出修正動議的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/31.wav", + "text": "這樣在程序上可能會比較有效率" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/32.wav", + "text": "請問各位委員代表有無意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/33.wav", + "text": "現在開始進行討論精神衛生法保留條文首先是第3條之條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/34.wav", + "text": "先請衛福部代表說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/35.wav", + "text": "主席各位委員針對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/36.wav", + "text": "我們已經有採納各個委員所提出的修正建議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/37.wav", + "text": "包括加入社區支持等概念" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/38.wav", + "text": "另外我們在這邊主要是針對本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/39.wav", + "text": "對本條第8項第9項及第10項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/40.wav", + "text": "有稍微做一點修正跟敘明而已" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/41.wav", + "text": "目前左邊的建議修正版本為原則" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/42.wav", + "text": "\n至於委員們有提到很多其他的名詞" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/43.wav", + "text": "已經有敘述" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/44.wav", + "text": "像家屬家庭照顧者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/45.wav", + "text": "等很多在民法裡都有定義" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/46.wav", + "text": "了所以不建議在這邊再加入" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/47.wav", + "text": "以上說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/48.wav", + "text": "本席先肯定衛福部在這裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/49.wav", + "text": "還是有增加一些修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/50.wav", + "text": "譬如社區支持也有一段基本的文字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/51.wav", + "text": "\n我這裡的版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/52.wav", + "text": "原本其實就是依照CRPD在國際審查時所" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/53.wav", + "text": "所強調的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/54.wav", + "text": "而留在社區的自由其實就是要給他" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/55.wav", + "text": "原本缺乏的資源跟服務" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/56.wav", + "text": "嘛所以我認為這裡當然要越明確越好\n" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/57.wav", + "text": "\n我的條文所增加的重點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/58.wav", + "text": "還有病人參與" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/59.wav", + "text": "自立生活心理支持生活重建" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/60.wav", + "text": "同儕支持照顧者支持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/61.wav", + "text": "但是在這裡這是一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/62.wav", + "text": "還滿重要的概念說明的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/63.wav", + "text": "希望能夠有一個比較完整的版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/64.wav", + "text": "\n我很快地唸一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/65.wav", + "text": "裡社區支持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/66.wav", + "text": "以及與其他人同等之權利" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/67.wav", + "text": "並應採取有效及適當之措施" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/68.wav", + "text": "以促進病人充分享有該等權利" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/69.wav", + "text": "以及充分融合及社會參與" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/70.wav", + "text": "為促進病人於社區自立生活" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/71.wav", + "text": "提供病人於社區生活中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/72.wav", + "text": "所需之心理支持生活重建" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/73.wav", + "text": "居住就業自立生活同儕運作" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/74.wav", + "text": "或由同儕提供支持之服務" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/75.wav", + "text": "照顧者支持及其他支持措施" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/76.wav", + "text": "並提供合理調整" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/77.wav", + "text": "我還是希望我們能夠協商然後再放進去更多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/78.wav", + "text": "以上謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/79.wav", + "text": "我們來看一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/80.wav", + "text": "范委員的版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/81.wav", + "text": "7頁開始" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/82.wav", + "text": "下半部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/83.wav", + "text": "的部分現在主要講到的就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/84.wav", + "text": "第1項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/85.wav", + "text": "第8款" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/86.wav", + "text": "關於社區支持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/87.wav", + "text": "義看起來范委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/88.wav", + "text": "社區支持的定義是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/89.wav", + "text": "更詳細" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/90.wav", + "text": "有所不同" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/91.wav", + "text": "或其他黨團" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/92.wav", + "text": "\n請邱委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/93.wav", + "text": "對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/94.wav", + "text": "你當然也可以針對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/95.wav", + "text": "范雲委員所提的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/96.wav", + "text": "衛福部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/97.wav", + "text": "等一下我們統一再請衛福部回" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/98.wav", + "text": "我先提出問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/99.wav", + "text": "衛福部在宣導在1月的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/100.wav", + "text": "曾提到本法修正的五大重點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/101.wav", + "text": "當然有強調到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/102.wav", + "text": "心理健康促進" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/103.wav", + "text": "也有提到這個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/104.wav", + "text": "請問這個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/105.wav", + "text": "有沒有需要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/106.wav", + "text": "在哪個地方做一個定義" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/107.wav", + "text": "他們怎麼樣的一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/108.wav", + "text": "專業的呈現" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/109.wav", + "text": "對於這個部分稍後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/110.wav", + "text": "稍後衛福部一併回答的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/111.wav", + "text": "請再順便回答一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/112.wav", + "text": "有沒有需要在這個地方做一個定義" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/113.wav", + "text": "規定或者在後面要怎麼樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/114.wav", + "text": "再來說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/115.wav", + "text": "願意也可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/116.wav", + "text": "有一個地位來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/117.wav", + "text": "一起照顧人民" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/118.wav", + "text": "好稍後再請衛福部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/119.wav", + "text": "一併說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/120.wav", + "text": "謝謝主席" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/121.wav", + "text": "的修" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/122.wav", + "text": "法協商大家都非常重視" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/123.wav", + "text": "這個法案的修正希望能夠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/124.wav", + "text": "更與時俱進" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/125.wav", + "text": "有一個版本但是今天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/126.wav", + "text": "大家可能有看到我又再提出" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/127.wav", + "text": "出修正動議因為有比較" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/128.wav", + "text": "長的休會時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/129.wav", + "text": "我們也可以跟相關的團體" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/130.wav", + "text": "怎麼樣可以把更進步的觀念" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/131.wav", + "text": "放到這次的精神衛生法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/132.wav", + "text": "裡面\n我們都知道原來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/133.wav", + "text": "的部分我們有幾個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/134.wav", + "text": "條牽涉到定義的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/135.wav", + "text": "希望用心理不適" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/136.wav", + "text": "來代替精神有問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/137.wav", + "text": "污名化還有一個就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/138.wav", + "text": "一樣都只想要靠醫療來解決" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/139.wav", + "text": "一切的社區問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/140.wav", + "text": "另外有關心理健康" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/141.wav", + "text": "促進我們也知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/142.wav", + "text": "WHO有提到這就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/143.wav", + "text": "我們也覺得這是民眾應該要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/144.wav", + "text": "有的權利並且我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/145.wav", + "text": "數十年來都是以精神醫療" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/146.wav", + "text": "嚴重精神疾病的處遇" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/147.wav", + "text": "\n所以這次我" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/148.wav", + "text": "因此做了比較大幅的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/149.wav", + "text": "心理健康的定義" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/150.wav", + "text": "心理健康促進" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/151.wav", + "text": "的定義後續就" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/152.wav", + "text": "跟行政院版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/153.wav", + "text": "比較接近的相關內容" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/154.wav", + "text": "\n其實就像我剛剛講到的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/155.wav", + "text": "我們真的很希望透過這次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/156.wav", + "text": "這樣才能夠讓我國來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/157.wav", + "text": "響應國際人權公約" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/158.wav", + "text": "包括CRPDCEDAW" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/159.wav", + "text": "健康權的要求還有落實" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/160.wav", + "text": "永續發展目標SDGs" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/161.wav", + "text": "今天我們在討論協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/162.wav", + "text": "時可以更透過這些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/163.wav", + "text": "包括像長者跟照顧者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/164.wav", + "text": "能覺察心理不適的議題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/165.wav", + "text": "及早地來處理與協助" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/166.wav", + "text": "這樣的發言後續如果有再討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/167.wav", + "text": "時我們可以再進一步論述謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/168.wav", + "text": "請賴香伶委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/169.wav", + "text": "行政院的再修正版" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/170.wav", + "text": "確實加入了社區支持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/171.wav", + "text": "在第3頁社區支持的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/172.wav", + "text": "病人於社區生活" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/173.wav", + "text": "就學就養及其他支持服務" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/174.wav", + "text": "以統合性之支持服務" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/175.wav", + "text": "使病人於社區生活" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/176.wav", + "text": "中享有與他人平等之" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/177.wav", + "text": "權利支持其於社區" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/178.wav", + "text": "及融合社區" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/179.wav", + "text": "的統合性的支持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/180.wav", + "text": "跟社區參與及融合" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/181.wav", + "text": "社區的內容還是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/182.wav", + "text": "不明確所以我覺得剛剛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/183.wav", + "text": "社區支持應該要再" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/184.wav", + "text": "具體化一點其實並不影響" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/185.wav", + "text": "修法的文字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/186.wav", + "text": "裡面說就養就醫及其他" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/187.wav", + "text": "支持措施與協助其實如果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/188.wav", + "text": "沒有再更細的規劃的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/189.wav", + "text": "大概就像剛剛立法說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/190.wav", + "text": "所提有關社區" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/191.wav", + "text": "支持的內涵" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/192.wav", + "text": "\n現在有非常多第一線" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/193.wav", + "text": "服務的團體特別是社區" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/194.wav", + "text": "的支持性團體跟病友" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/195.wav", + "text": "團體都強調" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/196.wav", + "text": "要能夠回歸社區同時" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/197.wav", + "text": "社區中的支持體系不能僅" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/198.wav", + "text": "靠醫政單位或是社政單位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/199.wav", + "text": "還包括他們的自立生活" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/200.wav", + "text": "生活重建還有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/201.wav", + "text": "同儕運作同儕之間的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/202.wav", + "text": "支持性服務甚至是照顧者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/203.wav", + "text": "的支持體系等等所以如果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/204.wav", + "text": "可以在社區支持的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/205.wav", + "text": "文字定義當中加入幾個明確" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/206.wav", + "text": "的概念或是在立法說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/207.wav", + "text": "加以詳述我覺得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/208.wav", + "text": "比較能夠回歸現在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/209.wav", + "text": "第二塊支持體系就是社區" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/210.wav", + "text": "或是精神疾患的家人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/211.wav", + "text": "像過去大家理解的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/212.wav", + "text": "那種慢性疾病或是身體殘疾" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/213.wav", + "text": "它是一個mental的東西" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/214.wav", + "text": "第3條第7款社區支持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/215.wav", + "text": "明你們認為的融合性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/216.wav", + "text": "跟統合性的概念" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/217.wav", + "text": "如果真的不行我也建議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/218.wav", + "text": "要用附帶決議把第3條第7款" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/219.wav", + "text": "做一��補充性的說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/220.wav", + "text": "以上是我的建議謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/221.wav", + "text": "王婉諭委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/222.wav", + "text": "首先在心理健康或是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/223.wav", + "text": "心理健康促進這部分其實剛剛也有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/224.wav", + "text": "其他委員提到就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/225.wav", + "text": "當我們在後面的法條可能也有提到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/226.wav", + "text": "這些文字的時候為了要讓它" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/227.wav", + "text": "與疾病的現象做一個區別" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/228.wav", + "text": "同時也希望能夠更進一步往前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/229.wav", + "text": "做到心理健康促進相關的議題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/230.wav", + "text": "應該要把這部分納入這次我們也提出" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/231.wav", + "text": "希望把心理健康及心理健康促進" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/232.wav", + "text": "定義\n另外剛剛大家一直在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/233.wav", + "text": "討論的其實也是這次精神衛生法修法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/234.wav", + "text": "的改變就是應該要把社區支持的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/235.wav", + "text": "納入而且不只是納入而已應該要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/236.wav", + "text": "更細緻地來談之前其實" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/237.wav", + "text": "我們已經就這個部分談得滿多的但" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/238.wav", + "text": "修正動議是希望能夠涵蓋得更廣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/239.wav", + "text": "主要是因為我們看到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/240.wav", + "text": "CRPD正在進行審議的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/241.wav", + "text": "關於社區支持的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/242.wav", + "text": "有特別提點出來認為我們應該要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/243.wav", + "text": "國際審查結論性意見內的第68點和第69" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/244.wav", + "text": "一直提到的是衛生福利部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/245.wav", + "text": "剝奪了身心障礙者的自由不允許" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/246.wav", + "text": "他們選擇在哪裡生活和與誰一起生活" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/247.wav", + "text": "以及在這樣的情況下被限定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/248.wav", + "text": "在醫院和機構是因為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/249.wav", + "text": "缺乏了支援和服務使他們能夠在社區" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/250.wav", + "text": "都應該要具備讓這些人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/251.wav", + "text": "生活來做準備" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/252.wav", + "text": "並且提供個人的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/253.wav", + "text": "計畫這部分其實國際委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/254.wav", + "text": "都有一再地提到\n我覺得臺灣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/255.wav", + "text": "一直希望能夠跟國際接軌即便" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/256.wav", + "text": "我們的CRPD是用內國" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/257.wav", + "text": "法化的方式來做處理但我們還是希望" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/258.wav", + "text": "應該要朝這樣審查性的結論跟建議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/259.wav", + "text": "告訴大家其實我們在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/260.wav", + "text": "持續地希望能夠跟世界的意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/261.wav", + "text": "和世界的法案方向來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/262.wav", + "text": "謝謝主席我也要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/263.wav", + "text": "呼應一下我個人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/264.wav", + "text": "認為比較" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/265.wav", + "text": "納入第3條另外" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/266.wav", + "text": "更細緻的規範" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/267.wav", + "text": "所以我覺得行政院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/268.wav", + "text": "原始的行政院版本好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/269.wav", + "text": "健康跟心理健康促進" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/270.wav", + "text": "具體的定義" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/271.wav", + "text": "衛生法中出現過二十" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/272.wav", + "text": "需要有清楚的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/273.wav", + "text": "剛剛有幾個委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/274.wav", + "text": "其實這兩個詞" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/275.wav", + "text": "在後面非常多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/276.wav", + "text": "地方都會出現" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/277.wav", + "text": "要不要去定義它我覺得衛福部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/278.wav", + "text": "部可以討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/279.wav", + "text": "至於心理不適我就覺得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/280.wav", + "text": "不適合放因為後面沒有這個文字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/281.wav", + "text": "所以在這邊放定義很怪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/282.wav", + "text": "因為定義是要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/283.wav", + "text": "回應後面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/284.wav", + "text": "必須要概括性地在這邊做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/285.wav", + "text": "\n這次衛福部提出來的第3" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/286.wav", + "text": "委員會審查時不一樣的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/287.wav", + "text": "第10款" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/288.wav", + "text": "關精神照護" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/289.wav", + "text": "機構全部把它定義到這邊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/290.wav", + "text": "來了就是有做結構性的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/291.wav", + "text": "之前第21條把這些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/292.wav", + "text": "都定位為精神" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/293.wav", + "text": "把精神照護機構在這邊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/294.wav", + "text": "不然我們在後面會混淆" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/295.wav", + "text": "有好多的名詞" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/296.wav", + "text": "法裡面的用詞做清楚明確" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/297.wav", + "text": "的定義後面是在規範" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/298.wav", + "text": "這些精神照護機構所要做的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/299.wav", + "text": "工作我覺得這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/300.wav", + "text": "會比較清楚所以對於" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/301.wav", + "text": "行政院現在建議的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/302.wav", + "text": "所謂架構的調整我是支持的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/303.wav", + "text": "謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/304.wav", + "text": "認為說明欄寫得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/305.wav", + "text": "得不夠詳細" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/306.wav", + "text": "其他委員對此也有呼應" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/307.wav", + "text": "所以針對第" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/308.wav", + "text": "款" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/309.wav", + "text": "等一下請衛福部回應" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/310.wav", + "text": "是不是要更詳細地列入" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/311.wav", + "text": "一些相關說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/312.wav", + "text": "第二部分是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/313.wav", + "text": "要不要把" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/314.wav", + "text": "心理健康" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/315.wav", + "text": "或心理健康促進" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/316.wav", + "text": "定義的款裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/317.wav", + "text": "有以上這兩部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/318.wav", + "text": "林委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/319.wav", + "text": "奕華邱委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/320.wav", + "text": "\n現在請衛福部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/321.wav", + "text": "說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/322.wav", + "text": "謝謝各位委員的指教" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/323.wav", + "text": "支持這個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/324.wav", + "text": "我想做一個建議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/325.wav", + "text": "如果我們要把它寫得更具體" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/326.wav", + "text": "可是要具體的情況下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/327.wav", + "text": "在這個法裡面對於精神病人的協助" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/328.wav", + "text": "可能在其他的法例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/329.wav", + "text": "本來依法也有相關的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/330.wav", + "text": "福利身分有經濟支持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/331.wav", + "text": "有所謂的長照" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/332.wav", + "text": "等等那個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/333.wav", + "text": "我們是不是就不用寫得那麼清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/334.wav", + "text": "所以我提出" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/335.wav", + "text": "是不是可以修正為社區支持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/336.wav", + "text": "於社區生活中所" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/337.wav", + "text": "生活重建" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/338.wav", + "text": "居住" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/339.wav", + "text": "日間式服務" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/340.wav", + "text": "居家式服務" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/341.wav", + "text": "社區式服務" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/342.wav", + "text": "家庭支持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/343.wav", + "text": "與" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/344.wav", + "text": "同儕支持服務" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/345.wav", + "text": "在這個法裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/346.wav", + "text": "因為在經濟安全在長照" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/347.wav", + "text": "福利相關的法規" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/348.wav", + "text": "或是長照相關的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/349.wav", + "text": "依法都可以得到這樣的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/350.wav", + "text": "服務所以我們是不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/351.wav", + "text": "可以聚焦因為這裡看起來寫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/352.wav", + "text": "對我們來講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/353.wav", + "text": "我們會覺得內涵是一樣的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/354.wav", + "text": "聚焦在這幾項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/355.wav", + "text": "這也是我們接下來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/356.wav", + "text": "這個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/357.wav", + "text": "謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/358.wav", + "text": "那是不是要把文字寫出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/359.wav", + "text": "關於社區支持的部分其實依第" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/360.wav", + "text": "把詳細的內容寫出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/361.wav", + "text": "這邊的社區支持照理講只是一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/362.wav", + "text": "第3條其實只是針對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/363.wav", + "text": "名詞作定義" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/364.wav", + "text": "事情都統統寫在裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/365.wav", + "text": "裡面有規定要另外訂定一個子法規" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/366.wav", + "text": "然後把要做的事情寫在裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/367.wav", + "text": "這樣才能夠兼顧到原則" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/368.wav", + "text": "跟" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/369.wav", + "text": "所要做的事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/370.wav", + "text": "以上稍微補充說明一下\n第二" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/371.wav", + "text": "關於心理健康及心理健康促進" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/372.wav", + "text": "我也瞭解" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/373.wav", + "text": "所以我們當初有訂了一個策略就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/374.wav", + "text": "每次修法慢慢地逐步提升心理健康促進" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/375.wav", + "text": "但是到底什麼是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/376.wav", + "text": "心理健康什麼是心理健康促進" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/377.wav", + "text": "並沒有很一致的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/378.wav", + "text": "內容大家可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/379.wav", + "text": "要提供居住方案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/380.wav", + "text": "要有社區營造" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/381.wav", + "text": "大的政策角度在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/382.wav", + "text": "說這件事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/383.wav", + "text": "而不是我們用什麼介入措施" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/384.wav", + "text": "什麼策略就可以直接改善" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/385.wav", + "text": "心理健康或促進" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/386.wav", + "text": "心理健康所以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/387.wav", + "text": "我們當初在這個法裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/388.wav", + "text": "雖然有提到心理健康" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/389.wav", + "text": "心理健康促進但是都比較" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/390.wav", + "text": "是宣示性原則性的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/391.wav", + "text": "一直到現在大家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/392.wav", + "text": "也沒有非常好非常" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/393.wav", + "text": "一致性的策略或" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/394.wav", + "text": "定義所以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/395.wav", + "text": "到底要怎麼做心理健康促進其實" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/396.wav", + "text": "你去問提這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/397.wav", + "text": "案子的人他們也想不出來要怎麼做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/398.wav", + "text": "要做社區營造" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/399.wav", + "text": "很多都是強調社區營造" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/400.wav", + "text": "可是社區營造不太是我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/401.wav", + "text": "在這個level" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/402.wav", + "text": "要去討論的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/403.wav", + "text": "那都是一個很大的策略" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/404.wav", + "text": "性角度的思維其" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/405.wav", + "text": "實WHO" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/406.wav", + "text": "心理健康促進有一個定義" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/407.wav", + "text": "達兩面的文字可是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/408.wav", + "text": "沒辦法簡要地說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/409.wav", + "text": "什麼是心理健康促進" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/410.wav", + "text": "沒有打算在這邊就把它" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/411.wav", + "text": "寫得很清楚就是因為實在也寫不清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/412.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/413.wav", + "text": "了請問各位委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/414.wav", + "text": "還有沒有其他意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/415.wav", + "text": "\n請范委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/416.wav", + "text": "司長的想法當然就是希望" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/417.wav", + "text": "越簡潔越好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/418.wav", + "text": "有一些關鍵的文字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/419.wav", + "text": "是不是能夠放進去這樣大家在思考上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/420.wav", + "text": "就會比較清楚一個就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/421.wav", + "text": "平等參與因為他們現在在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/422.wav", + "text": "社區完全被孤立" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/423.wav", + "text": "居住安置就學就業" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/424.wav", + "text": "就養就醫等等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/425.wav", + "text": "可是並沒有社會參與的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/426.wav", + "text": "部分其實他的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/427.wav", + "text": "同儕支持照顧者支持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/428.wav", + "text": "資源後面你們再考量" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/429.wav", + "text": "像社會參與" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/430.wav", + "text": "至於其他不能放進去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/431.wav", + "text": "的東西是不是可以考量放到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/432.wav", + "text": "立法理由當中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/433.wav", + "text": "讓那個說明可以更清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/434.wav", + "text": "一點如果你要立法理由的版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/435.wav", + "text": "我們這邊可以有我想有些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/436.wav", + "text": "關鍵字因為他們現在在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/437.wav", + "text": "社區中完全是孤立的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/438.wav", + "text": "目前你們的版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/439.wav", + "text": "就是集中在居住安置" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/440.wav", + "text": "就學就業就養" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/441.wav", + "text": "可是沒有社會參與的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/442.wav", + "text": "支持照顧者支持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/443.wav", + "text": "的精神要放在裡面你的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/444.wav", + "text": "資源才會照顧到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/445.wav", + "text": "以前原本沒有辦法看到的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/446.wav", + "text": "視角以上謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/447.wav", + "text": "我覺得還有一些應該要涵蓋進去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/448.wav", + "text": "因為就像我剛才提到的國際審查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/449.wav", + "text": "意見也是覺得在這部分著墨較少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/450.wav", + "text": "另外還有一個部分是我剛剛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/451.wav", + "text": "我們的修正動議第10項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/452.wav", + "text": "有提到精神危機前期" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/453.wav", + "text": "當然我們之前一直在談的危機處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/454.wav", + "text": "在自傷傷人之舉的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/455.wav", + "text": "才會把它當成是危機的發生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/456.wav", + "text": "這個部分已經有相關的機制來做處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/457.wav", + "text": "所以我們就把這個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/458.wav", + "text": "我們這邊提到的是在前期" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/459.wav", + "text": "如果還不到強制就醫階段的自傷傷人之虞" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/460.wav", + "text": "病人已經是一個比較" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/461.wav", + "text": "然後又欠缺對危機的瞭解更多認識" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/462.wav", + "text": "的情況下其實就應該要積極的介入" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/463.wav", + "text": "這樣是為了避免" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/464.wav", + "text": "衛福部就有相關的計畫正在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/465.wav", + "text": "執行當中但是在法案上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/466.wav", + "text": "其實是付之闕如的所以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/467.wav", + "text": "希望能夠把它繼續往前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/468.wav", + "text": "是不是應該要有一個適當的定義" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/469.wav", + "text": "包括我們在這裡提到的像是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/470.wav", + "text": "在比較脆弱的狀態或是生活" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/471.wav", + "text": "發生明顯困難的時候需要相關的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/472.wav", + "text": "精神衛生以及心理健康比較前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/473.wav", + "text": "期中前期的涵蓋" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/474.wav", + "text": "而不是只有在事情發生之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/475.wav", + "text": "而已謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/476.wav", + "text": "委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/477.wav", + "text": "謝謝主席剛剛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/478.wav", + "text": "經過大家的討論還有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/479.wav", + "text": "官員的說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/480.wav", + "text": "他們的能力只能針對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/481.wav", + "text": "所以在精神" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/482.wav", + "text": "衛生法裡面是針對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/483.wav", + "text": "已經是病人的部分來著手" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/484.wav", + "text": "但是我們今天要求的是剛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/485.wav", + "text": "剛有提到幾個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/486.wav", + "text": "我們希望能夠站在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/487.wav", + "text": "比較永續的概念因為我們都知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/488.wav", + "text": "發現心理不適" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/489.wav", + "text": "成為精神疾病的風險" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/490.wav", + "text": "也間接幫助健保的永續" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/491.wav", + "text": "減少精神醫療" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/492.wav", + "text": "的支出也可以讓健保" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/493.wav", + "text": "\n另外要如何來強化" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/494.wav", + "text": "社區預防的篩檢功能" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/495.wav", + "text": "對於一些所謂早發的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/496.wav", + "text": "部分就是早期發現病人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/497.wav", + "text": "及早來做轉介" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/498.wav", + "text": "重點還是在前端的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/499.wav", + "text": "我們不希望" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/500.wav", + "text": "因為最近大家很關注的其實都是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/501.wav", + "text": "這樣的事情發生了遺憾" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/502.wav", + "text": "疾病了所以我們覺得應該" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/503.wav", + "text": "心理健康心理健康促進" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/504.wav", + "text": "有那麼多名詞出現" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/505.wav", + "text": "還是可以給它做個定義" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/506.wav", + "text": "但總是一個方向" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/507.wav", + "text": "越來越強的時候可以根據這樣的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/508.wav", + "text": "法規政策都能夠漸漸" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/509.wav", + "text": "地更加完整" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/510.wav", + "text": "定義上我認為還是必須" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/511.wav", + "text": "剛剛大家提到的心理不適" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/512.wav", + "text": "轉折的說法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/513.wav", + "text": "就是心理不適" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/514.wav", + "text": "為什麼我們也希望這邊加個定義" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/515.wav", + "text": "當然牽涉到後面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/516.wav", + "text": "我提的修正版本裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/517.wav", + "text": "心理不適的預防" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/518.wav", + "text": "同等地看到心理健康" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/519.wav", + "text": "心理不適" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/520.wav", + "text": "都是互為關係" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/521.wav", + "text": "都有關係的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/522.wav", + "text": "當定義清楚之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/523.wav", + "text": "政策作為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/524.wav", + "text": "未來也才能夠更著重在這個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/525.wav", + "text": "國際人權公約等相關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/526.wav", + "text": "健康權部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/527.wav", + "text": "跟國際接軌這樣的目的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/528.wav", + "text": "我們當然希望可以把它修得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/529.wav", + "text": "更前進更完整" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/530.wav", + "text": "因為我們終究不只是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/531.wav", + "text": "的立場而是希望以整體來看待" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/532.wav", + "text": "心理健康促進這個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/533.wav", + "text": "以上再補充謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/534.wav", + "text": "請賴香伶委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/535.wav", + "text": "次長的意思是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/536.wav", + "text": "可以在文字修正裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/537.wav", + "text": "加入范雲" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/538.wav", + "text": "范雲委員提到的一些內容" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/539.wav", + "text": "你們在第24條未來有一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/540.wav", + "text": "子法的授權我現在是沒有看到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/541.wav", + "text": "所以等一下請你再說明一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/542.wav", + "text": "因為現在你們的第24條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/543.wav", + "text": "好像是新增一個條文和剛剛講的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/544.wav", + "text": "連結" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/545.wav", + "text": "第23條會有一個授權" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/546.wav", + "text": "我們沒有看到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/547.wav", + "text": "版本等一下請說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/548.wav", + "text": "要訂定子法嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/549.wav", + "text": "可以把文字調出來或跟大家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/550.wav", + "text": "報告一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/551.wav", + "text": "針對社區支持你也覺得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/552.wav", + "text": "現在只有4行幾個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/553.wav", + "text": "的是其他支持措施與協助" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/554.wav", + "text": "所以如果你們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/555.wav", + "text": "對於其他支持與協助是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/556.wav", + "text": "放入剛剛講到的幾個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/557.wav", + "text": "概念不管是對於" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/558.wav", + "text": "自立生活生活重建" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/559.wav", + "text": "同儕照顧支持者照顧" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/560.wav", + "text": "等等這些都" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/561.wav", + "text": "含在我剛剛講的立法說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/562.wav", + "text": "裡面我也看到你們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/563.wav", + "text": "就社區服務規劃分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/564.wav", + "text": "為個人照顧社會參與家庭支持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/565.wav", + "text": "社區支持的概念" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/566.wav", + "text": "輪廓其實滿清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/567.wav", + "text": "了剛剛司長也說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/568.wav", + "text": "內容所以一種方式是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/569.wav", + "text": "立法說明裡面把" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/570.wav", + "text": "所謂社區支持的概念" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/571.wav", + "text": "更明確化第二個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/572.wav", + "text": "就是像剛剛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/573.wav", + "text": "次長說的把社區" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/574.wav", + "text": "支持的內容再豐富" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/575.wav", + "text": "都大同小異但是如果沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/576.wav", + "text": "放入我覺得對於未來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/577.wav", + "text": "執行者包括地方政府" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/578.wav", + "text": "可能有大有小地方政府" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/579.wav", + "text": "的資源也不同所以我覺得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/580.wav", + "text": "這個還是要由中央" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/581.wav", + "text": "總體性地妥適" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/582.wav", + "text": "在修法文字裡面加" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/583.wav", + "text": "諸確認的概念會比較" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/584.wav", + "text": "周延以上\n現在請" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/585.wav", + "text": "說明第24條的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/586.wav", + "text": "之外剛剛王婉諭" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/587.wav", + "text": "精神危機前期積極" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/588.wav", + "text": "介入措施我的版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/589.wav", + "text": "也有剛剛還沒有機會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/590.wav", + "text": "講所以在王婉諭委員講完" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/591.wav", + "text": "之後我也呼應一下\n" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/592.wav", + "text": "CRPD國際審查的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/593.wav", + "text": "衛生出現需要照顧" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/594.wav", + "text": "的人得到常規的機會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/595.wav", + "text": "而且讓他們瞭解" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/596.wav", + "text": "行為管理或其他介入措施" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/597.wav", + "text": "公開的意見與建議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/598.wav", + "text": "有的方式還是比較傾向" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/599.wav", + "text": "讓人就醫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/600.wav", + "text": "吃藥或者是醫療化機構化" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/601.wav", + "text": "這個部分要學習其他國家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/602.wav", + "text": "的話不管現在能不能" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/603.wav", + "text": "夠做到位但有些概念應該" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/604.wav", + "text": "要開始做或是開始試做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/605.wav", + "text": "以澳洲的經驗來講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/606.wav", + "text": "跟急迫程度的差別" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/607.wav", + "text": "有時候危機只是一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/608.wav", + "text": "狀態現在發病不代表" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/609.wav", + "text": "一直都會發病" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/610.wav", + "text": "就積極介入措施" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/611.wav", + "text": "而且要有跨專業的團體" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/612.wav", + "text": "不是只有醫療" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/613.wav", + "text": "還包含社工心理警消" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/614.wav", + "text": "這是滿重要的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/615.wav", + "text": "所以其實衛福部在這次的修法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/616.wav", + "text": "上應該要有更多的社區介入" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/617.wav", + "text": "我想社區的部分大家都有概念" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/618.wav", + "text": "積極介入的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/619.wav", + "text": "衛福部是不是能夠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/620.wav", + "text": "進行針對全國性的試辦計畫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/621.wav", + "text": "或是等到心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/622.wav", + "text": "心衛中心社安網人力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/623.wav", + "text": "建置充足之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/624.wav", + "text": "往這個方向努力所以要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/625.wav", + "text": "放這個在這裡是這樣子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/626.wav", + "text": "不知道是什麼時候至少在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/627.wav", + "text": "這個時候概念可以清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/628.wav", + "text": "所以就條文的內容" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/629.wav", + "text": "前期積極介入的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/630.wav", + "text": "8頁中間那一欄民眾" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/631.wav", + "text": "黨團及委員等提案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/632.wav", + "text": "的部分那個部分就是我的提案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/633.wav", + "text": "文字上應該跟王婉諭委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/634.wav", + "text": "的條文接近度非常高" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/635.wav", + "text": "以上請參考謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/636.wav", + "text": "請洪申翰委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/637.wav", + "text": "我想講一下第7款" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/638.wav", + "text": "有關社區支持這些舉措" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/639.wav", + "text": "第一我覺得我們是不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/640.wav", + "text": "的事情是定義" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/641.wav", + "text": "如果今天國際" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/642.wav", + "text": "上面對社區支持的定義" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/643.wav", + "text": "是怎麼樣我認為就應該比照國際" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/644.wav", + "text": "嘛沒有道理說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/645.wav", + "text": "國際上對於社區支持是這個定義但是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/646.wav", + "text": "我們以後要怎麼跟大家討論范" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/647.wav", + "text": "范雲委員列的這些理念" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/648.wav", + "text": "這些內容有很多東西是來自於" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/649.wav", + "text": "之前CRPD的審查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/650.wav", + "text": "衛福部或" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/651.wav", + "text": "心理師如果要說哪些東西" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/652.wav", + "text": "不是請你指出現在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/653.wav", + "text": "哪些部分的內容" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/654.wav", + "text": "舉證啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/655.wav", + "text": "這些內容是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/656.wav", + "text": "來自CRPD也就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/657.wav", + "text": "的內容" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/658.wav", + "text": "他們認知這些內容是包括" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/659.wav", + "text": "在社區支持的範圍裡面這是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/660.wav", + "text": "定義" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/661.wav", + "text": "\n我們今天在談的第3條是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/662.wav", + "text": "定義現在不是談要做什麼事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/663.wav", + "text": "要做什麼事情是後面在講的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/664.wav", + "text": "什麼事情做得到什麼事情做不到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/665.wav", + "text": "哪些內容做得到哪些內容做不到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/666.wav", + "text": "那是後面在講的事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/667.wav", + "text": "\n但就定義來說這些事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/668.wav", + "text": "是不是包括在目前國際" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/669.wav", + "text": "通用最新的定義裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/670.wav", + "text": "有這方面的專業" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/671.wav", + "text": "可以告訴我如果覺得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/672.wav", + "text": "哪些內容並沒有包括在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/673.wav", + "text": "目前國際慣用的定義裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/674.wav", + "text": "就應該舉證讓大家知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/675.wav", + "text": "這不是喊價的事情啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/676.wav", + "text": "CRPD的社區支持是這些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/677.wav", + "text": "事項結果臺灣的社區支持只有裡面的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/678.wav", + "text": "三分之二這也很奇怪我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/679.wav", + "text": "接下來在開相關會議的時候這變成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/680.wav", + "text": "是一件奇怪的事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/681.wav", + "text": "但我們做得到哪些我覺得這可以在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/682.wav", + "text": "授權的條文裡面去談這個我同意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/683.wav", + "text": "\n但是定義就是定義" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/684.wav", + "text": "目前國際上面的標準和要求" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/685.wav", + "text": "有沒有包括范雲委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/686.wav", + "text": "第7項的條文所" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/687.wav", + "text": "匡列的這些內容是不是目前國際" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/688.wav", + "text": "慣用的定義如果是就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/689.wav", + "text": "如果不是這個我也不覺得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/690.wav", + "text": "是什麼立法理由的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/691.wav", + "text": "是就是不是就不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/692.wav", + "text": "如果有在裡面就在裡面不在裡面就不" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/693.wav", + "text": "在裡面今天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/694.wav", + "text": "大家提出來的內容是CRPD" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/695.wav", + "text": "的審查委員建議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/696.wav", + "text": "衛福部覺得不是就要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/697.wav", + "text": "提出明確的論證說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/698.wav", + "text": "這些事情不是在社區支持的範圍" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/699.wav", + "text": "裡面講清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/700.wav", + "text": "就這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/701.wav", + "text": "請吳玉琴委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/702.wav", + "text": "在這個討論裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/703.wav", + "text": "再來討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/704.wav", + "text": "精神危機前期" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/705.wav", + "text": "積極介入措施" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/706.wav", + "text": "如果後面沒有這些條文沒有這些文字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/707.wav", + "text": "在這裡做定義大概也很奇怪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/708.wav", + "text": "確實這個條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/709.wav", + "text": "可能是要最後審慎來討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/710.wav", + "text": "當然對於社區支持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/711.wav", + "text": "這件事這邊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/712.wav", + "text": "應該是要有一個簡易的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/713.wav", + "text": "社區支持的內涵" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/714.wav", + "text": "有不同的建議希望能夠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/715.wav", + "text": "具體的一" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/716.wav", + "text": "些服務措施所以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/717.wav", + "text": "范雲委員提的文字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/718.wav", + "text": "會更是一個具體條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/719.wav", + "text": "的內涵" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/720.wav", + "text": "剛剛諶司長提到第24條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/721.wav", + "text": "可能大家手上沒有相關資料" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/722.wav", + "text": "因為它是通過的條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/723.wav", + "text": "在第24條已經通過的條文是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/724.wav", + "text": "由中央主管機關來做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/725.wav", + "text": "相關的獎勵" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/726.wav", + "text": "服務措施的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/727.wav", + "text": "一些服務內涵服務方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/728.wav", + "text": "由中央來訂定子法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/729.wav", + "text": "的資料是針對協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/730.wav", + "text": "要處理的條文所以大家可能" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/731.wav", + "text": "的內涵是什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/732.wav", + "text": "這一條確實" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/733.wav", + "text": "很難有共識因為大家都希望" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/734.wav", + "text": "能夠放一些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/735.wav", + "text": "後面有沒有相關條文通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/736.wav", + "text": "做定義可能是很奇怪的請" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/737.wav", + "text": "徐志榮委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/738.wav", + "text": "因為我的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/739.wav", + "text": "修正動議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/740.wav", + "text": "跟林委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/741.wav", + "text": "大概雷同" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/742.wav", + "text": "所以我就有關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/743.wav", + "text": "\n我想心理疾病" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/744.wav", + "text": "發展" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/745.wav", + "text": "察覺心理不適以後在行為上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/746.wav", + "text": "有反映我們就是應該" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/747.wav", + "text": "這個應該也是社會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/748.wav", + "text": "達到的目標不要等到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/749.wav", + "text": "真的發生什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/750.wav", + "text": "嚴重的行為以後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/751.wav", + "text": "再花更多社會資源" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/752.wav", + "text": "來彌補這個後果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/753.wav", + "text": "超前部署" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/754.wav", + "text": "預防的意思" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/755.wav", + "text": "這是我對有關心理不適的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/756.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/757.wav", + "text": "再來先請" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/758.wav", + "text": "衛福部再說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/759.wav", + "text": "要不要把一些名詞" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/760.wav", + "text": "也納入定義新增" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/761.wav", + "text": "第7款" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/762.wav", + "text": "要寫到什麼程度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/763.wav", + "text": "然後要特別提醒" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/764.wav", + "text": "洪申翰委員講的那一部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/765.wav", + "text": "不同的定義" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/766.wav", + "text": "那會造成什麼樣的後果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/767.wav", + "text": "你們也要說明一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/768.wav", + "text": "問題我們很重要的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/769.wav", + "text": "是要讓病人可以平等地在社區生活" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/770.wav", + "text": "精神衛生法第1條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/771.wav", + "text": "就已經非常明確" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/772.wav", + "text": "促進人民心理健康" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/773.wav", + "text": "預防及治療" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/774.wav", + "text": "精神疾病保障病人權益" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/775.wav", + "text": "支持並協助病人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/776.wav", + "text": "於社區平等生活" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/777.wav", + "text": "特制定本法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/778.wav", + "text": "是不是還有必要在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/779.wav", + "text": "社區支持裡面再去闡明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/780.wav", + "text": "最主要的精神" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/781.wav", + "text": "就是我們希望能夠協助病人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/782.wav", + "text": "可以在社區平等生活" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/783.wav", + "text": "這是第一個說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/784.wav", + "text": "\n第二個部分有關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/785.wav", + "text": "社區支持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/786.wav", + "text": "病人在社區當中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/787.wav", + "text": "我們應該提供哪些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/788.wav", + "text": "服務的內涵" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/789.wav", + "text": "所謂社區支持的定義" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/790.wav", + "text": "因為那個就是希望能夠協助" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/791.wav", + "text": "病人在社區生活當中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/792.wav", + "text": "我們應該提供哪些服務" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/793.wav", + "text": "讓他可以平等地在社區當中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/794.wav", + "text": "生活現在是否" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/795.wav", + "text": "否要在名詞定義裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/796.wav", + "text": "寫得這麼清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/797.wav", + "text": "其實已經有闡明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/798.wav", + "text": "例如第23條已經闡明了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/799.wav", + "text": "剛剛提到的第24條是因為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/800.wav", + "text": "沒有出現是因為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/801.wav", + "text": "委員會通過的條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/802.wav", + "text": "都有一個授權辦法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/803.wav", + "text": "現在的定義裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/804.wav", + "text": "更積極的社會參與這個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/805.wav", + "text": "如果可以的話我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/806.wav", + "text": "可以把它納進來讓它" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/807.wav", + "text": "我們可以在名詞定義的就" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/808.wav", + "text": "頓號然後接社會參與" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/809.wav", + "text": "我們可以把它加進去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/810.wav", + "text": "我們也可以再把它" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/811.wav", + "text": "闡明得更加清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/812.wav", + "text": "我們接下來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/813.wav", + "text": "一定都會積極來做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/814.wav", + "text": "不只是社安網" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/815.wav", + "text": "其實我們現在都已經" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/816.wav", + "text": "公彩回饋金" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/817.wav", + "text": "還有相關的補助案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/818.wav", + "text": "有一些案都已經在積極地" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/819.wav", + "text": "對於相關的社區" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/820.wav", + "text": "支持服務我們一定會全力以赴" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/821.wav", + "text": "司長還有沒有補充" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/822.wav", + "text": "洪申翰委員發言" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/823.wav", + "text": "基本上我也認同剛剛洪申翰委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/824.wav", + "text": "講的其實這邊只是定義名詞" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/825.wav", + "text": "如果大家去查名稱" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/826.wav", + "text": "大概就是socialsupport或communitysupport" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/827.wav", + "text": "socialsupport有很多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/828.wav", + "text": "定義" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/829.wav", + "text": "communitysupport查不到很明確" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/830.wav", + "text": "的定義基本上就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/831.wav", + "text": "病人在社區生活的時候需要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/832.wav", + "text": "給他很多協助幫助他在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/833.wav", + "text": "社區生活簡單來講就是這樣\n" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/834.wav", + "text": "我再說明一下剛剛講的心理不適" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/835.wav", + "text": "其實我在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/836.wav", + "text": "就沒聽過什麼叫心理不適" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/837.wav", + "text": "它是一個不" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/838.wav", + "text": "愉快的感覺不舒服" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/839.wav", + "text": "這個名稱在專業上沒有人用過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/840.wav", + "text": "奇怪我們當然都瞭解這" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/841.wav", + "text": "就是覺得心裡不舒服" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/842.wav", + "text": "等等如果要把它寫成一個定義" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/843.wav", + "text": "其實真的滿為難的我也上網去查了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/844.wav", + "text": "一下全世界也沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/845.wav", + "text": "這樣的一個名稱可能" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/846.wav", + "text": "可以找到一兩篇paper" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/847.wav", + "text": "即psychological" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/848.wav", + "text": "discomfort除" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/849.wav", + "text": "此之外我也找不太到什麼太多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/850.wav", + "text": "可以參考的文獻所以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/851.wav", + "text": "我建議不要因為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/852.wav", + "text": "單純一個人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/853.wav", + "text": "或是一個老師的講法就把它" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/854.wav", + "text": "這樣真的是有點奇怪而且會不知道要幹什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/855.wav", + "text": "定義要弄到包山包海" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/856.wav", + "text": "強調一次要做什麼或不" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/857.wav", + "text": "做什麼那是後面的條文要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/858.wav", + "text": "去處理的問題定義" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/859.wav", + "text": "就是定義但今天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/860.wav", + "text": "目前提出來的理據是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/861.wav", + "text": "這是CRPD的委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/862.wav", + "text": "認為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/863.wav", + "text": "應該包括在社區支持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/864.wav", + "text": "理念中的這有它的理據" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/865.wav", + "text": "因為它是來自CRPD公約" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/866.wav", + "text": "委員的認知這是包括" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/867.wav", + "text": "在社區支持的範圍裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/868.wav", + "text": "也許衛福部一直在想的是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/869.wav", + "text": "中談到的社區支持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/870.wav", + "text": "包括哪些事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/871.wav", + "text": "如果今天我們把它" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/872.wav", + "text": "入法可能後面會有一個結果就" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/873.wav", + "text": "就是以後我們在講社區支持時可" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/874.wav", + "text": "可能要說對不起臺灣的社區支持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/875.wav", + "text": "沒有包括長期照顧" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/876.wav", + "text": "是不是有可能會這樣因為我們現在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/877.wav", + "text": "處理的是定義問題不是說你要不要做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/878.wav", + "text": "我們變得有可能要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/879.wav", + "text": "講沒有沒有臺灣版的社區支持沒包括" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/880.wav", + "text": "長期照護臺灣版的社區" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/881.wav", + "text": "支持沒包括什麼什麼反而" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/882.wav", + "text": "對不起來會不會出現" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/883.wav", + "text": "這個狀況所以我認為這件事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/884.wav", + "text": "假設今天范雲委員的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/885.wav", + "text": "論證作為基礎的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/886.wav", + "text": "它在國際上就有一定的正當性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/887.wav", + "text": "說我們不是這樣那就要提出" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/888.wav", + "text": "相對更清楚的佐證" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/889.wav", + "text": "我認為是這樣但我強調我" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/890.wav", + "text": "不是說定義該包山包海" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/891.wav", + "text": "的審查作為支持這部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/892.wav", + "text": "我覺得衛福部要想清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/893.wav", + "text": "要把能夠做什麼和有能力做什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/894.wav", + "text": "定義的問題請" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/895.wav", + "text": "請林奕華委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/896.wav", + "text": "我覺得剛剛司長有點情緒" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/897.wav", + "text": "了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/898.wav", + "text": "去討論條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/899.wav", + "text": "但你把心理不適" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/900.wav", + "text": "說成袂爽我覺得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/901.wav", + "text": "這是你自己的定義" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/902.wav", + "text": "為了避免污名化" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/903.wav", + "text": "名詞本來就可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/904.wav", + "text": "透過後面的文字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/905.wav", + "text": "我是選舉出身的我們都知道在社區裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/906.wav", + "text": "可能會發生問題的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/907.wav", + "text": "尤其我們現在好不容易把" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/908.wav", + "text": "心口司兩項業務分開" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/909.wav", + "text": "這個世紀大家要強調" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/910.wav", + "text": "健康的定義心理健康是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/911.wav", + "text": "多麼重要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/912.wav", + "text": "因此心理健康司的成立" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/913.wav", + "text": "本來就是要讓這件事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/914.wav", + "text": "邁進一大步" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/915.wav", + "text": "所以今天你告訴我心理健康司成立之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/916.wav", + "text": "心理健康不知道怎麼定義" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/917.wav", + "text": "個字要怎麼定義你跟我說無法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/918.wav", + "text": "定義" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/919.wav", + "text": "的內容裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/920.wav", + "text": "你在心理健康促進宣導" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/921.wav", + "text": "裡面還提到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/922.wav", + "text": "包括婦女心理健康促進" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/923.wav", + "text": "嬰幼兒心理健康促進青少年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/924.wav", + "text": "心理健康促進" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/925.wav", + "text": "注意力不足過動症心理健康促進" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/926.wav", + "text": "長者心理健康促進" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/927.wav", + "text": "疾病心理健康促進等等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/928.wav", + "text": "好多都是心理健康促進而" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/929.wav", + "text": "而你又告訴我心理健康促進無法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/930.wav", + "text": "司在做什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/931.wav", + "text": "當我們都已經在做的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/932.wav", + "text": "卻告訴我們心理健康和" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/933.wav", + "text": "心理健康促進無法定義" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/934.wav", + "text": "這個我沒辦法接受" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/935.wav", + "text": "心理健康" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/936.wav", + "text": "心理不適" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/937.wav", + "text": "心理健康促進三者本來就" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/938.wav", + "text": "這部分還是可以放在定義裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/939.wav", + "text": "有出現的文字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/940.wav", + "text": "我覺得要回過頭來再講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/941.wav", + "text": "一下我們認為還是可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/942.wav", + "text": "在定義裡面做相關的處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/943.wav", + "text": "因為蘇院長確診" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/944.wav", + "text": "隨時會停會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/945.wav", + "text": "我們暫時休息3分鐘" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/946.wav", + "text": "還沒有簽名的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/947.wav", + "text": "趕快去簽名" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/948.wav", + "text": "因為其他委員有說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/949.wav", + "text": "還沒簽到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/950.wav", + "text": "大概3分鐘就好我們3分鐘後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/951.wav", + "text": "繼續協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/952.wav", + "text": "各位委員的意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/953.wav", + "text": "我們今天協商到4點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/954.wav", + "text": "到4點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/955.wav", + "text": "反正我們在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/956.wav", + "text": "這個會期一定會讓這個完成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/957.wav", + "text": "一次協商沒完成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/958.wav", + "text": "我們會再次協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/959.wav", + "text": "然後還有院會的協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/960.wav", + "text": "希望這個會期確定能夠完成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/961.wav", + "text": "剛剛賴委員於私底下的協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/962.wav", + "text": "剛剛提的那個修正版本來討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/963.wav", + "text": "參照范雲委員的意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/964.wav", + "text": "他提了一個修正版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/965.wav", + "text": "先唸一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/966.wav", + "text": "那個建議修正版本的第7款" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/967.wav", + "text": "前面全部都" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/968.wav", + "text": "自立生活及其他支持措施與協助" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/969.wav", + "text": "居住安置就學及就養裡面其實都有了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/970.wav", + "text": "社會參與自立生活再加進來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/971.wav", + "text": "就有另外再規定了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/972.wav", + "text": "是不是社區支持我們可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/973.wav", + "text": "謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/974.wav", + "text": "請范委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/975.wav", + "text": "謝謝剛剛洪申翰委員的解方" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/976.wav", + "text": "我覺得那還是衛福部要去做的工作" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/977.wav", + "text": "剛剛次長講把社會參與" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/978.wav", + "text": "放在就醫之後這個我滿同意的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/979.wav", + "text": "一開始的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/980.wav", + "text": "協助病人於社區平等生活" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/981.wav", + "text": "了社區支持的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/982.wav", + "text": "可不可以開宗明義就寫指" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/983.wav", + "text": "指平等運用社區資源" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/984.wav", + "text": "因為你有一點點和平等那個部分還是差滿多的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/985.wav", + "text": "以上謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/986.wav", + "text": "等一下再請衛福部回應" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/987.wav", + "text": "但是心理健康和心理健康促進" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/988.wav", + "text": "要不要列為定義好像還是有不同的意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/989.wav", + "text": "林奕華委員那邊一直提到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/990.wav", + "text": "你們成立這個司獨立出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/991.wav", + "text": "最主要就是要促進心理健康" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/992.wav", + "text": "做心理健康的促進" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/993.wav", + "text": "結果針對你們這個宗旨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/994.wav", + "text": "反而沒有一個定義" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/995.wav", + "text": "他也覺得很奇怪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/996.wav", + "text": "所以這一點大家會有共識嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/997.wav", + "text": "有沒有共識" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/998.wav", + "text": "心理健康促進" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/999.wav", + "text": "從英文的mentalhealthpromotion翻譯過來的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1000.wav", + "text": "其實它的範圍並不是只有中文心理健康促進的概念而已" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1001.wav", + "text": "我們以心理健康司\n為名也是妥協下的說法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1002.wav", + "text": "在大陸是翻譯成精神健康" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1003.wav", + "text": "所以它的範圍更廣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1004.wav", + "text": "並不只是心理健康而已" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1005.wav", + "text": "包含整個疾病的照顧都在裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1006.wav", + "text": "所以它比較廣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1007.wav", + "text": "我們這邊寫心理健康容易落入" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1008.wav", + "text": "只是很單純地感覺良好叫做心理健康" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1009.wav", + "text": "範圍比較窄" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1010.wav", + "text": "所以對於這邊要寫心理健康和" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1011.wav", + "text": "和心理健康促進的定義" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1012.wav", + "text": "我們並不是很贊成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1013.wav", + "text": "也沒有什麼具體措施可以採行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1014.wav", + "text": "採行當初我們會強調這個部分只是比較偏倡議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1015.wav", + "text": "然後以逐年增加內涵的概念來做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1016.wav", + "text": "其實還是做不到什麼東西" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1017.wav", + "text": "而要寫或不寫其實我們沒有絕對的意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1018.wav", + "text": "只是覺得不是很適合" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1019.wav", + "text": "至於心理不適我們是完全反對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1020.wav", + "text": "實際上包括在臨床方面都沒有這樣的用法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1021.wav", + "text": "人家看到也不知道那是什麼東西" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1022.wav", + "text": "就是有點奇怪因" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1023.wav", + "text": "對於心理健康或心理健康促進" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1024.wav", + "text": "要不要放到名詞定義裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1025.wav", + "text": "這個部分就先行保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1026.wav", + "text": "我們繼續往下討" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1027.wav", + "text": "第7款的部分好像比較有一些進展" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1028.wav", + "text": "我們回頭的時候再來處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1029.wav", + "text": "是不是要達成共識" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1030.wav", + "text": "讓第3條部分通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1031.wav", + "text": "以條為單位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1032.wav", + "text": "沒關係啦我們先有這樣的共識" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1033.wav", + "text": "當回頭處理第3條的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1034.wav", + "text": "我們知道第7款" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1035.wav", + "text": "大家已經比較有一個共識" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1036.wav", + "text": "但是對於要不要增加" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1037.wav", + "text": "心理健康心理健康促進" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1038.wav", + "text": "的部分大家是有歧異" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1039.wav", + "text": "的我們第二輪回頭的時候再來處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1040.wav", + "text": "第4條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1041.wav", + "text": "先請衛福部說明一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1042.wav", + "text": "建議修正版和原來的院版" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1043.wav", + "text": "有什麼樣的差異" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1044.wav", + "text": "現在還有爭議的部分在哪裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1045.wav", + "text": "特別和以前不一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1046.wav", + "text": "第6款當中病人醫療服務" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1047.wav", + "text": "第8款部分第二行長期照顧與" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1048.wav", + "text": "大致是這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1049.wav", + "text": "其他矛盾的地方" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1050.wav", + "text": "或大家意見不一的地方並沒有太多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1051.wav", + "text": "以上跟大家報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1052.wav", + "text": "各位委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1053.wav", + "text": "他們這個版本又修正過了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1054.wav", + "text": "就是委員會出來以後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1055.wav", + "text": "他們在考量各個版本之後做的修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1056.wav", + "text": "社區支持服務之規劃及推動" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1057.wav", + "text": "所以這個社區支持服務的政策" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1058.wav", + "text": "包括資源布建" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1059.wav", + "text": "還有一些方案規劃" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1060.wav", + "text": "這是中央的權責" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1061.wav", + "text": "還是是一個什麼樣的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1062.wav", + "text": "因為剛剛講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1063.wav", + "text": "到如果社區照顧包含社區參與" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1064.wav", + "text": "生活重建與自立生活等等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1065.wav", + "text": "放在第8款" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1066.wav", + "text": "還需不需要把社區支持的資源布建" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1067.wav", + "text": "列為一個單項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1068.wav", + "text": "作為中央主管機關的權責" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1069.wav", + "text": "基本上我們是政策規劃推動" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1070.wav", + "text": "執行面還是在地方" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1071.wav", + "text": "就是有關地方權責的規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1072.wav", + "text": "我們則主要是在整個大的政策規劃方面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1073.wav", + "text": "所以社區支持的資源" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1074.wav", + "text": "如果有布建政策法規方案之規劃" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1075.wav", + "text": "也是中央的權限" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1076.wav", + "text": "是把社區支持的資源布建單" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1077.wav", + "text": "第一個是心理健康促進政策" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1078.wav", + "text": "第二個是精神疾病預防治療與相關的政策" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1079.wav", + "text": "再來就進到病人權益保障" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1080.wav", + "text": "所以我的修正動議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1081.wav", + "text": "社區支持的資源布建政策法規方案之規劃" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1082.wav", + "text": "訂定及宣導" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1083.wav", + "text": "其他部分跟你們的版本類似" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1084.wav", + "text": "是不是要在主管機關的職掌裡明確" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1085.wav", + "text": "不然我看現在第4條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1086.wav", + "text": "中央主管機關的掌理事項中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1087.wav", + "text": "也沒有特定性的處理社區支持這個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1088.wav", + "text": "以上說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1089.wav", + "text": "我的意見其實跟賴委員接近" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1090.wav", + "text": "討論時我們有提出修正動議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1091.wav", + "text": "這個檔案又回到我們第一次版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1092.wav", + "text": "後面有一個第3款" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1093.wav", + "text": "建議將社區支持資源布建的相關部分納入" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1094.wav", + "text": "原因就在於" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1095.wav", + "text": "當我們看待這個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1096.wav", + "text": "時包括剛才一再提到的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1097.wav", + "text": "一個是心理健康促進" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1098.wav", + "text": "一個是精神疾病的防治" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1099.wav", + "text": "這些都是我們持續要努力的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1100.wav", + "text": "我們還是希望能夠在主管事項裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1101.wav", + "text": "尤其是放在前三項裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1102.wav", + "text": "的也希望得到大家的支持\n" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1103.wav", + "text": "我們其實沒有看到比較細項的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1104.wav", + "text": "所以請教衛福部未來這個病人服務的意涵" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1105.wav", + "text": "會以什麼方式制定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1106.wav", + "text": "第5條我們就等審查第5條時再討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1107.wav", + "text": "針對賴香伶委員及王婉諭委員提的意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1108.wav", + "text": "請衛福部說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1109.wav", + "text": "都知道社區支持範圍很大" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1110.wav", + "text": "事實上在我們提出的第4條中包" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1111.wav", + "text": "第10款是病人家庭" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1112.wav", + "text": "都是對病人本身的社區支持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1113.wav", + "text": "如果我們要把它變成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1114.wav", + "text": "就要有個第3款" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1115.wav", + "text": "有可能我們會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1116.wav", + "text": "可是就沒有第8款及第9款" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1117.wav", + "text": "因為這兩款是社區支持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1118.wav", + "text": "這個部分是比較細項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1119.wav", + "text": "用什麼方式會比較好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1120.wav", + "text": "這個部分我們沒有很堅持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1121.wav", + "text": "就是看要怎麼樣去呈現" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1122.wav", + "text": "我覺得次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1123.wav", + "text": "次長這樣說更可以彰顯" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1124.wav", + "text": "第3款是放在前頭" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1125.wav", + "text": "並涉及中央權責" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1126.wav", + "text": "都在做社區支持的規劃及推動" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1127.wav", + "text": "資源布建" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1128.wav", + "text": "所以我很希望衛福部要爭取" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1129.wav", + "text": "自己在第3款" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1130.wav", + "text": "加入我們講的即源頭上的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1131.wav", + "text": "一個政策資源布建的態度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1132.wav", + "text": "很多地方都可以看到社區支持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1133.wav", + "text": "但是各地方怎麼做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1134.wav", + "text": "資源到不到位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1135.wav", + "text": "中央怎麼補助地方" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1136.wav", + "text": "這些都在你的角色上面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1137.wav", + "text": "就是社區融入" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1138.wav", + "text": "回歸社區之上位概念" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1139.wav", + "text": "嘛所以我希望次長可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1140.wav", + "text": "接受增列第3款也" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1141.wav", + "text": "甚至第7款都有寫到社區支持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1142.wav", + "text": "這是我的建議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1143.wav", + "text": "請王婉諭委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1144.wav", + "text": "發言等一下再請衛福部回答" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1145.wav", + "text": "我也認為增加第3款" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1146.wav", + "text": "其實並不影響到後面的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1147.wav", + "text": "會提到心理衛生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1148.wav", + "text": "或是精神疾病的調查等等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1149.wav", + "text": "難道不也涵蓋在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1150.wav", + "text": "第一款或第二款裡面嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1151.wav", + "text": "前面的大方向這三個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1152.wav", + "text": "是剛才提到的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1153.wav", + "text": "然後後面還有哪些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1154.wav", + "text": "要處理的部分也一併納入" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1155.wav", + "text": "所以增加第3款" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1156.wav", + "text": "並不會影響到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1157.wav", + "text": "款即便是如此" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1158.wav", + "text": "剛剛提到要併起來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1159.wav", + "text": "其他後面好幾項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1160.wav", + "text": "報告一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1161.wav", + "text": "基本上寫在這邊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1162.wav", + "text": "就是代表我們中央政府" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1163.wav", + "text": "要做的事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1164.wav", + "text": "不管它是放在哪一款" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1165.wav", + "text": "其實現在的體例都只是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1166.wav", + "text": "要去做的都是規劃及推動" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1167.wav", + "text": "在這部分就包括" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1168.wav", + "text": "我們要做整體的政策規劃" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1169.wav", + "text": "以及相關的資源布建並" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1170.wav", + "text": "並且去推動" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1171.wav", + "text": "有一個什麼方案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1172.wav", + "text": "以及有多少經費" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1173.wav", + "text": "可是是由地方去執行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1174.wav", + "text": "這跟放在哪一款" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1175.wav", + "text": "其實是沒有關係的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1176.wav", + "text": "只是說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1177.wav", + "text": "如果我們現在還是要把" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1178.wav", + "text": "再另外設一款的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1179.wav", + "text": "它勢必跟其他的內涵" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1180.wav", + "text": "還是會有一些重疊的地方" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1181.wav", + "text": "如果是這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1182.wav", + "text": "的話我們可能就必須再去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1183.wav", + "text": "做一些酌修" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1184.wav", + "text": "然後在社區支持內涵外的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1185.wav", + "text": "還有哪些部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1186.wav", + "text": "不然到最後真的有一些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1187.wav", + "text": "內涵彼此會互相涵蓋的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1188.wav", + "text": "所以這個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1189.wav", + "text": "再跟委員做說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1190.wav", + "text": "請吳玉琴委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1191.wav", + "text": "我想補充一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1192.wav", + "text": "有規定精神疾病預防" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1193.wav", + "text": "治療與資源布建" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1194.wav", + "text": "建政策法規方案之規劃" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1195.wav", + "text": "訂定及宣導" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1196.wav", + "text": "其實這裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1197.wav", + "text": "而資源布建" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1198.wav", + "text": "應該不會只有機構式的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1199.wav", + "text": "包括社區式的資源布建" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1200.wav", + "text": "都應該含括在這樣的概念裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1201.wav", + "text": "剛剛次長也特別提到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1202.wav", + "text": "第8款" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1203.wav", + "text": "服務的規劃及推動" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1204.wav", + "text": "還有第9款的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1205.wav", + "text": "病人社會參與及" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1206.wav", + "text": "自立生活的規劃及推動" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1207.wav", + "text": "至於要怎麼寫大概的意義" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1208.wav", + "text": "就是資源布建" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1209.wav", + "text": "一定是中央要去做規劃而" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1210.wav", + "text": "而執行是在地方" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1211.wav", + "text": "地方一定比較是協助" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1212.wav", + "text": "將這些政策做執行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1213.wav", + "text": "沒有說一定要怎麼修" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1214.wav", + "text": "衛福部在文字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1215.wav", + "text": "上應該是有放" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1216.wav", + "text": "放進去了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1217.wav", + "text": "沒有漏掉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1218.wav", + "text": "大家看起來好像" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1219.wav", + "text": "沒有明列出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1220.wav", + "text": "可是事實上資源布建" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1221.wav", + "text": "應該在第2款" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1222.wav", + "text": "已經有列舉了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1223.wav", + "text": "我想從幾個角度來看這件事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1224.wav", + "text": "其實我們可以看到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1225.wav", + "text": "不管是院長也好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1226.wav", + "text": "或是總統也好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1227.wav", + "text": "他們在一些相關的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1228.wav", + "text": "政策文告當中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1229.wav", + "text": "當中提到社區的頻率" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1230.wav", + "text": "看起來社區是一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1231.wav", + "text": "如果從這個角度來講的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1232.wav", + "text": "現在我們在討論的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1233.wav", + "text": "社區支持資源布建之規劃與政策" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1234.wav", + "text": "我認為絕對是一件" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1235.wav", + "text": "在基本的態度上我會認為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1236.wav", + "text": "布建政策凸顯出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1237.wav", + "text": "或是把它清楚地寫出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1238.wav", + "text": "我認為這是一件對的事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1239.wav", + "text": "但我自己也清楚知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1240.wav", + "text": "衛福部在這件事情上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1241.wav", + "text": "為難的地方" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1242.wav", + "text": "社區變得這麼重要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1243.wav", + "text": "但請問社區的主管機關是誰" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1244.wav", + "text": "\n社區資源的主管單位是誰" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1245.wav", + "text": "這件事情對衛福部來說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1246.wav", + "text": "非常為難的地方" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1247.wav", + "text": "所以如果真的要落實到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1248.wav", + "text": "現在越來越進步的觀念" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1249.wav", + "text": "也就是對於社區和社區支持概念的同時" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1250.wav", + "text": "在社區裡運作資源布建的更大權限" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1251.wav", + "text": "或是衛福部要去找內政部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1252.wav", + "text": "溝通獲得對於社區裡面的事務" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1253.wav", + "text": "如果衛福部一直以來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1254.wav", + "text": "都沒有辦法清楚成為統整社區" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1255.wav", + "text": "所有相關事務和資源的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1256.wav", + "text": "坦白說不論我們在文字裡面怎麼寫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1257.wav", + "text": "都會打一個滿大的折扣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1258.wav", + "text": "以上是我對於剛剛的討論所提" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1259.wav", + "text": "的幾個思考意見謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1260.wav", + "text": "有這個問題嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1261.wav", + "text": "洪申翰委員剛才提到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1262.wav", + "text": "會不會造成主管機關的混淆" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1263.wav", + "text": "或是你們在執行上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1264.wav", + "text": "會有什麼困難" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1265.wav", + "text": "這部分等一下請一併回答其實" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1266.wav", + "text": "其實現在的爭點很簡單也就是關於" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1267.wav", + "text": "社區支持相關的資源布建規劃" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1268.wav", + "text": "等等這樣的條文要不要把它拉到前三款" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1269.wav", + "text": "的修正版本裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1270.wav", + "text": "這到底有什麼差異或是會不會造成執行上的困難" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1271.wav", + "text": "主席對不起我講的不是權責上的混淆" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1272.wav", + "text": "我覺得他們現在遇到的問題是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1273.wav", + "text": "在社區裡面的授權是不足的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1274.wav", + "text": "都會討論到社區支持的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1275.wav", + "text": "就我自己的立場而言我支持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1276.wav", + "text": "應該儘量把社區的概念凸顯出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1277.wav", + "text": "但現況是衛福部在社區裡面的授權是不足的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1278.wav", + "text": "這件事情很容易讓他們在實質上的執行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1279.wav", + "text": "與條文上的要求出現落差" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1280.wav", + "text": "這個問題我們必須設法加以克服" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1281.wav", + "text": "如果不克服這件事情不論在條文上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1282.wav", + "text": "怎麼寫到時候法律執行下去一樣會出現落差" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1283.wav", + "text": "我在講的事情是文字上的進步性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1284.wav", + "text": "與實質上他們在權責分工授權分配的狀況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1285.wav", + "text": "出現了一個根本性的落差" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1286.wav", + "text": "這個落差我們必須想辦法克服" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1287.wav", + "text": "請衛福部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1288.wav", + "text": "可是我們過去其實勉強做一點點做了十幾年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1289.wav", + "text": "現在在往2.0我們才開始正式去布建社區心衛中心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1290.wav", + "text": "在沒有這個社區心衛中心的前提底下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1291.wav", + "text": "當然我們社政單位也做了很多社區" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1292.wav", + "text": "沒有排斥精神病人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1293.wav", + "text": "那是因為過去我們在社區的布建是很少的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1294.wav", + "text": "沒有資源的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1295.wav", + "text": "沒有社區心衛中心個案根本找不到資源" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1296.wav", + "text": "即使有資源個案也不知道資源在哪裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1297.wav", + "text": "所以才會需要有社區心衛中心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1298.wav", + "text": "用個案管理的方式來協助個案取得資源" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1299.wav", + "text": "這也是為什麼今天大家在提很多社區資源的重要性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1300.wav", + "text": "這個重要性我們都認同" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1301.wav", + "text": "只是大家如果直接拿國外的現狀來看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1302.wav", + "text": "或者CRPD的委員看國外的經驗用臺灣的實務來比" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1303.wav", + "text": "\n所以我們剛剛在談這件事情的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1304.wav", + "text": "方向上我們都很贊成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1305.wav", + "text": "只是那個距離還很遙遠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1306.wav", + "text": "感覺大家一直在談很雲端的目標及方向" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1307.wav", + "text": "但是我們連簡單的都還沒做到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1308.wav", + "text": "我的感受比較是這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1309.wav", + "text": "把它提到第3款來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1310.wav", + "text": "等於是凸顯它的重要性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1311.wav", + "text": "這樣對你們推動心衛中心也好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1312.wav", + "text": "還是你覺得這樣反而沒幫助" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1313.wav", + "text": "等一下你再回答" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1314.wav", + "text": "剛剛洪申翰委員講的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1315.wav", + "text": "其實有一點點彰顯我們這個階段" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1316.wav", + "text": "因為我們落後別的國家60年是不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1317.wav", + "text": "要讓它慢慢起來還是怎麼樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1318.wav", + "text": "可是至少我們現在看到的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1319.wav", + "text": "是如果你去看WHO" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1320.wav", + "text": "關於MentalHealth今年的報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1321.wav", + "text": "其中載明現在政府要做的MentalHealth" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1322.wav", + "text": "社區為中心的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1323.wav", + "text": "而不是再回到醫療機構等等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1324.wav", + "text": "當大家都覺得這個是重點的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1325.wav", + "text": "我們現在強調它才是一個最好的做法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1326.wav", + "text": "因為別人也試了這麼久" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1327.wav", + "text": "我們現在應該把它放在更重要的位置" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1328.wav", + "text": "每個地方的發展是不一樣的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1329.wav", + "text": "如果中央不能做好的規劃" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1330.wav", + "text": "大家在態度上觀念上要非常地清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1331.wav", + "text": "這個以社區Community-Based的approach" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1332.wav", + "text": "我覺得也許在這裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1333.wav", + "text": "可以在順序上或怎麼樣能夠反映出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1334.wav", + "text": "以上謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1335.wav", + "text": "謝謝主席" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1336.wav", + "text": "我想多位委員都很支持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1337.wav", + "text": "現在能夠在立法的周延性上面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1338.wav", + "text": "賦予社區支持這樣的上位概念" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1339.wav", + "text": "是由衛福部統整" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1340.wav", + "text": "我確實不確定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1341.wav", + "text": "衛福部是不是在社區的角色上面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1342.wav", + "text": "力有未逮以至於因為暫時無法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1343.wav", + "text": "達成所以不以法律的方式來明確化" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1344.wav", + "text": "社區心衛中心必須要滿足" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1345.wav", + "text": "滿足現在非常多找不到資源" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1346.wav", + "text": "不得其門而入" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1347.wav", + "text": "甚至不知如何求助" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1348.wav", + "text": "我覺得這不影響你們正在做的事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1349.wav", + "text": "只是讓它在立法上面除了在順位上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1350.wav", + "text": "第一你們的核心還是為了心理健康促進" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1351.wav", + "text": "第二你們對於精神疾病的預防治療" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1352.wav", + "text": "本來醫政體系" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1353.wav", + "text": "社政就業勞動體系都已經加入了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1354.wav", + "text": "還包括剛剛提到尚未完成的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1355.wav", + "text": "所以我覺得它當然不是只for" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1356.wav", + "text": "精神病友的支持體系" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1357.wav", + "text": "因此才需要你們用資源布建的政策法規" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1358.wav", + "text": "你也比較知道全民心理健康的趨勢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1359.wav", + "text": "對於你們做的規劃地方也可以依循來做介入及協助" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1360.wav", + "text": "所以我還是支持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1361.wav", + "text": "其次你們自己在立法說明裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1362.wav", + "text": "也已經很強調社區服務的內涵" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1363.wav", + "text": "對於你們在立法說明所講的內容我都很贊成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1364.wav", + "text": "所以我相信你們已經準備好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1365.wav", + "text": "跟你們放入第8款或第9款" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1366.wav", + "text": "我覺得這在強度上是不同的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1367.wav", + "text": "院長又確診" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1368.wav", + "text": "我們更應該在完成修法上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1369.wav", + "text": "更進一步讓社區工作者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1370.wav", + "text": "的心裡面更確定和踏實" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1371.wav", + "text": "我們願意為這件事達成共識" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1372.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1373.wav", + "text": "我再說明一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1374.wav", + "text": "真的很謝謝我知道委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1375.wav", + "text": "真的很關心我們在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1376.wav", + "text": "社區支持的整體布建" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1377.wav", + "text": "以及中央要承擔起這樣的責任" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1378.wav", + "text": "目前我們確實也是這樣在做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1379.wav", + "text": "我現在要跟委員說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1380.wav", + "text": "中央主管機關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1381.wav", + "text": "中央主管機關就是我們衛福部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1382.wav", + "text": "就是衛政和社政要做的事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1383.wav", + "text": "剛剛講到有就學就業" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1384.wav", + "text": "有跟委員說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1385.wav", + "text": "這個授權辦法還要會同" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1386.wav", + "text": "中央勞動及教育主管機關來定之" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1387.wav", + "text": "也就是說社會支持的範圍" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1388.wav", + "text": "會大過於主管機關的業務" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1389.wav", + "text": "第24條已經都有寫到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1390.wav", + "text": "中央主管機關要會同" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1391.wav", + "text": "勞動及教育主管機關來訂定了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1392.wav", + "text": "我們中央一定會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1393.wav", + "text": "確實來擔負起這樣一個責任" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1394.wav", + "text": "在這邊再跟委員做說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1395.wav", + "text": "謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1396.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1397.wav", + "text": "條文保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1398.wav", + "text": "第4條保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1399.wav", + "text": "在第15頁" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1400.wav", + "text": "第5條是地方主管機關的權責" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1401.wav", + "text": "但是是地方主管機關的權責" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1402.wav", + "text": "我們在第5條後面還有寫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1403.wav", + "text": "應視需要整合衛生社政教育勞政警政消防及其他相關資源" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1404.wav", + "text": "所以你們經過修正的版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1405.wav", + "text": "跟原來版本的差異" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1406.wav", + "text": "差異的部分就跟上面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1407.wav", + "text": "剛剛第4條的部分一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1408.wav", + "text": "對把一些比較敏感的字眼拿掉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1409.wav", + "text": "第2項就寫得比較完整" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1410.wav", + "text": "第1項第5款病人醫療" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1411.wav", + "text": "這兩個字去掉就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1412.wav", + "text": "不只醫療" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1413.wav", + "text": "還包括其他" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1414.wav", + "text": "只有在這兩方面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1415.wav", + "text": "會不會有跟第4條一樣的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1416.wav", + "text": "有要特別強調" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1417.wav", + "text": "同樣的問題嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1418.wav", + "text": "我們版本中第4條和第5條的配合" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1419.wav", + "text": "就是希望中央涉及到的是政策法規方案之規劃制定及宣導" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1420.wav", + "text": "地方當然就是執行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1421.wav", + "text": "還有部分的規劃" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1422.wav", + "text": "的占比及角色應該也不是主" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1423.wav", + "text": "要的所以我不確定剛剛次長是覺得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1424.wav", + "text": "對你們會比較好還是比較不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1425.wav", + "text": "其他單位都在你們是不是也發表一下你們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1426.wav", + "text": "在整個社區支持方案裡面的角色" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1427.wav", + "text": "我希望為了國家整體的運行上面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1428.wav", + "text": "能夠讓權責分工資源效益" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1429.wav", + "text": "的綜效提升" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1430.wav", + "text": "對你們沒有增加真正的作法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1431.wav", + "text": "我們沒有很堅持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1432.wav", + "text": "但我覺得要討論清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1433.wav", + "text": "是不是有這個問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1434.wav", + "text": "如果有這個問題在立法例上面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1435.wav", + "text": "其他部會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1436.wav", + "text": "有沒有意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1437.wav", + "text": "因為內政部還會牽涉到警政消防那一塊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1438.wav", + "text": "請警政消防直接說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1439.wav", + "text": "警政" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1440.wav", + "text": "主席" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1441.wav", + "text": "各位委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1442.wav", + "text": "內政部警政署報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1443.wav", + "text": "有關剛剛衛福部所講的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1444.wav", + "text": "有關警政消防的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1445.wav", + "text": "分我們本於國家的行政" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1446.wav", + "text": "我們都全力配合" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1447.wav", + "text": "警政署的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1448.wav", + "text": "本法當中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1449.wav", + "text": "都有列舉警察單位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1450.wav", + "text": "及消防單位所應該要盡的職責" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1451.wav", + "text": "最主要是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1452.wav", + "text": "維持治安" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1453.wav", + "text": "這是我們二大主軸" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1454.wav", + "text": "至於其他行政協助事項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1455.wav", + "text": "我們也是很樂意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1456.wav", + "text": "從法條來看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1457.wav", + "text": "在這部法裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1458.wav", + "text": "裡面已經有6條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1459.wav", + "text": "是警政署要做的事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1460.wav", + "text": "我想沒有問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1461.wav", + "text": "等一下��們就會碰到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1462.wav", + "text": "直接跟他們相關的條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1463.wav", + "text": "在我們委員會討論的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1464.wav", + "text": "其實這一點討論的滿多的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1465.wav", + "text": "他們就是要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1466.wav", + "text": "完全配合執行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1467.wav", + "text": "他們的配合" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1468.wav", + "text": "沒有問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1469.wav", + "text": "主要重點在於第4條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1470.wav", + "text": "因為地方其實是在執行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1471.wav", + "text": "規劃宣導" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1472.wav", + "text": "所以我認為第5條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1473.wav", + "text": "就不一定要像第4條這樣處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1474.wav", + "text": "有關第3款的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1475.wav", + "text": "我們還是尊重大家的意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1476.wav", + "text": "第4款已經保留了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1477.wav", + "text": "對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1478.wav", + "text": "第4條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1479.wav", + "text": "已經保留了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1480.wav", + "text": "第4條第3款" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1481.wav", + "text": "是一樣的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1482.wav", + "text": "只差在政策和法規" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1483.wav", + "text": "所以你就保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1484.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1485.wav", + "text": "剛才有提到病人服務的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1486.wav", + "text": "要涵蓋到哪裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1487.wav", + "text": "請衛福部回答一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1488.wav", + "text": "我們會有一些疑慮" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1489.wav", + "text": "相關專業人員的培訓規劃" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1490.wav", + "text": "和訓練部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1491.wav", + "text": "我稍微說明一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1492.wav", + "text": "地方主管機關病人服務" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1493.wav", + "text": "指的是比較廣泛的定義" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1494.wav", + "text": "並沒有特別針對什麼事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1495.wav", + "text": "大部分還是以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1496.wav", + "text": "或是一些醫事機構" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1497.wav", + "text": "為主\n其實在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1498.wav", + "text": "精神衛生和心理衛生的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1499.wav", + "text": "發展過程中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1500.wav", + "text": "每個階段的對象都不一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1501.wav", + "text": "就像我們以前會補助" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1502.wav", + "text": "醫院設立病床" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1503.wav", + "text": "完全不獎助這件事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1504.wav", + "text": "完全不會再去補助他們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1505.wav", + "text": "重點都在社區支持的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1506.wav", + "text": "所以我們補助的對象" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1507.wav", + "text": "也都比較偏向社區支持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1508.wav", + "text": "社區服務的對象所以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1509.wav", + "text": "所以它只是個通則性的說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1510.wav", + "text": "因為第5條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1511.wav", + "text": "和第4條都有同樣的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1512.wav", + "text": "要把社區支持這部分的條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1513.wav", + "text": "拉到第3款來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1514.wav", + "text": "既然是同樣的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1515.wav", + "text": "\n接著處理第8條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1516.wav", + "text": "主要講的是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1517.wav", + "text": "內政主管機關要做的事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1518.wav", + "text": "上次協商過後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1519.wav", + "text": "建議下面淡黃色的字眼就" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1520.wav", + "text": "是主管機關內政部所提出來的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1521.wav", + "text": "只有一個地方要修改這是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1522.wav", + "text": "過去這段時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1523.wav", + "text": "有些委員提出的建議即" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1524.wav", + "text": "倒數第三行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1525.wav", + "text": "的協助護送就醫前面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1526.wav", + "text": "應該要加一個應\n" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1527.wav", + "text": "這邊是不是要加應" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1528.wav", + "text": "可能要請大家來討論一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1529.wav", + "text": "只是加了應\n會變得更清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1530.wav", + "text": "這個修正版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1531.wav", + "text": "這個是第2項增列的文字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1532.wav", + "text": "然後第1項裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1533.wav", + "text": "也有把心理諮商加進去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1534.wav", + "text": "所以好像是更積極的意思" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1535.wav", + "text": "\n各位委員有沒有其他意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1536.wav", + "text": "沒有的話我們就按照這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1537.wav", + "text": "警政署有關是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1538.wav", + "text": "警政署有什麼意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1539.wav", + "text": "第2項是委員會出來以後再加的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1540.wav", + "text": "你也不能推翻第1項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1541.wav", + "text": "後來增加在第2項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1542.wav", + "text": "第2項的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1543.wav", + "text": "但是剛剛衛福部講的應的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1544.wav", + "text": "既然前面已經有必要時" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1545.wav", + "text": "而且後面像第53條第49條中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1546.wav", + "text": "他要做什麼事情規定得很清楚因" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1547.wav", + "text": "必要時協助醫護護送就醫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1548.wav", + "text": "果是用應好像會比較強硬一點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1549.wav", + "text": "在後面的條文規定得很清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1550.wav", + "text": "法律條文也是很清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1551.wav", + "text": "所以我建議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1552.wav", + "text": "為於必要時協助護送就醫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1553.wav", + "text": "後面文字都是一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1554.wav", + "text": "主席我的看法是這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1555.wav", + "text": "因為前面已經是於必要時" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1556.wav", + "text": "所以就覺得好像也" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1557.wav", + "text": "拿掉而且我覺得建議版本上都有了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1558.wav", + "text": "現在變成建議版本上有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1559.wav", + "text": "卻要立法院同意把應字拿掉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1560.wav", + "text": "好像變成是我們的態度變得比較消極" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1561.wav", + "text": "因為現在是立法院要通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1562.wav", + "text": "建議版本上已經把應字放上去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1563.wav", + "text": "現在又要我們立委同意把應字拿掉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1564.wav", + "text": "我認為不妥" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1565.wav", + "text": "也是支持院版的修正版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1566.wav", + "text": "就是用原本的必要時" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1567.wav", + "text": "應協助護送就醫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1568.wav", + "text": "既然這就是希望能夠強調" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1569.wav", + "text": "他有這樣的責任以及在必要的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1570.wav", + "text": "也應該要去做的情況下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1571.wav", + "text": "原本法條的寫法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1572.wav", + "text": "\n既然他本來就已經會做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1573.wav", + "text": "而且也應該要做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1574.wav", + "text": "請吳玉琴委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1575.wav", + "text": "後面的第49條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1576.wav", + "text": "其實裡面很多都已經是寫應了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1577.wav", + "text": "對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1578.wav", + "text": "所以不用再計較要不要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1579.wav", + "text": "確後面的第49條都呼應了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1580.wav", + "text": "衛福部也同意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1581.wav", + "text": "嘛第2項的文字是你們擬的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1582.wav", + "text": "按照衛福部建議的修正版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1583.wav", + "text": "協商通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1584.wav", + "text": "他們提出來的版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1585.wav", + "text": "\n好處理下一條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1586.wav", + "text": "第8條的附帶決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1587.wav", + "text": "最後才處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1588.wav", + "text": "附帶決議都最後才處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1589.wav", + "text": "我們我們有宣告後面才處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1590.wav", + "text": "請王委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1591.wav", + "text": "上次審查的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1592.wav", + "text": "我們的意見是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1593.wav", + "text": "如果附帶決議通過之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1594.wav", + "text": "用附帶決議來處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1595.wav", + "text": "我們就同意第8條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1596.wav", + "text": "現在如果第8條先通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1597.wav", + "text": "之後再來處理全部的附帶決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1598.wav", + "text": "有可能那個附帶決議還是不會通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1599.wav", + "text": "上一次協商的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1600.wav", + "text": "我們就已經提到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1601.wav", + "text": "我們有提一個附帶決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1602.wav", + "text": "如果在那個附帶決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1603.wav", + "text": "可以通過的前提下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1604.wav", + "text": "把一些東西" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1605.wav", + "text": "我們就支持院版的第8條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1606.wav", + "text": "我們同意院版沒有錯" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1607.wav", + "text": "應該要一併來處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1608.wav", + "text": "比較建議是這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1609.wav", + "text": "不然好像" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1610.wav", + "text": "你們有一個附帶決議要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1611.wav", + "text": "你們才會支持第8條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1612.wav", + "text": "是嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1613.wav", + "text": "提的還是這一次提的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1614.wav", + "text": "所以你們那時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1615.wav", + "text": "是在委員會提附帶決議嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1616.wav", + "text": "就是在大本裡面這邊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1617.wav", + "text": "我就比較具體建議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1618.wav", + "text": "因為第8條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1619.wav", + "text": "基本上應該是沒什麼問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1620.wav", + "text": "理論上附帶決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1621.wav", + "text": "應該也沒什麼問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1622.wav", + "text": "我是怕又有一些意外" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1623.wav", + "text": "我是內政部消防署代表委員的附帶決議建議每一個警察分局或者是層級相當的消防機關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1624.wav", + "text": "至少設置一名專職的心理專業人力並希望在本法修正過後五年落實" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1625.wav", + "text": "目前消防機關都有委託張老師或類似的心理輔導機關在做這樣的心理輔導諮商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1626.wav", + "text": "特別是針對救災後的創傷壓力症候群" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1627.wav", + "text": "我們最近也特別成立基金由專業的團體來做個人跟團體的輔導工作" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1628.wav", + "text": "可以嗎你們現在就可以處理第8條所談到的這個問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1629.wav", + "text": "不用再增設心理輔導相關的專業人力就可以處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1630.wav", + "text": "是嗎他" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1631.wav", + "text": "他講的應該是游毓蘭委員的提案啦附帶決議都還沒處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1632.wav", + "text": "所以附帶決議後面再處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1633.wav", + "text": "\n現在處理第十六條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1634.wav", + "text": "規定中央主管機關應以首長為召集人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1635.wav", + "text": "包括要邀請哪些人員召開諮議會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1636.wav", + "text": "大家覺得那樣有點污名化" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1637.wav", + "text": "所以就把病情穩定幾個字拿掉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1638.wav", + "text": "只寫病人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1639.wav", + "text": "增加第七款病人及家庭支持服務規劃及推動" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1640.wav", + "text": "第八款改為政府機關執行心理健康業務之整合督導及協調" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1641.wav", + "text": "把促進拿掉因為心理健康的業務更廣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1642.wav", + "text": "前項病人病人家屬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1643.wav", + "text": "我們本來也是寫前項病情穩定之病人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1644.wav", + "text": "把病情穩定幾個字拿掉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1645.wav", + "text": "以上報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1646.wav", + "text": "主要在那個病人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1647.wav", + "text": "原來是病情穩定病人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1648.wav", + "text": "那現在都用病人來代替" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1649.wav", + "text": "就是不要去排斥" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1650.wav", + "text": "那個很難定義" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1651.wav", + "text": "有時候所謂病情穩定之病人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1652.wav", + "text": "比較難定義" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1653.wav", + "text": "反而會變成讓主管機關可能可以排斥一些人的參與" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1654.wav", + "text": "所以放比較寬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1655.wav", + "text": "其實主要是為了去污名化" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1656.wav", + "text": "我想這個是進步的改變" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1657.wav", + "text": "各位委員有沒有不同意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1658.wav", + "text": "沒有的話我們就按照" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1659.wav", + "text": "衛福部建議的修正版本協商通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1660.wav", + "text": "──好還沒通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1661.wav", + "text": "包括病友團體們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1662.wav", + "text": "及病人家屬團體們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1663.wav", + "text": "因為它是一個類似諮詢的性質" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1664.wav", + "text": "不完全有決定權的情況下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1665.wav", + "text": "是不是應該要讓他們的代表比例能夠增加" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1666.wav", + "text": "因為我們當初是提二分之一就是三分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1667.wav", + "text": "分之一改二分之一" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1668.wav", + "text": "4月20日的修正動議有提出" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1669.wav", + "text": "但是沒有整理上來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1670.wav", + "text": "三分之一" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1671.wav", + "text": "所以想瞭解一下現在的執行狀況和衛福部的看法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1672.wav", + "text": "好衛福部說明一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1673.wav", + "text": "對不起因為事先沒有想到這個答案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1674.wav", + "text": "我記得大概是三分之一" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1675.wav", + "text": "啦其實比例已經滿高的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1676.wav", + "text": "現在在我們的諮議會裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1677.wav", + "text": "已經有三分之一是病人權益" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1678.wav", + "text": "或者病人家屬團體" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1679.wav", + "text": "或者是病人在裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1680.wav", + "text": "因為每個專業人員都想放在裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1681.wav", + "text": "我們整個委員會裡面的三分之一" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1682.wav", + "text": "已經是病人權益或病人家屬團體" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1683.wav", + "text": "如果更高一點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1684.wav", + "text": "呢五分之二" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1685.wav", + "text": "因為包括政府代表" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1686.wav", + "text": "各個機關也要有人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1687.wav", + "text": "再加上還要請專家進來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1688.wav", + "text": "所以人數上其實我們已經滿為難的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1689.wav", + "text": "每年在簽這個的時候就已經覺得很不容易" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1690.wav", + "text": "政府機關會占一定的名額" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1691.wav", + "text": "\n請吳委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1692.wav", + "text": "到底哪些成員要配置進來確實是一個難題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1693.wav", + "text": "精神衛生法其實各部會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1694.wav", + "text": "都是我們的目的事業主管機關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1695.wav", + "text": "一起加入進來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1696.wav", + "text": "所以接下來如果在這個諮詢會議裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1697.wav", + "text": "可能各部會也要派一堆人進來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1698.wav", + "text": "尤其是很重要的部會都一定要進來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1699.wav", + "text": "所以裡面已經有目的事業主管機關的代表" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1700.wav", + "text": "還要有專家學者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1701.wav", + "text": "以及專業團體" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1702.wav", + "text": "比較是保障確保病人病人家屬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1703.wav", + "text": "跟病人權益促進團體" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1704.wav", + "text": "跟政策的推動上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1705.wav", + "text": "我覺得是比較OK的啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1706.wav", + "text": "這裡是一個諮詢會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1707.wav", + "text": "不是一個權益倡議的地方而已" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1708.wav", + "text": "的是盯著政府的相關政策" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1709.wav", + "text": "要往前走" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1710.wav", + "text": "或是我們相關的精神衛生業務" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1711.wav", + "text": "可以順利推展" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1712.wav", + "text": "我是覺得這樣的三分之一" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1713.wav", + "text": "雖然不是很理想" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1714.wav", + "text": "但是確保一定是高於三分之一" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1715.wav", + "text": "因為目前我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1716.wav", + "text": "檢視也沒有其他" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1717.wav", + "text": "如果照程序處理的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1718.wav", + "text": "我們有看到一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1719.wav", + "text": "修正動議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1720.wav", + "text": "下他的版本也是三分之一" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1721.wav", + "text": "就是不得少於三分之一" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1722.wav", + "text": "三分之一真的已經是很多了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1723.wav", + "text": "因為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1724.wav", + "text": "有政府代表跟專家代表" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1725.wav", + "text": "還有病人方的代表" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1726.wav", + "text": "其實這三方是均衡的概念" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1727.wav", + "text": "請問各位委員有沒有其他意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1728.wav", + "text": "我覺得是還可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1729.wav", + "text": "政府代表" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1730.wav", + "text": "學者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1731.wav", + "text": "衛福部建議的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1732.wav", + "text": "修正版本協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1733.wav", + "text": "下一條是第十七" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1734.wav", + "text": "上面那條是中央" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1735.wav", + "text": "的諮詢會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1736.wav", + "text": "條指的是地方主管機關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1737.wav", + "text": "我們也是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1738.wav", + "text": "把病情穩定的病人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1739.wav", + "text": "改成病人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1740.wav", + "text": "加上病人及家庭" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1741.wav", + "text": "支持服務之推動" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1742.wav", + "text": "各局處執行心理健康" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1743.wav", + "text": "促進業務" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1744.wav", + "text": "心理健康業務" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1745.wav", + "text": "也是把病情穩定的病人改成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1746.wav", + "text": "病人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1747.wav", + "text": "以上說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1748.wav", + "text": "比較沒有問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1749.wav", + "text": "跟上一個條文是配套的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1750.wav", + "text": "好如果沒有其他意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1751.wav", + "text": "第十七條就按照衛福部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1752.wav", + "text": "建議的修正版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1753.wav", + "text": "協商通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1754.wav", + "text": "大家看第二" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1755.wav", + "text": "第二行這裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1756.wav", + "text": "這邊是寫中央主管" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1757.wav", + "text": "機關得依人口醫療資源" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1758.wav", + "text": "與心理衛生資源" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1759.wav", + "text": "性劃分責任區域" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1760.wav", + "text": "建立區域心理健康促進" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1761.wav", + "text": "王婉諭委員蔣萬安委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1762.wav", + "text": "還有其他委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1763.wav", + "text": "都有提出不同的意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1764.wav", + "text": "這邊我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1765.wav", + "text": "建議照行政院版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1766.wav", + "text": "在此說明原因這" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1767.wav", + "text": "區域劃分的概念" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1768.wav", + "text": "比較是在心理衛生裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1769.wav", + "text": "因為有牽涉到醫療資源" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1770.wav", + "text": "所以我們才會劃分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1771.wav", + "text": "如果在地的資源不夠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1772.wav", + "text": "別的醫療資源就可以來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1773.wav", + "text": "相互支援的概念" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1774.wav", + "text": "可是在社區支持裡面相對比較" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1775.wav", + "text": "沒有不一樣的概念" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1776.wav", + "text": "還是以行政院版本來通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1777.wav", + "text": "民眾黨有提修正動議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1778.wav", + "text": "我們的第十九條有加入社區" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1779.wav", + "text": "支持資源的分布情況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1780.wav", + "text": "處理醫療及社政方面你們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1781.wav", + "text": "過去就有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1782.wav", + "text": "也都還可以承擔" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1783.wav", + "text": "如果放入社區支持這個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1784.wav", + "text": "會不會有什麼問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1785.wav", + "text": "自理上如果他情緒穩定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1786.wav", + "text": "正常服藥我覺得大家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1787.wav", + "text": "還願意接納" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1788.wav", + "text": "社區心理衛生中心的布建" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1789.wav", + "text": "可以提供" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1790.wav", + "text": "他們一些必要性的支持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1791.wav", + "text": "關於中央主管機關的權責也算是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1792.wav", + "text": "一個新的規劃" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1793.wav", + "text": "所以我想知道的是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1794.wav", + "text": "這個部分跟剛剛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1795.wav", + "text": "講的分區分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1796.wav", + "text": "責任的關聯性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1797.wav", + "text": "是不是有納入社區支持體系" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1798.wav", + "text": "而不是只有醫療跟" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1799.wav", + "text": "社政的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1800.wav", + "text": "請" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1801.wav", + "text": "賴香伶委員的意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1802.wav", + "text": "因為我們前面一直都有談到這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1803.wav", + "text": "社區支持的重要性所以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1804.wav", + "text": "心理衛生資源後面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1805.wav", + "text": "增加社區支持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1806.wav", + "text": "最後一句話也是在醫療服務網" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1807.wav", + "text": "後面加上與社區支持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1808.wav", + "text": "網這樣可以讓它前後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1809.wav", + "text": "更一致而且中央主管機關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1810.wav", + "text": "這個部分謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1811.wav", + "text": "請衛福部說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1812.wav", + "text": "條剛剛諶立中司長已經有講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1813.wav", + "text": "它是一個醫療網的概念" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1814.wav", + "text": "其實社區支持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1815.wav", + "text": "強調的是可近性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1816.wav", + "text": "我們都知道社區資" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1817.wav", + "text": "資源裡包括居住" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1818.wav", + "text": "就學就養社會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1819.wav", + "text": "參與等等它應該落實" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1820.wav", + "text": "反而是必須要很" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1821.wav", + "text": "積極地來社區" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1822.wav", + "text": "網是我們把全" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1823.wav", + "text": "醫療網所以大家會互相支援" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1824.wav", + "text": "可是社區支持必須" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1825.wav", + "text": "社區化必須就近" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1826.wav", + "text": "就地的提供服務所以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1827.wav", + "text": "現在對於社區支持的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1828.wav", + "text": "服務我們會希望是以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1829.wav", + "text": "每個社區心理衛生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1830.wav", + "text": "中心為一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1831.wav", + "text": "最重要的點然後在社區" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1832.wav", + "text": "心理衛生中心的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1833.wav", + "text": "社區支持的相關服務所以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1834.wav", + "text": "它不是一個網的概念" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1835.wav", + "text": "\n大家可能會擔心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1836.wav", + "text": "社政或是勞政都有跨縣市" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1837.wav", + "text": "分工合作的機制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1838.wav", + "text": "所以是沒有問題的譬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1839.wav", + "text": "譬如他的戶籍地" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1840.wav", + "text": "在某個縣市" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1841.wav", + "text": "但他的居住地可能在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1842.wav", + "text": "與提供的服務大概都會以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1843.wav", + "text": "居住地為主" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1844.wav", + "text": "這樣子是沒有問題的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1845.wav", + "text": "醫療網的概念其實是不一樣的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1846.wav", + "text": "社區支持要做得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1847.wav", + "text": "說明謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1848.wav", + "text": "各位委員針對衛福部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1849.wav", + "text": "我不太確定從第3條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1850.wav", + "text": "的醫政單位社政單位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1851.wav", + "text": "勞政單位教育單位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1852.wav", + "text": "的邏輯概念好像" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1853.wav", + "text": "是有所不同" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1854.wav", + "text": "醫療網是以服務六大區" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1855.wav", + "text": "跟地方衛生局" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1856.wav", + "text": "達成其後送" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1857.wav", + "text": "如果衛政是這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1858.wav", + "text": "難道社政跟勞政不是嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1859.wav", + "text": "職業安全衛生署有分北中南區" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1860.wav", + "text": "地方還是可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1861.wav", + "text": "做很綿密的溝通甚至督導" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1862.wav", + "text": "還有資源的挹注" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1863.wav", + "text": "\n我覺得如果談到社區就好像" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1864.wav", + "text": "跟衛福部沒有關係" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1865.wav", + "text": "那到底主責的會是哪個部門" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1866.wav", + "text": "哪個部門願意來承擔" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1867.wav", + "text": "社區照顧網絡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1868.wav", + "text": "現有布建都從零開始做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1869.wav", + "text": "一開始進駐" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1870.wav", + "text": "都是衛政大家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1871.wav", + "text": "難免心裡會覺得壓力大" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1872.wav", + "text": "或是責任太重" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1873.wav", + "text": "支持包括剛剛講得生活重建" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1874.wav", + "text": "自立生活" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1875.wav", + "text": "或是照顧者支持的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1876.wav", + "text": "這些當然不會是衛生單位的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1877.wav", + "text": "職責所以我一直強調" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1878.wav", + "text": "我們放入社區" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1879.wav", + "text": "支持的概念是希望" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1880.wav", + "text": "這個法未來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1881.wav", + "text": "各局處的專業領域" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1882.wav", + "text": "甚至是地方公私協力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1883.wav", + "text": "請不要套入過去的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1884.wav", + "text": "鬆動跟調整的機會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1885.wav", + "text": "法案我還是支持保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1886.wav", + "text": "啦但是我的概念跟想法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1887.wav", + "text": "是希望在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1888.wav", + "text": "社會心理的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1889.wav", + "text": "很多精神病友的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1890.wav", + "text": "只有醫療可以做最後的協助" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1891.wav", + "text": "不管是CRPD" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1892.wav", + "text": "還是各個研究" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1893.wav", + "text": "都很肯定臺灣的社區" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1894.wav", + "text": "有很多人願意投入" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1895.wav", + "text": "衛福部可以跟其他部門" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1896.wav", + "text": "多討論一下這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1897.wav", + "text": "執行效益跟執行方案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1898.wav", + "text": "是不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1899.wav", + "text": "應該要有一個更" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1900.wav", + "text": "積極的態度不是說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1901.wav", + "text": "這個都不行然後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1902.wav", + "text": "更綿密所以不需要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1903.wav", + "text": "我覺得跟我的實務經驗差很大" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1904.wav", + "text": "所以我請主席可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1905.wav", + "text": "就這部分請他們做評估報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1906.wav", + "text": "請吳玉琴委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1907.wav", + "text": "5月10日討論這一條的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1908.wav", + "text": "可能衛福部還是要說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1909.wav", + "text": "現在是依人口" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1910.wav", + "text": "依醫療資源也新增" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1911.wav", + "text": "心理衛生資源" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1912.wav", + "text": "這個部分做考量" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1913.wav", + "text": "類似以前劃分醫療" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1914.wav", + "text": "但是要做為什麼用途" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1915.wav", + "text": "要建立的是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1916.wav", + "text": "心理健康促進" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1917.wav", + "text": "我記得我們上次有建議應該把照護" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1918.wav", + "text": "或是剛剛提到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1919.wav", + "text": "的社區支持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1920.wav", + "text": "還有醫療服務網來訂定實施計畫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1921.wav", + "text": "因為做這些調查一定有目的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1922.wav", + "text": "是要做什麼用途" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1923.wav", + "text": "應該要把社區支持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1924.wav", + "text": "或是我們──我記得我們上次討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1925.wav", + "text": "有建議要放進照護" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1926.wav", + "text": "但這次我看到的文字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1927.wav", + "text": "照護又不見了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1928.wav", + "text": "所以這個地方是不是請" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1929.wav", + "text": "對於大家的關心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1930.wav", + "text": "像我關心照護" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1931.wav", + "text": "是不是能夠把它們都涵蓋進去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1932.wav", + "text": "看是用什麼名詞或什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1933.wav", + "text": "文字把它們涵蓋進去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1934.wav", + "text": "謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1935.wav", + "text": "謝謝兩位委員對這個的關心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1936.wav", + "text": "其實大家講得也是很實際" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1937.wav", + "text": "我們原有的條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1938.wav", + "text": "在最右邊第二行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1939.wav", + "text": "所謂的醫療網" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1940.wav", + "text": "或者用人口分布" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1941.wav", + "text": "布資源的概念" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1942.wav", + "text": "是原來醫療的概念" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1943.wav", + "text": "所以它最早是用來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1944.wav", + "text": "病床的資源" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1945.wav", + "text": "對我們來講現在就再進一步" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1946.wav", + "text": "是社區心衛中心的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1947.wav", + "text": "資源在這方面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1948.wav", + "text": "用這樣子的概念在布建" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1949.wav", + "text": "這個概念和社政的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1950.wav", + "text": "福利概念是完全不一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1951.wav", + "text": "的概念" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1952.wav", + "text": "所以我們會有什麼分區啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1953.wav", + "text": "啦比較是用這種" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1954.wav", + "text": "醫療的概念在寫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1955.wav", + "text": "這一個條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1956.wav", + "text": "如果要用支持性資源的寫法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1957.wav", + "text": "我建議是回到原有的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1958.wav", + "text": "那種概念裡面去寫會比較好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1959.wav", + "text": "支持性資源寫進去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1960.wav", + "text": "會有一點奇怪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1961.wav", + "text": "這種支持性資源的概念" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1962.wav", + "text": "成本的投資" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1963.wav", + "text": "等等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1964.wav", + "text": "有它一定的用途" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1965.wav", + "text": "其實很強調可近性的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1966.wav", + "text": "這種情況底下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1967.wav", + "text": "適不適合用這樣的名稱" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1968.wav", + "text": "放在這裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1969.wav", + "text": "也要就教大家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1970.wav", + "text": "因為大家基本觀念好像真的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1971.wav", + "text": "我們先把今天可以解決的先解決好嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1972.wav", + "text": "我覺得好像大家可以再思考一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1973.wav", + "text": "和責任其實不太一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1974.wav", + "text": "它也是一個所謂服務網的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1975.wav", + "text": "我們在談社區支持的時候或是在談第十九條的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1976.wav", + "text": "不應該侷限在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1977.wav", + "text": "僅有醫療服務網而已" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1978.wav", + "text": "不同等級的協助" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1979.wav", + "text": "應該都一併考慮進來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1980.wav", + "text": "先行保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1981.wav", + "text": "\n繼續處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1982.wav", + "text": "請大家看第34頁" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1983.wav", + "text": "左邊第2條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1984.wav", + "text": "這邊就是在強調" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1985.wav", + "text": "病人之精神醫療照護" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1986.wav", + "text": "為之" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1987.wav", + "text": "日間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1988.wav", + "text": "留院但現在的名稱已經不叫日間留院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1989.wav", + "text": "所以我們後來就把名稱" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1990.wav", + "text": "update一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1991.wav", + "text": "除了第7款的社區支持服務" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1992.wav", + "text": "在第8款我們增加了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1993.wav", + "text": "個案管理服務" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1994.wav", + "text": "原因是我們現在在心衛中心最主要就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1995.wav", + "text": "採取個案管理服務" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1996.wav", + "text": "可是如果沒有給這些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1997.wav", + "text": "服務工作同仁或者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1998.wav", + "text": "服務個案管理的業務" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/1999.wav", + "text": "有一個法律依據的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2000.wav", + "text": "對他們來講比較不夠尊重" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2001.wav", + "text": "所以我們想在這邊再加上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2002.wav", + "text": "第8款的個案管理服務" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2003.wav", + "text": "以上說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2004.wav", + "text": "這部分其實就連動到我們剛剛在討論的第3條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2005.wav", + "text": "有提出來有一個部分是在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2006.wav", + "text": "精神危機前期積極" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2007.wav", + "text": "介入的措施" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2008.wav", + "text": "因為之前在談論這個部分時" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2009.wav", + "text": "衛福部認為應該是把危機處理放在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2010.wav", + "text": "後端自傷傷人的時候才進入" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2011.wav", + "text": "危機處理而不是前端的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2012.wav", + "text": "所以我們這邊還是希望能夠就前端如何積極性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2013.wav", + "text": "就如同之前提到的不論是在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2014.wav", + "text": "民團的意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2015.wav", + "text": "在過去支持的意見或者是在社會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2016.wav", + "text": "事件發生之後其實都有很多這樣的討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2017.wav", + "text": "同時在這次CRPD的審查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2018.wav", + "text": "一旦發生之後才用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2019.wav", + "text": "醫療的部分介入或是強制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2020.wav", + "text": "力介入其實更應該要做到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2021.wav", + "text": "的是從前面開始當他" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2022.wav", + "text": "有一些些不穩定狀態的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2023.wav", + "text": "就應該透過這樣子的處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2024.wav", + "text": "然後去給一些積極性的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2025.wav", + "text": "我們之前一直在爭取的專線電話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2026.wav", + "text": "還有同儕的支持等等可能都要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2027.wav", + "text": "納入這樣的範圍裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2028.wav", + "text": "所以我們才會在第2條第8款" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2029.wav", + "text": "談的危機處理又分為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2030.wav", + "text": "衛福部認為的危機處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2031.wav", + "text": "後端和前段精神" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2032.wav", + "text": "危機前期的積極性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2033.wav", + "text": "如果再" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2034.wav", + "text": "款下去呢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2035.wav", + "text": "衛福部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2036.wav", + "text": "跟委員報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2037.wav", + "text": "精神危機處理這個概念" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2038.wav", + "text": "是新創出來的名詞" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2039.wav", + "text": "這個概念其實在國外" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2040.wav", + "text": "也是在試辦階段" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2041.wav", + "text": "最早來自美國紐約的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2042.wav", + "text": "降落傘計畫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2043.wav", + "text": "但是他們現在已經把整個計畫都取消了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2044.wav", + "text": "其實我們現在布建很多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2045.wav", + "text": "概念的時候就像剛剛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2046.wav", + "text": "王委員講的精神危機處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2047.wav", + "text": "就是把個案管理建立起來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2048.wav", + "text": "之後就會有一個基本的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2049.wav", + "text": "精神危機處理人員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2050.wav", + "text": "如果再進一步我們在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2051.wav", + "text": "優化計畫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2052.wav", + "text": "當個案出現危機狀況的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2053.wav", + "text": "醫院會有團隊進到家裡面去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2054.wav", + "text": "處理\n但是委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2055.wav", + "text": "這邊提到的精神危機" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2056.wav", + "text": "它指的是要用社工" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2057.wav", + "text": "同儕團體等等到家裡去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2058.wav", + "text": "陪伴24小時" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2059.wav", + "text": "或者怎麼樣用這樣的方式來做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2060.wav", + "text": "但那個是說起來容易" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2061.wav", + "text": "做起來難" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2062.wav", + "text": "目前臺灣沒有這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2063.wav", + "text": "足夠的人力可以做這件事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2064.wav", + "text": "也沒有這樣的資源" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2065.wav", + "text": "美國紐約州做這個事情是他們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2066.wav", + "text": "的市長拿他的基金來做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2067.wav", + "text": "但市長下來之後整個計畫就cancel" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2068.wav", + "text": "了也就是說它這個執行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2069.wav", + "text": "面上其實還有滿大的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2070.wav", + "text": "\n在臺灣其實我們也" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2071.wav", + "text": "很努力希望這樣的想法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2072.wav", + "text": "能夠存活下去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2073.wav", + "text": "所以在前面這2年我們都有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2074.wav", + "text": "基金的預算去補助它" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2075.wav", + "text": "試辦但我們只能" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2076.wav", + "text": "補助試辦因為沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2077.wav", + "text": "那麼多那麼有熱心的人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2078.wav", + "text": "可以去做這件事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2079.wav", + "text": "而且在臺灣的環境跟委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2080.wav", + "text": "報告我覺得還有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2081.wav", + "text": "滿大的落差跟不成熟" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2082.wav", + "text": "所以這個理念" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2083.wav", + "text": "也已經有做到相當" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2084.wav", + "text": "心衛社工的布建" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2085.wav", + "text": "建以及我們再請醫院團隊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2086.wav", + "text": "這個加起來其實" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2087.wav", + "text": "已經有相當的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2088.wav", + "text": "在裡面了並不是一定要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2089.wav", + "text": "按照那樣子的方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2090.wav", + "text": "所謂的請社工" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2091.wav", + "text": "一起到家裡面去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2092.wav", + "text": "或支持那位發病的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2093.wav", + "text": "病人它只是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2094.wav", + "text": "一種模式而已" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2095.wav", + "text": "而那個模式在美國也只是試辦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2096.wav", + "text": "以上報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2097.wav", + "text": "請王婉諭委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2098.wav", + "text": "我們談的不是只有要把社工師納進去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2099.wav", + "text": "應該是說不只是醫療人員而且" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2100.wav", + "text": "就因為我們現在有試辦過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2101.wav", + "text": "只是卡在量能和培力不足" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2102.wav", + "text": "的情況下就不入法嗎我覺得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2103.wav", + "text": "這樣的說法其實滿奇怪的也就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2104.wav", + "text": "說現在沒有辦法做到全面然後我們也已經有在做了所以不要入法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2105.wav", + "text": "其實有很多很多法規通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2106.wav", + "text": "去做而且我們應該要努力去做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2107.wav", + "text": "而不是先有了預算然後到最後都" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2108.wav", + "text": "做好了才入法我覺得這樣的說法有點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2109.wav", + "text": "本末倒置其實有很多法律" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2110.wav", + "text": "都是先行在前面然後後續" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2111.wav", + "text": "該補足的人該補足的錢再往上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2112.wav", + "text": "去補足怎麼會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2113.wav", + "text": "說因為我們已經有在做了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2114.wav", + "text": "然後沒有辦法擴大沒有錢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2115.wav", + "text": "沒有人所以我們現在先不放進去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2116.wav", + "text": "雖然我很支持這個方向" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2117.wav", + "text": "再請衛福部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2118.wav", + "text": "之前我們有請教" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2119.wav", + "text": "剛剛講的紐約這個部分是失敗" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2120.wav", + "text": "的對不對就是還在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2121.wav", + "text": "實驗階段我當時覺得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2122.wav", + "text": "早但是後來我又" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2123.wav", + "text": "查了一些不同的資料當然司長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2124.wav", + "text": "如果有更多資料可以告訴我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2125.wav", + "text": "還是滿多文獻都說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2126.wav", + "text": "的積極介入其實是一個非常" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2127.wav", + "text": "有效的作法不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2128.wav", + "text": "只有你剛剛講的降落傘那個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2129.wav", + "text": "作法還有很多別的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2130.wav", + "text": "及更多的成本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2131.wav", + "text": "如公共衛生或相關的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2132.wav", + "text": "成本所以我會覺得這方面是不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2133.wav", + "text": "還有一些不同" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2134.wav", + "text": "的作法當然臺灣這個部分是正在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2135.wav", + "text": "裡那麼你採取下列方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2136.wav", + "text": "為之沒有說每一樣都會採取" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2137.wav", + "text": "啊但是因為我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2138.wav", + "text": "們這一次修法是滿難得的機會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2139.wav", + "text": "所以先放在這邊因為我自己" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2140.wav", + "text": "在待會兒第27條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2141.wav", + "text": "也是有一樣的名詞概念所以我們前面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2142.wav", + "text": "我想這部分跟司長有不同" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2143.wav", + "text": "看法但是還是要先提出" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2144.wav", + "text": "謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2145.wav", + "text": "賴香伶委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2146.wav", + "text": "我也支持前二位委員的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2147.wav", + "text": "意見因為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2148.wav", + "text": "我也說過我有這樣的一個家人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2149.wav", + "text": "危機前期積極介入" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2150.wav", + "text": "協助的措施我想" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2151.wav", + "text": "司長也很難講出一套" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2152.wav", + "text": "最有效的方案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2153.wav", + "text": "來定義" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2154.wav", + "text": "它但是它確實必須要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2155.wav", + "text": "提供非常多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2156.wav", + "text": "友家庭或者是個人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2157.wav", + "text": "能夠被接住" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2158.wav", + "text": "也好提供" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2159.wav", + "text": "他的支持性措施" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2160.wav", + "text": "也好因為發病之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2161.wav", + "text": "沒有辦法與" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2162.wav", + "text": "的溝通如果我們都已經發現它" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2163.wav", + "text": "它的一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2164.wav", + "text": "階段所謂精神危機" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2165.wav", + "text": "的前期應該是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2166.wav", + "text": "有一些經驗值" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2167.wav", + "text": "而且很多服務的團體甚至" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2168.wav", + "text": "精神科醫師都已經告訴我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2169.wav", + "text": "我覺得這正是我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2170.wav", + "text": "此次修法裡面最突破" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2171.wav", + "text": "的地方如果我們連" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2172.wav", + "text": "這個都不面對也���願意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2173.wav", + "text": "承認這樣的一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2174.wav", + "text": "困境是來自" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2175.wav", + "text": "他後面發病後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2176.wav", + "text": "的危險甚至暴力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2177.wav", + "text": "甚至自傷" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2178.wav", + "text": "或傷人那個後果我覺得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2179.wav", + "text": "再回到精神醫療院所去用藥" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2180.wav", + "text": "去把他拘禁" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2181.wav", + "text": "甚至做一些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2182.wav", + "text": "刑事上判決等等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2183.wav", + "text": "都是後者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2184.wav", + "text": "既然討論到這裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2185.wav", + "text": "一個概念入法以及" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2186.wav", + "text": "提供各種方式的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2187.wav", + "text": "嘗試會是精神" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2188.wav", + "text": "衛生法賦予他" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2189.wav", + "text": "能夠跟這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2190.wav", + "text": "一個進步性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2191.wav", + "text": "也是一個嘗試甚至" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2192.wav", + "text": "嘗試之後是失敗我不" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2193.wav", + "text": "覺得這是失敗我希望" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2194.wav", + "text": "司長也不要氣餒就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2195.wav", + "text": "美國即使失敗我們不一定會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2196.wav", + "text": "失敗我們的經驗也未必" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2197.wav", + "text": "不能先於其他國家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2198.wav", + "text": "所以我也很懇切希望" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2199.wav", + "text": "能夠在部分的條文裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2200.wav", + "text": "讓這個文字入法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2201.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2202.wav", + "text": "沒有其他" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2203.wav", + "text": "意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2204.wav", + "text": "我們就按照" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2205.wav", + "text": "這個修正動議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2206.wav", + "text": "要通過了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2207.wav", + "text": "其實剛剛委員講的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2208.wav", + "text": "這個點真的很重要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2209.wav", + "text": "用的名詞的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2210.wav", + "text": "就是委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2211.wav", + "text": "可能希望在法裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2212.wav", + "text": "精神危機前期的一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2213.wav", + "text": "處理方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2214.wav", + "text": "處遇方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2215.wav", + "text": "或早期介入方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2216.wav", + "text": "現在在推的方案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2217.wav", + "text": "我們是所謂疑似或" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2218.wav", + "text": "高風險的概念" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2219.wav", + "text": "其實也有這樣一個方案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2220.wav", + "text": "我也跟諶司長說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2221.wav", + "text": "做我們本來就有方案在做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2222.wav", + "text": "工作模式其實我們現在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2223.wav", + "text": "機制也是一個模式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2224.wav", + "text": "以及除了優化" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2225.wav", + "text": "之外有沒有其它的可能性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2226.wav", + "text": "這部分我們是可以來想" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2227.wav", + "text": "只是要不要用這個詞" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2228.wav", + "text": "啦因為用這個詞" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2229.wav", + "text": "讀的文獻他們就很容易" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2230.wav", + "text": "像降落傘那樣的模式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2231.wav", + "text": "啦我只是在想我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2232.wav", + "text": "針對疑似跟高風險" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2233.wav", + "text": "服務案的一個概念" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2234.wav", + "text": "這個可能是比較像現在我們在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2235.wav", + "text": "臺灣推的如果是這樣的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2236.wav", + "text": "我們怎麼樣子把它" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2237.wav", + "text": "可以來做討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2238.wav", + "text": "我們也覺得早期介入是重要的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2239.wav", + "text": "以上謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2240.wav", + "text": "主席謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2241.wav", + "text": "針對這個議題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2242.wav", + "text": "這次衛福部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2243.wav", + "text": "也加了一個個案管理服務" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2244.wav", + "text": "一個概念" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2245.wav", + "text": "這個名詞真的大家還要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2246.wav", + "text": "再共識一下所謂精神" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2247.wav", + "text": "危機前的積極介入" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2248.wav", + "text": "有一點像是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2249.wav", + "text": "社安網裡面精神照護" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2250.wav", + "text": "服務資源在建構的就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2251.wav", + "text": "疑似精神病人的早期" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2252.wav", + "text": "介入或是及早" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2253.wav", + "text": "地去做相關的協助" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2254.wav", + "text": "比較像是這個類型" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2255.wav", + "text": "所以我們應該不用一個專" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2256.wav", + "text": "有名詞而是一個形容" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2257.wav", + "text": "那是不是適合在這裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2258.wav", + "text": "我也要疑慮\n" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2259.wav", + "text": "我們目前已經" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2260.wav", + "text": "服務措施像" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2261.wav", + "text": "急診門診" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2262.wav", + "text": "或全日住院這裡已經很清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2263.wav", + "text": "這個要加" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2264.wav", + "text": "各項服務這裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2265.wav", + "text": "訂下去就是衛福部一定要全力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2266.wav", + "text": "完成啦因為這是法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2267.wav", + "text": "定的責任法定的義務" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2268.wav", + "text": "要去執行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2269.wav", + "text": "所以這個地方當然衛福部會擔憂" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2270.wav", + "text": "它到底做得到或做不到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2271.wav", + "text": "\n如果是疑似或是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2272.wav", + "text": "早期介入我覺得你們一定會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2273.wav", + "text": "在建構這個系統" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2274.wav", + "text": "這樣可能比較安心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2275.wav", + "text": "但如果是一個所謂降落傘" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2276.wav", + "text": "有點擔心因為它在經驗" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2277.wav", + "text": "上面還沒有那麼充足" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2278.wav", + "text": "如果入法之後它一定要執行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2279.wav", + "text": "它就會擔心執行不了到時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2280.wav", + "text": "會違反相關的法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2281.wav", + "text": "職責沒有盡到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2282.wav", + "text": "\n所以我覺得文字的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2283.wav", + "text": "是不是要請衛福部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2284.wav", + "text": "把文字再寫得更精準" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2285.wav", + "text": "早期介入的概念應該放進來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2286.wav", + "text": "如果是這樣的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2287.wav", + "text": "修正可能會比較適合" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2288.wav", + "text": "謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2289.wav", + "text": "剛剛這個討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2290.wav", + "text": "就反映了我們前面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2291.wav", + "text": "沒有去定義造成的困擾" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2292.wav", + "text": "變成是不一樣的東西" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2293.wav", + "text": "關於前面那個定義" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2294.wav", + "text": "精神危機前期積極" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2295.wav", + "text": "介入措施指提供" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2296.wav", + "text": "危機前期病人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2297.wav", + "text": "入家式危機處理團隊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2298.wav", + "text": "危機穩定計畫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2299.wav", + "text": "透過密集性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2300.wav", + "text": "支持服務" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2301.wav", + "text": "社區支持服務" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2302.wav", + "text": "喘息中心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2303.wav", + "text": "同儕支持等服務" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2304.wav", + "text": "必要時得協助" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2305.wav", + "text": "安排醫療服務" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2306.wav", + "text": "它並沒有特定指一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2307.wav", + "text": "叫做降落傘或者其它的東西" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2308.wav", + "text": "嘛所以那個時候其實就需要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2309.wav", + "text": "那可能會讓後面很多的東西" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2310.wav", + "text": "也不一定要到機構化" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2311.wav", + "text": "或進入機構" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2312.wav", + "text": "所以我想這個部分是不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2313.wav", + "text": "有再討論的空間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2314.wav", + "text": "也請衛福部這邊思考一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2315.wav", + "text": "謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2316.wav", + "text": "所以范委員第3條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2317.wav", + "text": "定義裡面就有這個定義" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2318.wav", + "text": "我剛剛講的前面版本的第3行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2319.wav", + "text": "就是講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2320.wav", + "text": "有這一個所謂" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2321.wav", + "text": "精神危機前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2322.wav", + "text": "積極" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2323.wav", + "text": "精神危機前期積極介入措施" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2324.wav", + "text": "的定義" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2325.wav", + "text": "是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2326.wav", + "text": "我們請衛福部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2327.wav", + "text": "我稍微補充說明一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2328.wav", + "text": "就是降落傘計畫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2329.wav", + "text": "裡面的定義" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2330.wav", + "text": "完全把那個copy過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2331.wav", + "text": "是有困難的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2332.wav", + "text": "你現講的降落傘是紐約那邊特定的東西" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2333.wav", + "text": "這個可能澳洲或其它國家也有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2334.wav", + "text": "我們就不用去討論降落傘" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2335.wav", + "text": "但是因為有些事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2336.wav", + "text": "有本末先後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2337.wav", + "text": "我們現在還在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2338.wav", + "text": "找褲子穿" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2339.wav", + "text": "結果這邊想要開" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2340.wav", + "text": "賓士有一點困難" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2341.wav", + "text": "我們今天要做同樣一件事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2342.wav", + "text": "資源" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2343.wav", + "text": "先想辦法做到這樣的目的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2344.wav", + "text": "這個就是我們的疑似病人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2345.wav", + "text": "及高風險計畫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2346.wav", + "text": "其實我們做的是同樣的事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2347.wav", + "text": "提到那個計畫裡面的那些人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2348.wav", + "text": "喘息中心什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2349.wav", + "text": "都是不存在的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2350.wav", + "text": "完全沒有可以辦這件事情的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2351.wav", + "text": "完全沒有的東西" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2352.wav", + "text": "而且連試辦都還沒有真正試辦完成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2353.wav", + "text": "不願意放到法裡面因為其實" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2354.wav", + "text": "我們在執行面還有很多疑慮" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2355.wav", + "text": "我們現在已經試辦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2356.wav", + "text": "疑似��人及高風險計畫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2357.wav", + "text": "我們試辦覺得是成功的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2358.wav", + "text": "從去年開始" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2359.wav", + "text": "全面推動" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2360.wav", + "text": "我們現在正在做同樣的事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2361.wav", + "text": "這邊我有一個疑義" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2362.wav", + "text": "這樣的部分我覺得這個專業上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2363.wav", + "text": "有必要釐清" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2364.wav", + "text": "因為這邊講他也許不是那種高風險" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2365.wav", + "text": "其他人但是他可能" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2366.wav", + "text": "有一個危機家人無法承擔" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2367.wav", + "text": "需要介入" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2368.wav", + "text": "您剛剛講你們的措施還沒到位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2369.wav", + "text": "或是說什麼賓士我覺得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2370.wav", + "text": "好像不一定要這樣討論\n" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2371.wav", + "text": "也許有一些基本的元素那個文字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2372.wav", + "text": "可以修改" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2373.wav", + "text": "可以省去後面很多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2374.wav", + "text": "也許在這個時候放入" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2375.wav", + "text": "其實是有必要的我們能做到多少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2376.wav", + "text": "還可以再討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2377.wav", + "text": "每一樣都有而是說等服務" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2378.wav", + "text": "如果你覺得絕對做不到的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2379.wav", + "text": "也許我們可以協商那個文字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2380.wav", + "text": "請王婉諭委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2381.wav", + "text": "其實應該是說不論從105年到110年的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2382.wav", + "text": "提升計畫或者是現在正在處理中的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2383.wav", + "text": "疑似" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2384.wav", + "text": "或社區精神病人優化照護計畫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2385.wav", + "text": "大概都是類似這樣的概念" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2386.wav", + "text": "當然不是說一定要完全" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2387.wav", + "text": "跟降落傘模式一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2388.wav", + "text": "我們也沒有這樣子提出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2389.wav", + "text": "不是等到自傷傷人之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2390.wav", + "text": "而是在前期就要積極處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2391.wav", + "text": "是沒有錯的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2392.wav", + "text": "降落傘計畫其實像澳洲" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2393.wav", + "text": "等等其實都有類似的東西在裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2394.wav", + "text": "我們並不是只要copy其中一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2395.wav", + "text": "只是我們想表達的是應該要涵蓋的不只是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2396.wav", + "text": "自傷傷人或者就醫之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2397.wav", + "text": "才會有這樣子的協助" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2398.wav", + "text": "而是在前期當他有一些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2399.wav", + "text": "請衛福部再說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2400.wav", + "text": "跟范雲委員提出的意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2401.wav", + "text": "其實我們在概念上彼此沒有什麼太大的差異" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2402.wav", + "text": "只是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2403.wav", + "text": "衛福部是政策的主管機關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2404.wav", + "text": "我們在規劃的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2405.wav", + "text": "三種狀態" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2406.wav", + "text": "一個是一般的狀態" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2407.wav", + "text": "所以我們用個案管理的方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2408.wav", + "text": "讓社區心衛中心的關懷員去關懷他" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2409.wav", + "text": "比較複雜一點的個案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2410.wav", + "text": "我們用心衛社工去關懷他" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2411.wav", + "text": "第二種狀態就進入" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2412.wav", + "text": "風險狀態" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2413.wav", + "text": "這個個案最近有一些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2414.wav", + "text": "或者最近開始出現睡眠不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2415.wav", + "text": "的狀況就進入風險狀態" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2416.wav", + "text": "或者是疑似的狀態" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2417.wav", + "text": "這時候我們就用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2418.wav", + "text": "進行入家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2419.wav", + "text": "第三種狀態就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2420.wav", + "text": "危機狀態" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2421.wav", + "text": "危機處理小組" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2422.wav", + "text": "另外危機處理狀態" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2423.wav", + "text": "是有相關性的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2424.wav", + "text": "包括強制住院強制社區治療" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2425.wav", + "text": "都是我們處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2426.wav", + "text": "危機狀態的一種方法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2427.wav", + "text": "\n委員剛剛提的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2428.wav", + "text": "的很多概念其實跟我們並沒有什麼不一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2429.wav", + "text": "真正有差距的在於" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2430.wav", + "text": "我們的資源來源是來自醫院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2431.wav", + "text": "除了醫院的專業人員以外" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2432.wav", + "text": "還能另外找到其他的資源" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2433.wav", + "text": "甚至要找同儕團體一起進入" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2434.wav", + "text": "我覺得差異在這裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2435.wav", + "text": "另外再跟委員報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2436.wav", + "text": "寫得很清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2437.wav", + "text": "其實在通過的第49條第1項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2438.wav", + "text": "就是如果發現疑似" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2439.wav", + "text": "可以通知地方主管機關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2440.wav", + "text": "提供醫療關懷或社區" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2441.wav", + "text": "支持服務的協助" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2442.wav", + "text": "其實就是疑似跟" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2443.wav", + "text": "只是沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2444.wav", + "text": "把所謂的疑似或是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2445.wav", + "text": "高風險寫得那麼清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2446.wav", + "text": "可是這一次我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2447.wav", + "text": "自傷傷人了才介入" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2448.wav", + "text": "而是有疑似高風險" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2449.wav", + "text": "然後有通知" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2450.wav", + "text": "所以第49條第1項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2451.wav", + "text": "其實已經有這樣的設計" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2452.wav", + "text": "當然這方面可能要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2453.wav", + "text": "問專業的意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2454.wav", + "text": "至少我看到跟了解的高風險" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2455.wav", + "text": "跟這個的定義其實是不大一樣的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2456.wav", + "text": "因為你的高風險定義" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2457.wav", + "text": "有自傷傷人沒有嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2458.wav", + "text": "你的高風險的定義跟我們這邊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2459.wav", + "text": "講到需要的是不是一致" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2460.wav", + "text": "協助安排醫療服務" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2461.wav", + "text": "可是前面很多比較不是那麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2462.wav", + "text": "醫療化的服務這個可能也是個差異" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2463.wav", + "text": "一個是定義" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2464.wav", + "text": "另外就是提供的服務的性質" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2465.wav", + "text": "不好意思第49條第1項是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2466.wav", + "text": "提供醫療關懷或社區" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2467.wav", + "text": "支持服務之協助" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2468.wav", + "text": "其實都包括在裡面了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2469.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2470.wav", + "text": "這個沒有共識" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2471.wav", + "text": "\n處理第21條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2472.wav", + "text": "說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2473.wav", + "text": "指政府機關得依" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2474.wav", + "text": "需要設立" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2475.wav", + "text": "或獎勵民間機構成立一些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2476.wav", + "text": "照護機構提供病人相關的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2477.wav", + "text": "照護服務" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2478.wav", + "text": "它的範圍" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2479.wav", + "text": "或是獎補助等等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2480.wav", + "text": "尤其是第4項規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2481.wav", + "text": "精神照護機構" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2482.wav", + "text": "或非由各級" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2483.wav", + "text": "不得為病人提供" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2484.wav", + "text": "住宿或治療服務" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2485.wav", + "text": "但身心障礙福利機構" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2486.wav", + "text": "老人福利機構及長期照顧" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2487.wav", + "text": "服務機構依其設立目的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2488.wav", + "text": "涉及提供精神照護服務者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2489.wav", + "text": "不在此限" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2490.wav", + "text": "這一條��面加入的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2491.wav", + "text": "第4項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2492.wav", + "text": "避免一些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2493.wav", + "text": "不相關的團體" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2494.wav", + "text": "隨意收留精神病人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2495.wav", + "text": "\n剛剛漏了一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2496.wav", + "text": "修正說明的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2497.wav", + "text": "其實這裡面不包含" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2498.wav", + "text": "病人或家屬間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2499.wav", + "text": "基於互助所提供的短期住宿" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2500.wav", + "text": "有一些保留的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2501.wav", + "text": "說明跟排除的情況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2502.wav", + "text": "各位委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2503.wav", + "text": "衛福部建議的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2504.wav", + "text": "修正版本有沒有不同意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2505.wav", + "text": "好我們也沒有其他" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2506.wav", + "text": "修正動議第21條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2507.wav", + "text": "就按照衛福部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2508.wav", + "text": "提供的修正版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2509.wav", + "text": "我補充一下因為我覺得這個條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2510.wav", + "text": "的變動比較大大家可能對那個脈絡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2511.wav", + "text": "不是很清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2512.wav", + "text": "\n當時在委員會審查的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2513.wav", + "text": "原來的條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2514.wav", + "text": "是哪些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2515.wav", + "text": "寫得滿多的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2516.wav", + "text": "但是我質疑一點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2517.wav", + "text": "這幾類是不是都在它的範圍內" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2518.wav", + "text": "所以後來衛福部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2519.wav", + "text": "把這些都放在定義裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2520.wav", + "text": "作為精神照護機構" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2521.wav", + "text": "而這裡就單純在規範" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2522.wav", + "text": "精神照護機構" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2523.wav", + "text": "醫事人員或社工師" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2524.wav", + "text": "登記最重要的是未" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2525.wav", + "text": "未依法設立精神照護機構" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2526.wav", + "text": "各級政府主管機關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2527.wav", + "text": "委託補助或管理者不得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2528.wav", + "text": "為病人提供" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2529.wav", + "text": "住宿或治療服務" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2530.wav", + "text": "其實我們一直關心的是住宿服務" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2531.wav", + "text": "的罰則" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2532.wav", + "text": "那個罰則是針對未立案機構" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2533.wav", + "text": "\n關於此處的變動在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2534.wav", + "text": "之後我們其實跟衛福部有很多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2535.wav", + "text": "的討論最後做了文字上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2536.wav", + "text": "讓所謂龍發堂" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2537.wav", + "text": "條例可以比較清楚的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2538.wav", + "text": "住宿治療的機構如果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2539.wav", + "text": "地方政府或中央政府委託的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2540.wav", + "text": "的補充不然這個變動那麼大" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2541.wav", + "text": "過就是過與不及" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2542.wav", + "text": "如果限制太嚴" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2543.wav", + "text": "可能現在很多已經在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2544.wav", + "text": "都會受到排擠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2545.wav", + "text": "但是我們又要規範" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2546.wav", + "text": "建議的修正版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2547.wav", + "text": "協商通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2548.wav", + "text": "\n接著處理第" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2549.wav", + "text": "第21條那個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2550.wav", + "text": "或在第幾行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2551.wav", + "text": "你們自己修正的版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2552.wav", + "text": "你們有什麼意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2553.wav", + "text": "對多一個頓號" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2554.wav", + "text": "第4項第三行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2555.wav", + "text": "改好送過來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2556.wav", + "text": "我們就會按照你們修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2557.wav", + "text": "後的版本協商通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2558.wav", + "text": "再發言第" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2559.wav", + "text": "23條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2560.wav", + "text": "支持服務應該依多元連續" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2561.wav", + "text": "服務原則規劃辦理我們在此對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2562.wav", + "text": "地方主管機關可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2563.wav", + "text": "自行委託或補助獎勵等等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2564.wav", + "text": "除了全日型" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2565.wav", + "text": "日間型居家型以外" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2566.wav", + "text": "我們增加了一個社區型" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2567.wav", + "text": "型的服務機制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2568.wav", + "text": "然後在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2569.wav", + "text": "第3項除了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2570.wav", + "text": "地方主管機關應提供病人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2571.wav", + "text": "情緒支持喘息服務" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2572.wav", + "text": "之外我們多加了一個專線服務" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2573.wav", + "text": "及其他支持性服務" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2574.wav", + "text": "以上說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2575.wav", + "text": "提案的院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2576.wav", + "text": "我跟大家解釋一下第" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2577.wav", + "text": "第23條主要是規範" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2578.wav", + "text": "地方主管機關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2579.wav", + "text": "應該做什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2580.wav", + "text": "增加第2款心理支持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2581.wav", + "text": "因為第1款是居家照顧" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2582.wav", + "text": "就業服務之後增加" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2583.wav", + "text": "第10款由同儕運作" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2584.wav", + "text": "或由同儕提供支持之" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2585.wav", + "text": "服務" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2586.wav", + "text": "另外增訂第2項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2587.wav", + "text": "應提供照顧者下列" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2588.wav", + "text": "服務項目" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2589.wav", + "text": "二臨時短期照顧及其它喘息服務" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2590.wav", + "text": "三照顧者教育訓練及研習" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2591.wav", + "text": "四家庭關懷訪視" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2592.wav", + "text": "心理支持及照顧者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2593.wav", + "text": "同儕支持服務" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2594.wav", + "text": "\n我回頭解釋一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2595.wav", + "text": "為什麼增加這些部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2596.wav", + "text": "主要就是明定地方要增加" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2597.wav", + "text": "等三項工作因為CRPD審查的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2598.wav", + "text": "當時的國際審查委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2599.wav", + "text": "建立心理健康" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2600.wav", + "text": "同儕工作角色" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2601.wav", + "text": "以及基於同儕支援的執業" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2602.wav", + "text": "和復原服務" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2603.wav", + "text": "並為其提供資源" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2604.wav", + "text": "因此增加同儕工作者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2605.wav", + "text": "服務" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2606.wav", + "text": "也確保所有的身心障礙者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2607.wav", + "text": "相關的服務" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2608.wav", + "text": "參考長照法第9條的家庭照顧者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2609.wav", + "text": "支持服務" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2610.wav", + "text": "的定義可能不要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2611.wav", + "text": "限於家屬這麼的狹隘" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2612.wav", + "text": "而是能夠提供家庭照顧者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2613.wav", + "text": "相關的支持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2614.wav", + "text": "關於精神疾病家庭支持中心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2615.wav", + "text": "可能衛福部會認為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2616.wav", + "text": "現在一下子做不出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2617.wav", + "text": "精神疾病家庭支持中心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2618.wav", + "text": "我是可以作成附帶決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2619.wav", + "text": "但是我希望其他部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2620.wav", + "text": "及照顧者的服務能夠增加在這一" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2621.wav", + "text": "一條謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2622.wav", + "text": "先請王婉諭委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2623.wav", + "text": "發言然後衛福部再一併回答" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2624.wav", + "text": "的部分就如同剛剛范委員提到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2625.wav", + "text": "林召委的版本也有提到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2626.wav", + "text": "應該要有一些比較細項部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2627.wav", + "text": "當初衛福部來溝通的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2628.wav", + "text": "社區支持服務之內容及" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2629.wav", + "text": "執行方式由中央主管機關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2630.wav", + "text": "如果不是訂在原本的第23條內" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2631.wav", + "text": "其實我自己可以同意由" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2632.wav", + "text": "中央主管機關另外定之" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2633.wav", + "text": "而不是一減再減最後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2634.wav", + "text": "就消失了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2635.wav", + "text": "對啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2636.wav", + "text": "我也覺得你說明一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2637.wav", + "text": "本來有一些細項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2638.wav", + "text": "跟委員報告其實我們是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2639.wav", + "text": "第24條因為第24條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2640.wav", + "text": "支持服務內容加上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2641.wav", + "text": "怎麼樣獎補助獎補" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2642.wav", + "text": "我們後續要去做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2643.wav", + "text": "子法規的訂定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2644.wav", + "text": "所以我們把" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2645.wav", + "text": "一些條文做了一點整併" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2646.wav", + "text": "否則到處都寫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2647.wav", + "text": "不知道重點在哪裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2648.wav", + "text": "但是第24條我們今天不會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2649.wav", + "text": "處理上次已經通過了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2650.wav", + "text": "有通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2651.wav", + "text": "那個內容" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2652.wav", + "text": "在委員會的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2653.wav", + "text": "是有宣告委員吳玉琴等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2654.wav", + "text": "20人提案增訂第" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2655.wav", + "text": "十六條之1條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2656.wav", + "text": "就有列這一些細項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2657.wav", + "text": "條次定為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2658.wav", + "text": "第二十四條其後條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2659.wav", + "text": "次依次變更" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2660.wav", + "text": "是這樣嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2661.wav", + "text": "是這個大本的第二冊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2662.wav", + "text": "但是它的對象是只有中央" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2663.wav", + "text": "主管機關應該要獎勵" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2664.wav", + "text": "和補助的機構法人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2665.wav", + "text": "但第23條其實是更上位的就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2666.wav", + "text": "我們在談社區支持服務應該涵蓋哪些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2667.wav", + "text": "東西其中如果有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2668.wav", + "text": "如何認定才會是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2669.wav", + "text": "第24條但現在不是有第24條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2670.wav", + "text": "之後那第23條就不用了因為第23條涵蓋到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2671.wav", + "text": "工作或我們期待要做的服務工作這些就" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2672.wav", + "text": "應該要先定義出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2673.wav", + "text": "然後有經過補助的其資格認定才會在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2674.wav", + "text": "第24條處理所以你說因為有第24條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2675.wav", + "text": "第23條不要有其實有點奇怪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2676.wav", + "text": "我還是來幫忙補充說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2677.wav", + "text": "其實第23條的社區" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2678.wav", + "text": "支持服務大家都很關心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2679.wav", + "text": "衛福部提的是一個比較概括式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2680.wav", + "text": "的寫法但各位委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2681.wav", + "text": "都很" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2682.wav", + "text": "條列式的寫得很清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2683.wav", + "text": "所以剛剛范雲委員提到的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2684.wav", + "text": "居家服務心理支持等等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2685.wav", + "text": "等等大家都很想列" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2686.wav", + "text": "提的就是一個概括性的寫法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2687.wav", + "text": "很重要的是我的版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2688.wav", + "text": "的版本後來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2689.wav", + "text": "都有一些退讓就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2690.wav", + "text": "所以剛剛王委員也在擔心你連" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2691.wav", + "text": "授權的部分都劃掉了原來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2692.wav", + "text": "跟我們溝通的時候有提到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2693.wav", + "text": "要授權就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2694.wav", + "text": "社區支持服務之內容" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2695.wav", + "text": "及執行方式由中央主管機關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2696.wav", + "text": "在這邊細列至少你可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2697.wav", + "text": "授權\n剛剛諶司長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2698.wav", + "text": "的意思是第24條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2699.wav", + "text": "有點概略性地提到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2700.wav", + "text": "行政院的版本通過了我們在委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2701.wav", + "text": "通過的是中央主管機關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2702.wav", + "text": "應獎勵補助機構法人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2703.wav", + "text": "或團體從事病人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2704.wav", + "text": "社區支持及復健" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2705.wav", + "text": "相關服務前項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2706.wav", + "text": "從事服務之機構法人或" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2707.wav", + "text": "與其服務人員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2708.wav", + "text": "之資格條件服務內容" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2709.wav", + "text": "作業方式管理獎勵" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2710.wav", + "text": "補助及其他相關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2711.wav", + "text": "事項之辦法由中央主管機關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2712.wav", + "text": "會同中央勞動及教育主管" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2713.wav", + "text": "機關定之所以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2714.wav", + "text": "諶司長是希望第24條可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2715.wav", + "text": "的社區支持服務之內涵" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2716.wav", + "text": "可能包括服務內容都" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2717.wav", + "text": "在裡頭所以他覺得第24條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2718.wav", + "text": "及第23條要搭配來看第2" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2719.wav", + "text": "3條是規定地方" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2720.wav", + "text": "政府要提供這些服務" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2721.wav", + "text": "中央訂遊戲規則跟" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2722.wav", + "text": "獎勵辦法可能層次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2723.wav", + "text": "上他是這樣分\n某個程度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2724.wav", + "text": "上我有被說服但某些程度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2725.wav", + "text": "上也感到不安原來我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2726.wav", + "text": "大家希望社區支持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2727.wav", + "text": "又怕不夠周延" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2728.wav", + "text": "像剛剛提到的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2729.wav", + "text": "簡稱降落傘計畫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2730.wav", + "text": "也希望未來能夠不斷增加新型的服務" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2731.wav", + "text": "都可以授權在中央的子法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2732.wav", + "text": "規中訂定可是這邊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2733.wav", + "text": "又不寫了會不會漏掉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2734.wav", + "text": "可能部裡面再詳細說明一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2735.wav", + "text": "因為我知道你的邏輯是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2736.wav", + "text": "第23條為地方的職責" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2737.wav", + "text": "第24條是中央" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2738.wav", + "text": "子法但這樣夠不夠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2739.wav", + "text": "我們有一些擔憂請衛福部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2740.wav", + "text": "我們再看那個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2741.wav", + "text": "部分我覺得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2742.wav", + "text": "不同的內容可以放在同一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2743.wav", + "text": "授權辦法當中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2744.wav", + "text": "我們回去再跟法規" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2745.wav", + "text": "應該怎麼寫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2746.wav", + "text": "好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2747.wav", + "text": "授權辦法裡面也看得到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2748.wav", + "text": "整個社區支持的內涵" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2749.wav", + "text": "再來就是獎勵" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2750.wav", + "text": "你們的第24條已經通過了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2751.wav", + "text": "第24條已經通過了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2752.wav", + "text": "第24條不能再修" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2753.wav", + "text": "所以是第23條對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2754.wav", + "text": "我的建議還是一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2755.wav", + "text": "回復到原本的第5項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2756.wav", + "text": "社區支持服務之內容及執行方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2757.wav", + "text": "由中央主管" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2758.wav", + "text": "但如果只有第24條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2759.wav", + "text": "有可能那個子法就未涵蓋第23條的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2760.wav", + "text": "至於中央主管機關要不要把它變成是同一份" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2761.wav", + "text": "我覺得那是執行面的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2762.wav", + "text": "但應該要涵蓋的範圍包含第" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2763.wav", + "text": "第23條的內容及第24條的內容" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2764.wav", + "text": "這兩份是不是要變成一份" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2765.wav", + "text": "有道理嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2766.wav", + "text": "要增加第5項嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2767.wav", + "text": "衛福部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2768.wav", + "text": "可以我們就增加第5項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2769.wav", + "text": "那就是由我們定之" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2770.wav", + "text": "它是不是一個授權的辦法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2771.wav", + "text": "這樣在條文上要怎麼寫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2772.wav", + "text": "你們想一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2773.wav", + "text": "我們來修一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2774.wav", + "text": "也可以我們在其他的法規" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2775.wav", + "text": "第5項請你們去擬文字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2776.wav", + "text": "文字出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2777.wav", + "text": "委員吳玉琴等24人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2778.wav", + "text": "提案增訂第十六" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2779.wav", + "text": "條之1" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2780.wav", + "text": "條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2781.wav", + "text": "條次定為第二十四條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2782.wav", + "text": "其後條次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2783.wav", + "text": "依序變更" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2784.wav", + "text": "本法條次變更及條文內" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2785.wav", + "text": "條次調整" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2786.wav", + "text": "授權議事人員處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2787.wav", + "text": "新增條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2788.wav", + "text": "是大家同意的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2789.wav", + "text": "如果大家沒有意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2790.wav", + "text": "就照這個宣告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2791.wav", + "text": "通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2792.wav", + "text": "一下剛剛開會的時候您有宣告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2793.wav", + "text": "如果對通過的條文還有意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2794.wav", + "text": "不是說不能動" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2795.wav", + "text": "不是不能動" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2796.wav", + "text": "還是可以提" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2797.wav", + "text": "但是我們要走一輪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2798.wav", + "text": "之後你再提" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2799.wav", + "text": "修正動議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2800.wav", + "text": "的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2801.wav", + "text": "他們會弄第5項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2802.wav", + "text": "我的版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2803.wav", + "text": "有變動到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2804.wav", + "text": "說明欄" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2805.wav", + "text": "一併處理的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2806.wav", + "text": "再一起處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2807.wav", + "text": "立法說明的那部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2808.wav", + "text": "立法說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2809.wav", + "text": "五專線服務係指" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2810.wav", + "text": "提供病人與家屬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2811.wav", + "text": "溫暖型專線電話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2812.wav", + "text": "服務" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2813.wav", + "text": "我們在條文裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2814.wav", + "text": "提到的專線服務" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2815.wav", + "text": "你們的條文出來以後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2816.wav", + "text": "就順便討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2817.wav", + "text": "再一起處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2818.wav", + "text": "第27條處理完以後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2819.wav", + "text": "因為我們宣告的開會時間也到了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2820.wav", + "text": "其他的條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2821.wav", + "text": "等下一次協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2822.wav", + "text": "\n現在處理第27條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2823.wav", + "text": "請衛福部說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2824.wav", + "text": "第27條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2825.wav", + "text": "特別是針對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2826.wav", + "text": "社區心理衛生中心之" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2827.wav", + "text": "之設立" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2828.wav", + "text": "由社區心理衛生中心辦理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2829.wav", + "text": "教育訓練諮詢轉介轉銜服務" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2830.wav", + "text": "資源開發" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2831.wav", + "text": "社區心理衛生中心之病人個案管理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2832.wav", + "text": "依本法第32條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2833.wav", + "text": "第3項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2834.wav", + "text": "出院後之精神病人及" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2835.wav", + "text": "第49條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2836.wav", + "text": "第3項經指定精神醫療機構" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2837.wav", + "text": "治療後之精神病病人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2838.wav", + "text": "社區心理衛生中心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2839.wav", + "text": "請范委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2840.wav", + "text": "讓我們把這條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2841.wav", + "text": "討論完" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2842.wav", + "text": "討論之前我要先抗議一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2843.wav", + "text": "今天這些資料是哪個單位整理的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2844.wav", + "text": "為什麼我的第27條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2845.wav", + "text": "的提案16位立委所連署的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2846.wav", + "text": "都印成立法院關係文書而" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2847.wav", + "text": "而未被整理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2848.wav", + "text": "我的版本完全沒問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2849.wav", + "text": "但也遺漏我的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2850.wav", + "text": "造成大家跟我討論的困難度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2851.wav", + "text": "所以是不是請主席" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2852.wav", + "text": "注意一下這是怎麼整理的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2853.wav", + "text": "議事人員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2854.wav", + "text": "修正動議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2855.wav", + "text": "我們是有正式的���案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2856.wav", + "text": "不是修正動議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2857.wav", + "text": "併入協商的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2858.wav", + "text": "這邊整理出來的有這麼多委員的版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2859.wav", + "text": "為什麼我的部分沒有在裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2860.wav", + "text": "版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2861.wav", + "text": "併入協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2862.wav", + "text": "是這樣嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2863.wav", + "text": "那今天也都沒有辦法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2864.wav", + "text": "印出來嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2865.wav", + "text": "了不然怎麼討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2866.wav", + "text": "那要等將來院會之前的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2867.wav", + "text": "協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2868.wav", + "text": "好啦我跟大家說明一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2869.wav", + "text": "教育" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2870.wav", + "text": "訓練諮詢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2871.wav", + "text": "精神危機前期" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2872.wav", + "text": "積極介入措施" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2873.wav", + "text": "第二個是在後面前項社區" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2874.wav", + "text": "心理衛生中心應置心理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2875.wav", + "text": "護理職能治療社會工作" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2876.wav", + "text": "之後增加" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2877.wav", + "text": "同儕工作者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2878.wav", + "text": "這幾個字然後是原本的及其他相關專業人員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2879.wav", + "text": "單一窗口" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2880.wav", + "text": "第一個是希望能夠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2881.wav", + "text": "增加地方主管機關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2882.wav", + "text": "也要有剛剛講的精神危機前期" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2883.wav", + "text": "積極介入措施" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2884.wav", + "text": "後面就是社區心理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2885.wav", + "text": "衛生中心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2886.wav", + "text": "除了原本的心理護理職能治療" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2887.wav", + "text": "社工之外" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2888.wav", + "text": "希望增加同儕工作者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2889.wav", + "text": "窗口\n主要的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2890.wav", + "text": "和剛剛講得有關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2891.wav", + "text": "其實這樣都能夠讓它的服務" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2892.wav", + "text": "更到位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2893.wav", + "text": "也就是提供目前精神疾病" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2894.wav", + "text": "病人相關的服務" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2895.wav", + "text": "此外因為它的資源分散" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2896.wav", + "text": "所以單一窗口也是非常有必要的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2897.wav", + "text": "而且剛剛講到的精神危機前期" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2898.wav", + "text": "積極介入措施" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2899.wav", + "text": "也比較能夠在必要的時候提供" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2900.wav", + "text": "緊急救援" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2901.wav", + "text": "現在就算衛福部覺得還沒辦法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2902.wav", + "text": "完全長出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2903.wav", + "text": "放進去然後儘可能" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2904.wav", + "text": "階段性地去做到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2905.wav", + "text": "以上希望大家可以支持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2906.wav", + "text": "謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2907.wav", + "text": "好因為你的版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2908.wav", + "text": "一直到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2909.wav", + "text": "朝野協商的時候都還在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2910.wav", + "text": "27條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2911.wav", + "text": "請王婉諭委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2912.wav", + "text": "可是我們的修正動議第27條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2913.wav", + "text": "在討論的時候心衛中心的定義就包含" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2914.wav", + "text": "各級的部分都應該來努力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2915.wav", + "text": "所以文字上反而缺少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2916.wav", + "text": "措施或是衛福部想要定義的什麼名詞" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2917.wav", + "text": "不過概念都是一樣的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2918.wav", + "text": "其實這個部分應該是要納進去的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2919.wav", + "text": "工作者願意進入心衛中心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2920.wav", + "text": "一起來協力我們當然也樂觀其成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2921.wav", + "text": "而且這也是更好的方向" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2922.wav", + "text": "好所以第27條就" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2923.wav", + "text": "保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2924.wav", + "text": "\n現在處理第23條他們把" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2925.wav", + "text": "支持服務之內容及" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2926.wav", + "text": "執行方式由中央主管" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2927.wav", + "text": "機關公告之" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2928.wav", + "text": "所以它要去公告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2929.wav", + "text": "\n第23條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2930.wav", + "text": "衛福部再修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2931.wav", + "text": "條文協商通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2932.wav", + "text": "本條修法說明欄" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2933.wav", + "text": "增列第5項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2934.wav", + "text": "專線的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2935.wav", + "text": "吳玉琴委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2936.wav", + "text": "剛剛宣告我" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2937.wav", + "text": "但是接下來的討論還沒完成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2938.wav", + "text": "\n原來行政部門提供的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2939.wav", + "text": "都是既有的條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2940.wav", + "text": "中間插這一條進來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2941.wav", + "text": "有點混亂" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2942.wav", + "text": "因為到最後還是會授權議事人員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2943.wav", + "text": "所以我們應該將它暫定為在第23條之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2944.wav", + "text": "未來整個條文還是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2945.wav", + "text": "處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2946.wav", + "text": "不是嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2947.wav", + "text": "請拿麥克風" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2948.wav", + "text": "所以現在就定為第24條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2949.wav", + "text": "我們之後的討論都還是按照原來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2950.wav", + "text": "行政院版的條次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2951.wav", + "text": "次最後再授權由你們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2952.wav", + "text": "整理對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2953.wav", + "text": "\n請你說明一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2954.wav", + "text": "跟委員報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2955.wav", + "text": "因為本法是全案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2956.wav", + "text": "的階段就要把條次定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2957.wav", + "text": "定好定好之後比如說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2958.wav", + "text": "委員提的增訂第十六條之1" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2959.wav", + "text": "如果沒有把條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2960.wav", + "text": "次定為第二十四條將來在院會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2961.wav", + "text": "二三讀的時候就它的條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2962.wav", + "text": "議事處是沒有辦法處理的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2963.wav", + "text": "所以我們在黨團協商的時候就要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2964.wav", + "text": "把條次定為第二十四條因此我剛剛請" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2965.wav", + "text": "召委宣告的就是第" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2966.wav", + "text": "的條次變更條文裡面的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2967.wav", + "text": "才授權我們議事人員處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2968.wav", + "text": "以前的例子都是這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2969.wav", + "text": "我們剛剛唸的宣告裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2970.wav", + "text": "就是委員吳玉琴等20人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2971.wav", + "text": "提案增訂第十六條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2972.wav", + "text": "之1條文條次定為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2973.wav", + "text": "其後條次依序" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2974.wav", + "text": "變更本法條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2975.wav", + "text": "次變更及條文內" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2976.wav", + "text": "條次調整授權" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2977.wav", + "text": "議事人員處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2978.wav", + "text": "這次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2979.wav", + "text": "會議的宣告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2980.wav", + "text": "本日協商會議所" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2981.wav", + "text": "收各黨團及委員所提之" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2982.wav", + "text": "修正動議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2983.wav", + "text": "均列入紀錄" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2984.wav", + "text": "刊登公報" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2985.wav", + "text": "今日協商會議因時間已屆" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2986.wav", + "text": "先到此為止" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2987.wav", + "text": "下次協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2988.wav", + "text": "自保留條文之第32條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2989.wav", + "text": "開始進行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2990.wav", + "text": "\n現在散會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14496/2991.wav", + "text": "謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/0.wav", + "text": "現在宣立法院朝野黨團協商會議開始" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/1.wav", + "text": "今天要研商的主題是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/2.wav", + "text": "中選會函請本院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/3.wav", + "text": "推薦代表參加憲法修正案公民複決之發表會或辯論會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/4.wav", + "text": "相關事宜案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/5.wav", + "text": "所以先請法制局報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/6.wav", + "text": "讓大家做參考" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/7.wav", + "text": "交由修憲委員會研議處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/8.wav", + "text": "後經院長指示讓法制局加入幫忙研究相關法制問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/9.wav", + "text": "以下謹做簡要說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/10.wav", + "text": "\n距離最近一次修憲乃94年之第7次修憲" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/11.wav", + "text": "上次雖然也是由本院提出憲法修正案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/12.wav", + "text": "惟當時係由任務型國大複決" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/13.wav", + "text": "乃憲政史上第一次辦理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/14.wav", + "text": "並未細分憲法層次公投案及其他法律層次公投案之程序" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/15.wav", + "text": "以致中選會直接依照他們訂的法規命令" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/16.wav", + "text": "即全國性公民投票意見發表會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/17.wav", + "text": "或辯論會實施辦法第3條規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/18.wav", + "text": "由立法院代表正方" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/19.wav", + "text": "來函說明的最後一頁" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/20.wav", + "text": "也就是剛剛所報告的全國性公投意見發表會或辯論會實施辦法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/21.wav", + "text": "來要求國會推薦參加憲法層次的公民投票案相關發表會或辯論會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/22.wav", + "text": "依照這個方式運作" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/23.wav", + "text": "是否適合由本院建立這種憲政慣例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/24.wav", + "text": "也請各位委員商討" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/25.wav", + "text": "議事處將本件修憲案送交中選會辦理公投時" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/26.wav", + "text": "適用一般公投案有關提案連署審核及相關處理程序" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/27.wav", + "text": "\n至於現行公投法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/28.wav", + "text": "沒有針對修憲複決案性質" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/29.wav", + "text": "排除性質不相符的程序規範" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/30.wav", + "text": "並進而一體適用的法制疑義亦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/31.wav", + "text": "請各位委員參閱本局之書面參考意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/32.wav", + "text": "以上簡單說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/33.wav", + "text": "我請教一下法制局意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/34.wav", + "text": "過去修憲是由國民大會提" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/35.wav", + "text": "出這次是第一次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/36.wav", + "text": "由立法院提出憲法修正案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/37.wav", + "text": "制局是贊成立法院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/38.wav", + "text": "派人參加嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/39.wav", + "text": "跟委員說明一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/40.wav", + "text": "比較低位階的法規命令" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/41.wav", + "text": "辦理直接代為推定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/42.wav", + "text": "立法院是正方" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/43.wav", + "text": "行政院是反方" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/44.wav", + "text": "然而這跟我們提出憲法修正案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/45.wav", + "text": "乃依照憲法增修條文規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/46.wav", + "text": "經過四分之三委員高度共識的情況下所提出" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/47.wav", + "text": "的而行政部門" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/48.wav", + "text": "則依照低位階法規命令" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/49.wav", + "text": "來代為推定誰是正方" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/50.wav", + "text": "誰是反方" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/51.wav", + "text": "這點在此次公民複決程序" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/52.wav", + "text": "確有扞格與不合理之處" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/53.wav", + "text": "以上說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/54.wav", + "text": "2005年修憲以後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/55.wav", + "text": "我們第一次碰到的狀" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/56.wav", + "text": "狀況2005年時" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/57.wav", + "text": "我們修的是單一選區兩票制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/58.wav", + "text": "制那時候還有國大" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/59.wav", + "text": "所以那時候是由立法院擔任正方" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/60.wav", + "text": "派立法院副院長鍾榮吉到國大去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/61.wav", + "text": "然後由國大去複決" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/62.wav", + "text": "而這一次則是史無前例的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/63.wav", + "text": "\n剛才法制局長表示行政院是反方" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/64.wav", + "text": "那是推定的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/65.wav", + "text": "行政院今天已經正式行文給中選會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/66.wav", + "text": "中選會也公告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/67.wav", + "text": "了行政院表示自己是正方" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/68.wav", + "text": "它是基於三個理由" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/69.wav", + "text": "包括這個有具體正面的意義" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/70.wav", + "text": "國際潮流" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/71.wav", + "text": "以及讓年輕人能夠有完善的權利義務" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/72.wav", + "text": "行政院已經表示" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/73.wav", + "text": "它是正方" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/74.wav", + "text": "哪有行政院變成反方" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/75.wav", + "text": "依照法律的推定那是因為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/76.wav", + "text": "以前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/77.wav", + "text": "正反方都有人連署" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/78.wav", + "text": "不過既然行政院已經表示自己" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/79.wav", + "text": "己是正方" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/80.wav", + "text": "了看起來這個程序我們不走也不行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/81.wav", + "text": "辯論會要在10月20日之前報名" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/82.wav", + "text": "也可以說是辯論會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/83.wav", + "text": "如果沒有反方的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/84.wav", + "text": "也有人要當正方的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/85.wav", + "text": "其程序是怎麼樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/86.wav", + "text": "當然要向立法院來申請" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/87.wav", + "text": "但他要符合有設立辦事處" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/88.wav", + "text": "有在宣傳" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/89.wav", + "text": "條件夠了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/90.wav", + "text": "因為我們有5個名額看要讓幾個給他們都可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/91.wav", + "text": "假如有人要當反方的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/92.wav", + "text": "怎麼辦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/93.wav", + "text": "他也要去成立辦事處去宣傳" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/94.wav", + "text": "10月20日以前要決定這些事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/95.wav", + "text": "是乎假如都有人去申請正方反方的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/96.wav", + "text": "當然有正反方的辯論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/97.wav", + "text": "如果沒有那就是單方的電視發表會而已" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/98.wav", + "text": "大概是這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/99.wav", + "text": "\n我認為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/100.wav", + "text": "這個程序我們一定要把它完成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/101.wav", + "text": "如我們這個步驟不做的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/102.wav", + "text": "將來會受到挑戰" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/103.wav", + "text": "我想沒有人擔得起" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/104.wav", + "text": "反正這5場是電視" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/105.wav", + "text": "辯論會也罷" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/106.wav", + "text": "是說明會也罷" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/107.wav", + "text": "是意見陳述也罷" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/108.wav", + "text": "剛才法制局可能沒有注意到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/109.wav", + "text": "行政院已經行文給中選會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/110.wav", + "text": "而且中選會今天已經" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/111.wav", + "text": "\n對它已經公告了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/112.wav", + "text": "中選會也公告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/113.wav", + "text": "了怎麼可能行政當反方" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/114.wav", + "text": "呢那不可能嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/115.wav", + "text": "中選會已經公告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/116.wav", + "text": "行政院表示的意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/117.wav", + "text": "是要當正方" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/118.wav", + "text": "大概是這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/119.wav", + "text": "大家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/120.wav", + "text": "發給本院的函裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/121.wav", + "text": "第四點就已經提到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/122.wav", + "text": "正方是由大院推薦5位代表人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/123.wav", + "text": "要是我沒有聽錯" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/124.wav", + "text": "法制局是不是有一點點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/125.wav", + "text": "不同的意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/126.wav", + "text": "行政命令沒有辦法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/127.wav", + "text": "國民黨的立場是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/128.wav", + "text": "我在這邊建議啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/129.wav", + "text": "立法院有5位可以代表的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/130.wav", + "text": "我們國民黨想要爭取2位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/131.wav", + "text": "我們希望能夠爭取" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/132.wav", + "text": "為什麼你要爭取" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/133.wav", + "text": "因為這個函寫得非常明白" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/134.wav", + "text": "就是立法院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/135.wav", + "text": "沒有關係我們等一下再講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/136.wav", + "text": "謝謝院長及各黨團的黨鞭" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/137.wav", + "text": "鞭其實台灣民眾黨對於修憲的態度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/138.wav", + "text": "一直都是保持一致的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/139.wav", + "text": "尤其針對18歲公民權的提倡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/140.wav", + "text": "我們也是從第一個會期就開始" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/141.wav", + "text": "不遺餘力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/142.wav", + "text": "但是我們剛剛也聽到法制局的意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/143.wav", + "text": "還有各位委員的寶貴意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/144.wav", + "text": "因為這一次是第一次公民複決的修憲案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/145.wav", + "text": "公投法第十七條第二項是否適用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/146.wav", + "text": "或如何適用修憲複決案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/147.wav", + "text": "這個程序我覺得還是要把它釐清清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/148.wav", + "text": "對於中選會送過來的這個公文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/149.wav", + "text": "其實法制局有位階上不同的意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/150.wav", + "text": "再來就是行政院也沒有完全依照" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/151.wav", + "text": "他們現在的建議或要求" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/152.wav", + "text": "行政院也要求要擔任正方" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/153.wav", + "text": "當然如果能夠透過發表會或是辯論會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/154.wav", + "text": "向民眾示明下修公民權" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/155.wav", + "text": "至18歲的重要性跟代表性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/156.wav", + "text": "我覺得這個都是正面的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/157.wav", + "text": "相信大家也是贊成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/158.wav", + "text": "的但是關於程序面的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/159.wav", + "text": "我想我們還是要用謹慎的態度去處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/160.wav", + "text": "因為這件事是中選會主管" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/161.wav", + "text": "所以我認為議事處還是要發文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/162.wav", + "text": "向中選會說明法制局跟委員提供的看法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/163.wav", + "text": "不要在程序上有瑕疵" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/164.wav", + "text": "尤其是現在到底是要透過辯論會或是發表會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/165.wav", + "text": "我覺得這個部分要先把它定義清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/166.wav", + "text": "至於各黨代表的名額" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/167.wav", + "text": "大家可以再來討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/168.wav", + "text": "以及我們大家同不同意這件事" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/169.wav", + "text": "程序上會不會有瑕疵" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/170.wav", + "text": "等這個部分應該要先確定清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/171.wav", + "text": "\n我想這一題應該沒有人願意擔任反方吧" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/172.wav", + "text": "看起來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/173.wav", + "text": "我不曉得反方到底" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/174.wav", + "text": "要如何擔任如果是這樣的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/175.wav", + "text": "是不是要透過發表會的形式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/176.wav", + "text": "就是立法院的態度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/177.wav", + "text": "如果是這樣的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/178.wav", + "text": "我們要往下走就會比較容易" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/179.wav", + "text": "我本來以為今天中選會會派人到現場來說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/180.wav", + "text": "但是沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/181.wav", + "text": "看來今天是立法院內大家先凝聚共識" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/182.wav", + "text": "先提供大家參考謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/183.wav", + "text": "請邱總召" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/184.wav", + "text": "院長各位同仁" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/185.wav", + "text": "因為中選會發函的第四點提到正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/186.wav", + "text": "正方由立法院推薦5位代表人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/187.wav", + "text": "至於反方這邊寫的是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/188.wav", + "text": "得由行政院推薦2位代表人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/189.wav", + "text": "或依公投法第2條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/190.wav", + "text": "經許可設立辦事處的反對意見者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/191.wav", + "text": "推薦3位代表人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/192.wav", + "text": "行政院也認為自己是正方嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/193.wav", + "text": "所以看起來行政院也不可能去擔任反方" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/194.wav", + "text": "因為這涉及到18歲公民權" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/195.wav", + "text": "是定死在這邊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/196.wav", + "text": "而且說實在的這已經遲到太久了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/197.wav", + "text": "啦全世界幾乎沒有幾個國家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/198.wav", + "text": "還是像臺灣一樣要到20歲才可以投票" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/199.wav", + "text": "所以這個要讓它過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/200.wav", + "text": "是一個非常重要的事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/201.wav", + "text": "立法院各黨團都已經有共識" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/202.wav", + "text": "了而且是四分之一委員提議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/203.wav", + "text": "出席委員四分之三同意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/204.wav", + "text": "送出立法院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/205.wav", + "text": "好不容易才送出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/206.wav", + "text": "這樣一個修憲案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/207.wav", + "text": "我們當然希望真的能夠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/208.wav", + "text": "但是要通過這個公投" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/209.wav", + "text": "需要971萬張的選票" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/210.wav", + "text": "比起蔡總統的得票817萬還要高" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/211.wav", + "text": "但是正方能夠多多的論述" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/212.wav", + "text": "並且讓國人能夠瞭解到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/213.wav", + "text": "18歲公民權的重要性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/214.wav", + "text": "這當然也是一個非常重要的事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/215.wav", + "text": "不管它是電視辯論會也好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/216.wav", + "text": "或者是發表會也好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/217.wav", + "text": "然後能夠讓國人瞭解" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/218.wav", + "text": "18歲公民權對現代臺灣民主的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/219.wav", + "text": "重要性跟它的意義" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/220.wav", + "text": "我想中選會當然有它的說法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/221.wav", + "text": "但是請各位同仁不要忘了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/222.wav", + "text": "立法院是憲政機關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/223.wav", + "text": "就是說我覺得我們是在立下憲政的慣例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/224.wav", + "text": "我們一定是正方這是毫無疑問的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/225.wav", + "text": "出席四分之三立委投票通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/226.wav", + "text": "的當然我們要代表去捍衛我們的這一塊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/227.wav", + "text": "至於行政院的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/228.wav", + "text": "如果照中選會說法他們應該扮演反方" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/229.wav", + "text": "而他們也放棄了扮演反方的角色" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/230.wav", + "text": "但我們就不管行政院要做什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/231.wav", + "text": "我們當然還是正方" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/232.wav", + "text": "所以我們的這一塊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/233.wav", + "text": "就只是很單純的要派多少人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/234.wav", + "text": "各政黨怎麼派" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/235.wav", + "text": "然後去為我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/236.wav", + "text": "四分之三通過的憲法修正案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/237.wav", + "text": "去辯護就是這麼單純而已" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/238.wav", + "text": "至於中選會那部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/239.wav", + "text": "我覺得不是我們關注的重點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/240.wav", + "text": "我們的決定絕對比它大" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/241.wav", + "text": "因為我們是憲政機關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/242.wav", + "text": "我們要立下憲政慣例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/243.wav", + "text": "是很單純的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/244.wav", + "text": "只是要派多少人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/245.wav", + "text": "如果行政院他們要辯" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/246.wav", + "text": "那他們的quota用過去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/247.wav", + "text": "我們的部分就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/248.wav", + "text": "我們把它發揮到極致" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/249.wav", + "text": "我相信每一個政黨都很願意去為這個議題辯護" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/250.wav", + "text": "那應該沒有太大的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/251.wav", + "text": "過去2次公投我都有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/252.wav", + "text": "上去做公投的辯論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/253.wav", + "text": "看起來滿明確的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/254.wav", + "text": "其實如果沒有人去跟中選會申請反方辦事處的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/255.wav", + "text": "也許一個很可能的狀況就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/256.wav", + "text": "沒有反方就是5場" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/257.wav", + "text": "但每一場都只有正方做論述" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/258.wav", + "text": "我覺得看起來這是有可能的狀況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/259.wav", + "text": "當然就像剛才羅委員說的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/260.wav", + "text": "反正我們立法院的工作就是派出5個正方" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/261.wav", + "text": "那我們這5個正方要怎麼處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/262.wav", + "text": "到時候有沒有反方" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/263.wav", + "text": "確實我們現在還沒有辦法說定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/264.wav", + "text": "也許突然有個團體殺出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/265.wav", + "text": "說要去成立反方辦事處" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/266.wav", + "text": "也不一定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/267.wav", + "text": "因為今天中選會才公布題目" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/268.wav", + "text": "也就是要成立反方辦事處或正方辦事處" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/269.wav", + "text": "都是今天才能夠起跑" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/270.wav", + "text": "畢竟要有題目才能夠申請正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/271.wav", + "text": "正反方的辦事處" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/272.wav", + "text": "所以之後會不會有反方辦事處或怎麼樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/273.wav", + "text": "其實我們也不知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/274.wav", + "text": "但我們今天的工作很清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/275.wav", + "text": "就是立法院這邊用什麼方法協調出5位正方的代表" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/276.wav", + "text": "我覺得命題倒是相對清楚的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/277.wav", + "text": "一直以來有長期推動" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/278.wav", + "text": "18歲公民權的民間團體" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/279.wav", + "text": "來問我們說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/280.wav", + "text": "第一個他們想成立正方辦事處" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/281.wav", + "text": "有機會的話他們想爭取成為上場" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/282.wav", + "text": "去做正方辯護的代表" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/283.wav", + "text": "他們有提出這個強烈的意願" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/284.wav", + "text": "那就看我們等一下怎麼討論這個事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/285.wav", + "text": "謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/286.wav", + "text": "所以在這裡對於剛剛法制局所講的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/287.wav", + "text": "那是不對的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/288.wav", + "text": "好像看起來不必" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/289.wav", + "text": "去參加這場辯論會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/290.wav", + "text": "是不是這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/291.wav", + "text": "他沒有這樣講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/292.wav", + "text": "中選會原來的公文裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/293.wav", + "text": "對啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/294.wav", + "text": "他說行政院是反方" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/295.wav", + "text": "第二點就是一般大家會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/296.wav", + "text": "憲政層次跟一般法律層次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/297.wav", + "text": "這兩個層次是不一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/298.wav", + "text": "就是在創造憲政慣例喔" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/299.wav", + "text": "這個剛才羅委員也講了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/300.wav", + "text": "大家共同決定共同承擔嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/301.wav", + "text": "所以剛才" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/302.wav", + "text": "法制局說行政院是反方" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/303.wav", + "text": "那是錯誤的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/304.wav", + "text": "公告了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/305.wav", + "text": "那個只是推定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/306.wav", + "text": "我們今天不是在討論這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/307.wav", + "text": "法制局也不要講這種話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/308.wav", + "text": "而且中選會已經公告了行政院是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/309.wav", + "text": "正方" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/310.wav", + "text": "我是覺得大家小心一點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/311.wav", + "text": "\n第二個當然立法院現在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/312.wav", + "text": "是唯一的修憲機關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/313.wav", + "text": "來創造憲政慣例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/314.wav", + "text": "現在很清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/315.wav", + "text": "這也很快喔" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/316.wav", + "text": "然後來申請" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/317.wav", + "text": "假如有正方要跟我們申請我們再" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/318.wav", + "text": "來看待這個事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/319.wav", + "text": "反方是不是有人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/320.wav", + "text": "倒不是我們的事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/321.wav", + "text": "把這些程序先確定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/322.wav", + "text": "那我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/323.wav", + "text": "有那種" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/324.wav", + "text": "要推動" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/325.wav", + "text": "這些到現在為止" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/326.wav", + "text": "還沒確定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/327.wav", + "text": "表示它是正方" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/328.wav", + "text": "行政院可不可以加入正方代表" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/329.wav", + "text": "假如行政院加進來的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/330.wav", + "text": "我們4黨加上行政院5個就滿了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/331.wav", + "text": "到時候有人來申請" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/332.wav", + "text": "看誰要讓他也無所謂" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/333.wav", + "text": "到時再看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/334.wav", + "text": "這個先明確化" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/335.wav", + "text": "今天應該" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/336.wav", + "text": "要找中選會一起來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/337.wav", + "text": "我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/338.wav", + "text": "程序先明確化以後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/339.wav", + "text": "才能夠決定後續的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/340.wav", + "text": "我看行政院這個是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/341.wav", + "text": "後來的文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/342.wav", + "text": "對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/343.wav", + "text": "文有先後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/344.wav", + "text": "那個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/345.wav", + "text": "文是今天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/346.wav", + "text": "他早就去文了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/347.wav", + "text": "中選會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/348.wav", + "text": "現在是要彌補這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/349.wav", + "text": "這是有問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/350.wav", + "text": "沒關係啦現在就是大家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/351.wav", + "text": "共同承擔" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/352.wav", + "text": "不要一開始講說什麼行政院是反方" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/353.wav", + "text": "人家已經問行政院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/354.wav", + "text": "而且已經正式公告了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/355.wav", + "text": "現在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/356.wav", + "text": "大家都同意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/357.wav", + "text": "嘛那我們接下來就討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/358.wav", + "text": "推薦人數分配的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/359.wav", + "text": "那至少應該保留1席" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/360.wav", + "text": "就是1位給民眾代表" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/361.wav", + "text": "所以我們現在看怎麼樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/362.wav", + "text": "做有4位代表" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/363.wav", + "text": "要如何分配" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/364.wav", + "text": "1黨派1黨派1位大家有意見嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/365.wav", + "text": "行政院既然加入正方" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/366.wav", + "text": "看它要不要派可不可以派" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/367.wav", + "text": "由大院推薦5位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/368.wav", + "text": "為什麼要保留行政院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/369.wav", + "text": "沒有啊這是給" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/370.wav", + "text": "大院啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/371.wav", + "text": "指立法院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/372.wav", + "text": "沒有關係不要緊張" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/373.wav", + "text": "我們的4個先派好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/374.wav", + "text": "再公平也不過了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/375.wav", + "text": "反方只有一個人會做反方另" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/376.wav", + "text": "給民眾團體坦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/377.wav", + "text": "白講啦會做反方只有一個人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/378.wav", + "text": "社會大眾" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/379.wav", + "text": "最後1個讓院長去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/380.wav", + "text": "第5個留給所謂的社會團體" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/381.wav", + "text": "到時候我們怎麼樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/382.wav", + "text": "來遴選這個社會團體" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/383.wav", + "text": "這是非常非常複雜" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/384.wav", + "text": "因為中選會抽籤" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/385.wav", + "text": "但是有問題啊為什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/386.wav", + "text": "因為它是希望由我們推" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/387.wav", + "text": "是立法院推薦喔" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/388.wav", + "text": "這部分我們再處理嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/389.wav", + "text": "後面有程序啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/390.wav", + "text": "但是我會建議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/391.wav", + "text": "要不我們立法院就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/392.wav", + "text": "4席我們1黨1席" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/393.wav", + "text": "沒有沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/394.wav", + "text": "全國性公民投票意見發表會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/395.wav", + "text": "或辯論會實施辦法裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/396.wav", + "text": "正方" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/397.wav", + "text": "只有5個代表" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/398.wav", + "text": "還有更多嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/399.wav", + "text": "沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/400.wav", + "text": "時間已經押出來了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/401.wav", + "text": "了不來就視同放棄嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/402.wav", + "text": "團體可不可以參加" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/403.wav", + "text": "有沒有團體的名額" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/404.wav", + "text": "可以啊民間團體嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/405.wav", + "text": "依法來成立" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/406.wav", + "text": "如果有團體來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/407.wav", + "text": "我們再來處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/408.wav", + "text": "或是你們兩個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/409.wav", + "text": "這個是常理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/410.wav", + "text": "修憲是大家共同的議題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/411.wav", + "text": "所以我們就是把那一席" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/412.wav", + "text": "透過開放" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/413.wav", + "text": "由團體來申請" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/414.wav", + "text": "我們到時候再討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/415.wav", + "text": "哪一個團體比較適合" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/416.wav", + "text": "大家各政黨來共同決定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/417.wav", + "text": "這樣可以嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/418.wav", + "text": "那一個到最後還是要大家協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/419.wav", + "text": "對啊大家協商嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/420.wav", + "text": "我講一個事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/421.wav", + "text": "坦白說我自己做過民間團體" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/422.wav", + "text": "我曾經去申請過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/423.wav", + "text": "正方辦事處" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/424.wav", + "text": "其實現在是12日從現在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/425.wav", + "text": "到20日只剩8天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/426.wav", + "text": "連署人要300多位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/427.wav", + "text": "因為今天才公布題目" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/428.wav", + "text": "他沒有辦法提前先做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/429.wav", + "text": "所以要在8天內完成300多人的連署" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/430.wav", + "text": "還要寄回來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/431.wav", + "text": "坦白說我不能說完全不可能" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/432.wav", + "text": "但是難度滿高的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/433.wav", + "text": "讓大家知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/434.wav", + "text": "這個資訊總之我們之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/435.wav", + "text": "還是會遴選一個團體" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/436.wav", + "text": "完成所謂正方辦事處的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/437.wav", + "text": "坦白說是不容易" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/438.wav", + "text": "的大家連署過就知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/439.wav", + "text": "現在我們就討論場次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/440.wav", + "text": "要怎麼分配" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/441.wav", + "text": "大家有看到嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/442.wav", + "text": "這邊有寫幾月幾日的場次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/443.wav", + "text": "第1場" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/444.wav", + "text": "第1場" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/445.wav", + "text": "先表達" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/446.wav", + "text": "們要第1場" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/447.wav", + "text": "第1場" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/448.wav", + "text": "抽籤就好了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/449.wav", + "text": "可是現在我們只有4個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/450.wav", + "text": "哪一個是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/451.wav", + "text": "空下來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/452.wav", + "text": "如果大家有共識" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/453.wav", + "text": "那我們就做第1場到第4場" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/454.wav", + "text": "然後讓大家來抽" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/455.wav", + "text": "第5場" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/456.wav", + "text": "再請各黨團來簽署" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/457.wav", + "text": "\n二臺灣常被國際譽為民主典範" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/458.wav", + "text": "但至今尚未實施18歲公民權" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/459.wav", + "text": "年底將舉行公民複決" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/460.wav", + "text": "中選會辦理本次憲法複決案時" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/461.wav", + "text": "要兼顧正方的意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/462.wav", + "text": "充分宣導" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/463.wav", + "text": "全國同胞" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/464.wav", + "text": "今年11月26日" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/465.wav", + "text": "大家一定要出來投票" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/466.wav", + "text": "為18歲公民權修憲案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/467.wav", + "text": "投下公民複決的同意票" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/468.wav", + "text": "阿母招阿爸" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/469.wav", + "text": "大家投票挺18』" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/470.wav", + "text": "』\n三會後我們將本次會議的公報紀錄" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/471.wav", + "text": "函送中選會做為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/472.wav", + "text": "其執行相關業務" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/473.wav", + "text": "及日後修正法規之參考" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/474.wav", + "text": "這樣可不可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/475.wav", + "text": "決定事項一" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/476.wav", + "text": "各黨團同意有關中央選舉委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/477.wav", + "text": "舉辦之憲法修正案公民複決發表會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/478.wav", + "text": "由各黨團分別推薦1位代表人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/479.wav", + "text": "民進黨黨團推薦代表參加第1場次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/480.wav", + "text": "國民黨黨團推薦代表參加第4場次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/481.wav", + "text": "台灣民眾黨黨團推薦代表參加第2場次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/482.wav", + "text": "時代力量黨團推薦代表參加第3場次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/483.wav", + "text": "上述名單請於10月19日（星期三）中午" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/484.wav", + "text": "12時前送交議事處彙整\n二" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/485.wav", + "text": "基於時效考量" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/486.wav", + "text": "本案授權議事處於10月20日以前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14480/487.wav", + "text": "將上述名單資料函送中央選舉委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/0.wav", + "text": "現在各黨團的黨鞭都已經到齊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1.wav", + "text": "我們就開始進行今天的協商會議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/2.wav", + "text": "\n在進行協商之前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/3.wav", + "text": "先跟各黨團做個報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/4.wav", + "text": "由於原住民族文化事業基金會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/5.wav", + "text": "董監事的任期將於12月屆滿" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/6.wav", + "text": "行政院函請本院推舉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/7.wav", + "text": "社會公正人士擔任" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/8.wav", + "text": "董監事資格審查委員一案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/9.wav", + "text": "由政黨比例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/10.wav", + "text": "推舉13位公正人士組成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/11.wav", + "text": "相關的草稿請各黨團" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/12.wav", + "text": "如果同意就簽署" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/13.wav", + "text": "等一下一起處理嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/14.wav", + "text": "要簽的時候一起簽" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/15.wav", + "text": "就循例嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/16.wav", + "text": "這是循例啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/17.wav", + "text": "等一下大家看一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/18.wav", + "text": "審查委員名單啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/19.wav", + "text": "好這個讓大家看一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/20.wav", + "text": "\n現在我們就進行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/21.wav", + "text": "警械使用條例的協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/22.wav", + "text": "我先介紹" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/23.wav", + "text": "長有內政部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/24.wav", + "text": "徐國勇部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/25.wav", + "text": "黃明昭署長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/26.wav", + "text": "法務部陳明堂政務次長\n" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/27.wav", + "text": "\n現在我們就" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/28.wav", + "text": "開始進行今天的協商議題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/29.wav", + "text": "研商警械使用條例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/30.wav", + "text": "部分條文修正草案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/31.wav", + "text": "\n案這是由民進黨黨團" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/32.wav", + "text": "國民黨黨團提議協商的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/33.wav", + "text": "最主要是第4條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/34.wav", + "text": "第10條之1" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/35.wav", + "text": "及第十一條這3條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/36.wav", + "text": "就照委員會的意見通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/37.wav", + "text": "我們現在就集中討論這3條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/38.wav", + "text": "看大家的意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/39.wav", + "text": "院長各位同仁" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/40.wav", + "text": "有關警械使用條例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/41.wav", + "text": "剛才院長講的沒有錯" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/42.wav", + "text": "委員會修的時候是12條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/43.wav", + "text": "第10條之1" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/44.wav", + "text": "是有關調查小組" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/45.wav", + "text": "針對第四條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/46.wav", + "text": "有作文字修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/47.wav", + "text": "第四條的文字修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/48.wav", + "text": "內容等一下再來講沒有關係" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/49.wav", + "text": "最主要就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/50.wav", + "text": "警察用槍的時機" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/51.wav", + "text": "整個警械使用條例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/52.wav", + "text": "我們是要碰觸這一塊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/53.wav", + "text": "什麼時候要對空鳴槍" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/54.wav", + "text": "什麼時候可以開槍" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/55.wav", + "text": "當然這個問題必須很明確" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/56.wav", + "text": "所以我們在第四條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/57.wav", + "text": "去修正這個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/58.wav", + "text": "但是我同時也看到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/59.wav", + "text": "是不是等一下我們就針對這幾個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/60.wav", + "text": "來討論就可以了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/61.wav", + "text": "以上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/62.wav", + "text": "院長各位同仁" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/63.wav", + "text": "徐部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/64.wav", + "text": "及陳次長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/65.wav", + "text": "當然是一個非常非常" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/66.wav", + "text": "重要的事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/67.wav", + "text": "我們的版本有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/68.wav", + "text": "三個重點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/69.wav", + "text": "就是不希望" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/70.wav", + "text": "再有下一個警察的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/71.wav", + "text": "\n第一個就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/72.wav", + "text": "第1條的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/73.wav", + "text": "我們認為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/74.wav", + "text": "應該要有一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/75.wav", + "text": "足夠防禦的防護設備跟訓練" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/76.wav", + "text": "精進員警執勤安全方案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/77.wav", + "text": "動用第二預備金" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/78.wav", + "text": "經費核定近5億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/79.wav", + "text": "元4.8億" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/80.wav", + "text": "途第一個是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/81.wav", + "text": "設置13個互動式靶場" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/82.wav", + "text": "第二個是採購電擊槍" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/83.wav", + "text": "第三個是採購警棍" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/84.wav", + "text": "這13個靶場" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/85.wav", + "text": "平均每位同仁一年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/86.wav", + "text": "才訓練不到一次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/87.wav", + "text": "第二個電擊槍則平均" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/88.wav", + "text": "每100位員警" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/89.wav", + "text": "只有6位可以配發到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/90.wav", + "text": "在回答我的質詢時表示" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/91.wav", + "text": "即便是他這種解釋" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/92.wav", + "text": "也不會100位警察" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/93.wav", + "text": "只有6位可以配發到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/94.wav", + "text": "嘉義鐵路殺警案到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/95.wav", + "text": "本次臺南殺警案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/96.wav", + "text": "可以看到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/97.wav", + "text": "兇嫌的犯案手法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/98.wav", + "text": "都是近身持刀攻擊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/99.wav", + "text": "但是中央到目前為止採購的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/100.wav", + "text": "防砍功能背心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/101.wav", + "text": "是0件" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/102.wav", + "text": "件不曾採購任何具備" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/103.wav", + "text": "防砍功能的背心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/104.wav", + "text": "讓第一線同仁" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/105.wav", + "text": "置身於風險中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/106.wav", + "text": "我真的非常生氣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/107.wav", + "text": "因為他說警政署的防彈背心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/108.wav", + "text": "都有防砍的功能" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/109.wav", + "text": "這完全是莫名其妙" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/110.wav", + "text": "他也搞不清楚狀況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/111.wav", + "text": "防彈背心就是防彈背心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/112.wav", + "text": "有的有防砍功能" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/113.wav", + "text": "有的沒有防砍功能" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/114.wav", + "text": "但是防砍衣基本上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/115.wav", + "text": "就是另外一個配備" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/116.wav", + "text": "你現在到底要不要去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/117.wav", + "text": "處理這個問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/118.wav", + "text": "這是我們所關切的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/119.wav", + "text": "所以我們希望這個部分應該要入法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/120.wav", + "text": "從嘉義到臺南的殺警案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/121.wav", + "text": "已經失去了3位年輕警察同仁的生命" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/122.wav", + "text": "不應該再讓這樣的遺憾" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/123.wav", + "text": "繼續發生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/124.wav", + "text": "所以應該把提供充足的裝備" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/125.wav", + "text": "及訓練入法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/126.wav", + "text": "\n我再提醒大家一點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/127.wav", + "text": "按照警政署的規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/128.wav", + "text": "這個是1976年的訓練規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/129.wav", + "text": "應該要訓練的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/130.wav", + "text": "體技訓練則是4到6個小時" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/131.wav", + "text": "但是到現在都完全沒有達成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/132.wav", + "text": "應該是說有四分之一的機關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/133.wav", + "text": "沒有達成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/134.wav", + "text": "如果是體技訓練" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/135.wav", + "text": "則是百分之百的機關都沒有達成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/136.wav", + "text": "就是希望它能夠入法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/137.wav", + "text": "這是第1條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/138.wav", + "text": "\n第4條就是剛剛柯總召講的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/139.wav", + "text": "警察應該具備連續性強制力的概念" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/140.wav", + "text": "這是一個美國法上面的概念" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/141.wav", + "text": "所以我們希望在第4條的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/142.wav", + "text": "不管是要使用警棍" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/143.wav", + "text": "或是要使用警刀槍械等等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/144.wav", + "text": "不是依所辦的案件類型去區分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/145.wav", + "text": "而是應該以情境的強度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/146.wav", + "text": "也就是以他面對的危險性為依據" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/147.wav", + "text": "一條一條來好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/148.wav", + "text": "邱委員一條一條來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/149.wav", + "text": "好那就先從第1條開始" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/150.wav", + "text": "因為這一條是定義而已" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/151.wav", + "text": "是警械使用條例的定義" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/152.wav", + "text": "要怎麼增加設備" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/153.wav", + "text": "體例上是不是這樣的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/154.wav", + "text": "還有說你們設備不足" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/155.wav", + "text": "你要回答一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/156.wav", + "text": "增加這一項是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/157.wav", + "text": "還是改院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/158.wav", + "text": "各位委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/159.wav", + "text": "因為這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/160.wav", + "text": "還有執勤的辨識" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/161.wav", + "text": "如果再加入裝備的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/162.wav", + "text": "是不是立法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/163.wav", + "text": "我們建議是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/164.wav", + "text": "這樣會不會比較妥適一點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/165.wav", + "text": "包括他的防護裝備等等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/166.wav", + "text": "種類滿多的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/167.wav", + "text": "是給我們行政機關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/168.wav", + "text": "一個彈性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/169.wav", + "text": "我們在附帶決議裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/170.wav", + "text": "充實我們的裝備" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/171.wav", + "text": "是不是可以做這樣的建議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/172.wav", + "text": "這個有跟警政署討論過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/173.wav", + "text": "但是真的必須要特別強調一點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/174.wav", + "text": "這個防護裝備的部分才是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/175.wav", + "text": "非常非常重要的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/176.wav", + "text": "假設他在面對這樣的情境在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/177.wav", + "text": "在沒有足夠防護裝備的情況之下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/178.wav", + "text": "而且以臺南的案件來講的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/179.wav", + "text": "根本防不勝防" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/180.wav", + "text": "所以防護設備防護裝備" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/181.wav", + "text": "事實上是非常重要的一環" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/182.wav", + "text": "我們也希望警政署" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/183.wav", + "text": "真的確實去做好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/184.wav", + "text": "那我們第1條就這樣決定好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/185.wav", + "text": "就是以附帶決議處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/186.wav", + "text": "請看第4條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/187.wav", + "text": "第4條是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/188.wav", + "text": "是民進黨黨團提的關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/189.wav", + "text": "第4條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/190.wav", + "text": "這一次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/191.wav", + "text": "警械使用條例要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/192.wav", + "text": "要修正的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/193.wav", + "text": "但持平而論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/194.wav", + "text": "幾個層次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/195.wav", + "text": "什麼時候要對空鳴槍" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/196.wav", + "text": "什麼情況下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/197.wav", + "text": "在緊急必要的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/198.wav", + "text": "應該要開槍" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/199.wav", + "text": "要定義清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/200.wav", + "text": "警察執行勤務時" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/201.wav", + "text": "將危及到警察人員或" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/202.wav", + "text": "他人的生命安全" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/203.wav", + "text": "得使用槍械逕行射擊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/204.wav", + "text": "第一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/205.wav", + "text": "以致命性武器" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/206.wav", + "text": "危害物品" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/207.wav", + "text": "或交通工具" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/208.wav", + "text": "攻擊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/209.wav", + "text": "沒有辦法警察" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/210.wav", + "text": "好開槍了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/211.wav", + "text": "第二個就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/212.wav", + "text": "有事實足認" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/213.wav", + "text": "有致命性武器" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/214.wav", + "text": "意圖攻擊警察的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/215.wav", + "text": "這是第二個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/216.wav", + "text": "他意圖搶奪警察的配槍" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/217.wav", + "text": "你不緊急處理不行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/218.wav", + "text": "就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/219.wav", + "text": "增加一二三款" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/220.wav", + "text": "當然" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/221.wav", + "text": "還有第4款就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/222.wav", + "text": "其他危害警察人員或" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/223.wav", + "text": "我們必須這樣處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/224.wav", + "text": "我們認為這部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/225.wav", + "text": "可能是今天朝野協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/226.wav", + "text": "要加入的一個重點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/227.wav", + "text": "一點關係都沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/228.wav", + "text": "只有這個才有關係" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/229.wav", + "text": "爾後也要處理這個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/230.wav", + "text": "把它明確化" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/231.wav", + "text": "最後一項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/232.wav", + "text": "總共有4款" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/233.wav", + "text": "請各位委員能夠支持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/234.wav", + "text": "管委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/235.wav", + "text": "我們討論了又討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/236.wav", + "text": "這樣的立法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/237.wav", + "text": "大概就是把警察" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/238.wav", + "text": "使用警械" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/239.wav", + "text": "分成三個層次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/240.wav", + "text": "第一個層次就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/241.wav", + "text": "比較一般的狀況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/242.wav", + "text": "跟器具" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/243.wav", + "text": "第二個情況是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/244.wav", + "text": "我們很明確地" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/245.wav", + "text": "把它設定在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/246.wav", + "text": "第1項第4款第5款的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/247.wav", + "text": "情形之下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/248.wav", + "text": "就是當他有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/249.wav", + "text": "這兩種情形需要的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/250.wav", + "text": "他可以就地" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/251.wav", + "text": "使用其他所可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/252.wav", + "text": "使用的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/253.wav", + "text": "器具物品" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/254.wav", + "text": "這個時候我們可以把" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/255.wav", + "text": "他在這種情形之下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/256.wav", + "text": "所使用的非法定的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/257.wav", + "text": "物品跟器械" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/258.wav", + "text": "當作就是警械" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/259.wav", + "text": "我們也給予" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/260.wav", + "text": "合法化" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/261.wav", + "text": "第三層是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/262.wav", + "text": "更急迫地危及" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/263.wav", + "text": "他的生命了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/264.wav", + "text": "定的這四款" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/265.wav", + "text": "很緊急" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/266.wav", + "text": "急迫的情況有必要的情況之下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/267.wav", + "text": "他就可以逕行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/268.wav", + "text": "開槍射擊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/269.wav", + "text": "等於是分為三個層" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/270.wav", + "text": "次然後每一層次都有非常具體" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/271.wav", + "text": "的定義及" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/272.wav", + "text": "地成熟既能夠兼顧" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/273.wav", + "text": "警察執法之所需要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/274.wav", + "text": "以及保障警察" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/275.wav", + "text": "人員執法時候的人身" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/276.wav", + "text": "完成使命跟任務" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/277.wav", + "text": "所以請大家支持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/278.wav", + "text": "謝謝各位我覺得這一條也是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/279.wav", + "text": "我個人比較傾向" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/280.wav", + "text": "支持的不過就是到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/281.wav", + "text": "槍械" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/282.wav", + "text": "逕行射擊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/283.wav", + "text": "我不知道我們是在這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/284.wav", + "text": "前面已經講了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/285.wav", + "text": "達到這個效果說不定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/286.wav", + "text": "它不是槍械" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/287.wav", + "text": "致命的武力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/288.wav", + "text": "槍械來射擊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/289.wav", + "text": "之警械麻煩請看一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/290.wav", + "text": "增加這一項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/291.wav", + "text": "我是擔心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/292.wav", + "text": "這會不會反而限縮" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/293.wav", + "text": "我先講現行的條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/294.wav", + "text": "就行政院版" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/295.wav", + "text": "第1項第5" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/296.wav", + "text": "款" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/297.wav", + "text": "警察人員之生命" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/298.wav", + "text": "身體自由裝備" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/299.wav", + "text": "遭受強暴或" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/300.wav", + "text": "脅迫或有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/301.wav", + "text": "事實足認為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/302.wav", + "text": "有受危害之虞" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/303.wav", + "text": "使用槍械及警" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/304.wav", + "text": "足認有受危害" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/305.wav", + "text": "之虞時就可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/306.wav", + "text": "使用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/307.wav", + "text": "我是擔心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/308.wav", + "text": "會不會反而" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/309.wav", + "text": "致命性因為增加了第1款" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/310.wav", + "text": "致命性武器" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/311.wav", + "text": "危險物品" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/312.wav", + "text": "第1款和第2款" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/313.wav", + "text": "都是這樣寫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/314.wav", + "text": "意圖奪取警察人員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/315.wav", + "text": "配槍" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/316.wav", + "text": "更嚴謹我是擔心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/317.wav", + "text": "啦更嚴謹更嚴格" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/318.wav", + "text": "因為列舉了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/319.wav", + "text": "會產生這樣的疑慮" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/320.wav", + "text": "\n我們就以臺南" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/321.wav", + "text": "殺警案為例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/322.wav", + "text": "對方只是拿" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/323.wav", + "text": "刀刀是不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/324.wav", + "text": "致命性的我不知道要怎麼去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/325.wav", + "text": "本來法官" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/326.wav", + "text": "可以判斷足" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/327.wav", + "text": "因為現行條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/328.wav", + "text": "第5款" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/329.wav", + "text": "是更寬鬆的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/330.wav", + "text": "可以有更大的空間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/331.wav", + "text": "我是擔心這樣以上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/332.wav", + "text": "謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/333.wav", + "text": "各位黨團的幹部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/334.wav", + "text": "因為第1項的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/335.wav", + "text": "是一個原則性的規範" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/336.wav", + "text": "而且它涉及到兩種" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/337.wav", + "text": "可能的所謂" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/338.wav", + "text": "警方可以使用的一些器械" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/339.wav", + "text": "包括警刀跟槍械" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/340.wav", + "text": "再者這個規範有幾個問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/341.wav", + "text": "第一在面臨這種情況的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/342.wav", + "text": "到底是要用警刀或槍械" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/343.wav", + "text": "這時候可能就會有一些裁量空間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/344.wav", + "text": "這是法官在判定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/345.wav", + "text": "他就要思考哪一個是適合的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/346.wav", + "text": "所以第1項部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/347.wav", + "text": "會造成就是因為它不足" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/348.wav", + "text": "所以我們需要透過第2項來強化" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/349.wav", + "text": "明確化可以使用槍械的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/350.wav", + "text": "\n我們在第2項修訂了這四種情況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/351.wav", + "text": "就是非常明確" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/352.wav", + "text": "警方人員在第一線的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/353.wav", + "text": "遇到下面這個狀況的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/354.wav", + "text": "他就可以拿槍械" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/355.wav", + "text": "明確化未來要防衛自己" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/356.wav", + "text": "或他人遭遇死亡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/357.wav", + "text": "或重傷威脅的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/358.wav", + "text": "他就可以採取槍械" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/359.wav", + "text": "至於第1款的部分就很清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/360.wav", + "text": "如果執法人員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/361.wav", + "text": "他人用致命性武器危險物品" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/362.wav", + "text": "第2款是有事實足認" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/363.wav", + "text": "所以第1款是實際攻擊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/364.wav", + "text": "第2款是意圖攻擊警察人員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/365.wav", + "text": "時第3款就是剛剛提到的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/366.wav", + "text": "意圖奪取槍械" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/367.wav", + "text": "因為他可能會造成警察人員或其他人員的傷亡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/368.wav", + "text": "最後在沒辦法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/369.wav", + "text": "含括的情況之下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/370.wav", + "text": "第4款就列了這種情況緊急" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/371.wav", + "text": "的規定事實上也給警方更多的空間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/372.wav", + "text": "所以我覺得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/373.wav", + "text": "第1項跟第2項最大的不同" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/374.wav", + "text": "就是第1項包括了刀械" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/375.wav", + "text": "警刀在裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/376.wav", + "text": "所以會讓警察在使用上可以有一些裁量" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/377.wav", + "text": "空間讓法官在判斷上有裁量" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/378.wav", + "text": "��糊的空間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/379.wav", + "text": "甚至警方在使用上會猶豫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/380.wav", + "text": "可能必須要有一些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/381.wav", + "text": "自己冗長思考判斷" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/382.wav", + "text": "所以我想第2項主要是要補足" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/383.wav", + "text": "第1項不足的地方" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/384.wav", + "text": "然後明確化可以使用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/385.wav", + "text": "槍械近距離射擊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/386.wav", + "text": "所以應該是更明確更好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/387.wav", + "text": "也更保障我們的警察人員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/388.wav", + "text": "好請邱總召" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/389.wav", + "text": "我們的版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/390.wav", + "text": "是採取美國法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/391.wav", + "text": "連續性強制力的概念" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/392.wav", + "text": "就是說使用警棍警刀槍械" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/393.wav", + "text": "等哪一種警械" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/394.wav", + "text": "並不是依照所辦的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/395.wav", + "text": "案件類型區分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/396.wav", + "text": "而是應該以情境強度危險性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/397.wav", + "text": "國家的政策裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/398.wav", + "text": "警察法上面都有具備" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/399.wav", + "text": "警察人員連續性強制力的概念" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/400.wav", + "text": "非致命性及致命性的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/401.wav", + "text": "強制力措施分成五個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/402.wav", + "text": "強制力的層級" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/403.wav", + "text": "供警察在選擇運用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/404.wav", + "text": "強制力的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/405.wav", + "text": "依照現場所面臨的情境判斷" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/406.wav", + "text": "採取最妥適的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/407.wav", + "text": "等等之類的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/408.wav", + "text": "這個應該是也有外國的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/409.wav", + "text": "比較能夠呼應現在的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/410.wav", + "text": "需求" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/411.wav", + "text": "跟行政院的提案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/412.wav", + "text": "比較就像剛剛羅委員講的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/413.wav", + "text": "增加了第2項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/414.wav", + "text": "又包含4" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/415.wav", + "text": "4款" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/416.wav", + "text": "在這4款裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/417.wav", + "text": "比如說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/418.wav", + "text": "有規定其他危害警察人員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/419.wav", + "text": "或他人生命或身體" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/420.wav", + "text": "情況急迫時" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/421.wav", + "text": "應該是一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/422.wav", + "text": "另外第" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/423.wav", + "text": "款基本上是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/424.wav", + "text": "或危險物品意圖攻擊警察" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/425.wav", + "text": "精確地描述" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/426.wav", + "text": "所謂的緊急狀況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/427.wav", + "text": "基本上我也是持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/428.wav", + "text": "保留態度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/429.wav", + "text": "另外一個層面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/430.wav", + "text": "到底要怎麼樣精確的描述" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/431.wav", + "text": "警員在面對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/432.wav", + "text": "這樣的危險性情境強度的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/433.wav", + "text": "我覺得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/434.wav", + "text": "應該是要能夠儘可能的去具體描述" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/435.wav", + "text": "好一點否則將來如果發生爭議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/436.wav", + "text": "因為我們後面還有規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/437.wav", + "text": "要有一個調查委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/438.wav", + "text": "這樣的情境的時候到時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/439.wav", + "text": "嚴重的紛爭這對警員或是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/440.wav", + "text": "對人民來講都是一個非常大的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/441.wav", + "text": "院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/442.wav", + "text": "還有時代力量" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/443.wav", + "text": "邱總召都有提到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/444.wav", + "text": "這些修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/445.wav", + "text": "到底是限縮或擴張" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/446.wav", + "text": "是不是要保護員警使用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/447.wav", + "text": "或是擴張他們使用的時機" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/448.wav", + "text": "我覺得要加以考量因為有不同的看法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/449.wav", + "text": "連立法委員的看法都不一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/450.wav", + "text": "是不是請法務部跟" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/451.wav", + "text": "內政部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/452.wav", + "text": "不然會沒有結論謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/453.wav", + "text": "管委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/454.wav", + "text": "我們看第1項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/455.wav", + "text": "第1項是一大包" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/456.wav", + "text": "就是這些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/457.wav", + "text": "狀況都可以使用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/458.wav", + "text": "警械器具" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/459.wav", + "text": "然後在這一大包裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/460.wav", + "text": "如果是第4款" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/461.wav", + "text": "跟第5款你不但可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/462.wav", + "text": "使用警械還可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/463.wav", + "text": "使用在你周邊所拿得到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/464.wav", + "text": "的其他" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/465.wav", + "text": "第三種狀況是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/466.wav", + "text": "很緊急的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/467.wav", + "text": "那個就不是在這一包裡面我再增加" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/468.wav", + "text": "在有非常緊急的情況的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/469.wav", + "text": "你可以使用這" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/470.wav", + "text": "其中殺傷力最大的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/471.wav", + "text": "槍械逕行射擊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/472.wav", + "text": "所以並不是越來越" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/473.wav", + "text": "限縮" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/474.wav", + "text": "根據那個連續性的強度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/475.wav", + "text": "我們在不同強度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/476.wav", + "text": "在明確化情境" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/477.wav", + "text": "的情況之下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/478.wav", + "text": "當強度越來越強的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/479.wav", + "text": "執法可以達到目的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/480.wav", + "text": "又能保障人身安全的方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/481.wav", + "text": "不是越來越限縮" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/482.wav", + "text": "所以當你符合逕行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/483.wav", + "text": "射擊這個情境" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/484.wav", + "text": "你同時也符合" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/485.wav", + "text": "符合第1項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/486.wav", + "text": "我這樣解釋大概就比較知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/487.wav", + "text": "那個層次了好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/488.wav", + "text": "謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/489.wav", + "text": "請張委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/490.wav", + "text": "在談到什麼時候可以逕" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/491.wav", + "text": "逕行射擊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/492.wav", + "text": "也就是開槍" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/493.wav", + "text": "先談技術性一點的問題這裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/494.wav", + "text": "比如第1款" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/495.wav", + "text": "都有提到意圖" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/496.wav", + "text": "比較會是未來爭執的點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/497.wav", + "text": "也就是說到底那個狀況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/498.wav", + "text": "下算不算有意圖" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/499.wav", + "text": "比方說這個東西亮出來了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/500.wav", + "text": "就是有意圖嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/501.wav", + "text": "為何我覺得這是第2款第3款在技術上的一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/502.wav", + "text": "第4款規定只要有危害" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/503.wav", + "text": "警察人員或他人生命的情況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/504.wav", + "text": "這一項的修正前面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/505.wav", + "text": "因為前面就是這樣講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/506.wav", + "text": "生命或身體時" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/507.wav", + "text": "原來的意思是一致的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/508.wav", + "text": "如果真的要這樣修" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/509.wav", + "text": "在技術上要怎麼解決" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/510.wav", + "text": "謝謝接下來請莊委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/511.wav", + "text": "謝謝我剛剛聽了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/512.wav", + "text": "大家都是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/513.wav", + "text": "警察整個警械的使用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/514.wav", + "text": "尤其是讓逕行射擊的部分有更" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/515.wav", + "text": "有人認為是擴張其實倒還好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/516.wav", + "text": "請大家仔細去看一下每一款" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/517.wav", + "text": "��一樣今天你增訂了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/518.wav", + "text": "第2款尤其是第2款剛剛大家有提到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/519.wav", + "text": "意圖攻擊警察人員或他人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/520.wav", + "text": "會判斷不出來意圖" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/521.wav", + "text": "倒也不是只有主觀上說是意圖" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/522.wav", + "text": "就是意圖其實" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/523.wav", + "text": "呈現上客觀上有足以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/524.wav", + "text": "判斷的地方像這種情況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/525.wav", + "text": "比如你要去搶取警察人員的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/526.wav", + "text": "時你本來就是要即時" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/527.wav", + "text": "必要所以就規定在第3款" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/528.wav", + "text": "不是屬於第1款第2款" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/529.wav", + "text": "的這些行為態樣然後你用暴力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/530.wav", + "text": "本來就必須即刻即時" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/531.wav", + "text": "\n當然我們看到這些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/532.wav", + "text": "之後大家會覺得好像又限縮了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/533.wav", + "text": "其實還是有客觀的情況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/534.wav", + "text": "對警察" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/535.wav", + "text": "逕行射擊這個部分明確化" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/536.wav", + "text": "也兼顧到整個人權的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/537.wav", + "text": "其實很多都是在警械" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/538.wav", + "text": "了所以我認為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/539.wav", + "text": "其實是非常合理的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/540.wav", + "text": "好謝謝接下來請游" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/541.wav", + "text": "毓蘭發言再來是柯建銘委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/542.wav", + "text": "謝衣鳯委員然後是邱總" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/543.wav", + "text": "這部法其實" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/544.wav", + "text": "已經20年沒有修正了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/545.wav", + "text": "說實在的也是警政署" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/546.wav", + "text": "刑事警察局及很多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/547.wav", + "text": "所做的研究報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/548.wav", + "text": "今天民進黨黨團提出的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/549.wav", + "text": "的修正動議有點治絲益棼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/550.wav", + "text": "益棼之所以這樣說剛剛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/551.wav", + "text": "這個是逕行開槍" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/552.wav", + "text": "可是我們完全不知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/553.wav", + "text": "我們同仁在現場的狀況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/554.wav", + "text": "之下開槍是不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/555.wav", + "text": "最有效的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/556.wav", + "text": "說不定旁邊有一把斧頭" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/557.wav", + "text": "或怎麼樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/558.wav", + "text": "也說不定在那個時候有一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/559.wav", + "text": "都很難講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/560.wav", + "text": "所以有沒有必要一定要用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/561.wav", + "text": "所謂的逕行開槍" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/562.wav", + "text": "第二個是當我們規範得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/563.wav", + "text": "將來在整個判斷上一" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/564.wav", + "text": "定會碰到很多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/565.wav", + "text": "法官們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/566.wav", + "text": "反而會設限" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/567.wav", + "text": "臺北市警察局開治安顧問會議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/568.wav", + "text": "當刑警40年沒有開過槍" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/569.wav", + "text": "可是他旁邊有多少人死掉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/570.wav", + "text": "都在槍林彈雨之中進出" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/571.wav", + "text": "37年前在美國" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/572.wav", + "text": "警察哪些開槍是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/573.wav", + "text": "那個時候我們老師在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/574.wav", + "text": "課堂上弄了一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/575.wav", + "text": "那是一個警察在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/576.wav", + "text": "處理酒吧裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/577.wav", + "text": "一個醉酒的案件" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/578.wav", + "text": "這樣就可以開槍了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/579.wav", + "text": "生命安全對旁邊的人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/580.wav", + "text": "就已經造成威脅" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/581.wav", + "text": "所以我們寫這麼細" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/582.wav", + "text": "其實對於我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/583.wav", + "text": "那千鈞一髮" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/584.wav", + "text": "髮的1秒鐘" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/585.wav", + "text": "不要講1分鐘那個不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/586.wav", + "text": "我們用慢動作" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/587.wav", + "text": "去思考的法官們經常" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/588.wav", + "text": "講你為什麼只打一槍" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/589.wav", + "text": "剛剛楊源明跟我說他們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/590.wav", + "text": "小弟連續開了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/591.wav", + "text": "32槍他自己也不知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/592.wav", + "text": "甚至於我們還有很多刑警" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/593.wav", + "text": "也不知道自己" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/594.wav", + "text": "已經流血過多快要死了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/595.wav", + "text": "\n所以我麻煩" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/596.wav", + "text": "各位真的我們不要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/597.wav", + "text": "限制然後多一點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/598.wav", + "text": "支持謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/599.wav", + "text": "柯總召" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/600.wav", + "text": "我們在討論這個的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/601.wav", + "text": "我尊重每一個人的意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/602.wav", + "text": "警察大學的教授" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/603.wav", + "text": "版本的條文現在修正情形" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/604.wav", + "text": "怎麼樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/605.wav", + "text": "本警械使用條例是從" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/606.wav", + "text": "第1條第2條第3條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/607.wav", + "text": "包括警棍什麼時候使用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/608.wav", + "text": "指揮交通的時候使用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/609.wav", + "text": "第3條是規定在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/610.wav", + "text": "緊急情況時使用警棍" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/611.wav", + "text": "第2條是規定在指揮交通的時候使用警棍" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/612.wav", + "text": "大家先看一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/613.wav", + "text": "時代力量的版本是把第3條也修掉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/614.wav", + "text": "了把警棍都修掉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/615.wav", + "text": "了併到刀和槍" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/616.wav", + "text": "會更加麻煩" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/617.wav", + "text": "們把它修掉以後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/618.wav", + "text": "強制力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/619.wav", + "text": "比如說美國有這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/620.wav", + "text": "但是連續性強制力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/621.wav", + "text": "力包括致命性以及非致命性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/622.wav", + "text": "時代力量這樣把第3條修掉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/623.wav", + "text": "把警棍" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/624.wav", + "text": "放在刀械和槍" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/625.wav", + "text": "的那反而更模糊化" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/626.wav", + "text": "更沒有幫助" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/627.wav", + "text": "我們現在的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/628.wav", + "text": "版本這樣寫法是比照聯合國執" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/629.wav", + "text": "執法人員國際使用的基本原則" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/630.wav", + "text": "我想警察最需要這個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/631.wav", + "text": "刀和槍" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/632.wav", + "text": "委員也講得很清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/633.wav", + "text": "平常可以使用到的東西" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/634.wav", + "text": "在緊急情況下都可以用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/635.wav", + "text": "這是不是在保護警察" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/636.wav", + "text": "我們增加這個是在緊急危險" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/637.wav", + "text": "這要讓他們平常就有這個觀念" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/638.wav", + "text": "是要保護警察更明確化" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/639.wav", + "text": "也保護第三者都是很重要的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/640.wav", + "text": "所以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/641.wav", + "text": "我們分為4款" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/642.wav", + "text": "請警政署或司法院回答" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/643.wav", + "text": "院長各黨團的總召" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/644.wav", + "text": "所有的委員大家好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/645.wav", + "text": "朝野在這裡討論警械" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/646.wav", + "text": "使用條例就是因為過去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/647.wav", + "text": "發生的殺警奪槍案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/648.wav", + "text": "導致了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/649.wav", + "text": "身亡的悲劇" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/650.wav", + "text": "是我們不希望再發生的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/651.wav", + "text": "到底" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/652.wav", + "text": "我們把這個條文複雜化" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/653.wav", + "text": "或者是簡化的程度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/654.wav", + "text": "會讓警察" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/655.wav", + "text": "能夠真正地使用警械" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/656.wav", + "text": "而不是我們今天修法的過程當中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/657.wav", + "text": "變成了警械不使用的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/658.wav", + "text": "條例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/659.wav", + "text": "我相信這是我們在修法當中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/660.wav", + "text": "必須要考量的重點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/661.wav", + "text": "條文版本比較重要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/662.wav", + "text": "所以我覺得應該" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/663.wav", + "text": "要考量" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/664.wav", + "text": "所有警察同仁" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/665.wav", + "text": "綜合時代力量邱總召" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/666.wav", + "text": "法條是給" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/667.wav", + "text": "大部分都是守法的警察" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/668.wav", + "text": "同仁來看的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/669.wav", + "text": "那麼你在越複雜的程度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/670.wav", + "text": "下會不會造成他們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/671.wav", + "text": "在使用警械的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/672.wav", + "text": "相對的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/673.wav", + "text": "他們在顧慮又更多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/674.wav", + "text": "而沒有辦法立即" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/675.wav", + "text": "去反應在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/676.wav", + "text": "來保護自己" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/677.wav", + "text": "甚至保護我們所有人民的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/678.wav", + "text": "我認為今天這個法條的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/679.wav", + "text": "修正應該要以這個為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/680.wav", + "text": "最大的重點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/681.wav", + "text": "來討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/682.wav", + "text": "所以等一下希望警政署以及" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/683.wav", + "text": "也提出他們專業的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/684.wav", + "text": "意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/685.wav", + "text": "他們使用上最方便" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/686.wav", + "text": "以及" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/687.wav", + "text": "這個條文最簡潔有力的情況下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/688.wav", + "text": "作為我們今天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/689.wav", + "text": "修法的依據" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/690.wav", + "text": "接下來請邱總召" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/691.wav", + "text": "院長各位同仁" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/692.wav", + "text": "美國法上面的連續性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/693.wav", + "text": "強制力概念" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/694.wav", + "text": "基本上側重點是在情境" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/695.wav", + "text": "它不是說你拿了什麼樣的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/696.wav", + "text": "物品或交通工具" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/697.wav", + "text": "什麼樣的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/698.wav", + "text": "武器還是什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/699.wav", + "text": "而是說情境強度跟其危險性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/700.wav", + "text": "作為依據" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/701.wav", + "text": "因為民進黨黨團的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/702.wav", + "text": "版本看起來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/703.wav", + "text": "提到致命性武器" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/704.wav", + "text": "危險物品或交通工具" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/705.wav", + "text": "等攻擊傷害" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/706.wav", + "text": "挾持脅迫警察人員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/707.wav", + "text": "這個交通工具" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/708.wav", + "text": "是不是不用去考慮" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/709.wav", + "text": "它的情境" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/710.wav", + "text": "我覺得這個是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/711.wav", + "text": "會有一個問號" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/712.wav", + "text": "等一下也可以請司法院或是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/713.wav", + "text": "內政部法務部表示意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/714.wav", + "text": "因為你" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/715.wav", + "text": "還是要去對其情境" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/716.wav", + "text": "當下這個狀況去做判斷" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/717.wav", + "text": "因為後面調查委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/718.wav", + "text": "就會跟著這個部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/719.wav", + "text": "分所以要怎麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/720.wav", + "text": "去描述如果沒有情境" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/721.wav", + "text": "去判斷的話好像" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/722.wav", + "text": "是很困難的一件事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/723.wav", + "text": "\n第二個部分必須要提醒" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/724.wav", + "text": "的就是到底這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/725.wav", + "text": "跟行政院的版本差異何在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/726.wav", + "text": "意思是說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/727.wav", + "text": "是所謂的放寬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/728.wav", + "text": "其實要提醒的是如果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/729.wav", + "text": "從這樣的條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/730.wav", + "text": "在另外一方面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/731.wav", + "text": "其實法界也都是有這樣的討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/732.wav", + "text": "如果你把這個界限拉得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/733.wav", + "text": "比較放寬的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/734.wav", + "text": "當然代表可能會有誤判的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/735.wav", + "text": "風險" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/736.wav", + "text": "致命性的武器" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/737.wav", + "text": "公務員沒有過失的情況之下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/738.wav", + "text": "以現在我國的制度上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/739.wav", + "text": "就可能取得警械使用條例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/740.wav", + "text": "之補償而不是賠償" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/741.wav", + "text": "這個就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/742.wav", + "text": "在警械使用條例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/743.wav", + "text": "第十一條的補償部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/744.wav", + "text": "第一個它的金額要不要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/745.wav", + "text": "提高第二個不只是第三人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/746.wav", + "text": "被使用警械的相對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/747.wav", + "text": "人也應該要納入" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/748.wav", + "text": "求告無門這樣的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/749.wav", + "text": "這樣的調整而產生的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/750.wav", + "text": "風險也應該要由" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/751.wav", + "text": "國家承擔" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/752.wav", + "text": "我們可以看一下現在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/753.wav", + "text": "依照警械使用條例的補償" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/754.wav", + "text": "死亡的話大概就是250萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/755.wav", + "text": "50萬元所以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/756.wav", + "text": "就這個部分也應該" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/757.wav", + "text": "調整如果要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/758.wav", + "text": "比本來的第六條警察" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/759.wav", + "text": "人員應基於急迫需要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/760.wav", + "text": "合理使用槍械不得逾越必要程度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/761.wav", + "text": "還要更" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/762.wav", + "text": "路邁進的話他的補償" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/763.wav", + "text": "調整比較妥適" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/764.wav", + "text": "邱總召接下來鄭天財" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/765.wav", + "text": "委員然後再管委員再李德維" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/766.wav", + "text": "委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/767.wav", + "text": "等一下德維委員講完以後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/768.wav", + "text": "回應一下好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/769.wav", + "text": "\n請鄭天財委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/770.wav", + "text": "剛剛唸的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/771.wav", + "text": "第5款是現行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/772.wav", + "text": "條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/773.wav", + "text": "身體" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/774.wav", + "text": "足認有受" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/775.wav", + "text": "危害之虞的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/776.wav", + "text": "他就可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/777.wav", + "text": "使用槍械" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/778.wav", + "text": "如果我們現在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/779.wav", + "text": "通過民進黨黨團所提的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/780.wav", + "text": "修正動議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/781.wav", + "text": "由於最後一款" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/782.wav", + "text": "危害警察人員或" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/783.wav", + "text": "他人生命或" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/784.wav", + "text": "身體情況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/785.wav", + "text": "急迫時" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/786.wav", + "text": "你必須要證明情況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/787.wav", + "text": "急迫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/788.wav", + "text": "會比原來的更" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/789.wav", + "text": "臺南殺警案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/790.wav", + "text": "所受的訓練" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/791.wav", + "text": "非常嚴謹" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/792.wav", + "text": "保守跟美國的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/793.wav", + "text": "警察比我們的警察" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/794.wav", + "text": "非常保守" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/795.wav", + "text": "因為過去司法判決" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/796.wav", + "text": "的結果���這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/797.wav", + "text": "我們現在如果還要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/798.wav", + "text": "求情況急迫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/799.wav", + "text": "要證明情況急迫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/800.wav", + "text": "就是因為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/801.wav", + "text": "很保守對方已經" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/802.wav", + "text": "拿刀警察先用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/803.wav", + "text": "辣椒水噴" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/804.wav", + "text": "噴了之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/805.wav", + "text": "歹徒" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/806.wav", + "text": "就拿著刀" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/807.wav", + "text": "撲上去殺他了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/808.wav", + "text": "結果我們的警察還採取" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/809.wav", + "text": "警告性的用槍" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/810.wav", + "text": "他有開槍" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/811.wav", + "text": "但是他沒有對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/812.wav", + "text": "射因為是先進行警告性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/813.wav", + "text": "的我們的警察已經被訓練成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/814.wav", + "text": "方式在這樣的情況之下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/815.wav", + "text": "你們的版本是好意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/816.wav", + "text": "這一項的第4款" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/817.wav", + "text": "其他危害警察人員或他人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/818.wav", + "text": "生命或身體情況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/819.wav", + "text": "急迫時" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/820.wav", + "text": "是不是不要寫情況急迫時" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/821.wav", + "text": "我們還是用現行第4條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/822.wav", + "text": "規定為其他" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/823.wav", + "text": "足認有危害警察" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/824.wav", + "text": "人員或他人生命" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/825.wav", + "text": "或身體" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/826.wav", + "text": "時" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/827.wav", + "text": "情況急迫這個不要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/828.wav", + "text": "已經被訓練成很" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/829.wav", + "text": "你還要再加情況急迫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/830.wav", + "text": "在認定上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/831.wav", + "text": "接下來請管委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/832.wav", + "text": "你們執政黨儘量不要講好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/833.wav", + "text": "不然拖很久沒關係沒關係" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/834.wav", + "text": "還是要講清楚好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/835.wav", + "text": "剛剛已經裁示了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/836.wav", + "text": "剛剛已經" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/837.wav", + "text": "沒有剛剛已經裁示了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/838.wav", + "text": "德維委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/839.wav", + "text": "就是這樣嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/840.wav", + "text": "沒有已經裁示了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/841.wav", + "text": "不要這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/842.wav", + "text": "用槍鄭" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/843.wav", + "text": "完全沒有限縮" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/844.wav", + "text": "都可以���槍" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/845.wav", + "text": "但是用槍分三個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/846.wav", + "text": "層次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/847.wav", + "text": "第一個層次是持槍警戒" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/848.wav", + "text": "第二個層次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/849.wav", + "text": "是對空鳴槍" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/850.wav", + "text": "第三個層次是逕行射擊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/851.wav", + "text": "所以都符合" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/852.wav", + "text": "就是第4項的情況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/853.wav", + "text": "都符合前面可以用槍的情況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/854.wav", + "text": "只是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/855.wav", + "text": "不必去怎樣反而在這麼緊急的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/856.wav", + "text": "候就可以直接逕行射擊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/857.wav", + "text": "所以更是保障他們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/858.wav", + "text": "當他們逕行射擊的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/859.wav", + "text": "會得到保護" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/860.wav", + "text": "應該是這個意思才對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/861.wav", + "text": "另外就是要請" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/862.wav", + "text": "為什麼呢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/863.wav", + "text": "因為葉委員說要用行政院版" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/864.wav", + "text": "那現在行政院版的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/865.wav", + "text": "是要用第1條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/866.wav", + "text": "我現在是游委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/867.wav", + "text": "這真的是抱歉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/868.wav", + "text": "就是說游委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/869.wav", + "text": "說要用行政院版" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/870.wav", + "text": "問題是行政院版的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/871.wav", + "text": "第1條已經不見了所以要改" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/872.wav", + "text": "喔因為這裡的這一項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/873.wav", + "text": "是說要用第1條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/874.wav", + "text": "院版的第2項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/875.wav", + "text": "是用第1條的第2項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/876.wav", + "text": "第1條已經變成審查會版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/877.wav", + "text": "的第1條已經不是行政院版" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/878.wav", + "text": "第1條了那就完全" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/879.wav", + "text": "限縮完全不能夠使用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/880.wav", + "text": "其他器械" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/881.wav", + "text": "所以如果游委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/882.wav", + "text": "團版而要用行政院版" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/883.wav", + "text": "那還是要改寫因為行政院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/884.wav", + "text": "版的第1條已經不見了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/885.wav", + "text": "李委員發言完了以後讓警政" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/886.wav", + "text": "來回應現在因為又有曾銘宗委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/887.wav", + "text": "跟陳椒華委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/888.wav", + "text": "後面就讓他們兩個也發言完" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/889.wav", + "text": "版本真正的重點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/890.wav", + "text": "就是4個字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/891.wav", + "text": "叫做逕行射擊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/892.wav", + "text": "擊是要把逕行射擊明確化" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/893.wav", + "text": "基本上我覺得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/894.wav", + "text": "不用去條列" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/895.wav", + "text": "第一第二第三第四" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/896.wav", + "text": "我反而建議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/897.wav", + "text": "就改成第1項情形" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/898.wav", + "text": "警察人員執行職務時" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/899.wav", + "text": "認犯罪嫌疑人或行為人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/900.wav", + "text": "危及警察" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/901.wav", + "text": "人員或他人生命" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/902.wav", + "text": "或身體時" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/903.wav", + "text": "得使用槍械逕行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/904.wav", + "text": "就結束後面的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/905.wav", + "text": "列舉都不需要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/906.wav", + "text": "因為後面的列舉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/907.wav", + "text": "其實跟前面都重複" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/908.wav", + "text": "沒有什麼意義" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/909.wav", + "text": "現在只是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/910.wav", + "text": "叫逕行射擊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/911.wav", + "text": "一種是亮槍" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/912.wav", + "text": "一種是對空鳴槍" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/913.wav", + "text": "一種是逕行射擊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/914.wav", + "text": "要這4個字而已" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/915.wav", + "text": "所以我建議後面的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/916.wav", + "text": "一二三四就不必了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/917.wav", + "text": "了直接就這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/918.wav", + "text": "其實" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/919.wav", + "text": "人員在關鍵時刻" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/920.wav", + "text": "可以用槍" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/921.wav", + "text": "這才是最大的重點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/922.wav", + "text": "相關單位趕快說明一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/923.wav", + "text": "到底怎麼樣寫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/924.wav", + "text": "對他們最好最方便" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/925.wav", + "text": "才是最支持他們這才是重點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/926.wav", + "text": "接下來請曾銘宗總召" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/927.wav", + "text": "謝謝其實" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/928.wav", + "text": "這樣下去恐怕到晚上10點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/929.wav", + "text": "為什麼如果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/930.wav", + "text": "用列舉這一項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/931.wav", + "text": "之下有四款" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/932.wav", + "text": "很多重複" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/933.wav", + "text": "像剛才鄭天財委員講的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/934.wav", + "text": "就是其他危害警察" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/935.wav", + "text": "人員或他人生命" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/936.wav", + "text": "這個條文就包山包" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/937.wav", + "text": "海那前面列舉的根本很多情況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/938.wav", + "text": "是重複的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/939.wav", + "text": "還是那句話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/940.wav", + "text": "讓法務部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/941.wav", + "text": "和警政署看看可不可行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/942.wav", + "text": "縮執政黨很喜歡講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/943.wav", + "text": "我們等一下每個人都講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/944.wav", + "text": "我的意見就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/945.wav", + "text": "在民進黨的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/946.wav", + "text": "修正動議這邊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/947.wav", + "text": "危及" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/948.wav", + "text": "及這個危及的認定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/949.wav", + "text": "是怎麼樣來認定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/950.wav", + "text": "如果我們的條文文字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/951.wav", + "text": "必須要有危及" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/952.wav", + "text": "才能夠使用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/953.wav", + "text": "這樣的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/954.wav", + "text": "是不是會造成我們警察人員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/955.wav", + "text": "更不敢去用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/956.wav", + "text": "以上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/957.wav", + "text": "謝謝陳委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/958.wav", + "text": "\n接下來我們就請內政部跟法務部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/959.wav", + "text": "看有什麼回應" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/960.wav", + "text": "院長各位委員我首先要感謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/961.wav", + "text": "大家對警察同仁用槍" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/962.wav", + "text": "時機的支持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/963.wav", + "text": "我想不管委員的意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/964.wav", + "text": "為何出發點都是支持警察" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/965.wav", + "text": "這一點我代表內政部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/966.wav", + "text": "跟警政署來向委員們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/967.wav", + "text": "先表達感謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/968.wav", + "text": "希望明天能夠順利通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/969.wav", + "text": "向院長跟各位委員表達感謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/970.wav", + "text": "\n其實我們從這個條文裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/971.wav", + "text": "可以看到譬如" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/972.wav", + "text": "有事實足認" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/973.wav", + "text": "認這個意思就是它的必要性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/974.wav", + "text": "他用槍的時機就是它的合目的性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/975.wav", + "text": "第1項第2項第3項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/976.wav", + "text": "第4項強度一再增加" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/977.wav", + "text": "這就是比例原則" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/978.wav", + "text": "有一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/979.wav", + "text": "警察人員使用槍械的規範裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/980.wav", + "text": "其實它也是按照" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/981.wav", + "text": "這樣子就是這個強度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/982.wav", + "text": "用必要性合目的性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/983.wav", + "text": "的比例原則" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/984.wav", + "text": "所以其實這個規範就是現在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/985.wav", + "text": "逕行射擊列進去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/986.wav", + "text": "其實我們裡面也有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/987.wav", + "text": "持槍就有三個狀況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/988.wav", + "text": "第一個就是持槍警戒" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/989.wav", + "text": "第二個就是我們一般所謂的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/990.wav", + "text": "對空鳴槍事實上那個叫做鳴槍制止" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/991.wav", + "text": "第三個就是逕行射擊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/992.wav", + "text": "這在我們的規範裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/993.wav", + "text": "就已經有了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/994.wav", + "text": "本來在105年就已經有這個規範" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/995.wav", + "text": "我是認為從我們以前的規範裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/996.wav", + "text": "如果再來對照這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/997.wav", + "text": "基本上因為第1項第2項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/998.wav", + "text": "第3項第4項的比例性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/999.wav", + "text": "跟必要性是越來越強" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1000.wav", + "text": "在情境最強" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1001.wav", + "text": "最急迫的情況就是第4項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1002.wav", + "text": "情況嚴重" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1003.wav", + "text": "都可以用槍械逕行射擊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1004.wav", + "text": "法院所講的就是舉重明輕" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1005.wav", + "text": "如果這個都可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1006.wav", + "text": "或者是所謂的準警械" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1007.wav", + "text": "就是在隨手可得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1008.wav", + "text": "在急迫的第二種" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1009.wav", + "text": "這種必要性狀況也" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1010.wav", + "text": "當然也可以使用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1011.wav", + "text": "\n所以就這裡來講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1012.wav", + "text": "我們的意見是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1013.wav", + "text": "這一個版本是把我們當時" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1014.wav", + "text": "應該是這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1015.wav", + "text": "以上向委員們做個說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1016.wav", + "text": "謝謝院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1017.wav", + "text": "委員我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1018.wav", + "text": "基層員警" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1019.wav", + "text": "常在實務上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1020.wav", + "text": "他們礙於用槍" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1021.wav", + "text": "在那裡猶豫思考" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1022.wav", + "text": "因為我們現在四條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1023.wav", + "text": "第1項的各款" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1024.wav", + "text": "確實是比較模糊一點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1025.wav", + "text": "他們急迫需要給他們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1026.wav", + "text": "明確化的使用時機" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1027.wav", + "text": "他們才可以大膽的使用槍枝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1028.wav", + "text": "所以如果我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1029.wav", + "text": "把105年頒訂的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1030.wav", + "text": "員警第一線在使用槍械的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1031.wav", + "text": "他就可以大膽" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1032.wav", + "text": "使用這個符合明確性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1033.wav", + "text": "他就可以使用了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1034.wav", + "text": "所以我們的看法還是支持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1035.wav", + "text": "一個依循一個法律上的依循" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1036.wav", + "text": "他才不會在那裡猶豫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1037.wav", + "text": "你看在整個第1項各款" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1038.wav", + "text": "情形他要拿捏" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1039.wav", + "text": "這個思考的時間點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1040.wav", + "text": "在用槍的短時間裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1041.wav", + "text": "要思考去用槍的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1042.wav", + "text": "時間上來不及所以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1043.wav", + "text": "符合什麼明確化符合什麼要件" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1044.wav", + "text": "我們就用槍了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1045.wav", + "text": "甚至也使這些想要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1046.wav", + "text": "作奸犯科的人有所警惕" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1047.wav", + "text": "反而也不敢犯罪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1048.wav", + "text": "更讓社會大眾能知道用槍" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1049.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1050.wav", + "text": "主席各位委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1051.wav", + "text": "我先講個情境" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1052.wav", + "text": "沒有錯要用警械要有情境" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1053.wav", + "text": "二三十年前我在當檢察官的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1054.wav", + "text": "當時使用槍" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1055.wav", + "text": "的SOP他們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1056.wav", + "text": "三響現在別說3響" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1057.wav", + "text": "因為對方就開槍了所以他們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1058.wav", + "text": "後來有改\n其實剛才" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1059.wav", + "text": "時力有提到要有一個情境" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1060.wav", + "text": "第1項剛才很多委員也都有提到層次感" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1061.wav", + "text": "因此基本上是第1項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1062.wav", + "text": "可以用槍用刀用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1063.wav", + "text": "等於就是第1項的修正版" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1064.wav", + "text": "在特殊情況下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1065.wav", + "text": "剛才有好幾位委員提到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1066.wav", + "text": "最主要是在序文裡面的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1067.wav", + "text": "使用槍械逕行射擊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1068.wav", + "text": "傷害性危險性很高" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1069.wav", + "text": "所以原則上如果在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1070.wav", + "text": "情境中沒有辦法考慮到第1項的情況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1071.wav", + "text": "沒辦法用其他東西也" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1072.wav", + "text": "沒辦法符合比例原則的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1073.wav", + "text": "所以後面的幾款" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1074.wav", + "text": "事實上就是對警察" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1075.wav", + "text": "進行一點限縮" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1076.wav", + "text": "此才有了後面第4款" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1077.wav", + "text": "的其他因為當時很難判斷" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1078.wav", + "text": "尤其是在黑夜的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1079.wav", + "text": "因此要有一個概括條款" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1080.wav", + "text": "基本上還是在保障警察" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1081.wav", + "text": "使用槍械的時機同時也顧慮到警察的生命" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1082.wav", + "text": "之所以會有第1款" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1083.wav", + "text": "的話可能就要回到第1項去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1084.wav", + "text": "這裡的處理是有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1085.wav", + "text": "層次感的也有某種程度的限縮" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1086.wav", + "text": "要求別亂開槍" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1087.wav", + "text": "以符合比例原則" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1088.wav", + "text": "接下來請司法院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1089.wav", + "text": "謝謝院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1090.wav", + "text": "各款的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1091.wav", + "text": "首先我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1092.wav", + "text": "尊重主管機關及" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1093.wav", + "text": "就剛剛所看到的條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1094.wav", + "text": "我提供幾個面向供大家參考" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1095.wav", + "text": "看起來是現行已有的規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1096.wav", + "text": "在警察的行政規則裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1097.wav", + "text": "叫做警察人員使用槍械規範" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1098.wav", + "text": "現在已經有了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1099.wav", + "text": "目前如果要把它提升到警械條例就" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1100.wav", + "text": "是提升其法位階" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1101.wav", + "text": "認為這樣能讓警察" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1102.wav", + "text": "在用槍的時候覺得更放心的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1103.wav", + "text": "這可能就是一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1104.wav", + "text": "考量" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1105.wav", + "text": "及其前提" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1106.wav", + "text": "的部分大家如果不回到剛剛說的那個行政規則去看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1107.wav", + "text": "他們用槍有三階段" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1108.wav", + "text": "第一個是拿槍出來警戒" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1109.wav", + "text": "第二個是要鳴槍制止" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1110.wav", + "text": "第三個才能逕行射擊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1111.wav", + "text": "直接把逕行射擊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1112.wav", + "text": "先對空鳴槍就逕行射擊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1113.wav", + "text": "的意思這可能是因為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1114.wav", + "text": "才讓大家不瞭解" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1115.wav", + "text": "剛剛有委員提到已經有第1項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1116.wav", + "text": "了為什麼還要有第4項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1117.wav", + "text": "客觀的情狀來看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1118.wav", + "text": "有第1項的各款情形時" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1119.wav", + "text": "可以用槍用刀用警棍" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1120.wav", + "text": "是說只要警察" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1121.wav", + "text": "主觀上認為這麼危急的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1122.wav", + "text": "就可以用槍了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1123.wav", + "text": "所以這是在提升對警察人員的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1124.wav", + "text": "事後還要受限於很多客觀的情形" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1125.wav", + "text": "當然還是要檢驗不過警察" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1126.wav", + "text": "的裁量判斷所以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1127.wav", + "text": "第4項的規範用語請" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1128.wav", + "text": "警察人員認為有這樣的情形時" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1129.wav", + "text": "就可以這麼做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1130.wav", + "text": "了\n第四點是我看這個條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1131.wav", + "text": "執法人員使用武力和火器" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1132.wav", + "text": "要求只有在保護生命" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1133.wav", + "text": "而不可避免的狀況下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1134.wav", + "text": "也就是在這麼緊急又危急的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1135.wav", + "text": "狀況之下應該要讓警察可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1136.wav", + "text": "所以我們也要兼顧到旁邊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1137.wav", + "text": "無辜的人可能會受到波及" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1138.wav", + "text": "也有若干用語的調整" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1139.wav", + "text": "而且像第1款就提到致命性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1140.wav", + "text": "武器這裡的第1款比剛剛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1141.wav", + "text": "提到的警察內部行政規則" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1142.wav", + "text": "已把一些模糊的用語刪掉了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1143.wav", + "text": "第2款也提升了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1144.wav", + "text": "因為要有事實足認所以並不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1145.wav", + "text": "憑空去想像要有事實足認" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1146.wav", + "text": "認才可以這麼用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1147.wav", + "text": "的部分大家應該有共識" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1148.wav", + "text": "第四則是規定要在很急迫的時候才可以用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1149.wav", + "text": "所以這樣的用語" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1150.wav", + "text": "也可以兼顧到公約上的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1151.wav", + "text": "用剛剛委員說的以很" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1152.wav", + "text": "概括的方式來說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1153.wav", + "text": "即保護警察人員或是他人生命受到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1154.wav", + "text": "緊急危害的必要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1155.wav", + "text": "情況這種立法方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1156.wav", + "text": "還是把它明確地寫出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1157.wav", + "text": "有提到如果把它寫出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1158.wav", + "text": "有助於警察的教育訓練" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1159.wav", + "text": "也有助於社會大眾" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1160.wav", + "text": "在這種情況下警惕" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1161.wav", + "text": "這可能是他們的立法用意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1162.wav", + "text": "但是要怎麼樣規範" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1163.wav", + "text": "我們還是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1164.wav", + "text": "以上謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1165.wav", + "text": "各單位都已經說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1166.wav", + "text": "跟司法院講得很清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1167.wav", + "text": "司法院因為它有三階段" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1168.wav", + "text": "前面有警戒" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1169.wav", + "text": "後面才逕行射擊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1170.wav", + "text": "司法院廳長有講文字上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1171.wav", + "text": "能不能讓它" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1172.wav", + "text": "更清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1173.wav", + "text": "底下這樣的條文國民黨是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1174.wav", + "text": "贊成的不然請他們去擬條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1175.wav", + "text": "基本上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1176.wav", + "text": "沒有說有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1177.wav", + "text": "任何文字要調整吧" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1178.wav", + "text": "不是尊重" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1179.wav", + "text": "才使用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1180.wav", + "text": "請問司法院有沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1181.wav", + "text": "認為哪邊不夠明確" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1182.wav", + "text": "報告委員剛剛曾總召" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1183.wav", + "text": "講到可能在序文當中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1184.wav", + "text": "的最後兩行是得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1185.wav", + "text": "使用槍械逕行射擊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1186.wav", + "text": "或是大家已經有共識說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1187.wav", + "text": "是得不經鳴槍" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1188.wav", + "text": "制止使用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1189.wav", + "text": "射擊就是前面的階段要不要註明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1190.wav", + "text": "謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1191.wav", + "text": "我想我們這4款" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1192.wav", + "text": "這裡的序文裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1193.wav", + "text": "其實用其他的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1194.wav", + "text": "能達到目的也可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1195.wav", + "text": "但是把它明確化" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1196.wav", + "text": "可以用槍械" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1197.wav", + "text": "那是更讓員警有所遵" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1198.wav", + "text": "院長我補充一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1199.wav", + "text": "德維委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1200.wav", + "text": "是羅委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1201.wav", + "text": "就是要逕行射擊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1202.wav", + "text": "但是你的逕行射擊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1203.wav", + "text": "射擊這幾個字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1204.wav", + "text": "或身體時" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1205.wav", + "text": "款其他危害警察人員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1206.wav", + "text": "或他人生命或身體" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1207.wav", + "text": "情況急迫時" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1208.wav", + "text": "這不都是重複的嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1209.wav", + "text": "所以我的看法很簡單" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1210.wav", + "text": "要不然你就把上面改一改" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1211.wav", + "text": "改成第1項情形" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1212.wav", + "text": "警察人員執行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1213.wav", + "text": "職務時認犯罪嫌疑人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1214.wav", + "text": "或行為人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1215.wav", + "text": "有下列" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1216.wav", + "text": "各款之一" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1217.wav", + "text": "得使用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1218.wav", + "text": "警械逕行射擊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1219.wav", + "text": "然後後面你想列就列" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1220.wav", + "text": "嘛我們沒意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1221.wav", + "text": "那麼想列就列吧" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1222.wav", + "text": "現在換" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1223.wav", + "text": "致政委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1224.wav", + "text": "我本來以為李德維委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1225.wav", + "text": "是說下面各款不必列" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1226.wav", + "text": "那麼李德維委員也是贊成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1227.wav", + "text": "下面各款可以列" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1228.wav", + "text": "那個要列" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1229.wav", + "text": "列的話比較不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1230.wav", + "text": "空白授權" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1231.wav", + "text": "空白授權比較危險" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1232.wav", + "text": "因為還是要兼顧人權保障" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1233.wav", + "text": "所以需要列" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1234.wav", + "text": "啦\n現在大概就是第4項的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1235.wav", + "text": "要不要改" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1236.wav", + "text": "剛剛曾委員是說要問" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1237.wav", + "text": "司法院看是不是還要更明確" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1238.wav", + "text": "\n司法院是說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1239.wav", + "text": "大概就是在使用槍械" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1240.wav", + "text": "逕行射擊前加上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1241.wav", + "text": "得不經鳴槍示警是不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1242.wav", + "text": "那你為什麼只寫鳴槍示警" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1243.wav", + "text": "應該是不經持槍警" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1244.wav", + "text": "戒鳴槍示警" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1245.wav", + "text": "那就變成好像是贅字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1246.wav", + "text": "所以到底有沒有需要報" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1247.wav", + "text": "或許寫在說明裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1248.wav", + "text": "也可以讓大家瞭解" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1249.wav", + "text": "第1項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1250.wav", + "text": "的文字可能要稍微調整" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1251.wav", + "text": "兩邊用語要一致第" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1252.wav", + "text": "5款後面是寫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1253.wav", + "text": "原來是足認為有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1254.wav", + "text": "去掉足認有是常用的嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1255.wav", + "text": "文字調整" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1256.wav", + "text": "就是第1項第5款後段" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1257.wav", + "text": "本來有個為把" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1258.wav", + "text": "為拿掉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1259.wav", + "text": "沒有意見我們就這樣通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1260.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1261.wav", + "text": "你有什麼意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1262.wav", + "text": "誰要講誰" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1263.wav", + "text": "來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1264.wav", + "text": "法制局" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1265.wav", + "text": "各位經過協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1266.wav", + "text": "想要採取民進黨黨團的修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1267.wav", + "text": "動議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1268.wav", + "text": "民進黨黨團修正動議第4項的序文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1269.wav", + "text": "寫的是有下列各款之一" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1270.wav", + "text": "所以建議修正為有下列各款" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1271.wav", + "text": "情形之一加情形二字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1272.wav", + "text": "\n另外" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1273.wav", + "text": "參照警察" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1274.wav", + "text": "勤務裝備機具" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1275.wav", + "text": "配備標準" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1276.wav", + "text": "配備項目與標準" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1277.wav", + "text": "第3款的裝備二字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1278.wav", + "text": "裝備機具" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1279.wav", + "text": "這樣可以完整含括警察人員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1280.wav", + "text": "實務上使用警械的範圍" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1281.wav", + "text": "並使兩個規範的用語" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1282.wav", + "text": "文字做小調整" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1283.wav", + "text": "有下列各款之一改" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1284.wav", + "text": "為有下列各款情形之一" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1285.wav", + "text": "然後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1286.wav", + "text": "以上文字調整" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1287.wav", + "text": "對這個小調整" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1288.wav", + "text": "有沒有意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1289.wav", + "text": "沒有意見的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1290.wav", + "text": "第4條的部分就這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1291.wav", + "text": "通過\n" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1292.wav", + "text": "現在處理第10條之1" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1293.wav", + "text": "是不是也照民進黨黨團" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1294.wav", + "text": "我先說明一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1295.wav", + "text": "我們有做調整我要說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1296.wav", + "text": "一下你先說沒關係" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1297.wav", + "text": "第1項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1298.wav", + "text": "我們的跟行政院版本一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1299.wav", + "text": "但增加了第2款" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1300.wav", + "text": "警察人員使用警械" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1301.wav", + "text": "致人死亡或" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1302.wav", + "text": "重傷爭議案件" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1303.wav", + "text": "針對警械使用前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1304.wav", + "text": "之值勤情狀" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1305.wav", + "text": "工作時數" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1306.wav", + "text": "應勤裝備" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1307.wav", + "text": "及警察機關訓練" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1308.wav", + "text": "之適當性進行調查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1309.wav", + "text": "及提供意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1310.wav", + "text": "用意就是你不能只就" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1311.wav", + "text": "使用槍的當時" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1312.wav", + "text": "也要把他的身體狀況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1313.wav", + "text": "做相關調查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1314.wav", + "text": "這樣才能真正確保警察的權益" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1315.wav", + "text": "增加第3項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1316.wav", + "text": "本委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1317.wav", + "text": "應每年調查警械使用情形" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1318.wav", + "text": "警察人員值勤遇襲案件" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1319.wav", + "text": "勤務制度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1320.wav", + "text": "應勤裝備警械使用教育訓練" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1321.wav", + "text": "及倫理促進" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1322.wav", + "text": "等實際狀況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1323.wav", + "text": "並上網公布調查報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1324.wav", + "text": "最後一項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1325.wav", + "text": "本委員會置委員若干人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1326.wav", + "text": "就法律心理學" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1327.wav", + "text": "醫學警學" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1328.wav", + "text": "鑑識專長之專家學者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1329.wav", + "text": "及警察人員代表" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1330.wav", + "text": "遴聘之" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1331.wav", + "text": "本委員會之組織規程" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1332.wav", + "text": "及運作辦法由內政部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1333.wav", + "text": "之這是我們的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1334.wav", + "text": "修正動議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1335.wav", + "text": "為了節省時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1336.wav", + "text": "看看警政署" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1337.wav", + "text": "法務部或者內政部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1338.wav", + "text": "請游委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1339.wav", + "text": "我還是要再重申一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1340.wav", + "text": "我之所以認為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1341.wav", + "text": "應該有一個常設的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1342.wav", + "text": "或者是鑑定小組" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1343.wav", + "text": "我比較prefer的是鑑定小組" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1344.wav", + "text": "堅持要用調查小組" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1345.wav", + "text": "我沒有意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1346.wav", + "text": "但是我覺得必須要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1347.wav", + "text": "常設的原因是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1348.wav", + "text": "這樣才有辦法蒐集" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1349.wav", + "text": "所有警察用槍" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1350.wav", + "text": "詳細資料" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1351.wav", + "text": "有效" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1352.wav", + "text": "且比較強力的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1353.wav", + "text": "建議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1354.wav", + "text": "讓未來的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1355.wav", + "text": "為什麼因為我記得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1356.wav", + "text": "李昌鈺博士跟我講過一句話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1357.wav", + "text": "他說319的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1358.wav", + "text": "他帶了很多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1359.wav", + "text": "國際的鑑識專家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1360.wav", + "text": "到臺灣提" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1361.wav", + "text": "在答詢的時候有提到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1362.wav", + "text": "現在臺灣的槍枝案件" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1363.wav", + "text": "大概不到兩成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1364.wav", + "text": "是用制式手槍" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1365.wav", + "text": "絕大多數" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1366.wav", + "text": "即八成多快九成是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1367.wav", + "text": "改造" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1368.wav", + "text": "真正驗槍的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1369.wav", + "text": "應該是在臺灣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1370.wav", + "text": "尤其用槍的部分因為我們這邊的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1371.wav", + "text": "狀況比較特殊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1372.wav", + "text": "所以本席" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1373.wav", + "text": "不堅持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1374.wav", + "text": "但是我也提出一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1375.wav", + "text": "附帶決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1376.wav", + "text": "司法機關能夠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1377.wav", + "text": "重視" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1378.wav", + "text": "這絕對是個專業" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1379.wav", + "text": "我很不喜歡我們在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1380.wav", + "text": "委員會審查的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1381.wav", + "text": "司法院或者是法務部的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1382.wav", + "text": "代表都說開槍不是專業" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1383.wav", + "text": "哪一個男人沒有打過靶" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1384.wav", + "text": "\n錯了開槍絕對是專業" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1385.wav", + "text": "尤其" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1386.wav", + "text": "是這些有爭議的案件" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1387.wav", + "text": "所以我們要尊重專業" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1388.wav", + "text": "以上是我的意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1389.wav", + "text": "謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1390.wav", + "text": "本來行政院送來的就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1391.wav", + "text": "然後委員會審查的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1392.wav", + "text": "加了一項即第2項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1393.wav", + "text": "前項調查小組對於警械使用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1394.wav", + "text": "妥適性之判斷" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1395.wav", + "text": "得考量使用人員當時" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1396.wav", + "text": "之合理認知" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1397.wav", + "text": "委員會審查的時候大家加了第2項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1398.wav", + "text": "我們是接受的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1399.wav", + "text": "成則是其組織及運作方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1400.wav", + "text": "由內政部定之" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1401.wav", + "text": "之現在我們談一談" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1402.wav", + "text": "假如游毓蘭委員過去有所堅持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1403.wav", + "text": "要鑑定小組" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1404.wav", + "text": "調查小組就可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1405.wav", + "text": "條文通過才來談附帶" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1406.wav", + "text": "OK" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1407.wav", + "text": "根據刑事訴訟法第208條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1408.wav", + "text": "本來就是可以囑託" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1409.wav", + "text": "所以他要囑託誰都可以囑託" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1410.wav", + "text": "現在要回到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1411.wav", + "text": "國民黨談的所謂" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1412.wav", + "text": "我不知道時代力量有沒有版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1413.wav", + "text": "但好像也是委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1414.wav", + "text": "來看這個是作用法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1415.wav", + "text": "作用法裡面沒有辦法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1416.wav", + "text": "把組織法又強制進去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1417.wav", + "text": "等於就是不可以設委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1418.wav", + "text": "原則搞清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1419.wav", + "text": "這是作用法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1420.wav", + "text": "作用法不可以設委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1421.wav", + "text": "所以這個是小組" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1422.wav", + "text": "這部分是不是請大家能" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1423.wav", + "text": "接受" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1424.wav", + "text": "因為基準法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1425.wav", + "text": "作用法等等要分清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1426.wav", + "text": "一下組織法一下作用法跳來跳去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1427.wav", + "text": "3個法是不一致的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1428.wav", + "text": "我們讓它一致就好了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1429.wav", + "text": "這是作用法好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1430.wav", + "text": "我表示一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1431.wav", + "text": "有跟警政署討論過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1432.wav", + "text": "調查小組委員會的部分我們並不堅持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1433.wav", + "text": "說實在的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1434.wav", + "text": "過去發生這樣的案件時" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1435.wav", + "text": "如果沒有這樣的機制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1436.wav", + "text": "以現行法制來講有沒有辦法可以運作" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1437.wav", + "text": "法院也在處理這個事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1438.wav", + "text": "法院照常可以囑託但" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1439.wav", + "text": "我們都知道臺灣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1440.wav", + "text": "不要說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1441.wav", + "text": "屈指可數但就是不多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1442.wav", + "text": "署長也非常清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1443.wav", + "text": "這個意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1444.wav", + "text": "比較有可能" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1445.wav", + "text": "就是一組人的意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1446.wav", + "text": "如果有一個這樣的調查小組" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1447.wav", + "text": "事實上就可以有多個專家進來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1448.wav", + "text": "讓他們彼此可以在專業上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1449.wav", + "text": "我覺得這是一個正面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1450.wav", + "text": "\n我們的版本在調查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1451.wav", + "text": "委員會的組成中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1452.wav", + "text": "中多了一個基層警察" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1453.wav", + "text": "的團體代表" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1454.wav", + "text": "這部分我們也跟警政署表達過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1455.wav", + "text": "其實這是非常重要的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1456.wav", + "text": "因為也許這些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1457.wav", + "text": "曾經在年輕時執" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1458.wav", + "text": "執業過警察" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1459.wav", + "text": "但他是不是有這麼多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1460.wav", + "text": "的服務經驗" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1461.wav", + "text": "所以我們覺得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1462.wav", + "text": "這個委員會的另一個功能" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1463.wav", + "text": "調查意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1464.wav", + "text": "而已而是在向後的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1465.wav", + "text": "未來如果再發生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1466.wav", + "text": "這樣的事情是不是有一些可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1467.wav", + "text": "非常重要的一環" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1468.wav", + "text": "附帶決議來表示謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1469.wav", + "text": "謝謝主席我跟" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1470.wav", + "text": "游委員的意見一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1471.wav", + "text": "只是我" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1472.wav", + "text": "把它講得更清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1473.wav", + "text": "我們也贊同行政院的版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1474.wav", + "text": "但是我們的第1項第2款" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1475.wav", + "text": "警察人員使用警械" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1476.wav", + "text": "致人死亡或重傷" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1477.wav", + "text": "爭議案件針對警械" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1478.wav", + "text": "使用前之值勤情狀" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1479.wav", + "text": "工作時數" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1480.wav", + "text": "應勤裝備及" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1481.wav", + "text": "警察機關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1482.wav", + "text": "訓練之適當性進行調查及" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1483.wav", + "text": "調查的相關情況要上網公布部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1484.wav", + "text": "基本上我們不堅持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1485.wav", + "text": "但是會把它寫成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1486.wav", + "text": "附帶決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1487.wav", + "text": "不不附帶決議你們要尊重" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1488.wav", + "text": "啦我們大家都在這裡很久" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1489.wav", + "text": "了法案在這裡處理時" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1490.wav", + "text": "都是處理到條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1491.wav", + "text": "部分至於附帶決議因為當天也會提出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1492.wav", + "text": "屆時我們在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1493.wav", + "text": "再來接著請張其祿委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1494.wav", + "text": "謝謝院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1495.wav", + "text": "先表述一下民眾黨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1496.wav", + "text": "事實上因為民眾黨黨團這邊的提案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1497.wav", + "text": "啦其實他們所關切的就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1498.wav", + "text": "這個調查小組" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1499.wav", + "text": "未來到底有沒有比較" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1500.wav", + "text": "基層的員警在裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1501.wav", + "text": "可能是官官相護結果就是不行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1502.wav", + "text": "\n這個地方" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1503.wav", + "text": "應該是這樣子現在我們看到民進黨黨團" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1504.wav", + "text": "判斷得考量" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1505.wav", + "text": "使用人員當時之合理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1506.wav", + "text": "提的這些事項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1507.wav", + "text": "因為在民眾黨的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1508.wav", + "text": "當時他為什麼使用這些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1509.wav", + "text": "槍械或者是他到底" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1510.wav", + "text": "因為現在的這個版本是比較" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1511.wav", + "text": "把這個寫清楚一點\n另外" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1512.wav", + "text": "就是關於那個組織" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1513.wav", + "text": "因為現在民進黨黨團" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1514.wav", + "text": "跟運作方式由內政部定之" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1515.wav", + "text": "之我們也希望這個地方" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1516.wav", + "text": "至少能夠有一定的比例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1517.wav", + "text": "在這種狀況下的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1518.wav", + "text": "民眾黨這邊也可以支持民進黨黨團" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1519.wav", + "text": "謝謝張委員接下來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1520.wav", + "text": "請鄭天財委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1521.wav", + "text": "委員會審查的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1522.wav", + "text": "除了鑑定委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1523.wav", + "text": "跟調查小組" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1524.wav", + "text": "這樣的用詞之外" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1525.wav", + "text": "很重要的是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1526.wav", + "text": "游委員的版本就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1527.wav", + "text": "這個調查小組" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1528.wav", + "text": "或鑑定小組" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1529.wav", + "text": "所完成的這些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1530.wav", + "text": "得應司法機關之委託" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1531.wav", + "text": "做這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1532.wav", + "text": "工作但是司法院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1533.wav", + "text": "是反對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1534.wav", + "text": "的事實上它是得啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1535.wav", + "text": "上次我召開" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1536.wav", + "text": "司法院還是有這樣的一個意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1537.wav", + "text": "請大家參考以上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1538.wav", + "text": "警政署來跟我協商的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1539.wav", + "text": "這個只能夠照院版" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1540.wav", + "text": "不能夠做文字的變動" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1541.wav", + "text": "我就中計了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1542.wav", + "text": "所以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1543.wav", + "text": "我就說好吧那就把我的精神" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1544.wav", + "text": "附帶決議如果是這樣子的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1545.wav", + "text": "織及運作方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1546.wav", + "text": "由內政部定之\n" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1547.wav", + "text": "你用的是調查小組" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1548.wav", + "text": "把我原來提案裡面的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1549.wav", + "text": "置委員若干人就法律" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1550.wav", + "text": "鑑識專長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1551.wav", + "text": "還有警察人員代表" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1552.wav", + "text": "民進黨黨團做這樣的修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1553.wav", + "text": "要把這個放進去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1554.wav", + "text": "請內政部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1555.wav", + "text": "我這樣子建議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1556.wav", + "text": "是不是我們在其組織及運作方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1557.wav", + "text": "我們已經同意了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1558.wav", + "text": "對署長有跟我講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1559.wav", + "text": "一定會占一定的比例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1560.wav", + "text": "就是一定要把它放進去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1561.wav", + "text": "不要在法裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1562.wav", + "text": "我們在組織法裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1563.wav", + "text": "就是要授權命令的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1564.wav", + "text": "要有這樣的一個文字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1565.wav", + "text": "即它要有一個授權依據" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1566.wav", + "text": "一定會定進去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1567.wav", + "text": "我們前面講學者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1568.wav", + "text": "這就包括很多人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1569.wav", + "text": "後面經過法律的授權以後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1570.wav", + "text": "查照案要送來立法院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1571.wav", + "text": "耶到最後查照" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1572.wav", + "text": "本案就照這樣通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1573.wav", + "text": "啦照執政黨團的通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1574.wav", + "text": "法制局對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1575.wav", + "text": "法律的文字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1576.wav", + "text": "法制局第二次報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1577.wav", + "text": "針對第10條之1如果要採取" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1578.wav", + "text": "民進黨黨團的修正動議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1579.wav", + "text": "我們有一些文字的意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1580.wav", + "text": "第一個就是配合本條調查小組" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1581.wav", + "text": "它是屬於行政責任的調查性質" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1582.wav", + "text": "所以第1項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1583.wav", + "text": "爭議案件的案件兩個字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1584.wav", + "text": "是不是可以調整為事件" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1585.wav", + "text": "可以避免跟刑事訴訟法相關法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1586.wav", + "text": "律的刑事案件兩個字的用字混用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1587.wav", + "text": "另外為了符合" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1588.wav", + "text": "立法慣用的標點符號規範" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1589.wav", + "text": "第3項的後段" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1590.wav", + "text": "原先是寫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1591.wav", + "text": "其組織及運作方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1592.wav", + "text": "由內政部定之" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1593.wav", + "text": "之應該調整為其組織及運作方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1594.wav", + "text": "定之這個體例也跟" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1595.wav", + "text": "審查會通過的條文第1條第2項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1596.wav", + "text": "後段的體例相符" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1597.wav", + "text": "有沒有問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1598.wav", + "text": "那就這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1599.wav", + "text": "事件嗎法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1600.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1601.wav", + "text": "通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1602.wav", + "text": "現在請大家看第十一條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1603.wav", + "text": "第十一條應該比較沒有意見吧" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1604.wav", + "text": "看誰有意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1605.wav", + "text": "因為我們的版本已經在桌子上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1606.wav", + "text": "就沒有了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1607.wav", + "text": "行政院的版本有一些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1608.wav", + "text": "改" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1609.wav", + "text": "的地方" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1610.wav", + "text": "是人民或是第三人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1611.wav", + "text": "\n我們是認為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1612.wav", + "text": "回到第三人就好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1613.wav", + "text": "如果警察開槍" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1614.wav", + "text": "傷及無辜就要賠償嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1615.wav", + "text": "如果是人民的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1616.wav", + "text": "這樣對國民感情而言就會有點問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1617.wav", + "text": "所以這一部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1618.wav", + "text": "我是覺得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1619.wav", + "text": "這是第一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1620.wav", + "text": "當初在委員會的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1621.wav", + "text": "作比較有層次的調整" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1622.wav", + "text": "第一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1623.wav", + "text": "就是牽涉到國賠的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1624.wav", + "text": "致傷害人民" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1625.wav", + "text": "自由或權利的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1626.wav", + "text": "應該要國賠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1627.wav", + "text": "包括生命財產" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1628.wav", + "text": "這是第1項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1629.wav", + "text": "就是要國賠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1630.wav", + "text": "第2項是如" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1631.wav", + "text": "我們當然必須" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1632.wav", + "text": "大概是這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1633.wav", + "text": "因可歸責該第三人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1634.wav", + "text": "限最後就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1635.wav", + "text": "這個基準" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1636.wav", + "text": "剛才一開始時代力量也談過包" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1637.wav", + "text": "補償項目基準程序及其他" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1638.wav", + "text": "相關事項之辦法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1639.wav", + "text": "之\n我們調整" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1640.wav", + "text": "的重點就是把" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1641.wav", + "text": "民進黨黨團" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1642.wav", + "text": "提的修正條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1643.wav", + "text": "第一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1644.wav", + "text": "原來的行政院版" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1645.wav", + "text": "是但人民有可歸責" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1646.wav", + "text": "之事由時" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1647.wav", + "text": "法院得減免" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1648.wav", + "text": "其金額" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1649.wav", + "text": "的版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1650.wav", + "text": "該第三人之事由者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1651.wav", + "text": "不在此限就是不分輕重" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1652.wav", + "text": "只要是可歸責於" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1653.wav", + "text": "第三人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1654.wav", + "text": "就全部都不能" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1655.wav", + "text": "不在此限就是不行而" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1656.wav", + "text": "而本來行政院的版本是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1657.wav", + "text": "還可以由法院斟酌" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1658.wav", + "text": "減免他的金額" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1659.wav", + "text": "所以這個部分請" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1660.wav", + "text": "再考量" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1661.wav", + "text": "這是第一個\n第二個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1662.wav", + "text": "行政院的版本或是現在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1663.wav", + "text": "我們還是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1664.wav", + "text": "要考量國家賠償法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1665.wav", + "text": "的用詞" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1666.wav", + "text": "國家賠償法的用詞" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1667.wav", + "text": "義務機關我們是不是把它" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1668.wav", + "text": "一致將賠償機關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1669.wav", + "text": "改為賠償義務機關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1670.wav", + "text": "這是國家賠償法的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1671.wav", + "text": "用詞" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1672.wav", + "text": "來講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1673.wav", + "text": "民進黨黨團的版本第2項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1674.wav", + "text": "前項情形" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1675.wav", + "text": "為警察人員出於" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1676.wav", + "text": "故意之行為所致者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1677.wav", + "text": "賠償義務機關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1678.wav", + "text": "得向其求償" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1679.wav", + "text": "不受國家賠償法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1680.wav", + "text": "第2條第3項規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1681.wav", + "text": "故意或" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1682.wav", + "text": "重大過失的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1683.wav", + "text": "得求償" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1684.wav", + "text": "所以這裡要不要加這個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1685.wav", + "text": "這是立法技術的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1686.wav", + "text": "我們的版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1687.wav", + "text": "因為教育訓練" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1688.wav", + "text": "裝備勤務管理有所不足" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1689.wav", + "text": "或其他原因" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1690.wav", + "text": "致侵害人民權利依國家賠償法規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1691.wav", + "text": "那是一個國家賠償類型的具體化" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1692.wav", + "text": "但是我們並不堅持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1693.wav", + "text": "也可以把它改成附帶決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1694.wav", + "text": "民進黨黨團修正動議裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1695.wav", + "text": "提到致" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1696.wav", + "text": "生命身體或財產" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1697.wav", + "text": "補償這個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1698.wav", + "text": "這個補償以現在來講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1699.wav", + "text": "因為未來恐怕會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1700.wav", + "text": "發生更多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1701.wav", + "text": "類似這種" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1702.wav", + "text": "這本來就是一個風險" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1703.wav", + "text": "這個風險應該由國家來承擔" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1704.wav", + "text": "有一個第三人因為這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1705.wav", + "text": "而中槍" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1706.wav", + "text": "甚至失去了他的生命" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1707.wav", + "text": "依照我們現在的規定就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1708.wav", + "text": "250萬再加上30萬的殯葬費" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1709.wav", + "text": "一共280萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1710.wav", + "text": "元署長應該瞭解我在說什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1711.wav", + "text": "是應該要去處理的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1712.wav", + "text": "這個但書有很大的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1713.wav", + "text": "可歸責該第三人之事由者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1714.wav", + "text": "不在此限那表示什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1715.wav", + "text": "表示這個第三人就不能夠請求" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1716.wav", + "text": "可以修正為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1717.wav", + "text": "但因可歸責於第三人之事由者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1718.wav", + "text": "得減輕或免除" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1719.wav", + "text": "第三人的責任到底到什麼程度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1720.wav", + "text": "而中槍而他有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1721.wav", + "text": "可歸責的事由但是他有可歸責" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1722.wav", + "text": "責事由是不是到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1723.wav", + "text": "他完全都不會受到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1724.wav", + "text": "補償這是一個很大的問號" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1725.wav", + "text": "所以這正是要讓" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1726.wav", + "text": "個案法官有一個機會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1727.wav", + "text": "讓他可以在這個個案裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1728.wav", + "text": "去判斷到底是不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1729.wav", + "text": "要賠500萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1730.wav", + "text": "那就少一點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1731.wav", + "text": "但是不至於有完全免除" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1732.wav", + "text": "的狀況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1733.wav", + "text": "請游委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1734.wav", + "text": "謝謝各位其實這一條對於" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1735.wav", + "text": "現在的員警來講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1736.wav", + "text": "是最重要的一個保障" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1737.wav", + "text": "要讓他們沒有後顧之憂" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1738.wav", + "text": "比較喜歡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1739.wav", + "text": "而不希望是用第三人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1740.wav", + "text": "我已經看到內政部的意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1741.wav", + "text": "剛剛邱總召在談的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1742.wav", + "text": "馬有失蹄人有錯手" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1743.wav", + "text": "對象到最後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1744.wav", + "text": "同仁在執勤時" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1745.wav", + "text": "要去抓通緝犯" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1746.wav", + "text": "或是有贓車的狀況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1747.wav", + "text": "他判斷錯誤" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1748.wav", + "text": "一定要用第三人到時候他" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1749.wav", + "text": "開槍的對象" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1750.wav", + "text": "並不是每一個跟警察遭遇的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1751.wav", + "text": "完全都是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1752.wav", + "text": "\n個人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1753.wav", + "text": "還是建議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1754.wav", + "text": "行政院版" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1755.wav", + "text": "如果是可以歸責的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1756.wav", + "text": "再給予法官" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1757.wav", + "text": "或免除的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1758.wav", + "text": "心理上的負擔" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1759.wav", + "text": "這個部分賠償義務機關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1760.wav", + "text": "是符合國家賠償法的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1761.wav", + "text": "時力有提到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1762.wav", + "text": "授權辦法當中將來要不要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1763.wav", + "text": "擴大到什麼程度也可以按照比例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1764.wav", + "text": "來處理所以在基準裡面訂定辦法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1765.wav", + "text": "來處理就可以了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1766.wav", + "text": "時力所提的概念可以��在裡面不必在這裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1767.wav", + "text": "寫得太多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1768.wav", + "text": "\n再者關於第3項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1769.wav", + "text": "的但書到底是不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1770.wav", + "text": "例行政執行法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1771.wav", + "text": "如果可歸責於" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1772.wav", + "text": "該當事人的話是不補償的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1773.wav", + "text": "所以在立法的原則" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1774.wav", + "text": "上面既然可歸責於他" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1775.wav", + "text": "他要來打我" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1776.wav", + "text": "如果可歸責還要補償的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1777.wav", + "text": "那當然是屬於減免的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1778.wav", + "text": "各位委員可以做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1779.wav", + "text": "立法上的參考" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1780.wav", + "text": "你說可歸責還要補償是什麼問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1781.wav", + "text": "如果是可歸責的話原則上不補償" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1782.wav", + "text": "這是有立法例的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1783.wav", + "text": "對啊剛才也有委員提到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1784.wav", + "text": "可歸責還要給予補償" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1785.wav", + "text": "在立法上如果各位委員認為需要的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1786.wav", + "text": "當然是屬於減免" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1787.wav", + "text": "基本上我們贊成的是可歸責就不補償" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1788.wav", + "text": "委員的意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1789.wav", + "text": "可以另外再斟酌看看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1790.wav", + "text": "部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1791.wav", + "text": "院長各位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1792.wav", + "text": "因可歸責於第三人之事" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1793.wav", + "text": "由者不在此限的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1794.wav", + "text": "其實" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1795.wav", + "text": "一般來講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1796.wav", + "text": "第三人本來就是和案子無關的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1797.wav", + "text": "很難想像" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1798.wav", + "text": "事由是和加害人沒有關係的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1799.wav", + "text": "一般來講都是積極的幫助" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1800.wav", + "text": "或是消極的阻擋警察辦案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1801.wav", + "text": "所以才會有這種歸責事由" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1802.wav", + "text": "不然第三者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1803.wav", + "text": "和案件無關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1804.wav", + "text": "一般都是因為跳彈" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1805.wav", + "text": "情況所以為什麼會這樣規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1806.wav", + "text": "我覺得在法律上是有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1807.wav", + "text": "這樣子沒有問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1808.wav", + "text": "當然用減輕免除" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1809.wav", + "text": "也許法院就有判斷的餘地" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1810.wav", + "text": "但事實上第三者如果有歸責的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1811.wav", + "text": "變���加害人的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1812.wav", + "text": "幫手等於是共犯" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1813.wav", + "text": "或是犯罪結構當中的一部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1814.wav", + "text": "一般來講都是這樣子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1815.wav", + "text": "以上意見提供給委員們參考" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1816.wav", + "text": "這個要反對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1817.wav", + "text": "子剛剛次長和部長都提" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1818.wav", + "text": "都提到可歸責的狀況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1819.wav", + "text": "其實我們都很清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1820.wav", + "text": "假設只有百分之一的可歸責狀況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1821.wav", + "text": "難道人民失去一條命" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1822.wav", + "text": "不是這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1823.wav", + "text": "的我們必須嚴肅看待" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1824.wav", + "text": "這件事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1825.wav", + "text": "正是因為案件的類型" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1826.wav", + "text": "不同當然有可能" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1827.wav", + "text": "有一些是像部長所講的那種狀況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1828.wav", + "text": "由他有可能是共犯等等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1829.wav", + "text": "但是也有可能不是啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1830.wav", + "text": "所以要怎麼辦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1831.wav", + "text": "在條文的但書當中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1832.wav", + "text": "就把它鎖死" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1833.wav", + "text": "原則就是如果有侵害到第三人的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1834.wav", + "text": "他就可以請求補償現" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1835.wav", + "text": "現在要有一個但書" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1836.wav", + "text": "那個但書就是把一些例外的規定除掉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1837.wav", + "text": "譬如它是在有歸責的狀況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1838.wav", + "text": "百分之百的可歸責" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1839.wav", + "text": "也有可能是百分之一的可歸責" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1840.wav", + "text": "那怎麼辦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1841.wav", + "text": "就是要放給法官在個案裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1842.wav", + "text": "去做衡量" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1843.wav", + "text": "這個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1844.wav", + "text": "大家要再商榷一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1845.wav", + "text": "事由的第三人可以減輕" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1846.wav", + "text": "主要是要有一個減輕或免除" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1847.wav", + "text": "補償的規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1848.wav", + "text": "有的時候很難" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1849.wav", + "text": "判斷" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1850.wav", + "text": "不是百分之百" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1851.wav", + "text": "交由法官" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1852.wav", + "text": "法院去判斷" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1853.wav", + "text": "既然現行條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1854.wav", + "text": "考量減免其金額" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1855.wav", + "text": "同意賠償機關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1856.wav", + "text": "增加義務兩個字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1857.wav", + "text": "的用詞" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1858.wav", + "text": "以上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1859.wav", + "text": "發表意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1860.wav", + "text": "如果覺得有重大的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1861.wav", + "text": "這是應該的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1862.wav", + "text": "但是誠如剛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1863.wav", + "text": "透過第三者公正的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1864.wav", + "text": "我們也可以接受" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1865.wav", + "text": "為什麼我一開始的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1866.wav", + "text": "在第10條之1" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1867.wav", + "text": "小組的原因" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1868.wav", + "text": "不管是車禍" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1869.wav", + "text": "事故的鑑定委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1870.wav", + "text": "或者醫療事故的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1871.wav", + "text": "委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1872.wav", + "text": "但是你們都已經說要用調查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1873.wav", + "text": "可以長時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1874.wav", + "text": "去蒐集這些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1875.wav", + "text": "凡事就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1876.wav", + "text": "要開始去做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1877.wav", + "text": "規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1878.wav", + "text": "比較細項的規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1879.wav", + "text": "或規範以及教育訓練" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1880.wav", + "text": "上面都能夠符合" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1881.wav", + "text": "請司法院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1882.wav", + "text": "謝謝院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1883.wav", + "text": "剛剛聽主管機關的意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1884.wav", + "text": "似乎在這邊也可以調整" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1885.wav", + "text": "也符合各位委員的想法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1886.wav", + "text": "如果採這個方向的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1887.wav", + "text": "現在的警察職權執行法第31條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1888.wav", + "text": "第1項也有類似的規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1889.wav", + "text": "有可歸責之事由時" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1890.wav", + "text": "得減輕或免除其金額" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1891.wav", + "text": "用語可以供參考" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1892.wav", + "text": "因為第一個補償的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1893.wav", + "text": "不是法院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1894.wav", + "text": "而是警察機關自己要先做補償" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1895.wav", + "text": "如果雙方都沒有意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1896.wav", + "text": "這件事就不會到法院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1897.wav", + "text": "所以第一關可能還是要回到行政機關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1898.wav", + "text": "謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1899.wav", + "text": "策略的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1900.wav", + "text": "被害人保護法其實有相關的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1901.wav", + "text": "條款" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1902.wav", + "text": "有下列各款情形之一者得不補償其損失之全部或一部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1903.wav", + "text": "就是有可歸責之事由" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1904.wav", + "text": "文字的一致性建議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1905.wav", + "text": "該第三人之事由者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1906.wav", + "text": "得不補償其損失之全部或一部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1907.wav", + "text": "意思跟剛剛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1908.wav", + "text": "司法院的說法是一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1909.wav", + "text": "的但是文字就跟" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1910.wav", + "text": "我們現有法典" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1911.wav", + "text": "的書寫方式一致化" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1912.wav", + "text": "這是一個建議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1913.wav", + "text": "得不補償其損失之全部或一部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1914.wav", + "text": "償也可以減量" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1915.wav", + "text": "對這就是犯保法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1916.wav", + "text": "剛才管委員所提到的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1917.wav", + "text": "但是這裡的前提是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1918.wav", + "text": "所以剛才司法院提出" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1919.wav", + "text": "減輕或免除其金額" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1920.wav", + "text": "因為警察勤務條例也有這種立法例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1921.wav", + "text": "樣是否比較簡單明確" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1922.wav", + "text": "不用全部或一部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1923.wav", + "text": "剛剛是提出警勤的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1924.wav", + "text": "也許" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1925.wav", + "text": "我們可以接受" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1926.wav", + "text": "邱委員和鄭天財委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1927.wav", + "text": "沒意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1928.wav", + "text": "因為大家都是讀法律的都可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1929.wav", + "text": "就照這樣好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1930.wav", + "text": "大家就不要再講了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1931.wav", + "text": "就照這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1932.wav", + "text": "文字怎麼寫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1933.wav", + "text": "K呀像司法院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1934.wav", + "text": "因為他說警察勤務條例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1935.wav", + "text": "支持廳長的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1936.wav", + "text": "意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1937.wav", + "text": "謝謝院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1938.wav", + "text": "有一點補充意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1939.wav", + "text": "報告事項第二案是委員洪孟楷" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1940.wav", + "text": "警械使用條例第1條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1941.wav", + "text": "第10條之1及第十一條條文修正草案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1942.wav", + "text": "第十九案是委員張育美" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1943.wav", + "text": "沒有併案討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1944.wav", + "text": "建議將它列入協商結論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1945.wav", + "text": "列入協商結論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1946.wav", + "text": "明天的案子都還" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1947.wav", + "text": "論\n大家都是這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1948.wav", + "text": "還沒出現" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1949.wav", + "text": "明天逕付二" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1950.wav", + "text": "一年後也可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1951.wav", + "text": "這樣會有點問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1952.wav", + "text": "能處理我們一定處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1953.wav", + "text": "好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1954.wav", + "text": "逕付二讀就好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1955.wav", + "text": "逕付二讀就併案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1956.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1957.wav", + "text": "協商主題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1958.wav", + "text": "行政院函請審議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1959.wav", + "text": "委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1960.wav", + "text": "王美惠等20人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1961.wav", + "text": "委員蔣萬安等19人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1962.wav", + "text": "委員賴惠員等19人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1963.wav", + "text": "委員張宏陸等20人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1964.wav", + "text": "委員管碧玲等17人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1965.wav", + "text": "及民眾黨黨團分別擬具" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1966.wav", + "text": "警械使用條例部分條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1967.wav", + "text": "修正草案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1968.wav", + "text": "及委員黃世杰等17人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1969.wav", + "text": "分別擬具" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1970.wav", + "text": "警械使用條例增訂第10條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1971.wav", + "text": "之1條文草案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1972.wav", + "text": "委員游毓" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1973.wav", + "text": "游毓蘭等16人擬具" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1974.wav", + "text": "警械使用條例第4條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1975.wav", + "text": "第10條之1及第十一條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1976.wav", + "text": "條文修正草案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1977.wav", + "text": "委員溫玉霞等16人及委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1978.wav", + "text": "羅致政等17人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1979.wav", + "text": "分別擬具警械使用條例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1980.wav", + "text": "第一條及第十一條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1981.wav", + "text": "條文修正草案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1982.wav", + "text": "併案協商之警械使用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1983.wav", + "text": "條例修正案等案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1984.wav", + "text": "\n協商結論一協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1985.wav", + "text": "通過條文第4條增訂" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1986.wav", + "text": "第10條之1第11條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1987.wav", + "text": "補充立法說明1項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1988.wav", + "text": "（如附件）三其餘均照" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1989.wav", + "text": "審查會審查結果通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1990.wav", + "text": "\n四條號及條文中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1991.wav", + "text": "引述之條號授權" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1992.wav", + "text": "\n五各黨團同意9月30日（星期五" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1993.wav", + "text": "）第2次院會議程" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1994.wav", + "text": "報告事項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1995.wav", + "text": "所列委員洪孟楷等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1996.wav", + "text": "委員張育美等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1997.wav", + "text": "分別所擬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1998.wav", + "text": "警械使用條例修正案等2案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/1999.wav", + "text": "逕付二讀" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/2000.wav", + "text": "與相關提案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/2001.wav", + "text": "併案協商並照上開協商結論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/2002.wav", + "text": "進行討論處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/2003.wav", + "text": "原則上是這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/2004.wav", + "text": "明天早上都沒有表決" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/2005.wav", + "text": "但是有很多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/2006.wav", + "text": "的十幾個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/2007.wav", + "text": "不知道可不可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/2008.wav", + "text": "如果沒表決大家就不會動員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/2009.wav", + "text": "我如果反對他就沒辦法表決了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/2010.wav", + "text": "這都OK的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/2011.wav", + "text": "協助更周全" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/2012.wav", + "text": "你強押警政署全部要吞下去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/2013.wav", + "text": "有的東西我不是那麼清楚警政署要看清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/2014.wav", + "text": "我們沒有動員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/2015.wav", + "text": "附帶決議本來就是有人反對的話就沒有了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/2016.wav", + "text": "所以儘量能夠協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/2017.wav", + "text": "就這些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/2018.wav", + "text": "十幾案沒有辦法在這裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/2019.wav", + "text": "回到新竹都8點了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/2020.wav", + "text": "很累好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/2021.wav", + "text": "行政部門先看清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/2022.wav", + "text": "假如行政部門" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/2023.wav", + "text": "等一下讓我把它講清楚好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/2024.wav", + "text": "請行政部門看清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/2025.wav", + "text": "稍微調整文字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/2026.wav", + "text": "能夠接受" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/2027.wav", + "text": "就不予處理了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/2028.wav", + "text": "文字可以修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/2029.wav", + "text": "對啦警政署看一看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/2030.wav", + "text": "明天要處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/2031.wav", + "text": "反對就表決" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/2032.wav", + "text": "跟院長各位委員報告明天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/2033.wav", + "text": "警政署去跟各位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/2034.wav", + "text": "但是他還沒有來跟我們協調" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/2035.wav", + "text": "明天再叫他們去講一講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/2036.wav", + "text": "不能接受" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/2037.wav", + "text": "反對就不予處理了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/2038.wav", + "text": "不行不行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/2039.wav", + "text": "反對還是要表決" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/2040.wav", + "text": "因為條文的部分我們已經說我們不再堅持了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/2041.wav", + "text": "要能夠通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/2042.wav", + "text": "要能夠處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/2043.wav", + "text": "這是程序問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/2044.wav", + "text": "通常附帶決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/2045.wav", + "text": "反對的話就是要表決" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/2046.wav", + "text": "要怎麼表決" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/2047.wav", + "text": "沒有我們沒有這個共識" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/2048.wav", + "text": "人數不足怎麼表決" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/2049.wav", + "text": "人數不足怎麼表決" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/2050.wav", + "text": "所以現在先不要談這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/2051.wav", + "text": "嘛現在先不要談" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/2052.wav", + "text": "跟他談好的方向" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/2053.wav", + "text": "跟我們談" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/2054.wav", + "text": "儘量可能讓它可以通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/2055.wav", + "text": "我們事先已經把這10個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/2056.wav", + "text": "也已經跟署長談了很多次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/2057.wav", + "text": "你現在拿出來我們看都還沒看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/2058.wav", + "text": "他同意我們也要同意啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/2059.wav", + "text": "這是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/2060.wav", + "text": "柯總召" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/2061.wav", + "text": "召這樣子好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/2062.wav", + "text": "大家不要再作秀了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/2063.wav", + "text": "\n不然的話現在馬上談" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/2064.wav", + "text": "大家都知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/2065.wav", + "text": "你這樣講就有對立的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/2066.wav", + "text": "大家都一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/2067.wav", + "text": "\n假如人數不足怎麼表決" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/2068.wav", + "text": "請大家理性思考一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/2069.wav", + "text": "這個是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/2070.wav", + "text": "原則問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/2071.wav", + "text": "如果不同意就不予處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/2072.wav", + "text": "這是原則問題該" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/2073.wav", + "text": "表決就表決沒關係" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/2074.wav", + "text": "表示誠意嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/2075.wav", + "text": "先退駕" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/2076.wav", + "text": "這很快啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/2077.wav", + "text": "我陪大家談一談" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/2078.wav", + "text": "可以就可以不行的話要甲動再" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/2079.wav", + "text": "應該都是可以談的啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/2080.wav", + "text": "署長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/2081.wav", + "text": "你不要走我們來談" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/2082.wav", + "text": "我看國民黨的附帶決議還好啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/2083.wav", + "text": "只是到現在總共有十幾個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/2084.wav", + "text": "要稍微看一" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/2085.wav", + "text": "跟大家報告一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/2086.wav", + "text": "本案在二讀進行前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/2087.wav", + "text": "依協商共識由各黨團各推派" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/2088.wav", + "text": "一名代表發���" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/2089.wav", + "text": "發言完畢即依協商結論進行二讀" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14446/2090.wav", + "text": "\n協商結論現在已經簽署完畢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/0.wav", + "text": "是謝謝主席各位委員請財政部主席各位委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/1.wav", + "text": "財政部的意見也是建議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/2.wav", + "text": "我們希望能夠在所得稅法第十七條裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/3.wav", + "text": "做整體通盤的考量" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/4.wav", + "text": "因為到目前為止" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/5.wav", + "text": "關於所得稅法第十七條委員的提案總共有38案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/6.wav", + "text": "建議修正或增訂的項目有45項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/7.wav", + "text": "我們希望是在這個扣除額整體去考量納稅義務" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/8.wav", + "text": "還有社會政策的優先性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/9.wav", + "text": "謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/10.wav", + "text": "還有財政部的說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/11.wav", + "text": "簡單講一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/12.wav", + "text": "住宅市場發展及管理條例的修法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/13.wav", + "text": "次長一再表示平均地權條例的修法很重要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/14.wav", + "text": "那除了平均地權條例之外" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/15.wav", + "text": "租屋的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/16.wav", + "text": "這個是很重要的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/17.wav", + "text": "是20個契約的其中一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/18.wav", + "text": "在過去的時候人們就發現" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/19.wav", + "text": "有房子的人是所有權人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/20.wav", + "text": "他比較強勢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/21.wav", + "text": "所以在民法租賃契約的專章裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/22.wav", + "text": "或者散見各種法規範裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/23.wav", + "text": "它就有注意到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/24.wav", + "text": "應該要去保障租客的權利" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/25.wav", + "text": "譬如民法第402條的買賣不破租賃" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/26.wav", + "text": "房子雖然賣給人家了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/27.wav", + "text": "但是後手還是跟租客之間成立了租賃關係" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/28.wav", + "text": "類似這樣的概念" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/29.wav", + "text": "\n所以在這種關係上面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/30.wav", + "text": "我們要處理的應該是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/31.wav", + "text": "到底在這樣的高房價" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/32.wav", + "text": "造成年輕世代沉重負擔跟壓力的情況之下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/33.wav", + "text": "我們一定要讓他可以租得起房" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/34.wav", + "text": "而且能夠保障他" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/35.wav", + "text": "所以在這個狀況之下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/36.wav", + "text": "有去做一些相應的調整" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/37.wav", + "text": "譬如我們在第10條裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/38.wav", + "text": "雖然它有規定出租人提前終止租約的催告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/39.wav", + "text": "但是問題來了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/40.wav", + "text": "它沒有定一個相當期限" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/41.wav", + "text": "催告等於形同具文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/42.wav", + "text": "反而是限縮了承租人的權益保障" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/43.wav", + "text": "所以就這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/44.wav", + "text": "我們希望能夠把它補起來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/45.wav", + "text": "因為考量到我剛才說的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/46.wav", + "text": "租賃糾紛裡面承租人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/47.wav", + "text": "跟別人租房子已經相對比較弱勢了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/48.wav", + "text": "其實已經足夠明確" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/49.wav", + "text": "了所以你如果再把它加一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/50.wav", + "text": "難以繼續居住\n的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/51.wav", + "text": "什麼叫難以繼續居住" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/52.wav", + "text": "然後他還要負舉證責任" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/53.wav", + "text": "實務上這是很困難" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/54.wav", + "text": "的所以在這邊提案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/55.wav", + "text": "希望能夠刪除這樣的限制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/56.wav", + "text": "好比說他發生紛爭的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/57.wav", + "text": "過去我們租房" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/58.wav", + "text": "（所有權人）發生糾紛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/59.wav", + "text": "到底這個要怎麼處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/60.wav", + "text": "實務上現在的做法好比" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/61.wav", + "text": "好比說我們去嘉義市" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/62.wav", + "text": "義市東區的調解會調解" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/63.wav", + "text": "調解不成的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/64.wav", + "text": "它可能是一個小額訴訟" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/65.wav", + "text": "你就去嘉義地院提起小額訴訟" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/66.wav", + "text": "等等之類的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/67.wav", + "text": "\n所以在這個情況之下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/68.wav", + "text": "事實上本來調解會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/69.wav", + "text": "的功能就是車禍的也來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/70.wav", + "text": "租房子的也來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/71.wav", + "text": "離婚的也可以什麼都來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/72.wav", + "text": "對租賃或是對房地相關的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/73.wav", + "text": "是否充足這是個問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/74.wav", + "text": "所以我們希望" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/75.wav", + "text": "提出一個租賃爭議調解委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/76.wav", + "text": "針對這一類型的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/77.wav", + "text": "調解機制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/78.wav", + "text": "其實這個量也夠大" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/79.wav", + "text": "你可以看到各地大學的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/80.wav", + "text": "法律服務社裡面大家來問的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/81.wav", + "text": "很多也都是租賃的糾紛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/82.wav", + "text": "量其實也夠大" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/83.wav", + "text": "租賃法律關係專門訓練的人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/84.wav", + "text": "建立起一個租賃糾紛的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/85.wav", + "text": "調解機制可能會對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/86.wav", + "text": "\n剛剛次長也提到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/87.wav", + "text": "實價登錄的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/88.wav", + "text": "因為現在看起來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/89.wav", + "text": "是不動產經紀業的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/90.wav", + "text": "成交契約才有登錄的義務" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/91.wav", + "text": "不管是不動產交易的透明化也好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/92.wav", + "text": "或者是租屋的實價" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/93.wav", + "text": "登錄機制等等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/94.wav", + "text": "這都是一樣都是希望" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/95.wav", + "text": "能夠更了解不管是不動產交易市場也好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/96.wav", + "text": "或租屋市場的樣貌" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/97.wav", + "text": "所以提出這樣的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/98.wav", + "text": "主張" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/99.wav", + "text": "\n最後一個內政部雖然有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/100.wav", + "text": "應約定及不得約定事項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/101.wav", + "text": "但是它沒有罰則" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/102.wav", + "text": "這是一樣的意思譬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/103.wav", + "text": "譬如你有催告但是你沒有定期限" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/104.wav", + "text": "這樣就形同具文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/105.wav", + "text": "或是你有約定及不得約定事項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/106.wav", + "text": "但是你沒有相關的罰則" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/107.wav", + "text": "所以希望在第38條之1定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/108.wav", + "text": "定一個罰則" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/109.wav", + "text": "可以藉以保障包租代管" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/110.wav", + "text": "總合來講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/111.wav", + "text": "已經有這樣的需要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/112.wav", + "text": "我們如何在租客和" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/113.wav", + "text": "和出租人之間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/114.wav", + "text": "平衡點到底在哪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/115.wav", + "text": "現在看起來我們更需要去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/116.wav", + "text": "其實我們的法規範" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/117.wav", + "text": "相較於歐洲來講對承租人的保障" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/118.wav", + "text": "應該要趕快跟上這樣一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/119.wav", + "text": "腳步以上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/120.wav", + "text": "聚焦我們是不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/121.wav", + "text": "就從保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/122.wav", + "text": "逐條進行條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/123.wav", + "text": "第5條是保留的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/124.wav", + "text": "內政部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/125.wav", + "text": "有沒有修正意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/126.wav", + "text": "現行條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/127.wav", + "text": "主席" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/128.wav", + "text": "剛才聽到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/129.wav", + "text": "大家都很願意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/130.wav", + "text": "修" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/131.wav", + "text": "讓效果顯現出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/132.wav", + "text": "剛才聽花次長說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/133.wav", + "text": "縣市大家都反對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/134.wav", + "text": "的理由是什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/135.wav", + "text": "是你們去宣導不夠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/136.wav", + "text": "是不是要讓我們知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/137.wav", + "text": "不然中央" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/138.wav", + "text": "也嚇了一跳" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/139.wav", + "text": "主席" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/140.wav", + "text": "到那條的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/141.wav", + "text": "處理第5條這邊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/142.wav", + "text": "有沒有任何問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/143.wav", + "text": "怎麼樣請內政部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/144.wav", + "text": "主席跟各位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/145.wav", + "text": "委員報告我剛剛有特別提到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/146.wav", + "text": "其實方向上面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/147.wav", + "text": "我們當然也期待" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/148.wav", + "text": "保障" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/149.wav", + "text": "把整部消保法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/150.wav", + "text": "企業的要求" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/151.wav", + "text": "通通加諸在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/152.wav", + "text": "房東的身上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/153.wav", + "text": "我們可能還沒有整個好好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/154.wav", + "text": "檢視過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/155.wav", + "text": "處理能夠透過消保" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/156.wav", + "text": "系統來處理糾紛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/157.wav", + "text": "事項和不應記載事項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/158.wav", + "text": "在租賃契約租屋體系底下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/159.wav", + "text": "能夠百分之百涵蓋" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/160.wav", + "text": "這樣的方向我們都支持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/161.wav", + "text": "但是消保法不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/162.wav", + "text": "只有這些內容" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/163.wav", + "text": "消保法對企業責任的要求" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/164.wav", + "text": "其實還有其他" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/165.wav", + "text": "關於產品無過失責任" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/166.wav", + "text": "我會建議是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/167.wav", + "text": "再多討論一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/168.wav", + "text": "消保法裡面這麼多的責任" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/169.wav", + "text": "很多小房東擔得起還是擔不起" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/170.wav", + "text": "我們再來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/171.wav", + "text": "談這一條會比較平衡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/172.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/173.wav", + "text": "其實我" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/174.wav", + "text": "第5條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/175.wav", + "text": "第1項不得約定之事項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/176.wav", + "text": "其內容得包括" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/177.wav", + "text": "限制或免除" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/178.wav", + "text": "租賃當事人之一方" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/179.wav", + "text": "義務或責任" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/180.wav", + "text": "違反了人家定契約的精神" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/181.wav", + "text": "限制的這麼死" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/182.wav", + "text": "那以後全都用公版的契約就好啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/183.wav", + "text": "他們不能自訂契約" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/184.wav", + "text": "不是這樣吧" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/185.wav", + "text": "我覺得你這個以後可能會變這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/186.wav", + "text": "主席" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/187.wav", + "text": "討論的就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/188.wav", + "text": "否為消保法的消費關係" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/189.wav", + "text": "內政部的報告提到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/190.wav", + "text": "大概有95%都適用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/191.wav", + "text": "只有5%不適用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/192.wav", + "text": "適用消保法關係的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/193.wav", + "text": "也有不適用不具消費關係的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/194.wav", + "text": "此時即依照我們訂定的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/195.wav", + "text": "與不得約定事項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/196.wav", + "text": "房東" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/197.wav", + "text": "約束" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/198.wav", + "text": "是不是過當" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/199.wav", + "text": "企業的相當" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/200.wav", + "text": "無過失責任" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/201.wav", + "text": "這樣是不是過重\n" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/202.wav", + "text": "適用消保法這點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/203.wav", + "text": "點從過去到現在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/204.wav", + "text": "包括消保會在內其實都開過好幾次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/205.wav", + "text": "會與" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/206.wav", + "text": "會的專家學者對此並未定調" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/207.wav", + "text": "之所以沒有定調是因為適" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/208.wav", + "text": "甚至包租業者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/209.wav", + "text": "\n所以我的版本比較是在談" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/210.wav", + "text": "租賃專法中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/211.wav", + "text": "中應記載與不得記載事項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/212.wav", + "text": "讓所有的條件都要符合" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/213.wav", + "text": "我想這部分就是這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/214.wav", + "text": "部分就比較輕一點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/215.wav", + "text": "也就是房東如果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/216.wav", + "text": "違反規定時先提醒警告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/217.wav", + "text": "之後再罰兩千元到一萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/218.wav", + "text": "元\n某個程度來說這其" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/219.wav", + "text": "的樣態而定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/220.wav", + "text": "那麼我們是不是就在專法中處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/221.wav", + "text": "如果用消保法的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/222.wav", + "text": "得不太適合" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/223.wav", + "text": "再做細部討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/224.wav", + "text": "因為這是一個立法過程" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/225.wav", + "text": "我們要思考清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/226.wav", + "text": "張委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/227.wav", + "text": "主席各位委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/228.wav", + "text": "行政院消費者保護處" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/229.wav", + "text": "在做這些事\n" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/230.wav", + "text": "\n至於到底有無消費關係" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/231.wav", + "text": "實施出租行為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/232.wav", + "text": "並以出租為業" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/233.wav", + "text": "還有承租的目的是否自用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/234.wav", + "text": "等等這些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/235.wav", + "text": "如果能把這點寫清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/236.wav", + "text": "比較混沌不清的狀況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/237.wav", + "text": "也就是等於把行政院的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/238.wav", + "text": "實務作為解決問題的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/239.wav", + "text": "以上謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/240.wav", + "text": "花次長各位同仁大家好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/241.wav", + "text": "目前在資訊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/242.wav", + "text": "租屋者相對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/243.wav", + "text": "不公平" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/244.wav", + "text": "而我的主張是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/245.wav", + "text": "個人出租也要申報" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/246.wav", + "text": "因為假如透過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/247.wav", + "text": "話有什麼事情房仲還會幫忙協助處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/248.wav", + "text": "其實" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/249.wav", + "text": "的心態或是他到底有沒有良心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/250.wav", + "text": "做當然有些縣市不願意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/251.wav", + "text": "做但能不能分階段" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/252.wav", + "text": "把它納進來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/253.wav", + "text": "不然這麼大的一個缺口" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/254.wav", + "text": "尤其租屋者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/255.wav", + "text": "是相對處於弱勢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/256.wav", + "text": "我覺得應該儘量把它納進來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/257.wav", + "text": "房東也享有免稅" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/258.wav", + "text": "基本上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/259.wav", + "text": "租屋者免稅的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/260.wav", + "text": "所以在大方向上我是希望能夠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/261.wav", + "text": "儘量公開透明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/262.wav", + "text": "假設一時做不到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/263.wav", + "text": "看看能不能分階段" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/264.wav", + "text": "我比較支持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/265.wav", + "text": "吳玉琴委員的提案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/266.wav", + "text": "條文是把租賃關係分成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/267.wav", + "text": "具有消費關係者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/268.wav", + "text": "適用消保法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/269.wav", + "text": "非具有消費關係者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/270.wav", + "text": "就用另外一種方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/271.wav", + "text": "來處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/272.wav", + "text": "不用這樣區分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/273.wav", + "text": "如果這樣區分的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/274.wav", + "text": "會變成還要再加入這樣一個判斷" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/275.wav", + "text": "我覺得這會非常的複雜" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/276.wav", + "text": "吳玉琴委員的版本是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/277.wav", + "text": "不再區分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/278.wav", + "text": "是否具有消費關係" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/279.wav", + "text": "就全部把住宅租賃契約納入本條的規範" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/280.wav", + "text": "\n第二個是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/281.wav", + "text": "約定改為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/282.wav", + "text": "應記載或不得記載事項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/283.wav", + "text": "應該授權由中央主管機關定之" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/284.wav", + "text": "我覺得這樣是比較清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/285.wav", + "text": "的如果違反" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/286.wav", + "text": "應記載或不得記載事項的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/287.wav", + "text": "它是一個無效的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/288.wav", + "text": "契約條款規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/289.wav", + "text": "\n最後補充一個就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/290.wav", + "text": "剛剛提到的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/291.wav", + "text": "其實這個東西應該是要有罰則" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/292.wav", + "text": "如果沒有罰則的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/293.wav", + "text": "而已法律其實很講究" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/294.wav", + "text": "的是構成要件寫出來之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/295.wav", + "text": "這個要很清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/296.wav", + "text": "以上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/297.wav", + "text": "第5條的所有提案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/298.wav", + "text": "其實是兩個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/299.wav", + "text": "完全不同" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/300.wav", + "text": "是兩個完全不同的取向" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/301.wav", + "text": "一個是把" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/302.wav", + "text": "包租代管的業者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/303.wav", + "text": "當作非" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/304.wav", + "text": "企業經營者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/305.wav", + "text": "不當作消保法適用的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/306.wav", + "text": "企業經營者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/307.wav", + "text": "反而把個別" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/308.wav", + "text": "房東個人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/309.wav", + "text": "房東當作企業" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/310.wav", + "text": "經營者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/311.wav", + "text": "把它納入消保法管理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/312.wav", + "text": "民眾黨的第二個提案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/313.wav", + "text": "這個提案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/314.wav", + "text": "大概就會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/315.wav", + "text": "讓個別的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/316.wav", + "text": "個人式的個人房東" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/317.wav", + "text": "者所" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/318.wav", + "text": "應該要負無過失" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/319.wav", + "text": "即負擔所有一切" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/320.wav", + "text": "健康安全跟���命" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/321.wav", + "text": "相關的房客" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/322.wav", + "text": "保護" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/323.wav", + "text": "房東所承擔得起" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/324.wav", + "text": "的我覺得我們要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/325.wav", + "text": "更清楚瞭解" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/326.wav", + "text": "還是要回歸去想" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/327.wav", + "text": "要適用消保法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/328.wav", + "text": "是為了要保護" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/329.wav", + "text": "租屋者的權利" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/330.wav", + "text": "是要保護他哪部分的權利" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/331.wav", + "text": "程序部分的權利" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/332.wav", + "text": "還是實質的無過失" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/333.wav", + "text": "責任的權利" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/334.wav", + "text": "如果是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/335.wav", + "text": "程序性的權利" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/336.wav", + "text": "讓他可以在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/337.wav", + "text": "有糾紛爭議的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/338.wav", + "text": "納入消費者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/339.wav", + "text": "糾紛處理讓消保官" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/340.wav", + "text": "來保護爭議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/341.wav", + "text": "假設是那個的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/342.wav", + "text": "文字就不應該是現在的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/343.wav", + "text": "這種文字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/344.wav", + "text": "現在這個文字是包括" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/345.wav", + "text": "程序的保護跟" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/346.wav", + "text": "全部統統包在一起" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/347.wav", + "text": "讓他澈底成為一個企業" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/348.wav", + "text": "經營者然後要負所有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/349.wav", + "text": "消保法要求的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/350.wav", + "text": "無過失責任" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/351.wav", + "text": "這個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/352.wav", + "text": "我們要保護租屋者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/353.wav", + "text": "但是同時也要瞭解" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/354.wav", + "text": "對房東的法律角色" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/355.wav", + "text": "怎麼設定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/356.wav", + "text": "如果我們只是要保護" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/357.wav", + "text": "房客在跟" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/358.wav", + "text": "房東有糾紛時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/359.wav", + "text": "能夠受消保官" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/360.wav", + "text": "的救濟程序" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/361.wav", + "text": "如果我們只是想要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/362.wav", + "text": "在那個救濟程序引用消保法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/363.wav", + "text": "現在已經都有接受了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/364.wav", + "text": "第二個就是我們在文字上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/365.wav", + "text": "就應該把它侷限在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/366.wav", + "text": "救濟程序的準用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/367.wav", + "text": "而不是整部消保法的準用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/368.wav", + "text": "\n所以我看這一題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/369.wav", + "text": "我們今天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/370.wav", + "text": "根本不可能有結論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/371.wav", + "text": "第5條今天是不可能有結論的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/372.wav", + "text": "因為這兩個取向" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/373.wav", + "text": "截然不同" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/374.wav", + "text": "倒是吳玉琴委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/375.wav", + "text": "approach" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/376.wav", + "text": "那個部分我們能不能多討論一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/377.wav", + "text": "因為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/378.wav", + "text": "適用準用整部消保法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/379.wav", + "text": "我覺得剛剛恐怕也沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/380.wav", + "text": "很多委員如此" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/381.wav", + "text": "主張" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/382.wav", + "text": "我想民眾黨當初會提出" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/383.wav", + "text": "這個可能最主要也是在救濟程序" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/384.wav", + "text": "上的保障" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/385.wav", + "text": "而不是整部消保法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/386.wav", + "text": "無過失責任的權利取得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/387.wav", + "text": "所以這個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/388.wav", + "text": "我們反而比較知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/389.wav", + "text": "整部消保法真的可能" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/390.wav", + "text": "有窒礙難行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/391.wav", + "text": "倒是吳玉琴委員的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/392.wav", + "text": "應記載" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/393.wav", + "text": "不得記載應約定不得約定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/394.wav", + "text": "事項的那個部分我們可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/395.wav", + "text": "多討論一下它的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/396.wav", + "text": "妳的主張" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/397.wav", + "text": "主席我想我們今天的版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/398.wav", + "text": "消費關係是採用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/399.wav", + "text": "消保會的一個函釋將第" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/400.wav", + "text": "1050165274號" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/401.wav", + "text": "所謂的消費關係" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/402.wav", + "text": "裡的租賃" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/403.wav", + "text": "做了一個援引過來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/404.wav", + "text": "所以我相信這個部分並不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/405.wav", + "text": "包山包海的去處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/406.wav", + "text": "租賃的關聯性只是在定義上面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/407.wav", + "text": "裡面所謂企業出租" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/408.wav", + "text": "裡面做說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/409.wav", + "text": "\n整體大家都知道現在租屋市場" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/410.wav", + "text": "大概有百萬戶" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/411.wav", + "text": "這百萬戶裡面如果扣除剛剛所講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/412.wav", + "text": "可以類企業型的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/413.wav", + "text": "扣除之外才是剛剛大家擔心的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/414.wav", + "text": "小房東小房客" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/415.wav", + "text": "其實現在小房東的權益也沒有受到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/416.wav", + "text": "保障很多小房東大概也沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/417.wav", + "text": "辦法在現有的法規裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/418.wav", + "text": "去主張自己的權利" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/419.wav", + "text": "大家應該還記得當時在質詢的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/420.wav", + "text": "我們也有針對現在用消保法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/421.wav", + "text": "其實數量很少我記得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/422.wav", + "text": "數字不到百戶" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/423.wav", + "text": "所以消保法確實是如此如果大家都說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/424.wav", + "text": "好像沒有擴大到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/425.wav", + "text": "讓雙方的權益在這個系統上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/426.wav", + "text": "可以處理所以我覺得把" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/427.wav", + "text": "適度的援引進來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/428.wav", + "text": "都是走地政業務的調處" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/429.wav", + "text": "看起來調處的量是多的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/430.wav", + "text": "可是結果也沒有真的能夠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/431.wav", + "text": "滿意或認同" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/432.wav", + "text": "租屋條例裡面對於" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/433.wav", + "text": "糾紛處置的有效性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/434.wav", + "text": "整體上如果用消保法好像" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/435.wav", + "text": "會很嚴格規格很高可是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/436.wav", + "text": "現在去適用的量及其" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/437.wav", + "text": "次長當時好像也有分析過也承認" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/438.wav", + "text": "沒有達到你們認為的效果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/439.wav", + "text": "所以我希望的是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/440.wav", + "text": "即使不是在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/441.wav", + "text": "做處分的目的性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/442.wav", + "text": "但是它的適用性是要請大家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/443.wav", + "text": "慎重面對到底什麼機制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/444.wav", + "text": "應記載不得記載也是會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/445.wav", + "text": "涉及到公權力的落實" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/446.wav", + "text": "這兩個部分還是請內政部多處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/447.wav", + "text": "一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/448.wav", + "text": "我說明一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/449.wav", + "text": "行政院消費者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/450.wav", + "text": "保護處" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/451.wav", + "text": "租賃契約具消費" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/452.wav", + "text": "關係者適用消費者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/453.wav", + "text": "保護法相關規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/454.wav", + "text": "所以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/455.wav", + "text": "如果照" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/456.wav", + "text": "吳玉琴委員的條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/457.wav", + "text": "這句話都沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/458.wav", + "text": "的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/459.wav", + "text": "就等於是刪除了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/460.wav", + "text": "消費者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/461.wav", + "text": "保護法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/462.wav", + "text": "因為原來的規定是有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/463.wav", + "text": "你現在把它刪除" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/464.wav", + "text": "就會被解釋成租" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/465.wav", + "text": "消費者保護法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/466.wav", + "text": "會有這樣的疑慮" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/467.wav", + "text": "所以等一下也要請" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/468.wav", + "text": "消保處來說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/469.wav", + "text": "包括針對其他" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/470.wav", + "text": "內容的意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/471.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/472.wav", + "text": "吳委員的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/473.wav", + "text": "他等一下會解釋" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/474.wav", + "text": "雖然租賃不適用消費者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/475.wav", + "text": "保護的調處機制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/476.wav", + "text": "但是它後面就適用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/477.wav", + "text": "調解委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/478.wav", + "text": "就是用這個專法專門去設一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/479.wav", + "text": "的調解委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/480.wav", + "text": "那部分等一下他會解釋" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/481.wav", + "text": "我倒是也真的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/482.wav", + "text": "有catch到賴委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/483.wav", + "text": "的主張剛剛賴委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/484.wav", + "text": "所說的要適用消費者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/485.wav", + "text": "保護關係也是指調處" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/486.wav", + "text": "機制就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/487.wav", + "text": "要準用消保法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/488.wav", + "text": "大概也是準用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/489.wav", + "text": "機制那幾條不應該" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/490.wav", + "text": "整部準用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/491.wav", + "text": "這兩個方向要用哪個方向" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/492.wav", + "text": "一個方向就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/493.wav", + "text": "準用消保法某幾條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/494.wav", + "text": "這是一個方向" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/495.wav", + "text": "另外一個方向就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/496.wav", + "text": "吳委員的提案專門為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/497.wav", + "text": "到底我們要走哪個方向" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/498.wav", + "text": "我覺得那個最上位要先決定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/499.wav", + "text": "這個上位不決定好也走不下去請" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/500.wav", + "text": "吳委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/501.wav", + "text": "我們有自己的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/502.wav", + "text": "應記載跟不得記載事項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/503.wav", + "text": "有關爭議的部分其實大家的焦點都" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/504.wav", + "text": "是租賃關係有爭議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/505.wav", + "text": "的時候要怎麼處理關於第" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/506.wav", + "text": "內政部��提案就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/507.wav", + "text": "協助調處" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/508.wav", + "text": "並免徵調處費用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/509.wav", + "text": "我們原來認為租賃的相關爭議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/510.wav", + "text": "大概就放在地方政府層級處理了可是這麼多年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/511.wav", + "text": "調解案數是個位數" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/512.wav", + "text": "所以其實是沒有功能的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/513.wav", + "text": "這是一個專法本來這個專法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/514.wav", + "text": "的概念其實也希望在地方政府就可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/515.wav", + "text": "調處所以我在我的版本中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/516.wav", + "text": "處理本條例中有關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/517.wav", + "text": "租賃關係的糾紛時" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/518.wav", + "text": "可以設住宅租賃糾紛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/519.wav", + "text": "專家一起協助" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/520.wav", + "text": "當然也可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/521.wav", + "text": "比照鄉鎮市調解委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/522.wav", + "text": "條例的相關規定來處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/523.wav", + "text": "如果屬於消費關係" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/524.wav", + "text": "要不要就準用消保法的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/525.wav", + "text": "相關調解的條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/526.wav", + "text": "我覺得這樣等於是多元" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/527.wav", + "text": "的方式我記得在上次討論的過程中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/528.wav", + "text": "專家學者也都比較主張" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/529.wav", + "text": "多元的調解管道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/530.wav", + "text": "有些具消費關係的是不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/531.wav", + "text": "也準用消保法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/532.wav", + "text": "裡面調解的條文我覺得這些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/533.wav", + "text": "都是多元調解的管道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/534.wav", + "text": "報告召委及各位委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/535.wav", + "text": "還沒有租賃" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/536.wav", + "text": "房屋租賃定型化契約的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/537.wav", + "text": "應記載跟不得記載事項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/538.wav", + "text": "就已經出爐了其實當時" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/539.wav", + "text": "考量點就在於" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/540.wav", + "text": "房東跟房客之間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/541.wav", + "text": "有很多糾紛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/542.wav", + "text": "不管是因為房東" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/543.wav", + "text": "所造成的或因為房客所" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/544.wav", + "text": "造成的我們總認為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/545.wav", + "text": "一定要有一套規範使" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/546.wav", + "text": "雙方在產生糾紛之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/547.wav", + "text": "有一個處理的依據" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/548.wav", + "text": "麻煩內政部能不能" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/549.wav", + "text": "按照消保法的規定授權" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/550.wav", + "text": "內政部去定一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/551.wav", + "text": "房屋租賃定型化契約的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/552.wav", + "text": "應記載不得記載事項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/553.wav", + "text": "可是我們訂完之後很快地在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/554.wav", + "text": "兩年過後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/555.wav", + "text": "租賃條例也就在立法院通過了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/556.wav", + "text": "如果是一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/557.wav", + "text": "考量點可能不是只有單純地" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/558.wav", + "text": "在所謂的房客" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/559.wav", + "text": "我們一直認為的消費者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/560.wav", + "text": "權益端落實保障比較多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/561.wav", + "text": "而是要平衡去保障" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/562.wav", + "text": "從消費者保護法的角度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/563.wav", + "text": "去做的立法一定是站在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/564.wav", + "text": "消費者權益保障的角度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/565.wav", + "text": "要考量多一點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/566.wav", + "text": "\n所以後來在上一次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/567.wav", + "text": "會期結束之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/568.wav", + "text": "專家的意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/569.wav", + "text": "有幾位學者提供了一些看法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/570.wav", + "text": "比如就吳玉琴委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/571.wav", + "text": "如果我們有專法的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/572.wav", + "text": "那是不是就是用專法的方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/573.wav", + "text": "跳脫原來的消費關係" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/574.wav", + "text": "而這在於站在一個平衡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/575.wav", + "text": "不管是房東或房客" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/576.wav", + "text": "的一個衡平立場" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/577.wav", + "text": "去處理相關以後所發生的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/578.wav", + "text": "這樣的意見其實我們在徵詢的過程中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/579.wav", + "text": "跟臺中市政府" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/580.wav", + "text": "倒是還蠻傾向" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/581.wav", + "text": "一個所謂的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/582.wav", + "text": "租賃法律關係" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/583.wav", + "text": "去規範房東跟房客之間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/584.wav", + "text": "用所謂打破" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/585.wav", + "text": "消費關係的看法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/586.wav", + "text": "當然也有一些縣市政府" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/587.wav", + "text": "像新北或桃園" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/588.wav", + "text": "因為他們大概認為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/589.wav", + "text": "目前他們的消保官部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/590.wav", + "text": "其實他們已經寬認了很多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/591.wav", + "text": "有爭議的所謂一人房東的案件" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/592.wav", + "text": "他們都納進來做所謂消費爭議的調解" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/593.wav", + "text": "其實是蠻有一些多元的意見存在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/594.wav", + "text": "既然有專法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/595.wav", + "text": "那就不要一定要依附在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/596.wav", + "text": "從消保法本身來看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/597.wav", + "text": "所著重的保障就是消費者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/598.wav", + "text": "但是從租賃的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/599.wav", + "text": "條例上來看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/600.wav", + "text": "不一定只有保障所謂房客" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/601.wav", + "text": "這個消費者也許房東也有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/602.wav", + "text": "非常弱勢的房東" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/603.wav", + "text": "所以應該是站在一個很衡平的角度去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/604.wav", + "text": "做考量如何讓" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/605.wav", + "text": "整個的租賃專法能夠更符合" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/606.wav", + "text": "可能就是剛剛管委員講的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/607.wav", + "text": "就是如果我們把房東也認為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/608.wav", + "text": "是企業經營者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/609.wav", + "text": "我們好像於心不忍" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/610.wav", + "text": "在國民感情上好像沒有辦法去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/611.wav", + "text": "但是如果說今天是一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/612.wav", + "text": "張姓女士" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/613.wav", + "text": "即便他是房東可是他已經" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/614.wav", + "text": "造成很大的影響" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/615.wav", + "text": "那是一個業者的管理我覺得那沒有問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/616.wav", + "text": "那就要用所謂" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/617.wav", + "text": "業者的方向去做管理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/618.wav", + "text": "但是如果是一般的房東" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/619.wav", + "text": "似乎不應該對他賦予" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/620.wav", + "text": "像消費者保護法中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/621.wav", + "text": "\n以上是消保處的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/622.wav", + "text": "看法跟意見大概是綜整一些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/623.wav", + "text": "學者專家給我們的一些看法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/624.wav", + "text": "以上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/625.wav", + "text": "這個涉及到整體的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/626.wav", + "text": "政策" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/627.wav", + "text": "到底這個政策要怎麼樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/628.wav", + "text": "做調整" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/629.wav", + "text": "這是很重要的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/630.wav", + "text": "所以還是要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/631.wav", + "text": "由行政部門做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/632.wav", + "text": "整體的考量" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/633.wav", + "text": "我補充一點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/634.wav", + "text": "對於這個問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/635.wav", + "text": "消費關係或者怎麼樣之類" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/636.wav", + "text": "其實我覺得癥結點是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/637.wav", + "text": "成效不彰" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/638.wav", + "text": "會比較好就是來處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/639.wav", + "text": "房客跟房東之間的糾紛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/640.wav", + "text": "消費關係的話我比較有一個co" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/641.wav", + "text": "rn就像剛才處長講的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/642.wav", + "text": "以新竹縣市來講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/643.wav", + "text": "新竹縣是一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/644.wav", + "text": "消保官" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/645.wav", + "text": "新竹市也是一個消保官" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/646.wav", + "text": "那我有一點擔心就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/647.wav", + "text": "就會變成是消保官來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/648.wav", + "text": "的消費關係裡面已經包羅萬象" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/649.wav", + "text": "執行面上是不是能夠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/650.wav", + "text": "處理這個問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/651.wav", + "text": "不彰我覺得是事實" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/652.wav", + "text": "所以在這一點上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/653.wav", + "text": "我們比較傾向的是在吳" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/654.wav", + "text": "委員的第十六條也有這樣的主張" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/655.wav", + "text": "就是在縣市政府的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/656.wav", + "text": "機制裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/657.wav", + "text": "在地政處或者在哪裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/658.wav", + "text": "有一個專門在調解" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/659.wav", + "text": "解租賃關係的機制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/660.wav", + "text": "至於差異在哪裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/661.wav", + "text": "差異是比起現有的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/662.wav", + "text": "鄉鎮市公所的調解" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/663.wav", + "text": "解可能會比較好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/664.wav", + "text": "因為他們有許多的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/665.wav", + "text": "地政專家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/666.wav", + "text": "或是有受相關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/667.wav", + "text": "租賃法律關係的人士" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/668.wav", + "text": "來進行調解" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/669.wav", + "text": "而且這個機制久了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/670.wav", + "text": "也會累積很多的實務經驗" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/671.wav", + "text": "可能比較有幫助" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/672.wav", + "text": "好由於這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/673.wav", + "text": "涉及到整體政策的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/674.wav", + "text": "重大調整" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/675.wav", + "text": "包括後面的條文都有連帶關係" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/676.wav", + "text": "還有行政院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/677.wav", + "text": "等相關的部門" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/678.wav", + "text": "盤點看到底應該" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/679.wav", + "text": "要怎麼處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/680.wav", + "text": "這也會涉及到未來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/681.wav", + "text": "消保法的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/682.wav", + "text": "那消保官是不是以後還要處理這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/683.wav", + "text": "可能就沒有了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/684.wav", + "text": "所以要通盤考量人力等各方面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/685.wav", + "text": "行政部門" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/686.wav", + "text": "第一個除了跟消保單位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/687.wav", + "text": "之間的協調溝通" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/688.wav", + "text": "當初只有問" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/689.wav", + "text": "問這一題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/690.wav", + "text": "這可能會需要比較多的時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/691.wav", + "text": "我們的總質詢大概是一個多月" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/692.wav", + "text": "在總質詢結束後才可以開始處理法案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/693.wav", + "text": "主席是不是請他們利用這" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/694.wav", + "text": "差不多一個月的時間趕快" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/695.wav", + "text": "機關的溝通" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/696.wav", + "text": "趕快去做好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/697.wav", + "text": "請教各位委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/698.wav", + "text": "因為這涉及到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/699.wav", + "text": "重大政策" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/700.wav", + "text": "我們是不是就交給院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/701.wav", + "text": "這樣還是太快喔因為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/702.wav", + "text": "這個很專業" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/703.wav", + "text": "他們拿出來的東西也不知道是什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/704.wav", + "text": "院長也不會馬上協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/705.wav", + "text": "在送到他那裡以後任何人都可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/706.wav", + "text": "隨時要求他啟動啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/707.wav", + "text": "我覺得還是要給我們委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/708.wav", + "text": "還是先不要送出委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/709.wav", + "text": "我們各黨團" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/710.wav", + "text": "我們連看都沒看過就交給黨團三長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/711.wav", + "text": "我也不服啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/712.wav", + "text": "好那我就繼續現" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/713.wav", + "text": "在只有兩條通過有十幾個條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/714.wav", + "text": "係到基本結構我們連看都沒看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/715.wav", + "text": "好那就另定期協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/716.wav", + "text": "就照剛才所講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/717.wav", + "text": "的請行政部門趕快" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/718.wav", + "text": "進行規劃" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14434/719.wav", + "text": "並提出修正條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/0.wav", + "text": "我在8月的時也曾" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/1.wav", + "text": "司法院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/2.wav", + "text": "還有相關的機關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/3.wav", + "text": "司法院今天也提出" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/4.wav", + "text": "經送交給我了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/5.wav", + "text": "給各位委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/6.wav", + "text": "秘書長9月8日的一份公文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/7.wav", + "text": "而我們今天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/8.wav", + "text": "保留條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/9.wav", + "text": "黨團有再提" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/10.wav", + "text": "修正條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/11.wav", + "text": "所以我們等一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/12.wav", + "text": "涉及到該條條文時" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/13.wav", + "text": "如果跟" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/14.wav", + "text": "條文亦即與內政委��會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/15.wav", + "text": "審查通過的條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/16.wav", + "text": "有不一樣的話就再提出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/17.wav", + "text": "如果一樣就不用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/18.wav", + "text": "這樣我們就可以集中焦點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/19.wav", + "text": "內政委員會進行審查時所" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/20.wav", + "text": "保留的兩條條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/21.wav", + "text": "上次委員會審查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/22.wav", + "text": "所通過的條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/23.wav", + "text": "有第1條到第4條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/24.wav", + "text": "第6條第8條第10條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/25.wav", + "text": "以及增訂第10條之二" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/26.wav", + "text": "第10條之三" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/27.wav", + "text": "及第十二條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/28.wav", + "text": "內政委員會上次審查時" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/29.wav", + "text": "通過的條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/30.wav", + "text": "保留的條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/31.wav", + "text": "是增訂第10條之一" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/32.wav", + "text": "及第十一條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/33.wav", + "text": "對上次通過的條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/34.wav", + "text": "我再念一次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/35.wav", + "text": "是第1條到第4條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/36.wav", + "text": "是內政委員會上次通過的條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/37.wav", + "text": "第6條第8條第10條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/38.wav", + "text": "然後增訂第10條之二" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/39.wav", + "text": "第10條之三" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/40.wav", + "text": "及第十二條也是上次通過的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/41.wav", + "text": "對於內政委員會上次通過的條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/42.wav", + "text": "各位委員有沒有要再表示意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/43.wav", + "text": "主席我補充一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/44.wav", + "text": "有增加一段話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/45.wav", + "text": "增列中央主管機關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/46.wav", + "text": "應充分提供第1項警械" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/47.wav", + "text": "以及警察人員防護裝備" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/48.wav", + "text": "並提供充足的警械使用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/49.wav", + "text": "及安全防護訓練" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/50.wav", + "text": "但現行條文沒有這一項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/51.wav", + "text": "由於今天所討論的是警械使用條例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/52.wav", + "text": "就像我剛才跟部長稍微聊了一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/53.wav", + "text": "包括我們能提供充分的警械" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/54.wav", + "text": "這部分應該是很重要的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/55.wav", + "text": "主要有兩個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/56.wav", + "text": "部分一個是警械" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/57.wav", + "text": "針對電擊器的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/58.wav", + "text": "另一個部分是發" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/59.wav", + "text": "我們也有一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/60.wav", + "text": "2020推動精進員警執勤安��方案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/61.wav", + "text": "購置400多支電擊槍" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/62.wav", + "text": "但因為臺灣總計有七萬多名警察" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/63.wav", + "text": "每一百位警察" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/64.wav", + "text": "只有6位可以配置電擊槍" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/65.wav", + "text": "有這樣的條文去強化" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/66.wav", + "text": "\n第二個關於防護裝備的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/67.wav", + "text": "因為從嘉義鐵路殺警案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/68.wav", + "text": "兇嫌犯案手法都是近身持刀攻擊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/69.wav", + "text": "我們也應該具備防砍功能的背心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/70.wav", + "text": "才能讓第一線同仁免於這樣的風險" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/71.wav", + "text": "依照警察人員教育訓練實施計畫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/72.wav", + "text": "每人每月射擊至少應訓練兩小時" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/73.wav", + "text": "體技訓練至少四小時" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/74.wav", + "text": "射擊訓練時數" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/75.wav", + "text": "且有百分之百的機關沒有達到體技訓練的時數" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/76.wav", + "text": "數所以從剛剛這幾個例子來看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/77.wav", + "text": "現在的狀況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/78.wav", + "text": "警察人員教育訓練實施計畫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/79.wav", + "text": "是1976年所頒訂的計畫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/80.wav", + "text": "迄今已經過了46年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/81.wav", + "text": "所以我們應該要朝著時代的演變" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/82.wav", + "text": "社會的氛圍" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/83.wav", + "text": "警力的配置等做進一步的調整" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/84.wav", + "text": "這個計畫恐怕已經不符合實際的需求" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/85.wav", + "text": "我們希望能在第1條第3項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/86.wav", + "text": "增加我剛剛講的條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/87.wav", + "text": "這樣才能讓我們基層員警的防護配備" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/88.wav", + "text": "以上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/89.wav", + "text": "第4條因為就像剛剛提到的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/90.wav", + "text": "員警所面對的情境強度跟危險性的態樣不一而足" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/91.wav", + "text": "能增加一個美國法上面的原則" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/92.wav", + "text": "就是警械的使用應遵循連續性強制力原則" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/93.wav", + "text": "在法界的討論也非常多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/94.wav", + "text": "包括非致命性及致命性強制力措施等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/95.wav", + "text": "五個強制力的層級" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/96.wav", + "text": "當然如果要把它規定得很細緻恐怕也很困難" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/97.wav", + "text": "但是美國法上面所做的努力就是儘" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/98.wav", + "text": "儘可能的再把它細緻化" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/99.wav", + "text": "針對他們現場所面臨情境的判斷" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/100.wav", + "text": "採取一個最妥適的強制力層級" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/101.wav", + "text": "同時也兼顧到治安的維護與人民安全的比例原則" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/102.wav", + "text": "所���我們希望能夠在第3項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/103.wav", + "text": "增列警械使用應遵循連續性強制力原則" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/104.wav", + "text": "以上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/105.wav", + "text": "這是有關第1條跟第4條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/106.wav", + "text": "主席我覺得這個法案已經拖很久了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/107.wav", + "text": "我們應該要趕快處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/108.wav", + "text": "而不要在這裡浪費時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/109.wav", + "text": "因此我認為是不是由院長進行協調" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/110.wav", + "text": "因為各黨團都有代表在那裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/111.wav", + "text": "不要每次社會發生什麼事情才" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/112.wav", + "text": "才說我們已經有在處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/113.wav", + "text": "了事實上這條條文已經很慢了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/114.wav", + "text": "速了因為我覺得現在大家心態都一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/115.wav", + "text": "只是時間實在拖太久了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/116.wav", + "text": "部分我特別請內政部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/117.wav", + "text": "司法院先進行協商溝通" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/118.wav", + "text": "顯然沒有做到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/119.wav", + "text": "到也因此司法院還是有不同意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/120.wav", + "text": "否則東一個西一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/121.wav", + "text": "我們最主要是要加快速度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/122.wav", + "text": "因為我們希望禮拜四可以請院長召開協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/123.wav", + "text": "不好意思" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/124.wav", + "text": "幾位的意見我都贊成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/125.wav", + "text": "對於現在的警察同仁來講也很重要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/126.wav", + "text": "謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/127.wav", + "text": "而之前的審議並不是完全沒有共識" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/128.wav", + "text": "修正現在只剩下保留的第10條之1第" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/129.wav", + "text": "十一條之1這些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/130.wav", + "text": "納入社會上對此的需求也滿高的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/131.wav", + "text": "我們希望能加速審議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/132.wav", + "text": "然是禮拜四所以你們要加速進行整合" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/133.wav", + "text": "我再跟警政署討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/134.wav", + "text": "今天明天就馬上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/135.wav", + "text": "那就禮拜四院長協商時再來處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/136.wav", + "text": "像時代力量今天的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/137.wav", + "text": "我是考量到警察同仁" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/138.wav", + "text": "已經習慣那條條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/139.wav", + "text": "一旦把它刪除" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/140.wav", + "text": "改成第幾項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/141.wav", + "text": "刪除再把其他很重要的條文移到別的地方" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/142.wav", + "text": "這樣一來老師要重新" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/143.wav", + "text": "他會以為第3條不見了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/144.wav", + "text": "我只是建議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/145.wav", + "text": "這是我的建議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/146.wav", + "text": "真的把一條條文刪除" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/147.wav", + "text": "對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/148.wav", + "text": "這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/149.wav", + "text": "內政部跟" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/150.wav", + "text": "警政署與" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/151.wav", + "text": "刑事警察局" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/152.wav", + "text": "還有司法院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/153.wav", + "text": "所以這部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/154.wav", + "text": "院長有確定星期四嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/155.wav", + "text": "30日禮拜幾" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/156.wav", + "text": "禮拜五" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/157.wav", + "text": "禮拜五要上院會了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/158.wav", + "text": "禮拜四要協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/159.wav", + "text": "禮拜五下午" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/160.wav", + "text": "禮拜五上午還有院會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/161.wav", + "text": "他們說直接送交院長協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/162.wav", + "text": "因為一開始會卡關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/163.wav", + "text": "我先向各位說明一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/164.wav", + "text": "現在修正動議撤了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/165.wav", + "text": "今天協商條文的第" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/166.wav", + "text": "等16人提案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/167.wav", + "text": "要先謝謝各位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/168.wav", + "text": "絕大多數的人都" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/169.wav", + "text": "把第10條之1改為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/170.wav", + "text": "改為設置調查小組" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/171.wav", + "text": "審議委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/172.wav", + "text": "會拘束到司法院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/173.wav", + "text": "本人─就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/174.wav", + "text": "以前的葉毓蘭─現在的游毓蘭" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/175.wav", + "text": "鑑定小組" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/176.wav", + "text": "魯明哲委員是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/177.wav", + "text": "鑑定委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/178.wav", + "text": "蔣萬安委員是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/179.wav", + "text": "鑑定審議小組" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/180.wav", + "text": "民眾黨黨團是調查委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/181.wav", + "text": "行政院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/182.wav", + "text": "版本王美惠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/183.wav", + "text": "謝衣鳯管碧玲" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/184.wav", + "text": "黃世杰賴惠員等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/185.wav", + "text": "都是調查小組" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/186.wav", + "text": "張宏陸委員是審查委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/187.wav", + "text": "\n我想說明一點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/188.wav", + "text": "一點司法院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/189.wav", + "text": "有關單位代表及" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/190.wav", + "text": "學者專家設火災" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/191.wav", + "text": "調查鑑定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/192.wav", + "text": "火災原因" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/193.wav", + "text": "醫療法第98條第1項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/194.wav", + "text": "中央主管機關應設置" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/195.wav", + "text": "醫事審議委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/196.wav", + "text": "司法及檢察機關之委託鑑定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/197.wav", + "text": "公路法第67條第1項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/198.wav", + "text": "車輛刑事" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/199.wav", + "text": "行車事故" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/200.wav", + "text": "鑑定及" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/201.wav", + "text": "覆議事項由交通部指定之" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/202.wav", + "text": "所屬機關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/203.wav", + "text": "辦理可見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/204.wav", + "text": "不管是消防法醫療法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/205.wav", + "text": "公路法都有授權" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/206.wav", + "text": "\n內政部一再強調要尊重" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/207.wav", + "text": "司法獨立審判" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/208.wav", + "text": "精神故建議使用調查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/209.wav", + "text": "小組" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/210.wav", + "text": "但從刑事訴訟法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/211.wav", + "text": "主管機關及剛剛我唸給各位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/212.wav", + "text": "書面報告並沒有就" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/213.wav", + "text": "鑑定小組或者魯" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/214.wav", + "text": "魯委員所提的鑑定委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/215.wav", + "text": "表達過任何反對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/216.wav", + "text": "的看法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/217.wav", + "text": "至於後續" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/218.wav", + "text": "出具的鑑定報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/219.wav", + "text": "法院要認定為鑑定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/220.wav", + "text": "意見還是調查報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/221.wav", + "text": "究竟在證據法上的性質" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/222.wav", + "text": "是如何司法院的代表在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/223.wav", + "text": "委員會審查的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/224.wav", + "text": "曾經提到可能" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/225.wav", + "text": "有部分是鑑定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/226.wav", + "text": "但也有可能是文書" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/227.wav", + "text": "證據因為它本質上比較" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/228.wav", + "text": "像是鑑定這個時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/229.wav", + "text": "就必須要由法院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/230.wav", + "text": "或檢察官來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/231.wav", + "text": "囑託鑑定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/232.wav", + "text": "比較符合客觀" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/233.wav", + "text": "公正性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/234.wav", + "text": "\n本席原來的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/235.wav", + "text": "得依職權其實司法機關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/236.wav", + "text": "還是可以得依職權" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/237.wav", + "text": "調查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/238.wav", + "text": "就是委託這個鑑定小組" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/239.wav", + "text": "我知道依照現在行政院組織法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/240.wav", + "text": "內政部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/241.wav", + "text": "是法律專業絕對沒有他所顧慮" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/242.wav", + "text": "我們可能會侵害司法獨立審判" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/243.wav", + "text": "要成立鑑定小組" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/244.wav", + "text": "以專業客觀的立場來審視" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/245.wav", + "text": "協助司法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/246.wav", + "text": "偵審機關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/247.wav", + "text": "釐清真相就警械" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/248.wav", + "text": "使用的時機過程" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/249.wav", + "text": "及相關責任進行鑑定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/250.wav", + "text": "並作出公正合理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/251.wav", + "text": "的判斷提供" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/252.wav", + "text": "專業的鑑定意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/253.wav", + "text": "供司法機關參採" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/254.wav", + "text": "所以鑑定小組" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/255.wav", + "text": "出具的鑑定結果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/256.wav", + "text": "不是更符合專家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/257.wav", + "text": "鑑定的精神嗎\n" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/258.wav", + "text": "而且以我們的國情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/259.wav", + "text": "來說開槍本來就是一件" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/260.wav", + "text": "我看到了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/261.wav", + "text": "說實在的我看到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/262.wav", + "text": "的檢察主管機關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/263.wav", + "text": "不是什麼專業" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/264.wav", + "text": "說實在的字字句句" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/265.wav", + "text": "都" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/266.wav", + "text": "讓我們第一線" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/267.wav", + "text": "的同仁心裡在淌血" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/268.wav", + "text": "大家以為高中時" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/269.wav", + "text": "打過靶就代表有開槍" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/270.wav", + "text": "的專業能力嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/271.wav", + "text": "警察執法時用槍" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/272.wav", + "text": "要考慮很多的因素" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/273.wav", + "text": "所以一定要由專家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/274.wav", + "text": "本席的原始提案是一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/275.wav", + "text": "常設的鑑定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/276.wav", + "text": "小組這有點像" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/277.wav", + "text": "我們最熟悉的在推動" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/278.wav", + "text": "性平的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/279.wav", + "text": "我們會設性騷擾" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/280.wav", + "text": "防治委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/281.wav", + "text": "性侵害防治委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/282.wav", + "text": "至於會不會每個案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/283.wav", + "text": "子都成立" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/284.wav", + "text": "其實都還要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/285.wav", + "text": "依個案來審理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/286.wav", + "text": "所以我覺得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/287.wav", + "text": "這個鑑定小組" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/288.wav", + "text": "的成立可以從" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/289.wav", + "text": "一個警察的執法角度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/290.wav", + "text": "出發對於警械" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/291.wav", + "text": "的使用時機整個過程" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/292.wav", + "text": "以及責任來加以釐清" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/293.wav", + "text": "並不是只要會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/294.wav", + "text": "扣扳機就代表會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/295.wav", + "text": "使用警槍" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/296.wav", + "text": "開一槍就好了為什麼要開四槍" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/297.wav", + "text": "連警槍最基本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/298.wav", + "text": "的構造都搞不清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/299.wav", + "text": "剛剛本席請各位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/300.wav", + "text": "第10條之1我的建議是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/301.wav", + "text": "如果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/302.wav", + "text": "內政部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/303.wav", + "text": "修法比較" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/304.wav", + "text": "就是直接刪除內政部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/305.wav", + "text": "為鑑定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/306.wav", + "text": "這六個字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/307.wav", + "text": "比較容易說服大家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/308.wav", + "text": "因為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/309.wav", + "text": "警察依職權調查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/310.wav", + "text": "就定位為調查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/311.wav", + "text": "司法機關之" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/312.wav", + "text": "委託就定位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/313.wav", + "text": "為鑑定也就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/314.wav", + "text": "剛剛本席所講的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/315.wav", + "text": "現在各縣市政府" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/316.wav", + "text": "直轄市政府都有設置" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/317.wav", + "text": "這是應設置" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/318.wav", + "text": "不管是家暴委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/319.wav", + "text": "性侵害防治委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/320.wav", + "text": "或者稱為小組都可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/321.wav", + "text": "這邊要成立的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/322.wav", + "text": "專業" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/323.wav", + "text": "調查資料庫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/324.wav", + "text": "一個非常重要的單位所以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/325.wav", + "text": "我的建議是在這邊成立一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/326.wav", + "text": "鑑定小組它是常設的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/327.wav", + "text": "組織但是在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/328.wav", + "text": "有必要的時候司法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/329.wav", + "text": "機關仍然可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/330.wav", + "text": "委託" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/331.wav", + "text": "當他們認為有需要鑑定的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/332.wav", + "text": "參考意見時他們也可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/333.wav", + "text": "接受委託以上就是我的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/334.wav", + "text": "說明\n所以本席把" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/335.wav", + "text": "在內委會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/336.wav", + "text": "審查的時���所提的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/337.wav", + "text": "然後回復到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/338.wav", + "text": "我原來提的這個提案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/339.wav", + "text": "但是也針對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/340.wav", + "text": "上次在內委會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/341.wav", + "text": "審查的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/342.wav", + "text": "大家所爭執的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/343.wav", + "text": "我建議把我的條文內容" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/344.wav", + "text": "所以整個條文會變成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/345.wav", + "text": "警察人員執行職務時" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/346.wav", + "text": "使用警械" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/347.wav", + "text": "致人重傷" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/348.wav", + "text": "死亡之爭議案件" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/349.wav", + "text": "應設" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/350.wav", + "text": "警械使用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/351.wav", + "text": "鑑定小組" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/352.wav", + "text": "（以下稱本小組" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/353.wav", + "text": "）本小組得依職權" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/354.wav", + "text": "或應" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/355.wav", + "text": "檢察機關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/356.wav", + "text": "或司法機關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/357.wav", + "text": "之委託調查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/358.wav", + "text": "我們這個條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/359.wav", + "text": "所應該要有的一些合法權益" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/360.wav", + "text": "謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/361.wav", + "text": "主席" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/362.wav", + "text": "對於剛才" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/363.wav", + "text": "大家所說的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/364.wav", + "text": "承辦單位去溝通" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/365.wav", + "text": "也是跟以前一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/366.wav", + "text": "這幾天請他們先私下去做溝通" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/367.wav", + "text": "請主席裁決一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/368.wav", + "text": "因為剛剛游委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/369.wav", + "text": "有點名" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/370.wav", + "text": "所以我還是要回應一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/371.wav", + "text": "還是調查委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/372.wav", + "text": "還是又要變成鑑定小組" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/373.wav", + "text": "我覺得可以討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/374.wav", + "text": "你們還是利用這一兩天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/375.wav", + "text": "的時間好好地去溝通協調" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/376.wav", + "text": "我要說明的是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/377.wav", + "text": "無論有沒有把" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/378.wav", + "text": "檢察司法機關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/379.wav", + "text": "得囑託鑑定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/380.wav", + "text": "寫上去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/381.wav", + "text": "它都可以被" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/382.wav", + "text": "囑託鑑定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/383.wav", + "text": "游委員這個我們不要黑白講啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/384.wav", + "text": "不要講說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/385.wav", + "text": "沒有寫就沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/386.wav", + "text": "這個權力或什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/387.wav", + "text": "所以這個是一定要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/388.wav", + "text": "沒有啦就是對照起來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/389.wav", + "text": "好像指名道姓起來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/390.wav", + "text": "好像就是說沒有寫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/391.wav", + "text": "因為您在上一次直接就" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/392.wav", + "text": "指明說我們這樣是在拘束" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/393.wav", + "text": "司法審判" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/394.wav", + "text": "警察同仁" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/395.wav", + "text": "他們的用槍案件被那些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/396.wav", + "text": "法官" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/397.wav", + "text": "天龍國的法官" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/398.wav", + "text": "象牙塔裡面的法官怎麼樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/399.wav", + "text": "我們都願意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/400.wav", + "text": "讓警察專業的結論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/401.wav", + "text": "更能夠讓" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/402.wav", + "text": "司法跟檢調機關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/403.wav", + "text": "來採納" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/404.wav", + "text": "因為他們最瞭解自己的專業" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/405.wav", + "text": "所以有沒有寫進來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/406.wav", + "text": "都得被囑託" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/407.wav", + "text": "這是第一件事" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/408.wav", + "text": "第二件事如果我們要像" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/409.wav", + "text": "醫審會那樣的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/410.wav", + "text": "醫審會在醫療法裡面的規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/411.wav", + "text": "文我們這個也會變成說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/412.wav", + "text": "光是游委員講的那個條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/413.wav", + "text": "也變成有所不足" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/414.wav", + "text": "在他們的三個條文裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/415.wav", + "text": "如果我們要明定它是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/416.wav", + "text": "有鑑定效果的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/417.wav", + "text": "像醫審會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/418.wav", + "text": "就規定社會人士" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/419.wav", + "text": "法學專家不得少於" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/420.wav", + "text": "三分之一" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/421.wav", + "text": "來確保它的專業" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/422.wav", + "text": "跟公信力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/423.wav", + "text": "嘛所以如果我們要朝那個方向" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/424.wav", + "text": "去擬定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/425.wav", + "text": "那麼游委員講的條文也是不夠的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/426.wav", + "text": "\n所以我的意思是說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/427.wav", + "text": "你們好好地利用這一兩天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/428.wav", + "text": "的時間去溝通協調" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/429.wav", + "text": "警械使用條例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/430.wav", + "text": "修訂通過以後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/431.wav", + "text": "警界同仁基於錯誤的認知" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/432.wav", + "text": "又是只有怨言" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/433.wav", + "text": "我不願意看到這種結果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/434.wav", + "text": "所以我們在這裡的討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/435.wav", + "text": "不要有什麼指控" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/436.wav", + "text": "對照" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/437.wav", + "text": "怎樣才叫做比較保障" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/438.wav", + "text": "怎樣就不夠保障" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/439.wav", + "text": "我覺得我們不要那樣去談" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/440.wav", + "text": "大家最後最有共識" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/441.wav", + "text": "最符合我們的立法目的要旨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/442.wav", + "text": "而且" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/443.wav", + "text": "也能夠更確保我們的設計" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/444.wav", + "text": "最後真的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/445.wav", + "text": "能夠達到我們想要的效果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/446.wav", + "text": "朝向那裡好好地去協調" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/447.wav", + "text": "好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/448.wav", + "text": "主席我補充一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/449.wav", + "text": "這一條在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/450.wav", + "text": "這次修法裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/451.wav", + "text": "算是一個關鍵點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/452.wav", + "text": "包括王美惠委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/453.wav", + "text": "包括在場許多黨團" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/454.wav", + "text": "委員都有提出相應的版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/455.wav", + "text": "我一直在想" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/456.wav", + "text": "其實我們的版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/457.wav", + "text": "相關機關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/458.wav", + "text": "專家學者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/459.wav", + "text": "大概是這兩塊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/460.wav", + "text": "啦\n其實我們都知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/461.wav", + "text": "臺灣在這方面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/462.wav", + "text": "能夠有足夠能力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/463.wav", + "text": "鑑定的人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/464.wav", + "text": "其實是屈指可數" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/465.wav", + "text": "其實相關的專家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/466.wav", + "text": "像是警大的孟憲輝教授" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/467.wav", + "text": "李俊億教授等等之類的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/468.wav", + "text": "但是我覺得這個委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/469.wav", + "text": "剛剛管委員有提到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/470.wav", + "text": "或者是說是不是要具備像" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/471.wav", + "text": "醫審會那樣的功能" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/472.wav", + "text": "我覺得這裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/473.wav", + "text": "會有一個意義" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/474.wav", + "text": "啦我自己覺得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/475.wav", + "text": "它的主要意義是在於說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/476.wav", + "text": "當我們沒有這個東西的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/477.wav", + "text": "現在警械使用導致人們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/478.wav", + "text": "重傷失能死亡事件" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/479.wav", + "text": "到法院去的時" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/480.wav", + "text": "但是問題在於" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/481.wav", + "text": "有可能只能" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/482.wav", + "text": "囑託一位專家跟他的團隊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/483.wav", + "text": "因為臺灣的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/484.wav", + "text": "這些專家就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/485.wav", + "text": "這麼地屈指可數" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/486.wav", + "text": "我覺得成立一個委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/487.wav", + "text": "比較有意義是在於說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/488.wav", + "text": "沒有這個委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/489.wav", + "text": "還是可以囑託鑑定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/490.wav", + "text": "還是可以解決" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/491.wav", + "text": "但成立這個委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/492.wav", + "text": "我覺得比較大的意義是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/493.wav", + "text": "能夠讓這些基層警察代表" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/494.wav", + "text": "其他的聲音也可以進到這個委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/495.wav", + "text": "裡面來表達" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/496.wav", + "text": "一組人在做鑑定的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/497.wav", + "text": "這些相關基層警察團體的代表" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/498.wav", + "text": "進來組成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/499.wav", + "text": "可能在這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/500.wav", + "text": "層面上會比較有意義" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/501.wav", + "text": "所以我們的版本比較像是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/502.wav", + "text": "參考消防法第27條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/503.wav", + "text": "災害事故調查會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/504.wav", + "text": "這個在消防法裡面也有規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/505.wav", + "text": "\n第二個就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/506.wav", + "text": "委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/507.wav", + "text": "比較重要的是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/508.wav", + "text": "因為關於鑑定這個部分我說過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/509.wav", + "text": "這一點部長非常清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/510.wav", + "text": "嘛這種案件還是會處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/511.wav", + "text": "但是在這個委員會裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/512.wav", + "text": "可以就這些警械" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/513.wav", + "text": "械使用的合理性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/514.wav", + "text": "警察人員勤務的管理等等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/515.wav", + "text": "不是只有這個個案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/516.wav", + "text": "就是我剛剛提到的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/517.wav", + "text": "因為看到嘉義的這個例子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/518.wav", + "text": "我們希望警察的裝備" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/519.wav", + "text": "能夠充足" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/520.wav", + "text": "並且提出" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/521.wav", + "text": "改善的建議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/522.wav", + "text": "我覺得這是重點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/523.wav", + "text": "不管是嘉義或是臺南的員警" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/524.wav", + "text": "能夠在這個委員會裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/525.wav", + "text": "提出具體的改善建議事項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/526.wav", + "text": "不要讓下一次的傷痛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/527.wav", + "text": "又在其他人身上發生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/528.wav", + "text": "我覺得在這樣的層面上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/529.wav", + "text": "有一個委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/530.wav", + "text": "會比過去沒有一個委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/531.wav", + "text": "即便這些案件也在法院裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/532.wav", + "text": "囑託國內的槍枝專家鑑定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/533.wav", + "text": "相較來講會比較好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/534.wav", + "text": "主席" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/535.wav", + "text": "讓我發言一下好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/536.wav", + "text": "謝謝主席" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/537.wav", + "text": "對於臺南這一次的殺警案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/538.wav", + "text": "我們都感到相當的遺憾" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/539.wav", + "text": "也很難過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/540.wav", + "text": "列席來跟大家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/541.wav", + "text": "最後這個逃犯" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/542.wav", + "text": "甚至還竄逃到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/543.wav", + "text": "我的選區裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/544.wav", + "text": "其實當初在那幾天的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/545.wav", + "text": "整個臺南市警察局" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/546.wav", + "text": "是非常非常地緊張" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/547.wav", + "text": "我本人的一個建議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/548.wav", + "text": "無論是調查小組" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/549.wav", + "text": "還是其他的成員小組" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/550.wav", + "text": "新單位可不可能" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/551.wav", + "text": "常態性地蒐集" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/552.wav", + "text": "然後分析員警被" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/553.wav", + "text": "在這裡也要特別特別" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/554.wav", + "text": "所有的單位不管是內政部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/555.wav", + "text": "我們的警專自" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/556.wav", + "text": "2017年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/557.wav", + "text": "起已連續3年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/558.wav", + "text": "情境模擬雷射射擊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/559.wav", + "text": "射擊訓練場" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/560.wav", + "text": "很可惜這3年都沒有獲准都" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/561.wav", + "text": "爭取到這個預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/562.wav", + "text": "這個也是要特別跟部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/563.wav", + "text": "及署長做一個提醒" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/564.wav", + "text": "案發生的那幾天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/565.wav", + "text": "我要謝謝部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/566.wav", + "text": "也特別喊話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/567.wav", + "text": "要大膽地用槍" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/568.wav", + "text": "其實這個都是鼓舞士氣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/569.wav", + "text": "主張的就是臺灣警察" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/570.wav", + "text": "其實是武力的分級" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/571.wav", + "text": "當然這會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/572.wav", + "text": "涉及到法律規範的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/573.wav", + "text": "我們的修法到現在已經是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/574.wav", + "text": "17年了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/575.wav", + "text": "我想很多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/576.wav", + "text": "都非常的焦慮" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/577.wav", + "text": "就是在我的選區裡頭" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/578.wav", + "text": "所以我們接觸到很多的警眷也知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/579.wav", + "text": "跟擔心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/580.wav", + "text": "個主張\n我想審" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/581.wav", + "text": "審慎的研議當然就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/582.wav", + "text": "這次我們修法時大家共同的一個態度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/583.wav", + "text": "相對的就是有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/584.wav", + "text": "已經執行30年了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/585.wav", + "text": "為什麼我們到現在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/586.wav", + "text": "分得那麼清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/587.wav", + "text": "到底是要用警棍" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/588.wav", + "text": "危急自己生命安全的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/589.wav", + "text": "狀態之下腦筋還要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/590.wav", + "text": "再轉一下這部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/591.wav", + "text": "我覺得我們是非常" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/592.wav", + "text": "失職的所以在這裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/593.wav", + "text": "我們好好的把這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/594.wav", + "text": "法來修好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/595.wav", + "text": "謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/596.wav", + "text": "事實上我們的條文都" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/597.wav", + "text": "跟政黨無關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/598.wav", + "text": "各位委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/599.wav", + "text": "內政部今天有提" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/600.wav", + "text": "出他們的意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/601.wav", + "text": "很詳細" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/602.wav", + "text": "對於第10條之1" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/603.wav", + "text": "也有一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/604.wav", + "text": "建議條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/605.wav", + "text": "如果大家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/606.wav", + "text": "除了內政部主動之外" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/607.wav", + "text": "去提供建議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/608.wav", + "text": "讓他們再做整理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/609.wav", + "text": "因為時間很短希望大家能夠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/610.wav", + "text": "就請內政部及" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/611.wav", + "text": "警政署" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/612.wav", + "text": "基本上內政部已經有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/613.wav", + "text": "針對司法院的意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/614.wav", + "text": "給予尊重" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/615.wav", + "text": "本來就可以去委託" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/616.wav", + "text": "了本來就有這樣的一個機制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/617.wav", + "text": "在那邊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/618.wav", + "text": "所以我們就不要那麼堅持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/619.wav", + "text": "我是建議啦當然這部分還是要溝通" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/620.wav", + "text": "\n我們就" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/621.wav", + "text": "來主持朝野" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/622.wav", + "text": "朝野協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14432/623.wav", + "text": "就這樣處理好謝謝大家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/0.wav", + "text": "首先介紹數位發展部部長唐鳳先生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/1.wav", + "text": "的因為數位發展部的成立對國人來講有非常大的期待" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/2.wav", + "text": "尤其在整個疫情後的時代不管是產業的發展資安的保護" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/3.wav", + "text": "還是整體國民生活型態的改變其實它都是至關重要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/4.wav", + "text": "既然是一個新的部會我想很多事情必須要把它釐清" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/5.wav", + "text": "也擔負很多必須要做的政策溝通責任及工作" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/6.wav", + "text": "我想很多民眾對這部分還需要更深一步的瞭解" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/7.wav", + "text": "至於數位發展部組織法草案在委員會審議的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/8.wav", + "text": "當時是透過交通委員會跟司法及法制委員會聯席" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/9.wav", + "text": "委員會但是我們看到現在數位發展部的權責目標" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/10.wav", + "text": "其實我們認為是經濟委員會現在大概有三個說法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/11.wav", + "text": "第一是交通委員會第二是經濟委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/12.wav", + "text": "我也有聽說唐鳳部長希望在教育及文化委員會延續之前科技部的脈絡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/13.wav", + "text": "第一個是負責數位經濟相關產業的發展跟資通安全" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/14.wav", + "text": "我們知道經濟的發展是至關重要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/15.wav", + "text": "相關資通安全的部分其實不只是我們人民的資通安全" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/16.wav", + "text": "數發部成立以後移轉的業務跟預算主要是與通傳會跟交通部有高度重疊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/17.wav", + "text": "依數位發展部組織法第2條的內容" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/18.wav", + "text": "掌管業務主要由通傳會交通部郵電司的業務來移撥" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/19.wav", + "text": "移撥人員也與此兩部會高度相關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/20.wav", + "text": "在預算方面除了公務預算也會用前瞻基礎第四期的特別預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/21.wav", + "text": "基於國會監督的角色主要業務" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/22.wav", + "text": "跟交通委員會相關的部分是我們剛剛提到的兩點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/23.wav", + "text": "但是根據數發部近期公布的施政重點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/24.wav", + "text": "主要還是推動我國數位政策的創新與變革" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/25.wav", + "text": "相對來講還要整合整個電信資訊資安網路跟傳播五大領域" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/26.wav", + "text": "以加速產業數位創新與轉型帶動數位相關的產業發展" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/27.wav", + "text": "這是最終目標" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/28.wav", + "text": "應該要很清楚地向國人說明短中長期目標" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/29.wav", + "text": "第一階段是不是以產業發展的協助跟轉型為主" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/30.wav", + "text": "第二階段是提升相關的數位公民意識及民主韌性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/31.wav", + "text": "2個署這部分應該要講清楚說明白" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/32.wav", + "text": "\n我這邊也幫大家整理一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/33.wav", + "text": "這是數發部目前的組織架構" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/34.wav", + "text": "目前這個部分的工作規劃" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/35.wav", + "text": "兩個署的部分則分別隸屬數位產業署及資通安全署" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/36.wav", + "text": "署一個是針對產業發展" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/37.wav", + "text": "另一個是針對資通安全" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/38.wav", + "text": "撥一部分業務" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/39.wav", + "text": "而資通安全署的業務則是從交通部移撥" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/40.wav", + "text": "在增設數位發展部轄下有幾個重點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/41.wav", + "text": "尤其是部會移轉業務的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/42.wav", + "text": "包含交通部的通訊整體資源規劃" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/43.wav", + "text": "而在後面主要的發展目標" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/44.wav", + "text": "再來就是整個納入國發會所提出的智慧政府及開放資料" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/45.wav", + "text": "其擴增業務不管是在數位轉型數位法制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/46.wav", + "text": "資料治理人才培育及監理沙盒等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/47.wav", + "text": "這些都是經濟委員會監管的業務" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/48.wav", + "text": "而通傳會其實也僅僅移轉通訊傳播基礎建設" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/49.wav", + "text": "及電信產業發展與輔導" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/50.wav", + "text": "這是我們比較有疑問的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/51.wav", + "text": "所以如果從這點及數發部目前提出的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/52.wav", + "text": "組織改造變革與相關業務發展方向來看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/53.wav", + "text": "我們認為經濟發展" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/54.wav", + "text": "還有產業協助轉型是目前的主要業務" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/55.wav", + "text": "也應該是初期的重點工作" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/56.wav", + "text": "因為產業的厚實及基礎建設的提升" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/57.wav", + "text": "會有利於後面相關數位建設的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/58.wav", + "text": "以及資通安全的強化" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/59.wav", + "text": "我覺得這是息息相關的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/60.wav", + "text": "當然數位公民意識的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/61.wav", + "text": "我們認為數位發展部在立法院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/62.wav", + "text": "應該歸屬於經濟委員會來監督審查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/63.wav", + "text": "以上是我們的發言謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/64.wav", + "text": "好謝謝邱總召" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/65.wav", + "text": "接下來哪一位要發表高見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/66.wav", + "text": "台灣民眾黨主張要在經濟委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/67.wav", + "text": "有沒有不同意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/68.wav", + "text": "數位發展部的業務報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/69.wav", + "text": "及未來的預算審查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/70.wav", + "text": "比較適當" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/71.wav", + "text": "負責所以在本屆第3第4會期" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/72.wav", + "text": "就是交由司法及法制聯席交通委員會排審" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/73.wav", + "text": "也就是司法委員會聯席交通委員會審查完竣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/74.wav", + "text": "內容雖然增加了數位產業署" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/75.wav", + "text": "但是大家當時對於數位發展部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/76.wav", + "text": "交由交通委員會審查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/77.wav", + "text": "其實好像已經有共識了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/78.wav", + "text": "第二個理由就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/79.wav", + "text": "移撥單位包括附屬單位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/80.wav", + "text": "原本就多是由交通委員會來負責" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/81.wav", + "text": "再來數位發展部組織法第9條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/82.wav", + "text": "國家通訊傳播委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/83.wav", + "text": "及其他機關之現職人員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/84.wav", + "text": "隨業務移撥至數位發展部及所屬機關時其" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/85.wav", + "text": "其官等職等服務年資待遇退休資遣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/86.wav", + "text": "資遣撫恤其他福利及工作條件" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/87.wav", + "text": "等均有保障" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/88.wav", + "text": "另外移撥到數位發展部的單位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/89.wav", + "text": "原本主要也是交通委員會負責的單位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/90.wav", + "text": "而且附屬單位如電信技術中心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/91.wav", + "text": "也是移撥到數位發展部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/92.wav", + "text": "這些附屬單位的預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/93.wav", + "text": "過去都是由交通委員會負責處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/94.wav", + "text": "因此時代力量認為數位發展部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/95.wav", + "text": "應該維持由交通委員會來負責審查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/96.wav", + "text": "\n第三個主要的理由" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/97.wav", + "text": "就是現在中央政府總預算的負責單位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/98.wav", + "text": "包括交通部NCC公共工程委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/99.wav", + "text": "等3個單位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/100.wav", + "text": "經濟委員會目前已經有經濟部農委會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/101.wav", + "text": "國發會及公平會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/102.wav", + "text": "而教文更多了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/103.wav", + "text": "現在有教育部文化部國科會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/104.wav", + "text": "故宮原能會及中研院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/105.wav", + "text": "已經有6個單位了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/106.wav", + "text": "所以將數位發展部交由交通委員會負責審查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/107.wav", + "text": "在委員會的政府單位分工平衡上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/108.wav", + "text": "應該也是比較合理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/109.wav", + "text": "的我首先的發言是針對這個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/110.wav", + "text": "時代力量還是認為由交通委員會來負責審查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/111.wav", + "text": "比較適合" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/112.wav", + "text": "以上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/113.wav", + "text": "隸屬哪一個委員會利弊的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/114.wav", + "text": "我是比較贊成放在經濟委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/115.wav", + "text": "因為不諱言" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/116.wav", + "text": "數位發展部未來的一些業務內容" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/117.wav", + "text": "當然跟產業的發展" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/118.wav", + "text": "尤其是數位產業的發展" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/119.wav", + "text": "跟現在大家很重視的資通安全的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/120.wav", + "text": "在某種程度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/121.wav", + "text": "上大家還是認為產業發展的這一塊是屬於比較攻的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/122.wav", + "text": "我所謂的攻是攻擊的攻" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/123.wav", + "text": "就是比較有發展潛力的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/124.wav", + "text": "至於資通安全的部分是屬於比較守的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/125.wav", + "text": "所以接下來我們當然希望數位發展部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/126.wav", + "text": "對於國內數位產業發展" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/127.wav", + "text": "的部分能夠讓國內的經濟發展跟建設" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/128.wav", + "text": "有更多可以協助跟規劃的方向" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/129.wav", + "text": "所以在這個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/130.wav", + "text": "比起所謂守的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/131.wav", + "text": "就是資通安全的這個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/132.wav", + "text": "是不是首選應該還是放在經濟委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/133.wav", + "text": "畢竟在這個部分裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/134.wav", + "text": "大家對於唐鳳部長也罷" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/135.wav", + "text": "或者數位發展部在未來國內" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/136.wav", + "text": "相關的整個數位產業的整合跟前景" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/137.wav", + "text": "大家還是有很多的期許" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/138.wav", + "text": "應該是以經濟委員會為主" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/139.wav", + "text": "謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/140.wav", + "text": "院長各位委員同仁" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/141.wav", + "text": "在哪一個委員會審查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/142.wav", + "text": "事實上每一位立法委員都可以去審查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/143.wav", + "text": "這不是委員會要去增加它的影響力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/144.wav", + "text": "當我們大家有這個正確觀念的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/145.wav", + "text": "這個議題是毫無政治衝突的議題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/146.wav", + "text": "我首先闡明這個質疑\n" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/147.wav", + "text": "數發部在審查的時候當然" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/148.wav", + "text": "所有的組織法都是由司法委員會主審" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/149.wav", + "text": "然後和交通委員會一起聯席審查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/150.wav", + "text": "剛剛談到有關數位產業署的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/151.wav", + "text": "本來送來的法案沒有這個署" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/152.wav", + "text": "一部一署而已" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/153.wav", + "text": "是後來劉世芳委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/154.wav", + "text": "以及本黨一些委員我們大家硬加上去的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/155.wav", + "text": "的後來是由我去協商的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/156.wav", + "text": "我認為再加這個署" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/157.wav", + "text": "大家說數位產業發展很重要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/158.wav", + "text": "要去反對也很困難" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/159.wav", + "text": "硬要加就加" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/160.wav", + "text": "所以院會就通過了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/161.wav", + "text": "所以它的職掌裡面就限縮" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/162.wav", + "text": "在輔導以及獎勵而已" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/163.wav", + "text": "就是對於數位產業" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/164.wav", + "text": "關於產業的輔導及獎勵" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/165.wav", + "text": "5G產業人工智慧等什麼都和經濟有關係" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/166.wav", + "text": "總體來講這是政事別的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/167.wav", + "text": "而當我們要講機關別的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/168.wav", + "text": "它當然要有主體隸屬關係" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/169.wav", + "text": "那時候如果有這樣的考量" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/170.wav", + "text": "將來在資通安全上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/171.wav", + "text": "和數發部一些比較有關聯性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/172.wav", + "text": "的部分所以才這樣處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/173.wav", + "text": "不必很堅持要在哪一個委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/174.wav", + "text": "我們都很瞭解大家都很關心產業發展" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/175.wav", + "text": "每個委員都可以到任何一個委員會去質詢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/176.wav", + "text": "預算最後還是要回到朝野協商來處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/177.wav", + "text": "數發部的預算不到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/178.wav", + "text": "中央政府總預算的1%而已" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/179.wav", + "text": "我在經濟委員會你就來經濟委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/180.wav", + "text": "不要這種觀念啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/181.wav", + "text": "你也可以到交通委員會去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/182.wav", + "text": "我們不要說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/183.wav", + "text": "我在這裡你就來我這裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/184.wav", + "text": "不好意思院長補充一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/185.wav", + "text": "我沒有在經濟委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/186.wav", + "text": "喔我現在在國防外交" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/187.wav", + "text": "不要這樣戴帽子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/188.wav", + "text": "我們今天也不是說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/189.wav", + "text": "在哪一個委員會就要爭取在哪一個委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/190.wav", + "text": "這個議題現在大家突然注意起來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/191.wav", + "text": "甚至我們第一次朝野協商的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/192.wav", + "text": "邱臣遠委員說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/193.wav", + "text": "這個要專案報告我們都反對嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/194.wav", + "text": "組織法已經在立法院搞了十幾年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/195.wav", + "text": "從來沒有一個單一組織法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/196.wav", + "text": "由行政院長來做專案報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/197.wav", + "text": "它是整個國家的整個組織法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/198.wav", + "text": "要怎麼弄" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/199.wav", + "text": "都是尊重委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/200.wav", + "text": "提出來以後一起去審查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/201.wav", + "text": "從馬英九時期搞到現在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/202.wav", + "text": "我們還有好幾個子法沒有完成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/203.wav", + "text": "因為前一陣子引發一些議題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/204.wav", + "text": "大家比較關心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/205.wav", + "text": "注就來要專案報告或是在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/206.wav", + "text": "要大家來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/207.wav", + "text": "多做攻防" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/208.wav", + "text": "坦白講沒有什麼實益" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/209.wav", + "text": "益大家冷靜來看待就好了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/210.wav", + "text": "啦\n這樣的情形底下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/211.wav", + "text": "既然立法院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/212.wav", + "text": "當初就是這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/213.wav", + "text": "長期以來的觀念就是如此" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/214.wav", + "text": "法案預算就跟著" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/215.wav", + "text": "嘛法案就是司法跟交通" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/216.wav", + "text": "我們今天走一半再拖回來說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/217.wav", + "text": "變成經濟" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/218.wav", + "text": "也不必有這樣的爭議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/219.wav", + "text": "請各位委員能夠考慮一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/220.wav", + "text": "謝院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/221.wav", + "text": "數發部未來的業務內容當然很多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/222.wav", + "text": "它的法定上在組織法裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/223.wav", + "text": "列定的所謂掌理事項裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/224.wav", + "text": "數位經濟只是其中一部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/225.wav", + "text": "雖然它有所謂的數位產業署" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/226.wav", + "text": "但這十大的業務裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/227.wav", + "text": "事實上數位經濟直接相關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/228.wav", + "text": "的大概只有兩樣到三樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/229.wav", + "text": "其他就是單獨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/230.wav", + "text": "針對整個臺灣數位發展的總體規劃" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/231.wav", + "text": "\n我也呼應剛才陳椒華委員提到的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/232.wav", + "text": "在當時審組織法的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/233.wav", + "text": "就是司法搭配交通" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/234.wav", + "text": "委員會當時就是負責整個擘劃數位發展部方向" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/235.wav", + "text": "的一個很重要的委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/236.wav", + "text": "第二個就是剛才提到的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/237.wav", + "text": "在委員會的分工上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/238.wav", + "text": "我們知道委員會的角色" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/239.wav", + "text": "主要是在協助院會處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/240.wav", + "text": "交付的這些相關議案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/241.wav", + "text": "或者預算的審查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/242.wav", + "text": "最後還是要回到院會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/243.wav", + "text": "��一個分工的角度來看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/244.wav", + "text": "經濟委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/245.wav", + "text": "審理部會跟預算的規模是大很多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/246.wav", + "text": "的包括經濟部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/247.wav", + "text": "農委會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/248.wav", + "text": "但是相較之下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/249.wav", + "text": "目前的交通委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/250.wav", + "text": "就是交通部工程會跟NCC而已" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/251.wav", + "text": "所以如果為了協助" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/252.wav", + "text": "整個院會在處理預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/253.wav", + "text": "我們認為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/254.wav", + "text": "可以把數發部放在交通委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/255.wav", + "text": "也可以讓每個委員會之間的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/256.wav", + "text": "職掌跟權力稍微平衡一點點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/257.wav", + "text": "同時就協助院會處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/258.wav", + "text": "相關的工作上也會更有效率" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/259.wav", + "text": "所以我們還是認為放在交通委員會比較適當" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/260.wav", + "text": "謝謝院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/261.wav", + "text": "我這邊稍微再補充一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/262.wav", + "text": "也有把歷程講了一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/263.wav", + "text": "當然今天我們也沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/264.wav", + "text": "事今天還是歸屬委員會比較重要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/265.wav", + "text": "剛才羅委員也有再補充" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/266.wav", + "text": "坦白說數位發展部當時能設立" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/267.wav", + "text": "行政機關組織基準法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/268.wav", + "text": "14個部為什麼要設部一定有它" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/269.wav", + "text": "也未必一定要設為部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/270.wav", + "text": "而且我們也知道設數位發展部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/271.wav", + "text": "我想剛才我們民眾黨這邊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/272.wav", + "text": "邱總召已經講得很清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/273.wav", + "text": "擺在經濟委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/274.wav", + "text": "\n原因我再補充一點點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/275.wav", + "text": "設署的目的可能是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/276.wav", + "text": "專門性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/277.wav", + "text": "有決策性才會設到署" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/278.wav", + "text": "\n這是按照組織基準法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/279.wav", + "text": "本來的精神" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/280.wav", + "text": "剛才柯總召已經講了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/281.wav", + "text": "一個是資通安全" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/282.wav", + "text": "數位產業" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/283.wav", + "text": "事情當然去更專業的委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/284.wav", + "text": "是比較適合的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/285.wav", + "text": "另外在交通委員會這邊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/286.wav", + "text": "其實坊間也說過一個問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/287.wav", + "text": "事實上應該這樣說NCC" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/288.wav", + "text": "它是在監理的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/289.wav", + "text": "任務執行又混雜在一起" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/290.wav", + "text": "\n再來坦白說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/291.wav", + "text": "交通委員會可能" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/292.wav", + "text": "更著重在建設這一個層面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/293.wav", + "text": "唐部長溝通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/294.wav", + "text": "其實連部長自己都覺得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/295.wav", + "text": "在做這樣的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/296.wav", + "text": "事以專業的角度來看應該放在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/297.wav", + "text": "經濟委員會這地方是合理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/298.wav", + "text": "唐部長說屬於教育及文化委員會這個概念" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/299.wav", + "text": "混在一起我覺得反而問題會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/300.wav", + "text": "更多至少我們先表述一下立場" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/301.wav", + "text": "謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/302.wav", + "text": "我相信今天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/303.wav", + "text": "我們來到這裡就像剛才柯總召講的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/304.wav", + "text": "不是為了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/305.wav", + "text": "任何一個委員會的擴權" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/306.wav", + "text": "放在哪一個委員會讓整體" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/307.wav", + "text": "的預算可以共同來討論才是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/308.wav", + "text": "今天討論的要點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/309.wav", + "text": "所以剛才羅委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/310.wav", + "text": "經濟委員會有幾個部會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/311.wav", + "text": "交通委員會有幾個部會這樣子一" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/312.wav", + "text": "一個分類的說法我覺得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/313.wav", + "text": "對於我們整體預算的討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/314.wav", + "text": "比較沒有實質綜" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/315.wav", + "text": "\n剛才柯總召也提到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/316.wav", + "text": "為什麼我們要主張" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/317.wav", + "text": "放在經濟委員會是因為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/318.wav", + "text": "數位產業署是最後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/319.wav", + "text": "才決定的但我必須要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/320.wav", + "text": "講其實從數位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/321.wav", + "text": "發展部的組織法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/322.wav", + "text": "第1條開宗明義就" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/323.wav", + "text": "說了為了數位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/324.wav", + "text": "產業發展" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/325.wav", + "text": "的業務才來設立" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/326.wav", + "text": "數位發展部所以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/327.wav", + "text": "數位產業的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/328.wav", + "text": "發展部非常重要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/329.wav", + "text": "的條件過去唐鳳" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/330.wav", + "text": "所有資訊的透明化" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/331.wav", + "text": "我認為是一個比較" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/332.wav", + "text": "理想化的政策" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/333.wav", + "text": "但是如果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/334.wav", + "text": "要落實到實際" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/335.wav", + "text": "產業發展的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/336.wav", + "text": "我認為這是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/337.wav", + "text": "唐鳳部長你接下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/338.wav", + "text": "這個部長最重要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/339.wav", + "text": "的挑戰之一" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/340.wav", + "text": "所以我才認為依" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/341.wav", + "text": "既然是為了數位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/342.wav", + "text": "產業發展來設立這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/343.wav", + "text": "部我們就要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/344.wav", + "text": "重視產業未來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/345.wav", + "text": "整體的布" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/346.wav", + "text": "臺灣的經濟發展" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/347.wav", + "text": "以及整體的相關性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/348.wav", + "text": "關於數位發展部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/349.wav", + "text": "我們可以看到它的總" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/350.wav", + "text": "它的總預算是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/351.wav", + "text": "萬元左右但是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/352.wav", + "text": "它對於" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/353.wav", + "text": "數位產業發展跟數" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/354.wav", + "text": "位產業機構" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/355.wav", + "text": "相關的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/356.wav", + "text": "補助以及委外" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/357.wav", + "text": "的經費委辦的經費" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/358.wav", + "text": "億3,000多萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/359.wav", + "text": "整個預算的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/360.wav", + "text": "75%" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/361.wav", + "text": "的預算以及它" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/362.wav", + "text": "組織法開宗明義" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/363.wav", + "text": "講的就是為了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/364.wav", + "text": "數位產業發展" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/365.wav", + "text": "而數位產業發展" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/366.wav", + "text": "跟哪一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/367.wav", + "text": "委員會最有關係" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/368.wav", + "text": "呢就是經濟委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/369.wav", + "text": "所以絕對不是因為這是一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/370.wav", + "text": "數位產業署或是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/371.wav", + "text": "委員會審理的部會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/372.wav", + "text": "預算比較少" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/373.wav", + "text": "所以我們就應該把它歸納在哪個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/374.wav", + "text": "之我們應該看的是數位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/375.wav", + "text": "發展部對於" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/376.wav", + "text": "未來的發展以及" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/377.wav", + "text": "跟哪一個委員會比較" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/378.wav", + "text": "有相關性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/379.wav", + "text": "兩個會期經濟" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/380.wav", + "text": "委員會召委的經驗我認為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/381.wav", + "text": "一個57億元��預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/382.wav", + "text": "業務報告跟預算審查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/383.wav", + "text": "個一兩天的會議時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/384.wav", + "text": "我認為並不會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/385.wav", + "text": "影響任何一個委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/386.wav", + "text": "預算的時程或是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/387.wav", + "text": "到所有的業務審查我覺得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/388.wav", + "text": "數位發展部跟" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/389.wav", + "text": "哪一個委員會比較" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/390.wav", + "text": "予以界定我覺得這樣會比較好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/391.wav", + "text": "各位委員院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/392.wav", + "text": "部組織法第1" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/393.wav", + "text": "條就明定行政院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/394.wav", + "text": "為促進全" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/395.wav", + "text": "國通訊資訊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/396.wav", + "text": "資通安全" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/397.wav", + "text": "網路與傳播" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/398.wav", + "text": "等數位產業發展" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/399.wav", + "text": "在資通安全" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/400.wav", + "text": "委員會然後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/401.wav", + "text": "上個會期是參加" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/402.wav", + "text": "組織法的審查我是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/403.wav", + "text": "全程參與的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/404.wav", + "text": "\n再來在參與的過程" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/405.wav", + "text": "中當然" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/406.wav", + "text": "那時應該不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/407.wav", + "text": "唐鳳部長負責的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/408.wav", + "text": "安全的部分的確是我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/409.wav", + "text": "發展部最" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/410.wav", + "text": "目的本席認為資通安全" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/411.wav", + "text": "也是國家安全" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/412.wav", + "text": "我們不反對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/413.wav", + "text": "也是很重要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/414.wav", + "text": "如各位委員剛剛所說的在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/415.wav", + "text": "審查審理或是過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/416.wav", + "text": "審查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/417.wav", + "text": "預算時包括移撥單位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/418.wav", + "text": "或是著重在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/419.wav", + "text": "資通安全等等的確" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/420.wav", + "text": "就是放在交通委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/421.wav", + "text": "未來我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/422.wav", + "text": "在聯席的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/423.wav", + "text": "主責就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/424.wav", + "text": "交通委員會聯席的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/425.wav", + "text": "經濟" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/426.wav", + "text": "教文委員會的委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/427.wav", + "text": "也可以來聯席我想" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/428.wav", + "text": "這個部分在技術上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/429.wav", + "text": "也不會有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/430.wav", + "text": "教文有6個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/431.wav", + "text": "所以在交通委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/432.wav", + "text": "目前是3個單位我們再加1個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/433.wav", + "text": "說實在是比較平衡合理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/434.wav", + "text": "所以我還要再強調一次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/435.wav", + "text": "謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/436.wav", + "text": "的發言之後我想表達" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/437.wav", + "text": "一下意見剛剛柯總召" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/438.wav", + "text": "有講既然之前的組織法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/439.wav", + "text": "大家在審查上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/440.wav", + "text": "既然照這樣子我們是不是就不需要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/441.wav", + "text": "再做改變我想如果是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/442.wav", + "text": "用這樣的觀念那數位發展" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/443.wav", + "text": "部也沒有成立的必要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/444.wav", + "text": "那就用原本部會上面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/445.wav", + "text": "數位業務的內容做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/446.wav", + "text": "相關的推動就可以了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/447.wav", + "text": "我想這本來就是一個滾動式過程" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/448.wav", + "text": "的討論今天既然會召開這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/449.wav", + "text": "協商就代表這件事情在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/450.wav", + "text": "數位產業的發展它是至關重要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/451.wav", + "text": "所以今天我們才會去做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/452.wav", + "text": "包含組改的的變動也是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/453.wav", + "text": "把它放在交通委員會大家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/454.wav", + "text": "的功能會不會疊床架屋" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/455.wav", + "text": "我也待過交通委員會我也擔任過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/456.wav", + "text": "召委我們非常清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/457.wav", + "text": "我知道謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/458.wav", + "text": "多是在建設但是經濟委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/459.wav", + "text": "整個數發部未來的施政上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/460.wav", + "text": "更深入的溝通因為我想立法院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/461.wav", + "text": "是採委員會中心主義跟" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/462.wav", + "text": "民意代表溝通等於也是跟" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/463.wav", + "text": "相關民意直接的溝通" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/464.wav", + "text": "並透過這樣的方式帶動" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/465.wav", + "text": "整個產業的發展不然" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/466.wav", + "text": "很多相關的資通安全其實這跟" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/467.wav", + "text": "相關的產業的發展跟" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/468.wav", + "text": "到底我們自己的廠商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/469.wav", + "text": "有沒有辦法提升到這樣的保護能力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/470.wav", + "text": "其實它是有很直接相關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/471.wav", + "text": "不然以後可能要透過外包或" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/472.wav", + "text": "都是有機會發生的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/473.wav", + "text": "所以今天我們是很客觀地去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/474.wav", + "text": "討論這個事情我也待過經濟委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/475.wav", + "text": "這兩年我待過經濟委員會跟交通委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/476.wav", + "text": "資通安全對於國防" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/477.wav", + "text": "也是相對重要所以這部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/478.wav", + "text": "是我們經過很審慎的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/479.wav", + "text": "認為說可以考慮" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/480.wav", + "text": "納入經濟委員會來做相關的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/481.wav", + "text": "預算審理跟相關的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/482.wav", + "text": "監督這樣可能可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/483.wav", + "text": "甚至可以帶動國內產業的發展" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/484.wav", + "text": "因為我們知道國發會是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/485.wav", + "text": "做整體國家政策跟產業" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/486.wav", + "text": "地圖的擘劃一個很重要的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/487.wav", + "text": "部會我們現在最擔心的就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/488.wav", + "text": "各部會各行其事疊床架屋加上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/489.wav", + "text": "上沒有橫向聯繫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/490.wav", + "text": "這是我們最擔心的狀況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/491.wav", + "text": "所以我們希望唐鳳部長也可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/492.wav", + "text": "瞭解我們大家的看法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/493.wav", + "text": "我想今天的協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/494.wav", + "text": "我也要具體建議院長是不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/495.wav", + "text": "可以讓唐鳳部長表達一下他的意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/496.wav", + "text": "再做更進一步的討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/497.wav", + "text": "還是希望可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/498.wav", + "text": "在經濟委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/499.wav", + "text": "做相關的監督跟審理以上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/500.wav", + "text": "謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/501.wav", + "text": "接下來還有兩位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/502.wav", + "text": "一位是李德維委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/503.wav", + "text": "首先對於剛才" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/504.wav", + "text": "邱委員所談的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/505.wav", + "text": "如果輪到經濟部就沒有成立的必要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/506.wav", + "text": "我覺得這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/507.wav", + "text": "在滾動檢討過程中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/508.wav", + "text": "一定要滾到經濟部去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/509.wav", + "text": "我覺得不以為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/510.wav", + "text": "經濟委員會不是經濟部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/511.wav", + "text": "你剛才一開口就這樣講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/512.wav", + "text": "我並沒有凹你" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/513.wav", + "text": "我們來理性的談清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/514.wav", + "text": "鳯也說錯了說什麼第1條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/515.wav", + "text": "就是數位產業發展" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/516.wav", + "text": "沒有這一條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/517.wav", + "text": "陳椒華委員講得很清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/518.wav", + "text": "行政院為促進全國通訊資訊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/519.wav", + "text": "資通安全" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/520.wav", + "text": "網路與傳播等數位產業發展" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/521.wav", + "text": "剛才邱臣遠委員所談的就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/522.wav", + "text": "交通部應該予以建設" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/523.wav", + "text": "這是傳統的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/524.wav", + "text": "交通部主要是在建設" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/525.wav", + "text": "整個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/526.wav", + "text": "網路建設NII以及" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/527.wav", + "text": "資安安全是未來國家最重要的一塊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/528.wav", + "text": "郵電司有一些類似的部分能挪過來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/529.wav", + "text": "以及將來需要NCC" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/530.wav", + "text": "所以它當初會到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/531.wav", + "text": "是有一定的道理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/532.wav", + "text": "現在不能因為加了一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/533.wav", + "text": "數位產業發展署" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/534.wav", + "text": "從客變整個拉過去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/535.wav", + "text": "而且當初數位產業發展部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/536.wav", + "text": "是委員在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/537.wav", + "text": "有礙於一些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/538.wav", + "text": "以後也是一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/539.wav", + "text": "有自治性的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/540.wav", + "text": "就是產業及數位服務" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/541.wav", + "text": "的補助獎勵什麼都補助獎勵" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/542.wav", + "text": "不會把主從關係" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/543.wav", + "text": "破壞掉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/544.wav", + "text": "網路安全與頻譜政策" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/545.wav", + "text": "未來最重要的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/546.wav", + "text": "它具體結合" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/547.wav", + "text": "大家\n我們上個禮拜" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/548.wav", + "text": "這邊和那邊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/549.wav", + "text": "嗎我想大家再思考一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/550.wav", + "text": "第2條執掌部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/551.wav", + "text": "則有國家數位發展政策" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/552.wav", + "text": "不是數位產業發展政策" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/553.wav", + "text": "而是國家數位發展政策" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/554.wav", + "text": "這點寫得很清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/555.wav", + "text": "大家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/556.wav", + "text": "這個交付表決能看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/557.wav", + "text": "嗎不好吧" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/558.wav", + "text": "我們原來是怎麼樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/559.wav", + "text": "的當然在原始設計上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/560.wav", + "text": "有一定的理念" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/561.wav", + "text": "聽唐部長講一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/562.wav", + "text": "也是應該的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/563.wav", + "text": "其實今天大家都很理性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/564.wav", + "text": "獎助經費" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/565.wav", + "text": "達4億1,977萬元" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/566.wav", + "text": "研究院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/567.wav", + "text": "聯絡希望能提供相關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/568.wav", + "text": "完全沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/569.wav", + "text": "要特別提出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/570.wav", + "text": "我們認為放在經濟委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/571.wav", + "text": "剛剛大家也說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/572.wav", + "text": "應該請唐鳳部長說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/573.wav", + "text": "其祿委員特別講到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/574.wav", + "text": "數位發展部接下來的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/575.wav", + "text": "是產業發展" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/576.wav", + "text": "資通安全各方面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/577.wav", + "text": "部長講一下這樣對於" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/578.wav", + "text": "相應的協助" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/579.wav", + "text": "是比較有幫助的謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/580.wav", + "text": "謝謝主席我第三次發言" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/581.wav", + "text": "已經有媒體" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/582.wav", + "text": "誰希望到數位發展部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/583.wav", + "text": "成立的必要性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/584.wav", + "text": "為什麼要成立因為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/585.wav", + "text": "成立\n至於相關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/586.wav", + "text": "單位還是放在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/587.wav", + "text": "交通委員會這點我剛剛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/588.wav", + "text": "強調過了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/589.wav", + "text": "發展也不一定要放在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/590.wav", + "text": "經濟委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/591.wav", + "text": "觀光產業請問為什麼不放在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/592.wav", + "text": "經濟委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/593.wav", + "text": "遊輪產業也在發展遊輪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/594.wav", + "text": "產業的主責單位也是觀光局" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/595.wav", + "text": "也是放在交通" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/596.wav", + "text": "我們應該以資通安全為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/597.wav", + "text": "重要的考量" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/598.wav", + "text": "至於相關產業發展上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/599.wav", + "text": "上未來交通" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/600.wav", + "text": "蓬勃展開就像大家都知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/601.wav", + "text": "所以我還是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/602.wav", + "text": "後我們認為還是放在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/603.wav", + "text": "交通委員會比較適合" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/604.wav", + "text": "差不多有兩種" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/605.wav", + "text": "不同意見我們讓唐" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/606.wav", + "text": "部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/607.wav", + "text": "我補充一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/608.wav", + "text": "讓總召再補充一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/609.wav", + "text": "我講一個歷史故事" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/610.wav", + "text": "1993年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/611.wav", + "text": "柯林頓當選美國總統" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/612.wav", + "text": "那一年我進到立法院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/613.wav", + "text": "我總質詢的第一個題目" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/614.wav", + "text": "以NI" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/615.wav", + "text": "I建構智慧型美麗島" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/616.wav", + "text": "因為那時候NI" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/617.wav", + "text": "是美國開始" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/618.wav", + "text": "就是說我們要打破" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/619.wav", + "text": "傳統的交通建設" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/620.wav", + "text": "網絡建設很重要將來資安會很重要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/621.wav", + "text": "所以後來我也主張" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/622.wav", + "text": "就是我們後來的NCC" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/623.wav", + "text": "國民黨執政的時候我是行政院NI" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/624.wav", + "text": "I執行委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/625.wav", + "text": "那時候還有跟" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/626.wav", + "text": "政務委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/627.wav", + "text": "包括劉兆玄等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/628.wav", + "text": "資訊安全" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/629.wav", + "text": "資通等等全世界未來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/630.wav", + "text": "是拼這一塊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/631.wav", + "text": "不是傳統的基礎建設" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/632.wav", + "text": "所以那時候連戰提出" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/633.wav", + "text": "亞太營運中心電信中心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/634.wav", + "text": "我那時候主張電信開放" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/635.wav", + "text": "第二類電信開放" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/636.wav", + "text": "也是著重在這一塊上面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/637.wav", + "text": "全國通訊資訊資安等等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/638.wav", + "text": "所以我覺得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/639.wav", + "text": "該照原來的規劃" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/640.wav", + "text": "想法就是這樣的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/641.wav", + "text": "以上做這樣的補充" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/642.wav", + "text": "謝謝柯總召" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/643.wav", + "text": "非常謝謝各位委員的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/644.wav", + "text": "垂詢當然分屬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/645.wav", + "text": "哪一個委員會完全尊重大院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/646.wav", + "text": "的意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/647.wav", + "text": "不過剛才有一些委員有一些比較具體的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/648.wav", + "text": "容我回答一下\n" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/649.wav", + "text": "剛才提到國家資通安全" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/650.wav", + "text": "研究院也就是資安院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/651.wav", + "text": "的籌設因為它有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/652.wav", + "text": "兩個部分一個是現有技" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/653.wav", + "text": "技服的團隊另外一部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/654.wav", + "text": "是目前在新國科會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/655.wav", + "text": "之前科技部裡面的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/656.wav", + "text": "資安卓越中心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/657.wav", + "text": "資安卓越中心裡面跟研究" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/658.wav", + "text": "比較相關的可能還是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/659.wav", + "text": "會在新的國科會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/660.wav", + "text": "轄下但是能夠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/661.wav", + "text": "在短時間裡面實際在攻防" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/662.wav", + "text": "討論目前還在進行中還沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/663.wav", + "text": "一個很確定的分野" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/664.wav", + "text": "所以很抱歉委員之前詢問" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/665.wav", + "text": "的時候還沒有一個很確定的答案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/666.wav", + "text": "但是一旦有確定的答案反正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/667.wav", + "text": "我們預計年底設立我們隨時" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/668.wav", + "text": "有討論出確定的答案就會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/669.wav", + "text": "跟委員報告這是第一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/670.wav", + "text": "委員之前說我們應該" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/671.wav", + "text": "多說明我們的政策" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/672.wav", + "text": "特別是在一些新興的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/673.wav", + "text": "我們完全都同意我們會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/674.wav", + "text": "更平易近人的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/675.wav", + "text": "把我們的政策講清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/676.wav", + "text": "我為什麼提這個是因為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/677.wav", + "text": "新的衛星技術或者5G專網" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/678.wav", + "text": "之類當然資安是最重要的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/679.wav", + "text": "但是當資安確立" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/680.wav", + "text": "之後這個確立資安本身" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/681.wav", + "text": "讓大家相信我們本身" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/682.wav", + "text": "也是一個branding也是讓國際" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/683.wav", + "text": "知道臺灣是可信賴的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/684.wav", + "text": "所以資安本身是一個產業" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/685.wav", + "text": "產業的數位轉型本身也是資安" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/686.wav", + "text": "的一環所以我們的資安署" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/687.wav", + "text": "跟產業署是非常密切緊密地結合" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/688.wav", + "text": "\n我想不管是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/689.wav", + "text": "在哪一個委員會我們都會秉持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/690.wav", + "text": "任何委員會相關委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/691.wav", + "text": "有想要垂詢的議題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/692.wav", + "text": "不分是哪一個委員會我們都會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/693.wav", + "text": "具體回答以上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/694.wav", + "text": "好謝謝唐部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/695.wav", + "text": "將近一個小時大家的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/696.wav", + "text": "協商並沒有共識" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/697.wav", + "text": "本案經過黨團協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/698.wav", + "text": "還沒有得到共識" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/699.wav", + "text": "依本院議事先例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/700.wav", + "text": "新增部會應列屬於哪一個委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/701.wav", + "text": "得經黨團協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/702.wav", + "text": "提報院會決定之" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/703.wav", + "text": "\n本案就" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/704.wav", + "text": "做以下宣告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/705.wav", + "text": "有關數位發展部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/706.wav", + "text": "業務職掌歸屬於" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/707.wav", + "text": "何一常設委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/708.wav", + "text": "提報院會決定之" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/709.wav", + "text": "在院會決定前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/710.wav", + "text": "各黨團有共識" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/711.wav", + "text": "\n沒有意見的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/712.wav", + "text": "院會決定前各黨有共識" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/713.wav", + "text": "弄一個案子還是怎麼樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/714.wav", + "text": "對我們就提報院會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/715.wav", + "text": "院會什麼時候決定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/716.wav", + "text": "跟各位黨鞭報告如果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/717.wav", + "text": "院長這樣宣告的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/718.wav", + "text": "我們會在報告事項裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/719.wav", + "text": "增列這個案子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/720.wav", + "text": "就照共識辦理如果沒有的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/721.wav", + "text": "第一次就要表決" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/722.wav", + "text": "所以最好早一點在第一次院會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/723.wav", + "text": "因為29日就要提過來了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/724.wav", + "text": "第二次院會是30日" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/725.wav", + "text": "所以會在第一次院會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/726.wav", + "text": "不然國民黨占主席臺什麼都不必搞" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/727.wav", + "text": "好就照這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/728.wav", + "text": "快有需要堅持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/729.wav", + "text": "嗎數位基礎建設很重要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/730.wav", + "text": "好我們就繼續溝通" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/731.wav", + "text": "繼續溝通" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/732.wav", + "text": "啦不行的話23日處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/733.wav", + "text": "我現在再提一個事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/734.wav", + "text": "30日處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/735.wav", + "text": "警械使用條例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/736.wav", + "text": "而已我想這件事大家都很急" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/737.wav", + "text": "是不是下禮拜請院長召集朝野協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/738.wav", + "text": "大家談一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/739.wav", + "text": "警械使用條例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/740.wav", + "text": "禮拜幾" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/741.wav", + "text": "那個已經一年多不排" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/742.wav", + "text": "我們會去表達" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/743.wav", + "text": "27日28日我們再來處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/744.wav", + "text": "好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/745.wav", + "text": "我們會提案請院長協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/746.wav", + "text": "委員會用不完的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/747.wav", + "text": "還是要到這裡來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/748.wav", + "text": "我們會到現場去提交" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/749.wav", + "text": "請院長朝野協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/750.wav", + "text": "就這樣好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/751.wav", + "text": "好30日以前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14429/752.wav", + "text": "好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/0.wav", + "text": "看哪一黨團要先發表高見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/1.wav", + "text": "院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/2.wav", + "text": "各位黨團代表" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/3.wav", + "text": "很高興在這裡又再次碰面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/4.wav", + "text": "了我們馬上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/5.wav", + "text": "又有很長的時間在一起" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/6.wav", + "text": "開議以後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/7.wav", + "text": "但是無論如何" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/8.wav", + "text": "我們有責任把立法院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/9.wav", + "text": "讓立法院早日能夠開議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/10.wav", + "text": "順利進行因為我們有很多法定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/11.wav", + "text": "的事情必須處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/12.wav", + "text": "這個會期除了總質詢以外" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/13.wav", + "text": "有四大預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/14.wav", + "text": "第一個就是中央政府總預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/15.wav", + "text": "第二個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/16.wav", + "text": "是前瞻4期" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/17.wav", + "text": "第四個就是今年度的國營事業預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/18.wav", + "text": "這些都是法定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/19.wav", + "text": "的是委員會要審查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/20.wav", + "text": "然後院會要處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/21.wav", + "text": "這是立法院的基本責任與義務" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/22.wav", + "text": "至於法案當然今天不在討論範圍內" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/23.wav", + "text": "我們今天最主要討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/24.wav", + "text": "什麼時候來開議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/25.wav", + "text": "讓大家聽聽看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/26.wav", + "text": "今天是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/27.wav", + "text": "期五" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/28.wav", + "text": "立法院往例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/29.wav", + "text": "像這個會期的開議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/30.wav", + "text": "是不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/31.wav", + "text": "大家討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/32.wav", + "text": "一下什麼時候要把總預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/33.wav", + "text": "什麼時候把前瞻預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/34.wav", + "text": "委可能我要拜託大家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/35.wav", + "text": "切一個時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/36.wav", + "text": "警械使用條例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/37.wav", + "text": "希望早一點處理假" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/38.wav", + "text": "來處理的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/39.wav", + "text": "可能要總質詢結束以後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/40.wav", + "text": "到11月初去了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/41.wav", + "text": "這個大家比較有共識" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/42.wav", + "text": "要切一個時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/43.wav", + "text": "警械使用條例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/44.wav", + "text": "先透過委員會協商這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/45.wav", + "text": "可以順便一起來處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/46.wav", + "text": "半天就夠了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/47.wav", + "text": "國營事業預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/48.wav", + "text": "過去的就不必說了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/49.wav", + "text": "我是覺得還是要提早處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/50.wav", + "text": "免得到總質詢結束" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/51.wav", + "text": "以後再來處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/52.wav", + "text": "這樣對大家也不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/53.wav", + "text": "人家預算都要用完了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/54.wav", + "text": "我們還在亡羊補牢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/55.wav", + "text": "不是很好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/56.wav", + "text": "假如大家可以同意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/57.wav", + "text": "再來談什麼時候總預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/58.wav", + "text": "乃至於" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/59.wav", + "text": "決算的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/60.wav", + "text": "另外就是警械" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/61.wav", + "text": "使用條例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/62.wav", + "text": "以及111年度的國營事業預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/63.wav", + "text": "那兩個可以併在一起一個下午就結束" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/64.wav", + "text": "因為111年度國營事業預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/65.wav", + "text": "都是談了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/66.wav", + "text": "先把法定的東西處理完畢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/67.wav", + "text": "然後委員會怎麼樣我們當然都尊重" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/68.wav", + "text": "時各政黨怎麼攻防" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/69.wav", + "text": "當然都是尊重以上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/70.wav", + "text": "懇請" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/71.wav", + "text": "開議日大家能夠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/72.wav", + "text": "和平來談" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/73.wav", + "text": "各位黨團的總召" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/74.wav", + "text": "黨團的代表" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/75.wav", + "text": "剛剛柯總召也有談到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/76.wav", + "text": "今天是星期五" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/77.wav", + "text": "柯總召建議23" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/78.wav", + "text": "即下週五" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/79.wav", + "text": "開議我們的建議是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/80.wav", + "text": "過去常會的經驗是會期時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/81.wav", + "text": "不夠之後還要加開臨時會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/82.wav", + "text": "這麼趕的時間裡面很難針對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/83.wav", + "text": "預算案做精緻的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/84.wav", + "text": "討論因為這個會期是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/85.wav", + "text": "預算會期今年又" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/86.wav", + "text": "遇到地方選舉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/87.wav", + "text": "有些召委跟委員會把重心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/88.wav", + "text": "放在地方" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/89.wav", + "text": "考察行程" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/90.wav", + "text": "剛才跟柯總召談" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/91.wav", + "text": "跑地方行程" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/92.wav", + "text": "香山南寮到處跑" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/93.wav", + "text": "最近我也去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/94.wav", + "text": "協調很多法案法案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/95.wav", + "text": "沒有通過的這個問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/96.wav", + "text": "都會產生所以法案大塞車" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/97.wav", + "text": "保護被害人的性私密影像" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/98.wav", + "text": "吹哨者的吹哨者保護法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/99.wav", + "text": "居住正義的平均地權條例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/100.wav", + "text": "火火送進來之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/101.wav", + "text": "貪污治罪條例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/102.wav", + "text": "人權委員會要動起來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/103.wav", + "text": "所必要的監察法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/104.wav", + "text": "或是職權行使法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/105.wav", + "text": "有非常多法案還卡在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/106.wav", + "text": "一讀或是等待黨團" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/107.wav", + "text": "民進黨政府" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/108.wav", + "text": "非常引以為傲的同性婚姻" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/109.wav", + "text": "跨國同婚的修正草案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/110.wav", + "text": "現在司法院通過之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/111.wav", + "text": "還卡在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/112.wav", + "text": "行政院已經超過一年半這" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/113.wav", + "text": "機關敗訴之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/114.wav", + "text": "這些戶所在等內政部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/115.wav", + "text": "到底是不是能夠准許" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/116.wav", + "text": "跨國同婚結果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/117.wav", + "text": "還是被拒絕拒絕之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/118.wav", + "text": "又跑去法院法院又判機關敗訴" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/119.wav", + "text": "最近發生民眾打1985檢舉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/120.wav", + "text": "陸軍少將搭公務車" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/121.wav", + "text": "出入聲色場所" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/122.wav", + "text": "結果反而把人家的資訊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/123.wav", + "text": "被檢舉人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/124.wav", + "text": "跟他的朋友還直接打電話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/125.wav", + "text": "給檢舉人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/126.wav", + "text": "發生這種離譜的事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/127.wav", + "text": "吹哨者保護法講這麼多年了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/128.wav", + "text": "戴立紳" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/129.wav", + "text": "都還沒工作" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/130.wav", + "text": "也沒辦法回復公職" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/131.wav", + "text": "長期關注的氣候變遷因應法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/132.wav", + "text": "跟精神衛生法等等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/133.wav", + "text": "我們也都希望能夠在這個會期" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/134.wav", + "text": "趕快修法通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/135.wav", + "text": "今年是選舉年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/136.wav", + "text": "選舉制度長期的一些問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/137.wav", + "text": "譬如說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/138.wav", + "text": "選舉經費是不是要有上限" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/139.wav", + "text": "黨的初選經費設限" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/140.wav", + "text": "等等我們也希望在選舉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/141.wav", + "text": "罷免法裡面有一些規範" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/142.wav", + "text": "這次選舉抄襲案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/143.wav", + "text": "頻傳這要怎麼處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/144.wav", + "text": "促轉會結案報告建議的政治檔案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/145.wav", + "text": "條例修法等等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/146.wav", + "text": "也非常急迫的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/147.wav", + "text": "最後一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/148.wav", + "text": "就是警消到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/149.wav", + "text": "司法人員的加班費" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/150.wav", + "text": "還有警察和法警" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/151.wav", + "text": "裝備的改善" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/152.wav", + "text": "比如臺南" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/153.wav", + "text": "這兩個警察的事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/154.wav", + "text": "院長有到現場" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/155.wav", + "text": "但是現在的問題是裝備" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/156.wav", + "text": "都要進一步" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/157.wav", + "text": "也是為國努力的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/158.wav", + "text": "基層人員最基本的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/159.wav", + "text": "權利保障" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/160.wav", + "text": "儘速開議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/161.wav", + "text": "週四可以讓各委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/162.wav", + "text": "選舉召委" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/163.wav", + "text": "週五開始總質詢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/164.wav", + "text": "就可以正常運作" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/165.wav", + "text": "有這麼多要處理的預算案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/166.wav", + "text": "法案加上選舉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/167.wav", + "text": "一定有很多行程跟工作要處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/168.wav", + "text": "避免最後時間又來不" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/169.wav", + "text": "謝謝邱總召" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/170.wav", + "text": "謝謝院長還有各大黨團" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/171.wav", + "text": "的黨鞭幹部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/172.wav", + "text": "民眾黨的態度非常明確" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/173.wav", + "text": "因為這一次的休會期間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/174.wav", + "text": "而且目前有非常多國人關心的議題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/175.wav", + "text": "所以我們具體的建議是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/176.wav", + "text": "希望以下個禮拜二即9月20日作為開議日" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/177.wav", + "text": "也可以儘快地去排程" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/178.wav", + "text": "就可以進行召委的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/179.wav", + "text": "選舉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/180.wav", + "text": "有幾個重點我" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/181.wav", + "text": "包含剛剛談到的四大預算案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/182.wav", + "text": "112年度的總預算前瞻預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/183.wav", + "text": "另外大家可能都漏掉一點就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/184.wav", + "text": "也需要更精緻地" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/185.wav", + "text": "法案的推動上為了維護" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/186.wav", + "text": "居住正義對平均地權條例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/187.wav", + "text": "這個部分也是要優先來處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/188.wav", + "text": "氣候變遷因應法礦業法等等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/189.wav", + "text": "包含台電在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/190.wav", + "text": "與民生經濟相關的事務" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/191.wav", + "text": "都需要我們花更多的時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/192.wav", + "text": "非常關心數位發展部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/193.wav", + "text": "這也都是社會所殷殷期盼的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/194.wav", + "text": "是國人非常期盼的一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/195.wav", + "text": "有相當大的期待" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/196.wav", + "text": "但是對於目前唐鳳部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/197.wav", + "text": "所提出來的一些願景跟" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/198.wav", + "text": "工作內容其實有非常多的國人還是非常地" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/199.wav", + "text": "關於立法院的權責" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/200.wav", + "text": "到底是由哪一個委員會去審查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/201.wav", + "text": "其實對這個部分也應該要做一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/202.wav", + "text": "明確的規範因為數位發展部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/203.wav", + "text": "層面非常廣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/204.wav", + "text": "成立數位發展部的時候有一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/205.wav", + "text": "很重要的部分就是產業發展" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/206.wav", + "text": "包含現在所談到的提升" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/207.wav", + "text": "數位韌性還有資通安全" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/208.wav", + "text": "現有的委員會來看如果有關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/209.wav", + "text": "有關監理或資通安全這個是屬於NCC" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/210.wav", + "text": "所以是在交通委員會當時組織法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/211.wav", + "text": "是放到交通委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/212.wav", + "text": "好像是在交通" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/213.wav", + "text": "委員會\n可是唐鳳部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/214.wav", + "text": "有對外發言他一直期待是在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/215.wav", + "text": "教育及文化委員會這樣跟過去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/216.wav", + "text": "科技部的脈絡比較一致目前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/217.wav", + "text": "我們搞不清楚但是我們知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/218.wav", + "text": "數位發展部有一個非常重要的部分就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/219.wav", + "text": "產業的數位發展跟" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/220.wav", + "text": "相關數位產業的提升" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/221.wav", + "text": "這又跟經濟委員會有關係" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/222.wav", + "text": "如果說到資通安全" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/223.wav", + "text": "這是兩百多億元的預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/224.wav", + "text": "對於相關權責立法院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/225.wav", + "text": "身為最高民意機關而負責監督" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/226.wav", + "text": "還有相關規範" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/227.wav", + "text": "做更明確清楚的說明所以我希望對這個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/228.wav", + "text": "日為9月20日希望" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/229.wav", + "text": "行政院針對數位發展部做一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/230.wav", + "text": "專案報告關於總質詢的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/231.wav", + "text": "我們希望在9月23日來進" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/232.wav", + "text": "進行院長的施政總質詢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/233.wav", + "text": "也請大家支持謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/234.wav", + "text": "好謝謝邱總召\n接下來請國民" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/235.wav", + "text": "各黨團的代表關於國民黨的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/236.wav", + "text": "上禮拜五就已經是9日" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/237.wav", + "text": "所以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/238.wav", + "text": "我們也不諱言這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/239.wav", + "text": "會期基本上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/240.wav", + "text": "我們有很多委員同仁" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/241.wav", + "text": "不管是參選也好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/242.wav", + "text": "或是輔選也好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/243.wav", + "text": "也建議要給大家一點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/244.wav", + "text": "假如決定下禮拜二的話其實" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/245.wav", + "text": "真的是有限啦所以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/246.wav", + "text": "國民黨這邊也是建議在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/247.wav", + "text": "假如是下禮拜二的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/248.wav", + "text": "行程都已經排好了整個要做變動" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/249.wav", + "text": "也會有點辛苦所以對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/250.wav", + "text": "這個部分我們也特別提出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/251.wav", + "text": "\n關於剛剛柯總召所提到的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/252.wav", + "text": "警械使用條例的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/253.wav", + "text": "討論跟處理因為畢竟" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/254.wav", + "text": "兩位員警" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/255.wav", + "text": "能感同身受所以國民黨這邊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/256.wav", + "text": "當然也希望早一點來處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/257.wav", + "text": "\n另外關於剛剛民眾黨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/258.wav", + "text": "所提到數發部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/259.wav", + "text": "當然一個新部會的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/260.wav", + "text": "也談到所謂" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/261.wav", + "text": "數位中介服務法的相關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/262.wav", + "text": "談的東西" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/263.wav", + "text": "可能是數發部在處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/264.wav", + "text": "當然現在還不知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/265.wav", + "text": "所以數發部包含其員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/266.wav", + "text": "員額的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/267.wav", + "text": "今天的主題還是在談" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/268.wav", + "text": "開議的事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/269.wav", + "text": "院長各位黨團代表" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/270.wav", + "text": "在態度上當然我們希望能夠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/271.wav", + "text": "但現實上現在有個困難" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/272.wav", + "text": "就是有幾個立委的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/273.wav", + "text": "訪團還在國外" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/274.wav", + "text": "尤其是臺美國會議員聯誼會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/275.wav", + "text": "有跨黨派的委員現在正在美國" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/276.wav", + "text": "進行國會外交" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/277.wav", + "text": "就我們瞭解他們最快要到20日才能夠" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/278.wav", + "text": "再隔離3天左右的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/279.wav", + "text": "大概也是23" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/280.wav", + "text": "日如果20日就開議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/281.wav", + "text": "現在正在國外進行公務" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/282.wav", + "text": "訪問的這些委員之權益" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/283.wav", + "text": "建議還是以23日" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/284.wav", + "text": "日針對剛才所談的一些事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/285.wav", + "text": "包括時代力量所談的那些法案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/286.wav", + "text": "剛才一開始我就講了法案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/287.wav", + "text": "另一類是委員會審查完畢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/288.wav", + "text": "送出委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/289.wav", + "text": "此外行政院也陸續送進來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/290.wav", + "text": "剛才說的包括氣候變遷" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/291.wav", + "text": "的4個相關法案如刑法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/292.wav", + "text": "及犯罪被害人保護法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/293.wav", + "text": "都送出委員會了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/294.wav", + "text": "了那些法案要處理的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/295.wav", + "text": "開議以後我們就邊協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/296.wav", + "text": "沒差別啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/297.wav", + "text": "這些都是可以處理的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/298.wav", + "text": "至於礦業法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/299.wav", + "text": "委員會都還沒審" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/300.wav", + "text": "查開議後隨時都可以排審" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/301.wav", + "text": "的部分\n關於法案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/302.wav", + "text": "剛才講了很多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/303.wav", + "text": "這是在講你們未來的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/304.wav", + "text": "每一個政黨都有優先法案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/305.wav", + "text": "當然我們都尊重" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/306.wav", + "text": "可以有秩序地安排" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/307.wav", + "text": "包括剛才民眾黨所談的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/308.wav", + "text": "數發部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/309.wav", + "text": "的部分在上個會期已經處理過了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/310.wav", + "text": "連數發部成立的目的功能等等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/311.wav", + "text": "數發部的整體預算占總預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/312.wav", + "text": "不到1%其" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/313.wav", + "text": "其功能很重要我們都承認" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/314.wav", + "text": "\n我不建議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/315.wav", + "text": "像民眾黨所說的由" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/316.wav", + "text": "院長針對數發部做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/317.wav", + "text": "不要這樣子好不" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/318.wav", + "text": "不好一個部會的成立上個會議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/319.wav", + "text": "都談得很清楚了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/320.wav", + "text": "了至於要在哪個委員會審查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/321.wav", + "text": "我比較持平而論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/322.wav", + "text": "數位產業發展署是後來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/323.wav", + "text": "原來是怎麼樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/324.wav", + "text": "是交通委員會主審" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/325.wav", + "text": "既然已經這樣審下來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/326.wav", + "text": "了現在你說交由" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/327.wav", + "text": "回歸到尊重立法院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/328.wav", + "text": "排下去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/329.wav", + "text": "院長和議事處" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/330.wav", + "text": "早就有安排我" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/331.wav", + "text": "們尊重就好了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/332.wav", + "text": "我比較建議的是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/333.wav", + "text": "今天我們說程序的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/334.wav", + "text": "不要談法案內容" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/335.wav", + "text": "法案內容的可變之處非常多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/336.wav", + "text": "關於法案的話就講不完" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/337.wav", + "text": "了我們就說程序" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/338.wav", + "text": "莎力一點我希望大家就" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/339.wav", + "text": "什麼時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/340.wav", + "text": "總預算付委" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/341.wav", + "text": "我們今天都把它定下來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/342.wav", + "text": "1年度的國營事業預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/343.wav", + "text": "一起處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/344.wav", + "text": "警械使用條例只有3條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/345.wav", + "text": "應該很快會有共識" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/346.wav", + "text": "沒有共識就表決而已" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/347.wav", + "text": "拖對立法院也不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/348.wav", + "text": "如果23日可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/349.wav", + "text": "何時總預算付委" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/350.wav", + "text": "何時處理警械使用條例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/351.wav", + "text": "這樣程序比較容易進行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/352.wav", + "text": "識滿高的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/353.wav", + "text": "院長各位同仁大家好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/354.wav", + "text": "基本上國民黨黨團" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/355.wav", + "text": "有幾點意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/356.wav", + "text": "大方向我們支持9月23日" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/357.wav", + "text": "不可否認現在還有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/358.wav", + "text": "他們回來還要隔離" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/359.wav", + "text": "在國內的委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/360.wav", + "text": "其實也要給他們一定的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/361.wav", + "text": "彈性去調整相關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/362.wav", + "text": "行程所以大方向" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/363.wav", + "text": "開議這是第一點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/364.wav", + "text": "邱總召提到的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/365.wav", + "text": "數位發展部的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/366.wav", + "text": "哪個委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/367.wav", + "text": "歸交通歸經濟" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/368.wav", + "text": "或者其他委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/369.wav", + "text": "希望朝野" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/370.wav", + "text": "要有共識這是第二點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/371.wav", + "text": "\n第三點就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/372.wav", + "text": "國民黨的優先法案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/373.wav", + "text": "包括警械使用條例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/374.wav", + "text": "外役監條例氣候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/375.wav", + "text": "變遷因應法等等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/376.wav", + "text": "大方向我們都支持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/377.wav", + "text": "雖然下會期是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/378.wav", + "text": "預算會期不容易" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/379.wav", + "text": "但是它有急迫性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/380.wav", + "text": "國民黨黨團贊成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/381.wav", + "text": "\n第四點就是柯總召" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/382.wav", + "text": "提了2次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/383.wav", + "text": "今年的營業" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/384.wav", + "text": "其實柯總召很清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/385.wav", + "text": "他跟我們講過很多次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/386.wav", + "text": "本來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/387.wav", + "text": "在5月底之前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/388.wav", + "text": "我們全力支持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/389.wav", + "text": "讓它趕快通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/390.wav", + "text": "因為時間已經delay了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/391.wav", + "text": "而且也謝謝院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/392.wav", + "text": "朝野協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/393.wav", + "text": "有共識" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/394.wav", + "text": "所以我們本來講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/395.wav", + "text": "5月或者臨時會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/396.wav", + "text": "國民黨黨團強力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/397.wav", + "text": "支持國營事業預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/398.wav", + "text": "趕快通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/399.wav", + "text": "但是沒想到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/400.wav", + "text": "會計法第99條之1" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/401.wav", + "text": "強行通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/402.wav", + "text": "破壞朝野氣氛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/403.wav", + "text": "那你不能休會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/404.wav", + "text": "休會3個月之後什麼都沒講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/405.wav", + "text": "就說要通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/406.wav", + "text": "這不行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/407.wav", + "text": "至少看你還是民進黨要不要道歉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/408.wav", + "text": "是第一點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/409.wav", + "text": "大家就忘記了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/410.wav", + "text": "是審查預算通過的決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/411.wav", + "text": "不執行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/412.wav", + "text": "這也是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/413.wav", + "text": "游院長主持的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/414.wav", + "text": "防疫紓困預算第3次追加" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/415.wav", + "text": "2,600億元" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/416.wav", + "text": "6月18日三讀通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/417.wav", + "text": "政府施政須依法執行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/418.wav", + "text": "並公開透明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/419.wav", + "text": "而且要接受" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/420.wav", + "text": "各界的檢視" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/421.wav", + "text": "必須按照傳染病防治法第27" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/422.wav", + "text": "7條規定政府" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/423.wav", + "text": "購買疫苗會議的過程" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/424.wav", + "text": "須錄音" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/425.wav", + "text": "而且要公布詳細紀錄" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/426.wav", + "text": "這個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/427.wav", + "text": "經過院長主持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/428.wav", + "text": "後來的結論是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/429.wav", + "text": "前開規定於該類疫苗" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/430.wav", + "text": "全數交貨完成後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/431.wav", + "text": "兩個月內公布相關會議紀錄" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/432.wav", + "text": "協商過程" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/433.wav", + "text": "加了2個字─全數" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/434.wav", + "text": "那現在高端" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/435.wav", + "text": "等很多疫苗都買了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/436.wav", + "text": "我們跟衛福部要資料" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/437.wav", + "text": "竟然說要封存" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/438.wav", + "text": "10年20年30年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/439.wav", + "text": "你要依照" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/440.wav", + "text": "不然審預算審什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/441.wav", + "text": "審假的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/442.wav", + "text": "去年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/443.wav", + "text": "6月18日" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/444.wav", + "text": "院長也在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/445.wav", + "text": "你說對不起我也接受" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/446.wav", + "text": "我剛剛唸了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/447.wav", + "text": "審查防疫紓困第3次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/448.wav", + "text": "追加2,600" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/449.wav", + "text": "什麼建請案是主決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/450.wav", + "text": "我等一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/451.wav", + "text": "調錄音帶給你看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/452.wav", + "text": "沒有沒有沒有沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/453.wav", + "text": "我現在給你看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/454.wav", + "text": "你要審" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/455.wav", + "text": "111年度營業" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/456.wav", + "text": "及非營業預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/457.wav", + "text": "國民黨強力支���" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/458.wav", + "text": "但有兩個條件" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/459.wav", + "text": "民進黨要道歉不然" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/460.wav", + "text": "至少要說對不起" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/461.wav", + "text": "那一天打架強行通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/462.wav", + "text": "你至少要講個對不起啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/463.wav", + "text": "第二個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/464.wav", + "text": "我在講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/465.wav", + "text": "很嚴肅的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/466.wav", + "text": "就是這兩個前提" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/467.wav", + "text": "我們才願意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/468.wav", + "text": "院長你應該記得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/469.wav", + "text": "這個是朝野協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/470.wav", + "text": "嗎買疫苗" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/471.wav", + "text": "要錄音錄影要公布會議紀錄" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/472.wav", + "text": "我提的主決議通過了現在說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/473.wav", + "text": "要封存10年20年30年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/474.wav", + "text": "去年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/475.wav", + "text": "怎麼沒有要求" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/476.wav", + "text": "沒關係等一下來面對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/477.wav", + "text": "謝謝院長還有各個黨團代表" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/478.wav", + "text": "我想這部分大家都有一致共識" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/479.wav", + "text": "不是下禮拜二就是下禮拜五開會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/480.wav", + "text": "我們立法院就是為人民監督" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/481.wav", + "text": "大家都已經準備好了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/482.wav", + "text": "誠如剛剛我們黨團的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/483.wav", + "text": "總召跟書記長所講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/484.wav", + "text": "國民黨團也認為9月23日" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/485.wav", + "text": "是可行的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/486.wav", + "text": "但是我建議我要跟院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/487.wav", + "text": "特別報告國人都很關心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/488.wav", + "text": "數位發展部的歸屬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/489.wav", + "text": "是各黨團到最後的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/490.wav", + "text": "要求拜託院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/491.wav", + "text": "一定要在9月23日以前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/492.wav", + "text": "召開朝野協商確認數位發展部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/493.wav", + "text": "要在哪個委員會為什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/494.wav", + "text": "因為9月23日是禮拜五" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/495.wav", + "text": "如果順利開議的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/496.wav", + "text": "即9月26日原則上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/497.wav", + "text": "就會選召委" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/498.wav", + "text": "召委選完之後大家都知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/499.wav", + "text": "各召委負責哪一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/500.wav", + "text": "部會包括預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/501.wav", + "text": "都是由召委來安排" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/502.wav", + "text": "因此如果數位發展部都還沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/503.wav", + "text": "確定在哪個委員會的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/504.wav", + "text": "及其權限都會非常地困難" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/505.wav", + "text": "還有一個禮拜的時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/506.wav", + "text": "到下禮拜五之前有4天的上班日" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/507.wav", + "text": "都可以由院長這邊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/508.wav", + "text": "來召開朝野協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/509.wav", + "text": "是9月28日選召委不是9月2對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/510.wav", + "text": "對啦有關時間的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/511.wav", + "text": "我是說在選召委之前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/512.wav", + "text": "一定要確認數位發展部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/513.wav", + "text": "也有提到這個會期" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/514.wav", + "text": "我們有優先的氣候變遷因應法的法案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/515.wav", + "text": "要拜託院長因為其實上個會期" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/516.wav", + "text": "就已經出委員會了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/517.wav", + "text": "但是到目前為止有一些爭議的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/518.wav", + "text": "還沒有召開朝野協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/519.wav", + "text": "能夠儘速召開朝野協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/520.wav", + "text": "並且我們期待" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/521.wav", + "text": "在總質詢結束之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/522.wav", + "text": "就可以來處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/523.wav", + "text": "氣候變遷因應法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/524.wav", + "text": "因為我想這是國人一致的共識" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/525.wav", + "text": "2050淨零碳排不要只是口號" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/526.wav", + "text": "而是實際的行動" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/527.wav", + "text": "我們要用實際的行動" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/528.wav", + "text": "來給予國人最基本的交代" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/529.wav", + "text": "以上兩件謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/530.wav", + "text": "張幹事長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/531.wav", + "text": "再補充一下民眾黨的意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/532.wav", + "text": "意見我們當然還是希望數" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/533.wav", + "text": "專報的應該是要有一個專報" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/534.wav", + "text": "我們立法過程是完成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/535.wav", + "text": "了這是沒有錯但是因為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/536.wav", + "text": "國人也非常關切" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/537.wav", + "text": "而且其實也才成立" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/538.wav", + "text": "在預算人事上大家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/539.wav", + "text": "關切我覺得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/540.wav", + "text": "有一個專報把它講清楚並不見得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/541.wav", + "text": "這麼支持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/542.wav", + "text": "部長都能把這件事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/543.wav", + "text": "一併解釋清楚也並不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/544.wav", + "text": "因為這是新的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/545.wav", + "text": "哪一個委員會都還沒有很清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/546.wav", + "text": "所以這件事確實應該" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/547.wav", + "text": "在我們選" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/548.wav", + "text": "透過協商把這件事先" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/549.wav", + "text": "未來委員會的運作應該" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/550.wav", + "text": "會比較順利所以我們也是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/551.wav", + "text": "我這邊只是補充住居正義" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/552.wav", + "text": "的一些相關法案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/553.wav", + "text": "委員包括吳玉琴委員可能" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/554.wav", + "text": "也會去參加其實很多民團" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/555.wav", + "text": "已經在外面談了很多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/556.wav", + "text": "不管是平均地權條例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/557.wav", + "text": "租賃條例所得稅法的這些修法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/558.wav", + "text": "小英總統自己說的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/559.wav", + "text": "大家已經都有一些共識" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/560.wav", + "text": "我們也希望真的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/561.wav", + "text": "能夠把它落實下去所以這幾個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/562.wav", + "text": "跟審查的一些進程" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/563.wav", + "text": "委員會的部分我想這是立法院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/564.wav", + "text": "自己的職權自己來決定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/565.wav", + "text": "部分黨團想要聽聽看行政部門的意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/566.wav", + "text": "我們也沒意見但是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/567.wav", + "text": "都可以問院長這個問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/568.wav", + "text": "至於要所謂的專報這是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/569.wav", + "text": "很奇怪的作法因為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/570.wav", + "text": "你叫他做了專報你們是要尊重專報" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/571.wav", + "text": "的結論還是你" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/572.wav", + "text": "又有不同意見我覺得還是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/573.wav", + "text": "回到我們立法委員自己的職權" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/574.wav", + "text": "是哪個委員會適合放這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/575.wav", + "text": "如果各位對專報有意見想瞭解" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/576.wav", + "text": "行政院的立場那就在你們總質詢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/577.wav", + "text": "的時間去詢問行政院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/578.wav", + "text": "院長各位同仁" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/579.wav", + "text": "是要9月20日還是9月23日" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/580.wav", + "text": "在這一個點上但是我" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/581.wav", + "text": "聽來聽去理由" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/582.wav", + "text": "只是因為有一些委員在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/583.wav", + "text": "國外但是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/584.wav", + "text": "基本上回來之後就" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/585.wav", + "text": "像剛剛羅致政委員講的他們回來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/586.wav", + "text": "之後要隔離" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/587.wav", + "text": "忘記事實上我們有視訊設備" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/588.wav", + "text": "不然我們要視訊設備幹嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/589.wav", + "text": "所以用視訊設備" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/590.wav", + "text": "也可以處理這個問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/591.wav", + "text": "這個差" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/592.wav", + "text": "假設9月20日開議之後有禮拜三" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/593.wav", + "text": "及禮拜四的委員會如果9" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/594.wav", + "text": "就不會有禮拜三禮拜四" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/595.wav", + "text": "的委員會就到下一週" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/596.wav", + "text": "才會開始所以重點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/597.wav", + "text": "我覺得柯總召的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/598.wav", + "text": "因為基本上國會存在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/599.wav", + "text": "的目的本身就是監督" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/600.wav", + "text": "所以執政黨想要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/601.wav", + "text": "儘量去推遲" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/602.wav", + "text": "不是說可以理解啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/603.wav", + "text": "基本上我當然是反對這個作法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/604.wav", + "text": "我在上禮拜的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/605.wav", + "text": "就跟院長講我" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/606.wav", + "text": "意思你你讓我講一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/607.wav", + "text": "\n因為我上禮拜的時候就跟" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/608.wav", + "text": "院長講談話會是不是可以早一點開" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/609.wav", + "text": "我看了之後我覺得滿難過的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/610.wav", + "text": "我陪著候選人在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/611.wav", + "text": "開學了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/612.wav", + "text": "過了一個暑假之後小學都已經開學" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/613.wav", + "text": "納稅人的血汗錢結果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/614.wav", + "text": "在這個基礎上面我會覺得9" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/615.wav", + "text": "開議事實上已經" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/616.wav", + "text": "推遲太久太久了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/617.wav", + "text": "因為憲法是規定9月1日" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/618.wav", + "text": "日就應該報到報到之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/619.wav", + "text": "就要想辦法趕快開議\n" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/620.wav", + "text": "\n最後我要再講一點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/621.wav", + "text": "我真的覺得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/622.wav", + "text": "像剛剛柯總召就講到法案分三大類" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/623.wav", + "text": "我們講一點就好了就像" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/624.wav", + "text": "風火火地說現在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/625.wav", + "text": "的房價高不可攀" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/626.wav", + "text": "請問這個會期要不要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/627.wav", + "text": "讓它通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/628.wav", + "text": "建商這些亂七八糟的說法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/629.wav", + "text": "什麼叫做在這樣的狀況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/630.wav", + "text": "之下會變成硬著陸" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/631.wav", + "text": "講這種話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/632.wav", + "text": "臺灣的房價高不可攀但大家知道嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/633.wav", + "text": "今年臺灣的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/634.wav", + "text": "出生率已經到13萬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/635.wav", + "text": "人了都" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/636.wav", + "text": "已經是破紀錄" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/637.wav", + "text": "在這種狀況之下居然還在那邊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/638.wav", + "text": "你不要扯到我身上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/639.wav", + "text": "我在講話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/640.wav", + "text": "這是場講道理的比賽" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/641.wav", + "text": "不是講話大聲就贏" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/642.wav", + "text": "你你公然恐嚇" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/643.wav", + "text": "什麼叫做講話小心一點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/644.wav", + "text": "什麼叫做講話小心一點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/645.wav", + "text": "大家評評理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/646.wav", + "text": "全國老百姓也可以評評理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/647.wav", + "text": "一個執政黨黨團的總召" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/648.wav", + "text": "可以公然恐嚇" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/649.wav", + "text": "在野黨黨團的總召嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/650.wav", + "text": "應該有的做法嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/651.wav", + "text": "什麼叫做小心一點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/652.wav", + "text": "臺灣民主30年" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/653.wav", + "text": "民進黨黨團的總召" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/654.wav", + "text": "比過去我們反對的國民黨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/655.wav", + "text": "難道小黨不能在議會裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/656.wav", + "text": "什麼叫做你講話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/657.wav", + "text": "要小心一點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/658.wav", + "text": "我今天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/659.wav", + "text": "是在外" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/660.wav", + "text": "國民兩黨在反對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/661.wav", + "text": "是行政院通過送到立法院的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/662.wav", + "text": "我今天在講這件事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/663.wav", + "text": "的是有很多事情要處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/664.wav", + "text": "有很多事情要處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/665.wav", + "text": "9月20日開議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/666.wav", + "text": "就可以進入真正的委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/667.wav", + "text": "不然到你發言的時" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/668.wav", + "text": "啊我現在要講的是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/669.wav", + "text": "差異就在這個地方" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/670.wav", + "text": "並不是沒有事情要處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/671.wav", + "text": "這樣才是一個比較負責任的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/672.wav", + "text": "態度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/673.wav", + "text": "儘快開議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/674.wav", + "text": "23日開議覺得莫名奇妙" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/675.wav", + "text": "23日開議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/676.wav", + "text": "雖然我不同意但我可以理解" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/677.wav", + "text": "可是國民黨主張" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/678.wav", + "text": "23日開議去唱和民進黨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/679.wav", + "text": "現在這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/680.wav", + "text": "好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/681.wav", + "text": "如果如果你要講我會尊重" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/682.wav", + "text": "進入程序比較重要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/683.wav", + "text": "不用你講我們沒關係" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/684.wav", + "text": "剛剛曾銘宗總召的說法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/685.wav", + "text": "攻防會有一個過程" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/686.wav", + "text": "你剛剛講到了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/687.wav", + "text": "有關國營事業預算的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/688.wav", + "text": "老實說如果按照以前的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/689.wav", + "text": "臨時會就可以解決" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/690.wav", + "text": "了還可以包括平均地權條例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/691.wav", + "text": "但問題是大家別忘了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/692.wav", + "text": "當初說5月31日休會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/693.wav", + "text": "是大家朝野之間共同的決定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/694.wav", + "text": "也就是說這個法案沒有繼續審" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/695.wav", + "text": "其實是大家都已經說好的就不用再追究" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/696.wav", + "text": "了這一點是我要先回應你的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/697.wav", + "text": "第二個我也回應一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/698.wav", + "text": "日期上提早看起來大家好像很認真" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/699.wav", + "text": "但如果要討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/700.wav", + "text": "時間的充分程度" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/701.wav", + "text": "其實除了日期之外" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/702.wav", + "text": "還有時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/703.wav", + "text": "只要開議之後大家充分討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/704.wav", + "text": "離開散會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/705.wav", + "text": "然後回去跑攤那沒有意義嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/706.wav", + "text": "這種日期提早有什麼意義沒有意義" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/707.wav", + "text": "啊應該是在會期當中很認真地審議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/708.wav", + "text": "才是關鍵" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/709.wav", + "text": "\n再拉回來說李德維委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/710.wav", + "text": "剛剛已經講得非常清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/711.wav", + "text": "大家從報章媒體上已經約略得知" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/712.wav", + "text": "是9月23日好像有透露出這個時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/713.wav", + "text": "剛剛曾總召也沒有反對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/714.wav", + "text": "嘛因為依照以前的慣例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/715.wav", + "text": "預算會期大部分都是中下旬為主" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/716.wav", + "text": "大家可以理解這個時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/717.wav", + "text": "又是選舉會期" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/718.wav", + "text": "我覺得不要在這種程序上做那麼多爭執" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/719.wav", + "text": "如同主席所說的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/720.wav", + "text": "是程序問題這個時間先訂下來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/721.wav", + "text": "其他的意見大家朝野協商的時候再好好來談" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/722.wav", + "text": "請鄭衣鳯委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/723.wav", + "text": "我不是鄭衣鳯" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/724.wav", + "text": "謝衣鳯委員抱歉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/725.wav", + "text": "院長要道歉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/726.wav", + "text": "抱歉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/727.wav", + "text": "我姓謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/728.wav", + "text": "非常同意邱總召所說的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/729.wav", + "text": "我們因為疫情的關係" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/730.wav", + "text": "休會都沒有加開" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/731.wav", + "text": "臨時會其實所有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/732.wav", + "text": "的委員都希望" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/733.wav", + "text": "回到立法院來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/734.wav", + "text": "監督目前行政院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/735.wav", + "text": "以及在很多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/736.wav", + "text": "國內的民生議題上面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/737.wav", + "text": "給民眾非常" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/738.wav", + "text": "不好的觀感所以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/739.wav", + "text": "原則上當然是越快越好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/740.wav", + "text": "希望儘快地協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/741.wav", + "text": "但是大家不要忽略" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/742.wav", + "text": "尤其是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/743.wav", + "text": "昨天美國國會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/744.wav", + "text": "通過臺灣政策法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/745.wav", + "text": "出了他們的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/746.wav", + "text": "外交委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/747.wav", + "text": "本來我們也不應該為了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/748.wav", + "text": "任何一個訪團" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/749.wav", + "text": "而耽誤我們開會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/750.wav", + "text": "的時間但是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/751.wav", + "text": "我們的外交委員會現在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/752.wav", + "text": "到美國去參訪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/753.wav", + "text": "我覺得我們是不是應該" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/754.wav", + "text": "等他們回來尤其在現在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/755.wav", + "text": "國際情勢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/756.wav", + "text": "非常嚴重的情況下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/757.wav", + "text": "內政以外我們是不是也應該" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/758.wav", + "text": "這些臺灣外交" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/759.wav", + "text": "上面的需求" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/760.wav", + "text": "我覺得等他們一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/761.wav", + "text": "是可以的等到23日" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/762.wav", + "text": "這個應該是大家可以接受" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/763.wav", + "text": "的時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/764.wav", + "text": "\n同時我也必須在這裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/765.wav", + "text": "反對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/766.wav", + "text": "邱總召" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/767.wav", + "text": "所講的你可以罵" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/768.wav", + "text": "柯總召沒有問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/769.wav", + "text": "可是曾總召" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/770.wav", + "text": "在打房上面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/771.wav", + "text": "他的房地合一稅" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/772.wav", + "text": "是比行政院還嚴苛的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/773.wav", + "text": "所以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/774.wav", + "text": "怎麼會說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/775.wav", + "text": "他在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/776.wav", + "text": "一起呼應那些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/777.wav", + "text": "房地產業者呢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/778.wav", + "text": "我相信" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/779.wav", + "text": "國民黨是在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/780.wav", + "text": "看臺灣的經濟趨勢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/781.wav", + "text": "通膨嚴重的情況下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/782.wav", + "text": "房價會不會上漲" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/783.wav", + "text": "是不是造成房價高居不下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/784.wav", + "text": "以及目前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/785.wav", + "text": "因為缺工" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/786.wav", + "text": "建築成本上升的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/787.wav", + "text": "會不會讓整體" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/788.wav", + "text": "經濟產生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/789.wav", + "text": "減緩的效果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/790.wav", + "text": "身為立法院監督" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/791.wav", + "text": "非常需要去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/792.wav", + "text": "關注臺灣經濟" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/793.wav", + "text": "未來的成長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/794.wav", + "text": "會不會因為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/795.wav", + "text": "疫情導致" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/796.wav", + "text": "這些相關的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/797.wav", + "text": "問題畢竟通膨及" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/798.wav", + "text": "房價等等都有正負效益的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/799.wav", + "text": "要怎麼樣密切觀察" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/800.wav", + "text": "來把關的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/801.wav", + "text": "我們國民黨團" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/802.wav", + "text": "絕對非常支持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/803.wav", + "text": "越早開議越好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/804.wav", + "text": "只是因為目前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/805.wav", + "text": "我再堅持第二點邱" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/806.wav", + "text": "邱總召你可以打柯總召" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/807.wav", + "text": "但是不要打國民黨團" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/808.wav", + "text": "的曾總召" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/809.wav", + "text": "我們絕對是打房的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/810.wav", + "text": "我很尊敬" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/811.wav", + "text": "我很尊敬你" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/812.wav", + "text": "但是你今天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/813.wav", + "text": "你們的同仁王婉諭也在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/814.wav", + "text": "國外啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/815.wav", + "text": "我等一下跟你講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/816.wav", + "text": "有些視訊不能做的事" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/817.wav", + "text": "所以我的意思是國民黨的立場" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/818.wav", + "text": "是這樣子然後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/819.wav", + "text": "你說我們有意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/820.wav", + "text": "跟民進黨一樣說我們莫名其妙" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/821.wav", + "text": "顯智你才莫名其妙" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/822.wav", + "text": "這是第一點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/823.wav", + "text": "\n第二點有關平均地權條例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/824.wav", + "text": "你看報導" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/825.wav", + "text": "導要看全文啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/826.wav", + "text": "我說大方向支持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/827.wav", + "text": "囤房稅是本人提的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/828.wav", + "text": "財政部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/829.wav", + "text": "也不推喔" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/830.wav", + "text": "比你們的版本還好啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/831.wav", + "text": "這個時候要不要推" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/832.wav", + "text": "平均地權條例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/833.wav", + "text": "我的立場是大方向贊成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/834.wav", + "text": "但是執政黨是誰" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/835.wav", + "text": "是民進黨啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/836.wav", + "text": "條例要不要過掌握在誰手上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/837.wav", + "text": "柯總召手上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/838.wav", + "text": "我再講一次在立法院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/839.wav", + "text": "柯總召想過的法案有哪個過不了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/840.wav", + "text": "會計法第99條之1" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/841.wav", + "text": "就強行通過啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/842.wav", + "text": "那是你自己後來退了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/843.wav", + "text": "更何況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/844.wav", + "text": "你仔細聽" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/845.wav", + "text": "我也贊成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/846.wav", + "text": "四波的選擇性信用管制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/847.wav", + "text": "還有升息" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/848.wav", + "text": "價也相對平穩了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/849.wav", + "text": "我相信" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/850.wav", + "text": "財政部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/851.wav", + "text": "但你不能夠意見不一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/852.wav", + "text": "就罵人家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/853.wav", + "text": "\n何況你沒有把我們國民黨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/854.wav", + "text": "團的全體意見看清楚啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/855.wav", + "text": "我再講一次我大方向支持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/856.wav", + "text": "但是你" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/857.wav", + "text": "這一波一直升息" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/858.wav", + "text": "尤其是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/859.wav", + "text": "首次購屋的青年朋友" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/860.wav", + "text": "你也要顧慮到他的立場" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/861.wav", + "text": "所以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/862.wav", + "text": "我的立場是大方向支持但" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/863.wav", + "text": "但最後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/864.wav", + "text": "我的建議是請柯總召拿出" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/865.wav", + "text": "最後的決定顯" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/866.wav", + "text": "智你竟然攻擊我們國民黨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/867.wav", + "text": "謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/868.wav", + "text": "我們還是回到今天協商的主軸" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/869.wav", + "text": "就是很簡單的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/870.wav", + "text": "開議日期" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/871.wav", + "text": "不要變成一個政策立場或政治立場的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/872.wav", + "text": "核心就是920和923差別在哪裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/873.wav", + "text": "談的看起來沒問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/874.wav", + "text": "但事實上問題很大" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/875.wav", + "text": "因為920開議除了有視訊能不能進行的問題之外" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/876.wav", + "text": "選舉辦法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/877.wav", + "text": "規定第二會期的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/878.wav", + "text": "是開議日的次日要編定召委" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/879.wav", + "text": "在兩日內就要進行召委選舉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/880.wav", + "text": "換句話說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/881.wav", + "text": "如果920開會的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/882.wav", + "text": "922就要選召委" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/883.wav", + "text": "但今天很多委員都還沒出關喔" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/884.wav", + "text": "我們知道投票是秘密投票" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/885.wav", + "text": "這些在外面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/886.wav", + "text": "要怎麼投票" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/887.wav", + "text": "所以如果是923開議的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/888.wav", + "text": "到928才會有所謂" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/889.wav", + "text": "選召委的事情如果是920開議的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/890.wav", + "text": "922就要選召委" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/891.wav", + "text": "這是法律的規定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/892.wav", + "text": "我們要怎麼克服這個問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/893.wav", + "text": "\n所以我還是回到一個現實面和技術面的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/894.wav", + "text": "我們認為923還是比較可行如果要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/895.wav", + "text": "920" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/896.wav", + "text": "開議姑且不論早點開可能表示我們比較認真" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/897.wav", + "text": "或好像我們沒有辜負我們的責任" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/898.wav", + "text": "跟美方的國會議員進行溝通" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/899.wav", + "text": "以及另一位邱總召" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/900.wav", + "text": "三位講完後就不要再講了好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/901.wav", + "text": "因為有的人重複" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/902.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/903.wav", + "text": "剛好四個總召" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/904.wav", + "text": "我們就做決定這樣好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/905.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/906.wav", + "text": "我現在回應一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/907.wav", + "text": "曾總召" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/908.wav", + "text": "但我是在討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/909.wav", + "text": "持平來說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/910.wav", + "text": "跟柯總召講的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/911.wav", + "text": "我才會這樣講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/912.wav", + "text": "是不是已經都在對平均地權條例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/913.wav", + "text": "打預防針" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/914.wav", + "text": "我用1分鐘講一下你講什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/915.wav", + "text": "不管是政府產業" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/916.wav", + "text": "還是一般民眾都不希望房" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/917.wav", + "text": "市硬著陸" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/918.wav", + "text": "在此關鍵時刻是否推動" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/919.wav", + "text": "管制力道很強的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/920.wav", + "text": "平均地權條例修法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/921.wav", + "text": "可以再考慮" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/922.wav", + "text": "國民黨召委不會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/923.wav", + "text": "你是這麼說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/924.wav", + "text": "我也要把柯總召講的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/925.wav", + "text": "唸一次柯總召都不會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/926.wav", + "text": "叫我道歉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/927.wav", + "text": "因為他知道我在跟他做政策的辯論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/928.wav", + "text": "接著要進入" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/929.wav", + "text": "大選現在時機" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/930.wav", + "text": "還不適合談這個議題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/931.wav", + "text": "這個議題關係重大" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/932.wav", + "text": "黨內難有共識" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/933.wav", + "text": "那我要講的是什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/934.wav", + "text": "現在房價高不可攀" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/935.wav", + "text": "行政院真的推出" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/936.wav", + "text": "內政部推出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/937.wav", + "text": "之後打了一個折" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/938.wav", + "text": "還是推出來了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/939.wav", + "text": "對不對現在我們最重要的事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/940.wav", + "text": "新北議員候選人彭盛韶的圖裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/941.wav", + "text": "截出來的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/942.wav", + "text": "我一句一句去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/943.wav", + "text": "唸既然最後你們的態度是這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/944.wav", + "text": "到底我們要怎麼對國人交代" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/945.wav", + "text": "那個是舊消息我還有新的講法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/946.wav", + "text": "所以你要update" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/947.wav", + "text": "民眾黨黨團表達一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/948.wav", + "text": "我們知道國會外交非常" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/949.wav", + "text": "重要現在國際情勢包含" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/950.wav", + "text": "臺美關係非常至關重要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/951.wav", + "text": "一直認為要提早開議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/952.wav", + "text": "這是我們的原則所以剛剛謝衣鳯委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/953.wav", + "text": "談到的我們基本上也認同" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/954.wav", + "text": "甚至是第3個禮拜就開議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/955.wav", + "text": "沒想到這樣還被特定媒體攻擊了一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/956.wav", + "text": "我在這邊澄清" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/957.wav", + "text": "我們還是希望可以提早開議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/958.wav", + "text": "認為9月23日比較" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/959.wav", + "text": "要考慮到其他委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/960.wav", + "text": "原則上這個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/961.wav", + "text": "我們尊重大家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/962.wav", + "text": "但是針對數位發展部的專報" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/963.wav", + "text": "民眾黨黨團還是堅持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/964.wav", + "text": "前提是朝野協商一定要展開" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/965.wav", + "text": "專報也一定要展開" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/966.wav", + "text": "服務法引起社會反彈之外" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/967.wav", + "text": "當時在立法院已經審查完成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/968.wav", + "text": "相關立法程序但是不管它" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/969.wav", + "text": "它的員額預算還是它的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/970.wav", + "text": "任務甚至是唐鳳部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/971.wav", + "text": "對外發表的一些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/972.wav", + "text": "大部分的民眾是聽不懂的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/973.wav", + "text": "包含多元宇宙科民主" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/974.wav", + "text": "網路司不要說一般" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/975.wav", + "text": "民眾聽不懂可能連立法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/976.wav", + "text": "委員跟他溝通講白一點都" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/977.wav", + "text": "得霧煞煞\n如果執政黨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/978.wav", + "text": "發展現在除了產業發展" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/979.wav", + "text": "國安提升國民數位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/980.wav", + "text": "部會的如果你們認為這是一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/981.wav", + "text": "非常重要的政策跟" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/982.wav", + "text": "應該要把態度表現出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/983.wav", + "text": "就讓蘇院長唐鳳部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/984.wav", + "text": "到立法院講清楚說明白" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/985.wav", + "text": "好地針對這個議題進行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/986.wav", + "text": "更清楚也趁此機會讓行政院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/987.wav", + "text": "人民講清楚說明白" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/988.wav", + "text": "所以這個部分我們堅持希望" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/989.wav", + "text": "以上謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/990.wav", + "text": "聽了一輪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/991.wav", + "text": "今天不要談法案內容" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/992.wav", + "text": "任何法案內容在這裡講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/993.wav", + "text": "一天都講不完" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/994.wav", + "text": "也不會正式進入程序性的協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/995.wav", + "text": "的邱臣遠委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/996.wav", + "text": "要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/997.wav", + "text": "持平而論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/998.wav", + "text": "開議之後各部會首長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/999.wav", + "text": "都要進行業務報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/1000.wav", + "text": "好好去問" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/1001.wav", + "text": "唐部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/1002.wav", + "text": "但不會在行政院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/1003.wav", + "text": "行一個部會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/1004.wav", + "text": "的各位這早在上個會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/1005.wav", + "text": "期就討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/1006.wav", + "text": "包��約聘僱人員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/1007.wav", + "text": "我記得那時候謝衣鳯委員有提一個法案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/1008.wav", + "text": "可以有一半" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/1009.wav", + "text": "一部二署" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/1010.wav", + "text": "和謝衣鳯委員的主張都是可以一半" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/1011.wav", + "text": "反而是更多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/1012.wav", + "text": "分我不主張" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/1013.wav", + "text": "今天大家好不容易對23日有共識不" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/1014.wav", + "text": "不要再橫生枝節" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/1015.wav", + "text": "要先有專案報" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/1016.wav", + "text": "掛牌了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/1017.wav", + "text": "都一起通過了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/1018.wav", + "text": "這是第一點\n" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/1019.wav", + "text": "時代力量的立場常常" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/1020.wav", + "text": "沒關係" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/1021.wav", + "text": "迴力鏢是會回到你身上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/1022.wav", + "text": "的這一點我們要講清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/1023.wav", + "text": "有關平均地權條例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/1024.wav", + "text": "我知道你一早就召" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/1025.wav", + "text": "這個我都能體會但不必常常演這種戲" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/1026.wav", + "text": "我都尊重" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/1027.wav", + "text": "像今天謝衣鳯委員就講得很好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/1028.wav", + "text": "他認為23日開議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/1029.wav", + "text": "銘宗也講得很理性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/1030.wav", + "text": "這個法是要經過大家討論不是我不" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/1031.wav", + "text": "很多過程" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/1032.wav", + "text": "各部會也都要參與" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/1033.wav", + "text": "整個國際政治形勢變化" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/1034.wav", + "text": "大家都知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/1035.wav", + "text": "這個不是拿來作秀的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/1036.wav", + "text": "是非常實際的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/1037.wav", + "text": "選舉一到我知道時代力量就搞這一條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/1038.wav", + "text": "天天都在打那個議題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/1039.wav", + "text": "這樣時代力量才會長大" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/1040.wav", + "text": "如果要罵我" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/1041.wav", + "text": "迴力鏢會回到你身上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/1042.wav", + "text": "溝通" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/1043.wav", + "text": "銘宗委員提到兩個條件" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/1044.wav", + "text": "曾銘宗很喜歡叫人家道歉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/1045.wav", + "text": "剛才叫你道歉也叫我道歉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/1046.wav", + "text": "曾委員我跟你講很抱歉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/1047.wav", + "text": "我們立場上一定要這樣做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/1048.wav", + "text": "很抱歉我們立場上一定要這樣做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/1049.wav", + "text": "大家都有政治立場" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/1050.wav", + "text": "打架也打完了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/1051.wav", + "text": "我們前���未來比較重要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/1052.wav", + "text": "就是整個疫苗採購完畢後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/1053.wav", + "text": "要到財政及衛環委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/1054.wav", + "text": "進行專案報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/1055.wav", + "text": "那就排啊沒有關係我們就面對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/1056.wav", + "text": "但這麼久都沒有排我不知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/1057.wav", + "text": "是不是採購完畢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/1058.wav", + "text": "了召委有權就可以排會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/1059.wav", + "text": "我們都尊重" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/1060.wav", + "text": "沒有一個人能夠閃躲任何議題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/1061.wav", + "text": "只是大家立場的表現" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/1062.wav", + "text": "29日委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/1063.wav", + "text": "就開始了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/1064.wav", + "text": "我們要拜託大家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/1065.wav", + "text": "總預算的付委" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/1066.wav", + "text": "我們全部把它" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/1067.wav", + "text": "議接下去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/1068.wav", + "text": "9月30日" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/1069.wav", + "text": "前瞻4" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/1070.wav", + "text": "因為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/1071.wav", + "text": "29日財政委員會開始" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/1072.wav", + "text": "曾銘宗在財政委員會所以知" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/1073.wav", + "text": "總預算什麼時候付委" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/1074.wav", + "text": "等財政委員會排出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/1075.wav", + "text": "即總預算審查日程弄出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/1076.wav", + "text": "10月4日" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/1077.wav", + "text": "期二讓總預算付委" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/1078.wav", + "text": "這些都照程序來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/1079.wav", + "text": "30日我們來排前瞻4期" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/1080.wav", + "text": "10月4日我們排" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/1081.wav", + "text": "總預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/1082.wav", + "text": "委至於" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/1083.wav", + "text": "警械使用條例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/1084.wav", + "text": "及國營事業" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/1085.wav", + "text": "我們把警械使用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/1086.wav", + "text": "質詢下午切個時間來處理警械使用條例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/1087.wav", + "text": "及國營事業預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/1088.wav", + "text": "如果中間要協" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/1089.wav", + "text": "商下禮拜可請院長來協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/1090.wav", + "text": "前瞻4期付委" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/1091.wav", + "text": "10月4日總預算付委" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/1092.wav", + "text": "這樣立法院就能走" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/1093.wav", + "text": "我也尊重" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/1094.wav", + "text": "有些召委" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/1095.wav", + "text": "一定會先排業務報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/1096.wav", + "text": "有人則會排法案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/1097.wav", + "text": "全部排總預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/1098.wav", + "text": "歷年來的總預算審查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/1099.wav", + "text": "當然都要拜託國民黨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/1100.wav", + "text": "他們常常" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/1101.wav", + "text": "因選舉會有一些專案報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/1102.wav", + "text": "我們都尊重" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/1103.wav", + "text": "是不是可以這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/1104.wav", + "text": "柯總召的建議大家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/1105.wav", + "text": "有沒有不同的意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/1106.wav", + "text": "我有幾個想法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/1107.wav", + "text": "好朋友" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/1108.wav", + "text": "你當場攻擊我" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/1109.wav", + "text": "就沒有私交的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/1110.wav", + "text": "何況你拿的資料是舊的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/1111.wav", + "text": "這是你講過的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/1112.wav", + "text": "一句一字都是你講過的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/1113.wav", + "text": "你聽我講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/1114.wav", + "text": "你可能不知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/1115.wav", + "text": "經濟" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/1116.wav", + "text": "是動態的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/1117.wav", + "text": "經濟是非常動態" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/1118.wav", + "text": "的你不能" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/1119.wav", + "text": "拿清朝的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/1120.wav", + "text": "明朝的官" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/1121.wav", + "text": "啊你可能不清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/1122.wav", + "text": "對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/1123.wav", + "text": "美國又升息了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/1124.wav", + "text": "所以這種東西是動態的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/1125.wav", + "text": "你不能拿舊的資料" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/1126.wav", + "text": "而我最新的講法是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/1127.wav", + "text": "內政部經濟部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/1128.wav", + "text": "因此不能拿舊的想法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/1129.wav", + "text": "尤其你有你的想法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/1130.wav", + "text": "要不然你讓我講我就攻擊你" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/1131.wav", + "text": "這樣不好嘛你要論述" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/1132.wav", + "text": "是可以的但是不要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/1133.wav", + "text": "點名" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/1134.wav", + "text": "你們要監督民進黨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/1135.wav", + "text": "總召這件事情是這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/1136.wav", + "text": "你剛剛講的囤房稅" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/1137.wav", + "text": "等等之類" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/1138.wav", + "text": "我們也跟你表示過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/1139.wav", + "text": "財政部行政院能夠推出" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/1140.wav", + "text": "一個囤房稅的條例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/1141.wav", + "text": "民進黨的很多委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/1142.wav", + "text": "我把" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/1143.wav", + "text": "完現在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/1144.wav", + "text": "行政院好不容易" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/1145.wav", + "text": "為什麼我今天要在這邊講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/1146.wav", + "text": "國民黨不會主動" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/1147.wav", + "text": "去排" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/1148.wav", + "text": "這個法案這時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/1149.wav", + "text": "要怎麼辦也許人家想排" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/1150.wav", + "text": "是說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/1151.wav", + "text": "你怎麼會知道我們內部決策" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/1152.wav", + "text": "對所以我會想說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/1153.wav", + "text": "是真的要支持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/1154.wav", + "text": "居住正義" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/1155.wav", + "text": "回到程序問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/1156.wav", + "text": "那我也可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/1157.wav", + "text": "邱顯智每講一句話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/1158.wav", + "text": "我都放大" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/1159.wav", + "text": "我每次都跟你談" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/1160.wav", + "text": "我是這樣講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/1161.wav", + "text": "我做為一個政治人物" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/1162.wav", + "text": "我本來就應該要受到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/1163.wav", + "text": "最嚴厲的檢驗和批判" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/1164.wav", + "text": "同樣的道理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/1165.wav", + "text": "我剛剛在監督不然他怎麼會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/1166.wav", + "text": "叫我小心一點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/1167.wav", + "text": "黃國昌上身好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/1168.wav", + "text": "我不會跟你搞這一套" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/1169.wav", + "text": "硬著陸你應該要請教他" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/1170.wav", + "text": "房市硬著陸的解釋" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/1171.wav", + "text": "這個總質詢再去問" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/1172.wav", + "text": "院長我再講一" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/1173.wav", + "text": "大家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/1174.wav", + "text": "應該要跟柯總" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/1175.wav", + "text": "大家剛才都同意回到程序" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/1176.wav", + "text": "好休息5分鐘" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/1177.wav", + "text": "我還沒講完柯總召剛剛講的幾件事情我要請教一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/1178.wav", + "text": "院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/1179.wav", + "text": "外界有在問" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/1180.wav", + "text": "11月26日選舉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/1181.wav", + "text": "之前要不要休會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/1182.wav", + "text": "這要再召開一次協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/1183.wav", + "text": "這牽涉到議程要怎麼排" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/1184.wav", + "text": "慣例應該是沒有啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/1185.wav", + "text": "有還是沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/1186.wav", + "text": "有還是沒有要講清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/1187.wav", + "text": "曾經有也曾經沒有沒" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/1188.wav", + "text": "不用這麼前瞻啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/1189.wav", + "text": "另外" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/1190.wav", + "text": "我剛剛提到兩個條件" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/1191.wav", + "text": "我接受" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/1192.wav", + "text": "將會議紀錄送來但你們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/1193.wav", + "text": "到現在都不送它" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/1194.wav", + "text": "它封存10年20年30年的機密" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/1195.wav", + "text": "這是什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/1196.wav", + "text": "這是所有的疫苗全數" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/1197.wav", + "text": "認真一點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/1198.wav", + "text": "該類疫苗" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/1199.wav", + "text": "該類疫苗" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/1200.wav", + "text": "該類" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/1201.wav", + "text": "不是全部沒" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/1202.wav", + "text": "該類疫苗" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/1203.wav", + "text": "它的結論就是重點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/1204.wav", + "text": "立法院財政委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/1205.wav", + "text": "備查嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/1206.wav", + "text": "結論是什麼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/1207.wav", + "text": "這個是假的啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/1208.wav", + "text": "什麼假的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/1209.wav", + "text": "這已經通過了除非" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/1210.wav", + "text": "沒關係議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/1211.wav", + "text": "至於講的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/1212.wav", + "text": "那些專報我們就照" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/1213.wav", + "text": "決議怎麼樣就怎麼做隨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/1214.wav", + "text": "說要處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/1215.wav", + "text": "111年度營業及非營業的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/1216.wav", + "text": "我們就審議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/1217.wav", + "text": "OK好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/1218.wav", + "text": "沒問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/1219.wav", + "text": "這樣好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/1220.wav", + "text": "曾銘宗委員所提要專報要什麼資料" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/1221.wav", + "text": "該怎麼樣就怎麼樣處理好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/1222.wav", + "text": "然後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/1223.wav", + "text": "或是9月30日也可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/1224.wav", + "text": "半天就夠了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/1225.wav", + "text": "警械使用條例及" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/1226.wav", + "text": "111年度國營事業預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/1227.wav", + "text": "因為我們沒有共識就撤掉了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/1228.wav", + "text": "搞不好有幾百項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/1229.wav", + "text": "還原就好了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/1230.wav", + "text": "回到原狀就好了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/1231.wav", + "text": "我們好不容易協商了一兩個禮拜" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/1232.wav", + "text": "這個東西細節再談" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/1233.wav", + "text": "先把時間排出來好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/1234.wav", + "text": "沒有那個半天" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/1235.wav", + "text": "詢9月30日下午" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/1236.wav", + "text": "國營事業預算及警械使用條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/1237.wav", + "text": "例有時間再協商你" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/1238.wav", + "text": "出來我們再協商沒有關係" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/1239.wav", + "text": "10月4日及10月7日" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/1240.wav", + "text": "日總預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/1241.wav", + "text": "及前瞻4期預算一起報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/1242.wav", + "text": "上次就是這樣一起報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/1243.wav", + "text": "做一次報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/1244.wav", + "text": "各一天啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/1245.wav", + "text": "院長一起報告完畢" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/1246.wav", + "text": "然後先進行總預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/1247.wav", + "text": "接下來就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/1248.wav", + "text": "因為蘇建榮部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/1249.wav", + "text": "所以總預算可能要到4日" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/1250.wav", + "text": "這樣好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/1251.wav", + "text": "23日開議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/1252.wav", + "text": "30日下午" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/1253.wav", + "text": "國營事業預算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/1254.wav", + "text": "這兩天一天處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/1255.wav", + "text": "總預算一天處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/1256.wav", + "text": "做報告時一併報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/1257.wav", + "text": "上次就是如此" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/1258.wav", + "text": "4日兩個一起報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/1259.wav", + "text": "針對數發部的專報" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/1260.wav", + "text": "原則上我們認為至少要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/1261.wav", + "text": "要下次安排時間請院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/1262.wav", + "text": "要把這個納進去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/1263.wav", + "text": "到現場來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/1264.wav", + "text": "院長不好意思" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/1265.wav", + "text": "一句話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/1266.wav", + "text": "剛剛有聽到曾總召提到有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/1267.wav", + "text": "關地方選舉前的休會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/1268.wav", + "text": "還是院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/1269.wav", + "text": "我是要表示地方選舉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/1270.wav", + "text": "應該是立委" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/1271.wav", + "text": "我們今天才開始" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/1272.wav", + "text": "就要講什麼時候休息不好啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/1273.wav", + "text": "邱顯智總召你那邊有沒" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/1274.wav", + "text": "有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/1275.wav", + "text": "我現在是不是可以唸了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/1276.wav", + "text": "我唸一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/1277.wav", + "text": "沒有邊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/1278.wav", + "text": "下個禮拜或者找一個時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/1279.wav", + "text": "可能要找他們來協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/1280.wav", + "text": "協商後再決定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/1281.wav", + "text": "直接把時間訂下來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/1282.wav", + "text": "這次就寫進去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/1283.wav", + "text": "下禮拜擇期協商數發部何去何從" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/1284.wav", + "text": "但是你想要邀請部會首長來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/1285.wav", + "text": "他們不好意思表示意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/1286.wav", + "text": "這是立法院的權責" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/1287.wav", + "text": "我們自己協商就好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/1288.wav", + "text": "協商是我們立法院" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/1289.wav", + "text": "你們建議什麼時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/1290.wav", + "text": "下禮拜三或下禮拜二都可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/1291.wav", + "text": "中午來一下就好了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/1292.wav", + "text": "我講實情啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/1293.wav", + "text": "禮拜三早上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/1294.wav", + "text": "苗栗競選總部成立" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/1295.wav", + "text": "數位發展部何去何從" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/1296.wav", + "text": "情歸何處" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/1297.wav", + "text": "我們就確定禮" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/1298.wav", + "text": "拜二不過我覺得還是要請他們來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/1299.wav", + "text": "如果有問題的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/1300.wav", + "text": "就可以問他" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/1301.wav", + "text": "是9月20日還是9月27" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/1302.wav", + "text": "9月20日" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/1303.wav", + "text": "但是我們還是要邀請數發部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/1304.wav", + "text": "但是我們有問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/1305.wav", + "text": "要問他兩" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/1306.wav", + "text": "但是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/1307.wav", + "text": "我們要求數發部唐鳳部長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/1308.wav", + "text": "這個要寫進去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/1309.wav", + "text": "另外" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/1310.wav", + "text": "9月30日" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/1311.wav", + "text": "使用條例列進去我沒有意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/1312.wav", + "text": "但是因為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/1313.wav", + "text": "今年度的營業非營業" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/1314.wav", + "text": "要落實" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/1315.wav", + "text": "這個先刪掉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/1316.wav", + "text": "不他表示不算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/1317.wav", + "text": "我們要看到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/1318.wav", + "text": "衛福部把資料會議紀錄送到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/1319.wav", + "text": "我們要看到資料" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/1320.wav", + "text": "你放心啦你只要履行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/1321.wav", + "text": "我講話算話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/1322.wav", + "text": "我知道下禮拜你們蔣萬安要去告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/1323.wav", + "text": "就是配合你們一些動作" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/1324.wav", + "text": "沒有沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/1325.wav", + "text": "這個先拿掉你只要履行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/1326.wav", + "text": "我半夜都跟你協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/1327.wav", + "text": "好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/1328.wav", + "text": "只有留下警械使用條例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/1329.wav", + "text": "我們立法院的權責" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/1330.wav", + "text": "是權利也是義務" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/1331.wav", + "text": "我們必須" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/1332.wav", + "text": "講話算話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/1333.wav", + "text": "好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/1334.wav", + "text": "另外" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/1335.wav", + "text": "等一下我講清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/1336.wav", + "text": "就能馬上處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/1337.wav", + "text": "了即便切一個院會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/1338.wav", + "text": "好沒有問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/1339.wav", + "text": "我配合你" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/1340.wav", + "text": "洗澡洗一半也要跳出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/1341.wav", + "text": "10月7日" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/1342.wav", + "text": "前瞻對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/1343.wav", + "text": "你們是11個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/1344.wav", + "text": "我們是7個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/1345.wav", + "text": "怎麼差這麼多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/1346.wav", + "text": "你們就執政黨" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/1347.wav", + "text": "好嗎" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/1348.wav", + "text": "我們給" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/1349.wav", + "text": "差不多啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/1350.wav", + "text": "沒有關係啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/1351.wav", + "text": "好啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/1352.wav", + "text": "這樣我就不用唸了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/1353.wav", + "text": "你們現在都看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/1354.wav", + "text": "要加上一個數發部9月20日" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/1355.wav", + "text": "朝野協商是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/1356.wav", + "text": "下午兩點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/1357.wav", + "text": "要加要加" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/1358.wav", + "text": "這要簽名" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/1359.wav", + "text": "下午兩點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/1360.wav", + "text": "我們預測9月20日" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/1361.wav", + "text": "唐鳳部長來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/1362.wav", + "text": "我們都尊重反" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/1363.wav", + "text": "哪個委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/1364.wav", + "text": "都是逃不了的我們都會問他" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/1365.wav", + "text": "沒有共識就院會那要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/1366.wav", + "text": "院會處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/1367.wav", + "text": "因為立法院就是這樣子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/1368.wav", + "text": "跟大家報告一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/1369.wav", + "text": "了各黨團都簽好了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14428/1370.wav", + "text": "謝謝大家的辛苦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/0.wav", + "text": "因為我一直看著" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/1.wav", + "text": "那邊心想怎麼沒有看到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/2.wav", + "text": "我現在要開個玩笑" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/3.wav", + "text": "原來已經藍白合了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/4.wav", + "text": "開玩笑開玩笑" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/5.wav", + "text": "會議開始" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/6.wav", + "text": "今天要繼續研商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/7.wav", + "text": "幼兒教育及照顧法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/8.wav", + "text": "修正草案與" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/9.wav", + "text": "教保服務人員條例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/10.wav", + "text": "修正草案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/11.wav", + "text": "我現在介紹一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/12.wav", + "text": "首先介紹教育部部長潘文忠先生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/13.wav", + "text": "如果有機會再介紹" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/14.wav", + "text": "\n接下來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/15.wav", + "text": "就宣布一下對不對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/16.wav", + "text": "園區管理局作業基金" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/17.wav", + "text": "已經同意就通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/18.wav", + "text": "新增的主決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/19.wav", + "text": "這個要編號已" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/20.wav", + "text": "我現在跟大家報告一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/21.wav", + "text": "科學園區作業基金" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/22.wav", + "text": "對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/23.wav", + "text": "主決議一" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/24.wav", + "text": "因為這個是柯總召提出來的而" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/25.wav", + "text": "而這個是建請案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/26.wav", + "text": "所以我覺得科學園區管理局" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/27.wav", + "text": "應該要更重視這個案件" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/28.wav", + "text": "慈雲路的空橋" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/29.wav", + "text": "那個地方我有去辦過會勘" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/30.wav", + "text": "所以應該大力支持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/31.wav", + "text": "謝謝邱總召" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/32.wav", + "text": "我們把這個編號" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/33.wav", + "text": "昨天我不在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/34.wav", + "text": "但我知道大家都很關切這個案子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/35.wav", + "text": "今天總召也等於是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/36.wav", + "text": "把大家的心意表露" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/37.wav", + "text": "所以我們也支持這個方向" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/38.wav", + "text": "好謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/39.wav", + "text": "研商的主題就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/40.wav", + "text": "幼照法跟教保條例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/41.wav", + "text": "事實上這兩個法案" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/42.wav", + "text": "現在都只有各保留四條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/43.wav", + "text": "都有共識也簽了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/44.wav", + "text": "就不討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/45.wav", + "text": "這四條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/46.wav", + "text": "這四條好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/47.wav", + "text": "好大家都同意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/48.wav", + "text": "謝謝大家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/49.wav", + "text": "幼照法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/50.wav", + "text": "教育部說明一下就好了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/51.wav", + "text": "好教育部說明一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/52.wav", + "text": "主席以及各位委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/53.wav", + "text": "所關心的大概分為幾個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/54.wav", + "text": "委員手上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/55.wav", + "text": "有一份是有關保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/56.wav", + "text": "條文研處的說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/57.wav", + "text": "條文對照表" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/58.wav", + "text": "另外後面還有一份是有關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/59.wav", + "text": "我們教保機構" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/60.wav", + "text": "不當對待幼兒案件的通報" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/61.wav", + "text": "調查認定跟授權子法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/62.wav", + "text": "的一個框架讓委員參考" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/63.wav", + "text": "首先就研處說明其中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/64.wav", + "text": "委員關心的有幾個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/65.wav", + "text": "第一個是有關定義" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/66.wav", + "text": "而定義的說明我們跟委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/67.wav", + "text": "會也有提到過未來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/68.wav", + "text": "我們在幼照法施行細則裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/69.wav", + "text": "會針對相關的定義" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/70.wav", + "text": "做敘明同時我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/71.wav", + "text": "也會訂定一個注意事項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/72.wav", + "text": "注意事項當中來敘明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/73.wav", + "text": "這是有關第3條第1項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/74.wav", + "text": "通報的時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/75.wav", + "text": "我們這次也在條文裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/76.wav", + "text": "把委員所關心的24小時" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/77.wav", + "text": "納在第3條第2項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/78.wav", + "text": "委員也關心通報之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/79.wav", + "text": "何時開始啟動調查程序" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/80.wav", + "text": "目前我們是在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/81.wav", + "text": "兩個工作日開始啟動" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/82.wav", + "text": "調查程序敘" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/83.wav", + "text": "同時對於調查結果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/84.wav", + "text": "要給相關的這些人知悉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/85.wav", + "text": "目前也在條文中敘明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/86.wav", + "text": "委員同時也關心" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/87.wav", + "text": "這些認定是什麼樣的機制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/88.wav", + "text": "不是施政報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/89.wav", + "text": "不用說得那麼清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/90.wav", + "text": "是不是這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/91.wav", + "text": "──你們希望照哪個版本通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/92.wav", + "text": "我們再讓各黨團" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/93.wav", + "text": "──我們先講結論好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/94.wav", + "text": "你們是希望照哪個版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/95.wav", + "text": "他們都知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/96.wav", + "text": "他們的主張是怎麼樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/97.wav", + "text": "如果大家沒有共識" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/98.wav", + "text": "是的麻煩主席跟委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/99.wav", + "text": "第4頁和第5頁最右邊欄位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/100.wav", + "text": "這個欄位就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/101.wav", + "text": "綜整所有委員關心的事項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/102.wav", + "text": "我們臚列在這裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/103.wav", + "text": "給委員參考" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/104.wav", + "text": "你們是希望我們照" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/105.wav", + "text": "哪一個版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/106.wav", + "text": "最右邊這一欄" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/107.wav", + "text": "提會討論版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/108.wav", + "text": "是的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/109.wav", + "text": "看大家有什麼意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/110.wav", + "text": "有意見大概就是要保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/111.wav", + "text": "第3條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/112.wav", + "text": "邱總召" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/113.wav", + "text": "有幾個問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/114.wav", + "text": "其實部長在委員會的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/115.wav", + "text": "大家也有提出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/116.wav", + "text": "我有幾個問題想要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/117.wav", + "text": "請教因為這個涉及到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/118.wav", + "text": "教保機構違規" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/119.wav", + "text": "或者是不當" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/120.wav", + "text": "對待幼兒事件的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/121.wav", + "text": "到確定裁罰" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/122.wav", + "text": "許多的狀況是家長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/123.wav", + "text": "沒辦法得到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/124.wav", + "text": "的資訊或者是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/125.wav", + "text": "教保服務機構受到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/126.wav", + "text": "裁罰必須要減招停辦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/127.wav", + "text": "廢止設立許可的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/128.wav", + "text": "業者有可能是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/129.wav", + "text": "避不見面的狀況\n" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/130.wav", + "text": "家長一方面沒有辦法得到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/131.wav", + "text": "去追查這個案件" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/132.wav", + "text": "要怎麼轉托" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/133.wav", + "text": "的問題還有費用的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/134.wav", + "text": "等等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/135.wav", + "text": "所以就這個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/136.wav", + "text": "我有提出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/137.wav", + "text": "要由何人" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/138.wav", + "text": "由我們的主管單位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/139.wav", + "text": "向幼托家長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/140.wav", + "text": "說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/141.wav", + "text": "這些違規裁罰的結果也好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/142.wav", + "text": "費用退還也好協助轉托" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/143.wav", + "text": "也好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/144.wav", + "text": "能夠讓家長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/145.wav", + "text": "等一下請教育部回應" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/146.wav", + "text": "\n第二個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/147.wav", + "text": "就是有關教保服務機構" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/148.wav", + "text": "不當對待幼兒案件通報" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/149.wav", + "text": "調查認定授權等等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/150.wav", + "text": "調查下去認定的結果" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/151.wav", + "text": "也會影響到教保員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/152.wav", + "text": "他可能一年到四年沒辦法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/153.wav", + "text": "執業甚至是終身不得任教的狀況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/154.wav", + "text": "教育部所提出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/155.wav", + "text": "教保服務機構人員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/156.wav", + "text": "設置要點等等等一下是不是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/157.wav", + "text": "可以進一步說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/158.wav", + "text": "我想請教育部也" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/159.wav", + "text": "與教保人員條例第33" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/160.wav", + "text": "教保機構負責人或其他人員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/161.wav", + "text": "依第26條通報直轄" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/162.wav", + "text": "市縣（市）主管機關我很支持" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/163.wav", + "text": "至遲不得超過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/164.wav", + "text": "24小時也就是要立即通報" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/165.wav", + "text": "我不太清楚第2項與第1項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/166.wav", + "text": "的關聯性是什麼因為看起來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/167.wav", + "text": "教保機構之負責人或其他人員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/168.wav", + "text": "知悉有前項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/169.wav", + "text": "情形或" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/170.wav", + "text": "行為應該" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/171.wav", + "text": "最遲不得超過24" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/172.wav", + "text": "小時因為你們突然在第2項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/173.wav", + "text": "放了這個文字可是又牽扯到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/174.wav", + "text": "與第1項又好像沒有完全的關係" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/175.wav", + "text": "第2項與第1項的關聯性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/176.wav", + "text": "請林委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/177.wav", + "text": "有關第3條的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/178.wav", + "text": "元素我們這邊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/179.wav", + "text": "有意見所以就先保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/180.wav", + "text": "但是在一些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/181.wav", + "text": "模糊的解釋" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/182.wav", + "text": "宣示性的但因為現在牽涉到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/183.wav", + "text": "後面的罰則" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/184.wav", + "text": "甚至牽涉到老師工作權" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/185.wav", + "text": "育部說清楚除了在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/186.wav", + "text": "這邊出現以及在聯合" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/187.wav", + "text": "出現之外還有在哪邊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/188.wav", + "text": "有出現過不當對待" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/189.wav", + "text": "的文字另外把定義也透過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/190.wav", + "text": "此我們有訂一個機制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/191.wav", + "text": "站在各方公平審理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/192.wav", + "text": "委員會裡面大家是真的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/193.wav", + "text": "很認真地去討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/194.wav", + "text": "用一個機制來進行調查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/195.wav", + "text": "誰的權益上都能夠比較" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/196.wav", + "text": "公正客���去調查狀況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/197.wav", + "text": "應該要怎麼樣來做一些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/198.wav", + "text": "處理不管是罰款或是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/199.wav", + "text": "懲罰的部分或是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/200.wav", + "text": "工作權的部分這個部分我們已經" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/201.wav", + "text": "各縣市政府都必須要成立" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/202.wav", + "text": "委員會訂定出來雖然" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/203.wav", + "text": "是如此可是不當對待" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/204.wav", + "text": "如果沒有一個明確定義的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/205.wav", + "text": "可能會牽涉到各縣市的解釋" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/206.wav", + "text": "會有很大的差別" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/207.wav", + "text": "所以我認為這個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/208.wav", + "text": "教育部還是必須要講清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/209.wav", + "text": "才不至於到了各縣市就算" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/210.wav", + "text": "我們有一個公正的機制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/211.wav", + "text": "或公平的機制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/212.wav", + "text": "但因為牽涉到法律名詞的解釋" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/213.wav", + "text": "寬鬆或嚴謹" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/214.wav", + "text": "造成在處理上面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/215.wav", + "text": "定義這個部分要請教育部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/216.wav", + "text": "跟我們說明\n第二個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/217.wav", + "text": "孩子健康上面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/218.wav", + "text": "的部分是針對小學" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/219.wav", + "text": "到高中小學" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/220.wav", + "text": "非基改的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/221.wav", + "text": "有直接列到法裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/222.wav", + "text": "學校衛生法沒有辦法照顧到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/223.wav", + "text": "要幼照法的要求" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/224.wav", + "text": "很多委員在幼照法提了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/225.wav", + "text": "相關條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/226.wav", + "text": "都寫在上面我是比較" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/227.wav", + "text": "懇切地希望教育部在這邊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/228.wav", + "text": "能夠允諾\n" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/229.wav", + "text": "教育部有接受" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/230.wav", + "text": "就是第十二條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/231.wav", + "text": "已經通過的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/232.wav", + "text": "應依據中央主管機關所定幼兒園" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/233.wav", + "text": "餐點食物內容及營養基準" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/234.wav", + "text": "以及中央衛生主管機關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/235.wav", + "text": "所定國人膳食" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/236.wav", + "text": "營養素參考攝取量" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/237.wav", + "text": "提供衛生安全及營養均衡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/238.wav", + "text": "之餐食" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/239.wav", + "text": "我們用行政命令方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/240.wav", + "text": "在規範" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/241.wav", + "text": "飲食的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/242.wav", + "text": "叫作中央主管機關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/243.wav", + "text": "所定幼兒園餐點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/244.wav", + "text": "食物內容及營養基準" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/245.wav", + "text": "此基準到目前為止" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/246.wav", + "text": "有一個東西是有放進去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/247.wav", + "text": "就是要使用國內的肉品" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/248.wav", + "text": "非基改沒有寫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/249.wav", + "text": "另外我們也希望用國內肉品" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/250.wav", + "text": "還要包括加工品" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/251.wav", + "text": "因為小孩也有可能吃到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/252.wav", + "text": "肉鬆" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/253.wav", + "text": "尤其小孩很容易" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/254.wav", + "text": "吃到還有像絞肉等等的東西" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/255.wav", + "text": "所以能不能把一些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/256.wav", + "text": "加工品也放到這個基準裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/257.wav", + "text": "我們也希望把福島食品放進去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/258.wav", + "text": "站在一個比較客觀立場" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/259.wav", + "text": "變成還要去表決" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/260.wav", + "text": "可是如果今天同意" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/261.wav", + "text": "是國小以上在法上面有保障" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/262.wav", + "text": "就是不能吃到非基改的東西" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/263.wav", + "text": "但在幼兒園我們反而" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/264.wav", + "text": "都沒有限制" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/265.wav", + "text": "這很奇怪" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/266.wav", + "text": "啊幼兒的健康更需要照顧" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/267.wav", + "text": "反而是可以吃非基改的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/268.wav", + "text": "願意把我們剛剛講的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/269.wav", + "text": "都修進去基準" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/270.wav", + "text": "讓這部法能夠趕快順利地" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/271.wav", + "text": "通過我想我們可以來協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/272.wav", + "text": "教育部給予我們善意的回應" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/273.wav", + "text": "要不然的話就變成真的只好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/274.wav", + "text": "用表決因為這是民生性的東西" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/275.wav", + "text": "我們也不希望" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/276.wav", + "text": "再去走表決" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/277.wav", + "text": "總召都授權給我" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/278.wav", + "text": "我就把意見表達出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/279.wav", + "text": "列入基準裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/280.wav", + "text": "大家都希望做到的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/281.wav", + "text": "林委員我請教你" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/282.wav", + "text": "因為現在教育部有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/283.wav", + "text": "整合大家的意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/284.wav", + "text": "大表的最右邊就是提會討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/285.wav", + "text": "結構已經不一樣了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/286.wav", + "text": "是不是你針對這個提會版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/287.wav", + "text": "覺得哪裡還要修改" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/288.wav", + "text": "且容易解決" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/289.wav", + "text": "如果沒有的話意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/290.wav", + "text": "看是不是可以具體" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/291.wav", + "text": "地方提出來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/292.wav", + "text": "謝謝主席我想這個條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/293.wav", + "text": "看起來在綜整之後其實把" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/294.wav", + "text": "程序法的規範都" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/295.wav", + "text": "放入第3條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/296.wav", + "text": "原來比較單純的是有關定義的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/297.wav", + "text": "不管像身心虐待" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/298.wav", + "text": "體罰霸凌" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/299.wav", + "text": "霸凌對幼兒身心暴力不當" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/300.wav", + "text": "對待我剛剛看到教育部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/301.wav", + "text": "有提供一個簡表式的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/302.wav", + "text": "列管文字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/303.wav", + "text": "另外一個是圖例式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/304.wav", + "text": "它的規範已經把" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/305.wav", + "text": "國內現在法裡面能用到的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/306.wav", + "text": "不管是教師法施行細則" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/307.wav", + "text": "或者是相關的法規" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/308.wav", + "text": "看起來就是在這個範疇內" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/309.wav", + "text": "訂定一個類似負責跟流程的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/310.wav", + "text": "說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/311.wav", + "text": "支持跟尊重" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/312.wav", + "text": "不當對待的範例裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/313.wav", + "text": "我看到裡面的文字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/314.wav", + "text": "也有寫了一些案例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/315.wav", + "text": "我只是想就教一件事情" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/316.wav", + "text": "就是霸凌這件事" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/317.wav", + "text": "兩次以上告誡其他小朋友" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/318.wav", + "text": "不要與該名幼兒說話時" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/319.wav", + "text": "幼兒處於不友善環境" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/320.wav", + "text": "這件事情發生在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/321.wav", + "text": "比較幼幼班的孩子身上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/322.wav", + "text": "定義是怎麼樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/323.wav", + "text": "而其他部分我相信大家對於" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/324.wav", + "text": "不當對待的部分你們大概" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/325.wav", + "text": "也都是用舉例的方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/326.wav", + "text": "來處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/327.wav", + "text": "等一下是不是請部長就一併說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/328.wav", + "text": "\n第二個比較是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/329.wav", + "text": "綜整之後的法條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/330.wav", + "text": "我們民眾黨的版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/331.wav", + "text": "關於第3條的修正其實是在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/332.wav", + "text": "第2項就是涉及到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/333.wav", + "text": "教保服務機構的辦理事項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/334.wav", + "text": "裡面有關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/335.wav", + "text": "環境食品安全與" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/336.wav", + "text": "衛生及疾病預防部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/337.wav", + "text": "有加了一項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/338.wav", + "text": "跟剛剛林奕華委員的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/339.wav", + "text": "是有機會在這裡增列第6款" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/340.wav", + "text": "來做處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/341.wav", + "text": "還是部裡面在綜整保留條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/342.wav", + "text": "也不認為需要像" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/343.wav", + "text": "剛剛講到的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/344.wav", + "text": "特別是有關乙型受體素" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/345.wav", + "text": "版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/346.wav", + "text": "的第2項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/347.wav", + "text": "是在原條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/348.wav", + "text": "第25條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/349.wav", + "text": "第2項裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/350.wav", + "text": "有關於不得使用含乙型受體素" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/351.wav", + "text": "之生鮮食材或" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/352.wav", + "text": "產製品" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/353.wav", + "text": "這樣看起來並沒有綜整進去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/354.wav", + "text": "所以也請一併說明好不好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/355.wav", + "text": "以上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/356.wav", + "text": "我就一起說明因為我講的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/357.wav", + "text": "還有國民黨委員提出來的版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/358.wav", + "text": "都加了最後一項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/359.wav", + "text": "我們都新增了最後一項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/360.wav", + "text": "因為前面有提到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/361.wav", + "text": "要針對環境食品安全的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/362.wav", + "text": "以我的版本為例就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/363.wav", + "text": "前項食品安全應包含" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/364.wav", + "text": "採購非基因改造" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/365.wav", + "text": "非日本福島等五縣市之食品" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/366.wav", + "text": "與不含乙型受體素" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/367.wav", + "text": "及其加工品再製品" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/368.wav", + "text": "也許可以修成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/369.wav", + "text": "應包含採購非基因改造" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/370.wav", + "text": "非日本福島等五縣市之食品" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/371.wav", + "text": "與" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/372.wav", + "text": "\n或是就直接寫明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/373.wav", + "text": "本國肉品及" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/374.wav", + "text": "加工品再製品" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/375.wav", + "text": "符合民進黨的說法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/376.wav", + "text": "也許不堅持把乙型" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/377.wav", + "text": "受體素這幾個字放進去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/378.wav", + "text": "但改成我國" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/379.wav", + "text": "肉品再製品" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/380.wav", + "text": "我可以接受做這樣的調整" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/381.wav", + "text": "有共識的話我覺得這是宣示孩子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/382.wav", + "text": "健康守護他們健康" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/383.wav", + "text": "如果基準願意寫大家可以討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/384.wav", + "text": "但是入法當然是最好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/385.wav", + "text": "的尤其剛剛民眾黨也提到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/386.wav", + "text": "謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/387.wav", + "text": "針對他們的意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/388.wav", + "text": "主席以及各位委員我先做說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/389.wav", + "text": "首先" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/390.wav", + "text": "剛剛委員提到的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/391.wav", + "text": "開始的通報" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/392.wav", + "text": "一直到後面的調查跟認定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/393.wav", + "text": "誠如委員在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/394.wav", + "text": "附件一所看到的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/395.wav", + "text": "都會有授權子法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/396.wav", + "text": "應該要告知相關的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/397.wav", + "text": "行為人或者是事件" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/398.wav", + "text": "當事人等等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/399.wav", + "text": "目前除了在法律條文當中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/400.wav", + "text": "我們在授權的子法中也一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/401.wav", + "text": "的部分我們目前也開始在著手處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/402.wav", + "text": "設置要點等等以及包含" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/403.wav", + "text": "會議讓他們有這方面的知能" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/404.wav", + "text": "也開始徵詢各方的意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/405.wav", + "text": "如委員所垂詢以及指教的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/406.wav", + "text": "就是第3條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/407.wav", + "text": "跟第33條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/408.wav", + "text": "跟第26條的關係" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/409.wav", + "text": "的其實就是一個知悉的狀況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/410.wav", + "text": "也就是說當他知悉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/411.wav", + "text": "就有責任要做通報" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/412.wav", + "text": "通報這是委員剛剛提出來的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/413.wav", + "text": "部分\n另外還有委員提到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/414.wav", + "text": "在第3條第1項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/415.wav", + "text": "所臚列的各種樣態" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/416.wav", + "text": "當時在訂定這個法案的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/417.wav", + "text": "其實也是思考兒童權利公約" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/418.wav", + "text": "進行專家審查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/419.wav", + "text": "也認為如果我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/420.wav", + "text": "能在幼教法裡面將相關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/421.wav", + "text": "其實也有利於" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/422.wav", + "text": "我們確實是關注" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/423.wav", + "text": "於委員關心未來這些樣態" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/424.wav", + "text": "很重要的是有一些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/425.wav", + "text": "注意事項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/426.wav", + "text": "在注意事項也會臚列各種樣態" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/427.wav", + "text": "這銜接過來就是剛剛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/428.wav", + "text": "目前霸凌我們是用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/429.wav", + "text": "如果委員有看到我們提供的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/430.wav", + "text": "即使定義是這樣但幼幼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/431.wav", + "text": "的小孩跟國民小學的小孩" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/432.wav", + "text": "上有所不同所以委員可以看到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/433.wav", + "text": "我們的定義是如同國民" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/434.wav", + "text": "舉例的時候一定會關注到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/435.wav", + "text": "2歲到6歲孩子的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/436.wav", + "text": "不一樣狀態所以您可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/437.wav", + "text": "看到我們在例示上有講如果像是霸凌" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/438.wav", + "text": "次以上對這個小小孩應該就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/439.wav", + "text": "屬於霸凌再跟委員報告" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/440.wav", + "text": "我們目前大概有二" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/441.wav", + "text": "十三十位各方的專家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/442.wav", + "text": "在幫我們列舉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/443.wav", + "text": "列舉各種不同的例示" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/444.wav", + "text": "的討論相信未來我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/445.wav", + "text": "意見後逐步把這些例示" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/446.wav", + "text": "例示補充得更完善" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/447.wav", + "text": "我們很感謝林委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/448.wav", + "text": "在前次討論第十二條的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/449.wav", + "text": "加入授權" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/450.wav", + "text": "包含幼兒園餐點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/451.wav", + "text": "食物內容跟營養基準訂定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/452.wav", + "text": "我們目前在幼兒園與其" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/453.wav", + "text": "分班設立變更及管理辦法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/454.wav", + "text": "第三十八條已經要求" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/455.wav", + "text": "幼兒園要依直轄市" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/456.wav", + "text": "縣市主管機關所定規" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/457.wav", + "text": "規範進行相關的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/458.wav", + "text": "餐點跟公布這次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/459.wav", + "text": "在委員的垂詢跟" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/460.wav", + "text": "指教下在第十二條再增加" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/461.wav", + "text": "署及教育部可以訂定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/462.wav", + "text": "更周全的相關規範" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/463.wav", + "text": "由縣市跟幼兒園" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/464.wav", + "text": "來做處理目前來講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/465.wav", + "text": "大概都是用正向表列的方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/466.wav", + "text": "其實就是經由" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/467.wav", + "text": "地方鎖定以及未來中央鎖定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/468.wav", + "text": "以及委員授權我們訂定的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/469.wav", + "text": "何提供孩子比較適當的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/470.wav", + "text": "飲食等等應該都可以在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/471.wav", + "text": "簡要說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/472.wav", + "text": "還有沒有什麼意見\n請" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/473.wav", + "text": "不好意思請教幾個問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/474.wav", + "text": "因為這還是集中在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/475.wav", + "text": "以及教保條例第33條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/476.wav", + "text": "在於教育部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/477.wav", + "text": "出了委員會之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/478.wav", + "text": "規劃出這樣的一個設計" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/479.wav", + "text": "看起來是這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/480.wav", + "text": "這是很關鍵的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/481.wav", + "text": "但有幾個比較細部的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/482.wav", + "text": "我們當然是支持有一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/483.wav", + "text": "專責的委員會來做調查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/484.wav", + "text": "\n第一個問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/485.wav", + "text": "是直轄市縣市主管機關知悉" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/486.wav", + "text": "負責人等等之類的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/487.wav", + "text": "除了這個管道之外" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/488.wav", + "text": "這個被害的學生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/489.wav", + "text": "或其法定代理人家長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/490.wav", + "text": "是不是可以向" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/491.wav", + "text": "這個委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/492.wav", + "text": "簡單講就是它的案件" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/493.wav", + "text": "僅此一項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/494.wav", + "text": "第二個問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/495.wav", + "text": "這個委員會的組成包括" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/496.wav", + "text": "機關代表具兒童保護意識" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/497.wav", + "text": "細部當然是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/498.wav", + "text": "由中央主管機關定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/499.wav", + "text": "之而我的疑問是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/500.wav", + "text": "就這個被害學生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/501.wav", + "text": "而言這個程序參與權要如何" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/502.wav", + "text": "何進行可不可以稍微說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/503.wav", + "text": "的權利" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/504.wav", + "text": "所謂的申請調查權是說他是不是能" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/505.wav", + "text": "並要求這個委員會做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/506.wav", + "text": "第三個層次在我們的版本裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/507.wav", + "text": "因為我自己本身也辦這種案件" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/508.wav", + "text": "假設這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/509.wav", + "text": "小孩" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/510.wav", + "text": "各方面可能" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/511.wav", + "text": "有需要人家協助的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/512.wav", + "text": "本有規定在這種情況" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/513.wav", + "text": "之下這個調查小組的成員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/514.wav", + "text": "組成應該要考量到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/515.wav", + "text": "我覺得這種案件在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/516.wav", + "text": "算是少數" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/517.wav", + "text": "如果這個被害者" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/518.wav", + "text": "是一個特殊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/519.wav", + "text": "調查委員會的成員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/520.wav", + "text": "是不是應該要有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/521.wav", + "text": "提會討論版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/522.wav", + "text": "其實中間已經吸納委員會討論的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/523.wav", + "text": "24小時內一定要通報的責任" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/524.wav", + "text": "主管機關接到2個工作天內" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/525.wav", + "text": "就要開始調查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/526.wav", + "text": "因為這樣證據才不會被湮滅" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/527.wav", + "text": "邱顯智委員關心的調查委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/528.wav", + "text": "其實我們之前有把各個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/529.wav", + "text": "家長代表都有放進去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/530.wav", + "text": "調查出來的書面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/531.wav", + "text": "報告要有哪些內容" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/532.wav", + "text": "呢教育部有答應內容" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/533.wav", + "text": "要比照性騷擾等其他的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/534.wav", + "text": "在文字說明中要講得" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/535.wav", + "text": "受害者相關陳述的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/536.wav", + "text": "依照性騷法其實都有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/537.wav", + "text": "\n我覺得目前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/538.wav", + "text": "點大家沒有共識" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/539.wav", + "text": "一個就是剛剛講到的食物" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/540.wav", + "text": "非福島等要不要放進去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/541.wav", + "text": "的書面調查報告就好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/542.wav", + "text": "這個教育部剛剛並沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/543.wav", + "text": "因為之前我們討論很多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/544.wav", + "text": "應該是在賴召委主持的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/545.wav", + "text": "就有給大家還滿仔細的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/546.wav", + "text": "更明顯的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/547.wav", + "text": "定義會訂在幼" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/548.wav", + "text": "幼教法及教保服務人員條例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/549.wav", + "text": "裁罰基準也會有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/550.wav", + "text": "這部分就是看大家覺得這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/551.wav", + "text": "還夠不夠\n我想這樣也許會更聚焦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/552.wav", + "text": "好謝謝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/553.wav", + "text": "在教文委員會討論非常久" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/554.wav", + "text": "所以後來新增" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/555.wav", + "text": "這些部分包括原來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/556.wav", + "text": "說明欄我們都反對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/557.wav", + "text": "過程機制要如何做" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/558.wav", + "text": "等這真的是我們委員會花很多時間" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/559.wav", + "text": "討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/560.wav", + "text": "教育部也是綜整大家的意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/561.wav", + "text": "唯一就是剛剛講的不當對待" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/562.wav", + "text": "只是想讓教育部在協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/563.wav", + "text": "時再說一次因為到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/564.wav", + "text": "其實在統稱上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/565.wav", + "text": "都叫做不當" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/566.wav", + "text": "對待的通報跟調查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/567.wav", + "text": "我們以前在教育體系裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/568.wav", + "text": "所有東西都叫不當對待" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/569.wav", + "text": "不當對待變成是抽出來了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/570.wav", + "text": "或不當對待" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/571.wav", + "text": "我們在教育體系的不當對待" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/572.wav", + "text": "同樣都是不當對待四個字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/573.wav", + "text": "但是用法上卻有所不同" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/574.wav", + "text": "所有東西都叫不當對待" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/575.wav", + "text": "但現在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/576.wav", + "text": "體罰霸凌" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/577.wav", + "text": "變成是其他的概念" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/578.wav", + "text": "透過這樣的協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/579.wav", + "text": "可能是什麼樣態" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/580.wav", + "text": "才不至於有剛剛講的因為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/581.wav", + "text": "縣市政府認知的不同" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/582.wav", + "text": "導致有不同的解釋" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/583.wav", + "text": "這點當然我們都希望可以站在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/584.wav", + "text": "讓大家未來能夠更加清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/585.wav", + "text": "\n我想這個條文裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/586.wav", + "text": "最後一項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/587.wav", + "text": "管理規定確實執行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/588.wav", + "text": "並定期檢討改進" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/589.wav", + "text": "因為裡面有提到食品安全" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/590.wav", + "text": "大家都知道現在的家長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/591.wav", + "text": "對於孩子的食品安全是非常非常重視的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/592.wav", + "text": "提到後面要再加一項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/593.wav", + "text": "希望可以排除一些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/594.wav", + "text": "我們認為對孩子健康" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/595.wav", + "text": "比較不利的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/596.wav", + "text": "第二其實我有點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/597.wav", + "text": "擔心那個基準它" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/598.wav", + "text": "它的約束力到底到哪裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/599.wav", + "text": "你們現在是叫基準" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/600.wav", + "text": "所以我把它列到上面是寫基準" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/601.wav", + "text": "約束力可以到哪裡" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/602.wav", + "text": "還有它有沒有相關的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/603.wav", + "text": "罰則" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/604.wav", + "text": "看起來好像也沒有什麼相關的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/605.wav", + "text": "所���如果可以入法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/606.wav", + "text": "我們覺得還是最好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/607.wav", + "text": "可以把剛剛講的這些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/608.wav", + "text": "因為學校衛生法本來就有入法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/609.wav", + "text": "非基改是有入法的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/610.wav", + "text": "幼照的部分沒有入法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/611.wav", + "text": "所以我們主張如果可以入法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/612.wav", + "text": "會比較代表照顧幼兒園的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/613.wav", + "text": "小學以上都是如此" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/614.wav", + "text": "的這些孩子我們更是要保護" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/615.wav", + "text": "他們的健康\n另外一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/616.wav", + "text": "是我剛剛講的如果大家" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/617.wav", + "text": "比較不適合" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/618.wav", + "text": "也許在政黨上立場" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/619.wav", + "text": "覺得不適合那就把它改成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/620.wav", + "text": "採用國內在地" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/621.wav", + "text": "肉品" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/622.wav", + "text": "之生鮮食材" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/623.wav", + "text": "再製品就把它修正成" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/624.wav", + "text": "國內在地肉品看能不" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/625.wav", + "text": "我覺得如此是在宣示我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/626.wav", + "text": "更加重視跟守護" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/627.wav", + "text": "的意見怎麼樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/628.wav", + "text": "有沒有意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/629.wav", + "text": "我看這樣好了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/630.wav", + "text": "讓執政黨發表意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/631.wav", + "text": "如果再不一樣我們就保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/632.wav", + "text": "好不好因為討論滿" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/633.wav", + "text": "看能不能接受" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/634.wav", + "text": "沒有辦法接受意見不同" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/635.wav", + "text": "我們就保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/636.wav", + "text": "先跟大家報告一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/637.wav", + "text": "這個保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/638.wav", + "text": "因為它有相關性會連動" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/639.wav", + "text": "我剛才已經有唸過了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/640.wav", + "text": "那時林奕華委員還沒有到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/641.wav", + "text": "場但是我已經唸過第3條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/642.wav", + "text": "這4條是連動的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/643.wav", + "text": "我們就一起保留就這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/644.wav", + "text": "\n請執政黨說明一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/645.wav", + "text": "是不是能夠接受在野黨的意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/646.wav", + "text": "謝謝院長" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/647.wav", + "text": "剛才主要分三個部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/648.wav", + "text": "第一個是對於通報" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/649.wav", + "text": "第二個是對於這些行為的定義第三個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/650.wav", + "text": "我認為通報的事項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/651.wav", + "text": "跟如何定義" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/652.wav", + "text": "那個定義今天有一個附件" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/653.wav", + "text": "所以請大家看一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/654.wav", + "text": "通報之後在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/655.wav", + "text": "今天教育部的修正案中" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/656.wav", + "text": "其實也有把委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/657.wav", + "text": "的成員都寫清楚了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/658.wav", + "text": "我相信各黨團應該是可以" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/659.wav", + "text": "接受才對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/660.wav", + "text": "\n最後一項是有關於食品的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/661.wav", + "text": "剛才林奕華委員在第二次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/662.wav", + "text": "應該是你們有考慮到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/663.wav", + "text": "國際貿易的問題嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/664.wav", + "text": "那個時候我們在學校衛生法裡也有談到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/665.wav", + "text": "非基改就有放進去沒有錯" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/666.wav", + "text": "食材的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/667.wav", + "text": "文字上應該是優先採用國內食材" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/668.wav", + "text": "文字請教育部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/669.wav", + "text": "再看一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/670.wav", + "text": "如果真的要列進去的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/671.wav", + "text": "最多最多寫到跟學校食品" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/672.wav", + "text": "以上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/673.wav", + "text": "等一下如果要保留的話是不是可以先請" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/674.wav", + "text": "做了很多努力" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/675.wav", + "text": "的意見都納進去了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/676.wav", + "text": "啦但是還是沒有辦法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/677.wav", + "text": "滿足大家的意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/678.wav", + "text": "邱總召現在講完了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/679.wav", + "text": "大家還有沒有意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/680.wav", + "text": "不然我們就請教育部說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/681.wav", + "text": "說明完意見還不同我們就保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/682.wav", + "text": "主席但是我說實在我比較建議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/683.wav", + "text": "可以不用保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/684.wav", + "text": "啦因為剛剛這樣幾乎快要有共識" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/685.wav", + "text": "啦還是我們不要寫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/686.wav", + "text": "那麼清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/687.wav", + "text": "沒有啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/688.wav", + "text": "大家可以有共同接受的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/689.wav", + "text": "版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/690.wav", + "text": "你的版本也有寫不當管教" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/691.wav", + "text": "嘛你每一個都挑戰" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/692.wav", + "text": "我現在講的是後面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/693.wav", + "text": "大家程序都用得很清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/694.wav", + "text": "我想那個很難有共識" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/695.wav", + "text": "啦那些我們在學校衛生法就談過了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/696.wav", + "text": "有授權總召" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/697.wav", + "text": "現在說的是最後一項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/698.wav", + "text": "我剛剛前面講的只是因為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/699.wav", + "text": "就像貴黨一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/700.wav", + "text": "會說一下你們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/701.wav", + "text": "不是啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/702.wav", + "text": "大家有共識的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/703.wav", + "text": "因為你們有講我當然也可以講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/704.wav", + "text": "你一樣的事情講三次林" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/705.wav", + "text": "反而這邊比較少講對啦但我" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/706.wav", + "text": "我認為有兩種處理方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/707.wav", + "text": "有兩種方式" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/708.wav", + "text": "你不是在解決你要搞我們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/709.wav", + "text": "我這怎麼是搞" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/710.wav", + "text": "第一個是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/711.wav", + "text": "總召在學校衛生法裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/712.wav", + "text": "沒有協調" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/713.wav", + "text": "在學校衛生法裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/714.wav", + "text": "非基改本來就在學校衛生法裡面的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/715.wav", + "text": "就是長這樣嘍" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/716.wav", + "text": "跟我無關喔" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/717.wav", + "text": "只是它是屬於" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/718.wav", + "text": "小學以上的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/719.wav", + "text": "這是第一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/720.wav", + "text": "一律採用國內在地豬肉牛肉之" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/721.wav", + "text": "生鮮食材" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/722.wav", + "text": "本來都有寫了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/723.wav", + "text": "我覺得法上如果可以寫" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/724.wav", + "text": "那當然是好的宣示嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/725.wav", + "text": "我覺得不需要到這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/726.wav", + "text": "還是你們要答應我們可以做附帶決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/727.wav", + "text": "把非基改這些" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/728.wav", + "text": "列入到基準裡面去修改" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/729.wav", + "text": "如果國小以上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/730.wav", + "text": "非基改都入法了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/731.wav", + "text": "法上面都寫了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/732.wav", + "text": "那我今天退到放進" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/733.wav", + "text": "我覺得一點都不過分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/734.wav", + "text": "可不可以這樣子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/735.wav", + "text": "起碼我們做附帶決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/736.wav", + "text": "站在守護孩子健康的立場林" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/737.wav", + "text": "林委員你講得很有道理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/738.wav", + "text": "但是我" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/739.wav", + "text": "聽你這樣講就是把這個法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/740.wav", + "text": "法的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/741.wav", + "text": "事實上是在處理受虐" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/742.wav", + "text": "但你要處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/743.wav", + "text": "剛才邱總召有講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/744.wav", + "text": "因為我有讓你充分發言" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/745.wav", + "text": "我們可以調錄影帶" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/746.wav", + "text": "調錄影帶" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/747.wav", + "text": "大部分都是你在講喔" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/748.wav", + "text": "但是學校衛生法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/749.wav", + "text": "規範的是小學" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/750.wav", + "text": "以上嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/751.wav", + "text": "請教育部回答一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/752.wav", + "text": "回答以後意見如果還不同" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/753.wav", + "text": "我們就保留就這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/754.wav", + "text": "\n請教育部──我看這一次請潘部長說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/755.wav", + "text": "委員的指教" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/756.wav", + "text": "相關細節的內容" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/757.wav", + "text": "在委員會討論的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/758.wav", + "text": "能在法上綜整的就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/759.wav", + "text": "現在這個版本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/760.wav", + "text": "而委員提到的有一些是在立法說明裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/761.wav", + "text": "把它明列也就是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/762.wav", + "text": "很多都會在子法訂定" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/763.wav", + "text": "但是因為委員都很認真" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/764.wav", + "text": "所以說明的時候都希望教育部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/765.wav", + "text": "應該要先寫清楚" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/766.wav", + "text": "我想委員如果有看到我們的補充" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/767.wav", + "text": "立法說明就會知道" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/768.wav", + "text": "它會指向你未來在訂" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/769.wav", + "text": "也要訂出這樣的寫法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/770.wav", + "text": "這是我的綜整" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/771.wav", + "text": "有關食品" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/772.wav", + "text": "營養衛生" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/773.wav", + "text": "這個我也謝謝林奕華委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/774.wav", + "text": "其實從學校衛生法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/775.wav", + "text": "後面的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/776.wav", + "text": "契約範本我們都是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/777.wav", + "text": "比較正向去表列" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/778.wav", + "text": "不會去列出" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/779.wav", + "text": "的優良生鮮食品" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/780.wav", + "text": "為一個最大的定調" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/781.wav", + "text": "因為這個本來從教育上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/782.wav", + "text": "不只是保護孩子" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/783.wav", + "text": "食農教育的這些作法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/784.wav", + "text": "所以之前" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/785.wav", + "text": "雖然大家很熱烈地討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/786.wav", + "text": "有關乙型受體素等等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/787.wav", + "text": "但是從校園執行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/788.wav", + "text": "契約範本在各縣市大家定下來之後" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/789.wav", + "text": "幾乎沒有縣市沒有學校" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/790.wav", + "text": "有去吃到用到" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/791.wav", + "text": "其他委員所關心的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/792.wav", + "text": "這些類型" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/793.wav", + "text": "在整個處理上面幼兒園也會朝" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/794.wav", + "text": "朝學校衛生法的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/795.wav", + "text": "來執行" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/796.wav", + "text": "後面的基準" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/797.wav", + "text": "我們都當然是秉持這個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/798.wav", + "text": "我相信維護學童安全" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/799.wav", + "text": "包含所有委員的要求跟共識" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/800.wav", + "text": "這兩部法跟後續" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/801.wav", + "text": "一定會是一致的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/802.wav", + "text": "跟委員做以上的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/803.wav", + "text": "報告\n至於剛才" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/804.wav", + "text": "邱總召有提到一個" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/805.wav", + "text": "但是當時在討論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/806.wav", + "text": "說明會要不要開這個在委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/807.wav", + "text": "大家討論得很多" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/808.wav", + "text": "如果一定要開說明會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/809.wav", + "text": "那在什麼時機什麼場合" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/810.wav", + "text": "等等所以當時在委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/811.wav", + "text": "委員也都認為反而應該是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/812.wav", + "text": "明確的調查結果來通知" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/813.wav", + "text": "所以就正式入在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/814.wav", + "text": "項次後端這個我想" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/815.wav", + "text": "也都是委員當時在討論的時候" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/816.wav", + "text": "所提醒的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/817.wav", + "text": "\n剛才總召也提到一點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/818.wav", + "text": "就是對特教學生的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/819.wav", + "text": "因為這些孩子可能在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/820.wav", + "text": "表述各方面不容易" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/821.wav", + "text": "後面的細節" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/822.wav", + "text": "所定的這些子法裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/823.wav", + "text": "還是回應剛剛講的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/824.wav", + "text": "如果第十二條有的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/825.wav", + "text": "那好像第三十條不需要" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/826.wav", + "text": "但是第十二條講的定義內容" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/827.wav", + "text": "都無涉食品安全" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/828.wav", + "text": "是營養跟健康的考慮" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/829.wav", + "text": "所以這兩條不一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/830.wav", + "text": "如果要用兒童的餐點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/831.wav", + "text": "食物內容及營養基準" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/832.wav", + "text": "那剛剛林奕華委員說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/833.wav", + "text": "在這樣基準內修訂" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/834.wav", + "text": "這個教育部能不能答應" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/835.wav", + "text": "他已經退到這裡了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/836.wav", + "text": "學校衛生法有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/837.wav", + "text": "幼教法反而沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/838.wav", + "text": "在法的體例上也不一致" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/839.wav", + "text": "所以其實是這三點" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/840.wav", + "text": "但是我指出這個不是說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/841.wav", + "text": "講很多遍是法律的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/842.wav", + "text": "因為我們是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/843.wav", + "text": "黨團協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/844.wav", + "text": "我們是共識" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/845.wav", + "text": "我再重申黨團協商" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/846.wav", + "text": "最主要是共識決" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/847.wav", + "text": "如果大家意見不同" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/848.wav", + "text": "那就保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/849.wav", + "text": "我我再建議這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/850.wav", + "text": "有沒有可能我們做一個附帶決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/851.wav", + "text": "請教育部修正" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/852.wav", + "text": "剛剛那個基準" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/853.wav", + "text": "能夠將學校衛生法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/854.wav", + "text": "第幾條以及現在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/855.wav", + "text": "契約範本的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/856.wav", + "text": "就請幼兒園能夠比照" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/857.wav", + "text": "類似這樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/858.wav", + "text": "總可以吧" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/859.wav", + "text": "文字上不出現這些字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/860.wav", + "text": "總可以吧" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/861.wav", + "text": "但是起碼你讓幼兒園的小孩" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/862.wav", + "text": "可以比照嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/863.wav", + "text": "我覺得這應該是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/864.wav", + "text": "很OK啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/865.wav", + "text": "執政黨要不要想一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/866.wav", + "text": "我真的覺得這個應該是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/867.wav", + "text": "可以接受的啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/868.wav", + "text": "要不然說實在的拿這個去表決" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/869.wav", + "text": "變成說你們覺得幼兒園可以吃基改" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/870.wav", + "text": "這樣也不好啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/871.wav", + "text": "因為現在那個基準" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/872.wav", + "text": "裡面基改就是可以的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/873.wav", + "text": "你現在是在問執政黨黨團嘛" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/874.wav", + "text": "林委員的意思就是說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/875.wav", + "text": "你不堅持你的版本的最後一項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/876.wav", + "text": "但是你要去寫附帶決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/877.wav", + "text": "但是目前沒有附帶決議的文字" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/878.wav", + "text": "宣示意義" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/879.wav", + "text": "我們對幼兒的健康是跟小學以上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/880.wav", + "text": "的一樣" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/881.wav", + "text": "比照學校衛生法的第幾條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/882.wav", + "text": "以及現在學校契約範本" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/883.wav", + "text": "我覺得這應該很OK啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/884.wav", + "text": "我來說明一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/885.wav", + "text": "如果是附帶決議的話" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/886.wav", + "text": "沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/887.wav", + "text": "我要說的是你要提我們沒有意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/888.wav", + "text": "那個以後再講你" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/889.wav", + "text": "提了我們再看看" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/890.wav", + "text": "如果要提附帶決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/891.wav", + "text": "你可以提這" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/892.wav", + "text": "就寫出來給大家看附" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/893.wav", + "text": "我們討論法律" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/894.wav", + "text": "後請你擬一個附帶決議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/895.wav", + "text": "那就先保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/896.wav", + "text": "幼照法" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/897.wav", + "text": "第3條第5條第57條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/898.wav", + "text": "第59條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/899.wav", + "text": "一併保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/900.wav", + "text": "\n現在處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/901.wav", + "text": "教保條例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/902.wav", + "text": "因為教保條例的四條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/903.wav", + "text": "跟剛才的四條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/904.wav", + "text": "是有相關性" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/905.wav", + "text": "教保條例的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/906.wav", + "text": "教保服務人員條例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/907.wav", + "text": "33條跟幼照的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/908.wav", + "text": "條文相似" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/909.wav", + "text": "但是它沒有後面那段" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/910.wav", + "text": "其實跟後面幾條無關啦" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/911.wav", + "text": "但是剛剛講不當對待我們只是請他們說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/912.wav", + "text": "我沒有反對" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/913.wav", + "text": "沒有意見" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/914.wav", + "text": "你的意思是說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/915.wav", + "text": "這四條就可以讓它通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/916.wav", + "text": "只要第3條保留就好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/917.wav", + "text": "只有第3條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/918.wav", + "text": "有問題是因為" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/919.wav", + "text": "教保條例第33條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/920.wav", + "text": "只有不當對待的議題而已" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/921.wav", + "text": "民眾黨還沒講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/922.wav", + "text": "報告主席" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/923.wav", + "text": "我們民眾黨黨團的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/924.wav", + "text": "第38條之1" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/925.wav", + "text": "最後一項有關" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/926.wav", + "text": "累罰的部分能不能請" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/927.wav", + "text": "教育部先回應一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/928.wav", + "text": "因為它是對照到第4條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/929.wav", + "text": "第4條累罰" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/930.wav", + "text": "的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/931.wav", + "text": "因為我們是" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/932.wav", + "text": "訂在第38條之1" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/933.wav", + "text": "但你們的綜整裡面並沒有" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/934.wav", + "text": "回應所以先請你們" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/935.wav", + "text": "回應一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/936.wav", + "text": "針對第33條謝謝剛剛教育部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/937.wav", + "text": "答應說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/938.wav", + "text": "針對員工24小時檢舉的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/939.wav", + "text": "教育部在兩個禮拜內會跟勞動部" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/940.wav", + "text": "稍微討論一下相關細節" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/941.wav", + "text": "謝謝剛剛的溝通" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/942.wav", + "text": "之1邱委員提案的最後一項" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/943.wav", + "text": "關於五年內再犯" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/944.wav", + "text": "累罰的部分因為你們的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/945.wav", + "text": "回應沒有寫到這一段所以請" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/946.wav", + "text": "教育部回應一下你們最後綜整" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/947.wav", + "text": "罰和五年內再犯的問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/948.wav", + "text": "在整個幼照法和" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/949.wav", + "text": "行政罰法的部分也就是說" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/950.wav", + "text": "其實是比較嚴重的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/951.wav", + "text": "最高可以罰到60萬元其實還可" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/952.wav", + "text": "用行政罰法再加上去" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/953.wav", + "text": "因為有這個條文在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/954.wav", + "text": "所以我們建議應該可以不用" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/955.wav", + "text": "再提到幾年內等等" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/956.wav", + "text": "這樣的文字以上" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/957.wav", + "text": "所以就用行政罰法套過來" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/958.wav", + "text": "不另立一項做五年內的規範" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/959.wav", + "text": "是不是好瞭解" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/960.wav", + "text": "報告主席" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/961.wav", + "text": "因為剛剛教保條例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/962.wav", + "text": "在通過的條文裡面" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/963.wav", + "text": "我們依著委員的建議" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/964.wav", + "text": "把幼兒園跟教保中心的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/965.wav", + "text": "罰則拉到一致" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/966.wav", + "text": "致因為在法的體系裡面好" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/967.wav", + "text": "各位" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/968.wav", + "text": "請稍微" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/969.wav", + "text": "我把結論宣讀" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/970.wav", + "text": "院長不好意思" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/971.wav", + "text": "教保服務人員那部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/972.wav", + "text": "因為剛剛通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/973.wav", + "text": "有個條次是不是讓我們說明一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/974.wav", + "text": "再請院長這邊做最後的結論" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/975.wav", + "text": "跟各位委員" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/976.wav", + "text": "其中有一部分是幼兒園跟" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/977.wav", + "text": "教保中心裁罰的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/978.wav", + "text": "標準拉到一致" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/979.wav", + "text": "因為我們把教保中心的" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/980.wav", + "text": "條次你給我們委員會" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/981.wav", + "text": "你還是要到院會宣布啊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/982.wav", + "text": "我在院會宣布一下" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/983.wav", + "text": "你不必在這邊" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/984.wav", + "text": "講" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/985.wav", + "text": "等一下反而" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/986.wav", + "text": "有關於幼照法的部分" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/987.wav", + "text": "一協商通過條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/988.wav", + "text": "第6條第5條第52條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/989.wav", + "text": "第54條第56條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/990.wav", + "text": "第57條第58條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/991.wav", + "text": "第59條（如附件" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/992.wav", + "text": "條文第3條\n三" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/993.wav", + "text": "原審查會保留" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/994.wav", + "text": "附帶決議2案送院會處理" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/995.wav", + "text": "\n四其餘均照審查" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/996.wav", + "text": "會審查結果通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/997.wav", + "text": "\n五本案條文及援引之條次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/998.wav", + "text": "授權議事人員調整" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/999.wav", + "text": "教保條例" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/1000.wav", + "text": "一協商通過條文" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/1001.wav", + "text": "第33條第34條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/1002.wav", + "text": "第41條第43條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/1003.wav", + "text": "第44條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/1004.wav", + "text": "（補充立法說明" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/1005.wav", + "text": "）第46條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/1006.wav", + "text": "第48條第49條" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/1007.wav", + "text": "會審查結果通過" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/1008.wav", + "text": "\n三本案條文及援引之條次" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/1009.wav", + "text": "授權議事人員調整" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/1010.wav", + "text": "現在" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/1011.wav", + "text": "協商結論已經簽好了" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/1012.wav", + "text": "應該沒有問題" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/1013.wav", + "text": "大家都有共識" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/1014.wav", + "text": "今天的會議就到此結束" + }, + { + "audio": "../sentence_wavs/14404/1015.wav", + "text": "散會\n謝謝大家" + } +] \ No newline at end of file